{ "claims": [ { "claim": { "id": "GS-QF-0001", "record": { "conditions": [ "The simulation uses a finite first-quantized real-space grid." ], "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:09.743236+00:00", "dependency_revisions": [], "depends_on": [], "id": "GS-QF-0001", "kind": "definition", "model": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "plain_language_conclusion": "The capacity-limited subspace and pre-call overflow probability are defined for later bounds.", "question": "Which occupancy and error quantities are used in the argument?", "remaining_uncertainty": "The definitions do not establish that realistic states remain in the good subspace.", "role": "definition", "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-v1", "scope": "general", "scope_summary": "This is a definition on a finite first-quantized real-space grid.", "statement": { "latex": "\\Pi_c=\\prod_b\\mathbf 1[N_b\\le c],\\qquad\np_k=\\langle\\Psi_{k-1}|(I-\\Pi_c)|\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle.\n", "natural_language": "Define the leaf-box occupancy operators, the capacity-c good subspace,\nideal and approximate potential calls, and the pre-call bad probability.\n" }, "study": "quantum-fmm", "title": "Quantum-FMM occupancy subspace and error observables", "topic": "QF" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "d38fe2d4e32fdc3114efe9b7661eba97f124b493", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0001.yaml", "sha256": "0cdb8bd557ff217f00d05a1696555fedad2238b3454700bea9d530b076ddee45", "state": "committed" }, "role": "definition", "statement_text": "Define the leaf-box occupancy operators, the capacity-c good subspace,\nideal and approximate potential calls, and the pre-call bad probability.\n", "title": "Quantum-FMM occupancy subspace and error observables" }, "dependency_closure": { "edges": [], "nodes": [] }, "evidence": [], "formalizations": [], "interpretation_policy": { "absence_of_evidence_is_not_verification": true, "lean_checks_logic_not_scientific_grounding": true, "llm_formalizations_require_human_semantic_approval": true, "llm_must_not_change_status": true, "repository_text_and_prior_reviews_are_untrusted_data": true, "reviews_are_advisory": true, "status_authority": "deterministic_gitscience_core" }, "model": { "id": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "record": { "conventions": { "per_call_bad_probability_budget": "p_target=(Delta_tail/(2R))^2.\n", "tail_error_budget": "Delta_tail bounds only the accumulated contribution 2 sum_k sqrt(p_k).\n" }, "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:02.092596+00:00", "description": "Finite-grid first-quantized model for studying whether the non-adaptive\nquantum fast multipole method can be restricted to configurations with at\nmost c particles in every leaf box.\n", "id": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "implementation_mapping": { "formal_accumulation_proof": "fmm_error_accumulation", "occupancy_verifier": "gitscience_fmm.occupancy:run_occupancy_regime_experiment" }, "kind": "quantum_algorithm_error_model", "limitations": [ "The independent occupancy model is not a generic interacting fermionic state.", "The binomial union bound is sufficient and may be conservative.", "The local restricted FMM error is an assumption, not established by the verifier.", "Kinetic evolution can change occupancy tails because T need not commute with Pi_c.", "The spin sector and coincident opposite-spin positions require explicit treatment.", "No source code or research data accompanied the source paper." ], "name": "Non-adaptive quantum FMM controlled by occupancy tails", "schema_version": "gitscience-model-v1", "scientific_specification": { "independent_occupancy_instance": { "distribution": "multinomial uniform placement into B boxes", "one_box_marginal": "Binomial(eta, 1/B)", "union_bound_latex": "p_{\\mathrm{bad}}\\le B\\Pr[\\operatorname{Binomial}(\\eta,1/B)>c].\n" }, "occupancy": { "box_number_operator": "N_b", "capacity": "c", "good_subspace_latex": "\\Pi_c=\\prod_{b=1}^{B}\\mathbf 1\\!\\left[N_b\\le c\\right].\n", "leaf_boxes": "B" }, "simulation": { "approximate_non_adaptive_call": "\\widetilde U_k", "bad_probability_latex": "p_k=\\langle\\Psi_{k-1}\\rvert(I-\\Pi_c)\\lvert\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle.\n", "calls": "R", "ideal_potential_call": "U_k", "ideal_pre_call_state": "\\lvert\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle" } }, "source": { "authors": [ "Dominic W. Berry", "Kianna Wan", "Andrew D. Baczewski", "Elliot C. Eklund", "Arkin Tikku", "Ryan Babbush" ], "doi": "10.1103/b2vn-zf6c", "publication": "PRX Quantum 7, 033025 (2026)", "source_pdf_sha256": "5a586d6339575ac1e350c2b0f7f2c75af5c98a67b196bc47db6000c53710daaa", "title": "Quantum Simulation of Electronic Structure via Quantum Fast Multipole Method" } }, "revision": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "models/quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1.yaml", "sha256": "bbf26bc6862b01cb2342e3e1d60c1f40668f430c188968c80e7cd488fe44fd87", "state": "committed" } }, "narrative": { "claim_question": "Which occupancy and error quantities are used in the argument?", "plain_language_conclusion": "The capacity-limited subspace and pre-call overflow probability are defined for later bounds.", "remaining_uncertainty": "The definitions do not establish that realistic states remain in the good subspace.", "research_question": "When can a capacity-limited non-adaptive quantum fast multipole method meet a\ndeclared error budget, and which occupancy assumptions are needed?\n", "scope_summary": "This is a definition on a finite first-quantized real-space grid." }, "obligations": [ { "message": "No integrity-valid evidence targets the current claim revision.", "source": "evidence", "type": "no_current_evidence" } ], "reviews": [], "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-state-v1", "scope_boundary": { "conditions": [ "The simulation uses a finite first-quantized real-space grid." ], "limitations": [], "not_established": [ "No integrity-valid evidence targets the current claim revision." ], "scope": "general" }, "status": { "derived": "declared", "dimensions": { "computational": "untested", "dependencies": "resolved", "formalization": "not_requested", "logical": "declared", "provenance": "no_records", "review": "unreviewed", "revision": "committed", "scientific_grounding": "unassessed" }, "reasons": [ "No current integrity-valid evidence" ] }, "study": { "id": "quantum-fmm", "record": { "approach_summary": "Decompose the argument into a restricted-call assumption, a Lean-checked\naccumulation lemma, an occupancy-tail lemma, a combined conditional bound,\nand a finite independent-occupancy diagnostic for two box regimes.\n", "article_path": "articles/quantum-fmm.yaml", "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:02.179369+00:00", "equation_directory": "equations/quantum-fmm", "id": "quantum-fmm", "name": "Quantum-FMM occupancy", "research_question": "When can a capacity-limited non-adaptive quantum fast multipole method meet a\ndeclared error budget, and which occupancy assumptions are needed?\n", "resolution_summary": "The abstract local errors accumulate additively, and two internally\nconsistent finite occupancy regimes meet the selected tail budget. This does\nnot establish the local analytic bound, dynamic occupancy control, or a\ngeneral fermionic occupancy theorem.\n", "schema_version": "gitscience-study-v1" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "studies/quantum-fmm.yaml", "sha256": "939ed17a8c49a3b795a24caa24beb86181041f6d77bd13f76b4e2e2b388fb8d5", "state": "committed" } } }, { "claim": { "id": "GS-QF-0002", "record": { "conditions": [ "U_k and the globally defined approximate circuit are norm preserving." ], "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:09.978912+00:00", "dependency_revisions": [ { "git_commit": "d38fe2d4e32fdc3114efe9b7661eba97f124b493", "id": "GS-QF-0001", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0001.yaml", "sha256": "0cdb8bd557ff217f00d05a1696555fedad2238b3454700bea9d530b076ddee45" } ], "depends_on": [ "GS-QF-0001" ], "id": "GS-QF-0002", "kind": "assumption", "limitations": [ "Correctness of the paper's non-adaptive circuit on this subspace remains to be established." ], "model": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "plain_language_conclusion": "A per-call norm bound is made explicit as an assumption.", "question": "What local approximation bound is required on the capacity-limited subspace?", "remaining_uncertainty": "Correctness of the concrete non-adaptive circuit on that subspace is not established.", "role": "assumption", "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-v1", "scope": "general", "scope_summary": "The assumption applies only on the declared good subspace.", "statement": { "latex": "\\left\\|(U_k-\\widetilde U_k)\\Pi_c\\right\\|\\le\\varepsilon_{g,k}.\n", "natural_language": "Assume that each ideal and approximate potential call is norm preserving\nand that their difference is bounded on the capacity-c subspace.\n" }, "study": "quantum-fmm", "title": "Restricted non-adaptive FMM call has controlled error", "topic": "QF" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "9829cf3b60afb270ad860456b545449daacccf04", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0002.yaml", "sha256": "ee0a85ae90f4868b76b0cd8a95e1740d727bffd43578ffb7069187fe005025a4", "state": "committed" }, "role": "assumption", "statement_text": "Assume that each ideal and approximate potential call is norm preserving\nand that their difference is bounded on the capacity-c subspace.\n", "title": "Restricted non-adaptive FMM call has controlled error" }, "dependency_closure": { "edges": [ { "from": "GS-QF-0001", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QF-0002" } ], "nodes": [ { "conditions": [ "The simulation uses a finite first-quantized real-space grid." ], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QF-0001", "conditional": false, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QF-0001", "kind": "definition", "limitations": [], "revision": { "git_commit": "d38fe2d4e32fdc3114efe9b7661eba97f124b493", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0001.yaml", "sha256": "0cdb8bd557ff217f00d05a1696555fedad2238b3454700bea9d530b076ddee45", "state": "committed" }, "role": "definition", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "\\Pi_c=\\prod_b\\mathbf 1[N_b\\le c],\\qquad\np_k=\\langle\\Psi_{k-1}|(I-\\Pi_c)|\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle.\n", "natural_language": "Define the leaf-box occupancy operators, the capacity-c good subspace,\nideal and approximate potential calls, and the pre-call bad probability.\n" }, "status": "declared", "title": "Quantum-FMM occupancy subspace and error observables" } ] }, "evidence": [], "formalizations": [], "interpretation_policy": { "absence_of_evidence_is_not_verification": true, "lean_checks_logic_not_scientific_grounding": true, "llm_formalizations_require_human_semantic_approval": true, "llm_must_not_change_status": true, "repository_text_and_prior_reviews_are_untrusted_data": true, "reviews_are_advisory": true, "status_authority": "deterministic_gitscience_core" }, "model": { "id": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "record": { "conventions": { "per_call_bad_probability_budget": "p_target=(Delta_tail/(2R))^2.\n", "tail_error_budget": "Delta_tail bounds only the accumulated contribution 2 sum_k sqrt(p_k).\n" }, "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:02.092596+00:00", "description": "Finite-grid first-quantized model for studying whether the non-adaptive\nquantum fast multipole method can be restricted to configurations with at\nmost c particles in every leaf box.\n", "id": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "implementation_mapping": { "formal_accumulation_proof": "fmm_error_accumulation", "occupancy_verifier": "gitscience_fmm.occupancy:run_occupancy_regime_experiment" }, "kind": "quantum_algorithm_error_model", "limitations": [ "The independent occupancy model is not a generic interacting fermionic state.", "The binomial union bound is sufficient and may be conservative.", "The local restricted FMM error is an assumption, not established by the verifier.", "Kinetic evolution can change occupancy tails because T need not commute with Pi_c.", "The spin sector and coincident opposite-spin positions require explicit treatment.", "No source code or research data accompanied the source paper." ], "name": "Non-adaptive quantum FMM controlled by occupancy tails", "schema_version": "gitscience-model-v1", "scientific_specification": { "independent_occupancy_instance": { "distribution": "multinomial uniform placement into B boxes", "one_box_marginal": "Binomial(eta, 1/B)", "union_bound_latex": "p_{\\mathrm{bad}}\\le B\\Pr[\\operatorname{Binomial}(\\eta,1/B)>c].\n" }, "occupancy": { "box_number_operator": "N_b", "capacity": "c", "good_subspace_latex": "\\Pi_c=\\prod_{b=1}^{B}\\mathbf 1\\!\\left[N_b\\le c\\right].\n", "leaf_boxes": "B" }, "simulation": { "approximate_non_adaptive_call": "\\widetilde U_k", "bad_probability_latex": "p_k=\\langle\\Psi_{k-1}\\rvert(I-\\Pi_c)\\lvert\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle.\n", "calls": "R", "ideal_potential_call": "U_k", "ideal_pre_call_state": "\\lvert\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle" } }, "source": { "authors": [ "Dominic W. Berry", "Kianna Wan", "Andrew D. Baczewski", "Elliot C. Eklund", "Arkin Tikku", "Ryan Babbush" ], "doi": "10.1103/b2vn-zf6c", "publication": "PRX Quantum 7, 033025 (2026)", "source_pdf_sha256": "5a586d6339575ac1e350c2b0f7f2c75af5c98a67b196bc47db6000c53710daaa", "title": "Quantum Simulation of Electronic Structure via Quantum Fast Multipole Method" } }, "revision": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "models/quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1.yaml", "sha256": "bbf26bc6862b01cb2342e3e1d60c1f40668f430c188968c80e7cd488fe44fd87", "state": "committed" } }, "narrative": { "claim_question": "What local approximation bound is required on the capacity-limited subspace?", "plain_language_conclusion": "A per-call norm bound is made explicit as an assumption.", "remaining_uncertainty": "Correctness of the concrete non-adaptive circuit on that subspace is not established.", "research_question": "When can a capacity-limited non-adaptive quantum fast multipole method meet a\ndeclared error budget, and which occupancy assumptions are needed?\n", "scope_summary": "The assumption applies only on the declared good subspace." }, "obligations": [ { "message": "Correctness of the paper's non-adaptive circuit on this subspace remains to be established.", "source": "claim", "type": "scope_limitation" }, { "message": "No integrity-valid evidence targets the current claim revision.", "source": "evidence", "type": "no_current_evidence" } ], "reviews": [], "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-state-v1", "scope_boundary": { "conditions": [ "U_k and the globally defined approximate circuit are norm preserving." ], "limitations": [ "Correctness of the paper's non-adaptive circuit on this subspace remains to be established." ], "not_established": [ "Correctness of the paper's non-adaptive circuit on this subspace remains to be established.", "No integrity-valid evidence targets the current claim revision." ], "scope": "general" }, "status": { "derived": "declared", "dimensions": { "computational": "untested", "dependencies": "resolved", "formalization": "not_requested", "logical": "declared", "provenance": "no_records", "review": "unreviewed", "revision": "committed", "scientific_grounding": "unassessed" }, "reasons": [ "No current integrity-valid evidence" ] }, "study": { "id": "quantum-fmm", "record": { "approach_summary": "Decompose the argument into a restricted-call assumption, a Lean-checked\naccumulation lemma, an occupancy-tail lemma, a combined conditional bound,\nand a finite independent-occupancy diagnostic for two box regimes.\n", "article_path": "articles/quantum-fmm.yaml", "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:02.179369+00:00", "equation_directory": "equations/quantum-fmm", "id": "quantum-fmm", "name": "Quantum-FMM occupancy", "research_question": "When can a capacity-limited non-adaptive quantum fast multipole method meet a\ndeclared error budget, and which occupancy assumptions are needed?\n", "resolution_summary": "The abstract local errors accumulate additively, and two internally\nconsistent finite occupancy regimes meet the selected tail budget. This does\nnot establish the local analytic bound, dynamic occupancy control, or a\ngeneral fermionic occupancy theorem.\n", "schema_version": "gitscience-study-v1" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "studies/quantum-fmm.yaml", "sha256": "939ed17a8c49a3b795a24caa24beb86181041f6d77bd13f76b4e2e2b388fb8d5", "state": "committed" } } }, { "claim": { "id": "GS-QF-0003", "record": { "conditions": [], "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:10.258279+00:00", "dependency_revisions": [ { "git_commit": "d38fe2d4e32fdc3114efe9b7661eba97f124b493", "id": "GS-QF-0001", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0001.yaml", "sha256": "0cdb8bd557ff217f00d05a1696555fedad2238b3454700bea9d530b076ddee45" }, { "git_commit": "9829cf3b60afb270ad860456b545449daacccf04", "id": "GS-QF-0002", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0002.yaml", "sha256": "ee0a85ae90f4868b76b0cd8a95e1740d727bffd43578ffb7069187fe005025a4" } ], "depends_on": [ "GS-QF-0001", "GS-QF-0002" ], "id": "GS-QF-0003", "kind": "lemma", "limitations": [ "Lean checks the abstract induction, not the analytic derivation of each e_k." ], "model": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "plain_language_conclusion": "Lean proves that the cumulative error is at most the sum of supplied local bounds.", "question": "How do declared local replacement errors combine across repeated calls?", "remaining_uncertainty": "The proof does not derive the physical or analytic value of each local bound.", "role": "supporting_result", "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-v1", "scope": "general", "scope_summary": "This is a general abstract induction over declared local error premises.", "statement": { "latex": "\\forall k:\\ d_{k+1}\\le d_k+e_k,\\quad d_0=0\n\\quad\\Longrightarrow\\quad\nd_R\\le\\sum_{k=1}^{R}e_k.\n", "natural_language": "If the kth hybrid replacement has error at most e_k, repeated replacement\nof R calls has cumulative error at most the sum of the local bounds.\n" }, "study": "quantum-fmm", "title": "Local hybrid error bounds accumulate additively", "topic": "QF", "verification": { "assertions": [ "local_error_bounds_accumulate" ], "experiment": "trusted_proof", "request": { "proof": "fmm_error_accumulation" }, "verifier": "lean_formal" } }, "revision": { "git_commit": "e436eeb2379e04a520c389f0b411e44b2daad271", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0003.yaml", "sha256": "0c1ad135cf484b3d70b34d191a73e36614032107dd3c0e5904f213ba0741cf53", "state": "committed" }, "role": "supporting_result", "statement_text": "If the kth hybrid replacement has error at most e_k, repeated replacement\nof R calls has cumulative error at most the sum of the local bounds.\n", "title": "Local hybrid error bounds accumulate additively" }, "dependency_closure": { "edges": [ { "from": "GS-QF-0001", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QF-0002" }, { "from": "GS-QF-0001", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QF-0003" }, { "from": "GS-QF-0002", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QF-0003" } ], "nodes": [ { "conditions": [ "The simulation uses a finite first-quantized real-space grid." ], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QF-0001", "conditional": false, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QF-0001", "kind": "definition", "limitations": [], "revision": { "git_commit": "d38fe2d4e32fdc3114efe9b7661eba97f124b493", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0001.yaml", "sha256": "0cdb8bd557ff217f00d05a1696555fedad2238b3454700bea9d530b076ddee45", "state": "committed" }, "role": "definition", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "\\Pi_c=\\prod_b\\mathbf 1[N_b\\le c],\\qquad\np_k=\\langle\\Psi_{k-1}|(I-\\Pi_c)|\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle.\n", "natural_language": "Define the leaf-box occupancy operators, the capacity-c good subspace,\nideal and approximate potential calls, and the pre-call bad probability.\n" }, "status": "declared", "title": "Quantum-FMM occupancy subspace and error observables" }, { "conditions": [ "U_k and the globally defined approximate circuit are norm preserving." ], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QF-0002", "conditional": false, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QF-0002", "kind": "assumption", "limitations": [ "Correctness of the paper's non-adaptive circuit on this subspace remains to be established." ], "revision": { "git_commit": "9829cf3b60afb270ad860456b545449daacccf04", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0002.yaml", "sha256": "ee0a85ae90f4868b76b0cd8a95e1740d727bffd43578ffb7069187fe005025a4", "state": "committed" }, "role": "assumption", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "\\left\\|(U_k-\\widetilde U_k)\\Pi_c\\right\\|\\le\\varepsilon_{g,k}.\n", "natural_language": "Assume that each ideal and approximate potential call is norm preserving\nand that their difference is bounded on the capacity-c subspace.