text
stringlengths 0
89.3k
|
---|
GLEU AccuracyZero LLMProfessional Safe |
HelpfulPairwise |
DISCMedLLM 37 MTQA MCQA Accuracy Zero Few LLMProactive |
Professional HelpfulIndividual |
Zhongjing 38 STQA MTQAHuman |
LLMProfessional Safe |
FluentPairwise |
Case Study |
BianQue 39 MTQABLEU ROUGE |
PQAZero Human Case Study |
Alpacare 40 STQA MTQA Accuracy Rouge Zero FewHuman |
LLMProfessional HelpfulPairwise |
Case Study |
QilinMed 41 STQA MTQAF1Score BLEU |
ROUGEZero Few SFT Human Case Study |
Taiyi 42 MTQA NLP F1Score Accuracy Zero Human Case Study |
ChiMedGPT 43STQA MTQA |
MCQA NLPF1Scores Accuracy |
BLEU ROUGEZero Few Human Case Study |
MediTron 44 MCQA Accuracy Zero Few SFT |
HuatuoGPTII 45STQA MTQA |
MCQAAccuracy ZeroHuman |
LLMProfessional Helpful |
Patientfriendly FluentPairwise |
Case Study |
AntGLMMed 46 MCQA Accuracy Few SFT |
GPTdoctor 47 STQAHuman |
LLMProfessional Fluent |
Patientfriendly |
DoctorlikeIndividual |
Pairwise |
BioMistral 48 MCQA Accuracy Zero Few SFT |
MMedLM 49 STQA MCQAAccuracy BLEU |
ROUGE BERTScoreZero SFTHuman |
LLMProfessional Pairwise |
InMDX 9 Human Case Study |
MeLLaMA 50 MCQA NLPAccuracy F1score |
ROUGE BERTScoreZero Few SFT |
JMLR 51 Human Case Study |
BiMediX 52 MCQA Accuracy Zero |
OncoGPT 53 STQA BERTScore Zero Human Case Study |
Apollo 54 MCQA Accuracy Few |
Qibo 55STQA MCQA |
NLPAccuracy Rouge ZeroHuman |
LLMProfessional Safe |
FluentPairwiseJOURNAL OF L ATEX CLASS FILES VOL 14 NO 8 AUGUST 2021 15 |
QA benchmark involves consecutive questions and answers |
such as a dialog between a doctor and a patient This bench |
mark assesses the ability of medical LLMs to perform medical |
diagnosis understand context ensuring answers are based on |
previous dialog and engage in interactive QA testing the |
models ability to interact in realworld medical scenarios and |
maintain fluent dialog The multiplechoice QA benchmark |
presents a question along with multiple options requiring the |
model to identify the correct answer With explicit correct |
answers this benchmark allows precise quantification of the |
medical LLMs capability Additionally some works not only |
evaluate the options outputted by the model but also assess |
reasoning content The varied multiplechoice questions eval |
uate the models depth of knowledge across diverse medical |
domains and its logical reasoning ability The commonly used |
evaluation metrics for natural language generation tasks are |
Accuracy BLEU 130 ROUGE 131 Distinct 132 and |
GLEU 133 In addition to traditional evaluation metrics |
certain studies have introduced evaluation metrics tailored to |
healthcare dialog contexts For instance BianQue 39 pro |
poses a novel evaluation metric named Proactive Questioning |
Ability PAQ to assess the capability of LLMs in proactively |
asking and querying questions to users |
The majority of medical QA benchmarks comprise existing |
medical QA datasets with only a limited number of bench |
marks specifically gathered for particular evaluations Note |
that the vast datasets employed in training LLMs may result |
in overlap between training and test sets Therefore data de |
duplication and data leakage checks are necessary to ensure |
fairness of the test results |
2 Protocols Medical LLMs are commonly assessed |
through three protocols Zeroshot Fewshot and Task |
specific Supervised Finetuning aiming to investigate model |
performance across varying levels of contextual information |
The zeroshot protocol is to evaluate the ability of a model to |
directly perform a medical task with an unknown distribution |
while assessing its generalization ability and adaptability It |
only requires a natural language description of the downstream |
task without providing specific examples to ask the model to |
understand the medical task and use the intrinsic knowledge |
to accomplish this task In the natural language understanding |
task MeLLaMA 50 and Taiyi 42 designed prompt tem |
plates for each downstream task to guide the output format of |
the model to meet the expected requirements For the prompt |
for QA tasks it usually give a role to the LLM and then guide |
the models output style in line with expectations For instance |
a prompt might be You are an experienced doctor please |
respond to the patients inquiries with patience and kindness |
Patient inputs Doctor Moreover addressing |
medical issues often necessitates intricate multistep reasoning |
Hence certain studies have employed prompt strategies to |
enhance model performance For instance MediTron 44 uti |
lizes the prompt strategy Zeroshot ChainofThought 134 to |
guide the model towards a more comprehensive understanding |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.