article
stringlengths 0
745k
| abstract
stringlengths 0
92.7k
|
|---|---|
the pioneering work of weinberg @xcite launched the basis for the effective field theory ( eft ) of nuclear forces starting from the expansion of an effective chiral lagrangian .
it gives a nucleon - nucleon ( nn ) interaction which is , in leading order , the one - pion - exchange potential ( opep ) plus a dirac - delta .
the program of applying effective field methods to the nn system was pursued by many authors with significative results in few - nucleon systems ( see e.g. @xcite ) . in a more general context of few - body systems ,
short range interactions have many applications which are discussed in detail in ref .
@xcite .
more recently , the authors of @xcite and @xcite treat the one - pion - exchange potential ( opep ) plus derivative dirac - delta interactions using dimensional and boundary condition regularizations , respectively .
in particular , when comparing the theoretical approach with the data @xcite , it was shown in ref .
@xcite that the leading order interaction , opep plus a dirac - delta , renormalized using subtracted scattering equations , dominates the results obtained for the @xmath1 phase - shifts and mixing parameter .
however , considering only the leading - order term , the results obtained for the @xmath0 phase shift are not satisfactory .
this is an evidence that higher order terms in the effective interaction are important in this channel ( see e.g. refs .
@xcite ) .
the fit of the @xmath0 phase - shift up to laboratory momentum @xmath2 mev / c requires an effective nn interaction with the addition of a term with second order derivatives of the dirac - delta . in the relative momentum space , we have @xmath3 where the @xmath4 s are unregulated strengths and @xmath5 is a matrix element of the one - pion - exchange potential . the motivation of the second term of ( [ veft ] ) is to simulate effects of heavy particle exchanges by a sum of a dirac - delta interaction and its derivatives , while keeping the ope as the long range part of the interaction . in the renormalization method described in @xcite ,
we include @xmath6 , as the method is based on a kernel - subtraction procedure that generates terms of the type @xmath7 in the scattering matrix elements even when one considers only @xmath8 and @xmath9 in the interaction .
in fact , the method also generates higher - order derivatives terms when ope is considered . in the weinberg counting rule scheme ,
the derivative contact interactions we are considering comes along with the two - pion - exchange ( tpe ) @xcite .
for a recent calculation in the nn system considering tpe see e.g. ref . @xcite . as an exploratory calculation , in the present work
we consider only the contact terms , leaving tpe for a future work . in the scattering equation ,
the effective bare potential ( [ veft ] ) produces integrals that diverge as much as @xmath10 .
therefore it is necessary at least three subtractions in the kernel of the lippman - schwinger ( ls ) equation , since each subtraction introduces a factor of @xmath11 . differently from the recent works
@xcite and @xcite , we implement the method of subtracted scattering equations @xcite to deal with this problem .
the subtraction method has also been shown to be practical in providing renormalization group invariant solutions for three - body scattering equations with contact interactions @xcite , and also proved to be useful in describing the halo structure of weakly bound exotic light nuclei @xcite .
the one - subtracted scattering equation used in our previous work @xcite was generalized in @xcite to allow any order of subtraction , permitting the inclusion of derivatives of the contact interaction in the effective two - body potential .
the driving term of the n - subtracted ls equation is constructed recursively , renormalizing the model at each subtraction order , while keeping renormalization group invariance of the approach ( for details see @xcite ) . in the present work ,
we obtain the @xmath0 nucleon - nucleon amplitude from the effective interaction ( [ veft ] ) , using a three - times subtracted scattering equation , as demanded by the higher divergent term of the type @xmath10 .
we perform an analysis of the physical contribution coming from each order term in the recursive order - by - order renormalization procedure .
it this way we access their significance in the parameterization of the effective interaction to obtain the desired observables .
we should note that the contact interactions that we are considering are obviously meaningless without regularization and renormalization due to the generated ultraviolet divergences in the lippman - schwinger equation .
this work is organized as follows . in section 2 ,
we discuss the subtraction method applied to opep . in section 3 ,
we present the main formulas of the recursive subtraction method to treat the scattering equation , as well as our strategy to solve it . in section 4 ,
we show numerical results for the singlet phase - shift with our conclusion .
the partial wave decomposition of opep for the @xmath0 state is @xcite : @xmath12 where @xmath13 and @xmath14 are the relative momentum .
the regular part of ope has a finite scattering matrix , solution of the partial - wave projected ls equation : @xmath15 where @xmath16 is the second term in the right - hand side of ( [ sing ] ) .
the t - matrix of the one - pion - exchange plus the dirac - delta potential @xcite is obtained here using distorted wave theory @xcite as suggested in @xcite : @xmath17 t_\delta(e ) \left[1+g^{(+)}_0(e)t_{\pi}(e ) \right ] \ , \label{tpivw1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath18^{-1}$ ] is the free green s function with @xmath19 in the two - nucleon rest - frame , and @xmath20 the green s function for the regular part of the pion - exchange interaction is @xmath21 the direct solution of ( [ tpivw2 ] ) is plagued by infinities in the momentum integration . in order to get finite solution within our scheme we reformulate ( [ tpivw2 ] ) in a subtracted fashion , where only one subtraction is enough @xcite .
let us briefly explain the subtraction method @xcite discussing the treatment of potentials where the matrix elements behave as a constant in the ultraviolet momentum region , like in ( [ tpivw2 ] ) , which needs one subtraction to allow finite results for the t - matrix . using the lippmann - schwinger equation @xmath22 = [ 1+t(e)g^{(+)}_0(e)]v \ , \label{rtv1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the potential @xmath23 can be formally written in terms of the t - matrix at a certain energy @xmath24 as @xmath25^{-1}t(-\mu^2 ) \ . \label{rv}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for convenience we use a negative energy for the subtraction such that the green s function is real .
> from ( [ rv ] ) and ( [ rtv1 ] ) we obtain the one - subtracted scattering equation : @xmath26 by introducing a convenient notation , which is useful for more subtractions , the driving term of ( [ rt1v0 ] ) is denoted as @xmath27 .
a subtracted free green function is written as @xmath28 which allows to rewrite the renormalized t - matrix equation ( [ rt1v0 ] ) as @xmath29 for a dirac - delta potential , ( [ rt10 ] ) produces finite results once @xmath30 is given . in this simple case ,
the matrix elements of @xmath30 in the relative momentum representation is just the renormalized coupling constant .
the method of subtracted equations is easily applied to ( [ tpivw2 ] ) , and one should note that the free green s function in ( [ rt10 ] ) is being replaced by the interacting one , @xmath31 .
we obtain the t - matrix for an arbitrary energy @xmath32 in terms of the t - matrix at a given energy scale @xmath24 : @xmath33 the renormalized strength of the interaction defines @xmath34 at the subtraction point , @xmath35 , which is enough to get a finite amplitude for the opep plus a dirac - delta at this energy : @xmath36\lambda_{\mathcal { r}00 } \left[1+\frac{2}{\pi}\int^\infty_0dq'~{q'}^2 \frac{t_{\pi}(q',p;-\mu^2)}{-\mu^2-{q'}^2 } \right ] \ , \label{tpivw3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the t - matrix for the regular part of the one - pion - exchange potential in the @xmath0 channel is given by eq .
( [ tpifinal ] ) .
the scattering t - matrix is not finite for the bare effective potential ( [ veft ] ) , which imply that regularization and renormalization are required to define the scattering amplitude .
the method we use consists in constructing regularized and renormalized scattering equations with propagators subtracted at certain scales , which are convenient for introducing the physical inputs .
our motivation in using the subtracted method was to treat a bare potential that includes a regular part plus the dirac - delta interaction and its derivatives , for which the t - matrix has a definite form for a certain @xmath37 .
that given , no approximations are performed in getting the scattering amplitude .
let us consider point - like interactions that include up to four terms , a contact interaction plus its derivatives .
after partial - wave decomposition to the singlet @xmath38wave state , the bare potential is given by @xmath39 where @xmath40 corresponds to the regular part of opep plus a dirac - delta interaction @xmath41 . in order to calculate the scattering amplitude for the bare potential ( [ vefts ] ) with subtracted equations ,
the strategy is the following .
first one has to define the starting point of the iterative procedure to get the driving term of the subtracted equation . in the present case
, at least three subtractions are required to allow a finite result for the the t - matrix , and two iterations are consequently needed to get the driving term .
the iterative process begins with the t - matrix of ope plus dirac - delta potentials ( [ tpivw3 ] ) , leading to one subtraction in the kernel ( @xmath42 ) , as shown in section 2 .
next , as we show in the following subsection , two iterations are performed and added the amplitude @xmath43 at the subtraction scale ( @xmath44 and @xmath45 are the renormalized strengths of the interaction ) .
a three - fold subtracted t - matrix equation has to be used to define the scattering amplitude of the effective potential ( [ vefts ] ) , which in operator form and for a general number of subtractions @xmath46 reads @xcite : @xmath47 where @xmath48^{-1}v^{(n-1)}(-\mu^2;e)\ ; , \label{vn } \\ g^{(+)}_n(e;-\mu^2)&\equiv&\left[(-\mu^2-e)g_0(-\mu^2)\right]^n g^{(+)}_0(e ) .
\label{gn}\end{aligned}\ ] ] one should note that the form of the above equation with @xmath42 when applied to three - body systems results in the subtracted form used in @xcite , where the boundary condition was taken at the scattering threshold .
the recursive formula to derive the driving term @xmath49 starts from @xmath50 given by ( [ tpivw3 ] ) .
so far , only the opep and the dirac - delta interactions have been introduced in the calculation .
the higher order derivatives of the dirac - delta potential in ( [ vefts ] ) are introduced in the driving term of the three - fold subtracted equation .
the matrix element of @xmath51 for the full effective interaction of ( [ vefts ] ) in the angular momentum basis , @xmath52 get the contribution from the derivatives of the dirac - delta interaction , through the values of @xmath53 - the renormalized strengths of the corresponding terms in the potential .
the integral equations for the matrix elements , @xmath54 , are @xmath55 with @xmath56 .
the explicit form of the three - fold subtracted ls equation is : @xmath57 in the angular momentum basis the scattering amplitude is @xmath58 and the low - energy parameters are defined by the effective range expansion @xmath59 with @xmath60 the scattering length and @xmath61 the effective range .
we observe that in our method the kernel is subtracted at a given scale which allows to perform the momentum integrals up to infinity , in that sense the subtracted equations are automatically regularized . in the cutoff regularization ,
the hilbert space is truncated and intermediate states goes up to a given momentum scale , such that the effective interaction includes the effect of the neglected states @xcite .
our method softens the contribution of the higher momentum intermediate states , with the partially removed physics parameterized through the driving term . of course we could move the subtraction scale , at the expense of a more complicated form for the driving term
this fact also happens in a cut - off regularization when the cut - off is moved @xcite .
the nucleon - nucleon observables are invariant under the change of the arbitrary subtraction point , therefore one can start at any convenient energy scale @xmath62 . however , the form of the driving term and its coefficients in ( [ vrenfinal ] ) which define the scattering amplitude are tied to the prescription used to define the renormalized theory .
the key point of the renormalization group method is to change this prescription without altering the predictions of the theory @xcite .
the invariance of the t - matrix under changes of renormalization prescriptions imposes a definite rule to modify @xmath63 in ( [ tren ] ) , which appears in a form of a non - relativistic callan - symanzik ( nrcs ) equation @xcite : @xmath64 derived from ( [ tren ] ) and @xmath65 .
equation ( [ ss3 ] ) substantiate the invariance of the renormalized t - matrix under dislocation of the subtraction point , with the boundary condition given by ( [ vrenfinal ] ) .
then , we observe that there is a non - trivial dependence on the subtraction point appearing in the driving term of the subtracted scattering equation , although the physical results of the model are kept unchanged .
the solution of ( [ ss3 ] ) implies in a complicated evolution of @xmath63 as @xmath66 changes .
not only the lambda s would change , but also the form of the driving term .
the ultraviolet behavior of the driving term is not changed by the evolution in @xmath66 .
the evolution should not be truncated as @xmath66 is varied to keep the t - matrix invariant . at different
@xmath66 the potential @xmath67 has a complicate form from the solution of nrcs equation .
similarly , the evolution of renormalization group equations as introduced by bogner , kuo and schwenk @xcite for the nn scattering does not truncate on certain operators as the cutoff is varied to keep observables unchanged .
the renormalized strengths @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath45 and the subtracion point @xmath66 are found by fitting some low - energy phase shift data . for each set of @xmath44 , @xmath45 and @xmath66 , we fit the singlet scattering length @xmath70 fm through the value of @xmath68 .
the three parameters left are adjusted to reproduce the nijgemen data @xcite up to the center of mass momentum @xmath13 of about 300 mev / c .
we get an effective range of @xmath71 fm compared with the value of 2.68 fm from ref .
the parameters found are displayed in table [ tab1 ] , where @xmath72 mev / c corresponds to a negative subtraction energy point @xmath73 - 50 mev .
we emphasize that the results for the scattering length shown in the table correspond to the values obtained considering only the parameters found from the best fit of the singlet phase - shift using eq.([vrenfinal ] ) as input for the three - fold subtracted scattering equation ( [ trenfinal ] ) .
of course , from pionless eft , we know that one could adjust the scattering length and the singlet phase - shifts at very low - energies with only contact interactions .
first , we show in figure [ fig1 ] the results of our method for only @xmath74 for the singlet and triplet channels using the one - fold subtracted t - matrix equations as performed in detail in ref .
@xcite , where we have used @xmath75 it is worth to mention that , for @xmath76 , @xmath77 . in the present framework
, we are using directly as input @xmath78 ( see eqs .
( [ tpivw3 ] ) and ( [ vrenfinal ] ) ) .
the large values of @xmath66 in fig . [ fig1 ] arise due to the choice given by eq .
( [ v1pd ] ) .
we observe that the large @xmath66 limit converges . for the singlet channel ,
@xmath40 is not enough to describe the data .
however , the approach works reasonably well in the spin - triplet channel when we consider eq .
( [ v1pd ] ) for the coupled channels with @xmath79 and @xmath80 .
therefore , we will not consider the spin - triplet channel further in the present work where we focus on the huge discrepancy of the singlet channel .
we leave a detailed analysis of the coupled channels for a future work , where we also intend to include the two - pion - exchange interaction .
in figure [ fig2 ] we present the results obtained when we include @xmath84 . in order to evaluate the contributions of the different terms in the effective potential for the parameters of the best fit displayed in table i
, we calculate the @xmath0 phase shifts for the individual contributions of @xmath85 , @xmath41 and @xmath84 , as well as for the combinations @xmath86 , @xmath40 and @xmath87 . below @xmath88 mev / c the different calculations presents results that underestimate the data due to the fact that @xmath89 23.7 fm , especially for @xmath85 and @xmath40 , while for @xmath84 and @xmath86 @xmath90 is better approximated ( see table [ tab1 ] ) . in the last two cases , as the short - range part of the effective interaction is dominated by the higher - order derivatives of the dirac - delta , the calculation is about enough to describe the phase shifts above @xmath91 mev / c .
therefore , the most relevant contribution in this channel comes from @xmath86 , while the regular part of the pion exchange potential appears at low energies as it provides the long range part of the potential .
although our approach is rg invariant , it is not simple to explicitly incorporate rg invariance in the driving term of the three - fold subtracted equations . in order to have an insight of the effects included by the evolution of the driving term through the cs equation , it is important to study how our fit depends on @xmath66 . for this purpose
, we calculate the phase shifts for values of @xmath66 around the best - fit value ( @xmath92 ) keeping the @xmath4 s intact , as shown in fig .
we observe that , at very low momenta the fit is not affected . for higher momenta ,
the phase shifts present a monotonic behaviour : it increases ( decreases ) as @xmath66 gets larger ( smaller ) .
the use of the nrcs equation ( [ ss3 ] ) would cancel this effect in order to keep the t - matrix , and thus the observables , invariant . in conclusion ,
we show in this letter how to apply the subtracted scattering equations @xcite to the nn singlet channel , when more than one subtraction is required to renormalize the corresponding interaction .
the approach consists of a regularization of the integrand of the original scattering equation by using a given subtraction procedure in the propagator at some energy scale with where the t - matrix is known .
the subtraction scale can be moved without modifying the calculated observables once the inhomogeneous term of the subtracted scattering equation runs with the scale according to the non - relativistic callan - symanzik ( nrcs ) equation .
in the present case , the boundary condition is determined by the renormalized coupling constants and by the t - matrix of the ope and dirac - delta potentials at the specified value of the subtraction point . as a final remark ,
the subtracted scattering equation method is recursive and can be easily extended when higher order derivatives of the dirac - delta are present in the two - body effective interaction .
* acknowledgements * + this work was partially supported by fundao de amparo pesquisa do estado de so paulo ( fapesp ) , conselho nacional de desenvolvimento cientfico e tecnolgico ( cnpq ) and fundao de amparo pesquisa do estado do rio de janeiro ( faperj ) . v.s.t thanks to faepex / unicamp for financial support .
m. t. yamashita , t. frederico , a. delfino , and l. tomio , phys .
a * 66 * ( 2002 ) 052702 ; ibidem , phys .
rev . a * 68 * ( 2003 ) 033406 ; f. bringas , m. t. yamashita , and t. frederico , phys .
a * 69 * ( 2004 ) 040702 . | the subtracted kernel approach is shown to be a powerful method to be implemented recursively in scattering equations with regular plus point - like interactions .
the advantages of the method allows one to recursively renormalize the potentials , with higher derivatives of the dirac - delta , improving previous results .
the applicability of the method is verified in the calculation of the @xmath0 nucleon - nucleon phase - shifts , when considering a potential with one - pion - exchange plus a contact interaction and its derivatives .
the @xmath0 renormalization parameters are fitted to the data .
the method can in principle be extended to any derivative order of the contact interaction , to higher partial waves and to coupled channels .
pacs 03.65.ca , 11.10.hi , 05.10.cc , 03.65.nk renormalization , renormalization group , nonrelativistic scattering theory |
the discovery of iron - based superconductors @xcite has triggered great interests in the field of condensed matter physics .
a lot of theoretical and experimental works suggest complicated fermi surfaces and unconventional pairing mechanism@xcite .
there is a common issue between the iron pnictides and the cuprates , that in both systems the superconductivity is in the vicinity of the antiferromagnetic ( af ) order , leading to a very similar phase diagram .
however , the feature of the undoped parent phase is actually quite different .
the cuprate may be categorized as the so - called mott insulator , while the iron pnictide is a poor metal .
the phase diagram has thus been a focus of intense research in order to pursue an understanding of the relationship between the afm and the superconducting ( sc ) states , and intimately the superconducting mechanism@xcite . for the electron
doped 122 family , such as ba(fe@xmath0co@xmath1)@xmath2as@xmath2 , a lot of works both in experiment and theory illustrate the systemic evolution of the transport properties and electronic structure , all indicate the importance of the multiband effect@xcite .
it was presumably believed that in the underdoped regime , the af and the sc phase compete for the density of states along the fermi surfaces . in the overdoped regime superconductivity
suffers from a suppression of the spin fluctuations@xcite , and probably the loss of the fermi surface nesting .
these two effects lead to an asymmetric superconducting dome , which is somewhat different from the case in the cuprate superconductors . by analyzing the transport @xcite and optical data@xcite in ba(fe@xmath0co@xmath1)@xmath2as@xmath2 , it has been consistently claimed that the mobility of the electron band are much higher than that in the hole band .
it is curious to know in a hole - doped sample , would the mobility disparity survive , disappear , or change sign ? in this paper we report the systematic studies on resistivity , hall effect and magnetoresistivity on selected hole doped ba@xmath0k@xmath1fe@xmath2as@xmath2 single crystals .
the detailed investigations and analysis suggest the asymmetric quasiparticle scattering in the hole and electron band , with still a much larger mobility in the electron band .
meanwhile we present the evidence that the electron doping induced by substituting the fe sites with co results in a great impurity scattering , but without breaking too much cooper pairs .
these fe - sites doping may generate the impurities which can only scatter the electrons with small momentum transfer , with the inter - pocket pairing un - intact .
k@xmath1fe@xmath2as@xmath2 ( x=@xmath10 0.39 ) single crystals .
the af / structural transition is shifted to lower temperatures and becomes invisible with further potassium doping .
the resistivity anomaly in normal state can not be explicitly resolved when the doping level is 0.25 with t@xmath6 = 29 k , and beyond . ( b ) temperature dependence of derivative of the resistivity d@xmath7/dt .
the peak in d@xmath7/dt associated with the af / structural transition is suppressed with doping and disappears at x = 0.25 .
inset : zero field cooling magnetization of six superconductive samples . ]
the ba@xmath0k@xmath1fe@xmath2as@xmath2 single crystals were grown by self - flux method using feas as the flux , detailed procedures of synthesizing the samples are similar to the previous reports@xcite .
the crystal structure and chemical composition were checked by x - ray diffraction and energy dispersive x - ray microanalysis . for the transport measurements ,
all the samples were cut into rectangular shape and the standard six electric probes were made by silver paste .
the electronic transport measurements were carried out in a physical properties measurement system ( ppms , quantum design ) with the temperature down to 2 k and magnetic field up to 9 t. the superconducting transition temperature of the samples were determined by the 50% of the normal state resistivity .
the in - plane longitudinal and the hall resistance were measured by either sweeping the magnetic field at a fixed temperature or sweeping the temperature at a fixed magnetic field . both sets of data coincide with each other .
fig.1(a ) shows the temperature dependence of resistivity for ba@xmath0k@xmath1fe@xmath2as@xmath2 single crystals with doping levels ranging from undoped parent phase to optimally doped compounds .
it is clear that the potassium doping makes the system evolve from af ( with a resistivity anomaly ) to superconductive .
the sharp drop of resistivity at about 138 k due to the af / structural transition can be observed in the parent phase . with doping holes ,
the resistivity anomaly is suppressed and shifts to lower temperatures , which is agreeable with the peak in the derivative of the resistivity d@xmath11/dt shown in fig.1(b ) .
when the doping level x reaches 0.25 , the resistivity anomaly disappears and a little pit can be observed in d@xmath11/dt where the superconducting transition temperature is 29 k. with further doping , the t@xmath6 reaches a maximum value at 39 k. for the electron - doped fe - based 122 family , the magnetic and structural transition are slightly separated@xcite leading to two close peaks on the d@xmath11/dt vs. t curves .
the resistivity anomaly exhibits two kinks which are corresponding to the two peaks in d@xmath11/dt for the underdoped samples . while for hole - doped bafe@xmath2as@xmath2
, some experiments show that the af and structure transition occur at the same temperature in underdoped region @xcite . in our measurements
, we observed only one single sharp peak in d@xmath11/dt vs. t curves for underdoped ba@xmath0k@xmath1fe@xmath2as@xmath2 which is agreeable with previous results .
here we would like to emphasize several contrasting issues by comparing the resistivity curves in electron doped ba(fe@xmath0co@xmath3)@xmath4as@xmath4 ( co-122)@xcite and hole doped ba@xmath0k@xmath1fe@xmath2as@xmath2 ( k-122 ) samples ( fig.1 ) .
firstly , in the co-122 samples , the resistivity at 300 k reduces to half value of undoped sample when the system is optimally doped @xcite , this is actually not the case in the k-122 .
one can see from fig.1(a ) that , the resistivity at 300 k drops only about 20 - 30@xmath12 when the doping is getting to the maximum value . what is more interesting is that the resistivity value when the superconductivity sets in is quite close to each other although the t@xmath6 changes from 10 k ( x=0.10 ) to 29 k ( x=0.25 ) . this may suggest the resistivity is mainly dominated by the electron band , which is weakly influenced by the hole doping .
the interest triggered by this observation is two fold : the threshold for the occurrence of the superconductivity is governed by the residual resistivity at t@xmath6 , while the t@xmath6 value is determined by the hole concentration , perhaps by how strong the suppression to the antiferromagnetic phase is .
it is not clear at this moment what leads to this strange behavior , but clearly it indicates a novel mechanism of the superconductivity .
secondly , the resistivity exhibits an up - rising step at the af / structural transition in the electron doped co-122 , while in k-122 , this transition exhibits always as a drop of resistivity at t@xmath13 and it is smeared up gradually with more doping .
thirdly , the rrr , namely the ratio between the room temperature resistivity and the residual resistivity ( just above t@xmath6 ) is about 2.4 in co-122,@xcite indicating a strong impurity scattering .
but it seems such a strong scattering does not block the superconductivity .
based on the picture of pairing through inter - pocket scattering,@xcite the non - magnetic impurities may be detrimental to the supercnductivity if they induce the inter - pocket scattering . in this sense , the impurities here may induce the scattering only with small momentum transfer , for example , intra - pocket scattering . in the optimally hole
doped samples , the rrr can get to 14 , indicating a weak impurity scattering . at high temperatures ,
the @xmath7-t curve shows a bending down feature for the hole doped samples . in the conventional single band metal ,
the bending down of resistivity was interpreted as the approaching to the ioffe - regel limit , which is corresponding to the case that the mean free path induced by the phonon scattering is comparable to the atomic lattice constant .
this seems not the case here , since the electron doped sample co-122 has the same structure and similar phonon spectrum , but the bending down feature of resistivity has not been observed up to 300 k. above mentioned behavior of the resistivity can be qualitatively understood by the two band scenario with asymmetric scattering rate in the hole and the electron pockets .
according to the simple two band model , the conductivity can be written as @xmath14 , with @xmath15 the conductivity , @xmath16 the charge carrier density , @xmath17 the relaxation time , @xmath18 the mass of the @xmath19-th band ( @xmath19 = @xmath20 or @xmath21 for the electron and hole band , respectively ) .
therefore the resistivity can be described as @xmath22 it is known that the parent phase has identical area of electron and hole fermi surfaces in the non - magnetic phase , therefore we can assume an identical charge carrier densities @xmath23 and @xmath24 for the two bands ( @xmath25 ) .
considering m@xmath26@xmath27m@xmath28 as revealed by arpes@xcite and specific heat@xcite , and assuming that @xmath29 , the conductivity is thus dominated by electron band . with the electron doping ,
the term @xmath30 is getting much larger than @xmath31 which reduces the resistivity further .
to the optimally doping at about x = 0.08 , @xmath23 has increased a lot , perhaps doubled , this reduces the resistivity to almost its half . in the case of k-122
, the situation is different .
if still adopting the relation of @xmath32 , doping holes will decrease @xmath23 but increase @xmath24 , in this case the resistivity should increase , instead of decrease . actually doping holes
will on one hand decrease @xmath23 and increase @xmath24 , but more important is to lower down the @xmath33 and @xmath34 , in this case , the resistivity will be determined by a balance between these quantities and shows a weak doping dependence . a quantitative understanding would require a detailed doping dependence of @xmath16 , @xmath17 , @xmath18 ( @xmath19 = @xmath20 , @xmath21 )
this is out of the scheme of what we can get from a simple resistivity measurement and analysis .
some calculations indicate that the conductivity for electrons grows strongly upon electron doping , while the hole conductivity varies weakly compared to that of the electrons@xcite .
thus the resistivity of hole - doped ba@xmath0k@xmath1fe@xmath2as@xmath2 at 300 k changes less than that for electron - doped ba(fe@xmath0co@xmath3)@xmath4as@xmath4 .
the multi - band effect that one band is strongly coupled and relatively clean , while the other band is weakly coupled and characterized by much stronger impurity scattering will cause anomalous t - dependence of the in - plane resistivity : the curve is convex with the tendency to saturate at high temperature@xcite . ) of ba@xmath0k@xmath1fe@xmath2as@xmath2 .
the data sets are offset vertically by 0.25 for clarity .
( b ) the fitting parameter n for six doped superconducting samples ( see text ) . ] k@xmath1fe@xmath2as@xmath2 and ba(fe@xmath0co@xmath3)@xmath4as@xmath4 .
no splitting between the structural and afm transitions has been observed in the hole doped samples .
the curve of t@xmath6 vs. doping in wide hole doping region ( solid line ) was taken from the ref.@xcite .
the data in the electron doped regions were adopted from ref.@xcite . ] in fig.2(a ) we present temperature dependence of the normalized @xmath11 by the room temperature resistivity @xmath7(300k ) .
a quick glance at the data can immediately see that the @xmath11-t curve in the low temperature region changes from a non - linear to a linear behavior towards optimal doping . in order to know precisely the evolution of the resistivity with doping
, we fit the data in the low temperature region by the equation @xmath35 with three fitting parameters @xmath36 , a and n for each curve . due to the saturation in the resistivity at high temperatures and the anomalies of resistivity induced by the af / structure transition
, we fit the data below the af / structure transition ( for x=0.25 and below ) . for the optimally doped sample ,
the fitting was done with the data between 40 and 120 k. the resulted fitting parameters are presented in table i and the exponent n is shown in fig.2(b ) . the evolving from a power law with exponent n = 2.3 to a linear temperature dependence can be easily observed in fig.2(b ) , which may indicate the crossover from a fermi liquid behavior to non - fermi liquid when the quantum critical point is approached .
it was previously pointed out that the exponent n in metals near an afm quantum critical point ( qcp ) may be sensitive to disorder@xcite .
while in k-122 the impurity scattering is quite weak , this can be corroborated by the negligible @xmath36 value at the optimal doping . at the optimal doping ,
the t - linear resistivity in the low temperature region may suggest a quantum critical point .
similar behaviors have been observed in sr@xmath0k@xmath1fe@xmath2as@xmath2@xcite , bafe@xmath2as@xmath37p@xmath1 @xcite , ba(fe@xmath0co@xmath3)@xmath4as@xmath4 @xcite etc .. it has been pointed out that the quantum fluctuation becomes very strong when the neel temperature of the afm order becomes zero .
it is this strong quantum fluctuation that heavily couple to the itinerant electrons and modifies the transport property .
although it was argued that this linear feature may be reconstructed with a residual term and a t@xmath38 term in the optimally doped ba(fe@xmath0co@xmath3)@xmath4as@xmath4 system,@xcite , the systematic evolution shown in our present study can rule out this possibility .
for the cuprate superconductors , the antiferromagnetic order of the magnetic moments of the cu@xmath39 is completely suppressed before superconductivity sets in .
they do not coexist at any point of the t@xmath6(p ) ( p : doped hole number ) phase diagram ( exception was suggested in the bi-2201 system ) .
in contrast , the coexistence of the afm and the superconductivity can be observed in underdoped region of the dome of k-122 @xcite .
fig.3 shows the phase diagram of ba@xmath0k@xmath1fe@xmath2as@xmath2 and ba(fe@xmath0co@xmath3)@xmath4as@xmath4 . although there are some reports claiming that magnetically ordered phases and sc state are probably mesoscopically / microscopically separated @xcite , most of the studies on k or co doped samples are in favor for the coexistence of magnetic order and superconductivity and have consistently ruled out the presence of phase separation@xcite .
the very small residual specific coefficient @xmath40 in the optimally doped ba@xmath41k@xmath42fe@xmath2as@xmath2 also strongly suggest the absence of macroscopic phase separation , since otherwise one should be able to see a large residual term of specific heat .
therefore we argue that the qcp occurs near the optimally doped samples where the afm order vanishes at about zero k. in the specific heat measurements , we also found that the mass enhancement @xmath43 goes up quickly when the optimally doping point is approached.@xcite to confirm the existence of quantum critical point and the coexistence of magnetic order and superconductivity need certainly extra investigations using other local probes .
.[tab : test]fit parameters [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] k@xmath1fe@xmath2as@xmath2 ( x = 0 @xmath44 0.37 ) .
the hall coefficient r@xmath5 changes suddenly from a negative value in the undoped sample to a positive one with slight k - doping .
the af / structure transition can be found in the underdoping dome ( 0.08 @xmath45 x @xmath45 0.25 ) as a onset of the rising of the hall coefficient r@xmath5 .
for the optimal doped sample , r@xmath5 varies less pronounced with the temperature .
( b ) the doping dependence of hall coefficient at different temperatures . ]
k@xmath1fe@xmath2as@xmath2 ( [email protected] ) measured at 9 t. inset : magnetoresistivity of the samples ( x=0.2 , 0.25 , 0.37 ) .
an anomaly at around 80 - 100 k can be easily observed . ]
the hall coefficient r@xmath5 from undoped bafe@xmath2as@xmath2 to optimally doped k-122 are presented in fig.4(a ) and the systematic evolution can be observed .
the hall coefficient r@xmath5 changes suddenly from a negative value in the undoped sample to a positive one with slight k - doping , and it keeps lowering with further doping in low temperature region .
for each doping level , the sudden increase of the hall coefficient is corresponding to the af / structure transition which is agreeable with the resistivity anomaly for underdoped k-122 ( x = [email protected] ) . above the af / structure transition temperature
the hall coefficient varies weakly .
the general formula for the hall coefficient in the boltzmann approximation reads @xmath46 for fully compensated semimetals within the two - band model , eq.3 reduces to @xmath47 by definition , undoped samples are compensated , that is , n@xmath26
= n@xmath28 = n@xmath48 . the eq .
4 can be written as @xmath49 where @xmath50 ( @xmath51 ) is the mobility . if @xmath52 , then @xmath53 , the transport is dominated by the electron band@xcite . however , with the potassium doping , the hole pocket increases in size instantly and the electron pocket contracts . at the hole doping with an @xmath54 @xmath44 @xmath55 , the hall coefficient changes sign . with further doping , the hole - doped systems have a presence of @xmath56 pocket near ( @xmath57 ) .
in addition to ( @xmath58,0 ) scattering between @xmath59 and @xmath60 sheets , new phase space for scattering opens up.@xcite .
the asymmetric scattering rate in the hole and the electron pockets play an important role on r@xmath5 .
fig.4 shows the doping dependence of hall coefficient at 50 k , 100 k , 150 k , 200 k. in low temperature region , r@xmath5 changes sign and reaches a large value with little potassium doping . with further doping
, r@xmath5 decreases gradually .
in high temperature region the r@xmath5 varies very little , which is agreeable with the recent calculation@xcite . in the electron doped 122 system ,
the transport property is dominated by electron . in compensated case ,
the results can be explained by remarkable different mobilities of hole and electrons@xcite . for hole doped k-122 , the asymmetric scattering rate in the hole and the electron pockets still holds , but the relative ratio between @xmath61 and @xmath62 may change a little bit , namely @xmath62 will get enhanced .
this is especially necessary to interpret the dropping down of resistance at high temperatures when the slight holes are doped into the system , as shown in fig.1 .
the temperature dependence of magnetoresistivity for nine samples measured at a magnetic field of 9 t are presented in fig.5 .
the data shows also a non - monotonic doping dependence and a sudden increase below af / structure transition , which is associated very well with the anomaly found in resistivity and hall effect .
in undoped sample , the large magnetoresistivity with a magnitude of about 35% ( at about 9 t ) has been found in low temperature region .
with increasing doping , the magnetoresistivity decreases instantly .
it remains unclear yet what causes this large magnetoresistance within the af phase .
there are two main explanations : ( 1 ) the magnetic field will break down the antiferromagnetic order to some extent and lead to stronger spin fluctuations and thus larger scattering to itinerant electrons ; ( 2 ) a magnetic field will induce a stronger localization leading to an enhanced resistivity .
in addition to this strong magnetoresistance in the antiferromagnetic state , an anomalous feature at about 80 to 100 k can be observed even in the optimally doped sample in which the af state dose not exist at all .
one can see this in the inset of fig.5 .
the magnetoresistance rises up gradually when the temperature is lowered down , but it drops suddenly at about 100 k and reaches almost zero ( for the optimally doped sample ) , then it rises up again in the lower temperature region and smoothly connected to the magnetoresistance induced by the vortex motion in the mixed state .
this anomaly at about 100 k may be associated with a possible pseudogap feature due to some unknown reasons .
this is consistent with the recent observation in the c - axis resistive measurements where a maximum of @xmath63 is observed.@xcite a high temperature pseudogap was also claimed very recently from the optical conductivity measurements.@xcite further experimental and theoretical investigations are needed to clarify this point .
in summary , we investigated resistivity , hall effect and magnetoresistance systematically on single crystals of ba@xmath0k@xmath1fe@xmath2as@xmath2 ranging from undoped to optimally doped samples .
the resistivity in the normal state of ba@xmath0k@xmath1fe@xmath2as@xmath2 is insensitive to the potassium doping compared to the electron doped ba(fe@xmath0co@xmath3)@xmath4as@xmath4 samples .
the hall coefficient r@xmath5 changes suddenly from a negative value in the undoped sample to a positive one with slight k - doping , and it keeps lowering with further doping .
this contrasting behavior is interpreted as due to the asymmetric scattering between the electron and hole bands with the much larger mobility in the former .
an anomalous feature of magnetoresistivity has been observed at about 80 to 100 k and may be associated with a possible pseudogap feature .
a linear feature of resistivity @xmath11 vs. @xmath8 was observed just above @xmath9 for the optimally doped sample , which suggests a quantum criticality .
acknowledgement : we acknowledge the fruitful discussions with i. i. mazin , m. a. tanatar and p. hirschfeld .
this work is supported by the natural science foundation of china , the ministry of science and technology of china ( 973 project no : 2011cba001002 ) , and the ministry of education of china ( 985 project ) .
y. kamihara , t. watanabe , m. hirano , and h. hosono , j. am . chem.soc . * 130 * , 3296 ( 2008 )
. i. i. mazin , d. j. singh , m. d. johannes , and m. h. du , phys .
rev . lett .
* 101 * , 057003 ( 2008 ) .
kazuhiko kuroki , seiichiro onari , ryotaro arita , hidetomo usui , yukio tanaka , hiroshi kontani , and hideo aoki , phys .
* 101 * , 087004 ( 2008 ) .
f. wang , h. zhai , y. ran , a. vishwanath and d. h. lee , phys .
rev . lett . * 102 * , 047005 ( 2009 ) .
h. ding , p. richard , k. nakayama , k. sugawara , t. arakane , y. sekiba , a. takayama , s. souma , t. sato , t. takahashi , z. wang , x. dai , z. fang , g. f. chen , j. l. luo , and n. l. wang , europhys . lett .
* 83 * , 47001 ( 2008 ) .
r. t. gordon r. t. gordon , n. ni , c. martin , m. a. tanatar , m. d. vannette , h. kim , g. d. samolyuk , j. schmalian , s. nandi , a. kreyssig , a. i. goldman , j. q. yan , s. l. budko , p. c. canfield , and r. prozorov , phys .
* 102 * , 127004 ( 2009 ) . c. ren ,
z. s. wang , h. q. luo , h. yang , l. shan , and h. h. wen , phys .
* 101 * , 257006 ( 2008 ) .
b. zeng , g. mu , h. q. luo , t. xiang , i. i. mazin , h. yang , l. shan , c. ren , p. c. dai , and h. h. wen , nature communications * 1 * , 115 ( 2010 ) .
j. zhao , q. huang , c. d. cruz , s. l. li , j. w. lynn , y. chen , m. a. green , g. f. chen , g. li , z. li , j. l. luo , n. l. wang , and p. c. dai , nature materials * 7 * , 953 ( 2008 ) .
l. fang , h. q. luo , p. cheng , z. s. wang , y. jia , g. mu , b. shen , i. i. mazin , l. shan , c. ren , and h. h. wen , phys .
b * 80 * , 140508 ( r ) ( 2009 ) .
n. ni , m. e. tillman , j. q. yan , a. kracher , s. t. hannahs , s. l. budko , and p. c. canfield , phys .
b * 78 * , 214515 ( 2008 ) . m. rotter , m. pangerl , m. tegel , and d. johrendt , angew .
int . ed . *
47 * , 7949 ( 2008 ) .
h. chen , y. ren , y. qiu , w. bao , r. h. liu , g. wu , t. wu , y. l. xie , x. f. wang , q. huang , and x. h. chen , europhys . lett . * 85 * , 17 006 ( 2009 ) .
j. p. reid , m. a. tanatar , x. g. luo , h. shakeripour , s. ren de cotret , n. doiron - leyraud , j. chang , b. shen , h .- h .
wen , h. kim , r. prozorov , and l. taillefer arxiv:1105.2232v1 ( 2011 ) .
f. l. ning , k. ahilan , t. imai , a. s. sefat , m. a. mcguire , b. c. sales , d. mandrus , p. cheng , b. shen , and h. h. wen , phys .
* 104 * , 037001 ( 2010 ) .
j. j. tu , j. li , w. liu , a. punnoose , y. gong , y. h. ren , l. j. li , g. h. cao , z. a. xu , and c. c. homes , phys .
b * 82 * , 174509 ( 2010 ) .
f. rullier - albenque , d. colson , a. forget , p. thuery , and s. poissonnet , phys .
b * 81 * , 224503 ( 2010 ) . m. a. tanatar , e. c. blomberg , h. kim , k. cho , w. e. straszheim , b. shen , h. h. wen , and r. prozorov arxiv:1106.0533v1 . g. li , w. z. hu , j. dong , z. li , p. zheng , g. f. chen , j. l. luo , and n. l. wang , phys
* 101 * , 107004 ( 2008 ) .
n. barisic , d. wu , m. dressel , l. j. li , g. h. cao , and z. a. xu , phys .
b * 82 * , 054518 ( 2010 ) .
j. h. chu , j. g. analytis , c. kucharczyk , and i. r. fisher , phys .
b * 79 * , 014506 ( 2009 )
. h. q. luo , z. s. wang , h. yang , p. cheng , x. y. zhu , and h. h. wen , supercond .
* 21 * , 125014 ( 2008 ) .
l. shan , y. l. wang , b. shen , b. zeng , y. huang , a. li , d. wang , h. yang , c. ren , q. h. wang , z. h. pan , and h. h wen , nature physics * 7 * , 325 - 331 ( 2010 ) .
m. rotter , m. tegel , i. schellenberg , f. m. schappacher , r. puttgen , j. deisenhofer , a. gnther , f. schrettle , a. loidl , and d. johrendt , new j. phys .
* 11 * , 025014 ( 2009 ) .
h. ding , k. nakayama , p richard , s. souma , t. sato , t. takahashi , m. neupane , y. m. xu , z. h. pan , a. v. fedorov , z. wang , x dai , z , fang , g. f. chen , j. l. luo , and n. l. wang , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 23 * , 135701 ( 2011 ) g. mu , h. q. luo , z. s. wang , l. shan , c. ren , and h. h. wen , phys .
b * 79 * , 174501 ( 2009 ) a. f. kemper , m. m. korshunov , t. p. devereaux , j. n. fry , h. p. cheng , and p. j. hirschfeld , arxiv:1102.1422 ( 2011 ) .
a. a. golubov , o. v. dolgov , a. v. boris , a. charnukha , d. l. sun , c. t. lin , a. f. shevchun , a. v. korobenko , m. r. trunin , and v. n. zverev arxiv:1011.1900 ( 2010 ) .
a. rosch , phys .
lett . * 82 * , 4280 ( 1999 ) .
b. lv , m. gooch , b. lorenz , f. chen , a. m. guloy , and c. w. chu , new j. phys . * 11 * , 025013 ( 2009 ) y. nakai , t. iye , s. kitagawa , k. ishida , h. ikeda , s. kasahara , h. shishido , t. shibauchi , y. matsuda , and t. terashima , phys .
lett . * 105 * , 107003 ( 2010 ) .
y. zhang , j. wei , h. w. ou , j. f. zhao , b. zhou , f. chen , m. xu , c. he , g. wu , h. chen , m. arita , k. shimada , h. namatame , m. taniguchi , x. h. chen , and d. l. feng , phys .
* 102 * , 127003 ( 2009 ) .
f. massee , y. huang , r. huisman , s. de jong , j. b. goedkoop , and m. s. golden _ phys .
b _ * 79 * , 220517 ( 2009 ) .
d. johrendt and r. puttgen physica c * 469 * , 332 ( 2009 ) .
g. mu , b. zeng , p. cheng , z. s. wang , l. fang , b. shen , l. shan , c. ren , and h. h. wen _ chin .
. lett _ * 27 * , 037402 ( 2010 ) t. goko , a. a. aczel , e. baggio - saitovitch , s. l. budko , p. c. canfield , j. p. carlo , g. f. chen , pengcheng dai , a. c. hamann , w. z. hu , h. kageyama , g. m. luke , j. l. luo , b. nachumi , n. ni , d. reznik , d. r. sanchez - candela , a. t. savici , k. j. sikes , n. l. wang , c. r. wiebe , t. j. williams , t. yamamoto , w. yu , and y. j. uemura , phys .
b * 80 * , 024508 ( 2009 )
. j. t. park , d. s. inosov , ch .
niedermayer , g. l. sun , d. haug , n. b. christensen , r. dinnebier , a.v .
boris , a. j. drew , l. schulz , t. shapoval , u. wolff , v. neu , x. p. yang , c. t. lin , b. keimer , and v. hinkov , phys .
lett * 102 * , 117006 ( 2010 ) .
a. a. aczel , e. baggio - saitovitch , s. l. budko , p. c. canfield , j. p. carlo , g. f. chen , p. c. dai , t. goko , w. z. hu , g. m. luke , j. l. luo , n. ni , d. r. sanchez - candela , f. f. tafti , n. l. wang , t. j. williams , w. yu , and y. j. uemura , phys .
b * 78 * , 214503 ( 2008 ) .
w. k. yeoh , b. gault , x. y. cui , c. zhu , m. p. moody , l. li , r. k. zheng , w. x li , x. l. wang , s. x. dou , c. t. lin , and s. p. ringer , arxiv:1104.0453 ( 2011 ) .
n. l. wang , w. z. hu , z. g. chen , r. h. yuan , g. li , g. f. chen , and t. xiang , arxiv:1105.3939 ( 2011 ) . | resistivity , hall effect and magnetoresistance have been investigated systematically on single crystals of ba@xmath0k@xmath1fe@xmath2as@xmath2 ranging from undoped to optimally doped regions . a systematic evolution of the quasiparticle scattering has been observed .
it is found that the resistivity in the normal state of ba@xmath0k@xmath1fe@xmath2as@xmath2 is insensitive to the potassium doping concentration , which is very different from the electron doped counterpart ba(fe@xmath0co@xmath3)@xmath4as@xmath4 , where the resistivity at 300 k reduces to half value of the undoped one when the system is optimally doped . in stark contrast , the hall coefficient r@xmath5 changes suddenly from a negative value in the undoped sample to a positive one with slight k - doping , and it keeps lowering with further doping .
we interpret this dichotomy due to the asymmetric scattering rate in the hole and the electron pockets with much higher mobility of the latter .
the magnetoresistivity shows also a non - monotonic doping dependence indicating an anomalous feature at about 80 k to 100 k , even in the optimally doped sample , which is associated with a possible pseudogap feature . in the low temperature region
, it seems that the resistivity has the similar values when superconductivity sets in disregarding the different t@xmath6 values , which indicates a novel mechanism of the superconductivity .
a linear feature of resistivity @xmath7 vs. @xmath8 was observed just above @xmath9 for the optimally doped sample , suggesting a quantum criticality . |
recent discoveries have underlined a key role of astrophysics in the study of nature . in this paper
we are presenting a potential instrument for measuring high energy photon polarization with a proven detector technique which should allow preparation of a reliable tool for the space - borne observatory .
polarization of the photon has played an important role ( sometimes even before it was recognized ) in physics discoveries such as the famous young s interference experiment @xcite , michelson - morley s test of the ether theory @xcite , determination of the neutral pion parity @xcite and many others , including more recently the spin structure of the nucleon @xcite .
polarization of the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) will likely be a crucial observable for the inflation theory ( see planck [ sci.esa.int/planck ] and bicep [ bicepkeck.org ] results ) . during the last decade ,
observations from the agile [ agile.rm.iasf.cnr.it ] and fermi - lat [ www-glast.stanford.edu ] pair production telescopes have enhanced our understanding of gamma ( @xmath0 ) ray astronomy . with the help of these telescopes numerous high energy @xmath0 ray sources have been observed .
however , the current measurements are insufficient to fully understand the physics mechanism of such @xmath0 ray sources as gamma ray bursts ( grbs ) , active galactic nuclei ( agns ) , blazars , pulsars , and supernova remnants ( snrs ) . even though both telescopes cover a wide range of energy ( from 20 mev to more than 300 gev ) , neither of them is capable of polarization measurements .
medium to high energy photon polarimeters for astrophysics were proposed by the nasa group @xcite and recently by the saclay group @xcite .
both are considering ar(xe)-based gas - filled detectors : the time projection chamber with a micro - well or micromega section for amplification of ionization .
in this paper we evaluate the features of an electron - positron pair polarimeter for the full energy range from 20 mev to 1000 mev and then propose a specific design for a polarimeter in the 100 to 300 mev energy range using silicon micro - strip detectors , msds , whose principal advantage with respect to the gas - based tpc is that the spatial and two - track resolution is about five to ten times better . the paper is organized in the following way : in section [ sec_moti ] we briefly discuss the motivation for cosmic @xmath0 ray polarimetry in the high energy region .
section [ sec_pol ] is devoted to measurement techniques , polarimeters being built and current proposals . in section [ sec_flux ]
we calculate the photon flux coming from the crab pulsar and crab nebula .
the design of the new polarimeter and its performance are discussed in the last few sections .
there are several recent reviews of photon polarimetry in astrophysics @xcite which address many questions which we just briefly touch on in this section .
photon polarimetry for energy below a few mev is a very active field of astrophysical research , and some examples of the productive use of polarimetry at these energies include : detection of exoplanets , analysis of chemical composition of planetary atmosphere , and investigation of interstellar matter , quasar jets and solar flares .
however , no polarization measurements are available in the medium and high energy regions because of the instrumental challenges .
the primary motivation in proposing a polarimeter is our interest in understanding the emission and production mechanisms for polarized @xmath0 rays in pulsars , grbs , and agns by measuring polarization of cosmic @xmath0 rays in this under - explored energy region ( @xmath1 @xmath2 mev ) .
additionally , the polarization observations from the rotation - powered and accretion - powered pulsar radiation mechanisms could help to confirm the identification of black hole candidates @xcite .
polarization measurements could reveal one of the possible effects induced by quantum gravity , the presence of small , but potentially detectable , lorentz or cpt violating terms in the effective field theory .
these terms lead to a macroscopic birefringence effect of the vacuum ( see @xcite for more information ) .
up to now , the highest energy linear polarization measurement has been for grb 061122 in the 250 - 800 kev energy range @xcite , and vacuum birefringence has not been observed in that region .
therefore , extending polarization sensitivity to higher energies could lead to detection of vacuum birefringence , which would have an extraordinary impact on fundamental physics , or in the case of null detection we could significantly improve the present limits on the lorentz invariance violation parameter .
further , according to the observations by the energetic gamma ray experiment telescope ( egret ) [ heasarc.gsfc.nasa.gov/docs/cgro/egret ] , the synchrotron emission of the crab nebula is significant in the energy below @xmath3 200 mev @xcite .
additionally , the theoretical studies state that most of the @xmath0 rays coming from the crab nebula around 100 mev may come from its inner knot @xcite , so the observations in the neighborhood of 100 mev will help to test this theoretical hypothesis and confirm the emission mechanism .
furthermore , the observation of the @xmath0 rays from the crab pulsar provides strong evidence of the location of the @xmath0 ray emitting region as it lies in the center of the nebula .
it is also worth mentioning that polarimetry could test the theories assuming existence of axions ( hypothetical particles introduced to solve the strong cp problem of qcd ) .
it is interesting that the same axions or axion - like particles can serve as a foundation for a relevant mechanism of sun luminosity @xcite .
a theoretical study @xcite has shown that polarization observations from grbs can be used to constrain the axion - photon coupling : @xmath4 for the axion mass @xmath5 ev .
the limit of the coupling scales is @xmath6 ; therefore , the polarimetry of grbs at higher energies would lead to tighter constraints . in two of the following subsections
we will briefly explain how polarization measurements are involved in confirming the emission mechanism and geometry of two above - mentioned sources .
pulsars are a type of neutron star , yet they are highly magnetized and rotate at enormous speeds .
the questions concerning the way magnetic and electric fields are oriented , how particles are accelerated and how the energy is converted into radio and @xmath0 rays in pulsars are still not fully answered .
because of the extreme conditions in pulsars interiors , they can be used to understand poorly known properties of superdense , strongly magnetized , and superconducting matter @xcite . moreover , by studying pulsars one can learn about the nuclear reactions and interactions between the elementary particles under these conditions , which can not be reproduced in terrestrial laboratories .
particle acceleration in the polar region of the magnetic field results in gamma radiation , which is expected to have a high degree of polarization @xcite .
depending on the place where the radiation occurs , the pulsar emission can be explained in the framework of a polar cap model or an outer cap model . in both models ,
the emission mechanism is similar , but polarization is expected to be dissimilar @xcite ; hence , polarimetry could be used to understand the pulsar s emission mechanism .
polarization measurements would also help to understand grbs .
the grbs @xcite are short and extremely bright bursts of @xmath0 rays .
usually , a short - time ( from @xmath5 s to about @xmath7 s ) peak of radiation is followed by a long lasting afterglow .
the characteristics of the radiation emitted during the short - time peak and during the afterglow are different .
the number of high - energy photons which may be detected during the short - time burst phase is expected to be small compared with the one for the long - lived emission .
while only about 3% of the energy emitted during the short - time burst is carried by high - energy photons with @xmath8 mev , the high energy photons of the afterglow carry about half of the total emitted energy . therefore , there is a possibility of observing polarization of high energy photons during the afterglow .
the emission mechanism of grbs , the magnetic composition , and the geometry and morphology of grb jets are still uncertain but can be at least partly revealed in this way .
it is worth noting that several studies have discussed how the degree of polarization , @xmath9 , depends on the grb emission mechanisms . in one example , using monte carlo methods toma @xmath10 @xcite showed that the compton drag model is favored when the degree of polarization @xmath9@xmath11@xmath12 , and @xmath13-@xmath14 concerns the synchrotron radiation with the ordered magnetic fields model .
moreover , studies by mundell @xmath10 @xcite and lyutikov @xmath10 @xcite have proven that polarimetry could assist in revealing the geometry of grb jets .
several physical processes such as the photoelectric effect , thomson scattering , compton scattering , and electron - positron pair production can be used to measure photon linear polarization .
polarimeters based on the photoelectric effect and thomson scattering are used at very low energies .
compton polarimeters are commonly used for energies from 50 kev to a few mev @xcite . ) above an energy range of a few mev . ]
some of the major achievements in astrophysics that were obtained using polarimetry are : the discovery of synchrotron radiation from the crab nebula @xcite ; the study of the surface composition of solar system objects @xcite ; the measurement of the x - ray linear polarization of the crab nebula @xcite , which is still one of the best measurements of linear polarization for astrophysical sources ; mapping of solar and stellar magnetic fields @xcite ; detection of polarization in the cmb radiation @xcite ; and analysis of large scale galactic magnetic fields @xcite . the measurement of polarization in this high energy @xmath0 ray regime can be done by detecting the electron - positron pairs produced by @xmath0 rays and analysis of a non - uniformaty of event distribution in the electron - positron pair plane angle , as discussed in ref .
however , implementation of this technique should consider limitations due to multiple coulomb scatterings in the detector , and there are no successful polarization measurements for astrophysical sources in the energy regime of interest in our paper . a number of missions have included cosmic @xmath0 ray observations , but only a few of them are capable of measuring polarization .
the polarimetry measurements were mainly restricted to @xmath0 rays with low energies e @xmath15 10 mev . as an example
, the reuven ramaty high energy solar spectroscopic imager ( rhessi ) [ hesperia.gsfc.nasa.gov/rhessi3 ] , launched to image the sun at energies from 3 kev to 20 mev , was capable of polarimetry up to 2 mev , and the results were successfully used to study the polarization of numerous solar flares @xcite .
the spi detector international gamma - ray astrophysics laboratory ( integral ) instrument [ sci.esa.int/integral ] has the capability of detecting polarization in the range of 3 kev to 8 mev @xcite .
it was used to measure the polarization of grb 041219a , and later a high degree of polarization of @xmath0 rays from that source @xcite was confirmed .
the tracking and imaging gamma ray experiment ( tigre ) compton telescope , which observes @xmath0 rays in the range of @xmath16
@xmath17 mev , can measure polarization up to 2 mev . recently ,
morselli @xmath10 proposed gamma - light to detect @xmath0 rays in the energy range 10 mev 10 gev ,
and they believe that it will provide solutions to all the current issues that could not be resolved by agile and fermi - lat in the energy range 10 200 mev .
it can also determine the polarization for intense sources for the energies above a few hundred mev with high accuracy @xcite .
in spite of the limitations of the instruments capability , there are numerous polarimetry studies in @xmath0 ray astrophysics , and various proposals have been put forth regarding medium and high energy @xmath0 ray polarimeters .
for example , bloser @xmath10 @xcite proposed the advanced pair telescope ( apt ) , also a polarimeter , in the @xmath3 50 mev 1 gev range . that proposal uses a gas - based time projection chamber ( tpc ) with micro - well amplification to track the @xmath18 , @xmath19 path .
the polarization sensitivity was estimated by using geant4 monte carlo simulations .
preliminary results indicated that it will be capable of detecting linearly polarized emissions from bright sources at 100 mev .
as an updated version of the apt , hunter @xmath10
@xcite suggested the advanced energetic pair telescope ( adept ) for @xmath0 ray polarimetry in the medium energy range ; further , they mentioned that it would also provide better photon angular resolution than fermi - lat in the range of @xmath3 5 to @xmath3 200 mev .
harpo is a hermetic argon tpc detector proposed by bernard @xmath10 @xcite which would have high angular resolution and would be sensitive to polarization of @xmath0 rays with energies in the mev - gev range .
a demonstrator for this tpc was built , and preliminary estimates of the spatial resolution are encouraging .
currently , the harpo team is finalizing a demonstrator set up to characterize a beam of polarized @xmath0 rays in the energy range of 2 76 mev @xcite .
observations of the @xmath0 rays from the crab pulsar and crab nebula have been reported in ref .
@xcite for eight months of survey data with fermi - lat .
the pulsar dominates the phase - averaged photon flux , but there is an off - pulse window ( 35% of the total duration of the cycle ) when the pulsar flux is negligible and it is therefore possible to observe the nebular emission . according to the conducted analysis , the spectrum of the crab nebula in the @xmath17-@xmath20 mev range can be described by the following combined expression : @xmath21 where the quantity @xmath22 is measured in @xmath23 representing the number of photons reaching @xmath24 @xmath25 of the detector area per second , per @xmath24 mev of energy .
the energy @xmath26 on the right hand side is measured in gev .
the prefactors @xmath27 and @xmath28 are determined by 35% of the total duration of the cycle , while @xmath29 and @xmath30 .
the first and second terms on the right hand side , as well as the indices `` sync '' and `` ic '' , correspond to the synchrotron and inverse compton components of the spectrum , respectively . as one can see , these terms have different dependence on the energy @xmath26 since they represent different contributions to the total spectrum . the first part ( the synchrotron radiation )
comes from emission by high energy electrons in the nebular magnetic field while the second part is due to the inverse compton scattering of the primary accelerated electrons . for convenience
let us rewrite the expression for the spectrum of the crab nebula in the form @xmath31 where the energy @xmath26 on both sides is now measured in mev , so @xmath32 and @xmath33 . integrating @xmath22 , for the photon flux above @xmath17 mev coming from the crab nebula we obtain the number @xmath34 giving for the total cycle duration @xmath35 , or @xmath36 .
at the same time the averaged spectrum of the crab pulsar is described in @xcite as follows : @xmath37 where @xmath38 , @xmath39 and the cut - off energy @xmath40 .
as before , the energy @xmath26 on both sides is measured in mev . integrating this expression , for the photon flux above @xmath17 mev coming from the crab pulsar we obtain the number @xmath41 , or @xmath42 .
thus , the pulsar s photon flux is twice as intensive as the nebula s
. a fast photometer could be insert in the polarimeter instrumentation to collect events and have a temporal tag and consequently distinguish between nebula and pulsar photons , see e.g. @xcite .
we will use the numbers above for an estimation of the polarimeter results at a 100 mev energy cut .
for a 500 mev cut the statistics drops by a factor of five ( because @xmath43 is much higher the exponential factor does not play a role ) .
it is worth noting that the estimates following from @xcite approximately agree with the corresponding estimates made in @xcite ( where the formulas ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) describe the synchrotron and inverse compton components of the crab nebula spectrum while the formula ( 3 ) describes the averaged crab pulsar spectrum ) .
really , according to @xcite , the total crab nebula photon flux above @xmath17 mev is @xmath44 , while for the crab pulsar the value again reads @xmath45 .
the photo production of an electron - positron pair in the field of nuclei is a well understood process which was calculated in qed with all details including the effect of photon linear polarization , see e.g. ref .
the kinematics and variables of the reactions are shown in fig .
[ fig : kinematics ] .
the distribution of events over an azimuthal angle @xmath46 of a positron ( electron ) relative to the direction of an incident photon has the following form : + @xmath47 , where @xmath48 is the analyzing power , @xmath49 is the degree of the photon linear polarization , and @xmath50 is the angle of the photon linear polarization vector in the detector coordinate system . in practice @xcite , angle @xmath51
could be used instead of @xmath46 because at the photon energies of interest the co - planarity angle @xmath52 .
pair photo production ( left picture ) and the azimuthal angles in the detector plane from ref .
the photon momentum is directed along the z axis .
the photon polarization vector @xmath53 is parallel to the x axis .
the angle @xmath54 is the angle between the photon polarization plane and the plane constructed by the momentum of the photon and the momentum of the positron ( the electron ) .
the angle @xmath55 is called the co - planarity angle .
the labels p and n indicate the positions of the crossings of the detector plane by the positron and the electron .
the azimuthal angle @xmath51 between the polarization plane and the vector @xmath56 is a directly measurable parameter.,scaledwidth=65.0% ] the value of analyzing power @xmath48 was found to be a complicated function of the event parameters and detection arrangement @xcite .
the numerical integration of the full expression could be performed for given conditions , see e.g. @xcite . in a high energy limit a compact expression for the integrated analyzing power for the pair photo - production from atomic electron
was obtained in ref .
@xcite .
the practical design and the test of the polarimeter for a beam of high energy photons were reported in ref .
there we detected both particles of the pair and reconstructed the azimuthal angle of the pair plane @xmath51 ( see fig .
[ fig : kinematics ] ) .
the analyzing power , averaged over energy sharing between electron and positron and pair open angle of the experimental acceptance , has been found to be [email protected] , comparable to a 0.14 value as shown in fig .
[ fig : asy_e+e - m ] reproduced from @xcite .
when the pair components move through the converter , the azimuthal angle built on pair coordinates and pair vertex becomes blurred due to multiple scattering .
it is useful to note that the purpose of development in ref .
@xcite was a polarimeter for an intense photon beam .
the thickness of the converter in the beam polarimeter was chosen to be very small to minimize systematics of the measurement of the photon polarization degree .
however , the polarimeter could be calibrated by using the highly polarized photon beams produced in the laser - backscattering facilities . for the cosmic ray polarimeter
, we propose a larger converter thickness and calibration of the device .
such an approach is more productive for cosmic rays studies where a relative systematic error on the polarization degree at the level of 3 - 5% is acceptable .
let us also note that for the photon beam polarimetry there are additional options such as a coherent pair production in an oriented crystal and a magnetic separation of the pair components used many years ago in nuclear physics experiments .
for the space - borne photon investigation , those polarimeters are not applicable for the obvious reasons of the limited angle range for the coherent effects and the large weight and power consumption of the magnetic system .
an active converter with a coordinate resolution of a few microns would allow us to construct a dream device , a very efficient polarimeter .
a real world active - converter device , a gas - filled tpc , has a spatial resolution of 100 @xmath58 m and much larger two - track resolution of 1.5 - 2 mm ( for a few cm long drift distance ) .
such a polarimeter will be a very productive instrument for the photon energy range below 50 mev .
however , because of these resolutions , it would be hard to measure the degree of polarization of photons whose energy is bigger than 100 mev .
a polarimeter with separation of the converter and pair detector functions could benefit from the high coordinate resolution of the silicon msd of 10 - 15 @xmath58 m , its two - track resolution of 0.2 mm , and flexibility for the distance between a converter and pair hits detector : between them would be a vacuum gap .
the key parameters of the polarimeter are the efficiency , @xmath59 , and analyzing power , @xmath48 . here
we outline the analysis of the figure - of - merit , @xmath60 .
we will consider a polarimeter as a stack of individual flat cells , each of which is comprised of a converter with a two - dimensional coordinate readout and a coordinate detector for two - track events with no material between them .
the thickness of the converter , where the photon produces the electron - positron pair , defines in the first approximation the polarimeter efficiency as follows : @xmath61 the efficiency of one cell is @xmath62 with @xmath63 is the thickness of the converter in units of radiation length .
the @xmath64 is the reduction of the photon flux due to absorption in a single cell defined as @xmath65 , where @xmath66 is the thickness of the cell in units of radiation length , and @xmath67 is the number of cells in the device of length @xmath68 and geometrical thickness of the cell @xmath69 .
the converter thickness needs to be optimized because above some thickness it does not improve the @xmath70 or the accuracy of the polarimeter result ( see the next section ) . as it is shown in fig .
[ fig : asy_e+e - m ] , selection of the symmetric pairs ( @xmath71 ) provides an analyzing power @xmath72 while the averaged over pair energy sharing @xmath73 .
however , the value of the @xmath70 is largest when the cut on pair energy sharing is relaxed .
the practical case for the energy cut is @xmath74 , which allows us to avoid events with a low value of @xmath48 and most @xmath75-electron contamination .
the average value of @xmath48 for such a range of @xmath76 energy sharing is 0.20 .
the energy of the particles and the shower coordinates could be measured by a segmented electromagnetic calorimeter or estimated from the width of the track , which due to multiple scattering is inversely proportional to the particle momentum . in the photon energy range of interest
, both electron and positron will pass through a large number of cells .
determination of particle energy based on multiple scattering would provide @xmath320% relative energy resolution , which is sufficient for the proposed cut @xmath74 .
estimation of the particle energy could also be useful for rejection of the hits in msds induced by the @xmath75-electrons .
a monte carlo simulation was used to evaluate the general effects of pair production in the converter and the specific design of the polarimeter .
we used a geant3-based mc code to study the photon detection efficiency and electron - positron pair azimuthal distribution in a wide range of the converter thickness up to 10% of radiation length . because both the pair opening angle and multiple scattering are scaled with the photon energy , the distributions are almost energy independent .
we present first the results for the 100 mev photon energy for different thicknesses of the converter at a fixed distance of 20 mm between the converter end and the detector .
we used a standard geant3 pair production generator for the unpolarized photons and at the conversion point introduced a weighting factor for each event as @xmath77 to simulate a polarization effect on an event - by - event basis .
the value of azimuthal angle modulation at the pair production point was fixed at 0.20 , which is the average value of the analyzing power @xmath48 at production over the selected range of particle energies .
the pair component propagation was realized in the mc , and the track parameters were evaluated .
[ fig : mc100 ] shows the summary of mc results .
the apparent optimum converter thickness is close to 1 mm for which the projected @xmath78 is reasonably large and the @xmath70 is close to the saturation limit .
however , we are expecting that when @xmath75-electron hits are included in analysis the optimum thickness for the 100 mev photon case will be smaller and the @xmath70 would be a bit lower .
-0.05 in the coordinate detector allows determination of the opening angle between the pair components and the azimuthal angle of the pair plane relative to the lab coordinate system , the main variable for measurement of the photon polarization .
such a detector is characterized by the coordinate resolution , @xmath79 , and the minimum two - track distance , @xmath80 , at which coordinates of two tracks could be determined with quoted @xmath79 accuracy .
the @xmath80 is typically 2 mm for drift chamber .
for tpc with micromega amplification stage and strip - type readout , @xmath80 is about 4 strips or 1.6 mm ( pitch equal to 400 @xmath81 ) . for silicon msd @xmath80
is about 0.20 mm ( pitch equal to 50 @xmath81 ) .
the opening angle between the pair components is on the order of @xmath82 , where @xmath83 is the photon energy and @xmath84 is the electron rest mass .
the events with an opening angle larger than @xmath85 but less than @xmath86 provide most of the analyzing power , as it is shown in ref .
it is easy to find that the resulting geometrical thickness of the cell is @xmath87 , whose numerical values are shown in tab .
[ tab : cell_thickness ] . 0.1 in .the geometrical cell thickness , @xmath69 , in * cm * for the different detectors and photon energies .
[ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ tab : cell_thickness ] for photon energies above 100 mev , the silicon msd is a preferable option because of the limit on the apparatus s total length . indeed , considering a 300 cm total length and an energy of 500 mev , the number of cells is 5 for the drift chamber option , 6 for the tpc / micromega , and 46 for the msd option . on another side ,
the total amount of matter in the polarimeter should be limited to one radiation length or less , because of significant absorption of the incident photons which will reduce the average efficiency per cell .
for example , in the msd option 54% absorption will occur with 46 cells ( 1 mm thickness 2d readout converter detector and two 0.3 mm thickness 1d readout track detectors ) .
the detection efficiency ( pair production in the converters ) could be estimated as @xmath88 ( eq . [ eq : eff ] ) , which is about 34% for the selected parameters of the polarimeter . however , the useful statistics result is lower due to a cut on the pair components energies and contributions of the non - pair production processes , especially at low photon energy . for a photon energy of 100 mev ,
the obtained efficiency is 0.28% per cell and the overall efficiency for the 46 cell polarimeter is 9% .
the efficiency becomes significantly larger ( @xmath315% ) for a photon energy of 1000 mev .
assuming observation of the crab pulsar photon source with a 1 m@xmath89 detector for one year the total statistics of pairs ( above a 100 mev photon energy cut ) was estimated to be @xmath90 .
for the projected analyzing power @xmath48 of 0.10 the statistical accuracy of the polarization measurement is @xmath91 for the msd detector option .
realization of such high accuracy would require a prior calibration of the polarimeter at a laser - back scattering facility .
the detectors of the cell of the msd - based polarimeter include two parts the first for the measurement of the x and y coordinates of each pair component and the second for the measurement of the x and y coordinates of the production vertex .
the second part should be done using a two - dimensional readout msd because with a one - dimensional readout the most useful events will have only one coordinate of the vertex .
the first part of the cell could be realized with a one- or two - dimensional readout .
we consider below the two - dimensional readout for the third plane only .
-0.05 in the thickness of the silicon plate is 0.3 ( 1.0 ) mm , and the readout strip pitch is 50(100 ) @xmath81 for the first two ( third ) planes .
two first msds are rotated by 90@xmath92 , so three planes allow determination of the coordinates in two - track events .
the third plane will serve as a converter for the next cell .
it provides both coordinates of the production vertex , see fig .
[ fig : cells ] for a three cell example .
the first two msds also serve as veto detector(s ) for the photon converted in the third msd .
a proposed 46 cell structure in a 300 cm long polarimeter leads to a cell length 6.5 cm , which allows optimal coverage of a wide range of photon energies .
a calorimeter will be used for crude ( 10 - 20% ) measurement of the photon energy ( combined energy of the @xmath93 pair ) .
the configuration proposed above called for a 1 mm thickness msd with two - sided readout strips , which is twice as large as the maximum currently available from industry .
we are nevertheless expecting that such an advance in technology could be made for the current project . in any case
the 1 mm converter could be replaced by two 0.5 mm converters .
the projected results of polarization measurement are shown in fig . [
fig : projected - result ] .
the photon angular resolution of the proposed system could be estimated from the msd spatial resolution and thickness of the cell as 1 mrad for 100 mev photon energy .
a @xmath0 ray polarimeter for astrophysics could be constructed using silicon msd technology .
each of 46 cells will include one msd with 2d readout of 1 mm thickness and 0.1 mm pitch and two msds with 1d readout of 0.3 mm thickness and 0.05 mm pitch . using a total of 138 m@xmath89 area of msd ( 46 cells ) and @xmath94 readout channels ( assuming a factor of 10 multiplexing ) the polarimeter would provide a device with 9 - 15% photon efficiency , a 0.10 analyzing power , and a 1 mrad angular resolution . in a year - long observation , the polarization of the photons from the crab pulsar
would be measured to 6% accuracy at an energy cut of 100 mev and @xmath315% accuracy at an energy cut of 1000 mev .
the authors are grateful to s.d .
hunter for stimulating and fruitful discussion .
we would like to acknowledge contributions by v. nelyubin and s. abrahamyan in the development of the mc simulation .
this work is supported by nasa award nnx09av07a and nsf crest award hrd-1345219 . t. young , phil .
royal society london , * 92 * 12 ( 1802 ) .
a. michelson and e. morley , american journal of science * 34 * , 333 ( 1887 ) . c. n. yang , phys .
rev . * 77 * , 722 ( 1950 ) ; j. h. berlin and l. madansky , phys .
rev . * 78 * , 623 ( 1950 ) . c. aidala , s. bass , d. hasch , and g. mallot , rev .
* 85 * , 655 ( 2013 ) , arxiv : hep - ph/1209.2803 .
p. f. bloser _ et al .
_ , the mega project : science goals and hardware development , new astronomy reviews * 50 * , 619 ( 2006 ) .
d. bernard and a. delbart , nucl .
instr . meth . a * 695 * , 71 ( 2012 ) ; d. bernard , nucl .
instr . meth .
a * 729 * , 765 ( 2013 ) , arxiv : astro - ph/1307.3892 .
f. lei , a.j . dean and g.l .
hills , space science reviews * 82 * , 309 ( 1997 ) .
m.l . mcconnell and j.m .
ryan , new astronomy reviews * 48 * , 215 ( 2004 ) .
m.l . mcconnell and p.f .
bloser , chinese journal of astronomy and astrophysics * 6 * , 237 ( 2006 ) .
h. krawczynski _ et al .
_ , astroparticle physics * 34 * , 550 ( 2011 ) . w. hajdas and e. suarez - garcia , polarimetry at high energies , in @xmath95observing photons in space : a guide to experimental space astronomy@xmath95 , eds . m.c.e .
huber _ et al .
_ , 599 ( springer , 2013 ) .
m. pohl , particle detection technology for space - borne astro - particle experiments , arxiv : physics/1409.1823 .
m. dovciak _
et al . _ ,
mnras * 391 * , 32 ( 2008 ) , arxiv : astro - ph/0809.0418 .
s. r. kelner , soviet journal of nuclear physics * 10 * , 349 ( 1970 ) ; s.r .
kelner , yu.d .
kotov , and v.m .
logunov , soviet journal of nuclear physics * 21 * , 313 ( 1975 ) .
m. l. mcconnell _ et al .
_ , in aas / solar physics division meeting 34 , bulletin of the american astronomical society , vol .
35 , p. 850
( 2003 ) .
e. kalemci _
et al . _ ,
* 169 * , 75 ( 2007 ) , arxiv : astro - ph/0610771 .
a. morselli _
_ , nuclear physics b , proc
. supp . * 239 * , 193 ( 2013 ) , arxiv : astro - ph/1406.1071 .
et al . _ ,
astroparticle physics * 59 * , 18 ( 2014 ) .
d. bernard _ et al .
_ , harpo : a tpc as a gamma - ray telescope and polarimeter , arxiv : astro - ph/1406.4830 ; d. bernard , harpo : a tpc as a high - performance @xmath0-ray telescope and a polarimeter in the mev - gev energy range , conseil scientifique du labex p2io , 17 december 2014 .
_ , the astrophysical journal * 708 * , 1254 ( 2010 )
. f. meddi _ et al .
_ , publications of the astronomical society of the pacific , volume 124 , issue 195 , pp.448 - 453 ( 2012 ) ; f. ambrosino _ et al .
_ , journal of the astronomical instrumentation , volume 2 , issue 1 , i d . 1350006 ; f. ambrosino _ et al .
_ , proceedings ot the spie , volume 9147 , i d .
91478r 10 pp .
r. buehler _ et al .
_ , the astrophysical journal * 749 * , 26 ( 2012 )
. h. olsen and l. c. maximon , phys .
rev . * 114 * , 887 ( 1959 ) ; l. c. maximon and h. olsen , phys . rev . * 126 * , 310 ( 1962 ) .
b. wojtsekhowski , d. tedeschi , and b. vlahovic , nucl .
instr . meth .
a * 515 * , 605 ( 2003 ) .
v. boldyshev and y. peresunko , yad .
* 14 * , 1027 ( 1971 ) , translation in the soviet journal of nuclear physics , * 14(5 ) * , 576 ( 1972 ) . c. de jager _
j. a * 19 * , 275 ( 2004 ) ; arxiv : physics/0702246 . | a high - energy photon polarimeter for astrophysics studies in the energy range from 20 mev to 1000 mev is considered .
the proposed concept uses a stack of silicon micro - strip detectors where they play the roles of both a converter and a tracker .
the purpose of this paper is to outline the parameters of such a polarimeter and to estimate the productivity of measurements .
our study supported by a monte carlo simulation shows that with a one - year observation period the polarimeter will provide 6% accuracy of the polarization degree for a photon energy of 100 mev , which would be a significant advance relative to the currently explored energy range of a few mev .
the proposed polarimeter design could easily be adjusted to the specific photon energy range to maximize efficiency if needed . |
the past decade has seen a renewed interest in low frequency radio astronomy with a strong focus on cosmology with the highly redshifted 21 cm line of neutral hydrogen .
numerous facilities and experiments are already online or under construction , including the giant metre - wave radio telescope ( gmrt ; @xcite ) , the low frequency array ( lofar ; @xcite ) , the long wavelength array ( lwa ; @xcite ) and the associated large aperture - experiment to detect the dark ages ( leda ) experiment , the cylindrical radio telescope ( crt / baoradio , formerly hshs , @xcite ) , the experiment to detect the global eor step ( edges ; @xcite ) , the murchison widefield array ( mwa ; @xcite ) , and the donald c. backer precision array for probing the epoch of reionization ( paper ; @xcite )
. 21 cm cosmology experiments will need to separate bright galactic and extragalactic foregrounds from the neutral hydrogen signal , which can be fainter by as much as 5 orders of magnitude or more ( see , e.g. , @xcite and @xcite ) .
as such , an unprecedented level of instrumental calibration will be necessary for the detection and characterization of the 21 cm signal . achieving this level of calibration accuracy is complicated by the design choice of many experiments to employ non - tracking antenna elements ( e.g. lwa , mwa , lofar and paper ) .
non - tracking elements can provide significant reductions in cost compared to traditional dishes , while also offering increased system stability and smooth beam responses .
however , non - tracking elements also present many calibration challenges beyond those of traditional radio telescope dishes .
most prominently , the usual approach towards primary beam calibration pointing at and dithering across a well - characterized calibrator source is not possible . instead , each calibrator can only be used to characterize the small portion of the primary beam it traces out as it passes overhead .
additionally , the wide fields of view of many elements make it non - trivial to extract individual calibrator sources from the data ( see , e.g. , @xcite and @xcite for approaches to isolate calibrator sources ) .
finally , many of these arrays use dipole and tile elements , the response of which are not easily described by simple analytic functions . in this paper , we present a method for calibrating the primary beams of non - tracking , wide - field antenna elements using astronomical sources .
we illustrate the technique using both simulated and observed paper data from a 12 antenna array at the nrao site in green bank , wv .
paper is an interferometer operating between 100 and 200 mhz , targeted towards the highly - redshifted 21 cm signal from the epoch of reionization .
although the cosmological signal comes from every direction on the sky , an accurate primary beam model will be necessary to separate the faint signal from bright foreground emission . in this work
, we use a subset of the brightest extragalactic sources to calibrate the primary beam . because interferometers like paper are insensitive to smooth emission on large scales , these extragalactic sources are easily detectable despite the strongly increasing brightness of galactic synchrotron emission at low radio frequencies . only the measured relative flux densities of each source
are needed to create a beam model , but to facilitate comparision with other catalogs , we use the absolute spectrum of cygnus a from @xcite to place our source measurements on an absolute scale .
the structure of this paper is as follows : in [ motivation ] we motivate the problem and the need for a new approach to primary beam calibration for wide - field , drift - scanning elements . in [ methods ] we present our technique for primary beam calibration .
we show the results of applying the method to simulated and actual observations in [ sims ] and [ data ] , respectively , and we conclude in [ conclusions ] .
for non - tracking arrays with static pointings such as paper , every celestial source traces out a repeated source track " across the sky , and across the beam , each sidereal day . the basic relationship between the perceived source flux density ( which we shall call a measurement , @xmath1 ) measured at time @xmath2 and the intrinsic source flux density ( @xmath3 ) is : @xmath4 where @xmath5 is the response of the primary beam toward the time - dependent source location @xmath6 .
if the inherent flux density of each source were well - known , it would be straightforward to divide each @xmath7 by @xmath3 to obtain @xmath5 along the source track @xmath8 . to form a complete beam model , one
would then need enough well - characterized sources to cover the entire sky .
in the 100 - 200 mhz band , however , catalog accuracy for most sources is lagging behind the need for precise beam calibration @xcite , which in turn is necessary for generating improved catalogs . without accurate source flux densities ,
both @xmath5 and @xmath3 are unknowns , and equation [ basicmeas ] is underconstrained .
the problem becomes tractable if several sources pass through the same location on the sky , and therefore are attenuated by the same primary beam response .
however , the density of bright sources at low frequencies is insufficient to relate sources at different declinations .
additional information is necessary to break the degeneracy between primary beam response and the inherent flux densities of sources .
one way to overcome the beam - response / flux - density degeneracy described above is to assume @xmath9 rotational symmetry in the beam . under this assumption ,
each source creates two source tracks across the sky : one corresponding to the actual position of the source , and the other mirrored across the beam center . under this symmetry assumption , tracks overlap at crossing points , " as schematically illustrated in figure [ trackexample ] for two sources : cygnus a and virgo a. and @xmath10 steps in elevation and azimuth , respectively .
_ right : _ the tracks of cygnus a and virgo a , and their @xmath9 rotated images overlaid .
there are now 6 crossing points .
these are the locations where the beam and source parameters can be solved for independently . ] at a crossing point , there are only 3 unknowns , since each source is illuminated by the same primary beam response , @xmath5 . since two circles on the sky cross twice (
if they cross at all ) , there will be two independent relations that together provide enough information to constrain both the primary beam response at those points and the flux densities of sources passing through them ( relative to an absolute flux scale ) . by using multiple sources ,
it is possible to build a network of crossing points that covers a large fraction of the primary beam .
furthermore , such a network allows data to be calibrated to one well - measured fiducial calibrator . for observations with the green bank deployment of paper , source fluxes
are related to cygnus a from @xcite .
in the rest of this section , we discuss the algorithmic details of how this approach to primary beam calibration is implemented .
these steps are : 1 .
extracting measurements of perceived source flux densities versus time from observations ( [ pfluxes ] ) , 2 .
entering measurements into a gridded sky and finding crossing points ( [ gridding ] ) , 3 . solving a least - squares matrix formulation of the problem ( [ lstsqs ] ) , and , finally , 4 . deconvolving the irregularly sampled sky to create a smooth beam ( [ deconvolution ] ) .
we also discuss prior information that can be included to refine the beam model in [ priors ] .
the principal data needed for this approach are measurements of perceived flux density versus time for multiple calibrator sources as they drift through the primary beam . in practice ,
any method of extracting perceived individual source flux densities ( such as image plane analysis ) could be used ; the beam calibration procedure is agnostic as to the source of these measurements . in this work ,
we use delay / delay - rate ( ddr ) filters to extract estimates of individual source flux densities as a function of time and frequency .
the frequency information can be used to perform a frequency - dependent beam calibration if the snr in the observations is high enough .
these filters work in delay / delay - rate space ( the fourier dual of frequency / time space ) to isolate flux density per baseline from a specific geometric area on the sky ; for a full description of the technique , the reader is referred to @xcite .
the first step of our pipeline to produce perceived flux density estimates is to filter the sun from each baseline individually in ddr space .
this is done to ensure that little to no signal from the sun , which is a partially - resolved and time - variable source , remains in the data .
( in principle , data from different observing runs separated by several months could provide complete sky coverage while avoiding daytime data altogether .
we chose to use data from only one 24 hour period to minimize the effect of any long timescale instabilities in the system ) .
a markov - chain monte carlo ( mcmc ) method for extracting accurate time- and frequency - dependent source models via self - calibration using ddr - based estimators is then used to model the 4 brightest sources remaining : cygnus a , cassiopeia a , virgo a , and the crab nebula ( taurus a ) .
the mcmc aspect of this algorithm iterates on a simultaneous model of all sources being fit for to minimize sidelobe cross - terms between sources . after removing the models of cygnus
a , cassiopeia a , virgo a and taurus a from the data , a second pass of the mcmc ddr self - calibration algorithm extracts models of the remaining 22 sources listed in table [ srctable ]
. we can increase the signal - to - noise at a crossing point by combining all measurements within a region over which the primary beam response can be assumed to be constant . to define these regions , we grid the sky . in this work ,
the beam model is constructed on an healpix map @xcite with pixels @xmath11 on a side .
the choice of grid pixel size is somewhat arbitrary .
using a larger pixel size broadens the beam coverage of each source track , creating more crossing points and helping to constrain the overall beam shape .
however , when the pixels are too large , each pixel includes data from sources with larger separations on the sky .
since the principal tenet of this approach is that each source within a crossing point sees the same primary beam response , excessively large pixels can violate this assumption , resulting in an inaccurate beam model . for paper data , a healpix grid with @xmath12 pixels
is found to be a good balance between these competing factors , as will be explained in [ beamsims ] .
for other experiments with narrower , more rapidly evolving primary beams , smaller pixels may be necessary . to introduce our measurements of perceived flux density into the grid , we first recast equation [ basicmeas ] into a discrete form : @xmath13 where @xmath14 and @xmath15 are the respective perceived source flux densities and primary beam responses in the pixel @xmath16 , and @xmath17 is a source index labelling the inherent source flux density , @xmath3 . to generate a single measurement of a source for each pixel @xmath16
, we use a weighted average of all measurements of that source falling with a single pixel .
the weights are purely geometric and come from interpolating the measurement between the four nearest pixels .
once all the data are gridded , we solve equation [ healmeas ] for all crossing pixels simultaneously . to do this
, we set up a linearized least - squares problem using logarithms : @xmath18 because thermal noise in measurements becomes non - gaussian in equation [ logmeas ] , the solution to the logarithmic formulation of the least - squares problem is biased . in [ beamsims ]
, we investigate the effect of this bias using simulations and find that the accuracy of our results is not limited by this bias , but instead by sidelobes of other sources .
therefore , while equation [ basicmeas ] can in principle be solved without resorting to logarithms using an iterative least - squares approach , we find that this is not necessary given our other systematics .
once the logarithms are taken , we can construct a solvable matrix equation , which can be expressed generally as : @xmath19 where @xmath20 is a column - matrix of weights , @xmath21 is a column - matrix of measurements , @xmath22 is the matrix - of - condition , describing which measurements are being used to constrain which parameters , and @xmath23 is a column matrix containing all the parameters we wish to measure : the beam responses @xmath5 and the source flux densities @xmath3 . to illustrate the form of this equation , we present the matrix representation of the cygnus a / virgo a system shown in figure [ trackexample ] : @xmath24 on the left - hand side of the equation are the two column matrices @xmath20 and @xmath21 .
the weights , @xmath25 , are defined in [ weighting ] .
@xmath21 contains logarithms of the perceived source flux density measurements in each pixel , @xmath14 .
recall that each @xmath14 corresponds to one source . on the right - hand side
, the weighting column matrix @xmath20 appears again , followed by the matrix - of - condition @xmath22 , and then @xmath23 , a column matrix containing the parameters we wish to solve for : the primary beam response at the 6 crossing points and the flux densities of virgo and cygnus .
the matrix - of - condition , @xmath22 , identifies which sources and crossing points are relevant for each equation .
we have schematically divided it : to the left of the vertical line are the indices used for selecting a particular crossing point ; to the right are those for the sources .
the first 4 lines represent the two northern cygnus / virgo crossing points , and the next four represent the two southern ones ( which are identical copies of the northern ones ) .
finally , the last 4 lines represent the 2 points where virgo crosses itself ; notice that the cygnus source column is blank for these 4 rows .
it should be noted that equations [ matrix2 ] and [ matrix1 ] contains no absolute flux density reference . the simplest way to set
this scale is to treat all the recovered flux densities as relative values compared to the flux calibrator ( cygnus a in the case presented here ) .
one can then place all the flux densities onto this absolute scale .
an equally valid approach is to append an extra equation with a very high weight , which sets the flux calibrator to its catalog flux value . in a least - squares approach ,
optimal weights are inversely proportional to the variance of each measurement . to calculate the variance of each measurement , we must propagate the uncertainty in the initial perceived flux density measurements through the averaging and logarithm steps .
the noise level in each interferometric visibility is roughly constant , and the ddr filters average over a fixed number of visibilities for each perceived flux density estimate , leading to equal variance at each time sample . to produce optimal weights accounting for the many time samples averaged into each beam pixel and the propagation of noise through the logarithm , each logarithmic measurement in equation [ matrix2 ]
should be weighted by : @xmath26 where @xmath27 indexes the time step ( which is generally fast enough to produce many measurements inside a pixel ) , @xmath28 is the geometric sub - pixel interpolation weighting of each measurement , and @xmath14 is the weighted average of all measurements of a source s flux density in pixel @xmath16 . without the square root ,
these weights would be proportional to the inverse of the variance in each logarithmic measurement ; the sum over the geometric weights is the standard reduction of variance for a weighted average , and the factor of @xmath29 comes from propagating variances through the logarithm .
the square root appears because a least - squares solver using matrix inversion will add in an additional factor of the weight , leading to the desired inverse - variance weighting .
other solvers using different methods may require different weights .
the solution of equation [ matrix2 ] , the matrix @xmath22 , contains two distinct sets of parameters : the beam responses at crossing points and the flux densities of each source ( modulo an absolute scale ) .
there is additional information that may be included to improve the beam model beyond that generated by solving for the responses at crossing points .
given the flux - density solutions for each source , each source track now provides constraints on beam pixels that are not crossing points . by dividing each
perceived flux density source track by the estimated inherent flux density from the least - squares inversion , we produce a track of primary beam responses , with greater coverage than that provided by crossing points alone .
we illustrate the difference in coverage in figure [ cross_v_track ] .
used to calibrate the paper primary beam .
the projection is orthographic with zenith at the center ; dotted lines are @xmath30 and @xmath10 steps in elevation and azimuth , respectively . _
right : _ the sky coverage of all 25 source tracks .
although the least - squares inversion solves only for the beam response at crossing points , we can include all source track data using the recovered flux density of each source to create a primary beam estimate along the entire track . ]
the left hand panel shows the locations of crossing points for the 25 sources used to calibrate the paper beam , listed in table [ srctable ] .
the right hand panel shows the increased beam coverage that comes from including non - crossing point source - track data .
to create an initial beam model , we average within each pixel the estimated beam responses from each source , weighting by the estimated flux of that source . given equal variance in each initial perceived flux density measurement , this choice of weights is weighting by signal to noise . to produce a model of the beam response in any direction , we must fill in the gaps left by limited sky sampling .
we use a clean - like @xcite deconvolution algorithm in fourier space to fill in the holes in the beam .
we iteratively fit and remove a fraction of the brightest fourier component of our beam until the residuals between the model and the data are below a specified threshold .
in addition to measured beam responses derived from source tracks , we add the constraint that the beam must go to zero beyond the horizon . in the deconvolution
, each pixel is weighted by the estimate of the beam response in that pixel , reflecting that snr will be highest where the beam response is largest .
this beam - response weighting was unnecessary in previous steps , since the least - squares approach solved for each pixel independently .
this weighting scheme again represents signal - to - noise weighting , given the equal variance in our initial perceived flux density estimates .
the result of the deconvolution is an interpolated primary beam model with complete coverage across the sky . up to this point ,
we have made only two fairly weak assumptions about our beam : that it possesses @xmath9 rotational symmetry , and that the response is zero below the horizon . however ,
if we have additional prior knowledge about our beam , we can better constrain the final model . in particular
, we can use beam smoothness constraints to identify unphysically small scale features introduced by sidelobes in the source extraction or by incomplete sampling in the deconvolution .
we choose to incorporate additional smoothness information by filtering our model in fourier space to favor large - scale modes .
paper dipoles were designed with emphasis on spatial and spectral smoothness in primary beam shape . to smooth the paper beam model
, we choose a cutoff in fourier space that corresponds to the scale at which @xmath31 of the power is accounted for in a computed electromagnetic model of the beam .
while such a filter is not necessarily generalizable to other antenna elements , we find it necessary to suppress the substantial sidelobes associated with observations from a 12-antenna paper array that are discussed below .
to test the robustness of this approach , we apply it to several simulated data sets .
the results of these simulations , with and without gaussian noise , are described below in [ beamsims ] .
we also simulate raw visibility data to test the effectiveness of source extraction ; these simulations are discussed in [ vissims ] . the major difference between these two methods of simulation
is that the simulation using raw visibility data allows for imperfect source isolation , leading to contamination of the source tracks by sidelobes of other sources .
these sidelobes have a significant effect on the final beam model that is derived .
we simulate perceived flux density tracks using several model beams of different shapes , including ones with substantial ellipticity and an @xmath32 rotation around zenith .
we also input several source catalogs , including a case with @xmath33 jy sources spaced every degree in declination , and a case using the catalog values and sources listed in table [ srctable ] that approximately match the sources extracted from observations . in all combinations of beam models and source catalogs ,
we recover the input beam and source values with @xmath34 error .
the average error in source flux density is 2.5% .
we see no evidence for residual bias , as the distribution of error is consistent with zero mean to within one standard deviation .
we also test the effect of adding various levels of gaussian noise to a simulation involving a fiducial beam model and the 25 sources listed in table [ srctable ] .
only when the noise level exceeds an rms of 10 jy in each perceived flux density measurement does the mean error in the solutions exceed 10% .
as the noise increases beyond this level , there is a general trend to bias recovered flux densities upward ; as mentioned earlier , this bias is introduced by the logarithms in equation [ logmeas ] .
however , the expected corresponding noise level of ddr - extracted perceived flux density measurements from our 12-element paper array is @xmath35 jy per sample . at a simulated rms noise level of 1 jy
, the solutions are recovered with a mean error of @xmath36 .
this result validates our previous statement that the bias introduced by the logarithms in equation [ logmeas ] is not a dominant source of error .
it is also worth noting that these simulations were used to identify @xmath12 as the best healpix pixel side for our grid ; with too large a pixel size ( @xmath37 ) the model becomes significantly compromised .
this results from combining measurements of sources that are subject to significantly different primary beam responses .
we choose not to use a smaller pixel size , since it will reduce the fractional sky coverage of our crossing points and increase the computational demand of the algorithm .
we also apply this technique to simulated visibilities in order to test the complete analysis pipeline , including the ddr - based estimation of perceived source flux densities .
the visibility simulations are implemented in the aipy software toolkit .
the simulated observations correspond to actual observations made with the 12-element paper deployment in green bank described in
we match the observations in time , antenna position , and bandwidth .
we also include the expected level of thermal noise in the simulated visibilities . we simulate
perceived " visibilities by attenuating the flux density of each source by a model primary beam . the ddr filters return estimates of perceived source flux density for the input primary beam . in these simulations , we only include bright point sources and a uniform - disk model of the sun . as a result
, source extraction is expected to be more accurate in simulation than in real data , since the sources we extract account for @xmath38 of the simulated signal .
however , these simulations do provide a useful test of ddr - filter - based source extraction and of the level of contamination from sidelobes . as might be expected ,
the estimates of perceived source flux density versus time from simulated visibilities contain structure that is not attributable to the beam .
these features are almost all due to sidelobes of other sources ; they persist in real data and are reproducible over many days .
figure [ trackcompare ] shows the difference in the source tracks produced for cassiopeia a by each simulation method ( cases 1 and 2 in the figure ) , as well as the track extracted from the observed data described [ data ] ( case 3 ) .
we find that the ddr filter only extracts a fraction of the flux density from the crab nebula .
this bias is unique to crab , and is most likely a result of the proximity of the sun to crab in these observations , coupled with the limited number of independent baselines in the 12-antenna array .
for this reason , we choose to exclude the crab from our final analysis . performing the least - squares inversion described in [ lstsqs ] on the simulated source tracks , we find that the sidelobes introduce errors into estimates of source flux densities .
the average error in flux density is 10% , with the largest errors exceeding 20% .
the distribution of errors is consistent with zero mean , indicating no strong biasing of the flux densities .
we also find that the resultant primary beam model matches the input beam to within 15% percent .
however , the model contains small scale variations , as seen in figure [ filter ] . fills in gaps in sky coverage , but leaves small scale structure that is not associated with the primary beam ( gray curve ) . by filtering the solution in the fourier domain to incorporate prior knowledge of beam smoothness , one can achieve an improved beam model ( black curve ) . ] using prior knowledge of beam smoothness , we can reject these features as unphysical and apply a fourier - domain filter , as described in [ priors ] .
this filter reduces the effect of sidelobes in the source tracks , as they appear on fourier scales that are not allowed by smoothness constraints .
even with a relatively weak prior on smoothness ( i.e. , retaining more fourier modes than are present in our input model ) , we substantially reduce the small scale variations in our beam .
the effect of the filter on small scale variations is illustrated in figure [ filter ] .
the filter also reduces large scale errors in the model , bringing the overall agreement to with 10% of the input beam . in summary , we find that although interfering sidelobes from other sources compromise our source flux density measurements , our approach recovers the input primary beam model at the 15% level . with the introduction of a fourier space filter motivated by prior knowledge of the beam smoothness
, the output model improves to within 10% of the input .
it is also worth noting that the effectiveness of the beam calibration technique presented here will substantially improve with larger arrays , where sidelobe interference will be reduced and source tracks will more closely resemble the ideal case discussed in
[ beamsims ] .
in this section , we describe the application of this technique to 24 continuous hours of data taken with the paper array deployed at the nrao site near green bank from july 2 to july 3 , 2009 . at this time ,
the array consisted of 12 crossed - dipole elements . only the north / south linear polarization from each dipole was correlated .
the data used in this analysis were observed between 123 to 170 mhz ( avoiding rfi ) and were split in 420 channels .
the array was configured in a ring of 300 m radius .
the longest baselines are 300 m , while the shortest baseline is 10 m ; the configuration is shown in figure [ antpos ] .
this configuration gives an effective image plane resolution of @xmath39 .
in addition to the ddr - filter algorithm described in [ pfluxes ] , several other pre - processing steps are necessary .
per - antenna phase and amplitude calibration are performed by fringe fitting to cygnus a and other bright calibrator sources .
we also use a bandpass calibration based on the spectrum of cygnus a. this calibration is assumed to be stable over the full 24 hours .
two further steps in the reduction pipeline were first described in @xcite : gain linearization to mitigate data quantization effects in the correlator , and rfi excision .
new to this work is the use of the cable and balun temperatures to remove time - dependent gains caused by temperature fluctuations .
a thirteenth dipole was operated as the gain - o - meter " described in @xcite . in brief , the gain - o - meter " is an antenna where the balun is terminated on a matched load , rather than a dipole .
the measured noise power from this load tracks gain fluctuations in the system .
we record the temperature of several components of our gain - o - meter " using the system described in @xcite .
we find a strong correlation between the absolute gain of our system and the temperature of these components ; this effect is illustrated in figure [ tdepgains ] .
we correct for these gain changes by applying a linear correction derived from the measured temperature values .
this step is crucial for the success of the beam calibration ; without correcting for them , these gain drifts are indistinguishable from an east / west asymmetry in the primary beam . after these steps , we process the data with the ddr - filtering algorithm to produce estimates of perceived flux density versus time for the 25 sources listed in table [ srctable ] .
the first estimate of the paper primary beam derived with this approach is shown in figure [ dirtybeam ] . , dotted lines are @xmath30 and @xmath10 steps in elevation and azimuth , respectively . ]
this figure is produced by dividing each source track by an estimate of its inherent flux density produced by the least squares inversion .
this transforms each track into an estimate of the primary beam response , which are the added together into a healpix map .
there are significant fluctuations from pixel to pixel that are clearly unphysical , and relate to source sidelobes .
there are also significant gaps in beam coverage , even with 25 source tracks .
figure [ cleanbeam ] show the results after deconvolving the sampling pattern from figure [ dirtybeam ] . , dotted lines are @xmath30 and @xmath10 steps in elevation and azimuth , respectively .
this model was produced by deconvolving the sampling pattern from figure [ dirtybeam ] , interpolating over the gaps in declination where there are no strong calibrator sources . ]
the beam is now complete across the entire sky , although there is still substantial small - scale structure unrelated to the inherent beam response .
we suppress these features in our final model by retaining only the large scale fourier components , as described in [ deconvolution ] .
this final model is shown in figure [ filterbeam ] .
, the grayscale colors are linear and show the primary beam response , normalized to 1.0 at zenith .
solid black lines are contours of constant beam response in 10% increments ; the thick black line is the half - power point .
dotted lines are @xmath30 and @xmath10 steps in elevation and azimuth , respectively .
this smooth model was produced by retaining only the large scale fourier components from figure [ cleanbeam ] .
the cutoff in fourier space was derived from a computed electromagnetic paper beam simulation .
this fourier mode selection substantially smooths out variations in the initial solution that are unphysical based on the smoothness of beam response in the simulation . ]
it is clear that with our deconvolution and choice of fourier modes , we recover a very smooth , slowly evolving beam pattern , as expected from previous models of the paper primary beam .
the measured flux densities of the calibrator sources , produced by the least - squares inversion , are presented in table [ srctable ] .
the overall flux scale is normalized to the value of cygnus a reported in @xcite .
error - bars are estimated by measuring the change in flux necessary to increase @xmath40 between the model and the measured perceived source flux density tracks by 1.0 . as noted in
[ vissims ] , these flux densities can be compromised by sidelobes of other sources
. however , the results are generally accurate to within @xmath41 .
we perform several tests to investigate the validity of our results .
the comparison of our recovered fluxes to their catalog values shows generally good agreement .
as argued in @xcite and @xcite , there is considerable difficulty in accurately comparing catalogs , particularly at these frequencies .
differences in interferometer resolution and synthesized beam patterns can lead to non - trivial disagreement in measured source flux densities .
given this fact , and the complicated sidelobes associated with a 12-element array present in our method , we do not find the lack of better agreement with catalog fluxes troubling . to test the stability of our pipeline
, we test a separate observation spanning the following day .
the beam model produced by this data matches our first model to within 2.5% , and source flux densities remain consistent to 5% .
this test confirms our suspicion that our errors are not dominated by random noise .
we have presented a new technique for calibrating the primary beam of a wide - field , drift - scanning antenna element .
the key inputs to the method are measurements of perceived flux density of individual sources versus time as they drift through the beam . in this paper
, we use delay / delay - rate filters @xcite as estimators in a self - calibration loop to extract such measurements from raw interferometric data . however , the remainder of our method is agnostic to how these tracks are derived .
the only assumption necessary to make this an over - constrained and solveable problem is @xmath9 rotational symmetry in the beam . with this assumption , we create crossing points " where there is enough information for a least - squares inversion to solve for both the inherent flux density of each source and the response of primary beam at the crossing points .
we test this approach using simulated tracks of perceived source flux density across the sky and simulated visibilities . using the source tracks
, the least - squares inversion reliably recovers the primary beam values and source flux densities in the presence of noise 10 times that present in a 12-element paper array .
the simulated visibilities demonstrate that sidelobes of other bright sources are the source of the dominant errors in source extraction when only 12 antennas are used .
the presence of these features in the perceived source flux densities limits the accuracy of estimates of inherent source flux densities .
however , in simulation , we are able to recover a primary beam model accurate to within 15% percent and source flux densities with an average error of 10% . using prior information regarding beam smoothness , we improve our model to better than 10% accuracy .
while these caveats about the effectiveness of the least - squares technique in the presence of sidelobes may seem worrisome , it bears repeating that these are issues with data quality and not with the technique itself .
for example , data from a 32-element paper array has shown that ddr filters can extract the sources used in this analysis with little systematic biases .
( we do not use this data here do the lack of a temperature record for gain stabilization and the presence of a particularly active sun when the array was operating . )
therefore , it seems that this technique has significant potential for precise beam calibration on larger arrays .
another future goal for this technique is to calibrate the frequency - dependence of the beam . here
, we have used our entire bandwidth to improve signal - to - noise in source extractions . for a larger array with higher snr and lower sidelobes ,
our perceived source flux density measurements can be cut into sub - bands to look at the beam as a function of frequency .
finally , it is possible to forgo the assumption of @xmath9 rotational symmetry altogether and allow for possible north / south variation in the beam .
an experiment in which the dipoles are _ physically _ rotated on a daily basis can be used to create the same kind of crossing points , since one has changed the section of the beam each source crosses through .
work is progressing on such an experiment using the paper array .
the paper project is supported through the nsf - ast program ( award # 0804508 ) , and by significant efforts by staff at nrao s green bank and charlottesville sites .
paper acknowledges the significant correlator development efforts of jason r. manley .
we also thank our reviewer for their helpful comments .
arp acknowledges support from the nsf astronomy and astrophysics postdoctoral fellowship under award ast-0901961 .
ra & dec & measured flux density ( jy ) & catalog flux density ( jy ) & name + 1:08:54.37 & + 13:19:28.8 & @xmath42 & 58 , 49 & 3c 33 + 1:36:19.69 & + 20:58:54.8 & @xmath43 & 27 & 3c 47 + 1:37:22.97 & + 33:09:10.4 & @xmath44 & 50 & 3c 48 + 1:57:25.31 & + 28:53:10.6 & @xmath45 & 7.5 , 16 , 23 & 3c 55 + 3:19:41.25 & + 41:30:38.7 & @xmath46 & 50 & 3c 84 + 4:18:02.81 & + 38:00:58.6 & @xmath47 & 60 & 3c 111 + 4:37:01.87 & + 29:44:30.8 & @xmath48 & 204 & 3c 123 + 5:04:48.28 & + 38:06:39.8 & @xmath49 & 85 & 3c 134 + 5:42:50.23 & + 49:53:49.1 & @xmath50 & 63 & 3c 147 + 8:13:17.32 & + 48:14:20.5 & @xmath51 & 66 & 3c 196 + 9:21:18.65 & + 45:41:07.2 & @xmath52 & 42 & 3c 219 + 10:01:31.41 & + 28:48:04.0 & @xmath53 & 30 & 3c 234 + 11:14:38.91 & + 40:37:12.7 & @xmath54 & 21.5 & 3c 254 + 12:30:49.40 & + 12:23:28.0 & @xmath55 & 1100 & vir a + 14:11:21.08 & + 52:07:34.8 & @xmath56 & 74 & 3c 295 + 15:04:55.31 & + 26:01:38.9 & @xmath57 & 72 & 3c 310 + 16:28:35.62 & + 39:32:51.3 & @xmath58 & 49 & 3c 338 + 16:51:05.63 & + 5:00:17.4 & @xmath59 & 325 , 378 , 373 & her a + 17:20:37.50 & -0:58:11.6 & @xmath60 & 180 , 236 , 276 , 215 & 3c 353 + 18:56:36.10 & + 1:20:34.8 & @xmath61 & 680 & 3c 392 + 19:59:28.30 & + 40:44:02.0 & @xmath62 & 10623 & cyg a + 20:19:55.31 & + 29:44:30.8 & @xmath63 & 36 & 3c 410 + 21:55:53.91 & + 37:55:17.9 & @xmath64 & 43 & 3c 438 + 22:45:49.22 & + 39:38:39.8 & @xmath65 & 50 & 3c 452 + 23:23:27.94 & + 58:48:42.4 & @xmath66 & 6230 & cas a | we present a new technique for calibrating the primary beam of a wide - field , drift - scanning antenna element .
drift - scan observing is not compatible with standard beam calibration routines , and the situation is further complicated by difficult - to - parametrize beam shapes and , at low frequencies , the sparsity of accurate source spectra to use as calibrators .
we overcome these challenges by building up an interrelated network of source crossing points " locations where the primary beam is sampled by multiple sources . using the single assumption
that a beam has 180@xmath0 rotational symmetry , we can achieve significant beam coverage with only a few tens of sources .
the resulting network of crossing points allows us to solve for both a beam model and source flux densities referenced to a single calibrator source , circumventing the need for a large sample of well - characterized calibrators .
we illustrate the method with actual and simulated observations from the precision array for probing the epoch of reionization ( paper ) . |
when cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) photons pass through galaxy clusters , they compton up - scatter on hot electrons , making a small increment ( decrement ) above ( below ) the peak of the cmb primary spectrum .
the size of this distortion in the cmb spectrum , the sunyaev - zeldovich ( sz ) effect @xcite , is proportional to the electron pressure integrated along the line - of - sight . besides being an important probe of the physics of the intracluster medium
, the sz effect is a promising tool in cosmology : the signal produced by a cluster is practically redshift independent and can be observed to high redshifts .
the planck surveyor satellite @xcite will produce a cluster catalogue with up to @xmath010.000 ( sufficiently massive ) clusters out to @xmath1 @xcite . by combining sz and x - ray observations of relaxed clusters
the hubble constant @xmath2 can be derived , limits can be put on @xmath3 , and the gas mass fraction in clusters can be measured @xcite .
the sz effect was first detected in three nearby clusters more than two decades ago by @xcite , but the last five years , due to advances in sub millimetre receiver technology , routine measurements have been done for @xmath4 clusters using facilities such as the ovro and bima telescopes . right now a large number of telescopes have started observing the sz signal or are under construction ( e.g. acbar , carma , suzie iii , spt , apex etc . ) , and in the near future alma will gradually become online enabling unprecedented resolution and sensitivity for making detailed observations of individual clusters .
current sz surveys of galaxy clusters ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* for a set of current observations ) have observed the unresolved integrated sz signal from clusters , but with carma , alma and the spt also the sz signal as a function of radius from the cluster centre will be measured .
@xcite has used the 3rd year wmap data to extract sz images from 193 clusters . stacking them
they have obtained an averaged sz profile for clusters with @xmath5kev .
spatially resolved sz images probe , in a way complementary to x - ray observations , the distribution of thermal energy in clusters which in turn is closely linked to the total cluster mass . furthermore
, since the sz effect essentially depends on the electron pressure , the physics going into understanding it is simpler and more robust , than is the case for the x - ray emission . in this paper
we use realistic high resolution n - body / sph simulations of galaxy clusters and groups together with observed temperature profiles of nearby groups and clusters to predict the radial sz profile of different types of systems of galaxies , and compare our results to the averaged profile of @xcite .
we introduce a universal fitting formula , with only two free parameters , that can be employed in future observations .
furthermore , we show that fitting this profile enables a precise estimate of the total mass in the system . in the next section
we describe the computer experiments , that are used to construct the synthetic sz profiles . in section 3
we discuss the simulated data and present our results , and in section 4 we discuss and provide our conclusions .
we use 24 galaxy group and galaxy cluster simulations to study the sz effect for systems of virial temperatures of about 1 to 6 kev .
the models include 12 groups of approximately the same mass ( @xmath6 ) , 11 identical clusters with @xmath7 ( `` virgo '' clusters ) , but simulated with different gas physics , and a single large cluster of @xmath8 ( a `` coma '' cluster ) .
the models are re - simulated from a low resolution cosmological dark matter simulation , where the halos are identified with a halo finder .
the particles are traced back in time to a initial redshift @xmath9 , and the virial volume is repopulated with both gas and dark matter at a high resolution .
the code includes radiative cooling , star formation , supernova feedback , chemical evolution and back reaction from a redshift dependent uv field .
the different models are summarised in table [ tab : models ] . for a detailed description of the different gas physics going into the code in general , and the `` virgo '' cluster simulations in particular we refer to @xcite .
the groups were all selected at random , the only criterion being their virial mass , and therefore they comprise a cosmological fair sample of groups with @xmath10 .
the different masses of the clusters allow us to probe the mass dependence of the sz profile , while the `` virgo '' models are used to investigate how robust our predictions are for the sz profile with respect to assumptions on the underlying physics .
the groups , being a statistically unbiased sample , give limits on cosmic variance for the given virial mass ( @xmath11 ) . we have divided the groups into three different classes according to their morphology and evolutionary history : groups with merging activity ( 186,231,239,262 ) , fossil groups ( 189,228,236,244 ) and normal groups ( 190,233,247,276 ) . a group is considered fossil if the difference in apparent r - band magnitude of the first and second brightest galaxy is greater than two @xcite , and a group is merging if it by visual inspection has significant merging activity in the core , or if the rms scatter in 3d radial shells of the temperature , pressure and density , is comparable to the average value in the shell .
@c@c@c@c@c@ name&@xmath12\,\,$]&@xmath13\,\,$ ] & @xmath14$]&commentsgroups & 186 & 0.99 & 1.08 & @xmath15 & merging group189 & 1.07 & 1.09 & @xmath16 & cool - core , fossil group190 & 1.21 & 1.22 & @xmath17 & normal group 228 & 1.07 & 1.10 & @xmath18 & cool - core , fossil group231 & 0.99 & 1.08 & @xmath19 & merging group233 & 1.03 & 1.09 & @xmath20 & normal group 236 & 1.00 & 0.99 & @xmath21 & fossil group239 & 0.91 & 1.11 & @xmath22 & merging group244 & 1.13 & 1.08 & @xmath23 & fossil group247 & 1.01 & 1.15 & @xmath24 & normal group262 & 0.97 & 1.03 & @xmath25 & merging group276 & 1.02 & 1.07 & @xmath20 & cool - core groupclusters & ay - sw & 2.13 & 2.07 & @xmath26 & arimoto - yoshii imfay - sw-8 & 2.18 & 2.10 & @xmath27 & 8 times resolutionay - vol39 & 2.18 & 2.18 & @xmath27 & @xmath28 ay - swx2 & 2.18 & 2.04 & @xmath29 & 2 times snii feedback ay - swx4 & 2.17 & 2.09 & @xmath30 & 4 times snii feedback ay - ph0.75&2.23 & 2.10 & @xmath31 & preh .
@xmath32part @ z=3 ay - ph1.5 & 2.27 & 2.14 & @xmath33 & preh .
@xmath34part @ z=3 ay - ph50 & 2.19 & 2.07 & @xmath31 & preh . @xmath35part @ z=3 ay - cond & 2.26 & 2.08 & @xmath36 & thermal conduction sal - sw & 2.24 & 2.10 & @xmath37 & salpeter imf sal - wfb & 2.27 & 2.23 & @xmath31 & weak feedback coma & 5.57 & 5.27 & @xmath38 & relaxed massive cluster
the sz profiles of the simulated systems can only be used as templates for an universal fitting formula , if the profiles are in accordance with observations . in fig .
[ fig : szeprofs ] are shown the spherically averaged sz profiles compared to the only currently published sz profile ( @xcite ) , obtained using data from the wmap satellite .
the observed points may indicate a slightly more bended profile than the simulations , but within the 1-@xmath39 error bars there is fairly good agreement . from the simulations there is a clear trend towards steeper profiles , for more massive and relaxed clusters and groups reflecting differences in the underlying dm potentials ( see fig .
[ fig : dmpot ] ) .
this should be recalled when constructing an average observational profile , because the average profile may not represent a true ( `` universal '' ) physical profile , but rather a smeared average of the real profiles .
the central core of the sz profile ( @xmath40 can not be probed by wmap , due to its limited resolution of at most @xmath41 . to extend the dynamic range of the observations we combine gravitational potentials from the simulations with observed average x - ray temperature profiles . under the assumption of hydrostatic equilibrium in the core of the systems , we can then predict the inner part of the sz profile .
the compton @xmath42-parameter , which determines the overall temperature decrement in the cmb radiation due to the sz effect , is proportional to the integrated pressure @xmath43 of the electrons along the line of sight @xmath44 assuming hydrostatic equilibrium and spherical symmetry @xmath45 we can use the proportionality of @xmath43 , and the compton @xmath42-parameter in a volume element , @xmath46 , to obtain @xmath47 we have constructed three different averaged gravitational potentials based on the normal groups , the fossil groups and the `` virgo '' clusters . for the temperature profiles we use observed clusters by @xcite , and make one average profile constructed from the galaxy groups with virial temperatures less than 2.5 kev , and one constructed from the massive clusters in the sample with virial temperatures between 3.5 and 8.5 kev .
the dark matter distribution , derived from the simulations , is quite robust against the specific gas physics involved in the simulation .
this is demonstrated in fig .
[ fig : dmpot ] , where it is seen that all the `` virgo '' models , in spite of the different gas physics , have essentially the same gravitational potentials from @xmath48 and outwards . however , there are systematic differences between different types of systems with the same mass .
fossil groups are more relaxed compared to normal groups , and their mass distribution is similar to relaxed clusters , like the `` virgo '' and `` coma '' models from @xmath48 and outwards ( see fig . [
fig : dmpot ] ) .
therefore the above reconstruction procedure gives a good idea of future resolved sz observations of the cores of clusters of galaxies , and our six resolved profiles are a fair sample of what can be expected . from fig .
[ fig : szeprofs ] it is clear , that albeit the sz profiles constructed from the observed temperature profiles and the dark matter density profiles are in approximate agreement with the profiles extracted from the simulations , they have a tendency to be more peaked at the centre .
this can be traced to differences in the observed and simulated temperature profiles ( see e.g. eq . [
eq : hs ] ) , and to the typical masses of the observed systems .
the different temperature profiles are normalised with a global temperature @xmath49 . to enable direct comparison to the observed temperature profiles by @xcite we compute @xmath49 as the average projected spectral - like temperature @xcite in the interval @xmath50 .
all profiles converge to the same universal curve for @xmath51 , but in the inner part of the systems there are differences ( see fig .
[ fig : tempprof ] ) .
the simulated systems have all flat profiles at the core , which are in good qualitative agreement with observations of clusters of similar virial mass , but the average observed profiles have lower normalised temperatures towards the centre , with more or less the same offset between the `` coma '' cluster and the observed cluster profile ( constructed from clusters with 3.5 kev @xmath52 8.5 kev ) , and between the average simulated and observed group temperature profiles ( the latter constructed from groups with @xmath53 kev @xcite ) .
the offset compared to observations and relatively flat temperature profiles are well known problems for simulations invoking radiative cooling and feedback processes ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , but it is further accentuated by an offset in mass between the observed and simulated groups and the observed clusters , and the simulated `` virgo '' clusters . as can be seen in fig .
[ fig : szeprofs ] all the sz profiles have nearly the same form , but the overall normalisation , tension and slope of the different profiles depends on the mass , and the specific cluster . to construct a simple model we have tried to fit a variety of combinations of beta profiles and exponential profiles for the density combined with a polytropic or isothermal equation of state , but it does not yield a satisfactory fit . the correct temperature to use , when constructing a sz profile , is the mass weighted , and it does not necessarily agree with the temperature inferred from x - ray observations ( @xcite ) , which may explain why the above combination works well for x - ray observations , while not so for our sample of sz profiles . to circumvent this problem we are using a novel universal profile that directly fit the data , without assuming anything about the underlying temperature and density distributions , while using as few parameters as possible .
the main morphological differences are in the slope / tension and in the normalisation of each profile , and it is indeed possible to construct a model , that with only two free parameters , a normalisation , and a characteristic scale can fit the full set of simulations and observations in detail .
the profiles extracted from the simulated data do not per se contain any errors , but a measure of the natural scatter in a profile @xmath54 at a given radial distance , is the variance @xmath55 of @xmath56 inside the radial bin at @xmath57 .
we have used this variance estimate to construct a goodness of fit parameter @xmath58 for each projected 2d and spherically averaged 3d profile @xmath59 , @xmath60 given by @xmath61 where @xmath62 is the model with parameters @xmath63 .
the internal scatter in relaxed systems is much smaller , giving stronger constraints than from merging systems .
this is sensible , since the observational scatter among relaxed clusters is smaller too .
we have found that using a triple exponential model gives an excellent fit to the data : @xmath64\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath65 .
while this model at first sight might appear complicated , it has two attractive features : ( i ) the 2d profile can be derived in a closed form from the 3d profile .
( ii ) most of the parameters can be fixed to global values , leaving only two free parameters for fitting all systems considered in this paper . with only two parameters in the model
it can readily be applied to future observations , even if they only map the sz profile with a few observational points . by integrating along one of the axes we find the 2d profile to be @xmath66 r\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath67 is the modified bessel function of the second kind .
minimising @xmath68 simultaneously for all models over the range @xmath69 , while varying @xmath70 and @xmath71 as global parameters , and @xmath72 , @xmath73 for each model , treating the @xmath74 , @xmath75 , and @xmath76projections as different clusters , we find the global best fit parameters to be @xmath77 in fig .
[ fig : gof ] we see how these yield very reasonable @xmath58 for all projections , and the 3d profiles .
the only systems that have a @xmath58 significantly larger than one are either merging , or characterised by a very smooth profile with almost no variation in the radial bin , and hence a very small @xmath55 ( see e.g. fig . [
fig : profiles ] ) .
+ + the two free parameters , the overall scale @xmath73 , and the overall normalisation @xmath72 scale with @xmath78 and with @xmath79 , the integrated sz effect inside @xmath78 , respectively , but there is a large scatter between different clusters , where the tightest relation is found for the fossil groups , that act as an extension of the clusters with almost the same scaling relation .
they are related as @xmath80 to push the boundaries of our fitting formula for other systems we have also applied it to the @xcite data , and the profiles for the centre of the systems , derived from observed temperature profiles ( see fig . [
fig : fits ] ) .
the average sz profile is described well by the formula , while there are problems with fitting the core ( @xmath81 ) of the cluster set of central profiles ( the lower right panel in fig .
[ fig : fits ] ) . even though some of these combinations ( e.g. a normal group dm potential combined with a massive cluster temperature profile ) are extreme , the lack of agreement may be because in the central parts of the observed systems there are significant non - thermal contributions to the pressure balance from e.g. an agn @xcite or from cosmic rays @xcite , and hence the assumption of hydrostatic equilibrium does not apply . or it may be that the simulated systems do not include an adequate description of the physical processes in the centre of the systems . nonetheless , the contribution of the central @xmath82 to the total sz signal is approximately 5% , and the parameters are not much affected even if we can not reconstruct the innermost part of the profiles with perfection .
the sz profile of the systems seems to be universally well described by only two parameters , except for possibly in the central parts of the clusters .
it measures the distribution of thermal energy in the system , and is therefore related to the gravitational potential , if we assume the system is relaxed . using assumptions about hydrostatic equilibrium and using a phenomenological approach several `` fundamental plane '' relations
have been constructed ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the main ingredients for the fundamental plane has been the integrated sz effect and a characteristic scale in the system , for example @xmath83 , the radius enclosing half of the integrated signal .
this has given a relation between the integrated sz effect , a characteristic scale , and the total mass with a rough scatter of 14% @xcite .
with our fit to the profiles we get a very precise measurement of this characteristic scale , that take into account the different bending of the profiles .
fitting the total mass as a function of @xmath79 and @xmath73 we find ( see fig . [
fig : massrel ] ) instead of @xmath79 , but it does not yield as good a fit . ]
@xmath84 with only a 4% scatter . in @xcite a phenomenological model is used to construct a set of , essentially , one dimensional models for the clusters .
it includes normal or tophat distributed controlling parameters , with broadening in agreement with observed clusters . to check
if the smaller scatter we see for eq . [ eq : massestimate ] is due to more similarity in the simulated systems , we have tried to use the fundamental plane of @xcite , on the simulated systems .
we find good agreement with a 15% scatter for our data ( see fig .
[ fig : massrel ] ) .
+ the first resolved sz profiles will be obtained for nearby massive clusters . to make a crude test for how our fitting formula works on real data ,
we have made a set of mock observations taking as a starting point the most massive cluster in our sample , the `` coma '' cluster .
we use five logaritmically spaced rings at a distance of @xmath85\,{r_{180}}$ ] .
the resolution of the first generation of sz instruments is limited , and therefore we have chosen not to include observational points at smaller radii . to get a good measure of the scatter we generated @xmath86 mock observations , with normal distributed logarithmic error bars of 0.22 dex on the total in each ring @xmath87 , giving an relative error of @xmath88 on @xmath87 itself . for simplicity we have disregarded any correlation there may exist between the different radial bins , and artificially have fixed the relative errors to a uniform level .
the five rings are then fitted ( see fig .
[ fig : synth ] ) using eq .
( [ eq : profile ] ) giving @xmath73 .
the integrated sz effect @xmath79 for each mock observation is found by integrating the fitted profile . inserting @xmath73 and @xmath79 derived from each mock observation into eq .
( [ eq : massestimate ] ) we find a reconstructed mass of @xmath89 , or an @xmath90 error on the reconstructed mass .
there is a @xmath91 systematic offset compared to the real mass of @xmath92 . with five rings
the error on the total signal is @xmath93 .
the mass goes roughly as @xmath94 , and we would expect roughly a @xmath95 error on the mass , in agreement with what is found .
in this paper we have constructed a simple empirical model for the radial profile of the sunyaev zeldovich effect in groups and clusters of galaxies .
the model has been motivated by , and validated against a mixture of simulations and observations , and is characterised by only two parameters : the overall normalisation , and a typical length scale related to the slope of the profile .
it gives a very good fit to the simulated systems , and there is a tight relation between the parameters and the total mass of the system .
furthermore , the results are robust to the detailed gas physics employed in the simulations .
this can be seen by considering the subset of the systems , the `` virgo '' clusters , that are started from the same initial conditions , but simulated with different implementations of the gas physics ( see table 1 ) .
because of the different gas physics there is an appreciable scatter in @xmath79 , but still the mass ( @xmath96 ) of the clusters is well reconstructed ( see fig .
[ fig : massrel ] ) .
the simulations are in good agreement with an observed average profile extracted from wmap data for the outer part of the sz profiles @xmath97 .
currently there are no published high resolution observations of the core sz profile , but we can get an indirect measure by using temperature profiles extracted from clusters observed in x - rays together with dark matter potentials from the simulations . reconstructing the sz profile , under the assumption of hydrostatic equillibrium , we see that these `` core profiles '' are relative peaked , compared to the simulations .
this is traced to differences in the temperature profile of the simulated systems , compared to what is observed using x - rays .
we have to await future observations of the resolved cluster cores , to determine to what extent this cusp in the central part is real , or a result of the hypothesis of hydrostatic equilibrium , which is known to be violated in the centre of clusters of galaxies , where non - thermal processes such as agn heating @xcite , and cosmic rays @xcite can play an important role for the pressure balance .
we stress that the model we have presented here is readily applicable to future observations .
this will give a good proxy for the mass of the observed system .
it will also help in reconstructing the full sz profile from observations with low spatial resolution , to be used in conjunction with x - ray observations in the study of cluster dynamics . a fitting routine written in idl for the profile that can be applied to observed or simulated data can be found at + http://www.phys.au.dk/~haugboel/software.shtml .
we thank the danish center for scientific computing for granting the computer resources that made this work possible .
the dark cosmology centre is funded by the danish national research foundation .
this research was supported by the dfg cluster of excellence `` origin and structure of the universe '' .
kp acknowledges support from the instrument center for danish astrophysics . | the sunyaev - zeldovich ( sz ) effect gives a measure of the thermal energy and electron pressure in groups and clusters of galaxies . in the near future sz surveys
will map hundreds of systems , shedding light on the pressure distribution in the systems .
the thermal energy is related to the total mass of a system of galaxies , but it is only a projection that is observed through the sz effect . a model for the 3d distribution of pressure is needed to link the sz signal to the total mass of the system . in this work
we construct an empirical model for the 2d and 3d sz profile , and compare it to a set of realistic high resolution sph simulations of galaxy clusters and groups , and to a stacked sz profile for massive clusters derived from wmap data .
furthermore , we combine observed temperature profiles with dark matter potentials to yield an additional constraint , under the assumption of hydrostatic equilibrium .
we find a very tight correlation between the characteristic scale in the model , the integrated sz signal , and the total mass in the systems with a scatter of only 4% .
the model only contains two free parameters , making it readily applicable even to low resolution sz observations of galaxy clusters .
a fitting routine for the model that can be applied to observed or simulated data can be found at http://www.phys.au.dk/~haugboel/software.shtml . |
experimental observations and robust theoretical arguments have established that our universe is essentially non - visible , the luminous matter scarcely accounting for one per cent of the critical density of a flat universe ( @xmath0 ) .
the current picture describes an universe consisting of unknown species of dark energy ( @xmath1 ) and dark matter ( @xmath2 ) of which less than @xmath3 is of baryonic origin .
most of the dark matter would then be made of non - baryonic particles filling the galactic halos , at least partially , according to a variety of models .
weak interacting massive ( and neutral ) particles ( wimps ) are favourite candidates to such non - baryonic components . the lightest stable particles of supersymmetric theories , like the neutralino , describe a particular class of wimps . without entering into considerations about how about how large the baryonic dark component of the galactic halo could be ,
we take for granted that there is enough room for wimps in our halo , to try to detect them , either directly or through their by - products .
discovering this form of dark matter is one of the big challenges in cosmology , astrophysics and particle physics .
wimps can be looked for either directly or indirectly .
the indirect detection of wimps proceeds currently through two main experimental lines : either by looking in cosmic rays experiments for positrons , antiprotons , or other antinuclei produced by the wimps annihilation in the halo ( caprice , bess , ams , glast , veritas , magic ... ) , or by searching in large underground detectors ( superkamiokande , sno , soudan , macro ) or underwater neutrino telescopes ( baikal , amanda , antares , nestor ) for upward - going muons produced by the energetic neutrinos emerging as final products of the wimps annihilation in celestial bodies ( sun , earth ... ) .
this talk will deal with the direct detection of wimps .
the direct detection of wimps relies in the measurement of the wimp elastic scattering off the target nuclei of a suitable detector . pervading the galactic halos , slow moving ( @xmath4
km / s ) , and heavy ( @xmath5 gev ) wimps could make a nucleus recoil with a small energy of a few kev ( @xmath6 kev ) , at a rate which depends of the type of wimp and interaction .
only a fraction of the recoil , qt , is visible in the detector , depending on the type of detector and target and on the mechanism of energy deposition .
the so - called quenching factor , q , is essentially unit in thermal detectors whereas for the nuclei used in conventional detectors it ranges from about 0.1 to 0.6 .
for instance for a ge nucleus only about 1/4 of the recoil energy goes to ionization . on the other hand ,
the smallness of the neutralino - matter interaction cross - section makes the rates of the nuclear recoil looked for very small .
the variety of models and parameters used to describe the astrophysics , particle physics and nuclear physics aspects of the process make the neutralino - nucleus interaction rate encompass several orders of magnitude , going from 10 to @xmath7 c / kg day , according to the susy model and parameters@xcite .
in fact , it is not higher than @xmath8 c / kg day , for the neutralino parameters which provide the most favourable relic density ( @xmath9 ) . due to such small rate and small energy deposition produced by the wimp elastic scattering ,
the direct search for particle dark matter through their scattering by nuclear targets requires ultralow background detectors of a very low energy threshold .
moreover , the ( almost ) exponentially decreasing shape of the predicted nuclear recoil spectrum mimics that of the low energy background registered by the detector . all these features together make the wimp detection a formidable experimental challenge .
customarily , one compares the predicted event rate with the observed spectrum .
if the former turns out to be larger than the measured one , the particle which would produce such event rate can be ruled out as a dark matter candidate .
that is expressed as a contour line @xmath10(m ) in the plane of the wimp - nucleon elastic scattering cross section versus the wimp mass .
that excludes , for each mass m , those particles with a cross - section above the contour line @xmath10(m ) .
the level of background sets , consequently , the sensitivity of the experiment in eliminating candidates or in constraining their masses and cross sections .
however , this mere comparison of the expected signal with the experimentally observed spectrum will not be able to detect the wimp , because such spectrum , even extremely small , could still be due to pure background sources .
in other words , it would be difficult to be convinced that such signal is due to wimps and not to mere background sources . a convincing proof of the detection of wimps would need to find unique signatures in the data characteristic of them and not of the background .
there exist some temporal or spatial asymmetries specific of the wimp interaction , which can not be faked by the background or by instrumental artifacts .
they are due to the kinematics of the motion of the earth ( and of our detectors ) in the galactic halo .
the only distinctive signature investigated up to now is a predicted annual modulation of the wimp signal rate due to the seasonal variation produced by the earth s motion with respect to the sun .
such a seasonal affect has been found by the dama experiment at the @xmath11 level and has been associated to the existence of a wimp .
the detectors used so far are : ionization detectors of ge ( igex , cosme , h / m , hdms ) and of si ( ucsb ) , scintillation crystals of nai ( zaragoza , dama , ukdmc , saclay , elegants ) , liquid or liquid - gas xenon detectors ( dama , ucla , ukdmc ) , calcium fluoride scintillators ( milan , osaka , roma ) , thermal detectors ( bolometers ) with saphire absorbers ( cresst , rosebud ) , with telurite absorbers , ( mibeta , cuoricino ) or with germanium absorbers ( rosebud ) as well as bolometers which also measure the ionization , like that of si ( cdms ) and of ge ( cdms , edelweiss ) .
new detectors and techniques are entering the stage .
worth to be mentioned are : scintillating bolometers of calcium tungstate which measure heat and high ( cresst and rosebud ) , and of bgo ( rosebud ) ; a tpc sensitive to the direction of the nuclear recoil ( drift ) ; devices which use superheated droplets ( simple and picasso ) , or those which use colloids of superconducting superheated grains ( orpheus ) . there exist also projects featuring a large amount of target nuclei in segmented detectors , both with ionization ge detectors ( genius , gedeon ) and cryogenic thermal devices ( cuore ) .
table 4 gives an overview of the experiments on direct detection of wimps currently in operation or in preparation .
a review of neutralino dark matter can be found in ref @xcite . wimp direct detection
are reviewed , for instance in ref @xcite and @xcite .
recent results are given in ref @xcite .
the smallness and rarity of wimp signals dictate the experimental strategies for their detection : reduce first the background , by controlling the radiopurity of the detector , its components , the shielding and the environment .
the best radiopurity has been obtained in conventional ge experiments ( igex , h / m ) . in the case of the nai scintillators ( dama , ukdm , anais ) ,
the achieved backgrounds are still one order of magnitude worse than those reached in ge , but the use of new radiopure powder in the crystals has lead to substantial improvements ( dama ) . the next step is to use discrimination mechanisms able to distinguish electron recoils ( tracers of the background ) from nuclear recoils ( originated by wimps or neutrons ) .
two types of techniques have been applied for such purpose : a statistical pulse shape analysis ( psd ) based on the different timing behaviour of both types of pulses and a background rejection method based on the identification ( on an event - by - event basis ) of the nuclear recoils , by measuring at the same time two different mechanisms of energy deposition , like the ionization ( or scintillation ) and heat , capitalizing the fact that for a given deposited energy ( measured as phonons ) the recoiling nucleus ionizes less than the electrons .
examples of psd are ukdmc , saclay , dama and anais , whereas the event by event discrimination has been successfully applied in cdms and edelweiss by measuring ionization and heat and now in cresst and rosebud by measuring light and heat .
a promising discriminating technique is that used in the two - phase liquid - gas xenon detector with ionization plus scintillation , of the zeplin series of detectors .
an electric field prevents recombination , the charge being drifted to create a second pulse in addition to the primary pulse .
the amplitudes of both pulses are different for nuclear recoils and gammas allowing their discrimination .
another technique is to discriminate gamma background from neutrons ( and so wimps ) using threshold detectors like neutron dosimeters which are blind to most of the low linear energy transfer ( let ) radiation ( e , @xmath12 , @xmath13 ) .
detectors which use superheated droplets which vaporize into bubbles by the wimp ( or other high let particles ) energy deposition are simple and picasso . an ultimate discrimination will be the identification of the different kind of particles by the tracking they left in , say , a tpc , plus the identification of the wimp through the directional sensitivity of the device ( drift ) .
obviously one should try to make detectors of very low energy threshold and high efficiency to see most of the signal spectrum , not just the tail .
that is the case for the bolometer experiments which seen efficiently the energy delivered by the wimp ( quenching factor is unity ) , ( mibeta , cresst , rosebud , cuoricino , cdms and edelweiss ) .
after the process of reducing and identifying the background is driven to its best , then one should search for distinctive signatures of the dark matter particles to prove that you are , indeed , seeing a wimp .
identifying labels are derived from the earth motion through the galactic halo , which produces two assymetries distinctive of wimps : first , the earth orbital motion around the sun has a summer - winter variation which results in a small ( 5% ) annual modulation of the wimp interaction rates ; and second , the earth ( and solar system ) motion through the galactic centre produces a large ( @xmath14 ) directional assymetry forward - backward of the recoiling nucleus .
the annual modulation signature has been already explored .
pioneering searches for wimp annual modulation signals were carried out in canfranc ( nai-32 ) , kamioka ( elegants ) and gran sasso ( dama - xe ) .
recently the dama experiment at gran sasso , using a set of nai scintillators reported in 1997 and 2000 an annual modulation effect of at the @xmath11 level interpreted as due to a wimp of about 60 gev of mass and scalar cross - section on protons of @xmath15 picobarns .
as far as the forward - backward assymetry of the signal is concerned the drift project will search for it .
information and current results of the experiments mentioned above can be found in references @xcite and @xcite . in particular , in the underground facility of the canfranc tunnel ( spain ) , various of the techniques mentioned above
are currently employed in a search for wimps@xcite : ge ionization detectors , ( cosme and igex ) , sodium iodine scintillators ( nai-32 and anais ) , thermal detectors with al@xmath16o@xmath17 and ge absorbers ( rosebud - i ) as well as and with calcium tungstate and bgo scintillating bolometers ( rosebud - ii ) . to illustrate how these searches proceed we will present the case for ge detectors , and
will describe its status , achievements and results . as one of the main achievements in ge experiments
is their low radioactive background , essential ingredient in the search for dark matter , we will illustrate it with a saga of germanium experiments performed in canfranc and the succesive suppresion of the background obtained .
such reduction has provided the lowest raw background rate obtained so far and , consequently , the stringest exclussion plots ever derived with ionization detectors .
the high radiopurity and low background achieved in germanium detectors , their fair low energy threshold , their reasonable quenching factor ( about 25% ) ( nuclear recoil ionization efficiency relative to that of electrons of the same kinetic energy , or ionization yield ) and other nuclear merits make germanium a good option to search for wimps with detectors and techniques fully mastered .
the first detectors applied to wimp direct searches ( as early as in 1987 ) were , in fact , ge diodes , as by - products of @xmath18-decay dedicated experiments .
the exclusion plots @xmath10(m ) for spin - independent couplings obtained by former ge experiments [ pnnl / usc / zaragoza ( twin @xcite and cosme-1@xcite@xcite ) , ucsb @xcite , calt / neu / psi @xcite , h / m @xcite ] are still remarkable and have not been surpassed till recently by nai experiments ( dama)@xcite using statistical pulse shape discrimination ( psd ) or by cryogenic experiments measuring both heat and ionization like cdms@xcite and edelweiss@xcite .
table 5 shows the germanium ionization detector experiments currently in operation .
a ge detector of natural isotopic abundance ( cosme ) of the u. zaragoza / u. s. carolina / pnnl collaboration and another one ( rg - ii ) made of enriched @xmath19ge of the igex collaboration are being used in canfranc to search for wimps interacting coherently with the ge nuclei of the detectors .
the cosme detector was fabricated at princeton gamma - tech , inc . in princeton ,
new jersey , using germanium of natural isotopic abundance .
the refinement of newly - mined germanium ore to finished metal for this detector was expedited to minimize production of cosmogenic @xmath20ge .
the detector is a p - type coaxial hyperpure natural germanium crystal with a mass of 254 g and an active mass of 234 g which has a long term resolution of 0.43 kev full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) at the 10.37 kev gallium x - ray . in its first canfranc installation ( at 675 m.w.e )
the detector was placed within a shielding of 10 cm of 2000 yr .
old ( roman ) lead ( inner layer ) plus 20 cm of low activity lead ( about 70 yr old ) .
a 3 mm thick pvc box sealed with silicone closed the lead shielding to purge the radon gas .
the pvc box was covered by 1 mm of cadmium and 20 cm of paraffin and borated polyethylene . all the shielding and
mounting was supported by 10 cm of vibrational and acoustic insulator sandwiched within two layers of 10 cm of wood mounted on a floor of concrete ( 20 cm ) .
it was operated in the former canfranc underground facility at 675 m.w.e . in a small gallery of the canfranc railway tunnel in the spanish pyrenees closed to the traffic . in that set - up ,
the energy threshold was @xmath21 kev and the background at threshold was about 10 counts kev@xmath22 kg@xmath22 day@xmath22 .
after about 500 days of data taking ( referred as cosme-1 experiment ) no signal originated by wimp appeared and , from the background spectrum , an exclusion plot in the cross - section versus wimp masses plane was derived , assuming wimp - matter spin - independent couplings . in the cosme-1 data , the energy range chosen to derive the exclusion plot was from 1.6 to 8 kev where the background was , approximately , 5 counts/(kev kg day ) . in spite of such modest figure , the results after 130 kg day of exposure improved the exclusion plots at low masses ( from 9 to 20 gev ) obtained with other ge experiments because of the low threshold energy of cosme-1 .
the cosme detector has been reinstalled , in better background conditions in the new canfranc underground laboratory lsc ( at 2450 m.w.e . ) inside a marinelli beaker in roman lead ( cosme-2 ) in a common shielding ( described later ) together with the three 2.1 kg enriched germanium detectors of igex ( the international germanium experiment on double beta decay ) . in its new installation , cosme-2 has an energy threshold of @xmath23 kev , and an energy resolution of @xmath24 kev at 10 kev .
the average background rate , in 311 days of exposure ( mt=72.8 kg day ) is 0.6 c/(kev kg day ) from 2 to 15 kev and 0.3 c/(kev kg day ) from 15 to 30 kev which is significantly better ( more than one order of magnitude ) than in cosme-1 .
the cosme-2 spectrum is shown in fig . [ fig_1 ] together with that of cosme-1 , to show the remarkable background reduction obtained in the new set - up and shielding and the disappearance of the cosmogenically induced peaks in the 8 - 10 kev energy region due to the about ten years elapsed between the two experiments .
the numerical data of cosme 2 are given in table [ tab - cos-9 ] .
.low - energy data from the cosme-2 detector ( mt @xmath25 73 kg - d ) .
[ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] the exclusion plots resulting from the igex-2000 data are derived from the recorded spectrum fig . 2 in one - kev bins from 4 kev to 50 kev .
the method followed in deriving the plot has been the same for all the detectors .
as recommended by the particle data group , the predicted signal in an energy bin is required to be less than or equal to the ( 90% c.l . )
upper limit of the ( poisson ) recorded counts .
the derivation of the interaction rate signal supposes that the wimps form an isotropic , isothermal , non - rotating halo of density @xmath26 gev/@xmath27 , have a maxwellian velocity distribution with @xmath28 km / s ( with an upper cut corresponding to an escape velocity of 650 km / s ) , and have a relative earth - halo velocity of @xmath29 km / s .
the cross sections are normalized to the nucleon , assuming a dominant scalar interaction .
the helm parameterization@xcite is used for the scalar nucleon form factor , and the recoil energy dependent ionization yield used is the same that in ref @xcite @xmath30 .
the exclusion plots obtained from the cosme-2 spectrum ( fig .
[ fig_1 ] and table [ tab - cos-9 ] ) and from cosme-1 ( fig .
1 ) have been calculated , as previously noted , in the same way as for igex . as shown in fig .
3 , the igex-2000 results@xcite ( thick - solid line ) exclude wimp - nucleon cross - sections above 1.3x10@xmath31 nb for masses corresponding to the 50 gev dama region . also shown is the combined germanium contour ( thin - dashed line ) , including the last heidelberg - moscow data@xcite ( recalculated from the original energy spectra with the same set of hypotheses and parameters ) , the dama experiment contour plot derived from pulse shape discriminated spectra@xcite , and the dama region corresponding to their reported annual modulation effect@xcite .
the igex-2000 exclusion contour@xcite improves that of other germanium experiments for masses between 20 gev and 200 gev , which includes the mass region corresponding to the neutralino tentatively assigned to the dama modulation effect and results from using only raw data without background subtraction .
the cosme-2@xcite@xcite exclusion contour also slightly improves the ge - combined plot for masses between 20 and 40 gev .
then , a new set - up was constructed , with the purpose of further improving the background . in particular
all the detectors except igex rg - ii were removed from the shielding , leaving rg - ii alone .
a new , thorough cleaning of the inner layers of the bricks of lead was performed , and the free space left was stretched . in this
new set - up , the detector rg - ii is surrounded by not less than 40 - 45 cm of lead of which 25 cm are archaeological . also the muon veto covers now more completely the ensemble , because three dewars have been removed .
a substantied improvement is that of the neutron shielding which has been enlarged to up to 40 cm of thickners , consisting of polyethylene blocks and borated water tanks .
= 7.5 cm the results obtained whit this new shielding are from a recent run and correspond to an exposure of mt=80 kg days@xcite . the spectrum obtained in this new set - up , and labelled igex-2001 ,
is shown in figure 4 compared with the previous igex-2000 spectrum@xcite .
the numerical data are given in table 3 .
= 7.5 cm the energy threshold of the detector is , as in previous runnings , 4 kev and the fwhm energy resolution at the 75 kev pb x - ray line is 800 ev .
the background rate recorded was @xmath32 c / kev / kg / day between 410 kev , @xmath33 c / kev / kg / day between 1020 kev , and @xmath34
c / kev / kg / day between 2540 kev .
as it can be seen , the background below 10 kev has been substantially reduced ( about a factor 50% ) with respect to that obtained in the previous set - up of igex-2000 , essentially due to the improved shielding ( both in lead and in polyethylene - water).this suggests that the neutrons could be an important component of the low energy background in igex@xcite . the new exclusion plot derived in this improved conditions igex-2001@xcite
is shown in fig .
[ dm - ig-5 ] ( thick solid line ) .
it improves the igex-2000@xcite exclussion contourn ( thick dashed line ) as well as that of the other previous germanium ionization experiments ( and in particular that of the last result of heidelberg - moscow experiment@xcite now specifically depicted by the thick dotted line ) for a mass range from 20 gev zone to 200 gev , which encompass , as already said , that of the dama mass region . in particular , this new igex result excludes wimp - nucleon cross - sections above 7 @xmath35 pb for masses of 40 - 60 gev and enters the dama region .
igex excludes the upper left part of this region .
that is the first time that a direct search experiment without background discrimination , but with very low ( raw ) background , enters such region .
also shown for comparison are the contour lines of the other experiments , cdms@xcite and edelweiss@xcite ( thin dashed line ) , which have entered that region by using bolometers which also measure ionization .
the dama region ( closed line ) corresponding to the @xmath11 annual modulation effect reported by that experiment@xcite and the exclusion plot obtained by dama nai-0@xcite ( thin solid line ) by using statistical pulse shape discrimination are also shown .
a remark is in order : for cdms two contour lines have been depicted according to a recent recommendation , the exclusion plot published in ref .
@xcite ( thin dotted line ) and the cdms expected sensitivity contour ( thin dot - dashed line)@xcite . data collection is currently in progress and some strategies are being considered to further reduce the low energy background .
another 50 % reduction from 4 kev to 10 kev ( which could be reasonably expected ) would allow to explore practically all the dama region in 1 kg y of exposure . in the case of reducing the background down to the flat level of 0.04 c / kg / kev / day ( currently achieved by igex for energies beyond 20 kev )
, the dama region would be widely surpassed . in figure
[ dm - ig-6 ] we plot the exclusions obtained with a flat background of 0.1 c / kg / kev / day ( dot - dashed line ) and of 0.04 c / kg / kev / day ( solid line ) down to the current 4 kev threshold , for an exposure of 1 kg year .
as can be seen , the complete dama region ( m=@xmath36 gev , @xmath37=(@xmath38)x10@xmath39 nb ) could be tested with a moderate improvement of the igex performances .
table5 a new experimental project on wimp detection using larger masses of germanium of natural isotopic abundance ( gedeon , germanium detectors in one cryostat ) is planned@xcite .
it will use the technology developed for the igex experiment and it would consist of a set of @xmath401 kg germanium crystals , of a total mass of about 28 kg , placed together in a compact structure inside one only cryostat . this approach could benefit from anticoincidences between crystals and a lower components / detector mass ratio to further reduce the background with respect to igex .
the gedeon single cell is a cylindrical cryostat in electroformed copper ( dimensions 20 cm diameter @xmath41 32 cm long ) hosting 28 germanium crystals which share the same common copper cryostat ( 0.5 mm thick ) .
the ge crystals , are arranged in four plates suspended from copper rods .
the cell is embedded into a precision - machined hole made in a roman lead block providing a shield of 20 cm , and surrounded by another lead shielding 20 cm thick . a cosmic veto and a large neutron shield
complete the shielding .
the preliminary mc estimated background in the @xmath42 kev region ranges from @xmath43 to @xmath44 c / kev kg day , according to the level of radioimpurities included as input@xcite .
the radiopurity assays have been carried out in the canfranc laboratory for the lead and copper components of the shielding .
the background final goal of gedeon , below 100 kev , would be hopefully in the region of @xmath45 c / kev kg day and this value has been used to calculate anticipated @xmath10(m ) exclusion plots in the most favourable case .
the expected threshold assumed has been @xmath46 kev and the energy resolution in the low energy region has been taken @xmath47 kev .
the mc estimated background of the gedeon unit cell ( 28 crystals ) is given in fig .
a detailed study is in progress to assess the physics potential of this device . the exclusion plot which could be expected with such proviso for 24 kg y of exposure
is shown in the figure [ dm - ig-6 ] . moreover , following the calculations presented in@xcite , gedeon would be massive enough to search for the wimp annual modulation effect@xcite and explore positively an important part of the wimp parameter space including the dama region . a second phase of gedeon with four cryostats ( 112 detectors and a total mass of 92 kg of ge ) is also being considered .
the data presented here regarding ge ionization detectors resulted from collaborative research with the members of the cosme and the igex collaborations , formed by c.e .
aalseth , f.t .
avignone , r.l .
brodzinski , s. cebrin , e. garca , w.k .
hensley , i.g .
irastorza , i.v .
kirpichnikov , a.a .
klimenko , h.s .
miley , j. morales , a. ortiz de solrzano , s.b .
osetrov , v.s .
pogosov , j. puimedn , j.h.reeves , m.l .
sarsa , a.a .
smolnikov , a.g .
tamanyan , a.a .
vasenko , s.i .
vasiliev , j.a .
villar members to whom i am deeply indebted .
the results contained in this paper have already been published in the open literature .
i wish to thank especially s. cebrin and i.g .
irastorza for their invaluable collaboration in the making of the exclusion plots and to j. morales and i.g .
irastorza for many useful discussions on igex - dm .
i thank s.cebrian for allowing me the use of the mc results for gedeon and j.puimedon for the making of the radiopurity measurement .
the present work was partially supported by the cicyt and mcyt ( spain ) under grant number aen99 - 1033 .
a. morales , `` dark matter and its detection '' , summary talk given at the nupecc workshop on present and future of neutrino physics , frascati , nupecc report in highlights and opportunities in nuclear physics , ed .
by j. vervier et al . , december 1997 .
( astro - ph/9810341 ) .
avignone and a.morales , proc .
conference on neutrino physics and astrophysics .
helsinki , june 1996 , ed .
k. enkvist et al . in world scientific pub . ( 1997 ) p. 413 ; a. morales `` selected projects in direct detection of dark matter '' , proc .
neutrino telescopes workshop , venice , february 1999 .
m. baldo - ceolin , p. 24 ; l. baudis and h.v .
klapdor `` direct detection of non baryonic dark matter '' , astro - ph /0003434 and y. ramachers `` non baryonic dar matter searches '' ; xi rencontres de blois , june 1999 , astro - ph /9911260 .
a. morales , `` direct detection of wimp dark matter '' ( astro - ph/9912554 ) .
review talk at the taup 99 workshop , college de france , paris .
b ( proc . suppl . ) 87 ( 2000 ) 477 and review talk at the taup 2001 workshop , laboratori nazionali del gran sasso , italy , sept . 2001 , to be published in nucl .
b ( proc . suppl . ) 2002 .
a. morales et al .
[ igex collaboration ] , hep - ex/0110061 oct .
2001 and i.g .
irastorza et al .
( igex coll . ) , talk given at the taup workshop sept .
2001 , ln gran sasso . to be published in nucl .
b ( proc . suppl . ) 2002 . | an overview of the main strategies followed in the search for non - baryonic particle dark matter in the form of wimps is given . to illustrate these searches the case for germanium ionization detectors
is selected .
= -4 mm |
the estimation of quantum states by using measured data is crucial to verify the quality of any quantum device . to fully determine a quantum state , i.e. to perform a quantum state tomography
, one needs to accumulate enough data to compute the expectation values of an informationally complete set of observables @xcite .
the availability of a complete set of measurements to be implemented by the experimenter is not straightforward and in general quantum state reconstruction is carried out by complicated set - ups that have to be robust against noise and decoherence sources , in order not to limit the accuracy of the reconstruction @xcite .
the standard technique used in quantum optics for the full reconstruction of quantum states is coherent homodyne detection @xcite , which has recently been extended to ultracold atoms in @xcite .
homodyne detection requires the use of a , not always available , local oscillator field that acts as a phase reference for the state under reconstruction @xcite . for atomic internal states simpler interferometric techniques
can be used to map the relative phases of internal components onto the level populations @xcite .
cold atomic systems and degenerate quantum gases are indeed unique tools for quantum simulations @xcite and precision measurements of atom characteristics beyond the classical limit @xcite . however , their applications outside laboratory depend critically on the simplification and downsizing of bulky cold - atom setups . indeed , an interesting technological development is given by the possibility of integrating cold atoms with nanostructures @xcite .
an important invention in this direction is the realization of a bose - einstein condensate ( bec ) in microscopic magnetic traps based on the micro - electronics technology , yielding the so - called atom - chip @xcite .
for example , experiments based on atom - chips have demonstrated nonlinear interferometers with the sensitivity beyond the standard quantum limit @xcite , nonclassical interferometry with motional states @xcite , and quantum zeno dynamics @xcite .
this work presents a practical , experimentally undemanding , tomography protocol , that relies only on the time - resolved measurements of the atomic population distribution among atomic internal states .
this protocol allows the reconstruction of a , not necessarily pure , state of a @xmath0-level quantum system , where the coherence elements are unknown and usually challenging to be measured .
the idea is simple : the state to be reconstructed evolves in time and the population distribution is measured at different times ; the same dynamics is numerically simulated starting from a randomly chosen initial state ; we run an optimization protocol that minimizes the difference between the simulated and measured data in such a way that the optimal solution provides the tomographic reconstruction of the initial state .
our procedure is based on the complete knowledge of the system evolution .
notice that , by applying the proposed scheme to a complete set of known states , one is in principle able to reconstruct the system dynamics , leading to a procedure similar to the quantum process tomography @xcite .
the experimental apparatus is based on a microscopic magnetic trap , or atom chip @xcite , where we bring an atomic sample of @xmath1rb to quantum degeneracy by forced evaporative cooling .
most of the structures and wires necessary to the magnetic trapping , the forced evaporation and successive manipulation of the atoms are all embedded in the atom chip , making this device versatile and experimentally easy to use @xcite .
our bec has typically @xmath2 atoms in the low field seeking hyperfine state @xmath3 , at a critical temperature of @xmath4 and is @xmath5 away from the chip surface .
the experiment described in this work is performed @xmath6 after the bec release from trap to guarantee a homogeneous magnetic bias field and strongly reduce the effects of atomic collisions . in this way
the most relevant source of noise on the evolution turns out to be the instability of the environmental magnetic field .
we consider a @xmath0-level system represented by the five fold @xmath7 hyperfine ground level of @xmath1rb . in the presence of a magnetic bias field the degeneracy between the magnetic sublevels
is lifted according to the breit - rabi formula .
using two external helmholtz coils , we arbitrarily set the magnetic field to @xmath8 @xcite .
to drive the atomic dynamics we apply a radio - frequency field ( rf ) oscillating at @xmath9@xcite using a wire structure embedded in the chip .
thanks to the relative proximity between the bec and the emitting wire with @xmath10 mw of rf power we excite magnetic dipole transitions between the atomic levels at rabi frequencies up to @xmath11 khz . to record the number of atoms in each of the @xmath12 states of the @xmath13 hyperfine state we use a stern - gerlach method .
after the state manipulation has been performed , in addition to the homogeneous bias field , we apply an inhomogeneous magnetic field along the quantization axis for @xmath14 .
this causes the different @xmath12 states to spatially separate . after an expansion time of @xmath15 a standard absorption imaging sequence
is performed .
the recorded atomic population in each @xmath12 state is normalized to the total number of observed atoms .
it is important to stress that each measurement sequence completely destroys the system .
this means that each sampling is associated to a different experimental cycle of production and manipulation of the bec and we have to rest on the assumption that both the state preparation and the tomographic procedure always yield the same result .
this assumption is a posteriori confirmed by the agreement between the prepared and reconstructed state .
we sample every @xmath16 oscillation of the rf field , corresponding to having a data point every @xmath17 .
we repeat @xmath16 times each measurement to obtain the mean values of the relative atomic populations @xmath18 and standard deviations @xmath19 for each sublevel @xmath20 .
an example is represented in fig.[fig1 ] . and
the five atomic populations ( points ) are recorded every @xmath21 , i.e. every @xmath16 oscillation of the rf field applied to the atomic sample .
the superimposed line is the theoretical evolution with the estimated initial condition @xmath22 minimizing the error @xmath23 between experimental and theoretical data.,scaledwidth=95.0% ]
the post - processing analysis is formulated in the following way : suppose that we want to estimate the initial quantum ( not necessarily pure ) state of a @xmath0-level system , described by the density operator @xmath24 . to do that
, we use the a priori known hamiltonian operator @xmath25 describing its dynamics and the measurements of the subsystem populations at different evolution times @xmath26 . in other words , we measure the observables @xmath27 , hence obtaining the expectation values @xmath28=p_i(t)$ ] , where @xmath29 and @xmath30 are , respectively , the annihilation and creation operators for each sublevel @xmath20 , and @xmath31 is the time - evolution of the unknown state @xmath22 that we want to estimate . in the case of fully coherent hamiltonian evolution , one has @xmath32 with @xmath33 $ ] being the unitary evolution operator . if the system is , instead , subjected to a noisy evolution , as it is the case in most experimental situation , one has @xmath34 with @xmath35 being the so - called quantum map or quantum channel or quantum operation mapping @xmath22 into @xmath31 @xcite . in our case
the hamiltonian , written in the rotating wave approximation , is @xmath36 where the state basis is chosen to go from @xmath37 to @xmath38 , the rf field rabi frequency is @xmath39 , the detunings @xmath40 are defined by @xmath41 and @xmath42 . in order to include the unavoidable presence of dephasing noise , mainly originated in our experiment by the presence of magnetic field fluctuations superimposed on the bias field , we add in our model a lindblad super - operator term @xmath43 , acting on the density matrix @xmath44 as @xmath45 $ ] , which randomizes the phase of each sublevel @xmath46 with a homogenous rate @xmath47 .
we finally obtain the density matrix evolution as @xmath48 + { \cal l}(\rho(t ) ) \ ; .
\label{eqn : l}\ ] ] ( left ) and the reconstructed one @xmath22 ( right ) , with the real ( upper ) and the imaginary ( lower ) components .
the uhlmann fidelity @xmath49 between @xmath22 and @xmath50 is @xmath51.,scaledwidth=95.0% ] to reconstruct the state one has @xmath52 unknown independent real parameters defining the @xmath53 density matrix , with the constraint of leading to a physical state , i.e. a semi - definite positive , hermitian matrix @xmath44 of unitary trace .
this problem can be also formulated in the language of semidefinite programming @xcite .
it corresponds to finding the initial state @xmath22 minimizing the difference ( e.g. , mean squared error ) between the measured populations @xmath54 and the quantities @xmath55 $ ] for each observed time step @xmath56 , hence @xmath57-p_i(t_j ) ||$ ] with @xmath58 mapping @xmath22 into @xmath31 being the solution of the master equation in ( [ eqn : l ] ) , and @xmath59 being any mathematical norm . here
, we have implemented the minimization algorithm using the subplex variant of the nelder - mead method @xcite . in particular , to take into account also the experimental uncertainties , we minimize , with respect to @xmath22 , the following weighted mean squared error function @xmath60 where @xmath61 $ ] and @xmath62 .
versus the tomography time ( used to minimize the error @xmath23 ) , where @xmath49 is the uhlmann fidelity between @xmath22 and @xmath50 , @xmath22 is the state reconstructed from the experimental data , and @xmath50 the expected one.,scaledwidth=70.0% ]
to test our scheme , we have prepared , by applying known hamiltonian evolutions , a set of states to be reconstructed .
for example , in fig .
[ fig1 ] we reconstruct a state that is obtained by applying a @xmath63 pulse @xcite to the @xmath64 state .
we report the experimentally recorded population evolutions in a @xmath65-long time window .
we then compare these results with the theoretical evolutions of the diagonal elements ( i.e. populations ) of the reconstructed state @xmath22 . for this reconstruction , based on 16 averaged observations of the five - level populations ,
the computed error is @xmath66 , corresponding to an uhlmann fidelity @xcite of @xmath67 between the reconstructed density matrix @xmath68 and the prepared one @xmath50 , that are pictorially represented in fig.[fig2 ] .
let us point out that no a priori knowledge of the initial state has been used for the tomographic reconstruction .
however , this information has been exploited to calculate the uhlmann fidelity .
moreover , we have faithfully reconstructed , with errors below @xmath69 , other states prepared by using the hamiltonian in eq .
( [ eqn : h ] ) and randomly varying over time the detunings @xmath70 and @xmath71 .
these low errors correspond to fidelities higher than @xmath72 . to check the reconstruction error convergence with respect to number of collected data we apply the optimization algorithm to the population distributions in different time windows @xmath73 , and computed the quantity @xmath74 in each case .
the results in fig.[fig3 ] show that , when @xmath73 is comparable with the system natural evolution timescale ( @xmath75 ) , the reconstruction accuracy is already satisfactory , with the error quickly saturating to its minimum value .
furthermore , this technique can be also exploited to get further information on the system evolution , e.g. estimate the amount of dephasing noise in the system dynamics resulting from its coupling to the external environment . as a function of the tomography time @xmath76 ( reconstruction window
@xmath77 $ ] ) and the dephasing rate @xmath47 , whose optimal values @xmath78 minimizing the error @xmath79 are shown in the dashed line.,scaledwidth=65.0% ] more specifically , we have reconstructed the initial density matrix measuring the population evolution within different time windows @xmath77 $ ] , with @xmath80 ~\mu s$ ] , but neglecting the presence of dephasing , i.e. @xmath81 .
then , for any reconstruction , we have found the optimal value of dephasing rate @xmath78 @xmath82 $ ] hz minimizing the error @xmath79 between the theoretical and experimental data see fig .
it turns out that the optimal dephasing rate increases with the tomography time @xmath76 , hence selecting the noise spectrum components larger than @xmath83 , as expected .
in other words , another important application of our procedure is to extract information on the presence of external noise and then indirectly on the strength of the coupling between the system and the environment .
we expect this to allow the characterization of the type of external noise , with the possibility of identifying the presence of temporal correlations .
to summarize , we have experimentally demonstrated a tomographic reconstruction algorithm that relies on data collected during the evolution of an unknown quantum state , assuming a complete knowledge of the system hamiltonian .
the advantages of this protocol are the simplicity of the post - processing procedure and the use of a quite conventional absorption imaging technique .
furthermore , we have shown the convergence of the protocol even using a small amount of collected data , compared to standard tomographic technique .
finally , we have also estimated the rate of the dephasing noise present in our system dynamics by repeating this procedure for longer tomography time windows and minimizing the reconstruction error . moving another step further
, a promising application may be represented by the possibility of characterizing the noise itself , for instance its spatial and temporal correlations , by investigating the behaviour of the state reconstruction error in terms of different noise models .
the proposed scheme therefore realizes quantum state tomography but could readily be modified to perform quantum process tomography by assuming complete knowledge of the input states , hence providing a very feasible and useful tool for several quantum technological applications .
this work was supported by the seventh framework programme for research of the european commission , under fet - open grant malicia , qibec , siqs , by miur via prin 2010llkjbx , and by dfg via sfb / trr21 .
the work of f.c . has been supported by eu fp7 marie curie programme ( career integration grant no .
293449 ) and by miur
firb grant ( project no .
rbfr10m3sb ) .
we thank m. inguscio for fruitful discussions and continuous support .
the value of the field @xmath84 is chosen around @xmath85 so that it is much larger than the magnetic noise fluctuations but , at the same time , the current used to produce it is not high enough to cause significant heating of the coils the rf frequency @xmath86 is chosen to be @xmath87 in a way that the detuning with the energy differences between neighbouring levels @xmath88 at @xmath89 is symmetric respect to the @xmath90 level , for example @xmath91 | we realize on an atom - chip a practical , experimentally undemanding , tomographic reconstruction algorithm relying on the time - resolved measurements of the atomic population distribution among atomic internal states . more specifically
, we estimate both the state density matrix as well as the dephasing noise present in our system by assuming complete knowledge of the hamiltonian evolution . the proposed scheme is based on routinely performed measurements and established experimental procedures , hence providing a simplified methodology for quantum technological applications . |
the prediction of the yield stress for electrorheological ( er ) fluids is the main concern in theoretical investigations of er fluids .
early studies failed to derive the experimental yield stress data @xcite because these studies were almost based on a point - dipole approximation @xcite .
the point - dipole approximation is routinely adopted in computer simulation because it is simple and easy to use . since many - body and multipolar interactions between particles have been neglected , the strength of er effects predicted by this model is of an order lower than the experimental results .
hence , substantial effort has been made to sort out more accurate models .
klingenberg and coworkers developed empirical force expression from numerical solution of laplace s equation @xcite .
davis used the finite - element method @xcite .
clercx and bossis developed a full multipolar treatment to account for multipolar polarizability of spheres up to 1,000 multipolar orders @xcite .
yu and coworkers developed an integral equation method which avoids the match of complicated boundary conditions on each interface of the particles and is applicable to nonspherical particles and multimedia @xcite .
although the above methods are accurate , they are relatively complicated to use in dynamic simulation of er fluids .
alternative models have been developed to circumvent the problem : the coupled - dipole model @xcite and the dipole - induced - dipole model @xcite , which take care of mutual polarization effects when the particles approach and finally touch .
the did model accounts for multipolar interactions partially and is simple to use in computer simulation of er fluids @xcite .
as an illustration , we employed the did model to simulate the athermal aggregation of particles in er fluids both in uniaxial and rotating fields .
we find that the aggregation time is significantly reduced . in the next section , we review the multiple image method and establish the dipole - induced dipole ( did ) model . in section iii , we apply the did model to the computer simulation of er fluids in a uniaxial field . in section iv , we extend the simulation to athermal aggregation in rotating fields .
discussion on our results will be given .
here we briefly review the multiple images method @xcite and extend the method slightly to handle different dielectric constants . consider a pair of dielectric spheres , of radii @xmath0 and @xmath1 , dielectric constants @xmath2 and @xmath3 respectively , separated by a distance @xmath4 .
the spheres are embedded in a host medium of dielectric constant @xmath5 . upon the application of an electric field
@xmath6 , the induced dipole moment inside the spheres are respectively given by ( si units ) : @xmath7where the dipolar factors @xmath8 are given by : @xmath9 from the multiple image method @xcite , the total dipole moment inside sphere @xmath0 is : @xmath10 , \label{trans - a - dielectric } \\
p_{al } & = & ( \sinh \alpha)^3 \sum_{n=1}^\infty \left [ { p_{a0 } b^3 ( 2\beta)^{n-1}(2\beta')^{n-1 } \over ( b\sinh n\alpha + a\sinh ( n-1)\alpha)^3 } + { p_{b0 } a^3 ( 2\beta)^{n}(2\beta')^{n-1 } \over ( r \sinh n\alpha)^3 } \right ] , \label{long - a - dielectric } \end{aligned}\]]where the subscripts @xmath11 ( @xmath12 ) denote a transverse ( longitudinal ) field , i.e. , the applied field is perpendicular ( parallel ) to the line joining the centers of the spheres .
similar expressions for the total dipole moment inside sphere @xmath1 can be obtained by interchanging @xmath0 and @xmath1 , as well as @xmath13 and @xmath14 .
the parameter @xmath15 satisfies : @xmath16 in ref.@xcite , we checked the validity of these expressions by comparing with the integral equation method .
we showed that these expression are valid at high contrast .
our improved expressions will be shown to be good at low contrast as well ( see below ) .
the force between the spheres is given by @xcite : @xmath17 for monodisperse er fluids ( @xmath18 , @xmath19 and @xmath20 ) , klingenberg defined an empirical force expression @xcite : @xmath21being normalized to the point - dipole force @xmath22 , where @xmath23 and @xmath24 ( all tending to unity at large separations ) are three force functions being determined from the numerical solution of laplace s equation .
the klingenberg s force functions can be shown to relate to our multiple image moments as follow ( here @xmath18 , @xmath19 and @xmath25 ) : @xmath26where @xmath27 and @xmath28 are the reduced multiple image moments of each sphere .
we computed the numerical values of these force functions separately by the approximant of table i of the second reference of ref.@xcite and by eq.([klingen ] ) . in fig.1
, we plot the multiple image results and the klingenberg s empirical expressions . we show results for the perfectly conducting limit ( @xmath29 ) only . for convenience , we define the reduced separation @xmath30 . for reduced separation @xmath31 ,
simple analytic expressions were adopted by klingenberg . as evident from fig.1 , the agreement with the multiple image results is impressive at large reduced separation @xmath32 , for all three empirical force functions . however , significant deviations occur for @xmath33 , especially for @xmath34 . for @xmath35 ,
alternative empirical expressions were adopted by klingenberg . for @xmath36 ,
the agreement is impressive , although there are deviations for the other two functions . from the comparison
, we would say that reasonable agreements have been obtained .
thus , we are confident that the multiple image expressions give reliable results .
the analytic multiple image results can be used to compare among the various models according to how many terms are retained in the multiple image expressions : ( a ) point - dipole ( pd ) model : @xmath37 term only , ( b ) dipole - induced - dipole ( did ) model : @xmath37 to @xmath38 terms only , and ( c ) multipole - induced - dipole ( mid ) model : @xmath37 to @xmath39 terms . in a previous work @xcite
, we examine the case of different size but equal dielectric constant ( @xmath19 ) only . here
we focus on the case @xmath18 and study the effect of different dielectric constants . in fig.2
, we plot the interparticle force in the longitudinal field case against the reduced separation @xmath40 between the spheres for ( a ) @xmath41 ( @xmath42 ) and ( b ) @xmath43 ( @xmath44 ) and various @xmath45 ratios . at low contrast
, the did model almost coincides with the mid results .
in contrast , the pd model exhibits significant deviations .
it is evident that the did model generally gives better results than pd for all polydispersity .
the multiple image expressions [ eqs.(3)(4 ) ] allows us to calculate the correction factor defined as the ratio between the did and pd forces : @xmath46where @xmath47 , @xmath48 and @xmath49 are the point - dipole forces for the transverse , longitudinal and @xmath50 cases respectively .
these correction factors can be readily calculated in computer simulation of polydisperse er fluids .
the results show that the did force deviates significantly from the pd force at high contrast when @xmath13 and @xmath14 approach unity . the dipole induced interaction will generally decrease ( increase ) the magnitude of the transverse ( longitudinal ) interparticle force with respect to the point - dipole limit . for simplicity
, we consider the case of two equal spheres of radius @xmath0 , initially at rest and at a separation @xmath51 .
an electric field is applied along the line joining the centers of the sphere .
the equation of motion is given by : @xmath52where @xmath53 is the displacement of one sphere from the center of mass .
the separation between the two spheres is thus @xmath54 and the initial condition is @xmath55 at @xmath56 .
eq.(11 ) is a dimensionless equation .
we have chosen the following natural scales to define the dimensionless variables : @xmath57 where @xmath58 is the field strength , @xmath59 is the masss , @xmath60 is the coefficient of viscosity . using typical parameters , we find @xmath61 is of the order milliseconds .
we have followed klingenberg @xcite to ignore the inertial effect , captured by the parameter @xmath62 . @xmath63
the neglect of @xmath62 can be justified as follows . for values common to er suspension : @xmath64 pa s , @xmath65 kg , @xmath66 m @xmath67 , the inertial term @xmath62 is of the order @xmath68 .
we also neglect the thermal motion of the particles which is a valid assumption at high fields .
we should remark that the initial separation @xmath51 is related to the volume fraction @xmath69 , defined as the ratio of the volume of the sphere to that of the cube which contains the sphere @xcite , i.e. @xmath70 , and @xmath71 for the pd approximation , eq.(11 ) admits an analytic solution : @xmath72^{1/5}.\]]we integrate the equation of motion by the 4th order runge - kutta algorithm , with time steps @xmath73 and 0.001 for small and large volume fractions respectively . in fig.3(a ) , we plot the displacement @xmath74 versus time graph for the pd case and find excellent agreement between analytic and numerical results . for the did model
, we have to integrate the equation of motion numerically . in fig.4 , we plot the displacement @xmath74 versus time graph for the aggregation of two spheres in uniaxial fields . at small volume fractions ,
i.e. , when the initial separation is large , the time for aggregation is large and the did results deviate slightly from the pd results . however , at large volume fractions , the did results are significantly smaller than the pd calculations .
the effect becomes even more pronounced at large @xmath13 . in fig.5(a ) , we plot the ratio of aggregation time of the did to pd cases .
the results showed clearly that the aggregation time has been significantly reduced when mutual polarization effects are considered .
the reduction in aggregation time becomes even pronounced for small initial separations .
recently , martin and coworkers @xcite demonstrated athermal aggregation with the rotating field . when a rotating field is applied in the @xmath75-@xmath76 plane at a sufficiently high frequency that particles do not move much in one period
, an average attractive dipolar interaction is created .
the result of this is the formation of plates in the @xmath75-@xmath76 plane .
consider a rotating field applied in the @xmath75-@xmath76 plane : @xmath77 .
the dimensionless equation of motion for the two sphere case becomes : @xmath78where @xmath79 is the displacement of one sphere from the center of mass . for large @xmath80
, we may safely neglect the @xmath76 component of the motion . in the pd approximation , @xmath81 and @xmath82
, we find the analytic result : @xmath83^{1/5}.\]]the separation between the two spheres is just @xmath84 , with the initial separation @xmath55 at @xmath56 . in the rotating field case
, we also integrate the equation of motion by the 4th order runge - kutta algorithm , but with @xmath85 and @xmath86 as the time steps .
note that @xmath87 should be the largest time step which can be used because we must at least go through a cycle consisting of the transverse and longitudinal field cases .
the oscillating effect of a rotating field is less observable when the time step is smaller than this maximum value . in fig.3(b )
, we plot the displacement versus time graph for the pd case in rotating field and find an excellent agreement between analytic and numerical results .
it is evident that the aggregation time is 4 times of that of the uniaxial field case .
in fact , eq.(14 ) reduces to eq.(12 ) as @xmath88 .
at large @xmath80 , eq.(14 ) becomes : @xmath89^{1/5}.\ ] ] that is , in the pd approximation , the time average force becomes 1/4 of that of the uniaxial field case .
it is because the two dipole moments spend equal times in the transverse and longitudinal orientations , while @xmath90 in the pd case , leading to an overall attractive force that is 1/4 of the force of the uniaxial field case .
when the multiple image force is included , we expect that the magnitude of @xmath91 increases while that of @xmath92 decreases and we expect an even larger attractive force when the spheres approach . in this case
, the aggregation time must be reduced even more significantly . in fig.5(b ) , we plot the ratio of aggregation time of the did to pd cases for @xmath29 and several @xmath80 .
the @xmath93 curve is just for the uniaxial field case .
the results showed clearly that the aggregation time has been significantly reduced when mutual polarization effects are considered .
the reduction in aggregation time becomes even pronounced for small initial separations .
it is observed that fluctuations exist when the initial separation between the spheres is 2.4@xmath0 or less .
it is because the motion is sensitive to the initial orientation of the dipoles when the spheres are too close .
similarly , we consider the aggregations of 3 and 4 equal spheres , arranged in a chain , an equilateral triangle and a square . for a chain of 3 spheres in a rotating field ,
the central sphere does not move , while the two spheres at both ends move towards the central sphere . for 3 spheres in an equilateral triangle
, the center of mass ( cm ) will not move while each sphere moves towards the cm , subject to the force of the other two spheres .
the same situation occurs for 4 spheres in a square , in which each sphere moves towards the cm , subject to the force of the other 3 spheres . in the pd approximation , we report the analytic results as follows . for 3 spheres in a chain , @xmath94^{1/5}.\]]for 3 spheres in an equilateral triangle , @xmath95^{1/5}.\]]for 4 spheres in a square , @xmath96^{1/5}.\]]in each of the above cases , @xmath75 is the distance of one sphere from the center of mass . in the case of 3 spheres in a chain ,
the separation between the spheres is same as @xmath97 . in the case of 3 spheres in an equilateral triangle , the separation between spheres is @xmath98 . in the case of 4 spheres in a square
, the separation between spheres is @xmath99 .
again , we integrate the equation of motion by the 4th order runge - kutta algorithm .
we find excellent agreements between the analytic and numerical results ( not shown here ) .
it has been found that the displacement in the @xmath76-direction is about 0.5% for @xmath100 and a larger @xmath80 has been used in the simulation . on the other hand , it is time consuming for simulations with @xmath101 .
it is evident from the displacement - time graph that the results are correct . in fig.6 ,
the oscillation amplitude is reduced when the rotating frequency increases in the simulation .
this is consistent with the assumption made in our analytic expressions . in fig.7
, it is observed that fluctuations exist when the initial separation between the spheres is 2.4@xmath0 or less in all three graphs .
again , it is because the motion is sensitive to the orientation of the dipoles when the spheres are close . from the simulation ,
the reduction effects become even pronounced for the rotating electric field case than the uniaxial field case .
here a few comments on our results are in order . in this work
, we studied the aggregation time for several particles .
we should also examine the morphology of aggregation , due to multiple image forces . in this connection
, we can also examine the structural transformation by applying the uniaxial and rotating fields simultaneously @xcite .
we have done simulation in the monodisperse case .
real er fluids must be polydisperse in nature : the suspending particles can have various sizes or different permittivities .
polydisperse electrorheological ( er ) fluids have attracted considerable interest recently because the size distribution and dielectric properties of the suspending particles can have significant impact on the er response @xcite . we should extend the simulation to polydisperse case by using the did model . in summary
, we have used the multiple image to compute the interparticle force for a polydisperse electrorheological fluid .
we apply the formalism to a pair of spheres of different dielectric constants and calculate the force as a function of the separation .
the results show that the point - dipole approximation is oversimplified .
it errs considerably because many - body and multipolar interactions are ignored .
the dipole - induced - dipole model accounts for multipolar interactions partially and yields overall satisfactory results in computer simulation of er fluids while it is easy to use .
this work was supported by the research grants council of the hong kong sar government under grant cuhk4284/00p .
p. m. adriani and a. p. gast , phys .
fluids * 31 * , 2757 ( 1988 ) .
d. j. klingenberg , f. van swol and c. f. zukoski , j. chem . phys . * 91 * , 7888 ( 1989 ) .
d. j. klingenberg , f. van swol and c. f. zukoski , j. chem . phys . * 94 * , 6160 ( 1991 ) .
d. j. klingenberg and c. f. zukoski , langmuir * 6 * 15 ( 1990 ) ; d. j. klingenberg , f. van swol and c. f. zukoski , j. chem . phys . * 94 * , 6170 ( 1991 ) . l. c. davis , appl .
. lett . * 60 * , 319 ( 1992 ) .
h. j. h. clercx and g. bossis , phys .
e * 48 * , 2721 ( 1993 ) .
k. w. yu , hong sun and jones t. k. wan , in _ proceedings of the 5th international conference on electrical transport and optical properties of inhomogeneous media _ , physica b * 279 * , 78 ( 2000 ) .
z. w. wang , z. f. lin and r. b. tao , int .
phys . * 10 * , 1153 ( 1996 ) .
k. w. yu and jones t. k. wan , in _ proceedings of the 9th international conference on discrete simulation of fluid dynamics _ ,
. comm . * 129 * , 177 ( 2000 ) .
j. d. jackson , _ classical electrodynamics _ ( wiley , new york 1975 ) .
j. e. martin , r. a. anderson and c. p. tigges , j. chem . phys .
* 108 * , 3765 ( 1998 ) ; * 108 * , 7887 ( 1998 ) . c. k. lo and k. w. yu , phys .
e , to be published .
m. ota and t. miyamoto , j. appl .
76 * , 5528 ( 1994 ) . | we have employed the multiple image method to compute the interparticle force for a polydisperse electrorheological ( er ) fluid in which the suspended particles can have various sizes and different permittivites .
the point - dipole ( pd ) approximation being routinely adopted in computer simulation of er fluids is shown to err considerably when the particles approach and finally touch due to multipolar interactions .
the pd approximation becomes even worse when the dielectric contrast between the particles and the host medium is large . from the results ,
we show that the dipole - induced - dipole ( did ) model yields very good agreements with the multiple image results for a wide range of dielectric contrasts and polydispersity . as an illustration ,
we have employed the did model to simulate the athermal aggregation of particles in er fluids both in uniaxial and rotating fields .
we find that the aggregation time is significantly reduced . the did model accounts for multipolar interaction partially and is simple to use in computer simulation of er fluids . |
in order for hydrodynamics codes to be able to simulate shocks it is necessary that the width of the shock be spread over a few mesh cells , or represent a few inter - particle spacings , depending on whether a grid or particle based code is being used . in reality
, however , the true width of the shock is only a few mean free paths , giving a shock thickness @xmath5 , of @xmath6 where @xmath7 is the number density and @xmath8 is the collisional cross - section .
a few simple calculations show that the true shock thickness is orders of magnitude smaller than the shock thickness obtained in simulations .
this allows the possibility that gas in simulations can cool artificially while passing through a shock , and that temperature - sensitive quantities , such as ionization levels and molecular abundances may also vary .
any such effects will be purely numerical because of the finite shock crossing time in simulations . in the present paper
will consider a number of possibilities .
firstly , if gas is able to cool during a shock the maximum temperature the gas will reach after passing through the shock will be reduced from that of an adiabatic jump . where the cooling function rate decreases with increasing temperature , this
will then reduce the cooling time of the post - shock gas .
secondly , we shall consider the evolution of the ionization level through a shock , where the cooling rate is proportional to the number density of free electrons .
this has important consequences for simulations of primordial structure formation as the ionization level determines the rate of molecular hydrogen ( ) and hydrogen - deuterium ( hd)production .
these two molecules then determine the cooling time of the gas down to temperatures less than @xmath9k .
finally , we shall also address the question of instability of radiative shocks .
imamura et al . (
1984 ) and chevalier and imamura ( 1982 ) found that radiative shocks with a cooling rate per unit volume @xmath10 ( where @xmath11 is the mass density and @xmath12 the temperature ) are unstable against perturbations when @xmath13 .
this instability results in periodic oscillations of the position of the shock front and of the jump temperature at the shock front .
we address the nature of these oscillations in the context of galaxy formation using a cooling function composed of the sum of a number of terms , each with a different power law .
shocks can be generally classified into three types , depending upon the amount of cooling present . in adiabatic shocks
the shocked gas does not cool significantly during the period of time of interest .
isothermal shocks have the same jump conditions at the shock front as an adiabatic shock , but the cooling is very rapid so that the downstream gas is at the same temperature as the upstream gas .
any cooling tail is thus very narrow . in between these two extremes
is the case where the shocked gas has a cooling time of order the time - scale which is of interest in a given situation . for an adiabatic shock
the conservative form of the fluid equations in the absence of sources which change momentum , mass or energy can be written as @xmath14 @xmath15 @xmath16=0 \label{equ : if3}\ ] ] where the variables @xmath17 , @xmath18 , @xmath11 , @xmath19 and @xmath20 represent velocity , position , density , specific energy and pressure respectively , all evaluated in the rest frame of the shock . if we apply equations [ equ : if1]-[equ : if3 ] to gas far upstream and write its properties in terms of gas far downstream , we arrive at the rankine - hugoniot jump conditions : @xmath21 @xmath22 @xmath23 where @xmath12 is the gas temperature , @xmath24 the boltzmann constant @xmath25 the mean molecular weight and @xmath26 the mass of a hydrogen atom . the suffixes @xmath27 and @xmath28 refer to the upstream and downstream gas respectively and the equation of state of the gas is given by the equations : @xmath29 @xmath30 taking @xmath31 we can write the pressure of the shocked gas as @xmath32 for the case of an isothermal shock where the temperature of the gas far downstream is equal to its temperature up stream , the conservation of energy equation is no longer valid and should be replaced with the condition @xmath33 .
we must stress however that the gas will still undergo an adiabatic jump at the shock front before cooling back down to its upstream temperature . for the case of a radiative shock
we wish to determine the path between the state of the gas at the shock front and its state downstream . in order to do this
we must add a cooling term to the energy flux equation : @xmath34=0 \\ \label{equ : apf3}\ ] ] the cooling term @xmath35 serves to determine the path between the down stream and adiabatic jump conditions , but does not change them in any way .
equations [ equ : if1 ] , [ equ : if2 ] and [ equ : apf3 ] can be numerically integrated for any cooling function resulting in an analytic profile from the specified down - stream conditions to the shock front .
the shock front is reached when the adiabatic jump condition of equation [ equ : stop ] is satisfied .
the shock tube simulations were performed using a smoothed particle hydrodynamics code .
the code was that described by couchman , thomas & pearce ( 1995 ) but with modified geometry to make the simulation volume cuboidal with dimensions of @xmath36 .
the shock front was initially set to be at z coordinate @xmath37 with gas flowing in the z direction . on what will be the upstream side of this point ,
particles are placed one per unit volume and given unit mass .
on the downstream side , particles were placed four per unit volume .
their mass however is allowed to vary in order for the gas to have any density profile that is initially desired . the density profile , along with the temperature and velocity of the gas ,
is read in upon the start of a simulation .
for this geometry the simulation thus starts with @xmath38 particles .
the particles on each side of the shock front were allowed to relax independently to a glass - like initial state .
the sides of the simulation box were periodic , with the exception of each end , where gas was fed into the box at the appropriate rate upstream and removed from the simulation a sufficient distance downstream so as not to effect any cooling tail .
a padding region of two mesh cells at each end was necessary and gas within this region had its position updated on each time - step , but did not have its energy , velocity or density updated .
( the code searches for @xmath39 neighbours , thus needing a search radius of approximately @xmath28 units when particles are located one per cell .
it is this distance that determines the size of the padding region as any particle closer than this distance to the end of the simulation volume would experience a non - symmetric force . )
all simulations were performed in the rest frame of the shock and the units the code used were dimensionless until a cooling function was chosen .
the cooling function , and ionization / recombination rates were integrated using rk4 from press et al .
( 1992 ) , this routine being called at the end of each time - step .
all the rates used were tabulated on the first timestep .
the cooling function for objects with high virial temperatures ( above @xmath40k ) collapsing after the universe has been enriched with metals can be written as the sum of three terms : a bremsstrahlung term , @xmath41 , a metal line - cooling term , @xmath42 and a h - he term , @xmath43 .
the fit for each term is split into two temperature regimes . for @xmath44k
we have , where @xmath45erg @xmath46 @xmath47 : @xmath48 @xmath49 @xmath50 for @xmath51k we have : @xmath52 @xmath53 @xmath54 where @xmath55 is the metallicity in terms of solar .
the above cooling function is a good approximation to within a factor of @xmath28 to raymond & smith ( 1977 ) .
the nature of this cooling function is such that the cooling rate rises abruptly as one moves from a temperature @xmath56k to @xmath57k .
the cooling rate peaks at @xmath58k and then decreases , reaching a minimum at @xmath59k . at this point bremsstrahlung
cooling starts to become effective and the cooling rate begins to slowly rise as the temperature increases further . for gas being shocked from @xmath40k to a temperature of order @xmath59k
the cooling function is of a suitable nature to produce a significant reduction in the cooling time of shocked gas , if in - shock cooling is present .
the cooling rate being most rapid at lower temperatures and then decreasing as the temperature rises above @xmath58k means that a modest reduction in the maximum temperature reached could make a significant difference to the cooling time as it is the hottest gas that takes the longest to cool .
unfortunately a declining cooling function makes the shock unstable and in this section we restrict ourselves to studying shocks which do not reach the declining part of the cooling function , and which thus settle down into a steady state .
the nature of such shocks can be specified by the ratio of the cooling time to the shock crossing time .
if the cooling time is very long , and the ratio is thus large , the effect of in - shock will be negligible .
conversely , if the cooling time is very rapid , in - shock cooling will tend to drive the shock towards an isothermal transition .
the cooling time itself will be determined by the physical conditions that are being simulated and will be determined by the density and temperature of the gas .
the shock crossing time will depend upon the mass resolution of the code and will vary as the cube root of the particle mass . by specifying the downstream conditions of the shock , equations [ equ : if1 ] , [ equ : if2 ] and [ equ : apf3 ] were numerically integrated for @xmath35 of section @xmath60 , and a profile of the cooling tail
was obtained .
the integration was stopped at the shock front , when equation [ equ : stop ] was satisfied .
this profile was then read directly into the shock - tube to create the initial conditions , with the shock front being placed at the boundary between the low and high mass particles .
particles within the region of the cooling tail had their temperature , velocity and mass adjusted to recreate the analytic shock profile .
the simulations were then allowed to run until a steady state - state was reached .
the upstream gas was started with a temperature of @xmath61k and the analytic jump temperature was @xmath62k .
the density of gas far downstream had a density twelve times that of the upstream gas .
two simulations were ran , one with a ratio of the shock crossing time to the cooling time of @xmath63 , and the other with a ratio of @xmath64 .
figures [ fig : stable1 ] and [ fig : stable2 ] show the temperature profiles as a function of position for two shocks with ratios of @xmath63 and @xmath64 respectively . despite the upper part of the theoretical shock being in the unstable regime
the simulations were found to settle down into a steady state .
this was aided by in - shock cooling which reduces the maximum temperature reached .
the solid lines in show the analytic temperature profiles .
we can see that the maximum temperature obtained is approximately @xmath65 percent less than the analytic jump temperature in figure [ fig : stable1 ] , and @xmath37 percent less for the simulation of figure [ fig : stable2 ] with a particle mass @xmath66 times greater .
the effect that these reductions in jump temperature have on the cooling tails can be seen to be somewhat erratic . in both cases the cooling time of the gas decreases by a factor of approximately @xmath28 , but the spatial extent of the cooling tail depends upon the resolution .
the reason for this is that spatial location is not an accurate indication of the cooling time , as the latter is dependent upon the density .
we would not necessarily expect the shock - tube simulations to have the same density profile or the same density jump at the shock front as the theoretical profile .
however they do converge to the correct jump conditions far downstream .
the sort of objects in numerical simulations where in - shock cooling will be important are those with a low ratio of cooling time to shock crossing time and which cool on a time - scale of order the dynamical time of the virialized halo .
objects which cool on a time - scale much longer than this are generally of little interest as they will not collapse sufficiently quick to form luminous objects . at the other extreme , if an object cools on a time - scale much less than the dynamical time
the gas will be in a state of free - fall collapse ; in - shock cooling will certainly be present in this case as the cooling is so rapid , but the correct conditions will be recovered on a time - scale less than the dynamical time . as an example , consider the collapse of an object with a cooling time equal to its collapse time , in a cosmological simulation with a dark - matter particle mass of @xmath67 .
taking @xmath68 , a galaxy with total mass of @xmath69 collapsing at redshift @xmath28 would have a shock velocity at about @xmath70km@xmath71 .
taking the shock to be spread over @xmath72 inter - particle spacings , we find the ratio of the cooling time to the shock crossing time to be @xmath64 . if the same object were to be simulated with a particle mass @xmath73 times lower , the ratio would increase to @xmath74 .
the shock - tube simulations described in this section suggest that , for either large - scale cosmological simulations with a ratio of @xmath64 , or simulations of a single galaxy with a ratio of @xmath63 the effect of in - shock cooling will reduce the maximum temperature reached by between @xmath65 to @xmath37 percent and reduce the cooling time by a factor of approximately @xmath28 .
the most important cooling mechanisms for a primordial gas with a temperature above @xmath75k result from recombination of electrons with hydrogen ions and collisional excitation of neutral hydrogen by collisions with free electrons , the excited hydrogen atom then emits a photon which , should it not be re - absorbed , amounts to a reduction in the internal energy of the gas .
the cooling terms , taken from haiman , thoul and loeb ( 1996 ) are : @xmath76 @xmath77 where @xmath78 is the temperature in units of @xmath58k
. the rate of energy loss from the gas will be proportional to the number densities of both neutral hydrogen and free electrons .
the ionization level thus needs to be known and is generally not equal to its equilibrium value for the situations we shall consider . in order to trace the ionization level we need to specify the ionization and recombination rates . for the purpose of this section
we consider a gas composed entirely of hydrogen which is ionized through the reaction : @xmath79 this proceeds at a rate ( black 1978 ) : @xmath80 the gas recombines via the reaction : @xmath81 which proceeds at a rate ( hutchins 1976 ) : @xmath82 for the electron - cooling runs , the gas was started with jump conditions for a perfectly isothermal shock .
the motivation for this approach is that the cooling time is short , meaning that the perfectly isothermal conditions are reasonably close to the stable profile and should soon evolve to that state .
the mass of the downstream particles was adjusted so that the correct density jump was obtained and the simulations were then allowed to run until the developing temperature , density and ionization profiles reach a stable state .
gas upstream had an ionization level of @xmath83 and a temperature of 12000k , which was the minimum temperature permitted in the simulations .
gas at or below 12000k did not have its ionization level updated and was not allowed to cool further as this would slow down the code too much .
instead , cooling below 12000k was estimated analytically .
run 1 is a fiducial run with units designed to represent an object at a redshift of 20 containing 10@xmath84 particles with a total baryonic mass of @xmath85 and a virial temperature of 78000k .
runs @xmath28 and @xmath72 have the same mass resolution as the fiducial run but represent objects with higher and lower virial temperatures respectively . runs @xmath86 and @xmath87 have the same virial temperature as the fiducial run but lower and higher mass resolution respectively . runs @xmath88 and @xmath89 have a lower virial temperature than the fiducial but different mass resolutions .
the mass resolution is represented by the number of particles an object of mass @xmath90 would contain , although the simulations which have been performed have the same number of particles in every case .
table @xmath27 below lists the results of seven shock - tube simulations using the cooling functions of equations [ equ : emc ] and [ equ : emc2 ] . from left to right , the column headings of table 1 are : run number ; the number of particles an object of mass @xmath91 would contain , @xmath92 ; the ( analytic ) virial temperature @xmath93 ( the temperature the shocked gas should jump to ) ; the ratio of the maximum temperature obtained in the simulations to the virial temperature , @xmath94 ; the analytic ionization level for gas cooling from the virial temperature to 12000k , @xmath95 ; the ionization level of gas in the simulation that has cooled back to 12000k divided by the analytic level , @xmath96 ; the ratio of the simulated to analytic cooling times from the peak of the shock , down to 12000k , @xmath97 ; the ratio of the numerical to the analytic cooling times to reach 600k , @xmath98 ; and the ratio of the numerical to the analytic fractions at 600k , h@xmath99/h@xmath100 .
the analytic ionization level at 12000k , @xmath95 , assumes an adiabatic shock followed by rapid cooling and was calculated by integrating the shock conservation equations [ equ : if1 ] , [ equ : if2 ] and [ equ : apf3 ] with the cooling functions of equations [ equ : emc ] and [ equ : emc2 ] using non - equilibrium chemistry . cooling below 12000k
was calculated allowing the gas to cool at a constant density to @xmath101k via the cooling mechanism .
a detailed treatment of the gas chemistry was used incorporating formation and destruction of , ionization and recombination , the cooling functions of equations [ equ : emc ] and [ equ : emc2 ] and the cooling function .
the destruction and cooling rates of was taken from martin , schwarz and mandy ( 1996 ) .
the simulated cooling time from 12000k to 600k , @xmath102 , and fraction h@xmath103 use @xmath104 as the starting ionization level ; @xmath105 and h@xmath106 use @xmath95 as the input ionization . [ cols="^,^,>,^,<,^,^,>,^",options="header " , ] the effect of in - shock cooling is dramatic and striking in the fiducial run .
the maximum temperature the shock reaches is only @xmath107 of its theoretical value .
this leads to an increase in the cooling time for the gas to cool back down to 12000k by an astonishing factor of @xmath108 .
there are a number of contributing factors to this extreme figure .
firstly , although the ionization level at 12000k is @xmath109 times lower in the shocktube than expected , this is a conservative estimate of the difference , as the factor is somewhat higher than this at other points on the cooling tail .
this is because the lower jump temperature obtained results in a much slower rate of of ionization . also , the density of the theoretical profile is somewhat higher at any given temperature ( above 12000k ) as the gas has reduced its temperature by a greater factor than gas at the same temperature in the shock tube .
e.g. for the fiducial run , at 22000k the theoretical profile has a density of @xmath110 while gas at this temperature in the shocktube has has a density of only @xmath111 .
these effects combined produce the high factors of @xmath97 seen in table 1 .
the consequences of this are of extreme importance as simulations of such objects will be meaningless unless in - shock cooling can be removed , as the increase in the cooling times of such objects will slow the collapse . also of importance is the ability of an object to cool to temperatures below 12000k when molecular hydrogen becomes the dominant coolant .
molecular hydrogen is formed via the reactions @xmath112 @xmath113 its production is thus proportional to the ionization level , the free electrons acting as a catalyst .
the effect of in - shock cooling on the fiducial run was found to halve the abundance and to increase the cooling time from 12000k to 600k by a factor of two . increasing the shock jump temperature , whilst retaining the same spatial and mass resolution results in a modest increase in the maximum temperature obtained at the shock front .
this difference is sufficient to cause the ionization level of the cooled downstream gas , @xmath114 to be higher than that obtained in the fiducial run by a factor of almost three .
however , the correct ionization level is still some way from being obtained in each of runs @xmath27 , @xmath28 and @xmath72 . comparing these runs
shows that the fractional temperature reached increases with decreasing virial temperature , and the ionization level gets closer to its theoretical value .
however , these trends do not appear to carry over to the cooling times and abundances when the virial temperature increases from 78000k to 168000k .
this is due to the complex interaction between reaction rates and cooling times .
as one might expect , improving the mass resolution reduces the severity of any in - shock effects . for jump temperatures of 78000k and 39000k , as the mass resolution is improved there is a steady convergence towards the correct values of the abundance , the cooling time to @xmath101k , the cooling time from the virial temperature to 12000k and the jump temperature .
essentially the convergence of the first three is determined by the convergence towards the correct jump temperature , as it is this temperature that determines the extent to which the gas is re - ionized which in turn determines the rate of production and the cooling time .
figure [ fidprofs ] shows the ionization level as a function of time for an analytical shock and for three shocks each with a virial temperature of 39000k , but with different mass resolutions . in each case
we have defined time zero to be the time when gas reaches the maximum temperature .
negative time represents gas which is being heated by the shock but has not yet reached the peak .
these figures show the effect of lowering the resolution from the analytical profile , through runs 7 , 3 and 5 .
note that the y - scale is the same in each panel but the x - scale is not .
we can see from the graphs that as resolution is improved there is a convergence of the final ionization level and cooling time towards the theoretical profile .
however , even if an object were to contain @xmath115 particles the effects of in - shock cooling would still remain significant , most noticeably for @xmath116 .
such resolutions are at present not possible , and even if they were the quantities we have considered are yet to converge
. we must conclude that the resolution of typical simulations being performed is hopelessly inadequate and if sensible results are to be obtained a way of removing in - shock cooling must be found .
for a planar radiative shock with a cooling function @xmath117 , chevalier and imamura ( 1982 ) showed that for @xmath118 the shock is unstable against perturbations and will undergo oscillations both spatially and in the jump temperature .
the latter results from the fact that as the shock front moves , the relative velocity of the upstream gas in the frame of the shock varies .
this in turn results in a different solution of the jump equations .
the situation is similar for stable shocks also : if perturbed , they also undergo oscillations but with a decaying amplitude . for values of @xmath119 between @xmath120 and @xmath28 chevalier and
imamura found the frequency of oscillation , @xmath121 , to vary between @xmath122 and @xmath123 with units of @xmath124 where @xmath125 is the mean distance from the shock front to the point upstream where the gas has cooled to its upstream temperature , and @xmath126 is the velocity of the upstream gas .
the maximum displacement of the shock front from its mean position , @xmath127 , was also calculated and was found to be @xmath128 , where @xmath129 is the steady state cooling time and @xmath130 the speed the shock front is moving at .
the following simulations verify the instabilities found by chevalier and imamura ( 1982 ) for the case of a realistic cooling function composed of a number of power law terms , ( some of which are stable ) .
an analytic profile of the cooling tail was calculated as in section @xmath131 .
the gas upstream had a temperature of @xmath132k with a density jump of @xmath9 for the downstream gas .
this results in a temperature jump of a factor of @xmath133 to @xmath134k .
the cooling function used was that of section @xmath86 , meaning that gas with a temperature above @xmath58k is in the unstable regime .
the fact that the shock is unstable means that a steady state will never be reached so the simulation was ran until the nature of the oscillations became apparent .
the unstable nature of both the position and jump temperature of radiative shocks is well demonstrated upon consideration of figures [ usp ] and [ ust ] .
although the cooling function used is not strictly a power law , but rather a combination of power laws , we find that both the magnitude of the spatial oscillations , and their period , are in reasonable agreement with the work of chevalier and imamura as presented above .
the frequency of oscillations @xmath121 was found to be @xmath135 , where @xmath136 and p is the observed period of oscillations .
the majority of heated gas in the simulation has @xmath137 . for the case of @xmath138 , chevalier and
imamura found the oscillation frequency to be @xmath139 .
the agreement is reasonable , although interpolation of the chevalier and imamura values to intermediate values of @xmath121 is somewhat uncertain as there is no obvious linear trend in their results .
the maximum displacement of the shock was found to be @xmath140 which agrees well with the theoretical value of @xmath141 .
the effects of in - shock cooling on the simulations is uncertain but , given that we know it is present , it may account for the extreme oscillations down to an isothermal transition as seen in figure 5 .
we note , however , that the period and spatial magnitude of the oscillations appears to be correct even when in - shock cooling is present . in the absence of in - shock cooling ,
any halo with a virial temperature of more than a few times 10@xmath0k ( i.e. galaxies ) will be subject to such an instability .
in this paper we have clearly demonstrated that in - shock cooling has important consequences for numerical simulations of galaxy formation , especially at high redshifts , where collisional excitation of hydrogen by free electrons , cooling by recombination and cooling by molecular hydrogen are the relevant coolants , but also for galaxies with higher virial temperatures collapsing at lower redshifts .
the effect of in - shock cooling on a stable radiative shock was found to decrease the maximum temperature reached by @xmath65 percent when the ratio of the cooling - time to shock crossing time was @xmath63 .
this value increased to @xmath37 percent for a ratio of @xmath64 .
the result of this was that the profiles of the cooling tails were found to have different spatial extents from the theoretical profile .
from this we conclude that although the effects of in - shock cooling are quite small , the collapse rate of such objects could be altered along with the spatial extent of any cooling tail .
the effect on primordial objects of in - shock cooling was found to be extremely significant : the ionization level emerging from the shock was significantly lower by a factor of @xmath1 in the best resolved case , and up to a factor of @xmath142 in the worst case .
the implications for the cooling time of the gas ranged from an increase of a factor of @xmath109 up to nearly @xmath73 , for the cooling times above 12000k . below 12000k
the result was less extreme , ranging from a factor of @xmath143 to @xmath1 .
this difference is nevertheless important and will significantly slow the collapse of any object .
the resulting molecular hydrogen abundance of the gas after it was allowed to cool to @xmath101k was found in all cases to decrease from its analytic value by a factor of around 2 . for the case of an unstable shock
we find oscillations of the spatial location of the shock front and the maximum temperature reached .
it is likely that the extreme oscillations of temperature observed ( cooling to a virtually isothermal state ) are fueled by in - shock cooling . for the resolutions currently achievable
, an incorrect result will be obtained for simulations of galaxy formation . finally , figure [ fig : qopfig ] shows a successful attempt to remove in - shock cooling from the fiducial run . the method used to remove the effect was case - specific and
was achieved by allowing the gas to cool only when its temperature is in excess of the adiabatic jump temperature or its density exceeds the adiabatic jump density .
the upper curve in figure [ fig : qopfig ] shows the gas density , the lower curve shows the temperature and the middle curve , with the double maximum , shows the dimensionless ratio of the artificial pressure to the pressure , @xmath144 .
the density and temperature are plotted in code units .
the finite width of the shock can clearly be seen and the correct jump conditions and ionization level both at the peak of the shock and downstream are recovered .
the correct cooling tail down to a temperature of 12000k is also recovered .
the importance of the ratio @xmath144 is that it is a dimensionless indicator of when the gas is being shocked and might therefore be used as a method of removing in - shock cooling from other simulations , by means of preventing the gas from cooling when @xmath144 exceeds a certain threshold value ( i.e. when the gas is being shocked ) . however , this approach is unlikely to prove successful for two reasons .
firstly , consideration of the double maximum structure of @xmath144 as seen in figure [ fig : qopfig ] means than gas which is shocking does not necessarily have a value of @xmath144 greater than gas which is not .
indeed , gas which is radiating rapidly ( which is the case for gas whose density is increasing ) has values of @xmath144 as high as gas which is being shocked . secondly , although @xmath144 is dimensionless and in theory could produce a threshold value true for all scales of simulations , we would not expect the threshold value to be the same for shocks of different strengths .
these two reasons rule out the use of @xmath144 as a possible means of eliminating in - shock cooling .
this was tested in a large - scale cosmological simulation .
different objects were found to have very different values of @xmath144 and it was obvious that there was no single value that could be used to determine when gas was being shocked .
the authors would like to thank paul nulsen for discussion about the effects of in - shock cooling .
anninos p. , zhang y. , abel t. and norman m. l. , new astronomy , 2 , 209 black j.h .
, 1978 , apj , 222 , 103 chevalier r. a. & imamura j. n. , 1982 , apj , 261 , 543 couchman h. , thomas p. a. , and pearce f. r. , 1995 , apj , 452 , 797 haiman z. , thoul a. a. and loeb a. , 1996 , apj , 464 , 523 hutchins j. b. , 1976 , apj , 205 , 103 imamura j.n . , wolff m. t. & durisen r. h. , apj , 1984 , 276 , 667 martin p.g .
, schwarz d. h. & mandy m. e. , 1996 , apj , 461 , 265 press w.h . , teukolsky s. a. , vetterling w. t. & flannery b.p . , 1992 ,
numerical recepies in fortran 2nd edition , cup raymond j.c . & smith b. w. , astrophys .
j.suppl . , 1977 , 35 , 419 | we model a one - dimensional shock - tube using smoothed particle hydrodynamics and investigate the consequences of having finite shock - width in numerical simulations caused by finite resolution of the codes .
we investigate the cooling of gas during passage through the shock for three different cooling regimes . for a theoretical shock temperature of 10@xmath0k , the maximum temperature of the gas is much reduced .
when the ration of the cooling time to shock - crossing time was 8 , we found a reduction of 25 percent in the maximum temperature reached by the gas .
when the ratio was reduced to 1.2 maximum temperature reached dropped to 50 percent of the theoretical value . in both cases the cooling time was reduced by a factor of 2 . at lower temperatures , we are especially interested in the production of molecular hydrogen and so we follow the ionization level and abundance across the shock .
this regime is particularly relevent to simulations of primordial galaxy formation for halos in which the virial temperature of the galaxy is sufficiently high to partially re - ionize the gas .
the effect of in - shock cooling is substantial : the maximum temperature the gas reaches compared to the theoretical temperature was found to vary between 0.15 and 0.81 for the simulations performed , depending upon the strength of the shock and the mass resolution .
the downstream ionization level is reduced from the theoretical level by a factor of between @xmath1 and @xmath2 , and the resulting abundance was found to be reduced to a fraction of @xmath3 to @xmath4 of its theoretical value
. at temperatures above 10@xmath0k , radiative shocks are unstable and will oscillate .
we reproduce these oscillations and find good agreement with the previous work of chevalier and imamura ( 1982 ) , and imamura , wolff and durisen ( 1984 ) .
the effect of in - shock cooling in such shocks is difficult to quantify , but is undoubtedly present .
we conclude that extreme caution must be exercised when interpretting the results of simulations of galaxy formation .
methods : numerical hydrodynamics shock waves |
weakly interacting massive particles ( wimps ) are believed to be the most plausible candidate for dark matter ( dm ) in the universe .
wimps are predicted to exist in many extensions of the standard model of particle physics .
most of the well - motivated wimp candidates are majorana ( _ i.e. _ , @xmath0 ) fermions .
this in particular is often the case in models based on supersymmetry ( susy ) .
perhaps the most popular wimp candidate is the lightest neutralino , a superposition of the susy partners of the electroweak gauge bosons ( gauginos ) and higgs particles ( higgsinos ) .
other plausible wimp candidates for cold dm ( cdm ) , the axino and gravitino ( fermionic susy partners of the axion and graviton , respectively ) are also majorana particles . in the case of non - relativistic majorana wimps ,
their predicted elastic scattering couplings to atomic nuclei are effectively of two types @xcite . in scalar , or spin - independent ( si ) interactions
the wimp coupling is proportional to the mass of the nucleus . in the axial , or spin - dependent
( sd ) case , the coupling is proportional to the spin of the nucleus .
direct searches for galactic halo wimps through their elastic scattering off target nuclei are currently being carried out by several groups . in the absence of a positive signal
it is the aim of these experiments to set limits on the properties of wimp dark matter independently of its precise composition .
this is accomplished by setting limits on the cross sections for si and sd interactions between wimps and target nuclei as functions of wimp mass . to enable comparison with results from other experiments ( which may use different target nuclei )
one often translates these limits to bounds on the wimp - proton cross section .
the current procedure used for the conversion is relatively straightforward in the case of si interactions but becomes problematic in the case of sd interactions .
the reason for this is that limits on spin - dependent wimp - proton scattering cross sections contain considerable dependence on a particular wimp composition ( _ e.g. _ , gaugino - like versus higgsino - like neutralino wimp )
. since the spin of target nuclei is carried both by constituent protons and neutrons , when converting to a wimp - proton cross section a value for the ratio of the wimp - proton and wimp - neutron cross sections must be assumed .
but in many cases this ratio can vary significantly depending on the assumed type of wimp . in the particular case of a predominantly gaugino neutralino wimp
this ratio varies by several orders of magnitude @xcite . as a result ,
current experimental limits on the wimp - proton cross section for sd interactions are fraught with potentially significant wimp - type dependence . in this letter
, we introduce an alternative method for deriving limits on spin - dependent wimp - nucleon interactions .
this new procedure allows one to extract experimental limits in a ( majorana ) wimp - model independent way .
first , in sec . 2 , we briefly summarise the current practice .
the new method is presented in sec .
3 and its features are discussed in sec .
the current procedure for calculating spin - dependent wimp - nucleon cross section limits from experimental data can be summarised as follows ( following refs .
assume a detector consists of some species of nucleus , @xmath1 .
using the convention of ref .
@xcite ( see eqn . ( 7.13 ) ) , the total wimp - nucleus cross section @xmath2 can be written as @xmath3 where the wimp - target reduced mass @xmath4 is given by @xmath5 for wimp mass @xmath6 and target nucleus mass @xmath7 . the `` enhancement factor '' @xmath8
is given in eqns .
( 7.14 ) and ( 7.35 ) of ref .
@xcite for sd and si interactions , respectively , and will also be given explicitly below .
as emphasized in ref .
@xcite , @xmath2 ( called there @xmath9 ) is , strictly speaking , _ not _ the total cross section .
it is , by definition , the `` standard '' total wimp - nucleus cross section at zero momentum transfer .
however , it is the quantity that is conventionally used by experimental groups for setting limits and we will continue calling it here the total wimp - nucleus cross section . in the first step , the data is used to calculate limits @xmath10 on the si and sd wimp - nucleus cross sections .
( if the target is made of several species of nuclei ( _ e.g. _ , na and i ) , the procedure is performed for each species separately and next the limits are combined together . ) in each case it is assumed that only the given type of interaction ( sd or si ) dominates the total cross section .
the wimp - target cross section limit @xmath10 obtained for target @xmath11 can be expressed in terms of limits on wimp - nucleon ( _ i.e. _ _ free _ proton or neutron ) cross sections @xmath12 and @xmath13 @xmath14 where @xmath15 is defined by setting @xmath16 ( @xmath17 ) in the expression for the reduced mass @xmath4 above , and similarly for @xmath18 ( see also below ) .
this conversion is made conventionally to the wimp - proton cross section limit using the former expression .
the purpose of this conversion is twofold .
it allows one to compare limits derived by different experiments which use different target materials .
second , theoretical calculations in specific ( _ e.g. _ , susy ) models give predictions for @xmath19 ( and @xmath20 ) which can be next directly compared with experimental results . in the si case
the conversion is straightforward .
this is because now the enhancement factor is proportional to the square of the atomic number , @xmath21 ^ 2 $ ] where @xmath22 and @xmath23 are the effective wimp couplings to protons and neutrons , respectively .
for majorana wimps @xmath24 and so one typically has @xmath25 and the conversion does not depend on the specific wimp type . for massive dirac neutrino - like wimps
@xmath26 and @xmath27 and again the conversion does not depend on the wimp model or its parameters .
in the sd case however the situation is more complex . here
the enhancement factor as defined here ( and in ref .
@xcite ) differs slightly from a similar quantity @xmath28 used in refs .
@xcite : @xmath29 . ] is given by @xmath30 where @xmath31 and @xmath32 are ( wimp - type dependent ) effective wimp - proton and wimp - neutron couplings and @xmath33 are the expectation values of the proton and neutron spins within the nucleus and @xmath34 is the total nuclear spin . in the particular case of free nucleons
one finds @xmath35 and @xmath36 where @xmath37 has been used .
this definition of @xmath8 normalises the spin - dependent nuclear form - factor @xmath38 used in calculating nuclear recoil energy spectra to unity at @xmath39 : @xmath40 where @xmath41 here the @xmath42 are the respective isoscalar , isovector and interference term form - factors for nucleus @xmath43 ( assumed to be known from nuclear calculations ) and @xmath44 and @xmath45 are isoscalar and isovector coefficients . using this definition most of the wimp model - dependencies in @xmath46
are absorbed into @xmath8 , leaving @xmath38 and hence the shape of recoil energy spectra relatively model - independent .
recent calculations @xcite have shown that @xmath38 still contains some residual model - dependencies owing to differences in the @xmath47-dependence of the @xmath42 form - factors .
these differences are however small for most nuclei of interest , including na , i and f @xcite , and will henceforth be neglected .
it is clear from eqn .
( [ eq0.1c ] ) that , in the sd case , converting wimp - target cross section limits @xmath10 to the wimp - proton cross section @xmath12 becomes problematic .
this is because the enhancement factor @xmath8 now receives contributions from both proton and neutron terms . as we will argue below , due to the presence of wimp - dependent coefficients
@xmath48 , both of these contributions can be of comparable order and even of opposite sign . as a result , the ratio @xmath49 in eqn .
( [ eq0 ] ) , and hence the derived limit @xmath12 will depend on the assumed type of wimp . in the early ( single - particle or odd - group model ) calculations
the nuclear spin was always assumed to be dominated either by the proton or by the neutron term in eqn .
( [ eq0.1c ] ) .
thus when dealing with odd - proton targets , such as na or i , the @xmath50 in the expression for @xmath8 was conveniently cancelled by the @xmath50 in the analogous expression for the wimp - proton cross section enhancement factor @xmath51 .
model dependencies were thus eliminated .
the conversion is however complicated when dealing with odd - neutron targets because of the factor @xmath52 remaining in the expression for @xmath12 in eqn .
( [ eq0 ] ) .
this ratio is not guaranteed to be constant and in general is wimp model - dependent . in the important case of susy neutralino wimps early estimates of the @xmath53 values used in calculating @xmath31 and @xmath32 were nevertheless such that the ratio @xmath54 was always of order unity , independent of the neutralino composition .
later estimates of @xmath53 @xcite have however shown that although this is still true for predominantly higgsino neutralinos , the ratio for gaugino neutralinos is highly susy model - dependent and can vary by several orders of magnitude ( as demonstrated by fig .
[ fig0 ] for models from the database described in refs .
gaugino - like neutralinos as dm wimps are strongly favoured by a combination of naturalness and cosmological arguments @xcite in which case this problem becomes particularly acute .
a still further problem arises when using more recent shell - model calculations for @xmath55 and @xmath56 @xcite .
these indicate non - zero contributions to the nuclear spin from _ both _ protons _ and _ neutrons , and in this case the @xmath50 factor can not be cancelled from even odd - proton nuclei .
hence even if one of these contributions is larger than the other , as is often the case , then the wimp - dependent ratio of @xmath31 and @xmath32 can be such that both contributions to the cross section are substantial .
furthermore , @xmath57 and @xmath58 can in general be of opposite sign and similar magnitude .
hence , a more proper way of writing the enhancement factor would be @xmath59 in general therefore , depending on the particular wimp type , the wimp - target cross section can be considerably reduced relative to that of its constituent nucleons . in these circumstances limits set by assuming the simple case of higgsino neutralino or heavy neutrino wimps ( constant @xmath60 ) would prove to be unduly optimistic .
we will now present a new method for deriving limits on spin - dependent wimp - nucleon interactions .
the method will be free from the problems described above and will allow one to derive experimental limits in a way which is independent of the type of the assumed ( majorana ) wimp .
we will start by identifying the separate proton and neutron contributions to the total enhancement factor @xmath8 @xmath61 in light of eqn .
( [ eq : iapm ] ) , this gives @xmath62 .
following eqns .
( [ eq00 ] ) and ( [ eq0.1c ] ) we thus define the proton and neutron contributions @xmath63 and @xmath64 to the total cross section @xmath2 as : @xmath65 using eqns .
( [ eq00 ] ) , ( [ eq : iapm ] ) and ( [ eq9 - 1 ] ) , one can express @xmath2 as @xmath66 we note that @xmath63 and @xmath64 are _ not _ measured cross sections .
they are nevertheless convenient auxiliary quantities which identify separate proton and neutron contributions to the total cross section @xmath2
. we will now proceed as follows .
( see the appendix for a more rigorous treatment . )
we will first make an auxiliary assumption that @xmath67 .
in other words , we assume that the total wimp - nucleus cross section is dominated by the proton contribution only .
we then _ define _ the wimp - proton cross section limit @xmath12 corresponding to the wimp - target @xmath11 cross section limit @xmath10 as @xmath68 analogously , the wimp - neutron cross section limit @xmath13 is defined by assuming that @xmath69 and writing @xmath70 it is clear that the use of the ratios @xmath71 and @xmath72 ensures the cancellation of the wimp - dependent @xmath50 and @xmath73 terms contained within the wimp - target cross section @xmath2 and hence ensures wimp model - independence .
values of @xmath74 and @xmath75 for typical nuclei of interest obtained using data from refs .
@xcite are listed in table [ t1 ] .
these properties can now be used in expressing wimp - independent experimental limits on the wimp - nucleus sd interaction cross section @xmath10 in terms of @xmath19 and @xmath20 which are the quantities whose values are predicted by specific theoretical models . if an experiment publishes the limits @xmath12 and @xmath13 then eqn . (
[ eq9 - 2 ] ) can be used to define a wimp - independent excluded region in the @xmath19 - @xmath20 plane as @xmath76 because of relative sign ambiguity , the condition ( [ eq5 ] ) implies two bounds corresponding to constructive and destructive interference .
a conservative limit corresponds to the relative minus sign which reduces the overall wimp - target cross section .
we note , however , that in comparing with a specific theoretical ( e.g. susy ) model there will be no sign ambiguity : the theoretical model predicts not only @xmath19 and @xmath20 but also the signs of @xmath31 and @xmath32 . in this case
the sign in eqn .
( [ eq5 ] ) is known and is given by the sign of @xmath77 .
an alternative way of expressing the limits in this procedure is to consider exclusion regions directly in terms of the fundamental wimp - nucleon coupling coefficients @xmath31 and @xmath32 . in this case
( [ eq5 ] ) is replaced by @xmath78 where we applied eqn .
( [ eq00 ] ) to the case of the nucleons to obtain @xmath79 and @xmath80 .
the small proton - neutron mass difference has been ignored .
the variables @xmath31 and @xmath32 can have either sign , and the relative sign inside the square is now determined by the sign of @xmath81 only . eqn .
( [ eq5a ] ) corresponds geometrically in the @xmath31 - @xmath32 plane to excluding a region exterior to two parallel lines whose slope has opposite sign to @xmath82 .
there is no limit on @xmath31 or @xmath32 between these lines .
this region extends to infinity in both directions .
so far , we have presented the method for one species of target nucleus only .
a generalisation to two or more nuclei in the same target is straightforward .
analogously to the wimp - proton cross section limit in the current method @xcite , the limits @xmath83 and @xmath84 from different nuclei @xmath85 in the target @xmath11 can be combined by using @xmath86 it should be noted that when calculating the combined excluded region in @xmath19 - @xmath20 parameter space for two or more nuclei in the same target material it would be incorrect to use eqn .
( [ eq5 ] ) with the combined limits @xmath12 and @xmath13 calculated using eqn .
( [ eq4 ] ) .
the correct approach is to use instead the generalisation of eqn .
( [ eq5 ] ) given by @xmath87 a similar generalisation can also be applied to eqn .
( [ eq5a ] ) . in this case for given @xmath12 and @xmath13 optimum limits on the coupling coefficients @xmath31 and @xmath32 could be obtained by using two different target nuclei with @xmath88 of opposite sign , such as are found in nacl or naf .
the allowed region would then lie inside the intersection of the two bands of opposite slope . as a practical illustration , we consider limits from a synthetic data set ( assumed to be from a nai detector ) using both the current and the proposed techniques .
the data set consists of recoil energy dependent event rate limits which have been converted to wimp mass dependent target nucleus cross section limits using nuclear kinematics and eqn . ( [ eq0.2 ] ) as described in ref .
@xcite . in fig .
[ fig1 - 1](a ) we plot the limits calculated using the current technique ( _ i.e. _ using the expression for @xmath12 given in eqn .
( [ eq0 ] ) with @xmath8 from eqn .
( [ eq0.1c ] ) ) .
we do this for three different neutralino wimp compositions ( _ i.e. _ different ratios @xmath89 from fig . [ fig0 ] ) .
this results in overall ( combined na and i ) limits @xmath90 which , for a given wimp mass but different type , can be different by almost two orders of magnitude : a thick solid curve corresponds to the limit for the higgsino wimp ( @xmath91 ) , which is currently commonly assumed , while the two thick dash - dotted lines correspond to the two gaugino wimp cases giving the extremal limits for wimps of mass 100 gev / c@xmath92 .
these two curves illustrate the considerable effects of destructive ( upper curve ) and constructive ( lower curve ) interference between proton and neutron contributions to the nuclear spin .
results obtained using the proposed technique are presented in figs .
[ fig1 - 1](b ) and ( c ) .
we plot the limits @xmath12 and @xmath13 calculated using eqns .
( [ eq4.-1p ] ) - ( [ eq4.-1n ] ) and hence avoiding the assumption of a specific wimp composition .
we can clearly see that the limits in windows ( a ) , ( b ) and ( c ) differ considerably .
in all the cases at small wimp masses the best limits are provided by na due to its slowly - varying form - factor @xmath38 .
however , at larger masses iodine provides a better limit due to its larger value for @xmath74 ( table [ t1 ] ) .
the spin of both nuclei is carried predominantly by protons and so for this target the limits @xmath12 are in general superior to @xmath13 .
the individual limits @xmath12 and @xmath13 presented in figs .
[ fig1 - 1 ] ( b ) and ( c ) contain all the information which allows one to draw , for a given wimp mass , exclusion regions in the @xmath19 - @xmath20 plane by using eqn . ( [ eq6 ] ) .
this is shown in fig .
we use the same data set as before and set a wimp mass of 100 gev / c@xmath92 .
[ fig1](a ) and ( b ) correspond to minus and plus signs respectively in eqn .
( [ eq6 ] ) , although in the absence of knowledge of this sign the former plot gives the more conservative limits .
finally we note that , in the presented technique , one can incorporate limits @xmath93 set on the spin - independent wimp - nucleon cross section @xmath94 by constituent nuclei @xmath85 using the technique of sec . 1 : @xmath95 in summary , in contrast to the currently used practice of using only the wimp - proton cross section @xmath19 for presenting the sd wimp - nucleus cross section limits
, this alternative method effectively uses both the wimp - proton and wimp - neutron cross sections @xmath19 _ and _ @xmath20 .
this ensures that the wimp - model dependence of the experimental sd cross section limits is removed .
the method applies to targets with one or more species of nuclei in the target and allows unambiguous comparisons with theoretical predictions .
in contrast to the currently used procedure , the new technique makes it possible for a given experiment to set limits on the spin - dependent wimp - nucleon cross section in a wimp - independent way .
another significant advantage of the new technique is that it makes the direct comparison of experimental results with theoretical predictions possible .
given the wimp - proton and wimp - neutron exclusion plots from a particular experiment , one can determine whether a specific choice of parameters is allowed or excluded for a given wimp mass simply by using eqn .
( [ eq7 ] ) .
in fact , all the information needed to allow or exclude any wimp candidate ( like susy neutralino wimps with arbitrary composition , non - susy heavy neutrino , etc . ) can be presented in only three figures ( e.g. fig .
[ fig1 - 1](b ) and fig .
[ fig1 - 1](c ) plus one si cross section limit plot ) .
no additional plots similar to fig . [ fig1 ] need be drawn to determine the exclusion region for a particular wimp mass .
it is not surprising that dark matter experiments using odd - proton targets will generally give very good wimp - proton cross section limits and rather weak wimp - neutron cross section limits for the same wimp - target cross section limits .
just the opposite will be true with experiments using odd - neutron targets .
this is what one should in fact expect : odd - proton and odd - neutron targets are effectively measuring two quite different and unrelated quantities ( @xmath19 and @xmath20 ) .
it is only in the particular case of higgsino neutralino and heavy neutrino wimps @xcite that the limits from such targets calculated using the new technique are still comparable , by using a constant value for @xmath91 to combine @xmath12 and @xmath13 into a single limit on the wimp - proton cross section .
these limits are equivalent to those obtained using the current technique ( _ i.e. _ fig .
[ fig1 - 1](a ) ) . in any case
, experiments may find it useful to publish such limits in addition to the @xmath19 and @xmath20 limit curves calculated using the new technique ( _ i.e. _ fig .
[ fig1 - 1](b ) and fig .
[ fig1 - 1](c ) ) . in the event of a discovery of spin - dependent wimp - nucleon interactions it is likely that a different procedure from that described above would be required to analyse the data .
in this case a fit would likely be performed to the observed nuclear recoil energy spectrum , with parameters such as the wimp mass and cross sections on each target nucleus being considered to be free .
this would in turn define an allowed region in @xmath19 - @xmath20 parameter space for each allowed wimp mass and it would be this region which could be compared with theoretical predictions . in conclusion ,
a new technique has been presented for deriving spin - dependent wimp - nucleon cross section limits from direct detection dark matter experiments .
this technique retains the attractive features of the current procedure , including the ability to combine limits from individual target nuclei .
the new technique , however , has the additional advantage of allowing the calculation of wimp - nucleon spin dependent cross section limits in a wimp - independent manner and of making it possible to compare experimental results with theoretical predictions .
here we present the basic formalism behind the alternative method presented in sec . 3 .
for the sake of completeness , we will include here some expressions given already there .
the separate proton and neutron contributions to the total enhancement factor @xmath8 given in eqn .
( [ eq0.1c ] ) are given in eqns .
( [ eq2 ] ) @xmath96 so that , from eqn . ( [ eq : iapm ] ) , @xmath97 .
following eqns .
( [ eq00 ] ) and ( [ eq0.1c ] ) the proton and neutron contributions @xmath63 and @xmath64 to the total cross section @xmath2 are defined as ( eqns .
( [ eq9 - 1 ] ) ) : @xmath98 using eqns .
( [ eq00 ] ) , ( [ eq : iapm ] ) and ( [ eq9 - 1 ] ) , one can then write @xmath99 ( eqn .
( [ eq9 - 2 ] ) ) . applying eqn .
( [ eq00 ] ) to protons and neutrons respectively and comparing with eqns .
( [ eq9 - 1 ] ) we find the following relations @xmath100 it is clear that the use of the ratios @xmath101 and @xmath102 ensure the cancellation of the @xmath50 and @xmath73 terms contained within wimp - target cross section @xmath2 and hence ensure wimp model - independence . unfortunately , the quantities @xmath63 and @xmath64 can not be measured directly .
we will therefore make independently the assumptions that @xmath103 in which case eqns .
( [ eq:3ap ] ) become @xmath104 in other words @xmath105 and @xmath106 are the wimp - proton and wimp - neutron cross sections derived from the wimp - target cross section @xmath2 by assuming that it is dominated by its proton and neutron contributions respectively .
these new quantities are related to @xmath19 ( @xmath20 ) and @xmath63 ( @xmath64 ) by @xmath107 hence from eqn .
( [ eq9 - 2 ] ) , @xmath108 experiments set limits @xmath10 on @xmath2 , while @xmath19 and @xmath20 are quantities whose values are predicted by theoretical models .
it is our goal to set limits on @xmath19 and @xmath20 by using the measured values of @xmath10 . in direct analogy with eqn .
( [ eq0 ] ) we then define the wimp - proton cross section limit @xmath12 corresponding to the wimp - target @xmath11 cross section limit @xmath10 as @xmath109 which are eqns .
( [ eq4.-1p ] ) - ( [ eq4.-1n ] ) in sec . 3 .
if an experiment publishes the total sd wimp - target cross section limit @xmath10 in terms of the corresponding limits @xmath12 and @xmath13 then a wimp - independent excluded region in the @xmath19 - @xmath20 plane will be given by the condition ( [ eq5 ] ) @xmath110
drt wishes to thank j.d .
lewin for extensive discussions and pparc for support .
we would like to thank cern and everyone involved with the organisation of the dark matter tools 99 workshop where the bulk of this work was carried out .
goodman , e. witten , _ phys .
* d31 * ( 1985 ) 3059 - 3063 . j.d .
lewin , p.f .
smith , _ astropart .
phys . _ * 6 * ( 1996 ) 87 - 112 .
g. jungman , m. kamionkowski , k. griest , _ phys .
* 267 * ( 1996 ) 195 - 373 .
j. engel , s. pittel , p.vogel , _ int . j. mod . phys .
_ * e1 * ( 1992 ) 1 - 37 .
ressell , d.j .
dean , _ phys .
_ * c56 * ( 1997 ) 535 - 546 .
ressell , _ private communication_. l. bergstrm , p. gondolo , _ astropart .
phys . _ * 5 * ( 1996 ) 263 - 278 .
j. edsj , p. gondolo , _ phys . rev . _ * d56 * ( 1997 ) 1879 - 1894 ; l. bergstrm , p. ullio , _ nucl . phys . _ * b504 * ( 1997 ) 27 - 44 ; e.a .
baltz , j. edsj , _ phys .
* d5902 * ( 1999 ) 3511 - 3524 .
l. roszkowski , _ phys .
lett . _ * b262 * ( 1991 ) 59 - 67 .
table 1 : values of @xmath55 , @xmath111 , @xmath74 and @xmath75 for various nuclei .
values of @xmath112 and @xmath111 for na , te , i and xe are taken from ref .
values for f are taken from ref .
all others are from the review of ref .
@xcite and the references contained therein .
figure 1 : the ratio @xmath113 plotted against neutralino composition @xmath114 for models from the database built up in refs .
@xcite . here
@xmath115 is the gaugino fraction and @xmath116 is the higgsino fraction .
small values of @xmath114 correspond to predominantly higgsino neutralinos while large values correspond to predominantly gaugino neutralino . in all models
plotted , the neutralino is a good dark matter candidate ( _ i.e. _ its relic density is in the range @xmath117 ) .
the neutralino - proton and neutralino - neutron cross sections @xmath118 and @xmath119 are calculated as in ref .
+ figure 2 : exclusion regions for simulated data from a nai detector .
figure ( a ) shows in the current technique the limits @xmath12 calculated using eqn .
( [ eq4 ] ) for the case of three different neutralino wimps .
the thick solid curve is the combined limit for a higgsino - like wimp ( corresponding to @xmath91 ) , which is currently commonly assumed .
the two thick dash - dotted curves are the combined limits calculated for two different gaugino neutralino cases assuming either destructive ( upper curve ) or constructive ( lower curve ) interference respectively between proton and neutron contributions to the nuclear spin . also shown are the individual limits from na ( dashed ) and i ( dotted ) nuclei contributing to the combined limit on the higgsino - like wimp .
+ figures ( b ) and ( c ) show the limits @xmath12 and @xmath13 respectively calculated from the same data using eqns .
( [ eq4.-1p ] ) - ( [ eq4.-1n ] ) in the framework of the new technique . dashed ( dotted ) curves again correspond to individual limits from na ( i ) nuclei and thick solid curves to combined limits obtained using eqn . [ eq4 ] .
the limits are neutralino wimp type independent .
+ figure 3 : exclusion regions in @xmath19 - @xmath20 plane are plotted in the case of 100 gev / c@xmath92 wimps calculated from the data of fig . [ fig1 - 1](b ) and ( c ) using eqn . [ eq6 ] . figure ( a ) is for the conservative case of destructive interference ( @xmath120 ) while figure ( b ) is for the case of constructive interference ( @xmath121 )
. dashed ( dotted ) curves correspond to limits from na ( i ) alone while the full thick curves show the combined limits .
note that in figure ( a ) no limit can be set by any one nucleus when @xmath122 due to destructive interference between the proton and neutron contributions .
combination of limits from two nuclei with different @xmath123 allows such a limit to be set however . | a new method is proposed for extracting limits on spin - dependent wimp - nucleon interaction cross sections from direct detection dark matter experiments .
the new method has the advantage that the limits on individual wimp - proton and wimp - neutron cross sections for a given wimp mass can be combined in a simple way to give a model - independent limit on the properties of wimps scattering from both protons _ and _ neutrons in the target nucleus .
extension of the technique to the case of a target material consisting of several different species of nuclei is discussed .
-1.cm shef - hep/00 - 2 , + mpi - pht/2000 - 16 , + may 2000 + + + + + + + + + : 95.35.+d ; 12.60.jv ; 14.80.ly _ keywords _ : dark matter ; wimp ; neutralino ; supersymmetry |
a precise determination of the bottom quark mass , being one of the fundamental parameters in the standard model ( sm ) , is of paramount interest in several areas of present day particle phenomenology . in the past
, qcd moment sum rule analyses have been successfully applied for extracting charm and bottom quark masses from experimental data on the charmonium and bottomium systems respectively @xcite .
the basic ingredient in these investigations is the vacuum polarisation @xmath3 , @xmath4 induced by the vector current @xmath5 for a heavy quark @xmath6 .
inclusive quantities , like @xmath3 , where no reference to a particular hadronic state is needed , are especially well suited for a description in terms of quarks and gluons .
theoretically , @xmath3 can be calculated in the framework of the operator product expansion ( ope ) .
on the phenomenological side , the imaginary part of @xmath3 is a physical quantity , related to the experimentally measured cross section for @xmath7 : @xmath8 because of its analytic properties , @xmath9 satisfies a dispersion relation . taking @xmath10 derivatives of @xmath9 at @xmath11 ,
one arrives at the following expression for the @xmath10th moment @xmath12 , @xmath13 where @xmath14 .
@xmath15 is the heavy quark pole mass , defined as the pole of the perturbatively renormalised propagator . under the assumption of quark - hadron duality
, the moments @xmath12 can either be calculated theoretically in renormalisation group improved perturbation theory , including non - perturbative condensate contributions , or can be obtained from experiment . in this way
, hadronic quantities like masses and decay widths get related to the qcd parameters @xmath16 , quark masses and condensates . as can be seen from eq .
( [ eq : mn ] ) , for large values of @xmath10 the moments become more and more sensitive to the quark mass , but also to the threshold region which is dominated by large coulombic corrections growing like @xmath17 .
the situation is greatly improved by utilising the quark mass in the @xmath1 scheme where perturbative qcd corrections turn out to be much smaller than in the pole mass scheme .
in addition for large @xmath10 the non - perturbative terms , the first being the gluon condensate , start to dominate over the perturbative contribution .
it will prove possible to find an intermediate range of @xmath10 where the sum rules are already very sensitive to the bottom quark mass and contributions from higher states are sufficiently suppressed , whereas the corrections from higher order as well as non - perturbative corrections are still under control .
the perturbative spectral function @xmath18 can be expanded in powers of the strong coupling constant @xmath19 , @xmath20 with @xmath21 . from this expression
the corresponding moments @xmath22 can be calculated via the integral of eq .
( [ eq : mn ] ) .
the first two terms are known analytically and can for example be found in ref .
@xcite .
the second order contribution is as yet not fully known analytically .
however , exploiting available results at high energies , analytical expressions for the first eight moments @xmath23 ( @xmath24 ) and the known threshold behaviour of @xmath25 , pad approximants for the function @xmath25 could be extracted @xcite .
this information is sufficient for a reliable determination of @xmath23 for @xmath10 in the region of interest . until now
, our expressions for the moments have been written in terms of the pole quark mass @xmath15 .
the relation between the pole and @xmath1 mass is known up to second order in @xmath19 @xcite : @xmath26\ ] ] where @xmath27 and @xmath28 are renormalisation scales for coupling and mass respectively .
explicit expressions for @xmath29 and @xmath30 can be found in appendix a of ref .
@xcite . using this relation
one finds the following expression for the moments @xmath31 and @xmath23 in the @xmath1 scheme : @xmath32 these expressions for the moments will be used in our numerical analysis presented in section 5 .
the leading non - perturbative correction is the gluon - condensate contribution to the massive vector correlator .
it is known at the next - to - leading order @xcite .
the relative growth of @xmath33 is proportional to @xmath34 .
therefore , the non - perturbative contribution grows much faster than the perturbative moments .
in addition , in the pole mass scheme , the next - to - leading order correction to @xmath35 is of the same size or larger as the leading term . because the perturbative expansion for the gluon condensate can not be trusted , we shall restrict our analysis to the range @xmath36 where its contribution to the @xmath37 moments is below 3% .
for different reasons to be discussed below , we shall anyhow restrict the analysis to moments @xmath38 . thus the gluon condensate can be safely neglected .
the first six @xmath0 resonances have been observed .
their masses are known rather accurately , and their electronic widths have been measured with an accuracy which ranges from 3% for the @xmath39 to 23% for the @xmath40 . for our purposes ,
the narrow width approximation provides a very good description of these states , because the full widths of the first three @xmath0 resonances are roughly a factor @xmath41 smaller than the corresponding masses , and the higher - resonance contributions to the moments are suppressed : @xmath42 where @xmath43 $ ] and the running fine structure constant @xmath44 @xcite .
the @xmath45 cross - section above threshold is unfortunately very badly measured @xcite . the second term in eq .
( [ eq : phen ] ) accounts for the contributions to @xmath46 above the sixth resonance as well as additional continuum contributions between @xmath47 and @xmath48 and is approximated by the perturbative qcd continuum .
hence the threshold @xmath49 should lie somewhat lower than the mass of the next resonance which has been estimated in potential models .
it is found to be @xmath50 .
a more precise estimate of @xmath51 can be obtained by requiring stability of the sum rule for very low moments . from the numerical analysis to be discussed below ,
we find @xmath52 . on the other hand only taking into account the first three @xmath0
resonances and requiring stability of the sum rule we obtain @xmath53 as expected .
using the theoretical expression for the moments of eq .
( [ eq : mn ] ) and the phenomenological ansatz ( [ eq : phen ] ) , the bottom quark mass can be calculated as a function of @xmath10 .
this is shown in figure 1 for various values of the input parameters . in our previous work @xcite , besides @xmath54 , we have also performed a determination of @xmath55 from the @xmath0 sum rule .
it was demonstrated that upon evolution to the scale @xmath56 the value of @xmath57 was completely compatible with current world averages though the error was larger .
thus , in this work we now decided to use @xmath19 as an input parameter within the current average @xmath58 @xcite .
the uncertainty in @xmath19 is included in the final error on @xmath54 .
although in the @xmath1 scheme the higher order perturbative corrections at a scale @xmath59 are much smaller than in the pole mass scheme , nevertheless for large @xmath10 they become dominant . for our central estimate of @xmath54
we thus followed the same strategy as in ref .
we choose a mass renormalisation scale @xmath28 where the perturbative corrections are minimal in the range of interest for @xmath10 .
this is realised at @xmath60 . for this choice from the solid curve in fig .
1 it is clear that the prediction for @xmath54 is stable even for @xmath61 where the non - perturbative contributions start to become important .
the more ` natural ' choice @xmath59 is displayed in the dotted curve . in this case
the result for @xmath54 is stable up to @xmath62 and then becomes unreliable due to @xmath19 corrections growing large .
for this reason we have restricted the range of @xmath10 from which we determine the bottom quark mass to @xmath63 . including all variations of the input parameters as well as the renormalisation scales in our error estimate @xcite , as our final result for the running @xmath1 mass @xmath64 we obtain : @xmath65 for very low moments the continuum contribution in eq .
( [ eq : phen ] ) is not very well suppressed and thus @xmath54 displays a strong dependence on the threshold @xmath51 . as has been already discussed in the last section , by requiring stability of the sum rule we obtain @xmath52 ( solid line ) . for comparison , as extreme cases , in fig . 1 we have also plotted the sum rule for the choices @xmath53 ( dashed line ) and @xmath66 ( dot - dashed line )
. the first case corresponds to using the perturbative qcd continuum above the @xmath67 but nevertheless including the higher resonance contribution .
this is certainly overcounting the continuum contribution .
the second choice would assume a very high mass for the @xmath68 and no additional continuum contribution above the @xmath67 .
this is definitely on the low side of the estimates . as can be seen in fig .
1 , even for these extreme cases using moments with @xmath69 sufficiently suppresses the dependence on the continuum contribution and gives a good determination of @xmath54 .
our updated result for the bottom quark @xmath1 mass @xmath64 as obtained from the sum rules for the @xmath0 system is in very good agreement to other recent determinations also including lattice gauge theory @xcite .
it is @xmath70 higher than our previous determination for @xmath54 @xcite .
the reason was a small inconsistency in implementing the scale dependence of the @xmath1 mass in our numerical program .
however , this shift lies well within the range of our estimated error .
very recently it has become possible to obtain an estimate of the bottom quark mass measuring three - jet rates at lep @xcite .
the natural scale at which @xmath54 is evaluated in this case is @xmath56 .
evolving the value for @xmath54 determined in our analysis to the @xmath71-boson mass , we find : @xmath72 the result obtained from lep measurements is at present much less precise but nevertheless in very good agreement with the value given above . on the other hand
it is the first indication of a scale running of the bottom quark mass in the @xmath1 scheme .
another frequently used mass definition for the bottom quark is the pole mass .
recent determinations of the bottom quark pole mass include @xcite .
the pole mass determination from the @xmath0 system suffers from two difficulties : firstly the @xmath73 corrections in this case are much larger than for the @xmath1 scheme and a resummation of these large coulombic corrections has to be performed .
the second problem is the fact that the pole mass suffers from a renormalon ambiguity which introduces an intrinsic unknown uncertainty . using our result for @xmath54 given above and the perturbative relation between pole and @xmath1 mass given in section 2 , we obtain @xmath74 .
this result is in agreement with the cited pole mass determinations except for the previous work by the authors where @xmath75 was found .
the discrepancy is due to the fact that in ref .
@xcite the contribution from the coulomb poles has been neglected .
this contribution formally is of @xmath76 and the analysis @xcite was especially aiming for a consistent treatment of higher orders up to @xmath77 .
nevertheless it turned out that the contribution from coulomb poles is very important and should be included .
the analysis in the @xmath1 scheme was not inflicted by such a problem .
we shall come back to these and related questions in a forthcoming publication . | the talk presents an update of the bottom quark mass determination from qcd moment sum rules for the @xmath0 system by the authors @xcite . employing the @xmath1 scheme
, we find @xmath2 .
the differences to our previous analysis will be discussed and we comment on the determination of the pole mass for the bottom quark . |
ngc7538irs1 was first detected in the radio at 5 ghz by @xcite , who found three compact radio sources at the se edge of the large ( @xmath3 4 ) region ngc7538 , which is at a distance 2.65 kpc @xcite .
the brightest of the three , source b , has later become known as irs1 @xcite .
the far - infrared luminosity of the three sources is @xmath31.9 10@xmath7 , completely dominated by irs1@xcite .
irs1 was first resolved with the vla at 14.9 ghz by @xcite , who showed that it has a compact ( @xmath302 ) bipolar n - s core with faint extended fan - shaped lobes , suggesting an ionized outflow .
this is an extremely well - studied source with numerous masers , a prominent molecular outflow and extremely broad hydrogen recombination lines indicating substantial mass motion of the ionized gas @xcite .
although it has been modeled as an ionized jet @xcite or a photo - ionized accretion disk @xcite , the source is usually referred to as an ultra compact or hyper compact region with a turnover at @xmath3 100 ghz . since we have carried extensive observations of irs1 with bima and carma , the desire to determine the contribution from dust emission at mm - wavelengths led us to investigate where the free - free emission from irs1 becomes optically thin .
such a determination is not possible from published data , because irs1 has been observed with a variety of vla configurations , some of which resolve out the extended emission and others may only quote total flux .
this prevented us from separately estimating the flux for the compact bipolar core and the extended lobes .
furthermore the flux density varies with time @xcite , which makes it difficult to derive an accurate spectral index .
we have retrieved and re - analyzed a few key observations of ngc7538irs1 from the vla data archive . these are all long integration observations with very high angular resolution , good uv - coverage , and high image fidelity .
table [ tbl-1 ] gives the observing dates , synthesized beam width , sensitivity , the integrated flux of the bipolar core , and the observed total flux .
we included a bna array observation obtained by us at x - band ( 8.5 ghz)@xcite , because it is more contemporary with the high frequency data sets and provides an additional data point at a frequency where there are no other high angular resolution vla data available .
fig [ fig - irs1 - 3 ] shows the irs1 - 3 field at 4.8 ghz , while fig [ fig - vla ] shows the morphology of the compact bipolar core as a function of frequency .
we determined flux densities of the compact bipolar core with an accuracy of a few percent .
the results are given in table [ tbl-1 ] .
table [ tbl-1 ] also gives total flux densities , obtained by integrating over the whole area where we detect emission from irs1 . at 4.9 ghz
the total linear extent of irs1 is @xmath3 7 , while it is @xmath3 14 at 43.4 ghz .
even though we can reliably determine the flux density of the bipolar core at 43.4 ghz , some of the faint extended emission is filtered out ; therefore the total flux is underestimated . at 4.9 ghz
the bipolar core has a total length of @xmath3 11 fwhm ( full width half maximum ) , with a separation between the two peaks of 068 , at 14.9 ghz the size is 044 with a peak separation of 024 ( table [ tbl-1 ] ) .
at 43.4 ghz we can still fit the core with a double gaussian with a peak separation of @xmath3 012 , while the linear size ( length ) has a fwhm of 020 .
since one of our data sets ( x - band , 8.4 ghz ) has insufficient resolution to resolve the two bipolar cores , we plot the linear size ( length ) as a function of wavelength in fig . [ fig - jet ] , although fitting to the lobe separation gives virtually identical results , but with a larger uncertainty .
we find the size to vary with frequency as @xmath8 , while the flux density increases with frequency as @xmath9 .
the frequency dependence of the total flux is more difficult to estimate , since some vla configurations are not very sensitive to faint extended emission and will therefore underestimate the total flux .
if we chose data sets which give a reliable flux for irs2 , which is a spherical region with a size of @xmath3 8 , we find that the total flux from irs1 has a slightly steeper spectral index , 0.8 @xmath10 0.03 determined from data sets from 4.8 ghz to 49 ghz .
the fit to the total flux densities for irs1 is shown as a dotted line in fig .
[ fig - jet ] .
such a shallow frequency dependence would require a very steep density gradient in the ionized gas , if the emission originates from an region ionized by a central o - star , although it is not impossible , see e.g. @xcite . a high - density region with a steep density gradient should be spherical , not bipolar with a dark central lane as we observe in irs1 .
neither can a steep density gradient model explain the extremely broad recombination lines observed in irs1 @xcite .
all these characteristics can be explained , if the emission originates in an ionized stellar wind or jet @xcite .
the inner part of the jet is optically thick and further out , where the jet expands , the emission becomes optically thin . at higher frequencies
the outer part of the jet becomes optically thin and therefore appears shorter and more collimated , exactly what we see in irs1 , see fig [ fig - vla ] .
for a uniformly expanding spherical wind , the size of the source varies as a function of frequency as @xmath11 , while the flux density density goes as @xmath12 @xcite .
since we resolve the emission from irs1 , we know that it is not spherical , but instead it appears to originate in an initially collimated bipolar jet ( opening angle @xmath13 30 ) approximately aligned with the molecular outflow from irs1 , see section [ accretion ] . for
a collimated ionized jet , @xcite showed that it can have a spectral index anywhere between 2 and @xmath140.1 , depending on gradients in jet width , velocity , degree of ionization , and temperature .
lccllll 4.86 & 0.43 @xmath15 0.37 @xmath165.4 & 0.30 & 1.06 @xmath15 0.44 @xmath149.6 & 94.3 @xmath10 4.8 & 122.5 & 1984:1123 + 8.46 & 1.21 @xmath15 0.47 @xmath140.5 & 0.05 & 0.76 @xmath15 0.30 @xmath1410.9 & 135.7 @xmath10 13.6 & 148.1 & 2003:1014 + 14.94 & 0.14 @xmath15 0.12 @xmath1647.6 & 0.017 & 0.44 @xmath15 0.20 @xmath140.3 & 185.9 @xmath10 5.6 & 248.7 & 2006:0226,0512 + 14.91 & 0.14 @xmath15 0.10 @xmath1613.7 & 0.081 & 0.50 @xmath15 0.20 @xmath141.2 & 165.2 @xmath10 13.3 & 291.0 & 1994:1123 + 22.37 & 0.08 @xmath15 0.08 @xmath1443.0 & 0.017 & 0.34 @xmath15 0.17 @xmath163.1 & 286.5 @xmath10 11.5 & 370.0 & 1994:1123 + 43.37 & 0.14 @xmath15 0.12 @xmath1614.5 & 0.17 & 0.20 @xmath15 0.14
@xmath141.0 & 429.7 @xmath10 12.9 & 473.7 & 2006:0706,0914 +
although the molecular outflow from irs1 in early studies was found to be quite compact and going from se to nw @xcite , we find that the molecular outflow is very extended ( @xmath17 4 ) and approximately aligned with the free - free jet from analyzing large mosaics obtained with carma in @xmath18co and @xmath19co j = @xmath20 , and hco@xmath4 j = @xmath20 . for hco@xmath4 we filled in missing zero spacing with fully sampled single dish maps obtained with fcrao .
a thorough discussion of the molecular outflow is beyond the scope of this paper , and will be discussed in a forthcoming paper ( corder et al .
2009 , in prep ) . here
we therefore summarize some of the main results .
the carma mosaics show that the outflow is very large and has a position angle ( pa ) of @xmath3 @xmath1420 , which is similar to the orientation of the collimated inner part of the ionized jet driven by irs1 on smaller angular scales .
the outflow extends several arcminutes to the north and starts as a wide angle limb brightened flow . to the south
the outflow is difficult to trace , because of several other outflows in the giant molecular core in which irs1 is embedded , but appears more collimated with a linear extent of @xmath3 2 .
analysis of spitzer irac archive data show that the outflow may be even larger to the south .
the 5.8 and 8.0 @xmath21 m irac images show a jet - like feature projecting back towards irs1 , extending to @xmath3 3.5 ( 2.6 pc ) from irs1 , which is much further out than what was covered by the carma mosaics @xcite .
however , the carma observations also confirm that irs1 is still heavily accreting . in hco@xmath4
j = @xmath20 we observe a clear inverse p cygni profile towards the strong continuum emission from irs1 ( fig [ fig - ipc ] ) .
the absorption is all red - shifted and has two velocity components , which could mean that the accretion activity is varying with time ( episodic ) . from these data
@xcite estimates @xmath3 6.8 of infalling gas . with the assumption that the accretion time is similar to the free - fall time , @xmath3 30,000 yr
, @xcite finds an accretion rate @xmath3 2 10@xmath6 m@xmath22/yr , which will block most of the uv photons from the central o - star , allowing them to escape only at the polar regions .
in fig . [ fig - jet ] we also plotted flux densities at 3 and 1 mm from the literature @xcite , supplemented with our own results at 3 mm from bima ( wright et al .
2009 , in prep ) and carma @xcite .
all the observed flux densities at 3 mm or even at 1.3 mm can be explained by free - free emission , with at most a marginal excess from dust emission .
high angular resolution carma continuum observations at 91.4 and 108.1 ghz confirm what is predicted from the fit to total flux densities in fig [ fig - jet ] , i.e. that the free - free emission dominates at 3 mm .
these carma observations resolve irs1 with a size of 05 @xmath2303 pa @xmath141 and 04 @xmath2301 pa 20 at 94 and 109 ghz , respectively , i.e. the 3 mm emission is aligned with the free - free emission , and not with an accretion disk , which is expected to be perpendicular to the jet . since we detect a collimated free - free jet and since there is a strong accretion flow towards irs1 ( section [ accretion ] ) , irs1 must be surrounded by an accretion disk .
the morphology of the free - free emission suggests that the disk should be almost edge - on , and centered halfway between the northern and the southern peak of the optically thick inner part of the free - free jet .
however , if such an edge - on accretion disk is thin , i.e. the height of the disk is small relative to its diameter , it may not provide much surface area , and is therefore difficult to detect at 3 mm . at 3 mm irs1 and irs2
are very strong in the free - free , and even the free - free emission from irs3 can not be ignored , which makes it very hard to detect dust emission from the accretion disk .
since the spectral index for dust is @xmath3 3 - 3.5 , the dust emission may start to dominate at frequencies above 300 ghz , observable only by sma , but even at 1.3 mm we may have a much better chance to detect the accretion disk .
there is some evidence for such a disk in 450 and 350 @xmath21 m continuum images obtained at jcmt @xcite .
until higher spatial resolution interferometer images are available , it is not clear whether this emission originates in a disk , from the surrounding in - falling envelope , or from a superposition of several nearby sources .
free - free emission from ionized jets is very common in low mass protostars ( class 0 and class i sources ) , which all appear to drive molecular outflows .
this situation is especially true for young stars , which often have rather well collimated outflows @xcite
. jets may also be common in young early b - type high mass stars @xcite , although they have not been studied as well as low - mass protostars , because they are short lived , more distant and harder to identify .
although there have not been any detections of jets in young o stars , i.e. stars with a luminosity of @xmath17 10@xmath7 , such objects are likely to exist .
broad radio recombination line ( rrl ) objects , many of which are classified as ultra compact or hyper compact regions @xcite offer a logical starting point , because they show evidence for substantial mass motions , which would be readily explained if the recombination line emission originates in a jet .
several of them also show evidence for accretion . in the sample analyzed by @xcite , which partly overlaps with the sources discussed by @xcite , they find four sources ( including irs1 ) with bipolar morphology .
all appear to be dominated by wind ionized emission , although not necessarily jet driven winds .
k3 - 50a , however , at a distance of 8.7 kpc @xcite , has a luminosity of a mid - o star , drives an ionized bipolar outflow @xcite , and has a spectral index of 0.5 in the the frequency range 5 - 15 ghz @xcite .
k3 - 50a is therefore another example of an o - star , where the free - free emission appears to be coming from an ionized jet
. detailed studies of broad rrl objects will undoubtedly discover more examples of jet - ionized regions .
such objects are likely to drive molecular outflows , excite masers and show evidence for strong accretion . to summarize : we have shown that the emission from irs1 is completely dominated by a collimated ionized jet .
the jet scenario also readily explains why the free - free emission is variable , because the accretion rate from the surrounding clumpy molecular cloud will vary with time
. it also explains why irs1 is an extreme broad rrl object
. since most hyper compact regions are broad rrl objects , and show rising free - free emission with similar spectral index to irs1 , other sources now classified as hyper compact regions , may also be similar to irs1 .
the national radio astronomy observatory ( nrao ) is a facility of the national science foundation operated under cooperative agreement by associated universities , inc .
the bima array was operated by the universities of california ( berkeley ) , illinois , and maryland with support from the national science foundation .
support for carma construction was derived from the states of california , illinois , and maryland , the gordon and betty moore foundation , the kenneth t. and eileen l. norris foundation , the associates of the california institute of technology , and the national science foundation .
ongoing carma development and operations are supported by the national science foundation under a cooperative agreement , and by the carma partner universities . | analysis of high spatial resolution vla images shows that the free - free emission from ngc7538irs1 is dominated by a collimated ionized wind .
we have re - analyzed high angular resolution vla archive data from 6 cm to 7 mm , and measured separately the flux density from the compact bipolar core and the extended ( 15 - 3 ) lobes .
we find that the flux density of the core is @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is the frequency and @xmath2 is @xmath3 0.7 .
the frequency dependence of the total flux density is slightly steeper with @xmath2 = 0.8 .
a massive optically thick hypercompact core with a steep density gradient can explain this frequency dependence , but it can not explain the extremely broad recombination line velocities observed in this source .
neither can it explain why the core is bipolar rather than spherical , nor the observed decrease of 4% in the flux density in less than 10 years .
an ionized wind modulated by accretion is expected to vary , because the accretion flow from the surrounding cloud will vary over time .
bima and carma continuum observations at 3 mm show that the free - free emission still dominates at 3 mm .
hco@xmath4 j = @xmath5 observations combined with fcrao single dish data show a clear inverse p cygni profile towards irs1 .
these observations confirm that irs1 is heavily accreting with an accretion rate @xmath32 10@xmath6 /yr . |
current models of hierarchical galaxy formation predict that galaxies form via the accretion of smaller lumps of gas , stars , and dark matter ( e.g. silk & norman 1981 ; kauffman , white , & guiderdoni 1993 ; cole et al .
recent simulations of this process assuming a lambda - dominated cold dark matter ( cdm ) universe uniformly reveal the presence of large numbers of low - mass dark matter halos persisting around larger galaxies into the present day ( e.g. klypin et al .
1999 , moore et al .
it remains unclear if these dark matter halos are filled with gas and/or stars and can be associated with dwarf galaxies and/or clouds or if they lack the mass to retain any baryons .
this raises the question : do we see such gaseous remnants of galaxy formation in emission around galaxies today ?
there have been many detections of clouds around nearby galaxies , many of which have been hypothesized to be primordial gas associated with galaxy formation .
no , however , has been unambiguously associated with galaxy formation .
its origin can be more readily attributed to tidal interactions , galactic fountains , or galaxy accretion .
ngc 4449 is an irregular galaxy with two counter - rotating gas complexes and extended distributed in large clouds , arms , and streamers ( hunter et al .
1998 ) . while this could be explained as infalling primordial gas ,
the distribution and kinematics of the gas are perhaps more simply explained as resulting from a tidal interaction with a nearby dwarf galaxy ( theis & kohle 2001 ) . in ngc 6946 , many clouds of are seen moving at velocities inconsistent with the rotation of the galaxy ( kamphuis & sancisi 1993 ) .
this high - velocity gas is widely associated with holes in the disk , and may be explained as gas that was ejected via a galactic fountain powered by supernovae in the galaxy .
an alternative explanation is that these clouds are infalling primordial material which has punched holes in the galaxy ( kamphuis & sancisi 1993 ) .
there are many other cases of seen outside of the main body of galaxies which have less certain origins .
ic 10 ( wilcots & miller 1998 ) and ngc 925 ( pisano , wilcots , & elmegreen 1998 ) are two examples of galaxies in groups of galaxies which have no stellar companions within @xmath0100 kpc , but both have clouds of @xmath010@xmath1@xmath2 within a few tens of kiloparsecs .
these clouds could be the remains of dwarf galaxies which have been torn apart by the larger galaxy , or they could be tidal debris from an ancient interaction , or these clouds could be primordial gas falling into these galaxies for the first time contributing to the ongoing assembly of these galaxies . finally , surrounding our own galaxy are the high - velocity clouds ( hvcs ) : clouds which lack stars and are moving at velocities inconsistent with galactic rotation .
because of this , we can not infer their distances or their masses ( see wakker & van woerden 1997 for a review ) .
hvcs most likely represent a variety of phenomena .
some hvcs are probably related to a galactic fountain ( shapiro & field 1976 ; bregman 1980 ) and are located in the lower galactic halo . other hvcs are certainly tidal in origin : the magellanic stream is the most obvious of these features , formed via the tidal interactions between the milky way , large magellanic cloud , and small magellanic cloud ( e.g. putman et al .
1998 ) , with other hvcs potentially related to other satellites , such as the sagittarius dwarf ( putman et al.2004 ) . and
some hvcs , such as complex c , may be infalling primordial gas ( wakker et al .
1999 ; tripp et al . 2003
gibson et al . 2001 ) . finally , blitz et al .
( 1999 ) and braun & burton ( 1999 ) suggested that hvcs are the debris from the formation of the local group , and not just the milky way , and are associated with dark matter halos . in this scenarios hvcs
are distributed throughout the local group with d@xmath0100 kpc 1 mpc and @xmath3@xmath010@xmath4@xmath2 .
klypin et al .
( 1999 ) and moore et al .
( 1999 ) raised the issue that cdm models of galaxy formation predict that the local group should have hundreds of small dark matter halos , while the number of known , luminous satellite galaxies is only @xmath020 . if hvcs are associated with dark matter halos then this discrepancy , the `` missing satellite '' problem ,
would be resolved .
also at issue is if the local group is somehow unique in this regard and other galaxies have a sufficient number of satellites to match predictions .
unfortunately , none of the detections discussed above are clearly associated with galaxy formation .
all of the detections may have alternative origins .
to better constrain the origin of such clouds , a more systematic search for them is required .
i discuss here the early results of such an survey of loose groups analogous to the local group using the parkes multibeam instrument and done in collaboration with david barnes ( melbourne ) , brad gibson ( swinburne ) , lister staveley - smith ( atnf ) , and ken freeman ( anu ) .
this survey will determine if there are massive analogs to hvcs in other groups of galaxies associated with dark matter halos as described above .
furthermore , this survey will find gas - rich dwarf galaxies and determine if the `` missing satellite '' problem is unique to the local group or a ubiquitous problem in all groups .
finally , these observations will serve as a benchmark for the properties of galaxies in spiral - rich loose groups and how they compare to galaxies in other environments .
to search for hvc analogs , to test models of galaxy formation , and to better understand the properties of groups like the local group , we have surveyed six spiral - rich , loose groups in 21 cm emission using the parkes multibeam instrument ( pisano et al .
2004a , b ) .
a loose group is a collection a few large galaxies and tens of smaller ones , where the large galaxies are well - separated , of order a few hundred kpc , over an area of @xmath01 mpc@xmath5 .
in contrast to compact groups , such as stephan s quintet and those cataloged by hickson ( 1982 ) where interactions are a driving force , loose groups generally have few interactions occurring .
we were particularly interested in loose groups containing only large spiral galaxies ; groups analogous to the local group .
if hvcs are associated with the formation of the local group , then they should be present in these groups as well .
the parkes multibeam observations were conducted in six separate observing runs between october 2001 and june 2003 .
the multibeam instrument was repeatedly scanned in right ascension and declination over an area of @xmath01 mpc@xmath625 square degrees with a velocity coverage of @xmath71500 kms@xmath8 until an rms sensitivity of 5 - 8 mjy beam@xmath8 per 3.3 kms@xmath8 channel was reached .
this translates to a @xmath3 sensitivity at the distances of these groups , [email protected] mpc , of 5.3 - 8.1@xmath1010@xmath11@xmath2 per channel .
the parkes data had fake sources inserted before multiple double - blind searches by eye for all sources were made .
all sources , not just new ones , were confirmed with follow - up australia telescope compact array ( atca ) observations . based on our identification of fake sources
, we determined that our searches were nearly 100% complete down to an integrated flux limit of ten times the rms noise times the square root of the number of channels ( pisano et al .
2004a , b ) . only three
groups have had their parkes detections confirmed with atca follow - up observations : lgg 93 , 180 , & 478 . in these three groups ,
all 20 previously optically - identified group members were detected as well as seven new -rich dwarf galaxies .
no clouds without stars identified on the digital sky survey were found .
because pisano et al .
( 2004a ) did not detect any hvc analogs in the three groups surveyed , we are unable to confirm the existence of analogs of the type proposed by blitz et al .
( 1999 ) and braun & burton ( 1999 ) .
we can , however , place limits on the masses and , hence , distances of the hvcs around the milky way if such objects are ubiquitous in the group environment .
this has been done by pisano et al .
( 2004b ) .
pisano et al .
examine only the compact hvcs ( chvcs ) identified by braun & burton ( 1999 ) as likely being associated with dark matter halos .
this is because many of the other classes of hvcs , such as the magellanic stream and large complexes , discussed by blitz et al .
( 1999 ) as being associated with dark matter have other , more likely , origins as discussed above .
pisano et al .
assume that chvcs are distributed in a gaussian manner about the milky way , and ask for what parent population of chvcs and what d@xmath12 for their distribution would we expect to see _ zero _ analogs around galaxies in the loose groups surveyed given the detection limits of the observations .
figure [ hvc ] illustrates the combined constraints from the observations of lgg 93 , 180 , & 478 on the distances and population of chvcs around the milky way .
if the chvc population in other groups has the same properties and as those around the milky way , then at the 95% confidence level , for 270 clouds , we see that chvcs must be clustered within 160 kpc of the milky way with an average @xmath3 of @xmath134@xmath1010@xmath11@xmath2 .
this is in good agreement with recent limits derived by other authors using a variety of other methods examining both milky way hvcs ( e.g. de heij et al .
2002 ) and extragalactic analogs ( e.g. zwaan 2001 ) and makes the original blitz et al .
( 1999 ) and braun & burton ( 1999 ) models which place hvcs at @xmath01 mpc extremely unlikely .
these limits imply that chvcs are more closely associated with individual galaxies , rather than groups of galaxies , and that there is not a large reservoir of neutral hydrogen , @xmath131@xmath1010@xmath14@xmath2 , waiting to be accreted onto galaxies like the milky way .
these observations do not rule out the presence of a large reservoir of ionized gas , however .
the observations of loose groups by pisano et al .
( 2004a ) do not find large numbers of -rich galaxies that would correspond to the low mass dark matter halos seen in the simulations by klypin et al .
( 1999 ) or moore et al .
( 1999 ) . as such
we can infer that the local group is not unique in its lack of low mass , luminous satellites as compared to the predictions of cdm simulations .
pisano & wilcots ( 2003 ) previously found this to be the case for gas - rich companions to isolated galaxies .
these results are illustrated in figure [ cvdf ] .
the cumulative velocity distribution functions for the local group , loose groups , and isolated galaxies have roughly consistent slopes which are inconsistent with the cdm models . from this
it is clear that our measurements of luminous halos do not match cdm predictions and either an alternative form of dark matter ( such as warm dark matter , coln et al .
1999 ) or a mechanism suppressing the collapse of baryons into dark halos ( e.g. tully et al .
2002 ) is needed to reconcile the observations with models .
these results will be discussed in more detail in future papers ( pisano et al .
, in preparation ) .
i would like to thank the organizers of the tullyfest for inviting me to present this work at such an excellent meeting .
i would also like to thank the staff at parkes and the atca for their wonderful support of these observations .
i would like to acknowledge generous support from both an atnf bolton fellowship and nsf mps distinguished international research fellowship grant ast0104439 . | models of hierarchical galaxy formation predict that large numbers of low - mass , dark matter halos remain around galaxies today .
these models predict an order of magnitude more halos than observed stellar satellites in the local group .
one possible solution to this discrepancy is that the high - velocity clouds ( hvcs ) around the milky way may be associated with the excess dark matter halos and be the gaseous remnants of the galaxy formation process .
if this is the case , then analogs to the hvcs should be visible in other groups . in this paper
, we review the observations of clouds lacking stars around other galaxies and in groups and present early results from our survey of loose groups analogous to the local group and its implications for the nature of hvcs and galaxy formation .
[ firstpage ] local group intergalactic medium galaxies :
dwarf galaxies : formation |
groups of galaxies are useful tracers of large - scale structure .
they provide sites in which to study the environmental dependence of galaxy properties , the galactic content of dark matter haloes , the small - scale clustering of galaxies , and the interaction between galaxies and hot x - ray emitting intragroup gas .
thus , it is desirable to have an extensive , homogeneous catalogue of groups of galaxies representing the various bound systems in the local universe . many studies in the past relied upon the pioneering work of abell ( 1958 ) to provide a set of target galaxy clusters ( see also abell , corwin & olowin 1989 , lumsden 1992 and dalton 1997 for similar studies ) .
however , because of the lack of redshift information available when abell was defining his cluster catalogue , concerns have been raised over the completeness of his sample and the impact that line - of - sight projections would have in contaminating it ( lucey 1983 ; sutherland 1988 ; frenk 1990 ; van haarlem , frenk & white 1997 ) . as a result of these worries , it became fashionable to select galaxy cluster samples based upon cluster x - ray emission ( gioia 1990 ; romer 1995 ; ebeling 1996 ; bhringer 2001 ) , this method being less prone to projection effects .
this strategy nevertheless brings its own complications , because x - ray emission depends sensitively on the details of intracluster gas physics .
the construction of galaxy redshift surveys over the past twenty years has enabled a number of groups to pursue the optical route to group - finding .
huchra & geller ( 1982 ) , geller & huchra ( 1983 ) , nolthenius & white ( 1987 ) , ramella , geller & huchra ( 1989 ) and moore , frenk & white ( 1993 ) used subsets of the center for astrophysics ( cfa ) redshift survey , containing a few thousand galaxies , to investigate both the abundance and the internal properties of samples of a few hundred galaxy groups .
maia , da costa & latham ( 1989 ) extended the database using the southern sky redshift survey of a further @xmath6 galaxies and identified a sample of @xmath7 groups containing at least two members .
all - sky galaxy samples of @xmath8 , @xmath9 and @xmath10 galaxies were used for group - finding by tully ( 1987 ) , gourgoulhon , chamaraux & fouqu ( 1992 ) and garcia ( 1993 ) respectively .
deeper surveys of small patches of sky have also been used to find groups by ramella ( 1999 , @xmath11 galaxies ) and tucker ( 2000 , @xmath12 galaxies ) .
giuricin ( 2000 ) , merchn , maia & lambas ( 2000 ) and ramella et al ( 2002 ) have performed analyses on catalogues containing up to @xmath13 galaxies , but the largest set of galaxy groups so far is that provided by merchn & zandivarez ( 2002 ) .
they used the @xmath14 galaxies in the contiguous northern and southern galactic patches ( ngp and sgp ) in the ` 100k ' public data release of the 2dfgrs ( colless 2001 ) .
this work extends that sample to the ngp and sgp regions in the complete 2dfgrs .
the entire survey contains about 220000 galaxies , @xmath1 of which are in the two contiguous patches once the completeness cuts detailed below have been applied . as well as using more galaxies than were previously available
, this study also contains the results from rigorous tests of the group - finding algorithm .
these are facilitated by the construction of very detailed mock 2dfgrss , created using a combination of dark matter simulations and semi - analytical galaxy formation models .
comparing the properties of the recovered galaxy groups to those of the underlying parent dark matter haloes provides a robust framework within which the parameters of the group - finding algorithm can be chosen so as to apportion the galaxies optimally .
furthermore , the ability to relate , in a quantitative fashion , the input mass and galaxy distributions to the set of recovered galaxy groups , is of crucial importance when trying to extract scientific information from the group catalogue .
this approach is identical in spirit to that adopted by diaferio ( 1999 ) when they studied the northern region of the cfa redshift survey .
the choice of group - finding algorithm is described in section [ sec : fof ] .
details of the mock catalogue construction and group - finder testing are given in sections [ sec : mock ] and [ sec : test ] .
section [ sec:2df ] contains the results when the group - finder is applied to the real 2dfgrs .
given a set of galaxies with angular positions on the sky and redshifts , the task of the group - finder is broadly to return sets of galaxies that are most likely to represent the true bound structures that are being traced by the observed galaxies .
for some applications , not missing any of the true group members will be particularly desirable . for others , minimising the amount of contamination by nearby , yet
physically separate , objects will be the priority .
it is inevitable that some distinct collapsed objects , situated near to each other in real space and along a similar line - of - sight , will be spread out by line - of - sight velocities to the extent that they overlap with one another .
thus , some unavoidable contamination is to be expected .
the aim of the group - finder described here is to find a compromise between the extremes of finding all true members and minimising contamination , with a view to providing groups that have velocity dispersions and projected sizes similar to those of their parent dark matter haloes . naturally , the efficiency of such a group - finder can only be calibrated and tested when the properties of the associated dark matter haloes are known .
the use of realistic mock catalogues is thus central to the entire group - finding procedure because it directly affects the composition of the final group catalogue through the choice of parameters for the group - finder . to date
, the job of finding groups in galaxy redshift surveys has typically been assigned to a percolation algorithm ( see tully 1987 , marinoni 2002 and references within trasarti - battistoni 1998 for alternative approaches ) that links together all galaxies within a particular linking volume centred on each galaxy .
these friends - of - friends ( fof ) algorithms are specified by the shape and size of the linking volume and how it varies throughout the survey . in order to produce galaxy groups corresponding to a similar overdensity throughout the survey
, the linking volume should be scaled to take into account the varying number density of galaxies that are detected as a function of redshift .
previous studies have not all chosen the same scaling for the linking length with mean observed galaxy number density , @xmath15 . at higher redshifts ,
flux - limited catalogues contain a lower number density of galaxies , causing the mean intergalaxy separation to increase .
the algorithm proposed by huchra & geller ( 1982 ) scales both the perpendicular ( in the plane of the sky ) and the parallel ( line - of - sight ) linking lengths ( @xmath16 and @xmath17 ) in proportion to @xmath18 .
ramella , geller & huchra ( 1989 ) scaled both linking lengths in proportion to @xmath19 .
in contrast , nolthenius & white ( 1987 ) and moore , frenk & white ( 1993 ) chose to set @xmath17 to correspond to the typical size in redshift space of groups detected as a function of redshift .
the perpendicular linking lengths were scaled in proportion to @xmath19 , this being how the mean projected separation varies .
thus , in contrast with the other methods , the aspect ratio of this linking volume is not independent of redshift . in choosing how to scale the linking lengths
, there is one primary condition that one would like to satisfy .
namely , that for a particular group of galaxies sampled at varying completeness , the edges of the recovered group should be in similar places . if this is achieved , then the inferred velocity dispersion and projected size and the actual contamination should be independent of the sampling rate . scaling both @xmath16 and @xmath17 by @xmath18 will lead to groups of similar shape and overdensity being found throughout the survey .
of course if the galaxy distribution is sampled very sparsely then this scaling can lead to linking lengths that are large with respect to the size of real gravitationally bound structures so , depending upon the nature of the galaxy survey , it may be desirable to put an upper limit on the size of the linking volume .
the maximum value of the perpendicular linking length is one of the parameters of the algorithm used here .
having defined how the linking volume scales with mean observed galaxy number density , the choice of its shape and size still remains .
the shape of the linking volume should clearly be spherical in the case where real galaxy distances are measured .
however , with redshift space distances , groups will appear elongated along the line - of - sight , and one can appreciate that in order to find all of the group members , @xmath20 would be helpful .
an approximate estimate of the amplitude of this stretching can be made by considering how rapidly galaxies will be moving in a halo of mass @xmath21 and radius @xmath22 .
if the circular velocity satisfies @xmath23 , the line - of - sight velocity dispersion can be written as @xmath24 and the total mass is @xmath25 , where @xmath26 is the critical density and @xmath27 defines the mean density relative to critical within the halo , then @xmath28 setting @xmath29 yields @xmath30 ( note that , according to the spherical ` top - hat ' model @xmath31 for @xmath32 and @xmath33 models respectively ; eke , cole & frenk 1996 ) thus , for an object with virial radius @xmath22 , the velocities produce a @xmath34 stretch along the line - of - sight of @xmath35 . the ratio of parallel to perpendicular sizes is independent of @xmath22 .
this ignores the redshift measurement errors which will add in an @xmath22-independent parallel contribution of @xmath36 for the 2dfgrs ( colless 2001 ) with no corresponding perpendicular increase . even at the lowest redshifts this error term is smaller than the typical line - of - sight linking length for the 2dfgrs .
consequently , the shape of the linking volume should be elongated , with a particular aspect ratio given by @xmath37 , and the appropriate value for this ratio should be @xmath38 to enclose @xmath39 of the galaxies along the line - of - sight . in dark matter n - body simulations ,
friends - of - friends group - finders are often applied in real space with a linking length that is @xmath40 times the mean interparticle separation in order to identify groups having overdensities that are @xmath41 ( davis 1985 ) .
this choice of linking length has been shown by jenkins ( 2001 ) to yield a halo mass function that is independent of redshift and @xmath42 , and thus provides a good definition of the underlying dark matter haloes .
since redshift space , rather than real space distances are available in the 2dfgrs , it is unclear quite what value of @xmath43 , in terms of the mean intergalaxy separation , is appropriate to reproduce the boundary of the groups as defined by a @xmath40 set of dark matter groups .
the parameter @xmath44 will be used to set the overall size of the linking volume through @xmath45 .
the semi - analytical model of cole ( 2000 ) predicts that light is typically more concentrated than mass in groups .
thus , a value of @xmath43 smaller than @xmath46 is likely to be appropriate for recovering the @xmath40 set of dark matter groups from a galaxy survey .
this discussion implies that the linking volume should be elongated along the redshift direction , and provides rough expectations for both the aspect ratio and overall size of the volume that will best recover the underlying dark matter haloes .
however , the precise shape of this volume is yet to be specified .
both a cylinder and an ellipsoid could satisfy the above requirements . in the absence of peculiar velocities ,
an ellipsoid reduces smoothly to the usual real space spherical linking volume , but tests on mock 2dfgrss reveal that a cylinder is slightly more effective at recovering groups that trace the underlying dark matter haloes .
this empirical motivation leads to a cylindrical linking volume being employed throughout this paper . while the picture painted in section [ ssec : link ] is pleasingly simple , with both the aspect ratio and the linking volume being independent of group mass , in practice the optimum linking volume to recover the @xmath40 set of dark matter groups from the galaxy survey is not quite this universal .
there are a number of reasons why this similarity breaks down .
for instance , the mass to light ratio in the mock catalogues varies with halo mass such that light is less concentrated in more massive clusters .
also , halo concentration depends on mass , and concentration affects the halo velocity structure and total enclosed overdensity ( when the halo edge is defined by an isodensity contour ) . using the galaxy population which sparsely samples the dark matter groups , these factors combine to yield a small systematic bias in the recovered group properties .
tests with mock catalogues have shown that this produces either small haloes with overestimated sizes ( and velocity dispersions ) , or large clusters with sizes that are underestimated . across the range of masses from @xmath47
this amounts to a @xmath48 per cent effect in the projected size and slightly smaller in the velocity dispersion . to correct for this
requires knowledge of the halo mass in which each galaxy resides .
an estimate of this quantity is made by measuring the galaxy density relative to the background in a cylinder with aspect ratio @xmath49 and a comoving projected size of @xmath50 .
this density contrast , @xmath51 , is then used to scale both the size and aspect ratio of the linking cylinder according to @xmath52 and @xmath53 where @xmath54 , @xmath55 and @xmath56 are parameters to be fitted from the mock catalogues .
this enables the removal of the biases described above , while effectively increasing the spread in linking lengths at a given redshift by a few tens of per cent .
in addition to varying with redshift , the mean observed galaxy number density , @xmath15 , depends on the depth to which a particular region of sky was surveyed , and the efficiency with which redshifts were measured .
the production of maps that describe the angular variation of the survey magnitude limit , @xmath57 , the redshift completeness , @xmath58 , and a function , @xmath59 , related to the apparent magnitude dependence of the redshift completeness , is described in section 8 of colless ( 2001 ) .
these quantities , along with a galaxy weight , @xmath60 , that models the local completeness of the 2dfgrs , were combined to define @xmath15 at the position of each galaxy .
galaxy weights were calculated by removing all fields in the 2dfgrs that have a completeness less than 70% and then all sectors ( areas defined by the overlap of 2dfgrs fields ) that have a completeness less than 50% .
rejecting all galaxies from fields of low completeness eliminates from the sample the small amount of data that was taken in poor observing conditions . rejecting sectors with low completeness removes regions which are incomplete due to the fact that some 2dfgrs fields were not observed or are excluded by the above cut .
unit weight is then assigned to all the galaxies of the parent apm catalogue in the remaining sectors .
all of these galaxies without measured redshifts have their weight redistributed equally to their 10 nearest neighbours with measured redshifts . since low completeness sectors are excluded , the weights produced are never large .
their mean value is @xmath61 with an rms dispersion of @xmath46 .
the inverse of the weight , @xmath62 , is a local measure of the completeness in the 2dfgrs around each galaxy . the model for the redshift completeness as a function of apparent magnitude is @xmath63 , \label{redcomp}\ ] ] where @xmath64 is a normalization factor determined by the overall completeness in a given direction .
the incompleteness in a given direction is a result not only of the failure to obtain redshifts for some of the faintest galaxies , but also of the failure to target galaxies either because the corresponding 2dfgrs field was not observed or because of constraints on the fibre positioning . to determine the completeness assumed in constructing the mock 2dfgrs catalogues , @xmath64
is set in each sector by demanding that the completeness averaged over apparent magnitude @xmath65 be equal to the measured overall completeness , @xmath58 , in that sector . here , the integrals are over the apparent magnitude range of the survey , from a global bright magnitude limit to the local faint magnitude limit . a simple power - law fit to the observed number counts , @xmath66 , is used .
in contrast , to model the completeness in the genuine or constructed mock catalogue , @xmath64 is fixed at the position of each galaxy by demanding that @xmath67 .
that is , the inverse of the weight assigned to each galaxy is taken as a local measure of the completeness in that direction . in the case of the genuine survey
this has the advantage that it will automatically take account of any small scale variation in the completeness that might occur due to the constraints on fibre positioning . having fixed @xmath64 , the comoving number density of galaxies at each angular position and redshift
is computed from the 2dfgrs luminosity function as @xmath68 the luminosity function used here is that estimated by norberg ( 2002 ) , convolved with their model of the 2dfgrs magnitude measurement errors .
taking all of these survey characteristics into account , and defining a maximum perpendicular linking length in physical coordinates as @xmath69 , the comoving linking lengths associated with a particular galaxy are @xmath70;~~ \ell_{|| } = r \ell_\perp ~ , \label{ldefs}\ ] ] and two galaxies @xmath71 and @xmath72 , at comoving distances @xmath73 and @xmath74 with an angular separation @xmath75 , are linked together if @xmath76 and @xmath77 the conversion of observed redshift to comoving distance ( @xmath78 ) requires an assumption about the cosmological model .
this impacts both on the inferred galaxy comoving space density , as @xmath79^{2/3}/h(z)^{1/3}$ ] ( see peacock 1999 ) and on the comoving distance for a given redshift . the angle subtended by the chosen linking length scales like @xmath80 . throughout this paper @xmath81 and @xmath82
will be used .
this is appropriate for the mock catalogues and not obviously very wrong for the real one ( spergel 2003 ) . at the median survey redshift of @xmath4 ,
this model yields an angular linking length that is almost two per cent larger ( and a comoving distance that is about five per cent larger ) than an einstein - de sitter model .
it is clearly important to understand how the galaxy groups discovered by this percolation algorithm are related to the underlying distribution of dark matter in the universe . to address this issue and , at the same time ,
determine the optimum set of parameters to use in the group - finder , mock 2dfgrss have been constructed using high resolution n - body simulations of cosmological volumes and a semi - analytical model of galaxy formation . the main n - body simulation used is the @xmath83cdm gif volume described by jenkins ( 1998 ) .
the density parameter is @xmath84 , the cosmological constant is @xmath85 and the normalisation of density fluctuations is set so that the present - day linear theory rms amplitude of mass fluctuations in spheres of radius @xmath86 , @xmath87 .
the box size is @xmath88 .
another simulation with @xmath89 particles in a @xmath83cdm box of length @xmath90 with @xmath91 has also been used to test the sensitivity of the optimum group - finding parameters to the amplitude of the mass fluctuations .
it turns out that the optimum parameter choice is insensitive to this change in @xmath92 , although the amount of spurious contamination does increase by @xmath93 per cent when this decrease in the contrast between groups and not groups is applied .
the gif volume will be used in the subsequent analysis .
dark matter haloes are identified in these simulation cubes using a friends - of - friends algorithm with a linking length of @xmath40 times the mean interparticle simulation .
the kinetic and potential energies of grouped particles are computed and unbound particles are removed from the group .
bound groups of 10 or more particles are retained , giving a halo mass resolution of @xmath94 ( see benson 2001 for further details ) .
the reference semi - analytical galaxy formation model of cole ( 2000 ) is used to populate the bound haloes identified in the @xmath95 output of the n - body simulation following the prescription outlined in benson ( 2000 ) .
the halo mass resolution of the n - body simulation in turn imposes a resolution limit in the semi - analytical calculation .
this corresponds to the absolute magnitude of central galaxies that occupy dark matter haloes that have ten or more particles .
scatter in the formation histories of galaxies and variable amounts of dust extinction cause a spread in the relationship between the luminosity of a central galaxy and the mass of the host halo . as a working definition , the magnitude limit of a @xmath95 volume - limited galaxy catalogue constructed from the n - body simulation is taken to be @xmath96 ; at this luminosity , @xmath97 of central galaxies predicted in a semi - analytical model calculation without any halo mass limitations reside in haloes resolved by the simulation .
the luminosity resolution of the volume - limited catalogue , when combined with the global @xmath98 correction adopted by norberg ( 2002 ) , implies that a mock 2dfgrs survey constructed from this simulation output will only be complete above a redshift of @xmath99 .
the median redshift of the 2dfgrs is @xmath100 , so it is desirable to extend the mock catalogue to fainter luminosities .
this was done by constructing a volume limited sample of galaxies from a separate semi - analytical calculation for haloes with masses less than the n - body resolution limit .
these galaxies were then assigned at random to the particles in the simulation that were not part of a bound halo .
this should be a reasonable approximation because the clustering of dark matter haloes is almost independent of mass for masses beneath the resolution limit of the gif simulation ( jing 1998 ) . using this technique ,
the luminosity limit was shifted to @xmath101 , so that a flux limited catalogue constructed from this output would be complete above a redshift of @xmath102 . a mock
2dfgrs was constructed from the volume - limited galaxy catalogue by applying the following steps : + o ) a monotonic transformation was applied to the magnitudes given by the semi - analytical model , perturbing them slightly so as to reproduce the 2dfgrs luminosity function .
the reason for doing this is that the galaxy luminosity function of the semi - analytical model is not a perfect match to the measured 2dfgrs luminosity function ( see fig . 1 of benson 2000 ) and
it is desirable that the selection function of the mock catalogue should accurately match that of the genuine survey .
the magnitudes are then perturbed using the model of the 2dfgrs magnitude measurement errors described in norberg ( 2002 ) .
+ i ) the volume - limited catalogue was replicated , about a randomly located observer , to take into account the much greater depth of the 2dfgrs volume compared to the size of the n - body simulation box .
this has no impact upon the tests of the group - finder presented here , although it does mean that the mock is unsuitable for studying the clustering of groups on scales approaching the size of the simulation box .
+ ii ) galaxies were then selected from within this volume by applying the geometric and apparent magnitude limits of the 2dfgrs survey defined by the map , @xmath57 , of the survey magnitude limit ( see section 2 and colless 2001 section 8) .
this produces a mock catalogue in which every galaxy has a redshift .
+ iii ) the appropriate redshift completeness was then imposed sector by sector on the mock catalogue , by randomly retaining galaxies so as to satisfy the function @xmath103 ( equation [ redcomp ] ) . +
this method ignores any systematic variation of the completeness within a sector , and in particular it does not take account of close - pair incompleteness on angular scales less than @xmath104 arcmin . to investigate the effect of this , a second set of mocks was also produced , in which close pairs were identified in the parent mock catalogue and preferentially rejected when reproducing the incompleteness in each sector .
not all close pairs are missed in the 2dfgrs because the large overlaps between 2dfgrs fields permits different members of close pairs to be targetted on different fields .
one statistic that can be used to quantify the level of close - pair incompleteness is the ratio of the angular correlation function of objects that have measured redshifts to that of the full parent catalogue ( hawkins 2003 ) . to reproduce the appropriate level of close pair incompleteness in the mock catalogue ,
the parameters of the rejection algorithm ( the angular scale of the close pairs and the fraction that are rejected ) were tuned so as to reproduce this statistic . in practice ,
the recovered groups hardly varied at all with the inclusion of the close pair incompleteness .
this is because of the combination of the large amount of field overlap in the 2dfgrs and the small angles over which fibre clashes become important .
every galaxy in the mock survey is either spawned by a dark matter halo containing at least ten particles or is a background galaxy that is located at the position of an ungrouped dark matter particle . in the following section
, the phrase _ the number of galaxies spawned by a particular dark matter halo _ will be used to refer to the subset of galaxies belonging to that halo which make it through the observing procedure and into the mock survey .
the use of a realistic mock 2dfgrs catalogue to set the parameters required for the group - finder and to interpret the nature of the derived groups represents a clear advance over previous work , which either neglected to present any such tests or , at best , used mock catalogues constructed from dark matter only simulations .
one criticism that could be levelled at the approach presented here is that it is model dependent .
however , direct tests have been performed to confirm that the optimum group - finding parameters are insensitive to catalogues created with a @xmath48 per cent lower value of @xmath92 ( and appropriate adjustments to the semi - analytical galaxy formation model ) .
it should be borne in mind that the default model does provide a very reasonable description of the real universe . in particular
, it is in excellent agreement with a number of observables that have a direct bearing on group - finding in the 2dfgrs : the local luminosity function in the @xmath105-band ( see figure 10 of madgwick 2002 ; cole 2000 ) , the clustering of luminous galaxies ( benson 2000 ) and the dependence of galaxy clustering on luminosity ( benson 2001 ; norberg 2001 ) . any alternative model would also need to reproduce all of these relevant observations for the testing of the group - finder to be similarly appropriate .
the mock surveys , complete with their parent dark matter haloes , provide a database on which to optimise the parameters of the group - finder .
these are mainly the maximum perpendicular linking length ( @xmath106 ) , the aspect ratio of the linking cylinder ( @xmath49 ) and the number of mean intergalaxy separations defining the perpendicular linking length ( @xmath43 ) . in the remainder of this paper , the additional tweaks to the linking volume described in section [ sec : fof ]
will be set to values obtained empirically : @xmath107 the process of deciding which is the best set of group - finding parameters requires a definition of what is good .
a good group - finder should find a high fraction of the available groups , provide accurate estimates of their size and velocity dispersion , avoid splitting them up into subgroups and minimise the number of interloping galaxies . in an attempt to quantify these qualities ,
the following four statistics have been defined : + 1 . completeness , @xmath108 , is the fraction of detectable dark matter haloes that have more than half of their spawned galaxies in a single galaxy group .
a dark matter halo is _ detectable _ if it spawns at least two galaxies into the mock survey .
the median accuracy , @xmath109 or @xmath110 , is the median @xmath111 of the ratio of associated galaxy group to dark matter group velocity dispersion or projected size .
the _ associated galaxy group _ is the one that both contains the largest number of the galaxies spawned by this dark matter halo ( or the group with most members overall if there is a tie ) , and is associated to this halo .
a galaxy group is _ associated _ with the dark matter halo that spawned most of its members .
if this is not unique , then the most massive of the possible dark matter haloes is chosen . with these definitions , it is possible for more than one galaxy group to be associated with the same dark matter halo , but that dark matter halo will have only one associated galaxy group .
the set of values from which @xmath109 and @xmath110 come is constructed by matching every detected dark matter halo with its associated galaxy group .
a _ detected dark matter halo _ is one with an associated galaxy group .
the spread about the median is described by the semi - interquartile range , @xmath112 or @xmath113 .
fragmentation , @xmath114 , is the mean number of extra galaxy groups per dark matter halo having mass , defined later in this subsection , at least @xmath46 times that of their associated dark matter halo for all detected dark matter haloes .
the quality , @xmath115 , of an individual halo to group match is defined as @xmath116 where @xmath117 is the number of member galaxies spawned by this halo that are found in the associated galaxy group , @xmath118 is the number of group members not spawned by this halo and @xmath119 is the total number of galaxies spawned by this dark matter halo . + the velocity dispersions of the galaxy groups were calculated using a variant of the gapper estimator described by beers , flynn & gebhardt ( 1990 ) .
this is an efficient estimator that is resistant to outlying velocities .
tests on groups found from mock catalogues showed that this estimator gave an @xmath109 that varied less with the minimum number of galaxies per group than other choices .
the gapper estimator also yielded an @xmath112 that was at least as low as the others for groups of all sizes . in detail
this involves ordering the set of recession velocities @xmath120 of the @xmath121 group members and defining gaps as @xmath122 using the following weights @xmath123 the gapper estimate of the velocity dispersion can then be written as @xmath124 under the assumption that one of the galaxies is moving at the centre - of - mass velocity of the halo , which is certainly true for the mock catalogues , the estimated velocity dispersion is multiplied by an extra factor of @xmath125 before the redshift measurement error , @xmath126 , is removed in quadrature , giving @xmath127 velocity dispersions of the parent haloes , which inevitably have many more dark matter particles in them than there are galaxies in the associated groups , were calculated as the root mean squared velocity difference from the mean .
the projected size of groups and haloes , @xmath22 , is defined as the weighted root mean squared projected separation from the group centre of the members .
this calculation is performed taking into account the galaxy weights resulting from the variable incompleteness , as described in section [ ssec : nofz ] .
the centre is defined using an iterative method that first calculates the arithmetic weighted mean position of the remaining galaxies then rejects the most distant galaxy .
when only two galaxies remain , the position of the galaxy with a larger weight , or if these are the same , the larger flux , is deemed to represent the group centre .
the projected group size is then the weighted rms projected physical separation of the other @xmath128 galaxies from this central galaxy .
this measurement , in conjunction with the velocity dispersion , can be used to estimate the group mass as @xmath129 where the value of @xmath130 was chosen so that , for the optimum choice of group - finding parameters described later in this section , the median mass was unbiased .
this led to a choice of @xmath131 .
the fragmentation statistic was calculated using these galaxy group masses .
these definitions provide a framework within which comparisons can be made between group catalogues returned by different group - finding parameters .
a good set of parameter values will yield a set of galaxy groups that have a completeness near to @xmath132 , a median accuracy of @xmath133 ( this being the log of the ratio of measured to true velocity dispersion or radius ) , independent of the group mass or redshift , with a small spread about this median , a fragmentation near to @xmath133 , and a quality of @xmath134 .
= 8.5 cm = 18.5 cm = 18.5 cm in section [ sec : fof ] , the three main free parameters of the group - finder were described .
these determine the overall size of the linking volume through @xmath43 , the maximum size of the linking volume via @xmath106 and the aspect ratio of the linking volume , defined by @xmath49 . applying the group - finder to the mock catalogues described in section [ sec : mock ] using various group - finding parameters ,
the recovered galaxy groups can be compared with their parent dark matter haloes , and the optimum set of parameters can be found .
the following three subsections detail the effect of varying each of these parameters individually .
the appropriate value for the maximum perpendicular linking length , @xmath106 , should be similar to the size of the typical objects that are detectable at larger redshifts , where the number density of galaxies is low and this limit becomes relevant .
values around a couple of physical @xmath135 are therefore a good place to search . @xmath136 and
@xmath137 have been fixed .
the justification for choosing these particular parameter values is contained in the following two subsections .
[ fig : bz ] shows the behaviour of the comoving perpendicular linking length with redshift for @xmath138 .
the increase of @xmath16 with redshift reflects the decreasing mean observed number density of galaxies , and the spread in linking length at a given redshift comes from the angular variation in survey depth and the fraction of galaxies with measured redshifts .
larger values of @xmath106 lead to larger linking volumes at the highest redshifts and some associated additional contamination .
decreasing @xmath106 yields underestimates of the projected sizes and velocity dispersions of the groups at redshifts where the limit affects the size of the linking volume .
thus @xmath138 is chosen as a physically motivated compromise . as was estimated in section [ sec : fof ]
, the appropriate choice for the axis ratio of the linking cylinder is @xmath93 .
a variety of values surrounding this one have been tried in conjunction with @xmath138 and @xmath137 .
[ fig : varyr ] compares the properties of the dark matter haloes with those of their associated galaxy groups .
the projected group sizes are fairly insensitive to @xmath49 as would be expected considering that these changes only impact upon the line - of - sight linking length .
in contrast , the velocity dispersions are affected , and the more elongated linking volumes yield larger values , with an unbiased median being returned when @xmath139 .
as the linking volume is stretched , the completeness , fragmentation and quality change only very slightly , with the most significant change being a decrease of the quality of the group matches at higher redshift .
note that the drop in quality for the most massive haloes is driven by the large number of high redshift , poorly sampled groups . to illustrate this , an additional long - dashed line is included in the lowest two panels in the first column of fig .
[ fig : varyr ] showing the results using only the groups at @xmath140 .
this demonstrates that considering only the nearby , well sampled massive groups yields a mean halo quality , and interloper content , that is comparable with the lower mass haloes . using the requirement that the median velocity dispersion be faithfully measured selects @xmath136 as the best choice .
this is comparable with that suggested by the rough calculation leading to equation [ lrat2 ] .
note that without the additional halo mass dependent tweaks to the linking volume discussed in section 2 , the values of which are given in section [ ssec : defs ] , there would be a gradient of @xmath141 in all median accuracy curves as a function of dark matter halo mass .
keeping @xmath138 and @xmath136 fixed , the value of @xmath43 , the number of mean intergalaxy separations defining the perpendicular linking length , was varied from @xmath4 up to @xmath142 , and the parent @xmath40 dark matter haloes were again compared with the resulting galaxy groups .
[ fig : varyb ] shows the results .
as the linking lengths are increased , the recovered median group velocity dispersions and projected sizes also increase as larger volumes are grouped together .
this is in contrast to the results when @xmath49 was varied and only the velocity dispersions were much affected .
these changes are significant for all parent dark matter halo masses . along with these variations , the increasing linking lengths increase completeness , reduce fragmentation and decrease the quality of the matches .
the least biased accuracies are produced when @xmath137 , and this is the value adopted for the rest of this paper .
= 8.5 cm the results from the testing described in the previous three subsections suggest that an appropriate choice of group - finding parameters is @xmath138 , @xmath136 and @xmath137 .
these provide a set of groups that have unbiased velocity dispersions and sizes . in doing this ,
they contain almost all of the galaxies that should be included in groups with at least @xmath143 members , and some interlopers as well .
smaller values of all of the above three parameters should be employed if reducing contamination is of greater importance than capturing as many true group members while not overestimating the velocity dispersion or projected size .
the level of contamination in the groups found by this particular choice of group - finding parameters is illustrated in fig . [
fig : zdist ] .
this shows the redshift dependence of ratios of the memberships of the following three sets : 1 ) @xmath144 , representing all galaxies in the mock survey , 2 ) @xmath145 , representing all grouped galaxies and 3 ) @xmath146 , representing galaxies that come from dark matter haloes which have spawned at least two galaxies into the mock survey , those that could be linked to another galaxy spawned by the same parent halo .
@xmath147 is used to denote the overlap between sets @xmath145 and @xmath146 , and @xmath148 is the membership of group @xmath71 .
the dotted curve in fig . [ fig : zdist ] shows that the detected groups contain almost all of the galaxies that belong in set @xmath146 for all redshifts . for redshifts less than @xmath149 ,
the fraction of all galaxies that are grouped is @xmath150 , as shown by the long dashed curve , whereas the solid curve shows that the fraction of all galaxies in set @xmath146 is only @xmath151 . of the grouped galaxies in this redshift range , only about @xmath152 per cent of them are members of set @xmath146 .
this quantity is shown by the short dashed line in fig .
[ fig : zdist ] .
the accuracy statistic relates only to the dark matter haloes that have spawned at least two galaxies ( the detectable haloes ) , and have at least one associated galaxy group . for the above choice of group - finding parameters ,
about @xmath153 per cent of galaxy groups are the best matches to detectable dark matter haloes , @xmath154 per cent are associated with dark matter haloes that have only spawned one galaxy , @xmath155 per cent are other matches with dark matter haloes and the remaining @xmath156 per cent are made up completely from background galaxies that have been spawned by no well defined dark matter halo .
thus , a significant fraction of the recovered groups are not being used to determine the group - finding parameters .
these groups usually have velocity dispersions and projected sizes that are larger than those of their parent dark matter haloes .
consequently , the measured velocity dispersion and projected size for typical groups containing @xmath143 galaxies , will be overestimates of those of the underlying dark matter halo .
however , it would be inappropriate to adapt the group - finding parameters to be unbiased when these spurious groups are included , because this would inevitably spoil the results for the good matches .
= 21.5 cm = 15.5 cm together , the ngp and sgp regions in the 2dfgrs contain @xmath157 galaxies once cuts of 70% and 50% have been applied for field and sector completeness respectively .
this set of galaxies , with their appropriate weights so that the mean observed galaxy number density @xmath15 can be defined for each galaxy according to equation [ nofz ] , has been used along with the friends - of - friends group - finder described in section [ sec : fof ] with @xmath138 , @xmath136 and @xmath137 , in order to find ` real ' galaxy groups . the resulting catalogue places @xmath0 per cent of all of the galaxies within @xmath158 groups with at least two members . a total of @xmath159 groups are found with at least four members , and their median redshift and velocity dispersion are @xmath4 and @xmath160 respectively .
the corresponding quantities for the sets of groups with at least 3 or 5 members are ( @xmath161 , median @xmath162 , median @xmath163 ) = ( 12566 , 0.11 , 227 ) and ( 4503 , 0.11 , 286 ) . the spatial distribution of the 2piggs containing at least @xmath164 galaxies is illustrated in fig .
[ fig : dots ] .
each dot represents a group , with the colour and size representing the group velocity dispersion and weighted galaxy content respectively .
typical dot sizes decrease at large redshifts because the flux - limited survey means that large distant groups are sampled with only a few bright galaxies . at @xmath165
the typical velocity dispersion also grows .
this happens both because only the bigger groups have enough bright galaxies to be recovered , and the smaller group memberships produce larger errors on the measured velocity dispersions , thus increasing the abundance of groups with apparently large velocity dispersions .
figure [ fig : props ] shows the distributions of these groups with respect to redshift , velocity dispersion , mass and weighted number of members , for the ngp and sgp strips of the survey . while the sgp has almost @xmath166 per cent more galaxies in it than the ngp , the fraction grouped ( 0.56 and 0.54 for the ngp and sgp respectively ) and the distributions of properties of the resulting groups are very similar .
the main difference is in the redshift distribution of groups , where the lower flux limit in the sgp betrays itself with a more extended distribution than the ngp .
consequently , a few extra high velocity dispersion , or equivalently high mass , clusters are found in the south .
although they are not reproduced here , these distributions of group properties are well matched to those found from the mock catalogues that were used to calibrate the group - finder .
figures [ fig : ndist ] and [ fig : vdist ] show how the group memberships and velocity dispersions vary with redshift .
this ties together the information contained in figures [ fig : dots ] and [ fig : props ] , showing how the typical number of galaxies per group decreases with increasing redshift , while the velocity dispersion increases with increasing redshift . one interesting comparison can be made with the results of merchn & zandivarez ( 2002 ) .
they used the public 100k data release version of the 2dfgrs and defined groups with a percolation algorithm similar to the one used here . for 2piggs containing at least four members ,
the mean redshift and velocity dispersion , @xmath4 and @xmath160 , are very similar to their values of @xmath167 and @xmath168 .
the total number of these groups has increased from the @xmath169 that merchn & zandivarez found to @xmath159 in the 2pigg catalogue .
this factor is similar to the increase in the total numbers of galaxies being used , roughly the same fraction of galaxies are being grouped in both cases .
= 8.5 cm = 8.5 cm
a friends - of - friends percolation algorithm has been described , calibrated and tested using mock 2dfgrss and then applied to the real 2dfgrs in order to construct the 2dfgrs percolation - inferred galaxy group ( 2pigg ) catalogue . from the mock catalogues , it is possible to determine the typical accuracies with which velocity dispersions and projected halo sizes
are recovered . for detectable haloes recovered with galaxy groups containing at least @xmath164 members
the estimates of the velocity dispersion are unbiased in the median and the ratio of inferred to true velocity dispersion has a semi - interquartile range of @xmath170 per cent . the corresponding number for the spread about the median ratio of inferred to true projected size is @xmath171 per cent . without the use of detailed mock catalogues to calibrate the group - finder , the ability to derive science from the 2pigg catalogue
would be compromised by the uncertainty in how the recovered groups related to the underlying distribution of matter .
this is thus a crucial step in the group - finding procedure . when applied to the two contiguous patches in the real 2dfgrs , containing @xmath1 galaxies , this percolation algorithm groups @xmath0 per cent of the galaxies into @xmath2 groups containing at least two members .
focusing on those groups with at least @xmath164 members , their median redshift and velocity dispersion are @xmath4 and @xmath160 repectively .
more detailed distributions of fundamental group properties are characterised in section [ sec:2df ] .
this 2pigg catalogue is the largest currently available set of groups .
it should provide a useful starting point for a number of studies concerning large scale structure , galaxy group properties and the environmental dependence of galaxy properties .
upcoming papers will describe in more detail the contents of the groups , for instance the galaxy luminosity functions within groups , the mass - to - light ratios of groups , the manner in which galaxies are apportioned to different groups and the spatial distribution of galaxies within groups .
the spatial abundance of groups both as a function of total group luminosity and mass will also be investigated .
the catalogue , including basic group properties , is available on the www , at http://www.mso.anu.edu.au/2dfgrs / public/2pigg/. a description of the contents of this web page is given in the appendix .
vre and cmb are royal society university research fellows .
jap is grateful for a pparc senior research fellowship .
abell g.o . , 1958 ,
apjs , 3 , 211 abell g.o .
, corwin h.g . , olowin r.p . , 1989 , apjs , 70 , 1 benson a.j . , cole s. , frenk c.s . ,
baugh c.m . ,
lacey c.g . , 2000 ,
mnras , 311 , 793 benson a.j . , frenk c.s . ,
baugh c.m . , cole s. , lacey c.g . , 2001 , mnras , 327 , 1041 bhringer h. , 2001 , a&a , 369 , 826 cole s. , lacey c.g . , baugh c.m .
, frenk c.s . , 2000 ,
mnras , 319 , 168 colless m. ( the 2dfgrs team ) , 2001 , mnras , 328 , 1039 dalton g.b . , maddox s.j . , sutherland w.j . ,
efstathiou g. , 1997 , mnras , 289 , 263 davis m. , efstathiou g. , frenk c.s .
, white s.d.m . , 1985 , apj , 292 , 371 diaferio a. , kauffmann g. , colberg j.m . ,
. , 1999 , mnras , 307 , 537 ebeling h. , voges w. , bhringer h. , edge a.c .
, huchra j.p . , briel u.g . , 1996 , mnras , 281 , 799 eke , v.r . , cole , s. & frenk , c.s . , 1996 , mnras , 282 , 263 frenk , c.s . ,
white , s.d.m . , efstathiou , g. , davis , m. , 1990 , apj , 351 , 10 garcia a.m. , 1993 , a&as , 100 , 47 geller m.j .
, huchra j.p . , 1983 , apjs , 52 , 61 gioia i.m . ,
henry j.p . , maccacaro t. , morris s.l . , stocke j.t . , wolter a. , 1990 , apj , 356 , l35 giuricin g. , marinoni c. , ceriani l. , pisani a. , 2000 , apj , 543 , 178 gourgoulhon e. , chamaraux p. , fouqu p. , 1992 ,
a&a , 255 , 69 hawkins e. ( the 2dfgrs team ) , 2003 , mnras , in press ( astro - ph/0212375 ) huchra j.p .
, geller m.j . , 1982 , apj , 257 , 423 jenkins a. , 1998 , apj , 499 , 20 jenkins a. , 2001 , mnras , 321 , 372 jing y.p . , 1998 ,
apj , 503 , l9 lucey j.r . , 1983 , mnras , 204 , 33 lumsden s.l . , nichol r.c .
, collins c.a . ,
guzzo l. , 1992 , mnras , 258 , 1 madgwick d.s .
( the 2dfgrs team ) , 2002 , mnras , 333 , 133 maia m.a.g . , da costa l.n .
, latham d.w . , 1989 , apjs , 69 , 809 marinoni c. , davis m. , newman j.a . , coil a.l . , 2002 , apj , 580 , 122 merchn m.e . , maia m.a.g .
, lambas d.g . , 2000 , apj , 545 , 26 merchn m.e .
, zandivarez a. , 2002 , mnras , 335 , 216 moore b. , frenk c.s .
, white s.d.m . , 1993 , mnras , 261 , 827 nolthenius r. , white s.d.m . , 1987 , mnras , 225 , 505 norberg p. ( the 2dfgrs team ) , 2001 , mnras , 328 , 64 norberg p. ( the 2dfgrs team ) , 2002 , mnras , 336 , 907 peacock j.a . , 1999 , cosmological physics , cambridge univ . press , cambridge ramella m. , geller m.j . , huchra j.p . , 1989 , apj , 344 , 57 ramella m. , 1999 , a&a , 342 , 1 ramella m. , geller m.j . , pisani a. , da costa l.n . , 2002 ,
aj , 123 , 2976 romer a.k . , 1995 , ph.d .
thesis , univ .
edinburgh spergel d.n . , 2003 ,
apj , in press ( astro - ph/0302209 ) sutherland w. , 1988 , mnras , 234 , 159 trasarti - battistoni r. , 1998 , a&as , 130 , 341 tucker d.l . , 2000 , apjs , 130 , 237 tully r.b . , 1987 , apj , 321 , 280 van haarlem m.p .
, frenk c.s .
, white s.d.m . , 1997 , mnras , 287 , 817
[ cols= " < , < , < , < , < , < , < , < " , ] http://www.mso.anu.edu.au/2dfgrs/public/2pigg/ contains : + 1 ) the lists ( ngp and sgp ) of galaxies and the index of the groups in which they are placed , + 2 ) lists of group properties for the 2piggs , +
3 ) the equivalent lists for some mock catalogues . + to illustrate the type of data that are available
, table [ tab : gals ] shows the information provided for a subset of the galaxies and table [ tab : eg ] contains a list of all 2piggs containing at least 100 members . | the construction of a catalogue of galaxy groups from the 2-degree field galaxy redshift survey ( 2dfgrs ) is described .
groups are identified by means of a friends - of - friends percolation algorithm which has been thoroughly tested on mock versions of the 2dfgrs generated from cosmological n - body simulations .
the tests suggest that the algorithm groups all galaxies that it should be grouping , with an additional 40 per cent of interlopers .
about @xmath0 per cent of the @xmath1 galaxies considered are placed into groups containing at least two members of which @xmath2 are found . of these , @xmath3 contain at least four galaxies , and these groups have a median redshift of @xmath4 and a median velocity dispersion of @xmath5 .
this 2dfgrs percolation - inferred galaxy group ( 2pigg ) catalogue represents the largest available homogeneous sample of galaxy groups .
it is publicly available on the www .
catalogues galaxies : clusters : general . |
molecular species are useful diagnostics for understanding the physics and chemistry of the interstellar medium ( ism ) , and have been studied in various ways for many years .
most molecules are observed in dense molecular clouds via rotational emission lines in the radio band .
these emission studies are indispensable to our understanding of galactic ecology and the ism : they yield maps of dense regions , have very high spectral ( velocity ) resolution , and allow us to study complex molecules not otherwise observable .
there are some drawbacks to molecular emission studies , however .
first , analysis of the line excitation is very model - dependent and can lead to significant systematic errors .
second , since spatial resolution is typically low ( and varies from species to species ) , it is sometimes hard to discern whether emission from different species comes from the same location within a cloud .
this makes comparisons among species difficult .
molecular absorption line observations have some important advantages over emission line studies .
first , absorption from different species observed in the same line of sight are more likely to coexist spatially , thus reducing geometrical ambiguities and allowing more reliable inter - species comparisons .
second , because the unexcited molecules are observed directly , column density determinations are not as model - dependent as for emission studies , and hence more accurate .
third , some molecular species ( notably h@xmath0 and c@xmath0 ) are essentially unobservable in the radio due to lack of a dipole moment .
these species can sometimes be observed via electronic transitions in the ultraviolet ( e.g. , @xcite ) , or through rotational - vibrational transitions in the visible or infrared ( e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ) . and finally , molecular abundances derived from absorption measures can easily be compared to line - of - sight bulk properties ( e.g. , extinction , polarization , and atomic abundances ) which are also derived from absorption measures .
co and c@xmath0 have transitions at 2.3 @xmath2 m and 8775 , respectively , which can be observed in absorption .
the primary drawback to studying molecular absorption lines in the infrared ( ir ) is finding a suitable background star .
the target must be bright in the ir yet fortuitously placed behind a substantial amount of absorbing material . in our effort to find background sources for absorption line studies in regions also accessible to emission - line studies ,
we have selected the target w40 irs 1a , an ob star embedded within the radio source w40 .
this source appears well - suited for our purposes ; though dim in the visible ( @xmath11 ) it is bright in the ir ( @xmath12 ) , and lies behind about 9 magnitudes of extinction in @xmath13 ( @xmath14 ) .
w40 itself is a blister - type region breaking out of a local molecular cloud , about 400 pc away towards the galactic center ( @xcite ; @xcite ) .
a group of hot stars ( most likely b - class ) is bathing the region with ionizing radiation ; w40 irs 2a ( os 2a ) seems to be producing most of the energy ( @xcite ) .
irs 1a is brighter than 2a in the optical and near - ir indicating somewhat greater extinction toward irs 2a .
crutcher and chu ( 1982 ) mapped @xmath1co and @xmath15co , hco@xmath16 , hcn and h@xmath17 emission toward w40 , generating a comprehensive kinematic interpretation of the region .
valle et al .
( 1987 , 1991 , 1992 , and 1994 ) have done extensive studies on the properties of the molecular cloud and its interaction with the region using recombination lines , radio continuum emission , and co emission . the existence of circumstellar dust shells around w40 irs 1a , 2a and 3a ( @xmath18 k and @xmath19 ) has been suggested based on broad - band ir imaging and continuum measurements in the millimeter and sub - millimeter ( @xcite ; @xcite ) .
both co and c@xmath0 are important interstellar molecules .
co is the most abundant molecule in the ism after molecular hydrogen , and has a number of important roles : the co emission lines at 2.6 mm and shorter are not only responsible for cooling molecular clouds but also serve as tracers for h@xmath0 and dense molecular gas ( e.g. , @xcite and references therein ) . c@xmath0 is much less abundant than co and has been observed primarily in diffuse and translucent clouds ( e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ) . like h@xmath0 , c@xmath0 has no dipole moment and hence no pure rotational spectrum .
it is a very useful diagnostic of cloud physical conditions such as kinetic temperature , density , and radiation field intensity ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . both co and
c@xmath0 are important to carbon chemistry everywhere in the ism . co absorption at 2.3 @xmath2 m ( @xmath20 ) has not been observed as frequently as the v = 1 - 0 band at 4.7 @xmath2 m , most likely owing to the smaller transition probabilities .
it is , however , easier to observe at 2.3 @xmath2 m since the thermal background from the earth s atmosphere is much lower than at 4.7 @xmath2 m .
black and willner ( 1984 ) and black et al .
( 1990 ) used the lines at 2.3 @xmath2 m to study the physical conditions and chemistry toward ngc 2024 , ngc 2264 and afgl 2591 . recently , lacy et al .
( 1994 ) were able to observe both co and h@xmath0 absorption near 2.3 @xmath2 m toward ngc 2024 irs 2 yielding for the first time a direct measure of the h@xmath0/co ratio in a molecular cloud .
absorption lines of c@xmath0 have been used to address a number of problems in the ism , including : diffuse interstellar cloud chemistry ( e.g. @xcite ) , carbon chemistry in translucent clouds ( e.g. @xcite ) , molecular cloud envelopes ( e.g. @xcite ) , and the line of sight structure toward @xmath21 oph ( e.g. @xcite ) .
federman et al . ( 1994 ) provide a good compilation of c@xmath0 measurements up to 1992 .
in this paper we report on absorption - line studies of co and c@xmath0 toward w40 irs 1a .
the line of sight is discussed in the next section . in section 3
we describe our observations and the results , and in section 4 we discuss their implication for the physical state of the material in this line of sight .
the final section contains a brief summary of our conclusions .
very little is known about the interstellar sightline to w40 irs 1a .
both crutcher and chu ( 1982 ) and smith et al .
( 1985 ) infer @xmath22 .
the average extinction due to diffuse material over 400 pc is about 0.6 mag ( see @xcite , p. 155 ) .
therefore the obscuring material is most likely local to the w40 region and more dense than the diffuse ism .
in addition , crutcher and chu ( 1982 ) found a molecular @xmath15co component in front of the w40 region with @xmath23 km s@xmath24 , @xmath25 @xmath5 , and @xmath26 , further suggesting that the sightline passes through cold material , most likely associated with the neighboring molecular cloud . the line of sight intersects at least 3 distinct physical regimes .
as noted above there appears to be some cold foreground material , perhaps associated with the nearby molecular cloud .
closer to w40 irs 1a there must be a photon - dominated region ( pdr ) , and closer still , the w40 region itself . if w40 irs 1a has a circumstellar dust shell , it is not clear what its effect on the co and c@xmath0 spectra might be . a warm dust shell
might be associated with an elevated gas temperature , and hence the appearance of high-@xmath27 molecular rotational lines .
the region is roughly 0.9 pc across and has an electron density of 200 @xmath9 ( based on results in crutcher and chu [ 1982 ] and a distance of 400 pc ) . the column density of ionized hydrogen associated with the region should be about @xmath28 @xmath5 , assuming spherical geometry and that all hydrogen is ionized . using the relation of total hydrogen column density to extinction found in bohlin , savage , & drake ( 1978 ) , the region should contribute @xmath29 mag to the line - of - sight extinction .
this , of course , assumes a standard gas - to - dust ratio , which may not apply to regions in general .
the contribution to @xmath14 could increase or decrease depending primarily on the nature of any grain - destroying shocks which may have passed through the region . in either case
, the region probably does not strongly contribute to the total extinction on the line of sight to w40 irs 1a .
in addition , molecules like co and c@xmath0 can not survive in the harsh environment , so the region should not contribute to the line - absorption for these molecules either .
there is almost surely a photon - dominated region ( pdr ) on the line of sight to w40 irs 1a , which could account for as much as @xmath30 , nearly the entire measured visual extinction ( see @xcite for a good discussion ) .
hydrogen is expected to be neutral or molecular throughout the pdr .
co and perhaps c@xmath0 can not survive in the regions of the pdr closest to the region .
the effect of dust in pdrs is poorly understood , and so a quantitative treatment of these regions in general is difficult . in summary ,
co and c@xmath0 absorption lines should sample the cold material in the foreground , at least part of the pdr , and none of the region . a circumstellar dust shell ,
if it exists , would most likely only contribute to high-@xmath27 molecular absorption .
the visual extinction ( @xmath31 ) should arise almost entirely in the foreground material ( which may be part of the local molecular cloud ) and the pdr , though we note that the pdr could in theory produce all of the observed extinction .
the observations of w40 irs 1a were obtained with the cassegrain echelle spectrograph and the rca ccd camera on the 4-m mayall telescope at kitt peak national observatory on the night of ut 16 june 1983 .
two spectra , each of one hour s duration , were recorded in the region of the 2 - 0 band of the phillips system ( a@xmath32 x@xmath33 ) of c@xmath0 .
the entire 2 - 0 band was contained in a single order with its center near 8775 and with a nominal reciprocal dispersion of 0.074 per pixel at the face of the ccd chip .
quartz lamp and thorium - argon spectra were obtained for flat - fielding and wavelength calibration .
an 84 @xmath2 m wide slit was employed , providing a nominal resolution of 0.15 which in turn corresponds to approximately 2 pixels on the chip .
the two consecutive one - hour frames were co - added and averaged . similarly , two separate flat - field frames were co - added and averaged , and the result was divided into the averaged stellar frame to produce the final photometric spectrum . both flat - field and stellar frames were bias - corrected .
the average of fifteen bias frames was first subtracted from the flat - field and stellar frames , after which a second - order bias correction was accomplished by subtracting from the average stellar and flat - field frames the mean row biases obtained from the masked bias columns of each .
the final spectrum was extracted by collapsing the three columns along the slit direction which contained the maximum signal .
this spectrum is shown in figure 1 .
spikes are due to cosmic ray hits and possibly oh airglow lines .
rotational lines in all three branches ( p , q and r ) were identified , with the rotational quantum number @xmath27 reaching as high as 12 for the q - branch . unfortunately , there were problems with the wavelength calibration at the telescope and we were not able to derive a precise measure for the radial velocities of the c@xmath0 lines .
equivalent widths for these lines were determined using standard spectral reduction procedures in the noao / iraf package , and column densities for each of the rotational levels were calculated from the rotational lines using a simple gaussian curve - of - growth ( c.f .
@xcite ) . initially , the @xmath34-value derived by erman et al . ( 1982 ) was used .
recently , the phillips system transition probabilities have been refined ( see @xcite and references therein ) and the column densities have been adjusted to reflect the new @xmath34-value derived by lambert , sheffer , and federman ( 1995 ) , @xmath35 .
the data for each line and the column densities for each @xmath27 are shown in tables 1 and 2 .
several of the lines exhibited effects of saturation , and an estimate of the doppler constant ( @xmath36 ) was derived by requiring that rotational lines originating from the same rotational energy level yield the same rotational population for that level .
this method is a simple extension of the doublet ratio method used in the analysis of saturated atomic species .
the best value for the doppler constant was found to be 1.25 km s@xmath24 .
the @xmath37 data are not included due to high uncertainty : only the q12 line was observed and it is very weak . the @xmath38 rotational - vibrational lines for co fall near 2.3 @xmath2 m , within the k band . since the oscillator strengths are smaller , the @xmath38 lines are not as saturated as their @xmath39 cousins at 4.7 @xmath2 m .
in addition , it is somewhat easier to observe at 2.3 @xmath2 m , as the sky emission at 4.7 @xmath2 m is much greater and more problematic .
contamination from stellar co absorption should be negligible since w40 irs 1a appears to be a hot o or b star , which would not allow stellar co to survive ( @xcite ; @xcite ) .
circumstellar gas and dust , if it exists , could affect the high-@xmath27 molecular levels .
ro - vib transitions at 2.3 @xmath2 m for @xmath1co were observed ut 11 june 1994 and ut 21 july 1997 using the cshell ir spectrometer at nasas infrared telescope facility ( irtf ) on mauna kea .
the irtf is a 3 meter primary , off - axis cassegrain yielding f/13.67 at the spectrometer slit .
the cshell is a cryogenically cooled echelle spectrometer with a 256 x 256 sbrc insb detector array ( @xcite ) .
we used the 0.5 slit which gives @xmath40 .
only the r0 , 1 , and 2 transitions were detected ( figure 3 ) with upper limits placed on r3 , 4 and 5 .
a summary of the observations is shown in table 3 .
the data were obtained and reduced following typical ir observing procedures which we briefly summarize below .
dark frames were coadded and subtracted from the flat - field image for each wavelength setting .
w40 irs 1a and the standard stars were observed in both the `` a '' and `` b '' beams ( each beam places the spectrum in a different spatial location on the detector ) .
beam differences ( a - b and b - a ) were calculated to eliminate sky emission , then coadded and normalized using the flat field for the appropriate wavelength setting .
wavelength calibration was achieved using ar , kr , and xe lamps with 3 lines per wavelength setting .
one dimensional spectra for w40 irs 1a , the standard stars , and the calibration lamps were then extracted from the detector images using the apall task in iraf .
once the wavelength solution was applied , telluric absorption features were identified in both the standard stars and w40 irs 1a spectra .
telluric lines were eliminated from the w40 irs 1a spectra using the iraf task telluric , which shifts and scales the standard star spectrum before dividing into the object spectrum .
it is important to note that merely dividing the standard star spectrum into the object spectrum does not produce the _ true _ object spectrum without telluric features . to properly remove telluric features
, one must generate an _ expected _ object spectrum , convolve it with the standard star spectrum , and compare to the actual observed object spectrum .
lacy et al .
( 1994 ) give a good discussion of this technique .
we opted to merely divide , however , as our data quality did not warrant more sophisticated techniques .
the r0 , 1 , and 2 lines are shown in figure 3 .
these lines imply @xmath41 km s@xmath24 , in contrast with the 8 km s@xmath24 foreground molecular material seen in emission ( @xcite ) .
since emission line data sample a large , beam - averaged area , and absorption lines just a pencil beam , we do not necessarily expect velocities derived from both to agree .
we merely note that they are not wildly different .
@xmath42 corresponds to a resolution of @xmath43 km s@xmath24 .
the r0 , 1 , and 2 lines all have fwhm @xmath44 km s@xmath24 and hence are not well - resolved . after continuum normalization ,
each line was directly integrated for equivalent width .
errors reflect continuum placement ambiguity and are of high confidence ( @xmath45 ) .
all the widths ( along with transition information and errors ) are given in table 4 .
widths for the r3 , r4 and r5 lines are 2@xmath46 upper limits based on the noise in the continuum at the expected line position .
the equivalent width of any absorption line is dependent on the column density of the species and , if saturated , the velocity parameter _
@xcite ) . we generated a model curve of growth ( cog ) using @xmath47 km s@xmath24 , as determined from the c@xmath0 lines .
each @xmath1co equivalent width was fit to the cog independently and the column density for each rotational level ( @xmath48 ) is given in table 5 .
the r2 through r5 lines were clearly optically thin while the r0 and r1 lines were more optically thick , falling on the transition from the linear portion to the saturated part of the cog .
if the @xmath36-value for co is greater than 1.25 km s@xmath24 , then the r0 and r1 lines become more optically thin and their abundances drop by 2 and 0.5 @xmath49 @xmath5 respectively . summing the abundances for each line
gives a total column density of @xmath50 @xmath5 ( assuming @xmath1co to be the dominant isotope ) .
depending on the excitation of the higher @xmath27 levels , this value could be slightly too small , and if @xmath51 km s@xmath24 , then it would be too high .
our column density for co is nearly identical to that inferred by crutcher & chu ( 1982 ) for the foreground , @xmath52 @xmath5 . in an effort to detect the co ice band at 4.7 we made observations with moderate spectral resolution at the united kingdom ir telescope ( ukirt ) using the cgs4 on 19 august 1998 .
all observations were carried out while nodding along the slit to remove atmospheric emission .
the total integration time on w40 irs 1a was 11.2 minutes at an average airmass of 1.45 .
the spectrum for w40 irs 1a was ratioed by bs 7236 ( b9v ) to remove telluric absorption features .
the s / n is @xmath53 at 4.67 and no co ice feature is apparent .
an upper limit for the optical depth of the band is @xmath54 ( 2@xmath46 ) , implying @xmath55 @xmath5 ( @xcite ) .
the depletion of co into icy mantles for the w40 irs 1a sightline must be less than 1 % .
we have three basic diagnostics for the temperature and density toward w40 irs 1a .
the @xmath15co emission data imply @xmath56 , much lower than the nearby molecular cloud , @xmath57 ( @xcite ) .
excitation conditions can also be derived from the rotational populations of co and c@xmath0 .
the rotational level populations of the c@xmath0 phillips system ( @xmath58 ) are attained via radiative pumping .
lifetimes of these levels are so long that collisions and upward electronic transitions are the most important depopulation mechanisms . hence the rotational populations reflect the competition between pumping and collisions and are non - thermal in general ( @xcite ) . for densities greater than @xmath59 @xmath9 the @xmath60 and @xmath61 levels
are very nearly thermal .
otherwise , the populations depend on the thermal temperature , @xmath62 , and the radiation parameter , @xmath63 , where @xmath64 is the collision partner density ( usually @xmath65h@xmath66h@xmath67 ) , @xmath46 is the effective cross section for collisional de - excitation , and @xmath68 is the scaling factor for the radiation field in the far - red ( @xcite ) . total molecular abundance and excitation temperatures were calculated from models which fit a maxwell - boltzmann population distribution to the observed rotational level abundances . as had been found for other relatively dense clouds ( @xcite ) , the rotational abundances could not be fit with a single temperature distribution , presumably as a result of radiative pumping ( @xcite ; @xcite ) .
consequently , we fit these data with a two - temperature model used by lutz and crutcher ( 1983 ) : j - levels 4 through 10 were fit with an excitation temperature ( @xmath69 ) of 126 k , which we associate with the effects of radiative pumping . after correcting the populations in j = 0 and 2 for the contributions from the 126 k population distribution , we derived a j=2/j=0 excitation temperature of 39 k , which we associate with the thermal distribution of the gas .
the resulting total column density of c@xmath0 towards w40 irs 1a is @xmath70 @xmath5 , based on a boltzmann distribution for both temperatures .
this is the highest column density of c@xmath0 yet seen in absorption .
figure 2 shows the final fits . in comparing the results for w40 irs 1a to the radiative pumping models calculated by van dishoeck ( 1984 ) , we found that they are best characterized by her model with a kinetic temperature of 40 k and a radiation parameter , @xmath63 of @xmath71 .
assuming @xmath72 , @xmath73 @xmath74 ( @xcite ) , and that hydrogen ( + h@xmath0 ) is the only important collision partner , we get @xmath75 @xmath9 for the w40 irs 1asightline .
since the value of @xmath46 is not known to better than a factor of 2 ( @xcite ) , our value for @xmath76 is equally imprecise .
in addition , for an enhanced ( or depleted ) radiation field , the estimated collision ( hydrogen ) density would scale accordingly .
rotational transitions of co are primarily excited by collisions with hydrogen .
de - excitation can occur via collisions with hydrogen or by spontaneous line emission .
the critical density at which collisions begin to overtake spontaneous emission is around 3000 @xmath9 .
more detailed studies of the excitation , photodissociation , and chemistry have been conducted by van dishoeck & black ( 1988 ) and warin , benayoun , & viala ( 1996 ) .
in general it is found that the rotational populations of co are sub - thermal except for the first few levels in dense cases ( @xcite ) .
hence the assumption of lte will almost always produce excitation temperatures which underestimate the actual thermal temperature ( @xmath77 ) .
recent work by wannier , penprase , & andersson ( 1997 ) suggests that the dominant form of co excitation in diffuse and translucent clouds can be line emission from nearby molecular clouds , if the clouds have similar velocity vectors . as a start
, we constructed a boltzmann plot for the @xmath1co data ( figure 4 ) .
fitting the temperature to all lines gives @xmath78 k. this value is similar to that found by cruther & chu ( 1982 ) , but it is important to note that the excitation temperatures for @xmath15co and @xmath1co are different in general ( @xcite ) . since the thermal temperature is greater than the co rotational temperature in general , @xmath6 k , which is consistent with the c@xmath0 analysis .
warin , benayoun , & viala ( 1996 ) have constructed models of co excitation for the dense , translucent , and diffuse cloud regimes , including uv photodissociation .
these models show very clearly that the excitation temperature is much lower than the thermal temperature for diffuse and translucent clouds .
the excitation of co in dense clouds is nearly thermal and @xmath79 .
if we assume that the cloud(s ) toward w40 irs 1a are dense , then @xmath80 k. for diffuse and translucent clouds , the level populations observed can be scaled ( see section 4.2 of warin , benayoun , & viala [ 1996 ] ) to derive `` pseudo - lte '' rotational populations , i.e. representative lte populations for the actual thermal temperature of the gas .
a slope can be fitted to these populations and a thermal temperature inferred .
if the cloud(s ) toward w40 irs 1a are translucent , then the r0 population is reduced by @xmath81 ( changes in r1 and r2 happen to be negligible ) .
the resulting populations imply @xmath82 k ( see figure 4 ) , which still does not agree with the c@xmath0 analysis .
it is not clear , however , that the models constructed by warin , benayoun , & viala ( 1996 ) apply to our line of sight : the uv field is probably higher than normal near w40 , and it seems very likely that there are multiple clouds on the sightline .
since the cloud(s ) on the w40 irs 1a line of sight are very near the w40 molecular cloud , and the lsr velocities of both are similar ( 5 and 8 km s@xmath24 ) , the excitation for @xmath1co may be at least partially radiative . comparing to models constructed by wannier , penprase , & andersson ( 1997 )
it is apparent that our @xmath78 k is degenerate : it can be accounted for by many combinations of radiative excitation , collision partner density , and kinetic temperature . the c@xmath0 excitation conditions can help constrain those for @xmath1co . if we assume @xmath83 k , the density of the gas can range from 0 to 450 @xmath9 , depending on the efficiency of radiative excitation .
collisional excitation becomes dominant as @xmath84 approaches 450 @xmath9 ( which we use as an upper limit ) .
if we further assume @xmath8 @xmath9 ( as indicated by the c@xmath0 data ) , then the excitation of co can only be explained by collisional and radiative processes combined
. a summary of the w40 irs 1a sightline cloud physical properties based on the co and c@xmath0 data in this paper as well as the co emission study by crutcher and chu ( 1982 ) is given in table 6 .
as discussed in section 2 , we assume that nearly all of the absorption on this line of sight arises in one cloud complex ( single or multiple components ) local to the w40 region , since it is only 400 pc distant ( i.e. , the cloud(s ) can not be diffuse ) .
the physical conditions are best determined by c@xmath0 : @xmath85 @xmath9 and @xmath86 k. the co emission and absorption values and limits agree very well .
the cloud(s ) are clearly not dense enough to be considered molecular , but could be considered translucent .
translucent lines of sight typically have @xmath87 and can be studied via both absorption lines ( uv , optical , and/or ir ) , and radio emission lines .
in addition , translucent material is expected in the outer envelopes of molecular clouds ( @xcite ) .
we postulate that the w40 irs 1a sightline is composed of multiple translucent components associated with the w40 molecular cloud .
co and c@xmath0 abundances have been determined jointly for a number of sightlines , a sample of which is shown in table 7 .
w40 irs 1a is one of few sightlines allowing a direct comparison of co and c@xmath0 in _ absorption_. the abundance ratio we derive is co / c@xmath0 @xmath88 ( 2@xmath46 ) .
the depletion of co onto dust is negligible ( @xmath89 ) , in view of our failure to detect co ice , but the c@xmath0depletion has not been assessed .
note that the co / c@xmath0 ratio increases from diffuse to translucent and molecular regimes indicating ( to first order ) that the formation / destruction rates favor co over c@xmath0as cloud type changes . this may merely be due to self - shielding of co , but other processes may also be in action : the data are not yet precise enough to tell . assuming all hydrogen is molecular ,
we can estimate the amount of h@xmath0 on the w40 irs 1a line of sight from @xmath3 .
using an h@xmath0/co ratio of @xmath90 ( based on the direct comparison of h@xmath0 and co ir absorption lines toward ngc 2024 irs 2 ( @xmath91 ) , @xcite ) , we find @xmath92 @xmath5 .
the h@xmath0:co ratio is derived from a direct comparison of weak absorption lines and hence should be reliable , but is based on only one data point : ngc 2024 irs 2 .
if this sightline is abnormal in any way , then the ratio does not necessarily apply to other lines of sight such as w40 irs 1a . the @xmath14 calculated by crutcher and chu ( 1982 ) and smith et al .
( 1985 ) assumes a `` normal '' extinction law ( @xmath93 ) , which may be incorrect .
the ratio of visual to selective extinction , @xmath94 , is a grain size distribution indicator ( @xcite ) : @xmath95 implies an abundance of small grains compared to the typical size distribution , whereas @xmath96 implies that larger grains dominate the extinction .
as interstellar clouds collapse the dust grains tend to agglomerate , eliminating the smaller particles ( @xcite ) .
if the line of sight toward w40 irs 1a does indeed sample the edge of a molecular cloud , then we would expect a population of larger grains and @xmath97 .
smith et al .
( 1985 ) found @xmath98 = 2.2 for w40 irs 1a and assuming it is an ob star , @xmath99 .
for @xmath100 , we get a range in @xmath14 of 7.5 to 12.5 , which agrees with the previous work by crutcher and chu ( 1982 ) and smith et al .
( 1985 ) . our calculated value of @xmath14 can be used to predict the amount of co expected toward w40 irs 1a . as discussed in section 2 ,
however , the extinction and co absorption may not be well - correlated in the pdr , leading us to slightly _ overestimate _
@xmath3 based on @xmath14 .
conversely , most studies of the co/@xmath14 ratio have not addressed the depletion of co into ice mantles ( which may be as high as 40 % , @xcite ) . since co is almost entirely in the gas - phase for the w40 irs 1a line of sight
, these studies will _ underestimate _ the predicted co column density . using radio maps , spectroscopic data , and star counts in the taurus and @xmath101 oph clouds , frerking , langer , and wilson ( 1982 ) found : @xmath102 for @xmath103 in @xmath5 and @xmath104 .
this relation predicts @xmath105 @xmath5 ( with @xmath106co@xmath107c@xmath108o@xmath109 ) for our line of sight , very nearly the same as we have measured .
interestingly , it may be that the pdr effect nearly balances the depletion effect .
there is no strong correlation between c@xmath0 and @xmath110 ( @xcite ) though other dust indicators have not been investigated .
the lack of correlation may be due to the fact that many of the stars included in c@xmath0 absorption studies to date have been distant supergiants where some of the sightline extinction is caused by diffuse clouds , which lack abundant c@xmath0 . comparing the w40 irs 1a sightline to others in table 7 , it is apparent that co and c@xmath0 generally increase with @xmath14 but the data are too scattered to draw any strong conclusions . the measurement of co and c@xmath0 absorption toward cyg ob2
12 , the classic diffuse cloud line of sight with @xmath111 , is quite interesting .
lutz and crutcher ( 1983 ) found @xmath112 @xmath5 ( adjusted for new phillips system @xmath34-values in lambert , sheffer , and federman ( 1995 ) ) , about half of the abundance on the w40 irs 1a sightline .
recently , mccall et al . (
1998 ) measured co ir absorption toward cyg ob2 no .
12 yielding @xmath113 @xmath5 , a factor of 60 less than what we find for w40 irs 1a over nearly the same total visual extinction .
the 4.7 @xmath2 m co ice feature is not seen on this line of sight ; therefore , depletion of co onto ice mantles can not readily explain the discrepancy .
this clearly shows that the gaseous co to dust ratio changes from diffuse to denser environments . as an interesting side note ,
we have compared the total hydrogen column density ( assuming all of it to be molecular ) for both w40 irs 1a and ngc 2024 irs 2 to the hydrogen / reddening correlations found by bohlin , savage , and drake ( 1978 ) and dickman ( 1978 ) ( figure 5 ) .
the @xmath110 for ngc 2024 irs 2 assumes @xmath114 ( @xcite ; @xcite ) and @xmath94 ranging from 3 to 5 .
the correlations ( `` intercloud '' and `` cloud '' ) from bohlin , savage , and drake ( 1978 ) are based on l@xmath17 absorption for lightly reddened sightlines with @xmath115 , while the relation from dickman ( 1978 ) , derived from co emission , is good to @xmath116 . in figure 5
we have extrapolated out to @xmath117 .
the data from w40 irs 1a and ngc 2024 irs2 agree with the extrapolated relations surprisingly well , within factors of 2 or so .
we have used @xmath1co and c@xmath0 ir and visible absorption lines to investigate the line of sight toward w40 irs 1a .
the c@xmath0 data were obtained at the 4 m mayall telescope at kpno and the @xmath1co data from the cshell on the irtf .
the co ice band at 4.7 was not detected .
this sightline is clearly much more dense than diffuse , based on @xmath22 and a distance of only 400 pc ( we calculate a range in @xmath14 of 7.5 to 12.5 , assuming a population of large grains ) .
our @xmath1co and c@xmath0 data show : \1 . the c@xmath0 excitation conditions , @xmath86 k and @xmath8 @xmath9 , agree with limits determined from co emission and absorption .
since the @xmath14 is large and both absorption and emission measures are available , we postulate that the w40 irs 1asightline has multiple translucent components .
\3 . comparing to other sightlines in table 7 , we find an overall increase in @xmath3 and @xmath118 with increasing @xmath14 . the data , however , are too scattered to draw any further conclusions at this point
. the ratio of co to c@xmath0 appears to increase from diffuse to translucent and molecular sightlines probably due to the self - shielding of co. \4 .
the column density of co toward w40 irs 1a is @xmath119 times that found for cyg ob2 no .
12 , the classic diffuse line of sight ( @xcite ) , despite very similar @xmath14 values .
this is not a depletion effect , and suggests that the co - to - dust ratio changes from diffuse to dense environments .
finally , the relationship of hydrogen column density to interstellar reddening ( @xcite ; @xcite ) was found to be roughly consistent with recent data out to @xmath120 ( figure 5 ) .
contrary to the co - to - dust ratio , the hydrogen - to - dust ratio appears to be valid from diffuse to dense regimes .
this research was supported by nasa graduate student research program grant ( ngt5 - 50032 ) to r. y. shuping and nasa grant nag5 - 4184 to t. p. snow .
we would like to thank the staff and operators at kpno , the irtf ( j. rayner ) , and the ukirt ( t. kerr ) for their help and tireless duty through the night .
many thanks to j. black and the referee s. federman , whose comments and suggestions greatly improved the content and quality of this paper . b. l. lutz would like to thank k. sheth who carried out the curve - of - growth analysis and temperature fits for the c@xmath0 lines .
r. y. shuping would like to thank b - g andersson , j. h. lacy , and d. jansen for their helpful input , and also d. e. schutz for useful conversations and support .
black , j. h. & willner , s. p. 1984
, , 279 , 673 black , j. h. , van dishoeck , e. f. , willner , s. p. , & woods , r. c. 1990 , , 358 , 459 bohlin , r. c. , savage , b. d. , & drake , j. f. 1978 , , 224 , 132 cardelli , j. a. , clayton , g. c. , & mathis , j. s. 1989 , , 345 , 245 chackerian , c. & tipping , r. h. 1983 , j. molec .
spectrosc . , 99 , 431 chaffee , f. h. , jr . ,
lutz , b. l. , black , j. h. , vanden bout , p. a. , & snell , r. l. 1980 , , 236 , 474 chiar , j. e. , adamson , a. j. , kerr , t. h. , & whittet , d. c. b. 1995 , , 455 , 234 crawford , i. a. 1997 , , 290 , 41 crutcher , r. m. & chu , y. 1982 , regions of recent star formation , 53 , roger , r. s. & dewdney , p. e. eds .
dickman , r. l. 1978 , , 37 , 407 erman , p. , lambert , d. l. , larsson , m. , & mannfors , b. 1982 , , 253 , 983 federman , s. r. , strom , c. j. , lambert , d. l. , cardelli , j. a. , smith , v. v. , & joseph , c. l. 1994 , , 424 , 772 federman , s. r. , lambert , d. l. , van dishoeck , e. f. , andersson , b - g , & zsargo , j. 1999 , in prep frerking , m. a. , langer , w. d. , & wilson , r. w. 1982 , , 262 , 590 gredel , r. , van dishoeck , e. f. , de vries , c. p. , & black , j. h. 1992 , , 257 , 245 gredel , r. , van dishoeck , e. f. , & black , j. h. 1994 , , 285 , 300 greene , t. p. , tokunaga , a. t. , toomey , d. w. , & carr , j. s. 1993 , proc .
spie , 1946 , 313 hollenbach , d. j. 1990 , asp conference series vol .
12 , the evolution of the interstellar medium , l. blitz ed .
jiang , d. r. , perrier , c. , & lena , p. 1984
, , 135 , 249 jura , m. 1980 , , 235 , 63 lacy , j. h. , knacke , r. , geballe , t. r. , & tokunaga , a. t. 1994 , , 428 , l69 lambert , d. l. , sheffer , y. , & federman , s. r. 1995 , , 438 , 740 lutz , b. l. & crutcher , r. m. 1983 , , 271 , l101 magnani , l. & onello , j. s. 1995 , , 443 , 169 mantz , a. w. & maillard , j .- p .
1974 , j. molec .
spectrosc . , 53 , 466 mccall , b. j. , geballe , t. r. , hinkle , k. h. , & oka , t. 1998 , science , 279 , 1910 shull , j. m. & beckwith , s. 1982 , , 20 , 163 smith , j. , bentley , a. , castelaz , m. , gehrz , r. d. , grasdalen , g. l. , & hackwell , j. a. 1985 , , 291 , 571 spitzer , l.jr .
1978 , physical processes in the interstellar medium , ( new york : wiley ) tielens , a. g. g. m. & allamandola , l. j. 1987 , physical processes in interstellar clouds , eds . g. e. morfill & m. scholer , p. 333
, dordrecht : reidel valle , j.p .
1987 , , 178,237 valle , j. p. & macleod , j. m. 1991 , , 250 , 143 valle , j. p. , guilloteau , s. & macleod , j. m. 1992 , , 266 , 520 valle , j. p. & macleod , j. m. 1994 , , 108 , 998 van dishoeck , e. f. 1984 , phd thesis , leiden university van dishoeck , e. f. & black , j. h. 1982 , , 258 , 533 van dishoeck , e. f. & black , j. h. 1988 , , 334 , 771 van dishoeck , e. f. & black , j. h. 1989 , , 340 , 273 wannier , p. , penprase , b. e. , & andersson , b - g 1997 , , 487 , l165 warin , s. , benayoun , j. j. , & viala , y.p .
1996 , , 308 , 535 zeilik , m. & lada , c. j. 1978 , , 222 , 896 ccc r0 & 8757.7 & @xmath121 r2 & 8753.9 & @xmath122 q2 & 8761.2 & @xmath123 p2 & 8766.0 & @xmath124 r4 & 8751.6 & @xmath125 q4 & 8763.7 & @xmath126 p4 + q8 & 8773.3 & @xmath127 r6 & 8750.8 & @xmath128 q6 & 8767.7 & @xmath129 p6 & 8782.3 & @xmath130 p8 & 8792.6 & @xmath131 q10 & 8780.1 & @xmath132 q12 & 8788.5 & @xmath133 cccc r0 & 2.34530523 & 8.78 & @xmath141 r1 & 2.34326929 & 5.89 & @xmath142 r2 & 2.34127497 & 5.33 & @xmath143 r3 & 2.33932336 & 5.11 & @xmath144 r4 & 2.33741273 & 5.00 & @xmath144 r5 & 2.33554435 & 4.94 & @xmath144 ccccccc c@xmath0 & ... & 1.25 & @xmath150 & 39 and 126 & @xmath151 & ... @xmath15co em . & 8 & ... & @xmath152 & ... & ... & @xmath153 @xmath1co & @xmath154 & ... & @xmath155 & @xmath156 & @xmath157 & ... ccccccc w40 irs 1a & @xmath158(18 ) & @xmath159(14 ) & @xmath160 & t & 7.5 12.5 & this work cyg ob2 # 12 & 2(16 ) & @xmath161(14 ) & @xmath162 & d & @xmath163 & 1 , 2 hd94413 & 0.71.2(16 ) & 2.8(13 ) & 250430 & t & 2.4 & 3 hd154368 & 0.61.5(16 ) & 4.6(13 ) & 130330 & t & 2.5 & 3 hd169454 & 0.551.8(16 ) & 5.6(13 ) & 100320 & t & 3.3 & 3 @xmath164 per & 1.1(15 ) & 1.8(13 ) & 60 & d & 0.9 & 4 hd27778 & 2.5(16 ) & 3.0(13 ) & 830 & t & 1.2 & 4 @xmath101 oph a & 1.9(15 ) & 2.1(13 ) & 90 & t & 1.4 & 4,7 @xmath21 oph & 2.3(15 ) & @xmath165(13 ) & 130 & d / t & 0.96 & 4 20 aql & 3(15 ) & 4.2(13 ) & 71 & d / t & 0.99 & 4 hd207198 & 2.6(15 ) & 2.4(13 ) & 110 & t & 1.9 & 4 hd21483 & 1.0(18 ) & 7.4(13 ) & 100 - @xmath166 & t & 1.7 & 4 @xmath21 per & 1.2(15 ) & 2.8(13 ) & 43 & d / t & 1.0 & 4 x per & 5.0(15 ) & 4.2(13 ) & 120 & t & 1.4 & 4 hd 26571 & 6.0(16 ) & 8.8(13 ) & 680 & d / t & 0.9 & 4 ae aur & 1.3(15 ) & 4.6(13 ) & 28 & t & 1.6 & 4 hd110432 & 1.0(15 ) & 2.4(13 ) & 42 & t & 1.2 & 4 @xmath167 sco & 1.0(12 ) & @xmath168 & @xmath169 & d & 0.19 & 5 @xmath170 sco & 1.2(13 ) & @xmath168 & @xmath171 & d & 0.62 & 5 @xmath172 sco & 4.0(13 ) & @xmath173 & @xmath174 & d & 0.68 & 5 @xmath175 oph & 3.0(14 ) & 2.8(13 ) & 11 & t & 1.2 & 4 9 cep & 1.7(13 ) & 1.0(13 ) & 2 & d & 1.5 & 4 hd 210121 & 3.0(15 ) & 5.2(13 ) & 58 & t ( high lat . ) & @xmath176 & 6 @xmath177 cep & 1.4(15 ) & 1.4(13 ) & 100 & d & 1.8 & 4 | the h ii region w40 harbors a small group of young , hot stars behind roughly 9 magnitudes of visual extinction . we have detected gaseous carbon monoxide ( co ) and diatomic carbon ( c@xmath0 ) in absorption toward the star w 40 irs 1a .
the 2 - 0 r0 , r1 , and r2 lines of @xmath1co at 2.3 @xmath2 m were measured using the cshell on the nasa ir telescope facility ( with upper limits placed on r3 , r4 , and r5 ) yielding an @xmath3 of @xmath4 @xmath5 .
excitation analysis indicates @xmath6 k. the phillips system of c@xmath0 transitions near 8775 was measured using the kitt peak 4-m telescope and echelle spectrometer .
radiative pumping models indicate a total c@xmath0 column density of @xmath7 @xmath5 , two excitation temperatures ( 39 and 126 k ) , and a total gas density of @xmath8 @xmath9 .
the co ice band at 4.7 was not detected , placing an upper limit on the co depletion of @xmath10 .
we postulate that the sightline has multiple translucent components and is associated with the w40 molecular cloud . our data for w40 irs 1a coupled with other sightlines ,
shows that the ratio of co / c@xmath0 increases from diffuse through translucent environs .
finally , we show that the hydrogen to dust ratio seems to remain constant from diffuse to dense environments , while the co to dust ratio apparently does not . |
the two - level model of atoms interacting with light fields @xcite has often been used to explore optical cooling mechanisms @xcite . its inherent simplicity
the atom has one ground state and one excited state makes the resulting models amenable to analysis , but also suppresses mechanisms @xcite that , in the appropriate parameter regimes , dominate the interaction .
a notable example of such an initially overlooked mechanism in atomic physics is three - dimensional optical molasses @xcite . by means of the two - level model
, one can predict the equilibrium temperature , the so - called `` doppler '' temperature @xmath0 , of atoms in molasses to be @xmath1 , where @xmath2 is the ( half - width at half - maximum ) linewidth of the transition from the excited to the ground level @xcite .
data from early three - dimensional molasses experiments contradicted this @xcite , showing that the achievable equilibrium temperature was in fact much lower .
this discrepancy was resolved independently by two groups @xcite , both explanations relying on the inclusion of the manifold of magnetic sublevels in each of the ground and excited states . in particular
, the motion of the atoms in the optical field leads to a non - adiabatic following of the magnetic sublevel populations , which gives rise to a strong viscous force and efficient cooling to temperatures significantly lower than the doppler temperature .
we recently @xcite explored a new scattering theory that deals with the interaction of light and matter in a unified form applicable from microscopic to macroscopic systems . in that work we only considered the two - level atom model and showed , in particular , how our model can explain such mechanisms as standard optical molasses and mirror - mediated cooling @xcite . in this paper
we extend this model to deal with magnetic sublevels , in much the same spirit as ref .
in due course , this extension will enable us to deal with multilevel atoms interacting with an arbitrarily complex system composed of immobile mirrors , cavities , mems devices , etc .
, without resorting to a quantized model for such a system .
+ after we introduce the general extension in the next section , we then proceed to explore two prototypical systems the @xmath3 transition , leading to the `` sisyphus '' cooling mechanism , and the @xmath4 transition in section [ sec : linperplin ] and section [ sec : sigmasigma ] , respectively .
, @xmath5 , @xmath6 , and @xmath7 .
the scatterwe has velocity @xmath8 and is described by means of its polarizability tensor @xmath9 . the field mode amplitudes are , in general , functions of the wavenumber @xmath10 . ]
we investigate the interaction of atoms with light of different polarizations . to this end
, we denote the two polarization basis vectors by @xmath11 and @xmath12 , whereby the standard circular polarization basis is equivalent to setting @xmath13 and @xmath14 . starting from the transfer matrix model explored in ref .
@xcite and using the definitions in fig .
[ fig : system ] , we replace each of the field modes by a corresponding jones vector , similar to the model used in ref . @xcite . thus , for example , @xmath15 and similarly for @xmath16 , @xmath17 and @xmath18 .
the transfer matrix @xmath19 , describing the effect of the scatterer on the four field modes by means of the relation @xmath20 is now transformed into an order @xmath21 tensor of the form @xmath22 where each of @xmath23 ( @xmath24 ) is a @xmath25 matrix relating the respective jones vector components . a general recipe for transforming the formulae for the field mode amplitudes , as given in ref .
@xcite , can be summarized by means of the two replacements @xmath26 wherever necessary . in particular , then , @xmath27 we follow ref .
@xcite , complement e@xmath28 3-b , in defining the polarizability tensor @xmath9 as the steady - state expectation value of the polarizability operator @xmath29 ; @xmath9 is therefore given by the trace @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the steady - state density matrix describing the system and the summation runs over all the internal sublevels of the atom , and where we construct the order 4 polarizability operator tensor @xmath29 similarly to ref .
@xcite , eq .
( 14.9 - 24 ) . in the general @xmath11 ,
@xmath12 basis : @xmath32\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath33 being the characteristic polarizability of the atom . in eq .
( [ eq : chime ] ) , the dipole moment operator @xmath34 ( @xmath35 ) is related to the @xmath11 ( @xmath12 ) polarized light field and the sum runs over all the internal sublevels , @xmath36 , of the atom .
the matrix elements of @xmath34 ( @xmath35 ) are given by the appropriate clebsch - gordan coefficients .
importantly , this new transfer matrix still retains all its properties , allowing us to model the interaction of the multilevel atom with an arbitrary system of immobile optical elements such as mirrors , cavities , waveplates , etc . as in our previous work @xcite
, this interaction is accounted for by the multiplication of the various transfer matrices of the elements making up the system ; this model is , in principle , applicable to systems of arbitrary complexity . finally , we recall that the diagonal elements , @xmath37 , of @xmath31 are the populations in each of the sublevels , whereas its off - diagonal elements , @xmath38 , are the respective coherences . the matrix elements of @xmath31 are obtained from the appropriate optical bloch equations ( see , for example , the procedure outlined in ref .
we note here that , through its dependence on @xmath31 , @xmath39 depends on the fields that it helps to determine , and thus eq .
( [ eq : standardtmm ] ) will in general become a set of nonlinear equations . in cases , like the ones considered in the following sections , where only one multilevel atom is interacting with a linear optical system
, this problem may be solved using a procedure similar to the one outlined below : the fields surrounding the atom are obtained from the input fields through linear operations and then used with the optical bloch equations to obtain the populations and coherences of the atom s various levels .
knowledge of these quantities then determines the fields , and hence the forces acting on the atom , completely .
+ in the following sections we will restrict our discussion to the case where the input field is not modified by other transfer matrices
. we will apply this mechanism to investigate the behaviour of atoms in two cases where the polarization of the light varies in space on scales of the order of the wavelength to verify the validity of the model given by eq .
( [ eq : newmatrix ] ) to eq .
( [ eq : chime ] ) . in the first instance
, we illuminate our atom with two counterpropagating linearly polarized beams .
we choose the planes of polarization of the two beams to be orthogonal to each other .
the second configuration we will investigate involves illuminating the atom with two circularly polarized beams , choosing opposite handedness for the two beams .
these two cases mirror those in ref . @xcite .
transition . ] in this and the following sections , we will adopt the low - intensity hypothesis .
this allows us to simplify the optical bloch equations and resulting system considerably by neglecting the populations and coherences of the excited state sublevels .
we can thus replace @xmath31 by the ground state steady - state density matrix , @xmath40 .
we denote the diagonal element @xmath41 of @xmath40 , the population in sublevel @xmath42 , by @xmath43 , and the off - diagonal element @xmath44 , the coherence between sublevels @xmath42 and @xmath45 , by @xmath46 . here
we will discuss what is perhaps the simplest transition between two levels with multiple magnetic sublevels : the @xmath3 transition . in this case
, we have two ground sublevels so that @xmath47 is a @xmath25 matrix . fig .
[ fig:1 - 2_to_3 - 2 ] tabulates the clebsch - gordan coefficients required to evaluate @xmath9 .
we thus have : @xmath48 and @xmath49 whereby @xmath50 suppose , now , that we illuminate the atom with two counterpropagating beams having orthogonal linear polarization and equal intensity .
this can be represented by setting @xmath51 and @xmath52 where the shift in the @xmath53 coordinate is introduced to simplify our expressions . using the optical bloch equations
, we can show that the steady state populations in the ground sublevels at zero atomic velocity are given by @xmath54 noting that the populations do not depend on the field amplitudes in the low intensity regime .
we work to lowest order in @xmath33 and make use of the above relations to find the net force acting on the atom : @xmath55\cdot\bigl(\mathbf{b}-\mathbf{c}\bigr)^\star\right\}}\nonumber\\ & \phantom{=\ } + 4\tfrac{v}{c}\hbar k{\,\text{im}\!\left\{\bigl(\boldsymbol{\zeta}\mathbf{b}\bigr)\cdot\mathbf{c}^\star+\bigl(\boldsymbol{\zeta}\mathbf{c}\bigr)\cdot\mathbf{b}^\star\right\}}\nonumber\\ & \phantom{=\ } -2\tfrac{v}{c}\hbar k^2{\,\text{im}\!\left\{\biggl[\frac{\partial\boldsymbol{\zeta}}{\partial k}\bigl(\mathbf{b}+\mathbf{c}\bigr)\biggr]\cdot\bigl(\mathbf{b}+\mathbf{c}\bigr)^\star\right\}}\nonumber\\ & \approx2\hbar k\lvert b\rvert^2{\,\text{im}\!\left\{\bigl[\boldsymbol{\zeta}\bigl(\mathbf{b}+\mathbf{c}\bigr)\bigr]\cdot\bigl(\mathbf{b}-\mathbf{c}\bigr)^\star\right\}}\nonumber\\ & \phantom{\approx\ } + 2\tfrac{v}{c}\hbar k^2{\,\text{im}\!\left\{\biggl[\frac{\partial\boldsymbol{\zeta}}{\partial k}\bigl(\mathbf{b}+\mathbf{c}\bigr)\biggr]\cdot\bigl(\mathbf{b}+\mathbf{c}\bigr)^\star\right\}}\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have assumed that @xmath56 .
the velocity - dependent force terms in the above expression arise through the doppler shifting of photons both between field modes in the same polarization and between field modes in different polarizations ; these mechanisms are accounted for by the diagonal and off - diagonal terms in @xmath9 , respectively .
these terms emerge through the velocity - dependent terms in the generalised transfer matrix .
+ in the present case , eq . ( [ eq : generalforce ] ) simplifies approximately to @xmath57 assuming that @xmath33 is real for simplicity .
+ we now let @xmath58 be a characteristic residence time of the two ground state sublevels ; this will introduce a non - adiabatic following term , proportional to @xmath8 , in the populations of each of the sublevels and emerges from the optical bloch equations .
thus , we obtain the expression @xmath59 which agrees precisely with the standard literature ( cf .
( 4.20 ) and ( 4.23 ) in ref .
transition . ]
if we illuminate an atom with two counterpropagating beams of light in a @xmath60@xmath61 configuration , rich dynamics are obtained not in the simplest ( @xmath3 ) case , but in the next simplest , where the ground state has three magnetic sublevels ( @xmath62 ) and the excited state five ( @xmath63 ) . in this case , then , we can express @xmath47 and @xmath29 as @xmath64 and @xmath65 using the clebsch - gordan coefficients in fig .
[ fig:1_to_2 ] . together , these give @xmath66 with @xmath67 representing the nonzero coherence between the @xmath68 and the @xmath69 sublevels .
note that we again apply the low intensity hypothesis , thereby replacing @xmath31 with @xmath40 .
we now illuminate the atom with two counterpropagating beams of equal intensity , @xmath5 and @xmath6 , possessing @xmath60 and @xmath61 polarization , respectively : @xmath70 and @xmath71 we again use eq . ( [ eq : generalforce ] ) to derive the force acting on the atom , which is given by @xmath72 where the populations and coherences are again obtained from the optical bloch equations , and can be found in ref . @xcite . by observing the natural correspondence between @xmath33 and @xmath73 in this latter reference , we can see that our expression for the force acting on the atom again agrees with the standard literature to first order in @xmath74 ( cf .
( 5.9 ) in ref .
@xcite ) . the resulting friction force is thus due to both the doppler shift , as evident in the terms shown explicitly in eq .