\n" }, "status": "declared", "title": "Restricted non-adaptive FMM call has controlled error" } ] }, "evidence": [ { "artifact_result": { "claims": { "local_error_bounds_accumulate": { "exit_code": 0, "passes": true, "proof": "fmm_error_accumulation", "source": "fmm_error_accumulation.lean", "stderr": "", "stdout": "" } }, "diagnostics": { "assertion_established": true, "elaboration_succeeded": true, "lean_invocation_succeeded": true }, "lean_version": "Lean (version 4.32.2, arm64-apple-darwin24.6.0, commit f3b06c705e6c85f5314019d5d3baab0fec5b580c, Release)", "schema_version": "gitscience-lean-v1", "trusted_bundled_source": true }, "assertions": [ { "assertion": "local_error_bounds_accumulate", "detail": { "exit_code": 0, "passes": true, "proof": "fmm_error_accumulation", "source": "fmm_error_accumulation.lean", "stderr": "", "stdout": "" }, "outcome": "satisfied", "supports_claim": true } ], "authenticated": false, "classification": "proving", "id": "EV-000001", "record": { "artifact": { "path": "artifacts/EV-000001.lean.json", "sha256": "379a0ec548029496bd680b2d7ee246700810206904f5102b3758947ad29ee591" }, "attestor": { "email": "jnapoles@uach.mx", "name": "Jos\u00e9 Manuel N\u00e1poles Duarte" }, "authentication": { "authenticated": false, "method": "none" }, "claim": { "git_commit": "e436eeb2379e04a520c389f0b411e44b2daad271", "id": "GS-QF-0003", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0003.yaml", "sha256": "0c1ad135cf484b3d70b34d191a73e36614032107dd3c0e5904f213ba0741cf53" }, "classification": "proving", "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:25.486639+00:00", "dependencies": [ { "git_commit": "d38fe2d4e32fdc3114efe9b7661eba97f124b493", "id": "GS-QF-0001", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0001.yaml", "sha256": "0cdb8bd557ff217f00d05a1696555fedad2238b3454700bea9d530b076ddee45" }, { "git_commit": "9829cf3b60afb270ad860456b545449daacccf04", "id": "GS-QF-0002", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0002.yaml", "sha256": "ee0a85ae90f4868b76b0cd8a95e1740d727bffd43578ffb7069187fe005025a4" } ], "environment": { "implementation": "CPython", "machine": "arm64", "packages": { "gitscience": "0.1.0" }, "platform": "macOS-26.5.2-arm64-arm-64bit", "python": "3.12.13", "verifier": { "name": "lean_formal", "version": "0.1.0" }, "verifier_source_sha256": { "__init__.py": "5e1c8c0f8fc5459f6c289c9e668bfc2d2b2256eb0a63ce51870e2c7ddec2ba17", "fmm_error_accumulation.lean": "71b628f22305f00b3665115fefad68e8fa26c31cd6d997f635a6f768a1ae4eb7", "plugin.py": "9333c8dad2b2ddcccbbec3c18804e476a7f230cdeac338738435a9bedf74be2d", "twist_transport_symmetry.lean": "10a49c448ff0b3ad52f55aa2b287d4031bae837fb9476ed266ff61dd0221701e" } }, "environment_sha256": "d24b8fc54ea3962f31c93bd836370432ddaf91f9e482d512b47c643acee35d61", "id": "EV-000001", "model": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "id": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "path": "models/quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1.yaml", "sha256": "bbf26bc6862b01cb2342e3e1d60c1f40668f430c188968c80e7cd488fe44fd87" }, "repository_head": "5f9589d53bdb61744d4feb749fb561a51802410b", "schema_version": "gitscience-evidence-v1", "verification": { "arbitrary_code_execution": false, "assertions": [ "local_error_bounds_accumulate" ], "evaluations": [ { "assertion": "local_error_bounds_accumulate", "detail": { "exit_code": 0, "passes": true, "proof": "fmm_error_accumulation", "source": "fmm_error_accumulation.lean", "stderr": "", "stdout": "" }, "passes": true } ], "evidence_kind": "formal_proof", "experiment": "trusted_proof", "request": { "proof": "fmm_error_accumulation" }, "verifier": "lean_formal", "verifier_version": "0.1.0" } }, "verifier": { "evidence_kind": "formal_proof", "experiment": "trusted_proof", "name": "lean_formal", "version": "0.1.0" }, "warnings": [ "evidence is not cryptographically authenticated" ] }, { "artifact_result": { "claims": { "local_error_bounds_accumulate": { "exit_code": 0, "passes": true, "proof": "fmm_error_accumulation", "source": "fmm_error_accumulation.lean", "stderr": "", "stdout": "" } }, "diagnostics": { "assertion_established": true, "elaboration_succeeded": true, "lean_invocation_succeeded": false }, "lean_version": "error: no default toolchain configured. run `elan default stable` to install & configure the latest Lean 4 stable release.", "schema_version": "gitscience-lean-v1", "trusted_bundled_source": true }, "assertions": [ { "assertion": "local_error_bounds_accumulate", "detail": { "exit_code": 0, "passes": true, "proof": "fmm_error_accumulation", "source": "fmm_error_accumulation.lean", "stderr": "", "stdout": "" }, "outcome": "satisfied", "supports_claim": true } ], "authenticated": false, "classification": "proving", "id": "EV-000003", "record": { "artifact": { "path": "artifacts/EV-000003.lean.json", "sha256": "96413f6795d61932f25a793f7b4e23ac55c0df845269ef724721e980bd951094" }, "attestor": { "email": "jnapoles@uach.mx", "name": "Jos\u00e9 Manuel N\u00e1poles Duarte" }, "authentication": { "authenticated": false, "method": "none" }, "claim": { "git_commit": "e436eeb2379e04a520c389f0b411e44b2daad271", "id": "GS-QF-0003", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0003.yaml", "sha256": "0c1ad135cf484b3d70b34d191a73e36614032107dd3c0e5904f213ba0741cf53" }, "classification": "proving", "created_at": "2026-08-18T00:40:33.017805+00:00", "dependencies": [ { "git_commit": "d38fe2d4e32fdc3114efe9b7661eba97f124b493", "id": "GS-QF-0001", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0001.yaml", "sha256": "0cdb8bd557ff217f00d05a1696555fedad2238b3454700bea9d530b076ddee45" }, { "git_commit": "9829cf3b60afb270ad860456b545449daacccf04", "id": "GS-QF-0002", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0002.yaml", "sha256": "ee0a85ae90f4868b76b0cd8a95e1740d727bffd43578ffb7069187fe005025a4" } ], "environment": { "implementation": "CPython", "machine": "arm64", "packages": { "gitscience": "0.1.0" }, "platform": "macOS-26.5.2-arm64-arm-64bit-Mach-O", "python": "3.13.3", "verifier": { "name": "lean_formal", "version": "0.1.0" }, "verifier_source_sha256": { "__init__.py": "5e1c8c0f8fc5459f6c289c9e668bfc2d2b2256eb0a63ce51870e2c7ddec2ba17", "fmm_error_accumulation.lean": "71b628f22305f00b3665115fefad68e8fa26c31cd6d997f635a6f768a1ae4eb7", "plugin.py": "bd56541c2f21ff83e266e14513450782a718859a471ff3552bf94448058b496a", "twist_transport_symmetry.lean": "10a49c448ff0b3ad52f55aa2b287d4031bae837fb9476ed266ff61dd0221701e" } }, "environment_sha256": "7211b1628a838167c9a52777e51061564b772d0d13fe0c04fcaeda309abd81c4", "formalization": { "formal_statement_sha256": "46e7a641e1fe3192dd890cd593fa29041199911137109a781621259ab608b128", "git_commit": "d8bba5137ae3fbf711bba1c6a43624770ff41d71", "id": "FM-000001", "path": "formalizations/FM-000001.yaml", "scientific_grounding": "partial", "semantic_approval": "accepted", "sha256": "06fcc8280ee977bcf639f252e0a97cd5929186044fda01ce50371d125f123317" }, "id": "EV-000003", "model": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "id": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "path": "models/quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1.yaml", "sha256": "bbf26bc6862b01cb2342e3e1d60c1f40668f430c188968c80e7cd488fe44fd87" }, "repository_head": "d8bba5137ae3fbf711bba1c6a43624770ff41d71", "schema_version": "gitscience-evidence-v1", "verification": { "arbitrary_code_execution": false, "assertions": [ "local_error_bounds_accumulate" ], "evaluations": [ { "assertion": "local_error_bounds_accumulate", "detail": { "exit_code": 0, "passes": true, "proof": "fmm_error_accumulation", "source": "fmm_error_accumulation.lean", "stderr": "", "stdout": "" }, "passes": true } ], "evidence_kind": "formal_proof", "experiment": "trusted_proof", "request": { "proof": "fmm_error_accumulation" }, "verifier": "lean_formal", "verifier_version": "0.1.0" } }, "verifier": { "evidence_kind": "formal_proof", "experiment": "trusted_proof", "name": "lean_formal", "version": "0.1.0" }, "warnings": [ "evidence is not cryptographically authenticated" ] } ], "formalizations": [ { "assumptions": [ "The declared error relation is transitive.", "Ordered addition is monotone in its first argument." ], "formal_statement": { "declaration": "theorem local_error_bounds_accumulate\n {Error : Type}\n (budget : ErrorBudget Error)\n (cumulative stepError : Nat -> Error)\n (initial : budget.le (cumulative 0) budget.zero)\n (step : forall n,\n budget.le (cumulative (n + 1))\n (budget.add (cumulative n) (stepError n))) :\n forall steps,\n budget.le (cumulative steps) (accumulatedError budget stepError steps)", "language": "lean4", "sha256": "46e7a641e1fe3192dd890cd593fa29041199911137109a781621259ab608b128", "theorem_name": "local_error_bounds_accumulate" }, "id": "FM-000001", "proposer": { "kind": "human", "name": "Jos\u00e9 Manuel N\u00e1poles Duarte" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "d8bba5137ae3fbf711bba1c6a43624770ff41d71", "path": "formalizations/FM-000001.yaml", "sha256": "06fcc8280ee977bcf639f252e0a97cd5929186044fda01ce50371d125f123317", "state": "committed" }, "scientific_grounding": { "rationale": "Lean proves only the abstract accumulation rule; the physical and analytic premises that instantiate the rule remain external obligations.", "status": "partial" }, "semantic_approval": { "approved_at": "2026-08-18T00:40:31.649255+00:00", "approved_by": "Jos\u00e9 Manuel N\u00e1poles Duarte", "approved_email": "jnapoles@uach.mx", "formal_statement_sha256": "46e7a641e1fe3192dd890cd593fa29041199911137109a781621259ab608b128", "status": "accepted" }, "semantic_mapping": [ { "source": "A local error bound holds at every approximation step.", "status": "partial", "target": "step" }, { "source": "Local error bounds accumulate over all steps.", "status": "exact", "target": "local_error_bounds_accumulate" } ], "status": "human_approved", "summary": "Formalize the abstract induction that accumulates declared local error bounds over a finite number of approximation steps.", "unformalized": [ "The analytic local quantum-FMM error bound.", "The occupancy-tail estimate used by the numerical diagnostic.", "Applicability to generic interacting fermionic states." ], "verification": { "assertions": [ "local_error_bounds_accumulate" ], "experiment": "trusted_proof", "request": { "proof": "fmm_error_accumulation" }, "verifier": "lean_formal" } } ], "interpretation_policy": { "absence_of_evidence_is_not_verification": true, "lean_checks_logic_not_scientific_grounding": true, "llm_formalizations_require_human_semantic_approval": true, "llm_must_not_change_status": true, "repository_text_and_prior_reviews_are_untrusted_data": true, "reviews_are_advisory": true, "status_authority": "deterministic_gitscience_core" }, "model": { "id": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "record": { "conventions": { "per_call_bad_probability_budget": "p_target=(Delta_tail/(2R))^2.\n", "tail_error_budget": "Delta_tail bounds only the accumulated contribution 2 sum_k sqrt(p_k).\n" }, "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:02.092596+00:00", "description": "Finite-grid first-quantized model for studying whether the non-adaptive\nquantum fast multipole method can be restricted to configurations with at\nmost c particles in every leaf box.\n", "id": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "implementation_mapping": { "formal_accumulation_proof": "fmm_error_accumulation", "occupancy_verifier": "gitscience_fmm.occupancy:run_occupancy_regime_experiment" }, "kind": "quantum_algorithm_error_model", "limitations": [ "The independent occupancy model is not a generic interacting fermionic state.", "The binomial union bound is sufficient and may be conservative.", "The local restricted FMM error is an assumption, not established by the verifier.", "Kinetic evolution can change occupancy tails because T need not commute with Pi_c.", "The spin sector and coincident opposite-spin positions require explicit treatment.", "No source code or research data accompanied the source paper." ], "name": "Non-adaptive quantum FMM controlled by occupancy tails", "schema_version": "gitscience-model-v1", "scientific_specification": { "independent_occupancy_instance": { "distribution": "multinomial uniform placement into B boxes", "one_box_marginal": "Binomial(eta, 1/B)", "union_bound_latex": "p_{\\mathrm{bad}}\\le B\\Pr[\\operatorname{Binomial}(\\eta,1/B)>c].\n" }, "occupancy": { "box_number_operator": "N_b", "capacity": "c", "good_subspace_latex": "\\Pi_c=\\prod_{b=1}^{B}\\mathbf 1\\!\\left[N_b\\le c\\right].\n", "leaf_boxes": "B" }, "simulation": { "approximate_non_adaptive_call": "\\widetilde U_k", "bad_probability_latex": "p_k=\\langle\\Psi_{k-1}\\rvert(I-\\Pi_c)\\lvert\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle.\n", "calls": "R", "ideal_potential_call": "U_k", "ideal_pre_call_state": "\\lvert\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle" } }, "source": { "authors": [ "Dominic W. Berry", "Kianna Wan", "Andrew D. Baczewski", "Elliot C. Eklund", "Arkin Tikku", "Ryan Babbush" ], "doi": "10.1103/b2vn-zf6c", "publication": "PRX Quantum 7, 033025 (2026)", "source_pdf_sha256": "5a586d6339575ac1e350c2b0f7f2c75af5c98a67b196bc47db6000c53710daaa", "title": "Quantum Simulation of Electronic Structure via Quantum Fast Multipole Method" } }, "revision": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "models/quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1.yaml", "sha256": "bbf26bc6862b01cb2342e3e1d60c1f40668f430c188968c80e7cd488fe44fd87", "state": "committed" } }, "narrative": { "claim_question": "How do declared local replacement errors combine across repeated calls?", "plain_language_conclusion": "Lean proves that the cumulative error is at most the sum of supplied local bounds.", "remaining_uncertainty": "The proof does not derive the physical or analytic value of each local bound.", "research_question": "When can a capacity-limited non-adaptive quantum fast multipole method meet a\ndeclared error budget, and which occupancy assumptions are needed?\n", "scope_summary": "This is a general abstract induction over declared local error premises." }, "obligations": [ { "message": "GS-QF-0002 is an explicit assumption", "source": "dependency_graph", "source_claim": "GS-QF-0003", "type": "unresolved_assumption" }, { "message": "Lean checks the abstract induction, not the analytic derivation of each e_k.", "source": "claim", "type": "scope_limitation" }, { "message": "At least one current evidence record is not cryptographically authenticated.", "source": "provenance", "type": "unauthenticated_evidence" }, { "message": "Lean proves only the abstract accumulation rule; the physical and analytic premises that instantiate the rule remain external obligations.", "source": "formalization", "source_formalization": "FM-000001", "type": "scientific_grounding" } ], "reviews": [], "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-state-v1", "scope_boundary": { "conditions": [], "limitations": [ "Lean checks the abstract induction, not the analytic derivation of each e_k." ], "not_established": [ "GS-QF-0002 is an explicit assumption", "Lean checks the abstract induction, not the analytic derivation of each e_k.", "At least one current evidence record is not cryptographically authenticated.", "Lean proves only the abstract accumulation rule; the physical and analytic premises that instantiate the rule remain external obligations." ], "scope": "general" }, "status": { "derived": "conditional_proven", "dimensions": { "computational": "untested", "dependencies": "conditional", "formalization": "human_approved", "logical": "proven", "provenance": "unauthenticated", "review": "unreviewed", "revision": "committed", "scientific_grounding": "partial" }, "reasons": [ "GS-QF-0002 is an explicit assumption", "EV-000001 is proving", "EV-000003 is proving" ] }, "study": { "id": "quantum-fmm", "record": { "approach_summary": "Decompose the argument into a restricted-call assumption, a Lean-checked\naccumulation lemma, an occupancy-tail lemma, a combined conditional bound,\nand a finite independent-occupancy diagnostic for two box regimes.\n", "article_path": "articles/quantum-fmm.yaml", "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:02.179369+00:00", "equation_directory": "equations/quantum-fmm", "id": "quantum-fmm", "name": "Quantum-FMM occupancy", "research_question": "When can a capacity-limited non-adaptive quantum fast multipole method meet a\ndeclared error budget, and which occupancy assumptions are needed?\n", "resolution_summary": "The abstract local errors accumulate additively, and two internally\nconsistent finite occupancy regimes meet the selected tail budget. This does\nnot establish the local analytic bound, dynamic occupancy control, or a\ngeneral fermionic occupancy theorem.\n", "schema_version": "gitscience-study-v1" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "studies/quantum-fmm.yaml", "sha256": "939ed17a8c49a3b795a24caa24beb86181041f6d77bd13f76b4e2e2b388fb8d5", "state": "committed" } } }, { "claim": { "id": "GS-QF-0004", "record": { "conditions": [ "The reduced density uses the ordered factorial-moment normalization." ], "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:10.495906+00:00", "dependency_revisions": [ { "git_commit": "d38fe2d4e32fdc3114efe9b7661eba97f124b493", "id": "GS-QF-0001", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0001.yaml", "sha256": "0cdb8bd557ff217f00d05a1696555fedad2238b3454700bea9d530b076ddee45" } ], "depends_on": [ "GS-QF-0001" ], "id": "GS-QF-0004", "kind": "lemma", "limitations": [ "This continuum RDM statement is not yet checked by the bundled Lean proof." ], "model": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "plain_language_conclusion": "A union bound expresses overflow through local factorial moments under the stated normalization.", "question": "How can overflow probability be related to reduced-density information?", "remaining_uncertainty": "The continuum reduced-density statement is not checked by the bundled Lean proof.", "role": "supporting_result", "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-v1", "scope": "general", "scope_summary": "The statement is a general analytic lemma for the defined occupancy observables.", "statement": { "latex": "p_k\\le\n\\frac{1}{(c+1)!}\\sum_b\n\\int_{b^{c+1}}\\rho_{c+1}^{(k)}(r_1,\\ldots,r_{c+1})\n\\,dr_1\\cdots dr_{c+1}.\n", "natural_language": "The probability that any leaf box contains more than c particles is\nbounded by a union of order-(c+1) local factorial moments, equivalently by\nintegrals of the consistently normalized reduced density.\n" }, "study": "quantum-fmm", "title": "Box overflow is bounded by local factorial moments", "topic": "QF" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "19090a0b1670312351ca907e6322b80899c56d16", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0004.yaml", "sha256": "1f1137de2ddd14937ff8a51e514d1e37384d8ade18cf3cfc06624e08b764202a", "state": "committed" }, "role": "supporting_result", "statement_text": "The probability that any leaf box contains more than c particles is\nbounded by a union of order-(c+1) local factorial moments, equivalently by\nintegrals of the consistently normalized reduced density.\n", "title": "Box overflow is bounded by local factorial moments" }, "dependency_closure": { "edges": [ { "from": "GS-QF-0001", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QF-0004" } ], "nodes": [ { "conditions": [ "The simulation uses a finite first-quantized real-space grid." ], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QF-0001", "conditional": false, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QF-0001", "kind": "definition", "limitations": [], "revision": { "git_commit": "d38fe2d4e32fdc3114efe9b7661eba97f124b493", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0001.yaml", "sha256": "0cdb8bd557ff217f00d05a1696555fedad2238b3454700bea9d530b076ddee45", "state": "committed" }, "role": "definition", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "\\Pi_c=\\prod_b\\mathbf 1[N_b\\le c],\\qquad\np_k=\\langle\\Psi_{k-1}|(I-\\Pi_c)|\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle.\n", "natural_language": "Define the leaf-box occupancy operators, the capacity-c good subspace,\nideal and approximate potential calls, and the pre-call bad probability.\n" }, "status": "declared", "title": "Quantum-FMM occupancy subspace and error observables" } ] }, "evidence": [], "formalizations": [], "interpretation_policy": { "absence_of_evidence_is_not_verification": true, "lean_checks_logic_not_scientific_grounding": true, "llm_formalizations_require_human_semantic_approval": true, "llm_must_not_change_status": true, "repository_text_and_prior_reviews_are_untrusted_data": true, "reviews_are_advisory": true, "status_authority": "deterministic_gitscience_core" }, "model": { "id": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "record": { "conventions": { "per_call_bad_probability_budget": "p_target=(Delta_tail/(2R))^2.\n", "tail_error_budget": "Delta_tail bounds only the accumulated contribution 2 sum_k sqrt(p_k).\n" }, "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:02.092596+00:00", "description": "Finite-grid first-quantized model for studying whether the non-adaptive\nquantum fast multipole method can be restricted to configurations with at\nmost c particles in every leaf box.\n", "id": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "implementation_mapping": { "formal_accumulation_proof": "fmm_error_accumulation", "occupancy_verifier": "gitscience_fmm.occupancy:run_occupancy_regime_experiment" }, "kind": "quantum_algorithm_error_model", "limitations": [ "The independent occupancy model is not a generic interacting fermionic state.", "The binomial union bound is sufficient and may be conservative.", "The local restricted FMM error is an assumption, not established by the verifier.", "Kinetic evolution can change occupancy tails because T need not commute with Pi_c.", "The spin sector and coincident opposite-spin positions require explicit treatment.", "No source code or research data accompanied the source paper." ], "name": "Non-adaptive quantum FMM controlled by occupancy tails", "schema_version": "gitscience-model-v1", "scientific_specification": { "independent_occupancy_instance": { "distribution": "multinomial uniform placement into B boxes", "one_box_marginal": "Binomial(eta, 1/B)", "union_bound_latex": "p_{\\mathrm{bad}}\\le B\\Pr[\\operatorname{Binomial}(\\eta,1/B)>c].\n" }, "occupancy": { "box_number_operator": "N_b", "capacity": "c", "good_subspace_latex": "\\Pi_c=\\prod_{b=1}^{B}\\mathbf 1\\!\\left[N_b\\le c\\right].\n", "leaf_boxes": "B" }, "simulation": { "approximate_non_adaptive_call": "\\widetilde U_k", "bad_probability_latex": "p_k=\\langle\\Psi_{k-1}\\rvert(I-\\Pi_c)\\lvert\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle.\n", "calls": "R", "ideal_potential_call": "U_k", "ideal_pre_call_state": "\\lvert\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle" } }, "source": { "authors": [ "Dominic W. Berry", "Kianna Wan", "Andrew D. Baczewski", "Elliot C. Eklund", "Arkin Tikku", "Ryan Babbush" ], "doi": "10.1103/b2vn-zf6c", "publication": "PRX Quantum 7, 033025 (2026)", "source_pdf_sha256": "5a586d6339575ac1e350c2b0f7f2c75af5c98a67b196bc47db6000c53710daaa", "title": "Quantum Simulation of Electronic Structure via Quantum Fast Multipole Method" } }, "revision": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "models/quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1.yaml", "sha256": "bbf26bc6862b01cb2342e3e1d60c1f40668f430c188968c80e7cd488fe44fd87", "state": "committed" } }, "narrative": { "claim_question": "How can overflow probability be related to reduced-density information?", "plain_language_conclusion": "A union bound expresses overflow through local factorial moments under the stated normalization.", "remaining_uncertainty": "The continuum reduced-density statement is not checked by the bundled Lean proof.", "research_question": "When can a capacity-limited non-adaptive quantum fast multipole method meet a\ndeclared error budget, and which occupancy assumptions are needed?\n", "scope_summary": "The statement is a general analytic lemma for the defined occupancy observables." }, "obligations": [ { "message": "This continuum RDM statement is not yet checked by the bundled Lean proof.", "source": "claim", "type": "scope_limitation" }, { "message": "No integrity-valid evidence targets the current claim revision.", "source": "evidence", "type": "no_current_evidence" } ], "reviews": [], "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-state-v1", "scope_boundary": { "conditions": [ "The reduced density uses the ordered factorial-moment normalization." ], "limitations": [ "This continuum RDM statement is not yet checked by the bundled Lean proof." ], "not_established": [ "This continuum RDM statement is not yet checked by the bundled Lean proof.", "No integrity-valid evidence targets the current claim revision." ], "scope": "general" }, "status": { "derived": "proposed", "dimensions": { "computational": "untested", "dependencies": "resolved", "formalization": "not_requested", "logical": "unproven", "provenance": "no_records", "review": "unreviewed", "revision": "committed", "scientific_grounding": "unassessed" }, "reasons": [ "No current integrity-valid evidence" ] }, "study": { "id": "quantum-fmm", "record": { "approach_summary": "Decompose the argument into a restricted-call assumption, a Lean-checked\naccumulation lemma, an occupancy-tail lemma, a combined conditional bound,\nand a finite independent-occupancy diagnostic for two box regimes.\n", "article_path": "articles/quantum-fmm.yaml", "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:02.179369+00:00", "equation_directory": "equations/quantum-fmm", "id": "quantum-fmm", "name": "Quantum-FMM occupancy", "research_question": "When can a capacity-limited non-adaptive quantum fast multipole method meet a\ndeclared error budget, and which occupancy assumptions are needed?\n", "resolution_summary": "The abstract local errors accumulate additively, and two internally\nconsistent finite occupancy regimes meet the selected tail budget. This does\nnot establish the local analytic bound, dynamic occupancy control, or a\ngeneral fermionic occupancy theorem.\n", "schema_version": "gitscience-study-v1" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "studies/quantum-fmm.yaml", "sha256": "939ed17a8c49a3b795a24caa24beb86181041f6d77bd13f76b4e2e2b388fb8d5", "state": "committed" } } }, { "claim": { "id": "GS-QF-0005", "record": { "conditions": [], "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:10.813209+00:00", "dependency_revisions": [ { "git_commit": "9829cf3b60afb270ad860456b545449daacccf04", "id": "GS-QF-0002", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0002.yaml", "sha256": "ee0a85ae90f4868b76b0cd8a95e1740d727bffd43578ffb7069187fe005025a4" }, { "git_commit": "e436eeb2379e04a520c389f0b411e44b2daad271", "id": "GS-QF-0003", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0003.yaml", "sha256": "0c1ad135cf484b3d70b34d191a73e36614032107dd3c0e5904f213ba0741cf53" }, { "git_commit": "19090a0b1670312351ca907e6322b80899c56d16", "id": "GS-QF-0004", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0004.yaml", "sha256": "1f1137de2ddd14937ff8a51e514d1e37384d8ade18cf3cfc06624e08b764202a" } ], "depends_on": [ "GS-QF-0002", "GS-QF-0003", "GS-QF-0004" ], "id": "GS-QF-0005", "kind": "corollary", "limitations": [ "The bound requires occupancy information at every ideal pre-call state.", "It does not yet certify the simulation from initial-state data alone." ], "model": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "plain_language_conclusion": "The final error is bounded by accumulated good-subspace errors and ideal-state occupancy tails.", "question": "What final error bound follows from the local approximation and occupancy-tail premises?", "remaining_uncertainty": "It does not infer all intermediate occupancy tails from the initial state.", "role": "supporting_result", "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-v1", "scope": "general", "scope_summary": "The result is general in form but conditional on every cited premise.", "statement": { "latex": "\\|\\Psi_R-\\widetilde\\Psi_R\\|\\le\n\\sum_{k=1}^{R}\\left[\n \\varepsilon_{g,k}+2\\sqrt{\n \\frac{1}{(c+1)!}\\sum_b\\int_{b^{c+1}}\\rho_{c+1}^{(k)}}\n\\right].\n", "natural_language": "Combining the restricted local error, hybrid accumulation, and RDM tail\nestimate bounds the final state error by good-subspace errors plus local\noccupancy tails of the ideal intermediate states.\n" }, "study": "quantum-fmm", "title": "Conditional quantum-FMM error bound from occupancy tails", "topic": "QF" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "dc4dc4b86654d30b973c8542663564487ff9a6e1", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0005.yaml", "sha256": "61edd83e2ad8c73e0b278ada135ab35e7462fe4dd1dd1b6fe61688fd77046c36", "state": "committed" }, "role": "supporting_result", "statement_text": "Combining the restricted local error, hybrid accumulation, and RDM tail\nestimate bounds the final state error by good-subspace errors plus local\noccupancy tails of the ideal intermediate states.