discourse_id
stringlengths 12
12
| essay_id
stringlengths 12
12
| discourse_text
stringlengths 4
4.1k
| discourse_type
stringclasses 7
values | discourse_effectiveness
stringclasses 3
values |
---|---|---|---|---|
1f6df629e365
|
6C3E863C67FC
|
If there is a tie in the in the electoral vote "the election would be thrown to the House of Representatives" (paragraph 12). This is an unfair method also becasue now there's only one vote per state and some states have a higher population than others which can and will cause contreversy in the public. "The pressure, which would greatly complicate the presidential election process, may be redcued" (patagraph 22) but it still doesn't reduced the fact that swing voters can cause catastrophe within the electoral voting process. This is because they are the most targeted voting areas due to their reputations as the "most thoughtful voters".
|
Evidence
|
Effective
|
4052c7f866e4
|
6C3E863C67FC
|
All in all, the Electoral college has both its good things and their downfalls. As can be seen the bad out ways the good in this situation. A voters vote isn't necessarily direct because they aren't voting on a single representative, they are voting on a group of individuals in which they believe will vote for the candidate in which they choose. Also, being that the number of electors is based on a state's number of congressional represenatives it is an unequal and unfair number of electors per state. The electoral college can even cause an uproar if a tie ever falls in place because the "tie breaker" is left in the hands of the House of Representatives. Basically "the electoral colleg is unfair, and irrational" (paragraph 14) and it should be abolished because there is a great amount of mix ups and failures within the system itself.
|
Concluding Statement
|
Effective
|
c4ce39f83858
|
6C50FC009033
|
Under the electoral college system, voters vote not for the president, but for a slate of electors, who in turn elect the president.
|
Lead
|
Adequate
|
d7705c093461
|
6C50FC009033
|
we should get rid of the Electoral College for many reasons.
|
Position
|
Adequate
|
4d8a34b5d66d
|
6C50FC009033
|
One reason is that small states do not get any attention from the upcoming presidents
|
Claim
|
Adequate
|
a1e8253b4eb0
|
6C50FC009033
|
because their electoral votes for the small states are to small like Alaska only has 3 electoral votes unlike California which has 55 electoral votes so the upcoming presidents can just not even think about the small states and go for bigger states like Florida, Texas, and California.
|
Evidence
|
Adequate
|
de17b125f1e0
|
6C50FC009033
|
People say "The electoral college is unfair, outdated, and irrational" and Bob Dole said "Abolish the electoral college."
|
Claim
|
Adequate
|
f33ca00e3334
|
6C50FC009033
|
Many things can go wrong in the electoral college like their can be a tie in the sytem where is would be thrown to the House of Representatives, where state delegations vote on the president.
|
Evidence
|
Adequate
|
9c51eda38ee0
|
6C50FC009033
|
Another reason is what some people call the disaster factor,
|
Claim
|
Adequate
|
3f034c73dc9b
|
6C50FC009033
|
consider that state legislatures are technically responsible for picking electors, and that those electors could always defy the will of the people. who would vote for some one to not listen to them and do what they want? then the electoral college is useless in the sense of voting for who you want.
|
Evidence
|
Adequate
|
3c926634af86
|
6C50FC009033
|
people say that the electoral college avoids run-off elections
|
Counterclaim
|
Adequate
|
16d8740e4c18
|
6C50FC009033
|
however the electoral college is unfair to voters, because of the winner-take-all system in each state.
|
Rebuttal
|
Ineffective
|
9b42f768e065
|
6C5A6D1D0C13
|
I was meaning to ask you can you please leave the electoral college.
|
Position
|
Adequate
|
722cd9f98575
|
6C5A6D1D0C13
|
In way many people were grateful for this kind art education in many ways people use this place for so long to know how many scarefices that many people choose this area than no other. There got to be a diffrent reason to come in mind for can stop this idea from elimanating this fine place to construct for all years of hard work
|
Evidence
|
Ineffective
|
d22f2fccbc8b
|
6C5A6D1D0C13
|
For so long many people still would like to choose this college as great example for their success.