( [ eq : sigmasigmaforce ] ) , as well as through the non - adiabatic following of the atomic sublevel populations .
by revisiting the transfer matrix formalism and expressing the polarizability of a scatterer as the expectation value of a quantum operator , we have endowed it with a strong quantum character that allows us to handle atoms with multiple ground and excited state sublevels . in principle , our extended formalism is only limited by its reliance on the optical bloch equations to give expressions for the ground state populations and coherences ; we have retained the character of our earlier formalism that allowed us to work to arbitrary order in the polarizability .
we have applied this theory to two standard sub - doppler cooling configurations , the so - called `` lin@xmath75lin '' and `` @xmath60@xmath61 '' configurations , and thereby reproduced the known expressions for the force acting on the atom .
this work was supported by the uk engineering and physical sciences research council ( epsrc ) grant ep / e058949/1 and by the _ cavity - mediated molecular cooling _ network within the euroquam programme of the european science foundation ( esf ) , as well as by the national scientific fund of hungary ( contract no .
nf68736 ) . | we present a generic transfer matrix approach for the description of the interaction of atoms possessing multiple ground state and excited state sublevels with light fields .
this model allows us to treat multi - level atoms as classical scatterers in light fields modified by , in principle , arbitrarily complex optical components such as mirrors , resonators , dispersive or dichroic elements , or filters .
we verify our formalism for two prototypical sub - doppler cooling mechanisms and show that it agrees with the standard literature . |
recent measurements of the positron fraction in cosmic rays ( crs ) up to 100 gev by the pamela experiment @xcite ( and of the sum of the electron plus positron fluxes by atic @xcite and ppb - bets @xcite ) have triggered a lot of interest on the possibility that there may be a dominant contribution to these terms from the annihilation or decay of dark matter ( dm ) particles , assumed to compose the dark halo of the milky way .
indeed , the sharp raise in the positron fraction detected by pamela above 10 gev , confirming and super - exceeding previous hints of an anomaly @xcite is a feature which can not be accommodated within the `` standard picture '' , with primary electrons accelerated in supernova remnants ( snrs ) and secondary positrons produced mainly from the interaction of primary cosmic - rays with the interstellar medium ( ism ) during propagation .
it is instead suggestive of an extra primary source of positrons .
pulsars are well - motivated candidates for this role , see , e.g. , @xcite .
another interesting possibility is the recent proposal that positrons ( and electrons ) are secondary products of hadronic interaction within the cosmic ray sources @xcite .
a contribution to the positron flux from dark matter was predicted long ago , see , e.g. @xcite ; depending on the dark matter particle mass and on the shape of the electron / positron yield from annihilation or decay , the excess can be accommodated , see , e.g. , @xcite .
a few puzzling issues arise however in connection to the dark matter interpretations : the required positron injection rate is fairly large , and , supposing the signal is due to annihilating particles , this points to pair annihilation rates much larger than the typical rates for thermal relic weakly interacting massive particles ( wimps ) and/or to substructure enhancements which should be unrealistically large . also , it is to some extent surprising that a dark matter signal emerges clearly in the positron flux and it is still hiding in other indirect detection channels : for typical particle physics dark matter candidates ( where the `` typical '' here stands for the absence of a mechanism forcing the coupling of the dark matter particle to light leptons only ) signals to background ratios tend to be larger for the antiproton flux ( and even more , in perspective , for the antideuteron flux ) , and for the gamma - ray component produced via neutral pion decays .
these features have guided recent work on both proposing new dark matter candidates , as well as setting constraints on the range of those that had been previously proposed .
the issue of whether the standard cosmic ray picture could give a fair description of the electron / positron populations in the galaxy and of whether the dm component could give a sizable contribution had actually been risen a few times even before the recent refined measurements of their local fluxes . indeed , although there is a wide consensus in associating the observed multi - wavelength diffuse emission in the galaxy to cr interactions with the ism and magnetic field , cr spectra and propagation parameters tuned to describe the local picture can lead to an underestimation of the flux in some regions of the sky .
high energy electrons emit radio to microwave photons via synchrotron radiation on the galactic magnetic fields and an excess in the innermost region of the galaxy has been claimed based on wmap data ( the so - called `` wmap haze '' ) when scaling the measured synchrotron radio intensities to the microwave band @xcite . equally important is the inverse compton ( ic ) radiation component of high energy electrons on the starlight and microwave photon backgrounds .
one of the models put forward to address the excess above 1 gev reported by egret in the observations of the diffuse gamma - ray emission of the galaxy @xcite considered the possibility of a dominant contribution from ic on starlight of an electron population in the galaxy , on average , much larger than what is locally measured @xcite ( `` optimized '' galprop model ) .
recent preliminary data @xcite from the fermi gamma - ray telescope ( formerly glast ) , however , do not seem to confirm the egret excess , with the level of the diffuse flux at high energy ( @xmath0 gev ) possibly consistent with a standard cosmic - ray setup and pointing to an instrumental effect in egret .
other excesses , which are not commonly connected to a dm interpretation , has been reported in the x - ray emission at the galactic ridge @xcite and in the tev @xmath1-ray emission measured by milagro @xcite .
the first relies on a quite complicate region , where simplified assumptions on the primary injection spectra and on the ism properties can break down
. the contribution of unresolved source in the milagro data can be large @xcite .
moreover , we are mostly interested in a fair description of the local region , which involve only the diffuse emission at intermediate and high latitudes and longitudes .
most attempts to insert the dark matter interpretation of the pamela data into a more global picture have involved either other species such as gamma - ray and antiproton yields , or other dark matter environments ( e.g. , the central region of the galaxy , or galactic satellites , instead of the local dark matter population which , in case the dark matter interpretation holds , would be most likely responsible for the measured positron flux ) . these kind of comparisons are inevitably model dependent .
comparing yields is certainly very powerful when having a reference particle physics model in mind ; on the other hand , as already mentioned , one may just tune the dark matter candidate in such way that only light leptons are produced as detectable yields .
radiative components are instead unavoidably associated to electron / positron yields : ic emission of a 100 gev to 1 tev electron on @xmath2 m starlight photons gives gamma - rays with energies peaked in about the range 50 gev to 5 tev ; the associated synchrotron emission on a 1 @xmath3 g magnetic field is peaked between 50 to 5000 ghz ( scaling linearly with the magnetic field ) .
having normalized the electron / positron yield to the locally observed flux , the extrapolation for the radiative emission in the local portion of the galaxy and its neighborhood is fairly solid , since although it is true that there are uncertainties in the astrophysical model involved , such as the parameters in the cosmic - ray propagation model and the level of the stellar radiation and magnetic fields , these need to be in turn readjusted to the local measurements ( regarding the local electron flux as well as from ratios of secondaries to primaries in cosmic rays ) .
extrapolations to , e.g. , the central region of the galaxy to compare , e.g. , with the wmap haze , are much more uncertain since they rely on the extrapolations for the astrophysical parameters ( with various kinds of degeneracies which can be involved ) as well as for the level of dark matter yield ( in connection , e.g. , with the dark matter density profile ) .
we will study the dark matter contribution to galactic radiation seed at intermediate to large latitudes .
the emission in such portion of the sky can actually probe the local environment and this test of the dm interpretation of the pamela excess can be thus considered self - consistent .
we will analyze the dependence of the predicted signal on the uncertainties in the cosmic - ray propagation model .
we will also sketch the differences with respect to the picture in which the source(s ) accounting for the pamela positron fraction is confined to the stellar disc rather than being spread to on a much larger vertical extension such as in case of the dark matter source . the reference to test
experimentally our proposal will be the fermi gamma - ray telescope ( and , to a minor extent , the planck satellite @xcite ) .
recent analyses of the diffuse galactic emission induced by dm models in light of the pamela and atic data includes refs .
@xcite .
the paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec : crprop ] , we present the description of the particle propagation in the galaxy . in section [ sec :
source ] , we discuss the spectral and spatial distribution of the cr and dm sources . in section [ sec : signal ] , we present the results for the final @xmath4 distribution and for the multi - wavelength diffuse emission induced by crs and dm .
section [ sec : conc ] concludes .
we adopt the description of cosmic - rays as particles propagating in a determinate environment ( i.e. , disregarding the effects induced on the ism by the interaction with crs ) . the cr propagation equation for a particle species @xmath5
can be written in the form @xcite : = ( d_xxn_i - v_c n_i ) + p p^2 d_ppp 1p^2 n_i - p + q(r , p , t)++ [ eq : transport ] where @xmath6 is the number density per particle momentum ( @xmath7 , with @xmath8 being the number density in the energy interval @xmath9 ) , @xmath10 is the source term , @xmath11 is the spatial diffusion coefficient along the regular magnetic field lines , @xmath12 is the velocity of the galactic wind , @xmath13 is the coefficient of the diffusion in momentum space , @xmath14 is the momentum loss rate , and @xmath15 and @xmath16 are the time scales for fragmentation loss and radioactive decay , respectively .
the transport equation is solved numerically and assuming a cylindrical symmetry , with halo boundaries at disc radius @xmath17 kpc and half - thickness @xmath18 as described below .
we exploited a modified version of the galprop code @xcite .
the main modifications consist in introducing by input the spatial and spectral profiles of the dm source ( computed within the darksusypackage @xcite ) , and in including the possibility of a spatially varying diffusion coefficient . in the following ,
we mainly consider one - zone models with isotropic diffusion , which can be regarded as the most extensively tested models of the recent past ( see , e.g. , ref .
@xcite for a review ) .
our approach is to perform self - consistent tests in the local region and the parameters in eq .
[ eq : transport ] are chosen to strictly reproduce the local directly - observed spectra of nuclei and electrons .
the goal of the paper is to study the possibility of disentangling the diffuse signals originated from two different sources , crs and dm , having different spatial distributions .
the cr injection source is confined to the galactic plane , while the dm profile has a spherical shape .
the region with intermediate and large @xmath19 is thus the best target for the analysis .
the propagation reshuffles the distribution of the two populations of electrons ( and thus ic and bremsstrahlung signals ) , and the @xmath1-ray signal associated to the decays of cr pions .
the scaling of the signal along the @xmath19-direction is affected by almost any quantity entering in the transport equation , such as the description of the diffusion , the wind velocity , the magnetic field structure , and the interstellar radiation field ( isrf ) distribution .
moreover , it is dramatically sensitive to the height of the propagation halo , namely , to the boundary condition along the @xmath19-axis .
we are not interested in performing a full scan of the propagation parameters space and estimating the corresponding uncertainties in the cr spectra ( see , e.g. , refs .
@xcite ) ; rather , we want to investigate how different scalings along the @xmath19-direction due to different propagation models can affect the predictions for the signal to background ratio .
we consider six benchmark scenarios of propagation and injection spectra , which are summarized in table 1 . in the following ,
we motivate our selection .
.benchmark models of propagation .
the spectral index break for protons and electrons is at 9 gev in the cases with kolmogorov diffusion , and at 40 and 9 gev , respectively , in the kraichnan case .
the scale of diffusion in the model b5 is taken to be @xmath20 kpc . [
cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] kpc and @xmath21 gev .
_ left panel _ : propagation model b0 : we show primary cr electrons ( blue solid ) , secondary cr @xmath22 produced in the ism ( blue short dashed ) , secondary cr @xmath22 produced at the source ( black dotted ) , and @xmath22 induced by dm annihilation in the model dm@xmath23 ( blue thick dotted ) . for comparison , we plot the distribution of a source scaling as @xmath24 ( black solid ) , with an arbitrary normalization . _
central panel _ : the same of the left panel , but adding the propagation models b1 ( green ) and b2 ( red ) and considering only the contributions from primary electrons and dm induced electrons + positrons .
_ right panel _ : the same of the central panel , but in the propagation models b3 ( orange ) , b4 ( cyan ) , and b5 ( magenta).,width=207 ] kpc and @xmath21 gev .
_ left panel _ :
propagation model b0 : we show primary cr electrons ( blue solid ) , secondary cr @xmath22 produced in the ism ( blue short dashed ) , secondary cr @xmath22 produced at the source ( black dotted ) , and @xmath22 induced by dm annihilation in the model dm@xmath23 ( blue thick dotted ) . for comparison , we plot the distribution of a source scaling as @xmath24 ( black solid ) , with an arbitrary normalization . _
central panel _ : the same of the left panel , but adding the propagation models b1 ( green ) and b2 ( red ) and considering only the contributions from primary electrons and dm induced electrons + positrons .
_ right panel _ : the same of the central panel , but in the propagation models b3 ( orange ) , b4 ( cyan ) , and b5 ( magenta).,width=207 ] kpc and @xmath21 gev .
_ left panel _ : propagation model b0 : we show primary cr electrons ( blue solid ) , secondary cr @xmath22 produced in the ism ( blue short dashed ) , secondary cr @xmath22 produced at the source ( black dotted ) , and @xmath22 induced by dm annihilation in the model dm@xmath23 ( blue thick dotted ) . for comparison , we plot the distribution of a source scaling as @xmath24 ( black solid ) , with an arbitrary normalization . _
central panel _ : the same of the left panel , but adding the propagation models b1 ( green ) and b2 ( red ) and considering only the contributions from primary electrons and dm induced electrons + positrons .
_ right panel _ : the same of the central panel , but in the propagation models b3 ( orange ) , b4 ( cyan ) , and b5 ( magenta).,width=207 ] we start with the case of pair annihilating wimps .
the explanation of the pamela data requires a wimp mass @xmath25 gev .
wimps with @xmath26 tev and inducing a very hard spectrum of @xmath27 are disfavoured by the fermi data on @xmath22 ( assuming a power - law for the injection spectra of primary electrons ) .
we consider the scenario of a wimp annihilating directly into @xmath27 as a toy benchmark case to show that for any dm model inducing a hard spectra of @xmath27 fitting the pamela positron fraction , the associated diffuse emission is at a detectable level , independently on the mass ( for @xmath28 gev ) .
a heavy wimp ( i.e. , @xmath29 few hundreds of gev ) with the same final state would actually induce an ic emission which is already strongly constrained by egret data @xcite . for the dme benchmark scenario , we consider a wimp mass of 300 gev . a light(i.e . , @xmath30 gev ) wimp candidate annihilating into @xmath31 does not provide an explanation to the pamela data .
the @xmath1-ray emission induced by a heavy ( i.e. , @xmath32 gev ) dm candidate with the same annihilation modes ( and fitting the pamela excess ) could violate constraints by act measurements of dwarf satellites @xcite and of the galactic ridge @xcite .
we refer to a sample case standing in middle of this mass interval , namely a wimp mass of 400 gev ( dm@xmath33 ) .
a wimp annihilating into @xmath34 with mass @xmath35 tev can give a very good fit to , simultaneously , the pamela and fermi data . in the benchmark case dm@xmath3 , we consider @xmath36 tev .
we tune the annihilation cross section in order to fit the positron fraction measured by pamela above 10 gev and the @xmath22 local spectrum measured by fermi .
the fit is performed adding the dark matter component to the background contribution from standard primary crs and the secondaries produced along propagation , computed in the same propagation model configuration .
we allow the normalization and spectral index of both primary and secondary cr electrons to vary with respect to the cases reported in table 1 ( within the ranges @xmath37 and @xmath38 ) , reflecting some uncertainties on their modelling . within these assumptions ,
the models describing the dm component with the benchmark scenario dm@xmath23 can not reproduce simultaneously the two sets of data .
they would require some exotic assumptions for the primary injection spectra .
therefore , in this case we restrict the analysis to the fit of the pamela dataset only , requiring the @xmath22 spectrum induced by dm@xmath23 alone to be consistent with the fermi observations .
the best fit values for the dm@xmath23 scenario are : @xmath39 , for dm@xmath33 scenario are : @xmath40 , and for dm@xmath3 scenario are : @xmath41 in the ( b0 , b1 , b2 , b3 , b4 , b5 ) propagation model , respectively . for the dm@xmath33 and dm@xmath3 scenarios ,
all the models provide a good fit to the data .
the theoretical curves do not reproduce the data in an extremely precise way only for what concerns the positron fraction at energies below 20 gev in the propagation models b1 and b3 .
in such cases , the production of secondary positrons from primary cr is enhanced ( see fig . [
fig : crspectra]b ) and the background alone tends to be in conflict with pamela data at low energies .
we plot in fig .
[ fig : lisepem ] the obtained @xmath22 spectrum and positron fraction of the three benchmark dm scenarios in the propagation model b0 . note that , as expected , the best - fit values for the annihilation rates are significantly larger than the thermally averaged annihilation rate at the time of decoupling of wimps , namely , @xmath42 .
many explanations have been proposed to motivate such mismatch , like , e.g. , non thermal production mechanism , non - standard cosmology at the time of dm decoupling , and sommerfeld enhancement . as we already mentioned , in the case of burkert dm profile , the differences in the spatial distribution of a signal scaling with @xmath43 , as in the wimp case , or with @xmath44 , as in the decaying dm case , are very mild .
therefore , our results can be rephrased in term of benchmark decaying dm scenarios with decaying modes analogous to the annihilation modes introduced above , and with mass scale doubled .
the corresponding decay rate can be approximately estimated by @xmath45 , where @xmath46 is the mass of the wimp in the annihilating dm scenario .
as discussed in the previous section , for comparison , we consider also the case of an extra non - standard component due to the production of secondary @xmath4 inside cr sources . in fig .
[ fig : lisepem ] , we plot the @xmath22 spectrum and positron fraction in the propagation model b0 for a population injected with @xmath47 , an energy - cutoff at @xmath48 tev and normalization tuned to the best fit value for the pamela and fermi data ( again allowing mild variations in the normalization and spectral index of primary and secondary electrons ) .
the absence of sharp features in the @xmath22 spectrum detected by fermi implies that the contribution of the source of positrons responsible for the pamela excess to the total @xmath22 local flux or to the associated diffuse emission , can be hardly singled out .
if the spatial distribution of the sources of such `` exotic '' components traces the cr sources , the last sentence would be true everywhere in the galaxy . in fig .
[ fig : vertprof ] , we plot the vertical profiles of the electron number density distributions , at the local radial distance @xmath49 kpc and @xmath21 gev . for this slice of the galaxy , at rather large distance from the gc ,
the determination of propagation model parameters as derived by matching the lis of nuclei is rather robust .
we are focusing on some typical energy at which electron and positron sources relevant for the raise in the positron fraction are also a significant contribution to the total population of @xmath22 . in fig .
[ fig : vertprof]a we consider the propagation model b0 , and plot the vertical profile of cr primary electrons ( solid ) , secondary @xmath22 produced in the ism ( short - dashed ) , secondary @xmath22 injected at the source ( dashed - dotted ) , and @xmath22 flux induced by wimp annihilations in the dm@xmath23 scenario ( dotted ) . all these cases but
the latter follow a distribution which is mainly confined to the disc ( although broadened by the diffusion ) .
the dm - induced component is instead much flatter ( we plot for comparison the profile of the dm injection source @xmath50 ) .
it is the dominant component at intermediate and large z. we thus expect the associated radiative emission to dominate at intermediate and high latitudes . in order to understand how this conclusion is dependent on the propagation model considered , we show the cases of the propagation model b1 and b2 ( plus again b0 , for comparison ) in fig .
[ fig : vertprof]b , and of b3 , b4 , and b5 in fig [ fig : vertprof]c . in these figures , we do not plot the vertical profiles of secondary @xmath22 .
their shapes are analogous to the cr primary electrons profile and the rescaling factor is roughly the same as in fig .
[ fig : vertprof]a .
note from fig .
[ fig : vertprof]b that , as expected , as the boundary of propagation @xmath18 increases ( decreases ) , the region at which the dm - induced component is dominant becomes larger ( smaller ) . from fig .
[ fig : vertprof]c , we conclude that at high energies the effect of convection ( model b3 ) on the shape of the vertical profile is negligible .
the same conclusion applies also to the effect of varying the spectral index of the diffusion coefficient ( model b4 ) . in the model b5
, the population of electrons induced by dm at high @xmath19 is mildly reduced with respect to the model b2 since the spatial diffusion coefficient is increasing with @xmath19 , and electrons and positrons are less efficiently confined . -ray diffuse spectrum at intermediate latitudes ( @xmath51 ) , integrated over longitudes @xmath52 and compared to the fermi preliminary data @xcite . _ left panel _ : emission in the propagation model b0 . the cr ( primary+secondary )
spectra associated to @xmath53-decay , ic , and bremsstrahlung are shown by thin dotted lines .
the thick solid blue line is the sum of the three components .
the solid black line shows the extragalactic background in the model described in the text ( thick ) and fitted from egret data @xcite ( thin ) .
the ic + fsr emission associated to the wimps dm@xmath23 and dm@xmath3 are shown by thick dotted and thick dashed - dotted lines , respectively .
the ic + @xmath1-ray from @xmath53-decay signals induced by the wimp dm@xmath33 are shown by thick dashed lines . _
central panel _ : emission in the propagation models b1 ( green ) and b2 ( red ) .
same line styles of the left panel .
_ right panel _ : the same of central panel , but for the propagation models b3 ( orange ) , b4 ( cyan ) , and b5 ( magenta).,width=207 ] -ray diffuse spectrum at intermediate latitudes ( @xmath51 ) , integrated over longitudes @xmath52 and compared to the fermi preliminary data @xcite .
_ left panel _ : emission in the propagation model b0 . the cr ( primary+secondary )
spectra associated to @xmath53-decay , ic , and bremsstrahlung are shown by thin dotted lines .
the thick solid blue line is the sum of the three components .
the solid black line shows the extragalactic background in the model described in the text ( thick ) and fitted from egret data @xcite ( thin ) .
the ic + fsr emission associated to the wimps dm@xmath23 and dm@xmath3 are shown by thick dotted and thick dashed - dotted lines , respectively .
the ic + @xmath1-ray from @xmath53-decay signals induced by the wimp dm@xmath33 are shown by thick dashed lines . _
central panel _ : emission in the propagation models b1 ( green ) and b2 ( red ) .
same line styles of the left panel .
_ right panel _ : the same of central panel , but for the propagation models b3 ( orange ) , b4 ( cyan ) , and b5 ( magenta).,width=207 ] -ray diffuse spectrum at intermediate latitudes ( @xmath51 ) , integrated over longitudes @xmath52 and compared to the fermi preliminary data @xcite .
_ left panel _ : emission in the propagation model b0 . the cr ( primary+secondary )
spectra associated to @xmath53-decay , ic , and bremsstrahlung are shown by thin dotted lines .
the thick solid blue line is the sum of the three components .
the solid black line shows the extragalactic background in the model described in the text ( thick ) and fitted from egret data @xcite ( thin ) .
the ic + fsr emission associated to the wimps dm@xmath23 and dm@xmath3 are shown by thick dotted and thick dashed - dotted lines , respectively .
the ic + @xmath1-ray from @xmath53-decay signals induced by the wimp dm@xmath33 are shown by thick dashed lines . _
central panel _ : emission in the propagation models b1 ( green ) and b2 ( red ) .
same line styles of the left panel .
_ right panel _ : the same of central panel , but for the propagation models b3 ( orange ) , b4 ( cyan ) , and b5 ( magenta).,width=207 ] the discussion in the previous section pointed out that , in order to detect a dm - induced signal in the diffuse emission of the galaxy , intermediate and high latitudes are the best targets . at high latitudes ,
the diffuse extragalactic gamma - ray background ( egb ) is expected to become the dominant background component . to estimate the level of the extragalactic emission in the fermi preliminary data @xcite reported in fig .
[ fig : emissint ] , we rely on the egret data and we consider the fit obtained in ref .
@xcite ( upper black curve ) .
the sharp increase in sensitivity to point sources of the fermi telescope with respect to egret , may , on the other hand , lower significantly such term . in three months of observations
, fermi has already detected an amount of individually resolved active galactic nuclei ( which are believed to be the main component of the egb ) corresponding to @xmath54 7% of the egret extragalactic diffuse gamma - ray background @xcite .
we consider a model for the contribution of unresolved blazars as in ref .
@xcite ( lower black curve in fig .
[ fig : emissint ] and [ fig : emisshigh ] ) , estimating the fermi point source sensitivity as @xmath55 , roughly corresponding to 3 years of observations .
another crucial ingredient to estimate the diffuse extragalactic radiation is absorption of gamma - rays at high energies , mainly due to pair production on the extragalactic background light emitted by galaxies in the ultraviolet , optical and infrared bands .
we consider the parametrization of this effect in ref .
@xcite , as derived in the context of the @xmath56cdm cosmological model . in fig .
[ fig : emissint ] , we plot the @xmath1-ray diffuse spectrum at @xmath51 , integrated over longitude ( @xmath52 ) , and compared to the fermi preliminary data .
these measurement do not confirm the egret excess in the gev energy range , with the level of the detected diffuse flux being significantly reduced . in fig .
[ fig : emissint]a we show the case of the `` conventional '' propagation model b0 . in the previous section , in order to determine the best fit values of the annihilation cross sections , we allowed the normalization and spectral index for primary and secondary cr electrons / positrons to vary with respect to the benchmark cases reported in table 1 ( see fig .
[ fig : lisepem]b ) . on the other hand , such mild variations in the spectra
induce negligible variations in the associated diffuse emissions .
thus , in the following , for sake of clearness , we consider the background cr emission as given by the benchmark models of table 1 .
the first remark is that the sum ( blue solid line ) of three cr components ( blue thin dotted lines ) , namely , ic , bremsstrahlung , and @xmath53-decays , plus the extragalactic background contribution ( black solid line ) , can approximately account for the measured flux at @xmath0 gev ( note that propagation models have not been tuned to do so , while we are just extrapolating from the lis of nuclei ) .
exotic components , claimed in order to explain the egret excess , are now significantly constrained , at least at mid - latitudes . in the same plot
one can see that the @xmath1-ray flux induced by our benchmark dm models is more than one order of magnitude smaller than the detected flux at @xmath57 gev , while it becomes comparable to or higher than the background at @xmath58 100 gev . at such energies ,
both the ic and fsr signals are relevant in the model dm@xmath23 ( thick dotted line ) and dm@xmath3 ( thick dashed - dotted line ) , while in the model dm@xmath33 ( thick dashed line ) the flux is driven by the @xmath53-decay emission . note that the in the dm@xmath23 scenario the final @xmath4 spectrum is very sharp and thus the peaks of the ic emission on cmb and on infrared and optical starlight are clearly visible , while in the dm@xmath3 and dm@xmath33 cases they are smoothed . the @xmath1-ray diffuse spectrum at intermediate latitudes for the propagation models b1 and b2 is shown in fig .
[ fig : emissint]b .
as expected , the ic signal associated to the wimp dm@xmath23 and dm@xmath3 is enhanced ( reduced ) than the cr signal for the model b2 ( b1 ) with respect to the `` conventional '' model , making the wimp scenario more easily detectable ( undetectable ) .
moreover the cr secondary positron spectrum in the model b2 ( b1 ) is reduced ( enhanced ) , see fig . [
fig : crspectra]b . in the fit of the pamela excess
, this leads to an enhancement ( decrease ) in the normalization of the dm - induced positron spectrum , and thus in the annihilation cross section , implying a higher ( smaller ) signal associated to @xmath53-decay and fsr . from fig .
[ fig : emissint]c , one can see that the level of cr diffuse spectra at high energy in the model b3 , b4 , and b5 is almost identical to the `` conventional '' case .
the dm - induced emissions are also analogous .
all the cr benchmark scenarios considered in the discussion induce emissions which are fair in agreement with the fermi preliminary data .
we find a slight mismatch only in the model b1 at high energy , caused by the lower level of ic and bremsstrahlung radiations as follows from the fact that we are introduced a smaller region for @xmath4 propagation and thus a smaller region for radiative emission , and in the model b4 at low energy , due to the choice of spectral indices ( see the @xmath4 spectrum at @xmath54 gev energies in fig . [
fig : crspectra]b ) .
as already emphasized a few times in the paper , the cr emission is almost confined on the disc ( i.e. , it is elongated in the @xmath59 direction and rapidly decreasing along @xmath19 ) .
therefore , the diffuse emission in @xmath60 coordinates ( namely , the flux integrated along the line of sight labeled by the angles @xmath60 ) tends to have a flatter longitudinal profile as the latitude increases .
this is true also for the dm components ( being the dm profile and the isrf distribution , relevant for ic emission , decreasing with @xmath19 ) , but to a smaller extent , especially at intermediate latitudes .
we expect therefore larger ratios for the dm signal to cr background at longitudes close to the center of the galaxy ; on the other hand , our procedure for estimating parameters in the propagation model is driven by local data , and thus our extrapolations are more reliable outside the inner region
. -ray diffuse emission at intermediate latitudes ( @xmath51 ) and @xmath61 gev . _
left panel _ : emission in the propagation model b0 .
the cr profiles associated to @xmath53-decay and ic are shown by thin solid lines .
the solid black line shows the extragalactic background in the model described in the text .
the profile of the ic emission associated to secondary @xmath22 produced at the source is shown by the black dotted line .
the ic + fsr emissions associated to the wimps dm@xmath23 and dm@xmath3 are shown by thick dotted and dashed - dotted lines , respectively .
the ic + @xmath1-ray from @xmath53-decay signals induced by the wimp dm@xmath33 are shown by thick dashed lines . _
central panel _ : emission in the propagation models b1 ( green ) and b2 ( red ) .
line styles as in the left panel .
_ right panel _ : the same of central panel , but for the propagation models b3 ( orange ) , b4 ( cyan ) , and b5 ( magenta).,width=207 ] -ray diffuse emission at intermediate latitudes ( @xmath51 ) and @xmath61 gev .
_ left panel _ : emission in the propagation model b0 .
the cr profiles associated to @xmath53-decay and ic are shown by thin solid lines .
the solid black line shows the extragalactic background in the model described in the text .
the profile of the ic emission associated to secondary @xmath22 produced at the source is shown by the black dotted line .
the ic + fsr emissions associated to the wimps dm@xmath23 and dm@xmath3 are shown by thick dotted and dashed - dotted lines , respectively .
the ic + @xmath1-ray from @xmath53-decay signals induced by the wimp dm@xmath33 are shown by thick dashed lines . _
central panel _ : emission in the propagation models b1 ( green ) and b2 ( red ) .
line styles as in the left panel .
_ right panel _ : the same of central panel , but for the propagation models b3 ( orange ) , b4 ( cyan ) , and b5 ( magenta).,width=207 ] -ray diffuse emission at intermediate latitudes ( @xmath51 ) and @xmath61 gev .
_ left panel _ : emission in the propagation model b0 .
the cr profiles associated to @xmath53-decay and ic are shown by thin solid lines .
the solid black line shows the extragalactic background in the model described in the text .
the profile of the ic emission associated to secondary @xmath22 produced at the source is shown by the black dotted line .
the ic + fsr emissions associated to the wimps dm@xmath23 and dm@xmath3 are shown by thick dotted and dashed - dotted lines , respectively .
the ic + @xmath1-ray from @xmath53-decay signals induced by the wimp dm@xmath33 are shown by thick dashed lines . _
central panel _ : emission in the propagation models b1 ( green ) and b2 ( red ) .
line styles as in the left panel .
_ right panel _ : the same of central panel , but for the propagation models b3 ( orange ) , b4 ( cyan ) , and b5 ( magenta).,width=207 ] in order to show that the detectability of a dm component inferred from fig .
[ fig : emissint ] is not only related to the picture in the central region of the galaxy , in fig .
[ fig : lonprofint ] we plot the longitudinal profile for the diffuse emission at @xmath61 gev and for @xmath51 ( namely , the same latitudes of fig .
[ fig : emissint ] ) .
note that the diffuse component induced by dm dominates over a large range of longitudes for any benchmark scenarios .
the picture is completely different with respect to the signal induced by secondary @xmath22 produced at the source , which is subdominant everywhere , having a spatial profile of injection identical to the primary sources .
the cr emission associated to @xmath53-decay is shown only in the `` conventional '' case ( fig .
[ fig : lonprofint]a ) . at high energy
, it is analogous for all the models of propagation , being mostly generated close to the disc .
it is highly irregular due to the variation of the gas density .
the longitudinal shape of the @xmath53-decay signal in the southern hemisphere ( @xmath62 ) would be different but with an overall size roughly analogous . from the figures ,
one can see that the longitudinal shapes of the signals are analogous for all the benchmark propagation models . in figs .
[ fig : emisshigh ] and [ fig : lonprofhigh ] , we repeat the same analysis at higher latitudes , namely , @xmath63 . as expected from the analysis of the previous section , in this case we find a larger ratio between the signal induced by dm to the emission associated to crs . on the other hand ,
the egb starts to play a major role .
the detection prospects for the wimp scenario dm@xmath33 are again very favourable in all the propagation models .
the emission induced by dm@xmath23 and dm@xmath3 is also detectable , being , roughly , of the same level of the sum of the backgrounds at @xmath64 gev .
this is no longer true at higher latitudes , where the egb takes over and such emission becomes too faint to give a clear signature .
[ fig : lonprofint ] , shows that , as explained in the discussion above , the longitudinal profiles become flatter than at lower latitudes .
the emissions come mostly from the local region and therefore these predictions can be assumed as rather robust .
note that the enhancement in the dm - induced ic emission in the propagation models with @xmath65 kpc ( b2 and b5 ) with respect to the `` conventional '' case ( @xmath66 kpc ) is more significant than at intermediate latitudes , and viceversa for the model b1 .
the b2 case is more favourable than the b5 model ; in the latter the @xmath4 population is slightly depleted at large @xmath19 since the spatial diffusion coefficient increases in such region .
the predictions in the models b3 and b4 are again analogous to the `` conventional '' case . -ray diffuse spectrum at high latitudes ( @xmath67 ) integrated over longitudes @xmath52 .
line styles and colors as in fig .
[ fig : emissint].,width=207 ] -ray diffuse spectrum at high latitudes ( @xmath67 ) integrated over longitudes @xmath52 .
line styles and colors as in fig .
[ fig : emissint].,width=207 ] -ray diffuse spectrum at high latitudes ( @xmath67 ) integrated over longitudes @xmath52 .
line styles and colors as in fig .
[ fig : emissint].,width=207 ] the level we predict for diffuse @xmath1-ray fluxes is about @xmath68 mev @xmath69 s@xmath70 sr@xmath70 at @xmath64 gev ( see figs . [
fig : emissint]-[fig : lonprofhigh ] ) . considering the fermi performances stated in ref .
@xcite ( roughly , an effective area of @xmath71 and a field of view @xmath72 sr ) , the expected number of counts , for an energy bin size of @xmath73 gev , is about @xmath74 sr@xmath70 yr@xmath70 .
we deduce that the diffuse @xmath1-ray spectra as predicted in figs .
[ fig : emissint ] and [ fig : emisshigh ] can be detected with a statistical error smaller than @xmath75 in 1 year of observation .
the precise description of longitudinal and latitudinal profiles requires , on the other hand , some years of observations . combining different slices of the sky , however , the disentanglement between the cr source having a `` disc '' shape and the wimp induced source having a spherical shape will be feasible in the forthcoming future .
full sky - maps , at 150 gev for the @xmath53-decay signal associated to primary cr and dm@xmath33 , and for the ic emission associated to cr electrons and dm@xmath3 is shown in figs .
[ fig : mapcr ] and [ fig : mapdm ] .
differences in morphologies for the various components are indeed very clear .
now we turn the discussion on the synchrotron emission in the radio and infrared bands .
electrons and positrons injected by dm or cr source interact with the galactic magnetic field , giving raise to a synchrotron radiation .
due to the spectral behaviour , the synchrotron emission is the dominant component of the galactic diffuse emission at low frequency . the sky - map of ref .
@xcite at 408 mhz is the standard calibration for the synchrotron diffuse signal ( although it could include a significant amount of unresolved sources ) .
foreground estimations in the wmap data @xcite suggest a spectral index for the synchrotron emission @xmath76 , at frequency up to 60 ghz .
( an anomalous component has be claimed to be present in the innermost region of the galaxy , a result which depends on the template used for the foreground estimation .
the associated spectral index turns out to be harder than 3 .
such component , dubbed `` wmap haze '' , has been associated to be a possible dm signal due to wimp annihilations @xcite .
since the haze is associated to the central portion of the galaxy , we will not discuss it here . ) in fig .
[ fig : radio ] , we show the emission associated to primary+secondary cr electrons in the `` conventional '' model at intermediate latitudes .
matching the diffuse emission induced by crs with the observed synchrotron emission in the whole galaxy is beyond the goal of this paper .
note , however , that the spectral index is very close to 3 , as required .
the overall normalization is also very close to the one estimated by the wmap team .
again , in order to explore a possible dm signal , the region at intermediate and large latitudes is the best target .
indeed , the magnetic field slowly decreases outside the disc ( we adopt the benchmark case @xmath77\,\mu$]g , as described in section [ sec : crprop ] ) , and , thus , the signal induced by a spherical dm profile is non - negligible at intermediate and large @xmath19 .
the peak of the synchrotron emissivity is approximately at the frequency @xmath78 , with @xmath79 the electron energy and @xmath80 the ambient magnetic field .
the injection of high energetic electrons ( @xmath81 gev ) induce a signal peaked at frequencies @xmath82 ghz .
it follows that this represents the best frequency range for the search of a synchrotron emission induced by a dm candidate injecting an electron / positron yield at the level of the pamela excess .
such frequencies are above the wmap range , while it could be possible to search for such a component with forthcoming planck satellite , which will have detection channels up to a frequency of @xmath83 ghz .
we show in fig .
[ fig : radio ] , the signals induced by the benchmark dm candidates introduced above , as computed in the propagation model b0 .
the detection prospects are less favourable than in the @xmath1-ray band .
only the benchmark scenario dm@xmath23 can induce a significant component at intermediate latitudes .
moreover , an extra uncertainty in the analysis at infrared frequencies is given by the fact that thermal emission rather than synchrotron is expected to dominate the foreground .
focusing the analysis on the spatial distribution and on polarization data could , however , help to disentangle a dm - induced synchrotron signal .
a firmer statement on such a possibility with the planck satellite deserves a more detailed dedicated study . -ray diffuse emission at high latitudes ( @xmath67 ) and @xmath61 gev .
line styles and colors as in fig .
[ fig : lonprofint].,width=207 ] -ray diffuse emission at high latitudes ( @xmath67 ) and @xmath61 gev .
line styles and colors as in fig .
[ fig : lonprofint].,width=207 ] -ray diffuse emission at high latitudes ( @xmath67 ) and @xmath61 gev .
line styles and colors as in fig .
[ fig : lonprofint].,width=207 ] in principle , data in the x - ray frequency band can also be used to test the diffuse continuum emission induced by dm pair annihilations or decays . on the other hand ,
the fluxes detected by integral spi @xcite and comptel @xcite in the inner region of the galaxy is a factor of few above the estimated cr diffuse emission ( as computed in the `` conventional '' model ) .
it follows that , generically , dm - induced fluxes are in turn less constrained by these data - sets with respect to the @xmath1-ray and radio observations . moreover , the case of a dm candidates which offers an interpretation of the pamela excess is even harder to be detected , since the hard injection spectrum of the dm - induced @xmath4 leads to a signal associated to the ic scattering with the cmb component which is subdominant with respect to the cr contribution , having the latter a softer spectrum ( see figs [ fig : emissint ] and [ fig : emisshigh ] ) .
we have presented a study of the diffuse @xmath1-ray emission induced by particle - dm models which can account for the pamela positron excess . the analysis has been focused on signals induced by pair annihilations ( or decays ) associated to the smooth component of the milky way dm halo , in a configuration with no significant enhancement in the dm density in the galactic center region , hence with none of the dm signals usually discussed from the center of the galaxy at a detectable level .
the goal was to present an analysis based on minimal sets of assumptions and extrapolations with respect to locally testable or measurable quantities ( for comparison , e.g. , ref .
@xcite considers also dm profiles with a central cusp , finding strong , though heavily model - dependent , constraints from gc observations ) . in this respect ,
e.g. , we are not directly comparing to the possibility of detecting dm fluxes from milky way satellites or other dark matter dominated objects , avoiding the extrapolations that are required when addressing this kind of predictions .
estimates of extragalactic @xmath1-ray background from unresolved dm structures lead typically to a flux below the astrophysical egb ( unless a substantial enhancement stems from populations of dense substructures ) , which is mainly related to unresolved blazars ; this component is therefore marginally relevant for our analysis ( although it could be possibly detected studying its anisotropy pattern @xcite ) . on the other hand , a contribution of unresolved galactic subhalos to the diffuse emission of the galaxy could be substantial @xcite . our conclusions would be strengthened , in particular , in case of a spatial distribution of subhalos antibiased with respect to the host halo mass distribution @xcite , which would give a larger diffuse emission at high latitudes and longitudes . while not changing the general picture , the estimation of this component depends on several quantities which are not well - known , such as the mass function , the spatial distribution and the concentration of subhalos .
the presence of a galactic dark disc can in principle affect our conclusions if the dm density associated to the disc is much higher than the density of the halo . however , this is quite unlikely , as also found in the simulation of ref .
@xcite , which proposed the existence of a dark disc in milky way - sized galaxies .
moreover , we consider , for simplicity , a spherical shape for the dm halo , which is actually an approximation .
significant deviations from sphericity could induce a different scaling of the signal in the longitudinal direction with respect to the latitudinal direction . however , our general conclusions will be unchanged , being crucially based only on the assumption that the dm halo is extended along the z - direction well further the stellar disc .
s@xmath70 sr@xmath70 ] .
_ left panel _ : inverse compton radiation . _ right panel _ : @xmath53-decay emission . ,
width=207 ] s@xmath70 sr@xmath70 ] .
_ left panel _ : inverse compton radiation . _ right panel _ : @xmath53-decay emission . ,
width=207 ] s@xmath70 sr@xmath70 ] .
_ left panel _ : inverse compton radiation in the dm@xmath3 scenario .
_ right panel _ : @xmath53-decay emission in the dm@xmath33 scenario.,width=207 ] s@xmath70 sr@xmath70 ] .
_ left panel _ : inverse compton radiation in the dm@xmath3 scenario . _ right panel _ : @xmath53-decay emission in the dm@xmath33 scenario.,width=207 ] we have compared the dm signal to standard astrophysical components , analyzing spectral and spatial features to derive which are the best energy band and region of the sky to disentangle the dm contribution from the galactic plus extragalactic background with the fermi lat telescope .
being the sources of acceleration for cr ( namely , supernovae type ii ) distributed within a thin disc , the ratio of the associated background versus the dm signal decreases as the latitude increases .
the extragalactic background has , on the other hand , a flat spatial distribution , and dominates at very large latitudes .
intermediate and moderately large latitudes ( @xmath85 ) are thus the most promising portion of the sky for the search of a diffuse emission induced by galactic dm
. fits to the pamela positron excess require sources with a rather hard spectrum .
the preferred dm - related interpretation is a scenario with prompt emission of leptonic final states ; we have discussed in detail three sample benchmark cases , namely emission of monochromatic @xmath4 , the case of @xmath86 yields , giving a shallower @xmath4 spectrum , and the channel @xmath87 as final state of annihilation / decay .
we have disregarded wimp models with annihilation channels producing soft spectra , like quark - antiquark pairs , and with weak gauge boson final states , which would overproduce cosmic - ray antiprotons @xcite .
we find that for all the benchmark models , after tuning the source rate to match the level of the pamela positron excess , the dm - induced @xmath1-ray flux becomes comparable to the background at energies @xmath64 gev . in case of pairs annihilation into monochromatic @xmath4 or into @xmath87 , @xmath1-rays arises from ic scattering of the propagating @xmath4 and fsr processes at emission ; the scenario is detectable for sufficiently heavy dm candidates ( @xmath88 gev ; the pamela positron data require @xmath89 gev ) . in the case of a dm candidate annihilating into @xmath31 with a mass of few hundreds of gev , as required by the pamela excess without violating act constraints
, the detectable @xmath1-ray component is due to the emission from @xmath53-decays , which peaks at , roughly , one - third of the dm mass .
these conclusions can be straightforwardly extended to a decaying dm scenario : the mass scale just needs to be doubled and the decay rate properly adjusted . in case of a dm candidate annihilating into a new light particle which in turn decays into leptons , the fsr is generally reduced ( depending on the model ) .
the total emission can be thus mildly reduced with respect to an analogous wimp case , but remains still sizable .
( dotted ) , dm@xmath33 ( dashed ) , and dm@xmath3 ( dashed - dotted ) .
_ left panel _ : spectrum at mid - high latitudes ( @xmath90 ) integrated over longitudes @xmath52 . _
right panel _ : latitudinal profile at `` small '' longitude ( @xmath91 ) and at frequency @xmath92 ghz . ]
( dotted ) , dm@xmath33 ( dashed ) , and dm@xmath3 ( dashed - dotted ) .
_ left panel _ : spectrum at mid - high latitudes ( @xmath90 ) integrated over longitudes @xmath52 . _ right panel _ : latitudinal profile at `` small '' longitude ( @xmath91 ) and at frequency @xmath92 ghz . ]
the statement regarding the detectability of the induced galactic diffuse @xmath1-ray flux has a marginal dependence on the model implemented to describe the propagation of charged particles in the galaxy .
we introduce a locally self - consistent picture , implementing for @xmath4 ( as well as for primary cr protons and all other relevant components ) a transport equation with propagation parameters tuned to reproduce the lis of cosmic rays .
in particular , being mostly sensitive to the picture at gev to tev energies , we fit propagation parameters to b / c data at @xmath93 gev .
we consider as a reference model the `` conventional '' model introduced by the galprop collaboration @xcite .
we then discuss the variation of the vertical profiles of cr and dm - induced electrons and of the associated diffuse emissions by changing the halo boundaries of propagation , introducing an advection term , modifying the spectral index for diffusion , and considering a spatially varying diffusion coefficient .
we have found that the signal to background ratio is enhanced if the halo boundaries in the @xmath19-direction are extended with respect to the `` conventional '' case ( @xmath66 kpc ) , and reduced if they are restricted .
the latter possibility is , however , disfavoured by cr data .
for all the other propagation models , the detection prospects are analogous to the `` conventional '' case .
we have also discussed the possibility of detecting radiative emissions at other wavelengths . in the radio and infrared bands ,
the synchrotron component associated to a scenario in which dm injects a very hard @xmath94 spectrum ( like , e.g. , a wimp with a large branching ratio of annihilation into @xmath4 ) is expected to be a significant component of the synchrotron diffuse emission of the galaxy at few hundreds of ghz .
this frequency range can be probed by the forthcoming planck mission . on the other hand , this picture is strongly constrained by the fermi data on @xmath94 , and the detection prospects at radio frequencies are , typically , less favourable than in the @xmath1-ray band . for the class of dm candidates explaining the raise in the positron fraction ,
the x - ray energy band is even less favourable , being the ic spectrum induced by dm harder than the one associated to crs . to conclude
, we have found that the dm interpretation of the pamela positron excess can be tested by the fermi lat telescope in the diffuse emission at mid - latitudes and high energy . in the case of a dm candidate injecting a very hard @xmath4 yield ,
the signal is given by the ic + fsr emission .
the case of a dm candidate with a sizable and hard @xmath1-ray yield from @xmath53-decay ( like the case of @xmath86 as final state of annihilation / decay ) , can be even more easily tested . a crucial ingredient for
the discussion is the different spatial profile for the cr primary sources ( confined to the disc ) and of dark matter induced components ( spherical distribution ) .
the two terms can be disentangled looking at the angular profile of the diffuse emission , with the optimal region to single out the dm component being at intermediate latitudes
. such cross - correlation test of the pamela excess would then be performed by focusing on a nearby portion of the galaxy , where the extrapolation on the dm density profile as well as on the propagation model parameters ( from the locally - measured cr spectra ) can be regarded as rather robust .
indeed , would fermi discover an extra @xmath1-ray term , with the spectral and angular features matching the features we discussed for the dm source , this would be a solid step towards the identification of the dm component of the universe . in turn
, would fermi find that the @xmath1-ray diffusion emission is instead in agreement with the prediction from standard cr components only , tight constraints on the dm interpretation of the pamela positron excess would follow . on the other hand , such picture would not be in contradiction with other scenarios addressing the pamela excess .
if the additional @xmath4 sources have a spatial distribution analogous to the standard cr source distribution , such as , e.g. , in the case of pulsars or secondary production inside cr sources , it will be very hard to single out the associated galactic diffuse emission .
indeed , it would be , typically , subdominant and with a signal to background ratio at the same level in any portion of the sky ; hence , a different strategy would be needed to cross - check these interpretations of the pamela positron excess .
m.r . acknowledges funding by , and the facilities of , the centre for high performance computing , cape town .
s. torii _ et al . _ [ ppb - bets collaboration ] , arxiv:0809.0760 [ astro - ph ] .
s. w. barwick _ et al .
_ [ heat collaboration ] , astrophys .
j. * 482 * ( 1997 ) l191 [ arxiv : astro - ph/9703192 ] . j. alcaraz _ et al . _ [ ams collaboration ] , phys .
b * 484 * ( 2000 ) 10 [ erratum - ibid .
b * 495 * ( 2000 ) 440 ] .
m. aguilar _ et al .
_ [ ams-01 collaboration ] , phys .
b * 646 * ( 2007 ) 145 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0703154 ] .
f. a. aharonian , a. m. atoyan , and h. j. voelk , astron . & astrophys .
* 294 * ( 1995 ) l41 .
p. blasi , arxiv:0903.2794 [ astro-ph.he ] .
s. rudaz and f. w. stecker , astrophys .
j. * 325 * ( 1988 ) 16 . j. r. ellis , r. a. flores , k. freese , s. ritz , d. seckel and j. silk , phys .
b * 214 * ( 1988 ) 403 .
m. kamionkowski and m. s. turner , phys .
d * 43 * ( 1991 ) 1774 .
m. cirelli , m. kadastik , m. raidal and a. strumia , nucl .
b * 813 * ( 2009 ) 1 [ arxiv:0809.2409 [ hep - ph ] ] .
d. p. finkbeiner , arxiv : astro - ph/0409027 .
d. hooper , d. p. finkbeiner and g. dobler , phys . rev .
d * 76 * ( 2007 ) 083012 [ arxiv:0705.3655 [ astro - ph ] ] .
g. dobler and d. p. finkbeiner , astrophys .
j. * 680 * ( 2008 ) 1222 [ arxiv:0712.1038 [ astro - ph ] ] .
d. t. cumberbatch , j. zuntz , h. k. k. eriksen and j. silk , arxiv:0902.0039 [ astro-ph.ga ] . s. d. hunter _
et al . _ ,
astrophys .
j. * 481 * ( 1997 ) 205 .
a. w. strong , i. v. moskalenko and o. reimer , astrophys .
j. * 613 * ( 2004 ) 962 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0406254 ] .
talks at entapp dark matter workshop 2009 by i. v. moskalenko and a. w. strong .
transparencies at http://indico.cern.ch/conferencedisplay.py?confid=44160 t. a. porter , i. v. moskalenko , a. w. strong , e. orlando and l. bouchet , astrophys .
j. * 682 * ( 2008 ) 400 [ arxiv:0804.1774 [ astro - ph ] ] .
a. a. abdo _ et al .
_ , arxiv:0805.0417 [ astro - ph ] . s. casanova and b. l. dingus , astropart . phys .
* 29 * ( 2008 ) 63 [ arxiv:0711.2753 [ astro - ph ] ] .
i. cholis , g. dobler , d. p. finkbeiner , l. goodenough and n. weiner , arxiv:0811.3641 [ astro - ph ] . j. zhang , x. j. bi , j. liu , s. m. liu , p. f. yin , q. yuan and s. h. zhu , arxiv:0812.0522 [ astro - ph ] .
e. borriello , a. cuoco and g. miele , arxiv:0903.1852 [ astro-ph.ga ] . v. barger , y. gao , w. y. keung , d. marfatia and g. shaughnessy , arxiv:0904.2001 [ hep - ph ] . m. kawasaki , k. kohri and k. nakayama , arxiv:0904.3626 [ astro-ph.co ] . m. cirelli and p. panci , arxiv:0904.3830 [ astro-ph.co ] .
berezinskii , v. s. , bulanov , s. v. , dogiel , v. a. , and ptuskin , v. s. , 1990 , amsterdam : north - holland , 1990 , edited by ginzburg , v.l . , a. w. strong and i. v. moskalenko , astrophys .
j. * 509 * ( 1998 ) 212 [ arxiv : astro - ph/9807150 ] .
p. gondolo , j. edsjo , p. ullio , l. bergstrom , m. schelke and e. a. baltz , jcap * 0407 * ( 2004 ) 008 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0406204 ] .
a. w. strong , i. v. moskalenko and v. s. ptuskin , ann .
nucl . part .
sci . * 57 * ( 2007 ) 285 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0701517 ] .
d. maurin , f. donato , r. taillet and p. salati , astrophys .
j. * 555 * ( 2001 ) 585 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0101231 ] . m. simet and d. hooper , arxiv:0904.2398 [ astro-ph.he ] .
gleeson , l. j. , and axford , w. i. , astrophys .
j. * 154 * ( 1968 ) 1011 f. donato , d. maurin and r. taillet , astron .
astrophys .
* 381 * ( 2002 ) 539 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0108079 ] . s. veilleux , g. cecil and j. bland - hawthorn , ann .
astron . astrophys .
* 43 * ( 2005 ) 769 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0504435 ] .
everett , j. e. , zweibel , e. g. , benjamin , r. a. , mccammon , d. , rocks , l. , and gallagher , j. s. , astrophys .
j. * 674 * ( 2008 ) 258 arxiv:0710.3712 [ astro - ph ] .
d. breitschwerdt , v. a. dogiel and h. j. volk , astron .
astrophys . 385:216 ( 2002 )
[ arxiv : astro - ph/0201345 ] .
ptuskin , v. s. , voelk , h. j. , zirakashvili , v. n. , and breitschwerdt , d. astron .
astrophys . 321:434 ( 1997 )
j. w. armstrong , b. j. rickett and s. r. spangler , astrophys . j. * 443 * ( 1995 ) 209 . c. evoli , d. gaggero , d. grasso and l. maccione , jcap * 0810 * ( 2008 ) 018 [ arxiv:0807.4730 [ astro - ph ] ] . v. s. ptuskin , i. v. moskalenko , f. c. jones , a. w. strong and v. n. zirakashvili , astrophys . j. * 642 * ( 2006 ) 902 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0510335 ] .
h. s. ahn _
et al . _ ,
astropart .
* 30 * ( 2008 ) 133 [ arxiv:0808.1718 [ astro - ph ] ] .
a. d. panov _ et al .
_ , arxiv:0707.4415 [ astro - ph ] .
engelmann , j. j. , ferrando , p. , soutoul , a. , goret , p. , and juliusson , e. astron .
astrophys . * 233 * ( 1990 ) 96 t. a. porter , i. v. moskalenko and a. w. strong , astrophys . j. * 648 * ( 2006 ) l29 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0607344 ] .
j. l. han , r. n. manchester , a. g. lyne , g. j. qiao and w. van straten , astrophys .
j. * 642 * ( 2006 ) 868 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0601357 ] .
j. c. brown _ et al .
_ , arxiv:0704.0458 [ astro - ph ] .
r. beck , arxiv:0810.2923 [ astro - ph ] , r. beck , arxiv:0812.4925 [ astro - ph ] . c. heiles and r. crutcher , arxiv : astro - ph/0501550 .
m. a. miville - deschenes , n. ysard , a. lavabre , n. ponthieu , j. f. macias - perez , j. aumont and j. p. bernard , arxiv:0802.3345 [ astro - ph ] . f. aharonian [ hess collaboration ] , astron .
astrophys .
* 464 * ( 2007 ) 235 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0611813 ] .
d. r. lorimer , arxiv : astro - ph/0308501 . k. m. ferriere , rev .
* 73 * ( 2001 ) 1031 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0106359 ] .
r. blandford and d. eichler , phys .
* 154 * ( 1987 ) 1 .
t. kobayashi , y. komori , k. yoshida and j. nishimura , astrophys .
j. * 601 * ( 2004 ) 340 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0308470 ] .
a. a. abdo _ et al .
_ [ the fermi lat collaboration ] , phys .
* 102 * ( 2009 ) 181101 [ arxiv:0905.0025 [ astro-ph.he ] ] . f. aharonian _ et al .
_ [ h.e.s.s .
collaboration ] , phys .
* 101 * ( 2008 ) 261104 [ arxiv:0811.3894 [ astro - ph ] ] .
a. w. strong , i. v. moskalenko and o. reimer , astrophys . j. * 537 * ( 2000 ) 763 [ erratum - ibid .
* 541 * ( 2000 ) 1109 ] [ arxiv : astro - ph/9811296 ] .
m. pohl and j. a. esposito , arxiv : astro - ph/9806160 .
f. yin , q. yuan , j. liu , j. zhang , x. j. bi and s. h. zhu , phys .
d * 79 * ( 2009 ) 023512 [ arxiv:0811.0176 [ hep - ph ] ] . c. r. chen , m. m. nojiri , f. takahashi and t. t. yanagida , arxiv:0811.3357 [ astro - ph ] .
a. ibarra and d. tran , jcap * 0902 * ( 2009 ) 021 [ arxiv:0811.1555 [ hep - ph ] ] .
e. nardi , f. sannino and a. strumia , jcap * 0901 * ( 2009 ) 043 [ arxiv:0811.4153 [ hep - ph ] ] .
g. bertone , m. cirelli , a. strumia and m. taoso , jcap * 0903 * ( 2009 ) 009 [ arxiv:0811.3744 [ astro - ph ] ] .
a. burkert , iau symp .
* 171 * ( 1996 ) 175 [ astrophys .
j. * 447 * ( 1995 ) l25 ] [ arxiv : astro - ph/9504041 ] .
j. edsjo , m. schelke and p. ullio , jcap * 0409 * ( 2004 ) 004 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0405414 ] .
m. kuhlen , j. diemand and p. madau , arxiv:0805.4416 [ astro - ph ] .
l. bergstrom , t. bringmann , m. eriksson and m. gustafsson , phys .
* 94 * ( 2005 ) 131301 , [ arxiv : astro - ph/0410359 ] .
a. birkedal , k. t. matchev , m. perelstein and a. spray , arxiv : hep - ph/0507194 . l. bergstrom , g. bertone , t. bringmann , j. edsjo and m. taoso , arxiv:0812.3895 [ astro - ph ] . m. regis and p. ullio , phys . rev .
d * 78 * ( 2008 ) 043505 [ arxiv:0802.0234 [ hep - ph ] ] .
r. essig , n. sehgal and l. e. strigari , arxiv:0902.4750 [ hep - ph ] .
a. a. abdo _ et al .
_ [ fermi lat collaboration ] , arxiv:0902.1559 [ astro-ph.he ] .
p. ullio , l. bergstrom , j. edsjo and c. g. lacey , phys .
d * 66 * ( 2002 ) 123502 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0207125 ] .
j. r. primack , r. s. somerville , j. s. bullock and j. e. g. devriendt , aip conf .
* 558 * ( 2001 ) 463 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0011475 ] .
a. a. abdo _ et al .
_ [ fermi lat collaboration ] , arxiv:0812.2960 [ astro - ph ] . w. b. atwood _ et al . _
[ lat collaboration ] , arxiv:0902.1089 [ astro-ph.im ] .
haslam , c. g. t. , salter , c. j. , stoffel , h. , & wilson , w. e. 1982 , a&as , 47 , 1 b. gold _ et al .
_ [ wmap collaboration ] , arxiv:0803.0715 [ astro - ph ] .
l. bouchet , e. jourdain , j. p. roques , a. strong , r. diehl , f. lebrun and r. terrier , arxiv:0801.2086 [ astro - ph ] . a. w. strong , h. bloemen , r. diehl , w. hermsen and v. schoenfelder , astrophys .
commun . * 39 * ( 1999 ) 209 [ arxiv : astro - ph/9811211 ] .
s. ando , e. komatsu , t. narumoto and t. totani , phys .
d * 75 * ( 2007 ) 063519 [ arxiv : astro - ph/0612467 ] . l. pieri , g. bertone and e. branchini , mon . not .
* 384 * ( 2008 ) 1627 [ arxiv:0706.2101 [ astro - ph ] ] .
j. i. read , g. lake , o. agertz and v. p. debattista , arxiv:0803.2714 [ astro - ph ] .
f. donato , d. maurin , p. brun , t. delahaye and p. salati , phys .
* 102 * ( 2009 ) 071301 [ arxiv:0810.5292 [ astro - ph ] ] . | we propose to test the dark matter ( dm ) interpretation of the positron excess observed by the pamela cosmic - ray ( cr ) detector through the identification of a galactic diffuse gamma - ray component associated to dm - induced prompt and radiative emission .
the goal is to present an analysis based on minimal sets of assumptions and extrapolations with respect to locally testable or measurable quantities .
we discuss the differences between the spatial and spectral features for the dm - induced components ( with an extended , possibly spherical , source function ) and those for the standard cr contribution ( with sources confined within the stellar disc ) , and propose to focus on intermediate and large latitudes .
we address the dependence of the signal to background ratio on the model adopted to describe the propagation of charged crs in the galaxy , and find that , in general , the dm - induced signal can be detected by the fermi gamma - ray space telescope at energies above 100 gev . an observational result in agreement with the prediction from standard
cr components only , would imply very strong constraints on the dm interpretation of the pamela excess . on the other hand ,
if an excess in the diffuse emission above 100 gev is identified , the angular profile for such emission would allow for a clean disentanglement between the dm interpretation and astrophysical explanations proposed for the pamela excess .
we also compare to the radiative diffuse emission at lower frequencies , sketching in particular the detection prospects at infrared frequencies with the planck satellite . |
the hope to develop a quantum information processing machine has made a strong impact in several distinct branches of science , e.g. , in theoretical and experimental quantum physics , in computer science , and in electrical and chemical engineering .
to succeed , it is essential to achieve high - precision quantum transformations , which so far are hindered by two problems : decoherence ( see @xcite for notation ) and gate control .
while the former can be solved to some extend by proposing new types of less fragile qubits , or implementing decoherence free subspaces @xcite , the solution to the latter could be the use of adiabatic transformations @xcite .
such transformations have the advantage that they can be surprisingly robust to various errors of experimental parameters .
this robustness of adiabatic gates , however , comes at the price of a significantly longer gate time , therefore giving the environment more time to destroy coherence . for this reason ,
it is important to understand the interplay of adiabaticity and decoherence , which was studied in several publications in connection to berry s phase @xcite . in these
, the authors usually postulated a markovian master equation of lindblad form .
however , microscopic derivations of master equations show that its structure crucially depends on the hamiltonian of the system .
therefore , the time dependence of the hamiltonian should be explicitly taken into account when deriving a master equation .
this approach was already taken , e.g. , in refs .
@xcite which studied the pumped charge in a cooper pair sluice , as well as in ref .
@xcite and ref .
@xcite which studied hysteresis in molecular magnets and entanglement of two spin molecules , respectively . in this paper
we are interested both in general properties of decoherence in adiabatic systems as well as in the concrete problem of cooper pair pumping .
we also discuss the applicability of the secular approximation and show that it leads to an incorrect pumped charge despite the fact that this approximation is very well justified if one is interested in the quantum state ( density matrix ) of the system .
we wish to point out that there are two distinct notions of adiabaticity .
first , in the quantum literature one speaks of adiabatic behavior if a closed system approximately follows the instantaneous eigenstates of the hamiltonian @xmath0 , i.e. @xmath1 with @xmath2 .
second , in the thermodynamical literature adiabaticity means that the system follows the instantaneous thermal equilibrium state @xmath3 $ ] , where @xmath4 is the temperature of the environment .
while both situations require a slow change of the hamiltonian , in the quantum case the time scale is set by the eigenfrequencies of the hamiltonian , whereas in the thermodynamic case the energy relaxation time @xmath5 ( often referred to as @xmath6 in the context of qubits ) is the appropriate time scale .
a master equation describing an adiabatically steered quantum system which is coupled to a thermal bath should therefore recover the thermodynamical adiabatic behavior in the respective limit . if @xmath5 is much longer than the period @xmath7 of a cyclically time
dependent hamiltonian , then one would expect that in the quantum adiabatic limit , the system approximately follows a mixture of the instantaneous eigenstates @xmath8 ( or more precisely of floquet states @xcite ) .
after a transient period the coefficients @xmath9 approach constant values @xmath10 which depend on some sort of time averaged level splittings of the hamiltonian as well as on the temperature @xmath4 of the environment .
this is the limit which was described in ref .
@xcite .
however , in the other limit , @xmath11 , one expects that after some transient time the system follows the instantaneous thermal state .
the coefficients then satisfy @xmath12 $ ] and hence cyclically depend on time .
our work represents an extension of ref .
@xcite as both limits as well as the crossover between them can be described by our master equations eq .
( [ lindblad ] ) and eq .
( [ nonlindblad ] ) . in section [ secflo ]
we introduce the floquet formalism for cyclic hamiltonians .
we then modify the formalism to separate the fast dynamics which arise from the energy splitting of the hamiltonian from the slow dynamics which are due to the adiabatic time dependence of the hamiltonian .
this procedure directly points to an approximation suitable for adiabatically driven , markovian open quantum systems , which results in a lindblad type master equation , but with time
dependent lindblad operators .
we find that decoherence is best described in the basis of the time
dependent floquet states in the sense that in this basis one can differentiate between dephasing ( the environmental influence on the off
diagonal elements of the density operator ) and relaxation ( diagonal elements ) .
the decoherence rates generally depend on time to guarantee that in the thermodynamical adiabatic limit the system follows the instantaneous thermal state .
it follows that a system coupled to a zero temperature environment does not relax into the instantaneous ground state of the hamiltonian , but into the slightly different floquet ground state .
we apply our theory in two simple examples . in one of these examples , the problem of cooper pair pumping ,
the measurable observable is the transferred ( pumped ) charge .
we show that although the lindblad master equation leads to a very good approximation for the density matrix of the system , it predicts a completely wrong transferred charge . to rectify the problem we refrain from the secular approximation and obtain a suitable master equation which is not of lindblad form .
in this section , we first present some well known results of the floquet theory @xcite .
we then modify this theory to allow for a separation of fast oscillations due to the energy of the states from the slow oscillations due to the periodic nature of the hamiltonian . for a time
periodic hamiltonian @xmath13 there exist solutions of the schrdinger equation of the form @xmath14 where the floquet modes @xmath15 have the same period as the hamiltonian , and @xmath16 are the quasi energies .
the quasi energies are only uniquely defined up to multiples of @xmath17 with @xmath18 , because @xmath19 for all @xmath20 correspond to the same floquet mode but with a shifted energy .
[ [ adiabatic - floquet - theory . ] ] * adiabatic floquet theory . * + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + for our purposes , it is advantageous to separate the fast dynamics associated with the instantaneous eigenfrequencies of the hamiltonian from the slow dynamics associated with the time dependence of @xmath0 .
such a separation is not provided by eq .
( [ 1 ] ) because the phase factors in eq . ( [ 1 ] ) oscillate with constant frequencies @xmath16 .
therefore , if the eigenfrequencies depend on time , as is generally the case , the floquet modes @xmath21 also oscillate rapidly .
a more convenient representation is provided by the states @xmath22 , which differ from the floquet modes only by a time dependent phase factor : @xmath23 here , @xmath24 is the instantaneous energy of the floquet mode , and @xmath25 is chosen such that the states @xmath26 are periodic in time .
in fact , it can be easily shown that @xmath27 is the non - adiabatic geometric phase ( aharonov anandan phase ) @xcite associated with the state @xmath22 .
note that the ambiguity in the quasi energies of the original floquet states is non existent in the modified floquet states .
therefore , we can now speak of a well defined floquet ground state and floquet excited states .
although the concept of a floquet ground state is not very meaningful if the driving is fast , for adiabatic driving it will turn out to have the same importance as the energy ground state for non driven systems .
indeed , the floquet ground state approaches the instantaneous ground state in limit of @xmath28 . in the adiabatic limit
, a system prepared in an energy eigenstate will stay in the respective instantaneous eigenstate . because the eigenstates are cyclic
, they are identical to the modified floquet states in a zeroth order adiabatic approximation . therefore , if the time evolution is adiabatic , the following approximations are valid @xmath29 here , @xmath30 and @xmath31 are the instantaneous eigenstates and energies of the hamiltonian , respectively , @xmath32 is the adiabatic geometric phase ( berry phase ) , and @xmath33 is the adiabatic parameter .
these modified floquet modes have the useful property to vary only slowly in time , such that the expansion @xmath34 can be restricted to @xmath35 .
this property will turn out to be useful in the derivation of a master equation .
[ [ superadiabatic - expansion . ] ] * superadiabatic expansion .
* + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + later on we will find that the system decoheres into the floquet states .
that is why we want to have a closer look at the relation of the floquet states to the instantaneous energy eigenstates .
the statement that an adiabatically evolving system follows the instantaneous eigenstates of the hamiltonian @xmath0 is only correct to zeroth order of the adiabatic parameter .
it is well known @xcite that if the hamiltonian is an analytic function in time , then the system follows more closely the eigenstates of the operator @xmath36 where we omitted the time dependence of the operators for shorter notation and used a dot to indicate the time derivative .
the operator @xmath37 is defined by @xmath38 .
similarly , @xmath39 is defined by @xmath40 , where @xmath41 are the eigenvectors of the transformed hamiltonian @xmath42 . the first term in eq .
( [ superad ] ) is of zeroth order in the adiabatic parameter , the second of first order , and so on .
one should note that for any given adiabatic parameter , the series eq .
( [ superad ] ) does not ( except for some special cases ) converge @xcite .
the smaller the adiabatic parameter , the longer the series improves before it starts to diverge .
if the series does converge , then the system will exactly follow the eigenstates of @xmath43 which are then the exact floquet states .
even if the series does not converge , in an approximation which improves exponentially with the adiabatic parameter , one can use the first few summands of eq .
( [ superad ] ) to obtain the floquet states .
thus , by using the floquet modes our theory implicitely takes into account terms of higher order in the adiabatic parameter .
in this section , we derive a master equation in the modified floquet basis . some properties of this basis
will lead to approximations which are appropriate for adiabatically evolving systems .
we assume that the total system evolves under the influence of the hamiltonian @xmath44 where @xmath45 and @xmath46 are the hamiltonians of the system of interest and the environment , respectively , and @xmath47 is their coupling with @xmath48 acting on the hilbert space of the system of interest and @xmath49 acting on the environments hilbert space .
we assume an initially uncorrelated state @xmath50 where @xmath51 describes the thermal equilibrium of the environment . without loss of generality
we assume tr@xmath52 , and using the born - markov approximation we arrive at the well known interaction picture master equation @xcite @xmath53 \label{7}\\ & & \times \left [ a(t\!-\!\tau)\rho_a(t)a(t)-a(t)a(t\!-\!\tau)\rho_a(t ) \right ] + c.c . , { \nonumber}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath54 and @xmath55 denote operators in the interaction picture .
we note that the unitary evolution operator used to transform @xmath48 into the interaction picture may be written conveniently as @xmath56 where we introduce the notation @xmath57 .
we use this form of the evolution operator to write @xmath58}a_{\alpha\alpha',k } { \left|{\phi_{\alpha}}\right\rangle}\!{\left\langle{\phi_{\alpha'}}\right| } , { \nonumber}\\ \label{9 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we used the fourier expansion @xmath59 as well as @xmath60 for most purposes , the angular frequencies @xmath61 $ ] may be approximated by the instantaneous transition frequencies .
we now substitute eq .
( [ 9 ] ) into eq .
( [ 7 ] ) to find the bloch - redfield type equation @xmath62 a_{\alpha\alpha',k}a_{\beta'\beta , l } { \nonumber}\\ & \!\times\ ! & e^{i\!\int_0^t dt'[\omega_{\beta\beta'}(t')-\omega_{\alpha\alpha'}(t ' ) - ( k+l)\omega ] } { \nonumber}\\ & \!\times\ ! & \left [ { \left|{\phi_\alpha}\right\rangle}\!{\left\langle{\phi_{\alpha'}}\right| } \rho_a(t){\left|{\phi_{\beta'}}\right\rangle}\!{\left\langle{\phi_{\beta}}\right| } \right.{\nonumber}\\ & & \left .
-{\left|{\phi_{\beta'}}\right\rangle}\!{\left\langle\left.{\phi_\beta}\right|{\phi_\alpha}\right\rangle}\!{\left\langle{\phi_{\alpha'}}\right|}\rho_a(t ) \right ] { \nonumber}\\ & \!+\ ! & \rm{c.c .
} , \label{12 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we define the one - sided fourier ( laplace ) transform of the environment correlation function @xmath63 & \!\!=\!\ ! & \int_0^\infty\!\ !
d\tau\ , e^{i\!\int_{t-\tau}^t\!\!\ !
dt ' [ \omega_{\!\alpha\alpha'}(t')+k\omega ] } { \rm{tr}}_b\![b(\tau)b\rho_b ] { \nonumber}\\ & \!\!\approx\!\ ! & \int_0^\infty\!\ !
d\tau\ , e^{i [ \omega_{\!\alpha\alpha'}(t)+k\omega]\tau } { \rm{tr}}_b\![b(\tau)b\rho_b ] .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] the latter form , which is more familiar from the theory of time independent systems , is valid if the eigenenergies do not change much on the time scale set by the correlation time of the environment . using the standard floquet modes , the master equation ( [ 12 ] ) was also derived in the review of grifoni and hnggi @xcite , and served as the starting equation in @xcite , where the authors proceeded by performing two rotating wave approximations ( rwa ) .
the first rwa is to neglect terms with @xmath64 , and the second one is to keep only terms with @xmath65 .
the first rwa is valid , if @xmath66 can be considered as fast rotating .
in particular for adiabatically evolving systems this might not always be the case , and therefore , we do not use this rwa in the following .
we perform an approximation which is particularly suitable for adiabatic driving , namely @xmath67 .
the requirement of a sufficiently smooth correlation function @xmath68 is satisfied if the modified floquet modes change slowly compared to the environment correlation time .
to arrive at a master equation of lindblad form and to guarantee complete positivity , we have to perform the second above described rwa , usually referred to as the secular approximation ( although , as we will see later , there are some instances where the secular approximation leads to erroneous results and one has to forego complete positivity _ at all times _ ) . noting that in general a rwa is valid
if the exponential in the neglected term is rotating fast , we recognize from eq .
( [ 12 ] ) that this rwa requires that @xmath69 is not of the same order as @xmath70
. this can only be guaranteed if the hamiltonian is varied adiabatically , and if the expansion in eq . ( [ 5 ] ) can indeed be restricted to only small values of @xmath71 .
therefore , the use of the modified floquet modes introduced in this paper is essential for this rwa to be valid , even in the adiabatic regime assumed here . noting that @xmath72 vanishes
unless @xmath73 is much smaller than the transition frequency @xmath74 , we proceed by neglecting all terms of eq .
( [ 12 ] ) with @xmath75 . using @xmath76 and transforming back into the schrdinger picture , eq .
( [ 12 ] ) becomes @xmath77 { \nonumber}\\ & \!+\ ! & \gamma(0)\left [ l_{0}(t)\rho_a(t)l^\dag_{0}(t)-\frac12 \left\{l^\dag_{0}(t)l_{0}(t),\rho_a(t)\right\ } \right ] { \nonumber}\\ & \!+\ ! & \sum_{\alpha\neq\beta } \gamma[\omega_{\alpha\beta}(t ) ] { \nonumber}\\ & \!\times\ ! & \left [ l_{\alpha\beta}(t)\rho_a(t)l^\dag_{\alpha\beta}(t)-\frac12 \left\ { l^\dag_{\alpha\beta}(t)l_{\alpha\beta}(t),\rho_a(t)\right\ } \right]\!. { \nonumber}\\ \label{lindblad } \end{aligned}\ ] ] with the lindblad operators @xmath78 while the operator @xmath79 causes pure dephasing ( i.e. it does not change the populations of the floquet modes ) , the operators @xmath80 are responsible for energy relaxation .
we further separated the imaginary and real part of the laplace transformed environment correlation function @xmath81 and found the lamb shift contribution to the hamiltonian @xmath82 |\!{\left\langle{\phi_\alpha(t)}\right|}a{\left|{\phi_\beta(t)}\right\rangle}\!|^2 { \left|{\phi_\beta(t)}\right\rangle}\!{\left\langle{\phi_\beta(t)}\right| } $ ] to be diagonal in the floquet basis .
thus , taking into account the explicit time dependence of the hamiltonian , we showed that the system does not decohere into the instantaneous eigenstates , but into the floquet states , a result previously obtained by @xcite .
the two bases are equal in the adiabatic limit , but they differ for finite periods @xmath7 as according to eq .
( [ superad ] ) the floquet states implicitly include higher order adiabatic contributions . while @xcite uses rates which are averaged over one period , we take into account the rates @xmath83|\!{\left\langle{\phi_\alpha(t)}\right|}a{\left|{\phi_\beta(t)}\right\rangle}\!|^2 $ ] at each instant of time , which might be important in particular for adiabatic driving . on the other hand
, the time dependent rates were already obtained in @xcite , where the authors assumed an infinite period @xmath28 and hence found that the system relaxes into a mixture of instantaneous energy eigenstates .
therefore , our theory generalizes previous works and reduces to the known results in the respective limits . because of the time dependent rates of eq .
( [ lindblad ] ) , we can not expect to find a steady state in the floquet basis .
nevertheless , there is a quasi stationary state @xmath84 with vanishing off - diagonals in the floquet basis .
if the temperature of the environment is zero , i.e. @xmath85 , then the system evolves into the floquet ground state . in the application of our theory to cooper pair pumping ,
we are advised by the well known fact @xcite that the use of the secular approximation may lead to an error in the transferred charge , despite the fact that it leads to a very good approximation of the actual density operator ( as explained in subsection [ cpp ] ) .
therefore , we provide here the schrdinger picture master equation obtained without the secular approximation .
this master equation follows from eq .
( [ 12 ] ) with @xmath67 .
thus we obtain @xmath86 + k(t)\rho_a(t)a^\dag + a\rho_a(t)k^\dag(t ) { \nonumber}\\ & & - a^\dag k(t)\rho_a(t ) - \rho_a(t)k^\dag(t ) a \label{14a } \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath87 { \left\langle{\phi_\alpha(t)}\right|}a{\left|{\phi_{\alpha'}(t)}\right\rangle } { \left|{\phi_{\alpha}(t)}\right\rangle}\!{\left\langle{\phi_{\alpha'}(t)}\right|}. { \nonumber}\\ \end{aligned}\ ] ] this master equation includes the cross - coupling between diagonals and off - diagonals of the density operator . in what follows we will use both , eq . ( [ lindblad ] ) and eq . ( [ 14a ] ) , depending on the situation .
in this section we illustrate our theory with some simple examples of two - level systems , which could potentially be tested in experiments . in the first
, the floquet states can be found analytically .
it serves to demonstrate the time dependence of the energy relaxation and dephasing rates , as well as the relaxation into the floquet ground state at zero temperature .
the second example is slightly more complex as it has a time dependent level splitting .
therefore , it exhibits a quasi stationary state where the populations in the floquet basis depend on time .
we consider the hamiltonian @xmath88 { \nonumber}\\ & \hat= & \frac12 \left(\begin{array}{cc } b_\| & b_\bot e^{-i\omega t } \\
b_\bot e^{i\omega t } & -b_\| \end{array}\right ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the matrix form is written in the basis @xmath89 of eigenvectors of @xmath90 .
the adiabatic parameter is easily obtained to be @xmath91 .
this hamiltonian describes , for example , a spin in a magnetic field which rotates around the z - axis .
because the eigenvalues of the hamiltonian do not depend on time , the modified floquet states equal the traditional floquet states : @xmath92 with real @xmath93 and @xmath94 satisfying @xmath95 \quad \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath96 .
the corresponding floquet energies are given by @xmath97 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and are equal to @xmath98 .
during one adiabatic cycle .
the damping @xmath99=0.7~\omega\hbar^2 $ ] is strong compared to the period @xmath7 , such that the quasi stationary state is closely approached within one period . in panel ( b )
the damping @xmath99=0.07~\omega\hbar^2 $ ] is weak such that the quasi stationary state is only reached after many periods . while black lines shows the populations of the floquet excited state @xmath100 , blue lines are the populations of the state @xmath101 .
the gray dashed line is the population of @xmath101 if the system would be in the instantaneous ground state .
parameters are chosen as @xmath102 , @xmath103 , and temperature @xmath104 ( solid ) , 5 @xmath105 ( dashed ) , 10 @xmath105 ( dotted ) .
the adiabatic parameter is @xmath106 .
[ fig1 ] ] we assume a coupling of the system to the environment via @xmath107 , which could be a fluctuating external magnetic field in x - direction . therefore , we find the lindblad operators in the schrdinger picture from eq .
( [ l ] ) with @xmath108 @xmath109 we see that there are times when dephasing is the dominant decoherence effect ( @xmath79 ) , and times when relaxation ( @xmath110 ) is dominant . in fig .
[ fig1 ] , we show results of the numerical integration of the master equation for an initial state @xmath111 . in panel
( a ) , the coupling to the environment is strong enough to force a thermal mixture of the floquet ground and excited states within one period @xmath7 , while in panel ( b ) , several periods are needed for the system to evolve into the thermal mixture .
the populations of the floquet states approach a constant in the long time limit because the level splitting of the hamiltonian does not depend on time .
the time dependence of the relaxation rate is noticeable in both panels . at zero temperature ,
the system relaxes into the floquet ground state @xmath112 , rather than into the instantaneous ground state of the hamiltonian .
note that if the time dependence of the hamiltonian were not explicitly taken into account in the derivation of the master equation , one would find that the system relaxes into the instantaneous ground state of the hamiltonian .
because the two states have slightly different populations of the state @xmath113 ( the solid blue line does not approach the gray dashed line in the limit @xmath114 ) , the importance of taking into account the time dependence of the hamiltonian can be tested experimentally by measuring @xmath90 after a sufficiently long time .
this effect scales linearly with the adiabatic parameter ( see section [ secflo ] ) and is particularly pronounced if one is in the slightly non - adiabatic regime , which is the case in fig .
[ fig1 ] .
[ fig2 ] ] in a cooper pair sluice @xcite [ see fig .
[ fig2 ] ( a ) for the design ] , the pumping of cooper pairs is achieved by a periodic and adiabatic modulation of three system parameters .
the effective josephson couplings @xmath115 can be controlled by magnetic fluxes through the left and right squid , respectively , while the charging energy @xmath116 is controlled via @xmath117 which is tuned by a gate voltage .
here , @xmath118 , where @xmath119 is the total capacitance of the island , and @xmath120 is the number operator of the excess cooper pairs on the superconducting island .
furthermore , the pumped charge depends on the phase difference @xmath121 of the two leads , which is fixed by embedding the design into a superconducting loop threaded by a fixed magnetic flux . in the following we only consider @xmath122 .
if the josephson couplings are small compared to the charging energy , then a two level approximation is valid , where only the two eigenstates of the number operator with the lowest charging energies are considered .
the hamiltonian is then @xcite @xmath123 the pumping pulses are shown in fig .
[ fig2 ] ( b ) .
essentially , @xmath117 is raised while the left josephson junction is open , therefore the island gains one cooper pair from the left lead .
when @xmath117 is lowered , the right junction is open and a cooper pair is pushed into the right lead .
we use a sufficiently slow pumping rate to assure good adiabaticity @xcite and without coupling to an environment , the system stays in the floquet ground state if it was initially prepared in this state .
the resulting current ideally is one cooper pair per pumping cycle . in an experiment ,
the josephson junctions can not be closed exactly , and we assume a realistic ratio of @xmath124 . therefore , in addition to the pumped current which depends on the pumping frequency , there will be a supercurrent which is independent of the pumping frequency @xcite .
this different frequency dependence can be used to extract the pumped charge . .
panel ( b ) shows @xmath125 ( solid ) and @xmath126 ( dashed ) , which relate to the dissipation and dephasing rate , respectively .
[ fig3 ] ] in this system the main source of decoherence are fluctuations of the gate charge @xmath117 , which according to eq .
( [ 22 ] ) results in a coupling to the environment described by the operator @xmath127 .
furthermore , we assume that the antisymmetrized environmental correlation spectrum @xmath128=\gamma_0\omega$ ] increases linearly with frequency , as is typically the case for voltage fluctuations .
we also assume an environment at thermal equilibrium @xmath129 , which leads to @xmath130\right.$ ] as well as @xmath131 , although dephasing is not important in a cooper pair pump because the system starts in the ground state .
it was already shown in @xcite that a zero temperature environment has no effect on ground state pumping . here
, we consider a finite temperature environment , which is able to excite the system . in fig .
[ fig3 ] ( a ) , the level splitting of the cooper pair sluice is plotted as a function of time for one pumping cycle .
it is important to note that at times when the level splitting is small , i.e. when the system can be excited by a relatively low temperature environment , then the dissipative coupling to the gate voltage fluctuations has a pronounced maximum , as is seen in panel ( b ) of fig .
therefore , we can expect that voltage fluctuations with temperature @xmath132ghz @xmath133 already have a significant effect on the state of the system .
[ [ transient - phenomena . ] ] * transient phenomena . * + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + ( solid ) , 2 ( dashed ) , 0 ( dotted ) ghz at coupling to dissipative bathe ( voltage fluctuations ) of strength @xmath134 , while in panel ( b ) we compare different coupling strengths @xmath135 ( solid ) , @xmath136 ( dashed ) , @xmath137 ( dotted ) at temperature @xmath138 ghz .
[ fig4 ] ] the first few pumping cycles are not of importance in cooper pair pumping , as the experimentally measurable quantity is the averaged current after many cycles .
however , in many other applications such as adiabatic quantum gates , one is interested mainly in the behavior of the system within one period .
therefore , we discuss here some interesting effects which happen before the system approached the quasi stationary state .
furthermore , this discussion might also be helpful in understanding the quasi stationary behavior studied below . in panel ( a ) of fig .
[ fig4 ] we consider the system initially in the floquet ground state and we plot the population of the floquet ground state as a function of time for a fairly strong coupling to the dissipative bath for different temperatures .
as predicted in @xcite , the system does not get excited if the environment has zero temperature ( dotted line ) .
as expected , the higher the temperature , the more populated the floquet excited state becomes , in particular at times when the level splitting is small . in panel ( b ) of fig .
[ fig4 ] , we plot the population of the floquet ground state as a function of time for a temperature of about 200 mk and various environmental coupling strengths .
if the coupling is strong ( solid line ) , the system follows the instantaneous thermal mixture of the floquet ground and excited states . for weaker couplings ( dashed and dotted lines )
, the system gets less excited during the short time where the level splitting is small .
furthermore , the short time interval with dissipative coupling [ see fig [ fig3 ] ( b ) ] is not sufficient for the system to return to the ground state once the level splitting is large .
ghz and @xmath139 .
[ fig5 ] ] finally , in fig .
[ fig5 ] we use even weaker coupling to the environment such that the system needs several pumping cycles to approach a quasi stationary state . as mentioned in section [ sec3 ] , this quasi stationary state still has time dependent populations of the two floquet states .
[ [ quasi - stationary - state . ] ] * quasi stationary state . * + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + ( dotted ) , 4 ( dashed ) , 6 ( solid ) ghz for a coupling to dissipative bath ( voltage fluctuations ) with @xmath134 . in panel ( b )
we compare different coupling strengths @xmath135 ( solid ) , @xmath137 ( dashed ) , @xmath140 ( dotted ) at temperature @xmath138 ghz .
[ fig6 ] ] now we assume that the system has already reached its quasi stationary state . in panel ( a ) of fig .
[ fig6 ] , we show the time dependence of the population of the floquet ground state for various temperatures . again , at times of a small level splitting the population of the floquet excited state is increased , while at times of a large level splitting the system returns towards the floquet ground state . in panel
( b ) , we compare the cases of different coupling strengths to the dissipative bath . if the coupling is strong ( solid ) the system closely follows a thermal mixture of the two floquet states according to the instantaneous level splitting . on the contrary , if coupling to the environment is weak ( dotted ) , it barely influence the system s state within one pumping cycle , which leads to a fairly constant population of each floquet state .
this is the limit which is described in ref .
the dashed line represents the intermediate situation .
[ [ current - and - pumped - charge . ] ] * current and pumped charge . * + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + ( black , solid ) , @xmath141 ( red , dashed ) , and @xmath90 ( blue , dotted ) are plotted as a function of time . for panel ( a ) the density operator is calculated without using the secular approximation , while for panel ( b ) the secular approximation was applied .
the similarity of the two panels verifies the accuracy of the secular approximation when being interested in the state of the system .
the small peak of @xmath107 at around @xmath142 ps is responsible for the current and is shown in detail in panels ( c ) and ( d ) .
we see that this peak is altered by the secular approximation , which explains why this approximation should be avoided when calculating the current .
we use @xmath135 and @xmath143 ghz . for clarity
, we use @xmath144 to avoid supercurrent and to expect one transferred cooper pair per cycle ( see main text ) .
indeed , panel ( a ) predicts 1.00 cooper pairs , while performing the secular approximation [ panel ( b ) ] leads to the incorrect value of 0.62 transferred cooper pairs .
[ figerror ] ] the operator of the current through the right josephson junction is given by ( see , e.g. , ref .
@xcite ) @xmath145 for @xmath146 we obtain @xmath147 .
the expectation value of the current is rather small if the state of the system is close to the ground state and therefore small errors in the density matrix can lead to significant relative errors in the current . in particular , it was argued in @xcite and discussed in detail in @xcite that the secular approximation leads to incorrect values for the current and therefore to the non - conservation of charge . in fig .
[ figerror ] we analyze the validity of the secular approximation .
we observe that the secular approximation is very good for the expectation values of all three observables , @xmath107 , @xmath141 , and @xmath90 .
thus the quantum state of the system is well approximated .
however , the small deviations in @xmath148 shown in fig . [ figerror ] are sufficient to significantly modify the result for the pumped charge , when integrated over long time .
we discuss the situation shown in fig .
[ figerror ] in more detail . to facilitate the qualitative understanding we assume , first , a vanishing residual josephson coupling @xmath144 and a coupling to the environment which is sufficiently strong for the state to closely follow the instantaneous thermal equilibrium .
the temperature is of the order of the minimal energy gap , but much lower than the energy gap at the beginning and the end of each half cycle [ see panel ( a ) of fig . [ fig3 ] ] . at the beginning of the cycle
the system will therefore be in the ground state with no excess cooper pair on the island .
when the system moves through the first avoided level crossing , the energy gap is small enough for the excited state to be populated .
nevertheless , after the first half cycle is completed , the energy splitting is large again and the system will again be in the ground state , which now has one excess cooper pair on the island . because @xmath149 during the the first half cycle , this cooper pair came from the left lead . with the same reasoning , the cooper pair leaves the island to the right lead during the second half cycle .
therefore , in this parameter regime we should obtain exactly one transferred cooper pair per pumping cycle , much like in the ground state pumping without coupling to an environment .
indeed , avoiding the secular approximation we obtain exactly one cooper pair per cycle [ panel ( a ) of fig . [ figerror ] ] , while performing the secular approximation [ panel ( b ) ] leads to the incorrect value of 0.62 transferred cooper pairs .
this failure of the secular approximation discussed above is not necessarily connected to the time dependence of the hamiltonian . to illustrate this ,
consider a time independent hamiltonian with @xmath150 and @xmath151 and assume the system to be relaxing from some initial non - equilibrium state to the thermal equilibrium state . in this process
the populations of the excited state and the ground state change in time . since these states have different expectation values of charge on the island , some current must flow .
however , for @xmath150 only off - diagonal elements of the density operator in the energy basis are responsible for current and in the secular approximation the off - diagonal elements are never generated if they were not present in the initial state .
this explains why the secular approximation must fail to take into account contributions to the current which are induced by dissipative effects . to guarantee the correctness of the transferred charge , in the following we use the master equation eq .
( [ 14a ] ) which was derived without the use of the secular approximation . in absence of dissipation the pumped charge @xmath152 and the charge transferred due to
the super current @xmath153 were found @xcite to be given by @xmath154 where @xmath155 is the residual critical current of the system . in the strictly adiabatic limit , these formulas need not to be modified if the environment has zero temperature @xcite .
our choice of @xmath122 then leads to exactly one pumped cooper pair per cycle , and any deviation from that ideal value is because the finite temperature environment is able to excite the cooper pair sluice .
( black , solid ) , 2 ( red , dashed ) , 4 ( blue , dotted ) , 6 ( gray , solid ) ghz at fixed coupling strength @xmath156 .
panel ( b ) compares different coupling strength @xmath157 ( black ) , 0.005 ( red ) , 0.1 ( blue ) at fixed temperature @xmath143 ghz .
the insets highlight the second current peak .
[ fig7 ] ] in fig .
[ fig7 ] we plot the current in units of cooper pairs per picosecond as a function of time , assuming that the system has already undergone enough cycles to be in the quasi stationary state . in panel
( a ) we compare different temperatures and we find that as the temperature increases , the current through the sluice decreases .
the reason is , that the floquet excited state carries supercurrent in the opposite direction to that of the ground state . in panel
( b ) , we compare different coupling strengths to the dissipative bath ( voltage fluctuations ) , and similarly find that the peak current decreases with the coupling strength .
however , the peak width increases with coupling strength such that the total transferred charge per cycle increases with the coupling strength ( see panel ( a ) of fig .
[ fig8 ] ) . this behavior can be explained qualitatively by looking at fig .
[ fig6 ] ( b ) . at the time of
maximal current , the population of the ground state decreases with growing coupling strength , therefore leading to a decreased peak current .
but at other times , the population of the ground state increases with growing coupling strength , as does therefore the current , resulting in wider current peaks .
panel ( a ) of fig .
[ fig8 ] shows the total transferred charge per pumping cycle @xmath158 plotted as a function of the coupling strength to the dissipative bath for different temperatures .
again , the charge decreases with temperature , but it slightly increases with @xmath159 .
panel ( b ) shows the corresponding pumped charge @xmath152 , which is obtained from @xmath160 , where @xmath161 is the transferred charge if the pumping cycle is traversed in the opposite direction which changes the sign of the pumped charge but leaves the supercurrent unchanged .
as expected , the pumped charge decreases with temperature .
the dependence on the coupling strength to the environment shows an increase with the growing coupling .
this supports the conclusion of @xcite that a strong coupling to the environment might be helpful for cooper pair pumping , and can be explained by the fact that at times when the level splitting is large , the system relaxes more effectively to the ground state . as elaborated before for @xmath144 , for one pumped cooper pair per cycle , it is sufficient if the system is in the ground state at the beginning of each half cycle .
we further plotted the transferred charge for @xmath144 which shows that the pumped charge is barely influenced by @xmath162 . for @xmath1636 ghz and strong coupling
the pumped charge does not converge to one cooper pair , but approaches a somewhat lower value .
that is because a higher temperature environment is able to excite the system even at the end of each half cycle when the energy splitting is large . to the environment for the temperatures @xmath1630 ghz , 2 ghz , 4 ghz , 6 ghz ( from top to bottom )
the residual coupling is @xmath164 .
panel ( b ) shows the pumped charge per cycle ( solid curves ) , which is calculated from the difference of the total charges obtained by traversing the pumping cycle in opposite directions . for comparison ( blue , dashed curves )
we also show the transferred charge per cycle without residual current @xmath144 , which shows that the pumped charge is barely influenced by the residual coupling @xmath162 .
in conclusion , we have explicitly taken into account the time dependence of an adiabatically and cyclically evolving hamiltonian to develope a master equation which is valid if the environment is markovian .
we found that decoherence takes place in the time dependent floquet basis and that the decoherence rates depend on time through the instantaneous level splittings as well as the instantaneous coupling to the noise .
we first applied our theory to a spin in an adiabatically changing magnetic field , where we found that the spin does not relax into the instantaneous ground state , but the slightly different floquet ground state which is very close to the superadiabatic ground state .
we then tested our theory on the example of the cooper pair sluice , where the time dependence of the decoherence rates is very pronounced .
this results in new features at finite temperatures and modifies the pumped charge which is measurable in current experiments @xcite .
we further explain why the current has to be calculated without using the secular approximation despite the fact that this approximation is very well justified if one is interested only in the state ( density matrix ) of the system .
there is no consistent terminology in the literature regarding terms like decoherence .
we use the term decoherence to describe all effects induced by an environment .
this includes the decrease of the off diagonals of the density matrix in the energy basis ( dephasing ) as well as the relaxation of the diagonals towards a steady state ( dissipation , energy relaxation ) . | for adiabatically and periodically manipulated dissipative quantum systems we derive , using floquet theory , a simple markovian master equation .
contrary to some previous works we explicitly take into account the time dependence of the hamiltonian and , therefore , obtain a master equation with a time - dependent dissipative part .
we illustrate our theory with two examples and compare our results with the previously proposed master equations . in particular , we consider the problem of cooper pair pumping and demonstrate the inadequacy of the secular ( rotating wave ) approximation when calculating the pumped charge .
the secular approximation producing a master equation of the lindblad type approximates well the quantum state ( density matrix ) of the system , while to determine the pumped charge a non - lindblad master equation beyond the rotating wave approximation is necessary . |
recently , economy has become an active research area for physicists .
they have investigated stock markets using statistical tools , such as the correlation function , multifractal , spin - glass models , and complex networks @xcite . as a consequence , it is now found evident that the interaction therein is highly nonlinear , unstable , and long - ranged .
all those companies in the stock market are interconnected and correlated , and their interactions are regarded as the important internal force of the market .
the correlation function is widely used to study the internal inference of the market @xcite . however , the correlation function has at least two limitations : first , it measures only linear relations , although a linear model is not a faithful representation of the real interactions in general .
second , all it says is only that two series move together , and not that which affects which : in other words , it lacks directional information .
therefore participants located in hubs are always left open to ambiguity : they can be either the most influential ones or the weakest ones subject to the market trend all along .
it should be noted that introducing time - delay can be a good remedy for these limitations .
some authors use such concepts as time - delayed correlation and time - delayed mutual information , and these quantities construct asymmetric matrices by preserving directionality @xcite . in case that the length of delay can be appropriately determined , one can also measure the ` velocity ' whereby the influence spreads . in this paper , however , we rely on a newly - devised variant of information to check its applicability .
information is an important keyword in analyzing the market or in estimating the stock price of a given company .
it is quantified in rigorous mathematical terms @xcite , and the mutual information , for example , appears as meaningful choice replacing a simple linear correlation even though it still does not specify the direction .
the directionality , however , is required to discriminate the more influential one between correlated participants , and can be detected by the transfer entropy ( te ) @xcite .
this concept of te has been already applied to the analysis of financial time series by marschinski and kantz @xcite .
they calculated the information flow between the dow jones and dax stock indexes and obtained conclusions consistent with empirical observations .
while they examined interactions between two huge markets , we may construct its internal structure among _ all _ participants .
let us consider two processes , @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
transfer entropy @xcite from @xmath1 to @xmath0 is defined as follows : @xmath2 where @xmath3 and @xmath4 represent the states at time @xmath5 of @xmath0 and @xmath1 , respectively .. in terms of relative entropy , it can be rephrased as the _ distance _ from the assumption that @xmath1 has no influence on @xmath0 ( i.e. @xmath6 ) .
one may rewrite eq .
( [ te1 ] ) as : @xmath7 from the property of conditional entropy
. then the second equality shows that te measures the change of entropy rate with knowledge of the process @xmath1 .
( [ te2 ] ) is practically useful , since the te is decomposed into entropy terms and there has been already well developed technique in entropy estimation .
there are two choices in estimating entropy of a given time series .
first , the symbolic encoding method divides the range of the given dataset into disjoint intervals and assign one symbol to each interval .
the dataset , originally continuous , becomes a discrete symbol sequence .
marschinski and kantz @xcite took this procedure and introduced the concept called _ effective transfer entropy_. the other choice exploits the generalized correlation integral @xmath8 . prichard and theiler @xcite showed that the following holds for data @xmath9 : @xmath10,\ ] ] where @xmath11 determines the size of a box in the box - counting algorithm .
we define the fraction of data points which lie within @xmath11 of @xmath12 by @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the heaviside function , and calculate its numerical value by the help of the box - assisted neighbor search algorithm @xcite after embedding the dataset into an appropriate phase space .
the generalized correlation integral of order @xmath15 is then given by @xmath16 notice that @xmath17 is expressed as an averaged quantity along the trajectory @xmath12 and it implies a kind of ergodicity which converts an ensemble average @xmath18 into a time average , @xmath19 .
temporal correlations are not taken into consideration since the daily data already lacks much of its continuity .
it is rather straightforward to calculate entropy from a discrete dataset using symbolic encoding . but
determining the partition remains as a serious problem , which is referred to as the _ generating partition problem_. even for a two - dimensional deterministic system , the partition lines may exhibit considerably complicated geometry @xcite and thus should be set up with all extreme caution @xcite . hence the correlation integral method is often recommended if one wants to handle continuous datasets without over - simplification , and we will take this route .
in addition , one has to determine the parameter @xmath11 . in a sense
, this parameter plays a role of defining the resolution or the scale of concerns , just as the number of symbols does in the symbolic encoding method . before discussing how to set @xmath11 , we remark on the finite sampling effect : though it is pointed out that the case of @xmath20 does not suffer much from finiteness of the number of data @xcite , then the positivity of entropy is not guaranteed instead @xcite .
thus we choose the conventional shannon entropy , @xmath21 throughout this paper .
there have been works done @xcite on correcting entropy estimation .
these correction methods , however , can be problematic when calculating te , since the fluctuations in each term of eq .
( [ te2 ] ) are not independent and should not be treated separately @xcite .
we actually found that a proper selection of @xmath11 is quite crucial , and decided to inactivate the correction terms here .
a good value of @xmath11 will discriminate a real effect from zero . without _ a priori _ knowledge , we need to scan the range of @xmath11 in order to find a proper resolution which yields meaningful results from a time series .
for reducing the computational time , however , we resort to the empirical observation that an airline company is quite dependent on the oil price while the dependency hardly appears in the opposite direction . fig .
[ fig_te1 ] shows this unilateral effect : the major oil companies , chevron and exxon mobile , have influence over delta airline . from @xmath22 which maximizes the difference between two directions ( fig .
[ fig_te2 ] ) , we choose the appropriate scale for analyzing the data . even in observing the temporal evolution
, this value gives good discrimination through the whole period . in fig .
[ fig_te1 ] , the influence seems reversed on very small length scales .
the te , however , is known to increase monotonically under refinement of the partitions in many cases @xcite and the refined partition means the small length scale which is covered by the small @xmath11 in the correlation integral method .
hence we regard this reversal as a finite sample effect in this paper , but it seems worth looking further into the characteristics of te analysis . and we set @xmath23 in eq .
( [ te1 ] ) since other values does not make significant differences .
this study deals with the daily closure prices of 135 stocks listed on new york stock exchange ( nyse ) from 1983 to 2003 ( @xmath24 trading days , @xmath25 trading day ) , obtained through the website @xcite .
we select stocks which is listed on nyse over the whole periods .
the companies in a stock market are usually grouped into business sectors or industry categories , and our data contain 9 business sectors ( basic materials , utilities , healthcare , services , consumer goods , financial , industrial goods , conglomerates , technology ) and 69 industry categories .
the following method shows how the information flows between the groups : suppose that we have a time series data @xmath26 , representing the daily closure price of a company at time @xmath5 .
a stock market analysis usually prefers treating the log return value : @xmath27 to the original price itself , since it satisfies the additive property : @xmath28 .
this log return transformation also make the result invariant under the arbitrary scaling of the input data .
therefore , in order to measure the information transfer between two companies , say @xmath0 and @xmath1 , we create the log return time series @xmath29 and @xmath30 from the raw price data
. then one can calculate the transfer entropies @xmath31 and @xmath32 between them from the equalities in the section 2 . for obtaining an overview of the market
, we consider groups of similar companies .
let @xmath0 be a company of the group @xmath33 , and @xmath1 be one of the group @xmath34 .
the _ information flow index _ between these two groups is defined as a simple sum : @xmath35 in addition , we define the _ net information flow index _ to measure the disparity in influences of the two groups as : @xmath36 if @xmath37 is positive , we can say that the category @xmath33 influences to the category @xmath34 . we examine the market with two grouping methods .
one is business sector , and the other is industry category . grouping into business sectors , however , does not exhibit clear directionality : the influence of the @xmath33 sector just alternates from that of the @xmath34 sector .
in other words , the difference between @xmath37 and @xmath38 over the whole period is almost 0 ( zero ) .
this unclarity comes from the fact that a business sector contains so many diverse companies that its directionality just cancels out . on the other hand ,
if we construct the asset tree through the minimum spanning tree , each business sector forms a subset of the asset tree and the subsets are connected mainly through the hub .
then , it can be said that each of the business sectors forms a cluster @xcite and there are no significant direct links among them .
hence we employ the industry category grouping , more detailed than the business sectors .
we have to exclude the categories which contain only one element , and table [ category ] lists the remaining industry categories used in the analysis . as in our previous observation
, it is verified again that oil companies and airline companies are related in a unilateral way : the category 20 , major oil & gas , has continuing influence over the category 19 , major airline , during the whole 14 periods under examination ( @xmath39 ) .
one can easily find such relations in other categories : for example , the category 20 always influences on the categories 15 ( independent oil&gas ) , 22 ( oil&gas equipment&services ) , and 23 ( oil&gas refining&marketing ) .
it also affects the category 27 ( regional airlines ) over 13 periods and maintains its power on the whole market during 11 periods ( fig . [ map ] ) .
it is well - known that economy greatly depends on the energy supply and price such as oil and gas .
transfer entropy analysis quantitatively proves this empirical fact .
the top three influential categories ( in terms of periods ) are the categories 10 ( diversified utilities ) , 12 ( electric utilities ) and 20 .
all of ten companies in the categories 10 and 12 are again related to the energy industry , such as those for holding , energy delivery , generation , transmission , distribution , and supply of electricity . on the contrary ,
an airline company is sensitive to the tone of the market .
these companies receive information from other categories almost all the time ( category 19 : 11 periods , category 27 : 12 periods ) . the category 8 ( credit services ) and the category 9 ( diversified computer systems , including only hp and ibm in our data ) are also market - sensitive as easily expected .
we calculated the transfer entropy with the daily data of the us market .
the concept of transfer entropy provides a quantitative value of general correlation and the direction of information .
thus it reveals how the information flows among companies or groups of companies , and discriminates the market - leading companies from the market - sensitive ones .
as commonly known , the energy such as natural resources and electricity is shown to greatly affect economic activities and the business barometer .
this analysis may be applied to predicting the stock price of a company influenced by other ones . in short , te proves its possibility as a promising measure to detect directional information .
we suggest that the merits and demerits of te should be judged in details with respect to those of the classical methods like the correlation matrix theory . over the whole 14 periods .
the degree of darkness represents the number of periods when @xmath33 is affected by @xmath34 , and @xmath40 s are left blank .
for example , the category 10 affects almost all the other categories and is affected by the categories 12 and 25 in a few periods .
the row of a market - leading category is bright on the average , while that of a market - sensitive one is dark.,scaledwidth=100.0% ] | in terms of transfer entropy , we investigate the strength and the direction of information transfer in the us stock market . through the directionality of the information transfer
, the more influential company between the correlated ones can be found and also the market leading companies are selected .
our entropy analysis shows that the companies related with energy industries such as oil , gas , and electricity influence the whole market .
, , , transfer entropy , information flow , econophysics , stock market + 05.20.gg , 89.65.gh , 89.70.+c |
the origin of water on earth is still puzzling ( e.g. the reviews by * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * and references therein ) . at one end of the models ,
the high temperature in the inner accretion disk hampered hydrous phases to exist so that external sources were needed , the so - called late veneer of comets , asteroids and/or meteorites suggested by lunar cratering ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) . at the other end , earth accreted hydrous silicate phases , or grains having adsorbed water from the solar nebula .
the d / h isotopic ratio plays a key role in constraining the models .
the comparable d / h ratio of earth s oceans and carbonaceous chondrites ( the only ones to contain enough water ) points towards a meteoritic veneer , while the cometary d / h ratio , twice as high as the terrestrial one , would require a mixture of cometary water with a roughly equal amount of primitive indigeneous d - poor terrestrial water .
while the abundance of noble gases in the earth s atmosphere suggests that only small amounts of cometary volatiles were brought to earth , the @xmath2os/@xmath3os ratio apparently rules out the carbonaceous chondrites as the main component of the veneer ( * ? ? ? * and references therein ) .
however , most of these arguments have shortcomings ( see discussions by * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . in particular , d /
h has only been measured in oort - cloud comets and it is not excluded that other types of comets or other reservoirs of hydrogen in comets exhibit different d / h ratios .
additional constraints are therefore mandatory .
recently , we found that the isotopic ratio @xmath0n/@xmath1n is consistently twice as high in cometary cn and hcn as in the earth s atmosphere and surface @xcite . since any delivery of water by comets would necessarily be accompanied by a delivery of nitrogen , the observed difference between terrestrial and cometary @xmath0n/@xmath1n can induce a measurable isotopic shift and provide independent constraints on the amount of water and nitrogen delivered by comets to earth s oceans and atmosphere , as detailed below .
the interest of considering the nitrogen isotopic ratio has been recently emphasized by @xcite .
we assume that cometary h@xmath4o and hdo add to a primitive mixture on earth to give the amounts presently measured in earth s water .
we have then @xmath5 where @xmath6 is the abundance in number , the suffix @xmath7 , @xmath8 , and @xmath9 respectively referring to primitive earth , cometary and terrestrial ( present earth ) values . from these equations we derive @xmath10 which provides the proportion of earth s water due to comets as a function of the isotopic ratio d / h in water .
the present earth d / h ratio is fairly well known and measured to be ( d / h)@xmath11 = [email protected] 10@xmath13 for water stored at the earth s surface , mainly in the oceans @xcite . for cometary water we have ( d / h)@xmath14 = [email protected] 10@xmath13 from in situ measurements of comet 1p / halley @xcite and from remote observations of three oort - cloud comets : c/1996 b2 ( hyakutake ) @xcite , c/1995 o1 ( hale - bopp ) @xcite and c/2002 t7 ( linear ) @xcite .
the primitive earth d / h ratio is not known . at one extreme
, we have the protosolar value of the huge h@xmath4 reservoir measured from dh / h@xmath4 in jupiter : ( d / h)@xmath15 0.26 10@xmath13 @xcite . at the other end ,
the d / h ratio estimated to be representative of the deep mantle ( d / h)@xmath16 1.36 10@xmath13 @xcite . in the case
that water from the warm , inner solar nebula is adsorbed by the rocky grains that formed the bulk of the earth , intermediate values ( d / h)@xmath17 0.81.0 10@xmath13 are likely to better characterize the primitive earth d / h ratio @xcite . with these values
, the proportion of earth s water due to comets varies between 50% and 10% ( eq . 2 ) , with plausible values up to 30% @xcite .
more detailed modelling , combining the d / h ratios with lunar cratering records and terrestrial mantle siderophiles , suggests that the contribution of comets to earth s water is smaller than 10% @xcite .
moreover , should a significant fraction of cometary material possess an even higher d / h as measured in hcn @xcite and assuming that this material can be recycled at the earth s surface , even smaller cometary contributions would be expected .
assuming similarly that the nitrogen isotopic ratio of the present earth results from the combination of primitive earth and cometary nitrogen mixtures , we have @xmath18 and @xmath19 since nitrogen is mostly in the form @xmath1n , we may write @xmath20 with the constraint @xmath21 which comes from the fact that the total amount of nitrogen delivered by comets to earth can not exceed the amount of nitrogen presently measured in earth s atmosphere and surface , i.e. @xmath22 . nitrogen recycling at earth s surface is implicitly assumed as well as the fact that the composition of the atmosphere has not significantly changed since the late veneer @xcite .
the amount of water and nitrogen at the surface of the present earth ( mostly in the oceans and in the atmosphere , respectively ) is relatively well known .
the water inventory by @xcite ( see also * ? ? ?
* ) gives 1.7 10@xmath23 kg of water at the earth s surface ( oceans , ice sheets , organic matter , metamorphic rocks , shales , sandstones , continental carbonates , evaporites , marine clays and marine carbonates ) .
the nitrogen inventory at the earth s surface ( atmosphere , sedimentary rocks , crustal igneous rocks ) gives 5.0 10@xmath24 kg of n@xmath4 @xcite .
thus @xmath25 @xmath26 3.8 10@xmath27 . the abundance of nitrogen in comets is poorly known . because n@xmath4 is not detected
, the nitrogen inventory in cometary ices mainly relies on the measurement of the nh@xmath28 and hcn volatiles . from the abundances given by @xcite , we compute
@xmath29 10@xmath30 adding the contributions of all observed n - bearing molecules and considering that contributions from other molecules are possible .
based on in - situ measurements by the giotto spacecraft , @xcite estimated the total n / o abundance in 1p / halley : n / o = [email protected] , including both the gas and the dust components . assuming that at most 60% of o is in h@xmath4o @xcite , @xmath31 3 10@xmath30 .
further modelling by @xcite and @xcite suggests that @xmath32 may be as high as 7 10@xmath30 , nitrogen being still depleted in comets by a factor 3 with respect to solar abundances . under the hypothesis that the nitrogen abundance in 1p / halley is representative of comets , we adopt the lower limit @xmath31 3 10@xmath30 from which we derive @xmath33 @xmath34 13% ( eq .
the present earth @xmath0n/@xmath1n ratio is accurately measured from n@xmath4 in the atmosphere : ( @xmath0n/@xmath1n)@xmath11 = 3.676 @xmath35 @xcite .
this is comparable to @xmath0n/@xmath1n = 3.64 10@xmath27 which characterizes the present mantle @xcite .
the primitive earth @xmath0n/@xmath1n is not known .
it may be close to @xmath0n/@xmath1n @xmath26 3.55 10@xmath27 , the value measured in enstatite chondrites thought to have released significant amounts of nitrogen during and shortly after the accretion phase @xcite .
on the other hand , a massive atmosphere could have been captured directly from the solar nebula @xcite where @xmath0n/@xmath1n @xmath26 2.3 10@xmath27 ( * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
* this value is estimated from the atmosphere of jupiter assumed to be a proxy of the n@xmath4 reservoir in the solar system . ) .
a large part of the early atmosphere might have been lost during the post - accretion phase ( much before the late veneer ) , possibly resulting in a small shift of the primitive @xmath0n/@xmath1nratio due to atmospheric escape @xcite .
given these uncertainties we consider in the following both ( @xmath0n/@xmath1n)@xmath36 = 2.3 10@xmath27 and ( @xmath0n/@xmath1n)@xmath36 = 3.55 10@xmath27 .
intermediate values are possible , as well as values closer to the present terrestrial value if fractionation by atmospheric escape has been significant .
@xmath0n/@xmath1n has been measured remotely in about twenty comets using optical - uv spectroscopy of cn , and in three comets on the basis of radio observations of hcn .
recent studies show that optical and radio measurements do agree within uncertainties @xcite .
the nitrogen isotopic ratio is remarkably similar from comet to comet and clusters around the `` anomalous '' @xmath0n/@xmath1n = [email protected] 10@xmath27 which is twice as high as the terrestrial value @xcite . on the other hand ,
the analysis of comet 81p / wild2 grains returned by stardust suggests bulk @xmath0n/@xmath1n ratios comparable to the terrestrial and chondritic values @xcite .
we therefore compute an average cometary ratio according to @xmath37 where @xmath38 = 6.8 10@xmath27 , @xmath39 = 3.55 10@xmath27 , and @xmath40 is the abundance of the isotopically anomalous nitrogen . in fig .
1 we illustrate the proportion of terrestrial nitrogen delivered by comets , @xmath41 , as a function of the relative abundance of anomalous nitrogen @xmath42 for various cases of interest ( eqs . 4 and 7 ) .
1 shows that the nitrogen isotopic shift between primitive and present earth can be easily accounted for by the addition of a cometary component thanks to the presence , even in small quantities , of isotopically anomalous nitrogen in comets .
the proportion of terrestrial water delivered by comets can be computed from fig . 1 and eq . 5 , i.e. @xmath33 @xmath34
0.13@xmath43@xmath41 for @xmath44 3 10@xmath30 . assuming that the carrier of the isotopically anomalous nitrogen is only hcn , we have @xmath45 2 10@xmath27 using the abundances of @xcite . although @xmath46 has not yet been measured in cometary ammonia , fractionation mechanisms predict that @xmath0n must be enhanced in nh@xmath28 before being transferred to hcn compounds @xcite .
if nh@xmath28 is also included in the carriers of the anomalous @xmath0n/@xmath1nratio , we have @xmath47 8 10@xmath27 using 6 10@xmath27 for the mean abundance of nh@xmath28 relative to h@xmath4o @xcite . in this case between 15% and 65% of earth s nitrogen
might have been delivered by comets ( fig . 1 ) .
we then estimate the upper limit @xmath48 @xmath34 9% , which can be as low as @xmath49 @xmath34 2% if the primitive earth @xmath0n/@xmath1n was close to 3.55 10@xmath27 .
given that the abundance of nitrogen in comets is probably larger than @xmath32 = 3 10@xmath30 , and that the refractory component may also contain isotopically anomalous nitrogen , the contribution of comets to earth s water is probably roughly twice as small as the upper limit we just derived , i.e. not larger than a few percent .
these constraints are more stringent than the values derived from d / h using eq . 2 .
moreover , as soon as @xmath49 @xmath34 7% , the amount of water delivered by comets is not sufficient to explain the d / h isotopic shift in terrestrial oceans from the primitive value ( eq .
2 ) so that additional sources of water are needed .
our estimates agree with the constraints derived from recent dynamical models of the solar system @xcite , and from mass - balance models based on d / h @xcite or based on noble metals and gases @xcite .
as far as the atmosphere is concerned , @xcite showed that a cometary contribution fitting the abundances of noble gases in the earth s atmosphere would deliver @xmath50 6% of the atmospheric nitrogen .
given the uncertainties on the abundances of noble gases in comets @xcite , this is compatible with our estimates provided that @xmath45 10@xmath30 and ( @xmath0n/@xmath1n)@xmath36 @xmath26 3.55 10@xmath27 in fig . 1 .
early fractionation due to atmospheric escape @xcite might also have slightly increased ( @xmath0n/@xmath1n)@xmath36 providing an even better agreement .
it is important to note that the anomalous @xmath0n/@xmath1n isotopic ratio was measured to be identical in oort - cloud and kuiper - belt comets @xcite so that our estimates apply to the contributions of both types of comets .
thanks to the fact that the @xmath0n/@xmath1n ratio measured in cometary cn and hcn is significantly different from the ratio measured on earth , and since any delivery of nitrogen from comets to earth necessarily accompanied that of water , we put independent constraints on the amount of earth s water possibly due to comets . under reasonable assumptions , we find that no more than a few percent of earth s water can be attributed to comets .
this is consistent with the constraints derived from d / h using various models @xcite .
since the @xmath0n/@xmath1n isotope ratio is not different in oort - cloud and kuiper - belt comets , our estimates apply to both types of objects .
our results also suggest that a significant part of earth s nitrogen might come from comets , supporting the idea of a dual origin of the earth s atmosphere @xcite
. a critical measurement to further constrain these quantities would be the determination of the @xmath0n/@xmath1n ratio in cometary nh@xmath28 , expected to be either anomalous or terrestrial .
although more detailed modelling is required for more quantitative estimates , our results demonstrate the interest of considering the @xmath0n/@xmath1n ratio to evaluate the contribution of comets to the late bombardment of the earth .
arpigny , c. , jehin , e. , manfroid , j. , hutsemkers , d. , schulz , r. , stwe , j. a. , zucconi , j .-
m . , ilyin , i. 2003 .
anomalous nitrogen isotope ratio in comets .
science 301 , 1522 - 1525 .
balsiger , h. , altwegg , k. , geiss , j. 1995 .
d / h and o-18/o-16 ratio in the hydronium ion and in neutral water from in situ ion measurements in comet halley .
journal of geophysical research 100 , 5827 - 5834 .
becker , r. h. , clayton , r. n. , galimov , e. m. , lammer , h. , marty , b. , pepin , r. o. , wieler , r. 2003 .
isotopic signatures of volatiles in terrestrial planets - working group report .
space science reviews 106 , 377 - 410 .
bockele - morvan , d. , and 11 colleagues 1998 .
deuterated water in comet c/1996 b2 ( hyakutake ) and its implications for the origin of comets .
icarus 133 , 147 - 162 .
bockele - morvan , d. , crovisier , j. , mumma , m.j . , weaver , h.a .
2004 . in comets
ii , eds . festou , m.c . ,
keller , h.u . , weaver , h.a . , ( university of arizona press , tucson ) , pp .
391 - 423 bockele - morvan , d. , and 17 colleagues 2008 .
large excess of heavy nitrogen in both hydrogen cyanide and cyanogen from comet 17p / holmes .
astrophysical journal 679 , l49-l52 .
charnley , s. b. , rodgers , s. d. 2002 .
the end of interstellar chemistry as the origin of nitrogen in comets and meteorites .
astrophysical journal 569 , l133-l137 .
dauphas , n. , robert , f. , marty , b. 2000 .
the late asteroidal and cometary bombardment of earth as recorded in water deuterium to protium ratio .
icarus 148 , 508 - 512 .
dauphas , n. , marty , b.2002 .
inference on the nature and mass of earth s late veneer from noble metals and gases .
journal of geophysical research 107 , e12 , 5129 - 5135 .
dauphas , n. 2003 . the dual origin of the terrestrial atmosphere .
icarus 165 , 326 - 339 .
deloule , e. , albarde , f. , sheppard , s. m. f. 1991 .
hydrogen isotope heterogeneities in the mantle from ion probe analysis of amphiboles from ultramafic rocks . earth and planetary science letters 105 , 543 - 553 .
drake , m.j .
origin of water in the terrestrial planets .
meteoritics and planetary science 40 , 1 - 5 eberhardt , p. , reber , m. , krankowsky , d. , hodges , r. r. 1995 . the d / h and @xmath24o/@xmath51o ratios in water from comet p / halley.astronomy and astrophysics 302 , 301 .
encrenaz , t. , puget , j.l . ,
dhendecourt , l. 1991 . from interstellar matter to comets :
elemental abundances in interstellar dust and in comet halley .
space science reviews 56 , 83 - 92 .
genda , h. , ikoma , m. 2008 .
origin of the ocean on the earth : early evolution of water d / h in a hydrogen - rich atmosphere .
icarus 194 , 42 - 52 .
gomes , r. , levison , h. f. , tsiganis , k. , morbidelli , a. 2005 .
origin of the cataclysmic late heavy bombardment period of the terrestrial planets .
nature 435 , 466 - 469 .
greenberg , j. m. 1998 . making a comet nucleus .
astronomy and astrophysics 330 , 375 - 380 .
huebner , w. 2002 .
composition of comets : observations and models .
earth , moon and planets 89 , 179 - 195 javoy , m. , pineau , f. , delorme , h. 1986 .
carbon and nitrogen isotopes in the mantle .
chemical geology 57 , 41 - 62 .
javoy , m. 2005 . where do the oceans come from ?
comptes rendus geoscience 337 , 139 - 158 hutsemkers , d. , manfroid , j. , jehin , e. , arpigny , c. , cochran , a. , schulz , r. , stwe , j. a. , zucconi , j .-
isotopic abundances of carbon and nitrogen in jupiter - family and oort cloud comets .
astronomy and astrophysics 440 , l21-l24 .
hutsemkers , d. , manfroid , j. , jehin , e. , zucconi , j .-
, arpigny , c. 2008 .
the @xmath51oh/@xmath24oh and od / oh isotope ratios in comet c/2002 t7 ( linear ) .
astronomy and astrophysics 490 , l31-l34 junk , g. , svec , h. j. 1958 . the absolute abundance of the nitrogen isotopes in the atmosphere and compressed gas from various sources .
geochimica et cosmochimica acta 14 , 234 - 243 .
lcuyer , c. , gillet , p. , robert , f. 1998 .
the hydrogen isotope composition of seawater and the global water cycle .
chemical geology 145 , 249 - 261 mahaffy , p. r. , donahue , t. m. , atreya , s. k. , owen , t. c. , niemann , h. b. 1998 .
galileo probe measurements of d / h and 3he/4he in jupiter s atmosphere .
space science reviews 84 , 251 - 263 .
manfroid , j. , jehin , e. , hutsemkers , d. , cochran , a. , zucconi , j .-
m . , arpigny , c. , schulz , r. , stwe , j.a . ,
ilyin , i. 2009 . the cn isotopic ratios in comets .
astronomy and astrophysics , submitted marty , b. , meibom , a. 2007.noble gas signature of the late heavy bombardment in the earth s atmosphere .
eearth 2 , 43 - 49 marty , b. , yokochi , r. 2006.water in the early earth .
reviews in mineralogy & geochemistry 62 , 421 - 450 mckeegan , k. d. , and 46 colleagues 2006 .
isotopic compositions of cometary matter returned by stardust .
science 314 , 1724 - 1728 meibom , a. , krot , a. n. , robert , f. , mostefaoui , s. , russell , s. s. , petaev , m. i. , gounelle , m. 2007 . nitrogen and carbon isotopic composition of the sun inferred from a high - temperature solar nebular condensate .
astrophysical journal 656 , l33-l36 .
meier , r. , owen , t. c. , matthews , h. e. , jewitt , d. c. , bockelee - morvan , d. , biver , n. , crovisier , j. , gautier , d. 1998 . a determination of the hdo / h2o ratio in comet c/1995 o1 ( hale - bopp ) .
science 279 , 842 .
meier , r. , owen , t. c. , jewitt , d. c. , matthews , h. e. , senay , m. , biver , n. , bockelee - morvan , d. , crovisier , j. , gautier , d. 1998 .
deuterium in comet c/1995 o1 ( hale - bopp ) : detection of dcn .
science 279 , 1707 .
morbidelli , a. , chambers , j. , lunine , j. i. , petit , j. m. , robert , f. , valsecchi , g. b. , cyr , k. e. 2000 .
source regions and time scales for the delivery of water to earth .
meteoritics and planetary science 35 , 1309 - 1320 .
owen , t. , bar - nun , a. 1998.from the interstellar medium to planetary atmospheres via comets.faraday discussions no .
109 , 453 - 462 .
owen , t. , mahaffy , p. r. , niemann , h. b. , atreya , s. , wong , m. 2001 .
protosolar nitrogen .
astrophysical journal 553 , l77-l79 .
pepin , r.o .
atmospheres on the terrestrial planets : clues to origin and evolution . earth and planetary science letters 252 , 1 - 14 robert , f. 2001 . the origin of water on earth .
science 293 , 1056 - 1058 rodgers , s. d. , charnley , s. b. 2008 .
nitrogen superfractionation in dense cloud cores.monthly notices of the royal astronomical society 385 , l48-l52 tolstikhin , i.n . , marty , b. 1998 .
the evolution of terrestrial volatiles : a view from helium , neon , argon and nitrogen isotope modelling . chemical geology 147 , 27 - 52 zhang , y. , zindler , a. 1993 . distribution and evolution of carbon and nitrogen in earth . earth and planetary science letters 117 , 331 - 345 . | new independent constraints on the amount of water delivered to earth by comets are derived using the @xmath0n/@xmath1n isotopic ratio , measured to be roughly twice as high in cometary cn and hcn as in the present earth . under reasonable assumptions ,
we find that no more than a few percent of earth s water can be attributed to comets , in agreement with the constraints derived from d / h . our results also suggest that a significant part of earth s atmospheric nitrogen might come from comets .
since the @xmath0n/@xmath1n isotopic ratio is not different in oort - cloud and kuiper - belt comets , our estimates apply to the contribution of both types of objects . , , , and number of pages : + number of tables : 0 + number of figures : 1 + the delivery of cometary water and nitrogen to earth d. hutsemkers + institut dastrophysique et de gophysique + universit de lige + alle du 6 aot 17 + b-4000 lige , belgium + + email : [email protected] + phone : + 32 4 366 9760 + fax : + 32 4 366 9746 comets , earth , origin , solar system |
the phoenix dwarf galaxy , discovered by schuster & west ( 1976 ) , has a morphological type of dirr / dsph ( mateo 1998 ) , meaning that although this galaxy has a low surface brightness and a mass and morphology like a dwarf spheroidal ( dsph ) galaxy , there is evidence of recent star formation ( canterna & flower 1977 ) .
color - magnitude diagrams obtained from ground - based images have been described by ortolani & gratton ( 1988 ) , van de rydt , demers , & kunkel ( 1991 ) , held , saviane , & momany ( 1999 ) , and martinez - delgado , gallart , & aparicio ( 1999 ) .
these studies find a broadly distributed metal - poor population of evolved giants , as well as a concentration of young stars in the central region of the galaxy .
several studies have found h i in the direction of phoenix ( carignan , demers , & cote 1991 ; young & lo 1997 ) ; most recently , st - germain , carignan , cote , & oosterloo ( 1999 ) have found that a mass of @xmath0 @xmath1 of h i gas is likely associated with phoenix .
studying star formation in dwarf galaxies has the potential to provide clues about the mechanisms which govern star formation , and the relative formation epochs for different types of galaxies .
key questions include the age of the oldest stellar populations are dwarf galaxies the oldest stellar systems and the building blocks for larger galaxies ? and
the degree to which star formation is episodic .
the latter issue has implications for the visibilities of different types of galaxies at high redshifts ; if star formation is strongly episodic , then even small galaxies can appear bright when observed at redshifts for which star formation rates were greatest .
we initiated a hst / wfpc2 study of phoenix to investigate its stellar population in greater detail .
in particular , our project was motivated by the desire to determine whether an ancient population of stars exists by looking for a horizontal branch population . during the period between proposal submission and the time the observations
were taken , however , several groups detected such a horizontal branch from ground - based observations ( held _ et al . _ 1999 , martinez - delgado _ et al . _ 1999 ,
tolstoy _ et al . _ 2000 ) . nonetheless , the deeper hst data still provide several pieces of valuable information about the star formation history of phoenix , which we discuss in this paper : 1 ) wfpc2 photometry of the horizontal branch is more precise than can be obtained from the ground , leading to the ability to study its morphology and determine its magnitude with higher precision , 2 ) the deeper observations allow us to observe stars down to the level of a turnoff for an ancient population , providing information on the distribution of ages of stars in phoenix , and 3 ) accurate photometry of the younger main sequence stars allows us to assess the degree to which more recent star formation has been episodic and also to get some indication of the relative metallicities of the young population compared with the older one . in section 2
we discuss our observations and data reduction .
section 3 discusses the morphology of the color - magnitude diagram . in section 4
we use numerical simulations of the distribution of stars in the color - magnitude diagram to infer the star formation history of phoenix , and discuss the uncertainties which attend such an analysis .
some implications of our phoenix results for the evolution of dwarf galaxies in general are discussed in section 5 .
one field in phoenix centered on @xmath2 ( j2000 ) = 01:51:06.3 , @xmath3 ( j2000 ) = -44:26:40.9 was imaged with wfpc2 on hst on 15 january 1999 .
while appearing to be close to the center of the galaxy as seen on the digitized poss , this field was chosen to avoid bright ( field ) stars .
our program was specifically intended to concentrate on the old background stellar population of phoenix .
however , given that various authors ( held _ et al . _ 1999 , martinez - delgado _ et al . _ 1999 ,
ortolani & gratton 1988 , canterna & flowers 1977 ) find the youngest stars in phoenix to be concentrated towards the center of the galaxy , our wfpc2 field does sample these stars as well .
table 1 shows the relevant parameters for the hst observations .
the wfpc2 observations were obtained over a total of 4 orbits .
six exposures were made through each of the f555w and f814w filters .
half of the exposures were made at one telescope pointing , while the remaining half were slightly offset by @xmath4 arcsec along the axes of the wfpc2 ccds .
data were processed through the stsci pipeline .
the combined exposures in f555w at one of the pointings are shown in figure [ fig : phoenix ] .
photometry was obtained using simultaneous psf - fitting on the entire stack of frames , as described in holtzman _
et al . _ ( 1997 ) , using custom software within the xvista data reduction package that was developed / modified based on the routines of stetson ( 1987 ) ; this software has been extensively used to reduce hst / wfpc2 data . in brief , all frames were constrained to have the same lists of stars with the same relative positions ( allowing for slight scale changes between the two different filters ) . the stars in different exposures through the same filter were constrained to have the same relative brightnesses , with frame - to - frame scaling constrained by the relative exposure times .
model psfs were derived individually for each frame using phase retrieval of a few bright stars to derive the mean focus for each frame , individual exposure jitter information , and the most recent estimates for the variations of aberrations and pupil functions across the wfpc2 field of view .
prior to the psf fitting , frames at each of the two pointings were compared with each other to flag cosmic rays in each frame , and these were ignored during the fitting process .
aperture corrections were determined by comparing the psf magnitudes with measurements of stars through @xmath5 radius apertures made on frames in which all neighbors had been subtracted using the psf - fitting results .
both psf - fitting and aperture photometry results were corrected for the effect of charge transfer efficiency problems in the wfpc2 detectors using the prescription of dolphin ( 2000 ) ; results presented in this paper were largely unaffected by this correction , however .
zeropoints from holtzman _
et al . _ ( 1995 ) were used to place the instrumental magnitudes on the synthetic wfpc2 photometric system ( which we use for comparison with isochrones ) , and transformations to johnson / cousins v and i from holtzman _
et al . _ ( 1995 ) were used for comparison with previous results on the tip of the red giant branch and giant branch colors .
the v vs. ( v - i ) and i vs. ( v - i ) color - magnitude diagrams ( cmds ) for the full wfpc2 field observed in phoenix are shown in figure [ fig : cmd ] .
photometric errors as estimated from the psf - fitting are plotted versus @xmath6 magnitude in figure [ fig : err ] and demonstrate the high accuracy of the wfpc2 photometry ; typical 1@xmath7 photometric errors at the horizontal branch are @xmath8 mag .
more detailed photometric errors were derived using a set of twenty artificial star tests . in each test , over a thousand simulated stars of a given brightness were added to images in a grid pattern ( to prevent additional crowding ) and photometry was rederived for all stars on the frame .
the 20 tests covered brightnesses between @xmath9 , with finer sampling at the faint end to measure the completeness of the photometry ; at each brightness , the artificial stars were chosen to have the median color of the observed stars at that brightness .
photometry for the simulated stars at each magnitude were extracted to provide error histograms .
these were used in the construction of artificial cmds discussed below . in general , the true errors ( difference between observed and simulated brightnesses ) are comparable to those estimated from the psf - fitting routines for the bulk of the simulated stars , but there is always a subset of stars which have significantly larger errors .
these are generally the product of systematic errors caused by crowding , and as a result , are correlated in the two bandpasses .
in addition , the errors for the artificial stars are smaller than those estimated by the psf - fitting routines for the brighter stars , which is most likely a result of using the exact same psf to create and reduce the artificial stars .
an indication of these effects is shown in the bottom panel of figure [ fig : err ] ; the various vertical bands are the measured errors for the simulated stars .
the distribution of these errors is non - gaussian since a small subset of stars have relatively large errors ; still , it is apparent that the bulk of the artificial stars have observed errors consistent with the rms errors which are output from the psf - fitting routine ( and shown as the continuous set of points ) .
we emphasize , however , that we use the observed error distribution from the artifical star tests in our detailed comparison of simulated cmds with the data discussed below .
error bars plotted in figure [ fig : cmd ] show the rms errors from the artificial star tests as a function of magnitude .
since the true distribution of errors is non - gaussian , these do not fully convey all the information we have used about the error distribution ; the error bars shown in figure [ fig : cmd ] were computed by determining an rms from the measured error distribution with rejection of @xmath10 outliers .
the cmd of phoenix provides examples of stars in many different stages of stellar evolution .
the cmd exhibits the types of sequences , most notably the near - vertical blue and red `` plumes , '' which are typical of dwarf irregular galaxies ( _ e.g. _ , cole _
et al . _
the main stellar sequences which constitute such plumes are illustrated by dohm - palmer _
et al . _ ( 1997 ) and gallart _ et al . _ ( 1996 ) .
the vertical blue sequence is the main sequence of a young stellar population in phoenix .
the red sequence is a combination of giant branch and asymptotic giant branch stars which can have a wide range of ages and metallicities .
in addition , there is a clear detection of a horizontal branch in phoenix , with both blue and red components .
there is a red clump of stars found near the intersection of the horizontal branch and the giant branch that extends more than 0.5 mag in v and i brighter than the red horizontal branch ( rhb ) .
the stars in this clump that are brighter than the rhb are intermediate - age ( 1 - 10 gyr ) core helium - burning stars . finally ,
there are indications of two sequences extending upwards from the red clump ; the most populated one is nearly vertical , and is particularly pronounced in the magnitude range @xmath11 , while a second very sparsely populated sequence gets bluer at brighter magnitudes ; these ( especially the bluer one ) can perhaps be seen more clearly in the larger area ground - based observations of held _ et al . _ ( 1999 ) .
these two sequences correspond to core helium burning stars at either end of the blue loops through which relatively young massive stars evolve . the red giant branch ( rgb )
is located between @xmath12 and 1.6 , and extends brightward to @xmath13 .
the color of the rgb can be used to place constraints on the metallicity of stars in phoenix , and the brightness of the tip can be used as a distance indicator . if we adopt a distance modulus of @xmath14 ( held _ et al . _ 1999 ,
and see below ) , then the mean color of the red giant branch at @xmath15 ( @xmath16 ) is @xmath17 , or @xmath18 . using the calibration of da costa & armandroff ( 1990 ) between @xmath19 at @xmath20 and [ fe / h ] , gives a mean metallicity for the phoenix red giants of [ fe / h ] @xmath21 .
our estimate of the mean metallicity of phoenix is in good agreement with the result of held _ et al . _ ( 1999 ) , @xmath22 dex lower than that of martinez - delgado _ et al . _ ( 1999 ) , and 0.13 dex higher than that of van de rydt _ et al . _
( 1991 ) . with an absolute visual magnitude of @xmath23 ( pritchett & van den bergh 1999 )
, phoenix falls very close to the [ fe / h ] versus @xmath24 relation obtained by caldwell _ et al . _ ( 1992 ) for local group dwarf elliptical and spheroidal galaxies .
the giant branch at @xmath15 is @xmath25 mag wide in @xmath26 .
if this is assumed to be entirely due to a metallicity spread within an ancient stellar population then the calibration of da costa & armandroff ( 1990 ) indicates a metallicity spread within phoenix of [ fe / h ] @xmath27 to @xmath28 however , two effects complicate the above determination of the mean metallicity and metallicity spread of phoenix from giant branch colors .
first , the blue edge of the giant branch is likely to include some asymptotic giant branch stars .
second , and probably more important , the giant branch color is a function of age as well as metallicity , in that younger giants are bluer than older ones . at fixed metallicity but mixed ages ,
the giant branch color derived from assuming an exclusively old population will underestimate the mean metallicity , and the giant branch width will overestimate the metallicity spread . however , if ages and metallicity are correlated , as would occur if younger populations are enhanced in metals , the true metallicity spread can be significantly _ larger _ than that inferred from the giant branch width assuming an exclusively old population .
although there is some uncertainty about the metallicity depending on the age , there is still an upper limit which can be placed on the metallicity of any component of the population .
even if the entire population was young ( less than a few gyr ) , the color of the giant branch would still require a metallicity less than [ fe / h ] @xmath29 -0.7 based on recent padova isochrones ( girardi _ et al . _ 2000 ,
girardi _ et al . _
this is demonstrated in figure [ fig : isorgb ] , which shows the phoenix cmd with isochrones for ages 1.6 , 3.2 , 6.4 , and 12.8 gyr at @xmath30 and @xmath31 . in order for the rgb to be consistent with a metallicity of z=0.004 ( [ fe / h ] = -0.7 ) ,
the padova isochrones indicate that the ages of rgb stars would have to be less than 2 gyr .
the deep hst data allow us to constrain the population further , since the red giant branch of phoenix is found to be well populated right down to @xmath32 , _
i.e. _ , down to the luminosities expected for the base of the rgb of a 13 gyr @xmath30 stellar population .
this demonstrates conclusively that not all the stars are young . within the allowed range of metallicity , giants which are
this faint must be older than @xmath29 6 gyr , based on comparisons with the padova isochrones ; for such ages , the dependence of giant branch color on age is relatively weak . since a significant fraction of the red giants
must be relatively old , the isochrones indicate that they must also be relatively metal - poor , _
i.e. _ [ fe / h ] @xmath33 -1.7
. a more quantitative discussion of the metallicity spread within phoenix requires analysis of the relative numbers of younger and older stars .
this is discussed further below . however , in terms of both the mean metallicity and the extension to faint magnitudes , the rgb of phoenix is consistent with this galaxy containing a substantial component of stars analogous to population ii of the milky way .
the magnitude of the tip of the red giant branch can be used as a distance indicator for metal - poor populations .
the accuracy of this technique in the current data set may be limited by the relatively small number of stars ; one might expect that the tip magnitude derived from the relatively smaller number of stars in the wfpc2 frame would be fainter than a true tip magnitude , since our tip is essentially defined by the single brightest red giant .
still , we find an apparent tip magnitude of @xmath34 , which is essentially identical to the tip magnitude derived by held _
et al . _ ( 1999 ) and just @xmath29 0.1 mag fainter than the rgb tip determined by martinez - delgado _ et al . _ ( 1999 ) , both from ground - based photometry .
we adopt an absolute magnitude of @xmath35 for the tip ( lee _ et al . _
1993 ) and a reddening of @xmath36 ( burstein & heiles 1982 ) , giving e(v - i ) = 0.026 ( @xmath37 ) .
this yields a distance modulus for phoenix based on the tip of the rgb of @xmath38 ; the error in this quantity is several percent based on uncertainties in the adopted extinction .
if the true tip is brighter than our brightest star , the distance modulus would be smaller .
our distance provides additional support for the derived trgb distances of held _ et al . _
( @xmath39 ) and martinez - delgado _ et al . _
( @xmath40 ) .
a horizontal branch ( hb ) can be discerned at @xmath41 and @xmath42 which merges with the red giant branch at @xmath43 .
there are well - defined blue ( bhb ) and red ( rhb ) components of the horizontal branch , separated by a gap which likely contains rr lyrae stars . at first glance the occurrence of a rhb in phoenix , which has a mean metallicity as low as [ fe / h ] @xmath44 ( _ i.e. _ , comparable to galactic globular clusters such as m13 and m3 )
, might indicate that phoenix is an example of a second - parameter stellar system .
however , if there is a metallicity spread , at least some of these rhb stars may have evolved from the most metal - rich old red giants in phoenix .
given that there is likely both an age and metallicity ( see below ) spread in phoenix , interpreting the morphology of the horizontal branch is a complex problem .
nevertheless , the presence of a distinct blue hb clearly indicates that there is an ancient population of stars in phoenix , as noted by tolstoy _
et al . _ ( 2000 ) .
the accurate wfpc2 photometry allows a measurement of the horizontal branch magnitude at @xmath45 . from ground - based photometry ,
et al . _ ( 1999 ) estimated the horizontal branch to be at @xmath46 . using the lee _
_ ( 1990 ) relation between the absolute visual hb magnitude and metallicity , our measurement gives a distance of @xmath47 , larger than the trgb method , but perhaps not in bad agreement given uncertainties in the hb calibration .
a young main sequence locus extends brightward to @xmath48 ( with a few even brighter stars ) or @xmath49 .
a similar blue plume with @xmath50 was found by martinez - delgado _ et al .
_ ( 1999 ) at magnitudes brighter than @xmath51 ( which corresponds to the faint limit of their photometry at @xmath52 ) , and is evident in the region @xmath53 and @xmath54 of fig .
12 of held _ et al .
_ ( 1999 ) . in these ground - based cmds
the main sequence population does not appear to be as prominent as seen in the wfpc2 cmd ; this may be an effect of larger photometric errors smearing out the ground - based observations of the main sequence and increasing incompleteness for bluer stars in the ground - based observations .
the accuracy of the wfpc2 photometry shows that the main sequence is well populated , and hence that the young star contribution to the total population of phoenix is significant , as will be shown quantitatively below .
figure [ fig : iso ] shows the padova isochrones for two ages ( 100 myr and 3.2 gyr ) and metallicities of @xmath30 and 0.004 .
the extension of the main sequence up to @xmath55 suggests that stars as young as 100 myr exist in phoenix , in good agreement with previous works ( martinez - delgado _ et al . _ 1999
et al . _
main sequence turnoff stars this bright would have masses of @xmath56 @xmath57 .
several points are apparent from figure [ fig : iso ] .
first , there are many stars which fall significantly redward of any of the zams isochrones .
the observed width ( in color ) of the upper main sequence is significantly larger than expected from observational errors ; from artificial star tests we find that magnitudes for the bulk of the stars are measured to an accuracy of a few percent down to @xmath58 .
the color spread of main sequence stars almost certainly implies that stars with a range of ages exist in phoenix ; it is highly unlikely that the color spread results entirely from metallicity spread , since very metal - rich stars would be required .
such a metal - rich population would produce giants significantly redder than any that are observed .
stars which fall redward of the zams are stars which are evolving off of the main sequence . despite the accurate photometry ,
there are no pronounced main sequence turnoffs in the cmd between ages of 100 myr and 4 gyr , suggesting that the young population in phoenix is _ not _ the result of one or several distinct bursts of star formation , but rather is the result of a more continuous star formation history over the past several gyr .
this is consistent with the analysis of martinez - delgado _ et al . _ ( 1999 ) , who estimate that the recent ( @xmath59 gyr ) star formation rate is comparable to the average star formation rate for the age interval 1 - 15 gyr .
it appears that the @xmath30 isochrone ( [ fe / h ] = @xmath60 , _ i.e. _ the metallicity inferred for the giants ) falls blueward of the main body of the main sequence , suggesting that the younger stars in phoenix have significantly higher metallicities than the older population .
this would imply that phoenix has undergone chemical enrichment over its lifetime .
this suggestion is supported by the giant branch colors as well ; if all of the stars in phoenix had [ fe / h ] @xmath29 -1.7 , the younger giants would be bluer than any of the observed giants .
a clear red clump of stars exists near the intersection of the horizontal branch with the red giant branch .
these are intermediate age ( several gyr ) core helium burning stars , and confirm the existence of an intermediate age population suggested by the width of the main sequence .
a sequence of red helium - burning stars ( with ages of around 0.4 - 0.8 gyr ) extends vertically upwards from the red end of the horizontal branch to an @xmath61 magnitude comparable to the tip of the red giant branch .
this sequence is located about 0.2 mag blueward of the @xmath30 rgb isochrones .
these are younger stars in the reddest stage of the so - called `` blue loops '' of later stellar evolution .
there is a hint of a sequence corresponding to the blue end of the blue loops ; this sequence slopes towards the main sequence and although it has only a few stars , it is defined by the observation that there are gaps around it in the cmd , suggesting that these stars are not foreground stars .
the exact details of the ages of these stars is difficult to ascertain without knowledge of their metallicities .
intermediate - age ( 1 - 10 gyr ) asymptotic giant branch stars are seen in cmds of dwarf irregular galaxies such as ic 1613 ( cole _ et al . _
1999 ) , sextans a ( dohm - palmer _
et al . _
1997 ) , and ngc 6822 ( gallart _ et al . _ 1996
) , where they extend redward of @xmath62 from the region of the tip of the first ascent giant branch .
there are few such stars apparent in the phoenix cmd of figure [ fig : cmd ]
. however , held _
et al . _ ( 1999 ) found a significant number of such stars in their ground - based cmd and they concluded on this basis that intermediate - age stars constitute a substantial component of phoenix ; additional evidence for the presence of agb stars is discussed by martinez - delgado _ et al . _ ( 1999 ) .
given that stars of many different ages are present in phoenix , it is of interest to know the relative number of stars at different ages , or alternatively , the history of the star formation rate . to some extent ,
the answer to this question depends on where one looks in phoenix , since it is apparent from larger field studies ( held _ et al . _ 1999 , martinez - delgado _ et al . _
1999 ) that the star formation history varies across the galaxy , with younger stars being more centrally concentrated . here
we consider somewhat more quantitatively the approximate star formation history that is required to match the populations seen in the central region of phoenix imaged by hst / wfpc2 .
we can also try to quantitatively address the relative numbers of stars of different metallicities .
there are many complications to extracting star formation histories from the distribution of stars in a cmd , and several groups have developed different methods for doing so ( _ e.g. _ , tolstoy & saha 1996 ; dolphin 1997 ; hernandez , valls - gabaud , & gilmore 1999 ; ng 1998 ; gallart _ et al . _ 1999
; holtzman _ et al . _
1999 ) . in the current paper
, we analyze our cmd based on the methods of holtzman _
et al . _ ( 1999 ) , in which the number of stars in many regions of the cmd are fit using least - squares techniques to a combination of basis functions of stellar populations of different ages and metallicities .
the best fit was derived using the @xmath63 estimator of mighell ( 1999 ) .
the interpretation of derived star formation histories , and in particular an understanding of the uncertainties in the results , is a complex issue .
detailed comparisons of results obtained by using different methods have not yet been performed , and the sensitivity of the results to systematic errors , _
e.g. _ , in the input stellar models or assumed initial mass function ( imf ) , is difficult to assess .
consequently , the results presented here should be viewed as preliminary ; we attempt to assess uncertainties by showing results not only for different parameters , but also using different subsets of the observed data to derive star formation histories . for the current purpose
, we derive a star formation history assuming an imf with the salpeter ( 1955 ) slope .
since we do not sample the lower main sequence of completely unevolved stars , independent constraints on the imf slope are difficult .
we also assume that unresolved binaries are not important in the observed cmd of phoenix , which will be the case regardless of the true binary fraction in the galaxy if the masses of binary stars are drawn independently from the same initial mass function .
this is because the most likely companion masses in this case are significantly lower than the masses of the stars which are observed and thus do not strongly affect the system luminosity or color
. the issue of whether masses in binary star pairs are uncorrelated or not is still the matter of significant debate .
we derive star formation histories for different age bins , where the width of the age bins increases logarithmically with lookback time .
this is necessitated by the fact that it becomes increasingly difficult to resolve ( in a temporal sense ) star formation events as one goes to older ages , since isochrones become more and more similar for older ages . as a result
, the derived star formation histories can not provide information about the variation of the star formation rate on time scales shorter than the width of the age bins , roughly 25% of the age of any given population . within each age bin
, the star formation rate is assumed to be constant .
star formation histories were extracted from the phoenix cmd for five different choices of distance modulus : @xmath64 , 23.0 , 23.1 , 23.2 , and 23.3 .
using @xmath65 , the distance as derived from our trgb , gave the best fits ( lowest @xmath66 ) , although they were only marginally better than those using @xmath40 .
for the reasons discussed above , it was not possible to find good fits to the cmd using an exclusively metal - poor population , or for that matter , using any star formation history in which the metallicity does not change over time .
this is because the giant branch requires a metal - poor population , while the main sequence requires a population of higher metallicity . as a result
, we imposed no constraints on an age - metallicity relation to fit the phoenix population ; the constituent basis stellar populations cover all combinations of age and metallicity , although only seven discrete metallicities ( corresponding to those for which we have isochrones from the padova group ) were used .
results for our best - fitting model are shown in figure [ fig : sfh ] .
the upper left panel gives the best fitting star formation rate as a function of lookback time .
since we only cover a small region of the galaxy , this star formation history is given in a relative sense only ; the total number of stars formed is normalized to sum to unity .
the quality of the fit can be judged by looking at the residual hess diagram shown in the lower right .
this panel shows the difference between the number of observed and the number of stars in the best - fitting model , in units of the expected @xmath67 errors from counting statistics ; the diagram is scaled so that the range of black to white covers from @xmath68 to @xmath69 , where @xmath7 is defined based on the suggestions made by mighell ( 1999 ) .
other panels show the derived cumulative age and metallicity distribution functions , and a comparison of the observed and model luminosity functions . in general , results are more uncertain for the youngest populations ( @xmath70 gyr ) , since the stars that are uniquely contributed by these populations ( upper main sequence stars ) comprise a relatively small number of the stars in the color - magnitude diagram .
the lower left panel gives a representation of the `` population box '' ( hodge 1989 ) for the central regions of phoenix .
this combines information about the derived formation rate as a function of age and metallicity .
remarkably , without imposing any constraints on the age - metallicity relation , we recover a rough relation in which metallicity increases with time ; a similar result also emerged from a similar analysis of several fields in the lmc ( holtzman _ et al . _
this lends quantitative support to our suggestion that the metallicity in phoenix has evolved over time ; the derived metallicity distribution is shown in the upper right panel .
the population box may also highlight some problems with the models as well ; the observed color - magnitude diagram appears to require a small population of young metal - poor stars .
the presence of this feature comes from the existence of a few relatively blue upper main sequence stars , so it is difficult to know for sure how seriously to consider them ; accurate photometry over a larger field is required .
a comprehensive understanding of the uncertainties in the results presented in figure [ fig : sfh ] is difficult .
the formal errors on the derived star formation rates are relatively small , usually 5 - 10% for most of the age bins ( larger for the youngest ages ) .
however , the true uncertainties are probably significantly larger and systematic , depending on the choice of constituent basis stellar populations , distance , reddening , imf , stellar models , the use of discrete metallicities , and the details of how the best fit is defined .
our experience with allowing these to vary suggests that while the star formation rate in individual age bins can vary significantly ( factor of two ) , the variations are correlated such that changes in derived star formation rate for one stellar population are generally accompanied by nearly opposite changes in other similiar ( _ i.e. _ , in age or metallicity ) populations . as a result
, the cumulative age distribution tends to be relatively robust against systematic errors .
this is demonstrated in figure [ fig : sfhcum ] , which shows cumulative age distributions for a variety of models .
the solid curves all use the same distance modulus , but are determined using different subsets of the observed data : results were derived using two different faint magnitude cutoffs ( @xmath71 and @xmath72 ) for the region of the cmd which was fit and using both the complete data set as well as using randomly selected subsamples of half the observed stars .
the dotted curves show the systematic changes resulting from using different distance moduli , although the extremes of these choices ( @xmath73 and 23.3 ) provide noticeably poorer fits .
our overall conclusion is that the cmd of phoenix requires star formation to have been ongoing at a roughly constant rate over a hubble time .
the fits suggest that the bulk of the stars even in the central region of phoenix are older than @xmath29 5 gyr .
the details of fluctuations in the overall star formation rate are significantly more uncertain .
although the fit in figure [ fig : sfh ] suggests some fluctuations in the star formation rate , we feel that the actual evidence for strong variations is weak , although they are certainly not ruled out .
different choices of population parameters ( _ e.g. _ , distance ) or what regions of the cmd are fit can change the timing and amplitude of these fluctuations . as a result
, it is less clear as to what the current results show about whether the star formation rate in phoenix is episodic .
however , it is clear from an inspection of the cmd that there are no distinct main sequence turnoffs as can be seen , for example , in the cmds of the carina dwarf spheroidal ( smecker - hane _ et al . _ 1996 ) .
one of the main reasons for uncertainties in the details of the star formation history comes from the age - metallicity degeneracy of the location of stars around the turnoff in a cmd ; different combinations of age and metallicity can place stars at the same location in the cmd . without the presence of the unevolved lower main sequence in the current data or independent measurement of metallicities
, it becomes difficult to accurately separate these different populations .
the situation would be improved with significantly deeper photometry and/or with the measurement of independent metallicities for individual stars in phoenix .
deep hst / wfpc2 imaging has provided a color - magnitude diagram ( cmd ) of the central regions of the phoenix dwarf galaxy at unprecedented accuracy .
the presence of stars at all ages is apparent in this diagram . a distinct horizontal branch and the presence of a red giant branch which extends all the way down to a turnoff expected for an old population indicates that this system has a substantial component of metal - poor stars with metallicities comparable to the mean of the galactic halo ; phoenix appears to have an underlying component of ancient population ii stars . in this respect
it is similar to dwarf spheroidal galaxies like ursa minor , draco , and sculptor , as previously concluded by held _
et al . _ ( 1999 ) , martinez - delgado _ et al . _ ( 1999 ) , and tolstoy _ et al . _ ( 2000 ) .
however , the existence of red clump stars and main sequence stars confirm that phoenix has experienced considerable star formation over the past few gyr , with star formation possibly as recent as 100 myr ago .
the location of the main sequence suggests that the metallicity in phoenix has evolved with time ; old blue horizontal branch stars and the giant branch stars require low metallicities , comparable to those in the halo of the milky way , while the younger main sequence stars suggest somewhat higher metallicities
. fits to the observed cmd suggest that star formation has been roughly continuous over the lifetime of phoenix .
there is no obvious evidence for strongly episodic star formation , although the formal fits for the star formation history suggest that a mildly varying star formation rate can certainly fit the data .
one caveat to this statement is that it applies only over relatively long ( _ e.g. _ , gyr ) timescales ; burstiness on very short timescales would be essentially impossible to distinguish from the cmd for all but the most recent past .
another caveat is that the details of the derived star formation rate are suspect due to a variety of reasons including the age - metallicity degeneracy ; independent measurements of metallicities of stars in phoenix should improve the situation considerably .
the implications are that a dwarf galaxy can have star formation which extends over nearly a hubble time . with roughly continuous star formation
, phoenix appears to resemble the magellanic clouds ( _ e.g. _ , holtzman _
et al . _
1999 ) . however , phoenix is a significantly less massive system in which it might be expected that the loss of interstellar gas and interruptions in star formation would be much more important .
in fact , the apparent star formation history of phoenix stands in contrast to the strongly episodic star formation of carina ( smecker - hane _ et al . _ 1994 , 1996 ,
hurley - keller _ et al . _
1998 ) , a dwarf galaxy that is only 0.8 mag fainter than phoenix ( mateo 1998 ) .
it appears that the mechanisms governing star formation in dwarf galaxies may be rather complex .
the hst / wfpc2 data on phoenix add support to the growing evidence in the literature that dwarf galaxies , both dirrs and dsphs , can have very varied star formation histories , particularly in recent epochs .
by contrast , it may be possible that there is at least some commonality between dwarf galaxies in regard to their early chemical evolution . as noted in section 3.1
, phoenix appears to follow the same integrated - magnitude versus metallicity relation as dwarf spheroidal galaxies in the local group , some of which , like draco and ursa minor , do not appear to have supported recent star formation such as that of phoenix .
nonetheless the degree of chemical enrichment in these systems , as indicated by the color of the old giant branch , would appear to be correlated with the overall ( luminous ) mass of the galaxy .
this suggests that the amount of metal enrichment during the earliest phases of star formation within dwarf galaxies ( perhaps more than @xmath74 gyr ago ) does vary in a way that depends to some extent on basic galaxy properties such as mass . in classical closed box models of chemical evolution
the average metallicity of all stars formed up to a given time is proportional to the fraction by mass of the galaxy that has turned into stars ( _ e.g. _ , smith 1985 ) . within the context of such a model ,
the observations indicate that the fraction of a galaxy which is turned into old metal - poor stars , and the attendant early chemical evolution history , is governed by similar mechanisms in both dsph and dirr galaxies .
support for this work was provided by nasa through grant number go-0698.02 - 95a from the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , incorporated , under nasa contract nas5 - 26555 .
burstein , d. & heiles , c. 1982 , aj , 87 , 1165 caldwell , n. , armandroff , t. e. , seitzer , p. , & da costa , g. s. 1992 , aj , 103 , 840 canterna , r. , & flower , p. j. 1977 , apj , 212 , l57 carignan , c. , demers , s. , & cote , s. 1991 , apj 381 , l13 cole , a. a. , _ et al . _ 1999 ,
aj , 118 , 1657 da costa , g. s. , & armandroff , t. e. 1990 , aj , 100 , 162 dohm - palmer , r. c. , skillman , e. d. , saha , a. , tolstoy , e. , mateo , m. , gallagher , j. , hoessel , j. , chiosi , c. , & dufour , r. j. 1997 , aj , 114 , 2514 dolphin , a. 1997 , newa , 2 , 397 dolphin , a. 2000 , pasp , in press gallart , c. , aparicio , a. , bertelli , g. , & chiosi , c. 1996 , aj , 112 , 1950 gallart , c. , freedman , w. l. , aparicio , a. , bertelli , g. , & chiosi , c. 1999 , aj , 118 , 2245 girardi , l. , bressan , a. , bertelli , g. , & chiosi , c. 2000 , a&as 141 , 371 girardi , l. , bressan , a. , chiosi , c. , bertelli , g. , & nasi , e. 1996 , a&as 117 , 113 held , e. v. , saviane , i. , & momany , y. 1999 , a&a , 345 , 747 hernandez , x. , valls - gabaud , d. , & gilmore , g. 1999 , mnras , 304 , 705 hodge , p. 1989
, ara&a , 27 , 139 holtzman , j. a. , burrows , c. j. , casertano , s. , hester , j.j . , trauger , j. t. , watson , a. m. , worthey , g. , & the wfpc2 idt 1995 , pasp , 107 , 1065 holtzman , j. a. , mould , j. r. , gallagher , j.s . , watson , a. m. , grillmair , c. j. , & the wfpc2 idt 1995 , aj , 113 , 656 holtzman , j. a. , gallagher , j.s . , cole , a.a .
, mould , j.r . , grillmair , c.j . , &
the wfpc2 idt 1999 , aj , 118 , 2262 hurley - keller , d. , mateo , m. , & nemec , j. , 1998 , aj , 115 , 1840 lee , y.w . , demarque , p. , & zinn , r. 1990 , apj 350 , 155 lee , m. g. , freedman , w. l. , & madore , b. f. 1993 , apj , 417 , 553 martinez - delgado , d. , gallart , c. , & aparicio , a. 1999 , aj , 118 , 862 mateo , m. 1998 , ara&a , 36 , 435 mighell , k.j . , 1999 , apj , 518 , 380 ng , y. k. 1998 , a&as , 132 , 133 ortolani , s. , & gratton , r. g. 1988 , pasp , 100 , 1405 pritchett , c. j. , & van den bergh , s. 1999 , aj , 118 , 883 salpeter , e. e. 1955 , apj , 121 , 161 schuster , h. e. , & west , r. m. 1976 , a&a , 49 , 129 smecker - hane , t. a. , stetson , p. b. , hesser , j. e. , & lehnert , m. d. 1994 , aj , 108 , 507 smecker - hane , t. a. , stetson , p. b. , hesser , j. e. , & vandenberg , d. a. 1996 , in from stars to galaxies : the impact of stellar physics on galaxy evolution , asp conf .
98 , eds . c. leitherer , u. fritze - von - alvensleben , & j. huchra ( san francisco : asp ) , p. 328
smith , g. h. 1985 , pasp , 97 , 1058 stetson , p.b .
1987 , pasp 99 , 191 st - germain , j. , carignan , c. , cote , s. , & oosterloo , t. 1999 , aj , 118 , 1235 tolstoy , e. , gallagher , j. , greggio , l. , tosi , m. , de marchi , g. , romaniello , m. , minniti , d. , & zijlstra , a. 2000 , the messenger , 99 , 16 tolstoy , e. , & saha , a. 1996 , apj , 462 , 672 van de rydt , f. , demers , s. , & kunkel , w. e. 1991 , aj , 102 , 130 young , l. , & lo , k.y .
1997 , apj 490 , 710 c c c + + dataset&filter&exposure time ( s ) + u48i0201r&f814w&100 + u48i0202m&f814w&1300 + u48i0203r&f814w&1000 + u48i0204r&f555w&100 + u48i0205r&f555w&1300 + u48i0206r&f555w&1100 + u48i0207r&f555w&100 + u48i0208r&f555w&1300 + u48i0209r&f555w&1000 + u48i020ar&f814w&100 + u48i020br&f814w&1300 + u48i020cr&f814w&1100 + | we present hst / wfpc2 photometry of the central regions of the phoenix dwarf .
accurate photometry allows us to : 1 ) confirm the existence of the horizontal branch previously detected by ground - based observations , and use it to determine a distance to phoenix , 2 ) clearly detect the existence of multiple ages in the stellar population of phoenix , 3 ) determine a mean metallicity of the old red giant branch stars in phoenix , and suggest that phoenix has evolved chemically over its lifetime , 4 ) extract a rough star formation history for the central regions which suggests that phoenix has been forming stars roughly continuously over its entire lifetime . |
in astrophysical plasmas , such as the solar corona , the three - dimensional ( 3d ) magnetic field topology is often highly complex . in such complex 3d magnetic fields , where traditional two - dimensional ( 2d ) x - point magnetic reconnection models may no longer be applicable , determining the sites at which dynamic phenomena and energy release may occur is a crucial and non - trivial problem .
due to the typically very high lundquist number , such events occur only at locations where intense currents ( singular under an ideal mhd evolution ) may form .
one such site is a 3d magnetic null point ( e.g. refs .
the nature of current sheet formation at such 3d nulls is investigated here .
3d null points are predicted to be present in abundance in the solar corona ( e.g. refs . [ ] ) .
furthermore , there is observational evidence that reconnection at a 3d null may be important in some solar flares @xcite , as well as in eruptive phenomena in active regions @xcite .
in addition , the first in situ observation @xcite of reconnection occurring at a 3d null point in the earth s magnetotail has recently been made by the cluster spacecraft .
moreover , current growth at 3d nulls has been observed in the laboratory @xcite .
the magnetic field topology and geometry in the vicinity of such a null can be described by the two sets of field lines which asymptotically approach , or recede from , the null .
a pair of field lines approach ( recede from ) the null from opposite directions , defining the ` spine ' ( or @xmath0-line ) of the null .
in addition , an infinite family of field lines recede from ( approach ) the null in a surface known as the fan ( or @xmath1- ) plane ( see refs . [ ] ) . to this point , many studies of the mhd behaviour of 3d nulls have been kinematic , see e.g. refs .
[ ] . however , a few solutions to the full set of mhd equations do exist for reconnection at current sheets located at 3d nulls , in incompressible plasmas .
these incompressible solutions are based upon the technique first proposed by craig & henton @xcite for the 2d reconnection problem .
the solutions describe steady - state current sheets aligned to the fan and spine of the null @xcite .
time - dependent solutions for the fan current sheets also exist @xcite . in a previous paper
[ ] , hereafter referred to as paper i we investigated the behaviour of 3d null points which are subjected to shearing boundary motions , and found that current sheets formed at the null . in this paper
we consider the effect of moving from the compressible towards the incompressible limit , which is found to have a profound effect on both the quantitative and qualitative properties of the current sheet .
this is highly relevant when it comes to comparing the observed current sheet formation with the analytical models , which must by necessity invoke various simplifications . typically , the plasma in the solar atmosphere or earth s magnetosphere is compressible
. thus it is of great interest to understand the relationship between this regime and the incompressible approximation , upon which much of the previous theory has been based .
the remainder of the paper is set out as follows . in sec .
[ idealgas ] we briefly review the previous results of paper i. in sec . [ fansheets ] we describe simulations in which we move towards the incompressible limit , and in sec .
[ analytical ] , we discuss the relation of our results to analytical incompressible solutions , and the implications for their dynamic accessibility . in sec .
[ fandrivesec ] we consider the case where we drive across the fan instead of across the spine of the null , and finally in sec .
[ conc ] we present a summary .
in paper i , we discussed the evolution of the magnetic field in the vicinity of a generic 3d magnetic null .
we demonstrated by means of a kinematic solution that an evolution of the null which acts to change the angle between the spine and fan ( such that the ratios of the null eigenvalues change in time ) is prohibited in ideal mhd .
we then went on to present the results of numerical simulations , which demonstrated the formation of strong current concentrations at the null in response to boundary perturbations .
simulation runs based on the same numerical code are presented below ( for further details on the numerical scheme , see refs .
[ ] ) . at @xmath2 the magnetic field in the domain is given by @xmath3 , which defines a 3d null whose spine lies along the @xmath4-axis , and whose fan is in the @xmath5 plane .
@xmath6 , and so taking the density ( @xmath7 ) and internal energy ( @xmath8 ) of the plasma to be uniform at @xmath2 we begin with an equilibrium [ we take @xmath9 , @xmath10 , where @xmath11 is a constant which determines the plasma-@xmath11 ( which is of course spatially dependent ) and @xmath0 is the ratio of specific heats ] .
all of the domain boundaries are line - tied , and are located at @xmath12=[\pm x_l , \pm y_l , \pm z_l]$ ] .
the configuration is then perturbed by imposing a plasma flow on the @xmath4-boundaries , while the @xmath13- and @xmath14-boundaries are placed sufficiently far away that there is insufficient time for information to propagate to them and back to the null before the simulations are halted .
a single time unit in the simulations is equivalent to the alfv ' en travel time across a unit length in a plasma of density @xmath9 and uniform magnetic field of modulus 1 .
the resistivity is taken to be uniform , with its value being based upon the dimensions of the domain .
note that at @xmath2 , @xmath15 is scale - free as it is linear , and thus , the actual value of @xmath16 is somewhat arbitrary until we fix a physical length scale to associate with the size of our domain .
the boundary driving takes the form on each boundary of two distorted vortices of opposite sense , which combine to provide the desired effect of advecting the spine in the @xmath17 direction , in opposite senses on opposite boundaries ( @xmath18 ) [ see paper i , eq . ( 19 ) and fig .
2(b ) ] . in the majority of the runs
described , the driving profile is transient , with its time dependence defined by @xmath19 @xmath20 , @xmath21 constant , so that the driving switches on at @xmath2 and off again at @xmath22 .
the result is that a current concentration forms at the null , which is expected to be singular in the ideal limit @xcite . during the early evolution , a stagnation flow , accelerated by the lorentz force ( but opposed by the plasma pressure )
acts to close up the spine and fan towards one another locally at the null .
the initial null is unstable to such a collapse of the spine and fan in any plane containing the spine , with the @xmath23 plane being selected by the orientation of the boundary driving .
it is precisely this collapse that was shown in the kinematic solution earlier in the paper to be prohibited under ideal mhd .
thus it must be facilitated by non - ideal processes . due to this local collapse , a current sheet forms which typically spans the collapsed spine and fan , with a tendency to spread along the fan surface ( especially for weaker driving ) .
accompanying the current growth is the development of a component of @xmath24 parallel to @xmath15 ( @xmath25 ) , signifying a breakdown of ideal behaviour , and magnetic reconnection .
the integral of this quantity along the magnetic field line in the fan perpendicular to the shear plane can be shown to give a physically meaningful measure of the reconnection rate giving the rate of flux transfer across the fan ( separatrix ) surface , see ref .
an examination of the quantitative properties of the current sheet showed that the peak current , peak reconnection rate , and sheet dimensions all scale linearly with the modulus of the driving velocity .
in addition , under continual boundary shearing , the current sheet appears to grow in size and modulus indefinitely ( rather than being controlled by any self - regulating mechanism ) .
this type of behaviour is also observed in 2d ` forced ' or ` driven ' reconnection simulations .
the nature of the current sheet seems to be controlled at all times by the degree of boundary displacement of the spine and fan ( and how quickly this displacement is attained ) , and so it may share some properties ( at a given time ) with the 2d ` non - uniform reconnection ' regimes ( see ref .
[ ] for a review ) .
care should be taken , however , in drawing parallels with either of these 2d models , since each involves an inflow of plasma through the boundaries .
by contrast , in our simulations the driving velocity is imposed parallel to the boundaries . in paper
i we considered the case of a monatomic ideal gas , that is we took the ratio of specific heats , @xmath26 .
it is straightforward to see that the incompressible limit may be reached formally by letting @xmath27 .
taking the time - derivative of the polytropic equation of state , @xmath28 , and substituting for @xmath29 using the continuity equation gives @xmath30
we repeat here the simulations described in paper i , with increased values of @xmath0 .
this is somewhat problematic numerically ( due to the increased wave speeds in the system ) , but in fact it turns out that even for moderately large values of @xmath0 , the differences are striking .
the parameters chosen for the simulation runs closely follow those taken in paper i , and are as follows . we take
@xmath31 , the driving strength @xmath32 , @xmath33 , @xmath34 ( boundary driving localisation ) , @xmath35 , @xmath36 , and the numerical domain has dimensions @xmath37 , @xmath38 .
the resolution of the simulations is @xmath39 , on a non - uniform mesh with smallest grid spacing near the null to achieve higher resolution there ; @xmath40 and @xmath41 .
( a ) at 50@xmath42 of maximum , at the time of its temporal peak , for ( a ) @xmath26 , ( b ) @xmath43 and ( c ) @xmath44.,title="fig : " ] ( b ) at 50@xmath42 of maximum , at the time of its temporal peak , for ( a ) @xmath26 , ( b ) @xmath43 and ( c ) @xmath44.,title="fig : " ] + ( c ) at 50@xmath42 of maximum , at the time of its temporal peak , for ( a ) @xmath26 , ( b ) @xmath43 and ( c ) @xmath44.,title="fig : " ] in the @xmath23 plane , at the time of its temporal peak , for ( a ) @xmath26 , ( b ) @xmath43 and ( c ) @xmath44.,title="fig : " ] in the @xmath23 plane , at the time of its temporal peak , for ( a ) @xmath26 , ( b ) @xmath43 and ( c ) @xmath44.,title="fig : " ] in the @xmath23 plane , at the time of its temporal peak , for ( a ) @xmath26 , ( b ) @xmath43 and ( c ) @xmath44.,title="fig : " ] as the driving begins ( @xmath2 ) , a disturbance propagates along the spine ( and nearby field lines ) , and focuses at the null . for @xmath26 , the null point ` collapses ' with the spine and fan closing up towards one another .
a strongly focused current sheet spans the spine and fan .
however , for larger values of @xmath0 , the current concentration distributes itself along the fan surface , becoming more weakly focused at the null for increasing @xmath0 ( see figs .
[ jisos ] , [ jxy ] ) .
furthermore , the fan surface remains increasingly planar at larger @xmath0 ( see fig . [ jxy ] ) , and also the spine and fan do not collapse towards each other to the same extent .
this is demonstrated in fig .
[ scaling](f ) , where the minimum angle between the spine and fan ( @xmath45 ) is plotted for runs with various values of @xmath0 .
we observe that even for @xmath44 , although the current sheet is approximately planar ( at @xmath5 ) , the minimum angle between the spine and fan is still significantly less than @xmath46 .
this is because the spine is still driven towards the fan by the boundary driving ( most of the stress from which is taken up in the weak field region around the null itself ) , even though the fan remains approximately in the @xmath5 plane rather than collapsing sympathetically towards the spine .
it is worth noting that the above described behaviour also depends on other parameters in the simulation .
for example , how effectively the null collapses is also dependent on the driving speed , with greater collapse and stronger focusing of the current sheet for larger @xmath20 ( see paper i ) .
therefore larger values of @xmath0 are likely to be required in order to render the fan approximately planar for larger @xmath20 , and also for larger @xmath21 ( longer driving time ) .
the plasma-@xmath11 is also a crucial parameter , since we find that increasing @xmath11 has a very similar effect to increasing @xmath0 .
it is natural to expect this on physical grounds , since increasing either parameter has the effect of increasing the sound speed , and reducing the effect of magnetic forces in plasma compression . finally , since the null collapse is driven by the lorentz force , a thinner more intense current sheet , which will form for a lower value of @xmath16 , will increase the degree of collapse .
thus , the extent to which the null collapses and the current focusses at the null is dependent on a combination of the driving velocity ( @xmath20 , @xmath21 ) and the plasma parameters @xmath0 , @xmath11 and @xmath16 .
an obvious question when examining the above results is whether the planar current sheet in the fan plane for large @xmath0 is a result of the symmetry of the configuration , with the null at the centre of the domain and the fan plane parallel to the driving boundaries .
we therefore re - ran the simulations at large @xmath0 with the null point rotated by a finite angle in the @xmath47-plane ( so that the spine and fan were no longer parallel to the boundaries ) . in this case ,
a planar current sheet still forms in the fan , and thus our results seem general in this respect .
accompanying the changing current localisation as we move towards the incompressible limit is a change in the behaviour of the plasma flow .
this again signifies the fact that the fan of the null remains increasingly planar . for @xmath26 ,
a stagnation flow is typically set up , which is accelerated by the lorentz force ( and opposed by the plasma pressure gradient ) , and which closes up the spine and fan .
however , for larger @xmath0 this flow is absent , and instead @xmath48 is approximately zero , and the flow is roughly parallel with the driving boundaries ( see fig .
[ vxy ] ) . plane at @xmath49 , for ( a ) @xmath26 and ( b ) @xmath44 .
background shading shows @xmath50.,title="fig : " ] plane at @xmath49 , for ( a ) @xmath26 and ( b ) @xmath44 .
background shading shows @xmath50.,title="fig : " ] finally , it should be noted that all of the above considerations are the same as for the case of a 2d x - point .
that is , repeating the above simulations but with the magnetic field at @xmath2 defined by @xmath51 , we see the same trend . for
@xmath26 the x - point collapses , forming a current sheet which locally spans the two separatrices ( a ` y - point ' appearance ) , but for large @xmath0 the x - point collapse is suppressed , and the current spreads along the ( unsheared ) separatrix ( as in ref . [ ] ) .
it is not only the qualitative properties of the current sheet which are affected by changing the plasma compressibility .
accompanying the spreading of the current sheet along the fan for increased @xmath0 is a decrease in the peak current and reconnection rate in the simulation , see fig .
[ scaling](a , b ) . of ( a )
the peak current ( @xmath52 ) , ( b ) the peak reconnection rate ( @xmath53 ) , ( c , d , e ) the current sheet fwhm at time of peak current ( @xmath54 ) and ( f ) the minimum angle between the spine and fan ( @xmath45 ) , where the dashed line indicates the value @xmath55 .
] the rate of change of each quantity around @xmath26 is much greater than that around @xmath44 , implying that even for this moderate value of @xmath0 , the behaviour is already a fairly good approximation to the incompressible limit ( for all other parameters fixed ) .
the change in geometry of the current sheet is evidenced by the variation in the dimensions of the region of high @xmath50 , @xmath56 , @xmath57 and @xmath58 ( measured at the time of current maximum , by the full - width - at - half - maximum ( fwhm ) in each coordinate direction ) . @xmath57 and @xmath58 increase with @xmath0 , showing how the current spreads along the fan surface as we move towards the incompressible limit [ fig .
[ scaling](d , e ) ] . on the other hand
, @xmath56 decreases as @xmath0 increases , demonstrating that the null point collapse is inhibited [ fig .
[ scaling](c ) ] .
even for @xmath59 , @xmath56 essentially measures the current sheet ` thickness ' .
we now investigate the relation between our simulation results and previous analytical solutions for incompressible plasmas . in the steady - state solutions of craig _
_ @xcite the assumption of incompressibility leads to a symmetry between @xmath15 and @xmath60 in the mhd equations .
progress is then made by defining a 3d current - free ` background field ' , upon which disturbance fields of low - dimensionality are super - imposed .
this necessarily results in current sheets which are also of reduced dimensionality .
the solutions are sometimes referred to as ` reconnective annihilation'@xcite , since they contain current sheets of infinite extent in at least one direction , and as a result the plasma advects field lines across either the spine or the fan , but they only diffuse towards the other of these ( through the current sheet ) .
it might be expected that the infinite nature of the current sheets is due to the severe analytical restriction of low - dimensionality ` disturbance fields ' . however , as we have seen above , applying shearing boundary motions to the spine footpoints of the null indeed results in a quasi - planar current sheet in the fan plane , albeit only for large @xmath0 . of great importance for any steady - state solution
is its dynamic accessibility under a time - dependent evolution .
investigations into the dynamic accessibility of two - dimensional @xcite solutions have been carried out by various authors ( e.g. refs . [ ] ) .
the results of the previous section provide strong evidence that in a fully dynamic and fully 3d ( yet incompressible ) system , the fan current sheet solutions are indeed dynamically accessible .
one further question which presents itself here is whether in fact the spine current solutions are also dynamically accessible . in the analytical solutions , a tubular spine current results from shearing perturbations of the fan plane
this is investigated in section [ fandrivesec ] .
it appears that in the incompressible limit , fan current solutions are dynamically accessible , and ( at least qualitatively ) provide an accurate snapshot of the dynamical and fully 3d behaviour .
however , in the case of a compressible plasma this appears not to be the case . in order to understand why this is
, we must examine the force balance which exists in the analytical solutions .
the method of the analytical solutions is based upon taking the vector product ( ` curl ' ) of the momentum equation , and solving this in conjunction with the induction equation .
the pressure can then be calculated _ a posteriori_. however , it has been realised @xcite that this places a limit on the maximum current ( or reconnection rate ) which can be attained in these ` flux - pile - up ' solutions , since the current sheet must be maintained by a large pressure at infinity . for current values above some limit
, the pressure required is unphysically large .
we can similarly examine the plasma pressure ( or pressure gradient ) which exists within the current sheet itself . in the steady - state fan current solution of craig _
@xcite , the magnetic and velocity fields are defined by @xmath61 @xmath62 @xmath63 , @xmath64 , @xmath65 constant , @xmath66 .
the pressure is found from the momentum equation , and the pressure gradient perpendicular to the fan plane is given by @xmath67 solving the induction equation for @xmath68 and @xmath69 ( see ref . [ ] ) reveals that in the current sheet , @xmath70 , @xmath71 .
thus in the current sheet we require a pressure gradient which scales as a negative power of @xmath16 , which becomes extremely large at realistic values of @xmath16 for astrophysical plasmas .
note though that the strongest pressure restriction occurs in the degenerate 2d case ( @xmath72 or @xmath73 ) .
once the pressure gradient can no longer accommodate the huge lorentz force within the sheet , the null point will begin to collapse , and the strict planar nature of the fan plane and current sheet will be lost ( note that the lorentz force always points in the direction which further closes the angle between spine and fan , while the pressure gradient acts in the opposite sense ) . with the symmetry of the system broken , the analytical solutions can no longer describe the behaviour , and we can expect the nature of the current sheet to be significantly altered .
a similar argument has been made by ma _
@xcite for the case of disturbances perpendicular to a 2d planar x - point
they found that once the strict symmetry of the system was broken , qualitatively very different behaviour resulted .
leaving the steady - state solutions and examining instead the time - dependent fan current sheet solutions @xcite , one arrives at a similar conclusion . in this case , the time - dependent pressure gradient force in the @xmath4-direction in the ideal localisation phase is given by @xmath74 for one disturbance component ( @xmath75 is a constant which determines the relative strengths of the background magnetic and plasma flow fields ) .
this peaks once resistive dissipation becomes important and the current density reaches a maximum value , when we have @xmath76 the contribution of the other disturbance component is obtained by replacing @xmath64 by @xmath77 in each of the above , @xmath78 .
thus the plasma pressure force in the @xmath4-direction ( or symmetry - breaking direction ) increases exponentially in time , in order to counteract the effect of the increasing lorentz force . for sufficiently small @xmath16
, the pressure force will no longer be able to balance the lorentz force during this localisation process , and the symmetry of the configuration will be lost .
the effect of the pressure gradient within our simulations is shown in fig .
[ gradp ] . here
, vectors of @xmath79 are plotted in the @xmath23 plane for @xmath44 at the time of the peak current .
it is clear that the pressure gradient force behaves exactly as described
its effect is localised primarily within the current sheet ( near the @xmath5 plane ; compare with fig . [ jxy ] ) , and is directed in such a sense as to oppose the collapse of the fan surface and current sheet .
plane , for the run with @xmath44 , with driving across the spine . ]
the fact that the geometry of the current sheet which we observe in our compressible simulations is very different to that of the analytical solutions is not completely unprecedented .
in fact , in laboratory experiments examining the formation of current sheets at 3d nulls , bogdanov _
et al_. @xcite made a similar observation .
they too found a current sheet forming at a finite angle to the global directions of both the null spine and fan , which had not been expected from prior self - similar analytical solutions @xcite .
however , it is interesting to observe that the incompressible solutions are indeed recovered in the limit of large @xmath0 , even though we make no assumption regarding the dimensionality of any fields in the solution .
note finally that all of the arguments given above carry through to the 2d case .
thus our results for the 2d null , when compared with the solution of ref .
[ ] , can be explained by similar reasoning .
we now consider the case where the fan of the null is sheared rather than the spine .
we re - run the simulations with @xmath80 , and again drive in the @xmath13-direction on the @xmath4-boundaries .
this time we use a uni - directional driving profile , which has the disadvantage of compressing the plasma at the boundaries , causing a few extra numerical difficulties , but has the advantage of shearing the fan plane in the same direction over the whole @xmath81-plane for each @xmath4-boundary . specifically , we take @xmath82 where @xmath83 is again defined by eq . ( [ tdepend ] ) .
we take @xmath84 , @xmath33 , @xmath85 , @xmath86 , domain dimensions @xmath37 , @xmath38 , @xmath35 and @xmath87 ( so that the travel time for the disturbance , which propagates at the alfv ' en speed , to reach the null is approximately the same as in the spine shearing cases ) .
the evolution of the null point for an ideal monatomic gas ( @xmath26 ) is very similar to the case where the spine is driven .
once again the disturbance focuses towards the null point , this time along its fan , and drives it to collapse . a current sheet which spans the spine and fan results [ fig .
[ jxyfan](a ) ] .
this is expected by comparison with the behaviour of wave - like shear perturbations @xcite . however , in the incompressible analytical solution of craig & fabling @xcite , a shear of the fan leads to tubular current structures aligned to the spine of the null . examining the behaviour for larger values of @xmath0
, we find that compressibility seems to have a similar effect to the spine driving case , but spine current sheets do not develop .
specifically , decreasing the compressibility again means that the null does not collapse to the same extent , though rather than spreading along the spine as predicted by the analytical solutions , the current again spreads along the fan [ fig .
[ jxyfan](b ) ] . in the @xmath23 plane ,
at the time of its temporal peak , for ( a ) @xmath26 , and ( b ) @xmath44 , for the case of driving across the fan.,title="fig : " ] in the @xmath23 plane , at the time of its temporal peak , for ( a ) @xmath26 , and ( b ) @xmath44 , for the case of driving across the fan.,title="fig : " ] these results provide strong evidence that spine current sheets are not dynamically accessible , at least in the absence of strong ( super - alfv ' enic ) inflows to drive the localisation .
this result has previously been anticipated by titov _
we instead expect tubular spine current structures to be associated with rotational motions , see ref .
[ ] . within these tubular structures
, we expect the current to flow parallel to the spine , corresponding to field lines spiralling around the spine .
by contrast , the current in the incompressible ` spine current ' solutions @xcite is directed parallel to the ( undisturbed ) fan plane ( while being localised close to the spine ) .
we have presented the results of 3d resistive mhd simulations of a driven 3d null point .
we focussed on the effect of moving from a compressible plasma towards an incompressible one , by varying the ratio of specific heats , @xmath0 , in our simulations .
this was found to strongly affect the resulting current sheet formation , both qualitatively and quantitatively .
we considered first the case where the spine of the null is sheared from the boundaries . for an ideal ,
monatomic plasma ( @xmath26 , compressible ) , the spine and fan of the null collapse towards one another , and a strongly focused current sheet forms at the null , locally spanning the spine and fan .
however , as @xmath0 is increased , the collapse of the null , and in particular of the fan plane , is suppressed .
the current sheet spreads increasingly along the fan surface , which remains increasingly planar throughout the simulation runs .
in addition , rather than forming a stagnation point flow as the null collapses , the plasma flow within the domain stays approximately parallel to the planar fan surface for large @xmath0 .
the same effect was found when @xmath11 was increased rather than @xmath0 , due to the physically similar nature of increasing either parameter , as discussed earlier .
quantitatively , the peak current and peak reconnection rate both drop significantly as @xmath0 ( or @xmath11 ) is increased ( see also ref . [ ] ) .
considering the case where the boundary shearing was applied across the fan plane of the null rather than the spine , we found similar behaviour .
in particular , the null point collapse is suppressed , and a more spatially diffuse current structure is found , localised to the fan surface .
our results provide strong evidence that the steady - state analytical fan current sheet solutions of craig _ et al .
_ @xcite are in fact dynamically accessible in a fully 3d , incompressible plasma .
however , they also imply that the equivalent spine current sheet solutions @xcite are not .
examining the fan current sheet solutions , it appears that the reason why they break down in a compressible plasma is the enormous pressure gradients which are required to maintain the imposed symmetry .
these pressure gradients scale inversely with the resistivity , and so in astrophysical plasmas become unphysically large .
this work was supported by the department of energy , grant no .
de - fg02 - 05er54832 , by the national science foundation , grant nos .
atm-0422764 and atm-0543202 and by nasa grant no .
nnx06ac19 g .
k. g. was supported by the carlsberg foundation in the form of a fellowship .
computations were performed on the zaphod beowulf cluster which was in part funded by the major research instrumentation program of the national science foundation , grant atm-0424905 . | the nature of current sheet formation in the vicinity of three - dimensional ( 3d ) magnetic null points is investigated .
the particular focus is upon the effect of the compressibility of the plasma on the qualitative and quantitative properties of the current sheet .
an initially potential 3d null is subjected to shearing perturbations , as in a previous paper [ pontin _ et al .
_ , phys .
plasmas , in press ( 2007 ) ] .
it is found that as the incompressible limit is approached , the collapse of the null point is suppressed , and an approximately planar current sheet aligned to the fan plane is present instead .
this is the case regardless of whether the spine or fan of the null is sheared .
both the peak current and peak reconnection rate are reduced .
the results have a bearing on previous analytical solutions for steady - state reconnection in incompressible plasmas , implying that fan current sheet solutions are dynamically accessible , while spine current sheet solutions are not . |
it is known that the most important component of an adaptive optics ( ao ) system is the corrector , which is the deformable mirror ( dm ) .
it can be a continuous face sheet or a surface formed by mirror segments @xcite . in the former the mirror boundary
is fixed and voltage applied to any one actuator influences the neighbouring surface as well . in the case of the micro - machined membrane deformable mirror(mmdm ) [ 2 ] this influence can be as large as 60@xmath1 [ 3 ] .
however , they are still preferred in many ao systems [ 4 - 8 ] because of their low cost and capability of achieving large stroke . a 37 channel mmdm from okotech , netherlands ,
is being used by us at the udaipur solar observatory ( uso ) for its solar adaptive optics [ 9 - 11 ] ( sao ) system .
although the mmdm is not common in many sao systems , its performance has been validated for solar observations[12 ] . in an ao system , it is necessary to bias the dm in such a way that the stroke can be achieved in both positive and negative directions from the biased position . in general , this can be achieved by applying a constant voltage to all the actuators . in case of the mmdm , application of a constant voltage to all the actuators deforms the mirror to a shape often approximated to be parabolic [ 13 ] . however , such approximations do not hold , at points away from the centre .
a dm , whose surface is distorted by applying a uniform set of voltage to its actuators , and placed in the optical setup at an angle to the beam will undoubtedly mimic a tilted parabolic mirror .
such a tilted curved / parabolic mirror will induce optical aberrations such as defocus , astigmatism and coma @xcite . while defocus can be compensated by moving the imaging system , astigmatism and coma can not be corrected by a simple alignment .
as the dm is also being used to compensate a turbulence - induced curvature term , it is necessary to determine the maximum angle of incidence at which the dm can be placed in the optical setup without introducing an additional set of aberrations than that which are inherent to the dm .
otherwise , at relatively large angles of incidence , when the dm corrects an atmosphere - induced defocus ( curvature term ) , it will inevitably introduce astigmatism . in order to minimize this astigmatism ,
an additional correction is required .
this constraints the bandwidth of the system . along with ` setup ' induced aberrations , intrinsic aberrations ( aberrations due to mirror s surface profile )
are also very important . as the technical passport of the dm states that the initial figure of the dm is astigmatic upto 1.3 fringes(p - v)[14 ]
, we would like to study the intrinsic aberrations as well . in this paper
we estimate , to a first order , the aberrations introduced in the optical system as a result of folding the beam using a dm with a bias voltage , for various angles of incidence .
the rest of the paper is organized as follows .
section 2 describes theoretical aspects related to the deformation of the mirror under an external , uniform voltage and in section 3 we present the theoretical investigation on astigmatism and defocus in such a deformed system .
section [ simu ] describes the simulations which demonstrate the aberrations introduced when the dm is placed at different angles of incidence .
the degradation in the observed image quality with varying curvature for different angles of incidence is discussed in section [ expt ] using an experimental setup .
the understandings from the simulations and the observations from the experiment are discussed in section [ discu ] .
is the diameter of the surface and @xmath2 is di - electric constant .
@xmath3 is the distance between the electrodes ab and cd .
thickness of the wafer is @xmath4 . ] in figure 1 , the silicon wafer w , with upper surface polished is place on the + ve electrode ab , which is subjected to potential @xmath5 , while the -ve electrode cd is grounded .
when @xmath6 , the wafer w has its undistorted shape @xmath7 , while it gets distorted to the shape , shown in @xmath8 , when @xmath9 .
if @xmath3 be the separation between the plates and @xmath2 be the dielectric permittivity of the material , filling the space between the plates , a charge density @xmath10 develops on the plates .
the resulting stress is given by @xmath11 thus , if @xmath12 be the young s modulus , @xmath13 be the poisson ratio and @xmath4 be the thickness of the wafer , then the deformation of the upper surface of the wafer is given by@xcite @xmath14 ^ 2 \\
\textrm{for}\;x = y=0,\quad z(0,0 ) & = & -\frac{p}{64}\frac{3}{2}\frac{(1-{\sigma}^2)}{eh^3}a^4 = -h_0\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath15 is defined as the sag of the membrane .
+ the gradient of the surface at any point on the @xmath16 membrane are given by @xmath17 \nonumber \\ z_y & = & \partial z/\partial y = \frac{4h_0}{a^4}\:y\left[a^2-(x^2+y^2)\right ] \label{zderivate}\end{aligned}\ ] ] accordingly , the two curvatures are given for @xmath18 @xmath19 \nonumber\\ k_y = \frac{1}{\rho_{y}}= -\frac{{\partial}^2 z } { { \partial y}^2 } & = & -\frac{4h_0}{a^4}\:\left[a^2-x^2 - 3\:y^2\right ] \label{rxry}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the convention being that the curvature is positive if the surface is convex ( center of curvature is located at @xmath20 i.e below the undistorted surface ) and negative if the surface is concave ( center of curvature is located at @xmath21 i.e above the undistorted surface ) .
where , @xmath22 and @xmath23 are the radii of curvature along @xmath24 and @xmath25 direction respectively .
the point where @xmath26 or @xmath27 or both equal to zero indicates the point of inflexion .
thus , at the center @xmath28 and we can express the equation ( 2 ) as @xmath29 where , @xmath30 . in the literature , the formula that is traditionally used for the radius of curvature is @xmath31 .
this gives a value , which is much larger than the actual radius of curvature at the center , it s magnitude being @xmath32 .
this is because on these formula , the circumference of the mirror @xmath33 and the point of sag @xmath34 are fitted to lie on a sphere for which simple geometry gives a radius @xmath35 as given above .
the actual values are , however given by equation [ rxry ] , showing that the surface can not be described by a unique radius of curvature .
the various aberrations , which appear in the fraunhofer limit are thus to be worked out with @xmath36 being given by equation [ sageqn ] , in which @xmath37 is found to be proportional to @xmath38 , a fact , which we present in our further results .
( b ) gradient @xmath39 and ( c ) curvature of the membrane at different points along the diameter for application of different voltages from 0 to 200 v;(d ) elevation @xmath40 , ( continuous line ) , gradient ( dotted line ) and curvature ( dashed line ) , for the application of 200 volts ; vertical dotted lines show the points of inflexion .
different parameters for a typical wafer that are being used here are : @xmath12 = 165 @xmath41 , @xmath13 = 0.24 , h=2.5 @xmath42 m , @xmath43=7.5 @xmath44 .
the colors in plots ( a - c ) , black , blue , green , yellow and red represent for voltages 0 , 50 , 100 , 150 , and 200 v , respectively . ]
figure @xmath45 show typical manifestations of @xmath46 , inclination and curvature of the membrane and the location of inflexion for typical values of various parameters of equation [ sageqn ] .
it is clear that the variations in @xmath47 and @xmath48 at different points on the surface , imply a reflecting surface with varying inclination , which would , in geometrical viewpoint , reflect the light from these points of incidence in different directions , consistent with the laws of reflection .
the curvatures @xmath26 and @xmath27 ascribe focusing and defocusing properties of the reflecting membrane surface .
figure [ sagimg ] show the surface map of the membrane with the application of voltage ; we fitted this surface with 21 zernike polynomials [ 16 ] , the retrieved coefficients show that the @xmath49 ( defocus ) and @xmath50 ( spherical aberration ) are the dominant terms .
figure [ raydia ] illustrates the image formation by a dm .
we assume that the dm lies in the @xmath51 plane in its un - deformed state , and the curved profile @xmath52 represents the dm under the influence of uniform voltage .
the deformation @xmath37 follows the equation ( 6 ) given in section 2 .
let a ray from a point source @xmath53(-@xmath54 , @xmath55 , @xmath56 ) be incident on the curved mirror at @xmath57 .
the light ray reflected by the dm is imaged using a lens of focal length @xmath58 on to a screen ` s ' placed at a distance of @xmath59 from the lens .
the lens lies in the @xmath60 plane such that @xmath61 form a right handed system of orthogonal axes .
the lens introduces a path length ` lens ' to the ray on propagating through the lens . in order to find the path followed by the rays , we calculate the path length @xmath62 and minimize the same with respect to @xmath63 and @xmath64 as demanded by fermat s principle .
the total optical path is given by @xmath65 for a perfectly aligned optical system , we have @xmath66 , so that @xmath67 @xmath68 \nonumber\\ \alpha_{22}&=&{1}/{l}-{2\:\cos\;\theta_1}/{\rho_o}\nonumber\\ \beta_{11}&=&{1}/{l}+{1}/{z_f}-{1}/{f_0}\nonumber\\ \beta_{22}&=&{1}/{z_f}\nonumber\\ \gamma_{11}&=&{-\cos\:\theta_1}/{l},\nonumber\\ \gamma_{22}&=&{-1}/{l } , \quad\delta_{0}={-1}/{z_f}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , we have neglected the terms contributing to a constant phase and kept only the leading terms that contribute to astigmatism and defocus . in order to find the path of the ray we apply fermat s principle . thus keeping ( x , y ) fixed we minimize @xmath69 w.r.t @xmath70 respectively , to yield , @xmath71 which are linear equations in the variables x , y , @xmath72 , @xmath73 , x , y. solving the above linear equations , @xmath74\,x = \alpha\,x\nonumber\\ y&=&\left[(\alpha_{22}\beta_{11}-{\gamma_{22}}^2)/(\gamma_{22}\delta_o)\right]\,y = \beta\,y \label{lineqnsol}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , the definitions for @xmath75
, @xmath76 can be found from the pre - factors .
these equations relate ( @xmath77 ) with each other . in other words , if the diameter of the lens be much larger than @xmath78 , i.e. the diameter of the dm then for any point of incidence ( @xmath79 ) on the dm , we know the point ( @xmath80 ) , which the ray of light reaches
. on defining @xmath81 we can write the coordinates of the point ( @xmath82 ) on the dm to be @xmath83 and @xmath84 .
thus , various rays , incident on the circle : @xmath85 on the dm , will reach the point ( @xmath86 ) , where @xmath87 , and @xmath88 .
this means that @xmath89 describes an ellipse @xmath90 .
thus on making @xmath91 we find all rays will reach @xmath92 where on the screen all the rays will lie inside a ellipse @xmath93 such that @xmath94 the results given in ( 12 ) and ( 13 ) enable us to estimate the astigmatic aberration inside the system . consider a case where on adjusting the screen and making @xmath95 we can make @xmath96 . in this case , @xmath97 the illumination on the screen will be confined only along the @xmath98 axis .
the necessary condition for that , i.e @xmath96 requires @xmath99 , as seen from equations ( 11 ) .
then on using the definition given in equation ( 9 ) , we find in the limits @xmath100 and @xmath101 , @xmath102 similarly on adjusting @xmath103 we can make @xmath104 . in this case @xmath105 and the illumination on the screen is confined only along the axis . for this to happen , we must have @xmath106 so that for @xmath107 , we get on using the definitions in equations ( 9 ) , @xmath108 the astigmatism in the system is then estimated as @xmath109 the above equation for astigmatism ( @xmath110 ) shows a strong dependence on @xmath111 , it varies very fast for @xmath112 and blows up as @xmath113 ( c.f .
table 1 ) .
it also shows that @xmath110 varies as @xmath38 . for any value of @xmath114 the patch of light on
the screen lies inside an ellipse , defined by equations ( 12 ) and ( 13 ) .
thus , the extent of the patch is defined by averaging @xmath115 over @xmath116 .
these give , @xmath117\end{aligned}\ ] ] the circle of least confusion is located at a point , where @xmath118 is minimum , i.e. at a value of @xmath119 for which , @xmath120 \end{aligned}\ ] ] + these derivatives can be evaluated from equations ( 11 ) on using the definitions given in equation ( 9 ) .
we find that in the limit @xmath121 , i.e. for curvatures not too large , as is the case for most practical situations .
@xmath122 .dependence of circle of least confusion on angle of incidence [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] in oc-1 , the dominant aberration is defocus @xmath123 along with a negligible amount of spherical aberration@xmath124 of the 3rd order ( table [ info1 ] ) .
these aberrations increase with the increase in voltage as seen from their corresponding zernike coefficients ( cf . ,
table [ info1 ] ) . to compensate these aberrations the focal plane position
must be shifted which is achieved by minimizing the merit function for an optimal focal plane position in zemax .
the process of optimization yields a wavefront error which is well within the diffraction limit . in oc-2 ,
the dominant aberrations were defocus ( z4 ) , astigmatism ( z6 ) along with small amounts of coma ( z7 ) ( table [ info2 ] ) .
these aberrations also increase with an increase in voltage .
after optimizing the focal plane position , the z4 coefficient reduces considerably , while the coefficient z6 , namely astigmatism , remains unchanged .
the overall wavefront quality varies from @xmath125/12.5 to 6.6@xmath125 when the voltage changes from 25 - 225 @xmath5 , before optimization .
after optimization the values vary from @xmath125/25 to 2.83@xmath125 for the same range of voltage .
thus at an angle of incidence of 45@xmath126 , application of any voltage to the dm introduces an additional astigmatism and coma ( cf . , table 3 ) .
it is to be noted that here the coefficient of coma is very small in comparison to that of astigmatism .
hence , we neglect coma in our further analysis .
however , we conjecture that the coefficient of coma is negligible because of the large f - number of the curved dm mirror , this may not be the case with a tilted curved mirror with a smaller f - number , where the coma is equally important as astigmatism @xcite . ) .
bottom panels : wavefront error ( wfe ) after optimization for optimum focus .
relation between applied voltage and astigmatism and defocus are shown in the respective figures .
the symbols represent the fitted values based on relations derived empirically.,width=302 ] as a further step , the amount of astigmatism induced by the ( curved ) dm for different angles of incidence was studied , as it is the only term that remains unaltered after optimization . as a matter of convenience
the astigmatism is expressed as the change in tangential and sagital focal planes rather than zernike coefficients as these values can be compared with those from an optical setup having a test target .
figure [ intri ] shows the increase in astigmatism ( change in sagital and tangential focii ) with increase in voltage ( i.e decrease in rc ) for different angles of incidence .
dependence of astigmatism and defocus on voltage and angle of incidence is derived empirically .
it shows that defocus depends only on the voltage applied , whereas astigmatism depends both on the voltage applied and the angle of incidence .
this is in agreement with the theory ( cf .
, equations 16 and 19 ) .
similarly , the wavefront error of the system at optimum focus varies with angle of incidence and it shows a similar trend as astigmatism . the system shows a considerable amount of wfe for angles of incidence @xmath127 9@xmath128 , with the wfe is worse than @xmath125/10 for any voltage .
the technical document of the dm states that in the absence of any voltage the initial mirror figure is astigmatic upto 1.3 fringes . in the simulations ,
this intrinsic aberration was modeled by utilizing
zernike fringe sag " [ 17 ] .
the terms z5 , z6 and , z12 , z13 refer to the first and third order astigmatism , respectively and were adjusted such that the initial difference between the tangential and sagital focus was 6 mm which corresponds to a wavefront error of 0.18 @xmath125 at @xmath125 = 550 nm .
the obtained coefficients were assigned to the dm to make the surface astigmatic .
the entire exercise as described in section [ simintri ] was repeated , astigmatism and wavefront error were estimated for different angles of incidence . at an angle of incidence of 0@xmath126 ,
the wavefront error remains constant at 0.18 @xmath125 after optimizing the focal plane for different values of rc , which correspond to the intrinsic astigmatism . at any other angle of incidence
the wavefront error shows quadratic variation with the increase in rc with a minimum value being around 0.18 @xmath125 .
this shows that the astigmatism arising from the surface figure needs to be corrected before using the dm in an optical setup .
to compare the results from the zemax simulations , we carried out an experiment with the dm , using an f#15 coude telescope as the light feed . with a set of relay lenses the image was magnified by a factor of 2 . at the focal plane of the f#30 beam an artificial target
was placed which was illuminated by sunlight . a lens of focal length 200 mm was used to collimate the light modulated by the target .
the dm was placed in the collimated beam which reflects the beam towards an imaging lens of focal length 300 mm ( refer figure [ od ] ) .
the voltage to the dm was controlled by 2 , 8-bit pci cards whose maximum output voltage to any channel is 5 v. the individual actuators were first assigned a port address as stated in the user manual and the pci output was checked for each channel .
a high voltage amplifier consisting of 2 high voltage amplifier boards , boost the signal from the pci cards .
each amplifier board contains 20 non - inverting dc amplifiers with a gain of 59 .
a high voltage stabilized dc supply was used to power the amplifier boards .
the maximum operating voltage of the dm is 162 v which corresponds to 256 digital - to - analog counts ( dac ) .
a @xmath129 pixel , cool - snap hq ccd with a pixel size of 6.45 @xmath42 m from roper scientific was used to image the target .
the difference between tangential and sagital planes and the circle of least confusion ( optimum focus ) were measured in order to estimate the intrinsic as well as induced aberrations . .
top panel show change in focus w.r.t change in voltage .
bottom panel show intrinsic astigmatism , as there is no tilt in the dm , astigmatism observed is intrinsic to the dm .
solid line represents the linear fit corresponds to the data points.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] for measuring the intrinsic aberration the dm was placed at an angle of 0@xmath126 similar to oc-1 in figure [ od ] .
the target had an l shape pattern and it was observed that the vertical line was focused at one location while the horizontal line at another .
this difference in the sagital and tangential focus is caused by astigmatism . to see if this astigmatism changes with the curvature of the dm , a uniform voltage was applied to all 37 actuators of dm from 0 to 225 dacs in steps of 25 dacs . for every voltage set , the tangential
, sagital and optimum focal positions ( @xmath130 and @xmath131 ) were measured and the corresponding images were recorded . the difference between the sagital and tangential focal positions do not vary with voltage ( cf . , figure [ expt0 ] ) which is in agreement with the results from the theory and simulation when an intrinsic astigmatism is considered for 0@xmath126 angle of incidence .
the optimum focus changes quadratically with the voltage applied . 220 pixels@xmath132 with a scale of 4.3 micron per pixel.,width=415 ] the presence of an intrinsic astigmatism results in a poor image quality which can be judged visually as shown in figure [ images0 ] which also shows images taken by a plane mirror kept at the same location of the dm .
astigmatism essentially arises due to different curvatures along different directions , hence as a first order trial we applied maximum voltage to a specific line of actuators alone and recorded the corresponding image as shown in figure [ images0]c . as a performance measurement , contrast of the images was estimated before and after correction for the entire image as well as for a few selected features as shown in figure [ images0]d .
although the improvement in image contrast is nominal , it is evident that a specific voltage set is necessary to compensate for the degradation caused by the intrinsic astigmatism .
the experiment was repeated by placing the dm at several angles of incidence and the tangential , sagital and optimum focus positions ( @xmath130 and @xmath131 ) were measured and the corresponding images were also recorded .
the defocus is quantified by noting the distance @xmath119 by which the screen has to be shifted to reach the position of the circle of least confusion .
the astigmatic aberrations is quantified by @xmath133 . both @xmath119 and @xmath134
are proportional to @xmath38 , their dependence on @xmath111 are strikingly different as seen from equations 16 and 20 . while the defocus @xmath119 has a weak dependence on @xmath111 , that of @xmath134 has a strong dependence on @xmath111 as seen from the functional forms of @xmath135 and @xmath136 .
the results are displayed in figure [ expt45 ] which is in agreement with those from the theory and simulations .
interestingly , for angles less than 10@xmath126 the astigmatism remains nearly a constant with the applied voltage as seen from the theory and simulations .
images obtained for different angles of incidence by applying 225 dacs to all the actuators of dm are shown in figure [ images45 ] .
a deformable mirror is an important component in an adaptive optics system for compensation of atmospheric turbulence .
a simple optical setup was made to study alignment issues and the intrinsic aberrations of a deformable mirror without employing any kind of wavefront sensor .
the nature of the surface deformation under the influence of a uniform voltage to all the actuators of deformable mirror is obtained theoretically and given in equation ( 2 ) .
the equation is used to calculate the sag of the deformed / curved mirror .
it is shown that radius of curvature of the deformable mirror is inversely proportional to the square of the voltage applied .
furthermore , we also analytically estimated the defocus and astigmatism due to such a curved mirror , which are shown in equations ( 16 ) and ( 20 ) .
simulations were performed with different voltages to the deformable mirror , which is kept at different angles of incidence .
it is demonstrated that the estimated error in focus is solely a function of the applied voltage where the former has a quadratic dependence on the latter .
the same is seen in astigmatism as well with an additional non - linear dependence on the angle of incidence .
simulations also shows that coefficient of coma is negligible in comparison to astigmatism , could be due to the large f - number of dm .
similar results were obtained from the experiment , wherein a 37 channel mmdm is placed in the collimated beam at different angles of incidence .
the dm when placed at 0@xmath126 angle of incidence shows a finite amount of intrinsic astigmatism which does not vary significantly with the radius of curvature ( i.e. application of voltage to dm ) ; this is in agreement with the technical report provided by the manufacturer .
it is also observed that the optimum focal plane position changes quadratically with voltage and does not exhibit a change of sign which concludes that the dm does not possess any intrinsic curvature that would change sign on application of voltages .
we have also shown that the image quality degrades with the application of voltage and the astigmatism increases with the increase in angle of incidence . from both , simulations and experiment it is demonstrated that when the dm is kept at angles greater than @xmath137 and voltages are applied to it
, there is an induced astigmatism which increases in general with the angle of incidence as is also predicted by the theory .
the close correlation between theory and experiment enable us to reach the following conclusion about the performance of dm .
it shows that apart from the forces appearing due to charging of the capacitor , there are no other spurious deforming forces in the system and the optics of the dm can thus be regarded to have sufficient reliability .
the detailed intensity distribution on the screen can also be computed by using equation ( 9 ) for the phase distortion due to deformation .
it is concluded that in order to operate the dm in real - time to correct for atmospheric induced aberrations , it necessary to a ) keep the dm at a very small angle of incidence and b ) to derive a suitable voltage set that will compensate the intrinsic astigmatism as well .
this voltage set can be simply added to any constant voltage set required to bias the dm surface , since the intrinsic astigmatism is independent of voltage ; it naturally facilitates using a suitable bias voltage in order to allow the membrane to move in either direction , which is being pursued and will be reported in future . in practical situations , for wavefront correction
the deformation may not be as simple as considered in the present investigations .
however , the present study enables us to ascertain the inherent defects in the system which has to be kept in mind , while using the deformable mirror for phase distortion correction .
rohan e. louis is grateful for the financial assistance from the german science foundation ( dfg ) under grant de 787/3 - 1 and the european commission s fp7 capacities programme under grant agreement number 312495 .
lijun zhu , pang - chen sun , dirk - uwe bartsch , william r. freeman , and yeshaiahu fainman , `` adaptive control of a micromachined continuous - membrane deformable mirror for aberration compensation '' , appl . opt . * 38 * , 168 - 176 ( 1999 ) .
d. s. dayton , s. restaino , j. gonglewski , j. gallegos , s. macdermott , s. browne , s. rogers , m. vaidyanathan , and m. shilko , `` laboratory and field demonstration of a low cost membrane mirror adaptive optics system '' , opt .
commun . * 176 * , 339 - 345 ( 2000 ) .
oskar van der luehe , dirk soltau , thomas berkefeld , and thomas schelenz `` kaos : adaptive optics system for the vacuum tower telescope at teide observatory '' in _ innovative telescopes and instrumentation for solar astrophysics _ , stephen l. keil , sergey v. avakyan , ed .
spie * 4853 * , 187 - 193 ( 2003 ) .
goran b. scharmer , peter m. dettori , mats g. lofdahl , and mark shand , `` adaptive optics system for the new swedish solar telescope '' in _ innovative telescopes and instrumentation for solar astrophysics _ , stephen l. keil , sergey v. avakyan , ed .
spie * 4853 * , 370 - 380 ( 2003 ) . c. u. keller , claude plymate , and s. m. ammons , `` low - cost solar adaptive optics in the infrared '' proc .
spie * 4853 * , in _ innovative telescopes and instrumentation for solar astrophysics _
, stephen l. keil , sergey v. avakyan , ed .
, 351 - 359 ( 2003 ) . | a deformable mirror ( dm ) is an important component of an adaptive optics system .
it is known that an on - axis spherical / parabolic optical component , placed at an angle to the incident beam introduces defocus as well as astigmatism in the image plane .
although the former can be compensated by changing the focal plane position , the latter can not be removed by mere optical re - alignment .
since the dm is to be used to compensate a turbulence - induced curvature term in addition to other aberrations , it is necessary to determine the aberrations induced by such ( curved dm surface ) an optical element when placed at an angle ( other than @xmath0 ) of incidence in the optical path . to this effect
, we estimate to a first order , the aberrations introduced by a dm as a function of the incidence angle and deformation of the dm surface .
we record images using a simple setup in which the incident beam is reflected by a 37 channel micro - machined membrane deformable mirror for various angles of incidence .
it is observed that astigmatism is a dominant aberration which was determined by measuring the difference between the tangential and sagital focal planes .
we justify our results on the basis of theoretical simulations and discuss the feasibility of using such a system for adaptive optics considering a trade - off between wavefront correction and astigmatism due to deformation . |
we , two non - experts , present several " calculations and some simple measurements related to global warming and the carbon cycle .
our purpose is to understand which phenomena are important in determining the temperature of the earth .
in this article we will use the following measured data.@xcite the power of the radiation of the sun per square perpendicular meter above the atmosphere is measured to be @xmath1w / m@xmath2 .
is @xmath3 , with @xmath4wm@xmath5k@xmath6 .
the power radiated by the sun is @xmath7 .
the power per unit perpendicular area received by earth ( outside of the atmosphere ) is @xmath8w / m@xmath9 . from these equations
we obtain the effective temperature of sun light : @xmath10k . ]
this is the `` .
since the surface of the earth is 4 times the surface of a disk of the same radius , the average incident solar power per square meter of the earth s surface is @xmath11w / m@xmath2 .
all fractions listed below refer to @xmath12w / m@xmath2 .
the fraction of sun light that is reflected by the earth is measured to be 0.31 ( 0.21 by clouds , 0.06 by air including dust and water vapor , and 0.04 by the ground ) .
this is the '' of the earth .
the remaining fraction ( 0.69 ) is absorbed by the earth ( @xmath13w / m@xmath2 by the surface , @xmath14w / m@xmath2 by the troposphere ( water vapor and aerosols ) , @xmath15w / m@xmath2 by the stratosphere , and @xmath15w / m@xmath2 by clouds ) .
so , the net solar power absorbed by the earth is @xmath16w / m@xmath2 for average cloud coverage .
the infrared radiation of the earth to space measured by satellites is @xmath17w / m@xmath2 for average cloud coverage ( @xmath18w / m@xmath2 by clouds , @xmath19w / m@xmath2 by water vapor and @xmath0 , and @xmath20w / m@xmath2 by the surface through the infrared atmospheric window ) .
so , the incoming and outgoing energies balance to high accuracy and determine the temperature of the biosphere .
the average temperature of the surface of the earth is 288k@xmath21c .
the average temperature of the atmosphere is about 250k@xmath22c . in cloud free conditions
the average solar power absorbed is @xmath23w / m@xmath2 , while the average emitted terrestrial radiation is @xmath24w / m@xmath2 .
the corresponding numbers for average cloud cover are @xmath25w / m@xmath2 and @xmath17w / m@xmath2 as mentioned before .
note that decreasing the cloud cover has a net heating effect .
the earth radiation spectrum measured from a satellite ( figure [ earthradiation ] ) shows that the infrared windows ( @xmath26 to @xmath27 m and 10 to @xmath28 m ) radiate as a blackbody at the surface temperature , the @xmath0 absorption band ( @xmath29 to @xmath30 m ) radiates at 215k ( corresponding to the altitude of the tropopause at 12 km ) , and the @xmath31 bands ( @xmath32 m and @xmath33 m ) radiate at @xmath34k ( corresponding to an altitude of 5 km ) .
let us begin with a simple model . from observations we know that , to high accuracy
, there is an equilibrium between incident solar power and radiated infrared power .
therefore @xmath35 where @xmath1w / m@xmath2 is the solar constant , @xmath36 is the fraction of incident sun light power that is absorbed by the earth , _ i.e. _ it is the " , @xmath37 is the emissivity in the infrared , @xmath38wm@xmath5k@xmath6 is the stefan - boltzmann constant , and @xmath39 is the temperature of the surface of the earth in degrees kelvin .
the factor @xmath40 was explained in section 2 .
we note that if @xmath41 the equilibrium temperature is 279k , quite close to the observed mean temperature of 288k . from the data presented in section 2
we conclude that @xmath42 for the earth as a whole , @xmath43 for areas covered by clouds ( it varies from 0.6 for cirrus to 0.1 for cumulonimbus ) , @xmath44 for cloudless ground , and @xmath45 for snow . because snow is mostly at high latitude
we sometimes replace @xmath46 for snow . from the data presented in section 2 we estimate that @xmath47 for the earth as a whole , @xmath48 for areas covered by clouds , @xmath49 for cloudless ground , and @xmath50 for snow . these " emissivities are valid for the model of this section , _
i.e. _ an earth surface characterized by a single temperature , and includes the atmosphere with its greenhouse gases .
the model is too crude to account for all observations , so these effective emissivities are approximate .
a summary of effective emissivities is presented in table [ emissivities ] . in the last column of the table
we show the equilibrium temperature for 100% coverage of black body , cloudless ground , clouds or snow .
the last row shows the world average .
.effective emissivities for infrared and visible radiation .
the last column shows the temperature corresponding to a 100% cover of black body , cloudless ground , cloud or snow .
the last row corresponds to 50% cloud cover , 5% snow cover , leaving 45% clear ground .
the measured average temperature is 288k . [
cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ]
the chemistry of carbon in the oceans is beautifully described in @xcite .
we are interested in these two equations of chemical equilibrium : @xmath51 = k_h p_{co_2 } , \label{henry}\ ] ] which describes the solution of @xmath0 in sea water , and @xmath52 [ hco_3 ^ - ] = k_{a1 } [ co_2 ] \label{bicarbonate}\ ] ] that describes the ionization of hydrated carbon dioxide .
@xmath53 is the partial pressure of @xmath0 in the atmosphere ( in atmospheres ) , and @xmath54 $ ] are concentrations in sea water ( in mol per liter ) .
the equilibrium constants have these values at @xmath55c ( @xmath56c ) : @xmath57 ( @xmath58 ) , and @xmath59 ( @xmath60 ) for 0.7 ionic strength.@xcite the calculations shown in table [ oceanc ] assume @xmath61atm ( _ _ i.e.__300ppm ) .
assuming that the total carbon in the air and the top 1000 m of the oceans is constant , and that 300ppm corresponds to @xmath62c and ph = 7.4 ( 8.3 ) , we obtain that a @xmath62c increase in the sea water temperature produces an increase of @xmath0 in the atmosphere of 40ppm ( 48ppm ) . in comparison , from antarctic and greenland ice cores
, it is found that @xmath63c changes in temperature have been accompanied by @xmath64ppm change in @xmath53 . in conclusion
, we qualitatively understand the coupling of the pre - historic temperature with the atmospheric concentration of @xmath0 : an increase of ocean temperature reduces its solubility to @xmath0 , * causing * an increase of the atmospheric concentration of @xmath0 .
the converse is not true : an increase of @xmath65ppm @xmath0 would increase the temperature , due to the greenhouse effect , by only @xmath66c .
let us now estimate the effect of acid rain due to a large volcanic explosion .
assume that @xmath67 kg are ejected .
assume that 0.1% of this is sulfur ( in any chemical form ) that ends up as sulphuric acid in the oceans .
the concentration of @xmath68 in the top 1000 m of the oceans would be @xmath69mmol / liter .
we measured the ph of ocean water off the coast of ecuador as a function of @xmath68 concentration : 7.3 , 7.0 , 6.3 , and 5.5 for 0 , 0.0084 , 0.0211 and 0.0422mmol / liter respectively .
so the change of ph is negligible ( @xmath70 ) , and the corresponding release of @xmath0 by the oceans is also negligible .
it is observed that the concentration of @xmath0 has increased linearly from 325ppm in 1970 to 375ppm in 2004.@xcite if this increase continues at constant rate it will take about @xmath71 years to reach twice the pre - industrial concentration of 290ppm .
it is observed that the buildup of atmospheric @xmath53 accurately follows the human emissions of @xmath0 ( due to burning of fossil fuels and the clearing of land for agricultural and urban use).@xcite the factor of proportionality is observed to be 65% .
the remaining 35% of emitted carbon apparently ends up in the surface ( mixed ) layer of the oceans and in bio - mass .
no saturation is observed so far , so the time constant with which carbon reaches the deep oceans is in excess of 50 years ( it is estimated that there are several time constants , some as long as 2000 years).@xcite there are enough world reserves of fossil fuels ( gas , oil and coal ) to last @xmath72 years at the present rate of consumption ( 6.5gt c per year ) . burning these reserves
would increase @xmath0 to three times the pre - industrial concentration assuming 65% of the emitted @xmath0 ends up in the atmosphere .
however , on these longer time scales it is estimated that 30% ( instead of 65% ) of the emitted @xmath0 will remain in the atmosphere.@xcite thus we estimate that burning all of the remaining reserves of fossil fuels in the next 150 years or so , will result in twice the pre - industrial @xmath0 concentration .
the solubility of @xmath0 in the oceans decreases with increasing temperature .
consider a drop in the temperature of the oceans .
with what time constant does the atmospheric concentration of @xmath0 drop due to the increased absorption by the oceans ?
here we assume that every @xmath0 molecule colliding with the ocean surface " to the surface .
the number of @xmath0 molecules colliding with a square meter of ocean surface per second is@xcite @xmath73 the number of @xmath0 molecules in the atmosphere per square meter is @xmath74m@xmath5 .
so the time constant for absorption of @xmath0 by very cold oceans is @xmath75s ( we have taken account that 0.7 of the surface of the earth is covered by oceans ) .
so equilibrium of @xmath0 and the oceans is very short if we neglect diffusion of @xmath0 through the atmosphere .
let us now consider diffusion .
the partial pressure of @xmath0 decreases with altitude exponentially with a characteristic height @xmath76 m .
how long does it take a molecule of @xmath0 to diffuse 5550 m through the atmosphere ?
the result is @xmath77 years .
this result assumes no convection .
convection will reduce this time considerably .
in fact , the flux of carbon from the atmosphere to the oceans and _ vice versa _ is enough to replace all the atmospheric carbon in 6 years.@xcite so , on time scales of interest , the partial pressure of @xmath0 in the atmosphere is proportional to the concentration of @xmath0 in the surface water of the oceans : they are in equilibrium .
in the process of photosynthesis , a plant takes @xmath0 from the air , breaks it up using solar energy , and releases @xmath78 back to the atmosphere .
the carbon attaches to water to form carbohydrates @xmath79 , which is what plants are made of .
so , for every molecule of oxygen released to the atmosphere , there remains one atom of carbon in the plant .
what happens to the carbon when the plant dies ?
there are three alternatives : the carbon can ( i ) return to the atmosphere , ( ii ) accumulate on the ground , or ( iii ) end up in the oceans
. the photosynthesis process can occur in both directions .
examples of photosynthesis in reverse direction are combustion when we burn wood , respiration , and decomposition by aerobic bacteria . in these processes
the carbon of the plant becomes attached to oxygen from the air , and is returned to the atmosphere as @xmath0 .
note that no net oxygen is produced : the oxygen released to the atmosphere during the plant growth is consumed during the plant aerobic decay .
the carbon can end up in the soil , either as partially decomposed organic matter ( humus ) , as hydrocarbons or as coal .
if the plant dies in a medium that lacks oxygen , such as in oceans , lakes , rivers , swamps or under volcanic ash , the anaerobic bacteria have a chance to decompose the plant ( without the competition from aerobic bacteria ) .
the anaerobic bacteria produce methane ( ") , carbonic acids , bicarbonates , and humic acids .
the methane can escape to the atmosphere , or under enough pressure and temperature , can polymerize into hydrocarbons or can be crushed into coal .
the carbon can be washed down the rivers , in the form of carbonic acids , bicarbonates , and humic acids which are soluble in water .
the rivers in the amazon basin are dark due to the humic acids .
the amazon rain forest has humus only in the first few centimeters of soil .
so we neglect alternative ( ii ) . to quantify alternative ( iii ) , we took samples of water of several tributaries of the amazon river ( napo alto , napo bajo , san francisco and tiputini ) and measured the concentration of bicarbonate ( 0.71 mol / m@xmath80 ) and carbonic acid ( 0.11 mol / m@xmath80 ) . assuming that these concentrations are typical of the amazon river , and multiplying by the yearly discharge of the river
, we obtain the carbon discharged to the atlantic ocean by the amazon river : 50 million ( metric ) tonnes per year . in total , the amazon basin fixes about 10 billion brute tonnes of carbon per year .
so , about 99.5% of this carbon returns to the atmosphere due to the aerobic decomposition of organic matter , while only about 0.5% is washed down the rivers into the atlantic ocean .
it is interesting to compare these numbers with the world energy - related release of carbon dioxide from the consumption of oil , gas and coal : 24 billion tonnes in 2004 .
this corresponds to 6.5 billion tonnes of carbon per year .
so the amazon basin can transfer , from the atmosphere to the oceans , one year s worth of carbon dioxide emission in 130 years !
with some degree of confidence , we arrive at the following conclusions . 1 . ever since we have accurate measurements of the temperature of the atmosphere , _
i.e. _ since 1702 , we observe a global increase of temperature of about 0.4@xmath81c per century .
this warming does not accelerate in the second half of the xx century .
in fact , we see no statistically significant global warming since 1940.@xcite we observe no correlation of the global temperature with the consumption of oil , coal and gas , or with population .
the atmospheric concentrations of @xmath0 begins to increase around 1940@xcite when oil consumption takes off , yet we observe no corresponding increase of the slope of global warming.@xcite some studies suggest that this is due to a balance between the heating effect of @xmath0 and the cooling effects of aerosols and deforestation.@xcite from the data it is concluded that the accumulated effect of humankind on the global temperature until 1990 is not statistically significant : @xmath82c.@xcite so , the observed global warming since 1702 is part of the natural variability of the climate as we pull out of the " three centuries ago .
the pre - industrial concentration of @xmath0 in the atmosphere was @xmath83 ppm in 1800 .
it has since increased to 375 ppm in 2004.@xcite there is convincing evidence that this increase is due to burning of fossil fuels ( and forrests , and the manufacture of cement ) .
detailed models estimate that the changes of atmospheric composition since pre - industrial times up to 1995 produce a change of temperature of @xmath84k due to all greenhouse gases ( about half of this is from @xmath0 ) , @xmath85k due to aerosols@xcite , and @xmath86k due to the change of albedo caused by deforestation@xcite .
so we do not know if human activity heats or cools the earth . as indicated above , no significant net change has been observed .
the increase of the concentration of @xmath0 in the atmosphere accurately tracks the burning of fossil fuels ( and forrests ) .
two thirds of the carbon burned ends up in the atmosphere as @xmath0 , and the remaining third ends up dissolved in the surface layer of the oceans ( the time constant for this dissolution is about 6 years ) .
the fraction of excess carbon in the atmosphere should decrease to one third in about 50 years as more carbon is incorporated into the oceans ( as @xmath0 , @xmath87 , @xmath88 , @xmath89 ) , and in the land and marine biota .
the last third of the excess @xmath0 in the atmosphere is expected to return to the deep oceans and become buried as elemental carbon and as carbonates with several time constants ranging from hundreds to thousands of years.@xcite 5 .
burning all of the remaining economically viable reserves of oil , gas and coal over the next 150 years or so will approximately double the pre - industrial atmospheric concentration of @xmath0 .
the global warming due to a doubling of the concentration of @xmath0 is expected to increase the average surface air temperature by 1.3k to 4.8k.@xcite the increase of temperature is expected to be higher than average at higher latitudes ( and lower than average at low latitudes ) .
the heating effect of @xmath0 is obvious when we look at the earth emission spectra shown in figure [ earthradiation ] .
the range of results is large , so global warming is a difficult problem that does not seem to converge : as the models become more complex , the uncertainties appear to increase ! 6 .
ice core samples indicate that @xmath0 concentration and temperature are well correlated : a change of temperature by 9.5@xmath81c corresponds to a change in @xmath0 concentration from 195ppm to 270ppm.@xcite does the change of @xmath0 concentration cause the change of temperature ( by the greenhouse effect ) , or does the change of temperature cause the change of @xmath0 concentration ( due to the temperature dependence of the solubility of carbon in the oceans ) ?
due to the greenhouse effect , an increase of @xmath0 concentration from 195ppm to 270ppm would cause an increase in temperature of @xmath66c , much too small to account for the observed change in temperature .
conversely , an increase of @xmath63c of the temperature of the upper 1000 m of the oceans would increase the atmospheric concentration of @xmath0 by @xmath90ppm ( depending on the ocean ph ) .
so it is plausible that the changes of temperature of the oceans * caused * the pre - historic changes of atmospheric @xmath0 concentration .
data suggests that large volcanic explosions can trigger transitions from glacial to interglacial climates , by covering ice with volcanic ash , thereby changing the equilibrium temperature of the earth as seen in table [ emissivities ] .
photosynthesis in the amazon basin fixes @xmath91 billion tonnes of carbon per year .
however , aerobic decay releases almost all of this carbon back to the atmosphere as @xmath0 .
the balance , @xmath92 million tonnes of carbon per year , is discharged to the atlantic ocean in the form of carbonic acids , bicarbonates , and humic acids . | we do several simple calculations and measurements in an effort to gain understanding of global warming and the carbon cycle .
some conclusions are interesting : ( i ) there has been global warming since the end of the " around 1700 .
there is no statistically significant evidence of acceleration of global warming since 1940 .
( ii ) the increase of @xmath0 in the atmosphere , beginning around 1940 , accurately tracks the burning of fossil fuels . burning all of the remaining economically viable reserves of oil , gas and coal over the next 150 years or so
will approximately double the pre - industrial atmospheric concentration of @xmath0 .
the corresponding increase in the average temperature , due to the greenhouse effect , is quite uncertain : between 1.3 and 4.8k .
this increase of temperature is ( partially ? ) offset by the increase of aerosols and deforestation .
( iii ) ice core samples indicate that the pre - historic @xmath0 concentration and temperature are well correlated .
we conclude that changes in the temperatures of the oceans are probably the cause of the changes of pre - historic atmospheric @xmath0 concentration .
( iv ) data suggests that large volcanic explosions can trigger transitions from glacial to interglacial climates .
( v ) most of the carbon fixed by photosynthesis in the amazon basin returns to the atmosphere due to aerobic decay . |
an analysis of spin dynamics involves calculations of spin correlators .
spin operators do not satisfy the wick theorem , and various methods have been used to still enable the use of perturbative ( diagrammatic ) methods .
one of the approaches is based on the majorana - fermion representation of spin operators .
this approach has a long history and was applied recently to condensed - matter problems .
@xcite in this approach one introduces three majorana fermions @xmath0 ( per spin ) and expresses the spin ( or pauli ) operators via these fermions : @xmath1 obviously , an analysis of spin - spin correlations based on eq .
( [ eq : majorana_representation_3 ] ) requires calculations of a four - fermion correlator . in this note
we show that spin correlators coincide with certain two - fermion ( i.e. , one - particle ) correlators .
we discuss under which conditions this identity may simplify the analysis and discuss its particular applications .
majorana fermions satisfy the anti - commutation relations : @xmath2 for @xmath3 and @xmath4 , and are real : @xmath5 ( @xmath6 ) .
these properties ensure that the representation ( [ eq : majorana_representation_3 ] ) reproduces the commutation relations of the spin algebra .
an important feature of the representation ( [ eq : majorana_representation_3 ] ) is the fact that the spin operators are bilinear ( ` bosonic ' ) combinations of dirac ( annihilation / creation ) fermionic operators .
one may construct the three majorana fermion operators ( for a spin ) out of three different dirac fermions , @xmath7 , each annihilation operator acting in its own two - dimensional hilbert space .
this ensures the anticommutation relations and the property @xmath8 .
the whole hilbert space is then 8-dimensional .
the dimensionality of the hilbert space may be reduced if two majorana fermions , e.g. @xmath9 and @xmath10 , are constructed as linear combinations of a single dirac fermion @xmath11 and its conjugate @xmath12 : @xmath13 and @xmath14 .
another dirac fermion @xmath15 is still needed to construct the third majorana fermion @xmath16 . in this mixed majorana - dirac picture
@xmath17 this ` drone - fermion ' representation was used for the analysis of magnetic systems in the 60s ( see refs .
the whole hilbert space in this representation is 4-dimensional .
depending on the rotational symmetry , this representation may be more convenient than ( [ eq : majorana_representation_3 ] ) .
we have described this construction in the hilbert space of two dirac fermions @xmath11 and @xmath18 .
alternatively one can view it as two replicas of the original spin .
indeed , let us label the basis states in the following way : denote the state without @xmath11- and @xmath18-fermions by @xmath19 , and also @xmath20 , @xmath21 , and @xmath22 .
for the state @xmath23 the first index @xmath24 denotes the spin component , while the second @xmath25 labels the spin copy .
one notices that the spin operators @xmath26 , @xmath27 , and @xmath28 do not mix the @xmath29- and @xmath30-subspaces , i.e. , they operate in the same way on the two ` copies ' of the spin .
further , one may view the index @xmath25 as an isospin and introduce the respective pauli isospin operators @xmath31 .
in particular , @xmath32 is the ` copy - switching ' operator : @xmath33 and @xmath34 .
the fermionic operators can be expressed as @xmath35 further , @xmath36 , for any @xmath37 .
accordingly , in terms of the fermionic operators we have @xmath38 .
the operator @xmath32 commutes with ` all other ' operators : with @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 , @xmath11 , @xmath39 , and @xmath40 .
a physical hamiltonian depends on the spin operators @xmath41 , @xmath42 , @xmath28 ( and on other degrees of freedom , e.g. , the electrons in the kondo problem ) .
thus the operator @xmath32 commutes with any hamiltonian and we obtain @xmath43 here we have used the fact that @xmath32 is time - independent , commutes with the majorana fermions , and that @xmath44 . for example , we obtain @xmath45\,[f(t')+f^{\dag}(t')]\rangle \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] in certain situations the identity ( [ eq : bubble_to_line_reduction ] ) may simplify the calculations .
indeed , if the majorana representation ( [ eq : majorana_representation_3 ] ) , ( [ eq : majorana_representation_2 ] ) is used for a calculation of spin - spin correlations , a four - fermion correlator needs to be evaluated . in a typical situation ,
the lowest - order contribution is given by a loop - like diagram which involves two fermionic propagators .
a straightforward evaluation of higher - order contributions requires an analysis of the self - energy corrections to these propagators as well as of the vertex corrections .
the use of the relation ( [ eq : bubble_to_line_reduction ] ) reduces the task to the evaluation of a single self - energy . in general , evaluation of this self - energy to all orders in the perturbative expansion
involves complicated diagrams and , in particular , other self - energies and vertex corrections .
hence an involved calculation may still be needed .
nevertheless , the relation ( [ eq : bubble_to_line_reduction ] ) may be useful if the needed self - energy part can be estimated reliably , for instance , by calculating the low - order contributions .
we discuss two examples in section [ sec : example ] .
note also that the relation ( [ eq : bubble_to_line_reduction ] ) may be straightforwardly generalized to multi - spin correlators , the evaluation of which then reduces to multi - fermion correlators .
further , in a problem , that involves many spins represented via majorana fermions , ( e.g. , a lattice spin model ) the @xmath32-operators for different spins ( sites ) may be involved in a relation similar to ( [ eq : bubble_to_line_reduction ] ) . in this case
their product does not drop out of the calculation ( unlike @xmath44 for one spin ) .
one might be concerned by the fact that eq .
( [ eq : bubble_to_line_reduction ] ) reduces a correlator of physical quantities to a correlator of `` unphysical '' operators .
another way of expressing this concern is to invoke the gauge symmetry . indeed the majorana representations ( [ eq : majorana_representation_3 ] ) and ( [ eq : majorana_representation_2 ] ) possess the discrete @xmath46-symmetry @xmath47 . as an operator which realizes the symmetry transformation one may choose @xmath48 ( cf
. ref .
for example , @xmath49 .
thus , the forth majorana fermion allowed in the hilbert space of the representation ( [ eq : majorana_representation_2 ] ) generates the symmetry transformation .
one can as well use as a generator @xmath50 , which just flips the sign of the wave function of the @xmath30-spin , keeping that of the @xmath29-spin intact .
consider now a time - dependent gauge transformation , which transforms a wave function @xmath51 to @xmath52 , where @xmath53 and @xmath54 .
it transforms the operators @xmath55 , @xmath56 .
thus the operator @xmath32 is now time - dependent and no longer commutes with the hamiltonian .
indeed , the gauge - transformed hamiltonian reads @xmath57 and the last ( gauge ) term does not commute with @xmath32 .
thus we find that @xmath58 i.e. , the single - fermion correlators are not gauge - invariant . the relation ( [ eq : bubble_to_line_reduction ] )
is written in a fixed gauge , in which @xmath59 . in an arbitrary gauge
, the factor @xmath60 should be added on the rhs making the identity gauge - invariant . in path - integral calculations the integration is performed over all configurations ( all gauges ) .
if a saddle - point solution breaks the @xmath46-symmetry ( and hence has a counterpart ) fluctuations which involve switching between two mean - field solutions play an important part and need special attention .
@xcite however , for perturbative calculations around a trivial saddle point , e.g. above the kondo temperature , the ` fixed - gauge ' relation ( [ eq : bubble_to_line_reduction ] ) might be quite useful .
the relation ( [ eq : bubble_to_line_reduction ] ) can simplify calculations , since to evaluate a single - fermion green function one needs only to evaluate a self - energy . in a perturbative regime , when one may restrict oneself to evaluating the lowest - order contribution , eq .
( [ eq : bubble_to_line_reduction ] ) simplifies the task .
one example of such a problem is dicussed in ref .
@xcite where continuous measurement of the state of a spin ( qubit ) by a quantum detector is analyzed and the ouput noise of the detector as well as the spin dynamics is studied . a calculation of a spin - spin correlator in the majorana representation requires an evaluation of a two - fermion loop and involves the analysis of two self - energy parts and a vertex correction .
it turns out that the vertex correction is important already in the lowest order and may even cancel one of the self - energy contributions .
this fact may be understood and the calculations are considerably simplified if the relation ( [ eq : bubble_to_line_reduction ] ) is invoked .
the obtained result coincides with an alternative calculation , in which instead of using the majorana representation to enable the use of the wick theorem one follows the dynamics of the spin directly .
this approach @xcite may be useful if the problem involves only a small number of spins ( or other ` non - wick ' degrees of freedom ) .
here we consider another example : the dissipative dynamics of a spin coupled to an environment , for instance , the spin - boson model .
consider the case of a purely transverse coupling : @xmath61 where @xmath62 is a fluctuating bosonic observable of the bath , whose hamiltonian @xmath63 determines the statistics of fluctuations .
we consider gaussian , but not necessarily equilibrium , fluctuations .
using the keldysh technique we perform a calculation considering the bath - spin coupling ( the second term on the rhs of eq .
( [ eq : hspin - bath ] ) ) as a perturbation .
below we use the notations of ref .
let us introduce the matrix green function of the bath : @xmath64 its keldysh component @xmath65 and the difference between the retarded and advanced components @xmath66 are related to the symmetrized and antisymmetrized correlators : @xmath67 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 . in equilibrium
they are related by the fluctuation - dissipation theorem : @xmath70 . here
@xmath71 and @xmath72 .
similarly , for the majorana fermion @xmath73 we define @xmath74 .
the bare green functions are @xmath75 and @xmath76 . for the @xmath11-fermion we use the bogolubov - nambu spinors @xmath77 and @xmath78 and define a matrix @xmath79 .
calculation of the spin propagators ( in a stationary state ) reduces due to the relation ( [ eq : bubble_to_line_reduction ] ) to the evaluation of the fermion green functions @xmath80 and @xmath81 .
these functions can be found from the the dyson ( kinetic ) equations : @xmath82 @xmath83 where @xmath84 and @xmath85 are the self - energies .
all the quantities in eq .
( [ eq : dyson_psi ] ) are @xmath86 matrices ( with the nambu and keldysh components ) . in the frequency domain the operator @xmath87 is given by @xmath88 while for @xmath89 we obtain @xmath90 we disregard infinitesimal imaginary terms in eqs .
( [ eq : g_psi_0 ] , [ eq : g_eta_0 ] ) since they are superseded by the self - energy parts in eqs .
( [ eq : dyson_psi ] , [ eq : dyson_eta ] ) .
the lowest - order contributions to the self - energies @xmath91 are shown in fig .
[ figure : sigma_ferm ] ( the matrix structure after the keldysh rotation is given @xcite ) .
we find that @xmath92 and @xmath93 , where @xmath94 ia a matrix in the nambu space .
similarly , we obtain @xmath95 and @xmath96 . while the retarded and advanced components of the bare fermion green functions are known , its keldysh component contains information about the distribution function and is sensitive to the environment ( cf .
@xcite ) . to perform the calculation , one introduces the distribution function @xmath97 via @xmath98
. evaluating @xmath84 from the first diagram in fig .
[ figure : sigma_ferm ] , we find @xmath99 \ , \ ] ] @xmath100 \ .\ ] ] the symmetry relation @xmath101 implies @xmath102 . hence without evaluating @xmath103 we find @xmath104 and @xmath105 the real parts of the retarded and advanced self - energies give the non - equilibrium generalization of the lamb shift , i.e. , renormalize the level splitting @xmath106 . this renormalization is small if the noise is weak and has a non - singular spectrum . substituting the self - energy @xmath84 into the dyson equation ( [ eq : dyson_psi ] )
we obtain @xmath107 where @xmath108 .
inverting eq .
( [ eq : g_psi_(-1 ) ] ) we obtain @xmath109 @xmath110 from eqs .
( [ eq : g_psi_ra ] ) and ( [ eq : g_psi_k ] ) we see that , at least in this order of perturbation theory , we can use the relation @xmath111 , where @xmath112 and ( for any pair @xmath113 of nambu indices ) @xmath114 a quantity of the zeroth order in the coupling constant . using these results we can calculate @xmath85 : @xmath115 \nonumber \\ & & + [ b\to -b]\ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath116 + [ b\to -b ] \
.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we evaluate the self - energy @xmath117 near the pole @xmath118 of the green function @xmath81 : @xmath119 and @xmath120 \ .\ ] ] now , with the acquired knowledge of single - fermion green functions , we can evaluate various spin - spin correlators .
we start with @xmath121 where the bosonic time - ordering is chosen for the spin components . from eq .
( [ eq : bubble_to_line_reduction ] ) we deduce that @xmath122 since @xmath123 $ ] , we obtain @xmath124 this result describes the peaks in the spectrum of spin corelations at @xmath125 , with the width corresponding to the dephasing rate @xmath126 , thus reproducing the form known , e.g. , from the analysis of the bloch - redfield equations .
@xcite similarly , for the green function of the majorana fermion @xmath127 we obtain @xmath128 where @xmath129 \ .\ ] ] the keldysh component vanishes , @xmath130 , and we find @xmath131 this may be compared to the peak shape obtained in the bloch - redfield approach .
@xcite it can be expressed in terms of the average value @xmath132 of the @xmath133-component : @xmath134\,\frac{2t_1^{-1}}{\omega^2 + t_1^{-2 } } \ , \ ] ] where the relaxation time is given by @xmath135 . the result ( [ eq : pi_zz ] )
reproduces the high - frequency behavior of eq .
( [ eq : pi_zz_exact ] ) and the ` width of the peak ' , which may be read off from the high-@xmath136 asymptotics , @xmath137 .
this indicates that at lower frequencies higher - order corrections ( contributions to @xmath117 ) are important , which requires a further analysis .
in summary , we discussed an identity relating spin correlations to single - particle majorana - fermion propagators and problems where the use of this relation simplifies the analysis .
we are grateful to a. auerbach , t. costi , y. gefen , m. kiselev , j. kroha , i. martin , and p. wlfle for stimulating discussions , and in particular to a. mirlin , a. rosch , and m. vojta for numerous inspiring conversations .
y.m . was supported by the humboldt foundation , the bmbf , and the zip programme of the german government . | in the majorana representation of a spin 1/2 we find an identity which relates spin - spin correlators to one - particle fermionic correlators .
this should be contrasted with the straightforward approach in which two - particle ( four - fermion ) correlators need to be calculated .
we discuss applications to the analysis of the dynamics of a spin coupled to a dissipative environment and of a quantum detector performing a continuous measurement of a qubit s state . |
it is the object of relativistic heavy - ion collisions to create and study strongly interacting matter excited beyond its hadronic phase @xcite .
the existence of such a phase [ the quark gluon plasma ( qgp ) ] has been predicted by lattice qcd calculations @xcite which exhibit a sudden rise in the scaled pressure and entropy density as the temperature is raised just beyond @xmath0 mev .
detailed models of nuclear reactions had predicted that the energy deposition in the center - of - mass frame should be sufficient to cause temperatures at mid - rapidity in central collisions of gold nuclei to reach upwards of @xmath1 mev @xcite .
these predictions have been confirmed by the experimental results of the four relativistic heavy - ion collider ( rhic ) detector collaborations , which have set a lower bound of about @xmath2 gev/@xmath3 on the energy density at a time @xmath4 fm / c in central au+au collisions @xcite . according to lattice calculations
, such energy densities should place the excited matter firmly in the deconfined region .
the fact that various lattice observables in the excited phase assume values close to those expected for a free gas of quarks and gluons has let to the picture that beyond @xmath5 , the degrees of freedom in chromodynamic matter are quasiparticles that carry the quantum numbers of quarks and gluons . however ,
experimental results from the four rhic detectors have cast doubts on this picture : the observed , large , elliptic and radial flow exhibited by the produced matter have led to the speculation that the produced matter may be strongly interacting @xcite .
these findings have given rise to phenomenological models in terms of bound states of quarks and gluons @xcite .
such approaches , however , do not fare well in comparison with lattice susceptibility calculations @xcite .
such lattice comparisons do not reveal any information regarding the gluon sector of the plasma . as a result ,
efforts to elucidate the nature of the gluon structure have taken a phenomenological turn @xcite _ e.g. _ , there have been recent attempts to probe this structure through jet correlations @xcite . here
, we explore a novel means of probing the gluonic structure of the produced matter is proposed : through its possible electromagnetic signature .
lepton pairs and real photons occupy a privileged status as they suffer essentially no final state interaction @xcite after their initial production .
thus , their emission rates have the potential to provide direct insight into the nature of the medium and its interactions . to this end
, we focus on the electromagnetic signatures of a series of pure glue processes , where the final rates are directly proportional to the gluon density of the produced matter .
gluons do not carry electric charge , yet their interactions may generate electromagnetic signatures if the _ medium _ is itself electrically charged .
in partonic matter at equilibrium , this is achieved by the introduction of a non - vanishing charge chemical potential or a net asymmetry between the quark and anti - quark populations .
this leads to a violation of furry s theorem @xcite and the appearance of diagrams where two gluons may fuse through a quark loop to form a photon see fig .
[ gg - gamma ] .
the possibility of such rates was first pointed out in ref .
@xcite , the dilepton rates from such processes in different scenarios was expounded upon in ref . @xcite .
because of restrictions imposed by yang s
theorem @xcite , dilepton rates from such processes become appreciable only at high transverse momentum of the dilepton pair or in the case where the incoming gluons are themselves massive . the current work , in some ways an extension of these efforts will focus on the photon signature , which does not suffer from either of these constraints .
a large number of previous and even recent photon production calculations from an electrically charged qgp have neglected the baryon chemical potential @xmath6 ( as well as other chemical potentials ) in the plasma @xcite : in these cases , the photon production rate only depends on the temperature .
it is now known that the central region at the cern sps and even rhic is not just heated vacuum @xcite , but actually displays a finite baryon density or an asymmetry between baryon and anti - baryon populations .
consequently , the baryon chemical density and thus @xmath6 in the qgp , does not vanish . in this case , the photon production rate ( from the deconfined sector ) is a function of both temperature @xmath7 and quark chemical potential @xmath8 of the qgp . in this treatment ,
isospin symmetry of two flavors is imposed , _
i.e. _ , both @xmath9 and @xmath10 quarks will be assumed to be massless and have chemical potentials @xmath11 . as can be immediately demonstrated ,
such a plasma is globally electrically charged .
the earliest estimates of photon production rates from electrically charged plasmas , in ref .
@xcite , had pointed out that given an energy density @xmath12 , the photon production rate will decrease strongly with increasing chemical potential of the medium
. however , such calculations only include processes which are non - vanishing at @xmath13 .
the calculation of rates from these channels have been rigorously carried out in ref .
@xcite , in the hard - thermal - loop effective theory @xcite at one loop .
rates at two loops in the htl theory , at vanishing chemical potential , were first presented in ref .
@xcite , where it was demonstrated that the two - loop rates from bremsstrahlung processes actually dominate over rates at leading order in the coupling .
all order resummed rates for bremsstrahlung processes which includes the landau - pomeranchuck migdal suppression from multiple scattering have been presented in ref .
the two loop rates have been extended to finite chemical potential and chemical non - equilibrium in ref .
the effects of dynamical evolution of the quark gluon plasma on space - time integrated photon yields from such two loop rates were presented recently in ref .
@xcite .
it is the object of the current work to extend this line of inquiry and present rates for hard photon production from processes which arise solely at finite chemical potential .
as this is the first such attempt , we focus on establishing the basic processes and will pursue phenomenological applications elsewhere . in the following section , the calculation of the matrix element of the one - loop gluon - gluon - photon vertex in the htl formalism is presented . in sect .
iii , the matrix element is incorporated into the hard photon production rate . in sect .
iv , numerical estimates of photon rates from these processes are presented and compared with the leading order rates of ref .
@xcite . a comparison with the resummed rates of ref .
@xcite can not be performed as yet as these calculations have not been extended to finite baryon density .
we summarize and outline future directions in sect .
at zero temperature and at finite temperature and zero charge density , diagrams in qed that contain a fermion loop with an odd number of photon vertices ( e.g. fig .
[ gg - gamma ] ) are canceled by an equal and opposite contribution originating from the same diagram with fermion lines running in the opposite direction ( furry s theorem @xcite ) .
this statement can also be generalized almost unchanged to qcd , for processes with two gluons and an odd number of photon vertices .
a physical perspective is obtained by noting that all these diagrams are encountered in the perturbative evaluation of green s functions with an odd number of gauge field operators . at zero ( finite ) temperature , in the well defined case of qed
, the focus lies on quantities such as @xmath14 ( @xmath15 $ ] ) under the action of the charge conjugation operator @xmath16 .
the photon , being charge conjugation negative , leads to @xmath17 . in the case of the vacuum @xmath18 , we note that @xmath19 , as the vacuum is uncharged . as a result @xmath20 at a temperature @xmath7 ,
the corresponding quantity to consider is @xmath21 where @xmath22 and @xmath8 is a chemical potential . here
, however , @xmath23 , where @xmath24 is a state in the ensemble with the same number of antiparticles as there are particles in @xmath25 and vice - versa . if @xmath26 _
i.e. _ , the ensemble average displays zero density , inserting the operator @xmath27 as before , one obtains , @xmath28 the sum over all states will contain the mirror term @xmath29 , with the same thermal weight . as a result , summing over all states in the ensemble gives ,
@xmath30 and furry s theorem still holds .
however , if @xmath31 ( @xmath32 unequal number of particles and antiparticles ) then @xmath33 the mirror term in such a case is @xmath34 , with a different thermal weight due to the fact that the net charge of the state @xmath35 is different and hence is weighted differently by the chemical potential . as a result , the thermal expectation of an odd number of gauge field operators is non - vanishing , @xmath36 and furry s theorem no longer holds .
one may say that the medium , being charged , manifestly breaks charge conjugation invariance and these green s functions are thus finite , leading to the appearance of new processes in a perturbative expansion .
two comments are in order : the eventual evaluation of the photon rate will appear to depend on the net baryon density ( as opposed to the net quark density ) , as , in the model of the plasma adopted , the net baryon density is carried equally by the up and down flavors . as pointed out in ref .
@xcite , this is not the only means by which a finite charge density may be achieved .
the processes of fig .
[ gg - gamma ] are also affected by the constraints imposed by yang s theorem which states that a spin one particle may not decay or be formed by two identical massless vectors @xcite .
the processes outlined in the following are computed within a thermalized medium , where the presence of longitudinal gluon excitations leads to a breaking of the symmetry which underlies yang s theorem .
the incorporation of thermal gluon masses and self - energies in perturbation theory has to be done carefully , owing to issues arising from color gauge invariance . in this work ,
the calculation is carried out in the gauge invariant resummed theory of hard - thermal - loops @xcite , where one assumes the temperature @xmath37 and as a result the coupling constant @xmath38 .
effective propagators and vertices involving soft @xmath39 momenta are obtained by integrating out the hard @xmath40 modes .
this allows for a well defined perturbative expansion of the photon production amplitude .
the feynman diagrams corresponding to the leading contributions ( in coupling ) to the new channel of photon production are those of fig .
[ gg - gamma ] , with two gluons and a photon attached to a quark loop @xcite .
such a process does not exist at zero temperature , or even at finite temperature and vanishing chemical potential . at non - zero density , this leads to two new sources for photon production : the fusion of gluons to form a photon ( @xmath41 ) and the decay of a massive gluon into a photon and a softer gluon ( @xmath42 ) .
the full , physical , matrix element is obtained by summing contributions from both diagrams which have fermion number running in opposite directions , @xmath43 .
the amplitudes corresponding to these two diagrams may be expressed in the imaginary time formalism as : @xmath44 { ( q+k)_\alpha q_\beta(q+k - p)_\gamma\over ( q+k)^2 q^2(q+k - p)^2}\nonumber \\ t_2^{\mu\rho\nu}(p , p - k , k ) & = & t\sum_{q_0 } \int { d^3q\over ( 2\pi)^3 } eg^2 { \delta_{ab}\over 2 } { \mathrm tr}[\gamma^\mu\gamma^\gamma\gamma^\rho\gamma^\beta\gamma^\nu\gamma^\alpha ] { ( q - k)_\alpha q_\beta(q - k+p)_\gamma\over ( q - k)^2 q^2(q - k+p)^2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the masses of quarks have been omitted as the momenta of the quarks is considered hard @xmath40 in the htl expansion . in the imaginary time formalism , the zeroth components of four momentum are discrete matsubara frequencies , @xmath45 where integers @xmath46 , @xmath47 and @xmath48 in the above expression range from @xmath49 to @xmath50 , and @xmath8 is the quark chemical potential .
it may be easily demonstrated @xcite , using the the properties of the @xmath51 matrices , that at zero chemical potential these two amplitudes cancel each other , consistent with the qcd generalization of furry s theorem @xcite .
the sum over the matsubara frequencies may be conveniently performed using the non - covariant propagator method of ref .
@xcite . here
, one defines a time - three - momentum propagator @xmath52 , as @xmath53 in the above equation , @xmath54 represents the real energy of the particle from its three momentum and not the conjugate the imaginary time @xmath55 .
the explicit expression of the imaginary time quark propagator is given by @xmath56{e^{-\tau ( { se}\mp\mu ) } } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath57 + 1})}$ ] are fermi - dirac distribution functions .
performing the summation of the matsubara frequency @xmath58 leads to the expression for the amplitude : @xmath59 \sum_{s_1s_2s_3 } \frac{s_1s_2s_3}{8e_{q+k}e_qe_{q+k - p } } \nonumber \\ & & { \tiny \frac{(q+k)_{s_1\alpha}{q_{s_2\beta } } { ( q+k - p)_{s_3\gamma } } } { i\omega_p - s_1e_{q+k}+s_3e_{q+k - p } } \left(\frac{{\delta\widetilde{n}}(e_{q+k})-{\delta\widetilde{n}}({e_q } ) } { { { { i\omega}}_k}-{s_1e_{q+k}}+{s_2}{e_q}}- \frac{{\delta\widetilde{n}}(e_{q+k - p})-{\delta\widetilde{n}}({e_q } ) } { { i\omega_k-{{i\omega } } _ p}-{s_3e_{q+k - p}}+{s_2}{e_q}}\right)}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the above equation , @xmath60 , and @xmath61 .
the further evaluation of the photon production amplitude is carried out in the htl approximation for the quark loop . in this limit ,
the photon and gluon momenta are considered soft @xmath62 , and the quark momenta are hard @xmath63 , where @xmath7 is the temperature and @xmath64 is the effective coupling constant in the medium .
the quark lines which carry a component of the external gluon energies are taylor expanded as follows , @xmath65 where @xmath66 and @xmath67 .
using the above approximation , allows for a factorization of the quark angular integral .
performing the integration over the magnitude of the quark momentum @xmath68 analytically , leads to the expression , @xmath69 \nonumber \\ & & \left\{-{\hat{q}_{+\alpha}\hat{q}_{+\beta}\hat{q}_{+\gamma } \over p\cdot\hat{q}_+ } \left({\vec{k}^2-(\vec{k}\cdot\hat{q})^2\over k\cdot\hat{q}_+ } + { \vec{k}{'^2 } -(\vec{k}'\cdot\hat{q})^2\over k'\cdot\hat{q}_+}\right ) - { k \hat{\mathcal{k}}_{\alpha}\hat{q}_{+\beta}\hat{q}_{+\gamma } - k'\hat{q}_{+\alpha}\hat{q}_{+\beta}\hat{\mathcal{k}'}_{\gamma } \over p\cdot\hat{q}_+}\left({\vec{k}\cdot\hat{q}\over k\cdot\hat{q}_+}-{\vec{k}'\cdot\hat{q}\over k'\cdot\hat{q}_+}\right ) \right .
\nonumber \\ & & \left .
\over p\cdot\hat{q}_+ } { [ \vec{k}^2-(\vec{k}\cdot\hat{q})^2 ] - [ \vec{k}{'^2}-(\vec{k}'\cdot\hat{q})^2]\over p\cdot\hat{q}_+}\left({\vec{k}\cdot\hat{q}\over k\cdot\hat{q}_+ } -{\vec{k}'\cdot\hat{q}\over k'\cdot\hat{q}_+ } \right ) \right .
\nonumber \\ & & \left .
- { \hat{q}_{+\alpha}\hat{q}_{+\beta}\hat{q}_{+\gamma } \over p\cdot\hat{q}_+ } \left({\vec{k}\cdot\hat{q}\over k\cdot\hat{q}_+ } { \vec{k}^2-(\vec{k}\cdot\hat{q})^2\over k\cdot\hat{q}_+ } + { \vec{k}'\cdot\hat{q}\over k'\cdot\hat{q}_+ } { \vec{k}{'^2}-(\vec{k}'\cdot\hat{q})^2\over k'\cdot\hat{q}_+ } \right ) + { 2\hat{q}_{+\alpha}\hat{q}_{+\beta}\hat{q}_{+\gamma } \over p\cdot\hat{q}_+ } \left({(\vec{k}\cdot\hat{q})^2\over k\cdot\hat{q}_+}+{(\vec{k}'\cdot\hat{q})^2\over k'\cdot\hat{q}_+ } \right ) \right .
\nonumber \\ & & \left .
- \hat{q}_{-\alpha}\hat{q}_{+\beta}\hat{q}_{+\gamma } { \vec{k}'\cdot\hat{q}\over k'\cdot{q}_+ } - \hat{q}_{+\alpha}\hat{q}_{-\beta}\hat{q}_{+\gamma } { \vec{p}\cdot\hat{q}\over p\cdot\hat{q}_+ } - \hat{q}_{+\alpha}\hat{q}_{+\beta}\hat{q}_{-\gamma } { \vec{k}\cdot\hat{q}\over k\cdot\hat{q}_+ } \right\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath70 and @xmath71 is the differential solid angle of the quark momentum @xmath68 .
the first line of the above equation , demonstrates explicitly that the amplitude is directly proportional to the chemical potential @xmath8 . as a result
, the contribution to the photon production rate from this channel will grow quadratically with increasing chemical potential if the temperature of the medium is held constant .
the remnant angular integral over @xmath72 is nontrivial and is performed numerically . the possibility of radiation or absorption of a space - like gluon by an on - shell quark induces a long distance enhancement in a small part of phase space in each of the two diagrams separately .
such contributions are diminished by the destructive interference between the two diagrams and thus do not contribute to any eventual long distance enhancement in the rate of photon production from this channel . including all contributions ,
leads to the survival of only the imaginary part of the amplitude in this sector .
the resulting expression is , @xmath73 \left(-{\mu\omega\over 8k}\right){i\pi } \nonumber\\ & & \left\ { -{1\over p\cdot\hat{\bar{q } } } \left ( k\hat{\mathcal{k}}_{\alpha } \hat{\bar{q}}_{+\beta } \hat{\bar{q}}_{+\gamma } - k'\hat{\bar{q}}_{+\alpha } \hat{\bar{q}}_{+\beta } \hat{\mathcal{k}'}_{\gamma } \right)-{[\vec{k}^2-(\vec{k}\cdot\hat{\bar{q}})^2 ] - [ \vec{k}{'^2}-(\vec{k}'\cdot\hat{\bar{q}})^2]\over ( p\cdot\hat{\bar{q}}_+)^2}\hat{\bar{q}}_{+\alpha}\hat{\bar{q}}_{+\beta } \hat{\bar{q}}_{+\gamma}\right.\nonumber\\ & & \left .
+ { k\over p\cdot\hat{\bar{q}}}\left(\hat{\mathcal{q}}_{\alpha } \hat{\bar{q}}_{+\beta } \hat{\bar{q}}_{+\gamma } + \hat{\bar{q}}_{+\alpha } \hat{\mathcal{q}}_{\beta } \hat{\bar{q}}_{+\gamma } + \hat{\bar{q}}_{+\alpha } \hat{\bar{q}}_{+\beta } \hat{\mathcal{q}}_{\gamma}\right ) - \hat{\bar{q}}_{+\alpha } \hat{\bar{q}}_{+\beta } \hat{\bar{q}}_{-\gamma } \right\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath74 and @xmath75 are given by @xmath76 the above equations represent the central result of this effort .
while this been derived in a thermalized environment , it may be easily generalized to moderate departures from equilibrium .
this will remain the subject of a future effort , where the above matrix element will be used to study the photon signature emanating from the gluon sector of different models of the qgp . in the subsequent sections
, the above amplitude will be applied to compute the photon production rate from gluon fusion and decay in the simplest model of a qgp , a plasma of quasi - particle quarks and gluons in complete thermal and chemical equilibrium .
in the preceding sections , the origin and derivation of the amplitude of photon production from two gluons through a quark triangle has been outlined .
such an amplitude may be used for different processes such as the fusion of gluons to form a photon or the decay of a gluon into a photon and a gluon of lower energy .
the production or absorption rate of photons from a dense medium is related to the imaginary part of the photon self - energy in the medium .
the choice of self - energy depends on the process of interest . in what follows
, the focus will lie on the imaginary part of the photon self - energy of fig .
[ photon - sf ] . in the case of a medium in complete thermal and chemical equilibrium ,
the thermal photon emission rate @xmath77 is related to the discontinuity or the imaginary part of the retarded photon self - energy @xmath78 at finite temperature @xmath7 through the relation @xcite , @xmath79 where @xmath80 and @xmath48 are the energy and momentum of the photons .
this formula is valid to all orders of strong interactions , but only to @xmath81 in the electromagnetic interactions , as the photons , once produced , will tend to escape from the matter without further interaction . the photon self energy from fig .
[ photon - sf ] may be expressed formally as , @xmath82 where @xmath83 is the effective photon - gluon - gluon vertex evaluated in the last section , and @xmath84 is the effective gluon propagator , after summing up all the htl contributions to the self - energy of the gluon . in the coulomb gauge ,
the propagator is given by @xcite @xmath85 in the above equation , @xmath86 , @xmath87 is the transverse projection tensor and @xmath88 specifies the rest frame of the medium ; the explicit expressions for @xmath89 and @xmath90 can be found in ref .
it is convenient to define the transverse and longitudinal gluon propagators @xmath91 and @xmath92 . in the complex @xmath93 plane , these propagators exhibit a discontinuity or cut from @xmath94 to @xmath47 ; in addition , they have poles at @xmath95 , which give the two dispersion relations for the longitudinal and transverse modes of the gluons in the medium . in the interest of completeness ,
these are plotted in fig .
[ dispersion - relation ] . for transverse gluons and longitudinal gluons in a quark gluon plasma , where @xmath96 is the thermal gluon mass.,width=302 ] in the plot , the upper branch is the dispersion relation for transverse excitation modes , and the lower branch is for the the longitudinal one .
the solid line represents the light cone .
the dispersion relations admit a thermal gluon mass at the intercept @xmath97 given as @xmath98 @xcite . in order to calculate the thermal photon differential production rate
, we evaluate the imaginary part or the discontinuity of the photon self - energy , which involves evaluating its various cuts . in the interest of a physical interpretation of the various cuts ,
the polarization tensor @xmath99 may be expanded as a product of polarization vectors as @xmath100 , where the @xmath101-axis is chosen as the direction of the photon momentum @xmath102 .
then the effective propagator may be formally written as @xmath103 where we set @xmath104 and @xmath105 , @xmath106 .
the entire expression for the rate , may be expressed in a factorized form @xmath107 , where @xmath108 is the matsubara frequency of the gluon and @xmath109 is the frequency of the external photon . the remaining sum over @xmath108 and the discontinuity across the real @xmath109
is achieved by means of the identity , @xcite , @xmath110 where @xmath111 and @xmath112 are the distribution functions of gluons , and @xmath113 and @xmath114 are the spectral functions of @xmath115 and @xmath116 . the spectral function @xmath117 for @xmath118 is defined as @xmath119 . employing the above formula , the discontinuity in the photon self - energy may be expressed in a kinetic form , @xmath120 where the matrix element @xmath121 , and @xmath122 and @xmath123 are the spectral functions of the gluon propagators @xmath124 and @xmath125 .
@xmath126 + \beta_{t , l}(k_0,k)\theta(k^2-k_0 ^ 2).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the spectral functions @xmath127 contain contributions from the poles @xmath128 with residue @xmath129 as well as from the branch cuts @xmath130 .
the product of two @xmath127 functions give three types of contribution : pole - pole , pole - cut , and cut - cut .
the pole - pole terms represent the process involving two quasi - particles with dispersion relations displayed in fig .
[ dispersion - relation ] .
the terms from the cuts represents the processes involving space - like gluons from the medium , _
i.e._. , gluons which are intermediate states of a scattering process . in this first effort
, the focus will lie on the hard photon production rate , _ i.e. _ , photons with momenta @xmath131 .
this requires that at least one of the gluons in fig .
[ photon - sf ] to be hard .
while in the usual htl prescription , such particles receive suppressed contributions from hard loops , a component of the htl self - energy which produces a thermal gluon mass is retained .
the cut - cut contribution with two space - like gluons is dominant only in the region where both gluon momenta are soft and may be ignored in this effort . as a result ,
the two main contributions to the hard photon rate computed in this paper emanate form the pole - pole and pole - cut terms . in the subsequent section , numerical estimates of the photon rate from a set of production scenarios is provided and compared to the corresponding rate from the leading process of hard photon production from compton scattering and pair annihilation .
in this section , numerical results for the hard photon production rate from a plasma with a finite charge density will be presented .
the calculation is performed for two massless flavors of quarks with @xmath132 .
in such a plasma , the strong coupling constant @xmath133 . the strange sector has been ignored in this calculation . in fig .
[ t=200 ] , the photon production from our new channel is compared with the contribution from the leading order qcd processes of quark anti - quark annihilation and quark gluon compton scattering .
vertex in a hot and dense medium with temperature @xmath134 compared with the contribution from qcd annihilation and compton processes.,width=377 ] the photon differential rate from qcd annihilation and compton processes at finite temperature and chemical potential is parameterized as in ref.@xcite by @xmath135 where the dimensionless quality @xmath136 is fitted to be @xmath137 for @xmath138 and @xmath139 for @xmath140 .
one may immediately note from fig .
[ t=200 ] that the contribution from the new channels presented in this paper , the @xmath141 vertex , to the photon production is much smaller than the qcd annihilation and compton processes at low chemical potential . however , with increasing chemical potential at a fixed temperature , the photon production rate from the @xmath141 vertex tends to increase at a swifter rate than qcd annihilation and compton contribution .
this may be understood from the fact that the matrix element corresponding to the @xmath141 vertex in fig .
[ gg - gamma ] is proportional to the chemical potential as we see from eq .
[ amplitude ] .
this leads to the conclusion that in baryon - rich matter such as that produced in low energy collisions of heavy ions or in the core of neutron stars , where the chemical potential of the medium is very large , the new channel from @xmath141 vertex will assume significance in comparison to the leading order rates . in
the above estimates , the chemical potential and temperature are held fixed separately . in ref .
@xcite , it is shown that the photon production rate from qcd annihilation and compton processes have a strong dependence on increasing chemical potential @xmath8 of the medium if the energy density of the medium is fixed .
if the energy density were held constant , the temperature @xmath7 and @xmath8 are related to each other by the equation of state ( eos ) . in
what follows , an estimate of hard photon production from a medium with fixed energy density is presented and compared with the leading order rates .
the equation of state is derived from the phenomenological mit bag model @xcite , where the energy density is given as , @xmath142 in the above equation , the constants are given as : @xmath143 and the bag constant @xmath144 is fixed to be @xmath145 mev@xmath146 .
if @xmath7 is made dependent of @xmath8 is this way , then both rates will decrease strongly with increasing chemical potential because of the decreasing of the temperature @xmath7 of the medium .
such a drop is even more pronounced for the case of the leading order rates . at rhic ,
one expects a maximum energy density of about @xmath147 gev/@xmath3 , and the average energy density will be smaller than this value .
we pick a conservative estimate of @xmath148 gev/@xmath3 , which corresponding to @xmath149 mev at zero chemical potential .
the results of the leading order rate and that from the two gluon channel is presented in fig . [ epsilon=1.8 ] .
vertex in a hot and dense medium with energy density fixed , @xmath150 , compared with the contribution from qcd annihilation and compton processes.,width=377 ] in the plot , we raise the chemical potential @xmath8 from @xmath151 to @xmath152 .
as is clearly evident , the photon production rate from our new channel decreases with increasing chemical potential with fixed energy density , showing a similar dependence to the qcd annihilation and compton processes .
it would appear that with energy density fixed , the photon production from our new channel has a much stronger dependence on the temperature than on the chemical potential and has not exceeded the photon production rate from qcd annihilation and compton processes in the range of energies explored . it should be recalled that the above statement is true of only the hard photon production rate and may not hold in an extension to soft photons where cut - cut contributions will contribute .
this is left as the subject for a future effort .
a determination of the degrees of freedom prevalent in the early dense matter created in a heavy - ion collision remains an outstanding question in the study of excited strongly interacting matter .
while lattice susceptibilities allow for constraints on the flavor sector of the produced matter , phenomenological explorations remain the sole method to determine the structure of the gluon sector . as a contribution to this on - going effort
we have presented the hard photon signature of the gluon sector . while the gluonic sector may not itself consist of quasi - particle gluons , the production of hard photons through the gluon fusion channel outlined in this paper , similar to the production of large mass drell - yan pairs , will be sensitive to the gluon structure functions of such matter .
the matrix element for the conversion of a gluon pair into a photon is vanishing in the vacuum and is non - zero solely in the presence of a charge density in the medium .
the amplitude for the production of a photon from two gluons in a thermal environment at finite chemical potential was presented in sec .
this was incorporated into the photon self - energy in a thermalized plasma in sec .
expressions for the photon production rate from the fusion or decay of in - medium gluons in such a scenario were derived subsequently .
phenomenological estimates of the photon production rate from such equilibrium channels have tended to be suppressed compared to the leading order rates for realistic values of temperature and chemical potential .
such estimates however do not constrain the photon production rate from jet plasma interaction channels @xcite . neither
do they limit the rates of photons produced form such channels in non - equilibrium scenarios , such as in the early plasma where the gluon populations far exceed those of the quarks .
the results of sec .
iii , which have been cast in the form of a kinetic theory , may be easily extended away from the equilibrium scenarios where they have been derived and applied to the above mentioned situations . yet another application of such rates is to photon production in neutron stars where the chemical potential far exceeds the temperature and many of the conventional channels are pauli blocked .
estimates of the photon production rate from two gluons in such diverse scenarios will be presented in upcoming efforts .
this work is supported in part by the natural sciences and engineering research council of canada , and by the u.s .
department of energy under grant no .
de - fg02 - 05er41367 and under contract no .
de - ac03 - 76sf00098 . | a new channel of direct photon production from a quark gluon plasma ( qgp ) is explored .
this process appears at next - to - leading - order in the presence of a charge asymmetry in the heated matter and may be effectively described as the bremsstrahlung of a real photon from a thermal gluon .
the photon production from this new mechanism is calculated in the effective theory of qcd at high temperature .
the results show that the photon production rate may not as big as the annihilation and compton scattering at low baryon density , but could become important in baryon - rich matter . |
in 1998 , bender and boettcher showed that a wide class of non - hermitian hamiltonians @xmath2 can possess entirely real spectra as long as they respect parity - time ( @xmath0 ) symmetry @xcite .
while the implications of @xmath0 symmetry in theoretical physics are still a matter of debate @xcite , classical systems such as optical @xcite and electronic @xcite systems provide an accessible test bed where the @xmath0 symmetry notion can be explored .
@xmath0-symmetric hamiltonians show a sharp spectral transition when a control parameter is varied , with the appearance of pairs of complex conjugate energies in the broken @xmath0 phase .
the phase transition is associated with the appearance of exceptional points @xcite or spectral singularities @xcite .
similar transitions are found in pseudo - hermitian hamiltonians @xcite , pseudo-@xmath0-symmetric driven hamiltonians @xcite , wick - rotated @xmath0 symmetric hamiltonians @xcite , and in liouvillean operators in the lindblad form @xcite . in particular , in ref.@xcite it was shown that a combination of unitary and antiunitary symmetry of quantum liouvilleans associated to certain open quantum systems implies a dihedral symmetry of the complex liouvillean spectrum .
a different ( and not necessarily dihedral ) symmetry of the spectrum is found in hamiltonian systems after application of wick rotation @xcite , which consists in rotating the time axis by @xmath3 in complex plane , i.e. to the transformation @xmath4 .
in particular , wick rotation of @xmath0 symmetric hamiltonians generates the same spectral transition in complex plane , but rotated by @xmath3 .
complexification of time and corresponding rotation of the spectrum deeply changes the physical signatures of the symmetry breaking .
physical systems described by wick - rotated @xmath0-symmetric models are found in hydrodynamics @xcite and in certain gauge field theories @xcite .
a paradigmatic example is the squire model , which was introduced in hydrodynamics to describes the normal vorticity of a plane couette flow @xcite and to explain large transient growths of perturbations in spite of the linear stability of the underlying flow @xcite .
+ in this work we show that spectral phase transitions in wick - rotated @xmath0-symmetric hamiltonians behave like phase transitions in dissipative systems driven out of equilibrium , and that optics can provide an accessible test bed where such spectral phase transitions and their physical signatures can be explored .
we consider transverse laser dynamics in optical resonators with variable reflectivity mirrors @xcite and discuss , as examples , the optical realization of the hydrodynamic squire model @xcite and the wick - rotated nonlinear @xmath0-symmetric dimer model @xcite .
a dynamical system that realizes a wick - rotated @xmath0-symmetric model is described quite generally by the following equation for an order parameter @xmath5 @xmath6 where @xmath2 is the @xmath0-symmetric operator defined by @xmath7 in eq.(2 ) , @xmath8 is the @xmath0-symmetric complex potential , whereas @xmath9 is a constant real parameter that just provides a shift of the real part of the energies of @xmath2 . in eq.(1 ) , a cubic nonlinear term is added to limit the growth of unstable modes of @xmath2 . in optics , a possible realization of eq.(1 ) is provided by transverse laser dynamics in an optical resonator with variable reflectivity and aspherical mirrors .
let us consider the optical cavity shown in fig.1 with a one spatial transverse coordinate @xmath10 .
the resonator comprises two end mirrors in a nearly self - imaging configuration @xcite , one totally - reflective flat mirror ( mirror 2 ) and the other one a variable - reflectivity and aspherical mirror ( mirror 1 ) .
the reflectivity of mirror 1 is given by @xmath11 $ ] , where @xmath12 and @xmath13 are the transversely - varying power reflectance and phase shift introduced by the aspherical surface of the mirror .
the gain medium , placed close to mirror 1 , is assumed to have a fast polarization and population relaxation rates ( class - a laser @xcite ; e.g. he - ne , ar@xmath14 , kr@xmath14 or dye lasers ) .
a set of two focusing lens of focal length @xmath15 and a gaussian aperture , placed in the focal plane of the lenses , provide spectral filtering of the optical field at the plane @xmath16 in the cavity @xcite ; see fig.1
. indicating by @xmath17 the spectral transmission of the gaussian aperture of size @xmath18 and neglecting diffraction ( propagative ) effects in the gain medium , assuming single - longitudinal mode oscillation the evolution of the electric field envelope @xmath19 at plane @xmath16 in the cavity is governed by the following equation ( see appendix a for details ) $ ] , whereas mirror 2 is a flat and fully reflective mirror .
the right panel shows the case of a flat tilted mirror . ]
@xmath20 where @xmath21 is the photon round - trip time in the cavity , @xmath22 is the double - pass saturated gain in the active medium , @xmath23 is the spatial spectral filtering parameter , @xmath24 is the laser wavelength , and @xmath25 = -{\rm ln } \sqrt{r(x)}-i \delta ( x).\ ] ] for class - a lasers the saturated gain @xmath22 is simply given by @xcite @xmath26 , where @xmath9 is the small - signal ( unsaturated ) gain parameter that depends on the pump rate and @xmath27 is inversely proportional to the saturation intensity of the laser transition .
close to laser threshold , the lamb expansion holds , i.e. @xmath28 , which provides the simplest model of gain saturation @xcite . after the introduction of normalized space and time variables @xmath29 , @xmath30 with characteristic spatial length @xmath31 and after setting @xmath32
, the field evolution inside the optical resonator can be set in the canonical form eq.(1 ) , where the real and imaginary parts of the potential @xmath33 are determined by the spectral reflectance and aspherical surface shape of the mirror 1 according to eq.(4 ) .
@xmath0 symmetry of @xmath2 requires that @xmath34 and @xmath35 be even and odd functions of @xmath36 , respectively .
an experimentally simple and interesting case is that of a tilted mirror @xcite of variable reflectance @xmath37 ( right panel in fig.1 ) .
indicating by @xmath38 the tilting angle , one has @xmath39 and thus @xmath40 where @xmath41 . in the following
we will present two significant examples of spectral phase transitions of eq.(1 ) with an optical potential of the form of eq.(5 ) : the optical analogue of the hydrodynamic squire model @xcite and the wick - rotated @xmath0-symmetric nonlinear dimer model @xcite .
let us consider the case where the reflectance @xmath12 of mirror 1 is a top - hat function , i.e. @xmath42 for @xmath43 and @xmath44 at @xmath45 , where @xmath46 is the finite mirror aperture .
the real part of the potential ( 4 ) , @xmath47 , describes an infinite potential well , i.e. it vanishes for @xmath48 and becomes infinite at the boundaries @xmath49 , where @xmath50 . in this limit @xmath51 and eq.(1 ) should be integrated in the interval @xmath52 with the boundary conditions @xmath53 : this is precisely the squire equation that describes the normal vorticity of a plane couette flow with linear velocity profile @xcite .
a typical example of numerically - computed spectrum of the squire operator as a function of mirror tilting @xmath16 is shown in fig.2(a ) for @xmath54 .
note that a transition from an entirely real spectrum to pairs of complex conjugate energies occurs at the @xmath0 symmetry breaking point @xmath55 , where the two lowest real energies coalesce yielding a pair of complex conjugate energies [ see the insets in fig.2(a ) ] . for @xmath56 , all eigenvalues of @xmath2 are real and positive ; in particular , at @xmath57 the energies are those of an infinite potential well and are given by @xmath58 , where @xmath59 is the transverse mode index .
as the gain @xmath9 is increased , the most unstable mode that reaches threshold is the mode with index @xmath60 , which is depicted in fig.2(b ) , left panel . above threshold a steady - state single transverse mode operation
is observed owing to gain saturation ; see fig.2(c ) .
a similar scenario is observed for a non vanishing value of @xmath16 below @xmath61 ; see fig.2(d ) .
conversely , above the @xmath0 symmetry breaking point , @xmath62 , there is a couple of transverse modes , with the same gain threshold but different oscillation frequencies that can compete .
an example of the profiles of such modes is shown in the central and right panels of fig.2(b ) . a weakly nonlinear analysis of eq.(1 ) above threshold shows that both modes oscillate , because self - saturation prevails over cross - saturation of the gain .
the technical details are given in appendix b. correspondingly , as @xmath16 is increased above @xmath63 the laser ceases to emit a continuous - wave power , and an oscillatory behavior is observed as a result of mode beating and mode non - orthogonality ; see fig.2(e ) .
the transition from a stationary to an oscillatory laser emission is thus the clear signature of the @xmath0 symmetry breaking transition in the wick - rotated hamiltonian . to get an idea of physical parameters corresponding to the symmetry breaking transition ,
let us consider as an example an optical cavity for a he - ne laser ( @xmath64 nm ) and let us assume a gaussian aperture of size @xmath65 m , a focal length @xmath66 cm , and a total cavity length @xmath67 cm .
the characteristic spatial and temporal scales are @xmath68 m and @xmath69 ns , so that the transverse aperture of mirror 1 is @xmath70 m , the symmetry breaking transition , from a stationary to an oscillatory laser output power , occurs at the tilting angle @xmath71 mrad ; finally , the temporal period of power oscillations in fig.2(e ) is @xmath72 ns .
as a second example , we consider the wick - rotated nonlinear @xmath0-symmetric dimeric model , which is obtained by assuming in eq.(5 ) a double well shape for the real part of @xmath33 . without wick rotation this model was studied in refs.@xcite , where coexistence of periodic and blow up ( unbounded ) solutions was predicted in the broken @xmath0 phase .
an example of two - hamped mirror reflectance @xmath34 that yields a quartic double - well potential @xmath73 is shown in fig.3(a ) .
the energy spectrum of @xmath74 versus @xmath16 shows a behavior similar to the squire operator ; in particular above a threshold @xmath63 the spectrum ceases to be real , and pairs of real energies coalesce and become complex conjugates .
figure 3(b ) shows the coalescence of the two lowest energy levels , corresponding to a symmetry breaking threshold @xmath75 . above laser threshold ,
the onset of @xmath0 symmetry breaking corresponds to a transition from a stationary to an oscillatory laser emission arising from the coexistence of two non - orthogonal competing transverse modes ; see fig.3(c ) .
an elegant physical explanation of the phase transition in terms of adler s theory of coupled oscillators @xcite can be gained within a reduced two - mode model of the double well potential @xcite .
the field @xmath5 is approximated as @xmath76 , where @xmath77 are the ground - state wave functions localized in each of the two wells of the potential .
the evolution equations of amplitudes @xmath78 are simply obtained from those of refs.@xcite after wick rotation , i.e. @xmath79 where @xmath80 is the hopping rate between adjacent wells , @xmath81 , @xmath82 is the decay rate in the absence of gain and coupling , @xmath83 accounts for mirror tilting , and @xmath84 is the gain saturation parameter .
note that @xmath85 measures the energy separation of the two levels in fig.3(b ) at @xmath57 , @xmath82 is the mean values of such energies , and @xmath83 is proportional to the non - hermitian parameter @xmath16 ( mirror tilting ) .
the optical power@xmath86 emitted by the laser is proportional to @xmath87 .
the reduced model satisfactorily captures the spectral phase transition and the nonlinear dynamics above lasing threshold of the original hamiltonian ; see figs.3(b , c ) .
interestingly , eqs.(6 ) and ( 7 ) describe a canonical model of coupled oscillators near hopf bifurcations , introduced for chemical and biological dissipative systems @xcite and studied in details by aronson _
the wick - rotated @xmath0 symmetric dimer model basically describes two coupled laser oscillators @xcite : the two - humped variable reflectivity mirror induces laser emission in two transverse regions , where the gain is maximum .
mode coupling is provided by evanescent field overlapping , whereas mirror tilting controls the detuning of frequency emission of the two lasing regions .
the transition observed in fig.3(c ) above the symmetry breaking is ultimately associated with breaking of oscillator phase locking .
in fact , after setting @xmath88 and considering the symmetric solutions @xmath89 , the coupled equations for the amplitude @xmath90 and relative phase @xmath91 of oscillators read ( see appendix c ) @xmath92 the phase equation is the adler s equation @xcite that describes a transition from a phase - locked state @xmath93 for @xmath94 ( i.e. @xmath95 , corresponding to a stationary amplitude @xmath90 , to a phase drift state , associated with an oscillatory amplitude @xmath96 for @xmath97 .
the signature of the spectral phase transition is thus universal phase locking - unlocking transition in adler s theory of coupled oscillators .
@xmath0 symmetry has provided a fruitful concept in different areas of physics . in this work
the notion of @xmath0 symmetry has been extended by considering wick rotation @xcite .
in particular we have shown that light dynamics in optical cavities provides an accessible laboratory tool to explore @xmath0 phase transitions in wick - rotated space .
wick rotation is known to be a useful tool in quantum physics to connect quantum mechanics and statistical mechanics @xcite . here
we suggest that wick rotation can provide a fruitful link between the physics of @xmath0 symmetric models @xcite and pattern forming dissipative systems @xcite , thus broadening the class of physical systems where the notion of @xmath0 symmetry can be applied and experimentally explored .
in this appendix we derive the paraxial wave equation ( 3 ) given in the main text that describes transverse beam beam dynamics in the optical resonator of fig.1 . to this aim ,
let us assume that the laser oscillates on a single cavity axial mode and let us indicate by @xmath98 the electric field amplitude at the transverse plane @xmath16 and at the @xmath99-th round - trip in the cavity .
the propagation of the field envelope in each round - trip can be readily obtained by considering the lensguide of fig.a.4 , which is obtained by unfolding the optical resonator starting from the plane @xmath16 .
one can then write @xmath100 where the round - trip operator @xmath101 is given by @xmath102 in the previous equation , @xmath103 is the single - pass saturated gain in the active medium ( i.e. @xmath104 where @xmath105 is the population inversion and @xmath106 is the stimulated emission cross section of the laser transition ) , @xmath107 $ ] is the reflectivity of mirror 1 , and @xmath108 is the huygens integral propagator that describes field propagation from plane @xmath16 at @xmath109 to plane @xmath110 in the lensguide of fig.a.4 . in writing eq.(a.2 ) , we neglected diffractive effects in the propagation across the gain medium , which is justified provided that the characteristic diffraction length of the resonator mode at plane @xmath16 is much larger than @xmath111 .
the huygens integral propagator @xmath108 is given by @xcite @xmath112\ ] ] where @xmath113 is the paraxial generalized ray matrix from plane @xmath16 to plane @xmath110 .
it can be readily calculated as the ordered product of the abcd matrices of simple elements in the chain , and reads explicitly @xmath114 in eq.(a.4 ) we have set @xmath115 , where @xmath18 is the size of the gaussian aperture placed in the focal planes of the lenses .
note that the abcd matrix is basically equivalent to the ray matrix describing free - space propagation over a complex distance @xmath116 . with such in mind
, it can be readily shown that the integral operator @xmath108 can be cast in the following differential form @xmath117 where we have set @xmath118 the operator @xmath108 basically corresponds to a spectral filter , in fourier space , of the near - field at plane @xmath16 .
equation ( a.2 ) then yields @xmath119 \exp ( \mathcal{d } \partial^2_x).\ ] ] following ref.@xcite , we introduce a continuously evolving field amplitude @xmath19 , which depends on space @xmath10 and time @xmath120 , such that @xmath121 is exactly equal to @xmath98 .
the envelope @xmath19 evolves in time according to the equation @xmath122 where the operator @xmath123 can be obtained from the relation @xmath124 . using the baker - campbell - hausdorff formula , one has @xmath125+\mathcal{d } \frac{\partial^2}{\partial x^2}+\hat{e}\ ] ] where we have set @xmath126+\frac{1}{12 } \left ( \left [ \hat{p}_1 , \left [ \hat{p}_1 , \hat{p}_2 \right ] \right ] -\left [ \hat{p}_2 , \left [ \hat{p}_1 , \hat{p}_2 \right ] \right ] \right)+ ... \ ] ] and @xmath127 , @xmath128 . assuming that the spectral filtering and the aspherical , variable - reflectivity mirror introduces small changes of the field @xmath129 in each round trip , at leading order the operator @xmath130 in eq.(s-9 ) provides a small correction and can be neglected @xcite , thus obtaining eq.(3 ) given in the text .
in this appendix we briefly present a weakly nonlinear analysis to eq.(1 ) for the optical squire model close to laser threshold in the broken @xmath0 phase , where two transverse modes reach laser threshold simultaneously [ see fig.2(a ) for @xmath131 giving rise to mode competition . to this aim ,
let us assume @xmath132 and let us indicate by @xmath133 the unsaturated gain parameter at the laser threshold , which is defined by the real part of the lowest energy @xmath129 in fig.2(a ) .
close to laser threshold , we look for a solution to eq.(1 ) as a power series @xmath134 where @xmath135 is a small parameter that measures the distance from the laser threshold , i.e. @xmath136 to avoid the appearance of secular growing terms in the asymptotic expansion ( b.1 ) , multiple time scales are introduced , namely @xmath137 , @xmath138 , .... substitution of the ansatz ( b.1 ) into eq.(1 ) and using the derivative rule @xmath139 yields a hierarchy of equations for successive corrections to @xmath140 . at leading order
@xmath141 one obtains @xmath142 where @xmath143 is the operator @xmath144 defined by eq.(2 ) for @xmath145 , i.e. @xmath146 . the ( non - decaying ) solution to eq.(b.3 ) can be written as a superposition of the two marginally - stable resonator modes @xmath147 with amplitudes @xmath148 that depend on the slow time scale @xmath149 , i.e. @xmath150 where @xmath151 are the complex - conjugate eigenvalues of @xmath143 with eigenvectors @xmath152 , i.e. @xmath153 note that @xmath154 corresponds to the frequency spacing between the two marginally - stable transverse modes .
note also that , owing to the @xmath0 symmetry of @xmath143 , one has @xmath155 . at order @xmath156 one obtains @xmath157 where we have set @xmath158 substitution of eq.(b.4 ) into eq.(b.7 ) shows that the driving term @xmath159 entering in eq.(b.6 ) can be written as @xmath160 where @xmath161 u_1 \nonumber \\ b & \equiv & \left [ ( -\partial_{t_2}+1)a_2-|a_2|^2a_2 |u_2|^2 -2|a_1|^2
a_2 |u_1|^2 \right ] u_2 \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] and where the dots stand for other terms oscillating like @xmath162 . to avoid the appearance of secularly growing terms in the solution to eq.(b.6 ) , that would prevent the validity of the asymptotic expansion ( b.2 ) , the following solvability conditions should be satisfied @xmath163 where @xmath164 are the eigenvectors of the adjoint operator @xmath165 corresponding to the eigenvalues @xmath166 , and @xmath167 is the ordinary ( hermitian ) inner product .
taking into account that @xmath168 and @xmath169 , from the solvability conditions ( b.9 ) one readily obtain @xmath170 where we have set @xmath171 if we stop the asymptotic analysis at this order and introduce the amplitudes @xmath172 , @xmath173 , one has @xmath174 where the slowly - varying complex amplitudes @xmath175 satisfy the nonlinear coupled equations @xmath176 equations ( b.14,b.15 ) admit of the following limit cycle solutions : \(i ) @xmath177 , @xmath178 , with @xmath179 .
\(ii ) @xmath180 , @xmath181 , with @xmath179 .
\(iii ) @xmath182 , with @xmath183 ( g_0-g_{0 \ ; th}$ ] .
+ + in the above equations , @xmath184 and @xmath185 denote the real and imaginary parts of the self- ( @xmath38 ) and cross- ( @xmath110 ) saturation terms . solutions ( i ) , ( ii ) correspond to laser oscillation on a single transverse mode , either @xmath186 or @xmath187 ; this solution exists provided that @xmath188 and is it stable for @xmath189 , i.e. if cross - gain saturation prevails over self - gain saturation .
solution ( iii ) corresponds to simultaneous oscillation of the two transverse modes .
such a solution exists for @xmath190 and it is stable for @xmath191 . the computation of the self- and cross - saturation coefficients @xmath192 and @xmath193 can be done numerically using eq.(b.12 ) once the mode profile @xmath186 has been computed . for the case shown in fig.2 [ see the mode profiles in central and right panels of fig.2(b ) ] , one obtains @xmath194 ( namely @xmath195 ) .
this explains the result of fig.2(e ) , where at @xmath196 simultaneous oscillations of two transverse mode , leading to mode beating and oscillation of the output laser power , is observed .
note that power oscillation arises because the transverse modes are not orthogonal .
in fact , using eq.(b.13 ) the normalized output power @xmath86 is readily calculated as @xmath197 the oscillating term , provided by the last term on the right hand side of eq.(b.16 ) , does not vanish whenever the inner product @xmath198 , i.e. for a non - hermitian operator @xmath143 .
after setting @xmath199 $ ] , the nonlinear equations ( 6 ) and ( 7 ) of coupled oscillators given in the text take the form @xmath200 where @xmath201 is the relative phase of the two oscillators .
an extended analysis of eqs.(c.1-c.3 ) was presented by aranson _
_ in ref.@xcite in a more general framework .
here we just briefly review the main results of relevance for our analysis . since asymmetric solutions @xmath202 to eqs.(c.1-c.3 )
are unstable @xcite , we focus on the symmetric case @xmath89 , so that one has @xmath203 in this case case the equation ( c.5 ) for the relative phase @xmath204 of oscillators decouples from the amplitude equation ( c.4 ) and has the form of adler s equation , which is a gradient flow , i.e. @xmath205 with @xmath206 .
this means that @xmath207 , i.e. in the dynamics the functional @xmath208 can not grow . for @xmath94
, @xmath208 has relative minima and a stable global attractor of the dynamics is @xmath209 with @xmath210 ( apart from multiplies than @xmath211 ) .
conversely , for @xmath212 the function @xmath213 does not show minima , the two oscillators can not be synchronized and the relative phase @xmath214 drifts indefinitely in time .
once the solution @xmath214 to the adler equation has been determined , the amplitude equation ( c.4 ) can be solved yielding the following general solution @xmath215}{1 + 2 \rho r^2(0 ) \int_0^t d \xi \exp \ { 2\eta \xi + 2 \kappa \int_0^ xi dq \cos \phi(q ) \}}.\ ] ] after an initial transient , the asymptotic behavior of eq.(c.6 ) as @xmath216 can be readily calculated and reads @xmath217 in the phase locking regime ( @xmath94 ) the amplitude @xmath218 settles down to the stationary value @xmath219 , whereas in the phase drift regime ( @xmath212 ) @xmath218 is an oscillatory function .
the period @xmath220 of oscillation can be computed as the time interval needed to the phase @xmath214 to drift from @xmath221 to @xmath222 , i.e. @xmath223 r. el - ganainy , k. g. makris , d. n. christodoulides , and z. h. musslimani , opt . lett .
* 32 * ( 2007 ) 2632 ; k. g. makris , r. el - ganainy , d. n. christodoulides , and z. h. musslimani , phys .
* 100 * ( 2008 ) 103904 .
a. guo , g. j. salamo , d. duchesne , r. morandotti , m. volatier - ravat , v. aimez , g. a. siviloglou , and d. n. christodoulides , phys .
* 103 * ( 2009 ) 093902 ; c. e. rter , k.g.makris , r. el - ganainy , d.n .
christodoulides , m. segev , and d. kip , nat . phys .
* 6 * ( 2010 ) 192 l. feng , m. ayache , j. huang , y .- l . xu , m .- h .
lu , y .- f .
chen , y. fainman , and a. scherer , science * 333 * ( 2011 ) 729 ; l. feng , y .- l .
xu , w. s. fegadolli , m .- h .
lu , j. e. b. oliveira , v. r. almeida , y .- f .
chen , and a. scherer , nat .
* 12 * ( 2013 ) 108 b. peng , s. k. ozdemir , f. lei , f. monifi , m. gianfreda , g. l. long , s. fan , f. nori , c. m. bender , and l. yang , nat
* 10 * ( 2014 ) 394 ; m. brandstetter , m. liertzer , c. deutsch , p. klang , j. schberl , h. e. treci , g. strasser , k. unterrainer , and s. rotter , nat . comm . * 5 * ( 2004 ) 4034 ; l. feng , z.j .
wong , r. ma , y. wang , and x. zhang ( 2014 ) arxiv:1405.2863 j. schindler , z. lin , j.m .
lee , h. ramezani , f.m .
ellis , and t. kottos , j. phys .
a * 45 * ( 2012 ) 444029 ; z. lin , j. schindler , f.m .
ellis , and t. kottos , phys .
a * 85 * ( 2012 ) 050101(r ) ; h. ramezani , j. schindler , f.m .
ellis , u. gnther , and t. kottos , phys .
a * 85 * ( 2012 ) 062122 m.e .
peskin and d. schroeder , _ an introduction to quantum field theory _
( perseus books , 1995 ) ; a. altland and b. simons , _ condensed matter field theory _ , 2th - edition ( cambridge university press , cambridge , 2010 ) . transient growth and turbulence arising from the non - normal nature of the underlying operator were also predicted in other physical systems , such as in mode - locked lasers .
see : f.x .
krtner , d.m .
zumbuhl , and n. matuschek , phys .
* 82 * ( 1999 ) 4428 ; s. longhi and p. laporta , phys .
e * 61 * ( 2000 ) r989 ; g.h.c .
new , m. noy , j.a .
crosse , a. rumley , l. newson , z .- y .
chen , c. cheung , and a. todhunter , opt .
* 282 * ( 2009 ) 4418 a.a .
sukhorukov , z. xu , and y.s .
kivshar , phys .
a * 82 * ( 2010 ) 043818 ; p. g. kevrekidis , d. e. pelinovsky , and d. y. tyugin , j. phys .
a * 46 * ( 2013 ) 365201 ; i. v. barashenkov , g. s. jackson , and s. flach , phys . rev .
a * 88 * ( 2013 ) 053817 l.a .
lugiato , m. brambilla , and a. gatti , adv . at .
* 40 * ( 1998 ) 229 ; f.t .
arecchi , s. boccaletti , and p. ramazza , phys .
rep . * 318 * ( 1999 ) 1 ; k. staliunas and v.j .
sanchez - morcillo , _ transverse patterns in nonlinear optical resonators _ ( springer tracts in modern physics , springer , berlin , 2003 ) . | @xmath0-symmetric models with a wick rotation of time ( @xmath1 ) show spectral phase transitions that are similar to those of dissipative systems driven out of equilibrium .
optics can provide an accessible test bed to explore spectral phase transitions of wick - rotated @xmath0-symmetric models .
this is shown by considering the transverse dynamics of laser light in optical cavities with variable reflectivity and tilted mirrors .
two specific examples are discussed : the optical analogue of the hydrodynamic squire model of vorticity , and the wick - rotated @xmath0-symmetric nonlinear dimer model . in the latter case the spectral phase transition
is associated with the universal phase locking - unlocking transition in adler s theory of coupled oscillators .
pt symmetry breaking ; dynamic laser instabilities ; coupled oscillators |
we report on the development of the medium
resolution spectrophotometer to accompany ( in real time ) spectral observations performed with the high resolution spectrographs @xcite on the 6meter telescope bta of the special astrophysical observatory .
the spectrophotometer uses a 0.7meter optics of the bta guide telescope and have a separate system for object positioning .
the spectrophotometer is managed via the internet . in high resolution ( r )
spectral observations on the bta the size of the spectral region simultaneously recorded depends mainly on the format of ccd used . for example , the spectral region simultaneously recorded with the nasmyth echelle spectrograph ( nes ) is equal approximately to 1000 , 1500 , 3000 at the ccd format 1k@xmath01k , 2k@xmath02k , 2k@xmath04k .
spectral lines measured in these regions are used for modeling of stellar atmospheres by comparing of theoretical and observational parameters of lines .
adequacy of the model could be checked through comparison both theoretical and observational spectral energy distribution .
but for such a procedure a photospheric continuum must be registered in broader spectral region , i.e. we need low resolution spectrophotometric observations .
for example , spectrophotometric data for stars in pleiades were obtained within 3200@xmath17900 region with r=130 @xcite .
auxilliary spectrophotometric observations of nonstationary stars must be performed in the equal time with the high and low resolution spectroscopy .
howerever such a regime it is difficult to organize in practice .
bta was equipped with the auxilliary reflector having focus 12 m and diameter of the mirror 0.7 m ( fig.[fig1 ] ) , which has worked before middle 80th as a guide system @xcite .
we analysed the suitability of this reflector for spectrophotometric observations making simultaneous with high resolution spectroscopy with a main mirror of the bta .
the spectrophotometer has to provide the following properties .
first , registration time at the 0.7m telescope can not exceed time registration of high resolution spectrum at the bta .
this condition limits a value of spectral resolution of the spectrophotometer .
second , the optics of the 0.7m telescope has to be achromatic .
therefore we removed th two - lenses corrector , after that the effective focal distance of the new layout is equal to 7.8 m .
third , the spectrophotometer has to have an autonomous system to positioning of the star at the input , which has to being independent of the actions of the observer at the bta .
the layout developed is shown in fig.[fig2 ] .
the dekker s size was selected aiming to catch a star image distorted by atmospheric dispersion .
the diameter of the collimated beam is equal to 32 mm . as a cross
disperser the abbe prism is used which allows to place main elements of the spectrophotometer in the plane parallel to back plane of reflector mirror .
we used the echelle grating r2 with grooves density 75gr / mm and the objective f=120 mm .
as a local corrector a planeparallel detail ruled by bending in two perpendicular axes is used @xcite .
when a star image wholly get into the dekker , the spectrophotometer works as slitless and spectral resolution is determined mainly by accuracy of the star retention on the dekker .
therefore we use a second layout of guiding inside the spectrophotometer @xcite .
optical elements of this second layout of guiding are not shown in fig.[fig2 ] . | we report on the development of the medium
resolution spectrophotometer to accompany ( in real time ) spectral observations performed with the high resolution spectrographs on the 6-m telescope bta . |
to securing communications through the use of information theoretic notions was started by shannon in the 1940 s . in his papers he related fundamental notions , such as entropy , to the secrecy of cryptographic systems @xcite .
inspired by the work of shannon , wyner published a paper proving that it was theoretically possible to secure communications solely through the choice of an encoding scheme for a specific channel model @xcite .
wyner s security model capitalizes on the eavesdropper receiving a noisier copy of what the intended user receives . in general , for communications security
, assumptions on the capabilities of eavesdroppers are required to design systems . in wyner
s paper , the presumption is on the channel noise of the eavesdropper .
on the other hand , in contemporary cryptography it is assumed that the eavesdropper is subject to certain computational limitations .
it is accepted that many people have attempted to break a cryptosystem , and their best efforts to recover plaintext require an infeasible amount of time . in particular ,
the computational complexity of factoring products of primes is unknown , although it is widely accepted to be a hard problem .
thus the only guarantee of the security of these systems is that numerous people have attempted to attack the system and have not succeeded .
the question for physical layer security is what circumstances will allow similar conclusions about the eavesdropper s capabilities as in cryptography . in physical layer security , channel noise combined with a special encoder provide the security .
thus for wyner s method , how can one ensure that the eavesdropper s channel has specific noise characteristics , thus limiting his / her decoding capabilities ? the goal in this paper is to work with a well - studied channel model , and gradually relax restrictions on the eavesdropper s capabilities .
as these relaxations are made , the effect on the security of the system will be evaluated .
we will show that if the real channel characteristics deviate even slightly from the assumptions , all guarantees of security are lost . since in a practical system , no assumptions ( either on the intended user s or the eavesdropper s channel ) are verifiable , we can not claim @xmath0 security .
the intended users rarely have control over the eavesdropper s access ( especially in the wireless setting ) or the eavesdropper s behavior , so basing a security system on questionable assumptions is risky . on the other hand , wyner s basic idea
can be easily combined with cryptographic methods to achieve a secure system based on computationally intractable problems .
for example , we can artificially create a channel that is information - theoretically secure under the assumption that the shared key can not be recovered , i.e. , the recovery of the key is computationally intractable .
the paper is organized as follows . in section
ii , the channel model is presented .
the general results for wiretap coding and achieving secrecy are discussed in section iii .
section iv quantifies the amount of secrecy lost when the eavesdropper has better access than anticipated . in section
v , a shared key cryptosystem is presented from mihaljevic@xcite , that sets the path for a more general method of combining stochastic encoding with computationally intractable problems .
the notation for this paper is as follows .
random variables will be represented by uppercase letters ( @xmath1 ) , and their instances by lower case letters ( @xmath2 ) .
caligraphic uppercase letters will represent the domain of the corresponding random variable ( @xmath3 ) .
since we will consider a sequence of codes , @xmath4 , we will use a @xmath5 subscript to denote the corresponding parameters , i.e. , @xmath4 will have rate @xmath6 .
the communication model used for this paper is a broadcast channel with confidential messages ( bcc ) @xcite , and depicted in fig .
[ fmod ] . in general , the bcc model has confidential messages and public messages .
the bcc model is a generalization of the wyner wiretap model . in this paper
, there will only be confidential messages .
the model in this paper consists of a memoryless concatenated additive white gaussian noise ( awgn ) channel followed by a 2-level and l - level analog to digital ( a / d ) converters on the main and wiretap channels , respectively .
( stochastic encoder ) a * _ stochastic encoder _ * , @xmath7 , with rate @xmath8 , input @xmath9 , and output @xmath10 , is a channel with transition probability @xmath11 , that satisfies ; 1 .
@xmath12 2 .
if @xmath13 and @xmath14 , then @xmath15 the input to the stochastic encoder is a uniform random variable , @xmath16 , which is the source message , and has entropy @xmath17 the stochastic encoder , with rate @xmath8 , outputs @xmath18 . for our channel model , we let @xmath19 . in this model
there is a legitimate receiver and an eavesdropper .
the legitimate user receives @xmath20 .
when @xmath21 , the eavesdropper receives @xmath22 . to distinguish the case when @xmath23 , we will say that the eavesdropper receives @xmath24 .
there is independent awgn noise in both the main and wiretap channel .
we assume that the eavesdropper has a noise variance greater than that of the legitimate receiver . when just considering the input and output , the channels are both discrete memoryless channels ( dmc ) .
the legitimate channel users will construct a security system based on the assumption that the eavesdropper is restricted to a two - level a / d converter , and @xmath25 .
the goal in this paper is to quantify the effect of making an incorrect assumption about @xmath26 , and suggest an improvement through the use of a shared key based cryptosystem . in the case
@xmath21 , it follows that the main and eavesdropper channels can be individually modeled as binary symmetric channels , @xmath27 , and @xmath28 respectively .
the corresponding crossover probabilities are @xmath29 , and @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the cdf for the normal distribution .
since @xmath25 , it follows that @xmath32 .
this means that the capacity of the wiretap channel is lower than the capacity of the main channel .
( stochastically degraded channel ) the channel , @xmath33 , is said to be * _ stochastically degraded _ * with respect to the channel , @xmath34 , if there exists a channel , @xmath35 , such that for every @xmath36 @xmath37 first note , the concatenation of @xmath27 and @xmath38 channels is a @xmath28 channel , where @xmath39 .
thus with regards to conditional probabilities , the concatenated and split bscs are equivalent , see fig .
[ stocheq ] .
it follows that the wiretap channel is stochastically degraded with respect to the main channel @xcite .
this is important since the results in wyner s wiretap paper pertain strictly to concatenated channels , yet they are extendable to split channels under these conditions .
it is clear that we have a channel model where the eavesdropper is `` worse off '' than the intended receiver . now
the question is how the additional uncertainty in the eavesdropper s channel leads to secrecy . to quantify the ability to send confidential messages over a broadcast channel ,
we define first a measure of uncertainty that the eavesdropper has with regards to the original message .
( equivocation ) the * _ equivocation _ * of the eavesdropper is defined as @xmath40 in the event @xmath41 , i.e. , @xmath22 provides no information about the original source , the eavesdropper s only available method is to guess according to the distribution of the source message . in designing a code ,
the objective is to achieve security through maximizing the equivocation .
that is if @xmath42 , then the system is secure .
( wiretap code ) a * _ wiretap @xmath43 code _ * , @xmath44 , for a bcc consists of * message set , @xmath45 * stochastic encoder , @xmath46 * decoder , @xmath47 secrecy in these systems is introduced through the use of the stochastic encoder .
the encoder will map one message to different outputs such that when the eavesdropper has enough error , any attempt to decode will result in a random message .
assume that the main channel is noiseless , and the wiretap channel is a @xmath48 .
let @xmath49 .
define the stochastic encoder as follows , * @xmath50 or @xmath51 with equal probability * @xmath52 or @xmath53 with equal probability we can calculate the equivocation of this simple coding scheme , which results in @xmath54 \\ \approx & 0.954 \end{aligned}\ ] ] observe in the case we transmit the message without any encoding over the channel , the eavesdropper will have equivocation @xmath55 .
thus we have increased the equivocation of the eavesdropper using a wiretap @xmath56 code .
increasing equivocation through a random one - to - many mapping is the notion behind using a stochastic encoder for security . in the above example
, we presented a rate @xmath57 stochastic encoder that increased the eavesdropper s equivocation .
the question remains as to what are the limits with regards to possible rates , and equivocation .
first we define requirements for a rate - equivocation pair to be achievable .
( achievability ) a rate - equivocation pair , @xmath58 , is * achievable * if there exists a series of wiretap @xmath59 codes , @xmath60 such that 1 .
@xmath61 ( * rate * ) 2 .
@xmath62 ( * probability of error * ) 3 .
@xmath63 ( * equivocation * ) the second achievability condition assures that the legitimate user will be able to decode the confidential message .
the third achievability condition is called weak secrecy , and puts a lower bound on the wiretapper s equivocation .
now we have the framework to define the secrecy capacity .
( secrecy capacity ) the secrecy capacity of a bcc with no common message is @xmath64 thus @xmath65 is the maximum rate at which error free communication is possible over the main channel , with maximum equivocation over the wiretap channel .
furthermore the region of achievable rates is characterized by the following generalization of the wyner s results .
( region of achievability)(korner and csiszar @xcite ) given a bcc with no common message the region , @xmath66 is a closed convex set for which there exist random variables , @xmath67 and @xmath68 , such that @xmath69 and @xmath70 are markov chains .
furthermore , the conditional distribution of @xmath71 ( respectively @xmath72 ) given @xmath73 characterizes the main ( respectively wiretap ) channel and 1 .
@xmath74 2 .
@xmath75 $ ] 3 .
@xmath76 $ ] in particular , @xmath77\ ] ] since the wiretap channel is stochastically degraded with respect to the main channel , @xcite and @xcite give us that for our channel model , the following corollary holds .
[ acst ] ( achievability for stochastically degraded channels)(korner and csiszar @xcite ) if the wiretap channel is stochastically degraded with respect to the main channel , then the above region , @xmath78 , simplifies to those pairs @xmath79 such that 1
. @xmath80 $ ] 2 .
@xmath81 3 .
@xmath82 in particular , @xmath83\ ] ] where the maximization is over probability distributions , @xmath84 , on @xmath73 .
thus for our channel model , in the case @xmath21 , it follows , @xmath85 \\ & = \max_{p_x } [ h(y ) - h(y|x ) - h(z ) + h(z|x ) ] \\ & = \max_{p_x } [ \mathcal{h}(p_w)-\mathcal{h}(p ) + h(y)-h(z ) ] \\ & \leq \mathcal{h}(p_w)-\mathcal{h}(p ) \label{eq : bla}\end{aligned}\ ] ] observe eq .
( [ eq : bla ] ) follows because a bsc does not decrease entropy , i.e. , @xmath86 . furthermore note for @xmath73 uniform , @xmath87 ,
thus @xmath88 this means that if the legitimate users believe that the eavesdropper has a a / d(2 ) converter , they will also believe that they can securely transmit over the main channel at @xmath89 bit per channel use . thereby under this belief , the eavesdropper will not be able to do better than random guessing of the source message . from this point ,
since @xmath90 is achievable , we will construct a sequence of random linear codes as specified in @xcite .
let @xmath91 be a sequence of positive numbers @xmath92 , such that @xmath93 .
then for each @xmath94 , we can choose @xmath95 large enough such that there exists a wiretap code , @xmath4 , satisfying ; 1 .
@xmath96 2 .
@xmath97 3 .
@xmath98 note , each @xmath4 is specified by a binary @xmath99 matrix , @xmath100 , with the following parameters ; @xmath101 } \\
k_{m,1 } & = \floor{n_m [ 1-h(p_w ) -2\epsilon_m ] } \\ k_m & = k_{m,1}-k_{m,2 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] then to encode a source message , @xmath102 , we randomly choose a solution @xmath103 of the equation , @xmath104\ ] ] as the encoded message .
to decode , a typical set decoder is used . in practice , this is not a realistic decoding scheme , but will suffice in this paper to allow us to calculate effects on equivocation .
han vinck and chen @xcite have an elegant proof that this coding method will suffice and achieves @xmath90 .
the rate - equivocation pair @xmath90 is achievable , and we have an associated sequence of wiretap codes , @xmath105 . we will now relax the restriction on the a / d(l ) converter to analyze the effect on equivocation .
our goal will be to look at the effects of increasing @xmath26 on the equivocation .
the _ equivocation loss _ is defined as the difference between the believed equivocation , and the actual equivocation . in other words ,
the equivocation loss is the amount of information ( in bits per channel use ) that is leaked to the eavesdropper as a result of a false belief ( wrong assumption ) by the legitimate users .
in particular , we are interested in the asymptotic value of the equivocation loss , @xmath106 as @xmath107 , where @xmath108 is dependent on l. since we are unaware of the capabilities of the eavesdropper , our assumption will be that arbitrarily level a / d converters are available .
( equivocation loss ) + @xmath109 @xmath110 this proof uses the analysis of the bsc - bsc wiretap channel given by han vinck , and chen .
first note by @xcite , we have the following equalities , @xmath111 \nonumber \\ & + h(x^{n_m } | y^{n_m})- h(x^{n_m } | s^{k_m } , z^{n_m})\end{aligned}\ ] ] the same holds for @xmath112 , replacing @xmath113 as needed .
next we substitute both equations into the difference of equivocation , resulting in , @xmath114 } { k_m}\ ] ] @xmath115 } { k_m}\ ] ] since conditioning reduces entropy , and @xmath116 is a markov chain , it follows , @xmath117 from @xcite , we have , 1 .
@xmath118 2 . for any @xmath119
, we can choose @xmath95 large enough so @xmath120 3 .
@xmath121 is dependent on @xmath95 , and @xmath122 thus we can bound the magnitude of the difference of the conditional entropies and take the limit , @xmath123 } { k_m } \\
\leq & \lim_{m \rightarrow \infty } \frac{2(h(p_{ew})+ p_{ew}k_{m,2})}{k_m } \\ \leq & \lim_{m \rightarrow \infty } \frac{2(h(\lambda)+ \lambda k_{m,2})}{k_m } \\
\leq & \lim_{m \rightarrow \infty } \frac{2(h(\lambda)+ \lambda ( n_m[1-h(p)-2\epsilon_m]+1))}{n_m(h(p_w)-h(p)-\epsilon_m ) } \\ = & \lim_{m \rightarrow \infty } \left [ \frac{2h(\lambda)}{n_m(h(p_w ) -h(p ) -\epsilon_m ) } \right ] \nonumber \\ + & \lim_{m \rightarrow \infty } \left [ \frac{2\lambda(n_m[1-h(p)-2\epsilon_m]+1)}{n_m(h(p_w ) - h(p ) -\epsilon_m ) } \right ] \\ = & 0\end{aligned}\ ] ] the last equality follows since for the first term in the sum , the numerator goes to @xmath124 , and the denominator grows .
the second term has @xmath125 , while the remainder converges to a constant . to complete the proof since
, @xmath126 then , @xmath127 hence , @xmath128}{k_m}\\ & = \frac{h(p_w ) -1 + i(x;\hat{z})}{h(p_w)-h(p)}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the equivocation loss theorem allows us to calculate the loss in uncertainty of the eavesdropper due to using an a / d(l ) converter , when it is assumed by the legitimate users that the eavesdropper is using an a / d(2 ) converter .
( approximation lemma ) + for any @xmath129 , there exists a @xmath130 and a / d(l ) converter such that @xmath131 observe that this lemma follows from the general definition of mutual information @xcite pg .
specifically , let @xmath132 and @xmath133 be finite partitions of the range of @xmath73 and @xmath134 , respectively .
the quantization of @xmath73 and @xmath134 by @xmath132 and @xmath133 ( denoted @xmath135_{\mathcal{p}}$ ] and @xmath136_{\mathcal{q}}$ ] ) are discrete random variables defined by @xmath137_{\mathcal{p}}=i)&=pr(x \in p_i)=\int_{p_i } df(x ) \\
pr([w]_{\mathcal{q}}=i)&=pr(w \in q_i)=\int_{q_i } df(w)\end{aligned}\ ] ] then by definition , @xmath138_{\mathcal{p}};[w]_{\mathcal{q } } ) \\ & = \sup_{\mathcal{q } } i(x;[w]_{\mathcal{q}}).\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the second equality follows trivially since @xmath139 .
since @xmath140_{\mathcal{q}_l}$ ] is a markov chain , , any a / d(l ) converter with associated partition @xmath141 will have @xmath142_{\mathcal{q}_l } ) \leq i(x;w ) $ ] .
thus given @xmath143 , by definition of @xmath144 , there exists a finite partition of the range of @xmath134 , say @xmath133 , such that @xmath145_{\mathcal{q } } ) < \epsilon.\ ] ] observe that @xmath136_{\mathcal{q}}$ ] is just @xmath108 for a particular a / d(l ) converter where @xmath146 . in short
, discretizing @xmath147 corresponds to an adequately chosen a / d(l ) converter , which is precisely @xmath24 .
note @xmath24 and @xmath147 are referenced from fig .
2 , where we use the notation @xmath24 when @xmath23 .
the dependence on @xmath26 is implicit in @xmath24 .
observe by the approximation lemma , it will suffice to approximate the equivocation associated with the a / d(l ) by the equivocation given by direct access to the awgn channel .
it is simpler to calculate @xmath148 instead of @xmath149 . then using the approximation lemma
, we have , [ mel](max equivocation loss ) @xmath150 this follows by direct application of the approximation lemma to the equivocation loss theorem .
now we are left with calculating @xmath148 .
first we shall calculate the cdf of @xmath134 .
@xmath151\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore taking the derivative , @xmath152 then by the definition of mutual information , @xmath153 ) , width=288 ] we have calculated the mutual information , and can now use corollary [ mel ] to estimate the loss in equivocation .
looking at ( [ mele ] ) we see as the noise power in the wiretap channel grows , that the equivocation loss goes to zero , which is illustrated in fig .
3 . on the other hand ,
as the noise power in the wiretap channel gets smaller , secrecy is lost . in particular , if the @xmath154 , approximately @xmath155 bits of secrecy is lost per bit transmitted .
the equivocation is less than half of the value for the case of a two level a / d converter . in this particular instance , where the eavesdropper is allowed to use arbitrary precision analog to digital converters , it is difficult to guarantee a particular amount of secrecy .
the analysis presented here is for a simple model , and is present only to illustrate the difficulty in making assumptions about the physical limitations in channel access of an eavesdropper . in the analysis of more complicated scenarios , especially in the wireless domain , incorrect assumptions on
the eavesdropper will present similar security losses .
on the other hand , this does not constitute a proof that physical layer security using wyner s method is not possible .
in the previous section , we illustrated what happens if the intended users believe that the eavesdropper uses an a / d(2 ) converter , but in reality the eavesdropper uses an a / d(l ) converter .
while this is , in many regards , a toy example , it illustrates that a wrong assumption ( belief ) on the eavesdropper s channel leads to a compromised security system . in other words ,
a system is information - theoretically secure only if the assumptions ( made by the intended users ) of the eavesdropper s channel are correct .
however , in practice , the intended users do not control the eavesdropper s channel nor behavior .
hence the intended users can never verify their assumptions .
in a practical setting , apart from using a better a / d converter , the eavesdropper can ; 1 ) use multiple antennas , 2 ) decrease the distance to the transmitter , 3 ) use non - awgn channels , etc ... if the intended users make the wrong guess regarding any of these parameters , they will not achieve a secure system . thus making assumptions about the wiretapper s capabilities
is difficult .
one potential alternative is to combine some of the techniques of modern cryptography with wyner s secrecy coding techniques .
we will artificially create random channels , and then use the corresponding stochastic encoding to secure the message .
our assumption will be , as in contemporary cryptography , that recovering the preshared key used to create the channel is computationally intractable .
we remove the dependence on a true source of randomness . in particular , the stochastic encoder is dependent on a source of true randomness .
our solution will be to use general purpose pseudorandom number generators as input to the stochastic encoder and input to create artificial channels . by pseudorandom number generation , we follow the guideline of goldreich@xcite , + _ `` loosely speaking , general - purpose pseudorandom generators are efficient deterministic programs that expand short randomly selected seeds into longer pseudorandom bit sequences , where the latter are defined as computationally indistinguishable from truly random sequences by any efficient algorithm . '' _ our general solution strategy is to simulate the main and wiretap channels in the wyner wiretap channel model at the transmitter prior to transmission , see fig .
the resulting data is then transmitted over a physical channel with channel coding such that it is assumed the eavesdropper and intended users have perfect copies of the sent data .
when we simulate the wiretap channel , it is done in such a way that the intended receiver with knowledge of a preshared key can reverse the simulation .
in addition , at no point do we assume a true source of randomness .
the first step in designing our system , is to choose the preferred channel types for the main and wiretap channel , where the wiretap channel is stochastically degraded with respect to the main channel .
we choose an encoding scheme that will achieve information theoretic security based on the assumption that the real channel model was implemented . up to this point , we are exactly in the framework of wyner s paper .
this is where we take a separate path .
we use pseudorandom number generation as the source of randomness for the stochastic encoding , and to artificially create the main channel .
the pseudorandom noise generators are initialized with a randomly selected seed that only the sender knows . in order to emulate the wiretap channel
, we use a general purpose pseudorandom number generator that is seeded with a preshared key . for the wiretap channel
we require that given the preshared key , the intended receiver must be able to reverse the process of emulating the wiretap channel . in this model
the intended receiver is knowledgeable of the shared key for the wiretap noise , and can remove this noise exactly . the pseudorandom noise used to emulate the main channel , can not be removed , and the intended user decodes using the error correcting code . at this point
the intended user has recovered the source message . on the other hand , the eavesdropper is knowledgable of the complete design of the system , with the exception of the preshared key .
the eavesdropper s attacks will then be based on exploiting the weakness of the pseudorandom number generation to recover the secret key , and seeds .
we provide an example that follows the approach of mihaljevic @xcite in system design . in particular , we assume the following notation : @xmath156_{i=1}^l : \text{plaintext } \\
\bold{r}&=[r_i]_{i=1}^{m - l } : \text{bernoulli}(1/2 ) \text{i.i.d .
random variables } \\
\bold{u } & = [ u_i]_{i=1}^k : \text{public bernoulli}(1/2 ) \text{i.i.d .
random variables } \\
\bold{s } & = [ s_{i , j}]_{i=1 \ : j=1}^{k \:\quad n } : \text { binary } ( k \times n ) \text{secret key matrix } \\
\bold{v } & = [ v_i]_{i=1}^n : \text { unknown bernoulli}(p ) \text{i.i.d .
random variables } \\
\bold{m } & : \text{invertible mixing matrix } ( m \times m ) \\ f_e & : \text{stochastic encoder from } \ { 0,1 \}^m \rightarrow \{0,1\}^n \\
g & : \text{decoder } \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] then encryption and decryption are as follows .
the ciphertext , @xmath157 , is calculated as @xmath158 where @xmath159 denotes concatenation .
let @xmath160 , be the truncation function which returns the first @xmath161 bits of @xmath162 .
decryption of the ciphertext , is shown below , @xmath163 there are three main parts in the design of this system . in particular , we first use concatenation of a random vector and a mixing matrix to increase the entropy of the input to the encoding .
this helps protect against known plaintext attacks .
then we create a main channel that is a @xmath27 , and we employ a stochastic encoding to correct for the corresponding errors .
finally we use a secret key matrix , and public random vector to create a `` noisier '' channel for the eavesdropper .
the new system is in fig .
[ prng ] . from an information theoretic point of view , since the error correction will compensate for the added randomness , this system is not secure , as the eavesdroppers channel is deterministic . from here
we take the viewpoint of conventional cryptography , that solving for the secret key is computationally intractable . in particular , this is an instance of the learning parity with noise ( lpn ) problem , which is provably np - hard .
furthermore the lpn problem is a natural choice for stochastic encoding techniques .
this follows since solving for the secret key , @xmath164 , is equivalent to decoding a random linear block code @xcite .
thus we are combining a computationally hard problem with an information theoretic based security method .
we have now made a trade off on assumptions about the eavesdropper s channel , to one on the ability to solve a computationally hard problem .
the latter is widely accepted in conventional cryptography .
a motivation for this paper , was to create a lightweight cryptographic system based on concepts from physical layer security .
two potential issues that will increase the complexity of using this system are ; 1 ) the creation of satisfactory and cryptographically secure random variables , and 2 ) proper choice of coding parameters .
creation of cryptographically secure pseudo - random numbers is a difficult problem , and in this security system they are directly applied to plaintext .
this leaves an opening for attacks on the pseudo - random number generator ( prng ) .
furthermore a source of public randomness is assumed .
this leaves the system open to man in the middle attacks .
thus we must include measures to guarantee availability and authenticity of the public random vector .
in addition , we must choose adequate coding parameters for the length of the @xmath165 vector , and the stochastic encoder , @xmath7 .
a thorough analysis should be performed to find a characterization of the eavesdropper s channel with regards to wyner s wiretap model . in particular , assuming the randomness in @xmath166 is cryptographically secure , we say the main channel is a @xmath27 channel .
then we may find a @xmath167 as large as possible and base the construction of @xmath7 on the assumption that the eavesdropper s channel is a @xmath28 .
observe choosing @xmath168 large , increases the rate of our stochastic encoder , which reduces the security of our system .
thus we must find an upper limit for @xmath168 such that the resulting parameters for @xmath165 and @xmath7 ensure it is computationally infeasible for the eavesdropper to recover the secret key .
in this paper , one of the concerns in basing a security system on assumptions about the eavesdropping capabilities of an unintended user has been adressed .
an alternative has been presented which uses one of the main principles of wyner s paper , security through stochastic encoding .
it is a convenient solution , in the sense that it does not require any changes in infrastructure . in particular
, it can be added on at the application layer .
it is noted , that this is a toy example , and used to illustrate a point .
a valid counter argument to the solution proposed in this paper , is that there is still an assumption made on the eavesdropper s capabilities in using this method .
the onus has been transferred from relying on physically acquiring the signal to computational limitations . in regard to this argument , this paper than serves two purpose .
first , it shows that care must be taken in assumptions about the eavesdropper .
in addition , for a simple case it illustrates how to calculate the effect of incorrect assumptions , and engineer a system within certain secrecy tolerances .
the author would mainly like to thank prof .
aleksandar kavcic for his patience , and assistance in writing this technical paper
. m. j. mihaljevic .
an approach for light - weight encryption employing dedicated coding , _
globecom _ , ieee , pp .
874 - 880 , 2012 i. csiszar and j. korner .
broadcast channels with confidential messages .
_ information theory , ieee transactions on _ , 24(3):339348 , may 1978 . | this paper highlights security issues that can arise when incorrect assumptions are made on the capabilities of an eavesdropper . in particular , we analyze a channel model based on a split binary symmetric channel ( bsc ) .
corresponding security parameters are chosen based on this channel model , and assumptions on the eavesdroppers capabilities
. a gradual relaxation of the restrictions on the eavesdropper s capabilities will be made , and the resulting loss of security will be quantified .
an alternative will then be presented that is based on stochastic encoding and creating artificially noisy channels through the usage of private keys .
the artificial channel will be constructed through a deterministic process that will be computationally intractable to reverse . |
the axion @xcite was postulated approximately twenty years ago to explain why the strong interactions conserve the discrete symmetries p and cp in spite of the fact that the standard model of particle interactions as a whole violates those symmetries .
it is the quasi - nambu - goldstone boson associated with the spontaneous breaking of a @xmath9 symmetry which peccei and quinn postulated . at zero temperature the axion mass is given by : @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the magnitude of the vacuum expectation value that breaks @xmath9 and @xmath12 is a strictly positive integer that describes the color anomaly of @xmath9 .
axion models have @xmath12 degenerate vacua @xcite .
searches for the axion in high energy and nuclear physics experiments have only produced negative results . by combining the constraints from these experiments with those from astrophysics @xcite ,
one obtains the following bound : @xmath13 ev .
the axion owes its mass to non - perturbative qcd effects . in the very early universe , at temperatures
high compared to the qcd scale , these effects are suppressed @xcite and the axion mass is negligible .
the axion mass turns on when the temperature approaches the qcd scale and increases till it reaches the value given in eq.(1.1 ) which is valid below the qcd scale .
there is a critical time @xmath14 , defined by @xmath15 , when the axion mass effectively turns on @xcite .
the corresponding temperature @xmath16 gev .
the implications of the existence of an axion for the history of the early universe may be briefly described as follows . at a temperature of order @xmath11
, a phase transition occurs in which the @xmath9 symmetry becomes spontaneously broken .
this is called the pq phase transition . at that time
axion strings appear as topological defects .
one must distinguish two cases : 1 ) inflation occurs with reheat temperature higher than the pq transition temperature ( equivalently , for the purposes of this paper , inflation does not occur at all ) or 2 ) inflation occurs with reheat temperature less than the pq transition temperature . in case 2 ) the axion field gets homogenized by inflation and the axion strings are ` blown away ' . when the axion mass turns on at @xmath14 , the axion field starts to oscillate .
the amplitude of this oscillation is determined by how far from zero the axion field is when the axion mass turns on .
the axion field oscillations do not dissipate into other forms of energy and hence contribute to the cosmological energy density today @xcite .
such a contribution is called of vacuum realignment " .
note that the vacuum realignment contribution may be accidentally suppressed in case 2 ) because the axion field , which has been homogenized by inflation , may happen to lie close to zero . in case 1 ) the axion strings radiate axions @xcite from the time of the pq transition till @xmath14 when the axion mass turns on . at @xmath14
each string becomes the boundary of @xmath12 domain walls .
if @xmath0 , the network of walls bounded by strings is unstable @xcite and decays away .
all of the present paper except section vi is concerned with this process , how many axions are produced in the decay , what is the velocity dispersion of these axions and what are the implications . if @xmath7 there is a domain wall problem @xcite because axion domain walls end up dominating the energy density , resulting in a universe very different from the one observed today .
there is a way to avoid the domain wall problem by introducing an interaction which slightly lowers one of the @xmath12 vacua with respect to the others . in that case ,
the lowest vacuum takes over after some time and the domain walls disappear .
there is little room in parameter space for that to happen but it is a logical possibility .
section vi discusses this in detail . in case 1 ) there are three contributions to the axion cosmological energy density .
one contribution @xcite is from axions that were radiated by axion strings before @xmath14 ; let us call it the string decay contribution .
a second contribution is from axions that were produced in the decay of walls bounded by strings after @xmath14 @xcite ; call it the contribution from wall decay .
a third contribution is from vacuum realignment @xcite . to convince oneself that there is a vacuum realignment contribution distinct from the other two , consider a region of the universe which happens to be free of strings and domain walls .
in such a region the axion field is generally different from zero , even though no strings or walls are present .
after time @xmath14 , the axion field oscillates implying a contribution to the energy density which is neither from string decay nor wall decay
. since the axion field oscillations caused by vacuum realignment , string decay and wall decay are mutually incoherent , the three contributions to the energy density should simply be added to each other @xcite . that axions walls bounded by strings decay predominantly into barely relativistic axions was suggested in ref.@xcite , where the size of the wall contribution to the axion energy density was estimated to be of the same order of magnitude as that from string decay and from vacuum realignment .
this is consistent with what we find here .
d. lyth @xcite also discussed the wall decay contribution and emphasized the uncertainties affecting it .
m. nagasawa and m. kawasaki @xcite performed computer simulations of the decay of walls bounded by string and obtained @xmath17 for the average energy of the radiated axions .
our simulations , presented in section iv , are similar to those of nagasawa and kawasaki but they are done on larger lattices and for a wider variety of initial conditions .
we obtain @xmath18 for @xmath2 .
we attribute the difference between our result and that of nagasawa and kawasaki to the fact that we give angular momentum to the collapsing walls , whereas they did not .
it should be emphasized that the lattice sizes which are amenable to present day computers are at any rate small compared to what one would ideally wish .
indeed the axion string core has size of order @xmath19 where @xmath20 is a coupling constant ( see section [ wbs ] ) whereas the axion domain wall thickness is of order @xmath21 .
the lattice constant must be smaller than @xmath22 for the lattice to resolve the string core .
on the other hand the lattice size must be larger than @xmath21 to contain at least one wall .
hence the lattice size in units of the lattice constant must be of order @xmath23 or larger if the simulations are done in 2 dimensions ( see section [ sos ] ) .
present day computers allow lattice sizes of order @xmath24 , i.e. @xmath25 . in axion models of interest @xmath26 .
the computer simulations inform us about the situation of interest only insofar it may be assumed that the motion and decay of walls bounded by strings do not vary dramatically from the case where @xmath27 is large to the case where @xmath27 is huge . to address this issue
, we study the dependence of @xmath28 upon the @xmath29 and find that it increases approximately as the logarithm of that quantity over the range accessible to the simulations .
this behaviour is understood in terms of the process by which the walls bounded by string decay .
if it persists all the way up to @xmath30 , then @xmath28 is of order 60 in models of interest .
there has been disagreement in the literature about the size of the string contribution .
many authors @xcite believe it is about a factor 100 larger than the vacuum realignment contribution .
we ourselves @xcite have argued that the string and vacuum realignment contributions are of the same order of magnitude .
the two different estimates are presented in subsection iiib . with regard to the wall contribution
, we argue that it is again of the same order of magnitude as that from vacuum realignment , with however large uncertainties .
section iii presents a unified treatment of all contributions .
the resulting axion cosmological energy density is obtained in subsection iiid .
the requirement that it does not overclose the universe , implies @xmath31 ev . by combining this bound with the one from stellar evolution mentioned earlier ,
the axion mass is constrained to lie in the window : @xmath32ev @xmath33 ev .
we find that the velocity dispersion of the axions from wall decay is much larger , by a factor of @xmath6 or so , than the velocity dispersion of the axions from string decay and vacuum realignment .
this has interesting implications for the formation and evolution of axion mini - clusters @xcite as discussed in section v. we find that the axions from wall decay bind only very loosely to axion mini - clusters and that they get readily stripped off when the mini - cluster falls into a galactic halo .
this ensures the existence of an unclustered component of galactic axion dark matter .
the existence of such a component is important for searches of axion dark matter on earth @xcite because it guarantees that the signal is on at all times .
another interesting consequence of the larger velocity dispersion of the axions from wall decay is that it may conceivably be measured .
if a signal is found in the cavity detector of dark matter axions @xcite , the energy spectrum of these axions can be measured with great resolution .
it has been pointed out that there are peaks in the spectrum @xcite because late infall of cold dark matter onto our galaxy produces distinct flows , each one with a characteristic local velocity vector .
these peaks are broadened by the primordial velocity dispersion .
the minimum time required to measure the primordial velocity dispersion of axions from vacuum realignment and string decay is too long ( @xmath34 years ) to be practical , but the minimum time required to measure that of axions from wall decay is much less .
this is discussed in subsection iiie .
this paper is organized as follows . in section
ii , we present a toy model which captures all the physics we are interested in .
we discuss the evolution of axion strings in the early universe and the formation of walls bounded by strings at the onset of the qcd phase transition .
we give an estimate of the density of walls at that time . in section iii , we discuss the decay of walls bounded by string and the axion population that results therefrom .
we also discuss the axions from vacuum realignment and from string decay and estimate the total cosmological energy density from these mechanisms . in section iv , we present our numerical simulations of the motion and decay of walls bounded by strings . in section
v , we discuss the effect of axions from wall decay upon the formation and evolution of axion miniclusters . in section
vi , we discuss axion models in which @xmath7 and in which the axion domain wall problem is solved by slightly lowering one of the @xmath12 vacua with respect to the others . in section vii , we summarize our conclusions .
the bulk of this paper is concerned with the cosmological properties of @xmath0 axion models .
@xmath0 means that the axion model has a unique vacuum .
the following toy model incorporates the qualitative features of interest to us : @xmath35 where @xmath36 is a complex scalar field . when @xmath37 , this model has a @xmath38 global symmetry under which @xmath39 .
it is analogous to the @xmath9 symmetry of peccei and quinn .
it is spontaneously broken by the vacuum expectation value @xmath40 .
the associated nambu - goldstone boson is the axion . the last term in eq .
( [ vi1 ] ) represents the non - perturbative qcd effects that give the axion its mass @xmath41 .
we have @xmath42 for @xmath43 .
when @xmath37 , the model has global string solutions .
a straight global string along the @xmath44-axis is the static configuration : @xmath45 where @xmath46 are cylindrical coordinates and @xmath47 is a function which goes from zero at @xmath48 to one at @xmath49 over a distance scale of order @xmath50 . @xmath47
may be determined by solving the non - linear field equations derived from eq .
( [ vi1 ] ) .
the energy per unit length of the global string is @xmath51 where @xmath52 is a long - distance cutoff .
( 2.3 ) neglects the energy per unit length , of order @xmath53 , associated with the core of the string . for a network of strings with random directions , as would be present in the early universe , the infra - red cutoff @xmath52 is of order the distance between strings . when @xmath54 , the model has domain walls .
if @xmath43 we may set @xmath55 when restricting ourselves to low energy configurations .
the corresponding effective lagrangian is : @xmath56 .
\label{vi2}\ ] ] its equation of motion has the well - known sine - gordon soliton solution : @xmath57 where @xmath58 is the coordinate perpendicular to the wall and @xmath59 is any integer .
( [ 2.5 ] ) describes a domain wall which interpolates between neighboring vacua in the low energy effective theory ( [ vi2 ] ) . in the original theory ( [ vi1 ] ) ,
the domain wall interpolates between the unique vacuum back to that same vacuum going around the bottom of the mexican hat potential @xmath60 once .
the thickness of the wall is of order @xmath21 .
the wall energy per unit surface is @xmath61 in the toy model . in reality
the structure of axion domain walls is more complicated than in the toy model , mainly because not only the axion field but also the neutral pion field is spatially varying inside the wall @xcite .
when this is taken into account , the ( zero temperature ) wall energy / surface is found to be : @xmath62 with @xmath63 . for @xmath0 , @xmath64 and @xmath11 are the same .
however , written in terms of @xmath64 , eq . ( 2.6 ) is valid for @xmath65 also . when @xmath66 , each string becomes the boundary of a domain wall . indeed
the presence of the string forces @xmath67 to vary by @xmath68 when @xmath69 goes around the string once and a domain wall is the minimum energy path that does this .
1 shows a cross - section of a wall bounded by a string .
two different length scales are involved : the wall thickness @xmath21 and the string core size @xmath70 .
walls bounded by string are of course topologically unstable . in the early universe ,
the axion is essentially massless from the pq phase transition at temperature of order @xmath11 to the qcd phase transition at temperature of order @xmath71 gev . during that epoch ,
axion strings are present as topological defects . at first the strings
are stuck in the plasma and are stretched by the hubble expansion .
however with time the plasma becomes more dilute and below temperature @xcite @xmath72 the strings move freely and decay efficiently into axions . because this decay mechanism is very efficient
, there is approximately one string per horizon from temperature @xmath73 to temperature @xmath74 gev when the axion acquires mass .
the decay of axion strings into axions has been discussed extensively in the literature and is reviewed in subsection [ sd ] . at temperature @xmath75
each string becomes the boundary of a domain wall .
walls not bounded by string are also present .
we want to obtain statistical properties of this network of walls and strings under the assumption that the axion field is randomly oriented from one horizon to the next just before the axion mass turns on at time @xmath14 .
in particular : what are the average densities of walls and of strings ? are there walls of extent which are not cut up by any string ?
what is the energy fraction in walls not cut up by string ? to address such questions , a cross - section of a finite but statistically significant volume of the universe near time @xmath14
was simulated in the following manner @xcite .
hexagonal grid was constructed .
each hexagon represents a causally disconnected region .
the circle @xmath76 is divided into three equal parts as shown in fig .
@xmath77 is at the middle of part 1 .
@xmath78 is at the boundary between parts 2 and 3 .
each hexagon is then randomly assigned a number 1 , 2 or 3 .
a hexagon to which # 1 is assigned is thought of as a horizon volume in which the average value of @xmath79 is in part 1 of the circle , and so on .
thus there is a domain wall at each boundary between two hexagons one of which has been assigned # 2 and the other # 3 . likewise there is an downward - going string at each vertex surrounded by hexagons to which # 1 , # 2 and # 3 have been assigned in clockwise order , and a upward - going string at each vertex surrounded by hexagons to which # 1 , # 2 and # 3 have been assigned in counter - clockwise order .
2b shows some examples .
3 shows a larger realization with the underlying grid removed .
3 shows that there are no infinite domain walls which are not cut up by any string .
the reason for this is simple .
an extended domain wall has some probability to be cut up by string in each successive horizon it traverses .
the probability that no string is encountered after traveling a distance @xmath80 along the wall decreases exponentially with @xmath80 .
3 also shows that finite domain walls which are not cut up by string , and which therefore close onto themselves like a sphere or a donut , are very rare .
indeed , the figure shows only one closed circle and a circle need not be a section of a sphere ; it could be a section of a tube .
the average density of walls at time @xmath14 predicted by the random process described here is approximately 2/3 per horizon volume .
this is consistent with fig .
in this section , we discuss the various contributions to the cosmological energy density in the form of _ cold _ axions .
in addition to cold axions , there is a thermal axion population whose properties are derived by the usual application of statistical mechanics to the early , high temperature universe @xcite .
the contribution of thermal axions to the cosmological energy density is subdominant if @xmath13 ev .
we concern ourselves only with cold axions here .
we distinguish the following sources of cold axions : + 1 .
vacuum realignment + a. `` zero momentum '' mode + b. higher momentum modes + 2 .
axion string decay + 3 .
axion domain wall decay + the basis for distinguishing the contribution from vacuum realignment from the other two is that it is present for any quasi - nambu - goldstone field regardless of the topological structures associated with that field .
contributions 1a and lb are distinguished by whether the misalignment of the axion field from the cp conserving direction is in modes of wavelength larger ( 1a ) or shorter ( 1b ) than the horizon size @xmath14 at the moment the axion mass turns on .
contribution 2 is from the decay of axion strings before the qcd phase transition .
contribution 3 is from the decay of axion domain walls bounded by strings after the qcd phase transition . in the past literature on the axion cosmological energy density ,
contributions 1a and 2 have been discussed in detail whereas contributions 1b and 3 have received much less attention .
this section presents a systematic analysis of all contributions .
let us track the axion field from the pq phase transition , when @xmath9 gets spontaneously broken and the axion appears as a nambu - goldstone boson , to the qcd phase transition when the axion acquires mass .
for clarity of presentation we consider in this subsection a large region which happens to be free of axion strings .
although such a region is rare in practice it may exist in principle . in it ,
the contribution to the cosmological axion energy density from string and domain wall decay vanishes but that from vacuum realignment does not . in more typical regions where strings are present
, the contributions from string and domain wall decay should simply be added to that from vacuum realignment . in the radiation dominated era under consideration , the space - time metric is given by : @xmath81 where @xmath82 is the age of the universe , @xmath83 are co - moving coordinates and @xmath84 is the scale factor .
the axion field @xmath85 satisfies : @xmath86 where @xmath87 is the time - dependent axion mass .
we will see that the axion mass is unimportant as long as @xmath88 , a condition which is satisfied throughout except at the very end when @xmath82 approaches @xmath14 .
the solution of eq .
( [ 3.2 ] ) is a linear superposition of eigenmodes with definite co - moving wavevector @xmath89 : @xmath90 where the @xmath91 satisfy : @xmath92 eqs .
( [ 3.1 ] ) and ( [ 3.3 ] ) show that the wavelength @xmath93 of each mode is stretched by the hubble expansion .
there are two qualitatively different regimes in the evolution of each mode depending on whether its wavelength is outside @xmath94 or inside @xmath95 the horizon . for @xmath96 ,
only the first two terms in eq .
( [ 3.4 ] ) are important and the most general solution is : @xmath97 thus , for wavelengths larger than the horizon , each mode goes to a constant ; the axion field is so - called `` frozen by causality '' . for @xmath98 , the first three terms in eq .
( [ 3.4 ] ) are important .
let @xmath99 .
then @xmath100 where @xmath101 since @xmath102 , this regime is characterized by the adiabatic invariant @xmath103 , where @xmath104 is the oscillation amplitude of @xmath105 .
hence the most general solution is : @xmath106 the energy density and the number density behave respectively as @xmath107 and @xmath108 indicating that the number of axions in each mode is conserved .
this is as expected because the expansion of the universe is adiabatic for @xmath109 .
let us define @xmath110 to be the number density , in physical and frequency space , of axions with wavelength @xmath111 , for @xmath112 .
the axion number density in physical space is thus : @xmath113 whereas the axion energy density is : @xmath114 under the hubble expansion axion energies redshift according to @xmath115 , and volume elements expand according to @xmath116 , whereas the number of axions is conserved mode by mode .
hence : @xmath117 moreover , the size of @xmath118 for @xmath119 is determined in order of magnitude by the fact that the axion field typically varies by @xmath64 from one horizon to the next .
thus : @xmath120 from eqs .
( [ 3.10 ] ) and ( [ 3.11 ] ) , and @xmath121 , we have : @xmath122 eq .
( [ 3.12 ] ) holds until the moment the axion acquires mass during the qcd phase transition .
the critical time is when @xmath123 is of order @xmath124 .
let us define @xmath14 : @xmath125 @xmath126 was obtained @xcite from a calculation of the effects of qcd instantons at high temperature @xcite : @xmath127 when @xmath128 is near @xmath71 gev .
the relation between @xmath128 and @xmath82 follows as usual from @xmath129 where @xmath130 is the effective number of thermal degrees of freedom .
@xmath130 is changing near 1 gev temperature from a value near 60 , valid above the quark - hadron phase transition , to a value of order 30 below that transition . using @xmath131
, one has @xmath132 which implies : @xmath133 the corresponding temperature is : @xmath134 we will make the usual assumption @xcite that the changes in the axion mass are adiabatic [ i.e. @xmath135 after @xmath14 and that the axion to entropy ratio is constant from @xmath14 till the present .
various ways in which this assumption may be violated are discussed in the papers of ref .
we also assume that the axions do not convert to some other light axion - like particles as discussed in ref .
@xcite .
the above discussion neglects the non - linear terms associated with the self - couplings of the axion . in general , such non - linear terms may cause the higher momentum modes to become populated due to spinodal instabilities and parametric resonance .
however , in the case of the axion field , such effects are negligible @xcite .
we are now ready to discuss the vacuum realignment contributions to the cosmological axion energy density .
this contribution is due to the fact that , at time @xmath14 , the axion field averaged over distances less than @xmath14 has in each horizon volume a random value between @xmath136 and @xmath137 , whereas the cp conserving , and minimum energy density , value is @xmath138 . the average energy density in this zero momentum mode " at time @xmath14 is of order : @xmath139 the corresponding average axion number density is : @xmath140 since @xmath123 is assumed to change adiabatically after @xmath14 , the number of axions is conserved after that time . hence : @xmath141 the axions in this population are non - relativistic and contribute @xmath41 each to the energy . this contribution is due to the fact that the axion field has wiggles about its average value inside each horizon volume .
the axion number density and spectrum associated with these wiggles is given in eq .
( [ 3.12 ] ) . integrating over @xmath142
, we find : @xmath143 for the contribution from vacuum realignment associated with higher momentum modes .
the bulk of these axions are non - relativistic after time @xmath14 and hence each axion contributes @xmath41 to the energy .
note that @xmath144 and @xmath145 have the same order of magnitude .
the contribution from axions which were produced in the decay of axion strings has been discussed extensively in the literature .
we describe it here for the purpose of completeness and clarity .
there is still disagreement about the size of this contribution .
we will go rapidly over those points which are not controversial , but indicate explicitly those which are .
axion strings have energy per unit length : @xmath146 where @xmath52 is an infra - red cutoff .
this is the same formula as eq .
( [ 2.3 ] ) but with the integral written in wavevector space .
in the early universe , when the strings have random directions relative to one another , @xmath52 is of order the distance between neighboring strings .
the strings move relativistically and decay efficiently into axions . as a result
there is approximately one string per horizon at all times after the temperature has dropped below @xmath73 but before the qcd phase transition . by definition ,
a long string traverses the horizon . by intersecting each other with reconnection ,
the long strings produce closed string loops of size smaller than the horizon which decay efficiently into axions .
one long axion string per horizon implies the energy density : @xmath147 we are interested in the _ number _ density of axions produced in the decay of axion strings because , as we will soon see , these axions become non - relativistic soon after time @xmath14 and hence contribute each @xmath41 to the energy .
the equations governing the number density @xmath148 of axions produced in the decay of strings are : @xmath149 @xmath150 where @xmath151 is defined by : @xmath152 in eqs .
( [ 3.22]-[3.24 ] ) , @xmath153 is the rate at which energy density gets converted from strings into axions at time @xmath82 , whereas @xmath154 is the spectrum of axions thus emitted .
the term @xmath155 in eq .
( [ 3.22 ] ) takes account of the fact that the hubble expansion both stretches @xmath156 and dilutes @xmath157 long strings . to obtain @xmath158 from eqs .
( [ 3.21]-[3.22 ] ) , we must know what @xmath151 characterizes the spectrum @xmath159 of axions radiated by cosmic axion strings at time @xmath82 .
the axions that are radiated at time @xmath82 are emitted by strings which are bent over a distance scale of order @xmath82 and are relaxing to lower energy configurations .
the main source is closed loops of size @xmath82 .
two views have been put forth concerning the motion and the radiation spectrum of such loops .
one view @xcite is that such a loop oscillates many times , with period of order @xmath82 , before it has released its excess energy and that the spectrum of radiated axions is concentrated near @xmath160 .
let us call this scenario @xmath161 .
a second view @xcite is that the loop releases its excess energy very quickly and that the spectrum of radiated axions @xmath162 with a high energy cutoff of order @xmath11 and a low energy cutoff of order @xmath160 .
let us call this scenario @xmath163
. in scenario @xmath161 one has @xmath164 and hence , for @xmath165 : @xmath166 whereas in @xmath163 one has @xmath167 and hence : @xmath168 comparing eqs .
( [ 3.12 ] ) , ( [ 3.25 ] ) and ( [ 3.26 ] ) , one sees that in @xmath161 the contribution from string decay to the cosmological axion energy density dominates by a factor @xmath169 over the contribution from vacuum realignment , whereas in @xmath163 the two contributions are of the same order of magnitude .
we have carried out computer simulations @xcite of the motion and decay of axion strings with the purpose of deciding between the two possibilities . in scenario @xmath161 ,
the wavevector spectrum @xmath170 of the energy stored in the axion field changes from @xmath171 , characteristic of the string [ see eq .
( [ 3.20 ] ) ] , to a spectrum peaked near @xmath172 after the string loop has decayed into axions . in scenario @xmath163 ,
@xmath170 does not qualitatively change . to distinguish between the two possibilities , we defined the quantity : @xmath173 and computed it as a function of time while integrating the equations of motion which follow from lagrangian ( [ vi1 ] ) with @xmath174 . in scenario @xmath161 , @xmath175
as the spectrum softens , whereas in @xmath163 , @xmath175 remains approximately constant .
we found in our simulations that @xmath175 by about 20% during the decay of closed string loops . in the simulations , @xmath176 is in the range 4 to 6 .
if scenario @xmath161 were correct , @xmath175 should have increased by the factor @xmath177 to 5 ( depending upon the loop size @xmath52 ) during the decay of loops .
so our simulations support scenario @xmath163 .
note that @xmath175 is the quantity that directly measures the string contribution to the axion cosmological energy density .
an important caveat is that the simulations are done for values of @xmath176 much smaller than those , of order 60 , which characterize axion strings in the early universe .
we will assume henceforth that axion production by cosmic string decay is consistent with possibility @xmath163 .
hence : @xmath178 it is of the same order of magnitude as the contributions [ eqs .
( [ 3.18 ] ) and ( [ 3.19 ] ) ] from vacuum realignment . during the qcd phase transition , when the axion acquires mass
, the axion strings become the boundaries of axion domain walls . fig .
3 shows a cross - section of a piece of the universe at that time . in 3 dimensions ,
the domain walls bounded by string may be like pancakes or they may be long surfaces with holes .
which type of configuration dominates matters little to the arguments given below .
it does matter that the universe is relatively free of domain walls which are not bounded by strings , i.e. domain walls which close onto themselves like spheres , donuts and so on .
we concluded in section [ wbs ] that such domain walls are in fact very rare .
near @xmath71 gev temperature , the time - dependent axion mass is given approximately by eq .
( [ 3.16n ] ) .
the wall energy per unit surface is @xmath179 since the chiral symmetry breaking phase transition has presumably not taken place yet , we do not use the zero - temperature result eq .
( [ 2.6 ] ) .
as illustrated in fig . 1 ,
the string at the boundary of a wall is embedded into the wall .
hence its infra - red cutoff @xmath52 , in the sense of eqs .
( [ 2.3 ] ) and ( [ 3.20 ] ) , is of order @xmath21 and its energy per unit length is therefore @xmath180 the surface energy @xmath181 of a typical ( size @xmath182 ) piece of wall bounded by string is @xmath183 whereas the energy in the boundary is @xmath184 .
there is a critical time @xmath185 when the ratio @xmath186 is of order one .
using eqs .
( [ 3.16n ] ) and ( [ 3.14 ] ) , we ( crudely ) estimate : @xmath187 @xmath188 after @xmath185 the dynamics of the walls bounded by string is dominated by the energy in the walls whereas before @xmath185 it is dominated by the energy in the strings . a string attached to a wall
is pulled by the wall s tension . for a straight string and flat wall ,
the acceleration is : @xmath189 therefore , after @xmath185 , each string typically accelerates to relativistic speeds , in the direction of the wall to which is it attached , in less than a hubble time .
we argue below that the string will then unzip the wall , and that the energy stored in the wall gets released in the form of barely relativistic axions .
however , before doing so , let us describe the competing decay mechanisms which have been discussed .
one mechanism is emission of gravitational waves @xcite .
a piece of wall bounded by string of size @xmath190 , assuming for the moment that it is long lived and that its motion is not damped by friction against the surrounding plasma , oscillates with frequency @xmath191 and hence emits gravitational waves .
the power @xmath192 may be estimated using the quadrupole formula : @xmath193 indeed , emission of gravitational waves by walls bounded by string of size @xmath14 is dominated by the wall contribution , rather than the string contribution , after time @xmath185 .
( 3.39 ) implies the lifetime : @xmath194 independently of size .
note that a piece of wall bounded by string may self - intersect with reconnection producing two walls bounded by string which may again intersect with reconnection , and so on . this fragmentation does not affect the lifetime ( [ 3.33 ] )
although it shifts the spectrum of gravitational waves to higher frequencies .
another energy dissipation mechanism is drag caused by the reflection of particles in the primordial plasma .
the reflection coefficients between various particles and axion domain walls are discussed in ref .
it was found there that axions which are not highly relativistic have reflection coefficient of order one and that the dominant friction experienced by the oscillating walls is on the fluid of cold axions that were produced by vacuum realignment and string decay .
consider a bent wall of curvature radius of order @xmath14 .
the tension in the wall provides a driving force per unit surface of order @xmath195 whereas reflection of cold axions produces a damping force per unit surface of order @xmath196 where @xmath197 is the velocity of the wall . adding the contributions from vacuum realignment [ eqs .
( [ 3.17 ] ) and ( [ 3.19 ] ) ] and from string decay [ eq . ( [ 3.28 ] ) ] we have @xmath198 .
this neglects the contribution @xmath199 of axions produced in the decay of the walls themselves but we will see below that @xmath199 is of the same order of magnitude as @xmath200 and @xmath158 . comparing the driving force with the damping force ,
one concludes that @xmath197 is of order one immediately after @xmath14 and hence that the rate of energy dissipation by friction is @xmath201 which implies : @xmath202 thus energy dissipation by friction is important just after the domain walls appear but this mechanism soon turns off as the universe becomes dilute .
if emission of gravitational radiation and friction on the cold axion fluid were the only important dissipation mechanisms , the conclusion would be that a typical wall , whether or not bounded by string , loses a large fraction of its energy by friction immediately after @xmath14 and then lives till a time of order @xmath203 when it decays into gravitons .
however we find it far more likely that the walls bounded by string decay into axions , long before @xmath203 . if emission of gravitational waves were the dominant dissipation mechanism , a piece of wall bounded by string of size @xmath190 , assuming for the moment that it does not reduce its size by self - intersections with reconnection , would oscillate on the order of @xmath204 times before decaying away .
this seems an implausibly large number considering that nothing forbids the wall from decaying into axions instead .
it is especially implausible when one considers that at each oscillation a wall bounded by string may self - intersect with reconnection producing two smaller walls bounded by string . if the two pieces produced by an intersection with reconnection are typically of roughly equal size it takes only @xmath205 iterations of this process for the size of the pieces to go down from @xmath14 to the thickness @xmath21 of the walls .
pieces of size @xmath21 surely decay into axions because their dynamics is dominated by the energy of the strings and strings are known to decay into axions efficiently .
even if the two pieces produced by a self - intersection with reconnection are typically of very different size , it takes at most @xmath206 iterations for the pieces to go down in size to @xmath21 .
hence for emission of gravitational waves to be the dominant decay mechanism , the probability @xmath207 of self - intersection with reconnection per oscillation can not be larger than @xmath208 .
@xmath207 may reasonably be thought to be of order one .
it seems implausible that @xmath207 could be as small as @xmath209 . in section [ sos ]
we describe our computer simulations of the motion and decay of walls bounded by string . in the simulations the walls decay immediately , i.e. in a time of order their size divided by the speed of light .
the average energy of the radiated axions is @xmath210 in the simulations .
however , as was already mentioned in the introduction , the simulations are done for @xmath211 , whereas in axion models of interest @xmath212 .
one reason this may affect the results is the following . when massless the axion field is equivalent , by a duality transformation , to an anti - symmetric two index gauge field @xmath213 @xcite .
the axion string is a source for this field .
if the string accelerates with acceleration @xmath214 it emits radiation of frequency of order @xmath214 . since @xmath215 in axion models of interest
[ see eq .
( [ 3.31 ] ) ] , the emission of axion radiation is inhibited by the fact that @xmath214 is considerably less than @xmath41 , the lowest possible frequency for axion radiation . in the simulations @xmath216 . at any rate , for the reasons given earlier ,
it is most plausible that the walls bounded by string decay into barely relativistic axions long before @xmath217 .
let @xmath218 be the time when the decay effectively takes place and let @xmath219 be the average lorentz @xmath220 factor then of the axions produced . in section
ii , we estimated the density of walls at time @xmath14 to be of order @xmath221 per horizon volume
. hence we estimate that between @xmath14 and @xmath218 the average energy density in walls is @xmath222 we used eq .
( [ 2.6 ] ) and assumed that the energy in walls simply scales as @xmath123 .
after time @xmath218 , the number density of axions produced in the decay of walls bounded by strings is of order @xmath223 note that the dependence on @xmath218 drops out of our estimate of @xmath224 .
if we use the value @xmath225 observed in our computer simulations , we have @xmath226 in that case the contributions from vacuum realignment [ eq . ( [ 3.18 ] ) and eq . ( [ 3.19 ] ) ] and domain wall decay are of the same order of magnitude .
however , we will find in section iv that @xmath220 rises approximately linearly with ln@xmath227 over the range of ln@xmath227 investigated in our numerical simulations . if this behaviour is extrapolated all the way to ln@xmath228 , which is the value in axion models of interest , then @xmath229 . in that case
the contribution from wall decay is subdominant relative to that from vacuum realignment .
adding the three contributions , and assuming scenario b for the string contribution , we estimate the present cosmological energy density in cold axions to be : @xmath230 following @xcite , we may determine the ratio of scale factors @xmath231 by assuming the conservation of entropy from time @xmath14 till the present . the number of effective thermal degrees of freedom at time @xmath14 is approximately @xmath232 .
we do not include axions in this number because they are decoupled by then .
let @xmath233 be a time ( say @xmath234 mev ) after the pions and muons annihilated but before neutrinos decoupled .
the number of effective thermal degrees of freedom at time @xmath233 is @xmath235 with electrons , photons and three species of neutrinos contributing .
conservation of entropy implies @xmath236 .
the neutrinos decouple before @xmath237 annihilation .
therefore , as is well known , the present temperature @xmath238k of the cosmic microwave background is related to @xmath239 by : @xmath240 . putting everything together we have @xmath241 combining eqs .
( [ 3.14 ] ) , ( [ 3.38 ] ) and ( [ 3.39 ] ) , @xmath242 dividing by the critical density @xmath243 , we find : @xmath244 where @xmath245 is defined as usual by @xmath246km / s@xmath247mpc . on the basis of the discussion in section iiia - d we distinguish two kinds of cold axions : + i ) axions which were produced by vacuum realignment or string decay and which were not hit by moving domain walls .
they have typical momentum @xmath248 at time @xmath14 because they are associated with axion field configurations which are inhomogeneous on the horizon scale at that time .
their velocity dispersion is of order : @xmath249 let us call these axions population i. + ii ) axions which were produced in the decay of domain walls .
they have typical momentum @xmath250 at time @xmath218 when the walls effectively decay .
their velocity dispersion is of order : @xmath251 the factor @xmath252 parameterizes our ignorance of the wall decay process .
we expect @xmath253 to be of order one but with very large uncertainties .
fortunately there is a lower bound on @xmath253 which follows from the fact that the time @xmath218 when the walls effectively decay must be after @xmath185 when the energy density in walls starts to exceed the energy density in strings . using eq .
( [ 3.35n ] ) , we find : @xmath254 since our computer simulations suggest @xmath220 is in the range 7 to 60 , the axions of the second population ( pop .
ii ) have much larger velocity dispersion than the pop .
+ note that there are axions which were produced by vacuum realignment or string decay but were hit by relativistically moving walls at some time between @xmath14 and @xmath218 .
these axions are relativistic just after getting hit and therefore are part of pop .
ii rather than pop .
i. the fact that there are two populations of cold axions , with widely differing velocity dispersion , has interesting implications for the formation and evolution of axion miniclusters .
this is discussed in section [ am ] .
here we speculate that the primordial velocity dispersion of pop .
ii axions may some day be measured in a cavity - type axion dark matter detector @xcite .
if a signal is found in such a detector , the energy spectrum of dark matter axions will be measured with great resolution .
it has been pointed out that there are peaks in the spectrum @xcite because late infall produces distinct flows , each with a characteristic local velocity vector .
these peaks are broadened by the primordial velocity dispersion , given in eqs .
( [ 3.48 ] ) and ( [ 3.49 ] ) for pop .
i and pop .
ii axions respectively .
these equations give the velocity dispersion in intergalactic space .
when the axions fall onto the galaxy their density increases by a factor of order @xmath6 and hence , by liouville s theorem , their velocity dispersion increases by a factor of order 10 .
[ note that this increase is not isotropic in velocity space .
typically the velocity dispersion is reduced in the direction longitudinal to the flow in the rest frame of the galaxy whereas it is increased in the two transverse directions . ]
the energy dispersion measured on earth is @xmath255 where @xmath256 is the flow velocity in the rest frame of the earth .
hence we find @xmath257 for pop .
i axions and @xmath258 for pop .
the minimum time required to measure @xmath259 is @xmath260 .
this assumes ideal measurements and also that all sources of jitter in the signal not due to primordial velocity dispersion can be understood .
there is little hope of measuring the primordial velocity dispersion of pop .
i axions since @xmath261 .
however @xmath262day @xmath263 , and hence it is conceivable that the primordial velocity dispersion of pop .
ii axions will be measured .
we have carried out an extensive program of 2d numerical simulations of domain walls bounded by strings .
the lagrangian ( 2.1 ) in finite difference form is @xmath264 - \sum_{j=1}^2\frac{1}{2 } \left [ \left(\phi_1(\vec{n}+\hat{j},t)-\phi_1(\vec{n},t)\right)^2 \right.\right . \nonumber\\ & & \left.+ \left(\phi_2(\vec{n}+\hat{j},t)-\phi_2(\vec{n},t)\right)^2 \right ] -\frac{1}{4 } \lambda \left[\left(\phi_1(\vec{n},t)\right)^2 + \left(\phi_2(\vec{n},t)\right)^2 -1\right]^2 \nonumber\\ & & \left .