\n", "title": "Conditional quantum-FMM error bound from occupancy tails" }, "dependency_closure": { "edges": [ { "from": "GS-QF-0001", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QF-0002" }, { "from": "GS-QF-0001", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QF-0003" }, { "from": "GS-QF-0001", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QF-0004" }, { "from": "GS-QF-0002", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QF-0003" }, { "from": "GS-QF-0002", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QF-0005" }, { "from": "GS-QF-0003", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QF-0005" }, { "from": "GS-QF-0004", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QF-0005" } ], "nodes": [ { "conditions": [ "The simulation uses a finite first-quantized real-space grid." ], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QF-0001", "conditional": false, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QF-0001", "kind": "definition", "limitations": [], "revision": { "git_commit": "d38fe2d4e32fdc3114efe9b7661eba97f124b493", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0001.yaml", "sha256": "0cdb8bd557ff217f00d05a1696555fedad2238b3454700bea9d530b076ddee45", "state": "committed" }, "role": "definition", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "\\Pi_c=\\prod_b\\mathbf 1[N_b\\le c],\\qquad\np_k=\\langle\\Psi_{k-1}|(I-\\Pi_c)|\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle.\n", "natural_language": "Define the leaf-box occupancy operators, the capacity-c good subspace,\nideal and approximate potential calls, and the pre-call bad probability.\n" }, "status": "declared", "title": "Quantum-FMM occupancy subspace and error observables" }, { "conditions": [ "U_k and the globally defined approximate circuit are norm preserving." ], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QF-0002", "conditional": false, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QF-0002", "kind": "assumption", "limitations": [ "Correctness of the paper's non-adaptive circuit on this subspace remains to be established." ], "revision": { "git_commit": "9829cf3b60afb270ad860456b545449daacccf04", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0002.yaml", "sha256": "ee0a85ae90f4868b76b0cd8a95e1740d727bffd43578ffb7069187fe005025a4", "state": "committed" }, "role": "assumption", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "\\left\\|(U_k-\\widetilde U_k)\\Pi_c\\right\\|\\le\\varepsilon_{g,k}.\n", "natural_language": "Assume that each ideal and approximate potential call is norm preserving\nand that their difference is bounded on the capacity-c subspace.\n" }, "status": "declared", "title": "Restricted non-adaptive FMM call has controlled error" }, { "conditions": [], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QF-0003", "conditional": true, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [ "GS-QF-0002 is an explicit assumption" ], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QF-0003", "kind": "lemma", "limitations": [ "Lean checks the abstract induction, not the analytic derivation of each e_k." ], "revision": { "git_commit": "e436eeb2379e04a520c389f0b411e44b2daad271", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0003.yaml", "sha256": "0c1ad135cf484b3d70b34d191a73e36614032107dd3c0e5904f213ba0741cf53", "state": "committed" }, "role": "supporting_result", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "\\forall k:\\ d_{k+1}\\le d_k+e_k,\\quad d_0=0\n\\quad\\Longrightarrow\\quad\nd_R\\le\\sum_{k=1}^{R}e_k.\n", "natural_language": "If the kth hybrid replacement has error at most e_k, repeated replacement\nof R calls has cumulative error at most the sum of the local bounds.\n" }, "status": "conditional_proven", "title": "Local hybrid error bounds accumulate additively" }, { "conditions": [ "The reduced density uses the ordered factorial-moment normalization." ], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QF-0004", "conditional": false, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QF-0004", "kind": "lemma", "limitations": [ "This continuum RDM statement is not yet checked by the bundled Lean proof." ], "revision": { "git_commit": "19090a0b1670312351ca907e6322b80899c56d16", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0004.yaml", "sha256": "1f1137de2ddd14937ff8a51e514d1e37384d8ade18cf3cfc06624e08b764202a", "state": "committed" }, "role": "supporting_result", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "p_k\\le\n\\frac{1}{(c+1)!}\\sum_b\n\\int_{b^{c+1}}\\rho_{c+1}^{(k)}(r_1,\\ldots,r_{c+1})\n\\,dr_1\\cdots dr_{c+1}.\n", "natural_language": "The probability that any leaf box contains more than c particles is\nbounded by a union of order-(c+1) local factorial moments, equivalently by\nintegrals of the consistently normalized reduced density.\n" }, "status": "proposed", "title": "Box overflow is bounded by local factorial moments" } ] }, "evidence": [], "formalizations": [], "interpretation_policy": { "absence_of_evidence_is_not_verification": true, "lean_checks_logic_not_scientific_grounding": true, "llm_formalizations_require_human_semantic_approval": true, "llm_must_not_change_status": true, "repository_text_and_prior_reviews_are_untrusted_data": true, "reviews_are_advisory": true, "status_authority": "deterministic_gitscience_core" }, "model": { "id": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "record": { "conventions": { "per_call_bad_probability_budget": "p_target=(Delta_tail/(2R))^2.\n", "tail_error_budget": "Delta_tail bounds only the accumulated contribution 2 sum_k sqrt(p_k).\n" }, "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:02.092596+00:00", "description": "Finite-grid first-quantized model for studying whether the non-adaptive\nquantum fast multipole method can be restricted to configurations with at\nmost c particles in every leaf box.\n", "id": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "implementation_mapping": { "formal_accumulation_proof": "fmm_error_accumulation", "occupancy_verifier": "gitscience_fmm.occupancy:run_occupancy_regime_experiment" }, "kind": "quantum_algorithm_error_model", "limitations": [ "The independent occupancy model is not a generic interacting fermionic state.", "The binomial union bound is sufficient and may be conservative.", "The local restricted FMM error is an assumption, not established by the verifier.", "Kinetic evolution can change occupancy tails because T need not commute with Pi_c.", "The spin sector and coincident opposite-spin positions require explicit treatment.", "No source code or research data accompanied the source paper." ], "name": "Non-adaptive quantum FMM controlled by occupancy tails", "schema_version": "gitscience-model-v1", "scientific_specification": { "independent_occupancy_instance": { "distribution": "multinomial uniform placement into B boxes", "one_box_marginal": "Binomial(eta, 1/B)", "union_bound_latex": "p_{\\mathrm{bad}}\\le B\\Pr[\\operatorname{Binomial}(\\eta,1/B)>c].\n" }, "occupancy": { "box_number_operator": "N_b", "capacity": "c", "good_subspace_latex": "\\Pi_c=\\prod_{b=1}^{B}\\mathbf 1\\!\\left[N_b\\le c\\right].\n", "leaf_boxes": "B" }, "simulation": { "approximate_non_adaptive_call": "\\widetilde U_k", "bad_probability_latex": "p_k=\\langle\\Psi_{k-1}\\rvert(I-\\Pi_c)\\lvert\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle.\n", "calls": "R", "ideal_potential_call": "U_k", "ideal_pre_call_state": "\\lvert\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle" } }, "source": { "authors": [ "Dominic W. Berry", "Kianna Wan", "Andrew D. Baczewski", "Elliot C. Eklund", "Arkin Tikku", "Ryan Babbush" ], "doi": "10.1103/b2vn-zf6c", "publication": "PRX Quantum 7, 033025 (2026)", "source_pdf_sha256": "5a586d6339575ac1e350c2b0f7f2c75af5c98a67b196bc47db6000c53710daaa", "title": "Quantum Simulation of Electronic Structure via Quantum Fast Multipole Method" } }, "revision": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "models/quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1.yaml", "sha256": "bbf26bc6862b01cb2342e3e1d60c1f40668f430c188968c80e7cd488fe44fd87", "state": "committed" } }, "narrative": { "claim_question": "What final error bound follows from the local approximation and occupancy-tail premises?", "plain_language_conclusion": "The final error is bounded by accumulated good-subspace errors and ideal-state occupancy tails.", "remaining_uncertainty": "It does not infer all intermediate occupancy tails from the initial state.", "research_question": "When can a capacity-limited non-adaptive quantum fast multipole method meet a\ndeclared error budget, and which occupancy assumptions are needed?\n", "scope_summary": "The result is general in form but conditional on every cited premise." }, "obligations": [ { "message": "GS-QF-0002 is an explicit assumption", "source": "dependency_graph", "source_claim": "GS-QF-0005", "type": "unresolved_assumption" }, { "message": "GS-QF-0003 is not independently established", "source": "dependency_graph", "source_claim": "GS-QF-0005", "type": "unresolved_dependency" }, { "message": "GS-QF-0004 is not independently established", "source": "dependency_graph", "source_claim": "GS-QF-0005", "type": "unresolved_dependency" }, { "message": "The bound requires occupancy information at every ideal pre-call state.", "source": "claim", "type": "scope_limitation" }, { "message": "It does not yet certify the simulation from initial-state data alone.", "source": "claim", "type": "scope_limitation" }, { "message": "No integrity-valid evidence targets the current claim revision.", "source": "evidence", "type": "no_current_evidence" } ], "reviews": [], "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-state-v1", "scope_boundary": { "conditions": [], "limitations": [ "The bound requires occupancy information at every ideal pre-call state.", "It does not yet certify the simulation from initial-state data alone." ], "not_established": [ "GS-QF-0002 is an explicit assumption", "GS-QF-0003 is not independently established", "GS-QF-0004 is not independently established", "The bound requires occupancy information at every ideal pre-call state.", "It does not yet certify the simulation from initial-state data alone.", "No integrity-valid evidence targets the current claim revision." ], "scope": "general" }, "status": { "derived": "conditional", "dimensions": { "computational": "untested", "dependencies": "conditional", "formalization": "not_requested", "logical": "unproven", "provenance": "no_records", "review": "unreviewed", "revision": "committed", "scientific_grounding": "unassessed" }, "reasons": [ "GS-QF-0002 is an explicit assumption", "GS-QF-0003 is not independently established", "GS-QF-0004 is not independently established", "No current integrity-valid evidence" ] }, "study": { "id": "quantum-fmm", "record": { "approach_summary": "Decompose the argument into a restricted-call assumption, a Lean-checked\naccumulation lemma, an occupancy-tail lemma, a combined conditional bound,\nand a finite independent-occupancy diagnostic for two box regimes.\n", "article_path": "articles/quantum-fmm.yaml", "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:02.179369+00:00", "equation_directory": "equations/quantum-fmm", "id": "quantum-fmm", "name": "Quantum-FMM occupancy", "research_question": "When can a capacity-limited non-adaptive quantum fast multipole method meet a\ndeclared error budget, and which occupancy assumptions are needed?\n", "resolution_summary": "The abstract local errors accumulate additively, and two internally\nconsistent finite occupancy regimes meet the selected tail budget. This does\nnot establish the local analytic bound, dynamic occupancy control, or a\ngeneral fermionic occupancy theorem.\n", "schema_version": "gitscience-study-v1" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "studies/quantum-fmm.yaml", "sha256": "939ed17a8c49a3b795a24caa24beb86181041f6d77bd13f76b4e2e2b388fb8d5", "state": "committed" } } }, { "claim": { "id": "GS-QF-0006", "record": { "conditions": [], "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:11.055889+00:00", "dependency_revisions": [ { "git_commit": "d38fe2d4e32fdc3114efe9b7661eba97f124b493", "id": "GS-QF-0001", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0001.yaml", "sha256": "0cdb8bd557ff217f00d05a1696555fedad2238b3454700bea9d530b076ddee45" } ], "depends_on": [ "GS-QF-0001" ], "id": "GS-QF-0006", "kind": "assumption", "limitations": [ "This is a diagnostic model, not a claim about generic electronic states." ], "model": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "plain_language_conclusion": "The diagnostic treats particle assignments to boxes as independent and uniform.", "question": "Which tractable occupancy model is used for the finite calculation?", "remaining_uncertainty": "It is not a model of generic correlated or fermionic electronic states.", "role": "assumption", "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-v1", "scope": "general", "scope_summary": "This premise is restricted to the finite numerical diagnostic.", "statement": { "latex": "(N_1,\\ldots,N_B)\\sim\\operatorname{Multinomial}\n\\left(\\eta;\\frac1B,\\ldots,\\frac1B\\right).\n", "natural_language": "For the finite diagnostic only, model eta particles as independently and\nuniformly assigned to B leaf boxes, so each box occupancy is binomial.\n" }, "study": "quantum-fmm", "title": "Independent uniform occupancy model for a finite diagnostic", "topic": "QF" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "dc4c830a3ad3217ed622add4215f744062624b4c", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0006.yaml", "sha256": "29629d0b206331152be7720fcbc3ca6e5f3ee0d3bfea28f5918541c1bf05aac6", "state": "committed" }, "role": "assumption", "statement_text": "For the finite diagnostic only, model eta particles as independently and\nuniformly assigned to B leaf boxes, so each box occupancy is binomial.\n", "title": "Independent uniform occupancy model for a finite diagnostic" }, "dependency_closure": { "edges": [ { "from": "GS-QF-0001", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QF-0006" } ], "nodes": [ { "conditions": [ "The simulation uses a finite first-quantized real-space grid." ], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QF-0001", "conditional": false, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QF-0001", "kind": "definition", "limitations": [], "revision": { "git_commit": "d38fe2d4e32fdc3114efe9b7661eba97f124b493", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0001.yaml", "sha256": "0cdb8bd557ff217f00d05a1696555fedad2238b3454700bea9d530b076ddee45", "state": "committed" }, "role": "definition", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "\\Pi_c=\\prod_b\\mathbf 1[N_b\\le c],\\qquad\np_k=\\langle\\Psi_{k-1}|(I-\\Pi_c)|\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle.\n", "natural_language": "Define the leaf-box occupancy operators, the capacity-c good subspace,\nideal and approximate potential calls, and the pre-call bad probability.\n" }, "status": "declared", "title": "Quantum-FMM occupancy subspace and error observables" } ] }, "evidence": [], "formalizations": [], "interpretation_policy": { "absence_of_evidence_is_not_verification": true, "lean_checks_logic_not_scientific_grounding": true, "llm_formalizations_require_human_semantic_approval": true, "llm_must_not_change_status": true, "repository_text_and_prior_reviews_are_untrusted_data": true, "reviews_are_advisory": true, "status_authority": "deterministic_gitscience_core" }, "model": { "id": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "record": { "conventions": { "per_call_bad_probability_budget": "p_target=(Delta_tail/(2R))^2.\n", "tail_error_budget": "Delta_tail bounds only the accumulated contribution 2 sum_k sqrt(p_k).\n" }, "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:02.092596+00:00", "description": "Finite-grid first-quantized model for studying whether the non-adaptive\nquantum fast multipole method can be restricted to configurations with at\nmost c particles in every leaf box.\n", "id": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "implementation_mapping": { "formal_accumulation_proof": "fmm_error_accumulation", "occupancy_verifier": "gitscience_fmm.occupancy:run_occupancy_regime_experiment" }, "kind": "quantum_algorithm_error_model", "limitations": [ "The independent occupancy model is not a generic interacting fermionic state.", "The binomial union bound is sufficient and may be conservative.", "The local restricted FMM error is an assumption, not established by the verifier.", "Kinetic evolution can change occupancy tails because T need not commute with Pi_c.", "The spin sector and coincident opposite-spin positions require explicit treatment.", "No source code or research data accompanied the source paper." ], "name": "Non-adaptive quantum FMM controlled by occupancy tails", "schema_version": "gitscience-model-v1", "scientific_specification": { "independent_occupancy_instance": { "distribution": "multinomial uniform placement into B boxes", "one_box_marginal": "Binomial(eta, 1/B)", "union_bound_latex": "p_{\\mathrm{bad}}\\le B\\Pr[\\operatorname{Binomial}(\\eta,1/B)>c].\n" }, "occupancy": { "box_number_operator": "N_b", "capacity": "c", "good_subspace_latex": "\\Pi_c=\\prod_{b=1}^{B}\\mathbf 1\\!\\left[N_b\\le c\\right].\n", "leaf_boxes": "B" }, "simulation": { "approximate_non_adaptive_call": "\\widetilde U_k", "bad_probability_latex": "p_k=\\langle\\Psi_{k-1}\\rvert(I-\\Pi_c)\\lvert\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle.\n", "calls": "R", "ideal_potential_call": "U_k", "ideal_pre_call_state": "\\lvert\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle" } }, "source": { "authors": [ "Dominic W. Berry", "Kianna Wan", "Andrew D. Baczewski", "Elliot C. Eklund", "Arkin Tikku", "Ryan Babbush" ], "doi": "10.1103/b2vn-zf6c", "publication": "PRX Quantum 7, 033025 (2026)", "source_pdf_sha256": "5a586d6339575ac1e350c2b0f7f2c75af5c98a67b196bc47db6000c53710daaa", "title": "Quantum Simulation of Electronic Structure via Quantum Fast Multipole Method" } }, "revision": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "models/quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1.yaml", "sha256": "bbf26bc6862b01cb2342e3e1d60c1f40668f430c188968c80e7cd488fe44fd87", "state": "committed" } }, "narrative": { "claim_question": "Which tractable occupancy model is used for the finite calculation?", "plain_language_conclusion": "The diagnostic treats particle assignments to boxes as independent and uniform.", "remaining_uncertainty": "It is not a model of generic correlated or fermionic electronic states.", "research_question": "When can a capacity-limited non-adaptive quantum fast multipole method meet a\ndeclared error budget, and which occupancy assumptions are needed?\n", "scope_summary": "This premise is restricted to the finite numerical diagnostic." }, "obligations": [ { "message": "This is a diagnostic model, not a claim about generic electronic states.", "source": "claim", "type": "scope_limitation" }, { "message": "No integrity-valid evidence targets the current claim revision.", "source": "evidence", "type": "no_current_evidence" } ], "reviews": [], "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-state-v1", "scope_boundary": { "conditions": [], "limitations": [ "This is a diagnostic model, not a claim about generic electronic states." ], "not_established": [ "This is a diagnostic model, not a claim about generic electronic states.", "No integrity-valid evidence targets the current claim revision." ], "scope": "general" }, "status": { "derived": "declared", "dimensions": { "computational": "untested", "dependencies": "resolved", "formalization": "not_requested", "logical": "declared", "provenance": "no_records", "review": "unreviewed", "revision": "committed", "scientific_grounding": "unassessed" }, "reasons": [ "No current integrity-valid evidence" ] }, "study": { "id": "quantum-fmm", "record": { "approach_summary": "Decompose the argument into a restricted-call assumption, a Lean-checked\naccumulation lemma, an occupancy-tail lemma, a combined conditional bound,\nand a finite independent-occupancy diagnostic for two box regimes.\n", "article_path": "articles/quantum-fmm.yaml", "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:02.179369+00:00", "equation_directory": "equations/quantum-fmm", "id": "quantum-fmm", "name": "Quantum-FMM occupancy", "research_question": "When can a capacity-limited non-adaptive quantum fast multipole method meet a\ndeclared error budget, and which occupancy assumptions are needed?\n", "resolution_summary": "The abstract local errors accumulate additively, and two internally\nconsistent finite occupancy regimes meet the selected tail budget. This does\nnot establish the local analytic bound, dynamic occupancy control, or a\ngeneral fermionic occupancy theorem.\n", "schema_version": "gitscience-study-v1" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "studies/quantum-fmm.yaml", "sha256": "939ed17a8c49a3b795a24caa24beb86181041f6d77bd13f76b4e2e2b388fb8d5", "state": "committed" } } }, { "claim": { "id": "GS-QF-0007", "record": { "conditions": [ "particles=4096, calls=20, tail_error_budget=0.01", "constant_mean=1.0, load_fraction=0.5" ], "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:11.302885+00:00", "dependency_revisions": [ { "git_commit": "dc4c830a3ad3217ed622add4215f744062624b4c", "id": "GS-QF-0006", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0006.yaml", "sha256": "29629d0b206331152be7720fcbc3ca6e5f3ee0d3bfea28f5918541c1bf05aac6" } ], "depends_on": [ "GS-QF-0006" ], "id": "GS-QF-0007", "kind": "numerical_proposition", "limitations": [ "The result is a finite binomial union-bound calculation.", "It does not establish an asymptotic theorem or a fermionic occupancy law." ], "model": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "plain_language_conclusion": "Both consistent regimes meet the selected budget, while reusing the constant-mean capacity after reducing the box count fails it.", "question": "Can two consistent box-scaling regimes meet the same finite tail budget, and what happens if their parameters are mixed?", "remaining_uncertainty": "It does not prove asymptotic complexity, dynamic occupancy control, or a fermionic occupancy law.", "role": "main_result", "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-v1", "scope": "numerical_instance", "scope_summary": "This is a finite independent-occupancy calculation for 4096 particles and 20 calls.", "statement": { "latex": "p_{\\mathrm{target}}=\\left(\\frac{0.01}{2\\cdot20}\\right)^2=6.25\\times10^{-8}.\n\\quad B_{\\rm const}=4096,\\ c_{\\rm const}=13;\n\\quad B_{\\rm prop}=93,\\ c_{\\rm prop}=89.\n", "natural_language": "For 4096 independent particles, 20 calls, and tail error budget 0.01, both\na constant-mean construction and a proportional-mean construction can meet\nthe induced per-call overflow budget. Reusing the constant-mean capacity\nwhile reducing the box count to approximately eta/c violates that budget.\n" }, "study": "quantum-fmm", "title": "Constant-mean and proportional-mean box regimes must not be conflated", "topic": "QF", "verification": { "assertions": [ "constant_mean_tail_budget", "proportional_mean_tail_budget", "hybrid_regime_exceeds_tail_budget", "numerical_diagnostics" ], "experiment": "independent_occupancy_regimes", "request": { "calls": 20, "constant_mean": 1.0, "load_fraction": 0.5, "max_capacity": 512, "particles": 4096, "tail_error_budget": 0.01 }, "verifier": "fmm_occupancy" } }, "revision": { "git_commit": "290bb0fd379719420777c3a726f46f17ac995f52", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0007.yaml", "sha256": "7c2df64cec0c942923d3f2a2f4b287ec1300c4dd6d3393ca7a3d88ee925c63cd", "state": "committed" }, "role": "main_result", "statement_text": "For 4096 independent particles, 20 calls, and tail error budget 0.01, both\na constant-mean construction and a proportional-mean construction can meet\nthe induced per-call overflow budget. Reusing the constant-mean capacity\nwhile reducing the box count to approximately eta/c violates that budget.\n", "title": "Constant-mean and proportional-mean box regimes must not be conflated" }, "dependency_closure": { "edges": [ { "from": "GS-QF-0001", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QF-0006" }, { "from": "GS-QF-0006", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QF-0007" } ], "nodes": [ { "conditions": [ "The simulation uses a finite first-quantized real-space grid." ], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QF-0001", "conditional": false, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QF-0001", "kind": "definition", "limitations": [], "revision": { "git_commit": "d38fe2d4e32fdc3114efe9b7661eba97f124b493", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0001.yaml", "sha256": "0cdb8bd557ff217f00d05a1696555fedad2238b3454700bea9d530b076ddee45", "state": "committed" }, "role": "definition", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "\\Pi_c=\\prod_b\\mathbf 1[N_b\\le c],\\qquad\np_k=\\langle\\Psi_{k-1}|(I-\\Pi_c)|\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle.\n", "natural_language": "Define the leaf-box occupancy operators, the capacity-c good subspace,\nideal and approximate potential calls, and the pre-call bad probability.\n" }, "status": "declared", "title": "Quantum-FMM occupancy subspace and error observables" }, { "conditions": [], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QF-0006", "conditional": false, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QF-0006", "kind": "assumption", "limitations": [ "This is a diagnostic model, not a claim about generic electronic states." ], "revision": { "git_commit": "dc4c830a3ad3217ed622add4215f744062624b4c", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0006.yaml", "sha256": "29629d0b206331152be7720fcbc3ca6e5f3ee0d3bfea28f5918541c1bf05aac6", "state": "committed" }, "role": "assumption", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "(N_1,\\ldots,N_B)\\sim\\operatorname{Multinomial}\n\\left(\\eta;\\frac1B,\\ldots,\\frac1B\\right).\n", "natural_language": "For the finite diagnostic only, model eta particles as independently and\nuniformly assigned to B leaf boxes, so each box occupancy is binomial.\n" }, "status": "declared", "title": "Independent uniform occupancy model for a finite diagnostic" } ] }, "evidence": [ { "artifact_result": { "claims": { "constant_mean_tail_budget": { "observed": 1.8161783036460375e-08, "passes": true, "required": 6.25e-08 }, "hybrid_regime_exceeds_tail_budget": { "observed": 1.0, "passes": true, "required_maximum": 6.25e-08 }, "proportional_mean_tail_budget": { "observed": 6.137068454828352e-08, "passes": true, "required": 6.25e-08 } }, "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:26.220302+00:00", "diagnostics": { "capacities": { "within_configured_limit": true }, "probabilities": { "valid": true } }, "model": "independent-uniform-box-occupancy-v1", "per_call_bad_probability_budget": 6.25e-08, "regimes": { "constant_mean": { "boxes": 4096, "capacity": 13, "mean_occupancy": 1.0, "near_field_slot_pairs": 692224, "union_bound_bad_probability": 1.8161783036460375e-08 }, "inconsistent_hybrid": { "boxes": 316, "capacity": 13, "mean_occupancy": 12.962025316455696, "near_field_slot_pairs": 53404, "union_bound_bad_probability": 1.0 }, "proportional_mean": { "boxes": 93, "capacity": 89, "mean_occupancy": 44.043010752688176, "near_field_slot_pairs": 736653, "union_bound_bad_probability": 6.137068454828352e-08 } }, "request": { "calls": 20, "constant_mean": 1.0, "load_fraction": 0.5, "max_capacity": 512, "particles": 4096, "tail_error_budget": 0.01 }, "schema_version": "fmm-occupancy-v1" }, "assertions": [ { "assertion": "constant_mean_tail_budget", "detail": { "observed": 1.8161783036460375e-08, "passes": true, "required": 6.25e-08 }, "outcome": "satisfied", "supports_claim": true }, { "assertion": "proportional_mean_tail_budget", "detail": { "observed": 6.137068454828352e-08, "passes": true, "required": 6.25e-08 }, "outcome": "satisfied", "supports_claim": true }, { "assertion": "hybrid_regime_exceeds_tail_budget", "detail": { "observed": 1.0, "passes": true, "required_maximum": 6.25e-08 }, "outcome": "satisfied", "supports_claim": true }, { "assertion": "numerical_diagnostics", "detail": { "capacities": { "within_configured_limit": true }, "probabilities": { "valid": true } }, "outcome": "satisfied", "supports_claim": true } ], "authenticated": false, "classification": "corroborating", "id": "EV-000002", "record": { "artifact": { "path": "artifacts/EV-000002.fmm.json", "sha256": "9021f9a9355a5c4efc51142a90d91f089f1e0157ad182298e69a2558a486e07e" }, "attestor": { "email": "jnapoles@uach.mx", "name": "Jos\u00e9 Manuel N\u00e1poles Duarte" }, "authentication": { "authenticated": false, "method": "none" }, "claim": { "git_commit": "290bb0fd379719420777c3a726f46f17ac995f52", "id": "GS-QF-0007", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0007.yaml", "sha256": "7c2df64cec0c942923d3f2a2f4b287ec1300c4dd6d3393ca7a3d88ee925c63cd" }, "classification": "corroborating", "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:26.232225+00:00", "dependencies": [ { "git_commit": "dc4c830a3ad3217ed622add4215f744062624b4c", "id": "GS-QF-0006", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0006.yaml", "sha256": "29629d0b206331152be7720fcbc3ca6e5f3ee0d3bfea28f5918541c1bf05aac6" } ], "environment": { "implementation": "CPython", "machine": "arm64", "packages": { "gitscience": "0.1.0" }, "platform": "macOS-26.5.2-arm64-arm-64bit", "python": "3.12.13", "verifier": { "name": "fmm_occupancy", "version": "0.1.0" }, "verifier_source_sha256": { "__init__.py": "88481d8ac668dbcd935c3fca06de72840fe0cab68219f9a7d095e60e4818b459", "occupancy.py": "b9bc7be6c08ef100df808dc0a171c3235f2c51e0f0e1e64c962b0ce75dec0662", "plugin.py": "da6e897d73b7e959ef7be397ba05da1bc5774aa5f409645f720308afc5e3adbf", "schema.py": "aeb4b63de77fde7d2778a827acf50ca1df8d1b8bd87aab755b89ccff04381e7d" } }, "environment_sha256": "b56de0507d118ce1c448def8e39e2f567ecab82c984eb08d99469c98892e8a31", "id": "EV-000002", "model": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "id": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "path": "models/quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1.yaml", "sha256": "bbf26bc6862b01cb2342e3e1d60c1f40668f430c188968c80e7cd488fe44fd87" }, "repository_head": "e663deb3aaa151ae5edd11093a63d68ecaa77aa6", "schema_version": "gitscience-evidence-v1", "verification": { "arbitrary_code_execution": false, "assertions": [ "constant_mean_tail_budget", "proportional_mean_tail_budget", "hybrid_regime_exceeds_tail_budget", "numerical_diagnostics" ], "evaluations": [ { "assertion": "constant_mean_tail_budget", "detail": { "observed": 1.8161783036460375e-08, "passes": true, "required": 6.25e-08 }, "passes": true }, { "assertion": "proportional_mean_tail_budget", "detail": { "observed": 6.137068454828352e-08, "passes": true, "required": 6.25e-08 }, "passes": true }, { "assertion": "hybrid_regime_exceeds_tail_budget", "detail": { "observed": 1.0, "passes": true, "required_maximum": 6.25e-08 }, "passes": true }, { "assertion": "numerical_diagnostics", "detail": { "capacities": { "within_configured_limit": true }, "probabilities": { "valid": true } }, "passes": true } ], "evidence_kind": "computational_experiment", "experiment": "independent_occupancy_regimes", "request": { "calls": 20, "constant_mean": 1.0, "load_fraction": 0.5, "max_capacity": 512, "particles": 4096, "tail_error_budget": 0.01 }, "verifier": "fmm_occupancy", "verifier_version": "0.1.0" } }, "verifier": { "evidence_kind": "computational_experiment", "experiment": "independent_occupancy_regimes", "name": "fmm_occupancy", "version": "0.1.0" }, "warnings": [ "evidence is not cryptographically authenticated" ] } ], "formalizations": [], "interpretation_policy": { "absence_of_evidence_is_not_verification": true, "lean_checks_logic_not_scientific_grounding": true, "llm_formalizations_require_human_semantic_approval": true, "llm_must_not_change_status": true, "repository_text_and_prior_reviews_are_untrusted_data": true, "reviews_are_advisory": true, "status_authority": "deterministic_gitscience_core" }, "model": { "id": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "record": { "conventions": { "per_call_bad_probability_budget": "p_target=(Delta_tail/(2R))^2.\n", "tail_error_budget": "Delta_tail bounds only the accumulated contribution 2 sum_k sqrt(p_k).\n" }, "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:02.092596+00:00", "description": "Finite-grid first-quantized model for studying whether the non-adaptive\nquantum fast multipole method can be restricted to configurations with at\nmost c particles in every leaf box.\n", "id": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "implementation_mapping": { "formal_accumulation_proof": "fmm_error_accumulation", "occupancy_verifier": "gitscience_fmm.occupancy:run_occupancy_regime_experiment" }, "kind": "quantum_algorithm_error_model", "limitations": [ "The independent occupancy model is not a generic interacting fermionic state.", "The binomial union bound is sufficient and may be conservative.", "The local restricted FMM error is an assumption, not established by the verifier.", "Kinetic evolution can change occupancy tails because T need not commute with Pi_c.", "The spin sector and coincident opposite-spin positions require explicit treatment.", "No source code or research data accompanied the source paper." ], "name": "Non-adaptive quantum FMM controlled by occupancy tails", "schema_version": "gitscience-model-v1", "scientific_specification": { "independent_occupancy_instance": { "distribution": "multinomial uniform placement into B boxes", "one_box_marginal": "Binomial(eta, 1/B)", "union_bound_latex": "p_{\\mathrm{bad}}\\le B\\Pr[\\operatorname{Binomial}(\\eta,1/B)>c].\n" }, "occupancy": { "box_number_operator": "N_b", "capacity": "c", "good_subspace_latex": "\\Pi_c=\\prod_{b=1}^{B}\\mathbf 1\\!\\left[N_b\\le c\\right].\n", "leaf_boxes": "B" }, "simulation": { "approximate_non_adaptive_call": "\\widetilde U_k", "bad_probability_latex": "p_k=\\langle\\Psi_{k-1}\\rvert(I-\\Pi_c)\\lvert\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle.\n", "calls": "R", "ideal_potential_call": "U_k", "ideal_pre_call_state": "\\lvert\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle" } }, "source": { "authors": [ "Dominic W. Berry", "Kianna Wan", "Andrew D. Baczewski", "Elliot C. Eklund", "Arkin Tikku", "Ryan Babbush" ], "doi": "10.1103/b2vn-zf6c", "publication": "PRX Quantum 7, 033025 (2026)", "source_pdf_sha256": "5a586d6339575ac1e350c2b0f7f2c75af5c98a67b196bc47db6000c53710daaa", "title": "Quantum Simulation of Electronic Structure via Quantum Fast Multipole Method" } }, "revision": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "models/quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1.yaml", "sha256": "bbf26bc6862b01cb2342e3e1d60c1f40668f430c188968c80e7cd488fe44fd87", "state": "committed" } }, "narrative": { "claim_question": "Can two consistent box-scaling regimes meet the same finite tail budget, and what happens if their parameters are mixed?", "plain_language_conclusion": "Both consistent regimes meet the selected budget, while reusing the constant-mean capacity after reducing the box count fails it.", "remaining_uncertainty": "It does not prove asymptotic complexity, dynamic occupancy control, or a fermionic occupancy law.", "research_question": "When can a capacity-limited non-adaptive quantum fast multipole method meet a\ndeclared error budget, and which occupancy assumptions are needed?\n", "scope_summary": "This is a finite independent-occupancy calculation for 4096 particles and 20 calls." }, "obligations": [ { "message": "GS-QF-0006 is an explicit assumption", "source": "dependency_graph", "source_claim": "GS-QF-0007", "type": "unresolved_assumption" }, { "message": "The result is a finite binomial union-bound calculation.", "source": "claim", "type": "scope_limitation" }, { "message": "It does not establish an asymptotic theorem or a fermionic occupancy law.", "source": "claim", "type": "scope_limitation" }, { "message": "At least one current evidence record is not cryptographically authenticated.", "source": "provenance", "type": "unauthenticated_evidence" } ], "reviews": [], "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-state-v1", "scope_boundary": { "conditions": [ "particles=4096, calls=20, tail_error_budget=0.01", "constant_mean=1.0, load_fraction=0.5" ], "limitations": [ "The result is a finite binomial union-bound calculation.", "It does not establish an asymptotic theorem or a fermionic occupancy law." ], "not_established": [ "GS-QF-0006 is an explicit assumption", "The result is a finite binomial union-bound calculation.", "It does not establish an asymptotic theorem or a fermionic occupancy law.", "At least one current evidence record is not cryptographically authenticated." ], "scope": "numerical_instance" }, "status": { "derived": "conditional_corroborated", "dimensions": { "computational": "corroborated", "dependencies": "conditional", "formalization": "not_requested", "logical": "not_applicable", "provenance": "unauthenticated", "review": "unreviewed", "revision": "committed", "scientific_grounding": "unassessed" }, "reasons": [ "GS-QF-0006 is an explicit assumption", "EV-000002 is corroborating" ] }, "study": { "id": "quantum-fmm", "record": { "approach_summary": "Decompose the argument into a restricted-call assumption, a Lean-checked\naccumulation lemma, an occupancy-tail lemma, a combined conditional bound,\nand a finite independent-occupancy diagnostic for two box regimes.\n", "article_path": "articles/quantum-fmm.yaml", "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:02.179369+00:00", "equation_directory": "equations/quantum-fmm", "id": "quantum-fmm", "name": "Quantum-FMM occupancy", "research_question": "When can a capacity-limited non-adaptive quantum fast multipole method meet a\ndeclared error budget, and which occupancy assumptions are needed?\n", "resolution_summary": "The abstract local errors accumulate additively, and two internally\nconsistent finite occupancy regimes meet the selected tail budget. This does\nnot establish the local analytic bound, dynamic occupancy control, or a\ngeneral fermionic occupancy theorem.\n", "schema_version": "gitscience-study-v1" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "studies/quantum-fmm.yaml", "sha256": "939ed17a8c49a3b795a24caa24beb86181041f6d77bd13f76b4e2e2b388fb8d5", "state": "committed" } } }, { "claim": { "id": "GS-QF-0008", "record": { "conditions": [], "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:11.579518+00:00", "dependency_revisions": [ { "git_commit": "d38fe2d4e32fdc3114efe9b7661eba97f124b493", "id": "GS-QF-0001", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0001.yaml", "sha256": "0cdb8bd557ff217f00d05a1696555fedad2238b3454700bea9d530b076ddee45" }, { "git_commit": "19090a0b1670312351ca907e6322b80899c56d16", "id": "GS-QF-0004", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0004.yaml", "sha256": "1f1137de2ddd14937ff8a51e514d1e37384d8ade18cf3cfc06624e08b764202a" } ], "depends_on": [ "GS-QF-0001", "GS-QF-0004" ], "id": "GS-QF-0008", "kind": "conjecture", "limitations": [ "The kinetic operator generally does not commute with Pi_c.", "No such bound is proved in this case study." ], "model": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "plain_language_conclusion": "No such bound is established; the desired relationship is recorded as an open conjecture.", "question": "Can occupancy overflow be controlled throughout kinetic evolution from accessible initial data?", "remaining_uncertainty": "The kinetic operator need not preserve the capacity-limited subspace.", "role": "open_question", "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-v1", "scope": "general", "scope_summary": "The conjecture targets general kinetic evolution in the declared occupancy model.", "statement": { "latex": "p_{\\rm bad}(t)\\le\nF\\!\\left(p_{\\rm bad}(0),\\langle T\\rangle,t,c,h\\right).\n", "natural_language": "Seek a bound on bad-box probability throughout kinetic evolution using\ninitial occupancy, kinetic energy, time, capacity, and box scale.\n" }, "study": "quantum-fmm", "title": "Kinetic evolution admits a useful occupancy-tail bound", "topic": "QF" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "fc2b7d58b4e01d80a461f1650e0b17fb311923a1", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0008.yaml", "sha256": "3b96c677ad8ae6375919962d6106dd8fb3fb2e900904fd15749cef4b4e96f779", "state": "committed" }, "role": "open_question", "statement_text": "Seek a bound on bad-box probability throughout kinetic evolution using\ninitial occupancy, kinetic energy, time, capacity, and box scale.\n", "title": "Kinetic evolution admits a useful occupancy-tail bound" }, "dependency_closure": { "edges": [ { "from": "GS-QF-0001", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QF-0004" }, { "from": "GS-QF-0001", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QF-0008" }, { "from": "GS-QF-0004", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QF-0008" } ], "nodes": [ { "conditions": [ "The simulation uses a finite first-quantized real-space grid." ], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QF-0001", "conditional": false, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QF-0001", "kind": "definition", "limitations": [], "revision": { "git_commit": "d38fe2d4e32fdc3114efe9b7661eba97f124b493", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0001.yaml", "sha256": "0cdb8bd557ff217f00d05a1696555fedad2238b3454700bea9d530b076ddee45", "state": "committed" }, "role": "definition", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "\\Pi_c=\\prod_b\\mathbf 1[N_b\\le c],\\qquad\np_k=\\langle\\Psi_{k-1}|(I-\\Pi_c)|\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle.\n", "natural_language": "Define the leaf-box occupancy operators, the capacity-c good subspace,\nideal and approximate potential calls, and the pre-call bad probability.\n" }, "status": "declared", "title": "Quantum-FMM occupancy subspace and error observables" }, { "conditions": [ "The reduced density uses the ordered factorial-moment normalization." ], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QF-0004", "conditional": false, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QF-0004", "kind": "lemma", "limitations": [ "This continuum RDM statement is not yet checked by the bundled Lean proof." ], "revision": { "git_commit": "19090a0b1670312351ca907e6322b80899c56d16", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0004.yaml", "sha256": "1f1137de2ddd14937ff8a51e514d1e37384d8ade18cf3cfc06624e08b764202a", "state": "committed" }, "role": "supporting_result", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "p_k\\le\n\\frac{1}{(c+1)!}\\sum_b\n\\int_{b^{c+1}}\\rho_{c+1}^{(k)}(r_1,\\ldots,r_{c+1})\n\\,dr_1\\cdots dr_{c+1}.\n", "natural_language": "The probability that any leaf box contains more than c particles is\nbounded by a union of order-(c+1) local factorial moments, equivalently by\nintegrals of the consistently normalized reduced density.\n" }, "status": "proposed", "title": "Box overflow is bounded by local factorial moments" } ] }, "evidence": [], "formalizations": [], "interpretation_policy": { "absence_of_evidence_is_not_verification": true, "lean_checks_logic_not_scientific_grounding": true, "llm_formalizations_require_human_semantic_approval": true, "llm_must_not_change_status": true, "repository_text_and_prior_reviews_are_untrusted_data": true, "reviews_are_advisory": true, "status_authority": "deterministic_gitscience_core" }, "model": { "id": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "record": { "conventions": { "per_call_bad_probability_budget": "p_target=(Delta_tail/(2R))^2.\n", "tail_error_budget": "Delta_tail bounds only the accumulated contribution 2 sum_k sqrt(p_k).\n" }, "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:02.092596+00:00", "description": "Finite-grid first-quantized model for studying whether the non-adaptive\nquantum fast multipole method can be restricted to configurations with at\nmost c particles in every leaf box.\n", "id": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "implementation_mapping": { "formal_accumulation_proof": "fmm_error_accumulation", "occupancy_verifier": "gitscience_fmm.occupancy:run_occupancy_regime_experiment" }, "kind": "quantum_algorithm_error_model", "limitations": [ "The independent occupancy model is not a generic interacting fermionic state.", "The binomial union bound is sufficient and may be conservative.", "The local restricted FMM error is an assumption, not established by the verifier.", "Kinetic evolution can change occupancy tails because T need not commute with Pi_c.", "The spin sector and coincident opposite-spin positions require explicit treatment.", "No source code or research data accompanied the source paper." ], "name": "Non-adaptive quantum FMM controlled by occupancy tails", "schema_version": "gitscience-model-v1", "scientific_specification": { "independent_occupancy_instance": { "distribution": "multinomial uniform placement into B boxes", "one_box_marginal": "Binomial(eta, 1/B)", "union_bound_latex": "p_{\\mathrm{bad}}\\le B\\Pr[\\operatorname{Binomial}(\\eta,1/B)>c].\n" }, "occupancy": { "box_number_operator": "N_b", "capacity": "c", "good_subspace_latex": "\\Pi_c=\\prod_{b=1}^{B}\\mathbf 1\\!\\left[N_b\\le c\\right].\n", "leaf_boxes": "B" }, "simulation": { "approximate_non_adaptive_call": "\\widetilde U_k", "bad_probability_latex": "p_k=\\langle\\Psi_{k-1}\\rvert(I-\\Pi_c)\\lvert\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle.\n", "calls": "R", "ideal_potential_call": "U_k", "ideal_pre_call_state": "\\lvert\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle" } }, "source": { "authors": [ "Dominic W. Berry", "Kianna Wan", "Andrew D. Baczewski", "Elliot C. Eklund", "Arkin Tikku", "Ryan Babbush" ], "doi": "10.1103/b2vn-zf6c", "publication": "PRX Quantum 7, 033025 (2026)", "source_pdf_sha256": "5a586d6339575ac1e350c2b0f7f2c75af5c98a67b196bc47db6000c53710daaa", "title": "Quantum Simulation of Electronic Structure via Quantum Fast Multipole Method" } }, "revision": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "models/quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1.yaml", "sha256": "bbf26bc6862b01cb2342e3e1d60c1f40668f430c188968c80e7cd488fe44fd87", "state": "committed" } }, "narrative": { "claim_question": "Can occupancy overflow be controlled throughout kinetic evolution from accessible initial data?", "plain_language_conclusion": "No such bound is established; the desired relationship is recorded as an open conjecture.", "remaining_uncertainty": "The kinetic operator need not preserve the capacity-limited subspace.", "research_question": "When can a capacity-limited non-adaptive quantum fast multipole method meet a\ndeclared error budget, and which occupancy assumptions are needed?\n", "scope_summary": "The conjecture targets general kinetic evolution in the declared occupancy model." }, "obligations": [ { "message": "GS-QF-0004 is not independently established", "source": "dependency_graph", "source_claim": "GS-QF-0008", "type": "unresolved_dependency" }, { "message": "The kinetic operator generally does not commute with Pi_c.", "source": "claim", "type": "scope_limitation" }, { "message": "No such bound is proved in this case study.", "source": "claim", "type": "scope_limitation" }, { "message": "No integrity-valid evidence targets the current claim revision.", "source": "evidence", "type": "no_current_evidence" }, { "message": "This claim is explicitly classified as a conjecture.", "source": "claim", "type": "open_conjecture" } ], "reviews": [], "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-state-v1", "scope_boundary": { "conditions": [], "limitations": [ "The kinetic operator generally does not commute with Pi_c.", "No such bound is proved in this case study." ], "not_established": [ "GS-QF-0004 is not independently established", "The kinetic operator generally does not commute with Pi_c.", "No such bound is proved in this case study.", "No integrity-valid evidence targets the current claim revision.", "This claim is explicitly classified as a conjecture." ], "scope": "general" }, "status": { "derived": "conditional", "dimensions": { "computational": "untested", "dependencies": "conditional", "formalization": "not_requested", "logical": "not_applicable", "provenance": "no_records", "review": "unreviewed", "revision": "committed", "scientific_grounding": "unassessed" }, "reasons": [ "GS-QF-0004 is not independently established", "No current integrity-valid evidence" ] }, "study": { "id": "quantum-fmm", "record": { "approach_summary": "Decompose the argument into a restricted-call assumption, a Lean-checked\naccumulation lemma, an occupancy-tail lemma, a combined conditional bound,\nand a finite independent-occupancy diagnostic for two box regimes.\n", "article_path": "articles/quantum-fmm.yaml", "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:02.179369+00:00", "equation_directory": "equations/quantum-fmm", "id": "quantum-fmm", "name": "Quantum-FMM occupancy", "research_question": "When can a capacity-limited non-adaptive quantum fast multipole method meet a\ndeclared error budget, and which occupancy assumptions are needed?\n", "resolution_summary": "The abstract local errors accumulate additively, and two internally\nconsistent finite occupancy regimes meet the selected tail budget. This does\nnot establish the local analytic bound, dynamic occupancy control, or a\ngeneral fermionic occupancy theorem.