|
Claim
|
Ineffective
|
3742eea24996
|
6C5A6D1D0C13
|
This my letter to you senator. But if you refuse this than i don't know what i would do,but what I do know is you choose what it came from your mind I can not stop you from picking the good or bad choices but I can help you pick the right choice. As well making a election area that only happens in four years is not really worth anything many would disagree for this nonsense build and just forget what just came in mind and pick the right choice
|
Concluding Statement
|
Ineffective
|
483a6062b268
|
6C60C14AE38A
|
I believe that the Electoral College should stay in process
|
Position
|
Adequate
|
cebd733bc2c7
|
6C60C14AE38A
|
because it consists of 538 electors and the majority (270) that are the electoral votes that are required to elect a president.
|
Claim
|
Ineffective
|
2334eb4eb8af
|
6C60C14AE38A
|
Elector groups are picked by the runner; the groups help raise votes for the runners to get more word out on what the runner has to offer for our country. Plus, they make sure the elector running, has good legitiment reasons for becomeing our countries representor. With the presidential election held every four years, the Electorial College can be still processing men, and women, who are wanting to represent our country.
|
Evidence
|
Ineffective
|
2478e8724be5
|
6C60C14AE38A
|
Furthermore, the state elector running for president, is assisted by our votes, because when you vote for your candidates, you are actually voting for your candidate's electors.
|
Claim
|
Adequate
|
db9cc33d2721
|
6C60C14AE38A
|
Once the presidential election is over, the staes governers start a "Certificate of Ascertainment" witch list all of the canidates who ran for president in your state along with the names of their respective electors.
|
Evidence
|
Adequate
|
fac6af864eb0
|
6C991A1A6C39
|
Some school offer distance learning as an opinion for students to attend classes from home by way of online or video conferencing. the students not focus in home sometime, for the TV, video games, and cell phones. The 20% the students, not go to school because is more difficult, but 80% the students go to school students don't benefit because have a distraction in home the TVs, are distraction or watching movies the students not focus in work in study some not doing a work or copies in internet .
|
Lead
|
Ineffective
|
78269b639ccc
|
6C991A1A6C39
|
Students don't have a friends because not work in groups sometime
|
Claim
|
Ineffective
|
7e4d92fb77cf
|
6C991A1A6C39
|
not distraction with other students and more distraction in home sometime not focus some students said 5% the students not focus in house because the cell phones distract the students not benefit being able to attend classes from home.
The some students story and online because in the morning not necessary take a shower or not wake up late, but some students is more fanny story in school because distract
|
Evidence
|
Ineffective
|
89f6e74a8e19
|
6C991A1A6C39
|
The video conferencing you need to pay for a classes, in work some students have a job, and pay school.
|
Claim
|
Ineffective
|
7786d23d167a
|
6C991A1A6C39
|
The students said is more easy go to school for have more friends and you understand more because the teacher explain you went you have a question the teacher explain you or went you have a work and you need help she explain you.
The peoples said is more easy went you story is school because not pay for you education is more fanny one time in here in school the students talking about the school pay but in online some people said is a bad idea some people said is a god idea about this topic.
The students, went you go to school has a library, old the material paper, or notebook, doing homework, and has a lunch, break fast in the morning, and the after noon so you have old the classes for example art, geographic, and music etc. Some students, and some people said is more easy story and the home because some people dont doing a bulling for a skin color.
The video conferencing you need to pay for a classes, in work some students have a job, and pay school.
some school offer distance learning as an opinion for students to attend classes from home by way of online or video conferencing. the students not focus in home sometime, for the TV, video games, and cell phones.
|
Evidence
|
Adequate
|
1de6bb9bdee6
|
6C991A1A6C39
|
The students is not a god idea to attend classes from home by way of online or video conferencing because some students copies a test in home or use a internet for a project or something like that
|
Position
|
Adequate
|
2f9b372101f2
|
6C991A1A6C39
|
Connected to, served by, or available through a system and especially a computer or telecommunications system as the internet also done while connected to a system, online shopping.
|
Concluding Statement
|
Ineffective
|
73bb943ad587
|
6C9A5A8FA2F9
|
I would agree with keeping the Electoral College because its a fair way to elect the president of the united states.
|
Position
|
Adequate
|
8e3024e38b30
|
6C9A5A8FA2F9
|
The Electoral College consists of 538 electors the majority only 270 votes is required for the final dessision. Each candidate running for the president has his or her own group of electors but the state law varys how many are selected. The presidential election is held every four yearson the tuesday after the first monday of november.