\hspace{-5 mm } \phantom{\frac{1}{2 } } + \eta \left(\phi_1(\vec{n},t)-1\right ) \right\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath265 labels the sites . in these units , @xmath266 ,
the wall thickness is @xmath267 and the core size is @xmath268 .
the lattice constant is the unit of length . in the continuum limit ,
the dynamics depends upon a single critical parameter , namely @xmath269 .
large two - dimensional grids @xmath270 were initialized with a straight or curved domain wall , at rest or with angular momentum .
the initial domain wall was obtained by overrelaxation , starting with the sine - gordon ansatz @xmath271 inside a strip of length the distance @xmath272 between the string and anti - string , and the true vacuum @xmath273 outside . the string and anti - string cores were approximated by @xmath274 , where @xmath275 and @xmath276 are polar coordinates about the core center , and held fixed during relaxation .
stable domain walls were obtained for @xmath277 . a first - order in time and second - order in space algorithm
was used for the dynamical evolution , with time step @xmath278 .
the boundary conditions were periodic throughout and the total energy was conserved to better than 1% .
if the angular momentum was nonzero , the initial @xmath279 was obtained as the difference of two relaxed wall configurations a small time step apart , divided by that time step .
the evolution of the domain wall was studied for various values of @xmath280 , the initial wall length @xmath272 and the initial velocity @xmath281 of the strings in the direction transverse to the wall , the string and anti - string going in opposite directions .
the strings attached to the wall are rapidly accelerated by the wall tension , the potential and gradient energies of the wall being converted into kinetic energy of the strings . fig .
4 shows the longitudinal velocity of the core as a function of time for the case @xmath282 and @xmath283 .
an important feature is the lorentz contraction of the core . for reduced core sizes @xmath284 , where @xmath285 is the lorentz factor associated with the speed of the string core , there is ` scraping ' of the core on the lattice accompanied by emission of spurious high frequency radiation .
this artificial friction eventually balances the wall tension and leads to a terminal velocity . in our simulations we always ensured being in the continuum limit . for a domain wall without rotation ( @xmath283 ) ,
the string cores meet head - on and go through each other .
several oscillations of decreasing magnitude generally occur before annihilation . for @xmath286
the string and anti - string coalesce and annihilate one another . for @xmath287 , the strings go through each other and regenerate a new wall of reduced length .
the relative oscillation amplitude decreases with decreasing collision velocity .
5 shows the core position as a function of time for the case @xmath288 .
6a shows the gradient , kinetic , string potential , wall potential and total energies as a function of time . by ` string ( wall ) potential ' energy , we mean the energy associated with the third ( fourth ) term in eq .
the total energy is accurately conserved in spite of the violent goings - on when the string and anti - string meet .
we also investigated the more generic case of a domain wall with angular momentum .
the strings are similarly accelerated by the wall but string and anti - string cores rotate around each other .
6b shows the gradient , kinetic , string potential , wall potential and total energies as a function of time for the case @xmath289 , and @xmath290 .
the field is displayed in fig . 7 at various time steps for the case @xmath291 and @xmath292 .
no oscillation is observed .
all energy is converted into axion radiation during a single collapse .
oscillations occur only when the angular momentum is too small for the string and anti - string cores to miss each other .
we performed spectrum analysis of the energy stored in the @xmath293 field as a function of time using standard fourier techniques .
the two - dimensional fourier transform is defined by @xmath294 f(\vec{n})\ ] ] for @xmath295 where @xmath296 .
the dispersion law is : @xmath297 fig .
8 shows the power spectrum @xmath298 of the @xmath293 field at various times during the decay of a rotating domain wall for the case @xmath299 , and @xmath290 .
initially , the spectrum is dominated by small wavevectors , @xmath300 .
such a spectrum is characteristic of the domain wall .
as the wall accelerates the string , the spectrum hardens until it becomes roughly @xmath301 with a long wavelength cutoff of order the wall thickness @xmath302 and a short wavelength cutoff of order the reduced core size @xmath303 . such a spectrum is characteristic of the moving string . in the case of the figure ,
the string and anti - string cores annihilate at about the time of the fourth frame ( fig .
the spectrum remains approximately @xmath301 during the annihilation process and thereafter . as discussed in section iiic , @xmath304 ,
the average energy of the radiated axions in units of the axion mass , is the quantity which determines the wall decay contribution to the axion cosmological energy density [ see eq .
( 3.43 ) ] .
9 shows the time evolution of @xmath305 for @xmath306 and various values of @xmath20 . by definition , @xmath307 where @xmath308 is the gradient and kinetic energy stored in mode @xmath309 of the field @xmath293 . after the domain wall has decayed into axions , @xmath310 . fig .
10 shows the time evolution of @xmath305 for @xmath311 and various values of @xmath281 . for small @xmath281 and/or small @xmath20 ,
i.e when the angular momentum is low and the core size is big , the string cores meet head on and the strings have one or more oscillations . in that case , @xmath312 .
this is consistent with the value , @xmath313 , found by nagasawa and kawasaki @xcite .
the low angular momentum regime , when the strings oscillate , is characterized by low energy of the radiated axions .
we believe this regime to be less relevant to wall decay in the early universe because it seem unlikely that the angular momentum of a wall at the qcd epoch could be small enough for the strings to oscillate then , especially when one considers that the actual wall configurations are 3 dimensional rather than 2d . in the more generic case when no oscillations occur , @xmath314 .
moreover , we find that @xmath315 depends upon the critical parameter @xmath280 , increasing approximately as the logarithm of that quantity ; see fig .
this is consistent with the time evolution of the energy spectrum , described in fig .
8 . for a domain wall , @xmath316
whereas for a moving string @xmath317 .
since we find the decay to proceed in two steps : 1 ) the wall energy is converted into string kinetic energy , and 2 ) the strings annihilate without qualitative change in the spectrum , the average energy of radiated axions is @xmath318 . assuming this is a correct description of the decay process for @xmath319 , then @xmath320 in axion models of interest .
present technology is inadequate for 3d simulations with sufficient resolution for the purposes we are interested in , such as obtaining reliable estimates of the factor @xmath220 .
however , lower resolution 3d and 2d simulations of string - wall networks were carried out in ref .
they showed qualitatively similar behaviour in 2 and 3 dimensions .
we saw in section iii that the axion fluid is inhomogeneous with @xmath321 at the time of the qcd phase transition .
as will be discussed below , the streaming length of the pop .
i axions ( those from vacuum realignment and string decay ) is too short for all these inhomogeneities to get erased by free streaming before the time @xmath322 of equality between matter and radiation .
@xmath322 is when density perturbations start to grow by gravitational instability . at time @xmath322 , the @xmath321 inhomogeneities in the axion fluid promptly form gravitationally bound objects , called axion miniclusters @xcite .
of course , axion miniclusters occur only if there is no inflation or if inflation occurs with reheat temperature above the phase transition where @xmath9 is spontaneously broken .
axion miniclusters were discussed in the seminal papers of hogan and rees @xcite , and of kolb and tkachev @xcite . however , in these pioneering studies the role of domain walls , and hence of axions from domain wall decay , was neglected .
also the estimates of the minicluster mass have varied considerably from one another
. hence we think it appropriate to give our own analysis of this interesting phenomenon .
as described in section iii , there are two populations of cold axions , pop .
i and pop .
ii , with velocity dispersions given by eqs.([3.48 ] ) and ( [ 3.49 ] ) respectively .
both populations are inhomogeneous with @xmath321 at the time of the qcd phase transition .
the free streaming length from time @xmath14 to @xmath322 is : @xmath323 for the sake of definiteness , we assume henceforth @xmath324 and @xmath325 km / s.mpc , in which case @xmath326 ev .
the free streaming length should be compared with the size @xmath327 of axion inhomogeneities at time @xmath322 . using eq.([3.48 ] )
we find for pop .
i : @xmath328 hence , in the axion mass range of interest , pop .
i axions do not homogenize . at @xmath322 many pop .
i axions condense into miniclusters since they have @xmath329 upon arrival .
the typical size of axion miniclusters is @xmath330 and their typical mass is : @xmath331 we assumed that half the cold axions are pop .
i and that half of those form miniclusters , hence the factor @xmath332 .
we used eq .
( 3.48 ) to estimate @xmath333 . using eq .
( [ 3.49 ] ) , we find for pop .
ii : @xmath334 using eq .
( 3.51 ) and the range @xmath335 7 to 60 , suggested by our numerical simulations , we conclude that pop . ii axions do homogenize and hence that the axion energy density has a smooth component at @xmath322 . at time t , pop . ii axions get gravitationally bound to the nearest minicluster if it is less than distance @xmath336 away . since most are at a distance @xmath337 , the bulk of pop .
ii axions become gravitationally bound to miniclusters when the temperature has dropped to : @xmath338 assuming @xmath339 .
thus we arrive at a qualitative picture of miniclusters before galaxy formation as having an inner core of pop .
i axions and a fluffy outer envelope of pop .
ii axions .
the inner core has size @xmath330 and density @xmath340 if @xmath341 ( i.e. @xmath342 ) , the outer envelope has roughly the same mass as the core but size @xmath343 and density @xmath344 if @xmath345 , then the envelope is correspondingly less massive and less dense .
when a minicluster falls onto a galaxy , tidal forces of the galaxy are apt to destroy it .
we find below that the outer envelopes almost surely get pulled off whereas the inner cores barely survive .
when a minicluster passes by an object of mass @xmath346 with impact parameter @xmath347 and velocity @xmath281 , the internal energy per unit mass @xmath259 given to the minicluster by the tidal gravitational forces from that object is of order @xcite @xmath348 whereas the binding energy per unit mass of the minicluster @xmath349 .
if the minicluster travels a length @xmath350 through a region where objects of mass @xmath346 have density @xmath59 , the relative increase in internal energy is : @xmath351 where @xmath352 .
( [ 6.10 ] ) follows from the fact that @xmath259 is dominated by the closest encounter and the latter has impact parameter @xmath353 : @xmath354 . note that @xmath355 is independent of @xmath346 .
the effect upon a minicluster of falling with velocity @xmath356 through the inner halo @xmath357kpc@xmath358 of our galaxy where @xmath359gr@xmath360 is : @xmath361 since we expect @xmath253 to be of order one , it seems very likely that the envelope gets pulled off after one or more crossings of the inner parts of the galaxy .
this result is reassuring for direct searches of dark matter axions on earth since it implies that a smooth component of dark matter axions with density of order @xmath362 permeates us whether or not there is inflation after the peccei - quinn phase transition .
if there were no pop .
ii axions one might fear that nearly all axions are in axion miniclusters .
this result can also be obtained by considering the tidal radius of a mini - cluster at our location in the galaxy : @xmath363 where @xmath364 kpc is our distance from the galactic center and @xmath365 is the mass of the galaxy interior to us .
@xmath366 is larger than the inner core size @xmath330 but smaller than the outer envelope @xmath367 .
a minicluster inner core which has spent most of its life in the central part of our galaxy only barely survived since @xmath368 in that case .
if most minicluster inner cores have survived more or less intact , the direct encounter of a minicluster with earth would still be quite rare , happening only every @xmath369 years or so .
the encounter would last for about 3 days during which the local axion density would increase by a factor of order @xmath370 .
in this section we consider axion models in which the number @xmath12 of degenerate vacua at the bottom of the mexican hat potential is larger than one .
@xmath12 is an integer given by @xmath371 here @xmath372 is the peccei - quinn charge , @xmath373 are the color charges and tr represents a sum over all the left - handed weyl spinors in the model .
it is easy to construct models for an arbitrary value of @xmath12 .
there are @xmath12 distinct degenerate equally spaced vacua at the bottom of the mexican hat potential @xcite .
the vacua are related by an exact spontaneously broken @xmath374 symmetry .
a domain wall is a transition in space from any one vacuum to a distinct neighboring vacuum .
a string is the boundary of @xmath12 walls . if @xmath7 and there is no inflation after the peccei - quinn phase transition , axion models suffer from a domain wall problem because the energy density in walls ends up exceeding the energy density in matter and radiation .
a domain wall dominated universe is very much unlike our own .
the walls are gravitationally repulsive @xcite .
the universe is divided into rapidly expanding bubbles with walls at the boundaries and islands of matter in the middles . when averaged on scales larger than the bubble size
, the universe expands as @xmath375 @xcite . at least in the case of axion walls ,
the islands are far too small for one island to be identified with our visible universe .
the axion domain wall problem can be solved 1 ) by having inflation with reheating temperature less than the pq phase transition temperature , or 2 ) by having @xmath0 as discussed in the other sections of this paper , or 3 ) by having a small explicit breaking of the @xmath374 symmetry @xcite .
the third solution is discussed in this section .
the symmetry breaking must lift completely the degeneracy of the vacuum and be large enough that the unique true vacuum takes over before the walls dominate the energy density . on the other hand
, it must be small enough that the pq mechanism still works .
the implications of biased discrete symmetry breaking have been discussed in a general manner in ref .
@xcite .
we may , for our purposes , take the effective action density for the axion field to be : @xmath376\ .
\label{5.1}\ ] ] the axion field @xmath85 is cyclic with period @xmath377 . thus eq .
( [ 5.1 ] ) implies @xmath12 degenerate vacua .
the axion decay constant is @xmath378 .
the domain wall is a transition in space from a vacuum , say @xmath379 , to a neighbor vacuum , say @xmath380 .
the energy per unit surface is @xmath381 .
the actual axion domain wall is only crudely described by eq .
( [ 5.1 ] ) because it involves not only a rotation of the axion field but also of the quark - antiquark condensates .
however eq . ( 6.2 ) is adequate for the order of magnitude estimates we are interested in here . between the pq and qcd phase transitions , axion strings are present and evolve as in the @xmath0 case . at time @xmath14
each string becomes the boundary of @xmath12 walls . for a brief period
the walls lose energy by friction against the primordial plasma but this dissipation process is soon turned off as the plasma becomes dilute .
causality implies that there is at least one domain wall per horizon on average since each horizon volume picks a vacuum independently from its neighbor . if there is of order one wall per horizon , the energy density in walls @xmath382 . in that case , the energy in walls per co - moving volume @xmath383 increases with time .
this suggests that there is not more than approximately one wall per horizon because energy in walls has low entropy and hence increases only reluctantly . with one wall per horizon ,
the fraction of the energy density in walls is @xmath384 if this fraction reaches one , the universe becomes domain wall dominated and disaster strikes as described above .
to get rid of the walls , we add to the model a tiny @xmath374 breaking term which lifts the vacuum degeneracy completely , e.g. : @xmath385 where @xmath386 is the pq field with the `` mexican hat '' potential , at the bottom of which @xmath387 . on the rhs of eq.(6.2 )
an extra term appears : @xmath388 now the unique true vacuum is the one for which @xmath389 is smallest .
its energy density is lowered by an amount of order @xmath390 relative to the other quasi - vacua . as a result ,
the walls at the boundary of a region in the true vacuum are subjected to an outward pressure of order @xmath390 .
since the walls are typically a distance @xmath82 apart , the volume energy @xmath391 associated with the lifting of the vacuum degeneracy grows more rapidly than the energy @xmath392 in the walls . at a time @xmath393 ,
the pressure favoring the true vacuum starts to dominate the wall dynamics and the true vacuum takes over , i.e. the walls disappear .
we require this to happen before the walls dominate the energy density . using eqs .
( [ 3.14 ] ) and ( [ 5.2 ] ) , we obtain : @xmath394 on the other hand @xmath395 is bounded from above by the requirement that @xmath396 does not upset the pq mechanism .
@xmath396 shifts the minimum of the effective potential for the axion field , inducing a @xmath397 .
the requirement that @xmath398 implies : @xmath399 eqs .
( [ 5.5 ] ) and ( [ 5.7 ] ) indicate that there is very little room in parameter space for this third solution to the axion domain wall problem , at least if @xmath400 ev . but the third solution is not completely ruled out . soon after time @xmath401
, a cross - section of a small fraction of the universe looks like fig . 3 except that every string
anti - string pair is connected by @xmath12 walls instead of just one wall .
this likely changes the mechanism by which the walls bounded by strings dissipate their energy since each string is being pulled in different directions by the @xmath12 walls to which it is attached .
the fraction @xmath275 of wall energy that goes into non - relativistic or barely relativistic axions is at any rate severely restricted since @xmath401 is much earlier than the time @xmath402 sec of equality between matter and radiation and , using eqs .
( [ 5.2 ] ) and ( [ 5.7 ] ) , @xmath403 the fraction of the cosmological energy density in axions from domain wall decay @xmath404 should be less than about 1/2 when @xmath405 .
this implies the bound @xmath406 where we used eq .
( [ 5.7 ] ) to obtain the second inequality
. however emission of gravitational waves is likely to be very effective because @xmath407 , given by eq .
( 3.40 ) , is not very much larger than @xmath401 .
thus decay of the walls into gravitational radiation is in this case both necessary and likely .
the third solution therefore predicts a peak in the present spectrum of gravitational waves at the frequency @xmath408 the energy density in these gravitational waves is of order @xmath409 where @xmath410 is the energy density in the cosmic microwave background .
we have discussed the fate of the walls bounded by strings which appear during the qcd phase transition in axion models with @xmath0 assuming the axion field is not homogenized by inflation . we have argued that the main decay mechanism of these objects is radiation of barely relativistic axions and that the decay takes place during or soon after the qcd phase transition .
we presented the results of our computer simulations of the motion and decay of walls bounded by strings . in the simulations , the walls decay immediately , i.e. in a time scale of order the light travel time .
the computer simulations also provide an estimate of the average energy of the axions emitted in the decay of the walls : @xmath1 when @xmath411 . because of restrictions on the available lattice sizes , the simulations are for values of @xmath412 of order 100 , whereas in axion models of interest
@xmath412 is of order @xmath413 . to address this shortcoming ,
we have investigated the dependence of @xmath414 upon @xmath415 and found that it increases approximately as the logarithm of this quantity .
this is because the decay process occurs in two steps : 1 ) wall energy converts into moving string energy because the wall accelerates the string , and the energy spectrum hardens accordingly ; 2 ) the strings annihilate into axions without qualitative change in the energy spectrum .
if this behaviour persists all the way to @xmath416 , then @xmath417 for axion models of interest . to parameterize our ignorance of the decay process we introduced two parameters : the time @xmath218 when the decay effectively takes place and the average lorentz factor @xmath418 of the radiated axions at time @xmath218 .
we found that in first approximation the cosmological energy density of axions from wall decay does not depend upon @xmath218 whereas it is inversely proportional to @xmath220 .
for @xmath419 the contribution from wall decay is of the same order of magnitude as that from vacuum realignment .
all three contributions - vacuum realignment , string decay and wall decay - were discussed in one unified treatment .
we discussed the velocity dispersion of axions from wall decay ( pop .
ii ) and found that it is much larger , by a factor @xmath6 or so , than that of axions from vacuum realignment and from string decay ( pop .
this has interesting consequences for the formation and evolution of axion miniclusters .
we showed that the qcd horizon scale density perturbations in pop.ii axions get erased by free streaming before the time @xmath322 of equality between radiation and matter whereas those in pop.i axions do not .
ii axions form an unclustered component of the axion cosmological energy density which guarantees that the signal in direct searches for axion dark matter is on all the time .
we speculated that the velocity dispersion of axions from wall decay may be large enough to be measured in a cavity detector of dark matter axions .
this would provide a direct experimental handle on some of the issues raised by axion cosmology , e.g. the question whether inflation occurred below or above the pq phase transition .
finally we discussed the cosmology of axion models with @xmath7 in which the axion domain wall problem is solved by postulating a small u@xmath8(1 ) breaking interaction which slightly lowers one of the @xmath12 vacua with respect to the others .
there is very little room in parameter space for this to work but it is a logical possibility .
we find that in this case the walls must decay into gravitational radiation of frequency of order @xmath420hz .
we thank e.w . kolb and e.p.s .
shellard for useful comments .
ps was the beneficiary of a fellowship from the j.s .
guggenheim memorial foundation .
this research was also supported in part by doe grant de - fg05 - 86er40272 at the university of florida and by doe grant w-7405-eng-048 at lawrence livermore national laboratory .
r. d. peccei and h. quinn , phys .
lett . * 38 * , 1440 ( 1977 ) ; phys .
* d16 * , 1791 ( 1977 ) ; s. weinberg , phys . rev . lett .
* 40 * , 223 ( 1978 ) ; f. wilczek , phys .
rev . lett . * 40 * , 279 ( 1978 ) .
j. e. kim , phys .
rep . * 150 * , 1 ( 1987 ) ; h .- y .
cheng , phys .
rep . * 158 * , 1 ( 1988 ) ; r. d. peccei , in _ cp violation _
by c. jarlskog , world scientific publ . , 1989 , pp 503 - 551 ; m. s. turner , phys . rep .
* 197 * , 67 ( 1990 ) ; g. g. raffelt , phys .
rep . * 198 * , 1 ( 1990 ) .
p. sikivie , phys .
. lett . * 48 * , 1156 ( 1982 ) .
janka , w. keil , g. raffelt and d. seckel , phys .
* 76 * , 2621 ( 1996 ) ; w. keil , h .-
janka , d.n .
schramm , g. sigl , m.s .
turner and j. ellis , phys .
* d56 * , 2419 ( 1997 ) .
d. j. gross r. d. pisarski and l. g. yaffe , rev .
* 53 * , 43 ( 1981 ) .
l. abbot and p. sikivie , phys . lett .
* b120 * , 133 ( 1983 ) ; j. preskill , m. wise and f. wilczek , phys . lett . * b120 * , 127 ( 1983 ) ; m. dine and w. fischler , phys . lett . * 120 * , 137 ( 1983 ) .
r. davis , phys .
d32 * , 3172 ( 1985 ) ; phys . lett . *
b180 * , 225 ( 1986 ) .
d. harari and p. sikivie , phys . lett . * b195 * , 361 ( 1987 ) . a. vilenkin and a.e .
everett , phys .
* 48 * , 1867 ( 1982 ) .
p. sikivie in _ where are the elementary particles _ , proc .
of the 14th summer school on particle physics , gif - sur - yvette , 1982 , edited by p. fayet
particules , paris , 1983 ) .
a. vilenkin and t. vachaspati , phys . rev .
* d35 * , 1138 ( 1987 ) ; r.l . davis and e.p.s .
shellard , nucl . phys . * b324 * , 167 ( 1989 ) ; a. dabholkar and j.m .
quashnock , nucl .
b333 * , 815 ( 1990 ) ; r.a .
battye and e.p.s .
shellard , nucl . phys . *
b423 * , 260 ( 1994 ) ; phys .
lett . * 73 * , 2954 ( 1994 ) ; ( e ) ibid . *
76 * , 2203 ( 1996 ) ; astro - ph/9802216 . c. hagmann and p. sikivie , nucl
* b363 * , 247 ( 1991 ) ; c. hagmann , s. chang and p. sikivie , to be published .
d. h. lyth , phys . lett . * b275 * , 279 ( 1992 ) .
m. nagasawa and m. kawasaki , phys .
d50 * , 4821 ( 1994 ) .
kolb and m.s .
turner , _ the early universe _
, addison - wesley , 1990 . c. j. hogan and m. j. rees , phys
b205 * , 228 ( 1988 ) . e. w. kolb and i. tkachev , phys .
lett . * 71 * , 3051 ( 1993 ) .
p. sikivie , phys .
. lett . * 51 * , 1415 ( 1983 ) and phys .
rev . * d32 * , 2988 ( 1985 ) ; l. krauss et al . , phys.rev
. lett . * 55 * , 1797 ( 1985 ) ; s. depanfilis et al .
, phys . rev .
59 * , 839 ( 1987 ) and phys . rev . *
d40 * , 3151 ( 1989 ) ; c. hagmann et al . , phys .
rev . * d42 * , 1297 ( 1990 ) ; k. van bibber et al .
. phys . * d3 * suppl .
33 ( 1994 ) ; s. matsuki et al .
, phys . lett .
* 336 * , 573 ( 1994 ) ; c. hagmann et al , phys .
lett . * 80 * , 2043 ( 1998 ) .
p. sikivie and j. ipser , phys . lett . *
b291 * , 288 ( 1992 ) ; p. sikivie , i. tkachev and y. wang , phys .
rev . lett . * 75 * , 2911 ( 1995 ) and phys .
d * 56 * , 1863 ( 1997 ) .
m.c . huang and p. sikivie ,
phys . rev . *
32 * , 1560 ( 1985 ) .
p. j. steinhardt and m. s. turner , phys .
b129 * , 51 ( 1983 ) ; w. g. unruh and r. m. wald , phys . rev . * d32 * , 831 ( 1985 ) ; m. s. turner , phys . rev .
* d32 * , 843 ( 1985 ) ; t. degrand , t. w. kephart and t. j. weiler , phys .
* d33 * , 910 ( 1986 ) ; g. lazarides , r. schaefer , d. seckel and q. shafi , nucl . phys . *
b346 * , 193 ( 1990 ) ; m. hindmarsh , phys . rev . * d45 * , 1130 ( 1992 ) . c. t. hill and g. g. ross , nucl . phys . * b311 * , 253 ( 1988 ) .
kolb , a. singh and m. srednicki , hep - ph/9709285 ; p.b .
greene , l. kofman and a.a .
starobinsky , hep - ph/9808477 .
m. kalb and p. ramond , phys . rev .
* d9 * , 2273 ( 1974 ) ; f. lund and t. regge , phys . rev . *
d14 * , 1524 ( 1976 ) ; e. witten , phys .
* b153 * , 243 ( 1985 ) .
a. vilenkin , phys .
* b133 * , 177 ( 1983 ) ; j. ipser and p. sikivie , phys . rev .
* d30 * , 712 ( 1984 ) .
ryden , w.h . press and d.n .
spergel , ap .
j. * 357 * , 293 ( 1990 ) .
y. zeldovich , y. kobzarev and l. okun , sov .
jetp * 40*,1 ( 1975 ) .
gelmini , m. gleiser and e.w .
kolb , phys .
d39 * , 1558 ( 1989 ) . | we discuss the appearance at the qcd phase transition , and the subsequent decay , of axion walls bounded by strings in @xmath0 axion models .
we argue on intuitive grounds that the main decay mechanism is into barely relativistic axions .
we present numerical simulations of the decay process . in these simulations
, the decay happens immediately , in a time scale of order the light travel time , and the average energy of the radiated axions is @xmath1 for @xmath2 .
@xmath3 is found to increase approximately linearly with @xmath4 .
extrapolation of this behaviour yields @xmath5 in axion models of interest .
we find that the contribution to the cosmological energy density of axions from wall decay is of the same order of magnitude as that from vacuum realignment , with however large uncertainties .
the velocity dispersion of axions from wall decay is found to be larger , by a factor @xmath6 or so , than that of axions from vacuum realignment and string decay .
we discuss the implications of this for the formation and evolution of axion miniclusters and for the direct detection of axion dark matter on earth .
finally we discuss the cosmology of axion models with @xmath7 in which the domain wall problem is solved by introducing a small u@xmath8(1 ) breaking interaction .
we find that in this case the walls decay into gravitational waves . |
organic molecules are promising candidates for the next generation of electronic devices and for solar energy conversion.@xcite among these , assemblies of dye molecules in the form of j - aggregates have attracted attention for their special optical properties.@xcite these are understood from delocalization of the exciton formed upon the absorption of light over tens to hundreds of monomers.@xcite because the dominant resonant transfer interactions between molecules are negative in a j - aggregate , the optically bright state is found at the bottom of the band , leading to a redshift of the absorption peak compared to a single chromophore .
other properties resulting from this exciton delocalization are superradiance and a hidden level structure at the band edge.@xcite the exciton delocalization in linear aggregates is reflected in the pump - probe spectrum@xcite and in the two - dimensional optical spectrum.@xcite most early studies focused on j - aggregates for which the optical properties can be explained with a model of a linear aggregate , which self - assemble in solution and are often studied at low temperature in a glass environment.@xcite over the past years there has been an intense interest in tubular j - aggregates.@xcite it is also possible to manufacture two - dimensional thin film j - aggregates of chromophore molecules , which were found to exhibit a redshift in the absorption.@xcite nonlinear optical experiments produced a two - dimensional spectrum similar to the spectrum of a linear aggregate , consisting of a single pair of positive and negative peaks.@xcite in order to analyse these findings , a model of a truly two - dimensional aggregate must be used,@xcite which goes beyond weakly coupled linear aggregates.@xcite in general , the transfer interactions between molecules depend strongly on their relative orientation .
this means that the absorption spectrum is sensitive to the details of the molecular arrangement .
therefore , modeling of the spectrum can help in determining the structure .
this is particularly helpful in cases where the structure is not known from other measurements.@xcite it is clear from experiment , as well as from consideration of the molecular structure , that the excitons in j - aggregates must couple to their environment .
this coupling leads to scattering between exciton states and to pure dephasing .
the total dephasing process can be studied by measuring the homogeneous line width in experiments such as photon echos , hole burning or two - dimensional spectroscopy . in particular , the dependence of the homogeneous line width on temperature can be analysed in order to understand the exciton phonon coupling mechanism . understanding the interaction with the environment is also important to assess
how many molecules in the aggregate are entangled upon optical excitation .
this entanglement , or delocalization , is the key quantity that causes the interesting properties of these systems .
however , interactions with phonons limit the localization size , and determining this quantity as a function of temperature is an important goal . it has been shown that the energy dependent localization size can be extracted from two - dimensional spectra.@xcite studies of the homogeneous line width have been performed on j - aggregates for which linear chain models explain the optical properties .
fidder et al.@xcite measured the homogeneous width in pic - br for temperatures between 1.5 and 190 k. the temperature dependence is clearly nonlinear and was modeled by coupling of the excitons to three harmonic modes with frequencies of 9 @xmath0 , 305 @xmath0 and 973 @xmath0 .
hirschmann and friedrich@xcite measured the homogeneous line width in pic - i for temperatures from 0.35 k to 80 k. the temperature dependence can be fitted by a sum of two exponentials or be explained by a theory that predicts a power law dependence.@xcite the homogeneous line shape is well approximated by a lorentzian for all temperatures .
in contrast to this work , experiments on thin films using two - dimensional optical spectroscopy have found a scaling of the homogeneous line width with temperature.@xcite this suggests that a different mechanism is responsible for the line width . in this work
, we use an excitonic model of two - dimensional brick layer j - aggregates and study the homogeneous line width as a function of temperature .
our theoretical model is presented in section ii and the results are presented in section iii .
specifically , we predict the excitonic coupling in molecular aggregates and thus correlate two - dimensional spectra with molecular arrangements .
these calculations are the topic of sections iiia , b , and c. then we consider population relaxation and the exciton lifetime n sec .
iiid and calculate the homogeneous line width as a function of temperature in section iiie .
finally , we analyse experimental measurements in sec . iv and conclude in section v. in the appendix , we consider alternative aggregate geometries .
the usual frenkel exciton model of j - aggregates starts from a single bright optical transition on each molecule .
the hamitonian includes a term which describes local excitation of a molecule with an excitation energy @xmath1 and a term for the coherent exciton motion from one molecule to the other , and is given in terms of the pauli creation and annihilation operators @xmath2 and @xmath3 by @xmath4 in this hamiltonian , the sums run over all molecules in the aggregate . if the molecules are far enough apart , the electrostatic interaction between them can be approximated by dipole dipole coupling , which gives @xmath5 here , @xmath6 is the transition dipole vector of molecule @xmath7 , @xmath8 is the relative position vector , @xmath9 is the distance and @xmath10 .
@xmath11 is a constant that scales the magnitude of the coupling and includes possible rescaling effects due to vibrations.@xcite here , we will use transition dipole coupling for all pairs of molecules .
for nearest neigbours , a better understanding of the coupling can be obtained from quantum chemical calculations.@xcite each molecule in the aggregate is influenced by a different local environment .
this leads to static disorder in the site energies @xmath1 , which are different for each aggregate in the ensemble .
this , in turn , leads to localization and a distribution of effective sizes of the exciton .
furthermore , the excitons in the aggregate interact with phonons in the surrounding material .
their dynamic effect is usually modeled as a reservoir of harmonic oscillators , which are described by the bath hamiltonian @xmath12 .
the interaction of these oscillators with the electronic excitations is assumed to be @xmath13 where the effective bath coordinate is to be thought of as the sum of couplings to individual bath modes , which can be written as @xmath14 . here ,
@xmath15 denote the coordinates of the bath modes , while @xmath16 are their coupling constants to the system .
the linear dependence on the bath coordinate can be thought of as a lowest order expansion in the coordinate .
the properties of the system bath interactions are determined by the correlation functions @xmath17 .
we will make the usual but not completely general assumption that the fluctuations on each site are uncorrelated and that their correlation function is the same on each site , @xmath18 .
the system hamiltonian ( for each realization of the static disorder ) can be diagonalized to give the exciton states @xmath19 , which we choose to be real , and energies @xmath20 , such that @xmath21 .
the wave functions relate the exciton basis to the site basis by the equation @xmath22 . in the same exciton basis
, the system bath interaction can be written as @xmath23 , with the diagonal fluctuations @xmath24 and the off - diagonal fluctuations that couple two different eigenstates @xmath25 in modified redfield theory@xcite , the diagonal fluctuations are treated exactly , while the off - diagonal fluctuations are included in second order perturbation theory .
the zero order hamiltonian @xmath26 does not couple the exciton states .
therefore , the absorption spectrum for this hamiltonian is simply the sum of contributions from each exciton state . in this case , where the system hamiltonian commutes with the system bath interaction ,
the linear and nonlinear response functions can be calculated analytically with the cumulant expansion . for the linear absorption in the time domain
, we find @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the transition dipole from the ground state to exciton state @xmath29 .
the spectrum @xmath30 is given as the fourier transform of @xmath31 .
the line shape function for each exciton state is given by @xmath32 , where @xmath33 is the inverse participation ratio@xcite .
the line shape function for a single site is defined as @xmath34 if the harmonic bath is interpreted in the continuum limit , the correlation function can be expressed in terms of the spectral density @xmath35 ( although , in principle , the spectral density can also contain delta functions which describe discrete modes ) .
the quantum correlation function @xmath36 is given in terms of the spectral density by the expression @xmath37 the homogeneous line width , which can be measured in photon echos or two - dimensional spectra can now be explained by two broadening mechanisms .
first , there is the pure dephasing contribution contained in eq .
second , there will be a contribution from @xmath38 . in second order perturbation theory with the markov and secular approximations , this term will lead to dephasing given as the sum of population relaxation rates .
this contribution can be termed dephasing from population relaxation .
the perturbative treatment of @xmath38 , which is known from experiment to be weak in certain linear j - aggregates,@xcite leads to scattering between exciton eigenstates .
the scattering rate between eigenstate @xmath39 and @xmath29 is given by @xmath40 where the sum runs over all molecules in the aggregate , @xmath41 , @xmath42 is the spectral density and @xmath43 for @xmath44 and @xmath45 for @xmath46 , with @xmath47 the bose einstein distribution .
the resulting dephasing rate of exciton state @xmath29 is given by @xmath48 .
then , the homogenous absorption line with both pure dephasing and dephasing from population relaxation is given by @xmath49 note that we neglect the radiative life time in this expression , which normally gives a negligible contribution to the linewidth .
also , in this work we do not include an ensemble of localization sizes causes by the presence of static disorder .
finally , it should be observed that the homogeneous line width is not equal to the sum of dephasing rates if multiple transitions overlap in the spectrum .
we assume that the molecules are placed on a brick layer lattice@xcite with aspect ratio @xmath50 and slip @xmath51 , see figure [ fig : coupling ] .
the grid has @xmath52 molecules in the x - direction and @xmath53 in the y - direction .
these sizes should not be interpreted as the physical size of the aggregate , but as the number of molecules over which an exciton is delocalized .
different geometries can then be obtained by varying the slip , while we assume a constant aspect ratio of @xmath54 , which is a reasonable number for molecules typically used to form thin films .
note that with this choice , a slip of 1.0 ( half a unit cell ) corresponds to a square lattice with dipoles oriented at 45 degrees with respect to the lattice vectors .
we note that , for the small aggregates considered in this paper , the choice of boundary conditions is important .
we limit our study to the boundary conditions shown in fig .
[ fig : coupling ] . in the appendix
, we consider the value of @xmath55 .
other arrangements , for example herringbone structures with two molecules per unit cell , are outside the scope of this paper . for
a constant prefactor @xmath11 the magnitude of the couplings will change with @xmath51 .
this is shown in figure [ fig : coupling ] .
we define the nearest neighbour coupling in the x - direction as @xmath42 .
note that we include all long range couplings in our model as well , and that we do nt use periodic boundary conditions . in figure
[ fig : coupling ] we observe that the values of @xmath51 for which an aggregate with negative couplings in both directions is formed are quite limited . in most cases ,
the coupling in the vertical direction is positive . because of this combination of negative and positive interactions , the system is not a perfect j - aggregate , in the sense that the bright state is not necessarily at the bottom of the band .
we will see that this has observable consequences for the two - dimensional optical spectrum .
negative couplings in both the x and y directions are found around @xmath56 , which is the structure close to the one assumed in experimental work on brick layer ptcda aggregates.@xcite in figure [ fig : dos ] we plot the density of states for a linear aggregate and several two - dimensional aggregates .
for each geometry , we scale the parameter @xmath42 ( or , equivalently @xmath11 ) , to obtain a shift of approximately 2500 @xmath0 of the aggregate absorption peak with respect to the absorption peak of the monomer .
this choice is made to stay close to the interpretation of experimental results , in which the spectral shift upon aggregation can be measured , but the structure of the aggregate ( i.e. a two - dimensional bricklayer lattice or a collection of semi - one - dimensional chains ) is not always a priori known .
in particular , we are interested in comparing with experimental data on bic aggregates studied in ref . , where this shift was observed to be around 2500 @xmath0 .
in order to obtain this shift , we set @xmath57 @xmath0 for the linear aggregate , @xmath58 @xmath0 for @xmath59 , @xmath60 @xmath0 for @xmath61 and @xmath62 @xmath0 for @xmath56 .
we note that , because of differences in the electrostatic environment , the shift does not necessarily directly reflect the excitonic coupling . in the linear case
, we observe a strong increase of the density at the band edge , reflecting the @xmath63 scaling in the case of an infinite chain.@xcite the two - dimensional aggregate with @xmath59 mirrors this behaviour , but has additional states at lower energy . for larger values of @xmath51
, however , the density of states decreases with decreasing energy , in line with the expected constant behaviour in the limit of an infinite sheet.@xcite we note that the difference in density of states between a linear and two - dimensional aggregate is quite dramatic .
for example , for the energy gap between the two lowest - lying states , we find 9.2 @xmath0 in a 25x25 lattice ( @xmath56 , @xmath64 ) , while it is only 0.45 @xmath0 in a linear chain with 625 molecules ( @xmath65 ) .
( note that we include long range interactions in the simulations leading to this number . )
we now turn our attention to the linear and two - dimensional optical spectra for this model system . for all models
the simulation predicts a dominant bright peak in the linear absorption spectra , which , by construction lies about 2500 @xmath0 below the monomer absorption peak .
however , we find that @xmath59 and @xmath56 are clearly distinguishable when the two - dimensional correlation spectrum is considered .
two - dimensional optical spectroscopy is a third - order nonlinear optical technique which correlates the evolution of the electronic state of the system during two time periods , called @xmath66 and @xmath67.@xcite the signal is plotted as a function of the fourier transforms of these two time periods , with frequencies labeled @xmath68 and @xmath69 .
the technique can be used to separate homogeneous broadening , which shows up as the anti - diagonal width of peaks in the two - dimensional plot , from inhomogeneous broadening , which contributes to the diagonal width .
it therefore provides a tool to measure the homogeneous line width .
when one looks at the real value of a two - dimensional spectrum , both negative peaks , colored in blue , and positive peaks , colored in red , are present .
blue peaks arise from interactions where one excitation is created , while red peaks correspond to processes where , during @xmath67 , coherences between one- and two - quantum states ( in which two excitation quanta are present in the system ) are present .
positive peaks are blue shifted with respect to negative peaks as a consequence of the pauli exclusion principle . the vertical distance between positive and negative peaks can be used as a ruler from which the exciton localization size can be determined .
we calculated two - dimensional optical spectra using the sum over states method,@xcite assuming only homogeneous broadening .
this simple method will give a good idea of the peak positions and relative intensities , but not of the details of the line shape .
note that in the calculation of the spectra , we have chosen to vary @xmath42 in order to obtain similar peak positions for all values of @xmath51 considered .
the reason for this choice is that @xmath42 is not known a priori in experiment , but the spectral shift with respect to the monomer can be measured . in our spectra , in the case @xmath59 , because of the presence of both positive and negative couplings in the system , the bright state is not at the bottom of the band .
because of the pauli exclusion principle , two excitons can not populate the same state.@xcite induced absorption peaks will show up at lower @xmath69 than the bleaching and stimulated emission peak .
this is most easily understood in the simplified case of a linear aggregate with nearest neighbor interactions only , for which the hamiltonian can be diagonalized analytically using a jordan - wigner transformation.@xcite the two - exciton states are then given as anti - symmetric products of one - exciton states . because the `` first '' exciton is not at the bottom of the band , the `` second '' exciton can go to a lower energy than the first one .
this leads to the induced absorption peak .
although this picture of two independent excitons is not strictly valid when long - range interactions are taken into account , the result that an extra induced absorption peak appears at low @xmath69 is also found numerically in the full calculation ( see fig .
[ fig : spec2d0 ] ) . note that for a linear aggregate the induced absorption peak is weaker than the bleaching and stimulated emission peak , while the two have approximately equal amplitude for the 2d lattice with @xmath56 .
both of these systems have the state with largest oscillator strength at the bottom of the band .
the presence of a large coupling in the y - direction makes the 2d lattice different from a product of one - dimensional aggregates , as considered in arias et al.@xcite we will see that the difference is crucial for a correct determination of the couplings in the system . in this case
the bright state is at the bottom of the band , and the two - dimensional spectrum shows a dominant pair of a positive and a negative peak ( see fig .
[ fig : spec2d0 ] ) .
because the occurrence of positive and negative peaks and their relative intensities in this spectrum are close to the observed spectrum for bic aggregates,@xcite this finding lends support to the model with a slip around @xmath70 for this system .
finally , we note that in the 2d lattice spectrum , a cross peak due to finite size effects is just visible to the right of the main peak .
simulated real part of the two - dimensional photon echo spectrum of ( a ) a linear j - aggregate with 36 molecules and of ( b - d ) various two - dimensional j - aggregates with a brick layer structure of 6x6 molecules .
the slip = ( b ) 0.5 , ( c ) 0.75 and ( d ) 1.0 .
homogeneous broadening with a single lorentzian line width is assumed and all contours are scaled to the amplitude in the spectrum of the linear aggregate .
negative ( bleaching and stimulated emission ) peaks are plotted in blue , while positive ( induced absorption ) peaks are plotted in red and yellow .
contours are at the same absolute level in all panels , and were drawn at -50 , -40 , -30 , -20 , 20 , 30 , 40 and 50 percent of the maximum amplitude of the spectrum of the linear aggregate . ]
we now consider the difference between a linear ( n@xmath71x1 ) and a brick layer ( nxn ) aggregate . in both cases , a dominant pair of positive and negative peaks
is found in the 2d spectrum.@xcite the relation between the nearest neighbor coupling and the peak shift of the aggregate compared to the monomer , which can be measured by finding the maximum in the linear spectra , is different .
this simple method , which relies on the fact that excitonic coupling shifts the peak , is frequently used to determine the coupling from experimentally obtained spectra , even though it neglects the shift in the single molecule transition frequency due to the electrostatic effect of the different environment in both cases .
the difference is easily explained from the fact that there are more neighbors and that there is therefore more coupling in the 2d aggregate .
quantitatively , the peak shift in a linear aggregate is 2.4 times the nearest neighbor coupling.@xcite in the 2d system with @xmath56 , we find that the shift is several times larger ( @xmath72 for a 6x6 bricklayer lattice ) .
thus , while estimating the couplings from the spectral shift , it is important to take the aggregate geometry into account . here , we established the rule that can be used to estimate the coupling in a two - dimensional brick layer aggregate from the measured linear absorption spectrum for parameters @xmath73 , @xmath54 . for other parameters
a similar rule can be established , which will , in general , be different from the rule derived from calculations on linear aggregates .
we note that the magnitude of the couplings and , therefore , spectral shifts strongly depend on the aggregate under study .
in particular , in ref .
much smaller couplings were found than in ref . .
however , the relation between spectral shift and coupling does not depend on the absolute value of these numbers .
we note that the practical rule described here is related to well established results derived from sum rules.@xcite we next consider the life time of the bright state , which for both the linear aggregate and the brick layer lattice with @xmath54 and @xmath56 lies at the bottom of the band .
this life time can be measured experimentally using pump - probe spectroscopy . for the well
studied system of linear aggregates in a glass , the temperature dependence of the life time of this state is mostly determined by scattering to higher states with the absorption of phonons .
the dephasing associated with population relaxation is found to dominate , leading to a @xmath74 dependence of the homogeneous line width.@xcite this result is obtained from perturbation theory , where the scattering rate between two eigenstates is the product of three contributions : the boltzmann factor of the phonons @xmath7 evaluated at the energy gap between both states , the exciton - phonon spectral density evaluated at the energy gap , which is taken cubic for the glass environment , and the overlap of the wave functions of the two states .
we refer to ref . for further details . in this model
, it is clear that the density of states at the band edge is very important for the life time . as was shown before
, this density of states is very different in linear and 2d aggregates . as a result
, the established theory for linear aggregates in a glass must be used with caution here .
the boltzmann factor is much larger and more strongly peaked in the linear chain , leading to larger scattering rates , and a smaller life time .
although the spectral density typically increases with energy , this is counteracted by the stronger exponential decay of the boltzmann factor .
we also expect different behavior of the life time as a function of temperature , because the argument used in heijs et al .
to arrive at the @xmath74 dependence is valid only for @xmath75 .
we therefore expect a different behaviour of the temperature dependence of the homogeneous line width , irrespective of the details of the interaction with the phonons . as the numerical calculations presented in fig .
[ fig : lifetime ] show , the life time is up to more than an order of magnitude larger in the brick layer system than in the linear aggregate for the same system ( delocalization ) size .
life times were computed for the same cubic spectral density in all cases and , in contrast to the previous sections , for a nearest neighbour coupling strength of @xmath76 , which is a typical value for the aggregates considered .
all long range couplings were included as well .
we note that the population relaxation rate as a function of temperature exhibits a power law dependence for linear aggregates , while a kink is observed for a 2d lattice .
the kink can be understood as follows . in the argument leading to a power law dependence of the scattering rates as a function of temperature ,
the summation over discrete states is replaced by an integration.@xcite this replacement is valid if the temperature is large compared to the energy gap between the relevant exciton states , which are the lowest two states in the band . for the 10x10 brick layer lattice used in fig .
[ fig : lifetime ] , the energy gap between these states is found to be 71 @xmath0 , which corresponds to a temperature of roughly 100 k. therefore , the power law dependence , which holds for high temperatures compared to the energy gap , breaks down and a kink is observed in the life time .
we also note that the temperature dependence of the life time depends very strongly on @xmath50 and @xmath51 .
as discussed in the appendix , there is almost no temperature dependence for certain values , while for other values the life time varies over orders of magnitude .
note that , to make a direct comparison possible , these calculations assume that the spectral density is the same for linear and two - dimensional aggregates .
we will argue later , based on the analysis of the experimentally measured temperature dependence of the homogeneous line width , that there is a linear component in the spectral density for the two - dimensional aggregates .
however , the suppression of relaxation rates in the two - dimensional aggregates based on the much smaller boltzmann factor will occur irrespective of the spectral density .
if , indeed , a linear spectral density is more appropriate for two - dimensional aggregates , we can also obtain population relaxation rates for this case .
the result is shown in figure [ fig : lifetimelinj ] .
parameters were estimated based on the experimental data for a bic aggregate , see section [ sec : exp ] . for this choice of the spectral density , the pure dephasing can be characterized by a rate if the temperature is low compared to the cut - off frequency of the bath.@xcite the life time is also plotted in the figure .
we observe that pure dephasing dominates the homogeneous line width up to a certain temperature , which depends on the system size used in the simulations ( i.e. the exciton localization size ) . for higher temperatures ,
population relaxation becomes more important .
this finding can be used to determine an upper limit for the delocalization size .
comparison with experiment shows that the predominance of dephasing from population relaxation , which is found for linear aggregates , does not explain experiment for the thin film . a perfectly linear relation between the homogeneous line width and the temperature was measured.@xcite
although this finding could be explained from population relaxation with a different @xmath77 dependence of the spectral density , this is not a plausible explanation of the experimental findings .
a sub - ohmic power@xcite , on the order of @xmath78 in the spectral density would be needed .
there is no clear microscopic mechanism that would lead to this behavior .
furthermore , it would be very surprising that the temperature dependence of the homogeneous line width is exactly linear .
therefore , it is more logical to assume that the mechanism leading to homogeneous broadening is different in linear and 2d aggregates .
the different mechanism can be understood by the difference in population relaxation rates found in the previous section . in linear aggregates ,
the density of states at the band edge is large , leading to strong scattering between exciton states and fast relaxation of the population in the bright state .
this population relaxation leads to dephasing , which dominates the homogeneous line width .
in contrast , in two - dimensional aggregates , the density of states at the band edge is orders of magnitude smaller . population relaxation , which depends strongly on the difference in energy between eigenstates , is suppressed for the smooth spectral densities that we assume here .
the accompanying dephasing is therefore also much weaker than in the case of linear aggregates .
therefore , pure dephasing becomes more important and can dominate the homogeneous line width .
this is the main finding of this paper .
this model predicts that the life time broadening is only a small part of the homogeneous line width .
this prediction could be tested experimentally by measuring the life time of the bright state with pump - probe spectroscopy .
we will now see how the dominance of pure dephasing in two - dimensional aggregates leads to a linear scaling of the homogeneous line width with temperature .
we assume that the spectral density is polynomial in frequency up to a cut - off frequency @xmath79 , @xmath80 where @xmath81 is a cut - off function .
common forms for this function are an exponential , a lorentzian or a heaviside step function .
while this spectral density quite generally describes the interaction with the bath , we assume here that intramolecular vibrations do not play a role .
we are now in a position to analyse the pure dephasing term @xmath82 . in the fast modulation limit , which we assume here
because , as we will see , it leads to a linear relation between the homogeneous line width and temperature , one can replace the correlation function by a delta function , @xmath83 . the pure dephasing contribution to the spectrum
is then given by a rate @xmath84 , because @xmath85 . by comparing with eq .
[ cfj ] one finds that the rate is related to the slope of the spectral density at zero frequency,@xcite @xmath86 .
therefore , there is no pure dephasing rate for a super - ohmic spectral density ( @xmath87 ) .
note that this statement is also valid outside the fast modulation limit , because the linear term in the line shape function is also given by the slope of the spectral density at zero frequency in the more general case .
there is still pure dephasing , but @xmath82 has no linear term . for an ohmic spectral density ( @xmath88 ) , which is the most commonly used form , because it corresponds to a linear density of states and a frequency independent exciton phonon coupling , we see that the pure dephasing rate is linearly proportional to temperature.@xcite thus , for an ohmic spectral density in the fast modulation limit , we expect a linear scaling of the homogeneous line width with temperature .
we note that it would be desirable to measure the time scale of the bath directly to strengthen this argument .
to close this section , we briefly discuss kubo stochastic line shape theory,@xcite which is valid in the high temperature limit , to estimate the temperature dependence of the pure dephasing in the slow dephasing limit .
the correlation function in this case is given by @xmath89 where the variance of the fluctuations can be expressed in terms of the reorganization energy @xmath90 and temperature by calculating the correlation function from the drude - lorentz spectral density @xmath91 .
one finds @xmath92 . the lineshape function for this model
is easily calculated to be @xmath93 one sees that in the fast modulation limit @xmath94 , in agreement with the pure dephasing rate introduced earlier . in the slow modulation limit , @xmath95 , where @xmath96 is related to the inhomogeneity in the energies of exciton states .
the line shape in the frequency domain is a gaussian with standard deviation proportional to @xmath96 . because the variance @xmath97 is linearly proportional to temperature , the line width scales as the square root of temperature in this regime .
note that this regime is less relevant for our discussion of the homogeneous line width , which is determined by fast fluctuations , while very slow fluctuation contribute only to the inhomogeneous line width .
however , this analysis shows that if the fast modulation limit is not strictly applicable,@xcite deviations from linear scaling of the line width with temperature are expected . before presenting a comparison to experiment
, we briefly discuss the role of static disorder . as indicated by eq .
[ dlgt ] , at low temperature , the line - shape and its t - dependence will be dominated by inhomogeneous broadening resulting from static disorder . in fact , a published calculation [ see fig . 7 of ref . ]
clearly shows the transition from inhomogeneous broadening to homogenous broadening in the disordered chain system .
interestingly , this transition corresponds to optimal diffusion along the chain , suggestion optimization when dynamics and static disorders balance .
another point is that the relative contribution of pure dephasing decreases with the size of localization , as shown in fig .
[ fig : lifetimelinj ] .
it is known that the anderson localization size scales with the disorder and this universal scaling depends critically on the dimensionality .
this scaling and its implication on diffusion were reported in a recent study @xcite and will be further explored in two - dimensional j - aggregates.@xcite
by comparing the measured 2d spectra in ref . with our calculated spectra , we observe that a slip around 1.0 is the most plausible structure for these systems . a slip around 0.5 and smaller
is ruled out , because an extra induced absoption peak appears below the bleaching and stimulated emission peak , which is not observed in experiment . as explained in section [ sec : nncoupl ] , the estimate of the resonant transfer interactions in two - dimensional aggregates should be done with a different formula than in linear aggregates . to obtain an estimate of the coupling @xmath42
, one should divide the excitonic peak shift by a factor of 4.9 .
this factor depends on @xmath51 and @xmath50 . by doing this , we find that the nearest neighbor coupling in the aggregate studied by arias et al .
is around -75 mev for bic ( instead of -153 mev based on a linear model ) and -104 mev for u3 ( instead of -212 mev ) . in ptcda aggregates considered by mueller et al .
, the shift was found to be 400 cm-1 .
this would lead to an interaction of -82 @xmath0 .
this value corresponds to -10 mev , and is therefore significantly smaller than for the other two aggregates . under the assumption that the homogeneous line width is completely determined by pure dephasing
, we can extract system parameters from the experimental data by following the discussion in the previous section .
the slope of the homogeneous line width versus temperature , @xmath98 , is given by @xmath99 , where @xmath100 is the localization size of the exciton .
thus , we find that @xmath101 for bic . to proceed further , it would be desirable to measure @xmath79 independently , for example from the time dependent stokes shift . from this estimate , by assuming a value for @xmath100 , we can derive the parameters for the model by heijs et al .
, and calculate the population relaxation times as shown in figure [ fig : lifetimelinj ] .
we used the same large value of @xmath102 , which means that we are consistently in the markovian regime .
we conclude that in order to obtain a linear relationship between homogeneous life time and temperature up to 250 k , the exciton should be localized on a segment smaller than 9 molecules ( 3x3 ) . for larger temperatures , deviations from linear behaviour
are expected , as can be seen in the figure .
this is consistent with the dynamic localization size estimated from experiments on bic and u3 , @xcite and slightly smaller than values found for ptcda.@xcite note that in our modified redfield approach dynamic localization is not included by construction and that we therefore regard @xmath100 as a parameter in the calculations .
in conclusion , we have used the standard frenkel exciton model to study the excitonic properties in brick layer thin film j - aggregates .
we have introduced a novel theory to explain the experimentally measured linear temperature dependence of the pure dephasing rate .
we have found that the exciton couplings determined from peak shifts in the linear spectrum depend strongly on the geometry of the system . in particular , the couplings in two - dimensional aggregates are a few times smaller than estimates based on a linear aggregate model . to explain the linear scaling of the homogeneous line width with temperature , we propose pure dephasing as the main homogeneous broadening mechanism .
because the energy gaps between exciton states at the bottom of the band are much larger in two - dimensional than in linear aggregates , population relaxation is surpressed .
this leads to a smaller contribution to the line width from population relaxation in two - dimensional aggregates , as well as to longer exciton life times . from the experimental data
, we can extract the product of the reorganization energy and the typical bath time reorganization time scale .
pump - probe experiments , which can measure the lifetime of excited states , are suggested to confirm whether dephasing due to population relaxation is indeed less important than pure dephasing .
it will also be valuable to determine the time scale of the reorganization of the phonon environment experimentally .
a much simpler model could in principle explain the exact linear temperature dependence .
stochastic line shape theory for a single two - level system coupled to a bath in the fast modulation limit predicts a lorentzian homogeneous line with a width @xmath103 , where @xmath104 is the standard deviation of the fluctuations and @xmath105 their correlation time .
because the variance of the fluctuations depends linearly on temperature this would explain the observed temperature dependence irrespective of the form of the spectral density . a microscopic model that could make the exciton state behave as an effective two - level system is the presence of correlated fluctuations .
if the site energy fluctuations are not independent , as in the model of heijs et al . , but correlated over a distance comparable to the exciton localization size , they will not lead to scattering between eigenstates , and therefore no contribution to the line width from scattering in the exciton band occurs .
we believe that the localization size is large enough to make the model of correlated fluctuations not plausible .
our calculations are limited by the assumption in modified redfield theory , where off - diagonal fluctuations in the exciton basis are treated perturbatively and therefore dynamic localization is not included .
they could be improved by taking both the diagonal and off - diagonal system bath coupling terms into account non - perturbatively .
this could be achieved with the cumulant expansion method,@xcite stochastic path integrals,@xcite or hierarchy of equation of motion simulations.@xcite these methods can be used to study the effect of dynamic localization,@xcite but are difficult to apply given the large reorganization energy and low temperature compared to the excitonic coupling in the system .
they could also be used to calculate the localization size , which is treated as a parameter in our work .
we remark that modified redfield theory becomes more accurate with an increase in the excitonic energy gap , which means that the theory is more accurate for systems of modest localization size , as we consider here . for some aggregates , intermolecular vibrations
are important,@xcite which could be considered in future work .
experimental measurement of the stokes shift may help to improve our understanding of the role of vibrations .
finally , it would be desirable to get a better estimate of the resonant transfer interactions from quantum chemical simulations and to include radiative decay to the ground state in our calculations .
on the experimental side , collecting 2d spectra as a function of the waiting time to elucidate energy transfer mechanisms@xcite would be a possible future extension .
the results presented here contribute to the understanding of the photophysics of two - dimensional j - aggregate thin films .
work by kan and agd was supported as part of the center for excitonics , an energy frontier research center funded by the u.s .
department of energy , office of science , basic energy sciences under award # de - sc0001088 .
jc was supported by the nsf ( grant no .
che-1112825 ) .
agd was furthermore supported by a marie curie international incoming fellowship within the 7th european community framework programme ( grant no .
hgd acknowledges financial support by the joachim - herz - stiftung , hamburg within the pier fellowship program .
in this appendix , we consider a wider range of geometries than were presented in the main text , in particular , a brick layer lattice with a larger aspect ratio @xmath55 . in figure
[ fig : couplinga3 ] we plot the resonant transfer interaction for an aspect ratio of 3 .
similar as in the case @xmath54 , we find that there is only a limited range of values of the slip @xmath51 for which interactions are negative in the horizontal as well as the vertical direction . in figure
[ fig : dosa3 ] we plot the density of states for @xmath55 .
we observe a clear difference in the density of states at the band edge between linear aggregates and brick layer aggregates .
we note that for a slip of @xmath59 , the state with maximum oscillator strength is blue shifted with respect to the monomer .
we calculated the life time of the bright state for a @xmath106 brick layer lattice for different values of @xmath50 and @xmath51 , using the same procedure as outlined in the main text . for @xmath54 , with @xmath107 and @xmath59 , the temperature dependence varies dramatically less than for the value of @xmath56 used in the main text ( data not shown ) . in particular , for @xmath107 the lifetime is constant at the very small value of 1.5 @xmath108 ps over the entire range of temperatures considered ( 20 to 350 k ) . for @xmath59 , the life time decreases from 8 @xmath109 ps at 20 k to 2 @xmath109 ps at 350 k , still a much smaller variation than was observed in fig .
[ fig : lifetime ] for @xmath56 .
we attribute the difference to the presence of states which are lower in energy than the bright state .
the system can relax to these states by spontaneous emission of a phonon , which is independent of temperature . for @xmath55 and @xmath59 , we also find a constant lifetime over the range of temperature from 20 k to 350 k. for @xmath56 and @xmath110 , we find a very strong dependence on temperature , as can be seen from the data plotted in fig .
[ fig : lifetimea3 ] .
we conclude that measuring the temperature dependence of the life time of the bright state can be used as a tool to probe the molecular arrangement in brick layer aggregates . | we study the excitonic coupling and homogeneous spectral line width of brick layer j - aggregate films .
we begin by analysing the structural information revealed by the two - exciton states probed in two - dimensional spectra .
our first main result is that the relation between the excitonic couplings and the spectral shift in a two - dimensional structure is different ( larger shift for the same nearest neighbour coupling ) from that in a one - dimensional structure , which leads to an estimation of dipolar coupling in two - dimensional lattices .
we next investigate the mechanisms of homogeneous broadening - population relaxation and pure dephasing - and evaluate their relative importance in linear and two - dimensional aggregates .
our second main result is that pure dephasing dominates the line width in two - dimensional systems up to a crossover temperature , which explains the linear temperature dependence of the homogeneous line width .
this is directly related to the decreased density of states at the band edge when compared with linear aggregates , thus reducing the contribution of population relaxation to dephasing .
pump - probe experiments are suggested to directly measure the lifetime of the bright state and can therefore support the proposed model . |
in the present year 2000 we are celebrating the 100th birthday of quantum theory and the 75th birthday of quantum mechanics .
thus it took only 25 years from the first inception of the new theory until its final consolidation .
quantum field theory is almost as old as quantum mechanics .
but the formulation of a fully consistent synthesis of the principles of quantum theory and classical relativisitic field theory has been a long and agonizing process and , as a matter of fact , has not yet come to a satisfactory end , in spite of many successes . the best approximation to nature in the microscopic and relativistic regime of elementary particle physics which we presently have , the so called _ standard model _
, does not yet have the status of a mathematically consistent theory .
it may be regarded as an efficient algorithm for the theoretical treatment of certain specific problems in high energy physics , such as the perturbative calculation of collision cross sections , the numerical analysis of particle spectra etc .
yet nobody has been able so far to prove or disprove that the model complies with _ all _ fundamental principles of relativistic quantum physics .
this somewhat embarassing situation is not so widely known .
it is therefore gratifying that the clay mathematics institute has recently drawn attention to it by endowing a price of 1.000.000 $ for the mathematical consolidation of an important piece of the standard model , the yang mills theory .
so the mathematical and conceptual problems of relativistic quantum field theory are in many respects a rewarding field of activity for mathematical physicists .
there are two strategies to make further progress .
either one tries to improve the existing mathematical methods for the treatment of models of physical interest .
this is the approach of constructive quantum field theory @xcite . or one proceeds from a sufficiently rigid mathematical framework , consistent with all basic principles of quantum field theory , and aims at new conceptual insights and constructive ideas by structural analysis . such a general framework which is useful for the solution of both , conceptual puzzles and constructive problems , is _ algebraic quantum field theory _
( aqft ) , frequently also called _ local quantum physics_.
it was invented by rudolf haag and daniel kastler @xcite and has proven to be consistent with the developments in elementary particle physics for several decades .
it is the aim of this contribution to recall the physical ideas and mathematical structures underlying aqft and to outline some recent interesting results which reveal its flexibility for the treatment of a variety of problems .
more systematic recent reviews of this approach can be found in @xcite .
the relation between the conventional approach to quantum field theory , based on the lagrangian formalism , and algebraic quantum field theory may be compared with the concrete and abstract approaches to differential geometry .
if one is dealing with concrete ( computational ) problems in geometry , it is natural to use coordinates , tensor fields , christoffel symbols etc , whereas in the general structural analysis one relies on intrinsic concepts such as the notions of manifold , fiber bundle , connection etc .
both points of view have their virtues and full insight is only gained by combining them .
the situation is similar in relativistic quantum field theory . in the concrete lagrangian approach ,
one specifies the field content of the theory acting on the given space
time manifold @xmath0 as well as a corresponding lagrangian .
the difficult step is `` quantization '' which is accomplished either by appealing to the correspondence principle ( canonical quantization ) or to general structural results according to which the problem can be reformulated in terms of classical statistical field theory ( euclidean approach ) . if everything has been said and done , one obtains the vacuum correlation functions of the fields . from them
one can reconstruct a hilbert space on which the observables , such as the stress energy tensor , the currents etc .
act as operators .
the lagrangian approach is well suited for the computational treatment of concrete models , but it is not intrinsic . for different lagrangians with different field content may describe the same physics .
this phenomenon of `` quantum equivalence '' of classical field theories has been observed in many examples @xcite .
one may therefore ask whether there is a more intrinsic way of describing relativistic quantum field theories . a fully satisfactory answer to this question
is provided by aqft . in this approach
the basic objects are the algebras generated by the observables localized in given space
time regions ; fields are not mentioned in this setting and are regarded as a kind of coordinates of the algebras .
the passage from the field theoretic setting to the algebraic one requires the following steps : * determine the set @xmath1 of observables of the underlying theory for each space time point @xmath2 * construct for each relatively compact space
time region @xmath3 a corresponding _ local algebra of observables _ , @xmath4 i.e. the von neumann algebra ( double commutant ) generated by the respective observables in the underlying hilbert space . in view of the fact that the observables @xmath5 are only defined in the sense of sesquilinear forms ( or as operator valued distributions ) , the latter step is somewhat subtle .
but it has been shown to be meaningful in the models which have been constructed so far @xcite and also in the general wightman setting of quantum field theory under some very general conditions @xcite .
the resulting structure is an assignment of algebras to spacetime regions , @xmath6 which is called a _
local net _ in view of its order preserving properties .
any such net inherits some fundamental properties from the underlying field theory .
these are @xcite * locality : operators localized in causally disjoint regions commute * covariance : the space time symmetries act by automorphisms on the net * stability : there exist distinguished states ( expectation functionals ) on the net , describing stable elementary systems such as the vacuum . whereas the first two points are well understood and have an obvious physical interpretation , the mathematical characterization of elementary states on arbitrary space time manifolds is a more difficult issue which is still under discussion , cf .
@xcite and references quoted there . for the class of maximally symmetric spaces
there are no such problems , however . according to the deep insights of haag and kastler , the full physical information of a theory is already contained in the net structure , i.e. the respective map from space time regions to algebras .
phrased differently , equivalent quantum field theories can be identified by the fact that they generate isomorphic local nets .
this assertion may be somewhat surprising at first sight since the passage from the observables , which normally have a specific physical interpretation , to the local algebras seems to be a rather forgetful operation .
that no information is lost in this step has been confirmed by now by numerous results @xcite .
a direct way of seeing this has been established by fredenhagen and hertel @xcite who proved for the class of minkowski space theories that the set of basic observables can be recovered from the local net by the formula @xmath7 the somewhat tricky point in this reconstruction is the need to proceed from the algebras @xmath8 of bounded operators to unbounded sesquilinear forms .
it is accomplished by completing these algebras in a suitable locally convex topology , indicated by the bar
. it should be noted , however , that the algebraic framework is in some respect more flexible than the field theoretic setting . for the local algebras may also accommodate extended objects , such as wilson loops or finite mandelstam strings , which are not built from point like observable fields .
aqft is thus compatible with the structures found in the quantum field theories of present physical interest and complements them by putting emphasis on their intrinsic features .
it may thus be regarded as a minimal setting for the description of the systems appearing in high energy physics .
we discuss in the following some issues where the virtues of this approach become manifest .
guided by insights gained from algebraic quantum field theory , brunetti and fredenhagen @xcite have recently established a perturbative construction of local nets on arbitrary globally hyperbolic space
times @xmath0 .
they propose to treat this problem in two steps : first one constructs the nets of local algebras in some convenient hilbert space representation , thereby fixing the theory .
this step requires control of the notorious ultraviolet divergences ( renormalization ) and can be handled by configuration space methods and microlocal techniques .
infrared problems , related to the so called adiabatic or infinite volume limit , do not appear in this construction . in a second step
one may then turn to the determination of the states of physical interest on this net and to their analysis .
this requires the passage to new hilbert space representations of the algebraic structures and may thus be regarded as a problem in the representation theory of local nets . in minkowski space theories both problems
are frequently treated simultaneously because of the possibility of characterizing the vacuum state directly by momentum space properties ( spectrum condition ) .
but , as indicated above , this strategy does not work for arbitrary space time manifolds .
thus the brunetti
fredenhagen approach is a very natural way of circumventing these difficulties .
following @xcite , we outline this method by discussing the theory of a self - interacting scalar field on a given space - time @xmath0 .
the perturbative construction of the net requires the following steps : * consider the free scalar field @xmath9 on the space time @xmath0 , @xmath10 = -i \ , \delta(x , y ) \ , 1,\ ] ] where @xmath11 denotes the dalembertian and @xmath12 the causal commutator function on @xmath0 , in a regular hilbert space representation induced by some hadamard state @xcite . *
construct _ wick powers _ of the free field for @xmath13 , @xmath14 the existence of these operator valued distributions was first established in @xcite by methods of microlocal analysis and shown in @xcite to be largely independent of the chosen regular hilbert space representation .
these wick powers are the building blocks for the construction of interacting fields .
* define the time ordered exponentials ( local s operators ) @xmath15 where @xmath16 is any test function and @xmath17 is the volume form on @xmath0 .
( more generally , one considers such exponentials for finite sums of wick powers . )
the proof that these exponentials are meaningful expressions is the most difficult step in the construction .
it has been established in @xcite in perturbation theory by defining @xmath18 as formal power series in @xmath16 .
the coefficients in this series suffer from ambiguities due to short distance singularities which require renormalization .
this problem is solved by generalizing methods of epstein and glaser ( causal perturbation theory ) .
if @xmath19 , there does not appear a proliferation of these ambiguities with increasing order of perturbation theory ( renormalizability ) .
* use bogolubov s formula @xmath20 to define , for given interaction density @xmath21 , local operators for the cutoff density @xmath22 . up to this point
the construction is akin to the treatment of minkowski space theories , although the technical details are more involved in view of the absence of space time symmetries . the adiabatic limit of @xmath23 for @xmath24 may not exist , however , due to infrared problems caused by the _ ad hoc _ choice of a defining representation of the interacting theory .
this difficulty can be circumvented by the following important observation @xcite .
let @xmath3 and let @xmath25 .
there exists a unitary operator @xmath26 such that @xmath27 in view of this result it is meaningful to define local algebras , setting for @xmath3 and any @xmath16 with @xmath28 @xmath29 according to the preceding proposition , these algebras are unique up to isomorphisms @xmath30 , which do not change the physical interpretation .
one may thus proceed to an algebraic adiabatic limit by considering the algebras @xmath31 the inclusion ( net ) structure of this family of algebras is given by their natural embeddings and the algebraic operations of addition , multiplication as well as the * operation in @xmath32 are pointwise defined for each @xmath16 . in this way
one arrives at a ( perturbative ) net @xmath33 for the given interaction .
thus the algebraic point of view leads to a natural perturbative construction of nets of local algebras in any space
time @xmath0 .
similar methods have also been applied to the construction of local nets of observables in gauge theories in minkowski space @xcite , cf .
also @xcite and references quoted there .
we turn next to a conceptual problem in minkowski space quantum field theories , namely the asymptotic particle interpretation . in the gauge theories of physical interest , the basic fields are in general unphysical and not related to stable particles .
one has therefore to develop methods to determine the particle features of these theories from the vacuum correlation functions of the local observables .
the confinement problem in quantum chromodynamics and the infraparticle problem in quantum electrodynamics are two well known examples illustrating this issue . here
the algebraic point of view led recently to some interesting progress .
the following steps are necessary in the particle analysis of any theory : * introduce some meaningful particle concept * establish methods to determine the particle content of the theory * analyze the properties of these particles * develop a scattering ( collision ) theory .
one has a quite satisfactory understanding of these points in theories with short range forces ( mass gap ) .
there the natural starting point is wigner s particle concept , according to which the possible states of a particle are described by vectors in some irreducible representation of the poincar group or its two fold covering , respectively .
it is well known , however , that this approach does not work , for example , in theories with electrically charged particles , cf .
for example @xcite .
so it seems desirable to develop a universal particle concept which applies also in those cases .
such a more flexible particle concept was introduced in @xcite .
it is based on the notion of _ particle weight _ which is a generalization of dirac s idea of an improper momentum eigenstate of a particle .
there are two possibilities of looking at these improper states . *
traditional : improper momentum eigenstates are regarded as vector valued distributions , i.e. maps from a space of wave functions into the physical hilbert space , @xmath34 it is anticipated in this approach that the improper states become normalizable by superposition ( interference effects ) .
* alternative : improper states of _ fixed _ momentum are regarded as linear maps from a space @xmath35 of localizing operators into the physical hilbert space , @xmath36 here the improper states become normalizable by localization .
it is important to notice that the second approach is more general than the first one .
it is expected to be applicable even if the superposition principle fails for the improper states .
this happens , for example , if the process of localization is inevitably accompanied by particle production ( such as in quantum electrodynamics , where infinite clouds of soft photons are produced ) . in quantum mechanics , suitable localizing operators
would be rapidly decreasing functions of the position operator ; but the notion of position operator is not meaningful in a field theoretic setting .
nevertheless , localizing operators @xmath37 exist in aqft in abundance and are easily constructed .
simple examples are all operators of the form @xmath38 here @xmath39 is any test function whose fourier transform vanishes in the forward light cone and @xmath40 , where @xmath41 are the unitaries inducing the space time translations @xmath2 and
@xmath42 is any local observable .
the operators @xmath37 can be shown to annihilate all states ( disregarding vectors of arbitrarily small norm ) which do not describe excitations of the vacuum in some ( sufficiently large but finite ) space time region @xmath43 .
so , roughly speaking , they `` project '' onto states which differ from the vacuum in @xmath43 . in this sense
they are localizing operators .
it is technically important that these localizing operators form a left ideal @xmath44 in the c@xmath45algebra @xmath46 generated by all local observables .
it is convenient to proceed from the improper states to corresponding positive , linear and non
normalizable functionals on the domain @xmath47 , @xmath48 called particle weights
. these functionals can be characterized in an intrinsic manner . in particular
they are extremal and invariant under space
time translations .
as @xmath49 is a @xmath50algebra , one can recover by the gns reconstruction theorem the improper particle states from these particle weights . after having introduced in aqft a general particle concept
, one has to develop methods to determine the particle content of a theory ( described by particle weights ) .
this is accomplished by analyzing the timelike asymptotic properties of the physical states in the vacuum sector @xmath51 of the theory .
so let @xmath52 be any expectation functional induced by vectors in the subspace @xmath53 of the physical hilbert space @xmath54 .
one then considers the functionals @xmath55 these expressions are mathematically meaningful as a consequence of locality and the shape of the energy momentum spectrum @xcite .
moreover , the family of functionals @xmath56 is equibounded .
so this family has limit points @xmath57 the functionals @xmath58 are , by their very construction , invariant under translations , but highly mixed .
it is therefore natural to ask whether they can be decomposed into particle weights .
an affirmative answer to this question was recently given by porrmann @xcite .
more specifically , there holds the following statement .
@xmath59 where each @xmath60 is a particle weight of momentum @xmath61 and `` internal index '' @xmath62 and @xmath63 is a measure depending on the initial state @xmath64 .
( the internal index @xmath62 describes the intrinsic features of a particle , such as its charge quantum numbers and spin . )
thus the preceding asymptotic construction and subsequent decomposition of functionals provides a general method to determine the stable particle content of any theory , including the charged particles ( which appear in the vacuum sector only as pairs of opposite charge , but asymptotically give rise to particle weights contributing to the mixtures @xmath58 ) .
this result is a substantial generalization of work of araki and haag for massive theories with a complete particle interpretation @xcite .
no _ a priori _ input about particles is necessary for its derivation ; this shows that the concept of particle weight is sufficient for the description of the asymptotic particle features of any theory .
the next step in the analysis is the determination of the possible properties of particle weights . to this end
one first constructs for each particle weight the corresponding sector of the physical hilbert space , @xmath65 one can then establish the following general results @xcite .
* mass : the energy momentum @xmath61 of the underlying improper state @xmath66 and therefore its mass @xmath67 can be sharply defined in the sector @xmath68 by the formula @xmath69 where @xmath70 is the unitary representation of the translations on @xmath68 ( which can be shown to exist ) . *
spin : if , for given @xmath61 , there is a _
finite _ multiplet of particle weights , there exists a unitary representation @xmath71 of the ( covering group of the ) stability group @xmath72 of @xmath61 such that for @xmath73 @xmath74 where @xmath75 are matrix representations of @xmath72 and @xmath76 .
thus if @xmath77 , the particle weights can have spin @xmath78 , in accordance with the results found by wigner .
however , in contrast to the case of wigner particles , there may appear for particle weights with mass @xmath79 representations with arbitrary helicity .
* coherence : let @xmath80 be the decomposition of @xmath68 with respect to the spatial momentum and consider the restrictions @xmath81 of the generator @xmath82 of the time translations to the respective subspaces . for the point spectrum of these restrictions there appear the possibilities @xmath83 the former case corresponds to the familiar situation of wigner particles , where the improper states @xmath84 are affiliated with the same sector and thus can coherently be superimposed . in the latter case , where @xmath85 has purely continuous spectrum for @xmath86 , the superposition principle fails for particle weights of different momenta .
this situation is expected to prevail in theories with long range forces . in view of the latter result it seems a rewarding experimental challenge to test the status of the superposition principle for electrically charged particle weights .
the theory predicts that there ought to be a substantial difference in the asymptotic coherence properties of electrically neutral and charged particles . in a final step
one has to establish a collision theory for particles described by weights .
in general one may not expect that a scattering matrix exists for these entities , but it is always possible to define and compute collision cross sections .
a general method to this effect has been outlined in @xcite .
we conclude this section with the remark that , in contrast to the case of many particle quantum mechanics , the completeness of the particle interpretation in quantum field theory is still an open problem , even in the case of short range forces .
a survey of the state of the art can be found in @xcite .
triggered by developments in string theory , known under the catchwords of holography or ads / cft correspondence ( cf .
@xcite and references quoted there ) , there has recently emerged interest in the relation between quantum field theories on different space
time manifolds .
one speaks of _ holography _ if there is a correspondence between a quantum field theory on a space
time @xmath87 and a theory on its boundary @xmath88 .
in other words , given the theory on @xmath87 , one can unambiguously determine the theory on @xmath89 and _ vice versa_. a related notion is _ transplantation _
, where such a correspondence exists between theories on space
times @xmath87 , @xmath89 of equal dimension .
in the conventional field theoretic setting a satisfactory understanding of these issues seems impossible .
it is clear from the outset that one can not identify point fields on @xmath87 and @xmath89 in a meaningful way , @xmath90 with regard to holography ,
the best one can do is to proceed from a field theory on @xmath87 by restriction to a corresponding theory on @xmath89 , cf . @xcite .
but it is in general impossible to recover from the latter data the original fields .
similar problems hamper also the idea of transplanting fields .
here the algebraic point of view provides a solution : bearing in mind that a theory is fixed by the underlying net , one realizes that it is sufficient ( and frequently possible ) to identify local algebras for certain sufficiently rich families of regions @xmath91 , @xmath92 , @xmath93 thereby establishing a rigid link between the two theories in question .
this insight was first used by rehren in his analysis of the issue of holography @xcite .
similar ideas were applied to the problem of transplantation in @xcite .
we outline in the following the underlying simple geometrical facts .
holography : + the simplest example , where the idea of holography can be illustrated , is the correspondence between quantum field theories on anti de sitter space ( ads ) and on its minkowskian boundary . in proper coordinates ,
ads can be envisaged as a full cylinder whose tube like boundary is conformal minkowski space . as indicated above
, one has to identify suitable regions in the given space
times in order to establish a correspondence between the respective theories . for the case at hand , rehren proposed to consider a family of causally complete wedge shaped regions @xmath94 . their intersections with the boundary of ads
are diamond shaped regions , @xmath95 , cf .
figure 1 .
it is crucial that with this choice there exists a bijection @xmath96 between these regions which is * causal : @xmath97 , where the prime indicates causal complementation * symmetric : @xmath98 for @xmath99 , where iso and conf indicate the isometry and conformal group of the respective spaces * order preserving : @xmath100 if @xmath101 . after these geometrical preparations it is straightforward to establish the desired correspondence between nets on ads and @xmath102ads as well as the corresponding unitary representations of the respective symmetry groups and the vacuum states , setting * @xmath103 for @xmath104 * @xmath105 * @xmath106 . starting from a local , covariant and stable net on ads one obtains in this way a local , conformally covariant and stable net on minkowski space and _ vice versa _
( by reading the defining relations from right to left ) .
so one arrives at @xcite there is a one to
one correspondence between local , covariant and stable qft s on ads and on @xmath102ads = conformal minkowski space .
it seems plausible that the general idea of holography can also be applied to other space time manifolds with suitable boundaries .
+ transplantation : + the possibility of identifying quantum field theories on space times of equal dimension ( transplantation ) has been exemplified in @xcite for a special class of robertson walker space times ( rw ) . in this approach
one makes use of the fact that these space times can be conformally embedded into de sitter space ( ds ) .
given this embedding , one chooses a certain specific family @xmath107 of diamond shaped regions in ds and , taking the intersection with rw of those regions @xmath108 whose edge lies completely in rw , one obtains a corresponding family of regions @xmath109 in rw , @xmath110 this construction is indicated in figure 2 .
we mention as an aside that the respective regions can also be characterized in an intrinsic coordinate independent manner .
given these regions , there exists a unique bijection @xmath111 : @xmath112 with the property of being * causal : @xmath113 * symmetric : @xmath114 , @xmath115 here @xmath116 denotes the induced action of the elements @xmath16 of the isometry group of de sitter space , iso ds , on the family of regions @xmath109 .
this action can in general not be described by a point transformation on rw .
but if @xmath117 one has @xmath118 . on the basis of these geometrical facts it is straightforward to establish a one to
one correspondence between theories on ds and rw , setting * @xmath119 iff @xmath120 * @xmath121 , @xmath122 an immediate consequence of the geometrical properties of @xmath111 is @xcite each local , covariant _ ds_theory can be mapped to a local , covariant ( ultra symmetric ) _
rw_theory and _ vice versa_. here the term `` ultra symmetric '' means that the resulting rw theory exhibits , besides the familiar space
time isometries , an aditional geometrical symmetry which is _ not _ induced by point transformations .
this situation differs from the ads / cft correspondence , where the minkowskian theory on the boundary of ads is conformally invariant .
an intriguing recent result in algebraic quantum field theory is the insight that local nets can be constructed from a few local algebras in suitable `` relative positions '' @xcite .
it is of interest in this context that the local von neumann algebras are universal ( model independent ) objects : they are generically to the _ unique _ hyperfinite type iii@xmath123 factor @xcite .
so the starting point of this novel construction is a concrete and well studied algebra , denoted by @xmath0 in the following ; the second ingredient is a standard ( cyclic and separating ) vector @xmath124 for @xmath0 in the underlying hilbert space .
given these quantities , one can consistently define a conjugation @xmath125 it is an anti linear closable operator whose closure is denoted by the same symbol and whose polar decomposition has the form @xmath126 here @xmath127 is an anti unitary operator , called _ modular conjugation _ , and the positive selfadjoint operator @xmath128 is the _ modular operator_. the corresponding unitary group @xmath129 is called _
modular group_. irrespective of the choice of @xmath0 and @xmath124 within the above limitations , there hold the following basic relations established by tomita and takesaki : * @xmath130 * @xmath131 based on these facts , wiesbrock introduced in @xcite the notion of _ half sided modular inclusion _ of a von neumann algebra @xmath132 , where @xmath133 likewise has @xmath124 as standard vector , by posing the condition @xmath134 the unitary group @xmath135 , obtained by the trotter product formula @xmath136 then has the following properties @xcite .
let @xmath132 be a half sided modular inclusion .
the corresponding modular groups generate a unitary representation of @xmath137 such that * @xmath138 * @xmath139 * the spectrum of the generator of @xmath135 is contained in @xmath140 * @xmath141 .
an analogous result holds if @xmath140 is replaced by @xmath142 in @xmath143 .
another useful concept , characterizing the relative position of von neumann algebras , is the notion of _ modular intersection _ @xcite : two von neumann algebras @xmath0 , @xmath133 are said to have modular intersection if @xmath144 is half sided modular in @xmath0 and @xmath133 , respectively .
similarly to the situation discussed in the preceding proposition , the modular groups can be shown to generate a unitary representations of a lie group in the latter case as well .
these general mathematical facts have immediate applications in algebraic quantum field theory .
local nets on @xmath145 @xcite + any modular inclusion fixes a local , covariant and stable net of local algebras on the light ray @xmath145 .
one first assigns algebras to half lines , setting @xmath146 the algebras corresponding to arbitrary intervals @xmath147 \subset \rr$ ] are given by @xmath148 it then follows from the preceding proposition and the basic relations of tomita takesaki theory that the net @xmath149 on @xmath145 is local ( operators localized in disjoint intervals commute ) , @xmath150covariant and stable ( @xmath124 being a ground state for @xmath135 ) .
thus , given two algebras in suitable relative position , one can construct a full chiral quantum field theory .
( in a similar way one sees that any modular intersection fixes a conformally invariant quantum field theory on the compactified light ray s@xmath151 . )
local nets on @xmath152 @xcite + in order to obtain in a similar manner local nets on higher dimensional space times , one has to proceed from a larger set of algebras in appropriate relative positions . in the case of two dimensional minkowski space , one starts from three algebras , forming two half sided modular inclusions @xmath153 . by the preceding proposition one
then has two unitary groups @xmath154 , where @xmath155 are interpreted as light cone coordinates of @xmath156 .
these groups are assumed to commute , @xmath157 in this way one obtains a unitary positive energy representation @xmath135 of the translations @xmath152 on which the modular group of @xmath0 acts like a lorentz transformation , @xmath158 one then can proceed as in the preceding case and define algebras for wedge shaped regions of the form @xmath159 , setting @xmath160 the algebras associated with diamonds @xmath161 , cf .
figure 3 , are obtained by setting @xmath162 in this way one arrives at a local , poincar covariant net on @xmath152 where @xmath124 describes the vacuum vector .
local nets on @xmath163 , @xmath164 @xcite + the construction of local nets from a few algebras was recently extended to three and four dimensional minkowski space in @xcite .
the crucial and difficult step in this approach is the formulation of conditions which guarantee that the modular groups affiliated with the algebras and the underlying vector @xmath124 generate representations of the poincar group @xmath165 .
any family of algebras @xmath166 in suitable modular positions fixes a local , @xmath165covariant net on @xmath163 with vacuum state @xmath124 .
we refrain from giving here the precise conditions on the algebras and only note that , in analogy to the cases discussed before , the corresponding modular groups generate representation of @xmath165 with positive energy .
the algebras @xmath167 can consistently be assigned to wedge regions in @xmath163 and the local algebras associated with diamonds are defined by taking intersections .
the converse of this statement is a well known theorem by bisognano and wichmann @xcite , cf .
also @xcite .
these intriguing results should admit a generalization to other space time manifolds , cf .
also @xcite for a related approach .
moreover , they seem to be of relevance for the classification of local nets and are possibly a step towards a novel , completely algebraic approach to the construction of local nets .
the preceding account of recent results in aqft illustrates the role of this approach in relativistic quantum field theory : it is a concise framework which is suitable for the development of new constructive schemes , the mathematical implementation of physical concepts and ideas , the elaboration of general computational methods and the clarification of the relation between different theories as well as their structural analysis and classification .
so this framework complements the more concrete approaches to relativistic quantum field theory and thereby contributes to the understanding and mathematical consolidation of this important area of mathematical physics .
99 a. jaffe , constructive quantum field theory , p. 111 in : _ mathematical physics 2000
_ , a. fokas et al .
eds . , imperial college press 2000 r. haag and d. kastler , ( 1964 ) 848 d. buchholz and r. haag , ( 2000 ) 3674 d. buchholz , current trends in axiomatic field theory , preprint hep - th/9811233 s. coleman , phys .
* d11 * ( 1975 ) 2088 m. lscher , nucl .
* b326 * ( 1989 ) 557 k. intriligator and n. seiberg , nucl .
b , proc .
* 45bc * ( 1996 ) 1 w. driessler and j. frhlich , ann .
henri poincar * 27 * ( 1977 ) 221 h .- j .
borchers and j. yngvason , ( 1992 ) 15 r. haag , _ local quantum physics _ ,
2nd revised ed . , springer ( 1996 ) r.m .
wald , _ quantum field theory in curved spacetime and black hole thermodynamics _
, chicago university press 1994 r. brunetti , k. fredenhagen and m. khler , ( 1996 ) 633 d. buchholz , o. dreyer , m. florig and s.j .
summers , ( 2000 ) 475 c.j .
fewster , class . quantum grav .
* 17 * ( 2000 ) 1897 h. sahlmann and r. verch , preprint math - ph/0002021 k. fredenhagen and j. hertel , ( 1981 ) 555 r. brunetti and k. fredenhagen , ( 2000 ) 623 m. dtsch and k. fredenhagen , ( 1999 ) 71 g. scharf , _ finite quantum electrodynamics : the causal approach _ , 2nd ed .
, springer 1995 d. buchholz , phys .
lett . * b174 * ( 1986 ) 331 d. buchholz , m. porrmann and u. stein , phys .
* b267 * ( 1991 ) 377 d. buchholz , on the manifestations of particles , p. 177
in : _ mathematical physics towards the 21st century _ , r.n .
sen and a. gersten eds . , ben
gurion university of the negev press 1994 d. buchholz , ( 1990 ) 631 m. porrmann , the concept of particle weights in local quantum field theory , phd thesis , universitt gttingen 2000 h. araki and r. haag , ( 1967 ) 77 d. buchholz and m. porrmann , ann .
henri poincar * 52 * ( 1990 ) 237 d. iagolnitzer , _ scattering in quantum field theories : the axiomatic and constructive approaches _ , princeton university press 1993 e. witten , adv .
* 2 * ( 1998 ) 253 m. bertola , j. bros , u. moschella and r. schaeffer , ads / cft correspondence for n point functions , preprint hep - th/9908140 k .- h .
rehren , ann .
henri poincar * 1 * ( 2000 ) 607 d. buchholz , j. mund and s.j .
summers , transplantation of local nets and geometric modular action on robertson walker space times , preprint hep - th/0011237 h.w .
wiesbrock , ( 1993 ) 83 ; erratum : ( 1997 ) 683 h.w .
wiesbrock , ( 1997 ) 203 h.w .
wiesbrock , ( 1998 ) 269 r. khler and h.w .
wiesbrock , modular theory and the reconstruction of four dimensional quantum field theories , preprint , to appear in d. buchholz , c. dantoni and k. fredenhagen , ( 1987 ) 123 j.j .
bisognano and e.h .
wichmann , ( 1975 ) 985 ; ( 1976 ) 303 h.j .
borchers , ( 2000 ) 3604 | algebraic quantum field theory is an approach to relativistic quantum physics , notably the theory of elementary particles , which complements other modern developments in this field .
it is particularly powerful for structural analysis but has also proven to be useful in the rigorous treatment of models . in this contribution a non technical survey is given with emphasis on interesting recent developments and future perspectives .
topics covered are the relation between the algebraic approach and conventional quantum field theory , its significance for the resolution of conceptual problems ( such as the revision of the particle concept ) and its role in the characterization and possibly also construction of quantum field theories with the help of modular theory .
the algebraic approach has also shed new light on the treatment of quantum field theories on curved spacetime and made contact with recent developments in string theory ( algebraic holography ) . |
the enhancement of _ photoacoustic tomography _ ( pat ) by taking dissipation into account is currently a very active subfield of pat with various contributions from engineers , mathematicians and physicists . for basic facts on pat in the absence and presence of dissipation ,
we refer for example to @xcite and @xcite , respectively .
there are several strategies for solving this class of problem .
firstly , _ regularization methods _ focus on a rigorous mathematical analysis and numerical solution of the inverse problem bearing its degree of ill - posedness in mind .
due to its mathematical character , this aspect of pat is usually carried out by mathematicians .
this work does not deal with this aspect of pat .
secondly , exact and approximate reconstruction formulas and time reversal methods are developed and investigated by engineers , mathematicians and physicists .
it is beneficial that these methods furnish physical insights of the considered inverse problem .
this paper focuses on physical and arithmetical aspects of time reversal of dissipative pressure waves satisfying the _ wave equation of nachman , smith and waag _
@xcite ) endowed with the respective source term of pat .
this equation has the advantage that it is more accurate than the _ thermo - viscous _ wave equation and permits the modeling of several relaxation processes .
recently , a _ small frequency approximation _ of a time reversal functional for pat based on the _ thermo - viscous wave equation _ were proposed and investigated in @xcite .
subsequently , motivated by the work @xcite , a _ small frequency approximation _ of a time reversal functional that is based on the _ wave equation of nachman , smith and waag _ was derived in @xcite .
the goal of the following paper is to derive and investigate an _ exact time reversal formula _ as well as its _ small wave number approximation_. in contrast to @xcite , we carry out our investigation in the _ wave vector - time domain _ , which permits a more detailed analysis . for simplicity ,
we concentrate on the case of one relaxation process . in order to explain the results of this paper in more details , we start with the wave equation model which reads for one relaxation process as follows ( cf . page 113 in @xcite ) @xmath12 where @xmath0 and @xmath13 correspond to the _ initial pressure function _ and the _ relaxation time _ , respectively . if @xmath14 , @xmath15 and @xmath3 denote the _ speed of sound _
, the _ density _ and the _ compressibility _ of the medium , respectively , then @xmath16 as shown in @xcite , @xmath17 is required to guarantee a finite wave front speed @xmath18
. then @xmath19 holds . the direct problem associated to this equation
consists in calculating the pressure function @xmath20 for given initial pressure data @xmath0 .
now to the inverse pat problem . the pat problem considered in this paper
consists in the estimation of the initial pressure function @xmath0 from pressure data @xmath20 measured at a boundary @xmath21 that satisfies wave equation ( [ weqnsw ] ) .
here it is tacitly assumed that @xmath0 vanishes outside @xmath22 and @xmath23 is a sufficiently large time period such that every @xmath24 satisfies @xmath25 .
the algorithm of our time reversal method can be described as follows : first calculate the function @xmath26 from the boundary data on @xmath21 and the pressure data inside @xmath22 at time @xmath27 .
the latter data are negligible for sufficiently large @xmath27 .
secondly , solve the time reversed wave equation @xmath28 on @xmath29 $ ] with the help of the calculated function @xmath30 .
finally , define the _ time reversal imaging functional _ by occurs in the functional , because due to the source term in ( [ trweqnsw ] ) only half of the energy of the original pressure wave propagates inside @xmath22 .
the other half propagates outside @xmath22 . ]
@xmath31 : = 2\,q|_{t = t } \,.\ ] ] in this paper we derive from the exact representation of @xmath1 that @xmath32 this result justifies our time reversal method .
we emphasize that @xmath6 can not hold for dissipative media ( @xmath33 ) .
moreover , we show for tissue similar to water that the _ small wave number approximation _ @xmath7 of the imaging functional satisfies @xmath34 where @xmath35 for @xmath5 . here
@xmath36 denotes the _ fourier transform _ of @xmath37 with respect to @xmath38 and @xmath39 denotes the _ space convolution_. in addition , our analysis and simulations indicate that a resolution of @xmath11 is feasible ( in the noise - free case ) .
we note that the theoretical results of this paper are valied for any space dimension @xmath40 . +
this paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec - opeq ]
we derive an exact representation of @xmath1 and discuss the limit @xmath41 for vanishing compressibility .
the small wave number representation of @xmath1 is derived and discussed in the subsequent section . for a better understanding of the results
, we have visualized many of our results ( like eigenvalues , coefficients and so on ) with matlab . moreover , for the convenience of the reader , we have listed the solution of the dissipative wave equation and its time reversal in the appendix .
finally , the paper is concluded with the section conclusions .
first we derive an exact representation of the time reversal image @xmath1 defined by ( [ defimagf ] ) . throughout this paper
we denote by @xmath42 the wave number corresponding to the wave vector @xmath43 .
let @xmath44 be the solutions of the wave equation ( [ weqnsw ] ) and its time reverse ( [ trweqnsw ] ) at time @xmath45 , respectively , derived in the appendix .
the representations for @xmath46 and @xmath47 for @xmath48 are listed in the appendix and visualized in fig .
[ fig : a ] and fig . [ fig:01 ] . in this paper
we focus on tissue similar to water for which @xmath49 is real - valued and @xmath50 with real - valued @xmath51 and @xmath52 listed in the appendix ( cf . fig .
[ fig:01 ] ) . and @xmath53 ( @xmath54 ) for @xmath55 $ ] .
we see that @xmath56 and @xmath57 .
the lower row visualizes @xmath58 , @xmath59 and @xmath60 for @xmath61 $ ] .
we see that @xmath62 and each @xmath63 has the same growth behavior as in ( [ o2]).,title="fig:",height=188 ] and @xmath53 ( @xmath54 ) for @xmath55 $ ] .
we see that @xmath56 and @xmath57 .
the lower row visualizes @xmath58 , @xmath59 and @xmath60 for @xmath61 $ ] .
we see that @xmath62 and each @xmath63 has the same growth behavior as in ( [ o2]).,title="fig:",height=188 ] + and @xmath53 ( @xmath54 ) for @xmath55 $ ] .
we see that @xmath56 and @xmath57 .
the lower row visualizes @xmath58 , @xmath59 and @xmath60 for @xmath61 $ ] .
we see that @xmath62 and each @xmath63 has the same growth behavior as in ( [ o2]).,title="fig:",height=188 ] and @xmath53 ( @xmath54 ) for @xmath55 $ ] .
we see that @xmath56 and @xmath57 .
the lower row visualizes @xmath58 , @xmath59 and @xmath60 for @xmath61 $ ] .
we see that @xmath62 and each @xmath63 has the same growth behavior as in ( [ o2]).,title="fig:",height=188 ] employing these representations and @xmath64 for @xmath65 to ( [ defimagf ] ) results in @xmath66\,\hat\varphi\,.\ ] ] because @xmath67 , @xmath68 and @xmath69 ( cf . appendix ) , it follows with @xmath70 and @xmath71 that @xmath72 with _ real - valued _
functions @xmath73 and @xmath74 \ , . \end{aligned}\ ] ] for the last identity we used @xmath75 applying the inverse fourier transform and the convolution theorem ( cf .
appendix ) to the image @xmath1 yields @xmath76 where @xmath39 denotes the convolution with respect to the space variable @xmath77 . for @xmath48 .
we see that @xmath78 and @xmath79 are highly oscillating and that each @xmath80 has the growth behavior as in ( [ o3 ] ) .
although @xmath81 is bounded , it is of order @xmath82 , i.e. matlab can not calculate @xmath83 and thus @xmath84 was plotted instead of @xmath79.,title="fig:",height=188 ] for @xmath48 .
we see that @xmath78 and @xmath79 are highly oscillating and that each @xmath80 has the growth behavior as in ( [ o3 ] ) .
although @xmath81 is bounded , it is of order @xmath82 , i.e. matlab can not calculate @xmath83 and thus @xmath84 was plotted instead of @xmath79.,title="fig:",height=188 ] from the representations of @xmath47 and @xmath46 for @xmath48 in the appendix , it follows that ( cf . fig . [ fig:01 ] ) @xmath85 and ( cf .
[ fig : a ] ) @xmath86 in this paper we focus on tissue similar to water for which @xmath87 is real - valued , is complex - valued for large @xmath88 and thus @xmath89 is exponentially increasing , which implies a stronger restriction on @xmath0 . ]
i.e. @xmath89 is bounded and thus @xmath90 is bounded , too . from ( [ zeta12 ] ) , ( [ zeta3 ] ) with the boundedness of @xmath81 , ( [ o1 ] ) and ( [ o2 ] ) , it follows for each @xmath91 that ( cf . fig .
[ fig : zeta ] ) @xmath92 the previous asymptotic relations show that time reversal can be applied successfully if the initial pressure function @xmath0 is a _
quadratic integrable _ function , because @xmath93 holds with @xmath94}(|\zeta_1(k)|^2,\,|\zeta_2(k)|^2,\,|\zeta_3(k)|^2)<\infty \,,\ ] ] where @xmath95 .
that is to say , the time reversal image @xmath1 exists and is _ quadratic integrable _ if @xmath0 is _
quadratic integrable_. we would like to make a short remark about the numerical problem of calculating @xmath97 as the inverse fourier transform of @xmath79 .
although @xmath81 is bounded , it is of order @xmath82 in the small wave number region and thus the term @xmath83 in the representation of @xmath79 can not be calculate by matlab .
in addition , @xmath79 is highly oscillatory .
all in all , @xmath96 can not be calculated numerically in the form ( [ zeta3 ] ) .
however , it will be shown in section [ sec - small ] below that @xmath97 is negligible small under appropriate conditions .
it is noteworthy that this can be explained due to wave propagation .
now we show that @xmath1 is a good approximation of @xmath0 if the compressibility @xmath3 is sufficiently small .
more precisely , we show @xmath98 from ( [ deftau0 ] ) we conclude @xmath99 and @xmath100 and thus wave equation ( [ weqnsw ] ) becomes for @xmath5 @xmath101 we see that @xmath5 leads to the dissipation free case . because @xmath102 depends continuously on @xmath103 , @xmath2 and @xmath104 , it remains to show that @xmath105 for @xmath106 . for @xmath106 , the characteristic equation ( [ eqlambda ] ) in the appendix simplifies to @xmath107 which has the solutions @xmath108 moreover , the expressions for @xmath46 listed in the appendix simplify to @xmath109 employing these results to ( [ zeta12 ] ) and ( [ zeta3 ] ) yields @xmath110 and therefore @xmath111 in theorem 3 in @xcite , it is shown that @xmath112 if @xmath27 is sufficiently large and consequently the claim @xmath113 for @xmath5 follows . here
@xmath114 denotes the inverse fourier transform .
it is best to discuss ( [ propdelta ] ) via the equivalent relation @xmath115({\mathbf{x}},t ) = \frac{\delta({\mathbf{x}})}{2 } \qquad\mbox{on $ \omega$ for sufficiently large $ t$. } \ ] ] here @xmath116 is defined by @xmath117 denotes the solution of the _ standard wave equation _ with source term @xmath118 which vanishes at time @xmath45 everywhere except at @xmath119 . hence @xmath120_{t
= t}$ ] corresponds to a wave at time @xmath45 initiated by the source term @xmath121 which vanishes everywhere except at those @xmath38 satisfying @xmath122 in words , one half of the wave initiated at the sphere @xmath119 propagates into the sphere and arrives in @xmath123 at time @xmath27 and the other half propagates outward the sphere and arrives in @xmath124 at time @xmath27 .
if we focus only on space points in @xmath22 which do not contain the points @xmath77 with @xmath124 , then the above identity follows .
if the period @xmath27 during which the pressure data are acquired is sufficiently large , then this assumption is always satiesfied .
because ( [ propdelta ] ) for @xmath125 instead of @xmath27 is required later , we have assumed at the beginning of this paper that @xmath27 is so large that @xmath126 holds .
for theoretical considerations and numerical simulations , it is desirable to have a small wave number approximation of the time reversal imaging function @xmath1 . in the following
we derive such an approximation of @xmath1 and discuss its properties . motivated by the thermo - viscous case , we consider @xmath127 as the threshold between small and large wave numbers . from the representations of @xmath47 for @xmath48 in the appendix
, it follows for @xmath128 that ( cf . fig . [ fig:01 ] )
@xmath129 @xmath130 , @xmath131 , @xmath87 and @xmath132 for @xmath55 $ ] .
@xmath133 and @xmath134 are the small wave number approximations of @xmath131 and @xmath87 .
the lower row visualizes @xmath135 , @xmath131 , @xmath87 and @xmath132 for @xmath136 $ ] .
we see that @xmath137 , @xmath138 and @xmath139 for @xmath140 which agrees with ( [ limmu]).,title="fig:",height=192 ] , @xmath131 , @xmath87 and @xmath132 for @xmath55 $ ] .
@xmath133 and @xmath134 are the small wave number approximations of @xmath131 and @xmath87 .
the lower row visualizes @xmath135 , @xmath131 , @xmath87 and @xmath132 for @xmath136 $ ] .
we see that @xmath137 , @xmath138 and @xmath139 for @xmath140 which agrees with ( [ limmu]).,title="fig:",height=192 ] + , @xmath131 , @xmath87 and @xmath132 for @xmath55 $ ] .
@xmath133 and @xmath134 are the small wave number approximations of @xmath131 and @xmath87 .
the lower row visualizes @xmath135 , @xmath131 , @xmath87 and @xmath132 for @xmath136 $ ] .
we see that @xmath137 , @xmath138 and @xmath139 for @xmath140 which agrees with ( [ limmu]).,title="fig:",height=192 ] , @xmath131 , @xmath87 and @xmath132 for @xmath55 $ ] .
@xmath133 and @xmath134 are the small wave number approximations of @xmath131 and @xmath87 .
the lower row visualizes @xmath135 , @xmath131 , @xmath87 and @xmath132 for @xmath136 $ ] .
we see that @xmath137 , @xmath138 and @xmath139 for @xmath140 which agrees with ( [ limmu]).,title="fig:",height=192 ] this , the convolution theorem ( cf .
appendix ) and the identity ( [ propdelta ] ) imply @xmath141 if @xmath27 is sufficiently large .
hence @xmath142 because @xmath143 is very large , we have @xmath144 and thus @xmath145 with @xmath146 for the following argumentation , it is required that @xmath147 such that ( [ propdelta ] ) holds for @xmath148 replacing @xmath0 .
the crucial point will be that the inverse fourier transform of the previous sinus and cosinus functions are non - dissipative waves , only their coefficients depend on dissipation . * from @xmath149 , @xmath150 and
identity ( [ propdelta ] ) , we get @xmath151 on @xmath152 and for sufficiently large @xmath27 .
hence the term with @xmath153 in @xmath79 can be neglected . * because of @xmath154 it follows similarly as in item 1 ) that @xmath155 on @xmath152 and for sufficiently large @xmath27 .
therefore @xmath79 can be neglected . in summary , we get under the assumption ( [ ass ] ) the _ small wave number approximation _
@xmath156 let ( [ ass ] ) be satisfied and @xmath157 because @xmath158 is nothing else but the solution of the _ standard wave equation _ with source term @xmath159 , it follows that @xmath160 in words , the waves within @xmath22 propagated out of @xmath22 and , due to our assumption , no wave propagated into @xmath22 .
hence the term @xmath158 vanishes .
similarly , one shows that @xmath161 is the derivative with respect to @xmath27 of a function vanishing inside of @xmath22 and consequently @xmath97 is negligible on @xmath22 .
the parameter values for tissue similar to water at normal temperatur are ( cf .
@xcite ) @xmath162 for which @xmath163 follows . as time period
, we have chosen the value @xmath164 with @xmath165 .
we assume that @xmath166 such that the small wave number approximation is applicable for @xmath43 with @xmath167 . for this range of @xmath168
, it follows that @xmath169 with @xmath170 hence we arrive at @xmath171 we note that @xmath172 for @xmath41 , i.e. @xmath173 holds in the dissipation - free case . +
a simple example satisfying our assumptions is given by @xmath174 here @xmath175 is a constant and @xmath176 is the variance of @xmath0 .
this indicates that a resolution of @xmath177 is possible ( in the noise - free case ) .
in this paper we have proposed a time reversal functional @xmath1 for solving pat of a dissipative medium that obeys the causal wave equation of nachman , smith and waag .
this model is appropriate for tissue that is similar to water .
our theoretical and numerical investigations have shown that * the time reversal image @xmath1 for the considered dissipative medium does not give the exact initial pressure function @xmath0 , * however , if the compressibility @xmath3 tends to zero , then @xmath113 holds .
* moreover , for appropriate conditions , we have @xmath178 and a resolution of @xmath11 is feasible ( in the noise - free case ) .
all in all , it follows that ( regularized ) time reversal is a valuable solution method for pat of dissipative tissue similar to water .
for the convenience of the reader we list the representations of the solutions @xmath20 and @xmath179 of the dissipative wave equation ( [ weqnsw ] ) and its time reverse ( [ trweqnsw ] ) , respectively , in this appendix .
we use the following definition of the _ fourier transform _
@xmath180 such that the _ convolution theorem _ reads as follows @xmath181 by @xmath88 we denote the the wave number of the wave vector @xmath43 , i.e. @xmath42 . fourier transformation of the wave equation ( [ weqnsw ] ) with respect to @xmath77 and solving the _ helmholtz equation _ @xmath182 yields @xmath183 with @xmath184 where @xmath47 and @xmath46 for @xmath48 are the solutions of @xmath185 and @xmath186 with @xmath187 the respective _ cardano s formula _ read as follows @xmath188 with @xmath189 @xmath190 and @xmath191{\frac{\delta_1 + \sqrt{\delta_1 ^ 2 - 4\,\delta_0 ^ 3}}{2}}\,.\ ] ] .
we see that @xmath192 is real - valued for @xmath193 but complex - valued for @xmath194 . in this paper
we focus on tissue similar to water , i.e. @xmath195.,title="fig:",height=188 ] .
we see that @xmath192 is real - valued for @xmath193 but complex - valued for @xmath194 . in this paper
we focus on tissue similar to water , i.e. @xmath195.,title="fig:",height=188 ] from the above _ cardano s formula _ , we get @xmath196 with @xmath197 for real - valued @xmath192
, it follows that @xmath135 , @xmath131 and @xmath87 are real - valued . for tissue
similar to water , we have @xmath195 and thus @xmath192 is positive and real - valued ( cf . fig .
[ fig : cs ] ) .
moreover , it can be shown that @xmath198 if @xmath192 is real - valued , then it follows from @xmath67 that @xmath199 is real - valued and @xmath68 ( cf .
fig [ fig : a ] ) , which permits to simplify the representation of the time reversal image @xmath1 in section [ sec - opeq ] .
finally , it can be shown that @xmath200 and thus @xmath201 the functions @xmath135 , @xmath131 , @xmath87 and @xmath132 for the parameter values as in ( [ parvalues ] ) are visualized in fig .
[ fig:01 ] . for these values
, we have @xmath202 and @xmath203 ( cf . fig . [ fig:01 ] ) .
similarly as above , it follows for nice @xmath30 that the solution of the time reversed wave equation ( [ trweqnsw ] ) is given by @xmath204 with @xmath205 here @xmath47 and @xmath46 for @xmath48 are defined as above .
p. burgholzer and h. grn and m. haltmeier and r. nuster and g. paltauf : compensation of acoustic attenuation for high - resolution photoacoustic imaging with line detectors . in a.a .
oraevsky and l.v .
wang , editors , _ photons plus ultrasound : imaging and sensing 2007 : the eighth conference on biomedical thermoacoustics , optoacoustics , and acousto - optics _ ,
volume 6437 of _ proceedings of spie _ , page 643724 .
spie , 2007 .
hristova , y. and kuchment , p. and nguyen , l. : reconstruction and time reversal in thermoacoustic tomography in acoustically homogeneous and inhomogeneous media .
_ inverse problems _ ,
24(5):055006 ( 25pp ) , 2008 .
kowar , r. and scherzer , o. : attenuation models in photoacoustics . in _ mathematical modeling in biomedical imaging ii : _ lecture notes in mathematics 2035 , doi 10.1007/978 - 3 - 642 - 22990 - 9_4 , springer - verlag 2012 . | the goal of _ photoacoustic tomography _ ( pat ) is to estimate an _ initial pressure function _ @xmath0 from pressure data measured at a boundary surrounding the object of interest .
this paper is concerned with a time reversal method for pat that is based on the dissipative wave equation of nachman , smith and waag @xcite .
this equation has the advantage that it is more accurate than the _ thermo - viscous _ wave equation . for simplicity , we focus on the case of one _ relaxation process_. we derive an exact formula for the _ time reversal image _ @xmath1 , which depends on the _ relaxation time _ @xmath2 and the _ compressibility _ @xmath3 of the dissipative medium , and show @xmath4 for @xmath5 .
this implies that @xmath6 holds in the dissipation - free case and that @xmath1 is similar to @xmath0 for sufficiently small compressibility @xmath3 .
moreover , we show for tissue similar to water that the _ small wave number approximation
_ @xmath7 of the time reversal image satisfies @xmath8 with @xmath9 for @xmath10 . for such tissue ,
our theoretical analysis and numerical simulations show that the time reversal image @xmath1 is very similar to the initial pressure function @xmath0 and that a resolution of @xmath11 is feasible ( in the noise - free case ) . |
the periodically forced sir model @xmath2 @xmath3 @xmath4 and variants of it , are extensively used to model seasonally recurrent diseases @xcite . here
@xmath5 are the fractions of the population which are susceptible , infective , and recovered , @xmath6 denotes the birth and death rate , @xmath7 the recovery rate , and @xmath8 , which we assume is a positive continuous @xmath0-periodic function , is the seasonally - dependent transmission rate ( so that @xmath0 is the yearly period ) . when simulating this model numerically ( see section [ numerical ] ) , it is observed that : \(i ) if @xmath9 , where @xmath10 @xmath11 then all solutions tend to the disease free equilibrium @xmath12
this fact can be rigorously proved , see @xcite .
\(ii ) if @xmath13 , then depending on the values of the parameters , one observes convergence to @xmath0-periodic orbits , or to @xmath14-periodic orbits with @xmath15 ( subharmonics ) , or chaotic behavior .
a fundamental question , that is addressed here , is the _ existence _ of a @xmath0-periodic solution of the system .
we demand , of course that the components @xmath16 of this solution will be positive .
obviously when @xmath9 , a positive periodic solution can not exist , because such a solution would not converge to the disease - free equilibrium .
we will prove , however , that [ main ] whenever @xmath1 , there exists at least one @xmath0-periodic solution @xmath17 of ( [ s])-([r ] ) , all of whose components are positive . thus , when @xmath0-periodic behavior is not observed in simulations , this is not due to the fact that such a solution does not exist , but rather to the fact that all @xmath0-period solutions are unstable . despite the fact that the existence of a @xmath0-periodic solution of the @xmath0-periodically forced sir model is a fundamental issue , the only paper in the literature of which we are aware to have dealt with this question is the recent paper of jdar , villanueva and arenas @xcite .
they treated a more general system then we do here ( including loss of immunity and allowing other coefficients besides @xmath8 to be @xmath0-periodic ) . restricting their existence result to the case of the sir model ( [ s])-([r ] )
, they proved , using mawhin s continuation theorem , that a @xmath0-periodic solution exists whenever the condition @xmath18 holds .
note that the condition ( [ jodar ] ) implies that @xmath19 , that is @xmath1 , but it is a stronger condition .
theorem [ main ] uses only the condition @xmath1 , so that together with the fact noted above , that when @xmath9 a @xmath0-periodic solution does _ not _ exist , we have that @xmath1 is a _ necessary and sufficient _
condition for the existence of a @xmath0-periodic solution with positive components .
our technique for proving theorem [ main ] relies on nonlinear functional analysis , for which we refer to the textbooks @xcite . reformulating the problem as one of solving an equation in an infinite dimensional space of periodic functions ,
we define a homotopy between the periodically forced problem and the autonomous problem in which @xmath8 is replaced by the mean @xmath20 .
the autonomous problem has an endemic equilibrium , which is a trivial periodic solution .
we then employ leray - schauder degree theory to continue this solution along the homotopy .
the challenge here lies in the fact that there we always have a trivial periodic solution , given by the disease - free equilibrium , which lies on the boundary of the relevant domain @xmath21 in the functional space , which requires us to construct a smaller domain @xmath22 excluding the trivial solution , and to show that the conditions for applying the leray - schauder theory hold for the domain @xmath23 .
we note that our proof of theorem [ main ] is easily extended to give the same result for the sirs model , which includes loss of immunity @xmath24 @xmath25 @xmath26 we present the proof for the sir model ( @xmath27 ) in order to avoid notational clutter . in section [ proof ]
we prove theorem [ main ] . in section
[ numerical ] we discuss how to obtain the @xmath0-periodic solution numerically , which can not be done by direct numerical simulation when it is unstable , and present some results obtained by using the galerkin method .
finally , in section [ discussion ] we mention some other works providing rigorous mathematical results on forced sir models , beyond numerical simulation .
since @xmath16 are fractions of the population we have @xmath28 for all @xmath29 - note that by adding the equations ( [ s])-([r ] ) we have @xmath30 .
since @xmath31 does not appear in ( [ s]),([i ] ) , the equation ( [ r ] ) can be ignored , and it suffices to proved the existence of a periodic solution of ( [ s]),([i ] ) satisfying @xmath32 where the third condition is equivalent to @xmath33 .
we decompose @xmath8 as @xmath34 setting , for @xmath35 $ ] , @xmath36 we consider the system @xmath37 @xmath38 which is homotopy between an unforced system with @xmath39 and our system ( [ s]),([i ] ) , which corresponds to @xmath40 . for @xmath41 , ( [ s1]),([i1 ] )
has exactly two periodic solutions , which are constant , given by @xmath42 @xmath43 we note that @xmath44 ( the disease - free equilibrium ) is in fact a ( trivial ) periodic solution of ( [ s1])-([i1 ] ) for _ all _ @xmath45 . our aim is to continue the solution @xmath46 with respect to @xmath45 in order to prove the existence of a periodic solution for @xmath40 .
to this end , we now reformulate the problem in a functional - analytic setting , which will enable us to employ degree theory .
we rewrite ( [ s1]),([i1 ] ) as @xmath47 @xmath48 let @xmath49 be the banach spaces @xmath50 @xmath51 define the linear operator @xmath52 by @xmath53 and the nonlinear operator @xmath54 @xmath55 then the periodic problem for ( [ s2])-([i2 ] ) can be rewritten as @xmath56 it is easy to check that @xmath57 is invertible , that is the equations @xmath58 and @xmath59 have unique @xmath60 @xmath0-periodic solutions @xmath61 for any @xmath62 , and the mapping @xmath63 given by @xmath64 is bounded .
we can thus rewrite ( [ re ] ) as @xmath65 where @xmath66 is given by @xmath67 since @xmath63 is bounded , and since , by the arzela - ascoli theorem , @xmath68 is compactly embedded in @xmath69 , we can consider @xmath70 as a compact operator from @xmath69 to itself , and since @xmath54 is continuous , @xmath71 is compact as an operator from @xmath69 to itself .
we therefore consider ( [ re1 ] ) in the space @xmath69 , and we note that any solution in @xmath69 will in fact be in @xmath68 , hence a classical solution of ( [ s2]),([i2 ] ) . since @xmath72 is a compact perturbation of the identity on @xmath69 , leray - schauder theory is applicable .
since we want our solution to satisfy ( [ pos ] ) , we want to solve ( [ re1 ] ) in the subset @xmath73 given by @xmath74 note that for @xmath41 the solution @xmath46 given by ( [ i0 ] ) lies in @xmath21 .
our aim is to continue this solution in @xmath45 up to @xmath40 .
we recall that the leray - schauder degree theory ( see e.g. @xcite ) implies that , given a bounded open set @xmath75 , the existence of a solution @xmath76 of ( [ re1 ] ) for all @xmath35 $ ] will be assured if the following conditions hold : \(i ) @xmath77 , \(ii ) @xmath78 , \(iii ) @xmath79 for all @xmath80 , @xmath35 $ ] . the most obvious choice for @xmath23 would be @xmath81 .
however , this will not do , since @xmath44 ( given by ( [ i00 ] ) ) satisfies @xmath82 and @xmath83 , so that ( iii ) does not hold . to satisfy ( iii )
we will need to choose @xmath23 so as to exclude @xmath44 from its boundary .
we take @xmath23 to be the open subset of @xmath21 given by @xmath84 where @xmath85 is fixed .
note that @xmath86 .
we will show below that @xmath23 satisfies ( i)-(iii ) if @xmath87 is chosen so that @xmath88 .
we first show that @xmath44 is the _ only _ solution of ( [ re1 ] ) on @xmath89 . [ only ] if @xmath90 is a solution of ( [ re1 ] ) for some @xmath35 $ ] , then @xmath91 , as given by ( [ i00 ] ) .
assume that @xmath92 is a solution of ( [ s2]),([i2 ] ) .
note that @xmath92 , if an only if @xmath93 and at least one of the following conditions holds : \(i ) there exists @xmath94 so that @xmath95 .
\(ii ) there exists @xmath94 so that @xmath96 .
\(iii ) there exists @xmath94 so that @xmath97 .
we now consider each of these three cases : \(1 ) assume ( i ) holds .
let @xmath98 be the solution of @xmath99 and let @xmath100 .
then @xmath101 is a solution of the initial - value problem ( [ s2]),([i2 ] ) with initial condition @xmath102 by uniqueness of the solution for the initial - value problem , we conclude that @xmath103 , @xmath104 . thus @xmath105 satisfies @xmath106 , and since the only periodic solution of this equation is @xmath107 , we conclude that @xmath108 , as we wanted to prove .
\(2 ) assume now that ( ii ) holds .
then from ( [ s2 ] ) we get @xmath109 . but
this implies that @xmath110 for @xmath111 sufficiently close to @xmath112 , which contradicts ( [ cl ] ) .
thus this case is impossible .
\(3 ) assume now that ( iii ) holds .
moreover since we have already proven the result in the case that ( i ) holds , we may assume that @xmath113 for all @xmath29 . adding ( [ s1 ] ) and ( [ i1 ] ) we get @xmath114 therefore we conclude that @xmath115 for @xmath111 sufficiently close to @xmath112 , contradicting ( [ cl ] ) .
therefore this case is impossible .
we can now show that @xmath23 , defined by ( [ u ] ) , satisfies ( iii ) .
assume @xmath1 .
if @xmath116 then , for any @xmath35 $ ] there are no solutions @xmath76 of ( [ re1 ] ) with @xmath117 .
suppose @xmath117 .
then either @xmath92 or @xmath118 and @xmath119 in the first case , lemma [ only ] and the fact that @xmath120 imply that @xmath76 is not a solution of ( [ re1 ] ) .
we therefore assume that @xmath118 and ( [ bc ] ) holds , which implies that @xmath121 assume by way of contradiction that @xmath76 solves ( [ re1 ] ) , or equivalently @xmath76 solves ( [ s2]),([i2 ] ) . using the assumption @xmath118
, we have that @xmath122 is everywhere positive , so we can divide ( [ i2 ] ) by @xmath122 , and integrate over @xmath123 $ ] , to obtain @xmath124 but from ( [ bc1 ] ) we get @xmath125 by the assumption @xmath126 we have @xmath127 , so that ( [ vv ] ) implies @xmath128 contradicting ( [ ee ] ) . to apply the leray - schauder degree it remains to verify that ( i ) and ( ii ) hold .
since @xmath129 , the condition @xmath130 implies @xmath77 , so ( i ) holds . to prove ( ii ) , it suffices to show that the frchet derivative @xmath131 is invertible .
since @xmath132 is a compact perturbation of the identity so that @xmath131 is fredholm , it suffices to prove that the kernel of @xmath131 is trivial .
indeed , let us assume that @xmath133 , and prove that @xmath134 .
we have @xmath135 , or , equivalently , @xmath136 note that @xmath137 so that ( [ ker ] ) is equivalent to @xmath138 the characteristic polynomial of the above matrix is @xmath139 noting that @xmath140 and that , for @xmath141 , @xmath142 , we see that the matrix has no imaginary or @xmath143 eigenvalues , so that ( [ sys ] ) has no periodic solutions except @xmath144 , and the claim is proved .
we have thus proven that ( i)-(iii ) hold , which completes the proof of theorem [ main ] .
as we have noted in the introduction , the period solution whose existence was proved whenever @xmath1 is observable in numerical simulation of ( [ s])-([r ] ) only for those parameter regimes for which it is stable .
therefore , if we are interested in examining the shape and amplitude of the @xmath0-periodic solution for values of the parameters for which the system displays subharmonic or chaotic behavior , we need a different computational approach .
we now describe a simple approach that we successfully implemented , which allows us to observe the @xmath0-periodic solution for arbitrary parameters .
we used the galerkin method , expanding the periodic solution @xmath145 in a fourier series .
we used the maple system , whose symbolic capabilities make the implementation particularly easy .
we take @xmath146 , @xmath147 and search for approximate periodic solutions of ( [ s]),([i ] ) the form @xmath148,\nonumber\\ \tilde{i}(t)&=&a_i^{0}+\sum_{n=1}^n [ a_i^{n}\cos(nt)+b_i^{n}\sin(nt)].\end{aligned}\ ] ] plugging ( [ fo ] ) into ( [ s])-([i ] ) , and then taking the fourier coefficients of both sides of the equations with respect to @xmath149 we get @xmath150 algebraic equations in @xmath150 variables , which we numerically solve for @xmath151 , obtaining the approximate @xmath0-periodic solution ( [ fo ] ) .
we have found that the numerical iteration for solving the algebraic equations , using maple s fsolve command , works well , when we start with the initial conditions for the iteration given by the endemic equilibrium of the autonomous case , that is @xmath152 ( see ( [ i0 ] ) ) and @xmath153 for @xmath154 .
we check that the functions @xmath155 indeed approximate a periodic solution of ( [ s]),([i ] ) by observing that the highest fourier coefficients @xmath156 are very small , and by plugging @xmath155 into ( [ s]),([i ] ) and checking that the residual is small .
we note that theoretical justification of the galerkin method for approximating periodic solutions can be found , e.g. , in @xcite .
we now present some examples of results obtained by the method described above . with the period @xmath157 of the forcing representing one year ,
we took take @xmath7 corresponding to a @xmath158-week infectious period , @xmath159 , @xmath6 corresponding to @xmath160 population growth rate per year , giving @xmath161 .
these parameters are approximately those estimated for measles .
we consider different values of the strength of seasonality @xmath45 ( see ( [ for ] ) ) . in figure 1
we plot , for different value of @xmath45 , the periodic solution found by the galerkin method ( with @xmath162 ) , together with a solution of ( [ s])-([i ] ) obtained by direct simulation , starting the plot at @xmath163 to ensure that transients have decayed .
[ fig1 ] -periodic forcing ( @xmath146 ) , obtained by direct simulation , and the @xmath0-periodic solution obtained by the galerkin method ( dashed line ) , for varying strength of seasonality @xmath45 .
top row , from left to right : @xmath164 , bottom row : @xmath165 .
other parameters : @xmath166 , @xmath159 , @xmath167.,title="fig:",width=170,height=170]-periodic forcing ( @xmath146 ) , obtained by direct simulation , and the @xmath0-periodic solution obtained by the galerkin method ( dashed line ) , for varying strength of seasonality @xmath45 .
top row , from left to right : @xmath164 , bottom row : @xmath165 .
other parameters : @xmath166 , @xmath159 , @xmath167.,title="fig:",width=170,height=170]-periodic forcing ( @xmath146 ) , obtained by direct simulation , and the @xmath0-periodic solution obtained by the galerkin method ( dashed line ) , for varying strength of seasonality @xmath45 .
top row , from left to right : @xmath164 , bottom row : @xmath165 .
other parameters : @xmath166 , @xmath159 , @xmath167.,title="fig:",width=170,height=170 ] + -periodic forcing ( @xmath146 ) , obtained by direct simulation , and the @xmath0-periodic solution obtained by the galerkin method ( dashed line ) , for varying strength of seasonality @xmath45 .
top row , from left to right : @xmath164 , bottom row : @xmath165 .
other parameters : @xmath166 , @xmath159 , @xmath167.,title="fig:",width=170,height=170]-periodic forcing ( @xmath146 ) , obtained by direct simulation , and the @xmath0-periodic solution obtained by the galerkin method ( dashed line ) , for varying strength of seasonality @xmath45 .
top row , from left to right : @xmath164 , bottom row : @xmath165 .
other parameters : @xmath166 , @xmath159 , @xmath167.,title="fig:",width=170,height=170]-periodic forcing ( @xmath146 ) , obtained by direct simulation , and the @xmath0-periodic solution obtained by the galerkin method ( dashed line ) , for varying strength of seasonality @xmath45 .
top row , from left to right : @xmath164 , bottom row : @xmath165 .
other parameters : @xmath166 , @xmath159 , @xmath167.,title="fig:",width=170,height=170 ] [ fig2 ] -periodic solution obtained by the galerkin method , for varying strength of seasonality @xmath168.,title="fig:",width=377,height=188 ] when @xmath169 , the system behavior is @xmath157-periodic , so the solution of the simulated system coincides with the @xmath157-periodic solution found by the galerkin method . at @xmath170 ,
the @xmath157-periodic solution has lost stability , and we see bifurcation to a subharmonic of order 2 ( period @xmath171 ) , which is still quite close to the @xmath157-periodic solution , with larger and smaller epidemics alternating . at @xmath172
the @xmath171-periodic subharmonic solution is already quite different , with a large epidemic every two years . at @xmath173
we observe that the system has a subharmonic of order 4 ( period @xmath174 ) , while at @xmath175 we observe chaotic behavior .
the @xmath157-periodic solution ( which is unstable except for the case @xmath169 ) increases in amplitude and becomes less sinusoidal as @xmath45 increases ( note the differences in scales in the different plots ) .
in figure 2 we plot the @xmath157-periodic solutions for all values of @xmath45 , for a better view .
the forced sir model is a beautiful example of a simple nonlinear dynamical system which displays complicated behaviors which are difficult to understand in intuitive terms .
moreover , these complicated behaviors are relevant to explaining the epidemiology of infectious diseases in humans , as studies comparing the behavior of the sir and variants of it to surveillance data have shown @xcite .
we have proven the fundamental result that a @xmath0-periodic solution exists for the @xmath0-periodically forced sir model whenever @xmath1 . as we have stressed ,
this does not mean that the dynamics of the model is periodic , since the periodic solution whose existence is proved need not be stable , although one can use standard perturbation theory to prove that the @xmath0-periodic solution _ is _ stable provided the seasonality parameter @xmath45 in ( [ deco ] ) is sufficiently small .
numerical simulations show that complex dynamics - subharmonic and chaotic behavior - is very common in the forced sir model .
it is interesting to ask to what extent the complex dynamics of the forced sir model can be rigorously understood , beyond numerical simulations . while we do not expect to be able to precisely characterize the dynamics of the model for different parameter values , it is of great interest even to be able to rigourously prove that complicated dynamics occurs for at least _ some _ parameter values . in this context
we mention the work of h.l .
smith @xcite , who proved that the forced sir model can have multiple stable subharmonic oscillations in certain parameter ranges .
chaotic behavior has been rigorously established by glendinning & perry @xcite for a variant of the forced sir model , in which the dependence of the incidence term on @xmath122 is nonlinear .
for the standard sir model ( [ s])-([r ] ) , we are not aware of a proof of chaotic behavior . classifying and explaining the dynamical patterns observed in simulations of the forced sir model is still very challenging , so that , like other well - known ` simple ' models such as the forced pendulum equation , the forced sir model can serve as a stimulus and as a benchmark problem for new developments in nonlinear analysis . | we prove that the seasonally - forced sir model with a @xmath0-periodic forcing has a periodic solution with period @xmath0 whenever the basic reproductive number @xmath1 .
the proof uses the leray - schauder degree theory .
we also describe some numerical results in which we compute the @xmath0-periodic solution , where in order to obtain the @xmath0-periodic solution when the behavior of the system is subharmonic or chaotic , we use a galerkin scheme .
* msc * : 34v25 , 37j45 , 92d30 . |
shear flow can drive dense colloidal dispersions into states far from equilibrium .
especially of interest is the possibility to shear melt colloidal solids , in particular metastable colloidal glasses and gels , and to investigate shear - melted ( yielding ) colloidal glasses .
does a yield stress and/or yield strain exist ( petekidis _ et al .
are shear - melted states necessarily heterogeneous ( e.g. shear banded ) ?
does ageing prevent stationary states under steady shearing ?
do hydrodynamic interactions dominate the properties in flow ?
these are just some of the questions whose answers will provide insights into the still murky glassy state .
recently the integration through transients ( itt ) approach has been used to generalize the mode coupling theory ( mct ) of the structural glass transition to the case of steady shearing ( fuchs cates 2002 , 2009 ) , and to arbitrary homogeneous flows ( brader _ et al .
_ 2008 ) , albeit based on a number of approximations .
first , homogeneous flow profiles are assumed from the outset , second , hydrodynamic interactions are neglected , and third , the mode coupling ( mean - field - like ) decoupling approximation , splitting a four point density fluctuation function into the product of two - point density correlators , has been applied . while simplified ( schematic ) models of mct - itt ( fuchs cates 2003 ) can well be fitted to the linear rheology ( frequency dependent storage and loss moduli ) and non - linear rheology ( flow curves , viz .
stress as function of shear rate ) of model dispersions ( siebenbrger _ et al .
_ 2009 ) , no fully quantitative comparison between the theory and data without additional approximations has been presented up to now .
we provide this first quantitative comparison , solving the mct - itt equations for hard discs confined to move in a plane , and performing brownian dynamics simulations for a binary hard disc mixture , also in two dimensions .
computational ( memory ) constraints force us to work in two dimensions , which is still of some experimental relevance , as glasses have been observed in quasi - two - dimensional dispersions ( bayer _ et al .
use of a binary mixture suppresses the nucleation rate sufficiently for even our long simulation runs to remain free of crystal nuclei . as hydrodynamic interactions are absent also in the simulation , and as lees - edwards boundary conditions ( le ) in combination with the thermostat
impose a homogeneous shear rate , the integration of the equations of motion in the simulation ensure a stringent test of the theory .
results for the stationary shear and normal stresses , and for the shear - distorted microstructure are presented and discussed .
the input quantities entering the theory , and transient density correlation functions , which ( crucially ) enter during intermediate mct - itt steps , are characterized also .
our work bears some similarity to the study by miyazaki , reichman , and yamamoto , who , however , concentrated on fluid states under shear , and on their time dependent fluctuations ( miyazaki _ et al .
we focus here on the yielding glass state , and its stationary , time - independent averages , which are not accessible to the theory in ref .
( miyazaki _ et al .
_ 2004 ) . in order to compare quantitatively with theory
, we aimed for better statistics than in comparable previous two - dimensional simulation studies of sheared glasses ( yamamoto onuki 1998 ; furukawa _ et al .
the basic concept of the algorithm has been described in detail in three dimensions in ( scala _ et al .
_ 2007 ) and can easily be adapted to two dimensions @xmath0 and @xmath1 . in order to prevent crystallisation at high densities we consider a binary mixture with a diameter ratio of @xmath2 at equal number concentrations ( @xmath3 ) .
@xmath4 hard discs move in a simulation box of volume @xmath5 with periodic lees edwards boundary conditions at packing fraction @xmath6 .
the mass of the particles is set equal to unity , thermal energy @xmath7 sets the energy scale , and @xmath8 is used as unit of length in the following .
we choose our coordinate axes such that flow is in the @xmath0-direction and the shear gradient @xmath9 is in the @xmath1-direction . after putting the particles on their initial positions we provide gaussian distributed velocities which will be overlain by the linear shear flow . to propagate the system forwards in time we employ a semi - event - driven algorithm . for every particle at the time
@xmath10 the algorithm determines the possible collision time @xmath11 with any other particle .
this is easily achieved by solving the equation @xmath12 where @xmath13 and @xmath14 denote the diameters of the particles @xmath15 and @xmath16 , @xmath17 the relative vector between both particles , and @xmath18 the relative velocities .
the smallest solution @xmath19 for all particle pairs determines the next event in the algorithm .
all particles can then be propagated according to : @xmath20 . with the conservation of energy and momentum
the binary collision laws impose new velocities @xmath21 for the particle @xmath16 and @xmath15 @xmath22 due to the boundary conditions any particle in the vicinity of the box - boundary can collide with an image particle coming from the other end of the box .
the boxes are constructed in such a way that they are translated with the velocity @xmath23 , where @xmath24 denotes the size of the box .
the boundary conditions thus have the consequence that the velocities tend to increase .
therefore a thermostat has to be introduced . after a time
@xmath25 a so - called brownian step sets in , which assures that the particles move diffusively for longer times . in the brownian step at the time @xmath26 ,
all particle velocities are freshly drawn from a gaussian distribution with @xmath27 .
after that linear shear flow is imposed so that @xmath28 holds . as the system starts from a cubic lattice it is necessary to wait for the system to relax before meaningful stationary averages can be taken .
the quantity of interest in the work presented here is the potential part of the stress : @xmath29 , with the relative force components ( in @xmath30-direction ) of particles @xmath15 and @xmath16 @xmath31 , and the particles relative distance components @xmath32 .
the kinetic part will play no role , and thus has already been omitted . as we consider hard particles the forces
must be calculated from the collision events . by observing the collisions within a certain time window @xmath33 forces
may be extracted using the change of momentum which occurs during the observation time .
this leads to the evaluation algorithm ( lange _ et al .
_ 2009 ; foss brady 2000 ) @xmath34 where the summation is over all collisions of particles @xmath15 and @xmath16 at time @xmath35 within the time window @xmath36 .
the procedure effectively sums the momentum changes @xmath37 in the @xmath38 direction multiplied by the relative distance of the particles @xmath39 in the @xmath40 direction . here and below the brackets @xmath41 denote the average over different simulation runs . + additionally the shear stress can be computed via the contact value @xmath42 : @xmath43 where @xmath44 denote the @xmath45-dependent partial contact values of the two components and @xmath46 the minimal distance between two particles .
@xmath45 is the polar angle . +
the green - kubo relation @xmath47 holds for the non - sheared system .
thus the shear viscosity can be extracted from the simulation via ( alder _ et al .
_ 1970 ) @xmath48 where the sum runs over all collisions .
the second pivot in this analysis is the equal - time structure factor and its deviation from the quiescent system . exploiting that @xmath49 is a real quantity ,
we can extract it via @xmath50 where the double sum runs over all pairs of particles @xmath15 and @xmath16 ( @xmath51 ) .
the pairs @xmath52 are determined by the le boundary conditions and the constraint of having the lowest distance among all possible image particles in the surrounding boxes . + for low peclet numbers ( pe@xmath53=@xmath54)in fluid states , @xmath42 can be expanded : @xmath55 .
this result can be used to derive the relative distortion of the structure factor in the linear response regime ( strating 1999 ) .
@xmath56}\ ] ] while @xmath57 can be obtained via @xmath58
the mct - itt approach generalizes the mct of the glass transition to colloidal dispersions under strong continuous shear .
it considers @xmath59 spherical particles with arbitrary interaction potential which move by brownian motion relative to a given linear shear profile .
an equation of motion for a _ transient _ density correlator @xmath60 encodes structural rearrangements , and approximated generalized green - kubo laws relate stress relaxation to the decay of density fluctuations .
the transient density correlator is defined by @xmath61 , where the density fluctuation is as usual @xmath62 , and , in itt , the average can be performed over the equilibrium gibbs - boltzmann ensemble .
thus the normalization of the initial value @xmath63 is given by the equilibrium structure factor @xmath64 .
the time - dependent or _ shear - advected _ wavevector @xmath65 appearing in the definition eliminates the affine particle motion with the flow field , and gives @xmath66 in the absence of brownian motion .
shear flow coupled to random motion causes @xmath60 to decay , as given by an ( exact ) equation of motion containing a retarded friction kernel which arises from the competition of particle caging and shear advection of fluctuations @xmath67 where the initial decay rate contains taylor dispersion as @xmath68 .
the generalized friction kernel @xmath69 , which is an autocorrelation function of fluctuating stresses , is approximated , following mct precepts by an expression involving the structural rearrangements captured in the density correlators @xmath70 with abbreviation @xmath71 , @xmath72 the particle density , and a vertex function given by @xmath73 where @xmath74 is the ornstein - zernicke direct correlation function @xmath75 .
an additional memory kernel is neglected ( fuchs cates 2009 ) .
the equilibrium structure factor , @xmath76 , encodes the particle interactions and introduces the experimental control parameters like density and temperature .
similarly , the potential part of the stress @xmath77 in the non - equilibrium stationary state ( neglecting the diagonal contribution that gives the pressure ) is approximated assuming that stress relaxations can be computed from integrating the transient density correlations @xmath78 flow also leads to the build up of shear - induced micro - structural changes , which , again integrating up the transient density correlators , can be found from @xmath79 a far smaller isotropic term in @xmath80 ( see ( fuchs cates 2009 ) ) is neglected here , as it is of importance for the plane perpendicular to the flow only .
the set of coupled eqs . [ mct1],[mct2 ] and [ mct3 ]
was solved self - consistently using modifications of standard algorithms and the ng - iteration - scheme ( ng 2009 ) . the functions were discretized on a 2d - fourier - grid consisting of 101 grid points in either coordinate direction using a cutoff of @xmath81 .
more explicitly the fourier - grid was discretized as @xmath82 with @xmath83 being the particle diameter . in order to enhance the accuracy , the advected direct correlation function @xmath84 in eq .
[ mct3 ] was calculated from the input structure factor once it has been advected beyond the fourier - grid cutoff up to @xmath85 . for the time - integration of the convolution integral in eq .
[ mct1 ] an initial time step of @xmath86 was used .
the time - integration in the calculation of derived quantities eqs .
[ sigma_xy ] and [ distsq ] was performed by dividing the integration interval into two sub - intervals , the first one containing times shorter , the other one times longer than @xmath87 .
the integration was then carried out on the intrinsic quasi - logarithmic grid of the mct equation solver for times @xmath88 and on an equally - spaced linear time - grid with spacing @xmath89 for times @xmath90 .
the mct - itt approach uses structural equilibrium correlations as input , computes transient structural density correlators to encode the competition between flow - induced and brownian motion , and calculates all stationary properties from time - integrals over the transient fluctuations . in this section ,
the input and intermediate quantities of the theoretical calculations are presented and discussed .
the equilibrium structure factor @xmath64 is the only input quantity to the mct - itt equations .
it varies smoothly with density or temperature , but leads to the transition from a shear - thinning fluid to a yielding glassy state at a glass transition density @xmath91 .
figure [ fig1 ] shows modified hyper - netted chain structure factors of monodisperse hard discs in @xmath92 from ( bayer _ et al .
_ 2007 ) used in the mct - itt calculations . for comparison ,
the averaged structure factors obtained from the binary mixture simulation are shown also . in both cases ,
the value of the glass transition density @xmath91 is included in the curves in fig .
[ fig1 ] , and only smooth changes in @xmath64 are noticeable .
the short range order at the average particle distance , as measured in the primary peak of @xmath64 , increases with densification .
differences in the structure between the mono- and the bidisperse system become appreciable beyond the primary peak , and especially beyond the second peak in @xmath64 .
also the height of the primary peak in @xmath64 at @xmath91 differs , indicating that the averaged structure factor in the bidisperse system does not well characterize the local structure and caging in the simpler system , and that a comparison with a bidisperse mct - itt calculation should be performed .
as this is outside the present numerical reach , we proceed by comparing results for the characteristic wavevectors denoted @xmath93 to @xmath94 in fig .
the angular dependence of the anisotropic structure will be explored along the special directions indicated in the insets .
the central quantities in mct - itt , which encode the competition between shear driven motion and random fluctuations , are the transient density correlators .
structural rearrangements manifest themselves as a ( second ) slow relaxation process in the @xmath95 , whose relaxation time depends sensitively on the distance to the glass transition , measured by the ( relative ) separation parameter @xmath96 , and on the magnitude of the shear rate .
figure [ fig2 ] shows representative curves in a fluid state ( left column ) and in a shear - melted glassy state ( right column ) for the wavevectors and directions defined in fig .
[ fig1 ] , and for nine different shear rates .
the denoted bare peclet numbers measure the shear rate compared to the brownian diffusion time estimated with the single particle diffusion coefficient @xmath97 at infinite dilution .
characteristically , for the present strongly viscoelastic system , shear affects the structural relaxation already at extremely small bare peclet numbers pe@xmath98 .
the short time motion , which corresponds to the local diffusion of the particles within their neighbour cages , however , is not much affected as long as pe@xmath99 holds . + + in the fluid ( @xmath100 ) , a linear response regime , where shear does not affect the decay of thermal fluctuations , is observed for small ( dressed ) peclet or weissenberg numbers pe@xmath101 , where pe@xmath102 measures the shear rate relative to the intrinsic relaxation time .
the latter can be estimated from the relaxation of @xmath103 , viz . at the primary peak of @xmath64 , where the structure relaxes most slowly in the quiescent case .
the final ( or @xmath30- ) relaxation time @xmath11 increases strongly when approaching the glass transition ; with @xmath104 predicted by mct ( bayer _ et al .
_ 2007 ) . for the fluid state in fig .
[ fig2 ] , only pe@xmath105 is small enough that pe@xmath106 holds and the final relaxation curves agree for different shear rates . in the glass ( @xmath107 ) , shear is the origin of the decay of the otherwise frozen - in density fluctuations , and all nine shear rates lead to different final decays .
while for small and larger wavevectors the final decay is rather isotropic , around the main peak in @xmath64 some anisotropy is noticeable in the transient correlators . in the direction perpendicular to the flow , @xmath108 ( red ) ,
shear is not as efficient in decorrelating the density as in the other directions , which fall closer together .
+ + one of the central predictions of mct - itt concerns the existence of a scaling law describing the yielding of glassy states , which manifests itself by an approach to a master function @xmath109 for decreasing shear rate , @xmath110 and @xmath107 , where the rescaled time @xmath111 agrees with the accumulated strain .
this scaling law , which is quite obvious in fig .
[ fig2 ] , is tested quantitatively for some wavevectors in fig .
[ figyield ] , and holds extremely well ( for @xmath93 ) , or with pre - asymptotic corrections ( for @xmath112 ) .
the shapes of the yielding master functions can be very well fitted with compressed exponentials , @xmath113 , but the parameters , including the exponent @xmath114 , depend on wavevector and orientation ; see table [ table1 ] for representative values .
.parameters of the compressed exponentials @xmath115 fitted to the yield master functions shown in fig . [ figyield ] . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the quite good fit to compressed exponentials is at present only a numerical observation . yet
, close to the glass transition asymptotic expansions are possible which analytically predict the initial part of the yield master functions ( fuchs cates 2002,2003,2009 ) : @xmath116 as the critical glass form factor @xmath117 and the critical amplitude @xmath118 are isotropic , this result suggests a rather isotropic yielding process right at the glass transition density .
approximating @xmath119 by an exponential , it also provides an estimate for the final relaxation time under shear . except for @xmath120 all quantities in the above formula have been determined in quiescent mct ( bayer _ et al .
_ 2007 ) , and our values ( e.g. @xmath121 ) differ only because of the coarser discretization in @xmath122 space that is necessary under shear .
close to the glass transition , we estimate @xmath123 . as the bottom left panel in fig .
[ figyield ] and fig .
[ fig2 ] both show , this estimate for the final relaxation time is quite good close to the transition , but deeper in the glass the correlators become somewhat more anisotropic . specifically for @xmath108 ( red ) with wavevector magnitudes around @xmath124 , the correlator slows down relative to other orientations .
more detailed analytical predictions , are possible around @xmath117 , where spatial and temporal dependences in the transient fluctuations decouple ( fuchs cates 2003 ) : @xmath125 @xmath126 is a universal function , which only depends on @xmath127 , and @xmath128 is another mct time scale that diverges at the glass transition ( bayer _ et al .
this factorization property known from quiescent mct generalizes to steady shear , and is an essential feature of the localization transition that underlies glass formation in mct . in fig .
[ figbeta ] , the quantity @xmath129 is plotted which should become wavevector and orientation independent if factorisation holds .
this holds in the liquid , and in the glass , where however shear leads to strong ( anisotropic ) pre - asymptotic corrections already for @xmath130 .
based on the approximated generalized green - kubo relations of eqs .
( [ sigma_xy ] ) and ( [ distsq ] ) , and the properties of the transient correlators discussed in the previous section , mct - itt makes a number of predictions for stationary stresses and structural correlations ( fuchs cates 2002 , 2009 ) . in the following
, we will test these qualitatively , but also quantitatively , by comparing them to the two - dimensional simulation data .
the quantity of most interest in nonlinear rheology is the shear stress @xmath131 .
flow curves giving the shear stress as function of the shear rate can be obtained in the simulations and are shown in fig .
[ figstress ] .
the viscosity decreases below its newtonian value @xmath132 upon increasing the shear rate already for small pe@xmath53 values .
shear thinning in which the stress increases less than linearly with @xmath133 , sets in at pe of the order of unity , and this crossover shifts to lower and lower pe@xmath53 for increasing density . at the density around @xmath134 ,
the crossover leaves the accessible shear rate window .
we use this as estimate of an ideal glass transition density , where the final relaxation time and the quiescent newtonian viscosity ( @xmath135 ) diverge .
moreover , at this density the flow curves change from a characteristic s shape in the fluid , to exhibiting a rather @xmath133-independent plateau at small shear rates .
this change is the hallmark of the transition in mct - itt between a shear thinning fluid and a yielding glass ( siebenbrger _ et al .
_ 2009 ) .
+ the numerical mct - itt solutions show the same transition scenario , but because of the approximations involved , exhibit a different critical density than the simulations .
even if theory and simulation considered the same ( binary ) system , a difference in critical packing fraction would be expected as is well known also in three dimensions ( voigtmann _ et al .
thus the following mct - itt calculations match the relative separation @xmath136 from @xmath91 in order to compare with the simulations . as mct - itt
is aimed at describing the long time structural motion , errors need to be anticipated in its description of short time properties .
this is obvious in real dispersions , where hydrodynamic interactions ( neglected in mct - itt ) affect the short time diffusion coefficient @xmath137 , but may arise in the following comparisons , also .
a rescaling of the effective peclet number pe@xmath138 would correct for this change in @xmath137 . in order not to introduce additional fit parameters we refrain from doing so , but anticipate
that future comparisons may require @xmath139 .
the approach to a yield scaling law , where the final decay of the transient correlators depends on the accumulated strain only ( see figs .
[ fig2 ] and [ figyield ] ) , predicts the existence of a ( dynamical ) yield stress @xmath140 , which characterizes the shear melted glass . in the bidisperse
hard disc mixture , at the glass transition it takes the ( critical ) value @xmath141 ; below the glass transition , the yield stress jumps to zero , @xmath142 .
its quantitative prediction is quite a challenge for theory , because eq . [ sigma_xy ] shows that it requires an accurate calculation of the shear driven relaxation process .
mct - itt overestimates the critical yield stress @xmath143 by roughly a factor 10 because , presumably , the decay of the transient correlators is too slow . yet , of course the difference between the monodisperse system in the mct - itt calculation and the bidisperse simulated system contributes in unknown way to the error .
it appears reasonable to assume that mixing two species reduces the stresses under flow , which would explain part of the deviation .
+ at larger shear rates , the flow curves from simulation appear to approach a second newtonian plateau which , presumably , strongly depends on the hard - core character of excluded volume interactions and is outside the reach of the present mct - itt .
the latter , by using its sole input @xmath64 rather than pair potential , is not directly aware of hard - core constraints .
we checked , however , that the states remain homogeneous and random up to the pe@xmath53 values shown .
reassuringly , the same rescaling factor of 0.1 as for the shear stress brings theoretical and simulational normal stress differences , @xmath144 , into register also ; see fig .
[ fignorm ] .
the normal stress differences are positive ( indicating that the dispersion would swell after flowing through a nozzle ) , and show similar behavior to the stress , increasing like @xmath145 in the fluid for small shear rates , and leveling out onto a plateau in the yielding glass .
the macroscopic stresses in the flowing dispersion are experimentally most important , but provide only an averaged description of the local effects of shear .
spatially resolved information can be learned from the distorted structure factor @xmath146 , which in mct - itt is connected to the stress via @xmath147 as follows from eqs .
( [ sigma_xy ] ) and ( [ distsq ] ) .
+ + figure [ figsqcolor ] shows colour - coded structure factors @xmath148 as function of the two - dimensional wavevector @xmath122 , with @xmath149 in the direction of flow and @xmath150 along the gradient direction . in the left column , panels with simulation data
are compared to panels in the right column obtained in mct - itt .
scattering intensities are presented @xmath151 ( top row ) in the linear response regime in the fluid , effectively measuring the equilibrium structure factors already shown in fig .
[ fig1 ] , @xmath152 ( middle row ) at high shear in the glass , where all densities are in the shear thinning region , and @xmath153 ( bottom row ) in the glass at low shear rate , where the yielding glassy state is tested .
while the fluid @xmath148 is isotropic for small pe@xmath53 ( case @xmath151 ) , as required by linear response theory , increasing pe@xmath53 to values around unity , leads to an ellipsoidal scattering ring , which is elongated along the so - called compressional axis @xmath154 , and more narrow along the extensional axis @xmath155 ; this indicates that shear pushes particles together along the compressional and pulls particles apart along the extensional diagonals ( vermant solomon 2005 ) . theory and simulation data in this representation
qualitatively agree except for that mct - itt somewhat overestimates the anisotropic distortion of the glass structure at low pe@xmath53 .
+ + + a more careful look onto the distorted microstructure is provided by @xmath156-dependent cuts through @xmath148 along the directions colour - coded in fig .
important for the direction @xmath108 ( red ) is the need , present in both simulation and theory , to average @xmath148 over a small but finite angle , because exactly at @xmath108 the structure oscillates noisily around zero .
+ especially of interest are the intensities of case @xmath153 , where the stationary structure of the shear melted solid is studied .
the density @xmath157 is not yet high enough to lie in the glass , but close enough to the glass transition so that the correlations at quite low rate , namely pe@xmath158 , closely resemble the ones of glassy states at very low shear rates .
( while we can get good statistics for stresses at pe@xmath159 for all densities , structure factors can not be sampled sufficiently there . ) at this density of @xmath157 also the equilibrium structure factor @xmath64 can be obtained in long simulation runs , and the ( relative ) difference @xmath160 can thus be determined .
it is shown in fig .
[ figsqrel ] for two states in order to investigate the distorted structure of the shear melted glass in detail .
we base the following discussion on the hypothesis that pe@xmath161 at @xmath157 captures a glass - like state in the limit of low bare peclet number .
figure [ figsqrel ] provides a sensitive test of the accuracy of the theoretical predictions .
the lower left panel shows that the structure factor at vanishing shear rate @xmath162 jumps discontinuously at the glass transition ; while @xmath163 holds in the fluid , @xmath164 holds in the glass .
relative deviations @xmath165 of 20% remain .
simulation finds quite isotropic deviations which show a maximum on the low-@xmath156 side of the primary peak in @xmath64 .
mct - itt predicts the absence of a linear response regime in @xmath148 as function of the shear rate in the glass , and derives it from the existence of the yield scaling law in the transient correlators .
because @xmath133 sets the time scale for the final relaxation into the stationary state , the limit @xmath166 does not agree with the quiescent result @xmath167 .
+ quantitatively , mct - itt overestimates the distortion again by a factor up to 10 , and finds a noticeable anisotropy , as discussed in context with fig .
[ figsqcolor ] .
while the difference between the bidisperse and the monodisperse system may influence the comparison , we believe that the major origin of the error is that mct - itt underestimates the speeding up of structural rearrangements caused by shear .
the too slow transient correlators thus become anisotropic because the accumulated strain @xmath168 becomes too big before structural correlations have decayed .
qualitatively , aspects of the anisotropy predicted by mct - itt can be seen in the simulations at only slightly larger shear rates , like at pe@xmath169 shown in the middle left panel of fig .
[ figsqrel ] . while along the two axis- and the extensional diagonal direction , the low-@xmath156 wing of the primary peak in @xmath148 becomes enhanced under shear , along the compressional axis ( magenta ) it gets suppressed , and the high-@xmath156 wing is pushed up .
simulation also finds a suppression of the peak height along all directions , which mct - itt reproduces along the diagonal directions .
overall the anisotropy and the magnitude of the distortions predicted by mct - itt remain too large , but the deviation decreases . the differences between the equilibrium structure factors @xmath64 in the simulated and in the calculated system should be taken into account in future work , and presently preclude comparisons at larger wavevectors .
the first fully quantitative solutions of the mct - itt equations for the distorted microstructure and the stresses in steadily sheared two - dimensional shear - thinning fluids and yielding glasses of brownian hard discs exhibit all the universal features discussed within schematic mct - itt models ( fuchs cates 2003 ) .
they compare qualitatively well , but quantitatively with appreciable errors , with brownian dynamics simulations of a bidisperse mixture without hydrodynamic interactions in a linear shear profile , which for all states considered remains in an homogeneous and disordered state .
the non - analytic behavior of the stationary properties , and the lack of a linear response regime throughout the ( shear - melted ) glass state , predicted by theory , can be found in the simulation .
work funded in part by dfg - irtg 667 , and epsrc grants ep/045316 and ep/030173 .
mec holds a royal society research professorship [ lastpage ] | brownian dynamics simulations of bidisperse hard discs moving in two dimensions in a given steady and homogeneous shear flow are presented close to and above the glass transition density .
the stationary structure functions and stresses of shear melted glass are compared quantitatively to parameter free numerical calculations for monodisperse hard discs using mode coupling theory ( mct ) within the integration through transients ( itt ) framework .
theory qualitatively explains the properties of the yielding glass but quantitatively overestimates the shear driven stresses and structural anisotropies .
[ firstpage ] |
according to the theory of relativity or quantum electrodynamics ( qed ) , the rest mass of photon should be exactly zero .
however , even if the photon rest mass is not zero , qed and classical electromagnetism remain intact @xcite .
this is because a non - zero photon mass would not damage gauge invariance of the first kind ( which would lead to non - conservation of charge ) , but would only damage the gauge invariance of the second kind .
thus , the question of the photon mass is experimental , since it is impossible to fully prove that the photon rest mass is exactly zero via experiments .
the only experimental strategy is to place ever tighter upper limits on photon rest mass . due to the uncertainty principle
, there is an ultimate upper limit of photon rest mass @xcite , e.g. @xmath7 , where @xmath8 corresponds to the age of universe .
however , such an upper limit is extremely difficult to place . from the theoretical point of view , the photon - mass correction to maxwell s equations would cause changes to the classical electromagnetic properties
one can then constrain the photon mass through testing these properties .
so far , the photon mass has been constrained via different methods , which are divided into secure and speculative results @xcite .
the former includes frequency dependence of the speed of light ( @xmath9 ) @xcite , dispersion in the ionosphere ( @xmath10 ) @xcite , coulomb s law ( @xmath11 ) @xcite , jupiter s magnetic field ( @xmath12 ) @xcite , and solar wind magnetic field ( @xmath13 ) @xcite .
the latter includes extended lakes method ( @xmath14 ) @xcite , higgs mass for photon ( no limit feasible ) @xcite , cosmic magnetic fields ( @xmath15 ) @xcite , and so on .
testing the correctness of massless photon is one of the most intriguing tasks in modern physics .
if the photon has nonzero mass , the dispersion relation would be @xmath16 , where @xmath17 and @xmath18 is the photon mass ( see appendix ) .
this is the standard energy - momentum expression in the special theory of relativity , which is similar to the plasma dispersion relation ( with the plasma frequency @xmath19 replaced by @xmath20 ) .
this dispersion relation means that photons with different energies have different velocities .
one important requirement of the energy - momentum equation is that the frequency of the free electromagnetic wave must satisfy @xmath21 , or @xmath22 . for the magnetic dipole radiation in pulsars , the angular frequency of
the electromagnetic wave is equal to the angular frequency of rotation , i.e. @xmath23 . one natural question arises : what happens if @xmath24 for a magnetic dipole ?
in this paper , we propose a new method to obtain a limit of the photon mass by applying spindown information of pulsars .
traditional pulsars are rapidly spinning magnetized neutron stars , but white dwarf pulsars have been theoretical expected and recently proven to exist @xcite . the rotational kinetic energy luminosity is given by @xmath25 , where @xmath26 is the pulsar mass , @xmath27 is the pulsar radius , and @xmath28 is the angle velocity .
observations show that @xmath29 in general , i.e. pulsars spin down .
since gravitational wave spindown is negligible for slow - rotators such as radio pulsars , magnetars , and wd pulsars , pulsar spindown is naturally attributed to electromagnetic torques ( due to magnetic dipole radiation and wind power ) .
the magnetic dipole radiation from the rotating magnetosphere in the vacuum can sufficiently clarify the main properties of radio pulsars , including the pulsar spin down , stable radio sequence and so on .
for @xmath30 , the energy losses of the vacuum magnetic dipole radiation energy is given by @xmath31 , where @xmath32 is the polar magnetic field , and @xmath33 is the angle between magnetic axis and rotation axis .
the radiation energy originates from the rotational kinetic energy of the pulsar , leading to the pulsar spinning down .
we first calculate the magnetic dipole radiation with @xmath34 . following @xcite ( see appendix ) , we obtain the radiation power of the magnetic dipole field in vacuum : @xmath35 for @xmath36 ; @xmath37 for @xmath38 , where @xmath39 is the magnetic dipole moment . for @xmath40 ,
the magnetic dipole radiation power reduces to the classical result , i.e. , @xmath41 .
we define @xmath42 to characterize the correction of non - zero photon mass effect .
the @xmath43 relation for the vacuum case is presented in figure [ fig1 ] .
interestingly , if @xmath44 , the magnetic dipole radiation power drops to zero , leading to @xmath45 .
therefore , in the vacuum case , one can use the spin - down observation of the pulsars with the longest period to constrain the photon mass , i.e. @xmath46 .
since @xmath18 upper limit is inversely proportional to @xmath1 , pulsars with longer period would give more stringent constraints .
for neutron - star radio pulsars , the longest - period one is psr j2144 - 3933 @xcite with @xmath47 , @xmath48 , and spin - down luminosity @xmath49 . for magnetars ,
the longest - period one is 1es 1841 - 045 @xcite with @xmath50 , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 . for the wd pulsars , some magnetized wds @xcite with @xmath53
have periods around one hour @xcite . however , no spindown measurements have been reported .
the wd m dwarf binary system , ar scorpii , was recently reported to emit pulsed broadband emission @xcite .
the wd pulsar in ar scorpii has a measured spindown parameters @xmath2 , @xmath54 , and @xmath55 .
the mean luminosity of ar scorpii is @xmath56 , which includes the thermal emission of @xmath57 from the stellar components .
therefore , the non - thermal emission from ar scorpii could be comfortably powered by the magnetic dipole radiation of the white dwarf @xcite .
such a long period white dwarf pulsar can provide a stringent constraint on the photon mass . in figure [ fig1 ] ,
the blue , red and yellow lines denote the periods of psr j2144 - 3933 , 1es 1841 - 045 and the wd pulsar in ar scorpii , respectively .
the respective constrained upper limit of the photon mass are shown in table [ tab1 ] : for psr j2144 - 3933 @xcite , one has @xmath58 ; for 1es 1841 - 045 , one has @xmath59 ; and for the wd pulsar in ar scorpii , one has @xmath3 .
relation for vacuum case .
the blue red and yellow lines denote @xmath47 for psr j2144 - 3933 , @xmath50 for 1es 1841 - 045 and @xmath2 for the wd pulsar in ar scorpii , respectively . ]
if the the magnetic axis is parallel to the rotation axis , the magnetic dipole radiation is zero in vacuum .
however , pulsars are believed to be surrounded by a electron - positron plasma @xcite , which could be developed through a photon - pair cascade .
the outflowing plasma exerts an electromagnetic torque on the pulsar , so that the pulsar would spin down due to the existence of a pulsar wind @xcite . to quantify the effect of non - zero photon mass on the wind spindown rate ,
we first calculate the magnetic dipole field with @xmath34 .
we consider a statistic field solution ( see appendix ) : @xmath60 .
the corresponding solution is @xcite @xmath61 note that @xmath62 , where @xmath63 is the magnetization for the dipole approximation . according to @xmath64 , one has @xcite
@xmath65\left(1+\mu r+\frac{\mu^2 r^2}{3}\right)\frac{e^{-\mu r}}{r^3}\nonumber\\ & -&\frac{2}{3}\mu^2\bm{m}\frac{e^{-\mu r}}{r}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the magnetic field components in a spherical coordinate system are given by @xmath66 ( left ) and @xmath34 ( right).,title="fig : " ] ( left ) and @xmath34 ( right).,title="fig : " ] the field - line equation @xmath67 can be written as @xmath68 .
interestingly , for @xmath69 , one has @xmath70 for @xmath71 , which means that the magnetosphere trends to a 3-dimensional sphere , as shown in figure [ fig2 ] . integrating the field - line equation ,
one obtains @xmath72 .
thus , the open field line angle at the pulsar surface becomes @xmath73 where @xmath74 denotes the correction factor with respect to zero photon mass case , and @xmath75 is the light cylinder radius .
as shown in figure [ fig2 ] and figure [ fig3 ] , the larger the photon mass @xmath18 , the smaller the polar cap .
relation for non - vacuum wind spindown case .
the blue red and yellow lines denote @xmath47 for psr j2144 - 3933 , @xmath50 for 1es 1841 - 045 and @xmath2 for the wd pulsar in ar scorpii , respectively . ]
next , we calculate the plasma density in the magnetosphere . since photon mass does not affect the lorentz force density of the matter @xcite , the ohm s law is still @xmath76 . for astrophysical force - free plasmas , one has @xmath77 , since @xmath78 , @xmath79 @xcite .
therefore , the charge density is given by @xmath80 ( see appendix ) .
on the other hand , according to the statistic field equation : @xmath81 , one has @xmath82 , where @xmath83 is the classical goldreich - julian density @xcite .
the new plasma charge density @xmath84 with @xmath34 is then given by @xmath85 for a neutron star ( white dwarf ) , since @xmath86 is usually satisfied , one has @xmath87 ( @xmath88 ) , so that the magnetic field strength and the charge density at the pole are @xmath89 and @xmath90 , respectively , which are consist with the case of @xmath30 .
the radius of the polar cap is @xmath91 .
the potential difference between the center and the edge of the polar is @xmath92 .
the net charged - particle flux from the polar cap is @xmath93 , where @xmath94 with @xmath95 is the mean number density of the primary charged particles at the polar cap , which is essentially the goldreich - julian density .
the spin - down power of the wind is therefore approximately @xmath96 where @xmath97 and @xmath98 is the spin - down power of the wind with @xmath30 .
the above result can be also given by the method of @xcite and @xmath99 .
( see appendix ) . the @xmath43 relation for non - vacuum wind spindown case is presented in figure [ fig4 ] .
similar to the vacuum case , the wind spin down power rapidly fall off beyond a certain @xmath18 given a measured @xmath1 .
the difference from the vacuum case is that there is no absolute cutoff at @xmath100 . in order to constrain the photon mass using @xmath101 , where @xmath102 and @xmath98 , one needs to also measure the magnetic field of the pulsar using other method , such as , mhd pumping , zeeman splitting , cyclotron lines , magnetar bursts , etc .
relation for non - vacuum wind spindown case .
the blue red and yellow lines denote @xmath47 for psr j2144 - 3933 , @xmath50 for 1es 1841 - 045 and @xmath2 for the wd pusalr in ar scorpii , respectively . ] [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] [ tab1 ] once @xmath1 , @xmath103 and @xmath32 are measured , one would obtain @xmath104 and constrain the upper limit of the photon mass . we still take the data from psr j2144 - 3933 , 1es 1841 - 045 and the wd pulsar in ar scorpii as examples .
we assume that @xmath105 .
the upper limits of the photon mass using different sources are shown in table [ tab1 ] .
specially , the wd pulsar in ar scorpii @xcite has @xmath2 , @xmath54 and @xmath55 .
recently , an independent constraint on the white dwarf surface magnetic field strength was set via mhd pumping of the secondary @xcite , which gives @xmath106 , leading to @xmath107 .
our adoption of a large @xmath6 , e.g. @xmath105 , is therefore reasonable .
for the vacuum dipole radiation case , we get @xmath108 ( @xmath109 ) ; for the non - vacuum wind spindown case , we get @xmath110 ( @xmath4 ) , respectively . for different @xmath1 .
the solid and dashed lines denote the vacuum dipole spindown case and the non - vacuum wind spindown case , respectively .
we adopt @xmath111 ( red ) and @xmath112 ( blue ) in the calculations . ]
in summary , we proposed a method of using pulsar ( including neutron stars and white dwarfs ) spin - down observations to set a stringent upper limit on the photon mass . specially , for the recent pulsed observation of ar scorpii
, we obtain a stringent constraint on the photon mass @xmath108 ( @xmath4 ) for @xmath105 .
since some magnetized white dwarfs @xcite with @xmath53 have periods up to one hour and longer @xcite , we strongly urge further observations to these objects to detect their spindown behavior ( @xmath103 ) and to measure their magnetic field strength independently . these observations would give an upper limit around @xmath113 , which would be the most stringent limit within the secure methods .
this work is partially supported by the initiative postdocs supporting program ( no .
bx201600003 ) , the national basic research program ( 973 program ) of china ( no .
2014cb845800 ) and project funded by china postdoctoral science foundation ( no .
2016m600851 ) .
yuan - pei yang is supported by a kiaa - cas fellowship .
the classical maxwell equations and the corresponding lagrangian are based on the hypothesis that the photon mass is zero .
if photon has a non - zero mass , one can modify the lagrangian density by adding a `` mass '' term .
such a new lagrangian is known as the proca lagrangian @xcite , which is given by @xmath114 where @xmath115 is the gauge potential , @xmath116 is the external current sources , the field @xmath117 is given by @xmath118 , and @xmath17 , where @xmath18 is the photon mass .
the proca equation reads @xmath119 in lorenz gauge , according to current conservation , the above equation can be written as @xmath120 each component of @xmath121 satisfies the klein - gordon equation with source , where @xmath122 .
the massy - photon maxwell s equation is given by the proca equation in the three - dimensional versions @xcite , i.e. @xmath123 the associated poynting vector is @xmath124 next , we consider the radiation of massive photons with a certain frequency .
we assume that a point source of strength @xmath125 resides at the origin .
the spherical wave @xmath126 caused by such a source is given by @xmath127 for an outgoing wave with @xmath125 as a function of @xmath128 , one has @xcite @xmath129 . \label{wave_equation}\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore , the dispersion relation is given by @xmath130 this is the standard energy - momentum expression in the special theory of relativity .
the group velocity is variable with frequency , @xmath131 which means that the wave is dispersed and the anomaly at @xmath132 is representative .
since massy photons with different energies have different velocities , one may use extragalactic sources to constrain the photon mass @xcite .
following @xcite , we assume that the electric dipole moment is @xmath133 . in the long - wave - length limit , namely @xmath134 , the vector potential is given by the integral of solutions eq.([wave_equation ] ) , i.e. @xmath135,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath136 is the dispersion relation .
the magnetic and electric fields are given by @xmath137,\nonumber\\ \bm{e}&=&-\frac{ic}{\omega}(\nabla\times\bm{b}+\mu^2\bm{a})=\frac{1}{cr}[\omega^2\bm{p}-k^2\bm{n}(\bm{n}\cdot\bm{p})]\exp[i(\omega t - kr)],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath138 is the unit vector from the origin to @xmath139 .
the poynting vector can be written as @xmath140 therefore , the radiation power per unit solid angle is @xmath141 the total radiation power is @xcite @xmath142 for @xmath21 ; and @xmath143 for @xmath144 . for the magnetic dipole field ,
@xmath145 , @xmath146 , and @xmath147 , where @xmath39 is the magnetic dipole moment , we obtain the symmetric result of the total radiation power of the magnetic dipole field in the vacuum as @xmath148 for @xmath21 ; and @xmath37 for @xmath144 .
here , we calculate the pulsar spindown luminosity using the method of @xcite . at first , we define the enclosed magnetic flux of the open fieldline region as @xmath149 where @xmath150 is the magnetic flux of the open field line in the standard magneto - static dipole model . the last equality is derived from eq.([mag ] ) .
we assume that the flux distribution along the open field lines is close to the michel split - monopole solution @xcite , e.g. , @xmath151 due to magnetospheric rotation , the electric current circuits are generated at the pulsar poles , forming electromagnetic torques antiparallel to the angular momentum of the pulsar , e.g. , @xmath152 , where @xmath153 denotes any stellar cross section , and @xmath154 denotes the poloidal electric current density @xmath154 .
finally , the stellar rotation energy loss through the electromagnetic torques is given by @xcite @xmath155 where @xmath156 is the classical magnetic dipole radiation power , and @xmath157 this result is consistent with eq.([wp ] ) . | pulsars are magnetized rotating compact objects .
they spin down due to magnetic dipole radiation and wind emission .
if photon has a nonzero mass , the spin down rate would be smaller than the zero mass case .
we show that an upper limit of the photon mass , i.e. @xmath0 , could be placed if a pulsar with period @xmath1 is observed to spin down . recently
, a white dwarf ( wd ) m dwarf binary , ar scorpii was found to emit pulsed broadband emission with pulses @xcite .
the spin - down luminosity of the wd can comfortably power the non - thermal radiation from the system . applying our results to the wd pulsar with @xmath2
, we obtain a stringent upper limit of the photon mass of @xmath3 assuming vacuum dipole spindown , or @xmath4 for @xmath5 assuming wind spindown , where @xmath6 is the ratio of wind spindown luminosities between the cases with and without photon mass . |
the known galactic globular clusters ( gc ) - less than 150 ( harris @xcite ) - were discovered mostly through optical searches , that are obviously biased against highly obscured gcs .
since the galaxy is estimated to have @xmath9 gcs ( harris @xcite ) , a certain number of them may still be hidden behind the galactic disk .
the two micron all sky survey ( 2mass ) offers an opportunity to carry a search for the missing gcs , and recently hurt et al .
( @xcite , @xcite ) reported a serendipitous discovery of two new gcs : 2mass gc01 and 2mass gc02 ( gc01 and gc02 hereafter ) .
their estimates suggest @xmath10 mag , rendering these clusters unobservable in the optical wavebands . a summary of the available data for the new clusters is given in table [ tbl-1 ] ( hurt et al .
@xcite ) .
.basic cluster data [ cols="^,^,^,^ " , ]
we carried out the first deep nir photometry of and - new galactic gcs , discovered by the 2mass .
the data suggest that they are metal rich gcs , consistent with their location in the disk .
we detected the rgbs and the rgb bumps and estimated their distance and reddening using the brightness of rgb bumps and the color of the rgb .
we found @xmath4 , @xmath5 kpc , and @xmath11 , @xmath7 , for and respectively . here , we assumed [ fe / h]@xmath120.5 , typical for disk clusters , but a different metal abundance could change our results within @xmath8% .
our data suggest extinction similar to the @xmath13 and @xmath14 mag for and , obtained by hurt et al .
( @xcite ) . a better knowledge of the metal abundance is crucial for an accurate distance and reddening determination with this technique .
we will report a more sophisticated monte - carlo foreground removal method , metallicity estimates , and deeper cmds and color - color diagrams in a subsequent paper .
alves , d.r .
, 2000 , preprint ( astro - ph/0003329 ) carretta , e. , gratton , r. , 1997 , a&as , 121 , 95 davidge , t.j . ,
simons , d.a .
, 1991 , aj , 101 , 1720 ferraro , f.r . , montegriffo , p. , origlia , l. , fusi pecci , f. , 2000 , aj , 119 , 1282 glass , i.s . , feast , m.w .
, 1973 , mnras , 163 , 245 harris , w. , 1991 , ara&a , 29 , 543 harris , w. , 1996 , aj , 112 , 1487 hurt , r.l . , jarrett , t. , cutri , r. , skrutskie , m. , schneider , s. , van driel , w. , 1999 , aas , 194.0711 hurt , r.l . , jarrett , t.h . , kirkpatrick , j.d . ,
cutri , r.m . ,
schneider , s.e . , skrutskie , m. , 2000 , preprint ( astro - ph/0006262 ) ivanov , v.d . ,
borissova , j. , alonso - herrero , a. , russeva , t. , 2000 , aj , 119 , 2274 kuchinski , l.e . ,
frogel , j.a . ,
terndrup d.m . , 1995 , aj , 109 , 1131 persson , s.e . ,
murphy , d.c .
, krzeminski , w. , roth , m. , rieke , m.j . , 1998 , aj , 116 , 2475 rieke , g.h . ,
lebofski , m.j . , 1985 , apj , 288 , 618 stetson , p. , 1993
, user s manual for daophot ii | we present a preliminary report on the first deep infrared photometry of and ( gc01 and gc02 hereafter ) - new galactic globular cluster ( gc ) candidates , discovered by the 2mass .
they both appear to be genuine disk gcs though highly obscured .
the location of the two gcs suggests that they are metal rich - [ fe / h]@xmath00.5 .
we estimated their distance and reddening using the @xmath1 brightness of the red giant branch ( rgb ) bump , and @xmath2 color of the rgb at @xmath3 mag : @xmath4 , @xmath5 kpc , and @xmath6 , @xmath7 mag , for and respectively .
variation in the metal abundance can change our results within @xmath8% . |
in quasi - one dimensional organic conductors tmtsf ( tetrametyltetraselenafulvalence ) salts , there are several experimental evidences of superconductivity , @xcite which exhibit the large critical field being much larger than the pauli limit.@xcite for @xmath1 , the triplet superconducting(sc ) state has been maintained from the measurement of the knight shift and the nmr relaxation rate .
@xcite for @xmath0 , @xcite in the weak magnetic field , the singlet state with line nodes has been suggested by the the knight shift and relaxation rate of the nmr experiment in the sc phase.@xcite further , it has been suggested that the triplet or fflo state emerges under strong magnetic field.@xcite the specific property of @xmath0 emerges due to the anion ordering below 24k .
the folded fermi surfaces with a unit cell containing four tmtsf molecules is obtained from the transfer integrals , which are estimated from the extended hckel method based on the x - ray diffraction measurement.@xcite several theoretical works have been performed to understand the superconductivity in the quasi - one dimensional organic conductors .
the single band models for @xmath1 has been investigated by perturbation theories .
@xcite the magnetic field favors the triplet or fflo superconductivity , @xcite while the on - site repulsion induces the singlet superconductivity in the absence of magnetic field .
@xcite the interplay between the spin and charge fluctuations in the triplet superconductivity has been investigated by the renormalization group theories .
@xcite the inter - site repulsions play important roles for the triplet superconductivity .
@xcite in the multi band models for @xmath0@xcite , on the other hand , the singlet superconductivity with anisotropic gap ( but without line nodes ) has been suggested in the absence of magnetic field.@xcite in the present study , the possible singlet state with line nodes in the absence of magnetic field is investigated , since the experiment indicates the existence of line nodes.@xcite we use the extended multi - site hubbard model representing the system of @xmath0 , when the transfer energies are given by the extended hckel method with the x - ray diffraction measurement.@xcite the unit cell consists of four tmtsf sites owing to the presence of the anion ordering .
fruther , the roles of the charge fluctuation for the triplet state are also investigated on such a multi - site system .
the spin and charge fluctuations are treated by the random phase approximation ( rpa ) on the site - representation , @xcite and the order parameters of the superconductivity are evaluated using the linearized gap equation as described in 2 .
the singlet and triplet superconductivities are investigated by varying the magnitude of the anisotropic nearest - neighbor repulsive interactions with the fixed on - site interaction in 3 .
the origins and properties of those sc states are discussed in 4 . in 5 ,
summary and discussion are given .
figure [ fig : hopping ] ( a ) shows the transfer integrals describing the two - dimensional ( 2d ) electronic system for @xmath0 , where we choose the x - axis along the stacking direction of tmtsf molecules .
the thickness of the lines connecting between the molecules represents the relative magnitude of @xmath2 .
figure [ fig : hopping ] ( b ) displays the inter - site replusive interactions , which are taken in the present model . .
the x - axis is taken as the stacking direction .
the unit cell ( the dotted line ) consists of 4 molecules with several transfer energies @xmath2 .
( b ) inter - site repulsive interactions @xmath3 and @xmath4 , where @xmath4 is discarded . ] based on figs .
[ fig : hopping ] ( a ) and ( b ) , the extended multi - site hubbard model is given by @xmath5 with @xmath6 and @xmath7 where @xmath8 denotes a two dimensional lattice vector for the unit cell , and @xmath9 is a vector connecting different cells .
quantities @xmath10 and @xmath11 are indices of molecules in the unit cell and @xmath12 represent spin . the transfer energies , @xmath2 ,
are obtained by the extended hckel method based on the x - ray diffraction measurement.@xcite coupling constants @xmath13 and @xmath14 correspond to the on - site and nearest neighbor coulomb interactions , respectively . for @xmath14 , there is a relation , @xmath15 .
the unit of the energy is taken as ev .
we investigate the superconductivity by varying the nearest neighbor coulomb interactions between the tmtsf chains , i.e. , @xmath16 along the @xmath17 axis and @xmath18 along the @xmath19 axis ( see fig .
[ fig : hopping ] ( b ) ) . in the rpa ,
the critical value of the nearest neighbor coulomb interaction along the intrachain , @xmath4 , at which the charge fluctuation diverges , is more than twice of those of @xmath16 and @xmath18 .
this comes from the fact that the role of the nesting vector is incompatible with that of @xmath4 .
the same fact has been shown in the renormalization group theory.@xcite thus @xmath4 is discarded in the present study . using fourier transformation ,
the hamiltonian is rewritten as @xmath20 where @xmath21 @xmath22 with @xmath23 , and the other elements are zero .
the transfer energies are given by@xcite @xmath24 and @xmath25 along conduction chains , @xmath26 along y - axis , and @xmath27 where @xmath28 , @xmath29 and @xmath30 correspond to transfer energies between molecules in a unit cell , those between the nearest neighbor cells , and those between the next - nearest neighbor cells , respectively .
note @xmath31 .
we choose @xmath32 for nearest neighbor , i , e , @xmath33 and @xmath34 for next nearest neighbor , i.e. , @xmath35 .
( see fig .
[ fig : hopping](b ) . ) the tight - binding hamiltonian eq .
( [ eq : h - kinetic2 ] ) is diagonalized by @xmath36 where @xmath37 is an index of the band representation and @xmath38 denotes the eigen energy measured from the fermi energy ( @xmath39 ) .
note that the eigenvector @xmath40 gives the transformation from the site representation to the band representation . in fig .
[ fig : bands](a ) , the energy band spectrum is shown .
there are four bands due to four molecules in the unit cell where the first and second bands from the top crosses the fermi surface .
the shape of quasi one - dimensional fermi surface is shown in fig .
[ fig : bands](b ) representing the folded fermi surface . in fig .
[ fig : fermis ] , the density of states , @xmath41 , is shown where @xmath42 and sum rule is given by @xmath43 .
these double one - dimensional fermi surfaces have been observed by amro@xcite .
the spin and charge fluctuations in the weak coupling regime are treated by rpa . @xcite where the site representation@xcite for singlet and triplet pairing interactions are given respectively as @xmath44 @xmath45 the hat denotes a matrix representation with an element @xmath46 .
the pairing interactions are obtained from @xmath47 and @xmath48 which denote spin susceptibility and charge susceptibility ; @xmath49 and @xmath50 the quantity @xmath51 is an irreducible susceptibility which is given by @xmath52 where @xmath53 is the fermi distribution and @xmath54 denotes temperature . in order to examine a symmetry of order parameter of the superconductivity ,
we solve numerically a linearized gap equation given by , @xmath55 \sigma^a_{\alpha \beta}({\bf k ' } ) .\ ] ] @xmath56 is anomalous self energy and @xmath57 denotes a bare green s function written as @xmath58 where @xmath59 is matsubara - frequency ( @xmath60 ) and n is an integer . the quantity @xmath61 ( a = singlet , triplet ) denotes the paring interactions for singlet state and triplet state which are rewritten as @xmath62 and @xmath63 the r.h.s . of eqs .
( [ eq : psinglet2 ] ) and ( [ eq : ptriplet2 ] ) is given by @xmath64 @xmath65 @xmath66 note that @xmath67 and @xmath68 represent spin fluctuation , and @xmath69 denotes the charge fluctuation .
the transition temperature for the sc state , @xmath70 , is determined by the condition , @xmath71 .
the gap function at @xmath72 , @xmath73 , is estimated from @xmath74 , where @xmath75 is chosen to reproduce the gap which is expected from @xmath70 . @xcite using @xmath73 , we get the quasi - particle bands @xmath76 by diagonalizing hamiltonian @xmath77 , @xmath78 @xmath79 where @xmath80 given by eq .
( [ eq : h - kinetic2 ] ) with the 3/4 filling , where the two bands 1 and 2 from the top cross the fermi energy , @xmath81 .
( b ) the fermi surfaces for the first and second bands , where the arrow represents the nesting vector . ]
in the present study temperature is fixed at t = 0.01 [ ev ] .
we take 24 @xmath82 24 meshes for calculating the bands , the susceptibilities , and the superconductivity .
the energy bands are shown in fig .
[ fig : bands](a ) .
since the electrons are @xmath83-filled , the fermi surfaces exist in upper two bands .
the density of states ( dos ) is shown in fig .
[ fig : fermis ] .
there is a large van hove singularity above the fermi energy .
now we consider the electron correlation effects .
it is expected that @xmath13 plays important roles for superconductivity in @xmath0 , because @xmath0 is located next to the spin density wave ( sdw ) state in the phase diagram suggested by jerome.@xcite then we calculate the possible sc states in @xmath0 by choosing @xmath84 which is close to the critical value for the divergence of the spin fluctuation in the rpa .
we investigate the roles of the charge fluctuation by varying the interchain repulsive interactions , @xmath16 and @xmath18 , with the fixed @xmath13 , where we define @xmath85 as @xmath86 and @xmath87 at @xmath88 and @xmath89 . the red and blue represent the repulsive and attractive interactions , respectively
. the symbol o corresponds to @xmath90 . ] for @xmath90 , spin and charge pairing interactions ( @xmath91 and @xmath92 ) are shown in fig .
[ fig : pair ] where @xmath91 is much larger than @xmath92 .
the susceptibility @xmath47 which determines @xmath91 is strongly enhanced by @xmath13 compared with @xmath48 , since the @xmath93 vector for the peak of @xmath47 is the same as the nesting vector .
now we examine numerically eq . ( [ eq : linear - gapeq ] ) to find that @xmath94 for spin singlet is larger than that for spin triplet , e.g. , @xmath95 for the singlet state and 0.3 for the triplet state at @xmath96 and @xmath90 . in the present paper , a phase factor in anomalous self energy
is determined in order to maximize the value @xmath97 .
the anomalous self energy consists of 16 elements of @xmath98 on the basis of site representation .
diagonal elements @xmath99 are larger than others .
the momentum dependence of these elements is given by `` @xmath100 '' which indicates a sign change on a line separating two fermi surfaces in fig .
[ fig : bands](b ) .
the absence of the node on the fermi surface , which gives a full gap state ( written as `` singlet ( full ) '' ) , is consistent with that of shimahara s result . @xcite as for the off - diagonal element of @xmath56 , there is a clear contribution from the same chain , e.g. , ( 1,2 ) and ( 3,4 ) , while that from the interchain is negligibly small .
these behavior of intrachain dependence suggests a role of dimerization , which reduces to the half - filled band as shown in fig .
[ fig : bands ] . for singlet and triplet states for @xmath101 .
the horizontal axis is shown for @xmath102 which represents from the point ( o ) to ( a ) , from the point ( o ) to ( d ) and from the point ( o ) to ( g ) , where these points in the parameter space are given by @xmath103=(0,0 ) ( o ) , ( 0.00,0.64 ) ( a ) , ( 0.33,0.62 ) ( d ) , and ( 0.70,0.00 ) ( g ) , respectively
. the solid line denotes @xmath94 for the singlet state and the dashed line denotes @xmath94 for the triplet state . ] ) for @xmath104 . where parameters corresponding to points ( a ) , ( d ) , ( e ) and ( g ) are ( 0.00,0.64 ) , ( 0.33,0.62 ) , ( 0.49,0.49 ) , and ( 0.70,0.00 ) , respectively .
the attractive interaction is represented by blue on the @xmath105-@xmath106 plane . for the comparison ,
@xmath107 is shown . ]
we examine the effect of inter chain interactions @xmath85 to find a possibility of new sc state which is induced by charge fluctuation . with increasing @xmath85 , @xmath48 increases , and diverges at @xmath108 . in order to calculate the region where the charge fluctuation becomes a dominant one ,
@xmath85 is chosen to satisfy the condition that @xmath109 and @xmath110 .
we examine the sc state on the line from @xmath103=(0,0 ) ( o ) to several points given by @xmath103=(0.00,0.64 ) ( a ) , ( 0.11,0.64 ) ( b ) , ( 0.21,0.64 ) ( c ) , ( 0.33,0.62 ) ( d ) , ( 0.49,0.49 ) ( e ) , ( 0.67,0.22 ) ( f ) and ( 0.70,0.00 ) ( g ) , respectively .
the ratio of @xmath16 to @xmath18 increases as the point moves from ( a ) to ( g ) . by solving eq .
( [ eq : linear - gapeq ] ) , @xmath94 for singlet and triplet states are calculated and the larger one is chosen as the expected state . in the region of small @xmath85 , the singlet sc state similar to one at @xmath89 is realized where the state with a full gap is found . in fig .
[ fig : lv ] , the @xmath85 dependence of @xmath94 of both singlet and triplet states is shown as a function of @xmath85 for three cases of ( o ) @xmath111 ( a ) , ( o ) @xmath111 ( d ) , and ( o ) @xmath111 ( g ) .
for the variation from ( o ) to ( a ) , ( the first case ) , the singlet state is suppressed and the triplet state is expected . for the variation of @xmath85 from ( o ) to ( d ) ( the second case ) , the singlet state moves to the triplet state close to @xmath112 . for the variation of @xmath85 from ( o ) to ( g ) ( the third case ) , the singlet state remains as the dominant state but moves to another singlet state ( as explained later ) after @xmath94 takes a minimum close to ( g ) .
here we note the v dependence of @xmath94 for triplet state , which is enhanced by @xmath48 . from eq .
( [ eq : p - triplet ] ) , the term for the spin fluctuation and that for the charge fluctuation has the same sign in triplet pairing interaction .
although the triplet sc state is enhanced but the singlet state is suppressed by charge fluctuations , such an effect becomes large only close to @xmath112 .
this is why the singlet state is favored and the region for the triplet state is small even in the presence of @xmath85 .
now we examine the respective sc state precisely based on the pairing interaction shown in figs . [
fig : pair2 ] and anomalous self - energy .
( i ) first , we discuss the case indicating a possible triplet sc state , which is given by ( a ) and ( d ) .
when @xmath48 is increased by @xmath85 , the singlet state is suppressed but the triplet state is enhanced ( fig .
[ fig : pair2 ] ( a ) and ( d ) ) .
actually , the competition between these two kinds of fluctuations occurs for the singlet state as seen from eq .
( [ eq : p - singlet ] ) and by noting a fact that the peak position of @xmath92 is nearly the same as that of @xmath113 from fig .
[ fig : pair ] . the triplet state may be expected when @xmath114 , and is rather favored by the introduction of @xmath16 .
when the point moves from ( a ) to ( d ) ( i.e. , increasing @xmath16 ) , the peak position of @xmath92 begins to deviate slightly from @xmath115 and the attractive interaction increases due to the increase of the amount of @xmath92 integrated with respect to the momentum .
\(ii ) secondly , we study the region where the singlet state is favored by the effects of @xmath48 ( points ( e ) - ( g ) .
the pairing interactions ( @xmath92 ) induced by charge fluctuation are shown in figs . [
fig : pair2 ] ( e ) and ( g ) where the position of the peak is different from that of in @xmath47 . as a result ,
the effect of @xmath48 on the singlet pairing state becomes compatible with that of @xmath47 for @xmath116 .
further since @xmath92 is larger than @xmath91 , the spin singlet state is determined mainly by @xmath48 and is assisted by @xmath47 .
the change of the self - energy along @xmath117 axis is very small .
this comes from the difference in the peak position of charge fluctuations i.e. , @xmath115 for ( a ) and that on the @xmath117 axis for ( e ) and ( g ) . .
] finally , we examine the node of the gap , which is calculated from eqs .
( [ eq : bcsh ] ) and ( [ eq : diago2 ] ) .
figure [ fig : nodes ] denotes the position of nodes and fermi surfaces for points ( o ) , ( f ) , ( g ) and ( d ) . for the singlet state ( o ) , which is mediated by @xmath47 the node exists between two different fermi surfaces implying a full gap due to the existence of the two bands.@xcite for ( f ) and ( g ) ,
the singlet state mediated by @xmath48 has two nodes at @xmath118 , which cross the fermi surfaces .
gap function for triplet has a node on the line @xmath119 suggesting a full - gap state .
we have found the possible singlet sc state with the line nodes in the extended multi - site hubbard model representing @xmath0 with the multi - band and under the anion ordering .
such a state is induced by the charge fluctuation owing to the interchain coulomb interaction @xmath16 ( along the @xmath17-axis ) , while the singlet sc state with anisotropic ( but finite ) gap suggested by shimahara@xcite is reproduced in the presence of the strong spin fluctuation .
moreover , we have investigated the roles of the charge fluctuation for the triplet sc state .
it is found that the triplet state appears in a certain range of the interchain coulomb interactions , @xmath16 and @xmath18 , it is noted that the charge fluctuation cooperates with the spin fluctuation for the triplet pairing , but competes for the singlet pairing .
for such a triplet state , the p - wave like state is obtained in the present multi - site model , while the f - wave gap function have been suggested in the single site models .
@xcite finally we discuss how to distinguish the sc state with the lines and that with full gap of anisotropy on the fermi surface . using a maximum , @xmath120 , and a minimum , @xmath121 , for the latter case
, @xmath122 reveals the exponential behavior at low temperature , i.e. , @xmath123 . in the preset case
, it is expected that @xmath122 exhibits exponential decrease at lower temperatures than @xmath124k using the ratio given by both our and shimahara s results . on the other hand , yonezawa et al .
have reported that the @xmath122 exhibits @xmath125 behavior at temperatures lower than @xmath126k@xcite .
this fact suggests that the sc state with the line nodes supports the result of the nmr experiment in the absence of magnetic field .
we are thank to s. yonezawa , y. maeno , h. shimahara for useful discussions . this work was financially supported in part by a grant - in - aid for special coordination funds for promoting science and technology ( scf ) , scientific research on innovative areas 20110002 , and scientific research 19740205 from the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology of japan .
99 k. bechgaard , k. carneiro , m. olsen , f. b. rasmussen , and c. s. jacobsen 1981 _ phys .
lett . _ * 46 * 852 . m. takigawa , h. yasuoka , and g. saito 1987 _ j. phys .
jpn . _ * 56 * 873 - 876 .
d. jrome 1991 _ sciense _ * 252 * 1509 .
j. shinagawa , y. kurosaki , f. zhang , s. e. brown , d. jrome , j. b. christensen , and k. bechgaard 2007 _ phys .
lett . _ * 98 * 147002 . i. j. lee , m. j. naughton , g. m. danner and p. m. chaikin 1997 _ phys . rev
. lett . _ * 78 * 3555 .
i. j. lee , s. e. brown , w. g. clark , m. j. strouse , m. j. naughton , w. kang , and p. m. chaikin 2002 _ phys .
lett . _ * 88 * 017004 .
i. j. lee , d. s. chow , w. g. clark , m. j. strouse , m. j. naughton , p. m. chaikin , and s. e. brown 2003 _ phys .
b _ * 68 * 092510
. s. yonezawa , s. kusaba , y. maeno , p. auban - senzier , c. pasquier , k. bechgaard , and d. jrome 2008 _ phys .
_ * 100 * 117002 .
s. yonezawa , s. kusaba , y. maeno , p. auban - senzier , c. pasquier , and d. jrome 2008 _ j. phys .
_ * 77 * 054712 .
s. kusaba , s. yonezawa , y. maeno , p. auban - senzier , c. pasquier , k. bechgaard , d. jrome 2008 solid state science * 10 * 1768 - 1772
. h. yoshino , a. oda , t. sakaki , t. hanajiri , j. yamada , s. nakatsuji , h. anzai and k. murata 1999 _ j. phys .
jpn . _ * 68 * 3142 .
j. p. pouget , g. shirane , k. bechgaard and j. m. fabre 1983 _ phys .
b _ * 27 * 5203 .
d. le pvelen , j. gaultier , y. barrans , d. chasseau , f. castet , and l. ducasse 2001 _ the european physical journal b _ * 19 * 363 . y. tanaka , and k. kuroki 2004 _ phys . rev . b _ * 70 * 060502
. k. kuroki , and y. tanaka 2005 _ j. phys .
jpn . _ * 74 * 1694 .
h. aizawa , k. kuroki , and y. tanaka 2008 _ phys .
b _ * 77 * 144513 . h. aizawa , k. kuroki , t. yokoyama , and y. tanaka 2009 _ phys . rev
. lett . _ * 102 * 016403 . n. belmechri , g. abramovici , and m. heritier 2008 _ eur .
lett . _ * 82 * 47009 .
h. kino , and h. kontani 1999 _ j. phys .
_ * 68 * 1481 .
r. duprat , and c. bourbonnais 2001 _ eur . phys .
j. b. _ * 21 * 219 .
y. fuseya , and y. suzumura 2005 _ j. phys .
jpn . _ * 74 * 1263 .
j. c. nickel , r. duprat , c. bourbonnais , and n. dupuis 2005 _ phys .
lett . _ * 95 * 247001 .
h. shimahara 2000 _ phys .
b _ * 61 * 14936 .
y. hasegawa and k. kishigi 2008 _ phys . rev .
b _ * 78 * 045117
. a. kobayashi , y. tanaka , m. ogata , and y. suzumura 2004 _ j. phys .
_ * 73 * 1115 .
a. kobayashi , s. katayama , k. noguchi , and y. suzumura 2004 _ j. phys .
jpn . _ * 73 * 3135 . | we have theoretically investigated the spin and charge fluctuations in the quasi - one dimensional organic superconductor @xmath0 . using the extended multi - site hubbard model , which contains four sites in a unit cell and the transfer energies obtained by the extended hckel method
, we calculate the linearized gap equation with the random phase approximation , to find novel order parameters of superconductivity due to several kinds of charge fluctuations induced by the anisotropic intersite repulsive interactions . for the singlet state ,
the order parameter with line nodes appears in the case of the strong charge fluctuation , while the order parameter with anisotropic gap suggested by shimahara is reproduced in the spin fluctuation .
the triplet state is also obtained for the wide parameter range of repulsive interactions due to a cooperation between charge and spin fluctuations .
organic conductor , tmtsf , superconductivity , electron correlation , spin fluctuation , charge fluctuation |
over the past twenty years , discoveries of planets , stars and substellar objects have demonstrated the enormous diversity of astrophysical bodies in the universe .
thanks to modern techniques and technology , it is now possible to study the atmospheres of these objects and retrieve some knowledge of their composition , structure and dynamics .
however , these are extremely complex systems to model and accurate observations are still difficult to perform . in particular , it is crucial for the correct characterisation of these atmospheres that complete and accurate descriptions of the molecules that comprise them are available . here
phosphine , or ph@xmath6 , is considered .
phosphorus is the one of the most abundant chemically reactive volatile elements in a solar type system ( with s , after h , c , n and o ) .
although phosphorus has considerably smaller cosmic abundances than h , o , c or n , it is predicted to have an important role in atmospheric chemistry and dynamics .
phosphorus is not particularly common in the universe but it is ubiquitous and is important for most essential biochemical functions . due to its role as biogenic particle , phosphorus
could potentially be used in the search for extinct or extant life in other planets @xcite . a large fraction of the existing phosphorus in various astronomical environments
is expected to be found in the form of phosphine , or ph@xmath6 @xcite .
phosphine is an extremely toxic , semi - rigid , relatively stable , oblate , symmetric - top molecule , and has so far been detected in the lower troposphere of the earth , the atmospheres of jupiter and saturn , and in the carbon star envelope irc + 10216 @xcite .
partially due to the lack of strong absorption from ch@xmath7 , the 5 @xmath2 m spectral window is a region of low opacity in jupiter , saturn and the earth s atmosphere . alongside other molecules ( co , geh@xmath7 , ash@xmath1 )
, ph@xmath1 is partly responsible for the continuum opacity in this region and has detectable absorption bands @xcite , specifically the @xmath8 overtone bending band . in jupiter
, phosphorus is found at approximately tropospheric solar abundances ( 1.1 ppm ) in the form of phosphine , and is over four times more abundant in saturn ( 4.5 ppm ) , also as phosphine @xcite .
this agrees with models of core accretion that expect saturn to have a considerably larger fraction of ice to gas than jupiter . in both planets ,
this abundance of a disequilibrium species like phosphine at observable levels of the atmosphere reflects both a large reservoir in deep regions of the planets and the strength of the convective transport of the molecule . in local thermochemical equilibrium ( lte )
, p@xmath9o@xmath10 would be expected to dominate the upper atmospheres of planets with approximate solar abundances .
however , almost no p@xmath9o@xmath10 is found in these environments because phosphine quenching and rapid vertical mixing from regions where ph@xmath1 is dominant leads to high disequilibrium abundances .
this quenching occurs because timescales for the conversion of ph@xmath6 to p@xmath9o@xmath10 are much larger than the convective timescales , so the production of p@xmath9o@xmath10 is kinetically inhibited @xcite .
disequilibrium chemistry is expected to lead to phosphine being orders of magnitude more abundant than predicted by equilibrium models , both for environments where t @xmath11 and at the uppermost atmosphere of most substellar objects @xcite .
the thermal decomposition of phosphine at high temperatures has been studied for a long time , starting with @xcite .
recently @xcite discussed at length the pressure and temperature parameters at which phosphine is expected to be found in solar composition and lte environments . at 1 bar , phosphine is predicted to be a dominant phosphorus carrying molecule in environments with temperatures up to about 1500 k , and it is expected to contribute to the composition of atmospheres up to about 2500 k if the pressure is above 3 bar . the detection of phosphine can therefore be used as a chemical probe for deep layers of both jupiter and saturn s atmosphere , as it is only present at the top layers through vertical mixing .
analysis of future observations of jupiter from nasa s texes , nasa s juno and esa s juice will require accurate data on phosphine , and past observations of saturn from cassini / vims and cassini / cirs will gain from further understanding its spectrum @xcite . suspected inaccuracies found in regions of the existing phosphine data may be behind misinterpretation of previous astronomical data @xcite . additionally , juno will cover the full latitude and longitude of jupiter and its analysis of the polar atmosphere of jupiter should confirm a depletion of phosphine in the polar vortices analogous to saturn s @xcite .
titan has also been predicted to contain phosphine , but spectrum recorded with cassini cirs failed to detect any , putting an upper limit of 1 ppb on the phosphine abundance of its atmosphere @xcite .
similar unsuccessful detections of phosphine in neptune and uranus suggest that the abundance of phosphorus on these planets is sub solar @xcite , with an upper limit of 0.1 times solar p / h abundance .
the existence of phosphine outside the solar system has recently been confirmed by @xcite in the carbon star envelope irc + 10216 , with an abundance of @xmath12 relative to h@xmath13 .
this was done using the hifi instrument on board herschel .
together with hcp , ph@xmath6 is one of the major phosphorus carriers in the inner circumstellar regions .
there have been multiple predictions of phosphine in many other astrophysical environments , but its presence and formation scenarios remain poorly understood and none has been found outside the solar system other than the aforementioned discovery of circumstellar phosphine in irc + 10216 .
this is due to a variety of factors , including the sparsity of fundamental data which this work is rectifying .
below are some of the expectations for further phosphine detection .
a particular region of interest is the 4.1 - 5.1 @xmath2 m window , which is found to be an interval of very low opacities in both jupiter and saturn .
it is therefore expected that detection of ph@xmath1 in this region could be used as a marker for vertical convection and a tracer for tropospheric dynamics in the upper atmospheres of other astronomical bodies , namely hot jupiters and brown dwarfs . in y
dwarfs , with @xmath14 k , phosphine should exhibit a strong feature in the mid - infrared at 4.3 @xmath2 m @xcite , where it is predicted to be the dominant source of opacity .
t dwarfs , with @xmath15 k , will mostly be dominated by other molecules ( e.g. h@xmath16 , nh@xmath1 , ch@xmath7 , co , h@xmath16o and co@xmath16 ) but phosphine can still have a significant contribution to the shape of the spectrum .
the nirspec near - infrared spectrograph on jwst will be able to collect spectra in the 2.9 - 5 @xmath2 m region with sufficient sensitivity to detect the presence or absence of phosphine , particularly for slightly cooler y dwarfs with @xmath17 k @xcite .
phosphine is predicted to be the dominant phosphorus molecule in cool t dwarfs like gliese 229b where it is expected to carry all the phosphorus in the atmosphere to the top layers , with approximately 0.6 ppm .
ph@xmath1 should be detectable ( for resolutions higher than 1.2 @xmath4 ) in the 4.45 - 5.40 @xmath2 m spectral window of gliese 229b , particularly the 4.3 @xmath2 m feature @xcite .
models estimate that , for regions where @xmath181155 k , the major phosphorus carrying gas in gliese 229b is phosphine , with rapid vertical mixing quenching its destruction @xcite . as the temperature rises , ph@xmath6 is converted to p@xmath9o@xmath10 , but it should still be present at observable heights . in hotter environments , like hd209458b and l dwarfs , where phosphorus equilibrium chemistry is approached , the phosphine abundances decrease significantly to about 50 ppb @xcite .
it is still possible to detect phosphine in these atmospheres , but higher resolution is required to distinguish its features from that of neighbouring co bands @xcite .
however , phosphine is expected to be the dominant phosphorus carrying species at the observable atmosphere of hot t dwarfs and cool l dwarfs , with effective temperatures between 1000 and 1400 k @xcite .
there are still disequilibrium effects that are not completely understood .
for example , observations of saturn s upper troposphere found that phosphine abundances decreased with depth @xcite , contradicting the proposal that phosphine is dredged up through vertical mixing from deeper layers of the atmosphere . this depletion is not understood , as there is no known formation mechanism for phosphine at the upper levels of saturn s atmosphere that could lead to the abundances observed . suggested explanations for this inconsistency are a poor understanding of the aerosol opacity in the vims observations and intensity uncertainties in the molecular data .
future detections of phosphine can only be achieved by accurately modelling these atmospheres .
this requires an extensive knowledge of the temperature dependent spectrum of phosphine , which can only be established with a comprehensive line list .
there are multiple sources of phosphine data @xcite , both experimental and theoretical , which are further described in our previous paper on room temperature phosphine @xcite .
additionally , a recent paper by @xcite improved the experimental phosphine spectrum for the 4.085.13 @xmath2 m region , which , as mentioned above , is of particular importance due to it being an interval of low opacity in gas giants and brown dwarfs @xcite .
most of these experimental sources have already been incorporated in the hitran database @xcite and collectively contain less than 30 000 lines , and no wavelength coverage shorter than 2.7 @xmath2 m .
despite these efforts , no complete line list for hot phosphine exists in the literature .
the line lists mentioned above only cover low values of rotational excitations , a small number of bands , and some regions are missing altogether .
often , contamination of gas samples affects the measured intensities @xcite , and this can be an effect that is hard to accurately compensate for .
it is not unusual for experimental data with extremely accurate line positions to have intensity uncertainties well above 10% .
additionally , all the experimental datasets mentioned above are designed to be used only at room temperature and below . consequently , they are insufficiently complete to be appropriate for use in the characterisation of atmospheres of any astronomical bodies at higher temperatures .
a theoretical line list for phosphine was previously computed by us @xcite , henceforth syt .
however , although syt contains many orders of magnitude more lines than any previous phosphine line list ( 137 million transitions between 5.6 million energy levels ) , it too was only designed to be accurate for temperatures below 300 k , making it unsuitable for most astronomical studies . since hitemp @xcite , hitran s high - temperature database , does not include phosphine , salty is the first line list suitable for modelling phosphine spectra in environments up to 1500 k. the completeness and coverage of the salty line list makes it particularly suitable for studies of non - lte environments .
the current work is performed as part of the exomol project .
this project aims to provide line lists of spectroscopic transitions for key molecular species which are likely to be important in the atmospheres of extrasolar planets and cool stars ; its aims , scope and methodology are summarised in @xcite .
the salty line list builds on previously released ones for polyatomic hydrides such as water @xcite , ammonia @xcite , formaldehyde @xcite , and methane @xcite .
finally we note that energy levels generated for this work have been used as part of a study to compute thermodynamic properties of phosphine and ammonia , including its partition function , for temperatures up to 6000 k @xcite .
in the following ph@xmath1 and phosphine will refer to the main isotopologue @xmath0ph@xmath1 , since @xmath0p is the only non - synthetic , stable isotope of phosphorus .
salty is a catalogue of transitions , each characterised by a frequency , its lower and upper energy level , einstein coefficient and quantum numbers .
together these fully describe the spectrum of the phosphine molecule within the frequency range 0 10 000 @xmath4 , or wavelengths longer than 1 @xmath2 m .
it contains 16 803 703 395 transitions between 7 480 690 energy levels below 18 000 @xmath4 , with rotational quantum number @xmath19 values up to 46 .
the highest energy state considered is 18 000 @xmath4 above the zero - point energy ( 5 213.9280 @xmath4 ) for phosphine , as the intensity of transitions to higher energy levels is too weak to be important , even at temperatures of 1500 k. consequently , to ensure that the line list is complete within the frequency range 0 10 000 @xmath4 , the highest lower energy state considered is 8 000 @xmath4 .
all transitions are within the ground electronic state of phosphine , since the first excited electronic state is above the dissociation limit of the molecule .
the strongest salty transition has an einstein-@xmath20 coefficient of @xmath21 s@xmath22 while the weakest lines go down to @xmath23 s@xmath22 . in non - lte environments
even extremely weak lines can play an important role in the shape of a spectrum .
this is the reason behind including transitions with extremely weak absorptions in salty .
the final line list is presented in the exomol format @xcite , with a transition file ordered in increasing transition frequency and an energy file .
the former contains a description of each transition by its upper ( final ) and lower ( initial ) energy level reference numbers ( @xmath24 and @xmath25 ) , as well as the electric dipole transition probability represented as an einstein coefficient @xmath26 in s@xmath22 . using this information ,
the line intensity of each transition can be calculated for any given temperature .
the latter connects each index with the description of the corresponding energy level .
each energy level is described by the quantum numbers associated with the molecular group symmetry @xcite , @xmath27(m ) for ph@xmath1 and total angular momentum @xmath19 .
the quantum numbers for xy@xmath1 molecules are quite complicated and have recently been discussed in detail for ammonia by @xcite .
our ph@xmath1 quantum numbers follow the same general principles but are somewhat simpler since we neglect the possibility of a tunnelling mode .
each energy level is described by the following quantum numbers : @xmath28 where @xmath29 . here
the vibrational quantum numbers @xmath30 ( symmetric stretch ) , @xmath31 ( symmetric bend ) , @xmath32 ( asymmetric stretch ) and @xmath33 ( asymmetric bend ) correspond to excitations of , respectively , the @xmath34 , @xmath35 , @xmath36 and @xmath37 modes .
the doubly degenerate modes @xmath36 and @xmath37 require additional quantum numbers @xmath38 and @xmath39 describing the projections of the corresponding angular momenta ( see @xcite ) .
the vibrational quantum number @xmath40 , characterizes the coupling of @xmath41 and @xmath42 .
the projection of the total vibrational angular momentum @xmath43 is included to reduce ambiguity in the description of the energy levels , as it was in syt @xcite .
@xmath44 , @xmath45 , and @xmath46 are , respectively , the symmetry species of the rotational , vibrational and total internal wave - functions in the molecular symmetry group @xmath47(m ) , spanning @xmath48 , @xmath49 and @xmath50 , where @xmath50 is two - fold degenerate .
@xmath19 is the total angular momentum and @xmath51 is the projection of the total angular momentum on the molecule fixed axis @xmath52 .
these twelve quantum numbers reduce ambiguity to the assignment of the energy levels . however , only @xmath19 and @xmath53 are rigorous ; at higher energies , energy states can not necessarily be assigned unambiguous quantum labels .
apart from the quantum numbers we also provide the largest eigen - coefficient used to produce the theoretical assignment , see , for example , @xcite .
since ph@xmath1 transitions obey the strict selection rules @xmath54 , and @xmath55 , no higher @xmath19 values were considered because @xmath56 is the highest value of @xmath19 for which there are eigenvalues exist below 8 000 @xmath4 , which is the highest lower energy threshold used in salty .
excerpts from the energy and transition files are given in tables [ t : energy - file ] and [ t : transit - file ] , respectively , with seven additional columns giving trove quantum numbers which are described in the supplementary data and by @xcite .
as per the exomol convention , these are named salty.transitions and salty.states .
the complete line list is freely available and can be downloaded from the strasbourg data centre , cds , via ftp://cdsarc.u-strasbg.fr/pub/cats/j/mnras/ or from the exomol website , www.exomol.com .
the website also offers the opportunity to download cross sections @xcite .
.[t : energy - file ] extract from the salty energy file . [
cols="^,>,>,>,>,>,>,>,>,>,>,>,>,>,>,>,>,>,>,>,>,>",options="header " , ] using the equations above and the present line list , multiple cross - sections were simulated for ph@xmath1
. figures [ ph3_overview ] and [ ph3_zooms ] illustrate the temperature dependence of phosphine for @xmath57 = 300 , 500 , 1000 , 1500 and 2000 k. it can be seen that the spectra at higher temperatures have less features and a loss of sharp @xmath58-branches .
figure [ ph3_zooms ] , part * c * , covers the wavelength region 3.8 5.1 @xmath2 m which , as mention above , is of particular importance for the spectral characterisation of brown dwarfs and gas giants .
[ f : nlines : temp ] demonstrates how the density of lines per an absorption intensity @xmath59 unit changes with temperature , covering the whole wavenumber range 010 000 @xmath4 . as the temperature rises , the number of intense lines increases but the range of intensities in the spectrum becomes narrower .
the gaussian - like intensity distributions peak at @xmath60 = @xmath61 , @xmath62 , @xmath63 , and @xmath63 for @xmath57 = 298 , 500 , 1000 , and 1500 k , respectively .
this is different from the intensity distribution found for ch@xmath9 by @xcite , where the proportion of strong lines was found to be much larger .
@xcite offers a detailed comparison of syt to the existing experimental data , where it was found that it replicates very well the observed phosphine spectra at room temperature , with a maximum rms deviation from cdms @xcite of 0.076 @xmath4 for the rotational spectrum and of 0.23 @xmath4 from hitran @xcite . as can be seen from fig .
[ hitran_comparison ] , the salty line list is also in excellent agreement with hitran ( and incorporated cdms data ) , and it is expected that salty will have slightly lower rms deviations from experiment at this temperature .
the most recent cdms update @xcite contains a very comprehensive description of the pure rotational band of phosphine .
figure [ cdms ] demonstrates that salty is in excellent agreement with the cdms data .
the transitions in the bottom left box shows a deviation of approximately 0.01 @xmath4 , while the right most box , at higher wavenumbers , shows a deviation of approximately 0.04 @xmath4 .
the apparent intensity disagreements with hitran occur because of an overestimation of the intensity of some of the degenerate @xmath64 transitions which are in such close proximity that they have been perceived as one doubly strong transition in the experimental data .
this has been partially resolved by @xcite , who corrected these intensities for the region 1950 to 2450 @xmath4 .
the bottom left box in figure [ hitran_comparison ] includes this data , and it can be seen salty is in much better agreement with it than with the hitran data .
we recommend that the @xcite data should be included in the next release of hitran .
the data in hitran are generally very accurate for room temperature simulations . however ,
if the current hitran database is used to simulate high temperature spectra , the differences become much more striking , as can be seen in fig .
[ hightemp_overview ] .
the only available data above 300 k comes from the pacific northwest national laboratory ( pnnl ) who provide cross - sections for ph@xmath6 up to temperatures of 323 k @xcite . comparisons with salty for @xmath65 c , or 323 k , can be seen in fig .
[ f : pnnl ] .
the pnnl data is approximately @xmath66 weaker than salty s , but both are otherwise in good agreement . given its larger density and coverage , it is recommended that salty is used to simulate cross - sections , even at low temperatures .
an accurate and comprehensive line list for phosphine is presented , which has been called salty .
it contains 16.8 billion transitions between 7.5 million energy levels and it is suitable for simulating spectra up to temperatures of 1500 k. its only limitations are : upper states with energies above 18000 @xmath4 are excluded , and there is an effective short - end wavelength cut - off of 1 @xmath2 m , which is an unimportant region for ph@xmath6 .
salty improves on the previous room temperature phosphine line list syt in terms of the size of the basis set , corresponding refined potential energy surface and increased spectral range .
it is therefore recommended that salty is used for all applications , even at low temperatures where syt would provide reasonable results .
the tunnelling effect present in ammonia is predicted in phosphine but has yet to be observed in phosphine @xcite , due to its much higher inversion barrier ( 12 300 @xmath4 ) .
this tunnelling effect is not considered here , but rough preliminary calculations have predicted the position , size and intensity of transitions from split energy levels . further work on this effect will be published elsewhere .
the salty line list is presented as the latest in a series of molecules as part of the exomol project , which aims to provide comprehensive line lists for every molecule relevant to the characterisation of the atmospheres of cool stars and exoplanets .
salty is freely available online in full or filtered by wavelength and intensity , from the exomol website .
the line list in its entirety is very large but can be made more manageable by using cross sections @xcite ( available at exomol ) or @xmath67-coefficients @xcite .
this work was supported by the erc advanced investigator project 267219 .
the research made use of the dirac@darwin , dirac@cosmos and the emerald hpc clusters .
dirac is the uk hpc facility for particle physics , astrophysics and cosmology and is supported by stfc and bis .
the cosmos shared memory system at damtp , university of cambridge operated on behalf of the stfc dirac hpc facility .
this equipment is funded by bis national e - infrastructure capital grant st / j005673/1 and stfc grants st / h008586/1 , st / k00333x/1 .
the emerald high performance computing facility is provided via the centre for innovation ( cfi ) .
the cfi is formed from the universities of bristol , oxford , southampton and ucl in partnership with stfc rutherford appleton laboratory .
we thank james briggs ( cosmos ) and cheng liao ( sgi ) for their help with the plasma eigensolver .
tennyson j. , hill c. , yurchenko s. n. , 2013 , in aip conference proceedings , vol .
1545 , 6@xmath68 international conference on atomic and molecular data and their applications icamdata-2012 , aip , new york , pp . | a comprehensive hot line list is calculated for @xmath0ph@xmath1 in its ground electronic state .
this line list , called salty , contains almost 16.8 billion transitions between 7.5 million energy levels and it is suitable for simulating spectra up to temperatures of 1500 k. it covers wavelengths longer than 1 @xmath2 m and includes all transitions to upper states with energies below @xmath3 @xmath4 and rotational excitation up to @xmath5 .
the line list is computed by variational solution of the schrdinger equation for the rotation - vibration motion employing the nuclear - motion program trove .
a previously reported _ ab initio _
dipole moment surface is used as well as an updated ` spectroscopic ' potential energy surface ( pes ) , obtained by refining an existing _ ab initio _ surface through least - squares fitting to the experimentally derived energies .
detailed comparisons with other available sources of phosphine transitions confirms salty s accuracy and illustrates the incompleteness of previous experimental and theoretical compilations for temperatures above 300 k. atmospheric models are expected to severely underestimate the abundance of phosphine in disequilibrium environments , and it is predicted that phosphine will be detectable in the upper troposphere of many substellar objects .
this list is suitable for modelling atmospheres of many astrophysical environments , namely carbon stars , y dwarfs , t dwarfs , hot jupiters and solar system gas giant planets .
it is available in full as supplementary data to the article and at www.exomol.com .
molecular data ; opacity ; astronomical data bases : miscellaneous ; planets and satellites : atmospheres ; stars : low - mass ; stars : brown dwarfs .
[ firstpage ] |
very significant resources are being invested in large surveys of the stellar content of our galaxy .
we clearly are under an obligation to make every effort to extract as much science from these expensive data as we can .
a survey catalogue is always dominated by selection effects : it contains stars that are nearby and luminous .
moreover several of the quantities measured for stars , for example parallax @xmath2 , proper motion @xmath3 , @xmath4 enhancement @xmath5 $ ] , contain non - negligible errors , and the quantities of physical interest that we derive from them , such as distance @xmath6 , luminosity @xmath7 and velocity @xmath8 , have correlated errors with highly non - gaussian error distributions .
models play a vital role in extracting science from surveys by taking into account ( i ) selection effects ( ii ) measurement errors and ( iii ) combining constraints on the properties of the galaxy from different surveys . here
we illustrate these principles .
there is a long tradition of extracting science from surveys with kinematic models such as the besanon model @xcite .
these models are constructed by assigning to each spatial point a velocity ellipsoid , generally assumed to be gaussian .
equilibrium dynamical models are superior to kinematic models in several ways . *
although the galaxy can not be in dynamical equilibrium , equilibrium models are of fundamental importance because an estimate of the galaxy s gravitational potential @xmath9 is key for any modelling enterprise and we can constrain @xmath10 only to the extent that the galaxy is in dynamical equilibrium : if it is allowed to be out of equilibrium , _ any _ distribution of stars in phase space is consistent with _ any _ gravitational potential
we constrain @xmath10 by assuming that the potential is deep enough to prevent stars flying apart in the next dynamical time but not so deep as to cause them to slump into the centre in the same period . * equilibrium dynamical models have much less freedom than kinematic or non - equilibrium models because their velocity structure is firmly tied to the density structure by the assumed potential
. consequently a small number of parameters suffices to specify a realistic dynamical model , and optimising the model by adjusting these parameters is reasonably straightforward .
* observed velocity distributions are far from gaussian but are well reproduced by quasi - isothermal s. * a properly constructed equilibrium dynamical model can be used as the foundation for the construction of non - equilibrium models via perturbation theory . in this way
the model can be extended to include non - equilibrium phenomena such as spiral structure and the warp .
we have known since the numerical experiments of the 1960s that most orbits in galaxy - like flattened , axisymmetric potentials admit three integrals of motion , and by the strong jeans theorem the distribution function ( ) of an equilibrium model can be assumed to be a function @xmath11 of these integrals . since any function @xmath12 of the integrals is obviously itself an integral of motion , there is considerable choice in what we use for arguments of the .
one choice stands out above all others : the action integrals @xmath13 .
the special properties enjoyed by the actions include : ( i ) they alone can be complemented by canonically conjugate variables @xmath14 to form a complete set of canonical coordinates @xmath15 for phase space ; ( ii ) the space in which the actions are cartesian coordinates , action space , provides an undistorted compression of six - dimensional phase space in the sense that the volume of phase space occupied by orbits with actions in @xmath16 is @xmath17 ; ( iii ) actions are adiabatic invariants so when the galaxy s potential is slowly deepened , for example by the accretion of gas to form the disc , the orbits of stars change but their actions do not .
the property of adiabatic invariance enables us to compute the effects of accretion without knowing precisely how the accretion occurred we need to know only the initial and final potentials , not the intermediate potentials .
the ability to embed the actions in a complete system of canonical coordinates is the key handling non - equilibrium aspects of the galaxy through perturbation theory
angle - action coordinates were invented in the 19th century in order to compute the dynamics of the solar system using perturbation theory .
particle physics , condensed - matter physics , plasma physics , and celestial mechanics are all built around perturbation theory , which is not merely the means by which we compute the implications of models but provides the concepts
feynman diagrams , phonons , spin - waves , mean - motion resonances , etc .
, with which we understand the phenomena .
galactic dynamics will remain a primitive branch of physics until it too makes extensive use of perturbation theory , and our first step towards that goal must be expressing equilibrium models in terms of angle - action coordinates .
the angular momentum around the galaxy s approximate symmetry axis @xmath18 is one of the three actions .
the best expressions we have @xcite for the integral of motion that controls the extent of a star s excursions perpendicular to the galactic plane are for the vertical action @xmath19 .
consequently the only real temptation to employ an integral that is not an action is the temptation to use the energy @xmath20 as the third integral rather than the radial action @xmath21 , which controls the extent of a star s radial oscillation .
for some the arguments advanced above for choosing @xmath21 over @xmath20 do not suffice to wean them off @xmath20 , and to these people we say that if your has the form @xmath22 it is quite tricky to find the self - consistent gravitational potential @xcite .
indeed , the search for @xmath10 proceeds iteratively one guesses @xmath10 , evaluates the density @xmath23 then implied , solves poisson s equation for the corresponding potential @xmath24 and repeats the process until convergence . at each iteration the central potential changes , with the result that the density depends upon a different range of values of @xmath20 , and the iterations converge only if some subtle scalings are employed ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ( b ) ) .
since actions always range from 0 for a star that rests at the bottom of the potential well to @xmath25 for marginally bound stars , when we adopt @xmath26 the iterations converge automatically . in the following
we take the to have the form @xmath26 and not waste time on more traditional formulations .
@xcite showed that superpositions of quasi - isothermal s give good fits to the geneva - copenhagen catalogue and successfully predict data from the sdss and rave surveys . a quasi - isothermal has the form @xmath27 where @xmath28 is essentially the radial scale length of the disc , @xmath29 is the radius of a circular orbit of angular momentum @xmath18 , @xmath30 and @xmath31 are the radial and vertical epicycle frequencies of this orbit , and @xmath32 and @xmath33 are approximately equal to the radial and vertical velocity dispersions of the disc at @xmath34 .
the name `` quasi - isothermal '' for this derives from the observation that in the epicycle approximation @xmath35 is the in - plane epicycle energy and @xmath36 is the energy of vertical oscillations , so the becomes an exponential function of these energies like the gibbs distribution of standard statistical mechanics .
the hipparcos data showed that the velocity dispersions of thin - disc stars grow with age @xmath37 roughly as @xmath38 ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) , so @xcite set @xmath39 where @xmath40 is a parameter that controls the velocity dispersion of the stars at birth , @xmath41 is the age of the oldest thin - disc stars and @xmath42 is essentially the present velocity dispersion at @xmath34 .
this dispersion is expected to decrease outwards through the disc , and an appropriate functional form is @xmath43 where @xmath44 is a number , @xmath45 is the radius over which the velocity dispersion falls by a factor @xmath46 .
@xcite showed that the hipparcos data are consistent with the hypothesis that the star formation rate ( sfr ) near the sun has varied with time as @xmath47 so a reasonable form for the of the thin disc is @xmath48 that is , the thin disc is modelled as a superposition of quasi - isothermal discs , one for each coeval cohort of stars , with the velocity dispersion of each cohort increasing with age .
b12 took the thick disc to be a single quasi - isothermal comprising exclusively old stars .
the of the complete disc is then @xmath49 where the individual s are normalised such that @xmath50 and @xmath51 is the fraction of the mass of the disk contributed by the thick disc . in principle
every observationally distinguishable class of star can have its own .
kinematics and chemistry are highly correlated , so stars with different metallicities must have different s. we can model this situation by extending the above to an extended distribution function ( ) , which is a function of chemical composition in addition to actions .
we start by supposing that the chemical composition of the interstellar medium ( ism ) is at any given time a function of galactocentric radius @xmath52 only , and that the chemical composition of a star is the same as that of the ism at the coordinates @xmath53 of its birth .
the upper panel of fig .
[ jjbfig : zhist ] shows the time dependence of metallicity at several radii in the model of @xcite .
we model this dependence with @xmath54 \left[\tanh\left(\tau_m-\tau\over\tau_f\right)-1\right],\ ] ] where from sb09 we adopt the current metallicity - radius relation @xmath55 which yields a linear decline of [ fe / h ] near the sun flattening to @xmath56 at large @xmath52 . here
@xmath57 is the maximum age of any star in the galaxy , @xmath58 is that star s value of @xmath59 , and @xmath60 is a parameter that controls the rate of enrichment at early times .
following sb09 we adopt @xmath61 and @xmath62 .
the lower panel of fig .
[ jjbfig : zhist ] shows a reasonable fit to the sb09 model is afforded by @xmath63 . in the ism according to the model of schnrich & binney ( 2009 ) .
each curve corresponds to a radius that increases from top to bottom in steps of @xmath64 , the curve for @xmath65 being shown in red .
the lower panel shows the analytic approximation to this evolution afforded by eqs .
( [ jjbeq : mrt ] ) and ( [ jjbeq : mr ] ) .
the increment in @xmath52 between curves is again @xmath64 with the curve for @xmath66 shown in red .
the region to the right of the dotted vertical line is taken to constitute the thick disc , which has the of a single quasi - isothermal . ] in the ism according to the model of schnrich & binney ( 2009 ) .
each curve corresponds to a radius that increases from top to bottom in steps of @xmath64 , the curve for @xmath65 being shown in red .
the lower panel shows the analytic approximation to this evolution afforded by eqs .
( [ jjbeq : mrt ] ) and ( [ jjbeq : mr ] ) .
the increment in @xmath52 between curves is again @xmath64 with the curve for @xmath66 shown in red .
the region to the right of the dotted vertical line is taken to constitute the thick disc , which has the of a single quasi - isothermal . ] with the assumption that a star s metallicity is given by equation ( [ jjbeq : mrt ] ) with @xmath52 interpreted as @xmath29 the becomes @xmath67 on account of churning @xcite , the present angular momentum @xmath18 of a star differs from its birth angular momentum @xmath68 by a random offset , which we assume is drawn from a gaussian distribution with dispersion @xmath69 that grows with time , so @xmath70 with churning taken into account , the becomes @xmath71 where @xmath72 and @xmath73 .
when we use the @xmath74-function to execute the integral over @xmath68 we obtain @xmath75 where @xmath68 is given by @xmath76 .
to test a model by comparing it with a catalogue , we have to `` observe '' the model in in the same way that the survey observes the galaxy .
most of the major surveys now underway make strenuous efforts to be photometrically complete in some well - defined way .
nevertheless this completeness is achieved , if at all , only in the final data release because a host of complex constraints and considerations affect the order in which targets are selected bright stars are likely to be selected ahead of faint ones , and in crowded fields it may be impossible to sweep up adjacent targets in the first visit to the field . fortunately , these considerations are almost always velocity - blind in the sense that the probability that a given star is included in a particular data release is rigorously independent of its velocity . in these circumstances
it is easy to test a model with a catalogue for which we have estimates of distance and chemical composition as follows .
we bin the stars spatially and chemically in any convenient way . for each star in a bin
we choose a hypothetical true distance @xmath77 using either a simple gaussian distribution in @xmath77 or , more rigorously , using the a posteriori probability distribution of @xmath77 for each star that is returned by a bayesian distance - determination algorithm @xcite .
the probability distributions from a bayesian algorithm are clearly to be preferred because they take into account the higher density of stars near us than further away and also distance ambiguities associated with uncertainty as to whether a star is a dwarf or some type of giant . in the same spirit
we select a hypothetical true metallicity @xmath78 by sampling the product of the model s metallicity distribution along that line of sight and the probability distribution of measurement errors in @xmath59 .
once hypothetical true values of all relevant observables have been selected in this way , we sample the model s velocity distribution at the hypothesised location @xmath79 we convert @xmath8 into the line of sight velocity @xmath80 and proper motion @xmath81 using the hypothesised distance @xmath77 .
next we add to @xmath80 and @xmath81 appropriate measurement errors before converting them back to a space velocity @xmath8 using the measured distance @xmath6 .
these velocities constitute the model s predictions for the distribution of velocities of catalogued stars in the given spatial bin .
these predictions take fully into account all measurement errors , no matter how gross , in distances , velocities and metal abundances .
if the measurement errors have been correctly assessed , any statistically significant discrepancy between this theoretical velocity distribution and the observed one must reflect a shortcoming of the model .
b12 fitted a @xmath26 to the geneva - copenhagen catalogue ( gcs ) of f and g stars @xcite as follows .
first the thin - disc was fitted to the histograms of @xmath82 , @xmath83 and @xmath84 velocity components .
then the data set was augmented by the @xcite estimates of the stellar density @xmath85 at distance @xmath86 from the plane , and the entire was fitted .
since the fits to all the data , especially the distribution of @xmath84 components and the gr83 density points , were excellent , it was evident that the gravitational potential adopted is not far from the truth .
however , more rigorous tests of the ( , @xmath10 ) combination of this model are provided by using it to predict the velocity distributions of rave stars , which , unlike the gcs stars , extend far beyond a sphere around the sun of radius @xmath87 .
, right column @xmath88 .
the red points are the prediction of the model for thin - disc stars , the black points show velocities measured by rave .
the numbers in brackets at the bottom give the mean values of @xmath52 and @xmath89 for stars in that bin.,title="fig:",width=172 ] , right column @xmath88 .
the red points are the prediction of the model for thin - disc stars , the black points show velocities measured by rave .
the numbers in brackets at the bottom give the mean values of @xmath52 and @xmath89 for stars in that bin.,title="fig:",width=172 ] , right column @xmath88 .
the red points are the prediction of the model for thin - disc stars , the black points show velocities measured by rave .
the numbers in brackets at the bottom give the mean values of @xmath52 and @xmath89 for stars in that bin.,title="fig:",width=172 ] , right column @xmath88 .
the red points are the prediction of the model for thin - disc stars , the black points show velocities measured by rave .
the numbers in brackets at the bottom give the mean values of @xmath52 and @xmath89 for stars in that bin.,title="fig:",width=172 ] , right column @xmath88 .
the red points are the prediction of the model for thin - disc stars , the black points show velocities measured by rave .
the numbers in brackets at the bottom give the mean values of @xmath52 and @xmath89 for stars in that bin.,title="fig:",width=172 ] , right column @xmath88 .
the red points are the prediction of the model for thin - disc stars , the black points show velocities measured by rave .
the numbers in brackets at the bottom give the mean values of @xmath52 and @xmath89 for stars in that bin.,title="fig:",width=172 ] components of rave giants .
left column : stars with @xmath90 , right column @xmath88 .
the red points are the prediction of the model , the black points show velocities measured by rave .
the numbers in brackets at top left give the mean values of @xmath52 and @xmath89 for stars in that bin followed by the mean observational error .
the dotted curves show models of the underlying error - corrected distribution and the black curves show the result of convolving these distributions with the stated errors.,title="fig:",width=172 ] components of rave giants .
left column : stars with @xmath90 , right column @xmath88 .
the red points are the prediction of the model , the black points show velocities measured by rave .
the numbers in brackets at top left give the mean values of @xmath52 and @xmath89 for stars in that bin followed by the mean observational error .
the dotted curves show models of the underlying error - corrected distribution and the black curves show the result of convolving these distributions with the stated errors.,title="fig:",width=172 ] components of rave giants . left column : stars with @xmath90 , right column @xmath88 .
the red points are the prediction of the model , the black points show velocities measured by rave .
the numbers in brackets at top left give the mean values of @xmath52 and @xmath89 for stars in that bin followed by the mean observational error .
the dotted curves show models of the underlying error - corrected distribution and the black curves show the result of convolving these distributions with the stated errors.,title="fig:",width=172 ] components of rave giants . left column : stars with @xmath90 , right column @xmath88 .
the red points are the prediction of the model , the black points show velocities measured by rave .
the numbers in brackets at top left give the mean values of @xmath52 and @xmath89 for stars in that bin followed by the mean observational error .
the dotted curves show models of the underlying error - corrected distribution and the black curves show the result of convolving these distributions with the stated errors.,title="fig:",width=172 ] components of rave giants . left column : stars with @xmath90 , right column @xmath88 .
the red points are the prediction of the model , the black points show velocities measured by rave .
the numbers in brackets at top left give the mean values of @xmath52 and @xmath89 for stars in that bin followed by the mean observational error .
the dotted curves show models of the underlying error - corrected distribution and the black curves show the result of convolving these distributions with the stated errors.,title="fig:",width=172 ] components of rave giants .
left column : stars with @xmath90 , right column @xmath88 .
the red points are the prediction of the model , the black points show velocities measured by rave .
the numbers in brackets at top left give the mean values of @xmath52 and @xmath89 for stars in that bin followed by the mean observational error .
the dotted curves show models of the underlying error - corrected distribution and the black curves show the result of convolving these distributions with the stated errors.,title="fig:",width=172 ] figs .
[ jjbfig : gw ] and [ jjbfig : gvphi ] show results for giants .
we divide the stars into those inside / outside the solar radius , and into three bins in @xmath89 .
the black points show histograms for @xmath91 rave giants ; each point s vertical bar shows the statistical error in that bin .
the red points show the corresponding theoretical predictions
. shows histograms for the vertical velocity component @xmath92 ( the direction of this component changes from point to point in the @xmath93 plane to track a principal axis of the velocity ellipsoid ) .
the mean @xmath94 coordinates of the contributing stars appear in brackets in the lower centre of each panel above the error - corrected velocity dispersion in the bin ( sd ) and the mean velocity ( mv ) . in all panels
the red and black histograms agree nearly perfectly , even though the stars that contribute to the lower four panels lie far outside the region occupied by the gcs stars , to which the was fitted
. shows histograms for @xmath95 .
although not perfect , the agreement between the red and black histograms is again impressive given that the red points are predictions rather than fits to these data .
the fit becomes near - perfect if one assumes that the distances to the most remote stars have been overestimated by @xmath96 .
in the last section we merely tested against rave data a previously selected basic . now we report fitting an to a combination of segue and gcs data . in this work
we include a halo described by a classical isothermal @xmath97 .
the parameters of the halo , including the local density of its stars , are fixed .
its metallicity distribution is a gaussian centred on @xmath98 with dispersion @xmath99 .
it contributes @xmath100 of local stars .
the thick disc was taken to be a single quasi - isothermal distribution with the metallicity - angular momentum relation that one gets by integrating with respect to @xmath37 within the lower panel of from @xmath101 to @xmath102 .
likelihood maximisation was first used to fit the of the thick disc to g dwarfs in the dr9 segue catalogue with @xmath88 and @xmath86 in @xmath103 .
@xmath104 possible values of @xmath105 , @xmath8 and @xmath59 were chosen for each star @xmath4 from that star s error distribution .
for each such coordinate set the ratio @xmath106 is the normalised probability density of the assigned velocity given the position and metallicity assignments .
crucially , by dividing by the velocity integral we have made @xmath107 insensitive to the spatial and metallicity coordinates , and therefore to the survey s selection function .
the average @xmath108 over all randomly sampled velocities @xmath109 is a statistically more stable measure of the probability of the star s measured velocity ( around which the @xmath109 cluster ) that inherits the same insensitivity to the selection function . in order to ensure that the density profile @xmath85 of the thick disc is appropriate , the parameters of the thick - disc were chosen by maximising the function @xmath110\over\sigma_{\rm gr}(z)}\right|^2,\ ] ] where @xmath111 is the density profile from gr83 , @xmath112 are the errors in @xmath113 , and @xmath114 is the density profile predicted by the . after pinning down the parameters of the thick - disc in this way
, the gcs velocities , with @xmath59 values from @xcite were used to maximise a log likelihood similar to equation ( [ jjbeq : logl ] ) but ( a ) using all the gr83 points in the sum over @xmath86 , and ( b ) with @xmath115 in eq .
( [ jjbeq : defsn ] ) made sensitive to @xmath59 in addition to @xmath8 by adding integration over @xmath59 to the denominator @xmath116 where @xmath117 is the complete rather than just of just that of the thick disc . .
] shows that the final model provides reasonable if not spectacular fits to the velocities of segue dwarfs that were not used in the fitting procedure .
the lower - left panel of shows that the model provides an excellent fit to the distribution of @xmath84 components of gcs stars , while the upper two panels show that the fits to the @xmath82 and @xmath83 components are imperfect at low velocities , presumably on account of the prominence of streams near the origin of the @xmath118 plane @xcite .
our fitting procedure yields the joint probability distributions of the parameters of each disc .
we do not have space to describe these distributions fully here , but we note a few points : * the thick disc is hotter vertically than horizontally : @xmath119 .
the velocity dispersion parameters of the thin disc are as expected ( @xmath120 ) .
* the thick - disc has a small scale length parameter ( @xmath121 ) .
however , this parameter describes the distribution of birth radii of stars , and on account of strong radial migration described by the parameter @xmath69 in equation ( [ jjbeq : defssigmal ] ) , the present distribution of thick - disc stars would be described by a significantly larger scale length @xmath122 . *
the scale length parameter of the thin disc is larger than that of the thick disc ( @xmath122 ) .
the spatial distribution of thin - disc stars is broadened by radial migration , even if not to the same extent as in the thick disc , so the current scale length is at the upper end of former estimates .
the thin disc has a remarkably large value , @xmath123 , of the scale length on which the dispersions decrease radially . *
the thick disc contributes @xmath124 of local stars , a value that is smaller than those ( @xmath125 and @xmath126 ) estimated by @xcite and @xcite but a factor of 3 larger the the original estimate of gr83 .
given that the model density profile @xmath85 falls below the gr83 points in the range @xmath127 ( lower right - hand panel of ) , the normalisation of the thick disc may be too low .
however , shows that the metallicity distribution of the gcs stars provide a contrary indication : when the thick - disc normalisation is large enough to fit the gr83 points , the gcs metallicity distribution shows fewer metal - poor stars than the segue data require . @xcite
derived a profile @xmath85 from the sdss data that is slightly less steep than the gr83 data , so using this profile would raise the normalisation of the thick disc s contribution to the and thus exacerbate the conflict with the gcs metallicity distribution .
how serious is is our inability to fit the metal - weak tail of the gcs metallicity distribution simultaneously with the gr83 density profile and the segue metallicity distribution ?
possible explanations include : ( i ) one or both of the gcs and segue metallicity scales is wrong ; ( ii ) during the formation of the thick disc , the star - formation rate varied rapidly , with the consequence that the actual metallicity distribution in the thick disc is not adequately approximated by the one we have gleaned from the right - hand end of the lower panel of under the assumption that of a constant sfr .
( iii ) the thick disc s is not approximately quasi - isothermal .
specifically , if the were not a monotonically decreasing function of @xmath19 , it would be possible to have the required number of metal - poor stars at @xmath128 without exceeding the number seen at @xmath129 because the density profile @xmath85 of the thick disc could be non - decreasing at @xmath130 .
two strong objections can be raised to this fix : ( a ) the proposed density profile conflicts with the conclusion of @xcite that mono - abundance populations have double - exponential density profiles , as predicted by quasi - isothermal s ; ( b ) if , as seems likely , the thick disc formed by stars being scattered from near - circular orbits during an early disorderly phase in the life of the galaxy , the must decrease in the direction that stars diffused , namely that of increasing @xmath19 . for these reasons
we consider it unlikely that the conflict arises from the assumed form of the and is more likely to arise from either differences in metallicity scales or rapid early fluctuation in the sfr .
equilibrium dynamical models are crucial for the scientific exploitation of surveys .
we have given two examples of their use .
first we have shown that a fitted to the velocity distribution of local stars plus the gr83 density profile predicts the velocity distributions of rave stars with remarkable success given that most rave stars lie far from the sun .
second we have introduced an analytic to model the correlations between kinematics and chemistry . the is inspired by a particular picture of disc formation but its validity is ultimately independent of its original physical motivation .
we fitted this to a combination of the segue data for g dwarfs seen @xmath131 from the plane and the local gcs stars .
the resulting makes reasonably successful predictions for kinematic data not used in the fitting process , but provides an unsatisfactory fit to the distribution in [ fe / h ] of the gcs stars in the sense of requiring more low - metallicity stars than observed .
we discussed possible resolutions of this discrepancy , and none is very attractive .
aumer , m. & binney , j. , 2009 , mnras , 397 , 1286 binney , j. , 2010 , mnras , 401 , 2318 binney , j. , 2012a , mnras , 426 , 1328 binney , j. , 2012b , mnras , 426 , 1342 ( b12 ) binney et al . , 2013 , mnras , to be submitted binney , j. , & tremaine , s. , 2008 , _
galactic dynamics _ , princeton university press , princeton bovy j. , rix h .- w . , liu c. , hogg d.w . , beers t.c . ,
lee y.s . , 2012 , apj , 753 , 148 burnett , b. & binney j. , 2010 , mnras , 407 , 339 casagrande , l. , schnrich , r. , asplund , m. , cassisi , s. , ramirez , i. , melndez , j. , bensby , t. , & feltzing , s. , 2011 , a&a , 530 , 138 dehnen w. , 1998 , aj , 115 , 2384 fuhrmann k. , 2011 , mnras , 414 , 2893 gilmore g. , reid n. , 1983 , mnras , 202 , 1025 holmberg j. , nordstrm b. , andersen j. , 2007 , a&a 475 , 519 juric et al . , 2008 , apj , 673 , 864 nordstrom , b. , mayor m. , andersen j. , holmberg j. , pont f. , jorgensen b.r . ,
olsen e.h . ,
udry s. , mowlavi n. , 2004 , a&a , 418 , 989 prendergast , k.h .
, & tomer , e. , 1970 , aj , 75 , 674 robin a. , reyl c. , derrire s. , picaud s. , 2003 , a&a , 409 , 523 rowley , g. , 1988 , apj , 331 , 124 sanders , j.l .
, 2012 , mnras , 426 , 128 schnrich , r. & binney , j. , 2009 , mnras , 396 , 203 ( sb09 ) selwood , j.a . &
binney , j. , 2002 , mnras , 336 , 785 | equilibrium dynamical models are essential tools for extracting science from surveys of our galaxy .
we show how models can be tested with data from a survey before the survey s selection function has been determined .
we illustrate the application of this method by presenting some results for the rave survey .
we extend our published analytic distribution functions to include chemistry and fit the chosen functional form to a combination of the geneva copenhagen survey ( gcs ) and a sample of g - dwarfs observed at @xmath0 by the segue survey . by including solid dynamics we are able to predict the contribution that the thick disc / halo stars surveyed by segue should make to the gcs survey .
we show that the measured [ fe / h ] distribution from the gcs includes many fewer stars at @xmath1 than are predicted .
the problem is more likely to lie in discordant abundance scales than with incorrect dynamics . #
1to 0pt#1 = cmmib10 = cmmib7 = = # 1 ii aa # 1#2 # 1#1 = # 1fig . [ # 1 ] |
this work was supported by air force office of scientific research ( afosr ) ( fa8655 - 09 - 1 - 3020 ) ; engineering and physical sciences research council ( epsrc ) ( ep / k034480/1 ( bloqs ) ; ep/ j000051/1 , nqit ) ; european commission ( ec ) ( piefga-2013 - 62737 , ief - ga-2012 - 331859 , ip siqs ( 600645 ) , piif - ga-2013 - 629229 ) ; european research council ( erc ) ( moquacino ) ; royal society .
we thank a. abdolvand and p. st .
j. russell from the max planck institute for the science of light ( germany ) for providing us with the hollow - core fibres and their characterization .
we would also like to thank i. g. hughes for his insighftul comments on the early version of the manuscript .
j. nunn , n. k. langford , w. s. kolthammer , t. f. m. champion , m. r. sprague , p. s. michelberger , x .-
jin , d. g. england , and i. a. walmsley , `` enhancing multiphoton rates with quantum memories , '' physical review letters * 110 * , 133601 ( 2013 ) .
m. r. sprague , p. s. michelberger , t. f. m. champion , d. g. england , j. nunn , x .-
jin , w. s. kolthammer , a. abdolvand , p. s. j. russell , and i. a. walmsley , `` broadband single - photon - level memory in a hollow - core photonic crystal fibre , '' nature photonics * 8 * , 287291 ( 2014 ) .
a. bhagwat , a. slepkov , v. venkataraman , p. londero , and a. gaeta , `` on - demand all - optical generation of controlled rb - vapor densities in photonic - band - gap fibers , '' physical review a * 79 * , 063809 ( 2009 ) .
a. d. slepkov , a. r. bhagwat , v. venkataraman , p. londero , and a. l. gaeta , `` generation of large alkali vapor densities inside bare hollow - core photonic band - gap fibers . ''
optics express * 16 * , 1897683 ( 2008 ) .
a. burchianti , a. bogi , c. marinelli , c. maibohm , e. mariotti , s. sanguinetti , and l. moi , `` optical characterization and manipulation of alkali metal nanoparticles in porous silica , '' the european physical journal d * 49 * , 201210 ( 2008 ) .
l. weller , r. j. bettles , p. siddons , c. s. adams , and i. g. hughes , `` absolute absorption on the rubidium d1 line including resonant dipole dipole interactions . ''
journal of physics b : atomic , molecular and optical physics * 195006 * , 05 ( 2011 ) .
m. r. sprague , d. g. england , a. abdolvand , j. nunn , x .-
jin , w. s. kolthammer , m. barbieri , b. rigal , p. s. michelberger , t. f. m. champion , p. s. j. russell , and i. a. walmsley , `` efficient optical pumping and high optical depth in a hollow - core photonic - crystal fibre for a broadband quantum memory , '' new journal of physics * 15 * , 055013 ( 2013 ) .
t. karaulanov , m. t. graf , d. english , s. m. rochester , y. j. rosen , k. tsigutkin , d. budker , e. b. alexandrov , m. v. balabas , d. f. j. kimball , f. a. narducci , s. pustelny , and v. v. yashchuk , `` controlling atomic vapor density in paraffin - coated cells using light - induced atomic desorption , '' physical review a - atomic , molecular , and optical physics * 79 * , 19 ( 2009 ) .
f. benabid , p. j. roberts , f. couny , and p. s. light , `` light and gas confinement in hollow - core photonic crystal fibre based photonic microcells , '' journal of the european optical society : rapid publications * 4 * , 09004 ( 2009 ) .
s. michelberger , t. f. m. champion , m. r. sprague , k. t. kaczmarek , m. barbieri , x. m. jin , d. g. england , w. s. kolthammer , d. j. saunders , j. nunn , and i. a. walmsley , `` interfacing ghz - bandwidth heralded single photons with a room - temperature raman quantum memory , '' new journal of physics * 17 * , 43006 ( 2015 ) . | alkali - filled hollow - core fibres are a promising medium for investigating light - matter interactions , especially at the single - photon level , due to the tight confinement of light and high optical depths achievable by light - induced atomic desorption . however , until now these large optical depths could only be generated for seconds at most once per day , severely limiting the practicality of the technology .
here we report the generation of highest observed transient ( @xmath0 for up to a minute ) and highest observed persistent ( @xmath1 for hours ) optical depths of alkali vapours in a light - guiding geometry to date , using a caesium - filled kagom - type hollow - core photonic crystal fibre .
our results pave the way to light - matter interaction experiments in confined geometries requiring long operation times and large atomic number densities , such as generation of single - photon - level nonlinearities and development of single photon quantum memories .
optical quantum memories are a crucial component of photonic quantum technologies , enabling the storage and manipulation of optically encoded quantum information @xcite or temporal multiplexing of probabilistic operations @xcite .
such memories require strong light - matter coupling that facilitates the transformation of a photon into a matter excitation .
the coupling strength can be increased from the material side , by increasing the number of atoms interacting with light , i.e. the optical depth ( od ) , or from the photonic side , by confining the photons in a waveguide geometry , which overcomes the focused light interaction length limit imposed by free - space diffraction .
warm vapours contained in hollow - core photonic crystal fibres ( hc - pcf ) are therefore a promising candidate for such applications @xcite .
another exciting approach are cold atomic gases coupled to tapered optical fibres @xcite .
hc - pcfs filled with alkali vapours have been used to demonstrate the basic building blocks required for photonic quantum information processing , i.e. single - photon level optical nonlinearities @xcite ( with the potential of using rydberg atoms @xcite ) and optical memories @xcite .
the latter application especially requires fibres of relatively large core sizes ( @xmath2 m ) , such as the kagom fibres used in this work , as the transit time of atoms through the core can be a fundamental limit to the memory efficiency and lifetime .
an exciting solution to this is the use of spin - preserving coatings , but their use in confined geometries is still under investigation @xcite . due to the alkali s reactivity , adsorption to the core surfaces significantly limits the ambient optical depths achievable in hc - pcfs .
two ways to overcome this limitation is to use less reactive non - alkali vapours such as mercury @xcite or use ultracold alkali atoms contactlessly guided within the fibre core @xcite . in the case of warm alkali vapours , on the other hand , light - induced atomic desorption ( liad )
has been used to generate high transient ods in hollow - core fibres @xcite .
high - power infrared laser light stimulates the desorption of alkalis via at least two pathways : one , the direct vapourisation of metallic layers , and two , surface - plasmon enhanced heating of metallic nanoclusters @xcite . in bulk glass cells ,
liad was used to generate persistent moderate increases in optical depth ( 600% over 15 minutes ) @xcite
. however , the persistency of high od using liad has been elusive . here , we report the observation of ultra - high transient and high persistent optical depth of caesium ( cs ) confined in large - core kagom hc - pcfs of two different core sizes .
we also develop a phenomenological model that agrees with our observations .
the experiment was the following .
we have investigated the effect of liad on two 20 cm kagom - structured hc - pcfs of @xmath3 m and @xmath4 m core diameters ( fig .
[ fig : setup ] ( a ) and ( b ) respectively ) .
the two fibres were inserted inside a single vacuum chamber , which was consequently baked and evacuated to a base pressure @xmath5 torr .
the chamber was then passively loaded with caesium from an ampoule inside the system .
after loading the chamber for a month at @xmath6c , we turned down the temperature to a room level of @xmath7c , keeping the windows slightly warmer in order to avoid cs accumulation , and allowed it to further load for 12 months , over which we conducted experiments . this time
could be decreased if the system was kept at a higher temperature throughout the loading period .
m hc - pcf with light coupled into the core .
( b ) scanning electron microscopy image of the @xmath4 m hc - pcf core .
( c ) schematic of the experiment . ]
in order to measure the optical depth of caesium vapours inside the fibres , we send in a weak probe beam [ @xmath8 nw into the @xmath9 m hc - pcf ] derived from an external cavity diode laser ( ecdl ) , that is scanned in frequency over the d2 line of cs ( @xmath10 , at 852 nm ) and coupled into the fibre core .
we use a combination of flipper mirrors and translation stages for switchable coupling into the two fibres , as shown in fig . [
fig : setup ] ( c ) .
the transmitted light is subsequently measured on an avalanche photodiode ( thorlabs apd110a / m ) , operated in linear mode .
the resultant transmission profile is fitted to a series of voigt functions , i.e. convolutions of the lorenzian function due to homogenous broadening and gaussian function from the inhomogenous broadening of the transitions from the different hyperfine states of @xmath11 .
the absorption pre - factor @xmath12 and inhomogenous linewidth @xmath13 were taken as free parameters of the fit . assuming the homogenous linewidth @xmath14 ( as we observe in our fitting , taking into account possible self - broadening effects at higher densities @xcite ) , the absorption pre - factor @xmath12 can be related to the `` on - resonance '' optical depth @xmath15 via @xmath16 the desorbing liad beam is derived from an ecdl at 780 nm , which is amplified via a tapered amplifier , and sent into a single mode fibre . with this
we generate up to 300 mw of liad light which we couple , counter - propagating with respect to the weak probe , into the hc - pcf .
the effective intra - fibre liad power was around 80 mw . in order to separate the
residual back - reflected ( mostly from the hc - pcf end face ) liad beam from the weak probe , we use a combination of polarisation and spectral filtering ( fig .
[ fig : setup ] ( c ) ) . in order to explore the long - lived temporal dynamics of the optical depth due to liad in our system
, we take a series of over 20,000 consecutive probe transmission scans ( which correspond to three hours of data acquisition ) , during which we turn liad on and off with an electronically - controlled shutter .
figure [ fig : example ] shows typical measured transmission , along with fits , of the weak probe beam through the @xmath4 m core fibre when its frequency is scanned over the d2 line of cs for the case of liad being off ( top ) and at the peak od of it being on ( bottom ) . due to the large cores of kagom - type hc - pcfs , there is a measurable trace of non - adsorbed alkali in the vapour phase even at room temperature with liad being off .
transitions in cs in a @xmath4 m core fibre .
top : no liad , fitted @xmath17 , @xmath18 ; bottom : liad , fitted @xmath19 , @xmath20 . ]
figure [ fig : odlong26 ] shows the change in optical depth of cs in a @xmath3 m kagom hc - pcf when liad illumination is applied at room temperature over three hours . within the span of 10s
the od rises by three orders of magnitude and reaches a maximum value of @xmath21 , which corresponds to an average number density of atoms @xmath22 @xmath23@xcite .
m core fibre .
insets show the behaviour of the optical depth at the beginning ( left - bottom ) and end ( right - bottom ) of liad illumination . ] after the sharp initial rise , the od drops by an order of magnitude over 4 minutes .
this is a significantly longer time for which such high ods have been observed in a similar system before @xcite . over the next 3 hours the optical depth remains above 2000
this is the highest persistent liad - induced od ever observed .
figure [ fig : odlong44 ] shows similar data for the @xmath4 m core fibre .
the initial rise in od is slightly slower than in the @xmath3 m core fibre ( 20s rise time ) , but the final od reached is higher , at @xmath24 , after which it stays above @xmath25 for up to a minute .
this is to our knowledge the highest reached od in an alkali - filled hollow - core fibre system and is comparable to the ods generated by heating bulk cells to hundreds of degrees , even though the fibre system operates at room temperature , extending its operational lifetime , and allowing for faster and more precise control of the optical depth .
m core fibre .
insets show the behaviour of the optical depth at the beginning ( left - bottom ) and end ( right - top ) of liad illumination . ]
the visible mid - term fluctuations in liad - induced od can be attributed to changing liad powers , due to experimental instabilities .
switching off the liad beam ( at @xmath26s and @xmath27s in the insets of fig .
[ fig : odlong26 ] and [ fig : odlong44 ] , respectively ) causes the od to rapidly drop .
the liad - induced changes in od appear to be governed by two processess of different timescales : a sharp initial rise and fall in od over the course of a few minutes and a subsequent significantly slower fall in od over the course of hours .
the initial sharp peak in od only occurs for the first run of the experiment per day and requires around a day of quiescence to regenerate to its former level , which is consistent with previous observations in similar systems @xcite .
this is attributed to the highly efficient light - induced desorption of alkali nanoclusters , which require several hours of quiescence to reform on the surface of the fibre core in order to be efficiently desorbed again .
high - power light can also desorb alkalis deposited as metallic layers .
layer desorption is considered to be much less efficient , but leads to a constant elevated level of od , since the re - adsorbed alkali can be immediately desorbed @xcite . however , considering only the desorption of nanoclusters and layers , and their reformation / readsorption , does not explain the slow fall in od observed in our experiment . in order for our model of liad to mimic the data correctly , we had to include another process .
this process decreases the amount of cs in the whole system under liad illumination , but regenerates it during the period of darkness . in coated bulk cells , the process responsible for similar long - term depletion of desorbable alkali
was identified to be its interaction with the coating itself , including light - stimulated absorption into the coating @xcite .
a similar depletion effect was also observed in liad from porous alumina , where the pores acted as a sink for the atoms @xcite , and in vapour cells with closable stems @xcite .
we speculate that in glass hollow - core fibres the mechanism responsible for long - term depletion of alkali vapour during liad illumination is the escape of the vapour out of the fibre ends , due to a strong , liad - induced vapor pressure differential on the boundary between the fibre and its surroundings .
we have devised a rate equation model based on the assumptions outlined above , obtaining the following set of equations : @xmath28 where @xmath29 are the fractions of atoms in the vapour , layer and nanocluster phase , respectively .
the first two terms on the right - hand side of the first equation describe liad , i.e. the light - induced desorption of metallic layers and nanoclusters .
the desorption rates are @xmath30 and @xmath31 for the layers and nanoclusters respectively , with nanocluster desorption much more efficient ( @xmath32 ) .
@xmath33 is the liad beam power .
the next two terms describe the equilibrium processes of alkali adsorption as layers and its escape out of the fibre as vapour . @xmath34 and @xmath35 are the adsorption rate ( fast ) and equilibrium ratio of atoms in the vapour and layer phases . @xmath36 is the fraction of atoms in the sink , i.e. outside the fibre , and @xmath37 and @xmath38 are the atomic escape rate from the fibre ( slow ) and the equilibrium ratio of atoms on the outside and inside the fibre ( in the vapour phase ) .
figure [ fig : model ] shows a comparison between experimental data ( top ) and the numerical solution of the model ( bottom ) .
the model was fed with the measured liad power in the fibre , and the rate coefficients from eq .
[ eq : rateeq ] were found manually ( shown in table [ tab : tab1 ] ) , in order to get the closest similarity to data .
indeed , the model accurately describes the qualitative features of the data , confirming that the process limiting the long - term od is reversible absorption of the atoms into a sink during prolonged liad illumination , which physically could be the escape of the atomic vapour into the space outside the fibre ends .
m core fibre ( top ) and our rate - equation model ( bottom ) .
insets show the behaviour of the optical depth at the beginning ( left ) and end ( right ) of liad illumination . ]
.*rate coefficients from eq .
[ eq : rateeq ] used to generate the model shown in fig .
[ fig : model ] . * [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ tab : tab1 ] in summary , we have constructed a caesium - filled hollow - core fibre system which combines high alkali atomic densities with strong light guidance at room temperature .
after passively loading two fibres of @xmath3 m and @xmath4 m core diameters with the alkali for almost a year , we generate the highest observed transient ods @xmath0 in this system using light - induced atomic desorption .
we are then able to maintain ods larger than 2000 for at least three hours .
we attribute this to a long loading time of the fibre and high in - coupled liad optical power .
we observe no significant difference in the liad dynamics between the two core sizes .
using a rate - equation model approach , we identified the loss of atoms , possibly due to their escape from the fibre during liad illumination , as the main process responsible for the long - term fall in od . a possible way to prevent the long - term drop in od
is to seal the alkali - filled hc - pcf ends to prevent the atoms inside from escaping .
this can be achieved for example , by splicing the hc - pcf to single mode fibres , creating a fibre - based microcell @xcite , which has the additional benefit of being integratable into current photonic networks .
the duration of the transient ultrahigh ods due to nanocluster desorption would still be limited by the long reformation time of the nanoclusters .
these results open the way towards using an alkali - filled fibre for conducting time- and atomic density - intensive experiments , such as investigating single photon quantum memories @xcite or single photon nonlinearities @xcite . |
during the past decade study of nonlinear behavior of magnetic crystals has been attracted large attention , specially it accompany with the progress in some other fields such as development of theory of nonlinear differential equation , achieving new laboratory results and also potential applications in other branches of science and technology [ 1 , 2 ] .
particles with spin @xmath0 are more interesting among the other nano particles [ 3 , 4 ] .
this is because of existing of complexity in their behavior due to their multipole dynamic spin excitations . in such systems ,
the number of necessary parameters for complete description of macroscopic properties increases up to 4s , that s stands for magnitude of system spin .
also it worthwhile , the process of achieving classical spin equations and dynamic multipoles is based on coherent states that are obtained in @xmath1 group[5 ] .
we consider unitary anisotropic hamiltonian as form of : @xmath2 which , @xmath3 are spin operators in lattice @xmath4 , and @xmath5 is anisotropy coefficient .
this is hamiltonian of one dimensional ferromagnetic spin chain observed in compositions like @xmath6 [ 6 ] . in this paper
the goal is to obtain classical equation for stated hamiltonian and finding the answer of spin wave for small linear excitations upper than the ground state .
coherent states issued nearest approximation to classical state i.e. pseudo classical , because they minimize uncertainty principles . for this reason ,
in section 2 , coherent states for spin @xmath7 developed that are the same as coherent states in su(3 ) group . to obtain classical hamiltonian , we need average values of spin operator ; so in section 3 , these values and classical hamiltonian equation are derived . in section 4 ,
hamiltonian equation computed in previous section is substituted in classical equations of motion resulted from using feynman path integral on coherent states , and then we acquire spin wave equations and dispersion equations of dipole and quadupole branches for small linear excitation above the ground state , and finally we calculate soliton answers of linearized equations .
coherent states are special quantum states that their dynamic is very similar to behavior of their classical system .
the kind of coherent state that is used in a problem depends on symmetry of existent operators . with considering existent symmetry in operators of hamiltonian ( 1 ) , coherent states in su(3 ) group
is used for accurate description and considering all multipole excitations . in this group ,
ground state considered as @xmath8 and its single - site coherent state is written as : @xmath9 is wigner function for spin @xmath7 and two angles @xmath10 and @xmath11 determine alignment of classical spin vector .
angle @xmath12 determines direction of quadruple torque around the spin vector .
parameter g specifies change of length of average value of quadruple torque and also of magnitude of spin vector .
lagrangian can be obtained by use of feynman path integral for declared coherent states as:[8 ] @xmath13 where @xmath14 and h is classical energy of system obtained by averaging hamiltonian ( 1 ) on coherent states ( 2 ) .
two other terms appear when acquiring lagrangian of spin system .
the first is kinetic term that has berry phase characteristics issued from quantum interference of instanton paths and has important role in quantum phenomenons such as spin tunneling and the second is boundary term that depends on boundary values of path .
both of term have no role in classical dynamic of spin excitations and so are not considered here .
average spin values in su(3 ) group written as:[9 ] @xmath15 by averaging hamiltonian ( 1 ) and using ( 4 ) , the continuous limit of classical hamiltonian obtained as:[4 ] @xmath16 to obtain classical equation of motion , the above classical hamiltonian is substituted in motion equations resulted from lagrangian equation : @xmath17 these equations completely describe nonlinear dynamics of hamiltonian of problem up to quadrupole excitation .
solutions of these equations are magnetic solitons .
these equations result landau - lifshitz equation if quadrupole excitations ignored @xmath18 .
so these equations are more general in comparison with landau - lifshitz and have more degree of freedom .
it s noteworthy that solution of these equations has different range of solitons . for small linear excitation from ground stste , classical equations of motion change to : @xmath19 to obtain dispersion equations , functions @xmath20 and g
are considered as plane waves and their substitution in linearized equations result in dispersion equation for spin wave near the ground state : @xmath21\end{aligned}\ ] ] from the above equation , it is obvious that both dipole and quadruple branches of unitary hamiltonian are dispersive in presence of linear excitations . to compute soliton answers of equations ( 7 ) , we define variable @xmath22 such as @xmath23 . in this case above equations convert to below nonlinear equations .
@xmath24 the first equation is third order differential equation .
so change of dipole moment in hamiltonian ( 1 ) is not of the form of soliton .
solution of this equation has the following forms : @xmath25\end{aligned}\ ] ] the second equation is nonlinear klein - gordon equation and shows change of average value of quadruple excitation that its solution is of the form of hylomorphic solitons .
these solitons are like q - ball solitons .
the reason of this name is because of they cause matter have appropriate form .
also these solitons are of the kind of non topologic ones because their boundary values in ground and infinity are the same from the topological point of view .
if rewrite nonlinear klein - gordon equation ( 9 ) as : @xmath26 where @xmath27 numerical solution of ( 11 ) is plotted in figure ( 1 ) . in this computation
we consider @xmath28 and @xmath29
. analytical solution of above nonlinear klein - gordon equation is the following form : @xmath30\end{aligned}\ ] ] where c is constant .
in this paper , we study semi - classic theory for spin systems with spin @xmath31 that contain anisotropic exchange terms . it is shown that for anisotropic ferromagnet
, value of average quadruple torque is not constant ( @xmath32 ) and its dynamic contains rotational term around classical spin vector ( @xmath33 ) and another dynamics that relates to change of length of quadruple torque .
there are no such excitations in regular magnets and their dynamics is achieved by use of average value of heisenberg spin hamiltonian .
also it is shown that soliton solutions are of the kind of non topologic hilomorphic solitons for quadruple excitations .
o. abdulloev , kh .
muminov , accounting of quadrupole dynamics of magnets with spin , proceedings of tajikistan academy of sciences , n.1 , 1994 , p.p .
28 - 30 ( in russian ) .
v. g. makhankov , m. a. granados , and a. v. makhankov , `` generalized coherent states and spin @xmath34 systems , '' journal of physics a , vol .
29 , no . 12 , 2005 | we discuss system with non - isotropic non - heisenberg hamiltonian with nearest neighbor exchange within a mean field approximation process .
we drive equations describing non - heisenberg non - isotropic model using coherent states in real parameters and then obtain dispersion equations of spin wave of dipole and quadrupole branches for a small linear excitation from the ground state . in final , soliton solution for quadrupole branches for these linear equations obtained . |
interference of waves both in the form of light and massive particles , such as electrons , neutrals , and atoms , has proven to be a very sensitive method of measuring physical quantities ( see e.g. ref .
@xcite and references therein ) .
this includes precise measurements of electromagnetic fields , gyromagnetic constants , gravitational acceleration and rotation relative to an inertial system .
when it comes to interference of quantum objects with internal energy structure , the method of ramsey interferometry , involving two - level objects , has been in particular successful @xcite .
the accuracy in determining the internal state energies by ramsey interferometry scales inversely proportional to the square root of the interrogation time .
trapped individual atomic ions , laser cooled or sympathetically cooled , have led to the most precise measurements to date @xcite .
such ions , occupying much less than a cubic micron , are ideal for controlled laser excitations , and they can exhibit coherence time in the range of hundreds of seconds @xcite . molecular ion , initially prepared in its ground state , interacts with a first off - resonant laser pulse ( the mg@xmath2 coolant ion is not shown ) .
then the resulting wavepacket evolves freely for a controllable time delay @xmath3 , until a second pulse is applied , generating a new wavepacket .
this step is sensitive to the relative individual phases of the free - field states that make up the wavepacket prior to the second pulse and thus on the time delay .
the final rotational populations are measured by a state - sensitive dissociation pulse ( blue arrow ) . ] here a ramsey - type interferometer using the rotational levels of a trapped and sympathetically cooled mgh@xmath2 molecular ion @xcite is presented , as schematically illustrated in fig .
[ fig : ramsey ] . compared to the standard version employed in atom interferometry @xcite ,
the @xmath4 pulses are replaced by off - resonant femtosecond laser pulses which couple to the polarizability anisotropy of the molecule and induce rotational wavepacket dynamics .
each field - free eigenstate in the wavepacket acquires a specific phase during free evolution , equivalent to specific optical path lengths acquired in light interferometry .
the resulting field - free populations are obtained from rotational state selective photodisociation spectroscopy @xcite as a function of pulse delay .
their dependence on the time delay between the pulses defines the interferogram .
the visibility of the interferogram depends on the laser pulse parameters and the initial state .
in particular , the visibility can be enhanced by varying the intensity of the second pulse . as an application of the interferometer ,
the measurement of the molecular polarizability anisotropy is discussed , taking both the experimental uncertainties of the initial populations as well as population measurement errors into account . the interferometric method to determine the static dipole polarizabilities discussed here represents , for molecular ions , an interesting alternative to microwave spectroscopy previously used @xcite .
conversely , the interferometric technique may be used to probe local electric fields , like the radio - frequency fields at the position of the molecular ion in a ( linear ) paul trap . the potentially very long interogation times with trapped ions
can make such an interferometer extremely sensitive .
the article is organized as follows : section [ sec : model ] introduces the model and numerical tools .
the results are presented in sec .
[ sec : results ] , starting with an assessment of the effective rotor approximation in sec .
[ subsec : era ] , followed by an analysis of the wavepacket created by the first laser pulse and the characterization of the interferograms in secs .
[ subsec : onepulse ] and [ subsec : if ] .
the prospects for measuring the polarizability anisotropy are discussed in sec .
[ subsec : alpha ] . section [ sec : conclusions ] concludes .
a single trapped mgh@xmath2 ion , translationally cooled down to sub - kelvin temperatures and in its electronic ground state , is considered .
the ion interacts with femtosecond laser pulses which are far off resonance from any transition in mgh@xmath2 and linearly polarized along the laboratory fixed @xmath5-axis .
the hamiltonian describing the rovibrational motion of the molecular ion and its interaction with the off - resonant field is given by ( @xmath6 ) @xmath7 where the first two terms describe the radial kinetic and potential energy , respectively .
@xmath8 is the orbital angular momentum operator , and @xmath9 the intensity profile of the laser pulse .
@xmath10 denotes the molecular polarizability anisotropy and @xmath11 the molecular polarizability perpendicular to the interatomic axis .
@xmath12 is the angle between the polarization vector of the laser pulse and the interatomic axis . assuming linear and parallel pulse polarizations , the hamiltonian ( [ eq : ham0 ] ) is independent of the azimutal angle @xmath13 .
therefore @xmath14 , and the @xmath15-term gives rise to the selection rule @xmath16 .
the potential curve and polarizabilities are taken from ref .
@xcite . in eq .
, the leading term of the light - matter interaction is assumed to be via the ion s polarizability anisotropy .
the interaction of the light with the permanent dipole moment of the molecular ion has been neglected because it averages to zero if the laser pulses are off - resonant .
simulations of the vibrational dynamics under a pulse with @xmath17 nm , starting from the ground vibrational level , yield a total population of vibrationally excited levels of the order of @xmath18 to @xmath19 , depending on the laser intensity .
this confirms that practically no vibrational excitations take place which is not surprising given that the energy difference between the ground and first excited vibrational level corresponds to a wavelength of @xmath20 nm .
it is only for @xmath21 that vibrational transitions may become resonant .
however , the matrix elements for these transitions is so small that they play essentially no role .
since for low - lying rovibrational levels the vibrational energy is much larger than the rotational energy , the two degrees of freedom can be adiabatically separated @xcite . to this end ,
the vibrational eigenfunctions are obtained by diagonalizing @xmath22 , given by the first two terms in eq . .
denoting radial expectation values by @xmath23 for the @xmath24th vibrational level , the vibrational motion can be integrated out in eq . .
this yields the so - called effective rotor approximation ( era ) @xcite where all @xmath25-dependent quantities in eq .
( [ eq : ham0 ] ) are replaced by their expectation values , @xmath26 with @xmath27 .
the era neglects ro - vibrational couplings but goes beyond the rigid rotor approximation , since its parameters are obtained by integrating over the vibrational motion instead of just replacing @xmath25 by the equilibrium distance .
the values of the molecular parameters in eq . for mgh@xmath2 ,
calculated using the _ ab initio _ data of ref .
@xcite , are listed in table [ tab : rotpar ] ; they are found to be in good agreement with the experimental values of ref .
@xcite .
.parameters of mgh@xmath2 , used in hamiltonian ( [ eq : ham2 ] ) .
[ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] the rotational dynamics are characterized by the rotational period , @xmath28 , which amounts to @xmath29fs for mgh@xmath2 .
this short rotational period is a consequence of the large difference in the atomic masses and the small hydrogen mass .
rotational wavepacket revivals occur when the wavepacket returns to its initial state .
they can be analysed by the correlation function , @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the field - free rotational eigenenergy with corresponding eigenfunction , @xmath32 here , @xmath33 is the associated legendre function of degree @xmath34 and order @xmath35 .
revivals occur at times @xmath36 , for which @xmath37 .
that is , the conditions @xmath38 with @xmath39 integer need to be fulfilled simultaneously for all @xmath34 which make up the wavepacket @xmath40 .
the laser pulses @xmath41 which create the wavepackets are assumed to have a gaussian temporal envelope such that the pulse fluence becomes @xmath42 here @xmath43 is the maximum pulse intensity and @xmath44 is the full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) duration of the intensity profile . in particular , for constant fluence @xmath45 , the intensity and pulse duration are inversely proportional . three different initial states will be considered in the investigations presented below .
ideally for wavepacket interferometry , the molecule is in its ground rotational state ( @xmath46 ) . in an experiment , however , a completely pure initial state can not be fully realized , but recent experiments with mgh@xmath2 ions trapped in a cryogenic environment have led to a nearly 80% rotational ground state population through helium buffer gas cooling @xcite .
the ideal initial state is therefore compared to a thermal ensemble with a rotational temperature of 20@xmath47k and to an incoherent ensemble prepared in current room - temperature experiments by rotational cooling @xcite with the same ground state population ( @xmath48 ) as a thermal ensemble at 20@xmath47k .
an incoherent initial state is described by a density operator , @xmath49 : @xmath50 for a thermal state at temperature @xmath36 , @xmath51 with @xmath52 , @xmath53 , and @xmath54 the partition function , whereas for the experimentally prepared initial state , the values of @xmath55 are taken from ref .
@xcite .
since the timescale of the interferometer is much shorter than any decoherence time , the time evolution is coherent and the density operator at time @xmath56 is given by @xmath57 inserting eq . ,
each @xmath35 state may be considered separately , reducing the numerical effort in the calculations , since the hamiltonian conserves @xmath35 .
the time - dependent population of the state @xmath58 , with all corresponding @xmath35-states taken into account , is then obtained as @xmath59 i.e. , each pure state @xmath60 is propagated separately , using a chebychev propagator , and the resulting population is added up incoherently with its proper weight .
the summation over the initially populated values of @xmath34 in eq .
( [ eq : incoh ] ) can be truncated at @xmath61 .
the basis set expansion in the legendre polynomials is found to be converged for @xmath62 , provided @xmath63 w/@xmath64 .
before presenting the results obtained with hamiltonian , the accuracy of the era is checked in sec .
[ subsec : era ] .
then the interferometer is analyzed in a step - wise fashion , starting in sec .
[ subsec : onepulse ] with the dependence of the wavepacket , that is created by the first pulse , on pulse intensity and duration .
the complete interferometer time evolution is presented in sec .
[ subsec : if ] , determining pulse parameters that yield high - visibility interferograms . prospects for using the interferometer to measure the molecular polarizability are discussed in sec . [
subsec : alpha ] . the era , eq . ,
is tested against the full rovibrational dynamics , generated by hamiltonian , considering the interaction with one pulse of @xmath65fs duration . to this end ,
the radial coordinate in eq .
is represented on a fourier grid , and the time - dependent schrdinger equation with hamiltonian is solved . the absolute difference in the final - time population
is found to be within 0.01 for @xmath66 and intensities @xmath67w/@xmath64 .
the relative error amounts to less than one percent for @xmath34 up to @xmath68 and intensities up to @xmath69 w/@xmath64 . for intensities @xmath70w/@xmath71w/@xmath64 , the absolute error due to
the era is within 0.015 for @xmath66 , whereas the relative error reaches 10% to 15% .
while both absolute and relative errors become larger for higher @xmath34 states , the era is applicable for our purposes since low - lying @xmath34 states ( @xmath72 ) are most relevant for interferometry and only moderate pulse intensities will be considered to ease experimental feasibility . fs pulse as a function of pulse intensity . the arrow at @xmath73 indicates the laser intensity for which equal population of the states @xmath46 and @xmath74 is obtained , corresponding to the black line in fig .
[ fig : landscape1 ] . ] starting from a pure initial state ( @xmath46 , @xmath75 ) , a femtosecond laser pulse creates a rotational wavepacket which , due to the selection rules , is made up of states @xmath76 , all with @xmath75 . since the laser - molecule interaction is off - resonant and gaussian pulse envelopes are assumed , the composition of the wavepacket is only determined by the intensity and duration of the pulse .
the dependence of the final rotational state populations on pulse intensity and duration is shown in fig .
[ fig : landscape1 ] for @xmath77 .
curves of constant pulse duration ( intensity ) correspond to horizontal ( vertical ) cuts in fig .
[ fig : landscape1 ] .
the black line indicates pulses of @xmath78fs duration .
constant pulse fluences correspond to hyperbolas in the landscape , cf .
eq . . hyperbolas are clearly visible in fig .
[ fig : landscape1 ] , indicating that it is the pulse fluence that determines the population transfer . for the pulse parameters corresponding to
the upper left part of each panel in fig .
[ fig : landscape1 ] , the molecule can approximately be described as a two - level system , consisting of the states @xmath46 and @xmath74 .
this should allow for the closest analogy to a ramsey interferometer as used with atoms @xcite . for short pulses , @xmath79 fs , the final populations show a more complicated behavior , with more states being significantly populated , save for very small @xmath43
. a wide range of pulse parameters gives rise to significant population of @xmath74 , see the lower left corner of fig .
[ fig : landscape1 ] ( b ) .
significant population of the @xmath68 state is obtained for intensities larger than @xmath80w/@xmath64 and pulses shorter than 150@xmath47fs .
however , the @xmath68 state starts to be populated already at smaller pulse intensities .
this inhibits a perfect 50%-50% superposition of the states @xmath46 and @xmath74 . in a typical experimental setup ,
the transform - limited pulse duration is fixed , i.e. , to 100@xmath47fs , whereas the intensity is more easily varied .
the dependence of the final state populations on pulse intensity for a 100@xmath47fs pulse is presented in fig .
[ fig : op ] , as marked by the black lines in fig .
[ fig : landscape1 ] . for low intensity , the behaviour is similar to a two - level system , as to be expected from the nearest neighbour coupling in hamiltonian .
as the intensity increases , more levels are populated and the result deviates more and more from the simple two - level picture . for even higher pulse intensities ,
recurring peaks of low @xmath34 states appear .
note that only a small number of levels can be superimposed at a given field intensity .
intensities for which population curves cross , indicating equal population , are particularly interesting for interferometry since they should yield good contrast . the first such occurrence , at @xmath81 w/@xmath64 for @xmath82 and @xmath74 , is marked by @xmath73 in the figure .
another crossing occurs at @xmath83 w/@xmath64 for @xmath74 and @xmath68 .
but for incoherent initial states , corresponding to the experimental distribution of ref .
@xcite ( solid lines ) and a thermal ensemble at 20@xmath47k ( dashed lines ) . ]
the dynamics becomes more involved for incoherent initial states since in this case also states with @xmath84 are initially populated .
figure [ fig : ensemble ] shows the final field - free state populations as a function of laser intensity for a 100@xmath47fs pulse , comparing two different initial states , the experimental distribution of ref .
@xcite and a thermal ensemble at 20@xmath47k .
the final @xmath46 population of the two ensembles behaves very similarly , with only a small offset in initial population .
also , both ensembles qualitatively lead to the same dynamics as the pure initial state in fig .
[ fig : op ] , confirming that the ensemble dynamics is dominated by @xmath46 , at least for the intensities examined in fig .
[ fig : ensemble ] .
the final @xmath74 population on the other hand shows some differences between the two initial ensembles , with the peak occurring slightly earlier and the maximum population difference being slightly smaller for the thermal ensemble . for @xmath68 and @xmath85 ,
the initial populations are negligible in the thermal ensemble and small , but non - zero in the experimental distribution of ref .
therefore the resulting final populations after interaction with the pulse in fig .
[ fig : ensemble ] are similar to those obtained for the pure initial state in fig .
[ fig : op ] .
although the initial population in @xmath68 and @xmath85 is non - negliglible for the experimental distribution , these states do not take part in the dynamics for pulse intensities up to @xmath86 w/@xmath64 .
this is promising in view of obtaining high - visibility interferograms even with incoherent initial states .
w/@xmath64 ( as indicated by the arrow in fig .
[ fig : op ] ) and @xmath87fs .
b : spectrum @xmath88 of the populations shown in panel ( a ) . ]
interferograms are obtained when the molecule interacts with two laser pulses , separated by a time delay , @xmath3 . for simplicity ,
the parameters @xmath43 and @xmath44 are chosen to be the same for both pulses except where indicated . first , consider the pure initial state with @xmath89 .
the laser intensity and pulse duration were chosen such that the first pulse yields equal populations for @xmath46 and @xmath74 , as marked by @xmath73 in fig .
[ fig : op ] . since very little population is transferred to states other than @xmath46 and @xmath74 by the first pulse ( @xmath90 , @xmath91 ) , a simple interference pattern is obtained in fig .
[ fig : interfer ] with the population predominantly in @xmath46 and @xmath74 for all time delays .
the condition fo revivals of the wavepacket created by the first pulse becomes @xmath92ps .
the revival time is indicated in fig . [ fig : interfer ] , confirming the estimate of 2.6@xmath47ps predicted by the correlation function .
a very high contrast , or , equivalently , large visibility , is observed for the lower @xmath34 states .
the visibility is defined as @xmath93 where @xmath94 ( @xmath95 ) is the maximum ( minimum ) population of the @xmath34th state .
the @xmath46 state reaches an almost perfect visibility of one and the @xmath74 state around 0.9 , reflecting the almost perfect 50%-50% superposition of these two states .
the fourier spectra of the delay - dependent final populations in fig .
[ fig : interfer](a ) are shown in fig . [
fig : interfer](b ) , @xmath96}$ ] with @xmath97 denoting the fourier transform and @xmath98 . as is evident from fig .
[ fig : interfer](b ) , the spectrum is useful to visualize the components of the wave packet created by the first pulse , since it displays peaks at the eigenenergies ( @xmath99 , @xmath100 , @xmath101 ) as well as at the quantum beats ( @xmath102 ) .
the similar peak heights of @xmath103 and @xmath104 at @xmath99 , @xmath100 reflect the almost identical population of the states @xmath46 and @xmath74 .
they differ at higher energies , since population from the @xmath74 state is further excited into the @xmath68 state .
k ( black ) , compared to that of a pure initial state with @xmath46 ( blue ) : final populations of the field - free rotational states ( a : @xmath46 , b : @xmath74 ) as a function of pulse delay .
pulse parameters as in fig .
[ fig : interfer ] . ]
next , fig .
[ fig : incoh ] examines the potentially detrimental effect of incoherence in the initial states on the interferogram .
it compares the interference patterns for the pure initial state of fig .
[ fig : interfer ] with those obtained for the experimental distribution of ref .
@xcite and a 20@xmath47k thermal ensemble . when measuring the final population of @xmath46 , the two incoherent ensembles give practically identical results , cf .
[ fig : incoh](a ) .
their delay - dependence is qualitatively the same as that of the pure initial state , but the maximum amplitudes are reduced from close to one down to about @xmath105 .
notwithstanding , the visibility , @xmath106 , is only reduced to 0.96 for the experimental distribution and 0.91 for the thermal ensemble . for @xmath74 ( fig . [
fig : incoh](b ) ) , the maximum population still amounts to about @xmath105 , at least for the experimental distribution .
the interferograms of the incoherent ensembles differ significantly from each other , and they also differ qualitatively from the interferogram of the pure initial state .
this simply reflects the fact that the dynamics of the @xmath74 state is affected by more states in the initial ensemble .
if one wants to test the composition of the initial state interferometrically , measurement of @xmath74 is therefore preferred to @xmath46 .
the visibility of the interferograms for @xmath74 is reduced , compared to the pure state , to 0.85 for the experimental distribution of ref .
@xcite and to 0.76 for the thermal state .
these numbers are very encouraging in view of the feasibility of a rotational interferometer . in summary ,
incoherence in the initial state does not preclude interferometry , in particular if one measures the @xmath46 population .
populations as function of delay , for different values of the polarizability anisotropy @xmath107 and increasing intensity of the second pulse ( a : identical pulse intensities , b : @xmath108 , c : @xmath109 , d : @xmath110 ) .
the pulse duration is @xmath87fs for both pulses , and the intensity of the first pulse is @xmath111w/@xmath64 .
the initial state corresponds to the experimental distribution of ref .
@xcite . ] the high visibility of the interferograms presented in sec .
[ subsec : if ] suggests that the rotational interferometer can be employed to determine molecular parameters such as the polarizability anisotropy .
figure [ fig : dalpha_pr ] shows interferograms obtained by measuring the final @xmath46 population for several values of @xmath107 in atomic units : 16.20@xmath47a@xmath112 ( the _ ab initio _ value ) , 17.01@xmath47a@xmath112 ( 5% larger ) and 15.39@xmath47a@xmath112 ( 5% smaller ) , increasing the peak intensity of the second pulse . whereas the interferograms are essential identical for the three values of the polarizability anitropy if the pulses have the same intensity ( fig .
[ fig : dalpha_pr]a ) , the curves become more and more distinguishable when the intensity of the second pulse is increased ( fig .
[ fig : dalpha_pr]b - d ) .
the better distinguishability comes at the price of a slightly deteriorated visibility of 0.79 for @xmath113 ( fig .
[ fig : dalpha_pr]c ) compared to 0.97 for equal intensities ( fig .
[ fig : dalpha_pr]a ) .
particularly promising features are observed for @xmath113 in fig .
[ fig : dalpha_pr]c for delays around @xmath114ps , @xmath115ps , @xmath116ps and @xmath117ps .
such clear differences should still be observable , even when inevitable error bars are taken into account .
populations as a function of time delay , for different values of the polarizability anisotropy @xmath107 , accounting for 2% ( a ) and 5% ( b ) measurement uncertainty in the final populations .
the initial state corresponds to the experimental distribution of ref .
@xcite with 2% uncertainty in the initial populations taken into account ( @xmath118fs for both pulses , @xmath119w/@xmath64 for the first pulse , @xmath120w/@xmath64 for the second pulse ) . ] for a smaller range of pulse delays , @xmath121ps@xmath122ps@xmath123 $ ] . ]
measurement errors in the final @xmath46 population of 2% and 5% are assumed in fig .
[ fig : dalpha1](a ) and ( b ) , respectively . in the case of a 2% measurement error ,
the interferograms are easily distinguishable from each other , i.e. , the curves including error bars do not overlap , in various ranges of time delays , for example for @xmath124ps,2.0@xmath47ps@xmath123 $ ] , @xmath125ps,2.9@xmath47ps@xmath123 $ ] , or @xmath126ps,3.8@xmath47ps@xmath123 $ ] . for a 5% measurement error
, however , only the latter interval of pulse delays allows to determine the polarizability anisotropy with a confidence level of @xmath1275% . within this region
the interferogram is particularly sensitive to small variations in the molecular polarizability anisotropy .
a zoom of this region is shown in fig .
[ fig : dalpha_zoom ] , where two more values of @xmath107 , 16.52@xmath47a@xmath112 and 15.88@xmath47a@xmath112 , larger by @xmath1272% than the _ ab initio _ value , have also been included .
it is seen that for a 2% measurement error the interferometer is readily sensitive to @xmath0 shifts in @xmath107 , whereas for a 5% measurement error , only shifts of @xmath128 can unequivocally be distinguished .
our predictions for the sensitivity of the rotational interferometer are based on averaging over many wavepacket calculations to account for inevitable experimental inaccuracies .
one might argue that the corresponding noise effects may come into play differently in the era and the full rovibrational dynamics . in order to be sure that our conclusions are not compromised by a break - down of the era , figs .
[ fig : dalpha1 ] and [ fig : dalpha_zoom ] compare the interferogram obtained within the era for the _ ab initio _ value of @xmath107 with that obtained from full two - dimensional calculations , using hamiltonian . while slight deviations in the error bars between era and 2d model
are visible , in particular in fig .
[ fig : dalpha1](b ) and [ fig : dalpha_zoom](b ) , they are sufficiently small not to affect the confidence levels stated above .
that is , a sensitivity of the interferometer to changes in the polarizability anisotropy of @xmath1272% ( @xmath1275% ) requires the measurement errors not to exceed the same level .
a ramsey - type interferometer , employing off - resonant femtosecond laser pulses to induce rotational wavepacket dynamics in a trapped , cooled mgh@xmath2 molecular ion , can be implemented using current experimental capabilities . unlike in atom interferometry , where it is comparatively straight - forward to pick two isolated levels for rabi cycling , application of the second pulse leads to rotational ladder climbing in the molecule .
perfect visibility of the interferogram can thus only be obtained for @xmath46 , whereas measuring @xmath74 leads to 90% .
it also requires a pure initial state with @xmath46 , @xmath75 .
preparing a molecule perfectly in its rovibrational ground state is a very challenging task .
however , a ground state population of 38% , as prepared in ref .
@xcite , is found to decrease the visibility for @xmath46 to only 96% and that for @xmath74 to only 85% . even for a thermal distribution with a rotational temperature of 20@xmath47k ,
high - visibility interferograms are predicted .
the required intensities are moderate for the case of the mgh@xmath2 molecular ion , of the order of @xmath129w/@xmath64 for 100@xmath47fs laser pulses .
this suggests feasibility of a rotational ramsey interferometer , combining standard trapping and cooling techniques for molecular ions with 800@xmath47 nm femtosecond laser pulses .
such an interferometer could be used for example to determine the molecular polarizability anisotropy in the vibrational ground state by comparing an experimental interferogram to theoretical predictions for various values of @xmath130 . taking experimental uncertainties in the initial populations as well as population measurement errors into account ,
the interferometer is found to be sensitive to changes in the polarizability anisotropy of @xmath131% , respectively , @xmath132% assuming the same level of experimental inaccuracy .
it will be interesting to see whether the rotational ramsey interferometer can also be used to determine the dependence of the molecular polarizability anisotropy on the internuclear separation .
a possible route could be provided by recording rotational interferograms for several vibrational states .
alternatively , one could exploit the full rovibrational dynamics . in both cases , however , it might turn out to be difficult to disentangle effects that are due to the shape of the potential energy curve ( which is also known only approximately ) from those that are caused by the @xmath133-dependence of the polarizability anisotropy .
additionally , the interferometric technique may be utilized to probe local electric fields , such as the radio - frequency fields at different positions within a ( linear ) paul trap .
obviously , the rotational ramsey interferometer will work as well for other molecular ion species , provided the laser light does not drive resonant transitions .
we would like to thank rosario gonzlez - frez and daniel reich for fruitful discussions .
financial support by the cost action mp1001 iota , the danish ministry of higher education and science through the sapere aude program and the european commission under the seventh framework programme fp7 ga 607491 comiq is gratefully acknowledged . | a ramsey - type interferometer is suggested , employing a cold trapped ion and two time - delayed off - resonant femtosecond laser pulses .
the laser light couples to the molecular polarization anisotropy , inducing rotational wavepacket dynamics .
an interferogram is obtained from the delay dependent populations of the final field - free rotational states .
current experimental capabilities for cooling and preparation of the initial state are found to yield an interferogram visibility of more than 80% .
the interferograms can be used to determine the polarizability anisotropy with an accuracy of about @xmath0 , respectively @xmath1 , provided the uncertainty in the initial populations and measurement errors are confined to within the same limits . |
let @xmath15 be an oriented closed @xmath16-manifold , and @xmath17 a homomorphism between the tangent bundle @xmath18 and an oriented vector bundle @xmath19 of rank @xmath16 on @xmath20 .
suppose that @xmath21 allows only generic corank one singularities , namely it has only @xmath22-singularities .
when @xmath23 is an even number , the euler characteristic @xmath24 of the vector bundle @xmath19 satisfies the following formula @xmath25 where @xmath26 ( resp .
@xmath27 ) is the euler characteristic of the subset @xmath28 ( resp .
@xmath29 ) of @xmath20 at which the co - orientation induced by @xmath21 is ( resp . is not )
compatible with the orientation of @xmath18 ( cf . ) , the number @xmath30 ( resp .
@xmath31 ) is the euler characteristic of the set of positive ( resp .
negative ) @xmath32-points .
in particular , @xmath33 ( resp .
@xmath34 ) is equal to the number @xmath35 ( resp .
@xmath36 ) of positive ( resp . negative ) @xmath37-points ( cf . definition [ def : pm ] ) .
for example , the formulas for @xmath38 are given by @xmath39 moreover , when @xmath40 and @xmath21 is the bundle homomorphism map , we get @xmath41 the formula is an analogue of the gauss bonnet - type formula for closed surfaces given in ( * ? ? ?
* ( 2.4 ) ) , ( * ? ? ?
* ( 3.1 ) ) and @xcite .
in fact , the left hand side of can be written in terms of the integration of the pfaffian of curvature form of an arbitrarily given metric connection on @xmath19 .
the assumption that @xmath21 admits only @xmath42-singularities ( @xmath43 ) is meaningful , since one can generate a pair of connected @xmath44-sets on the set of @xmath45-points for each @xmath46 . also , as pointed out in saeki and sakuma @xcite , any closed orientable @xmath47-manifolds with vanishing signature admit @xmath48-maps into @xmath49 having only fold or cusp singularities .
the @xmath50-version of our formula was given by levine @xcite .
if we set @xmath21 the derivative of a morin map @xmath51 , then we get a formula , which is proved by nakai @xcite and dutertre - fukui @xcite .
( in this paper , the numbering of morin singularities is different from the usual one , see remark [ rmk : morin ] . )
so the formula is a generalization of them .
our proof is independent of those in @xcite and @xcite .
more precisely , we apply the poincar - hopf index formula for sections of oriented vector bundles .
( in @xcite and @xcite , viro s integral calculus @xcite is applied . )
it should be remarked that index formulas in @xmath50-coefficients for globally defined morin maps @xmath52 ( @xmath53 ) are given by fukuda @xcite and saeki @xcite .
our main purpose is to prove the following two assertions : [ thm : a ] let @xmath7 be a @xmath54-manifold and @xmath0 a wave front .
suppose that @xmath13 admits only @xmath42-singularities ( @xmath55 ) .
then the singular set of @xmath13 satisfies the identity @xmath56 where @xmath57 is the degree of the gauss map @xmath58 induced by @xmath13 , @xmath59 ( resp .
@xmath60 ) is the euler characteristic of the subset @xmath5 ( resp .
@xmath6 ) of @xmath7 at which the volume density function @xmath61 is positive ( resp .
negative ) for an oriented local coordinate system @xmath62 , where @xmath63 .
this formula is not a direct consequence of the index formula for the gauss map @xmath1 .
in fact , the singular set of @xmath13 does not coincide with that of its gauss map in general . on the other hand ,
the following assertion is a hypersurface version of ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 3.2 ) .
[ thm : b ] let @xmath64 be the @xmath54-sphere and @xmath65 a strictly convex immersion .
suppose that the blaschke normal map @xmath66 ( cf . admits only @xmath22-singularities for @xmath67 .
then the singular set of @xmath68 satisfies the identity , where @xmath69 is the subset of @xmath64 at which the determinant of the affine shape operator ( called the affine gauss - kronecker curvature ) is negative , and @xmath70 ( resp .
@xmath71 ) is the set of positive ( resp .
negative ) @xmath32-points of @xmath72 for each @xmath73 . to prove the formula
, we apply our formula by setting @xmath21 the derivative of the affine shape operator of @xmath13 ( see section [ sec : appl ] ) .
the paper is organized as follows : in section [ sec : prelim ] , we give a precise definition of @xmath22-singularities and show the well - definedness of the positivity and the negativity of odd order @xmath12-singular points .
in section [ sec : char ] , we define characteristic vector fields with respect to the homomorphism @xmath17 and show the existence of such a vector field @xmath74 defined on @xmath20 .
it is well - known that the sum of all indices of zeros of a section @xmath75 of @xmath19 are equal to the euler characteristic @xmath24 of the vector bundle @xmath19 .
since the section @xmath76 of @xmath19 has finitely many zeros , it holds that @xmath77 using this , we prove the formulas . however ,
for the sake of simplicity , we prove only for the cases @xmath38 in sections [ sec : even2 ] and [ sec : even4 ] .
the general formulas can be easily follows by imitating these proofs .
finally , in section [ sec : appl ] , we prove theorems [ thm : a ] and [ thm : b ] .
several other applications are also given in section [ sec : appl ] .
let @xmath20 be an oriented closed @xmath16-manifold and @xmath17 a bundle homomorphism between the tangent bundle @xmath78 and an oriented vector bundle @xmath19 of rank @xmath16 .
then a point @xmath79 is called a _ singular point _ if the linear map @xmath80 has a non - trivial kernel , where @xmath81 is the fiber of @xmath19 at @xmath82 .
since @xmath20 is oriented , we can take a non - vanishing @xmath16-form @xmath83 defined on @xmath20 which is compatible with respect to the orientation of @xmath20 .
furthermore , since @xmath19 is also oriented , there is a non - vanishing section @xmath84 of the determinant line bundle of the dual @xmath85 of @xmath19 defined on @xmath20 which is compatible with the orientation of @xmath19 .
then there is a ( unique ) @xmath48-function @xmath86 such that @xmath87 where @xmath88 is the pull - back of @xmath84 by @xmath21 .
we set @xmath89 a point @xmath79 is a singular point if and only if @xmath90 . a singular point @xmath79 is called _ nondegenerate _ if the exterior derivative @xmath91 does not vanish at @xmath82 .
the bundle homomorphism @xmath21 is called _ nondegenerate _ if all of the singular points are nondegenerate .
if @xmath92 is nondegenerate , the singular set @xmath93 of @xmath21 is an embedded hypersurface of @xmath20 , which coincides with the boundary @xmath94 .
suppose @xmath92 is nondegenerate .
[ def : phi - function ] let @xmath95 be an open subset of @xmath20 .
a function @xmath96 is called a _ @xmath21-function _ around @xmath97 if the following hold : 1 .
@xmath98 and has the same sign of @xmath99 , and 2 .
@xmath100 is the level set @xmath101 near @xmath82 . for each @xmath21-function , the well - known preparation theorem for @xmath48-functions yields that there exists a @xmath48-function @xmath102 on @xmath95 such that @xmath103 of course
, @xmath104 itself is a @xmath21-function . in the following discussion
, we may replace @xmath104 by an arbitrarily fixed @xmath21-function . since @xmath21 is nondegenerate , the kernel of @xmath21 at each point @xmath105 is of dimension @xmath106 .
in particular , there exists a smooth vector field @xmath107 defined on a sufficiently small neighborhood @xmath108 such that the restriction @xmath109 has the property that @xmath110 belongs to the kernel of @xmath111 for each @xmath112 .
we call @xmath113 a _ null vector field _ and @xmath107 an _ extended null vector field _ ( cf
. @xcite ) .
we set @xmath114 , @xmath115 and @xmath116 inductively .
[ def : pm ] let @xmath117 be a nondegenerate bundle homomorphism and @xmath118 its singular set .
a point @xmath105 is called an _ @xmath119-point _ if the extended null vector field @xmath107 is not a tangent vector of @xmath118 at @xmath82 ( cf .
* definition 2.1 ) ) .
then the set of @xmath119-points is given by @xmath120 a point @xmath121 is called _ @xmath8-nondegenerate _
if @xmath122 does not vanish at @xmath82 . in this case @xmath123 consists of a hypersurface in @xmath118 near @xmath82 .
a point @xmath105 is called an _ @xmath124-point _ if it is not an @xmath125-point , but @xmath126 does not vanish at @xmath82 . in this case
, @xmath82 is @xmath8-nondegenerate and the set of @xmath124-points near @xmath82 is given by ( cf .
* definition 2.2 ) ) @xmath127 we define @xmath128-points ( @xmath129 ) inductively , assuming that @xmath42-points has been defined , as follows : suppose that @xmath82 is a @xmath130-nondegenerate point .
then the set @xmath131 of @xmath130-nondegenerate points is an embedded @xmath132-submanifold of @xmath20 near @xmath82 .
then @xmath82 is called a _ @xmath133-nondegenerate point _ , if @xmath134 does not vanish at @xmath82 . by this induction
, it holds that @xmath135 which is an @xmath132-dimensional submanifold of @xmath20 .
a @xmath136-nondegenerate point @xmath105 is called an _ @xmath128-point _ if it is not an @xmath22-point and @xmath137 does not vanish at @xmath82 . by definition , such a point @xmath82 is @xmath130-nondegenerate and the set of @xmath128-points has the following expression near @xmath82 : @xmath138 our definition of @xmath22-points is independent of both the choice of extended null vector fields @xmath107 and the choice of @xmath21-functions @xmath104 ( cf .
@xcite ) .
[ rmk : morin ] as seen in the following examples [ ex : morin ] and [ ex : wave ] , our definition of @xmath22-points gives a unified intrinsic treatment of singularities of morin maps between the same dimensional manifolds and the @xmath22-singularities appeared in hypersurfaces in @xmath139 at the same time .
however , in this intrinsic treatment , usual @xmath130-th singularities for morin maps and @xmath128-singularities for wave fronts are both regarded as @xmath128-singularities of bundle homomorphisms . in other words
, the order of singularities of morin maps is not synchronized with the order of singularities of the corresponding bundle homomorphisms .
for example , a fold ( i.e. a morin-1-singularity ) and a cusp ( i.e. a morin-2-singularity ) induce an @xmath125-singular point and an @xmath140-singular point of bundle homomorphism , respectively . the following assertion holds : [ fact : ojm ] a point @xmath105 is an @xmath128-point @xmath141 if and only if 1 .
[ item : ojm:1 ] @xmath142 , @xmath143 , 2 .
[ item : ojm:2 ] and the jacobi matrix of an @xmath144-valued @xmath48-map @xmath145 is of rank @xmath130 at @xmath82 . if @xmath146 , then @xmath147 and the condition [ item : ojm:2 ] of fact [ fact : ojm ] is automatically satisfied for @xmath125-points and @xmath140-points . in other words , the second condition of fact [ fact : ojm ]
comes into effectively only @xmath129 .
we denote by @xmath148 the set of @xmath22-points in @xmath20 .
[ def : morin ] a nondegenerate bundle homomorphism @xmath17 is called a _
morin homomorphism _ if the set of singular points of @xmath21 consists of @xmath22-points for @xmath149 .
this definition is motivated by the existence of the following two typical examples : [ ex : morin ] let @xmath20 and @xmath150 be oriented @xmath16-manifolds , and let @xmath51 be a @xmath48-map having only morin singularities .
then the differential @xmath151 of @xmath13 canonically induces a map @xmath152 which gives a morin homomorphism ( cf .
appendix of @xcite ) .
let @xmath153 and @xmath154 be the fundamental @xmath16-forms of @xmath20 and @xmath150 , respectively .
then there exists a @xmath48-function @xmath104 on @xmath20 such that @xmath155 holds .
the set @xmath28 ( resp .
@xmath29 ) coincides with the set where @xmath156 ( @xmath157 ) .
the sign of the @xmath21-function @xmath104 coincides with the sign of the jacobian of @xmath13 with respect to oriented local coordinate systems of @xmath20 and @xmath150 . in this case , @xmath148-singularities of the morin map @xmath13 are @xmath128-singularities of the morin homomorphism @xmath158 ( see remark [ rmk : morin ] ) .
[ ex : wave ] let @xmath159 be a wave front which admits only @xmath128-singularities ( @xmath160 ) .
suppose that @xmath13 is _ co - orientable _ , that is , there exists a globally defined unit normal vector field @xmath1 along @xmath13 .
let @xmath161 be the pull - back of @xmath162 by @xmath13 , and consider the subbundle @xmath163 of @xmath161 whose fiber @xmath81 at @xmath79 is the orthogonal complement of @xmath164 .
then the differential @xmath151 of @xmath13 induces a bundle homomorphism @xmath165 called the _
first homomorphism _ of @xmath13 as in ( * ? ? ? * section 2 ) , which gives a morin homomorphism ( cf .
appendix of @xcite ) .
consider a function @xmath166 where @xmath167 ( @xmath168 ) and @xmath169 is an oriented local coordinate system of @xmath20 .
then @xmath104 is a @xmath21-function , and the set @xmath28 ( resp .
@xmath29 ) coincides with the set where @xmath156 ( resp .
@xmath157 ) .
we fix a morin homomorphism @xmath170 .
then @xmath171 hold .
since @xmath20 is orientable and closed , @xmath172 are @xmath173-dimensional orientable and closed submanifolds of @xmath20 , for each @xmath174 .
we now fix a riemannian metric @xmath175 on @xmath20 .
then , we can take a normal vector field @xmath176 globally defined on each hypersurface @xmath172 embedded in @xmath177 for @xmath174 , where @xmath178 .
the following assertion holds , which will play a crucial role in proving our index formula : [ prop : k_even ] if @xmath130 @xmath179 is even , then the sign of the function @xmath180 as in on the set @xmath131 does not depend on the choice of the sign of the null vector field @xmath113 .
even if we change the null vector field @xmath113 to @xmath181 , the sign of the function @xmath180 on the set @xmath131 does not change , since @xmath130 is even . by the proposition above , the following two subsets of @xmath131 are well - defined if @xmath130 is even : @xmath182 [ prop : k_odd ] let @xmath130 be an odd number , and @xmath82 an @xmath128-point
. then the vector field @xmath183 along @xmath131 points towards the domain @xmath184 at @xmath82 , where @xmath178 .
we denote by @xmath185 the riemannian metric of @xmath186 induced by the riemannian manifold @xmath187 .
then the hypersurface @xmath131 embedded in @xmath186 can be characterized as the level set @xmath188 .
then we have that @xmath189 where `` @xmath190 '' denotes the gradient of the function with respect to the metric @xmath185 .
thus @xmath191 is positive at @xmath82 .
since @xmath192 gives the normal vector field along @xmath131 pointing towards @xmath184 , the assertion is proven .
there is @xmath193-ambiguity in the choice of a normal vector @xmath194 along the hypersurface @xmath131 in @xmath186 .
so , if @xmath130 is odd , we assume that @xmath194 points towards the direction @xmath184 .
[ def : pm - ak ] let @xmath17 be a morin homomorphism and @xmath82 an @xmath12-point . since the sign of @xmath195 does not depend on the @xmath193 ambiguity of the choice of extended null vector field @xmath107 ( cf .
proposition [ prop : k_even ] ) , we call @xmath82 a _ positive @xmath12-point _ ( resp . a _ negative @xmath12-point _ ) if @xmath195 is positive ( resp
. negative ) .
the set of positive ( resp .
negative ) @xmath12-points is denoted by @xmath196 ( resp .
@xmath197 ) . then @xmath198 hold . if @xmath199 and @xmath200 is a wave front , then positive ( resp .
negative ) @xmath140-points as in example [ ex : wave ] correspond to positive ( resp .
negative ) swallowtails .
the riemannian metric @xmath175 on @xmath20 induces a geodesic distance function on each submanifold @xmath172 ( @xmath174 ) . for a positive number @xmath201 ,
we denote by @xmath202 the @xmath203-tubular neighborhood of @xmath172 in @xmath204 , where @xmath178 . since our conclusion does not depend on riemannian metrics on @xmath20
, we may also assume that our riemannian metric @xmath175 satisfies the following condition , by changing the metric if necessary : @xmath205 let @xmath74 be a vector field of @xmath20 which vanishes at @xmath79 .
take a local coordinate system @xmath206 at @xmath82 and write @xmath207 then a zero @xmath82 of @xmath74 is called _ generic _ if the jacobian of the map @xmath208 does not vanish at @xmath209 . a vector field @xmath74 defined on @xmath20
is called _ generic _ if all its zeros are generic .
[ def : x ] a @xmath48-vector field @xmath74 defined on @xmath20 is called a _
characteristic vector field _ for a morin homomorphisum @xmath117 , if it satisfies the following four conditions . 1 .
[ char:0 ] @xmath74 is a generic vector field on @xmath20 which does not vanish at each point of @xmath118 .
[ char:1 ] for each @xmath210 , there exists a generic vector field @xmath211 along @xmath212 such that the zeros of @xmath213 on @xmath214 coincide exactly with the zeros of @xmath211 on @xmath212 .
moreover , @xmath215 holds on @xmath212 . in particular
, @xmath213 vanishes on @xmath216-points .
[ char:2 ] for each @xmath128-point @xmath82 ( i.e. @xmath217 ) satisfying @xmath218=0 , there exists a neighborhood @xmath95 of @xmath82 of @xmath20 such that the restriction @xmath74 to @xmath219 is tangent to @xmath220 for @xmath221 .
[ char:3 ] the function given by the inner product @xmath222 is non - negative along @xmath212 and positive on @xmath223 for @xmath224 and for sufficiently small @xmath201 . in this section , we shall construct a characteristic vector field , which will play a crucial role in proving the formula in the introduction : there exists a characteristic vector field defined on @xmath20 associated to a morin homomorphism @xmath21 . for each @xmath225 , the @xmath226-th
normal vector @xmath227 is a null vector at @xmath82 . applying lemma [ lem : app ] in the appendix by setting @xmath228 and @xmath229
, there exists a generic vector field @xmath230 on @xmath231 such that @xmath232 for each @xmath225 .
thus we can take a vector field @xmath230 on @xmath231 which does not vanish on @xmath233 . by definition
, @xmath234 holds , where @xmath235 ( resp .
@xmath236 ) is the zeros of @xmath237 ( resp .
@xmath230 ) .
we extend @xmath230 to a vector field @xmath238 on @xmath239 : we consider a @xmath203-tubular neighborhood @xmath240 in @xmath239 .
since we can take @xmath203 to be sufficiently small , there exists a canonical diffeomorphism @xmath241 \longrightarrow \overline{{\mathcal{n}}_\delta(\sigma^1)}\ ] ] such that @xmath242 is a normal geodesic with the arclength parameter starting from each @xmath243 with the initial velocity vector @xmath244 .
then @xmath245 gives the unit vector field defined on @xmath240 which is an extension of @xmath244 .
let @xmath246 $ ] be a smooth function satisfying @xmath247 and @xmath248 on @xmath249 .
let @xmath250 be the vector field on @xmath240 via parallel transport of @xmath230 along each normal geodesic @xmath251 .
we set @xmath252 which is a vector field on @xmath240 .
since @xmath253 on @xmath254 , @xmath255 has no zeros on @xmath240 .
moreover , @xmath256 holds on @xmath231 because of the property .
since @xmath239 is compact , we can apply lemma [ lem : app ] in the appendix by setting @xmath257 and @xmath258 , and get a generic vector field @xmath238 defined on @xmath259 such that @xmath238 coincides with @xmath230 on @xmath231 . by definition
, @xmath260 holds .
moreover , @xmath261 does not meet @xmath240 , by our construction .
we now assume that @xmath211 @xmath262 has been already defined and give a method to construct the vector field @xmath263 , as follows : since @xmath203 can be taken to be sufficiently small , there exists a canonical diffeomorphism @xmath264
\longrightarrow \overline{{\mathcal{n}}_\delta(\sigma^k)}\ ] ] such that @xmath265 is the normal geodesic of @xmath266 with arclength parameter starting from each @xmath267 into the direction @xmath268 .
then @xmath269 gives the unit vector field defined on @xmath270 as an extension of @xmath268 .
let @xmath271\ ] ] be a smooth function such that @xmath272 and @xmath273 on @xmath274 .
let @xmath275 be the vector field on @xmath270 via parallel transport of @xmath211 along each normal geodesic @xmath276 .
we set @xmath277 which is a vector field on @xmath270 .
then @xmath278 has no zeros on @xmath270 since @xmath211 does not vanish on @xmath279 .
we then apply lemma [ lem : app ] in the appendix by setting @xmath280 and get a generic vector field @xmath263 defined on @xmath266 such that @xmath74 coincides with @xmath211 on @xmath281 .
it can be easily checked that @xmath282 is a desired characteristic vector field .
here we prove formula for @xmath199 .
although this formula was proved as a corollary of the gauss - bonnet formula in @xcite and @xcite , our proof in this section is new .
let @xmath74 be a characteristic vector field associated to @xmath283 .
take a section @xmath75 of @xmath19 as @xmath76 .
then the following assertion holds : [ prop : dim2_a ] let @xmath284 , @xmath261 and @xmath236 be the set of zeros for @xmath75 , @xmath74 and @xmath230 , respectively .
then it holds that @xmath285 since @xmath286 , the property [ char:0 ] implies that @xmath287 .
since @xmath288 is a linear isomorphism when @xmath289 , we have .
since @xmath290 is an empty set , the property [ char:2 ] of characteristic vector field yields @xmath291 since @xmath292 on @xmath231 and @xmath230 is proportional to a null vector @xmath293 on each @xmath140-point @xmath82 , we can get . when @xmath199 , reduces to @xmath294 [ prop : dim2_b ] the first term of the right - hand side of satisfies @xmath295 we denote by @xmath296 the sign of the function @xmath104 at a point @xmath82 .
since @xmath297 ( resp .
@xmath298 ) if @xmath299 is orientation preserving ( resp .
orientation reversing ) , we have that @xmath300 we set @xmath301 where the overline means the closure operations .
if we choose @xmath203 sufficiently small , then @xmath302 is contained in @xmath303 and @xmath304 ( resp .
@xmath305 ) has the same homotopy type as @xmath306 ( resp .
@xmath307 ) . in particular , the following identity holds @xmath308 here , @xmath309 ( resp .
@xmath74 ) is the outward vector of @xmath310 ( resp .
@xmath311 ) by the property [ char:3 ] of definition [ def : x ] of the characteristic vector field @xmath74 . since the operation @xmath312 is orientation preserving , applying the poincar - hopf index formula ( cf .
@xcite ) , we have that @xmath313 similarly , we can also show that @xmath314 which proves the assertion .
[ prop : dim2_add ] the second term of the right - hand side of satisfies @xmath315 we fix @xmath82 on @xmath316 .
then @xmath82 is an @xmath125-point .
let @xmath317 be a local coordinate system of @xmath259 around @xmath82 which is compatible to the orientation of @xmath259 such that @xmath231 is the level set @xmath318 and @xmath319 gives an extended null vector field on @xmath95 ( cf . ) . by the well - known preparation theorem for @xmath48-functions , there exists a section @xmath320 of @xmath19 on @xmath95 such that @xmath321 . on the other hand
, we set @xmath322 . then @xmath323 gives a frame field of @xmath19 on @xmath95 .
in fact , since @xmath324 is a @xmath92-function ( cf . definition [ def : phi - function ] ) , there exists a @xmath48-function @xmath13 such that ( cf . )
@xmath325 which implies that @xmath326 .
now we set @xmath327 then it holds that @xmath328 since @xmath104 vanishes on @xmath329 , we have @xmath330 , where @xmath331 . in particular , @xmath332 holds at @xmath82 . on the other hand , since @xmath333 holds at @xmath82 ,
we have that @xmath334 here we used that @xmath335 , which is the conclusion of [ char:1 ] of definition [ def : x ] , @xmath336 , and the fact that @xmath337 . since @xmath338 for sufficiently small @xmath203 , the characteristic vector field @xmath74 points in the direction of @xmath339 at @xmath82 .
so we have that @xmath340 holds at @xmath82 .
thus @xmath341 and @xmath342 since @xmath343 , applying the poincar - hopf index formula for the vector field @xmath230 on @xmath231 , we get the assertion .
by , propositions [ prop : dim2_b ] and [ prop : dim2_add ] , the formula follows immediately from the following assertion : [ prop : dim2_c ] let @xmath82 be an arbitrarily given @xmath140-point .
then it holds that @xmath344 we take a local coordinate system @xmath317 centered at @xmath82 such that @xmath345 gives a null vector field along @xmath231 .
in particular , @xmath346 .
we set @xmath347 .
since @xmath348 ( @xmath349 ) vanishes on @xmath231 , there exists a section @xmath350 of @xmath19 on @xmath95 such that @xmath351 .
since @xmath352 is a @xmath21-function ( see definition [ def : phi - function ] ) , there exists a @xmath48-function @xmath13 such that ( cf . ) @xmath353 which implies that @xmath354 consists of a frame of @xmath19 on @xmath95 .
we set @xmath355 by [ char:2 ] and [ char:0 ] of definition [ def : x ] , @xmath356 and @xmath357 , and hence we have @xmath358 and @xmath359 .
we now set @xmath360 then it holds that @xmath361 and @xmath362 . by [ char:2 ] of definition [ def :
x ] , @xmath74 is tangent to @xmath231 on a neighborhood of @xmath82 .
since @xmath104 vanishes along @xmath231 , it holds that @xmath363 at @xmath82 , where we used the fact that @xmath364 .
since @xmath365 vanishes along @xmath231 and @xmath366 , the fact @xmath367 yields that @xmath368 holds at @xmath82 . since @xmath369 and @xmath370 , we can conclude that @xmath371 .
in particular , we have that @xmath372 by using the facts @xmath373 , we have that @xmath374 since the sign of an @xmath140-point coincides with the sign of @xmath375 , proposition [ prop : dim2_c ] is proved .
in this section , we prove the following assertion , which will be a key to proving our formula for @xmath16-dimensional manifolds ( @xmath376 ) .
[ thm : coord ] let @xmath74 be a characteristic vector field associated to the bundle homomorphism @xmath17 .
let @xmath206 be a local coordinate system centered at an @xmath128-point @xmath79 @xmath377 satisfying the following properties : 1 . [ coord:1 ]
@xmath378 gives a local coordinate system of the singular submanifold @xmath379 for each @xmath380 , that is , @xmath381 2 .
[ coord:2 ] @xmath382 spans the tangent space of @xmath379 for each @xmath380 at @xmath82 , 3 .
[ coord:3 ] @xmath383 coincides with an extended null vector field @xmath107 on @xmath95 .
suppose that @xmath384 vanishes at @xmath82 .
then @xmath74 has an expression @xmath385 such that @xmath386 and we have @xmath387 [ ref : exists ] the existence of the coordinate system @xmath169 as in is shown as follows : firstly , we take a coordinate system @xmath388 such that @xmath389 gives a local coordinate ( at @xmath82 ) of the singular submanifold @xmath379 for each @xmath390
. let @xmath107 be an extended null vector field and @xmath391 be the local @xmath106-parameter group of transformations generated by @xmath392 .
consider the map @xmath393 which gives the desired local coordinate system .
by @xmath394 at @xmath82 , the property [ char:0 ] of the characteristic vector field @xmath74 and [ coord:3 ] , we have .
moreover , the property [ coord:1 ] , @xmath395 ( as in definition [ def : x ] ) is represented as @xmath396 we set @xmath397 by the well - known preparation theorem for @xmath48-functions , we can write @xmath398 , where @xmath399 is a local section defined on a neighborhood of @xmath82 . since @xmath400 is a @xmath21-function , we have that @xmath401 which implies that @xmath320 , , @xmath402 gives a frame on the vector bundle @xmath19 around @xmath82 .
so we can write @xmath403 we set @xmath404 if @xmath405 , it holds that @xmath406 since @xmath104 vanishes on @xmath118 , the property [ coord:2 ] implies that @xmath407 moreover , since @xmath369 ( in fact , @xmath82 is a nondegenerate singular point ) , we have that @xmath408 then the equality @xmath409 yields that @xmath410 consider the case that @xmath411 . then by the property [ char:2 ] in definition [ def : x ] , @xmath74 is a tangent vector of @xmath118 . since @xmath104 vanishes along @xmath118 , we have @xmath412 since @xmath413 , , @xmath414 are tangent vectors of @xmath118 at @xmath82 , and yield that @xmath415 holds at @xmath82 , where @xmath416 and we used the fact that @xmath417 on the other hand , @xmath418 is identically zero on @xmath419 , so [ coord:2 ] implies that @xmath420 hence we have @xmath421 now we would like to show that @xmath422 for @xmath423 , by induction .
we have already shown it for @xmath2 .
we prove the assertion for @xmath424 , assuming it is true up until @xmath425 .
since @xmath74 is a tangent vector of @xmath426 and @xmath427 is constant along @xmath426 , we have that @xmath428 since @xmath429 is identically zero on @xmath426 . on the other hand ,
since @xmath430 vanishes for @xmath431 , the fact @xmath432 implies that @xmath433 differentiating and using , we get the identity @xmath434 then , the fact @xmath435 ( @xmath436 ) reduces to the following two identities @xmath437 which proves . in particular ,
when @xmath438 , it holds that @xmath439 since @xmath440 .
now taking into the account , we have that @xmath441 hence we have @xmath442 which proves the assertion .
let @xmath74 be a characteristic vector field associated to a morin homomorphism @xmath443 as in the previous section . take a section @xmath75 of @xmath19 as @xmath444 we denote by @xmath261 and @xmath284 the set of zeros of @xmath74 and @xmath75 , respectively . the following assertion can be proved like as in proposition [ prop : dim2_a ] .
[ prop : dim4_a ] let @xmath445 @xmath446 be the set of zeros for @xmath447 . then it holds that @xmath448 like as for proposition [ prop : dim2_b ] , one can prove the following assertion : [ prop : dim4_b ] the first term of the right - hand side of in the introduction satisfies @xmath449 now the formula for the four dimensional case reduces to the following two propositions : [ prop : dim4_c ] the second and forth terms of the right - hand side of in the introduction satisfy @xmath450 we set @xmath451 ( resp .
@xmath452 ) and fix a point @xmath453 satisfying @xmath454 arbitrarily . by the property [ char:2 ] in definition [ def : x ] , there exists a vector field @xmath447 on @xmath172 such that @xmath455 .
setting @xmath146 ( resp .
@xmath456 ) , we can apply theorem [ thm : coord ] by setting @xmath457 for a local coordinate system @xmath458 such that @xmath459 gives a null vector field . in this coordinate system
, it holds that @xmath460 by [ char:3 ] of definition [ def : x ] , it holds that @xmath461 since @xmath130 is odd and @xmath462 is positively proportional to @xmath463 , [ char:3 ] of definition [ def : x ] yields that @xmath464 thus @xmath465 holds .
since @xmath455 and @xmath220 is odd dimensional , it holds that @xmath466 [ prop : dim4_d ] the third and fifth terms of the right - hand side of in the introduction satisfy @xmath467 we set @xmath468 ( resp .
@xmath469 ) and fix a point @xmath453 satisfying @xmath454 arbitrarily . by the property [ char:2 ] of the characteristic vector field , there exists a vector field @xmath447 on @xmath172 such that @xmath455 . setting @xmath470 ( resp .
@xmath471 ) , we can apply theorem [ thm : coord ] on putting @xmath457 for a local coordinate system @xmath458 such that @xmath459 gives a null vector field . since @xmath173 is
even , it holds that @xmath472 we denote by @xmath473 and @xmath474 the closures of the sets @xmath475 and @xmath476 , respectively . by [ char:3 ] , @xmath447 points towards @xmath477 .
since @xmath173 is even , the poincar - hopf formula yields that @xmath478 similarly , we have that @xmath479 which proves the assertion .
when @xmath20 is odd dimensional , that is , @xmath480 , one can prove @xmath481 and @xmath482 like as in proposition [ prop : dim4_d ] , since @xmath483 is inward for @xmath484 and outward for @xmath485 .
then we have @xmath486 on the other hand , we have @xmath487 like as in proposition [ prop : dim4_c ] . hence splits into @xmath16-sets of trivial identities .
this is the reason why we restricted our attention to even dimensional case up to now .
in this section , we shall give several applications of our formula : recall that a map @xmath488 between @xmath54-manifolds is called a _
morin map _ if the corresponding bundle homomorphism @xmath158 as in example [ ex : morin ] admits only @xmath22-singularities for @xmath489 ( cf .
remark [ rmk : morin ] ) .
[ thm : quine ] let @xmath7 and @xmath490 be compact oriented @xmath54-manifolds , and let @xmath488 be a morin map .
then it holds that @xmath491 where @xmath492 is the topological degree of the map @xmath13 and @xmath5 ( resp .
@xmath6 ) is the set of points at which the jacobian of @xmath13 is positive ( resp .
negative ) .
this formula is a generalization of quine s formula @xcite for morin maps between @xmath8-manifolds .
it should be remarked that the numbering of morin singularities are different from the usual one , see remark [ rmk : morin ] ) .
for example , fold ( resp .
cusp ) singularity is an @xmath125-singularity ( resp .
an @xmath140-singularity ) in .
let @xmath19 be the pull - back of the tangent bundle @xmath493 of @xmath490 by @xmath13 .
then the map @xmath13 induces a bundle - homomorphism @xmath494 as in example [ ex : morin ] .
since @xmath13 is a morin map , @xmath495 has only @xmath22-singular points , and then the formula follows from using the fact that @xmath496 .
[ rmk : df1 ] when @xmath3 , the stable singularities of @xmath497 maps between @xmath47-manifolds consist of @xmath22-singular points , elliptic and hyperbolic umbilic points
. then a generalization of for stable mapping @xmath13 is given in ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 5.13 ) as follows : @xmath498 where @xmath499 ( resp .
@xmath500 ) is the number of positive ( resp .
negative ) hyperbolic umbilic points .
in fact , elliptic umbilic points do not affect the formula .
next we give applications for immersed hypersurfaces in @xmath14 .
let @xmath7 be a compact oriented @xmath54-manifold and @xmath0 a wave front .
suppose that there exists a globally defined unit normal vector field @xmath1 along @xmath13 .
then it induces the gauss map @xmath501 and a family of wave fronts @xmath502 each of which is called a _ parallel hypersurface _ of @xmath13 .
the gauss map of @xmath503 is equal to @xmath504 .
[ thm : bw2 ] let @xmath7 be a compact oriented @xmath54-manifold and @xmath505 an immersion .
suppose that the gauss map @xmath506 is a morin map .
then the singular set of @xmath506 satisfies the identity in the introduction , where @xmath6 is the set of points at which the gauss - kronecker curvature of @xmath13 ( i.e. the determinant of the shape operator ) is negative .
this formula is a generalization of the bleeker - wilson formula @xcite for gauss maps of immersed surfaces in @xmath14 .
we apply the formula for the gauss map @xmath506 of the immersion @xmath13 .
then we have that @xmath507 since @xmath13 is an immersion , it is well - known that @xmath508 is equal to @xmath509 .
next , we show that @xmath5 ( resp .
@xmath6 ) coincide with the set where the gauss - kronecker curvature is positive ( resp .
negative ) : let @xmath175 be the induced riemannian metric on @xmath7 by the immersion @xmath13 , and let @xmath510 be an oriented local orthonormal frame field on @xmath511 such that @xmath512 that is , @xmath320 ,
, @xmath513 are eigenvector fields of the shape operator of @xmath13 , and @xmath514 , , @xmath515 are principal curvatures
. then we have that @xmath516 where @xmath517 is the gauss - kronecker curvature of @xmath13 .
this @xmath104 is positive ( resp .
negative ) if and only if @xmath518 ( resp .
@xmath519 ) , which proves the assertion .
[ rmk : df2 ] applying to the same argument , the statement for @xmath3 of corollary [ thm : bw2 ] is improved as follows : let @xmath520 be an immersion .
suppose that the gauss map @xmath506 is a stable map .
then the singular set of @xmath506 satisfies the identity @xmath521 where @xmath499 ( resp .
@xmath500 ) is the number of positive ( resp .
negative ) hyperbolic umbilic points of @xmath506 .
we apply our formula for the bundle homomorphism @xmath522 as in example [ ex : wave ] .
then it is sufficient to show that @xmath523 is equal to @xmath524 .
let @xmath68 be a vector field on the @xmath54-sphere @xmath64 . by a parallel transport , @xmath525 ( @xmath526 ) can be considered as a vectors in @xmath81 for @xmath527 .
thus , @xmath68 induces a section @xmath528 of @xmath19 defined on @xmath7
. then @xmath529 holds , which proves the identity .
next , we give an application for parallel hypersurfaces for strictly convex hypersurfaces .
[ thm : bw ] let @xmath64 be the @xmath54-sphere and @xmath530 be a strictly convex immersion , that is , the gauss map @xmath531 is a diffeomorphism .
let @xmath532 be a value such that the parallel hypersurface @xmath533 has only @xmath22-singularities @xmath534 .
then the singular set of @xmath503 satisfies the identity and @xmath535 is a @xmath536-function for @xmath537 ( cf . definition [ def : phi - function ] ) , where @xmath538 is the gauss - kronecker curvature of @xmath503
. the corresponding assertion for a convex surface @xmath539 is given by martinez - maure @xcite under the generic assumption that the gaussian curvature is unbounded at the singular set of @xmath503 , and proved in @xcite for the general case .
the above formula is a generalization of it .
we apply theorem [ thm : a ] for the bundle homomorphism @xmath540 .
since @xmath13 is convex , the gauss map @xmath541 is of degree one .
since @xmath542 is an immersion , and the gauss map @xmath504 is common in the parallel family @xmath543 we have that @xmath544 where @xmath545 ( resp .
@xmath546 ) is the set where @xmath547 , where @xmath548 is the volume density function as in the statement of theorem [ thm : a ] .
moreover , since @xmath504 is an immersion , one can take the riemannian metric @xmath549 on @xmath64 as the pull - back of the canonical metric of @xmath64 by @xmath504 , and let @xmath550 be an oriented local orthonormal frame field on @xmath64 with respect to @xmath549 such that @xmath551 that is , @xmath320 , , @xmath513 are eigenvector fields of the shape operator of @xmath13 . since @xmath552 the gauss - kronecker curvature @xmath538 of @xmath503 is expressed as @xmath553 on the other hand , @xmath554 which implies that @xmath538 is a @xmath555-function , where @xmath556 .
now we consider the singularities of vector fields on @xmath7 .
let @xmath557 be an arbitrary linear connection on @xmath7 and @xmath74 a vector field defined on @xmath7 .
one can apply the formula for the bundle homomorphism @xmath558 if @xmath495 admits only @xmath22-singularities and get the formula , where @xmath5 is the set of points where @xmath559 forms a positive frame for a given locally defined positive frame @xmath560 on @xmath561 . in @xcite
, this map was introduced on a riemannian @xmath8-manifold , and we called the singular points of @xmath562 the _ irrotational points _ there .
however , it would be better to call them the _
@xmath22-singular points of the vector field _ with respect to the connection @xmath557 .
in fact , the singular set of @xmath562 has no relation to the rotations of the vector fields . at the end of this section
, we give an application for the blaschke normal maps for strictly convex hypersurfaces : we fix a strictly convex immersion @xmath563 then there exists a unique vector field @xmath68 along @xmath13 satisfying the following two properties , which is called the _
affine normal vector field _ :
1 . the linear map @xmath564 gives an endomorphism on @xmath565 , that is , @xmath566 is tangent to @xmath567 for each @xmath568 , where @xmath557 is the canonical affine connection on @xmath14 , 2 .
there exists a unique covariant symmetric tensor @xmath569 such that @xmath570 gives a tangential vector field on @xmath567 for any vector fields @xmath230 , , @xmath571 on @xmath64 .
since @xmath13 is strictly convex , @xmath569 is positive definite .
then the @xmath54-form @xmath83 defined by @xmath572 coincides with the volume element associated to @xmath569 , where @xmath230 , , @xmath571 are vector fields on @xmath64 and `` @xmath573 '' denotes the canonical volume form of @xmath14 .
the vector field @xmath68 induces a map @xmath574 which is called the _
blaschke normal map _ of @xmath13 .
the following assertion holds like as in the case of @xmath2 ( cf .
* lemme 3.1 ) ) . the blaschke normal map @xmath72 gives a wave front .
consider a non - zero section @xmath575 where @xmath576 is the dual vector space of @xmath14 , and @xmath577 is the map defined by @xmath578 which is called the _ conormal map _ of @xmath13 . by definition , @xmath579 induces an isotropic map of @xmath64 into the projective cotangent bundle @xmath580 with the canonical contact structure .
take a local coordinate system @xmath62 of @xmath64 .
then we have that @xmath581 since @xmath569 is positive definite , one can show that @xmath582 are linearly independent .
moreover , since @xmath583 for each @xmath584 , @xmath585 is linearly independent . in particular , the map @xmath579 induces a legendrian immersion , which proves the assertion .
if the singular points of @xmath586 consist only of @xmath22-singular points ( @xmath67 ) , the affine shape operator @xmath587 gives a morin homomorphism .
applying for @xmath588 , we get theorem [ thm : b ] . finally , we give an example which demonstrates theorem [ thm : b ] : consider a plane curve @xmath589 which lies on the upper - half plane and gives a convex curve if @xmath590 .
rotate it along the horizontal axis , we get a rotationally symmetric strictly convex surface in @xmath591 .
the left hand side of figure [ fig : normal ] indicates the curve @xmath592 for @xmath593 , and the right hand side of figure [ fig : normal ] gives the profile curve of the blaschke normal map @xmath68 of the surface for @xmath593 .
as shown in figure [ fig : normal ] ( right ) , @xmath68 has no swallowtails ( i.e. it has no @xmath594-singularities ) , and our formula implies that the euler number @xmath595 vanishes .
in fact , the set @xmath596 gives a cylindrical strip if one rotate the profile curve of @xmath68 along the horizontal axis .
( left ) and the profile curve of @xmath68 ( right ) . ,
title="fig:",width=170 ] ( left ) and the profile curve of @xmath68 ( right ) .
, title="fig:",width=188 ]
we prove the following assertion , which is needed to prove the existence of a characteristic vector field associated to a given morin homomorphism : [ lem : app ] let @xmath20 be a compact manifold and @xmath74 a @xmath48-vector field defined on an open subset of @xmath20 containing a compact subset @xmath597 such that @xmath74 has no zeros on the boundary @xmath598 of @xmath597 .
then there exists a @xmath48-vector field @xmath599 defined on @xmath20 such that @xmath599 coincides with @xmath74 on @xmath597 and has only generic zeros on @xmath600 .
we may assume that @xmath74 is defined on a neighborhood @xmath95 of @xmath597 .
take an open subset @xmath601 such that @xmath602 where @xmath603 is the closure of @xmath601 .
taking @xmath95 sufficiently close to @xmath597 , we may assume that @xmath74 has no zeros on @xmath604 , where @xmath605 ( possibly empty ) is the set of the interior points of @xmath597 .
then we can take @xmath48-functions @xmath606 $ ] @xmath607 such that @xmath608 on @xmath597 ( resp .
@xmath609 on @xmath603 ) and @xmath610 on @xmath611 ( resp .
@xmath609 on @xmath612 ) .
we set @xmath613 , which is a vector field on @xmath20 .
it is well - known that there exists a sequence of generic vector fields @xmath614 on @xmath20 converging to @xmath615 with respect to the whitney @xmath48-topology .
we set @xmath616 then @xmath617 coincides with @xmath74 on @xmath597 , because @xmath618 on @xmath597 .
since @xmath615 has no zeros on the compact set @xmath619 , @xmath617 has a zero on @xmath620 if @xmath621 holds at @xmath82 .
this is impossible for sufficient large @xmath173 , since @xmath622 as @xmath623 and @xmath624 $ ] .
moreover , @xmath617 coincides with @xmath625 on @xmath611 , since @xmath610 on the complement of @xmath601 .
thus it has only generic zeros on @xmath611 .
in particular @xmath617 has the desired property for sufficiently large @xmath173 .
99 v. i. arnold , s. m. gusein - zade and a. n. varchenko , singularities of differentiable maps , vol .
@xmath106 , monographs in math .
82 , birkhuser , 1985 .
r. bott and l. w. tu , differential forms in algebraic topology ( graduate texts in mathematics ) , springer verlag 1982 .
d. bleecker and l. wilson , _ stability of gauss maps _ , illinois j. of math . * 22 * ( 1978 ) 279289 .
n. dutertre and t. fukui , _ on the topology of stable maps _ , preprint , arxiv:1009.2257 . t. fukuda , _ topology of folds , cusps and morin singularities _
, in , eds y. matsumoto , t. mizutani , and s. morita , pages 331357 , academic press , 1987 .
h. levine , _ the singularities @xmath626 _ , illinois j. math . * 8 * ( 1964 ) , 152168
. y. martinez - maure , _ sommets et normals concourantes des courbes convexes de largeur constante et singularits des hrissons _ , arch
. math .
* 79 * ( 2002 ) , 489498 .
o. saeki and k. sakuma , _
stable maps between @xmath47-manifolds and elimination of their singularities _ , j. london math
* 59 * ( 1999 ) , 11171133 .
k. saji , m. umehara and k. yamada , _ the geometry of fronts _ , ann . of math .
* 169 * ( 2009 ) , 491529 .
k. saji , m. umehara and k. yamada , _ coherent tangent bundles and gauss - bonnet formulas for wave fronts _ , to appear in journal of geometric analysis ( doi10.1007/s112220 - 010 - 9193 - 5 ) .
o. viro , _ some integral calculus based on euler characteristic _ , lecture notes in math .
1346 ( 1988 ) 127138 , springer - verlag . | let @xmath0 be a hypersurface which allow only generic corank one singularities , and admits globally defined unit normal vector field @xmath1 .
then we show the existence of an index formula .
for example , when @xmath2 or @xmath3 , it holds that @xmath4 respectively , where @xmath5 ( resp .
@xmath6 ) is the subset of @xmath7 at which the co - orientation of @xmath7 induced by @xmath1 coincides ( resp
. does not coincide ) with the orientation of @xmath7 for @xmath2 , @xmath8 , and @xmath9 ( resp .
@xmath10 ) for @xmath11 is the euler number of the set of positive ( resp .
negative ) @xmath12-singular points of @xmath13 .
the formula for @xmath2 is known . to prove the results ,
we prepare an index formula for corank one singularities of vector bundle homomorphisms on @xmath7 . as its application , an index formula for blaschke normal map of strictly convex hypersurfaces in @xmath14
is also given . |
the discovery of the first transiting exoplanet , hd209458 ( charbonneau et al . 2000 ) was quickly followed by a measurement and characterization of the planet s atmospheric transmission spectrum ( charbonneau et al . 2002 ) .
spectroscopic observations of this type provide invaluable probes of planetary physics , formation , and evolution .
the measurement , however , is difficult because of the tiny contrast , @xmath3 , between the signal ( the absorption lines in the light transmitted through the planet atmosphere ) and the background ( the unobstructed light from the host star ) . in hd209458
the observation was possible owing to the closeness ( and hence brightness , @xmath4 mag ) of the star , combined with the stability provided by the _ hubble space telescope_. only a few measurements of this kind have been successful to date ( e.g tinetti et al . 2007 ; redfield et al .
2008 ; zhou & bayliss 2012 ; see also berta et al .
2012 for a recent null result ) .
future prospects for exoplanet transmission spectra have focused on the capabilities of the _ james webb space telescope _ ( jwst ) , and on space mission concepts such as _ darwin_activities / space@xmath5science / darwin@xmath5overview/ ] and the _ terrestrial planet finder_. jwst and other future telescopes may indeed be able to extend exoplanet atmospheric measurements down to planet masses of a few earths , particularly in the habitable zones around m - stars ( e.g. , webb & wormleaton 2001 ; ehrenreich et al .
2006 ; beckwith 2008 ; kaltenegger & traub 2009 ; deming et al . 2009 ; rauer et al .
2011 ; pall et al .
2011 ; benneke & seager 2012 ) , though at the price of many tens to hundreds of hours of total exposure time , integrated over many transits , and only if such transiting planets exist around nearby m - dwarfs that are bright enough .
current studies of potentially detectable species in earth - like atmospheres have focused on water vapour , methane , co@xmath2 , o@xmath2 , and ozone in the near- to mid - infrared ( ir ) part of the spectrum .
the detection of bio - markers that signal the presence of life on a planet , such as ozone , o@xmath2 , or even the `` red edge '' of chlorophyll , is more challenging , and most studies ( e.g. von paris et al .
2013 ) have expressed pessimistic prospects for their detection even with post - jwst space missions currently considered . on earth ,
o@xmath2 is the prime bio - marker , being produced almost exclusively by photosynthesis .
the terrestrial atmosphere had a 2 - 4% oxygen abundance since an age of @xmath6 gyr , with a rise to the present - day levels of 20 - 30% starting only after another @xmath7 gyr , probably due to the appearance of large vascular land plants ( e.g. , canfield 2005 ; goldblatt et al .
2006 ; kump et al .
if all life on earth ceased , abiotic processes would remove all oxygen from the atmosphere within @xmath8 yr .
ozone , with a strong signature at 9.6@xmath9 m , is an indirect bio - marker , produced on earth via uv illumination of o@xmath2 but it can also form via abiotic processes , and may be masked by co@xmath2 absorption features ( e.g. , von paris et al . 2011 ; 2013 ) .
direct detection of o@xmath2 in exoplanet atmospheres has been considered mainly via the rather weak absorption signal at @xmath10 m ( e.g. , fujii et al .
2012 , but see palle ' et al .
2009 , where the feature is strengthened by oxygen dimers in refraction - enhanced lower - atmosphere spectra ) , and via the o@xmath2 absorption bands in the red part of the optical spectrum the a , b and @xmath11-bands , centered at @xmath12 m , @xmath13 m , and @xmath14 m , respectively .
agol ( 2011 ) noted that white dwarfs ( wds ) have long - lived habitable zones .
if these zones host earth - mass planets , the planets could potentially harbour life . whereas no planets have yet been detected around a wd , there is some circumstantial evidence for their existence .
at least one example of a stellar remnant , a neutron star , has a planetary system ( wolszczan & frail 1992 ) .
sion et al .
( 2009 ) estimated , based on the presence of photospheric metals in at least 15% of wds , which possibly results from the accretion of debris disks , that a similar fraction of wds could host terrestrial planets or asteroids . a similar analysis by zuckerman et al .
( 2010 ) suggested a fraction as high as 30% .
infrared excess emission has been found in several tens of of such polluted wds , and has been interpreted as circumstellar dust rings produced by the tidal disruption of rocky planets or planetesimals , and subsequently accreted onto the wd , which then displays related elemental signatures ( zuckerman & becklin 1987 ; kilic et al .
2005 , 2006 ; jura et al .
2009 ; farihi et al .
2009 , 2010ab,2012 ) .
in several cases ( zuckerman et al . 2007 ; klein et al .
2011 ; dufour et al .
2012 ) , the wd atmospheric abundance pattern has been studied in detail , and found to be similar to the outer composition of rocky bodies in the solar system .
gaensicke et al .
( 2006 , 2007 ) identified double - peaked emission from metal - rich gas disks around two wds , with the metals thought to result from sublimated solids .
a small planet within several au can not survive the asymptotic giant branch phase , and therefore needs to migrate in from a wider orbit to the habitable zone , after the wd has formed . even then
, barnes & heller ( 2012 ) and nordhaus & spiegel ( 2012 ) have emphasized that the tidal heating of the planet , until it had achieved full circularization and synchronization , would lead to full loss of any water and volatiles present .
we note , however , that the young earth was also a hot and dry place , but volatiles and water were then delivered to it by a barrage of comets .
the comet impact rate then decreased to its present low level , greatly lowering the biological damage of such impacts .
it is not implausible that such post - formation volatile delivery also could take place on an earth - like planet in a wd s habitable zone , perhaps driven by the same scattering process that drove the planet itself to migrate inward after the formation of the wd . di stefano et al .
( 2010 ) , drake et al .
( 2010 ) and faedi et al .
( 2011 ) noted that , owing to the small sizes of wds , transits of earth - sized and smaller planets orbiting them could easily be detected .
as pointed out by agol ( 2011 ) , the habitable zone of a wd is close to its tidal disruption region . at the smallest possible separation ,
the probability for a transit is of course the highest , and agol ( 2011 ) has outlined a survey for discovering such planets .
here we point out that , compared to planets transiting main - sequence stars , planets transiting wds will also enjoy a much higher contrast of their atmospheric transmission signal above the background light of their host stars .
this makes the characterization of a planet atmosphere via its transmission spectrum easily feasible with jwst .
in particular , we show that the a absorption band of o@xmath2 will be measurable , if o@xmath2 is present in the exoplanet at the level found on earth over the past 1 gyr or so .
below , we calculate the parameters of the required wd survey , and the detectability of the sought - after atmospheric bio - signatures .
we then simulate a jwst spectrum of an earth - like planet transit accross a wd , and summarize our main conclusions .
we begin by estimating the size and type of the wd sample that would need to be assembled and surveyed , in order to discover a transiting earth - like planet that would be amenable to an atmospheric bio - marker detection .
white dwarfs follow a narrow mass distribution , with most wds at @xmath15 ( kepler et al . 2007 ; kleinman et al . 2013 ) or @xmath16 ( holberg et al .
2008 ; gianninas et al . 2011 ; falcon et al . 2012 ; giammichele et al . 2012 ) .
either way , the radius of a wd of such typical mass is @xmath17 km ( e.g. suh & mathews 2000 ) .
agol ( 2011 ) defines a `` continuously habitable zone '' around a wd that is habitable for at least 3 gyr as a wd slowly cools . for an earth - density planet orbiting an @xmath18 wd
, this zone extends from the tidal disruption limit , at semimajor axis @xmath19 au , out to @xmath20 au . adopting @xmath21au as a fiducial value , the probability for a transit by a planet of radius @xmath22
, @xmath23 obtains a value @xmath24 for an earth - like planet with @xmath25 km . supposing 20% of all wds host an earth in their continuously habitable zones
, one would need to survey about 500 wds to discover one transiting system . keeping an eye toward discovering the o@xmath2 bio - marker in the planet transmission spectrum , and recalling that bio - generated o@xmath2 appeared on earth only after @xmath6 gyrs
, we will focus on wds that are @xmath26 gyr old .
although this terracentric bias may be misguided , the limited available observational resources dictate that we focus on the systems most likely to have had enough time for oxygen - releasing life to evolve , rather than finding null results in systems that have not had enough time .
a @xmath27 carbon - oxygen wd that cools for @xmath28 gyr reaches an effective temperature of @xmath29k ( bergeron et al .
2001 ) and a bolometric absolute magnitude @xmath30 .
apart from the fact that planets around such wds will have resided in their continuous habitable zones already for a few gyr , giving potential life some time to evolve , the temperature at this wd age can also be beneficial in terms of avoiding a hard uv spectrum that is likely detrimental to life forms .
ignoring the subtle physics of wd cooling , the rate of change in the total thermal energy content of a wd equals the power that is thermally radiated away from its surface , @xmath31 , and the thermal energy content is proportional to @xmath32 ( assuming a self - similar temperature profile throughout the cooling history ) . as a result , the cooling rate scales as @xmath33 the luminosity function of wds that are born at a rate @xmath34 will be @xmath35 with the last proportionality assuming a roughly constant star - formation rate , which leads to a constant wd formation rate , @xmath36const .
the number of wds per logarithmic luminosity interval is then @xmath37 harris et al .
( 2006 ) and giammichele et al .
( 2012 ) derived consistent measurements of the luminosity function of local wds , which is well fit by a power law with a sharp cutoff at @xmath38 mag .
the logarithmic slope of their plotted wd luminosity functions appears remarkably similar to the expected @xmath39 value based on the above simple considerations .
the cutoff magnitude , for a typical @xmath40 wd , corresponds to a stellar life time of 2.5 gyr plus a cooling time of 10 gyr , that sum to about a hubble time . at @xmath30 mag ,
the local density of wds is @xmath41 .
assembling the brightest ( and hence accessible to jwst spectroscopy ) sample of 500 wds with @xmath42 mag ( that are therefore @xmath43 gyr old ) requires an all - sky survey for wds that are within 40 pc .
most of the wds in the sample will thus have an apparent magnitude of @xmath44 .
while such an all - sky sample of local wds does not exist as of yet , the upcoming _ gaia _ astrometric mission , which will have errors of @xmath45 milliarcsec at this magnitude , will easily detect the trigonometric parallaxes of such wds and will permit assembling a wd sample such as this . the wd sample will then need to be monitored photometrically , to find the one or two cases , if they exist , that are transited by habitable - zone earth - size planets . as noted by agol ( 2011 ) , about 10% of any existing transiting planets around these
wds will be discovered already in _ gaia _
photometry , so there is a mild chance to find a transiting earth already at that stage
. the orbital period will be of order 10 to 20 hours , and the transit will last of order a minute or two , during which the wd flux will decrease by order unity .
the surveying stage can thus be carried out with a number of dedicated , 0.5m - class , telescopes , that monitor each wd continuously with 1-min cadences for a night or two . the candidate transiting cases can be followed up , using larger telescopes , with shorter - cadence photometry and radial - velocity spectroscopic observations , to determine transit ephemerides , planet sizes , and masses .
if and when an earth - like planet transiting a wd has been discovered , its atmosphere can be characterized via transmission spectroscopy . when observing a continuum source through one radial column of the earth s atmosphere at resolutions @xmath46 , the optical o@xmath2 lines become resolved and reach centre - line depths of @xmath47 in the a band and @xmath48% in the b band ( and considerably weaker in the @xmath11 band , which we will not consider further ) . at a resolution of @xmath49 that is practical with jwst in this case ,
the line depths are reduced by factors of a few . because an earth - like planet and a wd are of comparable size , the planet will cover about one - half of the wd disk during a typical transit .
the area of the wd that is covered by the planet atmosphere will then be about @xmath50 , where @xmath51 is the exponential scale height of the planet atmosphere , and @xmath52 is the height above the planet surface at which a line of sight tangent to the planet passes a column of atmosphere equal to one vertical column .
this requirement on @xmath53 can be approximated as @xmath54 a planet s radius @xmath55 depends on the planet mass and composition .
the atmospheric scale height @xmath51 will depend on the gravitational acceleration at the planet s surface @xmath56 , and thus again on the planet s mass and composition , but also on the atmospheric composition and temperature @xmath57 , @xmath58 where @xmath59 is the boltzmann constant , @xmath9 is the mean molecular mass , and @xmath60 is the sound speed .
@xmath57 , in turn , depends on atmospheric composition and distance from the parent star .
thus , planets of differing masses , compositions , and orbits will have different ratios @xmath61 , and hence differing values of @xmath53 that satisfy the transcendental equation ( [ 5hequation ] ) .
nevertheless , for a range of real planet @xmath61 ratios , @xmath53 equals approximately 5 .
we find that for the earth , with @xmath62 km and @xmath63 km , @xmath64 .
for jupiter , with @xmath65 km and @xmath66 km , @xmath67 . for a hot jupiter , with @xmath57 that is 5 times higher than jupiter
s , @xmath68 .
beckwith ( 2008 ) has solved the integral expression for the atmospheric path length giving @xmath53 , and derived @xmath69 for terrestrial parameters .
the unocculted area of the wd will typically be @xmath70 , because for the average transit impact parameter roughly one - half of the wd area will be covered by the planet .
the contrast between the atmospheric signal @xmath71 ( which we define here as the part of the wd light that impinges upon the atmospheric annulus ) and the unocculted background @xmath72 is then , @xmath73 for an earth - like planet transiting a wd .
this is of course a much larger and more favourable contrast ratio then in the case of earths transiting main - sequence stars .
the dominant source of noise involves poisson fluctuations in the number of photons from the unobscured light of the background star , in this case the wd .
the required number of detected signal photons in the transmitted spectrum , for a given @xmath74 , therefore satisfies @xmath75 or @xmath76 signal photons and @xmath77 background photons per spectral resolution element for @xmath78 . in
4 we show that such a @xmath74 in the continuum of the transmitted spectrum is sufficient for detecting clearly the o@xmath2 a - band absorption , which at @xmath49 has a band - center absorption depth of about 50% , and spans several resolution elements .
the half - occulted wd will have about 18 mag , and hence a photon flux of @xmath79 at a wavelength of @xmath80 .
for jwst , 0.88 of the 6.5-m - diameter collecting area is unobstructed , and for the near infrared imaging slitless spectrograph ( niriss ) with the gr700xd grism ( @xmath49 ) the total system throughput at @xmath81 is about 0.15 ( doyon 2012 ) . during a single transit of length of 2 minutes , about 4,200 photons per 10 resolution element will be accumulated . integrating over 160 such 2-minute transits ,
the required @xmath74 for detecting the oxygen bands will be obtained .
this would amount to 5.3 hours of net jwst exposure time ( i.e. excluding telescope overheads ) , albeit spread out over daily or twice - daily visits during several months .
if the exoplanet atmosphere has an o@xmath2 abundance of only a few percent , i.e. 1/10 of the present level , as was on earth at ages @xmath6@xmath82 gyr , the o@xmath2 signature will be undetectable , unless one resorts to jwst exposures which are 100 times longer ( as are being considered for studying planets around m stars ) . on the other hand , the near infrared spectrum will be obtained simultaneously in the full @xmath83 m niriss wavelength range , over which the system throughput is 30 - 40% .
strong signatures of other molecular species in the the planet atmosphere , such as water and co@xmath2 , will be detectable with @xmath84 hr exposure .
naturally , if a suitable habitable - zone earth - mass planet transiting a wd is discovered at the survey stage , it will be straightforward to obtain its atmospheric transmission spectrum with a ground - based 10-m - class telescope , _ if _ the planet atmosphere is significantly different from the terrestrial example . with a collecting area 3 times larger than jwst , the total exposure time would be correspondingly shortened .
the added challenge of variable telluric atmospheric absorption during and out of transit could be addressed by simultaneously observing , through the instrument slit , a neighbouring star of similar brightness . however , if the planet atmosphere is also earth - like , it will be difficult to detect it from the ground , after our own highly variable ( both temporally and spatially ) atmosphere has imprinted on the spectrum the same signature , but @xmath85 times stronger .
indeed , a null ground - based detection of a planetary atmosphere could mean either that there is no planet atmosphere or that there is one but it is similar to earth s , hence requiring a space - based telescope such as jwst .
alternatively , snellen et al . ( 2013 ) have described a program for detecting the atmosphere of an earth twin utilising the next generation of large telescopes and very high spectral resolution , to separate the extraterrestrial and telluric signals by means of the velocity shift of the planet lines . for planets larger than the wd , which will typically occult the wd completely during transit , the probability of a transit of the planet _ atmosphere _ across the wd will be @xmath86 i.e. , similar to the earth - like case
. however , given that the planet temperature will be the same as in the previous earth - size case ( assuming @xmath87 in the habitable zone ) , but the gravity will be larger in proportion to @xmath55 , the scale height @xmath51 will be proportionally smaller .
the area covered by the planet atmosphere will be typically just @xmath88 . for planets larger than the wd , the atmospheric transmission signal will thus decrease linearly with planet radius , while the background emission from the wd will remain unchanged , and hence the required exposure times will increase in proportion to the planet radius . among planets transiting wds ,
earth - like planets are thus optimal for atmospheric transmission studies , since their radius is similar to that of wds .
to demonstrate the feasibility of the proposed observations , we have simulated the jwst transmission spectrum observation of an earth - like planet transiting a wd in the @xmath83 m wavelength range .
the earth s empirical atmospheric absorption spectrum , including the optical o@xmath2 bands at @xmath89 , was taken from wallace et al .
( 2011 ) based on observations of the sun at different air masses . for the wavelength band of @xmath90
m , we use the infrared atmospheric transmission spectra available at the gemini observatory , which were calculated using the atran modeling program ( lord 1992 ) .
specifically , we have used the model calculated for 1.0 air mass at the altitude of mauna kea , with a water vapour column of 1.6 mm .
the amount of water vapour one could expect to observe in transmission in any earth - like planet , let alone in a planet orbiting a wd , is highly uncertain . on the one hand ,
the terrestrial mean water column is 25 mm , i.e. 15 times larger than we have adopted . on the other hand ,
almost all of the terrestrial water vapour is confined within one scale height , i.e. within a projected atmospheric area that is 5 times smaller than we have assumed .
but then , most or all of this water - vapour - rich atmospheric layer could be hidden from view in an exoplanet transmission spectrum by optically thick clouds or haze of water ( e.g. burgasser 2009 ) . the uncertainties associated with the existence and height of clouds as well as the composition and mixing of the atmosphere ,
can lead to a very broad range of possible h@xmath2o absorption strengths in an exoplanet atmosphere ( e.g. fujii et al . 2012 ) .
the 1.6 mm column we have chosen to illustrate the effect is therefore just one of many possible values .
refraction in the planet atmosphere is another factor that could affect the expected signal ( garcia - munoz et al .
2012 ) .
we have rebinned the full @xmath83 m absorption spectrum to the @xmath91 spectral resolution of the niriss gr700xd grism , diluted it with the wd continuum emission ( 170 times brighter ) and added poisson noise according to the total expected photon counts , as described in
this procedure implicitly assumes that the transmission spectrum through a height @xmath52 is representative of the spectrum at all heights , from zero to to @xmath52 above the surface of the planet . in reality , for a tangential path below about 10 km , the earth s atmosphere becomes quite opaque at most wavelengths , due to absorption by ozone bands , in addition to water clouds , aerosols , and rayleigh scattering , and therefore these lowest regions will not contribute to the transmission signal . on the other hand , at intermediate heights ,
the interesting absorbers actually have a larger optical depth , and hence layers at those heights contribute a stronger signal , than those at @xmath52 ( see kaltenegger & traub 2009 ) . in the balance , the above assumption provides a reasonable approximation of the expected spectrum .
figures 1 and 2 show representative spectral regions of the simulated spectrum in the optical band around the o@xmath2 a and b bands and in the infrared region around several h@xmath2o and co@xmath2 features .
the o@xmath2 a - band and the h@xmath2o and co@xmath2 features are all clearly detected in this simulated 5.3 hr integrated exposure .
we have verified that the h@xmath2o band , which is strong and broad , is detectable even with @xmath92 of the exposure time .
we have shown that jwst will be able to detect the o@xmath2 bio - signature in the absorption spectrum of a habitable earth - mass planet as it transits a wd , after a total integration time of about 5 hours .
finding a suitable planetary system requires first assembling a sample of @xmath1 wds with apparent magnitudes of @xmath93 within @xmath94 pc , which is feasible with _ gaia _ , and then monitoring them with small telescopes in order to find the transits .
earth - mass planets in the habitable zones of wds may offer the best prospects for detecting bio - signatures within the coming decade .
we thank mukremin kilic , remko de kok , tsevi mazeh , dimitar sasselov , laura schaefer , ignas snellen , dave spiegel , amiel sternberg , lev tal - or , and the anonymous referee , for useful input .
l. acknowledges support from the sackler professorship by special appointment at tel aviv university , which enabled this collaboration .
d.m acknowledges support by a grant from the us - israel binational science foundation . | the characterization of the atmospheres of habitable - zone earth - mass exoplanets that transit across main - sequence stars , let alone the detection of bio - markers in their atmospheres , will be challenging even with future facilities .
it has been noted that white dwarfs ( wds ) have long - lived habitable zones and that a large fraction of wds may host planets .
we point out that during a transit of an earth - mass planet across a wd , the planet s atmospheric transmission spectrum obtains a much higher contrast over the stellar background compared to a main - sequence host , because of the small surface area of the wd .
the most prominent bio - marker in the present - day terrestrial atmosphere , molecular oxygen , is readily detectable in a wd transit via its a - band absorption at @xmath0 m .
a potentially life - sustaining earth - like planet transiting a wd can be found by assembling a suitable sample of @xmath1 wds and then surveying them for transits using small telescopes . if and when a transiting case is found , the o@xmath2 absorption in the planetary atmospheric transmission spectrum would be detectable with the james webb space telescope ( jwst ) in about 5 hours of total exposure time , integrated over 160 2-minute transits .
characterization of the planet atmosphere using other tracers such as water vapour and co@xmath2 will be considerably easier .
we demonstrate this future discovery space by simulating a possible transmission spectrum that would be obtained with jwst .
[ firstpage ] planets : extrasolar white dwarfs : |
the main goal of the lhc physics program is to unravel the origin of electroweak symmetry breaking , with the leading explanation being the standard model higgs boson . in considering the sm higgs hypothesis , or more generally the correct description of electroweak symmetry breaking ( ewsb ) as realized in nature , it is important to synthesize the experimental results which are determined to date , in terms of symmetries that must be ( at least approximately ) respected in a successful effective description of physics at the weak scale .
probes of the mechanism of electroweak symmetry breaking can be summarized in terms of tests of the properties of the @xmath5 , @xmath6 bosons through electroweak precision data observables ( ewpd ) , probes of the low energy flavour changing signatures of weak scale physics , and direct searches .
the results of the first two of these probes indicate that a viable theory of ewsb can reduce parameter tuning by adopting an approximate @xmath7 custodial symmetry to comply with ewpd @xcite , and imposing approximate minimal flavour violation ( mfv ) @xcite , in order to be robustly consistent with the results of the flavour physics program .
the sm higgs sector with renormalizable couplings to the fermions is exactly consistent with mfv by definition , but it is only approximately @xmath7 symmetric
. recently , atlas and cms have reported significant exclusion limits for a standard model higgs boson over a broad range of masses .
the current exclusion regions reported by atlas @xcite are @xmath8 , @xmath9 and @xmath10 at @xmath11 confidence level ( cl ) . while the higgs mass region excluded by cms @xcite at this cl
is @xmath12 .
there is also a suggestive combination of experimental hints in multiple final state signatures pointing in both experiments to a higgs mass @xmath13 .
although certainly not conclusive , the evidence for a light resonance with this mass scale and approximately sm higgs - like properties has also been augmented by the observation of 7 events ( compared to an expected background of 2 events ) within one @xmath14 of 124 gev in the @xmath15 channel at cms @xcite , which would correspond to a sm higgs boson produced through vector boson fusion . we will use these experimental results in this paper to determine to what degree current data is selecting a sm higgs boson or not .
these experimental hints , along with the lack of any clear evidence of new states discovered to date at the lhc are suggestive that an effective theory of the ewsb sector , including a light scalar resonance and the approximate symmetries of @xmath7 as well as mfv , is currently an appropriate description of the data .
we will examine recent results from the lhc in this framework and ascertain up to what degree experiment is selecting a sm higgs doublet at present .
we perform a broad analysis of this question in sections ii and iii in terms of two parameters characterizing the deviation from the sm value in the gauge and fermion couplings of a higgs boson .
we find two nearly degenerate minima in the global fit .
the effective lagrangian we employ emerges naturally in composite higgs scenarios .
we comment on their interpretation in terms of current data .
the lhc results should be interpreted in the context of the indirect evidence for the sm higgs and its properties in ewpd .
we examine the consistency of the results of our global fit to lhc higgs - like data and ewpd in section iv . finally ,
in section v , we discuss how future measurements can be presented in a manner that can more precisely and efficiently refine the understanding of such an effective theory with the aim of clarifying if the correct description of ewsb is the sm higgs mechanism or not .
in particular we point out the utility of ratios of best fit signal strengths which can be provided by the experimental collaborations and which have the ability to resolve the degeneracy in the two best fit regions we find when examining lhc higgs - like data .
this is due to the fact that , although an individual experimental signal can be faked by a higgs - like degree of freedom , it is difficult for such a degree of freedom to simultaneously reproduce the higgs predictions in other channels with different dependencies on effective couplings .
we consider an effective lagrangian with a light scalar resonance , denoted as @xmath16 in the following , that includes the goldstone bosons associated with the breaking of @xmath17 and the sm field content . a minimal description of these degrees of freedom
is given by an effective chiral lagrangian with a nonlinear realization of the @xmath18 symmetry .
the goldstone bosons eaten by the @xmath19 bosons are denoted by @xmath20 , where @xmath21 , and are grouped as ( x ) = e^i _ a ^a / v , with @xmath22 .
the @xmath23 field transforms linearly under @xmath24 as @xmath25 where @xmath26 indicate the transformation on the left and right under @xmath27 and @xmath28 , respectively , while @xmath7 is the diagonal subgroup of @xmath24 , under which the scalar resonance @xmath16 transforms as a singlet .
a derivative expansion of such a theory is given by @xcite & = & ( _ h)^2 - v(h ) + ( d_^ d^ ) , + & & - ( |u_l^i |d_l^i ) ( c y_ij^u u_r^j + y_ij^d d_r^j ) + h.c . , + v(h ) & = & m_h^2 h^2 + ( ) h^3 + ( ) h^4 + .