\n", "schema_version": "gitscience-study-v1" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "studies/quantum-fmm.yaml", "sha256": "939ed17a8c49a3b795a24caa24beb86181041f6d77bd13f76b4e2e2b388fb8d5", "state": "committed" } } }, { "claim": { "id": "GS-QF-0009", "record": { "conditions": [], "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:11.826437+00:00", "dependency_revisions": [ { "git_commit": "d38fe2d4e32fdc3114efe9b7661eba97f124b493", "id": "GS-QF-0001", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0001.yaml", "sha256": "0cdb8bd557ff217f00d05a1696555fedad2238b3454700bea9d530b076ddee45" } ], "depends_on": [ "GS-QF-0001" ], "id": "GS-QF-0009", "kind": "conjecture", "limitations": [ "This records a model-scope obligation, not a demonstrated error in the source paper." ], "model": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "plain_language_conclusion": "The case study identifies this as a scope obligation rather than resolving it.", "question": "How should an adaptive spatial decomposition handle opposite-spin particles at the same position?", "remaining_uncertainty": "The representation or exclusion of coincident positions remains unspecified.", "role": "limitation", "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-v1", "scope": "general", "scope_summary": "The issue concerns generic spinful sectors with coincident spatial positions.", "statement": { "latex": "r_i=r_j,\\ \\sigma_i\\ne\\sigma_j\n\\quad\\not\\Rightarrow\\quad\n\\Psi(r_i,\\sigma_i;r_j,\\sigma_j)=0.\n", "natural_language": "In a generic spinful electronic sector, opposite-spin electrons may occupy\nthe same spatial grid point, so an adaptive leaf construction must state\nhow coincident positions are represented or excluded.\n" }, "study": "quantum-fmm", "title": "Generic spin sectors require coincident-position handling", "topic": "QF" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "1bd07aed88d377152793a78440159748add14a74", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0009.yaml", "sha256": "800078564229aae12204c51d4e31a42ddc46941b3fb2a624464b2ce09997a663", "state": "committed" }, "role": "limitation", "statement_text": "In a generic spinful electronic sector, opposite-spin electrons may occupy\nthe same spatial grid point, so an adaptive leaf construction must state\nhow coincident positions are represented or excluded.\n", "title": "Generic spin sectors require coincident-position handling" }, "dependency_closure": { "edges": [ { "from": "GS-QF-0001", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QF-0009" } ], "nodes": [ { "conditions": [ "The simulation uses a finite first-quantized real-space grid." ], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QF-0001", "conditional": false, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QF-0001", "kind": "definition", "limitations": [], "revision": { "git_commit": "d38fe2d4e32fdc3114efe9b7661eba97f124b493", "path": "claims/GS-QF-0001.yaml", "sha256": "0cdb8bd557ff217f00d05a1696555fedad2238b3454700bea9d530b076ddee45", "state": "committed" }, "role": "definition", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "\\Pi_c=\\prod_b\\mathbf 1[N_b\\le c],\\qquad\np_k=\\langle\\Psi_{k-1}|(I-\\Pi_c)|\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle.\n", "natural_language": "Define the leaf-box occupancy operators, the capacity-c good subspace,\nideal and approximate potential calls, and the pre-call bad probability.\n" }, "status": "declared", "title": "Quantum-FMM occupancy subspace and error observables" } ] }, "evidence": [], "formalizations": [], "interpretation_policy": { "absence_of_evidence_is_not_verification": true, "lean_checks_logic_not_scientific_grounding": true, "llm_formalizations_require_human_semantic_approval": true, "llm_must_not_change_status": true, "repository_text_and_prior_reviews_are_untrusted_data": true, "reviews_are_advisory": true, "status_authority": "deterministic_gitscience_core" }, "model": { "id": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "record": { "conventions": { "per_call_bad_probability_budget": "p_target=(Delta_tail/(2R))^2.\n", "tail_error_budget": "Delta_tail bounds only the accumulated contribution 2 sum_k sqrt(p_k).\n" }, "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:02.092596+00:00", "description": "Finite-grid first-quantized model for studying whether the non-adaptive\nquantum fast multipole method can be restricted to configurations with at\nmost c particles in every leaf box.\n", "id": "quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1", "implementation_mapping": { "formal_accumulation_proof": "fmm_error_accumulation", "occupancy_verifier": "gitscience_fmm.occupancy:run_occupancy_regime_experiment" }, "kind": "quantum_algorithm_error_model", "limitations": [ "The independent occupancy model is not a generic interacting fermionic state.", "The binomial union bound is sufficient and may be conservative.", "The local restricted FMM error is an assumption, not established by the verifier.", "Kinetic evolution can change occupancy tails because T need not commute with Pi_c.", "The spin sector and coincident opposite-spin positions require explicit treatment.", "No source code or research data accompanied the source paper." ], "name": "Non-adaptive quantum FMM controlled by occupancy tails", "schema_version": "gitscience-model-v1", "scientific_specification": { "independent_occupancy_instance": { "distribution": "multinomial uniform placement into B boxes", "one_box_marginal": "Binomial(eta, 1/B)", "union_bound_latex": "p_{\\mathrm{bad}}\\le B\\Pr[\\operatorname{Binomial}(\\eta,1/B)>c].\n" }, "occupancy": { "box_number_operator": "N_b", "capacity": "c", "good_subspace_latex": "\\Pi_c=\\prod_{b=1}^{B}\\mathbf 1\\!\\left[N_b\\le c\\right].\n", "leaf_boxes": "B" }, "simulation": { "approximate_non_adaptive_call": "\\widetilde U_k", "bad_probability_latex": "p_k=\\langle\\Psi_{k-1}\\rvert(I-\\Pi_c)\\lvert\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle.\n", "calls": "R", "ideal_potential_call": "U_k", "ideal_pre_call_state": "\\lvert\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle" } }, "source": { "authors": [ "Dominic W. Berry", "Kianna Wan", "Andrew D. Baczewski", "Elliot C. Eklund", "Arkin Tikku", "Ryan Babbush" ], "doi": "10.1103/b2vn-zf6c", "publication": "PRX Quantum 7, 033025 (2026)", "source_pdf_sha256": "5a586d6339575ac1e350c2b0f7f2c75af5c98a67b196bc47db6000c53710daaa", "title": "Quantum Simulation of Electronic Structure via Quantum Fast Multipole Method" } }, "revision": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "models/quantum-fmm-occupancy-v1.yaml", "sha256": "bbf26bc6862b01cb2342e3e1d60c1f40668f430c188968c80e7cd488fe44fd87", "state": "committed" } }, "narrative": { "claim_question": "How should an adaptive spatial decomposition handle opposite-spin particles at the same position?", "plain_language_conclusion": "The case study identifies this as a scope obligation rather than resolving it.", "remaining_uncertainty": "The representation or exclusion of coincident positions remains unspecified.", "research_question": "When can a capacity-limited non-adaptive quantum fast multipole method meet a\ndeclared error budget, and which occupancy assumptions are needed?\n", "scope_summary": "The issue concerns generic spinful sectors with coincident spatial positions." }, "obligations": [ { "message": "This records a model-scope obligation, not a demonstrated error in the source paper.", "source": "claim", "type": "scope_limitation" }, { "message": "No integrity-valid evidence targets the current claim revision.", "source": "evidence", "type": "no_current_evidence" }, { "message": "This claim is explicitly classified as a conjecture.", "source": "claim", "type": "open_conjecture" } ], "reviews": [], "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-state-v1", "scope_boundary": { "conditions": [], "limitations": [ "This records a model-scope obligation, not a demonstrated error in the source paper." ], "not_established": [ "This records a model-scope obligation, not a demonstrated error in the source paper.", "No integrity-valid evidence targets the current claim revision.", "This claim is explicitly classified as a conjecture." ], "scope": "general" }, "status": { "derived": "proposed", "dimensions": { "computational": "untested", "dependencies": "resolved", "formalization": "not_requested", "logical": "not_applicable", "provenance": "no_records", "review": "unreviewed", "revision": "committed", "scientific_grounding": "unassessed" }, "reasons": [ "No current integrity-valid evidence" ] }, "study": { "id": "quantum-fmm", "record": { "approach_summary": "Decompose the argument into a restricted-call assumption, a Lean-checked\naccumulation lemma, an occupancy-tail lemma, a combined conditional bound,\nand a finite independent-occupancy diagnostic for two box regimes.\n", "article_path": "articles/quantum-fmm.yaml", "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:02.179369+00:00", "equation_directory": "equations/quantum-fmm", "id": "quantum-fmm", "name": "Quantum-FMM occupancy", "research_question": "When can a capacity-limited non-adaptive quantum fast multipole method meet a\ndeclared error budget, and which occupancy assumptions are needed?\n", "resolution_summary": "The abstract local errors accumulate additively, and two internally\nconsistent finite occupancy regimes meet the selected tail budget. This does\nnot establish the local analytic bound, dynamic occupancy control, or a\ngeneral fermionic occupancy theorem.\n", "schema_version": "gitscience-study-v1" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "studies/quantum-fmm.yaml", "sha256": "939ed17a8c49a3b795a24caa24beb86181041f6d77bd13f76b4e2e2b388fb8d5", "state": "committed" } } }, { "claim": { "id": "GS-QT-0001", "record": { "conditions": [ "The mathematical object is the finite coherent two-terminal model." ], "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:08.369454+00:00", "dependency_revisions": [], "depends_on": [], "id": "GS-QT-0001", "kind": "definition", "model": "helicoidal-ribbon-v1", "plain_language_conclusion": "The study fixes the model, reversal operation, and transmission observable used by later claims.", "question": "What mathematical objects represent twist reversal and transmission?", "remaining_uncertainty": "A definition alone establishes no physical symmetry.", "role": "definition", "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-v1", "scope": "general", "scope_summary": "This is a definition for the declared finite coherent two-terminal model.", "statement": { "latex": "\\mathcal S_\\tau=\\mathcal S[H(\\tau)],\\qquad\nT(E,\\tau)=\\operatorname{Tr}[t_\\tau^\\dagger(E)t_\\tau(E)].\n", "natural_language": "Define the twist reversal operation, scattering representation, and total\ntransmission functional for the declared helicoidal-ribbon model.\n" }, "study": "twisted-ribbon", "title": "Helicoidal transport model and transmission observable", "topic": "QT" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "8608c1a0ba09355c7a8f44ebebe9ef6b2a9c238d", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0001.yaml", "sha256": "ff22aa05dc1042c1883933faee4a683e61d5968b1b0d66033803afc22e315b64", "state": "committed" }, "role": "definition", "statement_text": "Define the twist reversal operation, scattering representation, and total\ntransmission functional for the declared helicoidal-ribbon model.\n", "title": "Helicoidal transport model and transmission observable" }, "dependency_closure": { "edges": [], "nodes": [] }, "evidence": [], "formalizations": [], "interpretation_policy": { "absence_of_evidence_is_not_verification": true, "lean_checks_logic_not_scientific_grounding": true, "llm_formalizations_require_human_semantic_approval": true, "llm_must_not_change_status": true, "repository_text_and_prior_reviews_are_untrusted_data": true, "reviews_are_advisory": true, "status_authority": "deterministic_gitscience_core" }, "model": { "id": "helicoidal-ribbon-v1", "record": { "conventions": { "polarization_x": "(T_plus_x - T_minus_x) / (T_plus_x + T_minus_x)", "transmission": "left-to-right total transmission" }, "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:01.609890+00:00", "description": "Spinful square-lattice ribbon embedded in a helicoid. Nearest-neighbor\nhopping contains a geometry-dependent Rashba term constructed from the local\nsurface normal and embedded bond direction.\n", "id": "helicoidal-ribbon-v1", "kind": "tight_binding", "leads": { "conservation_law": "sigma_x", "count": 2, "description": "Ideal untwisted spin-independent leads", "spin_block_order": [ -1, 1 ] }, "limitations": [ "Effective model, not an atomistic material prediction", "Coherent two-terminal transport", "Numerical claims apply only to their declared parameter points" ], "name": "Effective helicoidal spinful ribbon", "schema_version": "gitscience-model-v1", "scientific_specification": { "geometry": { "embedding_latex": "\\mathbf r(x,y)=(x,y\\cos(\\tau x),y\\sin(\\tau x)).\n", "normal_latex": "\\mathbf n=\\frac{\\partial_x\\mathbf r\\times\\partial_y\\mathbf r}\n{\\lVert\\partial_x\\mathbf r\\times\\partial_y\\mathbf r\\rVert}.\n" }, "hamiltonian": { "hopping_latex": "-tI_2+i\\lambda\\boldsymbol{\\sigma}\\cdot\n(\\bar{\\mathbf n}_{ij}\\times\\hat{\\mathbf d}_{ij})\n", "latex": "H = \\sum_i c_i^\\dagger (4t+V)I_2 c_i\n+ \\sum_{\\langle i,j\\rangle}\n\\left[c_i^\\dagger\\left(-tI_2+i\\lambda\n\\boldsymbol{\\sigma}\\cdot\n(\\bar{\\mathbf n}_{ij}\\times\\hat{\\mathbf d}_{ij})\\right)c_j\n+ \\mathrm{h.c.}\\right].\n", "onsite_latex": "(4t+V)I_2" }, "hilbert_space": { "internal_degree": "spin-1/2", "lattice": "square", "orbitals_per_site": 2 }, "implementation_mapping": { "hopping_term": "gitscience_kwant.twisted_nanoribbon:scattering_hopping", "model_builder": "gitscience_kwant.twisted_nanoribbon:build_system", "transmission": "kwant.smatrix.transmission" }, "observables": { "polarization_x_latex": "P_x=\\frac{T_{+x}-T_{-x}}{T_{+x}+T_{-x}}.\n", "transmission_latex": "T(E,\\tau)=\\operatorname{Tr}[t^\\dagger(E,\\tau)t(E,\\tau)].\n" }, "parameters": { "V": { "request_key": "onsite", "units": "model_energy_unit" }, "lambda": { "request_key": "soc", "units": "model_energy_unit" }, "t": { "request_key": "hopping", "units": "model_energy_unit" }, "tau": { "request_key": "tau", "units": "inverse_lattice_spacing" } } } }, "revision": { "git_commit": "91fa0437cb652d050b98f06c38207a3bec3cae54", "path": "models/helicoidal-ribbon-v1.yaml", "sha256": "b535168e6345e16378bf91c138d01aadf36efe83e9e8f9a403aa850e8b324a78", "state": "committed" } }, "narrative": { "claim_question": "What mathematical objects represent twist reversal and transmission?", "plain_language_conclusion": "The study fixes the model, reversal operation, and transmission observable used by later claims.", "remaining_uncertainty": "A definition alone establishes no physical symmetry.", "research_question": "Does reversing the sign of a ribbon's twist leave its total two-terminal\ntransmission unchanged, and what is actually established by formal and\nnumerical checks?\n", "scope_summary": "This is a definition for the declared finite coherent two-terminal model." }, "obligations": [ { "message": "No integrity-valid evidence targets the current claim revision.", "source": "evidence", "type": "no_current_evidence" } ], "reviews": [], "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-state-v1", "scope_boundary": { "conditions": [ "The mathematical object is the finite coherent two-terminal model." ], "limitations": [], "not_established": [ "No integrity-valid evidence targets the current claim revision." ], "scope": "general" }, "status": { "derived": "declared", "dimensions": { "computational": "untested", "dependencies": "resolved", "formalization": "not_requested", "logical": "declared", "provenance": "no_records", "review": "unreviewed", "revision": "committed", "scientific_grounding": "unassessed" }, "reasons": [ "No current integrity-valid evidence" ] }, "study": { "id": "twisted-ribbon", "record": { "approach_summary": "Separate the model definition, a physical covariance assumption, the formal\nimplication checked by Lean, the model-level corollary, and a finite Kwant\ncalculation at one declared parameter point.\n", "article_path": "articles/twisted-ribbon.yaml", "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:01.696689+00:00", "equation_directory": "equations/twisted-ribbon", "id": "twisted-ribbon", "name": "Twisted ribbon transport", "research_question": "Does reversing the sign of a ribbon's twist leave its total two-terminal\ntransmission unchanged, and what is actually established by formal and\nnumerical checks?\n", "resolution_summary": "Lean establishes that the declared covariance implies even transmission,\nand Kwant corroborates even transmission at the reference point. The\ncovariance itself and generality across energies and geometries remain open.\n", "schema_version": "gitscience-study-v1" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "91fa0437cb652d050b98f06c38207a3bec3cae54", "path": "studies/twisted-ribbon.yaml", "sha256": "dab8bf0d83004a462e52fc0da5487dda8a2c7760311a5012602c19d7b390abee", "state": "committed" } } }, { "claim": { "id": "GS-QT-0002", "record": { "conditions": [ "The leads and boundary conditions preserve the declared transformation." ], "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:08.623837+00:00", "dependency_revisions": [ { "git_commit": "8608c1a0ba09355c7a8f44ebebe9ef6b2a9c238d", "id": "GS-QT-0001", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0001.yaml", "sha256": "ff22aa05dc1042c1883933faee4a683e61d5968b1b0d66033803afc22e315b64" } ], "depends_on": [ "GS-QT-0001" ], "id": "GS-QT-0002", "kind": "assumption", "limitations": [ "This physical covariance is declared as an assumption, not proved by Lean." ], "model": "helicoidal-ribbon-v1", "plain_language_conclusion": "The required covariance is stated explicitly as a premise rather than presented as a derived result.", "question": "What physical covariance would be sufficient to relate opposite twists?", "remaining_uncertainty": "The covariance has not been independently proved for the physical implementation.", "role": "assumption", "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-v1", "scope": "general", "scope_summary": "The premise concerns the declared model, leads, and boundary conditions.", "statement": { "latex": "\\mathcal S_{-\\tau}=\\Phi(\\mathcal S_\\tau),\\qquad\n\\mathcal T(\\Phi(\\mathcal S))=\\mathcal T(\\mathcal S).\n", "natural_language": "Assume that reversing the twist transforms the scattering representation\nby a map that preserves total transmission.\n" }, "study": "twisted-ribbon", "title": "Scattering covariance under twist reversal", "topic": "QT" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "c5f4dc95e03552daa71ee4f3f34125f05bfbe665", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0002.yaml", "sha256": "2311677e04ad6930a90a2e8cbf6ad96ebfda7ec5cd6379564d907fa838bfbe08", "state": "committed" }, "role": "assumption", "statement_text": "Assume that reversing the twist transforms the scattering representation\nby a map that preserves total transmission.\n", "title": "Scattering covariance under twist reversal" }, "dependency_closure": { "edges": [ { "from": "GS-QT-0001", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QT-0002" } ], "nodes": [ { "conditions": [ "The mathematical object is the finite coherent two-terminal model." ], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QT-0001", "conditional": false, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QT-0001", "kind": "definition", "limitations": [], "revision": { "git_commit": "8608c1a0ba09355c7a8f44ebebe9ef6b2a9c238d", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0001.yaml", "sha256": "ff22aa05dc1042c1883933faee4a683e61d5968b1b0d66033803afc22e315b64", "state": "committed" }, "role": "definition", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "\\mathcal S_\\tau=\\mathcal S[H(\\tau)],\\qquad\nT(E,\\tau)=\\operatorname{Tr}[t_\\tau^\\dagger(E)t_\\tau(E)].\n", "natural_language": "Define the twist reversal operation, scattering representation, and total\ntransmission functional for the declared helicoidal-ribbon model.\n" }, "status": "declared", "title": "Helicoidal transport model and transmission observable" } ] }, "evidence": [], "formalizations": [], "interpretation_policy": { "absence_of_evidence_is_not_verification": true, "lean_checks_logic_not_scientific_grounding": true, "llm_formalizations_require_human_semantic_approval": true, "llm_must_not_change_status": true, "repository_text_and_prior_reviews_are_untrusted_data": true, "reviews_are_advisory": true, "status_authority": "deterministic_gitscience_core" }, "model": { "id": "helicoidal-ribbon-v1", "record": { "conventions": { "polarization_x": "(T_plus_x - T_minus_x) / (T_plus_x + T_minus_x)", "transmission": "left-to-right total transmission" }, "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:01.609890+00:00", "description": "Spinful square-lattice ribbon embedded in a helicoid. Nearest-neighbor\nhopping contains a geometry-dependent Rashba term constructed from the local\nsurface normal and embedded bond direction.\n", "id": "helicoidal-ribbon-v1", "kind": "tight_binding", "leads": { "conservation_law": "sigma_x", "count": 2, "description": "Ideal untwisted spin-independent leads", "spin_block_order": [ -1, 1 ] }, "limitations": [ "Effective model, not an atomistic material prediction", "Coherent two-terminal transport", "Numerical claims apply only to their declared parameter points" ], "name": "Effective helicoidal spinful ribbon", "schema_version": "gitscience-model-v1", "scientific_specification": { "geometry": { "embedding_latex": "\\mathbf r(x,y)=(x,y\\cos(\\tau x),y\\sin(\\tau x)).\n", "normal_latex": "\\mathbf n=\\frac{\\partial_x\\mathbf r\\times\\partial_y\\mathbf r}\n{\\lVert\\partial_x\\mathbf r\\times\\partial_y\\mathbf r\\rVert}.\n" }, "hamiltonian": { "hopping_latex": "-tI_2+i\\lambda\\boldsymbol{\\sigma}\\cdot\n(\\bar{\\mathbf n}_{ij}\\times\\hat{\\mathbf d}_{ij})\n", "latex": "H = \\sum_i c_i^\\dagger (4t+V)I_2 c_i\n+ \\sum_{\\langle i,j\\rangle}\n\\left[c_i^\\dagger\\left(-tI_2+i\\lambda\n\\boldsymbol{\\sigma}\\cdot\n(\\bar{\\mathbf n}_{ij}\\times\\hat{\\mathbf d}_{ij})\\right)c_j\n+ \\mathrm{h.c.}\\right].\n", "onsite_latex": "(4t+V)I_2" }, "hilbert_space": { "internal_degree": "spin-1/2", "lattice": "square", "orbitals_per_site": 2 }, "implementation_mapping": { "hopping_term": "gitscience_kwant.twisted_nanoribbon:scattering_hopping", "model_builder": "gitscience_kwant.twisted_nanoribbon:build_system", "transmission": "kwant.smatrix.transmission" }, "observables": { "polarization_x_latex": "P_x=\\frac{T_{+x}-T_{-x}}{T_{+x}+T_{-x}}.\n", "transmission_latex": "T(E,\\tau)=\\operatorname{Tr}[t^\\dagger(E,\\tau)t(E,\\tau)].\n" }, "parameters": { "V": { "request_key": "onsite", "units": "model_energy_unit" }, "lambda": { "request_key": "soc", "units": "model_energy_unit" }, "t": { "request_key": "hopping", "units": "model_energy_unit" }, "tau": { "request_key": "tau", "units": "inverse_lattice_spacing" } } } }, "revision": { "git_commit": "91fa0437cb652d050b98f06c38207a3bec3cae54", "path": "models/helicoidal-ribbon-v1.yaml", "sha256": "b535168e6345e16378bf91c138d01aadf36efe83e9e8f9a403aa850e8b324a78", "state": "committed" } }, "narrative": { "claim_question": "What physical covariance would be sufficient to relate opposite twists?", "plain_language_conclusion": "The required covariance is stated explicitly as a premise rather than presented as a derived result.", "remaining_uncertainty": "The covariance has not been independently proved for the physical implementation.", "research_question": "Does reversing the sign of a ribbon's twist leave its total two-terminal\ntransmission unchanged, and what is actually established by formal and\nnumerical checks?\n", "scope_summary": "The premise concerns the declared model, leads, and boundary conditions." }, "obligations": [ { "message": "This physical covariance is declared as an assumption, not proved by Lean.", "source": "claim", "type": "scope_limitation" }, { "message": "No integrity-valid evidence targets the current claim revision.", "source": "evidence", "type": "no_current_evidence" } ], "reviews": [], "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-state-v1", "scope_boundary": { "conditions": [ "The leads and boundary conditions preserve the declared transformation." ], "limitations": [ "This physical covariance is declared as an assumption, not proved by Lean." ], "not_established": [ "This physical covariance is declared as an assumption, not proved by Lean.", "No integrity-valid evidence targets the current claim revision." ], "scope": "general" }, "status": { "derived": "declared", "dimensions": { "computational": "untested", "dependencies": "resolved", "formalization": "not_requested", "logical": "declared", "provenance": "no_records", "review": "unreviewed", "revision": "committed", "scientific_grounding": "unassessed" }, "reasons": [ "No current integrity-valid evidence" ] }, "study": { "id": "twisted-ribbon", "record": { "approach_summary": "Separate the model definition, a physical covariance assumption, the formal\nimplication checked by Lean, the model-level corollary, and a finite Kwant\ncalculation at one declared parameter point.\n", "article_path": "articles/twisted-ribbon.yaml", "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:01.696689+00:00", "equation_directory": "equations/twisted-ribbon", "id": "twisted-ribbon", "name": "Twisted ribbon transport", "research_question": "Does reversing the sign of a ribbon's twist leave its total two-terminal\ntransmission unchanged, and what is actually established by formal and\nnumerical checks?\n", "resolution_summary": "Lean establishes that the declared covariance implies even transmission,\nand Kwant corroborates even transmission at the reference point. The\ncovariance itself and generality across energies and geometries remain open.