The states are called districts for example the word state also refers to the disrict of Columbia.
|
Evidence
|
Ineffective
|
aa946512dc8a
|
6C9A5A8FA2F9
|
You can help choose your states electors when you vote forpresident. Even though your voting for your candidate your really voting for the candidates electors.
|
Claim
|
Ineffective
|
5e26104b155b
|
6C9A5A8FA2F9
|
Most states have a winner takes all system that awards all electors to the winning presidential candidate.
|
Evidence
|
Adequate
|
981382132a03
|
6C9A5A8FA2F9
|
After the presidential election your govenor prepares a certificate of ascertainment listing all of your candidates who ran for president in your state. The Certificate of Ascertainment also declares the winning presidential candidate in your state at the meeting of the electors in December. Then the certificate is sent to the congress and the national records of the presidential election.
|
Evidence
|
Ineffective
|
5787ed23bac6
|
6CA3EC0D0FC8
|
In the article "Driverless Cars Are Coming", the author presents both positive and negative aspects of driverless cars. How do i feel about driverless cars?
|
Lead
|
Adequate
|
ad48180bb108
|
6CA3EC0D0FC8
|
I am against driverless cars for many reasons.
|
Position
|
Adequate
|
46616569f93a
|
6CA3EC0D0FC8
|
First, safety will always be a huge concern, especially if the driver is not the one driving the car.
|
Claim
|
Adequate
|
0d7a775154c4
|
6CA3EC0D0FC8
|
In addition, the production of driverless cars would cost alot so it might come out of the tax payers money.
|
Claim
|
Adequate
|
cbf8d62f8a2d
|
6CA3EC0D0FC8
|
Finaly, I believe that the driverless cars will never be completely driverless
|
Claim
|
Adequate
|
a8239c81b234
|
6CA3EC0D0FC8
|
For a driverless car to be a good idea and be suitable for everybody, it needs to be completely safe for everybody. In the article, the author tells us that most driving laws focus on keeping the drivers, the passengers, and the pedestrians safe. We all know that safety is the most important way, but what is the best way to keep the drivers, the passengers, and the pedestrians safe? The author tells us that lawmakers already know that safety is best achieved with alert drivers. How are the drivers going be alert when they are in a drivetless car. What if there is a system malfunction? What if the driver falls asleep while the car is driving itself? The outcomes don't look good.
|
Evidence
|
Adequate
|
98a415757049
|
6CA3EC0D0FC8
|
The author asks us a very good question. He asked, "If the technology fails and someone is injured, who is at fault- the driver or the manufacturer?" There will people suing the companies because they expected the driverless car to be a safe car and be able to drive itself because it's a driveless car.
|
Evidence
|
Adequate
|
4254bc4904dc
|
6CA3EC0D0FC8
|
This would affect the buyers and manufacturers in a negative way.
|
Claim
|
Adequate
|
5d99ab880c8f
|
6CA3EC0D0FC8
|
The production of driveless cars and the cost to buy driverless cars would cost alot. This would also affect the buyers and the manufacturers in a negative way.
|
Evidence
|
Ineffective
|
68730785cef7
|
6CA3EC0D0FC8
|
Finally, even if there was to be a driverless cars, it would not be completely driverless. This would cause concern for the manufacturers and the buyers.
|
Evidence
|
Ineffective
|
452833d9ce9a
|
6CA3EC0D0FC8
|
It is true that driverless cars can benefit people, but it can also bring danger and concerns. I am against the development of driverless cars. First, safety will always be a concern. Driverless would not be completely safe because safety is best achieved with alert drivers. The drivers would not be completely alert if they were in a driveless car. In addition, the production and the cost to buy driverless cars would be high. This would cause problems for the manufacturers and the buyers. Finally, even if there was to be a driverless car, it would not be completeyly driverless and unfortunately, it would not be completely safe.
|
Concluding Statement
|
Adequate
|
955023ecad94
|
6CAE55B3180D
|
I have an idea concerning community service.