[ eq : efflag ] here we have adopted for later convenience the notation of composite models @xcite .
minimal flavour violation dictates that the sole source of flavour violation are the yukawa couplings and that @xmath16 is a singlet in flavour space and that its couplings to fermions ( @xmath29 ) are flavour - universal .
( note that mfv is also compatible with @xmath30 proportional to a combination of the sm yukawa matricies . )
we adopt this assumption , although we note that the lhc data is essentially only sensitive to flavour violation linked to the large top coupling ( scaled by @xmath31 from its sm value ) at present . the @xmath17 subgroup of @xmath24 is weakly gauged in such theories .
we will fit the current data including the leading linear higgs - like coupling effects in the lagrangian of eq .
( [ eq : efflag ] ) .
we will neglect , however , dimension five operators @xmath32 , @xmath33 , @xmath34 and other higher dimension operators in the fit , focusing on the effect of @xmath35 and @xmath31 .
this can be justified by uv model building , for example in the composite higgs case . in general , the coefficients @xmath36 are arbitrary numerical parameters subject to experimental constraints .
model building in the uv of this effective theory fixes relations between the parameters .
the completion of the theory with a sm higgs boson fixes @xmath37 and @xmath38 , and higher order terms in the polynomial expansion of the @xmath16 field vanish . in this case
@xmath16 becomes part of a linear multiplet u = ( 1 + ) , reducing the theory to the sm higgs boson lagrangian where the growth in @xmath39 of the high energy scattering cross section @xmath40 is exactly cancelled .
for other choices of these parameters the growth in @xmath39 of high energy scattering processes is only moderated .
first we will explore to what degree a light scalar resonance leading to the current experimental excesses reported by cms and atlas is consistent with a sm higgs boson interpretation or not .
note that the fermiophobic higgs hypothesis is frequently interpreted to correspond to the singular point where @xmath41 , while a more general interpretation of this hypothesis is @xmath42 with @xmath35 unfixed , but constrained by current data .
the experimental hints for the higgs boson that have been reported to date in each channel individually provide only marginal evidence .
the best fit values to the signal strengths @xmath43 for particular higgs masses are summarized in table i. in table i we also give in the second column the expected mass sensitivity of the various experimental signatures as well as in the third column the best fit value for @xmath44 together with the @xmath45 experimental error and the @xmath11 confidence level limit . if the mass resolution is not explicitly quoted , as in the @xmath46 and the @xmath47 results given by atlas , we display as an estimate the mass sensitivity for these channels as quoted by cms .
since the mass sensitivity is such that the best fit masses can reasonably be interpreted to overlap , we do not introduce a correction factor in the fit to shift to a common mass value .
we also display , in column two , the local significance when given by the experiments . in column four
we schematically list the leading sensitivity of the signal in terms of the cross section rescaling and the effective branching ratios to final states @xmath48 given by @xmath49 $ ] .
the actual production cross section rescalings are combinations including subdominant channels , that can introduce further dependence on ( a , c ) , see section iii.a .
we do not include a look elsewhere effect as we are performing a global fit for a particular mass value @xmath50 gev .
the cms photon measurements are split up in accordance with ref .
the @xmath51 events are classified by the conversion of the photon in the crystal - defining a parameter @xmath52 - and their location in the detector , being endcap - e or barrel - b. the data we fit to also have associated exclusion curves .
we take these exclusions into account by another procedure described in the text .
note that the @xmath53 searches at atlas are included in the exclusion analysis but not fit to in the signal strength best fit as the corresponding experimental error is not available .
the excesses of events with @xmath54 the same mass scale in various channels are suggestive of a resonance , that could be interpreted as evidence of a light higgs boson .
we will assume that these excesses of events correspond to the same underlying physics and fit the data to discern the degree up to which the excesses are consistent with a sm higgs boson interpretation .
our procedure to perform a global fit to the current data is as follows .
we also show joint fits for the higgs mass values @xmath56 where we have taken the experimentally reported @xmath57 and the corresponding theory predictions at a common @xmath58 due to the release of the required data by cms , after version one of this paper .
the data we use is given in table iii for each particular higgs mass value chosen .
these results are shown for various masses in fig .
8 . examining the results
, one clearly sees that the excess at @xmath59 can be distinguished globally to be a likely statistical fluctuation compared to the global fit to the excess of events around @xmath60 . for the three mass values , the best fit points @xmath61 are @xmath62 , @xmath63 and @xmath64 , where for the latter two masses we use the cms di - photon data resolved into subclasses .
fitting to @xmath65 with global di - photon best fit data only , compared to di - photon data split into subclasses , shows that the discrimination on the parameter space offered by separately reporting the vbf induced @xmath66 signal is important .
we also encourage the experimental collaborations to report the degree of contamination of this signal with @xmath67 initial state higgs events to enable a consistent treatment of the reported best fit signal stengths .
one can demonstrate how the vbf signal interpolates between the two results shown in fig . 8 by adding in contamination due to @xmath68 events with our consistent rescaling procedure . one finds the series of plots shown in fig . 9 for various degrees of contamination .
note that cms also reports @xmath69 events which offer a similar discrimination of the parameter space as the @xmath66 signal in principle .
however , again contamination due to @xmath68 events will exist and is not reported by the collaborations .
we do not use this data as a separate channel at present .
the update to the data has a small effect on the @xmath70 of the sm higgs hypothesis compared to the best fit value of the current data . assuming no contamination due to gg for vbf events one finds that our previously reported global fit with the moriond 2012 data update ( but without correcting to a single higgs mass value in the experimental best fit signal strengths ) has the sm hypothesis residing on a @xmath71 curve around the best fit value of @xmath72 . assuming a @xmath73 contamination of the vbf events due to gg , the sm hypothesis remains consistent with the data at @xmath74 compared to the best fit value . for a direct comparison ,
the fermiophobic scenario with @xmath75 is consistent with the data at @xmath76 for the same global fit .
when a @xmath77 contamination due to gg events for the vbf diphoton signal of cms is assumed , the same fermiophobic scenario is consistent with the data at the @xmath78 .
we do not consider a fermiophobic scenario to be favoured by the global data or the pattern of deviations from the sm in the current data set .
with such marginal signal events , statistical fluctuations in the data are still present affecting the pattern of deviations .
finally , the 95% cl exclusion curves from atlas and cms in the plots of this appendix have been determined using a more precise method than eq .
( [ applim ] ) . in the same spirit of ref .
@xcite , for each individual search channel @xmath79 , we have first approximated the corresponding probability density function of the signal strength parameter @xmath44 by a gaussian @xmath80 $ ] .
we have obtained the quantities @xmath81 and @xmath82 trying to get the best approximation to the reported 95% cl in that channel , @xmath83 ( obtained from the equation @xmath84 ) . in the case of cms channels
, we use the approximation of ref .
@xcite ( which uses @xmath85 and obtains @xmath86 by solving the equation that determines @xmath83 ) . in the case of atlas data ,
we find better agreement with the reported limits by directly using @xmath87 and @xmath82 as provided channel , where we find a discrepancy between the limit derived from @xmath88 and @xmath82 and the reported limit .
we therefore do not use this channel to extract the combined limit in the @xmath72 plane .
although this is a subdominant channel , the impact of such discrepancy on the sm exclusion around @xmath89 gev is not negligible . in the case of the @xmath90 channel , for some ranges of higgs masses
the reported ( negative ) value of @xmath91 is hitting a boundary and we could not use it to reproduce well the experimental limit . in these cases
we use the same approximation as for the cms channels . ] . to illustrate the precision of our approximations to the exclusion limits we compare them with the official 95% cl limit on @xmath92 in fig .
[ fig : limitscomp ] . in the left ( right )
panel we show the cms ( atlas ) limit , with the official curve in black .
the red curve is the simple approximation of eq .
( @xmath93 ) and the green curves are more precise determinations of the limit as explained above .
the dashed green line corresponds to an approximate determination of @xmath94 and @xmath82 as in ref .
the solid green line ( only shown for atlas ) uses @xmath95 and @xmath82 as provided . for cms ( left ) and
atlas ( right ) .
the official curve is the black solid line .
the red curve is obtained from the simple approximation of eqn.([applim ] ) .
the green curves are more precise determinations of the limit as explained in the text.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=49.0% ] for cms ( left ) and atlas ( right ) .
the official curve is the black solid line .
the red curve is obtained from the simple approximation of eqn.([applim ] ) .
the green curves are more precise determinations of the limit as explained in the text.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=49.0% ] as the draft of this work was being finalized two analyses with overlap to some of the work presented here appeared @xcite .
we thank ricardo gonalo , aurelio juste , michael spira , wade fisher , joey huston , vivek sharma and josh bendavid for helpful communication on related theory and data . this work has been partly supported by the european commission under the contract erc advanced grant 226371 masstev , the contract pitn - ga-2009 - 237920 unilhc , and the contract mrtn - ct-2006 - 035863 forcesuniverse , as well as by the spanish consolider ingenio 2010 programme cpan ( csd2007 - 00042 ) and the spanish ministry micnn under contract fpa2010 - 17747 and fpa2008 - 01430 .
mm is supported by the dfg sfb / tr9 computational particle physics .
99 l. susskind , phys .
d * 20 * ( 1979 ) 2619 .
s. weinberg , phys .
d * 19 * ( 1979 ) 1277 .
p. sikivie , l. susskind , m. b. voloshin and v. i. zakharov , nucl .
b * 173 * ( 1980 ) 189 .
r. s. chivukula and h. georgi , phys .
b * 188 * ( 1987 ) 99 .
g. dambrosio , g. f. giudice , g. isidori and a. strumia , nucl .
b * 645 * ( 2002 ) 155 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0207036 ] .
a. j. buras , acta phys .
b * 34 * , 5615 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0310208 ] . v. cirigliano , b. grinstein , g. isidori and m. b. wise , nucl .
b * 728 * ( 2005 ) 121 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0507001 ] .
the atlas collaboration , arxiv:1202.1408 [ hep - ex ] .
the cms collaboration , arxiv:1202.1488 [ hep - ex ] .
the cms collaboration , arxiv:1202.1487 [ hep - ex ] .
g. f. giudice , c. grojean , a. pomarol and r. rattazzi , jhep * 0706 * , 045 ( 2007 ) [ hep - ph/0703164 ] .
r. contino , c. grojean , m. moretti , f. piccinini and r. rattazzi , jhep * 1005 * , 089 ( 2010 ) arxiv:1002.1011 .
r. grober and m. muhlleitner , jhep * 1106 * , 020 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1012.1562 [ hep - ph ] ] .
a. v. manohar and m. b. wise , phys .
b * 636 * ( 2006 ) 107 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0601212 ] .
c. p. burgess , j. matias and m. pospelov , int .
j. mod .
a * 17 * , 1841 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/9912459 ] .
v. barger , h. e. logan and g. shaughnessy , phys .
d * 79 * , 115018 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0902.0170 [ hep - ph ] ] .
r. lafaye , t. plehn , m. rauch , d. zerwas and m. duhrssen , jhep * 0908 * , 009 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0904.3866 ] . s. bock , r. lafaye , t. plehn , m. rauch , d. zerwas and p. m. zerwas , phys .
b * 694 * , 44 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1007.2645 ] .
b. grinstein and m. trott , phys .
d * 76 * , 073002 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv:0704.1505 ] .
w. d. goldberger , b. grinstein and w. skiba , phys .
lett . * 100 * , 111802 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0708.1463 ] .
f. bonnet , m. b. gavela , t. ota and w. winter , arxiv:1105.5140 [ hep - ph ] . c. englert , t. plehn , m. rauch , d. zerwas and p. m. zerwas , phys .
b * 707 * , 512 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1112.3007 [ hep - ph ] ] .
m. duhrssen , s. heinemeyer , h. logan , d. rainwater , g. weiglein and d. zeppenfeld , phys .
d * 70 * , 113009 ( 2004 ) [ hep - ph/0406323 ] .
b. a. campbell , j. ellis and k. a. olive , arxiv:1111.4495 [ hep - ph ] .
the cms collaboration , arxiv:1202.1489 [ hep - ex ] .
s. dittmaier _ et al . _
[ lhc higgs cross section working group collaboration ] , arxiv:1101.0593 .
k. agashe , r. contino and a. pomarol , nucl .
b * 719 * , 165 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0412089 ] .
r. contino , l. da rold and a. pomarol , phys .
d * 75 * , 055014 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0612048 ] .
b. holdom and j. terning , phys .
b * 247 * ( 1990 ) 88 .
m. e. peskin and t. takeuchi , phys .
* 65 * ( 1990 ) 964 .
m. golden and l. randall , nucl .
b * 361 * ( 1991 ) 3 .
m. e. peskin and t. takeuchi , phys .
d * 46 * ( 1992 ) 381 . | we outline a method for characterizing deviations from the properties of a standard model ( sm ) higgs boson .
we apply it to current data in order to characterize up to which degree the sm higgs boson interpretation is consistent with experiment .
we find that the sm higgs boson is consistent with the current data set at the @xmath0 confidence level , based on data of excess events reported by cms and atlas , which are interpreted to be related to the mass scale @xmath1 , and on published @xmath2 exclusion regions .
we perform a global fit in terms of two parameters characterizing the deviation from the sm value in the gauge and fermion couplings of a higgs boson .
we find two minima in the global fit and identify observables that can remove this degeneracy .
an update for moriond 2012 data is included in the appendix , which finds that the sm higgs boson is now consistent with the current data set at only the @xmath3 confidence level ( which corresponds to @xmath4 tension compared to the best fit point ) . |
collective behaviour of interacting _ intelligent _ agents such as birds , insects or fishes shows highly non - trivial properties and sometimes it seems to be quite counter - intuitive @xcite . as well - known , many - body systems having a lot of _ non - intelligent _ elements , for instance , spins ( tiny magnets in atomic scale length ) , particles , random - walkers etc .
also show a collective behaviour like a critical phenomenon of order - disorder phase transitions with ` spontaneous symmetry breaking ' in spatial structures of the system .
up to now , a huge number of numerical studies in order to figure it out have been done by theoretical physicists and mathematicians @xcite .
they attempted to describe these phenomena by using some probabilistic models and revealed the ` universality class ' of the critical phenomena by solving the problem with the assistance of computer simulations .
of course , the validity of the studies should be checked by comparing the numerical results with the experimental findings . if their results disagree with the empirical data ,
the models they used should be thrown away or should be modified appropriately .
on the other hand , for the mathematical modeling of many - body systems having interacting _ intelligent _ agents ( animals ) , we also use some probabilistic models , however , it is very difficult for us to evaluate the modeling and also very hard to judge whether it looks like _ realistic _ or not due to a lack of enough empirical data to be compared .
one of the key factors for such non - trivial collective behaviour of both _ non - intelligent _ and _ intelligent _ agents is obviously a ` competition ' between several different ( and for most of the cases , these are incompatible ) effects .
for instance , the ising model as an example of collective behaviour of _ non - intelingent _ agents exhibits an order - disorder phase transition @xcite by competition between the ferromagnetic interactions between ising spins ( ` energy minimization ' ) and thermal fluctuation ( ` entropy maximization ' ) by controlling the temperature of the system . on the other hand , as a simplest and effective algorithm in computer simulations for flocks of _ intellingent _ agents , say , animals such as starlings , the so - called boids founded by reynolds @xcite has been widely used not only in the field of computer graphics but also in various other research fields including ethology , physics , control theory , economics , and so on . the boids simulates the collective behaviour of animal flocks by taking into account only a few simple rules for each interacting _ intelligent _ agent . however , there are few studies to compare the results of the boids simulations with the empirical data .
therefore , the following essential and interesting queries still have been left unsolved ; * what is a criterion to determine to what extent the flocks seem to be _ realistic _ ? * is there any quantity ( statistics ) to measure the _ quality _ of the artificial flocks ? from the view point of ` engineering ' , the above queries are ( in some sense ) not essential because their main goal is to construct a useful algorithm based on the collective behaviour of agents .
however , from the natural science view points , the difference between empirical evidence and the result of the simulation is the most important issue and the consistency is a guide to judge the validity of the computer modeling and simulation .
recently , ballerini _ at al _
@xcite succeeded in obtaining the data for such collective animal behaviour , namely , empirical data of starling flocks containing up to a few thousands members .
they also pointed out that the angular density of the nearest neighbors in the flocks is not uniform but apparently biased ( it is weaken ) along the direction of the flock s motion . with their empirical findings in mind , in this paper , we examine the possibility of the boids simulations to reproduce this _ anisotropy _ and we also investigate numerically the condition on which the anisotropy emerges . this paper is organized as follows . in the next section ,
we explain the empirical findings by ballerini _
et al _ @xcite and introduce a key concept _ anisotropy _ and a relevant quantity @xmath0-value . in section 3 , the boids modeling and setting of essential parameters in our simulations are explicitly explained .
the results are reported in section 4 .
the last section provides concluding remarks .
in this section , we briefly review the measurement of the realistic flocks and the evaluation of the empirical data by ballerini _ et al _ @xcite .
they measured each bird s position in the flocks of starling ( _ sturnus vulgaris _ ) in three dimension . to get such 3d data , they used ` stereo matching ' which reconstructs 3d - object from a set of stereo photographs . from these data
, they calculated the angular density of the nearest neighbours in the flock .
they measured the angles ( @xmath1 , @xmath2 ) , where @xmath1 stands for the ` latitude ' of the nearest neighbour for each bird measured from the direction of the motion of the flock , whereas @xmath2 denotes ` longitude ' which specifies the position of the nearest neighbour for each bird around the direction of flock s motion , for all individuals in the flock and made the 2d - map of angular density distribution using the so - called ` mollweide projection ' .
their figure clealy shows that the density is not uniform but obviously biased .
for instance , we find from the figure that the dinsity around @xmath3 and @xmath4 are extremely low in comparison with the density in the other directions .
the property of the biased distribution due to the absence of the birds along the direction of the flock s motion is referred to as _ anisotropy _
the main goal of this paper is to reveal numerically that the artificial flock by the boids exhibits the anisotropy as the realistic flock shows @xcite . to quantify the degree of the anisotropy
, we use a useful statistics ( a kind of ` order parameters ' in the research field of statistical mechanics ) introduced in the following subsections .
ballerini _ et al _ also introduced a useful indicator , what we call @xmath0-value .
the @xmath0-value is calculated according to the following recipe .
let @xmath5 be an unit vector pointing in the direction of the @xmath6 -nearest neighbour of the bird @xmath7 and let us define the projection matrix @xmath8 in terms of the @xmath5 as follows .
@xmath9 where @xmath10 is the number of birds in the flock .
then , the @xmath0-value is given by @xmath11 where @xmath12 denotes the normalized eigenvector corresponding to the smallest eigenvalue of the projection matrix @xmath8 . from the definition ,
the @xmath12 coincides with the direction of the lowest density in the flock .
the vector @xmath13 appearing in the equation ( [ eq : def_gamma ] ) means the unit vector of flock s motion .
the bracket @xmath14 means the average over the ensembles of the flocks .
the @xmath0-value for the uniform distribution of the position @xmath15 for a given vector @xmath13 , namely , the @xmath0 for @xmath16 is easily calculated as @xmath17 where we used @xmath18 .
therefore , the distribution of the @xmath6-nearest neighbours has anisotropic structure when the @xmath0-value is larger than @xmath19 , namely the condition for the emergence of the anisotropy is explicitly written by @xmath20 by measuring this @xmath0-value for artificial flock simulations , one can show that the anisotropy also emerges in computer simulations . to put it into other words ,
the system of flocks is spatially ` symmetric ' for @xmath21 , whereas the symmetry is ` spontaneously ' broken for @xmath22 .
this ` spontaneous symmetry breaking ' is nothing but the emergence of anisotropy . in the following sections , we carry out the boids simulations and evaluate the anisotropy by the @xmath0-value .
then , we find that the ` spontaneous symmetry breaking ' mentioned above actually takes place by controlling the essential parameters appearing in the boids .
to make flock simulations in computer , we use the so - called boids which was originally designed by reynolds @xcite .
the boids is one of the well - known mathematical ( probabilistic ) models in the research fields of cg and animation .
actually , the boids can simulate very complicated animal flocks or schools although it consists of just only three simple interactions for each agent in the aggregation : 1 . * cohesion * : making a vector of each agent s position toward the average position of local flock mates .
* alignment * : making a vector of each agent s position towards the average heading of local flock mates and keeping the velocity of each agent the average value of flock mates .
* separation * : controlling the vector of each agent to avoid the collision with the other local flock mates .
it is important for us to bear in mind that ` local flock mates ' mentioned above denotes the neighbours within the range of views for each agent .
each agent decides her ( or his ) next migration by compounding these three interactions . in our boids simulations ,
each agent is defined as a mass point and specified by a set of 3d - coordinate @xmath23 , an unit vector of motion , and the speed .
we define each agent s view as a sphere with a radius @xmath24 without any blind corner .
we also define the ` separation sphere ' with a radius @xmath25 and the distance between the nearest neighbours is specified by the length @xmath26 ( see figure [ fig : range ] ) .
the interaction of ` separation ' is switched on if and only if the @xmath26 is smaller than the @xmath27 .
some other essential parameters appearing in our boids simulations and the setup are also explicitly given as follows .
* * field of simulations : * three dimensional open space without any gravity or any air resistance .
moreover , there is no wall and no ground surface . * * the number of agents in the flock : * the system size of simulations is @xmath28 * * initial condition on the speed of each agent : * @xmath29 . *
* initial condition on the location of each agent : * all agents are distributed in a sphere with radius @xmath30 . *
* the shape and the range of each agent s view : * a sphere with radius @xmath31 . * * the shape and the range of separation : * a sphere with radius @xmath32 . for the above setting of the parameters
, we shall implement two types of programming codes .
one is a programing code for a single simulation ( ` ss ' for short ) , and another code is for multiple simulations ( ` ms ' for short ) .
the ss runs in the gui ( graphical user interface ) and it shows us a shape of the flock in real time , whereas the ms enables us to carry out a number of simulations with different initial conditions . by controling the three essential interactions , namely , ` cohesion ' , ` alignment ' and ` separation ' mentioned above , we obtain four different aggregations having different collective behaviours .
each behavour of the aggregations is monitored ( observed ) by the ss . to specify the aggregation process of the flocks ,
we define the update rule of the vector of movement for each agent by @xmath33 where @xmath34 means the time step of the update and @xmath35 denotes the @xmath36-norm of a vector @xmath37 .
@xmath38 is a vector pointing to the center of mass from each agent s position .
@xmath39 denotes a vector to be obtained by averaging over the velocities of all agents .
@xmath40 means a vector pointing to the direction of the movement of each agent to be separated from her ( or his ) nearest neighbouring mate .
therefore , the aggregation of the flock is completely specified by the weights of the above vectors , namely , @xmath41 . among all possible combinations of these weights
, we shall pick up typical four cases .
each property and the shape of each aggregation are explained as follows . * _ case 1 _ ( * crowded aggregation ) * : the aggregation obtained by controlling the interaction of ` cohesion ' much stronger than the others , namely , @xmath42 . * _ case 2 _ ( * spread aggregation ) * : the aggregation obtained by controlling the interaction of ` separation ' much stronger than the others , namely , @xmath43 . * _ case 3 _ ( * synchronized aggregation ) * : the aggregation obtained by controlling the interaction of ` alignment ' much stronger than the others , namely , @xmath44 . * _ case 4 _ ( * flock aggregation ) * : this aggregation obtained by adjusting every interactions appropriately , namely , @xmath45 . using the ms , we simulate each aggregation for @xmath46 times for different initial conditions . in each simulation , we measure the angular distribution and then the value of @xmath0 is calculated .
the number of crash is also updated when the coordinate of each agent is identical to ( is shared with ) the other agents .
we start each measurement from the time point at which the total amount of the change in every agent s speed is close to @xmath47 through the 80 turns of the update . in the next section ,
we explain the details of the result .
in association with the each aggregation , we evaluate the @xmath0-value with standard deviation and the average number of crashes for 200 independent runs of the boids simulations . in following ,
we summarize the results . * _ case 1 _ ( * crowded aggregation ) * : the typical behaviour of the flock and the angular distribution are shown in the upper left panel in figure [ fig : fg3 ] and figure [ fig : fg4 ] , respectively .
the @xmath0-value is @xmath48 with standard deviation @xmath49 and the average number of crashes is @xmath50 . * _ case 2 _ ( * spread aggregation ) * : the typical behaviour of the flock and the angular distribution are shown in the upper right panel in figure [ fig : fg3 ] and figure [ fig : fg4 ] , respectively . the @xmath0-value is @xmath51 with standard deviation @xmath52 and the average number of crashes is @xmath47 . *
_ case 3 _ ( * synchronized aggregation ) * : the typical behaviour of the flock and the angular distribution are shown in the lower left panel in figure [ fig : fg3 ] and figure [ fig : fg4 ] , respectively .
the @xmath0-value is @xmath53 with standard deviation @xmath54 and the average number of crashes is @xmath47 . *
_ case 4 _ ( * flock aggregation ) * : the typical behaviour of the flock and the angular distribution are shown in the lower right panel in figure [ fig : fg3 ] and figure [ fig : fg4 ] , respectively . the @xmath0-value is @xmath55 with standard deviation @xmath56 and the average number of crashes is @xmath47 . - and @xmath57-planes ) are shown .
, title="fig:",width=264 ] - and @xmath57-planes ) are shown .
, title="fig:",width=264 ] - and @xmath57-planes ) are shown .
, title="fig:",width=264 ] - and @xmath57-planes ) are shown .
, title="fig:",width=264 ] the aggregation of _ case 4 _ ( ` flock aggregation ' ) has the highest @xmath0-value among the four cases and its angular density clearly shows a lack of nearest neighbours along the direction of flock s motion leading to an anisotropy . for all aggregations except for the _ case 4 _ ,
the @xmath0-values are lower than @xmath58 , namely , they have no anisotropy . from these results
, we find that boids computer simulations having appropriate weights @xmath59 shows anisotropy structures as real flocks exhibit .
it is also revealed that one can evaluate to what extent an arbitrary flock simulation is close to real flocks through the @xmath0-value . from the results obtained here , we might have another question , namely , it is important for us to answer the question such as whether the aggregation having a higher @xmath0-value than the _ case 4 _ seems to be more _ realistic _ than the _ case 4 _ or not . to answer the question ,
we carry out the simulations of the flock aggregation which has a higher @xmath0-value ( _ case 5 _ ) than the _ case 4_. the results are summarized as follows . * _ case 5 _ ( * crowded aggregation ) * : the angular distribution is shown in figure [ fig : fg5 ] . the @xmath0-value is @xmath60 with standard deviation @xmath61 and the average number of crashes is @xmath62 .
-value than the _ case 4_. , width=283 ] obviously , the above aggregation has the highest @xmath0-value leading to the strongest anisotropy among the five cases .
however , it is hard for us to say that it is an _
optimal flock _ because the number of cashes is also the highest ( @xmath63 times ) and to make matter worse , the number itself is apparently outstanding .
this result tells us that an aggregation having much stronger anisotropic structures is not always a better flock .
the above result is reasonably accepted because the @xmath0-value is calculated from the angular distribution of nearest neighbours without any concept of the _ distance _ between agents .
therefore , the flock having a dense network might have highly risks of crashes more than the sparse network . for this reason , in order to judge whether a given aggregation has a better flock behaviour or not , we should use the other criteria which take into account the distance between nearest neighbours . inspired by the empirical data analysis by ballerini _
et al _ @xcite , we finally calculate the @xmath0-value as a function of the order of the neighbour . the result is shown in figure [ fig : fg6 ] .
-value as a function of the neighbour @xmath64 in the real flock .
, width=302 ] in this figure , @xmath64 denotes the order of the neighbour , for instance , @xmath65 or @xmath66 means the nearest neighbour , the next nearest neighbour , respectively .
the figure shows a similar behaviour to the corresponding plot in the reference @xcite , that is , the @xmath0-values monotonically decrease as @xmath64 increases and they converge to @xmath67 beyond @xmath68 . this result might be a justification to conclude that our boids simulations having appropriate weight vectors @xmath59 actually simulate a _ realistic _ flock .
in this paper , we showed that the anisotropy observed in the empirical data analysis @xcite also emerges in our boids simulations having appropriate weight vectors @xmath59 . from the @xmath0-value we calculated
, one can judge wheter an optional aggregation behaves like a _ real flock _ or not .
the system of flocks is spatially ` symmetric ' for @xmath69 , whereas the symmetry is ` spontaneously ' broken for @xmath22 .
we found from the behaviour of ` order parameter ' @xmath0 that this ` spontaneous symmetry breaking ' is nothing but the emergence of anisotropy . as well - known , there are some conjectures on the origin of the emergence of anisotropy .
for instance , the effect of bird s vision is one of the dominant hypotheses .
in fact , real starlings have lateral visual axes and each of the starlings has a blind rear sector @xcite .
if all individuals in the flock move to avoid their nearest neighbours which are hidden in their blind sectors , the effect of the blind sector is more likely to be a factor to emerge the anisotropy of nearest neighbours in the front - rear directions .
however , our result proved that this hypothesis is _ not always correct _ because agents in our simulation have no blind sector of their views .
nevertheless , we found that our flock aggregation has an anisotropy of the nearest neighbours .
the result means that the agent s blind as an effect of vision is _ not necessarily required _ to produce the anisotropy and much more essential factor for the anisotropy is _ the best possible combinations of three essential interactions _ in the boids .
+ we hope that these results might help us to consider the relevant link between boids simulations and empirical evidence from real world .
we were financially supported by grant - in - aid scientific research on priority areas _ ` deepening and expansion of statistical mechanical informatics ( dex - smi ) ' _ of the mext no .
one of the authors ( ji ) was financially supported by insa ( indian national science academy ) - jsps ( japan society of promotion of science ) bilateral exchange programme .
he also thanks saha institute of nuclear physics for their warm hospitality during his stay in india .
m. ballerini , n. cabibbo , r. candelier , a. cavagna , e. cisbani , i. giardina , v. lecomte , a. orlandi , g. parisi , a. procaccini , m. viale and v. zdravkovic , _ interaction rulling animal collective behaviour depends on topological raher than metric distance , evidence from a field study _ , _ proceedings of the national academy of sciences usa _ * 105 * , pp.1232 - 1237 ( 2008 )
. a. cavagna , i. giardina , a. orlandi , g. parisi , a. procaccini , m. viale and v. zdravkovic , _ the starflag handbook on collective animal behaviour : part ii , empirical methods _ , _ animal behaviour _ * 76 * ,
issue 1 , pp237 - 248 ( 2008 ) . | in real flocks , it was revealed that the angular density of nearest neighbors shows a strong _ anisotropic structure _ of individuals by very recent extensive field studies by ballerini et al [ _ proceedings of the national academy of sciences usa _ * 105 * , pp.1232 - 1237 ( 2008 ) ] . in this paper , we show that this empirical evidence in real flocks , namely , the structure of anisotropy also emerges in an artificial flock simulation based on the _ boids _ by reynolds [ _ computer graphics _ * 21 * , pp.25 - 34 ( 1987 ) ] .
we numerically find that appropriate combinations of the weights for just only three essential factors of the boids , namely , ` cohesion ' , ` alignment ' and ` separation ' lead to a strong anisotropy in the flock .
this result seems to be highly counter - intuitive and also provides a justification of the hypothesis that the anisotropy emerges as a result of self - organization of interacting intelligent agents ( birds for instance ) . to quantify the anisotropy
, we evaluate a useful statistics ( a kind of _ order parameters _ in statistical physics ) , that is to say , the so - called @xmath0-value defined as an inner product between the vector in the direction of the lowest angular density of flocks and the vector in the direction of the moving of the flock .
our results concerning the emergence of the anisotropy through the @xmath0-value might enable us to judge whether an arbitrary flock simulation seems to be _
realistic _ or not .
+ * keywords * : self - organization , anisotropy , boids , swarm intelligence simulation , collective behaviour + |
prime numbers have attracted mathematically oriented minds .
they are fountains of the interesting problems which are left unresolved to the present . as well as prime numbers , natural numbers themselves sometimes show unexpected behaviors in spite of their simple appeal . in this note
, we would like to present a simple property arising from the combination of two unsolved problems in number theory ; the mersenne prime numbers and the collatz - kakutani conjecture .
namely , we show that there exists an approximate linear relation between an index of the mersenne prime and its collatz - kakutani path length , both of which are defined in the next section .
let us start with a brief descriptions of the mersenne primes and the collatz - kakutani conjecture@xcite .
a mersenne number is a positive integer given by @xmath0 where @xmath1 is a positive integer , called `` index '' .
a mersenne prime is a mersenne number that is prime .
it has been shown that if @xmath2 is a mersenne prime , @xmath1 must be prime . however , the converse is not true .
in fact , only forty - seven mersenne primes have been found up to date with the largest one given when @xmath3 .
this is also the largest known prime number .
there are many fundamental questions left unresolved such as whether there are infinitely many mersenne primes .
the behaviors of mersenne primes are irregular and unpredictable as seen in other types of prime numbers .
therefore , the recent discoveries of the mersenne primes were achieved with the help of massively distributed computers , and the effort for finding new mersenne primes has been made continuously @xcite .
the mersenne primes are known for their relationships with the perfect numbers , and they are also applied to create pseudorandom number generators @xcite .
the collatz - kakutani conjecture is also one of the unsolved problems in number theory .
this conjecture is a halting problem that the following operations will stop for an arbitrary positive number .
consider a positive integer @xmath4 .
if @xmath4 is odd , @xmath5 is the next integer .
if @xmath4 is even , @xmath6 is the next integer .
if we repeat this process , it will eventually reach the halting state @xmath7 for all positive integers .
for example , if we start from @xmath8 , we have a sequence as @xmath9 this process can be visualized as the collatz - kakutani tree as shown in fig . 1a .
the conjecture states that this tree covers all the positive integers .
even though this conjecture is unsolved , it is generally believed as true from arguments through probability theories and through computational verifications .
let us introduce the `` collatz - kakutani path length '' @xmath10 for a number of steps for @xmath4 to reach @xmath7 through the above operations , i.e. , a number of operational steps needed to reach @xmath11 ( `` the root '' ) on the collatz - kakutani tree .
for example , @xmath12 .
the relationship between @xmath4 and @xmath10 is highly irregular and no simple law for the path length is found if the collatz - kakutani conjecture is false ] . as a result ,
the plot of @xmath10 versus @xmath4 produces a irregular graph as shown in fig .
while the general relationship between @xmath4 and @xmath10 is unknown , there are some trivial relations such as @xmath13 .
note that , the number @xmath14 is just one larger than the mersenne number @xmath15 . on the collatz - kakutani tree to the root of tree @xmath7 for integers up to x=2000 . ]
our main finding to report is the fact that a path length of a mersenne prime is approximately proportional to its index for large n , namely , @xmath16 this is shown in fig . 2 , which we computed up to the largest known 47th mersenne prime , @xmath17 .
the behavior of the path length @xmath18 is non
monotonic for small indices , e.g. , @xmath19 .
we expect , however , beyond @xmath20 , the path length increases monotonically with @xmath1 for the mersenne primes .
also , there seems no regular path to reach the root of the tree , @xmath7 .
for example , we have examined the path for two nearby mersenne primes , @xmath21 and @xmath22 .
while they both have the path length @xmath18 of approximately @xmath23 , they share the last 16 steps , namely , @xmath24 and @xmath11 . the relations between indices of the mersenne primes and their path lengths are summarized in table [ tbl_pathlength ] . .
path lengths of the mersenne primes . [ cols= " <
, < , < , < " , ] ( top ) and @xmath25 ( bottom ) versus @xmath1 .
the mersenne primes are marked by arrows , and horizontal line is at @xmath26 .
a. prime indices near @xmath27 ( @xmath28 , b. every fifth prime indices near @xmath29 ( @xmath30 ) , c. every fifth prime indices near @xmath31 ( @xmath32 . ]
the nature and mechanism of these properties appeared in figure 4 need to be studied further .
we , nevertheless , conjecture that these qualitative behavior will continue to larger mersenne numbers , and the mersenne prime appears with its @xmath33 .
unfortunately , again , this is clearly not sufficient to select out the mersenne primes .
if this conjecture is true , however , we can heuristically rule out points that are further away from the horizontal line of @xmath33 from candidates of the mersenne primes .
we have used the collatz - kakutani tree as a provider of `` length '' for natural numbers , and obtained a conjecture for the mersenne primes .
this may be yet another example where prime numbers can give rise to an emergence of unexpected order , such as ulam spiral @xcite .
though the reason behind such simple behavior is left unclear , this approach of using the collatz - kakutani tree can be extended to other types of set of numbers known for irregularities , possibly leading to interesting insights@xcite .
authors would like to thank dr .
masaru suzuki , dr . atsushi kamimura , and shigenori matsumoto for useful discussions .
t.o . would like to thank emeritus prof .
yuji ito of keio university , for his account on his advisor , late prof .
shizuo kakutani of yale university .
m. l. stein , s. m. ulam , m. b. wells , a visual display of some properties of the distribution of primes , _ amer .
math . monthly _ * 71 * ( 1964 ) 516 m. l. stein , s. m. ulam , an observation on the distribution of primes , _ amer .
monthly _ * 74 * ( 1967 ) 43 . after the initial submission to the arxive
, we are pointed to the following work by the author .
j. sinyor , the @xmath34 problem as a string rewriting system , _ int .
j. of math . and math
. science _
* 2010 * ( 2010 ) 458563 | we present here a new conjecture for the nature of the mersenne prime numbers by connecting it with the collatz - kakutani problem . by introducing a natural _ path length _ on the basis of the collatz - kakutani tree ,
we conjecture that this path length of a mersenne prime from the root of the collatz - kakutani tree is approximately proportional to the index of the mersenne prime .
we also discuss difference of behaviors between mersenne numbers and mersenne primes . |
the simplest model of strongly interacting bosons is the bose - hubbard model ( bhm ) , which has been used to describe superfluid helium@xcite , cooper pairs in thin granular superconducting films@xcite and josephson junction arrays@xcite .
much theoretical work has concentrated on the phase diagram of the bhm in zero magnetic field@xcite because of the technical problems associated with introducing an external magnetic field ( such as the sign problem in quantum monte carlo simulations ) .
experimentalists on the other hand have concentrated on studying systems in an external magnetic field because the phase transition can be tuned by adjusting the magnetic field rather than changing the samples measured@xcite .
we study the bhm on two - dimensional lattices in a perpendicular magnetic field by extending the strong - coupling perturbation theory for the field - free case@xcite .
this theoretical technique can incorporate magnetic - field dependence in a straightforward manner and is useful in studying field - tuned transitions .
we concentrate on pure systems in this contribution and do not include any effects due to disorder
. we present zero - temperature phase diagrams , study excitation - gap energies , calculate the dynamical critical exponent @xmath0 for small fields , and compare our theoretical results with experimental ones .
the bhm contains the key physics of a many - particle bosonic system with competing potential and kinetic energy effects .
the typical zero - temperature phase diagram for the non - magnetic case shows incompressible mott - insulating ( mi ) phases surrounded by compressible superfluid phases ( sf ) @xcite .
the insulator to superfluid transitions at the tip of the lobes ( where the density remains constant ) are driven by quantum phase fluctuations , while those at the sides of the lobes ( where the density varies ) are driven by density fluctuations , i.e. particle or hole excitations . introducing a magnetic field
is expected to increase the region of the mi phase because the localizing effect on the itinerant bosons reduces the stability of the sf phase .
we consider bosons with total spin @xmath1 .
the only effect of a perpendicular magnetic field @xmath2 is then on the orbital motion of the bosons , which effects changes in the phase of the hopping - matrix @xmath3 between lattice sites @xmath4 and @xmath5 . by choosing a landau - gauge for the vector - potential @xmath6 ,
the bose - hubbard hamiltonian in an external magnetic field becomes @xmath7 where the hopping matrix is nonzero only between nearest neighbors and is given by @xmath8 this hopping matrix is hermitian because @xmath9 is real and @xmath10 . here
the boson creation operator for lattice site @xmath4 is @xmath11 , @xmath12 is the corresponding number operator , @xmath13 is the on - site repulsion of the bosons , and @xmath14 is the chemical potential .
we choose @xmath13 to be our energy scale and measure all energies in units of @xmath13 .
the magnetic flux quantum is given by @xmath15 , and the magnetic flux per plaquette @xmath16 is a measure of the strength of the magnetic field @xmath2 ( where @xmath17 is the lattice spacing ) .
the form of the zero - temperature phase diagram can be understood by starting from the atomic limit@xcite , where the hopping @xmath9 is zero and every site is occupied by a fixed number of bosons @xmath18 .
the energy to add one boson onto a site with @xmath18 bosons is @xmath19 , so that there is a finite energy gap when @xmath20 and the system is an incompressible mott insulator .
when @xmath21 , then all states with a density between @xmath18 and @xmath22 bosons per site are degenerate in energy , and the system becomes a compressible fluid . as the strength of the hopping matrix elements increases , the range of the chemical potential about which the system is incompressible decreases .
the mott insulator phase disappears at a critical value of the hopping matrix elements ( which depends on the strength of the magnetic field and the density of the insulating phase ) and the system becomes a superfluid ( see fig.[phasesqtri ] ) .
we provide a systematic study of the bhm in a magnetic field by examining the system in a perturbative expansion about the atomic limit with the boson kinetic energy acting as the perturbation .
the paper is organized as follows : section ii describes the formalism used in the strong - coupling perturbation theory in the presence of a magnetic field .
section iii presents the results for the phase diagrams and the excitation energies in a magnetic field , and section iv contains the conclusions .
our procedure is to calculate the ground - state energy of the mi phase with @xmath18 bosons per site @xmath23 , and of the excited states in the charge sector with one extra boson @xmath24 and one extra hole @xmath25 , in a rayleigh - schrdinger perturbative expansion in the hopping matrix element @xmath9 ( the kinetic energy is chosen as the perturbative part of the hamiltonian ) .
when the energy of the mi and the state with one extra boson are equal , the system undergoes a phase transition from the incompressible mi phase to the compressible sf phase with density larger than @xmath18 . the similar occurs when the state with one extra hole is degenerate with the mi phase ( except now the density of the sf phase is less than @xmath18 ) .
the detailed formalism of the strong - coupling expansion for the ground - state energies has already been presented@xcite .
the only modifications of the previous calculations needed here are to take into account the fact that the hopping matrix now has a complex phase and the changes required for the nonbipartite hopping matrix of the triangular lattice .
the important parameter that enters the results is the minimal eigenvalue @xmath26 of the kinetic energy matrix @xmath27 which includes a factor @xmath28 that depends on the magnetic field .
this parameter determines how the degeneracy is lifted in the first - order secular equation for the energy of the excited states in the charge sector .
formally this solution of the minimal eigenvalue is identical to finding the band minimum in the hofstadter problem@xcite .
the mott phase diagram is determined by the two mott phase boundaries
one for the particle excitations [ where @xmath29 and one for hole excitations [ where @xmath30 . for each value of @xmath9
there is a critical value of the chemical potential where the system changes phase from an incompressible to compressible fluid .
the upper and lower curves for the mott phase lobe are then described by this critical value of the chemical potential @xmath31 .
the results of our expansion through third - order are @xmath32\epsilon t^3\nonumber\\ & + & 12\delta_{lat}n_0(\frac{31}{4}n_0 ^ 2+\frac{21}{2}n_0 + 3 ) \cos(2\pi\phi)t^3+o(t^4)\nonumber\\ \mu_{h}(t)&=&n_0 - 1-\epsilon n_0 t+n_0(n_0 + 1)\epsilon^2 t^2- \frac{n_0 + 1}{2 } ( 5n_0 + 1)zt^2\nonumber\\ & + & n_0(n_0 + 1)[(2n_0 + 1)(-2-\epsilon^2)+z(\frac{25}{4}n_0 + \frac{11}{4})]\epsilon t^3\nonumber\\ & -&12\delta_{lat } ( n_0 + 1)(\frac{31}{4}n_0 ^ 2 + 5n_0+\frac{1}{4 } ) \cos(2\pi\phi)t^3+o(t^4 ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath33 or @xmath34 for the square or the triangular lattice , respectively , and @xmath35 is the corresponding number of nearest neighbors ( 4 or 6 , respectively ) .
these results have been verified by both analytical small - cluster calculations and by numerical cluster expansions .
the magnetic field appears in two places : ( 1 ) the magnetic field couples to the orbital current of the bosons as the particle or hole travels around a lattice plaquette and encloses the flux @xmath36 . in our third - order calculation , the orbital coupling only enters for the triangular lattice ( it enters at fourth order for the square lattice as four hops are required to enclose a plaquette ) . ( 2 ) the other effect of the magnetic field is to change the minimal energy of the extra particle or hole moving in the mott phase background . although the location of this mininum in the brillouin zone is gauge - dependent , its value is not ( thus @xmath37 ) .
we consider a rational flux @xmath38 . to find the minimal eigenvalues @xmath26 of the hopping matrix @xmath39 , we follow bellisard @xcite and hasegawa@xcite . in the landau gauge ,
the system maintains its translational invariance in the @xmath40-direction while it requires @xmath41 steps for translational invariance in the @xmath42-direction .
for the square lattice , the period @xmath41 equals @xmath43 , for the triangular lattice , @xmath44 for even @xmath43 and @xmath45 for odd @xmath43 .
a fourier - transformation now changes @xmath39 to the following @xmath46-matrix @xmath47 : @xmath48 with @xmath49 the eigenvalues within the corresponding brillouin - zone @xmath50 determine the @xmath41 energy bands of a boson moving in the magnetic field .
the minimal eigenvalue of the band - structure @xmath26 is shown in fig .
[ butterfly ] as a function of the magnetic flux per plaquette @xmath36 .
this is the parameter that enters eq .
( [ mueq ] ) to determine the mott phase boundary .
notice how on the square lattice the largest dip is at @xmath51 followed by 1/3 , 1/4 , and 2/5 , ... while on the triangular lattice the sequence corresponds to 1/2 , 1/4 , 1/3 , and 3/8 , ... the relation @xmath52 holds for all lattices , since the flux of @xmath53 is equivalent to a flux of 0 .
hence , the maximal magnetic field that can be applied corresponds to @xmath51 .
this maximal field configuration is realized by all real hopping matrix elements for each lattice : on the square lattice one takes three positive and one negative matrix element on each plaquette , while on the triangular lattice one takes all matrix elements to be negative . in particular , the `` fully frustrated '' case of @xmath51 on a triangular lattice
is the only nonzero magnetic - field case that can be easily treated by a high - order expansion@xcite because it maintains the full periodicity of the triangular lattice in zero magnetic field . rather than plotting the phase diagrams for just a third - order expansion , we choose to extrapolate our results using knowledge about the overall structure of the phase diagram .
there are numerous ways in which one can envision extrapolating the results of our third - order expansion to higher order .
it has been demonstrated by elstner and monien that a pade analysis of the strong coupling perturbation series yields rapid convergence in zero field @xcite .
we apply this method to the magnetic - field case for small magnetic fields by using a pade approximant@xcite for the logarithmic derivative of the difference in particle and hole mott phase boundaries @xmath54 .
we assume the same behavior as found in the zero - field case , where the tip of the mott lobe has a power law `` critical point '' with an exponent @xmath0 , @xmath55
. then the pade analysis fits @xmath56 to estimate the critical point and the dynamical critical exponent ( the pole determines @xmath57 and the residue determines @xmath0 ) .
the rest of the pade approximant determines @xmath58 , which then allows @xmath59 to be constructed .
a similar pade analysis for the midline of the mott lobe @xmath60 $ ] ( which is a regular function of @xmath9 ) then allows the entire phase diagram to be constructed .
atomic systems with a lattice spacing @xmath17 of around @xmath61 require a field of @xmath62 tesla for a half flux quantum per plaquette .
this is too large a field to be accessed experimentally , hence atomic systems always lie in the low - field region , where the perturbation theory is most accurate .
however for macroscopic lattice systems , with @xmath63 ( as in a josephson - junction array ) the whole magnetic field range is attainable by experiments with fields as low as @xmath64 gauss .
we show below how our theoretical results compare to the superfluid - insulator transitions on two dimensional josephson - junction arrays @xcite .
( 60,50)(0,0 ) ( 21,0 ) ( 86,0 ) fig .
[ phasesqtri ] presents the phase diagram of the first three lobes for the square lattice [ phasesqtri](a ) and the triangular lattice [ phasesqtri](b ) in the low magnetic - field region .
the incompressible , mott - insulating phase grows in size when the magnetic field increases from zero .
this shows , as expected , the localizing effect of the magnetic field on the itinerant bosons .
it appears that the shape of the lobes changes from a simple power - law dependence at the tip to something else .
there are three possibilities for the shape of the phase lobe at the tip : ( i ) it remains power - law - like with an exponent that may depend on the magnetic field ; ( ii ) it has a more exotic `` cusp - like '' dependence as seen in the kosterlitz - thouless transition ; or ( iii ) it has a discontinuous change in slope at the tip , and thereby has a `` first - order - like '' shape corresponding to the crossing of the two curves representing the upper and lower phase lobes , with no `` critical '' behavior at the tip ( this last result corresponds to @xmath65 ) .
there is theoretical evidence in favor of this last conclusion , which is a similar behavior to what happens to the mi phase in the presence of disorder , but here the explanation is different@xcite . if @xmath66 is expressed in lowest terms , then the order parameter requires @xmath43 components to describe it . as @xmath43 increases , it is more likely that the transition is first - order rather than second - order , and hence one would expect that the tip has a slope discontinuity immediately upon the introduction of the magnetic field , since small fields correspond to large values of @xmath43 .
the pade analysis given above assumes that ( i ) holds , but as @xmath0 approaches 1 for larger fields , the system crosses over to the behavior of ( iii ) unless something more exotic like ( ii ) intervenes .
we can not distinguish between scenarios ( i ) or ( iii ) with the low - order expansions presented here , but our results suggest scenario ( iii ) is correct , because the exponent @xmath0 rapidly approaches 1 as the field is increased . clearly further theoretical analysis is needed to decide this issue . for larger magnetic fields , we find that the two boundaries of the mott phase lobe no longer cross at a critical value of @xmath9 , but rather they `` repel '' each other .
this indicates that the tip of the mi phase lobe has moved out to such a large value of @xmath9 that the perturbation theory needs to be carried out to higher order to achieve proper convergence .
such an exercise has been already carried out through a linked - cluster expansion for the fully frustrated case ( @xmath51 ) on a triangular lattice@xcite .
the calculation from 3rd to 11th order converges toward a `` first - order '' transition @xmath67 at @xmath68 which yields a much larger insulating phase regime than with no magnetic field where @xmath69 .
a comparable experimental result is found@xcite where the insulator to superfluid transitions on josephson - junction arrays were studied by changing the ratio of the josephson coupling energy @xmath70 and the charging energy @xmath71 .
since @xmath70 is the energy scale for the superconducting coupling between the islands and @xmath71 is the scale for the interaction between the charge carriers , they can be related to the hopping energy @xmath9 and the on - site repulsion @xmath13 , respectively .
the results for small temperatures can be extrapolated to @xmath72 and show a transition at larger @xmath73 for the @xmath51 case than for the @xmath74 case , which qualitatively matches with our calculations ( since @xmath75 increases with magnetic field ) .
the experimental data can be analyzed in one of two dual pictures with the bose hubbard model . in the first view , the bosons are the cooper pairs on each island , and the main effect of the magnetic field is to modify the hopping matrix .
vortices appear in this case as supercurrent loops in the system .
while the density of vortices increases as the magnetic field is modified , the density of cooper pairs remains essentially constant over the low field ranges ( on the order of gauss ) explored in the experiments .
the second picture employs the duality transformation that views the vortices themselves as the bosonic particles@xcite .
the mobility of the vortices is determined by @xmath71 and their interaction by @xmath70 , so the roles of those parameters are reversed in this case .
the magnetic field then takes on the role of the chemical potential .
we will not employ this second picture here , which has been used to evaluate the mott insulating phase of the vortices in the quasi - one - dimensional josephson junction arrays@xcite . in the following we compare small - field results .
as shown in fig .
[ phasesqtri ] the mi phase area and the location of the tip of the lobe increase with increasing magnetic field up to about @xmath76 ( for the square lattice ) .
the measurements of @xcite show @xmath77 and @xmath78 for @xmath74 and @xmath79 respectively , which is similar to our results with @xmath57 increasing by about 45% from 0.057 to 0.083 as @xmath80 increases from 0 to 0.1 .
in addition , the tip location for larger field strengths saturates in the experiments , which is a result that we can not confirm , because our analysis through third - order in @xmath9 fails when @xmath57 becomes too large .
( 60,50)(0,0 ) ( 21,0 ) ( 86,0 ) [ deltamutri ] in fig .
[ deltamutri](a ) we show the evolution of the excitation - gap energies @xmath59 for fixed hopping @xmath9 as a function of magnetic field . initially the gap energy increases which indicates the increasing stability of the mi phase in a weak magnetic field . for larger magnetic fields
, we see dips in the gap energy around rational magnetic fluxes such as @xmath81 or @xmath82 ( which can be reliably calculated for small values of @xmath9 ) .
a similar commensurable structure is found in experiments that measure the zero - bias resistance @xmath83 of a josephson - junction array in a magnetic field@xcite . a small @xmath84 indicates proximity to the sf phase . at rational @xmath80
the vortices form a lattice which is commensurable with the josephson - junction array and favors a pinning of the vortices , leading to a decrease of the zero - bias resistance .
qualitatively , we see the same behavior in the excitation gap energies and the zero - bias resistance .
notice how the dips track closely with the dips seen in the minimal eigenvalue of the hopping matrix as shown in fig .
[ butterfly ] .
this behavior explains the dips seen in the experimental data on the triangular lattice that are most prevalent at 1/2 , followed by 1/4 , 1/3 , 3/8 , and so on .
the experimental data@xcite also shows that the system has four different regions of superconducting stability for one value of @xmath9 , centered at 0 , 1/2 , 1/4 and 1/3 . while our results in fig .
[ deltamutri](a ) only show superconductivity around @xmath74 [ where @xmath85 , we can see that if @xmath9 was increased , and the calculations carried out to higher order , it is likely that we would see additional superconducting regions appearing ( we believe first around 1/2 , followed by 1/4 and 1/3 ) .
finally we study the magnetic - field dependence of the dynamical critical exponent @xmath0 ( eq . [ znuformel ] ) for small fields in fig .
[ exponent](b ) .
the bhm in zero magnetic field can be mapped onto a three - dimensional xy model which has @xmath86 independent of the lattice structure@xcite . by using the pade analysis on our third - order expansion ,
we obtain @xmath87 for the square lattice and @xmath88 for the triangular lattice at @xmath74 . a pade analysis of a tenth - order expansion@xcite yields @xmath89 for both lattice types , which shows the convergence of higher - order calculations in our method .
as seen in fig .
[ deltamutri ] , the dynamical exponent appears to increase as the magnetic field increases .
it is , however , difficult to conclude whether @xmath0 remains equal to it s zero - field value , increases with magnetic field , or immediately jumps to one upon the onset of a magnetic field , solely on the basis of this third - order analysis .
but , the fact that the most likely point to have @xmath90 is @xmath51 ( because it requires only two components for the order parameter ) , and a higher - order expansion predicts @xmath65 there , leads us to conjecture that @xmath65 for all nonzero magnetic fields .
this latter result is supported by monte carlo data on the antiferromagnetic xy model for stacked triangular planes , which have a weakly first - order transition rather than a critical point@xcite .
in conclusion , we applied a strong - coupling @xmath91-expansion ( up to third order ) to study the insulator - superfluid phase transitions of the two - dimensional bose - hubbard model under the influence of a magnetic field . although our analysis is limited , we are able to produce reasonable results that both agree with physical intuition and with experiments .
we found that the mott insulating phase enlarges with an increasing magnetic field .
this is explained by the localizing effect of the magnetic field on the moving bosons .
qualitative agreement in the increase of the critical hopping energy @xmath57 was found with experimental results on josephson junction arrays@xcite . for small magnetic fields ,
we find a power - law behavior of the gap energy close to the critical point ( @xmath92 ) with a dynamical critical exponent that increases with @xmath80 . for larger magnetic fields ,
we find a repulsion of the two phase boundaries , which indicates a change from the power - law like behavior to either kosterlitz - thouless behavior or to a `` first - order '' transition .
our results are also consistent with the `` critical point '' immediately changing to a `` first - order '' discontinuous change in the slope of the phase boundaries as the magnetic field is turned on .
we found that the gap energies for small fixed hopping and variable magnetic field illustrate commensurability effects for rational fluxes which is also seen in josephson - junction array experiments .
more work is needed to understand the change in character of the insulator to superfluid phase transition as a magnetic field is introduced : does the system have a field - dependent power - law dependence which crosses over to a `` first - order '' ( or more exotic cusp - like shape ) as the field increases , or does it immediately become `` first - order '' in a field .
higher - order calculations are needed to decide this issue .
it would also be interesting to extend the scaling analysis of the bhm to include its behavior in an external magnetic field .
we would like to thank m. ma for useful and interesting discussions .
j.k.f . acknowledges support from an onr yip grant n000149610828 and from the petroleum research fund administered by the american chemical society ( acs - prf 29623-gb6 ) .
h. m. jaeger , d. b. haviland , b. g. orr and a. m. goldman , phys .
b * 40 * , 182 ( 1989 ) ; y. liu and k. a. mcgreer , b. nease , d. b. haviland , g. martinez , j. w. halley , and a. m. goldman , phys . rev . lett . * 67 * , 2068 ( 1991 ) .
h. s. j. van der zant , f. c. fritschy , w. j. elion , l. j. geerligs , and j. e. mooij , phys .
lett . * 69 * , 2971 ( 1992 ) ; h. s. j. van der zant , w. j. elion , l. j. geerligs and j. e. mooij , phys .
b * 54 * , 10081 ( 1996 ) .
b. pannetier , j. chaussy , r. rammal and j. c. villegier , phys .
lett . * 53 * , 1845 ( 1984 ) ; a. f. hebard and m. a. paalanen , ibid . *
65 * , 927 ( 1990 ) ; a. yazdani and a. kapitulnik , ibid .
* 74 * , 3037 ( 1995 ) .
a. van oudenaarden and j. e. mooij , phys .
lett . * 76 * , 4947 ( 1996 ) ; a. van oudenaarden , s. j. k. vrdy , and j. e. mooij , ibid . *
77 * , 4257 ( 1996 ) ; a. van oudenaarden , b. van leeuwen , m. p.
m. robbens , and j. e. mooij , phys .
b * 57 * , 11684 ( 1998 ) . | the bose - hubbard model in an external magnetic field is investigated with strong - coupling perturbation theory .
the lowest - order secular equation leads to the problem of a charged particle moving on a lattice in the presence of a magnetic field , which was first treated by hofstadter .
we present phase diagrams for the two - dimensional square and triangular lattices , showing a change in shape of the phase lobes away from the well - known power - law behavior in zero magnetic field .
some qualitative agreement with experimental work on josephson - junction arrays is found for the insulating phase behavior at small fields . |
this work was supported by the french anr project no . anr-13-bs04 - 0013 - 01 .
we thank j. debray for sample preparation and f. lvy - bertrand for infrared measurements .
m. j. harris , s. t. bramwell , d. f. mcmorrow , t. zeiske and k. w. godfrey , phys .
lett . * 79 * , 2554 ( 1997 ) .
a. p. ramirez , a. hayashi , r. j. cava , r. siddharthan and b. s. shastry , nature * 399 * , 333 ( 1999 ) .
j. s. gardner , s. r. dunsiger , b. d. gaulin , m. j. p. gingras , j. e. greedan , r. f. kiefl , m. d. lumsden , w. a. macfarlane , n. p. raju , j. e. sonier , i. swainson and z. tun , phys .
lett . * 82 * , 1012 ( 1999 ) .
see supplemental material for additional information on : geometry of tb@xmath0ti@xmath0o@xmath1 crystal , cef - phonon coupling symmetry , cef doublet transitions , detailed experimental methods and far - infrared phonon spectra .
m. ruminy , m. n. valdez , b. wehinger , a. bosak , d. t. adroja , u. stuhr , k. iida , k. kamazawa , e. pomjakushina , d. prabakharan , m. k. haas , l. bovo , d. sheptyakov , a. cervellino , r. j. cava , m. kenzelmann , n. a. spaldin , and t fennell , phys .
b * 93 * , 214308 ( 2016 ) . | the spin liquid ground state of tb@xmath0ti@xmath0o@xmath1 has remained a long standing problem . by synchrotron
based terahertz measurements , we provide evidence of strong coupling between the magnetic and lattice degrees of freedom that begins to develop at high temperatures .
this is revealed by hybrid crystal electric field - phonon excitations which appear at 0.67thz below 200k , and around 0.42thz below 50k .
this double vibronic process only occurs for tb@xmath2 in the titinate family due to adequate energy matching and strong quadrupolar moments .
lattice motion is then the driving force behind spin flips , promoting quantum terms in the effective hamiltonian that describes tb@xmath0ti@xmath0o@xmath1 . .
over the last decade , spin - ice physics has aroused significant attention @xcite .
it emerges in pyrochlore magnets , like ho@xmath0ti@xmath0o@xmath1 or dy@xmath0ti@xmath0o@xmath1 , as a result of effective ferromagnetic interactions coupling the ising - like rare earth magnetic moments constrained along the local @xmath3 directions by the crystal field @xcite(fig .
[ fig : absspec ] ( a , b ) ) .
this combination impedes long range order , favoring a disordered and macroscopically degenerate magnetic state governed by an organizing principle , the so - called ice rule " , where two spins point into and two out of each elementary tetrahedron in the structure @xcite . the possibility that quantum fluctuations can melt
the spin ice state is a topical issue .
it is expected to lead to a wealth of exotic phenomena such as a quantum superposition of `` two - in two - out '' configurations and emergent electrodynamics with new deconfined particles @xcite . in this context , the puzzling behavior of the spin liquid tb@xmath0ti@xmath0o@xmath1 has attracted much attention . despite effective antiferromagnetic interactions ,
tb@xmath0ti@xmath0o@xmath1 features no long range order @xcite .
remarkably , the ground state supports elastic power law spin correlations @xcite , bearing some resemblance with the pinch point pattern observed in spin ices @xcite .
below 300mk , a dispersing low - energy collective mode is found to emerge from these pinch points , reaching its maximum energy at @xmath40.25mev @xcite .
this signal likely corresponds to fluctuations between the two @xmath5 electronic states of the crystal electric field ( cef ) ground state doublet .
it was interpreted as a signature of interactions between quadrupoles , highlighting the importance of those degrees of freedom @xcite .
this is because the non - kramers nature of tb@xmath2 ions prevents magnetic exchange alone from inducing such fluctuations within the ising - like ground state @xcite .
a property that distinguishes tb@xmath0ti@xmath0o@xmath1from the other rare - earth titanates is the cef energy spectrum of tb@xmath2 .
it features a first excited doublet at a low energy of @xmath6mev above the ground state @xcite , compared to 25mev for ho@xmath2 in the prototype spin ice compound .
furthermore , below @xmath420k , this excited doublet has been shown to couple to a transverse acoustic phonon , forming a hybrid magneto - elastic excitation @xcite .
it was proposed that a magneto - elastic coupling , linear in the phonon displacement and in the quadrupolar electronic moments , could explain the peculiar ground state of tb@xmath0ti@xmath0o@xmath1 . to confirm this hypothesis , it is important to show that this magneto - elastic coupling not only occurs for the excited cef doublet , but also with the ground doublet . in this letter
, we provide evidence for such a coupling using terahertz ( thz ) spectroscopy , which probes the brillouin zone center in the energy range close to @xmath7 .
our synchrotron based experiments , performed with an unprecedented accuracy , show a splitting of both the ground and first excited doublets that occurs by coupling with the acoustic phonon at temperatures as high as 50k .
this confirms that the actual ground state of tb@xmath0ti@xmath0o@xmath1 has a mixed magnetic and phononic nature .
moreover , we show that this low temperature vibronic process is not alone .
a second process is observed as high as 200k and couples the first excited cef state and associated transition at @xmath7 with a silent optical phonon mode .
the measurements were performed using a tb@xmath0ti@xmath0o@xmath1 single crystal grown by the floating zone technique previously described in @xcite .
we have measured the polarization dependent thz spectrum in the 0.21.0thz ( 0.824.14mev ) energy range using both standard ( ssr)@xcite and coherent synchrotron radiation ( csr)@xcite techniques .
focus is given to the `` high temperature '' regime , from 300k to 6k .
four plaquettes , 2 mm in diameter , were chosen to test the magnetoelectric activity of the excited modes according to the main cubic symmetry axes .
specifically , the ( 100 ) wafer ( 1 mm thick ) is perpendicular to the four - fold axis while the ( 111 ) wafer ( 300@xmath8 m thick ) is perpendicular to the three - fold axis . to probe the local rare earth symmetry with an ising direction along
@xmath9 $ ] , two additional wafers ( 1@xmath100 ) , and ( 11@xmath11 ) ( 300@xmath8 m thick ) are used allowing three mutually orthogonal planes : ( 111 ) , ( 1@xmath100 ) , and ( 11@xmath11 ) . note then , that the projection of the polarized thz field in the local frame is mixed between the 4 tb@xmath2 sites of each tetrahedron ( see supplemental material @xcite ) .
typical spectra are given in fig .
[ fig : absspec](c ) with a 200k reference .
as the temperature is lowered down to 6k , an absorption peak develops around 0.42thz ( 1.7mev ) . this feature is consistent with the first excited cef level previously reported by neutron and optical spectroscopic studies @xcite .
a much weaker and so far unreported peak is visible at 0.67thz ( 2.78mev ) .
previous experimental studies suggest that the low - temperature magnetic correlations first begin to develop below 50k @xcite .
we therefore analyze this temperature regime using the spectrum at 60k ( fig .
[ fig : absspec](d ) ) as a reference . noticeably , in fig .
[ fig : absspec](d ) the peak at 0.67thz ( 2.78mev ) is not present indicating that its strength and energy position do not change significantly over this temperature range and its contribution is divided out along with the background . at the same time , close inspection reveals a three peak structure within the cef excitation .
the four observed peaks , with 200k and 60k references , are fit by gaussian profiles shown in the inset of fig .
[ fig : absspec](d ) designated p0 , p1 , p2 and p3 .
their energy position and normalized total area are shown in fig .
[ fig : tmpdpnd ] .
no significant temperature shifts are observed for their energy position except for a slight hardening below 20k for p3 and above 100k for p1 .
the precise fitted peak energies at 6k are e0=0.332(4)thz ( 1.37(2)mev ) , e1=0.41(6)thz ( 1.71(2)mev ) , e2=0.502(9)thz ( 2.08(3)mev ) , and e3=0.672(6)thz ( 2.78(3)mev ) .
p0 , p1 and p2 mainly appear below 50k , while p3 appears at the much higher temperature of 200k , indicating a different origin .
it is tempting to assign the three peak structure ( p0-p2 ) to a splitting of the ground and first excited cef levels , that share the @xmath12 symmetry
. the resulting four level scheme will give rise to the 3 observed excitations if the central peak ( p1 ) corresponds to two different transitions of the same energy ( see fig .
[ fig : hyb ] ( a ) ) within our experimental precision .
the @xmath12 splitting is then similar for both the ground state doublet and the first excited doublet at a value of 0.085thz ( 0.35mev ) .
such a splitting corresponds very nicely in energy with the collective mode measured by neutron scattering at a much lower temperature ( 50mk ) @xcite .
it should be emphasized that it is experimentally impossible to assign the entire four peak spectrum to transitions between the two doublets with different splittings @xcite .
the temperature profile for the outer peaks ( p0 and p2 ) is modeled by a two - level system with an energy barrier of 0.42thz ( @xmath13 1.7mev ) .
it bears similarity to the temperature dependence of the magneto - elastic mode ( mem ) measured by fennell _
et al .
_ using inelastic neutron scattering @xcite .
this mem has been shown to arise from hybridization between the @xmath14 acoustic phonon and first excited cef level taking on a magneto - elastic component .
a zone center extrapolation of the scattering vector dependent neutron data is in good agreement with the energy of p2 at 0.50thz ( 2.08mev ) .
since the acoustic phonon branch must also cross the cef ground state at the zone center , hybridization with the ground state is also expected due to its identical @xmath12 symmetry .
this is exactly what we observe , with similar splitting for both the ground and first excited states .
this suggests that the collective mode built on the basis of the @xmath5 states in the ground doublet already incorporates lattice degrees of freedom as does the first excited cef state .
similar vibronic phonon - cef interactions have also been shown for ceal@xmath0 and facilitate mixing between the ground and first excited cef states @xcite . in tb@xmath0ti@xmath0o@xmath1 ,
the hybridization process between the two @xmath12 cef levels and the @xmath14 acoustic phonon depicted in fig .
[ fig : hyb ] ( b ) is not alone . a recent report by ruminy _ et al .
@xcite suggests that other hybridized magneto - elastic optical ( meom ) excitations occur at much higher energies around 3.9thz ( 16mev ) due to the proximity of optical phonons .
their work is corroborated by a complementary study focused on the phonon spectrum in these compounds @xcite .
noticeably , their ab inito calculations show that the lowest energy phonon is at @xmath41.1thz ( 4.6mev ) and has @xmath15 symmetry .
this phonon is optically silent ( both in raman and infrared ( ir ) spectroscopy ) , and it is not observed by inelastic neutron scattering because of a negligible scattering cross section . since it is quite close in energy to the additional p3 excitation that occurs below 200k at 0.67thz ( 2.78mev ) , we assign p3 to a coupling mechanism between this @xmath15 phonon and the first excited cef level .
it is worth noting that this optical phonon branch does not cross the @xmath12 ground state , and therefore is not coupled to it .
using infrared reflection measurements , we have checked that the 7 expected ir active phonon modes are present in the range 80800 @xmath16(2.424thz ) @xcite .
the observed phonon energies reveal a discrepancy in comparison to the calculated values which suggests that the lowest energy @xmath15 phonon may indeed be even closer to the first excited @xmath12 cef level .
therefore , two different vibronic processes must occur in tb@xmath0ti@xmath0o@xmath1at two different temperature scales .
a diagram of the two coupling mechanisms and corresponding level scheme is depicted in fig .
[ fig : hyb ] .
the high temperature vibronic process involves the first excited @xmath12 cef and the lowest energy @xmath15 optical phonon .
the resulting hybridization develops below 200k as seen with the appearance of peak p3 at an intermediate energy between the @xmath12 cef level and the @xmath15 phonon energy .
this coupling mechanism transfers magnetic thz activity to an otherwise silent phonon .
the low temperature vibronic process occurs when magnetic fluctuations set in below 50k .
it involves the ground and first excited cef levels , which both have @xmath12 symmetry , and the @xmath14 acoustic phonon .
it results in the splitting of both the ground and first excited doublets which acquire a mixed electronic - phononic character .
additional valuable information about these cef - phonon processes is obtained by the selection rules observed for each excitation and their angular dependence when the polarization of the thz electric ( @xmath17 ) and magnetic ( @xmath18 ) fields is rotated .
we first confirm that the hybridized features ( p2 and p3 ) are mainly of magnetic origin .
when measuring two configurations with the same direction for @xmath18 but 90 degrees rotation for @xmath17 , the same features are present @xcite . using a rotative sample mount , we were then able to precisely measure the angular dependence of the spectrum for a rotation about the [ 100 ] fourfold and @xmath19 $ ] two fold axes of the cubic structure ( fig .
[ fig : angldpnd ] ) .
note that the [ 100 ] axis has no particular meaning in the rare earth site symmetry while the @xmath19 $ ] direction corresponds to a two fold axis for two sites out of four on each tetrahedron @xcite . around
[ 100 ] , the spectrum remains unchanged as expected .
in contrast , around @xmath19 $ ] , a strong anisotropy appears for all peaks except p1 .
p2 has a maximum intensity for @xmath20 $ ] , while both p0 and p3 behave inversely with maximum intensities when @xmath21 $ ] .
there is also a transfer of spectral weight between p2 and p3 showing that the two vibronic processes are not independent .
this double vibronic mechanism accounts for a mixing between electronic states and propagating phonon modes , which occur in crystals when the excitations are of the same symmetry and are close enough in energy @xcite .
the transverse components of the acoustic t@xmath22 phonon fulfill the symmetry requirements for both the ground and first excited cef states and their coupling may induce a splitting of these doublet levels . as for the silent optical t@xmath23 phonon
, its longitudinal component is also allowed to couple to the cef states inducing no splitting but a shift in the cef level .
this optical phonon is close in energy to the first excited cef doublet and will dominantly form vibrons with it at high temperature .
its dispersion can be reasonably assumed flatter than that of the acoustic phonon leading to a larger density of states . at lower temperatures ,
this vibronic process should weaken owing to thermal depopulation leaving the vibronic process with the acoustic phonon to gradually take hold . while p3 is still preset at 6k
, this process appears evident in fig .
[ fig : tmpdpnd ] ( c ) with a slight reduction in the intensity of p3 at the lowest temperatures .
importantly , the double vibronic process involves quadrupolar operators which behave as spin flip operators in the @xmath24 ground state doublet basis . as a result , phonons ( and lattice zero point motion )
are now the source of spin fluctuations and by their virtual exchange may give rise to new quantum terms in the effective hamiltonian of tb@xmath0ti@xmath0o@xmath1 . depending on their strength , a long range quadrupolar order or coulomb - phase like state might be stabilized , provided the ising term dominates @xcite .
furthermore , an interesting feature of the vibronic process is that the acoustic phonon crosses the two doublets , which being themselves close in energy , will also partially mix .
we anticipate that the magnetic dipolar operators will then behave as spin flip operators in the basis of the dressed @xmath5 electronic states .
this mechanism , already proposed in ref @xcite , could be the source of additional fluctuations
. this will not be the case for ho@xmath0ti@xmath0o@xmath1 and dy@xmath0ti@xmath0o@xmath1 : although the symmetry of both phonons and cef states are identical , the energy of the first cef state is one order of magnitude larger reducing the vibronic process solely to the ground state .
more importantly , the quadrupolar matrix elements in the basis of the ground @xmath5 electronic states are essentially zero for ho@xmath2 and dy@xmath2 . in summary , using synchrotron based thz spectroscopy , we show that two temperature regimes are present in the spin ice candidate tb@xmath0ti@xmath0o@xmath1 revealing two different vibronic processes . the first one , below 50k , concerns the ground and first excited cef levels which couple to the acoustic @xmath14 phonon .
this is the temperature scale of magnetic fluctuations @xcite as well as elastic softening @xcite .
the second regime , below 200k , is associated to the coupling between the first cef level and the lowest energy optical phonon of symmetry @xmath15 and is in agreement with the high temperature plateau observed in the muon spin relaxation rate @xcite for this compound .
this double vibronic process , of quadrupolar origin , affects the electronic state that can no longer be described solely by electronic wave functions .
rather a collective vibronic state prevails , built on the ground and first excited cef states mixed with two different phonons .
it is activated with dramatic effects in tb@xmath0ti@xmath0o@xmath1 by virtue of adequate energy matching and strong quadrupolar moments that only occur in this compound . |
[ [ section ] ] in the paper @xcite published in 1987 , a. beilinson formulated his famous conjectures on the properties of hypothetical categories of mixed motivic sheaves over a scheme .
in addition to the classical case of motives with rational coefficients , some conjectures about the category of motives with a finite coefficient ring @xmath0 were proposed there .
equivalent conjectures describing motivic complexes with finite coefficients were earlier formulated by s. lichtenbaum in @xcite . in the subsequent works of v.
voevodsky @xcite and others , triangulated categories @xmath3 of motives over @xmath1 were constructed ( assuming only the resolution of singularities ) for any field @xmath1 and any coefficient ring @xmath4 , @xmath5 , or @xmath0 .
beilinson predicted existence of abelian categories of mixed motives ; the triangulated categories now known would then be equivalent to the derived categories of those abelian categories .
the problem of constructing such categories of mixed motives , or finding them as subcategories of the triangulated categories of motives , remains open . in this paper
we study the cases of mixed tate and artin tate motives over a field with finite coefficients and discuss the related homological algebra formalism in general .
[ [ introd - t - structures ] ] there are three essentially independent conditions one has to verify in order to establish that a triangulated category @xmath6 is equivalent to the derived category of an abelian category .
first one has to find an abelian subcategory @xmath7 , or , more technically speaking , define a _
t - structure _
@xcite on the category @xmath6 .
secondly , one has to check that this t - structure is `` of the derived type '' ( * ? ? ?
* subsection 4.0 ) , i. e. , the natural homomorphisms of the @xmath8 groups @xmath9)$ ] are isomorphisms for all @xmath10 , @xmath11 .
thirdly , one has to construct a triangulated functor @xmath12 compatible with the embeddings of @xmath13 into @xmath14 and @xmath6 .
very roughly , given a full subcategory @xmath7 , the condition that @xmath13 is the heart of a t - structure on @xmath6 is a restriction on the groups @xmath15)$ ] for @xmath16 , while the condition that the t - structure is of the derived type is a restriction on the groups @xmath15)$ ] for @xmath17 .
the former condition amounts to the existence of _ canonical filtrations _ on the objects of @xmath6 with subquotients in @xmath13 , while the latter condition is equivalent to the existence of _ silly filtrations_. as to the problem of existence of a triangulated functor from @xmath14 to @xmath6 , it can be viewed independently of the choice of the subcategory @xmath7 as arising solely from shortcomings of the notion of a triangulated category per se .
[ [ section-1 ] ] let us discuss the canonical and silly filtrations in some more detail .
suppose we are given a complex @xmath18 with objects and morphisms from an abelian category @xmath13 .
then there are two filtrations which one can define on the complex @xmath19 : the _ canonical filtration _ by the subcomplexes @xmath20 and the _ silly filtration _ by the subcomplexes @xmath21 .
the former filtration is increasing when @xmath22 increases , while the latter one is decreasing ; the successive quotients of the former filtration are the cohomology objects @xmath23 , while the successive quotients of the latter one are the terms @xmath24 of the complex @xmath19 .
the canonical filtration owes its name to the fact that it does not depend on the choice of a particular complex inside a given quasi - isomorphism class and therefore is uniquely ( and functorially ) defined on objects of the derived category @xmath25 .
the silly filtration on an object of the derived category is not unique ; nevertheless , it is sensible to ask about its existence .
a typical example when the canonical filtrations do exist , but the silly filtrations may not is the following one .
let @xmath13 be an abelian subcategory of an abelian category @xmath26 ; consider the derived category @xmath27 of bounded complexes in the category @xmath26 with cohomology in the subcategory @xmath13 .
then one can see that the silly filtrations exist in @xmath27 if and only if the natural functor @xmath28 is an equivalence of categories , which means that the @xmath8 groups between the objects of @xmath13 computed in the larger category @xmath26 should coincide with those computed in @xmath13 . on the other hand
, the canonical filtrations may not exist on complexes whose terms belong to an additive category which is not abelian . [ [ introd - silly - filtrations ] ] the silly filtrations condition can be stated in several equivalent forms as a condition on a full subcategory @xmath29 closed under extensions in a triangulated category @xmath6 .
one of these formulations is quite simply that any element of the group @xmath15)$ ] with @xmath10 , @xmath30 and @xmath17 is the composition of such elements of degree @xmath31 .
this makes it possible to consider this condition independently of the condition that @xmath29 is the heart of a t - structure . given a t - structure with the heart @xmath13 on a triangulated category @xmath6 and assuming the existence of a certain refinement @xcite of the triangulated category structure on @xmath6 ( which does exist , at least , for all triangulated categories of algebraic origin )
, one can construct a triangulated functor @xmath32 .
this functor is an equivalence of triangulated categories if and only if the t - structure is of the derived type , i. e. , the silly filtrations , or @xmath8 decomposition , condition holds .
this answers , in theory , our question when a triangulated category is equivalent to the derived category of an abelian category .
notice the difference between our silly filtrations and the `` weight structures '' of bondarko @xcite : the orthogonality condition from the definition in @xcite is not assumed , and does not hold , in the situations considered in this paper .
indeed , the question of existence of silly filtrations on objects of a triangulated category with respect to a generating full subcategory ( closed under extensions ) that we are interested in here becomes trivial when the orthogonality , i. e. , the vanishing of @xmath15)$ ] for @xmath10 , @xmath30 and @xmath33 , is assumed .
[ [ section-2 ] ] let us discuss the case of tate motives with rational coefficients first .
one can define the category of mixed tate motives as the minimal subcategory of voevodsky s triangulated category @xmath34 containing the tate objects @xmath35 and closed under extensions .
beilinson s conjectures claim and voevodsky for his triangulated category of motives proves that the @xmath8 spaces between the tate objects are isomorphic to the appropriate pieces of the algebraic k - theory groups of the field @xmath1 .
this means that the first problem one encounters is to prove that the pieces of the algebraic k - theory corresponding to the spaces @xmath36)$ ] with negative numbers @xmath37 , and actually also with @xmath38 and @xmath39 , vanish which is the statement of the beilinson
vanishing conjectures_. this is the necessary and sufficient condition for existence of a t - structure on the triangulated subcategory of @xmath40 generated by the tate objects having the above - defined category of mixed tate motives as its heart . as to the silly filtrations ,
let us note that even if the abelian category of arbitrary mixed motives does exist , the condition that the @xmath8 spaces between the tate objects computed in this large abelian category coincide with those with respect to the abelian category of mixed tate motives is still highly nontrivial .
this is one of beilinson s conjectures ( * ? ? ?
* subsection 5.10.d(iv ) ) ; it is supported by the facts that one has @xmath36)=0 $ ] for @xmath41 , and , most remarkably , that the diagonal @xmath8 algebra @xmath42)$ ] , being isomorphic to the milnor k - theory algebra @xmath43 of the field @xmath1 with rational coefficients , is a quadratic algebra . [ [ section-3 ] ] another name for the silly filtration conjecture is the `` @xmath44-conjecture '' of bloch and kriz @xcite .
this terminology comes from the following series of examples .
let @xmath10 be a connected cw - complex and @xmath6 be the derived category of sheaves of abelian groups on @xmath10 .
denote by @xmath7 be the abelian subcategory of locally constant sheaves .
the subcategory @xmath13 is the heart of a bounded t - structure on the full triangulated subcategory in @xmath6 generated by @xmath13
. this t - structure is of the derived type if and only if @xmath10 is a @xmath44 .
alternatively , let @xmath6 be the derived category of sheaves of @xmath5-vector spaces on @xmath10 and @xmath7 be the abelian subcategory consisting of all unipotent local systems of finite rank .
the abelian category @xmath13 is the heart of a bounded t - structure on the full triangulated subcategory in @xmath6 generated by @xmath13 .
this t - structure is of the derived type if and only if the rational homotopy type of @xmath10 is a @xmath44 .
[ [ section-4 ] ] as we have already mentioned , the above homomorphisms @xmath45)$ ] are isomorphisms whenever they are surjective , that is , if and only if any element of the group @xmath15)$ ] with @xmath10 , @xmath11 and @xmath17 is the composition of such elements of degree @xmath31 . in the case of mixed tate motives , however , we only know the higher @xmath46 spaces between the simple objects @xmath35
. one can even show that it suffices to decompose any homomorphism @xmath47 $ ] with a simple object @xmath10 , but the condition that any higher homomorphism between two simple objects is decomposable is _ not _ sufficient .
it is not always possible to express the silly filtrations condition in terms of the algebra of higher homomorphisms between the simple objects ; when it is , it typically turns out to be a _
koszulity _ @xcite condition . for mixed tate motives with rational coefficients
, such a result can be obtained in the case of a field @xmath1 of finite characteristic .
a conjecture of parshin and beilinson claims that in this case the algebraic and milnor k - theory rings with rational coefficients coincide ; this means that @xmath36)=0 $ ] unless @xmath48 .
then the @xmath8 spaces computed in the abelian category of mixed tate motives are isomorphic to the higher @xmath46 spaces in the triangulated category if and only if the diagonal @xmath46 algebra , that is the milnor k - theory algebra @xmath43 , is koszul .
[ [ section-5 ] ] now let us turn to tate motives with finite coefficients . as in the rational coefficients case , there is a spectral sequence starting from the motivic cohomology groups @xmath49)$ ] , where @xmath50 , and converging to the algebraic k - theory of the field @xmath1 with coefficients @xmath0 .
in particular , the diagonal cohomology algebra @xmath51)$ ] is isomorphic to the milnor k - theory algebra @xmath52 . on the other hand , the beilinson
lichtenbaum conjectures connect motivic cohomology with galois cohomology of the field @xmath1 .
the triangulated category of motives with finite coefficients @xmath53 over a field @xmath1 of characteristic prime to @xmath2 comes together with the tale realization functor @xmath54 where @xmath55 is the absolute galois group of @xmath1 and @xmath56 is the derived category of discrete @xmath57-modules over @xmath0 .
this functor sends the tate object @xmath58 to the cyclotomic @xmath57-module @xmath59 .
the conjectures claim that the tale realization functor induces isomorphisms of the higher @xmath46 spaces as follows : @xmath60)&\simeq h^n(g_k,\,\mu_{m}^{\ot j - i } ) , \quad \text{for \
$ n\le j - i$ ; } \\ \operatorname{hom}_{{{\mathcal d}}{{\mathcal m}}}({{\mathbb z}}/m(i),{\mskip .5\thinmuskip\relax}{{\mathbb z}}/m(j)[n])&=0 , \quad \text{otherwise . } \end{aligned}\ ] ] in particular , comparing the two formulas for the diagonal cohomology one comes to the milnor
kato conjecture connecting the galois cohomology with cyclotomic coefficients with the milnor k - theory .
it was proven by voevodsky and suslin @xcite ( see also @xcite ) that the converse implication holds as well : if the milnor bloch
kato conjecture is true for any field containing the field @xmath1 , then the beilinson
lichtenbaum conjecture for the field @xmath1 follows .
[ [ section-6 ] ] in view of the beilinson lichtenbaum formulas , it is a natural problem to give a precise description of the triangulated subcategory generated by the tate objects in @xmath61 in terms of the galois group @xmath57 .
the question of finding an elementary construction , in terms of the galois group , of an abelian category of mixed tate motives with finite coefficients with the @xmath8 spaces given by the beilinson
lichtenbaum formulas was posed in ( * ? ? ? * subsection 5.10.d(vi ) ) . as in the rational coefficients case
, the minimal subcategory of @xmath61 containing the tate objects and closed under extensions seems to be the natural candidate for the category of mixed tate motives . by the definition ,
any object of this category has a canonical filtration whose successive quotients are direct sums of the tate objects , and this is the maximal subcategory with this property .
it turns out , however , that this category is _ not _ abelian .
the reason is that it follows from the formulas that , unlike in the rational coefficients case , for certain @xmath62 there exists a nonzero morphism @xmath63 corresponding to an isomorphism of @xmath57-modules @xmath64 .
it is easy to see that the kernel and cokernel of such a morphism in the above category of mixed tate motives are zero , and still this morphism is not an isomorphism . in the simplest case of an algebraically closed field @xmath1 and
a prime number @xmath2 , this category is equivalent to the category of finite - dimensional filtered vector spaces over @xmath0 .
[ [ section-7 ] ] instead of being abelian , the category of mixed tate motives with finite coefficients has a natural structure of an _
exact category_. the construction of the derived category of an abelian category can be generalized to exact categories smoothly , and , conversely , an additive subcategory of a triangulated category has a natural exact category structure if it is closed under extensions and there are no @xmath46 groups with negative degrees between its objects .
all the results about t - structures mentioned in [ introd - t - structures ] and [ introd - silly - filtrations ] can be extended to exact subcategories of triangulated categories .
[ [ introd - list - of - situations ] ] depending on the conditions on the field @xmath1 and the coefficient ring @xmath65 , it may or may not be possible to express all of the motivic cohomology @xmath66)$ ] , where @xmath67 , in terms of the diagonal cohomology @xmath68)\simeq { \mathrm{k}^{\mathrm{m\mskip-.2\thinmuskip\relax}}}_n(k)\ot_{{\mathbb z}}k$ ] in a simple way .
various conjectures and results predict that in the following situations this should be possible : 1 .
@xmath69 and @xmath70 ; 2 .
@xmath71 and @xmath70 ; 3 .
@xmath72 and @xmath1 contains a primitive root of unity of degree @xmath2 . in all of these cases ,
the silly filtration conjecture for the mixed tate motives over @xmath1 with coefficients in @xmath65 is equivalent to the koszulity condition on the graded algebra of diagonal motivic cohomology @xmath73 . on the other hand , in the following cases
there is apparently no simple way to express the motivic cohomology in terms of its diagonal part : 1 .
@xmath74 for a prime number @xmath75 , the field @xmath1 does not contain a primitive root of unity of degree @xmath75 , and @xmath76 ; 2 .
@xmath69 and @xmath77 . in these cases
, we do not know how to express the silly filtration conjecture in terms of the graded algebra @xmath73 , nor do we know whether one should expect the milnor algebra @xmath73 to be koszul for any motivic reasons .
[ [ section-8 ] ] the main results of this paper are as follows . assuming the beilinson lichtenbaum conjecture , we prove that the exact category of mixed tate motives with coefficients in @xmath0 is equivalent to the category of filtered modules @xmath78 over @xmath0 with a discrete action of the galois group @xmath57 such that each quotient module @xmath79 is isomorphic to a direct sum of several copies of the cyclotomic module @xmath59 . furthermore , we show that if the field @xmath1 contains a primitive @xmath2-root of unity , then the @xmath8 spaces computed in this exact category are isomorphic to the higher @xmath46 spaces in the triangulated category of motives ( i. e. , are given by the beilinson
lichtenbaum formulas ) if and only if the galois cohomology algebra @xmath80 is koszul .
recall that it was proven in the paper @xcite that the milnor
kato conjecture claiming the isomorphism between the galois cohomology and the milnor k - theory algebra modulo @xmath2 follows from its low - degree part ( an isomorphism in degree @xmath81 and a monomorphism in degree @xmath82 ) provided that the milnor algebra is koszul for all algebraic extensions of a given field .
the result of this paper means that the koszulity conjecture together with the low - degree part of the milnor
kato conjecture is equivalent to the full milnor
kato conjecture together with the silly filtrations condition for the exact category of mixed tate motives .
[ [ section-9 ] ] as a generalization of mixed tate motives , one can consider mixed artin tate motives over a field @xmath1 .
these are the motives @xmath83 $ ] of finite field extensions @xmath84 , their tate twists @xmath83(i)$ ] , and any extensions of these .
let us choose a finite galois extension @xmath85 and restrict ourselves to the exact subcategory @xmath29 of @xmath3 formed by all the successive extensions of the objects @xmath83(i)$ ] with @xmath86 . our _ main conjecture _ about artin
tate motives claims that this exact subcategory satisfies the silly filtrations condition , i. e. , the groups @xmath8 in @xmath29 are isomorphic to the corresponding @xmath46 groups in the triangulated category of motives @xmath3 .
we show that in the above situations ( i iii ) this conjecture is equivalent to the koszulity condition on the algebra of diagonal @xmath46 @xmath87{,\medspace}{\bigoplus\nolimits}_l\!{\mskip .5\thinmuskip\relax}k[l](n)[n])\ ] ] between the artin tate objects @xmath83(i)$ ] with @xmath86 .
moreover , for any fields @xmath88 of characteristic prime to @xmath2 , the exact category @xmath29 of mixed artin tate motives with coefficients @xmath72 over @xmath1 is equivalent to the category @xmath89 of filtered discrete modules @xmath57-modules @xmath78 over @xmath0 such that for any @xmath90 the @xmath57-module @xmath79 is isomorphic to a finite direct sum of @xmath57-modules induced from the cyclotomic modules @xmath59 over open subgroups of @xmath57 containing @xmath91 . assuming the main conjecture , this provides a description of the triangulated subcategory of @xmath3 generated by @xmath83(i)$ ] as the bounded derived category of the exact category @xmath89 of filtered @xmath57-modules .
[ [ section-10 ] ] to end , let us say a few words about the koszulity condition that appears in connection with the artin
tate motives with finite coefficients .
the theory of koszul algebras as developed in @xcite applies to graded algebras @xmath92 such that @xmath93 is a semi - simple algebra .
it is not difficult to generalize it to nonnegatively graded rings @xmath94 with an arbitrary base ring @xmath93 , assuming that @xmath94 is a flat left or right graded
@xmath93-module @xcite .
however , the graded algebra we are interested in does not satisfy the latter assumption .
it turns out that the koszul property , just as the property of a nonnegatively graded ring to be quadratic , does not depend on the base ring in the zero - degree component . for the graded algebra @xmath94 from
, one can simply replace the component @xmath93 with @xmath95 in order to define @xmath94 to be koszul if the graded ring @xmath96 is koszul in the sense of @xcite ( if @xmath2 is a prime number ) or in the sense of @xcite ( in the general case ) .
such is the contribution that this paper makes to the general theory of koszul rings .
[ [ section-11 ] ] after a more than a decade - long effort , v. voevodsky , in collaboration with m. rost and others , have recently finished their work on a complete proof of the milnor bloch
kato conjecture @xcite .
their approach is entirely different from the one suggested in @xcite ; instead , it builds upon the ideas and techniques of a. merkurjev and a. suslin s proofs @xcite in degrees @xmath81 and @xmath82 .
a simplified , elementary exposition of the easy first step of their argument can be found in the present author s
paper @xcite .
our koszulity conjectures remain wide open .
[ [ section-12 ] ] the fairly simple homological formalism describing the situations [ introd - list - of - situations](i - ii ) for tate motives with coefficients in a field @xmath65 is presented in section 1 .
an almost equally simple situation [ introd - list - of - situations](iii ) for tate motives with coefficients in a finite field @xmath65 is partly treated in section 2 using the filtered bar construction .
we pass to the full generality starting from section 3 , where we describe the exact subcategory of mixed objects in a triangulated category with the @xmath46 groups given by beilinson
lichtenbaum formulas .
the construction of the associated graded category to a filtered exact category with a twist functor and related natural transformation is presented in section 4 .
the restriction - of - base construction underlying the claim that the koszul property does not depend on the base ring is introduced in section 5 .
these three sections form the technical heart of the paper .
we prove that the diagonal cohomology ring is quadratic , and any quadratic ring can be realized as the diagonal cohomology , in section 6 .
the koszul property of ( big ) graded rings in the general and the flat cases is studied in section 7 .
we digress to apply our techniques in order to generalize the results of @xcite and ( * ? ? ?
* section 5 ) in section 8 .
in particular , we obtain a koszulity - based sufficient condition for existence of silly filtrations with respect to an exact subcategory of a triangulated category .
the proofs of main results are finished and the conclusions discussed in section 9 . in particular , the silly filtration conjecture for artin - tate motives is formulated , and some remarks about tate motives with integral coefficients are included .
the purpose of appendix a is to supply preliminary material on exact categories complementary to the standard expositions .
it covers big graded rings , saturatedness conditions , various axioms and examples of exact categories , two canonical embeddings to abelian categories , the derived categories of exact categories , the yoneda @xmath8 , and exact subcategories of triangulated categories .
the formalism of silly filtrations is presented in appendix b , and the @xmath44-conjecture of bloch and kriz is discussed in appendix c. it is explained why these are two equivalent formulations of the same conjecture ; both the rational and the finite coefficients are considered .
the realization functor to a ( filtered ) triangulated category from the derived category of its exact subcategory is constructed in appendix d. the author is grateful to v. voevodsky and a. beilinson for posing the problem and for numerous very helpful conversations .
i would like also to thank p. deligne , s. bloch , v. retakh , a. goncharov , d. orlov , a. vishik , a. polishchuk , v. vologodsky , and m. bondarko for very helpful discussions .
this work was started when the author was visiting the mathematics department of harvard university on the invitation of d. kazhdan in the fall of 1994 , and most of it has been done when i was a graduate student at the same university in the subsequent years .
i am glad to use this opportunity to thank harvard for its hospitality .
these results were presented at the fall 1999 conference in oberwolfah , and i want to thank the mfo and the organizers of the conference for the invitation .
the author was supported by a grant from p. deligne 2004 balzan prize and an rfbr grant when developing the later final ideas of the paper and writing it up .
let @xmath6 be a triangulated category generated by a sequence of objects @xmath97 , @xmath90 satisfying the following conditions @xmath98 ) = 0 \quad\text{for all $ i > j$ and $ n\in{{\mathbb z}}$ ; } \\ & \operatorname{hom}_{{\mathcal d}}(e_i , e_i ) \quad\text{is a division ring for all $ i\in{{\mathbb z}}$. } \end{aligned}\ ] ] let @xmath13 be the minimal full subcategory of @xmath6 , containing the objects @xmath99 and closed under extensions ( see @xcite or [ exact - triangulated ] for the definition ) .
the following result is a generalization of a theorem of m. levine @xcite ( see also @xcite ) inspired by r. bezrukavnikov s paper @xcite .
the subcategory @xmath13 is the heart of a ( necessarily bounded ) t - structure on @xmath6 if and only if @xmath100)=0 $ ] for all @xmath22 , @xmath101 and @xmath102 and @xmath103 for all @xmath39 .
`` if '' : let @xmath104 denote the full subcategory of @xmath6 consisting of direct sums of objects @xmath99 . clearly , @xmath104 is a semisimple abelian category and one has @xmath15)=0 $ ] for @xmath102 and @xmath10 , @xmath105 .
it follows that @xmath104 is an admissible abelian subcategory of @xmath6 in the sense of ( * ? ? ?
* subsection 1.2 ) , hence by ( * ? ? ?
* subsections 1.3.1314 ) the subcategory @xmath13 is the heart of a bounded t - structure on @xmath6 .
the reader can find some additional details in ( * ? ? ? * lemma 3 ) .
`` only if '' : the condition of vanishing of @xmath15)$ ] for @xmath102 and @xmath10 , @xmath11 follows immediately from the definitions of a t - structure and its heart .
now let @xmath106 be a morphism of degree @xmath107 . by the conditions ,
@xmath108 if @xmath109 , so it remains to consider the case @xmath110 .
let @xmath111 denote the cone of the morphism @xmath112 .
by ( * ? ? ?
* thorme 1.3.6 ) , there exists a distinguished triangle @xmath113\rarrow c\rarrow y\rarrow x[2]$ ] with @xmath10 , @xmath11 .
let @xmath114 denote the full triangulated subcategory of @xmath6 generated by the object @xmath99 .
it follows easily from that there is a triangulated functor of `` successive quotients '' from @xmath6 to the cartesian product of the triangulated subcategories @xmath115 sending @xmath97 to @xmath116 ( see ( * ? ? ?
* sections 1 and 4 ) or ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 1.3.2 ) ) . applying this functor to the above triangle
, one can see that @xmath10 is naturally isomorphic to @xmath99 and @xmath117 is isomorphic to @xmath118 in @xmath6 .
the compositions @xmath119 and @xmath120\rarrow c\rarrow e_i[1]$ ] are the identity morphisms , hence @xmath108 .
one _ can not _ move the second condition in from the list of premises of theorem to the list of conditions in the right hand side of the equivalence . indeed
, there exists a triangulated category @xmath6 generated by a single object @xmath121 with @xmath122)=0 $ ] for @xmath123 such that the full subcategory @xmath7 whose only objects are @xmath124 and @xmath107 is the heart of a bounded t - structure on @xmath6 , and @xmath125 is not a division ring .
one simply takes @xmath13 to be the quotient category of the category of not more than countably dimensional vector spaces over a field @xmath65 by the serre subcategory of finite - dimensional vector spaces , and @xmath126 .
let @xmath65 be a field and @xmath6 be a @xmath65-linear triangulated category generated by a sequence of objects @xmath97 , @xmath90 satisfying the conditions @xmath127 ) = 0 & & \quad\text{for all $ i > j$ } & & \text{and $ n\in{{\mathbb z}}$ ; } \\ & \operatorname{hom}_{{\mathcal d}}(e_i , e_i[n ] ) = 0 & & \quad\text{for all $ i\in{{\mathbb z}}$ } & & \text{and $ n\ne 0 $ ; } \\ & \operatorname{hom}_{{\mathcal d}}(e_i , e_i ) = k & & \quad\text{for all $ i\in{{\mathbb z}}$. } \end{alignedat}\ ] ] furthermore , assume that @xmath97 satisty the equivalent conditions of theorem from [ t - existence ] .
in addition , suppose that a triangulated autoequivalence of the category @xmath6 , denoted by @xmath128 , is given together with isomorphisms @xmath129 .
the functor @xmath128 will be called the _ twist _ functor and its integral powers will be denoted by @xmath130 , @xmath101 .
since @xmath13 is the heart of a t - structure on @xmath6 , there are natural maps @xmath131)$ ] for all @xmath10 , @xmath11 and @xmath132 , where @xmath133 denotes the yoneda @xmath8 in the abelian category @xmath13 ( see [ exact - triangulated ] , or @xcite , or ( * ? ? ?
* subsection 4.0 ) ) .
these maps are compatible with the multiplicative structure on @xmath133 and @xmath134 . besides , they are always isomorphisms for @xmath31 and monomorphisms for @xmath135 ( * ? ? ?
* remark 3.1.17 )
. we will be interested in the question when all these maps are isomorphisms .
the results below in this section are essentially due to a. beilinson , v. ginzburg , and v. schechtman @xcite .
recall that a graded algebra @xmath136 over a field @xmath65 with @xmath137 is called _ quadratic _
@xcite if it is multiplicatively generated by @xmath138 with relations in degree @xmath81 . 1 . for the above abelian category @xmath13 , one has @xmath139 for @xmath41 .
2 . the graded algebra @xmath94 with the components @xmath140 ( and the multiplication defined in terms of the yoneda multiplication on the ext using the twist functor @xmath128 on the category @xmath13 ) is quadratic .
3 . for any quadratic
graded algebra @xmath94 over @xmath65 there exists a @xmath65-linear abelian category @xmath13 with a sequence of objects @xmath141 and a twist functor @xmath128 on @xmath13 such that @xmath129 , all the objects of @xmath13 can be obtained from @xmath99 as iterated extensions , the derived category @xmath126 with the objects @xmath97 satisfies the conditions and the diagonal ext algebra @xmath142 is isomorphic to the graded algebra @xmath94 .
moreover , for any quadratic algebra @xmath94 there exists a unique , up to a unique exact equivalence , preserving @xmath99 and the twist functor , abelian category @xmath13 in such that @xmath139 for all @xmath143 , @xmath31 or @xmath81 . under the conditions ,
the functor of `` successive quotients '' mentioned in the proof in [ t - existence ] becomes simply a triangulated functor from @xmath6 to the bounded derived category of finite - dimensional graded @xmath65-vector spaces sending @xmath99 to the vector space @xmath65 placed in the cohomological degree @xmath107 and the grading @xmath22 . restricting this functor to the category @xmath13 , one obtains an exact faithful functor from @xmath13 to the category of finite - dimensional graded @xmath65-vector spaces transforming the twist to the shift of grading .
according to ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 2.14 ) , one can identify @xmath13 with the category of finite - dimensional graded left comodules over a graded coalgebra @xmath111 over @xmath65 so that the object @xmath99 corresponds to a one - dimensional comodule @xmath65 placed in degree @xmath22 .
besides , @xmath13 is a mixed category in the sense of ( * ? ? ? * subsection 2.1.2 ) , the indices of the increasing filtration in @xcite being minus the indices @xmath22 of the objects @xmath99 .
it follows that @xmath111 is nonpositively graded with @xmath144 .
an explicit construction of the coalgebra @xmath111 can be found in ( * ? ? ?
* subsection 2.1.7 ) .
since any @xmath111-comodule is a union of its finite - dimensional subcomodules , the spaces @xmath8 computed in the categories of arbitrary graded @xmath111-comodules and finite - dimensional graded @xmath111-comodules coincide .
hence the spaces @xmath145 can be computed as the bigrading pieces of the reduced cobar - complex @xcite @xmath146 where @xmath147 .
this proves parts ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) of the proposition ( see ( * ? ? ?
* beginning of section 2 and proposition 2 ) ) . to verify uniqueness in ( 4 ) , notice that in the assumptions of ( 4 ) the coalgebra @xmath111 is quadratic by (
* proposition 1 ) , so it is uniquely determined by its quadratic dual algebra @xmath94 .
to prove existence in ( 3 ) and ( 4 ) , it suffices to set @xmath111 to be the coalgebra quadratic dual to @xmath94 and @xmath13 to be the category of finite - dimensional graded @xmath111-comodules .
consequently , if the natural maps @xmath148)$ ] are isomorphisms for all @xmath10 , @xmath11 and @xmath149 , then @xmath100)=0 $ ] for @xmath41 and the graded algebra @xmath94 with the components @xmath150)$ ] is quadratic .
conversely , any quadratic algebra @xmath94 can be realized in this way .
assume that @xmath100)=0 $ ] for @xmath143 .
then the maps @xmath131)$ ] are isomorphisms for all @xmath10 , @xmath11 and all @xmath149 if and only if the graded algebra @xmath94 is koszul ( see @xcite for the definition ) .
as it was explained in the proof of proposition , the spaces @xmath151 are isomorphic to the bigraded pieces of the cohomology of a nonpositively graded coalgebra @xmath111 .
now if @xmath152 for @xmath153 , then the coalgebra @xmath111 is koszul , so by ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 3 ) , the algebra @xmath94 is koszul , too .
this proves the `` only if '' part .
`` if '' : since the maps @xmath131)$ ] are injective for @xmath154 , one has @xmath152 for @xmath153 and @xmath31 or @xmath81 , so the coalgebra @xmath111 is quadratic .
since these maps are also bijective for @xmath31 , the morphism of graded algebras @xmath155 is an isomorphism in degree @xmath156 and a monomorphisms in degree @xmath81 .
if the algebra @xmath94 is quadratic , it follows from part ( 2 ) of proposition that this morphism is an isomorphism .
consequently , the algebra @xmath94 is quadratic dual to the coalgebra @xmath111 , and if @xmath94 is koszul , then @xmath111 is koszul , too .
therefore , the morphisms @xmath157)$ ] are isomorphisms for all @xmath22 , @xmath158 , and @xmath37 .
since all the objects of @xmath13 are successive extensions of the objects @xmath99 , we are done .
one can drop the condition that @xmath6 be linear over a field in the above proposition and theorem , replacing the condition @xmath159 with the condition that @xmath160 be a division ring , as in [ t - existence ] .
an even greater generality of arbitrary base ring is achieved in sections [ diagonal - secn][koszul - rings - secn ] by replacing abelian hearts with exact subcategories .
[ coalgebra - secn ] let @xmath111 be a coalgebra over a field @xmath65 and @xmath161 be a coaugmentation of @xmath111 ( i. e. , a morphism of coalgebras ) .
recall ( * ? ? ?
* subsection 3.1 ) that the _ coaugmentation filtration _ on @xmath111 is an increasing filtration defined by the rule @xmath162 where @xmath163 is the iterated comultiplication map and the map @xmath164 is induced by the cokernel @xmath165 of the coaugmentation morphism .
the coalgebra @xmath111 is called _ conilpotent _ if the filtration @xmath166 is exhaustive , i. e. , @xmath167 . for any coaugmented coalgebra @xmath111 , the subcoalgebra @xmath168 is the maximal conilpotent subcoalgebra of @xmath111 .
the coaugmentation morphism endows any vector space over @xmath65 with a structure of @xmath111-comodule , called the _ trivial _
@xmath111-comodule structure .
a finite - dimensional @xmath111-comodule is a comodule over @xmath169 if and only if it is a successive extension of copies of the trivial comodule @xmath65 over @xmath111 .
set @xmath170 .
consider the category @xmath89 of finite - dimensional left @xmath111-comodules @xmath171 endowed with a decreasing filtration @xmath166 compatible with the filtration @xmath166 on @xmath111 .
this is equivalent to the filtration @xmath166 on @xmath171 being a filtration by @xmath111-subcomodules such that all the quotient @xmath111-comodules @xmath79 have trivial @xmath111-comodule structures .
we also assume that @xmath172 for @xmath173 and @xmath174 for @xmath175 .
the category @xmath89 has a natural exact category structure in which a short sequence @xmath176 is exact if and only if the sequence of associated graded vector spaces @xmath177 is exact ( cf .
[ exact - cat - examples]@xmath178(5 ) ) .
notice that the category @xmath89 only depends on the subcoalgebra @xmath179 .
let @xmath104 denote the abelian category of finite - dimensional left @xmath111-comodules ; then there is an exact forgetful functor @xmath180 .
there is a twist functor @xmath128 on the category @xmath89 defined by the rule @xmath181 . for any object @xmath182 there is a natural morphism @xmath183 that is transformed to the identity endomorphism by the forgetful functor @xmath180 .
denote by @xmath184 the one - dimensional trivial @xmath111-comodule @xmath65 placed in the filtration component @xmath22 .
then @xmath185 and there are natural morphisms @xmath186 for all @xmath90 corresponding to the identity morphism @xmath187 .
let @xmath188 be the cohomology algebra of the coaugmented coalgebra @xmath111 ( see ( * ? ? ?
* subsection 1.1 ) ) and @xmath189 be the bounded derived category of @xmath89 ( see [ exact - derived ] or @xcite ) . 1 . the objects @xmath97
satisfy the conditions .
2 . one has @xmath190 for @xmath41 .
the graded @xmath65-algebra @xmath94 with the components @xmath191 is quadratic and isomorphic to the `` quadratic part '' @xmath192 of the graded algebra @xmath193 ( see ( * ? ? ? * subsection 2.1 ) for the definition ) .
3 . the morphisms @xmath194 induced by the functor @xmath180 are isomorphisms for all @xmath195 if and only if the graded @xmath65-algebra @xmath193 is koszul .
let @xmath196 be the category of ( possibly infinite - dimensional ) filtered @xmath111-comodules @xmath78 such that @xmath174 for @xmath175 and @xmath197 .
the filtration @xmath166 on @xmath171 is assumed to be compatible with the filtration @xmath166 on @xmath111 , so the successive quotients @xmath79 have trivial @xmath111-comodule structures
. then the embedding functor @xmath198 induces isomorphisms on the @xmath8 spaces .
indeed , for any objects @xmath182 and @xmath199 and an admissible epimorphism @xmath200 there exists an object @xmath201 and a morphism @xmath202 such that the composition @xmath203 is an admissible epimorphism .
the same applies to the embedding of the abelian category @xmath104 to the category @xmath204 of all @xmath111-comodules .
for any filtered vector space @xmath205 over @xmath65 the @xmath111-comodule @xmath206 with its filtration @xmath166 induced by the filtration @xmath166 on @xmath111 and the filtration on @xmath205 is an injective object of @xmath196 .
indeed , for any object @xmath207 the space @xmath208 is isomorphic to the space of filtration - preserving @xmath65-linear maps @xmath209 , and in the exact category of filtered vector spaces all exact sequences are split .
now consider the reduced cobar - resolution @xmath210 of the trivial @xmath111-comodule @xmath65 @xmath211 and endow it with a filtration @xmath166 induced by the filtration @xmath166 on @xmath111 .
the complex @xmath212 is an injective resolution of the object @xmath213 , since the associated graded complex is exact .
computing the @xmath8 spaces in @xmath196 in terms of this resolution , we obtain the isomorphisms @xmath214 where @xmath215 is the cobar - complex @xmath216 with its induced filtration @xmath166 .
similarly , @xmath217 .
this immediately proves part ( 1 ) and the first assertion of ( 2 ) . besides
, one can easily see that the algebra @xmath94 is quadratic dual to the quadratic part of the graded coalgebra @xmath218 ( cf .
* proposition 2 ) ) .
it is isomorphic to @xmath192 by ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 5.1 ) and ( * ? ? ?
* proof of main theorem ) .
so it remains to prove part ( 3 ) .
`` only if '' : if @xmath219 for all @xmath220 , then the quotient complex @xmath221 has no cohomology except in degree @xmath37 .
but the accociated graded complex @xmath222 is isomorphic to the cobar - complex of the graded coalgebra @xmath218 . if the latter has no cohomology outside of the diagonal @xmath223 , then the graded coalgebra @xmath218 is koszul and consequently the quadratic dual algebra @xmath94 is koszul , too .
`` if '' : if the algebra @xmath193 is koszul , then @xmath224 ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 5.3 ) and the graded coalgebra @xmath218 is koszul ( * ? ? ?
* proof of main theorem ) .
thus @xmath225 for all @xmath226 .
it follows by passing to the inductive limit in @xmath22 that @xmath227 for all @xmath220 . instead of using the results of (
* main theorem and its proof ) and ( * ? ? ?
* section 5 ) in the above argument , one can reprove and generalize these results using the methods developed in this paper , and particularly in section [ associated - graded - secn ] .
see section [ nonfiltered - secn ] .
[ filtered - exact - secn ] let @xmath6 be a triangulated category and @xmath228 , @xmath90 be full subcategories , closed under extensions and such that @xmath229)=0 $ for all $ x\in{{\mathcal e}}_i$ , \
$ y\in{{\mathcal e}}_j$ , } \begin{array}{ll } \text{$i$ , $ j\in{{\mathbb z}}$ } & \text{and $ n=-1 $ , } \\
\text{or $ i > j$ } & \text{and $ n=0 $ or~$1$. } \end{array}\ ] ] let @xmath104 be an exact category and @xmath230 be a triangulated functor mapping @xmath231 into @xmath104 .
assume that @xmath232)\rarrow \operatorname{ext}_{{\mathcal e}}^n(x , y)$ } \\
\text{are isomorphisms for all $ x\in{{\mathcal e}}_i$ , \
$ y\in{{\mathcal e}}_j$ , \
$ i < j$ , and $ n=0 $ or~$1 $ , } \\
\text{and monomorphisms for $ i+2\le j$ and $ n=2$. } \end{array}\ ] ] let @xmath29 be the minimal full subcategory of @xmath6 , containing all @xmath231 and closed under extensions . then both @xmath231 and @xmath29 have natural exact category structures ( see @xcite or [ exact - triangulated ] ) and the functors @xmath233 are exact .
let @xmath89 be the category whose objects are triples @xmath234 , where @xmath235 is a finitely filtered object of @xmath104 , @xmath236 is a finitely supported object of the cartesian product of @xmath231 , and @xmath237 is an isomorphism . here
a `` finitely filtered object '' @xmath78 is a sequence @xmath238 of objects of @xmath104 and admissible monomorphisms between them such that @xmath174 for @xmath175 and @xmath239 is an isomorphism for @xmath173 .
the ( stabilizing ) inductive limit of @xmath240 as @xmath241 is denoted by @xmath171 .
the object @xmath242 is the collection of objects @xmath243 . a `` finitely supported object ''
@xmath244 is a collection of objects @xmath245 such that @xmath246 for all but a finite number of indices @xmath22 .
the object @xmath247 is the collection of objects @xmath248 .
the category @xmath89 has a natural exact category structure in which a short sequence with a zero composition is exact if the related sequence of graded objects @xmath236 is exact in the cartesian product of @xmath231 , i. e. , exact in each @xmath22 ( cf .
[ exact - cat - examples]@xmath178(4 - 5 ) ) . the exact category @xmath231 is equivalent to the full exact subcategory of @xmath89 consisting of all the triples @xmath234 such that @xmath249 for all @xmath250 . 1 . in the above situation , the exact categories @xmath29 and @xmath89 are naturally equivalent
conversely , given any exact categories @xmath104 and @xmath231 and exact functors @xmath251 , construct the exact category @xmath89 by the above procedure .
set @xmath189 .
then the subcategories @xmath252 and the functor @xmath230 induced by the forgetful functor @xmath180 satisfy the conditions . moreover
, the second assertion of holds for all @xmath110 and @xmath135 .
since the natural morphisms @xmath253 ) , \quad \text{$x$ , $ y\in{{\mathcal m}}$ , \ $ n\ge0$}\ ] ] ( see [ exact - triangulated ] ) are isomorphisms for @xmath38 or @xmath156 , by one has @xmath254 for @xmath255 , @xmath256 , @xmath109 , and @xmath38 or @xmath156 . using associativity of extensions in exact categories ( associativity of the `` @xmath257-operation '' ; cf .
* lemma 1.3.10 ) where this is done for triangulated categories ) , one can deduce from this vanishing of @xmath258 that any object of @xmath29 has a finite decreasing filtration with successive quotients in @xmath231 .
it follows from the vanishing of @xmath259 that such filtrations are unique and preserved by all the morphisms in @xmath29 .
one can also see that a short sequence with zero composition in @xmath89 is exact if and only if its short sequence of successive quotients is exact in the cartesian product of @xmath231 .
applying the functor @xmath260 to the above filtration on an object of @xmath29 , one obtains a filtered object of @xmath104 .
this defines the desired functor @xmath261 . to prove that it is an equivalence of exact categories
, one can use the following lemma .
let @xmath262 be an exact functor between exact categories and @xmath263 be a class of objects such that every object of @xmath13 can be obtained from objects of @xmath264 by successive extensions and every object of @xmath26 can be obtained from objects of @xmath265 in the same way .
then if the maps @xmath266 are isomorphisms for all @xmath10 , @xmath267 and @xmath38 or @xmath156 and monomorphisms for all @xmath10 , @xmath267 and @xmath135 , then the functor @xmath268 is an equivalence of exact categories .
using the five - lemma and induction on the number of subquotients in an iterated extension , one can show that the functor @xmath268 induces isomorphisms on @xmath269 for @xmath38 and @xmath156 .
this implies the assertion of lemma .
let us check that the conditions of lemma are satisfied for the functor @xmath261 and the class of objects @xmath270 .
let @xmath255 and @xmath256 . for @xmath109 , one has @xmath271 for any @xmath37 , because the natural decreasing filtrations on objects of @xmath29 and @xmath89 split any such extensions . for @xmath272 ,
one has @xmath273 for any @xmath37 , due to the same natural filtrations .
it remains to consider the case @xmath110 . for @xmath38 or @xmath156 , by [ exact - triangulated ] and
the natural maps @xmath274)\rarrow\operatorname{ext}^n_{{\mathcal e}}(x , y)$ ] are isomorphisms .
it is straightforward to check that the natural maps @xmath275 are isomorphisms , too . for @xmath38 ,
this is so because any morphism @xmath276 in @xmath104 is compatible with the filtrations on @xmath277 and @xmath278 , while any morphism between @xmath10 and @xmath117 considered as objects of the cartesian product of @xmath231 is zero . for @xmath31 , it suffices to say that any extension of @xmath277 and @xmath278 in @xmath104 determines an object of @xmath89 , which becomes an extension of @xmath10 and @xmath117 in @xmath89 .
it follows from what we have proven so far that the full exact subcategories consisting of extensions of objects from @xmath231 and @xmath279 in @xmath29 and @xmath89 are equivalent for any @xmath22 .
indeed , bijectivity on @xmath259 and injectivity on @xmath258 between the generating objects suffice to conclude that the functor is fully faithful ( see the proof of lemma ) , and then surjectivity on @xmath280 for @xmath255 , @xmath281 implies surjectivity of the functor on the objects .
the exact category structures on the two categories are the same , since in each of them a triple with zero composition is exact if and only if its triple of successive quotients is exact in @xmath282 .
consequently , the map @xmath283 is an isomorphism for @xmath284 .
finally , for @xmath285 by [ exact - triangulated ] and the natural maps @xmath286)\rarrow\operatorname{ext}^2_{{\mathcal e}}(x , y)$ ] are monomorphisms and they form a commutative square with the maps @xmath287 , hence the map @xmath288 is a monomorphism . we have already explained why @xmath289 for all @xmath109 and @xmath149 and why @xmath290 for all @xmath110 and @xmath38 or @xmath156 .
let us show that the map @xmath291 is injective for all @xmath110 . denote by @xmath292}$ ] the minimal full subcategory of @xmath89 containing @xmath293 , @xmath294 , and closed under extensions .
the notation @xmath295}$ ] and @xmath296 has the similar meaning .
any object of @xmath201 can be presented as an extension of an object @xmath297}$ ] and an object @xmath298 in a unique and functorial way .
suppose that a class in @xmath299 is presented as the product of two classes in @xmath300 and @xmath301 .
consider the exact triple @xmath302 .
since @xmath303 , our class in @xmath300 comes from a class in @xmath304 , so we can replace @xmath305 with @xmath306 .
analogously , one can replace @xmath305 with @xmath307 , so as to get @xmath308}$ ] .
now suppose that our class in @xmath299 is annihilated by the forgetful functor @xmath309 .
let our classes in @xmath300 and @xmath301 be presented by exact triples @xmath310 and @xmath311 in @xmath89 , so our class in @xmath299 is presented by the yoneda extension @xmath312 .
so the yoneda extension @xmath313 in @xmath104 is trivial .
this means that the morphism @xmath314 can be presented as a composition @xmath315 in such a way that the triples @xmath316 and @xmath317 are exact in @xmath104 ( see corollary [ exact - derived].3 ) .
define a decreasing filtration on @xmath318 by setting @xmath319 and @xmath320 for all @xmath321 , where the filtration @xmath166 on @xmath322 is a part of the data constituting the object @xmath323 .
the morphisms @xmath324 are admissible monomorphisms with the successive quotients @xmath325 , @xmath326 for @xmath327 , and @xmath328 .
this allows to lift @xmath318 to an object @xmath329 in @xmath89 so that the morphism @xmath330 factorizes as @xmath331 and the triples @xmath332 and @xmath333 are exact .
thus our class in @xmath334 vanishes .
[ associated - graded - secn ] let @xmath89 be a small exact category endowed with a sequence of full subcategories @xmath335 , @xmath90 .
assume that each subcategory @xmath231 is closed under extensions and every object of @xmath89 can be obtained as a successive extension of objects from @xmath231 .
moreover , assume that @xmath336 furthermore , suppose that a twist functor @xmath128 is defined on @xmath89 such that it is an autoequivalence of @xmath89 as an exact category and @xmath337 .
finally , suppose that a natural transformation @xmath338 is defined for all @xmath182 and @xmath339 for all @xmath10 .
assume that @xmath340 it follows from ( see the beginning of subsection [ proof - part - one ] ) that there is an exact functor of `` successive quotients '' @xmath341 .
let us require that @xmath342 it follows by induction on the number of subquotients in an iterated extension from and the first equation in that such a factorization is unique if it exists , i. e. , the morphisms @xmath343 are surjective and injective ( see [ additive - categories ] ) .
let @xmath104 and @xmath344 be exact categories and @xmath345 be a fully faithful exact functor ( so the image of an exact triple under @xmath346 must be an exact triple , but the converse is not required ) .
set @xmath347 and @xmath348 for all @xmath90 and consider the exact category @xmath89 of finitely filtered objects in @xmath104 with subquotients lifted to @xmath231 as constructed in section [ filtered - exact - secn ] .
identify each @xmath231 with the full exact subcategory of @xmath89 consisting of all the triples @xmath234 such that @xmath249 for @xmath250 .
let the twist functor @xmath128 on @xmath89 be defined by @xmath181 , @xmath349 , and the morphism @xmath343 be acting by the identity on @xmath171 and by zero on @xmath350 .
then all the conditions ( [ exact - filtered - eqn][nat - transf - factorize ] ) are satisfied . in particular , given a coaugmented coalgebra @xmath111 over a field @xmath65 one can take @xmath104 to be the abelian category of left @xmath111-comodules , @xmath344 to be the abelian category of finite - dimensional @xmath65-vector spaces , and @xmath346 to be the functor endowing a vector space with the trivial @xmath111-comodule structure .
then the category @xmath89 from the above example coincides with the category @xmath89 from section [ coalgebra - secn ] .
more generally , given a coalgebra @xmath111 over @xmath65 endowed with an increasing filtration @xmath351 compatible with the comultiplication , one can consider the exact category @xmath89 of finite - dimensional filtered @xmath111-comodules .
this category @xmath89 also satisfies ( [ exact - filtered - eqn][nat - transf - factorize ] ) .
together with the latter category , one can consider the category @xmath352 of finite - dimensional graded comodules over the graded coalgebra @xmath218
. then there will be the exact functor of associated graded comodule @xmath353 .
our goal in this section is to extend this construction to arbitrary exact categories @xmath89 satisfying the conditions ( [ exact - filtered - eqn][nat - transf - factorize ] ) .
so we would like to assign to such a category @xmath89 an exact category @xmath352 with the following properties .
the exact category @xmath352 should be endowed with a sequence of full exact subcategories @xmath231 , @xmath90 .
each subcategory @xmath231 should be closed under extensions and every object of @xmath352 should be an iterated extension of objects from @xmath231 .
furthermore , one should have @xmath354 finally , an autoequivalence of the exact category @xmath352 , denoted by @xmath128 , should be defined so that @xmath337 . the categories @xmath89 and
@xmath352 should be related in the following way .
there should be an exact functor @xmath355 mapping each @xmath356 to @xmath357 and defining an equivalence between these exact categories .
the functor @xmath358 should be compatible with the twist functors @xmath128 on @xmath89 and @xmath352 . and
most importantly , for any objects @xmath10 , @xmath359 there should be a functorial long exact sequence @xmath360 there is a construction assigning to any small exact category @xmath89 with the additional data satisfying a small exact category @xmath352 with the additional data and an exact functor @xmath355 satisfying .
the proof of theorem occupies the rest of this section .
consider the category @xmath361 whose objects are diagrams of the form @xmath362 where @xmath363 , @xmath364 , the rightmost map is obtained by applying the twist functor @xmath128 to the leftmost map , the compositions @xmath365 and @xmath366 are equal to the morphisms @xmath367 and @xmath368 , and the induced sequence @xmath369 is exact ( see [ exact - derived ] ) in @xmath370 .
let @xmath371 be the functor assigning to a diagram @xmath372 the object @xmath373 .
let @xmath374 denote the ideal of morphisms in @xmath361 annihilated by @xmath375 , and let @xmath376 be the quotient category .
let @xmath377 be the class of morphisms in @xmath378 that the functor @xmath375 sends to isomorphisms .
our first aim is to show that the class @xmath379 is localizing ( i. e. , satisfies the ore conditions ) .
it is clear that if any two morphisms @xmath380 in @xmath376 have equal compositions with a morphism @xmath381 or @xmath382 belonging to @xmath377 , then these two morphisms @xmath380 are equal .
let @xmath383 be two morphisms in @xmath361 such that the morphism @xmath384 is an admissible epimorphism in @xmath370 .
then the morphism @xmath385 is an admissible epimorphism in @xmath89 .
indeed , it suffices to check that the morphism @xmath386 is an admissible epimorphism , since an extension of admissible epimorphisms is always an admissible epimorphism .
consider the fibered product @xmath387 in @xmath89 ( see axiom ex@xmath388 in [ axioms ] ) .
let the map @xmath389 be defined as the composition @xmath390 and the map @xmath391 be induced by the maps @xmath200 , @xmath392 , @xmath393 , and minus the map @xmath394 .
then the diagram @xmath395 is an object of the category @xmath361 .
there are natural morphisms from this object to the objects @xmath396 and @xmath372 ; the square diagram formed by these two morphisms and the morphisms @xmath383 is commutative modulo @xmath374 .
the object @xmath397 is the fibered product of @xmath398 and @xmath399 over @xmath400 . in particular ,
if the morphism @xmath401 belongs to @xmath377 , then so does the morphism @xmath402 .
this proves a half of the ore conditions ; the dual half is proved in the dual way .
the category of diagrams @xmath372 is perhaps best viewed as a dg - category , and even an exact dg - category in the sense of ( * ? ? ?
* remark 3.5 ) ; its full subcategory @xmath361 of all diagrams satisfying the exactness condition can be then considered as its full exact dg - subcategory .
very roughly , the natural transformation @xmath403 plays the role of a ( central ) curvature element in a ( purely even ) `` cdg - ring '' @xmath89 .
it would be interesting to know whether one can use some derived category of the second kind of this exact dg - category in order to approach the following problem . how to construct the exact quotient category @xmath404 given only a twist functor @xmath128 and a natural transformation @xmath338 on an exact category @xmath89 , satisfying some reasonable conditions ( e. g. , that the morphisms @xmath343 be injective and surjective ) ?
the category @xmath352 is defined as the localization @xmath405 $ ]
. set a short sequence in @xmath352 to be exact if its image under the functor @xmath375 is exact .
let us check that this defines an exact category structure on @xmath352 .
consider a morphism @xmath112 in @xmath352 whose image under @xmath375 is an admissible epimorphism .
it is clear that such a morphism is surjective in @xmath352 .
represent @xmath112 by a morphism @xmath406 in @xmath361 and apply the construction from [ graded - category - construction ] to the pair of morphisms @xmath407 .
we obtain a morphism @xmath408 in @xmath361 whose image @xmath409 in @xmath352 completes the morphism @xmath112 to an exact triple .
let us check that the morphism @xmath409 is the kernel of @xmath112 .
any morphism with the target @xmath372 in @xmath352 can be represented by a morphism @xmath410 in @xmath361 .
assume that the composition @xmath411 is annihilated by @xmath375 .
then it follows from that the morphism @xmath412 factorizes through @xmath413 , since the composition @xmath414 is annihilated by @xmath415 .
this allows to lift the morphism @xmath416 to a morphism @xmath417 in @xmath361 .
finally , suppose that we are given an exact triple in @xmath352 ; it can be represented by a short sequence @xmath418 in @xmath361 .
any morphism with the target @xmath419 in @xmath352 can be represented by a morphism @xmath420 in @xmath361 . applying the construction of [ graded - category - construction ] again , we obtain an object @xmath421 in @xmath361 together with natural morphisms from it to @xmath396 and @xmath372 . just as above
, one can construct a morphism @xmath422 in @xmath361 and the triple @xmath423 is exact in @xmath352 .
these observations together with their dual versions suffice to check that @xmath352 satisfies the exact category axioms ex0 - -ex3 from [ axioms ] .
the functor @xmath355 assigns to an object @xmath10 the diagram @xmath424 ; it is obviously exact .
the twist functor @xmath425 on @xmath352 is induced by the twist functor @xmath426 on
the exact subcategory @xmath357 consists of all objects @xmath305 such that the graded object @xmath427 is concentrated in the grading @xmath428 .
one can construct a filtration @xmath429 on an object @xmath430 with successive quotients in @xmath231 by the rules @xmath431 or , equivalently , @xmath432 ; see subsection [ proof - part - two ] for the notation @xmath433 . using this filtration , one can easily check that the functor @xmath358 induces equivalences between the exact subcategories @xmath231 in @xmath89 and @xmath352 and the exact category @xmath352 satisfies .
the following lemmas will be needed in the remaining part of the proof .
let @xmath262 be an exact functor between exact categories such that for any admissible epimophism @xmath434 in @xmath26 there exist an admissible epimorphism @xmath435 in @xmath13 and a morphism @xmath436 in @xmath26 making the triangle @xmath437 commute .
let @xmath438 be a class in @xmath439 and @xmath440 be a class in @xmath441 such that @xmath442 and @xmath443 .
then there exist a morphism @xmath444 in @xmath13 and a class @xmath445 such that @xmath446 and @xmath447
. we will be mostly interested in the case @xmath448 ; however , in section [ base - restriction - secn ] we will also use the case @xmath31 .
let us start with some general remarks . by proposition [ exact - derived ] , a yoneda extension @xmath449 in an exact category @xmath104 is trivial if and only if there exists a yoneda extension @xmath450 mapping both to the extension @xmath449 and to the trivial extension @xmath451 .
the latter condition simply means that the admissible monomorphism @xmath452 splits .
furthermore , one can make the morphisms @xmath453 admissible epimorphisms by replacing @xmath454 with @xmath455 for @xmath456 , @xmath457 with @xmath458 , and @xmath459 with @xmath460 .
now we apply these observations to the case of the yoneda extension @xmath461 obtained by composing an extension representing @xmath440 with the image under @xmath268 of an extension representing @xmath438 .
an extension @xmath462 maps both to this composition and to the trivial extension , and moreover , the maps @xmath463 are admissible epimorphisms . using the assumption of lemma and decreasing induction on @xmath158 , one can construct admissible epimorphisms @xmath464 forming a map of yoneda extensions @xmath465 whose image under @xmath268 factorizes through the map of yoneda extensions @xmath466 .
this provides the desired morphism @xmath467 and class @xmath468 .
notice that we have obtained slightly more than we wanted : the assertion of lemma does not require the map @xmath112 to be an admissible epimorphism .
however , applying the assumption of lemma to construct an admissible epimorphism @xmath469 provides a way to obtain an admissible epimorphism @xmath470 together with a morphism @xmath469 in the category @xmath13 that we really need .
recall the definition of a _ big graded ring _ from [ big - graded - rings ] .
the next lemma can be viewed as a module version of corollary [ exact - triangulated].1 .
let @xmath262 be an exact functor between small exact categories satisfying the assumptions of lemma 1 .
then for any object @xmath471 the right graded module @xmath472 over the big graded ring @xmath473 over the set of all objects of @xmath13 is induced from the right module @xmath474 over the big subring @xmath475 .
there is an obvious natural map @xmath476 it is surjective , since for any class @xmath477 there exist a class @xmath478 and a morphism @xmath479 in @xmath26 such that @xmath480 .
one shows this using the assumption of lemmas 12 in a way similar to ( and simpler than ) that of the proof of lemma 1 .
since the category @xmath13 admits finite direct sums , in order to check injectivity it suffices to show that for any class @xmath478 and morphism @xmath479 in @xmath26 such that @xmath481 and @xmath33 there exists a morphism @xmath482 in @xmath13 and a morphism @xmath483 in @xmath26 such that @xmath484 and @xmath485 .
let us first consider the case @xmath31 .
present the class @xmath486 by an extension @xmath487 ; then the equation @xmath481 means that the morphism @xmath409 factorizes through the morphism @xmath488 .
so it suffices to take the admissible monomorphism @xmath489 as @xmath490 .
now we return to the general case @xmath33 .
present the class @xmath486 as the composition of a class @xmath491 and a class @xmath492 .
set @xmath493 ; then we have @xmath442 . by lemma 1
, there exists a morphism @xmath494 in @xmath13 and a class @xmath495 such that @xmath446 and @xmath447 .
set @xmath496 ; then we have @xmath497 .
consequently , there exists a morphism @xmath482 in @xmath13 and a morphism @xmath498 in @xmath26 such that @xmath484 and @xmath499 .
then @xmath500 .
it remains to obtain the long exact sequence ; we start with constructing the boundary map @xmath501 for all @xmath10 , @xmath359 and @xmath132 .
clearly , any object @xmath372 in @xmath352 is the target of an admissible epimorphism @xmath502 ; analogously , @xmath372 is the source of an admissible monomorphism into the object @xmath503 .
moreover , any admissible epimorphism @xmath504 in @xmath352 can be represented by a morphism @xmath505 in @xmath361 , hence there are admissible epimorphisms @xmath506 in @xmath89 and @xmath507 in @xmath352 such that the triangle @xmath508 commutes .
so the exact functor @xmath355 satisfies the assumption of lemmas 12 of [ two - lemmas ] . to construct the image of a morphism @xmath509 under the homomorphism @xmath510 , choose an admissible epimorphism @xmath381 and a morphism @xmath511 in @xmath89 such that the triangle @xmath512 commutes in @xmath352 .
let @xmath1 be the kernel of the admissible epimorphism @xmath381 ; then the composition @xmath513 is annihilated by the functor @xmath358 , and consequently factorizes through the morphism @xmath514 .
the morphism @xmath515 that we have obtained induces from the exact triple @xmath513 the desired extension of @xmath117 and @xmath516 in @xmath89 . alternatively , choose an admissible monomorphism @xmath382 and a morphism @xmath517 in @xmath89 such that the triangle @xmath518 commutes in @xmath352 .
let @xmath111 be the cokernel of the admissible monomorphism @xmath382 ; then the composition @xmath519 is annihilated by the functor @xmath358 , so we obtain a morphism @xmath520 .
this morphism induces from the extension @xmath521 an extension of @xmath522 and @xmath117 in @xmath89 .
let us show that the two extensions that we have obtained only differ by ( a twist and ) the minus sign .
the difference of the compositions @xmath523 and @xmath524 is annihilated by the functor @xmath358 , so there is a morphism @xmath525 in @xmath89 . together with the exact triples @xmath526 and @xmath521 and the morphisms @xmath515 and @xmath527 , this morphism forms a diagram in which one square commutes and the other one anticommutes .
it follows immediately that the map @xmath528 given by either of the above two rules is a well - defined homomorphism of bimodules over the big ring @xmath529 over the set @xmath530 of all objects of @xmath89 . by lemma 2 of [ two - lemmas ] and its dual version , the bimodule @xmath531 over the big graded ring @xmath532 over @xmath530 considered as either a left or right module is induced from its zero grading component @xmath533 as a module over the zero grading component @xmath534 of the big graded ring .
we want our maps @xmath535 to satisfy the equations @xmath536 and @xmath537 for any @xmath8 classes @xmath438 and @xmath486 of the degrees @xmath538 and @xmath539 in the exact category @xmath89 and any @xmath540 .
either of these two equations defines the sequence of maps @xmath541 uniquely , and one only has to check that the two conditions are compatible .
it suffices to check this for a class in @xmath542 decomposed into the product of a class in @xmath543 and an element in @xmath544 and also into the product of a class in @xmath545 and an element in @xmath546 .
we have two exact triples @xmath547 and @xmath548 in @xmath89 and a morphism of exact triples @xmath549 in @xmath352 .
choose an admissible epimorphism @xmath381 in @xmath89 such that the composition @xmath550 comes from a morphism @xmath551 in @xmath89 .
denote by @xmath552 the fibered product of @xmath318 and @xmath553 over @xmath10 .
choose an admissible epimorphism @xmath554 such that the composition @xmath555 comes from a morphism @xmath556 in @xmath89 .
consider the difference of the compositions @xmath557 and @xmath558 .
it is annihilated by the functor @xmath358 , and consequently factorizes through the morphism @xmath559 ; hence we get a morphism @xmath560 .
denote by @xmath561 the fibered product of @xmath562 and @xmath563 over @xmath564 .
define the morphism @xmath565 as the composition @xmath566 and the morphism @xmath567 as the sum of the compositions @xmath568 and @xmath569 .
then the square formed by the morphisms @xmath570 and @xmath571 is commutative , as is the triangle @xmath572 .
let @xmath573 be the kernel of the admissible epimorphism @xmath565 .
then there is an admissible epimorphism of exact triples @xmath574 and a morphism of exact triples @xmath575 whose images in @xmath352 form a commutative triangle with the morphism of exact triples @xmath549 .
let @xmath576 be the kernel of the admissible epimorphism @xmath574 .
then the morphism of exact triples @xmath577 is annihilated by the functor @xmath358 , so there is a morphism of exact triples @xmath578 . consider the extension of exact triples @xmath548 and @xmath576 and induce an extension of the exact triples @xmath548 and @xmath579 using the above morphism . we have obtained a commutative @xmath580 square formed by exact triples . for any such square ,
the two @xmath581 classes between the objects at the opposite vertices obtained by composing the @xmath258 classes along the perimeter differ by the minus sign .
this proves the desired equation in @xmath334 .
checking that the long sequence is a complex is easy .
we will start with proving exactness of the segment @xmath582 we have already explained in [ graded - category - posing ] that exactness at the term @xmath583 follows from the conditions ( [ exact - filtered - eqn][nat - transf - iso ] ) .
exactness at the term @xmath584 is provided by the condition .
let us prove exactness at the term @xmath585 .
suppose we are given a morphism @xmath509 , an admissible epimorphism @xmath381 , and a morphism @xmath511 such that the triangle @xmath512 commutes .
let @xmath1 be the kernel of the morphism @xmath586 and the composition @xmath513 be factorized as @xmath587 .
assume that the extension induced from the extension @xmath513 using the morphism @xmath515 splits .
then the morphism @xmath515 factorizes through the morphism @xmath588 , so there is a morphism @xmath589 .
subtracting from the morphism @xmath511 the composition @xmath590 we obtain a new morphism @xmath511 that annihilates @xmath1 .
hence this morphism factorizes through the admissible epimorphism @xmath381 , providing the desired morphism @xmath586 .
let us check exactness at the term @xmath591 .
suppose we are given an extension @xmath592 such that the morphism @xmath593 factorizes through the admissible monomorphism @xmath594 .
then we have a morphism @xmath202 , and the induced morphism @xmath595 annihilates the admissible monomorphism @xmath596 .
consequently , the morphism @xmath595 factorizes through the admissible epimorphism @xmath597 , providing a morphism @xmath598 . by the definition ,
the class of our extension @xmath599 is equal to @xmath600 .
let us prove exactness at the term @xmath601 .
suppose that an exact triple @xmath487 becomes split after the functor @xmath358 is applied to it .
then there exists a splitting morphism @xmath602 .
consequently , there exist an admissible epimorphism @xmath603 and a morphism @xmath604 such that the composition @xmath605 is the sum of @xmath112 and a morphism annihilated by @xmath358 , while the composition @xmath606 is also annihilated by @xmath358 .
let @xmath607 be the sum of the morphism @xmath112 and the composition @xmath608 .
then @xmath409 is also an admissible epimorphism , since @xmath609 is ; and the composition @xmath610 is also annihilated by @xmath358 , since @xmath611 . now
our exact triple @xmath487 is induced from the exact triple @xmath612 by a morphism @xmath613 annihilated by @xmath358 .
since the latter map factorizes through @xmath593 , we are done .
exactness at the further terms can be deduced from the exactness in this initial segment using lemma 1 of [ two - lemmas ] applied to the functors @xmath614 and @xmath355 .
[ base - restriction - secn ] let @xmath352 be an exact category endowed with a sequence of full subcategories @xmath231 , @xmath90 . assume that each subcategory @xmath231 is closed under extensions and every object of @xmath352 is an iterated extension of objects from @xmath231 .
furthermore , assume that @xmath615 finally , assume that the groups @xmath46 and @xmath258 in the category @xmath352 satisfy the conditions .
let @xmath616 be additive categories and @xmath617 be additive functors such that @xmath618 let @xmath361 denote the category whose objects are the triples @xmath619 , where @xmath620 is a finitely supported graded object , @xmath10 is an object of @xmath352 , and @xmath621 is an isomorphism in @xmath370 ( cf . section [ filtered - exact - secn ] ) , where @xmath415 denotes the functor of `` successive quotients '' @xmath622 ( see subsection [ graded - category - posing ] ) and @xmath623 .
the category @xmath361 has an exact category structure in which a short sequence is exact if the related sequence of graded objects @xmath350 is split exact .
the additive categories @xmath616 can be considered as the full subcategories of @xmath361 consisting of all the triples @xmath619 such that @xmath249 for @xmath250 .
then the exact category @xmath361 with the full subcategories @xmath616 satisfies all the above conditions and imposed on the exact category @xmath352 with the full subcategories @xmath231
. there is the natural ( forgetful ) exact functor @xmath624 .
let @xmath625 be a morphism of rings , @xmath104 be the category of finitely generated projective left @xmath626-modules , @xmath13 be the category of finitely generated projective left @xmath627-modules , and @xmath628 be the functor of extension of scalars , @xmath629 .
then the functor @xmath630 satisfies .
the homomorphism @xmath631 induced by the functor @xmath632 are 1 .
epimorphisms for all @xmath633 and @xmath10 , @xmath634 ; 2 .
isomorphisms for @xmath31 and @xmath10 , @xmath634 , if the graded objects @xmath635 and @xmath636 are supported in disjoint sets of indices @xmath22 ; 3 .
isomorphisms for all @xmath17 and @xmath10 , @xmath634 .
let @xmath637 be the additive category obtained by adjoining to @xmath616 the images of those idemponent endomorphisms @xmath638 for which the image of @xmath639 exists in @xmath231 .
then the functor @xmath617 factorizes through the embedding @xmath640 , so there is an additive functor @xmath641 . according to , the functors @xmath642
are surjective on the isomorphism classes of objects .
the same construction as above provides the exact category @xmath643 with the full subcategories @xmath637 , the embedding of exact categories @xmath644 , and the exact functor @xmath645 .
the full exact subcategory @xmath361 is closed under extensions in @xmath643 and all objects of the exact category @xmath643 are direct summands of certain objects of @xmath361 , hence the embedding @xmath644 induces isomorphisms on @xmath646 for all @xmath149 and @xmath10 , @xmath634 ( see corollary [ exact - triangulated].3 ) .
this reduces the problem to the case when the additive functors @xmath647 are surjective on the isomorphism classes of objects , which we will assume in the sequel .
this part of the argument does not depend on the assumption that the exact category structures on @xmath616 and @xmath231 are trivial .
conversely , given an exact category @xmath352 with full subcategories @xmath231 as above , the exact category @xmath648 with the full subcategories @xmath649 ( see [ additive - categories ] ) satisfies the same conditions that we have imposed on @xmath352 and @xmath231 . applying the above construction to the exact category @xmath650 and the additive functors @xmath651 , one can recover the original exact category @xmath352 with the full subcategories @xmath231 .
part ( 1 ) : notice that the functor @xmath632 is surjective on the isomorphism classes of objects .
so it suffices to prove that the map of the @xmath8 groups is surjective for @xmath31 .
suppose that we are given an exact triple @xmath652 in @xmath352 .
consider the related split exact triple @xmath653 in @xmath370 . choosing a splitting
, one can identify @xmath654 with @xmath655 .
this defines a lifting of the object @xmath656 to an object @xmath657 and of the exact triple @xmath658 to an exact triple @xmath487 in @xmath361 .
part ( 2 ) is obvious , since in its assumptions any splitting of the exact triple @xmath659 is simultaneously a splitting of the exact triple @xmath487 .
it follows from surjectivity on @xmath258 by means of the five - lemma and induction on the number of iterated extensions that it suffices to check injectivity on @xmath581 in the case when @xmath660 and @xmath661 for some @xmath22 , @xmath101 .
present our class in @xmath662 as the composition of some classes in @xmath663 and @xmath664 .
it was explained in subsection [ proof - part - two ] that one can choose @xmath665}$ ] ; since we now assume the exact category structures on @xmath616 to be trivial , one can actually choose @xmath666}$ ] , for the same reason .
let these classes @xmath258 be presented by exact triples @xmath667 and @xmath310 . the class @xmath668 represented by
the yoneda extension @xmath669 is trivial if and only if one can decompose the morphism @xmath670 as @xmath671 in such a way that the triples @xmath672 and @xmath673 are exact ( see corollary [ exact - derived].3 ) . in this case one
has @xmath674 , @xmath675 for @xmath327 , and @xmath676 ( see section [ associated - graded - secn ] for the notation @xmath677 ; cf .
[ proof - part - two ] ) .
this allows to lift the object @xmath656 to an object @xmath678 in such a way that the diagram remains commutative and the triples remain exact
. then the original class in @xmath662 is also trivial .
finally , let us prove injectivity on @xmath269 for @xmath679 using injectivity on @xmath680 .
notice that the functor @xmath681 satisfies the assumption of lemma 1 from subsection [ two - lemmas ] .
indeed , for any admissible epimorphism @xmath682 in @xmath352 one can lift the object @xmath318 to an object @xmath678 in such a way that the morphism @xmath682 lifts to an admissible epimorphism @xmath683 in @xmath361 . now consider a class in @xmath684 and decompose it into the product of classes in @xmath663 and @xmath685 .
assume that the product of the images of these classes in @xmath686 and @xmath687 vanishes .
by the mentioned lemma , there exists a morphism @xmath688 in @xmath361 such that the class in @xmath663 comes from a class in @xmath689 and the composition of the morphism @xmath690 in @xmath352 with the class in @xmath687 vanishes .
since the map @xmath691 is injective , it follows that the composition of the morphism @xmath688 in @xmath361 with the class in @xmath685 also vanishes .
therefore , the original class in @xmath684 is zero .
[ diagonal - secn ] let @xmath6 be a small triangulated category endowed with a sequence of full subcategories @xmath231 , @xmath90 .
assume that each @xmath231 is closed under extensions in @xmath6 and one has @xmath692)=0 $ for all $ x\in{{\mathcal e}}_i$ , \
$ y\in{{\mathcal e}}_j$ , and $ i\ge j$.}\ ] ] finally , suppose that a triangulated autoequivalence @xmath128 is defined on the triangulated category @xmath6 such that @xmath337 .
let @xmath693 be a full subcategory of @xmath344 such that any object of @xmath344 is a finite direct sum of objects from @xmath693 .
introduce the big graded ring of diagonal cohomology @xmath694))_{y , x\in{{\mathcal j}};{\mskip .5\thinmuskip\relax}n\ge0}$ ] over the set @xmath695 of all objects of @xmath693 ( see [ big - graded - rings ] ) .
let @xmath29 denote the minimal full subcategory of @xmath6 containing all @xmath231 and closed under extensions .
assume that every morphism @xmath47 $ ] of degree @xmath696 in @xmath6 between two objects @xmath10 , @xmath30 can be presented as the composition of a chain of morphisms @xmath697 $ ] with @xmath698 , @xmath699 , and @xmath700 cf.appendix
. then 1 .
one has @xmath15)=0 $ ] for all @xmath255 , @xmath256 , @xmath33 , and @xmath41 ; 2 .
the big graded ring @xmath94 is _ quadratic _ , i. e. , generated by the @xmath93-bimodule @xmath138 with relations in degree @xmath81 .
more precisely , a big graded ring @xmath701 is said to be _
quadratic _ if the natural maps @xmath702 are isomorphisms for all @xmath17 , where the tensor powers of the @xmath93-bimodule @xmath138 are taken over @xmath93 and the @xmath93-bimodule of quadratic relations @xmath703 is defined as the kernel of the multiplication map @xmath704 .
notice that the property of a big graded ring @xmath94 to be quadratic actually does not depend on the component @xmath93 , i. e. , for any big graded ring @xmath94 and a morphism of big rings @xmath705 over the same set @xmath706 the big graded rings @xmath94 and @xmath707 are quadratic simultaneously .
indeed , clearly @xmath94 is generated by @xmath138 over @xmath93 if and only if @xmath708 is generated by @xmath138 over @xmath709 ; and the relation @xmath710 for @xmath711 , @xmath712 and @xmath713 has degree @xmath81 . as in subsection [ proof - part - two ] , denote by @xmath714}$ ] the minimal full subcategory of @xmath6 , containing @xmath293 , @xmath294 , and closed under extensions .
it follows from the @xmath257-associativity lemma ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 3.1.10 ) and the condition that one has @xmath714}={{\mathcal m}}_{[r+1,j]}*{{\mathcal m}}_{[i , r]}$ ] for any @xmath715 , i. e. , for any object @xmath716}$ ] there exists a distinguished triangle @xmath717 $ ] with @xmath718}$ ] and @xmath719}$ ] .
this triangle does not have to be unique or functorial in our weak assumptions .
however , it follows from these assumptions that , given @xmath720 and @xmath30 , any element in @xmath721)$ ] comes from an element in @xmath722)$ ] ( for any choice of @xmath723 ) .
decomposing an arbitrary element of @xmath15)$ ] with @xmath633 into the product of elements from @xmath724)$ ] and using induction on @xmath37 , one can see that such an element has to come from an element in @xmath725)$ ] .
this proves part ( 1 ) . applying the above argument together with its dual version
, one can see that any element of @xmath15)$ ] with @xmath726 , @xmath727 , and @xmath696 can be decomposed into a product of elements from @xmath728)$ ] with @xmath729 .
taking @xmath730 , @xmath731 and presenting @xmath732 as finite direct sums of objects from @xmath733 , one can show that the big graded ring @xmath94 is generated by @xmath138 .
it remains to prove quadraticity . with any relation of degree @xmath37 between the elements of @xmath138 in the big graded ring @xmath94
one can associate a relation of the form @xmath734 in the big graded ring @xmath735))_{y , x\in{{\mathcal e}}_0;{\mskip .5\thinmuskip\relax}n\ge0}$ ] , where @xmath736)$ ] and @xmath737 .
let us show that all such relations follow from relations of degree @xmath81 .
assume that the product of an element @xmath738)$ ] and a class @xmath739,y[n])$ ] is zero , where @xmath726 , @xmath740 , @xmath727 , and @xmath741 .
consider the distinguished triangle @xmath742 $ ] ; then the object @xmath318 belongs to @xmath743}$ ] . since @xmath744 , the morphism @xmath440 extends to a morphism @xmath745,y[n])$ ] . by the assumption of theorem
, one can decompose the morphism @xmath746 as a product of a morphism @xmath747\rarrow s[2]$ ] and a morphism @xmath748\rarrow y[n]$ ] in @xmath6 , where @xmath749 .
as explained above , one can assume that @xmath750}$ ] .
so there is a distinguished triangle @xmath751 $ ] with @xmath752 and @xmath753 .
denote the morphism @xmath754\rarrow u[2]$ ] by @xmath755 .
the composition @xmath756\rarrow t[1]\rarrow s[2]$ ] factorizes through the morphism @xmath757\rarrow s[2]$ ] , providing a morphism @xmath758\rarrow u[2]$ ] .
the composition @xmath759\rarrow u[2]\rarrow s[2]$ ] vanishes , since the composition @xmath759\rarrow t[1]$ ] does ; hence the composition @xmath759\rarrow u[2]$ ] factorizes through the morphism @xmath755 , providing a morphism @xmath760 $ ] .
denote the composition @xmath757\rarrow s[2]\rarrow y[n]$ ] by @xmath761 .
now the relation @xmath744 of degree @xmath37 follows from the relations @xmath762 , @xmath763 , and @xmath764 of the degrees @xmath765 , @xmath81 , and @xmath765 , respectively .
decomposing the objects @xmath205 and @xmath363 into finite direct sums of objects from @xmath766 and @xmath767 , one can conclude that the original relation of degree @xmath37 in @xmath94 follows from relations of degree @xmath768 .
let @xmath94 be a big nonnegatively graded ring over a set @xmath706 ; suppose that @xmath94 is quadratic .
starting from @xmath94 , we would like to construct an exact category @xmath352 with the following properties . the exact category @xmath352 should be endowed with a sequence of full subcategories @xmath231 and an exact autoequivalence @xmath128 such that each @xmath231 is closed under extensions , every object of @xmath352 is an iterated extension of objects from @xmath231 , and @xmath337 .
the conditions and should be satisfied . there should be a full subcategory @xmath769 such that every object of @xmath344 is a finite direct sum of objects from @xmath693 .
the set @xmath695 of all objects of @xmath693 should be identified with @xmath706 , and the big graded ring of diagonal cohomology @xmath770 should be identified with @xmath94 .
finally , one should have @xmath771 notice that the conditions and imply @xmath772 for @xmath41 by the result of subsection [ diagonal - is - quadratic ] .
so the sum total of the conditions , , and can be simply restated as @xmath773 for any quadratic big graded ring @xmath94 over a set @xmath706 there exists a unique , up to a unique exact equivalence , exact category @xmath352 with the additional data described above satisfying the condition .
we will give two proofs of this theorem , both of which will be useful in the sequel . consider the big ring @xmath774 .
we will construct the category @xmath352 as a certain category of graded comodules over a graded coring over the big ring @xmath626 .
generally , a _ coring _ @xmath111 over @xmath626 is an @xmath626-bimodule endowed with @xmath626-bimodule maps @xmath775 and @xmath776 , called the comultiplication and counit , satisfying the conventional coassociativity and counit axioms .
right comodule _ @xmath171 over a coring @xmath111 is a right @xmath626-module endowed with an @xmath626-module map @xmath777 , called the right coaction , satisfying the conventional axioms .
let @xmath778 be a nonpositively graded coring over a big ring @xmath626 such that @xmath779 .
such a coring @xmath111 is said to be _
quadratic _ if the comultiplication map @xmath780 is injective and @xmath111 is the universal final object in the category of graded corings over @xmath626 with the components @xmath781 , @xmath782 , and @xmath783 fixed . given an @xmath626-bimodule @xmath782 and a subbimodule @xmath784 , the corresponding quadratic coring @xmath111 always exists .
its components can be constructed by induction in such a way that the initial fragment of the reduced cobar - complex @xmath785 where @xmath786 , would be exact in the gradings @xmath787 and below .
the coring @xmath111 we are interested in is the quadratic coring over @xmath626 with the initial components @xmath788 and @xmath789 .
the quadratic coring @xmath111 constructed in this way is called _ quadratic dual _ to the quadratic big ring @xmath94 . for any finite set mapping to @xmath706 one
can consider the corresponding finitely generated free right @xmath626-module ( see [ big - graded - rings ] ) .
the additive category @xmath344 of such @xmath626-modules is endowed with the full subcategory @xmath693 consisting of free modules with one generator ; the set @xmath695 is identified with @xmath706 and the big ring @xmath790 is naturally identified with @xmath626 . set @xmath352 to be the category of graded right @xmath111-comodules that are free and finitely generated as graded right @xmath626-modules . the full subcategories @xmath231 consist of the graded comodules concentrated in degree @xmath22 ; the twist functor @xmath128 shifts the grading .
a triple in @xmath352 is exact if it is ( split ) exact in every degree .
the conditions and are obviously satisfied .
it is also clear that @xmath791 for all @xmath255 , @xmath256 , and @xmath792 , since @xmath111 is cogenerated by @xmath782 . to show that @xmath793 for all @xmath255 , @xmath256 , and @xmath794 , present an arbitrary class in @xmath795 as the product of classes in @xmath796 and @xmath797 , where @xmath798}$ ] .
since @xmath111 is quadratic , one can check that the @xmath111-comodule structures on the graded @xmath626-modules @xmath799 and @xmath800 can be extended to a @xmath111-comodule structure on @xmath801 .
it is straightforward to identify the @xmath626-bimodule @xmath802 with @xmath138 and the @xmath626-bimodule @xmath803 with @xmath804 .
thus the big graded ring @xmath805 is isomorphic to @xmath94 by the result of [ diagonal - is - quadratic ] .
conversely , let @xmath361 be an exact category with the additional data satisfying all the conditions of theorem except perhaps .
then it is not difficult to construct an exact functor @xmath806 , where @xmath352 is the above category of @xmath111-comodules .
more precisely , one starts with identifying the additive subcategories @xmath807 with the category of finitely generated free right @xmath626-modules .
then one constructs the exact functors @xmath808}\rarrow{{\mathcal g}}$ ] using the class @xmath809 for @xmath255 and @xmath281 to define the coaction map @xmath810 . to construct the graded @xmath111-comodule structure corresponding to an arbitrary object in @xmath361 , one only has to check that the compositions @xmath811 factorize through @xmath812 whenever @xmath813 , @xmath814 , and @xmath815 for some @xmath678
this is so because the product of the classes in @xmath663 and @xmath664 corresponding to @xmath329 vanishes in @xmath662 .
if the category @xmath361 also satisfies , then the functor @xmath268 is an equivalence of exact categories by lemma from subsection [ proof - part - one ] .
this is only a proof of existence .
consider the dg - category @xmath264 whose objects are indexed by the pairs @xmath816 , where @xmath817 and @xmath818 .
the complex of morphisms @xmath819 has its only possibly nonzero term equal to @xmath820 in the cohomological degree @xmath821 .
the composition of morphisms in @xmath264 comes from the multiplication in @xmath94 .
let @xmath6 denote the derived category of contravariant dg - functors from @xmath264 to the category of complexes of abelian groups .
there is an autoequivalence @xmath822 on the dg - category @xmath264 ; let @xmath128 denotes the induced autoequivalence of @xmath6 .
let @xmath823 be the full subcategory of functors representable by the objects @xmath824 .
set @xmath825 to be the minimal additive subcategory of @xmath6 containing @xmath693 and @xmath826 .
let @xmath104 be the minimal full subcategory of @xmath6 , containing @xmath231 and closed under extensions ; then @xmath104 has a natural structure of exact category . clearly , one has @xmath15)=0 $ ] for @xmath255 , @xmath256 , and @xmath143 .
the big graded ring @xmath735))_{y , x\in{{\mathcal j}};{\mskip .5\thinmuskip\relax}n\ge0}$ ] is identified with @xmath94 . since the natural maps @xmath827)$ ]
are isomorphisms for all @xmath10 , @xmath105 and @xmath828 , and monomorphisms for @xmath135 , the condition follows .
since the big graded ring @xmath829 is quadratic by the result of [ diagonal - is - quadratic ] , its morphism to @xmath94 has to be an isomorphism .
[ koszul - rings - secn ] let @xmath830 be a big graded ring over a set @xmath706 .
a big graded ring @xmath94 is called _ koszul _ if there exists an exact category @xmath352 with full subcategories @xmath231 , a twist functor @xmath128 on it , and a full subcategory @xmath769 satisfying the assumptions of subsection [ quadratic - realized ] , for which the following stronger version of the condition holds @xmath831 in other words , @xmath94 is koszul if the exact category @xmath352 uniquely determined by the conditions of subsection [ quadratic - realized ] ( including ) , satisfies . by theorem from subsection [ diagonal - is - quadratic ]
, this condition always holds for @xmath41 ; the nontrivial part is the vanishing for @xmath832 .
it follows from the result of section [ base - restriction - secn ] that the koszul property does not depend on the base ring in the component of degree @xmath107 of @xmath94 . more precisely , set @xmath774 and let @xmath625 be any morphism of big rings over @xmath706 .
in addition to @xmath94 , consider the big graded ring @xmath833 .
then the big graded ring @xmath94 is koszul if and only if the big graded ring @xmath834 is ( cf .
remarks before the proof in subsection [ diagonal - is - quadratic ] ) .
it is known ( * ? ? ?
* sections 0.4 and 11.4 ) what the koszulity condition means in the case of a nonnegatively graded ring @xmath94 that is a flat left or right module over its zero - degree component @xmath774 .
we will see below in [ flat - koszul ] that our definition is equivalent to the definition from @xcite in the flat situation . for the reader
s convenience , we present a brief general discussion of flat koszulity over a base big ring in [ generalities ] .
one would like also to have a more explicit definition of koszulity in the general case .
morally , the idea is to replace @xmath626 with the `` absolute ring '' , known also as the `` field with one element '' @xmath835 ; one presumes that every module over @xmath835 is flat . in practice , this turns out to involve a certain condition of `` exactness of the matrix koszul complex '' for @xmath94 .
this is worked out , in two different ways , in [ general - koszul ] and [ triangulated - koszul ] .
one might think that the simplest way to interpret the condition would be to compute explicitly the groups @xmath8 over the graded coring @xmath111 constructed in the first proof in subsection [ quadratic - realized ] .
the problem is , it is not known how to compute @xmath8 in the exact category of @xmath626-projective comodules over a coring @xmath111 over a ring @xmath626 in general ; see ( * ? ? ?
* question 5.1.4 ) . in the flat case ,
we use this approach in [ flat - koszul ] .
any big graded ring @xmath94 such that @xmath836 for @xmath696 is koszul .
the objects of the related exact category @xmath352 ( as constructed in the first proof in [ quadratic - realized ] ) are finitely supported sequences of finitely generated free right @xmath93-modules @xmath837 , @xmath90 , endowed with right @xmath93-module maps @xmath838 . no compatibility condition is imposed on these maps .
the subcategory @xmath231 consists of all sequences @xmath171 such that @xmath839 for @xmath250 , and @xmath840 is the subcategory of free modules with one generator .
one easily checks that @xmath793 for any @xmath255 and @xmath841 , so @xmath352 is an exact category of homological dimension @xmath156 and is satisfied .
a _ @xmath706-colored matrix _ @xmath842 _ with entries in _ @xmath843 is a ( finite , rectangular ) matrix whose rows and columns are marked by elements of @xmath706 and the entry @xmath844 belongs to the group @xmath845 if the @xmath22-th row is marked by @xmath403 and the @xmath158-th column is marked by @xmath846 .
a pair of @xmath706-colored matrices @xmath847 with entries in @xmath843 and @xmath848 , respectively , is called _ composable _ if the number of columns in @xmath842 equals the number of rows in @xmath171 and the columns in @xmath842 and rows in @xmath171 corresponding to each other are marked by the same elements of @xmath706 . clearly , the product @xmath849 of any two composable matrices @xmath842 and @xmath171 is well - defined as a @xmath706-colored matrix with entries in @xmath850 .
a big nonnegatively graded ring @xmath94 is koszul if and only if the following condition holds .
let @xmath851 ,
, @xmath852 , @xmath853 be @xmath706-colored matrices with entries in @xmath138 such that every pair @xmath854 is composable and the product @xmath855 is zero .
let @xmath171 be a @xmath706-colored matrix with entries in @xmath848 , @xmath856 , such that the pair @xmath857 is composable and the product @xmath858 is also zero .
then there should exist @xmath706-colored matrices @xmath859 ,
, @xmath860 with entries in @xmath93 , @xmath861 , , @xmath862 with entries in @xmath138 , @xmath863 with entries in @xmath138 , and @xmath350 with entries in @xmath864 such that @xmath865 where all the pairs of matrices being multiplied are composable .
notice that the above matrix condition is not obviously self - opposite , i. e. , it is not immediately clear why the similar condition with the order of factors in the products of matrices reversed is equivalent to the condition from theorem .
however , it will be clear from the proof below that the koszul property of the big graded ring @xmath94 is also equivalent to the opposite matrix condition , hence the two opposite versions of the matrix condition are equivalent to each other .
notice first of all that the condition for @xmath31 is always trivial : it suffices to take @xmath866 and @xmath350 to be the identity matrices , @xmath867 , and @xmath868 .
the condition for @xmath869 simply means ( or in any event should be read to mean ) that any @xmath706-colored matrix @xmath171 with entries in @xmath848 can be decomposed into a product @xmath870 of two composable @xmath706-colored matrices @xmath871 and @xmath350 with entries in @xmath138 and @xmath864 , respectively .
this is equivalent to the big graded ring @xmath94 being multiplicatively generated by @xmath138 over @xmath93 .
the condition for @xmath448 means that for any composable @xmath706-colored matrices @xmath171 and @xmath842 with entries in @xmath848 and @xmath138 such that @xmath872 there exist @xmath706-colored matrices @xmath1 with entries in @xmath93 , @xmath873 with entries in @xmath138 , @xmath871 with entries in @xmath138 , and @xmath350 with entries in @xmath864 such that @xmath874 , @xmath875 , and @xmath876 . together with the condition for @xmath869
, this clearly implies that @xmath94 is quadratic ; the converse implication will follow from the argument below .
let @xmath877 , @xmath878 denote the exact category with the additional data corresponding to the quadratic big graded ring @xmath94 .
`` if '' : we will show by induction on @xmath37 that @xmath879 for all @xmath726 , @xmath880 , and @xmath881 .
the case @xmath31 is known by ; let @xmath696 .
suppose we are given a class in @xmath882 ; decompose it into a product of classes in @xmath883 and @xmath884 . as it was explained in subsections
[ proof - part - two ] and [ diagonal - is - quadratic ] , one can assume that @xmath885}$ ] . the sequence of classes in @xmath886 , @xmath887 , , @xmath888 coming from the class in @xmath883 and the filtered object @xmath305 defines a sequence of @xmath706-colored matrices @xmath851 , , @xmath852 .
the class in @xmath889 coming from the class in @xmath884 defines a matrix @xmath171 .
the existence of the object @xmath305 and the classes in @xmath796 and @xmath890 implies the equations on the products of consecutive matrices @xmath891 and @xmath171 . by assumption , it follows that there exist @xmath706-colored matrices @xmath866 , @xmath892 , @xmath871 , and @xmath350 satisfying the equations of theorem .
since @xmath893 vanishes outside of the diagonal , starting from the matrices @xmath892 one can construct @xcite an object @xmath894}$ ] and a class in @xmath895 related to these matrices in the same way as the object @xmath305 and the class in @xmath796 are related to the matrices @xmath891 . since @xmath896 also vanishes outside of the diagonal , starting from the matrices
@xmath866 one can construct a morphism @xmath688 such that the original class in @xmath796 comes from our new class in @xmath895 .
consider the class in @xmath897 obtained by composing the morphism @xmath688 with the class in @xmath890 .
then the related class in @xmath898 can be decoposed into the product of classes in @xmath899 and @xmath900 corresponding to the matrices @xmath871 and @xmath350 , where @xmath901 . due to the equation @xmath902 , the class in @xmath899 comes from a class in @xmath903 .
present the latter class by an exact triple @xmath904 .
the class in @xmath895 comes from a class in @xmath905 .
let us show that the composition of the morphism @xmath906 with the class in @xmath897 vanishes .
the image of that composition in @xmath907 is the composition of the morphism @xmath908 with the class in @xmath898 , which is clearly zero .
so our class in @xmath909 comes from a class in @xmath910 .
the latter class is zero by the assumption of induction on @xmath37 .
`` only if '' : suppose that we are given @xmath706-colored matrices @xmath891 , @xmath443 , and @xmath171 such that the consecutive pairs are composable with a zero product .
as above , with the matrices @xmath891 one can associate an object @xmath885}$ ] and an extension class in @xmath796 with @xmath911 ; from the matrix @xmath171 one can obtain a class in @xmath912 with @xmath880 .
the equation @xmath913 and the assumption of vanishing of @xmath914 outside of the diagonal allow to conclude that the latter class comes from a class in @xmath890 . by the same assumption ,
the product of these two classes vanishes in @xmath915 . by lemma 1 from [ two - lemmas ]
, there exists a morphism @xmath688 in @xmath352 such that the class in @xmath796 comes from a class in @xmath895 , while the induced class in @xmath897 vanishes .
one can assume that @xmath916 .
the morphism @xmath688 factorizes as @xmath917 , and the induced class in @xmath918 is the product of the class in @xmath919 corresponding to @xmath920 and a certain class in @xmath921 . by the same argument from subsection [ diagonal - is - quadratic ] that was referred to above
, one can assume that @xmath922 and @xmath923}$ ] .
it remains to construct matrices @xmath892 from the object @xmath924 and the class in @xmath925 , matrices @xmath866 from the morphism @xmath926 , a matrix @xmath871 from the class in @xmath927 , and a matrix @xmath350 from the class in @xmath928 .
let @xmath6 be a triangulated category and @xmath228 be full additive subcategories such that @xmath929)=0 \quad\text{for all $ x\in{{\mathcal e}}_i$ , \
$ y\in{{\mathcal e}}_j$ , } \begin{array}{l } \text{$n=1 $ , and $ i\ge j$ , or}\\ \text{$n\ge2 $ , and $ n\ne j - i$. } \end{array}\ ] ] furthermore , suppose that a triangulated autoequivalence @xmath128 is defined on @xmath6 such that @xmath337 .
let @xmath29 denote the minimal full subcategory of @xmath6 , containing all @xmath231 and closed under extensions .
let @xmath769 be a full subcategory such that every object of @xmath344 is a finite direct sum of objects of @xmath693 .
consider the big graded ring @xmath694 ) ) _ { y , x\in{{\mathcal j}};{\mskip .5\thinmuskip\relax}n\ge0}$ ] . 1 .
the big graded ring @xmath94 is koszul if and only if every morphism @xmath47 $ ] of degree @xmath696 in @xmath6 between two objects @xmath10 , @xmath30 can be presented as the composition of a chain of morphisms @xmath697 $ ] with @xmath698 , @xmath699 , and @xmath700 cf.appendix .
2 . an arbitrary big graded ring @xmath94 is koszul if and only if the following condition holds .
let @xmath851 ,
, @xmath852 , @xmath853 be @xmath706-colored matrices with entries in @xmath138 such that every pair @xmath854 is composable and the product @xmath855 is zero .
let @xmath171 be a @xmath706-colored matrix with entries in @xmath848 , @xmath856 , such that the pair @xmath857 is composable and the product @xmath858 is also zero .
then there should exist @xmath706-colored matrices @xmath930 ,
, @xmath931 , @xmath861 , , @xmath862 with entries in @xmath138 and @xmath350 with entries in @xmath864 such that @xmath932 where all the pairs of matrices being multiplied are composable .
notice that ( 2 ) provides a characterization of the koszul property of a big graded ring @xmath94 that is explicitly independent of the component @xmath93 ( since the condition for @xmath31 is trivial , see below ) .
we will show that the decomposition condition in ( 1 ) holds for a triangulated category @xmath6 and its full subcategory @xmath29 if and only if the matrix condition in ( 2 ) is satisfied for the corresponding big graded ring @xmath94 .
then it will remain to consider the triangulated category @xmath6 and its exact subcategory @xmath104 from the second proof in subsection [ quadratic - realized ] . by corollary
[ exact - triangulated].2 , the decomposition condition for such @xmath6 and @xmath933 is equivalent to the condition that the morphisms @xmath934)$ ] be isomorphisms for all @xmath10 , @xmath105 and @xmath149 , and the latter is clearly equivalent to the condition for the exact category @xmath104 . as in [ general - koszul ] , the condition for @xmath31 is always trivial : it suffices to take @xmath350 to be the identity matrix , @xmath935 , @xmath936 for @xmath937 , and @xmath938 for all @xmath22 .
the condition for @xmath869 should be read to mean that any @xmath706-colored matrix @xmath171 with entries in @xmath848 can be decomposed into a product @xmath939 , which is equivalent to @xmath94 being generated by @xmath138 .
the condition for @xmath448 implies that @xmath94 has quadratic relations ; the converse implication was essentially proven in section [ diagonal - secn ] ( see below for the details ) .
suppose that the matrix condition in ( 2 ) holds .
by proposition [ silly - filtrations - appx].1 , it suffices to show that any element in @xmath15)$ ] with @xmath940 , @xmath941 , and @xmath696 can be presented as the composition of an element in @xmath942)$ ] and an element in @xmath943)$ ] with @xmath944 . as it was explained in subsection [ diagonal - is - quadratic ]
, one can assume that @xmath945}$ ] .
suppose that @xmath10 is a successive extension of objects @xmath946 ,
, @xmath947 , where @xmath948 .
this means that there exist distinguished triangles @xmath949 $ ] for all @xmath950 such that @xmath951 and @xmath952 .
then the elements in @xmath953)$ ] obtained as the compositions @xmath954 $ ] provide matrices @xmath891 and the element in @xmath955)$ ] obtained as the composition @xmath956 $ ] provides a matrix @xmath171 .
the existence of the morphisms @xmath957 $ ] and @xmath47 $ ] implies the equations on the products of consecutive matrices @xmath891 and @xmath171 . by assumption
, it follows that there exist matrices @xmath958 , @xmath892 , and @xmath350 satisfying the equations of part ( 2 ) .
let @xmath697 $ ] , @xmath959 ,
, @xmath2 , and @xmath960 $ ] be morphisms corresponding to the matrices @xmath892 and @xmath350 , where @xmath961 .
since @xmath962)=0 $ ] for @xmath794 , it follows from the equations @xmath963 that there exists a successive extension of objects @xmath732 corresponding to our morphisms @xmath964 .
in other words , there exist distinguished triangles @xmath965 $ ] for all @xmath950 such that @xmath966 and the compositions @xmath967 $ ] are equal to our morphisms @xmath697 $ ] .
set @xmath968 . since @xmath969)=0 $ ] for @xmath970
, it follows from the equation @xmath971 that there exists a morphism @xmath972 $ ] making the triangle @xmath973 $ ] commutative .
finally , let @xmath974 $ ] be the morphisms corresponding to the matrices @xmath958 . since @xmath975)=0 $ ] for @xmath792 and @xmath976)=0 $ ] for @xmath970
, it follows from the equations on the matrices @xmath958 that one can construct a morphism @xmath759 $ ] making the triangle @xmath759 \rarrow y[n]$ ] commutative .
suppose that the decomposition condition in ( 1 ) holds .
let @xmath891 , @xmath443 , and @xmath171 be @xmath706-colored matrices satisfying the equations @xmath977 and @xmath913 .
as above , starting from these matrices one can construct a successive extension @xmath10 of objects @xmath948 and a morphism @xmath47 $ ] .
decompose this morphism as @xmath759\rarrow y[n]$ ] , where @xmath944 . by the argument from subsection [ diagonal - is - quadratic ]
, one can assume @xmath978}$ ] .
so the object @xmath305 is a successive extension of objects @xmath961 , @xmath979 , , @xmath2 .
hence we obtain morphisms @xmath697 $ ] .
since @xmath980)=0 $ ] for @xmath109 , one can obtain morphisms @xmath974 $ ] from the morphism @xmath981 .
the composition @xmath973 $ ] provides a morphism @xmath960 $ ] .
these morphisms define the desired matrices @xmath892 , @xmath958 , and @xmath350 .
let @xmath626 be a big graded ring over a set @xmath706 .
a right @xmath626-module @xmath171 is called _ flat _ if the functor @xmath982 is exact on the category of left @xmath626-modules .
flat left @xmath626-modules are defined in the similar way .
let @xmath830 be a big graded ring ; set @xmath774 .
assume that @xmath94 is quadratic .
consider the quadratic coring @xmath111 over @xmath626 defined in the first proof in subsection [ quadratic - realized ] .
introduce the reduced cobar - complex @xmath983 where @xmath786 ; this complex is bigraded with the ( cohomological ) grading @xmath37 by the number of tensor factors and the ( internal ) grading @xmath22 induced by the grading of @xmath111 .
let @xmath94 be a quadratic big ring such that either all the left @xmath93-modules @xmath984 are flat or all the right @xmath93-modules @xmath984 are flat .
then @xmath94 is koszul if and only if the cobar - complex has no cohomology outside of the diagonal @xmath985 .
first of all let us show that it suffices only to consider the case when the right @xmath93-modules @xmath984 are flat .
opposite big graded rings @xmath94 and @xmath986 are koszul simultaneously .
it is clear that @xmath94 and @xmath986 are simultaneously quadratic ; assume that they are .
let @xmath877 , @xmath878 be the exact category with the additional data corresponding to @xmath94 . consider the opposite exact category @xmath987 with the full subcategories @xmath988 , the twist functor @xmath989 , and the full subcategory @xmath990 .
then the exact category @xmath991 , @xmath992 corresponds to @xmath986 .
clearly , @xmath352 and @xmath993 satisfy simultaneously .
it remains to notice that the coring @xmath994 over @xmath995 opposite to the coring
@xmath111 corresponds to the quadratic ring @xmath986 in the same way as the coring @xmath111 corresponds to @xmath94 , and the cobar - complexes of @xmath111 and @xmath994 are isomorphic .
the rest of the proof is based on the following lemmas 2 - -4 .
let @xmath111 be a nonpositively graded coring over a big ring @xmath626 with @xmath779 .
then the embedding @xmath996 of the exact category @xmath352 of graded right @xmath111-comodules , free and finitely generated as graded @xmath626-modules , into the exact category @xmath361 of @xmath626-flat graded right @xmath111-comodules induces an isomorphism of the groups @xmath8 . clearly , it suffices to consider the categories @xmath997}$ ] and @xmath998}$ ] of graded @xmath111-comodules concentrated in the gradings @xmath999 $ ] .
we will show that the exact functor @xmath997}\rarrow{{\mathcal h}}_{[0,m]}$ ] satisfies the assumption of lemmas 12 from [ two - lemmas ] .
for this purpose we will use the big ring version of the govorov lazard theorem that any flat module is a filtered inductive limit of finitely generated free modules . more precisely
, we will need the fact that any morphism from a finitely presented @xmath626-module ( i. e. , the cokernel of a morphism of finitely generated free @xmath626-modules ) to a flat @xmath626-module factorizes through a finitely generated free @xmath626-module .
one proves this for modules over big rings in exactly the same way as in the case of conventional rings and modules ; see ( * ? ? ?
1.56 ) .
let @xmath1000 be an admissible epimorphism in @xmath998}$ ] onto an object @xmath1001}$ ] ; we would like to construct an admissible epimorphism @xmath435 in @xmath997}$ ] factorizable through the morphism @xmath1000 .
proceed by induction on @xmath2 , assuming that the morphisms @xmath1002 have been constructed already .
let @xmath1003 be a morphism into the grading component @xmath1004 from a right finitely presented @xmath626-module @xmath1005 such that the composition @xmath1006 is surjective and the compositions @xmath1007 of the grading components of the morphism @xmath1008 with the comultiplication maps @xmath1009 factorize through the morphism @xmath1010 for all @xmath950 .
one can even easily choose @xmath1005 to be a finitely generated free @xmath626-module .
suppose the above factorizations of morphisms to be fixed .
let @xmath1011 be a morphism of finitely presented @xmath626-modules through which the morphism @xmath1003 factorizes such that the right @xmath626-module @xmath1012 is a @xmath111-comodule , i. e. , the coassociativity equations for the above maps @xmath1013 together with the coaction maps of @xmath1014 hold after taking the composition with the epimorphisms @xmath1015 .
it is clearly possible to find such finitely presented @xmath626-module @xmath1016 , since there is only a finite number of equations on the tensor products of its elements that have to be satisfied . now
the morphism @xmath1017 between a finitely presented and a flat @xmath626-module factorizes through a finitely generated free @xmath626-module @xmath1018 .
this provides a right @xmath111-comodule @xmath920 , free and finitely generated as a right @xmath626-module , together with an epimorphism @xmath1019 factorizable through @xmath318 .
it remains to add to the comodule @xmath920 a direct summand , free and finitely generated over @xmath626 and concentrated in degree @xmath2 , to obtain a morphism @xmath435 whose kernel is also a free and finitely generated @xmath626-module .
let @xmath111 be a graded coring over a big ring @xmath626 such that the components @xmath1020 are flat right @xmath626-modules .
then for any @xmath626-projective graded right @xmath111-comodule @xmath10 and @xmath626-flat graded right @xmath111-comodule @xmath117 the groups @xmath1021 in the exact category @xmath361 of @xmath626-flat graded right @xmath111-comodules are computed by the cobar - complex @xmath1022 where @xmath1023 , while the differentials are constructed in terms of the comultiplication in @xmath111 and the right coactions of @xmath111 in @xmath10 and @xmath117 .
notice that our assertion does not depend on any positivity assumptions on the grading .
the complex @xmath1024 is a right resolution of the graded right @xmath111-comodule @xmath117 in the exact category @xmath361 .
actually , this resolution is even split over @xmath626 .
its terms are @xmath111-comodules @xmath1025 coinduced from flat right @xmath626-modules @xmath205 .
one only has to check that such coinduced comodules are adjusted to the functor @xmath1026 on the exact category @xmath361 .
indeed , the exact functor @xmath1027 from the category of flat right @xmath626-modules to the category of @xmath626-flat right @xmath111-comodules satisfies the dual version of the assumption of lemmas 12 from [ two - lemmas ] . to check this , consider an admissible monomorphism @xmath1028 in the category @xmath361 .
consider the morphism of @xmath626-modules @xmath1029 induced by the counit of @xmath111 .
let @xmath1 be the fibered coproduct of the @xmath626-modules @xmath205 and @xmath171 over @xmath1025 ; then @xmath1 is a flat right @xmath626-module and the morphism @xmath1030 is an admissible monomorphism of flat right @xmath626-modules .
the morphism of right @xmath626-modules @xmath1031 induces a morphism of right @xmath111-comodules @xmath1032 , which forms a commutative triangle with the morphism @xmath1028 and the morphism @xmath1033 coinduced from the admissible monomorphism @xmath1034 .
now since the exact triples of right @xmath111-comodules coinduced from exact triples of right @xmath626-modules remain exact after applying the functor @xmath1035 , one has @xmath1036 for @xmath1037 .
let @xmath1038 be a morphism of nonpositively graded corings over a big ring @xmath626 such that the map @xmath1039 is an isomorphism for @xmath937 .
let @xmath10 and @xmath117 be finitely generated free right @xmath626-modules placed in the gradings @xmath107 and @xmath2 , respectively .
then the maps @xmath1040 between the ext groups in the categories of right @xmath1041- and @xmath111-comodules , free and finitely generated as graded @xmath626-modules , are isomorphisms for @xmath679 .
it is claimed that the groups @xmath1021 for @xmath679 only depend on the exact subcategories @xmath1042}$ ] and @xmath1043}{\subset}{{\mathcal g}}$ ] .
indeed , any class in @xmath1021 can be decomposed into the product of classes in @xmath796 and @xmath1044 , where @xmath1045}$ ] .
the product of such two classes vanishes if and only if the class in @xmath796 is the composition of a class in @xmath1046 and a morphism @xmath688 , while the composition of the same morphism with the class in @xmath1047 vanishes .
moreover , one can choose @xmath1048}$ ] ( see the proof in [ general - koszul ] , `` only if '' part ) .
let us finish the proof of theorem .
`` if '' : the diagonal cohomology of the cobar - complex can be easily identified with the components @xmath984 . knowing that @xmath984 are flat right @xmath626-modules and the cobar - complex has no cohomology outside of the diagonal , one shows by induction that the components @xmath1049 are flat @xmath626-modules , too .
then it remains to apply lemmas 2 - -3 .
`` only if '' : proceed by induction on the internal grading @xmath2 . if the cohomology of the cobar - complex in the internal grading strictly above @xmath1050 are concentrated on the diagonal , then @xmath1049 are flat right @xmath626-modules for @xmath937 .
consider the graded coring @xmath1041 over @xmath626 with @xmath1051 for @xmath937 and @xmath1052 for @xmath1053 .
it follows from lemmas 2 - -4 that @xmath1021 for @xmath726 and @xmath1054 for @xmath741 can be computed in terms of the cobar - complex of the coring @xmath111 .
since we assume that these groups are zero for @xmath1055 , it follows that the cobar - complex has no cohomology outside of the diagonal in the internal grading @xmath1050 .
let @xmath65 be a commutative ring and @xmath94 be a big graded ring with a @xmath65-algebra structure , i. e. , the components @xmath1056 are @xmath65-modules and the multiplications are @xmath65-linear .
let @xmath627 be a ( conventional associative , not necessarily commutative ) @xmath65-algebra .
assume that either @xmath627 is @xmath65-flat , or the components of @xmath94 are flat @xmath65-modules .
then the big graded ring @xmath1057 is koszul whenever the big graded ring @xmath94 is koszul .
assuming additionally that for any @xmath65-module @xmath842 the vanishing of @xmath1058 implies the vanishing of @xmath842 , the converse implication also holds : @xmath94 is koszul if @xmath1057 is .
let us first consider the case when @xmath627 is @xmath65-flat .
then one can easily see that @xmath1057 is quadratic whenever @xmath94 is , and the converse also holds if @xmath627 is faithfully @xmath65-flat .
the nonpositively graded coring over @xmath1059 quadratic dual to @xmath1057 is naturally isomorphic to @xmath1060 , where @xmath111 is the coring quadratic dual to @xmath94 . the category of graded right comodules over @xmath1060 is naturally identified with the category of graded right comodules over @xmath111 endowed with a right @xmath627-modules structure which agrees with the @xmath65-module structure and commutes with the coaction of @xmath111 .
let @xmath1061 and @xmath1062 denote the exact categories of @xmath93-flat graded right @xmath111-comodules and @xmath1059-flat graded right @xmath1059-comodules .
then there is a natural exact functor @xmath1063 of forgetting the action of @xmath627 , which has an exact left adjoint functor @xmath1064 sending a comodule @xmath10 to the comodule @xmath1065 . by ( * ?
* lemma 2.1 ) , there are natural isomorphisms @xmath1066 for all @xmath37 and @xmath22 . by lemma 2 above , the left hand side of this isomorphism is isomorphic to the similar group @xmath8 in the category @xmath1067 of of graded right @xmath1068-comodules , free and finitely generated as @xmath1059-modules . by lemma 2 from [ two - lemmas ] , which is applicable according to the proof of lemma 2 above , the right hand side is isomorphic to @xmath1069 . indeed ,
one readily checks that for any object @xmath10 of the exact category @xmath1070 of right @xmath111-comodules , free and finitely generated as @xmath93-modules , and any object @xmath1071 there is a natural isomorphism @xmath1072 , since there is a similar isomorphism for morphisms of graded @xmath93-modules and @xmath627 is @xmath65-flat .
this proves the desired assertion .
the case when @xmath94 is @xmath65-flat is easily dealt with using the condition ( c ) from theorem 2 of subsection [ generalities ] below .
when @xmath65 is an artinian local commutative ring and @xmath1073 is its residue field , a stronger assertion holds .
namely , if @xmath94 is quadratic and @xmath848 is @xmath65-flat for @xmath31 , @xmath81 , and @xmath82 , then koszulity of @xmath1074 implies koszulity of @xmath94 and @xmath65-flatness of @xmath848 for all @xmath33 .
the proof is similar to that of ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 7.3 of chapter 6 ) . recall the definition of a quadratic big ring from subsection [ diagonal - is - quadratic ] and the definitions of a quadratic coring and the quadratic duality from the first proof in subsection
[ quadratic - realized ] .
let @xmath778 be a graded coring over a big ring @xmath626 such that @xmath779 .
let @xmath352 denote the exact category of graded right @xmath111-comodules that are free and finitely generated as graded right @xmath626-modules , and let @xmath361 be the category of graded right @xmath111-comodules that are flat as graded right @xmath626-modules .
let @xmath1075 and @xmath1076 denote the @xmath626-bimodules whose components @xmath1077 are the groups @xmath269 in the categories @xmath352 and @xmath361 between the free right @xmath626-modules with one generator placed in the gradings @xmath107 and @xmath2 .
the following conditions are equivalent : 1 .
@xmath1078 for all @xmath1055 and @xmath1079 is a flat right @xmath626-module for all @xmath37 ; 2 .
@xmath1080 for all @xmath1055 and @xmath1081 is a flat right @xmath626-module for all @xmath37 ; 3 .
the cobar - complex has no cohomology outside of the diagonal @xmath985 , and its cohomology on this diagonal are flat right @xmath626-modules ; 4 .
the coring @xmath111 is quadratic , and for any @xmath443 the lattice of subbimodules of the @xmath626-bimodule @xmath1082 generated by the subbimodules @xmath1083 , @xmath1084 , is distributive and the quotient bimodule for any pair of embedded bimodules in this lattice is a flat right @xmath626-module . let @xmath830 be a big graded ring with the zero - degree component @xmath1085 . consider the reduced bar - complex @xmath1086 where @xmath1087 ; this complex is bigraded with the ( cohomological ) grading @xmath37 by the number of tensor factors and the ( internal ) grading @xmath22 induced by the grading of @xmath94 . for a left @xmath94-module @xmath842 and a right @xmath94-module @xmath171 , let @xmath1088 denote the derived functor of tensor product of @xmath94-modules .
the groups @xmath1088 inherit the internal grading of @xmath842 , @xmath171 , and @xmath94 .
assume that the components @xmath984 are flat right @xmath626-modules .
then the following conditions are equivalent : 1 .
the graded abelian group @xmath1088 is concentrated in degree @xmath37 for any finitely generated free ( left and right ) @xmath626-modules @xmath842 and @xmath171 considered as graded @xmath94-modules concentrated in degree @xmath107 ; 2 . the graded abelian group @xmath1088 is concentrated in degree @xmath37 for any left @xmath626-module @xmath842 and any flat right @xmath626-module @xmath171 considered as graded @xmath94-modules concentrated in degree @xmath107 ; 3 .
the bar - complex has no cohomology outside of the diagonal @xmath1089 ; 4 .
the big ring @xmath94 is quadratic with the @xmath626-bimodule of quadratic relations @xmath1090 , and for any @xmath443 the lattice of subbimodules of the @xmath626-bimodule @xmath1091 generated by the subbimodules @xmath1092 , @xmath1084 , is distributive .
suppose a quadratic big ring @xmath94 and a quadratic coring @xmath111 are quadratic dual to each other .
consider the tensor products @xmath1093 and @xmath1094 ; they are endowed with the differentials constructed as the composition @xmath1095 of the comultiplication and the multiplication maps , and analogously for @xmath1094 .
define the internal grading on @xmath1093 and @xmath1094 by the rule that the component @xmath1096 or @xmath1097 lives in the grading @xmath1098 .
the complexes @xmath1093 and @xmath1094 are called the _ koszul complexes _ of the quadratic dual big ring @xmath94 and coring @xmath111 .
the following conditions are equivalent : 1 .
the big graded ring @xmath94 satisfies the equivalent conditions of theorem ; 2 .
the graded coring @xmath111 satisfies the equivalent conditions of theorem ; 3 . the components @xmath984 are flat right @xmath626-modules and either of the koszul complexes @xmath1093 or @xmath1094 is exact in the internal grading @xmath443 . a big graded ring @xmath94 or a graded coring @xmath111
is called _ right flat koszul _ if it satisfies the equivalent conditions of theorem 2 or theorem 1 , respectively .
according to corollary , quadratic dual quadratic big ring and quadratic coring are koszul simultaneously .
notice that our terminology is consistent : if @xmath94 is a big graded ring whose components @xmath984 are flat right @xmath93-modules , then @xmath94 is right flat koszul in the sense of the above definition if and only if it is koszul in the sense of the definition given in the beginning of this section . to see this , it suffices to compare theorem from [ flat - koszul ] with the above theorem 1(c ) and use corollary .
it was explained in [ flat - koszul ] how to prove the equivalence of ( a ) , ( b ) , and ( c ) in theorem 1 .
proving the equivalences ( a)@xmath1099(c ) and ( b)@xmath1099(c ) in theorem 2 is easy , since one can compute the @xmath1100 in terms of the bar - complex . to prove the equivalence of ( c ) and ( d ) in both theorems , one can use lemma 1 and the big ring version of lemma 2(a ) from ( * ? ? ?
* subsection 11.4.3 ) .
this also allows to prove the equivalence of ( a ) and ( b ) in corollary and deduce ( c ) from ( a - b ) .
finally , to pass from ( c ) of corollary to theorem 2(a ) one simply uses the koszul complex as a resolution of free ( left or right ) @xmath626-modules considered as @xmath94-modules concentrated in degree @xmath107 .
when one is thinking of the conditions ( a - b ) of theorem 2 , one keeps in mind that for any nonnegatively graded ring @xmath94 whose components are flat right @xmath626-modules , the graded abelian groups @xmath1101 are concentrated in degrees @xmath1102 . without the flatness condition ,
this is no longer true . for a counterexample
, it suffices to consider a field @xmath65 , the ring of polynomials in one variable @xmath1103 $ ] , and the graded commutative ring @xmath1104/(xy)$ ] with @xmath1105 and @xmath1106 .
another example is the graded ring @xmath834 over @xmath1107 with @xmath1108 , @xmath1109 , and @xmath1110 for @xmath17 .
the graded ring @xmath834 is koszul ( see example in the beginning of section [ koszul - rings - secn ] ) . to compute @xmath1111 one
can replace @xmath834 with its flat graded dg - algebra resolution over @xmath1112 and write down the bar - complex of the resolution .
hence one finds that the graded group @xmath1113 vanishes for even @xmath696 and is isomorphic to the group @xmath1114 placed in the degree @xmath1115 for odd @xmath33 .
of course , one can still use the reduced bar - complex to compute the @xmath1100 over @xmath94 _ relative to _
@xmath626 in the nonflat case , so the relative @xmath1100 is concentrated in the usual degrees .
let @xmath1116 be a nonnegatively graded ring and @xmath625 be a morphism of rings such that @xmath984 are flat right @xmath626-modules and flat right @xmath627-modules for all @xmath1117 .
then it follows from our results that the graded rings @xmath94 and @xmath1118 satisfy the conditions of theorem 2 simultaneously .
this can be proved directly in several ways . in particular
, one can use the spectral sequence @xmath1119 corresponding to the morphism of rings @xmath1120 .
there is also a simple lattice - theoretical argument .
[ nonfiltered - secn ] for any big graded ring @xmath830 , denote by @xmath1121 the `` quadratic part '' of @xmath94 , i. e. , the quadratic ring for which there is a natural morphism of big graded rings @xmath1122 that is an isomorphism in degrees @xmath38 and @xmath156 , and a monomorphism in degree @xmath135 .
the following set of stronger assumptions on the morphism @xmath1122 and the big graded ring @xmath1121 will play the key role in this section : @xmath1123 let @xmath104 be an exact category , @xmath344 be a small additive category , and @xmath345 be a fully faithful additive functor .
consider the category @xmath344 as an exact category with the trivial exact category structure and use the construction of example from section [ associated - graded - secn ] to obtain an exact category @xmath89 with full subcategories @xmath231 and a twist functor @xmath128 .
let @xmath309 denote the forgetful functor .
let @xmath769 be a full subcategory such that every object of @xmath344 is a finite direct sum of objects from @xmath693 .
consider the big graded ring @xmath1124 over the set @xmath695 .
assume that the big graded ring @xmath94 satisfies .
then the natural maps @xmath1125 are isomorphisms for all @xmath10 , @xmath941 and @xmath1126 , and the big graded ring @xmath1127 is isomorphic to @xmath1121 .
the case @xmath38 is clear .
according to part ( 2 ) of theorem from section [ filtered - exact - secn ] , the morphisms @xmath1128 are isomorphisms for @xmath10 , @xmath941 and @xmath1129 , and monomorphisms for @xmath1130 .
the former observation proves both assertions of proposition for @xmath31 . by the result of subsection [ diagonal - is - quadratic ]
, one has @xmath1131 for @xmath1132 and the big graded ring @xmath1133 is quadratic .
this establishes the second assertion in all degrees .
we have not yet used the assumptions so far . since by the assumption the component @xmath804 is multiplicatively generated by @xmath138 , the first assertion of proposition for @xmath135 also follows . now consider the exact category @xmath352 constructed in section [ associated - graded - secn ] . from the long exact sequence
we see that @xmath1134 , @xmath1135 for @xmath1136 , and @xmath1137 .
let us prove by induction that @xmath1138 for @xmath1139 .
assume that @xmath1140 for @xmath1141 .
let @xmath993 denote the exact category from subsection [ quadratic - realized ] corresponding to the quadratic ring @xmath1121 .
then the exact subcategories @xmath1042}$ ] and @xmath1142}$ ] are naturally equivalent .
since the ring @xmath1121 is koszul , one has @xmath1143 for @xmath153 .
hence @xmath1144 for @xmath1145 .
consequently , the map @xmath1146 is an isomorphism . by the assumption ,
the map @xmath1147 is a monomorphism .
it follows that the map @xmath1148 is a monomorphism , too .
. now since @xmath1121 is koszul , we have @xmath1149 for all @xmath1055 , hence the map @xmath1150 is an isomorphism for all @xmath1151 . in the above setting ,
assume that every object of @xmath104 can be obtained from objects of @xmath1152 by iterated extensions .
then the natural maps @xmath1153 are isomorphisms for all @xmath10 , @xmath359 and @xmath149 . the cases @xmath38 and @xmath156 are easy and do not depend on the assumption of lemma .
to check surjectivity of our maps for all @xmath37 , it suffices to notice that the functor @xmath260 is surjective on objects .
one can use corollary [ exact - triangulated].1 to prove both surjectivity and injectivity .
alternatively , use lemma 2 from [ two - lemmas ] for the functor @xmath260 , which satisfies its assumption . this argument does not depend on the assumption that the exact category structure on @xmath344 is trivial .
when it is , one can additionally notice that all the maps @xmath1125 constituting our inductive systems are injective for @xmath154 .
the following example was suggested to the author by a. beilinson . consider the case when the functor @xmath346 is an equivalence of additive categories .
then the natural maps @xmath1154 are isomorphisms for all @xmath10 , @xmath941 and @xmath1126 .
indeed , present any class in @xmath1155 as the composition of a chain of classes in @xmath1156 with @xmath1157 , @xmath1158 , and @xmath1159 . for
all @xmath1160 , choose objects @xmath729 so that @xmath1161 ; set @xmath699 and @xmath1162 . clearly , there are unique classes in @xmath1163 lifting the given classes in @xmath1156
. the product of these classes provides a class in @xmath1164 .
one checks that this construction defines a map @xmath1165 inverse to the natural map that we are interested in . using the construction of the exact category @xmath352 from section [ associated - graded - secn ] and the long exact sequence ( cf .
[ main - theorem ] ) , one can conclude that the big graded ring @xmath1166 is koszul .
let @xmath104 be a small exact category and @xmath1167 be a full subcategory such that every object of @xmath104 can be obtained from objects of @xmath693 by iterated extensions .
consider the big graded ring @xmath1168 over the set @xmath695 .
the following theorem is a far - reaching generalization of the main result of @xcite .
assume that the big graded ring @xmath94 satisfies the assumptions .
then @xmath94 is quadratic ( and consequently , koszul ) .
consider the full additive subcategory @xmath1169 consisting of the finite direct sums of objects from @xmath693 , and apply proposition and lemma .
let @xmath6 be a triangulated category and @xmath1170 be a full exact subcategory closed under extensions ( see [ exact - triangulated ] ) .
let @xmath1167 be a full subcategory such that every object of @xmath104 can be obtained from objects of @xmath693 by iterated extensions .
in addition to the above big graded ring @xmath94 , consider the big graded ring @xmath1171))_{y , x\in{{\mathcal j}};{\mskip .5\thinmuskip\relax}n\ge0}$ ] over the same set @xmath695 .
the following corollary generalizes the results of ( * ? ? ?
* section 5 ) .
assume that the big graded ring @xmath834 satisfies .
then the natural morphism @xmath1172 induces an isomorphism of big graded rings @xmath1173 .
in particular , if the big graded ring @xmath834 is koszul , then @xmath1174 and the natural morphisms @xmath1175)$ ] are isomorphisms for all @xmath10 , @xmath105 and @xmath132 . by corollary [ exact - triangulated].2 ,
the morphism @xmath1172 is an isomorphism in the degrees @xmath107 and @xmath156 and a monomorphism in the degree @xmath81 .
it follows that @xmath1176 and @xmath94 satisfies whenever @xmath834 does .
if this is the case , @xmath94 is quadratic by theorem , hence @xmath1173 .
if @xmath834 is also quadratic , then @xmath1174 and induction by the number of iterated extensions proves the last assertion of corollary .
one can easily extend lemma , theorem , and corollary to the situation when every object of @xmath104 is a direct summand of an object obtained from objects of @xmath693 ( resp .
@xmath344 ) by iterated extensions .
it suffices to use corollary [ exact - triangulated].3 .
let @xmath6 be a triangulated category and @xmath228 be its full subcategories , closed under extensions and such that @xmath929)=0 \quad\text{for $ x\in{{\mathcal e}}_i$ , \
$ y\in{{\mathcal e}}_j$ , \
$ n\ge-1 $ , and $ n > j - i$.}\ ] ] let @xmath104 be an exact category and @xmath230 be a triangulated functor mapping @xmath231 into @xmath104 .
assume that @xmath1177)\rarrow \operatorname{ext}_{{\mathcal e}}^n(x , y)$ } \\
\text{are isomorphisms for all $ x\in{{\mathcal e}}_i$ , \
$ y\in{{\mathcal e}}_j$ , \
$ n\ge-1 $ , and $ n\le j - i$. } \end{array}\ ] ] finally , assume that there exists a triangulated autoequivalence @xmath128 on @xmath6 such that @xmath337 and there is a functorial isomorphism @xmath1178 for all @xmath1179 .
let @xmath29 be the minimal full subcategory of @xmath6 , containing all @xmath231 and closed under extensions ; by @xcite or [ exact - triangulated ] , @xmath29 has a natural structure of exact category .
let @xmath769 be a full subcategory such that every object of @xmath344 is a finite direct sum of objects of @xmath693 .
consider the big graded ring @xmath1124 .
the natural morphisms @xmath1180)$ ] are isomorphisms for all @xmath10 , @xmath30 and @xmath149 if and only if the big graded ring @xmath94 is koszul . by part ( 1 ) of theorem from section [ filtered - exact - secn ] ,
the exact category @xmath29 is equivalent to the exact category @xmath89 constructed in example from section [ associated - graded - secn ] for the trivial exact category structure on @xmath344 . now
the `` if '' part follows from proposition from section [ nonfiltered - secn ] . to prove `` only if '' , it suffices to consider the exact category @xmath352 constructed in section [ associated - graded - secn ] .
it follows from the long exact sequence that @xmath772 for all @xmath255 , @xmath256 , and @xmath143 , and that the big graded ring @xmath1181 can be identified with @xmath94 .
thus @xmath94 is koszul .
let @xmath4 , @xmath1182 , @xmath1183 $ ] , or @xmath0 , @xmath1184 , be a coefficient ring and @xmath1 be a field . in the remaining part of this paper we discuss conjectural properties of certain subcategories of the triangulated category @xmath3 of motives over @xmath1 with coefficients in @xmath65 .
a few words about the definition of @xmath3 are due .
we are not in a position to discuss various definitions of the triangulated category of motives existing in the literature , so we simply presume that the category we are considering is the `` right '' triangulated category .
voevodsky s definition @xcite is certainly a good approximation , as it is very natural and has many properties that are important for us .
however , their proofs sometimes depend on various undesirable assumptions , such as that the field @xmath1 is perfect , has finite tale dimension over @xmath65 , or has resolution of singularities .
other known definitions have some other properties that are also important for us @xcite . in the course of our discussion , we refer to various results as to indicators of the properties that the `` right '' category is supposed to have .
let @xmath85 be a galois field extension .
consider the full triangulated subcategory @xmath1185 generated by the artin
tate motives @xmath83(i)$ ] , where @xmath83 $ ] are the motives of finite field extensions @xmath84 contained in @xmath842 , and @xmath1186 , @xmath90 denotes the tate twist .
let @xmath29 be the minimal full subcategory of @xmath6 , containing the objects @xmath83(i)$ ] and closed under extensions .
any morphism @xmath47 $ ] of degree @xmath696 in @xmath6 between two objects @xmath10 , @xmath30 can be presented as the composition of a chain of morphisms @xmath697 $ ] with @xmath698 , @xmath699 , and @xmath700 . by propositions 2 - -4 from appendix [ silly - filtrations - appx ] , this conjecture can be equivalently restated as follows : @xmath1187*{\dotsb}*{{\mathcal m}}[-a],\ ] ] where @xmath257 denotes the class of all extensions of objects from two given classes in a triangulated category @xcite .
iterated extensions of this form generalize silly filtrations on complexes ; thus the above conjecture can be called the _ silly filtration conjecture for artin
tate motives_. consider the case when @xmath72 and @xmath1188 is prime to @xmath2 . in this case
, there is the tale realization functor @xmath260 ( * ? ? ?
* subsection 3.3 ) ( see also @xcite ) from @xmath3 to the derived category @xmath1189 of the abelian category @xmath104 of discrete @xmath57-modules over @xmath0 , where @xmath57 is the absolute galois group of @xmath1 . the functor @xmath260 takes the object @xmath83(i)$ ] to the @xmath57-module @xmath1190 $ ] , where @xmath1191 is the module of @xmath2-roots of unity . the milnor
kato conjecture implies @xcite the beilinson lichtenbaum formulas @xmath1192(i),{\mskip .5\thinmuskip\relax}k[l''](j)[n])&\simeq
\operatorname{ext}^n_{{\mathcal e}}(\phi(k[l'](i)),{\mskip .5\thinmuskip\relax}\phi(k[l''](j ) ) ) , \quad\
! \text{for $ \,n\le j - i$ ; } \\
\operatorname{hom}_{{\mathcal d}}(k[l'](i),{\mskip .5\thinmuskip\relax}k[l''](j)[n])&=0 , \quad\ ! \text{otherwise . } \end{aligned}\ ] ] assuming , by part ( 1 ) of theorem from section [ filtered - exact - secn ] the exact subcategory @xmath1193 is equivalent to the exact category @xmath89 of filtered discrete @xmath57-modules @xmath78 over @xmath0 with a finite decreasing filtration @xmath166 such that the @xmath57-module @xmath79 is isomorphic to a direct sum of copies of `` cyclotomic - permutational '' @xmath57-modules @xmath1190 $ ] , where @xmath84 are finite extensions , @xmath86 . by the results of appendix [ categories - of - morphisms - appx ]
, this equivalence can be extended to a triangulated functor @xmath1194 .
the main conjecture from [ main - conjecture ] holds for @xmath65 and @xmath88 if and only if the functor @xmath1195 is an equivalence of triangulated categories .
this provides an elementary description of the triangulated category @xmath6 in terms of the galois group @xmath57 , solving ( for artin tate motives over a field ) the problem posed in ( * ? ? ?
* subsection 5.10.d(vi ) ) .
notice that even when @xmath1196 is algebraically / separably closed , the category of `` cyclotomic - permutational '' @xmath57-modules is still substantially different from the category of all discrete @xmath57-modules over @xmath65 , as there are many discrete @xmath57-modules that are not direct summands of permutational ones .
ignoring this difference , one could consider the exact category @xmath196 of all finitely filtered discrete @xmath57-modules over @xmath65 , with exact triples that become split after passing to associated graded @xmath57-modules . for the exact category @xmath196 , the beilinson
lichtenbaum formulas always hold ( see example from section [ nonfiltered - secn ] ) and no additional hypotheses are needed .
the supporting evidence for conjecture from [ main - conjecture ] that we possess is based on the properties of the big graded ring @xmath1197,k[l''](n)[n]))_{k{\subset}l''{,\medspace}l'{\subset}m}\ ] ] over the set of all ( isomorphism classes over @xmath1 of ) intermediate fields @xmath86 finite over @xmath1 .
when the extension @xmath85 is finite , one can equivalently consider the conventional graded ring . by
* theorem 3.4 ) , the @xmath65-module @xmath1198,k[l '' ] ( n)[n])$ ] is isomorphic to the direct sum of the degree-@xmath37 components of milnor k - theory rings @xmath1199 over the field direct summands @xmath171 of the tensor product @xmath1200 .
the multiplication in @xmath94 is described in terms of the multiplications in the milnor rings and the maps of inclusion and transfer between the milnor rings induced by morphisms of fields over @xmath1 . according to theorem from subsection [ diagonal - is - quadratic ]
, it follows from conjecture that the ( big ) graded ring @xmath94 is quadratic . in the case of tate motives , i. e. , when @xmath1201 , this is obviously so , since the milnor k - theory ring is quadratic by definition . in the general case of artin tate motives , it is not difficult to see that the ( big ) graded ring @xmath94 is multiplicatively generated by @xmath138 over @xmath93 . in fact
, it is only essential that the set of all fields @xmath84 entering into the definition of @xmath94 is closed under the operation of taking the composite extensions . for further evidence , see [ koszul - cases ] and
[ cyclic - extension ] , and also @xcite .
let us consider the three `` koszul '' cases ( i - iii ) from subsection [ introd - list - of - situations ] one by one . when @xmath69 and @xmath1202 , the beilinson
parshin conjecture @xcite predicts that @xmath1198,k[l''](i)[n])=0 $ ] for @xmath1203 . by part ( 1 ) of theorem from subsection [ triangulated - koszul ]
, it follows that conjecture from [ main - conjecture ] holds if and only if the ( big ) graded ring @xmath94 is koszul in the sense of the definition given in the beginning of section [ koszul - rings - secn ] .
similarly , when @xmath71 and @xmath1204 , it is known @xcite that @xmath1198,k[l'']{\allowbreak}(i)[n])=0 $ ] for @xmath1203 .
again , it follows that conjecture holds if and only if the ( big ) graded ring @xmath94 is koszul in the sense of the beginning of section [ koszul - rings - secn ] . finally , when @xmath72 and @xmath1 contains a primitive @xmath2-root of unity , the tale realization functor @xmath260 transforms the twist functor @xmath128 on @xmath6 to the identity functor on @xmath1189 , so the conditions of [ main - theorem ] are satisfied . assuming , by theorem from [ main - theorem ] ( and the last assertion of corollary [ exact - triangulated].2 ) it follows that conjecture holds if and only if the ( big ) graded ring @xmath94 is koszul in the same sense . in any of the above three cases
, in order to interpret the koszulity condition , one can replace the component @xmath93 of the graded ring with @xmath1205 , or replace the component @xmath93 of the big graded ring with @xmath1206 for @xmath1207 and @xmath107 otherwise .
the koszul property of the ( big ) graded ring @xmath94 is equivalent to the same property of the ( big ) graded ring @xmath1208 , and the latter ( big ) graded ring is flat over its zero - degree component @xmath709 , so the characterization of koszulity from subsections [ flat - koszul]--[generalities ] applies .
when @xmath65 is a field , this further simplifies to the classical koszul property of @xmath65-algebras @xcite . by corollary from [ flat - koszul ] ,
the koszulity conditions for coefficients @xmath71 or @xmath1209 in the cases ( ii ) and ( iii ) are equivalent to the koszulity conditions for the coefficients @xmath1210 or @xmath1211 , where @xmath1212 or @xmath1213 are prime numbers .
consider the case when @xmath74 and the field @xmath1201 contains a primitive @xmath75-root of unity .
it was proven in @xcite that koszulity of the milnor algebra @xmath1214 for all finite extensions @xmath1 of a given field @xmath166 implies the milnor bloch
kato conjecture for the field @xmath166 , assuming that the latter conjecture holds in small degrees ( the norm residue homomorphism in an isomorphism in the degree @xmath135 and a monomorphism in the degree @xmath1215 ) .
furthermore , koszulity of @xmath1214 together with the beilinson lichtenbaum conjecture implies conjecture from [ main - conjecture ] for tate motives with coefficients @xmath1211 over @xmath1 , as explained in [ koszul - cases ] .
conversely , assuming the milnor bloch
kato conjecture and conjecture from [ main - conjecture ] for tate motives with coefficients in @xmath1211 , koszulity of the algebra @xmath1214 follows due to @xcite and [ koszul - cases ] .
so koszulity of the milnor algebra @xmath1214 together with the low - degree part of the milnor
kato conjecture are equivalent to the full milnor bloch
kato conjecture together with conjecture from [ main - conjecture ] for tate motives with finite coefficients @xmath1211 .
when all these conjectures hold , the triangulated category @xmath6 of tate motives with coefficients @xmath1211 over @xmath1 is simply described as the derived category @xmath1216 of the exact category @xmath89 of finitely filtered discrete @xmath57-modules @xmath78 over @xmath1211 such that @xmath57 acts trivially on the quotient modules @xmath79 .
thus the silly filtration conjecture provides a motivic interpretation @xcite of the koszulity conjecture from @xcite .
let @xmath1 be a field and @xmath1136 be an integer prime to @xmath1188 .
imagine that there is a @xmath0-linear triangulated category @xmath1217 generated by objects @xmath1218 for all @xmath1219 dividing @xmath2 and @xmath90 .
there is a shift functor @xmath128 on @xmath1217 transforming @xmath1218 to @xmath1220 , and the triangulated subcategory in @xmath1217 generated by @xmath1221 is identified with the bounded derived category of @xmath0-modules .
the conventional triangulated category @xmath6 of tate motives with coefficients @xmath0 over @xmath1 is embedded into @xmath1217 as the triangulated subcategory generated by @xmath58 .
one has @xmath1222 ) = 0 $ ] for all @xmath102 and @xmath22 , @xmath101 .
finally , there is the tale realization functor @xmath1223 , where @xmath104 denotes the abelian category of discrete @xmath57-modules over @xmath0 .
this functor agrees with the tale realization functor for @xmath1224 ( so the groups @xmath1225 are described by the beilinson
lichtenbaum formulas ) and its restriction to the subcategory generated by @xmath1221 coincides with the obvious functor ( of `` trivial @xmath57-action '' ) from the bounded derived category of @xmath0-modules to @xmath1189
. then one can easily prove by induction on the cohomological degree @xmath37 that the subcategories @xmath1226 consisting of finite direct sums of the objects @xmath1227 satisfy the conditions ( [ triang - vanish - area][triang - bl - area ] ) .
thus the minimal full subcategory @xmath1228 containing all @xmath1218 and closed under extensions is equivalent to the exact category @xmath196 of finitely filtered discrete @xmath57-modules @xmath78 over @xmath0 such that the quotient @xmath57-modules @xmath1229 are finitely generated over @xmath0 with a trivial action of @xmath57 .
let @xmath29 denote the minimal full subcategory of @xmath6 containing the objects @xmath58 and closed under extensions
. it would be interesting to know under what assumptions all the maps @xmath1230 are isomorphisms , or equivalently , all the maps @xmath1231)$ ] are isomorphisms .
let @xmath74 and @xmath85 be a cyclic extension of degree @xmath75 of fields containing a primitive @xmath75-root of unity .
assume that the milnor
kato conjecture holds for fields @xmath842 and @xmath1 and coefficients @xmath65 . in this case
, the graded ring has the form @xmath1232{,\medspace}k\op k[g_k / g_m ] ) \\ & \simeq h^*(g_k,{{\mathbb
z}}/l)\oplus h^*(g_m,{{\mathbb z}}/l)\oplus h^*(g_m,{{\mathbb z}}/l)\oplus h^*(g_m,{{\mathbb z}}/l)[g_k / g_m],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath104 is the abelian category of discrete @xmath57-modules over @xmath1211 .
there is a conjecture ( * ? ? ?
* conjecture 16 ) that @xmath1233 is a koszul module over a koszul algebra @xmath1234 . by (
* corollary 6.2@xmath178(b ) ) , it follows from this conjecture that the graded algebra @xmath1235 is koszul .
consequently , the graded ring @xmath94 is also koszul .
thus , according to [ koszul - cases ] , conjecture from [ main - conjecture ] follows from ( * ? ? ?
* conjecture 16 ) for such a field extension @xmath85 and coefficients @xmath65 .
let @xmath65 be a coefficient ring and @xmath1236 be a tower of fields such that @xmath85 is a galois extension .
then the silly filtration conjecture for artin tate motives holds for the field extension @xmath1237 provided that it holds for the extension @xmath85 with the same coefficients @xmath65 . indeed , passage to the inductive limit with respect to the functors of extension of scalars reduces the quesion to the case when the field extension @xmath1238 is finite . in this case , the functor of extension of scalars @xmath1239 is right adjoint to the functor of restriction of scalars @xmath1240 .
both functors send the artin
tate motives @xmath1241(i)$ ] or @xmath1242(i)$ ] over @xmath1 or @xmath1243 corresponding to fields @xmath1244 to ( finite direct sums of ) similar motives over @xmath1243 or @xmath1 , respectively .
moreover , any motive @xmath1242(i)$ ] over @xmath1243 is a direct summand of the image of the motive @xmath1241(i)$ ] under the extension of scalars functor .
the assertion now follows from ( the dual version of ) proposition [ silly - filtrations - appx].1 .
let @xmath75 be a prime number and @xmath1 be a field of characteristic different from @xmath75 having no finite separable extensions of degree prime to @xmath75 .
set @xmath1196 to be the separable closure of @xmath1 and let @xmath94 be the corresponding big graded ring of diagonal @xmath46 for artin tate motives with coefficients @xmath1211 .
consider also the related big graded ring @xmath708 ( see [ koszul - cases ] ) .
assume that the galois symbol ( norm residue homomorphism ) for finite extensions of the field @xmath1 and coefficients @xmath1211 is an isomorphism in degree @xmath135 and a monomorphism in degree @xmath1215 .
then whenever the big graded ring @xmath94 ( or , equivalently , @xmath708 ) is koszul , this map is an isomorphism in all degrees for such fields and such coefficients .
this follows from theorem from section [ nonfiltered - secn ] .
this is another version of the approach to the milnor
kato conjecture suggested in @xcite .
notice that by [ at - base - change ] the koszulity condition that appears here holds for all algebraic extensions of a field @xmath1 if holds for @xmath1 . as a general heuristic rule , the cohomology algebra @xmath1245 of an object @xmath10 is koszul ( as a graded ring with the cohomological grading ) if and only if two conditions hold : 1 .
@xmath10 is of a @xmath44 type ; and 2 .
the dg - algebra computing @xmath1245 is `` quasi - formal '' , meaning that the higher massey products ( defined as the differentials in the spectral sequence converging from the cohomology of the bar - construction of @xmath1245 to the cohomology of the bar - construction of the dg - algebra computing it ) in @xmath1245 vanish .
in particular , any formal dg - algebra ( i. e. , dg - algebra which can be connected with its cohomology by a chain of multiplicative quasi - isomorphisms ) is quasi - formal .
concerning the @xmath44 condition , it has to be interpreted in a way consistent with the cohomology theory under consideration .
a discussion of the situation when @xmath10 is a rational homotopy type and @xmath1246 can be found in @xcite . in particular ,
given a profinite group @xmath1247 and a prime number @xmath75 , the cohomology algebra @xmath1248 is koszul if and only if 1 .
the natural map @xmath1249 induced by the map @xmath1250 from the group @xmath1247 to its maximal quotient pro-@xmath75-group @xmath1251 is an isomorphism of graded algebras ; and 2 .
the higher massey products in @xmath1248 vanish . assuming that @xmath1248 is koszul
, a proof of ( 1 ) can be found in ( * ? ? ?
* section 5 ) and ( 2 ) tautologically holds for the grading reasons . to deduce koszulity from ( 1 ) and
( 2 ) , notice that the coalgebra @xmath1252 of locally constant @xmath1253-valued functions on @xmath1251 is conilpotent , hence the bar - construction of its cobar - construction , being quasi - isomorphic to it ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 6.10(b ) ) , has cohomology concentrated in degree @xmath107 . a very general version of the implication koszulity @xmath1254 @xmath44 is provided by corollary in section [ nonfiltered - secn ] .
since it suffices to prove the milnor bloch
kato conjecture for the fields whose galois groups are pro-@xmath75-groups , it follows that this conjecture , taken together with the silly filtration conjecture for tate motives with coefficients @xmath1211 over fields containing a primitive @xmath75-root of unity , are equivalent to the assertion that the higher massey products in @xmath1234 vanish for any such field @xmath1 .
notice that the dg - algebra computing the galois cohomology with coefficients in @xmath1211 is _ not _ in general formal , only conjecturally quasi - formal .
indeed , the koszulity means that the associated graded coalgebra of @xmath1255 with respect to the coaugmentation filtration is koszul and quadratic dual to @xmath1234 @xcite .
the formality would mean that @xmath1255 is isomorphic to this associated graded coalgebra , i. e. , admits a koszul grading .
let @xmath1 be a finite extension of @xmath1256 or @xmath1257 , with @xmath1258 ; assume that @xmath1 contains a primitive @xmath75-root of unity if @xmath75 is odd , or a square root of @xmath1259 if @xmath1260 .
then the algebra @xmath1234 is an exterior algebra with two generators @xcite , so its quadratic dual coalgebra is a symmetric coalgebra with two generators .
if the group coalgebra @xmath1252 of @xmath1261 were quasi - isomorphic to the latter coalgebra , it would mean that @xmath1261 is commutative .
this is not the case ; in fact , @xmath1261 is a semidirect product of two copies of @xmath1262 with one of them acting nontrivially in the other one . the following attempt to describe the triangulated category of tate motives / motivic sheaves with finite coefficients @xmath0 over a smooth variety @xmath627 over a field @xmath1 of characteristic not dividing @xmath2 looks natural .
its development was influenced by the author s conversations with v. vologodsky .
consider the exact category @xmath89 whose objects are finitely filtered tale sheaves of @xmath0-modules @xmath1263 over @xmath627 such that the quotient sheaf @xmath1264 is the tensor product of a sheaf of @xmath0-modules lifted from the zariski / nisnevich topology of @xmath627 with the tale sheaf @xmath59 .
let @xmath6 be the full triangulated subcategory of @xmath1216 generated by the tate objects @xmath58 , which are identified with the sheaves @xmath59 placed in the filtration component @xmath22 .
then @xmath6 is the candidate triangulated category of tate motivic sheaves over @xmath627 . the main piece of evidence supporting this conjecture that is presently known to the author is that both the motivic cohomology of @xmath627 and the @xmath0-modules @xmath8 between the tate objects in the triangulated category @xmath6 localize in the zariski topology .
so it suffices to consider the case when @xmath627 is the spectrum of the local ring of a scheme point on a smooth variety . a different version of this construction ( for artin
tate rather than tate motivic sheaves ) is shown to work , under certain assumptions , in the forthcoming paper @xcite .
the following purports to answer a question posed to the author by v. vologodsky .
let @xmath205 be a discrete valuation ring with the quotient field @xmath1 and the residue field @xmath65 .
let @xmath1265 be a power of a prime different from @xmath1266 .
consider the embeddings of schemes @xmath1267 and @xmath1268 .
the functor @xmath1269 is supposed to take the triangulated subcategory of tate motives in @xmath61 into the triangulated subcategory of tate motives in @xmath1270 . below we suggest a conjectural description of this functor on tate motives in terms of complexes of filtered modules over the absolute galois groups @xmath57 and @xmath1271
. there is a natural closed subgroup @xmath1272 corresponding to the henselization @xmath413 of the discrete valuation field @xmath1 .
the group @xmath1271 is the quotient group of @xmath1273 by the inertia subgroup @xmath703 .
since @xmath1274 , the maximal quotient pro-@xmath75-group @xmath1275 of the group @xmath703 is naturally isomorphic to the projective limit @xmath1276 of the groups @xmath1277 of @xmath1278-roots of unity in @xmath1279 ( or equivalently , in @xmath1280 ) , while the ( profinite ) order of the group @xmath1281 is not divisible by @xmath75 .
let @xmath78 be a finitely filtered discrete @xmath57-module over @xmath0 whose quotient modules @xmath1282 are finite direct sums of the modules @xmath59 .
restrict the action of @xmath57 in @xmath171 to @xmath1273 ; since the subgroup @xmath1283 acts in @xmath171 by endomorphisms unipotent with respect to the filtration @xmath166 , its action factorizes through @xmath1284 .
hence the quotient group @xmath1285 acts in @xmath171 .
let @xmath1286 be a topological generator of the group @xmath1287 and @xmath1288 be the corresponding generator of the group @xmath1289 .
consider the map @xmath1290 .
since @xmath1286 acts trivially in @xmath242 , this map shifts the filtration , i. e. , defines a morphism of filtered @xmath0-modules @xmath1291 .
unless @xmath65 contains all the @xmath1278-roots of unity , this map does not respect the action of @xmath1285 , however . to deal with this problem , consider the expression @xmath1292 , defined for all nonnegative integers @xmath37 and taking values in the endomorphisms of @xmath171 .
the equations @xmath1293 and @xmath1294 hold .
one easily checks that the function @xmath1295 can be extended by continuity to a locally constant function of @xmath1296 . for any @xmath1296 , set @xmath1297 ; then @xmath1298 is a @xmath156-cocycle of the group @xmath1284 with coefficients in the filtration - preserving endomorphisms of @xmath171 , i. e. , the equation @xmath1299 holds for @xmath1300 , @xmath1301 . for any @xmath1302 , set @xmath1303
; then the function @xmath1304 takes values in the automorphisms of @xmath171 unipotent with respect to @xmath166 and satisfies the cocycle equation @xmath1305 .
let @xmath1306 be the action of @xmath1285 in @xmath1307 induced by the actions of @xmath1285 in @xmath171 and @xmath1289 .
define a new action @xmath1308 by the rule @xmath1309 , where @xmath1310 is the cyclotomic character .
this new action is associative due to the above cocycle equation for @xmath630 , since @xmath1311 .
denote the filtered @xmath0-module @xmath1307 endowed with this new action of the group @xmath1285 by @xmath1312 .
then @xmath1312 is a finitely filtered @xmath1285-module with cyclotomic associated quotients , and one readily checks that @xmath1313 is a morphism of filtered @xmath1285-modules . replacing @xmath1286 with @xmath1314 , where @xmath1302 , we obtain another similar morphism @xmath1315 .
the isomorphism of filtered @xmath1285-modules @xmath1316 identifies the morphisms @xmath1317 and @xmath1318 , which makes the two - term complex of filtered @xmath1285-modules @xmath1313 , denoted symbolically by @xmath1319 , defined uniquely up to a unique isomorphism .
now we can assign to any bounded complex @xmath1320 of finitely filtered discrete @xmath57-modules over @xmath0 with cyclotomic associated quotients the total complex of the bicomplex with two rows @xmath1321 .
the complex so obtained is a bounded complex of finitely filtered @xmath1285-modules with cyclotomic associated quotients .
we need to transform it into a similar complex of @xmath1271-modules .
pick a uniformizing element @xmath1322 in the ring @xmath205 ( or even in the field @xmath413 ) . then one can extend the field @xmath413 by adjoining a compatible system of @xmath1278-roots of @xmath1322 .
this ( not necessarily normal , but separable ) algebraic field extension corresponds to a section @xmath1323 of the surjective profinite group homomorphism @xmath1324 .
composing the action of @xmath1285 with this section , we obtain the desired complex of filtered @xmath1271-modules .
a change of the compatible system of @xmath1278-roots of @xmath1322 corresponds to an element of the kernel @xmath1325 of the group homomorphism @xmath1324 , and the conjugation with this element transforms one of the related two sections @xmath1323 into the other .
the action of this element defines the complex of @xmath1271-modules that we have constructed as independent of the choice of the compatible system of roots of @xmath1322 up to a unique isomorphism .
finally , assume that @xmath1326 and @xmath1327 are two uniformizing elements , and compatible systems of @xmath1278-roots have been chosen for each of them .
then we have two sections @xmath1328 , @xmath1329 differing by a cocycle @xmath1330 ; so @xmath1331 .
consider the two two - term complex of @xmath1271-modules @xmath1332 and @xmath1333 obtained by composing the action of @xmath57 in the two - term complex @xmath1313 with @xmath1328 and @xmath1334 .
we will construct a two - term complex of finitely filtered @xmath1271-modules with cyclotomic associated quotients @xmath1335 together with two quasi - isomorphisms @xmath1336 and @xmath1337 mapping this intermediate complex onto each of the two complexes that we need to compare . the filtered @xmath1271-module @xmath1338 is simply the direct sum @xmath1339 ; its morphisms @xmath1336 and @xmath1337 to @xmath1340 and @xmath1341 are the projections to the direct summands .
the filtered @xmath1271-module @xmath1342 is an extension of @xmath1343 with the kernel @xmath1340 .
we construct it as the filtered @xmath0-module @xmath1344 endowed with the action of @xmath1271 given by the formula @xmath1345 for @xmath1346 , @xmath1347 , and @xmath1348 .
this action is associative due to the cocycle equations for @xmath1295 .
the morphisms @xmath1349 and @xmath1350 are given by the rules @xmath1351 and @xmath1352 .
one checks that the kernels of @xmath1336 and @xmath1337 are contractible two - term complexes .
notice that the above construction is not applicable to artin tate motives , since the action of @xmath1276 on the associated quotient modules of the related filtered modules can be nontrivial , so the compatibility with the filtration breaks down . due to the results of this paper ( see section [ koszul - rings - secn ] ) , we now know what it _ means _ for the milnor ring ( with integral coefficients ) @xmath1353 of a field @xmath1 to be koszul .
it is still a mystery whether one should expect it to _ be _ koszul for an arbitrary field @xmath1 , or what the motivic interpretation of it being koszul might consist in .
in fact , we do not know this even for the algebra @xmath1354 ( see [ introd - list - of - situations ] ) .
fix a field @xmath1 .
we are interested in a negatively internally graded dg - algebra @xmath94 over @xmath1112 ( see appendix [ kpi1-appendix ] ) such that for any coefficient ring @xmath65 as above the full triangulated subcategory of the derived category of internally graded dg - modules over @xmath1355 generated by the free dg - modules @xmath1356 is equivalent to the full triangulated subcategory of @xmath3 generated by the tate objects @xmath1357 . moreover , the free dg - modules @xmath1356 should correspond to the tate objects @xmath1357 under this equivalence of triangulated categories , and the underlying bigraded @xmath1112-module of the dg - algebra @xmath94 should be flat ( i. e. , torsion - free )
. in particular , the cohomology @xmath1358 of the dg - algebra @xmath1355 should be isomorphic to the motivic cohomology of @xmath1 with coefficients in @xmath65
. there must be many candidate constructions of the dg - algebra @xmath94 obtainable from the contemporary literature ; we will suggest just one such construction adopted to voevodsky s definition @xcite of the triangulated category of geometric motives .
it was inspired by the papers @xcite .
consider the additive category @xmath1359 of smooth schemes over @xmath65 and finite correspondences between them , and pass to the dg - category of bounded complexes over @xmath1359 .
the latter is a tensor dg - category with respect to the cartesian product of schemes over @xmath65 ; in particular , there is the dg - endofunctor of tate twist acting on it . consider the full dg - subcategory of the `` relations '' of homotopy invariance and mayer vietoris ; close it under the tate twists and apply the construction of drinfeld localization ( * ? ? ?
* section 3 ) . set @xmath1360 for @xmath1361 , the @xmath46 being taken in the dg - category we have constructed ; @xmath137 , and @xmath1362 for @xmath62 .
it is clear that this construction is compatible with tensoring with a ring of coefficients @xmath65 in a reasonable sense .
another approach is to use one of the various constructions of the complex of algebraic cycles ( see e. g. @xcite ) in the role of @xmath94 .
now let @xmath111 denote the reduced bar - construction of the dg - algebra @xmath94 over @xmath1112 . by theorem
[ kpi1-appendix].1 , the main conjecture from [ main - conjecture ] for @xmath1363 and @xmath4 is equivalent to the dg - coalgebra @xmath111 having no cohomology in the positive cohomological degrees , @xmath1364 for @xmath1037 . by proposition [ kpi1-appendix].2@xmath178(1 ) , the beilinson
soul vanishing conjecture with rational coefficients is equivalent to @xmath1365 having no cohomology in the negative cohomological degrees , @xmath1366 for @xmath102 .
for the same reason , one expects @xmath1367 for @xmath102 if @xmath1 has a prime characteristic @xmath638 ( see [ koszul - cases ] ) . finally , by theorem [ kpi1-appendix].2@xmath178(1 ) , the beilinson
lichtenbaum conjecture implies @xmath1368 for @xmath1369 and any prime number @xmath1213 . by the universal coefficients formula
, it follows that one should expect @xmath1364 for all @xmath123 .
however , @xmath1370 is not supposed to be a torsion - free @xmath1112-module ; indeed , it should have nontrivial @xmath75-torsion for any @xmath1213 .
conversely , if @xmath1364 for @xmath123 , then @xmath1371 for @xmath1372 , @xmath1373 for @xmath102 and any coefficient ring @xmath65 , and the silly filtration conjecture holds for @xmath1363 and any @xmath65 . as to the cohomology coalgebra @xmath1374 , one can expect it to be described by the assertions of theorem [ kpi1-appendix].2@xmath178(2 - 3 ) . in general ,
given a flat dg - coalgebra @xmath111 over @xmath1112 with nonflat cohomology @xmath193 , there is no way to define a coalgebra structure on @xmath193 , as the natural map @xmath1375 has no natural inverse .
when @xmath1364 for @xmath123 , there is a natural coassociative coalgebra structure on @xmath1370 .
moreover , assume that @xmath111 is negatively internally graded , and consider the minimal full subcategory @xmath29 of the derived category of internally graded dg - comodules over @xmath111 , containing the trivial dg - comodules @xmath1376 and closed under extensions . since the homological dimension of @xmath1112 is equal to @xmath156 , @xmath29 is an exact subcategory of the triangulated category @xmath6 it generates .
now there is an exact cohomology functor from @xmath29 to the exact category @xmath352 of comodules over @xmath1370 , free and finitely generated as @xmath1112-modules .
but this functor is not an equivalence .
it suffices to consider the example when @xmath1377 is the algebraic closure of a finite field . in this case
, the internally graded dg - coalgebra @xmath111 should be quasi - isomorphic to the dg - coalgebra with the only nonzero components @xmath1378 and @xmath1379\rarrow{{\mathbb q}})$ ] , the term @xmath1380 $ ] being placed in the cohomological degree @xmath1259 and the term @xmath5 in the cohomological degree @xmath107 , with the identity embedding of @xmath1380 $ ] into @xmath5 as the differential . using the reduced cobar - construction
, one can compute that @xmath1381 and @xmath1382 $ ] for @xmath110 , while all the other @xmath8 groups between the objects @xmath1376 in the exact category @xmath29 vanish ( cf .
[ finite - field - tate - motives ] ) . in the exact category @xmath352
, the groups @xmath1383 for @xmath285 differ from those in @xmath29 ( while all the other @xmath8 groups between the objects @xmath1376 are the same ) . nor such a description of the exact category @xmath29 in terms of the nonflat coalgebra @xmath1370 , if it existed , would be of much use ; see remark in section [ koszul - rings - secn ] .
instead , it appears that one has to learn how to work with the dg - coalgebra @xmath111 up to a quasi - isomorphism in the class of negatively internally graded dg - coalgebras with torsion - free underlying bigraded @xmath1112-modules .
it is impossible in general to recover such a quasi - isomorphism class of a dg - coalgebra @xmath111 with @xmath1364 for @xmath123 from the graded coalgebra structure on @xmath1370 , as one can see in the case when @xmath782 and @xmath783 are nonzero , while @xmath1384 for @xmath1385 .
the point is , the map of complexes of @xmath1112-modules @xmath1386 is not determined , as a morphism in the derived category of @xmath1112-modules , by the induced map of the cohomology .
one example when the derived category of tate motives with integral coefficients admits an elementary construction is that of motives over a finite field .
one expects that @xmath1387)&\simeq \mu_{q^i-1}^{\ot i } , \quad \text{for \ $ i\ge0 $ ; } \\ \operatorname{hom}_{{{\mathcal d}}{{\mathcal m}}(\mathbb{f}_q,{{\mathbb z}})}({{\mathbb z}}(0),{{\mathbb z}}(i)[n])&=0 , \quad \text{for \ $ i\ne0 $ , \ $ n\ne1$. } \end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath1388)=0 $ ] for @xmath696 , the silly filtration condition is trivial in this case .
one can construct an exact category @xmath89 with the @xmath8 groups given by , except that @xmath1389 is replaced with @xmath1390 , in the following way .
first let us describe an exact category @xmath89 resembling mixed tate motives over the algebraic closure of a finite field @xmath1391 with integral coefficients .
consider the category of finitely filtered abelian groups @xmath78 endowed with a ( fixed ) splitting of the filtration over @xmath1392 , i. e. , @xmath1393 . here
@xmath1392 denotes the localization of @xmath1112 at the prime ideal @xmath1394 .
it is also required that @xmath242 be a finitely generated free abelian group .
define the objects @xmath1395 as the groups @xmath1112 placed in the filtration component @xmath22 .
then one has @xmath1396 and @xmath1397 $ ] for @xmath110 , while all the remaining @xmath8 groups between the objects @xmath1376 vanish .
all objects of @xmath89 are iterated extensions of @xmath1376 .
now consider the case of mixed tate motives over @xmath1398 with coefficients in @xmath1380 $ ] .
consider the exact category @xmath89 of finitely filtered @xmath1380$]-modules @xmath78 endowed with an endomorphism @xmath1399 that is compatible with the filtration @xmath166 and acts by multiplication with @xmath1400 on the successive quotient @xmath79 . it is required that @xmath242 be a finitely generated free module over @xmath1380 $ ] .
define the objects @xmath1380(i)\in{{\mathcal f}}$ ] as the modules @xmath1380 $ ] placed in the filtration component @xmath22 , with @xmath1295 acting on them by @xmath1400 .
then one has @xmath1401(i),{{\mathbb z}}[q^{-1}](i))={{\mathbb z}}[q^{-1}]$ ] and @xmath1402(i),{{\mathbb z}}[q^{-1}](j))\simeq { { \mathbb z}}/(q^{j - i}-1)$ ] for @xmath1403 , while all the remaining @xmath8 groups between the objects @xmath1380(i)$ ] vanish .
finally , to construct an exact category @xmath89 resembling mixed tate motives over @xmath1398 with integral coefficients , consider finitely filtered abelian groups @xmath78 endowed with a family of endomorphisms @xmath1404 such that @xmath1405 for @xmath1403 and the action of @xmath1406 on @xmath79 is the identity endomorphism .
define the objects @xmath1395 as the groups @xmath1112 placed in the filtration component @xmath22 , with @xmath1407 acting on them by @xmath1408 .
then one has @xmath1396 and @xmath1409 for @xmath1403 , while all the remaining @xmath8 groups between the objects @xmath1376 vanish .
one of the most important problems of the theory around the milnor
kato conjecture is to describe as precisely as possible the special properties of absolute galois groups , their cyclotomic characters , their subgroups , their cohomology , etc .
one particular aspects of this problem is to describe the behavior of galois cohomology with constant / cyclotomic coefficients with respect to extensions of the field @xmath1 .
this project was originally conceived as an approach to the latter problem .
the hope was that the main conjecture from [ main - conjecture ] would impose strong restrictions on the behavior of galois cohomology in field extensions .
this hope did not quite materialize , as it now appears that the main conjecture is not so strong .
consider the case of a cyclic extension of prime degree @xmath85 and arbitrary coefficients @xmath65 .
then the graded algebra @xmath94 from is isomorphic to @xmath1410).\ ] ] the multiplication in this algebra is defined in terms of the map @xmath1411 induced by the embedding of fields @xmath1412 , the transfer map @xmath1413 , and the action of @xmath1414 on @xmath1415 .
we have mentioned already in [ supporting - evidence ] that the algebra @xmath94 is generated by @xmath138 over @xmath93 .
furthermore , _ either _ a weak form of hilbert theorem 90 for the milnor k - theory _ or _ the statement of the bass tate lemma are both sufficient to conclude that @xmath94 is quadratic .
and in the situation of [ cyclic - extension ] , koszulity of @xmath94 follows from the conjecture from @xcite , but there is no apparent way to obtain the converse implication .
thus the main our achievements in this paper are the connection of the silly filtration conjecture with koszulity conjectures established in [ koszul - cases ] and the elementary construction of the category of mixed artin tate motives with finite coefficients obtained in [ elementary - description ] .
in addition , there is the result of [ classical - kpi1-integral ] on the @xmath44-conjecture with integral coefficients .
a _ preadditive category _ @xmath13 is a category in which the set of morphisms @xmath1416 between any two given objects is endowed with the structure of an abelian group in such a way that the composition maps are biadditive .
a functor @xmath1417 between preadditive categories is called _ additive _ if it takes the sums of morphisms in @xmath13 to the sums of morphisms in @xmath26 .
in particular , a preadditive category with a single object is the same that a ( noncommutative ) ring .
for this reason , we will use the term _ big ring over _ a set @xmath706 as another name for a small preadditive category with the set of objects @xmath1418 .
in other words , a big ring over @xmath706 is a collection of abelian groups @xmath1419 , @xmath1420 , together with multiplication maps @xmath1421 and unit elements @xmath1422 satisfying the conventional axioms .
let @xmath1423 denote the category of abelian groups .
a _ left module _ over a big ring @xmath94 over @xmath706 is another name for a covariant additive functor @xmath1424 , and a _ right module _ over @xmath94 is a contravariant additive functor between the same categories .
in other words , a left @xmath94-module @xmath842 is a collection of abelian groups @xmath1425 together with action maps @xmath1426 , and similarly for right modules . given a big ring @xmath94 over @xmath706 and a big ring @xmath834 over @xmath1427 , a _
bimodule _ @xmath1 over @xmath94 and @xmath834 is a collection of abelian groups @xmath1428 together with biaction maps @xmath1429 satisfying the obvious triadditivity , associativity , and unit axioms .
it follows from the latter definition that a bimodule over big graded rings can not be literally viewed as a left or a right module over one of the big rings ; rather , it is a _ collection _ of left @xmath94-modules and a collection of right @xmath834-modules .
nevertheless , we will speak of bimodules as if they have underlying left and right module structures , omitting the references to collections of modules for brevity .
any operations with collections of modules are performed with every module in the collection , providing the corresponding collections of outputs ; any properties of collections of modules are meant to hold for _ every _ module in the collection .
let @xmath842 be a left @xmath94-module and @xmath171 be a right @xmath94-module ; then the _ tensor product _ @xmath1430 is the abelian group generated by the formal symbols @xmath1431 , where @xmath1432 and @xmath1433 , subject to the conventional relations @xmath1434 for any @xmath1435 , @xmath1436 , and @xmath1437 , and biadditivity .
as explained above , this simultaneously defines the operation of tensor product of bimodules ; in particular , the tensor product of two @xmath94-bimodules is again an @xmath94-bimodule .
the category of @xmath94-(bi)modules is an abelian category satisfying ab5 and ab4 * , with a set of generators , and enough projectives and injectives @xcite . for any set @xmath703 mapping into @xmath706 one
defines the _ free _ left @xmath94-module @xmath842 generated by @xmath703 by the rule @xmath1438 , and similarly for free right modules .
these are just direct sums of representable functors on @xmath13 .
an @xmath94-module is _ projective _ if and only if it is a direct summand of a free module .
the functor of tensor product over @xmath94 is right exact .
a right @xmath94-module @xmath171 is _ flat _ if the functor @xmath1439 is exact on the abelian category of left @xmath94-modules .
any projective @xmath94-module is flat .
one defines the left derived functors @xmath1101 for @xmath149 , a right @xmath94-module @xmath171 and a left @xmath94-module @xmath842 , by the conventional derived functor procedure , using projective or flat resolutions .
the derived functors have the standard properties of the functor @xmath1100 over a ring ; in particular , resolving either argument leads to the same result .
a big ring @xmath94 over a set @xmath706 is said to be graded if every abelian group @xmath1440 is graded . in this paper , we only consider big rings graded by nonnegative integers .
thus a _ big graded ring _ is a collection of abelian groups @xmath1441 endowed with multiplication maps @xmath1442 and unit elements @xmath1443 satisfying the conventional biadditivity , associativity , and unit axioms .
one can consider graded modules over big graded rings in the obvious sense . for a further discussion of rings with several objects , see @xcite . one can show that if an object @xmath10 of a preadditive category @xmath13 is the product of a finite set of objects @xmath1444 , then it is also the coproduct of this set of objects , and vice versa .
in this case , @xmath10 is called the _ direct sum _ of @xmath1445 . an _ additive category _ is a preadditive category in which the ( co)product of any finite set of objects exists .
the preadditive category structure on an additive category can be recovered from its abstract category structure . following the terminology of a. neeman s paper @xcite , we call an additive category @xmath13 _ semi - saturated _
( _ weakly idempotent complete _ ) if any pair of its morphisms @xmath1446 and @xmath1447 such that @xmath1448 comes from an isomorphism @xmath1449 for some object @xmath1450 .
an additive category is called _ saturated _ ( _ karoubian _ , _ pseudo - abelian _ , _ idempotent complete _ ) if any its morphism @xmath1451 such that @xmath1452 is the projection on a direct summand of a decomposition @xmath1449 . for any additive category
@xmath13 there exists a unique , up to a uniquely defined equivalence , semi - saturated additive category @xmath1453 ( called the _ semi - saturation _ of @xmath13 ) together with an additive functor @xmath1454 such that any additive functor from @xmath13 to a semi - saturated additive category @xmath26 can be factorized through the functor @xmath1455 in a unique , up to an isomorphism , way .
there also exists a unique , up to a uniquely defined equivalence , saturated additive category @xmath1456 ( called the _ saturation _ of @xmath13 ) together with an additive functor @xmath1457 satisfying the same condition with respect to functors from @xmath13 to saturated additive categories @xmath26 .
let @xmath13 be a full additive subcategory of an additive category @xmath26 .
then the _ semi - saturation closure _ @xmath1458 of the subcategory @xmath13 in @xmath26 is the full subcategory of @xmath26 whose objects are all the objects @xmath1459 for which there exists an object @xmath11 such that the object @xmath1460 is also isomorphic to an object from @xmath13 .
the _ saturation closure _ @xmath1461 of a subcategory @xmath13 is defined in the same way except that one allows @xmath1462 .
for example , any additive category admitting either the kernels or the cokernels of all morphisms ( see below ) is saturated .
any triangulated category is semi - saturated .
a triangulated subcategory of a triangulated category is thick if and only if it coincides with its saturation closure @xcite .
the saturation of a triangulated category is naturally a triangulated category again @xcite . to see
just how bad a nonsaturated additive category can be , consider the category @xmath13 of all vector spaces @xmath205 over a field @xmath65 such that @xmath1463 , @xmath81 , or @xmath1464 .
this is an additive subcategory of the category of vector spaces , since it is closed under direct sums .
the category @xmath13 is not even semi - saturated . on the other hand ,
the category @xmath26 of all finite - dimensional vector spaces of dimension divisible by @xmath82 over @xmath65 is an example of a semi - saturated , but not saturated additive category .
the category of finitely generated free modules over a ring @xmath626 is not even semi - saturated in general .
a morphism @xmath1465 in a preadditive category @xmath13 is called the _ kernel _ of a morphism @xmath1466 if for any object @xmath1450 the sequence @xmath1467 is exact ; in this case we write @xmath1468 and @xmath1469 .
analogously , a morphism @xmath1470 is called the _ cokernel _ of a morphism @xmath1466 if for any object @xmath1450 there is an exact sequence @xmath1471 the notation : @xmath1472 and @xmath1473 .
a morphism @xmath112 is called _ injective _ if one has @xmath1474 and _ surjective _ if @xmath1475 . throughout this appendix
, we will sometimes use the following notation for computations in additive categories : the composition of several ( previously defined ) morphisms , say @xmath586 , @xmath489 , and @xmath1476 , will be denoted by @xmath1477 $ ] . then
an equation like @xmath1478=[x{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}t{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}z]$ ] means that the morphisms form a commutative square , etc .
there is a very detailed recent exposition @xcite of the theory of exact categories , covering most of the material that one needs to know in order to feel at ease while working with these things .
the purpose of the following subsections is to complement that exposition with several observations which will tend to add some clarity as far as our goals are concerned , or present an independent interest .
let @xmath104 be an additive category endowed with a class of _ admissible _ ( or _ exact _ ) _ triples _ of objects and morphisms @xmath1479 a morphism @xmath586 in the category @xmath104 will be called an _ admissible monomorphism _ if it can be embedded into an admissible triple @xmath1480 and an _ admissible epimorphism _ if there exists an admissible triple @xmath1481 .
an additive category
@xmath104 together with a class of admissible triples @xmath1482 is called an _ exact category _ if it satisfies the following axioms ex0 - -ex3 : * the zero triple @xmath1483 is admissible .
any triple isomorphic to an admissible triple is admissible .
* for any admissible triple @xmath1484 and any object @xmath1485 there are exact sequences @xmath1486 in other words , the morphisms @xmath381 and @xmath1487 are each other s kernel and cokernel .
* let @xmath1484 be an admissible triple .
then ( a ) for any morphism @xmath1488 there exists a commutative diagram @xmath1489 with an admissible triple @xmath1490 ; and analogously , ( b ) for any morphism @xmath1491 there exists a commutative diagram @xmath1492{y } \arrow{e } \arrow{n } \node{y '' } \arrow{n } \end{diagram}\ ] ] with an admissible triple @xmath1493 . *
\(a ) the composition of any two admissible monomorphisms is an admissible monomorphism .
( b ) the composition of any two admissible epimorphisms is an admissible epimorphism .
this list of axioms roughly corresponds to the axioms for exact categories commonly used in modern expositions @xcite , with two exceptions .
firstly , the numbering is different , and secondly , our axiom ex2 is usually stated in a different form ; see axiom ex@xmath388 below .
we prefer our axiom ex2 .
we will show that for any class of admissible triples @xmath1482 satisfying ex0 - -ex2 the diagrams and in ex2 are defined uniquely up to a unique isomorphism by the original triple @xmath1484 and the morphism @xmath1488 or @xmath1491 , respectively .
the object @xmath117 in the diagram is necessarily the fibered coproduct of the morphisms @xmath1488 and @xmath381 and the object @xmath117 in the diagram is the fibered product of the morphisms @xmath1491 and @xmath1487 . in other words ,
the axiom ex2 is equivalent modulo ex0ex1 to the following axiom ex@xmath388 . *
\(a ) for any admissible monomorphism @xmath381 and any morphism @xmath1488 there exists a fibered coproduct @xmath1494 in the category @xmath104 and the natural morphism @xmath1495 is an admissible monomorphism .
+ ( b ) for any admissible epimorphism @xmath1487 and any morphism @xmath1491 there exists a fibered product @xmath1496 in the category @xmath104 and the natural morphism @xmath1497 is an admissible epimorphism .
furthermore , the axiom ex2 together with the condition that the additive category @xmath104 be semi - saturated is equivalent modulo ex0 - -ex1 to the following axiom ex@xmath1498 . *
\(a ) a right divisor @xmath409 of an admissible monomorphism @xmath1499 is an admissible monomorphism .
+ ( b ) a left divisor @xmath112 of an admissible epimorphism @xmath1499 is an admissible epimorphism .
+ ( c ) if in the following commutative diagram @xmath1500{x_2 } \arrow{ne } \end{diagram}\ ] ] both triples @xmath1501 and @xmath1502 are admissible , then the morphism @xmath1503 is an isomorphism .
the conditions ex@xmath1498(a - b ) are a stronger version of the last `` obscure '' axiom in quillen s list of axioms for exact categories @xcite .
the obscure axiom claims that a right divisor of an admissible monomorphism is an admissible monomorphism provided that it has a cokernel , and a left divisor of an admissible epimorphism is an admissible epimorphism provided that it has a kernel .
it is known @xcite that the obscure axiom follows from the other ones .
the above stronger form of the obscure axiom holds if and only if @xmath104 is semi - saturated @xcite . the condition ex@xmath1498(c )
follows from ex0 - -ex1 and any of the conditions ex2@xmath178(a ) or ex2@xmath178(b ) .
finally , it is known that the conditions ex3@xmath178(a ) and ex3@xmath178(b ) are equivalent modulo ex0ex2 ( see @xcite ) .
sketches of proofs of the above equivalence assertions are given in the next subsection . in what follows
we assume that an additive category @xmath104 is endowed with a class of admissible triples satisfying the axioms ex0 - -ex1 .
it follows from the condition that if in the diagram the triple @xmath1490 is admissible and the morphism @xmath1487 is the cokernel of the morphism @xmath381 , then the object @xmath117 is the fibered coproduct @xmath1494 in the category @xmath104 .
analogously , it follows from that if in the diagram the triple @xmath1493 is admissible and the morphism @xmath381 is the kernel of the morphism @xmath1487 , then the object @xmath117 is the fibered product @xmath1496 .
we have to show that for any object @xmath1485 there is a bijective correspondence between the set of all morphisms @xmath1504 and the set of all pairs of morphisms @xmath1505 and @xmath1506 which form a commutative diagram with @xmath1488 and @xmath381 .
suppose a morphism @xmath1504 is annihilated by the compositions with @xmath1495 and @xmath586 . by ex1
, @xmath112 factorizes through the morphism @xmath1507 .
since the morphism @xmath1487 is assumed to be a cokernel , it follows that @xmath108 .
now let us assume that we are given a compatible pair of morphisms @xmath1505 and @xmath1506 .
applying ex2 to the admissible triple @xmath1490 and the morphism @xmath1505 , we obtain an admissible triple @xmath1508 together with the commutative diagram @xmath1509 consider the morphism @xmath1510 that is equal to the difference of two compositions @xmath1511 - [ x{\medspace { \overset{\scriptscriptstyle h}{\rightarrow}}\medspace}z{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}t]$ ] .
we have @xmath1512=0 $ ] , since @xmath1513 = [ x'{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}y'{\medspace { \overset{\scriptscriptstyle g}{\rightarrow}}\medspace}z{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}t]$ ] and @xmath1514 = [ x'{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}x{\medspace { \overset{\scriptscriptstyle h}{\rightarrow}}\medspace}z]$ ] .
therefore , the morphism @xmath1515 factorizes into the composition @xmath1516 $ ] for some morphism @xmath1517 .
the composition @xmath1518 is the identity , since @xmath1519 = [ x{\medspace { \overset{\scriptscriptstyle \chi}{\rightarrow}}\medspace}t{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}x '' ] = [ x{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}y{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}t{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}x '' ] - [ x{\medspace { \overset{\scriptscriptstyle h}{\rightarrow}}\medspace}z{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}t{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}x '' ] = [ x{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}x'']$ ] and the morphism @xmath1487 is surjective .
it follows that the morphism @xmath1520 $ ] annihilates @xmath1521 and , therefore , factorizes into the composition @xmath1522 $ ] for some morphism @xmath1523 .
let us check that the morphism @xmath1524 $ ] is the desired one .
we have @xmath1525 = [ y{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}t{\medspace { \overset{\scriptscriptstyle \psi}{\rightarrow}}\medspace}z{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}t ] = [ y{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}t ] - [ y{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}t{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}x''{\medspace { \overset{\scriptscriptstyle \phi}{\rightarrow}}\medspace}t]= [ y{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}t ] - [ y{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}x''{\medspace { \overset{\scriptscriptstyle \phi}{\rightarrow}}\medspace}t]$ ] .
now @xmath1526 = [ x{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}y{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}t ] - [ x{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}y{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}x''{\medspace { \overset{\scriptscriptstyle \phi}{\rightarrow}}\medspace } t ] = [ x{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}y{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}t ] - [ x{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}x''{\medspace { \overset{\scriptscriptstyle \phi}{\rightarrow}}\medspace}t ] = [ x{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}y{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}t ] - [ x{\medspace { \overset{\scriptscriptstyle \chi}{\rightarrow}}\medspace } t ] = [ x{\medspace { \overset{\scriptscriptstyle h}{\rightarrow}}\medspace}z{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}t]$ ] , which implies @xmath1527 = [ x{\medspace { \overset{\scriptscriptstyle h}{\rightarrow}}\medspace}z]$ ] . similarly , @xmath1528 = [ y'{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}y{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}t ] - [ y'{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}y{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}x''{\medspace { \overset{\scriptscriptstyle \phi}{\rightarrow}}\medspace } t ] = [ y'{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}y{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}t ] = [ y'{\medspace { \overset{\scriptscriptstyle g}{\rightarrow}}\medspace } z{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}t]$ ] , hence @xmath1529=[y'{\medspace { \overset{\scriptscriptstyle g}{\rightarrow}}\medspace } z]$ ]
. the conditions and are equivalent modulo .
analogously , the conditions and are equivalent modulo .
if the axioms are satisfied , then the axiom holds if and only if the additive category @xmath104 is semi - saturated and the axiom holds .
it follows from proposition 1 that any of the conditions ex2@xmath178(a ) or ex2@xmath178(b ) implies ex@xmath1498(c ) .
we already know that ex2 is equivalent to ex@xmath388 , and it is proven in @xcite that ex@xmath388 implies ex@xmath1498(a - b ) if @xmath104 is semi - saturated .
conversely , is easy to see @xcite that @xmath104 is semi - saturated whenever any of the conditions ex@xmath1498(a ) or ex@xmath1498(b ) holds .
we will deduce ex2 from ex@xmath1498 below .
let @xmath1484 be an admissible triple and @xmath1488 be a morphism . by the condition ex@xmath1498(a ) , the morphism @xmath1530 is an admissible monomorhism .
let @xmath1531 be its cokernel .
clearly , there exists a unique morphism @xmath1507 such that the diagram is commutative and the composition @xmath1490 is zero . by the condition ex@xmath1498(b ) , the morphism @xmath1507 is an admissible epimorphism .
it remains to show that the morphism @xmath1495 is its kernel .
it is clear that the morphism @xmath1507 is the cokernel of the morphism @xmath1495 .
let @xmath1532 be the kernel of the morphism @xmath1507 ; then there is a natural morphism @xmath1533 .
first let us show that the latter morphism is surjective .
suppose that the composition @xmath1534 vanishes for a certain morphism @xmath1535 . repeating the above construction starting with the admissible triple @xmath1536 and the morphism @xmath1535
, we obtain a commutative diagram @xmath1537{z } \arrow{e } \node{t } \end{diagram}\ ] ] where the triple @xmath1538 is admissible . since the morphism @xmath1532 is injective , the morphism @xmath1476 is injective , too .
since the composition @xmath1539 = [ y'{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}k{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}z{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}t]$ ] vanishes and the morphism @xmath1507 is the cokernel of the morphism @xmath1495 , the morphism @xmath1540 factorizes into the composition @xmath1541 for some morphism @xmath1542 .
hence @xmath1543 = [ k{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}y{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}x''{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}t ] = 0 $ ] , and it follows that @xmath1544 = 0 $ ] .
now consider the commutative diagram @xmath1545{k\op x } \arrow{ne } \end{diagram}\ ] ] the upper triple is admissible , and the morphism @xmath1546 is an admissible monomorphism by ex@xmath1498(a ) .
using the fact that the vertical morphism is surjective , one can check that the morphism @xmath1547 is the cokernel of the morphism @xmath1546 .
it remains to apply the condition ex@xmath1498(c ) .
the following counterexample shows that the condition ex@xmath1498(c ) is indeed necessary .
let @xmath13 be the additive category whose objects are morphisms of vector spaces @xmath1548 endowed with a subspace @xmath1549 and let @xmath1550 be the class of all triples for which ex1 holds .
one can check that this class of admissible triples satisfies ex0 - -ex1 , ex@xmath1498(a - b ) , and ex3 , but not ex@xmath1498(c ) .
note that if two classes of triples @xmath1551 and @xmath1552 satisfy the axioms ex0 - -ex2 , then their union @xmath1553 also does .
in particular , one has to use the axiom ex3 in order to prove that the direct sum of two admissible triples is an admissible triple .
the next counterexample shows that even if one assumes the latter property , the conditions ex0 - -ex2 still would nt imply ex3 .
let @xmath26 be the abelian category of 3-term sequences of vector spaces and morphisms @xmath1554 ( the composition can be nonzero ) .
there are six indecomposable objects in this category ; we will denote them by @xmath1555 , @xmath1556 , @xmath1557 , @xmath1558 , @xmath1559 , @xmath1560 , where @xmath1561 for @xmath1562 and @xmath107 otherwise .
let @xmath1563 be the class of all exact triples @xmath1484 in the abelian category @xmath26 such that for any morphism @xmath1564 the triple @xmath1565 induced from the original triple using the composition of morphisms @xmath1566 is split .
then it is not difficult to check that the class @xmath1563 satisfies ex0 - -ex2 and is closed under direct sums , but the composition of two admissible monomorphisms @xmath1567 and @xmath1568 is not an admissible monomorphism with respect to @xmath1569 .
an additive functor between exact categories is said to be _ exact _ if it sends admissible triples to admissible triples .
some examples of exact categories are listed below .
\(1 ) the trivial exact category structure : for any additive category @xmath13 , the class of all split triples @xmath1570 satisfies the axioms of an exact category .
\(2 ) the canonical exact category structure on an abelian category : the class of all short exact sequences in any abelian category satisfies the axioms ex0 - -ex3 .
\(3 ) let @xmath1571 be an exact category and @xmath1572 be a full additive subcategory .
then @xmath104 is called a _ full exact subcategory _ of @xmath13 if the class @xmath1482 of all triples in the category @xmath104 which belong to @xmath1550 is an exact category structure on @xmath104 .
any of the following two conditions is sufficient for @xmath104 to be a full exact subcategory in @xmath13 : ( a ) the subcategory @xmath104 contains the middle term @xmath10 of any admissible triple @xmath1484 in the category @xmath13 whenever it contains both terms @xmath553 and @xmath1573 ; or ( b ) the subcategory @xmath104 contains the remaining term of an admissible triple in the category @xmath13 whenever it contains the middle term and one of the other terms .
\(4 ) let @xmath13 and @xmath26 be exact categories , @xmath264 be an additive category , and @xmath1574 , @xmath1575 be additive functors sending admissible triples to triples satisfying ex1 . consider the category @xmath104 whose objects are pairs of objects @xmath1576 and @xmath1577 together with an isomorphism @xmath1578 .
set a triple in @xmath104 to be admissible if its images in @xmath13 and @xmath26 are admissible .
then @xmath104 is an exact category .
\(5 ) a _ filtered object _
@xmath10 in an exact category @xmath104 is a collection of objects @xmath1579 for all @xmath1580 and morphisms @xmath1581 for all @xmath1582 and @xmath1583 compatible with the compositions and such that all the triples @xmath1584 are admissible . a triple of filtered objects @xmath1484 is admissible if all the triples @xmath1585 are admissible in the category @xmath104 , or equivalently , all the triples @xmath1586 are admissible , where one denotes @xmath1587 . a _ finitely filtered object _ is a filtered object @xmath10 such that one has @xmath1588 for all but a finite number of indices @xmath711 .
the category of ( finitely ) filtered objects in an exact category is an exact category .
\(6 ) let @xmath104 be an exact category .
define a triple in @xmath1589 or @xmath1590 to be admissible if it is a direct summand of an admissible triple in @xmath104
. then @xmath1589 and @xmath1590 become exact categories , and @xmath104 is closed under extensions ( cf .
( 3a ) ) in each of them .
conversely , if @xmath13 is an exact category and @xmath1572 is a full exact subcategory such that every object of @xmath13 is a direct summand of an object of @xmath104 , then @xmath104 is closed under extensions in @xmath13 if and only if every triple from @xmath1550 is a direct summand of a triple from @xmath1482 .
\(7 ) let @xmath13 be an additive category in which all morphisms admit kernels and cokernels .
for any morphism @xmath1466 in @xmath13 consider the natural morphism @xmath1591 .
then the morphism @xmath1592 is surjective for any morphism @xmath112 in @xmath13 if and only if the composition of any two kernels is a kernel ( of some morphism ) in @xmath13 , if and
only if a right divisor of any kernel is a kernel , and if and only if any two morphisms @xmath381 and @xmath1488 , the former of which is a kernel , can be embedded into a commutative square @xmath1593 = [ x'{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}y'{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}y]$ ] , where the morphism @xmath1495 is injective . the dual assertions relate injectivity of the morphisms @xmath1594 with the properties of cokernels .
the class of all triples satisfying axiom ex1 defines an exact category structure on @xmath13 if and only if it satisfies axiom ex@xmath1498(c ) and all the above properties of kernels and cokernels hold in @xmath13 . in this case
, the additive category @xmath13 is said to be _ quasi - abelian_. ( cf .
@xcite . )
example [ exact - proofs].1 shows that the requirement of axiom ex@xmath1498(c ) can not be dropped . for an example of an additive category where kernels do not have the above properties , consider the abelian category @xmath26 from example [ exact - proofs].2 and its full subcategory @xmath13 whose objects are the direct sums of all the indecomposables except @xmath1558 .
then the morphism @xmath1595 is a composition of two kernels but not a kernel , and the morphism @xmath1592 is not surjective ( moreover , it is a kernel ) .
\(8 ) one can show that any semi - saturated additive category @xmath13 admits a maximal exact category structure , that is a class of triples satisfying ex0 - -ex3 and containing any other such class of triples .
more precisely , it is clear that in any additive category @xmath13 there exists a maximal class of triples satisfying ex0 - -ex2 .
in fact , this class consists of all triples @xmath1484 satisfying ex1 such that for any morphisms @xmath1488 and @xmath1596 the fibered coproduct @xmath1494 exists and the morphism @xmath1495 is a kernel , the fibered product @xmath1597 exists and the morphism @xmath1598 is a cokernel ; and the fibered product @xmath1599 exists . in this case , the fibered coproduct @xmath1600 also exists and is isomorphic to @xmath1599 ( equivalently , one could require existence of the former and deduce existence of the latter together with their isomorphism ) .
we claim that when @xmath13 is semi - saturated , this class of triples @xmath1484 also satisfies ex3 .
all the above assertions are quite straightforward to prove , except the ones from examples ( 7 - 8 ) .
the proofs of the latter are given below .
let us prove the assertions from the first paragraph ; the assertion from the second paragraph will then follow from proposition [ exact - proofs].2 . since the morphism @xmath1601 is a cokernel ,
the morphism @xmath1602 is surjective if and only if the morphism @xmath1603 is surjective .
let us show that this is the case if the composition of two kernels is a kernel .
let @xmath1470 be the cokernel of the morphism @xmath112 ; by the definition , the morphism @xmath1604 is the kernel of @xmath1605 .
let @xmath1606 be the cokernel of the morphism @xmath1603 and @xmath1607 be the kernel of the morphism @xmath1219 . by the assumption ,
the composition @xmath1608 should be a kernel .
since the morphism @xmath1609 factors through @xmath75 and the composition @xmath1610 is zero , it is easy to deduce that @xmath1605 is the cokernel of the morphism @xmath1611 .
now it turns out that both the morphisms @xmath1612 and @xmath1611 are the kernels of the morphism @xmath1613 , hence the morphism @xmath1614 is an isomorphism and @xmath1615 .
conversely , let us show that the composition @xmath112 of two kernels @xmath1616 and @xmath1617 is a kernel whenever the morphism @xmath1602 is surjective .
the morphism @xmath112 is equal to the composition @xmath1618 ; by the assumption , the morphism @xmath1619 is surjective .
since the morphism @xmath1620 is a kernel , it suffices to check that the morphism @xmath1619 is an isomorphism .
the latter is a particular case of the following general statement , which is not difficult to prove : a surjective right divisor of a composition of several kernels is an isomorphism .
now let us show that a right divisor of a kernel is a kernel provided that the composition of two kernels is a kernel .
let @xmath1621 and @xmath489 be a pair of morphisms whose composition @xmath1535 is the kernel of a morphism @xmath1622 .
let @xmath1470 be the cokernel of the morphism @xmath1532 and @xmath1604 be kernel of @xmath1605 ; then the morphism @xmath1532 factors through @xmath1623 .
since we have @xmath1624=0 $ ] , it is clear that the composition @xmath1625 factors through @xmath1605 and , consequently , @xmath1626=0 $ ] .
since the morphism @xmath1535 is the kernel of the morphism @xmath1622 , there exists a morphism @xmath1627 such that @xmath1628=[\operatorname{im}f{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}k{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}y{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}z]$ ] .
we have constructed morphisms between @xmath1 and @xmath1629 in both directions ; since the morphism @xmath1535 is injective and @xmath1630=[k{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}\operatorname{im}f{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}y{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}z ] = [ k{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}y{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}z]$ ] , it follows that @xmath1631={{\operatorname{id}}}_k$ ] .
therefore , the morphism @xmath1619 is the embedding of a direct summand , hence it is a kernel and the morphism @xmath1621 is the composition of two kernels @xmath1619 and @xmath1612 .
furthermore , assume that a right divisor of a kernel is a kernel .
let a morphism @xmath1616 be the kernel of a morphism @xmath1632 and a morphism @xmath1633 be the kernel of a morphism @xmath1634 .
consider the anti - diagonal morphism @xmath1635 ; since its composition with the projection @xmath1636 is a kernel , the morphism @xmath1637 should be the kernel of a certain morphism @xmath1638 .
since the morphism @xmath1633 is injective , it is easy to see that the morphism @xmath1639 is injective , too .
now one can check that the composition @xmath576 is the kernel of the diagonal morphism @xmath1640 .
we have also shown that any pair of morphisms @xmath1617 and @xmath1641 , where @xmath1617 is a kernel , can be embedded into a commutative square @xmath1642=[l{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}c{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}e]$ ] with an injective morphism @xmath1643 .
finally , assume that the latter condition holds .
let @xmath1644 and @xmath1645 be a pair of morphisms whose composition @xmath330 is the kernel of a morphism @xmath1646 . consider the pair of morphisms @xmath330 and @xmath1644 , and suppose that there is a commutative square @xmath1647= [ u{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}t{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}q]$ ] such that the morphism @xmath1648 is injective
. then one can check that the morphism @xmath1644 is the kernel of the morphism @xmath1649 with the components @xmath1650 - [ t{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}v{\medspace{\rightarrow}\medspace}q]$ ] and @xmath1651 $ ] . to prove the assertion from the second paragraph , notice first of all that the triples @xmath1490 and @xmath1652 satisfy ex1 . for @xmath1653 , the functoriality of fibered ( co)products provides two morphisms of triples with one common object @xmath1654 . by the definition of @xmath318 and since @xmath1655 , it follows that @xmath1656 .
it remains to show that @xmath1657 ; then it will follow that the triple @xmath1658 satisfies ex1 , and the class of all triples of this form , where the original triple @xmath1659 is fixed and the morphisms @xmath1488 and @xmath1596 vary , satisfies ex2 . for any morphism @xmath1660 , applying our construction to the composition @xmath1661 in place of the morphism @xmath382 , we obtain an object @xmath1662 together with a morphism of triples with one common object @xmath1663 . since @xmath1664 and @xmath1665 , the argument from the proof of proposition [ exact - proofs].1 shows that @xmath1657 .
let us turn to the assertion from the third paragraph .
whenever one is dealing with the axiom ex3 in the assumption of ex0 - -ex2 , the following commutative diagram plays the key role .
@xmath1666{\hbox to 0pt{\hss $ # 1$\hss } } \begin{gathered } \begin{picture}(160,69 ) \put(0,0 ) { \clap{u } } \put(11,5.5){\vector(4,1){56 } } \put(160,0 ) { \clap{v } } \put(93,19.5){\vector(4,-1){56 } } \put(40,30 ) { \clap{p } } \put(93,26){\vector(4,1){17 } } \put(120,30){\clap{q } } \put(50,30.25){\vector(4,-1){17 } } \put(80,19 ) { \clap{h } } \put(9,12.75){\vector(4,3){21 } } \put(80,60 ) { \clap{w } } \put(130,28.5){\vector(4,-3){21 } } \put(49,42.75){\vector(4,3){21 } } \put(90,58.5){\vector(4,-3){21 } } \end{picture } \end{gathered}\ ] ] given admissible monomorphisms @xmath1667 and @xmath1668 , one considers admissible triples @xmath1669 and @xmath1670 .
then one applies the property ex2@xmath178(a ) or ex@xmath388(a ) to the latter admissible triple and the morphism @xmath1671 , obtaining an admissible triple @xmath1672 . hence the above commutative diagram .
it is easy to check that the triple @xmath1673 satisfies ex1 .
the morphism @xmath1674 is the composition of two admissible monomorphisms , and the morphism @xmath1675 is a direct summand of the composition of two admissible epimorphisms @xmath1676 ( see @xcite ) . in the situation of example ( 8)
, one can readily check that the triple @xmath1673 allows the application of the push - forward procedure of axiom ex@xmath388(a ) and then the pull - back procedure of axiom ex@xmath388(b ) , and continues to satisfy ex1 after that .
a small additive category @xmath104 endowed with a class of admissible triples @xmath1482 is an exact category if and only if there exists an abelian category @xmath13 and a fully faithful functor @xmath1677 such that the subcategory @xmath1678 is closed under extensions and a triple @xmath1484 in the category @xmath104 belongs to @xmath1482 if and only if its image @xmath1679 is a short exact sequence in @xmath13 . in other words ,
the exact category structure on @xmath104 is induced from the canonical exact category structure on the abelian category @xmath13 in the sense of the above example [ exact - cat - examples]@xmath178(3a ) .
this is the statement of an embedding theorem first formulated by quillen in @xcite and proven in detail in several papers , including @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite .
in fact , any small exact category has _ two _ natural embeddings to abelian categories satisfying all the properties mentioned above ; the two embeddings differ by the categorical duality .
they are constructed in the following way .
consider the abelian category @xmath1680 of contravariant additive functors from @xmath104 to the category of abelian groups @xmath1423 .
a functor @xmath1681 is called _ left exact _ if for any admissible triple @xmath1484 in the category @xmath104 the sequence of abelian groups @xmath1682 is exact .
let us denote by @xmath1683 the full additive subcategory of left exact functors and by @xmath1684 the additive functor sending an object @xmath1685 to the representable contravariant functor @xmath1686 .
the category @xmath1687 is abelian .
this result is an additive version of the sheafification theory : arbitrary additive functors play the role of presheaves and the left exact functors are the sheaves .
note that the category @xmath1687 is not an abelian subcategory of the category @xmath1680 : the embedding functor @xmath1688 is only left exact . the functor @xmath1689 left adjoint to the embedding is exact , however ; this is the additive sheafification functor .
its construction is the main part of the proof .
one can also view the category @xmath1687 as the quotient category of @xmath1680 by the kernel of the sheafification .
the second embedding @xmath1690 is defined in terms of the covariant representable functors ; the category @xmath1691 is the full subcategory of @xmath1692 whose objects are all the left exact covariant functors .
for example , if @xmath104 is the category of finitely generated free ( or projective ) left modules over a ring @xmath626 endowed with the trivial exact category structure , then the functor @xmath1693 is the obvious embedding into the abelian category of all left @xmath626-modules and the functor @xmath1694 is the embedding into the abelian category opposite to the category of all right @xmath626-modules given by the rule @xmath1695 .
the following result demonstrates the difference between the two canonical embeddings @xmath1693 and @xmath1694 .
the functor @xmath1693 preserves kernels , and more generally , any limits .
in particular , for any morphism @xmath112 in an exact category @xmath104 , the morphism @xmath1696 is injective if and only if a morphism @xmath112 is injective . for any morphism @xmath112 in an exact category @xmath104 , the morphism @xmath1696 is surjective if and only if @xmath112 is a left divisor of some admissible epimorphism @xmath1499 in @xmath104 . in particular , if the category @xmath104 is semi - saturated , then the morphism @xmath1696 is surjective if and only if a morphism @xmath112 is an admissible epimorphism .
the dual statements hold for the embedding @xmath1694 .
the first assertion holds since all limits exist in a grothendieck category @xmath1687 and the embedding @xmath1697 preserves limits .
the third one follows from exactness of the functor @xmath1693 with respect to admissible triples in @xmath104 and the next proposition 2 , and the fourth one from axiom ex@xmath1498(b ) . for any objects @xmath1698 and @xmath1685 and any surjective morphism @xmath1699 in @xmath1687 there exists an admissible epimorphism @xmath200 in @xmath104 and a morphism @xmath1700 in @xmath1687 such that the triangle @xmath1701 is commutative in @xmath1687 .
see ( * ? ? ?
* lemma a.7.15 ) or ( * ? ? ?
* lemma a.22 ) .
whenever one is working with exact categories , one is faced with an unpleasant choice between making the ( semi-)saturatedness assumptions or doing without them .
the former approach restricts generality , while the second one complicates matters ; both the restrictions and the complications are felt as irrelevant and unnecessary .
one ends up oscillating between the two ways by passing from a category to its ( semi-)saturation and back , thus experiencing the worst aspects of both approaches .
no good solution to this problem is known to the author . in the definition of the derived category of an exact category ,
the ( semi-)saturation problem presents itself in a particularly complicated form .
we attempt to clarify the issues involved in the exposition below . given an additive category @xmath13 , we denote by @xmath1702 the homotopy category of ( unbounded ) complexes over @xmath13 . the homotopy category of complexes bounded from above , below , and both sides are denoted by @xmath1703 , @xmath1704 , and @xmath1705 . for @xmath1706 , @xmath1707 , @xmath1708 , or @xmath1709 , we say that a complex @xmath19 over @xmath13 is @xmath257-bounded if @xmath10 is respectively any complex , or a complex bounded from above , etc .
let @xmath104 be an exact category .
a complex @xmath19 over @xmath104 is said to be _ exact _ if there exist objects @xmath1710 and admissible triples @xmath1711 such that the differentials @xmath1712 in @xmath19 are equal to the compositions @xmath1713 .
it is known @xcite that the cone of a closed morphism of exact complexes is exact .
a complex @xmath19 is called _ acyclic _ if it is homotopy equivalent to an exact complex .
the full subcategory of @xmath257-bounded acyclic complexes is denoted by @xmath1714 . 1 . for any @xmath1706
, @xmath1707 , @xmath1708 , or @xmath1709 , a @xmath257-bounded complex over @xmath104 is acyclic if and only if it is homotopy equivalent to a @xmath257-bounded exact complex and if and only if it is a direct summand of a @xmath257-bounded exact complex .
2 . for any exact category @xmath104
, the full subcategory @xmath1714 is thick .
an exact category @xmath104 is saturated if and only if any acyclic complex over @xmath104 is exact .
a complex over @xmath104 is acyclic if and only if it is exact as a complex over @xmath1590 . for @xmath1715 , @xmath1708 , or @xmath1709 ,
an exact category @xmath104 is semi - saturated if and if any @xmath257-bounded acyclic complex over @xmath104 is exact .
a @xmath257-bounded complex over @xmath104 is acyclic if and only if it is exact as a complex over @xmath1589 .
4 . for @xmath1706 , @xmath1707 , or @xmath1708 ,
the natural functor @xmath1716 is an equivalence of triangulated categories identifying @xmath1717 with @xmath1718 . for any @xmath257 ,
the natural functor @xmath1719 is an equivalence of triangulated categories identifying @xmath1717 with @xmath1720 .
this lemma is just a somewhat more precise rephrasing of the results of @xcite .
notice that the canonical truncations are defined for exact complexes over an exact category .
in particular , any @xmath257-bounded complex homotopy equivalent to an exact complex is homotopy equivalent to a @xmath257-bounded exact complex . if @xmath19 is a @xmath257-bounded complex over @xmath104 homotopy equivalent to a @xmath257-bounded exact complex @xmath1721 over @xmath104 , then @xmath19 is a direct summand of the @xmath257-bounded exact complex @xmath1722 over @xmath104 @xcite .
clearly , any direct summand of a @xmath257-bounded exact complex over @xmath1590 is itself a @xmath257-bounded exact complex over @xmath1590 .
if @xmath19 is a @xmath257-bounded exact complex over @xmath1590 , then there is a @xmath257-bounded contractible complex @xmath1721 over @xmath1590 such that @xmath1723 is an exact complex over @xmath104 .
it is easy to show this using the fact that @xmath104 is closed under extensions in @xmath1590 .
consequently , @xmath19 is homotopy equivalent to @xmath1723 .
this suffices to prove parts ( 1 - 2 ) , the second assertion of ( 3 ) , the `` if '' part of the fourth assertion of ( 3 ) , and the second parts of both assertions of ( 4 ) .
similarly one proves the first parts of the assertions of ( 4 ) . the `` if '' parts of the first and third assertions of ( 3 ) are easy @xcite , and the `` only if '' parts are equivalent to the `` only if '' parts of the second and fourth assertions .
finally , the `` only if '' part of the third assertion of ( 3 ) follows by induction from axiom ex@xmath1498(a - b ) or the last two assertions of proposition [ quillen - embedding].1 . let @xmath104 and @xmath231 , @xmath90 be exact categories , @xmath251 be exact functors , and @xmath89 be the exact category of finitely filtered objects in @xmath104 with successive quotients lifted to @xmath231 as defined in section [ filtered - exact - secn ] .
then a complex @xmath19 over @xmath89 is exact ( acyclic ) if and only if the complex of successive quotients @xmath1724 is exact ( acyclic ) over @xmath231 for every @xmath90 . in particular ,
if the exact category structures on @xmath231 are trivial , then the complex @xmath19 is acyclic if and only if all the complexes @xmath1724 are contractible .
a morphism of complexes @xmath1725 in @xmath1726 is called a _ quasi - isomorphism _ if its cone is acyclic .
the ( bounded or unbounded ) _ derived categories _ of an exact category @xmath104 are defined as the triangulated quotient categories @xmath1727 or @xmath1728 for @xmath1715 , @xmath1708 , or @xmath1709 .
we are not discussing the set - theoretical issue of existence of localizations here ; they certainly do exist when the category @xmath104 is essentially small . for any exact category @xmath104 and any @xmath1715 , @xmath1708 , or @xmath1709 , the natural functor @xmath1729 is fully faithful .
this follows from the existence of canonical truncations of exact complexes . for any small exact category @xmath104 ,
the functors @xmath1730 and @xmath1731 induced by the canonical embeddings @xmath1732 and @xmath1733 are fully faithful .
this follows from proposition [ quillen - embedding].2 and its dual version .
let @xmath104 be a small exact category . by the definition
, we put @xmath1734)$ ] .
the composition of morphisms in the derived category defines multiplication maps @xmath1735 . in any exact category @xmath104 ,
the ext groups with negative numbers are zero , @xmath1736 for @xmath102 .
the natural morphism @xmath1737 is an isomorphism ; in other words , the functor @xmath1738 is fully faithful .
the ext groups with positive numbers @xmath1037 are computed by the following yoneda construction .
consider the set @xmath1739 of all exact complexes @xmath1740 over @xmath104 such that @xmath1741 for all @xmath1361 and @xmath1742 , @xmath1743 , and @xmath1744 .
two elements @xmath94 and @xmath1745 are said to be equivalent if there exists a third element @xmath1746 and two morphisms of complexes @xmath1747 and @xmath1748 , both inducing identity morphisms on the terms @xmath117 in degree @xmath107 and @xmath10 in degree @xmath1749 .
this is indeed an equivalence relation and the quotient set of the set of yoneda extensions @xmath1739 modulo this equivalence relation is canonically bijective to @xmath1750 .
alternatively , one can use morphisms of exact complexes going in the opposite direction , @xmath1751 and @xmath1752 ; this defines the same equivalence relation .
the addition in the ext groups is given by the baer sum construction .
the multiplication on the ext groups corresponds to the obvious composition operation on the yoneda extensions .
this follows from the construction of the triangulated quotient category @xcite and the existence of canonical truncations of exact complexes .
another important explicit construction of the higher @xmath8 groups in an exact category is provided by corollary [ exact - triangulated].1 below .
the product of the elements in @xmath1753 and @xmath1754 corresponding to admissible triples @xmath310 and @xmath667 in @xmath104 vanishes in @xmath1755 if and only if the composition of morphisms @xmath1756 can be factorized as @xmath1757 in such a way that the triples @xmath1758 and @xmath1759 are admissible in @xmath104 .
this is most simply deduced from the long exact sequence of @xmath8 groups corresponding to an admissible triple , which in turn follows from the definition of @xmath1760 in terms of morphisms in @xmath1761 .
an object of an exact category is called _ projective _ ( _ injective _ ) if the functor of morphisms from ( into ) this objects sends admissible triples to short exact sequences . a projective ( injective )
_ resolution _ of an object , or a complex of objects , in an exact category is a bounded above ( below ) complex of projective ( injective ) objects endowed with a quasi - isomorphism into ( from ) the given object or complex .
since any morphism into ( from ) an acyclic complex from ( into ) a bounded above ( below ) complex of projective ( injective ) objects is homotopic to zero , one can use projective ( injective ) resolutions to compute the groups @xmath8 in an exact category .
a full subcategory @xmath104 in a triangulated category @xmath6 is called an _ exact subcategory _
if @xmath1762)=0 $ ] for all @xmath10 , @xmath1763 and the class of all triples @xmath1480 in @xmath104 that can be embedded into a distinguished triangle @xmath1764 $ ] in @xmath6 defines an exact category structure on @xmath104 .
notice that the former condition guarantees that the distinguished triangle in the latter condition is unique if it exists .
axioms ex0 and ex1 are satisfied automatically by the class of admissible triples defined in the above way ; it is only axioms ex2 and ex3 that have to be checked .
a full subcategory @xmath104 in a triangulated category @xmath6 is said to be _ closed under extensions _
if it contains the middle term @xmath117 of any distinguished triangle @xmath1764 $ ] with @xmath10 , @xmath1485 .
any full subcategory @xmath1170 that is closed under extensions and satisfies the condition that @xmath1762)=0 $ ] for all @xmath10 , @xmath1485 is an exact subcategory of @xmath6 @xcite .
one applies the octahedron axiom in @xmath6 in order to show that axioms ex2 and ex3 hold in @xmath104 .
in particular , it follows from the description of @xmath1765 in proposition [ exact - derived ] for @xmath1766 , @xmath107 , @xmath156 that any exact category @xmath104 is an exact subcategory , closed under extensions , in its derived category @xmath1761 . for any exact subcategory @xmath104 in a triangulated category @xmath6 , there is a natural injective map of abelian groups @xmath1767)$ ] for all @xmath10 , @xmath1485 assigning to an admissible triple @xmath1480 in @xmath104 the rightmost map of the distinguished triangle @xmath1768 $ ] . to check additivity
, one can consider the direct sum of two copies of either @xmath10 or @xmath305 and use the functoriality , which is verified using the condition of vanishing of @xmath1762)$ ] .
the maps @xmath1769)$ ] are isomorphisms for all @xmath10 , @xmath1485 if and only if the subcategory @xmath104 is closed under extensions in @xmath6 .
let @xmath1170 be a small exact subcategory in a triangulated category .
consider the big graded ring of higher @xmath46 groups @xmath1770))_{y , x\in{{\mathcal e}}}.\ ] ] let @xmath1771 denote the big graded ring of @xmath8 groups in an exact category @xmath104 .
there is a natural isomorphism of big rings @xmath1772 and a natural injective morphism of bimodules @xmath1773 . for any small exact subcategory @xmath104 in a triangulated category @xmath6 , the multiplication maps @xmath1774 and @xmath1775
are injective for all @xmath149 .
it is easy to check using the existence of finite direct sums in the category @xmath104 that any element of @xmath1776 has the form @xmath1777 for some @xmath1778 and @xmath1779)$ ] .
consider the distinguished triangle @xmath1780 $ ] in @xmath6 corresponding to the admissible triple @xmath1781 in @xmath104 representing @xmath438 ; we will denote the morphism @xmath1782 $ ] also by @xmath438 .
now if the composition @xmath1783 $ ] is zero , there exists a morphism @xmath1784 $ ] such that @xmath1785 .
then we have @xmath1786 in the group @xmath1787 . for any small exact category @xmath104 ,
the big graded ring of ext groups @xmath1788 is a free big graded ring generated by the @xmath1789-bimodule @xmath1790 , that is the multiplication morphisms @xmath1791 are isomorphisms .
the morphisms @xmath1792 are injective by the above proposition and surjective by proposition [ exact - derived ] . for any exact subcategory @xmath104 in a triangulated category @xmath6
, there exists a unique sequence of morphisms of functors of two arguments @xmath1793 @xmath1794 ) , \qquad n\ge0,\ ] ] with the following properties : the maps @xmath1795 are compatible with the composition , the map @xmath1796 is the identity , and the map @xmath1797 sends the yoneda class of an admissible triple @xmath1798 in the exact category @xmath104 to the third arrow @xmath1799 $ ] of the corresponding distinguished triangle in the triangulated category @xmath6 .
moreover , if the morphism of functors @xmath1800 is an isomorphism for a certain @xmath149 , then all the maps @xmath1801 are injective . in particular ,
if @xmath104 is closed under extensions in @xmath6 , then @xmath1802 is an isomorphism and @xmath1803 is injective ; if all the maps @xmath1795 are surjective for @xmath1126 , then all of them are isomorphisms .
existence and uniqueness follow from corollary 1 ; alternatively , one can use the universal property of effaceable homological functors ( see @xcite ) .
injectivity follows from the proposition .
let @xmath13 be an exact category and @xmath104 be its full exact subcategory closed under extensions and such that any object of @xmath13 is a direct summand of an object of @xmath104 see .
then the natural maps @xmath1804 are isomorphisms for all @xmath10 , @xmath105 and @xmath149 .
a full subcategory @xmath13 in a triangulated category @xmath6 is the heart of a bounded t - structure on @xmath6 if and only if @xmath13 is closed under extensions , one has @xmath15)=0 $ ] for all @xmath10 , @xmath11 and @xmath102 , the exact category structure on @xmath13 is the canonical exact category structure of an abelian category , and the triangulated category @xmath6 is generated by @xmath13 ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 1.3.13 ) .
thus all the above results are applicable in the case when @xmath1805 is the heart of a t - structure on a triangulated category @xmath6 .
[ silly - filtrations - appx ] the results of this appendix elaborate on the condition that the morphisms @xmath1800 of corollary [ exact - triangulated].2 are surjective ( or equivalently , isomorphisms ) for an exact subcategory @xmath1170 closed under extensions .
it turns out that one does not have to assume that the groups @xmath1806)$ ] are zero in order to discuss this condition .
we will freely use the @xmath257-operation notation for classes of objects in triangulated categories @xcite .
besides , will use the notation of [ additive - categories ] related to semi - saturated completions and saturated closures .
let @xmath6 be a triangulated category , @xmath7 be a full subcategory , and @xmath1807 be the minimal full subcategory containing @xmath13 and closed under extensions .
then for any @xmath696 the following three conditions are equivalent : 1 .
any morphism @xmath1808 $ ] with @xmath1809 between two objects @xmath10 , @xmath30 can be presented as the composition of a chain of morphisms @xmath697 $ ] with @xmath698 , @xmath699 , and @xmath1810 .
any morphism @xmath1811 $ ] with @xmath1809 between two objects @xmath1576 and @xmath30 can be presented as the composition of a morphism @xmath1812 $ ] and a morphism @xmath756\rarrow y[k]$ ] with @xmath944 .
any morphism @xmath1811 $ ] with @xmath1809 between two objects @xmath1576 and @xmath30 can be presented as the composition of a morphism @xmath1813 $ ] and a morphism @xmath1814\rarrow y[k]$ ] with @xmath944 .
furthermore , any of the next two conditions implies the previous three : 1 .
any morphism @xmath1815 $ ] with @xmath1809 between two objects @xmath94 , @xmath1816 can be presented as the composition of a morphism @xmath1812 $ ] and a morphism @xmath756\rarrow b[k]$ ] such that @xmath944 and a cone of the morphism @xmath1812 $ ] belongs to @xmath1817 $ ] .
any morphism @xmath1811 $ ] with @xmath1809 between two objects @xmath94 , @xmath1816 can be presented as the composition of a morphism @xmath1813 $ ] and a morphism @xmath1814\rarrow b[k]$ ] such that @xmath944 and a cone of the morphism @xmath1814\rarrow b[k]$ ] belongs to @xmath1818 $ ] . a simple induction on @xmath37 proves ( c)@xmath1819(b ) ; including the equivalence of ( a - c ) for @xmath1820 in the induction assumption , we obtain ( b)@xmath1819(c ) .
it is obvious that ( a ) implies ( b ) and ( c ) . to prove ( c)@xmath1819(a ) , reformulate ( c ) as the assertion that for any morphism @xmath1811 $ ] with @xmath1576 and @xmath30 there exists a distinguished triangle @xmath1821\rarrow w[k]\rarrow z[k]\rarrow y[k+1]$ ] with @xmath944 such that the composition @xmath1811\rarrow w[k]$ ] vanishes .
the condition ( a ) can be restated as the similar assertion with @xmath1576 replaced by @xmath940 .
let @xmath1822 $ ] be a distinguished triangle in @xmath6 .
assuming that both objects @xmath138 and @xmath804 have the above property for any morphism @xmath1823 $ ] with @xmath30 , we will show that the object @xmath94 has the same property .
let @xmath1811 $ ] be any morphism ; consider the composition @xmath1824 $ ]
. then there exists a distinguished triangle @xmath1821\rarrow w_1[k ] \rarrow z_1[k]$ ] with @xmath1825 such that the composition @xmath1824\rarrow w_1[k]$ ] vanishes .
hence the composition @xmath1811\rarrow w_1[k]$ ] factorizes through the morphism @xmath1826 .
consider the morphism @xmath1827 $ ] that we have obtained .
there exists a distinguished triangle @xmath1828\rarrow w[k]\rarrow z_2[k]\rarrow w_1[k+1]$ ] with @xmath1829 such that the composition @xmath1830\rarrow w[k]$ ] vanishes .
then the composition @xmath1811\rarrow w_1[k]\rarrow w[k]$ ] also vanishes . by the octahedron axiom ,
the cone of the composition @xmath1821\rarrow w_1[k]\rarrow w[k]$ ] is an extension of @xmath1831 $ ] and @xmath1832 $ ] , so it belongs to @xmath1833 $ ] . to prove ( d)@xmath1819(b ) , reformulate ( d ) as the assertion that for any morphism @xmath1815 $ ] with @xmath94 , @xmath1816 there exists a distinguished triangle @xmath1834 $ ] with @xmath944 and @xmath1835 such that the composition @xmath1836 $ ] vanishes .
then argue as above .
now we know that ( d)@xmath1819(a ) , and the implication ( e)@xmath1819(a ) follows by duality . let @xmath6 be a triangulated category and @xmath1193 be a full subcategory closed under extensions .
then any morphism @xmath47 $ ] with @xmath17 between two objects @xmath10 , @xmath1837 can be presented as the composition of a chain of morphisms @xmath1838 $ ] with @xmath1839 , @xmath699 , and @xmath700 if and only if the following two conditions hold : 1 .
one has @xmath1840*{{\mathcal m}}{\subset}{{\mathcal m}}*{{\mathcal m}}[1]*{\dots}*{{\mathcal m}}[n]$ ] for any @xmath149 .
put @xmath1841}={{\mathcal m}}[-b]*{\dots}*{{\mathcal m}}[-a]$ ] for any @xmath1842 , @xmath1843}$ ] , and @xmath1844}$ ] .
then one should have @xmath1845})^{{\operatorname{sat}}}_{{\mathcal d}}$ ] .
besides , the triangulated subcategory generated by @xmath29 in @xmath6 coincides with @xmath1846}$ ] in this case .
the key ideas of the proof are summarized in the following lemma .
let @xmath6 be a triangulated category
. then 1 .
suppose that a morphism @xmath1847 in @xmath6 factorizes through an object @xmath124 .
then @xmath1848\}\ni\operatorname{cone}(f)\in \{e\}*\{a[1]\}*\{b\}*\{e[1]\}$ ] .
2 . suppose that the cones of two morphisms @xmath1172 and @xmath1849 are isomorphic in @xmath6 .
then both morphisms factorize through an object @xmath124 belonging to the intersection @xmath1850 .
3 . suppose that an object @xmath329 is a direct summand of an extension of objects @xmath94 and @xmath1851 and also a direct summand of an extension of objects @xmath111 and @xmath834 .
then , in particular , there are morphisms @xmath1852 and @xmath1853 ; suppose moreover , that their composition factorizes through an object @xmath124 .
then @xmath329 is a direct summand of an object in @xmath1854 .
part ( 1 ) : consider the distinguished triangles @xmath1855 \\ b[-1]\lrarrow c\lrarrow e\lrarrow b.\end{gathered}\ ] ] by the octahedron axiom , there are also distinguished triangles @xmath1856 \\ c\lrarrow d\lrarrow k\lrarrow c[1].\end{gathered}\ ] ] so @xmath1857\}$ ] and @xmath1858\in\{b\}*\{e[1]\}$ ] , hence @xmath1859\}\ni k\in\{d\}*\{c[1]\}{\subset}\{e\}*\{a[1]\}*\{b\}*\{e[1]\}.\ ] ] part ( 2 ) : by the octahedron axiom , there exist four distinguished triangles as above and the morphisms @xmath1172 and @xmath1849 factorize through @xmath124 .
clearly , @xmath1860 .
part ( 3 ) : by our assumption , there exist objects @xmath627 , @xmath1861 and distinguished triangles @xmath1862 \\ b[-1]\lrarrow c\lrarrow t\oplus w\lrarrow b.\end{gathered}\ ] ] combining the given morphisms with appropriate signs , we get a pair of morphisms @xmath1863 with zero composition
. there are distinguished triangles @xmath1864 \\ e\lrarrow k\lrarrow d\lrarrow e[1 ] \end{gathered}\ ] ] and @xmath1865\oplus l[1 ] \\ c\lrarrow l\lrarrow e\lrarrow c[1]\end{gathered}\ ] ] and a pair of morphisms @xmath1866 , @xmath1867 forming a morphism of distinguished triangles with a common vertex @xmath1868 . applying the octahedron axiom ,
we obtain distinguished triangles @xmath1869 \\ f\lrarrow t\oplus k\lrarrow b\lrarrow f[1]\end{gathered}\ ] ] finally , there is a morphism @xmath1870\oplus l[1]$ ] that can be obtained as the composition @xmath1871 \rarrow s[1]\oplus l[1]$ ] or @xmath1872\oplus l[1]$ ] .
this morphism can be included in the distinguished triangle @xmath1873\oplus k[-1]\lrarrow s\oplus l\lrarrow s\oplus t\oplus w \oplus e\oplus f\lrarrow t\oplus k,\ ] ] where the morphisms @xmath1874 are just the obvious embedding and projection , while the components @xmath1875 and @xmath1876 vanish .
hence we obtain the distinguished triangle @xmath1877\lrarrow l\lrarrow w\oplus e\oplus f\lrarrow k.\ ] ] now @xmath1878 and @xmath1879 , hence @xmath1880 .
first let us check the implication `` if '' .
let @xmath10 , @xmath30 , and @xmath1881 $ ] be a morphism in @xmath6 , where @xmath633 .
consider the object @xmath1882)$ ] ; then there is a distinguished triangle @xmath1883\lrarrow z\lrarrow x\rarrow y[n+1],\ ] ] so @xmath1884*{{\mathcal m}}$ ] . by ( i )
, there exists a distinguished triangle @xmath1885,\ ] ] where @xmath1886 and @xmath1887*{\dots}*{{\mathcal m}}[n]$ ] .
so @xmath305 is also a cone of the morphism @xmath1888\rarrow u$ ] . according to part ( 2 ) of the above lemma , the morphism @xmath1889 $ ] factorizes through an object @xmath1890\}*\{u\}\cap\{v[-1]\}*\{y[n]\ } { \subset}({{\mathcal m}}[-1]*{{\mathcal m}})\cap({{\mathcal m}}*{\dots}*{{\mathcal m}}[n])$ ] . by
( ii ) , @xmath1891 .
now the morphism @xmath112 factorizes through @xmath1892 $ ] , thus it also factorizes through an object of @xmath1893 $ ] .
it is not difficult to prove by induction that the minimal subcategory of @xmath6 containing @xmath29 , , @xmath1840 $ ] and closed under extensions coincides with @xmath1894 $ ] for any @xmath132 provided that ( i ) holds .
specifically , one proceeds by induction on @xmath37 , and then in the number of factors @xmath1895 $ ] with the largest possible value @xmath1089 in an iterated extension .
this proves the last assertion of the proposition .
now let us prove `` only if '' . to verify ( i ) , consider an object @xmath1884*{{\mathcal m}}$ ] .
as above , we have @xmath1882)$ ] for some morphism @xmath1881 $ ] , where @xmath10 , @xmath30 .
decompose the morphism @xmath112 as @xmath1896\rarrow y[n+1]$ ] , where @xmath1897 . by part ( 1 ) of lemma , @xmath1898\}*\{e[1]\ } { \subset}{{\mathcal m}}*{{\mathcal m}}*{{\mathcal m}}[n]*{{\mathcal m}}[1]$ ] .
a simple induction on @xmath37 finishes the proof of ( i ) . to prove ( ii ) ,
let us first check that @xmath1899*{\dots}*{{\mathcal m}}[n-1])^{{\operatorname{sat}}}_{{\mathcal d}}\cap({{\mathcal m}}*{\dots}*{{\mathcal m}}[n])^{{\operatorname{sat}}}_{{\mathcal d}}{\subset}({{\mathcal m}}*{\dots}*{{\mathcal m}}[n-1])^{{\operatorname{sat}}}_{{\mathcal d}}.\ ] ] let @xmath329 be an object in the intersection ; then @xmath329 is a direct summand of an extension of @xmath1900\in{{\mathcal m}}[-1]$ ] and @xmath1901 $ ] and also a direct summand of an extension of @xmath1902 $ ] and @xmath1903\in{{\mathcal m}}[n]$ ] .
the morphism @xmath1172 factorizes through an object @xmath1897 .
according to part ( 3 ) of lemma , @xmath329 is a direct summand of an object from @xmath1904*{{\mathcal m}}*{{\mathcal m}}*{{\mathcal m}}*{\dots}*{{\mathcal m}}[n-1]$ ] .
thus @xmath1905)^{{\operatorname{sat}}}_{{\mathcal d}}$ ] . a simple induction allows to deduce ( ii ) . in some cases
the condition ( ii ) is satisfied automatically .
first of all , it always holds when @xmath29 is the heart of a t - structure on @xmath6 ( see below ) .
secondly , it holds in the filtered case described in the next proposition .
let @xmath6 be a triangulated category endowed with a sequence of triangulated subcategories @xmath115 , @xmath90 such that @xmath1906 for any @xmath1907 and @xmath1908 with @xmath109 .
let @xmath1909 be full subcategories closed under extensions .
then the minimal full subcategory containing all @xmath1910 and closed under extensions @xmath1911 satisfies the condition of proposition for @xmath1912 if and only if all the subcategories @xmath1909 do .
consequently , if @xmath1909 satisfy for @xmath1912 and @xmath1193 satisfies , then @xmath29 also satisfies .
furthermore , if all @xmath1909 satisfy the following stronger version of condition , then so does @xmath1193 : * for any @xmath1842 and @xmath1913 , the intersection of @xmath1841}$ ] with the minimal full subcategory of @xmath6 , containing @xmath1914 $ ] , , @xmath1915 $ ] and closed under extensions is equal to @xmath1841\cap[c , d]}$ ] , where @xmath1916\cap[c , d]$ ] is the intersection of the segments @xmath1916 $ ] and @xmath1917 $ ] in @xmath1112 . to verify the first assertion , if suffices to consider the associated graded object functors @xmath1918 .
the second one follows from proposition 2 and its proof in the `` if '' direction , which only uses ( ii ) for @xmath1912 . to prove the last assertion ,
let us show that the intersection of @xmath1919*{\dots}*{{\mathcal m}}[n]$ ] with the minimal full subcategory of @xmath6 , containing @xmath1833 $ ] for @xmath1920 and closed under extensions coincides with @xmath1894 $ ] .
let @xmath1921*{\dots}*{{\mathcal m}}[n]$ ] ; then there exists a distinguished triangle @xmath1922\lrarrow u\lrarrow w\lrarrow v\ ] ] with @xmath1923*{{\mathcal m}}$ ] and @xmath1887*{\dots}*{{\mathcal m}}[n]$ ] .
assume that @xmath329 belongs to the minimal full subcategory of @xmath6 , containing @xmath1833 $ ] for @xmath1920 and closed under extensions ; then , since @xmath1924\}*\{w\}$ ] , so does @xmath363 . by our assumption , the images @xmath1925 of the object @xmath363 under the functors of associated graded objects @xmath1926 belong to @xmath1910 .
thus @xmath1886 and @xmath1927 $ ] .
the dual argument shows that the intersection of @xmath1928*{\dots}*{{\mathcal m}}[1]$ ] with the minimal full subcategory of @xmath6 , containing @xmath1833 $ ] for @xmath1929 and closed under extensions coincides with @xmath1928*{\dots}*{{\mathcal m}}$ ] .
the following counterexample shows , however , that the condition ( ii ) does not always hold for an exact subcategory @xmath1193 , and moreover , ( i ) does not imply ( ii ) in this case .
let @xmath26 be the abelian category of @xmath82-term complexes of vector spaces @xmath1554 ( the composition of the two arrows must be zero ) .
there are @xmath1464 indecomposable objects in this category , denoted @xmath1555 , @xmath1556 , @xmath1557 , @xmath1558 , @xmath1559 ( see example [ exact - proofs].2 ) .
let @xmath1930 be the full additive subcategory whose objects are the direct sums of all the indecomposables except @xmath1556 .
set @xmath1931 .
then @xmath29 is closed under extensions in @xmath26 and @xmath6 and inherits a trivial exact category structure , i. e. , all the exact triples in @xmath29 are split .
one can check that @xmath29 generates @xmath6 and satisfies ( i ) , but not ( ii ) .
furthermore , under the assumptions similar to those mentioned above the condition ( i ) allows a very simple reformulation .
let @xmath6 be a triangulated category and @xmath1193 be a full subcategory closed under extensions .
assume that we are in one of the following two situations : 1 .
@xmath29 is the heart of a bounded t - structure on @xmath6 .
@xmath6 is endowed with a sequence of triangulated subcategories @xmath115 , @xmath90 such that @xmath1906 for any @xmath1907 and @xmath1908 with @xmath109 .
each @xmath114 is equivalent to the bounded derived category @xmath1932 of an exact category @xmath1910 .
the subcategory @xmath1193 is the minimal full subcategory containing all @xmath1910 and closed under extensions , @xmath1933 .
then the condition of proposition always holds and is equivalent to its following weaker form : * @xmath1934}$ ] , where @xmath1841}={{\mathcal m}}[-b]*{\dots}*{{\mathcal m}}[-a]$ ] for any @xmath1842 . in the case
( b ) , according to lemma [ exact - derived]@xmath178(4 ) , @xmath1935 .
clearly , the condition ( ii ) does not become weaker when one replaces @xmath1910 with @xmath1936 and @xmath29 with @xmath1937 . according to proposition 2 ,
the sum total of the conditions ( i ) and ( ii ) does not change , either .
so we can assume that @xmath1910 are semi - saturated .
with this assumption , in both cases ( a ) and ( b ) we will prove the condition ( ii@xmath1938 ) of proposition 3 .
clearly , it implies both ( ii ) and ( i@xmath1938)@xmath1819(i ) .
according to proposition 3 , in the case ( b ) it suffices to consider the case when @xmath1939 and @xmath1940 .
as demonstrated in the proof of proposition 3 , it suffices to show that the intersection of @xmath1919*{{\mathcal m}}$ ] with the minimal full subcategory of @xmath6 , containing @xmath1833 $ ] for @xmath1920 and closed under extensions coincides with @xmath29 .
let @xmath1923*{{\mathcal m}}$ ] ; then there is a distinguished triangle @xmath1941\lrarrow y[-1]\lrarrow u\lrarrow x\ ] ] with @xmath10 , @xmath30 .
assume that @xmath363 belongs to the minimal full subcategory of @xmath6 , containing @xmath1833 $ ] for @xmath1920 and closed under extensions . in the case ( a ) , we have @xmath1942 , and it follows immediately from the long exact sequence of t - cohomology ( * ? ? ?
* thorme 1.3.6 ) that the morphism @xmath586 is surjective .
in the case ( b ) , using , e. g. , corollary [ exact - derived].2 and proposition [ quillen - embedding].1 , we can conclude that the morphism @xmath586 is an admissible epimorphism .
another way is to use the existence of canonical truncations of exact complexes over @xmath29 and axiom ex@xmath1498(b ) .
alternatively , one can use proposition 2 in order to conclude that @xmath1943 , and then deduce the assertion that @xmath586 is an admissible epimorphism in @xmath29 from the facts that it is such in @xmath1944 and the category @xmath29 is semi - saturated . in both cases
it follows that @xmath1886 .
[ kpi1-appendix ] let @xmath65 be a commutative ring and @xmath94 be dg - algebra over @xmath65 endowed with two @xmath1112-valued grading , called the _ internal _ and the _ cohomological _ gradings ( * ? ? ?
* appendix a ) .
the differential in @xmath94 raises the cohomological grading by @xmath156 and preserves the internal grading ; it also satisfies the super - leibniz rule with respect to the cohomological grading .
the cohomological grading is denoted by the upper indices and the internal grading by the lower ones .
let @xmath1945 $ ] denote the shift of cohomological grading of internally graded complexes by @xmath156 down ( as usually ) and @xmath128 denote the shift of their internal grading by @xmath156 up .
for an internally graded complex @xmath842 of @xmath65-modules with the differential @xmath1219 , let @xmath1946 denote its internally graded @xmath65-module of cohomology of @xmath842 with respect to @xmath1219 in the cohomological degree @xmath37 . assume further that @xmath94 ( with the differential forgotten ) is a flat bigraded @xmath65-module , that @xmath1362 for @xmath62 , and the complex @xmath93 is concentrated in the cohomological degree @xmath107 and freely generated as a @xmath65-module by the unit element of @xmath94 .
we will also consider internally graded dg - coalgebras @xmath111 over @xmath65 satisfying the same list of conditions , except that the counit map @xmath1947 is an isomorphism of complexes .
the reduced bar- and cobar - constructions assign to an algebra @xmath94 of the above kind a coalgebra @xmath111 of the above kind and vice versa ; these constructions preserve quasi - isomorphisms of algebras and coalgebras and are mutually inverse up to natural quasi - isomorphisms ( * ? ? ?
* theorem a.1.1 and remark a.1 ) .
let @xmath1948 denote the derived category of internally graded left dg - modules over @xmath94 .
we are interested in the triangulated subcategory @xmath1949 generated by the free dg - modules @xmath1950 , @xmath90 . let @xmath111 be the reduced bar - construction of @xmath94 and @xmath1951 be the derived category of internally graded left dg - comodules over @xmath111 .
no @xmath65-flatness conditions are imposed on the terms of dg-(co)modules .
the categories @xmath1948 and @xmath1951 are not equivalent in general ; however , their full subcategories formed by dg - modules and dg - comodules with cohomology bounded from above in the internal grading are equivalent ( * ? ? ?
* theorem a.1.2 and remark a.1 ) .
it follows that the category @xmath6 is equivalent to the full triangulated subcategory of @xmath1951 generated by the trivial dg - comodules @xmath1357 ; the equivalence sends @xmath1950 to @xmath1357 .
let @xmath29 denote the minimal full subcategory of @xmath6 containing the dg - modules @xmath1950 ( or the dg - comodules @xmath1357 ) and closed under extensions .
assume that the ring @xmath65 is noetherian and has a finite homological dimension .
then the triangulated subcategory @xmath1952 can be equivalently defined as the subcategory of all dg - comodules whose bigraded @xmath65-modules of cohomology are finitely generated .
one has @xmath1364 for all @xmath1037 if and only if any morphism @xmath47 $ ] of degree @xmath696 in @xmath6 between two objects @xmath10 , @xmath30 can be presented as the composition of a chain of morphisms @xmath697 $ ] with @xmath698 , @xmath699 , and @xmath700 .
`` if '' : it is easy to see that any dg - comodule over @xmath111 is a union of its dg - subcomodules that are finitely generated bigraded @xmath65-modules .
let @xmath10 be such a dg - subcomodule in the dg - comodule @xmath111 over @xmath111 .
by the last assertion of proposition [ silly - filtrations - appx].2 , there exists a distinguished triangle @xmath1953 $ ] in @xmath6 such that @xmath1954 for @xmath1372 and @xmath1955 for @xmath633 .
then the composition @xmath1956 vanishes as a morphism in @xmath6 , since @xmath1957 for any dg - comodule @xmath329 over @xmath111 . on the other hand ,
the morphism @xmath1958 is surjective for @xmath33 .
hence the morphism @xmath1959 vanishes for @xmath33 .
since this holds for all @xmath10 , it follows that @xmath1364 .
in fact , this argument does not depend on the assumption that the internal grading of @xmath111 is negative .
`` only if '' : by proposition [ silly - filtrations - appx].4@xmath178(b ) , it suffices to prove that the condition ( i@xmath1960 ) is satisfied .
let @xmath1961}$ ] denote the full triangulated subcategory of @xmath6 generated by the dg - comodules @xmath1357 with @xmath1962 and @xmath1963}{\subset}{{\mathcal d}}_{[-m,0]}$ ] be the minimal full subcategory , containing @xmath1357 and closed under extensions .
we will show by induction on @xmath2 that @xmath1961}=\bigcup_{a , b } { { \mathcal m}}_{[-m,0]}^{[a , b]}$ ] . since the homological dimension of @xmath65 is finite , it suffices to check that for any object @xmath1964}$ ] there exists a distinguished triangle @xmath1965\ ] ] such that @xmath117 belongs to the minimal full subcategory of @xmath1961}$ ] generated by @xmath1963}[-n]$ ] with @xmath1037 and closed under extensions , while @xmath1955 for @xmath1037 . using the assumption that the internal grading of @xmath111 is negative
, one can show by induction on the internal grading that any dg - comodule @xmath842 over @xmath111 is the filtered inductive limit of its dg - subcomodules @xmath873 such that the map @xmath1966 is injective and the underlying @xmath65-module of @xmath873 is finitely generated .
in particular , we can assume that our dg - comodule @xmath10 is finitely generated as a bigraded @xmath65-module .
consider the complex of @xmath65-modules @xmath946 ; clearly , there exists a distingushed triangle @xmath1967 $ ] in the derived category of @xmath65-modules such that @xmath1968 is a complex of finitely generated free @xmath65-modules concentrated in the cohomological degrees @xmath1037 , while @xmath1969 for @xmath1037 .
represent the object @xmath1970 by a finite complex of finitely generated @xmath65-modules such that the morphism @xmath1971 in the derived category comes from a morphism of complexes of @xmath65-modules .
let @xmath1972 be the dg - subcomodule of the dg - comodule @xmath111 consisting of all components of the internal degree @xmath1973 .
the morphism of complexes of @xmath65-modules @xmath1974 induces a morphism of dg - comodules @xmath1975 .
let @xmath329 be a dg - subcomodule of @xmath1976 such that the map @xmath1977 is injective , the underlying @xmath65-module of @xmath329 is finitely generated , @xmath329 contains @xmath1978 , and the morphism @xmath1979 factorizes through @xmath329 .
then , in particular , one has @xmath1980 for @xmath1037 .
let @xmath747 $ ] be the cone of the morphism @xmath1981 ; then the component @xmath1982 is isomorphic to the complex @xmath1968 in the derived category of @xmath65-modules .
there is a distinguished triangle @xmath1983 $ ] in the triangulated category @xmath6 . by the assumption of induction on @xmath2
, there exists a distinguished triangle @xmath1984 $ ] in @xmath1985}={{\mathcal d}}_{[-m+1,0]}(-1)$ ] such that @xmath363 belongs to the minimal full subcategory of @xmath1985}$ ] generated by @xmath1986}[-n]$ ] with @xmath1037 and closed under extensions , while @xmath1987 for @xmath1037 .
it remains to use the @xmath257-associativity lemma in order to obtain the desired distinguished triangle @xmath1988 $ ] .
assume that @xmath65 is a field . 1 .
@xmath29 is the heart of a t - structure on @xmath6 if and only if @xmath1364 for @xmath102 .
one has @xmath15)=0 $ ] for all @xmath10 , @xmath30 and @xmath102 provided that @xmath1364 for @xmath1369 .
one way to prove ( 1 ) is to use theorem [ t - existence ] for @xmath1989 . by that theorem , @xmath29 is the heart of a t - structure if and only if @xmath1990 for @xmath16 .
it follows immediately from the forms of the reduced bar- and cobar - constructions and their mutual inverseness up to quasi - isomorphism that @xmath1990 for @xmath16 if and only if @xmath1991 for @xmath102 .
= 1500 this approach depends on the assumption of negative internal grading ; the next one does nt . to prove ``
if '' , replace @xmath111 with its canonical truncation @xmath1992 , which is quasi - isomorphic to @xmath111 ; then the canonical truncations of dg - comodules over @xmath1993 considered as complexes of @xmath65-vector spaces become also their canonical truncations as dg - comodules ( cf .
* theorem 1.8@xmath178(b ) ) ) . to check `` only if '' , argue as in the proof of theorem [ positive - cohomology ] , the `` if '' part , using the existence of a distinguished triangle @xmath1994 $ ] in @xmath6 such that @xmath1954 for @xmath132 and @xmath1955 for @xmath1995 .
part ( 2 ) follows immediately from the form of the cobar - complex of @xmath111 . 1 .
assume that the bigraded @xmath65-algebra @xmath1996 contains a central nonzero - dividing element @xmath1997 of internal degree @xmath1998 and cohomological degree @xmath107 such that the quotient algebra @xmath1999 modulo its zero internal degree component @xmath2000 is concentrated in positive cohomological degrees .
then @xmath1364 for @xmath1369 .
2 . in the situation of ,
assume that @xmath2001 and the quotient algebra @xmath1999 is a koszul algebra over @xmath65 concentrated on the diagonal where sum of the cohomological and internal gradings is equal to zero .
let @xmath1851 denote the bar - construction of @xmath1999 .
then the bigraded coalgebra @xmath193 is the tensor product of the internally graded coalgebra @xmath2002 , which is concentrated in cohomological degree @xmath107 , and the exterior coalgebra @xmath2003 with one cogenerator @xmath1997 in the internal degree @xmath1259 and the cohomological degree @xmath1259 .
3 . assume that the dg - algebra @xmath94 contains an element @xmath1997 of internal degree @xmath1998 and cohomological degree @xmath107 , annihilated by the differential , central in @xmath94 , and nonzero - dividing in both @xmath94 and @xmath2004 .
assume further that @xmath2005 for all @xmath16 and @xmath2006 .
let @xmath1851 denote the bar - construction of the dg - algebra @xmath2007 .
then one has @xmath2008 for all @xmath1037 if and only if @xmath2009 for all @xmath1037 , and @xmath2008 for all @xmath102 if and only if @xmath2009 for all @xmath2010 . if both of these conditions hold , the bigraded coalgebra @xmath193 is the tensor product of the internally graded coalgebra @xmath2002 and the exterior coalgebra @xmath2003 with one cogenerator @xmath1997 in the internal degree @xmath1998 and the cohomological degree @xmath1259 .
the silly filtration of the reduced bar - complex @xmath2011 provides a spectral sequence starting from the cohomology of the bar - construction of @xmath2004 and converging to the cohomology of the bar - construction of @xmath94 .
this reduces part ( 1 ) to part ( 3 ) , if one takes also into account ( the first proof of ) part ( 1 ) of the preceding proposition . to prove part ( 2 ) , notice that in its assumptions the cohomology coalgebras of the bar - constructions of @xmath94 and @xmath2004 are isomorphic , since the grading on the cohomology of the bar - construction of @xmath2004 coming from the filtration coincides with the internal grading .
so it remains to prove ( 3 ) .
consider the morphism of dg - algebras @xmath1847 .
applying the left derived functor of extension of scalars @xmath2012 ( * ? ? ?
* subsection 1.7 ) to the trivial dg - module @xmath65 over the dg - algebra @xmath94 , we obtain an object @xmath2013 . since the dg - module @xmath834 over @xmath94 is quasi - isomorphic to the cone of the morphism @xmath2014 , the bigraded @xmath65-vector space @xmath2015 is two - dimensional , with one cohomology class in the internal grading @xmath107 and cohomological grading @xmath107 , and another one in the internal grading @xmath1998 and cohomological grading @xmath1259 . for the reasons of the natural filtration associated with the internal grading of dg - modules over @xmath834
, there is a distinguished triangle @xmath2016\lrarrow \mathbb l e_f(k)\lrarrow k\lrarrow k(-e)[2]\ ] ] in @xmath2017 . applying the triangulated functor of dg - module bar - construction to this distinguished triangle
, we obtain a distinguished triangle @xmath2018\lrarrow c\lrarrow d\lrarrow d(-e)[2]\ ] ] in @xmath2019 ( for the computation of the ( pre)image of the extension of scalars dg - module @xmath2020 under the bar - construction , see ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 6.9 ) ) .
the vector space of morphisms @xmath2021 $ ] in @xmath2019 is isomorphic to @xmath2022 ; the linear function corresponding to a morphism is the induced map @xmath2023 . for the morphism in the above distinguished triangle
, this map is zero , since the map @xmath2024 sends the unit element to the class of the element @xmath2025{\subset}c$ ] .
it suffices to check this in the case @xmath2026 $ ] and @xmath2027 , and then use the functoriality of our construction of distinguished triangle .
it follows from the condition of vanishing of @xmath2028 for @xmath16 and @xmath2006 that this class in @xmath2029 is nontrivial .
thus there is a short exact sequence of left @xmath2002-comodules @xmath2030)\lrarrow h(c)\lrarrow h(d)\lrarrow 0.\ ] ] the `` if and only if '' assertions of part ( 3 ) follow immediately .
now assume that @xmath2031 for all @xmath123 .
define a decreasing filtration @xmath166 on the dg - algebra @xmath94 by the rule @xmath2032 .
this filtration is finite on every internal degree component , so there is a spectral sequence starting from the cohomology of the bar - construction of @xmath2033 and converging to the cohomology of the bar - construction of @xmath94 .
the associated graded dg - algebra @xmath2033 is isomorphic to @xmath2034 $ ] , hence the cohomology of the bar - construction of @xmath2033 is isomorphic to @xmath2035 . to check this
, it suffices to construct the `` shuffle product '' morphism from the tensor product of bar - constructions to the bar - construction of the tensor product ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 1.1 of chapter 3 ) , and then reduce the question to the case of dg - algebras with trivial multiplication and/or differential by passing to associated graded objects with respect to appropriate additional filtrations . the grading on the cohomology of the bar - construction of @xmath2033 induced by the filtration @xmath166 coincides with minus
the cohomological grading , hence the cohomology coalgebras of the bar - constructions of @xmath94 and @xmath2033 are isomorphic .
in the situation of part ( 2 ) or ( 3 ) of theorem , one does _ not _ expect the dg - coalgebra @xmath111 to be quasi - isomorphic to its cohomology coalgebra @xmath193 , even though all the massey comultiplications on @xmath193 clearly vanish .
[ categories - of - morphisms - appx ] the results of [ exact - triangulated ] concerning the existence of ( canonically defined and compatible with the compositition ) morphisms of functors @xmath1800 for an exact subcategory @xmath104 in a triangulated category @xmath6 strongly suggest that there should exist a triangulated functor @xmath2036 compatible with the embeddings of @xmath104 into @xmath1761 and @xmath6 .
unfortunately , it seems to be impossible to construct such a functor in general , because of the problems with nonfunctoriality of the cone in a triangulated category . here
we will describe a refinement of the triangulated category structure that allows for construction of a functor @xmath1195 .
two different versions of such a refinement were suggested in the papers @xcite ; here we follow some kind of a middle path between the two .
namely , we use a modified form of the argument of @xcite to show that the entire filtered triangulated category structure as defined in @xcite is not needed for the above - mentioned purpose ; it suffices to have the triangulated category of two - step filtrations , or , which is the same , the triangulated category of morphisms , or of distinguished triangles .
our goal is to prove that a functor @xmath1195 exists whenever the triangulated category @xmath6 can be obtained from the homotopy category of ( unbounded ) complexes over some additive category by passing to triangulated subcategories and quotient categories any number of times .
let @xmath1916{\subset}{{\mathbb z}}$ ] be a finite or infinite segment of the integers , @xmath2037 .
@xmath1916$]-filtered triangulated category _
@xmath2038 is the following set of data . a triangulated category @xmath2039 is endowed with a family of triangulated subcategories @xmath2040
, @xmath2041 $ ] such that @xmath2039 is generated by @xmath2040 and @xmath2042 for a segment @xmath1917{\subset}[a , b]$ ] , denote by @xmath2043}$ ] the full triangulated subcategory of @xmath2039 generated by @xmath2040 with @xmath2044 $ ] .
a twist functor @xmath128 acting from @xmath2045}$ ] to @xmath2046}$ ] is given such that @xmath2047 for all @xmath2048 .
there is a natural transformation @xmath2049 for all @xmath2050}$ ] such that @xmath339 for all @xmath2051}$ ] .
finally , there is a functor @xmath2052 such that @xmath2053 is an isomorphism for all @xmath2050}$ ] .
the restriction of the functor @xmath2054 to @xmath2040 is an equivalence of categories @xmath2055 , and the map @xmath2056}$ and $ y\in{{\mathcal d}}{{\mathcal f}}_{[i , b]}$}. \end{array}\ ] ] it follows from that there is a triangulated functor of `` successive quotients '' @xmath2057}{\colon}{{\mathcal d}}{{\mathcal f}}\rarrow\prod{{\mathcal d}}{{\mathcal f}}_i$ ] ( see ( * ? ? ?
* sections 1 and 4 ) or ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 1.3.2 ) ) .
fix a segment @xmath1916 $ ] as above .
let @xmath104 be an exact category and @xmath89 be the exact category of finitely filtered objects @xmath305 in @xmath104 as defined in [ exact - cat - examples]@xmath178(5 ) for which @xmath2058 for @xmath2059 $ ] . set @xmath2060 and @xmath2061 .
let @xmath2062 be the image of the fully faithful triangulated functor @xmath2063 induced by the embedding of exact categories @xmath2064 assigning to an object @xmath1685 the filtered object @xmath201 with @xmath2065 and @xmath2066 for @xmath250 .
the twist functor @xmath425 is induced by the shift of the filtration , and the natural transformation @xmath403 is defined in the obvious way .
finally , let @xmath2052 be the triangulated functor induced by the forgetful functor @xmath180 assigning to a finitely filtered object @xmath201 the stabilizing limit of @xmath2067 as @xmath241 and @xmath2068 .
the condition is easy to check . as to the condition , it is obvious when the exact category structure on @xmath104 is trivial , so @xmath2069 and @xmath2070 .
the general case follows from the next proposition .
let @xmath2038 be an @xmath1916$]-filtered triangulated category and @xmath2071 be a triangulated subcategory .
denote by @xmath2072 the triangulated subcategory consisting of all the objects @xmath2073 such that @xmath2074 for all @xmath2041 $ ]
. then 1 .
the pair @xmath2075 with the additional data induced from that for the pair @xmath2038 is an @xmath1916$]-filtered triangulated category .
2 . if @xmath2071 is a thick subcategory , then so is @xmath2072 , and the pair @xmath2076 with the additional data induced from that for the pair @xmath2038 is an @xmath1916$]-filtered triangulated category . let us prove surjectivity .
a morphism in the category @xmath2078 is represented by a fraction @xmath2079 , where @xmath2080 .
let @xmath2081 be the embedding inverse to the equivalence @xmath2082 . by the condition for the pair @xmath2038
, there is a morphism @xmath2083 in @xmath2039 corresponding to the morphism @xmath2084 in @xmath6 .
let @xmath2085 $ ] ; since @xmath2086 , we have @xmath2087
. furthermore , @xmath2088 , hence there is a morphism @xmath2089 corresponding to the morphism @xmath2090 .
the fraction @xmath2091 provides the desired morphism @xmath586 in @xmath2092 . to check injectivity , consider a fraction @xmath2091 in @xmath2039 representing a morphism @xmath586 in @xmath2092 .
first of all let us show that one can choose @xmath2093}$ ] .
let @xmath2094 ; then there exists a distinguished triangle @xmath2095 , \quad c_{\ge i+1}\in{{\mathcal d}}{{\mathcal f}}_{[i+1,b ] } , \ \
c_{\le i}\in{{\mathcal d}}{{\mathcal f}}_{[a , i]}.\ ] ] in fact , it will be only important for us that @xmath2096}$ ] .
it follows from that the morphism @xmath2097\rarrow c_{\ge i+1}$ ] decomposes as @xmath2097 \rarrow\kappa_i w(c_{\ge i+1 } ) \rarrow c_{\ge i+1}$ ] .
set @xmath2098\to \kappa_i w(c_{\ge i+1}))$ ] and @xmath2099 . by
, one has @xmath2100)=0 $ ] for all @xmath37 . by the octahedron axiom ,
there is a distinguished triangle @xmath2101,\ ] ] hence the morphism @xmath2102 factorizes through the morphism @xmath1038 .
now let @xmath2103 $ ] ; then the morphism @xmath2104 factorizes through the morphism @xmath1000 . by the construction , @xmath2105}$ ] and
@xmath2106}$ ] .
finally , suppose that the morphism @xmath586 in @xmath2092 represented by a fraction @xmath2091 with @xmath2093}$ ] maps to a zero morphism in @xmath2078 .
this means that the morphism @xmath2107 factorizes through an object @xmath2108 .
then , by , the morphism @xmath2089 factorizes through the object @xmath2109 , hence our morphism @xmath586 in @xmath2092 vanishes .
it is also easy to see that if @xmath2038 is an @xmath1916$]-filtered triangulated category , then so is @xmath2110 , where the triangulated category structure on the saturation of a triangulated category @xcite is presumed for @xmath2111 and @xmath2112 .
from now on we will consider @xmath2113$]-filtered triangulated categories , or triangulated categories of two - step filtrations .
in this case , the twist functor @xmath425 and the natural transformation @xmath403 on @xmath2039 can be omitted in the definition of a filtered triangulated category , as they are determined by the remaining data .
recall the notation @xmath2114 , @xmath979 , @xmath156 for the functors @xmath2115 introduced in the proof of proposition [ filtered - triangulated ] .
the condition simply means that the functor @xmath2054 is right adjoint to @xmath2116 and left adjoint to @xmath2117 .
it follows from that the functor @xmath2118 is left adjoint to @xmath2116 and the functor @xmath2119 is right adjoint to @xmath2117 .
finally , there is a functor @xmath2120 left adjoint to the functor @xmath2118 .
it is given by the rule @xmath2121 $ ] , where the morphism @xmath2122 corresponds to the identity endomorphism of @xmath10 under the isomorphism .
the functor @xmath2123 $ ] is right adjoint to the functor @xmath2119 .
the situation has a triangular symmetry .
namely , setting @xmath2124 , @xmath2125 , and @xmath2126 defines a new @xmath2113$]-filtered triangulated category structure on the pair @xmath2038 , and the third such structure is given by @xmath2127 , @xmath2128 , and @xmath2129 . ideally , one would like these three sets of data to be permuted by a triangulated autoequivalence of @xmath2039 whose third power would be isomorphic to the shift functor @xmath2130 $ ] , but it is not clear how to obtain such an autoequivalence from our conditions ( [ ft - semiorthogonal][ft - hom - isomorph ] ) .
let @xmath2038 be a @xmath2113$]-filtered triangulated category and @xmath104 be an exact subcategory in @xmath6 in the sense of such that @xmath15)=0 $ ] for all @xmath10 , @xmath105 and @xmath102 . then there exists a natural triangulated functor @xmath2131 whose restriction to @xmath104 is the identity .
we start with constructing a functor from the category of bounded complexes @xmath2132 over @xmath104 ( and closed morphisms between them ) into @xmath6 .
let @xmath2133}({{\mathcal e}})$ ] denote the category of complexes concentrated in the interval @xmath1917 $ ] of cohomological degrees .
we proceed by induction in @xmath37 constructing a compatible system of functors @xmath2134}({{\mathcal e}})\rarrow{{\mathcal d}}$ ] such that @xmath2135{\dotsb}*{{\mathcal e}}{\subset}{{\mathcal d}}$ ] in the notation of @xcite .
the embedding @xmath2136 provides the functor @xmath1982 .
given the functor @xmath2137 , we construct the functor @xmath2138 as follows .
let @xmath2139 be a complex over @xmath104 concentrated in the degrees @xmath2140 $ ] ; then @xmath111 is the cone of a closed morphism of complexes @xmath2141 , where the complex @xmath1740 is concentrated in the degrees @xmath2142 $ ] and the object @xmath2143 is considered as a complex concentrated in degree @xmath107 .
consider the morphism @xmath2144 in @xmath2039 corresponding to the morphism @xmath2145 in @xmath6 .
since @xmath2146)$ ] , one can see that the cone of the morphism @xmath2147 is functorial in @xmath2139 , i. e. , defines a functor @xmath2148}({{\mathcal e}})\rarrow{{\mathcal d}}{{\mathcal f}}$ ]
. composing this functor with the functor @xmath2054 , we obtain the desired functor @xmath2138 .
it is clear that the functors @xmath2138 agree with each other and are compatible with the cohomological shift , thus they extend to a functor @xmath2149 .
the functor @xmath318 is additive , since it preserves finite direct sums .
a morphism @xmath2150 in @xmath2151 is homotopic to zero if and only if it factorizes through the complex @xmath2152 ( or @xmath2153 $ ] ) , and this complex is isomorphic to the direct sum of the complexes @xmath2154 .
the latter complexes are clearly annihilated by @xmath318 , hence the functor @xmath318 factorizes through the functor @xmath2155 .
the thick subcategory @xmath2156 is generated by complexes of the form @xmath2157 , where @xmath1484 is an admissible triple in @xmath104 .
one easily checks that such complexes are also annihilated by @xmath318 , so @xmath318 factorizes through @xmath1761 .
we have constructed the functor @xmath1195 ; it remains to check that it sends distinguished triangles to distinguished triangles .
any distinguished triangle in @xmath1761 comes from a term - wise split short exact sequence of bounded complexes @xmath2158 over @xmath104 .
one can assume that all the three complexes belong to @xmath2148}({{\mathcal e}})$ ] .
present the complex @xmath2139 as the cone of a closed morphism @xmath2141 and the complex @xmath2159 as the cone of a closed morphism @xmath2160 , where @xmath1740 , @xmath2161}({{\mathcal e}})$ ] . to check that the image of our distinguished triangle in @xmath1761 is a distinguished triangle in @xmath6
, it suffices to apply the @xmath2162-lemma ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 1.1.11 ) to the commutative square formed by the morphisms @xmath2163 and @xmath2164 in @xmath2039 , together with the assumption of induction on @xmath37 .
notice that one could also proceed in the dual way , cutting the leftmost term out of a complex @xmath2139 , rather than the rightmost term , as we have done .
this would provide another construction of a functor @xmath1195 . to prove that the two constructions produce isomorphic functors
, one would probably need to assume the existence of a @xmath2165$]-filtered triangulated category @xmath2166 containing @xmath2038 .
m. bondarko .
differential graded motives : weight complex , weight filtrations and spectral sequences for realizations ; voevodsky versus hanamura .
_ journ .
jussieu _ * 8 * , # 1 , p. 3997 , 2009 .
` arxiv : math.ag/0601713 ` b. keller . on gabriel
roiter s axioms for exact categories .
appendix to the paper : p. drxler , i. reiten , s. o. smal , .
exact categories and vector space categories . _ trans .
_ * 351 * , # 2 , p. 647692
, 1999 .
m. levine .
tate motives and the vanishing conjectures for algebraic @xmath1-theory . in _
algebraic @xmath1-theory and algebraic topology ( lake louise , canada , 1991 ) _ , nato adv .
sci.*407 * , kluwer , dordrecht , 1993 , p. 167188 .
l. positselski .
homological algebra of semimodules and semicontramodules : semi - infinite homological algebra of associative algebraic structures .
appendix c in collaboration with d. rumynin .
appendix d in collaboration with s. arkhipov .
monografie matematyczne , vol .
70 , birkhuser / springer basel , 2010 .
xxiv+349 pp . ` arxiv:0708.3398 [ math.ct ] ` l. positselski .
two kinds of derived categories , koszul duality , and comodule - contramodule correspondence .
_ memoirs of the amer . math .
_ , posted on november 19 , 2010 , s 0065 - 9266(2010)00631 - 8 ( to appear in print ) .
v+133 pp . ` arxiv:0905.2621 [ math.ct ] ` a. suslin , v. voevodsky .
bloch kato conjecture and motivic cohomology with finite coefficients . in _ the arithmetic and geometry of algebraic cycles ( banff , alberta , canada , 1998 )
_ , nato adv .
ser . c math .
phys.sci . * 548 * , kluwer , dordrecht , 2000 , p. 117189 .
r. thomason , t. trobaugh .
exact categories and the gabriel quillen embedding .
appendix a to the paper : higher algebraic k - theory of schemes and of derived categories . _ the grothendieck festschrift _ vol . 3 , p. 247435
, 1990 .
v. voevodsky .
triangulated categories of motives over a field . in _ cycles , transfers , and motivic homology theories _ , by v. voevodsky , a. suslin , and e. m. friedlander , annals of math .
studies 143 , princeton university press , princeton , nj , 2000 , p. 188238 . | the goal of this paper is to give an explicit description of the triangulated categories of tate and artin tate motives with finite coefficients @xmath0 over a field @xmath1 containing a primitive @xmath2-root of unity as the derived categories of exact categories of filtered modules over the absolute galois group of @xmath1 with certain restrictions on the successive quotients .
this description is conditional upon ( and its validity is equivalent to ) certain koszulity hypotheses about the milnor k - theory / galois cohomology of @xmath1 .
this paper also purports to explain what it means for an arbitrary nonnegatively graded ring to be koszul .
tate motives with integral coefficients are discussed in the `` conclusions '' section . |
nuclear cluster structure in the hoyle state , the second @xmath0 state at @xmath9 mev in @xmath2 , has been discussed for a long time by many authors @xcite .
cluster model approaches play an important role in understanding the structure and clarified that it has well developed @xmath8 cluster structure with more dilute density than that of saturation in the ground state , where @xmath3 clusters weakly interact with each other in a relative @xmath10-wave @xcite . in the recent fifteen years , however , the understanding of the hoyle state structure has been much deepened , by an advent of a new type of microscopic cluster model wave function , which is referred to as the tohsaki - horiuchi - schuck - rpke ( thsr ) wave function @xcite .
this wave function retains a structure that constituent @xmath3 clusters are loosely bound like a gas and occupy an identical orbit , and this structured phenomenon is now called the @xmath3 condensation .
one of the most important properties for the thsr wave function is to give a single and optimal configuration that is equivalent to a solution of full microscopic three - body problem @xcite . since it is well known that the solutions of the full microscopic three - body problem via @xmath8 resonating group method ( rgm ) @xcite and via generator
coordinate method ( gcm ) @xcite nicely reproduce many experimental data for the hoyle state , like the energy , width , electro - magnetic properties , etc , the equivalence leads to the conclusion that the hoyle state exists as the @xmath3 condensate composed of a weakly interacting and gaslike @xmath8 clusters . not only the hoyle state but also some other excited states in @xmath2 trigger a special interest in recent years .
for example , the second @xmath11 state was theoretically predicted by the use of the cluster models almost 40 years ago @xcite , but it was very recently when the existence was confirmed in several experiments @xcite , with a pioneering work by itoh _
_ as a beginning @xcite .
besides the second @xmath12 state , a new @xmath13 state is also observed at @xmath14 mev recently @xcite . the new @xmath12 and @xmath13 states
are now considered to form a rotational family with the hoyle state , though the detailed rotational structure is under question @xcite . while in ref .
@xcite a simple rotational structure based on a triangular shape of the @xmath8 clusters is assumed , it is pointed out in ref .
@xcite that this is not simply considered to be an ordinary rotational band that lies on @xmath15 line , due to the @xmath3-condensate nature of the hoyle state , where the third @xmath1 state @xmath16 above the hoyle state also plays an important role . a new experimental information is also given for the famous broad @xmath1 state observed at @xmath17 mev with a width of @xmath18 mev @xcite .
_ pointed out that the broad @xmath1 peak is decomposed into two peaks , giving the @xmath6 and @xmath7 states at @xmath19 mev and @xmath20 mev above the @xmath8 threshold , with the widths of @xmath21 mev and @xmath22 mev , respectively @xcite .
they also found a decay property that the @xmath7 state dominantly decays into @xmath23 while the @xmath6 state decays into @xmath24 .
some theoretical studies consistently reproduce the resonance parameters , where semi - microscopic @xcite or non - microscopic @xcite @xmath8 model is adopted . in particular , in ref .
@xcite , the authors applied the complex scaling method ( csm ) and analytic continuation of coupling constant ( accc ) method to the @xmath8 orthogonality condition model ( ocm ) .
they suggested by extrapolation that the @xmath6 state has an @xmath10-wave dominant structure with more dilute density than that of the hoyle state .
the observed decay property and resonance parameters of the @xmath6 and @xmath7 states are also reproduced by the recent calculation by the present author using an extended version of the thsr wave function , where @xmath25 correlation can be taken into account @xcite .
he further showed more directly by using the thsr wave function that the @xmath6 state is given rise to as a result of the monopole excitation from the hoyle state to have dominantly a higher nodal structure , where the @xmath3 cluster orbits around the @xmath26 in an @xmath10-wave with four nodes .
he also showed that the @xmath7 state has the largest @xmath27-factor in the channel of the @xmath3 cluster coupling with @xmath28 in a @xmath29-wave .
this is consistent with the previous result of the @xmath8 gcm calculation @xcite , where a large reduced width amplitude ( rwa ) from the @xmath23 channel is obtained , although their calculation fails in reproducing the observed @xmath6 state .
i should also mention that the antisymmetrized molecular dynamics ( amd ) and fermionic molecular dynamics ( fmd ) calculations reproduce the @xmath7 state and predict that the state dominantly has an intrinsic configuration of bent - armed shape of the @xmath8 clusters , like a linear - chain structure that was originally proposed by morinaga @xcite , although the observed @xmath6 state is also missing in their calculations @xcite . in ref .
@xcite , the linear - chain component of the @xmath7 state obtained by the @xmath8 ocm is identified to be @xmath30 configuration in the elliott @xmath31 model , which is calculated to be about @xmath32 % . in this paper ,
i investigate the excited @xmath0 states obtained in the previous work @xcite by using the extended thsr wave function and the so - called @xmath5-constraint method @xcite .
i focus on how much components concentrate on a single configuration of the extended thsr wave function with deformation parameters , and discuss physical natures of the states . in sec .
[ sec:2 ] , the original thsr wave function is explained , and then as its natural extension the extended thsr wave function is introduced . in sec .
[ sec:3 ] , the structures of the @xmath33 , @xmath6 , and @xmath7 states are discussed .
squared - overlap surfaces between the states and single configurations of the thsr wave function in their deformation parameter space are calculated .
[ sec:4 ] is devoted to conclusion .
the original thsr wave function with deformation @xcite is described below , @xmath34 , \nonumber \\ & & = { \cal a}\big [ \exp \big\ { - \sum_{i=1}^2 \mu_i \hspace{-0.2 cm } \sum_{k = x , y , z}\hspace{-0.1 cm } \frac{\xi_{ik}^2}{b^2 + 2\beta_{k}^2}\big\ } \phi(\alpha_1)\phi(\alpha_2)\phi(\alpha_3 ) \big],\nonumber \\ \label{eq : thsr } \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath35 being the antisymmetrization operator acting on the 12 nucleons , @xmath36 the internal wave function of the @xmath37-th @xmath3 particle assuming a @xmath38 configuration , like , @xmath39,\ ] ] @xmath40 , @xmath41 , the position vectors of the @xmath37-th @xmath3 particle and of total center - of - mass , respectively , @xmath42 and @xmath43 the jacobi coordinates between the @xmath3 particles , and @xmath44 .
the parameters @xmath45 and @xmath46 characterize the size of the constituent @xmath3 particle , and the size and shape of the total nucleus , respectively , though the axial symmetry @xmath47 is assumed throughout this study .
the extended version of the thsr wave function which i utilize in this work is a natural extension of the original form , eq .
( [ eq : thsr ] ) , as follows : @xmath48 , \label{eq:2 } \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the single parameter @xmath46 is decomposed into @xmath49 and @xmath50 corresponding to the two jacobi coordinates , @xmath51 and @xmath52 , and @xmath53 is a normalization constant .
this allows us to include @xmath54-type configuration beyond the original thsr wave function , where all @xmath3 clusters are restricted to move in an identical orbit .
this model wave function provides a picture that constituent clusters of a nucleus are trapped into a potential without any geometrical rigid configuration of the clusters under the constraint of antisymmetrization .
the center - of - mass wave functions of the constituent clusters are assumed to have deformable gaussian shapes with widths that are variational parameters and characterize the spatial size and shape of the nucleus .
this is mentioned as a `` container '' picture or non - localized concept of cluster structures in some recent publications ( see ref .
@xcite and references therein ) .
not only the gaslike cluster states like the hoyle state @xmath55 and @xmath56 @xmath57 but also ordinary cluster states , which had been believed to have non - gaslike localized cluster structures , such as the inversion doublet band with @xmath58 structure @xcite , @xmath8 and @xmath59 linear - chain structure @xcite , @xmath60 structure in @xmath61 @xcite , @xmath62 and @xmath63 structures in @xmath64 @xcite and @xmath65 @xcite , respectively , etc , can all be described by this thsr ansatz with almost @xmath66 % accuracy . since the excited states above the hoyle state were observed as resonances with non - negligible widths , it is more likely that the bound state approximation does not work well for those states .
i therefore use a technique to effectively eliminate continuum components that get mixed with the resonances , so - called @xmath5-constraint method , which is also used in refs .
@xcite and the effectiveness is already guaranteed . in this technique , by considering the fact that in calculations of bound states , pseudo continuum states are shown to have large root mean square ( r.m.s . )
radii , compared to those of resonances and bound states , one can remove effectively the spurious continuum components in the following way : first i solve the following equation , @xmath67 with @xmath68 , and @xmath69 , where @xmath70 is the angular - momentum projection operator onto @xmath71 . the eigenstates in eq .
( [ eq : cutoff1 ] ) can be written as , @xmath72 next i adopt , as bases to diagonalize hamiltonian , the eigenstates belonging to eigenvalues satisfying @xmath73 in eq .
( [ eq : cutoff2 ] ) , as follows : @xmath74 and obtain the eigenfunction , @xmath75 for hamiltonian , the same effective nucleon - nucleon interaction as used in ref .
@xcite , volkov no . 2 force @xcite , is adopted , where the strength parameters are slightly modified @xcite . the cutoff radius is now taken to be @xmath76 fm as in ref . @xcite .
.energies , widths , r.m.s .
radii , and monopole transition strengths .
units of energies and widths are mev , of radii @xmath77 , @xmath78 @xmath79 . experimental data ( exp . ) , thsr , ocm1 , ocm2 , fmc , and amd are taken from refs .
@xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , respectively . [ cols="^,<,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ tab:1 ] in table [ tab:1 ] , the calculated observables , energy , @xmath3-decay width , monopole transition strengths are compared with the experimental data and those of the other calculations . the present calculation consistently reproduces the corresponding experimental data .
the r.m.s .
radius of the @xmath6 state is the largest of the @xmath1 states and the much stronger monopole transition strength between the @xmath33 and @xmath6 states , than that between the @xmath33 and @xmath80 state ( see ref .
@xcite ) , can be seen .
these indicate , as discussed in ref .
@xcite , that the @xmath6 state is excited by monopole transition from the hoyle state to have a higher nodal structure between @xmath56 and @xmath3 cluster . as i mentioned in sec .
[ sec:2 ] , i adopted volkov no .
2 force as an effective nucleon - nucleon interaction in this work .
i also checked if the results depend on the choice of the force .
for example , when i adopt volkov no .
1 force , the energies of the @xmath33 , @xmath6 , and @xmath7 states become slightly higher by about @xmath81 mev , i.e. @xmath82 mev , @xmath83 mev , and @xmath84 mev , respectively .
however , i confirmed that qualitative features of these states that will be discussed in this section , such as the behaviours of squared overlaps , do not change at all .
i also mention that only the thsr ansatz lists rather complete physical quantities , including the r.m.s .
radii and monopole transition strengths , since the wave functions of both @xmath6 and @xmath7 states are definitely obtained . as mentioned in introduction , the amd and fmd calculations can not reproduce the @xmath6 state , and in ocm@xmath85csm@xmath85accc calculation in ref .
@xcite , denoted as ocm1 in this table , the wave function of the @xmath6 state can not be obtained . in eq .
( [ eq : ovlp1 ] ) with @xmath86 , i.e. for the @xmath33 state , in two parameter space , @xmath87 .
black solid curves are drawn in a step of @xmath88 and red dotted curves , which cover the region of @xmath89 , are in a step of @xmath90 . ] in eq .
( [ eq : ovlp2 ] ) with @xmath86 , i.e. for the @xmath33 state , in two parameter space , @xmath87 .
black solid curves are drawn in a step of @xmath88 and red dotted curves , which cover the region of @xmath91 , are in a step of @xmath90 . ] in ref .
@xcite , the author investigated the hoyle band @xmath92 and the @xmath6 and @xmath7 states by using the extended thsr wave function .
all the states obtained in his calculations are derived as solutions of the hill - wheeler equation eq .
( [ eq : wf ] ) , where many bases of thsr - type configurations are superposed
. this will , however , make it unclear how the thsr picture mentioned above is realized for those states , since the superposition of the thsr configurations might break its original picture .
thus , in order to investigate how the thsr picture holds for the @xmath1 states , i calculate the following two quantities : @xmath93 and @xmath94 the former is the squared overlap of the @xmath33 @xmath95 , @xmath6 @xmath96 and @xmath7 @xmath97 states in eq .
( [ eq : wf ] ) with the single configuration of the angular - momentum - projected thsr wave function , @xmath98 .
the latter is also the squared overlap of the @xmath1 states in eq .
( [ eq : wf ] ) with the single configuration of the angular - momentum - projected thsr wave function but the lower @xmath1 states components are subtracted by the projection operator defined as , @xmath99 , from the single thsr wave function .
@xmath100 is a normalization constant of the wave function @xmath101 . in fig .
[ fig:1 ] , i show the contour map of the squared overlap @xmath102 in two parameter space @xmath47 and @xmath103 with @xmath104 .
one can see that maximum value of the squared overlap amounts to @xmath105 at @xmath106 fm and @xmath107 fm .
while this large value indicates that the hoyle state is expressed by a single configuration of the thsr wave function with @xmath108 , the hoyle state is orthogonal to the ground state , and therefore the orthogonality condition should be imposed on the thsr wave function to describe the hoyle state .
i then calculate the second quantity of the squared overlap discussed above , @xmath109 with @xmath104 .
figure [ fig:2 ] shows the contour map in two parameter space @xmath87 .
the maximal value is found to be @xmath110 at @xmath111 , which is surprisingly large value , almost @xmath66 % .
this large value was already found before in refs .
@xcite with the thsr ansatz of @xmath108 , but i should note that in the present case this large value is also obtained in the calculation with larger model space @xmath112 , where @xmath113 and @xmath3 asymmetric configuration is allowed for . the fact that nevertheless this large value is again obtained strongly suggests that in the hoyle state the @xmath8 particles , democratically , without a strong @xmath114 correlation , take an identical motion , so that the @xmath8 condensate state is realized .
one can also find that the region denoted by dotted curve in red , where the squared overlap is more than @xmath115 , is widely ranged from prolately @xmath116 to oblately @xmath117 deformed shapes , passing through the spherical one @xmath118 , with large @xmath119 values .
this supports the idea that the hoyle state does not have any definite intrinsic shape but have a gaslike configuration of the @xmath8 particles .
i should also note that the projection operator @xmath120 , which removes the ground state component with compact structure , plays a role as a repulsive force to prevent the @xmath8 clusters from being resolved and to form well developed @xmath8 cluster structure for the hoyle state , due to its orthogonality condition .
this is essentially the same as the situation of @xmath56 , where the antisymmetrization operator @xmath35 removes the pauli forbidden states , to construct a structural repulsive core between the two @xmath3 clusters . in eq .
( [ eq : ovlp1 ] ) with @xmath121 , i.e. for the @xmath6 state , in two parameter space , @xmath87 .
black solid curves are drawn in a step of @xmath88 and red dotted curves , which cover the region of @xmath122 , are in a step of @xmath90 . ] in eq .
( [ eq : ovlp2 ] ) with @xmath121 , i.e. for the @xmath6 state , in two parameter space , @xmath87 .
black solid curves are drawn in a step of @xmath88 and red dotted curves , which cover the region of @xmath123 , are in a step of @xmath90 . ] in eq .
( [ eq : ovlp2 ] ) with @xmath121 , i.e. for the @xmath6 state , in two parameter space , @xmath124 , where the maximal values of @xmath125 obtained by varying @xmath50 are shown .
the region of @xmath126 is only shown in a step of @xmath127 of the contour lines . ]
next i show the contour map of the squared overlap for the @xmath6 state , @xmath128 in fig .
[ fig:3 ] and @xmath129 in fig .
[ fig:4 ] in two parameter space @xmath47 and @xmath103 . in fig .
[ fig:3 ] , the contour lines more than @xmath88 are denoted by dotted ones in red , in a step of @xmath90 .
one can see that the @xmath6 state does not have any squared overlap that is more than 0.1 in internal region of @xmath47 and @xmath103 .
it only has at most @xmath130 in an outside region around @xmath131 fm , @xmath132 fm .
i also check the squared overlap in the model space of @xmath133 , i.e. @xmath134 in four parameter space , but no large squared overlap more than 0.19 can be obtained . however , this situation changes drastically when i consider the thsr model space of its single configuration that is orthogonal to the hoyle state as well as to the ground state , i.e. @xmath135 , where the projection operator is defined as @xmath136 . then in fig .
[ fig:4 ] , i show the squared overlap @xmath129 in two parameter space , @xmath87 .
the contour lines more than @xmath137 are denoted by dotted ones in red , in a step of @xmath90 .
one can see that contrary to fig .
[ fig:3 ] , very large squared overlap appears in the internal region .
the largest one amounts to @xmath138 at @xmath139 .
one can also see that this large value quickly decreases toward around @xmath111 , which corresponds to the point giving the maximum squared overlap for the hoyle state in fig .
[ fig:2 ] .
this is of course due to the effect of the orthogonalization operator @xmath140 .
these results clearly indicate that in order to describe the @xmath6 state , the orthogonalization to the hoyle state as well as to the ground state is the most essential .
this implies that the @xmath6 state is intimately related to the hoyle state , like its family .
due to this orthogonalization , the @xmath6 state is considered to exist as an excitation mode from the hoyle state with respect to the internal motions of the @xmath8 clusters . in the previous paper ref .
@xcite , for the @xmath6 state , the large rwa of @xmath141 component with a higher node than in the hoyle state is calculated . also as shown in table [ tab:1 ] , the much larger monopole strength from the hoyle state than a single particle strength , @xmath142 , is obtained . from these results
, it was concluded that the @xmath6 state is given rise to as a result of the strong monopole transition from the hoyle state , to have a higher nodal structure .
these results are consistent with the present results , giving the interpretation that the monopole transition or vibration mode is brought about by the orthogonalization to the hoyle state , to necessarily provide the higher nodes in the internal motions of the @xmath8 clusters . in order to further investigate how @xmath6 state contains the @xmath25 correlation
, i then calculate the squared overlap in four parameter space , @xmath143 . for a given @xmath49 value ,
the maximal squared overlap obtained by varying @xmath50 value is shown in the contour map of fig .
[ fig:5 ] , as a function of two parameters @xmath144 .
the region giving more than the squared overlap of @xmath145 is only shown in fig .
[ fig:5 ] with contour lines in a step of @xmath127 . while the largest value appears at oblately deformed region , like fig .
[ fig:4 ] , it is also found that there appear two maxima in the prolately deformed region , which are about @xmath146 , at @xmath147 and @xmath148 .
the corresponding @xmath50 values are @xmath149 and @xmath150 , respectively . since @xmath49 and @xmath50 correspond to the deformation parameters of @xmath56 and the remaining @xmath3-cluster motion , respectively , and @xmath56 is expressed to have prolately deformed value for @xmath49 , this large squared overlap values indicate that the @xmath6 state has sizable @xmath25 correlation , which is also consistent with the previous calculation of the @xmath25 rwa . in eq .
( [ eq : ovlp1 ] ) with @xmath151 , i.e. for the @xmath7 state , in two parameter space , @xmath87 .
black solid curves are drawn in a step of @xmath88 and red dotted curves , which cover the region of @xmath152 , are in a step of @xmath90 . ] , which gives the maximal squared overlap , @xmath153 , in fig .
[ fig:6 ] . ]
finally i discuss the structure of the @xmath7 state .
as i mentioned in introduction , in the amd , fmd , and @xmath8 gcm calculations , the @xmath6 state may be missing and only the @xmath7 state was obtained .
the dominant intrinsic configuration of the @xmath7 state in the amd and fmd calculations shows a bent - armed structure of the @xmath8 clusters , resembling the linear - chain structure . on the other hand , in the ocm@xmath85csm@xmath85accc and @xmath8 gcm calculations , the @xmath7 state has a structure that the @xmath3 cluster predominantly couples in a @xmath29-wave with the @xmath28 core .
the same result is also given by the rwa analysis in the present ansatz in ref .
the problem is whether the interpretation of the linear - chain - like structure for the @xmath7 state is reasonable or not , since the amd and fmd calculations can not reproduce the @xmath6 and @xmath7 state simultaneously .
actually it was recently reported by suhara _
, that the orthogonality condition to the lower states plays an important role for the survival of the linear - chain structure state in @xmath2 @xcite . in fig .
[ fig:6 ] , i show the contour map of the squared overlap for the @xmath7 state , @xmath154 , in two parameter space , @xmath87 . the contour lines giving more than @xmath155 are denoted by dot in red , in a step of @xmath90 .
this contour map has a characteristic feature , where the strongly prolate deformation is only allowed to have a non - negligible squared overlap amplitude . except for this prolately deformed region ,
the squared overlap is less than @xmath88 .
the largest value is @xmath153 , which is not so much large but clearly indicates the @xmath8 linear - chain structure .
i can consider this situation as follows : it is shown that the extremely prolately - deformed shaped thsr wave function has very small overlap with the other shaped thsr wave function ( see fig . 2 in ref .
@xcite ) . since the configuration space other than the extremely prolately - deformed region
is already used by the hoyle state and the @xmath6 state ( see fig .
[ fig:1 ] and fig .
[ fig:3 ] ) , as well as by the ground state for the more compact region , the @xmath7 state has no choice but using the remaining configuration , to result in having the extremely prolately - deformed shape , i.e. linear - chain structure .
i also mention that this feature of the @xmath7 state is quite different from the behaviour of the hoyle state , in which the @xmath46 parameter space giving the large squared overlap is widely spanned as shown in fig .
[ fig:1 ] .
while the feature for the hoyle state implies that any definite intrinsic wave function for this state is difficult to be uniquely determined , the feature of the @xmath7 state allows for the definite intrinsic shape .
the parameter values giving the maximal squared overlap is calculated to be @xmath156 , which is close to @xmath157 that was obtained in a rather ideal one - dimension situation in ref .
@xcite . in ref .
@xcite , it is discussed that largely prolately - deformed thsr wave function shows one - dimensional @xmath3 condensate of @xmath8 clusters , which is fairly different from the ordinary picture of the linear - chain state with rigid - body @xmath8-cluster configuration arranged in a line in a spatially localized way .
thus i can say that the present @xmath7 state has the one - dimensional @xmath3 condensate structure by around @xmath158 % , where the @xmath8 clusters are loosely trapped into a prolately deformed potential like a one - dimensional gas . in eq .
( [ eq : ovlp2 ] ) with @xmath151 , i.e. for the @xmath7 state , in two parameter space , @xmath87 , in a step of @xmath88 . ] figure .
[ fig:7 ] shows the intrinsic density profile generated from the single thsr wave function , before angular - momentum projection , with @xmath156 , which gives the maximal squared overlap in fig .
[ fig:6 ] .
this density distribution shows a clear linear - chain structure of the @xmath8 clusters , i.e. localized @xmath3 clusters , with an extended long tail along the @xmath159-direction . as is discussed in ref .
@xcite , this comes from the inter-@xmath3 pauli repulsion , as a kinematical effect , which makes this object look like keeping localized clustering .
however , dynamics prefers a one - dimensional gas , according to the potential picture and the character of the thsr wave function mentioned above .
this is particularly expressed as the long tail elongated along the @xmath159-direction in this figure .
finally i show in fig .
[ fig:8 ] the contour map in the orthogonal space , @xmath160 as usual , in two parameter space @xmath87 .
the largest squared overlap value increases up to @xmath146 and the @xmath108 value to give the maximum slightly moves toward spherical region , which is @xmath161 , but still shows very strongly prolately - deformed shape . on the one hand
, this large value again supports that the @xmath7 state has a linear - chain shape . on the other hand ,
the second and third maxima also appear at @xmath162 and @xmath163 , where the maximal values are @xmath164 and @xmath165 , respectively .
the former and the latter correspond to the oblately deformed shape and the spherical shape , respectively .
this may suggest that due to the orthogonalization operator @xmath166 , some other correlations to unstabilize the linear - chain structure , like a bending mode , which allows for a spherical shape at a certain probability , take part in , as is discussed in ref . @xcite .
in conclusion , i investigated the excited @xmath0 states in @xmath2 by using the extended thsr wave function with @xmath5-constraint method .
in particular , i focused on the @xmath6 and @xmath7 states , which were recently found in experiment .
the physical properties of the states , relationship with the hoyle state , and similarities and differences between them were discussed by calculating the squared overlap with the single configurations of the extended thsr wave function .
the @xmath6 state was found to appear as a result of the orthogonalization to the hoyle state as well as to the ground state , so that the strong monopole transition or vibrational transition is induced .
the state is considered to be a family of the hoyle state with a higher nodal structure in internal motions of the @xmath8 clusters .
the @xmath7 state was shown to have a linear - chain structure as a dominant configuration , where the @xmath8 clusters move rather freely in a much elongated way along the @xmath159-axis , i.e. like a one - dimensional gas , though the density distribution shows a localized @xmath8 linear - chain structure , due to the inter-@xmath3 pauli repulsion . besides the linear - chain configuration
, some other correlations like a bending mode also seem to be mixed .
the author wishes to thank b. zhou , h. horiuchi , t. suhara , a. tohsaki , g. rpke , p. schuck , t. yamada for many helpful discussions .
this work is financially supported by hpci project and jsps kakenhi grant number 25400288 . the support of beihang university under the `` zhuoyue 100 talents '' program is gratefully acknowledged .
h. horiuchi , prog .