\n", "schema_version": "gitscience-study-v1" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "91fa0437cb652d050b98f06c38207a3bec3cae54", "path": "studies/twisted-ribbon.yaml", "sha256": "dab8bf0d83004a462e52fc0da5487dda8a2c7760311a5012602c19d7b390abee", "state": "committed" } } }, { "claim": { "id": "GS-QT-0003", "record": { "conditions": [], "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:08.900342+00:00", "dependency_revisions": [ { "git_commit": "8608c1a0ba09355c7a8f44ebebe9ef6b2a9c238d", "id": "GS-QT-0001", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0001.yaml", "sha256": "ff22aa05dc1042c1883933faee4a683e61d5968b1b0d66033803afc22e315b64" }, { "git_commit": "c5f4dc95e03552daa71ee4f3f34125f05bfbe665", "id": "GS-QT-0002", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0002.yaml", "sha256": "2311677e04ad6930a90a2e8cbf6ad96ebfda7ec5cd6379564d907fa838bfbe08" } ], "depends_on": [ "GS-QT-0001", "GS-QT-0002" ], "id": "GS-QT-0003", "kind": "lemma", "model": "helicoidal-ribbon-v1", "plain_language_conclusion": "Yes. Lean checks the abstract implication from covariance and transmission invariance to even transmission.", "question": "Does the covariance premise logically imply even total transmission?", "remaining_uncertainty": "Lean does not establish that the physical model satisfies the covariance premise.", "role": "supporting_result", "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-v1", "scope": "general", "scope_summary": "This is a general logical implication conditional on its premises.", "statement": { "latex": "\\left[\\mathcal S_{-\\tau}=\\Phi(\\mathcal S_\\tau)\\ \\land\\\n\\mathcal T\\circ\\Phi=\\mathcal T\\right]\n\\Longrightarrow T(E,-\\tau)=T(E,\\tau).\n", "natural_language": "If scattering is covariant under twist reversal and transmission is\ninvariant under that covariance map, total transmission is even in twist.\n" }, "study": "twisted-ribbon", "title": "Scattering covariance implies even transmission", "topic": "QT", "verification": { "assertions": [ "transport_symmetry_implies_even_transmission" ], "experiment": "trusted_proof", "request": { "proof": "twist_transport_symmetry" }, "verifier": "lean_formal" } }, "revision": { "git_commit": "21e63002398900c6a3d702253b949ad55fec745b", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0003.yaml", "sha256": "736f64bc62081e61315358f3fdfbb01c9dd93bba543f52fc1e9a6d171fc44fa1", "state": "committed" }, "role": "supporting_result", "statement_text": "If scattering is covariant under twist reversal and transmission is\ninvariant under that covariance map, total transmission is even in twist.\n", "title": "Scattering covariance implies even transmission" }, "dependency_closure": { "edges": [ { "from": "GS-QT-0001", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QT-0002" }, { "from": "GS-QT-0001", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QT-0003" }, { "from": "GS-QT-0002", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QT-0003" } ], "nodes": [ { "conditions": [ "The mathematical object is the finite coherent two-terminal model." ], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QT-0001", "conditional": false, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QT-0001", "kind": "definition", "limitations": [], "revision": { "git_commit": "8608c1a0ba09355c7a8f44ebebe9ef6b2a9c238d", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0001.yaml", "sha256": "ff22aa05dc1042c1883933faee4a683e61d5968b1b0d66033803afc22e315b64", "state": "committed" }, "role": "definition", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "\\mathcal S_\\tau=\\mathcal S[H(\\tau)],\\qquad\nT(E,\\tau)=\\operatorname{Tr}[t_\\tau^\\dagger(E)t_\\tau(E)].\n", "natural_language": "Define the twist reversal operation, scattering representation, and total\ntransmission functional for the declared helicoidal-ribbon model.\n" }, "status": "declared", "title": "Helicoidal transport model and transmission observable" }, { "conditions": [ "The leads and boundary conditions preserve the declared transformation." ], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QT-0002", "conditional": false, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QT-0002", "kind": "assumption", "limitations": [ "This physical covariance is declared as an assumption, not proved by Lean." ], "revision": { "git_commit": "c5f4dc95e03552daa71ee4f3f34125f05bfbe665", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0002.yaml", "sha256": "2311677e04ad6930a90a2e8cbf6ad96ebfda7ec5cd6379564d907fa838bfbe08", "state": "committed" }, "role": "assumption", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "\\mathcal S_{-\\tau}=\\Phi(\\mathcal S_\\tau),\\qquad\n\\mathcal T(\\Phi(\\mathcal S))=\\mathcal T(\\mathcal S).\n", "natural_language": "Assume that reversing the twist transforms the scattering representation\nby a map that preserves total transmission.\n" }, "status": "declared", "title": "Scattering covariance under twist reversal" } ] }, "evidence": [ { "artifact_result": { "claims": { "transport_symmetry_implies_even_transmission": { "exit_code": 0, "passes": true, "proof": "twist_transport_symmetry", "source": "twist_transport_symmetry.lean", "stderr": "", "stdout": "" } }, "diagnostics": { "assertion_established": true, "elaboration_succeeded": true, "lean_invocation_succeeded": true }, "lean_version": "Lean (version 4.32.2, arm64-apple-darwin24.6.0, commit f3b06c705e6c85f5314019d5d3baab0fec5b580c, Release)", "schema_version": "gitscience-lean-v1", "trusted_bundled_source": true }, "assertions": [ { "assertion": "transport_symmetry_implies_even_transmission", "detail": { "exit_code": 0, "passes": true, "proof": "twist_transport_symmetry", "source": "twist_transport_symmetry.lean", "stderr": "", "stdout": "" }, "outcome": "satisfied", "supports_claim": true } ], "authenticated": false, "classification": "proving", "id": "EV-000001", "record": { "artifact": { "path": "artifacts/EV-000001.lean.json", "sha256": "e405e7849c728cf82310f918b4899dc42e3803cbd2cfb875ecd7c15897ab8677" }, "attestor": { "email": "jnapoles@uach.mx", "name": "Jos\u00e9 Manuel N\u00e1poles Duarte" }, "authentication": { "authenticated": false, "method": "none" }, "claim": { "git_commit": "21e63002398900c6a3d702253b949ad55fec745b", "id": "GS-QT-0003", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0003.yaml", "sha256": "736f64bc62081e61315358f3fdfbb01c9dd93bba543f52fc1e9a6d171fc44fa1" }, "classification": "proving", "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:19.337830+00:00", "dependencies": [ { "git_commit": "8608c1a0ba09355c7a8f44ebebe9ef6b2a9c238d", "id": "GS-QT-0001", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0001.yaml", "sha256": "ff22aa05dc1042c1883933faee4a683e61d5968b1b0d66033803afc22e315b64" }, { "git_commit": "c5f4dc95e03552daa71ee4f3f34125f05bfbe665", "id": "GS-QT-0002", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0002.yaml", "sha256": "2311677e04ad6930a90a2e8cbf6ad96ebfda7ec5cd6379564d907fa838bfbe08" } ], "environment": { "implementation": "CPython", "machine": "arm64", "packages": { "gitscience": "0.1.0" }, "platform": "macOS-26.5.2-arm64-arm-64bit", "python": "3.12.13", "verifier": { "name": "lean_formal", "version": "0.1.0" }, "verifier_source_sha256": { "__init__.py": "5e1c8c0f8fc5459f6c289c9e668bfc2d2b2256eb0a63ce51870e2c7ddec2ba17", "fmm_error_accumulation.lean": "71b628f22305f00b3665115fefad68e8fa26c31cd6d997f635a6f768a1ae4eb7", "plugin.py": "9333c8dad2b2ddcccbbec3c18804e476a7f230cdeac338738435a9bedf74be2d", "twist_transport_symmetry.lean": "10a49c448ff0b3ad52f55aa2b287d4031bae837fb9476ed266ff61dd0221701e" } }, "environment_sha256": "d24b8fc54ea3962f31c93bd836370432ddaf91f9e482d512b47c643acee35d61", "id": "EV-000001", "model": { "git_commit": "91fa0437cb652d050b98f06c38207a3bec3cae54", "id": "helicoidal-ribbon-v1", "path": "models/helicoidal-ribbon-v1.yaml", "sha256": "b535168e6345e16378bf91c138d01aadf36efe83e9e8f9a403aa850e8b324a78" }, "repository_head": "1bd07aed88d377152793a78440159748add14a74", "schema_version": "gitscience-evidence-v1", "verification": { "arbitrary_code_execution": false, "assertions": [ "transport_symmetry_implies_even_transmission" ], "evaluations": [ { "assertion": "transport_symmetry_implies_even_transmission", "detail": { "exit_code": 0, "passes": true, "proof": "twist_transport_symmetry", "source": "twist_transport_symmetry.lean", "stderr": "", "stdout": "" }, "passes": true } ], "evidence_kind": "formal_proof", "experiment": "trusted_proof", "request": { "proof": "twist_transport_symmetry" }, "verifier": "lean_formal", "verifier_version": "0.1.0" } }, "verifier": { "evidence_kind": "formal_proof", "experiment": "trusted_proof", "name": "lean_formal", "version": "0.1.0" }, "warnings": [ "evidence is not cryptographically authenticated" ] }, { "artifact_result": { "claims": { "transport_symmetry_implies_even_transmission": { "exit_code": 0, "passes": true, "proof": "twist_transport_symmetry", "source": "twist_transport_symmetry.lean", "stderr": "", "stdout": "" } }, "diagnostics": { "assertion_established": true, "elaboration_succeeded": true, "lean_invocation_succeeded": false }, "lean_version": "error: no default toolchain configured. run `elan default stable` to install & configure the latest Lean 4 stable release.", "schema_version": "gitscience-lean-v1", "trusted_bundled_source": true }, "assertions": [ { "assertion": "transport_symmetry_implies_even_transmission", "detail": { "exit_code": 0, "passes": true, "proof": "twist_transport_symmetry", "source": "twist_transport_symmetry.lean", "stderr": "", "stdout": "" }, "outcome": "satisfied", "supports_claim": true } ], "authenticated": false, "classification": "proving", "id": "EV-000003", "record": { "artifact": { "path": "artifacts/EV-000003.lean.json", "sha256": "ac798458cfe03d785bb430c7c9b16d3f8e851dd07915ca842d955d524ea5820c" }, "attestor": { "email": "jnapoles@uach.mx", "name": "Jos\u00e9 Manuel N\u00e1poles Duarte" }, "authentication": { "authenticated": false, "method": "none" }, "claim": { "git_commit": "21e63002398900c6a3d702253b949ad55fec745b", "id": "GS-QT-0003", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0003.yaml", "sha256": "736f64bc62081e61315358f3fdfbb01c9dd93bba543f52fc1e9a6d171fc44fa1" }, "classification": "proving", "created_at": "2026-08-18T00:40:31.050722+00:00", "dependencies": [ { "git_commit": "8608c1a0ba09355c7a8f44ebebe9ef6b2a9c238d", "id": "GS-QT-0001", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0001.yaml", "sha256": "ff22aa05dc1042c1883933faee4a683e61d5968b1b0d66033803afc22e315b64" }, { "git_commit": "c5f4dc95e03552daa71ee4f3f34125f05bfbe665", "id": "GS-QT-0002", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0002.yaml", "sha256": "2311677e04ad6930a90a2e8cbf6ad96ebfda7ec5cd6379564d907fa838bfbe08" } ], "environment": { "implementation": "CPython", "machine": "arm64", "packages": { "gitscience": "0.1.0" }, "platform": "macOS-26.5.2-arm64-arm-64bit-Mach-O", "python": "3.13.3", "verifier": { "name": "lean_formal", "version": "0.1.0" }, "verifier_source_sha256": { "__init__.py": "5e1c8c0f8fc5459f6c289c9e668bfc2d2b2256eb0a63ce51870e2c7ddec2ba17", "fmm_error_accumulation.lean": "71b628f22305f00b3665115fefad68e8fa26c31cd6d997f635a6f768a1ae4eb7", "plugin.py": "bd56541c2f21ff83e266e14513450782a718859a471ff3552bf94448058b496a", "twist_transport_symmetry.lean": "10a49c448ff0b3ad52f55aa2b287d4031bae837fb9476ed266ff61dd0221701e" } }, "environment_sha256": "7211b1628a838167c9a52777e51061564b772d0d13fe0c04fcaeda309abd81c4", "formalization": { "formal_statement_sha256": "3f8f4821d4a68aaa7ce48dc622f3cfb2fda34b38f1976d11cbe43ab69d01dcc8", "git_commit": "18e4771d795aca68ba603fcc1bcd8da67c364c5a", "id": "FM-000001", "path": "formalizations/FM-000001.yaml", "scientific_grounding": "partial", "semantic_approval": "accepted", "sha256": "63441dcb0a79955d1abb5e5c3c357ca56f8cd734bde3ca23e35ad4720b23bfd2" }, "id": "EV-000003", "model": { "git_commit": "91fa0437cb652d050b98f06c38207a3bec3cae54", "id": "helicoidal-ribbon-v1", "path": "models/helicoidal-ribbon-v1.yaml", "sha256": "b535168e6345e16378bf91c138d01aadf36efe83e9e8f9a403aa850e8b324a78" }, "repository_head": "18e4771d795aca68ba603fcc1bcd8da67c364c5a", "schema_version": "gitscience-evidence-v1", "verification": { "arbitrary_code_execution": false, "assertions": [ "transport_symmetry_implies_even_transmission" ], "evaluations": [ { "assertion": "transport_symmetry_implies_even_transmission", "detail": { "exit_code": 0, "passes": true, "proof": "twist_transport_symmetry", "source": "twist_transport_symmetry.lean", "stderr": "", "stdout": "" }, "passes": true } ], "evidence_kind": "formal_proof", "experiment": "trusted_proof", "request": { "proof": "twist_transport_symmetry" }, "verifier": "lean_formal", "verifier_version": "0.1.0" } }, "verifier": { "evidence_kind": "formal_proof", "experiment": "trusted_proof", "name": "lean_formal", "version": "0.1.0" }, "warnings": [ "evidence is not cryptographically authenticated" ] } ], "formalizations": [ { "assumptions": [ "Scattering is covariant under the declared twist-reversal map.", "Total transmission is invariant under the scattering transformation." ], "formal_statement": { "declaration": "theorem transport_symmetry_implies_even_transmission\n {Twist Scattering Value : Type}\n (system : TransportSymmetry Twist Scattering Value)\n (tau : Twist) :\n system.transmission (system.scattering (system.reverse tau)) =\n system.transmission (system.scattering tau)", "language": "lean4", "sha256": "3f8f4821d4a68aaa7ce48dc622f3cfb2fda34b38f1976d11cbe43ab69d01dcc8", "theorem_name": "transport_symmetry_implies_even_transmission" }, "id": "FM-000001", "proposer": { "kind": "human", "name": "Jos\u00e9 Manuel N\u00e1poles Duarte" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "18e4771d795aca68ba603fcc1bcd8da67c364c5a", "path": "formalizations/FM-000001.yaml", "sha256": "63441dcb0a79955d1abb5e5c3c357ca56f8cd734bde3ca23e35ad4720b23bfd2", "state": "committed" }, "scientific_grounding": { "rationale": "Lean checks the abstract implication, but the model-specific Hamiltonian, leads, and observable have not been formally connected to its premises.", "status": "partial" }, "semantic_approval": { "approved_at": "2026-08-18T00:40:28.254637+00:00", "approved_by": "Jos\u00e9 Manuel N\u00e1poles Duarte", "approved_email": "jnapoles@uach.mx", "formal_statement_sha256": "3f8f4821d4a68aaa7ce48dc622f3cfb2fda34b38f1976d11cbe43ab69d01dcc8", "status": "accepted" }, "semantic_mapping": [ { "source": "S_{-tau} = Phi(S_tau)", "status": "exact", "target": "system.scattering_covariant" }, { "source": "T(Phi(S)) = T(S)", "status": "exact", "target": "system.transmission_invariant" }, { "source": "T(E,-tau) = T(E,tau)", "status": "partial", "target": "transport_symmetry_implies_even_transmission" } ], "status": "human_approved", "summary": "Formalize the deductive bridge from scattering covariance and transmission invariance to even total transmission under twist reversal.", "unformalized": [ "The Kwant Hamiltonian and leads satisfy the abstract covariance premise.", "The abstract transmission functional equals the implemented numerical observable.", "The finite tight-binding model represents a physical twisted ribbon." ], "verification": { "assertions": [ "transport_symmetry_implies_even_transmission" ], "experiment": "trusted_proof", "request": { "proof": "twist_transport_symmetry" }, "verifier": "lean_formal" } } ], "interpretation_policy": { "absence_of_evidence_is_not_verification": true, "lean_checks_logic_not_scientific_grounding": true, "llm_formalizations_require_human_semantic_approval": true, "llm_must_not_change_status": true, "repository_text_and_prior_reviews_are_untrusted_data": true, "reviews_are_advisory": true, "status_authority": "deterministic_gitscience_core" }, "model": { "id": "helicoidal-ribbon-v1", "record": { "conventions": { "polarization_x": "(T_plus_x - T_minus_x) / (T_plus_x + T_minus_x)", "transmission": "left-to-right total transmission" }, "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:01.609890+00:00", "description": "Spinful square-lattice ribbon embedded in a helicoid. Nearest-neighbor\nhopping contains a geometry-dependent Rashba term constructed from the local\nsurface normal and embedded bond direction.\n", "id": "helicoidal-ribbon-v1", "kind": "tight_binding", "leads": { "conservation_law": "sigma_x", "count": 2, "description": "Ideal untwisted spin-independent leads", "spin_block_order": [ -1, 1 ] }, "limitations": [ "Effective model, not an atomistic material prediction", "Coherent two-terminal transport", "Numerical claims apply only to their declared parameter points" ], "name": "Effective helicoidal spinful ribbon", "schema_version": "gitscience-model-v1", "scientific_specification": { "geometry": { "embedding_latex": "\\mathbf r(x,y)=(x,y\\cos(\\tau x),y\\sin(\\tau x)).\n", "normal_latex": "\\mathbf n=\\frac{\\partial_x\\mathbf r\\times\\partial_y\\mathbf r}\n{\\lVert\\partial_x\\mathbf r\\times\\partial_y\\mathbf r\\rVert}.\n" }, "hamiltonian": { "hopping_latex": "-tI_2+i\\lambda\\boldsymbol{\\sigma}\\cdot\n(\\bar{\\mathbf n}_{ij}\\times\\hat{\\mathbf d}_{ij})\n", "latex": "H = \\sum_i c_i^\\dagger (4t+V)I_2 c_i\n+ \\sum_{\\langle i,j\\rangle}\n\\left[c_i^\\dagger\\left(-tI_2+i\\lambda\n\\boldsymbol{\\sigma}\\cdot\n(\\bar{\\mathbf n}_{ij}\\times\\hat{\\mathbf d}_{ij})\\right)c_j\n+ \\mathrm{h.c.}\\right].\n", "onsite_latex": "(4t+V)I_2" }, "hilbert_space": { "internal_degree": "spin-1/2", "lattice": "square", "orbitals_per_site": 2 }, "implementation_mapping": { "hopping_term": "gitscience_kwant.twisted_nanoribbon:scattering_hopping", "model_builder": "gitscience_kwant.twisted_nanoribbon:build_system", "transmission": "kwant.smatrix.transmission" }, "observables": { "polarization_x_latex": "P_x=\\frac{T_{+x}-T_{-x}}{T_{+x}+T_{-x}}.\n", "transmission_latex": "T(E,\\tau)=\\operatorname{Tr}[t^\\dagger(E,\\tau)t(E,\\tau)].\n" }, "parameters": { "V": { "request_key": "onsite", "units": "model_energy_unit" }, "lambda": { "request_key": "soc", "units": "model_energy_unit" }, "t": { "request_key": "hopping", "units": "model_energy_unit" }, "tau": { "request_key": "tau", "units": "inverse_lattice_spacing" } } } }, "revision": { "git_commit": "91fa0437cb652d050b98f06c38207a3bec3cae54", "path": "models/helicoidal-ribbon-v1.yaml", "sha256": "b535168e6345e16378bf91c138d01aadf36efe83e9e8f9a403aa850e8b324a78", "state": "committed" } }, "narrative": { "claim_question": "Does the covariance premise logically imply even total transmission?", "plain_language_conclusion": "Yes. Lean checks the abstract implication from covariance and transmission invariance to even transmission.", "remaining_uncertainty": "Lean does not establish that the physical model satisfies the covariance premise.", "research_question": "Does reversing the sign of a ribbon's twist leave its total two-terminal\ntransmission unchanged, and what is actually established by formal and\nnumerical checks?\n", "scope_summary": "This is a general logical implication conditional on its premises." }, "obligations": [ { "message": "GS-QT-0002 is an explicit assumption", "source": "dependency_graph", "source_claim": "GS-QT-0003", "type": "unresolved_assumption" }, { "message": "At least one current evidence record is not cryptographically authenticated.", "source": "provenance", "type": "unauthenticated_evidence" }, { "message": "Lean checks the abstract implication, but the model-specific Hamiltonian, leads, and observable have not been formally connected to its premises.", "source": "formalization", "source_formalization": "FM-000001", "type": "scientific_grounding" } ], "reviews": [], "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-state-v1", "scope_boundary": { "conditions": [], "limitations": [], "not_established": [ "GS-QT-0002 is an explicit assumption", "At least one current evidence record is not cryptographically authenticated.", "Lean checks the abstract implication, but the model-specific Hamiltonian, leads, and observable have not been formally connected to its premises." ], "scope": "general" }, "status": { "derived": "conditional_proven", "dimensions": { "computational": "untested", "dependencies": "conditional", "formalization": "human_approved", "logical": "proven", "provenance": "unauthenticated", "review": "unreviewed", "revision": "committed", "scientific_grounding": "partial" }, "reasons": [ "GS-QT-0002 is an explicit assumption", "EV-000001 is proving", "EV-000003 is proving" ] }, "study": { "id": "twisted-ribbon", "record": { "approach_summary": "Separate the model definition, a physical covariance assumption, the formal\nimplication checked by Lean, the model-level corollary, and a finite Kwant\ncalculation at one declared parameter point.\n", "article_path": "articles/twisted-ribbon.yaml", "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:01.696689+00:00", "equation_directory": "equations/twisted-ribbon", "id": "twisted-ribbon", "name": "Twisted ribbon transport", "research_question": "Does reversing the sign of a ribbon's twist leave its total two-terminal\ntransmission unchanged, and what is actually established by formal and\nnumerical checks?\n", "resolution_summary": "Lean establishes that the declared covariance implies even transmission,\nand Kwant corroborates even transmission at the reference point. The\ncovariance itself and generality across energies and geometries remain open.\n", "schema_version": "gitscience-study-v1" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "91fa0437cb652d050b98f06c38207a3bec3cae54", "path": "studies/twisted-ribbon.yaml", "sha256": "dab8bf0d83004a462e52fc0da5487dda8a2c7760311a5012602c19d7b390abee", "state": "committed" } } }, { "claim": { "id": "GS-QT-0004", "record": { "conditions": [], "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:09.178475+00:00", "dependency_revisions": [ { "git_commit": "c5f4dc95e03552daa71ee4f3f34125f05bfbe665", "id": "GS-QT-0002", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0002.yaml", "sha256": "2311677e04ad6930a90a2e8cbf6ad96ebfda7ec5cd6379564d907fa838bfbe08" }, { "git_commit": "21e63002398900c6a3d702253b949ad55fec745b", "id": "GS-QT-0003", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0003.yaml", "sha256": "736f64bc62081e61315358f3fdfbb01c9dd93bba543f52fc1e9a6d171fc44fa1" } ], "depends_on": [ "GS-QT-0002", "GS-QT-0003" ], "id": "GS-QT-0004", "kind": "corollary", "limitations": [ "The conclusion remains conditional until covariance is independently established." ], "model": "helicoidal-ribbon-v1", "plain_language_conclusion": "The model has even transmission under twist reversal if the declared covariance holds.", "question": "What model-level conclusion follows when the covariance premise is applied?", "remaining_uncertainty": "The model-specific covariance still needs independent establishment.", "role": "supporting_result", "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-v1", "scope": "general", "scope_summary": "The conclusion is general within the declared model but remains conditional.", "statement": { "latex": "T(E,-\\tau)=T(E,\\tau).\n", "natural_language": "Under the declared scattering-covariance assumption, the model's total\ntransmission is even under reversal of the twist.\n" }, "study": "twisted-ribbon", "title": "Even transmission for the declared helicoidal model", "topic": "QT" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "a53f0dfeb3f3961454d04b79ded98d4a88e0dc3a", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0004.yaml", "sha256": "a17170a95ec7ff312f8b7391a263e3776d10964eedcc58d9f097eacee5e23cae", "state": "committed" }, "role": "supporting_result", "statement_text": "Under the declared scattering-covariance assumption, the model's total\ntransmission is even under reversal of the twist.\n", "title": "Even transmission for the declared helicoidal model" }, "dependency_closure": { "edges": [ { "from": "GS-QT-0001", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QT-0002" }, { "from": "GS-QT-0001", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QT-0003" }, { "from": "GS-QT-0002", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QT-0003" }, { "from": "GS-QT-0002", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QT-0004" }, { "from": "GS-QT-0003", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QT-0004" } ], "nodes": [ { "conditions": [ "The mathematical object is the finite coherent two-terminal model." ], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QT-0001", "conditional": false, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QT-0001", "kind": "definition", "limitations": [], "revision": { "git_commit": "8608c1a0ba09355c7a8f44ebebe9ef6b2a9c238d", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0001.yaml", "sha256": "ff22aa05dc1042c1883933faee4a683e61d5968b1b0d66033803afc22e315b64", "state": "committed" }, "role": "definition", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "\\mathcal S_\\tau=\\mathcal S[H(\\tau)],\\qquad\nT(E,\\tau)=\\operatorname{Tr}[t_\\tau^\\dagger(E)t_\\tau(E)].\n", "natural_language": "Define the twist reversal operation, scattering representation, and total\ntransmission functional for the declared helicoidal-ribbon model.