You probably are considering to make everyone to do community service and I'm on the same track
|
Lead
|
Adequate
|
a62a7bfe99a5
|
6CAE55B3180D
|
In my sight community service is essential.
|
Position
|
Adequate
|
772415af0e9e
|
6CAE55B3180D
|
Others may not have the time to do something they need done and we can help.
|
Claim
|
Adequate
|
4899e0e2d861
|
6CAE55B3180D
|
It is also much wiser to help someone in need rather than students at home playing video games or watching television.
|
Claim
|
Adequate
|
b884bee8f68b
|
6CAE55B3180D
|
Service helps you feel good inside and have better self esteem and may also help you physically.
|
Evidence
|
Adequate
|
836355e953bf
|
6CAE55B3180D
|
Some single parents don't have time to work, do household jobs, and take care of their kids everyday.
We may not be able to help with their work but we certainly are able to help them with household things.
They would appreciate it and it will help them to feel more relaxed.
|
Evidence
|
Adequate
|
6393d072ce4d
|
6CAE55B3180D
|
That is much more rewarding.
|
Evidence
|
Ineffective
|
995a2af08646
|
6CAE55B3180D
|
Community service may also help you physically.
|
Claim
|
Adequate
|
cab71f40bf9b
|
6CAE55B3180D
|
Hard work of cleaning or moving things is a way to be active.
The constant effort that you don't realize may be helping your strength and cardio.
Since we have an overweight problem in America it would actually help if we did more service.
|
Evidence
|
Adequate
|
6ffc56176be4
|
6CAE55B3180D
|
Many people now days don't have very high self esteem.
|
Claim
|
Adequate
|
99198432ceba
|
6CAE55B3180D
|
When you do service for someone else they will probably thank you over and over and say how wonderful you are.
It might actually make you think twice about yourself and try harder because you know someone cares.
|
Evidence
|
Effective
|
c115c82ec8b2
|
6CAE55B3180D
|
I think community service is very important for students to do because it helps other people, it helps you to become physically active, and it may raise your self esteem.
Even though people grumble about doing service it is really important that they do it.
In the end they will be glad they had the chance to do service for some other than themselves.
|
Concluding Statement
|
Adequate
|
5d03eb27be86
|
6CE2817B7E7A
|
The idea of these "Driveless Cars" does sound intersting and at the most fascinating. But however i'm going to say i'm all that for that particular idea for a few reasons
|
Lead
|
Ineffective
|
6c8f6ea3f5bc
|
6CE2817B7E7A
|
I don't see how it would be called "Driveless Cars" if there is still human assitance requried
|
Claim
|
Adequate
|
4bb8313acd06
|
6CE2817B7E7A
|
To me this isn't all the way driveless driving its more like the car assistaing you most of the time. And this could also cause problems betweem the drivers and the companys responible for these cars .
|
Evidence
|
Adequate
|
4ab69357c303
|
6CE2817B7E7A
|
The way I may see it is why spend thousands of dollars creating something the requries human skills you might as well not even make it
|
Claim
|
Adequate
|
7e0ceaa7aba5
|
6CE2817B7E7A
|
this creation is something not everyone can afford
|
Claim
|
Adequate
|
275762dad237
|
6CE2817B7E7A
|
If one driver has this creation but the may not this would most likely lead the driveless car driver to accidently hit the car or drive that has a driveless car there are also still chances of acidents
|
Evidence
|
Adequate
|
0accbba90bea
|
6CE2817B7E7A
|
So if not everyone can afford a driveless car why even bring it out for people.
|
Evidence
|
Adequate
|
eb97db899d81
|
6CE2817B7E7A
|
manufactures want to use camera to watch the driver can be uncomfortable to the drivers.
|
Claim
|
Adequate
|
9414e30294ee
|
6CE2817B7E7A
|
having to change laws here and there if this vehical is realsed nto everyone may follow or agree with them
|
Claim
|
Adequate
|
a1a6b9637e77
|
6CE2817B7E7A
|
There's people now that can't even follow the simple rules of driving.
|
Evidence
|
Adequate
|
210e921c8742
|
6CE2817B7E7A
|
this could also lack people's precaution or alterness in any type of car or anywhere else
|
Claim
|
Adequate
|
bcdbce3904cf
|
6CE2817B7E7A
|
if its times for the driver to do his or hers part what if they are on there cellphone like most days now and when they are alterted they look up and its to late. Its relly important that a person is alert at all times and take their own responibility.