. phys . * 51 * , 1266 ( 1974 ) ; * 53 * , 447 ( 1975 ) .
y. fukushima _ et al_. , suppl . of j. phys .
japan , * 44 * , 225 ( 1978 ) ; m. kamimura , nucl . phys .
a * 351 * , 456 ( 1981 ) .
e. uegaki , s. okabe , y. abe , and h. tanaka , prog .
. phys . * 57 * , 1262 ( 1977 ) ; * 62 * , 1621 ( 1979 ) .
y. fujiwara , h. horiuchi , k. ikeda , m. kamimura , k. kat@xmath167 , y. suzuki , and e. uegaki , suppl .
* 68 * , 29 ( 1980 ) .
p. descouvemont and d. baye , phys .
c * 36 * , 54 ( 1987 ) .
r. pichler , h. oberhummer , a. cst , and s. a. moszkowski , nucl .
a*618 * , 55 ( 1997 ) .
y. suzuki and m. takahashi , phys .
c * 65 * , 064318(2002 ) ; h. matsumura and y. suzuki , nucl .
a*739 * , 238 ( 2004 ) .
t. yamada and p. schuck , phys .
c * 69 * , 024309 ( 2004 ) .
t. yamada and p. schuck , eur .
j. a * 26 * , 185 ( 2005 ) . c. kurokawa and k. kat@xmath167 , phys .
c * 71 * , 021301 ( 2005 ) ; nucl .
a * 792 * , 87 ( 2007 ) .
y. funaki , a. tohsaki , h. horiuchi , p. schuck , and g. rpke , eur .
j. a * 28 * , 259 ( 2006 ) .
k. arai , phys .
c * 74 * , 064311 ( 2006 ) .
m. chernykh , h. feldmeier , t. neff , p. von neumann - cosel , and a. richter , phys .
lett . * 98 * , 032501 ( 2007 ) .
y. kanada - enyo , prog .
. phys . * 117 * , 655 ( 2007 ) .
s. ohtsubo , y. fukushima , m. kamimura , and e. hiyama , prog .
exp . phys .
2013 , 073d02 .
y. fukuoka , s. shinohara , y. funaki , t. nakatsukasa , and k. yabana , phys .
c * 88 * , 014321 ( 2013 ) .
m. freer , h. o. u. fynbo , prog .
. phys . * 78 * , 1 ( 2014 ) , and references therein .
a. tohsaki , h. horiuchi , p. schuck , and g. rpke , phys .
lett . * 87 * , 192501 ( 2001 ) .
y. funaki , h. horiuchi , a. tohsaki , p. schuck , and g. rpke , prog .
. phys . * 108 * , 297 ( 2002 ) .
y. funaki , h. horiuchi , a. tohsaki , prog .
. phys . * 82 * , 78 ( 2015 ) .
y. funaki , a. tohsaki , h. horiuchi , p. schuck , and g. rpke , phys .
c * 67 * , 051306(r ) ( 2003 ) . y. funaki , a. tohsaki , h. horiuchi , p. schuck , and g. rpke , eur . phys .
j. a * 24 * , 321 ( 2005 ) . y. funaki , h. horiuchi , w. von oertzen , g. rpke , p. schuck , a. tohsaki , and t. yamada , phys .
c * 80 * , 064326 ( 2009 ) .
m. freer _ et al .
_ , phys . rev .
c * 80 * , 041303(r ) ( 2009 ) . m. itoh _
c * 84 * , 054308 ( 2011 ) .
fynbo and m. freer , physics * 4 * , 94 ( 2011 ) .
zimmerman , n. e. destefano , m. freer , m. gai , and f. d. smit , phys .
c * 84 * , 027304 ( 2011 ) .
et al . _ ,
lett . * 110 * , 152502 ( 2013 ) .
et al . _ ,
a * 738 * , 268 ( 2004 ) .
m. freer _ et al .
c * 83 * , 034314 ( 2011 ) .
d. j. mari - lambarri , r. bijker , m. freer , m. gai , tz .
kokalova , d.j .
parker , and c. wheldon , phys .
* 113 * , 012502 ( 2014 ) .
y. funaki , phys .
c * 92 * , 021302(r ) ( 2015 ) .
c * 68 * , 014305 ( 2003 ) .
h. o. u. fynbo _
et al . _ ,
lett . * 91 * , 082502 ( 2003 ) ; h. o. u. fynbo _
a * 738 * , 59 ( 2004 ) ; h. o. u. fynbo _
et al . _ , nature(london ) * 433 * , 136 ( 2005 ) . c. aa .
a * 760 * , 3 ( 2005 ) .
et al . _ , j. phys . :
* 436 * , 012006 ( 2013 ) .
r. lazauskas , m. dufour , phys .
c * 84 * , 064318 ( 2011 ) .
s. ishikawa , phys .
c * 90 * , 061604(r ) ( 2014 ) .
h. morinaga , phys . rev .
* 101 * , 254 ( 1956 ) ; phys .
* 21 * , 78 ( 1966 ) .
t. neff and h. feldmeier , nucl .
a * 738 * , 357 ( 2004 ) .
k. kat@xmath167 , h. kazama , h. tanaka , prog .
phys . * 77 * , 185 ( 1987 ) .
y. funaki , h. horiuchi , and a. tohsaki , prog .
phys . * 115 * , 115 ( 2006 ) .
y. funaki , t. yamada , a. tohsaki , h. horiuchi , g. rpke , and p. schuck , phys .
c * 82 * , 024312 ( 2010 ) .
b. zhou , z. z. ren , c. xu , y. funaki , t. yamada , a. tohsaki , h. horiuchi , p. schuck , and g. rpke , phys .
c * 86 * , 014301 ( 2012 ) ; b. zhou , y. funaki , h. horiuchi , z. z. ren , g. rpke , p. schuck , a. tohsaki , c. xu , and t. yamada , phys .
lett . * 110 * , 262501 ( 2013 ) ; b. zhou , y. funaki , h. horiuchi , z. z. ren , g. rpke , p. schuck , a. tohsaki , c. xu , and t. yamada , phys .
c * 89 * , 034319 ( 2014 ) .
t. suhara , y. funaki , b. zhou , h. horiuchi , and a. tohsaki , phys .
* 112 * , 062501 ( 2014 ) .
y. funaki , t. yamada , e. hiyama , b. zhou , and k. ikeda , prog .
2014 * , 113d01 .
m. lyu , z. z. ren , b. zhou , y. funaki , h. horiuchi , g. rpke , p. schuck , a. tohsaki , c. xu , and t. yamada , phys .
c * 91 * , 014313 ( 2015 ) .
m. lyu , z. z. ren , b. zhou , y. funaki , h. horiuchi , g. rpke , p. schuck , a. tohsaki , c. xu , and t. yamada , phys .
c * 93 * , 054308 ( 2016 ) .
a. b. volkov , nucl .
a * 74 * , 33 ( 1965 ) .
t. yamada , y. funaki , h. horiuchi , k. ikeda , and a. tohsaki , prog .
* 120 * , 1139 ( 2008 ) ; t. yamada , y. funaki , t. myo , h. horiuchi , k. ikeda , g. rpke , p. schuck , and a. tohsaki , phys .
c * 85 * , 034315 ( 2012 ) .
t. suhara and y. kanada - enyo , phys .
c * 91 * , 024315(2015 ) . | background : : two new @xmath0 states are recently observed around a few mev above the hoyle state ( the second @xmath1 state in @xmath2 ) . the characters of them are only poorly discussed in theory and are still mysterious .
purpose : : i give for the first time a comprehensive understanding of the structures of the @xmath1 states by analyzing their wave functions , and discuss relationship with the hoyle state , similarities , and differences between the states .
method : : i extend a microscopic @xmath3-cluster model called tohsaki - horiuchi - schuck - rpke ( thsr ) wave function so as to incorporate @xmath4 asymmetric configuration explicitly . the so - called @xmath5-constraint method to effectively eliminate spurious continuum components is also used .
results : : the @xmath6 state is shown to have a very large squared overlap with a single configuration of the extended thsr wave function in an orthogonal space to the hoyle state as well as to the ground state .
the @xmath7 state has a maximal squared overlap with a single extended thsr wave function with an extremely prolately - deformed shape .
conclusions : : the @xmath6 state appears as a family of the hoyle state to have a higher nodal structure in the internal motions of the @xmath8 clusters , due to the orthogonalization to the hoyle state .
the @xmath7 state dominantly has a linear - chain structure , where the @xmath8 clusters move freely in a non - localized way , like a one - dimensional gas of the @xmath8 clusters . |
two outstanding mysteries in particle theory are the cause of electroweak symmetry breaking and the origin of flavor symmetry breaking by which the quarks and leptons obtain their diverse masses .
the standard model of particle physics , based on the gauge group @xmath0 accommodates both symmetry breakings by including a fundamental weak doublet of scalar ( `` higgs '' ) bosons @xmath1 with potential function @xmath2 .
however the standard model provides no explanation of the dynamics responsible for the generation of mass .
furthermore , the scalar sector suffers from two serious problems .
the scalar mass is unnaturally sensitive to the presence of physics at any higher scale @xmath3 ( e.g. the planck scale or a grand - unification scale ) : this is known as the gauge hierarchy problem .
in addition , if the scalar must provide a good description of physics up to arbitrarily high scale ( i.e. , be fundamental , not composite ) , the scalar s self - coupling ( @xmath4 ) is driven to zero at finite energy scales .
that is , the scalar field theory is free ( or `` trivial '' )
. then the scalar can not fill its intended role : if @xmath5 , the electroweak symmetry is not spontaneously broken .
it is , thus , necessary to seek the origin of mass in physics that lies beyond the standard model .
one intriguing possibility is to introduce supersymmetry @xcite .
the gauge structure of the minimal supersymmetric version of the standard model ( mssm ) is identical to that of the standard model , but each ordinary fermion ( boson ) is paired with a new boson ( fermion ) called its `` superpartner '' and two higgs doublets are needed to provide mass to all the ordinary fermions .
each loop of ordinary particles contributing to the higgs boson s mass is now countered by a loop of superpartners .
if the masses of the ordinary particles and superpartners are sufficiently close , the gauge hierarchy can be stabilized @xcite .
in addition , supersymmetry relates the scalar self - coupling to gauge couplings , so that triviality is not a concern .
another interesting class of models involve dynamical electroweak symmetry breaking@xcite . in these theories ,
a new strong gauge interaction with @xmath6 ( e.g technicolor ) breaks the chiral symmetries of a set of massless fermions @xmath7 at a scale @xmath8tev .
if the fermions carry appropriate electroweak quantum numbers , the resulting condensate @xmath9 breaks the electroweak symmetry as desired .
the logarithmic running of the strong gauge coupling renders the low value of the electroweak scale ( i.e. the gauge hierarchy ) natural .
the absence of fundamental scalar bosons obviates concerns about triviality . how is one to choose among the various models ?
consider a rough graph of the masses of the known fermions and gauge bosons : = = = = = = .5cme 1.27 cm w z .67 cm t + + + the top quark is singled out@xcite : it is the heaviest known elementary particle , with a mass of order the electroweak scale , @xmath10gev , and is far heavier than its weak partner ( @xmath11 ) .
this suggests that the top quark may afford us insight about existing models of electroweak physics and may even play a special role in electroweak and flavor symmetry breaking .
the large mass of the top quark has illuminated aspects of existing theories of electroweak and flavor physics .
we review some opportunities and constraints the top quark has provided for supersymmetric models and theories of dynamical electroweak symmetry breaking .
a challenge for supersymmetric models is to explain why the higgs scalar develops a negative mass - squared ( so that the electroweak symmetry breaks ) while the scalar partners of the ordinary fermions do not ( so that color and electromagnetism are preserved ) .
the heavy top quark provides a solution . in many types of models (
e.g. the constrained mssm ( cmssm ) , models of dynamical supersymmetry breaking ) the mass - squared of the higgs is related to that of the sfermions , and is therefore positive at scales ( @xmath12 ) well above the weak scale@xcite @xmath13 moving towards lower scales , the masses of the higgs ( @xmath14 ) and of the top squarks ( @xmath15 ) evolve under the renormalization group@xcite : @xmath16 clearly , the top quark s large yukawa coupling @xmath17 is important and the mass - squared of the higgs @xmath18 is affected more than that of the squarks . the approximate solution for the light higgs mass - squared at scale @xmath19 is @xmath20 for a top quark mass @xmath21 gev , the higgs mass - squared is driven negative near the electroweak scale @xcite , while those of the squarks are not . as desired , the electroweak symmetry breaks while color and electromagnetism survive .
after electroweak symmetry breaking , the higgs spectrum of the mssm includes two neutral scalar bosons .
the tree - level upper bound on the mass of the lighter one ( @xmath18 ) is @xmath22 .
this would appear to forbid @xmath23 and lies quite close to the experimental lower bound on @xmath24 .
radiative corrections involving the heavy top quark and its superpartners provide a resolution . for @xmath25 ,
the bound on @xmath14 becomes @xcite @xmath26 so that @xmath27 gev and @xmath23 ( the @xmath28 symmetric limit @xcite or `` light gaugino - higgsino window '' @xcite ) is still viable
. extended technicolor ( etc ) is an explicit realization of dynamical electroweak symmetry breaking and fermion mass generation .
one starts with a strong gauge group ( technicolor ) felt only by a set of new massless fermions ( technifermions ) and extends the technicolor gauge group to a larger ( etc ) group under which ordinary fermions are also charged . at a scale @xmath29 ,
etc breaks to its technicolor subgroup and the gauge bosons coupling ordinary fermions to technifermions acquire a mass of order @xmath29 . at a scale @xmath30
the technicolor coupling becomes strong enough to form a technifermion condensate and break the electroweak symmetry . because the massive etc gauge bosons couple the ordinary fermions to the condensate , the ordinary fermions acquire mass too .
the top quark s mass , e.g. , comes from and its size is @xmath31 @xmath32 .
thus the scale @xmath29 must satisfy @xmath33 tev in order to produce @xmath34 gev .
several difficulties arise when one tries to balance the need to create a wide range of ordinary fermion masses against the requirement of keeping the oblique correction @xmath35 small .
first are the so - called `` direct '' contributions@xcite to @xmath35 .
the etc sector must violate weak isospin in order to make @xmath36 .
this can induce dangerous technifermion ( @xmath37 ) contributions to @xmath35 : .5 cm @xmath38 to satisfy the experimental constraint @xmath39 , one might consider making the etc boson heavy .
this requires @xmath40 , which is too heavy to produce @xmath21gev .
a better alternative@xcite is to arrange for separate dynamical sectors to break the electroweak symmetry and produce the bulk of @xmath41 .
then the technifermions contributing to @xmath35 can satisfy @xmath42gev .
there are also `` indirect '' contributions@xcite to @xmath35 from isospin- violating .1 cm @xmath43 at low energies @xmath44 .
however the @xmath45 and @xmath11 quarks must feel some additional strong interaction not shared by the light fermions or technifermions , which can generate @xmath46 as sketched in figure [ figyy ] .
we will revisit these ideas later . while the contributions to @xmath35 just discussed are physically distinct from generation of @xmath41 , the very etc boson responsible for @xmath41 makes potentially large contributions to @xmath48 .
consider the simplest etc models , those in which the etc and weak gauge groups commute and the etc bosons carry no weak charge .
the etc boson responsible for generating the top quark mass couples to the current @xmath49 where @xmath50 is an etc clebsch , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 is a technifermion doublet .
the top quark mass comes from and is of order @xmath53 .
this implies @xcite that the size of the typical vertex correction arising from exchange of this etc boson is proportional to the top mass : @xmath54 . in particular ,
this etc boson causes a radiative correction to the @xmath47 vertex .1 cm @xmath55
we next consider whether the top quark s large mass implies that the @xmath45 quark has unique new interactions .
such scenarios provide alternative mechanisms of electroweak and flavor symmetry breaking and are experimentally testable .
to start , we return to extended technicolor .
our discussion of @xmath48 did not rule out the possibility of `` non - commuting '' models in which @xmath56 is embedded in @xmath57 so that the etc bosons carry weak charge .
to build such a model , one must balance the requirements of providing a range of quark masses against the need to ensure that the weak interactions are universal at low energies .
as discussed in @xcite , this leads to separate weak interactions for the 3rd generation fermions ( @xmath58 ) and the light fermions ( @xmath59 ) and the symmetry - breaking pattern @xmath60 the result is a model where the top quark has non - standard weak interactions .
our first concern is the value of @xmath48 this model predicts .
the etc boson .1 cm @xmath61 not make @xmath48 compatible with experiment .
but in addition , mixing of the @xmath62 .1 cm @xmath63 non - standard top quark weak interactions may be detectable in single top - quark production at tev33 @xcite .
the ratio of cross - sections @xmath64 can be measured ( and calculated ) to an accuracy @xcite of at least @xmath65 .
a non - commuting etc model might alter @xmath66 in several ways .
mixing of the two @xmath67 bosons alters the light @xmath67
s couplings to the final state fermions .
exchange of both heavy and light @xmath67 bosons contributes to the cross - sections .
but exchange of the etc boson that generates @xmath41 does * not * modify the @xmath68 vertex , because the boson does not couple to all of the required fermions : ( @xmath69 ) . in the case of @xmath48 ,
the vertex and boson mixing effects canceled , leaving @xmath48 at the standard model value ; here the boson mixing effects are not canceled and can yield a visible * increase * in @xmath66 ( see figure [ figxx ] ) . to build a dynamical symmetry breaking model that provides both electroweak symmetry breaking and a large @xmath41 ,
it has been suggested @xcite that all or some of electroweak symmetry breaking could be caused by a top quark condensate ( @xmath70 ) .
one way to implement this is to start with a spontaneously broken strong gauge interaction that distinguishes top from the other quarks .
suppose the model includes an @xmath71 for the @xmath45 ( and @xmath11 ) and an @xmath72 for the other quarks which break to their diagonal subgroup ( identified with @xmath73 at a scale @xmath29 .
at energies below @xmath29 , exchange of the heavy gauge bosons yields a new four - fermion interaction can cause top quark condensation . @xmath74
the simplest `` topcolor - assisted technicolor '' model@xcite incorporating top condensates has the following gauge group and symmetry - breaking pattern .
@xmath75 the groups @xmath76 and @xmath56 are ordinary technicolor and weak interactions ; the strong and hypercharge groups labeled `` h '' couple to 3rd - generation fermions and have stronger couplings than the `` l '' groups coupling to light fermions the separate @xmath77 groups ensure that the bottom quark will not condense when the top quark does .
below the scale @xmath29 , the lagrangian includes effective interactions for @xmath45 and @xmath11 : @xmath78 ^ 2 -{{4\pi \kappa_1}\over{m^2 } } \left[{1\over3}\overline{\psi_l}\gamma_\mu \psi_l + { 4\over3}\overline{t_r}\gamma_\mu t_r -{2\over3}\overline{b_r}\gamma_\mu b_r \right]^2\ ] ] so long as the following relationship is satisfied ( where the critical value is @xmath79 in the njl approximation @xcite ) @xmath80 only the top quark will condense and become very massive@xcite .
topcolor - assisted technicolor models have several appealing features@xcite@xcite .
technicolor causes most of the electroweak symmetry breaking , with the top condensate contributing a decay constant @xmath81 gev ; this prevents @xmath35 from being too large , as mentioned earlier .
so long as the @xmath82 charges of the technifermions are isospin - symmetric , they cause no additional large contributions to @xmath35 .
etc dynamics at a scale @xmath83tev generates the light fermion masses and contributes about a gev to the heavy fermions masses ; this does not generate large corrections to @xmath48 .
the top condensate can , then , provide the bulk of the top quark mass .
precision electroweak data constrain the mass of the extra @xmath62 boson in these models to weigh at least 1 - 2 tev @xcite . finally , we return to supersymmetric models .
consider the mass matrix for the supersymmetric partners of the top quark : _ t ^2 = the presence of @xmath41 in the off - diagonal entries shows that a large top quark mass can drive one of the top squarks to be quite light . if the top squark is light enough ( which experiment allows @xcite ) the decay @xmath84 becomes possible ; that is , the top quark may be the only quark able to decay to its own superpartner .
this idea can be tested in top quark production experiments .
the simplest test is to see whether the measured top mass and cross - section match , since the latter depends on how the top is assumed to decay .
cdf and do data indicate that assuming the top decays only through the standard channel @xmath85 gives a good fit to the data @xcite . if additional decay channels for the top existed , the production cross - section measured in the @xmath86 final states would be lower than the standard model prediction .
however , this effect could be balanced @xcite in supersymmetric models either by production of states that decay to top quarks @xmath87 or by production of states whose decays mimic those of top quarks @xmath88 .
checking these possibilities would require seeking , specific signatures of the presence of supersymmetric particles ; for instance , while qcd produces mainly top anti - top pairs , gluino pair production with subsequent decay to top quarks and squarks also produces top / top and anti - top / anti - top pairs in the ratio [ @xmath89 .
the top quark s large mass singles it out in several ways
. it may play a special role in electroweak symmetry breaking ( through its effects on rg running in supersymmetric models or through formation of top quark condensates ) .
it has potentially large effects on precision electroweak observables like @xmath35 or @xmath48 . in some cases
it has a strong influence on the masses of other particles such as higgs bosons or superpartners .
finally , the top quark may be subject to non - standard interactions that distinguish it from the up and charm quarks . as a result
, the top quark has already made a difference in our attempts to understand electroweak and flavor physics .
is the top quark actually different in any of the ways outlined here ?
time and experiment will tell ! a recent review is s. dawson , hep - ph/9602229 .
g. anderson , d. castano , and a. riotto , _
phys.rev . _ * d55 * , 2950 ( 1997 ) ; h. murayama and m. peskin , _ ann
nucl . part .
a recent review is r.s .
chivukula , hep - ph/9701322 .
recent reviews of top quark properties and prospects include r. frey et al . , hep - ph/9704243 ; s. frixione et .
al , hep - ph/9702287 .
h. baer et al . _
* d54 * , 5866 ( 1996 ) and * d53 * , 6241 ( 1996 ) and * d52 * , 2746 ( 1995 ) ; m. machacek and m. vaughn , _ nucl .
phys . _ * b222 * , 83 ( 1983 ) ; c. ford et al . , _ nucl
. phys . _ * b395 * , 17 ( 1995 ) ; m. dine , a. nelson , and y. shirman , _ phys . rev . _ * d51 * , 1362 ( 1995 ) ; m. dine .
et al . , _ phys .
rev . _ * d53 * , 2658 ( 1996 ) ; j. amundson et al .
, hep - ph/9609374 . l. ibanez , _ nucl . phys . _ * 218*,514 ( 1983 ) ; _ phys . lett . _ * b110 * , 215 ( 1982 ) ; j. ellis , d. nanopoulos , and k. tamvakis , _ phys .
lett _ * b121 * , 123 ( 1983 ) ; l. alvarez - gaume , j. polchinski , and m. wise , _ nucl .
b221 _ , 495 ( 1983 ) ; b. ananthanarayan , g. lazarides , and q. shafi , _ nucl . phys . _ * d44 * , 1613 ( 1991 ) . j. ellis , g. ridolfi and f. zwirner , _ phys .
lett . _ * b257 * , 83 ( 1991 ) ; h.e . haber and r. hempfling , _ phys . rev .
lett . _ * 66 * , 1815 ( 1991 ) .
l.j . hall and l. randall , _ nucl .
phys . _ * b352 * , 289 ( 1991 ) ; l. randall and n. rius , _ phys . lett . _ * b286 * , 299 ( 1992 ) ; n. rius and e.h .
simmons , _ nucl .
* b416 * , 722 ( 1994 ) ; e.h .
simmons and y. su , _ phys .
rev . _ * d54 * , 3580 ( 1996 ) .
j.l . feng , n. polonsky , and s. thomas , _ phys.lett . _
* b370 * , 95 ( 1996 ) .
t. appelquist et al . , _ phys .
lett _ * 53 * , 1523 ( 1984 ) and _ phys .
rev . _ * d31 * , 1676 ( 1985 ) .
chivukula , s.b .
selipsky and e.h .
simmons , _ phys
* 69 * , 575 ( 1992 ) .
lep electroweak working group and sld heavy flavor group ( d. abbaneo et al . ) , `` a combination of preliminary electroweak constraints on the standard model , '' cern - ppe-96 - 183 , dec 1996 . r.s .
chivukula , e.h .
simmons , and j. terning , _ phys .
* b331 * , 383 ( 1994 ) ; ibid .
_ phys . rev . _ * d53 * , 5258 ( 1996 ) .
t. stelzer and s. willenbrock , _ phys .
* b357 * , 125 ( 1995 ) ; e.h .
simmons , _ phys .
* d55 * , 5494 ( 1997 ) .
heinson , hep - ex/9605010 ; a.p .
heinson , a.s .
belyaev and e.e .
boos , hep - ph/9612424 ; m.c .
smith and s. willenbrock , _ phys .
rev . _ * d54 * , 6696 ( 1996 ) .
miransky , m. tanabashi and k. yamawaki , _ phys .
lett . _ * b221 * , 177 ( 1989 ) and _ mod .
lett . _ * a4 * , 1043 ( 1989 ) ; y. nambu , efi-89 - 08 ( 1989 ) unpublished ; w.j .
marciano , _ phys .
lett . _ * 62 * , 2793 ( 1989 ) ; w.a .
bardeen , c.t . hill and m. lindner , _ phys .
_ * d41 * , 1647 ( 1990 ) ; c.t .
hill , _ phys .
lett . _ * b266 * , 419 ( 1991 ) .
hill , _ phys .
_ * b345 * , 483 ( 1995 ) .
y. nambu and g. jona - lasinio , _ phys .
rev . _ * 122 * , 345 ( 1961 ) .
k. lane and e. eichten , _ phys .
lett . _ * b352 * , 382 ( 1995 ) ; r.s .
chivukula , b.a .
dobrescu , and j. terning , _ phys.lett . _ * b353 * , 289 ( 1995 ) ; g. buchalla et al . ,
_ phys.rev .
* d53 * , 5185 ( 1996 ) .
chivukula and j. terning , _ phys.lett . _ * b385 * , 209 ( 1996 ) .
d0 collaboration ( s. abachi et al . ) .
_ phys.rev.lett . _
* 76 * , 2222 ( 1996 ) .
m. paulini ( for the cdf and d0 collaborations ) , hep - ex/9701019 .
g.l . kane and s. mrenna ,
_ phys.rev.lett .
_ * 77 * , 3502 ( 1996 ) . | experiment shows that the top quark is far heavier than the other elementary fermions .
this finding has stimulated research on theories of electroweak and flavor symmetry breaking that include physics beyond the standard model .
efforts to accommodate a heavy top quark within existing frameworks have revealed constraints on model - building .
other investigations have started from the premise that a large top quark mass could signal a qualitative difference between the top quark and other fermions , perhaps in the form of new interactions peculiar to the top quark .
such new dynamics may also help answer existing questions about electroweak and flavor physics .
this talk explores the implications of the heavy top quark in the context of weakly - coupled ( e.g. susy ) and strongly - coupled ( e.g. technicolor ) theories of electroweak symmetry breaking . |
substantial progress achieved during the past decade in studies of active galactic nuclei has brought an increasingly wider recognition of the ubiquity of relativistic outflows ( jets ) in galactic nuclei , turning them into an effective probe of nuclear regions in galaxies @xcite .
emission properties , dynamics , and evolution of an extragalactic jet are intimately connected to the characteristics of the supermassive black hole , accretion disk and broad - line region in the nucleus of the host galaxy .
high - resolution radio observations access directly the regions where the jets are formed @xcite , and trace their evolution and interaction with the nuclear environment ( mundell et al .
these studies , combined with optical and x - ray studies , yield arguably the most detailed picture of the galactic nuclei @xcite . presented below is a brief summary of recent results in this field , outlining the relation between jets , supermassive black holes and nuclear regions in prominent active galactic nuclei ( agn ) . in this respect , this review is complementary to other recent reviews @xcite focused on formation and propagation of extragalactic relativistic jets .
jets in active galaxies are formed in the immediate vicinity of the central black hole @xcite , and they interact with every major constituent of agn ( see table [ lobanov : tb1 ] .
the jets carry away a fraction of the angular momentum and energy stored in the accretion flow @xcite or corona ( in low luminosity agn ; merloni & fabian 2002 ) and in the rotation of the central black hole @xcite . [
cols=">,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] column designation : @xmath0 dimensionless scale in units of the gravitational radius , @xmath1 ; @xmath2 corresponding linear scale , for a black hole with a mass of @xmath3 ; @xmath4 corresponding largest angular scale at 1gpc distance ; @xmath5 rest frame light crossing time ; @xmath6 rest frame orbital period , for a circular keplerian orbit . adapted from @xcite
the production of highly - relativistic outflows requires a large fraction of the energy to be converted to poynting flux in the very central region @xcite .
the efficiency of this process may depend on the spin of the central black hole @xcite .
the collimation of such a jet requires either a large scale poloidal magnetic field threading the disk @xcite or a slower and more massive mhd outflow launched at larger disk radii by centrifugal forces ( bogovalov & tsinganos 2005 ) . at distances of @xmath7
( @xmath8 is the gravitational radius of a black hole ) , the jets become visible in the radio regime , which makes high - resolution vlbi observations a tool of choice for probing directly the physical conditions in agn on such small scales .
recent studies indicate that at distances of @xmath9@xmath10 ( @xmath11pc ) the jets are likely to be dominated by pure electromagnetic processes such as poynting flux @xcite or have both mhd and electrodynamic components @xcite .
the flowing plasma is likely to be dominated by electron - positron pairs @xcite although a dynamically significant proton component can not be completely ruled out at the moment @xcite .
how far the magnetic field dominated region extends in extragalactic jets is still a matter of debate .
there are indications that this region does not extend beyond several parsecs .
parsec - scale flows show clear evidence for the presence of rapidly dissipating relativistic shocks ( e.g. lobanov & zensus 1999 ) preceeding the development of kelvin - helmholtz instability @xcite dominating the flow dynamics on kiloparsec scales @xcite .
_ ultracompact _ jets observed down to sub - parsec scales typically show strongly variable but weakly polarized emission ( possibly due to limited resolution of the observations ) .
compelling evidence exists for acceleration @xcite and collimation @xcite of the flows on these scales , which is most likely driven by the magnetic field @xcite .
the ultracompact outflows are probably dominated by electromagnetic processes @xcite , and they become visible in the radio regime ( identified as compact `` cores '' of jets ) at the point where the jet becomes optically thin for radio emission @xcite . at this point , the jets do not appear to have strong shocks @xcite and their basic properties are successfully described by quasi - stationary flows @xcite .
the evolution and variability of the `` core '' can be explained by smooth changes in particle density of the flowing plasma , associated with the nuclear flares in the central engine ( fig .
[ lobanov : fg01 ] .
intrinsic brightness temperatures of the ultracompact jets are estimated to be ( 1@xmath12k @xcite , implying that the energy losses are dominated by the inverse - compton process .
quasi - periodic variability of the radio emission from the ultracompact jets is most likely related to instabilities and non - stationary processes in the accretion disks around central black holes in agn ( igumenschev & abramovicz 1999 ; lobanov & roland 2005 ) .
alternative explanations involve binary black hole systems in which flares are caused by passages of the secondary through the accretion disk around the primary @xcite .
these models however require very tight binary systems , with orbits of the secondary lying well within @xmath9 schwarzschild radii of the primary ( between 20 and 100 schwarzschild radii , in the celebrated case of oj287 ; lehto & valtonen 1996 ) , which poses inevitable problems for maintaining an accretion disk around the primary ( for massive secondaries ; lobanov 2006 ) or rapid alignment of the secondary with the plane of the accretion disk ( for small secondaries ; ivanov et al .
discrepancy between the predicted and actual epoch of the latest outburst in oj287 @xcite indicates further that the observed behavior is not easy to be reproduced by a binary black hole scenario and it is indeed more likely to result from a quasi - periodic process in the disk , similarly to the flaring activity observed in 3c345 @xcite . in 3c309.1 at different frequencies @xcite .
solid line shows changes of @xmath13 due to pressure gradients in the blr clouds supported by thermal pressure and maintaining a mass distribution with spherically symmetrical gravitational potential .
the cloud region extends up to 400@xmath14 ( @xmath14 refers to the distance at which the jet becomes supersonic ) .
the equipartition regime is approached at the outer boundary of the cloud region , with @xmath15 .
significant deviations from the equipartition are seen on smaller scales , resulting in stronger self - absorption in the inner parts of the jet .
, scaledwidth=48.0% ]
a number of recent studies have used the ultracompact jets as probes of physical conditions in the central regions of agn .
these studies have focused on basic characteristics of relativistic flows and atomic , physical properties of the molecular material in circumnuclear regions of agn , and connection between relativistic outflows and accretion disks and broad - line emitting regions .
synchrotron self - absorption and external absorption in the ultracompact jets ( vlbi `` cores '' ) can be used effectively for determining the properties of the flow itself and its environment @xcite . absolute position of the core , @xmath16 , varies with the observing frequency , @xmath17 , so that @xmath18 , @xcite . if the core is self - absorbed and in equipartition , the power index @xmath19 @xcite .
changes of the core position measured between three or more frequencies can be used for determining the value of @xmath13 and estimating the strength of the magnetic field , @xmath20 , in the nuclear region and the offset , @xmath21 , of the observed core positions from the true base of the jet ( see fig .
[ lobanov : fg02 ] ) .
the combination of @xmath20 and @xmath21 gives an estimate for the mass of the central black hole @xmath22 .
core shift measurements provide estimates of the total ( kinetic + magnetic field ) power , the synchrotron luminosity , and the maximum brightness temperature , @xmath23 in the jets can be made @xcite .
the ratio of particle energy to magnetic field energy can also be estimated , from the derived @xmath23 .
this enables testing the original knigl model @xcite and several of its later modifications ( e.g. , hutter & mufson 1986 ; bloom & marscher 1996 ) .
the known distance from the nucleus to the jet origin will also enable constraining the self - similar jet model @xcite and the particle - cascade model @xcite .
recent studies of free - free absorption in agn indicate the presence of dense , ionized circumnuclear material with @xmath24k distributed within a fraction of a parsec of the central nucleus @xcite .
properties of the circumnuclear material can also be studied using the variability of the power index @xmath13 with frequency .
this variability results from pressure and density gradients or absorption in the surrounding medium most likely associated with the broad - line region ( blr ) .
changes of @xmath13 with frequency , if measured with required precision , can be used to estimate the size , particle density and temperature of the absorbing material surrounding the jets ( see figure [ lobanov : fg03 ] ) .
estimates of the black hole mass and size of the blr obtained from the core shift measurements can be compared with the respective estimates obtained from the reverberation mapping and applications of the @xmath25@xmath26 relation .
opacity and absorption in the nuclear regions of agn have been probed effectively using the non - thermal continuum emission as a background source .
absorption due to several atomic and molecular species ( most notably due to hi , co , oh , and hco@xmath27 ) has been detected in a number of extragalactic objects .
oh absorption has been used to probe the conditions in warm neutral gas @xcite , and co and hi absorption were used to study the molecular tori @xcite at a linear resolution often smaller than a parsec @xcite .
these observations have revealed the presence of neutral gas in a molecular torus in ngc4151 and in a rotating outflow surrounding the relativistic jet in 1946@xmath28708 @xcite .
connection between accretion disks and relativistic outflows @xcite has been explored , using correlations between variability of x - ray emission produced in the inner regions of accretion disks and ejections of relativistic plasma into the flow @xcite .
the jets can also play a role in the generation of broad emission lines in agn ( fig .
[ lobanov : fg04 ] ) .
the beamed continuum emission from relativistic jet plasma can illuminate atomic material moving in a sub - relativistic outflow from the nucleus , producing broad line emission in a conically shaped region located at a significant distance above the accretion disk @xcite .
magnetically confined outflows can also contain information about the dynamic evolution of the central engine , for instance that of a binary black hole system @xcite .
this approach can be used for explaining , within a single framework , the observed optical variability and kinematics and flux density changes of superluminal features embedded in radio jets .
extragalactic jets are an excellent laboratory for studying physics of relativistic outflows and probing conditions in the central regions of active galaxies .
recent studies of extragalactic jets show that they are formed in the immediate vicinity of central black holes in galaxies and carry away a substantial fraction of the angular momentum and energy stored in the accretion flow and rotation of the black hole . the jets are most likely collimated and accelerated by electromagnetic fields .
convincing observational evidence exists connecting ejections of material into the flow with instabilities in the inner accretion disks . in radio - loud objects ,
continuum emission from the jets may also drive broad emission lines generated in sub - relativistic outflows surrounding the jets .
magnetically confined outflows may preserve information about the dynamics state of the central region , allowing detailed investigations of jet precession and binary black hole evolution to be made .
this makes studies of extragalactic jets a powerful tool for addressing the general questions of physics and evolution of nuclear activity in galaxies .
arshakian , a.p .
lobanov , v.h .
chavushyan , et al . : in _ relativistic astrophysics and cosmology _ , eso astrophysical symposia , eds .
b. aschenbach , v. burwitz , g. hasinger , b. leibundgut ( springer : heidelberg 2006 ) ` astro - ph/0602016 ` u. bach , m. kadler , t.p .
krichbaum , et al . : in _ future directions in high resolution astronomy : the 10th anniversary of the vlba _ ,
asp conference proceedings , vol .
340 , ed . by j. romney , m. reed ( asp , san fransisco 2005 ) pp .
astro - ph/0309403 ` a.p .
lobanov , j.a .
zensus : in _ exploring the cosmic frontier : astrophysical instruments for the 21@xmath29 century _ , eso astrophysical symp .
series , ed . by a.p .
lobanov , j.a .
zensus , c. cesarsky , p.j .
diamond ( springer , heidelberg 2006 ) pp .
` astro - ph/0606143 ` | compact relativistic jets in active galactic nuclei offer an effective tool for investigating the physics of nuclear regions in galaxies .
the emission properties , dynamics , and evolution of jets in agn are closely connected to the characteristics of the central supermassive black hole , accretion disk and broad - line region in active galaxies .
recent results from studies of the nuclear regions in several active galaxies with prominent outflows are reviewed in this contribution . |
multi - particle and multi - jet final states are of great importance at the tevatron and at the future lhc or @xmath3 linear collider .
they serve both as signals and as important backgrounds to many new and already discovered physics channels . as an example
the production and decay of top quarks , higgs boson(s ) or susy particles can be mentioned .
a typical background is the production of weak vector bosons in association with jets . among others
the proper evaluation of the eight jet qcd background will be needed . to describe the production process of a number of particles the corresponding amplitudes have to be constructed .
this usually results in a very large number of terms , such that their automated construction and evaluation becomes the only solution .
apart from handling the number of amplitudes , which grows factorially with the number of particles , the integration over the multidimensional phase space of the final state particles represents a formidable task . in the past years various solutions to deal with these problems , implemented as different codes , have been presented .
either they are based on traditional methods of constructing feynman diagrams or alternative methods with recursive equations are implemented @xcite .
the new formalism based on the dyson - schwinger equations recursively defines one - particle off - shell green function .
it does not involve any calculation of individual diagrams but various off - shell subamplitudes are regroupped in such a way that as little of the computation as possible is repeated . on the contrary , in the traditional approach ,
the same parts of different feynman diagrams are recalculated all over again , see fig.[diagram ] , increasing the number of steps that should be done in order to get the full amplitude .
the recursive approach significantly decreases the factorial growth of the number of terms to be calculated with the number of particles down to @xmath4 or @xmath5 .
, each four - boson vertex must be replaced with a three - boson vertex by introducing an auxiliary field represented by the antisymmetric tensor @xmath6 , see @xcite for details . ] some examples of automatic parton level generators for any processes in the standard model are @xcite , madgraph / madevent@xcite , amegic++ @xcite and the helac / phegas package @xcite .
codes designed for specific processes are @xcite as well as alpgen @xcite . very recently also on shell recursive equations have been proposed @xcite .
however , event generators based on this new method are not publicly available yet . in this article the algorithm based on dyson - schwinger recursive equations is briefly reviewed .
it has been implemented as a new version of the multipurpose monte carlo generator helac in order to efficiently obtain cross sections for arbitrary multi - particle and multi - jet processes in the standard model .
dyson - schwinger equations give recursively the @xmath7point green s functions in terms of the @xmath8 , @xmath9,@xmath10 , @xmath11point functions .
these equations hold all the information for the fields and their interactions for any number of external legs and to all orders in perturbation theory .
the recursive content of the dyson - schwinger equations for qcd has already been introduced in ref.@xcite and reviewed recently in ref.@xcite . to include the electroweak sector , new vertices for leptons , the vector gauge bosons as well as for the scalar higgs boson
must be included .
additionally , the recursive equation for ( anti)quarks should be rewritten to express their interaction with the electroweak gauge bosons . in order to better illustrate this idea let us present as an example the recursive equations for the higgs boson interaction with massive particles only .
let @xmath12 represent the external momenta involved in the scattering processs taken to be incoming .
for a vector field we define a four vector @xmath13 , which describes any sub - amplitudes from which a vector boson @xmath14 with momentum @xmath15 can be constructed .
the momentum @xmath15 is given as a sum of external particles momenta .
accordingly we define a four - dimensional spinor @xmath16 , which describes any sub - amplitude from which a fermion with momentum p can be constructed and by @xmath17 a four - dimensional antispinor .
additionaly we have to introduces a scalar @xmath18 for a higgs boson .
the content of dyson - schwinger equations in this case can be understood diagrammatically as in fig.[higgs ] .
the subamplitude with an off - shell higgs boson momentum @xmath15 has contributions from three - bosons and four - bosons vertices plus the fermion antifermion vertex .
the black blobs denote subamplitudes with the same structure .
the following general recursive equations can be written down for a higgs boson with the momentum @xmath15 : @xmath19 where the higgs boson propagator is given by @xmath20 and @xmath21 is a sign function , which takes into account the sign change when two identical fermions are interchanged .
the scattering amplitude can be calculated by any of the following relations , @xmath22 where @xmath23 so that @xmath24 . the functions with hat are given by the previous expressions except for the propagator term which is removed by the amputation procedure .
this is because the outgoing momentum @xmath25 must be on shell .
the initial conditions are given by @xmath26 where the explicit form of @xmath27 are given in the ref.@xcite . in order to actually solve these recursive equations
it is convenient to use a binary representation of the momenta involved @xcite . for a process with @xmath1 external particles , to the momentum @xmath28 defined as @xmath29
a binary vector @xmath30 can be assigned , where its components take the values @xmath31 or @xmath32 , in such a way that @xmath33 moreover this binary vector can be uniquely represented by the integer @xmath34 where @xmath35 therefore all subamplitudes can be labeled accordingly , @xmath36 @xmath37 @xmath38 @xmath39 a very convenient ordering of integers in binary representation relies on the notion of level @xmath40 , defined simply as @xmath41 as it is easily seen all external momenta are of level @xmath32 , whereas the total amplitude corresponds to the unique level @xmath1 integer @xmath42 .
this ordering dictates the natural path of the computation ; starting with level-@xmath32 sub - amplitudes , we compute the level-@xmath43 ones using the dyson - schwinger equations and so on up to the level @xmath1 which is the full amplitude .
contrary to original helac @xcite , the computational part consists of only one step , where couplings allowed by the lagrangian defined by fusion rules are only explored .
subsequently , the helicity configurations are set up .
there are two possibilities , either exact summation over all helicity configurations is performed or monte carlo summation is applied .
for example for a massive gauge boson the second option is achieved by introducing the polarization vector @xmath44 where @xmath45 is a random number . by integrating over @xmath46
we can obtain the sum over helicities @xmath47 the same idea can be applied to the helicity of ( anti)fermions .
finally , the color factor is evaluated iteratively .
once again , we have two options .
either we proceed by computing all @xmath48 color configurations , where the gluon is treated as a quark - antiquark pair and @xmath49 is the number of quarks and antiquarks respectively , or monte carlo summation is applied .
only a fraction of all possible @xmath48 color configurations gives rise to a non zero amplitude . in the monte carlo approach for each event we randomly select a non vanishing color assignment for the external particles and evaluate the amplitude
an overall multiplicative coefficient must be introduced to provide the correct normalization .
the weight of the event is simply proportional to the @xmath50 multiplied by the number of non zero color configurations . assuming that , on average , all color configurations contribute the same amount to the cross section this approach is numerically more efficient than summing each event over all colors , see ref .
@xcite for further details . for the spinor wave functions as well as for the dirac matrices
, we have chosen the 4-dimensional chiral representation which results in particularly simple expressions .
all vertices in the unitary gauge have been included .
both the fixed width scheme ( fws ) and the complex mass scheme ( cms ) for unstable particles are implemented .
the computational cost of helac grows like @xmath51 , which essentially counts the steps used to solve the recursive equations . obviously for large @xmath1
there is a tremendous saving of computational time , compared to the @xmath2 growth of the feynman graph approach .
as an example the algorithm has been used to compute total cross sections for the production of weak vector bosons and the higgs boson in association with jets .
the following standard model input parameters have been used @xcite : @xmath52 the electromagnetic coupling is derived from the fermi constant @xmath53 according to @xmath54 all results are obtained with a fixed strong coupling constant @xmath55 calculated at the @xmath56 scale @xmath57 ._results for the total cross section for the associated production of higgs boson ( 130 gev ) with a @xmath58 pair , @xmath59 corresponds to summation over all possible color configurations , while @xmath60 corresponds to monte carlo summation . _ [ cols= " < ,
< , < " , ] the mass of an intermediate and a heavy higgs boson and associated standard model tree level widths are assumed to be : @xmath61 for the massive fermions the following masses have been applied : @xmath62 the mixing of the quark generations is neglected .
the cms energy was chosen @xmath63 @xmath64 .
the following cuts were used to stay away from soft and collinear divergencies in the part of the phase space intergated over : @xmath65 where @xmath66 are the transverse momentum and rapidity of the @xmath67-jet respectively .
additionaly @xmath68 is a radius of the cone of the jet defined as @xmath69 where @xmath70 @xmath71 there are several parameterizations for the parton structure functions , we used cteq6 pdf s parametrization @xcite . for the phase space generation we used two different generators .
the first one is phegas @xcite , which automatically constructs mappings of all possible peaking structures of a given scattering process .
self - adaptive procedures like multi - channel optimization @xcite is additionally applied exhibiting high efficiency .
the second one is a flat phase - space generator rambo @xcite . in the table [ tab1 ] .
results for the total cross section for the associated production of the higgs boson of @xmath72 gev mass , with a @xmath58 pair are presented .
the @xmath73 production channel is one of the most promising reactions to study both the top quark and the higgs boson at the lhc , in the second case especially for the @xmath74 decay channel of the higgs boson @xcite . as we can see from the table [ tab1 ] .
the @xmath75 process dominates due to the enhanced gluon structure function .
the final state of this channel consists of @xmath76 bosons and four @xmath77jet , two from the decay of the top quarks and two from the decay of the higgs boson .
the main background process is @xmath78 with the contributions from all intermediate states . in fig.[inv1 ] we present the invariant mass distribution for the @xmath74 system .
transverse momentum and rapidity distributions of @xmath79-jet for the background process are shown in fig .
[ pt - eta - b ] .
a more powerful channel for higher higgs boson masses is the vector boson fusion @xmath80 with @xmath81 decay . in the table [ tab2 ] .
results for the total cross section for some production processes of a heavy higgs boson of @xmath82 gev mass via vector boson fusion are presented .
the main background processes consist of @xmath83 channels . as an example
the distribution of the invariant mass of the @xmath84 system from the @xmath85 process is presented in fig.[inv1 ] .
transverse momentum and rapidity distributions of @xmath86-jet and @xmath76 are also shown in fig.[pt - eta - d ] and fig.[pt - eta - w ] .
an efficient tool for automatic computation of helicity amplitudes and cross sections for multi - particle final states in the standard model has been presented .
matrix elements and cross sections are calculated iteratively by dyson - schwinger equations .
we are free from the task of computing all feynman diagrams for a given process , which can become impossible for the large number of particles involved
. the computationally expensive procedures of summing over color and helicity configurations have been replaced by monte carlo summation . at this stage ,
the code is able to compute scattering matrix elements and cross sections for hard processes . in the next step
we plan to make calculations of fully hadronic final states in @xmath87 and @xmath88 collisions possible .
in particular , we wish to include the the emission of secondary partons and translate the emerging partons into primordial hadrons by interfacing this package with codes like pythia@xcite or herwig@xcite .
this kind of multipurpose monte carlo generator will be of great interest in the study of the tevatron , lhc or @xmath3 linear collider data .
work supported by the polish state committee for scientific research grants number 1 p03b 009 27 for years 2004 - 2005 ( m.w . ) .
in addition , m.w . acknowledges the maria curie fellowship granted by the the european community in the framework of the human potential programme under contract hpmd - ct-2001 - 00105 ( _ `` multi - particle production and higher order correction '' _ ) . the greece - poland bilateral agreement _ `` advanced computer techniques for theoretical calculations and development of simulation programs for high energy physics experiments '' _ is also acknowledged .
f. a. berends and w. giele , _ nucl .
phys . _ * b294 * ( 1987 ) 700 . f. a. berends and w. t. giele , _ nucl .
* b306 * ( 1988 ) 759 .
m. l. mangano , s. j. parke , and z. xu , _ nucl .
phys . _ * b298 * ( 1988 ) 653 .
m. l. mangano and s. j. parke , _ nucl .
_ * b299 * ( 1988 ) 673 .
f. a. berends , w. t. giele , and h. kuijf , _ nucl .
* b321 * ( 1989 ) 39 .
m. l. mangano , _ nucl .
phys . _ * b309 * ( 1988 ) 461 .
f. a. berends , w. t. giele , and h. kuijf , _ nucl .
* b333 * ( 1990 ) 120 .
f. a. berends , h. kuijf , b. tausk , and w. t. giele , _ nucl .
* b357 * ( 1991 ) 3264 .
m. l. mangano and s. j. parke , _ phys .
* 200 * ( 1991 ) 301367 .
f. caravaglios and m. moretti , _ phys .
_ * b358 * ( 1995 ) 332338 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/9507237[hep-ph/9507237 ] .
p. draggiotis , r. h. p. kleiss , and c. g. papadopoulos , _ phys .
lett . _ * b439 * ( 1998 ) 157164 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/9807207[hep-ph/9807207 ] .
f. caravaglios , m. l. mangano , m. moretti , and r. pittau , _ nucl .
* b539 * ( 1999 ) 215232 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/9807570[hep-ph/9807570 ] .
d. draggiotis , r. h. p. kleiss , and c. g. papadopoulos , _ eur .
phys . j. _
* c24 * ( 2002 ) 447458 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0202201[hep-ph/0202201 ] .
e. e. boos , m. n. dubinin , v. a. ilyin , a. e. pukhov , and v. i. savrin , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/9503280[hep-ph/9503280 ] .
a. pukhov _ et al . _ , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/9908288[hep-ph/9908288 ]
collaboration , e. boos _ et al .
_ , _ nucl .
_ * a534 * ( 2004 ) 250259 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0403113[hep-ph/0403113 ] . t. stelzer and w. f. long , _
* 81 * ( 1994 ) 357371 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/9401258[hep-ph/9401258 ] .
f. maltoni and t. stelzer , _ jhep _ * 02 * ( 2003 ) 027 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0208156[hep-ph/0208156 ] .
f. krauss , r. kuhn , and g. soff , _ jhep _ * 02 * ( 2002 ) 044 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0109036[hep-ph/0109036 ] .
a. kanaki and c. g. papadopoulos , _ comput .
phys . commun .
_ * 132 * ( 2000 ) 306315 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0002082[hep-ph/0002082 ] .
a. kanaki and c. g. papadopoulos , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0012004[hep-ph/0012004 ] .
t. kaneko and h. tanaka , talk presented at the 2nd jlc workshop , national lab . for high energy physics , tsukuba , japan ,
nov 6 - 8 , 1990 .
m. l. mangano , m. moretti , f. piccinini , r. pittau , and a. d. polosa , _ jhep _ * 07 * ( 2003 ) 001 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0206293[hep-ph/0206293 ] .
r. britto , f. cachazo , and b. feng , _ nucl .
* b715 * ( 2005 ) 499522 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0412308[hep-th/0412308 ] .
r. britto , f. cachazo , b. feng , and e. witten , _ phys . rev .
_ * 94 * ( 2005 ) 181602 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0501052[hep-th/0501052 ] . c. g. papadopoulos and m. worek , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0508291[hep-ph/0508291 ] . c. g. papadopoulos and m. worek , _
`` color decomposition of qcd amplitudes '' _ , in preparation .
collaboration , s. eidelman _ et al .
_ , _ phys .
* b592 * ( 2004 ) 1 .
j. pumplin _ et al .
_ , _ jhep _ * 07 * ( 2002 ) 012 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0201195[hep-ph/0201195 ] .
d. stump _ et al .
_ , _ jhep _ * 10 * ( 2003 ) 046 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0303013[hep-ph/0303013 ] . c. g. papadopoulos , _ comput
* 137 * ( 2001 ) 247254 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0007335[hep-ph/0007335 ] .
r. kleiss and r. pittau , _ comput .
* 83 * ( 1994 ) 141146 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/9405257[hep-ph/9405257 ] .
r. kleiss , w. j. stirling , and s. d. ellis , _ comput .
_ * 40 * ( 1986 ) 359 .
m. beneke _ et al . _ , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0003033[hep-ph/0003033 ]
a. djouadi , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0503172[hep-ph/0503172 ] .
t. sjostrand _ et al .
_ , _ comput .
* 135 * ( 2001 ) 238259 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0010017[hep-ph/0010017 ] .
g. corcella _ et al .
_ , _ jhep _ * 01 * ( 2001 ) 010 , http://www.arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0011363[hep-ph/0011363 ] . | a method to efficiently compute , in a automatic way , helicity amplitudes for arbitrary scattering processes at leading order in the standard model is presented .
the scattering amplitude is evaluated recursively through a set of dyson - schwinger equations .
the computational cost of this algorithm grows asymptotically as @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is the number of particles involved in the process , compared to @xmath2 in the traditional feynman graphs approach .
unitary gauge is used and mass effects are available as well .
additionally , the color and helicity structures are appropriately transformed so the usual summation is replaced by monte carlo techniques .
some results related to the production of vector bosons and the higgs boson in association with jets are also presented . |
the meson - cloud model plays an important role in dealing with non - perturbative quantum chromodynamics effects in the nucleon .
it has been used by several groups to interpret momentum distributions of sea quarks in the nucleon @xcite , measured in deep inelastic scattering .
the standard approach is based upon the sullivan process @xcite , in which the only essential parameter is the cut - off in the pion - nucleon - nucleon vertex .
originally the emphasis was mainly on the description of the isoscalar @xmath0 distributions .
more recently , since the observed violation of the gottfried sum rule , showing an excess of @xmath1 over @xmath2 in proton , the interest focussed on the properties of @xmath3 in the nucleon , whose @xmath4 dependence was measured recently @xcite .
the asymmetry in antiquark distributions has been interpreted mostly in terms of the pion - cloud model ( a review is given in ref .
@xcite , see also @xcite ) , and also in a soliton model in the large-@xmath5 limit @xcite . since pion properties are strongly affected by the nuclear medium , the pion cloud plays also an important role in modelling nuclear effects on deep inelastic processes .
it was used in the past in connection with the emc effect @xcite , leading to a few percent enhancement of the structure - functions ratio around @xmath6 .
similarly , most approaches predicted a nuclear enhancement of the pion field and hence the @xmath7 and @xmath8 distributions , leading to a noticeable increase in the predicted drell - yan ( dy ) cross - section ratio .
on the other hand experimentally the dy scattering on nuclear targets @xcite did not show much evidence for enhancement over nucleon targets .
several papers have dealt with this discrepancy , pointing out different mechanisms leading to reconciliation with the measurements @xcite . for the purpose of presenting our results
we find it convenient to separate them into two aspects .
the calculation of experimentally measured proton - nucleus to proton - deuteron dy cross - section ratio is our first aim .
the isospin asymmetric medium affects the various isospin states of the nucleon s pion cloud differently , leading to an excess of up antiquarks over down ones ( even if the distributions in free proton are identical ) for nuclei with more neutrons than protons .
since the charges of up and down quarks are different , the effect also shows up in the nuclear dy scattering cross section .
in addition to presenting the dy ratio , one can also investigate possible nuclear effects on the difference @xmath3 for a nucleon in the medium .
it has been pointed out by kumano that in a neutron - excess nucleus there could be medium effects contributing to this difference , coming from flavor - asymmetric parton recombination in the small bjorken-@xmath4 region @xcite .
the mechanism he considered contributes only at relatively small @xmath4 values ( @xmath9 ) and the effect is also rather small ( 210% of the observed asymmetric sea in the nucleon ) . in the present calculation
we extend the effective field theory approach to compute pion properties in isospin - symmetric nuclear medium @xcite to the case of arbitrary proton and neutron densities
. then we use the pion - cloud model @xcite to compute the medium - modified quark and antiquark distributions and the proton - nucleus dy cross section .
we assume that the medium effects solely originate from a modification of the pion cloud . and large @xmath10 , but this contribution is approximately flavor symmetric and
thus should not modify our results significantly . ]
the nucleons are treated in mean field approximation , while the delta - isobar and the pion are dressed self - consistently .
the effects of short - range baryon repulsion are included through migdal s @xmath11 parameters ( @xmath12 ) .
sensitivity of the pion distribution to the delta - hole self - energy was already recognized in ref .
@xcite , thus we carried out the computation with the self - consistently determined in - medium delta - isobar spectral function @xcite .
we compute the pion light - cone momentum distributions separately for the three charge states as a function of the asymmetry parameter @xmath13 .
for @xmath14 the @xmath15 distribution exceeds that of @xmath16 , which in turn is larger than the @xmath17 distribution , as expected on the basis of particle - hole self - energy relationships .
the drell - yan cross section for the process @xmath18 is given by ( suppressing the @xmath10 dependence ) @xmath19 dx_1dx_2 , \ ] ] where the sum is over all flavors , and @xmath20 are the longitudinal momentum fractions carried by quark of the beam and target nucleons , respectively . by a suitable selection of kinematics
the values of @xmath21 can be deduced from experiment @xcite .
if we consider the region @xmath22 when the antiquarks in the projectile play a negligible role , the ratio of the proton - nucleus to proton - deuteron dy cross - sections takes on the form @xmath23 where @xmath24 is close to unity . here
@xmath25 and @xmath26 are antiquark distributions in the free proton , while @xmath27 and @xmath28 are the antiquark distributions per nucleon in the nucleus , differing from the free - nucleon distributions by the medium modified pion - cloud contribution .
denoting the latter by @xmath29 and @xmath30 the dy ratio becomes @xmath31 \right\}. \label{dyratio2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we see from the above expression that apart from nuclear effects , leading to nonzero @xmath32 and @xmath33 , for @xmath34 there is a nucleonic one @xcite , stemming from the nonzero value of the antiquark - distribution difference @xmath35 in the free proton .
this underlines the necessity to use parton distributions in accordance with latest @xmath36 observations ( for discussion on this point see section iv ) . for the relatively small asymmetries of interest for stable nuclei
the ratio @xmath37 appearing in the above expression is practically independent of @xmath38 , leading to a linear dependence of @xmath39 on it . for the change of antiquark distributions due to pion - cloud modification
we use the convolution formula @xcite @xmath40 where @xmath41 , given by @xmath42 represents the change of the pion light - cone - momentum distribution per nucleon in the medium . @xmath43 ( @xmath44 ) and @xmath45 ( @xmath46 ) denote the distribution of @xmath47 per neutron ( proton ) in medium and in free space , respectively . they are discussed in the next section .
we consider a model consisting of pions , nucleons and delta - isobars in an infinite , spatially uniform system at zero temperature .
the proton and neutron densities are given through their chemical potentials @xmath48 and @xmath49 . the equilibrium conditions for nucleons , delta - isobars and pions imply that the chemical potential for the neutral pion is zero , while those of charged pions are : @xmath50 .
the antiparticles of nucleons and isobars are neglected , but a relativistic kinematics is used .
the nucleons are further treated in the mean - field approximation , with momentum - independent mass ( @xmath51 ) and energy shifts ( @xmath52 ) modelling their binding , i.e. @xmath53 for neutrons and @xmath54 for protons .
the schwinger - dyson equations without vertex corrections are then solved self - consistently for the delta - isobar and pion @xcite .
the pion self - energy consists of the particle - hole and delta - hole contributions , with both imaginary and real parts taken into account , assuring correct analytical properties .
short - range baryon repulsion is taken into account through migdal s @xmath55 parameters .
the sum - rules for spectral functions of pions and deltas are checked and found to be satisfied to 12% .
the pion light - cone momentum distributions are then calculated , using the in - medium pion self - energy .
direct calculation of the diagrams corresponding to the pion emitted by the in - medium nucleon proceeds analogously to ref .
@xcite , but separately for the three charge states of the pion and taking into account different neutron and proton densities ( and thus different @xmath56 effective masses and @xmath52 energy shifts ) .
it is well known that @xmath57 can be expressed compactly in terms of an integral over the spin - isospin response function or imaginary part of the pion propagator .
it is also possible to compute it directly from summing contributing diagrams @xcite , which represent emission of a dressed pion by a nucleon .
the latter procedure we prefer for numerical reasons , since it needs computation of the pion self - energy in smaller energy - momentum region .
the schematic expression for the pion light - cone distribution per nucleon has the form @xmath58 where @xmath59 represents the sum of relevant diagrams , @xmath60 the nucleon density , @xmath61 and @xmath62 ( @xmath63 ) is the momentum of incoming ( outgoing ) nucleon .
the full expression generalizing the case for isospin - symmetric medium from @xcite reads ( for the special case of @xmath17 on proton ) : @xmath64 where @xmath65 is the fermi momentum of the proton , @xmath66 the nucleon s mass , @xmath67 , @xmath68 the @xmath69 coupling and @xmath70 the form factor , while @xmath71 is the angle between @xmath72 and @xmath73 .
@xmath74 is the full pion propagator , corrected for the presence of four - fermion couplings through migdal s @xmath11 parameters , given as @xmath75 in ref .
@xcite , @xmath76 if the argument of the square root is positive , otherwise is zero , and @xmath77 the expression for @xmath15 is obtained by swapping the indices @xmath78 and @xmath79 and for neutral pions the total distribution is a sum of two terms corresponding to emission by proton or neutron .
the difference in distributions for the various charge states of pion basically comes from two factors .
one is the pauli blocking of the outgoing nucleon , which in neutron - rich medium restricts emission of @xmath17 ( from a proton , creating a neutron in the final state ) more than the emission of @xmath15 ( since a proton appears in this case in the final state ) .
the other effect is the dressing of the pion propagator , in which the particle - hole and delta - hole self - energies enter .
since the dominant contribution comes from the particle - hole contribution for @xmath80 ( neutron density larger than the proton one ) the @xmath15 propagator is affected more than the one of the @xmath17 ( more details are given in the next section ) .
while the delta has been shown to play an important role in the asymmetry for free nucleons , the medium effects are negligible @xcite and not included here , which is partially a consequence of the use of a soft pion - nucleon - delta form - factor , as obtained from a fit to pion - nucleon scattering @xcite . since the isobar s contribution for @xmath34 to @xmath81 is of the opposite sign compared to the contribution of eq .
( [ pidis ] ) , as discussed in the next section , at small @xmath4 inclusion of this term might result in a small decrease of the calculated isospin - asymmetry effect .
for numerical calculation we used the proton to neutron ratio of tungsten , for which there are measurements of the dy cross section @xcite .
the asymmetry parameter in this case is @xmath82 and for the fermi momenta of protons and neutrons we chose @xmath83mev and @xmath84mev , corresponding to total nucleon density slightly below the saturation density . to take into account the different binding of protons and neutrons for the energy shifts we take @xmath85mev , @xmath86mev , with the common effective mass @xmath87gev , thus assuring the correct asymmetry energy of 28 mev . for the pion - nucleon - nucleon vertex we use a dipole form - factor with cut - off @xmath88gev .
we checked that varying the cut - off in the range @xmath89 gev does not change appreciably the medium effect on the pion . in fig . 1 we present the pion light - cone - momentum distributions for nucleons in medium and in free space ( upper four curves ) , as well as
the excess pion distributions ( lower three curves ) .
the @xmath17 ( @xmath15 ) distributions are per proton ( neutron ) , while that of @xmath16 is per average nucleon in the medium .
the neutral pions see little difference between an isospin - symmetric and an isospin - asymmetric nuclear medium , as long as the total nucleon density is the same ( actually , the different mean - field shifts for proton and neutron may lead to a very small effect ) .
however , for the case of neutron excess , the @xmath15 distribution per neutron is larger than the @xmath17 distribution per proton .
this comes from a difference in particle - hole self energies , which is mainly responsible for the light - cone - momentum distributions .
it is easy to understand the difference if we look at the imaginary part of the self energy as a function of pion s energy .
if the energy is positive , the pion can excite a neutron from the fermi sea to become a proton ( above the proton fermi sea ) if its charge is positive .
a negative pion can make from a proton in the fermi sea a neutron above the neutron fermi sea .
since there are more neutrons than protons in the fermi sea , the absolute value of the imaginary part of the @xmath17 self energy will be larger than that of @xmath15 .
bearing in mind that in expression ( [ pidis ] ) the pion energy is negative ( for the dominating part of the integraton region ) and using the relation that @xmath90 we arrive at the inequality @xmath91 , in accordance with the numerical computation .
we mention that for the delta - hole self - energies the relationship between the @xmath15 and @xmath17 is the opposite to that of particle - hole one , i.e. for positive energy that of @xmath15 is larger ( in absolute value ) than the self - energy of @xmath17 ; a consequence of different isospin factors in the pion - nucleon - delta vertex .
we see that for the studied asymmetry there is a significant difference in the distributions of three charge states .
the distribution in isospin symmetric medium is very close to the @xmath16 distribution .
the valence distribution of negative pions contains up antiquarks and thus in neutron - rich matter they outnumber the down antiquarks present in the positive pions , due to nuclear effects on the pion clouds .
a comparison of this effect to the recently measured @xcite @xmath92 difference for proton is presented in fig .
2 . it shows the quantity @xmath37 compared to the mentioned @xmath93 , to which it is added in the expression ( [ dyratio2 ] ) for the dy ratio @xmath39 .
the quantity @xmath37 does not change appreciably with @xmath38 up to its value of 0.2 , but it is sensitive to the @xmath11 parameters . existing experimental and theoretical information @xcite suggests values of 0.55 0.7 for @xmath94 and 0.3 0.4 for @xmath95 and @xmath96 .
these values give results consistent with observed dy scattering for the isospin - symmetric calculation @xcite , and we use these values also in the present case . taking momentum
dependent @xmath11 parameters ( as suggested in ref .
@xcite ) could change the details of our results .
exploration of this and other effects we leave for a future publication . the free nucleon parton distributions are taken from ref .
they fit the @xmath35 and @xmath97 of ref .
@xcite quite well up to @xmath98 .
however , at larger @xmath4 the measured difference @xmath99 and especially the ratio @xmath97 are poorly fitted @xcite . to correct for this discrepancy , which would cause a significant increase in calculated @xmath39
, we impose a constraint @xmath100 for @xmath101 ( by using the arithmetic mean value ) and interpolate linearly between @xmath98 , when the unmodified distributions are used , and the point @xmath102 . in this way
, the employed distributions fit the measurements of ref .
@xcite very well . from fig . 2 we see that the two terms , whose sum appears in the square bracket of eq .
( [ dyratio2 ] ) , are of comparable magnitude , i.e. the nuclear effect of the isovector part of the dy ratio plays as important role as the nucleon antiquark asymmetry . since the squared charge of up antiquarks is four times that of down antiquarks , the former enter in the dy cross section with correspondingly larger weight .
this implies an enhancement of the dy cross - section ratio for neutron - rich medium compared to the isospin symmetric case . in fig . 3 the ratio of cross - sections ( per nucleon )
is shown as a function of @xmath103 , where both in the numerator and denominator integration over @xmath104 is performed for @xmath105 , corresponding to the experimental situation of ref .
the full line ( dash - dot line ) corresponds to @xmath82 and @xmath106 ( @xmath107 ) , dotted line is for @xmath108 , while the dashed line is for asymmetric medium ( @xmath82 ) , but without medium effect on the pion cloud .
measurements from ref .
@xcite for w are shown as points with error bars .
the errors are too large for any definite statement to be made on the isospin - asymmetry effect .
we mention that the difference for larger @xmath103 values between the @xmath108 case of fig . 3 in the present work and fig . 8 of ref .
@xcite is a consequence of the use of a more realistic dipole pion - nucleon - nucleon form - factor in the present calculation , and to a smaller extent due to a different set of parton distributions @xcite .
we remark that the small pion excess probability found in the present work would also lead to a pion contribution to the emc ratio for @xmath109 which is smaller than in some other approaches @xcite . however , this ratio is mostly sensitive to the nucleon self - energy in the medium and the role of pions is difficult to isolate .
we conclude : i ) a simultaneous experiment on a neutron - rich nucleus and an @xmath110 nucleus with a 5% accuracy should in principle be able to isolate the see up - down asymmetry ( term proportional to @xmath38 in eq .
( [ dyratio2 ] ) ) ; ii ) about 50% of the @xmath111 difference in a nucleus comes from nuclear effects .
therefore the assumption that nuclear effects are negligible as in ref .
@xcite can not be justified .
* acknowledgements * we acknowledge useful discussions with s. kumano .
this research was supported in part by an nwo ( netherlands ) fellowship and the hungarian research foundation ( otka ) grant t16594 .
this work is also part of the research program of the `` stichting voor fundamenteel onderzoek der materie '' ( fom ) with financial support from the `` nederlandse organisatie voor wetenschappelijk onderzoek '' ( nwo ) . | using a self - consistent delta - hole model the pion propagation in isospin asymmetric nuclear matter is studied . in neutron - rich matter , corresponding to heavy nuclei , a significant difference in positive and negative pion light - cone distributions is obtained leading to a nuclear enhancement of up antiquark distribution compared to the down antiquark one .
this means that the sea - quark asymmetry in the free nucleon can not be extracted model independently from an experiment on a neutron - rich nucleus . _
pacs : _ 21.65.+f ; 24.85.+p ; 13.40.-f isospin - asymmetric medium ; drell - yan scattering ; antiquark flavour asymmetry . |
when lines coalesce into broad unresolved patterns due to physical broadening mechanisms ( stark effect , auto - ionization , etc . ) , they can be handled by global methods @xcite .
on the other hand , some transition arrays exhibit a small number of lines that must be taken into account individually .
those lines are important for plasma diagnostics , interpretation of spectroscopy experiments and for calculating the rosseland mean , which is very sensitive to the gaps between lines in the spectrum .
the hybrid opacity code sco - rcg @xcite combines statistical methods and fine - structure calculations , assuming local thermodynamic equilibrium . in order to decide whether a detailed treatment of lines is necessary or not and to determine the validity of statistical methods
, the code uses criteria to quantify the porosity ( localized absence of lines ) of transition arrays .
data required for the calculation of lines ( slater , spin - orbit and dipolar integrals ) are provided by sco ( superconfiguration code for opacity ) @xcite , which takes into account plasma screening and density effects on the wave - functions .
then , level energies and lines are calculated by an adapted routine ( rcg ) of cowan s atomic - structure code @xcite performing the diagonalization of the hamiltonian matrix .
transition arrays for which a dla ( detailed line accounting ) treatment is not required or impossible are described statistically , by uta ( unresolved transition array ) , sosa ( spin - orbit split array ) or sta ( super transition array ) formalisms used in sco .
sco - rcg calculations are restricted to a particular type of superconfiguration , in which all supershells are made of individual orbitals up to a limit beyond which all the remaining orbitals are gathered into a large final supershell , consistent with inglis - teller limit @xcite .
the total opacity is the sum of photo - ionization , inverse bremsstrahlung and thomson scattering spectra calculated by sco code and a photo - excitation spectrum arising from contributions of sco and cowan s codes ( see fig .
1 ) in the form @xmath4 where @xmath5 is planck s constant , @xmath6 the avogadro number , @xmath7 the vacuum polarizability , @xmath8 the electron mass , @xmath9 the atomic number and @xmath10 the speed of light . @xmath11 is a probability , @xmath12 an oscillator strength , @xmath13 a profile and the sum @xmath14 runs over lines , utas , sosas or stas of all ion charge states present in the plasma .
special care is taken to calculate the probability of @xmath15 ( which can be either a level @xmath16 , a configuration @xmath17 or a superconfiguration @xmath18 ) because it can be the starting point for different transitions ( dla , uta , sosa , sta ) . in order to ensure the normalization of probabilities ,
we introduce three disjoint ensembles : @xmath19 ( detailed levels @xmath16 ) , @xmath20 ( configurations @xmath17 too complex to be detailed ) and @xmath21 ( superconfigurations @xmath18 that do not reduce to ordinary configurations ) . the total partition function then reads @xmath22 where each term is a trace over quantum states of the form tr@xmath23 $ ] , where @xmath24 is the hamiltonian , @xmath25 is the number operator , @xmath26 the chemical potential and @xmath27 .
the probabilities of the different species of the @xmath28-electron ion are @xmath29 in sco - rcg , configuration mixing is limited to electrostatic interaction between relativistic sub - configurations ( @xmath30 orbitals ) belonging to a non - relativistic configuration ( @xmath31 orbitals ) . in order to complement dla ( detailed line accounting ) efforts ,
the code was recently improved @xcite with the prta ( partially resolved transition array ) model @xcite , which may replace the single feature of a uta by a small - scale detailed transition array that conserves the known transition - array properties ( energy and variance ) and yields improved higher - order moments . in the prta approach , open subshells
are split in two groups .
the main group includes the active electrons and those electrons that couple strongly with the active ones .
the other subshells are relegated to the secondary group .
a small - scale dla calculation is performed for the main group ( assuming therefore that the subshells in the secondary group are closed ) and a statistical approach for the secondary group assigns the missing uta variance to the lines . in the case where the transition @xmath32 is a uta that can be replaced by a prta ( see fig .
2 ) , its contribution to the opacity is modified according to @xmath33 where the sum runs over prta lines @xmath34 between pseudo - levels of the reduced configurations , @xmath35 is the corresponding oscillator strength and @xmath36 is the line profile augmented with the statistical width due to the other ( non included ) spectator subshells .
the probability of the pseudo - level @xmath37 of configuration @xmath38 reads @xmath39 where @xmath40 is the probability of the genuine configuration given in eq .
( [ probs ] ) .
transitions ) measured by winhart et al .
temperature gradients are simulated by an average over four temperatures : 18 , 20 , 22 and 24 ev .
the full statistical sco calculation at @xmath41=20 ev is also represented.,width=377 ] = 192.91 ev and @xmath42=0.578 g.@xmath43 ( boundary of the convective zone of the sun).,width=377 ] = 1 kev and @xmath42=2 .
10@xmath44 g.@xmath43 ( transitions @xmath45).,width=377 ] .values of @xmath46 and @xmath47 of the zeeman components . @xmath48 and @xmath49 . @xmath50 $ ]
is the sign of @xmath51 . [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the sco - rcg code has been successfully compared to experimental spectra .
the comparisons in fig .
[ fig:1 ] shows the relevance of the hybrid model and the limits of a full statistical calculation . among others ,
the code is also used for astrophysical applications @xcite .
figure [ fig:2 ] represents the different contributions to opacity ( dla , statistical and prta ) for an iron plasma in conditions corresponding to the boundary of the convective zone of the sun .
quantifying the impact of a magnetic field on spectral line shapes is important in astrophysics , in inertial confinement fusion or for z - pinch experiments . because the line computation becomes even more tedious in that case , we propose , in order to avoid the diagonalization of the zeeman hamiltonian , to describe zeeman patterns in a statistical way . in the presence of a magnetic field @xmath52 , a level @xmath53 ( energy @xmath54 ) splits into @xmath55 states @xmath56 ( @xmath57 ) of energy @xmath58 ,
@xmath59 being the bohr magneton and @xmath60 the land factor in intermediate coupling ( provided by rcg routine ) .
each line splits in three components associated to selection rule @xmath61=@xmath62 , where @xmath62=0 for a @xmath63 component and @xmath64 for a @xmath65 component .
the intensity of a component can be characterized by the strength - weighted moments of the energy distribution .
the @xmath66 order moment reads @xmath67=3\sum_{m_1,m_2}{\left(\begin{array}{ccc}j_1 & 1 & j_2 \\ -m_1 & -q & m_2 \end{array}\right)}^2\left(e_2-e_1+\mu_bb\left[g_2m_2-g_1m_1\right]\right)^n,\ ] ] which can be evaluated analytically @xcite , using graphical representation of racah algebra or bernoulli polynomials @xcite .
a good representation of the zeeman profile is obtained using , for each component , the fourth - order gram - charlier expansion series : @xmath68,\ ] ] where @xmath69 , @xmath70 is the variance and the reduced centered moments are defined as @xmath71 where @xmath46 ( skewness ) and @xmath47 ( kurtosis ) quantify respectively the asymmetry and the sharpness of the component ( see table [ tab : a ] ) . the total line profile results from the convolution of @xmath72 with the other broadening mechanisms ( see fig .
[ fig:3 ] ) .
the contribution of a magnetic field to an uta can be taken into account roughly by adding a contribution @xmath73 [ @xmath52(mg)]@xmath74
ev@xmath74 to the statistical variance . the approximate method provides quite a good description of the effect of a strong magnetic field on spectral lines .
by combining different degrees of approximation of the atomic structure ( levels , configurations and superconfigurations ) , the sco - rcg code allows one to explore a wide range of applications , such as the calculation of rosseland means , the generation of opacity tables , or the spectroscopic interpretation of high - resolution spectra .
the prta model was recently adapted to the hybrid statistical / detailed approach in order to reduce the statistical part and fasten the calculations .
an approximate approach providing a fast and quite accurate estimate of the effect of an intense magnetic field on opacity was also implemented .
the formalism requires the moments of the zeeman components of a line , which can be obtained analytically in terms of the quantum numbers and land factors .
it was found that the fourth - order a - type gram - charlier expansion series provides better results than the usual development in powers of the magnetic field often used in radiative - transfer models . in the future
, we plan to improve the treatment of stark broadening in order to increase the capability of the code as concerns k - shell spectroscopy . | we present the hybrid opacity code sco - rcg which combines statistical approaches with fine - structure calculations .
radial integrals needed for the computation of detailed transition arrays are calculated by the code sco ( super - configuration code for opacity ) , which calculates atomic structure at finite temperature and density , taking into account plasma effects on the wave - functions .
levels and spectral lines are then computed by an adapted rcg routine of r. d. cowan .
sco - rcg now includes the partially resolved transition array model , which allows one to replace a complex transition array by a small - scale detailed calculation preserving energy and variance of the genuine transition array and yielding improved high - order moments .
an approximate method for studying the impact of strong magnetic field on opacity and emissivity was also recently implemented .
the hybrib detailed / statistical opacity code sco - rcg : new developments and applications jean - christophe pain@xmath0 , franck gilleron@xmath1 , quentin porcherot@xmath2 and thomas blenski@xmath3 @xmath1cea , dam , dif , f-91297 arpajon , france @xmath2dga , 94110 arcueil , france @xmath3cea , dsm , iramis , f-91191 gif - sur - yvette , france |
the emergence of spatio - temporal ordered structures in nonlinear systems is an ideal laboratory for investigating the trend toward complexification observed in nature at the physical , chemical , and biological level @xcite .
it is known that localized , or spatially - bound , order emerges in systems which are out of thermodynamic equilibrium , at the expense of growing overall disorder @xcite .
examples can be found in hydrodynamics , in networks of chemical reactions @xcite , in phase transitions and critical phenomena @xcite , and in living organisms @xcite .
for these localized ordered structures to survive , they must interact with an external environment , which maintains nonequilibrium conditions : in general , an isolated nonlinear system will eventually reach equilibrium , maximizing its entropy to the detriment of localized ordered structures . in other words , if localized ordered structures emerge during the approach to equilibrium of a closed system , they will eventually disappear as energy becomes increasingly equipartitioned amongst the system s many degrees of freedom .
the emergence of localized ordered structures is thus a nonequilibrium phenomenon , usually corresponding to an unequal partitioning of energy : if they are long - lived , they will serve as bottlenecks to equipartition .
[ an exception occurs for 1d field theories with sdw , where configurations such as kink - antikink pairs correspond to the equilibrium . ] following the pioneering work of fermi , pasta , and ulam in the early 1950s @xcite , several recent works have investigated the possibility that discrete kink - like structures may act as bottlenecks for equipartition in chains of nonlinear oscillators @xcite . in field theory and cosmology ,
most of the interest on ordered configurations has focused on topological ( kinks , vortices , monopoles ) @xcite or nontopological ( nontopological solitons , q - balls ) @xcite _ static _ solutions of the equations of motion . those configurations can be boosted towards each other with a certain velocity and made to interact , to model nonlinear composite particle interactions
. a well - known example are 1-dimensional breathers , time - dependent bound states that have been shown to result from interactions of kink - antikink pairs @xcite .
however , this is not surprising : any two or more static solitonic configurations with short - range attractive interactions can be prepared to generate spatially - bound time - dependent structures @xcite .
this is to be contrasted with the spatially - bound , time - dependent structures of interest here , that emerge _ spontaneously _ during the nonlinear evolution of a system .
we have recently found such structures in 2 + 1-dimensional simulations of nonlinear scalar field models @xcite .
such structures were identified with oscillons , long - lived _ time - dependent _ localized field configurations that have been previously found deterministically in a variety of physical systems , ranging from field theory models with amplitude - dependent nonlinearities @xcite , vertically vibrated grains @xcite , and stellar interiors @xcite . in this paper , we will examine the emergence of spatially - bound , time - dependent field configurations during the approach to equilibrium of ( 2 + 1)-dimensional scalar field models with typical double - well interactions .
these interactions are controlled by a tunable external parameter , which can be interpreted as an extra interaction that may be switched on or off at will . in the parlance of ising magnetic systems ,
the external interaction may be a spatially - homogeneous magnetic field , @xmath3 .
we will investigate both the symmetric double - well ( sdw ) extending previous results of ref .
@xcite as well as provide new results for the asymmetric case ( adw ) .
the interest in examining both cases stems from the fact that the ensuing dynamics will be quite different : while for the sdw the degeneracy in free energy density dictates that no critical nucleation is possible , this will not be the case for the adw .
in fact , for the sdw we observe the synchronous emergence of long - lived localized configurations ( oscillons ) , which eventually disappear as the system reaches equipartition @xcite .
we will argue that these configurations act as bottlenecks for equipartition , concentrating the field s energy in a narrow band of long - wavelength modes .
for the adw , and with the system initially quenched to the metastable state , the synchronous emergence of oscillons may trigger the nucleation of a critical droplet of the lower free - energy phase , which grows to complete the phase transformation .
we will show that , for a range of temperatures , the time - scales associated with this process are orders of magnitude faster than the typical statistical homogeneous nucleation , where a system _ adiabatically _ cooled into its metastable phase decays to its lowest free energy phase with typically exponentially - large time scales @xcite .
in fact , the present treatment , with an `` instantaneous '' quench ( faster than other typical time - scales in the system ) , and the arbitrarily slow cooling implicit of homogeneous nucleation calculations , represent the two extreme cases of a whole spectrum of possible cooling rates . since we will argue that the emergence of coherent structures is due to the resonant amplification of parametric excitations of certain field modes , we will refer to this nucleation mechanism as _ resonant nucleation . _ anticipating one of our results , for field models described by amplitude - dependent scalar nonlinearities , resonant nucleation of spatio - temporal order will be relevant whenever the cooling time scale @xmath4 is faster than the equilibration time - scale of the longest wavelength in the system , @xmath5 . [
the superscript `` 0 '' is a reminder that often the longest wavelength is associated with the zero mode of the system , which has the slowest relaxation time - scale .
] we note that we will always work far from the critical point where , of course , @xmath6 . for our recent work on the approach to criticality
please see ref .
@xcite .
the paper is organized as follows . in the next section
we discuss the general properties of the model ( a general ginzburg - landau model ) , the initial conditions , and the numerical implementation of the dynamics . in section 3
we present a mean field ( homogeneous hartree ) approximation adequate to describe the system in the presence of small fluctuations about equilibrium .
the fact that the homogeneous hartree approximation breaks down as nonperturbative excitations become progressively more important will provide us with useful information about the emergence of ordered structures .
in section 4 we argue that the emergence of spatio - temporal order is a consequence of parametric resonance , induced by the nonlinear coupling between the field s zero mode the forcing agent and smaller-@xmath7 modes .
we also provide entropic arguments in support of the statement that the emergence of coherent spatio - temporal structures delays equipartition of the energy and , thus , the approach to equilibrium . in section 5 , we extend our investigation to adws . for
a range of temperatures [ or initial energies , see below ] , we measure the time scales for the decay of the metastable state as a function of barrier height , contrasting them with those computed from homogeneous nucleation theory .
we identify two possible mechanisms for the decay : for small asymmetries , a critical nucleus is produced by the coalescence of two or more oscillons , while for larger asymmetries a single oscillon evolves into a critical nucleus .
we show that , for a range of temperatures associated with the presence of oscillons in the system , the time scale associated with the decay obeys a simple power law , @xmath8^b$ ] , where @xmath2 is the free - energy barrier of a critical fluctuation , and the exponent @xmath1 satisfying @xmath9 .
we conclude in section 6 with a summary of our results and outlook for future work .
we start by introducing the model we will work with and its statistical and numerical implementation .
we consider a ( 2 + 1)-dimensional real scalar field ( or scalar order parameter ) @xmath10 evolving under the influence of an on - site potential @xmath11 . if the system does not interact with an external bath , the continuum hamiltonian is conserved and gives the total energy of the system , for a given field configuration , @xmath12=\int d\,^2x\left[\frac{1}{2}(\partial_{t}\phi)^2+\frac{1}{2}(\nabla\phi)^2+v(\phi)\right ] , \label{h}\ ] ] where @xmath13 is the potential energy density .
the parameters @xmath14,@xmath15 , and @xmath16 are positive definite and temperature independent . before we go any further , a note on our choice of potential .
one could as easily have chosen a typical ginzburg - landau ( gl ) potential , @xmath17 , with @xmath3 an external homogeneous magnetic field .
the gl potential can be transformed into the potential of eq .
[ v ] by a field shift , @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is the solution of the cubic equation @xmath20 , @xmath21 , and @xmath22 .
we chose the potential of eq .
[ v ] for convenience .
our control parameter is @xmath15 .
we note that when @xmath23 the potential is an anharmonic single well . in this case , there are no spinodal instabilities .
( by spinodal instabilities we mean @xmath24 for certain values of @xmath25 , which may result in the unstable growth of modes . ) when @xmath26 ( in scaled units , see below ) the potential can assume a typical double - well shape [ sdw for equality and adw for @xmath27 , and spinodal instabilities are possible .
we will thus refer to the interactions modeled by @xmath15 as destabilizing interactions ( dis ) .
changing @xmath15 from an initial value of zero to a finite positive value can also be thought of as an `` instantaneous '' quench : the system , initially prepared in a single well , is `` tossed '' into a double - well potential within a time - scale much faster than any equilibration time - scale for longer wavelengths in the system , those with @xmath28 , where @xmath7 is the mode s wave number .
we will say more about this later on .
it is helpful to introduce the dimensionless variables @xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath31 , and @xmath32 ( henceforth dropping the primes ) .
when @xmath33 the two minima are degenerate ( sdw ) . if @xmath34 , the @xmath35 symmetry is explicitly broken . we will only be concerned here with the cases modeled by @xmath36 . for @xmath37
the minimum at @xmath38 becomes the local ( or metastable ) minimum ( adw ) and @xmath39 is the global minimum .
a statistical description of the state of the system is given by a set of time - dependent observables @xmath40 , each one calculated as an ensemble average over @xmath41 realizations , or microstates .
for example , @xmath42 in most cases , an observable within a particular microstate is itself an average over the area of the system , such as the average value of the field @xmath43 for the particular microstate @xmath44 .
most of the observables considered will have this `` double '' averaging .
such is the case for @xmath45 , @xmath46 ( the field s conjugate momentum ) , and the corresponding hierarchy of correlation functions .
it will be noted when this is not the case , particularly when quantities are no longer assumed to be translationally invariant , such as those describing localized configurations .
we prepare the field such that it is in thermal equilibrium at temperature @xmath47 in the single - well ( @xmath23 ) potential at some time prior to the quench at @xmath48 , when @xmath15 is set to a nonzero value .
when one is faced with a nonlinear equation of motion such as eq .
[ lang ] below , the thermal probability distribution for @xmath49 can not be obtained exactly . to generate the initial conditions for each of the microstates in the ensemble
, we instead couple the field in the single - well potential to a heat bath via a generalized langevin equation with additive noise , @xmath50 where the viscosity coefficient @xmath51 is related to the stochastic force of zero mean @xmath52 by the fluctuation - dissipation relation , @xmath53 eq . [ fd ] defines the two - point correlation function of the stochastic force , assumed here to be markovian . since this force will only be used during the preparation of the initial thermal state after the quench the coupling with the bath is turned off ( @xmath54 ) this assumption is sufficient .
[ however , it would be quite interesting to examine the effects of multiplicative noise in the nonequilibrium dynamics of this system when the contact with the thermal bath is kept throughout its evolution .
[ the role of multiplicative noise on the onset of synchronization in 1 + 1-dimensional fields has been recently investigated by munz and pastor - satorras @xcite .
] we note that even though we are preparing each microstate in an initial thermal state , there is a one to one correspondence between the temperature and the average energy of the field .
in fact , we can refer to the ensemble prepared as above as a microcanonical ensemble , since each microstate has energy @xmath55 , where @xmath56 .
such numerical accuracy in energy matches that obtained with other methods used preparing the initial state , including the popular monte carlo sampling .
it simply expresses the fact that , for large enough lattices that approach the thermodynamic limit , there is an equivalence between canonical and microcanonical ensembles @xcite .
the full evolution of the scalar field for each microstate is simulated using a staggered leapfrog integration of the equation of motion .
it is implemented on a square lattice with periodic boundary conditions .
integrations are performed with @xmath57 and @xmath58 with 1024 lattice sites per side .
the field is then defined over an area with sides of length @xmath59 .
the leapfrog scheme replaces second - order derivatives with finite - difference expressions that are accurate to @xmath60 .
the lattice spacing and system size are chosen so that computations can be carried out in a timely manner , while the numerical values of any observables and their corresponding continuum values are in good agreement .
for example , after the quench , the energy in this closed system is conserved by more than 1 part in @xmath61 .
results are independent of lattice size , provided large enough lattices are used . finally , all of the observables
are then averaged over an ensemble of @xmath62 microstates .
we start our investigation using a familiar perturbative method , the leading order or homogeneous hartree approximation ( hha ) .
an excellent account can be found in @xcite , where successive truncations within the hierarchy of correlation functions were used to simplify the equation of motion , all the while capturing the essential aspects of the dynamics .
we will borrow many of the same methods and notation found in this reference .
the hha assumes that the statistical distribution of the fluctuations in the field and its momentum remain gaussian throughout the evolution of the system .
we will see that this is indeed an excellent approximation in the following cases : i ) just prior to the quench ( that is , the initial state of the field in a single well ) for all temperatures considered ; ii ) at all times after the quench when the temperature is low ; iii ) at very early times after the quench when the temperature is high .
we start by considering the system before the quench is implemented ( @xmath23 ) , that is , the dynamics with the potential @xmath63 @xcite .
a simple way to implement the hha in this situation is to factor the cubic term in eq .
[ lang ] as @xmath64 , where @xmath65 is the translationally invariant mean - square variance of the field . since the field is in thermal equilibrium , @xmath65 is time - independent . in this approximation ,
the equation of motion becomes linear , @xmath66 the fourier transform of the field is a complex quantity given by @xmath67 the corresponding equation of motion for @xmath68 in @xmath7-space is [ with @xmath69 @xmath70 with the effective frequency squared @xmath71 we have introduced the hartree mass @xmath72 . notice that when there are fluctuations in this field ( @xmath73 ) the effective hartree mass is greater than the `` bare '' mass ( @xmath74 ) given by the potential in eq .
[ v ] . in this approximation ,
the modes evolve independently of one another , just as they would in a linear truncation of the equation of motion , only now each interacts with the homogeneous mean - field background .
a higher - order approximation is needed , however , to implement direct scattering between different modes .
if the system is in thermal equilibrium , the momentum modes in @xmath7-space will satisfy @xmath75 it then follows from eq .
[ eomk ] that the corresponding power spectrum for the field is @xmath76 to obtain the equilibrium quantity @xmath77 , one integrates eq .
[ phimode ] over the entire @xmath7-space and divides by the area .
( equivalently , one can integrate the corresponding two - point correlation function over @xmath78-space to obtain @xmath65 , since parseval s theorem guarantees that the two quantities are the same . )
one must be careful here , since the lattice results depend logarithmically on the ultraviolet cutoff ( lattice - spacing ) .
we refer the reader to ref .
@xcite , where a method is provided to handle such dependence perturbatively . for various temperatures .
the continuous lines are the theoretical predictions given by eq .
[ p_pi].,width=288,height=288 ] for various temperatures .
the continuous lines are the approximations given by eq .
[ p_phi].,width=288,height=288 ] in figures [ dist_pi ] and [ dist_phi ] we show the probability distributions for the initial state of the field and its momentum for various temperatures .
these distributions are obtained numerically by collecting the values of @xmath79 and @xmath49 of every microstate into bins of width @xmath80 , and then normalizing so that the sum over each distribution is unity .
not all data points are shown , making these figures more readable .
also shown are the gaussian probability distributions ( solid lines ) that are predicted from the boltzmann - gibbs formalism , @xmath81 the fitting parameter @xmath82 is obtained by comparing the area ( and ensemble)-averaged two - point corrrelation function of @xmath25 . the variance in figure [ dist_phi ] , @xmath65 ,
can be fitted linearly , @xmath83 .
the agreement between the numerical results and the theoretical predictions confirms the accuracy of the lattice dynamics and the applicability of the hha for low enough temperatures .
the probability distribution of @xmath79 is exact , while that of @xmath49 is indeed close to gaussian for the temperatures considered .
we also show , in figure [ spec_phi ] , the power spectrum of the field modes , @xmath84 , and compare it with the prediction from eq .
[ phimode ] , valid for the hha . for temperatures
@xmath47=0.1 , 0.2 , and 0.4 .
the solid lines are the approximations given by eq .
[ phimode].,width=288,height=288 ] in this subsection we examine the dynamics of the field after the quench .
we will limit our investigation to the case where @xmath85 at @xmath48 , that is , the potential is switched from a single well to a sdw .
the dynamics for adw potentials will be examined in section 5 . at @xmath48 the coupling to the bath
is set to zero , and the dynamics is thus conservative thereafter .
the system is closed , and can be described by a microcanonical ensemble of energy @xmath86 , where @xmath87 . as we remarked before , for large enough systems in equilibrium , as is the case here for @xmath88 , a description with fixed @xmath89
is equivalent to one with fixed @xmath47 .
we will use this initial temperature to characterize the system .
it is interesting to note that in the thermodynamic limit , an instantaneous quench to _ any _ positive value of @xmath15 will not change the energy of the system .
the field is initially symmetric in its distribution and the quench introduces an odd term into the hamiltonian . instead
, the energy is redistributed between its kinetic , gradient , and potential parts , and as a result the final equilibrium temperature will necessarily differ from the initial temperature . in this investigation , however , this change is always less than @xmath90 percent . for open systems , where the system remains in contact with a heat bath , we refer the reader to ref .
@xcite . due to the initial thermal distribution ,
defined entirely by the temperature @xmath47 , the sudden introduction of the cubic term into the potential actually has a minor effect on most of the field . in general , there is little net change in the forces present throughout the system , since the curvature of the single- and double - well potentials are the same at @xmath38 and the majority of the field is indeed close to this value ( see figure 2 ) .
that is , the linear equation of motion remains unchanged for the small - amplitude fluctuations that represent the peak of the field s probability distribution .
the few locations where the field is more responsive to the perturbation correspond to regions with relatively large absolute values of @xmath25 .
these values define the tails of the probability distribution .
the new nonlinear term present in the potential breaks the symmetry in the equation of motion , and this second - order effect causes larger - amplitude field fluctuations with negative ( positive ) values to experience a larger ( smaller ) restoring force than before .
overall , a net positive force is imposed on the symmetrically prepared field and , as a consequence , its average starts at @xmath91 and then begins to move toward @xmath92 , the maximum of the potential barrier between the two states .
we will see that @xmath45 is initially driven more out of equilibrium than all of the fluctuations about it .
this is not surprising , as longer wavelength modes have longer relaxation time - scales @xcite .
it is natural , then , to distinguish the dynamics of the two from each other .
first , define @xmath93 and let @xmath94 represent the fluctuations about this average .
then , @xmath95 where @xmath96 by definition . in the hha
, one assumes that these fluctuations and their momenta remain gaussian in their distribution .
one then obtains an equation of motion for @xmath97 , @xmath98 where we have introduced the effective potential for @xmath99 , @xmath100\phi_{\rm ave } + \frac{1}{2}\,m_{\rm h}^2(t)\,\phi_{\rm ave}^2
-\frac{\alpha_{\rm c}}{3}\,\phi_{\rm ave}^3+\frac{1}{8}\,\phi_{\rm ave}^4,\ ] ] that depends explicitly on the mean - square variance of the fluctuations through the time - dependent hartree mass @xmath101 . , just after the quench , for various initial temperatures @xmath47 .
the two vertical lines correspond to the inflection points of the bare ( @xmath102 ) potential .
they are also the turning points for the potential at @xmath103 . at @xmath104
the turning point is @xmath92.,width=288,height=288 ] @xmath105 at @xmath48 is shown in figure [ v_eff ] for various temperatures . for sufficiently low initial temperatures ( how low will become clear soon )
, @xmath97 will oscillate about the lhs minimum of the effective potential , @xmath106 .
it will then begin to relinquish its energy to higher modes through nonlinear scattering , and its amplitude will decay .
it is possible , then , to approximately bound this region of oscillation from the set of turning points for @xmath107 [ with @xmath108 retaining its @xmath48 value ] , @xmath109 these values give the location of @xmath97 where @xmath110 , and @xmath111 vanishes .
when @xmath112 there are four such turning points because of the symmetry about @xmath92 .
the primary region of interest is when @xmath113 , when fluctuations begin to probe the spinodal region of @xmath114 . by using eq .
[ tp ] , we can predict that @xmath97 will probe this region when @xmath115 , or @xmath103 . clearly , this is also where the leading - order hartree approximation fails .
it is interesting to consider also the case when @xmath116 , or @xmath117 .
there are only two turning points for @xmath99 , since @xmath105 is now a single - well potential symmetric about @xmath118 .
the fluctuations are large enough that the local maximum in the bare potential has little influence in the dynamics , and @xmath119 .
the fluctuations actually probe beyond both minima of the potential .
this case is similar to the phenomena of symmetry restoration in continuous phase transitions , and so in this context @xmath117 would be considered the critical temperature , @xmath120 . for all higher temperatures , @xmath119 @xcite . in this work , we are only concerned with temperatures well below @xmath120 , in fact below @xmath121 , where @xmath122 ( see figure 4 ) . in order to further quantify the dynamics in the hha
, we derive the set of differential equations for the time evolution of the coupled two - point correlation functions .
we define the translationally invariant quantities @xmath123 upon taking the time - derivative of each expression , the equations of motion can then equivalently be written in @xmath7-space .
they are @xmath124 where @xmath125 $ ] .
these equations , coupled with @xmath126 give the full dynamics of @xmath127 and @xmath97 and their corresponding two - point correlation functions @xmath128 and @xmath129 in the hha .
these two groups of expressions are likewise coupled through the quantities @xmath130 and @xmath97 .
the initial conditions are given by eqs .
[ pimode ] , [ phimode ] , and also @xmath131 .
these five first - order equations were solved numerically using a fourth - order runge - kutta algorithm .
the same lattice spacing from the leap - frog algorithm was used .
the calculation of @xmath132 is obtained by numerically averaging the radial function @xmath133 over the disk in @xmath7-space with radius @xmath134 , bounded by @xmath135 .
there is a slight discrepancy between the area of rectangular phase space used in the two - dimensional numerical integrations and the circular phase space used in this method . in light of the previous discussion regarding the dependence of the correlation functions on the lattice spacing
, this difference could possibly introduce error in the calculations of @xmath132 . to compensate for the smaller area used in the hha , the initial conditions for @xmath136 , given by eq .
[ phimode ] , are multiplied by a normalization factor of 1.041 so that the radial integration gives the expected average @xmath137 at @xmath48 .
the results will confirm the validity of this normalization method .
compared to that obtained through the hartree approximation , for various initial temperatures .
shown are @xmath138 ( short dash ) , @xmath139 ( long dash ) , and @xmath140 ( solid ) , as well as the corresponding hartree approximations ( dotted).,width=288,height=288 ] shown in figure [ phiavehartree ] is the numerical time evolution of @xmath97 compared to that obtained through the hha , for various initial temperatures .
the agreement is clearly excellent at lower temperatures , where @xmath141 undergoes almost - linear oscillations about the minimum of @xmath105 : there is very little scattering between modes . at @xmath142 scattering begins to take place , allowing for a slow transfer of energy from low-@xmath7 modes to higher-@xmath7 modes not accounted for in the hha .
we will soon show that this is also the temperature where the synchronous emergence of spatio - temporal order begins to take place .
notice also the dependence of the oscillation frequencies on the initial thermalization temperature . compared to that obtained through the hartree approximation , for various initial temperatures . shown
are @xmath138 ( short dash ) , @xmath139 ( long dash ) , and @xmath140 ( solid ) , as well as the corresponding hartree approximations ( dotted).,width=288,height=288 ] compared to that obtained through the hartree approximation , for various initial temperatures . shown
are @xmath138 ( short dash ) , @xmath139 ( long dash ) , and @xmath140 ( solid ) , as well as the corresponding hartree approximations ( dotted).,width=288,height=288 ] figures [ corrpihartree ] and [ corrphihartree ] compare the numerical time - evolution of @xmath143 and @xmath144 with the corresponding hha predictions .
the quantities are normalized to unity at @xmath48 through @xmath145 and @xmath83 , respectively .
the agreement is again excellent at lower temperatures . at @xmath140
, however , it is evident that energy is being fed into the fluctuations of the field .
the full numerical evolution depicts the amplitude of oscillation of @xmath143 decreasing at a rate larger than that predicted by the hha .
similarly , the amplitude of oscillation of @xmath144 increases at a larger rate .
again , this discrepancy is due primarily from the approximation s inability to account for direct scattering between modes . for various values of @xmath7 .
also shown are the results from the corresponding hartree approximation ( dotted lines ) .
the initial temperature is @xmath146 .
the amplitudes decrease for increasing @xmath7 .
shown , from the top down , are @xmath7=0.75 , 1.25 , 2.0 , and 4.75.,width=384,height=384 ] in figure [ speckhartree ] we show the transfer of energy between different @xmath7-modes .
displayed is the time evolution of @xmath147 for indicative values of @xmath7 .
the initial thermalization temperature is @xmath146 , corresponding to the value in which the majority of the field probes the spinodal region ( cf .
section iv ) .
this is well above the region of temperatures in which the hha is accurate . from the figure it is clear that scattering between low @xmath7 modes modes is taking place .
the approximation is only accurate for shorter wavelength modes , due to the fact that they remain in equilibrium even after the quench .
the breakdown of the hha at longer wavelengths implies that important nonlinear effects are strongly influencing the behavior of the field . in the next section
we investigate the emerging dynamics of these modes .
the results of the last section should have made it clear that at high temperatures nonlinear scattering leads to an efficient energy transfer between modes .
this energy transfer will eventually lead to the thermalization of the field in the sdw potential . as predicted by the hha , at @xmath148
there is consistent energy transfer from the zero - mode to these higher-@xmath7 modes . at these initial temperatures ,
@xmath97 undergoes damped oscillations about its effective minimum .
for @xmath146 , the amplitudes of these oscillations are large enough that @xmath97 just crosses the inflection point of the bare potential : roughly half of the field probes the spinodal region .
( solid line ) and @xmath149 ( dashed line ) for @xmath146.,width=288,height=288 ] figure [ corrandave ] illustrates the transfer of energy from @xmath97 to the fluctuations @xmath144 for @xmath146 .
the quantity @xmath150 is introduced so that a visual comparison can be made between these two components of the field . notice the correlation between the decaying amplitude of oscillation for @xmath97 and the increasing amplitude of the fluctuations . at @xmath151
most of this energy transfer is complete , after which time the two quantities display smaller oscillations that are almost exactly out of phase with each other . for earlier times , @xmath152 ,
a highly nonlinear scattering process occurs , as the zero - mode of the field pumps its energy into its neighboring small-@xmath7 modes .
figure [ spec60 ] shows the numerical time - evolution of @xmath147 for @xmath153 and @xmath152 , at @xmath146 .
first , notice that growth occurs mainly for modes with @xmath154 .
their maximum amplitude reaches a value that is up to 15 times greater than at @xmath48 .
the oscillations then begin to decay and , for @xmath155 ( discussed later ) , the amplitudes of the modes take on a constant value , albeit still many times larger than their initial value .
it is also apparent that for the time interval shown modes with @xmath156 are nearly time - independent , maintaining their initial thermal spectrum given by eq .
[ phimode ] .
this is true of all large-@xmath7 modes present in the numerical simulation , up to @xmath157 , which also indicates that the lattice spacing used has no effect on the emerging dynamics of the system .
.,width=288,height=288 ] we would now like to search for possible spatio - temporal ordering during the field s approach to equilibrium
. however , due to the noisy initial conditions , it is quite difficult to extract information about any emergent pattern , be it spatial and/or temporal . an added advantage to having an analytical expression for the initial thermal spectrum for all temperatures of interest ( cf .
. [ phimode ] ) should be clear : a wiener filter is extremely successful at removing undesirable noise whenever its spectrum is known , all the while maximally preserving the nonperturbative fluctuations that emerge @xcite . with the filtered field , one can catalog and track the location of all local extrema in the system at each instant in time and for all initial temperatures . to distinguish the large - amplitude fluctuations from the long - wavelength thermal noise that is also passed by the filter , only the values of these extrema that are greater than the characteristic amplitude of the noise , @xmath158 , are considered . with ample sorting
, a library is compiled containing the description of every large - amplitude fluctuation present during the entire evolution of the system ( the maximum time for the simulations is @xmath159 ) . for each fluctuation
the following attributes are recorded : its core location @xmath160 , nucleation time @xmath161 , core amplitude @xmath162 ( measured at @xmath160 ) , radius @xmath163 ( measured at half maximum ) , its total number of oscillations @xmath164 , the period of each oscillation @xmath165 , and its lifetime @xmath166 .
each of these attributes is time - dependent , with the exception of @xmath164 and @xmath166 .
almost every large - amplitude fluctuation oscillates anharmonically about the background value @xmath97 , which is recognized by the fact that most of them reappear at approximately the same location with regular frequency .
therefore , in general it is possible to establish the relationship @xmath167 , where @xmath168 is the average period of oscillation .
the set of observables is further reduced by averaging @xmath169 , @xmath162 , and @xmath163 over their corresponding values at the maximum of each oscillation for the lifetime of the fluctuation .
other than the nucleation time @xmath161 , each attribute is now time - independent .
hereafter , we will omit the @xmath170 notation and assume that these values are indeed averages . with this information
, a probability distribution function for the large - amplitude fluctuations is obtained for each initial temperature .
this function , denoted as @xmath171 , can be used to calculate averages over any of its variables .
similarly , one can integrate this function over a subset of variables to obtain a reduced distribution . in all cases , @xmath172 is normalized so that a numerical integration over all variables evaluates to unity .
the bin widths of each variable ( as any one variable of @xmath172 will be visualized as a histogram ) will be specified below . ) .
the darkest regions correspond to the most abundant fluctuations ( probability @xmath173 ) , with each lighter region then descending in intervals @xmath174.,width=288,height=288 ] for the moment , we focus our attention on the characteristics of fluctuations early in the evolution of the field , @xmath175 , and at an initial temperature @xmath146 . the quantity @xmath176 gives the reduced distribution function for the core amplitude and lifetime , and is shown in figure [ disttauphi ] .
the bin widths are @xmath177 and @xmath178 . the darkest regions in the figure correspond to the most probable fluctuations .
particularly noticeable is that fluctuations with core amplitudes @xmath179 and lifetimes @xmath180 dominate the distribution .
one can also see that fluctuations with small amplitudes @xmath181 have mostly short lifetimes .
there is a group of fluctuations , however , that have lifetimes @xmath182 and thus remain present in the system for substantially long periods of time .
in addition , their core amplitudes are confined to a narrower region @xmath183
. also marked on the horizontal axes is the location @xmath184 , which corresponds to the difference between the local maximum and the left minimum of the effective potential for @xmath146 , given by eq .
it follows that these long - lived oscillatory fluctuations have large enough amplitudes that their cores probe a narrow region centered about @xmath92 .
in fact , the large majority of long - lived fluctuations probe beyond the inflection point of @xmath105 at @xmath185 .
they are clearly nonperturbative in nature and would not be seen within the hha . in figure [ oscsnap ]
we show a sequence of snapshots of the filtered field within the time interval @xmath186 .
there are several features to be noted .
[ clearly , they are more striking with a full animation .
we invite the reader to view simulations in ref . @xcite . ] first , large - amplitude fluctuations seem to be of similar size ( spatially - bound configurations ) and spread throughout the lattice .
second , they emerge in near synchrony . as we will see below , this global ordering persists for the first few oscillation cycles .
third , as can be seen from figure [ disttauphi ] , these configurations can be quite long - lived . .
simulations can be viewed in ref .
@xcite.,width=384,height=768 ] we identify these spatially - bound , long - lived configurations with oscillons , which have been originally found as deterministic solutions of models with amplitude - dependent nonlinearities @xcite . in these studies ,
the field was prepared with a bubble - like profile ( typically a gaussian or a tanh ) , and for large enough initial radius and amplitude , observed to fall into an oscillon configuration , characterized by a rapid oscillation of its core , as shown in figure [ oscsnap ] . using harmonic perturbation analysis about an oscillon solution , it has been shown that such configurations require a minimum radius ( in 2 spatial dimensions for the sdw potential used here ) @xcite , @xmath187 we will now extend this result to the general adw potential .
first , we parameterize the radially - symmetric oscillon configuration by a gaussian @xcite @xmath188,~\ ] ] where @xmath189 gives the time behavior at the core of the configuration and @xmath163 is its radial dispertion , assumed here to be constant .
( this assumption is equivalent to reducing the dynamics to one degree of freedom ; it has been shown to provide results in excellent agreement with numerical simulations @xcite . ) with this ansatz , a lagrangian can be obtained and , from it , the equation of motion for @xmath189 .
linear perturbations about the solution , @xmath190 , oscillate with frequency @xmath191 note that @xmath192 has a minimum at @xmath193 .
there is an unstable bifurcation at @xmath194 for the sdw , @xmath195 and the instability is given by eq . [ rc ] .
oscillons are only possible for values of @xmath163 larger than @xmath196 .
larger asymmetries imply smaller values of @xmath196 . in order to strengthen our claim that oscillons are nucleated during the nonequilibrium evolution of @xmath10 ,
the inset in figure [ dist ] shows the distribution functions @xmath197 and @xmath198 for the radii and period of oscillation , respectively . to make a comparison with deterministic oscillons , only fluctuations with @xmath199 ( i.e. those that probe beyond the local maximum of the potential ) and @xmath200 are considered
that is , these are the lower bounds placed on the corresponding integrations over @xmath172 .
the bin widths are @xmath201 .
the fitted curves are gaussian functions with centers @xmath202 and @xmath203 and widths @xmath204 and @xmath205 , respectively . to complete the comparison , consider a deterministic oscillon evolving in a time - independent effective potential that is representative of this case . from figure [ corrandave ] a good approximation would be to take @xmath206 , so that @xmath207 .
the effective mass can thus be obtained from the curvature of the left - hand well , given by eq .
[ veff ] , and evaluates to @xmath208 . finally , from eq .
[ rc ] , we find that the effective minimum radius for which the deterministic oscillon remains stable is @xmath209 . comparing this result with figure [ dist ] we see that , indeed , the emerging oscillons satisfy this requirement remarkably well .
[ note that a proper comparison between oscillons that evolve in different potentials ( i.e. for fields at different initial temperatures ) always requires a suitable scaling of @xmath25 , @xmath210 , and @xmath211 . ] .
also shown ( inset ) are the probability distributions ( solid lines ) for the radius @xmath163 and period @xmath212 of these oscillons .
the fitted curves ( dashed lines ) are gaussian functions.,width=384,height=384 ] also shown in figure [ dist ] is the distribution of nucleation times for the emerging oscillons .
this quantity gives the number of oscillons nucleated between @xmath211 and @xmath213 , with @xmath214 .
it is obtained by calculating the reduced distribution function @xmath215 integrated over all the remaining variables .
the same lower limits are used for the integrals over @xmath162 and @xmath166 , so that only long - lived large - amplitude fluctuations are considered .
if there are @xmath216 such fluctuations , then the final expression for the number of oscillons nucleated as a function of time is @xmath217 the sharp peaks in @xmath41 at early times , @xmath218 , correspond to the synchronous emergence of oscillons . for @xmath155 ,
this global ordering gives way to only local ordering , in which oscillons emerge at arbitrary times with similar probability .
even this local emergence disappears after approximately @xmath219 ( more on this later ) .
notice the correlation between the synchronous nucleation of oscillons and the energy loss from the zero - mode ( c.f .
figure [ corrandave ] ) at early times , @xmath220 .
this phenomenon was observed for temperatures within @xmath221 ( see below ) .
below this temperature range the hha is valid and no coherent structure emerges . above this temperature
range the field separates into large , slowly evolving thin - walled domains , signalling the approach to criticality . in order to understand the mechanism behind the observed synchronous emergence , we decompose the field as in eq .
[ sepphi ] .
the linearized equation satisfied by the fourier modes of the fluctuations is @xmath222 where @xmath223 .
\label{omegaparares}\ ] ] in this approximation , the fluctuations obey a linear equation of motion with a time - dependent frequency determined by the value of @xmath97 .
equations of this type , generalized mathieu equations , are known to exhibit parametric resonance , which can lead to exponential amplification ( @xmath224 ) in the oscillations of @xmath225 at certain wavelengths .
they have been the focus of much recent attention in studies of reheating of the universe after an inflationary expansion phase @xcite . to verify that this is the mechanism behind the synchronous amplification of oscillon modes early in the field s evolution , we use in eq .
[ omegaparares ] the anharmonic solution for @xmath97 that would be obtained if the effective potential remained time - independent .
that is , we require that @xmath97 oscillates in the effective potential as determined immediately after the quench ( i.e. , without energy loss ) , just as the parametric driving force in generalized mathieu equations oscillates with constant amplitude . in this sense , we are considering the initial response of the fluctuations to the oscillations of @xmath97 , without accounting for the subsequent transfer of energy between the two . only with this approach
can one achieve a constant exponential amplification of @xmath226 and thus a good measure of resonance . even though this approximation only strictly holds for early times
, the results obtained will confirm its validity in describing the essential physics behind the observed synchronous emergence .
for the bottom - most contour and increasing in increments of @xmath227.,width=288,height=288 ] figure [ parares ] shows lines of constant exponential amplification rate @xmath228 of the fluctuations @xmath225 for various @xmath7 and @xmath47 . at low temperatures , @xmath229 ,
no modes are ever amplified .
as the temperature is increased , so is the amplitude of oscillation in @xmath97 , gradually causing the band @xmath230 to resonate .
it is helpful at this point to consider what modes comprise a typical oscillon .
to do so , we use a gaussian ansatz for the oscillon with a fixed radius @xmath163 , @xmath231 @xcite .
the fourier transform is itself a gaussian with a characteristic radius @xmath232 .
thus , a gaussian in real space is generally comprised of the band @xmath233 in @xmath7-space .
earlier [ cf .
figure [ dist ] ] it was found that the average radius of the emergent oscillons is @xmath202 at an initial temperature @xmath146 , which in this approximation corresponds to the band @xmath234 .
this agrees very well with what is seen in figure [ parares ] .
although in this linear approximation the entire band does not resonate until higher temperatures , it is expected that in the full equation of motion the nonlinear coupling between modes will broaden the resonance band at lower temperatures .
we have observed that the synchronous emergence of oscillons occurs for initial temperatures @xmath235 .
the lower bound is directly related to the nonlinear scattering between modes , which is absent at low temperatures . for temperatures above @xmath236 ,
the appearance of large domains precludes the identification of oscillons .
this is typical of the approach to criticality , where large spatial correlations in the field become more probable , destroying any local ordering .
thus , the observed quench - induced synchronous emergence of order is limited to temperatures sufficiently below @xmath120 .
in the introduction , we mentioned that long - lived locally - ordered structures may serve as bottlenecks to equipartition , as they slow down the distribution of energy between the system s various degrees of freedom .
below , we present evidence that oscillons do precisely that . a more formal proof is left for future work . a good observable to follow is the time evolution of @xmath237 for different modes , which should become flat when thermal equilibrium is achieved and the equipartition theorem is satisfied . in highly dissipative systems ( such as those governed by a langevin equation of motion with a large viscosity coefficient )
, energy exchange between each mode and the thermal bath tends to dominate the dynamics . in the nonequilibrium closed system considered here
, however , energy is only exchanged between the modes themselves , and the thermalization process turns out to be quite different . for various modes ( see text ) .
the data is boxcar averaged over a window @xmath238 .
also shown ( inset ) is the time evolution of @xmath127 , which attains equilibrium noticeably earlier than any of the higher modes shown.,width=288,height=288 ] in figure [ thermal ] we show the time evolution of @xmath237 for the values @xmath7=0.25 , 0.5 , 0.75 , 1.0 , 1.25 , and 1.5 ( top to bottom lines , respectively ) .
the curves are time - averaged over a window @xmath238 so that the large oscillatory behavior at early times ( @xmath218 ) is suppressed .
also shown in the inset is the time evolution of @xmath239 , which exhibits the thermalization trend of the zero mode .
@xmath127 displays damped oscillatory motion before reaching its equilibrium value at @xmath240 .
this is roughly the time in which the mode @xmath241 reaches its maximum average kinetic energy .
the mode @xmath242 also increases from @xmath48 to a maximum value at about the same time before decaying . for modes @xmath243
, however , the general trend is to slowly absorb energy as they asymptotically approach their equilibrium values from below on time - scales that can be much _ longer _ than the lower-@xmath7 modes .
there are two clear trends : small modes ( with @xmath244 ) grow very quickly and then relax to their final equilibrium values , while larger modes ( with @xmath245 ) slowly approach theirs .
thus , it is reasonable to conclude that most of the zero - mode s initial energy goes into its neighboring modes , those responsible for oscillon - like configurations [ cf .
figure [ parares ] ] , and only later on it is shared amongst larger @xmath7 modes .
this seems to suggest that there is a _ two - step energy cascade _ , a fast one at early times to small-@xmath7 modes , followed by a slower one to larger @xmath7 modes .
the early emergence of oscillons is consistent with this scenario .
we can further quantify this argument by introducing a measure of the entropy of the system based on the partitioning of the kinetic energy , @xmath246 : @xmath247 where @xmath248 is the probability distribution of the kinetic energy in @xmath7-space .
@xmath249 attains its maximum value when equipartition is satisfied , and @xmath250 where @xmath251 is the area of this space .
this occurs both at the initial thermalization @xmath252 and final equilibrium states , since in these cases all modes carry the same fractional kinetic energy . at these times
we recover the thermodynamic entropy of the system , @xmath253 , which is a measure of the number of accessible states in the system . [ the numerical implementation gives @xmath254 , where @xmath41 is the number of lattice points , or degrees of freedom . ] in figure [ s ]
we show the change of @xmath249 from the initial state , @xmath255 , for the system at @xmath146 . at late times
( @xmath256 ) , we have found that the system equilibrates exponentially in a time - scale @xmath257 . at early times , the localization of energy at lower @xmath7 modes , corresponding to the synchronous emergence of oscillons , prolongs this approach to equipartition .
the inset of figure [ s ] shows the large oscillations in the early evolution of @xmath249 ( dotted line ) .
also shown ( solid line ) is the average between successive peaks of @xmath249 , with a plateau at @xmath258 that coincides with the maximum oscillon presence in the system .
this is to be contrasted with an exponential approach to equilibrium .
thus , we see evidence that oscillon configurations indeed serve as early bottlenecks to equipartition , temporarily suppressing the cascading of energy from low-@xmath7 modes to higher modes . from the initial state for closed systems at @xmath146 .
the exponential approach to equilibrium is clear at late times .
the inset illustrates the role of oscillons as a bottleneck to equipartition.,width=288,height=288 ]
we will now investigate the dynamics with the adw potential , that is , for values of @xmath259 .
homogeneous nucleation predicts that , had the system been prepared in the metastable state at @xmath38 at some temperature @xmath47 , its decay rate per unit area would be controlled by the arrhenius factor , @xmath260 $ ] , where @xmath261 is the free - energy barrier for the nucleation of a critical nucleus or bounce @xcite .
( we set @xmath262 . )
it is often overlooked that this result is quite sensitive to how the initial state is prepared .
it assumes that the bounce is nucleated within a homogeneous background , by adopting a perturbative gaussian approximation for the evaluation of the partition function . in other words
, it assumes that no large - amplitude perturbations are present in the system @xcite .
it is also well - known that there are discrepancies between the theoretical prediction from homogeneous nucleation and a large array of experimental results concerning nucleation rates , from he@xmath263 @xcite and nematic liquid crystals @xcite to martensitic materials and polycrystals @xcite to fluids @xcite and numerical simulations @xcite . more often than not
, theoretical estimates greatly underestimate nucleation rates . surely , many of these discrepancies are related to limited knowledge of the nonequilibrium processes leading to nucleation at the atomic or mesoscopic scale for various materials .
however , we propose here that in certain cases the problem is rooted on the detailed set up of the initial metastable state . in particular , the quench we propose in this work , which may be mimicked in experimental situations , generates an instability capable of greatly accelerating the decay of the metastable state . in fact , we have observe that , for a range of temperatures , the nucleation rate per unit area is not that of homogeneous nucleation , @xmath264 $ ] , but a power law , @xmath265 , where @xmath266 is the critical nucleus free energy and the exponent @xmath1 is weakly temperature - dependent .
rn stands for resonant nucleation .
the power law applies precisely within the temperature range where we observe the synchronous emergence of oscillons at early times , @xmath267 , as we show next .
the change in @xmath15 will not modify the basic parametric amplification mechanism discussed above in the context of the sdw : for a range of temperatures , oscillons are still nucleated in synchrony at early times .
the difference is that , for @xmath37 , the system must reach the global free - energy minimum at @xmath268 .
[ of course , for large enough temperatures , @xmath269 , and/or small energy barriers the system will go straight into the global minimum , a cross - over decay .
we are not interested in these cases . ] in the usual treatment , the critical nucleation is described as the saddle - point in field - configuration space , the unstable direction dictated by the negative eigenvalue associated with the growth of the critical nucleus .
this is given by the solution of the equation @xmath270 , with appropriate boundary conditions , which determines the 2d bounce @xcite . in the absence of forcing , which is the case for homogeneous nucleation
, the system will randomly probe phase space until it eventually `` finds '' the saddle point .
the presence of quench - induced large - amplitude fluctuations in the field will drastically accelerate its decay . in figure [ decay - phi ]
we show the evolution of the order parameter @xmath107 as a function of time for several values of asymmetry , @xmath271 for @xmath146 . not surprisingly , as @xmath272 , the field remains longer in the metastable state , since the nucleation energy barrier @xmath273 at @xmath274 .
however , a quick glance at the time axis shows the fast decay time - scale , of order @xmath275 . for comparison , for @xmath276
, homogeneous nucleation would predict nucleation time - scales of order @xmath277 ( in dimensionless units ) , respectively .
[ the nucleation barriers are , @xmath278 and @xmath279 . ] clearly , while for smaller asymmetries @xmath97 displays similar oscillatory behavior to the sdw case before transitioning to the global minimum , as @xmath15 is increased ( asymmetry in potential is increased ) the number of oscillations decreases sharply . at @xmath146 for several values of the asymmetry .
( from left to right , @xmath280 . )
each curve is an ensemble average over 100 runs.,width=288,height=288 ] in figure [ powerlaw ] we show the log - log plot of the ensemble - averaged nucleation time - scales as a function of the nucleation barrier , or critical droplet free energy , @xmath281 for different temperatures , @xmath282 and @xmath283 .
the error bars are computed from the dispersion of the measured time scales within the ensemble .
the best fit is a power law , @xmath284 , with @xmath285 for @xmath286 and @xmath146 , and @xmath287 for @xmath140 .
this simple power law holds for the same range of temperatures where we have observed the synchronous emergence of oscillons . [ the range is similar for both sdw and adw . ]
it is not surprising that the exponent @xmath1 is larger for @xmath140 , where the synchronous emergence of oscillons is marginal : at lower temperatures , the oscillations of the field s zero mode have lower amplitude and oscillons become rarer .
in fact , as we remarked before , we have not observed any for @xmath288 for the sdw . for lower temperatures
, we should thus expect a smooth transition into the exponential time - scales of homogeneous nucleation .
we intend to analyse this transition and to obtain an analytical explanation for the power law in a forthcoming publication . as a first step in this direction
, we present below what we believe is the mechanism by which the transition completes for different nucleation barriers . for resonant nucleation as a function of critical nucleation free - energy barrier @xmath281 at @xmath140 , @xmath289 , and @xmath283 .
the best fit is a power - law with exponent @xmath290 for @xmath286 and @xmath283 and @xmath291 for @xmath140.,width=288,height=288 ] first , note that the error bars in figure [ powerlaw ] increase with nucleation barrier .
this spread in time scales is related to the dynamics of the system .
for @xmath292 the radius of the nucleation bubble diverges , @xmath293 .
clearly , due to the disparity between the power law and the exponential time scales , the mechanism by which the system approaches the global minimum is not through a random search in configuration space as is the case for homogeneous nucleation .
instead , we argue that oscillons will act as seeds for the nucleation of a critical fluctuation .
the way in which this happens depends on the nucleation barrier .
if @xmath294 , the critical nucleus will have a radius much larger than a typical oscillon [ cf .
figure [ dist ] ] ; it will appear as two or more oscillons coalesce .
as @xmath15 is increased further , the radius of the critical nucleus decreases , approaching that of an oscillon . in this case , a single oscillon may become the critical nucleus and promote the decay of the metastable state .
this explains the small number of oscillations on @xmath97 as @xmath15 is increased [ cf .
figure [ decay - phi ] ] . to corroborate our argument , in figure [ radius ]
we contrast the critical nucleation radius with that of oscillons for different values of energy barrier at @xmath146 . the average oscillon radius [ cf .
figure [ dist ] ] is @xmath295 , and is identified by the dashed line , with the dotted lines denoting its dispersion .
the critical nucleus radius , @xmath296 , is equal to @xmath297 for @xmath298 , or @xmath299 .
thus , for @xmath300 one can not distinguish between a single oscillon and a critical bubble .
since , as we have seen , oscillons appear very early on , the decay happens quite fast . for @xmath301 ,
approximately , the critical nucleus is the result of the coalescence of two or more oscillons .
they diffuse through the lattice and scatter , forming bound states , somewhat as in kink - antikink breathers in 1d field theory @xcite .
we emphasize that these values are only approximate ; they do not include the increase in coalescence rates due to diffusive motions on the lattice or an enhancement on the unstable growth of oscillons due to perturbations .
we expect that the one - oscillon decay will ensue for smaller values of @xmath15 . in @xcite
the reader can see a few representative simulations .
clearly , these arguments can be refined .
in particular , the details of oscillon coalescence remain unexplored
. however , they encapsulate the basic mechanism by which metastable states decay via resonant nucleation , as seen in numerical simulations . .
the dashed line shows the average radius for nucleated oscillons , while the dotted lines denote the dispersion of its value.,width=288,height=288 ]
we have investigated the nonequilibrium dynamics of a double - well model with a 2d scalar order parameter .
the system was initially prepared in thermal equilibrium at a fixed temperature in a anharmonic single - well potential , @xmath302 we then turned on a cubic interaction with tunable strength so that the resulting double - well potential can be symmetric ( sdw ) or asymmetric ( adw ) .
the turning - on of the interaction can be interpreted as a `` quench , '' as it occurs within a time - scale faster than any in the system .
the system is thus tossed into a double - well potential and , through its nonlinear interactions , redistributes its energy until it reaches equipartition . for the sdw case ,
we have observed that this approach to equilibrium occurs as a two - step energy cascade : quickly at first , as the zero - mode relinquishes its energy to nearby ( in @xmath7-space ) long - wavelength modes , and slower later , as the energy is partitioned with the short - wavelength modes . although we have adopted the language of nonequilibrium field theory , we remark that one could equally well treat the system as a microcanonical ensemble with fixed energy @xmath89 .
we showed that , for a range of initial temperatures , the initial stages of the dynamics are dominated by damped oscillations of the field s zero mode , which , via parametric resonance , excite the modes associated with coherent structures named oscillons .
we also showed that the initial emergence of oscillons occurs at the breakdown of the homogeneous hartree approximation .
furthermore , this emergence occurs in synchrony , characterizing a global emergence phenomenon .
as oscillons are long - lived coherent structures , they act as bottlenecks for equipartition .
the observed synchronous emergence dies away with the damping of the zero - mode oscillations .
oscillons then appear randomly throughout the lattice , until such a time when there is nt enough energy in long - wavelength modes .
we then investigated the dynamics in adws , where the final equilibrium state is at the global minimum of the potential .
the system was thermalized as for the sdw , in its metastable well .
also as before , the quenching induces damped oscillations of the field s zero mode and oscillons emerge .
we observed that , approximately for the same range of temperatures where oscillons emerged in the sdw case , the decay rate was greatly enhanced , when compared to homogeneous nucleation results .
in fact , we obtained an excellent fit to a _ power law decay _
time scale , @xmath303^b$ ] , where @xmath261 is the energy of the critical nucleus or bounce and @xmath1 is a numerical exponent , @xmath304 , for the temperatures we investigated .
we argued that there were two main mechanisms for what we called resonant nucleation : for small asymmetries , the critical nucleus appears as two or more oscillons coalesce . for larger asymmetries
, a single oscillon grows to become the critical nucleus , promoting the decay of the metastable state .
the greatly accelerated decay is due to the resonant oscillations of the zero mode , induced by the quenching .
it is thus plausible that such behavior may be observed in several related systems with a scalar order parameter .
the emergence of oscillons in granular materials appears due to the sinusoidal vibrations of their container @xcite ; this is mimicked here by the oscillation of the field s zero mode , which corresponds to the periodic oscillation of the whole lattice . as for granular materials ,
patterns emerge above a certain amplitude .
we do not claim to have modelled the behavior of granular materials here , but believe to have captured some of the essential physics .
also , since the model here falls in the ising universality class , we expect that similar qualitative behavior should occur , for example , in ferromagnets and possibly binary liquids and metal alloys , if long wavelength oscillations can be induced by the quenching process .
j. d. gunton , m. san miguel , and p. s. sahni , in _ phase transitions and critical phenomena _ , ed . c. domb and j. l. lebowitz , v. 8 ( academic press , london , 1983 ) ; j. d. gunton , j. stat
. phys . * 95 * , 903 ( 1999 ) . here is an incomplete list of references : g. n. felder and l. kofman , phys .
d * 63 * , 103503 ( 2001 ) ; p. b. greene and l. kofman , phys .
b * 448 * , 6 ( 1999 ) ; p. b. greene , l. kofman , a. d. linde and a. a. starobinsky , phys .
d * 56 * , 6175 ( 1997 ) ; d. boyanovsky , h. j. de vega and r. holman , arxiv : hep - ph/9701304 ; d. boyanovsky , m. dattanasio , h. j.de vega , r. holman and d. s. lee , phys .
d * 52 * , 6805 ( 1995 ) ; d. boyanovsky , h. j. de vega and r. holman , arxiv : hep - ph/9903534 . | we investigate , analytically and numerically , the emergence of spatio - temporal order in nonequilibrium scalar field theories . the onset of order is triggered by destabilizing interactions ( dis ) , which instantaneously change the interacting potential from a single to a double - well , tunable to be either degenerate ( sdw ) or nondegenerate ( adw ) . for the sdw case , we observe the emergence of spatio - temporal coherent structures known as oscillons .
we show that this emergence is initially synchronized , the result of parametric amplification of the relevant oscillon modes .
we also discuss how these ordered structures act as bottlenecks for equipartition . for adw potentials ,
we show how the same parametric amplification mechanism may trigger the rapid decay of a metastable state . for a range of temperatures ,
the decay rates associated with this resonant nucleation can be orders of magnitude larger than those computed by homogeneous nucleation , with time - scales given by a simple power law , @xmath0^b$ ] , where @xmath1 depends weakly on the temperature and @xmath2 is the free - energy barrier of a critical fluctuation . |
inflation was invented to resolve problems existing in hot big bang cosmology , such as flatness , horizon , primordial monopole problem@xcite ( for some early attempts see refs .
@xcite ) . after more than twenty years development
, one has obtained a deep sight at this theory .
however , it is still puzzled by an initial singularity which exists in usual inflationary models@xcite .
it has been suggested that , bouncing cosmology , which requires our universe initially experience a contracting phase before the hot big bang expansion , could provide a solution to the problem of the initial singularity . for years
, models of a bouncing universe have received a lot of attentions and there have been a number of works on constructing this scenario . for example , there are models with singular bounce such as the pre - big - bang @xcite and cyclic / ekpyrotic @xcite ; also in refs . @xcite
some non - singular bounce models were considered where the gravitation action was modified by higher order corrections ; and , see ref .
@xcite for a recent review on various models of bouncing cosmology .
recently , a new bounce model has been proposed @xcite , dubbed quintom bounce . in this model ,
a bouncing universe was obtained within the standard 4-dimensional friedmann - robertson - walker ( frw ) framework by making use of quintom matter@xcite .
the key feature of this model is that , the null energy condition ( nec ) has to be violated for a short while around the bounce point and after that the equation - of - state ( eos ) of our model @xmath0 is able to transit from below @xmath1 to above @xmath1 which makes the universe enter into normal expanding history .
the model of quintom bounce has presented a very interesting picture of the early universe .
firstly , the investigation of the cosmological perturbations in this model @xcite has shown a combination of some aspects found in some recently studied non - singular bounce models @xcite and some others in singular bounce models @xcite . secondly , in a recent study on quintom bounce , the authors of ref . @xcite
have found that a concrete model of quintom bounce are able to provide a scale - invariant spectrum in ultra - violet regime , and also give rise to an oscillation signature which could be verified in the forthcoming astronomical observations .
one important lesson of studying the primordial curvature perturbations is to investigate its bispectrum which describes the non - gaussianity of the power spectrum@xcite .
there is a number of information coded in this bispectrum , such as magnitude , shape , sign , and even running .
to probe these signatures , we expect to distinguish various models of the very early universe .
for example , in the usual slow - roll inflationary model , it is pointed out that non - gaussianity is negligible due to the suppression of slow - roll parameters@xcite ; however , in the models of ekyrotic / cyclic @xcite or island universe@xcite , a large non - gaussianity is predicted .
observationally , current cosmological data@xcite is consistent with gaussian distribution , however , the forthcoming observations will be sensitive to the non - gaussianity with much higher precision , such as planck satellite @xcite . given the considerations above , we in this paper calculate the bispectrum of a quintom bounce model .
our results show that non - gaussianity in this model is still suppressed by slow - roll parameters , but there is an interesting oscillation signal on the non - linear parameter and its maximal value is mildly bigger than that in the usual scenario of slow - roll inflationary models .
another important clue to discover the information of the very early universe is to study the relic gravitational wave background ( gwb ) formed by primordial tensor fluctuations .
there have been a number of detectors operating for the signals of primordial gwb , e.g. planck @xcite , big bang observer ( bbo ) @xcite , ligo @xcite .
moreover , the indirect detection of gwb attracts a lot of interests of the next generation of cmb observations , see related analyses @xcite .
the basic mechanism for the generation of primordial gwb in cosmology has been discussed in refs .
usually , inflation theory predicts that the power spectrum of primordial tensor fluctuations is scale - invariant and its value is roughly equal to scalar spectrum times a slow - roll parameter defined as @xmath2@xcite .
however , this so - called consistency relation is not necessary to be valid in a bounce scenario .
for example , ref .
@xcite has investigated the primordial gravitational waves in singular bounce models and predicted an undetectable gwb .
we in this paper study the relic gravitational waves in quintom bounce with coleman - weinberg potential .
interestingly , we find that the power spectrum of primordial gravitational waves is scale - invariant both in ultra - violet and infrared regimes but strongly oscillate in the middle band which is related to the bounce , and also find a sunken signature on the energy spectrum . these results on one side support the conclusions of ref .
@xcite in which the scalar perturbations were discussed , and on the other side provide another approaches to searching the signals of a bounce .
the outline of this paper is as follows . in section
ii , we briefly review the basic scenario of a quintom bounce model with a the coleman - weinberg potential , and the curvature perturbation . in section iii
, we make the calculation of non - gaussianity in the model of quintom bounce , and find that the non - linear parameter @xmath3 is oscillating around a small value which coincide with that in usual inflation model . in section iv , we investigate the tensor part of gravitational perturbations in this model , and then give the power spectrum and spectral index correspondingly . considering the influences of possible factors during the late time evolution
, we discuss the transfer function for the gravitational waves and finally obtain the energy spectrum of gwb we may probe in future observations . section v contains discussion and conclusions .
as proposed in ref .
@xcite , a model of quintom bounce can be described in terms of scalar fields which minimally couple to the four dimensional einstein s gravity .
the simplest model is realized by two scalar fields , with its lagrangian given by @xmath4 in a spatially flat friedmann - robertson - walker ( frw ) universe where the signature of the metric is taken to be @xmath5 . here
the essential component is the scalar field @xmath6 .
it plays a crucial role in giving a bouncing solution smoothly . without it , the model in ( 1 ) will be similar to the traditional inflation with a single scalar field , which as we know suffers from the problem of the initial singularity . in collaboration with qiu ,
xia and li@xcite , we take the potential to be only the function of the field @xmath7 , and specifically of coleman - weinberg form @xcite : @xmath8 which takes its maximum value @xmath9 at @xmath10 and vanishes at the minima when @xmath11 .
therefore , the scalar field @xmath6 merely affects the evolution around the bounce but decays out quickly when away from the bouncing point .
this model performs an interesting evolution for the background universe @xcite .
initially , @xmath7 stays at its left vacuum @xmath12 and the kinetic term of @xmath6 is sufficiently small .
this looks very natural and there is no argument for any fields being outside the planck scale , so it does not suffer the initial condition problem which appears in the usual inflationary model @xcite . at the beginning of the evolution ,
the field @xmath7 oscillates around the vacuum point @xmath12 , so the eos of the universe oscillates about @xmath13 and averagely the state looks similar to a matter dominated one . since the universe is contracting , the amplitude of the canonical field oscillation becomes larger and larger , in the meanwhile the contribution of @xmath6 also becomes important .
when the field reaches the plateau , the energy density of @xmath7 would be cancelled by that of @xmath6 and so the bounce happens .
after the bounce , as the field @xmath7 moves forward slowly along the plateau , the universe enters into a slow - roll phase and the eos of the universe is approximately @xmath1 , very much alike inflation . the process to link
the contraction and expansion is a smooth bounce , during which the evolution of the hubble parameter can be treated as a linear function of the cosmic time @xmath14 approximately .
finally , when the field @xmath7 drops " into the right vacuum @xmath15 , it will oscillate again and reheat the universe . to present the above analysis clearly
, we give the numerical calculation of background evolution in fig .
[ fig1:background ] . from this figure , we can see that , although the potential is symmetric w.r.t .
the field @xmath7 , the background evolution is asymmetric w.r.t . the cosmic time . , the hubble parameter @xmath16 and the canonical field @xmath7 in the model ( [ lagrangian ] ) where a coleman - weinberg potential is considered . in the numerical calculation
we choose the parameters @xmath17 , and the initial conditions as : @xmath18 where @xmath19 . ]
note that , the asymmetry of the evolution is a significant character since we are able to obtain a scale - invariant spectrum in virtue of this asymmetry .
the reason is as follows . since the evolution of the universe is asymmetric w.r.t .
the bounce point , it is possible for the primordial fluctuations keeping inside the horizon when the universe is contracting . and if so , while these perturbations are able to escape to the super - hubble region during the inflationary period , the initial bunch - davies condition for them can be basically saved and transferred through the bounce .
therefore , this scenario provides a possible approach to obtaining a scale - invariant spectrum .
however , as will be shown in the following , we find that the sub - hubble perturbations still deviate a little from the pure incoming plane wave on the matching surface between the bouncing phase and the expanding phase .
this deviation would bring some wiggles on the corresponding scale of the primordial power spectrum , which has been shown in ref .
@xcite can be detected by the future observations .
now we take a brief review of the linear curvature perturbation ( for details we refer to ref .
@xcite , and see ref .
@xcite for a comprehensive review ) , then study its evolution in the model of quintom bounce and obtain the expression for the primordial power spectrum . under the longitudinal ( conformal - newtonian ) gauge ,
the metric perturbations are given by @xmath20~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we introduce the comoving time @xmath21 defined by @xmath22 .
we start with the equation of motion of the gravitational potential @xmath23 where @xmath24 is the comoving hubble parameter and the prime denotes the derivative with respect to the comoving time .
this equation can be derived from the basic perturbation equations directly ( we refer the complete derivation to ref .
@xcite ) . as we have pointed out in describing the background evolution ,
the energy density of the scalar @xmath6 is usually negligible away from the bouncing point and hence we have @xmath25 .
therefore it is a good approximation to neglect the right hand side of eq .
( [ eomp ] ) when the universe is far away from the bounce .
moreover , we find that there is the relation @xmath26 in the bouncing phase and so the perturbation of @xmath6 decouples from eq .
( [ eomp ] ) , which has been checked in ref .
thus , in the paper we will neglect the r.h.s .
( [ eomp ] ) , and just focus on the adiabatic fluctuations which can be determined by a single physical scalar field degree of freedom @xmath27 .
if the evolution of the background is known , all other perturbation variables can be determined from @xmath27 .
a frequently used variable is the curvature perturbation in comoving coordinates @xmath28 which is defined as , @xmath29 and this variable can be calculated from @xmath27 and the background parameters .
for example , when the universe is in a nearly de - sitter like expansion , there is a simple relation @xmath30 with the slow - roll parameter @xmath31 . in usual case
this variable is well known to describe the adiabatic perturbations on large scales since it is a conserved quantity on super - hubble scales according to the equation @xmath32 and its dynamics can be simply and conveniently described by the equation of motion for mukhanov - sasaki variable @xcite .
however , this equation becomes ill - defined both at the bounce point with a vanishing hubble parameter @xmath33 and the cosmological constant boundary @xmath34 .
this point has been remarked in ref .
consequently , we investigate the evolution of the gravitational potential @xmath27 directly in deriving the curvature perturbation , and then moves to @xmath28 after the universe entering the expanding phase .
as introduced in the above , the universe in this model experiences three phases , a contracting one , a bounce , and finally an inflationary one .
we can resolve the perturbation equation in each phase respectively . in the detailed calculation
, we take the bunch - davies vacuum as the initial condition @xmath35 , and then make those solutions smoothly pass through the linking point applying the matching conditions@xcite ( see also @xcite for a recent study ) .
the detailed derivation has been presented in ref .
@xcite , and here we give the dominant part of the final gravitational potential directly : @xmath36 \right\}~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath37 and @xmath38 represent the comoving hubble parameter at the beginning and the end of the bouncing phase respectively . by comparing the coefficient ( [ fk ] ) and the initial form of @xmath27 , obviously the dominant mode of the gravitational potential deviate from the bunch - davies initial condition when the inflationary phase takes place .
moreover , we have the approximate relation @xmath30 .
so we eventually have the expression of the primordial power spectrum for the curvature perturbation - vacuum@xcite . however , these two are different in the detailed characteristics of the perturbations and the basic mechanisms for the generation of those perturbations . ]
@xmath39 from this result , one obviously find that the first term provides a nearly scale - invariant spectrum which is consistent with current cosmological observations .
however , the second term shows that there is a wiggle on the spectrum , due to the modified initial condition by the bounce relative to the standard inflation .
apparently , this oscillation term could affect the cmb temperature power spectrum and lss matter power spectrum@xcite .
in this section we investigate the evolution of the nonlinear part of scalar perturbations in our model .
as we have discussed in the last section , the universe experiences a nearly exponential expansion after the bounce , and so we can deal with the curvature perturbation of quintom bounce as in inflation theory except for the initial condition being modified .
thus , the slow - roll parameters can be defined in our model , with @xmath2 and @xmath40 . to expand the action to the third order of @xmath28 and drop the terms suppressed by slow - roll parameters @xmath41 and @xmath42
, we have the final cubic action for the curvature perturbation during the inflationary phase@xcite , @xmath43~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath44 and @xmath45 .
note that the last term @xmath46 in the third - order action can be absorbed by field redefinitions of @xmath28 .
it is taken as @xmath47 this field redefinitions do not affect any other of the @xmath48 terms in the third - order action , since the term @xmath49 are quadratic in @xmath28 . moreover ,
the last term in the third - order action can be cancelled by one extra quadratic part of this field redefinitions which is proportional to the first - order equations of motion @xmath50 exactly . after deriving out the third - order action ,
now we are able to get the three point function for our model .
it can be computed using the path integral formalism in the interaction picture as follows @xmath51>,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath52 denotes an initial time for the modes deep inside the horizon , and @xmath53 is the third order perturbative lagrangian .
recall in eq .
( [ pzeta ] ) we have obtained the linear curvature perturbation which deviates from that in the standard inflation theory by multiplying an extra factor defined as follows , @xmath54 considering this factor in the calculations , the leading order contributions to the three point correlator in our model are listed in the following , + ( a ) : contribution from @xmath55 . to make the expression simplified
, we define @xmath56 which is just the curvature spectrum in inflation models and @xmath57 .
so we have the three point correlator from @xmath55 : @xmath58 ( b ) : contribution from the field redefinition .
@xmath59&\end{aligned}\ ] ] moreover , since non - gaussianity measures the deviation of cmb power spectrum from the gaussian distribution , we can define a non - linear parameter @xmath3 as follows , @xmath60 so we eventually have @xmath3 to characterize the size of non - gaussianity , @xmath61{\bigg/}(\sum_i\frac{k_i^3}{c(k_i)})~.\end{aligned}\ ] ] there are two limiting cases of non - gaussianity , which are of particular interests for observations .
these are equilateral form ( @xmath62 ) and local form ( @xmath63 ) . to the case of equilateral form , @xmath3
is given by @xmath64~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have taken the limit @xmath65 .
for the local form , which corresponds to that @xmath66 mode exits horizon much earlier than the other two , we have the non - linear parameter @xmath67~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the limit is taken as @xmath68 .
one may notice that , the above results reduce to the single scalar slow - roll inflationary model when @xmath69 .
however , since the factor @xmath70 has modified the initial condition of curvature perturbation when the universe enters inflationary stage , it can bring an oscillation signature on the size of non - gaussianity as well . in order to compare our result with the non - gaussianity predicted by usual inflation model , we plot @xmath3 of equilateral and local forms in fig . [ fig2:fnl ] . with different forms predicted by our model
are shown by the magenta solid lines . to make the comparison
, we also give @xmath3 predicted by a single scalar inflation model in blue dotted lines . ]
our results show that the non - gaussianity in the quintom bounce model is still suppressed by the slow - roll parameters .
however , there is an oscillation signature on @xmath3 and the maximal value of @xmath3 is bigger than that in single scalar slow - roll inflationary models .
the reason for this effect is that the dominant modes of the curvature perturbations have deviated from the bunch - davies form when they pass through the bounce and enter the inflationary stage .
this is similar to the cases with non - gaussianity generated from a modified initial condition , for example see refs .
now we turn to consider the evolution of gravitational wave background from the tensor part of the primordial metric perturbations . in order to standardize the derivation
, we use the same convention as in ref .
@xcite . to begin with ,
we give the metric containing the tensor perturbations in the flat frw background as follows , @xmath71~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the latin indexes represent spatial coordinates . here the tensor perturbation @xmath72 satisfies the following constraints : @xmath73 due to these constraints , we only have two degrees of freedom in @xmath72 which correspond to two polarizations of gravitational waves . by adding the anisotropic part of the stress tensor @xmath74
, we have the equation of motion for tensor perturbations , @xmath75 the fourier transformations of the tensor perturbations and anisotropic stress tensor are give by , @xmath76 note that , what we are usually interested in are the distribution of the spectra of gravitational waves and the corresponding spectral index . based on the above formalism , the tensor power spectrum can be written as , @xmath77 and the definition of tensor spectral index @xmath78 is given by @xmath79 the gwb we observed today is characterized by the energy spectrum , @xmath80 where @xmath81 is the energy density of gravitational waves , and the parameter @xmath82 is the critical density of the universe . in respect
that the gwb we observed has already reentered the horizon , the modes should oscillate in the form of a sinusoidal function .
consequently , we can make use of the friedmann equation @xmath83 and then deduce the relation between the power spectrum and the energy spectrum as follows , @xmath84 which will be used in the following calculations .
now we follow one fourier mode of the tensor perturbations , labelled by its comoving wave number @xmath85 , and find that there are two paths which are different in the times of crossing the hubble radius .
the evolution of tensor perturbations is sketched in fig .
[ fig3:sketch ] .
initially all the perturbations stay inside the hubble radius in the far past .
since the hubble radius shrinks in the contracting phase , those modes with small comoving wave number exit the hubble radius while the large @xmath85 scales still keep inside .
when the bounce takes place , all the perturbations will keep inside the hubble radius because at that moment the hubble radius diverges .
after that the bounce is followed by a slow - roll expanding phase , so these fourier modes will escape out if the efolds for the post - bounce inflationary period is large enough .
after that , these modes will reenter the hubble radius at late times after the slow - roll expanding phase has finished . in our model .
] therefore , we can classify the tensor perturbations with different comoving wave numbers @xmath85 to two categories , as the two lines sketched in fig .
[ fig3:sketch ] .
the blue line denotes a mode with a scale @xmath85 which is large enough to keep it inside the hubble radius through the contracting phase and the bounce , and then escape outside during the post - bounce inflationary period ; the green line consists of a mode with small @xmath85 so that it exits the hubble radius in the contracting phase , then is pushed inside during the bounce and soon is pulled outside before the slow - roll expanding phase happens . due to the symmetry of @xmath86 , we can express the two polarizations as one function @xmath87 . neglecting the anisotropic stress tensor in the very early universe , we obtain the equation of motion for @xmath88 : @xmath89 following the background evolution of the universe , we obtain three solutions of gravitational waves similar to what we did with scalar perturbations . for
the universe which is contracting with its eos oscillating around @xmath13 , we have @xmath90 \nonumber\\&&+b^t_kh_{\frac{3}{2}}^{(2)}[k(\tau-\tilde\tau_{b- } ) ] \bigg\}~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath91 . here
@xmath92 and @xmath93 are the @xmath94-th hankel function of the first kind and second kind respectively .
besides , the parameters @xmath95 and @xmath96 can be determined by the initial condition for gravitational waves , which is usually taken as bunch - davies vacuum @xmath97 .
so we have @xmath98 and @xmath99 .
therefore , the asymptotic forms of the solution to the tensor perturbation in the contracting phase is @xmath100 when the universe undergoes the bouncing phase , we have the approximate relation that @xmath101 . to solve eq .
( [ eomt ] ) , we have @xmath102+d^t_k\sin[l(\tau-\tau_b)],~~{\rm k^2\geq\frac{y}{2 } } ; \\ \\ c^t_ke^{l(\tau-\tau_b)}+d^t_ke^{-l(\tau-\tau_b)},~~{\rm k^2<\frac{y}{2
} } , \end{array } \right .
\label{v2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we define @xmath103 . since the hubble parameter approaches zero when the universe is bouncing from a contraction to an expanding phase
, all the modes of the perturbations would return to the sub - hubble region .
however , from the above solution we interestingly find that , @xmath104 and @xmath105 are comparable . after the bounce , the slow - roll expanding phase takes place which drives the universe to inflate like a de - sitter spacetime . in this case , the solution to the gravitational waves is given by @xmath106 \nonumber\\ & & + f^t_kh_{\nu}^{(2)}[k(\tau-\tilde\tau_{b+ } ) ] \bigg\}~,\label{v3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath107 .
this solution has an asymptotic form , @xmath108 after the modes exit the horizon .
having obtained the solutions of the tensor perturbations in different phases , now we need to match these solutions and determine the coefficients @xmath109 , @xmath110 , @xmath111 and @xmath112 respectively .
this procedure is much similar to the matching process of scalar perturbations as done in the previous section . for a non - singular bounce scenario such as the quintom bounce model
, the continuity of background evolution implies that both @xmath88 and @xmath113 are able to pass through the bounce smoothly .
so we match @xmath88 and @xmath113 in ( [ v1 ] ) and ( [ v2 ] ) on the surface @xmath114 , and those in ( [ v2 ] ) and ( [ v3 ] ) on the surface @xmath115 . with these matching conditions
, we can determine all the coefficients and finally get @xmath116 .
however , as what we have analyzed at the beginning of this section , there are two paths for the tensor perturbations to evolve from a contracting phase to an expanding phase .
so there are two possible results for @xmath116 .
for the first case , the comoving wave number is large enough so that the tensor perturbations have never escape outside the hubble radius , thus we have @xmath117 where @xmath118 , and @xmath119 .
for the second case where the modes of gravitational waves are in small @xmath85 region , the expression @xmath116 is given by @xmath120 based on the above analysis , now we are able to derive the primordial power spectrum of gravitational waves . from the definition of eq .
( [ tensor power ] ) , the primordial power spectrum is given by @xmath121 from eqs .
( [ ef1 ] ) and ( [ ef2 ] ) , we can read that the spectrum are scale - invariant both at the large @xmath85 and small @xmath85 region , but oscillate when @xmath85 is near to a critical value @xmath122 . to illustrate the above analysis clearly , we do the numerical calculation and plot the results of primordial tensor power spectrum and the corresponding spectral index in fig . [ fig4:pnt ] . and the spectral index @xmath78 of tensor perturbations in our model .
the blue dash curve give the primordial power spectrum and the spectral index in a single scalar inflation model .
in the figure , we take the values of parameters the same as in fig .
[ fig1:background ] . ]
one can see that in fig .
[ fig4:pnt ] , when the value of @xmath85 is large enough , the red solid lines converge at the blue dash lines with an oscillation .
the amplitude of the oscillation gets the largest value when @xmath85 approaches the neighborhood of the critical value @xmath122 , and soon drop down to a minimal value when @xmath85 gets smaller .
this damping effect is caused by the modified dispersion relation of the tensor perturbations when they pass through the bouncing phase .
however , when the comoving wave number @xmath85 gets even smaller , the power spectrum is able to climb up and finally reaches a certain value with its spectral index returning to zero again . in the above section we discussed the behavior of tensor perturbations exhibited in primordial power spectrum and the spectral index .
however , we are more interested in how to recognize these perturbations in the gwb nowadays .
since the primordial gravitational waves are distributed in every frequency , once the effective co - moving wave number is less than @xmath123 , the corresponding mode of gravitational waves would escape the horizon and be frozen until it reenters the horizon .
the relation between the time when tensor perturbations exit the horizon and the time when they return is @xmath124 .
therefore , we have the conclusion that , the earlier the perturbations escape the horizon , the later they re - enter it .
moreover , once the effective co - moving wave number is larger than @xmath123 , the perturbations begin to oscillate like the plane wave , as shown in fig .
[ fig3:sketch ] . to relate the power spectrum observed today to the primordial one
, one can define a transfer function @xmath125 , given by refs .
@xcite : @xmath126 where @xmath127 is determined by the eos of the universe , @xmath128 is the redshift at the moment @xmath21 and @xmath129 is the redshift when the @xmath85 mode of gravitational wave reenters the horizon . here
the factor @xmath130 comes from the damping effect of freely streaming neutrinos @xcite .
moreover , the factor @xmath131 describes the redshift - suppressing effect on the primordial gravitational waves .
the rest factor shows that , when the gravitational waves reenter the horizon , there is a wall " lying on the horizon which affects the tensor spectrum .
considering today our universe is dominated by dark energy of which the eos is @xmath132 , we are able to obtain today s transfer function .
then we can get today s tensor power spectrum @xmath133 where @xmath134 represents the hubble parameter in the inflationary stage .
eventually , the present energy spectrum of gwb is given by @xmath135 .
in fig . [ fig5:omega ] we plot the numerical results of the energy spectrum in our model .
one can see that , when the frequency of gwb is large enough , the tensor energy spectrum of our model would agree with the prediction of the single scalar inflationary model .
however , when the frequency becomes smaller , the physics of a bounce begins to affect the behavior of the gwb .
moreover , there is an interesting sunken area in the middle band .
this sunken signal is resulted from the modified dispersion relation of the tensor perturbations when they pass through the bouncing phase . in our model .
the blue dash curve gives the energy spectrum in a single scalar inflation model . in the figure
, we take the values of parameters the same as in fig .
[ fig1:background ] . ]
bouncing cosmology , due to the avoidance of the initial singularity , has attracted a lot of interests in the literature @xcite ( and see ref .
@xcite for a recent review ) .
however , since it happens in extremely high energy regime , we hardly observe a bounce by experiments directly .
so it is a debate whether a bounce has taken place or not . to find the evidences of a bounce
, we need to know what can a bounce leave for observations .
this question is still discussed drastically in the literature , and one potential clue is to study the primordial gravitational fluctuations . in the context of the pre - big - bang scenario and in the cyclic / ekpyrotic cosmology ,
the primordial curvature perturbation strongly depends on the physics at the epoch of thermalization , and thus an uncertainty of a thermalized surface is involved @xcite . in the frame of loop quantum cosmology , it is argued that fluctuations before and after the bounce are largely independent @xcite ( yet see ref .
@xcite for some criticisms ) .
we in this paper have studied the perturbation theory of a quintom bounce model detailedly and show that there are some imprints of the bounce on cmb observations at large scales . in the main content we have analyzed both the linear and non - linear evolutions of scalar modes , and the tensor perturbations are also considered .
the model we considered is constructed by a double field quintom model with a coleman - weinberg potential .
we firstly have reviewed the background dynamics of this model , and obtained a scale - invariant scalar spectrum in virtue of an asymmetry of the background evolution around the bounce point .
a similar but more phenomenological scenario has been studied in refs .
@xcite as a possible solution to the suppressed low multi - poles of the cmb anisotropies .
moreover , since the gravitational perturbations in sub - hubble region would change their propagations when pass through the surface between the contracting phase and the bounce , there would be an oscillation signature generated both on the linear scalar modes and non - linear ones . we have also calculated the non - gaussianity and shown that the maximal value of non - linear parameter @xmath3 predicted by our model is mildly bigger than the usual one in single scalar slow - roll inflation , but the central value is still suppressed by the slow - roll parameters .
so we expect that a large non - gaussianity might be generated by other mechanisms@xcite in the frame of quintom bounce .
we in the last part of this paper focus on the behavior of the gravitational waves in quintom bounce . due to the effects of a bounce ,
the solution of the tensor perturbation is quite different from the usual one . in our analysis
, we find that the physics of a bounce would affect the evolution of primordial tensor perturbations at large scales of the universe , which corresponds to the physics in very early time .
the behavior of the energy spectrum of the gwb in our model is similar to that in the single scalar inflationary model in high - frequency regime .
however , for low - frequency regime the difference becomes larger .
moreover , there is a sunken area in the middle band which links high - frequency regime and low - frequency regime . if these signals would be detected , these might act as a smoking gun to the bouncing cosmology .
we thank hong li , mingzhe li , jie liu , yun - song piao , taotao qiu and jun - qing xia for helpful discussions . this work is supported in part by national natural science foundation of china under grant nos . 10533010 and 10675136 and by the chinese academy of science under grant no .
kjcx3-syw - n2 .
a. borde and a. vilenkin , phys .
* 72 * , 3305 ( 1994 ) .
g. veneziano , phys . lett .
b * 265 * , 287 ( 1991 ) ; m. gasperini and g. veneziano , astropart .
* 1 * , 317 ( 1993 ) ; m. gasperini and g. veneziano , phys .
rept . * 373 * , 1 ( 2003 ) .
j. khoury , b. a. ovrut , p. j. steinhardt and n. turok , phys .
d * 64 * , 123522 ( 2001 ) ; j. khoury , b. a. ovrut , n. seiberg , p. j. steinhardt and n. turok , phys .
d * 65 * , 086007 ( 2002 ) ; p.
j. steinhardt and n. turok , phys .
d * 65 * , 126003 ( 2002 ) .
m. bojowald , phys .
* 86 * , 5227 ( 2001 ) .
r. brustein and r. madden , phys .
d * 57 * , 712 ( 1998 ) .
t. biswas , a. mazumdar and w. siegel , jcap * 0603 * , 009 ( 2006 ) ; t. biswas , r. brandenberger , a. mazumdar and w. siegel , jcap * 0712 * , 011 ( 2007 ) . m. novello and s. e. p. bergliaffa , phys .
* 463 * , 127 ( 2008 ) .
y. f. cai , t. qiu , y. s. piao , m. li and x. m. zhang , jhep * 0710 * , 071 ( 2007 ) . b. feng , x. l. wang and x. m. zhang , phys .
lett . * b607 * , 35 ( 2005 ) . y. f. cai , t. qiu , r. brandenberger , y. s. piao and x. zhang , jcap * 0803 * , 013 ( 2008 ) . l. r. abramo and p. peter , jcap * 0709 * , 001 ( 2007 ) .
r. brandenberger , h. firouzjahi and o. saremi , jcap * 0711 * , 028 ( 2007 ) .
r. brustein , m. gasperini , m. giovannini , v. f. mukhanov and g. veneziano , phys .
d * 51 * , 6744 ( 1995 ) .
d. h. lyth , phys .
b * 524 * , 1 ( 2002 ) .
j. c. hwang , phys .
d * 65 * , 063514 ( 2002 ) .
f. finelli and r. brandenberger , phys .
d * 65 * , 103522 ( 2002 ) .
y. f. cai , t. t. qiu , j. q. xia , h. li and x. m. zhang , arxiv:0808.0819 [ astro - ph ] .
n. bartolo , e. komatsu , s. matarrese and a. riotto , phys .
rept . * 402 * , 103 ( 2004 ) .
j. m. maldacena , jhep * 0305 * , 013 ( 2003 ) .
v. acquaviva , n. bartolo , s. matarrese and a. riotto , nucl .
b * 667 * , 119 ( 2003 ) .
k. koyama , s. mizuno , f. vernizzi and d. wands , jcap * 0711 * , 024 ( 2007 ) .
e. i. buchbinder , j. khoury and b. a. ovrut , phys .
lett . * 100 * , 171302 ( 2008 ) .
j. l. lehners and p. j. steinhardt , phys .
d * 77 * , 063533 ( 2008 ) ; j. l. lehners and p. j. steinhardt , phys .
d * 78 * , 023506 ( 2008 ) .
y. s. piao , nucl .
b * 803 * , 194 ( 2008 ) ; y. s. piao , arxiv:0807.3813 [ gr - qc ] .
b. abbott _ et al .
_ [ ligo scientific collaboration ] , phys .
* 94 * , 181103 ( 2005 ) .
l. verde , h. peiris and r. jimenez , jcap * 0601 * , 019 ( 2006 )
. t. l. smith , m. kamionkowski and a. cooray , phys .
d * 73 * , 023504 ( 2006 ) .
l. a. boyle , p. j. steinhardt and n. turok , phys .
lett . * 96 * , 111301 ( 2006 ) .
_ , task force on cosmic microwave research , ( www.science.doe.gov/hep/tfcrreport.pdf ) .
a. a. starobinsky , jetp lett .
* 30 * , 682 ( 1979 ) [ pisma zh .
* 30 * , 719 ( 1979 ) ] ; v. a. rubakov , m. v. sazhin and a. v. veryaskin , phys .
b * 115 * , 189 ( 1982 ) ; r. fabbri and m. d. pollock , phys . lett .
b * 125 * , 445 ( 1983 ) ; l. f. abbott and m. b. wise , nucl .
b * 244 * , 541 ( 1984 ) .
e. d. stewart and d. h. lyth , phys .
b * 302 * , 171 ( 1993 ) .
l. a. boyle , p. j. steinhardt and n. turok , phys .
d * 69 * , 127302 ( 2004 ) .
s. r. coleman and e. weinberg , phys .
d * 7 * , 1888 ( 1973 ) .
j. q. xia , y. f. cai , t. t. qiu , g. b. zhao and x. zhang , arxiv : astro - ph/0703202 ; y. f. cai , h. li , y. s. piao and x. m. zhang , phys .
b * 646 * , 141 ( 2007 ) ; y. f. cai , m. z. li , j. x. lu , y. s. piao , t. t. qiu and x. m. zhang , phys .
b * 651 * , 1 ( 2007 ) .
n. deruelle and v. f. mukhanov , phys .
d * 52 * , 5549 ( 1995 ) .
r. durrer and f. vernizzi , phys .
d * 66 * , 083503 ( 2002 ) .
e. j. copeland and d. wands , jcap * 0706 * , 014 ( 2007 ) .
u. h. danielsson , phys .
d * 66 * , 023511 ( 2002 ) .
r. easther , b. r. greene , w. h. kinney and g. shiu , phys .
d * 66 * , 023518 ( 2002 ) .
x. chen , m. x. huang , s. kachru and g. shiu , jcap * 0701 * , 002 ( 2007 ) .
r. holman and a. j. tolley , jcap * 0805 * , 001 ( 2008 ) .
b. chen , y. wang and w. xue , jcap * 0805 * , 014 ( 2008 ) ; w. xue and b. chen , arxiv:0806.4109 [ hep - th ] .
y. f. cai and y. s. piao , phys .
b * 657 * , 1 ( 2007 ) .
l. a. boyle and p. j. steinhardt , phys .
d * 77 * , 063504 ( 2008 ) .
s. weinberg , phys .
d * 69 * , 023503 ( 2004 ) .
p. peter and n. pinto - neto , phys .
d * 66 * , 063509 ( 2002 ) . m. gasperini , m. giovannini and g. veneziano , phys .
b * 569 * , 113 ( 2003 ) .
l. e. allen and d. wands , phys . rev .
d * 70 * , 063515 ( 2004 ) .
y. s. piao , phys .
d * 70 * , 101302 ( 2004 ) ; y. s. piao and y. z. zhang , nucl .
b * 725 * , 265 ( 2005 ) .
p. creminelli and l. senatore , jcap * 0711 * , 010 ( 2007 ) .
e. i. buchbinder , j. khoury and b. a. ovrut , phys .
d * 76 * , 123503 ( 2007 ) ; e. i. buchbinder , j. khoury and b. a. ovrut , jhep * 0711 * , 076 ( 2007 ) . c. armendariz - picon and p. b. greene , gen .
grav . * 35 * , 1637 ( 2003 ) ; y. f. cai and j. wang , class .
grav . * 25 * , 165014 ( 2008 ) ; s. alexander and t. biswas , arxiv:0807.4468 [ hep - th ] ; m. r. setare , j. sadeghi and a. banijamali , arxiv:0807.0077 [ hep - th ] .
a. corichi and p. singh , phys .
lett . * 100 * , 161302 ( 2008 ) .
y. s. piao , b. feng and x. m. zhang , phys .
d * 69 * , 103520 ( 2004 ) ; y. s. piao , s. tsujikawa and x. m. zhang , class .
* 21 * , 4455 ( 2004 ) ; j. mielczarek , arxiv:0807.0712 [ gr - qc ] . | we in the paper study the metric perturbations generated in a bouncing universe driven by the quintom matter .
firstly , we review the background evolution of quintom bounce and the power spectrum of scalar perturbations .
secondly , we study the non - gaussianity of curvature perturbations and then calculate the tensor perturbations of the model . |
in @xcite it was shown that the combinatorics of the subtraction procedure inherent to perturbative renormalization gives rise to a hopf algebra @xmath0 which provides a conceptual framework to understand the intricacies of the forest formula of zimmermann . in @xcite
, it was shown that the delicate computational problem which arises from the transverse hypoelliptic theory of foliations , as formulated in noncommutative geometry , can only be settled thanks to a hopf algebra @xmath1 associated to each integer codimension .
this hopf algebra reduces transverse geometry , to a universal geometry of affine nature .
the aim of this paper is to establish a close relation between the above hopf algebras @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
we shall first recall the first results of @xcite which describe in the simplest case of codimension @xmath2 the presentation of the hopf algebra @xmath1 .
we shall then explain the origin of the hopf algebra @xmath0 from the renormalization of the divergences of qft and show following @xcite how @xmath3 is used in concrete problems of renormalization theory .
in the appendix we include the case of overlapping divergences .
we then give the presentation of the simplest model of @xmath0 namely the hopf algebra of rooted trees , and show that it is uniquely characterized as the solution of a universal problem in hochschild cohomology .
we then determine the formal lie algebra @xmath4 such that @xmath0 is obtained as the dual of the envelopping algebra of this lie algebra .
it turns out to be a refinement of the lie algebra of formal vector fields in one dimension .
we then show that many of the results of @xcite actually extend to this refinement of formal vector fields .
these results indicate that parallel to the ordinary differential calculus which underlies the transverse structure of foliations , the recipes of renormalization theory should be considered as a refined form of calculus and should be understandable on a conceptual ground .
concretely , in the first section we show in theorem ( 8) that the algebraic rules of the hopf algebra @xmath1 are the expression of the group law of composition of diffeomorphisms of @xmath5 in terms of the coordinates @xmath6 given by the taylor expansion of @xmath7 at @xmath8
. in particular this shows that the antipode in @xmath1 is , modulo a change of variables , the same as the operation of inversion of a formal power series for the composition law . in the second section we begin by the simplest and most explicit examples of divergent integrals of the kind that are met in quantum field theory computations .
we describe in this toy case the explicit counterterm construction and the immediate problem which arises from divergent subintegrations and explain how the hopf algebra @xmath0 finds the combinatorial solution of the subtraction problem from its antipode .
we next explain why the same holds in qft ( the treatment of overlapping divergences is postponed to the appendix ) . in the third section we exhibit the precise relation and analogy between @xmath0 and @xmath1 to the point that the antipode in @xmath0 appears as a direct analogue of the antipode in @xmath1 which we understood above as the inversion of formal power series .
the key nuance between the two hopf algebras is that where @xmath1 uses integers to label the taylor expansion , the hopf algebra @xmath0 uses rooted trees for labels .
the computation of the local index formula for transversally hypoelliptic operators ( @xcite ) is governed by a very specific hopf algebra @xmath1 , which only depends upon the codimension @xmath9 of the foliation .
the structure of this hopf algebra , its relation with the lie algebra of formal vector fields as well as the computation of its cyclic cohomology have been done in @xcite . in order to pursue the analogy between this development and the discovery by d. k. ( @xcite ) of the hopf algebra underlying renormalization
, we shall recall here in all details the presentation and first properties of the hopf algebra @xmath1 in the simplest case of codimension one .
useless to say this does not dispense one from consulting @xcite , in particular in connection with the specific representation of @xmath1 on crossed product algebras and the corresponding analysis .
we first define a bialgebra by generators and relations . as an algebra
we view @xmath1 as the envelopping algebra of the lie algebra which is the linear span of @xmath10 , @xmath11 , @xmath6 , @xmath12 with the relations , @xmath13 = x , [ y,\delta_n ] = n \ , \delta_n , [ \delta_n , \delta_m ] = 0 \ \forall \ , n , m \geq 1 , [ x,\delta_n ] = \delta_{n+1 } \ \forall \ , n \geq 1 \ , . \label{eq1}\ ] ] the coproduct @xmath14 in @xmath1 is defined by @xmath15 with @xmath16 defined by induction using ( [ eq1 ] ) and the equality , @xmath17 * lemma 1 . * _ the above presentation defines a hopf algebra @xmath18 . _
* one checks that the lie algebra relations ( [ eq1 ] ) are fulfilled by the elements @xmath19 , @xmath20 , @xmath21 , so that , by the universal property of the envelopping algebra , @xmath14 extends to an algebra homomorphism , @xmath22 and using the uniqueness of the extension , one also checks the coassociativity .
one needs to show the existence of the antipode @xmath23 .
it is characterized abstractly as the inverse of the element @xmath24 in the algebra of linear maps @xmath25 from @xmath1 to @xmath1 endowed with the product @xmath26 a simple computation shows that @xmath23 is the unique antiautomorphism of @xmath27 such that , @xmath28 note that the square of @xmath23 is not the identity .
@xmath29 in order to understand the hopf algebra @xmath1 , we first analyse the commutative subalgebra generated by the @xmath6 . for each @xmath9
we let @xmath30 be the subalgebra generated by @xmath31 , @xmath32 we let @xmath33 be the ideal , @xmath34 by induction on @xmath9 one proves the following * lemma 2 . *
_ for each @xmath9 there exists @xmath35 such that @xmath36 . _
* one has @xmath37 , and a simple computation shows that , @xmath38 and , @xmath39 in general , one determines @xmath40 by induction , using @xmath41 + n \ , \delta_1 \otimes \delta_n + [ \delta_1 \otimes y , r_{n-1 } ] \ , .
\label{eq11}\ ] ] since @xmath42 \subset { \cal h}_{n,0}$ ] and @xmath43 \subset { \cal h}_{n-1,0 } \subset{\cal h}_{n,0}$ ] , one gets that @xmath44 .
@xmath29 the equality ( [ eq10 ] ) shows that @xmath30 is not cocommutative for @xmath45 .
however , since it is commutative , we shall determine the corresponding lie algebra , using the milnor - moore theorem .
let @xmath46 be the lie algebra of jets of order @xmath47 of vector fields on the line , @xmath48 modulo @xmath49 .
* proposition 3 . * _ the hopf algebra @xmath30 is the dual of the envelopping agebra @xmath50 , @xmath51 . _
* for each @xmath52 we introduce a linear form @xmath53 on @xmath30 @xmath54 one has by construction , @xmath55 note that @xmath56 , @xmath57 is the counit of @xmath30 , @xmath58 ( check both sides on a monomial @xmath59 . )
thus in the dual agebra @xmath60 one can write ( [ eq13 ] ) as @xmath61 moreover the @xmath53 form a basis of the linear space of solutions of ( [ eq15 ] ) and we just need to determine the lie algebra structure determined by the bracket .
let , @xmath62 let us show that @xmath63 = 0 $ ] if @xmath64 , and that , @xmath65 = ( \ell - k ) \
, z'_{k+\ell , n } \ , , \label{eq17}\ ] ] if @xmath66 .
let @xmath59 be a monomial .
we need to compute @xmath67 .
one has @xmath68 we look for the terms in @xmath69 or @xmath70 and take the difference .
the latter is non zero only if all @xmath71 except @xmath72 .
moreover since @xmath73 is homogeneous of degree @xmath74 one gets @xmath75 and in particular @xmath76 = 0 $ ] if @xmath77 .
one then computes by induction using ( [ eq11 ] ) the bilinear part of @xmath73 .
one has @xmath78 , and from ( [ eq11 ] ) @xmath79 + n \
, \delta_1 \otimes \delta_n \ , .
\label{eq18}\ ] ] this gives @xmath80 thus the coefficient of @xmath69 is @xmath81 and we get @xmath82 = ( c_{k+\ell}^{\ell - 1 } - c_{k+\ell}^{k - 1 } ) \ , z_{k+\ell , n } \ , .
\label{eq20}\ ] ] one has @xmath83 thus one gets ( [ eq17 ] ) .
the elements @xmath84 of the lie algebra @xmath46 are related by ( [ eq16 ] ) to @xmath85 which satisfy the lie algebra relations ( [ eq17 ] ) .
the result then follows from the milnor - moore theorem .
@xmath29 the @xmath46 form a projective system of lie algebras , with limit the lie algebra @xmath86 of formal vector fields which vanish at order 2 at 0 .
thus the inductive limit @xmath87 of the hopf algebras @xmath30 is , @xmath88 the lie algebra @xmath86 is a _ graded _
lie algebra , with one parameter group of automorphisms , @xmath89 which extends to @xmath90 and transposes to @xmath91 as @xmath92 , a \rangle = \left\langle p , { \partial \over \partial \
, \alpha_t \ , ( a)_{t=0 } \right\rangle \qquad \forall \ , p \in { \cal h}^1 \ , \ a \in { \cal u } ( { \cal a}^1 ) \ , . \label{eq23}\ ] ] indeed @xmath93 is a one parameter group of automorphisms of @xmath87 such that @xmath94 now , using the poincar - birkhoff - witt theorem , we take the basis of @xmath90 given by the monomials , @xmath95 to each @xmath96 one associates the formal power series @xmath97 in the commuting variables @xmath98 , @xmath99 .
it follows from @xcite 2.7.5 that we obtain in this way an isomorphism of the algebra of polynomials @xmath100 on the algebra of polynomials in the @xmath98 s . to determine the formula for @xmath6 in terms of the @xmath98 s
, we just need to compute @xmath101 note that , by homogeneity , ( [ eq27 ] ) vanishes unless @xmath102 . for @xmath103 , we get @xmath104 where @xmath105 is the above isomorphism .
we determine @xmath106 by induction , using the derivation @xmath107 ( which corresponds to @xmath108 $ ] ) .
one has by construction , @xmath109 where @xmath110 is the transpose of @xmath111 . by definition of @xmath112
as a linear form ( [ eq12 ] ) one has , @xmath113 moreover the compatibility of @xmath110 with the coproduct of @xmath87 is given by @xmath114 where @xmath115 is the natural action of the algebra @xmath116 on its dual @xmath117 * lemma 4 . * _ when restricted to @xmath118 , @xmath110 is the unique derivation , with values in @xmath90 satisfying ( [ eq32 ] ) , moreover @xmath119 _ * proof . *
the equality @xmath120 shows that @xmath115 is a derivation of @xmath121 .
one has @xmath122 for @xmath123 so that @xmath124 on @xmath118 and the first statement follows from ( [ eq31 ] ) and ( [ eq32 ] ) .
the second statement follows from , @xmath125 which one proves by induction on @xmath126 using ( [ eq32 ] ) .
@xmath29 motivated by the first part of the lemma , we enlarge the lie algebra @xmath86 by adjoining an element @xmath127 such that , @xmath128 = z_{n-1 } \qquad \forall \ , n \geq 2 \ , , \label{eq35}\ ] ] we then define @xmath129 by @xmath130 = z_0 \ , \ [ z_0 , z_k ] = k \ , z_k \ , . \label{eq36}\ ] ] the obtained lie algebra @xmath131 , is the lie algebra of formal vector fields with @xmath132 , @xmath133 and as above @xmath134 .
let @xmath135 be the left ideal in @xmath136 generated by @xmath127 , @xmath129 , * proposition 5 .
* _ the linear map @xmath137 is uniquely determined by the equality @xmath138 $ ] mod @xmath135 . _
* let us compare @xmath110 with the bracket with @xmath127 .
by lemma 4 , they agree on @xmath118 .
let us compute @xmath139 $ ] .
one has @xmath140 = { m ( m-1 ) \over 2 } \ , z_1^{m-1 } +
, z_1^{m-1 } \ , z_0 \ , .
\label{eq37}\ ] ] for each monomial @xmath141 one has @xmath142
\in { \cal l}$ ] .
thus this holds for any @xmath143 .
moreover , using the basis of @xmath136 given by the @xmath144 we see that @xmath136 is the direct sum @xmath145 . @xmath29 we now define a linear form @xmath146 on @xmath136 by @xmath147 and @xmath148 .
* lemma 6 . *
_ for any @xmath12 one has _
@xmath149 \ldots ] ) \qquad \forall \ , a \in { \cal u } ( { \cal a}^1 ) \ , .\ ] ] * proof .
* let us first check it for @xmath103 .
we let @xmath150 .
then the degree of @xmath151 is @xmath152 and @xmath153 ) \ne 0 $ ] requires @xmath154 so that the only possibility is @xmath155 , @xmath156 . in this case one
gets @xmath157 ) = l_0 ( z_0 ) = 1 $ ] .
thus by ( [ eq28 ] ) we get the equality of lemma 6 for @xmath103 . for the general case note first that @xmath135 is stable under right multiplication by @xmath127 and hence by the derivation @xmath158 $ ] .
thus one has @xmath159 \ldots ] \ \hbox{mod } \ {
\cal l } \qquad \forall \ , a \in { \cal u } ( { \cal a}^1 ) \ , .
\label{eq39}\ ] ] now for @xmath160 one has @xmath153 )
indeed writing @xmath161 with @xmath162 , @xmath163 , one has @xmath164 = [ z_{-1 } , b ] \ , c + b \ , [ z_{-1 } , c]$ ] . since @xmath162 and
@xmath165 $ ] has strictly negative degree one has @xmath166)$ ] @xmath167 .
let @xmath168 be a non zero component of @xmath169 $ ] , then unless all @xmath170 are 0 it contributes by 0 to @xmath171 \
, c)$ ] . but
@xmath169 \in { \cal u } ( { \cal a}^0)_0 $ ] has no constant term .
thus one has @xmath172 )
= 0 \qquad \forall \ , a = z_n^{a_n } \ldots z_1^{a_1 } \ , z_0^{a_0 } \ , z_{-1}^{a_{-1 } } \label{eq40}\ ] ] except if all @xmath71 , @xmath173 and @xmath155 .
@xmath157 ) = 1 $ ] . using ( [ eq31 ] ) one has @xmath174 and the lemma follows .
@xmath29 one can now easily compute the first values of @xmath175 , @xmath176 , @xmath177 , @xmath178 , @xmath179 .
the affine structure provided by the @xmath6 has the following compatibility with left multiplication in @xmath90 .
* lemma 7 . * a ) _ one has @xmath180 , @xmath181 . _
\b ) _ for fixed @xmath182 there are @xmath183 such that _
* proof . *
a ) by induction using ( [ eq7 ] ) .
b ) follows , using @xmath185 .
@xmath29 the antipode @xmath23 in @xmath90 is the unique antiautomorphism such that @xmath186 it is non trivial to express in terms of the coordinates @xmath6 .
in fact if we use the basis @xmath187 of @xmath86 but in reverse order to construct the map @xmath105 we obtain a map @xmath188 whose first values are @xmath189 , @xmath190 , @xmath191 , @xmath192
. one has @xmath193 so that @xmath194 @xmath195 with @xmath196 in the latter expression .
thus @xmath197 , @xmath198 , @xmath199 , @xmath200 .
we thus get @xmath201 the meaning of all the above computations and their relation to the standard calculus of taylor expansions is clarified by the following theorem ( @xcite ) .
* theorem 8 . *
_ let @xmath202 be the group of formal diffeomorphisms of @xmath203 , of the form @xmath204 . for each @xmath9 ,
let @xmath205 be the functional on @xmath202 defined by , _
@xmath206 _ the equality @xmath207 determines a canonical isomorphism @xmath208 of the hopf algebra @xmath87 with the hopf algebra of coordinates on the group @xmath202 . _ we refer to theorem 8 of @xcite for the proof , as well as for the more elaborate structure of the hopf algebra @xmath1 .
this theorem certainly shows that the antipode , i.e. the map @xmath209 is certainly non trivial to compute .
note also that the expression @xmath210 is uniquely characterized by @xmath211 which suggests to define higher analogues of the schwartzian as @xmath212 .
in this section we want to motivate the hopf algebra structure behind the process of renormalization in quantum field theories ( qfts ) @xcite and show how relations to the hopf algebra of the previous section emerge .
the renormalization procedure appears as the cure for the disease caused by the unavoidable presence of uv divergences in qfts which describe the physics of local quantized fields .
such qfts describe successfully all known particle physics phenomenology .
the point of departure of the renormalization procedure is to alter the original lagrangian by an infinite series of counterterms labelled by feynman graphs , whose sole purpose is to cancel the uv - divergences coming from the presence of ill - defined integrals in the perturbative expansion of the theory .
recall that the perturbative expansion of the functional integral appears as a sum labelled by feynman graphs @xmath213 .
to each of these graphs corresponds an integral @xmath214 which is in general ill - defined . to compensate for the resulting infinities
one adds to the original lagrangian @xmath146 which appears as the argument of the exponential , an infinite series of counterterms @xmath215 , each term in the series corresponding to a feynman graph @xmath213 .
the difficulty in finding the cut - off dependent counterterm lagrangian @xmath216 comes only from the presence of ill - defined subintegrations ( usually dubbed subdivergences ) in the integral @xmath214 . indeed in the special case of a diagram without subdivergences
the counterterm is simply ( in the ms scheme ) just the pole part of @xmath214 .
as soon as subdivergences are present the extraction of @xmath217 is much more complicated since we want to take into account the previous subtractions which is necessary to maintain locality in the theory .
this obviously generates complicated combinatorial problems , which for the first time , acquire mathematical meaning thanks to the hopf algebra @xmath0 .
it is possible to study the basic properties of the renormalization procedure with the help of toy models , to which we now turn . in the following
we will consider integrals of the form @xmath218 for @xmath219 , which are to be regarded as functions of the parameter @xmath220 .
as it stands such an integral is ill - defined , due to its divergence at the upper boundary .
power counting reveals the presence of a logarithmic singularity , and in this respect the integral behaves no better or worse than a logarithmic divergent integral in qft , which one typically confronts due to the presence of uv divergences in loop integrations .
we will introduce a regularization , @xmath221 where @xmath222 is a small positive parameter .
we now easily evaluate the above integral @xmath223 where the presence of the pole term @xmath224 indicates the _ uv divergence _ in the integral .
, @xmath225 , @xmath226 . ]
the process of renormalization demands the subtraction of this uv divergence , and at this level we can straightforwardly proceed by a simple subtraction @xmath227 which is evidently finite if we send @xmath228 . here , @xmath229 acts as the counterterm for the ill - defined function @xmath230 , and the difference @xmath231 corresponds to the renormalized function associated to @xmath230 .
physicists have good reason to demand that a counterterm like @xmath229 above is independent of the external parameter @xmath220 , as to maintain locality in the theory .
before we explain this in more detail we want to generalize this simple example to the presence of subdivergences .
we consider @xmath232 we say that @xmath233 has the function @xmath234 as a subdivergence , but it still is overall divergent itself .
powercounting reveals that there is a divergent sector when the @xmath235 integration variable tends to infinity for any fixed @xmath236 , and when @xmath237 tend to infinity jointly .
there are no divergences when @xmath235 is kept fixed and @xmath236 tends to infinity , though .
all the divergences are of logarithmic nature .
having successfully eliminated the divergence in the previous example by a naive subtraction procedure , it is interesting to see if we can eliminate the divergences in @xmath233 by subtracting @xmath238 : @xmath239\\ & = & -\frac{\log(c)}{\epsilon}+\mbox{finite terms}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] unfortunately , this expression still suffers from a divergence in the @xmath235 integration , and we were thus not successful with this naive attempt . actually , we find that the divergence is @xmath240 .
the parameter @xmath220 in our toy model is the remaining scale of the green function .
in realistic qfts , this scale is furnished typically by an external momentum @xmath241 , say , and divergences of the form @xmath242 are non - local divergences : upon fourier - transformation , they involve the logarithm of a differential operator , for example the logarithm of an external @xmath243 would translate as @xmath244 . such terms can not be absorbed by local counterterms , and are strictly to be avoided if one wants to remain in the context of a local field theory . in the context of field theory , locality restricts counterterms to be polynomial in momenta .
correspondingly , in the context of our toy model , we thus look for counterterms which are at most polynomial in the parameter @xmath220 .
the failure above was twofold : the naive subtraction @xmath245 not only failed to render @xmath233 finite , but also this failure could only be absorbed by a non - local counterterm @xmath246 . to find a local counterterm ,
some more work is needed . following the guidance of field
theory we associate to @xmath233 ( corresponding to a bare green function ) a function which has its subdivergences subtracted ( a transition in field theory achieved by the @xmath247 operation ) : @xmath248.\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the subtraction term @xmath249 involves the _ counterterm _ @xmath229 times the analytic expression , @xmath230 , which we obtain from @xmath233 when we set the subdivergence @xmath234 in @xmath233 to one .
we realize that @xmath250 $ ] is a well - defined finite expression , the finite renormalized green function @xmath251 , @xmath252\right.\\ & & \left .- b(\epsilon,1-\epsilon)\left[b(2\epsilon,1 - 2\epsilon)- b(\epsilon,1-\epsilon)\right]\right\}\\ & = & \frac{1}{2}\log^2(c),\end{aligned}\ ] ] and thus identify @xmath253\ ] ] with the counterterm associated to @xmath233 .
note that @xmath254 , by construction .
the renormalized green function @xmath251 becomes a power series in @xmath255 ( without constant term ) .
note further that we can write an integral representation for it which eliminates the necessity to introduce a regularization at all : @xmath256- \frac{1}{x+1}\left[\frac{1}{y+x}-\frac{1}{y+1}\right]\right]dydx.\ ] ] this could be directly obtained following the bphz approach , and what we have just seen is the equivalence between on - shell renormalization ( subtraction at the on - shell value @xmath257 ) and the bphz renormalization in the toy model .
the above example shows how to find a local counterterm for an ill - defined integral with ill - defined subintegrations .
we first eliminated the ill - defined subintegration by a counterterm , and then proceeded to construct the counterterm for the integral as a whole . in qft one
proceeds in the same manner .
a bare green - function , given by an ill - defined integral , will suffer from a plethora of ill - defined subintegrations in general .
these subintegrations can be disjoint , nested or overlapping @xcite .
we will see later that the overlapping case resolves into the other ones .
this result was effectively already obtained in @xcite , and also known to others . an example how to resolve overlapping divergences in the case of @xmath258 theory in six dimensions
will be given in an appendix .
thus , we introduce at this stage a generalization of the above toy model allowing only for arbitrary nested or disjoint subdivergences . this motivates to generalize the example to functions @xmath259 of an external parameter @xmath220 , indexed by a rooted tree @xmath260 , due to the fact that any configurations of nested or disjoint subdivergences can be described by a rooted tree . the formal definition of a rooted tree is postponed to the next section , while here we continue to gain experience in the treatment of functions having nested and disjoint subdivergences .
we define for a tree @xmath260 with @xmath126 vertices , enumerated such that the root has number 1 , @xmath261 where @xmath262 is the number of the vertex to which the @xmath263-th vertex is connected via its incoming edge .
we can write this as @xmath264 if the root of @xmath260 connects to @xmath265 trees @xmath266
. fig.([f1 ] ) defines some simple rooted trees .
note that each vertex @xmath267 of the rooted tree corresponds to an integration variable @xmath268 , and that an edge connecting @xmath269 to @xmath267 towards the root indicates that the @xmath98 integration is nested in the @xmath268 integration .
integration variables which correspond to vertices which are not connected by an edge correspond to disjoint integrations .
for the rooted trees defined in fig.([f1 ] ) we find the following analytic expressions : @xmath270 note that @xmath271 .
the previous remarks motivate to introduce a hopf algebra based on rooted trees .
we still postpone all formal definitions to the next section and simply note that a _ rooted tree _
@xmath260 is a connected and simply - connected set of oriented edges and vertices such that there is precisely one distinguished vertex with no incoming edge .
this vertex is called the root of @xmath260 .
further , every edge connects two vertices and the _ fertility _ @xmath273 of a vertex @xmath274 is the number of edges outgoing from @xmath274 .
we consider the algebra of polynomials over @xmath275 in rooted trees .
note that for any rooted tree @xmath260 with root @xmath265 we have @xmath276 trees @xmath277 , @xmath278 , @xmath279 which are the trees attached to @xmath265 .
let @xmath280 be the operator which removes the root @xmath265 from a tree @xmath260 : @xmath281 fig.([guill- ] ) gives an example .
let @xmath282 the operation which maps a monomial of @xmath9 rooted trees to a new rooted tree @xmath260 which has a root @xmath265 with fertility @xmath283 which connects to the @xmath9 roots of @xmath284 .
@xmath285 this is clearly the inverse to the action of @xmath280 .
one has @xmath286 for any rooted tree @xmath260 .
fig.([guill+ ] ) gives an example .
we further set @xmath287 , @xmath288 .
we will introduce a hopf algebra on such rooted trees by using the possibility to cut such trees in pieces .
we start with the most elementary possibility .
elementary cut _ is a cut of a rooted tree at a single chosen edge , as indicated in fig.([ecut ] ) .
we will formalize all these notions in the next section .
by such a cutting procedure , we will obtain the possibility to define a coproduct in a moment , as we can use the resulting pieces on either side of the coproduct .
but before doing so we finally introduce the notion of an _ admissible cut _ , also called a _
simple cut_. it is any assignment of elementary cuts to a rooted tree @xmath260 such that any path from any vertex of the tree to the root has at most one elementary cut . fig.([cut ] ) gives an example .
an admissible cut @xmath289 maps a tree to a monomial in trees .
if the cut @xmath289 contains @xmath9 elementary cuts , it induces a map @xmath290 note that precisely one of these trees @xmath291 will contain the root of @xmath260 .
let us denote this distinguished tree by @xmath292 .
the monomial which is delivered by the @xmath293 other factors is denoted by @xmath294 .
the definitions of @xmath295 can be extended to monomials of trees in the obvious manner , by choosing a cut @xmath296 for every tree @xmath291 in the monomial : @xmath297 we have now collected a sufficient amount of structure to define a hopf algebra on rooted trees .
our aim is to see the correspondence between the hopf algebra formulated on rooted trees and the generation of a local counterterm for the functions @xmath259 introduced above , and finally to see the correspondence between the hopf algebra of rooted trees and the hopf algebra of the previous section .
before we define the hopf algebra of rooted trees , we leave it as an exercise to the reader to convince himself that any admissible cut in a rooted tree determines in the representation on functions @xmath259 a divergent subintegration , and that vice versa any divergent subintegration corresponds to an admissible cut .
for example , the single cut possible at @xmath271 corresponds to the single divergent subintegration in this function .
let us now establish the hopf algebra structure . following
@xcite we define the counit and the coproduct .
the _ counit _
@xmath222 : @xmath298 is simple : @xmath299 for any @xmath300 , @xmath301 the _ coproduct _ @xmath14 is defined by the equations @xmath302,\label{cop2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which defines the coproduct on trees with @xmath9 vertices iteratively through the coproduct on trees with a lesser number of vertices .
the reader should work out the examples in fig.(6 ) himself .
one checks coassociativity of @xmath14 @xcite .
also , we will give a formal proof in the next section .
the following statement follows directly from the results in the next section , but it is instructive to prove it here by elementary means to make contact with the previous section .
we claim that the coproduct can be written as @xmath303 * proof . *
the result is true for the tree @xmath277 having only one vertex .
the induction is on the number of vertices .
we use that @xmath304 has @xmath9 vertices if @xmath260 has @xmath305 .
thus , @xmath306 we used the fact that @xmath307 and that the only cut which distinguishes @xmath308 from @xmath309 is the cut which generates @xmath310 .
@xmath29 note that the above formula can be streamlined .
@xmath311 where the primed sum indicates that we include the empty cut and the full admissible cut in the definition of admissible cuts in the manner indicated in fig.([cop ] ) .
any cut corresponds to a choice of a subset of edges on the set @xmath312 of all edges of a given rooted tree @xmath260 .
the empty cut @xmath313 corresponds to the empty set in this sense .
thus , @xmath314 @xmath315 the full admissible cut @xmath316 is defined by the complementary result : @xmath317 @xmath318 it can be regarded as a cut @xmath220 on the one new edge of @xmath319 , defined as the intersection @xmath320 .
note that @xmath321,\ ] ] with the cut @xmath220 determined as above . in fig.([cop ] ) we indicate the full cut @xmath322 by a dashed box around the rooted tree @xmath323 .
the coproduct introduced here is linear in rooted trees in the right factor and polynomial in the left as one clearly sees in eq.([cop1 ] ) .
this is a fundamental property shared with the coproduct of the previous section .
we will explore this fact in some detail soon .
up to now we have established a bialgebra structure .
it is actually a hopf algebra .
following @xcite we find the antipode @xmath23 as @xmath324r^c(t),\end{aligned}\ ] ] and one immediately checks that @xmath325 & = & t+s(t)+ \sum_{\mbox{\tiny adm.~cuts $ c$ of $ t$}}s[p^c(t)]r^c(t)\\ & = & 0
= \epsilon(t ) \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] to show that @xmath326=0 $ ] one uses induction on the number of vertices @xcite .
we mentioned already that a cut on a tree @xmath260 is given by a subset of the set @xmath312 of the set of edges of @xmath260 .
so far , we allowed for a restricted class of subsets , corresponding to admissible cuts .
we actually enlarged the set already and considered the set @xmath327 of all edges of @xmath319 , to construct the full admissible cut .
we now consider all cuts corresponding to this set , that is all possible subsets of @xmath327 , including the empty set .
these subsets fall in two classes , one which contains the edge @xmath328 , one which does not contain this edge .
cuts corresponding to the first class we call full cuts , cuts not containing this distinguished edge we call normal cuts .
thus , the empty cut is a normal cut .
non - empty normal cuts are also called proper cuts .
note that for a given normal cut @xmath329 and the corresponding full cut @xmath330 we have @xmath331 @xmath332 while @xmath333 , where @xmath334 is the cardinality of the set @xmath289 .
let us give yet another formula to write the antipode , which one easily derives using induction on the number of vertices : @xmath335 this time , we have a non - recursive expression , summing over all full cuts @xmath289 , relaxing the restriction to admissible cuts .
we introduced full cuts so that the overall sign agrees with the number of cuts employed . note that we have for all @xmath336 @xmath337 = \sum_{\mbox{\tiny all cuts
$ c$ of $ t$}}(-1)^{n_c}p^c(t)r^c(t)=0=\epsilon(t),\ ] ] as each cut appears twice , either as a full cut or as a normal cut , with opposite sign , due to the fact that the cardinality of @xmath338 extends the cardinality of @xmath289 by one .
by now we have established a hopf algebra on rooted trees .
it is instructive to calculate the coproduct and antipode for some simple trees .
figs.([cop],[ant ] ) give examples .
note that in fig.([ant ] ) we represented cuts as boxes .
this is possible in a unique way , as each cut on a simply connected rooted tree can be closed in the plane to a box without further intersecting the tree and so that the root is in the exterior of the box . at this time
we can make contact to the previous section .
we note that the sum of the two trees with three vertices behaves under the coproduct as the element @xmath339 in the first section . defining @xmath340
, we find @xmath341 in accordance with eq.([eq10 ] ) in the previous section .
this is no accident , as we will soon see .
the reader should also check the formulas for the coproduct and antipode on examples himself .
it is now not difficult to employ this hopf algebra to regain the local counterterms for the toy model . by construction
, subdivergent sectors correspond to admissible cuts .
also , forests in the sense of renormalization theory are in one to one correspondence with arbitrary cuts , with full cuts corresponding to full forests , and normal cuts to normal forests .
this allows to recover local counterterms from the formula for the antipode in our hopf algebra .
the recursive and the non - recursive manner to write the antipode give rise to two equivalent formulas for the local counterterm , as it is standard in renormalization theory @xcite .
to see all this , note that any cut defines a natural bracket structure on @xmath342 . in a moment
we will see how this fact allows to introduce various different renormalization schemes @xmath343 .
it is instructive to come back to the toy model .
fig.([toyr ] ) summarizes how the standard notions of renormalization theory derive from the hopf algebra of rooted trees . in fig.([toyr ] ) we see the tree @xmath344 , corresponding to the function @xmath345 .
the antipode @xmath346 derives from full cuts which induce the following bracket structure on toy model functions : @xmath347+[[x_{t_2}(c)]x_{t_1}(c)]+[[x_{t_1}(c)]x_{t_2}(c ) ] -[[[x_{t_1}(c ) ] x_{t_1}(c ) ] x_{t_1}(c)].\ ] ] there is a certain freedom how to evaluate this bracket structure .
such a freedom is always there in renormalization .
it corresponds to a choice of renormalization map @xmath343 in the notation of @xcite , while in collins textbook @xcite it corresponds to the choice of the map @xmath348 which extracts the divergent part of a given expression .
as long as the evaluation of the bracket leaves the divergent part unchanged , it corresponds to a valid renormalization scheme , and we obtaine the finite renormalized green function from the consideration of @xmath349 , $ ] which gives rise to the following expression by summing over brackets induced by full and normal cuts @xmath350x_{t_1}(c)-[x_{t_1}(c)]x_{t_2}(c ) + [ [ x_{t_1}(c)]x_{t_1}(c)]x_{t_1}(c)\\ & - & [ x_{t_{3_1}}(c)]+[[x_{t_2}(c)]x_{t_1}(c)]+[[x_{t_1}(c)]x_{t_2}(c ) ] -[[[x_{t_1}(c)]x_{t_1}(c)]x_{t_1}(c)].\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is not to difficult to check the finiteness of this expression for the typical choices of renormalization schemes , on shell , @xmath351=x_t(1),\ ] ] minimal subtraction , @xmath351=pole part_\epsilon(x_t(1)),\ ] ] or bphz type schemes .
note that the only reason that the renormalized function @xmath352 does not vanish identically is that full cuts involve one more bracket evaluation than normal cuts .
as the bracket evaluation respects the divergent part , it is clear that functions @xmath352 must be finite , due to the very fact that @xmath353 $ ] involves a sum over all cuts in pairs of normal cuts and associated full cuts .
this gives rise to a sum of pairs of contributions , each pair being a difference @xmath354 $ ] between an analytic contribution @xmath11 and its bracket evaluation .
thus , as long as the bracket evaluation respects the divergent part of @xmath11 , we will obtain a finite result for @xmath355 .
let us now turn away from toy models and address qfts . by its very definition , pqft deals with the calculation of feynman diagrams .
as such , it confronts the problem of the presence of ultraviolet divergences in the diagrams .
hence , the diagrams refer to ill - defined analytic quantities .
this is reflected by the fact that the analytic expressions provided by the diagrams become laurent series in a regularization parameter .
the presence of pole terms in this laurent series then indicates the presence of uv - divergences in the first place .
equivalently , in the bphz spirit , we can taylor expand the integrand in external momenta and would find that the first few terms are ill - defined quantities .
the art of obtaining meaningful physical quantities from these laurent series is known as renormalization .
it is in this process that we will find the hopf algebra structure realized .
let us recall a few basic properties of renormalization .
feynman diagrams consist of edges ( propagators ) and vertices of different types . to each such type
we can assign a weight , and to a feynman diagram we can assign an integral weight called _ degree of divergence _ which can be calculated from the dimension of spacetime , the numbers of closed cycles in the feynman diagram , and the weights of its propagators and vertices .
one finds that the analytic expression provided by a feynman diagram under consideration provides uv - divergences if and only if its degree of divergence @xmath356 is @xmath357 .
one speaks of logarithmic , linear , quadratic , @xmath278 divergences for @xmath358 .
a feynman diagram usually contains subdiagrams , which have their own degree of divergence , and thus might provide uv - divergent analytic expressions by themselves .
all these divergences are to be compensated by local counterterms , which are to be calculated from a feynman graph and its divergent subgraphs .
fig.([exa2 ] ) shows how the previous discussion extends to a feynman graph with one subdivergent graph .
it is the main result of @xcite that the transition from a bare feynman diagram to its local counterterm , and to the renormalized feynman graph , is described by a hopf algebra structure . in this paper , we have changed the notation of @xcite and formulate the hopf algebra on rooted trees .
a glance at fig.([exa ] ) shows how to assign a rooted tree to a feynman graph with subdivergences .
this is possible in a unique manner as long as all subdivergences of the feynman graph are either disjoint or nested @xcite . in such circumstances
, we can associate a unique rooted tree to the graph .
if the subdivergences are overlapping , the renormalization will nevertheless follow the combinatorics dictated by the hopf algebra of rooted trees .
in such circumstances , a feynman graph corresponds to a sum of rooted trees @xcite .
we will comment on this fact in an appendix .
each feynman diagram @xmath213 furnishes a tree whose vertices are decorated by feynman graphs @xmath359 which are free of subdivergences themselves .
these decorations correspond to the letters in the parenthesized words of @xcite .
note that the set of all admissible cuts is by construction in one to one correspondence with the set of all superficially divergent subgraphs of @xmath213 .
further the set of all cuts is in one to one correspondence with the set of all forests in the sense of renormalization theory .
this is the main result of @xcite .
the antipode of the hopf algebra @xmath360 delivers the @xmath361-factor of a feynman diagram . at this stage
, we can summarize the results in @xcite using the language of the hopf algebra of rooted trees .
this is done in fig.([renormalization ] ) .
note that we even do not have to specify the renormalization scheme , but that the cuts used in the definition of the antipode on rooted trees extend to forests , so that we can apply any chosen renormalization prescription to evaluate the content of these forests .
thus , as before in the toy model , each cut corresponds to the operation @xmath348 in collins book @xcite , some operation which extracts the divergence of the expression on which it acts .
as we mentioned already , this operation was called @xmath343 in @xcite . at this point , we succeeded in deriving the renormalization procedure from the hopf algebra of rooted trees .
the attentive reader will have noticed that we ignored overlapping divergences in our discussion .
as promised , we will discuss them in an appendix , where it is shown how to assign a unique sum of rooted trees to any graph containing overlapping divergences , to which then our previous considerations apply . for us ,
these considerations of renormalization and the underlying hopf algebra of rooted trees are sufficient motivation to get interested in this hopf algebra .
we will continue our exploration of this subject by showing how it relates to the hopf algebra of the first section .
we saw some of these relations already , and now continue to make this more precise .
recall the relations @xmath341 which indicate an intimate connection to the hopf algebra @xmath1 introduced in the first section . to find the general relation between the two hopf algebras under consideration we first introduce naturally grown forests @xmath363 . to this end
, we consider an operator @xmath364 which maps a tree @xmath260 with @xmath9 vertices to a sum @xmath365 of @xmath9 trees @xmath366 , each having @xmath305 vertices , by attaching one more outgoing edge and vertex to each vertex of @xmath260 , as in fig.([ng ] ) .
the root remains the same in this operation .
now we define @xmath367 so that @xmath368 . on products of trees
@xmath364 will act as a derivation , comparable to the derivation @xmath111 introduced in eq.([eq29 ] ) . in fig.([ng ] ) we see the first few elements @xmath363 . note that there are non - trivial multiplicities as in @xmath369 .
let @xmath370=\delta_{n+1},\ ] ] @xmath371=n\delta_n.\ ] ] the following result , which is a trivial consequence of the results in the next section , initiated this paper : * with the coproduct of @xmath272 , the @xmath363 span a closed hopf subalgebra of @xmath272 .
* @xmath372 + k\delta_1 \otimes \delta_k+[\delta_1\otimes y , r_{k-1}].\end{aligned}\ ] ] the proof follows from the results in the next section , but it is instructive to investigate directly the compatibility of the operation of natural growth and the notion of an admissible cut : we note that @xmath6 is a sum of trees : @xmath373 , say .
thus , @xmath374
hence we can write , with the same @xmath366 as before , @xmath375\otimes r^{c^i}(t_i)\right.\nonumber\\ & & \left . + ( p^{c^i}(t_i)\otimes n[r^{c^i}(t_i)]\right\}\nonumber\\ & & + n\delta_1\otimes \delta_n\nonumber\\ & & + \sum_i \sum_{\mbox{\tiny all cuts $ c^i$ of $ t_i$ } } l[r^{c^i}(t_i)]\delta_1 p^{c^i}(t_i)\otimes r^{c i}(t_i),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where l(t ) gives the number of vertices of a tree @xmath260 .
thus , we decomposed the cuts at the components of @xmath376 in four classes : either the edge to the new grown vertex is not cut , then we will have natural growth on either the former @xmath377 or @xmath378 part .
thus , the first two contributions deliver the operator @xmath364 on either side of the tensorproduct . or , for the remaining two cases , the edge to the new grown vertex is cut .
these cases will always have a factor @xmath379 on the lhs of the tensorproduct . in these cases , it either was grown from the former @xmath378 part ( admissibility of cuts forbid that it was grown from the @xmath377 part ) , or it was grown from the whole uncut former @xmath6 , which gives the term @xmath380 .
hence we have decomposed the cuts possible at the trees of @xmath376 in terms of the cuts at the trees of @xmath6 .
fig.([instrr ] ) gives an instructive example . to finally prove the result , we note the following identities @xmath381\\ l(\delta_k)\delta_k & = & k \delta_k=[y,\delta_k],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we note that @xmath382=k$ ] is well - defined , as @xmath363 is a homogenous combination of trees with @xmath383 vertices . @xmath29 at this stage , we begin to see a fundamental connection between the process of renormalization and the results of @xcite .
thus , we will now set out to define the hopf algebra of rooted trees more formally and repeat the analysis of @xcite for it .
we shall formalize the simplest example from the last section as the hopf algebra of rooted trees , and extend many of the results of the first section to this more involved case . by a rooted tree @xmath348 we mean a finite , connected , simply connected , one dimensional simplicial complex with a base point @xmath384 @xmath385 .
this base point is called the root . by the degreee of the tree
we mean @xmath386 for each @xmath9 we have a finite set of rooted trees @xmath348 with @xmath387 where we only consider isomorphism classes of trees and choose a representative in each isomorphism class .
thus for @xmath103 we have one element @xmath388 , for @xmath389 we also have only one , @xmath390 , and for @xmath391 we have two , @xmath344 and @xmath392 , all defined in fig.([f1 ] ) . by a _
cut of a tree @xmath348 we mean a subset @xmath393 of the set of edges of @xmath348 such that , @xmath394 thus what is excluded is to have two cuts of the same path or branch . given a cut
@xmath220 the new simplicial complex @xmath395 with @xmath396 and @xmath397 is no longer connected , unless @xmath398 .
we let @xmath399 be the connected component of @xmath400 with the same base point and call it the trunk , while for each other connected component , called a cut branch , we endow it with the base point which is the edge of the cut . we obtain in this way a set , with multiplicity , of finite rooted trees . for each @xmath9 we let @xmath401 be the set of trees of degree @xmath402 , up to isomorphism , and
let @xmath30 be the polynomial commutative algebra generated by the symbols , @xmath403 one defines a coproduct on @xmath30 by , @xmath404 where the last sum is over all non trivial simple cuts ( @xmath405 ) of @xmath348 , while the product @xmath406 is over the cut branches , in accordance with eq.([cop1 ] ) .
equivalently , one can write ( [ eq3.6 ] ) as , @xmath407 where the last sum is over all simple cuts . this defines @xmath14 on generators and it extends uniquely as an algebra homomorphism , @xmath408 * lemma 1 . * _ the coproduct @xmath14 is coassociative .
_ * proof . *
it is enough to check the equality @xmath409 one can do it directly by introducing the notion of a double cut of @xmath348 , but we shall use instead the following map from @xmath410 to @xmath3 , @xmath411 where @xmath348 is the pointed tree obtained by connecting a new base point @xmath400 to the base points of the pointed trees @xmath412 .
the map @xmath25 is the unique linear map from @xmath0 to @xmath0 satisfying ( [ eq3.10 ] ) .
it agrees with the map @xmath282 introduced in the previous section .
let us show that , @xmath413 let @xmath414 and @xmath348 be as in ( [ eq3.10 ] ) so that @xmath415 . from ( [ eq3.7 ] ) , one gets , @xmath416 where all simple cuts of @xmath348 , ( including @xmath398 ) are allowed .
moreover , @xmath417 where again all simple cuts @xmath418 of @xmath419 are allowed .
let @xmath420 be the tree with base point @xmath400 and @xmath9 other vertices @xmath267 labelled from @xmath421 to @xmath422 , all directly connected to the base point @xmath400 .
we view @xmath420 in an obvious way as a subgraph of the tree @xmath348 , where the base points are the same and the vertex @xmath267 is the base point of @xmath419 . given a simple cut @xmath220 of @xmath348 one gets by restriction to the subgraph @xmath423 a cut of @xmath420 , it is characterized by the subset @xmath424 , @xmath425 .
the simple cut @xmath220 is uniquely determined by the subset @xmath426 and for each @xmath427 , i.e. each branch @xmath428 of @xmath420 which is not cut , by the simple cut @xmath418 of @xmath419 given by the restriction of @xmath220 to this subgraph .
thus the simple cuts @xmath220 of @xmath348 are in one to one correspondence with the various terms of the expression ( [ eq3.13 ] ) , namely the @xmath429 .
the two sums match termwise and , applying @xmath430 to ( [ eq3.13 ] ) one gets , @xmath431 this is eq.([cop2 ] ) of the previous section .
( note that @xmath432 by definition . )
one has , @xmath433 so that @xmath434 is coassociative
. let us assume that @xmath30 is coassociative and prove it for @xmath435 .
it is enough to check ( [ eq3.9 ] ) for the generators @xmath436 , with @xmath437 one has @xmath438 where the degree of all @xmath412 is @xmath402 , i.e. @xmath439 . using ( [ eq3.14 ] ) we can replace @xmath440 by @xmath441 where @xmath14 is the coassociative coproduct in @xmath30 .
thus we can use the notation which encodes the coassociativity of @xmath30 , @xmath442 the first term of ( [ eq3.9 ] ) is then : @xmath443 , which by ( [ eq3.14 ] ) gives @xmath444 the second term of ( [ eq3.9 ] ) is @xmath445 , which by ( [ eq3.14 ] ) gives , @xmath446 thus we conclude that @xmath14 is coassociative .
@xmath29 we shall now characterize the hopf algebra @xmath410 as the solution of a universal problem in hochschild cohomology . first , given an algebra @xmath131 with augmentation @xmath56 , let us consider the hochschild cohomology of @xmath131 with coefficients in the following bimodule @xmath447
. as a vector space @xmath448 , the _ left _ action of @xmath449 on @xmath447 is @xmath450 , for all @xmath451 , @xmath452 .
the _ right _
action of @xmath131 on @xmath447 is by @xmath453 , @xmath452 , @xmath454 .
thus the right module structure is through the augmentation .
let us denote the corresponding cocycles by @xmath455 , the coboundaries by @xmath456 and the cohomology as @xmath457 .
thus for instance a 1-cocycle @xmath458 is a linear map @xmath459 such that @xmath460 . next , given a hopf algebra @xmath461 we use the unit of @xmath462 and its coalgebra structure to transpose ( as in the harrison cohomology ) , the above complex .
more precisely an @xmath9-cochain @xmath25 is a linear map , @xmath463 and the coboundary @xmath464 is given by , @xmath465 @xmath466 where the lower index @xmath467 in @xmath468 indicates where the coproduct is applied . for @xmath469 , @xmath25 is just a linear form on @xmath462 and one has @xmath470 for @xmath103 , @xmath25 is a linear map from @xmath462 to @xmath462 and @xmath471 we shall use the notation @xmath472 , @xmath473 for the corresponding cocycles , cohomology classes , etc @xmath278 * theorem 2 . *
_ there exists a pair @xmath474 , unique up to isomorphism , where @xmath462 is a commutative hopf algebra and @xmath475 which is universal among all such pairs .
in other words for any pair @xmath476 where @xmath434 is a commutative hopf algebra and @xmath477 , there exists a unique hopf algebra morphism @xmath478 such that @xmath479 . _
* let @xmath0 be the hopf algebra of rooted trees and @xmath25 be the linear map defined by ( [ eq3.10 ] ) .
the equality ( [ eq3.11 ] ) shows that @xmath480 .
this shows that @xmath25 is a 1-cocycle .
it is clear that it is not a coboundary , indeed one has @xmath481 where @xmath400 is the tree with only one vertex .
moreover , for any coboundary @xmath482 one has @xmath483 since @xmath484 .
next consider a pair @xmath476 where @xmath434 is a commutative hopf algebra and @xmath485 is a 1-cocycle .
the equality @xmath479 uniquely determines an algebra homomorphism @xmath486 .
indeed on the linear basis @xmath487 of @xmath0 one must have , @xmath488 by multiplicativity of @xmath105 , while @xmath489 is determined by induction by @xmath490 , and , @xmath491 we need to check that it is a morphism of hopf algebras , i.e. that it is compatible with the coproduct , @xmath492 it is enough to check ( [ eq3.28 ] ) on generators of the form @xmath493 .
to do this one uses the cocycle property of @xmath494 which allows to write , @xmath495 one uses an induction hypothesis on the validity of ( [ eq3.28 ] ) , to write , @xmath496 making use of the identity @xmath497 .
thus one has , @xmath498 and the validity of ( [ eq3.28 ] ) for @xmath499 follows from the equality @xmath500 .
we have thus shown the existence and uniqueness of the hopf algebra morphism @xmath105 .
@xmath29 as the simplest example , let @xmath434 be the hopf algebra of polynomials @xmath501 , as above , with , @xmath502 the cohomology group @xmath503 is one dimensional , and the natural generator is the cocycle , @xmath504 the cocycle identity follows from the equality , @xmath505 the coboudaries are of the form , @xmath506 where @xmath507 is a distribution with support the origin , and possibly infinite order .
the tranpose @xmath508 of the morphism of hopf algebras given by theorem 2 determines a lie algebra homomorphism from the one dimensional lie algebra ( @xmath509 with the notations of section i ) , to the lie algebra @xmath510 which corresponds , by the milnor - moore theorem to the commutative hopf algebra @xmath0 .
we proceed as in section i to determine @xmath510 .
let @xmath511 be the linear span of the elements @xmath512 , indexed by rooted trees .
we introduce an operation on @xmath510 by the equality , @xmath513 where the integer @xmath514 is determined as the number of simple cuts @xmath220 of cardinality 1 such that the cut branch is @xmath515 while the remaining trunk is @xmath516 . and @xmath516 to @xmath348 with the transplantation used in the theory of operads .
indeed , in the latter , the root of the tree @xmath515 is restricted to be the end of a branch of @xmath516 . ]
* theorem 3 .
* a ) _ let @xmath510 be the linear span of the elements @xmath512 , indexed by rooted trees .
the following equality defines a structure of lie algebra on @xmath510 .
the lie bracket @xmath517 $ ] is @xmath518 .
_ \b ) _ the hopf algebra @xmath0 is the dual of the envelopping algebra of the lie algebra @xmath510 .
_ define @xmath519 we shall need the following lemma , * lemma 4 . *
_ one has @xmath520 , where the integer @xmath9 is the number of simple cuts @xmath220 of @xmath348 , @xmath521 such that the two branches are @xmath522 while @xmath523 . _
* when one evaluates ( [ eq3.37 ] ) against @xmath512 one gets the coefficient , @xmath524 the first sum corresponds to pairs of cuts , @xmath220 , @xmath525 of @xmath348 with @xmath526 and where @xmath525 is a cut of @xmath399 .
these pairs of cuts fall in two classes , either @xmath527 is a simple cut or it is not .
the second sum corresponds to pairs of cuts @xmath528 , @xmath529 of @xmath348 such that @xmath530 , @xmath531 and @xmath529 is a cut of @xmath532 . in such a case @xmath533
is never a simple cut so the difference ( [ eq3.38 ] ) amounts to substract from the first sum the pairs @xmath220 , @xmath525 such that @xmath527 is not a simple cut .
this gives , @xmath534 where @xmath535 is the number of simple cuts @xmath220 of @xmath348 of cardinality @xmath536 such that the two cut branches are @xmath515 and @xmath516 .
@xmath29 it is thus clear that , @xmath537 one then computes @xmath538 , z_{t_3 } ] + [ [ z_{t_2 } , z_{t_3 } ] , z_{t_1 } ] + [ [ z_{t_3 } , z_{t_1 } ] , z_{t_2}]$ ] .
one can write it , for short , as a sum of 24 terms , @xmath539 \b ) for each rooted tree @xmath348 let us define a linear form @xmath512 on @xmath0 by the equality , @xmath540 thus @xmath512 vanishes when paired with any monomial @xmath541 except when this monomial is @xmath542 while , @xmath543 since @xmath544 is the counit of @xmath0 and since @xmath512 satisfies @xmath545 it follows that the coproduct of @xmath512 is , @xmath546 where the coproduct on @xmath547 is defined , when it makes sense , by dualizing the product of @xmath0 .
similarly the product of two elements of @xmath547 is defined by @xmath548 since the bracket of two derivations is still a derivation , the subspace of @xmath547 of elements satisfying ( [ eq3.39 ] ) is stable under bracket .
what remains is to show that , @xmath549 \ , , \label{eq3.46}\ ] ] where the r.h.s .
is defined by the lie algebra structure of theorem 3 .
let @xmath550 be the augmentation ideal of @xmath0 , @xmath551 .
the formula defining the coproduct in @xmath0 shows that , @xmath552 where @xmath553 .
in fact one can compute @xmath554 modulo higher powers of @xmath550 , i.e. modulo @xmath555 , it gives , @xmath556 where @xmath220 varies among _ single cuts _ of the tree @xmath348 , where @xmath395 is the part of @xmath348 that contains the base point , while @xmath557 is the tree which remains .
when one computes @xmath558 the part which is not symmetric in @xmath522 is zero unless @xmath487 is equal to a single @xmath542 .
when one computes @xmath559 the only part which contributes comes from @xmath560 and it counts the number of ways of obtaining @xmath348 from @xmath515 and @xmath516 , which gives ( [ eq3.46 ] ) .
@xmath29 * proposition 5 .
* _ the equality degree @xmath561 of vertices of @xmath348 defines a grading of the lie algebra @xmath510 .
_ * proof . *
the number of vertices of any tree obtained by gluing @xmath515 to @xmath516 is the sum of the number of vertices of @xmath515 and @xmath516 .
@xmath29 we shall now show how to extend the hopf algebra @xmath0 to include the generators @xmath562 of the lie algebra of the affine group as in section i. the commutator of @xmath10 with @xmath542 will simply be given by , @xmath563=\ , deg(t)\delta_t \label{eq3.50}\ ] ] i.e. by the above grading .
the commutator with @xmath11 will generate a derivation @xmath364 of @xmath0 , uniquely determined by its value on the generators @xmath542 , by @xmath564 where the trees @xmath565 are obtained by adding one vertex and one edge to @xmath348 in all possible ways without changing the base point .
it is clear that the sum ( [ eq3.51 ] ) contains @xmath566 terms . using the derivation property of @xmath364 , one has , @xmath567 our first task will be to get a formula for @xmath568 .
* proposition 6 . * _ for any @xmath569 one has _
@xmath570 \ , .\ ] ] * proof . *
first , it is enough to check the equality when @xmath571 .
indeed , both @xmath572 and @xmath573 are derivations from @xmath0 to the @xmath0-bimodule @xmath574 ( using @xmath14 to define the bimodule structure ) .
thus so is their difference @xmath575 which vanishes provided it does on the generators @xmath542 .
let thus @xmath348 be a pointed tree and @xmath565 be obtained from @xmath348 by adjoining an edge at @xmath576 .
one has @xmath577 where @xmath578 varies among the simple cuts of @xmath565 .
one has @xmath579 where @xmath56 the new edge .
now the cuts @xmath525 for @xmath565 are of two kinds , \(a ) the new edge is not cut , ( a ) it is cut .
there is also another dichotomy , \(b ) the vertex @xmath580 belongs to the trunk , ( b ) it belongs to one of the cut branches .
if we sum ( [ eq3.53 ] ) over all possible @xmath565 we get , @xmath581 let us concentrate on the last term and consider first only the cuts @xmath525 which satisfy ( a ) we also consider the term , @xmath582 over all the cuts @xmath220 of the tree @xmath348 .
if we apply @xmath583 to ( [ eq3.55 ] ) , we obtain all possible cuts of a @xmath565 such that ( a ) ( b ) holds so that , @xmath584 it follows that , @xmath585 we can thus summarize what we obtained so far by , @xmath586 now consider the sum @xmath587 , the first case is when the _ only _ cut is the cut of the new edge .
the only cut branch gives us a @xmath379 and the number of ways of doing it is @xmath588 , thus we get @xmath589 \ , \ [ y , \delta_t ] = n \ , \delta_t \ , .
\label{eq3.59}\ ] ] the next case is when a non trivial cut @xmath220 remains after we remove the new edge . for that cut
@xmath220 the new vertex necessarily belongs to the trunk ( so that ( a ) ( b ) is excluded ) as follows from the very definition of a cut . for such cuts ,
the result is to get an additional @xmath379 among the @xmath590 , which comes from the cut new edge . the number of ways of doing it is exactly the degree of the trunk .
thus we get @xmath591 \ , .
\label{eq3.60}\ ] ] combining ( [ eq3.59 ] ) and ( [ eq3.60 ] ) we get , @xmath592 \ , .
\label{eq3.61}\ ] ] this is enough to assert that for any tree @xmath348 one has , @xmath593 \label{eq3.62}\ ] ] which ends the proof of proposition 6 .
@xmath29 in other words we can enlarge @xmath0 to @xmath594 by adjoining the elements @xmath595 with @xmath596 = n(a ) \
, , \ [ y , a ] = ( \deg a ) \ , a \qquad \forall \ , a \in { \cal h}_r \label{eq3.63}\ ] ] @xmath13 = x \ , , \ \delta y = y \otimes 1 + 1 \otimes y \ , , \
\delta x = x \otimes 1 + 1 \otimes x + \delta_1 \otimes y \ , .\ ] ] let us translate proposition 6 in terms of the transposed map @xmath597 acting on @xmath598
. one has @xmath599
@xmath600 @xmath601 @xmath602 thus , @xmath603 where @xmath604 ( resp .
@xmath605 ) is the transposed of the multiplication by @xmath379 ( resp .
@xmath606 ) @xmath607 one has @xmath608 .
thus , @xmath609 i.e. @xmath604 is a derivation .
moreover on the generator @xmath512 , @xmath610 indeed , @xmath611 unless @xmath612 , while for @xmath613 one gets that @xmath614 .
thus , @xmath615 where we use the poincar - birkhoff - witt theorem to write elements of @xmath616 in the form @xmath617 .
let us compute @xmath618 where @xmath348 is a tree with more than one vertex .
one has @xmath619 , and this vanishes unless @xmath103 .
moreover for @xmath103 , @xmath620 where @xmath621 is the number of times the tree @xmath348 is obtained by adjoining an edge and vertex to @xmath515 .
thus one has , @xmath622 we can now state the analogue of lemma 4 of section i as follows , where we let @xmath623 be the lie subalgebra of @xmath510 generated by the @xmath512 with @xmath624 . * lemma 7 .
* _ when restricted to @xmath625 , @xmath597 is the unique derivation , with values in @xmath626 satisfying ( [ eq3.70 ] ) , moreover , for @xmath627 and @xmath628 one has @xmath629 _ * proof .
* the first statement follows from ( [ eq3.64 ] ) and ( [ eq3.66 ] ) .
the second statement follows from , @xmath630 which one proves by induction on @xmath126 .
@xmath29 motivated by section i and the first part of the lemma , we enlarge the lie algebra @xmath510 by adjoining two elements @xmath631 and @xmath127 such that , @xmath130 = z_0 \ , \ [ z_0 , z_t ] = deg(t ) \ , z_t \,\ ] ] @xmath632 = \sum n ( t ; t_1 ) z_{t_1 } \qquad \forall \ , t , \ , \deg ( t)>1 \ , .\ ] ]
the obtained lie algebra @xmath135 , is an extension of the lie algebra of formal vector fields with @xmath132 , @xmath633 and as above @xmath134 , as follows from , * theorem 8 . *
_ the following equality defines a surjective lie algebra homomorphism from @xmath135 to @xmath131 , @xmath634 where @xmath635 is the number of times @xmath542 occurs in @xmath636 . _ * proof . * the elements @xmath11 , @xmath10 , and @xmath637 of the hopf algebra @xmath638
fulfill the presentation of section i for the hopf algebra @xmath639 , thus there exists a unique homorphism of hopf algebras @xmath640 from @xmath638 to @xmath639 such that , @xmath641 by construction , @xmath640 restricts to the subalgebra @xmath642 and defines a homomorphism to the hopf algebra @xmath643 . transposing this homomorphism to the lie algebras ,
one obtains the restriction of @xmath208 to the subalgebra @xmath644 .
@xmath29 at this stage we completed our understanding of the relation between the two hopf algebras .
it is best expressed by the lie algebra homomorphism @xmath208 from @xmath510 to @xmath86 .
its extension to the full @xmath645 justifies the construction of the latter lie algebra . by theorem 3 the hopf algebra @xmath0
should be thought of as the algebra of coordinates on a nilpotent formal group @xmath646 whose lie algebra is the graded lie algebra @xmath510 .
given a field @xmath647 , elements of the group @xmath648 are obtained precisely as the characters of the algebra @xmath649 . indeed ,
such characters correspond to group - like elements @xmath650 ( i.e. elements @xmath650 satisfying @xmath651 ) of a suitable completion of the envelopping algebra of @xmath510 . viewing @xmath650 as a linear form on @xmath0 gives us the desired character . if we let @xmath647 be the field of formal power series in a variable @xmath222 we thus obtain as points of @xmath648 the homomorphisms from @xmath0 to @xmath647 .
it is not difficult to check that the map which to every bare feynman diagram @xmath213 associates the corresponding laurent expansion ( in dimensional regularization , say , with regularized dimension @xmath652 , in four dimensions , say ) is precisely such a character .
this allows to reduce by the above conceptual mathematical structure of inversion in @xmath646 the computation of renormalization in qft to the primitive elements of the hopf algebra , i.e . to feynman diagrams without subdivergences . in order to better understand the extension of the group of diffeomorphisms provided by the group @xmath646
, it would be desirable to find a non - commutative manifold @xmath11 , whose diffeomorphism group is @xmath646 .
the coordinates @xmath653 of a diffeomorphism @xmath654 allow to reconstruct the latter by the formula @xmath655 this formula provides the clear meaning both for composition and inversion of diffeomorphisms .
of course , we would love to have a similar formula for the group @xmath646 and it is tantalizing to consider the feynman integral @xmath656 as a direct analogue of the above expression .
thanks the i.h.e.s .
, bures - sur - yvette , for hospitality during a stay jan .- feb .
1998 and the theory group at the cpt ( marseille ) for interest and discussions .
also , support by a heisenberg fellowship of the dfg for d.k . is gratefully acknowledged .
d.k . thanks r. stora for motivating the investigation which will be reported in @xcite .
99 d. kreimer , _ on the hopf algebra structure of perturbative quantum field theories _ , adv.theor.math.phys.*2.2 * ( 1998 ) 303 - 334 ; q - alg/9707029 .
a. connes , h. moscovici , _ hopf algebras , cyclic cohomology and the transverse index theorem _ , ihes publication ihes / m/98/37 ( 1998 ) .
j. dixmier , _ existence de traces non normales _ , _
c.r.acad.sci.paris_ , ser.a - b*262 * ( 1966 ) , a1107-a1108 .
collins , _ renormalization _ , cambridge univ.press ( 1984 ) .
d. kreimer , _ renormalization and knot theory _ , j.knot th.ram.*6 * ( 1997 ) 479 - 581 , q - alg/9607022 .
broadhurst , r. delbourgo , d. kreimer , _ unknotting the polarized vacuum of quenched qed _ , phys.lett.*b366 * ( 1996 ) 421 , hep - ph/9509296 .
d. kreimer , _ on overlapping divergences _ , in preparation .
t. krajewski , r. wulkenhaar , _ on kreimer s hopf algebra structure of feynman graphs _
, cpt-98/p.3639 ; hep - th/9805098 .
a prominent problem in renormalization theory is the presence of overlapping divergences .
we will soon see that to green functions which suffer from such overlapping divergences we will have to associate a sum of trees , while so far our experience only lead to the identification of single trees with a given green function .
we will proceed by studying the example of @xmath258 theory in six dimensions .
a full study will be given elsewhere @xcite , but we also mention that solutions to the problem of overlapping divergences were already found in @xcite , using combinatorical considerations concerning divergent sectors , in @xcite and @xcite using schwinger dyson equations , and were also known to others . in @xcite we will show how overlapping divergences give rise to a slightly modified hopf algebra , which eventually turns out to be identical to the hopf algebra of rooted trees considered here .
we sketch this more formal argument after the consideration of @xmath258 theory as an example . in whatever approach
one takes , the final message is the same : overlapping divergent functions can be resolved in sums of functions having only nested and disjoint divergences . to see how this comes about
, we will here employ yet another approach , using differential equations on bare green functions .
green functions in @xmath657 theory which are overall divergent are provided by two- and three - point functions , to which we refer as @xmath658}_n(q;m)$ ] and @xmath659}_n(p , q;m)$ ] .
here the subscript @xmath9 refers to the number of loops in the green - function , and @xmath126 is the mass of the propagator , while @xmath660 are external momenta .
we first consider @xmath659}_n(p , q;m)$ ] : @xmath661}_n(p , q;m)=\int d^6l_1\ldots d^6l_n \prod_{i:=1}^{3n}\frac{1}{p_i}.\ ] ] for @xmath662 , it is a product of @xmath663 propagators @xmath664 , where the @xmath665 are momentum vectors which are linear combinations of external momenta @xmath660 and @xmath9 internal momenta @xmath666 such that momentum conservation holds at each vertex .
then , one immediately sees that @xmath659}_n(p , q;m)- g^{[3]}_n(p , q;0)$ ] is overall convergent .
this follows directly from powercounting in the expression @xmath672 thus , to determine the counterterm for a vertex function , it suffices to consider the massless case.}_n(0,q;0)$ ] . ] in the context of @xmath258 theory in six dimensions , overlapping divergences can only be provided by two - point functions . the only circumstance which stops us to assign a unique tree to @xmath659}_n(p , q;m)$ ] is the fact that there might be overlapping subdivergences provided by massless two - point functions @xmath658}_s(k_i;0)$ ] , @xmath673 . before we handle these subdivergences , we turn to @xmath658}_n(q;m)$ ] itself . at @xmath9 loops , it consists of @xmath675 propagators @xmath676}_n(q;m)=\int d^6l_1\ldots d^6 l_n \prod_{i:=1}^{3n-1}\frac{1}{p_i}\ ] ] consider the difference @xmath677}_n(q;m)-g^{[2]}_n(q;0 ) & = & m^2 \int d^6l_1\ldots d^6l_n \prod_{i:=1}^{3n-1}\frac{1}{p_i } \sum_{j:=1}^{3n-1}\frac{1}{\overline{p_j}}\\ & & + \mbox{overall finite terms}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is of overall logarithmic degree of divergence .
as far as the overall counterterm is concerned , we can even nullify masses in this difference and thus find that the divergences of @xmath658}_n(q;m)$ ] can be separated as @xmath677}_n(q;m ) & = & m^2\int d^6l_1\ldots d^6l_n \prod_{i:=1}^{3n-1}\frac{1}{\overline{p_i } } \sum_{j:=1}^{3n-1}\frac{1}{\overline{p_j}}\\ & & + g^{[2]}_n(q;0)+u(q , m)\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath678 collects all the overall finite terms . the first term on the rhs is overall logarithmic divergent .
it only can provide overlapping divergences through massless functions @xmath658}_s(q;0)$ ] appearing as subgraphs in it , quite similar to the analysis of the vertex function , as the sum over @xmath679 squares one propagator in turn .
we have thus reduced all appearances of overlapping divergences to the presence of functions @xmath658}_i(q;0)$ ] , @xmath680 .
it remains to show how the overlapping divergences in @xmath658}_n(q;0)$ ] can be handled for all @xmath9 .
this is actually not that difficult . necessarily ,
@xmath658}_n(q;0)$ ] has the form @xmath676}_n(q;0)=(q^2)^{1-n\epsilon}f_{g_n}(\epsilon)\ ] ] where @xmath681 is a laurent series in @xmath222 .
hence @xmath658}_n(q;0)$ ] fulfils the differential equation @xmath682}_n(q;0)=g^{[2]}_n(q;0).\ ] ] this solves the problem .
the remaining source of overlapping divergences , @xmath658}_n(q;0)$ ] , is expressed in terms of the overall logarithmic divergent function @xmath683}_n(q;0)$ ] which is free of overlapping divergences .
such an approach is also very useful in practice @xcite .
fig.([f2 ] ) gives two examples for the resolution of overlapping divergences .
crosses in the figure indicate where the derivatives with respect to @xmath241 act for a chosen momentum flow through the graph .
so far , we decomposed graphs which have overlapping divergences into a sum of contributions each of which delivers a rooted tree .
thus , overlapping divergences correspond to a linear combination of rooted trees , while any feynman diagram without overlapping divergences corresponds to a single rooted tree .
one might suggest to enlargen the hopf algebra @xmath684 of rooted trees to another hopf algebra , @xmath685 say , so that @xmath685 directly contains elements which correspond to graphs with overlapping divergences @xcite .
let us at this stage mention a general fact which shows that any such hopf algebra @xmath685 is nothing else than the hopf algebra of rooted trees .
if we take into account the decorations of vertices by feynman diagrams without subdivergences , any such hopf algebra @xmath685 is a hopf algebra @xmath684 for an appropriate set of decorations .
consider a feynman graph @xmath213 which has overlapping subdivergences , but in a way that any of its divergent subgraphs @xmath686 and any of the complementary graphs @xmath687 is free of overlapping subdivergences .
the first example in fig.([f2 ] ) is of this type .
the cases we have excluded here will be handled later by a recursive argument .
we want to construct a hopf algebra @xmath685 which contains a single element @xmath688 such that the antipode @xmath689 delivers the counterterm without making recourse to the methods of the previous paragraph to disentangle @xmath688 first as a sum of trees @xmath366 in some decorated algebra @xmath684 .
the question is : could such an algebra have a structure different from @xmath684 ?
let us actually construct @xmath685 by fairly general arguments .
let @xmath690 be given , and let in particular all feynman graphs without subdivergences be identified .
hence all possible decorations , and thus all primitive elements of @xmath684 are assumed to be determined .
note that the primitive elements of @xmath685 are identical with the primitive elements of @xmath684 as graphs with overlapping divergences necessarily contain subdivergences , and thus do not provide primitive elements per se .
a feynman graph @xmath213 chosen as above has only subgraphs which can be described by proper rooted trees .
thus , its coproduct in @xmath685 will have the general form @xmath691 where the sum is over all subgraphs of @xmath213 , while @xmath692 and @xmath693 are the rooted trees assigned to the corresponding graphs . by the constraints which we imposed on @xmath213 this is always possible .
in @xmath685 we consider the above equation as the definition for the coproduct on elements @xmath694 . now
, we know that there exists an element @xmath699 such that @xmath700 this element @xmath348 is just the linear combination of rooted trees constructed in the previous section , but ist existences can be established on general grounds from the consideration of maximal forests @xcite .
finally we set @xmath701 and calculate @xmath702 now , if @xmath703 is superficially divergent at all it is a primitive element .
it thus can be described by the rooted tree @xmath277 . to be able to do so we only have to enlarge the algebra @xmath684 to contain the decoration @xmath703 .
an easy recursion argument finally allows to drop the constraint on @xmath213 @xcite .
one concludes that any hopf algebra which contains @xmath684 but also elements @xmath704 is isomorphic to the algebra of rooted trees @xmath684 with an enlarged set of primitive elements . in fig.([f2 ] ) we see some contributions which only generate the tree @xmath277 .
they correspond to such new primitive elements .
a detailed version of this argument will be given elsewhere @xcite . | we explore the relation between the hopf algebra associated to the renormalization of qft and the hopf algebra associated to the ncg computations of tranverse index theory for foliations .
= msbm10 = msbm7 = msbm5 = = = |
the old nova v842 cen ( nova cen 1986 ) was discovered on 1986 november 22 by mcnaught ( 1986 ) and reached a maximum magnitude of 5.6 from its pre - outburst brightness of about 18.5 .
whitelock ( 1987 ) and sekiguchi et al .
( 1989 ) estimated the @xmath2 decay time to be 48 d , thus classifying it as a moderately fast nova .
since 1987 , this object has been followed with photometric and spectroscopic observations from the ground and in space .
a summary of observations through 2005 is given by schmidtobreick et al .
( 2005 ) who concluded at that time that there was still insufficient time for the nova to have cooled down as either the white dwarf itself or a region of the accretion disk remained very hot , as evidenced by an extremely blue continuum and the presence of high excitation lines . iue observations in 1987 ( krautter & snijders 1990 ) provided a measurement of e(b - v ) = 0.55 from the 2200 feature and a subsequent distance near 1200 pc . a later iue observation obtained in 1991 ( gonzalez - riestra et al . , 1998 )
revealed the spectrum of this nova still showed emission lines of ciii ( 1175 ) , siiv ( 1400 ) , niv ] , civ ( 1550 ) , heii ( 1640 ) but no ciii ] ( 1909 ) .
the uv energy distribution became increasingly flatter during the time period when iue spectra were obtained ( 1987 - 1991 ) , indicating the gradual cooling of the heated white dwarf .
on the basis of a non - detection of v842 cen during the rosat survey , gonzalez - riestra et al .
( 1998 ) concluded that nuclear burning had largely shut off , thus giving a turn - off time of approximately 3.5 years .
two different studies have provided evidence that the system is being viewed at low orbital inclination , woudt & warner ( 2003 ) from the lack of orbital variation and schmidtobreick et al .
( 2005 ) from the width of the balmer lines .
schmidtobreick et al .
( 2005 ) interpret their spectra and photometric observations as suggesting that v842 cen is a low mass transfer object intermediate between novae and dwarf novae .
this in turn suggests that v842 cen could represent an important test case for the hibernation theory of cataclysmic variables ( shara et al .
1986 ) .
high speed photometry obtained in 2000 ( woudt & warner 2003 ) showed no persistent short timescale periodicity , but further photometry in 2008 ( woudt et al . 2009 ) revealed light curves that exhibited a coherent light modulation at 56.825 s , which they took as the rotation period of the white dwarf .
sidebands were apparent that were indicative of re - processing from a surface moving with an orbital period of 3.94 h. based upon their observations , they classified v842 cen as an intermediate polar ( ip ) of the dq herculis subclass ( woudt et al .
if the 57 second periodicity is the rotation period of the accreting white dwarf , then v842 cen would contain the 3rd most rapidly rotating white dwarf among ips .
the fact that a 57s periodicity was seen suggests that the mass transfer rate had declined significantly since the nova outburst .
luna et al . ( 2012 ) obtained xmm - newton x - ray spectra in 2011 which were consistent with the emission from an absorbed thin thermal plasma with a temperature distribution given by an isobaric cooling flow . from their cooling flow model fit and its corresponding @xmath3 ( 43 kev ) , they derived a very high temperature in the shocked region . following the method of yuasa et al .
( 2010 ) , they obtained a mass for the white dwarf in v842 cen of @xmath4 .
surprisingly however , they failed to detect the 57s periodicity found by woudt et al .
( 2009 ) , in either the om data or the epic data .
in addition , the x - ray luminosity appears to be much lower than other ips , especially considering the system s low inclination and thus direct visibility of the accretion region . to make further progress in understanding the decline and return to quiescence of this post - nova as well as the physical properties of the hot primary component
, we obtained a hubble space telescope ( hst ) ultraviolet spectrum along with ground - based optical and near - ir photometry .
these observations , an analysis of the uv spectrum with synthetic spectra , and our conclusions are presented in the sections below .
we observed v842 cen with hst on 18 march 2010 from 16:50:05 to 17:27:59 ut .
the instrumental setup used the cos / fuv configuration through the primary science aperture with the g140l grating in timetag mode for an exposure time of 2,274 seconds.there were no reported problems during the observation and the obtained spectrum had a s / n@xmath520:1 .
the data were downloaded from mast and processed through the standard pipeline .
the default extraction for the g140l grating is 57 pixels .
we de - reddened the data by adopting a color excess e(b - v ) = 0.55 and using the idl routine unred .
the original cos spectrum , smoothed but without de - reddening , is displayed in fig.1 . in fig.2 , we display the cos spectrum of v842 cen , de - reddened with e(b - v ) = 0.55 with the identified line features labelled and artifacts identified in the figure caption . in order to optimize the spectrum for the light curves
, we extracted with the optimum width of 41 pixels as found by maximizing the s / n through extractions using a series of widths .
optical time - series data were obtained using the 74-in radcliffe telescope at the sutherland site of the south african astronomical observatory with the university of cape town ccd and no filter .
data were obtained from 1:28:48 - 2:12:41 ut on march 18 .
optical v and j magnitudes were also obtained with the 1.3 m telescope of the small and moderate aperture research telescope system on cerro tololo on the night of march 18 at 7:40 ut .
calibration of stars in the field with the aavso chart sequence gave a v magnitude of 16.5 on this date , while the 2mass stars provided a j magnitude of 15.5 .
a light curve was created from the cos spectrum by binning the time - tag data into 6 sec bins ( comparable to the optical data ) and summing the fluxes over all useful wavelengths from 1127 - 2000 .
the resulting lightcurve was converted to fractional intensity for dft analysis .
the optical light curve was treated in the same manner .
then the dfts were computed and the white noise determined empirically with the shuffling technique described in kepler ( 1993 ) and mukadam et al.(2010 ) .
the top panel of figure 3 shows the original cos light curve and dft .
since there was a large change in flux from the start to the end of the observation , the trend was removed and the resulting residual light curve is shown in the second panel .
the computed dfts of the original and residual light curves are shown in the two bottom panels .
the dashed line in the residual dft shows the 3@xmath6 limit for the white noise as 9.5 mma ( with unit of milli - modulation amplitude ) .
there is no visible short period evident near this level .
the optical light curve was treated in the same fashion and is shown in figure 4 .
the length of the optical light curve is similar to the cos data , but was obtained about 15 hours earlier . for the optical data , we used a standard iraf ( tody 1993 ) reduction to extract sky - subtracted light curves from the ccd frames using psf fitting .
after a preliminary reduction , we converted the lightcurve to differential magnitude and the mid - exposure times of the ccd images to heliocentric julian date ( hjd ) .
magnitudes are used for the original light curve ( top panel ) to provide an easy comparison to past data of woudt et al .
( 2009 ) . as with the uv data , the decreasing long trend in the light curve
was removed to create a residual light curve ( in fractional intensity ) in the second panel .
the bottom panels show the resulting dfts .
there is clearly a peak at [email protected] with an amplitude of [email protected] mma .
while the noise level is high due to the short duration of the light curve , this period is greater than the 3@xmath6 noise level of 7.5 and consistent with the period present in the 2008 data of woudt et al .
the amplitude is higher than the value in 2008 ( 4.2mma ) .
we constructed a grid of theoretical , high gravity , solar composition photospheric spectra by first using the code tlusty ( version 203 ) ( hubeny 1988 ) to calculate the atmospheric structure which served as input to build the synthetic spectra with the code synspec ( version 48 ) ( hubeny and lanz 1995 ) .
we compiled a library of photospheric spectra covering the temperature range from 15,000k to 70,000k in increments of 1000 k , and a surface gravity range , log @xmath7 , in increments of 0.2 in log @xmath8 ( ballouz and sion 2009 ) .
we also used model accretion disks extracted from the optically thick , accretion disk model library of wade & hubeny ( 1998 ) .
for these models , we took the innermost disk radius , r@xmath9 , to be fixed at a fractional white dwarf radius of @xmath10 .
the outermost disk radius , r@xmath11 , was selected such that t@xmath12 is 10,000k since disk annuli beyond this radius have cooler zones with larger radii , thus providing only a very small contribution to the mid and far uv disk flux , including the cos fuv bandpass .
the disk models are steady state in the sense that the mass accretion rate is assumed to be the same for all radii . with these definitions ,
the run of disk temperature with radius is expressed as : @xmath13 where @xmath14 and @xmath15 limb darkening of the disk is fully taken into account in the manner described by diaz et al .
( 1996 ) involving the eddington - barbier relation , the increase of kinetic temperature with depth in the disk , and the wavelength and temperature dependence of the planck function ( ballouz & sion 2009 ) . the boundary layer contribution is ignored in our model fitting .
thus , the boundary layer is expected to be important only in the extreme ultraviolet below the lyman limit .
disk truncation was not included in this work .
in addition , for the purpose of handling disk truncation , we also constructed standard alpha accretion disk models for which we could vary the disk truncation radius .
these models , like the wade and hubeny ( 1998 ) grid are standard alpha disk models ( shakura & sunyaev 1973 ) , having the viscosity due to mhd turbulence , and with energy dissipated locally in the vertical direction . each disk model consisted of n rings of radii @xmath16 ( i = 1 , 2 , ..
n ) , where the temperature @xmath17 and density ( @xmath18 ) of each ring are given by the standard disk model . the codes tlusty & synspec
are then used to generate spectra for each of the disk rings , with the white dwarf mass , mass accretion rate , and radius of the ring as input .
the individual spectra of the rings are then added together to generate a disk spectrum for a given inclination and assumed limb darkening ( ballouz and sion 2009 ; godon et al.2012 ) .
our fitting procedure is as follows .
the best - fitting single temperature white dwarf model and the best - fitting accretion disk - only model to the observed spectrum were found .
depending upon the success of these fits , we assessed the possibility of whether a combination of a disk plus a white dwarf resulted in a statistically significant improvement to the fits compared iwth that achieved with disks or photospheres alone . using two @xmath19 minimization routines , either iuefit for disks - alone and photospheres - alone or diskfit for combining disks and photospheres or two - temperature white dwarfs , @xmath19 values and a scale factor
were computed for each model or combination of models ( godon et al.2012 ) .
the scale factor , @xmath20 , normalized to a kiloparsec and solar radius , can be related to the white dwarf radius r through : @xmath21 , where @xmath22 , and @xmath23 is the distance to the source .
for the white dwarf radius , we use the mass - radius relation from the evolutionary model grid of wood ( 1995 ) for c - o cores . the best - fitting model or combination of models was chosen based not only upon the minimum @xmath19 value achieved , but also the goodness of fit of the continuum slope , the goodness of fit to the observed lyman alpha region and consistency of the scale factor - derived distance with other distance estimates ( ballouz et al.2009 ) .
given that the v842 cen is a relatively young post - nova , it was expected that the white dwarf remains very hot and that the accretion rate should be quite high due to irradiation and/or bloating of the donor star by the nova event . however , the spectroscopic study by schmidtobreick et al.(2005 ) presented evidence that the accretion rate in v842 cen is considerably lower than expected .
moreover , the xmm study of luna et al.(2012 ) revealed a surprisingly low accretion rate , given that the system underwent a nova so relatively recently .
indeed , the x - ray luminosity of v842 cen appears to be below the flux level of other low inclination ips where the accretion region is directly visible ( woudt et al.2009 ) . if the accretion rate is as low as indicated by luna et al .
( 2012 ) , then it is possible that the underlying white dwarf photosphere is exposed in this old nova since the disk luminosity and the temperatures / luminosities of the accretion spots would be low enough that the white dwarf photospheric fuv flux dominates .
however , the problem with seeing primarily the white dwarf or a low disk luminosity is that the v magnitude of the system is still 2 magnitudes brighter than at quiescence .
an argument in favor of a disk is that the v - j color of 1 is more consistent with a disk than a hot wd .
if the underlying wd photospheric in v842 cen is exposed , then this is a rarity among ips since they are not known to undergo low states and the wd photospheric light is typically swamped by the accretion light of the heated polar spots and the accretion curtains . given that the intermediate polar status of v842 cen is not solidly confirmed but rests solely on the optical data , we explored model fitting using full accretion disk models alone , as though the wd is non - magnetic . since the low accretion rate in this old nova suggests that the white dwarf is exposed , then we also explored model fitting of the hst cos data with single temperature white dwarf photospheres .
our first fitting experiment implicitly assumed that v842 cen is a non - magnetic nova .
therefore , we utilized single temperature , solar composition white dwarf models . for this procedure , we fitted the cos spectrum with a total of 560 photosphere models between 15,000k and 70,000k with log g varying from 7 to 9 . without exception , the fits were poor with either the lyman alpha profile being far too broad when the continuum had the correct slope or with fair agreement to the lyman alpha profile but a markedly incorrect continuum slope .
moreover , the distances yielded by the photosphere fits are implausibly close .
hence , we have ruled out that the cos spectrum arises from a white dwarf photosphere . in figure 5 ,
a typical photosphere fit to the cos spectrum is shown with teff = 31,000k , log g = 8.6 .
our next fitting attempt used full accretion disks from the model grid of wade and hubeny ( 1998 ) .
there is substantial observational evidence supporting a low inclination for v842 cen but we explored all inclinations in the grid models . out of the roughly 900 disk models using every combination of @xmath24 , m@xmath25 , we tried to pinpoint the best - fitting accretion - disk model , wd model or combination of a disk and wd .
the full disk models yield quite good fits for low mass accretion rates , leading to distances of a few hundred parsecs .
the inclusion of a model wd with the disk model fits did not yield any significant improvement .
the best fitting full accretion disk fit has @xmath26 yr@xmath27 , @xmath28 , but a distance of only 210 pc if the wd mass is @xmath29 . if @xmath30 , then d = 281 pc . to obtain greater distances , close to 1 kpc , then mdot has to be > m@xmath31 m@xmath32 yr@xmath27 , for @xmath33 . all lower mass white dwarfs ( hence larger radii ) are ruled out as the distance becomes shorter . in figure 6 , we display the best - fitting full disk .
the blue regions in the figure are masked out of the fit for which the @xmath34 .
lower and higher inclinations than @xmath28 do not yield a distance @xmath35250 pc
. models that yielded larger distances up to 500pc deviate significantly and have much larger @xmath36 values . given the strong possiblity that v842 cen is an intermediate polar ,
trunacted accretion disk models are needed for comparison with the hst cos data .
but for a magnetic accretor , additional free parameters are introduced to the fitting such as the field strength , magnetic moment , disk truncation radius , and flux components associated with the accretion spots and the accretion curtains .
since the magnetic field strength of the white dwarf is unknown , the truncation radius of the accretion disk is a free parameter .
we made a first guess at the magnetic moment of the white dwarf by comparing it with magnetic wds in intermediate polars tabulated by belle & sion ( 2009 ) and mukai ( 2012 ) .
we created full accretion disk models using tlusty and synspec .
we then subtracted out inner annuli that had radii less than the inner disk radius .
because accretion disks do not have uv flux - contributing annuli past @xmath1 , we used the inner disk radius calculated from the optical emission line wings . from optical emission line wing velocities , assuming a keplerian disk , @xmath37 = 2.5 - 9.0 @xmath1 .
we then subtracted out inner annuli that had radii less than the inner disk radius .
we used the magnetic parameters of ex hydrae as approximate input for our truncated disk models for v832 cen since the wd masses and lower accretion rates of the two systems appear similar .
we adopted a magnetic moment of @xmath38 g@xmath39 ( norton et al.2004 ) and truncation radii of 3 @xmath1 and 5 @xmath1 .
we carried out truncated disk fits to the cos data for truncation radii of 3 @xmath1 and 5 @xmath1 .
for both truncation radii , and for disk inclinations of @xmath40 , @xmath41 , and @xmath42 , none of the fits were satisfactory .
for @xmath33 , the entire disk is only 10 @xmath1 to 12 @xmath1 in diameter so a truncation of the disk radius in that range leaves only a few annuli or no annuli at all . in figure 7
, we display a truncated disk fit for a disk inclination @xmath40 , a wd mass @xmath43 and accretion rate @xmath44 m@xmath32 yr@xmath27 . figures 8 and 9 show truncated model fits for the same parameters as figure 7 but with disk inclinations of @xmath41 and @xmath42 , respectively .
if the accretion rate were increased above @xmath45 m@xmath32 yr@xmath27 , then the accretion rate and diameter of the truncated disk would increase but the increased mass residing in the outer disk and the higher accretion rate would contradict the observations of schmidtobreick et al.(2005 ) , woudt et al .
( 2009 ) , and luna et al.(2012 ) demonstrating that the accretion rate is low .
the optical spectroscopic and photometric studies , including the optical data presented in this work , lend support to the classification of v842 cen as an intermediate polar . however , there are major difficulties with the intermediate polar classification .
the lack of a detection of the spin period in the uv cos data is also a problem .
the non - detection of x - rays by three different x - ray observatories , rosat , swift and xmm - newton and hence no x - ray signature of spin casts serious doubt on the ip classification .
moreover , our best - fitting , and simplest , accretion disk model of the hst cos observation is a full optically thick , steady state accretion disk with no magnetic truncation and a distance shorter than 500 pc .
our model fitting of the hst cos data rules out a white dwarf photosphere as the source of the fuv flux and indicates a surprisingly low accretion rate for a classical nova only 26 years after the explosion in 1986 when the accretion rate is expected to be high and the white dwarf should still be very hot .
indeed , the best model fit that we achieved was with a full optically thick disk appropriate for a non - magnetic white dwarf . this best - fit model has a solar mass white dwarf , @xmath41 , m@xmath46 m@xmath32 yr@xmath27 with a scale - factor derived distance of several hundred pc but still well below the distance of sekiguchi et al.(1989 ) and gill and obrien ( 1998 ) of 1 kpc . despite the indicators discussed above
, one can not rule out that v842 cen is an ip , based upon the optical observations alone .
however , definitive proof of an ip usually requires confirmatory x - ray observations ( k. mukai , private communication ) .
it is possible that the x - ray emission was either gone or reduced in amplitude at the time of the x - ray observations or that the x - rays were absorbed by material above the disk plane .
it is possible that the magnetic field of the white dwarf in v842 cen is weaker than in other ips with stable rotational signals from rotating white dwarf primaries ( woudt et al .
2009 ) . in this scenario ,
a more weakly magnetic rotating white dwarf would not exhibit a strong rotational signal for very long after the nova event because the magnetosphere of the wd is crushed by the ram pressure of the accretion flow . on the other hand
, this scenario for v842 cen requires that the enhanced accretion flow induced by irradiation of the donor be unexpectedly short - lived and the cooling of the very hot , post - nova white dwarf would be surprisingly rapid . the observational constraint that v842 cen s supersoft phase was no longer than 3.5 years may support extraordinarly rapid post - outburst evolution . in any event ,
the accretion rate is surprisingly low and the hot component cooler than expected for only 24 years post - nova , especially if irradiation of the donor star took place .
our interpretation remains fraught with puzzles .
why is the spin not evident in the fuv ( or x - rays ) ?
why is the v - magnitude two magnitudes brighter than pre - outburst if the accretion rate is low ?
why is there a large variation ( in uv flux ( and optical to a lesser degree ) during the 40 minutes of observation when , at low inclination , a full disk should be flat ? clearly , further observations and modeling are required before this conclusion becomes irrefutable .
the fact is that our present knowledge of post - nova behavior is poor and the broad spectroscopic diversity seen among post - novae with similar elapsed times since their outbursts is not yet understood .
wood , m. 1995 , in white dwarfs , proc . of the 9th european workshop on white dwarfs held at kiel , germany , 29 aug.1 sep .
1994 , lecture notes in physics vol .
d. koester & k. werner ( berlin : springer ) , 41 | we present ground - based optical and near infrared photometric observations and hubble space telescope cos spectroscopic observations of the old nova v842 cen ( nova cen 1986 ) .
analysis of the optical light curves reveals a peak at [email protected] with an amplitude of [email protected] mma , which is consistent with the rotation of a magnetic white dwarf primary in v842 cen that was detected earlier by woudt et al . , and led to its classification as an intermediate polar.however , our uv lightcurve created from the cos time - tag spectra does not show this periodicity .
our synthetic spectral analysis of an hst cos spectrum rules out a hot white dwarf photosphere as the source of the fuv flux .
the best - fitting model to the cos spectrum is a full optically thick accretion disk with no magnetic truncation , a low disk inclination angle , low accretion rate and a distance less than half the published distance that was determined on the basis of interstellar sodium d line strengths.truncated accretion disks with truncation radii of 3@xmath1 and 5@xmath1 yielded unsatisfactory agreement with the cos data .
the accretion rate is unexpectedly low for a classical nova only 24 years after the explosion when the accretion rate is expected to be high and the white dwarf should still be very hot , especially if irradiation of the donor star took place .
our low accretion rate is consistent with low accretion rates derived from x - ray and ground - based optical data . |
future electron - positrons colliders will require a flux of positrons much higher than what can be produced with current methods .
one of the scheme that has been proposed to achieve such flux is to use an intense flux of polarized high energy gamma rays @xcite which can be converted into polarized electron - positron pairs .
although promising this method requires the demonstration that such high intensity flux of gamma rays can be produced .
polarized positrons can be produced by compton interaction between an electron beam and a laser .
however given the low cross - section of this process , it is desirable to recycle both the photons and the electrons by , for instance , using an electron ring and a fabry - perot cavity ( fpc ) .
we decided to investigate such a scheme by installing a four - mirror fpc on the accelerator test facility ( atf ) @xcite damping ring at kek in japan .
the laser seed includes a modified commercial oscillator emmiting at 1031 nm with a repetition rate of 178.5 mhz .
we use a standard chirp pulse amplification ( cpa ) architecture in order to limit the non - linearities in the amplifier .
the amplifier is built around a commercial microstructure yb - doped double clad fiber .
the system delivers recompressed pulses of around 60 ps and up to 50 w average power .
the complete optical layout is shown on figure [ fig : optical_layout ] .
the fpc is built using the experience gained at lal in previous experiments @xcite .
the fpc is formed by 2 concave mirrors with a radius of curvature of 0.5 m and 2 flat mirrors arranged in a non - planar tetrahedron geometry ( see figure [ fig : cavity_geo ] ) .
the two concave mirrors form a @xmath2 waist at which the laser beam crosses the electron beam with a collision angle of 8 degrees .
the mirrors have a very high reflectivity ( 1 - 1060 ppm for one of them and 1 - 330 ppm for the others ) leading to a cavity finesse of the order of 3000 ( that is a power enhancement of about 1000 ) .
the duration of a round trip in the fpc is 5.6 ns .
great care had to be taken while designing the cavity to ensure that it is compatible with the ultra - high vacuum requirements of the atf ( @xmath3 mbar ) .
all the mirrors are mounted on actuators carts or tables that allow a fine adjustment of the cavity length .
furthermore one of the mirrors is mounted on a piezoelectric transducer ( pzt ) that allows to synchronize the length of the fpc with the repetition frequency of the atf by using a digital phase lock loop as shown on figure [ fig : digital_pll ] . in order to constructively stack the pulses in the fpc , it is mandatory to control the pulse to pulse phasing with an interferometric accuracy
. this is done using the pound - drever - hall method @xcite implemented in a virtex - ii fpga board as shown on figure [ fig : digital_pdh ] . the error signal generated by this method
is used to adjust the length of the laser oscillator . using this double digital feedback system
we have been able to keep the fpc locked on the atf and the laser oscillator locked on the fpc for several hours .
a detailed description of the atf at kek can be found in the literature @xcite . at the atf
the 1.28 gev electron bunches are separated by 2.8 ns .
although various fill patterns can be achieved in the atf damping ring ( dr ) , the data presented here were taken in single bunch single train mode in which the same electron bunch returns to the same position after 165 rf buckets ( one complete revolution of the atf dr equals to 462 ns ) .
given that a round trip in the fpc is 5.6 ns this means that electrons collide with the laser pulse stored in the fpc every other turn . during the collisions the gamma rays
are detected using a fast scintillation detector made of barium fluoride ( @xmath4 ) coupled with a photomultiplier tube ( pmt ) . to eliminate the slow component of scintillation an optical filter
is installed in front of the pmt .
the data acquisition is performed using a lecroy ws454 oscilloscope ( 1gs / s , 500 mhz bandwidth ) .
geant4 simulations have been used to study this calorimeter .
the fpc was commissioned in october 2010 and compton collisions were recorded on the first attempt .
we present here a brief analysis of some of the data taken . during data taking we record the waveforms from the pmt as well as the 357 mhz atf clock and laser power transmitted by fpc measured by a photodiode .
a full waveform contains approximately 200 000 samples spaced by 1 ns . on the day where the data presented here were taken the average power stored in
the cavity was 160 w. the 357 mhz clock is used to define the beginning of the periods in time during which the collisions occurred .
so , the length of the period is naturally 924 ns . for each period
we define the gate which contains the compton peak to calculate consequently its height and integral .
different quality cuts such as a cut on the shape of the electronic pulse , a cut on the arrival time of the signal etc . were applied to restrict the analysis to a high purity sample .
the shape of the detector s response creates a linear relation between the total charge and the maximum charge measured .
this can be seen as a correlation between the calculated peak height and peak integral as shown on figure [ fig : slope ] .
the spectrum of the gamma rays is shown on figure [ fig : spectrum ] .
it corresponds to the distribution of the energy deposited in the calorimeter expressed by the peak heights normalized by the laser power .
since we took data over a wide range of power stored in the fpc , we can study the gamma ray production for different ranges of that power . on figure [ fig : laserbins ]
, the average of the peak height distribution goes towards higher energy with increasing fpc power as expected . using cosmic rays for calibration , we can estimate the average number of scattered gammas per bunch crossing . according to this calibration ,
a peak height of 1 mv is equivalent to 34 mev of energy deposited in the calorimeter . assuming the mean energy of scattered gammas to be 24 mev , approximately 4 gammas are produced in average per bunch crossing ( for an average laser power stored in the cavity of 160 w ) .
as the repetition frequency of the collisions is about 1 mhz the flux of gamma rays achieved is about @xmath0 @xmath1/s ( this does not take into account the 0.75 duty cycle of the atf ) .
our experiment has been suspended due to the earthquake that struck japan in march 2011 however we plan to resume soon . to increase the compton flux we intend to replace the mirrors of the cavity by mirrors with a higher reflectivity , giving a finesse of about 30 000 .
we also plan to improve the laser system and to replace our gamma rays data acquisition chain with a faster one .
numerical simulations have shown that with the flux achieved so far we do not expect significant effects on the dynamics of the stored beam @xcite . however , with these future improvements , we intend to study the impact of compton collisions on the beam dynamics in the dr . | the next generation of e+/e- colliders will require a very intense flux of gamma rays to allow high current polarized positrons to be produced .
this can be achieved by converting polarized high energy photons in polarized pairs into a target . in that context
, an optical system consisting of a laser and a four - mirror passive fabry - perot cavity has recently been installed at the accelerator test facility ( atf ) at kek to produce a high flux of polarized gamma rays by inverse compton scattering . in this contribution , we describe the experimental system and present preliminary results . an ultra - stable four - mirror non planar geometry has been implemented to ensure the polarization of the gamma rays produced . a fiber amplifier is used to inject about 10w in the high finesse cavity with a gain of 1000 . a digital feedback system is used to keep the cavity at the length required for the optimal power enhancement .
preliminary measurements show that a flux of about @xmath0 @xmath1/s with an average energy of about 24 mev was generated .
several upgrades currently in progress are also described . |
controllable single - photon transport is of central importance in quantum information processing .
there have been many recent experimental @xcite and theoretical @xcite works probing the photon transport properties of a wavelength - scale cavity that incorporates a two- or multi - level system .
these works encompass both the weak and the strong coupling regime .
traditionally , such a system is typically studied with quantum trajectory method @xcite which , as a monte carlo approach , is inherently stochastic @xcite .
other approaches include employing a master equation @xcite or input - output formalism @xcite that assume a weak input coherent state , and usually involves uncontrolled approximations @xcite . however , the recent experiments allow us to determine the response to the input of a single injected photon .
thus , a theoretical framework that allows one to directly calculate the response of such a system to a single injected photon is valuable . in this article
, we provide a full quantum - mechanical and deterministic approach to solve the response of this system to a single photon , yielding a wealth of information on the transport properties , as well as the effects of dissipations to the relative phase between the excitations of the cavity mode and the two - level system .
our formalism treats the problems in real space , which is particularly convenient for discussing photon transport from one space - time point to another one .
moreover , the treatment is exact , and makes no assumptions on temporal behaviors of the constituents of the system .
rather , our formalism allows direct computation of the temporal evolution of the system .
we first describe a few configurations of the systems that is relevant to this paper .
[ fi : schematics](a ) and ( b ) show schematically a single - mode waveguide side - coupled to a cavity interacting with a two - level atom , where the cavity can be a single - mode microcavity ( fig .
[ fi : schematics](a ) ) , or a ring resonator that supports two degenerate counter - propagating modes ( fig .
[ fi : schematics](b ) ) .
several notable solid - state systems are of such geometry : a superconducting quantum bit - coplanar waveguide system @xcite , an atom - microtoroidal resonator - waveguide geometry @xcite , and a solid - state quantum dot - microdisk - waveguide system @xcite
. the second configuration has a single - mode cavity direct - coupled to the waveguide , as shown in fig .
[ fi : schematics](c ) .
many atomic cavity quantum electrodynamics ( cavity qed ) experiments use this configuration @xcite . in this paper
, we will focus on systems as described in fig .
[ fi : schematics](a ) and ( c ) .
the formalism can be generalized to treat the system in fig .
[ fi : schematics](b ) which will be published in a separate article .
the article is organized as follows : in sec .
[ sec : hamiltonian ] the effective real - space hamiltonian of the systems is introduced , and the exact one - photon solution is given .
[ sec : nodissipation ] discusses the non - dissipative case , give the transmission spectrum , the cavity and the atomic excitation amplitude , and point out the possibility of using the system as a single - photon switch by tuning the atomic transition frequency . in sec .
[ sec : dissipation ] , we examine the effects of the dissipations in the system .
our results indicate that the dissipation of the cavity and the atom , respectively , affects the transmission and the coherence between the cavity and the atom in qualitatively different manner . finally , in sec .
[ sec : direct ] we show that the single - photon transport of the direct - coupled case of fig .
[ fi : schematics](c ) can be mapped into those of the side - coupled case , thus the single - photon transport properties of the two systems are related .
we discuss the transmission spectrum of this case , and compare our results with experimental data of a recent circuit qed experiment .
in this section , we will derive an effective real - space hamiltonian to describe the systems of interest . as will be shown in later sections ,
such a real - space representation is particularly convenient for discussing the transport properties of the photons .
the interaction between propagating photons and a cavity with a single mode can be described by the hamiltonian @xcite : @xmath0where @xmath1 is the frequency of the mode of the propagating photon field corresponding to wave vector @xmath2 , _ i.e. _ , the dispersion relation .
@xmath3 ( @xmath4 ) is the bosonic creation ( annihilation ) operator of the propagating photon mode , @xmath5 is the resonance frequency of the cavity mode , @xmath6 ( @xmath7 ) is the bosonic creation ( annihilation ) operator of the cavity mode , and @xmath8 is the coupling between the cavity and the waveguide , which leads to the decay of cavity mode into the waveguide .
we now specialize eq .
( [ e : dicke ] ) to the case of a single - mode waveguide . by linearizing the dispersion ,
the effective real - space hamiltonian can be derived .
the typical dispersion @xmath1 of a single - mode waveguide is shown in fig .
[ fi : dispersion ] . for an arbitrary frequency @xmath9 that is away from the cut - off of the dispersion , with the corresponding wave vector @xmath10 ,
one approximates @xmath1 around @xmath11 and @xmath12 as [ e : linearboth ] @xmath13 where the subscripts @xmath14 and @xmath15 are used to label the branch . since we will be interested in a narrow bandwidth in vicinity of @xmath9
, we can further extend the range of @xmath16 and @xmath17 to @xmath18 .
thus , after linearizing the dispersion , one has @xmath19 each term on the right hand side of eq .
( [ e : afterlinearizing ] ) now can be easily represented in real space . by defining the fourier
transform @xmath20 where @xmath21 ( @xmath22 ) creates ( annihilates ) a right - moving photon at @xmath23 , the first term becomes @xmath24similarly , by defining @xmath25 where @xmath26 ( @xmath27 ) creates ( annihilates ) a left - moving photon at @xmath23 , the second term becomes @xmath28 the interaction term transforms as @xmath29 in deriving eq .
( [ e : linearizinginteraction ] ) , @xmath8 , the coupling strength between the cavity and waveguide , is assumed to be independent of @xmath2 , and is denoted by @xmath30 .
this assumption is equivalent to the markov approximation @xcite .
the linearization procedure is analogous to a commonly used procedure in electronic cases , where @xmath11 is chosen as the fermi wave vector @xmath31 @xcite .
having described the cavity - waveguide coupling , we now include both the atom part , as well as the interactions of the atom and the cavity with the reservoirs .
such interactions with reservoirs give rise to intrinsic dissipation @xcite .
the hamiltonian of the _ composite _ system @xmath32 is @xmath33 : @xmath34\notag\\ & + \omega_c a^{\dagger } a + g\left(\sigma_+ a + a^{\dagger } \sigma_{-}\right)\notag\\ & + \omega_e a_e^{\dagger}a_e + \omega_g a_g^{\dagger}a_g,\\ h_r/\hbar & \equiv h_{r_1}/\hbar + h_{r_2}/\hbar \notag\\ & \equiv \sum_j \omega_{1j } r_{1j}^{\dagger}r_{1j}+\sum_j \omega_{2j } r_{2j}^{\dagger}r_{2j},\\ h_{sr}/\hbar & \equiv h_{sr_1}/\hbar + h_{sr_2}/\hbar\notag\\ & \equiv \sum_j\left(\kappa^{*}_j r_{1j}^{\dagger}a + \kappa_j a^{\dagger } r_{1j}\right)+ \sum_j\left(\eta^{*}_j r_{2j}^{\dagger}\sigma_{- } + \eta_j \sigma_+ r_{2j}\right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath35 is the hamiltonian of the system @xmath36 of coupled waveguide - cavity - atom .
this hamiltonian includes the atomic part , and the interaction between the atom and the cavity .
@xmath37(@xmath38 ) is the creation operator of the ground ( excited ) state of the atom , @xmath39(@xmath40 ) is the atomic raising ( lowering ) ladder operator satisfying @xmath41 and @xmath42 , where @xmath43 describes the state of the system @xmath36 with @xmath44 propagating photons , @xmath45 photons in cavity mode , and the atom in the excited ( @xmath46 ) or ground ( @xmath47 ) state .
@xmath48 is the atomic transition frequency .
@xmath49 is the coupling strength between the cavity and the atom .
@xmath50 describes the reservoir , which is composed of two subsystems : @xmath51 , where the cavity couples only to @xmath52 , and the atom couples only to @xmath53 .
@xmath52 and @xmath53 are assumed to be independent .
each @xmath54 and @xmath53 is modeled as a collection of harmonic oscillators with frequencies @xmath55 and @xmath56 , and with the corresponding creation ( annihilation ) operators @xmath57 ( @xmath58 ) , and @xmath59 ( @xmath60 ) , respectively .
@xmath61 describes the interactions between the cavity and the atom with the reservoirs , respectively .
the cavity @xmath6 couples to the @xmath62th reservoir oscillator @xmath58 in @xmath52 with a coupling constant @xmath63 , while the atom @xmath64 couples to the @xmath62th reservoir oscillator @xmath60 in @xmath53 with a coupling constant @xmath65 . in appendix [ a : reservoircoupling ] , we show that by incorporating the excitation amplitudes of the reservoir @xmath14 , the effective hamiltonian @xmath66 of @xmath36 can be obtained and is given by : @xmath67\notag\\ & + \left(\omega_c -i\frac{1}{\tau_c}\right ) a^\dagger a + \left(\omega_e - i\frac{1}{\tau_a}\right ) a_e^{\dagger } a_e + \omega_g a_g^{\dagger } a_g\notag\\ & + \int dx\ , v\delta(x)\left(c_r^{\dagger}(x ) a + a^{\dagger}c_r(x ) + c_l^{\dagger}(x ) a + a^{\dagger}c_l(x)\right)\notag\\ & + g(a\sigma_+ + a^{\dagger}\sigma_{-}),\end{aligned}\]]where @xmath68 and @xmath69 are the dissipation rates of the cavity and the atom , respectively , due to coupling to the reservoir
. we will call @xmath66 as @xmath70 in the following for brevity . note that @xmath71 , @xmath49 , @xmath72 , and @xmath73 all have the same unit as frequency .
the temporal evolution of an arbitrary state @xmath74 describing the system @xmath36 is described by the schrdinger equation @xmath75 where @xmath70 is the effective hamiltonian of the system in eq . , and
@xmath74 can be expanded as @xmath76where @xmath77 is the vacuum , with zero photon in both the waveguide and the cavity , and with the atom in the ground state .
@xmath78 is the single - photon wavefunction in the @xmath79 mode .
@xmath80 is the time - dependent excitation amplitude of the cavity , and @xmath81 is the time - dependent excitation amplitude of the atom .
the expansion of the state @xmath74 in eq .
assumes that the atom was initially in the ground state and the cavity was empty when the incoming photon was at @xmath82 .
the schrdinger equation ( eq . ( [ e : schrodinger ] ) ) thus gives the following set of equations of motion : [ e : teom ] @xmath83 for any given initial state @xmath84 , the dynamics of the system can be obtained straightforwardly by numerically integrating the set of equations , eqs .
( [ e : teom ] ) . in particular , one could study the time - dependent transport of an arbitrary single - photon wave packet . in the following , we concentrate on the single - photon transport of constant frequency .
when @xmath74 is an eigenstate of frequency @xmath85 , _ i.e. _ , @xmath86 , eq . (
[ e : schrodinger ] ) yields the time - independent eigen equation @xmath87 and the interacting steady - state solution @xmath88 can be solved for . here
@xmath89 is the total energy of the coupled system @xmath36 , with @xmath90 , and @xmath91 . for an input state of one - photon fock state ,
the most general interacting eigenstate for the hamiltonian of @xmath70 takes the following form : @xmath92 , etc .
the connection between the interacting eigenstate and a typical scattering experiment is described by the lippmann - schwinger formalism @xcite .
the time - independent schrdinger equation of eq .
( [ e : timeindependent ] ) for the state @xmath88 of eq .
( [ e : interactingeigenstate ] ) yields the following equations of motion : [ e : eom ] @xmath93 with @xmath90 , and @xmath91 .
our aim is to solve for the transmission and reflection amplitudes for an incident photon . for this purpose , we take @xmath94 , and @xmath95 , where @xmath96 is the transmission amplitude , and @xmath97 is the reflection amplitude @xcite . solving eqs . - for @xmath98 , @xmath96 , @xmath97 , @xmath99 , and @xmath100 gives : @xmath101 which are valid in both strong and weak coupling regimes . before we proceed , here we briefly outline some of the main features of the transmission amplitude @xmath96 of eq .
( [ e : t ] ) . in a waveguide - side - coupled cavity - atom system as shown in fig .
[ fi : schematics](a ) , when the cavity mode and the atom are in - tune ( @xmath102 ) , the transmission spectrum is always symmetric with respect to the atomic transition frequency ( @xmath103 ) .
moreover , the transmission spectrum has two dips with spectral separation proportional to the atom - cavity coupling , and an on - resonance photon attains local maximum .
this is in contrast to the rabi splitting peaks in a direct - coupled cavity wherein an on - resonance attains local minimum .
the transmission spectrum remains symmetric even when the cavity and the atom dissipations are present , and only becomes asymmetric when the cavity and the atom are detuned .
also , a finite cavity dissipation does not destroy the phase relation between the atom and the cavity , but the atomic dissipation does .
here as a side note we make a comment on a recent approach using the input - output formalism to obtain the transmission and reflection amplitudes . in ref .
[ ] , in order to linearize the nonlinear term @xmath104 in the equations of motion of the heisenberg operators ( see eq .
( 2 ) in ref . [ ] ) , the two - level atom is approximated to be in the ground state all the time , such that @xmath105 is subsequently substituted with @xmath106 .
in fact , this approximation is non - physical , as can be seen from the exact solutions here , since the atom is strongly excited even with a single photon , in the absence of strong dissipation , which is the case of interest here .
such excitation is crucially important for using the atom to control the photon transport .
instead , one can show that the equations of motion in the heisenberg picture for the operators can give rise to a set of exact equations of motion of the amplitudes that is closed , provided we sandwich the operators with @xmath88 and vacuum state @xmath107 .
this set of equations has solutions identical to eq .
( [ e : t])-([e : ea ] ) . in particular , the nonlinear term @xmath104 gives the matrix element @xmath108 , which , after dividing the common factor @xmath109 on both sides of eq .
( 2 ) in ref .
[ ] , gives the @xmath110 term as in eq .
( [ e : eom4 ] ) . in doing so , one can then derive all the amplitudes , @xmath99 etc .
, and hence determines @xmath111 the single - photon transport is exactly solvable in both schrdinger picture and heisenberg picture .
below we investigate the effects of dissipations on the transmission spectrum .
we start by discussing the non - dissipative case , followed by examining the dissipations of the cavity and of the atom .
for each case , we will focus on the changes due to dissipations on the local maxima and minima determined from @xmath112 .
( 1)_atom - cavity in tune _ ( @xmath114 ) : the transmission spectrum for this case is shown in fig . [ fi : nodissipations](a ) .
the spectrum exhibits a maximum at @xmath115 . at @xmath115 ,
the on - resonance photon completely transmits ( @xmath116 ) , and the cavity is not excited ( @xmath117 ) , but only the atom is excited ( @xmath118 ) .
we note that , in contrast , when only the atom or the cavity is present , an on - resonance photon is completely reflected @xcite .
the transmission spectrum shows two minima at @xmath119 , which correspond to the rabi - splitted frequencies . at @xmath120 , the photon is completely reflected ( @xmath121 ) .
also , @xmath122 , thus the cavity excitation and the atom excitation are of equal amplitude and either in - phase or completely out of phase with each other .
the full - width at half - minimum ( @xmath123 ) of each dip is exactly @xmath71 , independent of the atom - photon coupling constant @xmath49 .
( in comparison , for a side - coupled cavity with no atom embedded , the cavity decay rate is also @xmath71 ) .
the spectral distance between the two local minima is @xmath124 .
when @xmath49 is small , the transmission peak thus becomes very narrow , exhibiting a spectrum that is analogous to electromagnetically induced transparency phenomena @xcite , as shown in fig .
[ fi : nodissipations](b ) .
( 2)_atom - cavity detuned _ ( @xmath125 ) : when the photon is on - resonant with the atom(@xmath115 ) , the transmission amplitude is always 1 , regardless of the detuning between the atom and the cavity , as shown in fig .
[ fi : nodissipations](c ) . on the other hand , when the atom is far detuned from the cavity resonance frequency ( @xmath126 ) , the single photon transmission spectrum has dips down to zero at the cavity frequency @xmath127 .
this feature could be exploited to achieve a fast single - photon switch : for an incoming photon with frequency @xmath128 , the transmission is 1 when the atom is in - tuned with the cavity ( @xmath129 ) ; while the transmission is essentially 0 when the atom is far detuned .
thus , by tuning the transition frequency of the atom , the single - photon transport can be regulated and the setup acts as a single - photon switch , as shown by fig .
[ fi : nodissipations](d ) .
this effect was pointed out in ref .
[ ] , here we give an exact derivation of this effect .
the unavoidable intrinsic dissipative processes in the system always result in the leakage of photons into non - waveguided degrees of freedom .
in general , the dissipations affect the transmission properties , and change the phase relation between the excitation amplitudes of the cavity mode and the atom .
however , as we show below , the dissipation of the cavity and of the atom affect these properties rather differently .
( 1)_atom - cavity in - tune , dissipative cavity _ ( @xmath114 ; @xmath130 and @xmath131 ) : the transmission spectrum is shown in fig .
[ fi : allcases](a ) .
the overall transmission spectrum remains symmetric with respect to @xmath115 .
the locations of the local maximum @xmath115 , and the local minima @xmath119 , are independent of cavity dissipation @xmath72 and are the same as in the dissipationless case . at @xmath115 ,
one still has @xmath116 , @xmath132 , and @xmath118 .
remarkably , a photon at this frequency still transmits perfectly and the cavity is not excited , even with the presence of the cavity dissipation @xmath72 .
one can understand this result from the non - dissipative case : since the cavity is not excited for a photon at @xmath115 , the cavity dissipation makes no effect on the transmission . at @xmath119 ,
one has @xmath133 for both frequencies .
@xmath134 approximates @xmath135 when the decay rate is small such that @xmath136 , _
i.e. _ , when the coupling rate between the waveguide and the cavity is larger compared with the cavity dissipation rate . moreover , at @xmath119 , @xmath137 .
thus , while the excitation amplitudes are reduced from the previous case , both cavity and atomic excitations are still either in - phase or out - of - phase with each other with the presence of cavity dissipation and has the same amplitude .
thus , the cavity on one hand largely insulates the atom from decohering interactions with external environment @xcite , on the other hand its own dissipation does not affect either the perfect transmission of an on - resonace photon , or the phase relation between the cavity and the atom at the rabi - splitted frequencies ( @xmath119 ) . when the dissipation is small , the full - width at half - maxium ( @xmath138 ) of each dip is exactly @xmath139 , independent of the atom - photon coupling constant @xmath49 .
( 2)_atom - cavity in - tune , dissipative atom case _
( @xmath114 ; @xmath140 and @xmath141 ) : the transmission spectrum is plotted in fig .
[ fi : allcases](b ) .
the overall transmission spectrum remains symmetric with respect to @xmath115 .
the local maximum is still located at @xmath115 , independent of atom dissipation @xmath73 and is the same as in the dissipationless case .
the local minima @xmath142 , accurate up to the third order of @xmath143 , are @xmath144 . at @xmath115 ,
one has @xmath145 comparing with the dissipative cavity case above , we thus see that the atom dissipation has a stronger effect on the transmission of an on - resonance photon than the cavity dissipation does .
the relative phase @xmath146 between the cavity excitation and the atom excitation is always @xmath147 for any value of non - zero atomic dissipation .
accurate up to second order of @xmath143 , @xmath148 , and the transmission amplitude is @xmath149 thus @xmath150 when the dissipation is small .
@xmath151 at the same limit
. moreover , the cavity excitation and the atom excitation are no longer in - phase ( @xmath152 ) , even at the order of @xmath73 .
the relative phase @xmath146 between the cavity excitation and the atom excitation is given by @xmath153 .
similarly , accurate up to second order of @xmath143 , @xmath154 , and the transmission amplitude is @xmath155which is complex conjugate of @xmath96 at @xmath156 in eq .
( [ e : tkbig ] ) .
the cavity excitation and the atom excitation are no longer completely out - phase ( @xmath157 ) even at the order of @xmath73 .
the relative phase @xmath146 between the cavity excitation and the atom excitation is @xmath158 .
nonetheless , at both rabi - splitted frequencies , @xmath159 .
the full - width at half - maxium ( @xmath160 ) of each dip is @xmath161 , independent of the atom - photon coupling constant @xmath49 .
( 3)_atom - cavity in - tune , dissipative cavity and atom case _ ( @xmath114 ; @xmath72 , @xmath141 ) : the local maximum is still located at @xmath115 exactly , while the rabi - splitted frequencies are shifted to @xmath162 .
the transmission spectrum remains symmetric with respect to @xmath115 . at @xmath115 , @xmath163
thus @xmath134 approximates @xmath164 , when @xmath165 , and @xmath72 , and is independent of cavity decay rate @xmath72 .
@xmath166 at this limit .
the cavity is slightly excited with @xmath167 .
the relative phase @xmath146 between the cavity excitation and the atom excitation is always @xmath147 for any value of non - zero atomic dissipation . at @xmath168 , @xmath169 .
the cavity excitation and the atom excitation are not in - phase at the order of @xmath73 .
similarly , at @xmath170 , @xmath169 , and the cavity excitation and the atom excitation are not completely out - phase even at the order of @xmath73 . also , the transmission amplitudes at two local minima are complex conjugate to each other , @xmath171 ( 4)_detuned , dissipative cavity and atom case _ ( @xmath172 ; @xmath72 , @xmath141 ) : when the cavity and the atom are in - tune , the single - photon transmission spectrum is always symmetric with respect to @xmath115 , regardless of the dissipations .
when the atomic transition frequency @xmath103 is detuned slightly away from the cavity frequency @xmath5 , the transmission spectrum becomes asymmetric .
the frequency of the local maximum is now located between @xmath103 and @xmath5 .
remarkably , there exists an optimal frequency for the incident single photons such that at which frequency the magnitude of the transmission is _ insensitive _ to the frequency detuning @xmath173 .
this `` cavity protected ''
optimal frequency can be obtained by expanding @xmath174 with respect to @xmath175 and numerically solving the resultant polynomial equation .
when the cavity and atom dissipations are small , retain only the first order term is enough , and the optimal frequency is essential at @xmath115 , as demonstrated in fig .
[ fi : allcases](c ) .
such optimal frequency could be useful to stabilize the single - photon transmission when the cavity frequency experiences drifting .
also , in the far - detuned case , the atom is essentially decoupled from the cavity , thus the transmission properties at @xmath127 are determined by the cavity only .
another configuration often employed in photon transport experiments is to directly place the cavity in the waveguide , as shown in fig .
[ fi : schematics](c ) . in this case , the transmitted photons in the forward direction can only do so by tunneling in and out of the cavity . in comparison ,
the reflected photons in the side - coupled case also has only contribution from the cavity .
thus , one anticipates that the _ transmission _ amplitude of the direct - coupled case is related to the _ reflection _ amplitude of the side - coupled case .
we show in the following that it is indeed so . to describe the direct - coupled case in fig .
[ fi : schematics](c ) , we first construct the hamiltonian for the system , which involves the fields in the left ( @xmath176 ) and right ( @xmath97 ) branches , and their interaction via the cavity , as shown in fig .
[ fi : folding ] . for the left branch ,
we define a field @xmath177 such that @xmath178 describes a photon that is moving to the right at @xmath179 in the left branch , and @xmath180 describes a photon that is moving to the left at @xmath179 in the left branch .
thus , @xmath178 describes an incoming photon and @xmath180 describes an outgoing photon in the left branch . in order to take into account the phase shift that occurs during the reflection at the end of the waveguide , we write the following hamiltonian @xmath181 here @xmath182 is the phase shift due to reflection , as shown below .
@xmath183 is a switch - on function with the general property that @xmath184 and @xmath185 in a short spatial extent , otherwise the specific form is unimportant . for computational purpose , one can take , for example , @xmath186 , where the spatial turning range is controlled by @xmath7 . the hamiltonian in eq .
( [ e : leftbranch ] ) is in fact equivalent to a free hamiltonian via the the following canonical ( gauge ) transformation : @xmath187__i.e . _ _ , the @xmath176-branch mode of the direct - coupled case is folded from the @xmath14-mode of the side - coupled case .
( [ e : leftbranch ] ) becomes @xmath188 the corresponding eigen wavefunctions of @xmath189 ( eq . ) and of @xmath50 ( eq . ) transform to each other according to @xmath190thus , in the left branch , for an incoming wave @xmath191 at @xmath192 , the outgoing wave ( _ i.e. _ , reflected wave ) acquires a phase @xmath182 to become @xmath193 at @xmath194 .
similarly , for the right ( @xmath97 ) branch in fig .
[ fi : folding ] , we define a field @xmath195 such that @xmath196 describes a photon that is moving to the right at @xmath197 in the right branch , and @xmath198 describes a photon that is moving to the left at @xmath197 in the right branch . thus , @xmath198 describes an incoming photon and @xmath196 describes an outgoing photon in the right branch .
the field in the right branch is described by the hamiltonian @xmath199via the canonical transformation @xmath200 _
i.e. _ , the @xmath97-branch mode of the direct - coupled case is folded from the @xmath15-mode of the side - coupled case , the hamiltonian @xmath201 of eq .
can be transformed into a free hamiltonian @xmath202with the wavefunction transformed as @xmath203 when the cavity is present to allow the tunneling between the @xmath176 and @xmath97 branches , the hamiltonian is @xmath204which , using eq .
( [ e : ltor ] ) and ( [ e : rtol ] ) , can be written as : @xmath205 similar to the hamiltonian of eq .
( [ e : hamiltonian ] ) but with the additional phase terms in the cavity - waveguide coupling terms
. it can be shown straightforwardly that the single - photon transmission and reflection amplitudes for systems described by the hamiltonian of eq .
( [ e : hamiltonian ] ) and of eq .
( [ e : hamiltonianwithphase ] ) respectively are identical and are both independent of @xmath182 and @xmath206 .
only the cavity and atomic excitation amplitudes depend upon @xmath182 and @xmath206
. the relations between each eigenfunctions are given by @xmath207 , and @xmath208 , _
i.e. _ , in the direct - coupled case the _ reflection _
amplitude is @xmath209 and the _ transmission _ amplitude is @xmath210 , where @xmath96 and @xmath97 are the transmission and reflection amplitudes of the side - coupled case discussed above ( eq . ( [ e : t ] ) and ( [ e : r ] ) ) .
this relation establishes the intuitive physical picture at the beginning of this section . to demonstrate the validity of our approach
, we apply our formalism to the transmission spectrum of single photons in a solid - state circuit qed system @xcite , where a superconducting josephson junction qubit is embedded in a cavity capacitively direct - coupled to a transmission line waveguide ( fig .
[ fi : schematics](c ) ) , thus the transmission amplitude is described by @xmath210 ( eq . ( [ e : r ] ) ) .
[ fi : fitting ] shows the results , where it is clearly seen that the experimental data can be fitted extremely well by @xmath211 @xcite .
importantly , our results indicate that the asymmetry in the two transmission peaks at the rabi frequencies is likely due to very slight frequency detuning between the cavity and the qubit .
dissipation and decoherence processes limit the performances of quantum information processing devices .
a thorough understanding on such processes therefore are of vital importance in the realistic implementations of any such quantum devices .
we have shown the impacts of the dissipations on the entanglement in a waveguide - cavity - atom system . here
we make some final remarks on our approach .
our approach could be generalized to take into account of other atomic degrees of freedom , such as multi - level atomic system , as well as the motion and the polarizability of the atom .
this allows the alternative treatment of a number of interesting one - dimensional problems , such as the resonant radiation pressure on neutral particles in a waveguide @xcite , strong optical interactions between particles @xcite , resonance cooling of polarizable particles @xcite , and low - light - level optical interactions with atomic vapor in fiber @xcite .
shen acknowledges the informative discussions with j. shin at stanford and k. srinivasan at nist .
s. fan acknowledges financial support by the david and lucile packard foundation .
in the effective hamiltonian of eq . , the dissipation rates of the cavity and the atom are characterized by @xmath72 and @xmath73 , respectively . here
we show explicitly how these intrinsic dissipation rates emerge as the system @xmath36 couples to a reservoir @xmath14 . to illustrate the physics
, we will use as an example a system that consists of an atom in a waveguide , in which the atom also couples to a reservoir , to derive the effective hamiltonian and to show that coupling to the reservoir yields a damped atom .
the same procedures carry through for the cavity - atom case as well .
the hamiltonian of the composite system @xmath32 is @xmath33 : @xmath212\notag\\ & + \omega_e a_e^{\dagger}a_e + \omega_g a_g^{\dagger}a_g,\\ h_r/\hbar & \equiv \sum_j \omega_j r_j^{\dagger}r_j,\\ h_{sr}/\hbar & \equiv \sum_j\left(\eta^{*}_j r_j^{\dagger}\sigma_{- } + \eta_j \sigma_+ r_j\right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath35 is the hamiltonian of the system @xmath36 of coupled waveguide - atom . the reservoir @xmath14 is modeled as a collection of harmonic oscillators with frequencies @xmath213 , and with the corresponding creation ( annihilation ) operators @xmath214 ( @xmath215 ) .
@xmath61 describes the interactions between the atom and the reservoir .
an arbitrary time - independent one - excitation state in @xmath32 is given by latexmath:[\]]where @xmath238 , and we have absorbed @xmath239 into @xmath240 .
the state is entirely in @xmath36 and is given by @xmath241|\emptyset\rangle + e_a \sigma_{+}|\emptyset\rangle.\ ] ] this approach thus yields a damped atom . | the single - photon transport in a single - mode waveguide , coupled to a cavity embedded with a two - leval atom is analyzed .
the single - photon transmission and reflection amplitudes , as well as the cavity and the atom excitation amplitudes , are solved exactly via a real - space approach .
it is shown that the dissipation of the cavity and of the atom respectively affects distinctively on the transport properties of the photons , and on the relative phase between the excitation amplitudes of the cavity mode and the atom . |
recurrent novae ( rne ) are ordinary novae ( binary systems with mass accreting onto a white dwarf until thermonuclear runaway is triggered ) for which the recurrence time scale is between a decade and a century , such that more than one eruption has been observed ( payne - gaposchkin 1964 ; bode & evans 2008 ; evans et al . 2008 ) . to have the fast recurrence time scale
, the novae must have the white dwarf near the chandrasekhar mass and have a high accretion rate .
these properties , at face value , imply that the white dwarf will soon exceed the chandrasekhar mass and become a type ia supernova , and thus rne are one of the premier candidates for the progenitor class of these supernovae .
rne typically have relatively fast eruptions , high ejection velocities , and small eruption amplitudes when compared to ordinary novae .
only ten rne are known with certainty in our milky way ( schaefer 2010 ) .
u scorpii ( u sco ) previously erupted in march 1999 with a peak at v=7.5 mag ( schaefer 2010 ) . in quiescence
, it has [email protected] and has deep _ total _ eclipses taking it down to v=18.9 mag ( schaefer 2010 ) with an orbital period of 1.23 days ( schaefer 1990 ; schaefer & ringwald 1995 ) . u sco is the fastest of all known novae , fading by three magnitudes from peak in just 2.6 days , while its rise from minimum to peak is 6 - 12 hours ( schaefer 2010 ) .
no light echo was detected to deep limits after the 1987 eruption ( schaefer 1988 ) .
u sco has now had ten known eruptions , in the years 1863 , 1906 , 1917 , 1936 , 1945 , 1969 , 1979 , 1987 , 1999 ( schaefer 2010 ) , and now 2010 as we report in this paper . with the discovery of the 1917 , 1945 , and 1969 eruptions ( schaefer 2001 ; 2004 ) ,
it has become apparent that u sco has outbursts at intervals of @xmath3 years since 1900 .
the exceptions to this are the two intervals of 19 and 24 years , which are easily interpreted as being double intervals , with eruptions around 1927 and 1957 having been missed .
( u sco is @xmath4 from the sun every 28 november , so a significant fraction of its very fast eruptions must be missed . ) with this , it became apparent that the next eruption of u sco should occur in the year @xmath5 .
schaefer ( 2005 ) made a better prediction , on the physical basis that the time between eruptions scales as the inverse of the average mass accretion rate between eruptions ( as measured from the b - band flux ) , with the scaling determined by the inter - eruption light curves from prior eruptions .
the predicted eruption date was @xmath6 .
this is the first time that a specific star has been predicted to have an eruption on a specific date . with this advance notice ,
a large international collaboration was formed to provide detailed photometry and spectroscopy in the x - ray , ultraviolet , optical , and infrared bands . with u
sco going from quiescence to peak to one magnitude below peak in 24 hours , we realized that we must have frequent monitoring of u sco to get a fast alert of an eruption . to this end
, we mobilized daily and hourly photometry with the smarts 1.3-m telescope in chile , the fully - robotic 2.0-m liverpool telescope ( steele et al . 2004 ) in the canary islands , and the four rotse 0.45-m telescopes in australia , texas , namibia , and turkey .
in addition , we mobilized a large number of observers through the american association of variable star observers ( aavso ) .
for the seven months each year centered on the opposition of u sco , we got hourly data .
the headquarters of the aavso served as the international clearinghouse for discovery reports and delivery of alerts to the world .
in addition , u sco was heavily monitored from 2001 to 2009 with long time series photometry , where the main goal was to precisely measure the timing of the eclipses .
the result of all this activity from 2000 - 2010 is the all - time best pre - eruption light curve for any nova .
this paper presents all the magnitudes and an analysis of this large data set .
since 1987 , one of us ( bes ) has heavily monitored u sco , with emphasis on the light curve around the time of the eclipses ( schaefer 1990 ; 2005 ; 2010 ; schaefer & ringwald 1995 ) .
these observations have been made with the mcdonald 2.7-m , 2.1-m , and 0.8-m telescopes in texas as well as with the 1.3-m , 1.0-m , and 0.9-m telescopes on cerro tololo in chile .
the typical integration times were 300 seconds in the b - band and i - band and 100 seconds in the v - band .
normal processing was carried out , and the photometry was done using the iraf package phot , which performs aperture photometry on the stars in this uncrowded field .
the magnitude of u sco was determined relative to a selection of nearby comparison stars , for which the primary comparison star , named ` comp ' ( j2000 16:22:25.6 -17:51:34 ) , has b=16.96 , v=15.87 , r=15.25 , and i=14.59 ( schaefer 2010 ) .
the photon statistics , as calculated by phot , are generally smaller than 0.01 mag , but the systematic uncertainties , as represented by the scatter in the measures of standard star magnitudes ( landolt 1992 ; 2009 ) , are typically 0.015 mag . the quoted uncertainty is the addition in quadrature of 0.015 mag and the uncertainty from photon statistics .
this data set consists of over 2100 magnitudes , mostly as fast time series photometry centered on times of eclipses .
the specific analysis of the eclipse shapes has already been presented in schaefer ( 2010 ) , while a specific analysis of the eclipse times is reserved for a separate paper . for the study in this paper
, the eclipse effects would only hide the other variability , so we have not included any magnitudes with orbital phase between -0.10 and + 0.10 . in all
, we have 162 magnitudes in the u , b , v , r , and i filters from 2001 to 2006 .
starting in early 2008 , we ( bes , ap , and lx ) began frequent regular monitoring of u sco with the 1.3-m smarts telescope on cerro tololo .
this telescope is queue - scheduled , so an operator takes images of u sco for us several times a week , thus allowing long - term frequent monitoring without requiring us to be at the telescope year - round .
most of the observations were 300 second exposures in the b - band , but we also made several sets of nearly simultaneous bvri images .
the procedures and analysis were identical to those described in the previous paragraph . in all
, we have 145 magnitudes from early 2008 until late 2009 .
beginning in early 2008 , one of us ( bes ) started using the robotic rotse telescopes to monitor u sco once every hour .
the rotse telescopes ( akerlof et al . 2003 ) are four automated 0.45-m f/1.9 telescopes with 1.85@xmath7 fields designed to provide very fast response to satellite triggers on gamma - ray bursts .
the four telescopes are located at coonabarabran , australia ; mount gamsberg , namibia ; bakirlitepe , turkey ; and mcdonald observatory , texas . this wide coverage in
longitude gives the potential for complete time coverage .
no filters were used , so the resultant magnitudes are similar to a very broad r - band .
the exposure time was 60 seconds in all cases .
the requested cadence was one exposure every hour from every rotse telescope , but problems such as clouds , dawn , daylight , a nearby full moon , an altitude lower than 20@xmath7 , higher priority alerts for gamma - ray bursts , and the usual equipment problems all make for a substantially lower cadence . in the months around opposition ,
the rotse system achieved the ideal of nearly hourly coverage for around a quarter of the days , while the average coverage was roughly 15 images in every 24 hour interval . in the months approaching the conjunction of u sco with the sun , the daily coverage decreased to one or two images per 24 hour interval .
for example , in 2009 , rotse first recorded that u sco was not in eruption on 9 january ( 43 days after conjunction ) and last imaged u sco on 18 october ( 40 days before conjunction ) .
the limiting magnitude varied widely ( with clouds , altitude , focus , and the moon ) , yet u sco was visible at low significance on about half the images . even on the best images ,
u sco did not get better than a 5-sigma detection , so in no case do we have accurate photometry from rotse . in all
, we have a set of roughly 7000 useable u sco images from rotse .
one of the goals of the hourly monitoring by rotse was so that we ( bes , ap , and mt ) could frequently check the images to try to discover the eruption as soon as possible .
another goal was to catch any pre - eruption rise ( see section 4 ) even if the amplitude was small and the duration was short .
for the eruption in january 2010 , there was no significant pre - eruption rise and our ( bgh , sd , jm , ml ) small - telescope monitoring produced a better light curve than rotse .
a third reason for the rotse program was the hope that we would catch u sco on the rise . in all previous eruptions ,
u sco has been recorded on the rise only three times , each being close to the peak , with the rise from quiescence apparently lasting 6 - 12 hours ( schaefer 2010 ) . in the hours before the discovery of the 2010 eruption
, the namibia rotse telescope did not look at u sco due to a higher priority follow - up to a gamma - ray burst , the turkey rotse had clouds , and the australia rotse was down with equipment problems . with the chance lack of any data on the rise and the poor photometric accuracy of the two years of monitoring
, we are not presenting any of the rotse magnitudes in this paper . beginning in early 2008 ,
we ( mt and aah ) organized a steady watch on u sco by the many observers of the aavso .
the primary goal was to catch u sco s eruption as quickly as possible .
the widespread distribution in longitude of the many aavso observers makes for frequent monitoring , and this was the best chance of catching the eruption early . for the half year around opposition , u sco was checked for outburst up to 6.7 times per day for monthly averages . a further requirement for getting fast reactions from the world s
telescopes was that the discovery had to be communicated from the discoverer to the rest of the world .
for this vital need , the aavso headquarters served as an around - the - clock , every - day - of - the - year communication center .
observers were instructed to report their discovery electronically , then automated services would alert key individuals who would test for validity and solicit fast confirmation . once the eruption was discovered , we would immediately start notifying the world through iau circulars and long - prepared phone and email lists . as part of this effort , many aavso members made positive measures of the brightness of u sco during the pre - eruption phase .
the aavso database contains 412 magnitudes ( from 29 observers ) and 2853 limits ( from 102 observers ) between the end of the 1999 eruption and the start of the 2010 eruption ( jd 2451557.148 to 2455224.127 ) .
the limits were vital at the time of the observation for knowing that u sco had not erupted , but they are not now helpful for following the accretion rate .
a further 77 magnitudes are not used here , primarily because the photometric system is not standard and the meaning of the magnitude would be unclear .
this leaves us with 335 positive detections in the pre - eruption time interval .
just over 90% of these magnitudes were made with unfiltered ccd imaging , where the magnitudes were calibrated differentially from nearby comparison stars using either the v - band or r - band magnitudes .
these magnitudes ( designated cv or cr ) will not be exactly on either the v or r magnitude systems , but the expected deviations ( less than 0.1 mag ) are always small compared to normal variations of u sco . our instrumentation is a 16-inch f/10 schmidt - cassegrain with a v filter located in new smyrna beach , florida ( bgh ) , an 18-inch newtonian telescope without filter located in barnesville , maryland ( jm ) , and a 10-inch schmidt - cassegrain telescope with a v filter located in clermont , florida ( sd ) . during the critical month before the eruption ,
all positive detections in the aavso database are provided by us ( bgh and jm ) from ccd images .
beginning in early 2009 , we ( mjd and mfb ) started monitoring u sco with the robotic 2.0-m liverpool telescope ( steele et al .
2004 ) at the observatorio del roque de los muchachos on la palma in the canary islands .
the goals were to define the pre - eruption light curve in many bandpasses and perhaps to catch a pre - eruption rise or the eruption rise itself .
the photometry was all differential with respect to the comparison stars given in schaefer ( 2010 ) .
the images were usually taken through many filters in quick succession once each night .
the filters we used were the b , v , sloan r , and sloan i. each light curve point consisted of three 60 s exposures .
the data were analysed using starlink software .
the typical photometric errors had an uncertainty of 0.01 - 0.02 mag . in all , we present here 173 magnitudes from the liverpool telescope . an important practical question was whether u sco erupted during its yearly conjunction with the sun every 28 november
. the worst case scenario would be for u sco to go up in early november , fade back to its quiescent level before any detection was made , and for the eruption to be completely missed .
if u sco went up while behind the sun , it would be vital to know this so that our community would not be waiting anxiously with many resources , and also so that observations in the late tail could still be performed .
for this , deep images would have to be made as far into twilight as possible .
professional telescopes do not go low enough in the sky , so the push into twilight was made entirely by aavso observers . for the november 2008 solar conjunction , u sco was lost on 2 november and deep images showed u sco to be near quiescence ( [email protected] ) on 3 january , for a solar gap of 62 days . for the november 2009 solar conjunction , u sco was last detected at v=18.6 on 21 october ( jm ) , was fainter than 12.0 mag on 4 november ( ml ) , last checked on 6 november , while after conjunction our images showed it to be fainter than v=14.0 on 27 december ( ml ) , fainter than v=14.3 on 28 december ( ml ) , fainter than v=17.4 on 30 december ( bgh ) , and at quiescence ( v=17.6 ) on 4 january ( bgh ) , for a solar gap of 51 - 59 days . from the v - band light curve template ( schaefer 2010 ;
schaefer et al .
2010b ) , u sco is at v=16.6 @xmath142 days after the peak .
with this extremely short duration , the possibility for a missed eruption was for a peak from 3 - 23 november 2008 or 7 - 16 november 2009 .
as a chance to discover a u sco eruption in the week around solar conjunction , one of us ( sd ) used the soho lasco c3 instrument ( which hides the sun behind a white light coronagraph and produces images of stars , comets , and the corona out to 32 solar radii from the sun ) to demonstrate that the nova never came to peak ( i.e. , [email protected] mag ) during that week - long interval .
the last positive detection of u sco before its eruption was by us ( bgh ) on jd 2455223.9473 .
nevertheless , there were later useful upper limits .
observing from the island of hawaii , we ( ml ) used a 20-inch f/3.6 reflector to place a visual limit of @xmath816.5 mag on jd 2455224.1271 .
the asas-3n telescope took a v - band image with a 180 second exposure on jd 2455224.1649 and we ( gp , dms , and bp ) did not detect any source to a limit of 15.0 mag . this robotic telescope is located in maui on hawaii at an elevation of 3056 m , with a f/2.0 lens with focal length of 200 mm for a field of view of 8.5@xmath7 on a side on a 2048x2048 pixel ccd chip . the last known observation before discovery ( with [email protected] ) was taken by us ( yw ) on jd 2455224.3438 with a 60-mm f/5.9 refractor with an unfiltered ccd located in yokosuka japan .
from these sources , we have collected 815 magnitudes for u sco between the end of the 1999 eruption and the discovery of the 2010 eruption .
( we also report on 16 useful limits and the first three eruption magnitudes . )
these are presented in table 1 .
the first column lists the heliocentric julian date ( hjd ) of the observation .
the second column gives the band of the observation .
the third column gives the magnitude and the one - sigma uncertainty .
the fourth column gives the source of the magnitude , either by identifying the telescope or by giving the aavso or vsolj observer identification code .
hbb is for b. g. harris , dks is for s. dvorak , mjle is for j. menke , lmk is for m. linnolt , sck is for b. e. schaefer , and wny is for y. watanabe .
the next column is the orbital phase of u sco ( with primary eclipses at phase 0.0 and 1.0 and secondary eclipses at phase 0.5 ) for the pre - eruption ephemeris of @xmath9 .
the last column gives the fractional year corresponding to the julian date of the observation .
figure 1 displays the full light curve for the b filter , while figure 2 shows the v band light curve after the start of 2009 .
figure 3 shows the folded light curves for the b and v bands .
table 2 lists various characteristic quantities ( magnitudes , colors , and fluxes ) , their averages , their rms scatters , and the number of observations going into the averages . for the science of this paper , we are only interested in the non - eclipsing behavior , so to be conservative , we have included only measures more than 0.10 in phase ( 0.123 in days ) away from the central eclipse times ( i.e. , between phases 0.10 and 0.90 ) .
for the colors , we have included only those colors derived from two magnitudes taken within 0.005 days of each other so as to keep the errors introduced by fast variations to a minimum .
the overall magnitudes ( for all bands ) and colors for the entire time interval ( from 2000 to the 2010 eruption ) are recorded .
we also break up the b and v band magnitudes into smaller intervals so as to seek significant variations .
finally , we include the average b - band fluxes as defined in section 6 .
the 2010 eruption was discovered by us ( bgh and sd ) as part of systematic nightly monitoring aimed specifically at the discovery of the eruption .
harris imaged u sco at 2010 jan 28.4385 ut ( jd 2455224.9385 ) , saw the bright star in the center of the field , and quickly realized that u sco was in eruption .
her first act was to send the observation to the aavso , and then she telephoned schaefer .
schaefer could not get confirmation from rotse , so he took his 6-inch telescope out into the front yard and made direct visual confirmation that u sco was bright in eruption .
independently , dvorak discovered the eruption , notified the aavso , and started a time series on u sco to cover the short time interval until dawn got too bright to continue .
these initial observations are included in table 1 .
circumstances , pictures , and anecdotes on the two independent discoveries are given in simonsen & macrobert ( 2010 ) .
in practice , our organization worked perfectly .
the aavso automated alert system woke up mt and ap . within an hour of the discovery ,
the eruption had been confirmed and worldwide notifications were started .
the first was to the iau circulars ( schaefer et al .
the sun had already risen in chile , so we started with more western observatories as well as spacecraft . within two hours ,
bes , ap , and mt had worked through all the long - prepared contact lists .
the response to these contacts ( both by members of our existing collaboration as well as by independent observers ) was excellent and fast .
the discovery of the 2010 eruption was a fulfillment of the prediction in schaefer ( 2005 ) that u sco would next erupt in the year [email protected] .
the eruption in 2010.1 falls well within the one - sigma region of the prediction .
this adds good confidence to the physical method of summing the total accreted material based on the b - band flux in the prior inter - eruption interval .
the folded light curve ( see figure 3 ) shows the primary eclipse at phases 0.0 , 1.0 , and 2.0 .
( the magnitudes are double plotted so as to make the eclipse at phase 1.0 easily visible . )
the out - of - eclipse brightness varies substantially , and this makes for a ragged eclipse light curve because each point is from a different epoch eclipse with a different amount of flickering light added .
the scatter around the middle of the eclipse is much smaller than the out - of - eclipse scatter , which implies that the flickering region is small and centrally located .
no secondary eclipse is visible in the b and v bands .
however , in the i - band , the secondary eclipse is visible with amplitude roughly 0.3 mag .
this is readily understood as the companion star is much cooler than the accretion disk so eclipses of the companion can only become noticeable at longer wavelength .
all cataclysmic variables , including novae and recurrent novae , show fast flickering .
u sco is no exception , and this flickering causes the substantial scatter in figures 1 and 2 . to quantify this ,
we have calculated the magnitude difference between pairs of magnitudes in the same band , with the pairs being separated in time by some range of delays . when the delays are shorter than one hour , the rms scatter of the magnitude differences is 0.06 mag , which is consistent with the expected scatter as based only on the quoted error bars . when the delays are longer than one day , the rms scatter of the magnitude differences is 0.27 , which corresponds to no correlation between the flickers .
the rms scatters are 0.09 , 0.13 , 0.18 , 0.19 , and 0.21 mag for delays of 0.05 - 0.10 , 0.10 - 0.15 , 0.15 - 0.20 , 0.20 - 0.50 , and 0.50 - 1.00 days , respectively . with this
, the timescale for correlated variations is from one hour to one day .
the amplitude of these variations is given by the maximum values of the magnitude differences , which is roughly 0.4 mag for all delays longer than 0.05 days .
our observations are not sensitive to fast , small - amplitude variations .
many of the recurrent novae have large secular variations in their quiescent light curves ( schaefer 2010 ) .
however , u sco does not appear to have any long - term variations , as can be seen in figure 1 . to quantify this for the b and v light curves , table 2 gives the averages for various time intervals .
again , no significant variations on time scales of one year or longer are found , despite having small error bars due to the many magnitudes included in the averages . on the timescale of a tenth of a year
, there is marginal evidence for variations , with the v - band average for 2009.7 - 2009.9 being @xmath10 fainter than average , but this variation is not reflected in other bands , so we think that this apparent change is not significant . in all , we see no evidence for variations on timescales from 0.1 to 10 years . on longer times scales , u sco has small , marginally - significant variations . during the last four inter - eruption intervals , the average b magnitude was [email protected] , [email protected] , and [email protected] , and [email protected] for 1969 - 1979 , 1979 - 1987 , 1987 - 1999 ( schaefer 2005 ) , and 1999 - 2010 respectively .
the chi - square for the observed averages ( on the hypothesis that the average is a constant ) is 12.1 for three degrees of freedom .
the best argument for the significance of these variations is that the deviations from the average are correlated with the duration of each inter - eruption time interval as predicted by theory ( see section 7 ) .
the earliest recorded image of u sco in quiescence is from the original palomar sky survey .
we measure [email protected] and [email protected] for 29 june 1954 .
this is substantially fainter than is normal for later decades , and the time is far from any plausible eclipse .
robinson ( 1975 ) examined all known pre - eruption light curves of novae as based on reports in the literature .
he found that five out of eleven novae have pre - eruption rises , lasting months to years in advance of the eruption , with amplitudes from 0.15 to 1.5 mag .
collazzi et al .
( 2009 ) have gone to the original archival photographic plates to measure many pre - eruption light curves , including the key novae with claimed pre - eruption rises .
four of the five claimed pre - eruption rises were found not to exist as based on our examination of the original plates , such that the claimed rises were caused by simple errors in the literature .
nevertheless , one of the rises ( for v533 her ) was confirmed and extended , with the rise being an exponential increase over @xmath11.5 years and a brightening by up to 1.5 mag .
also , an additional pre - eruption rise was confirmed in v1500 cyg , which brightened from roughly 21.5 mag to roughly 13 mag in the month preceding the eruption .
( v1500 cyg had the fastest known _ classical _ nova eruption , and was second only to u sco itself amongst all novae . ) in addition , a complex pre - eruption dip was confirmed for the recurrent nova t crb in the year before the eruption , with the dip being 1 - 2 mag deep . in all , three out of 22 novae had either pre - eruption rises or pre - eruption dips . with other recurrent novae and the fastest classical nova having anticipatory rises and dips , we should investigate whether u sco has any similar changes .
( we were also hopeful that any such phenomenon would allow us to anticipate the next eruption . ) for this , we can use our light curves to seek any rises or dips .
a glance at figure 1 quickly shows that there is no significant rise or dip .
quantitatively , table 2 shows that the b and v magnitudes from 2010.0 - 2010.1 are not significantly high or low . and
looking at the bottom of table 1 , we see that the last positive detection of u sco has v=18.2 ( bgh ) just 24 hours before the discovery . with this
, we can put strong limits on the presence of any pre - eruption rise or dip to be less than roughly 0.2 mag in amplitude on time scales from one day up to a year .
u sco rises from quiescence to peak in roughly 6 - 12 hours , although this is based on just three pre - peak positive detections and one limit ( schaefer 2010 ) . for the 1936 eruption ,
a single harvard plate shows b=10.75 at a time 0.25 days before peak . for the 1987 eruption , dr .
n. w. taylor measured v=14.0 in the day before the peak . for the 1999 eruption , p. schmeer measured v=9.5 at a time 0.31 days before the peak .
the final rise to maximum is at a rate of around 19 magnitudes per day , which would imply a rise time of roughly 12 hours if the rise is uniform throughout . for the 1999 eruption ,
b. monard set a limit that @xmath11 at a time 0.46 days before the peak .
we can use our data to obtain the best estimate for the time of peak in the 2010 eruption .
the discovery image was taken at jd 2455224.9385 ( bgh ) , and we have measured the magnitude of u sco ( with respect to the comparison star sequence in schaefer 2010 ) to be v=7.85 with the systematic uncertainties dominating at around 0.10 mag . the observed initial rate of decline is 1.4 mag per day ( schaefer et al .
the peak magnitude of u sco is v=7.5 , primarily as based on the observed peak of the 1999 eruption ( schaefer 2010 ) . in an exhaustive comparison of all rn eruptions and those from u sco in particular , schaefer ( 2010 ) found that all rn are consistent with having the identical eruption light curve shapes , and this is our basis for taking the peak from the 1999 u sco eruption as being the same for the 2010 eruption . with this , the peak of the 2010 eruption would have been 0.25 days before discovery , which gives a peak at jd 2455224.69 with a likely uncertainty of 0.07 days .
the observational limits from the 2010 eruption show that the eruption could not have started much before the asas-3n image at jd 2455224.1649 . from the limits on the prior eruptions , the eruption started 0.25 to 0.5 days before the peak , which is roughly from jd 2455224.19 to 2455224.44 .
thus , the time of the start of the expansion , as required by the ` universal decline law ' of hachisu & kato ( 2006 ) , can be expressed as jd [email protected] .
disappointingly , we have no observations from jd 2455224.3438 to 2455224.9385 and thus have completely missed the entire rise and the hour of peak . in january , u sco is fairly close to the sun and hence only visible from a narrow slice of longitude at any given time .
in the southern hemisphere , the start of the rise would only have been visible from the longitudes in the indian ocean , while the peak would only have been visible from the longitudes in the south atlantic ocean .
schaefer ( 2005 ) presented a new method for predicting the date of the next eruption of a recurrent nova based on the requirement that some constant amount of mass must be accumulated by the white dwarf between eruptions .
accretion rates vary substantially ( schaefer 2010 ; and see figure 1 ) , so the interval between eruptions ( @xmath12 ) depends on the average accretion during that time . if the accretion rate is high then the interval will be short , while if the accretion rate is low then @xmath12 will be high . for u sco ,
the blue light is dominated by the accretion disk , so the blue flux ( @xmath13 ) will be a measure of the accretion rate .
in particular for u sco , the accretion rate will be proportional to @xmath14 ( schaefer 2005 ) . by averaging @xmath14 over each interval @xmath12
, we can derive a quantity that is proportional to the average accretion rate .
then , @xmath15 should be proportional to the total mass accreted between eruptions , which should be a constant .
schaefer ( 2005 ) found that this quantity is indeed constant for four intervals for t pyx and three intervals for u sco ( despite widely varying values of @xmath12 for each system ) , with this providing a good test of nova trigger theory .
these _ observed _ values for @xmath15 provide empirical measures of the mass required to trigger the eruptions . then , based on the observed b magnitudes up until 2005 , schaefer ( 2005 ) was able to predict that u sco would next erupt in @xmath6 .
schaefer ( 2010 ) updated the situation to arrive at the same predicted date .
as noted above , the actual eruption on 2010.1 falls well within this prediction .
now , with the full pre - eruption light curve , we can better test the prediction and we can refine the constant for use in predicting the next eruption . to this end , we have first converted the b - band magnitudes to flux units where b=18 is taken to be the unit flux ( @xmath16 ) , which equals @xmath17 . the accretion rate will then be proportional to @xmath18 . to get the time averaged value from 2000 - 2010.1 , we should not simply average all the values , as this would produce a high weight to the behavior of u sco during 2008 and 2009 ( during which the majority of the b - band magnitudes were taken ) .
instead , we have taken time intervals and combined them with weights given by their duration . in table 2
, we list the average values of the measured @xmath18 for three intervals with roughly constant frequency of observations .
the uncertainty in these averages is the rms scatter divided by the square root of the number of observations .
the durations of these intervals were then used as weights for averaging the intervals , and the uncertainty in the overall average comes from the usual propagation of errors . the resultant average over the entire interval between the 1999.2 and 2010.1 eruption
is listed in table 2 . in all , @xmath19 .
schaefer ( 2005 ) produces values of @xmath20 for the three prior inter - eruption intervals .
these need to be updated for four reasons .
first , we need to standardize to the same flux level ( i.e. , b=18 ) as the unit flux .
second , we should be consistent and not include any magnitudes within phase 0.10 of the eclipse .
third , the individual observations should be formed into the averages with equal weight ( instead of weighted by the measurement uncertainty ) because intrinsic fluctuations are substantially larger than the measurement errors ( so we would not want to give high weight to a bright point simply because it has a small error bar ) .
fourth , the 1969 - 1979 interval has only two magnitudes , so instead of determining the uncertainty based on the rms scatter of just these two , we have equated the scatter to that during the 1987 - 1999 interval .
the resultant @xmath21 values are given in table 2 .
u sco erupted in the years 1969 , 1979 , 1987 , 1999 , and 2010 , with @xmath12 values of 10.4 , 7.9 , 11.8 , and 10.9 years for the four inter - eruption intervals .
the longest interval is a factor of 1.5@xmath22 the shortest interval .
we see that the shortest interval has the highest average accretion rate , while the longest interval has the lowest average accretion rate , and the two middle intervals have the middle average accretion rates .
the four intervals in time order have @xmath23 values of @xmath24 , @xmath25 , @xmath26 , and @xmath27 .
( the weighted average of these four values is [email protected] . )
nova trigger theory predicts that these values should be a constant .
indeed , the chi - square equals 3.4 for the hypothesis that the four values are equal to a constant , which is acceptable given the three degrees of freedom .
and we see that the values are consistent with being a constant despite @xmath12 varying by up to a factor of 1.5 .
so we have an improved confirmation of nova trigger theory .
u sco erupted in 1945 and 1969 , with an inter - eruption interval of 23.7 years .
the long interval could be because _ one _ eruption was missed around 1957 ( with intervals of around 11.8 and 11.9 years ) or because _ two _ eruptions were missed around 1953 and 1961 ( with intervals or around 7.9 , 7.9 , and 7.9 years ) .
these two possibilities can be distinguished due their greatly different prediction as to the quiescent b magnitude , roughly 18.52 versus 18.30 respectively .
the one measured magnitude ( [email protected] from 1954.5 ) suggests that the accretion rate was low , and hence that there was only one missed eruption . when will the next eruption of u sco occur ? over the next decade , we can keep track of the b - band magnitudes and work out when @xmath23 will equal @xmath28 .
such a prediction will only be accurate to roughly 5 months out of ten years , which is fairly good .
however , this method can not be used yet , because we can not predict the variations in the u sco accretion rate . for
now , the best that we can do is to use the long record of u sco where all of its inter - eruption intervals are @xmath3 years . with this
, we predict the next u sco eruption to be in 2020@xmath02 .
we thank the many observers from the american association of variable stars observers for their data as used in our light curves .
this work is supported under a grant from the national science foundation ( ast 0708079 ) .
the liverpool telescope is operated on the island of la palma by liverpool john moores university in the spanish observatorio del roque de los muchachos of the instituto de astrofisica de canarias with financial support from the uk science and technology facilities council .
akerlof , c. w. et al .
2003 , pasp , 115 , 132 bode , m. f. & evans , a. 2008 , classical novae , 2nd edition ( cambridge , cambridge univ . press ) collazzi , a.c .
, schaefer , b.e . , xiao , l. , pagnotta , a. , kroll , p. , lchel , k. @xmath29 henden , a.a .
2009 , aj , 138 , 1846 evans , a. , bode , m. f. , obrien , t. j. & darnley , m. j. 2008 , rs ophiuci ( 2006 ) and the recurrent nova phenomenon ( asp conf .
401 ) hachisu , i. & kato , m. 2006 , apjsupp , 167 , 59 landolt , a. u. 1992 , aj , 104 , 340 landolt , a. u. 2009 , aj , 137 , 4186 payne - gaposhkin , c. 1964 , the galactic novae ( dover , new york ) robinson , e. l. 1975 , aj , 80 , 515 schaefer , b. e. 1988 , apj , 327 , 347 schaefer , b. e. 1990 , apjlett , 355 , l39 schaefer , b. e. 2001 , iaucirc . ,
7749 schaefer , b. e. 2004 , iaucirc .
, 8279 schaefer , b. e. 2005 , apjlett , 621 , l53 schaefer , b. e. 2010 , apjsupp , 187 , 275 schaefer , b. e. , harris , b. g. , dvorak , s. , & linnolt , m. 2010a , iaucirc . ,
9111 schaefer , b. e. & ringwald , f. a. 1995 , apjlett , 447 , l45 schaefer , b. e. et al .
2010b , atel , 2507 simonsen , m. & macrobert , a. 2010 , sky & telescope , 119 , no . 5 , 18 steele , i. a. et al .