\n" }, "status": "declared", "title": "Helicoidal transport model and transmission observable" }, { "conditions": [ "The leads and boundary conditions preserve the declared transformation." ], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QT-0002", "conditional": false, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QT-0002", "kind": "assumption", "limitations": [ "This physical covariance is declared as an assumption, not proved by Lean." ], "revision": { "git_commit": "c5f4dc95e03552daa71ee4f3f34125f05bfbe665", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0002.yaml", "sha256": "2311677e04ad6930a90a2e8cbf6ad96ebfda7ec5cd6379564d907fa838bfbe08", "state": "committed" }, "role": "assumption", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "\\mathcal S_{-\\tau}=\\Phi(\\mathcal S_\\tau),\\qquad\n\\mathcal T(\\Phi(\\mathcal S))=\\mathcal T(\\mathcal S).\n", "natural_language": "Assume that reversing the twist transforms the scattering representation\nby a map that preserves total transmission.\n" }, "status": "declared", "title": "Scattering covariance under twist reversal" }, { "conditions": [], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QT-0003", "conditional": true, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [ "GS-QT-0002 is an explicit assumption" ], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QT-0003", "kind": "lemma", "limitations": [], "revision": { "git_commit": "21e63002398900c6a3d702253b949ad55fec745b", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0003.yaml", "sha256": "736f64bc62081e61315358f3fdfbb01c9dd93bba543f52fc1e9a6d171fc44fa1", "state": "committed" }, "role": "supporting_result", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "\\left[\\mathcal S_{-\\tau}=\\Phi(\\mathcal S_\\tau)\\ \\land\\\n\\mathcal T\\circ\\Phi=\\mathcal T\\right]\n\\Longrightarrow T(E,-\\tau)=T(E,\\tau).\n", "natural_language": "If scattering is covariant under twist reversal and transmission is\ninvariant under that covariance map, total transmission is even in twist.\n" }, "status": "conditional_proven", "title": "Scattering covariance implies even transmission" } ] }, "evidence": [], "formalizations": [], "interpretation_policy": { "absence_of_evidence_is_not_verification": true, "lean_checks_logic_not_scientific_grounding": true, "llm_formalizations_require_human_semantic_approval": true, "llm_must_not_change_status": true, "repository_text_and_prior_reviews_are_untrusted_data": true, "reviews_are_advisory": true, "status_authority": "deterministic_gitscience_core" }, "model": { "id": "helicoidal-ribbon-v1", "record": { "conventions": { "polarization_x": "(T_plus_x - T_minus_x) / (T_plus_x + T_minus_x)", "transmission": "left-to-right total transmission" }, "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:01.609890+00:00", "description": "Spinful square-lattice ribbon embedded in a helicoid. Nearest-neighbor\nhopping contains a geometry-dependent Rashba term constructed from the local\nsurface normal and embedded bond direction.\n", "id": "helicoidal-ribbon-v1", "kind": "tight_binding", "leads": { "conservation_law": "sigma_x", "count": 2, "description": "Ideal untwisted spin-independent leads", "spin_block_order": [ -1, 1 ] }, "limitations": [ "Effective model, not an atomistic material prediction", "Coherent two-terminal transport", "Numerical claims apply only to their declared parameter points" ], "name": "Effective helicoidal spinful ribbon", "schema_version": "gitscience-model-v1", "scientific_specification": { "geometry": { "embedding_latex": "\\mathbf r(x,y)=(x,y\\cos(\\tau x),y\\sin(\\tau x)).\n", "normal_latex": "\\mathbf n=\\frac{\\partial_x\\mathbf r\\times\\partial_y\\mathbf r}\n{\\lVert\\partial_x\\mathbf r\\times\\partial_y\\mathbf r\\rVert}.\n" }, "hamiltonian": { "hopping_latex": "-tI_2+i\\lambda\\boldsymbol{\\sigma}\\cdot\n(\\bar{\\mathbf n}_{ij}\\times\\hat{\\mathbf d}_{ij})\n", "latex": "H = \\sum_i c_i^\\dagger (4t+V)I_2 c_i\n+ \\sum_{\\langle i,j\\rangle}\n\\left[c_i^\\dagger\\left(-tI_2+i\\lambda\n\\boldsymbol{\\sigma}\\cdot\n(\\bar{\\mathbf n}_{ij}\\times\\hat{\\mathbf d}_{ij})\\right)c_j\n+ \\mathrm{h.c.}\\right].\n", "onsite_latex": "(4t+V)I_2" }, "hilbert_space": { "internal_degree": "spin-1/2", "lattice": "square", "orbitals_per_site": 2 }, "implementation_mapping": { "hopping_term": "gitscience_kwant.twisted_nanoribbon:scattering_hopping", "model_builder": "gitscience_kwant.twisted_nanoribbon:build_system", "transmission": "kwant.smatrix.transmission" }, "observables": { "polarization_x_latex": "P_x=\\frac{T_{+x}-T_{-x}}{T_{+x}+T_{-x}}.\n", "transmission_latex": "T(E,\\tau)=\\operatorname{Tr}[t^\\dagger(E,\\tau)t(E,\\tau)].\n" }, "parameters": { "V": { "request_key": "onsite", "units": "model_energy_unit" }, "lambda": { "request_key": "soc", "units": "model_energy_unit" }, "t": { "request_key": "hopping", "units": "model_energy_unit" }, "tau": { "request_key": "tau", "units": "inverse_lattice_spacing" } } } }, "revision": { "git_commit": "91fa0437cb652d050b98f06c38207a3bec3cae54", "path": "models/helicoidal-ribbon-v1.yaml", "sha256": "b535168e6345e16378bf91c138d01aadf36efe83e9e8f9a403aa850e8b324a78", "state": "committed" } }, "narrative": { "claim_question": "What model-level conclusion follows when the covariance premise is applied?", "plain_language_conclusion": "The model has even transmission under twist reversal if the declared covariance holds.", "remaining_uncertainty": "The model-specific covariance still needs independent establishment.", "research_question": "Does reversing the sign of a ribbon's twist leave its total two-terminal\ntransmission unchanged, and what is actually established by formal and\nnumerical checks?\n", "scope_summary": "The conclusion is general within the declared model but remains conditional." }, "obligations": [ { "message": "GS-QT-0002 is an explicit assumption", "source": "dependency_graph", "source_claim": "GS-QT-0004", "type": "unresolved_assumption" }, { "message": "GS-QT-0003 is not independently established", "source": "dependency_graph", "source_claim": "GS-QT-0004", "type": "unresolved_dependency" }, { "message": "The conclusion remains conditional until covariance is independently established.", "source": "claim", "type": "scope_limitation" }, { "message": "No integrity-valid evidence targets the current claim revision.", "source": "evidence", "type": "no_current_evidence" } ], "reviews": [], "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-state-v1", "scope_boundary": { "conditions": [], "limitations": [ "The conclusion remains conditional until covariance is independently established." ], "not_established": [ "GS-QT-0002 is an explicit assumption", "GS-QT-0003 is not independently established", "The conclusion remains conditional until covariance is independently established.", "No integrity-valid evidence targets the current claim revision." ], "scope": "general" }, "status": { "derived": "conditional", "dimensions": { "computational": "untested", "dependencies": "conditional", "formalization": "not_requested", "logical": "unproven", "provenance": "no_records", "review": "unreviewed", "revision": "committed", "scientific_grounding": "unassessed" }, "reasons": [ "GS-QT-0002 is an explicit assumption", "GS-QT-0003 is not independently established", "No current integrity-valid evidence" ] }, "study": { "id": "twisted-ribbon", "record": { "approach_summary": "Separate the model definition, a physical covariance assumption, the formal\nimplication checked by Lean, the model-level corollary, and a finite Kwant\ncalculation at one declared parameter point.\n", "article_path": "articles/twisted-ribbon.yaml", "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:01.696689+00:00", "equation_directory": "equations/twisted-ribbon", "id": "twisted-ribbon", "name": "Twisted ribbon transport", "research_question": "Does reversing the sign of a ribbon's twist leave its total two-terminal\ntransmission unchanged, and what is actually established by formal and\nnumerical checks?\n", "resolution_summary": "Lean establishes that the declared covariance implies even transmission,\nand Kwant corroborates even transmission at the reference point. The\ncovariance itself and generality across energies and geometries remain open.\n", "schema_version": "gitscience-study-v1" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "91fa0437cb652d050b98f06c38207a3bec3cae54", "path": "studies/twisted-ribbon.yaml", "sha256": "dab8bf0d83004a462e52fc0da5487dda8a2c7760311a5012602c19d7b390abee", "state": "committed" } } }, { "claim": { "id": "GS-QT-0005", "record": { "conditions": [ "energy=1.0, hopping=1.0, onsite=0.0, SOC=0.1" ], "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:09.536576+00:00", "dependency_revisions": [ { "git_commit": "a53f0dfeb3f3961454d04b79ded98d4a88e0dc3a", "id": "GS-QT-0004", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0004.yaml", "sha256": "a17170a95ec7ff312f8b7391a263e3776d10964eedcc58d9f097eacee5e23cae" } ], "depends_on": [ "GS-QT-0004" ], "id": "GS-QT-0005", "kind": "numerical_proposition", "model": "helicoidal-ribbon-v1", "plain_language_conclusion": "Yes. The two transmissions agree within 1e-7 at the declared energy, geometry, and couplings.", "question": "Does the Kwant model show equal transmission for opposite twists at the selected parameter point?", "remaining_uncertainty": "Wider parameter sweeps and an independent derivation of covariance are still required.", "role": "main_result", "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-v1", "scope": "numerical_instance", "scope_summary": "This corroborates one finite numerical instance, not all energies or ribbon geometries.", "statement": { "latex": "|T(E,\\tau)-T(E,-\\tau)|<10^{-7}\n\\quad\\text{at}\\quad E=1,\\ \\tau=0.08,\\ W=8,\\ L=24.\n", "natural_language": "At the declared parameter point, total transmission agrees under twist\nreversal within an absolute tolerance of 1e-7.\n" }, "study": "twisted-ribbon", "title": "Reference-point transmission is even under twist reversal", "topic": "QT", "verification": { "assertions": [ "transmission_even_in_tau", "numerical_diagnostics" ], "request": { "check_soc_zero": true, "check_zero_twist": true, "compare_opposite_tau": true, "energy": 1.0, "hopping": 1.0, "length": 24, "numerical_tolerance": 1e-09, "onsite": 0.0, "soc": 0.1, "symmetry_tolerance": 1e-07, "tau": 0.08, "width": 8 }, "verifier": "kwant_transport" } }, "revision": { "git_commit": "fee03849e888e7dfba2a63c4381148a0a35d6cd0", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0005.yaml", "sha256": "42d60e58a7e0ffab7ce0a07881bc09fb6528c7ef92ccf14297650b7a886d3185", "state": "committed" }, "role": "main_result", "statement_text": "At the declared parameter point, total transmission agrees under twist\nreversal within an absolute tolerance of 1e-7.\n", "title": "Reference-point transmission is even under twist reversal" }, "dependency_closure": { "edges": [ { "from": "GS-QT-0001", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QT-0002" }, { "from": "GS-QT-0001", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QT-0003" }, { "from": "GS-QT-0002", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QT-0003" }, { "from": "GS-QT-0002", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QT-0004" }, { "from": "GS-QT-0003", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QT-0004" }, { "from": "GS-QT-0004", "relation": "depends_on", "to": "GS-QT-0005" } ], "nodes": [ { "conditions": [ "The mathematical object is the finite coherent two-terminal model." ], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QT-0001", "conditional": false, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QT-0001", "kind": "definition", "limitations": [], "revision": { "git_commit": "8608c1a0ba09355c7a8f44ebebe9ef6b2a9c238d", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0001.yaml", "sha256": "ff22aa05dc1042c1883933faee4a683e61d5968b1b0d66033803afc22e315b64", "state": "committed" }, "role": "definition", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "\\mathcal S_\\tau=\\mathcal S[H(\\tau)],\\qquad\nT(E,\\tau)=\\operatorname{Tr}[t_\\tau^\\dagger(E)t_\\tau(E)].\n", "natural_language": "Define the twist reversal operation, scattering representation, and total\ntransmission functional for the declared helicoidal-ribbon model.\n" }, "status": "declared", "title": "Helicoidal transport model and transmission observable" }, { "conditions": [ "The leads and boundary conditions preserve the declared transformation." ], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QT-0002", "conditional": false, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QT-0002", "kind": "assumption", "limitations": [ "This physical covariance is declared as an assumption, not proved by Lean." ], "revision": { "git_commit": "c5f4dc95e03552daa71ee4f3f34125f05bfbe665", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0002.yaml", "sha256": "2311677e04ad6930a90a2e8cbf6ad96ebfda7ec5cd6379564d907fa838bfbe08", "state": "committed" }, "role": "assumption", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "\\mathcal S_{-\\tau}=\\Phi(\\mathcal S_\\tau),\\qquad\n\\mathcal T(\\Phi(\\mathcal S))=\\mathcal T(\\mathcal S).\n", "natural_language": "Assume that reversing the twist transforms the scattering representation\nby a map that preserves total transmission.\n" }, "status": "declared", "title": "Scattering covariance under twist reversal" }, { "conditions": [], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QT-0003", "conditional": true, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [ "GS-QT-0002 is an explicit assumption" ], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QT-0003", "kind": "lemma", "limitations": [], "revision": { "git_commit": "21e63002398900c6a3d702253b949ad55fec745b", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0003.yaml", "sha256": "736f64bc62081e61315358f3fdfbb01c9dd93bba543f52fc1e9a6d171fc44fa1", "state": "committed" }, "role": "supporting_result", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "\\left[\\mathcal S_{-\\tau}=\\Phi(\\mathcal S_\\tau)\\ \\land\\\n\\mathcal T\\circ\\Phi=\\mathcal T\\right]\n\\Longrightarrow T(E,-\\tau)=T(E,\\tau).\n", "natural_language": "If scattering is covariant under twist reversal and transmission is\ninvariant under that covariance map, total transmission is even in twist.\n" }, "status": "conditional_proven", "title": "Scattering covariance implies even transmission" }, { "conditions": [], "dependency_report": { "claim_id": "GS-QT-0004", "conditional": true, "missing_locks": [], "ready": true, "reasons": [ "GS-QT-0002 is an explicit assumption", "GS-QT-0003 is not independently established" ], "stale": false }, "id": "GS-QT-0004", "kind": "corollary", "limitations": [ "The conclusion remains conditional until covariance is independently established." ], "revision": { "git_commit": "a53f0dfeb3f3961454d04b79ded98d4a88e0dc3a", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0004.yaml", "sha256": "a17170a95ec7ff312f8b7391a263e3776d10964eedcc58d9f097eacee5e23cae", "state": "committed" }, "role": "supporting_result", "scope": "general", "statement": { "latex": "T(E,-\\tau)=T(E,\\tau).\n", "natural_language": "Under the declared scattering-covariance assumption, the model's total\ntransmission is even under reversal of the twist.\n" }, "status": "conditional", "title": "Even transmission for the declared helicoidal model" } ] }, "evidence": [ { "artifact_result": { "claims": { "polarization_x_odd_in_tau": { "absolute": 8.751679936302992e-16, "passes": true }, "transmission_even_in_tau": { "absolute": 2.9753977059954195e-14, "passes": true, "relative": 7.714880805053685e-15 }, "zero_soc_polarization": { "absolute": 7.216449660063518e-16, "passes": true }, "zero_twist_polarization": { "absolute": 7.861834433321209e-16, "passes": true } }, "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:22.231614+00:00", "diagnostics": { "minus_tau": { "hermitian": true, "lead_modes_matched": true, "spin_decomposition_consistent": true, "unitary": true }, "plus_tau": { "hermitian": true, "lead_modes_matched": true, "spin_decomposition_consistent": true, "unitary": true }, "zero_soc": { "hermitian": true, "lead_modes_matched": true, "spin_decomposition_consistent": true, "unitary": true }, "zero_tau": { "hermitian": true, "lead_modes_matched": true, "spin_decomposition_consistent": true, "unitary": true } }, "model": "effective-square-lattice-helicoidal-ribbon-v1", "request": { "check_soc_zero": true, "check_zero_twist": true, "compare_opposite_tau": true, "energy": 1.0, "hopping": 1.0, "length": 24, "numerical_tolerance": 1e-09, "onsite": 0.0, "soc": 0.1, "symmetry_tolerance": 1e-07, "tau": 0.08, "width": 8 }, "runs": { "minus_tau": { "energy": 1.0, "hamiltonian_dimension": 384, "hermiticity_residual": 0.0, "lead_block_nmodes": [ [ 2, 2 ], [ 2, 2 ] ], "polarization_x": -0.00565597053416505, "soc": 0.1, "spin_transmission_minus_x": 1.9392564469614837, "spin_transmission_plus_x": 1.9174430681449133, "tau": -0.08, "transmission": 3.8566995151063965, "transmission_decomposition_residual": 4.440892098500626e-16, "unitarity_residual": 1.2273990548217754e-14 }, "plus_tau": { "energy": 1.0, "hamiltonian_dimension": 384, "hermiticity_residual": 0.0, "lead_block_nmodes": [ [ 2, 2 ], [ 2, 2 ] ], "polarization_x": 0.0056559705341641744, "soc": 0.1, "spin_transmission_minus_x": 1.9174430681448995, "spin_transmission_plus_x": 1.9392564469614664, "tau": 0.08, "transmission": 3.8566995151063668, "transmission_decomposition_residual": 8.881784197001252e-16, "unitarity_residual": 7.423480306417935e-15 }, "zero_soc": { "energy": 1.0, "hamiltonian_dimension": 384, "hermiticity_residual": 0.0, "lead_block_nmodes": [ [ 2, 2 ], [ 2, 2 ] ], "polarization_x": 7.216449660063518e-16, "soc": 0.0, "spin_transmission_minus_x": 1.9999999999999984, "spin_transmission_plus_x": 2.0000000000000013, "tau": 0.08, "transmission": 4.0, "transmission_decomposition_residual": 0.0, "unitarity_residual": 1.2561403792849421e-14 }, "zero_tau": { "energy": 1.0, "hamiltonian_dimension": 384, "hermiticity_residual": 0.0, "lead_block_nmodes": [ [ 2, 2 ], [ 2, 2 ] ], "polarization_x": -7.861834433321209e-16, "soc": 0.1, "spin_transmission_minus_x": 1.9770350643451615, "spin_transmission_plus_x": 1.9770350643451584, "tau": 0.0, "transmission": 3.9540701286903195, "transmission_decomposition_residual": 4.440892098500626e-16, "unitarity_residual": 8.598322022528056e-15 } }, "schema_version": "kwant-transport-v1" }, "assertions": [ { "assertion": "transmission_even_in_tau", "detail": { "absolute": 2.9753977059954195e-14, "passes": true, "relative": 7.714880805053685e-15 }, "outcome": "satisfied", "supports_claim": true }, { "assertion": "numerical_diagnostics", "detail": { "minus_tau": { "hermitian": true, "lead_modes_matched": true, "spin_decomposition_consistent": true, "unitary": true }, "plus_tau": { "hermitian": true, "lead_modes_matched": true, "spin_decomposition_consistent": true, "unitary": true }, "zero_soc": { "hermitian": true, "lead_modes_matched": true, "spin_decomposition_consistent": true, "unitary": true }, "zero_tau": { "hermitian": true, "lead_modes_matched": true, "spin_decomposition_consistent": true, "unitary": true } }, "outcome": "satisfied", "supports_claim": true } ], "authenticated": false, "classification": "corroborating", "id": "EV-000002", "record": { "artifact": { "path": "artifacts/EV-000002.kwant.json", "sha256": "a6cf1259cd912b4eed85055038dcaa88ee9d385de874bd340b3895fee23ead56" }, "attestor": { "email": "jnapoles@uach.mx", "name": "Jos\u00e9 Manuel N\u00e1poles Duarte" }, "authentication": { "authenticated": false, "method": "none" }, "claim": { "git_commit": "fee03849e888e7dfba2a63c4381148a0a35d6cd0", "id": "GS-QT-0005", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0005.yaml", "sha256": "42d60e58a7e0ffab7ce0a07881bc09fb6528c7ef92ccf14297650b7a886d3185" }, "classification": "corroborating", "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:22.276040+00:00", "dependencies": [ { "git_commit": "a53f0dfeb3f3961454d04b79ded98d4a88e0dc3a", "id": "GS-QT-0004", "path": "claims/GS-QT-0004.yaml", "sha256": "a17170a95ec7ff312f8b7391a263e3776d10964eedcc58d9f097eacee5e23cae" } ], "environment": { "implementation": "CPython", "machine": "arm64", "packages": { "gitscience": "0.1.0", "kwant": "1.5.0", "numpy": "2.5.2", "scipy": "1.18.0", "tinyarray": "1.2.5" }, "platform": "macOS-26.5.2-arm64-arm-64bit", "python": "3.12.13", "verifier": { "name": "kwant_transport", "version": "0.1.0" }, "verifier_source_sha256": { "__init__.py": "45fc509738d8d027c9b75886f3aac282312bb2ed5969802c033450bc098fb164", "plugin.py": "471f78e25d204aa43a801b268147203c2804673d3b31a01d7518034905521e9d", "runner.py": "7531e60e00df19cf68386190e2fe49729236be0157ceb07b1221689e491f6cf5", "schema.py": "bf22774f9bd7ac973f0d70eefd6ce2cdc7d24df3a0412920f575b55bf78f1e8b", "twist_sweep.py": "4980d4a590547c579153219d30645685dbc13e9e5c8163c08cec5941e4bbbfe4", "twisted_nanoribbon.py": "a961540d9a5d2c81272935443aadce775ca020c7eb5ddd1293ba616772e6a127" } }, "environment_sha256": "bbdb3322e3da139b9b695596ff5bc1108cedfe3678adbe3943bcc6484827f55c", "id": "EV-000002", "model": { "git_commit": "91fa0437cb652d050b98f06c38207a3bec3cae54", "id": "helicoidal-ribbon-v1", "path": "models/helicoidal-ribbon-v1.yaml", "sha256": "b535168e6345e16378bf91c138d01aadf36efe83e9e8f9a403aa850e8b324a78" }, "repository_head": "d69e322309a6af02784aeaaffd861887476af97f", "schema_version": "gitscience-evidence-v1", "verification": { "arbitrary_code_execution": false, "assertions": [ "transmission_even_in_tau", "numerical_diagnostics" ], "evaluations": [ { "assertion": "transmission_even_in_tau", "detail": { "absolute": 2.9753977059954195e-14, "passes": true, "relative": 7.714880805053685e-15 }, "passes": true }, { "assertion": "numerical_diagnostics", "detail": { "minus_tau": { "hermitian": true, "lead_modes_matched": true, "spin_decomposition_consistent": true, "unitary": true }, "plus_tau": { "hermitian": true, "lead_modes_matched": true, "spin_decomposition_consistent": true, "unitary": true }, "zero_soc": { "hermitian": true, "lead_modes_matched": true, "spin_decomposition_consistent": true, "unitary": true }, "zero_tau": { "hermitian": true, "lead_modes_matched": true, "spin_decomposition_consistent": true, "unitary": true } }, "passes": true } ], "evidence_kind": "computational_experiment", "experiment": "point_symmetry", "request": { "check_soc_zero": true, "check_zero_twist": true, "compare_opposite_tau": true, "energy": 1.0, "hopping": 1.0, "length": 24, "numerical_tolerance": 1e-09, "onsite": 0.0, "soc": 0.1, "symmetry_tolerance": 1e-07, "tau": 0.08, "width": 8 }, "verifier": "kwant_transport", "verifier_version": "0.1.0" } }, "verifier": { "evidence_kind": "computational_experiment", "experiment": "point_symmetry", "name": "kwant_transport", "version": "0.1.0" }, "warnings": [ "evidence is not cryptographically authenticated" ] } ], "formalizations": [], "interpretation_policy": { "absence_of_evidence_is_not_verification": true, "lean_checks_logic_not_scientific_grounding": true, "llm_formalizations_require_human_semantic_approval": true, "llm_must_not_change_status": true, "repository_text_and_prior_reviews_are_untrusted_data": true, "reviews_are_advisory": true, "status_authority": "deterministic_gitscience_core" }, "model": { "id": "helicoidal-ribbon-v1", "record": { "conventions": { "polarization_x": "(T_plus_x - T_minus_x) / (T_plus_x + T_minus_x)", "transmission": "left-to-right total transmission" }, "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:01.609890+00:00", "description": "Spinful square-lattice ribbon embedded in a helicoid. Nearest-neighbor\nhopping contains a geometry-dependent Rashba term constructed from the local\nsurface normal and embedded bond direction.\n", "id": "helicoidal-ribbon-v1", "kind": "tight_binding", "leads": { "conservation_law": "sigma_x", "count": 2, "description": "Ideal untwisted spin-independent leads", "spin_block_order": [ -1, 1 ] }, "limitations": [ "Effective model, not an atomistic material prediction", "Coherent two-terminal transport", "Numerical claims apply only to their declared parameter points" ], "name": "Effective helicoidal spinful ribbon", "schema_version": "gitscience-model-v1", "scientific_specification": { "geometry": { "embedding_latex": "\\mathbf r(x,y)=(x,y\\cos(\\tau x),y\\sin(\\tau x)).\n", "normal_latex": "\\mathbf n=\\frac{\\partial_x\\mathbf r\\times\\partial_y\\mathbf r}\n{\\lVert\\partial_x\\mathbf r\\times\\partial_y\\mathbf r\\rVert}.\n" }, "hamiltonian": { "hopping_latex": "-tI_2+i\\lambda\\boldsymbol{\\sigma}\\cdot\n(\\bar{\\mathbf n}_{ij}\\times\\hat{\\mathbf d}_{ij})\n", "latex": "H = \\sum_i c_i^\\dagger (4t+V)I_2 c_i\n+ \\sum_{\\langle i,j\\rangle}\n\\left[c_i^\\dagger\\left(-tI_2+i\\lambda\n\\boldsymbol{\\sigma}\\cdot\n(\\bar{\\mathbf n}_{ij}\\times\\hat{\\mathbf d}_{ij})\\right)c_j\n+ \\mathrm{h.c.}\\right].\n", "onsite_latex": "(4t+V)I_2" }, "hilbert_space": { "internal_degree": "spin-1/2", "lattice": "square", "orbitals_per_site": 2 }, "implementation_mapping": { "hopping_term": "gitscience_kwant.twisted_nanoribbon:scattering_hopping", "model_builder": "gitscience_kwant.twisted_nanoribbon:build_system", "transmission": "kwant.smatrix.transmission" }, "observables": { "polarization_x_latex": "P_x=\\frac{T_{+x}-T_{-x}}{T_{+x}+T_{-x}}.\n", "transmission_latex": "T(E,\\tau)=\\operatorname{Tr}[t^\\dagger(E,\\tau)t(E,\\tau)].