|
Evidence
|
Adequate
|
23933c79701b
|
6CE2817B7E7A
|
While the details and positive benefits these "Driveless Cars" may sound great but the neagatives can also affect people. And the negatives can also put someone in the chance of danger .
|
Position
|
Adequate
|
f360051baf64
|
6D70F7B79D16
|
Electoral College is a great thing and some people might think its not, but there is some wrong things about it like voters vote not for the president, but for slate of electors who in turn elect the president
|
Lead
|
Ineffective
|
a837267047f9
|
6D70F7B79D16
|
I'm not going to keep it because its not a good idea and people want to vote for who they want and not vote just so someone can pick who they want like their choice didn't matter.
|
Position
|
Adequate
|
4a54b3c8a2b7
|
6D70F7B79D16
|
My argument against the electoral college is we might call the disaster factor.
|
Claim
|
Adequate
|
b33d4a885b1c
|
6D70F7B79D16
|
The american people consider themselves lucky that the 2000 fiasco was the biggest election crisis in a century; the system allows for mech worse. Consider that state legislatures are technically responsible for picking electors, and that those electors could always defy the will of the people. Back in 1960 segregationists in the Louisiana legislature nearly succeded in replacing the Democratic electors with new elecotrs who would oppose John F. Kennedy. ''So that a popular vote for Kennedy would not have actually gone to Kennedy.'' In the same vein, faithless electors have occasionally refused tovote for their party's candidate and cast a deciding vote for whomever they please.
Perhaps most worrying is the prospect of a tie in the electoral vote. In that case, the election would be thrown to the House of Representatives, where state delegations vote on the president. The Senate would choose the vice-president. Because each state casts only one vote, the single representative from Wyoming, representing 500,000 voters,would have as much say as the 55 representatives from California, who represent 35 million voters. Given that many voters vote one party for preident and another party for Congress, the House's selection can hardly be expected to reflect the will of the people.
|
Evidence
|
Adequate
|
c0a0ea965c57
|
6D757AA2C340
|
We should definitely strive in keeping the electoral college for so many reasons.
|
Lead
|
Adequate
|
1f0146c8db5f
|
6D757AA2C340
|
We need to keep the electoral college because it serves so many purposes in the united states.
|
Position
|
Adequate
|
d5e6f69efe13
|
6D757AA2C340
|
It hepls us decide who our president and vice presidents will be
|
Claim
|
Ineffective
|
7ffdfc2709e7
|
6D757AA2C340
|
it is a big help on our state workers.
|
Claim
|
Adequate
|
0bb6ca102531
|
6D757AA2C340
|
And most of the reason that people want to stop it is because they think that some of the nominees arent getting what they deserve.
|
Counterclaim
|
Ineffective
|
bbe4af0d516d
|
6D757AA2C340
|
We do understand that they put a lot of work in trying to become president but not everyone can win.
|
Rebuttal
|
Adequate
|
05ade120b3e7
|
6D757AA2C340
|
And to be fair, after the presidential election is over, our govenor prepares a "Certificate of Ascertainment" listing all of the candiates who ran for president in our state along with the names of their respective electors.
|
Evidence
|
Ineffective
|
7e22b06b2fdf
|
6D757AA2C340
|
The presidential election is held every four years on the Tuesday after the first Monday in November. You help choose your states electors when you vote for president because when you vote for your candidate you are usually voting for your candidates electors.
Each candidate running for president in your state has his or her own group of electors. The electors are generally chosen by the candidates political party, but state laws vary on how the elecotrs are selected and what their responsibilities are.
The advocates of this position are correct in arguing that the Electoral College method is not democratic in a modern sense...it is the electors who elect the president, not the people. So when you vote for your president your acually voting for the slate of electors.
|
Evidence
|
Ineffective
|
d088bd8a5f8e
|
6D757AA2C340
|
Having this Electoral College is so much help to our state workers.
|
Claim
|
Adequate
|
3ab060a402c5
|
6D757AA2C340
|
They dont actually have to do everything now...thanks to the Electoral College.