2004 , proc .
spie , 5489 , 679 llllll 2451702.1932 & cv & 18.1 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( laq ) & 0.038 & 2000.432 + 2451708.1195 & cv & 18.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( laq ) & 0.854 & 2000.448 + 2451719.0413 & cv & 18.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( laq ) & 0.729 & 2000.478 + 2452016.8446 & v & 17.90 @xmath0 0.01 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.738 & 2001.293 + 2452018.8356 & v & 18.05 @xmath0 0.02 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.356 & 2001.299 + 2452018.8397 & r & 17.69 @xmath0 0.01 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.359 & 2001.299 + 2452021.7832 & r & 17.61 @xmath0 0.02 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.751 & 2001.307 + 2452021.7864 & r & 17.63 @xmath0 0.01 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.754 & 2001.307 + 2452021.7895 & r & 17.61 @xmath0 0.02 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.757 & 2001.307 + 2452021.7925 & r & 17.54 @xmath0 0.02 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.759 & 2001.307 + 2452021.7956 & r & 17.57 @xmath0 0.01 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.761 & 2001.307 + 2452021.7986 & r & 17.58 @xmath0 0.01 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.764 & 2001.307 + 2452021.8588 & r & 17.47 @xmath0 0.01 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.813 & 2001.307 + 2452021.8621 & v & 17.84 @xmath0 0.01 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.816 & 2001.307 + 2452021.9508 & r & 17.52 @xmath0 0.01 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.888 & 2001.307 + 2452022.8163 & r & 17.34 @xmath0 0.01 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.591 & 2001.310 + 2452022.8197 & v & 17.67 @xmath0 0.01 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.594 & 2001.310 + 2452022.9468 & v & 17.74 @xmath0 0.02 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.697 & 2001.310 + 2452022.9506 & r & 17.34 @xmath0 0.01 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.700 & 2001.310 + 2452125.6972 & v & 17.98 @xmath0 0.04 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.197 & 2001.591 + 2452125.7101 & i & 17.24 @xmath0 0.03 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.207 & 2001.591 + 2452125.7118 & v & 18.24 @xmath0 0.05 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.209 & 2001.591 + 2452127.6580 & v & 17.99 @xmath0 0.02 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.790 & 2001.597 + 2452127.6594 & i & 17.16 @xmath0 0.01 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.791 & 2001.597 + 2452127.6616 & i & 17.15 @xmath0 0.02 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.793 & 2001.597 + 2452127.6686 & v & 18.00 @xmath0 0.03 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.799 & 2001.597 + 2452130.6395 & v & 18.06 @xmath0 0.01 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.213 & 2001.605 + 2452130.6480 & b & 18.33 @xmath0 0.02 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.220 & 2001.605 + 2452426.8409 & b & 18.86 @xmath0 0.02 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.920 & 2002.416 + 2452426.8452 & b & 18.83 @xmath0 0.03 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.924 & 2002.416 + 2452426.8497 & b & 18.92 @xmath0 0.03 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.927 & 2002.416 + 2452426.8537 & v & 18.35 @xmath0 0.02 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.931 & 2002.416 + 2452426.8587 & v & 18.17 @xmath0 0.02 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.935 & 2002.416 + 2452426.8624 & v & 18.38 @xmath0 0.03 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.938 & 2002.416 + 2452431.6794 & b & 18.17 @xmath0 0.01 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.852 & 2002.429 + 2452431.6834 & b & 18.15 @xmath0 0.01 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.856 & 2002.429 + 2452431.6863 & i & 17.34 @xmath0 0.01 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.858 & 2002.429 + 2452431.6879 & i & 17.36 @xmath0 0.02 & mcdonald 2.1 m & 0.859 & 2002.429 + 2452761.5052 & cr & 17.9 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.884 & 2003.332 + 2452763.4203 & cr & 17.7 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.440 & 2003.337 + 2452765.8658 & i & 17.61 @xmath0 0.02 & mcdonald 0.8 m & 0.428 & 2003.344 + 2452765.8724 & b & 19.03 @xmath0 0.04 & mcdonald 0.8 m & 0.433 & 2003.344 + 2452769.7860 & i & 17.36 @xmath0 0.02 & mcdonald 0.8 m & 0.613 & 2003.355 + 2452769.7926 & b & 18.73 @xmath0 0.04 & mcdonald 0.8 m & 0.619 & 2003.355 + 2452786.7196 & i & 16.61 @xmath0 0.02 & mcdonald 0.8 m & 0.375 & 2003.401 + 2452786.7243 & v & 18.13 @xmath0 0.03 & mcdonald 0.8 m & 0.378 & 2003.401 + 2452891.2341 & cr & 17.3 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.308 & 2003.687 + 2453054.5003 & cr & 17.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.986 & 2004.134 + 2453054.6003 & cr & 17.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.067 & 2004.134 + 2453068.5397 & v & 17.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.395 & 2004.173 + 2453082.9035 & u & 19.03 @xmath0 0.06 & mcdonald 0.8 m & 0.067 & 2004.212 + 2453082.9111 & b & 19.30 @xmath0 0.04 & mcdonald 0.8 m & 0.074 & 2004.212 + 2453082.9153 & v & 18.65 @xmath0 0.03 & mcdonald 0.8 m & 0.077 & 2004.212 + 2453082.9247 & r & 18.18 @xmath0 0.03 & mcdonald 0.8 m & 0.085 & 2004.212 + 2453082.9288 & i & 17.59 @xmath0 0.04 & mcdonald 0.8 m & 0.088 & 2004.212 + 2453092.5279 & cr & 17.2 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.889 & 2004.238 + 2453130.3553 & cr & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.629 & 2004.342 + 2453136.6145 & cr & 17.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.715 & 2004.359 + 2453152.4188 & cr & 17.7 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.559 & 2004.402 + 2453171.2315 & cr & 17.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.847 & 2004.454 + 2453172.2325 & cr & 17.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.660 & 2004.456 + 2453182.2841 & cr & 17.4 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.829 & 2004.484 + 2453187.7869 & v & 18.16 @xmath0 0.16 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.301 & 2004.499 + 2453187.7885 & v & 18.27 @xmath0 0.07 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.302 & 2004.499 + 2453187.7934 & r & 17.99 @xmath0 0.05 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.306 & 2004.499 + 2453187.7979 & i & 17.36 @xmath0 0.06 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.309 & 2004.499 + 2453187.8024 & i & 17.43 @xmath0 0.05 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.313 & 2004.499 + 2453187.8104 & b & 18.29 @xmath0 0.11 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.320 & 2004.499 + 2453189.4895 & r & 17.98 @xmath0 0.06 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.684 & 2004.504 + 2453189.4911 & b & 18.58 @xmath0 0.07 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.685 & 2004.504 + 2453189.4988 & b & 18.67 @xmath0 0.05 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.692 & 2004.504 + 2453189.5065 & v & 18.33 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.698 & 2004.504 + 2453189.5144 & r & 17.91 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.704 & 2004.504 + 2453189.5225 & i & 17.43 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.711 & 2004.504 + 2453189.5733 & i & 17.48 @xmath0 0.08 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.752 & 2004.504 + 2453189.5741 & i & 17.46 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.753 & 2004.504 + 2453189.5814 & i & 17.47 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.759 & 2004.504 + 2453189.6682 & i & 17.39 @xmath0 0.07 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.829 & 2004.504 + 2453189.6705 & i & 17.41 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.831 & 2004.504 + 2453189.6781 & i & 17.42 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.837 & 2004.504 + 2453191.4873 & i & 17.39 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.308 & 2004.509 + 2453191.4948 & i & 17.47 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.314 & 2004.509 + 2453191.5191 & i & 17.41 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.333 & 2004.509 + 2453191.5265 & i & 17.36 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.339 & 2004.509 + 2453191.5443 & i & 17.42 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.354 & 2004.509 + 2453191.5521 & i & 17.40 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.360 & 2004.509 + 2453191.5761 & i & 17.44 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.380 & 2004.509 + 2453191.5836 & i & 17.44 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.386 & 2004.509 + 2453191.6033 & i & 17.56 @xmath0 0.04 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.402 & 2004.510 + 2453191.6105 & i & 17.50 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.408 & 2004.510 + 2453191.6607 & i & 17.51 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.449 & 2004.510 + 2453191.6696 & i & 17.54 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.456 & 2004.510 + 2453191.6923 & i & 17.46 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.474 & 2004.510 + 2453191.6995 & i & 17.49 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.480 & 2004.510 + 2453191.7078 & i & 17.52 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.487 & 2004.510 + 2453191.7153 & i & 17.56 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.493 & 2004.510 + 2453191.7225 & i & 17.53 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.499 & 2004.510 + 2453191.7300 & i & 17.54 @xmath0 0.04 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.505 & 2004.510 + 2453191.7373 & i & 17.55 @xmath0 0.04 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.511 & 2004.510 + 2453191.7448 & i & 17.54 @xmath0 0.04 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.517 & 2004.510 + 2453191.7520 & i & 17.54 @xmath0 0.04 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.523 & 2004.510 + 2453191.7594 & i & 17.42 @xmath0 0.04 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.529 & 2004.510 + 2453191.7667 & i & 17.47 @xmath0 0.04 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.535 & 2004.510 + 2453191.7743 & i & 17.46 @xmath0 0.04 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.541 & 2004.510 + 2453191.7816 & i & 17.47 @xmath0 0.05 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.547 & 2004.510 + 2453192.5670 & i & 17.30 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.185 & 2004.512 + 2453194.6257 & i & 17.31 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.858 & 2004.518 + 2453194.6311 & i & 17.36 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.862 & 2004.518 + 2453195.4959 & i & 17.31 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.565 & 2004.520 + 2453195.4984 & i & 17.33 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.567 & 2004.520 + 2453195.5132 & i & 17.33 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.579 & 2004.520 + 2453195.5204 & i & 17.34 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.585 & 2004.520 + 2453195.5277 & i & 17.30 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.591 & 2004.520 + 2453195.5350 & i & 17.29 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.597 & 2004.520 + 2453195.5424 & i & 17.27 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.603 & 2004.520 + 2453195.5496 & i & 17.25 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.609 & 2004.520 + 2453195.5569 & i & 17.25 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.615 & 2004.520 + 2453195.5642 & i & 17.26 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.621 & 2004.520 + 2453195.5716 & i & 17.25 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.627 & 2004.520 + 2453195.5788 & i & 17.28 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.633 & 2004.520 + 2453195.5861 & i & 17.30 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.639 & 2004.520 + 2453195.5934 & i & 17.28 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.644 & 2004.520 + 2453195.6007 & i & 17.29 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.650 & 2004.520 + 2453195.6080 & i & 17.31 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.656 & 2004.520 + 2453195.6171 & i & 17.28 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.664 & 2004.521 + 2453195.6244 & i & 17.25 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.670 & 2004.521 + 2453195.6316 & i & 17.21 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.676 & 2004.521 + 2453195.6389 & i & 17.23 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.681 & 2004.521 + 2453195.6463 & i & 17.24 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.687 & 2004.521 + 2453195.6536 & i & 17.23 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.693 & 2004.521 + 2453195.6609 & i & 17.23 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.699 & 2004.521 + 2453196.4771 & i & 17.23 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.363 & 2004.523 + 2453196.4920 & i & 17.24 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.375 & 2004.523 + 2453196.4993 & i & 17.27 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.381 & 2004.523 + 2453196.5065 & i & 17.28 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.386 & 2004.523 + 2453196.5141 & i & 17.29 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.393 & 2004.523 + 2453196.5274 & i & 17.31 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.403 & 2004.523 + 2453196.5361 & i & 17.32 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.411 & 2004.523 + 2453196.5446 & i & 17.33 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.417 & 2004.523 + 2453196.5678 & i & 17.34 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.436 & 2004.523 + 2453196.5678 & i & 17.31 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.436 & 2004.523 + 2453196.5838 & i & 17.36 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.449 & 2004.523 + 2453196.5960 & i & 17.39 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.459 & 2004.523 + 2453196.6038 & i & 17.37 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.466 & 2004.523 + 2453196.6123 & i & 17.45 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.472 & 2004.523 + 2453196.6195 & i & 17.42 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.478 & 2004.523 + 2453196.6268 & i & 17.44 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.484 & 2004.523 + 2453196.6342 & i & 17.39 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.490 & 2004.523 + 2453196.6415 & i & 17.52 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.496 & 2004.523 + 2453196.6487 & i & 17.49 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.502 & 2004.523 + 2453196.6563 & i & 17.47 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.508 & 2004.523 + 2453196.6636 & i & 17.45 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.514 & 2004.523 + 2453196.6788 & i & 17.42 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.526 & 2004.523 + 2453196.6893 & i & 17.41 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.535 & 2004.523 + 2453196.6965 & i & 17.40 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.541 & 2004.523 + 2453196.7037 & i & 17.41 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.547 & 2004.523 + 2453196.7184 & i & 17.30 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.559 & 2004.524 + 2453196.7209 & i & 17.35 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.561 & 2004.524 + 2453196.7352 & i & 17.35 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.572 & 2004.524 + 2453196.7436 & i & 17.28 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.579 & 2004.524 + 2453196.7474 & i & 17.28 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.582 & 2004.524 + 2453196.7617 & i & 17.26 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.594 & 2004.524 + 2453196.7690 & i & 17.22 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.600 & 2004.524 + 2453197.5817 & i & 17.26 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.260 & 2004.526 + 2453197.5894 & r & 17.71 @xmath0 0.01 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.267 & 2004.526 + 2453197.5971 & v & 18.10 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.273 & 2004.526 + 2453197.6048 & b & 18.40 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.279 & 2004.526 + 2453197.6124 & u & 18.13 @xmath0 0.08 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.285 & 2004.526 + 2453197.7114 & i & 17.25 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.366 & 2004.526 + 2453199.4870 & i & 17.30 @xmath0 0.03 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.809 & 2004.531 + 2453199.4943 & i & 17.25 @xmath0 0.04 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.815 & 2004.531 + 2453199.5017 & i & 17.22 @xmath0 0.04 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.821 & 2004.531 + 2453199.5644 & i & 17.30 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.872 & 2004.531 + 2453199.5720 & i & 17.29 @xmath0 0.02 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.878 & 2004.531 + 2453199.5795 & i & 17.27 @xmath0 0.04 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.884 & 2004.531 + 2453199.6256 & i & 17.34 @xmath0 0.04 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.921 & 2004.531 + 2453199.6354 & i & 17.39 @xmath0 0.05 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.929 & 2004.532 + 2453199.6499 & i & 17.38 @xmath0 0.06 & ctio 1.0 m & 0.941 & 2004.532 + 2453201.2230 & cr & 17.9 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.219 & 2004.536 + 2453209.2464 & cr & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.740 & 2004.558 + 2453223.2763 & cr & 17.9 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.141 & 2004.596 + 2453237.2060 & cr & 17.7 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.461 & 2004.634 + 2453251.2566 & cr & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.879 & 2004.673 + 2453262.2206 & cr & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.789 & 2004.703 + 2453282.1998 & cr & 17.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.025 & 2004.758 + 2453288.2243 & cr & 17.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.921 & 2004.774 + 2453634.5334 & b & 18.46 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.348 & 2005.722 + 2453634.5399 & v & 17.94 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.353 & 2005.722 + 2453634.5447 & r & 17.60 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.357 & 2005.722 + 2453634.5488 & i & 17.14 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.360 & 2005.722 + 2453793.7702 & cr & 18.58 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mdj ) & 0.751 & 2006.158 + 2453793.7702 & cv & 18.86 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mdj ) & 0.751 & 2006.158 + 2453799.8147 & b & 18.09 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.663 & 2006.175 + 2453799.8212 & v & 17.62 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.668 & 2006.175 + 2453799.8260 & r & 17.34 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.672 & 2006.175 + 2453799.8303 & i & 16.90 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.676 & 2006.175 + 2453825.5522 & cr & 18.0 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.578 & 2006.245 + 2453829.6545 & cr & 17.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.912 & 2006.256 + 2453837.5751 & cr & 17.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.349 & 2006.278 + 2453855.5271 & cr & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.937 & 2006.327 + 2453919.2248 & cr & 17.7 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.701 & 2006.502 + 2453954.2322 & cr & 17.2 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.150 & 2006.597 + 2454175.5648 & cr & 18.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.015 & 2007.203 + 2454214.6058 & cr & 17.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.742 & 2007.310 + 2454264.4516 & cr & 17.4 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.249 & 2007.447 + 2454310.2360 & cr & 17.9 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.455 & 2007.572 + 2454507.4885 & cr & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.752 & 2008.112 + 2454513.6321 & cr & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.744 & 2008.129 + 2454527.9007 & b & 18.50 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.340 & 2008.168 + 2454536.8221 & b & 17.95 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.590 & 2008.193 + 2454542.8568 & b & 18.01 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.494 & 2008.209 + 2454547.8175 & b & 18.07 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.525 & 2008.223 + 2454553.8468 & b & 18.54 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.425 & 2008.239 + 2454559.8413 & b & 18.70 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.296 & 2008.256 + 2454562.5227 & cr & 17.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.475 & 2008.263 + 2454569.7868 & b & 18.34 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.378 & 2008.283 + 2454574.7898 & b & 18.85 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.444 & 2008.296 + 2454581.7947 & b & 18.92 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.136 & 2008.316 + 2454588.7733 & b & 18.43 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.808 & 2008.335 + 2454589.6856 & b & 18.35 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.549 & 2008.337 + 2454594.7340 & b & 18.35 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.651 & 2008.351 + 2454602.8623 & b & 18.74 @xmath0 0.04 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.257 & 2008.373 + 2454608.8429 & b & 18.81 @xmath0 0.04 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.117 & 2008.390 + 2454612.1178 & v & 17.9 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( dil ) & 0.778 & 2008.399 + 2454625.6568 & b & 18.43 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.781 & 2008.436 + 2454637.7691 & b & 18.45 @xmath0 0.04 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.624 & 2008.469 + 2454642.7118 & b & 18.70 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.641 & 2008.482 + 2454647.6258 & b & 18.32 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.634 & 2008.496 + 2454652.5651 & b & 17.94 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.648 & 2008.509 + 2454657.6969 & b & 18.09 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.818 & 2008.523 + 2454663.6044 & b & 18.36 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.619 & 2008.540 + 2454668.4006 & cr & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.516 & 2008.553 + 2454673.4072 & cv & 18.14 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pyg ) & 0.585 & 2008.566 + 2454674.6778 & b & 18.66 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.618 & 2008.570 + 2454683.6602 & b & 18.60 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.917 & 2008.595 + 2454685.2212 & cr & 17.7 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.186 & 2008.599 + 2454690.6428 & b & 18.11 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.591 & 2008.614 + 2454701.4197 & cv & 17.83 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pyg ) & 0.349 & 2008.643 + 2454702.4286 & cv & 17.93 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pyg ) & 0.169 & 2008.646 + 2454702.5739 & b & 18.03 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.287 & 2008.646 + 2454703.3935 & cv & 17.95 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pyg ) & 0.953 & 2008.649 + 2454704.4064 & cv & 17.61 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pyg ) & 0.776 & 2008.651 + 2454705.4003 & cv & 17.73 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pyg ) & 0.584 & 2008.654 + 2454706.4402 & cv & 17.99 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pyg ) & 0.429 & 2008.657 + 2454707.4081 & cv & 17.94 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pyg ) & 0.216 & 2008.660 + 2454707.6070 & b & 18.61 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.377 & 2008.660 + 2454709.3969 & cv & 17.75 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pyg ) & 0.832 & 2008.665 + 2454712.4106 & cv & 18.27 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pyg ) & 0.281 & 2008.673 + 2454713.2255 & cr & 18.2 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.943 & 2008.675 + 2454713.4125 & cv & 17.93 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pyg ) & 0.095 & 2008.676 + 2454723.3956 & cv & 17.61 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pyg ) & 0.208 & 2008.703 + 2454724.2045 & cr & 17.2 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.865 & 2008.706 + 2454726.5230 & b & 18.24 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.749 & 2008.712 + 2454727.9326 & cv & 17.72 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( bhq ) & 0.895 & 2008.716 + 2454728.9341 & cv & 17.78 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( bhq ) & 0.709 & 2008.719 + 2454732.5123 & v & 17.97 @xmath0 0.04 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.617 & 2008.728 + 2454732.5140 & r & 17.63 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.618 & 2008.728 + 2454732.5157 & i & 17.17 @xmath0 0.04 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.619 & 2008.728 + 2454732.5175 & b & 18.45 @xmath0 0.05 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.621 & 2008.728 + 2454733.3896 & cv & 18.26 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pyg ) & 0.330 & 2008.731 + 2454736.5041 & b & 18.58 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.861 & 2008.739 + 2454738.2362 & cr & 17.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.268 & 2008.744 + 2454738.5129 & b & 18.93 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.493 & 2008.745 + 2454740.5027 & v & 18.10 @xmath0 0.06 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.110 & 2008.750 + 2454740.5044 & r & 17.68 @xmath0 0.04 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.111 & 2008.750 + 2454740.5062 & i & 17.29 @xmath0 0.07 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.113 & 2008.750 + 2454740.5079 & b & 18.47 @xmath0 0.06 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.114 & 2008.750 + 2454742.5104 & b & 18.47 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.742 & 2008.756 + 2454745.4841 & b & 18.16 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.158 & 2008.764 + 2454746.3495 & cv & 18.07 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pyg ) & 0.861 & 2008.766 + 2454747.4891 & b & 18.62 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.787 & 2008.769 + 2454752.4958 & v & 17.78 @xmath0 0.06 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.856 & 2008.783 + 2454752.4975 & r & 17.46 @xmath0 0.05 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.857 & 2008.783 + 2454752.4992 & i & 17.11 @xmath0 0.06 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.859 & 2008.783 + 2454752.5010 & b & 18.18 @xmath0 0.08 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.860 & 2008.783 + 2454756.2098 & cr & 17.9 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.874 & 2008.793 + 2454861.0752 & cv & 18.56 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pkv ) & 0.093 & 2009.080 + 2454866.0710 & cv & 18.51 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pkv ) & 0.153 & 2009.094 + 2454881.5174 & cr & 17.3 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.705 & 2009.136 + 2454884.5797 & cr & 17.3 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.194 & 2009.145 + 2454884.7501 & sloan i & 17.16 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.332 & 2009.145 + 2454884.7542 & b & 17.88 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.335 & 2009.145 + 2454884.7563 & v & 17.46 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.337 & 2009.145 + 2454884.7582 & v & 17.45 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.339 & 2009.145 + 2454891.6675 & sloan i & 17.91 @xmath0 0.02 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.954 & 2009.164 + 2454891.6712 & b & 18.94 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.957 & 2009.164 + 2454891.6736 & v & 18.43 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.959 & 2009.164 + 2454891.6752 & v & 18.48 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.960 & 2009.164 + 2454893.9344 & cv & 17.87 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( dks ) & 0.796 & 2009.170 + 2454894.8580 & b & 18.34 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.546 & 2009.173 + 2454896.0435 & cv & 18.12 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pkv ) & 0.510 & 2009.176 + 2454896.2315 & cv & 17.76 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.662 & 2009.177 + 2454896.8338 & b & 18.22 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.152 & 2009.178 + 2454896.9346 & cv & 17.78 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( dks ) & 0.234 & 2009.178 + 2454898.5941 & cr & 17.4 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.582 & 2009.183 + 2454899.1651 & cv & 18.0 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.046 & 2009.185 + 2454899.8479 & b & 18.16 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.601 & 2009.186 + 2454899.9485 & cv & 17.49 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( dks ) & 0.683 & 2009.187 + 2454901.8391 & b & 18.38 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.219 & 2009.192 + 2454901.9489 & cv & 18.47 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( dks ) & 0.309 & 2009.192 + 2454902.0434 & cv & 18.31 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pkv ) & 0.385 & 2009.192 + 2454905.1590 & cv & 17.79 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.917 & 2009.201 + 2454905.8247 & b & 18.36 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.458 & 2009.203 + 2454908.8491 & b & 18.30 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.916 & 2009.211 + 2454911.0264 & cv & 18.00 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pkv ) & 0.686 & 2009.217 + 2454911.5833 & cr & 17.3 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.138 & 2009.219 + 2454911.8143 & b & 18.13 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.326 & 2009.219 + 2454912.7420 & sloan i & 17.46 @xmath0 0.01 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.080 & 2009.222 + 2454912.7460 & b & 18.31 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.083 & 2009.222 + 2454912.7481 & v & 17.83 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.085 & 2009.222 + 2454912.7500 & v & 17.81 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.086 & 2009.222 + 2454913.8012 & b & 18.47 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.940 & 2009.225 + 2454914.9116 & cv & 18.18 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( dks ) & 0.843 & 2009.228 + 2454914.9582 & cv & 17.78 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.881 & 2009.228 + 2454915.0132 & cv & 18.44 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pkv ) & 0.925 & 2009.228 + 2454915.6517 & cr & 17.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.444 & 2009.230 + 2454916.4988 & cr & 17.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.133 & 2009.232 + 2454916.7378 & b & 18.34 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.327 & 2009.233 + 2454917.6509 & cr & 17.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.069 & 2009.235 + 2454918.0053 & cv & 18.07 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pkv ) & 0.357 & 2009.236 + 2454918.5189 & cr & 17.9 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.774 & 2009.238 + 2454918.7660 & b & 19.20 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.975 & 2009.238 + 2454919.5610 & cr & 17.2 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.621 & 2009.240 + 2454919.5940 & sloan i & 17.36 @xmath0 0.01 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.648 & 2009.241 + 2454919.5976 & b & 18.24 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.651 & 2009.241 + 2454919.5997 & v & 17.70 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.653 & 2009.241 + 2454919.6016 & v & 17.71 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.654 & 2009.241 + 2454920.7856 & b & 17.96 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.616 & 2009.244 + 2454920.8880 & cv & 18.0 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( dks ) & 0.699 & 2009.244 + 2454921.0004 & cv & 18.01 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pkv ) & 0.791 & 2009.244 + 2454921.6982 & sloan i & 17.28 @xmath0 0.01 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.358 & 2009.246 + 2454921.7023 & b & 18.09 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.361 & 2009.246 + 2454921.7044 & v & 17.64 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.363 & 2009.246 + 2454921.7063 & v & 17.66 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.364 & 2009.246 + 2454921.9013 & cv & 17.92 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( dks ) & 0.523 & 2009.247 + 2454922.4063 & cr & 17.1 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.933 & 2009.248 + 2454922.7853 & b & 18.28 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.241 & 2009.249 + 2454923.5023 & cr & 17.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.824 & 2009.251 + 2454923.5767 & sloan i & 17.44 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.884 & 2009.251 + 2454923.5803 & b & 18.26 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.887 & 2009.251 + 2454923.5824 & v & 17.81 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.889 & 2009.251 + 2454923.5843 & v & 17.80 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.891 & 2009.251 + 2454924.7283 & b & 18.25 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.820 & 2009.255 + 2454925.7709 & cv & 18.16 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( dks ) & 0.668 & 2009.257 + 2454925.9883 & cv & 18.18 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pkv ) & 0.844 & 2009.258 + 2454926.1134 & cv & 18.09 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.946 & 2009.258 + 2454926.5486 & cr & 17.3 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.300 & 2009.260 + 2454926.5759 & sloan i & 17.20 @xmath0 0.02 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.322 & 2009.260 + 2454926.5800 & b & 18.04 @xmath0 0.07 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.325 & 2009.260 + 2454926.5820 & v & 17.58 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.327 & 2009.260 + 2454926.5839 & v & 17.59 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.328 & 2009.260 + 2454926.7196 & b & 18.23 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.439 & 2009.260 + 2454927.5027 & cr & 17.7 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.075 & 2009.262 + 2454928.7947 & b & 18.49 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.125 & 2009.266 + 2454930.0568 & cv & 17.61 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( bhq ) & 0.151 & 2009.269 + 2454930.8615 & b & 18.38 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.804 & 2009.271 + 2454931.1072 & cv & 19.35 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.004 & 2009.272 + 2454931.6620 & sloan i & 17.48 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0
m & 0.455 & 2009.274 + 2454931.6661 & b & 18.18 @xmath0 0.08 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.458 & 2009.274 + 2454931.6681 & v & 17.69 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.460 & 2009.274 + 2454931.6700 & v & 17.67 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.461 & 2009.274 + 2454932.7740 & b & 18.24 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.359 & 2009.277 + 2454933.1293 & cv & 17.98 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.647 & 2009.278 + 2454935.4532 & cr & 17.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.536 & 2009.284 + 2454936.7619 & b & 18.68 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.599 & 2009.288 + 2454937.5402 & sloan i & 17.78 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.232 & 2009.290 + 2454937.5443 & b & 18.88 @xmath0 0.10 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.235 & 2009.290 + 2454937.5463 & v & 18.24 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.237 & 2009.290 + 2454937.5482 & v & 18.20 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.238 & 2009.290 + 2454938.0613 & v & 18.50 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( bhq ) & 0.655 & 2009.291 + 2454938.4364 & cr & 18.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.960 & 2009.292 + 2454938.7630 & b & 18.70 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.226 & 2009.293 + 2454939.1014 & cv & 18.28 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.500 & 2009.294 + 2454940.5115 & cr & 17.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.646 & 2009.298 + 2454940.7541 & b & 18.26 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.844 & 2009.298 + 2454941.1800 & cv & 18.16 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pkv ) & 0.190 & 2009.300 + 2454942.5390 & sloan i & 17.19 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.294 & 2009.303 + 2454942.5472 & v & 17.54
@xmath0 0.13 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.301 & 2009.303 + 2454942.7979 & b & 18.23 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.505 & 2009.304 + 2454943.8966 & cv & 18.06 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( dks ) & 0.397 & 2009.307 + 2454944.1991 & cv & 17.96 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.643 & 2009.308 + 2454944.7328 & cv & 18.35 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( dks ) & 0.077 & 2009.309 + 2454945.9145 & cv & 18.1 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( dks ) & 0.037 & 2009.313 + 2454947.7751 & b & 18.58 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.549 & 2009.318 + 2454947.7996 & v & 18.47 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( cmp ) & 0.569 & 2009.318 + 2454947.8423 & cv & 18.37 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( dks ) & 0.604 & 2009.318 + 2454948.9029 & cv & 18.01 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( dks ) & 0.466 & 2009.321 + 2454949.3910 & cr & 17.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.862 & 2009.322 + 2454949.6660 & sloan i & 17.64 @xmath0 0.00 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.086 & 2009.323 + 2454949.6701 & b & 18.67 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.089 & 2009.323 + 2454949.6721 & v & 18.10 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.091 & 2009.323 + 2454949.6740 & sloan r & 17.91 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.092 & 2009.323 + 2454949.7563 & cv & 18.07 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( dks ) & 0.159 & 2009.323 + 2454949.7903 & b & 18.60 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.187 & 2009.323 + 2454951.1265 & cv & 18.21 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.273 & 2009.327 + 2454951.5689 & sloan i & 17.50 @xmath0 0.02 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.632 & 2009.328 + 2454951.5729 & b & 18.52 @xmath0 0.07 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.635 & 2009.328 + 2454951.5749 & v & 17.99 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.637 & 2009.328 + 2454951.5768 & sloan r & 17.82 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.639 & 2009.328 + 2454951.7800 & b & 18.57 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.804 & 2009.329 + 2454953.6866 & sloan i & 17.63 @xmath0 0.02 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.353 & 2009.334 + 2454953.6907 & b & 18.55 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.356 & 2009.334 + 2454953.6927 & v & 18.02 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.358 & 2009.334 + 2454953.6946 & sloan r & 17.87 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.360 & 2009.334 + 2454953.7107 & b & 18.53 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.373 & 2009.334 + 2454954.1088 & cv & 18.04 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.696 & 2009.335 + 2454955.6663 & cr & 17.7 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.962 & 2009.339 + 2454955.7640 & b & 19.40 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.041 & 2009.340 + 2454956.3773 & cr & 17.7 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.540 & 2009.341 + 2454956.4887 & sloan i & 17.64 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.630 & 2009.342 + 2454956.4927 & b & 18.77 @xmath0 0.16 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.634 & 2009.342 + 2454956.4947 & v & 18.14 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.635 & 2009.342 + 2454956.4967 & sloan r & 17.96 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0
m & 0.637 & 2009.342 + 2454959.8068 & b & 18.64 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.327 & 2009.351 + 2454964.5124 & sloan i & 17.74 @xmath0 0.02 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.151 & 2009.363 + 2454964.5164 & b & 18.89 @xmath0 0.09 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.154 & 2009.363 + 2454964.5184 & v & 18.20 @xmath0 0.07 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.156 & 2009.364 + 2454964.5204 & sloan r & 18.03 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.157 & 2009.364 + 2454964.7029 & b & 18.67 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.306 & 2009.364 + 2454966.3226 & cr & 17.7 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.622 & 2009.368 + 2454966.5177 & sloan i & 17.62 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.780 & 2009.369 + 2454966.5216 & b & 18.75 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.784 & 2009.369 + 2454966.5236 & v & 18.21 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.785 & 2009.369 + 2454966.5256 & sloan r & 18.01 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.787 & 2009.369 + 2454966.6656 & b & 18.67 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.900 & 2009.369 + 2454968.3567 & cr & 18.1 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.275 & 2009.374 + 2454968.5674 & sloan i & 17.95 @xmath0 0.02 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.446 & 2009.375 + 2454968.5714 & b & 18.93 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.449 & 2009.375 + 2454968.5734 & v & 18.42 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.451 & 2009.375 + 2454968.5754 & sloan r & 18.24 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.452 & 2009.375 + 2454968.7377 & b & 18.74 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.584 & 2009.375 + 2454970.5467 & cr & 18.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.054 & 2009.380 + 2454970.7732 & b & 18.86 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.239 & 2009.381 + 2454971.4556 & sloan i & 17.71 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.793 & 2009.382 + 2454971.4596 & b & 18.68 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.796 & 2009.383 + 2454971.4620 & v & 18.12 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.798 & 2009.383 + 2454971.4635 & sloan r & 17.97 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0
m & 0.800 & 2009.383 + 2454972.8519 & b & 18.71 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.928 & 2009.386 + 2454972.8582 & cv & 18.41 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pkv ) & 0.933 & 2009.386 + 2454973.0938 & cv & 18.03 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.124 & 2009.387 + 2454973.1579 & v & 18.3 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( dil ) & 0.176 & 2009.387 + 2454973.9704 & cv & 18.07 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.837 & 2009.389 + 2454974.3807 & cr & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.170 & 2009.391 + 2454974.7504 & b & 18.75 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.471 & 2009.392 + 2454975.4379 & sloan i & 18.12 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.029 & 2009.393 + 2454975.4419 & b & 19.33 @xmath0 0.07 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.032 & 2009.393 + 2454975.4439 & v & 18.67 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.034 & 2009.393 + 2454975.4458 & sloan r & 18.42 @xmath0 0.07 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.036 & 2009.393 + 2454975.7553 & cv & 18.29 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.287 & 2009.394 + 2454976.7628 & v & 18.05 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.106 & 2009.397 + 2454976.7644 & r & 17.72 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.107 & 2009.397 + 2454976.7661 & i & 17.26 @xmath0 0.04 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.109 & 2009.397 + 2454976.7678 & b & 18.55 @xmath0 0.04 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.110 & 2009.397 + 2454977.5431 & sloan i & 17.63 @xmath0 0.02 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.740 & 2009.399 + 2454977.5471 & b & 18.61 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.743 & 2009.399 + 2454977.5491 & v & 18.10 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.745 & 2009.399 + 2454977.5512 & sloan r & 17.92 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.747 & 2009.399 + 2454978.3128 & cr & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.366 & 2009.401 + 2454978.3168 & cr & 17.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.369 & 2009.401 + 2454978.3208 & cr & 17.7 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.372 & 2009.401 + 2454978.3238 & cr & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.374 & 2009.401 + 2454979.5858 & cr & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.400 & 2009.405 + 2454980.7266 & b & 18.63 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.327 & 2009.408 + 2454981.2502 & cv & 18.32 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.753 & 2009.409 + 2454981.4998 & sloan i & 18.09 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0
m & 0.955 & 2009.410 + 2454981.5145 & sloan i & 18.20 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.967 & 2009.410 + 2454981.5186 & b & 19.37 @xmath0 0.08 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.971 & 2009.410 + 2454981.5205 & v & 18.78 @xmath0 0.07 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.972 & 2009.410 + 2454981.5225 & sloan r & 18.62 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.974 & 2009.410 + 2454982.6930 & b & 18.64 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.925 & 2009.413 + 2454982.7332 & cv & 18.57 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.958 & 2009.413 + 2454983.4674 & b & 18.57 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.554 & 2009.415 + 2454983.4694 & v & 18.01 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.556 & 2009.415 + 2454983.4713 & sloan r & 17.87 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.558 & 2009.415 + 2454983.5017 & cr & 17.7 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.582 & 2009.415 + 2454983.7407 & b & 18.33 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.777 & 2009.416 + 2454984.7141 & b & 18.23 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.568 & 2009.419 + 2454985.7129 & b & 17.90 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.379 & 2009.422 + 2454986.2017 & cr & 17.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.776 & 2009.423 + 2454986.4127 & sloan i & 17.66 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.948 & 2009.423 + 2454986.4167 & b & 18.56 @xmath0 0.12 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.951 & 2009.423 + 2454986.4187 & v & 18.11 @xmath0 0.07 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.953 & 2009.423 + 2454986.4211 & sloan r & 17.96 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0
m & 0.955 & 2009.423 + 2454986.6494 & b & 18.11 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.140 & 2009.424 + 2454987.1799 & cv & 17.91 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.571 & 2009.426 + 2454987.5817 & cr & 17.3 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.898 & 2009.427 + 2454987.7251 & b & 19.41 @xmath0 0.04 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.014 & 2009.427 + 2454990.7816 & b & 18.21 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.498 & 2009.435 + 2454991.7044 & b & 18.02 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.248 & 2009.438 + 2454992.4328 & sloan i & 17.33 @xmath0 0.02 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.840 & 2009.440 + 2454992.4369 & b & 18.19 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.843 & 2009.440 + 2454992.4389 & v & 17.70 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.845 & 2009.440 + 2454992.4409 & sloan r & 17.51 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.847 & 2009.440 + 2454992.7323 & b & 18.34 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.083 & 2009.441 + 2454993.6972 & b & 18.21 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.868 & 2009.443 + 2454994.0200 & v & 17.52 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( dil ) & 0.130 & 2009.444 + 2454994.7425 & b & 18.31 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.717 & 2009.446 + 2454995.3586 & cr & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.218 & 2009.448 + 2454995.4596 & sloan i & 17.31 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.300 & 2009.448 + 2454995.4636 & b & 18.35 @xmath0 0.07 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.303 & 2009.448 + 2454995.4656 & v & 17.77 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.305 & 2009.448 + 2454995.4675 & sloan r & 17.60 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.306 & 2009.448 + 2454995.7532 & b & 18.29 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.538 & 2009.449 + 2454996.3515 & cr & 18.4 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.025 & 2009.451 + 2455002.5322 & sloan i & 18.06 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.047 & 2009.468 + 2455002.5362 & b & 19.11 @xmath0 0.07 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.051 & 2009.468 + 2455002.5382 & v & 18.48 @xmath0 0.07 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.052 & 2009.468 + 2455002.5402 & sloan r & 18.31 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.054 & 2009.468 + 2455003.2653 & cr & 18.2 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.643 & 2009.470 + 2455003.9401 & cv & 18.31 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.192 & 2009.471 + 2455004.7473 & v & 16.94 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( psd ) & 0.847 & 2009.474 + 2455004.7641 & v & 16.96 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( psd ) & 0.861 & 2009.474 + 2455004.9621 & cv & 18.7 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( nlx ) & 0.022 & 2009.474 + 2455005.0724 & cv & 18.62 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( bhq ) & 0.112 & 2009.475 + 2455005.3912 & cr & 18.3 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.371 & 2009.475 + 2455005.7532 & v & 18.06 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( sric ) & 0.665 & 2009.476 + 2455006.3362 & cr & 18.1 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.139 & 2009.478 + 2455006.4882 & sloan i & 17.70 @xmath0 0.02 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.262 & 2009.478 + 2455006.4922 & b & 18.76 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.265 & 2009.478 + 2455006.4942 & v & 18.22 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.267 & 2009.478 + 2455006.4962 & sloan r & 18.04 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.269 & 2009.478 + 2455007.0498 & cv & 18.44 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( bhq ) & 0.719 & 2009.480 + 2455007.2412 & cr & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.874 & 2009.480 + 2455007.5674 & b & 18.69 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.139 & 2009.481 + 2455008.5134 & b & 18.53 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.908 & 2009.484 + 2455009.3061 & cr & 18.0 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.552 & 2009.486 + 2455009.7414 & cv & 17.77 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( sric ) & 0.906 & 2009.487 + 2455010.3460 & cr & 17.7 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.397 & 2009.489 + 2455010.5803 & b & 18.62 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.588 & 2009.490 + 2455010.9357 & cv & 18.1 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.876 & 2009.491 + 2455011.4751 & cv & 17.96 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( muy ) & 0.315 & 2009.492 + 2455012.4913 & sloan i & 17.52 @xmath0 0.01 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.141 & 2009.495 + 2455012.4953 & b & 18.51 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.144 & 2009.495 + 2455012.4973 & v & 17.94 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.145 & 2009.495 + 2455012.4993 & sloan r & 17.76 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0
m & 0.147 & 2009.495 + 2455012.6152 & b & 18.56 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.241 & 2009.495 + 2455013.0802 & cv & 18.06 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.619 & 2009.496 + 2455013.4858 & b & 18.92 @xmath0 0.05 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.949 & 2009.498 + 2455014.5882 & b & 18.45 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.845 & 2009.501 + 2455014.6694 & cv & 17.95 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.911 & 2009.501 + 2455015.1362 & cv & 18.1 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.290 & 2009.502 + 2455015.1558 & cv & 17.95 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.306 & 2009.502 + 2455015.3108 & cr & 18.1 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.432 & 2009.503 + 2455018.6595 & b & 18.42 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.153 & 2009.512 + 2455019.1295 & cv & 17.89 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.535 & 2009.513 + 2455019.1392 & cv & 17.86 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.543 & 2009.513 + 2455019.2445 & cr & 17.3 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.629 & 2009.513 + 2455019.6121 & b & 18.63 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.927 & 2009.514 + 2455019.7439 & cv & 17.93 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.034 & 2009.515 + 2455020.1059 & cv & 18.16 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.329 & 2009.516 + 2455020.6297 & b & 18.38 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.754 & 2009.517 + 2455020.6710 & cv & 17.99 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.788 & 2009.517 + 2455020.7370 & v & 17.14 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( wwl ) & 0.841 & 2009.517 + 2455021.1146 & cv & 17.96 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.148 & 2009.518 + 2455021.1577 & cv & 18.09 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.183 & 2009.519 + 2455021.2154 & cr & 17.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.230 & 2009.519 + 2455021.4884 & sloan i & 17.63 @xmath0 0.02 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.452 & 2009.519 + 2455021.4924 & b & 18.47 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.455 & 2009.519 + 2455021.4943 & v & 17.95 @xmath0 0.07 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.457 & 2009.519 + 2455021.4963 & sloan r & 17.83 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0
m & 0.459 & 2009.519 + 2455021.6017 & b & 18.44 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.544 & 2009.520 + 2455021.6496 & cv & 18.11 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.583 & 2009.520 + 2455022.2654 & cr & 17.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.083 & 2009.522 + 2455022.5897 & b & 18.45 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.347 & 2009.522 + 2455022.6491 & cv & 17.9 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.395 & 2009.523 + 2455022.7025 & cv & 18.05 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.439 & 2009.523 + 2455023.2803 & cr & 18.0 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.908 & 2009.524 + 2455023.5690 & b & 18.57 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.143 & 2009.525 + 2455023.6563 & cv & 18.04 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.214 & 2009.525 + 2455023.7081 & cv & 18.28 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.256 & 2009.526 + 2455023.7447 & cv & 18.17 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.286 & 2009.526 + 2455024.2232 & cr & 17.4 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.675 & 2009.527 + 2455024.7032 & cv & 17.91 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.065 & 2009.528 + 2455025.0929 & cv & 18.14 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.381 & 2009.529 + 2455025.1363 & cv & 18.05 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.417 & 2009.529 + 2455025.2142 & cr & 17.9 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.480 & 2009.530 + 2455025.6573 & cv & 18.28 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.840 & 2009.531 + 2455026.1473 & cv & 17.84 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.238 & 2009.532 + 2455026.3724 & cr & 18.05 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( bzu ) & 0.421 & 2009.533 + 2455026.4402 & sloan i & 17.69 @xmath0 0.01 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.476 & 2009.533 + 2455026.4443 & b & 18.60 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.479 & 2009.533 + 2455026.4463 & v & 18.11 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.481 & 2009.533 + 2455026.4484 & sloan r & 17.97 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.483 & 2009.533 + 2455026.6593 & cv & 17.92 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.654 & 2009.534 + 2455026.6939 & cv & 18.0 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.682 & 2009.534 + 2455026.9864 & cv & 18.2 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( nlx ) & 0.920 & 2009.535 + 2455027.2600 & cr & 17.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.142 & 2009.535 + 2455027.6750 & cv & 18.22 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.480 & 2009.536 + 2455028.0956 & cv & 17.88 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.821 & 2009.538 + 2455028.1546 & cv & 17.9 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.869 & 2009.538 + 2455028.2690 & cr & 18.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.962 & 2009.538 + 2455028.7536 & cv & 17.57 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( sric ) & 0.356 & 2009.539 + 2455029.2459 & cr & 17.3 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.756 & 2009.541 + 2455029.6240 & b & 18.71 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.063 & 2009.542 + 2455029.6289 & cv & 18.2 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.067 & 2009.542 + 2455030.6482 & cv & 18.33 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.896 & 2009.545 + 2455031.2258 & cr & 17.7 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.365 & 2009.546 + 2455031.4477 & cv & 17.95 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pyg ) & 0.545 & 2009.547 + 2455032.0822 & cv & 18.19 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.061 & 2009.548 + 2455032.2137 & cr & 17.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.168 & 2009.549 + 2455032.4878 & sloan i & 17.47 @xmath0 0.02 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.391 & 2009.550 + 2455032.4918 & b & 18.41 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.394 & 2009.550 + 2455032.4938 & v & 17.89 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.396 & 2009.550 + 2455032.4958 & sloan r & 17.77 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.397 & 2009.550 + 2455032.8893 & cv & 17.98 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.717 & 2009.551 + 2455032.9295 & cv & 17.92 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.750 & 2009.551 + 2455033.1077 & cv & 17.99 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.894 & 2009.551 + 2455033.2126 & cr & 18.7 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.980 & 2009.552 + 2455033.8991 & cv & 18.02 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.538 & 2009.553 + 2455034.2005 & cr & 17.4 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.783 & 2009.554 + 2455034.6668 & cv & 18.35 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.161 & 2009.556 + 2455034.7064 & cv & 17.78 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( sric ) & 0.194 & 2009.556 + 2455035.2465 & cr & 17.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.633 & 2009.557 + 2455035.4884 & sloan i & 17.47 @xmath0 0.02 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.829 & 2009.558 + 2455035.4923 & b & 18.49 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.832 & 2009.558 + 2455035.4943 & v & 17.95 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.834 & 2009.558 + 2455035.4963 & sloan r & 17.77 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.836 & 2009.558 + 2455035.8740 & cv & 17.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( nlx ) & 0.142 & 2009.559 + 2455036.1247 & cv & 17.84 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.346 & 2009.560 + 2455036.1954 & cr & 17.4 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.404 & 2009.560 + 2455036.6378 & b & 18.44 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.763 & 2009.561 + 2455036.6485 & cv & 18.07 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.772 & 2009.561 + 2455036.9427 & cv & 19.12 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.011 & 2009.562 + 2455037.1186 & cv & 18.07 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.154 & 2009.562 + 2455037.6971 & cv & 17.84 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.624 & 2009.564 + 2455037.9416 & cv & 18.05 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.823 & 2009.565 + 2455037.9820 & cv & 17.95 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.856 & 2009.565 + 2455038.0482 & cv & 18.05 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.909 & 2009.565 + 2455038.2052 & cr & 18.2 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.037 & 2009.565 + 2455038.6556 & cv & 18.16 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.403 & 2009.566 + 2455039.0178 & cv & 17.98 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.697 & 2009.567 + 2455039.2101 & cr & 17.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.854 & 2009.568 + 2455039.9326 & cv & 18.14 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.441 & 2009.570 + 2455040.2301 & cr & 17.4 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.682 & 2009.571 + 2455040.5758 & b & 19.05 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.963 & 2009.572 + 2455041.0937 & cv & 18.09 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.384 & 2009.573 + 2455041.2130 & cr & 17.9 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.481 & 2009.573 + 2455041.6488 & b & 18.43 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.835 & 2009.575 + 2455042.5988 & b & 18.58 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.607 & 2009.577 + 2455044.9893 & v & 17.22 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( bhq ) & 0.550 & 2009.584 + 2455046.6768 & b & 18.56 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.921 & 2009.588 + 2455046.9893 & v & 17.96 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( bhq ) & 0.175 & 2009.589 + 2455047.5894 & cv & 17.94 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.663 & 2009.591 + 2455048.0763 & cv & 18.22 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.059 & 2009.592 + 2455048.4355 & sloan i & 17.52 @xmath0 0.01 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.350 & 2009.593 + 2455048.4395 & b & 18.45 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.354 & 2009.593 + 2455048.4414 & v & 17.93 @xmath0 0.07 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.355 & 2009.593 + 2455048.4434 & sloan r & 17.75 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.357 & 2009.593 + 2455048.4733 & sloan i & 17.57 @xmath0 0.02 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.381 & 2009.593 + 2455048.4772 & b & 18.52 @xmath0 0.07 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.384 & 2009.593 + 2455048.4791 & v & 17.96 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.386 & 2009.593 + 2455048.4811 & sloan r & 17.78 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.388 & 2009.593 + 2455048.5534 & cv & 18.27 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.446 & 2009.594 + 2455048.6338 & b & 18.47 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.512 & 2009.594 + 2455048.6900 & cv & 17.97 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.557 & 2009.594 + 2455049.9723 & v & 18.06 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( bhq ) & 0.599 & 2009.597 + 2455049.9777 & cv & 17.94 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.604 & 2009.597 + 2455050.0707 & cv & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.679 & 2009.598 + 2455050.5672 & cv & 18.22 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.083 & 2009.599 + 2455050.8958 & cv & 17.96 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.350 & 2009.600 + 2455051.9287 & cv & 17.95 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.189 & 2009.603 + 2455051.9728 & cv & 17.85 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.225 & 2009.603 + 2455052.4291 & sloan i & 17.22 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.596 & 2009.604 + 2455052.4331 & b & 18.06 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.599 & 2009.604 + 2455052.4350 & v & 17.60 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.601 & 2009.604 + 2455052.4370 & sloan r & 17.47 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.602 & 2009.604 + 2455053.1989 & cr & 17.4 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.222 & 2009.606 + 2455053.5649 & cv & 18.05 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.519 & 2009.607 + 2455053.5934 & b & 18.19 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.542 & 2009.607 + 2455053.6484 & v & 17.43 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( arj ) & 0.587 & 2009.608 + 2455053.6981 & v & 17.80 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mgw ) & 0.627 & 2009.608 + 2455054.4497 & sloan i & 17.38 @xmath0 0.02 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.238 & 2009.610 + 2455054.4556 & v & 17.84 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.243 & 2009.610 + 2455054.4575 & sloan r & 17.64 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.244 & 2009.610 + 2455054.5229 & b & 18.29 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.297 & 2009.610 + 2455054.6143 & v & 18.05 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( arj ) & 0.372 & 2009.610 + 2455055.2948 & cr & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.925 & 2009.612 + 2455055.9509 & cv & 17.92 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.458 & 2009.614 + 2455056.6351 & cv & 18.84 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.014 & 2009.616 + 2455056.9922 & cv & 17.97 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.304 & 2009.617 + 2455057.2436 & cr & 17.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.508 & 2009.617 + 2455057.5625 & cv & 17.99
@xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.768 & 2009.618 + 2455057.5702 & b & 18.34 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.774 & 2009.618 + 2455057.9987 & cv & 18.04 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.122 & 2009.619 + 2455058.5564 & cv & 17.96 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.575 & 2009.621 + 2455058.5892 & b & 18.18 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.602 & 2009.621 + 2455058.6450 & cv & 17.9 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.647 & 2009.621 + 2455059.1964 & cr & 17.3 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.095 & 2009.623 + 2455059.5504 & cv & 18.06 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.383 & 2009.624 + 2455059.6251 & cv & 18.02 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.444 & 2009.624 + 2455060.5543 & cv & 18.19 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.199 & 2009.626 + 2455060.6529 & cv & 18.29 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.279 & 2009.627 + 2455061.2272 & cr & 17.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.746 & 2009.628 + 2455061.5862 & cv & 19.03 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.037 & 2009.629 + 2455061.6248 & cv & 18.7 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.069 & 2009.629 + 2455062.2111 & cr & 17.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.545 & 2009.631 + 2455062.3873 & sloan i & 17.58 @xmath0 0.02 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.688 & 2009.631 + 2455062.3912 & b & 18.59 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.692 & 2009.631 + 2455062.3932 & v & 18.06 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.693 & 2009.631 + 2455062.3951 & sloan r & 17.87 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.695 & 2009.631 + 2455063.9631 & cv & 18.49 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( nmt ) & 0.969 & 2009.636 + 2455064.2179 & cr & 17.7 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.176 & 2009.636 + 2455064.5759 & cv & 18.35 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.467 & 2009.637 + 2455065.2878 & cr & 18.3 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.046 & 2009.639 + 2455066.2857 & cr & 17.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.856 & 2009.642 + 2455066.4128 & sloan i & 17.99 @xmath0 0.02 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.960 & 2009.642 + 2455066.4165 & b & 18.91 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.963 & 2009.642 + 2455066.4183 & v & 18.45 @xmath0 0.07 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.964 & 2009.642 + 2455066.4201 & sloan r & 18.33 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.966 & 2009.642 + 2455066.4247 & cv & 18.15 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( pyg ) & 0.969 & 2009.643 + 2455067.5596 & cv & 18.23 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.892 & 2009.646 + 2455068.2335 & cr & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.439 & 2009.647 + 2455068.5745 & cv & 18.08 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.716 & 2009.648 + 2455069.2264 & cr & 17.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.246 & 2009.650 + 2455070.2023 & cr & 18.4 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.039 & 2009.653 + 2455070.5523 & cv & 18.35 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.324 & 2009.654 + 2455072.1991 & cr & 17.4 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.662 & 2009.658 + 2455073.2380 & cr & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.506 & 2009.661 + 2455073.5008 & b & 18.65 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.720 & 2009.662 + 2455075.2009 & cr & 18.3 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.101 & 2009.667 + 2455076.2258 & cr & 18.0 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.934 & 2009.669 + 2455076.5441 & b & 19.12 @xmath0 0.05 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.193 & 2009.670 + 2455077.2117 & cr & 18.4 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.735 & 2009.672 + 2455078.2106 & cr & 17.9 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.547 & 2009.675 + 2455078.5161 & b & 18.76 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.795 & 2009.676 + 2455079.2145 & cr & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.363 & 2009.678 + 2455079.4997 & b & 19.02 @xmath0 0.08 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.595 & 2009.678 + 2455079.5013 & i & 17.70 @xmath0 0.06 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.596 & 2009.678 + 2455079.5030 & r & 18.16 @xmath0 0.05 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.597 & 2009.678 + 2455079.5045 & v & 18.55 @xmath0 0.07 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.599 & 2009.678 + 2455080.2844 & cr & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.232 & 2009.680 + 2455082.3062 & cr & 17.9 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.875 & 2009.686 + 2455083.5801 & b & 18.90 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.911 & 2009.689 + 2455084.1990 & cr & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.414 & 2009.691 + 2455084.5060 & cv & 18.22 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.663 & 2009.692 + 2455084.5538 & b & 18.94 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.702 & 2009.692 + 2455085.3689 & sloan i & 17.80 @xmath0 0.02 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.364 & 2009.694 + 2455085.3725 & b & 18.86 @xmath0 0.07 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.367 & 2009.694 + 2455085.3743 & v & 18.26 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.369 & 2009.694 + 2455085.3761 & sloan r & 18.07 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.370 & 2009.694 + 2455087.1957 & cr & 17.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.849 & 2009.699 + 2455088.3633 & sloan i & 17.72 @xmath0 0.02 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.798 & 2009.703 + 2455088.3669 & b & 18.79 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.801 & 2009.703 + 2455088.3688 & v & 18.22 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.802 & 2009.703 + 2455088.3706 & sloan r & 18.03 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.804 & 2009.703 + 2455088.5436 & cv & 18.73 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.944 & 2009.703 + 2455089.4934 & b & 18.83 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.716 & 2009.706 + 2455089.5215 & cv & 18.46 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.739 & 2009.706 + 2455090.2004 & cr & 17.3 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.291 & 2009.708 + 2455091.2563 & cr & 18.0 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.149 & 2009.710 + 2455093.2561 & cr & 17.7 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.774 & 2009.716 + 2455093.5311 & cv & 18.90 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.997 & 2009.717 + 2455094.2020 & cr & 17.9 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.543 & 2009.719 + 2455095.2039 & cr & 17.7 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.357 & 2009.721 + 2455095.5229 & cv & 18.15 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.616 & 2009.722 + 2455096.4845 & b & 18.47 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.397 & 2009.725 + 2455096.5228 & cv & 18.27 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.429 & 2009.725 + 2455100.5070 & b & 18.10 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.666 & 2009.736 + 2455101.2124 & cr & 17.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.240 & 2009.738 + 2455101.5017 & b & 18.23 @xmath0 0.02 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.475 & 2009.739 + 2455102.2203 & cr & 17.9 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.059 & 2009.741 + 2455102.5093 & cv & 18.15 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.293 & 2009.741 + 2455103.4949 & b & 18.25 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.094 & 2009.744 + 2455103.5022 & cv & 17.98 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.100 & 2009.744 + 2455104.4800 & b & 18.27 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.895 & 2009.747 + 2455104.5081 & cv & 18.18 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.918 & 2009.747 + 2455105.4955 & b & 18.45 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.720 & 2009.749 + 2455105.5190 & cv & 18.02 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.739 & 2009.750 + 2455106.4936 & b & 18.37 @xmath0 0.03 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.531 & 2009.752 + 2455106.4939 & cv & 18.3 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.532 & 2009.752 + 2455108.5038 & cv & 18.3 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.165 & 2009.758 + 2455109.4822 & b & 19.09 @xmath0 0.06 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.960 & 2009.760 + 2455110.5066 & cv & 18.26 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.792 & 2009.763 + 2455110.8767 & v & 17.67 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( bhq ) & 0.093 & 2009.764 + 2455113.4882 & b & 18.68 @xmath0 0.06 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.215 & 2009.771 + 2455114.4997 & b & 19.40 @xmath0 0.04 & smarts 1.3 m & 0.037 & 2009.774 + 2455123.2137 & cr & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mlf ) & 0.119 & 2009.798 + 2455123.4897 & cv & 18.4 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.343 & 2009.799 + 2455124.4856 & cv & 18.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.152 & 2009.801 + 2455126.4825 & cv & 18.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.775 & 2009.807 + 2455139.7083 & visual & @xmath812.0 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso(lmk ) & 0.523 & 2009.843 + 2455141.8861 & visual & @xmath811.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( ksh ) & 0.293 & 2009.849 + 2455158.9458 & cv & @xmath88.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso(dks ) & 0.156 & 2009.896 + 2455159.9875 & cv & @xmath88.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso(dks ) & 0.003 & 2009.899 + 2455161.0292 & cv & @xmath88.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso(dks ) & 0.849 & 2009.902 + 2455162.1792 & cv & @xmath88.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso(dks ) & 0.784 & 2009.905 + 2455163.1958 & cv & @xmath88.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso(dks ) & 0.610 & 2009.907 + 2455163.6125 & cv & @xmath88.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso(dks ) & 0.949 & 2009.909 + 2455165.3625 & cv & @xmath88.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso(dks ) & 0.371 & 2009.913 + 2455165.9708 & cv & @xmath88.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso(dks ) & 0.865 & 2009.915 + 2455193.1556 & visual & @xmath814.0 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso(lmk ) & 0.957 & 2009.989 + 2455194.1535 & visual & @xmath814.3 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso(lmk ) & 0.769 & 2009.992 + 2455195.9635 & v & @xmath817.4 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( hbb ) & 0.239 & 2009.997 + 2455200.9643 & v & 17.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( hbb ) & 0.303 & 2010.011 + 2455201.9701 & v & 17.40 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( hbb ) & 0.120 & 2010.014 + 2455202.9553 & v & 17.75 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( hbb ) & 0.921 & 2010.016 + 2455203.9426 & v & 17.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( hbb ) & 0.723 & 2010.019 + 2455206.9348 & cv & 18.4 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.154 & 2010.027 + 2455207.9399 & cv & 19.4 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.971 & 2010.030 + 2455208.9373 & v & 17.8 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( hbb ) & 0.782 & 2010.033 + 2455209.9455 & v & 17.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( hbb ) & 0.601 & 2010.035 + 2455210.9441 & cv & 18.15 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.413 & 2010.038 + 2455210.9527 & v & 18.2 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( hbb ) & 0.420 & 2010.038 + 2455211.9532 & cv & 18.2 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.233 & 2010.041 + 2455214.7784 & sloan i & 17.54 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.529 & 2010.049 + 2455214.7820 & b & 18.49 @xmath0 0.09 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.531 & 2010.049 + 2455214.7838 & v & 17.88 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.533 & 2010.049 + 2455214.7857 & sloan r & 17.75 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.534 & 2010.049 + 2455215.9105 & cv & 18.4 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.449 & 2010.052 + 2455215.9524 & v & 17.7 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( hbb ) & 0.483 & 2010.052 + 2455216.9534 & v & 17.7 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( hbb ) & 0.296 & 2010.055 + 2455217.7734 & sloan i & 18.07 @xmath0 0.03 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.962 & 2010.057 + 2455217.7770 & b & 19.18 @xmath0 0.08 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.965 & 2010.057 + 2455217.7789 & v & 18.59 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.967 & 2010.057 + 2455217.7807 & sloan r & 18.48 @xmath0 0.06 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.968 & 2010.057 + 2455219.7638 & sloan i & 17.73 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.580 & 2010.062 + 2455219.7674 & b & 18.76 @xmath0 0.07 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.583 & 2010.062 + 2455219.7693 & v & 18.15 @xmath0 0.07 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.584 & 2010.062 + 2455219.7711 & sloan r & 17.97 @xmath0 0.05 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.586 & 2010.062 + 2455219.9308 & cv & 18.32 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.716 & 2010.063 + 2455222.7671 & sloan i & 18.29 @xmath0 0.04 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.021 & 2010.071 + 2455222.7708 & b & 19.46 @xmath0 0.08 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.024 & 2010.071 + 2455222.7726 & v & 18.74
@xmath0 0.09 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.025 & 2010.071 + 2455222.7744 & sloan r & 18.55 @xmath0 0.08 & liverpool 2.0 m & 0.026 & 2010.071 + 2455222.9351 & cv & 18.16 @xmath0 0.02 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.157 & 2010.071 + 2455222.9628 & v & 18.3 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( hbb ) & 0.180 & 2010.071 + 2455223.9232 & cv & 18.6 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( mjle ) & 0.960 & 2010.074 + 2455223.9473 & v & 18.2 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso ( hbb ) & 0.980 & 2010.074 + 2455224.1271 & visual & @xmath816.5 @xmath0 0.1 & aavso(lmk ) & 0.126 & 2010.074 + 2455224.1649 & v & @xmath815.0 @xmath0 0.1 & asas-3n & 0.156 & 2010.074 + 2455224.3438 & cv & @xmath89.2 @xmath0 0.10 & vsloj(wny ) & 0.302 & 2010.075 + 2455224.9385 & v & 7.85 @xmath0 0.10 & aavso(hbb ) & 0.785 & 2010.076 + 2455224.9720 & visual & 8.1 @xmath0 0.3 & aavso(sck ) & 0.812 & 2010.077 + 2455224.9751 & v & 7.98 @xmath0 0.01 & aavso(dks ) & 0.815 & 2010.077 + [ table1 ] lllll u & 2004.5 & 18.13 & & 1 + b & 2001.6 - 2010.1 & 18.45 & 0.26 & 145 + v & 2000.4 - 2010.1 & 18.01 & 0.29 & 229 + r & 2001.2 - 2009.8 & 17.67 & 0.26 & 127 + i & 2001.5 - 2009.7 & 17.35 & 0.14 & 115 + sloan r & 2009.3 - 2010.1 & 17.86 & 0.18 & 26 + sloan i & 2009.1 - 2010.1 & 17.53 & 0.20 & 33 + u - b & 2004.5 & -0.27 & & 1 + b - v & 2005.7 - 2010.1 & 0.54 & 0.06 & 34 + v - r & 2001.2 - 2009.4 & 0.34 & 0.05 & 10 + r - i & 2004.4 - 2009.7 & 0.46 & 0.09 & 7 + r-i & 2009.3 - 2010.1 & 0.29 & 0.07 & 33 + b & 2001.6 - 2006.2 & 18.45 & 0.29 & 11 + b & 2008.1 - 2008.8 & 18.42 & 0.28 & 34 + b & 2009.1 - 2009.8 & 18.46 & 0.26 & 98 + b & 2010.0 - 2010.1 & 18.63 & 0.20 & 2 + v & 2000.4 - 2001.7 & 18.07 & 0.33 & 12 + v & 2003.4 - 2006.2 & 18.10 & 0.40 & 9 + v & 2008.3 - 2008.8 & 17.91 & 0.20 & 18 + v & 2009.1 - 2009.2 & 17.86 & 0.37 & 9 + v & 2009.2 - 2009.3 & 17.92 & 0.26 & 25 + v & 2009.3 - 2009.4 & 18.12 & 0.19 & 23 + v & 2009.4 - 2009.5 & 17.93 & 0.46 & 17 + v & 2009.5 - 2009.6 & 17.98 & 0.22 & 58 + v & 2009.6 - 2009.7 & 18.06 & 0.22 & 27 + v & 2009.7 - 2009.9 & 18.28 & 0.18 & 13 + v & 2010.0 - 2010.1 & 17.97 & 0.33 & 17 + @xmath18 & 2001.6 - 2006.2 & 0.58 & 0.20 & 11 + @xmath18 & 2008.1 - 2008.8 & 0.60 & 0.23 & 34 + @xmath18 & 2009.1 - 2010.1 & 0.56 & 0.20 & 100 + @xmath18 & 1999.2 - 2010.1 & 0.58 & 0.05 & 145 + @xmath18 & 1987.4 - 1992.2 & 0.50 & 0.03 & 26 + @xmath18 & 1979.5 - 1987.4 & 0.66 & 0.05 & 4 + @xmath18 & 1969.1 - 1979.5 & 0.55 & 0.12 & 2 + @xmath18 & 1954.5 & 0.33 & & 1 + [ averages ] | we report the discovery by b. g. harris and s. dvorak on jd 2455224.9385 ( 2010 jan 28.4385 ut ) of the predicted eruption of the recurrent nova u scorpii ( u sco ) .
we also report on 815 magnitudes ( and 16 useful limits ) on the pre - eruption light curve in the ubvri and sloan r and i bands from 2000.4 up to 9 hours before the peak of the january 2010 eruption .
we found no significant long - term variations , though we did find frequent fast variations ( flickering ) with amplitudes up to 0.4 mag .
we show that u sco did not have any rises or dips with amplitude greater than 0.2 mag on timescales from one day to one year before the eruption .
we find that the peak of this eruption occurred at jd [email protected] and the start of the rise was at jd [email protected] . from our analysis of the average b - band flux between eruptions , we find that the total mass accreted between eruptions is consistent with being a constant , in agreement with a strong prediction of nova trigger theory .
the date of the next eruption can be anticipated with an accuracy of @xmath05 months by following the average b - band magnitudes for the next @xmath110 years , although at this time we can only predict that the next eruption will be in the year 2020@xmath02 . |
the study of the role of electronic correlations in transition metal compounds is one of the most actively developing fields of modern condensed matter physics .
this class of materials exhibits rich and highly nontrivial physical phenomena such as unconventional transport properties including metal - insulator transitions , bad metal behavior or superconductivity , or ordering phenomena involving charge , orbital or spin degrees of freedom .
it is by now clear that most of these properties arise due to electronic correlations , in particular strong coulomb interactions among the partially occupied 3@xmath1 electrons of the metal ion . among these oxides ,
nio is a prototype system for strong electronic correlations with a high spin antiferromagnetic structure at low temperatures @xcite . the exact origin , nature and size of the fundamental gap and , more broadly ,
the electronic structure of nio , has been studied intensely for many years , and is also a major topic of text books on condensed matter physics @xcite .
initially nio was thought to be a classic mott insulating system @xcite with a large insulating gap .
however , later studies @xcite suggested that the gap might open between states of oxygen @xmath2 character and empty @xmath1 states , classifying nio as a charge - transfer insulator . over the years a vast number of experimental @xcite and theoretical @xcite studies have been carried out aiming at a clearer understanding of the electronic structure and magnetism of this system .
recently , there has been a growing interest also in understanding the properties of nio under pressure @xcite .
indeed , a pressure - driven mott insulator - to - metal transition ( imt ) was anticipated by mott _
et al . _
@xcite a long time ago , but the compression ration and the corresponding transition pressure @xmath5 were subjects of debate @xcite .
the density functional theory calculations using perdew - wang generalized gradient approximation ( pwgga ) functional @xcite predict the transition to occur at about 40@xmath6 volume compression [ ( v0-v)/v0 ] , while a calculation using hybrid functional b3lyp @xcite estimates it to be 65@xmath6 .
these volumes compression correspond to the critical pressure of transition p@xmath7 @xmath8 320 gpa and @xmath8 1320 gpa respectively according to their calculated equations of state @xcite which has been found to be very similar for both the functionals and is also in good agreement with the experimental report of ref . .
the first experimental observation of the transition @xcite finally came in 2012 , at a transition pressure of 240 gpa .
this transition pressure was also calculated based on the above mentioned theoretically calculated equation of state @xcite and it corresponds to 35@xmath6 volume compression .
on the theoretical side @xcite , it is now well established that neither the conventional effective single - particle band theory within local ( spin ) density approximation ( l(s)da ) , nor the l(s)da+u method in which l(s)da is augmented by an on - site coulomb repulsion term and an exchange term with the hubbard @xmath0 and hund exchange @xmath9 parameters , respectively can provide an accurate description of the electronic properties of nio .
hedin s gw approximation @xcite provides an interesting route to the antiferromagnetic insulating phase @xcite but can not describe the paramagnetic insulator .
a more sophisticated treatment of the correlation effects within a fully many - body technique like lda plus dynamical mean - field theory ( lda+dmft ) @xcite is inevitable to describe the nonquasiparticle features of the electronic spectrum of nio .
even then , nio turns out to be a tremendous challenge , due to its charge transfer character @xcite . in the lda+dmft method ,
the noninteracting part of the hamiltonian , obtained from lda involving a large number of valence @xmath10 , @xmath2 , and @xmath1 orbitals associated with all the atoms in the unit cell is expressed in an effective @xmath1-like wannier basis in order to construct an effective multiband hubbard model which is solved by dmft .
the interaction term for this hamiltonian is the effective interaction between the wannier orbitals which is again incorporated by a hubbard @xmath0 and hund exchange @xmath9 parameter .
the lda+dmft simulations of nio reported so far @xcite considered @xmath0 as an adjustable parameter to correctly reproduce the experimentally reported x - ray photoemission spectroscopy ( xps ) or / and bremsstrahlung isochromat spectroscopy ( bis ) spectra @xcite .
the different values of @xmath0 and @xmath9 , used in these studies are tabulated in table [ uj_reported ] .
values of @xmath0 ranging from 7.0 ev to 10 ev have been considered .
however there exists a first - principles method , the constrained random - phase approximation ( crpa ) @xcite which has been recently successfully employed to evaluate the screened coulomb interaction matrix elements ( @xmath0 an @xmath9 ) between the effective wannier functions in many transition metal compounds @xcite , including a study of mno under pressure @xcite .
this method @xcite is capable of efficiently determining all the possible coulomb matrix elements , e.g. , on site , off site , intraorbital , interorbital , and exchange , as well as their frequency dependence @xcite . despite enormous work on nio ,
the detailed investigation of the coulomb interaction parameters within the crpa approach is limited so far .
et al . _
@xcite reported matrix elements of the partially screened interactions including their frequency dependence using various low energy models and discussed the sensitivity of these parameters with respect to the chosen low energy model @xcite .
et al . _
@xcite used nio to benchmark the performance of a variant of the crpa scheme dubbed `` shell - folding '' , which incorporates the screening by @xmath11-interactions into effective @xmath1-@xmath1 and @xmath2-@xmath2 interactions .
however , none of these works addressed the important question of how the effective interactions evolve under pressure .
the effects of external pressure on these very important parameters ( @xmath0 and @xmath9 ) of nio , a most enigmatic strongly correlated material that has been of interest since the days of mott and hubbard , has not been analyzed so far .
a very recent theoretical study @xcite based on the state - of - the - art fully charge self - consistent dft+dmft method found the mott imt transition to coincide with a magnetic - to - nonmagnetic collapse transition at about 45@xmath6 volume compression which corresponds to a critical pressure of 429 gpa according to their calculated equation of state .
this study @xcite considered the value of @xmath0 and @xmath9 as high as 10 ev and 1 ev respectively and assumed those parameters to remain constant upon variation of the unit cell volume .
however the effective @xmath0 in transition metal compounds may be strongly dependent on pressure as has been emphasized in several previous works @xcite .
the practice of considering @xmath0 as a nearly pressure independent parameter may thus bias the results altogether .
therefore a quantitative estimation of the interactions parameters under pressure is particularly important for a material as important as nio whose behavior is primarily dominated by the strong coulomb interactions .
.the value of @xmath0 and @xmath9 ( in ev ) used in different reported lda+dmft studies . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] [ uv_afm ] in all of the reported lda+dmft simulations @xcite , the interactions parameters are considered somewhat different than those calculated within crpa including the estimated values of this work .
it has been found that a large value of @xmath0 is required to reproduce the experimental band gap as well as to obtain the satellite feature ( lower hubbard band ) at the correct binding energy .
this fact still remains an unsolved puzzle . in this context the frequency dependence of @xmath0 may provide a useful insight . with this in mind , in order to understand the necessity of using frequency dependence of @xmath0 for the experimental and high pressure structures in a realistic many - body model hamiltonian , we have first compared the computed real and imaginary components of averaged @xmath12 for the experimental structure among various low energy models in figs .
[ frequexp](a ) and ( b ) respectively . in the case of @xmath3-@xmath3 model , the real part of @xmath12
is found to be almost constant in the low frequency region upto around 10 ev .
this might suggests that the use of the static limit in this model is better justified than in the other setups .
this is also expected since no internal transition within the ni-@xmath13 and o-@xmath14 states is allowed in this model and the polarization involving the higher lying ni-@xmath15 , @xmath16 states are responsible for the first prominent peak which appears around 16 ev . however , since this model should of course describe the same physical situation as in the other models , it is clear that in the @xmath3-@xmath3 model the neglect of non - local ( and intershell @xmath1-@xmath2 ) interactions is a much more drastic approximation .
making @xmath0 frequency - dependent , appears to be a way to incorporate nonlocal screening processes in an effective local description .
indeed , in all the other models real parts of @xmath12 show a strong variation at low frequencies and correspondingly we also see sharp peaks in their respective imaginary parts , suggesting the failure of static limit .
in the @xmath1-@xmath1 and @xmath1-@xmath3 model , the first peak in the imaginary parts of @xmath12 appear around 8 ev which is originated from the polarization involving @xmath1-@xmath2 transitions .
since the origin of the higher energy peaks in these models are exactly same to the @xmath3-@xmath3 model , all the other peaks coincide with the peaks of @xmath3-@xmath3 model as expected .
the variation of the real part of @xmath0 at low @xmath17 become strongest in the @xmath4-@xmath3 and @xmath4-@xmath4 models , introducing an additional peak at around 2.6 ev in the imaginary part of @xmath0 .
this comes from the polarization involving transition between @xmath18 and @xmath4 states .
we also observe that a crossover from the low - energy screened regime to the high - energy tail takes place at around 23 ev which can be assigned to a plasma excitation . in order to provide credence to our results of @xmath12 , the experimental electron energy loss spectra ( eels ) , adopted from ref .
has been shown in fig .
[ frequexp](c ) .
the eels data of ref .
display a well - defined plasmon excitation at 22 ev , providing a very good agreement with our calculated results which is observed around 23 ev ( feature ii ) .
the other sharp feature ( marked as i ) at around 8 ev also agrees perfectly with the experimental eels data .
this further validates the use of lda electronic structure for calculating the effective @xmath12 and most importantly justifies the accuracy of our estimations .
we note that in addition to the two sharp characteristic features of eels data ( feature i and ii ) , our computed results also find several other important features at low as well as in high frequency regions .
next we analyze the frequency dependence of @xmath19 , @xmath20 and @xmath21 and their pressure dependence within @xmath3-@xmath3 model in fig .
[ frequdp](a)-(c ) .
we observe that the overall shapes of the @xmath12 are very similar for all the interactions , however the intensities of the peaks are different .
this is expected since the number of free electrons involved in the corresponding polarization are different .
we observe that compression of the lattice volume does not change the overall nature of the frequency dependence but shift the peak positions towards higher energy .
we also notice that the frequency variations of @xmath21 weaken with increasing pressure and almost become constant at the highest pressure of our study .
finally we discuss the pressure dependence of @xmath12 for the other models in fig .
[ frequ](a)-(d ) .
again we find that the peak positions are shifted toward higher energy keeping the overall shape of the @xmath12 intact .
this can be understood from the evolution of the basic electronic structure due to the application of pressure . as discussed in sec.iii(a ) , pressure enhances the crystal field splitting between @xmath18 and @xmath4 states as well as the @xmath1-@xmath2 energy differences , and therefore the peaks , arising due to the transitions between these states also gradually shift toward higher energy as a function of volume compression . in order to understand the robustness of the computed interaction parameters , we have carried out crpa calculations for the antiferromagnetic nio
the computed dos and projected pdos of antiferromagnetic phase for the experimental structure and compressed structure are displayed in fig .
[ dos_sp](a ) and ( b ) .
as we can see , similar to the non - spin polarized phase , pressure induces an increase in both the @xmath1 and @xmath2 bandwidths and their separations .
in agreement with the earlier studies , our calculation within lsda approach also obtained a gaped solution for the experimental structure .
however system becomes gapless upon compression .
for both the structures , we have also compared the total antiferromagnetic dos with its nonmagnetic counter part as shown in the inset of fig .
[ dos_sp](a ) and ( b ) .
our results indicate that although there is very little change in the bandwidth upon spin - polarization for the experimental structure , but antiferromagnetic ordering is responsible for opening up the gap at the fermi level [ see inset of fig .
[ dos_sp](a ) ] . owing to the fact that compression also tends to suppress the magnetism ,
the total antiferromagnetic dos in the high pressure phase is almost identical to the nonmagnetic total dos [ see fig . [ dos_sp](b ) ] .
these features provide an indication that the interaction parameters are likely not to be very different in the antiferromagnetic phase .
the averaged bare and partially screened interaction parameters are shown in table [ uv_afm ] for the antiferromagnetic phase as well as the non - spin polarized phase .
interestingly the bare and effective values of @xmath0 for the @xmath1 and @xmath2 orbitals are almost equal in both the phases as was indicated from the analysis of the electronic structure .
this further reveals that neither the spreads of the wannier function , nor the screenings are sensitive to the spin - polarization , establishing the robustness of the quantitative accuracy of our obtained results for the paramagnetic nio as discussed in this article .
in summary we have studied the bare and screened coulomb interactions parameters of nio under pressure using the crpa method .
compression induces little changes in the bare coulomb interactions , indicating only slight modification in the associated wannier functions , while it gives rise to an enhancement of the effective screened interactions .
a detailed analysis of the electronic structure reveals that the compression causes a very large separation between the ni-@xmath1 and o-@xmath2 states , resulting at the rpa level in a poor screening that leads to this counterintuitive trend of the effective interaction parameters .
in contrast , the growth with pressure of the inter - site interactions is primarily governed by a similar enhancement of the corresponding bare interactions .
we analyzed the frequency dependence of the effective screened interactions for the experimental equilibrium as well as compressed structures and concluded that it can not be ignored in a complete description of the electronic structure of nio .
thus it will be interesting to investigate the renormalization of the ni-@xmath1 states within a many - body calculation with frequency dependent @xmath0 , and analyze satellite structures beyond a description with static @xmath0 .
finally , we have detected a striking similarity in the interaction values between calculations assuming antiferromagnetic and non - magnetic behavior respectively , despite the quite different description of the low - energy states .
photoemission spectroscopy results and in particular the close similarity of spectra taken in the antiferromagnetic and paramagnetic phases can be interpreted as suggesting that the antiferromagnetic phase might eventually be a more faithful representation even of paramagnetic nio . in this sense , the agreement of the interaction values in the two calculations is encouraging , questioning the need for further self - consistency .
we acknowledge useful discussions with i. abrikosov , i. leonov , t. miyake , and d.d .
this work was supported by a consolidator grant of the european research council ( project correlmat 617196 ) and by idris / genci orsay under project t2016091393 .
hj acknowledges the financial support by the national natural science foundation of china ( projects no .
21373017 , 21321001 , 21621061 ) .
78ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/1.1735895 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1080/00018737700101443 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.52.1830 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.30.4734 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.34.395 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.26.4845 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.53.2339 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.33.4253 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.44.3604 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.53.10372 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.99.156404 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.100.206401 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.elspec.2014.11.003 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.30.957 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.33.8896 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.38.3449 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.64.2442 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.48.16929 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.50.8257 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.62.16392 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.74.195114 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/0953-8984/20/i=29/a=295214 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.79.235114 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.109.186401 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.91.115105 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.61.14984 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1134/1.1371350 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.69.035114 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.109.086402 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.5.290 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physb.2008.10.009 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrev.139.a796 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.93.126406 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.71.193102 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.82.045108 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.57.6884 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.68.13 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.75.165115 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.elspec.2010.05.021 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.93.235138 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.94.155135 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1080/14786435.2013.769693 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1134/s0021364012110070 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1140/epjst / e2010 - 01209 - 0 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.77.195124 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.70.195104 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.86.165105 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.77.085122 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.80.155134 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.83.121101 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.107.266404 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.86.085117 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.86.165124 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.89.125110 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.94.125147 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.79.235133 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.81.115116 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.87.165118 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1134/s1063776108070145 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.79.085125 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/s0038-1098(99)00577-3 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/s0927-0256(03)00112-5 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrev.136.b864 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.61.689 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.49.17293 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.46.9976 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.69.184404 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.96.226402 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.102.126403 [ * * , ( ) ] | in this work , we report the pressure dependence of the effective coulomb interaction parameters ( hubbard @xmath0 ) in paramagnetic nio within the constrained random phase approximation ( crpa ) .
we consider five different low energy models starting from the most expensive one that treats both ni-@xmath1 and o-@xmath2 states as correlated orbitals ( @xmath3-@xmath3 model ) to the smallest possible two - orbital model comprising the @xmath4 states only ( @xmath4-@xmath4 model ) .
we find that in all the considered models , the bare interactions are not very sensitive to the compression .
however the partially screened interaction parameters show an almost linear increment as a function of compression , resulting from the substantial weakening of screening effects upon compression .
this counterintuitive trend is explained from the specific characteristic changes of the basic electronic structure of this system .
we further calculate the nearest neighbor inter - site @xmath1-@xmath1 interaction terms which also show substantial enhancement due to compression .
our results for both the experimental and highly compressed structures reveal that the frequency dependence of the partially screened interactions can not be ignored in a realistic modeling of nio .
we also find that the computed interaction parameters for the antiferromagnetic nio are almost identical to their paramagnetic counter parts . |
the idea of noncommutative analogues of classical mathematical notions like topology , geometry , measure theory , or probability , derives from operator algebras . in the classical ( commutative ) context
, one can usually associate to a given space an appropriate set of complex - valued functions defined on that space .
this set becomes a commutative algebra under the operations of pointwise addition and multiplication of functions .
properties of the original space can be then expressed in terms of the algebra associated to that space . in the noncommutative context ,
one replaces the commutative algebra of functions with a noncommutative algebra ( usually , but not necessarily , of operators ) .
we exemplify with the case of interest for us . to define a probability space ,
one specifies a triple @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is a set , @xmath2 is a @xmath3algebra , and @xmath4 is a probability measure .
consider the space @xmath5 of essentially bounded measurable functions @xmath6 endowed with the linear functional @xmath7 it is known that @xmath8 is a @xmath9-algebra .
let us observe that for any set @xmath10 , the characteristic function of @xmath11 , @xmath12 belongs to @xmath13 and @xmath14 conversely , if @xmath15 satisfies @xmath16 for @xmath17almost all @xmath18 , then @xmath19 and @xmath20 almost surely .
moreover , @xmath21 thus , it appears natural to give the definition of a noncommutative probability space as it follows : [ noncommutativeprobabiltyspace ] a noncommutative probability space is a pair @xmath22 , where @xmath23 is a unital algebra over @xmath24 , and @xmath25 is a linear functional on @xmath23 such that @xmath26 an element @xmath27 is called a random variable .
the distribution of @xmath28 is the linear functional @xmath29 on @xmath30 $ ] ( the algebra of complex polynomials in one variable ) , defined by @xmath31 , @xmath32.$ ] for an introduction to the subject , we refer to @xcite .
the pair @xmath22 will be called a @xmath9-probability space if , in addition , @xmath23 is a @xmath9-algebra , and @xmath25 is positive and weakly continuous .
we shall generally consider the case when @xmath25 is also a trace ( i.e. @xmath33 for all @xmath34 ) in which case we call @xmath22 a tracial @xmath9-probability space .
let us observe that @xmath35 is a tracial @xmath9-probability space , and the notion of random variable in the noncommutative context translates in the classical case as `` bounded random variable '' .
moreover , if @xmath36 is a selfadjoint random variable in a @xmath37probability space , then @xmath29 extends to a compactly supported probability measure on the real line , i.e. there exists a unique probability measure @xmath38 such that @xmath39.\ ] ] while the classical notion of independence still has a meaning in the noncommutative context ( see @xcite for details ) , new types of independence arise naturally in noncommutative probability theory .
we record here the defintions of the three types of independence that we shall encounter in this paper . in the following three definitions ,
@xmath22 is a noncommutative probability space , and @xmath40 are two subalgebras of @xmath41 [ free ] the unital algebras @xmath40 are called free ( or freely independent ) if @xmath42 whenever @xmath43 @xmath44 @xmath45 and @xmath46 for @xmath47 [ boolean ] the ( usually not unital ) algebras @xmath40 are said to be boolean independent if @xmath48 for any @xmath49 , @xmath50 @xmath51 @xmath52 @xmath47 [ monotonic ] the ( usually not unital ) algebras @xmath40 are called monotonically independent if the following two conditions are satisfies : 1 . for all @xmath53 and @xmath54 we have @xmath55 ; 2 . for all
@xmath56 and @xmath57 we have @xmath58 @xmath59 and @xmath60 a pair of random variables @xmath61 is said to be independent in any of the above senses if the subalgebras @xmath40 ( unital in the case of free independence ) generated by @xmath62 , are independent .
definition [ free ] is due to voiculescu @xcite , definition [ monotonic ] to muraki @xcite , while the notion of boolean independence was first explicitly formulated by speicher and woroudi @xcite , but its origins can be traced to boejko @xcite . these notions of independence
make it possible to define several types of convolutions of probability measures .
it is known from the classical probability theory that any compactly supported probability measure @xmath63 on @xmath64 can be realized as the distribution of a selfadjoint random variable @xmath65 belonging to some @xmath9-probability space .
roughly speaking , to define a convolution of two compactly supported probability measures , one considers a pair of subalgebras of a noncommutative probability space which are independent in the required sense , and finds in each of the algebras a selfadjoint random variable distributed according to each of the two probability measures ; the distribution of the sum will be equal to the convolution of the two probability measures .
the following definitions make the above description more precise .
[ free ] 1 .
let @xmath66 be two compactly supported borel probability measures on the real line .
the free additive convolution of @xmath63 and @xmath67 , denoted by @xmath68 , is defined as the distribution of @xmath69 , where @xmath70 and @xmath71 are selfadjoint random variables belonging to some tracial @xmath9-probability space @xmath22 , free from each other , and distributed according to @xmath63 and @xmath67 , respectively .
2 . let @xmath66 be two compactly supported probability measures on the positive half - line @xmath72 the free multiplicative convolution @xmath63 and @xmath67 , denoted by @xmath73 , is the distribution of @xmath74 , where @xmath70 and @xmath71 are positive random variables belonging to some tracial @xmath9-probability space @xmath22 , free from each other , and distributed according to @xmath63 and @xmath67 , respectively .
3 . let @xmath66 be two probability measures on the unit circle @xmath75 in the complex plane .
the free multiplicative convolution of @xmath63 and @xmath67 , denoted by @xmath73 , is the distribution of @xmath76 , where @xmath70 and @xmath71 are unitary random variables belonging to some tracial @xmath9-probability space @xmath22 , free from each other , and distributed according to @xmath63 and @xmath67 , respectively .
definitions ( b ) and ( c ) have been extended to measures with noncompact support in @xcite . for more details ,
we refer to @xcite and @xcite .
[ boolean ] 1 .
let @xmath66 be two compactly supported borel probability measures on the real line .
the boolean additive convolution of @xmath63 and @xmath67 , denoted by @xmath77 , is defined as the distribution of @xmath69 , where @xmath70 and @xmath71 are selfadjoint random variables belonging to some tracial @xmath9-probability space @xmath22 , boolean independent , and distributed according to @xmath63 and @xmath67 , respectively .
2 . let @xmath66 be two probability measures on the unit circle @xmath75 in the complex plane .
the boolean multiplicative convolution of @xmath63 and @xmath67 , denoted by @xmath78 , is the distribution of @xmath76 , where @xmath70 and @xmath71 are unitary random variables belonging to some tracial @xmath9-probability space @xmath22 , distributed according to @xmath63 and @xmath67 , respectively , and such that @xmath79 and @xmath80 are boolean independent .
these definitions appear in @xcite and @xcite , respectively .
the extension of part ( a ) of the above definition to measures with noncompact support is done using analytic methods ( see theorem [ booleananalitic ] below ) .
[ monot ] 1 .
let @xmath66 be two compactly supported borel probability measures on the real line .
the monotonic additive convolution of @xmath63 and @xmath67 , denoted by @xmath81 , is defined as the distribution of @xmath69 , where @xmath70 and @xmath71 are selfadjoint random variables belonging to some tracial @xmath9-probability space @xmath22 , monotonic independent , and distributed according to @xmath63 and @xmath67 , respectively .
2 . let @xmath66 be two compactly supported borel probability measures on the positive half - line .
the monotonic multiplicative convolution of @xmath63 and @xmath67 , denoted by @xmath82 , is defined as the distribution of @xmath76 , where @xmath70 and @xmath71 are selfadjoint random variables belonging to some tracial @xmath9-probability space @xmath22 , distributed according to @xmath63 and @xmath67 , respectively , such that @xmath79 and @xmath80 are monotonic independent .
observe that , unlike the previous convolutions , monotonic convolutions are _ not _ commutative .
monotonic additive convolution has been introduced by muraki @xcite , while its multiplicative version has been defined by bercovici in @xcite . as in the case of boolean convolution
, one can define monotonic convolutions of probability measures with noncompact support with analytic methods , as it will be seen in theorems [ murakimonot ] and [ bercovicimonot ] .
it is not hard to see that the independence condition makes each of the above seven operations well - defined .
the way to construct independent random variables as in the above definitions can be found in @xcite for the case of free independence , @xcite for the case of boolean independence , and @xcite and @xcite for monotonic independence .
the present thesis focuses on an analytic perspective on the convolutions defined above , which will be described in the main body of the thesis .
our main interest will be in the free convolutions .
we will also point out connections between the three types of independence defined above .
these connections have not yet been explored to their fullest extent .
the thesis has three chapters .
the first two chapters have three sections each , while the much shorter third chapter is not divided into sections . in the first chapter we focus on regularity properties of free convolutions .
the first section of chapter 1 introduces a number of definitions and theorems from complex analysis that will be used all along the thesis , and describes the absolutely continuous , singular continuous and atomic parts of the free additive convolution of two probability measures , with respect to the lebesgue measure on @xmath83 specifically , we show that the absolutely continuous part is always nonzero , the density function is locally analytic , and , under slightly less general conditions , the singular continuous part is zero ( theorem [ reg+ ] ) . our main tool is a subordination result for analytic functions ( theorem [ firstsubordinationresult ] ) . in sections 2 and 3
we prove similar results for free multiplicative convolutions of probability measures supported on the positive half - line and on the unit circle in the complex plane , respectively ( theorems [ regx1 ] and [ regx2 ] ) .
note however that the existence of a singular continuous part remains open in these cases .
the second chapter is dedicated to proving the existence of partially defined semigroups with respect to free convolutions ( theorems [ mut+ ] , [ mutx1 ] , and [ mutx2 ] ) .
our main tools are three inversion theorems for analytic functions . in theorems
[ regptmut+ ] , [ regmutx1 ] , and [ regmux2 ] , we describe the absolutely continuous , singular continuous , and atomic parts of such measures . a brief mention of a connection with boolean convolution is also made . in the third chapter
we generalize results of muraki and bercovici on monotonic infinite divisibility .
namely , we show that any probability measure , not necessarily with compact support , which is infinitely divisible with respect to monotonic additive , and , respectively , multiplicative , convolution belongs to a one - parameter semigroup with respect to monotonic convolution .
this chapter is dedicated to describing the absolutely continuous and atomic part of free convolutions of measures . in the first section
we discuss the behavior of the absolutely continuous part with respect to the lebesgue measure of the free additive convolution of two borel probability measures supported on the real line , none of them concentrated in one point .
namely , we show that the the absolutely continuous part is never zero , its density function is locally analytic , and continuous everywhere where it is finite .
the results are derived by studying the boundary behavior of the subordination functions . as a byproduct
, we also obtain a new proof of biane s subordination result .
the second and third sections are dedicated to proving similar results for the free multiplicative convolution of probability measures on the unit circle and the positive half - line , respectively .
in addition , we also describe the atomic part of free multiplicative convolution of two probability measures .
( the analogous result for free additive convolution is already known . ) for any finite positive measure @xmath84 on @xmath64 , define its cauchy transform @xmath85 since @xmath86 we shall consider from now on only the restriction of @xmath87 to the upper half - plane @xmath88 for given @xmath89 let us denote @xmath90 the analytic function @xmath87 satisfies the following two properties : @xmath91 for any @xmath92 @xmath93 remarkably , as the following theorem shows , any function satisfying these two properties is the cauchy transform of some finite positive measure on @xmath64 ( for proof and details , we refer to @xcite ) .
[ cauchy ] let @xmath94 be an analytic function .
the following statements are equivalent : 1 .
there exists a unique positive measure @xmath84 on @xmath64 such that @xmath95 ; 2 . for any @xmath92
we have that @xmath96 exists and is finite .
3 . the limit @xmath97 exists and is finite .
moreover , the two limits from 2 and 3 both equal @xmath98 observe also that @xmath99 is the poisson integral of @xmath100 it turns out that in many situations it is much easier to deal with the reciprocal @xmath101 of the cauchy transform of the measure @xmath102 the following proposition is an obvious consequence of theorem [ cauchy ] : [ cauchyalt ] let @xmath103 be an analytic self - map of the upper half - plane .
the following statements are equivalent : 1 .
there exists a positive measure @xmath84 on @xmath64 such that @xmath104 ; 2 . for any
@xmath92 the limit @xmath105 exists and belongs to @xmath106 ; 3 .
the limit @xmath107 exists and belongs to @xmath106 .
moreover , both limits form 2 . and 3 .
equal @xmath108 in general , analytic self - maps of the upper half - plane can be represented uniquely by a triple @xmath109 , where @xmath110 is a real number , @xmath111 and @xmath112 is a positive finite measure on @xmath83 this representation is called the nevanlinna representation ( see @xcite ) . [ nevanlinna ]
let @xmath103 be an analytic function .
then there exists a triple @xmath109 , where @xmath113 , @xmath114 and @xmath112 is a positive finite measure on @xmath64 such that @xmath115 the triple @xmath109 satisfies @xmath116 @xmath117 and @xmath118 .
the converse of theorem [ nevanlinna ] is obviously true .
[ imf > imz ] an immediate consequence of proposition [ cauchyalt ] and theorem [ nevanlinna ] is that for any finite measure @xmath84 on @xmath64 , we have @xmath119 for all @xmath120 with equality for any value of @xmath121 if and only if @xmath84 is a point mass . in this case , the measure @xmath112 in the statement of theorem [ nevanlinna ] is zero . as observed above , any finite measure @xmath84 on the real line
is uniquely determined by its cauchy transform .
moreover , regularity properties of @xmath84 can be deduced from the behavior of @xmath87 , and hence of @xmath122 , near the boundary of its domain . in the following
we shall state several classical theorems concerning analytic self - maps of the unit disk @xmath123 of @xmath124 .
because the upper half - plane is conformally equivalent to the unit disc via the rational transformation @xmath125 most of these theorems will have obvious formulations for self - maps of the upper half - plane . for a function @xmath126 , and a point @xmath127
, we say that the nontangential limit of @xmath128 at @xmath28 exists if the limit @xmath129 exists for all @xmath130 , where @xmath131 a similar definition holds for functions defined in the unit disc .
we shall denote nontangential limits by @xmath132 or @xmath133 the following three theorems describe properties of meromorphic functions in the unit disc related to their nontangential boundary behavior .
[ fatou ] let @xmath134 be a bounded analytic function
. then the set of points @xmath135 at which the nontangential limit of @xmath128 fails to exist is of linear measure zero .
[ lindelof ] let @xmath136 be a meromorphic function , and let @xmath137 .
assume that the set @xmath138 contains more than three points .
if there exists a path @xmath139 such that @xmath140 and @xmath141 exists in @xmath142 , then the nontangential limit of @xmath128 at @xmath143 exists , and equals @xmath144 [ privalov ] let @xmath134 be an analytic function .
assume that there exists a set @xmath145 of nonzero linear measure in @xmath75 such that the nontangential limit of @xmath128 exists at each point of @xmath145 , and equals zero .
then the function @xmath146 for all @xmath147 .
theorem [ fatou ] is due to fatou , and theorem [ privalov ] to privalov .
theorem [ lindelof ] is an extension of a result by lindelf . for proofs
, we refer to @xcite
. the following lemma will be useful in the proof of the main result of this section .
[ nontangentialconvergenceatinfinity ] let @xmath103 be an analytic self - map of the upper half - plane .
suppose @xmath148 is a continuous path such that @xmath149 then the limit @xmath150 , if it exists , can not be infinite .
assume that there exists a path @xmath151 as in the statement of the lemma such that @xmath152 ofserve that @xmath153 never equals a negative number .
therefore , the range of the function @xmath154 omits more than three points from @xmath24 . since @xmath155 exists and is finite , theorem [ lindelof ] provides a contradiction .
consider a domain ( i.e. an open connected set ) @xmath156 , and a function @xmath157 .
the cluster set @xmath158 of the function @xmath128 at the point @xmath159 is @xmath160 the following result is immediate .
[ clusterconex ] let @xmath161 be a domain and let @xmath157 be continuous . if @xmath162 is locally connected at @xmath163 , then @xmath164 is connected .
this result appears in @xcite , as theorem 1.1 .
the following theorem of seidel describes the behavior of certain analytic functions near the boundary of their domain of definition . for proof
, we refer to @xcite , theorem 5.4 .
[ seidel ] let @xmath165 be an analytic function such that the radial limit @xmath166 exists and has modulus @xmath167 for almost every @xmath168 in the interval @xmath169 .
if @xmath170 is such that @xmath128 does not extend analytically through @xmath171 then @xmath172 this theorem can be applied to self - maps of the upper half - plane @xmath173 , via a conformal mapping , but in that case one must consider meromorphic , instead of analytic , extensions .
a second result refering to the behavior of @xmath174 for bounded analytic functions @xmath128 is the following theorem of carathodory .
( this result appears in @xcite , theorem 5.5 . )
[ caratheodory ] let @xmath134 be a bounded analytic function .
assume that for almost every @xmath175 the radial limit @xmath176 belongs to a set @xmath177 in the plane .
then , for every @xmath175 the cluster set @xmath178 is contained in the closed convex hull of @xmath177 .
the previous two theorems allow us to prove the following [ seidelcaratheodory ] 1 .
let @xmath128 be an analytic self - map of @xmath124 such that @xmath179 for almost every @xmath175 .
suppose that there is a point @xmath180 such that the function @xmath128 can not be continued analytically through @xmath181 then for any @xmath182 there is a set @xmath183 of nonzero lebesgue measure such that @xmath184 exists for all @xmath185 , and the set @xmath186 is dense in the arc @xmath187 2 .
let @xmath128 be an analytic self - map of @xmath173 such that @xmath188 exists and belongs to @xmath64 for almost every @xmath189 suppose that @xmath190 is such that @xmath128 can not be continued meromorphically through @xmath191 .
then for any @xmath192 there is a set @xmath193 of nonzero lebesgue measure such that @xmath194 exists for all points @xmath195 and the set @xmath196 is dense in the interval @xmath197 let @xmath128 and @xmath198 be as in the hypothesis of ( a ) . using theorems [ seidel ] and [ caratheodory ] ,
we conclude that , on the one hand , @xmath199 and on the other , that @xmath200 equals the closure of the convex hull of the set @xmath201 for any set @xmath202 with the property that @xmath203 exists for all @xmath204 , and @xmath205 has zero linear measure .
this implies that the set @xmath206 is dense in @xmath145 .
it remains to prove that the set @xmath207 of those @xmath175 such that @xmath184 exists and belongs to @xmath145 has nonzero linear measure .
if this were not true , then , according to theorem [ caratheodory ] , we could replace @xmath208 by @xmath209 in the previous argument , and obtain a contradiction .
this proves ( a ) .
part ( b ) follows directly from ( a ) , by using the conformal automorphism of the extended complex plane @xmath210 and its inverse .
we will next focus on boundary behaviour of derivatives of analytic self - maps of the unit disk and of the upper half - plane .
these results are described in detail by shapiro @xcite ; see also exercises 6 and 7 in chapter i of garnett s book @xcite .
[ juliacaratheodory ] let @xmath165 be an analytic function , and let @xmath211 .
the following statements are equivalent : 1 .
we have @xmath212 2 .
there exists a number @xmath213 such that @xmath214 and the limit @xmath215 exists and belong to @xmath106 .
moreover , if the equivalent conditions above are satisfied , the limit @xmath216 exists , and the following equality holds : @xmath217 if @xmath218 and @xmath214 then the limit in equation [ eq1.1 ] exists and equal infinity .
the number @xmath144 from the above theorem is called the julia - carathodory derivative of @xmath128 at @xmath219 .
the formulation of the preceding theorem for self - maps of the upper half - plane is similar ; however , for the point at infinity , the usual formula of the julia - carathodory derivative must be replaced by the limit @xmath220 consider now an analytic function @xmath221 a point @xmath222 is called a denjoy - wolff point for @xmath128 if one of the following two conditions is satisfied : 1 .
@xmath223 and @xmath224 ; 2 .
@xmath225 @xmath226 and @xmath227 the following result is due to denjoy and wolff .
[ denjoywolff ] any analytic function @xmath228 has a denjoy - wolff point . if @xmath128 has more than one such point , then @xmath229 for all @xmath121 in the unit disk .
if @xmath147 is a denjoy - wolff point for @xmath128 , then @xmath230 equality occurs only when @xmath128 is a conformal automorphism of the unit disc .
the denjoy - wolff point of a function @xmath128 is characterized also by the fact that it is the uniform limit on compact subsets of the iterates @xmath231 of @xmath128 .
we state the following theorem for the sake of completeness ( for the original statements , see @xcite and @xcite ) : let @xmath228 be an analytic function .
if @xmath128 is not a conformal automorphism of @xmath124 , then the functions @xmath232 converge uniformly on compact subsets of @xmath124 to the denjoy - wolff point of @xmath128 .
we now prove a general subordination result for analytic functions .
[ firstsubordinationresult ] let @xmath233 , @xmath234 be two analytic functions , which are not conformal self - maps of @xmath235 satisfying @xmath236 @xmath234 , and let @xmath237 be defined by @xmath238 .
then there exists a unique analytic self - map @xmath239 of @xmath173 such that @xmath240 for all @xmath241 moreover , @xmath242 let us first observe that @xmath128 is well defined .
indeed , since @xmath243 is not a conformal automorphism of @xmath173 , by remark [ imf > imz ] we have @xmath244 for all @xmath245 @xmath246 .
thus , for any @xmath121 with @xmath247 @xmath248 and @xmath249 we conclude that the formula defining @xmath128 makes sense , and @xmath128 takes values in the upper half - plane .
we shall now prove that for any fixed @xmath250 , @xmath251.\ ] ] assume to the contrary that there exists an @xmath252 $ ] such that @xmath253 define @xmath254 , @xmath255 then @xmath256 since @xmath257 , we conclude that @xmath258 this is possible only if @xmath259=\infty.$ ] the path @xmath260 @xmath261 , satisfies the conditions of lemma [ nontangentialconvergenceatinfinity ] , and we have @xmath262 and @xmath263 this contradiction implies that @xmath251.\ ] ] using this fact , we have @xmath264 for all @xmath252.$ ] also , as seen above , @xmath265 thus , by theorem [ denjoywolff ] , we conclude that the denjoy - wloff point of the function @xmath266 belongs to @xmath267 .
denote it by @xmath268 .
since , by theorem [ denjoywolff ] , @xmath269 , we can apply the implicit function theorem to conclude that the function @xmath270 is an analytic self - map of @xmath271 the uniqueness of the denjoy - wolff point of @xmath272 for each @xmath121 guarantees the uniqueness of @xmath273 this proves the existence and uniqueness of @xmath273 to complete the proof , we need to show that @xmath274 as noted above , @xmath275 , so @xmath276 for all @xmath277 by theorem [ nevanlinna ] , @xmath278 the same argument applied to @xmath279 in place of @xmath280 ) provides a unique analytic self - map of the upper half - plane @xmath281 such that @xmath282 we claim that the analytic function @xmath283 defined by @xmath284 @xmath120 also satisfies @xmath285 indeed , @xmath286 so that @xmath287 the uniqueness of @xmath281 implies that @xmath288 and thus @xmath289 since @xmath290 , @xmath120 the limit @xmath291 is at least one
. in particular , @xmath292 tends to infinity nontangentially as @xmath293 therefore @xmath294 we conclude that @xmath295 as desired .
let us observe that , given functions @xmath296 and @xmath297 as in the above theorem , the pair of analytic functions @xmath298 is uniquely determined by the system of equations @xmath299 the following theorem describes the boundary behavior of the function @xmath273 [ boundary+ ] let @xmath300 and @xmath301 be as in theorem [ firstsubordinationresult ] .
fix @xmath113 , and define the following two self - maps of the upper half - plane : @xmath302 @xmath234 .
assume that @xmath303 is not a conformal automorphism of @xmath271then : 1 .
if @xmath304 then the function @xmath239 extends analytically in a neighbourhood of @xmath110 .
2 . assume that there exist open intervals @xmath305 and @xmath306 in @xmath307 such that @xmath243 extends analytically through @xmath308 @xmath309 then the limit @xmath310 exists in @xmath311 consider a sequence @xmath312 and a number @xmath313 with the proprety that @xmath314 and
@xmath315 we have @xmath316 if @xmath317 is not an automorphism of the upper half - plane , then we can use the implicit function argument from the proof of theorem [ firstsubordinationresult ] to conclude that there exists a neighborhood of @xmath110 in @xmath24 on which the function @xmath239 extends analytically . on the other hand ,
if @xmath318 is a conformal automorphism of @xmath173 , denote by @xmath319 its inverse .
the equality @xmath320 can be rewritten as @xmath321 we conclude that @xmath322 ( and hence @xmath323 ) must be injective .
we apply @xmath322 to this equality to obtain @xmath324 for all @xmath121 in the open set @xmath325 and by analytic continuation , for all @xmath241 we conclude that @xmath323 is a conformal automorphism of the upper half - plane .
but then @xmath326 is also a conformal automorphism of @xmath235 contradicting the hypothesis .
this proves ( 1 ) .
assume now that the hypothesis in ( 2 ) is satisfied and yet @xmath327 contains more than one point .
by part ( 1 ) , @xmath328 and by lemma [ clusterconex ] , either @xmath329 is a closed interval in @xmath64 ( possibly all of @xmath64 ) , or @xmath330 is an open interval in @xmath83 we claim that for any @xmath331 in @xmath332 with the possible exception of three points , there exists a sequence @xmath333 converging to @xmath110 such that @xmath334 and @xmath335 for all @xmath336 .
let @xmath337 be a dense sequence in @xmath327 , and consider @xmath338 such that @xmath339 and @xmath340 @xmath341 we define a path @xmath342\longrightarrow\mathbb c^+\cup\{a\}$ ] such that @xmath343 @xmath344 and @xmath151 is linear on the intervals @xmath345,$ ] @xmath341 it will suffice to show that there exists at most one point @xmath331 in the interior of @xmath327 such that @xmath346 for some @xmath347 . indeed , assume to the contrary that @xmath348 are two such points .
the set @xmath349 separates @xmath173 into two components , and the path @xmath350 contains infinitely many points in either of the components , hence it crosses @xmath351 infinitely many times . by our assumption , crossings can not be close to @xmath331 or @xmath352 , and this implies the existence of a point in @xmath353 contradicting the hypothesis that @xmath354 this proves our claim . by fatou s theorem ( theorem [ fatou ] )
, the limit @xmath355 exists for almost all @xmath356 denote it by @xmath357 we shall prove that for every @xmath358 with at most three exceptions , @xmath359 indeed , suppose that @xmath360 for some @xmath358 and assume that @xmath361 converges nontangentially to @xmath331 .
then , using the relation @xmath362 @xmath120 remark [ imf > imz ] , and the fact that @xmath297 is not a conformal self - map of @xmath235 we obtain @xmath363 which is a contradiction .
assume that @xmath364 is a point where @xmath296 does not continue meromorphically .
proposition [ seidelcaratheodory ] ( b ) shows that the set @xmath365 has nonzero lebesgue measure . in particular , for all @xmath366 , @xmath367 where we used the analiticity of @xmath297 on @xmath368
privalov s theorem implies that @xmath369 for all @xmath241 rewriting this equality gives @xmath370 or , equivalently , @xmath371 contradicting the hypothesis .
we conclude that @xmath296 extends meromorphically through the whole interval @xmath372 let , as in the proof of theorem [ firstsubordinationresult ] , @xmath373 @xmath241 we shall argue that the set @xmath374 must be also infinite .
suppose this were not the case .
then for any @xmath375 @xmath376 so that , by analytic continuation , @xmath377 for all @xmath241 this contradicts the fact that @xmath296 is not a conformal automorphism of @xmath378 so @xmath379 must be an infinite set . as before , @xmath297 must continue meromorphically through all of @xmath380 . by passing to a subsequence
, we may assume that @xmath381 exists for every @xmath382 , with at most one exception .
suppose there were a point @xmath383 and a set @xmath384 of nonzero lebesgue measure such that @xmath385 for all @xmath386 taking limit as @xmath387 in the equality @xmath388 gives @xmath389 applying again privalov s theorem , we obtain that @xmath390 for all @xmath241 this contradicts the fact that @xmath296 is not a conformal automorphism of @xmath271 thus , there exists a set @xmath391 of positive lebesgue measure such that @xmath392 then , since @xmath297 extends analytically through @xmath380 , by ( [ eq1.2 ] ) we conclude that @xmath393 for all @xmath366 .
privalov s theorem implies that @xmath394 for all @xmath241 as we have proved already , this implies that @xmath323 and @xmath395 are conformal automorphisms of the upper half - plane , contradicting the hypothesis .
this concludes the proof . in the following , we prove subordination and regularity results for free additive convolutions of probability measures
. we shall start by stating ( without proof ) some well - known fundamental facts .
voiculescu @xcite has showed that there exists an analogue of the logarithm of the fourier transform for free additive convolution , called the @xmath396transform .
the @xmath396transform is defined in terms of the inverse `` near infinity '' of the reciprocal of the cauchy transform . for the proofs of the following results we refer to @xcite and @xcite .
[ inversion+ ] let @xmath63 be a probability on @xmath64 .
there exists a nonempty domain @xmath1 in @xmath173 of the form @xmath397 such that @xmath398 has a right inverse with respect to composition @xmath399 defined on @xmath1 .
in addition , we have @xmath400 and @xmath401 for every @xmath402 ( we recall that @xmath403 ) let @xmath404 , @xmath405 the basic property of the function @xmath406 is described in the following theorem of voiculescu : [ r - transform ] let @xmath66 be two probability measures supported on the real line . then @xmath407 for @xmath121 in the common domain of the three functions .
the function @xmath408 is called the @xmath396transform of the probability measure @xmath63 .
let @xmath66 be two borel probability measures , neither of them a point mass .
theorem [ nevanlinna ] assures us that the functions @xmath409 and @xmath410 satisfy the conditions of theorem [ firstsubordinationresult ] . with the notations from the proof of theorem [ firstsubordinationresult ] ,
denote @xmath411 by theorem [ nevanlinna ] and proposition [ inversion+ ] , there exists a cone @xmath412 such that @xmath243 , @xmath413 have right inverses on @xmath412 and @xmath414 let us replace @xmath121 in the relation @xmath415 ( equation ( 1.2 ) ) by @xmath416 we obtain @xmath417 or , equivalently , @xmath418 by theorem [ r - transform ] , we conclude that @xmath419 this allows us to give a new proof for the subordination result of biane @xcite ( see also @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite ) .
[ biane+ ] given two probability measures @xmath66 on @xmath64 , there exists a unique pair of analytic functions @xmath420 such that @xmath421 @xmath422 .
moreover , @xmath423 @xmath424 and @xmath425 if one of the two measures , say @xmath63 is a point mass , @xmath426 , then the statements of the corollary are obviously true , with @xmath427 and @xmath428 @xmath241 otherwise , as we have already seen , if we let @xmath429 and @xmath430 in theorem [ firstsubordinationresult ] , the functions @xmath431 and @xmath432 will satisfy the requirement of the corollary . uniqueness is guaranteed by theorem [ firstsubordinationresult ] , while the equation ( [ eq1.3 ] ) has been established before .
next , we use the boundary properties of the subordination functions shown in theorem [ boundary+ ] to describe the atomic , singular continuous , and absolutely continuous parts , with respect to the lebesgue measure on @xmath433 , of the free convolution @xmath68 of two probability measures @xmath434 on the real line . given a finite measure @xmath84 on @xmath64 , denote by @xmath435 , @xmath436 and @xmath437 the absolutely continuous , singular continuous , respectively atomic , parts of @xmath84 with respect to the lebesgue measure .
the following lemma describes the behaviour of the cauchy transform @xmath438 near points belonging to the support of the singular continuous part of the probability measure @xmath439 the result is not new , but since we do nt know a reference , we shall give its proof .
[ delavalee ] let @xmath63 be a borel probability measure on @xmath64 .
for @xmath440almost all @xmath127 , the nontangential limit of the cauchy transform @xmath438 of @xmath63 at @xmath28 is infinite .
it is enough to show that for @xmath441-almost all @xmath127 , the imaginary part of @xmath442 tends to infinity as @xmath443 approaches zero .
an elementary calculation shows that , for any @xmath444 and @xmath127 , @xmath445 let us observe that @xmath446 for all @xmath447 such that @xmath448 thus , for any given @xmath444 , the following holds : @xmath449)}{2y}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] now we can apply de la valle poussin s theorem ( @xcite , theorem 9.6 ) to conclude that @xmath450)}{2y}=\infty$ ] for @xmath440almost all @xmath451 ( see also @xcite , theorem 31.6 ) we shall first take care of the particular case not covered by theorem [ boundary+ ] . [ specialcase+ ] let @xmath66 be two borel probability measures on the real line , neither of them a point mass .
let @xmath113 , and define @xmath452 , @xmath453 , @xmath241 the function @xmath454 is a conformal automorphism of the upper half - plane if and only if @xmath63 and @xmath67 are convex combinations of two point masses .
moreover , in this case , @xmath455 , and the density of @xmath456 with respect to the lebesgue measure is analytic everywhere , with the exception of at most four points .
we claim that the analytic functions @xmath457 are both conformal automorphisms of the upper half - plane . indeed , observe first that both @xmath458 and @xmath459 are nonconstant , by remark [ imf > imz ] .
let @xmath460 be the inverse with respect to composition of @xmath461 so that @xmath462 this implies that @xmath458 is injective .
applying @xmath458 to both sides of the above equality , we conclude that @xmath463 for all @xmath219 in the open subset @xmath464 of the upper half - plane , so , by analytic continuation , for all @xmath465 this proves surjectivity of @xmath458 and thus our claim is proved . since @xmath466
we conclude that there exist @xmath467 such that @xmath468>0,\quad{\rm and}\quad u_\mu(z)=\frac{pz+q}{z+r},\quad z \in\mathbb c^+.\ ] ] modulo a translation of @xmath63 and @xmath67 , we may assume that @xmath469 .
this implies that @xmath470 and thus @xmath63 is the convex combination of two point masses , at @xmath471 with weights @xmath472 respectively .
a similar statement holds for @xmath473 conversely , if @xmath474 then a direct computation shows that @xmath475 so that @xmath476 and @xmath477=t(1-t)(u - v)^2>0,\ ] ] for all @xmath478 .
this proves the first statement of the proposition .
assume now that @xmath479 and @xmath480 with @xmath481 and @xmath482 , @xmath483 @xmath484 modulo a translation , we may assume that @xmath485 and @xmath486 thus , we just need to compute @xmath487 as we have seen before , @xmath488 from equation ( [ eq1.2 ] ) , we conclude that @xmath489 must satisfy the equation @xmath490 which means @xmath491 solving for @xmath492 gives as possible solutions @xmath493 ^ 2 + 4stuvz(z - u - v)}}{2(z - tv-(1-s ) u)}.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath494 , we have @xmath495 ^ 2 + 4stuvz(z - u - v)}}{2(z - tv-(1-s ) u)},\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] for all @xmath241 by relation ( [ eq1.2 ] ) , @xmath496 the only points where @xmath497 may fail to extend analytically to @xmath64 are the zeros of the equation @xmath498 ^ 2 + 4stuvz(z - u - v)=0\ ] ] ( i.e. when the expression under the square root sign is zero ) , and the zeros of the equations @xmath499
^ 2=}\nonumber\\ & & [ z(z - u - v)+uv(1-s - t)]^2 + 4stuvz(z - u - v),\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath500 ^ 2=}\nonumber\\ & & [ z(z - u - v)+uv(1-s - t)]^2 + 4stuvz(z - u - v),\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] which occur at the denominator of @xmath501 we have used maple to determine that the four solutions for the first equation ( denote them by @xmath502 ) are @xmath503 whether all four of these roots are distinct or not depends on the actual values of @xmath504 however , it is trivial to observe that they are all real ; indeed , @xmath505 by hypothesis , and an elementary computation shows that @xmath506 and @xmath507 with equality if and only if @xmath508 .
notice also that it is not possible that exactly three of the roots are distinct . also by using maple
, we have determined that the second and third equations have as solutions the numbers @xmath509 , and @xmath510 respectively .
we can thus write ( with the help of maple ) : @xmath511 as it can be seen from the above formula , the support of @xmath512 coincides with the set where the product @xmath513 @xmath514 , is negative , and , since @xmath497 can be infinite only at the points @xmath515 , the measure @xmath68 has at most four atoms , which may occur exactly in @xmath516 , or @xmath517 this concludes the proof
. we can now prove the main regularity result of this section .
[ reg+ ] let @xmath66 be two borel probability measures on the real line , neither of them a point mass .
then the following statements hold : 1 . the point @xmath113 is an atom of the measure @xmath518 if and only if there exist @xmath519 such that @xmath520 and @xmath521 moreover , @xmath522 2 .
the absolutely continuous part of @xmath68 with respect to the lebesgue measure is always nonzero and its density is locally analytic on the complement of a closed set of zero lebesgue measure .
assume in addition that @xmath523 is compact and @xmath524 is nonempty .
then the singular continuous part of @xmath68 is zero .
part ( 1 ) of the theorem is due to bercovici and voiculescu ( see @xcite , theorem 7.4 ) .
we shall proceed with the proof of part ( 2 ) .
suppose that @xmath68 is purely singular , and thus for almost all @xmath127 with respect to the lebesgue measure , we have @xmath525 by part ( 1 ) , we are assured that @xmath68 can not be purely atomic , so we must have @xmath526 and hence , by lemma [ delavalee ] , @xmath527 for uncountably many @xmath451 theorem [ seidel ] applied to the function @xmath528 yields a point @xmath529 such that @xmath530 using relation ( [ eq1.3 ] ) we conclude that at least one of @xmath531 , will intersect the upper half - plane .
( recall that @xmath532 are the subordination functions from corollary [ biane+ ] . )
but now we can apply theorem [ boundary+ ] ( 1 ) and proposition [ specialcase+ ] to obtain a contradiction .
thus , @xmath68 can not be purely singular .
next we prove that there exists a closed subset of @xmath64 of zero lebesgue measure on whose complement the density @xmath533 is analytic . by theorem [ fatou ] ,
there exists a subset @xmath207 of @xmath64 of zero lebesgue measure such that for all @xmath534 the limits @xmath535 , @xmath536 @xmath234 exist and are finite .
also , for almost all @xmath537 , with respect to @xmath538 we have @xmath539 by relation ( [ eq1.3 ] ) , at least one of @xmath536 @xmath424 must also be in @xmath173 .
for definiteness , assume @xmath540 part ( 1 ) of theorem [ boundary+ ] and proposition [ specialcase+ ] assure us that @xmath492 extends analytically through @xmath28 .
since @xmath541 the function @xmath542 also extends analytically through @xmath28 .
we conclude that the density of @xmath456 must be analytic in @xmath28 . on the other hand , if there exists an interval @xmath543 then @xmath544 for almost all @xmath545 with respect to the lebesgue emasure .
the same argument used in the proof of the existence of an absolutely continuous part of @xmath68 shows that @xmath546 extends meromorphically through @xmath547 .
of course , the set @xmath145 of points @xmath28 where @xmath533 is analytic is open in @xmath64 , and its complement is of zero lebesgue measure . to prove ( 3 ) , observe that our hypotheses on the supports of @xmath63 and @xmath67 allow us to apply either part ( 2 ) of theorem [ boundary+ ] , or proposition [ specialcase+ ] to conclude that the subordination functions @xmath492 and @xmath548 extend continuously to @xmath64 as functions with values in the extended complex plane @xmath142 . by relation ( [ eq1.3 ] ) , the same must hold for @xmath549 we shall denote by the same symbols the continuous extensions of the three functions to @xmath550 let us assume that @xmath551 lemma [ delavalee ] allows us to find an uncountable set @xmath552 such that no @xmath553 is an atom of @xmath68 , and @xmath554 we claim that for any @xmath553 1 .
@xmath555 2 .
@xmath556 3 .
@xmath557 part ( _ i _ ) is an easy consequence of theorems [ nevanlinna ] and [ lindelof ] . indeed , by theorem [ nevanlinna ] , we have that @xmath558 .
assume that @xmath559 then , by our assumption on @xmath28 , corollary [ biane+ ] , and theorem [ lindelof ] , we have @xmath560 which is absurd .
a similar argument shows that @xmath561 by theorem [ lindelof ] , we have @xmath562 the same argument applied to @xmath563 and @xmath548 in place of @xmath398 and @xmath492 yields @xmath564 this proves part ( _ ii _ ) of our claim .
we prove now part ( _ iii _ ) .
observe first that , by dominated convergence and by theorem [ juliacaratheodory ] applied to self - maps of @xmath235 for any @xmath565 such that @xmath566 we have @xmath567^{-1}\\ & = & \lim_{\stackrel{z\longrightarrow v}{\sphericalangle}}\frac{f_\mu(z)}{z - v}\\ & = & \liminf_{z\to v}\frac{\im f_\mu(z)}{\im z}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] applying this to @xmath568 yields @xmath569 and similarily @xmath570 for all @xmath553 ( we use here the convention @xmath571 ) . from relation ( [ eq1.3 ] )
we obtain @xmath572 the following chain of inequalities holds : @xmath573 we have assumed that @xmath63 and @xmath67 are not point masses , so the above implies that @xmath574 thus , multiplying the above inequality by @xmath575 will give @xmath576 or , equivalently , @xmath577 since @xmath553 , part ( 1 ) of the theorem tells us that the inequality above must be an equality .
this proves the last point of our claim .
using relation ( [ eq1.3 ] ) and the fact that @xmath578 , we obtain @xmath579 since any probability can have at most countably many atoms , this , together with part ( _ iii _ ) of our claim contradicts the fact that @xmath580 is uncountable and concludes the proof .
let @xmath84 be a finite borel measure on @xmath72 we define the analytic function @xmath581 the function @xmath582 is called the moment generating function of @xmath583 a simple computation shows that @xmath584 @xmath585 using this formula , one can prove the following analogue of theorem [ cauchy ] for measures supported on the positive half - line ( see @xcite , proposition 6.1 ) . [ moment ]
let @xmath586 be an analytic function such that @xmath587 for all @xmath588 .
the following two conditions are equivalent . 1 .
there exists a finite measure @xmath84 on @xmath589 such that @xmath590 .
2 . @xmath591 and there exists a number @xmath592 such that @xmath593 for all @xmath250 .
moreover , @xmath594 observe in particular that , unless @xmath84 is concentrated at zero , we have @xmath595 @xmath596 and @xmath597 for analytic functions @xmath598 satisfying these three conditions it is possible to define a continuous function @xmath599 such that @xmath600 , and @xmath601 on the negative half - line
. we will also consider the limit @xmath602 .
observe that @xmath603 exists if @xmath604 . in this case
it is easy to see that @xmath605 for all @xmath606 ; indeed , if @xmath607 , @xmath608 is a real number so that @xmath609 and @xmath610 would imply that the image under @xmath598 of a small half - disk @xmath611 contains numbers in @xmath612 .
an immediate consequence of this fact is that the function @xmath582 defined above never takes the value @xmath613 let now @xmath63 be a probability measure on @xmath72 it will be convenient to consider the function @xmath614 an analogue of theorem [ cauchyalt ] for the function @xmath615 is the following proposition ( see @xcite , proposition 2.1 ) .
[ eta ] let @xmath616 be an analytic function such that @xmath617 for all @xmath588 .
the following two conditions are equivalent . 1 .
there exists a probability measure @xmath618 on @xmath589 such that @xmath619 .
2 . @xmath620 and @xmath621 for all @xmath250 .
moreover , @xmath622 is a point mass if and only if there exists a @xmath623 such that @xmath624 observe first that , for @xmath250 , the set @xmath625 is a circular arc contained in @xmath173 , with endpoints 0 and @xmath626 , and tangent to the line @xmath627 .
thus , given @xmath618 , @xmath628 will belong to the convex hull @xmath629 , and therefore @xmath630 this last set is precisely @xmath631 , and we conclude that @xmath615 satisfies the conditions in ( 2 ) .
conversely , assume that @xmath632 satisfies ( 2 ) , and set @xmath633 , so that @xmath634 . for @xmath635
we have then @xmath636 , and thus @xmath637 .
thus @xmath638 which implies that @xmath639 and @xmath640 ( by the symmetry of @xmath641 about the line @xmath642 ) .
we conclude that @xmath643 , and the result follows from the preceding proposition .
if @xmath644 for some @xmath645 then @xmath646 , so @xmath647 for all @xmath648 assume that @xmath649 for some @xmath650 in the upper half - plane .
then @xmath651 so we conclude that there exists a number @xmath652 such that @xmath653 or , equivalently , @xmath654 we conclude that @xmath655 and thus @xmath656 .
[ inj]an immediate consequence of the definition of @xmath615 and of proposition [ moment ] is that for any @xmath657 @xmath658 and thus , as shown before , @xmath659 is injective .
next we prove a subordination result for analytic self - maps of the slit complex plane .
[ secondsubordinationresult ] let @xmath660 , @xmath234 be two analytic functions satisfying conditions @xmath661 @xmath234 ; @xmath662 , @xmath120 @xmath234 ; @xmath663 @xmath664 , @xmath234 .
define @xmath665 by @xmath666 and let @xmath667 , @xmath668 then 1 .
the function @xmath128 is well - defined and takes values in @xmath271 2 .
there exists a unique analytic self - map @xmath669 of @xmath173 such that @xmath670 , @xmath241 we start by proving ( 1 ) .
it follows from ( b ) and ( c ) that the functions @xmath671 map the upper half - plane into itself , @xmath672 and @xmath673 @xmath309 thus , if @xmath674 it is obvious that @xmath675 is well defined and takes values in @xmath173 . if @xmath676 then @xmath677 so that @xmath678 and we conclude again that @xmath679 let now @xmath241 if @xmath680 is such that @xmath681 then @xmath682 and @xmath683 if @xmath680 is such that @xmath684 then , using ( b ) and ( c ) , we have @xmath685 so @xmath686 and @xmath687 by ( c ) .
we conclude that @xmath688 for all @xmath689 , and thus @xmath128 is well defined and its range is included in the upper half - plane .
we prove now ( 2 ) .
for each @xmath250 denote @xmath690 , @xmath691 we claim that @xmath272 must have its denjoy - wolff point in @xmath271 indeed , for any @xmath692 @xmath693 so @xmath694 can not be a fixed point of @xmath272 , so the denjoy - wolff point of @xmath272 does not belong to the interval @xmath106 .
assume now that zero is the denjoy - wolff point of @xmath272 .
then , by the definition of the denjoy - wolff point , we have @xmath695 , and @xmath696 must belong to @xmath697.$ ] but @xmath698 by theorem [ juliacaratheodory ] , @xmath699 exists in @xmath700 if @xmath692 then @xmath701 , so , using ( a ) together with theorem [ lindelof ] , we obtain @xmath702 which contradicts the fact that @xmath703 $ ] . we conclude that @xmath694 must be infinity . since , by property ( b ) , we have @xmath704 for any @xmath705 we obtain @xmath706 by theorem [ lindelof ] and the monotonicity of @xmath707 .
property ( a ) yields again @xmath708 which contradicts the fact that @xmath703.$ ] we conclude that zero is not the denjoy - wolff point of @xmath272 .
suppose that @xmath272 has infinity as its denjoy - wolff point .
then we must have @xmath709 however , @xmath710 theorem [ juliacaratheodory ] assures us that @xmath711 if @xmath712 , then we have @xmath713 so @xmath714 a contradiction . if @xmath715 then , by theorem [ lindelof ] , the limit @xmath716 if it exists , must equal zero . since @xmath717 and , by theorem [ lindelof ] , @xmath718
we conclude that @xmath719 thus , infinity can not be the denjoy - wolff point of @xmath272 .
we still need to show that no point on the negative half - line is the denjoy - wolff point of @xmath720 suppose to the contrary that @xmath721 for some @xmath722 as we have already seen , @xmath723 so @xmath724 thus @xmath694 can not be a fixed point of @xmath272 .
this proved our claim .
let @xmath725 denote the denjoy - wolff point of @xmath720 since we have shown in part ( 1 ) that on the one hand @xmath726 takes values in the upper half - plane for any @xmath727 , and on the other @xmath728 we conclude that @xmath272 is not a conformal automorphism of @xmath271 thus , theorem [ denjoywolff ] assures us that the derivative of @xmath272 in the point @xmath729 has absolute value strictly less than one , @xmath730 by applying the implicit function theorem to the function @xmath731 , we conclude that @xmath729 depends analytically on @xmath121 .
thus , we have determined the existence of @xmath239 .
the uniqueness follows immediatly from the uniqueness of the denjoy - wolff point .
this proves part ( 2 ) of the theorem .
[ subordinationwithomega ] let @xmath732 , @xmath234 , be two analytic functions as in theorem [ secondsubordinationresult ] .
then there exists a unique analytic function @xmath733 such that @xmath734 moreover , @xmath735 for all @xmath250 . with the notations from theorem [ secondsubordinationresult ] ,
let @xmath736 @xmath737 it is clear that @xmath738 for all numbers @xmath121 in the upper half - plane . using the relation @xmath670 , we have : @xmath739 the above equality holds for all @xmath241 we conclude that @xmath740 and @xmath741 denote @xmath742 and observe that @xmath268 is a fixed point for the function @xmath743 since the functions @xmath732 satisfy the condition ( b ) from theorem [ secondsubordinationresult ] , the function @xmath744 can not be the identity function . by the denjoy - wolff theorem ( theorem [ denjoywolff ] )
, we obtain the uniqueness of @xmath273 since @xmath669 extends continuously to the negative half - line , it is now obvious that so does @xmath273 by the schwarz reflection principle , we can extend @xmath239 to the whole @xmath745 and its range will be included in @xmath746 this concludes the proof . as in the first section ,
let us observe that theorem [ secondsubordinationresult ] and corollary [ subordinationwithomega ] provide an analytic function @xmath747 @xmath748 satisfying the conditions @xmath749 and @xmath750 @xmath241 the pair of functions @xmath298 is uniquely determined by the equations @xmath751 we record here for later use the form of equations [ eq1.4 ] in terms of the functions @xmath633 : @xmath752 in the following theorem we shall describe the boundary behavior of the functions @xmath239 and @xmath753 [ boundaryx1 ] let @xmath754 and @xmath239 be as in corollary [ subordinationwithomega ] , and consider their restrictions to @xmath271 fix a point @xmath755 and define the following two self - maps of the upper half - plane : @xmath756 , @xmath424 @xmath241 assume that @xmath757 is not a conformal automorphism of @xmath271 then : 1 .
if @xmath758 , then the function @xmath239 extends analytically in a neighbourhood of @xmath110 .
the limit @xmath310 exists in @xmath759 we shall prove ( 1 ) by showing that the function @xmath669 extends analytically through @xmath110 .
let @xmath760 be a sequence converging to @xmath110 such that @xmath761 belongs to the upper half - plane .
we have : @xmath762 so @xmath144 is a fixed point of @xmath763 belonging to @xmath271 if @xmath763 is not a conformal automorphism of the upper half - plane , then the implicit function argument used in the proof of part ( 2 ) of theorem [ secondsubordinationresult ] implies that there exists a neighbourhood of @xmath110 in @xmath24 on which @xmath669 , and hence @xmath239 , extends analytically .
if @xmath764 is a conformal automorphism of the upper half - plane , denote by @xmath460 its inverse .
consider @xmath765 as in the statement of the theorem .
the equality @xmath766 is equivalent to @xmath767 we conclude that @xmath322 ( and hence @xmath323 ) must be injective .
let @xmath768 @xmath705 so that @xmath769 by applying @xmath770 to the above equality , we obtain @xmath771 since @xmath772 is open , the above equality must be true for all @xmath120 allowing us to conclude that @xmath323 is also surjective , so a conformal automorphism .
but then @xmath757 must also be a conformal automorphism of @xmath271 this contradicts the hypothesis .
we now prove part ( 2 ) of the theorem .
assume that @xmath327 contains more than one point . by part ( 1 )
, we must have @xmath773 and , by lemma [ clusterconex ] , either @xmath774 is a closed interval in @xmath64 , or @xmath330 is an open interval in @xmath83 as we have shown in the proof of theorem [ boundary+ ] ( 2 ) , for any @xmath775 with the possible exception of three points , there exists a sequence @xmath333 converging to @xmath110 such that @xmath776 and @xmath777 for all @xmath336 . by theorem [ fatou ]
, the limit @xmath778 exists for almost all @xmath356 denote it by @xmath779 we claim that for any @xmath358 with at most three exceptions , @xmath780 indeed , suppose that @xmath781 for some @xmath782 and assume that there exists a sequence @xmath783 such that @xmath361 converges nontangentially to @xmath331 . then , using ( [ eq1.4 ] ) and the fact that @xmath784 for all @xmath120 @xmath424 we obtain @xmath785 which is a contradiction .
assume that @xmath364 is a point where @xmath786 does not continue meromorphically .
proposition [ seidelcaratheodory ] ( b ) shows that the set @xmath787 has nonzero lebesgue measure . in particular , for all @xmath366 , @xmath788 by analytic continuation
, this implies that @xmath789 for all @xmath241 rewritting this equality gives @xmath790 or , equivalently , @xmath791 in particular , @xmath757 is an automorphism of the upper half - plane , contradicting the hypothesis .
we conclude that @xmath786 must extend meromorphically through the set @xmath372 let @xmath792 .
we shall argue that the set @xmath793 must also be infinte . indeed , suppose this were not the case .
then , for any @xmath794 , with at most one exception , @xmath795 so , by analytic continuation , @xmath796 @xmath241 this contradicts the hypothesis that @xmath797 for all @xmath121 in the upper half - plane .
so @xmath379 is an infinite set .
as before , @xmath798 must continue meromorphically through all of @xmath799 by passing to a subsequence , we may assume that @xmath800 exists for every @xmath794 , with at most one exception .
suppose there were a point @xmath383 and a set @xmath384 of nonzero lebesgue measure such that @xmath385 for all @xmath386 taking limit as @xmath387 in the equality @xmath801 gives @xmath802 we conclude by theorem [ privalov ] that @xmath803 for all @xmath250 , and hence @xmath804 for all @xmath120 contradicting the hypothesis .
thus , there exists a set @xmath805 of nonzero lebesgue measure such that @xmath806 then , as @xmath798 extends analytically through @xmath380 , we have , by ( [ eq1.4 ] ) @xmath807 for all @xmath808 by analytic continuation , we conclude that @xmath809 as we have already proved , this implies that @xmath323 and @xmath395 are conformal automorphisms of the upper half - plane , contradicting the hypothesis .
this concludes the proof . the results above will be used for analyzing properties of free multiplicative convolution . as in section 1 , we start by stating several well - known results . in @xcite
, voiculescu introduces the @xmath810transform , an analogue of the @xmath396transform for free multiplicative convolution .
we give below the main facts about the @xmath810transform , and for proofs we refer to @xcite and @xcite .
let @xmath63 be a probability measure on @xmath589 , @xmath811 as observed in remark [ inj ] , the restriction of @xmath615 to @xmath106 is injective .
denote by @xmath812 its right inverse , defined on some neighbourhood of @xmath813 in @xmath271 let @xmath814 [ stransform ] let @xmath66 be two probability measures supported on @xmath815 none of them concentrated at zero .
then @xmath816 for all @xmath121 in the common domain of the three functions .
the function @xmath817 is called the @xmath810transform of @xmath63 .
let @xmath66 be two borel probability measures on @xmath589 , none of them a point mass .
proposition [ eta ] assures us that the functions @xmath818 and @xmath819 satisfy the conditions of corollary [ subordinationwithomega ] . with the notations from ( [ eq1.4 ] ) ,
let @xmath820 observe that , by corollary [ subordinationwithomega ] , @xmath821 satisfies the conditions of proposition [ eta ] . by remark [ inj ] and proposition [ eta ]
, there exists an interval @xmath822 such that @xmath823 and @xmath821 have right inverses on @xmath824 let us replace @xmath121 in the relation @xmath825 ( equation ( [ eq1.4 ] ) ) by @xmath826 we obtain @xmath827 or , equivalently , @xmath828 by theorem [ stransform ] , we conclude that @xmath829 we can give now a new proof to biane s subordination result ( see @xcite , theorem 3.6 ) : [ biane2 ] given two probability measures @xmath66 on @xmath815 there exists a pair of analytic functions @xmath830 such that @xmath831 , @xmath832 if neither of @xmath66 is concentrated at zero , the functions @xmath532 are unique and satisfy the following four properties 1 .
@xmath833 @xmath834 2 .
@xmath835 @xmath424 3 .
@xmath836 for all @xmath120 @xmath424 4 .
@xmath837 for all @xmath838 @xmath309 if one of the two measures , say @xmath63 , equals @xmath839 then @xmath840 , and @xmath841 @xmath842 @xmath843 will satisfy the required conditions .
if one of the two measures , say @xmath63 , is concentrated at a point @xmath645 then the corollary is obviously true , with @xmath844 and @xmath845 if none of the two measures is a point mass , then , as we have already seen , if we let @xmath846 and @xmath819 , then the functions @xmath431 and @xmath432 provided by corollary [ subordinationwithomega ] will satisfy the requirements from the statement of the corollary . property ( a ) has been proved before for the functions @xmath847 ( see relation ( [ eq1.4 ] ) ) . to prove property ( b ) , observe that , by proposition [ eta ] and remark [ inj ] , we have @xmath848 property ( c ) has been proved in corollary [ subordinationwithomega ] , and property ( d ) follows trivially from the similar property of the functions @xmath849 next , we use the boundary properties of the subordination functions @xmath532 to describe the atomic and absolutely continuous parts with respect to the lebesgue measure of the free convolution @xmath73 of two probability measures on the positive half - line , none of them a point mass .
we start with some observations about the boundary behaviour of the function @xmath850 , particulary in the neighborhood of an atom .
fix a probability measure @xmath63 on @xmath589 and a real number @xmath851 .
the following two lemmas indicate how the presence or absence of an atom of @xmath63 can be detected from the boundary behaviour of @xmath850 .
[ atoms&tang ] suppose that @xmath852 is a bounded sequence in @xmath853 which converges tangentially to @xmath589 , i.e. @xmath854 for all @xmath855 .
then @xmath856 indeed , @xmath857
@xmath858 @xmath859 the hypothesis implies that @xmath860 for all @xmath861 .
moreover @xmath862 and the desired result follows by dominated convergence .
[ atoms&nontang ] suppose that @xmath852 , is a bounded sequence in @xmath853 , @xmath755 and @xmath863 nontangentially , i.e. @xmath864 then @xmath865 .
fix @xmath866 , and observe that @xmath867 @xmath868for @xmath869 . the inequality remains trivially true for @xmath870 as well .
now @xmath871 if @xmath872 , and @xmath873 if @xmath874 . the conclusion of the lemma follows then from the dominated convergence theorem .
[ remarkaboutpsi]relation @xmath875 @xmath250 , implies that whenever @xmath876 extends analytically through a point @xmath877 , @xmath438 will extend analytically through @xmath878 , and hence the density of @xmath879 with respect to the lebesgue measure will be analytic in the point @xmath878 .
we take care first of a particular case , not covered by theorem [ boundaryx1 ] .
[ specialcasex1 ] let @xmath66 be two borel probability measures supported on the interval @xmath815 none of them a point mass .
let @xmath645 and define @xmath880 @xmath881 @xmath241 the function @xmath454 is a conformal automorphism of the upper half - plane if and only if @xmath63 and @xmath67 are convex combinations of two point masses .
moreover , in this case , @xmath882 , and the density of @xmath883 with respect to the lebesgue measure is analytic everywhere , with the exception of at most four points .
observe that @xmath459 and @xmath458 are nonconstant functions taking values in the upper half - plane .
we claim that both @xmath459 and @xmath458 are conformal automorphisms of @xmath271 indeed , let @xmath460 be the inverse with respect to composition of @xmath454 , so that @xmath462 this implies that @xmath458 is injective .
applying @xmath458 to both sides of the above equality gives @xmath463 for all @xmath219 in the open set @xmath884 , so , by analytic continuation , for all @xmath465 this proves that @xmath458 must be surjective , and thus an automorphism of @xmath271 now it is obvious that @xmath459 must also be an automorphism of @xmath173 .
this proves our claim . as in the proof of proposition [ specialcase+ ] , there exist real numbers @xmath885 such that @xmath886>0,\quad{\rm and}\quad u_\mu(z)=\frac{pz+q}{sz+r},\quad z \in\mathbb c^+.\ ] ] since @xmath887 for all @xmath120 we conclude that @xmath888 thus , we may assume without loss of generality that @xmath889 modulo a translation of @xmath63 and @xmath67 , we may assume that @xmath890 . by direct computation , @xmath891 so that @xmath892 thus , @xmath63 is a convex combination of two atoms , at @xmath893 with weights @xmath894 a similar statement hold for @xmath473 conversely , if @xmath474 then a direct computation shows that @xmath895 so @xmath896 and thus @xmath897 observe that @xmath898=t(1-t)(u - v)^2>0.\ ] ] this proves the first statement of the proposition .
assume now that @xmath479 and @xmath899 modulo a translation , we may assume that @xmath900 , @xmath486 we shall compute the function @xmath901 corresponding to the measure @xmath902 by the same method as in the proposition [ specialcase+ ] .
unfortunately , the expression of the function is much less manageable than in the additive case .
as we have seen before , @xmath903 and @xmath904 for all @xmath241 from equation ( [ eq1.4 ] ) , we conclude that the subordination function @xmath489 must satisfy @xmath905 or , equivalently , @xmath906 @xmath907 with the help of maple , one can obtain the solution @xmath908 where the coefficients @xmath909 and @xmath162 are given below : @xmath910 @xmath911 @xmath912 @xmath913 from the expression of @xmath492 one can obtain @xmath548 by simply interchanging @xmath914 and @xmath915 by ( [ eq1.4 ] ) , @xmath916 so @xmath917 let us notice that , since @xmath918 the only points in @xmath106 where the limit of @xmath919 is infinite are the points where the limit of @xmath920 equals 1 , and @xmath919 can be continued analytically to @xmath921 if and only if @xmath922 can be continued meromorphically to @xmath878 , and @xmath923 the only points where @xmath922 may fail to extend meromorphically to @xmath589 are the roots of the equation @xmath924 , while @xmath925 if and only if @xmath926 i.e. if @xmath927 satisfies an equation of degree two with coefficients in @xmath64 ; the algebraic expression of @xmath492 indicates clearly that there can be at most eight points @xmath28 such that this happens . we conclude that there are at most twelve points in the interval @xmath589 where @xmath919 may fail to continue analytically .
we conclude that @xmath928 and the density of @xmath883 is analytic everywhere , with at most twelve exceptions .
this concludes the proof .
we are now ready to prove the main regularity result for free multiplicative convolutions of probability measures on the positive half - line ( parts ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) of the theorem below appear also in @xcite ) .
[ regx1 ] let @xmath66 be two borel probability measures supported on the interval @xmath72 then : 1 .
the following are equivalent : + \(i ) @xmath73 has an atom at @xmath755 ; + \(ii ) there exist @xmath929 so that @xmath930 and @xmath931 . moreover , @xmath932 .
2 . @xmath933 3 .
assume that neither @xmath934 nor @xmath67 is a point mass .
then @xmath883 is always nonzero , and its density with respect to the lebesgue measure is analytic outside a closed set of lebesgue measure zero .
the support of @xmath935 is closed , of zero lebesgue measure , and included in the support of @xmath883 .
we start by proving ( 1 ) , ( i)@xmath936(ii ) .
so let @xmath66 satisfy condition ( i ) .
set @xmath937 , @xmath938 , and note that @xmath939 by lemma [ atoms&nontang ] .
this implies that @xmath940 .
we shall prove the existence of two numbers @xmath941 such that , after possibly dropping to a subsequence , @xmath930 ; @xmath942 ; @xmath943 ; the sequence @xmath944 does not converge to zero ; and the sequence @xmath945 does not converge to zero . first , we claim that the sequence @xmath946 is bounded .
assume to the contrary that there is a subsequence of @xmath947 which tends to infinity .
observe that @xmath948 by corollary [ biane2 ] , so @xmath949 .
therefore @xmath950 @xmath951 which shows that the family of functions @xmath952 is uniformly bounded and comverges pointwise to zero as @xmath953 so we conclude that @xmath954 .
but by lemma [ atoms&tang ] , we obtain @xmath955.\ ] ] this contradicts the previous equality , and therefore @xmath956 must be bounded , as claimed .
passing to a subsequence , we infer the existence of @xmath957 such that @xmath958 as @xmath387 .
setting @xmath959 , we have @xmath960 by ( [ eq1.5 ] ) and lemma [ atoms&nontang ] .
note that @xmath961 ; indeed , if @xmath962 , we would have @xmath963 , which is a finite number . this proves ( j ) , ( jj ) and ( jjj ) . to prove ( jv ) , note that @xmath964 @xmath965 @xmath966 by corollary [ biane2 ] and lemma [ atoms&nontang ] .
also , the sequence @xmath967 does not converge to zero , by lemma [ atoms&tang ] . dropping if necessary to a subsequence
, we can assume that it is bounded away from zero .
this proves ( jv ) .
statement ( v ) follows by symmetry .
conditions ( jj ) and ( jv ) allow us to apply lemma [ atoms&nontang ] to conclude that @xmath968 and analogously @xmath969 we conclude that @xmath970 @xmath971\ ] ] @xmath972\ ] ] @xmath973\ ] ] @xmath974\ ] ] @xmath975+\lim_{n\to\infty}[a\omega_\mu(z_n)\omega_\nu(z_n)]\]]@xmath976 where we used ( [ eq1.5 ] ) in the next to the last equality .
this completes the proof of ( i)@xmath936(ii ) . to prove ( ii)@xmath936(i ) , consider two free selfadjoint random variables @xmath977 and @xmath978 in the tracial noncommutative probability space @xmath979 having distributions @xmath63 and @xmath67 respectively .
the fact that @xmath63 has an atom at @xmath980 , @xmath67 has an atom at @xmath981 and @xmath931 is equivalent to the fact that there are projections @xmath982 and @xmath983 with @xmath984 such that @xmath985 and @xmath986 .
then @xmath987 and @xmath988 , so @xmath73 has an atom at @xmath989 .
this concludes the proof of part ( 1 ) . to prove ( 2 ) , let @xmath977 and @xmath978 be two selfadjoint random variables as in the proof of ( a ) .
note that for any projection @xmath982 such that @xmath990 , we also have that @xmath991 , and we deduce that @xmath992 since @xmath993 is commutative , we have @xmath994 we first prove the opposite inequality for @xmath995 . to do this
, we analyze the behaviour of @xmath628 as @xmath996 nontangentially to @xmath589 .
consider the truncated cone @xmath997 and note that for @xmath998 we have @xmath999 since @xmath1000 equals @xmath626 if @xmath1001 and @xmath1002 if @xmath870 , the dominated convergence theorem yields @xmath1003 applying this fact to @xmath73 combined with ( [ eq1.5 ] ) , we obtain @xmath1004 we deduce that @xmath1005 and therefore there is a sequence @xmath1006 such that @xmath1007 and either @xmath1008 , or @xmath1009 .
assume for simplicity that @xmath1008 , and note that @xmath1010 by corollary [ biane2 ] . by the preceding calculations
, we must have @xmath1011 thus @xmath1012 whenever @xmath995 . to conclude the proof
, we must show that @xmath1013 and @xmath1014 implies @xmath995 .
indeed , in this case corollary [ biane2 ] applies to show that @xmath1015 is not identically zero .
the proof of ( 3 ) is similar to the proof of part ( 2 ) of theorem [ reg+ ] .
suppose that @xmath1016 part ( 1 ) of the theorem shows that @xmath73 can not be purely atomic , and thus , @xmath1017 since @xmath1018 we conclude as in the proof of part ( 2 ) of theorem [ reg+ ] that @xmath1019 for almost all @xmath127 , and that there exists a point @xmath1020 such that @xmath1021 does not continue analytically through @xmath1022 .
theorem [ seidel ] can now be applied to the function @xmath1023 and the point @xmath1022 to conclude that @xmath1024 and hence @xmath1025 relation ( [ eq1.4 ] ) implies that @xmath1026 , @xmath1027 are also infinite sets ( we recall that @xmath1028 are the subordination functions provided by corollary [ biane2 ] ) .
applying theorem [ boundaryx1 ] and proposition [ specialcasex1 ] yields a contradiction .
thus , @xmath73 can not be purely singular . next
we show that there exists a closed subset of @xmath589 of zero lebesgue measure on whose complement the density @xmath1029 is analytic . by theorem [ fatou ] and
proposition [ moment ] , there exists a set @xmath1030 of zero lebesgue measure such that for all @xmath534 the limits @xmath1031 @xmath1032 , @xmath234 exist and are finite . also , for almost all @xmath1033 such that @xmath1034 , with respect to @xmath883 , we have @xmath1035 so that @xmath1036 by equation ( [ eq1.5 ] ) , at least one of @xmath1032 , @xmath1037 must also be in @xmath271 for definiteness , assume that @xmath1038 part ( 1 ) of theorem [ boundaryx1 ] and proposition [ specialcasex1 ] assure us that @xmath1039 extends analytically through @xmath28 .
since @xmath541 the function @xmath1040 will also extend analytically through @xmath28 . by remark [ remarkaboutpsi ] , we conclude that the density of @xmath73 with respect to the lebesgue measure must be analytic in @xmath878 .
the set @xmath145 of points @xmath1041 where @xmath1042 is analytic is open in @xmath64 , and its complement in @xmath1043 is of zero lebesgue measure . on the other hand , if there exists an interval @xmath1044 , then @xmath1019 for almost all @xmath127 such that @xmath1045 , and the argument used in the proof of the existence of the absolutely continuous part of @xmath73 shows that @xmath1021 extends meromorphically through @xmath1046 in particular , @xmath1047 the tools and methods from this section are very similar to the ones used in the previous section .
let @xmath63 be a borel probability measure on the unit circle @xmath75 , and define the moment generating function @xmath1048 ( recall that @xmath124 denotes the unit disk . )
observe that @xmath1049 this immediately yields the following result .
[ momentcircle ] let @xmath1050 be an analytic function .
the following conditions are equivalent . 1 .
there exists a probability measure @xmath63 on @xmath75 such that @xmath1051 .
2 . @xmath1052 and @xmath1053 for all @xmath147 . the corresponding result for the function @xmath1054 is as follows . [ etacircle ]
let @xmath1055 be an analytic function .
the following conditions are equivalent . 1 .
there exists a probability measure @xmath63 on @xmath75 such that @xmath619 .
2 . @xmath1056 and @xmath1057 for all @xmath147 .
@xmath1058 for all @xmath147 .
moreover , @xmath63 is a point mass if and only if there exists @xmath1059 such that @xmath1060 the equivalence of ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) is , of course , the schwarz lemma , while the equivalence between ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) is a trivial consequence of proposition [ momentcircle ] .
suppose now that there exists @xmath1061 such that @xmath1060 then @xmath1062 for some @xmath1063 the function @xmath1064 maps @xmath124 into @xmath1065 , so , since @xmath1066 by the maximum principle we conclude that @xmath1067 must be constant , and thus @xmath1068 for all @xmath147 .
thus , @xmath1069 so that @xmath1070 the converse is trivial .
next we prove the analogue of theorem [ secondsubordinationresult ] for self - maps of the unit disk which fix the origin .
[ thirdsubordinationresult ] let @xmath1071 , @xmath234 , be two analytic functions , none of them a conformal automorphism of the unit disk , satisfying @xmath1072 , @xmath309 define @xmath1073 by @xmath1074 where we understand @xmath1075 as @xmath1076 then 1 .
the function @xmath128 is analytic on @xmath1077 and takes values in @xmath1078 2 .
there exists a unique analytic function @xmath1079 such that @xmath1080 moreover , @xmath1081 it is obvious that @xmath1082 for any @xmath1083 .
the only problem that might occur is when there exists a @xmath1084 such that @xmath1085 .
but then @xmath1086 so @xmath128 is a well - defined complex - valued analytic function . to see that it takes values in the unit disc , we apply the schwarz lemma to conclude that for any @xmath147 , @xmath1087 such that @xmath1088 we have @xmath1089 this inequality extends by continuity to all points @xmath1090
this proves ( 1 ) .
we now prove ( 2 ) .
fix a point @xmath1091 as in the proof of theorem [ firstsubordinationresult ] , the function @xmath1092 is a self - map of the unit disc , satisfying , as shown above , the inequality @xmath1093 thus , according to theorem [ denjoywolff ] , it must have a ( unique ) denjoy - wolff point .
denote it by @xmath268 .
since ( by the same theorem [ denjoywolff ] ) , we have @xmath1094 we can apply the implicit function theorem to conclude that the dependence @xmath270 is analytic .
obviously , @xmath1095 this proves ( 2 ) and concludes the proof . as before
, we observe that there exists an analytic function @xmath1096 , @xmath748 such that @xmath1097 the pair of functions @xmath298 is uniquely determined by the equations @xmath1098 as in section 2 , equatin ( [ eq1.6 ] ) can be expressed in terms of the functions @xmath633 : @xmath1099 [ remarkabour1stmoment0]it is obvious that the condition @xmath1100 , @xmath234 can not be removed , since in that case we would ( by theorem [ denjoywolff ] ) have @xmath1101 for all @xmath1102 however , one can still consider the case when only one of the two functions @xmath1103 say @xmath786 , has its derivative at the origin equal to zero . indeed , in this case
the proof of theorem [ thirdsubordinationresult ] applies to provide a function @xmath239 with the property that @xmath268 is the fixed point of @xmath720 in this case we can still define @xmath281 by @xmath748 but @xmath1104 will not be necessarily the fixed point of @xmath1105 where @xmath1106 in fact , if there exists a point @xmath1084 in the unit disk such that @xmath1107 , then @xmath1108 for all @xmath147 . in the following theorem
we describe some boundary properties of the functions @xmath239 and @xmath753 since the proof is similar to the proofs of theorems [ boundary+ ] and [ boundaryx1 ] , we omit it .
[ boundaryx2 ] let @xmath754 and @xmath239 be as in theorem [ thirdsubordinationresult ] .
fix a point @xmath1109 and define the following two self - maps of the upper half - plane : @xmath756 , @xmath424 @xmath1102 assume that @xmath757 is not a conformal automorphism of @xmath1078 then : 1 .
if @xmath1110 , then the function @xmath239 extends analytically in a neighbourhood of @xmath110 .
2 . assume that there exist open intervals @xmath305 , @xmath306 such that @xmath732 continues analytically through @xmath1111 @xmath309 then the limit @xmath310 exists in @xmath1112 we shall apply the previous results to the study of free convolutions of probability measures on the unit circle ( for details , see @xcite ) .
the definition and properties of the @xmath810transform for measures on @xmath75 are similar to the ones from section 2 . however , in order to invert the function @xmath615 around zero one needs the condition @xmath1113 .
this is equivalent to @xmath1114 because @xmath1115 under this condition , the inverse @xmath1116 is defined in a neighborhood of zero , and so is @xmath1117 .
the identity @xmath1118 holds in a neighborhood of zero provided that @xmath1119 . we can now prove a subordination theorem for free multiplicative convolution on the unit circle ( see @xcite , theorem 3.5 ) .
[ biane3 ] given two borel probability measures @xmath66 on the unit circle , there exists a pair of analytic functions @xmath1120 such that @xmath1121 @xmath1102 the pair of functions @xmath532 is uniquely determined by the following properties : 1 .
@xmath833 @xmath1122 2 .
@xmath1123 @xmath1124 3 .
@xmath1125 for all @xmath1126 @xmath309 if both @xmath63 and @xmath67 have first moment equal to zero , then we conclude by definitions [ free ] and [ free ] that @xmath73 has all moments equal to zero , so @xmath73 is the uniform distribution ( the haar measure ) on @xmath1127 we conclude that @xmath1128 for all @xmath1126 so the functions @xmath1129 , @xmath147 will do . if only one of the two measures has first moment zero , then , choosing in remark [ remarkabour1stmoment0 ] , @xmath431 and @xmath432 will provide the required pair . observe that in this case the function @xmath492 is uniquely determined .
if both @xmath63 and @xmath67 have nonzero first moment , then choosing @xmath431 in theorem [ thirdsubordinationresult ] and @xmath432 from equation ( [ eq1.6 ] ) will do .
the uniqueness is guaranteed by theorem [ thirdsubordinationresult ] , and the properties ( a ) through ( c ) are elementary consequences of theorem [ thirdsubordinationresult ] . for measures on @xmath75 we shall consider absolute continuity with respect to the uniform distribution on @xmath75 .
the notations will be the same as in section 1 .
the following regularity result holds for free convolutions of probability measures supported on @xmath75 . the proof
( see also @xcite ) is similar to the proofs of theorems [ reg+ ] and [ regx1 ] and will be omitted .
[ regx2 ] let @xmath66 be two borel probability measures supported on @xmath1127 then : 1 .
the following are equivalent : + \(i ) @xmath73 has an atom at @xmath755 ; + \(ii ) there exist @xmath929 so that @xmath930 and @xmath931 . moreover , @xmath932 .
2 . assume that neither @xmath934 nor @xmath67 is a point mass .
then @xmath883 is always nonzero , and its density with respect to the lebesgue measure is analytic outside a closed set of lebesgue measure zero .
the support of @xmath935 is closed , of zero lebesgue measure , and included in the support of @xmath883 .
in this chapter we study from an analytic point of view the existence and some properties of partially defined free convolution semigroups .
the existence of these objects , which have no classical counterpart , has been first observed in @xcite : it is shown there that for any given compactly supported probability measure @xmath63 on the real line , there exists a number @xmath1130 and a family of compactly supported probability measures @xmath1131 on @xmath64 such that @xmath1132 for all @xmath1133 and @xmath1134 for @xmath1135 @xmath1136 using combinatorial tools , nica and speicher have proved in @xcite that all the above statements are true for @xmath1137 .
an analytic approach to the existence of the family @xmath1131 can be found in @xcite . as a consequence of results in chapter 1
we know that for any @xmath1135 there exists an analytic self - map @xmath1138 of @xmath173 such that @xmath1139 . in @xcite
it is shown that this result extends to noninteger values of @xmath1140 .
the proof of the existence of the subordination function turns out to provide a sufficient argument for the existence of the measures @xmath1141 for all @xmath1142 several regularity results are deduced from properties of the function @xmath1138 .
the approach presented in this chapter is based on theorem [ denjoywolff ] .
we show existence and regularity properties for measures in partial semigroups with respect to both additive and multiplicative convolutions .
we also investigate connections with infinite divisibility with respect to free and boolean convoluitons , and point out some new properties of the cauchy transforms of measures which are infinitely divisible with respect to free convolutions .
most of the results presented here appear in @xcite .
we present first a global inversion theorem for certain analytic functions defined in the upper half - plane .
a somewhat weaker result has been proved in @xcite , theorem 2.2 .
[ inversionc+ ] let @xmath1143 be an analytic function such that @xmath1144 for @xmath250 , and the limit @xmath1145 is strictly positive . 1 . for every @xmath1146 there exists a unique @xmath250 such that @xmath1147 .
2 . there exists a continuous function @xmath1148 such that @xmath1149 , @xmath1150 is analytic , and @xmath1151 for @xmath250 .
3 . for each @xmath1152 , @xmath1153 is the denjoy - wolff point of the map @xmath1154 defined by@xmath1155 4 .
the function @xmath239 satisfies @xmath1156 @xmath250 , and @xmath1157 in particular , @xmath239 is one - to - one .
5 . if @xmath1158 is such that @xmath1159 , then @xmath239 can be continued analytically to a neighborhood of @xmath1160 . let us first consider the function @xmath1161 which maps @xmath173 to its closure , and therefore can be written in nevanlinna integral form @xmath1162 with @xmath1163 , @xmath1164 , and @xmath84 a borel , finite , positive measure on the real line . since clearly @xmath1165 and @xmath1166 , we easily deduce that @xmath1167 and @xmath1168 $ ] . in order to prove ( 1 ) ,
fix @xmath1146 .
we shall argue that the denjoy - wolff point of @xmath1169 belongs to @xmath173 .
first , @xmath1170 so that the denjoy - wolff point can not be a real number . on the other hand it can not be infinity either because @xmath1171 where the last fraction must be understood as @xmath1172 if @xmath890 .
denote then by @xmath1173 the denjoy - wolff point of @xmath1169 , and note that it is then the unique fixed point of @xmath1169 .
fixed points @xmath121 for @xmath1169 are precisely points with @xmath1147 , and the function @xmath1174 is analytic , by the implicit function theorem .
this proves ( 1 ) , and the part of ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) pertaining to points @xmath1146 .
let us note at this point that @xmath1169 is not a conformal automorphism of @xmath173 , and therefore @xmath1175 .
equivalently , @xmath1176 so that @xmath1177 for all @xmath1146 .
this implies the inequality @xmath1178 we shall show now that @xmath239 extends by continuity to a function @xmath1179 , and thus the preceding inequality will persist for @xmath1180 ( the proof appears also in @xcite , proposition 2.4 ) .
first assume that there exists a sequence @xmath1181 such that the limit @xmath1182 exists and belongs to @xmath1183 in this case we have @xmath1184 denote by @xmath1185 the order of the zero of @xmath1186 at @xmath1187 .
we can find analytic functions @xmath1188 defined in a set of the form @xmath1189 such that @xmath1190 for @xmath1191 and @xmath1192 .
clearly @xmath239 must coincide with one of the functions @xmath1193 on @xmath1194 and it follows that @xmath239 extends continuously to the interval @xmath1195 .
assume to the contrary that there is no sequence @xmath760 as in the first part of the argument .
in other words , if @xmath1181 and @xmath1196 exists , this limit is either infinite or real .
assume now that two sequences @xmath1197 have limit equal to @xmath28 and the limits @xmath1196 , @xmath1198 exist and are different .
consider a continuous path @xmath1199 passing through all the points @xmath760 and @xmath1200 , and such that @xmath1201 there exists then an open interval @xmath1202 such that for every @xmath1203 there is a sequence @xmath1204 such that @xmath1205 in fact @xmath1206 can be chosen so that @xmath1207 nontangentially as @xmath953 since @xmath1208 we deduce that the nontangential limit @xmath1209 of @xmath580 at @xmath1210 is equal to @xmath28 almost everywhere .
theorem [ privalov ] shows now that @xmath580 must be constant , and this is a contradiction .
therefore @xmath1211 exists . the case @xmath1212 is treated similarily . to conclude the proof of ( 2 ) we still need to show that @xmath1213 is finite if @xmath127 .
this will follow once we establish ( 3 ) for points on the boundary .
we proceed by proving that ( 3 ) and ( 5 ) hold for a point @xmath1158 with the property that @xmath1214 .
fix such a point @xmath1160 , and set @xmath1215 . with the trivial exception of @xmath1216 , the function @xmath1169
still maps @xmath173 to @xmath173 , and @xmath1217 .
indeed , @xmath1218 thus @xmath219 is indeed the denjoy - wolff point of @xmath1169 .
we conclude that @xmath1219 , with equality only when @xmath1169 is a conformal automorphism of @xmath173 .
the last case is trivial . indeed ,
when @xmath1220 , we have @xmath1221 , so that @xmath1169 can only be an automorphism of the form @xmath1222 for some @xmath1223 . in this case @xmath1224 , and the conclusions of the theorem are obvious since @xmath1225 if @xmath890 and @xmath1169 is an automorphism , we must have @xmath1226 for some real numbers @xmath1227 with @xmath1228 . in this case
@xmath1229 and the zeros of @xmath1230 are @xmath1231 .
we conclude that @xmath1232 .
the same conclusion holds when @xmath1169 is not an automorphism because @xmath1233 in both cases , the local inverse of @xmath580 at @xmath219 will be an analytic continuation of @xmath239 in a neighborhood of @xmath1160 . to conclude
, we must complete the proof of ( 3 ) by showing that @xmath1153 can not be infinite if @xmath1158 , and that @xmath1153 is the denjoy - wolff point of @xmath1169 .
fix then @xmath1158 , and exclude the case @xmath1234 which has just been treated .
we can also assume that the map @xmath1169 is not a conformal automorphism of @xmath173 , since in this case the function @xmath239 can be calculated explicitly . as in the first part of the proof , @xmath1235 which shows that @xmath1236 is not the denjoy - wolff point of @xmath1169 .
we conclude then that this denjoy - wolff point @xmath1237 is a real number .
we will show that @xmath1174 . to do this
we observe that ( since the julia - carathodory derivative of @xmath1169 at @xmath1237 is no more than one ) @xmath1169 maps the horodisk @xmath1238 into itself for @xmath444 .
in particular , since @xmath1169 has no fixed points in @xmath173 , @xmath1239therefore @xmath1240 we also have @xmath1241 so that , at long last , @xmath1242 as claimed .
let now @xmath63 be a borel probability measure on @xmath83 we shall use theorem [ inversionc+ ] to prove the existence of a family @xmath1243 such that @xmath1244 and @xmath1245 we recall that , by theorem [ r - transform ] , it will be enough to show that for each @xmath1140 there exists a probability measure @xmath1141 on the real line such that @xmath1246 for @xmath121 in the common domain of the two functions .
a slightly weaker version of this result can be found in @xcite .
[ mut+ ] consider a borel probability measure @xmath63 on @xmath64 , and a real number @xmath1247 1 .
there exists a probability measure @xmath1141 satisfying @xmath1246 for @xmath121 in the common domain of the two functions . 2 .
there exists an injective analytic map @xmath1248 such that @xmath1249 for @xmath1250 3 .
we have @xmath1251 and @xmath1252 where @xmath1253 for @xmath1250 if @xmath1254 , clearly @xmath1244 and @xmath1255 will satisfy the conclusions of the theorem .
assume therefore that @xmath1142 we clearly have @xmath1256 and @xmath1257 therefore , theorem [ inversionc+ ] implies the existence of an analytic function @xmath1248 satisfying @xmath1258 we also have @xmath1259 and @xmath1260 it follows that the function @xmath1261 satisfies the conditions @xmath1262 @xmath1263 , and @xmath1264 by proposition [ cauchyalt ] , these conditions imply the existence of a borel probability measure @xmath1141 on @xmath64 satisfying @xmath1265 note that the definition of @xmath1266 yields the first formula in ( 3 ) .
to prove ( 2 ) we observe that @xmath1267 so that @xmath1268 finally , let us observe that , for @xmath121 in the domain of definition of @xmath1269 we have @xmath1270 + \left(1-\frac{1}{t}\right)f_{\mu_t}(z+\varphi_{\mu_t}(z))\right ) \\ & = & f_\mu\left(\frac{1}{t}\left[z+\varphi_{\mu_t}(z)\right ] + \left(1-\frac{1}{t}\right)\frac{1}{z}\right ) \\ & = & f_\mu\left(z+\frac{1}{t}\varphi_{\mu_t}(z)\right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we used ( 2 ) in the second equality , and ( 3 ) in the third equality .
we conclude that the function @xmath1271 satisfies @xmath1272 and @xmath1273 therefore , @xmath1274 which proves ( 1 ) .
due to their properties , it is natural to denote the probability measures @xmath1141 from the theorem above by @xmath1275 in the following , we describe regularity properties of probability measures @xmath1276 for @xmath1142 we shall use theorem [ inversionc+ ] and theorem [ mut+ ] to describe the boundary behavior of @xmath1277 and thus characterize the absolutely continuous , singular continuous , and atomic , parts of @xmath1275 we recall that @xmath1278 is the poisson integral of the measure @xmath1279 and hence @xmath63 can be recovered as the weak*-limit of the measures @xmath1280 as @xmath1281 .
in particular , the density of @xmath63 ( relative to lebesgue measure ) is the @xmath1282-a.e .
limit of @xmath1283 as @xmath1281 , and this limit is , as seen also in lemma [ delavalee ] , a.e .
infinite relative to the singular part of the measure @xmath63 .
more specifically , @xmath28 is an atom of @xmath63 if and only of @xmath1284 and the julia - carathodory derivative @xmath1285 is finite .
the value of this derivative is then @xmath1286 these observations can now be used to prove a somewhat stronger version of the regularity results proved in @xcite .
[ regptmut+ ] let @xmath63 be a probability measure on @xmath64 , and let @xmath1140 . 1
. a point @xmath127 satisfies @xmath1287 if and only if @xmath1288 is an atom of @xmath63 with mass @xmath1289 .
if @xmath1290 , then @xmath28 is an atom of @xmath1276 , and @xmath1291 2 . the nonatomic part of @xmath1276 is absolutely continuous , and its density is continuous except at the ( finitely many ) points @xmath28 such that @xmath1287 .
3 . the density of @xmath1276 is analytic at all points where it is different from zero .
assume first that @xmath1287 .
this is equivalent to @xmath1292 , or , equivalently , @xmath1288 is the denjoy - wolff point of the function @xmath1293 defined in theorem [ inversionc+ ] ( 3 ) . by theorem [ denjoywolff ] , and the definition of @xmath1294 ,
this is equivalent to @xmath1295 and @xmath1296 .
we have then @xmath1297 so that @xmath1298 .
moreover , @xmath1299 , so that @xmath1300 this yields @xmath1301 , indicating that @xmath1288 is an atom of @xmath63 with the required mass .
conversely , if @xmath1289 , then the calculations above show that @xmath1295 and @xmath1296 .
thus , @xmath1302 and @xmath1303 we conclude by theorem [ denjoywolff ] that @xmath1288 is the denjoy - wolff point of @xmath1294 .
thus , @xmath1304 , and @xmath1292 .
therefore @xmath1305 in case @xmath1290 , we have @xmath1306 .
this implies that @xmath1307 and therefore @xmath1308 exists and belongs to @xmath1309 we conclude that @xmath1310 maps any nontangential path @xmath1311 in@xmath1312 ending at @xmath1288 into a nontangential path @xmath1313 ending at @xmath28 , and having the part sufficiently close to @xmath28 included in @xmath271 thus , @xmath1314 .
we deduce that @xmath1315 this shows that @xmath28 is an atom of @xmath1316 with the required mass .
as noted above , @xmath1287 almost everywhere relative to the singular part of @xmath1276 .
we deduce that this singular part has finite support , and therefore it is purely atomic .
the density of @xmath1276 is simply @xmath1317 , and is therefore continuous at all points where the denominator is not zero .
the analyticity of this density follows from the analyticity of @xmath1138 at points @xmath127 where @xmath1318 ( see theorem [ inversionc+ ] ( 5 ) )
. in the following , we apply theorems [ mut+ ] and [ inversionc+ ] to point out connections between free and boolean infinite divisibility and describe some properties of reciprocals of cauchy transforms of infinitely divisible measures with respect to free additive convolution . [ infdiv ] given an arbitrary convolution @xmath1319 we say that a probability measure @xmath63 is infinitely divisible with respect to @xmath1320 if for any @xmath1321 there exists a probability measure @xmath1322 such that @xmath1323 we shall denote by @xmath1324 the set of all probability measures which are infinitely divisible with respect to the convolution @xmath1320 . in @xcite bercovici and voiculescu have completely described infinitely divisible probability measures with respect to free additive convolution in terms of their @xmath396transforms .
we state the result below : [ infdiv+ ] a probability measure @xmath63 on @xmath64 is @xmath1325-infinitely divisible if and only if @xmath406 has an analytic extension defined on @xmath173 with values in @xmath1326 .
let @xmath1327 be an analytic function .
then @xmath25 is a continuation of @xmath406 for some @xmath1325-infinitely divisible measure @xmath63 if and only if @xmath1328 next , we give an analytic characterization of boolean additive convolution ( definition [ boolean ] , ( a ) ) , due to speicher and woroudi : [ booleananalitic ] consider two probability measures @xmath63 and @xmath67 on @xmath83 then @xmath1329 ( it is easy to observe that the operation @xmath1330 is commutative and associative .
however , unlike for classical and free additive convolutions , @xmath1331 is not usually equal to the shift of @xmath63 by the amount of @xmath110 . )
theorem [ booleananalitic ] makes the following result of speicher and woroudi less surprising : [ infdivboolean ] all probability measures on @xmath64 are infinitely divisible with respect to boolean additive convolution .
we can now prove the following result : [ ? ] fix a number @xmath1140 . with the notations from theorem [ mut+ ] ,
the following hold : 1 . for any probability measure
@xmath1332 , we have @xmath1333 for all @xmath250 , and @xmath398 extends continuously to @xmath64
. moreover , @xmath1334 @xmath63 has at most one atom , and the density of @xmath1335 with respect to lebesgue measure is analytic wherever positive ; 2 . the correspondence @xmath1336 induces a bijective correspondence @xmath1337 with the property that @xmath1338 for all probability measures @xmath1339 assume @xmath1332 . by theorem [ infdiv+ ] ,
@xmath1340 can be continued analytically to @xmath271 let us observe , by part ( ii ) of theorem [ infdiv+ ] , the function @xmath1341 satisfies the hypothesis of theorem [ inversionc+ ] , with @xmath1342 ( recall that @xmath1343 ) thus , there exists an analytic self - map @xmath239 of the upper half - plane such that @xmath1344 @xmath241 applying @xmath239 to both sides of this equality gives @xmath1345 for all @xmath1346 part ( 4 ) of theorem [ inversionc+ ] implies that @xmath1347 , so we conclude that @xmath1348 but @xmath1349 for @xmath121 in some large enough truncated cone at infinity .
we conclude that @xmath1350 , and by part ( 4 ) of theorem [ inversionc+ ] , we obtain that @xmath1333 for all @xmath241 the continuous extension of @xmath398 to @xmath64 follows from part ( 2 ) of the same theorem . by definition of infinite divisibility , we know that @xmath1351 for some probability measure @xmath1352 on @xmath64 .
thus , the statements refering to the absolutely continuous and singular continuous parts of @xmath63 follow from parts ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) of theorem [ regptmut+ ] . finally , by part ( 1 ) of theorem [ regptmut+ ] we know that in order for @xmath28 to be an atom of @xmath63 , we must have @xmath1284 .
since @xmath1333 for all @xmath120 we conclude that this can happen for at most one @xmath127 .
this completes the proof of ( a ) . to prove ( b ) , consider two arbitrary probability measures @xmath66 on @xmath1353 . define @xmath1354 @xmath1355 as we have seen in the proof of ( a ) , the right inverses @xmath1356 and @xmath1357 of @xmath1358 and @xmath1359 respectively , are reciprocals of cauchy transforms of probability measures which are infinitely divisible with respect to @xmath1325 ; denote them by @xmath1360 and @xmath1361 observe that , by its definition , @xmath1362 thus , @xmath1363 ( we have used theorem [ booleananalitic ] in the third equality . ) we conclude by theorem [ r - transform ] that @xmath1364 this shows that @xmath1365 is an injective homomorphism .
to show surjectivity , consider @xmath1366 and let @xmath1367 @xmath241 by theorem [ infdiv+ ] , we have @xmath1368 for all @xmath121 in the upper half - plane , and @xmath1369 let @xmath1370 observe that @xmath1371 for all @xmath120 and @xmath1372 we conclude by proposition [ cauchyalt ] that there exists a probability measure @xmath63 on @xmath64 such that @xmath1373 . a computation similar to
the one above shows that @xmath1374 a somewhat weaker version of part ( a ) of the above theorem can be found in @xcite , while for @xmath1375 the morphism described in part ( b ) is the bercovici - pata bijection ( see @xcite for details ) .
a result similar to the one from theorem [ mut+ ] holds for free multiplicative convolutions of measures supported on the unit circle .
however , as we shall see below , it is not always possible to start the semigroup at @xmath1254 , and the semigroup is not unique .
we begin with an inversion theorem for maps defined in the unit disk .
[ inversionx1 ] let @xmath1376 be a meromorphic function such that @xmath1377 and @xmath1378 for all @xmath147 .
then : 1 . for every @xmath1379
there exists a unique @xmath147 such that @xmath1380 .
2 . there exists a continuous function @xmath1381 such that @xmath1382 , @xmath1383 is analytic , and @xmath1384 for @xmath147 .
3 . for each @xmath1385 , @xmath1153 is the denjoy - wolff point of the map @xmath1386 defined by @xmath1387 4 .
the function @xmath239 is one - to - one .
5 . if @xmath1388 is such that @xmath1389 , then @xmath239 can be continued analytically to a neighborhood of @xmath1390 . if @xmath1391 , then @xmath1392 is indeed the unique point for which @xmath1393 .
assume therefore that @xmath1394 .
the function @xmath1169 is analytic on @xmath124 , and @xmath1395 we conclude that the denjoy - wolff point of @xmath1169 is in @xmath124 , and therefore there exists a unique @xmath1396 such that @xmath1397 , namely this denjoy - wolff point . since @xmath1398 the point @xmath1237 can not be zero , and therefore the equation @xmath1397 is equivalent to @xmath1380 .
the function @xmath1174 is easily seen to be analytic . to complete the proof of ( 2 ) , we must show that for every @xmath1388 , the limit @xmath1399 exists .
we distinguish two cases : 1 .
there exists a sequence @xmath1400 such that @xmath1401 and the limit @xmath1402 exists and belongs to @xmath124 ; 2 . for any sequence @xmath1400 such that @xmath1401 and the limit @xmath1402 exists , this limit is in @xmath1403 . assume first that ( a ) holds , and set @xmath1404 .
we claim that @xmath1405 . indeed , @xmath1406 we deduce that @xmath219 is the denjoy - wolff point of @xmath1407 , and hence @xmath1408 , with strict inequality unless @xmath1407 is a conformal automorphism of @xmath124 .
this last case means that@xmath1409 for some @xmath1410 and @xmath1411 . in this case @xmath1412 if @xmath1413
, then the zeros of @xmath1414 are equal to @xmath1415 . both of these zeros are on the unit circle , so that @xmath1416 .
we deduce that @xmath1417 is locally invertible at @xmath219 , and the local inverse is an analytic continuation of @xmath239 to a neighborhood of @xmath1390 .
when @xmath1407 is not a conformal automorphism , we must have @xmath1418 .
since @xmath1419 we deduce that @xmath1416 , and the analytic continuation of @xmath239 at @xmath1390 is obtained as in the previous case .
this argument shows that , in case ( a ) holds , @xmath239 has an analytic , in particular continuous , continuation at @xmath1390 , which also proves assertion ( 5 ) .
next we deal with case ( b ) .
assume that there exist two sequences @xmath1420 such that @xmath1421 , the limits @xmath1402 , @xmath1422 exist , and they are different .
choose a continuous path @xmath1423 passing through all the points @xmath1424 , and such that @xmath1425 .
it follows from our assumption that there exists an open interval @xmath1426 in the unit circle @xmath1427 such that every point @xmath1428 is of the form @xmath1429 , where @xmath1430 for all @xmath336 .
moreover , the sequence @xmath1431 can be chosen so that @xmath1432 , and thus @xmath1433 approaches @xmath1434 nontangentially . since @xmath1435
we conclude that the nontangential limit of @xmath1417 at @xmath1434 is @xmath1390 for almost every @xmath1428 .
privelov s theorem ( theorem [ privalov ] ) implies that @xmath1417 is identically equal to @xmath1390 .
this however is not true because @xmath1377 .
this contradiction shows that the limit @xmath1436 exists in case ( b ) as well . we have already shown that @xmath1153 is the denjoy - wolff point of @xmath1169 provided that @xmath1437 .
we will show that this is still true when @xmath1438 .
fix @xmath1438 , and denote by @xmath1237 the denjoy - wolff point of @xmath1169 . if @xmath1439 , then @xmath1397 so that @xmath1440 . since @xmath1417 is analytic at @xmath1237 , hence open , there exist points @xmath1441 such that @xmath1442 and @xmath1443 for @xmath694 close to 1 .
however , property ( 1 ) shows that @xmath1444 is the only point in @xmath124 such that @xmath1445 .
we deduce that @xmath1446 as claimed . on the other hand , if @xmath1447 , julia s theorem shows that , for each @xmath1448 , @xmath1169 maps the horodisk @xmath1449 into itself .
in particular , as @xmath1169 is not the identity map , @xmath1450 and @xmath1451 . therefore @xmath1452 and @xmath1453 . we conclude that @xmath1454 it remains to prove that @xmath239 is one - to - one on @xmath1065 . to do this ,
we observe first that for each @xmath1379 , @xmath1153 is the unique fixed point of @xmath1169 , and @xmath1169 is not a conformal automorphism of @xmath124 as @xmath1455 thus @xmath1456 , so that @xmath1457 using the relation @xmath1458 , the inequality becomes @xmath1459 which is equivalent to @xmath1460 consider now the logarithm of @xmath239 .
more precisely , let @xmath1461\times\mathbb r\to\mathbb c$ ] be a continuous function such that @xmath1462 for all @xmath694 and @xmath1463 .
we have @xmath1464 so that @xmath1465 provided that @xmath1466 .
this implies the inequality @xmath1467 whenever @xmath1466 .
this inequality extends by continuity to @xmath1468 as well .
assume now that @xmath1469 are such that @xmath1470 .
in this case there must exist an integer @xmath460 such that @xmath1471 , and this leads to a contradiction since @xmath1472 . as in section 1
, we use the above theorem to prove the existence of a partially defined free convolution semigroup of measures on @xmath1127 [ mutx1 ] consider a probability measure @xmath63 on @xmath75 having nonzero first moment , and let @xmath1140 be a real number . assume that the function @xmath615 never vanishes on @xmath1473 1 .
there exists a probability measure @xmath1141 on @xmath75 such that @xmath1474 , and @xmath1475 in a neighborhood of zero .
moreover , @xmath1476 never vanishes on @xmath1477 .
2 . there exists an analytic function @xmath1478 such that @xmath1479 and @xmath1480 for @xmath147 .
we have @xmath1481^{1/t},\quad z\in\mathbb d,\ ] ] and @xmath1482 for @xmath147 , where + @xmath1483^{t-1},\quad z\in\mathbb d.\ ] ] the function @xmath1484 , defined as in ( 3 ) , satisfies the conditions of theorem [ inversionx1 ] ( this is an immediate consequence of proposition [ etacircle ] and the hypothesis ) , which proves the existence of a right inverse @xmath1138 for @xmath1485 we define then @xmath1486 , and observe that @xmath1487 for some measure @xmath1141 on @xmath75 .
indeed , this follows immediatly from theorem [ inversionx1 ] ( 2 ) and proposition [ etacircle ] .
clearly @xmath1476 only vanishes for @xmath1392 ; this follows from the corresponding hypothesis on @xmath63 , and from the fact that @xmath1138 is injective . to conclude , we must verify the identities in ( 1 ) and ( 3 ) .
the inversion relation @xmath1482 amounts to @xmath1488^{t-1}=z,\ ] ] or @xmath1489^{t-1}=\frac z{\omega_t(z)}.\ ] ] this can also be written as @xmath1490^{t-1}\left[\frac z{\eta_{\mu_t}(z)}\right]^{t-1}=\frac z{\omega_t(z)},\ ] ] by injectivity of @xmath1138 and the hypothesis on @xmath615 . @xmath1490^{t}=\left[\frac z{\eta_{\mu_t}(z)}\right]^{1-t } = \frac z{\eta_{\mu_t}(z)}\left[\frac{\eta_{\mu_t}(z)}z\right]^t\ ] ] and hence @xmath1491^{1/t}\frac{\eta_{\mu_t}(z)}z,\ ] ] which verifies ( 3 )
. finally , if @xmath121 is close to zero , we have @xmath1492^{t-1}\\ & = \eta^{-1}_\mu(z)\left[\frac{\eta^{-1}_\mu(z)}z\right]^{t-1 } = z\sigma_\mu(z)\sigma_\mu(z)^{t-1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] dividing by @xmath121 we obtain the desired relation @xmath1475 .
it seems natural to denote @xmath1141 by @xmath1493 , but note that these measures are only determined up to a rotation by a multiple of @xmath1494 .
this is due to the choice involved in extracting roots . in case
@xmath615 has zeroes in @xmath1477 , we are assured by theorem [ biane3 ] that @xmath1495 has no zeros in @xmath1477 .
thus , one can still define @xmath1496 at least for @xmath1497 .
it will still be true that @xmath1498 for some conformal map @xmath1138 , but @xmath1138 might not have a globally defined left inverse .
its left inverse @xmath1499 is however the composition of two functions defined on @xmath124 because @xmath1138 is the composition of two functions which do have global left inverses .
let us also observe that whenever @xmath1500 , @xmath1141 is defined for any @xmath1501 , and equals the uniform distribution ( the haar measure ) on @xmath75 . in the following , we shall discuss regularity properties of measures @xmath1141 , @xmath1502 as we have observed at the beginning of section 1.3 of the previous chapter , in the case of probability measures @xmath63 on @xmath75 , we have @xmath1503 the real part of this function is the poisson integral of the measure @xmath1504 , and therefore this measure can be obtained as the weak*-limit of the measures @xmath1505 as @xmath1506 . in particular , the functions @xmath1507 converge @xmath1508-a.e . to the density of @xmath1509 , and they converge to infinity a.e .
relative to the singular part of this measure .
a number @xmath1510 is an atom of @xmath63 if and only if @xmath1511 and the julia - carathodory derivative @xmath1512 is finite ( this follows from lemma [ atoms&tang ] and theorem [ juliacaratheodory ] ) . in this case
this derivative is still given by @xmath1513 in the following result we will assume that a choice of arguments has been made so that the results of theorem [ mutx1 ] are correct . when @xmath1463 is an integer , the following result is true without the assumption that @xmath615 have no zeros different from @xmath1002 .
[ regmutx1 ] let @xmath63 be a probability measure on @xmath75 such that @xmath1113 , @xmath615 has no zeros in @xmath1477 , and let @xmath1140 .
consider the measure @xmath1493 provided by theorem [ mutx1 ] , and the corresponding functions @xmath1484 and @xmath1138 1 .
a point @xmath1514 satisfies @xmath1515 if and only if @xmath1516 and @xmath1517 is an atom of @xmath63 with mass @xmath1518 .
if @xmath1519 , then @xmath1520 is an atom of @xmath1493 , and @xmath1521 if @xmath1515 , there is a real number @xmath168 such that @xmath1522 and @xmath1523 .
2 . the nonatomic part of @xmath1493 is absolutely continuous , and its density is continuous except at the ( finitely many ) points @xmath1390 such that @xmath1524 .
3 . the density of @xmath1493 is analytic at all points where it is different from zero . as in the proof of theorem [ regptmut+ ] ,
( 2 ) and ( 3 ) follow easily from the continuity and analyticity properties of @xmath1138 , once ( 1 ) is established .
the formulas @xmath1525^{\frac t{t-1 } } , \quad z\in \mathbb d,\ ] ] show that @xmath1526 extends continuously to @xmath1065 , and these equalities persist when @xmath1527 even if @xmath1528 , provided that @xmath1529 is viewed as a nontangential limit .
this being said , let @xmath1514 satisfy @xmath1515 .
the above formulas show that @xmath1530 , and in fact @xmath1531 is one of the @xmath1532-powers of @xmath1390 . since , according to theorem [ inversionx1 ] , @xmath1531 is the denjoy - wolff point of the function @xmath1533 , we see , by theorem [ denjoywolff ] , that @xmath1534 , and @xmath1535 we will treat this derivative a little more carefully , on account of the fractional powers involved .
we have @xmath1536replacing @xmath121 by @xmath1531 , and using the equalities @xmath1534 and @xmath1537 , we obtain @xmath1538this number is nonnegative precisely when @xmath1518 .
conversely , if @xmath1516 , and @xmath1518 , then the above calculation will show that @xmath1484 has nonnegative julia - carathodory derivative at @xmath1531 , and , since @xmath1539 , we conclude that @xmath1531 is the denjoy - wolff point of @xmath1540 so that @xmath1534 .
this implies @xmath1515 .
the mass @xmath1541 can then be calculated using the chain rule in case @xmath1519 , as in the proof of theorem [ regptmut+ ] .
a connection similar to the one presented in proposition [ ? ] exists for measures on the unit circle .
we present first an analytic characterization of multiplicative boolean convolution ( definition [ boolean ] ( b ) ) , due to franz @xcite : [ utimesanalitic ] consider two probability measures @xmath63 and @xmath67 on @xmath75 .
we have @xmath1542 unlike in the additive case , not all probability measures are infinitely divisible with respect to multiplicative boolean convolution , as the following theorem of franz shows ( see @xcite , theorem 3.6 ) : [ franzinfdiv ] a probability measure @xmath63 on the unit circle , different from the haar measure , is infinitely divisible with respect to multiplicative boolean convolution if and only if there exists a real number @xmath1543 and a finite measure @xmath112 on @xmath75 such that @xmath1544 observe that , if @xmath63 is the uniform distribution on @xmath1545 then @xmath1546 for all @xmath147 , and thus @xmath63 is infinitely divisible with respect to @xmath1547 we state below the analogue of theorem [ infdiv+ ] for free multiplicative convolution , as it appears in @xcite , theorem 6.7 : [ infdivx1 ] 1 .
a probability measure @xmath63 on @xmath75 with nonzero first moment is infinitely divisible if and only if there exists a function @xmath1548 , analytic in @xmath124 , such that @xmath1549 for all @xmath147 and @xmath1550 2 .
let @xmath1551 be an analytic function .
then the function @xmath1552 has the form @xmath1553 for some @xmath993-infinitely divisible measure @xmath63 with nonzero first moment . as in the case of multiplicative boolean convolution
, we observe that the uniform distribution is also infinitely divisible with respect to @xmath1554 [ ? ? ] fix a number @xmath1140 . with the notations from theorem [ mutx1 ] ,
the following hold : 1 . for any @xmath993-infinitely divisible probability measure @xmath63 on @xmath75 , different from the uniform distribution on the unit circle
, @xmath615 extends continuously to @xmath1545 and the extension is injective .
moreover , @xmath1334 @xmath63 has at most one atom , and the density of @xmath1555 with respect to the uniform distribution on @xmath75 is analytic wherever positive ; 2 . the correspondence @xmath1556 induces a bijective correspondence @xmath1557 with the property that @xmath1558 for all @xmath1559 assume @xmath1560 by definition , @xmath1561 for some probability measure @xmath1562 on @xmath75 with nonzero first moment .
thus , by theorem [ regmutx1 ] , @xmath1334 and @xmath1555 has analytic density with respect to the uniform distribution on @xmath75 . to prove injectivity of @xmath1563 observe that
, by theorem [ infdivx1 ] , @xmath1564 for some analytic function @xmath980 on @xmath124 with @xmath1565 @xmath1566 we claim that the function @xmath1567 satisfies the hypotheses of theorem [ inversionx1 ] .
indeed , @xmath1377 trivially , and @xmath1568 by theorem [ infdivx1 ] ( i ) .
thus , there exists an analytic self - map of the unit disk @xmath239 such that @xmath1569 @xmath147 . applying @xmath239 to both sides of the equality gives @xmath1570 for all @xmath1571 since @xmath1393 if and only if @xmath1572 we must also have @xmath1081 but @xmath1573 for @xmath121 in some neighbourhood of @xmath1002 .
we conclude that @xmath1574 and thus , by part ( 4 ) of theorem [ inversionx1 ] , we conclude that @xmath615 exitends as a continuous injective function to @xmath1112 finally , by part ( 1 ) of theorem [ regmutx1 ] , we know that in order for @xmath135 to be an atom of @xmath63 , we must have @xmath1575 the injectivity of @xmath615 implies that this can happen for at most one @xmath1576 this proves part ( a ) of the proposition . to prove part ( b ) , consider two arbitrary probability measures @xmath1577 assume first that neither of them is the uniform distribution on @xmath75 .
define @xmath1578^{t-1},\quad \phi_t^\mu(z)=z\left[\frac{z}{\eta_\mu(z)}\right]^{t-1},\quad z\in\mathbb d.\ ] ] observe that , by theorem [ franzinfdiv ] , the above functions are indeed well - defined , and @xmath1579 , @xmath1580 as we have seen in the proof of ( a ) , there exist probability measures , denote them by @xmath1360 and @xmath1581 such that the @xmath1582 and @xmath1583 , where @xmath1584 denote the right inverses of @xmath1585 and @xmath1586 , respectively , provided by theorem [ mutx1 ] .
we claim that @xmath1587 . indeed ,
on some neighbourhood of zero we have @xmath1588 and hence @xmath1589 by analytic continuation , this equality holds for all @xmath1102 in particular , the function @xmath1590 is well - defnied , analytic , and @xmath1591 @xmath1592 of course , @xmath1593 implies that @xmath1594 we conclude by theorem [ infdivx1 ] that @xmath1595 similarily , @xmath1596 assume now that @xmath63 is the uniform distribution on @xmath1127 we define @xmath1597 . observe that in this case @xmath1598 we have thus proved that @xmath1365 is an injective homomorphism . to show surjectivity ,
let @xmath1599 we may assume without loss of generality that @xmath1600 is not the uniform distribution on @xmath75 . by theorem [ infdivx1 ] , @xmath1601 , @xmath147 , for some analytic function @xmath980 such that @xmath1602 let
@xmath1603 @xmath1102 we obviously have @xmath1604 and @xmath1605 define @xmath1606^{\frac{1}{t-1}},\quad z\in \mathbb d.\ ] ] observe that @xmath1607 and thus @xmath1608 and @xmath1609 we conclude by proposition [ eta ] that there exists a probability measure @xmath63 on @xmath75 such that @xmath619 .
also , the function @xmath1610 satisfies the condition @xmath1611 and thus , by proposition [ momentcircle ] , is of the form @xmath1612 for some positive finite measure @xmath112 on @xmath75 , and some number @xmath1613 we conclude by theorem [ franzinfdiv ] that @xmath1614 the computation above shows that @xmath1374 the results that will be presented in this section are similar to the ones in the previous sections . as before , we shall start with an inversion theorem , this time for maps defined on the slit complex plane .
the covering map @xmath1615 defined by @xmath1616 provides a conformal map of the strip @xmath1617 onto @xmath1618 .
call @xmath1619 the inverse of this conformal map .
for any function @xmath1620 there exists therefore a function @xmath1621 such that @xmath1622 . when @xmath1623 , the function @xmath128 is uniquely determined if we require it to be real - valued on @xmath64 or , equivalently , @xmath1624 .
thus , inversion results for functions defined on @xmath1625 can be naturally formulated for maps on @xmath1618 .
we will consider analytic functions defined in the band @xmath1626 , which is of course conformally equivalent to the right half - plane , the equivalence being realized by @xmath1627 , @xmath1628 .
the map @xmath25 sends @xmath1172 to @xmath1172 and @xmath1629 to zero , and from this one can easily deduce what the julia - carathodory derivatives should be at @xmath1630 . for a function
@xmath1631 they are @xmath1632 at @xmath1172 , and @xmath1633 at @xmath1629 . in order to use julia s theorem , we will need to look at the horodisks associated with a point @xmath1634 .
if @xmath162 is such a horodisk , then @xmath1635 is an ordinary disk contained in the right - half - plane , and tangent to the imaginary axis at the point @xmath1636 .
the point in ( the boundary of ) @xmath162 with the lowest imaginary part corresponds with the point in @xmath1635 with lowest argument . if @xmath1637 is this point , then the segment @xmath1638 $ ] must be tangent to @xmath1635 at @xmath1637 , and therefore it must have the same length as the other tangent from the origin , namely @xmath1639 $ ] .
we deduce that @xmath1640 , so that @xmath1641 .
it is easy to see that any point in @xmath1642 , with real part @xmath28 , is the lowest point in some horodisk .
the consequence we will use is as follows : if @xmath1643 is an analytic function with denjoy - wolff point @xmath1644 , then @xmath1645 for @xmath1646 .
[ inversionx2 ] consider an analytic function @xmath1621 with the property that @xmath1647 for all @xmath1648 .
assume that there exists a number @xmath1649 such that @xmath1650 and @xmath1651 for all @xmath1648 with @xmath1652 .
then : 1 . for every @xmath1653
there exists a unique @xmath1654 such that @xmath1655 .
2 . there exists a continuous function @xmath1656 such that @xmath1657 , @xmath1658 is analytic , @xmath1659 @xmath1660 and @xmath1661 for @xmath1654 .
3 . for each @xmath1662 , @xmath1153 is the denjoy - wolff point of the map @xmath1663 defined by @xmath1664where @xmath1665 .
the function @xmath239 satisfies @xmath1666 in particular , @xmath239 is one - to - one .
5 . if @xmath1667 is such that @xmath1668 , then @xmath239 can be continued analytically to a neighborhood of @xmath1160 . let us show that the functions @xmath1169 map @xmath1642 into itself .
we clearly have , from the properties of @xmath1669 that @xmath1670 and @xmath1671 the left - hand side of these inequalities is a convex combination of @xmath1672 and @xmath1673 , and hence is in @xmath1674 . for the right - hand sides we observe that @xmath1675 for @xmath1676 , and @xmath1677 for @xmath1678 .
observe that @xmath1679 for all @xmath127 .
this implies that @xmath1680 and similarly @xmath1681 we conclude that the denjoy - wolff point of @xmath1169 is not @xmath1630 , with the possible exception when @xmath128 is a real multiple of the identity map .
if @xmath1682 , then , by the above inequalities , @xmath1683 so the denjoy - wolff point of @xmath1169 belongs to @xmath1684 denote by @xmath1237 this point .
it is clear that @xmath1685 the function @xmath1686 is clearly an analytic self - map of @xmath1684 this proves ( 1 ) and parts of ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) .
we wish now to show that the function @xmath239 has a continuous extension to @xmath1687 .
fix @xmath1667 and , as in the case of the disk , consider two cases : 1 .
there exists a sequence @xmath1688 such that @xmath1689 and @xmath1690 exists and belongs to @xmath1642 ; 2 . for any sequence @xmath1691 such that @xmath1689 and @xmath1690 exists
, this limit is in @xmath1692 . if ( a ) holds and we set @xmath1404 , it is imediate that @xmath1693 this implies that @xmath219 is a fixed point for @xmath1169 , and therefore @xmath1694 .
the map @xmath1169 is never a conformal automorphism .
indeed , we have @xmath1695 and this implies that @xmath1630 are fixed points for @xmath1169
. the only conformal automorphisms of @xmath1642 with this property are translations @xmath1696 , with @xmath1163 , and it is obvious @xmath1169 does not have this form .
we conclude that @xmath1697 and therefore @xmath1698 .
thus @xmath128 is locally invertible at @xmath219 , and the local inverse continues @xmath239 analytically in a neighborhood of @xmath1160 .
thus we have proved ( 5 ) , the continuity of @xmath239 at @xmath1160 , as well as assertion ( 3 ) in case ( a ) .
assume now that ( b ) holds , and that there exist two sequences @xmath1699 and @xmath1700 in @xmath1642 such that @xmath1701 , the limits @xmath1402 , @xmath1702 exist , and they are different .
choose a continuous path @xmath1703 passing through all the points @xmath1424 , and such that @xmath1704 .
it follows from our assumption that there exists an open interval @xmath1426 in @xmath1692 such that every point @xmath1428 is of the form @xmath1429 , where @xmath1430 for all @xmath336 .
moreover , @xmath1705 can be chosen so that @xmath1706 , and thus @xmath1433 approaches @xmath1434 nontangentially . since @xmath1707
we conclude that the nontangential limit of @xmath128 at @xmath1434 is @xmath1160 for almost every @xmath1428 . as @xmath128 takes values in the band @xmath1708 , which is conformally equivalent to a disk , theorem [ privalov ]
can be used to deduce that @xmath128 is identically equal to @xmath1160 .
this however is not true because @xmath1709 this contradiction shows that the limit @xmath1710 exists in case ( b ) as well .
we will show next that assertion ( 3 ) is also verified in case ( b ) .
let us note first that the point @xmath1237 can not belong to @xmath1642 in this case . if it did , we would have @xmath1711 , and we would deduce as before that @xmath128 is invertible in a neighborhood of @xmath1237 , and the local inverse continues @xmath239 , which would place us in case ( a ) instead of ( b ) .
thus @xmath1237 is in @xmath1692 .
let us assume , for definiteness , that @xmath1712 , in which case we must also have @xmath1713 .
as in the previous arguments , @xmath1169 maps each horodisk at @xmath1237 into itself .
as noted before the statement of the theorem , this implies that , with @xmath1714 and @xmath1646 , @xmath1715 is a point close @xmath1237 if @xmath443 is close to @xmath1716 , and with greater imaginary part .
it follows that @xmath1717 , and @xmath1718 .
one concludes as before that @xmath1174 .
finally , for @xmath1682 we have @xmath1719 which implies that @xmath1720 this implies assertion ( 4 ) , first in @xmath1642 , and then by continuity in the closure of the domain . as in the previous sections
, we shall apply the above theorem to prove for each probability measure @xmath63 on @xmath589 the existence of a family @xmath1243 such that @xmath1244 and @xmath1721 [ mutx2 ] let @xmath618 be a probability measure on @xmath589 , and let @xmath1722 be a real number . 1 .
there exists a probability measure @xmath1723 on @xmath589 such that @xmath1724 for @xmath607 sufficiently close to zero . 2 .
there exists an analytic self - map of the slit complex plane @xmath1725 such that @xmath1726 , @xmath1727 , @xmath1728 for all @xmath250 , and @xmath1480 for all @xmath843 .
3 . the function @xmath1138 is given by @xmath1481^{1/t},\quad z\in\mathbb c\setminus[0,+\infty),\ ] ] where the power is taken to be positive for @xmath607 .
the analytic function @xmath1729 defined by @xmath1483^{t-1},\quad z\in\mathbb c \setminus[0,+\infty),\ ] ] satisfies @xmath1482 for @xmath1730 .
consider the analytic function @xmath128 provided by the argument before theorem [ inversionx2 ] , such that @xmath1731 as @xmath1732 the function @xmath128 will be uniquely determined by the requirement that @xmath1733 observe that @xmath1734 , since @xmath1735 as it follows from the definition of @xmath1736 moreover , since @xmath1737,$ ] we conclude that @xmath1738 thus , we can apply theorem [ inversionx2 ] to @xmath128 to obtain a function @xmath239 such that @xmath1661 , @xmath1739 an argument similar to the one in the proof of theorem [ mutx1 ] shows that the function @xmath1740 will satisfy the required conditions . a regularity result similar to the ones in theorems [ regptmut+ ] and [ regmutx1 ] holds for semigroups of probability measures on @xmath72 since the proof no different from the proofs of the above mentioned theorems , we omit it . [ regmux2 ]
let @xmath63 be a probability measure on @xmath589 , and let @xmath1140 . 1 .
a point @xmath1033 satisfies @xmath1741 if and only if @xmath1742 is an atom of @xmath63 with mass @xmath1743 .
if @xmath1744 , then @xmath878 is an atom of @xmath1493 , and @xmath1745 2 . the nonatomic part of @xmath1493 is absolutely continuous , and its density is continuous except at the ( finitely many ) points @xmath28 such that @xmath1741 .
3 . the density of @xmath1493 is analytic at all points where it is different from zero .
in this chapter we improve results of muraki related to probability measures which infinitely divisible with respect to monotonic convolutions .
our main tools will be two theorems of ch .
pommerenke and n. baker , which provide solutions to the abel equation for self - maps of the upper half - plane : given an analytic function @xmath128 , we say that @xmath1746 satisfies the abel equation if there exists a constant @xmath1747 such that @xmath1748 for all @xmath121 in the domain of @xmath128 .
muraki has given in @xcite an analytic method to compute additive monotonic convolutions ( recall definition [ monot ] ) of probability measures on the real line in terms of the reciprocals of their cauchy transforms : ( for another proof of this theorem , see @xcite . ) as definition [ infdiv ] makes clear , a probability measure @xmath63 will be infinitely divisible with respect to @xmath1750 if and only if for any @xmath1321 there exists a probability measure @xmath1322 such that @xmath1751 for all @xmath241 ( recall that for a given self - map @xmath128 of a domain @xmath162 , @xmath232 denotes the @xmath336-fold composition of @xmath128 with itself : @xmath1752 ) muraki has shown that for compactly supported measures infinite divisibility of @xmath63 is equivalent to the embedability of @xmath398 into a composition semigroup , i.e. a family @xmath1753 of reciprocals of cauchy transforms of probability measures such that @xmath1754 @xmath1755 and @xmath1756 for all @xmath1757 denote by @xmath580 the right half - plane , @xmath1758 and consider an analytic function @xmath1759 such that @xmath1760 following pommerenke , we denote @xmath1761 and @xmath1762 by pick s inequality , @xmath1763 so that latexmath:[$\lim_{n\to\infty } 1 . the limit @xmath1768 , @xmath1769 exists locally uniformly , @xmath1770 and there exists a number @xmath1223 such that @xmath1771 @xmath1772 2 .
@xmath1773 if and only if @xmath1774 . in this case
@xmath1775 for all @xmath1772 3 .
assume that @xmath1776 and fix @xmath1777 .
then @xmath1778 @xmath1779 as @xmath387 and there exists @xmath1780 such that @xmath460 is injective on @xmath1781 furthermore , @xmath1782 as @xmath1783 and @xmath443 is between @xmath1784 and @xmath1785 @xmath953 one can obviously apply theorems [ pom ] and [ pombak ] to self - maps of the upper half - plane , via the transformation @xmath1794 we shall use these two theorems to prove that analytic self - maps of the upper half - plane that have the julia - carathodory derivative at infinity equal to 1 can have at most one `` square root '' with respect to composition .
consider the following two self - maps of the right half - plane : @xmath1799 @xmath1800 @xmath1772 since @xmath1801 if and only if @xmath1802 we can reformulate the proposition in terms of self - maps of the right half - plane .
so , consider @xmath128 and @xmath1067 to be self - maps of the left half - plane @xmath580 . denote @xmath1803 and let @xmath1804 we shall consider separately the cases when @xmath1776 and when @xmath1805 , corresponding to theorems [ pom ] and [ pombak ] , respectively .
assume first that @xmath1806 is bounded away from zero .
in this case @xmath1807 converges to a nonconstant function @xmath460 with the property that @xmath1808 for some real number @xmath1809 without loss of generality , assume that @xmath1810 as @xmath953 as noted after theorem [ pom ] , the sequences @xmath1786 and @xmath1811 tend either to @xmath1812 or to @xmath1629 .
since @xmath1813 the limit must be the same ; we assume for definiteness that it is @xmath1814 by theorem [ pom ] , the sequences @xmath1815 and @xmath1816 tend to one as @xmath1817 so there exists @xmath1818 such that both these sequences have all their terms at distance less than @xmath1819 from @xmath167 for @xmath1820 we shall choose @xmath1821 large enough so that @xmath1822 @xmath1823 and @xmath1824 @xmath1825 for @xmath1826 observe that , since @xmath1827 and @xmath1828 , for @xmath1829 we have @xmath1830 moreover , for @xmath1829 either @xmath1831 or @xmath1832 choose now @xmath1833 to be large enough so that @xmath460 is injective on @xmath1834 . since @xmath1835 and both @xmath1836 and @xmath1837 belong to @xmath1834 , we conclude that @xmath1838 .
this is true for all @xmath336 large enough .
consider a neighbourhood @xmath1839 of @xmath1840 .
it is clear that the nonempty open set @xmath1841 will be included in @xmath1842 , if @xmath1839 is small enough . but this will imply that for any @xmath1843 we have @xmath1844 since @xmath1845 , we conclude that @xmath1846 for all @xmath1847 and hence @xmath1798 consider now the second alternative , that is @xmath1848 we claim that @xmath1849 indeed , @xmath1850 passing to limit in the above equality gives @xmath1851 the claim follows now from the fact that @xmath1852 with the notation from theorem [ pombak ] ( ii ) , we know from @xcite that @xmath128 is injective on @xmath1853 for @xmath1854 large enough .
consider a disk @xmath1855 such that @xmath1856 since @xmath1857 uniformly on @xmath1858 for @xmath1859 large enough , @xmath1860 is a connected subset of @xmath1861 since @xmath1862 , the functions @xmath1863 are injective on @xmath1864 .
it is easy to observe that @xmath1865 and @xmath1866 thus , the sequence @xmath1867 converges to a function @xmath1868 , defined on @xmath1791 and injective on @xmath1864 .
( for details , see @xcite , page 256 . )
we have @xmath1869
the same argument used for @xmath669 shows that if we replace in the above @xmath128 by @xmath1067 we obtain a function defined on @xmath1870 which coincides with @xmath1871 on @xmath1872 ( it is trivial to observe that @xmath1873 ) .
moreover , by an argument identical to the one used in the previous case ( the case when @xmath1765 was bounded away from 0 ) , there exists an open set @xmath1874 such that @xmath1875 for all @xmath1876 indeed , @xmath1877 which is an open set .
but then @xmath1878 so that , by injectivity of @xmath1879 @xmath1880 @xmath1847 and thus , @xmath1798 in his paper @xcite , carl cowen has a different approach towards solving abel s equation .
this approach will be useful for proving that every @xmath1750-infinitely divisible probability measure @xmath63 on @xmath64 belongs to a unique semigroup @xmath1881 with respect to monotonic additive convolution . in the following
, we shall introduce the notions and results relevant for our proof . for details , we refer to @xcite .
[ fundset ] given a domain @xmath1882 and an analytic map @xmath1883 , we say that @xmath1839 is a fundamental set for @xmath598 on @xmath1884 if @xmath1839 is an open , connected , simply connected subset of @xmath1884 such that @xmath1885 and for each compact set @xmath351 in @xmath1884 , there exists @xmath1886 so that @xmath1887 [ cowen ] let @xmath1888 be analytic , not constant and not a conformal automorphism of @xmath1889 and let @xmath1890 be the denjoy - wolff point of @xmath1891 assume that @xmath1892 then there exists a fundamental set @xmath1839 for @xmath25 on @xmath124 , a domain @xmath1 , either the complex plane or the unit disk , a linear fractional transformation @xmath1417 mapping @xmath1 onto itself , and an analytic mapping @xmath1893 such that @xmath25 and @xmath84 are injective on @xmath1839 , @xmath1894 is a fundamental set for @xmath1417 on @xmath1895 , and @xmath1896 moreover , @xmath1417 is unique up to conjugation by a linear fractional transformation mapping @xmath1 onto itself , and @xmath1417 and @xmath84 depend only on @xmath1897 not on the particular fundamental set @xmath1839 .
observe that any linear fractional transformation @xmath1417 is contained in a real analytic group with respect to composition : there exists @xmath1906 such that @xmath1907 and @xmath1908 for all @xmath1909 and @xmath341 denote by @xmath208 the infinitesimal generator of the semigroup @xmath580 .
consider now a function @xmath25 as in the above theorem . fix a fundamental set @xmath1839 of @xmath25 on @xmath124 , and let @xmath1910 define @xmath1911 [ cowensemigroup ] let @xmath25 satisfy the hypotheses of theorem [ cowen ] , and let @xmath1912 be defined as above . there exists a function @xmath1913 defined for @xmath147 and @xmath1914 , complex analytic in the first argument , real analytic in the second , such that @xmath1915 and such that @xmath1916 for all @xmath1917 , @xmath1918 the function @xmath1913 is defined by @xmath1919 moreover , the function @xmath1067 , given by @xmath1920 @xmath1126 is meromorphic on @xmath1889 holomorphic on @xmath1839 , and agrees with the infinitesimal generator of the semigroup @xmath1913 on the set @xmath1921 assume that @xmath1839 satisfies the conditions of theorem [ cowen ] for @xmath25 and consider a compact set with nonempty interior @xmath1922 . then , by theorem [ cowen ] , there exists @xmath1923 so that @xmath1924 for all @xmath1925 @xmath1926 @xmath1927 but by definition @xmath1928 let @xmath1929 so that there exists @xmath1930 such that @xmath1931 we claim that @xmath1932 indeed , since @xmath1933 we have @xmath1934 and @xmath1935 this proves our claim .
we conclude that the interior of the set @xmath1936 is nonempty .
recall that the probability measure @xmath63 on @xmath64 is said to be @xmath1750-infinitely divisible if for any @xmath1321 there exists a probability measure @xmath1937 such that @xmath1938 the measure @xmath1937 will be called an @xmath1939 root of @xmath439 the following proposition generalizes the results of @xcite , proposition 5.4 , to measures without compact support . 1 .
the family of probability measures @xmath1941 can be uniquely extended to a weak*-continuous semigroup @xmath1942 with respect to monotonic additive convolution .
the @xmath1939 root of @xmath63 is unique for all @xmath341 we shall first show that there exists an appropriate fundamental set for our functions @xmath1943
, @xmath1944 let us observe that if @xmath1945 is a fundamental set for @xmath1946 on @xmath235 then @xmath1945 is a fundamental set for @xmath1947 for all @xmath1948 moreover , if @xmath1949 satisfies the conditions of theorem [ cowen ] for @xmath1946 , then it satisfies the same conditions for @xmath1950 for all @xmath1948 indeed , it is clear that @xmath1951 and thus , by the denjoy - wolff theorem ( theorem [ denjoywolff ] ) , for any compact set @xmath1952 there exists @xmath1886 , @xmath1953 such that @xmath1954 .
assume now that @xmath1955 are such that @xmath1956 then @xmath1957 since @xmath1958 we have that @xmath1959 iterating this procedure , we obtain that @xmath1960 on the other hand , observe that @xmath1946 is injective on @xmath1961 for any fundamental set @xmath1961 of @xmath398 on @xmath271 indeed , if @xmath1962 and @xmath1963 then @xmath1964 and this implies @xmath1960 fix now @xmath341 without loss of generality , we may assume that @xmath1965 @xmath1966 proposition [ sqrt ] guarantees the uniqueness of the measures @xmath1967 @xmath1944 by theorems [ pom ] and [ pombak ] , we know that there exist @xmath84 and @xmath1968 such that @xmath1969 for fixed @xmath331 , theorem [ cowen ] assures us of the uniqueness of @xmath100 if we denote @xmath1970 @xmath1971 @xmath1972 theorem [ cowensemigroup ] provides the function @xmath1973 for all @xmath120 @xmath1974 we shall find a domain on which these functions coincide with @xmath1975 @xmath1966 assume @xmath1976 then @xmath1977 for all @xmath1978 since @xmath1979 and @xmath1980 we have @xmath1981 for @xmath121 in an open subset of the upper half - plane , @xmath1978 this is true for arbitrary @xmath52 and thus we have @xmath1982 for all @xmath1983 by theorem [ cowensemigroup ] ,
@xmath1984 as @xmath1985 tends to @xmath1629 uniformly on compact subsets of @xmath1986 we conclude that @xmath1987 uniformly on compact subsets of @xmath271 to obtain @xmath1141 for some @xmath1988 consider a sequence @xmath1765 of dyadic numbers converging to @xmath1463 . by proposition [ cauchyalt ]
, the analytic function @xmath1989 provides the required measure @xmath1141 by @xmath1990 ( the independence of the limit @xmath1266 from the chosen sequence @xmath1765 follows from the fact that @xmath1984 as @xmath1985 tends to @xmath1629 ) .
this proves ( 1 ) .
part 2 is an immediate consequence of the uniqueness of the semigroup from part 1 .
similar results hold for multiplicative monotone convolution of probability measures supported on @xmath589 ( recall definition [ monot ] ) .
however , in this case , the analogue of proposition [ compsemigr ] is an immediate consequence of results of cowen and goryanov .
let us first state the analogue of theorem [ murakimonot ] : for the proof of this theorem , we refer to @xcite define @xmath1992 by @xmath1993 where @xmath1994 is defined as in the beginning of chapter 2 , section 1.2 on @xmath173 , while @xmath1995 if @xmath1996 and @xmath1997 if @xmath1998 then the function @xmath1999 is a conformal automorphism such that @xmath2000 thus , for any probability measure @xmath63 on the positive half - line , the function @xmath2001 @xmath2002 is a self - map of the unit disk that maps the interval @xmath2003 into itself .
moreover , it is trivial to see that @xmath615 belongs to a composition semigroup @xmath2004 if and only if @xmath2005 belongs to a composition semigroup @xmath2006 and the correspondence is given by @xmath2007 @xmath1102 in @xcite , goryanov shows that any analytic self - map @xmath1746 of the unit disk preserving the interval @xmath2003 which is the @xmath336-iteration of an analytic self - map @xmath2008 of @xmath124 satisfying @xmath2009 can be embedded in a one - parameter semigroup with respect to composition ( this fact can be also derived from theorem 5.1 and its corollary from @xcite ) .
this , of course , provides the equivalent of proposition [ compsemigr ] for multiplicative monotone convolution on @xmath72 , _ one - parameter semigroups of analytic functions and a compositional analogue of infinite divisibility _ , proceedings of the institute of applied mathematics and mechanics , vol .
5 , tr . inst .
prikl . mat .
mekh . , * 5 * , ( 2000 ) , 4457 , g. julia , _
extension dun lemme de schwarz _ , acta math .
* 42*(1920 ) , 349355 . | we study convolutions that arise from noncommutative probability theory . in the case of free convolutions , we prove that the absolutely continuous part , with respect to the lebesgue measure , of the free convolution of two probability measures is always nonzero , and has a locally analytic density . under slightly less general hypotheses , we show that the singular continuous part of the free additive convolution of two probability measures is zero .
we also show that any probability measure belongs to a partially defined one - parameter free convolution semigroup . in this context
, we find a connection between free and boolean infinite divisibility . for monotonic convolutions , we prove that any infinitely divisible probability measure with respect to monotonic additive or multiplicative convolution belongs to a one - parameter semigroup with respect to the corresponding convolution .
our main tools are several subordination and inversion theorems for analytic functions defined in the upper half - plane .
we prove these theorems using the theory of denjoy - wolff fixed points .
lv first of all , my deepest thanks go to professor hari bercovici . without his teaching and
constant , careful , and patient guidance , nothing of my phd , including this thesis , could have been accomplished .
i am deeply grateful also to professor zhenghan wang .
i have learned a lot from him , and his help and support ( including financial , through an raship ) have been determinant for the completion of my work towards a phd .
i regret very much i was nt able to do more !
i thank professors ayelet lindenstrauss and scott w. brown for their active participation in my phd committee .
i have learned very much from many faculty members of the iu department of mathematics , either during courses , or in private discussions . among them
, i would like to mention professors steen andersson , eric bedford , hari bercovici , michael larsen , ayelet lindenstrauss , charles livingston , russel lyons , kevin pilgrim , and zhenghan wang .
i also thank misty cummings for all the help she gave me with the so - many bureaucratic problems .
special thanks are due to professor erban strtil , who first introduced me to the realm of advanced mathematics , and whose help , trust , and guidance made possible for me to become a student at iu .
i also thank professor george dinc for his help and teaching .
finally , i thank my parents and my grandparents , to whom this thesis is dedicated , and all my friends . |
optical frequency combs have been very useful scientific and technological tools in a wide range of applications such as optical clocks , precision spectroscopy , low phase noise microwave generation and optical communications . the general approach for producing frequency combs
is based on mode - locking in lasers .
an alternative approach has been recently demonstrated in a silica monolithic toroidal microresonator @xcite , where cavity enhanced four - wave mixing ( fwm ) occurs . as a result , this type of comb using the third - order susceptibility in resonators is usually referred to as kerr optical frequency comb . the emergence of such combs provides a compact and energy efficient solution .
therefore , extensive amount of works in both theories and experiments have been devoted to this field .
for example , the understanding of the comb formation is now very elaborate , and involves both coupled - mode and spatiotemporal models @xcite ; various applications have also been experimentally explored ranging from low phase noise microwave oscillations @xcite , ultra - short pulse generation @xcite , and optical communications @xcite . compared with kerr comb generation platforms based on chip - scale waveguide racetrack resonators @xcite ,
the mechanically polished disk resonators have a much wider range of material choices and can feature comb generation with very low pump power in the sub - mw level @xcite , which results from the ultra - high quality ( @xmath5 ) factors and small mode volumes in these wgm resonators . although kerr frequency combs in fluoride wgm resonators have been demonstrated in the telecommunication window and recently at @xmath6 in the mid - ir regime @xcite , there is still not a systematic study on the optimal choice of materials and the sizes of resonators .
moreover , anomalous @xmath1 is generally desirable for comb generation and the spanning of kerr combs is also strongly dependent on the dispersion profile .
recently , an analytical approximation for the dispersion of wgms in the disk geometry has been derived by two different groups , showing a good agreement with finite - element simulations and high - precision free spectral range ( fsr ) measurements @xcite .
it enables an accurate study of the impact of geometry on the @xmath1 . on the other hand ,
barium fluoride ( baf@xmath7 ) with a good transmission range covering the whole mid - ir window has been recently shown to be capable of supporting @xmath5 factors above @xmath0 @xcite , and this result broadens the choice of crystalline candidates for kerr comb generation . in this article , we report the study of material dispersion for different ir and mid - ir optical materials using sellmeier equations .
we point out that fluoride crystalline materials generally have significantly flatter material dispersion profile than other materials .
a systematic and theoretical investigation of the impact of resonator geometry and wgm indices on the @xmath1 is carried out , showing that the major radii and the radial wgm indices are key parameters to consider for @xmath1 tailoring in wgm resonators .
the impact of geometry on @xmath1 is also experimentally evidenced in an experiment showing how primary kerr combs with significantly different multiplicity can be generated with the same mgf@xmath7 resonator , but pumped in wgms with different radial orders .
we also investigate theoretically mgf@xmath7 and baf@xmath7 platforms for potential broadband comb generations in the telecom and mid - ir regimes .
is the primary parametric gain peak spacing from the pump frequency @xmath8.,width=340 ] as far as kerr frequency comb generation is concerned , the primary step has been the search of the optimal materials .
although the on - chip ring resonator as comb generation platforms is much more compact , mechanically polished high @xmath5 wgm crystalline resonators are still of great interest , due to the flexible choice of materials and ultra - high @xmath5 factors leading to power efficient operation . in these axi - symmetric disk resonators ,
the rim part can be treated as a toroidal boundary with the main radius @xmath9 and the curvature radius @xmath10 , as illustrated in fig .
[ fig : schematic ] ( a ) .
figure [ fig : schematic ] ( b ) gives a typical schematic drawing of kerr comb generation .
a single frequency continuous - wave ( cw ) pump laser can be coupled into the wgmr through a fiber taper or a prism @xcite . under certain conditions that have been analyzed in refs .
@xcite , the built - up intracavity light leads to the modulation instability ( mi ) gain with offset @xmath11 from the pump frequency @xmath8 .
the parametric fwm then creates the first two sidebands where wgms with single or multiple free spectral range ( @xmath12 ) relative to the pump mode meet the mi gain .
subsequent parametric process creates a comb with multiple - fsr spacing , generally referred to as the _ primary comb_. depending on the dispersion and pump condition , broadband kerr combs with single - fsr spacing and thousands of frequency lines can be further produced . as kerr comb arises from mi
gain , it thus prefers an anomalous dispersion profile similar to mi gain in optical fibers .
in addition , the mi theory in kerr comb generation predicts that the offset @xmath11 of the parametric gain peak frequency scales with the dispersion following @xmath13 @xcite .
hence , weak dispersion is generally favorable for broadband kerr comb generation .
it should be noted that the primary kerr comb shown in fig .
[ fig : schematic ] ( b ) also yields rolls ( or turing patterns ) in the spatial domain @xcite .
at this date , kerr optical frequency combs have been reported on wgm resonators made of fused silica , magnesium fluoride , calcium fluoride ( caf@xmath7 ) and sapphire @xcite , which are all capable of featuring @xmath5 factors above @xmath0 . recently
, such high @xmath5 factors have also been demonstrated on barium fluoride @xcite .
we thereby take into account this material with others for the investigation of the material dispersion ( @xmath14 ) using their sellmeier equations @xcite .
the @xmath14 is usually characterized by group delay dispersion ( in ps / km / nm ) : @xmath15 where @xmath16 is the wavelength , @xmath17 is the speed of light in vacuum , @xmath18 is the refractive index . ) , sapphire , mgf@xmath7 , caf@xmath7 and baf@xmath7 .
dashed lines designate the corresponding @xmath19 : @xmath20 , @xmath21 @xmath22 , @xmath23 and @xmath3 , respectively .
the vertical blue and brown zones highlight the telecommunication c - band and mid - ir windows .
note that the @xmath14 profile of mgf@xmath7 investigated here is derived for the ordinary ray .
the extraordinary one has very similar profile with a slightly different @xmath2 at @xmath24.,width=340 ] figure [ fig : dmaterial ] displays the corresponding material @xmath14 as a function of wavelength from 0.8 to 6 @xmath25 .
it should be noted that the dispersion is anomalous when @xmath1 is greater than zero .
a broadband comb generation will require a small @xmath1 value in this regime . on the other hand , a @xmath1 that is too large will also make kerr comb generation difficult , as the corresponding parametric gain could be too close to the pump frequency and do not meet any wgms ( the phase matching condition will therefore never be fulfilled ) .
one can also see that fluoride materials have flatter dispersion profiles than the others .
the corresponding @xmath2 of these materials are listed in table [ tab : material ] .
also shown are some optical characteristics of these materials @xcite .
[ b ] .characteristics of bulk fused silica , sapphire , mgf@xmath7 , caf@xmath7 , baf@xmath7 at @xmath26 for kerr comb generation^a^ [ cols="<,<,<,<,<,<",options="header " , ]
in conclusion , we have investigated the material dispersion profiles of different optical materials that support wgms with @xmath5 factors above @xmath0 .
we have studied the effect of geometry dispersion on the total @xmath1 of wgm disk - resonators .
this analysis has enabled us to demonstrate that the major radii of wgm resonators and the radial order indices are key parameters for dispersion tailoring . in particular , we have shown that the dispersion shift induced by selecting different radial families of modes in the same resonator allows for the generation of versatile combs .
barium fluoride could benefit from this feature and it offers the best dispersion profile in the mid - ir spectral range .
we expect this work to facilitate the efficient generation of kerr optical frequency combs in the telecom and mid - ir regimes .
the authors acknowledge financial support from the european research council ( erc ) through the projects nextphase and versyt .
they also acknowledge financial support from the _ centre national detudes spatiales _ ( cnes ) through the project shyro , from the _ rgion de franche - comt _ , and from the labex action . | optical whispering gallery mode ( wgm ) resonators have been very attracting platforms for versatile kerr frequency comb generations .
we report a systematic study on the material dispersion of various optical materials that are capable of supporting quality factors above @xmath0 . using an analytical approximation of
wgm resonant frequencies in disk resonators , we investigate the effect of the geometry and transverse mode order on the total group - velocity dispersion ( @xmath1 ) .
we demonstrate that the major radii and the radial mode indices play an important role in tailoring the @xmath1 of wgm resonators .
in particular , our study shows that in wgm disk - resonators , the polar families of modes have very similar @xmath1 , while the radial families of modes feature dispersion values that can differ by up to several orders of magnitude .
the effect of these giant dispersion shifts are experimentally evidenced in kerr comb generation with magnesium fluoride . from a more general perspective
, this critical feature enables to push the zero - dispersion wavelength of fluorite crystals towards the mid - infrared ( mid - ir ) range , thereby allowing for efficient kerr comb generation in that spectral range .
we show that barium fluoride is the most interesting crystal in this regard , due to its zero dispersion wavelength ( @xmath2 ) at @xmath3 and an optimal dispersion profile in the mid - ir regime .
we expect our results to facilitate the design of different platforms for kerr frequency comb generations in both telecommunication and mid - ir spectral ranges . 10 p. delhaye , a. schliesser , o. arcizet , t. wilken , r. holzwarth , and t. kippenberg , `` optical frequency comb generation from a monolithic microresonator , '' nature * 450 * , 12141217 ( 2007 ) .
y. k. chembo , d. v. strekalov , and n. yu , `` spectrum and dynamics of optical frequency combs generated with monolithic whispering gallery mode resonators , '' phys .
rev .
lett . * 104 * , 103902 ( 2010 ) .
y. k. chembo and n. yu , `` modal expansion approach to optical - frequency - comb generation with monolithic whispering - gallery - mode resonators , '' phys .
rev .
a * 82 * , 033801 ( 2010 ) .
a. b. matsko , a. a. savchenkov , w. liang , v. s. ilchenko , d. seidel , and l. maleki , `` mode - locked kerr frequency combs , '' opt . lett . *
36 * , 28452847 ( 2011 ) .
y. k. chembo and c. r. menyuk , `` spatiotemporal lugiato - lefever formalism for kerr - comb generation in whispering - gallery - mode resonators , '' phys .
rev .
a * 87 * , 053852 ( 2013 ) .
s. coen , h. g. randle , t. sylvestre , and m. erkintalo , `` modeling of octave - spanning kerr frequency combs using a generalized mean - field lugiato - lefever model , '' opt
. lett . * 38 * , 3739 ( 2013 ) . c. godey , i. v. balakireva , a. coillet , and y. k. chembo , `` stability analysis of the spatiotemporal lugiato - lefever model for kerr optical frequency combs in the anomalous and normal dispersion regimes , '' phys .
rev . a * 89 * , 063814 ( 2014 ) .
j. li , h. lee , t. chen , and k. j. vahala , `` low - pump - power , low - phase - noise , and microwave to millimeter - wave repetition rate operation in microcombs , '' phys .
rev .
lett . * 109 * , 233901 ( 2012 ) .
a. a. savchenkov , d. eliyahu , w. liang , v. s. ilchenko , j. byrd , a. b. matsko , d. seidel , and l. maleki , `` stabilization of a kerr frequency comb oscillator , '' opt . lett . * 38 * , 26362639 ( 2013 ) .
k. saha , y. okawachi , b. shim , j. s. levy , r. salem , a. r. johnson , m. a. foster , m. r. e. lamont , m. lipson , and a. l. gaeta , `` modelocking and femtosecond pulse generation in chip - based frequency combs , '' opt .
express * 21 * , 13351343 ( 2013 ) .
t. herr , v. brasch , j. jost , c. wang , n. kondratiev , m. gorodetsky , and t. kippenberg , `` temporal solitons in optical microresonators , '' nat .
photonics * 8 * , 145152 ( 2014 )
. j. pfeifle , v. brasch , m. lauermann , y. yu , d. wegner , t. herr , k. hartinger , p. schindler , j. li , d. hillerkuss , r. schmogrow , c. weimann , r. holzwarth , w. freude , j. leuthold , t. j. kippenberg , and c. koos , `` coherent terabit communications with microresonator kerr frequency combs , '' nat .
photonics * 8 * , 375380 ( 2014 ) .
l. razzari , d. duchesne , m. ferrera , r. morandotti , s. chu , b. little , and d. moss , `` cmos - compatible integrated optical hyper - parametric oscillator , '' nat .
photonics * 4 * , 4145 ( 2010 ) . c. wang , t. herr , p. delhaye , a. schliesser , j. hofer , r. holzwarth , t. hnsch , n. picqu , and t. kippenberg , `` mid - infrared optical frequency combs at 2.5 @xmath4 m based on crystalline microresonators , '' nat .
commun . * 4 * , 1345 ( 2013 ) .
i. breunig , b. sturman , f. sedlmeir , h. g. l. schwefel , and k. buse , `` whispering gallery modes at the rim of an axisymmetric optical resonator : analytical versus numerical description and comparison with experiment , '' opt .
express * 21 * , 3068330692 ( 2013 ) .
y. a. demchenko and m. l. gorodetsky , `` analytical estimates of eigenfrequencies , dispersion , and field distribution in whispering gallery resonators , '' j. opt .
soc .
am .
b * 30 * , 30563063 ( 2013 ) .
g. lin , s. diallo , r. henriet , m. jacquot , and y. k. chembo , `` barium fluoride whispering - gallery mode disk - resonator with one billion quality - factor , '' opt .
lett . * 39 * , 60096012 ( 2014 ) .
m. l. gorodetsky and v. s. ilchenko , `` optical microsphere resonators : optimal coupling to high - q whispering - gallery modes , '' j. opt .
. am .
b * 16 * , 147154 ( 1999 ) .
a. coillet , i. balakireva , r. henriet , k. saleh , l. larger , j. dudley , c. menyuk , and y. chembo , `` azimuthal turing patterns , bright and dark cavity solitons in kerr combs generated with whispering - gallery - mode resonators , '' ieee photon .
j. * 5 * , 61004096100409 ( 2013 ) .
a. a. savchenkov , a. b. matsko , v. s. ilchenko , i. solomatine , d. seidel , and l. maleki , `` tunable optical frequency comb with a crystalline whispering gallery mode resonator , '' phys .
rev .
lett .
* 101 * , 093902 ( 2008 ) .
a. savchenkov , a. matsko , w. liang , v. ilchenko , d. seidel , and l. maleki , `` kerr combs with selectable central frequency , '' nat .
photonics * 5 * , 293296 ( 2011 ) .
i. s. grudinin , l. baumgartel , and n. yu , `` frequency comb from a microresonator with engineered spectrum , '' opt . express * 20 * , 66046609 ( 2012 ) .
i. s. grudinin , l. baumgartel , and n. yu , `` impact of cavity spectrum on span in microresonator frequency combs , '' opt .
express * 21 * , 2692926935 ( 2013 ) .
v. s. ilchenko , a. a. savchenkov , a. b. matsko , and l. maleki , `` generation of kerr frequency combs in a sapphire whispering gallery mode microresonator , '' opt .
eng . * 53 * , 122607 ( 2014 ) .
d. milam , m. j. weber , and a. glass , `` nonlinear refractive index of fluoride crystals , '' appl .
. lett . * 31 * , 822825 ( 1977 ) .
m. j. weber , _ handbook of optical materials _ ( crc , 2003 ) .
g. lin , y. candela , o. tillement , z. cai , v. lefvre - seguin , and j. hare , `` thermal bistability - based method for real - time optimization of ultralow - threshold whispering gallery mode microlasers , '' opt .
lett . * 37 * , 51935195 ( 2012 ) . g. lin and n. yu , `` continuous tuning of double resonance - enhanced second harmonic generation in a dispersive dielectric resonator , '' opt .
express * 22 * , 557562 ( 2014 ) .
w. liang , v. s. ilchenko , a. a. savchenkov , a. b. matsko , d. seidel , and l. maleki , `` whispering - gallery - mode - resonator - based ultranarrow linewidth external - cavity semiconductor laser , '' opt . lett .
* 35 * , 28222824 ( 2010 ) .
a. c. turner , c. manolatou , b. s. schmidt , m. lipson , m. a. foster , j. e. sharping , and a. l. gaeta , `` tailored anomalous group - velocity dispersion in silicon channel waveguides , '' opt .
express * 14 * , 43574362 ( 2006 ) .
d. risti , m. mazzola , a. chiappini , a. rasoloniaina , p. fron , r. ramponi , g. c. righini , g. cibiel , m. ivanda , and m. ferrari , `` tailoring of the free spectral range and geometrical cavity dispersion of a microsphere by a coating layer , '' opt . lett . * 39 * , 51735176 ( 2014 ) .
g. lin , b. qian , f. oruevi , y. candela , j .- b .
jager , z. cai , v. lefvre - seguin , and j. hare , `` excitation mapping of whispering gallery modes in silica microcavities , '' opt .
lett . * 35 * , 583585 ( 2010 ) .
s. schiller , and r. l. byer , , `` high - resolution spectroscopy of whispering gallery modes in large dielectric spheres , '' opt . lett . * 16 * , 11381140 ( 1991 ) .
g. schunk , j. u. frst , m. frtsch , d. v. strekalov , u. vogl , f. sedlmeir , h. g. l. schwefel , g. leuchs , and c. marquardt , `` identifying modes of large whispering - gallery mode resonators from the spectrum and emission pattern , '' opt .
express * 22 * , 3079530806 ( 2014 ) .
o. arcizet , a. schliesser , p. delhaye , r. holzwarth , and t. j. kippenberg , `` optical frequency comb generation in monolithic microresonators , '' in _ practical applications of microresonators in optics and photonics _ ,
ed .
b. matsko , ( crc , 2009 ) , ch
. 11 .
j. li , h. lee , k. y. yang , and k. j. vahala , `` optical frequency comb generation in monolithic microresonators , '' opt .
express * 20 * , 2633726344 ( 2012 ) . |
let @xmath10 be @xmath2-dimensional complex - valued vectors .
we denote their inner product as @xmath11 now suppose we have a directed graph @xmath12 .
let us associate a vector @xmath13 with each vertex @xmath4 , and consider the product over all edges @xmath6 of the inner products of the corresponding vectors : @xmath14 for instance , for the graph in figure [ fig : example ] this product is @xmath15 the expectation of this product , where each @xmath5 is chosen independently and uniformly from the set of vectors in @xmath16 of norm @xmath8 , is a type of moment , where each @xmath5 appears with order @xmath17 .
it is a function of the graph @xmath1 and the dimension @xmath2 , which we denote as follows : @xmath18 .,width=172 ] a simple observation is that @xmath3 is zero unless @xmath1 is eulerian that is , unless @xmath19 for each vertex @xmath4 .
since @xmath5 appears in the product @xmath20 times unconjugated and @xmath21 times conjugated , multiplying @xmath5 by @xmath22 multiplies @xmath3 by @xmath23 . but
multiplying by a phase preserves the uniform measure , so the expectation is zero if @xmath24 for any @xmath4 .
so , let us suppose that @xmath1 is eulerian . in that case , what is @xmath3 ?
does it have a combinatorial interpretation ? and
how difficult is it to calculate ?
our main result is this : [ thm : main ] for any @xmath25 , computing @xmath3 , given @xmath1 as input , is @xmath0-hard under turing reductions .
if we extend @xmath0 to rational functions in the natural way , then we can replace @xmath0-hardness in this theorem with @xmath0-completeness .
our proof is very simple ; we show that @xmath3 is essentially identical to an existing graph polynomial , which is known to be @xmath0-hard to compute . along the way
, we will meet some nice combinatorics , and glancingly employ the representation theory of the unitary and orthogonal groups .
a _ circuit partition _ of @xmath1 is a partition of @xmath1 s edges into circuits
. let @xmath26 denote the number of circuit partitions containing @xmath27 circuits ; for instance , @xmath28 is the number of eulerian circuits .
the _ circuit partition polynomial _
@xmath29 is the generating function @xmath30 for instance , for the graph in figure [ fig : example ] we have @xmath31 .
this polynomial was first studied by martin @xcite , with a slightly different parametrization ; see also @xcite .
now consider the following theorem .
[ thm : q - j ] for any eulerian directed graph @xmath12 , @xmath32 where @xmath33 denotes @xmath19 .
given a vector @xmath34 and an integer @xmath35 , the outer product of @xmath36 with itself is a tensor of rank @xmath37 , or equivalently a linear operator on @xmath38 : @xmath39 in terms of indices , we can write @xmath40 then @xmath41 is a contraction of the product of these tensors , where upper and lower indices correspond to incoming and outgoing edges respectively .
for instance , for the graph in figure [ fig : example ] we can rewrite the product [ eq : prod - example ] as @xmath42 here we use the einstein summation convention , where any index which appears once above and once below is automatically summed from @xmath8 to @xmath2 .
now , since the @xmath5 are independent for different @xmath4 , we can compute @xmath3 by taking the expectation over each @xmath5 separately .
this gives a contraction of the tensors @xmath43 where @xmath44 , over all @xmath4 . in order to calculate @xmath45
, we introduce some notation .
let @xmath46 denote the symmetric group on @xmath35 elements .
we identify a permutation @xmath47 with the linear operator on @xmath38 which permutes the @xmath35 factors in the tensor product .
that is , @xmath48 or , using indices , @xmath49 where @xmath50 is the kronecker delta operator , @xmath51 if @xmath52 and @xmath53 if @xmath54 .
diagrammatically , @xmath55 is a gadget with @xmath35 incoming edges and @xmath35 outgoing edges , wired to each other according to the permutation @xmath55 .
we have the following lemma : [ lem : xd ] with @xmath45 defined as in , if @xmath56 is uniform in the set of vectors in @xmath16 of norm @xmath8 , then @xmath57 first , @xmath45 is a member of the commutant of the group @xmath58 of @xmath59 unitary matrices , since these preserve the uniform measure .
that is @xmath45 commutes with @xmath60 for any @xmath61 . by schur duality ,
the commutant is a quotient of the group algebra @xmath62 $ ] ; namely , the image of @xmath62 $ ] under the identification above .
thus @xmath45 is a superposition of permutations , @xmath63 .
we also have @xmath64 for any @xmath55 .
thus @xmath45 is proportional to the uniform superposition on @xmath46 , or equivalently the projection operator @xmath65 onto the totally symmetric subspace @xmath66 of @xmath38 . since @xmath67 while @xmath68 , we have @xmath69 .
finally , @xmath70 is the number of ways to label the @xmath35 factors of the tensor product with basis vectors @xmath71 in nondecreasing order or , for aficionados , the number of semistandard tableaux with one row of length @xmath35 and content ranging from @xmath8 to @xmath2 .
this gives @xmath72 .
to illustrate some ideas that will recur in the next section , we give an alternate proof .
first , note that @xmath73 is the number of ways to label each of @xmath55 s cycles with a basis vector ranging from @xmath8 to @xmath2 , or @xmath74 where @xmath75 denotes the number of cycles ( including fixed points ) .
thus @xmath76 to compute this generating function , we use the fact that each permutation @xmath47 appears once in the following product , where @xmath8 denotes the identity permutation , and @xmath77 denotes the transposition of the @xmath78th and @xmath79th object : @xmath80 this product works by describing a permutation @xmath81 of @xmath27 objects inductively as a permutation @xmath82 of the first @xmath83 objects , composed either with the identity or with a transposition swapping the @xmath27th object with one of the previous @xmath83 .
if we apply the identity , then the @xmath27th object is a fixed point , and @xmath84 , gaining a factor of @xmath2 in ; but if we apply a transposition , then @xmath85 .
thus becomes @xmath86 comparing traces again gives .
all that remains is to interpret the operators @xmath87 , and their contraction , diagrammatically .
lemma [ lem : xd ] tells us that , for each vertex @xmath4 of @xmath1 , taking the expectation over @xmath5 converts it to a sum over all @xmath88 ways to wire the incoming edges to the outgoing edges . but doing this at each vertex gives us a sum over all cycle partitions of @xmath1 .
contracting these tensors gives the number of ways to label each cycle in a each partition with a basis vector ranging from @xmath8 to @xmath2 , so each cycle contributes a factor of @xmath2 .
along with the scaling factor in , this completes the proof .
next we show that the cycle partition polynomial is @xmath0-hard . to our knowledge
, the following theorem first appeared in @xcite ; we prove it here for completeness .
[ thm : nump ] for any fixed @xmath89 , computing @xmath29 from @xmath1 is @xmath0-hard under turing reductions .
recall that the _ tutte polynomial _ of an undirected graph @xmath12 can be written as a sum over all subsets @xmath90 of @xmath91 , @xmath92 here @xmath93 denotes the number of connected components in @xmath1 .
similarly , @xmath94 denotes the number of connected components in the spanning subgraph @xmath95 , including isolated vertices .
when @xmath96 , we have @xmath97 where @xmath98 is the total excess of the components of @xmath90 , i.e. , the number of edges that would have to be removed to make each one a tree .
( black ) and its oriented medial graph @xmath99 ( gray).,width=288 ] if @xmath1 is planar , then we can define a directed medial graph @xmath99 as in figure [ fig : medial ] .
each vertex of @xmath99 corresponds to an edge of @xmath1 , edges of @xmath99 correspond to shared vertices in @xmath1 , and we orient the edges of @xmath99 so that they go counterclockwise around the faces of @xmath1 .
each vertex of @xmath99 has @xmath100 , so @xmath99 is eulerian .
the following identity is due to martin @xcite ; see also @xcite , or @xcite for a review .
@xmath101 we prove this using a one - to - one correspondence between subsets @xmath102 and circuit partitions of @xmath99 .
let @xmath4 be a vertex of @xmath99 , corresponding to an edge @xmath103 of @xmath1 .
then the circuit partition connects each of @xmath4 s incoming edge to the outgoing edge on the same side of @xmath103 if @xmath104 , and crosses over to the other side if @xmath105 .
it is easy to prove by induction that the number of circuits is then @xmath106 , in which case yields .
the theorem then follows from the fact , proven by vertigan @xcite , that the tutte polynomial for planar graphs is @xmath0-hard under turing reductions , except on the hyperbolas @xmath107 or when @xmath108 where @xmath109 .
thus computing @xmath29 for any @xmath89 is @xmath0-hard , even in the special case where @xmath1 is planar and where every vertex has @xmath110 .
we can also consider the case where the @xmath5 are real - valued , and are chosen uniformly from the set of vectors in @xmath111 of norm @xmath8 . in this case , the inner product @xmath7 becomes symmetric , so the graph @xmath1 becomes undirected .
we might then expect @xmath3 to be related to the circuit partition polynomial for undirected circuits , and indeed this is the case .
we again wish to compute the tensor @xmath112 .
first , let @xmath113 denote the set of perfect matchings of @xmath37 objects ; note that @xmath114 we can identify each matching @xmath115 with a linear operator on @xmath116 , where the first @xmath35 objects correspond to upper indices , and the last @xmath35 correspond to lower indices .
however , in addition to permutations that wire upper indices to lower ones with a bipartite matching , we now also have `` cups '' and `` caps '' that wire two upper indices , or two lower indices , to each other . for instance , if @xmath117 then @xmath113 includes three operators , corresponding to the three perfect matchings of @xmath118 objects : @xmath119{identity}}}\ , , \quad \delta^{\alpha_1}_{\beta_2 } \delta^{\alpha_2}_{\beta_1 } = { \raisebox{-7pt}{\includegraphics[height=18pt]{exchange}}}\ , , \quad \mbox{and } \quad \delta^{\alpha_1,\alpha_2 } \delta_{\beta_1,\beta_2 } = { \raisebox{-7pt}{\includegraphics[height=18pt]{cupcap}}}\ , .\ ] ] the first two of these operators correspond to the identity permutation and the transposition @xmath120 respectively , as in the previous section .
the third one is a _
cupcap _ ; it is the outer product of the vector @xmath121 with itself , where @xmath122 denotes the @xmath78th basis vector in @xmath111 .
we denote it @xmath123 , and more generally @xmath124 .
now , in the real - valued case , lemma [ lem : xd ] becomes the following : [ lem : xd - real ] if @xmath56 is uniform in the set of vectors in @xmath111 of norm @xmath8 , then @xmath125 where @xmath126 if @xmath127 is even , and @xmath128 if @xmath127 is odd .
analogous to the complex case , @xmath45 is a member of the commutant of the group @xmath129 of @xmath59 orthogonal matrices , since these preserve the uniform measure .
that is , @xmath45 commutes with @xmath130 for any @xmath131 .
the commutant of @xmath129 is the _
brauer algebra _ ; namely , the algebra consisting of linear combinations of the operators @xmath115 .
thus @xmath45 is of the form @xmath132 .
in addition to being fixed under permutations as in the complex case , @xmath45 is also fixed under partial transposes , which switch some upper indices with some lower ones .
thus @xmath45 is proportional to the uniform superposition @xmath133 . to find the constant of proportionality
, we again compare traces . as in the case of permutations ,
the trace of an operator @xmath115 is @xmath134 , where @xmath135 is the number of loops in the diagram resulting from joining the upper indices to the lower ones .
for instance , for the operators in , we have @xmath136 , @xmath137 , and @xmath138 .
thus we wish to calculate @xmath139 we can write @xmath140 as a product , analogous to : @xmath141 this product describes a matching @xmath142 of @xmath143 objects inductively as a matching @xmath144 of the first @xmath145 objects , composed either with the identity , or with a transposition or cupcap connecting the @xmath27th upper object with the @xmath78th lower one and the @xmath27th lower object with the @xmath78th upper one , or vice versa .
if we apply the identity , then the @xmath27th upper object is matched to the @xmath27th lower one , and @xmath146 , gaining a factor of @xmath2 in ; but if we apply a transposition or cupcap , then @xmath147 .
thus becomes @xmath148 we again have @xmath67 , and comparing traces gives .
as before , @xmath3 is a contraction of the tensors @xmath45 .
however , now @xmath1 is undirected , with no distinction between incoming and outgoing edges , so at each vertex of degree @xmath33 the appropriate tensor is @xmath149 .
applying lemma [ lem : xd - real ] to each @xmath4 sums over all the ways to match @xmath4 s edges with each other , and hence sums over all possible partitions of @xmath1 s edges into undirected cycles .
the trace of the resulting diagram is again the number of ways to label each cycle with a basis vector .
so , if define a polynomial @xmath150 as @xmath151 , where @xmath26 is the number of partitions with @xmath27 cycles , then theorem [ thm : q - j ] becomes [ thm : q - j - real ] for any undirected graph @xmath12 where every vertex has even degree , if we define @xmath3 by selecting the @xmath5 independently and uniformly from the set of vectors in @xmath111 with norm @xmath8 , then @xmath152 to our knowledge , the computational complexity of @xmath150 is open , although it seems likely that it is also @xmath0-hard .
our results above assume that each @xmath5 is chosen uniformly from the set of vectors in @xmath16 or @xmath111 of norm @xmath8 .
another natural measure would be to choose each component of @xmath5 independently from the gaussian distribution with variance @xmath153 , so that @xmath154=1 $ ] . for vectors in @xmath16 ,
the probability density of the norm @xmath155 is then @xmath156 compared to the case where @xmath157 , each @xmath5 contributes scaling factor of @xmath158 to the product .
the even moments of are @xmath159 = \frac{(d+k-1)!}{k^d ( k-1 ) ! } \
, , \ ] ] so in the gaussian distribution becomes @xmath160 where @xmath161 denotes the number of edges .
we could also have derived this directly from the gaussian analog of lemma [ lem : xd ] .
if @xmath56 is chosen according to the gaussian distribution on @xmath16 , and we again let @xmath45 denote @xmath162 , then @xmath163 similarly , in the real - valued case , if we choose each component of @xmath164 from the gaussian distribution on @xmath165 with variance @xmath153 , then becomes @xmath166 since @xmath167 both and are consequences of wick s theorem @xcite , that if @xmath168 obey a multivariate gaussian distribution with mean zero , then @xmath169 = \sum_{\mu \in m_t } \prod_{(i , j ) \in \mu } { \mathop\mathrm{exp}}[x_i x_j ] \ , .\ ] ] we are grateful to piotr niady for teaching us the sum , and to jon yard for introducing us to the brauer algebra .
this work was supported by the nsf under grant ccf-0829931 , and by the dto under contract w911nf-04-r-0009 . | we present a simple , natural @xmath0-complete problem .
let @xmath1 be a directed graph , and let @xmath2 be a positive integer .
we define @xmath3 as follows . at each vertex @xmath4
, we place a @xmath2-dimensional complex vector @xmath5 . we take the product , over all edges @xmath6 , of the inner product @xmath7 .
finally , @xmath3 is the expectation of this product , where the @xmath5 are chosen uniformly and independently from all vectors of norm @xmath8 ( or , alternately , from the gaussian distribution ) .
we show that @xmath3 is proportional to @xmath1 s cycle partition polynomial , and therefore that it is @xmath0-complete for any @xmath9 . |
this work is funded by ` agence nationale de la recherche ' under grant anr-08-blan-0093 - 01 .
+ 00 b. i. abelev _ et al . _ [ the star collaboration ] , phys .
c * 75 * ( 2007 ) 054906 .
s. huang [ phenix collaboration ] , j. phys .
g * 35 * ( 2008 ) 104105 .
n. borghini and j. y. ollitrault , phys .
b * 642 * ( 2006 ) 227 b. alver _ et al .
_ , phys .
c * 77 * ( 2008 ) 014906 .
m. miller and r. snellings , arxiv : nucl - ex/0312008 .
r. s. bhalerao , n. borghini and j. y. ollitrault , nucl .
a * 727 * ( 2003 ) 373 j. y. ollitrault , a. m. poskanzer and s. a. voloshin , phys
. rev .
c * 80 * ( 2009 ) 014904 . c. gombeaud and j. y. ollitrault , arxiv:0907.4664 [ nucl - th ] .
b. i. abelev et al .
[ star collaboration ] , phys .
c * 77 * ( 2008 ) 054901 j. adams et al .
[ star collaboration ] , phys .
c * 72 * ( 2005 ) 014904 h. j. drescher , a. dumitru , c. gombeaud and j. y. ollitrault , phys .
c * 76 * ( 2007 ) 024905 .
r. s. bhalerao , j. p. blaizot , n. borghini and j. y. ollitrault , phys .
b * 627 * ( 2005 ) 49 . | the fourth harmonic of the azimuthal distribution of particles @xmath0 has been measured for au - au collisions at the relativistic heavy ion collider ( rhic ) .
the centrality dependence of @xmath0 does not agree with the prediction from hydrodynamics .
in particular , the ratio @xmath1 , where @xmath2 denotes the second harmonic of the azimuthal distribution of particles , is significantly larger than predicted by hydrodynamics .
we argue that this discrepancy is mostly due to elliptic flow ( @xmath2 ) fluctuations .
we evaluate these fluctuations on the basis of a monte carlo glauber calculation .
the effect of deviations from local thermal equilibrium is also studied , but appears to be only a small correction .
combining these two effects allows us to reproduce experimental data for peripheral and midcentral collisions .
however , we are unable to explain the large magnitude of @xmath1 observed for the most central collisions . introduction the azimuthal distribution of emitted particles is a good tool for understanding the bulk properties of the matter created in non central nucleus - nucleus collisions . in the center of mass rapidity region , it can be expanded in fourier series : @xmath3 where @xmath4 is the azimuthal angle with respect to the direction of the impact parameter , and odd harmonics are zero by symmetry .
the large magnitude of elliptic flow @xmath2 observed at rhic suggests that the matter created in au - au collisions behaves like an almost perfect fluid .
however , recent experiments @xcite observe that , at midrapidity and fixed @xmath5 , @xmath6 , while ideal hydrodynamics predicts that @xmath7 @xcite . in this talk ,
i investigate this discrepancy .
fluctuations in initial conditions axis defines the reaction plane while the @xmath8 axis is the minor axis of the ellipse drawn by the participating nucleons ( grey dots ) .
, width=230 ] figure [ fig : fig1 ] presents a schematic picture of a non central heavy - ion collision ( hic ) .
the overlap area of the nuclei has an almond shape , which generates elliptic flow .
however , the matter is not continuously distributed in a nucleus .
the positions of the nucleons in the colliding nucleus are important : they also draw an ellipse which differs from the overlap area both in eccentricity and in orientation . from one event to the other , even at fixed impact parameter ,
the positions of the nucleons in the nucleus fluctuate .
the participant plane eccentricity ( @xmath9 ) , defined as the eccentricity of the ellipse drawn by the participating nucleons @xcite , thus fluctuates . since elliptic flow appears to be driven by this participant plane eccentricity , these eccentricity fluctuations translate into fluctuations of the flow coefficients @xmath2 and @xmath0 @xcite .
modeling eccentricity fluctuations the initial distribution of energy , which is needed to compute the initial eccentricity in a hic , is poorly known . in this talk i use a specific model , based on a monte carlo glauber ( mcg ) calculation @xcite .
the initial eccentricity is given for each event by : @xmath10 where @xmath11 and @xmath12 and the @xmath13 denote averages over participating nucleons .
each participant nucleon is given a weight proportional to the number of particles it creates , according to the two - component picture : @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the number of binary collisions of the nucleon .
the sum of weights scales like the multiplicity : @xmath16.\ ] ] where @xmath17 and @xmath18 are respectively the number of participants and of binary collisions of the considered event .
we choose the value @xmath19 which best describes the charged hadron multiplicity observed experimentally @xcite .
we define the centrality according to the number of participants .
we evaluate eccentricity fluctuations in centrality classes containing @xmath20 of the total number of events .
we do not introduce any hard core repulsion between nucleons in the mcg .
how eccentricity fluctuations affect @xmath21 . :
data from star @xcite and phenix @xcite ; error bars on star data points are our estimates of nonflow errors @xcite .
lines are predictions from ideal hydro with or without fluctuations.,width=259 ] there is no direct measure of the flow coefficients @xmath2 and @xmath0 .
they can be obtained using different analysis methods .
the one i will consider now relies on azimuthal correlations between particles near midrapidity . experimentally , @xmath2 can be extracted from the 2-particle correlation and @xmath0 from the 3-particle correlation using @xmath22 and @xmath23 , where angular brackets denote an average value within a centrality class .
thus , any experimental measure of @xmath21 obtained using this method is rather a measure of @xmath24 .
taking into account the ideal hydrodynamics prediction @xmath7 @xcite , we obtain : @xmath25 assuming that @xmath2 scales like the participant plane eccentricity @xmath9 , the effects of fluctuations on @xmath21 is obtained by computing : @xmath26 the resulting prediction for @xmath21 is displayed in figure [ fig : fig2 ] .
fluctuations clearly explain most of the difference between hydro and data .
it also appears that experimental data are still slightly higher than our prediction from fluctuations .
however , these predictions are based on a specific parametrization of the initial conditions .
flow fluctuations from experimental data , additional points ( labeled `` fluct . from @xmath2 '' ) are obtained using equation ( [ v24value ] ) with @xmath27 from @xcite and @xmath28 from @xcite.,width=259 ] another possible way of evaluating flow fluctuations is to compare the values of @xmath2 obtained using different analysis methods .
elliptic flow can be obtained from both @xmath29-particle cumulants ( @xmath28 ) and from @xmath30-particle cumulants ( @xmath27 ) using @xmath31 ( neglecting the non - flow contribution ) and @xmath32 .
inverting the last equation leads to : @xmath33 the values of @xmath21 obtained using this method are displayed on figure [ fig : fig3 ] .
they overshoot slightly our results from mcg eccentricity fluctuations , but the overall agreement remains good .
this provides a good check of our mcg prediction .
a small residual discrepancy remains between our prediction and the experimental data .
we argue that for peripheral to midcentral collisions , it may be understood in terms of deviations from local thermal equilibrium .
partial thermalization effects so far , i have only discussed how fluctuations in initial conditions modify the prediction from ideal hydrodynamics for @xmath21 . but
ideal hydrodynamics relies on the very strong assumption that the system remains in local thermal equilibrium ( a regime where the average number of collisions per particle @xmath34 is large ) throughout the evolution . in a previous work
@xcite we have shown that , in order to reproduce the centrality dependence of elliptic flow , the deviation from local thermal equilibrium must be taken into account ( @xmath35 would be a typical value for au - au collisions at the top rhic energy ) . with the knudsen number.,width=355 ] qualitatively , in the limit of small @xmath34 ( far from equilibrium ) , one expects both @xmath2 and @xmath0 to scale like @xmath34 , so that @xmath1 scales like @xmath36 : we thus expect that the farther the system from equilibrium , the larger @xmath1 @xcite . in order to have a more quantitative estimate of the effects of partial thermalization
, we use a @xmath37-dimensional solution of the relativistic boltzmann equation to study systems with arbitrary @xmath34 .
we use the knudsen number @xcite , @xmath38 , as a measure of the degree of thermalization of the system .
figure [ fig : fig4 ] displays the dependence of @xmath1 with the knudsen number . in the limit @xmath39 ,
transport results show that @xmath40 , which is close to @xmath41 .
we also observe , as expected from the low @xmath34 limit , that increasing @xmath42 leads to an increase of @xmath1 .
but this effect is only a small correction .
( right ) , with one additional curve showing the effect of the deviation from local equilibrium.,width=259 ] the effects of partial thermalization on the centrality dependence of @xmath43 are displayed on figure [ fig : fig5 ] .
the values of the knudsen number needed for this plot are borrowed from a previous study @xcite .
figure [ fig : fig5 ] shows that adding the effects of deviation from local thermal equilibrium to the fluctuations , our prediction overshoots slightly the data for midcentral and peripheral collisions , but the overall agreement is good .
we do not yet understand the large value of @xmath1 for central collisions .
conclusion to conclude , i would like to recall three points : 1 ) @xmath0 is mainly induced by @xmath2 ; 2 ) the deviation from local equilibrium has a small effect on @xmath1 ; 3 ) eccentricity fluctuations explain the observed values of @xmath1 , except for the most central collisions which require further investigation . |
description of nuclear pairing correlation has been a major subject in recent nuclear physics . for instance , in self - consistent meanfield ( scmf ) description of atomic nuclei , there have been various approaches in order to take the nuclear pairing correlation into account @xcite . these approaches based on the scmf or the nuclear density functional theory ( dft )
have provided considerable agreements with the measured binding energy as well as its odd - even staggering for bound nuclei . even with these efforts , however , the complete character of the nuclear pairing correlation has not been revealed .
for example , whether the phenomenological pairing interaction should have the volume or surface type of density dependence is still an open question @xcite . at present
, one can find several candidates for the sophisticated nuclear pairing model @xcite . in order to validate these models
, one may need reference observables to fit not only for bound nuclei .
also , it should be emphasized that the pairing correlation near and beyond the neutron and proton driplines could play a fundamental role to determine the limit of existence on the nuclear chart @xcite .
recently , it has been expected that the two - proton ( ) radioactivity may provide novel information on the nuclear pairing correlation . in the true emission @xcite
, a pair of protons is emitted simultaneously from the parent nucleus , whereas the single - proton emission is forbidden or strongly suppressed due to the pairing correlation energy .
the proton - proton pairing plays an essential role to determine the observables , especially the released energy ( q - value ) as well as the -decay width or lifetime @xcite .
the released q - value can be related with the proton - proton pairing strength in bound nuclei . on the other hand
, the -decay width has no correspondence in bound systems , whose lifetime is trivially infinite .
thus , decays may provide another lodestar with new experimental input to optimize and validate the pairing models .
thanks to the experimental developments , there has been a considerable accumulation of data for the -emitting nuclei @xcite . on the other side , however , theoretical studies have not been sufficient to clarify the relation between the radioactivity and the pairing correlation @xcite . because emission is a typical many - body problem , its elucidation could also provide an universal knowledge on the multi - particle quantum phenomena in various domains .
those include , _
e.g. _ the quantum entanglement @xcite , bcs - bec crossover @xcite , and efimov physics @xcite . in this article
, we discuss how the theoretical characters of pairing models are reflected on -decay properties , connected to a specific interest in sophisticating those models . for this purpose ,
we employ the time - dependent three - body model @xcite , whose simplicity enables us to phenomenologically understand the pairing model - dependence of radioactivity .
we focus on the emission from the ground state of the @xmath3be nucleus , assuming the configuration of two valence protons and a rigid @xmath4 core .
formalism of our model is given in sec .
[ sec : form ] . in sec .
[ sec : calc ] , we present numerical calculations and discussions .
finally sec .
[ sec : sum ] is devoted to summarize the article .
details of the time - dependent three - body calculations are present in ref.@xcite . in this article
, we employ the same method with some expansions . the decay from @xmath0be
is described as a time - evolution of the two protons in the spherical mean - field generated by the @xmath4 core .
the three - body hamiltonian is given as @xcite , @xmath5 where @xmath6 ( @xmath7 ) is the single particle ( s.p . )
hamiltonian between the core and the @xmath8-th proton .
@xmath9 is the reduced s.p .
mass with @xmath10 .
the core - proton potential is given as @xmath11 .
woods - saxon potential is expressed as v_ws(r ) = v_0 f(r ) + u_ls ( @xmath12 @xmath13 ) , [ eq : cp - ws ] with a function , @xmath14 $ ] , which can be related to the density - distribution of the core .
@xmath15 describes coulomb potential . for @xmath16 and @xmath17
, we employ the same parameters as in ref.@xcite , in order to reproduce the resonance energy and width in the @xmath18-channel of @xmath19 scattering , @xmath20 mev and @xmath21 mev , respectively @xcite . note that this resonance is attributable to the centrifugal potential barrier @xcite .
the @xmath2 pairing potential is introduced as @xmath22 . here
, we employ a schematic density - dependent contact ( sddc ) potential , v_p - p^(n)(_1 , _ 2 ) & = & w ( @xmath23 ) ( _ 1-_2 ) , + w(r ) & = & w_0 , [ eq : w_sddc ] for nuclear pairing interaction . here two protons have an contact pairing correlation , whose density - dependence is schematically approximated as the @xmath24 term .
notice also that @xmath25 . for intrinsic two - nucleon structures , including the dinucleon correlation , similar three - body model calculations with sddc pairing models
have been utilized @xcite , with a consistency between other theoretical results @xcite . with the contact interaction , it is generally known that one should introduce the energy cutoff , @xmath26 , in order to avoid the ultra - violet divergence @xcite . in present case , the bare strength , @xmath27 ,
can be determined so as to reproduce the empirical scattering length of nucleons in vacuum , @xmath28 fm , consistently to the energy - cutoff @xcite .
that is , w_0 = , with @xmath29 .
the cutoff energy is set as @xmath30 mev similarly in ref.@xcite , yielding @xmath31 mev@xmath32@xmath33 .
total expectation value of @xmath34 , which is conserved during the time - evolution , corresponds to the released q - value of the three - body decay .
that is , q_2p & = & , + & = & _ ( t ) + _ pair(t ) , + _
pair(t ) & = & , where @xmath35 is the pairing correlation energy ( pce ) . in order to reproduce the empirical q - value , @xmath36 kev @xcite
, we also employ a density - dependence parameter , @xmath37 in eq.([eq : w_sddc ] ) , corresponding to the surface type of the sddc pairing interaction .
indeed , it schematically describes the surface type of the density - dependent pairing interaction in meanfield calculations @xcite .
note also that pce approximately corresponds to the pairing gap when the system is bound .
we assume the @xmath38 configuration for two protons and the @xmath4 core , consistently to the total spin - parity which is also @xmath38 for the ground state of @xmath0be .
thus , the eigen - states of the three - body hamiltonian , @xmath39 , can be expanded on @xmath38 basis : & & = _
m u_nm , [ eq : expansion ] + & & _ m ( _ 1 , _ 2 ) = @xmath40 [ _ n_a ljm(_1 ) _ n_b lj(-m)(_2)]^0^+ , [ eq : basis_0p ] with the simplified notation , @xmath41 .
@xmath42 is the anti - symmetrization operator .
the expansion coefficients , @xmath43 , are determined by diagonalizing the hamiltonian matrix for @xmath34 .
state satisfies @xmath44 , with the radial quantum number @xmath45 , the orbital angular momentum @xmath46 , the spin - coupled angular momentum @xmath47 and the magnetic quantum number @xmath48 .
we employ the s.p .
states up to the @xmath49-channel . in order to take into account the pauli principle
, we exclude the first @xmath50 state , which is occupied by the protons in the core nucleus . the continuum s.p .
states ( @xmath51 ) of @xmath52 are discretized in the radial box of @xmath53 fm .
thus , continuum eigenstates of @xmath34 are also discretized . as we present in sec.[subsec : width ] , this radial box is sufficiently large to provide a good convergence in terms of the decay width .
it is worthwhile to mention that , if one neglects pce , -resonance state locates at @xmath54 , where @xmath55 is the @xmath19 resonance energy . in this case , where -wave function keeps the pure @xmath56 configuration , it was confirmed that the decay process is well described as a sequential emission @xcite .
taking pce into account , the resonance energy is decreased mainly due to the attractive pairing interaction .
figure [ fig : levels ] schematically describes this situation . in ref.@xcite ,
the finite - range and density - independent minnesota potential was employed to describe the pairing force @xcite , and then the strongly correlated emission was suggested . ''
should be corrected as `` @xmath57 '' . ] to occur the spatial correlation in this process , mixture of other configurations from @xmath56 plays an essential role @xcite .
in order to fix the initial state for time - evolution , we employ the same confining potential , @xmath58 , as in ref.@xcite .
this confining potential method has provided good approximations for quantum resonance phenomena @xcite , together with an intuitive way to understand their dynamics .
the initial state solved within the confining hamiltonian can be expanded on the eigen - basis of the original hamiltonian : @xmath59 .
thus , the time - evolution is represented as = _
n f_n ( t ) , [ eq : ex_e ] where @xmath60 .
it is worthwhile to note that the time - invariant discrete energy spectrum can be given as d(e_n)=@xmath61 ^ 2=@xmath62 ^ 2 .
if one takes the continuous energy limit , @xmath63 resembles the breit - wigner ( bw ) spectrum , which characterizes the quantum resonance properties of concerning radioactive process @xcite . in fig .
[ fig:1 ] , we plotted the normalized density distribution for the initial state .
that is , ( t;r_1,r_2,_12 ) = 8 ^ 2 r_1 ^ 2 r_2 ^ 2 _ 12 @xmath64 ^ 2 , at @xmath65 fm . for convenience ,
@xmath66 is translated to a function of the relative distance between the two protons , @xmath67 , and that between the core and the center of mass of two protons , @xmath68 . from fig .
[ fig:1 ] , we find the similar result in ref.@xcite , where a finite - range pairing interaction was used instead : the higher peak at @xmath69 fm and @xmath70 fm , as well as at @xmath71 , indicates a strong localization of two protons .
notice also that this localization is attributable to the spin - singlet configuration , suggesting a diproton correlation @xcite . in fig .
[ fig : dens_whole_tide ] , we plotted the time - development of state , in terms of the probability - density distribution .
it is well described that the confined two protons at @xmath65 are released during the time - development . the probability - density outside the core - proton barrier gradually increases , indicating an evacuation of two protons . in order to monitor their decay dynamics
more preciously , it is helpful to focus on the projected decay state @xcite .
that is , - ( t ) , with @xmath72 . because the initial state is well confined
, this projected decay state mainly represents the outgoing components released from around the core . in fig .
[ fig : dens_tide ] , we plot the density distribution of the projected decay state normalized at each point of time .
that is , _
d(t;r_1,r_2,_12 ) = , [ eq : decay_dens ] where @xmath73 is the decay probability . in fig .
[ fig : dens_tide ] , the strongly correlated -emission is suggested with our surface sddc pairing model
. the diproton correlation , which can be detected as a peak at @xmath74 fm and @xmath75 fm , as well as at @xmath71 , is dominant during the time - evolution .
notice also that the sequential emission , which is graphically indicated as a ridge along the @xmath76 line @xcite , is strongly suppressed .
this dynamical behavior of protons is similar to that suggested from the finite - range minnesota pairing model @xcite .
? = ? @ ccccc ccc & @xmath27 & @xmath77 & @xmath78 & @xmath79 & @xmath80 & @xmath81 & + & ( mev@xmath32@xmath33 ) & & ( kev ) & ( kev ) & ( kev ) & ( kev ) & + sddc ( surface ) &
@xmath82 & @xmath83 & @xmath84 & @xmath85 & @xmath86 & @xmath87 & + sddc ( mixed ) & ?
@xmath88 & @xmath89 & @xmath90 & @xmath91 & @xmath92 & @xmath87 & + sddc ( volume ) & ?
@xmath93 & @xmath94 & @xmath95 & @xmath96 & @xmath97 & @xmath98 & + sddc ( emitter ) & @xmath99 & @xmath100 & @xmath101 & @xmath102 & @xmath103 & @xmath104 & + minnesota @xcite & & & @xmath84 & @xmath105 & @xmath106 & @xmath107 & + experiment @xcite & & & @xmath108 & @xmath109 & @xmath110 & @xmath110 & + ? = 12
we next investigate the decay width , which is one of the directly measurable quantities of the emission . from the decay probability , @xmath111 ,
the -decay width is calculated as ( t ) = - = n_d(t ) .
[ eq : width ] it is worthwhile to note that , if the time - evolution follows the exponential decay rule , which is a fundamental property of radioactive processes , the decay probability is given as @xmath112 .
here @xmath113 is the constant decay width . in this case
, @xmath114 becomes identical to @xmath115 , which determines the mean lifetime of this system , @xmath116 . in fig .
[ fig : plpg ] , we plotted the actually calculated decay width as a function of time . with the sddc pairing interaction ,
we finely obtain the convergence of result after a sufficient time - evolution . from krylov - fock theorem @xcite , this coincides with that the energy distribution , @xmath117 , well approximates the bw spectrum , and thus reproduces the exponential decay rule .
@xmath114 at @xmath118 fm is @xmath85 kev , as tabulated in table [ table : cp ] . in fig .
[ fig : plpg ] , for a comparison , we fetch the result with the finite - range minnesota pairing force @xcite . from these results ,
we find that the sddc pairing interaction underestimates the experimental -decay width , whereas the finite - range minnesota pairing showed a good agreement with it .
remember that , as present in table [ table : cp ] , both pairing models are adjusted so as to reproduce the same q - value , corresponding to an equivalent condition on the pce . also , the core - proton potential and the cutoff parameters are common in both cases .
thus , the difference in -decay width should be purely attributed to the pairing properties . in fig .
[ fig : plpg ] , the partial decay widths for the spin - singlet and spin - triplet channels are also plotted @xcite : @xmath119 .
one finds again the dominance of the spin - singlet configuration in emission consistently to the density distribution in fig .
[ fig : dens_tide ] .
the exact values of @xmath120 at @xmath118 fm are also summarized in table [ table : cp ] . with the sddc pairing ,
the spin - singlet -decay width is remarkably small compared with the minnesota pairing case , whereas the spin - triplet width shows the similar values in both cases .
+ the smaller width in the sddc pairing case might be attributable to the numerical sensitivity . for radioactive processes governed by the quantum tunneling effect ,
even a small difference in q - value can yield a large change of the resultant decay width . in order to check this sensitivity
, we run the same calculations but changing the absolute strength of the pairing force .
that is , @xmath121 with @xmath122 , and @xmath123 , whereas @xmath124 exactly corresponds to the empirical q - value . because the pairing interaction is attractive , a reduction of it ( @xmath125 ) yields the enhanced q - value , meaning that the resonance energy is shifted to the higher region .
the @xmath78-@xmath126 relation obtained with the different pairing strengths is present in fig .
[ fig:5 ] .
obviously , the enhanced ( reduced ) q - value leads to the increase ( decrease ) of the decay width .
this can be kinetically understood as that the enhanced q - value increases the penetrability of the potential barrier and then yields the larger width , which is equivalent to the shorter lifetime .
similarly in table [ table : cp ] , the spin - singlet width is universally dominant , whereas the spin triplet width , indicated by the gap of the total and the spin - singlet widths , shows the similar values in both cases . in our calculations throughout several @xmath78 values ,
the sddc pairing commonly yields the smaller width than the minnesota pairing .
consequently , the difference in @xmath126 is not attributable to the q - value sensitivity , but concluding the pairing model - dependence .
note also that , with the sddc pairing , we could not reproduce the empirical @xmath78 and @xmath126 simultaneously , even within the experimental uncertainties . in fig .
[ fig:6 ] , the discrete energy spectra , @xmath117 , and their continuous distributions smeared by a cauchy - lorentz function are plotted .
we see that the spectrum width obtained with the sddc pairing model is not sensitive to the peak position , and it is narrower than that with the minnesota pairing model .
this result coincides with the @xmath126 values shown in fig .
[ fig:5 ] . in the remaining of this section
, we investigate what in the sddc pairing model essentially controls the -decay width . in scmf or dft calculations , so - called volume and mixed types of density - dependent pairing interaction have been employed as often as the surface type @xcite .
these characters of density - dependence can be approximated by @xmath127 and @xmath128 in eq.([eq : w_sddc ] ) for volume , mixed , and surface types , respectively . in order to investigate the role of density - dependence , we perform the similar calculations by changing @xmath77 , in addition to the original , surface sddc case ( @xmath37 ) . for @xmath129 and @xmath130
, we change the pairing strength , @xmath27 , so as to reproduce the same reference q - value .
those parameters are summarized in table [ table : cp ] .
notice that changing @xmath27 corresponds to the different value of vacuum - scattering length . in fig .
[ fig : plpg2 ] , we plot the decay widths obtained with different sddc parameterizations .
it is found that the volume sddc pairing yields the smallest @xmath126 value , whereas the mixed pairing reproduces the medium result between the surface and volume cases . considering the experimental reference quantities
, the surface sddc pairing somehow provides the best improvement among three cases .
here we also employ an _ emitter _
sddc potential with @xmath131 to help our discussion .
its parameters are also tabulated in table [ table : cp ] . with this model ,
we indeed obtain a good agreement with experiment : as shown in fig .
[ fig : plpg2 ] and table [ table : cp ] , the emitter sddc pairing can reproduce the experimental q - value and decay width simultaneously . consequently , fixing the same reference q - value , -decay width is connected to the density - dependence parameter , @xmath77 . in the top panel of fig .
[ fig : rho_1p ] , we plot the contact pairing strength , @xmath132 in eq.([eq : w_sddc ] ) , for several sddc parameterizations .
it is worthwhile to emphasize that , with the emitter sddc model , the pairing interaction is repulsive and thus the pairing correlation becomes unstable deeply inside the core .
also , due to the deeper @xmath27 value , two protons in vacuum earn a larger pce than that with other sddc models .
the sensitivity of -decay width is now understood from a synergy of pairing correlations in two regions . for this purpose , in fig .
[ fig : rho_1p ] , we present the one - proton probability - density distribution of the initial and time - developed states . that is , _
1(t;r ) & = & 8 ^ 2 _ 0^r_box dr_2 r_2 ^ 2 _ -1 ^ 1 d(_12 ) + & & @xmath133 ^ 2 .
because our -basis functions are anti - symmetrized , @xmath134 is symmetric for the exchange of @xmath135 and @xmath136 .
thus , @xmath137 represents the mean radial distribution of probability . from fig .
[ fig : rho_1p ] , in the surface and emitter sddc cases , the probability density shows a dispersive shape .
this is a product of ( i ) weak or repulsive pairing inside the core , as well as ( ii ) strong @xmath2 interaction in vacuum .
the first effect drives out the two - proton wave function tunneling the potential barrier , whereas the second favors a large probability density outside the core .
this mechanism then yields a loose stability with shorter mean lifetime . on the other hand , in the volume sddc case
, two - proton density hardly diverges with the isotropically attractive pairing interaction .
note that this mechanism commonly exists during the time - evolution , because the total hamiltonian itself is time - independent . with the present simple sddc interaction , @xmath77 and @xmath27
are not independent parameters to fit : when one is fixed , another should be determined consistently to @xmath138 . thus , model - dependence of @xmath126 contains two effects from ( i ) the density - dependent pairing inside the core , and ( ii ) @xmath2 scattering properties in vacuum @xcite . at this moment , however , separation of these effects is not trivial .
one possible approach is to employ a non - trivial parameterization of the density - dependence .
this approach could also help to resolve _ tri - lemma _ problem detailed in the next subsection .
lastly , we have confirmed that our conclusions do not change even if we employ a smaller value of @xmath26 .
we recalculated the decay width with @xmath139 mev , with sddc pairing strength renormalized to reproduce @xmath140 mev .
the obtained results reproduced the same width @xmath114 , as with the higher cutoff .
we mention an unnegligible problem raised from our results .
namely , there is a _ tri - lemma _ of @xmath141 , and the two - nucleon scattering length in vacuum , @xmath142 . in three - body model calculations for bound systems ,
all the two - body interactions are prepared to reproduce the partial two - body subsystems .
additionally , in order to reproduce the three - body binding energy , one often takes the dynamical effect into account .
density - dependent pairing model is a phenomenological procedure for this purpose . for bound systems ,
this method works if the three - body picture is adequate .
the situation changes for unbound @xmath0be . with sddc pairings combined with the well - adjusted core - proton potential for @xmath19 , ( i ) in the case of @xmath143 ( surface ) ,
@xmath144 is not reproduced , where we keep @xmath142 and @xmath78 consistently to experiments .
( ii ) with @xmath145 ( emitter ) , we reproduce the experimental @xmath78 and @xmath144 , whereas the pairing strength , @xmath27 , is inevitably modified inconsistently to the experimental scattering length . this is the tri - lemma of @xmath142 , @xmath78 , and @xmath126 .
note that this problem could be also found in ref.@xcite , where the softened minnesota pairing reproduces only @xmath78 and @xmath144 . in this work , certain sddc parameterization to resolve this problem has not been found .
one possible solution is to employ a non - trivial parameterization of the density - dependence , @xmath132 , in the pairing force .
the new @xmath132 should differ from our surface sddc function inside the core , whereas they should have the same @xmath27 value in vacuum .
another possible solution is phenomenological three - body force @xcite .
it may provide both the three - body dynamical effect and the asymptotic two - body properties consistently to experiments .
because these considerable solutions inevitably harm the simplicity of the present model , we leave these developments as a subject of future study .
although this tri - lemma remains , our conclusion about the pairing model - dependence in 2p - decay width is not changed . in order to improve theoretical pairing models , which can be connected to the effective pairing force in dft calculations , modern experimental data of -emitters
may provide adequate reference quantities . before closing our discussion
, we mention another sensitivity to the range of pairing force . the @xmath2 minnesota potential used in previous calculations
was given as v_p - p^(n ) = v_min & = & v_r e^-d^2/2q^2 + & + & v_s e^-d^2/2_s^2 q^2 _
s=0 + & + & v_t e^-d^2/2_t^2 q^2 _ s=1 , [ eq : pp_min ] where @xmath146 , @xmath147 mev , @xmath148 mev , @xmath149 mev , @xmath150 fm , @xmath151 , and @xmath152 .
@xmath153 is the projection to the spin - singlet ( triplet ) channel .
remember that @xmath154 was softened from the original value , @xmath155 mev @xcite , in order to reproduce the reference q - value . here
the first term describes a soft repulsive core .
decomposing @xmath156 , this term reads as v_r e^-d^2/2q^2 = w_r , where @xmath157 mev@xmath32@xmath33 , and similarly as expected for the following attraction terms . utilizing a well known formula , _
q0 = ( x/ ) = @xmath158 ( x ) , then at zero - range limit , we obtain _
q0 v_min(_1,_2 ) = w_0 ( _ 1-_2 ) , [ eq : minne_zr ] where @xmath159 mev@xmath32@xmath33 .
notice also that , for two - proton basis in @xmath38 configuration , matrix elements of the spin - triplet contact potential become zero automatically from the angular - momentum algebra @xcite .
indeed , this zero - range form is identical to the volume sddc pairing given in table [ table : cp ] , but with the deeper bare strength . employing the volume sddc pairing given in eq .
( [ eq : minne_zr ] ) , however , we confirmed that the @xmath160 three - body system fictionally becomes bound with @xmath161 mev , where the decay width is trivially zero . in order to reproduce the experimental q - value , @xmath140 mev
, we needed to use the shallower bare strength as in table [ table : cp ] . as a result
, we obtained @xmath162 and @xmath96 kev with the finite - range and zero - range minnesota potentials , respectively .
this shows a sensitivity of -decay width to the interaction range . to reinforce our conclusion , we repeat the same calculation but with the shorter range , @xmath163 fm in eq.([eq : pp_min ] ) .
in this case , we also need to employ the enhancement factor , @xmath164 , to reproduce the reference q - value : @xmath165 .
resultant -decay widths are displayed in fig.[fig:10 ] . as expected , the short - range minnesota yields the medium value of the decay width between the original and zero - range minnesota cases .
notice that , because minnesota forces are density - independent , this range - sensitivity should be attributed only to the vacuum scattering properties . here we simply emphasize that the finite range could be an alternative option instead of the density - dependence , in order to reproduce the concerning -decay width and q - value simultaneously .
we have discussed the dependence of radioactivity on nuclear pairing models within the time - dependent three - body model calculations .
comparing the zero - range sddc and the finite - range minnesota pairing forces , the dynamics is interpreted as the correlated emission similarly in both cases . evaluating the absolute decay probabilities
, we found that the two - proton decay width is remarkably sensitive to the pairing models , even with the equivalent condition on the emitted q - value . within the sddc pairing model ,
the -decay width significantly reflects the synergy of pairing correlations inside and outside the core .
it controls the penetrability of density , confined in the core - proton potential barrier at the initial state reproducing the reference q - value .
the surface or emitter sddc pairing provided the looser stability and thus the larger decay width .
because our three - body hamiltonian itself is not time - dependent nor self - consistent , it is not completely clear whether the similar density - dependence effect can be reflected on the scmf or dft calculations . thus , it is suggestive to expand our procedure to these frameworks @xcite , which enables us to perform the systematic investigation along the -drip line .
the work toward this direction could be helpful to sophisticate the theoretical pairing models , utilizing the -decay data as the reference quantities .
an experimental survey widely for the -emitter candidates could be profitable for this purpose @xcite . with the simple sddc pairing force , there remains a tri - lemma of @xmath141 , and the two - nucleon scattering length in vacuum , @xmath142 . in order to reproduce the whole two - body and three - body properties consistently to experiments ,
further model development is necessary .
we also found another kind of sensitivity to the range of pairing force .
considering the experimental q - value , with the finite - range minnesota potential , we finely reproduced the experimental -decay width @xcite . on the other side , at the zero - range limit of that potential ,
theoretical -decay width is significantly narrow .
because the density - dependence is absent in these cases , there should be another logic to explain the different width .
for this clarification , a further systematic analysis with respect of the interaction range may be helpful .
even it demands computational efforts , the work toward this direction is in progress now .
also , it might help to resolve the tri - lemma problem of 2p - decay .
comparison with other kind of experimental data , _
e.g. _ momentum distributions in refs .
@xcite , is an important topic for future work .
for this purpose , however , the present model space should be expanded sufficiently to reliable handle the long - range coulomb effects .
although the computational cost is highly increased , it may provides another procedure to validate effective pairing models .
t. oishi sincerely thank kouichi hagino and hiroyuki sagawa for fruitful discussions .
this work was supported by academy of finland and university of jyvskyl within the fidipro programme .
we acknowledge the csc - it center for science ltd . ,
finland , for the allocation of computational resources .
51ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty http://books.google.co.jp/books?id=k2haur-cq4ac[__ ] , cambridge monographs on particle physics , nuclear physics and cosmology ( , , ) and , eds . , http://www.worldscientific.com/worldscibooks/10.1142/8526#t=aboutbook[__ ] ( , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.75.607 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.75.121 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.53.2809 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1140/epja / i2009 - 10780-y [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.71.054303 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.78.024315 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.88.034314 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.87.064308 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.91.024305 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.81.034307 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nature11188 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.110.222501 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.physletb.2009.04.085 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.87.034328 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.90.034303 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1134/s1063779609050049 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/0034-4885/71/i=4/a=046301 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.84.567 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.86.044301 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.89.014331 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.physletb.2008.06.062 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.76.064316 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.99.022506 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0370-2693(70)90349-7 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.82.463 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.90.052514 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0003-4916(91)90033-5 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.56.3054 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.72.044321 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.82.024315 [ * * , ( ) ] , \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0375-9474(88)90124-8 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.71.064326 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/1402-4896/2012/i=t150/a=014024 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.75.021301 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.81.044308 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.88.042504 [ * * , ( ) ] \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0375-9474(77)90007-0 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.59.262 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.38.1747 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreva.69.042705 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ , reidel texts in the mathematical sciences , vol . 3 ( , , ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.86.044331 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.87.014605 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.90.024303 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.63.054313 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevc.80.034602 [ * * , ( ) ] | the sensitivity of two - proton emitting decays to the nuclear pairing correlation is discussed within a time - dependent three - body model .
we focus on the @xmath0be nucleus assuming @xmath1 configuration , and its decay process is described as a time - evolution of the three - body resonance state .
a noticeable model - dependence of two - proton decay width is found by utilizing schematic density - dependent contact ( sddc ) and the finite - range minnesota pairing models .
the model - dependence with the sddc pairing interaction can be understood by monitoring the time - dependent density distribution , which reflects ( i ) density dependence of pairing correlation inside the core , and ( ii ) @xmath2 scattering properties in vacuum .
our result suggests that two - proton decay width can be a suitable reference quantity to sophisticate the nuclear pairing model beyond the nucleon driplines . |
in parametric down - conversion , a pump photon of frequency @xmath0 incident on a medium with a second - order nonlinear susceptibility @xmath1 is split into two photons with lower frequency @xcite .
spontaneous parametric down conversion produces photon pairs that can be entangled in many degrees of freedom @xcite .
the resulting two - photon state , consisting of a signal photon at frequency @xmath2 and an idler photon at frequeny @xmath3 , is often called a biphoton . upon post - selection on the idler photons ,
the process provides a source of heralded single photons which represent the principal resource in many quantum information processing protocols like quantum cryptography @xcite or linear optics quantum computation @xcite .
quantum networks have been proposed @xcite that rely on stationary atoms or ions as information processing nodes and on single photons to transmit information via optical fibers .
first building blocks of this scheme have already been realized @xcite . for an efficient atom - photon coupling , the photon bandwidth has to match the linewidth of the atomic transition which is by orders of magnitude smaller than the bandwidth of the photons emitted in spontaneous parametric down - conversion . in order to reduce the photon bandwidth ,
cavity - enhanced parametric down - conversion can be applied .
a bright source of heralded narrow - band single photons was experimentally realized @xcite using a double - resonant optical parametric oscillator ( opo ) .
the nonlinear crystal was placed inside a cavity resonant for both the signal and the idler field , and in the output a single narrow - band longitudinal signal mode was selected with an external frequency filter . clearly , to conditionally achieve single - photon generation , the opo has to be operated in the regime far below threshold where the production rate of down - converted photons is small compared to the loss rate of the cavity .
a number of preceding experiments for biphoton generation in a double - resonant opo far below threshold have been performed @xcite , and the first theoretical description was given in ref .
recently , the theory of the double - resonant opo has been extended by analyzing the conditionally prepared single - photon state @xcite , and by providing a multi - mode treatment which is valid for both pulsed and stationary pump fields @xcite . to ensure reliable operation of a quantum network , continuous photon emission over a long period of time is essential .
for this purpose , an active stabilization of the opo is necessary which proves to be a complicated task in the double - resonant case while it is easier to achieve for a single - resonant cavity .
continuous biphoton generation in a single - resonant opo far below threshold has recently been demonstrated in our group @xcite using a setup where only the signal mode experiences resonance enhancement in the cavity while the orthogonally polarized idler mode is nonresonant due to deflection by an intra - cavity polarizing beam splitter .
additional passive filtering with the help of an external cavity can select a single longitudinal mode and will thus enable the generation of narrow - band single photons . to our knowledge , a theoretical treatment of the single - resonant opo far below threshold has not been performed so far . the present paper aims to fill this gap . based on the concepts of the pioneering theoretical studies of spontaneous parametric down - conversion @xcite
, we provide the theoretical background for our experimental results @xcite .
different from the approaches used for the theoretical description of the double - resonant opo @xcite , free - field quantization of the idler field is inevitable for our scheme .
this paper is organized as follows : in sec .
ii , the basic equations for describing the nonlinear interaction between the quantized signal and idler fields are provided . the biphoton production rate and
the biphoton wave functions are derived in sec .
iii by applying the standard perturbative treatment in the schrdinger picture @xcite .
the results are used in sec .
iv to derive the spectral properties of the emitted radiation and to study the the second - order signal - idler cross - correlation function .
v concludes the paper by establishing the connection to real experimental situations .
we consider type - ii parametric down - conversion in a nonlinear crystal of length @xmath4 that is pumped by a monochromatic linearly polarized classical field of frequency @xmath5 .
the crystal is assumed to be placed inside a cavity which is resonant for the signal field , but not for the idler field , polarized orthogonal to the signal .
1 shows a schematic picture of the corresponding experimental setup @xcite .
the central frequencies @xmath6 and @xmath7 of the signal and idler field depend on the properties of the birefringent nonlinear crystal and are determined by energy and momentum conservation known as phase - matching @xcite @xmath8 here , @xmath9 , @xmath10 , and @xmath11 are the wave vectors of the pump , signal , and idler waves which are collinear in the considered setup , with the signal leaving the cavity in positive @xmath12-direction .
the standing - wave fields of the pump and the signal inside the cavity are composed of two components , propagating in negative and positive @xmath12-direction , respectively . because of the phase - matching conditions , only those components contribute to the parametric interaction that have the same propagation direction as the idler wave . neglecting the vector notation of the fields ,
the positive - frequency part of the electric field in the relevant component of the classical pump inside the crystal can be written as @xmath13}.\ ] ] the weak signal and idler fields inside the crystal are described by the operators @xmath14 and @xmath15 , respectively , denoting the positive - frequency part of their co - propagating field components .
the interaction hamiltonian can be written in the simplified form @xmath16 where the second - order nonlinear susceptibility @xmath1 is frequency - dependent @xcite . before utilizing eq .
( [ h - int ] ) , we need to find explicit expressions for the operators @xmath17 and @xmath18 . for later use , we start by providing the operators for the signal and idler fields in free space .
the positive - frequency electric field operator of a wave with transverse cross - section @xmath19 propagating freely in @xmath12-direction is given by @xmath20 with @xmath21 where @xmath22 is the quantization length and @xmath23 denotes the photon annihilation operator of mode @xmath24 .
let us consider the signal field and introduce the frequency difference @xmath25 .
using @xmath26 , the transition to the continuum limit is performed via the replacement @xmath27 where the continuous field operators @xmath28 have the dimension @xmath29 .
since the bandwidth of the signal is small compared to its central frequency @xmath6 , the integration interval can be extended to @xmath30 , and we arrive at the approximate operator representation @xmath31 where @xcite @xmath32=\delta(\omega_1-\omega_2).\ ] ] similarly , the corresponding operator for the idler field in free space is given by @xmath33 where @xmath34 = \delta(\omega_1-\omega_2).\end{aligned}\ ] ] since in type - ii parametric down - conversion signal and idler photons are polarized orthogonally , we have @xmath35 = 0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we now turn to the fields inside the crystal . if the nonlinear interaction is small , we do not need to consider the complicated problem of field quantization in a nonlinear medium , but we can represent the field operators inside the crystal by adapting the corresponding expressions for the free - field operators in order to account for the presence of a lossless dispersive medium @xcite . in accordance with ref .
@xcite , the operator for the positive - frequency part of the idler field inside the crystal then takes the approximate form @xmath36},\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we introduced the wave vector at frequency @xmath37 , @xmath38 here , the replacements @xmath39 and @xmath40 have been performed where @xmath41 is the refractive index of the idler wave and @xmath42 . to describe the signal field
, we have to take the presence of the resonator into account .
let us first assume a lossless resonator completely filled with the nonlinear medium .
the quantization length of the field is then equal to the crystal length @xmath4 .
when @xmath43 denotes the refractive index of the signal , the adapted resonator eigenfrequencies characterizing the longitudinal modes can be written as @xmath44 where @xmath45 , @xmath46 and @xmath47 . since the frequency difference between adjacent modes is small compared to the total spectral width of the signal , as will become obvious in sec .
iv , we can assume without lack of generality that @xmath6 coincides with the frequency of a longitudinal mode and @xmath48 is an integer , i.e. that the cavity is tuned to resonance . using the taylor expansion @xmath49 , we find from eq .
( [ long ] ) after minor algebra that @xmath50 where @xmath51 is the group velocity of the signal at frequency @xmath6 . by adapting the empty - cavity field operator @xcite with the replacements @xmath52 and @xmath53 ,
the part of the standing - wave signal field operator inside the crystal that corresponds to a component traveling in positive @xmath12-direction in the lossless resonator is found to be @xmath54}}{2}\,.\ ] ] here , we replaced the quantization length under the square - root sign by the expression @xmath55 , following eqs .
( [ long1 ] ) and ( [ vg ] ) .
moreover , the summation has been extended to @xmath56 , in analogy to the expanded integration range in eq .
( [ sig - out ] ) .
the photon annihilation and creation operators for mode @xmath57 obey the usual commutation relation @xmath58 = \delta_{m , m^{\prime}}$ ] .
when resonator losses are incorporated , the modes turn into quasi - modes and the annihilation operators @xmath59 in eq .
( [ sig0-cr ] ) become time - dependent . according to the input - output formalism @xcite for a one - sided cavity with loss constant @xmath60 ,
the damping of mode @xmath57 is described by @xmath61 the operators @xmath62 and @xmath63 characterize the ingoing and outgoing photon flux at frequency @xmath64 and have the dimension s@xmath65 .
they are related by the boundary condition @xmath66 in order to determine @xmath67 , we use the representation @xmath68 where , in analogy to eq .
( [ com - a ] ) , @xmath69 = \delta_{m , m^{\prime}}\delta(\omega-\omega^{\prime } ) .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] eq .
( [ comm3 ] ) implies that the quasi - modes do not overlap which is justified in the good - cavity limit @xmath70 after inserting eq .
( [ in - out1 ] ) into eq .
( [ in - out ] ) , we obtain by fourier transformation the solution @xmath71 which has to be applied to eq .
( [ sig0-cr ] ) . the operator for the relevant field component of the signal in the lossy cavity
can then be written as @xmath72}.\qquad\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath73 is the wave vector corresponding to a traveling - wave component of frequency @xmath74 .
the denominator in the integral in eq .
( [ sig - cr ] ) describes radiation suppression for frequencies @xmath75 with @xmath76 while resonance enhancement occurs for @xmath77 .
so far , we have assumed a resonator length @xmath78 that coincides with the crystal length @xmath4 . if @xmath79 , a rigorous quantization of the signal field has to account for the exact position of the crystal inside the resonator , but is beyond the scope of the present paper .
for the purposes of our approximative treatment , however , it is sufficient to describe the signal field inside the crystal by eq .
( [ sig - cr ] ) with @xmath80 and @xmath81 where @xmath82 is the effective free spectral range .
the latter can be represented as @xmath83 where @xmath84 is the effective cavity round - trip time of a signal photon .
with the expressions for the operators of the signal and idler field at hand , we are now in the position to specify the interaction hamiltonian and to derive a perturbative solution of the schrdinger equation . making use of eqs .
( [ omega ] ) , ( [ pump ] ) , ( [ id - cr ] ) and ( [ sig - cr ] ) , as well as eq .
( [ long1 ] ) with @xmath85 and taking the frequency - dependence of the nonlinear susceptibility into account , we find from eq .
( [ h - int ] ) @xmath86 where we introduced the function @xmath87}\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] and defined the constant @xmath88 we are interested in the regime far below threshold where the biphoton production rate @xmath89 is much smaller than the cavity damping rate , @xmath90 and the mean photon number in the resonator therefore close to zero .
since the mean time interval between biphoton emission events is large compared to the cavity damping time , the resonator can be assumed to be empty before each emission event . for this case
, we can perform a perturbative treatment of the nonlinear interaction , assuming that at the initial time @xmath91 , the combined signal - idler field is in the vacuum state , described by @xmath92 . in the following we rely on the ideas developed for the theory of spontaneous parametric down - conversion @xcite . by expanding the formal solution of the time - dependent schrdinger equation , up to a normalization factor
, the state vector describing the combined signal - idler field at a time @xmath93 is found to be @xmath94 with @xmath95 after substituting eq .
( [ h - int1 ] ) into eq .
( [ psi - tilde ] ) , integration with respect to @xmath96 yields @xmath97 { \rm e}^ { \frac{i}{2}(m\delta\omega + \omega + \omega^{\prime})\delta t}\nonumber\\ & & \times\,a^{\dag } ( \omega_m+\omega ) b^{\dag } ( \omega_i+\omega^{\prime})|0\rangle,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we used the sinc - function defined as @xmath98 with @xmath99 .
the nonnormalized vector @xmath100 refers to the state of the radiation field on the condition that a signal - idler photon pair has been produced during the time interval @xmath101 . since this condition applies with the probability @xmath102 applying the commutation relations eqs .
( [ comm1 ] ) and ( [ comm3 ] ) , we get from eq .
( [ psi - tilde1 ] ) @xmath103.\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] because of the properties of the sinc - function , the integral is dominated by the region @xmath104 .
if @xmath101 is sufficiently large and @xmath105 is a slowly varying function of @xmath106 in this region , the latter function can be replaced by its value at @xmath107 @xcite . using the relation @xmath108 , the integration with respect to @xmath106 is then readily performed , and we obtain @xmath109 where @xmath110 for further evaluation , we need to specify the function @xmath111 . using eqs .
( [ k ] ) , ( [ ki ] ) , and ( [ ks ] ) with @xmath112 , taylor expansion around the central frequencies @xmath6 and @xmath7 yields @xmath113 where we introduced the time constant @xmath114 the latter is equivalent to @xmath115 and describes the difference between the transit times of a signal and idler photon through a crystal of length @xmath4 , originating from the difference in the signal and idler group velocities , @xmath116 and @xmath117 , defined by eq .
( [ vg ] ) and by the corresponding equation for the idler wave , respectively . since in any real experiment @xmath118
, it follows that @xmath119 where we used eq .
( [ t ] ) .
hence , we are considering a parameter range in this problem that is characterized by the combined inequality @xmath120 where eqs .
( [ goodcavity ] ) and ( [ kapp ] ) have been incorporated @xcite . assuming a constant nonlinear susceptibility within the bandwidth given by @xmath121 , we find from eqs .
( [ phim ] ) , ( [ dk ] ) , and ( [ f - m ] ) that @xmath122 in order to determine the rate of biphoton generation , we have to insert eq .
( [ phim1 ] ) into eq .
( [ kappa2 ] ) where the integration with respect to @xmath123 is effectively restricted to the cavity bandwidth @xmath60 with @xmath124 . hence , we neglect @xmath123 compared to @xmath125 in eq .
( [ phim1 ] ) for @xmath126 . moreover , eq . ( [ inequality1 ] ) implies @xmath127 in the relevant interval @xmath128 and therefore @xmath129 .
after integration with respect to @xmath12 , we get the approximation @xmath130 which can be used in connection with eq .
( [ kappa2 ] ) , ( [ kappa ] ) , and ( [ alpha ] ) to determine the rate of biphoton generation @xmath131 further simplification is possible if we transform the sum into an integral with respect to @xmath132 , introducing the positive increment @xmath133 where @xmath134 because of eq .
( [ inequality1 ] ) .
we then arrive at the expression @xmath135 that does not depend on the properties of the resonator because the mean photon number in our cavity is approximately zero and , in addition , an associated idler mode exists for each signal mode which meets the requirement for energy conservation .
the presented perturbative treatment relies on the condition @xmath136 so that the wave function @xmath137 in eq .
( [ psi - tilde1 ] ) and the approximation leading to eq .
( [ kappa2 ] ) are valid simultaneously .
the normalized vector @xmath138 can be denoted as the biphoton wave function since it represents the state of the radiation field on the condition that exactly one signal - idler photon pair is present .
a more convenient representation of the biphoton wave function is obtained if the sinc - function in eq .
( [ psi - tilde1 ] ) is replaced by @xmath139 according to the standard procedure @xcite .
mathematically , this corresponds to the limit @xmath140 , implying @xmath141 .
then , the integration with respect to @xmath106 can be performed immediately . in analogy to the expression given in ref .
@xcite , we obtain the biphoton wave function @xmath142 where @xmath111 is given by eq .
( [ phim1 ] ) and @xmath143 is a normalization constant .
the explicit value of @xmath143 @xcite is not important as long as only normalized quantities characterizing the radiation field are considered .
( [ psi ] ) clearly reveals the frequency - entanglement between the signal and idler photon and will serve as our basic equation to determine the properties of the emitted radiation .
first we investigate the output spectra @xmath144 and @xmath145 of the signal and idler field , defined as @xmath146 where @xmath147 and @xmath148 are the first - order temporal correlation functions of the respective fields outside the resonator . in the following , it is convenient to use the heisenberg picture and to start from the expression @xmath149 is the time - independent biphoton wave function given by eq .
( [ psi ] ) and @xmath150 and @xmath151 denote the positive - frequency parts of the time - dependent operators of the electric fields in free space , given by eqs .
( [ sig - out ] ) and ( [ id1 ] ) .
let us first determine the spectrum of the idler field . considering @xmath152 due to eq .
( [ comm1 ] ) , we obtain from eqs .
( [ id1 ] ) and ( [ psi ] ) @xmath153 by taking the inner product of @xmath154 and @xmath155 and applying the commutation relation eq .
( [ comm3 ] ) , we find @xmath156 in analogy to the derivation of eq .
( [ kappa3 ] ) , the dependence of @xmath157 on @xmath123 can be neglected within the relevant bandwidth determined by @xmath60 . after inserting eq .
( [ phim2 ] ) into eq .
( [ gi ] ) , the fourier transform yielding the idler spectrum according to eq .
( [ spectrum ] ) is readily performed .
the signal spectrum can be determined in a completely analogous way , and we finally arrive at the relation @xmath158 eq .
( [ si ] ) indicates that both the signal and idler spectrum are composed of lorentzians of halfwidth @xmath60 centered at frequencies @xmath159 with @xmath160 where the respective spectral envelopes are determined by the sinc - function in the nominator . from fig . 2
it becomes obviouos that the frequency bandwidth of the signal and idler photons is characterized by @xmath121 .
their temporal uncertainty is thus equal to the modulus of the time constant @xmath161 introduced in eq .
( [ tau0 ] ) and resulting from the phase - matching conditions .
even though the idler wave is not resonant , the longitudinal mode structure of the resonator is revealed in the idler spectrum due to the frequency entanglement between the signal and idler photon which arises from the interaction underlying the biphoton generation process .
the coincidence rate for detecting an idler photon at time @xmath96 and a signal photon at time @xmath162 , both at equal distance from the end facet of the crystal , is proportional to the temporal correlation function @xmath163 and @xmath164 are the free - field operators defined by eqs .
( [ sig - out ] ) and ( [ id1 ] ) . with the explicit expression for the biphoton wave function @xmath165 , given by eq .
( [ psi ] ) , we get @xmath166\quad\nonumber}\\ \times\sum_{m=-\infty}^{\infty } { \rm e}^{-im \delta\omega\tau } \int_{-\infty}^{\infty}d\omega\ , \frac{\phi_m(\omega)}{\frac{\gamma}{2}-i\omega } { \rm e}^{-i \omega\tau}|0\rangle,\qquad\end{aligned}\ ] ] where eq .
( [ comm ] ) and the corresponding relation for the signal modes @xmath167 following from eq .
( [ com - a ] ) , have been applied . according to eq .
( [ g2 ] ) , the correlation function @xmath168 is proportional to the squared norm of the hilbert vector on the right - hand side of eq .
( [ help1 ] ) .
it can be determined from the explicit expression for @xmath111 , given by eq .
( [ phim1 ] ) , together with the integral identities @xmath169 first , it is important to observe that @xmath170 which is equivalent to @xmath171 for @xmath172 and @xmath173 for @xmath174 , respectively .
mathematically , eq . ( [ g4 ] ) is due to the expression @xmath175 which results from inserting eq .
( [ phim1 ] ) into ( [ help1 ] ) and is negative in the given case for any @xmath12 inside the crystal , i.e. for @xmath176 .
therefore , the upper line of eq .
( [ int ] ) applies .
physically , the correlation function vanishes because the arrival time of the signal photon in a photon pair can precede the arrival time of the corresponding idler photon at most by a time interval that is within the temporal uncertainty interval @xmath177 inherent in the biphoton generation process . on the other hand ,
the presence of the resonator allows a signal photon to be detected considerably later than the associated idler photon since the signal photon may bounce back and forth between the resonator mirrors repeatedly before leaving the resonator . for time delays @xmath178 outside the limits of eq .
( [ g4 ] ) , we approximate @xmath111 by eq .
( [ phim2 ] ) where the integration with respect to @xmath12 has been performed and the dependence on @xmath123 has been neglected . after inserting eq .
( [ phim2 ] ) into eq .
( [ help1 ] ) , the damping of the cavity gives rise to a factor proportional to @xmath179 for @xmath180 which follows from the third line of eq .
( [ int ] ) @xcite .
since @xmath181 , we finally get from eq .
( [ help1 ] ) the approximate result @xmath182 according to eq .
( [ tau01 ] ) , the sign of @xmath161 is determined by the relation between the signal and idler group velocities , i.e. @xmath183 for @xmath184 and @xmath185 for @xmath186 .
a numerical evaluation reveals that eq .
( [ g5 ] ) describes a decaying periodic function with peaks of width @xmath177 centered at @xmath187 where @xmath188 and @xmath189 is the cavity round - trip time .
the time shift @xmath190 of the peaks arises since for @xmath172 the time needed by the center of the signal wave packet to travel from the middle of the crystal to its end facet is by the amount @xmath191 shorter than the time needed by the center of the idler wave packet to cover the same distance while the opposite holds for @xmath185 . transforming the sum in eq .
( [ g5 ] ) into an integral , the expression for the signal - idler cross - correlation function can be further approximated , in analogy to the procedure applied to derive eq .
( [ kappa4 ] ) . introducing @xmath132 and @xmath192
, we find that @xmath193 with @xmath194 since @xmath195 is an even function of @xmath196 . because of the periodicity of the cos - function ,
the parameter @xmath197 can be written as @xmath198 + 1\right)t\right]/\tau_0 $ ] where @xmath199 $ ] denotes the largest integer that does not exceed @xmath200 . since @xmath201 for @xmath202 and @xmath203 for @xmath204 ,
( [ g5 ] ) takes a simple form that can be combined with eq .
( [ g4 ] ) to yield the compact approximate representation @xmath205 where @xmath206\right|$ ] ( see fig . 3 ) . here
, we took into account that due to eq .
( [ inequality1 ] ) cavity damping is negligible during the time interval @xmath177 , i.e. @xmath207 .
in a real experiment , the sharp peaks of the function @xmath168 will be broadened due to the finite resolution time of the detector setup . when the latter is taken into account by performing the convolution with respect to a gaussian function , eq .
( [ g6 ] ) yields the time - averaged cross - correlation function @xmath208,\ ] ] where @xmath209 characterizes the effective resolution time and where we have assumed @xmath210 . the resulting averaged function is plotted in fig . 4 for two different values of @xmath209 .
a second - order cross - correlation function showing the behavior of the solid line in fig .
4 has recently been measured in our group @xcite , and the results have been found to be in excellent agreement with the predictions derived from eqs .
( [ g4 ] ) and ( [ g5 ] ) .
we still note that for spontaneous parametric down - conversion in a double - resonant cavity the signal - idler cross - correlation function has also been found to exhibit a comb - like structure which is , however , symmetric with respect to the time delay @xcite .
the effect has been explained by applying the concept of mode - locking to the frequency - entangled biphoton state , pointing out that due to the large coherence time of the pump , photon pairs with different frequencies have a common phase and form a coherent superposition @xcite .
to summarize , we performed a theoretical investigation of biphoton generation by spontaneous parametric down - conversion in a single - resonant opo far below threshold .
we derived analytical expressions for the rate of biphoton generation , for the output spectra of the signal and idler fields , as well as for the second order signal - idler cross correlation function .
our investigations provide the theoretical background for explaining the results of a recent experiment @xcite , where stable continuous operation of a single - resonant opo far below threshold has been demonstrated .
this work was supported by deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft dfg , grant be 2224/5 .
m. scholz acknowledges funding by deutsche telekom stiftung .
99 l. mandel and e. wolf , _ optical coherence and quantum optics _ ( cambridge university press , cambridge , 1995 ) .
j. t. barreiro , n. k. langford , n. a. peters , and p. g. kwiat , phys .
lett . * 95 * , 260501 ( 2005 ) . c. m. bennett and g. brassard , in _ proc .
ieee conference on computers , systems , and signal processing in bangalore , india _ ( ieee , new york , 1984 ) , p. 175 .
n. gisin , rev .
* 74 * , 145 ( 2002 ) .
e. waks , k. inoue , c. santori , d. fattal , j. vukovi , g. s. solomon , and y. yamamoto , nature * 420 * , 762 ( 2002 ) .
e. knill , r. laflamme , and g. j. milburn , nature * 409 * , 46 ( 2001 ) .
s. lloyd , m. s. shahriar , j. h. shapiro , and p. r. hemmer , phys .
* 87 * , 167903 ( 2001 ) .
j. i. cirac , p. zoller , h. j. kimble , and h. mabuchi , phys .
lett . * 78 * , 3221 ( 1997 ) . c. w. chou , j. laurat , h. deng , k. s. choi , h. de riedmatten , d. felinto , and h. j. kimble , science * 316 * , 1316 ( 2007 ) .
t. wilk , s. c. webster , a. kuhn , and g. rempe , science * 317 * , 488 ( 2007 ) .
j. s. neergaard - nielsen , b. meltholt nielsen , h. takahashi , a. i. vistnes and e. s. polzik , opt .
exp . * 15 * , 7940 ( 2007 ) .
z. y. ou and y. j. lu , phys .
lett . * 83 * , 2556 ( 1999 ) .
y. j. lu and z. y. ou , phys .
. a * 62 * , 033804 ( 2000 ) .
y. j. lu , r. l. campbell , and z. y. ou , phys .
lett . * 91 * , 163602 ( 2003 ) .
h. wang , t. horikiri , and t. kobayashi , phys .
rev . a * 70 * , 043804 ( 2004 ) . c. e. kuklewicz , f. n. c. wong , and j. h. shapiro , phys .
* 97 * , 223601 ( 2006 ) . c. e. kuklewicz , m. fiorentino , g. messin , f. n. c. wong , and j. h. shapiro , phys .
rev . a * 69 * , 013807 ( 2004 ) .
a. e. b. nielsen and k. mlmer , phys .
rev . a * 75 * , 023806 ( 2007 ) .
a. e. b. nielsen and k. mlmer , phys .
rev . a * 76 * , 033832 ( 2007 ) .
m. scholz , f. wolfgramm , u. herzog , and o. benson , appl .
* 91 * , 191104 ( 2007 ) . c. k. hong and l. mandel , phys .
rev . a * 31 * , 2409 ( 1985 ) .
r. ghosh , c. k. hong , z. y. ou , and l. mandel , phys .
rev . a * 34 * , 3962 ( 1986 ) .
d. f. walls and g. j. milburn , _ quantum optics _
( springer , berlin , 1994 ) . k. j. blow , r. loudon , s. j. d. phoenix , and t. j. shepherd , phys . rev .
a * 42 * , 4102 ( 1990 ) .
m. j. collett and c. w. gardiner , phys .
a * 30 * , 1386 ( 1984 ) . for completeness
, we state the formal result @xmath211 $ ] which follows with the help of eqs .
( [ comm3 ] ) , ( [ kappa ] ) and ( [ kappa2 ] ) .
the delta function arises since @xmath212 because of eq .
( [ comm1 ] ) . note that @xmath213 . in a typical experiment
@xcite , the relevant parameters are given by @xmath214 mhz , @xmath215 mhz , @xmath216 ghz , and @xmath217 ghz .
since a mathematically exact treatment of the discontinuity is physically irrelevant , we replace the value of the integral in the second line of eq .
( [ int ] ) by the value of the third line . | we present a quantum - theoretical treatment of biphoton generation in single - resonant type - ii parametric down - conversion . the nonlinear medium is continuously pumped and is placed inside a cavity which is resonant for the signal field , but nonresonant for the idler deflected by an intra - cavity polarizing beam splitter .
the intensity of the classical pump is assumed to be sufficiently low in order to yield a biphoton production rate that is small compared to the cavity loss rate .
explicit expressions are derived for the rate of biphoton generation and for the biphoton wave function .
the output spectra of the signal and idler field are determined , as well as the second - order signal - idler cross - correlation function which is shown to be asymmetric with respect to the time delay . due to frequency entanglement in the signal - idler photon pair
, the idler spectrum is found to reveal the longitudinal mode structure of the cavity , even though the idler field is not resonant . |
low - frequency radio telescopes have relatively large fields - of - view , because the telescope primary beam size scales with wavelength . current high - resolution ( sub - arcminute ) radio interferometers that operate at sub - ghz frequencies , like the giant metrewave radio telescope ( gmrt ) , the low - frequency array ( lofar ) , or the very large array ( vla ) , have field diameters measured in ( sometimes tens of ) degrees . typical challenges of handling high - resolution , low - frequency continuum observations are ( i ) imaging and deconvolving many sources inside ( and outside ! ) the large primary beam area , ( ii ) direction - dependent ( dd ) visibility amplitude and phase variations across the field - of - view due to antenna beam patterns , pointing errors , ionosphere , etc . , and the abundance of radio frequency interference ( rfi ) . processing data coming from these telescopes can be daunting , since all the challenges mentioned above ( and more ) needs to be dealt with at the same time . in data reduction ,
the _ art _ is to determine at any given time which effect is dominant in limiting the image quality .
generally , a few _ big effects _ stand out and are generally easy to identify and fix .
but subsequenty , many _ smaller effect _ will present themelves , which may be more difficult to recognize , and harder to identify and disentangle .
a effective way to mitigate the smaller effects is to perform iterations of ( dd ) calibration , imaging and flagging , in each step refining the quality of both the visibility data and the reconstructed sky model .
developments towards a semi - automated data reduction package started in 2006 , driven by the complicated reduction of gmrt 150 mhz observations on galaxy cluster abell 2256 ( and other similar data sets ) .
several challenges presented themselves at the same time : ( i ) the target contains faint , diffuse emission in the presence of bright interfering sources , ( ii ) the data was strongly affected by rfi on many baselines , ( iii ) the data was strongly affected by ionospheric phase distortions , ( iv ) the data was affected by instrumental instabilities .
it quickly became clear that this data required an algorithm to correct for ionospheric phase errors , and possibly other dd effects .
simultaneously followed the desire to automate several trivial but very time - consuming data reduction steps . for the basis of these new developments a stable data reduction package
was sought , with the possibility to easily expand the functionality .
this was found in the combination of the data reduction package aips @xcite and the powerful high - level programming language python ( and its standard scientific libraries like scipy , pylab , matplotlib , and numpy ) , with the parseltongue interface @xcite providing access to aips tasks , data files ( images and visibilities ) and tables from python .
a new python module was created named _ spam _ , an acronym for _ source peeling and atmospheric modeling _ , encapsulating high - level data reduction functions and new algorithm development .
spam - based data reductions , i.e. for gmrt observations , have been captured in python scripts that execute aips tasks directly ( mostly during initial reduction steps ) , call high - level functions that encompass multiple aips /parseltongue calls , and require few manual operations . these scripted data reductions automatically keep a history of the data reduction steps , and provide a standard that is well - tested and reproducible . at the same time , the spam user is required to perform some manual steps , and can easily decide to change the order of data reduction steps depending on the target field geometry and the intended science , therefore the term data reduction _ recipe _ is more appropriate than _ pipeline_. note that spam assumes an unpolarized sky , observed with limited ( @xmath0 percent ) fractional bandwidth .
spam recipes are available for all sub - ghz gmrt frequencies , developed and refined over the last several years , with minimal differences between frequencies .
the general structure of this data reduction is described in , and includes _ measuring _ dd ionospheric phase errors through peeling of bright sources within the science field ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , _ modeling _ these errors with a single- or multi - layer ionospheric phase model , and _ applying _ ionospheric phase corrections during wide - field ( re-)imaging of the science field ( see section [ sec : ioncal ] ) .
a combination of rfi- and bad data mitigation routines are used inbetween rounds of calibration and imaging . _
classical outlier removal _ excises visibilities mostly based on excessive visibility amplitudes and statistical outlier rejection along the time and frequency axes .
subtraction _ models and subtracts low - level , quasi - continuous , ground - based rfi based on its fringe - rotation signature ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) . and _ ripple killing _ excises bad visibility data based on a combination of high visibility amplitudes , high visibility weights and high imaging weights ( i.e. , though uniform weighting ) .
this is done by fourier - transforming residual images back onto the uv - plane , identifying high - amplitude uv - cells , and rejecting all visibilities that fall in these cells .
a more elaborate description will be given in an upcoming paper ( intema et al .
, in preparation ) . following @xcite there are four ionospheric calibration regimes , depending on the size of the radio interferometer array and the size of the field - of - view , both relative to the scale of phase structure in the ionosphere .
this makes most sense when imagining a single horizontal density wave ( or a bubble ) in a thin layer at a fixed height .
regime 4 is the most complex case , when both the horizontal size of the array and the projected field - of - view at ionospheric height are similar or larger than the horizontal scale of the ionospheric phase structure . in this regime , when looking towards a single source in the field - of - view , the higher - order phase structure over the array will cause both an apparent position shift and a source deformation .
when looking at a second source in the same field - of - view at sufficient distance from the first , both the apparent position shift and the source distortion will be different .
the spam ionospheric calibration strategy is designed to operate in regime 4 , meaning that it will also work in the less complex regimes 13 . in an automated peeling routine
, measurements of the ionospheric phase structure are obtained by phase calibrating on ( typically 1020 ) bright sources within the field - of - view . per time
interval ( typically 1020 seconds ) , the measured phases of all source antenna pairs are mapped onto a common domain along their line - of - sight , i.e. , at the pierce points through a virtual phase screen at fixed height .
the phases are fit with an optimized set of base functions , reproducing the measured phases , and predicting dd phases corrections in arbitrary viewing directions during imaging .
the automated wide - field imager applies any relevant dd phase corrections on the fly in a modified version of polyhedron ( facet - based ) imaging and cotton - schwab clean deconvolution ( e.g. , see * ? ? ?
the intrinsic book - keeping issues of faceted imaging are largely hidden from the user .
the imager also includes an iterative , robust clean boxing scheme , and simultaneous imaging of the primary beam area and bright outlier fields . in principle
, the generic imager can handle other dd effects as well , like asymmetric primary beams or pointing errors , as long as a model is available to generate the dd correction tables .
spam is an aips - based python package that provides semi - automated data reduction scripts for all sub - ghz frequencies at gmrt .
apart from well - tested standard data reduction steps , spam includes direction - dependent ( ionospheric ) calibration and imaging , and alternative rfi- and bad data mitigation methods . with spam ,
gmrt data reductions are highly efficient , highly reproducible , and give good quality results .
spam is available for everyone to use .
spam for casa , currently under development , will also provide wide - bandwidth ionospheric calibration , direction - dependent ionospheric faraday rotation calibration , and will naturally benefit from the advanced modes ( and continuous improvements ) of the casa imager ( e.g. , see * ? ? ? * and references therein ) . | high - resolution astronomical imaging at sub - ghz radio frequencies has been available for more than 15 years , with the vla at 74 and 330 mhz , and the gmrt at 150 , 240 , 330 and 610 mhz .
recent developments include wide - bandwidth upgrades for vla and gmrt , and commissioning of the aperture - array - based , multi - beam telescope lofar .
a common feature of these telescopes is the necessity to deconvolve the very many detectable sources within their wide fields - of - view and beyond .
this is complicated by gain variations in the radio signal path that depend on viewing direction .
one such example is phase errors due to the ionosphere . here
i discuss the inner workings of spam , a set of aips - based data reduction scripts in python that includes direction - dependent calibration and imaging .
since its first version in 2008 , spam has been applied to many gmrt data sets at various frequencies .
many valuable lessons were learned , and translated into various spam software modifications .
nowadays , semi - automated spam data reduction recipes can be applied to almost any gmrt data set , yielding good quality continuum images comparable with ( or often better than ) hand - reduced results . spam is currently being migrated from aips to casa with an extension to handle wide bandwidths .
this is aimed at providing users of the vla low - band system and the upcoming wide - bandwidth gmrt with the necessary data reduction tools .
[ firstpage ] atmospheric effects methods : data analysis instrumentation : interferometers |
the exceptional luminosity of type ia supernovae ( sn ia ) , and the tight empirical relationships among the decline rate , color , and peak luminosity of their light curves @xcite , make sn ia useful probes of the cosmic expansion history @xcite .
sn ia spectra and
inferred @xmath5ni masses ( e.g. , @xcite ) show reasonable agreement with models of the thermonuclear explosions of carbon - oxygen white dwarfs ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) .
additional evidence for a comparatively old progenitor population comes from the presence of sn ia in passive galaxies , and the observation that they show no preference for the brightest regions of their hosts , in contrast to core - collapse explosions that also exhibit h- and he - deficient spectra ( @xcite ; see also @xcite ) .
for sufficiently nearby sn ia ( @xmath6 mpc ) , pre - explosion _ hst _ imaging has the sensitivity to detect several classes of candidate progenitor systems .
current constraints suggest that sn ia progenitor systems consist primarily of either binary white dwarfs @xcite , or binaries where a single white dwarf accretes matter from a stellar companion ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . for the latter , single - degenerate channel ,
the white dwarf gains matter from a companion star up to a point where its mass is close to the chandrasekhar limit ( 1.4 m@xmath7 ) , precipitating eventual thermonuclear runaway .
accretion onto a white dwarf primary can occur through roche - lobe overflow ( rlof ) from a secondary with a h envelope @xcite or from a he star @xcite .
alternatively , in the case of the symbiotic channel , the white dwarf accretes mass from the wind generated by the secondary @xcite . characterizing the diversity of sn ia progenitor systems may be useful for explaining evidence that the luminosities of sn ia have a @xmath8 mag dependence on the properties of the host galaxy , after correcting for light - curve shape and color @xcite .
while earlier analyses have found useful nondetections at sn ia explosion sites ( e.g. , @xcite ; @xcite ) , @xcite were able to place significantly fainter limits on the luminosity at the explosion site of sn ia 2011fe in m101 ( @xmath9 mpc ; @xcite ) .
their nondetection excludes a bright red giant companion , specifically both model galactic progenitor symbiotic systems rs ophiuchi ( rs oph ) and t coronae borealis ( t crb ) , as well as the he - star system v445 puppis ( v445 pup ) .
here we report constraints on the progenitor system of sn 2014j using pre - explosion near - ultraviolet ( uv ) through near - infrared ( ir ) _ hst _ imaging of the explosion site whose coordinates we measure using keck - ii adaptive optics ( ao ) imaging .
section [ sec : discovan ] provides a brief summary of the discovery and early analysis of the spectra and light curve of sn 2014j . in [ sec : data ] , we describe the keck ao and _ hst _ pre - explosion images that we analyze in this paper .
the methods we use to extract upper luminosity limits for the progenitor system are explained in
[ sec : methods ] , while [ sec : results ] presents constraints on possible progenitor systems .
section [ sec : conclusions ] provides a summary of our conclusions .
sn 2014j was discovered by @xcite on ( ut dates are used throughout this paper ) during a university college london class observing session . @xcite found that the light curve favors a time of first light of , and showed that the early evolution of the light curve can be best described by a varying power law that shows a more rapid initial rise in luminosity than a @xmath10 dependence .
tendulkar et al .
( @xcite ; also @xcite ) acquired _
k_-band images with the near infrared camera 2 ( nirc2 ) in conjunction with the adaptive optics ( ao ) system @xcite on the keck - ii 10-m telescope .
the corrected point - spread function ( psf ) of their coadded image had a full width at half - maximum intensity ( fwhm ) of 0.36@xmath11 ( measured at a 10@xmath11 offset from sn 2014j ) .
@xcite consider a source 0.2@xmath11 ( 5@xmath12 ) from the measured sn position as a potential companion , although they suggest that a radio upper limit @xcite disfavors this possibility by setting a prohibitively low constraint on a donor star s mass - loss rate .
after removing galactic reddening determined by @xcite , @xcite find that the shape of the optical sn 2014j spectrum may be reproduced by applying a low @xmath13 extinction curve to a spectrum of sn 2011fe , a spectroscopically normal and unreddened sn ia ; a @xcite reddening law with and provides the best match to the observed sn 2014j spectrum .
the favored value of @xmath3 is consistent with the measured equivalent width ( ew ) of the diffuse interstellar band ( dib ) at 5780 .
@xcite analyze archival observations taken with the _ chandra _ x - ray telescope of the position of sn 2014j .
they are not able to exclude a low - temperature ( @xmath14 ev ) supersoft x - ray source coincident with the explosion .
additionally , they find that the explosion coordinates lie near the center of a @xmath15 pc structure of diffuse x - ray emission with inferred mass @xmath16 m@xmath7 , which they suggest may be a bubble inflated by one or more previous sn .
@xcite consider the possibility that sn 2014j may be associated with a prompt channel linked to nearby recent star formation .
to locate the sn site in pre - explosion _ hst _ exposures with high precision , we acquired wide - field nirc2 _ k_-band ao images of the site of sn 2014j on .
the sn was used as the guide star to measure tip - tilt corrections .
the fwhm natural seeing produced a psf with 0.65@xmath11 fwhm , while the ao - corrected images have a psf fwhm of 0.1@xmath11 near the sn position .
we first subtracted the median of a stack of bias exposures and then applied flat - field and distortion corrections to the nirc2 images .
although exposures of sn 2014j were acquired for the minimum possible integration time , the number of counts registered by the several pixels closest to the peak of the psf exceeded the range within which the detector has a linear response . both to register the ao exposures and then to measure the coordinates of the psf of sn 2014j , we needed to determine the center of the psf of the sn .
we therefore fit a two - dimensional gaussian model to the sn pixel intensity distribution in each of the exposures and allowed the psf center coordinates , fwhm , and normalization to vary .
saturated pixels in the nirc2 detector assume low data number ( dn ) values during readout .
for each exposure , we identified ( through visual inspection ) and masked the one or two pixels whose low dn values were consistent with a saturated pixel .
our @xmath17 goodness - of - fit statistic excludes pixels where the model value was in excess of the nonlinearity threshold .
centers of the fitted gaussian models coincided with the positions of the most saturated pixel .
the nirc2 exposures show no evidence for bleeding from saturated pixels .
we then used the best - fitting sn coordinates to align the reduced images .
the positions of the intensity peaks of many sources in m82 show variation with wavelength ; thus , to mitigate the contribution of this astrometric noise and to maximize the number of common sources , we registered the coadded _
k_-band image against archival _ hst _ f160w ( _ h _ ) images .
to minimize the effect of any remaining astrometric distortion in the nirc2 coadded image , we used sources only within the central section of the nirc2 coadded image when cross - registering with the _ hst _ f160w image . after extracting sources with sextractor @xcite and excluding extended objects with @xmath18 pixels
, we used the tweakreg routine in the astrodrizzle package to fit for an astrometric solution from common objects .
figure [ fig : ao ] shows the astrometrically matched , coadded _
k_-band exposure obtained with the nirc2 ao system , along with the coadded _
hst _ f160w image .
the position of the sn is in the world coordinate system ( wcs ) of the drizzled f160w image available from the hubble legacy archive ( hla ) .
the rms of the offsets between pairs of matched objects after applying the astrometric solution is in ra and in dec .
table [ tab : datasets ] provides a list of the _ hst _ imaging datasets of the explosion site that we use to place limits on the flux of the progenitor . except for the advanced camera for surveys ( acs ) exposures ,
the images within each dataset were processed , drizzled , and coadded to a common pixel grid by the hla team .
the acs coadded mosaics of drizzled images that we analyze are high level science products ( hlsp ) made available by the observers who acquired the data ( proposal 10776 ; pi : m. mountain ) .
we find an astrometric solution that aligns each coadded , drizzled _ hst _ image ( see table [ tab : datasets ] ) with the f160w reference coadded image through a sequence of two steps . the objective is to achieve an accurate astrometric solution near the coordinates of sn 2014j , so we trim each _ hst _ image to a subsection centered on the sn position . in the first step , we use the iraf ccmap routine to compute an approximate astrometric alignment using @xmath1910 sources in common between the images .
next we use source extractor ( sextractor ; @xcite ) to extract a catalog of objects in each image , and we derive a final astrometric solution from @xmath20500 sources using the tweakreg routine in the astrodrizzle package . in figure [
fig : hstimages ] , we show our measured sn coordinates , as well as those obtained by @xcite , in a coadded image of all pre - explosion _ hst _ exposures , and the f435w ( johnson _ b _ ) , f814w ( wide _ i _ ) , and f160w ( _ h _ ) _ hst _ coadded images .
the @xcite position was reported relative to the wcs of the hla f814w image , and we use our astrometric registration of the images to determine the location of the @xcite position in our reference f160w image . the sn 2014j position that we measure is offset by from the coordinates we calculate for the @xcite f814w position in the f160w image .
the angular distance between the position we estimate and the preliminary coordinates reported by @xcite may arise from several differences between our ao coadded images and astrometric fitting .
these include the substantially improved resolution of our nirc2 ao exposures ( 0.1@xmath11 ) compared to those analyzed by tendulkar et al .
( @xcite ; 0.36@xmath11 ) , our restriction of cross - matched sources to those inside of the central 16@xmath11 @xmath21 16@xmath11 region of the 40@xmath11 @xmath21 40@xmath11 wide - field nirc2 camera to minimize the effects of residual distortion , the numbers of matched sources ( and 8 , respectively ) incorporated into the astrometric fit by the two analyses , and our matching of sources in the _ k_-band nirc2 image against the near - ir _ hst _ f160w image as opposed to the _ i_-band f814w image to be able to minimize source confusion and the effects of differential reddening . as may be seen in the representative images in figure [ fig : hstimages ] , the local environment of sn 2014j exhibits strong surface brightness variations from both resolved and unresolved sources , as well as strong and varying extinction by dust . as in @xcite , our approach for estimating nondetection limits is to add artificial point sources .
we create a sequence of images , each with a superimposed artificial point source having fwhm appropriate to the _ hst _ instrument and bandpass filter .
we create a pixelated gaussian psf and use the pyfits package to add the artificial source to the _ hst _ image .
we place the psf @xmath222 pixels in a randomly determined direction away from the sn explosion site to avoid superimposing the psf on any possible underlying counts from a progenitor , which would yield a biased upper limit .
these offset positions are sufficiently modest that the local background is comparable to that at the sn site .
the artificial point source in each successive image contains 0.1 mag additional flux than that in the previous image .
we visually determine the limiting magnitude by identifying the first image for which the brightest pixel of the injected source has more counts than the neighboring local maxima produced by photon shot noise and background variation , and where pixels adjacent to the peak of the injected source have elevated counts consistent with a psf . to estimate the statistical significance of these visual detections for use in likelihood computations , we compute detection limits using a complementary technique .
we calculate the rms of the background flux in a region without detected sources or a strong intensity gradient .
we consider a 3@xmath12 detection to be one for which the source flux exceeds the background rms inside a 6-pixel aperture by a factor of 3 .
a circular aperture enclosing 80% of the flux of a point source is the default choice for most _ hst _ instruments when computing the signal - to - noise ratio ( s / n ) of a flux measurement using the exposure time calculator ( etc ) . for the acs wide field camera ( wfc )
, this corresponds to an area that includes @xmath23 pixels ( and corresponding background noise ) , and yields a limiting magnitude that is @xmath24 mag brighter and less sensitive than the value we compute for a 6-pixel background aperture . from inspection of the artificial point sources
, we find that visual detections , however , depend almost entirely on only the several pixels closest to the coordinates of the source .
we note that the limiting magnitudes of _ hst _ images calculated by @xcite in their analysis of the explosion site of sn 2011fe are consistent with estimates instead made using a circular aperture enclosing 80% of the flux .
as shown in table [ tab : datasets ] , the visual magnitude limits are comparable to the 3@xmath12 limits estimated using the background statistics . we assign accordingly a 3@xmath12 significance to the visual limits for the purpose of computing likelihood functions . to convert these limits on the apparent magnitudes of a progenitor system to constraints on a stellar source
, we use the @xcite library to model the spectral energy distributions ( seds ) of candidate progenitor systems of the sn , as well as ( following @xcite ) blackbody spectra with temperatures of 35,000 , 65,000 , and 95,000 k. for each combination of _ hst _ filter and instrument in table [ tab : datasets ] and all spectroscopic templates , we compute synthetic magnitudes with and without extinction from dust . after removing of foreground milky way ( @xmath25 ) extinction , @xcite estimated that additional extinction of with can best reproduce the shape of a premaximum optical spectrum of sn 2014j .
while we adopt the @xcite extinction curve for our progenitor constraints , we additionally compute synthetic magnitudes instead with an @xmath25 curve for m82 , using the total @xmath3 favored by @xcite .
as we demonstrate in [ sec : results ] , we obtain similar progenitor constraints for these differing values of @xmath2 . following @xcite , we first translate the upper limit on the flux for each filtered observation to a 2@xmath12 upper limit on the absolute magnitude @xmath26 , using a distance modulus to m82 of . after repeating this for all observations ,
we identify the most constraining upper limit on @xmath26 , and refer to this as the 2@xmath12 `` 1-frame '' limit for each spectrum template .
a combined constraint is estimated next by constructing a probability function that incorporates the upper magnitude limits in all filters .
the total probability ( as a function of @xmath26 and the template spectrum ) is the product of the probabilities of each filtered observation computed from the predicted model magnitude and the measured upper magnitude limit . to calculate the combined progenitor system limit
, we incrementally increase the absolute brightness @xmath26 until a 2@xmath12 probability ( @xmath27 ) is reached . as in @xcite ,
the combined constraints are @xmath280.8 mag deeper than `` 1-frame '' constraints which rely on observations in a single filter .
we would expect to detect , with 95% probability , such a 2@xmath12 source in a least one _ hst _ bandpass image , and in the coadded image in figure [ fig : hstimages ] .
table [ tab : datasets ] shows the detection upper limits for the coadded image of each dataset , and table [ tab : hrlimits ] lists the corresponding constraint on @xmath29 , in addition to @xmath26 , computed for each @xcite and blackbody spectrum . for each spectrum ,
the photometric band providing the faintest individual absolute magnitude limit is also identified in table [ tab : hrlimits ] . in figure
[ fig : rsoph ] , we plot the limits on the progenitor flux we estimate using the _ hst _ imaging . we also show measurements of the luminosity @xmath30 of rs oph during its quiescent phase as a function of frequency @xmath31 , and the uncertainty arising from current constraints on its distance .
the luminosity of rs oph is comparable to our upper detection limit mag , and the bright white dwarf primary in rs oph contributes significantly in bluer optical bandpasses , unlike the primary of t crb .
therefore , we create a near - uv to near - ir model of the spectrum of rs oph to account for the contribution of the white dwarf , and to show clearly the measurements that contribute to our constraints .
@xcite performed a decomposition of an optical spectrum of rs oph in its quiescent phase and find an a2 to a4 stellar spectrum for the hot component , and an m0 to m2 iii spectrum for the giant companion .
we fit for the linear combination of the corresponding @xcite stellar spectra that best matches the broadband magnitudes of rs oph during quiescence .
@xcite use an effective temperature of 3750 to 3650 k for the giant companion typical of m0 to m2 giant stars @xcite in their sn 2011fe progenitor analysis .
@xcite compiled _
j_- , _ h_- , and _
k_-band magnitudes of rs oph obtained during quiescence from 1971 through 1982 by @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite .
these measurements show modest variation of @xmath320.2 mag , and we use the median values ( @xmath33 , @xmath34 , @xmath35 mag ) as representative values during the quiescent phase .
magnitudes of rs oph measured by 2mass @xcite in 1999 ( @xmath36 , @xmath37 , @xmath38 mag ; see also @xcite ) , as well as values synthesized from a near - ir spectrum @xcite , are consistent with the magnitudes in quiescence assembled by @xcite .
we use the optical _ bvri _ photometry of rs oph during quiescence measured by @xcite to construct our model .
the @xcite optical measurements are , on average , fainter than those presented by @xcite for several epochs .
while @xcite combine optical and ir colors of rs oph taken on two dates to infer a possibly fainter flux in the ir , the combined values they present do not appear to be representative of the system in quiescence .
to estimate the luminosity of rs oph , we use mag @xcite , which is consistent with the value derived by @xcite , for an @xmath25 @xcite milky way extinction curve .
estimates for the distance to rs oph include @xmath39 kpc from modeling of the 2006 outburst ( e.g. , @xcite ) , @xmath40 kpc from radio observations of expanding material in the 1985 @xcite and 2006 @xcite outbursts , and @xmath41 kpc based on the assumption that the secondary fills the entire roche lobe @xcite . with a _
v_-band total magnitude of 11.5 in quiescence , we estimate a range in absolute magnitude of @xmath42 for distances of 1.4 kpc to 3.1 kpc . using our decomposition of the spectrum of rs oph in quiescence
, we estimate that the giant star should be @xmath43 mag fainter in @xmath44 than the total magnitude of the binary system .
as can be seen in figure [ fig : hstimages ] , the sn 2014j coordinates that the ao analysis favors are at a greater angular distance from the nearest resolved point source than the @xcite position .
this suggests that the star at a smallest angular offset is not a mass donor to the white dwarf progenitor of sn 2014j .
our coordinates also position sn 2014j closer to the center of an apparent dust cloud whose silhouette is visible in optical _ hst _ images .
figure [ fig : vband ] shows the derived constraints on the position of the progenitor system of sn 2014j in the hertzsprung - russell ( h - r ) diagram .
the upper luminosity limit excludes the bright extent of the region , marked in pale red , occupied by red giant stars .
the faint boundary of the red giant region corresponds approximately to the least luminous red giants in the hipparcos catalog @xcite , and we truncate the red giant region at an upper effective temperature of 5000 k. stars more luminous than the plotted @xmath45 mag bright boundary may instead be classified as red supergiant stars . with the exception of values for rs oph ( see [ sec : rsoph ] ) , we plot the ranges of effective temperature and @xmath26 values collected by @xcite for galactic candidate systems .
our luminosity limits are comparable to our faintest estimates for the luminosity of rs oph in quiescence , including the uncertainty in its distance in the galaxy .
the upper @xmath26 line intersects the @xmath26@xmath46 area corresponding to the less luminous galactic symbiotic system t crb @xcite .
u sco is a recurrent nova and supersoft x - ray source with a large white dwarf mass of @xmath47 m@xmath7 @xcite and a subgiant companion .
this candidate progenitor system is substantially too faint for detection in our archival images , as was the case for sn 2011fe . a candidate he
- rich single - degenerate progenitor system is the he nova v445 puppis ( v445 pup ) .
we use the @xcite estimate for @xmath26 based on a parallax distance measurement of @xmath48 kpc from the expansion of a bipolar shell after an eruption in year 2000 .
the upper luminosity limits for sn 2014j extend across the region of the h - r diagram corresponding to v445 pup .
figure [ fig : vband ] shows the theoretical limits on the he channel computed by @xcite using @xcite models and bolometric corrections from @xcite .
our measured limits are fainter than the predicted luminosities of he - star - channel progenitors with comparatively cool temperatures ( @xmath1 35,000 k ) . for comparison ,
we plot the luminosity limits for the progenitors of sn 2011fe @xcite and sn 2006dd @xcite ; the latter provides a constraint typical of sn ia other than sn 2011fe . for companions with very low effective temperature
( @xmath4 k ) , limits on the progenitor sn 2014j are significantly fainter than those for sn 2011fe , because the sn 2014j archival images extend to the near - ir . now referring to the stellar evolutionary tracks off the main sequence computed by @xcite , we find that a mass donor with effective temperature cooler than 4000 k would need to have a mass less than 2 m@xmath7 . the plotted evolutionary tracks are models with abundance ( @xmath49 ) consistent with the metallicity of m82 starburst regions @xcite .
the derived luminosity limits are significantly brighter than a hypothetical binary system of two white dwarfs that does not experience a long - lived merger phase @xcite , or a white - dwarf / main - sequence binary ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
comparison among the bright red (; mag ; @xcite ) , the dashed pale red (; mag ) , and the dashed pale blue (; mag ) lines shows that the progenitor constraints exhibit only modest change within the range of dust parameters reported from analyses of the sn 2014j light curve and spectra ( e.g. , @xcite ; @xcite ) .
while the total integration times of pre - explosion _ hst _ broadband imaging of the site of sn 2014j are almost all greater than that of the site of sn 2011fe , and m82 ( @xmath0 ; @xcite ) is at a smaller distance than m101 ( @xmath9 mpc ; @xcite ) , the upper flux limits at optical wavelengths that we estimate for the progenitor of sn 2014j are less constraining than those for the progenitor of sn 2011fe @xcite .
the brighter optical constraints on the progenitor of sn 2014j arise from the high extinction inferred along the line of sight to sn 2014j , and from the bright and varying local background in m82 ; the spectra and colors of sn 2011fe were consistent with a lack of extinction and it occurred at a location with low surface brightness . in the acs wfc
f814w flt images of the explosion sites , we measure an average of @xmath500.13 counts s@xmath51 pix@xmath51 close to the explosion site of sn 2011fe in m101 , and @xmath505.3 counts s@xmath51 pix@xmath51 close to sn 2014j in m82 .
we have used archival , pre - explosion _ hst _ images of m82 in the near - uv through near - ir to place constraints on the progenitor system of the type ia sn 2014j . assuming that the extinction and selective extinction along the line of sight to the sn estimated from the sn light curve and optical spectra are approximately correct ( e.g. , @xcite ; @xcite )
, we can exclude a progenitor system with a bright red giant mass - donor companion , including recurrent novae with luminosities comparable to the galactic prototype symbiotic system rs oph .
our limits are fainter than the predicted luminosity of he - star - channel progenitors with comparatively low effective temperature .
the available near - ir m82 data provide a fainter limit for mass donors with very low effective temperatures ( @xmath4 k ) than was possible at the explosion site of sn 2011fe in m101 . a hypothetical progenitor system consisting of two white dwarf stars that does not experience a long - lived merger phase
@xcite would have a luminosity significantly fainter than the upper limits we estimate .
cccccccc wfc3&uvis&f225w&2010 - 01 - 01&1665.0&11360&26.50&26.80 + wfc3&uvis&f336w&2010 - 01 - 01&1620.0&11360&26.71&27.23 + acs&wfc&f435w&2006 - 09 - 29&1800.0&10766&26.30&27.05 + wfc3&uvis&f487n&2009 - 11 - 17&2455.0&11360&26.01&25.94 + wfc3&uvis&f502n&2009 - 11 - 17&2465.0&11360&25.93&26.28 + wfpc2&wf&f502n&1998 - 08 - 28&3600.0&6826&21.76&22.70 + wfc3&uvis&f547m&2010 - 01 - 01&1070.0&11360&26.14&25.94 + wfpc2&wf&f547m&1998 - 08 - 28&100.0&6826&21.63&22.12 + acs&wfc&f555w&2006 - 03 - 29&1360.0&10766&26.42&26.52 + wfpc2&wf&f631n&1998 - 08 - 28&1200.0&6826&21.43&22.17 + acs&wfc&f658n&2004 - 02 - 09&700.0&9788&24.63&24.76 + acs&wfc&f658n&2006 - 03 - 29&4440.0&10766&25.06&25.17 + wfpc2&wf&f658n&1997 - 03 - 16&1200.0&6826&21.31&21.86 + wfc3&uvis&f673n&2009 - 11 - 15&2760.0&11360&24.53&25.62 + acs&wfc&f814w&2006 - 03 - 29&700.0&10766&24.83&25.09 + wfc3&ir&f110w&2010 - 01 - 01&1195.39&11360&23.54&23.51 + wfc3&ir&f128n&2009 - 11 - 17&1197.69&11360&22.90&22.85 + wfc3&ir&f160w&2010 - 01 - 01&2395.39&11360&22.43&22.48 + wfc3&ir&f164n&2009 - 11 - 17&2397.7&11360&21.98&22.17 [ tab : datasets ] cccccc o5 v&-3.25&-2.53&-2.51&-1.79&f555w + b0 v&-3.25&-2.55&-2.55&-1.85&f555w + a0 v&-3.26&-2.54&-3.26&-2.54&f555w + a5 v&-3.26&-2.48&-3.54&-2.76&f555w + f0 v&-3.08&-2.37&-3.61&-2.90&f814w + f5 v&-2.94&-2.26&-3.76&-3.08&f814w + g0 v&-2.76&-2.15&-3.77&-3.16&f814w + g5 v&-2.69&-2.08&-3.87&-3.26&f814w + k0 v&-2.55&-1.95&-3.93&-3.33&f814w + k5 v&-2.04&-1.40&-4.21&-3.57&f814w + m0 v&-1.63&-0.86&-4.49&-3.72&f110w + m4 v&-0.09&0.57&-4.52&-3.86&f110w + m5 v&0.71&1.43&-4.55&-3.83&f160w + b5 iii&-3.25&-2.54&-2.92&-2.21&f555w + g0 iii&-2.69&-2.03&-4.00&-3.34&f814w + g5 iii&-2.55&-1.90&-4.09&-3.44&f814w + k0 iii&-2.44&-1.79&-4.12&-3.47&f814w + k5 iii&-1.81&-1.03&-4.48&-3.70&f110w + m0 iii&-1.67&-0.86&-4.48&-3.67&f110w + m5 iii&0.18&0.90&-4.48&-3.76&f160w + m10 iii&3.84&4.42&-4.51&-3.93&f128n + b5 i&-3.26&-2.51&-3.09&-2.34&f555w + f0 i&-3.11&-2.38&-3.55&-2.82&f814w + f5 i&-3.04&-2.33&-3.70&-2.99&f814w + g0 i&-2.76&-2.13&-3.80&-3.17&f814w + g5 i&-2.60&-1.99&-3.91&-3.30&f814w + m2 i&-1.10&-0.42&-4.40&-3.72&f814w + bb1&-3.25&-2.53&-2.62&-1.90&f555w + bb2&-3.25&-2.53&-2.50&-1.78&f555w + bb3&-3.25&-2.53&-2.45&-1.73&f555w [ tab : hrlimits ] we greatly appreciate the critical contribution of observing time from vithal tilvi , nicola mehrtens , casey papovich , and mark dickinson that enabled us to complete the keck ao imaging , as well as their encouragement and helpful suggestions on the manuscript .
we thank michael liu , shriharsh tendulkar , yi cao , and trent dupuy for generously providing details of their nirc2 ao observations to aid our team in deciding whether any further imaging could be helpful .
correspondence with both matthew darnley and g. c. anupama was also useful .
a.v.f.s group at uc berkeley has received generous financial assistance from the christopher r. redlich fund , the tabasgo foundation , gary and cynthia bengier , and nsf grant ast-1211916 .
this work was also supported by nasa grants ar-12623 and ar-12850 from the space telescope science institute , which is operated by aura , inc . , under nasa contract nas 5 - 26555 .
k.j.s . is supported by nasa through einstein postdoctoral fellowship grant number pf1 - 120088 awarded by the chandra x - ray center , which is operated by the smithsonian astrophysical observatory for nasa under contract nas8 - 03060 .
some of the data presented herein were obtained at the w. m. keck observatory from telescope time allocated to nasa through the agency s scientific partnership with the california institute of technology and the university of california .
the observatory was made possible by the generous financial support of the w. m. keck foundation .
we recognize the hawaiian community for the opportunity to conduct these observations from the summit of mauna kea . , r. k. , mukai , k. , sokoloski , j. l. , et al .
2008 , in astronomical society of the pacific conference series , vol .
401 , rs ophiuchi ( 2006 ) and the recurrent nova phenomenon , ed .
a. evans , m. f. bode , t. j. obrien , & m. j. darnley , 52 | we constrain the properties of the progenitor system of the highly reddened type ia supernova ( sn ) 2014j in messier 82 ( m82 ; @xmath0 mpc ) .
we determine the sn location using keck - ii _ k_-band adaptive optics images , and we find no evidence for flux from a progenitor system in pre - explosion near - ultraviolet through near - infrared _ hubble space telescope ( hst ) _ images .
our upper limits exclude systems having a bright red giant companion , including symbiotic novae with luminosities comparable to that of rs ophiuchi . while the flux constraints are also inconsistent with predictions for comparatively cool he - donor systems ( @xmath1 35,000 k ) , we can not preclude a system similar to v445 puppis .
the progenitor constraints are robust across a wide range of @xmath2 and @xmath3 values , but significantly greater values than those inferred from the sn light curve and spectrum would yield proportionally brighter luminosity limits . the comparatively faint flux expected from a binary progenitor system consisting of white dwarf stars
would not have been detected in the pre - explosion _ hst _ imaging .
infrared _ hst _
exposures yield more stringent constraints on the luminosities of very cool ( @xmath4 k ) companion stars than was possible in the case of sn ia 2011fe . |
it is a long - standing problem to reproduce irreversible heat conduction phenomena , which are described by the fourier law , @xmath2 , where @xmath3 denotes the heat conductivity , on the basis of time - reversible microscopic dynamics .
recent studies have succeeded in reproducing the fourier law@xcite , and other linear nonequilibrium transport phenomena@xcite .
however , there remains an unsolved problem .
the studies cited above mainly used particle systems , such as hard spheres and lennard - jones particles , for example , but historically , nonlinear lattice systems have also been studied@xcite .
_ showed that the fourier law is reproduced in a three - dimensional ( 3d ) polymer - like lattice with an fermi - pasta - ulam-@xmath0 ( fpu-@xmath0 ) type interaction@xcite , but shiba _ et al .
_ observed the divergence of thermal conductivity for 3 and 4d fpu-@xmath0 lattices @xcite .
the purpose of this article is to study the energy transport behavior in nonlinear lattice systems .
let us start with a brief review of the study of heat conduction in nonlinear lattices .
it is well - known that no temperature gradients are formed if we use integrable systems , such as harmonic chains@xcite .
to realize linear temperature gradients , we need features that give rise to thermalization processes .
one possibility for generating such a feature is represented by nonintegrable nonlinear interactions@xcite .
nonintegrability results in macroscopically irreversible processes , even in conserved systems , even though the basic equation is reversible .
in recent years , heat conduction in 1d nonintegrable chains has been widely investigated@xcite . in these studies
, it was found that the heat conductivity of nonlinear lattices depends on the system size as @xmath4 , where @xmath5 denotes the length of the system , when the total momentum of the system is conserved .
although the value of the exponent @xmath6 seems to depend on the model , it is approximately 0.4 for several models , for example , fpu-@xmath0 lattices@xcite , fpu-@xmath6 lattices@xcite , diatomic toda lattices@xcite , and 1d binary hard - sphere gases@xcite exhibit similar power - law behavior .
this anomalous behavior originates in the power - law decay of the energy - flux autocorrelation function , @xmath7 , which is the integrand of the green - kubo formula@xcite , @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the total heat flux and @xmath10 is the volume of the system . in 1d nonlinear lattices , @xmath11 is the chain length .
the autocorrelation functions of systems with @xmath12 decay approximately as @xmath13 with @xmath14 .
phenomenological explanations for this decay exponent have been proposed using mode - coupling theory@xcite , the renormalization group analysis of 1d fluctuating hydrodynamics@xcite , and kinetic theory@xcite .
the same types of divergence of @xmath3 have been observed in 1d and 2d fluid systems . for simple classical fluids
, it has been well established that the autocorrelation function exhibits power - law decay called `` long - time tail''@xcite , which takes the form @xmath15 for @xmath16 .
this was discovered by alder and wainwright@xcite using computer simulations , and the study of long - time tail is still ongoing@xcite . in 3d systems
, the conductivity converges in the limit @xmath17 , as demonstrated by the green - kubo formula , eq .
( [ eq : gk ] ) . in 2d systems
, it diverges as @xmath18 .
such dimensionality dependence has been confirmed by computer simulations with hard - particle systems@xcite , lennard - jones fluids@xcite , and other systems .
the system dimensionality plays a key role in the behavior of transport coefficents in fluid systems .
how does the conductivity of nonlinear lattice systems depend on their dimensionality ?
one may naively expect a dependence that is similar to that in fluids , assuming that a phonon gas can be described by hydrodynamic equations of motion .
but this appears to be a too naive assumption .
recently , it was shown that the conductivity of a 3d extension of fpu-@xmath0 lattices displays divergence and that this divergence is consistent with the power - law decay of the autocorrelation function@xcite .
although the derivation of the long - time tail from the linearized hydrodynamic equations using the mode - coupling hypothesis@xcite implies its validity for mesoscopic to macroscopic scales , but not for microscopic scales , particle systems also possess long - time tails on microscopic scales . in simple particle systems ,
distances on the order of ten times the mean - free path are sufficient to observe the characteristic size dependence of the conductivity@xcite . in nonlinear lattices@xcite , however , it has been found that anomalous divergence continues up to systems of at least @xmath19 lattice sites .
this size corresponds to mesoscopic systems .
this means that the energy transport in nanoscopic to mesoscopic crystals is more complicated than that in fluid systems . from these findings , it is clear that further study of this problem is interesting both theoretically and with regard to nano technology .
such anomalous features should contribute to explanation of the anomalous features in heat transport observed in experiments and numerical simulations of nano scale systems such as carbon nanotubes@xcite .
our model and simulation method are presented in the next section .
the robust divergence of the thermal conductivity in 3d nonlinear lattices is demonstrated in the following two sections : in 3 , a simple cubic lattice is treated , and in 4 , an fcc lattice is treated . such divergence is also shown to exist in a system with a nonlinear interaction possessing a natural length scale in 5 . in 6 , the effect of the randomness of the mass is studied . in 7 ,
the results for a 2d nonlinear lattice are given .
the last section contains a summary and conclusion .
the first model we study is a simple 3d extension of fpu-@xmath0 lattices@xcite .
the model hamiltonian is @xmath20 , \label{eq:3dhamil}\ ] ] where the 3d vectors @xmath21 and @xmath22 denote the momentum and displacement of a particle at lattice point @xmath23 , respectively , and the mass @xmath24 is taken to be unity .
the summation over @xmath25 is a sum over nearest neighbors . @xmath26 and @xmath27 are parameters indicating the strength of interactions between these nearest - neighbor particles , and they are fixed as @xmath28 and @xmath29 in this paper .
we point out here that the spatial degrees of freedom of these dynamical models consist of the displacement vector @xmath30 , where @xmath31 represents the real spatial coordinates of the particles , and @xmath32 represents the equilibrium positions of the particles , which are at simple cubic lattice points . in other words ,
this model system possesses a crystal structure . in this model
the longitudinal and transverse modes are treated identically , and thus have the same dispersion relation in the harmonic limit .
the system size is denoted by @xmath33 .
we express the system size in terms of the number of particles @xmath34 , not the lengths @xmath35 .
thus , the system size is dimensionless @xmath36 . here , @xmath37 is the lattice spacing constant , which does not appear in the hamiltonian given by eq .
( [ eq:3dhamil ] ) . the only characteristic length scale that appears in eq .
( [ eq:3dhamil ] ) is @xmath38 , which is a typical length of phonon - phonon interactions .
we use periodic boundary conditions in the @xmath39- and @xmath40- directions .
the particles on both ends in the @xmath41-direction are attached to rigid walls , which are separated by one lattice space from the walls .
these particles interact with the wall through a potential that is identical to that for particle - particle interactions , and their local temperature is controlled by the nos - hoover method@xcite .
thus , the equations of motion are modified for these particles as @xmath42 here , @xmath43 denotes the nos - hoover thermostat variables , which obey @xmath44 where @xmath45 denotes the temperatures of the heat baths , which are set to @xmath46 on the left and @xmath47 on the right .
( here , @xmath48 increases to the right . )
the difference between @xmath46 and @xmath47 drives the energy transport in the system .
the quantity @xmath49 is the relaxation time of the heat baths , which is set to unity . for particles in the bulk ,
the equations of motion are @xmath50 particle dynamics simulations were used to study this system .
the initial displacements were zero for all particles ( _
i.e. _ , @xmath51 ) and the initial momenta @xmath21 were randomly assigned for each particle .
starting from this initial state , initial relaxation steps were discarded .
after the system reached a steady state , the temperature distribution , energy flux , and thermal conductivity were computed .
[ [ temperature ] ] temperature + + + + + + + + + + + using the virial theorem , we define the local temperature @xmath52 of a particle on lattice point @xmath23 as the long - time average of the kinetic energy .
( here , @xmath53 , @xmath54 . and @xmath48 are the labels of the lattice sites , with @xmath55 and @xmath56 . )
@xmath57 to obtain better accuracy , we averaged the temperature over the @xmath58 particles in the same cross section , and thus define @xmath59 as @xmath60 [ [ heat - flux ] ] heat flux + + + + + + + + + in this paper , we refer to energy flux as the heat flux , because the system itself is a thermodynamic system that relaxes to equilibrium due to its nonintegrability .
because the heat flux is conserved in the bulk region , there are two ways to measure it .
one way is to sum up the local contributions to the energy flow due to the interactions .
the microscopic energy transfer from site @xmath23 to site @xmath26 is given by @xmath61 where @xmath62 is the interaction potential between sites @xmath23 and @xmath26 . by performing this summation ,
we could obtain the total heat flow density as @xmath63 .
however , in this study , we used an alternative method ; we calculated the work done by the heat baths as @xmath64 here , the summation is over all the particles to which the left ( or right ) heat baths are attached .
we have confirmed that these two methods yield the same value of the heat flow to at least two significant figures .
[ [ thermal - conductivity ] ] thermal conductivity + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + in the simulations carried out for this study , the temperature distribution was found to be linear in the system and no temperature gap was observed .
therefore , the thermal conductivity @xmath65 can be estimated by @xmath66 for the numerical integration of the equations of motion , we used a strmer - verlet difference scheme , given by @xmath67 , \\
q_i^{n+1 } & = & q_i^n + \delta t\ \frac{p_i^{n+1/2}}{m } , \\ \zeta_i^{n+1
} & = & \frac{\delta t}{q } \left [ \sum_i \frac{(p_i^{n+1/2})^2}{3mk_bt } -1 \right ] \\
\mbox{and } & & \\
p_i^{n+1 } & = & p_i^{n+1/2 } -\frac{\delta t}{2}\left [ \frac{\partial}{\partial q_i}v(\ { q^{n+1 } \ } ) + \zeta_i^{n+1 } p_i^{n+1/2 } \right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath68 represents the number of time steps .
this scheme exhibits second - order convergence with @xmath69 .
for the bulk particles , without temperature control , this scheme reduces to the leap - frog integrator , which is symplectic .
therefore , the integration of the bulk area is numerically stable for all @xmath69 satisfying @xmath70 .
however , this scheme is not symplectic for the thermostatted particles .
the time step @xmath69 is taken to be small enough for the integration of these particles connected to the heat bath to be stable . throughout this paper
, @xmath69 is set to 0.02 .
the results for the simple cubic fpu-@xmath0 lattice are given in this section up to @xmath71 .
( a previous study gave results up to @xmath72@xcite . ) for each data point , the results are averaged over simulations starting from five independent initial conditions . first , we present the results for the temperatures @xmath73 . for this case , the spatial temperature profile is plotted in fig .
[ fig : temp1 ] for systems with @xmath74 , @xmath75 , and @xmath76 with the positions of the particles rescaled by the system size @xmath77 .
no boundary gap is observed in this temperature profile , and the results @xmath78 for all values of @xmath77 nearly coincide .
we thus conclude that we can estimate the thermal conductivity using eq .
( [ eq : conductivity ] ) .
the system size dependence of the estimated values of @xmath65 are plotted in fig .
[ fig : fpu3d ] on semi - log and log - log scales , up to the system size @xmath1 .
these results for @xmath65 suggest logarithmic divergence , although power - law divergence is not excluded .
when a power law is fitted to the data for @xmath79 , we obtain @xmath80 .
such a divergence was previously observed up to @xmath81@xcite , and it is now confirmed up to @xmath71 . note that the results show no sign of convergence . the behavior of @xmath65 when the heat bath temperatures are changed is shown in fig .
[ fig : tdiff2 ] . for the same @xmath77 , thermal conductivity becomes lower for higher @xmath82 .
this is expected because thermalization is enhanced when the temperature is high because of the stronger nonlinear interactions .
however , we observe that the divergence of @xmath65 with increasing system size is observed even at higher temperatures such as @xmath83 . .
[ fig : tdiff2 ] after beginning the simulation with the initial conditions described in 2 , we waited for the time period @xmath84 . by this time
, the system had relaxed to a nonequilibrium steady state , where the amount of energy flow per time was stationary . for the @xmath1 system , which is the largest system considered in the present study , and includes about @xmath85 particles , the total number of simulation steps multiplied by the number of particles is of the order of @xmath86 . for the @xmath1 system , approximately 20h of cpu time
was required to numerically calculate one sample , using an sx8 cluster with a peak performance of 128 gflops .
we also studied the thermal conductivity of an fcc system in order to determine its dependence on the lattice structure .
the hamiltonian of this model is also that given in eq .
( [ eq:3dhamil ] ) , but in this case , each particle interacts with its twelve nearest neighbors .
lattices of sizes @xmath87 are used , and each lattice point is again denoted by @xmath88 . in these simulations ,
particles only occupy sites where @xmath89 is even .
therefore , the total number of particles is @xmath90 .
nos - hoover heat baths were attached to the 1st and @xmath91th layers in the @xmath41-direction . in these layers ,
the particles are connected to the walls with the same interactions as those in the system discussed above ( fixed boundary condition ) .
periodic boundary conditions were adopted in the @xmath39- and @xmath40-directions .
similarly to the simple cubic case , it takes a time period of less than @xmath92 for the system to reach a nonequilibrium steady state .
the estimated values of the thermal conductivity are shown in fig .
[ fig : fcc2 ] up to the system size of @xmath93 .
the temperatures of the heat baths here are @xmath94 . in this figure ,
power - law divergence is clearly observed , and in this case , the possibility of logarithmic divergence is excluded .
fitting in the region @xmath95 yields @xmath96 .
this value of the exponent is larger than that for the simple cubic lattice 0.221(4 ) .
this suggests that the power - law exponent of the divergence is not determined only by the lattice dimensionality .
it is interesting that this divergence seems to be stronger than that in 1d models , for which the exponent was found to be approximately @xmath97@xcite .
using the hamiltonian in eq .
( [ eq:3dhamil ] ) , we can not realize a system in which longitudinal and transverse modes are treated differently .
however , in real solids , the dispersion relations for these modes generally differ , and they can have very different structures . to include such effects , we need to consider the interactions among the particles more carefully . here
, we consider the inclusion of the natural length of the interaction as a first step , and we consider the modified hamiltonian @xmath98 , \label{eq : nl}\ ] ] where @xmath99 , and @xmath100 is the natural length of the interaction .
a system comprising a simple cubic lattice was investigated using this hamiltonian by shimada _
et al . _ , and they observed normal heat conduction in three dimensions@xcite .
however , this model has the flaw that its transverse modes are softened , and as a result , the crystal structure was not maintained in their simulations . in order to realize a system that maintains a crystal structure in thermal equilibrium employing such a class of hamiltonians , we need to employ a stable structure .
one possibility is the fcc lattice , which can maintain its structure with only nearest - neighbor interactions . in this section
, we present simulation results for systems comprising fcc lattices , employing the hamiltonian in eq .
( [ eq : nl ] ) . here
, we set the parameters as @xmath101 the lattice structure here is the same as that in the previous sections .
thus , the heat flux flows along one of the face - centered directions , and the lattice constant is @xmath102 .
the temperatures of the heat baths were also set to @xmath94 in this case .
the temperature profiles are plotted in fig .
[ fig : tempfccn ] .
we again observe that the temperature gaps near the walls are small and that the results @xmath78 are the same for different system sizes @xmath5 .
we can therefore obtain the system size dependence of thermal conductivity using eq .
( [ eq : conductivity ] ) . as in the previous case
, we consider @xmath87 lattices with @xmath103 particles .
the system size dependence of thermal conductivity is plotted in fig .
[ fig : fccn ] on both semi - log and log - log scales .
it is clearly seen that the divergence is not logarithmic but of a power - law type .
fitting the data for the region @xmath104 , we obtain a tentative value for the power - law exponent of @xmath105 .
this result suggests that the anomalous behavior we have observed is not peculiar to a hamiltonian of the form of eq .
( [ eq:3dhamil ] ) , and we conjecture that it is a general property of insulating solids .
so far , all the results we have obtained for nonlinear lattice models with perfect crystalline order are consistent with anomalous thermal conductivity .
it is a future problem to investigate the extent to which this anomalous behavior can be observed .
the purpose of this paper is to show that the divergence of thermal conductivity is a robust property of nonlinear lattices , even in 3d cases .
it has been a long - standing belief that the following play important roles in thermal and transport phenomena : ( i ) nonlinearity in the interactions , ( ii ) the dimension of the system , and ( iii ) impurities or disorders . in the previous sections
, we showed that anomalous behavior exists if we include only ( i ) and ( ii ) . in this section , we investigate some systems with disorder . in 1d cases , disordered harmonic chains have been investigated for many years@xcite . for such systems driven by a langevin thermostat , it has been proved that there is a unique steady state with @xmath106@xcite .
li _ et al .
_ investigated heat transport in disordered fpu chains using nos - hoover thermostats@xcite .
they investigated heat transport at various temperatures and found that for sufficiently high temperatures , the thermal conductivity diverges as @xmath107 .
although in the case of nos - hoover thermostats , at low temperatures a unique nonequilibrium steady state might not exist , when the temperature @xmath108 is much higher than 0.5 , there should be no such problem . to eliminate this possible problem , therefore , we only investigated 3d systems at high temperatures .
the model we investigated has the following hamiltonian : @xmath109 .
\label{eq : massrand}\ ] ] the only difference between this hamiltonian and that appearing in eq .
( [ eq:3dhamil ] ) is that , in the above form , the masses of the particles @xmath110 vary among lattice sites .
this allows us to include disorder in the form of random masses .
we chose each @xmath110 as a random number given by @xmath111 where @xmath112 is a parameter adjusting the amplitude of randomness , and @xmath113 is a random number distributed uniformly on the interval of @xmath114 .
we set the average mass @xmath115 to unity .
using the hamiltonian in eq .
( [ eq : massrand ] ) , we carried out simulations for a system with a simple cubic lattice .
the setup for the simulation was similar to that for the simulations discussed in 3 , with @xmath116 .
the averages of the thermal conductivities obtained in 5 mass configurations were computed for various system sizes and two values of @xmath112 .
the system size dependence of the thermal conductivity is plotted in fig . [
fig : massrand ] .
it is observed that the thermal conductivity is lower when the effect of the disorder is stronger and that , here too , thermal conductivity diverges with increasing system size .
we conclude that disorder does not destroy the anomalous thermal conductivity .
because we could find no indication of normal heat conduction in the simulations considered so far , we also studied one extreme situation when the disorder effect should be very strong , that in which the system possesses impurities of infinite mass .
although the form of the hamiltonian in this case is also given by eq .
( [ eq : massrand ] ) , the mass was chosen as @xmath117 with a certain fraction of the masses set to infinity .
in other words , we fixed a certain fraction of the particles at their mechanical equilibrium position with @xmath51 .
we selected the fixed particles randomly from all the particles that are not connected to the heat baths with proportions of 10% and 20% .
these values are both below the critical percentage above which the paths of the heat flow are completely blocked . the system size dependence of the thermal conductivity is plotted in fig .
[ fig : fixed ] .
it is seen that although the model with @xmath118 fixed sites exhibits some divergence , the thermal conductivity of the model with @xmath119 fixed sites clearly converges to a finite value as @xmath77 is increased .
these results suggest that defects in crystalline solids play an important role in thermal conductivity behavior .
moreover , the conductivity clearly depends on the density of the fixed sites .
we now remark on past works investigating the 2d harmonic model with missing bond defects@xcite ( not missing particles ) , in which each particle has a scalar ( not vector ) dynamical variable , @xmath120 .
this model exhibits convergent thermal conductivity when there are sufficiently many missing bond defects , similarly to the system studied here .
more accurate , quantitative , and detailed investigations of the role of the various type of defects will be studied in the future .
here , we comment on some investigations of 2d systems .
we have already presented evidence that a 3d nonlinear lattice system generally exhibits power - law dependence on its system size . because it is unlikely that the thermal conductivity of a 2d system has weaker divergence than that of a three - dimensional system
, we conjecture that 2d nonlinear lattice systems also exhibit power - law divergence of the thermal conductivity .
there have not been many studies on 2d systems .
although it is not yet proven , it is widely believed that the thermal conductivity for such systems diverges logarithmically as the size increases@xcite .
we simulated a system consisting of a simple square 2d fpu-@xmath0 lattice whose hamiltonian is of the same form as eq .
( [ eq:3dhamil ] ) .
we fixed the aspect ratio to @xmath121 , where the @xmath40-axis is taken to be the direction of heat flow . for the size @xmath122
, we waited for approximately @xmath123 for the system to reach the nonequilibrium steady state .
the temperature profile of the steady state is plotted in fig .
[ fig:2dlimtemp ] .
it is seen that there are no temperature gaps near the walls .
thus , we can define the thermal conductivity by eq .
( [ eq : conductivity ] ) . the system size dependence of the thermal conductivity is plotted in fig .
[ fig:2dlim ] .
there , we see that the conductivity exhibits power - law divergence .
because the values of @xmath124 used here are much larger than the values of @xmath77 used in the three - dimensional systems that we studied , we can clearly distinguish the behavior here from logarithmic divergence .
the data presented here are sufficient to conclude that the divergence is stronger than conventional logarithmic divergence .
our estimation of the power - law exponent is @xmath125 , obtained by fitting in the region @xmath126 .
heat conduction in fpu-@xmath0 lattices was studied using nonequilibrium molecular dynamics simulations .
the divergence of the thermal conductivity was observed in simple cubic lattices up to the size @xmath1 .
such divergence was also observed in fcc lattice systems up to @xmath93 , in fcc lattice systems with a natural length included in the nonlinear interaction , and in simple cubic lattice systems with randomly distributed particle masses with a variance of 20% ( @xmath127 ) .
similar divergence for square lattice systems was also found for sizes up to @xmath122 .
these divergences are characterized by power - law dependences on the system size , and the power exponents do not appear to be unique , ranging from 0 ( logarithmic ) to @xmath128 for simple cubic lattice systems , and being approximately @xmath129 for fcc lattice systems .
convergence was observed in simple cubic lattice systems with randomly fixed particles .
the present results imply that the long - time - tail decay exponent @xmath130 of the energy flux autocorrelation function is not observed in the present systems with diverging thermal conductivity , although it has been observed in particle systems with an order - of - magnitude smaller number of degrees of freedom@xcite .
of course , the size limitation is always an issue to consider in finite - system analysis .
decay with an exponent of @xmath131 may appear in larger 3d nonlinear lattices , and thermal conductivity may converge .
for this reason , it would be worthwhile carrying out simulations on larger lattices using more powerful computers .
however , it should be remarked here that the @xmath1 lattice is already mesoscopic to macroscopic in the present technological sense : this lattice corresponds to insulators of size @xmath132nm@xmath133 when the lattice constant is assumed to be of the scale of diamonds , for example .
experimental observations of heat transport in crystals of this scale should be carried out .
there remain several open problems in addition to the system size problem .
one is to elucidate the direction dependence of the heat transport ; in the present study , the heat flow was always in the [ 001 ] direction .
another is to make the interaction potential function more realistic .
we are grateful to hisao hayakawa , masaharu isobe , tomio y. petrosky , akira shimizu , and akira ueda for fruitful discussions .
we also acknowledge keiji saito , takashi shimada , and satoshi yukawa for giving us ideas and assistance .
the numerical calculations were carried out on nec sx8 at yitp in kyoto university and hitachi sr11000 at issp in the university of tokyo . this work is partially supported by a japan society for the promotion of science grant ( no .
19340110 ) .
99 t. shimada , t. murakami , s. yukawa , k. saito , and n. ito : j. phys .
* 69 * ( 2000 ) 3150 .
t. murakami , t. shimada , s. yukawa , and n. ito : j. phys .
* 72 * ( 2003 ) 1049 .
f. ogushi , s. yukawa , and n. ito : j. phys .
. jpn . * 74 * ( 2005 ) 827 .
h. kaburaki , j. li , s. yip , and h. kimizuka , j. appl .
* 102 * ( 2007 ) 043514 .
t. ishiwata , t. murakami , s. yukawa , and n. ito : intern . j. mod
c * 15 * ( 2004 ) 1413 .
t. yuge , a. shimizu , and n. ito : j. phys .
* 74 * ( 2005 ) 1895 .
s. lepri , r. livi , and a. politi : phys . rep .
* 377 * ( 2003 ) 1 .
s. lepri , r. livi , and a. politi : phys .
* 78 * ( 1997 ) 1896 .
s. lepri : eur .
j. b * 18 * ( 2000 ) 441 .
t. hatano : phys .
e * 59 * ( 1999 ) r1 .
h. kaburaki and m. machida : phys .
lett . a * 181 * ( 1993 ) 85 .
k. aoki and d. kusnezov : phys .
* 86 * ( 2001 ) 4029 .
h. shiba , s. yukawa , and n. ito : j. phys .
* 75 * ( 2006 ) 103001 .
z. rieder , j. l. lebowitz , and e. lieb : j. math .
* 8 * ( 1967 ) 1073 .
r. e. peierls : _ quantum theory of solids _
( oxford university press , london , 1955 ) .
a. dhar , phys .
* 86 * ( 2001 ) 3554 .
g. casati and t. prosen : phys .
e * 67 * ( 2003 ) 015203(r ) .
m. s. green : j. chem
* 22 * 398 ( 1954 ) .
r. kubo : j. phys .
* 12 * ( 1957 ) 570 .
r. kubo , m. yokota , and s. nakajima : j. phys .
* 12 * ( 1957 ) 1203 .
s. lepri , r. livi , and a. politi : europhys .
* 43 * ( 1998 ) 271 .
o. narayan and s. ramaswamy : phys .
* 89 * ( 2002 ) 200601 .
t. mai and o. narayan : phys .
e * 73 * ( 2006 ) 061202 .
a. pereverzev : phys .
e * 68 * ( 2003 ) 056124 .
y. pomeau and p. rsibois : phys . rep .
* 19 * ( 1975 ) 63 p. rsibois and and m. de leener : _ classical kinetic theory of fluids _ ( john wiley & sons , new york , 1977 ) .
m. h. ernst , e. h. hauge , and j. m. j. van leeuwen : phys .
lett . a*34 * ( 1971 ) 419 .
m. h. ernst , e. h. hauge , and j. m. j. van leeuwen : phys .
rev . a * 4 * ( 1971 ) 2055 .
m. h. ernst , e. h. hauge , and j. m. j. van leeuwen : j. stat . phys .
* 15 * ( 1976 ) 7
. m. h. ernst , e. h. hauge , and j. m. j. van leeuwen : j. stat . phys . * 15 * ( 1976 ) 23 .
b. j. alder and t. e. wainwright : phys .
* 18 * ( 1967 ) 988 .
b. j. alder and t. e. wainwright : phys .
rev . a * 1 * ( 1970 ) 18 .
t. yuge and a. shimizu : j. phys .
* 76 * ( 2007 ) 093001 .
t. h. nishino : prog .
* 118 * ( 2007 ) 657 .
m. fujii , x. zhang , h. xie , h. ago , k. takahashi , t. ikuta , h. abe , and t. shimizu : phys .
lett * 95 * ( 2005 ) 065502 .
h. shioya , t. iwai , d. kondo , m. nihei , and y. awano : jpn .
* 46 * ( 2007 ) 3139 .
s. maruyama , physica b * 323 * ( 2002 ) 193 .
s. nos : prog .
* 103 * ( 1991 ) 1 .
d. n. payton and w. m. visscher : phys .
* 156 * ( 1967 ) 1032 .
a. casher and j. l. lebowitz : j. math .
* 12 * ( 1971 ) 1701 .
a. j. oconnor and j. l. lebowitz : j. math
. phys . * 15 * ( 1974 ) 692 .
h. matsuda and k. ishii : prog .
* 45 * ( 1970 ) 56 .
b. li , h. zhao , and b. hu : phys .
* 86 * ( 2001 ) 63 .
l. yang : phys .
* 88 * ( 2002 ) 094301 .
a. lippi and r. livi : j. stat .
* 100 * ( 2000 ) 1147 .
l. yang , p. grassberger , and b. hu : phys .
e * 74 * ( 2006 ) 062101 . | heat conduction in three - dimenisional nonlinear lattice models is studied using nonequilibrium molecular dynamics simulations .
we employ the fermi - pasta - ulam-@xmath0 model , in which nonlinearity exists in the interaction of the biquadratic form .
it is confirmed that the thermal conductivity , the ratio of the energy flux to the temperature gradient , diverges with increasing system size up to @xmath1 lattice sites .
this size corresponds to nanoscopic to mesoscopic scales of approximately 100 nm . from these results
, we conjecture that the energy transport in insulators with perfect crystalline order exhibits anomalous behavior .
the effects of the lattice structure , random impurities , and the natural length in interactions are also examined .
we find that fcc lattices display stronger divergence than simple cubic lattices . when impurity sites of infinitely large mass , which are thus fixed , are randomly distributed , such divergence vanishes . |
there is bountiful evidence for efficient particle acceleration at collisionless shocks in the universe .
the heliosphere , with its planetary bow shocks and traveling interplanetary shocks , has provided interesting and useful test cases for shock acceleration theories . in the remote regions of the universe , supersonic jets from active galactic nuclei ( agns ) and gamma - ray bursts ( grbs )
have offered fascinating windows into an energetic part of the cosmos , where non - thermal radio waves , x - rays and gamma - rays abound . fully understanding these sources mandates knowledge of how the particles that generate their light emission are energized .
the foremost paradigms invoke acceleration at relativistic shocks .
radio imaging reveals very structured and time - variable jets in agns , rapid x - ray and gamma - ray variability in both blazar agns and grbs suggest compact emission regions with relativistic bulk motions .
accordingly , comprehending the relationship between shock acceleration predictions and observations of these sources offers the key to elucidating the understanding of their environs ; this constitutes the focus of this paper . to effect this ,
an investigation of the features of diffusive shock acceleration is presented , using results from a test particle monte carlo simulation . then the paper addresses probes of the acceleration theory parameter space imposed by extant grb and blazar observations in high energy gamma - rays .
the monte carlo approach @xcite is one of several major techniques devised to model particle acceleration at relativistic shocks ; others include semi - analytic solutions of the diffusion - convection equation @xcite , and particle - in - cell ( pic ) full plasma simulations @xcite .
each has its merits and limitations .
tractability of the analytic approaches generally restricts their solutions to power - law regimes for the phase space distributions .
pic codes are rich in their information on shock - layer electrodynamics and turbulence .
however , to interface with astrophysical spectral data , a broad dynamic range in momenta is desirable , and this is the natural niche of monte carlo simulation techniques .
a core property of acceleration at the relativistic shocks is that the distribution functions are inherently anisotropic .
this renders the power - law indices and other distribution characteristics sensitive to directional influences , such as the magnetic field orientation with respect to the shock normal , and the nature of mhd turbulence that often propagates along the field lines .
these connections between observables and physical parameters of the shock environs are studied in some depth in this exposition .
the exploration of the properties of diffusive shock acceleration that is presented here employs the well - known kinematic monte carlo technique of ellison and jones that has been employed extensively in supernova remnant and heliospheric contexts , and is described in detail in numerous papers @xcite .
particles are injected upstream and allowed to convect into the shock , meanwhile diffusing in space so as to effect multiple shock crossings , and thereby gain energy through the shock drift and fermi processes . in general , the upstream fluid frame magnetic field is inclined at an angle to the shock normal .
the particles gyrate in laminar electromagnetic fields , with their trajectories being obtained by solving the lorentz force equation in the normal incidence shock rest frame ( nif ) , where the upstream flow is incident along the shock normal ( @xmath2-direction : see the left hand panel of fig .
[ fig : shock_geometry ] for the nif shock geometry ) . in this frame , when , there is a * u @xmath3 b * drift electric field in addition to the magnetic field .
the effects of alfvn wave and other hydromagnetic magnetic turbulence on particle propagation are modeled by phenomenologically scattering these ions elastically in the rest frame of the local fluid flow .
this is generally applicable for high alfnic mach number shocks .
the simulation outputs particle fluxes and momentum and angular distributions , usually in the nif , at any location upstream or downstream of the shock .
the simulation can routinely model diffusion incurred in particle interactions with mhd turbulence using either large - angle or small - angle scattering . at every scattering , the direction of the particle s momentum vector * p * is deflected in the local fluid frame to a new value @xmath4 .
the scattering angle is uniformly sampled within a solid angle up to a maximum deflection angle ( see figs . 2 and 3 of @xcite for the scattering geometry ) .
the time , , between scatterings in this frame is coupled @xcite to the mean free path , , and , via for particles of speed .
the resulting effect is that the gyrocenter of a particle with gyroradius is shifted randomly by a distance of the order of in the plane orthogonal to the local field .
accordingly , cross - field diffusion emerges naturally from the simulation . for large angle scattering ( las , defined more precisely below ) , the scattering solid angle is steradians , and the transport is governed by kinetic theory @xcite , where the ratio of the spatial diffusion coefficients parallel ( ) and perpendicular ( ) to the mean magnetic field is given by . here
, the parameter is the ratio of a particle s mean free path to its gyroradius .
as is often implemented for simplicity , in this work is assumed to be proportional to the particle momentum , so that is independent of .
this can be adjusted to accommodate other scattering laws as desired .
clearly , controls the amount of cross - field diffusion , and is a measure of the level of turbulence present in the system , i.e. is an indicator of .
the bohm limit of quasi - isotropic diffusion is realized when and .
this phenomenological description of diffusion in monte carlo techniques is most appropriate at high energies , and omits the details of microphysics present in plasma simulations such as pic codes . in the injection domain at slightly suprathermal energies ,
the influences of complex turbulent and coherent electrodynamic effects become important , and will substantially modify the picture from pure diffusion . -1.5truecm
-0.8truecm it will become clear below that in oblique relativistic shocks , the diffusive transport of particles across the field , and hence across the shock , becomes critical to their retention in the acceleration process .
accordingly , for such systems , the interplay between the field angle and the value of controls the spectral index of the particle distribution @xcite , a feature that is central to the interpretation of astrophysical source spectra . the phase space for acceleration theory results is now explored , before addressing their relevance to two classes of cosmic sources : gamma - ray bursts and blazars .
diffusive particle acceleration at relativistic shocks naturally divides into two regimes : mildly - relativistic ( ) and ultra - relativistic ( ) systems .
hereafter , subscripts denote upstream quantities . neither regime is accessible to diagnostics via _ in situ _ particle measurements since the principal astrophysical sources possessing relativistic shocks exhibiting signatures of acceleration , namely pulsar wind termination shocks , jets in active galactic nuclei ( blazars ) and gamma - ray bursts , are so distant .
an important property of diffusive acceleration at relativistic shocks that distinguishes them from their non - relativistic counterparts is their intrinsic anisotropy .
this is driven by the powerful convective influence that enables efficient loss of particles away and downstream from the shock .
the immediate consequence of this loss is a general difficulty in generating flat distributions of shock - accelerated particles , particularly for so - called superluminal ( ) relativistic discontinuities .
these losses are muted somewhat in mildly - relativistic shocks , which are naturally expected in grbs and perhaps also in blazars . moreover , the resulting distributions are more or less commensurate with those required to explain the radiation observations from these sources .
accordingly , this paper will study shocks , focusing on the power - law tails realized at high momenta , where all memory of the injection momentum has been destroyed by diffusion .
the array of possible distribution indices is highlighted , spawned by the sensitivity of both the energization in , and escape from , the shock layer , to ( i ) the size of the momentum deflection angle , ( ii ) the frequency or relative mean free path of scatterings , and ( iii ) the upstream field obliquity , a quantity connected to the global mhd structure of the shock . the first effect , the dependence of on , has been documented in several recent papers @xcite , and will just be summarized here .
when the diffusion in the shock layer samples large field fluctuations ( seen , for example , in pic simulations of relativistic shocks driven by the weibel instability @xcite ) , it corresponds to large momentum deflections , delineating the regime of large angle scattering ( las ) with ) , where is the upstream flow s incoming lorentz factor .
this regime was first explored for by ellison et al . @xcite .
such large deflections produce huge gains in particle energy , of the order of , in successive shock crossings .
these gains are kinematic in origin , and are akin to those in inverse compton scattering .
the result is an acceleration distribution that is highly structured and much flatter on average @xcite than for strong , parallel ( ) , shocks , i.e. those with high sonic and alfnic mach numbers .
the bumpy structure is kinematic in origin , corresponding to sequential shock transits @xcite , and becomes more pronounced @xcite for large .
for ultra - relativistic shocks , information of the injection momentum scale becomes insignificant when , and the bumps asymptotically relax to form a power - law distribution , with an index in the range of @xcite . from the plasma physics perspective , magnetic turbulence in relativistic shocks
could easily be sufficient to effect scatterings on intermediate to large angular scales , a proposition that becomes more enticing for ultra - relativistic shocks .
the principal focus in this paper is on particle distributions for regimes , which are much smoother in appearance , and often necessarily steeper , at least for superluminal regimes .
the property of distribution smoothness meshes more easily with radiation spectral observations of extragalactic astrophysical sources , thereby motivating exploration of this portion of phase space .
the kinematic energy gains in shock crossings are lowered considerably @xcite when drops below this `` lorentz cone '' angle .
accordingly , the character of and the particle anisotropy at the shock dichotomize , partitioned by the boundary .
intermediate scattering angles generate smooth distributions @xcite , much like those for small angle scattering ( sas , often called pitch angle diffusion , pad ) .
the sas regime has spawned the often cited asymptotic , ultrarelativistic index of for @xcite , first noticed in monte carlo simulations @xcite .
this special result , applicable in both shock rest and fluid frames for momenta , is realized only for parallel shocks with in the limit of , where the particle momentum is stochastically deflected on arbitrarily small angular ( and therefore temporal ) scales . in such cases ,
particles diffuse in the region upstream of the shock only until their velocity s angle to the shock normal exceeds around , after which they are rapidly swept downstream of the shock .
the lower kinematic energy gains in shock transits dominate higher shock - layer retention rates , and guarantee a steeper distribution under sas conditions for shocks ; the monotonic steepening and loss of structure as declines is exhibited in @xcite for ultra - relativistic shocks , and @xcite for the mildly - relativistic domain .
now the focus turns to the influence the effective frequency of scatterings , and the upstream field obliquity have on the accelerated population .
representative particle ( electrons or ion ) differential distributions that result from the simulation of diffusive acceleration at mildly - relativistic shocks of speed are depicted in the _ left panel _ of figure [ fig : sas_spec_index ] ( see @xcite for simulation results ) .
here , the subscript denotes components along the shock normal .
these distributions were generated for , i.e. in the sas regime , for low magnetic fields corresponding to alfvnic mach numbers , and in the nif frame .
results are displayed for two different upstream fluid frame field obliquities , namely and , with corresponding de hoffman - teller ( ht @xcite ) frame dimensionless speeds of and , respectively .
_ subluminal _ shocks are those where the ht flow speed corresponds to a physical speed , less than unity , i.e. the upstream field obliquity satisfies .
when , the de hoffman - teller frame does not exist , and the shock is said to be _
superluminal_. see the right hand panel of fig .
[ fig : shock_geometry ] for the ht frame shock geometry .
the distributions clearly exhibit an array of indices , including very flat power - laws , that are not monotonic functions of either the field obliquity nor the key diffusion parameter .
these properties are illustrated in the _ right panel _ of fig .
[ fig : sas_spec_index ] , where it is also evident that the distributions are generally steeper in superluminal shocks @xcite with . the left panel of fig .
[ fig : sas_spec_index ] also emphasizes that the normalization of the power - laws relative to the low momentum thermal populations is a strongly - declining function of .
this is a consequence of a more prolific convection of suprathermal particles downstream of the shock that suppresses diffusive injection from thermal energies into the acceleration process .
such losses are even more pronounced when , to the point that acceleration is not statistically discernible for runs with simulated particles .
this feature is salient for the discussion on astrophysical sources below .
-0.1truecm the existence of very flat distributions in the subluminal domain for very large is a remarkable feature of figure [ fig : sas_spec_index ] .
this phenomenon was identified by kirk & heavens @xcite in their eigenfunction solution technique @xcite for the diffusion - convection equation , which was restricted to subluminal , oblique shocks .
results for their analysis are presented as the solid curve labelled kh89 in the right panel of the figure .
clearly , the monte carlo indices closely approach those of the semi - analytic method of @xcite for , an agreement that is improved slightly when is increased to .
yet there are differences between the two approaches , and these yield the expected slight discrepancies in spectral index determination .
the method of @xcite , being tantamount to a guiding center technique , employs conservation of the magnetic moment for particle - shock interactions when determining transmission and reflection probabilities of charges , naturally differing from gyro - orbit determinations of these probabilities .
this nuance probably seeds the different values of derived in the two approaches , which , as expected , are small when shocks are effectively parallel , and highly oblique . more details of the comparison of these approaches are discussed in @xcite , which provides an extended exposition on the implementation of the monte carlo code , its validation and many of its key acceleration results .
it can also be noted that comparing with the indices derived by @xcite was the major motivation behind the artificial choice of the compression ratio , which is somewhat larger than the rankine - hugoniot mhd value for , conditions .
also , a low sonic mach number was chosen so as to maximize the efficiency of injection from thermal energies .
the origin of these flat indices is elucidated by the parameter survey here , and more specifically by the inclusion of cross field diffusion in the monte carlo simulations .
diffusive transport of particles perpendicular to the mean field was omitted in the analysis of @xcite , a restriction that is the primary reason for dropping below two .
this is clearly evident from the right panel of figure [ fig : sas_spec_index ] , which indicates that scenarios are realized only for , i.e. laminar fields and almost pure gyrational motion .
the primary origin of the acceleration is then connected to coherence in the shock layer . to provide further insight , individual particle trajectories were tracked in the monte carlo runs , and those exhibiting profound energy gains isolated .
one such example is provided in fig .
[ fig : sas_traj_mom ] , together with its corresponding momentum trace ( right panel ) ; the particles were injected with superthermal momenta to circumvent any injection problems .
diffusion has minimal impact on the gyrational motion in the left panel .
the trajectories are 2d projections , and the pitch angle is evolving almost adiabatically in the particle - shock interaction to preserve gyrational coherence .
the momentum histories in the right hand panel more readily highlight the property that the acceleration is directly coupled to periods when the particle s gyration straddles the shock .
moreover , inertial motion in the or * u*@xmath3*b * direction accompanies these epochs of energization .
these two characteristics are the hallmarks of _ shock drift acceleration _
( sda ) . ; the large value of is adopted to generate the requisite conditions for coherent interaction with the shock . in this projection ,
energy gains incurred while the particle s gyrations straddle the shock only become obvious when its pitch angles are altered in upstream transits .
particles that undergo these trajectories are rare , but populate the power - law tail .
the coupling between the fluid frame ( ) and nif shock rest frame ( ) momenta of the particle selected in the left panel , and the drift coordinate .
the shock frame momentum evinces oscillatory behavior during upstream excursions , and both and display the linear trend with drift that is characteristic of shock drift acceleration .
the fluid frame momentum exhibits a `` rectangular hysteresis '' while the particle gyrates in the shock layer .
, title="fig : " ] -0.1truecm ; the large value of is adopted to generate the requisite conditions for coherent interaction with the shock . in this projection ,
energy gains incurred while the particle s gyrations straddle the shock only become obvious when its pitch angles are altered in upstream transits .
particles that undergo these trajectories are rare , but populate the power - law tail .
the coupling between the fluid frame ( ) and nif shock rest frame ( ) momenta of the particle selected in the left panel , and the drift coordinate .
the shock frame momentum evinces oscillatory behavior during upstream excursions , and both and display the linear trend with drift that is characteristic of shock drift acceleration .
the fluid frame momentum exhibits a `` rectangular hysteresis '' while the particle gyrates in the shock layer .
, title="fig : " ] the acceleration of particles in the drift electric fields associated with oblique shock discontinuities has been extensively studied in non - relativistic contexts @xcite .
the origin of the effect is the net work done on a charge by the lorentz force in a zone of non - uniform magnetic field .
the principal equation governing this is @xmath5 where * e * is the * u*@xmath3*b * drift field that exists in any oblique shock rest frame other than the ht frame . in the uniform
* b * fields either upstream or downstream , the energy gains and losses acquired during a gyroperiod exactly cancel , so that no net work is done , .
in contrast , when a charge s gyromotion straddles the shock discontinuity , the sharp field gradient induces an asymmetry in the time spent by the charge either side of the shock , so that energy gains and losses do not negate each other . the compressive nature of the field discontinuity biases the net work done to positive increments in shock encounters between upstream excursions , and it is simply shown @xcite that , i.e. this energy gain scales linearly with displacement along the drift coordinate .
this is the punchline of the right panel of fig .
[ fig : sas_traj_mom ] , where effectively represents a time coordinate during shock drift episodes , with .
it is also noteworthy that interspersed between these acceleration periods are upstream excursions where infrequent scattering slowly tries to isotropize the pitch angles , a feature clearly identified for the sda phenomenon at non - relativistic shocks @xcite . particles that participate in the sda initially have ht frame pitch angle cosines considerably less than unity , so as to satisfy the reflection criterion : therefore they are rare in near - luminal shocks , for which the incident upstream angular distribution is highly - beamed around . during upstream excursions that follow reflection ,
the particles tend to get swept back to the shock as soon as they are deflected and acquire momenta outside their lorentz cone , i.e. before reaching isotropy in the upstream fluid frame .
therefore , in these cases , continues to satisfy the reflection criterion during these brief upstream epochs .
the repetition of sda and upstream excursions , i.e. trapping in and near the shock , is therefore virtually guaranteed once the initial reflection is realized for a select particle .
this investigation provides an identification of the significance of shock drift acceleration in controlling for relativistic shocks .
the reason it couples to unusually flat distributions ( ) revolves around extremely efficient trapping in the shock layer , which permits repeated episodes of sda in select particles with appropriately - tuned gyrophases at the onset of shock - orbit interactions .
the combination of the rapid energization rate , upstream hiatuses in sda , and a slow leakage rate downstream leads naturally @xcite to an approximate distribution .
but only when .
the introduction of turbulence easily disrupts the coherence and precipitates efficient convection downstream @xcite , quenching the effectiveness of sda .
the result then is a dominance of shock drift acceleration contributions by first order fermi ( turbulent ) ones when . more importantly ,
when , an inexorable sweeping of charges downstream in superluminal shocks overpowers both acceleration contributions and steepens the spectrum dramatically , as is evident in the right panel of fig .