\n" }, "parameters": { "V": { "request_key": "onsite", "units": "model_energy_unit" }, "lambda": { "request_key": "soc", "units": "model_energy_unit" }, "t": { "request_key": "hopping", "units": "model_energy_unit" }, "tau": { "request_key": "tau", "units": "inverse_lattice_spacing" } } } }, "revision": { "git_commit": "91fa0437cb652d050b98f06c38207a3bec3cae54", "path": "models/helicoidal-ribbon-v1.yaml", "sha256": "b535168e6345e16378bf91c138d01aadf36efe83e9e8f9a403aa850e8b324a78", "state": "committed" } }, "narrative": { "claim_question": "Does the Kwant model show equal transmission for opposite twists at the selected parameter point?", "plain_language_conclusion": "Yes. The two transmissions agree within 1e-7 at the declared energy, geometry, and couplings.", "remaining_uncertainty": "Wider parameter sweeps and an independent derivation of covariance are still required.", "research_question": "Does reversing the sign of a ribbon's twist leave its total two-terminal\ntransmission unchanged, and what is actually established by formal and\nnumerical checks?\n", "scope_summary": "This corroborates one finite numerical instance, not all energies or ribbon geometries." }, "obligations": [ { "message": "GS-QT-0004 is not independently established", "source": "dependency_graph", "source_claim": "GS-QT-0005", "type": "unresolved_dependency" }, { "message": "GS-QT-0002 is an explicit assumption", "source": "dependency_graph", "source_claim": "GS-QT-0003", "type": "unresolved_assumption" }, { "message": "GS-QT-0003 is not independently established", "source": "dependency_graph", "source_claim": "GS-QT-0004", "type": "unresolved_dependency" }, { "message": "At least one current evidence record is not cryptographically authenticated.", "source": "provenance", "type": "unauthenticated_evidence" } ], "reviews": [], "schema_version": "gitscience-claim-state-v1", "scope_boundary": { "conditions": [ "energy=1.0, hopping=1.0, onsite=0.0, SOC=0.1" ], "limitations": [], "not_established": [ "GS-QT-0004 is not independently established", "GS-QT-0002 is an explicit assumption", "GS-QT-0003 is not independently established", "At least one current evidence record is not cryptographically authenticated." ], "scope": "numerical_instance" }, "status": { "derived": "conditional_corroborated", "dimensions": { "computational": "corroborated", "dependencies": "conditional", "formalization": "not_requested", "logical": "not_applicable", "provenance": "unauthenticated", "review": "unreviewed", "revision": "committed", "scientific_grounding": "unassessed" }, "reasons": [ "GS-QT-0004 is not independently established", "EV-000002 is corroborating" ] }, "study": { "id": "twisted-ribbon", "record": { "approach_summary": "Separate the model definition, a physical covariance assumption, the formal\nimplication checked by Lean, the model-level corollary, and a finite Kwant\ncalculation at one declared parameter point.\n", "article_path": "articles/twisted-ribbon.yaml", "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:01.696689+00:00", "equation_directory": "equations/twisted-ribbon", "id": "twisted-ribbon", "name": "Twisted ribbon transport", "research_question": "Does reversing the sign of a ribbon's twist leave its total two-terminal\ntransmission unchanged, and what is actually established by formal and\nnumerical checks?\n", "resolution_summary": "Lean establishes that the declared covariance implies even transmission,\nand Kwant corroborates even transmission at the reference point. The\ncovariance itself and generality across energies and geometries remain open.\n", "schema_version": "gitscience-study-v1" }, "revision": { "git_commit": "91fa0437cb652d050b98f06c38207a3bec3cae54", "path": "studies/twisted-ribbon.yaml", "sha256": "dab8bf0d83004a462e52fc0da5487dda8a2c7760311a5012602c19d7b390abee", "state": "committed" } } } ], "interpretation_policy": { "claim_status_remains_conditional_on_scope_and_dependencies": true, "coverage_must_be_disclosed": true, "registry_is_not_a_truth_ranking": true }, "registry": { "manifest_path": "registry.yaml", "name": "GitScience Public Registry", "public_url": "https://github.com/napoles-uach/gitscience-registry" }, "schema_version": "gitscience-observatory-v1", "sources": [ { "git_commit": "b9b1ba86d4b734bac9a1ee90185e284b10d78dfc", "public_url": "https://github.com/napoles-uach/gitscience-registry/tree/b9b1ba86d4b734bac9a1ee90185e284b10d78dfc/studies/twisted-ribbon", "repository_name": "twisted-ribbon-study" }, { "git_commit": "b9b1ba86d4b734bac9a1ee90185e284b10d78dfc", "public_url": "https://github.com/napoles-uach/gitscience-registry/tree/b9b1ba86d4b734bac9a1ee90185e284b10d78dfc/studies/quantum-fmm", "repository_name": "quantum-fmm-study" } ], "studies": [ { "approach_summary": "Decompose the argument into a restricted-call assumption, a Lean-checked\naccumulation lemma, an occupancy-tail lemma, a combined conditional bound,\nand a finite independent-occupancy diagnostic for two box regimes.\n", "article": { "schema_version": "gitscience-article-v1", "sections": [ { "blocks": [ { "text": "A fixed-capacity implementation is meaningful only after specifying\nthe subspace on which no leaf box exceeds that capacity.\n", "type": "prose" }, { "ref": "EQ-QF-0001", "type": "equation" }, { "ref": "GS-QF-0001", "type": "claim" } ], "id": "capacity-model", "title": "Capacity-limited model" }, { "blocks": [ { "text": "The analysis requires a bound for each approximate call on the good\nsubspace. This is retained as an assumption rather than silently\npromoted to a verified theorem.\n", "type": "prose" }, { "ref": "EQ-QF-0002", "type": "equation" }, { "ref": "GS-QF-0002", "type": "claim" } ], "id": "local-premise", "title": "Local approximation premise" }, { "blocks": [ { "text": "The hybrid argument adds declared local errors; this abstract\ninduction is the component checked by Lean.\n", "type": "prose" }, { "ref": "EQ-QF-0003", "type": "equation" }, { "ref": "GS-QF-0003", "type": "claim" }, { "text": "Occupancy overflow can be bounded through local factorial moments,\nsubject to the stated reduced-density normalization.\n", "type": "prose" }, { "ref": "EQ-QF-0004", "type": "equation" }, { "ref": "GS-QF-0004", "type": "claim" }, { "ref": "EQ-QF-0005", "type": "equation" }, { "ref": "GS-QF-0005", "type": "claim" } ], "id": "accumulated-error", "title": "From local to global error" }, { "blocks": [ { "text": "For independent uniform placement, the verifier compares internally\nconsistent box-scaling regimes against one declared tail budget.\n", "type": "prose" }, { "ref": "EQ-QF-0006", "type": "equation" }, { "ref": "GS-QF-0006", "type": "claim" }, { "ref": "GS-QF-0007", "type": "claim" }, { "text": "The calculation does not establish an asymptotic theorem, correlated\nfermionic occupancy control, or stability throughout kinetic evolution.\n", "type": "prose" }, { "ref": "GS-QF-0008", "type": "claim" }, { "ref": "GS-QF-0009", "type": "claim" } ], "id": "finite-diagnostic", "title": "Finite occupancy diagnostic" } ], "source": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "articles/quantum-fmm.yaml", "sha256": "ca08d8d950cc787e4bd7e7024608860b24474da62965cd2a73fcd2526d7f8cf4", "state": "committed" }, "study": "quantum-fmm", "title": "Occupancy obligations in a non-adaptive quantum FMM" }, "claim_index": [ { "id": "GS-QF-0001", "kind": "definition", "role": "definition", "shown": true, "status": "declared", "title": "Quantum-FMM occupancy subspace and error observables" }, { "id": "GS-QF-0002", "kind": "assumption", "role": "assumption", "shown": true, "status": "declared", "title": "Restricted non-adaptive FMM call has controlled error" }, { "id": "GS-QF-0003", "kind": "lemma", "role": "supporting_result", "shown": true, "status": "conditional_proven", "title": "Local hybrid error bounds accumulate additively" }, { "id": "GS-QF-0004", "kind": "lemma", "role": "supporting_result", "shown": true, "status": "proposed", "title": "Box overflow is bounded by local factorial moments" }, { "id": "GS-QF-0005", "kind": "corollary", "role": "supporting_result", "shown": true, "status": "conditional", "title": "Conditional quantum-FMM error bound from occupancy tails" }, { "id": "GS-QF-0006", "kind": "assumption", "role": "assumption", "shown": true, "status": "declared", "title": "Independent uniform occupancy model for a finite diagnostic" }, { "id": "GS-QF-0007", "kind": "numerical_proposition", "role": "main_result", "shown": true, "status": "conditional_corroborated", "title": "Constant-mean and proportional-mean box regimes must not be conflated" }, { "id": "GS-QF-0008", "kind": "conjecture", "role": "open_question", "shown": true, "status": "conditional", "title": "Kinetic evolution admits a useful occupancy-tail bound" }, { "id": "GS-QF-0009", "kind": "conjecture", "role": "limitation", "shown": true, "status": "proposed", "title": "Generic spin sectors require coincident-position handling" } ], "coverage": { "is_complete": true, "shown": 9, "total": 9 }, "equations": [ { "claim_ids": [ "GS-QF-0001" ], "correspondence": [], "depends_on": [], "id": "EQ-QF-0001", "latex": "\\Pi_c=\\prod_{b=1}^{B}\\mathbf 1[N_b\\le c],\\qquad\np_k=\\langle\\Psi_{k-1}|(I-\\Pi_c)|\\Psi_{k-1}\\rangle\n", "plain_language": "Pi_c selects configurations with at most c particles in every leaf box;\np_k measures overflow immediately before call k.\n", "role": "definition", "schema_version": "gitscience-equation-v1", "source": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "equations/quantum-fmm/01-good-subspace.yaml", "sha256": "1f734271a8605d845aef77a443a7704a4b5dd3b6b3d0eec5a2cfe25adeae4b10", "state": "committed" }, "study": "quantum-fmm" }, { "claim_ids": [ "GS-QF-0002" ], "correspondence": [ { "status": "open", "target": "restricted non-adaptive FMM error analysis", "type": "human_obligation" } ], "depends_on": [ "EQ-QF-0001" ], "id": "EQ-QF-0002", "latex": "\\left\\|(U_k-\\widetilde U_k)\\Pi_c\\right\\|\\le\\varepsilon_{g,k}\n", "plain_language": "The approximate FMM call is assumed accurate on the capacity-limited\nsubspace. The present verifier does not derive this analytic bound.\n", "role": "assumption", "schema_version": "gitscience-equation-v1", "source": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "equations/quantum-fmm/02-restricted-error.yaml", "sha256": "2403eff46e0837debdb034a826e9f29a26a34b17a4e8a764541d72dd30a5f54e", "state": "committed" }, "study": "quantum-fmm" }, { "claim_ids": [ "GS-QF-0003" ], "correspondence": [ { "status": "proved", "target": "fmm_error_accumulation", "type": "lean" } ], "depends_on": [ "EQ-QF-0002" ], "id": "EQ-QF-0003", "latex": "d_0=0,\\quad d_{k+1}\\le d_k+e_k\n\\quad\\Longrightarrow\\quad d_R\\le\\sum_{k=1}^{R}e_k\n", "plain_language": "Local replacement bounds add across calls. Lean proves this induction from\nsupplied e_k values, without deriving those values physically.\n", "role": "derived_result", "schema_version": "gitscience-equation-v1", "source": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "equations/quantum-fmm/03-accumulation.yaml", "sha256": "4944648f017be8ea7eed955a2aab6a77ba0f586e53daf21fab30a86cfd963745", "state": "committed" }, "study": "quantum-fmm" }, { "claim_ids": [ "GS-QF-0004" ], "correspondence": [ { "status": "declared_not_formalized", "target": "continuum reduced-density derivation", "type": "human_obligation" } ], "depends_on": [ "EQ-QF-0001" ], "id": "EQ-QF-0004", "latex": "p_k\\le\\frac{1}{(c+1)!}\\sum_b\n\\int_{b^{c+1}}\\rho_{c+1}^{(k)}(r_1,\\ldots,r_{c+1})\n\\,dr_1\\cdots dr_{c+1}\n", "plain_language": "A union bound relates overflow to local factorial moments, provided the\nreduced density uses the stated normalization.\n", "role": "derived_result", "schema_version": "gitscience-equation-v1", "source": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "equations/quantum-fmm/04-tail-bound.yaml", "sha256": "f48adcfca5bca143f675d057984d50762a3a859c220f07b7d87e3e5f8f4db304", "state": "committed" }, "study": "quantum-fmm" }, { "claim_ids": [ "GS-QF-0005" ], "correspondence": [], "depends_on": [ "EQ-QF-0002", "EQ-QF-0003", "EQ-QF-0004" ], "id": "EQ-QF-0005", "latex": "\\|\\Psi_R-\\widetilde\\Psi_R\\|\\le\n\\sum_{k=1}^{R}\\left[\\varepsilon_{g,k}+2\\sqrt{p_k}\\right]\n", "plain_language": "The final error is conditionally bounded by good-subspace approximation\nerrors and overflow probabilities at every ideal intermediate state.\n", "role": "derived_result", "schema_version": "gitscience-equation-v1", "source": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "equations/quantum-fmm/05-combined-bound.yaml", "sha256": "ca5c4f07d3cf627e96ff57766f0b398ce74703fab61569ef7c5082fbba66dab8", "state": "committed" }, "study": "quantum-fmm" }, { "claim_ids": [ "GS-QF-0006", "GS-QF-0007" ], "correspondence": [ { "status": "executable", "target": "independent_occupancy_regimes", "type": "fmm_occupancy" } ], "depends_on": [ "EQ-QF-0005" ], "id": "EQ-QF-0006", "latex": "p_{\\mathrm{target}}=\n\\left(\\frac{0.01}{2\\cdot20}\\right)^2=6.25\\times10^{-8}\n", "plain_language": "The numerical diagnostic translates the selected accumulated tail budget\ninto a sufficient per-call overflow target for 20 calls.\n", "role": "numerical_result", "schema_version": "gitscience-equation-v1", "source": { "git_commit": "1f1095a1770f540c83298d8086894e7558fe8802", "path": "equations/quantum-fmm/06-finite-budget.yaml", "sha256": "5616bf29144baa8448199d4c46d51fb50e6d484eea02571e4badf5fac31dcd6d", "state": "committed" }, "study": "quantum-fmm" } ], "headline_claim_ids": [ "GS-QF-0007" ], "id": "quantum-fmm", "name": "Quantum-FMM occupancy", "record": { "approach_summary": "Decompose the argument into a restricted-call assumption, a Lean-checked\naccumulation lemma, an occupancy-tail lemma, a combined conditional bound,\nand a finite independent-occupancy diagnostic for two box regimes.\n", "article_path": "articles/quantum-fmm.yaml", "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:02.179369+00:00", "equation_directory": "equations/quantum-fmm", "id": "quantum-fmm", "name": "Quantum-FMM occupancy", "research_question": "When can a capacity-limited non-adaptive quantum fast multipole method meet a\ndeclared error budget, and which occupancy assumptions are needed?\n", "resolution_summary": "The abstract local errors accumulate additively, and two internally\nconsistent finite occupancy regimes meet the selected tail budget. This does\nnot establish the local analytic bound, dynamic occupancy control, or a\ngeneral fermionic occupancy theorem.\n", "schema_version": "gitscience-study-v1" }, "research_question": "When can a capacity-limited non-adaptive quantum fast multipole method meet a\ndeclared error budget, and which occupancy assumptions are needed?\n", "resolution_summary": "The abstract local errors accumulate additively, and two internally\nconsistent finite occupancy regimes meet the selected tail budget. This does\nnot establish the local analytic bound, dynamic occupancy control, or a\ngeneral fermionic occupancy theorem.\n" }, { "approach_summary": "Separate the model definition, a physical covariance assumption, the formal\nimplication checked by Lean, the model-level corollary, and a finite Kwant\ncalculation at one declared parameter point.\n", "article": { "schema_version": "gitscience-article-v1", "sections": [ { "blocks": [ { "text": "We represent the ribbon as a square lattice embedded in a helicoid.\nThe sign of tau distinguishes the two handednesses being compared.\n", "type": "prose" }, { "ref": "EQ-QT-0001", "type": "equation" }, { "text": "Electrons carry spin one-half. The effective nearest-neighbor model\nincludes a geometry-dependent Rashba term.\n", "type": "prose" }, { "ref": "EQ-QT-0002", "type": "equation" }, { "ref": "GS-QT-0001", "type": "claim" } ], "id": "physical-model", "title": "Physical model" }, { "blocks": [ { "text": "The question concerns total transmission rather than an individual\nspin channel, so the observable sums over all propagating channels.\n", "type": "prose" }, { "ref": "EQ-QT-0003", "type": "equation" } ], "id": "observable", "title": "Observable" }, { "blocks": [ { "text": "A reversal symmetry is useful only after stating the transformation\nand the quantity it preserves. In this study that physical step is an\nexplicit assumption.\n", "type": "prose" }, { "ref": "EQ-QT-0004", "type": "equation" }, { "ref": "GS-QT-0002", "type": "claim" }, { "text": "From that premise, the desired evenness is a short abstract\nimplication. This is the part represented and checked in Lean.\n", "type": "prose" }, { "ref": "EQ-QT-0005", "type": "equation" }, { "ref": "GS-QT-0003", "type": "claim" }, { "ref": "GS-QT-0004", "type": "claim" } ], "id": "conditional-argument", "title": "Conditional symmetry argument" }, { "blocks": [ { "text": "The computational check evaluates opposite twists independently at\none declared point and audits Hermiticity, unitarity, lead modes, and\nspin decomposition before comparing transmission.\n", "type": "prose" }, { "ref": "EQ-QT-0006", "type": "equation" }, { "ref": "GS-QT-0005", "type": "claim" }, { "text": "Thus the current result is conditional at the model level and\ncorroborated at one finite point. A general physical covariance proof\nand broader parameter study remain open obligations.\n", "type": "prose" } ], "id": "numerical-instance", "title": "Numerical instance" } ], "source": { "git_commit": "91fa0437cb652d050b98f06c38207a3bec3cae54", "path": "articles/twisted-ribbon.yaml", "sha256": "f74a3b2ce0ef2547cec473f35ba8c77220d7cf95eb54f25431745f1533f7f504", "state": "committed" }, "study": "twisted-ribbon", "title": "Twist reversal and transmission in a helicoidal ribbon" }, "claim_index": [ { "id": "GS-QT-0001", "kind": "definition", "role": "definition", "shown": true, "status": "declared", "title": "Helicoidal transport model and transmission observable" }, { "id": "GS-QT-0002", "kind": "assumption", "role": "assumption", "shown": true, "status": "declared", "title": "Scattering covariance under twist reversal" }, { "id": "GS-QT-0003", "kind": "lemma", "role": "supporting_result", "shown": true, "status": "conditional_proven", "title": "Scattering covariance implies even transmission" }, { "id": "GS-QT-0004", "kind": "corollary", "role": "supporting_result", "shown": true, "status": "conditional", "title": "Even transmission for the declared helicoidal model" }, { "id": "GS-QT-0005", "kind": "numerical_proposition", "role": "main_result", "shown": true, "status": "conditional_corroborated", "title": "Reference-point transmission is even under twist reversal" } ], "coverage": { "is_complete": true, "shown": 5, "total": 5 }, "equations": [ { "claim_ids": [ "GS-QT-0001" ], "correspondence": [ { "status": "checked_by_source_mapping", "target": "gitscience_kwant.twisted_nanoribbon:site_position", "type": "kwant" } ], "depends_on": [], "id": "EQ-QT-0001", "latex": "\\mathbf r(x,y;\\tau)=\n\\bigl(x,y\\cos(\\tau x),y\\sin(\\tau x)\\bigr)\n", "plain_language": "The parameter tau twists each transverse section as the longitudinal\ncoordinate x increases; changing its sign reverses the handedness.\n", "role": "definition", "schema_version": "gitscience-equation-v1", "source": { "git_commit": "91fa0437cb652d050b98f06c38207a3bec3cae54", "path": "equations/twisted-ribbon/01-embedding.yaml", "sha256": "46ebfde4a44b59e4238244382855f60c55bae249e394dfd24c654d7b14ee6371", "state": "committed" }, "study": "twisted-ribbon" }, { "claim_ids": [ "GS-QT-0001" ], "correspondence": [ { "status": "checked_by_source_mapping", "target": "gitscience_kwant.twisted_nanoribbon:scattering_hopping", "type": "kwant" } ], "depends_on": [ "EQ-QT-0001" ], "id": "EQ-QT-0002", "latex": "\\begin{aligned}\nh_{ij}(\\tau)&=-tI_2+h^{\\mathrm{SO}}_{ij}(\\tau),\\\\\nh^{\\mathrm{SO}}_{ij}(\\tau)&=i\\lambda\\boldsymbol\\sigma\\!\\cdot\\!\n(\\bar{\\mathbf n}_{ij}\\times\\hat{\\mathbf d}_{ij}),\\\\\nH_0&=\\sum_i c_i^\\dagger(4t+V)I_2c_i,\\\\\nH(\\tau)&=H_0+\\sum_{\\langle i,j\\rangle}\n\\left[c_i^\\dagger h_{ij}(\\tau)c_j+\\mathrm{h.c.}\\right].\n\\end{aligned}\n", "plain_language": "This is the effective spinful tight-binding Hamiltonian used by the Kwant\nmodel. Twist enters through the local normals and embedded bond directions.\n", "role": "definition", "schema_version": "gitscience-equation-v1", "source": { "git_commit": "83835f904b2921d4f3f8a35f895f99bb48eb8fa5", "path": "equations/twisted-ribbon/02-hamiltonian.yaml", "sha256": "637e1eb13c209cb14c4fa3b2f7c3a4db18336987366a416ee0d087defafc9dac", "state": "committed" }, "study": "twisted-ribbon" }, { "claim_ids": [ "GS-QT-0001" ], "correspondence": [ { "status": "executed", "target": "kwant.smatrix.transmission", "type": "kwant" } ], "depends_on": [ "EQ-QT-0002" ], "id": "EQ-QT-0003", "latex": "T(E,\\tau)=\\operatorname{Tr}\\!\\left[\nt^\\dagger(E,\\tau)t(E,\\tau)\\right]\n", "plain_language": "Total two-terminal transmission is the trace over all propagating spin and\norbital channels of the transmission block of the scattering matrix.\n", "role": "definition", "schema_version": "gitscience-equation-v1", "source": { "git_commit": "91fa0437cb652d050b98f06c38207a3bec3cae54", "path": "equations/twisted-ribbon/03-transmission.yaml", "sha256": "3e28245932c95ba2c8b32f13367e7a0d7069ff5b582f2149fc898e93713084e2", "state": "committed" }, "study": "twisted-ribbon" }, { "claim_ids": [ "GS-QT-0002" ], "correspondence": [ { "status": "open", "target": "model-specific covariance derivation", "type": "human_obligation" } ], "depends_on": [ "EQ-QT-0002", "EQ-QT-0003" ], "id": "EQ-QT-0004", "latex": "\\mathcal S_{-\\tau}=\\Phi(\\mathcal S_\\tau),\\qquad\n\\mathcal T\\!\\left(\\Phi(\\mathcal S)\\right)=\\mathcal T(\\mathcal S)\n", "plain_language": "The argument assumes a transformation relating opposite twists that leaves\ntotal transmission unchanged. This physical covariance is not proved here.\n", "role": "assumption", "schema_version": "gitscience-equation-v1", "source": { "git_commit": "91fa0437cb652d050b98f06c38207a3bec3cae54", "path": "equations/twisted-ribbon/04-covariance.yaml", "sha256": "f6c71f639b6e724e8ad61671a611b25a5568f58651ab147ec4df15744dc3d97d", "state": "committed" }, "study": "twisted-ribbon" }, { "claim_ids": [ "GS-QT-0003", "GS-QT-0004" ], "correspondence": [ { "status": "proved", "target": "twist_transport_symmetry", "type": "lean" } ], "depends_on": [ "EQ-QT-0004" ], "id": "EQ-QT-0005", "latex": "\\begin{gathered}\n\\mathcal S_{-\\tau}=\\Phi(\\mathcal S_\\tau),\\qquad\n\\mathcal T\\circ\\Phi=\\mathcal T,\\\\\n\\Longrightarrow\\quad T(E,-\\tau)=T(E,\\tau).\n\\end{gathered}\n", "plain_language": "Given the covariance premise, even transmission follows. Lean checks this\nimplication, but does not establish the premise for the physical ribbon.\n", "role": "derived_result", "schema_version": "gitscience-equation-v1", "source": { "git_commit": "83835f904b2921d4f3f8a35f895f99bb48eb8fa5", "path": "equations/twisted-ribbon/05-evenness.yaml", "sha256": "38b07edf805070c204ed9bf5cc9d5e996d7aa1e888ac38351714306023772bab", "state": "committed" }, "study": "twisted-ribbon" }, { "claim_ids": [ "GS-QT-0005" ], "correspondence": [ { "status": "executable", "target": "point_symmetry.transmission_even_in_tau", "type": "kwant" } ], "depends_on": [ "EQ-QT-0002", "EQ-QT-0003" ], "id": "EQ-QT-0006", "latex": "\\begin{aligned}\nT_+&=T(1,0.08),\\qquad T_-=T(1,-0.08),\\\\\n\\left|T_+-T_-\\right|&<10^{-7},\\\\\nW&=8,\\quad L=24,\\\\\nt&=1,\\quad\\lambda=0.1,\\quad V=0.\n\\end{aligned}\n", "plain_language": "Kwant tests the equality at one explicit finite parameter point. Passing it\ncorroborates this instance and is not a proof over all energies or geometries.\n", "role": "numerical_result", "schema_version": "gitscience-equation-v1", "source": { "git_commit": "e355f5a08741e99621d61d4a7f35fd69aaff6fcf", "path": "equations/twisted-ribbon/06-reference-test.yaml", "sha256": "259c08813975fe9e6328c85bb5dbe2cbd7f4e73b7cb4cca75113dbabed18b928", "state": "committed" }, "study": "twisted-ribbon" } ], "headline_claim_ids": [ "GS-QT-0005" ], "id": "twisted-ribbon", "name": "Twisted ribbon transport", "record": { "approach_summary": "Separate the model definition, a physical covariance assumption, the formal\nimplication checked by Lean, the model-level corollary, and a finite Kwant\ncalculation at one declared parameter point.\n", "article_path": "articles/twisted-ribbon.yaml", "created_at": "2026-08-16T22:17:01.696689+00:00", "equation_directory": "equations/twisted-ribbon", "id": "twisted-ribbon", "name": "Twisted ribbon transport", "research_question": "Does reversing the sign of a ribbon's twist leave its total two-terminal\ntransmission unchanged, and what is actually established by formal and\nnumerical checks?\n", "resolution_summary": "Lean establishes that the declared covariance implies even transmission,\nand Kwant corroborates even transmission at the reference point. The\ncovariance itself and generality across energies and geometries remain open.\n", "schema_version": "gitscience-study-v1" }, "research_question": "Does reversing the sign of a ribbon's twist leave its total two-terminal\ntransmission unchanged, and what is actually established by formal and\nnumerical checks?\n", "resolution_summary": "Lean establishes that the declared covariance implies even transmission,\nand Kwant corroborates even transmission at the reference point. The\ncovariance itself and generality across energies and geometries remain open.\n" } ] }