|
Evidence
|
Ineffective
|
7b35368c0955
|
6E5F2ED42575
|
Have you ever dreamed about exploring space? I know I have when wierd shapes or forms appear on things and places in our solar system people believe it aliens or a foriegn species that we know nothing about. Like in 1976 a global surveyor named the Viking snapped a photo of a landform that look likes a face on the planet called Cydonia. Humans always argue among each other over the fact whether it was made by aleins or just a natural landform
|
Lead
|
Adequate
|
edfe791c8909
|
6E5F2ED42575
|
It's and natural landform beacause it could of been caused from a piece of another planet branching of and crashing, or regular elements acting apon the planet itself.
|
Position
|
Adequate
|
dc38122d772a
|
6E5F2ED42575
|
Our solar system is huge there is alot of planets, and more uknown things humans do not know about. Many things can be floating around in outer space from other planet bigger or smaller. The peice of that planet or object broke off of could had of entered Cydonia atmosphere, and caused that landform to exist.
Many things have difrent ways of cleansing, and many other different ways of doing things. We do not know if the planet Cyndia caused the unsual lamdform itself from amy kid of element storms and much more.
|
Evidence
|
Ineffective
|
67062bf38bca
|
6E5F2ED42575
|
The planet Cyndia is very rare with the landform it has own it there could be many more planets and unknown things that have rare landforms about them in the big solar system,
|
Concluding Statement
|
Ineffective
|
2526943a8637
|
6E919842050C
|
In all honesty, if it were up to me, I would keep the Electoral College
|
Position
|
Adequate
|
d7f454b52f41
|
6E919842050C
|
Because imagaine what a catastrophe it would be if we did not have the Electoral College, how would they count the votes
|
Claim
|
Ineffective
|
8b065d280d03
|
6E919842050C
|
Anybodyvoted on who you wanted to win it go can cheat the number of votes to change the president they are voting for. With the Electoral College you can't do that because, once you voted who you want to win, it get sent out tothe electors. Who from that point on count how many voted for both of them and decide a winner.
|
Evidence
|
Ineffective
|
df9a3e53d5d1
|
6E919842050C
|
Now it is possible for somebody to secretly change the names that way but it is a higher stake, or risk to take not having the Electoral College.
|
Claim
|
Ineffective
|
cb9ec6950c83
|
6E919842050C
|
Also, it is possible for worker of the Electoral College to make a mistake in countung the counting the votes and to cause a big confussion in the votes but that is very highly impossible, if not impossible.
|
Evidence
|
Ineffective
|
110f40974ae3
|
6E919842050C
|
If you lived in Texas, for instance, and wanted to vote for John Kerry, you'd vote for a slate of 34 Democratic electors pledged to Kerry. On the off-chance that those electors won the statewide election, they would go to Congress and Kerry would get 34 electoral votes. Who are the electors? They can be anyone not holding public office. Who picks the electors in the first place?
|
Evidence
|
Adequate
|
4fcae324edf7
|
6E919842050C
|
The Electoral College is a widely regarded as an anachrosim, a non-democratic method of selecting a president that ought to be overruledbydeclaring the candidate who receives the most popular vote the winner. Not only that, but a disputeover the outcome of an Elecotral College voteis possible-it happened in 2000-
|
Counterclaim
|
Adequate
|
59574818c2e7
|
6E919842050C
|
but it is less likely than a dispute over the popular vote.
|
Rebuttal
|
Adequate
|
5ebea1a56f1b
|
6E919842050C
|
Their are five reasons to retain, or keep the Electoral College. First, it's a certainty of outcome, the winner is everybodys president, it swings states, not only does ig work for little states, but for big ones too, and you can avoid run-off elections.
|
Claim
|
Adequate
|
f06cda74a2ea
|
6E919842050C
|
So those are my reasons why we should keep the Electoral College, we should not overlook the goods that the Electoral College does to our nation just because of two little bad that can be repaired.
|
Concluding Statement
|
Adequate
|
90dc6720b57a
|
6ECD533A72F4
|
Driverless cars are the transportation system of the future. Their benefits greatly outweigh those of the current system.
|
Position
|
Adequate
|
853cea0f52b7
|
6ECD533A72F4
|
Driverless cars are easily possible to develop,
|
Claim
|
Effective
|
98f0a54e3ea7
|
6ECD533A72F4
|
much safer than regular cars,
|
Claim
|
Effective
|
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.