[ fig : sas_spec_index ] .
the shock acceleration theory results presented in the previous section can now be interpreted in the light of observations of astrophysical sources .
the first class of germane sources consists of gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) , whose prompt emission is generally observed in the 10 kev - 10 gev range , with a characteristic spectral break around 200 kev to 1 mev . above this break ,
the spectrum is generally ( but not always ) an extended power - law .
the focus here is on the relationship between the high energy spectral index and the underlying particle acceleration conditions .
this forges a direct connection to data from cgro s egret telescope , and now to the growing database of _ fermi _ lat burst detections .
the egret index distribution @xcite is constituted by a handful of sources with indices scattered in the range , with brighter bursts indices concentrated in the range , as tabulated in @xcite .
the recent _ fermi _ detection @xcite of grb 080916c in both the gbm and lat instruments offered an index of at energies above mev in its most luminous epoch , and a steeper spectrum ( ) at other times .
it is then evident that observationally , shock acceleration models must accommodate a radiation spectral index in the range in order to be viable .
moreover , they must reasonably account for the spectral variability identified in grb 080916c , i.e. fluctuating values in a given source .
if one presumes that these photon spectra result from synchrotron emission that rapidly cools the radiating electrons , a popular paradigm @xcite for the production of the prompt emission , then for electron acceleration populations .
the corresponding to the values of for the flat - spectrum egret burst grb 930131 and for grb 080916c for time intervals ( c , e ) @xcite are marked on the right panel of fig .
[ fig : sas_spec_index ] .
it then becomes clear that the emission in grb 930131 is consistent with acceleration at subluminal shocks and relatively near the bohm diffusion limit .
in contrast , the slightly steeper grb 080916c spectrum is better explained by mildly superluminal shocks in the - obliquity range , but only if the scattering is strong , i.e. . if , instead , synchrotron cooling is inefficient , the photon differential spectral index given by .
then the injected distribution must have an index higher by unity than that for cooling models , in order to match the burst observations .
this is a profound difference in that it moves the viable shock parameter space into the superluminal range , i.e. at higher field obliquities , and bohm - limited diffusion is observationally excluded .
no bursts have so far evinced extended power - law spectra flatter than , absolving the need for acceleration in shocks with extremely low turbulence , i.e. regimes .
this is fortunate , since , from the left panel of fig .
[ fig : sas_spec_index ] , such shocks are inherently inefficient accelerators .
moreover , the generation of field turbulence is a natural part of dissipation in shocks , so that almost laminar fields are not expected , nor observed in _ in situ _
magnetometer measurements at heliospheric shocks ( e.g. @xcite and references therein ) .
the second relevant astrophysical context concerns blazars , the subset of active galactic nuclei possessing relativistic jets of material emanating from the supermassive black holes at their centers ; these jets are oriented virtually towards the observer .
these have been the preserve of gamma - ray experiments ever since their discovery by egret @xcite , and subsequent observation by ground - based cherenkov telescopes at tev energies @xcite .
the tev - band signals typically exhibit steep photon spectra ( e.g. mkn 421 : @xcite ) that include the absorption due to pair producing interactions with infra - red and optical light generated by the intergalactic medium along the line of sight to the observer . the correction for this attenuation ( so called _ de - absorption _ ) , leads to the inference of extremely flat particle distributions in energetic gamma - ray blazars ( see for example @xcite ) , with indices as low as in high redshift sources . to accommodate
these observational constraints would require subluminal shocks with very modest or low turbulence levels .
yet , such inferences are based upon measurements in a limited waveband subject to profound absorption .
more improved diagnostics are now enabled by _
lat detections of blazars , which extend the observational window over a much larger energy range , nominally from 100 mev to over 1 tev , and most crucially , below the attenuation window .
accordingly , _ fermi _ observations can more directly probe the underlying radiating particle population .
a prime example of this is the multi - wavelength campaign on the pks 2155 - 304 blazar @xcite in a non - flare state , whose combined _ fermi_-_hess _
spectrum from 300 mev to 3 tev indicates an unattenuated photon spectral index of , steepening to above 1 gev . for a standard inverse compton scattering interpretation with insignificant radiational cooling
, this translates to an electron power - law index in the range , so that acceleration at mildly superluminal oblique shocks should provide the best description .
this paper has investigated some of the key characteristics of particle acceleration at relativistic shocks , including the identification of the role of shock drift acceleration in generating flat distributions in mildly - relativistic , subluminal shocks .
it has also explored the connection between the acceleration process and high energy emission in two classes of astrophysical sources , namely gamma - ray bursts and jets in blazars .
the simulation results presented clearly highlight the non - universality of the index of energetic , non - thermal electrons and ions , spawned by the variety of shock obliquities and the character of hydromagnetic turbulence in their environs .
this non - universality poses no problem for modeling grb or blazar high - energy power - law indices , though observations generally constrain the parameter space to subluminal or highly - turbulent and modestly superluminal shocks not far from the bohm diffusion limit .
diffusive acceleration at ultra - relativistic shocks requires in order to generate sufficiently low to mesh with observed source photon spectra .
it is unclear whether conditions in bursts and blazars can support such levels of turbulence at shocks embedded in their relativistic outflows , though it should be noted that large field fluctuations naturally emerge in pic simulations of weibel instability - driven relativistic shocks .
it is anticipated that the rich prospects for _ fermi _ gamma - ray observations of blazars and grbs in the next few years will enhance our understanding of particle acceleration in their environs .
ellison , d. c. , jones , f. c. & reynolds , s. p. 1990
, , @xmath6360 , 702 .
ellison , d. c. & double , g. p. 2004
, , @xmath622 , 323 .
niemiec , j. , & ostrowski , m. 2004 , , @xmath6610 , 851 .
stecker , f. w. , baring , m. g. & summerlin , e. j. 2007 , , @xmath6667 , l29 . baring , m. g. 2004 , nucl .
b , @xmath6136c , 198 .
kirk , j. g. & schneider , p. 1987
, , @xmath6315 , 425 .
kirk , j. g. & heavens , a. f. 1989 , , @xmath6239 , 995 .
kirk , j. g. , guthmann , a. w. , gallant , y. a. , achterberg , a. 2000 , , @xmath6542 , 235 .
hoshino , m. , arons , j. , gallant , y. a. & langdon , a. b. 1992 , @xmath6390 , 454 .
nishikawa , k .-
i . , et al . 2005 , , @xmath6622 , 927 .
medvedev , m. v. , et al .
2005 , , @xmath6618 , l75 .
spitkovsky , a. 2008 , , @xmath6682 , l5 .
jones , f. c. & ellison , d. c. 1991 , @xmath658 , 259 .
summerlin , e. j. & baring , m. g. 2006 , , @xmath638(7 ) , 1281 .
ellison , d. c. , baring , m. g. & jones , f. c. 1995 , @xmath6453 , 873 .
summerlin , e. j. & baring , m. g. 2009 , , in preparation .
forman , m. a. , jokipii , j. r. & owens , a. j. 1974 , @xmath6192 , 535 .
baring , m. g. 1999 , in _ proc .
of the 26th icrc , vol .
iv , p. 5 , . baring , m. g. 2009 , in _ proc .
6th huntsville grb symposium _ , eds . c. a. meegan , et al . , n. gehrels ,
& c. kouveliotou ( aip conf .
proc . 1133 , new york )
294 bednarz , j. & ostrowski , m. 1998 , , @xmath680 , 3911 .
de hoffman , f. & teller , e. 1950 , , @xmath680 , 692 .
sarris , e. t. , & van allen , j. a. 1974 , , @xmath679 , 4,157 .
jokipii , j. r. 1982 , , @xmath6255 , 716 .
pesses , m. e. , decker , r. b. & armstrong , t. p. 1982
, @xmath632 , 185 .
webb , g. m. , axford , w. i. & terasawa , t. 1983 , , @xmath6270 , 537 .
decker , r. b. & vlahos , l. 1986 , , @xmath6306 , 710 . baring , m. g. & summerlin , e. j. 2009 , , in preparation .
dingus , b. l. 1995 , , @xmath6231 , 187 . baring , m. g. & 2006 , , @xmath6650 , 1004 .
abdo , a. a. , et al .
( the _ fermi _ collaboration ) 2009 , science , @xmath6323 , 1688 .
rees , m. j. & mszros , p. 1992
, , @xmath6258 , 41p .
piran , t. 1999 , phys .
rep . , @xmath6314 , 575 .
mszros , p. 2002 , ann .
, @xmath640 , 137 .
balogh , a. , et al .
1995 , @xmath672 , 171 .
baring , m. g. , ogilvie , k. w. , ellison , d. , & forsyth , r. 1997 , , @xmath6476 , 889 .
hartman , r. c. , bertsch , d. l. , fichtel , c. l. , et al .
1992 , , @xmath6385 , l1 .
punch , m. , akerlof , c. w. , cawley , m. f. , et al .
1992 , nature,@xmath6358 , 477 .
krennrich , f. , bond , i. h. , bradbury , s. m. , et al .
2002 , , @xmath6575 , l9 .
aharonian , f. , akhperjanian , a. g. , beilicke , m. , et al .
2003 , ,@xmath6410 , 813 .
aharonian , f. , akhperjanian , a. g. , anton , g. , et al .
2009 , , @xmath6696 , l150 . | diffusive shock acceleration ( dsa ) at relativistic shocks is expected to be an important acceleration mechanism in a variety of astrophysical objects including extragalactic jets in active galactic nuclei and gamma ray bursts .
these sources remain strong and interesting candidate sites for the generation of ultra - high energy cosmic rays . in this paper , key predictions of dsa at relativistic shocks that are salient to the issue of cosmic ray ion and electron production
are outlined .
results from a monte carlo simulation of such diffusive acceleration in test - particle , relativistic , oblique , mhd shocks are presented .
simulation output is described for both large angle and small angle scattering scenarios , and a variety of shock obliquities including superluminal regimes when the de hoffman - teller frame does not exist .
the distribution function power - law indices compare favorably with results from other techniques .
they are found to depend sensitively on the mean magnetic field orientation in the shock , and the nature of mhd turbulence that propagates along fields in shock environs .
an interesting regime of flat spectrum generation is addressed , providing evidence for its origin being due to shock drift acceleration .
the impact of these theoretical results on gamma - ray burst and blazar science is outlined .
specifically , _ fermi _ gamma - ray observations of these cosmic sources are already providing significant constraints on important environmental quantities for relativistic shocks , namely the frequency of scattering and the level of field turbulence . to appear in proc .
of the _ 8th international astrophysics conference _
+ `` shock waves in space and astrophysical environments , '' ( 2010 ) , + eds .
x. ao , r. burrows & g. p. zank ( aip conf . proc . 1183 , new york ) .
address=@xmath0 department of physics and astronomy , ms-108 , rice university , p. o. box 1892 , + houston , tx 77251 - 1892 , usa email : [email protected] + @xmath1 heliospheric physics laboratory , code 672 , nasa s goddard space flight center , + greenbelt , md 20770 , usa email : [email protected] |
in recent years , compressive sensing ( cs ) has influenced many fields in signal processing .
basically , the theory states that if an unknown signal @xmath0 can be sparsely represented , only a few @xmath1 linear and non - adaptive measurements @xmath2 of the signal suffice to accurately reconstruct it . denoting the measurement vectors by @xmath3
, the measurement process can be compactly written as @xmath4^{\top } \bf{s } + \bf{z } = \bf{\phi } \bf{s } + \bf{z},\ ] ] where @xmath5 is the measurement matrix , and @xmath6 constitutes possible sampling errors . due to the reduced dimensionality ,
reconstructing @xmath7 from the measurements is ill - posed in general , and can not be done by simply inverting @xmath8 . however
, additional model assumptions on @xmath7 may help to find a solution . in this context ,
the _ sparse synthesis - approach _ and the _ co - sparse analysis - approach _ @xcite have proven extremely useful . in the sparse synthesis approach
it is assumed that a signal can be decomposed into a linear combination of only a few columns , called atoms , of a known dictionary @xmath9 with @xmath10 , i.e. @xmath11 with @xmath12 being the sparse coefficient vector .
many algorithms for solving the synthesis problem exist , cf . @xcite for an extensive overview .
the co - sparse analysis approach is a similar looking but yet very different alternative to tackle the cs problem .
its underlying assumption is that a signal multiplied by an _ analysis operator _
@xmath13 with @xmath14 results in a sparse vector @xmath15 .
if @xmath16 denotes a function that measures sparsity , the analysis model assumption is exploited via @xmath17 the analysis model has proven useful in the field of image reconstruction and we thus restrict ourselves to compressively sensed images here .
our approach is motivated by the observation that learning the operator leads to an improved image reconstruction quality @xcite , @xcite compared to applying a finite difference operator that approximates the image gradient , known as total variation ( tv - norm ) regularization @xcite , @xcite .
in contrast to the task of dictionary learning only a few analysis operator learning algorithms have been proposed in the literature so far , cf .
@xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite .
furthermore , from image denoising it is known that the reconstruction accuracy can be further improved when the dictionary or operator is not only learned on some general and representative training set , but rather directly on the specific signal that has to be reconstructed @xcite , @xcite .
these observations prompted us to combine the image reconstruction performance of the analysis approach together with the accuracy improvement capabilities of a learned operator .
the principle of cs relies on the fact that the signal @xmath18 has a sparse representation in a _ given _ basis or dictionary @xmath19 that is universal for the considered signal class of interest . however , such universal dictionaries do not necessarily result in the sparsest possible representation , which is crucial for the recovery success . due to this , in @xcite the concept of blind compressive sensing ( bcs ) has been introduced , which aims at simultaneously learning the dictionary and reconstructing the signal , see also @xcite and @xcite for an extension of this idea .
note that all these methods are based on the synthesis model and consider the problem of finding a suitable dictionary , while in this paper we focus on the analysis model .
in this work we address the problem of signal reconstruction from compressively sensed data regularized by an adaptively learned analysis operator .
the work of hawe _ et al . _
@xcite , which focuses on learning a global patch based analysis operator from noise free training samples , has already shown the superior performance of a learned operator compared to state - of - the - art analysis and synthesis based regularization , like e.g. k - svd denoising , in the context of classical image reconstruction problems .
that is why we extend this idea and build on their work to utilize the learning process to obtain a signal dependent regularization of the inverse problem .
since we are dealing with compressive measurements , our approach can be interpreted as an analysis - based bcs problem with no prior knowledge about the operator .
we extend the algorithm proposed in @xcite , where the operator is learned by a geometric conjugate gradient ( cg ) method on the so - called oblique manifold , to our setting of simultaneous image reconstruction and operator learning .
this approach allows us to compensate for various sampling noise models , i.e. gaussian or impulsive noise , by simply exchanging the data fidelity term .
to summarize , the advantages of our approach are as follows : ( i ) the learning process allows to adaptively find an adequate operator that fits the underlying image structure .
( ii ) there is no necessity to train the operator prior to the reconstruction .
( iii ) different noise types are handled by simply exchanging the data fidelity term .
our goal is to find a local analysis operator @xmath20 with @xmath14 simultaneously to the signal @xmath21 that has to be reconstructed from the compressive measurements . here
, the vector @xmath18 denotes a vectorized image of dimension @xmath22 , with @xmath23 being the width and @xmath24 being the height of the image , respectively , obtained by stacking the columns of the image above each other .
note that the analysis operator has to be applied to local image patches rather than to the whole image .
we denote the binary @xmath25 matrix that extracts the patch centered at the @xmath26 pixel by @xmath27 .
furthermore , practice has shown that the learning process is significantly faster if _ centered _
, i.e. zero mean patches are considered .
this can be easily incorporated by multiplying the vectorized patch with @xmath28 , where @xmath29 and @xmath30 are the identity operator and the matrix with all elements equal to one , respectively .
we employ constant padding at the image borders , i.e. replicating the boundary pixel values . in the end
, we globally promote sparsity with an appropriate function @xmath31 and write for the problem of finding a suitable analysis operator @xmath32 where @xmath33 denotes an admissible set , which implies some constraints on @xmath34 to avoid trivial solutions .
we follow the considerations of the authors in @xcite , demanding that : the rows of @xmath34 have unit euclidean norm , i.e. @xmath35 , for @xmath36 , where @xmath37 denotes the transposed of the @xmath38-row of @xmath34 . the analysis operator @xmath34 has full rank , i.e. @xmath39
. the mutual coherence of the analysis operator should be moderate .
these constraints motivate to consider the set of full rank matrices with normalized columns , which admits a manifold structure known as the oblique manifold @xmath40 here , @xmath41 is the diagonal matrix whose entries on the diagonal are those of @xmath42 .
since we require the rows of @xmath34 to have unit euclidean norm , we restrict @xmath43 to be an element of @xmath44 . to enforce the rank constraint ( ii )
we employ the penalty function @xmath45 furthermore , the mutual coherence of the analysis operator , formulated in constraint ( iii ) , can be controlled via the logarithmic barrier function of the atoms scalar products , namely @xmath46 considerations concerning the usefulness of these penalty functions can be found in @xcite . to measure the sparsity of the analyzed patches , we use the differentiable sparsity promoting function @xmath47 where @xmath48 is a positive constant and @xmath49 represents the @xmath50 standard basis vector with the same length as @xmath51 .
since we are interested in simultaneous operator learning and image reconstruction , we further introduce a data term @xmath52 , which measures the fidelity of the reconstructed signal to the measurements @xmath53 .
the choice of @xmath54 depends on the error model , i.e. by using @xmath55 the error is assumed to be gaussian distributed . if the noise is sparsely distributed over the measurements , we set @xmath56 .
this error model has also been utilized in @xcite to compensate for sparse outliers in the measurements . finally , combining the data term with the constraints and the sparsity promoting function @xmath57 , the augmented lagrangian optimization problem for adaptively learning the analysis operator with simultaneous image reconstruction consists of minimizing the cost @xmath58 subject to @xmath59 with the measurement matrix @xmath60 .
the scalar @xmath61 denotes the number of extracted image patches .
the parameter @xmath62 weights the fidelity of the solution to the measurements and the parameters @xmath63 control the influence of the two constraints .
since the cost function is restricted to a smooth manifold , we follow @xcite and employ a conjugate gradient on manifolds approach to solve the optimization problem .
the cg approach is scalable and converges fast in practice .
it is thus well - suited to handle the high dimensional problem of simultaneous image reconstruction and operator learning .
the challenges for developing the cg method are the efficient computation of the riemannian gradient , the step - size and the update directions . to that end
, we employ the product manifold structure of @xmath64 considered as a riemannian submanifold of @xmath65 .
to enhance legibility in the remainder of this section we denote the oblique manifold by ob .
we further denote the tangent space at a point @xmath66 as @xmath67 , with @xmath68 being a tangent vector at @xmath69 . the riemannian gradient at @xmath69 is given by the orthogonal projection of the standard ( euclidean ) gradient onto the tangent space @xmath67 .
the orthogonal projection of a matrix @xmath70 onto the tangent space @xmath67 is obtained by @xmath71 . using the product structure and denoting the partial derivatives of @xmath72 by @xmath73 and @xmath74 , respectively , the riemannian gradient of the cost function is @xmath75 in cg methods the updated search directions @xmath76 are linear combinations of the respective gradient and the previous search directions @xmath77 .
the identification of different tangent spaces is done by the so - called parallel transport @xmath78 , which transports a tangent vector @xmath79 along a _
geodesic _ to the tangent space @xmath80 . in the manifold setting geodesics can be considered as the generalization of straight lines .
we denote the geodesic from @xmath81 along the direction @xmath82 as @xmath83 . regarding the product manifold
the new iterates are computed by @xmath84 where @xmath85 denotes the step size that leads to a sufficient decrease of the cost function .
the parallel transport along the geodesics in the product manifold is then given by @xmath86 we use a hybridization of the hestenes - stiefel ( hs ) and the dai yuan ( dy ) formula as motivated in @xcite to determine the update of the search direction . with the shorthand notations @xmath87 and @xmath88 , as well as @xmath89 and @xmath90 the manifold adaptions of these formulas are @xmath91 where @xmath92 denotes the standard inner product in the respective euclidean spaces .
with the hybrid update formula @xmath93 the new search directions are given by @xmath94 in our implementation we use the well - known backtracking line search which is adapted to the manifold setting until the armijo condition is met .
we name our method analysis blind compressive sensing ( abcs ) and briefly summarize the whole procedure in algorithm 1 . for further details concerning cg - methods on the oblique manifold
the reader is referred to @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite .
* algorithm 1 * abcs * input : * initial operator @xmath95 , noisy measurements @xmath96 , measurement matrix @xmath8 , parameters @xmath97 + * set : * @xmath98 , @xmath99 , @xmath100 , @xmath101 , @xmath102 perform backtracking line search to get step size @xmath85 update to @xmath103 , cf .
compute @xmath104 compute @xmath105 , cf .
compute new cg - search directions @xmath106
@xmath107 @xmath108 maximum # of iterations * output : * @xmath109 , @xmath110
to measure the image reconstruction accuracy we use the peak signal - to - noise ratio @xmath111 and the mean structural similarity index ( _ mssim _ ) , with the same set of parameters as originally suggested and implemented in @xcite . throughout our experiments we use a patch size of @xmath112 ,
i.e. @xmath113 and set @xmath114 , as larger values of @xmath115 do not enhance the reconstruction quality .
we initialized @xmath95 to be a random matrix and normalized the rows to unit norm . with this initialization , convergence to a local minimum
was observed in all our experiments .
the parameters for the constraints are set to @xmath116 and @xmath117 .
the constant @xmath48 in the sparsity inducing function is chosen as @xmath118 .
the parameter @xmath119 takes into account the size of the image as well as the operator size and reads @xmath120 , with @xmath121 adjusted according to the noise level as explained below and a normalization factor @xmath122 .
we evaluate our method on the three images _ girl _ ( @xmath123 ) , _ barbara _ ( @xmath124 ) , and _ _ texture _ _ ) ] ( @xmath123 ) .
the measurements are obtained by using the real valued noiselet transformation proposed in @xcite . in the first experiment
we show the robustness of the abcs algorithm to sampling noise which follows a gaussian distribution . for this purpose ,
the measurements have been artificially corrupted by additive white gaussian noise with standard deviation @xmath125 .
the data term in reads @xmath126 .
we assume the noise level @xmath125 to be known and set @xmath127 . two measurement rates @xmath128 and @xmath129 are considered .
table [ tab : denoising ] shows the reconstruction performance for different noise levels . for comparison we used the algorithm of @xcite ( nesta ) , with tv - norm regularization and optimized parameters .
figure [ fig : res ] shows the reconstructed images from @xmath128 measurements and a noise level of @xmath130 .
we also tested the algorithm proposed in @xcite ( tval3 ) with different parameters , which achieves results comparable to nesta . due to space limitations , detailed results are not listed here . in all settings ,
the same measurements are used .
.image reconstruction from measurements corrupted by additive white gaussian noise with standard deviation @xmath125 .
the measurement rates are @xmath128 ( top ) and @xmath129 ( bottom ) .
achieved psnr in decibels and mssim .
[ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] both experiments confirm that the adaptively learned operator leads to an accuracy improvement compared to the reconstruction quality obtained with a fixed finite difference operator . in particular , the structures in the _ barbara _ and _ texture _ image are better preserved by abcs .
in this article we proposed an analysis based blind compressive sensing algorithm that simultaneously reconstructs an image from compressively sensed data and learns an appropriate analysis operator .
this process is formulated as an optimization problem , which is tackled via a geometric conjugate gradient approach that updates both the operator and the image as a whole at each iteration .
furthermore , the algorithm can be easily adapted to different noise models by simply exchanging the data fidelity term . | in this work we address the problem of blindly reconstructing compressively sensed signals by exploiting the co - sparse analysis model . in the analysis model
it is assumed that a signal multiplied by an analysis operator results in a sparse vector .
we propose an algorithm that learns the operator adaptively during the reconstruction process .
the arising optimization problem is tackled via a geometric conjugate gradient approach .
different types of sampling noise are handled by simply exchanging the data fidelity term .
numerical experiments are performed for measurements corrupted with gaussian as well as impulsive noise to show the effectiveness of our method . |
strongly interacting bosonic systems have attracted a lot of recent interest@xcite .
physical realizations include short correlation - length superconductors , granular superconductors , josephson arrays , the dynamics of flux lattices in type ii superconductors , and critical behavior of @xmath0 in porous media .
the bosonic systems are either tightly bound composites of fermions that act like effective bosonic particles with soft cores , or correspond to bosonic excitations that have repulsive interactions .
for this reason , these systems are modeled by soft - core bosons which are described most simply by the bose hubbard model .
various aspects of this model were investigated analytically by mean - field theory @xcite , by renormalization group techniques @xcite and by projection methods @xcite .
the bose hubbard model has also been studied with quantum monte carlo methods ( qmc ) by batrouni et al .
@xcite in one dimension ( 1 + 1 ) and by krauth and trivedi @xcite , van otterlo and wagenblast@xcite , and batrouni et al.@xcite in two dimensions ( 2 + 1 ) . in this contribution
, the mott phase diagram is obtained from a strong - coupling expansion that has the correct dependence on spatial dimensionality , is as accurate as the qmc calculations , and agrees with the known exact solutions .
preliminary results for the pure case have already appeared@xcite .
the bose hubbard model is the minimal model which contains the key physics of the strongly interacting bose systems the competition between kinetic and potential energy effects .
its hamiltonian is @xmath1 where @xmath2 is the boson annihilation operator at site @xmath3 , @xmath4 is the hopping matrix element between the site @xmath3 and @xmath5 , @xmath6 is the local site energy , @xmath7 is the strength of the on - site repulsion , and @xmath8 is the chemical potential .
the hopping matrix is assumed to be a real symmetric matrix @xmath9 and the lattice is also assumed to be bipartite ; _
i. e. _ , the lattice may be separated into two sublattices ( the @xmath10 sublattice and the @xmath11 sublattice ) such that @xmath4 vanishes whenever @xmath3 and @xmath5 both belong to the same sublattice ( in particular , this implies @xmath12 ) .
the local site energy @xmath6 is a quenched random variable chosen from a distribution of site energies that is symmetric about zero and satisfies @xmath13 .
the pure case corresponds to all site energies vanishing @xmath14 .
the form of the zero temperature ( @xmath15 ) phase diagram can be understood by starting from the strong - coupling or `` atomic '' limit @xcite . in this limit ,
the kinetic energy vanishes ( @xmath16 ) and every site is occupied by a fixed number of bosons , @xmath17 . in the pure case ,
the ground - state boson occupancy ( @xmath17 ) is the same for each lattice site , and is chosen to minimize the on - site energy . if the chemical potential , @xmath18 , is parameterized in terms of the deviation , @xmath19 , from integer filling @xmath17
, then the on - site energy is @xmath20 , and the energy to add a boson onto a particular site satisfies @xmath21 .
thus for a nonzero @xmath19 , a finite amount of energy is required to move a particle through the lattice .
the bosons are incompressible and localized , which produces a mott insulator . for @xmath22
, the ground - state energies of the two different boson densities are degenerate [ @xmath23 and no energy is needed to add or extract a particle ; _
i. e. _ , the compressibility is finite and the system is a conductor . as the strength of the hopping matrix elements increases , the range of the chemical potential @xmath8 about which the system is incompressible decreases .
the mott - insulator phase will completely disappear at a critical value of the hopping matrix elements . beyond this critical value of @xmath4
the system is a superfluid . in the disordered case , a mott - insulating phase may or may not exist depending upon the strength of the disorder .
the energy to add a boson onto site @xmath3 becomes @xmath24 , so that the system is compressible if a site @xmath3 can be found which satisfies @xmath25 .
if the disorder is assumed to be symmetrically bounded about zero ( @xmath26 ) then a mott insulator exists whenever @xmath27 .
the ground - state boson occupancy is uniformly equal to @xmath17 within the mott insulating phase which extends from @xmath28 ( when @xmath29 ) .
once again , the bosons are incompressible within the mott phase and the system is insulating .
as the hopping matrix elements increase in magnitude , the range of the chemical potential within which the system is incompressible decreases until the mott phase vanishes at a critical value of the hopping matrix elements .
the compressible phase will typically also be an insulator and is called a bose glass@xcite , but it has been conjectured that in some cases the transition proceeds directly from the mott insulator to the superfluid@xcite .
the phase boundary between the incompressible phase ( mott insulator ) and the compressible phase ( superfluid or bose glass ) is determined here in a strong - coupling expansion by calculating both the energy of the mott insulator and of a defect state ( which contains an extra hole or particle ) in a perturbative expansion of the single - particle terms @xmath30 . at the point where the energy of the mott state is degenerate with the defect state , the system becomes compressible . in the pure case ,
the compressible phase is also superfluid , but in the disordered case , the compressible phase is a bose glass ( except possibly at the tip of the mott lobe)@xcite .
there are two distinct cases for the defect state : @xmath31 corresponds to adding a _ particle _ to the mott - insulator phase ( with @xmath17 bosons per site ) ; and @xmath32 corresponds to adding a _ hole _ to the mott - insulator phase ( with @xmath33 ) bosons per site .
of course , the phase boundary depends upon the number of bosons per site , @xmath17 , of the mott insulator phase .
to zeroth order in @xmath34 the mott - insulating state is given by @xmath35 where @xmath17 is the number of bosons on each site , @xmath36 is the number of sites in the lattice and @xmath37 is the vacuum state .
the defect state is characterized by one additional particle ( hole ) which moves coherently throughout the lattice . to zeroth order in the single - particle terms the wave function for the `` defect '' state
is determined by degenerate perturbation theory : @xmath38 where the @xmath39 is the eigenvector of the corresponding single - particle matrix @xmath40 [ @xmath41 with the lowest eigenvalue ( the hopping matrix is assumed to have a nondegenerate lowest eigenvalue ) .
it is well known that the minimal eigenvalue of the single - particle matrix @xmath42 is larger than the sum of the minimal eigenvalue of the hopping matrix plus the minimal eigenvalue of the disorder matrix .
however , it has been demonstrated that as the system size becomes larger and larger , the minimal eigenvalue approaches the sum of the minimal eigenvalues of the hopping matrix and of the disorder matrix as closely as desired@xcite ( because of the existence of arbitrarily large `` rare regions '' where the system looks pure with @xmath43 or with @xmath44 ) .
therefore , in the thermodynamic limit , the perturbative energy of each defect state becomes @xmath45 @xmath46 to first order in @xmath47 , where @xmath48 is the minimal eigenvalue of the hopping matrix @xmath49 . in the case of nearest - neighbor hopping on a hypercubic lattice in @xmath50-dimensions ,
the number of nearest neighbors satisfies @xmath51 and the minimal eigenvalue is @xmath52 .
the boundary between the incompressible phase and the compressible phase is determined when the energy difference between the mott insulator and the defect state vanishes ( the compressibility is assumed to approach zero continuously at the phase boundary ) .
thus two branches of the mott lobe can be found depending upon whether the defect state is an additional hole or an additional particle .
the two branches of the mott - phase boundary meet when @xmath53 the additional one on the left hand side arises because @xmath19 is measured from the point @xmath54 . equation ( [ eq : critical condition ] ) may be used to estimate the critical value of the hopping matrix element beyond which no mott - insulator phase exists .
let @xmath55 denote the combination @xmath56 and consider the first - order expansions in eqs .
( [ eq : particle first order ] ) and ( [ eq : hole first order ] ) . the critical value of @xmath55 satisfies @xmath57 which vanishes when the disorder strength becomes too large ( @xmath58 ) .
note that the critical value of @xmath55 is _ independent _ of the dimension of the lattice ; _ the dimensionality first enters at second order in @xmath59 . _ the slope of the phase boundaries about the point @xmath60 are equal in magnitude @xmath61 $ ] , but change their magnitude as a function of the density @xmath17 , _ implying that the mott - phase lobes always have an asymmetrical shape_. note further that the presence of disorder shifts the phase boundaries uniformly by @xmath62 , but the slope is _ independent _ of the disorder distribution . the bose hubbard model in the absence of disorder is examined by a strong - coupling expansion through third order in the single - particle matrix @xmath47 in section ii .
the exact solution for an infinite - dimensional lattice@xcite is examined and various different extrapolation techniques are employed that do and do not utilize additional information of the scaling analysis of the critical point .
section iii describes the similar results for the disordered bose hubbard model and a discussion follows in section iv .
the bose hubbard model in eq .
( [ h ] ) is studied in the absence of disorder ( @xmath63 ) .
the many - body version of rayleigh - schr " odinger perturbation theory is employed throughout . to third order in @xmath34 ,
the energy of the mott state with @xmath17 bosons per site becomes @xmath64 \label{eq : emott}\ ] ] which is proportional to the number of lattice sites @xmath36 .
note that the odd - order terms in @xmath34 vanish in the above expansion ( odd - order terms may enter for nonbipartite lattices ) .
the energy difference between the mott insulator and the defect state with an additional particle ( @xmath31 ) satisfies @xmath65 \label{eq : edef upper}\end{aligned}\ ] ] to third order in @xmath34 ; while the energy difference between the mott insulating phase and the defect phase with an additional hole ( @xmath66 ) satisfies @xmath67 \label{eq : edef lower}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the eigenvector @xmath39 is the minimal eigenvector of the hopping matrix @xmath49 with eigenvalue @xmath48 and is identical in the particle and hole sectors .
these results have been verified by small - cluster calculations on two and four - site clusters .
note that the energy difference in eqs .
( [ eq : edef upper ] ) and ( [ eq : edef lower ] ) is _ independent _ of the lattice size @xmath36 indicating that qmc simulations should not have a very strong dependence on the lattice size .
in the case of nearest - neighbor hopping on a @xmath50-dimensional hypercubic lattice , the minimum eigenvalue satisfies @xmath68 , the sum @xmath69 becomes @xmath70 , and the sum @xmath71 equals @xmath72 .
equations ( [ eq : edef upper ] ) and ( [ eq : edef lower ] ) can then be solved for the shift in the chemical potential @xmath19 at which the system becomes compressible as a function of the parameter @xmath73 .
the results for the upper boundary are given by @xmath74 \label{eq : upper boundary}\end{aligned}\ ] ] to third order in @xmath55 , and the lower boundary is given by @xmath75 , \label{eq : lower boundary}\end{aligned}\ ] ] to third order in @xmath55 .
as a further check on the accuracy of the mott phase boundaries in eqs .
( [ eq : upper boundary ] ) and ( [ eq : lower boundary ] ) , we compare the perturbative expansion to the exact solution on an infinite - dimensional hypercubic lattice@xcite ( which corresponds to the mean - field solution ) .
note that the solution in ref .
was for the infinite - range - hopping model ; this solution is _ identical _ to that on an infinite - dimensional lattice in the pure case .
the mott phase boundary may be expressed as @xmath76 where the plus sign denotes the upper branch to the mott lobe @xmath77 , and the minus sign corresponds to the lower branch @xmath78 .
the critical point can also be determined as the value of @xmath55 where the square root vanishes .
one finds @xmath79 which depends on @xmath17 as @xmath80 in the limit of large @xmath17 .
the strong - coupling expansions ( [ eq : upper boundary ] ) and ( [ eq : lower boundary ] ) agree with the exact solution ( [ eq : inf - d delta ] ) when the latter is expanded out to third order in @xmath55 , providing an independent check of the algebra .
note further , that the exact solution uniquely determines the expansion coefficients of the powers of @xmath55 that do not involve inverse powers of @xmath50 and the perturbation expansion is only required to determine the @xmath81 corrections .
the strong - coupling expansion for the @xmath55 , @xmath8 phase diagram in one dimension is compared to the qmc results of batrouni et al .
@xcite in figure 1 .
the solid lines indicate the phase boundary between the mott - insulator phase and the superfluid phase at zero temperature as calculated from eq .
( [ eq : upper boundary ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : lower boundary ] ) .
the solid circles are the results of the qmc calculation@xcite at a small but finite temperature ( @xmath82 ) .
the dotted line is an extrapolation from the series calculation that will be described below .
note that the overall agreement of the two calculations is excellent .
for example , the critical value of the hopping matrix element for the first mott lobe ( @xmath17 ) is @xmath83 , while the qmc calculations found@xcite @xmath84 . a closer examination of fig .
1 shows a systematic deviation of the lower branch for larger values of @xmath55 .
we believe that this is most likely a finite - temperature effect , since the mott - insulator phase becomes more stable at higher temperatures @xcite , and the systematic errors of the qmc calculation due to finite lattice size and finite trotter error are easily controlled@xcite .
it is known from the scaling theory of fisher et al .
@xcite that the phase transition at the tip of the mott lobe is in the universality class of the @xmath85 dimensional @xmath86 model .
although a finite - order perturbation theory can not describe the physics of the tricritical point correctly , we find that the density fluctuations dominate the physics of the phase transition even close to the tricritical point .
note how the mott lobes have a cusp - like structure in one dimension , mimicking the kosterlitz - thouless behavior of the critical point .
figure 2 ( a ) presents the strong - coupling expansion for the @xmath55 , @xmath8 phase diagram in two dimensions . for comparison , the tricritical point of the first mott - insulator lobe as obtained by the qmc simulations of krauth and trivedi @xcite is marked by a solid circle with error bars ( the chemical potential for the tip of the mott lobe was not reported in ref .
, so we fixed it to be @xmath87 ) .
the solid line is the strong - coupling expansion truncated to third order , while the dotted line is an extrapolation described below .
their simulation gives a critical value of @xmath88 , whereas our calculation yields @xmath89 which is in reasonable agreement .
note that the qualitative shape of the mott lobes has changed from one dimension to two dimensions , mimicking the power - law critical behavior of the @xmath86 model in three or larger dimensions .
figure 2 ( b ) shows the corresponding figure for the @xmath90 limit corresponding to the quantum rotor model .
the qmc results are from van otterlo and wagenblast@xcite .
the horizontal axis has been rescaled to @xmath91 .
we believe that the relatively large difference between the qmc and the strong - coupling perturbation theory arises from the use of the villain approximation in the qmc simulations .
finally the strong - coupling expansion is compared to the exact calculation in infinite dimensions @xcite . in infinite dimensions ,
the hopping matrix element must scale inversely with the dimension @xcite , @xmath92 , @xmath93 , producing the mean - field - theory result of eq .
( [ eq : inf - d delta ] ) . in figure 3 the strong - coupling expansion ( solid line )
is compared to the exact solution ( dashed line ) and to an extrapolated solution ( dotted line ) which will be described below . even in infinite dimensions ,
the agreement of the strong - coupling expansion with the exact results is quite good . as a general rule
, the truncated strong - coupling expansions appear to be more accurate in _ lower _ dimensions , which implies that the density fluctuations of the bose hubbard model are also more important in lower dimensions . at this point
we turn our attention to techniques which enable us to extrapolate the strong - coupling expansions to infinite order in hopes of determining a more accurate phase diagram .
the simplest method is called critical - point extrapolation .
the critical point @xmath94 is calculated at each order ( @xmath95 ) of the strong - coupling expansion and is extrapolated to infinite order @xmath96 .
the ansatz that the extrapolation is linear in @xmath97 can be checked by determining the correlation coefficient @xmath98 of the critical points ( a value of @xmath99 that is near 1 indicates a linear correlation ) .
the correlations are found to be most linear for large dimensions ( @xmath100 in infinite dimensions for the first mott lobe ) but remain fairly linear even in one dimension ( @xmath101 for the @xmath102 extrapolation and @xmath103 for the @xmath104 extrapolation ) .
since the second- and third - order expansions are expected to be more accurate than the first - order calculation , we adopt the following strategy for performing the extrapolations : the results of the second- and third - order expansions are extrapolated to @xmath105 to determine the estimate for the critical point , and the results of the first , second and third orders are then extrapolated to @xmath106 in order to estimate the error in the critical point , and to test the linear - extrapolation hypothesis .
the error estimate is chosen to be 1.5 times as large as the difference between the two different extrapolations .
figure 4 plots the critical hopping matrix elements @xmath102 versus @xmath97 for the infinite - dimensional case and @xmath107 .
the solid dots are the results of the strong - coupling expansion truncated to @xmath95th order and the solid line is the linear extrapolant .
the open circles are the exact solutions from eq .
( [ eq : inf - d xcrit ] ) .
note that although the linear correlation coefficient is very close to 1 , the error in the critical point is about @xmath108 .
the results for the critical - point extrapolation are recorded in table i. the critical - point extrapolation does not yield any information on the shape of the mott lobes , but only determines the critical point . an alternate extrapolation technique , called the chemical - potential extrapolation method will determine an extrapolated mott - phase lobe and critical point .
the idea is to fix the magnitude of the hopping matrix elements and determine the value of the chemical potential from eqs .
( [ eq : upper boundary ] ) and ( [ eq : lower boundary ] ) for the upper and lower branch of the mott lobe .
the chemical potential is determined from a first , second , and third - order calculation and then extrapolated to infinite order assuming the ansatz of a linear dependence upon @xmath97 .
this procedure determines an extrapolated mott lobe that should be more accurate than the truncated strong - coupling series .
the result for the infinite - dimensional case is presented as a dotted line in fig .
3 . note that the critical point is not determined as accurately by this technique as it was in the critical - point extrapolation method .
the chemical - potential extrapolation method fails in one dimension since the extrapolated branches of the extrapolated mott lobe do not close .
a third approach is to use the results of the scaling theory@xcite .
the critical point is that of a @xmath85-dimensional @xmath86 model , and therefore , has a kosterlitz - thouless shape in one dimension and a power - law shape in higher dimensions .
examination of the exact result for infinite dimensions ( [ eq : inf - d delta ] ) leads one to propose the following ansatz for the mott lobe in @xmath109 @xmath110 where @xmath111 and @xmath112 are regular functions of @xmath55 ( that should be accurately approximated by their power - series expansions ) and @xmath113 is the critical exponent for the @xmath85-dimensional @xmath86 model . in the unconstrained - scaling - analysis extrapolation method the exponent @xmath113
is determined by the strong - coupling expansion in addition to the parameters @xmath114 and @xmath115 .
this provides a perturbative estimate of the exponent @xmath113 which can be checked against its well - known values . in the constrained - scaling - analysis extrapolation method @xmath113
is fixed at its predicted values@xcite of @xmath116 in two dimensions and @xmath117 in higher dimensions . in direct analogy to eq .
( [ eq : mu ansatz ] ) , we propose the kosterlitz - thouless form @xmath118 \label{eq : mu ansatz 1d}\ ] ] for the constrained - extrapolation - method in one dimension .
when the unconstrained - scaling - analysis extrapolation method is carried out , one finds that there is no solution for the critical exponent in one dimension ( which is consistent with kosterlitz - thouless behavior ) , that in @xmath119 the exponent satisfies @xmath120 , in @xmath121 the exponent is @xmath122 , and in infinite dimensions @xmath123 .
there is a slight @xmath17 dependence to the exponents that are calculated in this method , but that arises from the truncation of the series to such a low order .
in general , the unconstrained extrapolation method produces an accuracy of about @xmath124 in the exponent @xmath113 , and the method appears to work best in higher dimensions .
the results for the constrained - extrapolation method are plotted with a dotted line in fig . 1 for the one - dimensional case
. the values of the critical points are @xmath125 , @xmath126 , and @xmath127 for @xmath107 , respectively .
these critical points occur at larger values of @xmath55 than predicted by the qmc simulations@xcite , but it is difficult to gauge whether the extrapolated series expansions are more or less accurate than the qmc simulations because of the finite - temperature effects in the latter .
the constrained - extrapolation results in two dimensions are plotted with a dotted line in fig . 2 ( a ) and ( b ) .
the values of the critical points are @xmath128 , @xmath129 , @xmath130 for @xmath107 , respectively .
the agreement with the qmc simulations@xcite is excellent .
similarly , the extrapolated critical point for the @xmath131 rotor model is @xmath132 which also agrees well with the qmc . in this latter case [ fig . 2 ( b ) ]
the errors between the extrapolated series expansion and the qmc can be traced to the use of the villain approximation in the latter . when the constrained - scaling - analysis extrapolation method is applied to the infinite - dimensional case
the result is indistinguishable from the exact solution when the two are plotted on the same graph .
the extrapolation techniques work best in _ higher _ dimensions virtually producing the exact result in infinite - dimensions .
this gives us confidence that the extrapolated results of the series expansions can produce numerical answers that are at least as accurate as the qmc simulations .
the most common type of disorder distribution that has been considered in relationship to the `` dirty '' boson problem is the anderson model ( continuous disorder distribution ) . in the anderson model
the distribution @xmath133 for the on - site energies @xmath134 is continuous and flat , satisfying @xmath135 the symbol @xmath62 denotes the maximum absolute value that the site energy @xmath6 can assume for a given ( bounded ) distribution @xmath136 .
this disorder distribution is symmetric @xmath137 $ ] and in particular it satisfies @xmath13 .
the results presented in this contribution are _ insensitive _ to the actual shape of the disorder distribution ; all we require is a symmetric distribution with @xmath26 .
we begin by reexamining the exact solution of the infinite - range - hopping model@xcite . if all energies are measured in units of the boson - boson repulsion @xmath7 , then the analysis of ref .
derives an equation that relates the hopping matrix elements to the chemical potential at the mott phase boundary @xmath138 \rho(\epsilon ) d\epsilon\quad , \label{eq : inf - d disorder}\ ] ] with @xmath139 the chemical potential and @xmath140 the disorder distribution .
this solution assumes that the phase transition from the mott phase to the bose glass is a _ second - order _ phase transition . when eq .
( [ eq : inf - d disorder ] ) is solved for the anderson model distribution ( [ eq : anderson ] ) , one finds that the chemical potential for the lower branch of the mott lobe behaves like @xmath141 $ ] for small @xmath55 .
this result is _ nonperturbative _ in the hopping matrix elements and can not be represented by a simple perturbative theory about @xmath142 .
the reason why this happens is that the infinite - range - hopping model has no localized states for any disorder distribution ( however , this statement does depend on the disorder distribution@xcite ) .
localized states can occur in the infinite - dimensional limit at the tails of the distribution .
therefore we expect that the transition will have a different qualitative character on a hypercubic lattice with nearest - neighbor interactions .
in fact , the perturbative arguments given in the introduction , show that the phase boundaries have the _ same _ slope as they did in the pure case .
furthermore , we expect that the transition to be first order at the tip of the mott lobe because the states that the bosons initially occupy in the compressible phase are localized within the rare regions of the lattice ( where the site energies are all equal to @xmath143 ) implying that there is no diverging length scale at the transition .
the perturbative expansion for the energy of the mott phase is unchanged from eq .
( [ eq : emott ] ) in the presence of disorder ( if the disorder distribution satisfies @xmath144 , while the defect phases have a trivial dependence upon disorder ( in the thermodynamic limit)the energy for a particle or hole defect state is shifted by @xmath143 , so the effect of the disorder is simply to shift the mott - phase boundaries inward by @xmath145 .
the critical point , where the mott phase disappears , is no longer described by a second - order critical point [ in which the slope of @xmath146 becomes infinite at @xmath147 but rather is described by a first - order critical point [ in which the slope of @xmath146 changes discontinuously at @xmath147 . in the thermodynamic limit
one can always find a rare region of arbitrarily large extent which guarantees the existence of the first - order transition , but the density of these rare regions is an exponentially small function of their size .
for this reason the compressibility at the mott - phase boundary will also be exponentially small .
finite - size effects play a much more important role in the disordered case : _ it is impossible to determine the mott - phase boundary accurately in the thermodynamic limit by scaling calculations performed on small lattices , because the lattice size must be large enough to contain rare regions within which the bosons can be delocalized .
_ ( finite - size effects can be studied with the strong - coupling expansion which is given to third order in the single - particle matrix @xmath47 in the appendix . ) the most accurate way of calculating the mott phase boundary is then to take the results of the constrained - scaling - analysis extrapolation for the pure case and shift the branches by the strength of the disorder .
this is plotted in figure 5 for the one - dimensional case and two different values of disorder ( @xmath148 ) .
the thermodynamic limit is represented by the solid line for the pure case , and dotted lines for the disordered case , while the dashed line is the result of an anderson - model disorder distribution on a finite lattice with 256 sites .
the qmc results of batrouni , _ et . al._@xcite correspond to lattice sizes ranging from 16 sites to 256 sites ( the disorder parameter is @xmath149 for the solid dots and @xmath150 for the open dots ) .
the mott phase is stabilized on finite - sized systems because they do not possess the rare regions needed to correctly determine the mott phase boundary .
this is clearly seen in the qmc results , which predict a much larger region for the mott phase than the strong - coupling perturbation theory does in the thermodynamic limit .
the perturbative results for a finite system are much closer to the qmc results as expected .
( note that the finite - size calculations have not been extrapolated , so they should underestimate the stability of the mott phase in one dimension which is clearly seen in figure 5 . ) also the slope of the phase boundary approaches zero ( as @xmath151 for the finite - size systems@xcite .
figure 6 plots the mott - phase diagram for the disordered bose hubbard model in two dimensions and one value of the disorder ( @xmath152 ) in the thermodynamic limit . the solid dot ( with error bars )
is the qmc result@xcite ( for the pure case with @xmath149 ) and the open dot is the disordered case @xmath153 ) .
note that in dimensions larger than one , the finite - size effects for the tip of the mott lobe are not as strong as they are in one dimension .
we compare in figure 7 the differences between the infinite - dimensional lattice and the infinite - range - hopping model of ref . .
the solid lines correspond to the exact solution with no disorder , the dotted lines are the infinite - dimensional lattice strong - coupling expansion with disorder ( @xmath154 ) , and the dashed lines are the exact solution of the infinite - range - hopping model . in the case of disorder ,
the first - order nature of the transition is evidenced by the jump in the slope of the mott phase boundary at the tip of the lobe .
the second - order phase boundaries predict a more stable mott phase , and their slopes all approach zero as @xmath155 .
we expect in the region in between the ( first - order ) infinite - dimensional phase boundary and that of the ( second - order ) infinite - range - hopping model that the compressibility will be exponentially small , and will only become sizable as the second - order phase boundary is crossed . because the mott - phase to bose - glass phase transition is first order for the disordered case , and since the bose - glass to superfluid transition is always second order ( because it involves a collective excitation that extends through the entire lattice ) , it is quite unlikely that there would ever be a region where the mott phase has a transition directly to the superfluid .
_ the presence of the lifshitz rare regions strongly supports the picture that the mott phase is entirely enclosed within the bose - glass phase .
_ this result is _ independent _ of any perturbative arguments , since the rare regions must dominate the mott to bose - glass transition in the exact solution too .
finally , we calculate the dependence of the critical value of @xmath55 at the tip of the mott - phase lobe , as a function of the disorder strength @xmath62 .
figure 8 plots this value of @xmath156 versus @xmath62 for the one- , two- , and infinite - dimensional cases .
the plot is limited to the lowest mott - phase lobe with @xmath157 .
since the one - dimensional mott phase lobes have a cusp - like behavior that is removed when disorder is added to the system , we expect @xmath158 to decrease very rapidly for small disorder .
this effect is sharply reduced in higher dimensions . in the strong - disorder limit , the phase diagram is dominated by the first - order terms in the perturbative expansion , which have a trivial dependence on the dimensionality , but the slopes curves of the curves are unequal because @xmath159 depends strongly upon the dimensionality .
we have developed a strong - coupling perturbation - theory approximation to the bose hubbard model on a bipartite lattice .
the perturbative results can be extrapolated in a number of different ways which either do or do not take into account the scaling theory of the critical point at the mott tip .
we find that a perturbative expansion thru third order rivals the accuracy of the qmc simulations , and is likely the best method for determining the mott phase boundary of these interacting bose systems .
we treated two different cases : the pure case and the disordered case . in the pure case
the tip of the mott lobe satisfies a scaling relation because it corresponds to a second - order phase transition in a @xmath160-dimensional xy model .
this is because the compressible phase is also superfluid which implies there is a diverging length scale at the phase transition .
calculations in the pure case are insensitive to finite - size effects . in the disordered case we argued that the tip of the mott phase lobe corresopnds to a first - order phase transition because the initial single - particle excitations are localized into the rare regions of the lifshitz tails for any bounded disorder distribution . as a result
there is a kink in the mott phase boundary since the slope of @xmath146 has a discontinuous jump at the tip of the lobe . in this case
, there are strong finite - size effects because `` typical '' disorder distributions on finite lattices do not have lifshitz tails .
the results of these perturbative calculations have been compared to the available qmc simulations .
we find a remarkable agreement between the two and are unable to determine which method is more accurate in a quantitative determination of the phase boundaries .
the perturbation theory described here falls short in one aspect
it is unable to determine the bose - glass superfluid phase transition in the disordered case .
it is possible that such a calculation could be performed , but since the particle density at which it occurs is a priori not known , and since the superfluid susceptibility diverges in the bose - glass phase , such a calculation may be problematic .
we would like to thank m. fisher , th .
giamarchi , m. jarrell , m. ma , a van otterlo , r. scalettar , r. singh , and g. zimanyi for many useful discussions .
we would especially like to thank m. ma for pointing out that the mott to bose - glass phase transition is first order in the disordered case .
initial stages of this work were carried out by j. k. f. at the university of california , davis in 1994 and were completed during a visit to lcole polytechnique fdrale de lausanne in june 1995 .
jkf would like to thank the office of naval research ( under grant no .
n00014 - 93 - 1 - 0495 ) for support while at uc davis , and would like to thank the donors of the petroleum research fund , administered by the american chemical society ( acs - prf-29623-gb6 ) for support while at georgetown .
the rayleigh - schr " odinger perturbation theory for the case with disorder is straightforward , but rather tedious . in the thermodynamic limit
, the perturbative expansion simplifies because it is dominated by the rare regions of the lattice . for a finite - sized system ,
the perturbative results are more complicated .
we summarize here the main results for a third - order strong - coupling expansion in the presence of disorder .
the upper phase boundary for the mott to bose - glass transition is found by solving the equation @xmath162\cr & + n_0\left [ \sum_{ij}{\epsilon_i\over u}{t_{ij}^2\over u^2}f_j^2({3\over 2 } n_0 + 2 ) -{zt^2\over u^2}\sum_i{\epsilon_i\over u}f_i^2({17\over 4}n_0+{9\over 2 } ) \right ] \quad , \label{eq : appendix1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath39 is the minimal eigenvector of the single - particle matrix @xmath163 and @xmath164 is its corresponding eigenvalue .
the identity @xmath165 was needed in deriving the above result .
a similar calculation yields @xmath166\cr & + ( n_0 + 1)\left [ \sum_{ij}{\epsilon_i\over u}{t_{ij}^2\over u^2}g_j^2({3\over 4 } n_0+{1\over 4 } ) -{zt^2\over u^2}\sum_i{\epsilon_i\over u}g_i^2({7\over 2}n_0+{1\over 2 } ) \right ] \quad , \label{eq : appendix2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the lower phase boundary of the mott to bose - glass transition . here
we have that @xmath167 is the minimal eigenvector of the single - particle matrix @xmath168 and @xmath169 is its corresponding eigenvalue . in the thermodynamic limit we know that the minimal eigenvalue occurs in the rare regions where the disorder is constant and equal to its extreme value .
the ground - state eigenvector is delocalized within the rare region ( to minimize it s kinetic energy ) and localized to the rare region ( to minimize its disorder energy ) .
such an eigenvector is now _
separately _ an eigenvector of the kinetic - energy matrix and of the disorder matrix , so we have @xmath170 , @xmath171 , and @xmath172 with similar formulae for the @xmath173 eigenvector .
plugging these thermodynamic limits into eqs .
( [ eq : appendix1 ] ) and ( [ eq : appendix2 ] ) then yields the result that the mott phase boundaries are only shifted uniformly by @xmath145 , and all higher - order dependence on the disorder vanishes . j. k. freericks and h. monien , europhys . lett .
* 24 * , 545 ( 1994 ) ; h. monien and j. k. freericks , in _ strongly correlated electronic materials _ edited by k. s. bedell , z. wang , d. e. meltzer , a. v. balatsky , and e. abrahams , ( addison - wesley , reading , 1994 ) p. 320 . .
results for the critical - point extrapolation method described in the text .
the critical point is recorded for the first three mott lobes in one , two , three and infinite dimensions . where possible
the results from other calculation techniques are displayed in the last column . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^ " , ] | a strong - coupling expansion for the phase boundary of the ( incompressible ) mott insulator is presented for the bose hubbard model .
both the pure case and the disordered case are examined .
extrapolations of the series expansions provide results that are as accurate as the monte carlo simulations and agree with the exact solutions .
the shape difference between kosterlitz - thouless critical behavior in one - dimension and power - law singularities in higher dimensions arises naturally in this strong - coupling expansion .
bounded disorder distributions produce a `` first - order '' kink to the mott phase boundary in the thermodynamic limit because of the presence of lifshitz s rare regions . |
aging experiments in spin glasses @xcite first carried out by lundgren
_ et al . _ , have generated a large amount of experimental as well as theoretical work .
two types of experiments have been investigated : the zero - field - cooled experiment and the thermoremanent magnetization experiment , both leading to similar results . in the present article
, we will restrict ourselves to the thermoremanent magnetization experiment , consisting in first quenching the system below its glass transition temperature at time @xmath1 , applying a small constant magnetic field up to the waiting time @xmath2 , switching off the magnetic field at time @xmath2 , and measuring the magnetization relaxation at time @xmath3 .
it is an experimental observation that the magnetization relaxation depends on the `` age '' of the system , namely , on the waiting time .
different theoretical approaches have been developed so far , for instance : droplet picture @xcite , mean field models @xcite or phenomenological trap models @xcite .
several scenarios have been proposed , such as `` true '' versus `` weak '' ergodicity breaking @xcite , or `` interrupted '' aging @xcite .
the first two scenario depend on whether ergodicity breaking occurs for finite or infinite waiting times .
`` interrupted '' aging means that , at a finite temperature , there is no more aging if the waiting time is larger than finite ( but possibly large ) time scale . in other words ,
the system equilibrates in a finite time .
aging can be characterized by the violation of the fluctuation - dissipation theorem ( fdt ) .
if the system has reached thermodynamic equilibrium before the magnetic field is switched off at time @xmath2 , the magnetization response is then independent on @xmath2 . this situation can be realized either at large temperatures , or in an `` interrupted aging '' situation ( which will be the case in the present article ) , or , in the presence of non - interrupted aging , by formally taking the limit @xmath4 before the thermodynamic limit @xmath5 . then , the equilibrium thermoremanent magnetization @xmath6 is related in a simple fashion to the autocorrelation of the spin configurations at times @xmath2 and @xmath3 via the fdt ( see section [ sec - thermoremanent ] for more details ) . in the out - of - equilibrium dynamics ,
the fdt is no more valid , and there are analytical predictions in some mean - field solvable models of what is the fdt violation @xcite . in particular , cugliandolo and kurchan @xcite
have proposed that the out - of - equilibrium linear response kernel @xmath7 relating the magnetization to the correlation depends on @xmath8 and @xmath9 only through the autocorrelation @xmath10 .
the fdt violation is then characterized by a function @xmath0 that depends only on the autocorrelation , and , as recalled in section [ sec - thermoremanent ] , can be obtained from the thermoremanent magnetization simulations .
the aim of the present article is to study the fdt violation in dilute ising antiferromagnets at the percolation threshold , with a hamiltonian @xmath11 where the summation is carried out over neighboring pairs of spins on a percolation cluster . in practice
, will will study here only percolation clusters generated on a square lattice in a two dimensional space .
it is well - known that , for a finite cluster of @xmath12 sites , the dynamics freezes as the temperature is decreased below the glass cross - over temperature @xcite @xmath13 with @xmath14 the fractal dimension and @xmath15 the percolation exponent .
this glass cross - over originates from the conjugate effect of large - scale ` droplet ' excitations ( with zero temperature energy barriers that scale like @xmath16 @xcite ) , and the divergence of the correlation length at low temperatures @xcite .
it is of interest to understand the fdt violation in these systems for two reasons .
first , a quite different behavior from euclidian coarsening is expected , with more pronounced long - term memory effects due to the slow dynamics of ` droplet ' excitations .
we will indeed show that the function @xmath0 characterizing the fluctuation - dissipation ratio cross - overs from unity to a smaller value @xmath17 in the aging regime . whereas @xmath17 is zero in euclidian coarsening
, we find a non - zero value for coarsening on percolation clusters .
this indicates that , even though these non - frustrated systems show interrupted aging , the fdt violation in these systems shares some common features with `` true '' spin - glasses . the second motivation for studying these systems is , as will be developed in section [ sec - equilibrium ] , that the low temperature magnetic response to an external magnetic field is linear only for magnetic fields smaller than a typical field @xmath18 scaling like @xmath19 ( see section [ sec - equilibrium ] ) .
one is thus lead to study the fdt violation in the absence of linear response to an external magnetic field .
this article is organized as follows : section [ sec - equilibrium ] is devoted to analyzing the equilibrium magnetic response to an external magnetic field and to show that the low temperature equilibrium response is non linear . section [ sec - thermoremanent ] recalls how the function @xmath0 characterizing the fdt violation can be obtained from the thermoremanent magnetization experiment .
the results of our simulations are next presented and discussed in section [ sec - results ] .
in this section , we analyze the low temperature equilibrium response to an external magnetic field .
we consider a percolating cluster of @xmath12 sites , and first analyze a toy model for the magnetization response to an external magnetic field .
the equilibrium magnetization @xmath20 in an external magnetic field @xmath21 can be expressed as @xmath22 where @xmath23 denotes the thermal average of the observable @xmath24 with respect to the system without a magnetic field , and @xmath25 denotes the disorder average .
we are first going to formulate in section [ sec - formulation ] a low - temperature toy - model which allows analytical calculations of ( [ eq - expansion ] ) .
the predictions from this toy - model will be compared to simulations in section [ sec - comparison ] .
our toy - model relies on some assumptions about the geometry of the percolating clusters , and further assumptions about the low temperature magnetization distributions .
the validity of these assumptions relies on the fact that some of the predictions of our toy - model can be successfully compared to simulations ( see section [ sec - comparison ] ) . in the dilute antiferromagnets model ( [ eq - hamiltonian ] ) , the magnetization of the nel state of the percolating cluster is equal , up to a sign , to the difference @xmath26 in the number of sites in the two sublattices a and b , the number of sites in the percolating cluster being @xmath27 .
in order to allow for analytic treatment , we assume that both @xmath28 and @xmath29 are independent variables and gaussian distributed according to @xmath30 with a width @xmath31 scaling like @xmath32 . within these assumptions , the distribution of the nel state magnetization @xmath33 is also gaussian distributed : @xmath34 at zero temperature , the magnetization distribution of a given percolation cluster consists of two delta functions located at @xmath35 . as shown in fig .
[ fig - pm ] , the effect of a small temperature is a broadening of the two peaks at @xmath36 . the numerical calculations of @xmath37 shown in fig .
[ fig - pm ] were carried out using the swendsen - wang algorithm @xcite . in our toy - model
, we first make the approximation that all the geometry - dependence of the magnetization response is encoded in the single parameter @xmath33 .
this approximation becomes exact in the zero temperature limit . at a finite but sufficiently low temperature
, we still assume this single - parameter description of geometric fluctuations .
we further assume that the effect of a finite temperature is a gaussian broadening of the peaks at @xmath36 in the magnetization distribution : @xmath38 the thermal broadening @xmath39 originates from low temperature excitations above the nel state . at sufficiently low temperatures ,
only the lowest energy excitations contribute to @xmath31 .
if the system was not diluted , these excitations are properly described as a dilute gaz of clusters of spins with a wrong orientation with respect to the nel state .
the contribution to @xmath39 of these excitations is of the order of @xmath40 , @xmath41 being @xmath12-independent and behaving like @xmath42 .
it is also well - known that long range low energy ` droplets ' also exist in dilute percolating antiferromagnets , due to the self - similarity of the structure , and the fact that the order of ramification of the lattice is finite @xcite : it costs a finite energy to isolate a cluster of arbitrary size from the rest of the structure .
these ` droplet ' excitations can be clearly identified in the magnetization distribution of the ferromagnetic ising model @xcite .
in fact , we can account for these droplet excitations in an effective distribution of the parameter @xmath39 over the nel state magnetization @xmath33 .
we will come back on this point latter on in section [ sec - comparison ] .
we have chosen in ( [ eq - pm - toy ] ) a gaussian contribution of thermal excitations . the resulting contribution to the magnetization of these thermal excitations is linear in the magnetic field .
in fact , in order to describe how the magnetization saturates for magnetic fields scaling like @xmath43 , one should refine our toy - model to incorporate non gaussian tails in the magnetization distribution .
since , as mentionned previously , we are mainly interested in magnetic fields scaling like @xmath19 , these non gaussian tails do not play any significant role in this low magnetic field physics . within this toy - model ,
it is straightforward to calculate the magnetic field dependence of the average magnetization for a fixed value of @xmath33 .
to do so , we notice that the magnetization distribution in our toy - model is nothing but the convolution of @xmath44 and @xmath45 . as a consequence , @xmath46 from what we deduce the average magnetization for a given value of @xmath33 : @xmath47 for a fixed @xmath33 , and for a magnetic field smaller than the cross - over magnetic field @xmath18 defined as @xmath48
the magnetization response is linear , whereas it is non linear for magnetic fields stronger than @xmath18 . since @xmath33 and @xmath39 scale like @xmath49 , the cross - over field @xmath18 is small even for large systems .
more precisely , we now average the magnetization over the geometry : @xmath50 we should distinguish between the two regimes [ cols= " < , < " , ] as the magnetic field increased from zero , the response to the external field is first linear , and , for magnetic fields of the order of @xmath51 , cross - overs to a non linear behavior .
this behavior is shown in fig .
[ fig - aiman ] for various values of the ratio @xmath52 .
we now compare the predictions of our toy - model for the equilibrium magnetic response of percolation clusters to numerical calculations .
we have generated 2000 clusters for each value of the nel state magnetization @xmath33 .
all these clusters are contained inside the 20@xmath5320 square . in order to compare with the toy - model results ( [ eq - hstar ] ) , we have calculated for each of these clusters the cross - over field @xmath18 defined by the equality of the linear and cubic terms in the cumulant expansion ( [ eq - expansion ] ) : @xmath54 the magnetization distribution in a zero magnetic field being calculated with the swendsen - wang algorithm @xcite .
we have shown in fig .
[ fig - rescale ] the histogram of @xmath55 .
in the regime @xmath56 , eq .
( [ eq - hstar ] ) becomes @xmath57 : the histograms in fig .
[ fig - rescale ] would be a @xmath58 function located on the value @xmath59 . even if the histograms in fig .
[ fig - rescale ] have a finite width , we see that the scaling @xmath60 still holds , at least for not too small values of @xmath33 .
this suggests that @xmath39 is not @xmath33-independent but is rather distributed , and scales on average like @xmath33 .
we attribute this behavior to the existence of low energy droplet excitations .
since these excitations correspond to large magnetic domains , the magnetization induced by reversing these domains should be coupled to the total nel state magnetization @xmath33 .
in this section , we recall how the function @xmath0 characterizing the fdt violation can be obtained from the magnetization relaxation in the thermoremanent magnetization experiment .
we first assume linear response . in the presence of a time - dependent magnetic field @xmath61 ,
the linear contribution to the magnetization is @xmath62(t ) = \int_{- \infty}^t r(t , t ' ) h(t ' ) d t ' , \ ] ] with @xmath63 the kernel response .
we take here as a working hypothesis that @xmath64 a form of the response kernel suggested by the mean field model studies @xcite .
the auto - correlation @xmath65 is @xmath66 in most of the spin - glass models ( for instance : sherrington - kirkpatrick model , edwards - anderson model ) , the correlation length is vanishing , the reponse is purely local in space , and the terms @xmath67 vanish in ( [ eq - autocorr ] ) . in the presence of a finite correlation length ,
the thermoremanent magnetization is conjugate to the _ spatially non local _ autocorrelation ( [ eq - autocorr ] ) . from this point of view , ( [ eq - mag]),([eq - r]),([eq - autocorr ] ) can be safely taken as a extension of @xmath0 to our problem , in the sense that ( i ) lienar fdt reads @xmath68 ( ii ) we recover the usual definition of @xmath0 in the limit of a zero correlation length .
barrat @xcite used recently an interesting different method to handle spatially non local responses and non linearities : he measured the staggered magnetic response to a random field with a zero mean . in this way , the magnetic response to the random field is linear as a function of the width of the random field distribution , and conjugate to the _ local _ autocorrelations .
we underline that barrat does not consider the same conjugate quantities as ours , and the functions @xmath0 are thus different .
in particular , we can not handle symmetry breaking within our framework .
however , in the case of the present problem of magnetic systems on percolation clusters , the non linearities are quite weak and , as we will see , we can characterize their effects on dynamics , which could not be possible in the framework of barrat calculations . in the thermoremanent magnetization experiment
, @xmath61 is a step function @xmath69 , so that the thermoremanent magnetization reads @xmath70 where we have assumed @xmath71 [ we have indeed checked that this quantity was vanishing in our simulations ] .
the function @xmath0 is then obtained by differentiating the magnetic response @xmath72 with respect to the autocorrelation : @xmath73 .
if the waiting time is large enough so that equilibrium has been reached , the magnetic response @xmath74 is @xmath2-independent , @xmath0 is unity , and we recover the linear fdt : @xmath75 quite a lot of efforts have been devoted recently to characterize how the fdt is violated in an out - of - equilibrium situation .
analytical solutions were obtained in the framework of mean - field models @xcite .
the fluctuation - dissipation ratio was also obtained in numerical simulations in various models .
for instance , in the case of spin glasses , franz and rieger @xcite have analyzed the edwards - anderson model in three dimensions ; more recently , marinari _
_ @xcite have studied the fdt violation in three and four dimensional gaussian ising spin glasses , and shown that the fluctuation - dissipation ration @xmath0 is , in these models , equal to the static parisi function @xmath76 . a model of fragile glass
was also studied recently @xcite . as explained in section [ sec - equilibrium ] , the magnetic response of percolating dilute antiferromagnets is not linear for magnetic fields of the order of @xmath19 . in the absence of linear response , the equilibrium magnetization can be expanded in powers of the magnetic field @xmath21 , the coefficients of this expansion being the cumulants of the magnetization distribution ( see eq .
( [ eq - expansion ] ) ) . following the work of gallavotti and cohen @xcite , kurchan @xcite recently proposed an extension of the fdt to incoporate the effects of non linear response .
however , we can not use here this generalization in our monte carlo simulations since this would involve the calculation of the time - dependent magnetization distribution , included the tail where the magnetization is opposite to the magnetic field . for our purpose , we take here as a working phenomenological hypothesis that the thermoremanent magnetization is given by ( [ eq - mag ] ) , with the magnetic - field dependent response kernel @xmath77 in the presence of non linearities and out - of - equilibrium dynamics , @xmath78 contains contributions both from the non linearities and the aging dynamics .
however , in the limit of large waiting times , the system has equilibrated and thus only the non linearities contribute to @xmath78 . in the opposite limit of small waiting times , the non linearities do not contribute to @xmath0 , and , in this limit , a contact can be made with fdt violations in other systems , especially euclidian coarsening dynamics @xcite .
we now present our numerical calculations of @xmath0 .
our simulations were carried out on two clusters : a cluster @xmath79 with @xmath80 sites , @xmath81 , and a smaller cluster @xmath82 with @xmath83 sites and @xmath84 .
these two clusters are shown in fig .
[ fig - dessins ] .
we first present in section [ sec - eq - dyn ] the equilibrium dynamics : the waiting time is long enough for the system to have equilibrated in the external magnetic field , and , on the basis of the arguments presented in section [ sec - equilibrium ] , we expect sensible non linear effects .
in fact , the relaxation time is finite even in the thermodynamic limit ( interrupted aging ) . as the size of the system increases
, the relaxation time will first increase , due to zero energy barriers scaling like @xmath16 @xcite , and saturate when the linear size @xmath85 becomes larger than the correlation length given by @xcite @xmath86 with @xmath15 the percolation critical exponent .
the limit of small waiting times is next presented in section [ sec - out - eq - dyn ] .
in this situation , the magnetic response is linear .
the combined effects of non linearities and out - of - equilibrium response arising for intermediate waiting times are next presented in section [ sec - intermediate ] .
finally , the dependence on @xmath87 of the autocorrelation and the magnetic response are presented in section [ sec - tau - dependence ] .
we first examine the regime of a large waiting time @xmath2 , large enough for the magnetic response to be independent on @xmath2 . in practice
, we systematically checked that the magnetic response was unchanged when the waiting time was increased by a factor of @xmath88 .
the magnetic response @xmath89 is plotted as a function of the autocorrelation @xmath65 in fig .
[ fig4 ] for the clusters a and b. we clearly observe on fig .
[ fig4 ] important non linear effects since the magnetic response @xmath89 depends explicitly on the magnetic field @xmath21 , even at the relatively high temperature @xmath90 . in the short time limit , we observe a behavior of the type @xmath91 , whereas in the long time limit , @xmath92 . in order to interpolate between these two behaviors ,
we have fitted our numerical results to the form @xmath93 with @xmath94 where @xmath95 controls the width of the cross - over between the short and the long time regimes , and @xmath96 .
the fits obtained in this way are shown in fig .
[ fig4 ] , and , once the three parameters have been adjusted , a very good agreement with the simulation data is obtained .
the variations of @xmath78 deduced from the fits are shown in fig .
[ fig5 ] for the same simulations as in fig .
[ fig4 ] .
we observe in fig .
[ fig5 ] that @xmath78 cross - overs from unity at short times to a finite value @xmath97 in the long time relaxation .
if the response to the external magnetic field was linear , one would expect that @xmath68 . even though we could not address this question here
, we expect a non linear fdt of the type @xcite to hold in the long waiting time limit . in the short waiting time limit
, the thermoremanent magnetization is linear as a function of the magnetic field .
we have shown in fig .
[ fig6 ] the variations of the magnetic response @xmath98 versus the autocorrelation @xmath65 for the two values of the magnetic field @xmath99 , and @xmath100 .
linear response is clearly observed .
the variations of @xmath0 are shown in the insert of fig .
[ fig6 ] .
interestingly , the variations of @xmath0 in this situation where out - of - equilibrium effects are dominant are qualitatively the same as the ones in section [ sec - eq - dyn ] : @xmath24 cross - overs from unity at short times to a finite value in the long time limit .
we have no understanding of the reason why the variations of @xmath0 are qualitatively the same in the small and large waiting time limits , where deviations from linear fdt originate respectively from the out - of - equilibrium dynamics and non linear response .
the fact that @xmath0 is finite in the aging regime is a quite noticeable difference with euclidian coarsening @xcite , where @xmath24 is vanishing in the aging regime ( the linear response kernel @xmath63 in ( [ eq - mag ] ) is zero in this regime ) .
the long term memory of coarsening dynamics on percolating structures is thus stronger than for euclidian dynamics , which is maybe not surprising on the general grounds recalled in the introduction : a `` droplet '' of size @xmath12 has a zero temperature energy barrier scaling like @xmath101 @xcite , and a finite energy of the order of @xmath102 , @xmath103 being the order of ramification @xcite . in order to examine the conjugate effects of nonlinearities in the magnetization response and out - of - equilibrium dynamics , we carried out the thermoremanent magnetization simulation with the cluster b at the temperature @xmath104 , and for a waiting time @xmath105 .
the results are shown in fig .
[ fig7 ] , with @xmath87 up to @xmath106 .
we have checked that equilibrium was not reached by carrying a simulation with a waiting time @xmath107 . on the other hand , the magnetic response @xmath89 depends explicitly on the magnetic field @xmath21 , as is visible in fig .
[ fig7 ] . we observe that @xmath78 can still be fitted by the form ( [ eq - fit - x ] ) , even though we could not reach very small values of the correlation and magnetic responses , even for @xmath108 . in spin - glass models ,
the short time regime @xmath111 is valid up to a time @xmath112 of the order of the waiting time @xmath2 @xcite . as shown in fig .
[ fig - tau1 ] , we indeed observe such a dependence of @xmath112 in the out - of equilibrium situation : @xmath112 is of the order of @xmath113 for @xmath114 , and of the order of @xmath115 for @xmath116 .
however , for larger waiting times , non linearities significantly reduce @xmath112 ( @xmath117 for @xmath118 in fig .
[ fig - tau1 ] ) .
we observe in fig .
[ fig - tau2 ] in the case @xmath118 , @xmath90 ( equilibrium situation ) that @xmath112 is also a function of the magnetic field @xmath21 ( the value of @xmath112 for @xmath119 is one order of magnitude larger than for @xmath120 ) .
this effect is also visible in the out - of - equilibrium simulation shown in fig .
[ fig - tau2 ] ( @xmath104 ) .
however , from our simulations , we can not make a precise statement on the variations of @xmath112 as a function of @xmath21 for large waiting times .
we have thus carried out monte carlo simulations of the violation of the linear fdt in dilute percolating antiferromagnets .
we have shown that these systems exhibit non linear response for magnetic fields of the order of @xmath19 . in the small waiting time regime ,
the thermoremanent magnetization is linear in the magnetic field , but depends explicitly on the waiting time . on the other hand , for sufficiently large waiting times ,
the system has equilibrated ( interrupted aging ) , and the magnetic response is non linear .
interestingly , in both situations , as well as in the intermediate situation where both out - of - equilibrium and non linear effects come into account , the function @xmath0 characterizing the deviations from linear fdt has qualitatively the same shape : it is unity at short times and cross - overs to a constant finite value for long times , the cross - over occurring at @xmath112 . in the small waiting time limit , @xmath112 is of the order of the waiting time @xmath2 . for larger waiting times ,
non linearities strongly reduce @xmath112 as the magnetic field is increased . by comparison with domain growth processes in
non diluted lattices , the aging part of the dynamics shows stronger long - term memory , due to the existence of large scale low - energy ` droplet ' excitations .
* acknowledgments * r.m .
thanks a. barrat , l.f .
cugliandolo , j. kurchan , s. franz and p.c.w .
holdsworth for stimulating discussions .
part of the calculations presented here were carried out on the cray t3e computer of the centre de calcul vectoriel grenoblois of the commissariat lenergie atomique .
99 l. lundgren , p. svedlindh , p. norblad and o. beckman , phys .
lett . * 51 * ( 1983 ) 911 ; p. norblad , l. lundgren , p. svedlindh and l. sandlund , phys .
rev ; b * 33 * ( 1988 ) 645 ; l. lundgren , j. phys .
colloq france * 49 * ( 1988 ) c8 - 1001 and references therein .
m. alba , m. ocio and j. hamman , europhys .
* 2 * ( 1986 ) 45 ; j. phys .
france * 46 * ( 1985 ) l-1101 ; m. alba , j. hamman , m. ocio and p. refregier , j. appl . phys .
* 61 * ( 1987 ) 3683 ; e. vincent , j. hamman and m. ocio , recent progress in random magnets , d.h . ryan ed .
( world scientific , singapore , 1992 ) .
swendsen and j.s .
wang , phys .
* 57 * ( 1986 ) 2606 ; phys .
* 58 * ( 1987 ) 86 .
see also r.h .
swendsen , j.s .
wang and a.m. ferrenberg in _ the monte carlo method in condensed matter physics _ , topics in applied physics vol .
71 , k. binder ed .
( springer - verlag , berlin - heidelberg - new york , 1992 ) . | we analyze the violations of linear fluctuation - dissipation theorem ( fdt ) in the coarsening dynamics of the antiferromagnetic ising model on percolation clusters in two dimensions .
the equilibrium magnetic response is shown to be non linear for magnetic fields of the order of the inverse square root of the number of sites .
two extreme regimes can be identified in the thermoremanent magnetization : ( i ) linear response and out - of - equilibrium relaxation for small waiting times ( ii ) non linear response and equilibrium relaxation for large waiting times .
the function @xmath0 characterizing the deviations from linear fdt cross - overs from unity at short times to a finite positive value for longer times , with the same qualitative behavior whatever the waiting time .
we show that the coarsening dynamics on percolation clusters exhibits stronger long - term memory than usual euclidian coarsening .
16.8cm-.4cm-1 cm plus 0.2pt minus 0.1pt |
as the only missing particle in the standard model ( sm ) , the higgs boson is being intensively hunted at the lhc . recently ,
both the atlas and cms experiments have revealed hints of a higgs particle around @xmath6 @xcite .
while such a higgs mass can be well accommodated in the sm and the reported signal rates in several channels are also in agreement with the sm expectations after taking into account the large experimental uncertainty @xcite ( albeit the central value of the observed di - photon rate is somewhat above the sm prediction ) , the low energy supersymmetry ( susy ) seems to be a better framework to account for such a higgs . in low energy susy
the sm - like higgs mass is theoretically restricted in a narrow range and its di - photon rate at the lhc may exceed the sm prediction @xcite , both of which are welcomed by the lhc results . however , as the most popular low energy susy model , the minimal supersymmetric standard model ( mssm ) @xcite may have some tension to accommodate such a 125 gev higgs . as is well known , in the mssm the sm - like higgs mass is upper bounded by @xmath7 at tree - level and to get a higgs around @xmath6 we need sizable top / stop loop contributions , which depend quartically on the top quark mass and logarithmically on the stop masses @xcite .
this will , on the one hand , impose rather tight constraint on the mssm , and on the other hand , incur some fine - tuning @xcite .
such a problem can be alleviated in the so - called next - to - minimal supersymmetric standard model ( nmssm ) @xcite , which is the simplest singlet extension of the mssm with a scale invariant superpotential . in the nmssm , due to the introduction of some new couplings in the superpotential
, the sm - like higgs mass gets additional contribution at tree - level and also may be further pushed up by the mixing effect in diagonalizing the mass matrix of the cp - even higgs fields @xcite . as a result , a sm - like higgs around @xmath6 does not entail large loop contributions , which may thus ameliorate the fine - tuning problem @xcite . in this work , motivated by the recent lhc results
, we assume a sm - like higgs boson in @xmath8 and study its implication in the mssm and nmssm .
different from recent studies in this direction @xcite , we scan the model parameters by considering various experimental constraints and perform a comparative study for the mssm and nmssm .
we will investigate the features of the allowed parameter space in each model and particularly we pay more attention to the space of the nmssm which may be distinct from the mssm .
noting the lhc experiments utilize the channels @xmath9 , @xmath10 and @xmath11 in searching for the higgs boson @xcite , we also study their normalized production rates defined as @xmath12 where @xmath13 , and @xmath14 , @xmath15 and @xmath16 are respectively the rescaled couplings of the higgs to gluons , photons and weak gauge bosons by their sm values .
we are more interested in the case with @xmath17 because it is favored by current atlas and cms results @xcite .
as will be shown below , this case usually predicts a slepton or a chargino lighter than @xmath18 .
this paper is organized as follows . in sec .
ii , we recapitulate the characters of the higgs mass in the models for better understanding our numerical results . in sec .
iii , we perform a comprehensive scan over the parameter space of each model by imposing current experimental constraints and also by requiring a sm - like higgs boson in @xmath19 .
then we scrutinize the properties of the surviving parameter space . finally , we draw our conclusions in sec
in the mssm , the higgs sector consists of two doublet fileds @xmath20 and @xmath21 , which after the electroweak symmetry breaking , result in five physical higgs bosons : two cp - even scalars @xmath22 and @xmath23 , one cp - odd pseudoscalar @xmath24 and a pair of charged scalars @xmath25@xcite .
traditionally , such a higgs sector is described by the ratio of the higgs vacuum expectation values , @xmath26 , and the mass of the pseudoscalar @xmath27 . in most of the mssm parameter space ,
the lightest higgs boson @xmath22 has largest coupling to vector bosons ( i.e. the so - called sm - like higgs boson ) , and for moderate @xmath28 and large @xmath27 its mass is given by @xcite @xmath29 where @xmath30 , @xmath31 with @xmath32 and @xmath33 being the stop masses , @xmath34 with @xmath2 denoting the trilinear higgs - stop coupling and @xmath35 being the higgsino mass parameter .
obviously , the larger @xmath28 or @xmath36 is , the heavier @xmath22 becomes , and for given @xmath36 , @xmath37 reaches its maximum when @xmath38 , which corresponds to the so - called @xmath39 scenario . about eq.([mh ] ) , three points should be noted @xcite .
the first is this equation is only valid for small splitting between @xmath32 and @xmath33 . in case of large splitting ,
generally @xmath40 is needed to maximize @xmath37 .
the second is @xmath41 in eq.([mh ] ) is symmetric with respect to the sign of @xmath42 .
this behavior will be spoiled once higher order corrections are considered , and usually a larger @xmath37 is achieved for positive @xmath43 with @xmath44 being gluino soft breaking mass . and
the last is in eq.([mh ] ) , we do not include the contributions from the sbottom and slepton sectors .
such contributions are negative and become significant only for large @xmath28 . compared with the mssm , the higgs sector in the nmssm is rather complex , which can be seen from its superpotential and the corresponding soft - breaking terms given by @xcite @xmath45 here @xmath46 is the superpotential of the mssm without the @xmath35 term , the dimensionless parameters @xmath47 and @xmath48 are the coefficients of the higgs self couplings , and @xmath49 , @xmath50 , @xmath51 , @xmath52 and @xmath53 are the soft - breaking parameters . after the electroweak symmetry breaking , the three soft breaking masses squared for @xmath20 , @xmath21 and @xmath54 can be expressed in terms of their vevs ( i.e. @xmath55 , @xmath56 and @xmath57 ) through the minimization conditions of the scalar potential .
so in contrast to the mssm where there are only two parameters in the higgs sector , the higgs sector of the nmssm is described by six parameters @xcite : @xmath58 the higgs fields can be written in the following form : @xmath59 where @xmath60 , @xmath61 with @xmath62 and @xmath63 , @xmath64 and @xmath65 are goldstone bosons and @xmath66 . in the cp - conserving nmssm ,
the fields @xmath67 , @xmath68 and @xmath69 mix to form three physical cp - even higgs bosons , and @xmath70 and @xmath71 mix to form two physical cp - odd higgs bosons .
obviously , the field @xmath72 corresponds to the sm higgs field , and the scalar @xmath22 with largest @xmath68 component is called the sm - like higgs boson . under the basis ( @xmath67 , @xmath68 , @xmath69 ) , the elements of the mass matrix for @xmath73 fields at tree level are given by @xcite @xmath74,\\ { \cal m}^2_{33}&= & \frac{1}{4 } \lambda^2 v^2 ( \frac{m_a \sin 2\beta}{\mu})^2 + \frac{\kappa\mu}{\lambda } ( a_\kappa + \frac{4\kappa\mu}{\lambda } ) - \frac{1}{2 } \lambda \kappa v^2 \sin 2 \beta , \label{33}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath75 is nothing but @xmath41 at tree level without considering the mixing among @xmath73 , and its second term @xmath76 originates from the coupling @xmath77 in the superpotential .
for such a complex matrix , it is useful to consider two scenarios for understanding the results : * scenario i : @xmath78 and @xmath35 is fixed . in this limit , since @xmath79 , the singlet field @xmath69 is decoupled from the doublet fields , and the mssm mass matrix is recovered for the ( @xmath67,@xmath68 ) system .
this scenario indicates that , even for moderate @xmath47 and @xmath48 , @xmath37 should change little from its mssm prediction .
so in order to show the difference of the two models in predicting @xmath37 , we are more interested in large @xmath47 case . especially we will mainly discuss @xmath80 case , where the tree level contributions to @xmath41 , i.e. @xmath75 , are maximized for moderate values of @xmath28 rather than by large values of @xmath28 as in the mssm .
* scenario ii : @xmath81 and @xmath82 , which can be easily realized for a large @xmath83 . in this limit
, @xmath67 is decoupled from the ( @xmath68,@xmath69 ) system and the properties of @xmath37 can be qualitatively understood by the @xmath84 matrix @xcite @xmath85 where @xmath86 denotes the radiative corrections to @xmath37 with its form given by the last two terms of eq.([mh ] ) , and @xmath87 represents the potentially important effect of ( @xmath67,@xmath69 ) mixing on @xmath88 .
this matrix indicates that the ( @xmath68,@xmath69 ) mixing can push @xmath37 up once @xmath89 , and such effect is maximized for @xmath90 slightly larger than @xmath91 and at the same time @xmath92 slightly below @xmath93 ( larger @xmath94 will destabilize the vacuum ) @xcite . obviously , in this push - up case
, @xmath22 is the next - to - lightest cp - even higgs boson and the larger the ( @xmath95 ) mixing is , the heavier @xmath22 becomes .
alternatively , the mixing can pull @xmath37 down on the condition of @xmath96 , which occurs for large @xmath97 ( for @xmath98 , see discussion below ) as indicated by the expression of @xmath99 and the positiveness of @xmath87 . here
we remind that , due to the extra contribution @xmath76 to @xmath41 at tree level , @xmath37 in the pull - down case may still be larger than its mssm prediction for a certain @xmath86 . +
since our results presented below is approximately described by scenario ii , we now estimate the features of its favored region to predict @xmath100 .
first , since @xmath101 , @xmath102 implies that @xmath103 .
numerically , we find @xmath103 for the push - up case , and @xmath104 for the pull - down case ( see fig.[fig7 ] ) .
second , @xmath105 must be relatively small , which implies that @xmath98 for @xmath106 .
this can be understood as follows .
in the push - up case , since @xmath107 , the condition @xmath108 ( for vacuum stability ) has limited the size of @xmath109 . while in the pull - down case , a very large @xmath109 will suppress greatly @xmath37 to make it difficult to reach @xmath6 , and this in return limits the size of @xmath109 .
given that @xmath110 as required by the lep bound on chargino mass and that a larger @xmath35 is favored for the pull - down scenario , one can infer that the value of @xmath111 should be around 2 after considering that the third term in @xmath109 is less important .
numerically speaking , we find @xmath112 and @xmath113 ( see fig.[fig7 ] ) .
lastly , light stops may be possible in the nmssm with large @xmath47 to predict @xmath100 . to see this
, we consider the parameters @xmath114 and @xmath115 , and we get @xmath116 without considering the mixing effect to predict @xmath100 . this is in sharp contrast with @xmath117 in mssm for @xmath118 . in this work we use the package nmssmtools @xcite to calculate the higgs masses and mixings , which includes the dominant one - loop and leading logarithmic two - loop corrections to @xmath119 .
we checked our mssm results of @xmath37 by using the code feynhiggs@xcite and found the results given by nmssmtools and feynhiggs are in good agreement ( for @xmath120 they agree within @xmath121 for same mssm parameters ) .
in this work , we scan the parameters of the models and investigate the samples that predict @xmath122 and at the same time survive the following constraints @xcite : ( 1 ) the constraint from the lhc search channel @xmath123 for non - standard higgs boson .
( 2 ) the limits from the lep and the tevatron on the masses of sparticles as well as on the neutralino pair productions . ( 3 ) the constraints from b - physics , such as @xmath124 , the latest experimental result of @xmath125 , @xmath126 , @xmath127 and the mass differences @xmath128 and @xmath129 . ( 4 )
the indirect constraints from the electroweak precision observables such as @xmath130 , @xmath131 and @xmath132 , and their combinations @xmath133 @xcite .
we require @xmath134 to be compatible with the lep / sld data at @xmath135 confidence level .
we also require the susy prediction of the observable @xmath136 ( @xmath137 ) to be within the @xmath138 range of its experimental value @xcite .
( 5 ) the constraints from the muon anomalous magnetic moment : @xmath139 @xcite .
we require the susy effects to explain the discrepancy at @xmath0 level .
( 6 ) the dark matter constraints from wmap relic density ( 0.1053 @xmath140 0.1193 ) @xcite and the direct search result from xenon100 experiment ( at @xmath141 c.l . )
( 7 ) for the nmssm , we also require the absence of a landau singularity below the gut scale , which implies @xmath142 for small @xmath48 and @xmath143 for @xmath144 at weak scale . in our calculation , we fix @xmath145 and @xmath146 @xcite ( @xmath147 denotes the strange quark fraction in the proton mass ) , and use the package nmssmtools to implement most of the constraints and to calculate the observables we are interested in . in our scan , we note that the soft parameters in the slepton sector can only affect significantly the muon anomalous magnetic moment @xmath148 , which will in return limit the important parameter @xmath28 , so we assume them a common value @xmath149 and treat it as a free parameter . for the soft parameters in the first two generation squark sector , due to their little effects on the properties of the higgs bosons , we fix them
to be @xmath150 . as for the gaugino masses ,
we assume the grand unification relation , @xmath151 with @xmath152 being the fine structure constants of the different gauge groups , and treat @xmath153 as a free parameter . in order to reduce free parameters
, we also assume the unimportant parameters @xmath154 and @xmath155 to satisfy @xmath156 and @xmath157 . in order to study the implication of @xmath158 in generic susy ,
we relax the soft mass parameters to 5 tev and perform an extensive random scan over the following parameter regions : @xmath159 for the mssm , and @xmath160 for the nmssm . in our scan
, we only keep the samples satisfying the requirements listed in the text ( including @xmath161 ) .
to show the differences between the mssm and the nmssm , we also perform a scan similar to eq.([nmssm - scan ] ) except that we require @xmath162 . ) , projected in the plane of @xmath32 versus @xmath163 with @xmath164 and @xmath34.,title="fig:",width=211 ] ) , projected in the plane of @xmath32 versus @xmath163 with @xmath164 and @xmath34.,title="fig:",width=211 ] ) , projected in the plane of @xmath32 versus @xmath163 with @xmath164 and @xmath34.,title="fig:",width=211 ] in fig.[fig1 ] , we show the correlation of the lighter top - squark mass ( @xmath165 ) with the ratio @xmath166 ( @xmath167 ) for the surviving samples in the mssm and nmssm . as expected from eq.([mh ] ) , in order to predict @xmath100 in the mssm , a large @xmath42 is needed for a moderate light @xmath168 , and with @xmath169 becoming heavy , the ratio @xmath166 decreases , but is unlikely to vanish for @xmath170 .
these features are maintained for nmssm with @xmath171 ( see the middle panel ) but changed for nmssm with a large @xmath47 , where @xmath42 can possibly vanish even for @xmath172 .
fig.[fig1 ] also shows that a @xmath169 as light as @xmath173 is still able to give the required @xmath37 .
but in this case @xmath42 is large ( @xmath174 ) , which leads to a large mass splitting between two stops ( @xmath175 ) .
note that a @xmath169 as light as @xmath176 does not contradict the recent susy search result of the lhc @xcite .
since in heavy susy the radiative correction @xmath86 is usually very large , @xmath100 is unlikely to impose tight constraints on other parameters of the models . considering heavy susy
is disfavored by naturalness , we in the following concentrate on the implication of @xmath100 in sub - tev susy . in this section
, we study the implication of @xmath158 in low energy mssm and nmssm . in order to illustrate the new features of the nmssm
, we only consider the case with @xmath106 .
our scans over the parameter spaces are quite similar to those in eq.([mssm - scan ] ) and eq.([nmssm - scan ] ) except that we narrow the ranges of @xmath177 , @xmath178 and @xmath2 as follows : @xmath179 ) for both models and the requirement @xmath106 for the nmssm . here
the samples are projected in the plane of @xmath32 versus @xmath2 .
the upper ( lower ) panels correspond to @xmath180 ( @xmath17 ) with @xmath181 .
for the nmssm results , the circles ( green ) denote the case of the lightest higgs boson being the sm - like higgs ( the so - called pull - down case ) , and the times ( red ) denotes the case of the next - to - lightest higgs boson being the sm - like higgs ( the so - called push - up case ) .
, title="fig:",width=245 ] ) for both models and the requirement @xmath106 for the nmssm . here
the samples are projected in the plane of @xmath32 versus @xmath2 .
the upper ( lower ) panels correspond to @xmath180 ( @xmath17 ) with @xmath181 . for
the nmssm results , the circles ( green ) denote the case of the lightest higgs boson being the sm - like higgs ( the so - called pull - down case ) , and the times ( red ) denotes the case of the next - to - lightest higgs boson being the sm - like higgs ( the so - called push - up case ) .
, title="fig:",width=245 ] ) for both models and the requirement @xmath106 for the nmssm . here
the samples are projected in the plane of @xmath32 versus @xmath2 .
the upper ( lower ) panels correspond to @xmath180 ( @xmath17 ) with @xmath181 .
for the nmssm results , the circles ( green ) denote the case of the lightest higgs boson being the sm - like higgs ( the so - called pull - down case ) , and the times ( red ) denotes the case of the next - to - lightest higgs boson being the sm - like higgs ( the so - called push - up case ) .
, title="fig:",width=245 ] ) for both models and the requirement @xmath106 for the nmssm . here
the samples are projected in the plane of @xmath32 versus @xmath2 .
the upper ( lower ) panels correspond to @xmath180 ( @xmath17 ) with @xmath181 . for
the nmssm results , the circles ( green ) denote the case of the lightest higgs boson being the sm - like higgs ( the so - called pull - down case ) , and the times ( red ) denotes the case of the next - to - lightest higgs boson being the sm - like higgs ( the so - called push - up case ) .
, title="fig:",width=245 ] in fig.[fig2 ] we project the surviving samples of the models in the plane of @xmath32 versus @xmath2 , showing the results with @xmath180 and @xmath182 separately . as we analyzed in sec .
ii , the sm - like higgs in the nmssm may be either the lightest higgs boson ( corresponding to the pull - down case ) or the next - to - lightest higgs boson ( the push - up case ) . in the figure we distinguished these two cases .
we note that among the surviving samples the number of the pull - down case is about twice the push - up case .
fig.[fig2 ] shows that , in order to get @xmath100 in the mssm , @xmath32 and @xmath183 must be larger than about @xmath184 and @xmath185 respectively , and the bounds are pushed up to @xmath186 and @xmath187 respectively for @xmath17 . while in the nmssm , a @xmath169 as light as about @xmath188 ( in either the pull - down or push - up case ) is still able to predict @xmath100 , and even if one require @xmath17 , a @xmath169 as light as about @xmath176 is allowed . the fact that the nmssm allows a lighter @xmath169 than the mssm indicates that the nmssm is more natural than the mssm in light of the lhc results .
.the ranges of the rescaled couplings @xmath189 and @xmath190 predicted by the surviving samples of the two models .
the region of @xmath14(@xmath191 ) is obtained by only considering the samples with @xmath192 . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] since a light @xmath169 may significantly change the effective couplings @xmath14 and @xmath193 , we present in table i their predicted ranges for the surviving samples .
this table shows that @xmath14 is always reduced , and for @xmath194 in the nmssm , the reduction factor may reach @xmath195 . while @xmath193 exhibits quite strange behaviors : it is enhanced in the mssm , but may be either enhanced or suppressed in the nmssm .
this is because , unlike @xmath14 which is affected only by squark loops , @xmath193 gets new physics contributions from loops mediated by charged higgs boson , charginos , sleptons and also squarks , and there exists cancelation among different loops . as will be shown below , the current experiments can not rule out light sparticles like @xmath196 and chargino .
although the contributions of these particles to @xmath193 are far smaller than the @xmath197 loop contribution , they may still alter the coupling significantly .
, but showing the dependence of the di - photon signal rate @xmath198 on the effective @xmath199 coupling @xmath200.,title="fig:",width=264 ] , but showing the dependence of the di - photon signal rate @xmath198 on the effective @xmath199 coupling @xmath200.,title="fig:",width=264 ] since the di - photon signal is the most important discovery channel for the higgs boson around @xmath6 , it is useful to study its rate carefully . from eq.([definition1 ] ) one can learn that the rate is affected by @xmath14 and @xmath193 discussed above , and also by the total width of @xmath22 ( or more basically by the @xmath201 coupling since @xmath202 is the dominant decay of @xmath22 ) .
the importance of @xmath201 coupling on the di - photon rate was recently emphasized in @xcite .
here we restrict our study to the @xmath100 case . in fig.[fig3 ] we show the dependence of the di - photon signal rate @xmath198 on the effective @xmath199 coupling ( including the potentially large susy corrections @xcite ) normalized by its sm value .
this figure indicates that although the rate is suppressed for most of the surviving samples in both models , there still exist some samples with enhanced rate , especially the nmssm is more likely to push up the rate than the mssm .
this feature can be understood as follows .
in susy , @xmath17 requires approximately the combination @xmath203 to exceed 1 . for the mssm , given @xmath204 and @xmath205 for nearly all the cases , this condition is not easy to satisfy . while in the nmssm , due to the mixing between the doublet field @xmath68 and the singlet field @xmath69 , @xmath206 is possible once the singlet component in @xmath22 is significant , which is helpful to enhance the combination .
in fact , we analyzed carefully the @xmath207 cases and found they are characterized by @xmath208 and @xmath209 in the mssm , and by @xmath210 in the nmssm .
in other words , it is the enhanced @xmath211 coupling ( reduced total width of @xmath22 ) that mainly push up the di - photon rate in the mssm ( nmssm ) to exceed its sm prediction .
fig.[fig3 ] also indicates that the pull - down case in the nmssm is less effective in reducing @xmath212 and thus can hardly enhance the di - photon rate .
this is because in the push - up case , both @xmath213 and @xmath88 in eq.([re - m ] ) are moderate and often comparable , which are helpful to enhance the ( @xmath214 ) mixing .
finally , we note that in some rare cases of the nmssm the ratio @xmath215 may be very small even for @xmath210 .
this is because there exists very light higgs boson so that @xmath22 decays dominantly into them . , but
only for the mssm , projected in the planes of @xmath216 versus @xmath35 and @xmath215 versus @xmath217.,title="fig:",width=264 ] , but only for the mssm , projected in the planes of @xmath216 versus @xmath35 and @xmath215 versus @xmath217.,title="fig:",width=264 ] in order to further clarify the reason for the enhancement of the di - photon rate in the mssm , we scrutinize carefully the parameters of the model and find that the samples with @xmath17 correspond to the case with a large @xmath218 and @xmath219 , which is illustrated in fig.[fig4 ] .
this means that the stau loop plays an important role in enhancing @xmath220 .
we note that similar conclusion was recently achieved in @xcite , but in that work the authors did not consider the tight experimental constraints . from fig.[fig4 ]
we also note that @xmath221 is predicted in the mssm with @xmath222 .
so future precise measurement of @xmath215 and @xmath223 may be utilized to verify the correctness of the mssm . , but showing the signal rate @xmath224 versus the coupling @xmath225 . ,
title="fig:",width=264 ] , but showing the signal rate @xmath224 versus the coupling @xmath225 .
, title="fig:",width=264 ] considering the process @xmath226 ( @xmath4 ) is another important higgs search channel , we in fig.[fig5 ] show the signal rate versus the @xmath227 coupling .
this figure shows that in the mssm , @xmath22 is highly sm - like , while in the nmssm , the singlet component in @xmath22 may be sizable , especially in the push - up case , so that @xmath16 is reduced significantly .
the signal rate @xmath228 also behaves differently in the two models . in the mssm , because @xmath204 and in most cases @xmath229 , @xmath228 is always less than 1 ( for @xmath17 it varies between 0.7 and 0.95 ) . in the nmssm ,
however , @xmath228 may exceed 1 and in this case we find @xmath230 .
the reason for such a correlation is the two quantities have the same origin for their enhancement , i.e. the suppression of the @xmath231 due to the presence of the singlet component in @xmath22 . versus @xmath216 and versus @xmath48 respectively . , title="fig:",width=245 ] versus @xmath216 and versus @xmath48 respectively .
, title="fig:",width=245 ] versus @xmath216 and versus @xmath48 respectively .
, title="fig:",width=245 ] versus @xmath216 and versus @xmath48 respectively . ,
title="fig:",width=245 ] next we investigate the favored parameter space of the nmssm to predict @xmath100 . as introduced in sec .
ii , besides the soft parameters in the stop sector , the sensitive parameters include @xmath28 , @xmath35 , @xmath48 as well as @xmath232 . in fig.[fig6 ] , we project the surviving samples in the planes of @xmath35 versus @xmath216 and versus @xmath48 .
this figure shows three distinctive characters for the allowed parameters .
the first is that @xmath28 must be moderate , below 4 and 9 for the pull - down and the push - up case , respectively .
two reasons can account for it .
one is that in the nmssm with large @xmath47 , the precision electroweak data , i.e. the constraint ( 4 ) , strongly disfavor a large @xmath28 @xcite .
the other reason is that , as far as @xmath106 is concerned , a moderate @xmath28 is welcomed to enhance the tree level value of @xmath41 ( i.e. @xmath233 ) so that even without heavy stops , @xmath37 can still reach @xmath6 .
moreover , since the ( @xmath214 ) mixing is to reduce the value of @xmath213 in eq.([re - m ] ) in the pull - down case , a larger @xmath88 ( or equivalently a smaller @xmath28 ) is favored by the higgs mass .
the second character is that @xmath97 in the push - up case is usually much smaller than that in the pull - down case .
this is because , as we introduced in sec .
ii , a large @xmath97 is needed by the pull - down case to enhance @xmath88 in eq.([re - m ] ) .
the third character is obtained by comparing the parameter regions in the upper panels with those in the lower panels , which shows that @xmath17 puts a lower bound on @xmath48 , i.e. @xmath234 . the underlying reason is that for @xmath235 , the dark matter will be light and singlino - like , and to get its currently measured relic density , the dark matter must annihilate in the early universe by exchanging a light higgs boson @xcite . in this case
, @xmath22 mainly decays into the light bosons , which in return will suppress the di - photon rate . , but showing the correlation between @xmath232 and @xmath236 .
the dashed line denotes the relation @xmath237.,width=264 ] in fig.[fig7 ] we show the correlation of @xmath232 with @xmath236 .
this figure indicates that @xmath238 for the push - up case and @xmath239 for the pull - down case , which is in agreement with our expectation .
in fact , we checked each surviving sample and found it satisfies the condition : @xmath240 and @xmath241 , so the samples can be well described by scenario ii .
we also checked that the mixing of the field @xmath67 with @xmath68/@xmath69 is small and @xmath232 is approximately the heaviest cp - even higgs boson mass .
fig.[fig7 ] also indicates that the relation @xmath242 is maintained quite well in the push - up case , but is moderately spoiled in the pull - down case .
the reason is , as we introduced in sec .
ii , the requirement that @xmath109 should be moderately small actually implies @xmath243 with @xmath244 . in the push - up case
the third term in @xmath245 is not important , while in the pull case , although it is several times smaller than the second term , it may not be negligible .
we checked our results and found @xmath246 and @xmath247 for all the surviving samples .
about the nmssm with @xmath106 , three points should be noted .
the first is , from the results presented in fig.[fig6 ] , one may find the presence of a smuon and/or a chargino lighter than @xmath248 .
this is because the surviving samples are characterized either by @xmath249 or @xmath250 or by both in the nmssm ( see fig.[fig6 ] ) . then to explain the discrepancy of muon anomalous magnetic moment @xmath251
is needed for a low @xmath216 , and @xmath252 implies @xmath253 .
we numerically checked the validity of this conclusion .
the second point is , although @xmath254 may be regarded as a new source of fine tuning in the nmssm , it is rather predictive to get the value of @xmath232 once @xmath35 and @xmath28 are experimental determined .
finally , we note the favored region for @xmath35 and @xmath28 shown in fig.[fig6 ] does not overlap with that in fig.[fig4 ] .
this may be used to discriminate the models . , but projected on the plane of the charged higgs boson mass and @xmath216.,title="fig:",width=264 ] , but projected on the plane of the charged higgs boson mass and @xmath216.,title="fig:",width=264 ] finally , we briefly describe other implications of @xmath100 in the susy models . in fig.[fig8 ]
we project the surviving samples on the plane of @xmath28 versus @xmath255 with @xmath256 denoting the charged higgs boson .
this figure shows that @xmath256 must be heavier than about @xmath176 in the mssm .
this bound is much higher than the corresponding lep bound , which is about @xmath257 . for the nmssm with a large @xmath47
, the bound can be further pushed up to about @xmath184 .
this figure also indicates that in the mssm , @xmath28 may reach 35 for @xmath258 .
then based on the mc simulation by the atlas collaboration @xcite , one may expect that the charged higgs may be observable from the process @xmath259 at the early stage of the lhc
. however , this may be impossible .
the reason is , for relatively light @xmath256 and large @xmath28 , @xmath35 must be large to satisfy the constraint from dark matter direct detection experiments such as xenon100 .
this will greatly suppress the @xmath260 coupling @xcite .
for the nmssm , the hope to observe @xmath256 is also dim because @xmath28 is small . , but
exhibiting the spin - independent @xmath261-nucleon scattering cross section as a function of the dark matter mass.,title="fig:",width=264 ] , but exhibiting the spin - independent @xmath261-nucleon scattering cross section as a function of the dark matter mass.,title="fig:",width=264 ] in fig.[fig9 ] we show the spin - independent elastic scattering between dark matter and nucleon .
we use the formula presented in the appendix of @xcite to calculate the scattering rate . as expected , the xenon100 ( 2012 ) data to be released in near future will further exclude some samples , especially the pull - down case of the nmssm
will be strongly disfavored if xenon100 ( 2012 ) fails to find any evidence of dark matter ( assuming the grand unification relation of the gaugino mass ) .
from the left of fig.[fig9 ] one can learn that for the samples with @xmath17 in the mssm , the scattering rate is small , usually at least one order below than the sensitivity of the xenon100 ( 2012 ) .
motivated by the recent lhc hints of a higgs boson around 125 gev , we assume a sm - like higgs with the mass 123 - 127 gev and study its implication in low energy susy by comparing the mssm and nmssm . under various experimental constraints at @xmath0 level ( including the muon @xmath1 and the dark matter relic density ) , we scanned over the parameter space of each model
. then in the parameter space allowed by current experimental constraints and also predicting a sm - like higgs in 123 - 127 gev , we examined the properties of the sensitive parameters and calculated the rates of the di - photon signal and the @xmath3 ( @xmath4 ) signals at the lhc . among our various findings
the typical ones are : ( i ) in the mssm the top squark and @xmath2 must be large and thus incur some fine - tuning , which can be much ameliorated in the nmssm ; ( ii ) in the mssm a light @xmath262 is needed to make the di - photon rate of the sm - like higgs exceed its sm prediction , while the nmssm has more ways in doing this ; ( iii ) in the mssm the signal rates of @xmath5 at the lhc are never enhanced compared with their sm predictions , while in the nmssm they may be enhanced ; ( iv ) a large part of the parameter space so far survived will be soon covered by the expected xenon100(2012 ) sensitivity ( especially for the nmssm ) . therefore , although the low energy susy can in general accommodate a sm - like higgs boson near 125 gev and enhance its di - photon signal rate at the lhc , not all models of low energy susy are equally competent if they are required to satisfy all current experimental constraints . from our present study and some other studies in the literature ,
we conclude : * the fancy cmssm / msugra is hard to give a 125 gev sm - like higgs boson @xcite .
* the mssm can give such a 125 gev higgs and can also enhance its di - photon signal rate at the lhc , which , however , will incur some fine - tuning . * the nmssm ( the nearly minimal susy model ) can give a 125 gev sm - like higgs , but severely suppress its di - photon signal rate at the lhc @xcite . *
the nmssm is so far the best model to accommodate such a 125 gev higgs ; it can naturally ( without fine - tuning ) predict such a sm - like higgs mass and readily enhance its di - photon signal rate at the lhc . at the same time , in a large part of its parameter space , this model can also enhance the signal rates @xmath5 ( @xmath263 ) at the lhc and predict a large scattering rate of dark matter and nucleon at the xenon100 .
so the interplay of lhc and xenon100 will soon allow for a good test of this model .
this work was supported in part by the national natural science foundation of china ( nnsfc ) under grant nos .
10821504 , 11135003 , 10775039 , 11075045 , by specialized research fund for the doctoral program of higher education with grant no .
20104104110001 , and by the project of knowledge innovation program ( pkip ) of chinese academy of sciences under grant no .
kjcx2.yw.w10 .
99 atlas collaboration , arxiv:1202.1408 [ hep - ex ] ; arxiv:1202.1414 [ hep - ex ] ; arxiv:1202.1415 [ hep - ex ] .
cms collaboration , arxiv:1202.1416 [ hep - ex ] ; arxiv:1202.1487 [ hep - ex ] ; arxiv:1202.1488 [ hep - ex ] ; arxiv:1202.1489 [ hep - ex ] ; arxiv:1202.1997 [ hep - ex ] ; arxiv:1202.3478 [ hep - ex ] ; arxiv:1202.3617 [ hep - ex ] ; arxiv:1202.4083 [ hep - ex ] ; arxiv:1202.4195 [ hep - ex ] .
d. carmi , a. falkowski , e. kuflik and t. volansky , arxiv:1202.3144 [ hep - ph ] . j. r. espinosa , c. grojean , m. muhlleitner and m. trott , arxiv:1202.3697 [ hep - ph ] ; a. azatov , r. contino and j. galloway , arxiv:1202.3415 [ hep - ph ] .
s. moretti and s. munir , eur .
j. c * 47 * , 791 ( 2006 ) ; k. hsieh and c. p. yuan , phys .
d * 78 * , 053006 ( 2008 ) ; i. low and s. shalgar , jhep * 0904 * , 091 ( 2009 ) ; u. ellwanger , 698 , 293 ( 2011 ) . j. cao , z. heng , t. liu , j. m. yang , 703 , 462 ( 2011 ) .
u. ellwanger , arxiv:1112.3548 .
h. e. haber and g. l. kane , phys .
* 117 * , 75 ( 1985 ) ; j. f. gunion and h. e. haber , nucl .
b * 272 * , 1 ( 1986 ) [ erratum - ibid .
b * 402 * , 567 ( 1993 ) ] .
a. djouadi , phys .
rept . *
459 * , 1 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0503173 ] .
m. s. carena , j. r. espinosa , m. quiros and c. e. m. wagner , 355 , 209 ( 1995 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9504316 ] .
h. chankowski , j. r. ellis and s. pokorski , phys .
b * 423 * , 327 ( 1998 ) [ hep - ph/9712234 ] ; r. barbieri and a. strumia , phys .
lett . b * 433 * , 63 ( 1998 ) [ hep - ph/9801353 ] ; g. l. kane and s. f. king , phys .
b * 451 * , 113 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9810374 ] .
u. ellwanger , c. hugonie and a. m. teixeira , phys .
rept . * 496 * , 1 ( 2010 ) ; m. maniatis , int .
j. mod .
* a25 * ( 2010 ) 3505 [ arxiv:0906.0777 [ hep - ph ] ] .
for phenomenological studies , see , e.g. , j. r. ellis _ et al . _ , 39 , 844 ( 1989 ) ; m. drees , int .
a*4 * , 3635 ( 1989 ) ; s. f. king , p. l. white , 52 , 4183 ( 1995 ) ; b. ananthanarayan , p.n .
pandita , 353 , 70 ( 1995 ) ; b. a. dobrescu , k. t. matchev , 0009 , 031 ( 2000 ) ; r. dermisek , j. f. gunion , 95 , 041801 ( 2005 ) ; g. hiller , 70 , 034018 ( 2004 ) ; f. domingo , u. ellwanger , 0712 , 090 ( 2007 ) ; z. heng _ et al .
_ , 77 , 095012 ( 2008 ) ; r. n. hodgkinson , a. pilaftsis , 76 , 015007 ( 2007 ) ; w. wang _
_ , 680 , 167 ( 2009 ) ; j. m. yang , int . j. mod
. phys .
d * 20 * , 1383 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1102.4942 [ hep - ph ] ] ; u. ellwanger and c. hugonie , mod .
a * 22 * , 1581 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0612133 ] ; eur .
j. c * 25 * , 297 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9909260 ] ; u. ellwanger , eur .
j. c * 71 * , 1782 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1108.0157 [ hep - ph ] ] .
s. f. king , m. muhlleitner and r. nevzorov , arxiv:1201.2671 [ hep - ph ] .
z. kang , j. li and t. li , arxiv:1201.5305 [ hep - ph ] .
m. bastero - gil , c. hugonie , s. f. king , d. p. roy and s. vempati , phys .
b * 489 * , 359 ( 2000 ) [ hep - ph/0006198 ] ; a. delgado , c. kolda , j. p. olson and a. de la puente , phys .
lett . * 105 * , 091802 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1005.1282 [ hep - ph ] ] ; u. ellwanger , g. espitalier - noel and c. hugonie , jhep * 1109 * ( 2011 ) 105 [ arxiv:1107.2472 [ hep - ph ] ] ; g. g. ross and k. schmidt - hoberg , arxiv:1108.1284 [ hep - ph ] . s. heinemeyer , o. stal and g. weiglein , arxiv:1112.3026 ; a. arbey _ et al .
_ , arxiv:1112.3028 ; l. j. hall , d. pinner and j. t. ruderman , arxiv:1112.2703 ; p. draper _ et al .
_ , arxiv:1112.3068 ; a. arbey , m. battaglia and f. mahmoudi , arxiv:1112.3032 ; o. buchmueller _ et al .
_ , arxiv:1112.3564 ; m. kadastik _ et al .
_ , arxiv:1112.3647 ; j. cao , z. heng , d. li and j. m. yang , arxiv:1112.4391 [ hep - ph ] .
a. arvanitaki and g. villadoro , arxiv:1112.4835 [ hep - ph ] ; h. baer , v. barger , a. mustafayev , arxiv:1112.3017 ; i. gogoladze , q. shafi and c. s. un , arxiv:1112.2206 [ hep - ph ] ; j. l. feng , k. t. matchev and d. sanford , arxiv:1112.3021 [ hep - ph ] ; s. akula , b. altunkaynak , d. feldman , p.
nath and g. peim , arxiv:1112.3645 [ hep - ph ] ; a. bottino , n. fornengo and s. scopel , arxiv:1112.5666 [ hep - ph ] ; j. f. gunion , y. jiang and s. kraml , arxiv:1201.0982 [ hep - ph ] ; p. fileviez perez , arxiv:1201.1501 [ hep - ph ] ; j. ellis , m. k. gaillard and d. v. nanopoulos , arxiv:1201.6045 [ hep - ph ] ; n. karagiannakis , g. lazarides and c. pallis , arxiv:1201.2111 [ hep - ph ] ; l. roszkowski , e. m. sessolo and y. -l .
s. tsai , arxiv:1202.1503 [ hep - ph ] ; l. aparicio , d. g. cerdeno and l. e. ibanez , arxiv:1202.0822 [ hep - ph ] ; c. -f .
chang , k. cheung , y. -c .
lin and t. -c .
yuan , arxiv:1202.0054 [ hep - ph ] ; k. a. olive , arxiv:1202.2324 [ hep - ph ] ; j. ellis and k. a. olive , arxiv:1202.3262 [ hep - ph ] ; h. baer , v. barger and a. mustafayev , arxiv:1202.4038 [ hep - ph ] ; d. ghosh , m. guchait and d. sengupta , arxiv:1202.4937 [ hep - ph ] ; n. desai , b. mukhopadhyaya and s. niyogi , arxiv:1202.5190 [ hep - ph ] . m. carena , s. gori , n. r. shah and c. e. m. wagner , arxiv:1112.3336 [ hep - ph ] .
d. j. .
miller , r. nevzorov and p. m. zerwas , nucl .
b * 681 * , 3 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0304049 ] .
u. ellwanger , j. f. gunion and c. hugonie , jhep * 0502 * , 066 ( 2005 ) ; u. ellwanger and c. hugonie , comput .
commun . * 175 * , 290 ( 2006 ) .
g. degrassi _ et al .
_ , eur .
j. c * 28 * ( 2003 ) 133 ; s. heinemeyer , w. hollik and g. weiglein , eur .
j. c * 9 * ( 1999 ) 343 ; s. heinemeyer , w. hollik and g. weiglein , comput .
commun .
* 124 * ( 2000 ) 76 ; m. frank _ et al .
_ , jhep * 0702 * ( 2007 ) 047 ; g. altarelli and r. barbieri , 253 , 161 ( 1991 ) ; m. e. peskin , t. takeuchi , 46 , 381 ( 1992 ) . j. cao and j. m. yang , jhep * 0812 * , 006 ( 2008 )
. m. davier _ et al .
_ , eur .
j. c * 66 * , 1 ( 2010 ) .
j. dunkley _ et al .
_ [ wmap collaboration ] , astrophys . j. suppl . * 180 * , 306 ( 2009 ) .
e. aprile _ et al .
_ [ xenon100 collaboration ] , 107 , 131302 ( 2011 ) . h. ohki _ et al .
_ , 78 , 054502 ( 2008 ) ; d. toussaint and w. freeman , 103 , 122002 ( 2009 ) ; j. giedt , a. w. thomas and r. d. young , 103 , 201802 ( 2009 ) . n. desai and b. mukhopadhyaya , arxiv:1111.2830 [ hep - ph ] ; x. j. bi , q. s. yan and p. f. yin , 85 , 035005 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1111.2250 [ hep - ph ] ] ; b. he , t. li , q. shafi , arxiv:1112.4461 [ hep - ph ] .
m. s. carena , d. garcia , u. nierste and c. e. m. wagner , nucl .
b * 577 * , 88 ( 2000 ) .
j. cao and j. m. yang , phys .
d * 78 * , 115001 ( 2008 ) .
j. cao , h. e. logan and j. m. yang , phys .
d * 79 * , 091701 ( 2009 ) .
g. aad _ et al .
_ [ the atlas collaboration ] , arxiv:0901.0512 [ hep - ex ] .
j. cao , _ et al .
_ , phys .
d * 82 * , 051701 ( 2010 ) .
j. cao , _ et al .
_ , jhep * 1007 * , 044 ( 2010 ) . | motivated by the recent lhc hints of a higgs boson around 125 gev , we assume a sm - like higgs with the mass 123 - 127 gev and study its implication in low energy susy by comparing the mssm and nmssm .
we consider various experimental constraints at @xmath0 level ( including the muon @xmath1 and the dark matter relic density ) and perform a comprehensive scan over the parameter space of each model .
then in the parameter space which is allowed by current experimental constraints and also predicts a sm - like higgs in 123 - 127 gev , we examine the properties of the sensitive parameters ( like the top squark mass and the trilinear coupling @xmath2 ) and calculate the rates of the di - photon signal and the @xmath3 ( @xmath4 ) signals at the lhc .
our typical findings are : ( i ) in the mssm the top squark and @xmath2 must be large and thus incur some fine - tuning , which can be much ameliorated in the nmssm ; ( ii ) in the mssm a light stau is needed to enhance the di - photon rate of the sm - like higgs to exceed its sm prediction , while in the nmssm the di - photon rate can be readily enhanced in several ways ; ( iii ) in the mssm the signal rates of @xmath5 at the lhc are never enhanced compared with their sm predictions , while in the nmssm they may get enhanced significantly ; ( iv ) a large part of the parameter space so far survived will be soon covered by the expected xenon100(2012 ) sensitivity ( especially for the nmssm ) . |
search for the quark - gluon plasma ( qgp ) at relativistic heavy - ion collision experiments ( rhice ) has reached a very exciting stage with the ongoing experiments at rhic and with the upcoming heavy - ion experiments at the large hadron collider .
no one doubts that the qgp phase has already been created at rhic but conclusive evidence for the same is still lacking .
many signatures have been proposed for the detection of the qgp phase @xcite and these have been thoroughly investigated both theoretically and experimentally . along with continued investigation of these important signatures of qgp , there is a need for investigating novel signals exploring qualitatively non - trivial features of the qgp phase and/or the quark - hadron phase transition . with this view we focus on the non - trivial vacuum structure of the qgp phase which arises when one uses the expectation value of the polyakov loop @xmath1 as the order parameter for the confinement - deconfinement phase transition @xcite .
this order parameter transforms non - trivially under the center @xmath0 of the color su(3 ) group and is non - zero above the critical temperature @xmath2 .
this breaks the global @xmath0 symmetry spontaneously above @xmath2 , while the symmetry is restored below @xmath2 in the confining phase where this order parameter vanishes . in the qgp phase , due to spontaneous breaking of the discrete @xmath0 symmetry ,
one gets domain walls ( interfaces ) which interpolate between different @xmath0 vacua .
the properties and physical consequences of these @xmath0 interfaces have been discussed in the literature@xcite .
it has been suggested that these interfaces should not be taken as physical objects in the minkowski space @xcite .
similarly , it has also been subject of discussion whether it makes sense to talk about this @xmath0 symmetry in the presence of quarks @xcite . however , we will follow the approach where the presence of quarks is interpreted as leading to explicit breaking of @xmath0 symmetry , lifting the degeneracy of different @xmath0 vacua @xcite .
thus , with quarks , even planar @xmath0 interfaces do not remain static and move away from the region with the unique true vacuum .
our main discussion will be for the pure gauge theory which we discuss first .
later we will briefly comment on the situation with quarks . a detailed study with inclusion of quark effects
is postponed for a future work . in earlier works
some of us had shown that there are novel topological string defects which form at the intersection of the three @xmath0 interfaces .
these strings are embedded in the qgp phase and their cores consist of the confining phase .
structure of these strings and interfaces were discussed in these earlier works @xcite .
it was also shown that reflection of quarks from collapsing @xmath0 interfaces can lead to large scale baryon inhomogeneities in the early universe @xcite .
this effect is also utilized to argue for @xmath3 enhancement of quarks of heavy flavor ( consecutively corresponding hadrons ) in relativistic heavy - ion collisions @xcite . in this paper
we carry out numerical simulation of formation of these @xmath0 interfaces and associated strings at the initial confinement - deconfinement transition which is believed to occur during the pre - equilibrium stage in relativistic heavy - ion collision experiments . for the purpose of numerical simulation
we will model this stage as a quasi - equilibrium stage with an effective temperature which first rises ( with rapid particle production ) to a maximum temperature @xmath4 , where @xmath2 is the critical temperature for the confinement - deconfinement phase transition , and then decreases due to continued plasma expansion .
we use the effective potential for the polyakov loop expectation value @xmath1 as proposed by pisarski @xcite to study the confinement - deconfinement ( c - d ) phase transition . within this model ,
the c - d transition is weakly first order . even though lattice results show that quark - hadron transition is most likely a smooth cross - over at zero chemical potential , in the present work we will use this first order transition model to discuss the dynamical details of quark - hadron transition .
one reason for this is that our study is in the context of relativistic heavy - ion collision experiments ( rhice ) where the baryon chemical potential is not zero . for not too small values of the chemical potential ,
the quark - hadron phase transition is expected to be of first order , so this may be the case relevant for us any way ( especially when collision energy is not too high ) .
further , our main interest is in determining the structure of the network of z(3 ) domain walls and strings resulting during the phase transition .
these objects will form irrespective of the nature of the transition , resulting entirely from the finite correlation lengths in a fast evolving system , as shown by kibble @xcite .
the kibble mechanism was first proposed for the formation of topological defects in the context of the early universe @xcite , but is now utilized extensively for discussing topological defects production in a wide variety of systems from condensed matter physics to cosmology @xcite .
essential ingredient of the kibble mechanism is the existence of uncorrelated domains of the order parameter which result after every phase transition occurring in finite time due to finite correlation length .
a first order transition allows easy implementation of the resulting domain structure especially when the transition proceeds via bubble nucleation . with this view
, we use the polyakov loop model as in @xcite to model the phase transition and confine ourselves with temperature / time ranges so that the first order quark - hadron transition proceeds via bubble nucleation .
the @xmath0 wall network and associated strings ( as mentioned above ) formed during this early confinement - deconfinement phase transition evolve in an expanding plasma with decreasing temperature .
eventually when the temperature drops below the deconfinement - confinement phase transition temperature @xmath2 , these @xmath0 walls and associated strings will melt away
. however they may leave their signatures in the form of extended regions of energy density fluctuations ( as well as @xmath3 enhancement of heavy - flavor hadrons @xcite ) .
we make estimates of these energy density fluctuations which can be compared with the experimental data .
especially interesting will be to look for extended regions of large energy densities in space - time reconstruction of hadron density ( using hydrodynamic models ) . in our model , we expect energy density fluctuations in event averages ( representing high energy density regions of domain walls / strings ) , as well as event - by - event fluctuations as the number / geometry of domain walls / strings and even the number of qgp bubbles , varies from one event to the other .
a detailed analysis of energy fluctuations , especially the event - by - event fluctuations , is postponed for a future work .
we also determine the distribution / shape of @xmath0 wall network and its evolution .
in particular , our results provide an estimate of domain wall velocities ( for the situations studied ) to range from 0.5 to 0.8 .
these results provide crucial ingredients for a detailed study of the effects of collapsing @xmath0 walls on the @xmath3 enhancement of heavy flavor hadrons @xcite in rhice .
we emphasize that the presence of @xmath0 walls and string may not only provide a qualitatively new signature for the qgp phase in these experiments , it may provide the first ( and may be the only possible ) laboratory study of such topological objects in a relativistic quantum field theory system . the paper is organized in the following manner . in section
ii , we discuss the polyakov loop model of confinement - deconfinement phase transition . we describe the effective potential proposed by pisarski @xcite and discuss the structure of the @xmath0 walls and associated strings . in section iii
, we present the physical picture of the formation of these @xmath0 walls and associated strings in the confinement - deconfinement phase transition via the kibble mechanism which provides a general framework for the production of topological defects in symmetry breaking phase transitions .
we confine ourselves with temperature / time ranges so that the first order transition ( in the pisarski model ) proceeds via bubble nucleation .
the other possibility of spinodal decomposition is of completely different nature and we will present it in a future work .
( we mention here that a simulation of spinodal decomposition in polyakov loop model has been carried out in ref .
@xcite , where fluctuations in the polyakov loop are investigated in detail . in comparison , the main focus of our work is on the topological objects , z(3 ) walls , and strings , and energy density fluctuations resulting therefrom . ) in section iv , we discuss the calculation of the profile of the critical bubble using bounce technique @xcite and also the estimates of nucleation rates for bubbles for the temperature / time range relevant for rhice .
section v presents the numerical technique of simulating the phase transition via random nucleation of bubbles . in section
vi we discuss the issue of the effects of quarks in our model .
section vii presents the results of the numerical simulations .
here we discuss distribution of @xmath0 wall / string network formed due to coalescence of qgp bubbles ( in a confining background ) .
we also calculate the energy density fluctuations associated with @xmath0 wall network and strings .
we discuss evolution of these quantities with changing temperature via bjorken s hydrodynamical model . in section viii
we discuss possible experimental signatures resulting from the presence of @xmath0 wall network and associate strings .
section ix presents conclusions .
we first discuss the case of pure su(n ) gauge theory .
we will later discuss briefly the case with quarks .
the order parameter for the confinement - deconfinement ( c - d ) phase transition is the expectation value of the polyakov loop @xmath5 which is defined as @xmath6 here p denotes the path ordering , g is the gauge coupling , and @xmath7 , where t is the temperature .
@xmath8 , @xmath9 being the generators of su(n ) in the fundamental representation , is the time component of the vector potential at spatial position @xmath10 and euclidean time @xmath11 . under a global z(n )
symmetry transformation , @xmath5 transforms as @xmath12 the expectation value of @xmath1 is related to @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the free energy of an infinitely heavy test quark . for temperatures below @xmath2 , in the confined phase , the expectation value of polyakov loop is zero corresponding to the infinite free energy of an isolated test quark .
( hereafter , we will use the same notation @xmath1 to denote the expectation value of the polyakov loop . )
hence the z(n ) symmetry is restored below @xmath2 .
z(n ) symmetry is broken spontaneously above @xmath2 where @xmath1 is non - zero corresponding to the finite free energy of the test quark .
for qcd , @xmath15 , and we take the effective theory for the polyakov loop as proposed by pisarski @xcite . the effective lagrangian density is given by @xmath16 @xmath17 is the effective potential for the polyakov loop @xmath18 the values of various parameters are fixed to reproduce the lattice results @xcite for pressure and energy density of pure su(3 ) gauge theory .
we make the same choice and give those values below .
the coefficients @xmath19 and @xmath20 have been taken as , @xmath21 and @xmath22 .
we will take the same value of @xmath23 for real qcd ( with three massless quark flavors ) , while the value of @xmath20 will be rescaled by a factor of 47.5/16 to account for the extra degrees of freedom relative to the degrees of freedom of pure su(3 ) gauge theory @xcite .
the coefficient @xmath23 is temperature dependent @xcite .
@xmath23 is taken as , @xmath24 , where r is taken as t/@xmath2 . with the coefficients chosen as above
, the expectation value of order parameter approaches to @xmath25 for temperature @xmath26 . as in @xcite
, we use the normalization such that the expectation value of order parameter @xmath27 goes to unity for temperature @xmath26 .
hence the fields and the coefficients in @xmath28 are rescaled as @xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath31 and @xmath32 to get proper normalization of @xmath27 . for the parameters chosen as above
, the value of @xmath2 is taken to be 182 mev .
we see that the @xmath19 term in eq.(4 ) gives a cos(3@xmath33 ) term , leading to z(3 ) degenerate vacua structure . here , the shape of the potential is such that there exists a metastable vacuum upto a temperature @xmath34 250 mev .
hence first order transition via bubble nucleation is possible only upto @xmath35 mev .
we show the plot of v@xmath36 in @xmath37 direction in fig.(1a ) for a value of temperature t = 185 mev .
this shows the metastable vacuum at @xmath38 .
fig.(1b ) shows the structure of vacuum by plotting v(@xmath39 ) as a function of @xmath33 for fixed @xmath27 , where @xmath40 is the vacuum expectation value of @xmath17 at @xmath41 mev .
+ \(a ) plot of @xmath28 in @xmath42 direction for @xmath43 showing the metastable vacuum at @xmath44 . in ( a ) and ( b )
, plots of @xmath45 are given in units of @xmath46 .
the value of critical temperature is taken to be @xmath47 .
the @xmath0 structure of the vacuum can be seen in ( b ) in the plot of the potential @xmath28 as a function of @xmath33 for fixed @xmath48 . here
, @xmath40 corresponds to the absolute minimum of @xmath28 .
[ fig.1 ] in fig.(1b ) , the three degenerate vacua are separated by large barrier in between them . while going from one vacuum to another vacuum ,
the field configuration is determined from the field equations . for the case of degenerate vacua
, there are time independent solutions which have planar symmetry .
these solutions are called domain wall . for the non - degenerate case , as will be appropriate for the case when quarks are included as dynamical degrees of freedom in discussing the quark hadron transition , the solutions of the interfaces separating these vacua will be similar to the bounce solutions @xcite , though the standard bounce techniques need to be extended for the case of complex scalar field .
the resulting planar domain wall solutions will not be static . as mentioned above , we will be neglecting such effects of quarks , and
hence will discuss the case of degenerate vacua only .
later , in section vi , we will examine the justification of using the approximation of neglecting quark effects .
in physical space , after the phase transition , regions with different z(3 ) vacua are separated by domain walls . inside a domain wall , @xmath49 becomes very small as @xmath50 @xcite . in ref.@xcite the intersection of the three z(3 ) domain walls
was considered and , using topological arguments , it was then shown that at the line - like intersection of these interfaces , the order parameter @xmath1 should vanish .
this leads to a topological string configuration with core of the string being in the confining phase .
properties of these new string configurations were determined in @xcite using the model of eq.(3 ) .
this string configuration is interesting , especially when we note that such a string has exactly reverse physical behavior compared to the standard qcd string .
the qcd string exists in the confining phase , connecting quarks and antiquarks , or forming baryons , glueballs etc . inside the qcd string
, the core region is expected to behave as a deconfined region .
in contrast the string discussed in @xcite , arising at the intersection of z(3 ) walls , exists in the high temperature deconfined phase .
its core is characterized by restored @xmath0 symmetry , implying that it is in the confined phase . to differentiate it with the standard qcd string ,
this new string structure was called as _ the qgp string _ in ref.@xcite .
it is also important to note that although the standard qcd string breaks by creating quark - antiquark pairs , the qgp string can not break as it originates from topological arguments .
this qgp string , thus should either form closed loops , or it should end at the boundary separating the deconfined phase from the confined phase .
its structure is very similar to certain axionic strings discussed in the context of early universe @xcite .
note that as these strings contain the confining phase ( with @xmath44 ) in the core , while they are embedded in the qgp phase , a transition from deconfining phase to the confining phase , in the presence of such strings may begin from regions near the strings .
similarly , the presence of domain walls may lead to heterogeneous bubble nucleation in a first order quark - hadron transition .
we will be studying the formation of z(3 ) domain walls and these qgp strings in the initial confinement - deconfinement phase transition , and their subsequent evolution .
we now briefly describe the physical picture of the formation of topological defects via the kibble mechanism .
kibble first gave a detailed theory of the formation of topological defects in symmetry breaking phase transitions in the context of the early universe @xcite .
subsequently it was realized that the basic physics of kibble mechanism is applicable to every symmetry breaking transition , from low energy physics of condensed matter systems to high energy physics relevant for the early universe @xcite .
basic physics of the kibble mechanism can be described as follows . after a spontaneous symmetry breaking phase transition ,
the physical space consists of regions , called domains . in each domain
the configuration of the order parameter field can be taken as nearly uniform while it varies randomly from one domain to another . in a numerical simulation
where the phase transition is modeled to implement the kibble mechanism , typically the physical region is divided in terms of elementary domains of definite geometrical shape .
the order parameter is taken to be uniform within the domain and random variations of order parameter field within the vacuum manifold are allowed from one domain to the other . the order parameter field configuration in between domains
is assumed to be such that the variation of the order parameter field is minimum on the vacuum manifold ( the so - called geodesic rule ) . with this simple construction ,
topological defects arise at the junctions of several domains if the variation of the order parameter in those domains traces a topologically non - trivial configuration in the vacuum manifold .
see , ref .
@xcite for a detailed discussion of this approach .
we , however , will follow a more detailed simulation as in ref.@xcite where the kibble mechanism was implemented in the context of a first order transition .
bubbles of true vacuum ( determined from the bounce solution ) were randomly nucleated in the background of false vacuum .
each bubble was taken to have the uniform orientation of the order parameter in the vacuum manifold , while the order parameter orientation varied randomly from one bubble to another .
this provided the initial seed domains , as needed for the kibble mechanism .
evolution of this initial configuration via the field equation led to expansion of bubbles which eventually coalesce and lead to the formation of topological defects at the junctions of bubbles when the order parameter develops appropriate variation ( winding ) in that region .
important thing is that in this case one does not need to assume anything like the geodesic rule . as different bubbles come into contact during their expansion , the value of the order parameter in the intermediate region is automatically determined by the field equations .
an important aspect of the kibble mechanism is that it does not crucially depend on the dynamical details of the phase transition .
although the domain size depends on the dynamics of phase transitions , the defect number density ( per domain ) and type of topological defects produced via the kibble mechanism depends only on the topology of order parameter space and spatial dimensions .
if the vacuum manifold m has disconnected components , then domain walls form . if it is multiply connected ( i.e. , if m contains unshrinkable loops ) , strings will form .
when m contains closed two surfaces which can not be shrunk to a point , then monopoles will form in three dimensional physical space . in our case domain walls and
string network will be produced in the qgp phase . as discussed above ,
domain walls arise due to interpolation of field between different z(3 ) vacua . at the intersection of these interfaces
, string is produced .
as we explained in the introduction , we will study the z(3 ) domain wall and string formation with the first order transition model given by eq.(3 ) , such that the transition occurs via bubble nucleation .
the semiclassical theory of decay of false vacuum at zero temperature has been given in ref .
@xcite , and the finite temperature extension of this theory was given in ref .
the process of barrier tunneling leads to the appearance of bubbles of the new phase .
resulting bubble profile is determined using the bounce solution for the false vacuum decay which we will discuss below .
first we note general features of the dynamics of a standard first order phase transition at finite temperature via bubble nucleation .
a region of true vacuum , in the form of a spherical bubble , appears in the background of false vacuum .
the creation of bubble leads to the change in the free energy of the system as , @xmath51 where r is the radius of bubble , @xmath52 is the surface energy contribution and @xmath53 is the volume energy contribution .
@xmath54 is the difference of the free energy between the false vacuum and the true vacuum and @xmath55 is the surface tension which can be determined from the bounce solution .
a bubble of size @xmath56 will expand or shrink depending on which process leads to lowering of the free energy given above .
the bubbles of very small sizes will shrink to nothing since surface energy dominates . if the radius of bubble exceeds the critical size @xmath57 , it will expand and lead to the transformation of the metastable phase into the stable phase .
eq.(5 ) is useful for the so - called _ thin wall _
bubbles where there is a clear distinction between the surface contribution to the free energy and the volume contribution .
for the temperature / time relevant for our case in relativistic heavy - ion collisions this will not be the case .
instead we will be dealing with the _ thick wall _
bubbles where surface and volume contributions do not have clear separations .
we will determine the profiles of these thick wall bubbles numerically following the bounce technique @xcite .
first we note that for the effective potential in eq.(4 ) , the barrier between true vacuum and false vacuum vanishes at temperatures above about 250 mev .
so first order transition via bubble nucleation is possible only within the temperature range of @xmath58 mev - 250 mev . above @xmath59 250 mev
, spinodal decomposition will take place due to the roll down of field .
implementation of the dynamics of phase transition via spinodal decomposition is of completely different nature , and we hope to discuss this in a future work . as we are discussing the initial confinement - deconfinement transition in the context of rhice ,
clearly the discussion has to be within the context of longitudinal expansion only , with negligible effects of the transverse expansion .
however , bjorken s longitudinal scaling model @xcite can not be applied during this pre - equilibrium phase , even with the assumption of quasi - equilibrium ( as discussed above ) , unless one includes a heat source which could account for the increase of effective temperature during this phase to the maximum equilibrium temperature @xmath60 . as indicated above
, this heat source can be thought of as representing the rapid particle production ( with subsequent thermalization ) during this early phase .
we will not attempt to model such a source here .
instead , we will simply use the field equations resulting from bjorken s longitudinal scaling model for the evolution of the field configuration for the entire simulation , including the initial pre - equilibrium phase from @xmath61 to @xmath62 .
the heating of the system until @xmath63 will be represented by the increase of the temperature upto @xmath64 .
thus , during this period , the energy density and temperature evolution will not obey the bjorken scaling equations @xcite .
after @xmath65 , with complete equilibrium of the system , the temperature will decrease according to the equations in the bjorken s longitudinal scaling model .
we will take the longitudinal expansion to only represent the fact that whatever bubbles will be nucleated , they get stretched into ellipsoidal , and eventually cylindrical , shapes during the longitudinal expansion ( ignoring the boundary effects in the longitudinal direction ) .
the transverse expansion of the bubble should then proceed according to relative pressure difference between the false vacuum and the true vacuum as in the usual theory of first order phase transition .
we will neglect transverse expansion for the system , and focus on the mid rapidity region . with this picture in mind , we will work with effective 2 + 1 dimensional evolution of the field configuration , ( neglecting the transverse expansion of qgp ) .
however , for determining the bubble profile and the nucleation probability of bubbles , one must consider full 3 + 1 dimensional case as bubbles are nucleated with full 3-dimensional profiles in the physical space .
it will turn out that the bubbles will have sizes of about 1 - 1.5 fm radius . taking the initial collision region during the pre - equilibrium phase also to be of the order of 1 - 2 fm in the longitudinal direction , it looks plausible that the nucleation of 3-dimensional bubble profile as discussed above may provide a good approximation .
of course the correct thing will be to consider the bounce solutions for rapidly longitudinally expanding plasma , and we hope to return to this issue in some future work .
we neglect transverse expansion in the present work , which is a good approximation for the early stages when wall / string network forms
. however , this will not be a valid approximation for later stages , especially when temperature drops below @xmath2 and wall / string network melts . the way to account for
the transverse expansion in the context of our simulation will be to take a lattice with much larger physical size than the initial qgp system size , and allow free boundary conditions for the field evolution at the qgp system boundary ( which will still be deep inside the whole lattice ) .
this will allow the freedom for the system to expand in the transverse direction automatically .
with a suitable prescription of determining temperature from local energy density ( with appropriate account of field contributions and expected contribution from a plasma of quarks and gluons ) in a self consistent manner , the transverse expansion can be accounted for in this simulation .
we hope to come back to this in a future work .
let us consider the effective potential in eq.(4 ) , at a temperature such that there is a barrier between the true vacuum and the three z(3 ) vacua .
an example of this situation is shown in fig.1 for the case with @xmath66 185 mev .
the initial system ( of nucleons ) was at zero temperature with the order parameter l(x ) = 0 , and will be superheated as the temperature rises above the critical temperature .
it can then tunnel through the barrier to the true vacuum , representing the deconfined qgp phase . at zero temperature
, the tunneling probability can be calculated by finding the bounce solution which is a solution of the 4-dimensional euclidean equations of motion however , at finite temperature , this 4-dimensional theory will reduce to an effectively 3 euclidean dimensional theory if the temperature is sufficiently high , which we will take to be the case . for this finite temperature case ,
the tunneling probability per unit volume per unit time in the high temperature approximation is given by @xcite ( in natural units ) @xmath67 where @xmath68 is the 3-dimensional euclidean action for the polyakov loop field configuration that satisfies the classical euclidean equations of motion .
the condition for the high temperature approximation to be valid is that @xmath69 , where @xmath70 is the radius of the critical bubble in 3 dimensional euclidean space .
the values of temperature for our case ( relevant for bubble nucleation ) will be above @xmath71 mev .
as we will see , the bubble radius will be larger than 1.5 fm ( @xmath34 ( 130 mev)@xmath72 ) which justifies our use of high temperature approximation to some extent .
the determination of the pre - exponential factor is a non - trivial issue and we will discuss it below . the dominant contribution to
the exponential term in @xmath73 comes from the least action @xmath74 symmetric configuration which is a solution of the following equation ( for the lagrangian in eq.(3 ) ) .
@xmath75 where @xmath76 , subscript e denoting the coordinates in the euclidean space .
the boundary conditions imposed on @xmath77 are @xmath78 bounce solution of eq.(7 ) can be analytically obtained in the _ thin wall _
limit where the difference in the false vacuum and the true vacuum energy is much smaller than the barrier height .
this situation will occur for very short time duration near @xmath79 for the effective potential in eq.(4 ) .
however , as the temperature is rapidly evolving in the case of rhice , there will not be enough time for nucleating such large bubbles ( which also have very low nucleation rates due to having large action ) .
thus the case relevant for us is that of thick wall bubbles whose profile has to be obtained by numerically solving eq.(7 ) .
as we have mentioned earlier , in the high temperature approximation the theory effectively becomes 3 ( euclidean ) dimensional .
for a theory with one real scalar field in three euclidean dimensions the pre - exponential factor arising in the nucleation rate of critical bubbles has been estimated , see ref .
the pre - exponential factor obtained from @xcite for our case becomes @xmath80 it is important to note here that the results of @xcite were for a single real scalar field and one of the crucial ingredients used in @xcite for calculating the pre - exponential factor was the fact that for a bounce solution the only light modes contributing to the determinant of fluctuations were the deformations of the bubble perimeter . even though we are discussing the case of a complex scalar field @xmath1 , this assumption may still hold as we are calculating the tunneling from the false vacuum to one of the z(3 ) vacua ( which are taken to be degenerate here as we discussed above ) .
this assumption may need to be revised when light modes e.g. goldstone bosons are present which then also have to be accounted for in the calculation of the determinant
. a somewhat different approach for the pre - exponential factor in eq.(6 ) is obtained from the nucleation rate of bubbles per unit volume for a liquid - gas phase transition as given in ref .
@xcite , @xmath81 here @xmath82 is the dynamical prefactor which determines the exponential growth rate of critical droplets .
@xmath83 is a statistical prefactor which measures the available phase space volume .
the exponential term is the same as in eq.(6 ) with @xmath84 being the change in the free energy of the system due to the formation of critical droplet .
this is the same as @xmath85 in eq.(6 ) .
the bubble grows beyond the critical size when the latent heat is conducted away from the surface into the surrounding medium which is governed by thermal dissipation and viscous damping . for our case , in the general framework of transition from a hadronic system to the qgp phase , we will use the expression for the dynamical prefactor from ref.@xcite @xmath86 here @xmath55 is the surface tension of the bubble wall , @xmath87 is the difference in the enthalpy densities of the qgp and the hadronic phases , @xmath88 is thermal conductivity , @xmath89 is the critical bubble radius , and @xmath54 and @xmath90 are shear and bulk viscosities .
@xmath90 will be neglected as it is much smaller than @xmath54 . for @xmath88 and @xmath54 ,
the following parametrizations are used @xcite .
@xmath91 @xmath92 here @xmath93 is the ratio of the baryon density of the system to the normal nuclear baryon density , @xmath94 is in mev , @xmath54 is in mev/@xmath95c , and @xmath88 is in c/@xmath95 . with this , the rate in eq.(10 ) is in @xmath96 . for the range of temperatures of our interest ( @xmath97 ) , and for the low baryon density central rapidity region under consideration , it is the last @xmath98 independent term for both @xmath54 and @xmath82 which dominates , and we will use these terms only for calculating @xmath54 and @xmath82 for our case . for the statistical prefactor ,
we use the following expression @xcite @xmath99 the correlation length in the hadronic phase , @xmath100 , is expected to be of order of 1 fm and we will take it to be 0.7 fm @xcite ) . we will present estimates of the nucleation rates from eq.(6 ) as well as eq.(10 ) .
one needs to determine the critical bubble profile and its 3-dimensional euclidean action @xmath85 ( equivalently , @xmath84 in eq.(10 ) ) .
we solve eq.(7 ) using the fourth order runge - kutta method with appropriate boundary conditions ( eq.(8 ) ) , to get the profile of critical bubble @xcite . the critical bubble profiles ( for the 3 + 1 dimensional case )
are shown in fig.(2a ) for different temperatures .
the bubble size decreases as temperature increases , since the energy difference between true vacuum and false vacuum increases ( relative to the barrier height ) as temperature increases .
we choose a definite temperature @xmath101 mev for the nucleation of bubbles , which is suitably away from @xmath2 to give acceptable bubble size and nucleation probabilities for the relevant time scale . making @xmath94 larger ( up to @xmath102 mev when the barrier disappears ) leads to similar bubble profile , and the nucleation probability of same order .
+ \(a ) critical bubble profiles for different values of the temperature .
( b ) solid curve shows the critical bubble for the 3 + 1 dimensional case ( which for finite temperature case becomes 3 euclidean dimensional ) for @xmath94 = 200 mev and the dotted curve shows the same for 2 + 1 dimensional case ( i.e. 2 euclidean dimensions for finite temperature case ) .
[ fig.2 ] recall that we are calculating bubble profiles using eq.(7 ) relevant for the 3 + 1 dimensional case , however , the field evolution is done using 2 + 1 dimensional equations as appropriate for the mid rapidity region of rapidly longitudinally expanding plasma . in fig.(2b ) solid curve shows the critical bubble for the 3 + 1 dimensional case ( which for finite temperature case becomes 3 euclidean dimensional ) for @xmath94 = 200 mev and the dashed curve shows the same for 2 + 1 dimensional case ( i.e. 2 euclidean dimensions for finite temperature case ) .
it is clear that the 3 dimensional bubble is of supercritical size and will expand when evolved with 2 + 1 dimensional equations .
this avoids the artificial construction of suitable supercritical bubbles which can expand and coalesce as was done in ref.@xcite .
( recall that for the finite temperature case , a bubble of exact critical size will remain static when evolved by the field equations . in a phase transition , bubbles with somewhat larger size than the critical size expand , while those with smaller size contract . ) for the bubble profile given by the solid curve in fig.(2b ) , the value of the action @xmath68 is about 240 mev . using eq.(6 ) for the nucleation rate , we find that the nucleation rate of qgp bubbles per unit time per unit volume is of the order of @xmath103 .
the thermalization time for qgp phase is of the order of 1 fm at rhic ( say , for au - au collision at 200 gev energy ) .
hence the time available for the nucleation of qgp bubbles is at most about 1 fm .
we take the region of bubble nucleation to be of thick disk shape with the radius of the disk ( in the transverse direction ) of about 8 fm and the thickness of the disk ( in the longitudinal direction ) of about 1 fm .
total space - time volume available for bubble nucleation is then about 200 @xmath104 ( in practice , less than this ) . for the case of eq.(6 ) , net number of bubbles is then equal to 5 . for the case of the nucleation rate given by eq.(10 )
, one needs an estimate of the critical bubble size @xmath89 as well as bubble surface energy @xmath55 , ( along with other quantities like @xmath88 etc . as given by eqs.(11)-(14 ) ) .
determination of @xmath89 is somewhat ambiguous here as the relevant bubbles are thick wall bubbles as seen in fig.(2 ) .
here there is no clear demarcation between the core region and the surface region which could give an estimate of @xmath89 .
essentially , there is no core at all and the whole bubble is characterized by the overlap of bubble wall region .
we can take , as an estimate for the bubble radius @xmath89 any value from 1 fm - 1.5 fm .
it is important to note here that this estimate of @xmath89 is only for the calculation of nucleation rate @xmath73 , and not for using the bubble profile for actual simulation .
when bubbles are nucleated in the background of false vacuum with @xmath105 , a reasonably larger size of the bubble is used so that cutting off the profile at that radius does not lead to computational errors and field evolution remains smooth .
once we have an estimate of @xmath89 , we can then estimate the surface tension @xmath55 ( which also is not unambiguous here ) as follows . with the realization that essentially there is no core region for the bubbles in fig(2 )
, we say that the entire energy of the bubble ( i.e. the value of @xmath85 ) comes from the surface energy .
then we write @xmath106 for @xmath85 = 240 mev , we get @xmath107 mev/@xmath95 if we take @xmath89 = 1.5 fm . with @xmath89 = 1.0 fm ,
we get @xmath55 = 20 mev/@xmath95 . number of bubbles expected can now be calculated for the case when nucleation rate is given by eq.(10 ) .
we find number of bubbles to be about 10@xmath108 with @xmath89 taken as 1.5 fm .
this is in accordance with the results discussed in ref .
the bubble number increases by about a factor 5 if @xmath89 is taken to be about 1 fm .
thus , with the estimates based on eq.(10 ) , bubble nucleation is a rare event for the time available for rhice .
as we have mentioned above , for us the bubble nucleation on one hand represents the possibility of actual dynamics of a first order transition , while on the other hand , it represents the generic properties of the domain structure arising from a c - d transition , which may very well be a cross - over , occurring in a finite time . with this view , and with various uncertainties in the determination of pre - exponential factors in the nucleation rate , we will consider a larger number of bubbles also and study domain wall and string production .
first we will consider nucleation of 5 bubbles and then we will consider nucleation of 9 bubbles to get a better network of domain walls and strings .
in our simulation critical bubbles are nucleated at a time when the temperature @xmath94 crosses the value @xmath101 mev during the initial stage between @xmath61 to @xmath109 fm ( during which we have modeled the system temperature to increase linearly from 0 to @xmath60 ) .
we take @xmath110 mev so bubble nucleation stage is taken to be at @xmath111 fm when @xmath94 reaches the value 200 mev . again , this is an approximation since in realistic case bubbles will nucleate over a span of time given by the ( time dependent ) nucleation rate , which could lead to a spectrum of sizes of expanding bubbles at a given time .
however , due to very short time available to complete the nucleation of qgp bubbles in the background of confined phase , bubbles will have very little time to expand during the nucleation period of all bubbles ( especially as initial bubble expansion velocity is zero ) .
thus it is reasonable to assume that all the bubbles nucleate at the same time .
after nucleation , bubbles are evolved by the time dependent equations of motion in the minkowski space @xcite as appropriate for bjorken s longitudinal scaling model .
@xmath112 with @xmath113 at @xmath11 = 0 .
here @xmath114 , and dot indicates derivative with respect to the proper time @xmath11 . the bubble evolution was numerically implemented by a stabilized leapfrog algorithm of second order accuracy both in space and in time with the second order derivatives of @xmath115 approximated by a diamond shaped grid . here
we follow the approach described in @xcite to simulate the first order transition .
we need to nucleate several bubbles randomly choosing the corresponding z(3 ) vacua for each bubble .
this is done by randomly choosing the location of the center of each bubble with some specified probability per unit time per unit volume . before nucleating a bubble , it is checked if the relevant region is in the false vacuum ( i.e. it does not overlap with some other bubble already nucleated ) . in case there is an overlap , the nucleation of the new bubble is skipped . the orientation of @xmath77 inside each bubble is taken to randomly vary between the three z(3 ) vacua .
for representing the situation of relativistic heavy ion collision experiments , the simulation of the phase transition is carried out by nucleating bubbles on a square lattice with physical size of 16 fm within a circular boundary ( roughly the gold nucleus size ) .
we use fixed boundary condition , free boundary condition , as well as periodic boundary condition for the square lattice . to minimize the effects of boundary ( reflections for fixed boundary , mirror reflections for periodic boundary conditions ) , we present results for free boundary conditions ( for other cases , the qualitative aspects of our results remain unchanged ) . even for free boundary conditions ,
spurious partial reflections occur , and to minimize these effects we use a thin strip ( of 10 lattice points ) near each boundary where extra dissipation is introduced .
we use 2000 @xmath116 2000 lattice . for the physical size of 16 fm
, we have @xmath117 = 0.008 fm . to satisfy the courant stability criteria , we use @xmath118 , as well as @xmath119 , ( which we use for the results presented in the paper ) . for au - au collision at 200 gev
, the thermalization is expected to happen within 1 fm time . as mentioned above , in this pre - equilibrium stage
, we model the system as being in a quasi - equilibrium stage with a temperature which increases linearly with time ( for simplicity ) . the temperature of the system is taken to reach upto 400 mev in 1 fm time , starting from @xmath94 = 0 .
after @xmath109 fm , the temperature decreases due to continued longitudinal expansion , i.e. @xmath120 the stability of the simulation is checked by checking the variation of total energy of the system during the evolution .
the energy fluctuation remains within few percent , with no net increase or decrease in the energy ( for fixed and periodic boundary conditions , and without the dissipative @xmath121 term in eq.(16 ) ) showing the stability of the simulation .
the bubbles grow and eventually start coalescing , leading to a domain like structure .
domain walls are formed between regions corresponding to different z(3 ) vacua , and strings form at junctions of z(3 ) domain walls .
recall that the domain wall network is formed here in the transverse plane , appearing as curves .
these are the cross - sections of the walls which are formed by elongation ( stretching ) of these curves in the longitudinal direction into sheets . at the intersection of these walls , strings form . in the transverse plane , these strings looks like vortices , which will be elongated into strings in the longitudinal direction .
we now discuss the effects of quarks . as we mentioned above , we will follow the approach where the presence of quarks is interpreted as leading to explicit breaking of the z(3 ) symmetry , lifting the degeneracy of different z(3 ) vacua @xcite .
this has important effects in the context of our model .
first of all , different vacua having different energies implies different nucleation rates for the qgp bubbles with different z(3 ) vacua .
further , for non - degenerate vacua , even planar @xmath0 interfaces do not remain static , and move away from the region with the unique true vacuum .
thus , while for the degenerate vacua case every closed domain wall collapses , for the non - degenerate case this is not true any more . a closed wall enclosing
the true vacuum may expand if it is large enough so that the surface energy contribution does not dominate ( this is essentially the same argument as given for the bubble expansion , see eq.(5 ) and the discussion following it ) . to see the importance of these effects we need an estimate of the explicit symmetry breaking term arising from inclusion of quarks .
for this we use the estimates given in @xcite . even though the estimates in ref.@xcite are given in the high temperature limit
, we will use these for temperatures relevant for our case , i.e. @xmath122 mev , to get some idea of the effects of the explicit symmetry breaking .
the difference in the potential energy between the true vacuum with @xmath123 and the other two vacua ( @xmath124 , and @xmath125 , which are degenerate with each other ) is estimated in ref .
@xcite to be , @xmath126 where @xmath127 is the number of massless quarks .
if we take @xmath128 then @xmath129 . at the bubble nucleation temperature ( which we have taken to be about @xmath101 mev , the difference between the false vacuum and the true vacuum is about 150 mev/@xmath130 while @xmath131 at @xmath101 mev is about four times larger , equal to 600 mev/@xmath130 .
as @xmath94 approaches @xmath2 , this difference will become larger as the metastable vacuum and the stable vacuum become degenerate at @xmath2 , while @xmath131 remains non - zero . for @xmath94 near 250 mev ( where the barrier between the metastable vacuum and the stable vacuum disappears )
, @xmath131 becomes almost comparable to the difference between the potential energy of the false vacuum ( the confining vacuum ) and the true vacuum ( deconfined vacuum ) .
it does not seem reasonable that at temperatures of order 200 mev a qgp phase ( with quarks ) has higher free energy than the hadronic phase .
this situation can be avoided if the estimates of eq.(18 ) are lowered by about a factor of 5 so that these phases have lower free energy than the confining phase .
( a more desirable situation will be when @xmath131 approaches zero as the confining vacuum and the deconfining ( true ) vacuum become degenerate at @xmath2 . )
it is in the spirit of the expectation that explicit breaking of z(3 ) is small near @xmath2 for finite pion mass @xcite .
even with such lower estimates , the effects of quarks may give different nucleation probabilities for different z(3 ) vacua .
however , in this paper we will ignore this possibility .
this may not be very unreasonable as for thick wall bubbles thermal fluctuations may be dominant in determining the small number of bubbles nucleated during the short span of time available .
for very few bubbles nucleated , there may be a good fraction of events where different z(3 ) vacua may occur in good fraction .
also note that the pre - exponential factor for the bubble nucleation rate of eq.(6 ) , as given in eq.(9 ) increases with the value of @xmath68 .
thus , for the range of values of @xmath68 for which the exponential factor in eq.(6 ) is of order 1 , which is likely in our case , the nucleation rate may not decrease with larger values of @xmath68 , i.e. for the z(3 ) vacua with higher potential energies than the true vacuum .
( of course for very large values of @xmath68 the exponential term will suppress the nucleation rate . )
thus our assumption of neglecting quark effects for the bubble nucleation rate may not be unreasonable .
we now consider the effect of non - zero @xmath131 , as in eq.(18 ) , on the evolution of closed domain walls . the temperature range relevant for our case
is @xmath132 mev . in an earlier work
we had numerically estimated the surface tension of z(3 ) walls to be about 0.34 and 7.0 gev/@xmath95 for @xmath94 = 200 and 400 mev respectively .
the effects of quarks will be significant if a closed spherical wall ( with true vacuum inside ) starts expanding instead of collapsing .
again , using the bubble free energy eq.(5 ) , with @xmath133 and @xmath55 as the surface energy of the interface , we see that the critical radius @xmath134 of the spherical wall is @xmath135 for @xmath94 = 200 mev and 400 mev we get @xmath136 and 1.5 fm respectively . though these values are not large , these are not too small either when considering the fact that relevant sizes and times for rhice are of order few fm anyway .
the values of @xmath134 we estimated here are very crude as for these sizes wall thickness is comparable to @xmath134 hence application of eq.(5 ) , separating volume and surface energy contributions , is not appropriate .
further , as we discussed above , the estimate in eq.(18 ) which is applicable for high temperature limit , seems an over estimate by about an order of magnitude at these temperatures .
thus uncertainties of factors of order 1 may not be unreasonable to expect . in that case
the dynamics of closed domain walls of even several fm diameter will not be affected by the effects of quarks via eq.(18 ) .
we will see in the next section of simulation results that the domain walls and strings typically have large velocities ( e.g. about 0.5 - 0.8 ) at the time of formation .
these result from momentum of colliding bubble walls and from curvature in the shape of these walls ( as well as asymmetries in the profiles of strings ) at the time of formation . with such large velocities present , the effects of pressure differences between different z(3 ) vacua due to quarks may become subdominant in studying the evolution of these structures for the short time duration available for rhice . with this
, we will assume that for small closed walls , of order few fm diameter , as is expected in rhice , the quark effects in the evolution of wall network may be neglected .
we plan to remove these assumptions and include the effects of non - zero @xmath131 due to quarks on bubble nucleation and wall evolution in a future work .
as we mentioned above , the number of bubbles expected to form in rhice is small .
we first present and discuss the case of 5 bubbles which is more realistic from the point of view of nucleation estimates given by eq.(6 ) ( though a gross over - estimate for eq.(10 ) ) .
note that a domain wall will form even if only two bubbles nucleate ( with different z(3 ) vacua ) . however , to see qgp string formation , we need nucleation of at least three bubbles .
next we will discuss the case of 9 bubbles which is a much more optimistic estimate of the nucleation rate ( even for eq.(6 ) ) .
alternatively , this case can be taken as better representation of the case when the transition is a cross over and bubbles only represent a means for developing a domain structure expected after the cross - over is completed .
( in this case only relevant energy density fluctuations , as discussed below , will be those arising from z(3 ) walls and strings , and not the ones resulting from bubble wall coalescence . )
fig.3 - 7 show the results of simulation when five bubbles are nucleated with random choices of different z(3 ) vacua inside each bubble .
fig.3 shows a time sequence of surface plots of the order parameter @xmath1 in the two dimensional lattice .
fig.3a shows the initial profiles of the bubbles of the qgp phase embedded in the confining vacuum with @xmath44 at @xmath11 = 0.5 fm with the temperature @xmath66 200 mev .
( recall that for initial 1 fm time the temperature is taken to linearly increase from zero to @xmath60 = 400 mev . )
the radial profile of each bubble is truncated with appropriate care of smoothness on the lattice for proper time evolution .
fig.3b shows the profile of each bubble at @xmath137 1.5 fm showing the expansion of the bubbles .
near the outer region of a bubble the field grows more quickly towards the true vacuum .
if bubbles expand for long time then bubble walls become ultra - relativistic and undergo large lorentz contraction .
this causes problem in simulation ( see , e.g. @xcite ) . in our case
this situation arises at outer boundaries ( for the inner regions bubbles collide quickly ) . for outer regions
also it does not cause serious problem because of the use of dissipative boundary strip ( as explained above in sect.v ) .
\(a ) and ( b ) show plots of profiles of @xmath77 at @xmath138 0.5 fm and 1.5 fm respectively .
( c)-(i ) show plots of @xmath139 at @xmath137 1.5 , 2.5 , 4.0 , 6.0 , 9.0 , 11.0 , and 13.7 fm .
@xmath94 drops to below @xmath2 around at @xmath137 10.5 fm and @xmath66 167 mev at @xmath137 13.7 fm .
formation of domain walls and string and antistring ( at junctions of three walls ) can be seen in the plots in ( e ) - ( h ) .
[ fig.3 ] figs .
3c-3i show plots of @xmath139 clearly showing formation of domain walls and strings ( junctions of three walls ) . here
@xmath40 is a reference vacuum expectation value of @xmath77 calculated at the maximum temperature @xmath140 400 mev .
formation of domain walls , extending through the entire qgp region , is directly visible from fig.3e ( at @xmath141 fm ) onwards .
the temperature drops to below @xmath142 mev at @xmath143 fm .
the last plot in fig.3i is at @xmath144 fm when the temperature @xmath66 167 mev , clearly showing that the domain walls have decayed away in the confined phase and the field is fluctuating about @xmath44 .
plots of the phase @xmath33 of the order parameter @xmath77 .
( a ) shows the initial distribution of @xmath33 in the bubbles at @xmath138 0.5 fm .
( b ) - ( f ) show plots of @xmath33 at @xmath137 2.0 , 4.6 , 11.0 , 12.2 , and 13.7 fm respectively .
location of domain walls and the string ( with positive winding ) and antistring ( with negative winding ) are clearly seen in the plots in ( b)-(e ) .
the motion of the antistring and associated walls can be directly seen from these plots and an estimate of the velocity can be obtained .
[ fig.4 ] in fig.3f-3h we see two junctions of three domain walls where the qgp strings form .
this is seen more clearly in fig.4 where the phase @xmath33 of @xmath77 is plotted ( with the convention that @xmath33 is the angle of the arrow from the positive @xmath145 axis ) .
the domain walls are identified as the boundaries where two different values of @xmath33 meet , and strings correspond to the non - trivial winding of @xmath33 at the junctions of three walls . from fig.4b , c we clearly see that at one of the junctions we have a string ( at @xmath146 5 fm , @xmath147 8 fm ) with positive winding and we have an anti - string at @xmath146 9 fm , @xmath148 8 fm with negative winding .
note the rapid motion of the walls forming the antistring towards positive @xmath149 axis from fig.4c ( at @xmath138 4.6 fm ) to fig.4e ( at @xmath138 12.2 fm ) .
the average speed of the antistring ( and wall associated with that ) can be directly estimated from these figures to be about 0.5 ( in natural units with @xmath150 ) .
this result is important in view of the discussion in the preceding section showing that effects of pressure differences between different z(3 ) vacua , arising from quarks , may be dominated by such random velocities present for the walls and strings at the time of formation .
the motion of the walls here is a direct result of the straightening of the @xmath151 shaped wall structure due to its surface tension . for the same reason the wall in the left part of fig.4b also straightens from the initial wedge shape .
fig.4f shows almost random variations of @xmath33 at @xmath144 fm when the temperature is 167 mev , well below the critical temperature . though it is interesting to note that a large region of roughly uniform values of @xmath33 still survives at this stage .
surface plots of the local energy density @xmath152 in gev/@xmath130 .
( a ) - ( f ) show plots at @xmath137 3.0 , 3.6 , 5.0 , 6.0 , 8.0 , and 13.2 fm respectively .
extended domain walls can be seen from these plots of @xmath153 in ( b ) - ( e ) .
small peaks in @xmath153 exist at the locations of string and antistring ( larger peaks arise from oscillations of field where bubbles coalesce ) .
plot in ( f ) is at the stage when @xmath66 169 mev and domain walls have decayed away .
[ fig.5 ] fig.5 shows surface plots of the local energy density @xmath153 .
@xmath153 is plotted in units of gev/@xmath130 .
although the simulation is 2 + 1 dimensional representing the transverse plane of the qgp system , we calculate energy in 3 + 1 dimensions by taking a thickness of 1 fm in the central rapidity region .
fig.5a shows plot at @xmath138 3 fm when bubbles have coalesced . in fig.5b at @xmath154 3.6 fm we see that bubble walls have almost decayed ( in ripples of @xmath77 waves ) between the bubbles with same @xmath155 ( i.e. same z(3 ) vacua ) as can be checked from @xmath33 plots in fig.4 .
energy density remains well localized in the regions where domain walls exist .
also , one can see the small peaks in the energy density where strings and antistrings exist .
large peaks arise from oscillations of @xmath77 when bubble walls coalesce , as discussed in @xcite .
large values of @xmath153 near the boundary of the lattice are due to relativistically expanding bubble walls .
motion of walls and generation of increased fluctuations in energy density are seen in fig.5c-5e .
fig.5f at @xmath138 13.2 fm ( with @xmath94 = 169 mev ) shows that walls have decayed .
however , some extended regions of high energy density can be seen at this stage also .
contour plots of the local energy density @xmath153 at different stages . plots in ( a ) - ( f ) correspond to @xmath137 3.0 , 3.6 , 5.0 , 7.6 , 10.2 , and 13.2 fm respectively .
structure of domains walls formed near the coalescence region of bubbles with different @xmath33 is clear in ( b ) , whereas the bubble walls at lower half of @xmath149 region , and near @xmath156 10 fm , are seen to simply decay away due to same vacuum in the colliding bubbles .
motion of the antistring and associated domain walls is clear from plots in ( b ) - ( e ) .
the last plot in ( f ) is at @xmath157 fm when @xmath94 = 169 mev .
[ fig.6 ] fig.6 shows contour plots of energy density @xmath153 .
fig.6a shows coalescence of bubbles at @xmath137 3 fm .
fig.6b at @xmath154 3.6 fm clearly shows the difference in the wall coalescence depending on the vacua in the colliding bubbles . where domain walls exist , we see extended regions of high energy density contours whereas where the two vacua in colliding bubbles are same , there are essentially no high energy density contours .
motion of domain walls ( and strings at wall junctions ) is clearly seen in these contour plots in fig.6b-6d .
fig.6e is at @xmath138 10.2 fm when @xmath94 drops to @xmath2 .
wall structures are still present .
fig.6f is at @xmath137 13.2 fm ( @xmath94 = 169 mev ) when walls have decayed away , though some extended structures in contours still survive .
we have also calculated the variance of energy density @xmath158 at each time stage to study how energy fluctuations change during the evolution . in fig.7
we show the plot of @xmath159 as a function of proper time . here
@xmath153 is the average value of energy density at that time stage .
the energy density @xmath153 decreases due to longitudinal expansion , hence we plot this ratio to get an idea of relative importance of energy density fluctuations .
fig.7 shows initial rapid drop in @xmath159 due to large increase in @xmath153 during the heating stage upto @xmath11 = 1 fm , followed by a rise due to increased energy density fluctuations during the stage when bubbles coalesce and bubble walls decay , as expected .
interesting thing to note is a slight peak in the plot near @xmath138 10.5 fm when @xmath94 drops below @xmath2 .
this should correspond to the decay of domain walls and may provide a signal for the formation and subsequent decay of such objects in rhice .
plot of the ratio of variance of energy density @xmath160 and the average energy density @xmath153 as a function of proper time .
energy fluctuations increase during the initial stages when bubbles coalesce and bubble walls decay .
after that there is a slow decrease in energy fluctuation until the stage when the temperature drops below @xmath2 and @xmath143 fm .
energy fluctuations increase after this stage .
note small peak near the transition stage .
[ fig.7 ] fig.8 - 12 show the results of simulation where nine bubbles are nucleated .
fig.8 shows a time sequence of surface plots of @xmath1 ( similar to fig.3 ) .
fig.8a shows the initial profiles of the qgp bubbles at @xmath11 = 0.5 fm with the nucleation temperature of @xmath66 200 mev .
fig.8b shows the profile of @xmath77 for the bubbles at @xmath137 1.5 fm showing the expansion of the bubbles .
fig.8c-8i show plots of @xmath139 at different stages .
noteworthy here is the formation of a closed domain wall near the central region which is clearly first seen in fig.8e at @xmath137 5 fm .
the collapse of this closed domain wall is seen in the subsequent plots with the closed wall completely collapsing away in fig.8h at @xmath137 9.6 fm .
only surviving structure is an extended domain wall along the @xmath145 axis .
fig.8i is at @xmath157 fm when @xmath66 169 mev .
the domain walls have decayed away and @xmath77 fluctuates about the value zero as appropriate for the confined phase .
\(a ) and ( b ) show plots of profiles of @xmath77 at @xmath138 0.5 fm and 1.5 fm respectively for the case when 9 bubbles are nucleated .
( c)-(i ) show plots of @xmath139 at @xmath137 2.0 , 3.0 , 5.0 , 7.0 , 8.6 , 9.6 , and 13.2 fm respectively .
formation of a closed domain wall is first clearly seen in the plot in ( e ) .
this closed domain wall collapses as seen in plots in ( e ) through ( h ) .
only surviving domain wall is an extended wall along @xmath145 axis in ( h ) .
plot in ( i ) is when the temperature @xmath66 169 mev .
[ fig.8 ] fig.9 shows plots of the phase @xmath33 of @xmath77 at different stages .
initial phase distribution in different bubbles is shown in fig.9a at @xmath161 fm .
fig.9b shows the formation of closed , elliptical shaped domain wall at @xmath162 fm .
strings and antistrings can also be identified by checking the windings of @xmath33 .
the closed domain wall collapses , and in the process becomes more circular , as shown in the plots in fig.9b-9h .
fig.9h shows the plot at @xmath137 9.6 fm when the closed domain wall completely collapses away , leaving only an extended domain wall running along @xmath145 axis between @xmath163 fm .
the final fig.9i at @xmath164 fm is when the temperature @xmath165 167 mev showing random fluctuations of @xmath33 when domain walls have decayed away in the confining phase
. plots of the phase @xmath33 of @xmath77 .
( a ) shows initial distribution of @xmath33 in the bubbles at @xmath138 0.5 fm .
( b ) - ( i ) show plots of @xmath33 at @xmath137 2.6 , 5.0 , 6.0 , 7.0 , 8.0 , 8.6 , 9.6 , and 13.8 fm respectively .
( b ) shows formation of elliptical shaped closed domain wall which subsequently becomes more circular as it collapses away by @xmath137 9.6 fm as shown by the plot in ( h ) .
the plot in ( i ) is at @xmath166 mev showing random fluctuations of @xmath33 .
[ fig.9 ] fig.10 shows the surface plot of energy density @xmath153 at different stages .
extended thin regions of large values of @xmath153 are clearly seen in the plots corresponding to domain walls .
collapse of the closed domain wall is also clearly seen in fig.10c-10 g .
important thing to note here is the surviving peak in the energy density plot at the location of domain wall collapse .
this peak survives even at the stage shown in fig.10i at @xmath157 fm when @xmath167 mev , well below the transition temperature .
such _ hot spots _ may be the clearest signals of formation and collapse of z(3 ) walls .
surface plots of the local energy density @xmath153 in gev/@xmath130 .
( a ) - ( i ) show plots at @xmath137 2.6 , 3.5 , 4.6 , 5.6 , 7.0 , 8.6 , 9.6 , 11.2 , and 13.2 fm respectively .
formation and subsequent collapse of closed domain wall is clearly seen in plots in ( c ) through ( g ) .
note that the strong peak in @xmath153 resulting from domain wall collapse ( the _ hot spot _ ) survives in ( i ) when @xmath94 = 169 mev .
[ fig.10 ] contour plots of @xmath153 are shown in fig.11 . though closed domain wall can be seen already in fig.11b ( at @xmath137 3.5 fm ) , the domain wall is still attached to outward expanding bubble walls near @xmath156 3 fm , @xmath168 12 fm which affects the evolution / motion of that portion of the domain wall .
formation of distinct closed wall structure is first visible in fig.11c at @xmath1384.6 fm .
subsequent plots clearly show how the domain wall becomes circular and finally collapses away by fig.11k at @xmath169 fm .
note the survival of the _ hot spot _ even at the stage shown in fig.11_l _ at @xmath157 fm when @xmath66 169 mev .
one can make a rough estimate of the velocity of the closed wall during its collapse from these plots . in fig.11c , at @xmath137 4.6 fm , the @xmath145 extent of the closed wall is about 8 fm and the @xmath149 extent is about 5 fm .
the wall collapses away by the stage in fig.11k at @xmath137 9.6 fm .
this gives rough velocity of collapse in @xmath145 direction to be about 0.8 while the velocity in @xmath149 direction is about 0.5 .
note that here , as well as in fig.4 for the five bubble case , the estimate of the wall velocity is not affected by the extra dissipation which is introduced only in a very thin strip ( consisting of ten lattice points ) near the lattice boundary .
formation and collapse of such closed domain walls is important as the resulting hot spot can lead to important experimental signatures .
further , such closed domain wall structures are crucial in the studies of @xmath3 enhancement , especially for heavy flavor hadrons as discussed in @xcite contour plots of the local energy density @xmath153 at different stages .
plots in ( a ) - ( l ) correspond to @xmath137 2.6 , 3.5 , 4.6 , 6.0 , 6.6 , 7.0 , 7.6 , 8.0 , 8.6 , 9.0 , 9.6 , and 13.2 fm respectively .
formation of distinct closed wall structure is first visible in ( c ) at @xmath1384.6 fm .
subsequent plots show the collapse of this domain wall as it becomes more circular .
the wall finally collapses away in ( k ) at @xmath169 fm . note that concentration of energy density at the location of domain wall collapse ( the _ hot spot _ ) survives even at the stage shown in ( l ) at @xmath157 fm when @xmath66 169 mev .
[ fig.11 ] fig.12 shows the evolution of the ratio of the variance of energy density and the average energy density . as for the five bubble case , initial drop and rise are due to heating stage upto @xmath137 1 fm and subsequent bubble coalescence and decay of bubble walls . in this case
the ratio remain roughly constant upto @xmath170 10.5 fm which is the transition stage to the confining phase .
this is the stage when the surviving extended domain wall starts decaying .
this is also the stage soon after the closed domain wall collapses away .
the prominent peak at this stage should be a combined result of both of these effects .
the large increase in the variance of energy density at this stage should be detectable from the analysis of particle distributions and should be a clear signal of hot spots resulting from collapse of closed walls and the decay of any surviving domain walls .
plot of the ratio of variance of energy density @xmath158 and the average energy density @xmath153 as a function of proper time .
energy fluctuations increase during the initial stages when bubbles coalesce and bubble walls decay . after
that @xmath159 remains roughly constant until the stage when the temperature drops below @xmath2 at @xmath143 fm .
this is also the stage just after the collapse of the closed domain wall .
energy fluctuations sharply increase around this stage .
note the prominent peak at this stage .
the @xmath0 wall network and associated strings form during the early confinement - deconfinement phase transition .
they undergo evolution in an expanding plasma with decreasing temperature , and eventually melt away when the temperature drops below the deconfinement - confinement phase transition temperature .
they may leave their signatures in the distribution of final particles due to large concentration of energy density in extended regions as well as due to non - trivial scatterings of quarks and antiquarks with these objects . first , we focus on the extended regions of high energy density resulting from the domain walls and strings .
this is clearly seen in our simulations and some extended structures / hot spots also survive after the temperature drops below the transition temperature @xmath2 .
note that even the hot spot resulting from the collapse of closed domain wall in fig.9,10 will be stretched in the longitudinal direction into an extended linear structure ( resulting from the collapse of a cylindrical wall ) . we know
that at rhic energies , the final freezeout temperature is not too far below the transition temperature @xmath2 .
this means that the energy density concentrated in any extended ( sheet like for domain walls and line like for strings / hot spots ) regions may not be able to defuse away effectively . assuming local energy density to directly result in multiplicity of particles coming from that region ,
an analysis of particle distribution in @xmath3 and in rapidity should be able to reflect any such extended regions . in this context
, it will be interesting to investigate if the ridge phenomenon seen at rhic @xcite could be a manifestation of an underlying z(3 ) domain wall / string structure .
correlation of particle production over large range of rapidity will naturally result from longitudinally extended regions of high energy density ( _ hot spots _ in the transverse plane ) .
combined with flow effects it may lead to ridge like structures @xcite . if extended domain wall structure survives in the transverse plane also , this will then extend to sheet like regions in the longitudinal direction .
decay of such a region of high energy density may directly lead to a ridge like structure , without requiring flow effects .
we expect non - trivial signatures resulting from the consideration of interactions of quarks and antiquarks with domain walls .
it was shown in an earlier work @xcite using generic arguments that quarks and antiquarks should have non - zero reflection coefficients when traversing across these domain walls .
a collapsing domain wall will then concentrate any excess baryon number enclosed , leading to formation of baryon rich regions .
this is just like witten s scenario for the early universe @xcite ( which was applied for the case of rhice in ref .
however , for these works it was crucial that the quark - hadron transition be of ( strong ) first order .
as we have emphasized above , in our case formation of z(3 ) walls and strings will be a generic feature of any c - d phase transition .
even though we have implemented it in the context of a first order transition via bubble nucleation , these objects will form even if the transition is a cross - over .
thus , concentration of baryons in small regions should be expected to occur in rhice which should manifest in baryon concentration in small regions of rapidity and @xmath3 .
another important aspect of quark / antiquark reflection is that inside a collapsing wall , each reflection increases the momentum of the enclosed particle .
when closed domain walls collapse then enclosed quarks / antiquarks may undergo multiple reflections before finally getting out .
this leads to a specific pattern of @xmath3 enhancement of quarks with heavy flavors showing more prominent effects @xcite .
the modification of @xmath3 spectrum of resulting hadrons can be calculated , and the enhancement of heavy flavor hadrons at high @xmath3 can be analyzed for the signal for the formation of z(3 ) domain walls in these experiments @xcite . in our simulations
extended domain walls also form which show bulk motion with velocities of order 0.5 .
quarks / antiquarks reflected from such moving extended walls will lead to anisotropic momentum distribution of emitted particles which may also provide signature of such walls . for collapsing closed domain walls , spherical domain walls
were used for estimates in ref .
@xcite and in ref .
our simulation in the present work provides a more realistic distribution of shapes and sizes for the resulting domain wall network .
we have estimated the velocity of moving domain walls to range from 0.5 to 0.8 for the situations studied .
these velocities are large enough to have important effect on the momentum of quarks / antiquarks undergoing reflection from these walls .
one needs to combine the analysis of @xcite with the present simulation to get a concrete signature for baryon concentration and heavy flavor hadron @xmath3 spectrum modification .
we plan to carry this out in a future work .
we also plan to study effects of spontaneous violation of cp due to formation of these z(3 ) walls in rhice .
our results show interesting pattern of the evolution of the fluctuations in the energy density .
as seen in fig.7 and fig.12 , energy density fluctuations show rapid changes during stages of bubble wall coalescence and during collapse / decay of domain walls .
even string - antistring annihilations should be contributing to these fluctuations .
fluctuations near the transition stage may leave direct imprints on particle distributions .
it is intriguing to think whether dileptons or direct photons may be sensitive to these fluctuations , which could then give a time history of evolution of such energy density fluctuations during the early stages as well .
even the presence of domain walls and strings during early stages may affect quark - antiquark distributions in those regions which may leave imprints on dileptons / direct photons . an important point
to note is that in our model , we expect energy density fluctuations in event averages ( representing high energy density regions of domain walls / strings as discussed above ) , as well as event - by - event fluctuations .
these will result due to fluctuation in the number / geometry of domain walls / strings from one event to the other resulting from different distribution of ( randomly occurring ) z(3 ) vacua in the qgp bubbles .
even the number of qgp bubbles , governed by the nucleation probability , will vary from one event to the other contributing to these event - by - event fluctuations .
we have carried out numerical simulation of formation of @xmath0 interfaces and associated strings at the initial confinement - deconfinement phase transition during the pre - equilibrium stage in relativistic heavy - ion collision experiments .
a simple model of quasi - equilibrium system was assumed for this stage with an effective temperature which first rises ( with rapid particle production ) to a maximum temperature @xmath4 , and then decreases due to continued plasma expansion . using the effective potential for the polyakov loop expectation value @xmath1 from ref .
@xcite we study the dynamics of the ( c - d ) phase transition in the temperature / time range when the first order transition of this model proceeds via bubble nucleation . as we have emphasized above , though our study is in the context of a first order transition ,
its results are expected to be valid even when the transition is a cross - over .
( though for non - zero chemical potential the transition may indeed be of first order ) .
the generic nature of our results arises due to the fact that the formation of z(3 ) domain walls and associated strings happens due to the a general domain structure resulting after any transition ( occurring in a finite time ) .
this is the essential physics of the kibble mechanism underlying the formation of topological defects in symmetry breaking transitions .
the @xmath0 wall network and associated strings formed during this early c - d transition are evolved using field equations in a plasma which is longitudinally expanding , with decreasing temperature .
we have neglected here the transverse expansion which is a good approximation for the early stages near the formation stage of these objects , but may not be a good approximation for the later parts of simulations when temperature drops below @xmath2 and z(3 ) domain walls and strings melt away .
we have studied size / shape of resulting closed domain wall as well as extended domain walls and have estimated the velocities of walls to range from 0.5 to 0.8 .
we also calculate the energy density fluctuations expected due to formation of these objects .
various experimental signals which can indicate the formation of these topologically non - trivial objects in rhice have been discussed .
for example , existence of these objects will result in specific patterns of energy density fluctuations which may leave direct imprints on particle distributions . in our model
, we expect energy density fluctuations in event averages ( representing high energy density regions of domain walls / strings ) , as well as event - by - event fluctuations as the number / geometry of domain walls / strings and even the number of qgp bubbles , varies from one event to the other .
extended regions of large energy densities arising from z(3 ) walls and associated strings may be manifested in space - time reconstruction of hadron density ( using hydrodynamic model ) .
the correlation of particle production over large range of rapidity will be expected from such extended regions .
this , combined with the flow effects ( for string like regions ) , or possibly directly ( for sheet like extended region ) may provide an explanation for the ridge phenomena observed at rhic @xcite . also , from the reflection of quarks and antiquarks from collapsing domain walls , baryon number enhancement in localized regions ( due to concentration of net baryon number ) as well as enhancement of heavy flavor hadrons at high @xmath3 is expected .
we emphasize again that the presence of @xmath0 walls and string may not only provide qualitatively new signatures for the qgp phase in these experiments , it may provide the first ( and may be the only possible ) laboratory study of such topological objects in a relativistic quantum field theory system .
we are very grateful to sanatan digal , anjishnu sarkar , ananta p. mishra , p.s .
saumia , and abhishek atreya for very useful comments and suggestions .
usg , ams , and vkt acknowledge the support of the department of atomic energy- board of research in nuclear sciences ( dae - brns ) , india , under the research grant no 2008/37/13/brns .
usg and vkt acknowledge support of the computing facility developed by the nuclear - particle physics group of physics department , allahabad university under the center of advanced studies ( cas ) funding of ugc , india .
u. w. heinz , lectures given at 2nd latin american school of high - energy physics , san miguel regla , mexico , 1 - 14 jun 2003 , published in _ san miguel regla 2003 , high - energy physics _ 165 .
e - print : hep - ph/0407360 ; j. adams et al .
[ star collaboration ] , j. phys . *
g 32 * , l37,(2006 ) [ arxiv : nucl - ex/0509030 ] ; j.putschke , talk at quark matter 2006 for star collaboration ) , shanghai , nov.2006 ; s. a. voloshin , phys . lett . * b 632 * , 490 ( 2006)[arxiv : nucl - th/0312065 ] . | we study the dynamics of confinement - deconfinement ( c - d ) phase transition in the context of relativistic heavy - ion collisions within the framework of effective models for the polyakov loop order parameter .
we study the formation of @xmath0 walls and associated strings in the initial transition from the confining ( hadronic ) phase to the deconfining ( qgp ) phase via the so called kibble mechanism .
essential physics of the kibble mechanism is contained in a sort of domain structure arising after any phase transition which represents random variation of the order parameter at distances beyond the typical correlation length .
we implement this domain structure by using the polyakov loop effective model with a first order phase transition and confine ourselves with temperature / time ranges so that the first order c - d transition proceeds via bubble nucleation , leading to a well defined domain structure . the formation of @xmath0 walls and associated strings results from the coalescence of qgp bubbles expanding in the confining background .
we investigate the evolution of the @xmath0 wall and string network .
we also calculate the energy density fluctuations associated with @xmath0 wall network and strings which decay away after the temperature drops below the quark - hadron transition temperature during the expansion of qgp . we discuss evolution of these quantities with changing temperature via bjorken s hydrodynamical model and discuss possible experimental signatures resulting from the presence of @xmath0 wall network and associate strings .
key words : quark - hadron transition , relativistic heavy - ion collisions , z(3 ) domain walls |
hd50230 is a star of the b3v spectral type and a visual brightness of 8.95 mag .
the star had been regarded as constant until its first satellite observations were conducted .
* degroote et al .
( 2010 , 2012 ) ) detected more than 500 significant peaks in the _ corot _ data . with their spectroscopic observations they discovered that hd50230 is a double - lined spectroscopic binary with projected equatorial velocity of 7 and 117 kms@xmath1 for the primary and secondary , respectively .
for the primary component , they determined effective temperature of @xmath2 k and surface gravity of @xmath3 dex . for the secondary component they found only an upper limit @xmath4 k and assumed @xmath5 dex .
in the rich oscillation spectrum of hd50230 @xcite extracted eight peaks almost uniformly spaced in period . invoking the asymptotic theory
, they interpreted these peaks as a sequence of modes with the same spherical harmonic degree , @xmath6 , azimuthal order , @xmath7 , and consecutive radial orders , @xmath8 . assuming @xmath9 and @xmath10 they found that main - sequence star models with a mass of 78 @xmath11 can reproduce the observed period spacing . to test degroote s interpretation we re - analysed the _ corot _ data . using the lomb - scargle periodogram we found 515 significant frequency peaks comparing to 556 frequencies found by degroote at al .
most our frequencies are consistent with the degroote s determinations .
surprisingly , we found in our set many sequences of peaks nearly uniformly spaced in periods .
unfortunately , these sequences do not yield sufficient clues to mode identification and are likely accidental . in the left panel of fig.[fig1 ] , we present examples of three sequences ( filled symbols ) . for comparison , as open squares , a sequence found by @xcite is also shown .
we chose these sequences because if we assume that frequencies with the period spacing of @xmath12 d are dipole modes then , according to the asymptotic theory , those with @xmath13 0.06 and 0.04 d correspond to modes with @xmath14 and 3 , respectively .
unfortunately , they have some common frequencies .
thus , at best , there must be some missing modes . for further analysis , we selected nine frequencies from the sequence with @xmath12 d. two frequencies with the shortest periods were omitted because they have too low radial orders and may not follow the asymptotic theory .
next , we tried to reproduce these nine frequencies adopting two approaches . neglecting the effects of rotation
, we reached the best fits for models with the following parameters : @xmath15 @xmath11 , @xmath16 , @xmath17 , @xmath18 and @xmath19 @xmath11 , @xmath20 , @xmath21 , @xmath22 . here
, @xmath23 is the metal abundance by mass fraction and @xmath24 is the overshooting parameter from the convective core expressed in the terms of pressure scale height , @xmath25 .
however , the corresponding @xmath26 do not allow us to accept these solutions .
a better fit was obtained when we took into account rotational splitting .
then , interpreting the sequence as retrograde dipole modes for a model with @xmath27 @xmath11 , @xmath28 , @xmath29 , @xmath30 , and @xmath31 km s@xmath1 we got @xmath32 .
these large values of @xmath33 result from very small frequency errors .
since oscillation spectra of high- and moderate - order g modes are dense , we may expect that modes with different values of spherical harmonic degree @xmath6 , and azimuthal order @xmath7 , can accidentally form period sequences nearly equally spaced in period . to demonstrate such cases , we calculated pulsation modes with @xmath34 for models with @xmath35 @xmath11 and different rotational velocities .
then , in the same way as we did for the observations , we searched for modes equally spaced in period , considering only unstable modes .
we found many sequences with different mean period spacings composed of modes with different pairs ( @xmath36 ) .
an example is shown in the right panel of fig.[fig1 ] as squares .
the nearly constant period spacing is accidental and in no way is related to the asymptotic property of g modes .
the calculated sequences at fixed @xmath6 and @xmath7 , depicted in the same figure , show lower mean spacing and much larger deviation from constancy .
these results support the conclusion that , in dense oscillation spectra , appearance of equally spaced sequences may be accidental and they should be treated with caution .
when we realized that the observed period spacing can not be interpreted according to the asymptotic theory we lost the clue to mode identification which is prerequisite for deriving seismic constraints on stellar parameters .
since the prospects for progress looked to us rather grim , we decided to look for a different application of the rich frequency data on hd50230 .
one unsolved problem in the stellar pulsation theory is the amplitude limitation in stars with a large number of unstable modes .
the observed distribution of peaks over period ranges may yield an important hint leading us to the solution of this difficult problem . to this aim
the observed distribution must be confronted with simulations based on linear nonadiabatic calculations for models constrained by measured values of @xmath37 , @xmath38 and @xmath39 .
the linear calculations do not yield mode amplitudes and this information we want to extract from data .
we should search for the best fit to the observed distribution assuming various mode - selection principles .
the set of considered modes , which all must be unstable , may be terminated at some sufficiently high @xmath6 if the observational threshold can not be reached . in the histograms shown in fig.2 , we assume the random distribution of the r.m.s .
amplitude of relative variations of the stellar radius , _ the intrinsic amplitude of a mode _ , and considered modes with the photometric amplitudes @xmath40 mmag .
we included modes with degrees up to @xmath41 , because our simulations showed that for higher @xmath6 , the amplitudes in the _ corot _ band do not exceed the value of @xmath42 mmag .
we use the same model reproducing the central values of @xmath37 and @xmath38 ( see sect.1 ) for the primary but with three distinct rotation rates : @xmath43 km s@xmath1 .
the values of the inclination angle result from @xmath44 km s@xmath1 which was kept constant .
these rotation rates are higher than those estimated by ( * ? ? ?
* degroote et al .
( 2010 , 2012 ) ) based on analysis of high - order p modes . however , their estimate is uncertain and refers to the different part of the interior .
the effects of rotation were included in the framework of the traditional approximation , e.g. , @xcite , ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* townsend ( 2003 , 2005 ) ) .
for comparison , the observed histogram was shown in the left upper panel of fig.2 .
as one can see , we were unable to reproduce the observed distribution of frequencies . independently of rotation
, we have a shortage of unstable and `` visible '' ( @xmath40 mmag ) theoretical modes with the shortest as well as with highest frequencies , above about 2 d@xmath1 . for higher rotation rate
, one could expect that retrograde modes complement the lowest frequency range .
but the higher values of @xmath45 imply the lower values of the inclination angle which in turn favor the axisymmetric modes ( @xmath10 ) .
we considered also a possibility that some of the low - amplitude peaks may result from combinations and found it unlikely .
our results give certain limits on the intrinsic amplitudes of modes .
in dense oscillation spectra such as in the case of hd 50230 , equidistant period spacings can be very likely accidental and one should be cautious when interpreting such structures . although the dream of rich oscillation spectra in the b - type pulsators has come true , we still do not have any clue to identify angular numbers of observed frequencies . without additional observations which would allow for mode identification , a reliable seismic stellar model of the star can not be constructed .
we see prospects for gaining new insight into nonlinear mode selection in stars from available data on hd 50230 .
our efforts toward explaining the observed distribution of peaks in its oscillation spectrum will continue .
wd was supported by polish ncn grant dec-2012/05/b
/ st9/03932 .
ws was supported by polish ncn grant 2012/05/n / st9/03905 .
calculations have been carried out using resources provided by wrocaw centre for networking and supercomputing ( http://wcss.pl ) , grant no | attempts to interpret the observed oscillation spectrum of the spb star hd50230 are reported .
we argue that a nearly equidistant period spacing found in the oscillation spectrum of the star is most likely accidental .
the observed period distribution requires excitation of modes with the degree @xmath0 .
much more may be learned from the rich oscillation spectrum of the star but most of the work is still ahead of us . |
the torsional oscillation was discovered by howard and labonte 1980 as a travelling wave pattern superposed on the differential rotation .
the waves propagate from the poles toward the equator and they consist of prograde and retrograde zones with respect to the mean differential rotation profile , the amplitude of the deviations is about 7 m / sec .
two waves ( two prograde and retrograde belts ) coexist in both hemispheres . the feature was absolutely unexpected at the time of discovery and several attempts
have been made to check and interpret it .
the empirical studies basically confirmed the existence of the phenomenon by using either surface measurements ( ulrich , 2001 ) or subsurface detection by gong and mdi data ( howe et al .
, 2000 ; komm et al 2001 ; zhao and kosovichev , 2004 ) . as a result of these investigations
the torsional oscillation can be regarded to be a persistent feature which extends down to about 0.92 @xmath0 .
the theoretical approaches were motivated by the similarity of the equatorward migrations of the shearing belts and the activity belts .
this suggested that the activity cycle ( in particular the sprer s law ) must have something to do with the torsional oscillation .
the first description was published by yoshimura ( 1981 ) who suggested a mechanism driven by a lorentz force wave as a by - product of the dynamo wave .
recent models take into account the presence of the sunspots . in the model of petrovay and forgcs - dajka ( 2002 )
the sunspots modify the turbulent viscosity in the convective zone which leads to the modulation of the differential rotation .
in the model proposed by spruit ( 2003 ) the sunspots exert a cooling effect on the surface and this temperature variation results in geostrophic flows which would drive the torsional oscillation .
the present work was motivated by these recent works which suggested a possible connection between the sunspots and the torsional oscillation phenomenon .
we would like to find any spatial correlation between the torsional wave and any sunspot feature .
earlier works also indicated some spatial connections but e.g. labonte and howard ( 1982 ) averaged the latitudinal magnetic activity distribution for a longer time whereas zhao and kosovichev ( 2004 ) only indicated the location of the activity belt with no distribution information .
the aim of the present work is to follow the temporal variation of the latitudinal distribution of sunspot parameters in comparison with the migration of the torsional waves . as a first attempt three parameters were chosen to scrutiny .
two of them may be trivial : the number and the total area of sunspots .
the third parameter , the mean number of sunspots within the groups characterizes the complexity of the sunspot groups , because it can also be expected that the more complex is a sunspot group the more efficient is its interconnection with the local velocity fields .
the sunspot data were taken from the most detailed sunspot database , the debrecen photoheliographic data ( dpd ) .
this is the only material which contains the position and area data for each observable spot , even for the smallest ones , for each day .
the temporal coverage of the dpd was partial at the time of this work so , as a first attempt , we restricted the study to the years 1986 - 1989 ( gyri et al , 1996 ) .
the latitudinal distributions were determined in such a way that 1 degree latitudinal stripes were considered , and all mentioned parameters ( total number and total area of spots , as well as the mean number of spots per goups ) were added up for all stripes and three months .
a total amount xxx spots were taken into account in the given period . to compare the obtained distributions with the torsional pattern one has to determine the latitudinal location of the torsional wave i.e. the latitudes of prograde / retrograde belts and the shearing zones .
for this period the most suitable torsional data were provided by ulrich ( 2001 ) . in his figure 1 .
the shearing zones were reasonably well recognizable in this period .
figure 1 . shows the period 1986 - 89 taken from ulrich ( 2001 ) and the most probable lines of the shear zones ( dark regions indicate the prograde belts ) . in our further figures
these lines were adopted to mark the migrating shear zones .
the most obvious candidate may be the number of sunspots at a certain latitude .
the numbers of all spots have been added up in 1 degree wide stripes and 3-month periods in such a way that each sunspot group was taken into account at that time when it contained the largest number of spots .
the resulting distributions were plotted onto the plot of the migrating zones , see figure 2 , where the temporal dimension has been streched in order to minimize the overlap of the distribution curves . in this approach
the sizes of the spots were omitted , only the amount of the magnetix flux tubes was considered regardless of their strengths . the next possible candidate is the total area of the spots ( figure 3 ) .
the procedure was the same as in the case of the sunspot numbers , all area data were added up by @xmath1 latitude stripes .
sunspots were taken into account at that time when the total areas of their groups were the largest during their passage through the solar disc . in this approach
the total strength was considered regardless of the size distribution .
the third candidate was chosen to check the assumption that in case of a certain sunspot - torsion interconnection the more complex sunspot groups could exert more efficient impacts on the ambient flows .
the number of spots within the groups has been averaged for the @xmath1 latitude stripes and 3-month periods , the groups were considered at the time of their largest extensions .
the resulting distributions are displayed in figure 4 .
it is remarkable in the figures 2 . and 3 . that the distributions of both the spot number and area are so positioned that the peaks of the curves ( if they have unambiguous peaks at all ) are close to the shear zones but the bulges of the distributions are mostly situated in the faster belts
the curves of the number and area are mostly different , as was expected , but the mentioned character seems to be overwhelming on both cases .
this behaviour may be the signature of a really functioning interconnection between the torsional pattern and the magnetic flux ropes .
as for the complexity of the groups , no such trend can be recognized so this feature ( the number of spots per groups ) is apparently unimportant from this point of view .
the above features are the first ( preliminary ) results of our project and they seem to be encouraging . in the following works we are intended to extend the temporal domain of the study and to include also some further possible sunspot parameters to reveal the nature of this interaction .
the present work was supported by the grants otka t 37725 and esa pecs no.98017 .
one of the authors ( a.l . ) expresses his gratitude for the kind invitation and hospitality of the hvar observatory .
* gyri , baranyi , t. , csepura , g. , gerlei , o. , ludmny a. 1996 , debrecen photoheliographic data for the year 1986 publ .
debrecen obs .
10 , 1 - 61 .
* howard , r. , labonte , b. j. : 1980 , _ astrophys . j. _ * 239 * , l33-l36 . * howe , r. _ et al . _
: 2000,_astrophys . j. _ * 533 * , l163-l166 . * komm r.w . , hill f. , howe r. , 2001 , _ astrophys .
j. _ * 558 * 428 - 441 . * labonte , b. j.,howard r. : 1982,_solar physics _ * 75 * , 161 - 178 . *
petrovay , k. , forgcs - dajka e. , : 2002 , _ solar physics _ * 205 * , 39 - 52 . * spruit , h. c. : 2003,_solar physics _ * 213 * , 1 - 21 . * ulrich , r. k. : 2001,_astrophys . j. _ * 560 * , 466 - 475 . * yoshimura , h. _ astrophys . j. _ * 247 * 1102 - 1112 .
* zhao , j. , kosovichev , a. g. : 2004,_astrophys . j. _ * 603 * , 776 - 784 . | the torsional oscillation is a well established observational fact and there are theoretical attempts for its description but no final solution has yet been accepted .
one of the possible candidates for its cause is the presence of sunspots modifying the streaming conditions .
the present work focuses on the temporally varying latitudinal distribution of several sunspot features , such as the spot sizes and spot numbers .
these features are different faces of the butterfly diagram .
in fact some weak spatial correlations can be recognized . |
magnetic multilayered films have been receiving much attention from the research community in the field of spintronics .
recently , a device has been proposed @xcite and demonstrated @xcite , in which the magnetic and spin - transport properties are controlled thermo - electrically . at the core of
the new design is a tri - layer ( _ f / f / f _ ) of two strong ferromagnets ( _ f _ ) exchange - coupled by a weakly ferromagnetic spacer ( _ f _ ) having the curie point at / or near room temperature ( @xmath3 k ) .
the spacer _ f _ , controlling the exchange coupling between the outer layers , can be made of a diluted ferromagnetic alloy , such as ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 @xcite .
it is desirable that the spacer is compositionally uniform and does not contain multiple phases , which can form as a result of atomic segregation during film deposition or subsequent heat treatment .
alloys ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 in their bulk form are _ fcc _ binary substitution alloys ( @xmath4-phase ) , with ni and cu mutually solvable in any proportion up to the temperature of 627 k , where at @xmath5 , the @xmath4 phase separates into two , @xmath6 and @xmath7 @xcite . according to @xcite ,
the phase diagram contains a metastable region with phase separation at the nickel concentration of @xmath8 , which can lead to additional magneto - structural inhomogeneities in the system .
the results , obtained in this work , however , are obtained using an empirical model , based on the experimental data .
it is desirable to independently simulate the phase equilibria in the system ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 , first without using experimental information and then compare the results with the experimental findings . of particular interest is the influence of the magnetic interactions in the system on the potential structural and/or compositional phase separation .
the curie temperature of bulk ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 alloys depends linearly on the ni concentration @xcite . by varying the ni content from 0.5 to 1
the curie temperature is changed from 0 k to 627 k. however , based on neutron scattering data , it was shown that both bulk samples @xcite and sputtered films of ni - cu alloys @xcite exhibit partial phase separation and form ni rich clusters of typical size @xmath9 and magnetic moment @xmath10 @xmath11 .
the formation of such ni clusters and the resulting magnetic inhomogeneity in the material can lead to anomalous magnetic @xcite and transport @xcite properties . in this work
we investigate the mechanisms behind phase formations in diluted ferromagnetic alloy films of ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 and explain using first - principles calculations the enhancing effect of the exchange interaction on phase separation in the ferromagnetic composition range of @xmath2 .
we discuss optimum ways to prepare films with enhanced magneto - structural homogeneity .
films of diluted ferromagnetic ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 alloys , with @xmath12 in ni concentration , 100 nm thick , were deposited at room temperature on thermally oxidized si substrates using dc magnetron co - sputtering from cu and ni targets .
substrates of @xmath13 mm in size , placed above the cu and ni targets , along the line connecting the centers of the targets , were used to produce a continuous and essentially linear compositional gradient along the substrate strip . the base pressure in
the deposition chamber was @xmath14 torr and the ar pressure used during deposition was @xmath15 mtorr .
the deposition rate for ni and cu in the center of the substrate was @xmath16 / sec .
samples for magneto - structural measurements were cut from the substrate strip into short sections with dimensions of @xmath17 mm . in total ,
30 samples of various composition ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 were produced in the same fabrication cycle under the same conditions .
the thickness of the films was determined using a surface profilometer .
the composition of the films was determined using x - ray dispersion spectroscopy analysis .
ferromagnetic resonance ( fmr ) was used to determine the effective magnetization of the ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 films ( @xmath18 ) and their curie temperature ( @xmath19 ) .
fmr measurements were performed at @xmath20 ghz using a bruker elexsys - e500 spectrometer equipped with a goniometer for angle - dependent measurements and a variable temperature cryostat .
the effective magnetization was obtained from the resonance fields using the kittel formulae @xcite : @xmath21 where @xmath22 and @xmath23 are the measured perpendicular and in - plane fmr resonance fields , respectively , @xmath24 frequency , and @xmath25 the gyromagnetic ratio .
the curie temperature of the films was determined from the fmr data as temperature at which either @xmath18 or the fmr signal vanished .
the degree of magneto - structural non - uniformity in the films was estimated from the width of the fmr peaks ( magnetic non - uniformity leads to broader fmr peaks ) . mechanical stress arising from mismatches in the lattice parameters of the substrate and the films
can lead to perpendicular to the plane magnetic anisotropy in the films through magnetostriction .
this magnetostrictive contribution to @xmath18 can be estimated using @xcite : @xmath26 here @xmath27 is the saturation magnetization of the film , @xmath28 magnetostriction - induced perpendicular - anisotropy field , @xmath29 magnetostrictive constant , @xmath30 mechanical stress in the film .
it follows from ( [ fmreqh ] ) that for a strong magnetostrictive contribution and/or small saturation magnetization , the effective magnetization can become negative , which corresponds to its perpendicular - to - the - plane orientation in the absence of external fields @xcite .
figure [ hres(t ) ] shows the temperature dependence of the fmr resonance fields for ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 films with different ni content . for ni@xmath31cu@xmath32 and ni@xmath33cu@xmath34 films , @xmath35 in a broad temperature range , which indicates an out - of - plane magnetization orientation for these compositions . for films with higher concentrations of ni ( @xmath36 ) ,
@xmath37 and the magnetization is in - plane at zero field . the temperature dependence of the effective magnetization obtained using ( [ fmreq ] ) and the measured resonance fields ( see fig . [ hres(t ) ] ) are shown in fig .
[ meff(t ) ] . for all compositions ,
the effective magnetization first increases with increasing temperature from @xmath38 k to @xmath39 k and subsequently decreases above @xmath40 k. this indicates a significant magnetostrictive contribution to the anisotropy . for low ni concentrations , ni@xmath31cu@xmath32 and ni@xmath33cu@xmath34
, @xmath18 is negative , while for ni@xmath41cu@xmath42 , ni@xmath43cu@xmath44 , ni@xmath45cu@xmath46 , ni@xmath47cu@xmath48 and ni@xmath49cu@xmath50 @xmath51 .
thus , in films with low ni concentrations and therefore low saturation magnetization , magnetostriction results in perpendicular magnetic anisotropy .
cu@xmath1 films versus temperature .
( ) external field perpendicular to the film plane , ( ) field in the film plane .
] cu@xmath1 films with different ni content @xmath52 .
dashed line is the approximation for @xmath53 . ]
the temperature of the curie transition from the ferromagnetic to the paramagnetic state ( @xmath19 ) for ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 films with @xmath54 ; 0.85 ; 0.87 ; 0.89 and 0.92 was determined as the temperature at which @xmath55 . for ni@xmath31cu@xmath32 and ni@xmath33cu@xmath34 films with strong magnetostriction and out - of - plane magnetization
, it was more appropriate to determine the @xmath19 directly from the temperature dependence of the respective amplitudes of the fmr signal ( fig .
[ fmrlines ] ) .
@xmath19 in this case was determined as the temperature at which the fmr signal amplitude approached zero ( fig .
[ fmrlines ] ) .
cu@xmath34 , measured with the in - plane field ( a ) .
fmr signal amplitude for the in - plane field configuration for ni@xmath31cu@xmath32 and ni@xmath33cu@xmath34 films ( b ) . ]
@xmath19 as a function of concentration in ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 films , determined from the fmr data as described above , is shown in fig .
[ phasediag1 ] .
the figure also shows the phase diagram and @xmath19 for the same system in the bulk form @xcite .
the phase diagram also shows the lines of the binodal , spinodal , as well as the metastable regions , the existence of which was predicted in @xcite .
[ phasediag1 ] shows that in the vicinity of the metastable equilibria ( lines @xmath56 ) , the concentration dependence of the @xmath19 for bulk @xcite and film materials ( this work ) are significantly different . in films ,
the behaviour of @xmath57 is significantly non - linear , while in the bulk it is practically linear .
the non - linear @xmath19 vs. x in films indicates that magnetic and structural inhomogeneities increase with increasing cu content , specifically in the concentration range @xmath58 . the fact that @xmath19 in films is always higher than in the bulk ( fig .
[ phasediag1 ] ) suggests that in sputter deposited films regions or clusters rich in ni compared to the nominal composition of the film are formed .
the @xmath19 of such ni - rich regions is higher than the @xmath19 for the nominal composition .
cu@xmath1 ( @xmath59 ) @xcite and thin films ( @xmath60 , , this work ) .
lines @xmath56 correspond to metastable equilibria . ]
additional information about the non - uniformities in the films can be obtained from the analysis of the fmr line width .
[ fmrlinewidth ] shows the half width of the fmr lines for ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 films , for various temperatures between 200 and 380 k. judging from the relatively narrow line widths ( fig .
[ fmrlinewidth ] ) , the films can be considered rather uniform magnetically , at least within the ferromagnetic exchange length of @xmath61 nm .
it is also seen from the data that the degree of non - uniformity depends on the concentration in ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 films .
thus , at small cu concentrations , @xmath62 , the alloy has a narrow fmr line indicating relatively good magneto - structural uniformity . for higher cu concentrations , @xmath63 , the fmr line broadens , which indicates a higher magnetic non - uniformity .
this , combined with the observed enhanced @xmath19 from ni clustering , indicates that in this interesting concentration range near the metastable region of the phase diagram the films can become structurally non - uniform , possibly consisting from multiple compositional phases .
below we examine theoretically the microscopic mechanism of phase separation in the system , taking into account the interatomic magnetic interactions .
there are no direct experimental confirmations that magnetic interactions in ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 could be responsible for additional phase equilibria in the system .
temperatures required for reaching equilibrium conditions are difficult to attain experimentally , if at all possible . nevertheless , it was predicted @xcite that in ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 alloys with @xmath64 a metastable miscibility gap should exist due to magnetic interactions . for describing the magnetic contribution to the free energy , the authors of @xcite used a model proposed by chuang @xcite .
the model contains an empirical expression for the heat capacity of a ferromagnetic alloy , with adjustable parameters obtained from the experiment . in order to obtain a deeper insight into whether such miscibility gap could indeed exist and be due to magnetic interactions , it is highly desirable to first construct a solid state phase diagram of ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 system using experiment - independent first - principle calculations of interatomic interactions , and then compare the results with the experiment .
cu@xmath1 films , measured at different temperatures . ] for describing the ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 alloy we use a model hamiltonian taking into account the ni - ni exchange interactions .
the hamiltonian is similar to the one used in @xcite for describing fe@xmath0ni@xmath1 alloys .
the approach relies on a lattice model , with each site @xmath65 of the _ fcc _ lattice being occupied either by an atom of ni ( @xmath66 ) or cu ( @xmath67 ) .
the atomic fraction of ni ( @xmath52 ) will be taken as @xmath68 .
the magnetic interactions between the ni atoms in the system are described by the classical isotropic heisenberg model .
since the local magnetic moment of cu atoms is negligible , the magnetic interactions of cu - cu and cu - ni are omitted .
thus , the model hamiltonian of the system is : @xmath69 where @xmath70 are the mixing potentials responsible for `` chemical '' interactions between the atoms , @xmath71 magnetic exchange constants for ni - ni interactions ( independent of concentration @xmath68 ) , @xmath72 vector of unit length along the direction of the ni local magnetic moment .
values of unknowns @xmath70 for first 4 coordination shells and @xmath71 for 2 shells were obtained as solutions of a system of equations ( [ eqce ] ) for a set of ordered superstructures representing the ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 alloys .
the structures have various distributions of nickel atoms and different magnetic ordering .
since the most interesting region of the phase diagram is at high concentrations of ni , 5 superstructures of composition cuni@xmath73 ( 32 atoms per unit cell , ferromagnetic ordering ) and 3 structures of pure ni with ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic ordering were selected .
the total free energy of the structures were calculated within the density functional theory ( dft ) using the flapw method ( wien2k package @xcite ) .
the calculations were performed taking into account spin polarization , and the gga exchange correlation potential was taken to be of the form of @xcite .
the mt - radii for cu and ni were equal to 2.2 _ a.u .
_ , the electron density was calculated using 500 k - points in the first brillouin zone .
structural relaxation was performed for the lattice parameters and the atomic positions .
the atomic positions were iterated until the forces on the nuclei became smaller than 1 mry / a.u .
the accuracy of the total energy was approximately 1 mev .
the calculated values of the interatomic interactions ( in mev ) were : @xmath74 , @xmath75 .
the calculation of the phase equilibria was performed within the mean - field approximation for the hamiltonian of ( [ eqce ] ) .
all ni atoms were taken to have the same value of magnetic moment @xmath76 .
@xmath77 is obtained as @xcite @xmath78 , with @xmath79 being the effective magnetic field , @xmath80 boltzmann constant , @xmath81 absolute temperature , @xmath82 langevin function .
the free energy is given by the expression : @xmath83 phase equilibria were calculated using the standard `` common tangent '' method .
the obtained phase diagram of the solid ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 is shown in fig .
[ phasediag2 ] .
the lines shown are the binodal , spinodal , metastable equilibria , and the curie temperature @xmath19 of the alloy versus composition .
the curie temperature below the binodal line corresponds to a homogeneous solid solution .
metastable equilibria @xmath84 and @xmath85 are shown as dashed lines .
cu@xmath1 ( crystalline state ) . ]
the phase diagram contains a stable miscibility gap ( lines @xmath56 ) due to magnetic transformations in the alloy .
a similar miscibility gap exists in the fe - ni system ( phases @xmath86 , @xmath87 @xcite ) .
the presence of this miscibility gap in ni@xmath88cu@xmath1 system results in additional equilibria of phases with close compositions but different magnetic properties and , importantly , different curie temperatures .
the presence of different phases in the alloy should broaden the magnetic transition , which is indeed observed in our ni@xmath88cu@xmath1 films . possibly due to our ni atomic magnetic moments taken to be independent of composition , the obtained theoretical @xmath19 versus composition ( fig .
[ phasediag2 ] ) deviates from the measured one ( fig .
[ phasediag1 ] ) .
it should also be mentioned , that in contrast to the results of @xcite , our calculations show that the additional miscibility gap is stable .
thus , our ab - initio numerical theoretical analysis , not relying on experimental data , shows additional phase equilibria in the ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 system at high concentrations of ni .
these additional equilibria are due to the ferromagnetic interactions in the system . using the expression for the free energy of eq .
( [ eqfreeenrg ] ) it is possible to obtain the general condition for the existence of an additional miscibility gap . for this
, it is convenient to introduce the following quantities : @xmath89 , @xmath90 .
the lines of the spinodal and magnetic transformations intersect at point _ a _ ( fig .
[ phasediag2 ] ) , which gives two conditions : @xmath91 , @xmath92 .
the expressions for the spontaneous magnetization near @xmath19 , @xmath93 : @xmath94 , and that for the curie temperature @xmath95 , yield the following equation for the concentration at point _ a _ : @xmath96 thus : @xmath97 condition @xmath98 yields for the interaction parameters : @xmath99 , this in turn gives the concentration range for the miscibility gap : @xmath100 . to sum up , for binary alloys with decomposition ( @xmath101 ) and with one element being ferromagnetic ( @xmath102 )
, there must exist an additional miscibility gap due to the inter - atomic magnetic interactions .
the obtained phase diagram indicates that the magnetic and structural properties of the samples should strongly depend on the temperature of fabrication ( substrate temperature for films ) .
specifically , quenching the material on to substrates is expected to be beneficial for the uniformity of the films . here ,
a uniform mixing of the two elements in the magnetron plasma flux is frozen in on the substrate before the magnetic atoms have time to interact by exchange .
if annealed at a sufficiently high temperature and then cooled slowly , the exchange interaction in the film is expected to result in atomic diffusion as to favor ni - clustering and therefore partial phase separation into a ni - rich and cu - rich phases , as discussed above .
diluted ferromagnetic alloy films ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 obtained by magnetron sputtering exhibit partial phase separation into ni - rich and cu - rich phases .
the phase separation is more pronounced for higher cu dilution and leads to a broadening of the ferro- to paramagnetic phase transition in the system .
this process is modeled using ab - initio calculations , taking into account the magnetic interactions in the system .
our analysis shows that the phase separation in the concentration range of interest is due to the ni - ni exchange interaction , which favors clustering of ni and thereby compositional gradients in the alloy .
this can additionally lead to a significantly non - linear dependence of the curie temperature on the alloy concentration .
our analysis further suggests that the general nature of the observed phase separation in ni - cu , namely the exchange - induced magnetic atom clustering in an otherwise perfectly solvable two - component system , should be found in other diluted alloys of magnetic - nonmagnetic or strongly magnetic - weakly magnetic elements and likewise lead to magneto - structural inhomogeneities there .
authors would like to thank the fp7-fet - stele project for providing financial support for this study .
99 a. m. kadigrobov , s. andersson , d. radi , r. i. shekhter , m .
jonson , and v. korenivski , j. appl .
107 , 123706 , ( 2010 ) .
s. andersson and v. korenivski , j. appl .
107 , 09d711 , ( 2010 ) .
s. andersson and v. korenivski , ieee trans .
46 , 2140 , ( 2010 ) .
d. j. chakrabarti , d. e. laughlin , s. w. chen , and y. a. chang , in phase diagrams of binary copper alloys , edited by p. subramanian , d. chakrabarti , and d. laughlin , asm international , materials park , oh , ( 1994 ) , pp .
276 286 .
t. j. hicks , b. rainford , j. s. kouvel , g. g. low , and j. b. comly , phys .
22 , 531 , ( 1969 ) . c. g. robbins , h. claus , and p. a. beck , phys .
22 , 1307 , ( 1969 ) .
g. iannone , d. zola , a. a. armenio , m. polichetti , and c. attanasio , phys .
b 75 , 064409 , ( 2007 ) . a. kidron and e. hermon , phys .
a 31 , 186 , ( 1970 ) .
r. w. houghton , m. p. sarachik , and j. s. kouvel , phys .
25 , 238 , ( 1970 ) . c. kittel , phys .
73 , 155 , ( 1948 ) .
r. m. bozorth , ferromagnetism , wiley - vch , ( 1993 ) .
chuang , r. schmid , and y. a. chang , metall .
trans . a 16 , 153 , ( 1985 ) .
chuang , y. a. chang , r. schmid , and j .- c .
lin , metall .
a 17 , 1361 , ( 1986 ) .
m. b. taylor and b. l. gyorffy , j. magn .
magn . mater .
104 - 107 , 877 , ( 1992 ) .
p. blaha , k. schwarz , g. madsen , d. kvasnicka , and j. luitz , wien2k , an augmented plane wave + local orbitals program for calculating crystal properties , karlheinz schwarz , techn .
universitt wien , austria , ( 2001 ) .
j. p. perdew , k. burke , and m. ernzerhof , phys .
77 , 3865 , ( 1996 ) .
k. h. j. buschow and f. r. de boer , physics of magnetism and magnetic materials , kluwer academic publishers , ( 2003 ) . | magneto - structural properties of films of diluted ferromagnetic alloys ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 in the concentration range @xmath2 are studied experimentally .
films deposited by magnetron sputtering show partial phase separation , as evidenced by structural analysis and ferromagnetic resonance measurements .
the phase diagram of the ni@xmath0cu@xmath1 bulk system is obtained using numerical theoretical analysis of the electronic structure , taking into account the inter - atomic exchange interactions .
the results confirm the experimentally found partial phase separation , explain it as magnetic in origin , and indicate an additional metastable region connected with the ferromagnetic transition in the system .
dilute ferromagnets , thin films , phase diagram , ferromagnetic resonance , curie temperature |
the kondo lattice model ( klm ) is used to describe compounds containing localized magnetic moments , such as heavy fermion systems and kondo insulators .
@xcite the klm hamiltonian is given by : @xmath3here , @xmath4 and @xmath5 are itinerant and local ( @xmath6- ) spins on site @xmath7 , respectively .
the klm takes into account hopping of conduction electrons , @xmath8 , and their kondo interaction , @xmath0 , with local @xmath6-spins .
the kondo term causes a screening of local spins , but also induces indirect rkky interactions between the local spins on the lattice .
these two interactions compete , leading to either magnetically ordered or non - magnetic ground states , separated by the quantum critical point ( qcp ) .
@xcite the nature of the qcp in heavy fermion compounds is one of the central topics of condensed matter physics today .
@xcite various analytical and numerical methods have been used to study the klm , like the mean - field approach @xcite and quantum monte carlo ( qmc ) method .
@xcite the finite temperature lanczos method ( ftlm ) @xcite has been used to study thermodynamic functions .
@xcite also the periodic anderson model on finite size clusters has been studied with similar methods recently .
@xcite here , we use the ftlm and mainly focus the analysis on the temperature dependence and the ground state values of static correlation functions , of central importance for the qcp .
we compare onsite vs. intersite correlations on the lattice and also compare the former with the impurity case .
the latter is associated with rkky interactions .
we also investigate the evolution of the total onsite moment with kondo coupling strength @xmath0 .
the main advantage of the ftlm is that it involves no uncontrolled approximations and is exact for finite size clusters .
it treats both , kondo screening and rkky interactions , correctly .
we consider the 8-site cluster of a square lattice , as shown in the inset of fig .
[ dos ] , with periodic ( pbc ) and open ( obc ) boundary conditions at half filling .
we will show that for this cluster the two different boundary conditions lead to two interesting physical situations , which may have relevance to the two types of qcp s observed ( cf . ref . and references cited therein ) .
there is of course only one solution of the klm in the thermodynamic limit .
however , the real materials have more complex band structures than described by the n. n. hopping in ( [ klh ] ) . by varying boundary conditions for the klm on the small cluster one may mimic band structures with different characteristic behaviour of the density of states ( dos ) around the fermi level .
for this reason we present in detail the analysis of the klm on the finite cluster for the pbc and the obc and compare the two cases . in sec .
ii we discuss the specific heat anomalies obtained in the two cases .
iii discusses the central problem of kondo - lattice physics : the competition and crossover behaviour of onsite and intersite correlations as function of temperature and control parameter @xmath1 .
the associated kondo screening behaviour evident from the susceptibility and total local moment is presented in sec .
finally sec .
v summarizes the results in a phase diagram and gives the conclusions .
the specific heat for the pbc and the obc , for various coupling constants @xmath0 , is shown in fig .
[ cv ] .
the low - temperature specific heat for non - interacting case , @xmath9 , with pbc deviates significantly from the thermodynamic limit .
the reason is that 6 out of 8 electrons are placed on the `` fermi surface '' , shown in the inset of fig .
[ dos ] , thus the ground state is highly degenerate .
the specific heat for obc is closer to the thermodynamic limit .
the peak from the hopping term for @xmath10 is much more pronounced and at lower temperature , @xmath11 , for obc than for pbc .
the electronic states for obc are no longer bloch states , but the important point is that the electron energies are shifted from , and distributed below , the `` fermi level '' .
the distribution of these discrete levels is such that it relatively well mimics the continuum dos in the thermodynamic limit , as shown in fig .
[ dos ] .
the specific heat for pbc and obc , when kondo interaction is turned on , shows qualitatively different behavior in the weak coupling regime , @xmath12 , as shown in fig .
[ cv ] . for pbc , a double peak structure is observed at low temperatures for @xmath13 .
we may denote the positions of the upper and lower peak by @xmath14 and @xmath15 , respectively .
for obc only one low temperature peak appears at @xmath16 .
the origin of these peaks are spin degrees of freedom , whose degeneracy is lifted by kondo interaction . in the strong coupling limit there is only one peak in the specific heat , and it does not depend on the boundary conditions
. the specific heat for obc agrees with the results obtained with the same method for the 10-site cluster with pbc in ref . , as well as with the results obtained with the qmc in ref . .
the nature of the specific heat peaks may be revealed by considering appropriate static correlation functions .
we focus the analysis on the following two : @xmath17 is the onsite correlation function between local and itinerant spins , while @xmath18 is the intersite correlation function between local spins on neighboring sites for pbc . for obc these
are @xmath19 and @xmath20 , i.e. , the inner sites 3 and 6 are considered , because they are more representative than sites on the edges of the cluster ( cf .
[ dos ] ) .
the onsite correlations , @xmath17 , for pbc as function of temperature are shown in fig .
[ corrt ] .
they are also compared with the onsite correlations for the impurity case , where there is only one local spin , at site 1 , on the 8-site cluster . in the weak coupling regime
the onsite screening is decreased in the lattice , because there are less itinerant spins per local spin available for the screening .
the inflection points of the correlation functions , as function of temperature , indicate that the upper peak in the specific heat , at @xmath14 , corresponds to the formation of the onsite correlations , whereas the lower one , at @xmath15 , corresponds to the formation of the intersite correlations .
the ground state ( @xmath21 k ) correlations for pbc as function of coupling strength @xmath1 are shown in the inset of fig . [ corrpbc ] .
it is seen that the onsite correlations are stronger than the intersite correlations for all @xmath1 .
another characteristic is that @xmath17 jumps to the large absolute value as soon as @xmath0 is turned on .
this is a consequence of the degenerate itinerant degrees of freedom at fermi level for @xmath10 .
the free itinerant spins on the `` fermi level '' screen the local spins onsite as soon as @xmath22 ; the ground state splits off and is characterized by finite @xmath17 correlations .
the unscreened parts of the local spins form intersite correlations , @xmath18 , below @xmath15 , due to the rkky interaction .
the magnitude of @xmath18 increases rapidly as @xmath0 is turned on .
because of the very small energy scale ( quadratic in @xmath0 ) , convergence problems appear in the calculation of ground state @xmath18 correlations for @xmath23 and we were not able to determine whether they also jump for finite @xmath0 . in the strong coupling regime the intersite correlations vanish , while the onsite correlations saturate at @xmath24 , as the onsite singlets are formed .
the correlation functions , normalized to the ground state values , versus scaled temperature , as done in ref . , are shown in fig .
[ corrpbc ] .
the onsite correlations are characterized by a single temperature scale , perfectly linear in @xmath1 .
the intersite correlations are also characterized by a single temperature scale proportional to @xmath0@xmath25 .
this shows that for pbc the onsite screening is independent of the intersite correlations , which may be associated with rkky interactions .
this is a consequence of the special symmetry of the 8-site cluster which implies a large fraction of conduction electron sitting on the `` fermi surface '' .
nevertheless it is an interesting result which may have relevance for a case where the conduction electron dos is strongly peaked at the fermi level . the onsite correlations , @xmath19 , for obc as function of temperature and the comparison to the impurity case are also shown in fig .
[ corrt ] .
in contrast to the pbc , for obc the onsite correlations are enhanced in the lattice . in the case of obc
there are no `` free '' itinerant spins , i.e. , conduction electrons on the `` fermi level '' . in the weak coupling limit the onsite
screening is not a direct process and is weak .
the interesting point is the appearance of a new low energy scale in the lattice , which may be noted as a low - temperature downturn in the onsite correlations in fig .
[ corrt ] .
the ground state correlations are shown in the inset of fig .
[ corrobc ] .
the onsite correlations , @xmath19 , do not jump as @xmath0 is turned on , but rather increase continuously with @xmath0 .
the intersite correlations , @xmath20 , are much stronger than @xmath18 for pbc and in the weak coupling limit they are even larger in absolute values than the onsite @xmath19 correlations .
it is understandable , because the local spins are only weakly screened , due to the lack of `` free '' itinerant spins .
therefore , the unscreened local spins can form strong intersite correlations .
the normalized correlations as function of the scaled temperature for obc are shown in fig .
[ corrobc ] . the @xmath19 scale with @xmath0 only in the strong coupling limit . in the weak coupling limit
two characteristic temperatures or energy scales can be identified , as already mentioned above .
the upper one is associated with the energy splitting of the discrete energy levels ( cf .
[ dos ] ) , and is clearly a finite size effect .
the lower energy scale is associated with the additional onsite screening , due to the presence of other local spins in the lattice .
the intersite @xmath20 correlations are still approximately governed by a single energy scale , @xmath26 , just as for pbc .
indeed the behavior of the normalized intersite correlation functions for obc and pbc are quite similar , despite of the fact that the magnitude differs by a factor of two .
the spin correlations are also directly reflected in magnetic susceptibility , shown in fig .
[ chi ] , for pbc and obc .
it is multiplied by @xmath0 and plotted versus temperature scaled with @xmath0 , as was done in ref . .
the two peaks for pbc are clearly seen for small @xmath1 , as in the specific heat .
however , in the magnetic susceptibility even the lower peak for @xmath1@xmath27 is clearly seen .
this is because the lower peaks in the magnetic susceptibility are much more pronounced and at slightly higher temperatures than the corresponding peaks in the specific heat .
the position of the lower peak scales well with @xmath28 ( not shown in the figure ) .
the lower peak is not distinguishable any more for @xmath29 .
the position of the higher peak scales with @xmath0 . for obc only one large peak is seen .
for @xmath12 it scales approximately with @xmath28 . in the strong coupling limit , @xmath29 ,
the peak scales linearly with @xmath0 , just as for pbc .
the results for obc are similar to the results for the 10-site cluster with pbc in ref . .
these results are also similar to the results of the qmc calculations for larger clusters in ref . .
however , in ref .
, the magnetic susceptibility peak scales with @xmath0@xmath30 , while in the onsite correlations the characteristic temperature is proportional to @xmath0 , suggesting the existence of two low energy scales . in the insets of fig .
[ chi ] the ground state values of the total local moments are shown , defined as : @xmath31 the interesting quantity here is @xmath32 which is a measure of itinerant spin localization . in the strong coupling limit @xmath33 ,
i.e. , the itinerant spins become localized as the onsite singlets are formed and the hopping of conduction electrons is frozen .
when the conduction electrons are completely delocalized , i.e. , for @xmath0@xmath34 , @xmath35 , because the probability of finding one electron with spin up or down on one particular site is @xmath36 . accordingly , @xmath37 for @xmath9 while for @xmath38 it vanishes , as the onsite singlets are formed and the local moments completely screened .
there is a jump for @xmath1@xmath39 for pbc .
it has the same origin as the jump for the onsite correlations @xmath17 , i.e. , the highly degenerate unperturbed conduction electron ground state .
a jump is also present in @xmath32 . for obc
we see a continuous decrease of @xmath40 .
the @xmath40 is a good quantity to define a critical value of @xmath1 at which the crossover from predominantly magnetic to predominantly nonmagnetic ground state occurs .
the other possibility would be to compare directly the intersite and onsite correlations , but the intersite correlations depend strongly on the cluster size .
therefore we define a critical ( @xmath1)@xmath41 as the value for which @xmath42 . then for obc , ( @xmath1)@xmath43 ( cf .
[ chi ] ) , in good agreement with the values obtained from the quantum monte carlo @xcite and the mean - field analysis .
@xcite for pbc it would be @xmath44 , but for this small cluster size , obc are much more representative for the thermodynamic limit of the klm .
we may summarize the results in form of phase diagrams for pbc and obc , shown in fig .
[ phdia ] . in the phase
diagrams the positions of specific heat maxima are plotted as function of coupling strength , @xmath1 .
also the inflection points of the correlation functions are plotted , and they mostly follow the positions of the corresponding specific heat maxima . in the weak coupling regime , for pbc , two characteristic temperatures , @xmath14 and @xmath15 , are found .
the @xmath15 can not be determined for @xmath1@xmath45 , but we make the continuation with the @xmath18 inflection point temperature , @xmath46 , which can be defined for all coupling strengths . therefore we conclude that the corresponding anomaly in the specific heat is still there , but is too small to be identified .
the inflection points of the correlation functions reveal that the characteristic temperatures @xmath14 and @xmath15 correspond to the energy scales of onsite correlations and intersite correlations , respectively .
the former is linear in @xmath0 for all @xmath1 .
the latter is proportional to @xmath26 , and may be associated with the rkky interaction . for obc
, there is only one characteristic temperature , @xmath16 , for all @xmath1 . in the weak coupling regime , for @xmath1@xmath47 , below @xmath16 predominantly intersite correlations are formed .
however , @xmath16 is also the characteristic temperature of onsite correlations .
this is seen from the positions of inflection points for the corresponding correlations , also shown in the lower part of fig .
[ phdia ] .
because the intersite correlations dominate and the characteristic temperature is approximately quadratic in @xmath0 , the corresponding energy scale , in the weak coupling regime , may be associated with the rkky interaction .
it is important to note that @xmath48 , i.e. , the rkky interaction is not very sensitive to the distribution of non - interacting conduction electron states .
this is plausible with the known expression for the rkky characteristic temperature , @xmath49 ( e.g. @xcite ) , where @xmath50 is the band width .
it is also important that the rkky energy scale is the energy scale of the onsite correlations in the weak coupling regime for the obc .
we may generally conclude that the rkky energy scale is the lowest energy scale of the klm ; if the local spins are not screened above @xmath51 , then it is the only energy scale of the system .
in contrast , the onsite correlations , i.e. , the onsite screening of local spins , is very sensitive to the number of states within @xmath0 around the `` fermi level '' , as seen from the difference between @xmath14 and @xmath16 for pbc and obc , respectively .
this is plausible with the expression for the single impurity kondo temperature , which depends exponentially on the dos at the fermi level , @xmath52 ; @xmath53}$ ] . in the strong coupling regime
, only one characteristic temperature is found for both pbc and obc .
it corresponds to the energy of the onsite singlet formation , which is linear in @xmath0 .
boundary conditions are unimportant , because the local physics determines the properties of the system
. we may argue on the relevance of these results for the system in the thermodynamic limit .
recently a qcp was found @xcite whose properties deviate from the expected behavior ( e.g. @xcite ) .
the properties of the system at the qcp are determined by the competition between the onsite screening and the rkky interaction .
here we have shown that the competition between the onsite screening and the rkky interaction strongly depends on the particular form of the distribution of non - interecting conduction electron levels .
we may anticipate that in the thermodynamic limit this means a strong dependence on the particular form of non - interacting conduction electron dos . a strongly peaked dos near the fermi level favors onsite screening , while the rkky interaction is not very sensitive to the particular shape of the dos .
these results indicate that the shape of the dos is very important for the properties of the heavy fermion systems in the vicinity of the qcp .
finally , the qualitative behavior of the correlation functions for the klm with obc is similar to the klm without charge degrees of freedom , @xcite which is a generalized kondo necklace model in 2d from doniach s original work .
@xcite this shows that this simplified model describes well the spin degrees of freedom in the klm at half - filling . | we investigate the kondo lattice model on 2d clusters using the finite temperature lanczos method .
the temperature dependence of thermodynamic and correlations functions are systematically studied for various kondo couplings @xmath0 .
the ground state value of the total local moment is presented as well .
finally , the phase diagrams of the finite clusters are constructed for periodic and open boundary conditions .
for the two boundary conditions , two different regimes are found for small @xmath1 , depending on the distribution of non - interacting conduction electron states .
if there are states within @xmath2 around the fermi level , two energy scales , linear and quadratic in @xmath0 , exist .
the former is associated with the onsite screening and the latter with the rkky interaction .
if there are no states within @xmath0 around the fermi level , the only energy scale is that of the rkky interaction .
our results imply that the form of the electron density of states ( dos ) plays an important role in the competition between the kondo screening and the rkky interaction .
the former is stronger if the dos is larger around the fermi level , while the latter is less sensitive to the form of the dos . |
the physics of exotic nuclei with unusual @xmath5 ratios ( isospin ) has attracted world - wide attention . these nuclei are usually loosely bound and often exhibit resonances with a pronounced single - particle character since the fermi surface approaches the continuum . in some nuclei , the valence nucleons can be easily scattered into single - particle resonant states ( or gamow states ) in the continuum which is essential for the existence of exotic phenomena .
for example , the halo in @xmath6li @xcite can be successfully reproduced @xcite and giant halo nuclei @xcite are predicted by the relativistic continuum hartree - bogoliubov ( rchb ) theory @xcite in which the contribution from the continuum has been proven to be crucial to understand these halo phenomena .
there are also other attempts to include the contribution from the continuum in the non - relativistic @xcite and relativistic approaches @xcite . by taking into account a few resonant states close to the continuum threshold with the bcs method @xcite , the relativistic mean field ( rmf ) theory seems to be able to reproduce the rchb results and describe the main effects of the continuum .
it has also been shown that the contribution of the continuum to the giant resonances mainly comes from gamow states @xcite .
therefore , a proper treatment of resonant states is important for a deeper understanding of the properties in exotic nuclei .
presently , several techniques have been developed to study resonant states in the continuum .
one of them is the r - matrix theory in which resonance parameters ( i.e. energy and width ) can be reasonably determined from fitting the available experimental data @xcite .
the extended r - matrix theory @xcite and the k - matrix theory @xcite have also been developed .
the conventional scattering theory is also an efficient tool for studying resonances .
more precisely , the phase shift method is commonly used to determine parameters for a resonant state which corresponds to a pole of the s matrix @xcite . by discretizing the continuum ,
the contribution of the resonant states can be self - consistently taken into account via a bogoliubov transformation in coordinate space @xcite .
computationally , it is desired to deduce the properties of unbound states from the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of hamiltonians for bound states so that the methods developed for bound states can still be used . for this purpose ,
the bound - state - type methods have been developed , including the real stabilization method @xcite , the complex scaling method ( csm ) @xcite , and the analytic continuation in the coupling constant ( accc ) method @xcite . in the real stabilization method ,
the continuum is discretized in a box and the resonance can be found according to the fact that its energy should be stable against the change of the box size .
sometimes it is difficult to find the appropriate box sizes , and it also turns out that this approach is suitable for narrow resonances only @xcite . in the csm , the wave function for a resonant state is transformed to the square - integrable wave function for a bound state by rotating the position vector in coordinate space into the complex plane . since the csm involves the calculations of complex matrix elements , the corresponding difficulties related to complex eigenvalue problem still exist . in the accc method
, a resonant state becomes a bound state if one increases the attractive potential and the energy , width and wave function for the resonant state can be obtained by an analytic continuation carried out via a @xmath2 approximant ( pa ) from the bound - state solutions . compared with other bound - state - type methods , the accc approach is very effective and numerically quite simple because many methods available for bound - state problems can be used and the pa for analytic continuation can be implemented easily . within the framework of the non - relativistic schrdinger equation
, the accc method has been applied to investigate the energies and widths for resonant states in light nuclei combined with few - body methods @xcite , and to study single - particle resonant states in spherical and deformed nuclei by solving the schrdinger equation with woods - saxon potentials @xcite .
based on the schrdinger and dirac equations , the stability and convergence of the energies and widths for single - particle resonant states with square - well , harmonic - oscillator and woods - saxon potentials have been investigated and their dependence on the coupling constant interval and the order of the pa have been discussed in detail @xcite . the relativistic mean field ( rmf ) theory is widely used to describe properties of nuclear matter and finite nuclei successfully , not only for those nuclei near the valley of stability , but also for exotic nuclei with large neutron ( proton ) excess @xcite . previously the accc method was employed to study energies and widths for resonant states in stable nuclei @xmath7o and @xmath8ca in rmf theory @xcite . in the present work , we aim at exploring the single - particle resonant states , including resonance parameters and wave functions , in exotic nuclei by the accc method within the framework of the rmf theory .
this paper represents the first application of the rmf - accc method to obtain both the wave functions and resonance parameters .
the paper is organized as follows . in sec .
ii the accc method combined with the rmf theory is presented .
the numerical details are given in sec .
iii and its application to the doubly magic nucleus @xmath3zr in sec .
finally , we give a brief summary in sec .
the basic ansatz of the rmf theory is a lagrangian density whereby nucleons are described as dirac particles which interact via the exchange of various mesons ( the scalar @xmath9 , vector @xmath10 and iso - vector vector @xmath11 ) and the photon @xcite @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the nucleon mass and @xmath14 ( @xmath15 ) , @xmath16 ( @xmath17 ) , and @xmath18 ( @xmath19 ) are the masses ( coupling constants ) of the respective mesons . a nonlinear scalar self - interaction @xmath20 of the @xmath9 meson has been included @xcite .
the field tensors for the vector mesons are given as @xmath21 the classical variation principle gives the following equations of motion @xmath22 \psi_i ~=~ \epsilon_i\psi_i , \label{spinor1}\ ] ] for the nucleon spinors , where @xmath23 and @xmath24 are the single - particle energy and spinor wave function respectively , and the klein - gordon equations @xmath25 for the mesons , where @xmath26 are the vector and scalar potentials respectively and the source terms for the mesons are @xmath27 it should be noted that the contribution of negative energy states are neglected , i.e. , the vacuum is not polarized .
moreover , the mean field approximation is carried out via replacing meson field operators in eq .
( [ spinor1 ] ) by their expectation values , since the coupled equations eq .
( [ spinor1 ] ) and eq .
( [ mesonmotion ] ) are nonlinear quantum field equations and their exact solutions are very complicated . in this way ,
the nucleons are assumed to move independently in the classical meson fields .
the coupled equations can be solved self - consistently by iteration . for spherical nuclei , the potential of the nucleon and the sources of meson fields depend only on the radial coordinate @xmath28 .
the spinor is characterized by the angular momentum quantum numbers @xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath31 , the isospin @xmath32 for neutron and proton respectively , and the other quantum number @xmath33 .
the dirac spinor has the form @xmath34 where @xmath35 are the spinor spherical harmonics .
the radial equation of the spinor , i.e. eq . ( [ spinor1 ] ) , can be reduced to @xcite @xmath36}g_i^{lj}(r)&=&\varepsilon_i g_i^{lj}(r),{\nonumber\\}(\dfrac{\partial}{\partial r}+\dfrac{\kappa}{r})g_i^{lj}(r)-{\left[}m - v_m(r){\right]}f_i^{lj}(r)&=&\varepsilon_i f_i^{lj}(r),\end{aligned}\ ] ] in which @xmath37 , @xmath38 , and @xmath39 .
the meson field equations can be reduced to @xmath40 where @xmath41 , @xmath10 , @xmath11 , and photon ( @xmath42 for photon ) .
the source terms read @xmath43 and @xmath44 by solving eqs .
( [ dirac - r ] ) and ( [ ramesonmotion ] ) in a meshed box of size @xmath45 self - consistently , one can calculate the ground state properties of a nucleus .
the vector potential @xmath46 and the scalar potential @xmath47 , energies and wave functions for bound states are also obtained . by increasing the attractive potential as @xmath48 ,
a resonant state will be lowered and becomes a bound state if the coupling constant @xmath49 is large enough .
near the branch point @xmath50 , defined by the scattering threshold @xmath51 @xcite , the wave number @xmath52 behaves as @xmath53 these properties suggest an analytic continuation of the wave number @xmath54 in the complex @xmath49 plane from the bound - state region into the resonance region by @xmath2 approximant of the second kind ( paii ) @xcite @xmath55}(x)= i \dfrac{c_0+c_1 x+c_2x^2+\ldots + c_lx^l } { 1+d_1 x+d_2 x^2+\ldots+d_n x^n},\ ] ] where @xmath56 , and @xmath57 are the coefficients of pa .
these coefficients can be determined by a set of reference points @xmath58 and @xmath59 obtained from the dirac equation with @xmath60 . with the complex wave number @xmath61 , the resonance energy @xmath62 and the width @xmath63
can be extracted from the relation @xmath64 and @xmath65 , i.e. , @xmath66 in the non - relativistic limit ( @xmath67 ) , eq .
( [ e - w ] ) reduces to @xmath68 it is evident that the continuation in the coupling constant can be replaced by the continuation in @xmath54 plane along the @xmath52 trajectory determined by eq .
( [ pade - e ] ) to the point @xmath69 corresponding to the wave number for gamow state , i.e. , @xmath70}(\lambda=1)$ ] @xcite .
similarly , the wave function @xmath71 for a resonant state can be obtained by an analytic continuation of the bound - state wave function @xmath72 in the complex @xmath54 plane .
one can also prove that the wave function @xmath73 is an analytic function of the wave number @xmath54 in the inner region @xmath74 where the jost function analyticity dominates @xcite .
therefore , we use the technique , which has been adopted to find the complex resonance energy , to determine the resonance wave function @xmath71 .
firstly , we construct the pa to define the resonance wave function at any point @xmath28 in the inner region ( @xmath74 ) @xcite @xmath75}(k , r ) = \dfrac{p_l(k , r)}{q_n(k , r ) } = \dfrac{a_0(r)+a_1(r)k+a_2(r)k^2+\ldots + a_l(r)k^l } { 1+b_1(r ) k+b_2(r)k^2+\ldots+b_n(r ) k^n},\ ] ] where the coefficients @xmath76 and @xmath77 are dependent on @xmath28 .
these coefficients can be determined by a set of reference points @xmath78 and @xmath72 obtained from the dirac equation with @xmath79 .
the resonance wave function @xmath80}(k_r , r)~(r < r_0)$ ] can be extrapolated in this way .
( [ dirac - r ] ) can be rewritten as two decoupled schrdinger - like equations for the upper and the lower components respectively @xcite . for neutrons ,
the schrdinger - like equation for the upper component reads @xmath81 in the outer region where @xmath82 and @xmath83 .
its solution is the well known riccati - hankel function @xmath84 where @xmath85 is the usual regular solution , i.e. riccati - bessel function , and @xmath86 is the irregular solution , i.e. riccati - neumann function .
the outer wave function is matched to the inner wave function at @xmath87 @xmath88}(k_r , r_m ) = c(k_r){\left[}\hat{j}_\kappa(k_rr_m)+ d(k_r)\hat{n}_\kappa(k_rr_m){\right]},\ ] ] where @xmath89 is the coefficient for matching and @xmath90 with @xmath91 the phase shift .
it has been found that @xmath91 is almost a constant when @xmath92 is large enough .
given the upper component , the lower component @xmath93 can be calculated from the relationship between the upper and the lower components derived from eq .
( [ dirac - r ] ) , i.e. , @xmath94}.\ ] ] finally , the resonance wave function is normalized according to the zeldovich procedures @xcite .
in this section we give the details on how the accc method is realized within the framework of the rmf theory and exploit the analyticity of the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of the dirac equation with respect to the coupling constant . in rchb calculations
@xmath1ca is the doorway for exotic phenomena such as giant halos @xcite , in which the neutron resonant states play an important role in the continuum .
we select the neutron resonant state @xmath95 in @xmath1ca to investigate the analyticity of the eigenvalue and eigenfunction for the dirac equation with respect to the coupling constant .
the rmf equations are solved in a spherical box of the size @xmath96 fm , with a mesh size of @xmath97 fm @xcite .
several well used effective interactions for the rmf lagrangian will be used and the corresponding results will be compared .
the energy , width and wave function for the @xmath95 resonant state in @xmath1ca are obtained with the procedure given in the last section . as the stability and convergence ( e.g.
, the dependence on pa order ) of the energies and widths in the dirac and schrdinger equations have been investigated in refs .
@xcite , we do not discuss them here and use @xmath98 pa for the present calculations . in tab .
[ tab1 ] , we present the energies and widths for @xmath0 in @xmath1ca calculated with effective interactions nl3 @xcite , nlsh @xcite , tma @xcite and the newly developed pk1
@xcite parametrization .
the results from the scattering phase shift method ( rmf - s ) obtained similarly as in ref .
@xcite are also included for comparison .
the first step in rmf - s is to solve the dirac equation [ eq . ( [ dirac - r ] ) ] with scattering boundary conditions for the continuum spectrum .
the solutions , upper and lower components , have the same form as here in eq .
( [ match - g ] ) and eq .
( [ match - f ] ) respectively . the coefficients
@xmath99 and @xmath100 in eq .
( [ match - g ] ) and eq .
( [ match - f ] ) are fixed by the normalization condition of the scattering wave functions and the phase shift @xmath101 is calculated from the matching conditions .
it should be mentioned that the energy used in the wave functions is real and not unique , as opposed to complex and the unique value which is determined by the accc method in advance . in the vicinity of an isolated resonance ,
the resonance energy and width are extracted from the derivative of the phase shift @xmath101 in breit - wigner form , i.e. , @xmath102 after discretizing the real energy for scattering solutions and phase shift variation , the resonance energy is uniquely determined .
one can find from tab .
[ tab1 ] that the results from the accc and the scattering methods agree well .
different effective interactions give similar energies and widths .
therefore in the following calculations , we use only the effective interaction nl3 for illustration .
the resonance energy @xmath62 and width @xmath63 for the neutron resonant state @xmath95 in @xmath1ca , as a function of the coupling constant @xmath49 , are exhibited in fig .
[ fig-1 ] . filled
circles and crosses are the solutions of the dirac equation [ eq . ( [ dirac - r ] ) ] , and the former is used as input in the accc method .
solid curves are the outcome of @xmath98 pa [ eq .
( [ pade - e ] ) ] .
the dashed vertical line corresponds to the branch point @xmath103 .
when @xmath104 , the particle is bound . with @xmath49 decreasing from @xmath50 down to 1 ,
a nonvanishing imaginary part appears in the complex energy expressed by eq .
( [ e - w ] ) . at @xmath105 ,
one gets the resonance energy @xmath62 and width @xmath63 .
the agreement between the exact solutions of the dirac equation with large coupling constant ( crosses in fig . [ fig-1 ] ) and the extrapolated results of pa ( solid energy curve ) is quite good , which demonstrates the validity of the accc method .
the smooth solid line indicates good analyticity of the eigenvalue for the dirac equation with respect to the coupling constant .
the same results can also be obtained for the case of @xmath106 and @xmath107 pas , similar as in ref .
@xcite . in fig .
[ fig-2 ] , we show the real and imaginary parts of the upper component @xmath108 and the lower component @xmath109 at @xmath110 fm and @xmath111 fm respectively as functions of the resonance energy @xmath62 ( which corresponds to the coupling constant @xmath49 displayed in fig . [ fig-1 ] ) .
symbols in fig .
[ fig-2 ] have the same meaning as those in fig . [ fig-1 ] .
the neutron feels much stronger effect from the nuclear potential at @xmath110 fm than at @xmath111 fm .
similar to the case of the eigenvalue discussed above , the real and the imaginary part of each component behave smoothly , which indicates good analyticity of the eigenfunction for the dirac equation with respect to the coupling constant . the wave function obtained from the analytic continuation is connected continuously to the free wave function at the matching point @xmath92 . on one hand , the matching point @xmath92 should be large enough to make sure that the potential at @xmath92 vanishes , which is required by the outer part of the wave function .
on the other hand , @xmath92 should be far enough from the box radius @xmath45 to guarantee that the inner part of the wave function can be obtained accurately .
in the lower panel of fig .
[ fig-3 ] , the potential @xmath112 for @xmath1ca is plotted .
one finds that when @xmath113 fm , the potential becomes smaller than @xmath114 mev which is good enough for the precision in our calculations .
the upper limit of the matching point @xmath92 can be estimated by the behavior of the density from the upper panel in fig .
[ fig-3 ] .
the neutron density @xmath115 in @xmath1ca and @xmath116/4\pi r^2 $ ] decline rapidly in the vicinity of 20 fm because of the boundary condition in the rmf calculation .
the density curves in the range @xmath117 fm are smooth and behave reasonably .
therefore , the matching point should be chosen at any point between 14 fm and 18 fm .
we present the wave function for the neutron resonant state @xmath95 in @xmath1ca with different matching points in fig .
[ fig-4 ] .
as expected , the wave function is the same when changing the matching point @xmath92 from 14 fm to 18 fm . in the following calculations
, the wave function will be matched at @xmath118 fm , unless otherwise specified .
we apply the accc method within the framework of the rmf theory to calculate the energies , widths and wave functions for the resonant states in @xmath3zr .
since @xmath3zr is the core of the giant neutron halo predicted in rchb calculations @xcite , and the resonant states in @xmath3zr have been obtained by the scattering method @xcite , we choose this nucleus for comparison . in fig .
[ fig-5 ] , the energies and widths for the resonant states @xmath119 , @xmath120 , @xmath121 , @xmath122 , @xmath123 and @xmath124 are presented as a planar @xmath62@xmath63 plot .
the results of the accc and the scattering methods are in good agreement with each other for most of these states . from both methods ,
@xmath125 and @xmath126 have large widths , while @xmath121 and @xmath127 are very narrow .
the width for @xmath119 from the scattering method is slightly larger than our calculation . as for the resonant state @xmath120 ,
neither the energy nor the width can be extracted from the scattering calculation . from a quantum mechanical point of view , these single - particle resonant states are quasi - stationary ones captured by centrifugal barriers . the decay width for a resonant state
can be roughly explained by the penetration through the barrier . for those states with the same @xmath29 , i.e. , the same centrifugal barrier
, the higher state has a larger width , e.g. , for the two @xmath128 states @xmath125 and @xmath121 .
although @xmath123 is higher than @xmath122 , its width is smaller because of higher centrifugal barrier .
a similar argument also holds for a much higher but narrow state @xmath124 .
the wave functions for the resonant states @xmath119 , @xmath129 , @xmath125 and @xmath123 are respectively exhibited in figs .
[ fig-6 ] , [ fig-7 ] , [ fig-8 ] , and [ fig-9 ] .
since the imaginary part of the wave function is neglected in the scattering calculations @xcite , only the real parts of the upper and the lower components are given and compared in these figures . in fig .
[ fig-6 ] , one finds a considerable difference for the upper components at large @xmath28 in @xmath119 between these two methods .
this difference is consistent with the difference in energy and width as seen in fig .
[ fig-5 ] .
a similar difference is also seen for @xmath122 in fig .
[ fig-8 ] . for those states where the two methods give nearly the same energies and widths , e.g. , @xmath129 and @xmath123
, the wave functions agree quite well .
the small difference for the wave functions between these two methods found in figs .
[ fig-7 ] and [ fig-9 ] might be from the neglect of the imaginary part of the wave function in the scattering method .
in summary , the method of the analytic continuation in the coupling constant ( accc ) has been developed within the framework of the relativistic mean field ( rmf ) theory and used to investigate the resonance energies , widths and wave functions for single - particle resonant states in exotic nuclei .
the analyticity of these quantities , as functions of the coupling constant , are exploited for the neutron resonant state @xmath95 in @xmath1ca .
the energies , widths and wave functions for some resonant states in @xmath3zr are calculated and compared with those obtained from the scattering method .
the results from the accc method agrees satisfactorily with those from the scattering calculation as well as available data @xcite .
it is expected that the rmf - accc method , combined with the bcs theory , can be generalized to describe exotic phenomena in unstable nuclei .
this work is partly supported by the major state basic research development program under contract number g2000077407 , the national natural science foundation of china under grant no . 10025522 , and 10221003 , and the doctoral program foundation from the ministry of education in china under grant no .
20030001086 , as well as the national science foundation of south africa under grant
2054166 .
.energies and widths ( @xmath131 in mev for the neutron resonant state @xmath95 in @xmath1ca calculated by the accc ( rmf - accc ) and the scattering ( rmf - s ) method with the effective interactions nl3 , nlsh , pk1 , and tma . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] and width @xmath63 for the neutron resonant state @xmath95 in @xmath1ca , as a function of the coupling constant @xmath49 . filled circles and crosses are the solutions of the dirac equation , and the former is used as input in the accc method .
solid curves are the outcome of @xmath98 pa.,title="fig:",height=264 ] | single - particle resonant states in spherical nuclei are studied by an analytic continuation in the coupling constant ( accc ) method within the framework of the self - consistent relativistic mean field ( rmf ) theory .
taking the neutron resonant state @xmath0 in @xmath1ca as an example , we examine the analyticity of the eigenvalue and eigenfunction for the dirac equation with respect to the coupling constant by means of a @xmath2 approximant of the second kind .
the rmf - accc approach is then applied to @xmath3zr and , for the first time , this approach is employed to investigate both the energies , widths and wave functions for @xmath4 resonant states close to the continuum threshold .
predictions are also compared with corresponding results obtained from the scattering phase shift method . |
for the past two decades , extensive studies of high-@xmath0 cuprates have spotlighted many curious phenomena .
it has been argued that most phenomena are attributable to the strong correlations among electrons , which play significant roles in these materials .
however , since the discovery of sudden changes in the electron dispersion or `` kinks '' shown by the angle - resolved photoemission spectroscopy ( arpes ) , @xcite effects of electron - boson interactions on electronic self - energies have been recognized .
while the kinks are now indisputable in cuprates , @xcite their origin as arising from electronic coupling to phonons @xcite or magnetic excitations @xcite remains unclear .
recent scanning tunneling microscope study showed that the statistical distribution of energy of bosonic modes ( @xmath1 ) has meaningful difference between @xmath2 and @xmath3 materials .
thus , it should be hard to exclude the possibility that electron - phonon interaction ( epi ) significantly affects the electronic states in cuprates . in this study , we investigate the analysis upon the epi together with the electron - electron interaction ( eei ) on the basis of the two - dimensional ( 2d ) three - band hubbard
holstein ( hh ) model . with the use of our three - band hh model
, we can reproduce the situation of the real high-@xmath0 materials , in which epi mainly works on @xmath4 electrons at o sites .
our model hamiltonian @xmath5 is composed of @xmath6 electrons at each cu site , @xmath4 electrons at o site , and lattice vibrations of o atoms .
we consider only the on - site coulomb repulsion @xmath7 between @xmath6 electrons at each cu site as our eei .
let us define that @xmath8 and @xmath9 represent the chemical potential and the number of all electrons , respectively .
then , @xmath10 is divided into the non - interacting part , @xmath11 , the electron - electron interacting part @xmath12 , the phonon part @xmath13 , and the electron - phonon interacting part @xmath14 as @xmath15 here , @xmath16 and @xmath17 are the annihilation ( creation ) operator for @xmath6 and @xmath18 electrons of momentum @xmath19 and spin @xmath20 , respectively .
the non - interacting part @xmath11 is represented by @xmath21 we take the lattice constant of the square lattice formed from cu sites as the unit of length . then , @xmath22 and @xmath23 , where @xmath24 is the transfer energy between a @xmath6 orbital and a neighboring @xmath18 orbital and @xmath25 is that between a @xmath26 orbital and a @xmath27 orbital .
@xmath28 is the difference of energy levels of @xmath6 and @xmath4 orbitals . in this study , we take @xmath24 as the unit of energy .
the residual parts are described as follows : @xmath29 @xmath30 and @xmath31 where @xmath7 is the on - site coulomb repulsion between @xmath6 orbitals , @xmath32 is the number of @xmath19-space lattice points in the first brillouin zone ( fbz ) , and @xmath33 is the electron - phonon matrix element , respectively .
we consider that the half - breathing phonon mode , @xcite in which oxygen ions are vibrating along the @xmath34 or @xmath35 directions , is crucial for our problem .
thus , ignoring the other phonon modes , we have the electron - phonon interacting part as eq .
( [ eq:8 ] ) .
then , we introduced the unperturbed and perturbed green s functions , which are to be described in @xmath36 matrix form .
the unperturbed green s function @xmath37 is derived from eq .
( [ eq:6 ] ) as @xmath38^{-1},\ ] ] where @xmath39 is a @xmath36 unit matrix . using the abbreviation of fermion matsubara frequencies , @xmath40 with integer @xmath41 and temperature @xmath42 ,
the perturbed green function @xmath43 is determined by the dyson equation : @xmath44 where @xmath45 is the self - energy expected to be a diagonal matrix . in order to estimate the @xmath6 electron self - energy @xmath46 in eq .
( [ eq:1 ] ) , we adopt the fluctuation exchange approximation @xcite as follows : @xmath47 where @xmath48 , @xmath49 where @xmath50 with integer @xmath51 are boson matsubara frequencies , and @xmath52 in order to estimate the p@xmath53-electron self - energy @xmath54 in eq .
( [ eq:1 ] ) , we exploit the brillouin - wigner perturbation theory .
we adopt the self - consistent one - loop approximation as follows : @xmath55 where @xmath56 and @xmath57 is the epi on p@xmath53 electron .
our epi is determined as follows : @xmath58 , \label{eq:9}\ ] ] where @xmath59 and @xmath60 .
@xmath61 is the specific phonon energy for the half - breathing mode .
as above , we ignore the effects in which eei and epi are coupled .
thus , as shown by eqs .
( [ eq:2])-([eq:9 ] ) , in our formulation , eei and epi are completely decoupled .
of course , this assumption is inadequate to analyze the case in which the characteristic energy due to eei is comparable to the phonon energy .
however , as will be seen later , we actually treat the cases with rather high characteristic energy due to eei .
hence , decoupling eei with epi should be justified in our analysis .
the electron - phonon coupling constant @xmath62 does not depend on @xmath63 since @xmath64 and @xmath65 , where @xmath63 is the mass of an oxygen ion . in our model , thus , the isotope effect is reflected on the phonon energy in the electronic self - energies only , but not any changes in the strength .
we need to solve eqs .
( [ eq:1])([eq:3 ] ) in a fully self - consistent manner . during numerical calculations ,
we divide the fbz into @xmath66 meshes .
we prepare @xmath67 matsubara frequencies for temperature @xmath68 .
as shown later , at this temperature , our calculation can reproduce the important behavior of electrons in normal state .
moreover , to our knowledge , the situation will not be changed if we change @xmath42 to some extent .
@xmath69 and @xmath70 , which are all common for our calculations .
these values are chosen so that we can reproduce the typical fermi surface of bi@xmath71sr@xmath71cacu@xmath71o@xmath72 observed by arpes .
@xcite @xmath73 , @xmath74 , and @xmath75 unless stated .
the phonon energy is set as @xmath76 for @xmath77 material .
.[table:1]number of doped holes
. @xmath78 . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] fermi surfaces for @xmath2 materials indicated in table [ table:1].,width=196 ] dispersion kinks along the nodal direction .
momentum is measured from each fermi surface .
arrows indicate the momenta at which kinks occur.,width=317 ] doping dependence of kink energies .
bars indicate the discretization error during analytic continuation.,width=317 ] dispersion kinks along the nodal direction for @xmath79 .
the number of doped holes for @xmath77 material is @xmath80 .
the dashed lines show the ones for op in table [ table:1].,width=317 ] dispersion kinks along the nodal direction for @xmath81 .
the number of doped holes for @xmath77 material is @xmath82 .
the dashed lines show the ones for op in table [ table:1].,width=317 ] @xmath83 on @xmath84 , where @xmath85 for ( a ) , @xmath86 for ( b ) , @xmath87 for ( c ) , and @xmath88 for ( d ) , respectively.,width=317 ] @xmath89 on the same @xmath90 points as in fig .
[ figure:4].,width=317 ] dispersion kinks along the nodal direction for @xmath91 and @xmath92 .
they all correspond to op .
momentum is measured from the fermi surface for @xmath93.,width=317 ] we show the numbers of doped holes for our fully self - consistent solutions in table [ table:1 ] .
the numbers of doped holes both for @xmath2 and @xmath3 materials are exactly the same to three places of decimals and they correspond to four different hole - doped samples , lightly doped ( ld ) , underdoped ( ud ) , optimally doped ( op ) , and overdoped ( od ) , respectively . in fig .
[ figure:1 ] , we show the color map of the one - particle spectrum at fermi level @xmath94 , where @xmath95 in order to indicate the fermi surfaces for @xmath2 materials . in eq .
( [ eq:4 ] ) , the pad@xmath96 approximation is exploited for analytic continuation . furthermore , we calculate the electronic dispersions of the antibonding band @xmath97 along the nodal direction indicated as the cut in fig .
[ figure:1 ] for all our doping cases .
@xmath97 is determined as the @xmath98 point on which @xmath99 has the maximum value at each energy level .
due to this method , the curves of @xmath97 look like a series of line segments , as shown in fig . [ figure:2 ] .
we compare every @xmath97 of our solution with the one obtained by another fully self - consistent manner , in which the same calculation is performed , except for the epi .
we show our results on these dispersions in fig .
[ figure:2 ] , where we can easily recognize that the dispersion kinks along the nodal direction appear only when epi affects the @xmath18 electrons .
the kink energies were slightly shifted by @xmath100 substitution . in fig .
[ figure:3 ] , we detail how these kink energies shift depending on hole doping .
these theoretically evaluated isotope shifts are at most @xmath101 , which are much smaller than the ones measured by another group s arpes experiment .
@xcite furthermore , these isotope shifts are almost independent of hole doping while another group insists that they are critically affected .
@xcite considering the energy and momentum resolutions in their experiment , it may be hard to detect the subtle isotope shifts and their dependence on hole doping shown in our model .
let us now look at @xmath62 and @xmath28 dependences in the dispersion kinks along the nodal direction in detail .
figure [ figure:4 ] shows the energy dispersions for @xmath75 ( dotted lines ) and @xmath79 ( solid lines ) . there is no clear difference in the isotope effect between @xmath79 ( @xmath102 ) and @xmath75 ( @xmath103 ) , though the dispersion kinks for @xmath79 are distinctly shifted to the high binding energy compared with those for @xmath75 .
on the other hand , the isotope shift for @xmath81 ( @xmath104 ) is slightly shrank compared to that for @xmath105 ( @xmath102 ) , though the dispersions depend on the @xmath28 considerably , as shown in fig .
[ figure:5 ] .
hence , our model calculation shows that the isotope shifts are not sensitive to @xmath62 and @xmath28 .
considering that @xmath28 is closely related with eei in our three band hh model as discussed later , we can be fairly certain that the isotope shifts are determined by the relative strength between epi and eei .
however , these changes of the isotope shifts are minute , thus , our discussions so far are valid regardless of @xmath62 and @xmath28 . to clarify the epi effect on the @xmath18 electrons described above , we investigate the @xmath4 electron self - energy @xmath106 along the nodal direction .
in fig . [ figure:6 ] , we show @xmath83 on every six @xmath98 points along the nodal direction , located inside fermi surfaces .
the energy where @xmath83 is maximal corresponds to the one of the dispersion kink and shifts upward by @xmath100 substitution , as shown in fig .
[ figure:2 ] .
the energy dependence of @xmath83 is definitely due to the epi introduced with the use of eqs .
( [ eq:1 ] ) , ( [ eq:3 ] ) , and ( [ eq:9 ] ) .
thus , we can conclude that in our solutions for all doping levels from the ud to the od region , the dispersion kinks along the nodal direction are created _ only when the epi is included_. hereafter , we will discuss why the magnetic ingredients hardly bring the dispersion kinks along the nodal direction .
even when epi does not exist , the electrons in our results are exposed to the strong af fluctuation originating from the electronic correlation among @xmath6 electrons . in fig .
[ figure:7 ] , we show @xmath89 on the same six @xmath98 points as in fig . [ figure:6 ] .
it is shown that there is no clear difference in @xmath89 between @xmath2 and @xmath3 materials .
the energy dependence of @xmath89 is definitely due to the electronic correlation introduced with the use of eqs .
( [ eq:2])([eq:7 ] ) .
we easily recognize that @xmath89 uniformly increases with the binding energy and has no maximal value up to @xmath107 even for ld case , in which the strong af fluctuation is expected to be grown .
thus , along the nodal direction , the strong af fluctuation could cause the renormalization of the fermi velocity , however , it hardly promotes any anomalous behavior such as kink structure . finally , we will discuss how our eei affects the dispersion for @xmath2 materials . when the on - site coulomb repulsion @xmath7 is changed , the fermi velocity is renormalized differently , but this would not change the kink energy so much since the kink energy is determined by the epi alone .
[ figure:8 ] , we lay out our results for three different @xmath7s and they all correspond to op .
their total doped holes @xmath108 are slightly different as : @xmath109 and @xmath110 for @xmath111 and @xmath92 , respectively .
hence , the fermi momentum for @xmath112 moves inside ( or the fermi surface shrinks ) and the one for @xmath113 moves outside ( or the fermi surface enlarges ) , compared to the one for @xmath93 .
these changes of the fermi momenta are small ; however , the dispersions at higher energy are quite affected , reflecting the binding energy dependence of @xmath89 , as shown in fig .
[ figure:7 ] .
therefore , the dispersion at higher energy could be changed a lot by the eei even if the fermi velocities are almost independent of them .
by the analysis of our model , we can show that the dispersion kink along the nodal direction occurs due to epi .
the isotope effect upon the electronic dispersion is shown near the kink of energy dispersion , not in the high binding energy portions .
@xcite our evaluation of the subtle isotope shifts has been backed by the report of the recent arpes experiments @xcite which show the lack of the unusual isotope effect in the high energy portion .
@xcite fortunately for us , our scenario was possibly realized in further arpes experiment .
@xcite in addition to that , we have investigated how eei effects on the nodal dispersion .
it can hardly affect the kink and the nodal fermi velocity ; however , it can change the dispersion at higher energy .
hence , epi and eei play different roles on the nodal energy dispersion , respectively . of course
, our treatment of eei is just suited for _ weak coupling regime _ , and all of our parameter sets employed might be far from the ones for _ strong coupling regime_. if we investigate _ strong coupling regime _ with the use of another approach , the low energy structure corresponding to the superexchange @xmath114 could appear in the dispersion .
however , our results presented here suggest that the structure should appear as a broad peak at higher energy due to the frequency dependence of the strong af fluctuation , which will grow into @xmath114 . as we all know
, other works have already derive qualitatively similar conclusions on the basis of other models .
some groups adopt @xmath115-@xmath114 models @xcite and other groups do one - band hh models .
@xcite furthermore , other groups have succeeded in explaining the arpes results .
@xcite however , in our 2d three - band hh model , both the electron - electron interaction among the @xmath6 electrons and the epi on @xmath4 electrons are considered according to high-@xmath0 materials .
we believe that it is important that quantitatively consistent results with the arpes experiments can be reproduced from such a model .
the advantage will be when our analysis extends to the superconducting state , in which the @xmath4 electrons play important roles as well as @xmath6 electrons .
the authors are grateful to h. iwasawa and t. yanagisawa for their stimulating discussions .
the computation in this work was performed on intel xeon servers at neri in aist .
a. lanzara , p. v. bogdanov , x. j. zhou , s. a. kellar , d. l. feng , e. d. lu , t. yoshida , h. eisaki , a. fujimori , k. kishio , j .-
shimoyama , t. noda , s. uchida , z. hussain , and z .- x .
shen , nature ( london ) * 412 * , 510 ( 2001 ) .
x. j. zhou , t. yoshida , a. lanzara , p. v. bogdanov , s. a. kellar , k. m. shen , w. l. yang , e. ronning , t. sasagawa , t. kakeshita , t. noda , h. eisaki , s. uchida , c. t. lin , f. zhou , j. w. xiong , w. x. ti , z. x. zhao , a. fujimori , z. hussain , and z .- x .
shen , nature ( london ) * 423 * , 398 ( 2003 ) .
d. l. feng , n. p. armitage , d. h. lu , a. damascelli , j. p. hu , p. bogdanov , a. lanzara , f. ronning , k. m. shen , h. eisaki , c. kim , j .-
shimoyama , k. kishio , and z .- x .
shen , phys .
lett . * 86 * , 5550 ( 2001 ) .
j. f. douglas , h. iwasawa , z. sun , a. v. fedorov , m. ishikado , t. saitoh , h. eisaki , h. bando , t. iwase , a. ino , m. arita , k. shimada , h. namatame , m. taniguchi , t. masui , s. tajima , k. fujita , s. uchida , y. aiura , and d. s. dessau , nature ( london ) * 446 * , e5 ( 2007 ) .
h. iwasawa , y. aiura , t. saitoh , h. eisaki , h. bando , a. ino , m. arita , k. shimada , h. namatame , m. taniguchi , t. masui , s. tajima , m. ishikado , k. fujita , s. uchida , j. f. douglas , z. sun , and d. s. dessau , physica c * 463 - 465 * , 52 ( 2007 ) .
h. iwasawa , j. f. douglas , k. sato , t. masui , y. yoshida , z. sun , h. eisaki , h. bando , a. ino , m. arita , k. shimada , h. namatame , m. taniguchi , s. tajima , s. uchida , t. saitoh , d. s. dessau , and y. aiura ( unpublished ) .
w. meevasana , n. j. c. ingle , d. h. lu , j. r. shi , f. baumberger , k. m. shen , w. s. lee , t. cuk , h. eisaki , t. p. devereaux , n. nagaosa , j. zaanen , and z .- x .
shen , phys .
lett . * 96 * , 157003 ( 2006 ) . | we investigate the electronic dispersion of high-@xmath0 superconductor on the basis of the two - dimensional three - band hubbard model with the electron - phonon interaction together with the strong electron - electron interaction . in our model
, it is shown across the hole - doped region of high-@xmath0 superconductor that the electron - phonon interaction makes a dispersion kink , observed along the nodal direction , and that the small isotope effect appears on the electronic dispersion . |
most stars are born in stellar clusters , which in turn form from dense cores in giant molecular clouds ( gmcs ) . at least for massive clusters ( @xmath4 ) , it is known that they are highly dynamical structures and follow well - defined evolutionary tracks , depending on their initial mass and size @xcite . at very young ages
they are still embedded in their natal gas ; the duration of this embedded phase is thought to last between @xmath5 for clusters in the solar neighbourhood @xcite .
comparing the gas and stellar content in nearby star forming regions , observations find that the fraction of gas in a gmc which is turned into stars ( referred to as star formation efficiency - sfe ) lies in the range of @xcite .
similarly , simulations that model the expansion history of massive clusters in the solar neighbourhood find that the sfe of these clusters must have been of the order @xmath6 @xcite . in comparison , the sfe for an entire molecular clouds is much lower , only of the order of just a few per cent at most ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
at the end of the star formation process the remaining gas is expelled through various mechanisms such as , for example , the explosion of a supernova @xcite , bipolar stellar outflows @xcite , or stellar winds of the most massive stars @xcite .
it is expected that ultimately supernovae will remove any remaining gas from the cluster , but probably other processes like wind are more important , as clusters are already found to be gas poor at 1 - 3 myr , whereas even supernova with @xmath7 need already @xmath8 myr until they explode .
the gas expulsion itself is thought to happen on time scales smaller than or of the order of the dynamical times of the cluster @xcite .
gas expulsion is supposed to happen earlier in massive than in low - mass clusters due to the larger number of high mass stars .
the gas expulsion leaves the clusters in a supervirial state and they react by expanding with a simultaneous loss of a considerable portion of their members .
the cluster dynamics after gas expulsion investigated thoroughly in the past ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . within the clusters their members interact with each other , influencing already formed protoplanetary discs .
processes like external photoevaporation @xcite , viscous torques @xcite , turbulent effects @xcite , and magnetic fields @xcite are capable of reducing the discs in size , mass and/or angular momentum .
however , here we concentrate on the effect of the gravitational forces acting during close stellar fly - bys shape the discs resulting in loss of angular momentum ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) and/or mass ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
ideally one would simulate the entire cluster with each of the stars surrounded by a disc using smoothed particle hydrodynamics methods . in this case
effects like viscous spreading of the discs and multiple fly - bys would all treated in a self - consistent way .
still , even with modern supercomputers this is extremely challenging .
@xcite performed a direct theoretical investigation of disc sizes in clusters by combining n - body simulations of a low - mass cluster ( 100 stars ) with smoothed particle hydrodynamics ( sph ) simulations of protoplanetary discs and determined the disc sizes .
even for such a low - mass cluster he could only model the first @xmath9 of the development and had to make the artificial assumption of the stars to be of equal mass due to computational constraints .
thus , for the time being direct modelling of massive clusters and even more so a parameter study for those is completely out of the question .
therefore the standard procedure is a two step approach : first , simulations of the cluster dynamics are performed where the fly - by history of each star is recorded and , second , results from parameter studies are used to post - process the data and determine the effect on the discs ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
these studies concentrated on the disc frequency , average disc mass and angular momentum in the embedded phase of the cluster . however , non of these studies considered the gas content as such or the effect that the gas expulsion process has on the cluster dynamics . here
we want to concentrate instead on the disc size , because ( a ) it is the most sensitive indicator for the cluster influence @xcite , ( b ) with the advent of alma a direct comparison with observation is possible , and ( c ) it gives limits on the sizes of the potentially forming planetary systems that can be compared to exoplanetary systems .
there have been a few studies that investigated the influence of fly - bys on the disc size . however , they were usually based on the results from parameter studies of fly - bys between equal - mass stars @xcite .
a real cluster contains a wide spectrum of masses and therefore equal - mass fly - bys are the exception rather than the rule @xcite .
others proposed to convert the disc - mass criterion of @xcite directly into a disc size @xcite .
nevertheless,@xcite showed that this approach is error prone and devised a relation for the disc size after an fly - by which is valid over a large range of mass ratios between the star and the perturber .
@xcite , in the following referred to as vbp15 , used this more appropriate description of the effect of fly - bys on the disc size to perform study on embedded clusters of different mass and stellar density .
they found that fly - bys in the embedded phase are capable of reducing discs to sizes well below @xmath10 and that the median disc size strongly depends on the stellar density .
however , they again as all previous studies did not take into account the presence of the gas in the embedded phase and the effect of gas expulsion on the cluster dynamics .
in contrast to previous studies , we include here the effect of the gas on the cluster dynamics and model all the evolutionary stages of the clusters self - consistently - the embedded phase , the gas expulsion , and the expansion phase .
we quantify the differences between the fly - by history in the embedded phase and the expansion phase .
more importantly , we will demonstrate how the differences in cluster dynamics and time scales influence the fly - by dynamics and the final disc - size distribution in dense and sparse clusters .
the cluster simulations are performed using the code nbody6++ @xcite .
we model clusters of different mass , which is realised by performing simulations of clusters with different numbers of stars : , , , , , and @xmath11 ( e52 , e51 ) . however , the initial size of the clusters is kept fixed at a half - mass radius of @xmath12 which allows to study clusters of different density .
clusters depicted e.g. in @xcite usually have somewhat smaller radii ( @xmath13 pc ) as they still form stars .
there are strong indications that clusters sizes increase with age during the star formation process and are typically about 1 - 2 pc by the time star formation is finished @xcite .
currently it is not clear to which extent massive clusters are subject to substructure .
any potentially existing substructure is quickly erased in the star formation phase @xcite , at the latest the gas expulsion will eliminate any left - over substructure in the presented extended clusters . for simplicity , we assume here an initial stellar number density distribution according to a relaxed , smooth king distribution @xcite with a flat core which is representative for the orion nebula cluster ( onc ) which is just at the onset of gas expulsion and one of the best studied massive clusters in the solar neighbourhood . a detailed description of the density distribution , including an illustration of the initial density distribution as a function of the cluster radius ( their fig . 1 ) ,
can be found in @xcite .
any potentially existing substructure would make close encounters more common , so that the here presented results can be regarded as lower limits for the importance of the cluster environment on the protoplanetary discs .
in contrast to vbp15 and most previous work here we take into account the potential of the gas component , too .
the total mass of the system @xmath14 is with @xmath15 being the stellar component of the cluster , therefore , the gas mass is given by @xmath16 where sfe is the star formation efficiency which is assumed to be @xmath6 .
various studies have shown that such sfes are characteristic for massive clusters like , etc . in the solar neighbourhood ( for example * ? ? ?
the stars are initially still embedded in the remaining gas .
note that the gas density profile was chosen to be of plummer form @xcite with a half - mass radius similar to that of the stellar profile ( @xmath17 ) , because king gas profiles lead to numerical difficulties . apart from @xcite , all previous studies of this kind did not include the gas component , including it here basically results in a different velocity dispersion compared to the gas - free case .
it is assumed that the cluster is initially in virial equilibrium .
the stellar velocities and the individual stellar masses are sampled randomly , the former from a maxwellian distribution , the latter from the imf by @xcite with a lower stellar mass limit of @xmath18 and an upper mass limit of @xmath19 .
the embedded phase of clusters is thought to last between 1 - 3 myr @xcite .
accordingly , we simulated clusters with an embedded phase lasting , but also performed an additional set of simulations for the densest cluster with ( model e51 ) .
this allows us also to study how the length of the embedded phase influences the final distribution of protoplanetary disc sizes . for a more detailed summary of the set - up parameters
in contrast to previous work , we take into account that the gas expulsion process typically happens after @xmath5 .
the gas expulsion itself happens on short time scales , typically smaller than or of the order of several dynamical times @xmath20 of the cluster @xcite which is given by @xmath21 the dynamical time scales for the cluster models e0-e52 are very short , between @xmath22 , see column 7 of table [ tab : set - up_params ] .
therefore , and for better comparability of our cluster models , we assume the gas expulsion process in all clusters to be instantaneous . this immediate removal of the gas mass after leaves the cluster in a supervirial state , so that the cluster expands in order to regain virial equilibrium .
we will discuss the consequences of such an instantaneous gas - expulsion on the results compared to a longer expulsion time scale in .
we follow the cluster expansion until 10 myr have passed since the cluster was fully formed .
+ in each simulation , the fly - by history for each individual star was tracked and the fly - by properties recorded .
for each cluster model , a campaign of simulations with different random seeds was performed in order to improve statistics and minimise the effect of the initial individual set up of a cluster on the results .
the number of simulations for each set - up is given in column 3 of table [ tab : set - up_params ] .
ideally one would start out the simulation with an observed primordial disc size .
however , observationally it is challenging to measure disc sizes directly especially in embedded clusters .
in contrast to the disc fraction , disc size measurements are usually performed in ( nearly ) exposed clusters which have expelled most of their gas . for the
best observed stellar cluster in the solar neighbourhood , the onc , disc radii in the range from @xmath23 up to @xmath24 were found by several surveys @xcite .
however , the onc is already 1 myr old .
whether these measurements are representative for the primordial disc - size distribution or whether photoevaporation or fly - by processes have already altered the sizes remains unclear .
in other clusters disc sizes up to several thousand au have been reported .
therefore , there is no information about a typical initial disc size or a disc - size distribution in embedded stellar clusters .
for this reason , and for simplicity , all discs in a cluster are set up with the same initial size @xmath25 , ignoring any possible dependency of the disc size on the host mass ( cf .
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
we performed a numerical experiment , setting the initial disc size to a very large value of .
the interpretation of this large initial disc size will be discussed in and . in our simulations
we determine the size of the protoplanetary discs around the cluster members after each stellar fly - by using the equation @xmath26 given by @xcite , where @xmath27 is the mass ratio between the disc - hosting star ( @xmath28 ) and the perturber ( @xmath29 ) , @xmath30 the periastron distance in au , and @xmath31 the disc size previous to the fly - by in au .
this equation is valid for coplanar , prograde , parabolic fly - bys .
this type of fly - by is more destructive than inclined , retrograde or hyperbolic fly - bys @xcite .
however , the effect of inclined , retrograde and hyperbolic fly - bys is much less investigated .
first results by @xcite indicate that non - coplanar encounters have nevertheless a considerable effect on the disc size .
thus , the here presented result has to be regarded as lower limit of disc size , but will not be considerably smaller than it would be in the inclined case .
viscous forces , which might lead to disc spreading @xcite , and self - gravity between the disc particles are neglected in this model because the discs are set up containing only mass - less tracer particles .
every star in the cluster was surrounded by such a mass - less disc , therefore , each fly - by event is actually a disc - disc fly - by .
capturing of material from the disc of the passing star is disregarded in our approach as well .
the formula above only holds for star - disc fly - bys , where only the primary hosts a disc .
nevertheless , @xcite found that a generalisation of disc - disc fly - bys to star - disc fly - bys is valid as long as the discs have a low mass and not much mass is transferred between the two . for a more detailed description of the disc - size determination , its approximations , and the resulting influence on the results , see , @xcite . at the end of the diagnostic step the resulting fly - by and disc - size statistics are averaged over all simulations within one simulation campaign .
before presenting the results , we want to elucidate some definitions used in the following .
we use the term `` fly - by '' in our study for gravitational interactions between two stars which a ) reduce the disc size by at least @xmath32 ( @xmath33 ) . the term `` strongest fly - by '' or `` disc - size defining fly - by '' describes the fly - by with the strongest influence on the disc in the whole simulation - or for certain periods of cluster evolution . note that as equation [ eq : breslau_disc_size ] takes into account the mass ratio of the perturber and the host star , the strongest fly - by is not necessarily the closest one .
the cluster evolution , namely the same mass and radius development - confirm previous work .
however , here we have a closer look at the density evolution because this determines the here investigated fly - by history .
our simulations show that , as long as the clusters remain embedded in their natal gas ( , for model e51 ) , the stellar mass density basically stays constant ( see ) .
when the gas is expelled instantaneously at , the clusters respond to the now supervirial state by expanding leading to a significant drop in the stellar density .
the more massive clusters regain their virial equilibrium much faster than the less massive clusters @xcite due to their shorter dynamical time scales , see table [ tab : set - up_params ] . as a result their stellar density declines faster than in the lower - mass clusters - the density in the most massive cluster ( triangles and asterisks ) drops to @xmath34 of its initial value already after gas expulsion , whereas low mass clusters need up to after gas expulsion for such a decline . note that around the cluster models e0 , e2 , and e52 are indistinguishable in terms of their stellar mass density within @xmath17 , while having a very different density history . + naturally , the total number of fly - bys increases with cluster density which in our case is equivalent to the cluster mass . in the least dense cluster
roughly @xmath35 fly - bys that change the disc size take place during the @xmath36 simulated here whereas in the densest cluster model the number of fly - bys is approximately @xmath37 ( see ) . however , this increase is by far not as much as one would expect from a roughly 32 times higher density of models e51 and e52 in the embedded phase ( see ) .
the reason is that we only consider fly - bys that lead to a smaller disc size than previous to the fly - by , see sect .
[ sec : method ] . for the dense clusters
the disc sizes are reduced very quickly to very small sizes so that even closer disc - size changing fly - bys are rare at later times .
similarly , the number of fly - bys per star increases with cluster density . in model e0 each star undergoes on average a little more than one disc - size changing fly - by as defined above , whereas in model e52 its between four and five .
although the difference in density ( within the half - mass radius ) between these two models is almost a factor of 100 , the average number of fly - bys increases almost linearly by a factor of four due to the criterion mentioned above .
this is also reflected in the temporal development of the number of disc - size changing fly - bys .
depicts the fly - by history in the different cluster models .
it shows the cumulative fraction of fly - bys as a function of time , where the vertical lines mark the time of gas expulsion ( @xmath38 for model e51 , dotted blue , @xmath39 all other models , solid black ) .
the steeper slopes for the most massive clusters indicate that the discs are processed faster .
for example , more than @xmath40 of all disc - size reducing fly - bys in occur within the first whereas in it takes four times as long for the same portion of fly - bys to happen .
as to be expected , the majority of fly - bys happens in the dense embedded phase .
however , there are differences between the different cluster types , see . whereas in the most massive clusters disc - size changes happen nearly exclusively ( @xmath41 ) in the embedded phase ( black ) - and most even within the first few 100,000 years - in the least dense clusters only @xmath42 of all disc size changes occur in this phase .
the reason is that in the latter case the density decreases more slowly so that a higher fraction of about one seventh of disc - size reducing fly - bys happen in the expansion phase ( grey ) .
obviously the length of the embedded phase plays an important role . in ,
the gas is expelled after @xmath38 , whereas for the gas expulsion happens after @xmath39 . the earlier drop in cluster mass density in results in the total number of fly - bys in being roughly @xmath43 larger than in (
@xmath44 compared to @xmath45 ) .
again the reason why the number of fly - bys does not double for a twice as long embedded phase is that most of the discs have been reduced to a small disc size during the first myr and therefore the cross section for a disc - size changing fly - by has been reduced .
this means the early embedded phases largely determine the disc sizes .
+ the distinct clusters have very different influence on their protoplanetary discs , reflected for example in the overall median disc size ( ) .
this median disc size is about thirteen times smaller in ( @xmath11 stars ) than in ( @xmath46 stars ) as not only the number of fly - bys increases significantly with cluster density , but they are on average also closer or the mass ratio is higher . for the densest clusters most fly - bys happen at the beginning of the embedded phase , thus , the median disc sizes are nearly the same at the end of the embedded phase and at the end of the simulations .
however , for the median disc size is significantly larger at the end of the embedded phase ( @xmath39 ) than at the end of the simulations as roughly one seventh of the close fly - bys occur in the expansion phase . + it is important to note that we do not expect real discs to be generally as large as nearly @xmath47 .
the median disc size here only reflects the degree of the environment s influence on the discs .
for example , as long as the discs are initially @xmath48 , they are reduced in size in the densest cluster model .
by contrast , in the onc model only discs that are initially larger than @xmath24 are affected .
a real initial disc size distribution would be necessary to further constrain this , for a more detailed discussion see sect .
[ sec : discussion ] .
what does the spatial disc size distribution at the end of embedded phase look like ?
shows the median disc size as a function of the distance to the cluster centre of the stars for different cluster models at @xmath49 ( open black symbols ) . in the inner part of the onc - like cluster ( e2 ) for example , within a sphere of the initial half - mass radius ( @xmath17 ) the median disc sizes are considerably smaller than for the clusters outskirts .
the difference is even larger when one compares the extremes - the median disc size rises from @xmath50 at @xmath51 to @xmath52 at @xmath53 .
this is due to the higher density in the cluster core and the resulting higher fly - by frequency .
these trends have already been seen in simulations where the gas content was neglected ( vbp15 ) , however , there are quantitative differences .
compares the median disc size as a function of the distance to the cluster centre after @xmath39 of simulation time for the onc cluster model ( e2 ) obtained in vbp15 ( open squares ) and in this work ( circles ) . including the gas mass explicitly leads to a higher velocity dispersion in the embedded phase and thus stronger encounters .
therefore , the median disc sizes presented in this work are much smaller than in vbp15 . for example , at the rim of the cluster core ( 0.3 pc ) the median disc size in the work here is more than a factor of four smaller than in vbp15 ( @xmath54 compared to @xmath55 ) . at a distance of 1 pc the situation is even more extreme , as in our work the median disc size is roughly @xmath56 whereas in vbp15 more than half of the discs are not influenced at all and still retain their initial size . if we consider the first @xmath36 of cluster evolution , which includes
the embedded , gas - expulsion , and expansion phase ( black symbols in ) , in general , the denser the cluster is , the smaller the median disc size remains .
nonetheless , after @xmath36 the median disc size is nearly constant ( at least for models e2 and e52 ) within @xmath57 from the cluster centre .
this is not so much due to mixing , but basically mostly caused by the expansion of the cluster - the value of the median disc size in the cluster outskirts is now similar to that in the centre at the end of gas expulsion ( @xmath39 ) . while during the embedded phase most stars do not move significantly in radial directions and the dependence of the median disc size on the distance to the cluster centre
is preserved , after gas expulsion only about @xmath34 of stars remain bound to the cluster and the rest leaves the cluster very quickly @xcite .
the still bound stars largely move to positions more distant from the cluster centre than they were originally . that is the reason why the median disc size throughout the cluster in the expansion phase is similar to the median disc size in the inner cluster region shortly before gas expulsion .
this means that when older clusters are observed they work like a microscope showing us the central area of enlarged versions of younger clusters .
+ if observations of older clusters work like a microscope , what would an observed disc - size distribution in a cluster at different ages look like ? to answer this question , we investigate the onc - model cluster ( e2 ) at different ages with an artificial fixed field of view ( fov ) to mimic observations .
note that the fov for observations are usually squares whereas here we present spheres with a radius of @xmath58 , centred on the cluster origin . shows the resulting disc - size statistics for an onc - like cluster at @xmath38 ( white ) , @xmath39 ( grey ) , and @xmath36 ( black ) .
the total number of small discs increases much stronger than the number of discs with sizes of several hundreds of au .
the reason is that in the embedded phase discs which are already influenced but still a few hundreds of au large still reduced in size by follow - up encounters . in comparison ,
the shape of the disc - size distribution barely changes between the end of the embedded phase and the end of the simulations
. observations usually study only the central areas of a cluster , because their the stellar density of cluster members is so high that member identification is relatively easy - basically the rate of false - positives is very low . however , this concentration on the cluster centre is problematic , especially so for clusters after gas expulsion , which span large areas .
taking our results as a guideline the observed median disc size in an onc - like cluster @xmath36 after cluster formation , for example , would be in the cluster core @xmath59 whereas the overall median disc size is more than nine times as large ( @xmath60 , dotted horizontal line in figure [ fig : mean_disc_size_vs_cluster ] ) .
choosing initially artificially large discs of @xmath61 has the advantage that the obtained results can be applied any smaller , real disc size .
thus , figure [ fig : mean_disc_size_vs_distance_to_cluster_center_vs_initial_disc_size ] , tells us , for example , that if all stars had an initial disc size of , about half the stars had their discs severely truncated by fly - bys to disc sizes below @xmath62 .
an initial disc size of more than @xmath62 is a realistic scenario as surveys found discs in the onc with radii of @xmath63 @xcite .
note , that at an age of approximately @xmath38 even those might already have been reduced in size through photoevaporation and/or fly - bys . in the case of more massive clusters like ngc 6611
there are more and closer interactions , so that independent of the initial disc size ( as long as @xmath64 ) the resulting median disc is @xmath65 , see fig .
[ fig : mean_disc_size_vs_cluster ] .
+ in summary , observed disc sizes or disc - size distributions in massive clusters are a strong function of the cluster age , its evolutionary stage , its initial conditions , and the fov of the instrument .
one has to act with caution when comparing and interpreting such results .
the above described simulations required some approximations , which we discuss in the following .
in this study we neglect potentially existing initial substructuring of the clusters . in clusters with low velocity dispersions
the substructure will be erased quickly ( see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
most probably , substructure will be erased at the end of star formation @xcite , which is when our simulations start .
the cluster models were set up without primordial mass segregation .
many clusters show signs of mass segregation , but it is unclear whether this property is primordial or if dynamical evolution caused the observed mass segregation . if we included primordial mass segregation , the most massive stars would reside in the cluster core where the density is highest .
therefore , they would undergo more fly - bys , leading in turn to smaller discs around these stars .
furthermore , stronger gravitational focussing would lead to an increase in the overall fly - by frequency in the cluster centre and thus smaller discs .
all stars in the clusters were set up to be initially single excluding primordial binaries .
observations show that the multiplicity , that is the fraction of binaries , triples or systems of higher order , increases with stellar mass ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) .
the most massive stars would most probably be part of a binary then , losing their own disc quite quickly or not even forming one depending on the separation .
additionally , the gravitational focussing in the cluster due to multiple systems would be stronger than for a single , massive star , leading to an increase in the fly - by frequency and overall smaller discs .
one major difference to previous work is that we studied different evolutionary stages starting with the embedded phase , continuing with the gas expulsion , and the following expansion phase . due to the uncertainty in the age determination of clusters ,
the duration of the embedded phase is not well constrained by observations .
here we modelled the duration of the embedded phase as @xmath39 .
however , for the most massive clusters this is probably too long , as at that age massive clusters are already largely devoid of gas .
as most of the disc - size reducing fly - bys occur during the early stages of the embedded phase , with only @xmath66 of fly - bys happening in the second half of the embedded phase for the most massive clusters , our results should be not very sensitive to the assumed duration of the embedded phase .
the assumption of instantaneous gas expulsion is most likely justified for the most massive clusters in our investigation ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . nevertheless , for the lowest mass clusters this is less certain
. in this case a `` slow '' gas expulsion lasting several million years would give the cluster more time to adjust to the gas - mass loss and fewer stars would become unbound .
furthermore , the stellar density would remain higher for a longer time span , allowing the stars to undergo more fly - bys and resulting in smaller discs than in the presented results .
the influence of only the embedded phase was studied in vbp15 . comparing this to our current work , we find that the duration of the embedded phase e.g. for the lowest density cluster is strong . at the end of the embedded phase in vbp15 - lasting unrealistically @xmath67 -
the mean disc size is roughly @xmath68 inside @xmath69 , compared to @xmath70 ) for the here adopted @xmath39 long embedded phase .
if the gas was expelled slowly , a more realistic median disc size would lie between these two extremes .
further studies with an implicitly modelled gas - expulsion of a few myr are necessary to constrain this rough estimate .
+ here all fly - bys were assumed to be prograde , coplanar , and parabolic .
those fly - bys have a stronger effect on the discs than their retrograde , inclined counterparts @xcite .
however , @xcite found that for fly - bys with inclinations of @xmath71 the final disc properties do not differ much from the prograde coplanar case .
this was confirmed by @xcite , who found that even retrograde fly - bys can have a strong effect on the disc size .
discs after inclined fly - bys would be larger than the ones presented here , but at most by a factor of @xmath72 .
we only considered parabolic encounters , however , the typical eccentricity of a fly - by depends on the cluster density : the higher the density , the more eccentric are the fly - bys , see fig .
[ app_fig : dsc_enc_vs_ecc_vs_time ] . as pointed out by @xcite such hyperbolic fly - bys
have less influence on discs than parabolic fly - bys , making the here presented disc sizes again lower limits .
a detailed parameter study of hyperbolic fly - bys and their influence on the disc size would be necessary to extend our study . in this work
we did not include photoevaporation , which is also capable of reducing discs in size or destroying them completely @xcite . in the embedded phase
the stars are still surrounded by the cluster s natal gas which makes the external photoevaporation ineffective . when the gas is expelled the discs are prone to the radiation from nearby massive stars .
nevertheless , the stars move outwards and may become unbound after the gas expulsion , the stellar density decreases significantly making it less probable for stars being very close to their most massive companions . only for the small fraction of stars which have a close fly - by the radiation would further reduce the disc in size making the final discs sizes smaller than presented here . here
we study the effect on low - mass discs . in this case viscosity and self - gravity of the disc
can be neglected during the encounter as such .
however , viscosity would lead to disc spreading in the long - term .
@xcite performed combined nbody / sph - simulations of low - mass clusters including viscous discs and found viscous spreading a ) counteracting the size reduction due to stellar fly - bys and b ) making the discs prone to follow - up more distant fly - bys . recently , @xcite compared the results of nbody and sph simulations of discs after stellar fly - bys , showing that viscosity can result in warped disc structures whereas those features are not visible in mass - less ( purely nbody ) discs .
a disc - size determination in those cases would be more complicated than in the flat , mass - less discs used here .
we did not consider any dependence of the disc size on the host s mass ( cf .
e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
if the initial disc size did depend on the stellar mass , the more massive stars should have started out with larger discs than the less massive stars . @xcite
performed simulations of discs around and stars .
they set a density threshold of @xmath73 for material belonging to the discs and found disc sizes between roughly @xmath74 for low - mass stars up to a little more than @xmath10 for solar - like stars .
if confirmed it would mean that discs around massive stars are more prone to size changes by the environment than low - mass stars .
furthermore , this would mean that in all clusters , except , more than half of the discs around solar - like stars would be influenced strongly by stellar fly - bys , see .
recent simulations have tried to determine the fraction of planets that become affected by the cluster environment and either move on an eccentric orbit or become unbound @xcite .
however , these simulations concentrate on the initially much denser clusters that become long - lived open clusters .
this type of cluster will be studied in a follow - up paper .
in this paper we studied how the cluster environment changes the sizes of discs surrounding young stars .
in contrast to previous work we took the cluster development during the first @xmath36 explicitly into account . starting with initial conditions typical for young clusters at the end of their formation phase in the solar neighbourhood , we modelled the cluster dynamics from embedded throughout the expansion phase and determined the effect on the effect of gravitational interactions between the stars on the disc sizes .
these type of simulations were performed for clusters of different mass and density .
our findings are the following : 1 .
it is essential to include the gas dynamics in this kind of simulations , as the larger velocity dispersion leads to more encounters and significantly smaller disc sizes than in a gas - free treatment .
2 . the majority of disc - size changing fly - bys always takes place in the embedded phase .
however , the slower expansion phase in lower mass clusters means that here still @xmath66 of disc - size changing fly - bys happen , in comparison to just @xmath75 for high - mass clusters .
3 . for onc - like clusters
basically only discs larger than 500 au are affected by fly - bys , whereas in ngc 6611-like clusters , cutting discs below 100 au happens for @xmath40 of stars .
however , in all investigated cases the disc sizes in the dense cluster centres are much more affected than the average suggests . for example , in the ngc 6611-like case the median disc size is 54 au .
the duration of the embedded phase influences the final median disc size , but not as strong as one would expect , because early fly - bys reduce the disc size already , leading to smaller cross sections for later fly - bys . in the densest cluster
the median disc size after @xmath38 is already @xmath76 , at the end of the embedded phase @xmath77 , which is very close to the final median disc size of @xmath78 .
often disc sizes and frequencies ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) of clusters of different present density are compared to obtain information about to what degree the environment influences these properties .
however , clusters are highly dynamical and their current density is not necessarily representative for the past development .
we showed that between @xmath79 even the most extreme cluster models of e0 and e52 have very similar cluster mass densities within a sphere of @xmath17 , see . the faster evolution of massive clusters leads this situation where the density in massive clusters and low - mass clusters of the same age can be similar , but the clusters themselves are in very different evolutionary stages .
this means that at this specific point in time and in this sphere of @xmath17 fly - bys are equally likely in all of these initially very different clusters .
however , if we compare the median disc sizes in these `` equal - density '' clusters at this point in time ( @xmath80 ) , they differ considerably . in the least dense cluster
the median disc size is roughly @xmath81 whereas it is @xmath82 for the densest cluster model .
the reason is that the most massive clusters where once much denser than the lower mass clusters and therefore their disc sizes are reduced to a larger degree .
the different expansion of the clusters - slow for low - density and fast for high - density systems - leads to very distinct fly - by histories and , consequently , different median disc sizes and disc - size distributions . if one looks only at the embedded phase there seems to be a direct relation between stellar density and the disc size : the higher the density , the smaller the median size
thus it seems that this is easily testable against observations .
however , taking into account the different evolutionary phases and their different time scales for dense and less dense clusters show that a comparison is much more complex .
all these effects of cluster properties and observational constraints make it quite challenging to compare disc - size distributions in different clusters with each other .
it does not make sense comparing the properties in clusters of different densities as long as one does not take into account their evolutionary stage and their history .
the characteristics of stellar encounters change significantly with cluster density . for example , the relative velocity between two encountering stars increases for denser clusters .
figure [ app_fig : dsc_enc_vs_ecc_vs_time](a ) depicts the average relative encounter velocity - that is the velocity of the perturber relative to the host star at the time of periastron passage - for three cluster models , , and .
this encounter velocity can directly be correlated to the eccentricity of the perturber s orbit via : where @xmath85 is the gravitational constant , @xmath86 is the mass of the host star , @xmath87 the mass of the perturber , and @xmath30 the periastron distance , all in si units .
the eccentricity distribution for cluster models e0 , e2 , and e52 are shown in fig .
[ app_fig : dsc_enc_vs_ecc_vs_time](b ) for fly - bys leading to disc smaller than @xmath62 . in this study
we assumed all fly - bys to be parabolic .
this approximation only holds for the least dense cluster model , as the encounter velocities and therefore the eccentricities clearly increases with cluster density ( see also * ? ? ?
* ) . for the denser cluster models ( especially e52 )
a detailed study of the influence of hyperbolic fly - bys on disc sizes would be favourable .
previous studies suggest that their influence on the discs ( in these cases the disc mass and angular momentum ) is much smaller than the one of parabolic encounters ( for detailed discussions see e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
therefore , the disc sizes presented here might be lower limits . at very high densities , that is especially in cluster model e52 ,
fly - bys are no longer 2-body encounters but many - body interactions .
this leads to the extreme eccentricities of @xmath88 .
especially for this type of fly - by we expect the disc - size change to be smaller than for the here assumed prograde , coplanar , parabolic case . 0.48 , black symbols ) and at the end of the simulation covering the embedded , the gas expulsion , and the expansion phase ( @xmath36 ( red symbols ) ; ( b ) for the onc in this work , i.e. with gas mass ( circles , same as in ( a ) ) , and in vbp15 , i.e. without gas mass ( squares ) .
the lines in ( a ) and ( b ) only serve to guide the eye.,title="fig : " ] 0.48 , black symbols ) and at the end of the simulation covering the embedded , the gas expulsion , and the expansion phase ( @xmath36 ( red symbols ) ; ( b ) for the onc in this work , i.e. with gas mass ( circles , same as in ( a ) ) , and in vbp15 , i.e. without gas mass ( squares ) .
the lines in ( a ) and ( b ) only serve to guide the eye.,title="fig : " ] crrrrrrr model & @xmath89 & @xmath90 & @xmath91 & @xmath92 & @xmath15 & @xmath14 & @xmath20 + & & & [ myr ] & [ pc ] & @xmath93 $ ] & @xmath93 $ ] & [ myr ] + e0 & @xmath46 & 308 & 2.0 & 1.3 & @xmath94 & @xmath95 & 0.67 + e1 & @xmath96 & 168 & 2.0 & 1.3 & @xmath97 & @xmath98 & 0.47 + e2 & @xmath99 & 94 & 2.0 & 1.3 & @xmath100 & @xmath101 & 0.33 + e3 & @xmath102 & 47 & 2.0 & 1.3 & @xmath103 & @xmath104 & 0.24 + e4 & @xmath105 & 16 & 2.0 & 1.3 & @xmath106 & @xmath107 & 0.17 + e52 & @xmath11 & 9 & 2.0 & 1.3 & @xmath108 & @xmath109 & 0.12 + e51 & @xmath11 & 7 & 1.0 & 1.3 & @xmath110 & @xmath111 & 0.12 + , d. , matsuyama , i. , mccarthy , i. g. , & font , a. s. 2004 , in revista mexicana de astronomia y astrofisica conference series , vol . 22 , revista mexicana de astronomia y astrofisica conference series , ed . g. garcia - segura , g. tenorio - tagle , j. franco , & h. w. yorke , 3841 | it is still on open question to what degree the cluster environment influences the sizes of protoplanetary discs surrounding young stars .
particularly so for the short - lived clusters typical for the solar neighbourhood in which the stellar density and therefore the influence of the cluster environment changes considerably over the first 10myr . in previous studies often
the effect of the gas on the cluster dynamics has been neglected , this is remedied here . using the code nbody6++ we study the stellar dynamics in different developmental phases - embedded , expulsion , expansion - including the gas and quantify the effect of fly - bys on the disc size .
we concentrate on massive clusters @xmath0 , which are representative for clusters like the onc or ngc6611 .
we find that not only the stellar density but also the duration of the embedded phase matters .
the densest clusters react fastest to the gas expulsion and drop quickly in density , here @xmath1 of relevant encounters happen before gas expulsion .
by contrast , discs in sparser clusters are initially less affected but as they expand slower @xmath2 of discs are truncated after gas expulsion . for onc - like clusters we find that usually discs larger than 500au are affected by the environment , which corresponds to the observation that 200au - sized discs are common . for ngc6611-like clusters disc sizes are cut - down on average to roughly 100au .
a testable hypothesis would be that the discs in the centre of ngc6611 should be on average @xmath320au and therefore considerably smaller than in the onc . |
there has been a flourish of recent work concerned with time dependence in string theory ( see , for example @xcite,@xcite , @xcite , @xcite and references therein ) , where we have a @xmath0-brane probing the backgrounds of various supergravity solutions . whilst some of this work has focused on @xmath1-brane backgrounds ( @xcite , @xcite ) ,
much of it has dealt with @xmath25-branes .
this has been particularly fruitful since it is known that the instability of the probe brane can be explained using tachyon rolling @xcite , and has also emphasised the relationship betweeen bps and non - bps branes @xcite , @xcite . in a recent paper @xcite
, the dynamics of a @xmath1-brane in the background of @xmath3 coincident @xmath4-branes was considered using the dbi action .
the @xmath1-brane is effectively a probe , since it can explore the background without disturbing it .
this is because the fivebrane tension goes as @xmath5 , whilst the @xmath1-brane tension only goes as @xmath6 .
thus the @xmath25-branes are much heavier in the @xmath7 limit .
geometrically this implies that the fivebranes form an infinite throat in spacetime where the string coupling increases as we move closer to the bottom .
since the @xmath1-brane and the @xmath4-brane preserve different halves of the type ii supersymmetry , this configuration is unstable despite the fact that the @xmath1-brane is bps .
this means that the probe brane will be gravitationally attracted towards the sources .
the ramond - ramond charge of the @xmath0-brane is free to leak to the fivebranes during the motion , and we also find that the energy due to string emission is divergent for @xmath8 @xcite .
this indicates that the classical analysis is vaild only for larger dimension branes .
as the brane loses almost all of its energy it can form a bound state with the fivebranes , becoming a @xmath9 fivebrane - a member of the @xmath10 fivebrane multiplet .
the issue of stable trajectories was also discussed in @xcite , but it was found that the probe brane was either scattered or doomed to fall towards the @xmath25-branes .
however this was of interest since the infalling @xmath1-brane would probe the strong coupling region , where pertubation theory would be expected to fail .
it was argued that there was a range of energies for which pertubation theory was still reliable as the probe passed through the thoat . in this note
we would like to examine a similar situation , however rather than considering @xmath3 coincident @xmath25-branes we will be interested in a ring of @xmath25-branes . as in @xcite
this also has an exact description in terms of a coset model cft ( @xcite,@xcite ) @xmath11
. this background solution will also provide us with a throat geometry to probe , which is more complicated than in the point - like case .
in particular it is possible to find solutions that explore this throat region but without the string coupling blowing up and as such we can expect that perturbative techniques will be valid in this case .
in addition we also couple an electric field to the @xmath1-brane worldvolume and investigate the interplay between electrical energy and the energy density , and consider how this affects the probe brane dynamics .
since our configuration will appear pointlike at large distances , we expect some overlap with the work done in @xcite .
we are interested in whether this picture will lead to the formation of bound orbits , which is of particluar interest for cosmology ( see @xcite , @xcite and references therein ) , and also the possible implications for tachyon rolling .
we begin the note with a review of the supergravity background of the problem and introduce the effective @xmath1-brane action .
we then go on to discuss the dynamics of the probe brane in the different limits of the theory before concluding with some remarks .
we wish to study the dynamics of a @xmath0-brane in the background gravitational potential generated by a ring of @xmath3 , static @xmath4 branes in type ii string theory . in order to do this
we must first consider the background fields which are given by the chs solution @xcite .
we find that the metric , dilaton and ns @xmath12-field are @xmath13 where @xmath14 label the coordinates parallel to the ns5-brane and the indices @xmath15 run over the four transverse dimensions and @xmath16 is the string coupling in the asymtotically flat region . as usual @xmath17
is the @xmath18-form ns field strength , and @xmath19 is the harmonic function describing the @xmath4 branes which satisfies the poisson equation in the transverse space . for fivebranes at arbitrary positions with respect to an origin
, the harmonic function is descibed by @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the string length .
the geometry under consideration in this note is obtained from the extremal limit of the rotating @xmath4 brane solutions discussed in @xcite , with the harmonic function given by @xmath22 this represents a continuous uniform distribution of branes along a ring of radius @xmath23 , which is oriented in the @xmath24 plane in the transverse euclidean space .
it will be convenent to make the following coordinate transformations to fully exploit the symmetry of the problem : @xmath25 which effectively defines an @xmath26 symmetry . in terms of these coordinate definitions ,
the harmonic function reduces to @xmath27 we now wish to introduce our probe @xmath0-brane into this background which is described by the effective dbi action .
we assume that the worldvolume of the probe fills out the directions @xmath28 , and use the reparameterization invariance present to go to static gauge .
the transverse directions to the @xmath4 branes induce scalar fields on the @xmath0-brane world volume , whose behaviour is described by the dbi action @xmath29 @xmath30 is the @xmath0-brane tension , @xmath31 is the @xmath32 gauge field , whilst @xmath33 and @xmath34 are the pullbacks of the metric and the @xmath12 field to the brane : @xmath35 @xmath36 where @xmath37 run over the ten dimensional bulk spacetime and @xmath38 are the bulk metric and @xmath12-field .
for the rest of this note we will be interested in homogenous solutions of the equations of motion , where the transverse scalars are time dependent only .
this will also ensure that coupling to the b field vanishes and so we will ignore it from now on .
we will also consider a non zero electric field ( only ) on the brane world volume , i.e @xmath39 .
so , the induced metric becomes @xmath40 and upon substitution into ( [ eq : dbi ] ) we obtain @xmath41 where we have defined @xmath42 as the constant electric field strength in dimensionless units by absorbing the factors of @xmath43 .
also we have assumed ( see @xcite ) that @xmath44 is small in order to obtain the relatively simple form of the action ( [ eq : action ] ) . from the action we can also deduce the following canonical momenta : @xmath45 @xmath46 @xmath47 @xmath48 where @xmath49 represents the effective ` mass ' of the brane .
it will be useful to rescale these momenta to remove this mass dependence , and so we are left with : @xmath50 @xmath51 it now becomes a fairly straightforward procedure to calculate the canonical energy density of the brane .
@xmath52 from which we obtain the following equation for the motion of @xmath53 and @xmath54 : @xmath55 since the rhs of this equation is non - negative it imposes constraints on the strength of the electric field .
we first set the angular momentum terms to zero , which means that the following constraint must be satisfied : @xmath56 in order to determine the full constraint it is necessary to specify the trajectory of the probe brane .
since there is an explicit @xmath57 symmetry we can choose to investigate the motion in the plane parallel to the ring ( i.e @xmath58 ) , or in the plane transverse to the ring ( i.e @xmath59 ) . in the first instance , setting @xmath54 to zero reduces the harmonic function ( [ eq : harmonic2 ] ) to @xmath60 which can easily be seen to be singular at @xmath61 when the probe brane hits the ring . upon insertion into the contraint equation
we find : @xmath62 there are three cases to consider .
firstly we have @xmath63 , which means that the rhs will vanish identically and so @xmath64 must be less than unity . in the limit of small @xmath64 which we are working
this is automatically satisfied .
these conditions are also the same in the @xmath65 case and in the @xmath66 cases
. we can also consider the case of motion transverse to the disk plane by fixing @xmath59 .
this gives us a new harmonic function , namely @xmath67 which can be seen to be nowhere singular .
as a result , the constraint equation is modified slightly to become : @xmath68 the constraint conditions , however , are essentially the same as those for the case of motion in the plane , the slight difference being that the lead term never blows up .
now following @xcite we define the effective potential in the general case to be @xmath69 at this point we would like to investigate the equations of motion of the probe brane in this background , for simplicity and convenience we consider each case seperately .
as discussed previously , the ring plane is identified with the coordinates @xmath53 and @xmath70 , and the harmonic function is given by ( [ eq : planeharmonic ] ) . in the throat geometry of the ring solution
we can neglect the factor of unity in @xmath71 provided that @xmath72 .
because of the distribution of the @xmath4-branes , we can consider probe motion either inside or outside of the ring .
of course , the full equations of motion are complicated and need to be solved numerically ( see later ) , but we can make some progress by considering various limits .
we first imagine @xmath73 , which puts the probe brane very close to the centre of the ring , and so we neglect the factor of @xmath53 in the expression for the harmonic function .
the equation of motion now reads @xmath74 which has a solution given by @xmath75 i.e is linear in the bulk time @xmath76 .
thus at @xmath76=0 we expect the probe to be at the centre of the ring , which is the furthest distance from the @xmath4 branes , and as time evolves it moves outwards . obviously ( [ eq : throatsoln1 ] ) will only be valid in the small @xmath53 regime and so this solution can not be trusted as the probe nears the ring . furthermore , we can see that the solution becomes time independent if the following constraint is satisfied @xmath77 and the probe will always remain at the origin .
we can also consider the regime where the probe is located far from the ring , i.e @xmath78 , but with @xmath79 still larger than @xmath53 .
the equations of motion are now modified slightly to become @xmath80 which gives us the solution @xmath81 this is the same expression that kutasov found in @xcite for a probe moving in the background of a stack of coincident @xmath4-branes , and reinforces our claim that the ring distribution appears pointlike at large distances .
the above solution informs us that at @xmath82 the probe is at its maximum distance from the sources , and as time evolves it is gravitationally attracted towards the ring . of course
, we must be aware that this solution is no longer valid in the regime where the probe is near the ring .
so far we have made decent progress by simply considering the limits of the solutions , but in order to understand the ring background we must try and find explicit solutions for the equation of motion in the region close to the ring . in order to do this
we have resorted to a numerical approach .
consider first the case with @xmath83 .
figs 1 and 2 show numerical solutions for the distance @xmath84 . in fig 1
, we have taken the dimensionless energy density @xmath85 and the electric flux @xmath86 or @xmath87 and assumed a positive initial probe brane velocity and a starting value of @xmath53 outside the ring .
( in this and all subsequent plots we have taken @xmath88 for simplicity ) .
it is clear that in this case trajectories of the probe brane are bound to the ring and can not escape to infinity .
the effect of turning on the electric flux on the probe is to increase its effective mass which results in the maximum distance away from the ring being reduced .
fig 2 is the same situation but with @xmath89 . in this case
both solutions describe a probe that can escape the ring and move to infinity , the case with no electric flux having a greater escape velocity .
similar plots for starting positions inside the ring ( or trajectories where the initial velocity is towards the ring starting from @xmath90 ) show trajectories that eventually hit the ring at @xmath91 although strictly speaking , one can not follow these trajectories right to the ring location as in this region there are large string effects .
these solutions can be understood in terms of the effective potential @xmath92 plotted for various values of @xmath93 and @xmath94 .
fig 3 shows four such plots , taking e.g. @xmath85 or @xmath95 and @xmath96 or @xmath97 .
these plots cover the region from @xmath98 at the centre of the ring , to values outside .
as in the previous section we initially consider the situation when @xmath99 .
the equation of motion in this plane is similar to the one for motion in the ring plane , and we obtain the solution @xmath100 the same comments apply to this solution , except that in this instance the probe brane is no longer moving towards the @xmath4 branes as time evolves , since it is moving in the transverse plane to the ring .
again we must be aware that this linear solution is only valid for small @xmath54 .
if we now consider the case where @xmath101
, then we can again imagine that at large enough distances the ring distibution will appear pointlike and we expect to recover a similar solution to the previous section .
this is indeed the case , and the solution is @xmath102 where the same comments must apply when considering the critical value of the electric field .
once again we can understand the solutions in between small or large values of @xmath103 by using numerical methods .
given that a probe is attracted to the ns5 ring if it is postioned above it , we might guess that a brane , with small enough energy , falling towards the centre of the ring from above the plane of the ring , would pass through its centre and then extend below it to some maximum distance and then be attracted back through the centre of the ring and so on .
that is we might expect a special solution describing the oscillatory motion of the probe through the ring centre .
such a solution should match on to the linear solution described above when the probe is at a small distance either above or below the ring plane , ie when @xmath104 .
fig4 shows a plot of the numerical solution in this case the linear behaviour of @xmath105 as a function of @xmath76 , for small values of @xmath106 is evident from fig 4 so matches our analytic solution above . in this plot
the probe starts from @xmath107 at @xmath82 and reaches a maximum distance below the ring of about @xmath108 .
after this time the probe is attracted back up through the ring and the process repeats .
the motion thus describes oscillation between the two zeros of the effective potential @xmath109 which is plotted in fig 5 .
what is also noteworthy about this particular solution is that it is stable to stringy corrections since we can control the minimum distance the probe comes to the ring by making the ring radius sufficiently large . in the plot of fig 5
we have also shown the effect turning on some electric flux has on @xmath110 .
its clear that it results in making this potential more postive everywhere and hence reduces the range and period of the oscillation through the center .
what is particulary interesting is that there exists a critical value of the flux @xmath94 ( around @xmath111 ) beyond which oscillation is not possible and the probe is stuck at the ring center .
the existence of this critical value of the flux @xmath94 ( for a given energy density @xmath93 ) can easily be understood .
the energy density of a probe brane carrying flux @xmath94 which is at rest above the ring plane at distance @xmath112 ( with @xmath113 ) must satisfy @xmath114 where the harmonic function @xmath115 is given in ( [ eq : perpharmonic ] ) .
now we see that for given @xmath93 , turning on the flux , @xmath94 , on a probe brane which was initially at some point @xmath112 above the ring plane means that in order to satisfy this equation the probe has to move closer to the plane , thus increasing the value of @xmath116 . but as we keep increasing @xmath94 this can not carry on indefinitely as there is a maximum value that @xmath117 can take ( for fixed value of @xmath118 ) , which is its value at the centre of the ring . thus there is a critical value of flux for a given @xmath119 .
of course one has to bear in mind that we can not make the factor of @xmath120 too small as our derivations are only perturabtive in @xmath94 .
so far we have only considered radial trajectories with vanishing angular momentum , at this point we must also consider the probe dynamics when the momenta are non zero .
if we retain the angular momentum term in ( [ eq : eom ] ) we must try to solve @xmath122 as in the previous sections we begin by considering the limit @xmath73 , which puts the probe brane inside the ring . we find that the solution in this instance is given by the following expression ; @xmath123 this somewhat complicated expression reduces to ( [ eq : throatsoln1 ] ) in the limit @xmath124 . at the opposite end of the spectrum in the @xmath78 regime , we find that the solution is given by @xmath125 which again reproduces the earlier result in the limit of no angular momentum , and shows us that the momentum term has the effect of slowing the decrease of @xmath53 in the @xmath126 limit .
furthermore this equation provdes us with bounds on the angular momentum , since it must satisfy the constraint @xmath127 if @xmath128 saturates this bound then the only solution is @xmath129 .
thus we see that increasing the flux automatically leads to a reduction in the angular momentum .
this is in agreement with our intuative picture of the flux providing extra mass on the brane . in order to study trajectories of the full theory without resorting to the special limits in @xmath130 discussed above we again look to numerical solutions .
we expect that solutions to the full theory will describe the probe brane in an unstable orbit about the ring .
this is confirmed in fig 6 which is a parameteric plot in the @xmath131 plane of a solution which starts at ( @xmath132 ) at @xmath82 . in this plot we took @xmath133 and @xmath134 and
we see the trajectory spiralling outwards from the ring . starting with different initial conditions
would produce e.g. trajectories that spiral towards the ring ( either starting from inside or outside ) and eventually end on there .
fig 7 shows the plot of @xmath110 vs @xmath136 with all other values as above . the same function is also shown for @xmath137 , in which case the spiral trajectories can not escape to infinity .
figure 8 shows a 3-d plot of the effective potential for non - zero values for @xmath138 and @xmath139 and @xmath140 respectively .
for this value of the energy we expect trajectories corresponding to the probe brane moving away from the ring to escape to infinity , which corresponds to @xmath141 becoming negative at large distances in @xmath142 as can be seen in the plot .
on the other hand probe branes moving towards the ring feel a generic repulsion due to the presence of a centrifugal barrier coming from the angular momentum terms in @xmath110 .
this would lead to scattering of the probe brane off the ring which happens also in the case of point like source of ns5-branes , in the presence of angular momentum @xcite .
the plot also shows a ` gap ' in the centrifugal barrier located at the ring location @xmath143 so that its possible for some trajectories to still end on the ring itself ( ignoring possible stringy corrections ) .
a numerical study is needed to distinguish these various possibilities .
unfortunately this requires solving the full set of non - linear equations of motion for @xmath144 and @xmath145 which requires methods that go beyond those we used earlier
. nevertheless it would be interesting to explore the nature of trajectories in this case .
in this paper we have discussed same basic properties of probe - brane dynamics in the background geometry of a continuous distribution of ns5 branes around a ring . we have found similarities to the situation when the ns5 branes are concentrated at a point , namely that there is generally an attaction of the probe resulting in some trajectories ending on the ring or else describing the scattering of the probe off the ring .
we have found an interesting solution where the probe can oscillate through the centre of the ring in a manner that is stable to stringy corrections if the ring is taken large enough .
our studies involved a mixture of analytical and numerical methods .
a number of future problems concerning the properties of d - branes moving in the ns5-ring geometry come to mind .
the fate of probe branes falling towards the ring could be studied using similar methods to those developed in @xcite , @xcite and @xcite .
since the ns5-brane ring geometry is rather different from that due to a point source we might expect different behaviour as regards the probes decay into closed string modes .
indeed the decay crossection calculation would doubtless make use of the exact description of the system in terms of the @xmath11 cft . in this context
it would be interesting to study the stability of the transverse oscillating solution discussed earlier , ( when the probe moves through the ring centre ) to decay into closed string modes .
( @xcite,@xcite ) .
99 david kutasov , ` d - brane dynamics near ns5-branes ' , hep - th/0405058 .
d. bak , s .- j .
rey and h .- u .
yee , ` exactly soluble dynamics of ( p , q ) string near macroscopic fundamental strings ' , hep - th/0411099 .
konstandinos sfetsos , ` rotating ns5-brane solution and its exact string theoretical description ' , hep - th/9903201 , fortsch .
phys.48 , 199 ( 2000 ) .
a. sen , ` rolling tachyon ' , hep - th/0203211 , jhep 0204 ( 2002 ) 048 .
k. takahashi and k. ichikawa , ` cosmology and two - body problem of d - branes ' , hep - th/0310142 , phys .
d69 ( 2004 ) 103506 .
david kutasov , ` a geometric interpretation of the open string tachyon ' , hep - th/0408073 .
konstandinos sfetsos , ` branes for higgs phases and exact conformal field theoris ' , hep - th/9811167 , jhep 9901 ( 1999 ) 015 .
konstandinos sfetsos , on ( multi-)center branes and exact string vacua , hep - th/9812165
. y. nakayama , y. sugawara and h. takayanagi , ` boundary states for the rolling d - branes in ns5 background ' , hep - th/0406173 .
david a. sahayakan , ` comments on d - brane dynamics near ns5-branes ' , hep - th/0408070 .
ahmad ghodsi and amir e. mosaffa , ` d - brane dynamics in rr deformation of ns5-branes background and tachyon cosmology ' , hep - th/0408015 a. kehagias and e. kiritsis , ` mirage cosmology ' , hep - th/9910174 , jhep 9911(1999 ) 022 .
hossein yavartanoo , ` cosmological solution from d - brane motion in ns5-branes background ' , hep - th/0407079 . c. p. burgess , p. martineau , f. quevedo and r. rabadan , ` branonium ' , hep - th/0303170 , jhep 0306 ( 2003 ) 037 .
c. p. burgess , n. e. grandhi , f. quevedo and r. rabadan , ` d - brane chemistry ' , hep - th/0310010 , jhepo 0401 ( 2004 ) 067 .
kamal l. panigrahi , ` d - brane dynamics in dp - brane background ' , hep - th/0407134 .
c. g. callan , j. a. harvey and a. strominger , ` superymmetric string solitons ' , hep - th/9112030 . j. kluson , ` non - bps d - brane near ns5-branes ' , hep - th/0409298 .
douglas j smith , ` intersecting brane solutions in string and m - theory ' , class .
quantum grav . * 20 * ( 2003 ) r233-r300 n. lambert , h. liu and j. maldacena , ` closed strings from decaying d - branes ' , hep - th/0303139 . | we consider the classical motion of a probe d - brane moving in the background geometry of a ring of ns5 branes , assuming that the latter are non - dynamical .
we analyse the solutions to the dirac - born - infield ( dbi ) action governing the approximate dynamics of the system . in the near horizon ( throat )
approximation we find several exact solutions for the probe brane motion .
these are compared to numerical solutions obtained in more general cases .
one solution of particular interest is when the probe undergoes oscillatory motion through the centre of the ring ( and perpendicular to it ) . by taking the ring radius sufficiently large ,
this solution should remain stable to any stringy corrections coming from open - strings stretching between the probe and the ns5-branes along the ring .
qmul - ph-04 - 11 + * d - brane dynamics and ns5 rings * * steven thomas and john ward * _ department of physics , + queen mary , university of london , + mile end road , + london e1 4ns , u.k . + _ |
metastable states in finite volume statistical mechanics lattice systems , in which stochastic transition between states are controlled by an energy function , is a well understood phenomenon .
different mathematical theories have been developed in the last decades .
the pioneering _ pathwise approach _
@xcite , further developed for non
reversible dynamics in @xcite , and the more recent _ potential theoretic approach _
@xcite , further developed in @xcite via the use of the trace process , allow a thorough description of the phenomenon .
the first theory gives a handy definition of the metastable state and a physically clear interpretation of the associated exit time . in the low temperature limit
, it has been proven indeed that the time scale on which the system leaves the metastable state is exponentially large with the inverse temperature , with a mass given by the smallest energy barrier that the system has to overcome along the paths connecting the metastable state to the stable state . moreover
, the theory gives informations about the paths followed by the system during its transition to the stable state .
in particular it ensures that with high probability the system visits one of the configurations , namely , the critical droplets , where the smallest energy barrier is attained before reaching the stable state .
the latter theory , on the other hand , allows a precise estimate of the mean exit time .
in particular it is proven that , measured in terms of the exponential time scale , such a mean time can be written in terms of a quantity , called _ capacity _ , which can be bounded from above and from below by using effective variational principles . under suitable hypotheses on the energy landscape ,
the theory allows the computation of the prefactor and , what is very relevant on physical grounds , shows that it does depend on entropic effects .
indeed , in many specific models the prefactor has been computed explicitly and it turns out to be connected , loosely speaking , to the number of possible ways in which the system can perform its transition to the stable state @xcite .
more precisely , it depends on the number of critical droplets that the system can use as a gate towards the stable state . in this framework
general results are proven under suitable hypotheses on the energy landscape ruling out the possibility to have multiple non degenerate in energy metastable states . in this paper
we approach precisely such a problem and assume that two metastable states are indeed present .
moreover , we chose a peculiar structure of the energy landscape such that the two states form a series " , in the sense that , starting from the metastable state at higher energy , the system has to visit necessarily ( in probability in the low temperature limit ) the second one in its way towards the ground state .
we prove a sort of addition rule for the exit time and compute , on the exponential scale , a sharp estimate for the exit time .
we approach this problem in the framework of rather general reversible markov chains .
our aim is that of introducing a model covering both the standard statistical mechanics stochastic lattice models ( e.g. , the metropolis dynamics ) and the reversible probabilistic cellular automata . in this framework
we assume a minimal characterization of the energy landscape sufficient to ensure both the presence of two non degenerate in energy metastable state and their serial structure . in the last part of the paper we discuss an application of this theory .
indeed , we approach the blume capel model @xcite , whose metastability behavior has already been studied from different point of views and in different limits in @xcite , and we derive , with a different method , the same result recently proven in @xcite on the sharp estimate of the exit time from the metastable minus one state in the zero chemical potential case .
we mention that the application of our results to the probabilistic cellular automaton studied in @xcite is reported in @xcite .
the paper is organized as follows : in section [ s : genris ] the general model is introduced and our main results are stated .
those results are then proved in section [ s : dimo ] .
finally , the application to the blume capel model is discussed in section [ s : blume ] .
in this section we first introduce a general reversible markov chain and specify the conditions on the energy landscape in order to have a series of metastable states .
we next state our main results in this framework .
we want to give the notion of reversible markov chain ( * ? ? ?
* condition r , page 335 ) in a quite general setup so that the theory will apply to different and relevant examples such as statistical mechanics lattice models and the reversible probabilistic cellular automata .
consider a finite state space @xmath0 and a family of irreducible and aperiodic markov chain @xmath1 , with @xmath2 parametrized by the parameter @xmath3 , called _
inverse temperature_. we let @xmath4 and @xmath5 , for @xmath6 be respectively the transition matrix and the stationary measure .
we assume that the markov chains are reversible with respect to @xmath7 , namely , @xmath8 for any @xmath6 .
we also assume that the fact that a jump is not allowed does not depend on @xmath9 , namely , if @xmath10 then @xmath11 for any @xmath12 . the definition of the model will be completed by assuming a slightly enforced version of the well known wentzel friedlin condition and by requiring that the stationary measure is `` close '' to a gibbs one .
more precisely , we assume that there exists @xmath13 and @xmath14 such that , for any @xmath6 , @xmath15 if @xmath16 and @xmath17=r(x , y ) \;\;\textrm { if } p_\beta(x , y)>0 .\ ] ] note that @xmath18 and @xmath19 do not depend on the inverse temperature .
we shall call @xmath18 the _ cost function_. moreover , we assume that there exist two functions @xmath20 and a family of functions @xmath21 parametrized by @xmath3 such that @xmath22=s(x)\ ] ] for @xmath23 and @xmath24 .
the normalization factor in @xmath7 is denoted by @xmath25 and called _
partition function_. note that the function @xmath26 does not depend on the inverse temperature .
we shall call @xmath26 the _ hamiltonian _ or _ energy _ of the model . from and it follows immediately that @xmath27 for all @xmath6 such that @xmath28 and @xmath29 for @xmath23 . from and the conditions above it follows also that @xmath30 for all @xmath6 . for any @xmath23 ,
we denote by @xmath31 and @xmath32 $ ] respectively the probability and the average along the trajectories of the process started at @xmath33 . in this section
we discuss two important examples of dynamics fitting in the general scheme depicted above .
the _ metropolis _
dynamics on the states space @xmath0 with _ energy _
@xmath34 , _ inverse temperature _ @xmath9 , and _ connection matrix _ @xmath35 is defined by letting @xmath36_+ } \;\ ; \textrm { if } x\neq y\ ] ] where , for any real @xmath37 , we let @xmath38_+=a$ ] if @xmath39 and @xmath38_+=0 $ ] otherwise be the positive part of @xmath37 , and @xmath40 it is well known that the metropolis dynamics has as stationary measure the gibbs measure with hamiltonian @xmath41 , so that the condition is satisfied with @xmath42 and @xmath43 . now , we let @xmath44 and @xmath45 for @xmath46 and @xmath47 .
for any @xmath46 , we let also @xmath15 if @xmath48 and @xmath49_+$ ] otherwise . finally , we let @xmath50 if @xmath51 and @xmath52 otherwise .
it is immediate to verify that condition is satisfied for any @xmath6 .
a second important example is that of reversible probabilistic cellular automata ( pca ) .
reversible pca have been introduced in @xcite , see also @xcite for a detailed discussion , and provide a very interesting example of dynamics with a parallel updating rule which are reversible with respect to a stationary measure which is very close to a gibbs measure .
the metastable behavior of some reversible probabilistic cellular automata has been firstly studied in @xcite .
let @xmath53 be a finite cube with periodic boundary conditions .
associate with each site @xmath54 the state variable @xmath55 and denote by @xmath56 the _ state space_. for any @xmath23 we consider on @xmath57 the probability measure @xmath58\big\}\ ] ] for @xmath59 , where @xmath3 and @xmath60 are called _ inverse temperature _ and _ magnetic field _ respectively .
the function @xmath61 is such that its support is a subset of @xmath62 and @xmath63 for all @xmath64 .
recall that , by definition , the support of the function @xmath65 is the subset of @xmath62 where the function @xmath65 is different from zero .
we assume , also , that @xmath66 for any @xmath23 and @xmath54 .
we finally introduce the shift @xmath67 on the torus , for any @xmath54 , defined as the map @xmath68 such that @xmath69 .
a reversible pca is the markov chain on @xmath0 with transition matrix @xmath70 for @xmath6 .
we remark that the character of the evolution is parallel , in the sense that at each time all the spins are potentially flipped .
it is not difficult to prove @xcite that the above specified pca dynamics is reversible with respect to the finite volume gibbs like measure @xmath71 with @xmath72\ ] ] with @xmath25 the normalization constant .
the low temperature behavior of the stationary measure of the pca can be guessed by looking at the function @xmath73 the difference between @xmath74 and @xmath75 can be computed explicitly , indeed in @xcite it is proven that @xmath76 for each @xmath3 and @xmath23 . from the remarks above ,
recall also the assumption , it follows immediately that the reversible pca satisfies condition with @xmath77 , @xmath78 , and @xmath79 for any @xmath23 . as for the transition rates , we set @xmath80 we shall prove that @xmath81 thus , the reversible pca satisfies condition with @xmath82 and @xmath83 for any @xmath6 . for completeness
, we finally prove . in the following computation
we shall use many times the assumption .
first note that @xmath84 } ) } \\ { \displaystyle \phantom{mermermermermermremreme } \phantom{=}+ \beta \!\!\!\ ! \!\!\!\ ! \sum _ { { \genfrac{}{}{0pt}{}{i\in\lambda:}{y_i(\sum_{j\in\lambda}k(j - i)x_j+h)<0 } } } \!\!\!\ ! \!\!\!\ !
2y_i\big(\sum_{j\in\lambda}k(j - i)x_j+h\big ) } \end{array}\ ] ] hence @xmath85 } ) } \\ { \displaystyle \phantom{mermermermermermremreme } + \!\!\!\ ! \!\!\!\ !
\sum_{{\genfrac{}{}{0pt}{}{i\in\lambda:}{y_i(\sum_{j\in\lambda}k(j - i)x_j+h)<0 } } } \hspace{-1 cm } \log(1+e^{-2\beta y_i[\sum_{j\in\lambda } k ( j - i)x_j+h ] } ) } \vphantom{\bigg\{_\bigg\ } } \\ { \displaystyle \phantom{mermermermermermremreme } + \beta \!\!\!\ ! \!\!\!\
! \sum _ { { \genfrac{}{}{0pt}{}{i\in\lambda:}{y_i(\sum_{j\in\lambda}k(j - i)x_j+h)<0 } } } \!\!\!\ ! \!\!\!\ !
2y_i\big(\sum_{j\in\lambda}k(j - i)x_j+h\big ) } \vphantom{\bigg\{_\bigg\ } } \end{array}\ ] ] finally , @xmath85 } ) } \\ { \displaystyle \phantom{mermermermermermremreme } + \!\!\!\ ! \!\!\!\ ! \sum_{{\genfrac{}{}{0pt}{}{i\in\lambda:}{y_i(\sum_{j\in\lambda}k(j - i)x_j+h)<0 } } } \hspace{-1 cm } \log(e^{2\beta y_i[\sum_{j\in\lambda } k ( j - i)x_j+h]}+1 ) } \\ \end{array}\ ] ] yielding ( [ accaede ] ) . after the short `` intermezzo '' on the metropolis and the reversible pca models ,
we come back to the general setup of section [ s : reversibile ] .
let @xmath86 be the set of pairs @xmath87 such that @xmath28 or , equivalently , @xmath88 .
the quadruple @xmath89 is then a reversible energy landscape @xcite .
given @xmath90 we let its _ external boundary _ @xmath91 be the collection of states @xmath92 such that there exists @xmath93 such that @xmath94 . in words ,
the external boundary is made of those states outside @xmath95 such that there exists a state in @xmath95 where the system can jump . given @xmath90 such that @xmath96 for any @xmath97 , we shall denote by @xmath98 the energy of the states in @xmath95 .
for any @xmath90 we shall denote by @xmath99 the set of the minima of the energy inside @xmath95 , that is to say @xmath100 if and only if @xmath101 for any @xmath102 .
we let @xmath103 be the set of _ ground states _ of @xmath26 , namely , the set of the absolute minima of the energy . for any positive integer @xmath104 , @xmath105 such that @xmath106 for all @xmath107
is called a _ path _ joining @xmath108 to @xmath109 ; we also say that @xmath104 is the length of the path . for any path @xmath110 of length @xmath104
, we let @xmath111\ ] ] be the _ height _ of the path is implicitly taken into account in , indeed implies @xmath112 . ] .
for any @xmath113 we denote by @xmath114 the set of the paths joining @xmath115 to @xmath116 . for any @xmath113
we define the _ communication height _ between @xmath115 and @xmath116 as @xmath117 from , , and it follows immediately that @xmath118 for all @xmath113 . for any @xmath119 we let @xmath120 where we have used the notation @xmath121 for the set of paths joining a state in @xmath95 to a state in @xmath122 . for any @xmath113
we define also the _ communication cost _ from @xmath115 to @xmath116 as the quantity @xmath123 .
note that in general the communication cost from @xmath115 to @xmath116 differs from that from @xmath116 to @xmath115 . for any @xmath23
we denote by @xmath124 the set of states @xmath125 such that @xmath126 .
note that @xmath127 if @xmath128 .
we then define the _ stability level _ of any @xmath129 @xmath130 note that the stability level @xmath131 of @xmath33 is the minimal communication cost that , starting from @xmath33 , has to be payed in order to reach states at energy lower than @xmath132 .
following @xcite we now introduce the notion of maximal stability level .
assume @xmath133 , we let the _ maximal stability level _
be @xmath134 [ def1 ] we call metastable set @xmath135 , the set @xmath136 note that , since the state space is finite , the maximal stability level @xmath137 is a finite number .
following @xcite , that is to say by assuming the so called _ pathwise _ point of view , we shall call @xmath138 the set of _ metastable _ states of the system . each state
@xmath139 is called _
metastable_. a different , even if strictly related , notion of metastable states is that given in @xcite in the framework of the potential theoretic approach .
first recall that the _ dirichlet form _ associated with the reversible markov chain is defined as the functional @xmath140 : = \frac{1}{2}\sum_{y , z\in x } \mu_\beta(y)p_\beta(y , z ) [ f(y)-f(z)]^2\ ] ] where @xmath141 is a generic function .
thus , given two not empty disjoint sets @xmath119 the _ capacity _ of the pair @xmath95 and @xmath122 can be defined as @xmath142}{f\vert_y=1,f\vert_z=0 } } } \mathscr{d}_\beta[f]\ ] ] note that the capacity is a _ symmetric _
function of the sets @xmath95 and @xmath122 .
it can be proven that the right hand side of ( [ capac ] ) has a unique minimizer called _ equilibrium potential _ of the pair @xmath95 and @xmath122 and denoted by @xmath143 .
a nice interpretation of the equilibrium potential in terms of hitting times can be given .
for @xmath23 and @xmath90 we shall denote by @xmath144 the _ first hitting _ time to @xmath95 of the chain started at @xmath33 .
whenever possible we shall drop the superscript denoting the starting point from the notation .
then , it can be proven that @xmath145 where @xmath146 and @xmath147 are , respectively , the first hitting time to @xmath95 and @xmath122 for the chain started at @xmath33 . it can be proven that , for any @xmath90 and @xmath92 , @xmath148 see ( * ? ? ?
* equation ( 3.10 ) ) . [ pta ]
a set @xmath149 is said to be _
p.t.a.metastable _ if @xmath150}^{-1 } } { \min_{x\in{m}}\mu_\beta(x){[{{\normalfont\textrm{cap}}}_\beta(x , m\setminus\{x\})]}^{-1 } } = 0\ ] ] the prefix p.t.a .
stands for potential theoretic approach .
we used this expression in order to avoid confusion with the set of metastable states @xmath138 introduced in .
the physical meaning of the above definition can be understood once one remarks that the quantity @xmath151 , for any @xmath6 , is strictly related to the communication cost between the states @xmath33 and @xmath115 , see proposition [ t : apriori ] .
thus , condition ensures that the communication cost between any state outside @xmath152 and @xmath152 itself is smaller than the communication cost between any two states in @xmath152 .
in other words , it states that getting to @xmath152 starting from any state outside @xmath152 is `` much '' easier than going from any point in @xmath152 to any other point in @xmath152 . finally , given a p.t.a.metastable set @xmath149 , for any @xmath153 we let @xmath154 be the _ valley _ associated with @xmath33 . for any @xmath125 and any @xmath155 the quantity @xmath156 measures the probability that , starting from @xmath115 , the system touches @xmath152 for the first time in @xmath116 .
thus , by computing @xmath157 , one detects the best way to touch @xmath152 for the system started at @xmath115 .
hence , the condition @xmath158 selects all the sites @xmath115 such that , for the system started at @xmath115 , the best way to touch @xmath152 is that of touching it for the first time at @xmath33 .
the aim of this paper is that of proving an addition formula for the exit time from metastable states in the case in which they form a series . with this expression we mean
that the structure of the energy landscape is such that the system has two non degenerate in energy metastable states and the system , started at the one having higher energy , must necessarily pass through the second one before relaxing to the stable state .
see fig .
[ fig : fig01 ] for a schematic description of the situation we have in mind and that will be formalized through the following conditions .
[ t : series00 ] recall ( [ gamma ] ) and ( [ metastabile]).we assume that the energy landscape @xmath89 is such that there exist three states @xmath159 , @xmath160 , and @xmath161 such that @xmath162 , @xmath163 , and @xmath164 .
note that , by recalling the definition of the set of ground states @xmath165 , we immediately have that @xmath166 moreover , from the definition of maximal stability level it follows that ( see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 2.3 ) ) the communication cost from @xmath159 to @xmath161 is equal to that from @xmath160 to @xmath161 , that is to say @xmath167 note that , since @xmath168 is a metastable state , its stability level can not be lower than @xmath137 .
then , recalling that @xmath169 , one has that @xmath170 .
on the other hand , implies that there exists a path @xmath171 such that @xmath172 and , hence , @xmath173 .
the two bounds finally imply that @xmath174 note that the communication cost from @xmath161 to @xmath159 and that from @xmath160 to @xmath159 are larger than @xmath137 , that is to say , @xmath175 indeed , by recalling the reversibility property we have @xmath176 where in the last two steps we have used and condition [ t : series00 ] , which proves the second of the two equations .
the first of them can be proved similarly .
we want to implement in the model the series structure depicted in fig .
[ fig : fig01 ] . with this
we mean that when the system is started at @xmath168 with high probability it will visit @xmath177 before @xmath178 .
for this reason we shall assume the following condition .
( 100,130)(-30,25 ) ( 50,30)(60,60)(70,60 ) ( 70,60)(80,60)(85,20 ) ( 70,50)(0,1)10 ( 70,40)(0,-1)10 ( 68,43)@xmath179 ( 48,24)@xmath180 ( 84,14)@xmath181 ( 85,20)(90,50)(95,50 ) ( 95,50)(100,50)(105,15 ) ( 95,40)(0,1)10 ( 95,30)(0,-1)10 ( 93,33)@xmath179 ( 104,10)@xmath182 [ t : series01 ] condition [ t : series00 ] is satisfied and @xmath183 we remark that the condition [ t : series01 ] is indeed a condition on the equilibrium potential @xmath184 evaluated at @xmath168 .
the most important goal of this paper is that of proving the formula for the expectation of the escape time @xmath185 for the chain started at @xmath159 .
such an expectation , hence , will be of order @xmath186 and the prefactor will be that given in . at the level of logarithmic equivalence , namely , by renouncing to get sharp estimate , this result can be proven by the methods in @xcite .
more precisely , one gets that @xmath187 $ ] tends to @xmath137 in the large @xmath9 limit .
we can thus formulate the further assumptions that we shall need in the sequel in order to discuss the problem from the point of view of the potential theoretic approach .
[ t : series02 ] condition [ t : series00 ] is satisfied and there exists two positive constants @xmath188 such that @xmath189,\,\,\,\,\ , \frac{\mu_\beta(x_1)}{{{\normalfont\textrm{cap}}}_\beta({{x_1}},{{x_0 } } ) } = \frac{1}{k_1 } e^{\beta\gamma_{{\normalfont\textrm{m}}}}[1+o(1)]\ ] ] where @xmath190 denotes a function tending to zero in the limit @xmath191 .
we shall prove the addition rule for the exit times from the metastable states by using the sharp estimates provided by the potential theoretic approach to metastability originally developed in @xcite .
[ t : ptaset ] assume conditions [ t : series00 ] is satisfied .
then @xmath192 is a p.t.a.metastable set . by means of the theory in @xcite it is possible to write asymptotic estimates of the first hitting time to a subset of a p.t.a.metastable set when
the dynamics is started in state of the same p.t.a.metastable set not belonging to the considered subset .
these results , see for instance ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 1.3 ) , are typically proven under suitable not degeneracy conditions ( * ? ? ?
* definition 1.2 ) that are not satisfied in our case , due to the presence of multiple metastable states . in the following theorem we state two results that , for the reasons outlined above , can be deduced directly from those in @xcite . on the other hand , as we shall discuss in detail in section [ s : dimo ] , they can be deduced by some of the results proven in @xcite ( see , also , @xcite ) .
but , since we assumed strong hypotheses on the energy landscape of the model , it will be possible to prove the theorem directly by means of simple estimates .
this `` ad hoc '' proof is also given in section [ s : dimo ] .
[ t : meant ] assume conditions [ t : series00 ] is satisfied .
! \frac{\mu_\beta({{x_2 } } ) } { { { \normalfont\textrm{cap}}}_\beta({{x_2}},\{{{x_1}},{{x_0}}\})}[1+o(1)],\ , \mathbb{e}_{{{x_1}}}[\tau_{{x_0}}]\!=\ ! \frac{\mu_\beta({{x_1}})}{{{\normalfont\textrm{cap}}}_\beta({{x_1}},{{x_0}})}[1+o(1)]\ ] ] [ t : addition01 ] assume conditions [ t : series00 ] and [ t : series02 ] are satisfied . then @xmath194 = e^{\beta\gamma_{{\normalfont\textrm{m}}}}\frac{1}{k_2}[1+o(1 ) ] \;\;\;\textrm { and } \;\;\ ; { { \mathbb{e}}}_{{x_1}}[\tau_{{x_0 } } ] = e^{\beta\gamma_{{\normalfont\textrm{m}}}}\frac{1}{k_1}[1+o(1)]\ ] ] [ t : addition02 ] assume conditions [ t : series00 ] , [ t : series01 ] , and [ t : series02 ] are satisfied . then @xmath195 = e^{\beta\gamma_{{\normalfont\textrm{m}}}}\big(\frac{1}{k_1}+\frac{1}{k_2}\big)[1+o(1)]\ ] ]
we remark that theorem [ t : addition02 ] gives an addition formula for the mean first hitting time to @xmath161 starting from @xmath159 . neglecting terms of order @xmath190 ,
such a mean time can be written as the sum of the mean hitting time to the pair @xmath196 when the chain is started at @xmath159 and of the mean hitting time to @xmath161 when the chain is started at @xmath160 .
it is very interesting to note that no role is plaid in this decomposition by the mean hitting time to @xmath160 for the chain started at @xmath159 .
indeed , on the @xmath186 time scale no control can be proven for such a mean time .
for instance , in the case of the blume capel model that will be studied in section [ s : blume ] , in ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 2.5 ) it is proven that @xmath197/e^{\beta \gamma_\textnormal{m}}$ ] diverges in the limit @xmath191 .
in this section we proof the theorems stated above and related to the general setup given in section [ s : series ] .
_ proof of theorem [ t : ptaset ] . _
the theorem follows immediately by condition [ t : series00 ] , , and ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 3.6 ) .
@xmath198@xmath199 we just note that the theorem 3.6 in @xcite has been proved in a slightly different context , but the proof given there applies also to the more general case studied here .
theorem [ t : meant ] can be deduced by using the structure provided by theorem [ t : ptaset ] above , and the general results ( * ? ? ?
( 4.14 ) and lemma 4.3 ) .
alternatively , one can use ( * ? ? ?
* eq . ( 8.1.6 ) , eq .
( 8.3.3 ) , and lemma 8.13 ) .
since we assumed strong hypotheses on the energy landscape of the model , it is possible to prove directly equation by means of simple estimates . before discussing such a proof we state two useful lemmas .
recall condition [ t : series00 ] , in the first of the two lemmas we collect two bounds to the energy cost that has to be payed to go from any state @xmath200 to @xmath160 or to @xmath161 .
the second lemma is similar .
[ stimephi ] assume condition [ t : series00 ] is satisfied . for any @xmath23 and @xmath201 . if @xmath202 , we have that @xmath203 _ proof .
_ let us prove the first inequality .
by theorem 2.3 in @xcite we have that @xmath204 .
if by contradiction @xmath205 then , by the same theorem 2.3 in @xcite , @xmath139 which is in contradiction with condition [ t : series00 ] . as regards the proof of the second inequality we distinguish two cases .
case @xmath206 : we have that @xmath207 . by definition [ def1 ] of metastable state and by ( [ stability ] )
, we get @xmath208 that proves the inequality .
case @xmath209 : let us define the set @xmath210 and show that @xmath211 . since @xmath212 , the identity @xmath213 follows .
furthermore , being @xmath214 , we have @xmath215 ; hence , @xmath216 as well .
moreover , if @xmath217 then @xmath218 . by the definition [ def1 ]
, @xmath33 would be a metastable state , in contradiction with condition [ t : series00 ] .
hence , since @xmath211 , we have that @xmath219 that proves the inequality .
the inequality .
@xmath198@xmath199 [ stimephi2 ]
assume condition [ t : series00 ] is satisfied . for any @xmath23 and @xmath220 .
if @xmath221 , we have that @xmath222 _ proof .
_ let us prove the first inequality .
by theorem 2.3 in @xcite we have that @xmath223 . if by absurdity @xmath205 then , by the same theorem 2.3 in @xcite , @xmath139 which is in contradiction with condition [ t : series00 ] .
as regards the proof of the second inequality we distinguish two cases .
case @xmath224 : we have that @xmath225 . by definition [ def1 ] of metastable state and by ( [ stability ] )
, we get @xmath226 that proves the inequality .
case @xmath227 : let us define the set @xmath228 and show that @xmath211 . since @xmath229 , the identity @xmath230 follows . furthermore ,
being @xmath231 , we have @xmath232 ; hence , @xmath216 as well .
moreover , if @xmath217 then @xmath233 . by the definition [ def1 ] , @xmath33 would be a metastable state , in contradiction with condition [ t : series00 ] .
hence , since @xmath211 , we have that @xmath234 that proves the inequality .
@xmath198@xmath199 _ proof of theorem [ t : meant ] .
_ we prove in details the right of equation ( [ meant ] ) .
the proof is based on lemma [ stimephi ] .
the equation on the left can be deduced with precisely the same arguments and using the bounds in lemma [ stimephi2 ] .
the only general results used is the representation of the expected mean time in terms of the green function given in ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 3.3 ) ( see also equation ( 3.18 ) in the proof of the theorem 3.5 in @xcite or ( * ? ? ?
( 4.29 ) ) ) . indeed , recalling above , we have : @xmath235 = \frac{1}{{{\normalfont\textrm{cap}}}_\beta({{x_1}},{{x_0 } } ) } \sum_{x\in x } \mu_\beta(x ) \ , h_{{{x_1}},{{x_0}}}(x)\ ] ] considering the contribution of @xmath160 in the sum and recalling , we get the following lower bound : @xmath236 \ge \frac{1}{{{\normalfont\textrm{cap}}}({{x_1}},{{x_0 } } ) } \mu_\beta({{x_1 } } ) h_{{{x_1}},{{x_0}}}({{x_1}})= \frac{1}{{{\normalfont\textrm{cap}}}({{x_1}},{{x_0 } } ) } \mu_\beta({{x_1}})\ ] ] in order to provide un upper bound , we first use the boundary conditions in to rewrite as follows : @xmath237 = \frac{1}{{{\normalfont\textrm{cap}}}({{x_1}},{{x_0 } } ) } \big [ \sum_{{x\in x\setminus { { x_0}},}\atop{h(x)\leq h({{x_1 } } ) } } \mu_\beta(x ) h_{{{x_1}},{{x_0}}}(x)+ \sum_{{x\in x\setminus { { x_0}},}\atop{h(x ) > h({{x_1 } } ) } } \mu_\beta(x ) h_{{{x_1}},{{x_0}}}(x ) \big]\ ] ] recalling that @xmath238 , the equilibrium potential is not bigger than one , the configuration space is finite , and @xmath239 for some positive @xmath240 and for any @xmath23 such that @xmath241 , we get @xmath242 = \frac{1}{{{\normalfont\textrm{cap}}}({{x_1}},{{x_0 } } ) } \big [ \!\ ! \!\ !
\sum_{{x\in x\setminus { { x_0}},}\atop{h(x)\leq h({{x_1}}),\,x\neq{{x_1 } } } } \!\ ! \!\ !
\mu_\beta(x)\,h_{{{x_1}},{{x_0}}}(x)+ \mu_\beta({{x_1}})[1+o(1 ) ] \big]\ ] ] by ( [ eqpot ] ) and ( [ potbound ] ) we can give the following upper bound for the equilibrium potential @xmath243 , for any @xmath244 @xmath245 thus , if @xmath246 , we have @xmath247 where in the first inequality we used proposition [ t : apriori ] , in the second lemma [ stimephi ] , and @xmath248 are suitable positive constants . by using
we get @xmath237 \le \frac{1}{{{\normalfont\textrm{cap}}}({{x_1}},{{x_0 } } ) } \big [ \!\ ! \!\ !
\sum_{{x\in x\setminus { { x_0}},}\atop{h(x)\leq h({{x_1}}),\,x\neq{{x_1 } } } } \!\ ! \!\ !
c\mu_\beta(x ) e^{-\beta\delta}\frac{\mu_\beta({{x_1}})}{\mu_\beta(x)}+ \mu_\beta({{x_1}})[1+o(1 ) ] \big]\ ] ] which implies @xmath249 \le \frac{\mu_\beta({{x_1}})}{{{\normalfont\textrm{cap}}}({{x_1}},{{x_0}})}[1+o(1)]\ ] ] where we have used that the configuration space is finite .
the theorem finally follows by and .
@xmath198@xmath199 _ proof of theorem [ t : addition01 ] . _
the theorem follows immediately by exploiting condition [ t : series02 ] and applying theorem [ t : meant ] .
@xmath198@xmath199 the proof of theorem [ t : addition02 ] is based on the following lemma .
[ t : dimo00 ] given three states @xmath250 pairwise mutually different , we have that the following holds @xmath251 = { { \mathbb{e}}}_y[\tau_{\{w , z\ } } ] + { { \mathbb{e}}}_w[\tau_z]{{\mathbb{p}}}_y(\tau_w<\tau_z)\ ] ] _ proof . _
first of all we note that @xmath252+{{\mathbb{e}}}_y[\tau_z{{\mathbb{i}}}_{\tau_w\geq\tau_z}]\end{aligned}\ ] ] we now rewrite the first term as follows @xmath253 & = & { { \mathbb{e}}}_y [ { { \mathbb{e}}}_y[\tau_z{{\mathbb{i}}}_{\{\tau_w<\tau_z\}}|\mathcal{f}_{\tau_w } ] ] = { { \mathbb{e}}}_y[{{\mathbb{i}}}_{\{\tau_w<\tau_z\}}(\tau_w+{{\mathbb{e}}}_w[\tau_z])]\\ & = & { { \mathbb{e}}}_y[\tau_w{{\mathbb{i } } } _ { \{\tau_w<\tau_z\}}]+{{\mathbb{p}}}_y(\tau_w<\tau_z){{\mathbb{e}}}_w(\tau_z).\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used the fact that @xmath254 is a stopping time , that @xmath255 is measurable with respect to the pre@xmath254@xmath256algebra @xmath257 and the strong markov property which gives @xmath258=\tau_w+ { { \mathbb{e}}}_w[\tau_z]$ ] on the event @xmath259 . since @xmath260 , ( [ dimo00 ] ) follows .
@xmath198@xmath199 _
proof of theorem [ t : addition02 ] .
_ by we have that @xmath261 = { { \mathbb{e}}}_{{x_2}}[\tau_{\{{{x_1}},{{x_0}}\ } } ] + { { \mathbb{e}}}_{{x_1}}[\tau_{{x_0}}]{{\mathbb{p}}}_{{x_2}}(\tau_{{x_1}}<\tau_{{x_0}})\ ] ] by theorem [ t : addition01 ] and condition [ t : series01 ] it follows that @xmath262}= { e^{\beta\gamma_{{\normalfont\textrm{m}}}}\left(\frac{1}{k_1}+\frac{1}{k_2}\right ) } [ 1+o(1)]\ ] ] @xmath198@xmath199
in this section , as a possible application of the theory described above , we apply our results to the case of the blume capel model ( @xcite ) . in particular , we consider the model with null chemical potential , which has two metastable states non degenerate in energy .
we shall then derive , in a different way , the results already appeared in @xcite .
let us consider a square lattice @xmath263 with periodic boundary conditions and side length @xmath264 .
let @xmath265 be the single spin state space and @xmath266 be the configuration space .
the hamiltonian of the model @xcite is @xmath267 for any @xmath268 , where the first sum runs over the pairs of nearest neighbors and @xmath60 is the magnetic field .
we denote by @xmath7 the corresponding gibbs measure @xmath269 with inverse temperature @xmath9 .
we shall study the zero chemical potential blume capel model for the following choice of the parameters : the magnetic field @xmath270 and the torus @xmath62 are such that @xmath271 , @xmath272 is not integer , and @xmath273 finite , where , for any positive real @xmath37 , we let @xmath274 be the largest integer smaller than or equal to @xmath37 . the time evolution of the model is defined by the metropolis markov chain @xmath275 with @xmath276 the discrete time variable , see section [ s : esempi ] , with hamiltonian @xmath26 and connectivity matrix @xmath277 as already remarked in section [ s : esempi ] , the dynamics above is an example of the dynamics defined in section [ s : reversibile ] , provided we let @xmath278 @xmath44 and @xmath45 for @xmath46 and @xmath47 ; @xmath279 for any @xmath46 , @xmath15 if @xmath48 and @xmath280_+$ ] otherwise ; @xmath281 @xmath50 if @xmath51 and @xmath52 otherwise .
the notation introduced in section [ s : reversibile][s : meta ] is then trivially particularized to the blume capel case .
given @xmath282 and @xmath283 , we let @xmath284 be the restriction of @xmath256 to @xmath285 , namely , @xmath286 such that @xmath287 for any @xmath288 .
we let @xmath289 to be the configuration such that @xmath290 for all @xmath54 .
other two very relevant configurations are @xmath291 and @xmath292 , that is the configuration in which all the spin are minus one and the one in which all the spins are zero .
note that in these configurations the exchange part of the energy is minimal , although the magnetic part is not .
we now define the _ critical length _ of the model as @xmath293 we denote by @xmath294 the set of configurations in which all the spins are minus excepted those , which are zeros , in a rectangle of sides long @xmath295 and @xmath296 and in a site adjacent to one of the longest sides of the rectangle ( see fig . [
fig : fig02 ] ) .
we denote by @xmath297 the set of configurations in which all the spins are zeros excepted those , which are pluses , in a rectangle of sides long @xmath295 and @xmath296 and in a site adjacent to one of the longest sides of the rectangle ( see the caption of fig . [
fig : fig02 ] ) .
we have : @xmath298\ ] ] we then set @xmath299 a simple direct computation shows that for @xmath270 small one has @xmath300 . in order to give a result in the spirit of theorem [ t : addition02 ] in the case of the blume capel model , we first have to prove preliminary lemmas ensuring that the conditions assumed in the general discussion in section [ s : series ] are satisfied in the blume capel case .
[ t : bc010 ] with the parameters chosen as below , we have that @xmath301 , @xmath302 , and @xmath303 .
moreover , the maximal stability level @xmath304 is equal to @xmath305 .
[ t : bc020 ] with the parameters chosen as below , we have that there exists @xmath306 and @xmath307 such that for any @xmath308 @xmath309 [ t : bc040 ] with the parameters chosen as below , we have that @xmath310,\,\,\ , \frac{\mu_\beta({{\normalfont\textbf{0}}})}{{{\normalfont\textrm{cap}}}_\beta({{\normalfont\textbf{0}}},{{\normalfont\textbf{u}}})}= \frac{3e^{\beta\gamma_{\normalfont\textrm{c } } } } { 2(2\ell_{\normalfont\textrm{c}}-1)}\ , [ 1+o(1)]\ ] ] the lemmas [ t : bc010 ] and [ t : bc020 ] will be proven in section [ s : proof - esempio ] below .
the proof of the lemma [ t : bc040 ] will be given for completeness in section [ s : proof - esempio ] ; but we stress that a completely analogous result has been already proven in ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 2.3 ) for the continuous time version of the same model .
we finally state our main results about the sharp estimate in the exit time in the blume
capel model with zero chemical potential .
[ t : bc050 ] with the parameters chosen as below , we have that @xmath311 = e^{\beta\gamma_{\normalfont\textrm{c } } } \frac{3}{2(2\ell_{\normalfont\textrm{c}}-1)}[1+o(1 ) ] , \,\,\ , { { \mathbb{e}}}_{{\normalfont\textbf{0}}}[\tau_{{\normalfont\textbf{u } } } ] = e^{\beta\gamma_{\normalfont\textrm{c } } } \frac{3}{2(2\ell_{\normalfont\textrm{c}}-1)}[1+o(1)]\ ] ] [ t : bc060 ] with the parameters chosen as below , we have that @xmath312 = e^{\beta\gamma_{\normalfont\textrm{c } } } \frac{3}{(2\ell_{\normalfont\textrm{c}}-1)}[1+o(1)]\ ] ] the proof of the theorems is achieved by applying the general results discussed in section [ s : mainris ] and the model dependent lemmas given above .
indeed , theorem [ t : bc050 ] follows by theorem [ t : addition01 ] and lemmas [ t : bc010][t : bc040 ] , whereas theorem [ t : bc060 ] follows by theorem [ t : addition02 ] , and lemmas [ t : bc010][t : bc040 ] . in this section
we collect some definitions that will be used in the proof of the lemmas [ t : bc010][t : bc040 ] .
we let @xmath313 for any @xmath283 with @xmath314 .
recall @xmath264 denotes the side length of the squared lattice @xmath62 .
let @xmath315 ; for @xmath316 positive integers we let @xmath317 be the collection of the sites @xmath318 for @xmath319 where @xmath320 . roughly speaking ,
@xmath317 is the rectangle on the torus of side lengths @xmath321 and @xmath322 drawn starting from @xmath33 and moving in the positive direction along the two coordinate axes . for @xmath323 a positive integer we let @xmath324 .
we denote with @xmath325 the set of the configurations @xmath283 which are _ rectangular droplet _ of zeroes with side lengths @xmath321 and @xmath322 in a sea of minus , with @xmath316 integers such that @xmath326 .
more precisely , @xmath327 if and only if there exists @xmath328 such that either @xmath329 and the spins in the complementary set @xmath330 are negative .
moreover , we denote with @xmath331 the rectangular droplet of zeroes with side lengths @xmath321 and @xmath322 in a see of minuses and with the lower left corner in @xmath33 . given a rectangular droplet in @xmath332 ,
we let @xmath333 , and @xmath334 represent respectively the north , east , south , and west side of the rectangular droplet . for @xmath335 , we denote by @xmath336 the configuration obtained by adding a zero protuberance of length @xmath104 to the @xmath337side of the rectangular droplet ( see fig . [
fig : fig12 ] ) . note that @xmath104 is a not negative integer bounded by @xmath321 if @xmath338 and @xmath322 if @xmath339 .
note , also , that @xmath340 , @xmath341 if @xmath338 , and @xmath342 if @xmath343 .
moreover , we denote with @xmath344 the configuration obtained by adding a zero protuberance of length @xmath104 to any of the four side of the rectangular droplet .
( i.e. , @xmath345 ) .
we also let + @xmath346 . given a configuration in @xmath336 its _ rectangular envelope _ is the configuration obtained by flipping to zero the minuses on the side occupied by the protuberance .
then , we have that the rectangular envelope of a configuration in @xmath336 belongs to either @xmath347 or @xmath348 depending if @xmath343 or @xmath338 . given a configuration in @xmath349 with @xmath350 a _ standard growing path _
is a path @xmath351 such that @xmath352 is obtained by enlarging by one zero spin the protuberance in @xmath353 and @xmath354 is the rectangular envelope of @xmath355 .
note that @xmath356 and @xmath357 if @xmath343 or @xmath338 , respectively . given a configuration in @xmath349 with @xmath350 a _ standard shrinking path _
is a path @xmath351 such that @xmath352 is obtained by flipping to minus one of the zero spins of the protuberance having at most two neighboring minuses and @xmath354 is the configuration obtained by flipping to minus all the spin in the protuberance of @xmath355 . in case of a stripe winding around the torus ,
i.e. , @xmath358 , we use the same notation adopted for the rectangular droplets : @xmath325 is the set of the @xmath283 which are either _ horizontal stripes _ of zeroes in a see of minus if @xmath359 or _ vertical stripes _ if @xmath360 .
moreover , we denote with @xmath344 the configuration obtained by adding a zero protuberance of length @xmath104 to any of the two sides of the stripe with length smaller than @xmath264 . for any @xmath361 and @xmath328
, we define the spin
flip operator @xmath362 by letting @xmath363 be the configuration such that @xmath364 recall the definition of path in the configuration space given just above .
a path @xmath365 is _ downhill _ if and only if @xmath366 for any @xmath367 .
we say that a configuration @xmath283 is a _ local minimum _ of the hamiltonian if and only if @xmath368 for any @xmath369 such that @xmath370 .
for our purposes it is useful to introduce the notion of _ strict downhill _
path by saying that a path @xmath365 is _ strict downhill _ if and only if @xmath371 for any @xmath367 and @xmath372 is a local minimum of the hamiltonian .
_ proof of lemma [ t : bc010 ] .
* theorem 4.10 ) @xmath373 and @xmath374 . by direct inspection of the hamiltonian
it follows that @xmath375 and @xmath376 ( see , also , the comments below ( * ? ? ?
* condition 4.7 ) ) .
@xmath198@xmath199 the proof of lemma [ t : bc020 ] needs the discussion of some preliminary results aimed to describe the paths followed by the system when it performs the transition from @xmath291 to @xmath292 .
the first step is that of computing energy differences between configurations differing for a single spin .
such a difference will depend only on the configuration in a cross shaped neighborhood centered at the site with differing spins .
thus , for any @xmath328 , we denote with @xmath377 the neighborhood of @xmath33 defined as @xmath378 , where @xmath379 is the euclidean distance on the torus . given a configuration @xmath256 ,
the effect on the hamiltonian of a change of the spin at site @xmath33 will depend only on the configuration @xmath380 obtained by restricting @xmath256 to @xmath377 ( see , the definition of restriction given above ) .
all the possible cases are summarized in the table [ tab : main ] , where the configurations @xmath381 are listed and the corresponding difference of energies are reported .
[ tab : main ] ( 100,90)(-60,15 ) ( 60,15)(1,0)40 ( 60,15)(0,1)45 ( 60,60)(1,0)40 ( 100,15)(0,1)10 ( 100,60)(0,-1)25 ( 100,25)(1,0)5 ( 100,35)(1,0)5 ( 105,25)(0,1)10 ( 75,63)@xmath382 ( 53,35)@xmath383 ( 70,30 ) 30zeroes ( 105,50 ) -30minuses ( 160,15)(1,0)10 ( 170,15)(0,-1)5 ( 170,10)(1,0)15 ( 185,10)(0,1)5 ( 185,15)(1,0)15 ( 160,15)(0,1)45 ( 160,60)(1,0)40 ( 200,15)(0,1)45 ( 200,60)(0,-1)30 ( 175,63)@xmath382 ( 153,35)@xmath383 ( 170,30 ) 30zeroes ( 205,50 ) -30minuses we state and prove now the following lemma regarding enlarging a protuberance of a rectangular droplet following the energy drift .
[ l : allprot ] given @xmath384 , any strict downhill path started at @xmath256 is either a standard shrinking or growing path .
_ let us start considering the case @xmath385 , i.e. , proper rectangular droplets .
given @xmath384 , by table [ tab : main ] we deduce that for any @xmath386 , the restriction of @xmath256 to the cross neighbor @xmath387 is such that @xmath388 for any @xmath54 we denote with @xmath389 , the contribution of the site @xmath390 to the energy @xmath391 , i.e. , @xmath392 , where the sum is over the nearest
neighbor sites of @xmath390 .
consider , now , a strict downhill path @xmath393 started at @xmath256 .
since in a strict downhill path at each step there is one single spin which is flipped , we have that for any @xmath394 there exists a site @xmath395 and @xmath396 such that @xmath397 by ( [ e : vtype ] ) we have that @xmath398 and , by table [ tab : main ] , it follows immediately that @xmath399 therefore , a strict downhill path will either remove the protuberance ( i.e. , @xmath400 and @xmath401 ) or enlarge by one zero the existing one ( i.e. , @xmath402 and @xmath403 ) . in the first case @xmath404 .
since @xmath405 for any @xmath386 , by table [ tab : main ] it follows that @xmath406 is a local minimum of the hamiltonian .
hence , in this first case , the standard shrinking sequence is found . in the second case ,
i.e. , when the protuberance is enlarged , for any @xmath407 , @xmath408 .
notice that there are not anymore neighbors of type @xmath409 , because the protuberance , now , is at least wide two sites .
hence , if we use the same argument used for @xmath410 , we deduce that the only way of lowering the energy is by enlarging the protuberance along the side .
we can repeat the same argument until all the line is filled . in this way the standard growing sequence is found . in case of stripes ,
i.e. , @xmath358 , the proof is almost identical , with only minor adjustments : for instance in the set @xmath411 is not present anymore the neighborhood @xmath412 . @xmath198@xmath199
recall the definition of external boundary given in section [ s : rel ] and note that in the blume
capel case the external boundary of a subset of the configuration space is made of all those configurations not belonging to such a set and such that by changing the value of one single spin the configuration that is obtained belongs to the set .
we call a nonempty set @xmath413 a _ cycle _ if it is either a singleton or a connected set such that @xmath414 where @xmath415 a non - trivial cycle is a cycle for which ( [ e : nontrivialcycle ] ) holds .
following @xcite , we define the _ principal boundary _
@xmath416 of a cycle @xmath417 , as @xmath418 for any rectangular droplet or stripe @xmath419 we define the cycle @xmath420 made of all the configurations that can be reached starting from @xmath421 via a path whose energy stays below @xmath422 .
the following lemma gives a precise characterization of the minima of the energy of the external boundary of the cycle @xmath423 for any @xmath424 with @xmath425 , see .
[ l : rett0 ] for any @xmath424 such that @xmath425 , it holds : @xmath278 @xmath426 ; @xmath279 @xmath427 .
_ item @xmath278 .
let us start considering the case @xmath385 , i.e. , a proper rectangular droplet .
let @xmath419 .
as we have noted in the proof of lemma [ l : allprot ] we have that @xmath428 , for any @xmath429 .
this implies that ( see table [ tab : main ] ) the rectangular droplet @xmath421 is a local minimum of the hamiltonian .
moreover , by using the results in the table one has that @xmath430 for any @xmath54 excepted for the case of the corner erosion , namely , for @xmath390 equal to one of the four sites such that @xmath431 and @xmath432 . in these cases @xmath433 .
hence , all the flips but the corner erosion yield a configuration outside @xmath434 .
in particular , we remark that the equality @xmath435 is attained by adding a protuberance to the rectangular configuration , i.e. , @xmath436 .
this implies that @xmath437 .
let us give the following definitions . given a configuration @xmath438
, we define the @xmath439_rectangular envelope _ the configuration @xmath440 such that @xmath441 is the smallest rectangle containing @xmath442 , where @xmath443 is defined in ( [ lambdo ] ) .
furthermore , we will call _ corner erosion _ the spin flip from @xmath439 to @xmath444 in the site @xmath390 with neighborhood @xmath445 of type @xmath412 .
moreover , we define the set of configurations : @xmath446 in words , @xmath447 is the set of all the configurations obtained from @xmath421 by one step of corner erosion .
we note that for any configuration @xmath448 , @xmath429 we have that @xmath449 . by inspection of table [
tab : main ] , it follows that if @xmath450 , then @xmath451 so that @xmath452 and @xmath453 .
otherwise , if @xmath454 we have that @xmath455 for @xmath456 , while for @xmath432 we have : @xmath457 and @xmath458 , that gives a second corner erosion .
this suggests the following definition , for any @xmath459 : @xmath460 in words @xmath461 is the set of all the configurations obtained by @xmath421 with @xmath65 corner
erosions . notice that @xmath462 .
we show now that if @xmath463 then @xmath464 . if @xmath465 , then we have indeed that @xmath466 , where we used @xmath467 . if @xmath468 , for any @xmath465 , @xmath429 we have that : + @xmath469 . again , by inspection of table [ tab : main ] , it follows that , for @xmath54 such that @xmath470 : @xmath471 and @xmath472 . if @xmath390 is such that @xmath473 , we have that @xmath474 for @xmath456 , while for @xmath432 we have : @xmath475 so that @xmath476 . in words , from @xmath477 any spin
flip that is not corner
erosion increses the energy by more than @xmath435 . using similar arguments as above , for any @xmath478 and for any @xmath54 we have that @xmath469 .
if @xmath470 , we get : @xmath471 so that @xmath472 . if @xmath390 is such that @xmath473 , it follows : @xmath479 so that @xmath480 . in words , from @xmath478 any spin
flip , including the corner erosion , increases the energy by more than @xmath435 .
this conclude the proof of item @xmath278 , since we proved that @xmath481 and for any other path the configuration reached when exiting @xmath482 does not belong to @xmath483 .
item @xmath279.starting from @xmath421 by @xmath484 corner
erosions , it is not possible to change the rectangular envelope , since @xmath321 and @xmath322 are not smaller than @xmath485 .
furthermore , for any @xmath477 , with @xmath463 , every sites belonging to the rectangular envelope @xmath486 is such that there are at least other two neighboring sites with spin zero . by the proof of item @xmath278
, we have that starting from @xmath421 , all the possible spin flipped configurations @xmath487 for @xmath64 and @xmath361 , belongs either to @xmath447 or to @xmath488 .
furthermore , for any @xmath489 , all the possible spin flipped configurations @xmath490 for @xmath54 and @xmath361 , belongs either to @xmath491 or to @xmath492 .
for any @xmath493 , with @xmath468 , all the possible spin flipped configurations @xmath490 , belongs either to @xmath494 or to @xmath492 .
finally , for any @xmath495 , all the possible spin flipped configurations @xmath496 , belongs either to @xmath497 or to @xmath492 .
putting together the previous statements , we can analyze all the paths joining @xmath421 to @xmath438 with @xmath498 and we get that @xmath499 , with @xmath500 . therefore in any line and row of @xmath501
there are at lest two sites with spin @xmath439 .
thus , we have that @xmath502 since @xmath503 , for @xmath463 , the item follows . in case of stripes ,
i.e. , @xmath358 , the proof is simpler .
in fact it is not possible anymore to erode a corner : we have that @xmath504 , for any @xmath429 .
this implies that ( see table [ tab : main ] ) @xmath430 hence , all the flips yield a configuration outside @xmath434 . @xmath198@xmath199
[ l : rett1 ] for any @xmath505 , it holds : @xmath278 @xmath506 is made by the configurations in @xmath507 obtained by flipping to zero all the spins but one on one of the two shortest side of the zero droplet in @xmath421 ; @xmath279 @xmath427 .
_ the lemma can be proved by following the same strategy used in the proof of lemma [ l : rett0 ] .
@xmath198@xmath199 , width=340,height=226 ] we finally come to the proof of lemma [ t : bc020 ] . our strategy is similar to the one used in [ lemma 3.13 , @xcite ] .
we let @xmath508 be the collection of the following trivial and non trivial pairwise disjoint cycles ( see fig . [
fig : landscape ] ) : 1 .
[ i01 ] @xmath509 , 2 .
[ i02 ] all the configurations in @xmath510 , 3 .
[ i03 ] the non trivial cycles @xmath423 for @xmath419 such that @xmath511 and @xmath512 ; 4 . [ i04 ] any configuration obtained by adding a @xmath439 protuberance of length @xmath323 to one side of @xmath419 with @xmath513 and @xmath514 , and such that @xmath515 ( respectively @xmath516 ) if the protuberance has been added to the side with length @xmath321 ( respectively @xmath322 ) ; 5 .
[ i05 ] any configuration obtained by flipping to zero the spins associated with any nearest neighbor connected of the torus @xmath62 is said to be nearest neighbor connected if and only if for any @xmath517 there exists a sequence of pairwise nearest neighbor sites of @xmath518 such that the first is @xmath33 and the last is @xmath115 . ]
subset of the set of sites adjacent to the shortest sides of any rectangular droplet @xmath419 such that @xmath519 and @xmath520 ; 6 .
[ i06 ] any configuration obtained by flipping to zero the spins associated with any nearest neighbor connected subset of the set of sites adjacent to either the horizontal or vertical sides of any rectangular droplet @xmath419 such that @xmath521 ; 7 .
[ i07 ] any configuration obtained by adding an @xmath323 protuberance to one of the two sides of the stripe @xmath419 such that @xmath359 and @xmath522 ; 8 .
[ i08 ] any configuration different from @xmath292 obtained by flipping to zero the spins associated with any nearest neighbor connected subset of the set of sites associated with minus one spis of any rectangular droplet @xmath419 such that @xmath359 and @xmath523 ; 9 .
[ i09 ] all the configurations in @xmath524 , namely those configuration obtained by adding a @xmath439 protuberance of length one the side long @xmath525 of any rectangle @xmath526 ; 10 .
[ i10 ] the non trivial cycles @xmath423 for @xmath527 .
the @xmath528 satisfies the following properties : @xmath529 , @xmath530 , there exists a cycle @xmath531 such that @xmath532 , and for any cycle @xmath531 @xmath533 where it is useful to emphasize that @xmath528 is a collection of pairwise disjoint cycles .
the first two properties are immediate by definition .
we comment briefly on the last two . at step [ i06 ] in the definition of @xmath528 we added in particular the configurations in which all the spins on the lattice are equal to zero but one which is equal to minus one .
it is immediate to realize that the principal boundary of such a trivial cycle is the set @xmath534 .
finally , to prove equation one has to examine all the cycles included in @xmath528 and prove that their principal boundaries are subset of the right hand side of equation .
with the same labelling used in the costruction of the set @xmath528 we have : [ i01 ] . by the methods of proof of ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 4.12 ) we have that @xmath535 .
[ i02].for any @xmath536 the set @xmath537 is made of the configurations obtained by enlarging by one site the protuberance ; those configurations belong to the not trivial cycles added at step [ i03 ] .
[ i03].from item @xmath278 in lemma [ l : rett0 ] it follows that the principal boundary of the cycle @xmath423 is made by the configurations obtained by adding a protuberance to one of the four sides of the rectangle @xmath421 ; these configurations are added at steps [ i04 ] and [ i05 ] ; [ i04 ] .
consider the configuration @xmath421 and suppose the protuberance is on the side of length @xmath321 ( the argument is analogous in the other case ) , then @xmath537 is made of the configurations obtained by enlarging by one site the protuberance ; those configurations are either trivial cycles added to @xmath528 at step [ i04 ] or elements of the not trivial cycles added at step [ i03 ] . [ i05].consider the configuration @xmath421 and assume that it is not a stripe wind around the torus , then @xmath537 is made of the configurations obtained by flipping to zero any minus spin with precisely two neighboring zeros ;
those configurations are added to @xmath528 at step [ i05 ] . on the other hand ,
if @xmath421 is a stripe winding around the torus the principal boundary is the set of configurations obtained by adding a zero protuberance ; those configurations are added to @xmath528 at step [ i07 ] .
the discussion of the other cases is similar .
we just discuss explicitly the case [ i10 ] : by lemma [ l : rett1 ] we have that the principal boundary of the cycle @xmath423 is made of the configurations obtained by flipping to minus all the spins but one spin of one of the two shortest sides of the rectangular droplet @xmath421 ; those configurations are elements of @xmath538 .
[ l : exit ] consider the set @xmath508 .
then there exists @xmath306 such that for @xmath9 sufficiently large : @xmath539 _ proof .
_ we have that @xmath540 where in the first equality we have used the fact that for each cycle @xmath417 in @xmath508 the principal boundary @xmath416 is contained in @xmath508 ; the first inequality follows from the strong markov property and the second inequality is a consequence of ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 6.23 ) .
@xmath198@xmath199 _ proof of lemma [ t : bc020 ] . _ since @xmath541 , @xmath542 and @xmath543 , we have that , @xmath544 the lemma then follows from lemma [ l : exit ] .
@xmath198@xmath199 _ proof of lemma [ t : bc040 ] . _ the proof of this lemma could be given by applying proposition 2.3 and equation ( 5.1 ) in @xcite , correcting by a factor @xmath545 for passing from the continuos to the discrete time of the metropolis dynamics .
for the sake of completeness , we provide an alternative proof , based on theorem [ t:6.19 ] contained in appendix [ s : appendix : b ] . by ( * ? ? ? * lemma 4.9 ) , we have that @xmath546 .
moreover , by ( * ? ? ? * theorem 4.14 ) , we know that the minimal gates @xmath547 between @xmath291 and @xmath548 is @xmath549
. hence , by theorem [ t:6.19 ] , @xmath550\ ] ] with @xmath551 with @xmath552 , since the only possible transition to @xmath553 is removing the protuberance of the protocritical droplet . on the other hand , @xmath554 if the protuberance is on the corner and @xmath555 otherwise .
so that , @xmath556 therefore , @xmath557 \;\;.\ ] ] as regards the calculation of @xmath558 , by ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 4.9 ) , we have that @xmath559 .
moreover , by ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 4.14 ) , we know that the union of the minimal gates between @xmath292 and @xmath548 is @xmath560 . hence , @xmath561\ ] ] with @xmath562 with similar arguments as above , we get @xmath563 and , therefore , @xmath564 which completes the proof of the lemma
. @xmath198@xmath199 * aknowledgements . *
enmc thanks icms ( tu / e , eindhoven ) , eurandom ( tu / e , eindhoven ) , the mathematics department of delft university , and the mathematics department of utrecht university for kind hospitality .
frn and cs thank a. bovier for many stimulating discussions .
enmc and frn thank e. scoppola and f. den hollander for illuminating discussions .
the authors thank a. gaudilliere and m. slowik for useful discussions and comments and an anonymous referee , whose useful comments considerably improved the quality of the manuscript .
[ s : generali ] in this appendix we summarize some general results whose statement and proof can already be found in the literature but , sometimes , in slightly different contexts .
[ t : apriori ] consider the markov chain defined in section [ s : reversibile ] .
for every not empty disjoint sets @xmath119 there exist constants @xmath565 such that @xmath566 for all @xmath9 large enough . _
proof . _ the upper bound can be obtained by choosing @xmath567 in with @xmath568 for any pair @xmath569 such that @xmath570 and @xmath571 , we have that @xmath572 .
in fact , if by absurdity it were @xmath573 , it would be possible to construct a path @xmath110 starting at @xmath574 and ending in @xmath95 such that @xmath575 , which is in contradiction with @xmath571 .
hence , by ( [ diri - new ] ) and ( [ capac ] ) @xmath576 = \frac{1}{2 } \sum_{{u\in k(y , z)}\atop{v\in x\setminus k(y , z)}}\ , p_\beta(u , v ) e^{-g_\beta(u)}\ ] ] recalling and , we get that there exists @xmath417 such that for @xmath9 large enough @xmath577}\ ] ] finally , the upper bound in follows from the fact that @xmath572 for any @xmath570 and @xmath571 .
as regards the lower bound , it can be obtained by picking any path @xmath578 that realizes the minimax in @xmath579 and ignore all the transitions that are not the path and using the same argument as in the proof of [ lemma 3.1.1 , @xcite ] .
an alternative proof can be given applying the berman
konsowa lemma [ proposition 2.4 , @xcite ] which provides a complementary variational principle , in the sense that any test flow will give a lower bound .
hence , the lower bound can be obtained by picking any path @xmath578 , with @xmath580 , @xmath581 , such that it realizes the minimax in @xmath579 and such that @xmath582 for @xmath583 ( recall ( [ height ] ) and ( [ communication - set ] ) ) . if we choose a unitary flow for the edges in the path @xmath110 and null otherwise , the induced markov chains is a deterministic chain along the path , so that the expectation in [ proposition 2.4 , @xcite ] is just the contribution of the deterministic path .
hence , for the chosen flow we have : @xmath584^{-1}\geq c_1\frac{1}{z_\beta } e^{-\beta\phi(y , z)}[1+o(1)]\ ] ] where in the last inequality we used and .
@xmath198@xmath199 [ t : cri02 ] consider the markov chain defined in section [ s : reversibile ] .
we have that @xmath585 for any @xmath586 , @xmath587 , @xmath588 , and @xmath589 . _ proof . _ given @xmath589 , a renewal argument and the strong markov property yield : @xmath590 therefore @xmath591 recalling , we can rewrite the ratio in terms of ratio of capacities : @xmath592 hence , we get .
in this section we state and prove a slightly more general theorem than theorem 6.19 of @xcite . as in @xcite ,
the theorem holds for the metropolis dynamics introduced in section [ s : esempi ] , but in the more general setting of two metastable configurations .
we assume that condition [ t : series00 ] holds so that the energy landscape is such that there exist three states @xmath159 , @xmath160 , and @xmath161 such that @xmath162 , @xmath163 , and @xmath593 .
this theorem gives indeed the capacity between a configuration @xmath594 and a set @xmath595 in terms of the energy and cardinality of the minimal gates .
hence , the theorem considers the two case @xmath596 , @xmath597 and @xmath598 , @xmath599 . before stating the theorem we recall first some notions introduced in @xcite .
let @xmath604 and @xmath605 .
we say that @xmath606 is the _ set of saddles _ for the pair @xmath116 and @xmath607 if and only if @xmath608 for any @xmath609 .
we say that a set @xmath610 is a _ gate _ for the pair @xmath116 and @xmath607 if for any path @xmath611 such that @xmath612 we have that @xmath613 .
a gate @xmath547 for the pair @xmath116 and @xmath607 is said to be _ minimal _ if and only if for any proper subset @xmath614 of @xmath547 there exists a path joining @xmath116 to @xmath607 with maximal height equal to the communication height between @xmath116 and @xmath607 which does not pass through @xmath614 .
[ t:6.19 ] in the setup introduced above , consider @xmath615 and @xmath595 .
assume that the minimal gate @xmath547 for @xmath33 and @xmath518 is unique and that for any @xmath616 and @xmath617 we have @xmath618
. then @xmath619\ ] ] with @xmath620 where @xmath621 and @xmath622 .
_ upper bound : by ( [ cap - prop ] ) , ( * ? ? ? * theorem 5.4 ) and using the strong markov property , we can write : @xmath623\ ] ] in fact we have @xmath624\\ & = & \mu_{\beta}(x ) \sum_{z\in\gate}{{{\mathbb{p}}}}_x ( \tau_a<\tau_x,\tau_{z}<\tau_a,\tau_z<\tau_{\gate\setminus z})[1+o(1)]\\ & = & \mu_{\beta}(x ) \sum_{z\in\gate}{{{\mathbb{p}}}}_x ( \tau_a<\tau_x|\tau_{z}<\tau_a,\tau_z<\tau_{\gate\setminus z},\tau_z<\tau_x)\\ & & \phantom{\mu_{\beta}(x)\sum_{z\in\gate } } \times{{{\mathbb{p}}}}_x(\tau_{z}<\tau_a,\tau_z<\tau_{\gate\setminus z},\tau_z<\tau_x)[1+o(1)]\\ & = & \mu_{\beta}(x)\sum_{z\in\gate}{{{\mathbb{p}}}}_z ( \tau_a<\tau_x ) { { { \mathbb{p}}}}_x(\tau_{z}<\tau_a,\tau_z<\tau_{\gate\setminus z},\tau_z<\tau_x)[1+o(1)]\\ & = & \mu_{\beta}(x)\sum_{z\in\gate}{{{\mathbb{p}}}}_z ( \tau_a<\tau_x ) { { { \mathbb{p}}}}_x(\tau_z<\tau_{\gate\setminus z},\tau_z<\tau_x)[1+o(1 ) ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] where in the last step we used the fact that : @xmath625\ ] ] for the second term of [ cap_split_1 ] , we have , for any @xmath626 @xmath627[1+o(1 ) ] \nonumber \\ & = & \frac{1}{1-p(z , z)}(\sum_{y\in q_a } p(z , y ) { { \mathbb{p}}}_y(\tau_a<\tau_x ) + \!\!\sum_{y\in q_x } p(z , y ) { { \mathbb{p}}}_y(\tau_a<\tau_x))[1+o(1 ) ] \nonumber\\ & \leq & \frac{\hat{p}(z)}{\hat{p}(z)+\check{p}(z)}[1+o(1 ) ] \label{e : pa}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where in the first equality we used the fact that @xmath628 for any @xmath629 ; in the last step , we have used the trivial relation @xmath630 for bounding the first term of the sum , while the upper bound for the second term follows from @xmath631 and from the recurrence of non trivial cycle ( i.e. , by theorem 6.3 in @xcite , for any @xmath632 we have @xmath633 ) . hence ,
by ( [ e : pa ] ) and ( [ cap_split_1 ] ) we have : @xmath634 \\ & = & \mu_{\beta}(x)\sum_{z\in \gate } \frac{\hat{p}(z)}{\hat{p}(z)+\check{p}(z ) } \frac{\mu_\beta(z)}{\mu_\beta(x)}{{{\mathbb{p}}}}_z(\tau_x<\tau_\gate ) [ 1+o(1 ) ] \nonumber\\ & \leq&\sum_{z\in \gate } \mu_{\beta}(z ) \frac{\hat{p}(z)}{\hat{p}(z)+\check{p}(z ) } \sum_{y\in q_x}p(z , y ) [ 1+o(1 ) ] \leq\frac{e^{-\beta \phi(x , a)}}{z_\beta}\sum_{z\in \gate } \frac{\hat{p}(z)\check{p}(z)}{\hat{p}(z)+\check{p}(z)}\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] where in the second step we used reversibility and in the third one : @xmath635[1+o(1)]\ ] ] and the properties of the cycles @xmath636 and @xmath602 .
_ lower bound_.in order to prove the lower bound , we adapt to our setting the arguments of the proof in ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 3.2 ) .
we consider a subgraph @xmath18 in the space of configurations obtained removing all the connections to the configurations in @xmath637 .
we denote with @xmath638 the probability along the trajectories of this _ restricted _ process started at @xmath33 .
hence , by rayleigh s shortcut rule ( see ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 4.2 ) ) we have : @xmath639 if we now exploit the property of the restricted process we can write : @xmath640 where we used ( [ cap - prop ] ) and the strong markov property . by reversibility , ( [ cap_split ] )
becomes @xmath641 now , the first factor in ( [ captilde ] ) can be rewritten as @xmath642 we want to prove that inside @xmath636 the equilibrium potential @xmath643 is exponentially close to 1 .
therefore , for any @xmath644 , and for @xmath645 : @xmath646 where in the first inequality we used proposition [ t : cri02 ] , and in the second inequality proposition [ t : apriori ] .
therefore @xmath647= \check{p}(z ) [ 1+o(1)]\ ] ] where in the last step , we used the fact that the one step transition probabilities @xmath648 are equal , by construction , to @xmath649 of the original chain , for any @xmath626 . for the second factor @xmath650
: @xmath651 so that @xmath652 we want to prove that inside @xmath653 the equilibrium potential @xmath654 is exponentially close to 1 .
therefore for any @xmath655 , by using proposition [ t : cri02 ] , and proposition [ t : apriori ] we have @xmath656 so that @xmath657 = \frac{\hat{p}(z)}{{\hat{p}(z)+\check{p}(z)}}[1+o(1)]\ ] ] hence , by ( [ captilde ] ) , ( [ f1 ] ) , and ( [ factor22 ] ) , ( [ cap_gate ] ) follows .
@xmath198@xmath199 o. catoni .
`` simulated annealing algorithms and markov chains with rare transitions . '' in _ sminaire de probabilits , xxxiii _ , volume 1709 of _ lecture notes in math .
_ , pages 69119 .
springer , berlin , 1999 .
cirillo , p.y .
louis , w. ruszel , c. spitoni , `` effect of self
interaction on the phase diagram of a gibbs like measure derived by a reversible probabilistic cellular automata . '' _ chaos , solitons , and fractals _ * 64 * , 3647 ( 2014 ) .
cirillo , f.r .
nardi , c. spitoni , sum of exit times in a series of two metastable states in probabilistic cellular automata . " _
cellular automata and discrete complex systems _ , 22nd ifip wg 1.5 international workshop , automata 2016 , zurich , switzerland , june 15 - 17 , 2016 , proceedings , springer ( 2016 ) c. landim , p. lemire , metastability of the two dimensional blume
capel model with zero chemical potential and small magnetic field . " _ journ .
_ * 164 * , 346376 ( 2016 ) .
f. manzo , f.r .
nardi , e. olivieri , e. scoppola , on the essential features of metastability : tunnelling time and critical configurations . " _ journ .
phys . _ * 115 * , 591642 ( 2004 ) .
e. olivieri , e. scoppola , `` markov chains with exponentially small transition probabilities : first exit problem from a general domain .
i. the reversible case , '' _ journ .
phys . _ * 79 * , 613647 ( 1995 ) . | we consider the problem of non degenerate in energy metastable states forming a series in the framework of reversible finite state space markov chains .
we assume that starting from the state at higher energy the system necessarily visits the second one before reaching the stable state . in this framework
we give a sharp estimate of the exit time from the metastable state at higher energy and , on the proper exponential time scale , we prove an addition rule . as an application of the theory , we study the blume capel model in the zero chemical potential case . |
existence of minimal symplectic structures on @xmath1-manifolds is a fundamental question in smooth @xmath1-manifold topology .
there has been much interest especially in producing minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifolds in the homeomorphism classes of standard simply - connected @xmath1-manifolds with small second homology , such as blow - ups of @xmath10 or @xmath11 . over the last two decades
, many ingenious construction techniques , such as rational blowdowns , generalized fiber sum , knot surgery and luttinger surgery , have been introduced to effectively address this problem by fintushel and stern , gompf , jongil park , and several others .
( e.g. @xcite . ) resting on spectacular results of taubes on seiberg - witten invariants of symplectic @xmath1-manifolds , these constructions have demonstrated that minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifolds not only constitute _ small exotic @xmath1-manifolds _ ( which are homeomorphic but not diffeomorphic to standard ones ) , but also resource them in almost all the known instances . on the other hand ,
since the pioneering works of donaldson and gompf in late @xmath12s , it is known that symplectic @xmath1-manifolds , up to blow - ups , correspond to lefschetz fibrations , which can be studied combinatorially as _ positive factorizations _ ,
i.e. factorizations of boundary dehn twists into positive dehn twists in the mapping class groups of compact oriented surfaces .
this brings a priori an understanding that _ any _ symplectic @xmath1-manifold , if it exists , should come from a positive factorization . in practice , however , the very idea of constructing small exotic @xmath1-manifolds via new positive factorizations has hardly been utilized up to date .
the main objective of this article is to demonstrate ways to successfully implement this latter approach by constructing positive factorization for lefschetz fibrations with small number of critical points , which we call _ small lefschetz fibrations _ in analogy ( section [ smalllfs ] ) , as they correspond to @xmath1-manifolds with small second homology . by the virtue of our constructions
, these will provide simple descriptions of many new small exotic @xmath1-manifolds .
lefschetz fibrations of fiber genus @xmath13 and @xmath14 are well - known : their total spaces are diffeomorphic to complex surfaces @xmath10 , @xmath15 , elliptic surfaces @xmath16 , and their blow - ups @xcite .
therefore , for a lefschetz fibration to bear any new symplectic @xmath1-manifold , the fiber genus should be at least @xmath0 . by a thorough analysis of small genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations
, we will show that one can already achieve a lot with genus-@xmath0 fibrations .
[ mainthm ] there exist decomposable genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations , whose total spaces are minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifolds homeomorphic but not diffeomorphic to @xmath17 for @xmath18 , and to @xmath19 for @xmath20
. we will describe all the genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations in theorem [ mainthm ] explicitly via positive factorizations in the mapping class group of a genus-@xmath0 surface with one boundary component ( section [ sec : exotic ] ; theorems [ exoticcp ] and [ exotic3cp ] ) .
these positive factorizations contain at least two proper ( even smaller ! ) positive factorizations , which amounts to them decomposing as nontrivial fiber sums of lefschetz fibrations .
based on @xcite , this allows us to conclude that the corresponding lefschetz fibrations are _ minimal _ in the stronger sense : they are not only relatively minimal , i.e. not containing any exceptional spheres in the fibers , but also they do not contain any exceptional spheres at all ( proposition [ minimalityprop ] ) .
we construct the exotic genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations of theorem [ mainthm ] in two main steps . in section [ smalllfs ]
, we will describe a general procedure to produce small positive factorizations in the mapping class group , which we will call _ reverse engineering _
, motivated by a similar procedure defined by fintushel and stern under the same name to produce small exotic @xmath1-manifolds @xcite .
we employ this technique to obtain several ( very ) small positive factorizations , including the smallest possible positive factorization for a nontrivial genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration ( theorem [ thesmallest ] ) .
as we will observe ( proposition [ difftypes ] ) , these very small positive factorizations themselves are not exotic ; they always have total spaces _ diffeomorphic _ to complex rational and ruled surfaces .
then the second step of the construction will be to take products of certain conjugates of these positive factorizations to arrive at _ simply - connected _ exotic lefschetz fibrations of theorem [ mainthm ] .
as quick byproducts of our two step construction , we will also show that there are mostly nonholomorphic genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations with @xmath21 and @xmath22 , with any fundamental group @xmath23 ( remark [ noncomplex ] ) , and also that there exist an infinite family of pairwise non - diffeomorphic minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifolds in the homeomorphism classes of @xmath19 for @xmath24 ( corollary [ infinitecor ] ) .
next is a complementary result : [ scgeography ] any _ simply - connected _ minimal genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration @xmath25 with @xmath26 is homeomorphic to @xmath27 for some @xmath28 or to @xmath29 for @xmath30 .
this theorem will follow from our study of the _ geography _ of small minimal genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations in section [ geography ] . there
we analyze which pairs @xmath31 , where @xmath32 and @xmath33 are the number of dehn twists along nonseparating and separating curves in a positive factorization on a genus-@xmath0 surface , can possibly exist .
we will use a combination of obstructions coming from the algebraic topology and the seiberg - witten invariants of genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations ( lemmas [ constraints ] and [ atmost30 ] ) to determine the list of homeomorphism classes that can possibly support any simply - connected genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration with @xmath6 ( theorem [ scgeography ] ) .
the only possible case we have not been able to realize by a minimal simply - connected genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration so far is when @xmath34 and the total space is homeomorphic to @xmath35 .
this is the exception noted in the theorem , which we are inclined to believe exists .
we would like to remark that minimal , decomposable genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations in the homeomorphism class of @xmath36 are already present in the literature : as shown by fintushel and stern , knot surgery on the elliptic surface @xmath37 with a genus-@xmath14 fibered knot yields a genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration , and this fibration decomposes into two smaller fibrations on complex ruled surfaces @xcite , which has been seen as a very special example up until now . also preceding our results are a few other examples of minimal simply - connected genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations for larger @xmath38 and @xmath39 , which have been obtained through lantern substitutions corresponding to rational blowdowns : for again @xmath36 by endo and gurtas @xcite and for @xmath40 with @xmath41 by akhmedov and park @xcite . in section [ evensmaller ]
, we will show that luttinger surgeries along fibered lagrangian tori in small genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations over surfaces of positive genera can be used to produce minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifolds in even smaller homeomorphism classes ( theorem [ thm : evensmaller ] ) . per theorem [ scgeography ] , this can only be achieved by dropping the fibered aspect , and thus these examples always involve a couple of luttinger surgeries that destroy the fibration structure .
we will prove : [ mainthm3 ] there exist decomposable minimal genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations over @xmath42 and @xmath43 which are equivalent via luttinger surgeries to minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifolds homeomorphic to @xmath8 and @xmath9 , respectively .
the only other examples of minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifolds in theorem [ mainthm3 ] were given by akhmedov and park in @xcite , and later by fintushel and stern for @xmath8 in @xcite .
the vantage point in our constructions is that departing from lefschetz fibrations allows us to carry on fairly simple fundamental group calculations , and the resulting exotic @xmath1-manifolds are easy to describe in terms of handle decompositions ( remark [ experts ] ) .
let us finish by turning back to the fundamental point underlying our work initiated here .
as discussed above , _ any _ symplectic @xmath1-manifold , let it be fake , exotic , or else , would arise from a positive factorization for a lefschetz fibration or a pencil .
our analysis of genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations show that minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifolds homeomorphic to smaller number of blow - ups of @xmath10 , @xmath44 or @xmath45 will only come from positive factorizations in the mapping class group of higher genera surfaces .
we will carry on our work in this direction elsewhere .
_ acknowledgements . _
the main results of this article were presented at the great lakes geometry conference in ann arbor and the fukaya categories of lefschetz fibrations workshop at mit back in march 2015 ; we would like to thank the organizers for motivating discussions .
we also thank hisaaki endo and tom mark for their comments .
the first author was partially supported by the nsf grant dms-@xmath46 and the simons foundation grant @xmath47 .
we start with a quick review of basic definitions and properties of lefschetz fibrations and factorizations in mapping class groups of surfaces .
the reader can turn to @xcite for more details .
we will then present several preliminary results on the algebraic and differential topology of genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations , which we make repeated use of in the rest of the paper .
a _ lefschetz fibration _ on a closed , smooth , oriented @xmath1-manifold @xmath48 is a smooth surjective map @xmath49 whose critical locus consists of finitely many points @xmath50 , at which and at @xmath51 there are local complex coordinates ( compatible with the orientations on @xmath48 and @xmath52 ) with respect to which @xmath53 takes the form @xmath54 .
we say @xmath25 is a _
genus-@xmath55 lefschetz fibration _ for @xmath55 the genus of a _ regular fiber _ @xmath56 of @xmath53 .
hereon we use the term lefschetz fibration only when the set of critical points @xmath57 is nonempty , often referred as the lefschetz fibration being _ nontrivial_. we moreover assume that all the points @xmath50 lie in distinct _ singular fibers _ ; this can always be achieved after a small perturbation . a _ section _ of a lefschetz fibration @xmath25 is an embedded @xmath0-sphere @xmath58 intersecting all fibers of @xmath53 at one point , which , equivalently , is the image of a map @xmath59 such that @xmath60 . blowing down any collection @xmath61 of disjoint sections of self - intersection @xmath62 , one obtains a _ lefschetz pencil _ with _ base points _ @xmath63 .
it is shown by donaldson that every symplectic @xmath1-manifold admits a lefschetz pencil , whose base points can be blown up to arrive at a lefschetz fibration @xcite .
conversely , as shown by gompf , for every nontrivial lefschetz fibration @xmath25 , one can construct a symplectic form on @xmath48 , with respect to which regular fibers and any preselected collection of disjoint sections of @xmath53 are symplectic @xcite .
a singular fiber of @xmath25 is called _ irreducible _ if the complement of the critical point in the fiber is connected , and is called _ reducible _ otherwise .
lefschetz singularities locally correspond to @xmath0-handle attachments to @xmath64 with framing @xmath62 with respect to the fiber framing , where the attaching circles of these @xmath0-handles , called _ vanishing cycles _ , are embedded curves in a regular fiber @xmath56 . with this in mind ,
an irreducible singular fiber is given by a nonseparating vanishing cycle , and a reducible singular fiber is given by a separating one .
when the latter is null - homotopic on @xmath56 , one of the fiber components becomes an _ exceptional sphere _ , an embedded @xmath0-sphere of self - intersection @xmath62 , which can be blown down without altering the rest of the fibration . a common way to construct new lefschetz fibrations
is the _ fiber sum _ operation : let @xmath65 be a genus-@xmath55 lefschetz fibration with regular fiber @xmath66 for @xmath67 .
the _ fiber sum _ is a genus-@xmath55 lefschetz fibration @xmath53 on @xmath68 , obtained by removing a fibered tubular neighborhood of each @xmath66 and then identifying the resulting boundaries via complex conjugation on @xmath69 times a chosen orientation preserving - diffeomorphism @xmath70 .
we say a lefschetz fibration @xmath25 is _ indecomposable _ if it can not be expressed as a fiber sum .
a lefschetz fibration @xmath25 is called _ relatively minimal _ if there are no exceptional spheres contained in the fibers . in this paper
, we will often say @xmath25 is _ minimal _ , if there are no exceptional spheres in @xmath48 at all .
there are nonminimal lefschetz fibrations which are relatively minimal and do not have any sections of self - intersection @xmath62 @xcite .
non - minimal @xmath25 of positive genera are known to be indecomposable @xcite . for genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations , which are the focus of this paper
, we will use the following short - hand notation : a genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration @xmath25 is said to be of _ type @xmath31 _ if it is relatively minimal and it has exactly @xmath32 nonseparating and @xmath33 separating vanishing cycles .
let @xmath71 denote a compact , connected , oriented surface genus @xmath55 with @xmath72 boundary components , and @xmath73 denote its _ mapping class group _ , the group composed of orientation - preserving self homeomorphisms of @xmath71 which restrict to the identity along @xmath74 , modulo isotopies that restrict to the identity along @xmath74 as well .
we write @xmath75 , and @xmath76 for simplicity .
we denote by @xmath77 the positive ( right - handed ) dehn twist along the simple closed curve @xmath78 .
let @xmath79 be a _
nonempty _ collection of simple closed curves on @xmath71 , which do not become null - homotopic when @xmath74 is capped off by disks , and let @xmath80 be a collection of @xmath72 curves parallel to distinct boundary components of @xmath71 . for a collection @xmath81 of @xmath72 integers , if the relation @xmath82 holds in @xmath73 , then we call the word @xmath83 on the left - hand side a _ positive factorization of length @xmath84 _ of the mapping class @xmath85 in @xmath86 . capping off
@xmath74 induces a homomorphism @xmath87 , under which @xmath83 maps to a similar positive factorization of length @xmath84 of the identity element @xmath88 .
the positive factorization in ( [ factorization ] ) above gives rise to a genus-@xmath55 lefschetz fibration @xmath25 with @xmath84 critical points and @xmath72 disjoint sections @xmath89 of self - intersection @xmath90 @xcite .
identifying the regular fiber @xmath56 with @xmath91 , we can view the vanishing cycles of @xmath53 as @xmath92 .
in particular , we get all the information on the topology of reducible fibers ( how many there are and the genera of the fiber components they split ) and observe that @xmath25 is relatively minimal .
in fact , lefschetz fibrations can always be described in terms of positive factorizations .
the local monodromy around the singular fiber with vanishing cycle @xmath92 is @xmath93 , and thus , the global monodromy of the fibration around a disk containing all @xmath94 is a product of positive dehn twists , called a _
monodromy factorization_. the fact that the map extends over the base @xmath52 dictates that we get a positive factorization of the identity in @xmath95 . in the presence of sections @xmath89 , one can obtain a further lift of this factorization to @xmath73 , which yields a positive factorization @xmath83 as in ( [ factorization ] ) above @xcite when @xmath96 , there is indeed a one - to - one equivalence between genus-@xmath55 lefschetz fibrations up to isomorphisms ( orientation - preserving self - diffeomorphisms of the @xmath1-manifold and @xmath52 , which make the fibrations commute ) and positive factorizations of the identity element in @xmath95 up to _ hurwitz moves _ ( trading subwords @xmath97 with @xmath98 ) and _ global conjugations _ ( trading every @xmath93 with @xmath99 , for some @xmath100 ) . when a lefschetz fibration @xmath25 is built from a positive factorization @xmath101 of a product of boundary twists in @xmath73 as in ( [ factorization ] ) , one has it easy with reading off several algebraic topological invariants of @xmath48 from @xmath83 .
if we assume @xmath102 for the moment , i.e. when @xmath53 has at least one section , we have @xmath103 where @xmath104 denotes the subgroup of @xmath105 generated normally by @xmath79 . for @xmath106 standard generators of @xmath105 , we therefore get @xmath107 \cdots [ a_g , b_g ] , r_1 , \ldots , r_l \ , \rangle \ , , \ ] ] where each @xmath108 is a relation obtained by expressing @xmath92 ( oriented arbitrarily ) in @xmath106 . when @xmath109 , i.e. when it is not known from the positive factorization that the fibration has a section , @xmath110 is given by a similar presentation with possibly one additional nontrivial relation .
the euler characteristic of @xmath48 is given by @xmath111 .
a simple formula for the signature of @xmath48 is also available when all @xmath79 are fixed by a hyperelliptic involution on @xmath91 , in which case @xmath25 is called _
hyperelliptic_. since this condition always holds when @xmath112 ( per @xmath113 being hyperelliptic ) , for the purposes of this paper , we will content ourselves with this closed formula , which reads @xmath114 @xcite , where @xmath32 and @xmath33 are the number of nonseparating and separating curves in the collection @xmath79 . one can also define @xmath115 as the first chern class and @xmath116 as the holomorphic euler characteristic for any almost complex structure compatible with say a gompf symplectic form on @xmath25
. we will often find it more convenient to appeal to the numerical invariants @xmath117 and @xmath116 , even though they are determined by @xmath118 and @xmath119 via @xmath120 and @xmath121 .
summarizing the above for the case of genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations , we have : [ charnumbers ] if @xmath25 is a genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration of type @xmath31 , then * @xmath122 , * @xmath114 , * @xmath123 , * @xmath124 .
next lemma gathers a collection of necessary conditions on @xmath32 and @xmath33 for @xmath25 to be a genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration of type @xmath125 , listed in an increasing order of complexity in terms of involved arguments .
these all together will provide very powerful constraints on the existence of genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations .
[ constraints ] if @xmath25 is a genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration of type @xmath31 , then * @xmath126 , * @xmath127 , * @xmath128 .
the first relation is well - known .
the first homology group of @xmath113 is @xmath129 , where any dehn twist along a nonseparating curve corresponds to @xmath130 and any dehn twist along a nontrivial separating curve corresponds to @xmath131 . from the monodromy factorization of @xmath25 we then deduce that @xmath132 is a multiple of @xmath133 .
the second relation will follow from a lengthy play with the characteristic numbers of a genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration . picking an irreducible fiber component @xmath66 of self - intersection @xmath62 from each reducible singular fiber
, we obtain a disjoint collection of @xmath33 embedded tori .
the homology classes @xmath134 $ ] , for @xmath135 , generate an @xmath33-dimensional subspace @xmath136 of @xmath137 , to which the restriction of the intersection form @xmath138 is negative - definite . on the other hand ,
the first chern class of an almost complex structure associated to @xmath53 evaluates on a regular fiber @xmath56 as @xmath139 , so @xmath140\neq 0 $ ] in @xmath137 . since @xmath140 \in v^{\perp}$ ] , the orthogonal complement of @xmath136 with respect to @xmath138 , and since @xmath141 is nondegenerate
, there exists a class @xmath142 in @xmath143 with negative square .
thus we get an @xmath144-dimensional subspace @xmath83 of @xmath137 generated by @xmath142 and all @xmath145 , on which @xmath138 is negative - definite .
we conclude that @xmath146 now from the equalities @xmath147 @xmath148 we derive @xmath149 combining it with @xmath150 above , we get @xmath151 since @xmath25 should have at least one nonseparating vanishing cycle @xcite , we have @xmath152 .
so from @xmath153 we get : @xmath154 . since @xmath155 is even , we have @xmath156 , or equivalently @xmath157 .
lastly , if we take the fiber sum of two copies of @xmath25 , then the resulting genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration @xmath158 , _ the double of @xmath25 _ , is minimal .
it is observed by stipsicz @xcite that @xmath159 , so by the work of taubes @xcite , @xmath160 .
we easily calculate @xmath161 and @xmath162 ( by novikov additivity ) to conclude that @xmath163 . in turn ,
@xmath164 , which implies @xmath128 .
finally , we consider a special class of positive factorizations we will work with .
let @xmath83 be a positive factorization of the form @xmath165 in @xmath73 , where @xmath166 are products of positive dehn twists along curves which do not become null - homotopic when @xmath74 is capped off .
if the product @xmath167 , as a mapping class , commutes with some fixed @xmath168 , we can produce a new positive factorization @xmath169 , where @xmath170 denotes the conjugate factorization @xmath171 in particular , if @xmath172 ( and thus @xmath173 ) is a positive factorization , then for _ any _ @xmath174 , we get a new positive factorization @xmath169 , since boundary parallel dehn twists are central in @xmath73 .
we claim that in this case , a lefschetz fibration @xmath175 constructed from @xmath176 is always minimal .
our assumption on the dehn twist curves in @xmath166 implies that @xmath177 .
it follows that @xmath178 is a fiber sum of two nontrivial genus @xmath177 lefschetz fibrations constructed from the positive factorizations @xmath166 @xcite . by a theorem of usher on _
symplectic sums _
@xcite ( or see @xcite[theorem 1 ] for a simpler proof set only for fiber sums of lefschetz fibrations ) , @xmath179 is minimal .
hence we have the following conclusion , which will become our main criterion when arguing the minimality of certain lefschetz fibrations we will construct in this paper : [ minimalityprop ] let @xmath178 be a lefschetz fibration constructed from a positive factorization @xmath180 in @xmath95 , where @xmath166 are positive factorizations themselves , and @xmath174 any mapping class in @xmath95 .
then @xmath179 is a minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifold .
we note that when @xmath174 is a dehn twist @xmath181 , the symplectic lefschetz fibration @xmath178 prescribed by @xmath180 is obtained from the symplectic lefschetz fibration @xmath25 prescribed by @xmath165 via _ fibered luttinger surgery _
this is a special instance of _ luttinger surgery _ , where one cuts out a weinstein tubular neighborhood of an embedded lagrangian torus @xmath182 in a symplectic @xmath1-manifold @xmath48 and glues it back in differently in a way that the symplectic form in the complement extends @xcite .
the new symplectic @xmath1-manifold @xmath179 is determined by @xmath183 , along with a primitive curve @xmath184 on @xmath182 and an integer @xmath185 , called the _ surgery curve _ and the _ surgery coefficient_. in the case of fibered luttinger surgery above , the _ fibered lagrangian torus _
@xmath182 in @xmath25 is obtained by taking the parallel transport of @xmath186 over a loop @xmath187 enclosing all the lefschetz critical values coming from @xmath172 , and one chooses the surgery curve as @xmath186 and the surgery coefficient @xmath188 to arrive at @xmath178 .
similar to measuring the size of a @xmath1-manifold @xmath48 by the rank of @xmath189 , we will measure the size of a genus-@xmath55 lefschetz fibration @xmath25 by what amounts to @xmath189 once the genus @xmath55 is fixed : by the number of critical points @xmath84 . for which values of @xmath190 a genus-@xmath55 lefschetz fibration with @xmath84 critical points would qualify to be called `` _ _ small _ _
'' is a question contingent to the formulation of the focus problem ( as in the case of `` small '' @xmath1-manifolds ) . in this paper , we will call a genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration small when @xmath191 . as we will observe in section [ geography ] , for a simply - connected @xmath48 ,
this is the case for a minimal @xmath25 precisely when @xmath48 is in the homeomorphism classes of @xmath192 with @xmath193 , or @xmath194 with @xmath195 .
this section is devoted to the study of ( very ) small indecomposable genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations . here
we outline a general procedure to produce positive factorizations in @xmath73 with small numbers of dehn twists . we will call this procedure _ reverse engineering _
, not only because it reflects well the very nature of this process as we will explain shortly , but also to draw a parallel to a similar procedure introduced by fintushel and stern under the same name that can be employed effectively to construct small exotic @xmath1-manifolds @xcite .
two invariants one can attach to a positive factorization @xmath83 in @xmath73 are : @xmath196 , the length of @xmath83 , i.e. the number of positive dehn twists in @xmath83 , and @xmath197 , the signature of @xmath83 , which is defined for any positive factorization via meyer s signature cocycle @xcite . the euler characteristic and the signature of the corresponding lefschetz fibration @xmath25
are determined by these two invariants via the identities @xmath198 and @xmath199 , and vice versa . moreover , since @xmath200 , where @xmath201 , we see that a small positive factorization corresponds to a genus-@xmath55 lefschetz fibration @xmath25 with small @xmath202 and @xmath203 .
now if we would like to have a genus-@xmath55 lefschetz fibration @xmath25 with small @xmath202 ( say @xmath204 , the smallest it can be ) , we observe that the best way to realize @xmath203 with the least number of singular fibers is when we have many reducible fibers : for each reducible fiber of @xmath25 counts into @xmath203 ( cf . the proof of lemma [ constraints ] , and also see ozbagci s calculation of the local signature contributions @xcite ) .
note that the a posteriori guidance in this case becomes a fact when @xmath112 .
we will therefore aim for small positive factorizations with _ many _ separating dehn twists .
we will need two well - known relations in the mapping class group @xmath73 of @xmath71 . recall that if two curves are disjoint then the corresponding dehn twists commute , and if two simple closed curves @xmath205 and @xmath206 on @xmath71 intersect transversely at one point , then we have the _ braid relation _
@xmath207 note that modifying a given positive factorization by braid relations amount to applying hurwitz moves , which do not change the isomorphism class of the corresponding lefschetz fibration .
secondly , let @xmath208 be a _ chain _ of simple closed curves on @xmath71 such that @xmath92 and @xmath209 are disjoint if @xmath210 and that @xmath92 and @xmath211 intersect at one point .
then a regular neighborhood of @xmath212 is a subsurface of @xmath71 with one boundary component , @xmath213 .
we then have the _ @xmath214-chain _ relation @xcite @xmath215 a notable consequence of this relation is that for any curve @xmath213 on @xmath71 bounding a subsurface @xmath216 , the separating dehn twist @xmath217 can be replaced by a product of @xmath218 nonseparating dehn twists . in turn ,
any positive factorization in @xmath73 , @xmath219 , can be turned into one with only nonseparating dehn twists .
if @xmath220 is a positive factorization obtained from @xmath83 by replacing @xmath217 with the product @xmath221 , then we have @xcite[proposition 3.9 ] : @xmath222 we can now describe our general construction scheme , which relies on reversing the above trick . to reverse engineer a small positive factorization of given length @xmath223 and signature @xmath224
, we first look for a _ model _ positive factorization @xmath220 , a known factorization , whose length @xmath225 and signature @xmath226 can be derived from @xmath223 and @xmath224 via @xmath227 by replacing a number of separating vanishing cycles . moreover we want @xmath220 to contain many dehn twists along chains of curves .
we then apply braid relations to @xmath220 , and also to any other word we derive at intermediate steps , to get factors conjugate to @xmath221 , for some @xmath228 .
these factors will be then traded with separating dehn twists to arrive at a positive factorization @xmath83 with desired @xmath223 and @xmath224 .
_ when @xmath112 : _ our procedure is much simplified and easier to demonstrate in this case .
suppose that @xmath219 .
there is only one type of nontrivial separating vanishing cycle other than curve parallel to boundary , and it splits off genus-@xmath14 subsurfaces on both sides , allowing only a @xmath0-chain substitution : @xmath229 moreover , when @xmath112 , @xmath223 and @xmath224 determine the number of nonseparating and separating vanishing cycles , @xmath32 and @xmath33 .
call the positive factorization _ of type @xmath31 _ in this case . to produce a small positive factorization of type @xmath31 in @xmath230
, we look for a model positive factorization with only @xmath231 nonseparating vanishing cycles , and then employ braid relations to get subwords conjugate to @xmath232 . note , moreover , that we can employ lemma [ constraints ] first to check whether a positive factorization with such @xmath233 is even plausible ( see section [ geography ] ) . _
an easy example : _ let us demonstrate how quickly one can reverse engineer positive factorizations of types @xmath234 and @xmath235 in @xmath236 . here , we need a model factorization of type @xmath237 , and there are not so many of them ! the well - known analogue of the chain relation for a @xmath238-chain @xmath239 yields the positive factorization in @xmath236 @xmath240 which will be our model factorization @xmath220 .
here we have simplified our notation by letting @xmath241 denote the dehn twist @xmath93 along @xmath92 .
( we may assume that the curves @xmath92 are given in figure 1 , where one of the boundary components of @xmath242 is capped off . ) since @xmath243 are disjoint from @xmath244 , the factors @xmath245 and @xmath246 commute .
we may rewrite @xmath220 as @xmath247 where @xmath248 is a product of @xmath249 positive dehn twists that are all conjugates of @xmath250 . by the @xmath0-chain relation ,
we get new positive factorizations @xmath251 ( or @xmath252 and @xmath253 of @xmath254 in @xmath236 , which are of types @xmath234 and @xmath235 , respectively . here
@xmath255 ( resp .
@xmath256 ) is the boundary component of a regular neighborhood of @xmath257 ( resp .
@xmath258 ) .
it can shown that the conjugation of the last factorization by the inverse of @xmath259 is equal to a lift of the well - known positive factorization of the identity obtained by matsumoto we will discuss shortly . in @xcite
can also be obtained by the same method ; this will appear in @xcite . ] , @xmath92 , @xmath260 , @xmath261 , @xmath255 , @xmath262 , @xmath263 on @xmath264 , and @xmath265 generators @xmath266.,width=408 ] [ curves ] our aim in this section is to derive the smallest genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration .
this is equivalent to find a factorization of the identity in the mapping class group @xmath113 of the smallest length .
well - known relation , also obtained above , is of type @xmath267 .
so the length of the smallest factorization is less than or equal to @xmath268 . by lemma [ constraints ]
, there is no factorization of length less than @xmath269 , and if there is a factorization of length @xmath269 then @xmath270 .
suppose that we have a factorization of the identity of type @xmath271 . by trading three separating dehn twists by @xmath272 nonseparating dehn twists
, we get a factorization of of type @xmath273 . we know
a factorization of this type is @xmath274 where @xmath92 are simple the curves in figure 1 ; the closed surface @xmath43 is @xmath264 together with a disk glued along the boundary .
this is our starting point : we will go backward starting from ( [ eqn : l40 ] ) , so that the positive factorization ( [ eqn : l40 ] ) will be our model for reverse engineering a positive factorization of type @xmath271 .
instead of doing this computation in @xmath43 we will do it in @xmath264 instead , so that the lefschetz fibration corresponding to the factorization will have a section of square @xmath62 . in the mapping class group @xmath275 , consider the @xmath1-chain relation @xmath276 which turns into ( [ eqn : l40 ] ) when a disk is glued to @xmath264 . from the braid relation
, we see that @xmath277 for @xmath278 . using this
we obtain @xmath279 we note that the factors @xmath280 , @xmath281 , and @xmath282 on the right all commute with each other : this can be seen from the fact that @xmath282 fixes the curves @xmath283 and @xmath284 , and @xmath281 fixes the curves @xmath285 and @xmath286 . starting with the @xmath1-chain relation ( [ eqn:4-chain ] ) and then applying braid relations and the fact that dehn twists about disjoint curves commute in @xmath275
, we get @xmath287 keeping in mind that @xmath288 is in the center of @xmath275 , we conjugate both sides of this equality by @xmath289 and get @xmath290 where @xmath291 and @xmath292 . here
, we also used the fact that @xmath293 commutes with @xmath294 and @xmath295 .
the use of the braid relations and @xmath296 give @xmath297 where @xmath298 , @xmath299 and @xmath300 .
this may be rewritten as @xmath301 finally , by the @xmath0-chain relation , we write @xmath302 and @xmath303 to arrive at the desired result @xmath304 the nonseparating curves @xmath260 , and the separating curves @xmath305 are as shown in figure 1 .
set @xmath306 , so it is a positive factorization of @xmath217 in @xmath275 and let @xmath307 be the corresponding lefschetz fibration of type @xmath271 , with a section of self - intersection @xmath62 . since any genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration should have at least @xmath269 singular fibers @xcite , which is also deduced from lemma [ constraints ] , @xmath307 realizes the smallest possible genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration : [ thesmallest ] the positive factorization @xmath308 in @xmath275 prescribes _ the smallest _ genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration .
we note that we do not claim that the smallest genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration is _ unique _ up to isomorphism .
however , it is true that the total space is unique up to diffeomorphism . as seen above ,
a smallest genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration is of type @xmath271 . by proposition [ difftypes ] given at the end of this section
, any such lefschetz fibration has total space diffeomorphic to @xmath309 .
for instance , the semi - stable holomorphic genus-@xmath0 fibration with @xmath269 critical points constructed by xiao in @xcite , even though it lacks any further information on its monodromy or the total space , would be supported on the same manifold .
we finish by giving an explicit presentation of @xmath310 induced by @xmath311 . in a group @xmath312 ,
let @xmath313 denote the inverse of @xmath205 and let @xmath314 $ ] denote the commutator @xmath315 .
since the lefschetz fibration @xmath307 has a section , we get a presentation of @xmath310 , from the monodromy , with generators @xmath316 as in figure 1 , and with the following defining relators : @xmath317[a_2,b_2]=1 , \label{eqn : prestn0 } \\ & \phantom{o } & a_1 r^2=1 , \label{eqn : prestn1 } \\ & \phantom{o } & a_1 \bar{b}^2_1 r a_2=1 , \label{eqn : prestn2 } \\ & \phantom{o } & a_1 \bar{b}^4_1 r a_2 \bar{r } a_2 = 1 , \label{eqn : prestn3 } \\ & \phantom{o } & a_1 b_1 \bar{a}_1 a_2 b_2 \bar{a}_2 = 1 , \label{eqn : prestn4 } \\ & \phantom{o } & a_1 b_1 \bar{a}_1 \bar{b}_2 \bar{a}_2 r = 1,\label{eqn : prestn5 } \\ & \phantom{o } & [ r , \bar{a}_2 ] = 1 , \label{eqn : prestn6}\\ & \phantom{o } & [ a_1 , b_1 ] = 1 . \label{eqn : prestn7}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath318 . the relators ( [ eqn : prestn1]),([eqn : prestn2 ] ) ,
, ( [ eqn : prestn7 ] ) come from the vanishing cycles @xmath319 respectively .
the relations ( [ eqn : prestn0 ] ) and ( [ eqn : prestn7 ] ) imply that @xmath320=1 $ ] .
we may then rewrite the relation ( [ eqn : prestn4 ] ) as @xmath321 with this new relation , all the other relations either trivialize or become @xmath322 which shows that @xmath323 can be generated by @xmath324 .
thus @xmath110 is a free abelian group of rank @xmath0 generated by @xmath325 and @xmath326 ( also by @xmath325 and @xmath327 ) .
the positive factorization @xmath83 in @xmath236 of type @xmath235 we reverse engineered as a sampler at the end of section [ sec:3.1 ] is a lift of a well - known positive factorization constructed by matsumoto @xcite , which we will favor over @xmath83 because of its neatly symmetric presentation .
for the simple closed curves @xmath328 on @xmath264 given in figure 1 , we also have @xcite : @xmath329 in @xmath275 .
the positive factorization @xmath330 of @xmath331 then gives matsumoto s genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration of type @xmath235 , with a section of self - intersection @xmath62 .
the fundamental group @xmath332 of @xmath333 admits a presentation with generators @xmath334 and with relations @xmath335[a_2,b_2]=1 , \nonumber \\ & \phantom{o } & a_1a_2=1 , \label{eqn : prestn8 } \\ & \phantom{o } & a_1 \bar{b}_1 a_2 \bar{b}_2 = 1 , \label{eqn : prestn9 } \\ & \phantom{o } & b_2b_1 = 1 , \label{eqn : prestn10 } \\ & \phantom{o } & [ a_1,b_1 ] = 1 , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is easily seen to be a free abelian group of rank @xmath0 generated by @xmath323 and @xmath327 ( also by @xmath325 and @xmath326 ) .
the last four relations come from the vanishing cycles @xmath336 and @xmath255 , respectively .
three more positive factorizations will be needed in our later constructions .
the first one is the positive factorization we obtained in the process of deriving @xmath311 .
that is , we can trade back @xmath337 in @xmath311 with @xmath338 and obtain a positive factorization @xmath339 of @xmath288 in @xmath275 .
let @xmath340 be the corresponding genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration of type @xmath341 .
the fundamental group @xmath342 has a presentation with generators @xmath316 and with relations @xmath343 together with the additional relations @xmath344 induced by the new vanishing cycles @xmath285 and @xmath286 .
an easy calculation shows that @xmath342 is isomorphic to the cyclic group @xmath345 of order two , and is generated by @xmath325 .
the second one is derived from @xmath346 by trading one @xmath337 with @xmath338 , so we get a positive factorization @xmath347 of @xmath217 in @xmath275 .
let @xmath348 be the corresponding genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration of type @xmath234 .
as we already had @xmath349 generated by @xmath350 , adding the new relations induced by @xmath243 above gives @xmath351 .
the last positive factorization is well - known : for @xmath239 the curves given in figure 1 , one gets a lift to @xmath275 of a positive factorization of the hyperelliptic involution on @xmath43 , which can be then squared to get @xmath352 taking this positive factorization @xmath353 , we arrive at a genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration @xmath354 of type @xmath355 .
since the vanishing cycles @xmath356 represent the free homotopy classes of @xmath357 respectively , we easily see that @xmath358 .
we now give a sufficient condition for the total space of a genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration @xmath25 to be a rational or ruled surface , which allows one to easily identify the _ diffeomorphism _ type of @xmath48 .
the proof of the next lemma generalizes a circle of ideas employed by sato in @xcite .
[ rationalruled ] let @xmath25 be a genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration of type @xmath31 .
if @xmath359 , then @xmath360 , where @xmath361 and @xmath362 .
let @xmath25 be a genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration satisfying the conditions of the lemma .
to give our proof by contraposition , assume that @xmath48 is not a rational or a ruled surface .
let @xmath363 be a minimal model for @xmath48 , so @xmath364 for some non - negative integer @xmath72 .
it is easily seen that @xmath365 . by taubes @xcite and li - liu @xcite , any minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifold which is not rational or ruled has a non - negative @xmath366 .
it follows that @xmath367 on the other hand , there exist @xmath72 disjoint exceptional spheres @xmath368 in @xmath48 , each one of which is a positive multisection of @xmath25 ( see @xcite or for the most explicit discussion @xcite[proof of theorem 1 ] ) , and we have @xmath369 combining the two inequalities we obtain @xmath370 , that is , @xmath371 . by contraposition , we conclude that @xmath372 implies @xmath48 is rational or ruled , so it is diffeomorphic to either @xmath10 , an @xmath52-bundle over a riemann surface @xmath373 , or a blow - up of these .
note that @xmath48 can not be minimal : minimal rational or ruled surfaces have signature @xmath13 or @xmath14 , whereas for any _ nontrivial _
genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration ( which we always assume to be the case ) we have @xmath374 .
the same argument rules out @xmath375 .
therefore the diffeomorphism type of @xmath48 can be uniquely identified as @xmath376 for some non - negative integers @xmath377 and @xmath378 .
these integers can be easily calculated as @xmath379 and @xmath380 , and from lemma [ charnumbers ] we arrive at the given calculations of @xmath377 and @xmath185 in terms of @xmath32 and @xmath33 . with the constraints from lemma [ constraints ]
, there are very few possibilities for a genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration of type @xmath31 with @xmath359 .
namely , @xmath381 , @xmath234 and @xmath355 .
the lemma above nevertheless makes it possible to identify the diffeomorphism types of the total spaces of these small genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations given earlier in section [ smalllfs ] : [ difftypes ] any genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations of types @xmath382 and @xmath383 have total spaces @xmath384 , @xmath385 , @xmath386 and @xmath387 , respectively , and they are indecomposable .
in particular the lefschetz fibrations @xmath307 , @xmath388 , @xmath389 , @xmath354 have total spaces diffeomorphic to these ruled manifolds , in the given order .
although this proposition gives a unified answer , we would like to point out that partial results were already known : total spaces of the particular fibrations @xmath390 and @xmath391 were already known to matsumoto , who constructed them as double branched covers of rational ruled surfaces @xcite , and the case of a potential @xmath271 fibration was covered by sato in @xcite ( also see @xcite ) . [
( 16,2 ) ] a genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration of type @xmath341 presents a borderline case for our lemma above , for which we can stretch our arguments to identify the _ homeomorphism _ class of @xmath392 , the total space of the particular fibration @xmath340 we have constructed earlier . in this case , from @xmath393 , we get @xmath394 . by @xcite , we conclude that @xmath392 is either twice blow - up of a symplectic calabi - yau surface , or it is a rational or a ruled surface . as @xmath395 , the latter is ruled out . as in @xcite[proof of proposition 4.8 ] , one can then conclude that @xmath392 is homeomorphic to the enriques surface blown - up twice .
here we will determine which simply - connected @xmath1-manifolds with @xmath6 can admit minimal genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations . [ atmost30 ] for @xmath396 ,
only the following pairs @xmath31 can be realized as a _ minimal _ genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration of type @xmath31 : * @xmath397 , and * @xmath398 .
let @xmath25 be a minimal genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration of type @xmath31 .
since @xmath48 should have at least one nonseparating vanishing cycle @xcite , we will assume @xmath399 .
since it is a minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifold , we have @xmath400 @xcite , which simplifies to @xmath401 thus we have a strengthened version of the third constraint in lemma [ constraints ]
. our proof will follow from a routine check to see which possible pairs @xmath31 meet the constraints of lemma [ constraints ] , along with the strengthened inequality above .
clearly , no @xmath31 can satisfy the inequality @xmath402 when @xmath403 . for @xmath404 ,
the pairs @xmath405 are eliminated using the second inequality in lemma [ constraints ] , and @xmath406 by @xmath402 .
lastly , for @xmath407 , the pairs @xmath408 are ruled out by the second inequality in lemma [ constraints ] , and @xmath409 by @xmath402 .
we are now ready to determine all possible homeomorphism types of small _ simply - connected _ minimal genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations : [ scgeography ] any _ simply - connected _ minimal genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration @xmath25 with @xmath26 is homeomorphic to @xmath27 for some @xmath28 or to @xmath29 for @xmath30 . let @xmath25 be a simply - connected _ minimal _ genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration with @xmath26 . since @xmath48 admits an almost complex structure and @xmath410 , @xmath202 should be odd ( e.g. @xmath116 should be an integer ) .
so @xmath204 or @xmath249 . from the equation ( [ b1 ] ) ,
@xmath411 . combining it with @xmath412 ,
we get @xmath413 so we are in the ballpark of lemma [ atmost30 ] , since @xmath396 for @xmath26 . for @xmath410 , the second constraint in lemma [ constraints ]
can be improved as follows : the inequality @xmath414 now reads @xmath415 , so with the inequality @xmath416 , which states @xmath150 , we arrive at @xmath417 . this last inequality then rules out a couple more @xmath31 pairs allowed by lemma [ atmost30 ] ; namely @xmath418 and @xmath419 .
we are thus left with the possible values @xmath420 when @xmath21 and @xmath421 when @xmath7 . in all these cases @xmath422 , so the presence of a reducible fiber implies that there exists a homology class with an odd intersection number .
it follows that @xmath48 can not be spin . as @xmath48 is assumed to be simply - connected , using freedman s seminal work
, we can conclude that @xmath48 is homeomorphic to @xmath27 or to @xmath29 . calculating @xmath203 for the above list of pairs @xmath31
, we see that @xmath28 and @xmath30 .
when the number of singular fibers @xmath423 , we obviously have @xmath396 , so our take of `` small '' minimal genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations are indeed limited to the types in lemma [ atmost30 ] , and in the simply - connected case , to the homeomorphism classes listed in theorem [ scgeography ] . using lemma [ charnumbers ] , we can determine the possible characteristic numbers @xmath366 and @xmath424 of all minimal simply - connected genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations with at most @xmath425 singular fibers , as in the _ geography problem _ for minimal simply - connected symplectic @xmath1-manifolds or complex surfaces .
we will realize these lattice points in the next section .
what if we consider the geography problem for small _ simply - connected _
genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations which are asked to be only relatively - minimal ?
we can give a fairly complete answer to this question as well .
the possible pairs @xmath31 ruled out in the proof of lemma [ atmost30 ] using minimality were the followings : any @xmath31 with @xmath403 , @xmath406 , and @xmath409 . for @xmath403 , the pairs @xmath426 , @xmath427 and @xmath428
are all ruled out by lemma [ constraints ] .
proposition [ difftypes ] shows that any genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration of type @xmath271 or @xmath429 has a non - simply - connected total space .
the pairs @xmath234 , @xmath355 are readily realized by the fibrations @xmath389 and @xmath391 discussed in the previous section .
the @xmath238-chain relation @xmath430 in @xmath113 hands a genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration of type @xmath237 . applying braid relations
we can rewrite the left - hand side of the above equation in the form of @xmath431 , where @xmath432 is a product of @xmath433 positive dehn twists . using the lantern relation so as to trade the subword @xmath434 with a product of three dehn twists , we obtain a new positive factorization of the identity in @xmath435 , which yields a genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration of type @xmath436 .
( one can in fact find five more similar subwords and iterate this procedure ; see @xcite . ) similarly , applying lantern relations to the positive word @xmath437 , endo and gurtas found the fibrations of the type @xmath438 @xmath341 @xcite .
all other pairs , except for @xmath439 , are realized by the fibrations constructed in the next section .
[ nonminimalremark ] going back to the main theme of our article , we can ask if there is a _
genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration @xmath440 where @xmath48 is an exotic @xmath27 or @xmath29 .
let @xmath25 be such a fibration of type @xmath31 , which we can assume to be relatively - minimal after blowing - down any exceptional spheres on the fibers .
let @xmath441 denote the symplectic kodaira dimension of @xmath48 .
clearly , @xmath48 is not a rational or a ruled surface , so there are three possibilities by the work of sato : ( i ) @xmath442 , @xmath443 or @xmath444 ; ( ii ) @xmath445 , @xmath443 and @xmath446 ; ( iii ) @xmath447 , @xmath448 and @xmath449 @xcite[theorems 5.5 . and 5.12 ] .
we observe that ( iii ) is not possible , since the only possible types @xmath355 and @xmath237 have @xmath450 .
on the other hand ( i ) or ( ii ) are possible only if @xmath48 is an exotic @xmath451 surface blown - up once or twice ; the only possible types in this case being @xmath436 or @xmath237 by similar arguments . hence one does not get any exotic @xmath1-manifolds via nonminimal genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations , except possibly for those whose minimal models are exotic @xmath451 surfaces .
here we will construct minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifolds which are homeomorphic to small number of blow - ups of @xmath10 and @xmath452 , starting with the most interesting examples : exotic symplectic rational surfaces fibered by genus-@xmath0 curves . for each @xmath455 ,
let @xmath456 be the lefschetz fibration prescribed by the positive factorization @xmath457 , so that we have genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations of types of @xmath458 , @xmath459 and @xmath460 . by proposition [ minimalityprop
] , each one of them is minimal .
moreover , if we assume that @xmath461 is simply - connected , we calculate @xmath462 using the equation @xmath414 . as already argued in theorem [ scgeography ] ,
@xmath461 is then homeomorphic to @xmath463 , for @xmath464 , but certainly not diffeomorphic to it , since the latter are nonminimal .
thus , it remains to show that for appropriate choices of mapping classes @xmath465 , we can indeed get @xmath466 .
each @xmath457 contains the non - conjugated word @xmath467 , for @xmath468 or @xmath0 . as shown in section [ smalllfs ] , the relations induced by the vanishing cycles prescribed by either @xmath467 , when added to the presentation @xmath469[a_2,b_2]=1 \ ,
\rangle$ ] , already give an abelian group generated by @xmath325 and @xmath326 .
we obtain a presentation for @xmath470 by adding further relations induced by the vanishing cycles coming from the conjugated word @xmath471 , @xmath472 or @xmath473 , which clearly will be an abelian quotient of @xmath474 .
therefore , it suffices to understand these additional relations in the first integral homology group @xmath475 , the generators of which we will identify with @xmath316 .
the upshot of the above discussion is that we can choose the desired @xmath465 based on its action on @xmath476 . using the picard - lefschetz formula we can easily calculate the effect of the dehn twist @xmath477 on the homology class of a curve @xmath206 as @xmath478 = [ b ] + m ( a \cdot b ) [ a ] \
, \in h_1(\sigma_2 ) , \ ] ] where @xmath479 is the algebraic intersection number for the oriented curves @xmath205 and @xmath206 .
we will express @xmath465 as products of dehn twists to further simplify our calculations , and we will indeed show that a simple multitwist will work for all !
let us first consider @xmath481 . in this case , from the earlier relations @xmath482
, we see that the nonconjugated word @xmath311 induces the abelianized relations : @xmath483 whereas @xmath471 induces the following abelianized relations : @xmath484 the four relations together imply that @xmath485 and @xmath486 . hence @xmath487 for this choice of @xmath488 . for @xmath489 and @xmath490 , the nonconjugated word @xmath346 induces the abelianized relations : @xmath491 derived from the relations @xmath492 and @xmath493 .
now for @xmath489 , the abelianized relations above , induced by @xmath346 , together with those induced by @xmath494 given in @xmath495 immediately imply @xmath485 .
in turn , @xmath496 , so @xmath497 . we therefore get @xmath498 for the chosen @xmath499 .
the calculation for @xmath490 is even simpler .
@xmath473 induces the following abelianized relations : @xmath500 which , together with those above induced by @xmath346 , kill all the generators .
thus @xmath501 for @xmath502 we have chosen .
the existence of minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifolds in the above homeomorphism classes was already established . as shown by donaldson in his seminal paper @xcite , for @xmath504 blow - ups of @xmath10 , the dolgachev surface
@xmath505 was the first example ; for @xmath506 , kotschick proved that barlow s surface was minimal @xcite ; and for @xmath507 , the first example was obtained by jongil park s breakthrough article utilizing rational blowdowns @xcite . as we mentioned in introduction , examples of minimal , decomposable , genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations in the homeomorphism class of @xmath36 were obtained previously by fintushel and stern @xcite .
[ noncomplex ] with a small variation of the above constructions as in @xcite , we can also produce minimal genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration with any prescribed abelian group of rank at most @xmath0 : let @xmath508 and let @xmath509 , where @xmath510 and @xmath511 are nonnegative integers .
let @xmath512 be the lefschetz fibration with monodromy @xmath457 with @xmath513 .
a very similar calculation shows that @xmath514 has an abelian presentation @xmath515 .
hence , we get symplectic @xmath516 , with @xmath517 and @xmath518 , and any prescribed abelian fundamental group of rank at most @xmath0 . , @xmath519 and @xmath520 is given in a recent preprint of akhmedov and monden using the lantern substitution @xcite .
akhmedov pointed out to us that they have now updated their arxiv paper to include some nonexplicit examples with @xmath521 . ] for each fixed @xmath464 , infinitely many of these symplectic fibrations have total spaces which can not be a complex surface .
here is a quick argument : by the enrique - kodaira classification , a complex surface with odd first betti number is either of type vii or elliptic .
however , any minimal elliptic surface with odd betti number has euler characteristic zero , whereas for any minimal type vii surface it is @xmath0 .
so any @xmath461 with odd @xmath522 does not admit a complex structure , and we have infinitely many of them ( with @xmath523 for varying @xmath32 ) . very recently ,
rana , tevelev and urza have given an elaborate proof of the simple - connectivity of the craighero - gattazzo surface @xcite , which was shown earlier by dolgachev and werner to carry a holomorphic genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration @xcite .
the authors also showed that the dolgachev surface @xmath505 admits a holomorphic genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration .
it would be certainly interesting to know whether these holomorphic fibrations are equivalent to ours , and if there is a holomorphic counterpart of our genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration with @xmath524 as well .
the same question goes for the genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations with @xmath7 we construct below .
note that by the work of siebert and tian @xcite any genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration without reducible fibers ( satisfying a mild condition on its monodromy ) is holomorphic , but as we observed in the previous section , _ every _ minimal genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations with @xmath6 contains reducible fibers .
we will now construct minimal symplectic genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations whose total spaces are homeomorphic to blow - ups of @xmath45 .
this time we will define new positive factorizations of @xmath453 in @xmath275 using all of @xmath525 given in section [ smalllfs ] : letting @xmath531 be the lefschetz fibration prescribed by the positive factorization @xmath528 for @xmath532 , we obtain genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations of the types @xmath533 .
they are all minimal by proposition [ minimalityprop ] , and once we show that @xmath534 is simply - connected , we can once use theorem [ scgeography ] again to conclude that @xmath534 is an exotic @xmath535 , for @xmath532 . to prove that @xmath536 , observe that we already have relations induced by a _ subcollection _ of the vanishing cycles , killing @xmath265 .
this is the case for the subcollection coming from @xmath537 , @xmath538 , @xmath539 and @xmath437 , as we have shown in the previous subsection for the first two words , and in section [ smalllfs ] for the last two .
since the separating curve @xmath255 is disjoint from @xmath540 , we have @xmath541 .
so the vanishing curves in @xmath537 are contained in the vanishing curves of @xmath542 .
every @xmath528 contains one of these subwords , and therefore the corresponding @xmath534 is simply - connected .
as we have noted in introduction , we expect that there are also minimal , decomposable genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations in the homeomorphism class of @xmath35 , which we have not succeeded in constructing yet . on the other hand ,
the existence of minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifolds in the above homeomorphism classes were previously shown by other authors .
the first examples for @xmath544 blow - ups of @xmath45 were given by friedman and morgan @xcite and stipsicz and szabo @xcite ; for @xmath545 by gompf , using symplectic fiber sums @xcite ; and for @xmath546 by doug park using the same technique @xcite .
the explicit construction of @xmath534 moreover allows us to produce an infinite family of minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifolds in each homeomorphism class @xmath543 , for @xmath532 , which will follow from the following lemma : let @xmath547 be positive factorizations ( of the identity element ) in @xmath95 , with @xmath165 , [ infinite ] and let @xmath48 be the total space of the lefschetz fibration prescribed by @xmath83 with assume that there is a nonseparating simple closed curve @xmath548 on @xmath91 which is trivial both in @xmath549 and in @xmath550 , where @xmath551 and @xmath552 are the subgroups of @xmath105 normally generated by the curves in positive factorizations @xmath172 and @xmath553 , respectively .
then there exist an infinite family of pairwise non - diffeomorphic minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifolds ( resp .
irreducible @xmath1-manifolds which do not admit any symplectic structures ) all homeomorphic to @xmath48 .
the proof relies on the following illustrious theorem of fintushel and stern : if there exists an embedded symplectic torus @xmath182 in a simply - connected symplectic @xmath1-manifold @xmath48 with @xmath554 such that @xmath555 ^ 2=0 $ ] and @xmath556 , then one can perform _ knot surgery _ operation along fibered knots with different alexander polynomials to produce an infinite family of pairwise non - diffeomorphic symplectic @xmath1-manifolds in the same homeomorphism class as @xmath48 @xcite . using non - fibered knots with different alexander polynomials
, one can similarly produce an infinite family of irreducible @xmath1-manifolds none of which can admit symplectic structures .
now let @xmath547 be positive factorizations in @xmath95 , with @xmath165 , and @xmath548 be a nonseparating curve on @xmath91 which is trivial both in @xmath549 and in @xmath550 , for @xmath557 .
there exists a nonseparating curve @xmath186 on @xmath91 intersecting @xmath548 at one point .
since @xmath172 , as a mapping class , stabilizes any nonseparating curve on @xmath71 , we can take a parallel transport of @xmath186 over a curve @xmath187 enclosing the lefschetz critical values corresponding to @xmath172 to produce a lagrangian torus @xmath182 fibered over @xmath187 in the symplectic lefschetz fibration @xmath25 constructed from @xmath83 .
it follows from our assumption on @xmath548 that in @xmath48 , the torus @xmath182 intersects an immersed @xmath0-sphere @xmath558 , which is composed of two immersed disks bounding the curve @xmath548 viewed on a regular fiber over @xmath187 .
thus , if only such @xmath548 exist , we get a lagrangian torus @xmath182 in @xmath48 with @xmath559 ( since by seifert - van kampen , it is normally generated by the meridian @xmath560 of @xmath182 , which in this case bounds an immersed disk ) and @xmath555 \neq 0 $ ] in @xmath189 ( since @xmath561 ) . by gompf
s trick , any homologically essential lagrangian becomes symplectic after a local perturbation of the symplectic form @xcite , which necessarily has square zero .
this is the symplectic torus @xmath182 we need in order to invoke fintushel and stern s theorem .
[ infinitecor ] there exists an infinite family of pairwise non - diffeomorphic minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifolds ( resp .
irreducible @xmath1-manifolds which do not admit any symplectic structures ) in each homeomorphism class @xmath543 , for each @xmath532 . in @xmath562 , @xmath563 , @xmath564 , @xmath565 , we can take @xmath548 to be any @xmath260 appearing in the right most @xmath311 factor . similarly in @xmath566 , @xmath567 , @xmath568 , any @xmath261 in the right most @xmath346 factor would do .
lastly , by taking an even simpler conjugation , @xmath569 , we can make it easier to spot the desired @xmath548 in @xmath542 .
let us first verify that this still results in a simply - connected @xmath570 .
the relations induced by the vanishing cycles coming from the nonconjugated word @xmath571 already give a presentation of the cyclic group @xmath345 generated by @xmath325 .
the group @xmath572 is calculated by adding further relations coming from the conjugated word @xmath573 .
so all we need to see is that the latter kills @xmath325 . for @xmath569
, the abelianized relation @xmath574 coming from @xmath573 , together with the @xmath575 relation coming from @xmath311 , implies that @xmath485 .
thus @xmath576 . since @xmath577 is disjoint from @xmath578 , we have @xmath579 both in @xmath573 and in @xmath311 .
so we can take @xmath580 . relying on our explicit construction of the smallest lefschetz fibration @xmath307
, we can construct minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifolds in the homeomorphism classes of @xmath192 and @xmath581 for even smaller @xmath38 and @xmath39 . as dictated by theorem [ scgeography
] , this can only be achieved after giving up on the fibered aspect of our previous constructions of course .
below , we will content ourselves with demonstrating our ideas just for a couple examples , namely for @xmath582 and @xmath583 , the smallest values we are able to strike .
we will obtain the desired simply - connected minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifolds by generalizing our earlier constructions in two ways : first , we will build small lefschetz fibrations _ over @xmath373 _ with @xmath584 ; and second , we will perform luttinger surgeries along fibered lagrangian tori which no longer need to preserve the fibration structure .
the notion of a lefschetz fibration , along with all the associated definitions , can be easily extended to maps @xmath585 for any @xmath586 . in this case
, a positive factorization also contains a product of @xmath377 commutators @xmath587 $ ] in @xmath73 , that is : @xmath588\cdots [ \mathcal{a}_h , \mathcal{b}_h]\cdot t_{c_l } \cdots t_{c_2 } t_{c_1 } = t_{\delta_1}^{k_1 } \cdots t_{\delta_m}^{k_m } , \ ] ] which prescribes a _ symplectic _
genus-@xmath55 lefschetz fibration @xmath25 _ over @xmath373 _
when @xmath96 @xcite .
the euler characteristic of @xmath48 is given by @xmath589 , and when @xmath112 , we have the identical signature formula @xmath590 , where @xmath32 and @xmath33 are the number of nonseparating and separating @xmath79 . as shown by stipsicz , when @xmath584 , an additional perk is that @xmath48 is always minimal @xcite . however in this case @xmath48 can never be simply - connected , since @xmath110 surjects onto @xmath591 .
clearly , we can add any commutator @xmath587=1 $ ] in @xmath73 to a positive factorization of a non - minimal lefschetz fibration @xmath440 , and pass to a positive factorization of the type @xmath592 of a decomposable , minimal @xmath593 over a positive genus surface .
it is easy to see that adding @xmath377 many copies of the trivial commutator , i.e. when @xmath594 , we moreover have @xmath595 assuming @xmath596 .
now , adding one trivial commutator to the smallest positive factorization @xmath311 we have constructed , we get a symplectic genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration @xmath597 over @xmath42 with a section @xmath598 .
we have @xmath599 , @xmath600 , and @xmath601 . by a slight abuse of notation
, we also denote by @xmath316 the curves on a subsurface @xmath264 of a regular fiber @xmath602 representing the standard generators of @xmath603 , but isotoped to be in minimally intersecting position . in the same fashion
, we pick @xmath604 on the base @xmath42 , which also denote the standard generators of @xmath605 , while making sure they avoid a disk @xmath606 containing @xmath607 .
lastly let @xmath608 be a parallel copy of @xmath323 on @xmath264 and @xmath609 be a parallel copy of @xmath206 on @xmath610 .
we can then assume that the parallel transport of any @xmath611 over any @xmath612 is a lagrangian torus @xmath182 fibered over @xmath187 .
through the trivialization @xmath613 , we can view @xmath182 as a lagrangian @xmath614 with respect to a product symplectic form on @xmath615 .
we claim that performing the following four disjoint luttinger surgeries in @xmath616 : @xmath617 we obtain a simply - connected @xmath1-manifold @xmath618 . here
, we encode the surgery data by the triple @xmath619 , as in @xcite . per the choices we made above
, we can appeal to the meticulous work of baldridge and kirk in @xcite to deduce that @xmath620 has a presentation with generators @xmath621 , where the following relations hold ( among many others we do not include ) : @xmath622=1 , \\\ ] ] @xmath623 where @xmath624 are the meridians of the surgered lagrangian tori , each given by some commutator of the pairs @xmath625 , @xmath626 , @xmath627 and @xmath628 .
since @xmath629 and @xmath630=1 $ ] , it follows that @xmath327 and @xmath206 commute .
so from @xmath631 , we get @xmath632 . for all other @xmath624 are commutators of @xmath205 , the remaining relations in the last line above imply @xmath633 , and in turn @xmath634 .
thus @xmath635 .
clearly @xmath636 and @xmath637 .
since any exceptional sphere can be isotoped away from lagrangian tori @xcite , and for each luttinger surgery there is an inverse luttinger surgery , minimality of @xmath616 implies that @xmath618 is minimal .
hence @xmath638 is a minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifold which is an exotic @xmath639 .
our construction of a minimal symplectic @xmath640 can be built on the same construction scheme : now add _ two _ trivial commutators to the positive factorization @xmath311 to obtain a symplectic genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibration @xmath641 over @xmath43 with a section @xmath642 . here
we calculate @xmath643 , @xmath644 , @xmath645 .
choosing @xmath646 on the fibers as before , and the curves @xmath647 in the same fashion on the base @xmath43 , away from the critical values , we can define lagrangian tori @xmath614 for any @xmath648 and @xmath649 .
now let @xmath650 be the result of the following disjoint luttinger surgeries : @xmath651 then we get a presentation for @xmath652 with generators @xmath653 , where the following relations hold ( again , among many others we will not need ) : @xmath622=1 , [ b_2 , b]=1 , \\\ ] ] @xmath654 where the additional meridians @xmath655 are some commutators of the pairs @xmath656 and @xmath657 . by arguments identical to those we had before ( now repeating them also for @xmath142 and @xmath658 ) , we observe that these relations suffice to kill all the generators .
we thus have a simply - connected minimal symplectic @xmath650 , which is an exotic @xmath9 .
[ thm : evensmaller ] luttinger surgeries along fibered lagrangian tori in the symplectic genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations @xmath659 over @xmath42 and @xmath641 over @xmath43 yield minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifolds @xmath618 and @xmath650 homeomorphic to @xmath8 and @xmath9 , respectively .
we can easily use different genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations over @xmath42 and @xmath43 in our construction by adding other commutators to the positive factorization @xmath311 instead of the trivial one .
for instance , if we add @xmath660= [ t^{-1}_{c_1 } t_{c_4 } , 1]$ ] instead , we can produce a simply - connected @xmath1-manifold without the first two luttinger surgeries in each case . on this note , recall from section [ preliminaries ] that conjugating the first factors @xmath311 or @xmath346 with @xmath661 in the positive factorizations of @xmath662 we had earlier amount to fibered luttinger surgeries .
thus , several of the simply - connected minimal genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations @xmath456 and @xmath531 we have constructed earlier could be obtained from genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations corresponding to nonconjugated products via a pair of fibered luttinger surgeries along @xmath663 and @xmath664 , where @xmath187 is a curve on the base enclosing all the critical values coming from the first factor @xmath311 or @xmath346 .
[ experts ] a few words for the experts : in a nutshell , the manifolds @xmath618 and @xmath650 can be seen to be produced by first taking a symplectic sum of @xmath665 and @xmath666 , and then performing luttinger surgeries along lagrangian tori in the latter summand .
this has been a well - exploited approach to successfully construct many small @xmath1-manifolds ( e.g @xcite ) , where the true hardship had been in finding the desired symplectic surfaces with well - understood fundamental group complements , and then obtaining a manageable fundamental group presentation for the resulting @xmath1-manifold to argue that it is simply - connected .
we believe these issues are significantly easier to handle ( compare e.g. with the examples of @xcite ) when we use the lefschetz fibration @xmath307 as above .
similarly , describing a handle decomposition of our @xmath618 and @xmath650 is a relatively easier task departing from the handle decompositions of @xmath659 , @xmath641 .
d. auroux , _ mapping class group factorizations and symplectic @xmath1-manifolds : some open problems , _ problems on mapping class groups and related topics , 123132 , proc .
sympos . pure math .
74 , amer .
soc . , providence , ri , 2006 . y. matsumoto , _ lefschetz fibrations of genus two - a topological approach _ - , proceedings of the 37th taniguchi symposium on topology and teichmller spaces , ( s. kojima , et .
al . , eds . ) , world scientific , 1996 , 123148 . | we explicitly construct genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations whose total spaces are minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifolds homeomorphic to complex rational surfaces @xmath2 for @xmath3 , and to @xmath4 for @xmath5 .
complementarily , we prove that there are no minimal genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations whose total spaces are homeomorphic to any other simply - connected @xmath1-manifold with @xmath6 , with one possible exception when @xmath7
. meanwhile , we produce positive dehn twist factorizations for several new genus-@xmath0 lefschetz fibrations with small number of critical points , including the smallest possible example , which follow from a reverse engineering procedure we introduce for this setting .
we also derive exotic minimal symplectic @xmath1-manifolds in the homeomorphism classes of @xmath8 and @xmath9 from small lefschetz fibrations over surfaces of higher genera . |
t dwarfs are a spectral class of brown dwarfs distinguished by the presence of ch@xmath3 , h@xmath2o , and h@xmath2 collision - induced absorption ( cia ) in the near - infrared @xcite , and heavily pressure - broadened and absorption at optical wavelengths @xcite .
these objects have effective temperatures ( t@xmath8s ) ranging from @xmath01300 k at the transition between l and t dwarfs @xcite to @xmath0750 k for the latest - type t dwarf 2mass 0415@xmath90935 @xcite .
t dwarfs therefore comprise the coldest and intrinsically faintest brown dwarfs currently known , and as such are key objects for testing brown dwarf and extrasolar giant planet atmosphere models @xcite , probing the extreme low - mass end of the initial mass function @xcite , and expanding the census of the sun s nearest neighbors . for the past two years
, we have been conducting a wide - field ( 74% of the sky ) search for t dwarfs in the two micron all sky survey ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* hereafter 2mass ) .
this three - band , near - infrared ( @xmath10 ) imaging survey samples the peak of the t dwarf spectral energy distribution , and is therefore the most sensitive wide - field sky survey currently available for identifying these cold brown dwarfs .
our results to date include the discovery of the bright , and therefore potentially very close ( @xmath11 @xmath12 8 pc ) t dwarf 2mass 1503 + 2525 ( * ? ? ?
* hereafter paper i ) and three new t dwarfs identified in the southern hemisphere ( * ? ? ?
* hereafter paper ii ) . here
we present the discovery of seven new t dwarfs in both northern and southern hemispheres , all of which were verified by low resolution ( r@xmath0150 ) spectroscopic observations obtained with the irtf 3.0 m spex instument @xcite .
in @xmath13 2 we describe near - infrared imaging and spectroscopic observations of t dwarf candidates and comparison stars made using spex and other imaging instruments . in @xmath13 3 we analyze these data , classifying both the new t dwarfs and background stars , including four potential ultracool ( spectral types later than sdm7 ) subdwarfs , using the low - resolution spectra and spectral comparison stars .
we also report line strengths for the 1.243/1.252 @xmath1 doublet in six t dwarfs observed at moderate resolution ( r@xmath01200 ) with spex , and proper motions for all of the t dwarf discoveries . in @xmath13 4
we discuss our results , including distance and tangential velocity estimates , signatures of gravity and/or metallicity in the near - infrared spectrum of 2mass 0034 + 0523 , and prospects for future discoveries .
results are summarized in @xmath13 5 .
our selection of t dwarf candidates from the 2mass working point source database ( wpsd ) is described in detail in paper i. in brief , we chose point sources with @xmath14 , @xmath15 or @xmath16 , no optical counterpart with 5@xmath17 in the usno a2.0 catalog @xcite or by visual inspection of digitized sky survey ( dss ) images , no catalogued minor planet counterpart , and @xmath18
. revised 2mass photometry for these sources is given in the all sky data release ( adr ) point source catalog , and is based on improved photometric calibration , particularly at @xmath19-band ( see cutri et al .
2003 , @xmath13iv.1.c ) . in some cases
the new photometry pushes our candidates out of the initial selection criteria .
however , these candidates were retained , and their adr photometry is reported throughout this article . to date , a total of 912 t dwarf candidates have been observed as part of this search program .
follow - up near - infrared imaging observations of t dwarf candidates are required to eliminate the majority of contaminant sources .
these include minor planets whose ephemerides were unknown or were not incorporated at the time of 2mass data processing , and image artifacts that remain in the 2mass wpsd .
imaging observations also provide second epoch astrometry for confirmed t dwarfs that may be used to measure proper motion .
we therefore conducted a series of imaging campaigns using various instrumentation on 1 - 4 m class telescopes .
the spex instrument is comprised of a 1024@xmath201024 insb array as the primary detector for the spectrograph , and a second 512@xmath20512 insb array imaging / guiding camera with a @xmath21 field - of - view ( 0@xmath512 pixels ) .
we made use of the latter detector to image t dwarf candidates during our 2003 september 1719 ( ut ) irtf observing campaign .
conditions varied from clear to slightly hazy with seeing between 0@xmath550@xmath57 at @xmath19-band .
dithered exposure pairs of 30 s each were obtained at @xmath19-band and pair - wise subtracted for inspection .
we verified that each exposure was at least as deep as the corresponding 2mass image .
table 1 lists those sources that were absent in follow - up images .
five of these were identified as known asteroids using the small - body search tool maintained by the jet propulsion laboratory solar system dynamics group .
] , and were typically catalogued as asteroids after the 2mass observation .
the remaining sources have ecliptic latitudes @xmath22 and are therefore also likely to be as yet uncataloged minor planets .
gunn-@xmath23 band images of four new t dwarfs identified in this sample ( see @xmath13 3.1.2 ) were obtained using the palomar 1.5 m facility ccd camera on 2003 september 27 ( ut ) .
conditions were clear and photometric with 0@xmath57 seeing .
the ccd camera is a red - sensitive , 2048@xmath202048 , thinned detector with 24@xmath1 pixels .
pixel scale on the sky is 0@xmath5378 .
only the central 1024@xmath201024 region was used for a total field of view of 6@xmath245 on a side .
raw images were bias - subtracted and divided by a median - combined flat field frame generated from a series of lamp on / off exposures reflected from the interior dome .
all four t dwarf targets were detected in these images to sufficient signal - to - noise ( s / n @xmath25 10 ) to obtain reliable astrometry .
the lick 3.0 m gemini instrument @xcite is a dual 256@xmath20256 hgcdte / insb camera with 0@xmath568 pixels and a @xmath26 field of view .
j - band images of 2mass 1209@xmath91004 were obtained using this instrument on 2003 may 12 ( ut ) ; conditions were clear with seeing of 1@xmath52 .
observations were similar to those described in paper i , with a dithered pair of 30 s exposures obtained and differenced to produce the final science image ; no additional calibration was required for the astrometric measurements .
the aat 3.9 m iris2 near - infrared imager and spectrograph is a 1024@xmath201024 hgcdte array camera with 0@xmath54486 pixels and a 7@xmath247@xmath207@xmath247 field of view .
we used this camera to observe 2mass 1231 + 0847 , 2mass 1828@xmath94849 , and 2mass 2331@xmath94718 on 2003 june 11 and 2003
september 10 and 13 ( ut ) .
these data are part of an imaging program testing the use of ch@xmath3 filters to efficiently identify and classify t dwarf candidates ; the program is described in detail in tinney et al .
( in preparation ) .
conditions during the observations were non - photometric , with occasional cloud patches , although data were only obtained when the sky was clear .
seeing ranged from 0@xmath592@xmath50 .
targets were observed in dithered sets of three 40 s exposures in each of the ch@xmath3-s and ch@xmath3-l filters , which bisect the @xmath27-band about the 1.6 @xmath1 ch@xmath3 band .
images were processed via the iris2 data reduction pipeline , which is modeled after the ukirt orac - dr pipeline , and includes bad pixel masking , flat fielding , and alignment and re - sampling of the dithered exposures to produce a final , calibrated image .
a total of 66 t dwarf candidates and 33 spectral comparison stars were observed using the low - resolution prism mode of the spex spectrograph primarily over two observing runs , 2123 may 2003 and 1719
september 2003 ( ut ) .
a log of observations for the candidates and comparison stars are given in tables 2 and 3 , respectively .
conditions during the may run ranged from light to heavy cirrus with seeing of 0@xmath550@xmath59 at @xmath19-band .
one object , 2mass 0034 + 0523 , was observed on 5 september 2003 ( ut ) during clear conditions with similar seeing .
the prism mode of spex provides 0.72.5 @xmath1 continuous spectroscopy in a single order . using the 0@xmath55 slit
, we obtained a resolution r@xmath0150 ; dispersion on the chip is 2030 pixel@xmath6 . for all observations ,
the instrument rotator was positioned at the parallactic angle to mitigate differential color refraction across the broad spectral band observed .
total integration times ranged from 12 ( bright m giant and supergiant stars ) to 1600 s , and were typically obtained in multiple pairs of 180 s exposures dithered along the chip for sky subtraction . except for a few low declination sources ,
the majority of objects were observed at airmasses @xmath28 . in all but one case , we observed a0 stars selected from the henry draper ( hd ) catalog shortly before or after the target observation and at a differential airmass @xmath29 0.1 for flux calibration .
internal flat - field and ar arc lamps were observed immediately after the a0 star observations for instrumental calibration .
six t dwarfs , including five of the discoveries presented here , were also observed using the cross - dispersed , moderate - resolution sxd mode of spex during the may and september runs .
these observations are summarized in table 4 .
we employed the same 0@xmath55 slit as the prism observations to obtain r@xmath01200 spectra from 0.92.4 @xmath1 in four orders ; an additional order subtending 0.810.95 @xmath1 was measured for the bright t5.5 2mass 1503 + 2525 .
pixel dispersion on the chip ranged from 2.7 to 5.3 pixel@xmath6 .
we observed all targets with the slit rotated to the parallactic angle in dithered pairs of 300 s each , with total integration times of 18003000 s. a0v
/ a0vn hd stars and internal calibration lamps were observed immediately after each target observation .
all data were reduced using the spextool package @xcite .
for both the prism and sxd datasets , science data were corrected for linearity , pair - wise subtracted , and divided by the corresponding median - combined flat field image .
spectral data were optimally extracted using the default settings for aperture and background source regions , and wavelength calibration was determined from arc lamp and sky emission lines .
multiple spectral observations for each source were then median - combined after scaling the spectra to match the highest signal - to - noise observation .
telluric and instrumental response corrections for the science data were determined using the method outlined in @xcite . for the prism observations ,
line shape kernels were derived from the arc lines ; for the sxd observations , they were derived from the 1.005 @xmath1 paschen @xmath30 line in the a0 calibrator spectra .
adjustments were made to the telluric spectra to compensate for differing line strengths and velocity shifts .
final calibration was made by multiplying the observed target spectrum by its respective telluric correction spectrum .
for the sxd data , multiple orders for each target exposure were scaled and combined using the corresponding low - resolution prism spectrum as a relative flux template .
examination of the low - resolution spectra indicate that the majority of these candidate sources are late - type m dwarfs , based on the presence of weak h@xmath2o absorption at 1.4 and 1.9 @xmath1 ; co absorption at 2.3 @xmath1 ; tio and vo bands at 0.71.0 @xmath1 ; and feh , , and absorption at @xmath19-band .
this result is not unexpected , as many of these sources have @xmath31 , implying @xmath32 35 at the detection limit of the dss plates @xcite , typical for late - type m dwarfs @xcite .
the faintness of these objects also imply significant errors in their 2mass photometry , which explains in part their unusually blue @xmath33 colors . nevertheless , to better understand the nature of these contaminant sources , we classified their spectra by comparison to a suite of m- and l - type spectral standards and known objects , as listed in table 3 . a representative sample of these comparison spectra are shown in figure 1 . for the dwarfs , the strengthening of the 1.4 and 1.9 @xmath1 h@xmath2o bands , and 0.99 and 1.2 @xmath1 feh bands ; appearance of the 1.17 and 1.25 @xmath1 doublets ; weakening of the 0.76 , 0.82 , and 0.84 @xmath1 tio bands ;
shift in peak flux toward 1.3 @xmath1 ; and reddening of the 1.32.4 @xmath1 spectral energy distribution are all correlated with spectral type .
subdwarfs show distinctively stronger 0.99 @xmath1 feh absorption and weaker co and tio absorption than the dwarfs for equivalent h@xmath2o band strengths , as well as a shift in the peak of their spectral energy distributions to shorter wavelengths .
giant and supergiant m stars exhibit much deeper h@xmath2o bands and stronger vo , tio , and co absorption , but fairly weak or absent metal hydride bands and atomic lines .
using these diagnostics and the comparison spectra , we visually classified each of the observed sources that were not identified as t dwarfs . these classifications , which we estimate are accurate to within @xmath00.5 - 1.0 subtypes , are listed in table 2 ; uncertain numerical or luminosity classifications due to low s / n data are noted by a colon .
a large percentage of the late - type m dwarfs exhibit paschen @xmath7 emission ( 1.09 @xmath1 ) : 33% ( 6 of 18 ) of the m7-m7.5 dwarfs and 66% ( 12 of 18 ) of the m8-m8.5 dwarfs appear to be in emission , but none of the m5-m6.5 dwarfs . the observed emission is consistent with the high frequency ( @xmath0100% ) of h@xmath34 emission seen in the optical spectra of m7m8 dwarfs @xcite .
while most of the background sources exhibit spectral energy distributions and absorption features similar to the dwarf comparison stars , a handful of sources appear to be peculiar .
these include four objects that exhibit subdwarf characteristics .
as shown in figure 2 , 2mass 0142 + 0523 , 2mass 1640 + 1231 , and 2mass 1640 + 2922 all appear to be similar to or somewhat later than the sdm7.5 lsr 2036 + 5059 @xcite , with strong 0.86 , 0.99 , and 1.2 @xmath1 feh absorption ; weak 2.3 @xmath1 co absorption ; moderately strong 1.4 and 1.9 @xmath1 h@xmath2o absorption ; and a relatively blue 12.5 @xmath1 spectral slope .
another source , 2mass 0041 + 3547 , exhibits spectral features similar to the l1 standard 2mass 1439 + 1929 @xcite , but has stronger 0.86 and 0.99 @xmath1 feh absorption , weaker co , and a somewhat bluer 1.32.4 @xmath1 spectral slope .
this object may be a new early - type l subdwarf , similar to lsr 1610 - 0040 @xcite .
however , as there currently exists no classification scheme for ultracool subdwarfs at near - infrared wavelengths , we characterize these sources as candidate subdwarfs for the time being ; further spectral analysis will be presented in a future publication . it should be noted that only four subdwarfs later than type m7 are currently known @xcite .
finally , we address one additional background source , 2mass 1733 + 1529 , classified here as a dc 10 white dwarf based on its blackbody slope and absence of absorption lines ( figure 3 ) .
this object was selected because of its absence in the first generation palomar sky survey ( poss - i ) @xmath35-band plate ( figure 4 , left ) , although it is present on the @xmath36-band plate as well as the @xmath36- , @xmath35- ( figure 4 , right ) , and @xmath37-band plates of poss - ii .
the absence of this source in the poss - i @xmath35-band image was independently verified by m. gray and r. humphreys to a faint limit of @xmath38 19.520.0 using the minnesota automated plate scanner catalog , and by visual examination of poss - i prints available at the caltech astrophysics library .
2mass 1733 + 1529 is not listed in the @xcite white dwarf catalog ; and its small proper motion , 0@xmath505@xmath390@xmath504 yr@xmath6 , measured from lick 3 m gemini @xmath19-band imaging ( see @xmath13 3.3 ) , excludes it from the nltt @xcite and revised nltt @xcite proper motion catalogs . as this source is relatively bright in the optical ( @xmath35 = 16.9 in the usno - b1.0 catalog ; monet et al .
2003 ) , and given the absence of any obvious photographic anomaly , it is unclear as to why it was undetected on the poss - i @xmath35-band plate .
it is possible that 2mass 1733 + 1529 was obscured in this image by an eclipsing or transiting faint source , such as a low - mass stellar or substellar companion .
monitoring observations are planned to verify or place stringent constraints on this intriguing hypothesis .
seven of the candidates listed in table 2 exhibit clear absorption features of h@xmath2o ( 1.1 , 1.4 , and 1.9 @xmath1 ) and ch@xmath3 ( 1.3 , 1.6 , and 2.2 @xmath1 ) in their low - resolution spectra , characteristic of t dwarfs .
finder charts for these objects are given in figure 5 , low - resolution spectra are diagrammed in figure 6 , and spectrophotometric properties are listed in table 5 .
these objects exhibit a broad range of ch@xmath3 band strengths and near - infrared colors ( @xmath40 ) , encompassing early- , mid- , and late - type t dwarf spectral morphologies @xcite .
the new t dwarfs were classified by their low - resolution spectra following the technique of @xcite , which is based on the established mk process of spectral classification ( e.g. , morgan 1984 ) .
in addition to our candidates , we observed a set of five t dwarf spectral standards : sdss 0423@xmath90414 ( t0 ) , sdss 1254@xmath90122 ( t2 ) , 2mass 2254 + 3123 ( t4 ) , 2mass 0243@xmath92453 ( t6 ) , and 2mass 0415@xmath90935 ( t8 ) .
the t2 , t6 , and t8 standards are those established in @xcite , while the t0 and t4 standards were selected as part of an expanded list of spectral standards given in @xcite . to quantify our classifications , we used revised spectral indices from the latter reference which sample the major h@xmath2o and ch@xmath3 bands in the 12.5 @xmath1 region while avoiding strong telluric absorption regions .
these indices are defined as : @xmath41 @xmath42 @xmath43 @xmath44 and @xmath45 where @xmath46 designates the integrated flux between wavelengths @xmath47 and @xmath48 , and indices are defined as the ratio of flux at the base of the absorption band to the nearby pseudo - continuum region implies that no true continuum is present ; we therefore normalize to the local spectral maximum , or pseudo - continuum . ] .
these spectral indices were measured for all t dwarfs in our low - resolution spectral sample .
classifications for each index ( excluding the spectral standards ) were determined as the closest match to the standard values , allowing for subtypes halfway between the standard classes ( i.e. , integer subclasses ) .
final classifications for each object were determined as the mean of the individual index classifications , rounded off to the nearest 0.5 subclass .
table 6 lists the spectral indices and derived classifications for the new and previously known t dwarfs .
the scatter amongst individual index subtypes is typically 0.40.7 subclasses , with some objects exhibiting no scatter , justifying our 0.5 subclass precision . as a check , we compared derived subtypes to those from the literature for seven previously identified and classified t dwarfs ; all were consistent within 0.5 subclasses .
we also examined the behavior of the indices with spectral type , as shown in figure 7 ; all five indices show minimal scatter about a line connecting the standard values , again consistent with the adopted classification precision .
the scatter in these indices is in fact better than that seen in the classifications of @xcite and @xcite , reflecting overall higher signal - to - noise data and the improved spectral index definitions .
the spectral types for the t dwarf discoveries range from t3 ( 2mass 1209@xmath91004 ) to t7 ( 2mass 0034 + 0523 ) , the former object being the earliest - type t dwarf so far identified in our 2mass search .
as shown in figure 6 , the derived classifications are consistent with a monotonic increase in h@xmath2o and ch@xmath3 bandstrengths with spectral type .
moderate resolution spex spectra of six t dwarfs are shown in figure 8 .
these data reveal the complex h@xmath2o and ch@xmath3 molecular features in far greater detail than the prism spectra . while the s /
n of the higher resolution spectra are on average lower ( 1050% ) , most of the structure seen is real and repeats between the objects .
these data also resolve the 1.243/1.252 @xmath1 doublet , shown in detail in figure 8 , a key diagnostic of temperature at the brightest peak in the spectral energy distribution .
pseudo - equivalent widths ( pews ; equivalent width relative to the pseudo - continuum ) for these lines were measured following the method outlined in paper ii , directly integrating over the line profiles .
results are given in table 7 .
the strongest lines are found in the t5 2mass 2331@xmath94718 , which have pews of [email protected] and [email protected] for the 1.243 and 1.252 @xmath1 lines , respectively .
indeed , with the exception of the t5.5 2mass 0516@xmath90445 ( for which only low s / n data have been obtained ) , these are the strongest lines measured in any t dwarf to date @xcite . both 2mass 1503 + 2525 and 2mass 1231 + 0847 exhibit broadened lines , possibly due to rapid rotation or high photospheric pressure , the latter case indicative of high surface gravity .
also note the nearly absent lines in the t7 2mass 0034 + 0523 , due either to its low t@xmath8 or possibly metal deficiency ( see @xmath13 4.2 ) .
overall , the observed line strengths are in general agreement with previous work , with the strongest lines found amongst the t5 dwarfs and becoming progressively weaker toward the later spectral types .
proper motions for the t dwarf discoveries were measured using 2mass adr data and the follow - up imaging observations described in @xmath13 2.2 .
data analysis was similar to that described in paper ii .
we used 2mass catalog data as first epoch astrometry , while the follow - up images , taken roughly 35 years after the 2mass observations , comprised our second epoch dataset .
2mass sources within the re - imaged areas ( excluding the t dwarf ) were matched to detected sources on the follow - up images .
first - order coordinate solutions for the images were then determined by linear regression using this grid of background stars , allowing for the rejection of 3@xmath49 outliers ( i.e. , moving sources ) . for the iris2 ( ch@xmath3-s images only ) and ccd observations , @xmath01560 background sources were used , yielding positional uncertainties of 0@xmath510@xmath54 , equivalent to 2mass astrometric accuracy @xcite , and proper motion uncertainties of @xmath29 0@xmath51 yr@xmath6 . for the gemini observation of 2mass 1209@xmath91004 ,
only four background objects were available and astrometric uncertainties were assumed to be somewhat higher . using these coordinate solutions , the second epoch position of the t dwarf was computed and its motion derived .
we note that the agreement between proper motion determinations for 2mass 0034 + 0523 obtained with the palomar 60 ccd camera and aat iris2 lend confidence to the reliability of our measurements .
table 8 lists the resulting proper motions .
as expected for a nearby population of faint brown dwarfs , these objects have large motions in general , with 2mass 1231 + 0847 exhibiting the largest at 1@xmath555@xmath390@xmath507 yr@xmath6 .
this object would be easily identified in a near - infrared proper motion survey . on the other hand ,
two t dwarfs , 2mass 0407 + 1514 and 2mass 2331@xmath94718 , have motions below our sensitivity limits .
we discuss the associated tangential velocities for these t dwarfs below .
using the derived classifications and 2mass photometry , it is possible to estimate the spectrophotometric distances of our t dwarf discoveries .
we employed the polynomial @xmath19- and @xmath50-band absolute magnitude / spectral type relations from @xcite , based on parallax measurements from their own program and from @xcite .
distance estimates for each of the newly discovered t dwarfs were calculated in both bands ( with the exception of 2mass 0034 + 0523 which was not detected at @xmath50 by 2mass ) and for @xmath390.5 subclasses about the nominal classification .
final distances and uncertainties were determined by the mean and standard deviation of these estimates , respectively , and are listed in table 5 . assuming that they are single sources , all of the objects listed are within 25 pc of the sun , with the most distant object being the earliest - type t dwarf 2mass 1209@xmath91004 .
three objects , 2mass 0034 + 0523 , 2mass 1231 + 0847 , and 2mass 1828@xmath94849 , are at or within 10 pc from the sun within the reported uncertainties , with the first ( and latest - type ) object having an estimated distance of only [email protected] pc .
it should be noted that the uncertainties in these distance estimates do not take into account systematic deviations in the absolute magnitude / spectral type relation @xcite nor possible duplicity , and should be confirmed by parallax measurement . combining the distance estimates with the proper motion determinations from @xmath13 3.3
, we calculated tangential velocities for these t dwarfs , listed in table 8 .
the mean @xmath51 of those t dwarfs with detected motion is 43 km s@xmath6 with a standard deviation of 28 km s@xmath6 ; including the upper limits yields a somewhat lower mean of 33 km s@xmath6 .
this value is consistent with the mean @xmath51 for disk dwarfs ( 39 km s@xmath6 ; reid & hawley 2000 ) but is somewhat higher than that for field late - type m and l dwarfs ( 22 km s@xmath6 ; gizis et al .
2000 ) , suggesting that the t dwarfs in this sample may be drawn from a somewhat older population .
a similar difference in the @xmath51 distribution between field l and t dwarfs has also been noted by @xcite , and a mean age difference between these classes is predicted in field substellar mass function simulations @xcite .
this possible age segregation is consistent with the evolution of brown dwarfs , as an object of a given mass will evolve from warm ( l dwarf ) to cold ( t dwarf ) as it ages ; however , a larger sample must be considered before drawing any firm conclusions about the relative ages of the l and t dwarf field populations .
we note that the spectrophotometric distance of 2mass 1231 + 0847 is consistent within its uncertainties to the nearby ( [email protected] pc ; hipparchos ; perryman et al .
1997 ) k7v star gliese 471 , located roughly 8@xmath241 ( 6500 au ) to the northwest . indeed ,
2mass 1231 + 0847 was also identified in a parallel search for wide brown dwarf companions to nearby stars currently being conducted by j. d. kirkpatrick . however , while their direction of motion is nearly identical ( @xmath0230@xmath52 ) , 2mass 1231 + 0847 has a proper motion nearly twice as large as gliese 471 , and is therefore not a bound companion .
the t7 2mass 0034 + 0523 has the bluest @xmath33 color amongst the t dwarf discoveries , and it may be even bluer as 2mass photometry provides only an upper limit .
examination of near - infrared spectral data confirms this color , as 2mass 0034 + 0523 exhibits a fairly suppressed @xmath53-band peak in comparison to the rest of the t6t8 dwarfs observed .
this is quantified in figure 9 , which plots the logarithm of the spectral ratio @xmath54 as a function of spectral type for all of the t dwarfs observed .
spex prism data are ideally suited for this measurement , as the full near - infrared spectral range is sampled in a single order and no correction is required to match the relative scalings between the @xmath19- and @xmath53-bands .
the ratio exhibits a tight linear trend across the full spectral type range of t dwarfs , although there is a somewhat greater spread in values amongst the t5t6 dwarfs .
2mass 0034 + 0523 stands well above this trend , however , having the smallest value of @xmath55 , and hence the most suppressed @xmath53-band peak , in the entire sample .
the spectral properties of this source are reminiscent of the peculiar t6 2mass 0937 + 2931 @xcite , which not only has a very blue near - infrared color ( @xmath56 ; paper i ) , likely due to enhanced cia h@xmath2 absorption , but also strong absorption from the pressure - broadened 0.77 @xmath1 resonance doublet and the 0.99 @xmath1 feh band @xcite .
the enhanced pressure - sensitive features are symptomatic of a high pressure photosphere , which can exist on a brown dwarf with a high surface gravity ( i.e. , old and massive ) and/or a metal deficient atmosphere @xcite .
indeed , strong feh and cia h@xmath2 absorption are hallmarks of cool halo subdwarf spectra ( figure 1 ) , which are themselves typically older and metal - poor , and 2mass 0937 + 2931 has been interpreted as a possible thick disk or halo brown dwarf @xcite .
2mass 0034 + 0523 , like 2mass 0937 + 2931 , also has exceedingly weak 1.243/1.252 @xmath1 lines that may be due to reduced metallicity or higher surface gravity @xcite , although its late spectral type ( and hence cool temperature ) may be the dominant factor .
2mass 0034 + 0523 does not have a large @xmath51 as might be expected for a halo star , although on an individual basis this does not rule out its membership in an older kinematic population .
clearly , a more detailed study of both of these peculiar t dwarfs is needed to assess metallicity and/or gravity effects in cool brown dwarf spectra .
to date , we have observed roughly 70% of our 2mass search sample , identifying 31 t dwarfs , 8 of which have estimated or measured @xcite distances within 10 pc of the sun .
this is roughly consistent with the predicted numbers from paper i ( @xmath03545 t dwarfs ) , although we have uncovered less than half of the @xmath020 t dwarfs predicted to have distances less than 10 pc .
many of the latter are probably late - type t dwarfs , t@xmath8 @xmath29 1000 k , too faint to be detected by 2mass beyond a few parsecs .
in addition to these very low - luminosity sources , our search has identified one _ bona - fide _ ultracool halo subdwarf , the late - type sdl 2mass 0532 + 8246 @xcite , and now four candidate late - type subdwarfs requiring further verification .
in retrospect , the search criteria employed are well - suited for identifying these metal - deficient objects , which have red optical / near - infrared colors , peak in flux at @xmath19-band , and exhibit relatively blue @xmath33 colors due to enhanced cia h@xmath2 absorption @xcite .
such serendipitous discoveries provide a new opportunity for exploring the physical properties , particularly metallicity and age diagnostics , of very cool stars and brown dwarfs .
we have discovered seven new t dwarfs in the 2mass survey with spectral types ranging from t3 to t7 , spectrophotometric distances of 8.2 to 23 pc , and proper motions from our detection limit ( 0@xmath51 yr@xmath6 ) to 1@xmath555 yr@xmath6 .
this sample adds substantially to the current census of t dwarfs , now around 50 objects .
we have also identified four candidate ultracool subdwarfs , including one possible early - type l subdwarf , which share the blue near - infrared colors and red optical / near - infrared colors of our t dwarf discoveries .
we estimate that several t dwarfs remain to be identified in our sample , and possibly many more cool subdwarfs , yielding new targets in our quest to understand the observational properties of the lowest - mass stars and brown dwarfs in the solar neighborhood .
we thank our telescope operators bill golisch , dave griep , and paul sears , and instrument specialist john rayner , for their support during the irtf observations , and the irtf tac for its generous allocation of time for this project .
we also thank matt gray and roberta humphreys at the university of minnesota , jean mueller at palomar observatory , and the library staff at the caltech astrophysics library , for their assistance in obtaining , examining , and verifying poss - i images of 2mass 1733 + 1529 .
we are grateful to our referee for her / his prompt and thorough review of the original manuscript .
a. j. b. acknowledges support provided by nasa through hubble fellowship grant hst - hf-01137.01 awarded by the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , incorporated , under nasa contract nas5 - 26555 .
k. l. c. acknowledges support from a nsf graduate research fellowship .
this research has made use of the simbad database , operated at cds , strasbourg , france .
poss - i , poss - ii , serc , and aao @xmath35-band images were obtained from the digitized sky survey image server maintained by the canadian astronomy data centre , which is operated by the herzberg institute of astrophysics , national research council of canada .
the digitized sky survey was produced at the space telescope science institute under u.s .
government grant nag w-2166 .
the images of these surveys are based on photographic data obtained using the oschin schmidt telescope on palomar mountain and the uk schmidt telescope .
the plates were processed into the present compressed digital form with the permission of these institutions .
this publication makes use of data from the two micron all sky survey , which is a joint project of the university of massachusetts and the infrared processing and analysis center , funded by the national aeronautics and space administration and the national science foundation .
2mass data were obtained from the nasa / ipac infrared science archive , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration .
the authors wish to extend special thanks to those of hawaiian ancestry on whose sacred mountain we are privileged to be guests .
electronic copies of the spectra presented here can be obtained directly from the primary author .
lrlcccl 2mass j00344717@xmath93343404 & @xmath934 & 1998 oct 3 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 1999 xj197 + 2mass j02132776 + 1939028 & 6 & 1997 oct 19 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & + 2mass j02273983 + 1824524 & 4 & 1997 oct 20 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 2001 tl10 + 2mass j02322515 + 2942172 & 14 & 1997 nov 10 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & + 2mass j02381005 + 2725209 & 11 & 1997 nov 10 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & + 2mass j02470189 + 2200236 & 6 & 1997 oct 15 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & + 2mass j03153063 + 2101434 & 3 & 2000 nov 8 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & + 2mass j03483407 + 3231433 & 12 & 1998 jan 25 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 2002 aw2 + 2mass j04122822 + 1316535 & @xmath98 & 2000 nov 26 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2000 ua110 + 2mass j04185615 + 2527216 & 4 & 1997 nov 29 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & + 2mass j04265381 + 1158063 & @xmath910 & 1998 nov 18 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2001 ju3 + lcccccclcl 2mass j00013044 + 1010146 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 2003 sep 19 & 720 & 1.02 & hd 210501 & a0 v & m6v + 2mass j00115060@xmath91523450 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 18 & 720 & 1.29 & hd 219833 & a0 v & m7.5ve + 2mass j00335534@xmath90908247 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 2003 sep 19 & 720 & 1.15 & hd 1154 & a0 v & m8ve : + 2mass j00345157 + 0523050 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @xmath4 @xmath90.8 & 2003 sep 05 & 1800 & 1.05 & hd 5267 & a1 vn & t7 + 2mass j00412179 + 3547133 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 19 & 720 & 1.08 & hd 13869 & a0 v & sdl ?
+ 2mass j00552554 + 4130184 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 2003 sep 18 & 720 & 1.16 & hd 7215 & a0 v & m8ve : + 2mass j00583814@xmath91747311 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 18 & 720 & 1.28 & hd 219833 & a0 v & m6v + 2mass j01045111@xmath93327380 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 18 & 720 & 1.72 & hd 12275 & a0 v & m8v + 2mass j01151621 + 3130061 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 19 & 720 & 1.05 & hd 13869 & a0 v & m8.5ve + 2mass j01423153 + 0523285 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 2003 sep 17 & 720 & 1.05 & hd 18571 & a0 v & sdm7.5 ?
+ 2mass j01470204 + 2120242 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 2003 sep 18 & 720 & 1.09 & hd 7215 & a0 v & m7.5ve : + 2mass j01532750 + 3631482 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 18 & 720 & 1.10 & hd 7215 & a0 v & m6v + 2mass j03023398@xmath91028223 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 17 & 720 & 1.17 & hd 25792 & a0 v & m5.5v + 2mass j04035944 + 1520502 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 19 & 720 & 1.03 & hd 25175 & a0 v & m7v + 2mass j04070885 + 1514565 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 19 & 1080 & 1.01 & hd 25175 & a0 v & t5.5 + 2mass j04071296 + 1710474 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 19 & 720 & 1.00 & hd 25175 & a0 v & m8v + 2mass j04360273 + 1547536 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 18 & 720 & 1.00 & hd 25175 & a0 v & m6.5v + 2mass j11070582 + 2827226 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 23 & 1080 & 1.01 & hd 89239 & a0 v & m8ve + 2mass j11150577 + 2520467 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 2003 may 23 & 1080 & 1.01 & hd 89239 & a0 v & m7.5ve : + 2mass j11323833@xmath91446374 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 21 & 1200 & 1.00 & hd 101369 & a0 v & m7v + 2mass j11463232 + 0203414 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 22 & 1200 & 1.05 & hd 97585 & a0 v & m5.5v + 2mass j12095613@xmath91004008 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 22 & 1440 & 1.02 & hd 109309 & a0 v & t3 + & & & & 2003 may 23 & 1080 & 1.16 & hd 109309 & a0 v & + 2mass j12121714@xmath92253451 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 23 & 720 & 1.39 & hd 110649 & a0 v & m8ve + 2mass j12314753 + 0847331 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 21 & 1080 & 1.02 & hd 111744 & a0 v & t6 + 2mass j12575768@xmath90204085 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 22 & 1080 & 1.11 & hd 109309 & a0 v & sd : m5 + 2mass j13272391 + 0946446 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 2003 may 23 & 720 & 1.02 & hd 116960 & a0 v & m6v + 2mass j13593574 + 3031039 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 21 & 800 & 1.05 & hd 121626 & a0 & m7v + 2mass j14171672@xmath90407311 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 2003 may 22 & 1080 & 1.10 & hd 126129 & a0 v & m8ve : + 2mass j15243203 + 0934386 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 2003 may 22 & 720 & 1.04 & hd 136831 & a0 v & m7ve : + 2mass j15412408 + 5425598 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 21 & 1080 & 1.22 & hd 142282 & a0 & m8ve + 2mass j15561873 + 1300527 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 23 & 720 & 1.01 & hd 140729 & a0 v & m8.5ve + 2mass j15590462@xmath90356280 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @xmath4 0.3 & 2003 may 21 & 720 & 1.10 & hd 143396 & a0 & m8.5ve + 2mass j16304206@xmath90232224 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 22 & 720 & 1.09 & hd 145647 & a0 v & m8v + 2mass j16390818 + 2839015 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 23 & 720 & 1.02 & hd 145647 & a0 v & m7.5v + 2mass j16403197 + 1231068 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @xmath4 0.4 & 2003 may 21 & 720 & 1.01 & hd 151545 & a0 & sdm8 ? + 2mass j16403561 + 2922225 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 22 & 720 & 1.07 & hd 145647 & a0 v & sdm8 ? + 2mass j17252029@xmath90024508 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 2003 may 23 & 720 & 1.14 & hd 171149 & a0 v & m5v + 2mass j17330480 + 0041270 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 21 & 720 & 1.06 & hd 159835 & a0 & m7v + 2mass j17331764 + 1529116 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @xmath4 0.0 & 2003 may 21 & 720 & 1.01 & hd 159907 & a0 & dc 10 + 2mass j17364839 + 0220426 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 23 & 720 & 1.13 & hd 171149 & a0 v & m8v + 2mass j18112466 + 3748513 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 2003 may 22 & 720 & 1.07 & hd 174567 & a0 v & mid m : : + 2mass j18244344 + 2937133 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @xmath4 0.1 & 2003 may 23 & 720 & 1.08 & hd 165029 & a0 v & m6v + 2mass j18283572@xmath94849046 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 2003 sep 18 & 1080 & 2.7 - 2.8 & hd 177406 & a0 v & t6 + 2mass j18411320@xmath94000124 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 2003 sep 17 & 720 & 2.07 & hd 176425 & a0 v & m7.5ve : + 2mass j18530004@xmath94133275 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 2003 sep 18 & 720 & 2.10 & hd 176425 & a0 v & m7 pec + 2mass j19010601 + 4718136 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 2003 may 21 & 1440 & 1.13 & hd 177390 & a0 & t5 + 2mass j19240765@xmath92239504 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 21 & 1080 & 1.37 & hd 174072 & a0 v & m6v + 2mass j19312708 + 5948588 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 18 & 720 & 1.35 & hd 194354 & a0 vs & m5.5v + 2mass j19445221@xmath90831036 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 2003 sep 17 & 720 & 1.18 & hd 188489 & a0 v & m6v + 2mass j19522109@xmath95059169 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 18 & 720 & 3.04 & hd 183626 & a0 v & m6v + 2mass j19570817@xmath91627558 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 19 & 720 & 1.32 & hd 198787 & a0 v & m6v + 2mass j20494090 + 1140068 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 17 & 720 & 1.02 & hd 210501 & a0 v & m7.5v + 2mass j21100889 + 2132483 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 17 & 720 & 1.01 & hd 210501 & a0 v & m8v + 2mass j21105305 + 1903568 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 19 & 720 & 1.02 & hd 210501 & a0 v & m8.5ve + 2mass j21214516 + 2825375 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 19 & 720 & 1.06 & hd 210501 & a0 v & m7.5v + 2mass j21353463 + 2352085 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 19 & 720 & 1.06 & hd 210501 & a0 v & m7v + 2mass j22270083@xmath91231482 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 2003 sep 17 & 720 & 1.18 & hd 219833 & a0 v & m5.5v + 2mass j22425680 + 0720249 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 18 & 720 & 1.03 & hd 210501 & a0 v & m8ve : + 2mass j22453832@xmath90722060 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 17 & 720 & 1.12 & hd 219833 & a0 & m7 pec + 2mass j22465014@xmath90643357 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 17 & 720 & 1.12 & hd 219833 & a0 & m5v + 2mass j23270985 + 2341364 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 17 & 720 & 1.10 & hd 222749 & a0 v & m7.5ve : + 2mass j23312378@xmath94718274 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 17 & 720 & 2.7 - 2.8 & hd 216009 & a0 v & t5 + 2mass j23354680 + 1257273 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 18 & 720 & 1.02 & hd 210501 & a0 v & m8.5ve + 2mass j23363834 + 4523306 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 2003 sep 17 & 720 & 1.26 & hd 222749 & a0 v & m8v + 2mass j23480816 + 4052343 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 17 & 720 & 1.23 & hd 222749 & a0 v & m7.5v + 2mass j23592315@xmath91239079 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 18 & 720 & 1.22 & hd 219833 & a0 v & m7v + lcccccclcll 2mass j01514155 + 1244300 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 19 & 1080 & 1.03 & hd 13869 & a0 v & t1 : & 1 + 2mass j02431371@xmath92453298 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 2003 sep 17 & 1080 & 1.42 & hd 27616 & a0 v & t6 & 2 + 2mass j04151954@xmath90935066 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 17 & 1080 & 1.15 & hd 25792 & a0 v & t8 & 2 + 2mass j04234858@xmath90414035 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 17 & 720 & 1.10 & hd 31411 & a0 v & t0 & 1 + 2mass j11040127 + 1959217 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 21 & 960 & 1.02 & hd 101060 & a0 v & l4 & 3 + 2mass j11240487 + 3808054 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 22 & 360 & 1.05 & hd 98152 & a0 v & m8.5v & 3 + 2mass j12255432@xmath92739466ab & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 23 & 720 & 1.55 & hd 110141 & a0 v & t6/t8 : & 4,5 + 2mass j12545393@xmath90122474 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 22 & 720 & 1.08 & hd 109309 & a0 v & t2 & 6 + 2mass j14392836 + 1929149 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 23 & 360 & 1.00 & hd 122945 & a0 v & l1 & 7 + 2mass j14571496@xmath92121477 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 22 & 1080 & 1.33 & hd 133466 & a0 v & gl 570d , t8 & 8 + 2mass j15031961 + 2525196 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 2003 may 22 & 720 & 1.02 & hd 136831 & a0 v & t5.5 & 9 + 2mass j15261405 + 2043414 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 23 & 720 & 1.05 & hd 140729 & a0 & l7 & 10 + 2mass j16241436 + 0029158 & [email protected] & @[email protected] & @xmath4 0.0 & 2003 may 22 & 1440 & 1.09 & hd 145647 & a0 v & t6 & 11 + 2mass j16322911 + 1904407 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 22 & 1080 & 1.07 & hd 145647 & a0 v & l8 & 7 + 2mass j17072343@xmath90558249ab & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 23 & 960 & 1.19 & hd 171149 & a0 v & m9v / l3 & 12,13 + 2mass j17361766 + 1346225 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 21 & 180 & 1.05 & hd 165029 & a0 v & lp 508 - 14 , m4v & 14 + 2mass j17503293 + 1759042 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 23 & 1080 & 1.08 & hd 165029 & a0 v & t3.5 & 1 + 2mass j18261131 + 3014201 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 21 & 240 & 1.18 & hd 174567 & a0 vs & m8.5v & 15 + 2mass j19165762 + 0509021 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 19 & 200 & 1.04 & hd 189920 & a0 v & vb10 , m8v & 16 + 2mass j20282035 + 0052265 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 23 & 720 & 1.06 & hd 198070 & a0 vn & l3 & 17 + 2mass j20362186 + 5059503 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 18 & 720 & 1.18 & hd 194354 & a0 vs & lsr 2036 + 50 ; sdm7.5 & 15,18 + 2mass j20392378@xmath92926335 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 22 & 720 & 1.57 & hd 202941 & a0 v & m6v & 19 + 2mass j20491972@xmath91944324 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 19 & 360 & 1.34 & hd 198787 & a0 v & m7.5v & 19 + 2mass j20575409@xmath90252302 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 23 & 360 & 1.09 & hd 198070 & a0 vn & l1.5 & 20 + 2mass j21073169@xmath90307337 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 23 & 720 & 1.10 & hd 198070 & a0 vn & m9v & 3 , 21 + 2mass j21225635 + 3656002 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 18 & 720 & 1.05 & hd 209932 & a0 v & lsr 2122 + 36 ; esdm5 & 15,18 + 2mass j22120345 + 1641093 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 19 & 240 & 1.03 & hd 210501 & a0 v & m5v & 14 + 2mass j22282889@xmath94310262 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 17 & 1080 & 2.3 - 2.4 & hd 216009 & a0 v & t6.5 & 22 + 2mass j22341394 + 2359559 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 19 & 360 & 1.02 & hd 210501 & a0 v & m9.5v & 19 + 2mass j22541892 + 3123498 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 sep 18 & 720 & 1.04 & hd 209932 & a0 v & t4 & 2 + v * v1451 aql & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 22 & 12 & 1.16 & hd 185533 & a0 v & m5iii & 23 + v * z cep & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 22 & 72 & 1.27 & hd 203893 & a0 v & miab & 23 + sv * p 2312 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 2003 may 22 & 12 & 1.28 & hd 203893 & a0 v & m7iii & 23 + llccclc 2mass j00345157 + 0523050 & t7 & 2003 sep 19 & 3000 & 1.04 & hd 6457 & a0 vn + 2mass j12314753 + 0847331 & t6 & 2003 may 21 & 3000 & 1.08 & hd 111744 & a0 v + 2mass j15031961 + 2525196 & t5.5 & 2003 may 23 & 1800 & 1.01 & hd 131951 & a0 v + 2mass j18283572@xmath94849046 & t6 & 2003 sep 19 & 3000 & 2.7 - 2.8 & hd 177406 & a0 v + 2mass j19010601 + 4718136 & t5 & 2003 sep 19 & 2400 & 1.19 & hd 178207 & a0 vn + 2mass j23312378@xmath94718274 & t5 & 2003 sep 18 & 2400 & 2.5 - 2.6 & hd 216009 & a0 v + llccccc 2mass 0034 + 0523 & t7 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @xmath4 @xmath90.8 & [email protected] + 2mass 0407 + 1514 & t5.5 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & 19@xmath393 + 2mass 1209@xmath91004 & t3 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2mass 1231 + 0847 & t6 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + 2mass 1828@xmath94849 & t6 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & [email protected] + 2mass 1901 + 4718 & t5 & [email protected] & [email protected] & @[email protected] & 20@xmath393 + 2mass 2331@xmath94718 & t5 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + llcccccl + sdss 0423@xmath90414 & t0 & 0.62 & 0.95 & 0.64 & 1.07 & 0.83 & + sdss 1254@xmath90122 & t2 & 0.46 & 0.91 & 0.48 & 1.00 & 0.59 & + 2mass 2254 + 3123 & t4 & 0.36 & 0.87 & 0.39 & 0.63 & 0.31 & + 2mass 0243@xmath92453 & t6 & 0.14 & 0.66 & 0.30 & 0.36 & 0.16 & + 2mass 0415@xmath90935 & t8 & 0.04 & 0.44 & 0.18 & 0.11 & 0.05 & + + sdss 0151 + 1244 & t1@xmath391 & 0.64(0 ) & 0.95(0 ) & 0.64(0 ) & 1.03(1 ) & 0.70(1 ) & t0.5 + sdss 1750 + 1759 & t3.5 & 0.46(2 ) & 0.87(4 ) & 0.45(3 ) & 0.71(4 ) & 0.35(4 ) & t3.5 + 2mass 1503 + 2525 & t5.5 & 0.24(5 ) & 0.74(5 ) & 0.34(5 ) & 0.42(6 ) & 0.20(5 ) & t5 + 2mass 1225@xmath92739ab & t6 & 0.17(6 ) & 0.67(6 ) & 0.28(6 ) & 0.35(6 ) & 0.18(6 ) & t6 + sdss 1624 + 0029 & t6 & 0.16(6 ) & 0.71(6 ) & 0.31(6 ) & 0.34(6 ) & 0.14(6 ) & t6 + 2mass 2228@xmath94310 & t6.5 & 0.15(6 ) & 0.68(6 ) & 0.29(6 ) & 0.28(7 ) & 0.12(7 ) & t6.5 + gliese 570d & t8 & 0.06(8 ) & 0.50(8 ) & 0.20(8 ) & 0.15(8 ) & 0.10(8 ) & t8 + + 2mass 1209@xmath91004 & & 0.40(3 ) &
0.83(4 ) & 0.45(3 ) & 0.77(3 ) & 0.64(3 ) & t3 + 2mass 1901 + 4718 & & 0.28(5 ) & 0.78(5 ) & 0.36(5 ) & 0.47(5 ) & 0.24(5 ) & t5 + 2mass 2331@xmath94718 & & 0.19(6 ) & 0.72(5 ) & 0.33(5 ) & 0.49(5 ) & 0.21(5 ) & t5 + 2mass 0407 + 1514 & & 0.23(5 ) & 0.76(5 ) & 0.34(5 ) & 0.40(6 ) & 0.16(6 ) & t5.5 + 2mass 1828@xmath94849 & & 0.18(6 ) & 0.70(6 ) & 0.31(6 ) & 0.40(6 ) & 0.20(5 ) & t6 + 2mass 1231 + 0847 & & 0.18(6 ) & 0.68(6 ) & 0.27(6 ) & 0.39(6 ) & 0.17(6 ) & t6 + 2mass 0034 + 0523 & & 0.10(7 ) & 0.64(6 ) & 0.23(8 ) & 0.25(7 ) & 0.13(7 ) & t7 + llccccc 2mass 1901 + 4718 & t5 & 1.243 & [email protected] & & 1.252 & [email protected] + 2mass 2331@xmath94718 & t5 & 1.244 & [email protected] & & 1.252 & [email protected] + 2mass 1503 + 2525 & t5.5 & 1.243 & [email protected] & & 1.252 & [email protected] + 2mass 1828@xmath94849 & t6 & 1.243 & [email protected] & & 1.252 & [email protected] + 2mass 1231 + 0847 & t6 & 1.243 & [email protected] & & 1.253 & [email protected] + 2mass 0034 + 0523 & t7 & 1.241 & [email protected] & & 1.252 & [email protected] + llcccccc 2mass 0034 + 0523 & t7 & [email protected] & 72@xmath394 & 26@xmath395 & 3.07 & 17 & o + & & [email protected] & 74@xmath3913 & 27@xmath397 & 3.02 & 21 & a + 2mass 0407 + 1514 & t5.5 & @xmath4 0.09 & ... & @xmath4 8 & 5.19 & 13 & o + 2mass 1209@xmath91004 & t3 & [email protected] & 140@xmath398 & 51@xmath3912 & 4.26 & 4 & g + 2mass 1231 + 0847 & t6 & [email protected] & 228@xmath393 & 88@xmath3918 & 3.24 & 20 & a + 2mass 1828@xmath94849 & t6 & [email protected] & 50@xmath3912 & 17@xmath395 & 2.92 & 39 & a + 2mass 1901 + 4718 & t5 & [email protected] & 197@xmath393 & 35@xmath396 & 5.27 & 62 & o + 2mass 2331@xmath94718 & t5 & @xmath4 0.10 & ... & @xmath4 9 & 2.90 & 13 & a + | we present the discovery of seven new t dwarfs identified in the two micron all sky survey .
low - resolution ( r@xmath0150 ) 0.82.5 @xmath1 spectroscopy obtained with the irtf spex instrument reveal the characteristic h@xmath2o and ch@xmath3 bands in the spectra of these brown dwarfs .
comparison to spectral standards observed with the same instrument enable us to derive classifications of t3 to t7 for the objects in this sample .
moderate - resolution ( r@xmath01200 ) near - infrared spectroscopy for a subset of these discoveries reveal line strengths consistent with previously observed trends with spectral type .
follow - up imaging observations provide proper motion measurements for these sources , ranging from @xmath4 0@xmath51 to 1@xmath555 yr@xmath6 .
one object , 2mass 0034 + 0523 , has a spectrophotometric distance placing it within 10 pc of the sun .
this source also exhibits a depressed k - band peak reminiscent of the peculiar t dwarf 2mass 0937 + 2931 , and may be a metal - poor or old , high - mass brown dwarf .
we also present low resolution spex data for a set of m and l - type dwarf , subdwarf , and giant comparison stars used to classify 59 additional candidates identified as background stars .
these are primarily m5-m8.5 dwarfs , many exhibiting paschen @xmath7 , but include three candidate ultracool m subdwarfs and one possible early - type l subdwarf . |
many physical and biological systems under multi - component control mechanisms exhibit scale - invariant features characterized by long - range power - law correlations in their output .
these scaling features are often difficult to quantify due to the presence of erratic fluctuations , heterogeneity , and nonstationarity embedded in the output signals .
this problem becomes even more difficult in certain cases : ( i ) when we can not probe directly the quantity of interest in experimental settings , i.e. , the measurable output signal is a linear or nonlinear function of the quantity of interest ; ( ii ) when measuring devices impose a linear or nonlinear filter on the system s output ; ( iii ) when we are interested not in the output signal but in a specific component of it , which is obtained through a nonlinear transform ( e.g. , the magnitude or the sign of the fluctuations in the signal ) ; ( iv ) when comparing the dynamics of different systems by applying nonlinear transforms to their output signals ; or ( v ) when pre - processing the output signal by means of linear or nonlinear filters before the actual analysis .
thus , to understand the intrinsic dynamics of a system , in such cases it is important to correctly analyze and interpret the dynamical patterns in the system s output .
conventional two - point correlation , power spectrum , and hurst analysis methods are not suited for nonstationary signals , the statistical properties of which change with time @xcite . to address this problem , detrended fluctuation analysis ( dfa ) method was developed to accurately quantify long - range correlations embedded in a nonstationary time series @xcite .
this method provides a single quantitative parameter the scaling exponent @xmath9 to quantify the scale - invariant properties of a signal .
one advantage of the dfa method is that it allows the detection of long - range power - law correlations in noisy signals with embedded polynomial trends that can mask the true correlations in the fluctuations of a signal .
recent comparative studies have demonstrated that the dfa method outperforms conventional techniques in accurately quantifying correlation properties over a wide range of scales .
the dfa method has been widely applied to dna , cardiac dynamics , human electroencephalographic ( eeg ) fluctuations @xcite , human motor activity @xcite and gait @xcite , meteorology @xcite , climate temperature fluctuations , river flow and discharge @xcite , electric signals @xcite , stellar x - ray binary systems @xcite , neural receptors in biological systems @xcite , music @xcite , and economics . in many of these applications
the main problem is to differentiate scaling features in a system s output which are inherent to the underlying dynamics , from the scaling features which are an artifact of nonstationarities or different types of transforms and filters . in two previous studies
we have examined how different types of nonstationarities such as superposed sinusoidal and power - law trends , random spikes , cut - out segments , and patches with different local behavior affect the long - range correlation properties of signals @xcite .
here we use the dfa method to investigate how the scaling properties of noisy correlated signals change under linear and nonlinear transforms .
further , ( i ) we test to see under what types of transforms ( filters ) it is possible to derive information about the scaling properties of the signal of interest before the transformation , provided we know the correlation behavior of the transformed ( filtered ) signal , and ( ii ) we probe the `` apparent '' scaling of three common transformation functions after applying the dfa method exponential , logarithmic and polynomial .
we also evaluate the limitations of the dfa method under linear and nonlinear transforms . specifically , we consider the following : \(1 ) _ correlation properties of signals after transforms of the type _ : @xmath10 , where @xmath11 is a stationary signal with _ a priori _ known correlation properties .
\(i ) _ linear transform _ : @xmath12 .
transforms of this type are often encountered in physical systems .
for example : ( a ) from the fluctuations in the acceleration of a particle ( measurable quantity ) , one can derive information about how the force ( quantity of interest ) acting on this particle changes in time without directly measuring the force : @xmath13 ; ( b ) in pnp - transistors a difficult to directly measure base ( input ) current @xmath14 ( quantity of interest ) is amplified hundreds of times , so that small fluctuations in @xmath14 may lead to significant ( and measurable ) changes in the collector ( output ) signal @xmath15 ( measurable quantity ) : @xmath16 , and ( c ) changes in the volume @xmath17 ( quantity of interest ) of an ideal gas can be determined from fluctuations in the temperature ( measurable quantity ) provided the pressure is kept constant : @xmath18 .
\(ii ) _ nonlinear polynomial transform _ :
@xmath19 , where @xmath20 and takes on positive integer values .
for example : ( a ) from fluctuations in the current @xmath21 ( measurable quantity ) one can extract information about the behavior of the power lost as heat @xmath22 ( quantity of interest ) in a resistor : @xmath23 ; ( b ) measuring the temperature @xmath24 fluctuations of a radiating body the stefan s law defines the power emitted per unit area : @xmath25 .
further , linear and nonlinear polynomial filters are also used to renormalize data series representing an identical quantity measured in different systems before performing correlation analysis , e.g. , ( i ) normalizing heart rate recordings from different subjects to zero mean and unit standard deviation ( linear filters ) , or ( ii ) extracting the absolute value ( nonlinear filter ) of the heartbeat fluctuations in datasets obtained from different subjects @xcite . in this study
we consider two examples of nonlinear polynomial filters quadratic and cubic filters which represent the class of polynomial filters with even and odd powers , and we investigate how these filters change the correlation properties of signals .
since polynomial filters with even power wipe out the sign information in a signal , we expect quadratic and cubic filters to have a different effect . a recent study by y. ashkenazy _ et al . _
@xcite shows that the magnitude of a signal ( without sign information ) exhibits different correlation properties from that of the original signal .
thus it is necessary to investigate how quadratic and cubic filters change the scaling properties of correlated signals .
\(iii ) _ logarithmic filter _ : @xmath26 , is also widely used in renormalizing datasets obtained from different sources before comparative analysis .
for example , to compare the dynamics of price fluctuations @xmath27 of different company stocks , which may have a different average price , one often first obtains the relative price returns @xmath28 $ ] before performing correlation analysis @xcite .
it is assumed that upon taking the returns one does not alter the information contained in the original signal . to test this assumption we compare the correlation properties of the signal before and after a logarithmic filter .
\(2 ) _ correlation properties of transformation functions _ when analyzing the correlation properties of a signal after a given transform , it may be valuable to know what is the dfa result for the transformation function itself .
in addition , it is often the case that noisy signals are superposed on trends which can be approximated by a certain function .
previous studies have demonstrated that the dfa result of a correlated signal with a superposed trend is a superposition of the dfa result for the signal and the dfa result for the analytic function representing the trend @xcite .
here we investigate separately the results of the dfa for three functions which are very often encountered in physical and biological processes : ( i ) _ exponential _ , ( ii ) _ logarithmic _ and ( iii ) _
power law_. the layout of this paper is as follows : in sec .
[ secpuren ] , we describe how we generate signals with desired long - range power - law correlations and introduce the dfa method used to quantify correlations in nonstationary signals . in sec .
[ secfilters ] , we compare the correlation and scaling properties of signals before and after linear and nonlinear polynomial transforms . in sec .
[ seclogsignals ] , we consider the effect of nonlinear logarithmic filter on the long - range correlation properties of stationary signals . in sec .
[ sectrends ] , we investigate the performance of the dfa method on three analytic functions exponential , logarithmic , and power - law which are often encountered as trends in physical and biological time series .
we systematically examine the crossovers in the scaling behavior of correlated signals resulting from the transforms and trends discussed in secs .
[ secfilters]-[sectrends ] , the conditions of existence of these crossovers and their typical characteristics .
we summarize our findings in sec .
[ conclusion ] .
we analyze two types of signals : \(1 ) stochastic stationary signals \{@xmath29 } ( @xmath30 ) with different type of correlations ( uncorrelated , correlated , and anti - correlated ) and surrogate signals obtained from \{@xmath29 } after linear and nonlinear transforms .
we use an algorithm based on the fourier transform to generate stationary signals \{@xmath29 } with long - range power - law correlations as described in @xcite .
the generated signals \{@xmath29 } have zero mean and unit standard deviation .
\(2 ) exponential , logarithmic , and power - law functions which often represent transformations or trends in physical and biological data .
we use the detrended fluctuation analysis ( dfa ) method to quantify the correlation and scaling properties of these signals .
the dfa method is described in detail elsewhere @xcite .
briefly , it involves the following steps : ( i ) we integrate the signal after subtracting the global average ; ( ii ) we then divide the time series into boxes of length @xmath31 and perform , in each box , a least - square polynomial fit of order @xmath32 to the integrated signal to remove the local trend in each box ; ( iii ) in each box we calculate the root - mean - square fluctuation function @xmath33 quantifying the fluctuations of the integrated signal along the local trend ; ( iv ) we repeat this procedure for different box sizes ( time scales ) @xmath31 . a power - law relation between the average root - mean - square fluctuation function @xmath33 and the box size
@xmath31 indicates the presence of scaling : @xmath34 .
the scale @xmath31 for which this scaling holds represents the length of the correlation .
the fluctuations in a signal can be characterized by the scaling exponent @xmath9 , a self - similarity parameter which quantifies the strength of the long - range power - law correlations in the signal .
if @xmath35 , there is no correlation and the signal is uncorrelated ( white noise ) ; if @xmath36 , the signal is anti - correlated ; if @xmath37 , the signal is correlated .
since we use a polynomial fit of order @xmath32 , we denote the algorithm as dfa-@xmath32 .
further , we note that for stationary signals \{@xmath29 } with long - range power - law correlations , the value of the scaling exponent @xmath9 is related to the exponent @xmath38 in the power spectrum @xmath39 of signals \{@xmath29 } by @xmath40 .
since the power spectrum is the fourier transform of the autocorrelation function , one can find the following relationship between the autocorrelation exponent @xmath41 and the power spectrum exponent @xmath38 : @xmath42 , where @xmath41 is defined by the autocorrelation function @xmath43 and should satisfy @xmath44 @xcite .
the upper threshold for the value of the scaling exponent @xmath9 is related to the order @xmath32 of the dfa method : @xmath45 for dfa-@xmath32 @xcite .
in addition , integrating the signal before applying the dfa method will increase the value of the scaling exponent @xmath9 by 1 , thus the upper threshold will become @xmath46 for dfa-@xmath32 .
therefore , after integrating correlated signals with the scaling exponent @xmath47 , one needs to apply the dfa method with an order of polynomial fit higher than @xmath32 .
we also note that for anti - correlated signals , the scaling exponent obtained from the dfa-@xmath32 method overestimates the true correlations at small scales @xcite . to avoid this problem
, one needs first to integrate the original anti - correlated signal and then to apply the dfa-@xmath32 method @xcite .
the correct scaling exponent @xmath9 can then be obtained from @xmath48 [ instead of @xmath33 ] @xcite .
for that reason we first integrate and then apply the dfa method when considering anti - correlated signals .
= 0.9 = 0.9 = 0.89 = 0.9
in this section , we study the effect of linear and nonlinear polynomial transforms ( filters ) on the scaling properties of stationary signals \{@xmath29 } with long - range power - law correlations . specifically , we consider two types of nonlinear transforms quadratic and cubic as an example of even and odd polynomial filters . we generate the signals \{@xmath29 } with linear fractal properties and with _ a priori _ build - in correlations characterized by a dfa scaling exponent @xmath9 @xcite
we compare how the exponent @xmath9 changes after the transform .
we first test to see if these transforms affect the properties of uncorrelated signals ( white noise ) .
we find that the linear , quadratic , and cubic filters do not change the scaling properties of white noise the curves of the detrended fluctuation function @xmath33 for the filtered signals \{@xmath50 } collapse on the scaling curve of the original signal \{@xmath29 } , and the scaling exponent @xmath35 remains unchanged [ fig .
[ filters](a ) ] . for signals with correlations
we find that the linear and nonlinear polynomial filters have a different effect .
in particular , for both correlated ( @xmath51 ) and anti - correlated ( @xmath52 ) signals \{@xmath29 } we find that the scaling properties remain unchanged after the linear filter .
in contrast , the quadratic and cubic filters change the scaling behavior of both correlated and anti - correlated signals [ fig .
[ filters](b - d ) ] .
specifically , for _ anti - correlated _ signals , we find that : ( i ) after the quadratic filter the scaling behavior is dramatically changed to uncorrelated ( random ) behavior with @xmath35 at all scales ; ( ii ) after the cubic filter the scaling ( correlation ) function @xmath33 of anti - correlated signals is also changed and exhibits a crossover from anti - correlated behavior at small scales to uncorrelated behavior at larger scales [ fig .
[ filters](b ) ] .
we note that the quadratic filter removes the sign information in a signal , thus completely eliminating the anti - correlations in a signal .
in contrast , the effect of the cubic filter is not as strong as the effect of the quadratic filters , since a cubic filter preserves the sign information and the anti - correlations at small scales . for _
correlated _ signals we find that after both quadratic and cubic filters , the scaling behavior is unchanged at small and intermediate scales . at large scales
we observe a crossover to weaker correlations which is less pronounced when increasing the strength of the correlations ( higher values of @xmath9 ) in the signal \{@xmath29 } [ fig .
[ filters](c - d ) ] . for signals with very strong correlations ( @xmath53 ) , we find that the scaling behavior remains almost unchanged after nonlinear polynomial filters .
we also find that the quadratic filter leads to a more pronounced crossover at large scales compared to the cubic filter for all positively correlated signals .
= 0.9 = 0.9 = 0.9 = 0.9 in addition to nonlinear polynomial transforms , logarithmic transforms are often used in preprocessing procedures when there is a need to renormalize output signals obtained from different systems before comparing their correlation properties . in this section ,
we investigate the effect of logarithmic filters on the scaling properties of stationary signals with long - range power - law correlations .
we first generate stationary correlated signals \{@xmath29 } with a zero mean and unit standard deviation , and with _ a priori _ known and controlled correlation properties quantified by dfa scaling exponent @xmath9 . to ensure that all values in the signal are positive , before the logarithmic transform , we shift @xmath54 , where @xmath55 , @xmath56 is the minimal value in the series \{@xmath29 } and @xmath57 is a positive constant .
this linear transform does not alter the correlation properties of \{@xmath29 } , as demonstrated in sec .
[ secfilters ] , fig .
[ filters ] .
next we integrate the signal after the logarithmic transform @xmath58 and we perform a dfa-2 analysis . for uncorrelated ( white noise ) signals after the logarithmic filter , we find no change in the scaling properties and the correlation exponent remains @xmath35 in the entire range of scales [ fig .
[ logsg1](b ) ] . however , we find that the scaling properties of signals with certain degree of correlation change significantly . specifically , for anti - correlated signals ( @xmath52 ) we observe a crossover to uncorrelated ( white noise ) behavior at large scales .
this crossover becomes more pronounced ( and shifted to smaller scales ) when increasing the strength of anti - correlations ( decreasing @xmath9 ) [ fig .
[ logsg1](b ) ] .
this crossover behavior is caused by negative spikes in the signal following the logarithmic transform [ fig .
[ logsg1](a ) ] .
a similar effect was previously reported for stationary correlated signals with superposed random spikes @xcite .
for correlated signals ( @xmath51 ) , we find a threshold value for the correlation exponent @xmath59 , below which the scaling properties of the signal remain unchanged after the logarithmic filter . above @xmath60
there is a reduction in the strength of the positive correlations , i.e. , the value of the estimated exponent after the logarithmic filter is much lower compared to the correlation exponent @xmath9 in the original signal [ fig .
[ logsg1](d ) ] .
= 0.9 since the logarithmic filter is a nonlinear transform which diverges for values of the signal \{@xmath61 } close to zero , we next test how the scaling properties of the signal depend on the value of the offset parameter @xmath57 .
we consider anti - correlated and correlated signals with fixed values of @xmath9 and varied @xmath57 . for strongly anti - correlated signals
we find that even for large values of @xmath57 , there is a crossover to uncorrelated behavior in the scaling curve @xmath33 at large scales ( note that @xmath57 is the minimal value of the signal \{@xmath61 } ) .
this crossover shifts to smaller scales with decreasing @xmath57 [ fig.[logsg2](a ) ] .
further , we find that for decreasing @xmath57 , the scaling curves @xmath33 converge to a single curve , indicating random uncorrelated behavior in the range of large and intermediate scales . for anti - correlated signals with @xmath62
we find that this convergence is reached for @xmath63 [ fig.[logsg2](a ) ] . for signals with strong positive correlations ( @xmath64 ) ,
we also observe a change in the scaling behavior which becomes more pronounced when @xmath57 decreases .
however , in contrast to the anti - correlated signals , the deviation from the expected accurate scaling starts at intermediate scales and extends to smaller scales with decreasing @xmath57 [ fig.[logsg2](b ) ] . for signals with very strong correlations , e.g. @xmath65 , the deviation from the accurate scaling is observed only for @xmath63 , while for @xmath66 , there is no effect on the scaling [ fig.[logsg2](b ) ] .
this is in contrast to the situation observed for signals with strong anti - correlations ( @xmath62 ) where the logarithmic filter alters the scaling behavior even for much larger values @xmath67 [ fig.[logsg2](a ) ] .
finally we study the relation between the scaling exponent @xmath9 of the original `` input '' signal and the estimated exponent @xmath68 of the `` output '' signal after the logarithmic filter .
we find that for correlated signals within given range for the value of the scaling exponent @xmath69 , there is no change in the scaling properties after the logarithmic transform .
however , for signals with correlation exponents @xmath70 and @xmath71 , we find that the logarithmic transform can dramatically change the scaling behavior and this effect also strongly depends on the value of the offset parameter @xmath57 [ fig.[logsg3 ] ] .
therefore , the logarithmic filter is not recommended for anti - correlated signals and signals with very strong positive correlations applying this filter will mask the true correlations in the original signals .
= 0.9 = 0.9 in this section we investigate the scaling properties of three functions : _ exponential _ , _ logarithmic _ , and _ power - law_. these functions are often used in signal processing as transforms of various stochastic correlated signals and also appear as trends superposed on noisy signals derived from physical and biological systems . in previous work
@xcite we have demonstrated that the scaling behavior of a correlated signal with a superposed trend is superposition of the scaling behavior of the correlated signal and the `` apparent '' scaling behavior obtained from the dfa method for the analytic function representing the trend . therefore , understanding the results of the dfa for certain analytic functions becomes a necessary step to quantify the scaling behavior of system s outputs where correlated fluctuations are superposed with different trends .
= 0.98 = 0.9 \(i ) _ we first consider the exponential function in the form _ :
@xmath72 , where @xmath73 , @xmath74 , @xmath75 , @xmath76 , the parameter @xmath77 , the offset parameter @xmath8 is a positive constant .
we show the result of the dfa method in fig .
[ trends3 ] .
we find that the slope of the detrended fluctuation function @xmath33 vs. the scale @xmath31 obtained from the dfa method does not depend on the values of the parameters @xmath78 and @xmath8 ( there is only a vertical shift in @xmath33 for different values of @xmath8 and @xmath78 ) [ fig .
[ trends3](a ) ] . instead
, we find that the dfa scaling exponent @xmath9 depends only on the order @xmath32 of polynomial fit in the dfa method @xmath79 suggesting that the results of the dfa method do not depend on the details of the exponential function [ fig .
[ trends3](b ) ] . an analytic derivation for the fluctuation function @xmath33 and the value of the scaling exponent @xmath9 obtained from dfa-1
is presented in appendix a. = 0.94 = 0.9 \(ii ) _ we next consider the performance of the dfa method on a logarithmic function of the general form _ :
@xmath80 , where @xmath73 , @xmath74 , @xmath81 , @xmath76 and the offset parameter @xmath8 is a positive constant .
specifically , we investigate the dependence of the dfa scaling exponent @xmath9 on the value of the offset parameter @xmath8 .
we find that for very small values of @xmath8 , the dfa scaling exponent is @xmath82 . with increasing @xmath8
, we observe a crossover in @xmath33 at intermediate scales @xmath31 from @xmath82 at large scales to @xmath83 at small scales for dfa-2 [ fig .
[ trends2](a ) ] . for larger values of @xmath8
, we observe a scaling behavior in @xmath33 characterized by a single exponent @xmath83 in the entire range of scales @xmath31 [ fig .
[ trends2](a ) ] . in fig .
[ trends2](b ) we present the dependence of the dfa scaling exponent @xmath9 [ obtained in the fitting range @xmath84 on the offset parameter @xmath8 for different dfa order @xmath32 .
we find that for @xmath85 the exponent @xmath9 does not depend on the order @xmath32 of the dfa method and takes on a single value @xmath82 .
in contrast , for large values of @xmath86 , the exponent @xmath9 depends only on the order @xmath32 of the dfa method and takes on values @xmath79 .
this behavior is identical with the behavior obtained for the exponential function in fig .
[ trends3](b ) . for intermediate values of @xmath8
, we observe a crossover in the scaling behavior of the fluctuation function @xmath33 from @xmath82 to @xmath79 .
\(iii ) _ finally , we consider the general power - law function _ :
@xmath87 , where @xmath73 , @xmath74 , @xmath75 , @xmath76 , the power @xmath88 takes on real values and the offset parameter @xmath8 is a positive constant . as in the case of the logarithmic function ,
we find again that the dfa scaling exponent @xmath9 depends on the value of the offset parameter @xmath8 [ fig .
[ trends1](a ) ] . for certain fixed values of @xmath88 and with increasing @xmath8
, we observe a gradual transition in the fluctuation function @xmath33 from a scaling behavior spanning over a broad range of scales @xmath31 characterized by a small value of the exponent @xmath9 to a crossover at intermediate scales @xmath31 for larger values of @xmath8 , and finally to a scaling spanning over all scales @xmath31 with exponent @xmath83 for large values of @xmath8 for dfa-2 . in a previous study @xcite
we have found a specific relationship between the dfa exponent @xmath9 and the value of the power @xmath88 for the case of power - law function with offset parameter @xmath89 : @xmath79 for @xmath90 ; @xmath91 for @xmath92 ; @xmath93 for @xmath94 , where @xmath32 is the order of polynomial fit in the dfa-@xmath32 method .
our current analysis shows that this behavior is even more complicated when @xmath95 [ fig .
[ trends1](b ) ] .
specifically , we find that for values of @xmath85 the scaling exponent @xmath9 [ obtained in the fitting range @xmath84 depends only on the value of the power @xmath88 : @xmath91 .
in contrast , for large values of the offset parameter @xmath86 , we find that the exponent @xmath9 depends only on the order @xmath32 of the dfa method , and takes on values @xmath79 , which is similar to the results obtained for the general exponential and logarithmic functions in this range of @xmath8 [ fig .
[ trends3](b ) and fig .
[ trends2](b ) ] ) . for intermediate values of @xmath8 and for @xmath96
, we observe a crossover in the scaling behavior of the fluctuation function @xmath33 from @xmath91 to @xmath79 .
further , we find that for @xmath90 , the dfa-@xmath32 scaling exponent remains constant @xmath79 , and does not depend on the values of the offset parameter @xmath8 we note that for @xmath97 ( close to @xmath98 for dfa-1 ) the dependence of @xmath9 on @xmath8 is close to a horizontal line [ fig .
[ trends1](b ) ] . * analytic arguments * our results show that for large values of the offset parameter @xmath8 , the detrended fluctuation function @xmath33 for all three analytic functions exponential , logarithmic , and power - law exhibits identical slope , where the dfa scaling exponent @xmath9 does not depend on the particular functional form but only the order @xmath32 of the dfa method : @xmath79 [ fig .
[ trends3](b ) , [ trends2](b ) and [ trends1](b ) ] .
the reason for this common behavior is that ( i ) for large values of @xmath8 , in each dfa box of a given length @xmath31 , all three functions can be expanded in converging taylor series , allowing for a perfect fit by a finite order polynomial function , and ( ii ) that , due to this convergence , the same polynomial function can be used when shrinking the box length @xmath31 . in contrast , for very small values of the offset parameter @xmath8 , the dfa results for all three functions are distinctly different and does not depend on the order @xmath32 of the dfa method .
below we give some general analytic arguments for the dependence of the dfa exponent @xmath9 on the offset parameter @xmath8 presented in figs .
[ trends3 ] , [ trends2 ] and [ trends1 ] .
\(i ) _ general exponential function _ : @xmath99 .
first , we substitute the variable @xmath100 by @xmath101 : @xmath102 $ ] .
next , we consider a dfa box starting at the coordinate @xmath103 and ending at @xmath104 , where @xmath105 is proportional to the number of points @xmath31 in the box @xmath106 . for any value of @xmath107
we can expand the function in a taylor series : @xmath108 .
\label{eqnq1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] since this expansion converges , a finite polynomial function can accurately approximate the exponential function in each dfa box .
we note that the dfa-@xmath32 method applied to above polynomial functions gives the scaling exponent @xmath79 ( see @xcite ) .
thus , for any exponential function we find that the dfa scaling does not depend on the value of the offset parameter @xmath8 and depends only on the order @xmath32 of the polynomial fit in the dfa-@xmath32 procedure [ fig .
[ trends3](b ) ] .
( ii)_general logarithmic function _ : @xmath109 .
first , we substitute the variable @xmath100 by @xmath101 : @xmath110 $ ] .
next , we consider a dfa box starting at the coordinate @xmath103 and ending at @xmath104 , where @xmath105 is proportional to the number of points @xmath31 in the box @xmath111 . for any value of @xmath107
the taylor expansion is : @xmath112 this series is converging only when @xmath113 , i.e. , @xmath114 .
since @xmath115 , the condition for convergence in any dfa box @xmath116 partitioning the function is @xmath117 . from @xmath111 and
@xmath118 $ ] , we find that if @xmath119 , the logarithmic function in all dfa boxes is converging , and thus each box can be approximated by a polynomial function , leading to scaling exponent @xmath79 depending only on the order @xmath32 of the dfa-@xmath32 method [ fig .
[ trends2 ] ] . when @xmath120 , for certain values of @xmath115 , the series in eq .
( [ eqnq2 ] ) is diverging . since @xmath118 $ ] , for @xmath121
, we find that the logarithmic function is divergent in the first dfa box @xmath122 , leading to deviation in the dfa scaling for small values of @xmath8 [ fig .
[ trends2 ] ] .
\(iii ) _ general power - law function _ : @xmath123 $ ] .
first , we substitute the variable @xmath100 by @xmath101 : @xmath124 $ ] .
next , we consider a dfa box starting at the coordinate @xmath103 and ending at @xmath104 , where @xmath105 is proportional to the number of points @xmath31 in the box @xmath111 . for any value of @xmath107
the taylor expansion is : @xmath125 similar to the case of the logarithmic function , this series is converging only when @xmath113 .
following the same arguments as for the logarithmic function we find that when @xmath119 , the power - law function is converging in any dfa box , and thus can be approximated by a polynomial function , leading to the scaling exponent @xmath79 [ fig .
[ trends1 ] ] , which is identical to the case of exponential and logarithmic function .
in contrast , for @xmath126 , the power - law function is divergent in the first dfa box @xmath122 , as in the case of the logarithmic function , leading to a deviation in the scaling of @xmath33 for small values of @xmath8 [ fig .
[ trends1 ] ] . while in the case of logarithmic function this divergence leads to a fixed scaling exponent @xmath82 , for power - law functions the value of the scaling exponent @xmath9 depends also on the power @xmath88 [ fig . [ trends1 ] ] .
we note that the above arguments can be used to estimate the results of the dfa method for other functions . for all functions which can be expanded in convergent taylor expansion of a polynomial form in each dfa box partitioning the function
, the dfa method leads to identical scaling results with the exponent @xmath79 , which is a notable inherent limitation of the method . when there is divergent behavior in some or all of the dfa boxes partitioning a function , the dfa scaling exhibits crossover behavior to different values of the scaling exponent @xmath9 which depends on the functional form and the specific parameters of the function .
in summary , our study shows that linear transforms do not change the scaling properties of a signal .
however , the correlation properties of a signal change after applying a polynomial filter .
moreover , such change depends on the type of correlations ( positive or anti - correlations ) in the signal , as well as on the power ( odd or even ) of the polynomial filter . for the logarithmic filter
we find that the scaling behavior of the transformed signal remains unchanged only when the original signal satisfies certain type of correlations ( characterized by scaling exponent within a given range ) . comparing the `` apparent '' scaling behavior of the exponential , logarithmic , and power - law functions we find that within certain range for the values of the parameters , the dfa fluctuation function @xmath33 exhibits an identical slope , and that the dfa results of a class of other analytic functions can be reduced to these three cases .
we attribute this behavior to specific limitations of the dfa method . therefore ,
careful tests are necessary to accurately estimate the correlation properties of signals after nonlinear transforms .
this work was supported by nih grant hl071972 and nih / national center for research resources ( grant no . p41rr13622 ) and by the spanish ministerio de ciencia y tecnologia ( grants bfm2002 - 00183 and bio2002 - 04014-co3 - 02 ) .
we consider an exponential function of the type @xmath127 , where the parameters @xmath78 and @xmath8 take on real values .
the first step of the dfa method is to integrate the signal [ sec.[secpuren ] ] : where @xmath129 is the length of the signal and @xmath130 $ ] .
we divide the variable in the exponential by @xmath129 , so that ( @xmath131 ) is in the interval @xmath132 $ ] , as considered in sec .
[ sectrends ] .
the next step of the dfa method is to divide the integrated signal into boxes of length @xmath31 . for dfa-1 ,
the squared detrended fluctuation function in the @xmath133th box , @xmath134 , is where the parameters @xmath136 and @xmath137 are obtained by a linear fit to the integrated signal using least squares in the @xmath133th box .
these two parameters can be obtained analytically , although their expressions are too long . to obtain
the squared detrended fluctuation function for the entire signal partitioned in non - overlapping boxes of length @xmath31 , we sum over all boxes and calculate the average value : here , the index @xmath3 in the sum ranges from @xmath139 to @xmath140 ( there are @xmath141 boxes of length @xmath31 in the signal of length @xmath129 ) . using the analytical expressions for @xmath136 and @xmath137 , @xmath142 can be presented analytically in the form : due to the complexity of @xmath146 and @xmath147 , the expression of @xmath148 is very complicated .
however , as @xmath149 ( and usually , @xmath150 ) , one can expand @xmath151 in powers of @xmath31 to obtain : thus the dfa-1 scaling exponent is @xmath154 ( in agreement with the numerical simulation in sec .
[ sectrends ] , fig .
[ trends3 ] ) . in general
, we can obtain in a similar way that @xmath155 , when dfa-@xmath32 with an order @xmath32 of polynomial fit is used .
k. ivanova , t. p. ackerman , e. e. clothiaux , p. ch .
ivanov , h. e. stanley , and m. ausloos , j. geophys .
res . * 108*,4268 ( 2003 ) .
e. koscielny - bunde , a. bunde , s. havlin , h. e. roman , y. goldreich , and h. j. schellnhuber , phys .
lett . * 81 * , 729 ( 1998 ) .
j. f. eichner , e. koscielny - bunde , a. bunde , s. havlin , and h. j. schellnhuber , phys .
e * 68 * , 046133 ( 2003 ) .
k. fraedrich and r. blender , phys .
* 90 * , 108501 ( 2003 ) .
m. pattantyus - abraham , a. kiraly , and i. m. janosi , phys .
e * 69 * , 021110 ( 2004 ) .
z. siwy , m. ausloos , and k. ivanova , phys .
e * 65 * , 031907 ( 2002 ) .
a. varotsos , n. v. sarlis , and e. s. skordas , phys .
e * 67 * , 021109 ( 2003 ) .
p. a. varotsos , n. v. sarlis , and e. s. skordas , phys .
e * 68 * , 031106 ( 2003 ) . | when investigating the dynamical properties of complex multiple - component physical and physiological systems , it is often the case that the measurable system s output does not directly represent the quantity we want to probe in order to understand the underlying mechanisms . instead , the output signal is often a linear or nonlinear function of the quantity of interest . here ,
we investigate how various linear and nonlinear transformations affect the correlation and scaling properties of a signal , using the detrended fluctuation analysis ( dfa ) which has been shown to accurately quantify power - law correlations in nonstationary signals .
specifically , we study the effect of three types of transforms : ( i ) linear ( @xmath0 ) ; ( ii ) nonlinear polynomial ( @xmath1 ) ; and ( iii ) nonlinear logarithmic [ @xmath2 filters .
we compare the correlation and scaling properties of signals before and after the transform .
we find that linear filters do not change the correlation properties , while the effect of nonlinear polynomial and logarithmic filters strongly depends on ( a ) the strength of correlations in the original signal , ( b ) the power @xmath3 of the polynomial filter , and ( c ) the offset @xmath4 in the logarithmic filter .
we further apply the dfa method to investigate the `` apparent '' scaling of three analytic functions : ( i ) exponential [ @xmath5 , ( ii ) logarithmic [ @xmath6 , and ( iii ) power law [ @xmath7 , which are often encountered as trends in physical and biological processes .
while these three functions have different characteristics , we find that there is a broad range of values for parameter @xmath8 common for all three functions , where the slope of the dfa curves is identical .
we further note that the dfa results obtained for a class of other analytic functions can be reduced to these three typical cases .
we systematically test the performance of the dfa method when estimating long - range power - law correlations in the output signals for different parameter values in the three types of filters and the three analytic functions we consider . |
the concept of entanglement , as first introduced by schrdinger @xcite and discussed by einstein , podolsky , and rosen @xcite in 1935 , has historically been associated with systems of two or more quanta .
its counterintuitive consequences found a mathematical formulation in the work of bell @xcite of 1965 : pairs of quanta entangled in discrete variables ( i.e. , bohm - like entangled systems @xcite ) may give rise to purely quantum nonlocal correlations .
unfortunately , no loophole - free test of bell s inequality has been realized so far @xcite . besides their relevance in fundamental physics ,
these phenomena have attracted much attention due to their usefulness in quantum information technology .
extravagant but promising protocols such as quantum teleportation , quantum cryptography , and quantum computation have been proposed and experimentally verified ( see , e.g. , @xcite and references therein ) . in the early nineties ,
increasing attention has been given to a new perspective of quantum entanglement .
the concept of entanglement has indeed been extended to any system containing a fixed number ( @xmath0 ) of photons , provided at least one pair of spatiotemporal modes is involved .
then , even for @xmath1 , one may talk of single - photon n - mode entanglement " , provided @xmath2 .
the first steps in this direction were taken by tan , walls , and collet @xcite ( twc ) : when a single photon impinges on a beam - splitter whose outputs are described by the spatial modes @xmath3 and @xmath4 , the emerging single photon is described by the state @xmath5 is a single - photon fock state , and @xmath6 and @xmath7 are complex amplitudes such that @xmath8 .
in this perspective , a single photon , with its presence or absence from a given spatiotemporal mode , may represent a tool for entangling two ( or more ) well - separated field modes . in this case
, an experimental test of nonlocality would consist in performing simultaneous measurements on the separate field modes `` sharing '' the single photon and check if their mutual correlations violate a bell s inequality .
intensive studies and debates have been dedicated to the meaningfulness of extending both the concepts of entanglement and nonlocality to twc - type single - photon two - mode systems ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) . quite recently ,
babichev , et al.@xcite and zavatta , et al.@xcite have experimentally characterized a source of two - mode spatially and temporally delocalized single photons , respectively , by employing time - domain homodyne tomography @xcite and reconstructing both density matrix and wigner function of the measured system . in this respect ,
it is worth reminding that the density matrix or wigner function of a given system represents its most complete characterization and enables predicting the result of any possible measurement one may perform on the system @xcite .
the results indicate the existence of strong correlations between the two spatial / temporal modes carrying a coherently delocalized single photon .
whether or not such correlations are nonlocal can not be asserted ; for instance , the bell s inequality test performed in ref.@xcite is based upon dichotomization of quadrature data and heavily relies upon data - rejection .
of particular interest , in this respect , is the experiment by hessmo et al .
@xcite , who have implemented the theoretical proposals by tan et al .
@xcite and by hardy @xcite , demonstrating the nonclassical character of the correlations characterizing two spatial modes sharing a single photon .
similar to the two - photon case , also
entangled " single - photon sources may find immediate application in quantum information technology : single - photon ebits have indeed been proven to enable linear optics quantum teleportation @xcite and play a central role in linear optics quantum computation @xcite .
furthermore , the time - bin entanglement of the kind of ref.@xcite ( see also @xcite ) has been proven suitable for long distance applications @xcite , where the insensitivity to both depolarization and polarization fluctuations becomes a strong requirement . in this paper , we wish to make one step further in the direction of understanding and proving single photon n - mode entanglement . to this end
, we employ the single - photon source presented in ref.@xcite ( see sect.[sec : setup ] ) , perform two - mode homodyne tomography ( sect.[sec : exp_res ] ) and employ the reconstructed two - mode density matrix and wigner function to quantify the degree of entanglement ( sect .
[ ssec : entangl ] ) and implement a novel kind of tomographic bell s inequality test ( sects . [
sec : ineq_th ] and [ sec : bell ] ) .
in particular , we evaluate the degree of entanglement characterizing our single - photon system by employing vidal and werner s reformulation @xcite of peres separability criterion @xcite .
then , we employ the experimentally reconstructed two - mode wigner function to perform an innovative continuous variable bell s inequality test , based on the theoretical proposal by banaszek and wodkiewicz @xcite , which we briefly introduce in the next section .
let us start by briefly reviewing the theoretical proposal of ref.@xcite : the strict connection between the displaced parity operator ( a dichotomic observable ) and the wigner function @xcite , suggests that the wigner function of any two - mode / two - particle system ( whether positive or negative ) may play the role of a nonlocal correlation function .
bell s inequality can thus be recast in the form : @xmath9 is the value of the two - mode wigner function at the phase - space point ( @xmath10 ) defined by the quadratures @xmath11 and @xmath12 of the @xmath13-th mode / particle ( @xmath14 ) .
this inequality , which we shall name banaszek - bell s inequality , applies both to two - particle and to two - mode entangled systems , including spatially / temporally delocalized single photons .
interestingly , compared to all bell s inequalities theoretically proposed for continuous variables and based upon a - posteriori dichotomization of the measured field quadratures @xcite , banaszek - bell s inequality may achieve higher levels of violation .
for instance , based on the predictions of quantum mechanics , the time - bin encoded single - photon state @xcite : @xmath15 denotes a well - defined temporal mode ( or time bin ) , is expected to maximally violate the inequality of eq .
( [ ineq ] ) , giving @xmath16 for @xmath17 . the experimental test of banaszek - bell s inequality , in the form written in eq .
( [ ineq ] ) , is feasible : our idea is to perform two - mode homodyne detection on the two distinct time bins ( @xmath18 and @xmath19 ) carrying the temporally - delocalized single photon of eq .
( [ state_eq ] ) , and to use the experimental data to tomographically reconstruct the two - mode wigner function entering the inequality of eq .
( [ ineq ] ) .
our ultra - fast time - domain homodyne detection scheme has the potential to achieve this goal @xcite .
it is certainly true that , different from standard bell s inequality tests , our tomographic test imposes an indirect approach to bell s inequality : rather than directly employing the results of correlation measurements , our scheme requires the manipulation of the experimental quadrature data in order to reconstruct the wigner function entering eq .
( [ ineq ] ) .
note , however , that the reconstruction procedure is rather transparent , does not imply additional hypotheses on the state under study , and can only introduce noise , without _ hiding _ or _ enhancing _ any information contained in the data . then , finding a violation of eq .
( [ ineq ] ) through a tomographic approach indicates that also direct measurements would lead to a violation .
let us now consider the experimental setup : a mode - locked ti : sapphire laser emitting @xmath20 ps pulses at @xmath21 nm at a repetition rate of @xmath22 mhz , is frequency doubled in a lbo crystal ; the resulting train of phase - locked pulses impinges on a nonlinear bbo crystal , cut for degenerate non - collinear type - i spdc @xcite .
signal - idler photon pairs centered around @xmath21 nm are generated in symmetric directions . before entering an unbalanced fiber - based interferometer and being detected by a single - photon counter , the idler ( trigger ) photons
undergo a narrow spectral and spatial selection aiming to the conditional generation of a pure single - photon state in the signal mode ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) .
our setup is characterized by a single - photon preparation efficiency @xmath23 , which depends on both the dark counts of the trigger detector and on the purity of the prepared single photon @xcite .
the conditionally - prepared signal beam impinges on a 50 - 50 beam splitter ( bs ) where it is mixed with a strong local oscillator ( lo ) made of an attenuated version of the train of laser pulses .
two - mode , high - frequency , time - domain , balanced homodyne detection ( hd ) is then performed on two consecutive signal pulses , as depicted in fig .
[ fig_scheme]b ) .
the detection efficiency ( @xmath24 ) depends both on the efficiency of the two photodiodes ( @xmath25 ) and optical losses , and on the mode - matching with the local oscillator ( @xmath26 ) .
the overall experimental efficiency of our setup is thus expected to be of the order of : @xmath27 .
( color online ) .
a ) scheme for the remote preparation of a temporally delocalized single photon ; i ) and ii ) indicate the two indistinguishable alternatives leading to the coherent superposition of eq .
( [ state_eq ] ) in the signal arm .
b ) scheme for the two - mode , time - domain , homodyne tomography of such a time - delocalized single - photon state.,width=321 ] from the preparation viewpoint , the key part of our setup is the interferometer inserted in the idler channel : by setting the interferometer delay @xmath28 equal to the fixed inter - pulse separation @xmath29 characterizing the train of phase - locked pump pulses , a click in the idler channel does not distinguish the idler photon generated by the @xmath30 pump pulse which travelled the long arm , from the idler photon generated by the @xmath31 pump pulse which travelled the short arm ( see fig .
[ fig_scheme]a ) ) . for an infinite train of mode - locked pump pulses and
in the case of equal losses in the two arms of the interferometer , a click in the trigger detector projects the signal single photon onto the coherent superposition of eq .
( [ state_eq ] ) .
in order to check the degree of entanglement and to perform the tomographic test of bell s inequality on such conditionally and remotely prepared temporally - delocalized single photons , we have performed two - mode homodyne detection on the pair of consecutive signal time bins sharing the single photon ; this is pictorially drawn in fig .
[ fig_scheme]b ) . by making use of what we have recently named `` remote homodyne tomography '' @xcite to remotely vary the relative phase between the two - mode state and the lo pulses , we have performed about @xmath32 quadrature measurements on the two consecutive signal temporal modes carrying the delocalized single photon .
this has been made possible by the ultrafast operation of the homodyne detector recently developed in our laboratory @xcite .
the measured field quadratures have been employed to reconstruct the density matrix of the measured system by means of quantum tomography . in particular , we employ the pattern function method ( pf ) proposed by dariano , et al . @xcite to directly retrieve the elements of the two - mode density matrix in the number - state base from the measured quadrature data : @xmath33 is obtained from the statistical average of the corresponding pattern functions @xmath34 over all homodyne data , which is : @xmath35 where @xmath36 are the quadratures measured at phases @xmath37 on the two consecutive time bins .
the pattern functions have the form @xmath38 , with @xmath39 ( @xmath40 ) , where @xmath41 and @xmath42 are , respectively , the regular and irregular wave functions of the harmonic oscillator @xcite . in the experiment , @xmath43 is remotely varied by means of the interferometer while @xmath44 is left random since our system is independent of the global phase .
when reconstructing the quantum state , we allow each single - mode fock state to contain from zero to two photons ; each matrix index is thus varied from zero to two and a total of @xmath45 density matrix elements are reconstructed for the two - mode system , as shown in fig .
[ fig_dens]a .
no assumptions are made on the system to be reconstructed ; we just impose a truncation to the reconstruction space since no multi - photon contributions are expected .
the density matrix of the measured system has also been reconstructed by means of the maximum - likelihood method ( ml ) @xcite : the density matrix @xmath46 that most likely represents the homodyne data is retrieved by maximizing a functional @xmath47 involving the povm associated with two - mode homodyne measurements .
the only constraint we impose is that the density matrix @xmath46 is a positive - definite hermitian matrix with unitary trace . in order to limit the number of free parameters in the minimization procedure
, we impose @xmath48 to be independent of the global phase @xmath44 . in principle
, the ml method enables taking into account the experimental imperfections , thus reconstructing the density matrix of the measured system corrected for the experimental efficiency @xmath49 . at this stage
, we do not impose any such correction .
both the pf and the ml method ( without correcting for @xmath49 ) give very similar results ; hence , in fig .
[ fig_dens]a , we just plot the elements obtained from the pf method .
the reconstructed density matrix contains both the expected state of eq .
( [ state_eq ] ) and a vacuum component ( @xmath50 ) coming from the non - unitary experimental efficiency .
the measured system is thus given by the mixture @xmath51 with @xmath52 as given in eq .
( [ state_eq ] ) ; note that almost no multi - photon contribution exists in fig . [ fig_dens]a ) , as expected . from the vacuum component of the reconstructed density matrix
we evaluate the overall efficiency to be @xmath53 , a result in good agreement with our estimated single - photon preparation and detection efficiencies .
( color online ) .
a ) experimentally reconstructed density matrix elements ( absolute values ) relative to the mixed state of eq .
( [ rho_eq ] ) ; b ) same elements after `` vacuum cleaning '' by an inverse bernoulli transformation ; c ) density matrix elements reconstructed with the maximum - likelihood method incorporating the experimental inefficiency.,width=302 ] the reconstructed density matrix will now be employed to quantify the amount of entanglement characterizing the measured two - mode system . to this end
, we use the logarithmic negativity @xmath54 defined in @xcite , on the line of peres separability criterion @xcite . in general , peres criterion gives a _ necessary _ condition for separability @xcite : if a bipartite system is separable , the partial transpose of its density matrix ( i.e. , the transpose @xmath55 of subsystem @xmath3 alone ) remains a physical density matrix with positive eigenvalues .
then , if we find that the partial transpose of our density matrix is not positive definite , we know our single - photon system is certainly non separable . in order to quantify the degree of non - separability ( i.e. , the degree of entanglement )
, one can evaluate the logarithmic negativity defined as @xcite : @xmath56 , where the symbol @xmath57 indicates the trace norm : @xmath58 , which , for hermitian matrices , reduces to @xmath59 , with @xmath60 sum of the negative eigenvalues of @xmath61 @xcite .
in other words , the trace norm accounts for the negative eigenvalues of @xmath55 , and is thus directly related to the amount by which the partial transpose fails to be positive definite .
in fact , for a separable system , @xmath62 and the corresponding logarithmic negativity is zero ; for a maximally entangled @xmath63 bipartite system , @xmath64 and the corresponding logarithmic negativity is one . in our case
, the reconstructed density matrix yields a logarithmic negativity @xmath65 , thus showing the presence of some amount of entanglement even for non perfect detection efficiency .
this result is perfectly in line with the value expected from eq .
( [ rho_eq ] ) , with @xmath53 .
interestingly , the bipartite system described by eq .
( [ rho_eq ] ) is one of those striking " mixtures which remain inseparable ( i.e. , @xmath66 has a negative eigenvalue ) for any value of the efficiency @xmath49 @xcite .
a coherently delocalized single photon is thus extremely robust against losses : its degree of entanglement may decrease but never vanishes .
based on the above result , our single - photon two - mode system is characterized by purely quantum correlations .
our next step is to check whether such quantum correlations are nonlocal . to this end
, we reconstruct the two - mode wigner function of the measured system @xcite : @xmath67 where @xmath68 is the wigner function associated with the projector @xmath69 , and @xmath70 is the generic element of the experimentally reconstructed density matrix . the reconstructed wigner function can now be used to evaluate the combination defined in eq .
( [ ineq ] ) , thus checking for a violation of banaszek - bell s inequality .
we find that the parameter @xmath71 falls well within the limits imposed by local hidden - variable theories ( see fig .
[ fig_viola ] ) , a result that may be associated with the low overall experimental efficiency .
in fact , in the case of limited efficiency , the expected wigner function for the state of eq .
( [ rho_eq ] ) takes the form : @xmath72}{\pi^2 } \ , e^{-2|\alpha_1|^2 -2|\alpha_2|^2};\ ] ]
hence , taking @xmath73 , the combination given in eq .
( [ ineq ] ) becomes : @xmath74- e^{-4 \mathcal{j } } ( 8 \mathcal{j } \eta -2 \eta + 1).\ ] ] its behavior is plotted in fig .
[ fig_viola ] as a function of the squared amplitude @xmath75 for different values of the global efficiency @xmath49 and it is seen to closely match the experimental results ( squared points ) for @xmath76 . it is evident that the current level of experimental efficiency rules out the possibility of a loophole - free test of banaszek - bell s inequality , which would be attainable only for global experimental efficiencies larger than 96@xmath77 . to satisfy such strict requirements we need to introduce some auxiliary assumptions . in this perspective , it is worth noting that , different from photon counting , homodyne tomography allows one to explicitly _ see _ the effect of the experimental inefficiencies on the measured system : the overall efficiency @xmath49 enters into the reconstructed density matrix ( fig.[fig_dens]a ) in the form of vacuum .
in particular , we find that the vacuum component remains exactly the same when no interferometer is inserted in the idler channel and a single signal photon is perfectly localized within a given temporal mode .
this indicates that the non - unitary efficiency @xmath49 represents our inability of producing and detecting a pure single - photon state , but , once such imperfect single photon is coherently delocalized between separate time - bins , the coherence is not further affected by losses .
this is apparent from fig .
[ fig_dens]a ) , where all the density matrix elements associated with the entangled state of eq .
( [ state_eq ] ) have approximately equal weights . in other words ,
both detection and preparation inefficiencies give rise to state - independent losses as if a beam splitter with transmissivity @xmath49 were introduced in the signal path , mixing vacuum with the original state ( see eq .
( [ rho_eq ] ) and fig . [ fig_dens ] a ) ) . correcting for our non - unitary efficiencies is thus similar to making the standard fair - sampling assumption @xcite .
based on this reasoning , we have chosen to reconstruct the density matrix of the measured system by correcting for the non - unitary efficiency ; this is expected to remove the vacuum component from the reconstructed density matrix , which is , to make the @xmath50 element almost equal to zero and rescale the other elements accordingly .
we will implement such vacuum removal by employing two different strategies .
banaszek - bell s inequality will thus be tested under the fair - sampling assumption or , more precisely , on the resulting `` vacuum - cleaned '' wigner function . in the first case , we account for losses by making an inverse bernoulli transformation ( ibt ) of the reconstructed density matrix ; the result is shown in fig .
[ fig_dens]b ) .
the basic idea is to model the non - perfect experimental efficiency by a beam splitter with transmissivity @xmath49 followed by an ideal detector : the measured system @xmath78 can be seen as the attenuated version of the system incident on such fictitious beam splitter . since the output state of the beam splitter is related to the input state by a bernoulli transformation , inversion of this transformation gives the state @xmath48 of the incident " system , before its mixing with vacuum ( i.e. , before losses affect it ) @xcite . in the second case
, we directly reconstruct the loss - free density matrix by adopting the maximum - likelihood method ( ml ) while taking into account the experimental efficiency @xmath53 .
the results are shown in fig .
[ fig_dens]c ) @xcite . as shown in fig .
[ fig_viola ] , the wigner functions reconstructed from both the `` vacuum - cleaned '' density matrices give rise to a good agreement between the experimental data and the theoretical prediction of eq .
( [ ineqloss ] ) , with unitary efficiency .
the temporally - delocalized single photon thus clearly violates the lower bound of banaszek - bell inequality under our version of the fair - sampling assumption .
plot of the parameter @xmath79 ( eq . ( [ ineqloss ] ) ) for three different values of the overall efficiency @xmath49 .
continuous curves are theoretical predictions , while the points come from the experimental data .
the horizontal line indicates the lower bound imposed by banaszek - bell s inequality.,width=321 ] despite the observed violation of banaszek - bell s inequality , we can not claim nonlocality for our single - photon time - encoded two - mode system .
in fact , even in the case of unitary efficiency , our measuring scheme would still not satisfy the locality hypothesis : quadrature measurements on the two modes are actually done in sequence , so that a physical signal can in principle be exchanged between the two co - propagating temporal modes while homodyne measurements are performed on them .
the existence of this possibility makes our bell s inequality test subject to the so - called locality loophole , which automatically rules out the possibility of claiming non - locality @xcite .
however , this loophole simply derives from our choice of a temporal delocalization of the single photon and can in principle be eliminated in future experiments by introducing a fast switch which converts the two co - propagating temporal modes into two spatially - separated modes ; simultaneous measurements could then be performed on each of the two time - bins by two distant homodyne detectors .
our results demonstrate the feasibility of the tomographic approach to bell s inequality and may open the way toward new experiments for testing the foundations of quantum mechanics .
most important , our experiment sheds some light on the hotly debated concepts of single - photon two - mode entanglement and nonlocality @xcite .
on the one hand , single - photon two - mode states of the kind described by eq.([state_eq ] ) are known to give rise to interference upon recombination of the two spatiotemporal modes through an interferometric scheme ; in this perspective , the twc entanglement between two spatial modes sharing a single photon can be visualized in terms of wave - particle duality : the interference upon recombination supports the wave picture of light , while the lack of coincidence counts at the two exits of the entrance beam - splitter brings to evidence its particle nature . on the other hand , we have shown that our single - photon two - mode system manifests entanglement , both in terms of peres - like separability criteria and , under additional hypotheses , in the more restrictive terms of banaszek s version of bell s inequality .
the description of single - photon coherence effects in terms of single - photon n - mode entanglement is thus certainly possible and meaningful , and could contribute to make the counterintuitive wave - particle duality more intuitively accessible . in summary , we have evaluated the degree of entanglement of a single photon coherently delocalized between two distinct temporal modes and have implemented an innovative test of bell s inequality based on quantum homodyne tomography .
we have shown that , within some auxiliary assumptions , the correlations between two well - separated temporal modes sharing a single photon violate banaszek - bell s inequality . in this respect , it is worth emphasizing that none of our additional hypotheses is , in principle , indispensable .
in fact , different from bell s tests relying on post - selection , an improvement in the experimental efficiencies would allow us to avoid the fair sampling assumption ; indeed , a setup with an almost perfect single - photon preparation efficiency is currently possible .
furthermore a slight modification of the experimental setup would easily eliminate the locality loophole .
thanks to the high efficiencies achievable by homodyne detectors , out tomographic approach may represent the first step in the direction of a loophole - free test of bell s inequality . in this perspective , also the debated issue concerning the possibility of extending both concepts of entanglement and non - locality to a coherently delocalized single photon , finds here an interesting preliminary answer .
this work has been performed in the frame of the `` spettroscopia laser e ottica quantistica '' project of the physics department of the university of florence and partially supported by ente cassa di risparmio di firenze and miur , under the prin initiative and firb contract rbne01kz94 .
the most common auxiliary assumptions involved in the experimental tests of bell s inequality are : 1 ) the fair - sampling assumption , namely , the hypothesis that undetected events coming from low detection efficiencies would follow the same statistics of the measured data set , 2 ) post - selection , which consists in disregarding part of the state of a physical system by not measuring it ( i.e. , imposing a selective , or state - dependent , loss mechanism ) 3 ) the locality - loophole , which arises whenever a physical signal could be exchanged between the two systems under investigation during the measurement process .
e. santos , phys .
rev . lett . * 68 * , 894 ( 1992 ) ; l. hardy , _ ibid . _ * 75 * , 2065 ( 1995 ) and refs . therein ; d.m .
greenberger , _ et al .
_ _ ibid . _ * 75 * , 2064 ( 1995 ) ; a. peres , _ ibid . _ * 74 * , 4571 ( 1995 ) ; d. horne , _ et al .
a * 209 * , 1 ( 1995 ) ; k. jacobs , _ et al . _ ,
a * 54 * , r3738 ( 1996 ) a. peres , phys .
lett . * 77 * , 1413 ( 1996 ) b. yurke , _ et al .
lett . * 79 * , 4941 ( 1997 ) ; j. wenger , _ et al .
a * 67 * , 012105 ( 2003 ) ; s. daffer , _ et al .
_ , _ ibid _ * 72 * , 034101 ( 2005 ) by defining the purity parameter as @xmath80 , we get , in the spectral and the spatial domains , respectively : @xmath81 , and @xmath82 , where gaussian profiles with spectral and spatial widths @xmath83 and @xmath84 are assumed both for the pump power spectrum ( @xmath85 ) and for the filter transmission function in the idler channel ( @xmath86 ) .
the contribution of purity to the single - photon preparation efficiency is : @xmath87 .
g. m. dariano , _ et al .
a * 50 * , 4298 ( 1994 ) . after the vacuum - cleaning procedure , we find @xmath88 , which is very close to the unitary value expected for the pure state of eq .
( [ state_eq ] ) .
the amount of entanglement required for observing a violation of banaszek - bell s inequality is @xmath89 ; as far as the identification of entanglement is concerned , the more restrictive bounds imposed by bell s inequality with respect to peres criterion appear here explicitly . in this respect ,
it is worth reminding that also the first historical bell s inequality tests were affected by the locality loophole ; the problem was solved for the first time by a. aspect et al .
( prl * 49 * , 1804 ( 1982 ) ) . | time - domain balanced homodyne detection is performed on two well - separated temporal modes sharing a single photon .
the reconstructed density matrix of the two - mode system is used to prove and quantify its entangled nature , while the wigner function is employed for an innovative tomographic test of bell s inequality based on the theoretical proposal by banaszek and wodkiewicz ( phys .
rev .
lett .
82 , 2009 ( 1999 ) ) .
provided some auxiliary assumptions are made , a clear violation of banaszek - bell s inequality is found . |
the development of large - scale structure had to take place at epochs coresponding to redshifts greater than 0.2 ; moreover structure is now known to extend beyond scales of @xmath2 mpc .
both factors place the extent and evolution of large - scale structure beyond the reach of current optical and ir surveys and we must look outside these bands to address such key cosmological issues .
it has now been established that _
extragalactic radio sources _ can trace structure both to very early epochs and on very large scales @xcite,@xcite,@xcite .
this is a direct result of their uniform selection function : away from the galactic plane extragalactic radio sources are visible to very high redshifts ( @xmath3 ) with detection unaffected by obscuration .
moreover the high radio luminosities and strong space - density evolution yield a peak selection range of very high redshifts ( @xmath4 ) .
it was @xcite who showed how to determine the 3d 2-point spatial correlation function from 2d information in radio surveys themselves , a cosmological limber s equation , and an estimated redshift distribution for the radio sources to the survey limit .
this and more recent analyses use the best estimates of @xmath1 available , namely those from the comprehensive analysis of @xcite , in which all the then - known redshift and source - count data were synthesized into a determination of the epoch - dependent luminosity functions . these in turn can be used to predict @xmath1 at any frequency and flux - density level .
the statistical accuracy becomes rapidly poorer below flux densities equivalent to @xmath5 = 100 mjy , as the results are then an extrapolation .
moreover the analysis considers steep - and flat - spectrum populations separately and independently , while not including at all the starburst galaxy population which dominates at levels below a few mjy .
our recent analysis of radio source evolution in terms of a dual - population unified model @xcite,@xcite describes how the flat and steep - spectrum populations are physically related , and includes this latter starburst population .
accordingly it promises to predict @xmath1 with somewhat greater reliability , particularly at the lower flux densities .
our dual - population unified model is based on the two fanaroff - riley ( 1974 ) classes of radio galaxies as parent populations .
anisotropic radiation mechanisms of relativistic beaming along the radio axes and dusty tori shrouding the nuclei result in core - dominated quasars and bllac objects from these , when radio axes coincide closely with our line - of - sight .
we determined the cosmic evolution history of the two populations fri and frii from low - frequency ( 151 mhz ) survey statistics .
we then determined beaming models for the related quasars and bllac objects by matching predicted and observed source counts at 5 ghz using monte carlo orientation of the parent population . in this process
we adopted the pure luminosity evolution model for the starburst galaxy population derived by @xcite . in the process we found that a combination of strong cosmic evolution of the frii sources coupled with no evolution of the fri population is required to fit the low - frequency count data , while the best - fit beaming models for the two populations have parameters , jet - speeds in particular , which match those observed in vlbi observations of individual sources .
the composite model which we found for evolution and beaming gave a natural explanation of the change in source count shape with frequency , while showing good agreement with several other independent data sets .
our evolution and beaming model can be used predict at any frequency the intensity - dependent mix of the three underlying radio - source populations : the starburst galaxies , and the fri and frii radio galaxies together with their beamed ( on - axis ) counterparts .
figure 1 shows this mix for 1.4 ghz .
the model can also be used to predict the redshift distribution @xmath1 for any frequency and in a given intensity range .
figure 2 shows the @xmath1 derived for 1.4 ghz in the flux - density range @xmath6 mjy .
the dominant populations in this range ( see figure 1 ) are the fri sources ( beamed and unbeamed versions ) at moderate redshifts , with starburst galaxies at low redshift ; the high - power frii sources make only a minor contribution .
the implication for the latest generation of radio surveys which extend to @xmath7 mjy is that these surveys _ completely _ sample this the most powerful radio - source population ; one entire population is uniformly sampled across its entire evolutionary history to the highest observable redshifts by these sensitive radio surveys .
the difference between this estimation of @xmath1 and those used previously - in particular those from the models of @xcite - can be attributed to ( i ) the ` spike ' at @xmath8 due to the starburst galaxies , a population not included in previous analyses , and ( ii ) the lower median redshift due to the dominance of the unevolving fri population at this level .
lccc + & first @xcite & nvss @xcite & sumss @xcite + + + frequency & 1400 mhz & 1400 mhz & 843 mhz + area ( sq deg ) & 10,000 & 33,700 & 8,000 + resolution ( @xmath9 ) & 5@xmath9 & 45@xmath9 & 43@xmath9 + detection limit & 1 mjy & 2.5 mjy & @xmath105 mjy + coverage & ngp & @xmath11 @xmath1240@xmath13 & @xmath14 @xmath1230@xmath13 + sources / sq deg & @xmath1090 & @xmath1060 & @xmath1040 + * figure 1.*the predicted integral population mix at 1.4 ghz from our dual - population unified model @xcite , @xcite .
the contribution from the frii population ( frii radio galaxies and quasars ) is almost negligible at @xmath5=1 mjy . *
figure 2.*the total predicted @xmath1 for sources in the flux density range 1 @xmath15 100 mjy ( solid line ) from evolution models of @xcite ( average of models 1 - 4,6 & 7 ) ( dashed line ) , and @xcite ( dotted line ) . our evolution model ( and in consequence the @xmath1 predictions )
will be further refined by ( i ) incorporating the results from a multi - object spectroscopy campaign ( wyffos + wht , 2df + aat ) which targets first survey sources , and ( ii ) redefining the local radio luminosity function using spectra obtained by the 2df galaxy redshift survey ( m colless , these proceedings ) . | extragalactic radio sources are a unique cosmological probe in that they trace large - scale structure on scales inaccessible to other wavelengths .
however as radio survey data is inherently 2@xmath0 , the redshift distribution , @xmath1 , is necessary to derive spatial information . to obtain this distribution either we measure thousands of radio source redshifts to directly determine @xmath1 _ or _ we derive @xmath1 from statistical analyses of radio source count and identification data . in this paper
we show how the dual - population unification scheme can be incorporated into a rigorous statistical analysis of radio source count data , with the result that our simple parametric evolution and beaming model revises previous estimations of @xmath1 , specifically at low flux densites .
this revision is particularly pertinent given that the new generation of radio surveys extend to milli - jansky flux density levels : sampling source densities high enough to reveal spatial structure . in turn
, these new radio surveys will provide potent tests which will refine our model . |
astronomical ultraviolet studies were not possible before the advent of rocket - borne instruments and satellites due to atmospheric absorption and rayleigh scattering . the first satellite capable of uv observations , oao-2 , was launched in 1968 , and was followed by a host of other satellites ( cox 2000 ) , including thor delta-1 ( td-1 ) , astronomy netherlands satellite ( ans ) , and iue , among others .
the data obtained by these instruments are responsible for the vast majority of contributions to studies of interstellar dust , as dust grains preferentially extinguish short - wavelength light . by comparing heavily extinguished stars against their intrinsic fluxes ( the pair method ) ,
we can better understand grain properties and composition .
this is important for two reasons .
first , solid knowledge of grain properties will allow us to build more realistic grain models and correct for the effects of dust in stellar and galactic photometry and spectra more accurately .
second , dust grains are extremely sensitive to their environment , and can yield much information about local conditions and the physical and chemical processes which affect grains .
the pair method , first used by bless & savage 1970 , has since been used by many others to make extinction curves and study the ism in the milky way ( e.g. , york et al .
1973 ; nandy et al . 1975 , 1976 ; koorneef 1978 ; seaton 1979 ; snow & seab 1980 ; kester 1981 ; meyer & savage 1981 ; aiello et al .
1982 ; massa , savage & fitzpatrick 1983 ; massa & savage 1984 ; savage et al . 1985
; fitzpatrick & massa 1986 , 1988 , 1990 , hereafter fm86 , fm88 , fm90 ; clayton & fitzpatrick 1987 ; aiello et al .
1988 ; cardelli et al .
1988 , 1989 , hereafter ccm ; papaj , krelowski , & wegner 1991 ; papaj & krelowski 1992 , and jenniskens & greenberg 1993 , hereafter jg93 ) as well as in other galaxies ( borgman et al . 1975 ; nandy et al . 1981 ; koorneef & code 1981 ; clayton & martin 1985 ; fitzpatrick 1985 , 1986 ; clayton et al . 1996 ; bianchi et al . 1996
; gordon & clayton 1998 ; misselt et al . 1999 ; gordon et al .
2003 ) .
there are significant differences between dust grain properties in the galaxy and those found in the small and large magellanic clouds ( smc and lmc , respectively ) .
the smc bar has very strong , linear fuv extinction , while the sightlines toward the lmc2 supershell and the average lmc curve have a weaker bump and stronger fuv extinction than the average galactic r@xmath0=3.1 curve .
there are also significant differences in metallicities and the gas - to - dust ratios between the galaxy , lmc , and smc ( bohlin et al .
1978 ; gordon et al .
2003 ; luck & lambert 1992 ) .
a major leap forward in understanding interstellar extinction occurred in 1989 , when ccm suggested a mean extinction relation that depended on one parameter , the ratio of total - to - selective extinction , r@xmath0 ( = a@xmath1/e(b - v ) ) . with only very few exceptions ,
galactic extinction curves tend to follow this law within the uncertainties of the calculated r@xmath0 values and the extinction curves ( fitzpatrick 1999 ; clayton et al .
the galactic diffuse ism is well described by a curve where r@xmath0 = 3.1 .
r@xmath0 can also be thought of as a rough indicator of grain size , with low r@xmath0 sightlines having more small grains than high r@xmath0 sightlines .
the ccm extinction relation generally does not apply outside the galaxy , although recent work has shown that there are sightlines toward the lmc which may follow ccm ( gordon et al .
this law essentially replaced the galactic average extinction curve ( seaton 1979 ) with a family of r@xmath0-dependent extinction curves , with each curve representing a mean curve for sightlines of that particular value of r@xmath0 .
this also showed that many of the so - called `` anomalous '' sightlines ( e.g. clayton & fitzpatrick 1987 ) were in fact normal .
in addition to finding this relationship , ccm pointed out the usefulness of normalizing extinction curves to a@xmath1 , rather than e(b - v ) , as was usually done .
compared to e(b - v ) , a@xmath1 is a more basic quantity , and it is a direct measure of optical depth along a line of sight .
galactic extinction curves can be fit with six parameters ( fitzpatrick & massa 1990 ) which allow for quantitative analysis of extinction characteristics . despite all the work with extinction curves that has been done ,
a homogeneous database of milky way extinction curves does not exist .
the many previous studies , listed above , used data from different instruments , and variations of the pair method to construct extinction curves .
so , the results of these studies can not be compared easily .
also , these sightlines make up only about half of reddened sightlines available in the iue archive . to illustrate the disparateness of previous works , table [ tab : previous_work ] compares various aspects of previous studies to the present work .
column ( 1 ) lists authorship , ( 2 ) lists the number of sightlines , ( 3 ) lists the instrument the data was from , ( 4 ) shows if fm parameters were found , ( 5 ) shows whether the extinction curves were constructed using the mk classification or uv stellar features , and ( 6 ) shows if ir photometry , specifically r@xmath0 , was considered for the entire sample .
in order to solve this problem , we have built a homogeneous database of over four hundred extinction curves constructed in a uniform manner . over 150 of these sightlines
extend beyond 2 kpc , and 30 extend beyond 5 kpc , thus sampling a much larger volume of the galaxy than ever before .
this is a much larger and more complete database than any done previously . until the recent release of the 2mass database , jhk photometry was available for only a small fraction of the stars in the sample
now , estimates of r@xmath0 are available for the entire sample .
thus , it is now possible to draw a more coherent picture of extinction in the galaxy . in the following sections , we describe our database of extinction properties ,
present the results of our analyses , and discuss the implications for dust grains .
for the sake of homogeneity , hiltner s ubv photometry ( hiltner 1956 ; hiltner & johnson 1956 ) was preferred , when possible , and was obtained for 192 sightlines . in his massive compilation and assessment , nicolet ( 1978 ) found that hiltner s photometry was consistently of high quality .
systematic errors were typically less than 0.01 mag ( hiltner 1956 ) and photometry agreed well with the works of others ( nicolet 1978 ) .
photometry in the jhk bands was available for all the stars in the sample from the 2mass database ( cutri et al .
2003 ) .
reddened stars , observed by iue , having spectral types o3 to b5 were selected for the database .
an exception is hd 29647 , a b8 iii star , included because it has been well studied in the past ( e.g. , cardelli & savage 1988 ) .
this range of spectral types was chosen to minimize the effects of spectral mismatch in their extinction curves ( massa et al .
thorough discussions of the uncertainties in the pair method can be found in massa et al .
( 1983 ) , savage et al .
( 1985 ) , aiello et al . (
1988 ) , and gordon & clayton ( 1998 ) . only `` normal '' stars were included which had good unreddened uv comparison stars . the lower limit on e(b - v )
was 0.20 .
iue spectra for all of the stars in the sample were obtained from the multimission archive at space telescope ( mast ) .
the archive spectra were reduced using newsips and then recalibrated using the method developed by massa & fitzpatrick ( 2000 ) . the signal - to - noise of the newsips iue spectra
have been improved by 10 - 50% over those of iuesips iue spectra ( nichols & linsky 1996 ) .
low dispersion lwr / lwp and swp spectra were selected , from either aperture .
multiple spectra from one camera were averaged and then the long and short - wavelength segments were merged at the shortest wavelength of the swp . the wavelength coverage is @xmath31200 3200 with a resolution of @xmath35 .
the standard pair method , in which a reddened star is compared with an unreddened one of the same spectral type , was used to construct each sightline s extinction curve ( massa et al .
the comparison stars were selected from cardelli , sembach , & mathis ( 1992 ) and dereddened .
the spectral matches were made on the basis of comparing the uv spectra of pairs of stars rather than matching their visible spectral types .
r@xmath0 was estimated from the jhk colors as described in fitzpatrick ( 1999 ) .
a@xmath1 was found using r@xmath0 and e(b - v ) . in general , our uv spectral classifications are in good agreement with those which have been published previously ( e.g. , aiello et al . 1988 ; clayton & fitzpatrick 1987 ; papaj et al .
photometry , sources , mk and uv spectral types , reddenings , and calculated r@xmath0 values for all sightlines can be found in tables [ tab : phot ] , [ tab : citation_key ] , and [ tab : ext_query ] .
the resulting extinction curves were fit with the fitzpatrick - massa ( fm ) parameterization ( fitzpatrick & massa 1990 ) and then normalized to a@xmath0 .
setting @xmath4 , the fm fitting function is given by @xmath5 where @xmath6 and for @xmath7m@xmath8 , @xmath9 while @xmath10 for @xmath11m@xmath8 .
[ eq : fmfit ] results in 6 parameters , c@xmath12 , c@xmath13 , c@xmath14 , c@xmath15 , x@xmath16 , and @xmath17 , each of which describe different attributes of the curves . the first two ,
c@xmath12 and c@xmath13 , account for the intercept and slope of the linear background .
they are not independent of each other and can be merged into one parameter ( carnochan 1986 , fm88 ) , though that is not done here .
the quantities c@xmath14 and c@xmath15 correspond to the strength of the bump and the curvature of the fuv rise .
the last two parameters , @xmath18 and @xmath17 , correspond to the central wavenumber and width of the bump , respectively ; @xmath18 does not vary greatly from sightline to sightline , so it may be possible to reduce the number of parameters to four overall ( fitzpatrick 1999 ) . as can be seen in eqns .
[ eq : drude ] and [ eq : nonlinear ] , the bump is fit by a drude profile and the fuv extinction is fit by a nonlinear function .
the parameters were found using the three - step method of gordon et al .
( 2003 ) , over the wavelength range 2700 1250 .
the fm fit is not reliable longward of 2700 ( e. fitzpatrick 2002 , private communication ) .
the spectra are cut at the blue end at 1250 in order to exclude the ly@xmath19 feature at 1215 .
the normalization of the fm parameters was converted from e(b - v ) to a@xmath1 ( jg93 ) : @xmath20 so that the fm parameters become @xmath21 the resulting normalized fm parameters are listed in table [ tab : fm_query ] .
the dust environment was assessed by considering the traditional density measure , @xmath22 ; jg93 found that sightlines passing through dense regions had @xmath23 0.9 mag kpc@xmath8 , while more diffuse sightlines had @xmath24 0.9 mag kpc@xmath8 .
we have adopted this criterion for this study .
this parameter can be inaccurate since the density is averaged over the entire sightline ( jg93 ) .
other groups have noted that trends in extinction characteristics , especially those associated with the bump , can be linked to environmental influences ( fm86 ; cardelli & clayton 1991 ; jg93 ) .
figure [ fig : galaxy_fmfits ] shows the distribution of previously published sightlines in the galaxy with fm parameters normalized to e(b - v ) and the sightlines in this new database . because of our much larger sample , we have more complete coverage of nearby associations and more distant sightlines than previous works , pushing out further into the galaxy , and sampling a wider variety of environments . as distances were estimated using spectroscopic parallaxes , the uncertainties for stars plotted in fig . [
fig : galaxy_fmfits ] are large , with an average uncertainty of 50% .
the relationship between the various fm parameters were investigated as well as their dependence on r@xmath0@xmath8 . these are shown in figs . 2 - 8 .
for pairs of parameters with significant correlations , best - fit lines are plotted , using the least absolute deviation method as this is less affected by outliers than @xmath25 minimization .
there is a clear correlation between c@xmath12/r@xmath0 + 1.0 and c@xmath13/r@xmath0 ( see table [ tab : params_correl ] and fig .
[ fig : fm_params_cont ] ) .
this has been noted before ( carnochan 1986 ; fm86 ; jg93 ) . according to fm88 , c@xmath12 = -3.00 c@xmath13 + 2.04 , while jg93 find that c@xmath12 = ( [email protected] ) c@xmath13 + ( [email protected] ) .
this relation shows how tightly constrained the linear component of the extinction is with respect to @xmath27 ( fm88 ) .
there is also a weak correlation between c@xmath13/r@xmath0 and c@xmath14/r@xmath0 .
neither jg93 nor fm88 found any apparent relationships between the parameters c@xmath13 and c@xmath14 .
similarly , no correlation was found in our sample between these parameters .
a comparison of the parameters found in this study and those of jg93 and fm88 are shown in fig .
[ fig : c2_c3_rvcomp ] .
the values of c@xmath13 and c@xmath14 from the other groups have been divided by the values of r@xmath0 found in this work , and the best - fit line in the lower panel was found by considering points from both studies .
it was similar to that found here : c@xmath14/r@xmath1 = 1.77 c@xmath13/r@xmath0 + 0.67 , versus c@xmath14/r@xmath1 = 1.75 c@xmath13/r@xmath0 + 0.54 .
as both c@xmath13/r@xmath0 and c@xmath14/r@xmath0 increase with r@xmath0@xmath8 , and thus are influenced by similar environmental effects , perhaps it is not surprising that they themselves are correlated with each other . the parameters c@xmath15/r@xmath0 and c@xmath13/r@xmath0 do not show a correlation ; neither do the parameters c@xmath13/r@xmath0 and @xmath17 . these agree with the findings of fm88 and jg93 .
there is also no correlation ( @xmath28=0.13 ) between c@xmath15/r@xmath0 and @xmath17 .
this is in disagreement with the findings of carnochan ( 1986 ) , fm88 and jg93 , the latter of whom found a correlation coefficient @xmath28= 0.33 for these parameters .
these groups suggested that wider bumps tended to be found along sightlines with steep fuv rises , though this correlation was weak . in the present sample
, there was no correlation , regardless of whether the parameter c@xmath15 was normalized to e(b - v ) or a@xmath1 .
this reinforces the idea that factors influencing the bump width are distinct from those influencing the carrier of the fuv rise ( fm88 ) .
correlations between c@xmath13 , c@xmath14 , c@xmath15 , and r@xmath0@xmath8 , noted by ccm , are confirmed here , as is the absence of a correlation between x@xmath16 and r@xmath0@xmath8 .
also , while @xmath17 shows real variation , it does not appear to be linked with r@xmath0@xmath8 .
these can be seen in fig .
[ fig : ccm_karl ] . as
the 2175 bump is the only spectral feature yet known in the uv , parameters which describe it were carefully considered . in fig .
[ fig : c3_gamma ] , a relationship between c@xmath14/r@xmath0 and @xmath17 , very similar to the well - known relationship between c@xmath14 and @xmath17 , can be seen .
the values of c@xmath14/r@xmath0 are more confined at lower @xmath17 , but as @xmath17 increases , c@xmath14/r@xmath0 widens its range , with a general trend to increase with @xmath17 .
this was noted by both fm88 and jg93 in their studies of c@xmath14 and @xmath17 ; jg93 attributed it to the fitting procedure , but fm88 suggested that these two parameters are truly related in some way .
the width of the bump shows real variation and environmental dependence .
values for @xmath17 ranged from [email protected] @xmath29m@xmath8 ( hd 24263 ) to [email protected] @xmath29m@xmath8 ( hd 29647 ) .
this is a wider range than that reported by fm86 ( @xmath17 = [email protected] - [email protected] @xmath29m@xmath8 ) , perhaps reflecting the larger volume of the galaxy and wider range of environments covered by this study .
the average value in our sample is @[email protected] @xmath29m@xmath8 .
hd 29647 and hd 62542 have the broadest bumps , with @[email protected] @xmath29m@xmath8 and @xmath31 @xmath29m@xmath8 , respectively .
the average @xmath17 for dense and diffuse sightlines as defined above do not differ significantly , as @xmath32 = 0.95 @xmath260.04 @xmath29m@xmath8 and @xmath33 = 0.87 @xmath260.03 @xmath29m@xmath8 .
this likely reflects the density parameter s inability to sort out high versus low densities over long distances , as discussed previously .
a z - test ( i.e. , naiman , rosenfeld , & zirkel 1983 ) was done on the diffuse and dense @xmath17 subsets .
a z - test is essentially the same as a t - test , as it is used to determine if two different datasets have significantly different mean values , but is used for large samples . as with the t - test ,
the resulting significance of such a test ranges from 0 ( the samples have significantly different means ) to 1 ( the samples have essentially the same means ) .
for example , a significance of a few hundredths indicates that two samples have significantly different means .
for the dense and diffuse sightlines , the resulting significance was @xmath3 10@xmath34 , which implies that there is a very significant difference between the mean @xmath17 values of the dense and diffuse subsets .
[ fig : gamma_avonr ] shows a plot of all of the sightlines and their environmental dependence , and a plot of sightlines which are more than 3@xmath35 from the mean value of @xmath17 .
it can be seen that there is a clear trend that the narrowest bumps tend to be found along sightlines with @xmath360.9 mag / kpc , the `` diffuse '' subset .
these results strengthen those of fm86 and cardelli & clayton ( 1991 ) , who found that lines of sight that passed through bright nebulosities ( `` diffuse '' sightlines ) had narrower bumps than those that passed through dark clouds . fig .
[ fig : c4_c3 ] compares c@xmath15/r(v ) and c@xmath14/r(v ) , with respect to @xmath17 .
it can be seen that as the bump height increases , the range of values of the fuv rise increases , and the sightlines with the widest bumps tend to have higher values of c@xmath37/r(v ) , all of which has been reported previously by fm88 .
this is likely a reflection of the dependence of c@xmath14/r(v ) and @xmath17 on r@xmath38 .
no similar trends can be seen between c@xmath15/r(v ) and @xmath17 , as was discussed earlier .
[ fig : x0_gamma ] plots @xmath17 vs. x@xmath16 , the bump central wavelength , for the sample .
this figure shows that while @xmath17 varies significantly from one sightline to another , x@xmath16 does not .
the extremely narrow range of x@xmath16 agrees with fm86 , who found that the mean x@xmath16 = 4.60 @xmath29m@xmath8 .
they find extreme values of x@xmath16 are within @xmath260.04 @xmath29m@xmath8 of the mean .
neither hd 62542 nor hd 29647 were included in the fm86 sample .
jg93 found a similar value of @xmath39x@xmath40 @xmath29m@xmath8 for the aiello et al .
( 1988 ) sample . for the much larger sample studied here , @xmath39x@xmath41
= [email protected] @xmath29m@xmath8 , with values ranging from [email protected] @xmath29m@xmath8 ( hd 145792 ) to [email protected] @xmath29m@xmath8 ( hd 29647 ) . with the possible exception of hd 29647
, it appears that x@xmath16 does not vary from sightline to sightline .
cardelli & savage ( 1988 ) found that the 2175 bumps toward both hd 62542 and hd 29647 were significantly shifted to shorter wavelengths
. however , we find x@xmath42 0.03 @xmath29m@xmath8 for hd 62542 .
cardelli & savage ( 1988 ) found x@xmath16= [email protected] @xmath29m@xmath8 , and in the extinction curve shown in their work , the bump is visibly shifted blueward . in an effort to reproduce their results , the same iue spectra and uv comparison star were used to construct an extinction curve .
this curve was then fit over three ranges ; the original fm90 range ( 3.3 - 8.7 @xmath29m@xmath8 ) , from 3.7 - 8.0 @xmath29m@xmath8 , and from 3.7 - 8.7 @xmath29m@xmath8 excluding the region around ly@xmath19 .
none of these ranges produced a shifted bump .
while the spectra used by cardelli & savage ( 1988 ) are the same as used here , their spectra were reduced and calibrated with a different software package than those in the final archive . in our sample of 417 sightlines ,
only one was shifted as much as 3 @xmath35 beyond the mean .
we find x@xmath16 = [email protected] @xmath29m@xmath8 for hd 29647 , the same value found by cardelli & savage ( 1988 ) .
the other two fitting ranges that were considered when testing for hd 62542 s bump shift were applied to hd 29647 .
the values of x@xmath16 that were found were within 1 @xmath35 of the mean .
thus , it is quite possible that the shift in the hd 29647 bump also is fit dependent .
another sightline , lying close to that of hd 29647 has been studied ( clayton et al .
both sightlines pass through the taurus dark cloud .
the second sightline , toward hd 283809 , shows no evidence of a shifted bump . if the carrier is small graphite grains , then @xmath43 , where @xmath44 is the grain radius , while x@xmath16 is not a function of size ( bohren & huffman 1983 ; hecht 1986 ) .
hecht concluded that some fraction of small ( @xmath45 ) carbonaceous grains are bare and these are responsible for the bump . in this scenario ,
the bump width is dependent on the temperature and size distribution of these grains .
the remaining small carbon grains are hydrogenated , which would suppress the bump ( hecht 1986 ) .
one drawback to this model was that it required an overabundance of small grains in dense regions relative to diffuse regions ( fm86 ; sorrell 1990 ) , since a large value of @xmath17 implies small grain size in this scenario .
this conflicts with the observation that dense regions tend to have higher values of r@xmath0 , indicating the prevalence of large grains . however , since x@xmath16 is not dependent on r@xmath0 ( or anything else ) , the grains which produce the bump may form a separate population from those which are responsible for variations in r@xmath0 ( ccm ) . on the other hand , it can be seen in fig . [
fig : ccm_karl ] that there is a weak correlation between @xmath17 and r@xmath0@xmath8 .
this agrees with the finding that @xmath17 is environment dependent . in 1990 , sorrell expanded upon hecht s ( 1986 ) work , suggesting that the accretion of hydrogen on larger graphite grains with 60 @xmath46 was responsible for the variations in @xmath17 .
he suggested that hydrogenation of grains in dense regions broadens the bump , without affecting x@xmath16 .
mathis ( 1994 ) considered diamond , amorphous carbon ( amc ) , water ice , and pah mantles on graphite cores .
he found that the diamond coating tended to shift x@xmath16 to longer much wavelengths .
a thin coating of amorphous carbon yields x@xmath16 = 4.57 @xmath29m@xmath8 but produces a low @xmath17= 0.84 @xmath29m@xmath8 . increasing the thickness of mantle
does not increase @xmath17 to values that are observed ; a thicker mantle only broadens the bump to @xmath17=0.93 @xmath29m@xmath8 .
hydrogenated amorphous carbon mantles are even less suitable , as they shift x@xmath16 to longer wavelengths while having even less of an impact on @xmath17 than amc did .
water ice mantles may broaden @xmath17 , but only one sightline in our sample ( hd 29647 ) has the telltale 3.07 @xmath29 m ice feature ( goebel 1983 ) .
warren ( 1984 ) showed that ice mantles do not affect the bump because there is almost no absorption at wavelengths near 2175 .
neutral pahs are also possible bump grain candidates , as they can produce both x@xmath16 and @xmath17 consistent with observations , with x@xmath47 4.61 @xmath29m@xmath8 for @xmath17= 1.0 @xmath29m@xmath8 ( mathis 1994 ) .
however , these values were found by assuming that the optical constants of isolated pahs are similar to those comprising the mantle and by ignoring impurities which might alter the pah optical properties .
another drawback is that neutral pahs should have absorption features in the uv which are not seen ( clayton et al .
2003 ) , though joblin et al .
( 1992 ) showed that this could be masked by averaging over a distribution of pahs of different sizes . also , it is unlikely that many pahs are neutral in the diffuse ism ( e.g. , lepage et al .
2003 ) .
adherence to the r@xmath0-dependent extinction law of ccm in our sample was also examined . in order to do this , we found the ccm curve which best fit each extinction curve .
the extinction curves were fit with a ccm curve using a standard idl curve fitting routine that minimized the @xmath25 .
the values of r@xmath0 found this way were compared to those calculated using ir photometry as is shown in fig .
[ fig : rv_test ] .
while there is some scatter , there is generally good agreement between the two values , with the fitted r@xmath0 being within 3@xmath35 of the calculated value for 93% of the sample .
this indicates that the vast majority of sightlines agree with ccm within the measurement uncertainties .
the near absence of non - ccm sightlines in the galaxy could be attributed to the iue dataset somehow favoring lines of sight through ccm - type dust environments .
iue was a small telescope with limited dynamic range .
as a result , there is little information on grain parameters deep inside dark clouds .
the dust columns sampled in this study all have a@xmath48 5 mag .
next we measured deviations of each measured extinction curve from its best fit ccm curve .
we followed the method of mathis & cardelli ( 1992 ; hereafter mc92 ) , in which the authors specified the deviation at various wavelengths to be : @xmath49_{i } - [ a_{\lambda}/a_{v}]_{ccm}\ ] ] plots are shown of these deviations in fig . [ fig : deviations ] at 4.65 , 4.90 , 5.07 , 5.24 , and 7.82 @xmath29m@xmath8 .
the calculated and best - fit ccm extinction curves agreed within 2@xmath35 of each other for all but four of the sightlines , hd 210121 , hd 204827 , hd 62542 , and hd 29647 , which are deviant at several wavelengths .
their deviations are shown in table [ tab : deviations_list ] .
hd 204827 is an intriguing sightline .
it has been shown that when a foreground reddening component has been removed , its extinction curve resembles that of the smc , even though the environment of the dust in the hd 204827 cloud is quite different from that seen in the smc sightlines ( valencic et al .
a similar curve has been found toward hd 283809 ( whittet et al .
the dust local to hd 204827 has high density .
the hd 204827 dust cloud resembles a molecular cloud more than the diffuse ism .
the hd 204827 cloud is very rich in carbon molecules , showing large column densities of c@xmath50 , c@xmath37 , ch , and cn ( oka et al .
2003 ; thorburn et al .
the sightline to hd 204827 samples dust swept up by a supernova or hot star winds ( patel 1998 ) . in these respects ,
the hd 204827 dust is quite similar to the sightline toward hd 62542 ( cardelli & savage 1988 ) .
its dust is also rich in carbon molecules .
the sightline to hd 62542 also lies on the edge of material swept up by a stellar wind bubble .
the other two non - ccm , weak bump , steep far - uv sightlines in the galaxy , hd 29647 , and hd 210121 , are also associated with dense clouds ( cardelli & savage 1988 ; larson , whittet , & hough 1996 ; cardelli & wallerstein 1989 ) .
the dust in the molecular cloud associated with hd 210121 is likely to have been processed as it was propelled into the halo during a galactic fountain or other event .
the final sightline , toward hd 29647 , is sampling dust in a quiescent dense cloud .
the steep far - uv extinction in these clouds helps shield the molecules in these clouds from dissociating uv radiation leading to larger column densities ( mathis 1990 ) .
[ fig : delta782_ncn_sig2 ] shows the deviations , @xmath51 and @xmath52 , plotted against the column density of cn along the sightline divided by a@xmath0 for 46 sightlines from our sample , including the four non - ccm sightlines discussed above ( federman 1994 ; oka et al .
cn can be used as an indicator of relatively dense regions in diffuse , molecule - rich clouds ( joseph et al .
1986 ; gredel et al .
the average @xmath51 and n(cn)/a@xmath1 ( 10@xmath53@xmath54 mag@xmath8 ) for the 42 ccm - like sightlines were [email protected] and [email protected] , respectively . for the four non - ccm sightlines , these values were [email protected] and [email protected] .
these four sightlines have both high n(cn)/a@xmath1 and sigificant deviation from ccm at @xmath27=7.82 compared to the ccm - like sample .
similarly , burgh et al .
( 2000 ) showed that sightlines with steep fuv rises tend to have high n(co)/e(b - v ) , though they did not notice any correlating weakness in the bump strength .
virtually all of the non - ccm sightlines known today are in the ( diffuse ) magellanic clouds , not in dense galactic clouds ( e.g. , gordon et al .
clayton et al .
( 2000 ) , found that the average of seven low density , low reddening sightlines showed an extinction curve very similar to the lmc .
these 7 stars were found to be behind gas that showed signs of being subjected to shocks the deviations from ccm for the average of these 7 sightlines as well as for the smc and lmc average curves were also found and are included in figs .
[ fig : deviations ] and [ fig : rv_test ] .
similar deviations from ccm may arise in various dust environments .
the new extinction curves and values of r@xmath1 allow us to revise the ccm law .
this was done by following the method described in ccm ; that is , by plotting a@xmath55/a@xmath1 against r@xmath38 for all wavelengths , then performing a linear least - squares fit of the resulting correlation .
thus , for all wavelengths , the extinction a@xmath55/a@xmath56r@xmath0 . then , @xmath57 and @xmath58 were plotted against @xmath27 and fit with a polynomial expression by minimizing @xmath25 .
it was found that for 3.3 @xmath59m@xmath8 , @xmath60 where , for @xmath61m@xmath8 , @xmath62 and for @xmath63m@xmath8 , @xmath64 a comparison of extinction laws are plotted in fig .
[ fig : lots_of_lines ] .
the most noticeable difference between the law found here and the original ccm law , the increase in the zero - point of the uv extinction , is a consequence of the slightly higher value of the first term in @xmath57 . in 1988
, ccm also found a higher value for this term ( 1.802 ) than in 1989 ( 1.752 ) , when they found that the lower value , which was within the dispersion in the data , was needed for the curve to smoothly join the optical extinction data .
[ fig : lots_of_lines ] also shows the resulting curve when the average fm parameter values are used to construct extinction curves at different values of r@xmath1 , in a fashion similar to fitzpatrick ( 1999 ) .
the two methods of curve construction yield curves that are within 5% of each other for 2.5 @xmath65 r@xmath66 5.0 over the entire wavelength range .
for all values of r@xmath1 , the difference is primarily in the bump height , or the fm parameter c@xmath14 .
this is most noticeable for 5.0 @xmath39 r@xmath67 6.0 ; here , the curves agree to within 7% , with the curve found through the average fm parameters having a weaker bump than predicted by the either the revised or original ccm law .
this can also be seen to a certain extent in fig .
[ fig : ccm_karl ] . a weakened bump at high r@xmath1 may be expected from whittet et al.s ( 2004 ) work , which suggests that the bump carrier may be destroyed in dark clouds .
both the revised ccm curves and the average fm curves are within about 5% of the original ccm law for 2.5 @xmath65 r@xmath66 3.5 . however , for increasing values of r@xmath1 , the difference between the curves increases as well , reaching 20% at r@xmath68 . that the original ccm law agreed so well with the extinction curves examined here
is an indicator of the sizes of the uncertainties on the data .
changes in the value of the extinction zero - point is an important factor . if the first term in @xmath57 is decreased by 0.20 , the new ccm law and the original curve agree to within 15% for 2.5 @xmath65 r@xmath1 @xmath65 6.0 for @xmath69m@xmath8 , and within about 20% for @xmath70m@xmath8 .
the dotted curve , constructed from fitzpatrick s ( 1999 ) suggested values of fm parameters with only c@xmath50 ( and through it , c@xmath71 ) dependent on r@xmath1 , illustrate further the dependences of some fm parameters on r@xmath0 .
we have constructed a homogeneous database of uv extinction curves , all of which have been fit by the fm relation and for which values of r@xmath0 have been calculated .
all extinction curves and fm parameters have been normalized to a@xmath1 , rather than e(b - v ) , so that relationships between parameters may be more easily seen .
this is the largest and most comprehensive database of extinction curves yet constructed , sampling a wide variety of environments .
it contains much longer sightlines than those included in previous studies ( 30 sightlines have d @xmath2 5 kpc ) , thus greatly increasing the volume of the galaxy sampled compared to previous works .
over 150 sightlines have d @xmath2 2 kpc , so the regions of the galaxy beyond the solar neighborhood are well represented .
the ccm extinction relation accurately describes the diffuse galactic ism in virtually all cases . out of 417 sightlines , only 4 deviated consistently from their ccm extinction curves by more than 3@xmath35 .
this indicates that the physical processes which give rise to grain populations that have ccm - like extinction dominate the ism , and thus , the quantity r@xmath0 can accurately describe the uv extinction for most sightlines .
this implies that the grain populations responsible for different components of the extinction curve are being processed efficiently and systematically along most sightlines .
the new curves and r@xmath1 values allow for an updated ccm law to be made .
the original and updated versions are within 5% of each other for 2.5 @xmath65 r@xmath72 over the full wavelength range covered , 3.3 @xmath65 x @xmath73m@xmath8 . at higher values of r@xmath1 ,
the differences in the extinction zero - point reduce the agreement in the curves to about 20% .
the bump width has a strong environmental dependence , with narrow bumps favoring diffuse sightlines , and broad bumps favoring dense sightlines .
very broad bumps are rare , as only 21 out of 417 sightlines had @xmath74 1.1 .
the central wavelength of the bump is invariant and may be regarded as a constant , with x@[email protected] . unlike the other parts of the uv extinction curve
, this parameter does not respond to different environments .
the invariance of x@xmath16 , along with the observed variations in @xmath17 , put strong constraints on possible bump grain and mantle materials .
while there is evidence for shock processing in three of the four non - ccm sightlines , the common denominator is that all four sightlines have dense , molecule - rich clouds .
they also had weak bumps and strong fuv extinction for their measured r@xmath0 ccm curves , especially those which pass through cold , quiescent regions .
the weakened bump may reflect processing which modifies or destroys the bump carrier in dark clouds ( whittet et al .
this is seen in the bumpless dust toward hd 204827 and hd 283809 .
other dense sightlines with strong fuv extinction , hd 204827 , hd 62542 , and hd 210121 , pass through dense clouds that may have been exposed to shocks or strong uv radiation that disrupt large grains , possibly resulting in a size distribution that is skewed toward small grains .
aiello , s. , guidi , i. , barsella , b. , penco , u. , & perinotto , m. 1982 , ap&ss , 87 , 463 aiello , s. , barsella , b. , chlewicki , g.,greenberg , j. m. , patriarchi , p. , & perinotto , m. 1988 , a&as , 73 , 195 allain , t , leach , s. , & sedlmayr , e. 1996 , a & a , 305 , 602 allain , t , leach , s. , & sedlmayr , e. 1996 , a&a , 305 , 616 barbaro , g. , mazzei , p. , morbidelli , l. , patriarchi , p. , & perinotto , m. 2001 , a&a , 365 , 157 bianchi , l. , clayton , g. c. , bohlin , r. c. , hutchings , j. b. , & massey , p. 1996
, , 471 , 203 bless , r. c. & savage , b. d. 1970 , in ultraviolet stellar spectra and related ground - based observations , iau symp .
l. houziaux and h.e .
butler , ( dordecht : ridel ) , p. 28
bohlin , r. c. savage , b. d. , & drake , j. f. 1978 , apj , 224 , 132 bohren c. f. & huffman , d. r. 1983 , absorption and scattering of light by small particles ( new york : wiley interscience ) borgman , j. , van duinen , r. j. , & koornneef , j. 1975 , a&a , 40 , 461 burgh , e. b. , mccandliss , s. r. , andersson , b .- g . , & feldman , p. d. 2000 , , 541 , 250 cardelli , j. & clayton , g. 1991 , , 101 , 1021 cardelli , j. , clayton , g. , & mathis , j. 1988 , , 329 , 33 cardelli , j. , clayton , g. , & mathis , j. 1989 , , 345 , 245 cardelli , j. & savage , b. 1988 , , 325 , 864 cardelli , j. , sembach , k. r. , & mathis , j. s. 1992 , , 104 , 1916 cardelli , j. & wallerstein , g. 1989 , , 97 , 1099 carnochan , d. j. 1986 , mnras , 219 , 903 clayton , g. c. & fitzpatrick , e. l. 1987 , , 93 , 157 clayton , g. c. , gordon , k. d. , salama , f. , allamandola , l. j. , martin , peter g. , snow , t. p. , whittet , d. c. b. , witt , a. n. , & wolff , michael j. 2003 , apj , 592 , 947 clayton , g. c. , gordon , k. d. , & wolff , m. j. 2000 , , 129 , 147 clayton , g. c. , green , j. , wolff , m. , zellner , n. , code , a. , davidsen , a. , wuppe science team , & hut science team , 1996 , , 460 , 313 clayton , g. c. & martin , p. g. 1985 , , 288 , 558 cox , a. n. 2000 , allen s astrophysical quantities ed .
a. n. cox , ( 4th ed . ;
london : aip ltd . ) cutri , r.m . , et al . 2003 , 2mass second incremental all sky point source catalog draine , b. t. & lee , h. m. 1984 , apj , 285 , 89 draine , b. t. 1985 , apjs , 57 , 587 draine , b. t. 1987 , apjs , 64 , 505 federman , s. r. , strom , c. j. , lambert , d. l. , cardelli , jason a. , smith , v. v. , & joseph , c. l. 1994 , apj , 424 , 772 fitzpatrick , e. l. 1985 , , 59 , 77 fitzpatrick , e. l. 1986 , , 92 , 1068 fitzpatrick , e. l. 1999 , pasp , 111 , 63 fitzpatrick , e. & massa , d. 1990 , , 72 , 163 goebel , j. h. 1983 , apj , 268 , 41 gordon , k. & clayton , g. 1998 , , 500 , 816 gordon , k. , clayton , g. , misselt , k. , landolt , a. , & wolff , m. 2003 , , 594 , 279 gredel , r. , pineau des forets , g. , & federman , s. r. 2002 , a&a , 389 , 933 guetter , h. 1974 , pasp , 86 , 795 haupt , h. & schroll a. 1974 , a&as , 15 , 311 hecht , j. 1986 , apj , 305 , 817 hiltner , w. a. 1956 , , 2 , 389 hiltner , w. a. & johnson , h. l. 1956 , apj , 124 , 367 jackson , j. d. 1962 , in classical electrodynamics ( new york : wiley ) jenniskens , p. & greenberg , j. m. 1993 , a&a , 274 , 439 joblin , c. , lger , a. , & martin , p. 1992 , 393
, 79l joseph , c. l. , snow , t. p. jr . , seab , c. , & crutcher , r. m. 1986 , apj , 309 , 771 kester , d. 1981 , a&a , 99 , 375 koornneef , j. 1978 , a&a , 68 , 139 koornneef , j. & code , a. d. 1981 , apj , 247 , 860 larson , k. a. , whittet , d. c. b. , & hough , j. h. 1996 , , 472 , 755 le page , v. , snow , t. , & bierbaum , v. 2003 , apj , 584 , 316 luck , r. e. & lambert , david l. 1992 , apjs , 79 , 303 massa , d. , & fitzpatrick , e. l. 2000 , apjs , 126 , 517 massa , d. savage , b. d. & fitzpatrick , e. l. 1983 , , 266 , 662 massa , d. & savage , b. d. 1984 , apj , 279,310 mathis , j. 1990 , ara&a , 28 , 37 mathis , j. & cardelli , j. 1992 , , 104 , 1916 mathis , j. s. 1994 , apj , 422 , 176 meyer , d. m. & savage , b. d. 1981 , apj , 248 , 545 misselt , k. clayton , g. & gordon , k. 1999 , , 515 , 128 naiman , a. , rosenfeld , r. , & zirkel , g. 1983 , understanding statistics ( 3rd ed . ; new york : mcgraw - hill , inc . ) nandy , k. , thompson , g. i. , jamar , c. , monfils , a. , & wilson , r. 1975 , a&a , 44 , 195 nandy , k. , thompson , g. i. , jamar , c. , monfils , a. , & wilson , r. 1976 , a&a , 51 , 63 nandy , k. , morgan , d. h. , willis , a. j. , wilson , r. , & gondhalekar , p. m. 1981 , mnras , 196 , 955 nichols , j.s . &
linsky , j.l .
1996 , aj , 111 , 517 nicolet , b. 1978 , a&as , 34 , 1 1996 , aj , 111 , 517 oka , t. , thorburn , j. a. , mccall , b. j. , friedman , s. d. , hobbs , l. m. , sonnentrucker , p. , welty , d. e. , & york , d. g. 2003 , , 582 , 339 papaj , j. , krelowski , j. , wegner , w. 1991 , mnras , 252 , 403 papaj , j. & krelowski , j. 1992 , aca , 42 , 211 patel , n. a. , goldsmith , p. f. , heyer , m. h. , snell , r. l. , & pratap , p. 1998
, , 507 , 241 pendleton , y. j. , sandford , s. a. , allamandola , l. j. , tielens , a. g. g. m. & sellgren , k. 1994 , , 437 , 683 savage , b. d. ; massa , d. ; meade , m. ; wesselius , p. r. 1985 , apjs , 59 , 397 schild , r. , garrison , r. , & hiltner , w. 1983 , apjs , 51 , 321 seaton , m. j. 1979 , mnras , 187 , 73 smith , r. g. , sellgren , k. , & brooke , t. y. 1993 , mnras , 263 , 749 snow , t. p.
seab , c. g. 1980 , apj , 242 , l83 sorrell , w. h. 1990 , mnras , 243 , 570 spitzer , l. 1978 , physical processes in the interstellar medium , ( new york : john wiley & sons , inc . ) thorburn , j. a. , hobbs , l. m. , mccall , b. j. , oka , t. , welty , d. e. , friedman , s. d. , snow , t. p. , sonnentrucker , p. , york , d. g. 2003 , apj , 584 , 339 valencic , l. a. , clayton , g.c . , gordon , k.d . , & smith , t.l .
2003 , , 589 , 369 verstraete , l. , leger , a. , dhendecourt , l. , defourneau , d. , dutuit , o. 1990 , a&a , 237 , 436 warren , s. g. 1984 , appl .
optics , 23 , 1206 whittet , d. senoy , s. clayton , g. gordon , k. 2004 , in astrophyics of dust , in press york , d. g. , drake , j. f. , jenkins , e. b. , morton , d. c. , rogerson , j. b. , & spitzer , l. 1973 , apj , 182 , l1 and @xmath17 , have been divided by r@xmath0 and thus normalized to a@xmath1 .
dense sightlines ( those with @xmath75 ) are indicated by triangles , while diffuse sightlines ( @xmath76 ) are indicated with diamonds .
representative error bars are indicated .
[ fig : fm_params_cont],title="fig : " ] and @xmath17 , have been divided by r@xmath0 and thus normalized to a@xmath1 .
dense sightlines ( those with @xmath75 ) are indicated by triangles , while diffuse sightlines ( @xmath76 ) are indicated with diamonds .
representative error bars are indicated .
[ fig : fm_params_cont],title="fig : " ] and @xmath17 , have been divided by r@xmath0 and thus normalized to a@xmath1 .
dense sightlines ( those with @xmath75 ) are indicated by triangles , while diffuse sightlines ( @xmath76 ) are indicated with diamonds .
representative error bars are indicated .
[ fig : fm_params_cont],title="fig : " ] and @xmath17 , have been divided by r@xmath0 and thus normalized to a@xmath1 .
dense sightlines ( those with @xmath75 ) are indicated by triangles , while diffuse sightlines ( @xmath76 ) are indicated with diamonds .
representative error bars are indicated .
[ fig : fm_params_cont],title="fig : " ] and @xmath17 , have been divided by r@xmath0 and thus normalized to a@xmath1 .
dense sightlines ( those with @xmath75 ) are indicated by triangles , while diffuse sightlines ( @xmath76 ) are indicated with diamonds .
representative error bars are indicated .
[ fig : fm_params_cont],title="fig : " ] and c@xmath14 from all database sightlines , divided by r@xmath0 and thus normalized to a@xmath1 .
bottom panel : values of c@xmath13 and c@xmath14 from fm88 ( triangles ) and jg93 ( squares ) , divided by r@xmath0 and thus normalized to a@xmath1 .
representative error bars are indicated in both panels .
[ fig : c2_c3_rvcomp ] ] @xmath8 .
all parameters , except x@xmath16 and @xmath17 , have been divided by r@xmath0 and thus normalized to a@xmath1 .
symbols are the same as defined in fig .
the solid lines represent the best fits .
the dashed lines indicate the expected values from the ccm relation ; the dash - dot lines are from fitzpatrick s ( 1999 ) reformulation of the ccm law .
representative error bars are indicated .
[ fig : ccm_karl],title="fig : " ] @xmath8 .
all parameters , except x@xmath16 and @xmath17 , have been divided by r@xmath0 and thus normalized to a@xmath1 .
symbols are the same as defined in fig .
the solid lines represent the best fits .
the dashed lines indicate the expected values from the ccm relation ; the dash - dot lines are from fitzpatrick s ( 1999 ) reformulation of the ccm law .
representative error bars are indicated .
[ fig : ccm_karl],title="fig : " ] @xmath8 .
all parameters , except x@xmath16 and @xmath17 , have been divided by r@xmath0 and thus normalized to a@xmath1 .
symbols are the same as defined in fig .
the solid lines represent the best fits .
the dashed lines indicate the expected values from the ccm relation ; the dash - dot lines are from fitzpatrick s ( 1999 ) reformulation of the ccm law .
representative error bars are indicated .
[ fig : ccm_karl],title="fig : " ] @xmath8 .
all parameters , except x@xmath16 and @xmath17 , have been divided by r@xmath0 and thus normalized to a@xmath1 .
symbols are the same as defined in fig .
the solid lines represent the best fits .
the dashed lines indicate the expected values from the ccm relation ; the dash - dot lines are from fitzpatrick s ( 1999 ) reformulation of the ccm law .
representative error bars are indicated .
[ fig : ccm_karl],title="fig : " ] @xmath8 .
all parameters , except x@xmath16 and @xmath17 , have been divided by r@xmath0 and thus normalized to a@xmath1 .
symbols are the same as defined in fig .
the solid lines represent the best fits .
the dashed lines indicate the expected values from the ccm relation ; the dash - dot lines are from fitzpatrick s ( 1999 ) reformulation of the ccm law .
representative error bars are indicated .
[ fig : ccm_karl],title="fig : " ] @xmath8 .
all parameters , except x@xmath16 and @xmath17 , have been divided by r@xmath0 and thus normalized to a@xmath1 .
symbols are the same as defined in fig .
the solid lines represent the best fits .
the dashed lines indicate the expected values from the ccm relation ; the dash - dot lines are from fitzpatrick s ( 1999 ) reformulation of the ccm law .
representative error bars are indicated .
[ fig : ccm_karl],title="fig : " ] , vs. density .
the solid line is the cutoff between dense and diffuse lines of sight .
left panel : all sightlines in database .
right panel : sightlines beyond 3@xmath35 of the mean . in order to make the correlation easier to see ,
those lines of sight that agreed with the mean were removed ; the remainder are shown in the right hand panel . in both
, the line at @xmath22 = 0.9 indicates the cutoff between dense and diffuse lines of sight .
[ fig : gamma_avonr],title="fig : " ] , vs. density .
the solid line is the cutoff between dense and diffuse lines of sight .
left panel : all sightlines in database .
right panel : sightlines beyond 3@xmath35 of the mean . in order to make the correlation easier to see ,
those lines of sight that agreed with the mean were removed ; the remainder are shown in the right hand panel . in both
, the line at @xmath22 = 0.9 indicates the cutoff between dense and diffuse lines of sight .
[ fig : gamma_avonr],title="fig : " ] /r@xmath0 , vs. bump height , c@xmath14/r@xmath0 .
symbols are the same as defined in fig .
representative error bars are indicated .
the bump height ( c@xmath14/r@xmath0 ) and fuv curvature ( c@xmath15/r@xmath0 ) are plotted with respect to bump width .
values of @xmath17 were split into three categories , each roughly pertaining to environment , with diamonds indicating @xmath77 , triangles for @xmath78 , and squares for @xmath79 .
[ fig : c4_c3 ] ] values , found through @xmath25 minimization , compared to r@xmath0 values found through ir photometry .
a line of slope unity has been overlayed .
four lines of sight with unusual extinction are indicated ( filled circles ) .
lines of sight where the best - fit r@xmath0 did not agree with the measured value are indicated with error bars .
the average lmc ( filled triangle ) , lmc2 supershell ( filled diamond ) , and smc ( filled star ) are plotted . from clayton et al .
( 2000 ) , the average low - density sightline for a galactic region with extinction similar to that of the magellanic clouds ( the `` sd region '' ) is also shown ( filled square ) .
[ fig : rv_test ] ] law at various wavelengths .
representative error bars are indicated .
four galactic lines of sight with unusual extinction are named .
the sd region average sightline ( clayton et al .
2000 ; filled square ) , average lmc ( filled triangle ) , lmc2 supershell ( filled diamond ) , and smc ( filled star ) are also plotted .
[ fig : deviations],title="fig : " ] law at various wavelengths .
representative error bars are indicated .
four galactic lines of sight with unusual extinction are named .
the sd region average sightline ( clayton et al .
2000 ; filled square ) , average lmc ( filled triangle ) , lmc2 supershell ( filled diamond ) , and smc ( filled star ) are also plotted .
[ fig : deviations],title="fig : " ] law at various wavelengths .
representative error bars are indicated .
four galactic lines of sight with unusual extinction are named .
the sd region average sightline ( clayton et al .
2000 ; filled square ) , average lmc ( filled triangle ) , lmc2 supershell ( filled diamond ) , and smc ( filled star ) are also plotted .
[ fig : deviations],title="fig : " ] law at various wavelengths .
representative error bars are indicated .
four galactic lines of sight with unusual extinction are named .
the sd region average sightline ( clayton et al .
2000 ; filled square ) , average lmc ( filled triangle ) , lmc2 supershell ( filled diamond ) , and smc ( filled star ) are also plotted .
[ fig : deviations],title="fig : " ] law at various wavelengths .
representative error bars are indicated .
four galactic lines of sight with unusual extinction are named .
the sd region average sightline ( clayton et al .
2000 ; filled square ) , average lmc ( filled triangle ) , lmc2 supershell ( filled diamond ) , and smc ( filled star ) are also plotted .
[ fig : deviations],title="fig : " ] m@xmath8 and 4.65 @xmath29m@xmath8 versus abundance of cn .
values of n(cn ) are from federman ( 1994 ) and oka et al .
unusual galactic sightlines are indicated with solid cirles .
[ fig : delta782_ncn_sig2],title="fig : " ] m@xmath8 and 4.65 @xmath29m@xmath8 versus abundance of cn .
values of n(cn ) are from federman ( 1994 ) and oka et al .
unusual galactic sightlines are indicated with solid cirles .
[ fig : delta782_ncn_sig2],title="fig : " ] | we have assembled a homogeneous database of 417 ultraviolet ( uv ) extinction curves for reddened sightlines having international ultraviolet explorer ( iue ) spectra .
we have combined these with optical and 2mass photometry allowing estimates of the ratio of total - to - selective extinction , r@xmath0 , for the entire sample .
fitzpatrick - massa ( fm ) parameters have also been found for the entire sample .
this is the largest study of parameterized uv extinction curves yet published and it covers a wide range of environments , from dense molecular clouds to the diffuse interstellar medium ( ism ) , with extinctions a@xmath1 ranging from 0.50 to 4.80 .
it is the first to extend far beyond the solar neighborhood and into the galaxy at large , with 30 sightlines having distances @xmath2 5 kpc .
previously , the longest sightlines with fm parameters and r@xmath1 extended @xmath3 1 kpc .
we find that ( 1 . )
the ccm extinction law applies for 93% of the sightlines , implying that dust processing in the galaxy is efficient and systematic ; ( 2 . )
the central wavelength of the 2175 bump is constant ; ( 3 . ) the 2175 bump width is dependent on environment .
only four sightlines show systematic deviations from ccm , hd 29647 , 62542 , 204827 , and 210121 .
these sightlines all sample dense , molecule - rich clouds . the new extinction curves and values of r@xmath1
allow us to revise the ccm law . |
coronal mass ejections ( cmes ) are one of the most spectacular phenomena in the solar corona .
cmes show some kind of association with various forms of solar activities ; 40% of cmes were associated with flares , but more than 70% were associated with eruptive prominence or disappearing filaments ( munro et al . 1979 ; webb & hundhausen 1987 ; see kahler 1992 for review ) .
on the other hand , observations with soft x - ray telescope ( sxt ) aboard _ yohkoh _ revealed that formations of giant arcades are associated with filament eruptions that are not associated with flares ( tsuneta et al .
1992 ; hiei et al .
1993 , hanaoka et al . 1994 ; mcallister et al .
although such arcades are usually not recognized as flares because of their weak x - ray intensity , they have arcade structures with expanding cusp - shaped loops ( helmet streamer ) , which is very similar to flares . from this and other evidence ( e.g. yamamoto et al .
2002 ) it has been argued that their mechanism is the same as that of flares ; magnetic reconnection .
considering these observations , shibata ( 1996 ; 1999 ) suggest that cmes , filament eruptions , flares / giant arcades can be understood in a unified view : mass ejection and magnetic energy release via magnetic reconnection ( fig .
[ flmo ] ) .
although each cme shows different , complex structure , many of them have a typical structure , so called `` three - part structure '' , which consists of a bright core , a surrounding cavity , and a slightly bright outer edge ( illing & hundhausen 1985 ) . a prominence surrounded by dark cavity
is often observed inside a helmet streamer in the pre - eruption stage , and this structure appears to swell once an eruption starts .
this scenario is thought to be a simple interpretation of the formation of a three - part cme ( see hundhausen 1999 for review ) . on the other hand , lin et al .
( 2004 ) developed a semi - analytical reconnection model of a cme and explained three - part structure formation .
on the other hand , _ coronal dimmings _ explained as the euv or sxr decrease , are often observed around post - erupting loops ( sterling & hudson 1997 ; zarro et al . 1999 ) .
the observation with coronal diagnostic spectrometer ( cds ) aboard solar and heliospheric observatory ( soho ) showed that dimming was caused not by the decrease in temperature but by the decrease in plasma density ( harrison & lyons 2000 ) .
this results indicate that the mass which existed there in the pre - eruption stage are lost .
furthermore , harra & sterling ( 2001 ) showed blue - shifted motion coincided with coronal dimming in the cds observations , and therefore , suggested the lost mass is supplied to the cme . on the other hand ,
reconnection inflow can rarefy the inflow region ( tsuneta 1996 , nitta at al . 2001 ) .
it remains unclear which mechanism causes the dimmings . in this paper
we propose a new model that explains the formation of the three - part structure of cmes and the mechanism of dimmings self - consistently .
we performed 2.5-dimensional magnetohydrodynamic ( mhd ) simulations of a coronal mass ejection associated with a giant cusp - shaped arcade , where 2.5-d means that three vector components are included but the space is two dimension .
the numerical results are compared with the observations of cmes and associated phenomena in order to clarify their evolution processes . before describing the numerical model in detail
, it would be better to discuss the situation of the problem .
in solar flares , magnetic energy is thought to be converted into kinetic and thermal energies by magnetic reconnection . in the corona , because the thermal conductivity is very high , thermal energy is conducted very rapidly along the field lines .
when the conducted thermal energy heats the dense chromospheric plasma ( or nonthermal electrons collide to chromospheric plasma ) , the gas pressure increases suddenly .
the pressure gradient generates upward flow to the corona , and the flare loop is filled by the plasma comes from the chromosphere .
this process is called as chromospheric evaporation ( hirayama 1974 ) .
the flare loops filled by the hot dense plasma loses energy by radiation .
there are three key physical processes for energy balance : conduction , radiation , and reconnection .
the time scales of conductive cooling , radiative cooling , and reconnection heating are @xmath0 @xmath1 and @xmath2 respectively , where @xmath3 is the boltzmann constant , @xmath4(@xmath5 cgs ) is heat conduction coefficient along magnetic field @xcite , @xmath6 is the radiative loss function ( raymond , et al . 1976 ) .
the time scale of reconnection heating is derived from poynting flux of inflow region . in the condition of giant arcade in quiet region
( @xmath7 @xmath8 , @xmath9 k , @xmath10 cm , @xmath11 g , @xmath12 cm s@xmath13 , and @xmath14 erg @xmath15 s@xmath13 ; yamamoto et al .
2002 ) , @xmath16 sec , @xmath17 sec , and @xmath18 sec .
since @xmath19 is much longer than @xmath20 , we can neglect the effect of radiative cooling for this reconnection problem . though @xmath21 is also longer than @xmath20 at the initial state , the effect of conduction
can not be neglected because the temperature increases due to reconnection heating , so that @xmath21 becomes comparable to or even shorter than @xmath20 .
although magnetic reconnection coupled with heat conduction is important for solar flares , mhd simulations for such a problem are performed by only few researchers because of its numerical difficulty ( yokoyama & shibata , 1997,1998 , 2001 , chen et al .
these authors adopted antiparallel field for initial magnetic configuration .
for the comparison with observations , however , we have to perform simulations in more realistic conditions . in our simulation , we adopted initial magnetic filed configuration of chen and shibata ( 2000 ) and include the effect of heat conduction and discuss what difference the effect makes .
the initial results of this study have already been published in shiota et al .
( 2003 ) .
in the next section , the numerical method is described .
the numerical results are shown and the differences between adiabatic and conductive cases are described in 3 .
the numerical results of the conductive case are compared with _
observations in 4 .
finally , summary and discussions are given in 5 .
we perform simulations with a multi - step implicit scheme ( hu 1989 ) for two cases : a case without heat conduction ( case a ) and a case with heat conduction ( case b ) .
two - and - a - half dimensional time - dependent resistive mhd equations considered in this study are as follows : @xmath22 @xmath23 @xmath24 @xmath25 where @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 is magnetic resistivity , the quantity @xmath29 and @xmath30 are the dimensionless heat conduction function and its coefficient .
the seven independent variables are the plasma density ( @xmath31 ) , temperature ( @xmath32 ) , velocity ( @xmath33 ) , magnetic flux function ( @xmath34 ) , and perpendicular component of magnetic field ( @xmath35 ) .
the seven variables normalized with the characteristic values of giant arcades are used in the equations ( [ eqco ] ) - ( [ eneq ] ) .
the characteristic values of length , density , and temperature are obtained from the yohkoh observations ( see yamamoto et al . 2002 ) , which are @xmath36 cm , @xmath37 g @xmath8 ( i.e. , @xmath38 @xmath8 ) , and @xmath39 k , respectively . the unit of velocity is @xmath40 where @xmath3 is boltzmann constant and @xmath41 is the mass of hydrogen atom . the unit of magnetic field strength is chosen as @xmath42 the parameter @xmath43 is the ratio of gas to magnetic pressure at the surface of the flux rope ( magnetic configuration is descried in next subsection ) .
@xmath43 is chosen to be 0.01 .
the unit of time becomes @xmath44 , where @xmath45 is the local alfvn velocity around the flux rope ( @xmath46 km s@xmath13 ) and @xmath47 s. in only case b , we assume anisotropic spitzer type heat conduction , @xmath29 and @xmath30 in equation ( [ eneq ] ) are written as follows : @xmath48 @xmath49 the resistivity(@xmath28 ) is taken as an anomalous type as follows : @xmath50 where @xmath51 is the ( relative ion - electron ) drift velocity , and the dimensionless parameters are assumed as @xmath52 , and @xmath53 . it is known that the anomalous resistivity may be caused by plasma instabilities ( coppi & friedland 1971 ) in localized region , and localized resistivity triggers fast reconnection ( ugai & tsuda , 1977 ) .
the simulation box ( @xmath54 , @xmath55 ) is discretized by @xmath56 grid points , which are distributed non - uniformly in the @xmath57-direction and uniformly in the @xmath58-direction . the left ( @xmath59 ) , the right ( @xmath60 ) , and the upper boundaries ( @xmath61 ) are free boundaries where the plasma , magnetic field , and waves could pass through freely . the bottom of the simulation box is a line - tying boundary where all quantities , except for @xmath32 , are fixed outside of the emerging flux region ( described in section [ efr ] ) .
@xmath32 is determined by extrapolation , i.e. , the value was specified to be the same as that at its neighboring point .
initial magnetic field configuration is shown in figure [ init ] .
we adopt this configuration to mimic a cross section of the arcade and the flux rope shown in figure [ flmo ] .
this configuration is presented by three separate current elements ( see chen & shibata 2000 ) : a line current contained within flux rope ( which determines @xmath62 ) , its image current below the photosphere ( which determines @xmath63 ) , and four line currents just below the photosphere ( which determines @xmath64 ) .
potential field created by those currents are expressed as follows : @xmath65 [ ( x-0.3)^2+(y+0.3)^2]}{[(x+1.5)^2+(y+0.3)^2][(x-1.5)^2+(y+0.3)^2]}},\ ] ] @xmath66 @xmath67 @xmath68 where @xmath69 is the height of the flux rope and @xmath70 is the radius of the flux rope , which determine the configuration of magnetic field . in this study
, we set @xmath71 and @xmath72 .
the coefficient @xmath73 in the formula ( [ psif ] ) represents the strength of background field .
this is determined by trial and error in order to guarantee that the flux rope center approximately keeps stable for long enough time . in this study , it is set to be 0.2534 .
this physical meaning is as follows .
if we remove the flux rope , the magnetic field configuration are potential quadrupole field , produced by the four line currents and the image current below the photosphere .
this configuration makes a null point above the photosphere .
if we set at the null point a flux rope whose radius is infinitesimal , the configuration is in unstable equilibrium .
however in the simulation , the flux rope has a finite radius and therefore , we have to seek the solution very near to equilibrium . to satisfy the force balance within the flux rope , a perpendicular magnetic component ( i.e. , @xmath35 ) was introduced inside the flux rope :
@xmath74 other quantities are set to be uniform ; @xmath75@xmath76 .
statistical studies by feynman & martin ( 1995 ) show that reconnection favorable emerging flux is correlated well with cmes .
the meaning of reconnection favorable is that the orientation of newly emerging flux is opposite to that of pre - existing large scale coronal magnetic field . with numerical simulations ,
chen & shibata ( 2000 ) confirmed the discovery of feynman & martin ( 1995 ) that such emerging flux can trigger a cme . in this study , we adopt one case of chen - shibata model , in which newly emerging flux appears just below the flux rope .
the emerging process was realized by changing the magnetic field at the bottom boundary within @xmath77 .
time evolutions of density and temperature distributions in cases a and b are shown in figures [ casea ] and [ caseb ] , respectively .
the dynamical evolutions of both cases are almost the same as that of case a in chen & shibata ( 2000 ) .
magnetic reconnection occurs between the newly emerged flux and magnetic field just above it , which leads to partial magnetic cancellation , and hence the decrease in magnetic pressure .
the magnetized plasma at both sides ( left and right to the magnetic null point [ x point ] ) moves inward .
then magnetic field lines at both sides are pushed in , and therefore a current sheet is formed near the x point .
the current density inside of the sheet increases nearly exponentially .
when the condition equation ( [ anomal ] ) is satisfied , anomalous resistivity sets in and fast reconnection occurs .
the upward outflow associated with reconnection pushes the flux rope up .
the clearest difference between two cases is the difference in density and temperature distributions within the reconnection outflows ( see figures [ casea ] and [ caseb ] ) . in both cases ,
the plasma that passes through the reconnection region ( the x point ) is heated very much by joule heating .
however , in case b , because the heat conduction function become much larger in high temperature region , the heat is conducted along the field lines .
therefore , the temperature in reconnection region and within the reconnection outflows in case b becomes lower than that in case a. the gas pressure at the reconnection region balances with the gas and magnetic pressure outside the current sheet .
magnetic field strength and gas pressure at outside of the current sheet are almost the same in both cases .
therefore , plasma density at reconnection region in case b become higher .
it is found that global dynamics of the two cases are almost the same .
figure [ rec](a ) shows trajectories of the flux ropes and the x points , and figure [ rec](b ) shows reconnection rates , in both cases .
a little difference of dynamics is caused by the difference in the time evolutions of reconnection rate .
reconnection rate is defined as the reconnected magnetic flux per unit time and equals to the electric field @xmath78 in the diffusion region , i.e. , @xmath79 where @xmath80 and @xmath81 are magnetic flux function and current density at the x point , respectively , @xmath82 and @xmath83 are velocity and magnetic field of inflow region , respectively , and @xmath84 is the width of the current sheet . the reconnection rate in case a saturated earlier than in case b. why reconnection rate in case a lower than in case b ?
current density distribution at @xmath85 in both case are displayed in figure [ xp ] .
it is found that the current density at the x point in case b is larger than that in case a and the width of the current sheet in case b is thinner than that in case a. the reason is as follows : in the diffusion region , plasma is heated by magnetic energy dissipation , and gas pressure are increased there .
the enhanced gas pressure balances the magnetic pressure in the inflow region . in case b ,
the heat of the inside plasma is conducted along the field lines , and therefore the inside pressure becomes less than that in case a. as the sheet is pressed more and more , the magnetic dissipation ( plasma heating ) becomes larger , and then the gas pressure balances magnetic pressure in the outside region . in other words ,
the compressibility is enhanced in case b. this is the reason why the reconnection is faster in case b. this results are consistent with sato et al .
( 1990 ) , magara et al .
( 1996 ) and chen et al .
( 1999 ) .
yokoyama & shibata ( 1998 , 2001 ) performed mhd simulationeach of magnetic reconnection coupled with heat conduction . considering the energy balance between the conduction cooling and the reconnection heating ,
they derived a temperature scaling law of the top of a flare loop ; @xmath86 where @xmath87 and @xmath31 are magnetic field strength and density in the inflow region , and @xmath88 is the half length of the loop which is comparable to the height of the x point .
we applied the scaling law to our numerical results .
however , in our simulation non - uniform magnetic field is assumed for the initial condition , in contrast to that anti - parallel uniform magnetic field is used in yokoyama - shibata s numerical simulation .
it is not easy to define a typical value of magnetic filed strength here , so we take the average one in the inflow region . because of non - uniform magnetic field , the average magnetic field strength depends on the area we choose as the inflow region .
we chose several cases ( cases a , b , and c , as shown in figure [ tscl]c ) of the definition of the inflow regions .
we tabulate the results for the definition of the inflow regions in table 1 .
the values @xmath89 and @xmath90 in table 1 are the averages of magnetic field and density in each inflow region on the side of the x point @xmath91 at @xmath85 ( fig .
[ tscl ] ) . using these values
we calculate the theoretical temperature predicted by yokoyama - shibata s scaling law .
it is found that the temperatures predicted by yokoyama - shibata s scaling law are roughly consistent with our results .
the temperature of the loop tops may be determined by the condition just outside of the x point .
.temperature derived from yokoyama - shibata scaling law [ cols= " < , < , < , < , < " , ] from figures [ slow ] and [ slow2 ] , it is found that these slow shocks continue to propagate around the flux rope , the shock fronts form spiral patterns ( white and gray lines in fig . [ slow2 ] ) .
these slow shocks correspond to the two discontinuities nearest to the flux rope in figure [ tra ] .
why the slow shock structure around flux rope has not been found so far ?
most of reconnection studies until now adopted anti - parallel magnetic field for initial condition .
figure [ slowm ] is a schematic pictures of the results of the simulation . in the anti - parallel case , the results of reconnection forms slow shocks as shown in upper right panels of figure [ slowm ] .
the slow shocks propagate along field ( along the current sheet ) . on the other hands , in our numerical simulation
, initially current sheet does not exist .
the field above the flux rope are closed . because the slow shock propagates along the closed field , the spiral patterns are formed .
we can see the region where the density decreases ( rarefaction ) around the flux rope and the cusp - shaped loop in both cases , just outside the slow shocks discussed above .
why does the rarefaction occur ? in order to examine the motion of the plasma we calculate the divergence of the velocity at @xmath85 ( fig .
[ div ] ) .
figure [ div]a shows div @xmath92 with gray scales where the white indicates divergence ( expansion ) and the black indicates the opposite ( compression ) . in order to clarify the mass motion ,
the velocity is divided into two components which are parallel and perpendicular to the magnetic field , shown as follows ,
@xmath93 @xmath94 we also calculate the divergence of the two components of the velocity ( fig .
[ div ] b and c ) .
when fast reconnection starts , upward and downward directed reconnection outflows are generated .
the upward one collides with the flux rope and compresses the magnetic field ( region 1 displayed in fig .
[ div]b ) .
since this compression causes a magnetic pressure increase and leads to flow along the field lines .
in fact , the region 1 shows divergence in figure [ div]b .
the magnetic pressure increase in region 1 pushes the flux rope up .
the rise motion of the flux rope compresses the magnetic loops above it , and leads to the magnetic pressure increase .
in addition , because the magnetic field strength in the initial condition decreases as @xmath95 , the magnetic pressure decreases very rapidly . as the flux rope rises higher , the magnetic pressure inside the flux rope becomes larger than that in the ambient plasma , which leads to the expansion to the direction perpendicular to the magnetic field of the structure ( region 2 displayed in fig .
[ div]b ) .
this expansion is caused by the magnetic field and therefore occurs only in the region where magnetic fields are dominant .
in fact , the boundary between divergence and convergence is located quite near the boundary plasma @xmath96 as shown in figure [ div]a . above the region plasma @xmath97 ,
convergence is present because the plasma is swept up .
on the other hand , fast reconnection generates reconnection inflows on both sides of the reconnection region .
the reconnection inflow causes the expansion of the magnetic field , and therefore the expansion of the plasma in the perpendicular direction ( region 3 displayed in fig .
[ div]b ) .
the expansion causes a decrease of pressure , and hence plasma flows in along the field lines .
in fact , region 3 shows convergence in figure [ div]c .
additionally , this converging flow causes the expansion in region 4 in fig .
[ div]c note that we can see a converged layer on the inner boundary of region 4 in figures [ div]a and [ div]c .
this corresponds to the slow shock discussed in the previous section .
these rarefaction mechanisms work simultaneously . the plasma , which flows into the reconnection region and the slow shocks , flows out partly upward and the rest flows out downward .
the mass which previously existed in the rarefied regions goes partly to the cme and the the rest to the cusp - shaped loop .
we synthesized soft x - ray images from the density and temperature in the numerical results .
( lower panels of figure [ casea ] and [ caseb ] ) these images were produced by taking account of the filter response function of the soft x - ray telescope ( sxt ) aboard _ yohkoh _ ( tsuneta et al . 1991 ) .
seen in figure [ casea ] , the density of the reconnection outflow is very low because the temperature is very high in case a. therefore , the high temperature regions in the flare loop are observed as cavities .
such a flare loop have never been observed in _ yohkoh _ observations , while the appearance of loop in case b is consistent with observations ( for example fig .
[ obs ] ) .
the results of adiabatic case are quite different from the real corona .
therefore , we compared the results of case b with _ yohkoh_/sxt observations , in order to provide new interpretations of observed features .
figure [ obs ] shows the giant arcade ( helmet streamer ) formation on 1992 january 24 which was reported by hiei et al .
( 1993 ) . the event is thought to be face - on observation of giant arcade ( although it has a little orientation , see shiota et al .
2003 ) . in this event , after a y - shaped structure ( fig [ obs]b and c ) is ejected , a cusp - shaped arch is formed , and then the arch seems to grow larger and larger .
these evolution in the event is consistent with our numerical results ( fig .
[ caseb ] ) . in the numerical results ,
after a y - shaped structure is ejected , a cusp - shaped loop seems to grow larger and larger .
therefore , shiota et al . (
2003 ) suggest that the y - shaped structure in the event may correspond to the slow and fast shocks associated with magnetic reconnection .
it is known that a slow shock associated with magnetic reconnection is dissociated into a conduction front and an isothermal slow shock in solar flares ( forbes et al .
1989 ; yokoyama & shibata 1997 ) . on the other hand , because the temperature of arcades is not as high as that of flares , the slow shock is dissociated slightly under the condition of arcades ( see shiota et al .
2003 ) .
what is the outer boundary of the flux rope in the numerical results ? in figures [ slow ] , the boundary is found to be a weakly current density enhanced layer , which corresponds to weak slow shocks ( see [ sss ] ) .
these slow shocks propagate along the field lines from the x point , along either side of the flux rope , and finally collide with each other above the flux rope .
therefore , the plasma and current densities are weakly enhanced just above the flux rope ( figure [ slow ] ) . after the interference
, the shock waves also continue to propagate along the field lines .
the flux rope continues to expand as it rises ( see fig .
[ slow2 ] and fig .
[ div]a ) , and the inner boundary of the expansion corresponds to the slow shocks ( figure [ slow2 ] ) . if the simulation is performed for longer time , the slow shocks will continue to propagate , producing second interference point below the flux rope .
these processes will produce shell - like structures of around the flux rope ( fig .
[ three]a ) .
many cmes show their complicated structure in soho / lasco observation ( cremades & bothmer 2004 , fig .
[ three]b ) .
this process may explain such complicated structures of cmes .
recent observations reveal that solar flares often occur associated with the decrease of soft x - ray and euv intensity , that is so - called _ dimming _ ( sterling & hudson 1997 ; zarro et al .
hudson ( 1996 ) showed that , also in the giant arcade on 1992 january 24 , dimming occurred in the regions above the cusp - shaped arcades ( shown in fig .
[ obs2 ] ) .
soho observations indicated that the dimming is caused by the decrease in the plasma density not by the decrease in temperature ( harrison & lyons 2000 ) .
furthermore , harra & sterling ( 2001 ) showed blue - shifted motion coincided with coronal dimming in the cds observations , and therefore , suggested the lost mass is supplied to the cme , while the mechanism has not been confirmed . especially , the strong dimming is often observed in both sides of flare / giant arcades ( sterling & hudson 1997 ; hudson 1996 ) , hereafter we call such strong dimming as twin dimming we can see that the density around the flux rope and the cusp - shaped loop decreases in the simulation .
the decrease in density is observed as soft x - ray dimming ( fig .
[ caseb ] ) .
the dimming can be seen in both side of the x - ray arcade in the simulation , and these positions are consistent with those of twin dimming in observations .
therefore , soft x - ray twin dimming may correspond to the rarefaction in the simulation . as discussed in section 3.3 , the rarefaction caused by reconnection inflow and the expansion of the flux rope .
however , the expansion occurred mainly above the flux rope .
therefore the rarefaction in both side of the loop ( i.e. twin dimming ) are mainly caused by reconnection inflow . from the point of view of cme structure ,
the numerical results provide some new interpretations .
figure [ mod ] shows global structure seen in the results , which is very consistent with the `` three part structure '' observed in many cmes . according to the numerical results ,
the core consists of the flux rope and slow shocks , the cavity corresponds the ` dimming ' region around the flux rope which connected to the twin dimming regions , and the front loop corresponds to the region compressed by the forward fast shock ( fig .
[ mod ] ) . in this results ,
the loop in front of the cme is very weak and not a shock , because density is not stratified owing to the absence of the gravity . in another case of our numerical result including gravity ( see shiota et al . 2004 )
, the wave grows to a shock easily .
lin et al . (
2004 ) modeled a cme with semi - analytic reconnection model and explained the `` three part structure '' of cme as a separatrix bubble .
they discussed , in the paper , that the leading edge of three - part structure corresponds to the separatrix connected to the reconnection region . as they mentioned in the paper ,
their model is not realistic therefore more detailed computation is required .
our results can be applied the requirements , and suggest new interpretations ( fig . [ three ] and [ mod ] ) successfully . in some large arcade flares ( and some giant arcades )
, we can see often backbone - like features , which may be a series of brighter features on the top of each loop in the arcade in soft x - ray images ( sakurai et al .
1992 ) while loop top bright features at the loop top are also observed in some compact flares , which are called as ` feldman blob ' ( see acton et al .
in the event on 1992 january 24 , the top of the cusp - shaped loop is brighter than other region of the loop ( figure [ obs]d , e , and f ) .
on the other hand , calculated x - ray images show brighter feature on the top of the cusp - shaped loops .
the brighter feature is formed by the compression in the fast shock formed by the collision of the downward reconnection outflow . in order to compare the numerical result with sxt observations more directly , we calculated 3-dimensional views of the numerical results , assuming that the numerical results distributed uniformly to the perpendicular direction .
we apply the same way to calculate a 3-dimensional views as used in forbes & acton ( 1996 ) .
the calculated images are shown in figure [ 3da ] .
however , the effect of gravity ( density stratification ) is not included in our numerical simulations . if the effect of gravity is included , the density in upper corona becomes much smaller than thiese results .
the soft x - ray intensity is proportional to @xmath98 , the brightness of the feature in upper corona becomes much smaller .
in fact , the center of the y - shape is located at twice of the scale height , the intensity of the y - shape is negligible . therefore , we synthesized 3-dimensional soft x - ray images , in which the y - shape is removed ( the lower right two panels of fig .
[ 3da ] ) . in the figure ,
the bright feature in the numerical results looks like a backbone feature .
the results , hence , indicate that a backbone like feature of flare / giant arcades may correspond to the plasma compressed by the fast shock produced by a reconnection outflow .
in this paper , we proposed a new model that explains the formation of the three - part structure of cmes and the mechanism of dimmings self - consistently .
we performed mhd simulations of cmes associated with giant cusp - shaped arcades for the two cases ; one case includes heat conduction effect , while the other does not include .
the dynamics is similar in both case , while the reconnection rate in the conductive case is enhanced slightly compared to the adiabatic case and the temperature of the loop top is consistent with the theoretical value predicted by the yokoyama - shibata scaling law . in the conductive case
, a slow shock is hardly dissociated to an isothermal slow shock and a conduction front , different from the case for solar flares . as
magnetic reconnection occurs slow and fast shocks are formed to be attached to a y - shaped structure and a cusp - shaped loop .
the slow shocks continue to propagate along the field lines around the flux rope , forming two spiral patterns .
the density just outside the slow shocks decreases a great deal .
this decrease in density ( rarefaction ) is caused by expansion and reconnection inflow simultaneously .
compared with _
yohkoh_/sxt observations , the numerical results in case b are consistent with the observation of a giant arcade on 1992 january 24
. a y - shaped erupting structure observed in the event may correspond to the slow and fast shocks associated with the magnetic reconnection ( this is reported by shiota et al .
soft x - ray dimming is also observed in this event .
the position of the dimming regions are consistent with that of the rarefaction in the numerical results .
since the rarefaction occurs in the region outside the slow shocks , the inner boundary between the `` dimming '' and `` non - dimming '' regions may be slow shocks associated with the reconnection .
the global structure in the numerical results is similar to the `` three part structure '' of cmes . in the numerical results , the leading edge , cavity , and core
correspond to the region compressed by piston - driven fast mhd wave , the rarefaction region , and the flux rope .
the slow shocks associated with magnetic reconnection may play a role forming in complex features around the core . according to observations
the top of cusp - shaped loops in an arcade is brighter than other regions , which looks like a backbone of the arcade .
such a feature is reproduced in the numerical simulation , which indicates that the backbone feature corresponds to the fast shock created by the collision between the reconnection outflow and the arcade .
we found the evolution of slow shocks associated with reconnection in the configuration initially a flux rope exits .
the numerical results indicate that complex structures around a cme core may be formed by these slow shocks .
we proposed a self - consistent model of ` dimming ' .
the decrease in density observed as ` dimming ' is caused by expansion and reconnection inflow simultaneously . in the numerical results ,
the cavity of the three - part cme is connected to the ` dimming ' regions , and therefore the density decrease mechanisms are the same .
we proposed a new interpretation of three - part structure of cmes ( fig .
[ mod ] ) .
the authors thank d. h. brooks , j. lin , t. miyagoshi , a. asai , h. tonooka , and t. yokoyama , for useful discussions .
the yohkoh satellite is a japanese national project , launched and operated by isas , involving many domestic institutions , and with international collaboration of us and uk .
d. s. is supported by research fellowship of the japan society for the promotion of science ( jsps ) for young scientist .
the visit of p. f. c. to kyoto university was supported by the jsps .
p. f. c. is supported by nsfc ( 10333040 and 10403003 ) .
this work is supported by the grant - in - aid for the 21st century coe `` center for diversity and universality in physics '' from the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology ( mext ) of japan .
this work was partly supported by the grants - in aid of the mext of japan ( 16340058 , ks ) .
this work was supported in part by the jsps japan - uk cooperation science program ( principal investigators : k. shibata and n. o. weiss ) .
acton et al .
1992 , 1992 , , 44 , l71 chen , p. f. , fang , c. , ding , m. d. , & tang , y. h. 1999 , , 520 , 853 chen , p. f. , & shibata , k. 2000 , , 545 , 524 coppi , b. , & friedland , a. b. 1971 , , 169 , 379 cremades , h. & bothmer , v. , 2004 , astron .
, 422 , 307 feynman , j. & martin , s. f. , 1995 , , 100 , 3355 forbes , t. g. , & acton , l. w. , 1996 , , 459 , 330 forbes , t. g. , & lin , j. , 2000 , j. atmos .
, 62 , 1499 forbes , t. g. , malherbe , j. m. , & priest , e. r. 1989 , , 120 , 285 hanaoka , y. , et al .
1994 , , 46 , 205 harra , l. k. & sterling , a. c. 2001 , , 561 , l215 harrison , r. a. , & lyons , m. 2000 , astron .
, 358 , 1097 hiei , e. , hundhausen , a , j. , & sime , d. g. 1993 , , 20 , 2785 hirayama , t. 1974 , , 34 , 323 hu , y. q. 1989 , j. comput .
phys . , 84 , 441 hudson , h. s. 1996 , in iau colloq . 153 magnetodynamic phenomena in the solar atmosphere - prototyres of steller activity , ed
. y. uchida , t. kosugi , & h. s. hudson ( dordrecht : kluwer ) , 89 hundhausen , a. 1999 , the many faces of the sun : a summary of the results from nasa s solar maximum mission . ed . by keith t. strong ,
julia l. r. saba , bernhard m. haisch , and joan t. schmelz .
( new york : springer ) , p.143 illing , r. m. e. & hundhausen , a. j. 1985 , , 90 , 275 kahler , s. w. 1992 , annu .
astrophys . , 30 , 113 lin , j. , forbes , t. g. , & isenberg , 2001 , , 106 , 25053 lin , j. , raymond , j. c. , & van ballegooijen , a. a. , 2004 , , 602 , 422 mcallister , a. h. , dryer , m. , mcintosh , p. , singer , h. , & weiss , l. 1996 , , 101 , 13497 magara , t. , mineshige , s. , yokoyama , t. , & shibata , k. , 1996 , , 466 , 1054 munro , r. h. , gosling , j. t. , hildner , e. , macqueen , r. m. , poland , a. i. , & ross , c. l. , 1979 , , 61 , 201 nitta , s. , tanuma , s. , shibata , k. , & maezawa , k. 2001 , , 550 , 1119 priest , e. r. 1982 solar magnetohydrodynamics ( dordrecht : reidel ) , chap .
5.4 raymond , j. c. , cox , d. p. , & smith b. w. 1976 , , 204 , 290 sakurai , t. , shibata , k. , ichimoto , k. , tsuneta , s. , & acton , l. w. 1992 , , 44 , l123 sato , t. , hayashi , t. , watanabe , k. , horiushi , r. , tanaka , m. , swairi , n. , & kusana , k. , 1992 , phis .
fluids b , 4 , 450 shibata , k. , masuda , s. , shimojo , m. , hara , h. , yokoyama , t. , tanuma , s. , kosugi , t. , & ogawara , y. 1995 , , 451 , l83 shibata , k. , 1996 , adv .
space res .
, 17 , 9 shibata , k. , 1999 , astrophys .
, 264 , 129 shiota , d. et al .
2003 , , 55 , l35 shiota , d. et al .
2004 , in asp conf .
325 , the solar - b mission and the forefront of solar physics -proceeding of the fifth solar - b science meeting- , ed .
t. sakurai & t. sekii ( san francisco : asp ) , 373 spitzer , l. , jr . 1962 physics of fully ionized gases , interscience pub . , new york , chap . 5 sterling , a. c. & hudson , h. s. 1997 , , 491 , l55 tsuneta , s. , et al .
1991 , , 136 , 37 tsuneta , s. , takahashi , t. , acton , l. w. , bruner , m. e. , harvey , k. l. , & ogawara , y. 1992 , , 44 , l211 tsuneta , s. 1996 , , 456 , 840 ugai , m. & tsuda , t. 1977 , journal of pla .
, 17 , 337 webb , d. f. & hundhausen , a. j. , 1987 , 108 , 383 yamamoto , t. t. , shiota , d. , sakajiri , t. , akiyama , s. , isobe , h. , & shibata , k. 2002 , , 579 , l45 yokoyama , t. , & shibata , k. 1997 , , 474 , l61 yokoyama , t. , & shibata , k. 1998 , , 494 , l113 yokoyama , t. , & shibata , k. 2001 , , 549 , 1160 zarro , d. m. , sterling , a. c. , thompson , b. j. , hudson , h. s. , & nitta , n. , 1999 , 520 , l139 | we performed magnetohydrodynamic simulation of coronal mass ejections ( cmes ) and associated giant arcade formations , and the results suggested new interpretations of observations of cmes .
we performed two cases of the simulation : with and without heat conduction . comparing between the results of the two cases
, we found that reconnection rate in the conductive case is a little higher than that in the adiabatic case and the temperature of the loop top is consistent with the theoretical value predicted by the yokoyama - shibata scaling law .
the dynamical properties such as velocity and magnetic fields are similar in the two cases , whereas thermal properties such as temperature and density are very different . in both cases ,
slow shocks associated with magnetic reconnection propagate from the reconnection region along the magnetic field lines around the flux rope , and the shock fronts form spiral patterns . just outside the slow shocks ,
the plasma density decreased a great deal .
the soft x - ray images synthesized from the numerical results are compared with the soft x - ray images of a giant arcade observed with the soft x - ray telescope aboard _ yohkoh _ , it is confirmed that the effect of heat conduction is significant for the detailed comparison between simulation and observation .
the comparison between synthesized and observed soft x - ray images provides new interpretations of various features associated with cmes and giant arcades .
1 ) it is likely that y - shaped ejecting structure , observed in giant arcade 1992 january 24 , corresponds to slow and fast shocks associated with magnetic reconnection .
2 ) soft x - ray twin dimming corresponds to the rarefaction induced by reconnection .
3 ) the inner boundary of the dimming region corresponds to the slow shocks .
4 ) `` three - part structure '' of a cme can be explained by our numerical results .
5 ) the numerical results also suggest a backbone feature of a flare / giant arcade may correspond to the fast shock formed by the collision of the downward reconnection outflow . |
the recent superkamiokande data suggests the large neutrino flavor mixing between @xmath0 and @xmath1@xcite . according to this experimental result
, there have been a lot of theoretical attempts to explain why the large flavor mixing is realized in the lepton sector@xcite .
one of the interesting approaches is concentrating on the effects of the the renormalization group equation ( rge ) .
the rge effects cause the enhancement of the neutrino flavor mixing in some situations@xcite@xcite@xcite . in this paper
we analyze the rge of the neutrino flavor mixing between @xmath0 and @xmath1 in the minimal supersymmetric standard model ( mssm ) with right - handed neutrinos . here
we stand the position that the smallness of neutrino masses is explained by the seesaw mechanism@xcite .
we consider the situation that @xmath8 is much smaller than @xmath9 and @xmath10 , and expect the solar neutrino problem@xcite is solved by the oscillation between @xmath11 and a sterile neutrino @xmath3 @xcite .
this situation is so - called four light neutrino scenario@xcite@xcite and @xmath12 with @xmath13 .
however , the confirmation of this result still awaits future experiments .
recent measurements in the karmen detector exclude part of the lsnd allowed region@xcite . ] with the mass spectrum of @xmath4 . in this neutrino mass hierarchy
, we find that the mixing angle between @xmath0 and @xmath1 receives significant corrections from the renormalization group equation ( rge ) . in this case
the mixing angle at the high energy must be small as long as the mixing at the low energy is maximal .
from the view point of the model building , we must find the fundamental theory which induces the small mixing angle at the high energy in the four neutrino scenario with the above mass spectrum .
in this section we show the rges of the mssm with right - handed neutrinos .
the superpotential of the mssm is given by = _
|u_j + _ ij q_i h _
|d_j + _ ij l_i h _
|n_j + _ ij l_i h _
|e_j + _ h h _ h _ + 12 m_rij |n_i |n_j , [ superpotmssmh ] where the index @xmath14 stands for the generation number @xmath15 . in this paper
we neglect yukawa couplings of the first generation since we consider the case where @xmath8 is much smaller than @xmath9 and @xmath10 .
@xmath16 , @xmath17 , @xmath18 , @xmath19 , @xmath20 , @xmath21 and @xmath22 are quark doublet , lepton doublet , right - handed up - sector , right - handed down - sector , right - handed charged lepton , right - handed neutrino and higgs fields , respectively .
@xmath23 is the majorana mass matrix of the right - handed neutrinos , which is symmetric under the generation indices @xmath14 .
@xmath24 is the supersymmetric mass parameter of higgs particles . in this model
the rges of yukawa couplings are given by & = & [ ( 3 ^ + ^ ) + 3 ^ + ^ -4(_3 + 3_2 + _ 1 ) ] , + & = & [ ( 3 ^ + ^ ) + 3 ^ + ^ -4(_3 + 3_2 + _ 1 ) ] , + & = & [ ( 3 ^ + ^ ) + 3 ^ + ^ -4(3_2 + _ 1 ) ] , + & = & [ ( 3 ^ + ^ ) + 3 ^ + ^ -4(3_2 + _ 1 ) ] , where @xmath25 and @xmath26 is a renormalization point , respectively .
these equations are available for the energy region of @xmath27 , where @xmath28 denotes the energy scale of the majorana mass . below the scale of @xmath28
, we should take the decoupling effects of heavy neutrinos into account .
the effective theory is described without heavy neutrinos .
the superpotential of eq.([superpotmssmh ] ) is modified as = _
|u_j + _ ij q_i h _
|d_j + _ ij l_i h _ |e_j - 12 _ ij_i _ j h _
h_. [ superpotmssml ] here
@xmath29s are the light modes of neutrinos which remain after integrating out the heavy ones .
the coupling constant @xmath30 is defined as _
ij = ( m_r^-1 ^t)_ij .
it relates to the mass matrix of the light neutrinos as m^_ij = _ ij = _
ij , where , v^2 = v_^2 + v_^2 , with @xmath31 and @xmath32 .
the value of @xmath33 is given by v = m_z = 245.4 ( ) , with @xmath34 gev , @xmath35 , and @xmath36@xcite .
in @xmath37 , the rges of the yukawa couplings eqs.([eqn : rge - high ] ) are modified as & = & [(3^ ) + 3^ + ^ -4(_3 + 3_2+_1 ) ] , + & = & [(3^+^ ) + 3^ + ^ -4(_3 + 3_2+_1 ) ] , + & = & [(3^+^ ) + 3^ -4(3_2 + _ 1 ) ] , and = 1 8 ^ 2 [ \ { ( 3^ ) - 4 ( 3_2 + _
1 ) } + \ { ( ^ ) + ( ^)^t } ] . from eqs.([eqn : rge - low ] ) , we can see that the rges of quark and charged lepton do not include the neutrino yukawa couplings contrary to the case of @xmath38 as eqs.([eqn : rge - high ] ) .
hence below @xmath28 the running of the yukawa couplings of quark and charged lepton can be determined independently of that of the neutrinos . from now on we are concentrating on the rge effects below the scale of @xmath28 , which are given by eqs.([eqn : rge - low ] ) and ( [ eqn : rge_kappa ] ) . since rges of the yukawa couplings for quark and charged lepton of eqs.([eqn : rge - low ] ) can be solved without information about the neutrino sector as mentioned before , the renormalization point dependences of @xmath39 and @xmath40 are completely determined by the rges boundary conditions which we take the masses of quark and charged lepton gev , @xmath41 gev , @xmath42 gev , @xmath43 gev , @xmath44 gev , and @xmath45 gev at @xmath46@xcite . ] , the cabibbo - kobayashi - maskawa matrix @xcite and @xmath47 at the weak scale .
then we have only to concentrate on eq.([eqn : rge_kappa ] ) . here
we neglect @xmath48 phases in the flavor mixing matrices of the quark and the lepton sector for simplicity . for convenience ,
we take three independent parameters @xmath49 , @xmath50 and @xmath51 instead of @xmath30 [ @xmath52 , @xmath53 and @xmath54 . here
@xmath55 and @xmath51 are determined from @xmath30 by the following equations : & = & ( cc _ 23 & _ 23 + - _ 23 & _ 23 ) ( cc _ 2 & 0 + 0 & _ 3 ) ( cc _ 23 & - _ 23 + _ 23 & _
23 ) , + ^2 & & _ 3 ^ 2 - _ 2 ^ 2 , where _ 3 = ( + ) , _ 2 = ( - ) , with | 2_23 | . by using this relation , the rge of eq.([eqn : rge_kappa ] ) can be rewritten into the following three equations ) was firstly derived by babu , leung and pantaleone in ref .
@xcite . ] : _ r & = & - ( y_^2 - y_^2)_r , + ^2 2_23 & = & - ^22_23(1-^22_23 ) ( y_^2 - y_^2 ) , + ^2 & = & ^2 . both @xmath50 and @xmath51
directly relate to the observed quantities in neutrino oscillation experiments of this paper is an observable quantity . ] .
the mass squared difference can be written as @xmath56 by using eq.([eqn : neutrinomass ] ) .
as shown before , @xmath57 and @xmath58 are determined without knowing the neutrino yukawa coupling , thus we can obtain values of @xmath59 and @xmath60 at the weak scale by using only eqs.([eqn : rgekappa2a ] ) and ( [ eqn : rgekappa2b ] ) .
we analyze rges of eqs.([eqn : rgekappa2a ] ) and ( [ eqn : rgekappa2b ] ) by inputting various values of @xmath61 and @xmath60 for the initial conditions at @xmath62 ) in our analysis . ] .
now we show the numerical results of the rges .
figure [ fig : yem ] shows the energy dependence of the values of @xmath63 $ ] , which is the coefficients of the rges of @xmath60 in and @xmath64 in .
four lines correspond to the various values of @xmath47 , which we take 5 , 20 , 35 , and 50 .
the values of @xmath63 $ ] do not receive the significant rge corrections when @xmath65 is small .
figures [ fig : kr ] show the energy dependence of @xmath60 with @xmath66 .
we show the two cases of ( a):@xmath67 gev and ( b):@xmath68 gev with various initial conditions at @xmath28 . from the high energy to the low energy , @xmath60 simply increases .
if we take the small @xmath65 , the slope tends to be flat because the value of @xmath69 $ ] in decreases as fig .
[ fig : yem ] .
figures [ fig : engdepofsin ] show the energy dependence of the mixing angle with the same values of @xmath28 and @xmath70 as figs .
[ fig : kr ] .
there are three curves corresponding to the values of @xmath70 , and all of them have the same boundary condition of @xmath71 . from these figures
we can see that the mixing angle at the weak scale changes depending on the value of @xmath70 .
this difference can be easily understood by comparing figs .
[ fig : engdepofsin ] with figs .
[ fig : kr ] and by the existence of the factor @xmath72 $ ] in the r.h.s . of the rge of eq.([eqn : rgekappa2b ] ) .
let us see fig .
[ fig : kr](a ) and fig .
[ fig : engdepofsin](a ) , for example . in the case of @xmath73 , where @xmath60 does not exceed one at all the energy scales ,
the mixing angle does not receive the significant rge corrections .
it is because the r.h.s .
of eq.([eqn : rgekappa2b ] ) does not become so large as to enhance the mixing angle . on
the other hand , in the case of @xmath74 @xmath60 exceeds one near the weak scale , which results in the significant enhancement of the mixing angle by the factor @xmath72 $ ] .
finally in the case of @xmath75 , @xmath60 exceeds one above the weak scale .
then the mixing angle once becomes maximal at high energy , however , after there it decreases rapidly since the sign of @xmath72 $ ] changes .
figures [ fig : sin ] are the contour plots of the mixing angle @xmath50 at the weak scale .
these are obtained by solving eq.([eqn : rgekappa2b ] ) with the various @xmath70(horizontal axis ) and @xmath76(vertical axis ) . here
@xmath77 in figs .
[ fig : sin ] is the value at @xmath28 that induces @xmath78 . in the parameter region of @xmath79
, there are no significant rge corrections and then the mixing angle does not change drastically .
the energy dependence of the mixing angle in this case is similar to the solid lines in figs .
[ fig : engdepofsin ] .
next in the case of @xmath80 , which means @xmath81 , the mixing angle at the weak scale is strongly enhanced near the weak scale , as the dashed lines in figs .
[ fig : engdepofsin ] . then the mixing angle at the weak scale becomes maximal independently of the mixing angle at @xmath28 .
finally in the case of @xmath82 , the mixing angle at the weak scale becomes small even for the large mixing angle at @xmath28 , where the energy dependence of the mixing angle is similar to the dotted lines in figs .
[ fig : engdepofsin ] . from these arguments
we can easily see that there is the large enhancement of the mixing angle from the rge around @xmath83 .
figures [ fig : m3 ] are the contour plots of the heaviest neutrino mass @xmath84 at the weak scale .
the horizontal and vertical axes are the same as those of figs .
[ fig : sin ] .
we determine the masses of neutrino by substituting the parameters in with the result of figs .
[ fig : sin ] and the experimental value @xmath85 .
since we use the experimental value of @xmath86 instead of evaluating the rge of , we can determine the masses without any additional input parameters . as @xmath84 becomes large , the region of @xmath70
is limited around @xmath77 . compared with figs .
[ fig : sin ] , it is found that the region where the heaviest mass @xmath84 is larger than @xmath2 corresponds to the region where the mixing angle at the weak scale is always larger than 0.9 despite the small mixing at @xmath28 scale .
figures [ fig : sin35 ] and figures [ fig : m335 ] correspond to figures [ fig : sin ] and figures [ fig : m3 ] with another value of @xmath87 .
compared with the case of @xmath88 , the value of @xmath77 are just shifted to the right in the case of @xmath87 . around @xmath80 , the value of @xmath84 is slightly larger than that of @xmath88 at the same value of @xmath50 . in general , the smaller @xmath47 becomes , the more @xmath77 approaches one , and the value of @xmath84 around @xmath80 becomes larger .
the region where the maximal enhancement of the mixing angle is derived by the rge exists even in the case of small @xmath65 .
the value of @xmath84 around @xmath77 becomes larger corresponding to the smaller value of @xmath47 .
we stress here that the large enhancement factor at the weak scale induced by @xmath72 $ ] in is not the fine - tuning .
this factor must be inevitably large with @xmath89 if @xmath90 and @xmath84 are larger than @xmath2 .
it is worth noting that the enough enhancement of the mixing angle can be obtained even in the case of @xmath2 neutrino masses . even in the small @xmath65 ,
@xmath91 mass is enough to obtain this rge enhancement .
in this paper we analyzed the rge effects of the neutrino flavor mixing between @xmath92 and @xmath93 in the mssm with right - handed neutrinos .
the experimental result of the superkamiokande suggests the large neutrino flavor mixing between @xmath0 and @xmath1 with @xmath94 ev .
then we found that the mixing angle between @xmath0 and @xmath1 receives significant corrections from the rge in the case of @xmath4 . in this mass spectrum ,
the mixing angle at the decoupling scale of right - handed neutrinos must be small when @xmath95 .
finally we give a brief comment about the lsnd experimental result . in the above mass spectrum ,
both @xmath9 and @xmath10 must be of order 1 ev to explain the lsnd result . in this case
, the rge analysis shows that the mixing angle at the decoupling scale of right - handed neutrinos must be negligibly small and figs .
[ fig : m335 ] , there exist these lines .
they are too small to be drawn apparently in the large @xmath65 . ] . from the view point of the model building
, we must find the fundamental theory which induces the small mixing angle at the high energy scale in the four neutrino scenario with the mass spectrum of @xmath4 .
we would like to thank m. tanimoto for useful discussions .
no would like to thank k. hagiwara , j. hisano and y. okada for useful discussions and comments .
nh would like to thank s. raby and k. tobe for helpful discussions and comments .
the work of no is financially supported by the jsps research fellowships for young scientist , no.2996 .
nh is partially supposed by doe grant doe / er/01545 - 753 .
m. fukugita , m. tanimoto and t. yanagida , phys .
* d57 * ( 1998 ) 4429 ; k.s .
babu and s.m .
barr , phys .
b381 * ( 1996 ) 202 ; s.m .
barr , phys . rev .
* d55 * ( 1997 ) 1659 ; b. brahmachari and r.n .
mohapatra , phys . rev .
* d58 * ( 1998 ) 15003 ; c.h . albright and s.m .
barr , phys . rev . *
d58 * ( 1998 ) 13002 ; j. sato and t. yanagida , phys . lett .
* b430 * ( 1998 ) 127 ; s.l .
glashow , phys .
b256 * ( 1991 ) 255 ; e.j .
chun , c.w .
kim and u.w .
lee , phys . rev .
* d58 * ( 1998 ) 93003 ; y. chikira , n. haba and y. mimura , hep - ph/9808254 ; e. ma , hep - ph/9807386 ; m. tanimoto , hep - ph/9807283 ; y. nomura and t. yanagida , hep - ph/9807325 ; n. haba , hep - ph/9807552 ; s. davidson and s.f . king , hep - ph/9808296 ; r.n .
mohapatra and s. nussinov , hep - ph/9808301 ; y. grossman , y. nir and y. shadmi , hep - ph/9808355 ; r.n .
mohapatra and s. nussinov , hep - ph/9809415 .
t. yanagida , in _ proceedings of the workshop on unified theory and baryon number in the universe _ , ed .
o. sawada and a. sugamoto ( kek , report 79 - 18 , 1979 ) , p.95 ; m. gell - mann , p. ramond and s. slansky , in _
supergravity _ , ed .
p. van nieuwenhuizen and d. z. freedman ( north - holland , amsterdam , 1979 ) , p315 ; r. mohapatra and s. senjanovi , phys .
* 44 * ( 1980 ) 912 .
gallex collaboration , phys .
b388 * ( 1996 ) 384 ; sage collaboration , phys . lett . *
b328 * ( 1994 ) 234 ; homestake collaboration , nucl . phys .
* b 38 * ( proc . suppl . ) ( 1995 ) 47 ; kamiokande collaboration , nucl . phys .
* b 38 * ( proc . suppl . ) ( 1995 ) 55 ; super - kamiokande collaboration , y. fukuda et al .
* 81 * ( 1998 ) 1158 .
caldwell , r.n .
mohapatra , phys . rev .
* d48 * ( 1993 ) 3259 ; j.t .
peltoniemi , j.w.f .
valle , nucl .
* b406 * ( 1993 ) 409 ; r. foot and r.r .
volkas , phys .
rev * d52 * ( 1995 ) 6595 ; e. ma and p. roy , phys . rev .
* d52 * ( 1995 ) 4780 ; j.j .
gomez - cadenas and m.c .
gonzales - garcia , z. phys .
* c71 * ( 1996 ) 443 ; s.m .
bilenky , c. giunti and w. grimus , proc . of _ neutrino 96 _ , helsinki , june 1996 , edited by k. enqvist
( world scientific , 1997 ) ; s.m .
bilenky , c. giunti and w. grimus , eur .
j. * c1 * ( 1998 ) 247 ; n. okada and o. yasuda , int .
a12 * ( 1997 ) 3669 ; s.c .
gibbons , r.n .
mohapatra , s. nandi and a. raychaudhuri , phys . lett .
* b430 * ( 1998 ) 296 ; s.m .
bilenky , c. giunti and w. grimus , hep - ph/9805387 ; v. barger , t.j . weiler and k. whisnant ,
b427 * ( 1998 ) 97 ; v. barger , s. pakvasa , t.j . weiler and k. whisnant ,
phys . rev .
* d58 * ( 1998 ) 3016 ; e.m
. lipmanov , hep - ph/9806442 ; v. barger , hep - ph/9808353 ; s.m .
bilenky , c. giunti and w. grimus , hep - ph/9809368 ; s.m .
bilenky , c. giunti , w. grimus and t. schwetz , hep - ph/9809466 .
the lsnd results will be tested by the karmen experiment , talk by b. armbruster at 33rd rencontres de moriond : electroweak interactions and unified theories , les arcs , france , march 1998 , and talk by b. zeitnitz at ` neutrino 98 ' , takayama , japan , june 1998 , and also by the boone experiment , e. church et al .
, nucl - ex/9706011 . | the superkamiokande experiment suggests the large flavor mixing between @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
we show that the mixing angle receives significant corrections from the renormalization group equation ( rge ) when both the second and the third generation neutrino masses are larger than @xmath2 .
this means that the mixing angle must be small at the decoupling scale of right - handed neutrinos in the model containing a sterile neutrino @xmath3 with the mass spectrum of @xmath4 . [
cols="^,^ " , ] the renormalization group analysis of the large lepton flavor mixing and the neutrino mass + n. haba@xmath5 , @xmath6 , @xmath7 + @xmath5_department of physics , the ohio state university , columbus , ohio 43210 , usa _
+ @xmath6_theory group , kek , oho 1 - 1 , tsukuba 305 - 0801 , japan
_ + @xmath7_department of physics , nagoya university , nagoya , 464 - 8602 , japan _ + |
game theory provides a useful framework for describing the evolution of systems consisting of selfish individuals @xcite .
the prisoner s dilemma game ( pdg ) as a metaphor for investigating the evolution of cooperation has drawn considerable attention @xcite . in the pdg
, two players simultaneously choose whether to cooperate or defect .
mutual cooperation results in payoff @xmath1 for both players , whereas mutual defection leads to payoff @xmath2 gained both . if one cooperates while the other defects , the defector gains the highest payoff @xmath3 , while the cooperator bears a cost @xmath4 .
this thus gives a simply rank of four payoff values : @xmath5 .
one can see that in the pdg , it is best to defect regardless of the co - player s decision to gain the highest payoff @xmath3 .
however , besides the widely observed selfish behavior , many natural species and human being show the altruism that individuals bear cost to benefit others .
these observation brings difficulties in evaluating the fitness payoffs for different behavioral patterns , even challenge the rank of payoffs in the pdg .
since it is not suitable to consider the pdg as the sole model to discuss cooperative behavior , the snowdrift game ( sg ) has been proposed as possible alternative to the pdg , as pointed out in ref @xcite .
the main difference between the pdg and the sg is in the order of @xmath2 and @xmath4 , as @xmath6 in the sg .
this game , equivalent to the hawk - dove game , is also of much biological interest @xcite .
however , the original pdg and sg can not satisfyingly reproduce the widely observed cooperative behavior in nature and society .
this thus motivates numerous extensions of the original model to better mimic the evolution of cooperation in the real world @xcite .
since the spatial structure is introduced into the evolutionary games by nowak and may @xcite , there has been a continuous effort on exploring effects of spatial structures on the cooperation @xcite .
it has been found that the spatial structure promotes evolution of cooperation in the pdg @xcite , while in contrast often inhibits cooperative behavior in the sg @xcite . in recent years ,
extensive studies indicate that many real networks are far different from regular lattices , instead , show small - world and scale - free topological properties .
hence , it is naturally to consider evolutionary games on networks with these kinds of properties @xcite .
an interesting result found by santos and pacheco is that scale - free networks provide a unifying framework for the emergence of cooperation " @xcite .
so far , most studies of evolutionary games over networks are based on static network structure .
however , it has been pointed out that the network structure may coevolve with the game @xcite , where each individual would choose its co - players to gain more benefits , inducing the evolution of their relationship network .
some previous works about weighted networks suggest that it is indeed the traffic increment spurs the evolution of the network to maintain the system s normal and efficient functioning @xcite . from this perspective ,
in the present paper we propose an evolutionary model with respect to the interplay between the evolutions of the game and the network for characterizing the dynamics of some social and economic systems . in our model , the sg is adopted for its more general representation of the realism and evolutionary cooperative behavior . since growth is a common feature among networked systems @xcite
, we assume that the network continuously grows by adding new agents to the existent network on the basis of the payoff preferential attachment .
we focus on the evolution of the network structure together with the emergence and persistence of cooperation .
simulation results show that the obtained networks follow a power - law distribution , @xmath7 , with exponent @xmath8 tuned by a model parameter .
the average distance of the network scales logarithmically with the network size , which indicates the network has a small - world effect .
interestingly , the assortative mixing properties generated by our model demonstrate that the model can well mimic social networks . in parallel , with the extension of the network ,
the density of cooperators increases and approaches a stable value , which gives a new explanation for the emergence and persistence of cooperation .
we also explore the wealth distribution , where the so - called wealth is the accumulated payoff distribution of each individual .
the pareto law is well reproduced by our model . at last , we provide analyses for the obtained scale - free network structures . the paper is arranged as follows . in the following section ,
we describe the model in detail , in sec .
iii , simulation results and correspondent analytical ones are provided , and in sec .
iv , the work is concluded .
let us introduce briefly the sg first .
consider two drivers are trapped in two side of a snowdrift .
each driver has two possible selections , either shoving the snowdrift ( cooperator - c ) or remaining in the car and do nothing ( defect - d ) . if both cooperate , they could be back home on time , so that each will gain a reward of @xmath9 , whereas mutual defection results in still blocked by the snowdrift and each gets a payoff @xmath10 .
if only one driver shovels ( takes c ) , then both drivers can be back home .
the driver taking d gets home with do nothing and hence gets a payoff @xmath11 , while the driver taking c gains a sucker " payoff of @xmath12 .
thus , the rank of four payoff values is @xmath6 .
following common practice , the sg is rescaled with @xmath13 , @xmath14 and @xmath15 , where @xmath16 is a tunable parameter ranging from @xmath17 to @xmath18 . hence
, the payoffs can be characterized by a single parameter for convenient study .
[ 0.80 ] ( color online ) .
degree distributions and relevant cumulative degree distributions for different values of @xmath19 are shown in the top panel and the bottom , respectively .
the network size @xmath20 is @xmath21 .
each distribution is obtained by averaging over @xmath22 distinct simulation .
the degree distribution is nearly independent of @xmath16.,title="fig : " ] our model starts from @xmath23 nodes randomly connected with probability @xmath24 , each of which represents a player ( in the following , we fix @xmath25 and examine that it has no influence on our results in present work ) .
initially , the nodes are randomly assigned to be either strategy c or d with @xmath26 percentages . players interact with all their neighbors simultaneously and get payoffs according to the preset payoff parameter .
the total payoff of a certain player is the sum over all its encounters .
then , every node @xmath27 randomly selects a neighbor @xmath28 at the same time for possible updating its strategy .
the probability that @xmath27 follows the strategy of the selected node @xmath28 is determined by the total payoff difference between them , i.e. , @xmath29},\ ] ] where @xmath30 and @xmath31 are the total payoffs of @xmath27 and @xmath28 at the moment of the encounter . here
, @xmath3 characterizes noise " , including bounded rationality , individual trials , errors in decision , _
etc_. it should be noted that @xmath3 here plays a different role comparing with the cases of adopting the normalized payoff difference . in parallel , @xmath3 does not play the same role for different network sizes @xcite .
since in our model , the network size gradually grows , it is not easy to keep the effect of @xmath3 unchanged at every time step . for simplicity ,
we fix @xmath3 to @xmath32 during the evolution of the network . here
, we adopt the synchronous updating rule . after each step that players update their strategies ,
a new individual is added into the network with @xmath33 ( we fix @xmath34 for convenience ) links preferentially attached to existent nodes of higher payoffs , i.e. , @xmath35 where @xmath30 and @xmath31 are the total payoffs of @xmath27 and @xmath28 obtained in the interaction process .
@xmath19 is a tunable parameter , which reflects the original payoff values of players when they join into the game system . for simplicity , we set @xmath19 be a constant .
the payoff - based preferential selection takes into account the rich gets richer " characteristic and couples the dynamics of the evolutionary game and the evolution of the underlying network . after a new player joins into the network , the new one randomly choose strategy c or d and all old players preserve their strategies for the game in the next round . then , repeat the above procedures , and the network size gradually grows .
[ 0.80 ] ( color online ) .
average distance @xmath36 as a function of network size @xmath20 .
each data point is obtained by averaging over @xmath22 network realizations .
these results are independent of parameter @xmath16.,title="fig : " ] numerical simulations are performed to quantify the structural properties of the obtained networks . in figure 1 , we show the degree distribution and correspondent cumulative degree distribution @xmath37 , in networks of size @xmath38 .
the distributions clearly exhibit power - law behaviors , @xmath0 , in a broad range of degrees with a fat tail for very large degrees . besides
, for the cumulative degree distribution @xmath37 , a cut - off at very large degrees is observed for each distribution , which corresponds to the fat tail range .
the cumulative degree distribution provides a clear picture of the power - law behavior .
these results indicate that the empirically observed scale - free structure can be generated from the coupling of the game and the evolution of the network , which may be an explanation for the heterogenous structure of many social and economical networked - systems . moreover , the exponent @xmath8 is a function of @xmath19 , which makes our model more general for mimicking a variety of real networks .
we have checked that the parameter @xmath16 has slight effect on @xmath8 , while @xmath19 plays a major role .
analytical results of the power - law distribution will be given after the discussion of the correlation between individuals s payoffs and the degrees of nodes occupied by them . [ 0.80 ] ( color online ) .
assortative mixing coefficient @xmath39 as a function of parameter @xmath16 for different values of @xmath19 .
the network size @xmath20 is @xmath21 .
each data point is obtained by averaging over @xmath22 network realizations.,title="fig : " ] average path length is a key measure for quantifying the small - world effect , which is widely observed in the real world @xcite .
the average path length @xmath36 of a network is defined as @xmath40 where @xmath41 is the shortest path length from node @xmath27 to node @xmath28 , and @xmath20 is the network size .
we perform simulations on @xmath36 as a function of network size for different values of parameter @xmath19 .
each data point is obtained by averaging over @xmath22 different network realizations .
figure 2 shows that for all the values of @xmath19 , @xmath36 increases logarithmically with the growth of the network , but the slopes for different @xmath19 show slight differences .
these results demonstrate that the small - world effect can be reproduced by the proposed model .
another important structural feature useful for measuring the correlation among nodes of a network is the assortative mixing coefficient @xmath39 , or called degree - degree correlation @xcite , which is defined as follows : @xmath42 ^ 2}{m^{-1 } \sum_i \frac{1}{2}(j_i^2+k_i^2 ) -[m^{-1}\sum_i \frac{1}{2}(j_i+k_i)]^2},\ ] ] where @xmath43 and @xmath44 are the degrees of the two nodes at the end of the @xmath27th edge , with @xmath45 ( @xmath46 is the total number of edges of the observed graph ) .
two main classes of possible correlations have been observed in the real world : assortative behavior if @xmath47 , which indicates that large - degree nodes are preferentially connected with other large - degree nodes , and disassortative if @xmath48 , which denotes that links are more easily built between large - degree nodes and small - degree ones .
as demonstrated in ref @xcite , almost all social networks show positive values of @xmath39 , while others , including technological and biological networks , show negative @xmath39 .
however , the mechanism that leads to the basic difference between these two classes networks remains unclear @xcite .
we calculate the assortative mixing coefficient @xmath39 to check whether the generated networks by our model are suitable representations of social systems .
figure 3 shows @xmath39 as a function of parameter @xmath16 for different values of @xmath19 .
one can see that assortative behavior occurs as @xmath19 increases . for each value of @xmath19
, @xmath39 shows slight changes in the cases of low values of @xmath16 , while for large @xmath16 , assortative mixing is enhanced with the same value of @xmath19 .
the reported results demonstrate that the networks generated by our model can well capture the key distinguished structural property of social networks .
[ 0.80 ] ( color online ) .
cooperation density @xmath49 as a function of network size @xmath20 for different @xmath19 with fixing @xmath16 in the top panel and for different @xmath16 with fixing @xmath19 in the bottom panel.,title="fig : " ] so far we have studied the evolution of the underlying network structure influenced by the game .
next , we turn to the effect of changing network structure on the cooperative behavior in the game .
the key quantity for measuring the cooperation level of the game is the density of cooperators , @xmath49 @xcite .
figure 4 shows the time series of @xmath49 for different values of @xmath19 and @xmath16 .
one can find that after a short period of temporary behavior , @xmath49 reaches a stable value with small fluctuations around the average value .
hence , @xmath49 for each pair of @xmath19 and @xmath16 can be calculated by averaging a period time after the system enter a steady state . here , the network size @xmath20 is equal to the evolutionary time step , since each time an individual joins into the system . in fig . 5 , we report the @xmath49 depending on @xmath16 for different values of @xmath19 .
each data point is obtained by averaging over 10 different simulations with an average from @xmath50 to @xmath21 for each simulation .
one can see in fig . 5
, in the case of @xmath51 , @xmath49 shows no difference for distinct @xmath16 . while for @xmath52 , the lower the value of @xmath16 , the higher the cooperation level
it has been known that scale - free networks favor the emergence and persistence of cooperation @xcite .
thus , the fact that @xmath49 in our model is larger than that of well - mixed cases is attributed to the emergence of scale - free structural properties .
at the very beginning , the network evolves from a core of random - like structure , in which cooperation can not dominate in the game . while as the network gradually grows , power - law degree distribution emerges , which leads to a sharp increase of @xmath49 , as shown in fig . 4 from @xmath53 to @xmath54 .
the inhibited cooperation by the increment of @xmath19 is also ascribed to the weakened heterogeneity of degree distribution . as displayed in fig .
1 , lower value of @xmath19 corresponds to stronger heterogeneity of degree distribution reflected by the longer fat tail .
the above discussion gives a thorough picture that it is the growth and the payoff - based preferential attachment that produce scale - free network structures and meanwhile , the generated heterogeneity of degree distribution effectively promotes the emergence and persistence of cooperation . [ 0.80 ] ( color online ) .
cooperator density @xmath49 as a function of payoff parameter @xmath16 , for different @xmath19 .
each data point is obtained by averaging over 10 different simulations with an average from @xmath50 to @xmath21 for each simulation.,title="fig : " ] generally speaking , cooperation and defection are prototypical actions in economical systems . hence , evolutionary games may be suitable paradigms for studying and characterizing the phenomena observed in economical systems with players represented by agents .
in such systems , a well - known and extensively studied phenomenon is the wealth distribution of agents which follows the pareto law in the high - income group @xcite . in order to check the validity of our model for understanding economical behavior
, we investigate the wealth distribution by adopting the present evolutionary model , where the wealth of an agent is naturally represented by the accumulated payoff over time steps .
figure 6 reports the accumulated distribution of accumulated payoff @xmath55 in the whole population for different model parameters @xmath16 and @xmath19 .
one can see that power - law distribution can be observed in a wide range of @xmath55 , while the wealth distributions behave as exponential corrections in the zone of low values of @xmath55 , which is in accordance with the empirical evidence . moreover , in the left panel of fig .
6 , @xmath19 has strong influence on the exponent of power - law distribution and higher value of @xmath19 corresponds to larger exponent .
in contrast , in the right panel , @xmath16 nearly has no effect on the wealth distribution .
the correlation between @xmath19 and the exponent of wealth distribution makes our model general for reproducing the empirical observation .
[ 0.80 ] ( color online ) .
accumulated wealth distribution for different @xmath19 with fixing @xmath16 in the left panel and for different @xmath16 with fixing @xmath19 in the right panel .
the so - called wealth @xmath55 is the accumulated payoff over times of each individual .
the results are obtained by averaging over @xmath22 network realizations when the network size @xmath20 reaches @xmath21 .
the exponents of the power - law distribution in the left panel for @xmath56 and @xmath57 are @xmath58 and @xmath59 , respectively .
the empirical data of usa and japan are @xmath60 and @xmath61 , respectively @xcite .
hence , the real observations can be reproduced by our model by tuning the value of @xmath19.,title="fig : " ] in the following , we provide some analysis for the scale - free network structure induced by the payoff - preferential attachment via considering the correlation between the accumulated payoff @xmath55 of individuals and their correspondent degrees @xmath62 . as shown in fig .
7 , @xmath63 is a good linear function of @xmath62 with slope depending on @xmath16 in the simulations . using the mean - field approximation
, a node with degree @xmath62 may have @xmath64 cooperative neighbors and @xmath65 defectors and itself may be cooperator with probability @xmath49 and defector with @xmath66 .
thus , at time step @xmath67 , its payoff can be calculated as @xmath68 by substituting the elements of payoff matrix of the sg in eq .
( 5 ) , where @xmath13 , @xmath15 , @xmath14 and @xmath10 , eq . (
5 ) is simplified to @xmath69 then , we get the accumulated payoff @xmath70 where the approximation is ascribed to the fact that @xmath71 quickly reaches a stable value which is almost independent of @xmath67 ( as shown in fig .
4 ) , so that @xmath71 are replaced by @xmath49 for simplicity .
the inset of fig .
7 illustrates the comparison between the simulation results and the analytical ones on the the normalized slopes vs @xmath16 .
the theoretical predictions are calculated by substituting the simulation results of @xmath49 ( in fig .
5 ) into eq .
the theoretical results are consistent with simulations .
[ 0.80 ] ( color online ) .
correlation between the accumulated payoff of each individual @xmath63 and its degree @xmath62 for different values of @xmath16 .
the results are obtained by averaging over @xmath22 network realizations .
@xmath63 shows a linear function of @xmath62 .
simulation and analytical results of the normalized slope of each line depending on @xmath16 are displayed in the inset .
the network size @xmath20 is @xmath21.,title="fig : " ] accordingly , considering the relation between the payoff @xmath30 of an individual @xmath27 and its degree @xmath44 in eq .
( 6 ) , we give the evolution equation of the degree of a given node @xmath72 thus , we get @xmath73 with @xmath74 .
then , in the infinite size , the degree probability distribution can be acquired by @xmath75 with @xmath76 though this expression is somewhat rough because of several approximations , such as @xmath77 , eq .
( 9 ) can qualitatively describe the power - law degree distribution of the generated network .
in addition , we should mention a network model proposed by dorogovtsev and mendes @xcite , which is related to the present work .
in such model , by introducing the initial attractiveness " ( ia ) to each node , power - law degree distributions can be generated together with the exponent of the distribution controlled by strength of the ia .
very interestingly , the ia plays a significant role in the emergence of the assortative mixing property @xcite . in our model
, the parameter @xmath19 may play the same role as that of the ia in the perspective of assortative feature .
the introduction of @xmath19 enlarges the probability of poor players being connected by the new one in the growth process .
moreover , there is an approximately positive correlation between the payoff and the degree of a given individual .
hence , @xmath19 enhances the connecting probability between small - degree individuals that results in the assortative mixing behavior .
however , in our model , the degree distribution is not only controlled by @xmath19 and @xmath78 , but also by @xmath49 , as obtained in eq .
our model couples the dynamical process of the sg and the evolution of the network , which leads to the difference between our model and the network model of dorogovtsev and mendes .
in summary , we have studied the interplay of the evolutionary game and the relevant network structure .
simulation results indicate that both scale - free structural property and high cooperation level result from the interplay between the game and the network .
moreover , the resultant networks reproduce some typical features of social networks , including small - world and positive assortative mixing properties .
the investigation of the wealth distribution of players indicates the validity of our model in mimicking the dynamical behavior of economical systems .
however , some issues still remain unclear and deserve further study , such as the evolution of connections among existing nodes , as discussed in previous works @xcite . on the other hand , in the present work
, we only consider the case of birth " of new players , which leads to the growth of the network .
while , in social systems , death " and aging " are also important events and a previous work has already pointed out that the aging effect plays a significant role in the evolution of network structures @xcite .
therefore , there is a need to consider the death and aging processes for better characterizing the evolutionary dynamics of social systems in the future study . | we study the interplay between evolutionary game and network structure and show how the dynamics of the game affect the growth pattern of the network and how the evolution of the network influence the cooperative behavior in the game .
simulation results show that the payoff - based preferential attachment mechanism leads to the emergence of a scale - free structural property , @xmath0 .
moreover , we investigate the average path length and the assortative mixing features .
the obtained results indicate that the network has small - world and positive assortative behaviors , which are consistent with the observations of some real social networks . in parallel
, we found that the evolution of the underlying network structure effectively promotes the cooperation level of the game .
we also investigate the wealth distribution obtained by our model , which is consistent with the pareto law in the real observation .
in addition , the analysis of the generated scale - free network structure is provided for better understanding the evolutionary dynamics of our model . |
the low - energy interaction between hadrons contains a parity - violating ( pv ) component due to the weak interactions of quarks contained in the hadrons .
hadronic parity violation has received renewed interest with a number of ongoing and planned experiments @xcite as well as theoretical developments . traditionally , there are two different theoretical approaches to hadronic parity violation .
the most commonly used framework is the one - meson exchange model of desplanques , donoghue and holstein ( ddh ) @xcite . in a different approach by danilov @xcite the pv hadronic interactions
are described in terms of 5 low - energy amplitudes .
more recently , effective field theories ( efts ) have been applied to the problem of hadronic parity violation @xcite .
here we present results of calculations in the framework of pionless effective field theory ( ) . in only nucleon fields appear as dynamic degrees of freedom . at the energies of many of the current and
planned experiments the pion can not be resolved and can be integrated out .
the remaining interactions are given in terms of 5 @xmath1 contact terms , each accompanied by an unknown low - energy constand ( lec ) .
while the lecs can not be predicted within the theory , once they have been determined by comparison with a sufficient number of experimental data the theory has predictive power . as an eft
this approach is model - independent and allows for a systematic improvement of the results .
the results presented here constitute an important step in the determination of the pv low - energy constants .
in all interactions are described by contact terms . in the parity - conserving sector
the lagrangian is given by @xmath2 where @xmath3 and @xmath4 are su(2 ) pauli matrices in spin and isospin space , respectively , @xmath5 is the nucleon covariant derivative , @xmath6 and @xmath7 and @xmath8 are the isoscalar and isovector nucleon magnetic moments .
the partial wave projection operators are defined through @xcite @xmath9 in the power - divergence subtraction scheme @xcite , which we employ in our calculations , the low - energy couplings are given by @xmath10 with @xmath11 ( @xmath12 ) the @xmath13 ( @xmath14 ) scattering length and @xmath15 the renormalization point .
for the leading - order pv lagrangian we use the formulation given in @xcite , @xmath16 + h.c.,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath17 with @xmath18 some spin - isospin - operator , and @xmath19
nucleon - nucleon scattering is theoretically the most basic process in which to study hadronic parity violation .
the longitudinal asymmetry @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the total scattering cross section of a polarized nucleon with helicity @xmath22 on an unpolarized nucleon target , would vanish if parity were conserved . with the lagrangians given in sec .
[ sec : lags ] and neglecting coulomb interactions for the @xmath23 case we obtain at leading order @xmath24 and @xmath25 with @xmath26 linear combinations of the parameters of the lagrangian , and @xmath27 the differential cross section in partial wave @xmath28 . since @xmath29 is an observable and therefore independent of the renormalization point @xmath15 ,
the @xmath15-dependence of @xmath30 is dictated entirely by @xmath31 .
in addition , since the energy dependence of the differential cross sections in the @xmath32 and @xmath33 partial waves differ , a detailed study of the energy dependence of the @xmath34 asymmetry in principle allows an extraction of two different linear combinations of the pv parameters .
the result of eq .
( [ nn : ppnn ] ) does not take into account coulomb effects for the @xmath23 case .
coulomb interactions can be systematically incorporated in .
we find that at energies for which is applicable coulomb corrections turn out to be small and can be treated perturbatively @xcite .
there exist two experimental results for @xmath35 at @xmath36 @xcite and @xmath37 @xcite .
while the result at @xmath36 can be used to extract the combination @xcite @xmath38 the energy of @xmath37 lies outside the domain of applicability of .
by choosing suitable neutron polarizations the reaction @xmath0 allows access to two different pv observables . for polarized neutrons
one can determine the photon asymmetry @xmath39 at threshold , which is defined through @xmath40 where @xmath41 is the @xmath0 width and @xmath42 the angle between the neutron polarization and the direction of the outgoing photon momentum . at leading order
we obtain @xmath43 note again the appearance of a ratio of pv and pc couplings , indicating that any renormalization point dependence in the weak couplings is driven by those in the strong coupling .
we would also like to point out that we do not require phenomenological wave functions for the deuteron , but treat the deuteron field consistently in the eft framework .
there is an ongoing experimental effort at the spallation neutron source to measure @xmath39 to a sensitivity of @xmath44 ( see e.g. @xcite ) . for unpolarized neutron capture the pv interactions induce a circular polarization of the outgoing photon @xmath45 , @xmath46 where @xmath47 is the total cross section for photons with positive / negative helicity .
the leading - order result is given by @xmath48.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the asymmetry in the inverse reaction might be experimentally more feasible and is equal to @xmath45 for exactly reversed kinematics .
current experimental results are consistent with zero in both cases @xcite .
we have presented results for two - body pv observables in the framework of pionless effective field theory , in particular asymmetries in @xmath1 scattering and polarized radiative neutron capture , and an induced photon polarization in unpolarized neutron capture .
these results provide an important step in the determination of the unknown low - energy constants in the pv lagrangian of eq .
( [ lag : pv ] ) . in order to determine all five parameters
it is necessary to also consider few - body processes . in the future
we will look at observables such as , e.g. , asymmetries in @xmath49 or @xmath50 spin rotation for which experiments are ongoing or being considered .
i thank d.r .
phillips and r. p. springer for their collaboration on the topics presented here and many interesting discussions , as well as useful comments on the manuscript .
this work was supported by the us department of energy under grant de - fg02 - 93er40756 and grant de - fg02 - 05er41368 .
i also acknowledge financial support by the national science foundation ( career grant phy-0645498 ) and us department of energy ( de - fg02 - 95er-40907 ) .
e. stiliaris , eur .
phys . j. a * 24s2 * , 175 ( 2005 ) .
b. lauss _ et al .
_ , aip conf .
* 842 * , 790 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : nucl - ex/0601004 ] . c. d. bass _ et al .
_ , arxiv:0905.0395 [ nucl - ex ] . b. desplanques , j. f. donoghue and b. r. holstein , annals phys . * 124 * , 449 ( 1980 ) .
g. s. danilov , phys .
lett . * 18 * , 40 ( 1965 ) ; phys .
* b35 * , 579 ( 1971 ) .
* 14 * , 443 ( 1972 ) .
d. b. kaplan , m. j. savage , r. p. springer and m. b. wise , phys .
b * 449 * , 1 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : nucl - th/9807081 ] .
m. j. savage and r. p. springer , nucl .
a * 644 * , 235 ( 1998 ) [ erratum - ibid .
a * 657 * , 457 ( 1999 ) ] [ arxiv : nucl - th/9807014 ] .
m. j. savage , nucl .
a * 695 * , 365 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : nucl - th/0012043 ] .
s. l. zhu , c. m. maekawa , b. r. holstein , m. j. ramsey - musolf and u. van kolck , nucl .
a * 748 * , 435 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : nucl - th/0407087 ] .
d. b. kaplan , m. j. savage and m. b. wise , phys .
c * 59 * , 617 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : nucl - th/9804032 ] .
d. b. kaplan , m. j. savage and m. b. wise , phys .
b * 424 * , 390 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : nucl - th/9801034 ] .
d. b. kaplan , m. j. savage and m. b. wise , nucl .
b * 534 * , 329 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : nucl - th/9802075 ] .
d. eversheim _ et al .
_ , phys .
b * 256 * ( 1991 ) 11 ; p.
d. eversheim _ et al .
_ , spring meeting of the dpg , salzburg 1992 , abstract in verhandlungen der dpg ( 1992 ) 59 ; w. haeberli and b. r. holstein , arxiv : nucl - th/9510062 . s. kistryn _ et al .
_ , phys .
lett . * 58 * , 1616 ( 1987 ) . c. b. crawford , 4th international workshop `` from parity violation to hadronic structure and more '' , 22 - 26 june 2009 , bar harbor , ` http://web.mit.edu/pavi09/talks/crawford_neutron_cap_pv.pdf ` . | we present results for two - body observables that are sensitive to the parity - violating component of nucleon - nucleon interactions .
these interactions are studied using an effective field theory in which the only dynamic degrees of freedom are nucleon fields .
the observables we study are cross - section asymmetries in nucleon - nucleon scattering and asymmetries and induced polarizations in the process @xmath0 . |
in fig . [ fig01]a below ( see also fig . 3 of the main text ) , a sheet of paper is wrapped around a cylinder to model the shape adopted by the thin adhesive film during our peeling / tearing experiments .
the blue solid line indicates the peeling front whose shape is identified to a curve @xmath21 obtained by the intersection between a cylinder and a plane forming an angle @xmath57 with the @xmath1-axis ( see fig .
[ fig01]b , c ) .
when the sheet is unrolled and flattened , the creasing of the paper sheet reveals the curvature of the peeling front relevant for our study ( see fig . [ fig01]d , e ) .
this procedure allows to distinguish the part of the curvature of the curve @xmath21 that is due to the cylinder and the one that comes from the peeling front itself . in mathematical terms
, this means that we are dealing with the _ geodesic curvature _ , @xmath90 , of the curve @xmath21 and not with the total curvature .
as illustrated in fig .
[ fig01]e , this geodesic curvature varies slowly along the peeling front and is approximated in our study by the curvature , @xmath91 , at the tip of the front ( at @xmath92 ) .
the deviation between the peeling front and an arc of circle is also shown .
the accuracy of this approximation improves as the ratio between the width of the front , @xmath18 , and the radius of the cylinder , @xmath51 , decreases .
the equation of the cylinder is given by @xmath93 with @xmath94 .
the equation of the plane reads @xmath95 with @xmath96 .
consequently , the parametric equations for the intersecting curve @xmath21 is found to be @xmath97 with @xmath98 .
since we are only interested by the geodesic curvature at the _ tip _ of the curve @xmath21 , there are two equivalent ways to compute this quantity .
the first one is obviously to directly compute the geodesic curvature along the curve @xmath21 by using the general definition of this quantity , as detailed in the next section .
the second equivalent one is to compute the curvature at the tip of the curve @xmath99 obtained by projecting the curve @xmath21 in the plane @xmath58 , as mentioned in the main text . from eqs .
( [ cyl ] ) and ( [ plane ] ) , this curve , @xmath99 , is an ellipse whose equation reads @xmath100 the radius of curvature , @xmath12 , at the tip @xmath92 is thus given by @xmath101 this corresponds to the expression used in the main text and tested experimentally ( see fig .
3d of the main text ) .
an alternative procedure to obtain the result ( [ rbar ] ) is to compute the geodesic curvature defined by the relation @xcite @xmath102 where prime denotes the derivative with respect to the parameter @xmath25 , @xmath103 is the norm of @xmath104 and @xmath105 is the unit normal to the cylinder .
the radius of curvature @xmath12 is given by @xmath106 where @xmath107 is evaluated at @xmath108 which correspond to @xmath92 from eq .
( [ eq - curve ] ) .
the unit normal to the cylinder is computed from the gradient of @xmath109 as follow @xmath110 the expression of this normal vector along the curve @xmath21 is obtained by replacing @xmath111 and @xmath112 in terms of @xmath25 using the parametrization ( [ eq - curve ] ) : @xmath113 the rest of computation is done without difficulty and we obtain @xmath114 finally , the geodesic curvature at the tip of the curve @xmath21 is given by @xmath115 | flaps can be detached from a thin film glued on a solid substrate by tearing and peeling . for flat substrates
, it has been shown that these flaps spontaneously narrow and collapse in pointy triangular shapes . here
we show that various shapes , triangular , elliptic , acuminate or spatulate , can be observed for the tears by adjusting the curvature of the substrate . from combined experiments and theoretical models ,
we show that the flap morphology is governed by simple geometric rules .
cracks and fractures are commonly observed around us in various contexts @xcite ranging from drying mud @xcite to broken windows or ice floes @xcite .
the classical fracture theories , initially formulated by griffith and irwin @xcite , can reliably predict the onset of cracks motion .
in contrast , no general theory is able to predict the path of a crack as it propagates . in some specific cases however , interesting insight has been gained about cracks trajectories .
for example , thin films offer a particularly efficient set - up to study fracture propagation by limiting the crack motion to a two - dimensional manifold . in this context
, the crucial role of geometry was identified in some oscillatory fracture patterns obtained when a brittle elastic thin sheet is cut by a moving object @xcite .
the propagation of two interacting cracks in torn thin films is another example where fracture path can be understood @xcite . .
( a ) flat substrate , triangular shape . when the peeling front propagates by a infinitesimal @xmath0 along @xmath1-axis , it produces two cracks of length @xmath2 together with a variation of the width @xmath3 and a variation of the peeling area @xmath4 .
( b ) substrate with negative curvature , acuminate .
( c , d ) substrate with positive curvature with @xmath5 , spatulate ( c ) and @xmath6 , elliptic ( d ) , where @xmath7 is the initial width of the flap .
negative ( positive ) curvature , @xmath8 , @xmath9 and @xmath10 are defined in the text .
scale bars are 5 mm .
the peeling front propagates upward . ] for adhesive thin films , the adhesion strength influences the crack paths .
it was shown recently how thin film elasticity , adhesion and fracture act together to generate quasi - perfect triangular tears for pulled adhesive tape on flat substrates @xcite .
regardless of the material properties , _
i.e. _ adhesive / fracture energy , film thickness or bending modulus , the triangular morphology is extremely robust ; only the tearing angle , @xmath9 , is modified .
this property was recently used to study the elasticity of graphene from tearing experiments @xcite . in this letter , we show through a combined experimental and theoretical study , how geometry of the substrate on which the thin film is glued gives exquisite control of the shape of the tears . with cylindrical substrates , it is possible to generate convergent and even divergent crack paths as presented in fig .
[ fig1 ] . with a constant peeling angle @xmath11 .
@xmath12 is the radius of curvature of the peeling front .
( c ) cross - section along the cylindrical axis of the system .
@xmath13 is the radius of curvature of the ridge connecting the flap to the substrate , @xmath14 is the length of this ridge and @xmath15 is the applied force .
( d ) evolution of the tearing angle , @xmath9 , for a flat substrate as a function of the peeling angle , @xmath11 .
each data point corresponds to the average of at least 5 experiments . ] in the experiments , a thin elastic sheet is adhered to various flat or curved solid substrates .
two parallel notches are cut on one edge of the adhesive film to obtain a rectangular flap .
the flap is then pulled at a constant speed ( @xmath16 mm / s ) and at a constant peeling angle ( @xmath17 ) with a probe tack device ( see fig . [ fig2]a , b ) .
the final detached flaps were then digitized and further analysed ( imagej and plot digitizer ) to obtain the shape of the various tears ( selected tears are shown in fig .
[ fig1 ] ) . _
flat substrates_. the shapes of tears are fully determined by the evolution of the flap width , @xmath18 , with the peeled distance , @xmath19 during the advancing of both cracks ( fig .
[ fig1 ] ) . in order to explain this evolution
, we use a model based on the griffith s theory of fracture to describe the path of these tears @xcite .
it should be noticed that due to the peeling geometry , the pulling force induces a deformation of the adhesive film localized in a ridge with a curvature @xmath20 that connects the flap to the substrate , see fig .
[ fig2]c . the energy embedded into the system by pulling the flap is thus shared among the elastic energy stored in the ridge , the penalties associated to the creation of new surfaces , when cracks advance ( @xmath21 , the work of fracture of the film ) , and the energy dissipated in the de - adhesion process ( @xmath22 , the adhesive energy per unit area ) . the variation of energy for an infinitesimal motion of the peeling front is , thus , given by @xmath23 where @xmath24 , @xmath25 , @xmath2 and @xmath4 are the elastic energy of the flap , the film thickness , the increment in crack length , @xmath26 , and the variation of the peeling area @xmath27 ( see fig . [
fig1]a ) . assuming that @xmath24 depends only on @xmath18 and @xmath19 , the variation of energy needed to move the front by a distance @xmath0 becomes ( @xmath28 stands for @xmath29 ) , @xmath30 d\ell \label{energy}\ ] ] where @xmath31 since by convention a positive tearing angle leads to a decrease of the flap width . to solve this equation and find the function @xmath32 that determines the shape of the flap
, we need to compute the elastic energy stored in the ridge of curvature @xmath33 .
the average curvature of this ridge is simply given by @xmath34 , where @xmath14 is the length of the ridge ( fig .
[ fig2]c ) .
the elastic energy is , therefore , given by @xmath35 ( where @xmath36 is the bending modulus of the film ) .
the length of the ridge @xmath14 can be obtained through energy minimization , @xmath37 , reflecting a balance between the different energy terms of eq .
( [ energy ] ) . considering the expression of @xmath24 given above
, we obtain the relation @xmath38 assuming that the width of the flap is much larger than the length of the ridge ( so that the first term of eq . ( [ eqforl ] ) is negligible compared to the second one ) and using the approximation @xmath39 ( valid for the studied range of angles ) , we obtain the expression for @xmath14 , @xmath40 inserting this expression in eq .
( [ elastic_energy ] ) yields the final expression for the elastic energy .
the propagation of the cracks follows the angle @xmath9 which minimizes the variation of energy ( _ i.e. _ , this can be considered as the maximum - energy - release - rate criterion @xcite ) .
the tearing angle is determined by considering that @xmath41 . from eq .
( [ energy ] ) , this condition becomes @xmath42 the obtained final expression for the elastic energy combined with eq .
( [ sintheta ] ) determines the tearing angle as a function of the material properties @xmath43 depending on the relative importance of adhesion and crack energy terms ( determined by the ratio @xmath44 ) , we can distinguish two different regimes . for large flaps
, adhesion dominates the evolution of the crack path ( @xmath45 mm in our experiments ) .
this regime characterized by a constant tearing angle @xmath9 , is described by the relation @xmath46 this relation is similar to the one obtained in ref .
@xcite , the influence of the peeling angle @xmath11 being added .
the linear relation between @xmath47 and @xmath11 is in close agreement with the experimental data shown in fig .
[ fig2]d .
in addition , a regime dominated by the fracture energy should always be observed near the tip of the flaps , _
i.e. _ , when @xmath18 becomes very small .
this regime is characterized by @xmath48 .
the tearing angle thus increases for decreasing flap width ; this yields a shortening of the flap and a re - entrant morphology ( see for instance fig . 1 of @xcite ) . considering that @xmath49 , the shape of the tears in this regime corresponds to the power law @xmath50 .
however , it should be mentioned that this regime is rather difficult to observe when conventional adhesive tapes are used .
_ curved substrates_. when a thin film is glued on a curved substrate , the peeling / tearing process produces various morphologies for the flaps as depicted in fig .
[ fig1 ] .
those shapes depend on the radius of curvature , @xmath51 , of the substrate . for clarity
, we define the curvature as shown in fig .
[ fig2]a , b and use , in the following , the parameter @xmath52 equals @xmath53 or @xmath54 for positive or negative curvature , respectively .
the main ingredient determining the global shape of the tears is the morphology of the peeling front induced by the substrate curvature .
this front is linear for flat substrates , but , in contrast , it is characterized by a finite radius of curvature , @xmath12 , for cylindrical substrates as shown in fig .
[ fig3]c .
the direction of the curvature with respect to direction of the cracks propagation is determined by the sign of the substrate curvature .
this is the main source for the breaking of symmetry which explains the occurrence of closing or opening cracks path when the peeling of the adhesive film is performed on the exterior ( @xmath55 ) or the interior ( @xmath56 ) side of the cylinder , respectively .
the relation between the radius of curvature of the peeling front and the radius of curvature of the substrate can be explained with the help of simple geometrical arguments .
the limiting zone of contact between the adhesive film peeled with an angle @xmath11 and the substrate is given by the intersection between the cylindrical substrate and a plane forming an angle @xmath57 with the symmetry axis of the cylinder as shown on fig .
[ fig3]b .
the projection of this curve on the @xmath58 plane is characterized by a radius of curvature at its tip , @xmath12 , given by @xmath59 , see fig .
[ fig3]c .
this relation corresponds to the geodesic curvature of the intersection curve @xcite and is in very good agreement with the evolution of @xmath12 with the peeling angle ( fig .
[ fig3]d ) for various values of @xmath51 .
the curvature of the peeling front is not significantly influenced by the speed at which the front advances , _
i.e. _ by the adhesion energy , indicating that the origin of this curved morphology is purely geometric .
it is worth noting that the peeling front becomes linear for peeling angle @xmath11 close to @xmath60 irrespective of the curvature of the substrate ( @xmath12 tends to infinity for @xmath11 close to @xmath61 ) . .
( b ) lateral view showing the plane containing the limiting zone of contact between the adhesive film and the cylindrical substrate and forming an angle @xmath57 with @xmath62axis .
( c ) top view showing the curved morphology of the peeling front .
the angle @xmath63 defines the rotation at the cracks of the tangent of the curved front ( blue solid line ) with respect to a planar peeling front ( red solid line ) .
scale bar : 3 cm .
( d ) evolution of the observed radius of curvature @xmath64 with the peeling angle @xmath11 . ] in order to derive a model describing the shape of the flaps for curved substrates , we make the following assumptions : i ) the tears are produced in the adhesion regime . this approximation is justified since almost everywhere
the width of the flaps is large enough to neglect fracture energy ( @xmath65 mm ) except for the extreme tip of the convergent tears ; ii ) the distortion of the peeling front induces a rotation of the path direction of the cracks by an angle @xmath63 ( see fig .
[ fig3]c ) , keeping the same value of the tearing angle @xmath9 , given by eq .
( [ sintheta_f ] ) . to account for this rotation of the crack path with respect to the cylinder axis
, we introduce a new angle @xmath66 ( with @xmath67 , see here above ) .
the angle @xmath63 is determined by the distortion of the peeling front and the width of the flap and is given by @xmath68 .
this new geometry transforms the equation that determines the shape of the tears for curved substrates into @xmath69 with @xmath70 as the lowest order and using as above @xmath71 . introducing the normalization , @xmath72 and @xmath73
, we get the following ordinary differential equation ( ode ) @xmath74 the solution of this ode is given by @xmath75 \label{solution}\ ] ] where @xmath76 is an arbitrary point along the flap profile . 54.8 , 20.2 and 16 mm ) and ( b ) positive curvature obtained from 30 experiments ( @xmath77 18.5 and 14.1 mm ) .
the scalings used to normalize the plots are discussed in the text .
the solid lines correspond to eq .
( [ solution ] ) obtained from the model with @xmath78 . ]
let us now discuss in detail the morphology of these solutions for the different values of @xmath52 and @xmath79 . for substrates with negative curvature , we always observe closing tears with an `` acuminate leaf - like '' shape @xcite and a sharp decrease of @xmath10 with @xmath19 ( fig .
[ fig1]b ) . with @xmath80 and @xmath81 ( _ i.e.
_ , this point represents the ultimate tip of the tear ) , eq .
( [ solution ] ) simplifies to @xmath82 which captures almost perfectly the evolution of the tears shape for various samples ( see the master curve in fig . [
fig4]a ) . for the positive curvature ,
pulling an adhesive can produce either opening ( `` spatulate '' ) or closing ( `` elliptic '' ) tears as shown in fig .
[ fig1]c and d , depending on the initial value of the flap width .
interestingly , these morphologies and the transition in shape with the width are also captured by the model . for @xmath83 ,
the solution reads @xmath84 from this equation , two different regimes are indeed expected depending on the flap width . for large initial width ( @xmath85 or @xmath86 ) , we observe a rapid opening of the tears contrasting with the triangular shapes previously reported .
this behavior is predicted by the model since in this case , the exponential term of eq .
( [ solution - plus ] ) is strictly positive .
the agreement with the experimental data is very good , a master curve of all the results being given in fig .
[ fig4]b . for small width ( @xmath87 or @xmath88 )
, we recover closing tears but with an `` elliptic leaf - like '' shape instead of an acuminate one .
this behavior is also predicted by our model since in this case , the exponential term of eq .
( [ solution - plus ] ) is strictly negative .
again , the model based on geometry arguments captures the variety of the tear morphology observed for curved substrates .
the transition between opening and closing crack paths predicted by the model is also experimentally observed and perfectly reproduced by the theory ( fig .
[ fig4]b ) .
it should be emphasized that , for positively curved substrates and a given set of experimental conditions ( @xmath51 , @xmath11 , @xmath21 , @xmath22 , and @xmath25 ) there is a single value of the width @xmath89 that produces tears with a constant width and parallel cracks .
this value obviously corresponds to an unstable state lying between both opening and closing domains . as shown here above , the peeling front is linear for peeling angle close to @xmath61 regardless of the curvature of the substrate . as expected from the proposed model ,
the tears adopt a triangular morphology for various curved substrates when the flap is pulled at @xmath60 , see the inset of fig .
[ fig4]a . in conclusion , we have demonstrated for flaps detached from films glued to simple circular cylinders that a constant mean curvature strongly affects the crack path and thus the shape of the tears . moreover , the proposed model can be readily extended to any developable surface , _ i.e. _ conical or cylindrical .
indeed , eq . ( [ equa_diff ] ) describes the local behavior of the crack propagation and , therefore , a spatial variation of the surface curvature can be easily introduced
. a possible extension of this work could be the study of the influence of gaussian curvature on crack path and tear morphology for surfaces such as sphere , hyperboloid .
this work was partially supported by the belgian national funds for scientific research ( fnrs ) , the government of the region of wallonia ( remanos research programs ) , the european science foundation ( eurocores fanas , ebioadi ) .
99 m.j .
buehler and s. keten , rev .
mod .
phys . * 82 * , 1459 ( 2010 ) .
l. goehring _ et al .
_ , soft matter * 6 * , 3562 ( 2010 ) .
j. strm and j. timonen , phys .
rev .
lett . * 79 * , 3684 ( 1997 ) .
d. vella and j. s. wettlaufer , j. geophys
. res . *
113 * , c11011 ( 2008 ) .
a.a . griffith , philos .
trans .
r. soc .
a * 221 * , 163 ( 1921 ) .
g. irwin , j. appl .
mech .
* 24 * , 361 ( 1957 ) .
a. ghatak and l. mahadevan , phys .
rev .
lett . * 91 * , 215507 ( 2003 ) .
b. audoly , p.m. reis and b. roman , phys .
rev .
lett .
* 95 * , 025502 ( 2005 ) . y. cohen and i. procaccia , phys .
rev .
e * 81 * , 066103 ( 2010 ) .
m.l .
fender , f. lechenault and k.e .
daniels , phys .
rev .
lett . * 105 * , 125505 ( 2010 ) .
e. bayart , a. boudaoud and m. adda - bedia , phys .
rev .
lett . * 106 * , 194301 ( 2011 ) .
e. hamm _
et al . _ ,
nature mat .
* 7 * , 386 ( 2008 ) .
d. sen , k.s .
novoselov , p.m. reis and m.j .
buehler , small * 6 * , 1108 ( 2010 ) .
c.h .
wu , j. elasticity * 8 * , 235 ( 1978 ) . see supplemental material below . for clarity , we choose the chart of leaf morphology to describe the global shape of the tearing flaps .
yu.s .
slobodyan , `` geodesic curvature '' , in encyclopaedia of mathematics , ed .
m. hazewinkel , springer 2002 . *
_ supplemental material for _ `` how geometry controls the tearing of adhesive thin films on curved surfaces '' * |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.