article
stringlengths 0
745k
| abstract
stringlengths 0
92.7k
|
|---|---|
there may be a deep connection between the origin of matter in the universe and the observed neutrino oscillations .
this speculation is inspired by the idea that the heavy right handed majorana neutrinos that are added to the standard model for understanding small neutrino masses via the seesaw mechanism@xcite can also explain the origin of matter via their decay .
the mechanism goes as follows@xcite : cp violation in the same yukawa interaction of the right handed neutrinos , which go into giving nonzero neutrino masses after electroweak symmetry breaking , lead to a primordial lepton asymmetry via the out of equilibrium decay @xmath11 ( where @xmath12 are the known leptons and @xmath13 is the standard model higgs field ) .
this asymmetry subsequently gets converted to baryon - anti - baryon asymmetry observed today via the the electroweak sphaleron interactions@xcite , above @xmath14 ( @xmath15 being the weak scale ) .
since this mechanism involves no new interactions beyond those needed in the discussion of neutrino masses , one would expect that better understanding of neutrino mass physics would clarify one of the deepest mysteries of cosmology both qualitatively as well as quantitatively .
this question has been the subject of many investigations in recent years@xcite in the context of different neutrino mass models and many interesting pieces of information about issues such as the spectrum of right handed neutrinos , upper limit on the neutrino masses etc have been obtained . in a recent paper , @xcite , two of the authors showed that if one assumes that the lepton sector of minimal seesaw models has a leptonic @xmath0 interchange symmetry@xcite , then one can under certain plausible assumptions indeed predict the magnitude of the matter - anti - matter asymmetry in terms of low energy oscillation parameter , @xmath16 and a high scale cp phase .
the choice of @xmath0 symmetry was dictated by the fact that it is the simplest symmetry of neutrino mass matrix that explains the maximal atmospheric mixing as indicated by data .
using present experimental value for @xmath16 , one obtains the right magnitude for the baryon asymmetry of the universe .
the results of the paper @xcite were derived in the limit that @xmath0 interchange symmetry is exact . if however a nonzero value for the neutrino mixing angle @xmath8 is detected in future experiments , this would imply that this symmetry is only approximate .
also , since in the standard model @xmath17 and @xmath18 are members of the @xmath19 doublets @xmath20 and @xmath21 , any symmetry between @xmath17 and @xmath18 must be a symmetry between @xmath22 and @xmath23 at the fundamental lagrangian level .
the observed difference between the muon and tau masses would therefore also imply that the @xmath0 symmetry has to be an approximate symmetry . in view of this
, it is important to examine to what extent the results of ref.@xcite carry over to the case when the symmetry is approximate .
we find two interesting results under some very general assumtions : ( i ) a simple formula relating the lepton asymmetry and neutrino oscillation observables for the case of three right handed neutrinos , i.e. @xmath24 and ( ii ) a relation of the form @xmath25 for the case of two right handed neutrinos .
measurement of @xmath8 will have important implications for both the models ; in particular we show that in a class of models with two right handed neutrinos with approximate @xmath0 symmetry breaking , there is a lower limit on @xmath8 , which is between 0.1 to 0.15 depending on the values of the cp phase .
these values are in the range which will be probed in experiments in near future@xcite .
the basic assumption under which the two results are derived are the following : \(a ) type i seesaw formula is responsible for neutrino masses : \(b ) @xmath0 symmetry for leptons is broken only at high scale in the mass matrix of the right handed neutrinos .
the paper is organized as follows : in sec .
ii , we outline the general framework for our discussion ; in sec .
iii , we rederive the result of ref.@xcite for the case of exact @xmath0 symmetry ; in sec .
iv , we derive the connection between @xmath1 and oscillation parameters for the case of approximate @xmath0 symmetry .
iv is devoted to the case of two right handed neutrinos , where we present the allowed range of @xmath8 dictated by leptogenesis argument . in sec .
v , we describe a class of simple gauge models where these conditions are satisfied .
we start with an extension of the minimal supersymmetric standard model ( mssm ) for the generic the type i seesaw model for neutrino masses .
the effective low energy superpotential for this model is given by @xmath26 here @xmath27 are leptonic superfields ; @xmath28 are the higgs fields of mssm . @xmath29 and @xmath30 are general matrices where we choose a basis where @xmath31 is diagonal .
we do not display the quark part of the superpotential which is same as in the mssm .
after electroweak symmetry breaking , this leads to the type i seesaw formula for neutrino masses given by @xmath32 the constraints of @xmath0 symmetry will manifest themselves in the form of the @xmath29 and @xmath30 .
it has been pointed out that if we go to a basis where the right handed neutrino mass matrix is diagonal , we can solve for @xmath29 in terms of the neutrino masses and mixing angles as follows@xcite : @xmath33 where @xmath34 is a complex matrix with the property that @xmath35 .
the unitary matrix @xmath36 is the lepton mixing matrix defined by @xmath37 the complex orthogonal matrices @xmath34 can be parameterized as : @xmath38 with @xmath39 and similarly for the other matrices .
@xmath40 are complex angles .
let us now turn to lepton asymmetry : the formula for primordial lepton asymmetry in this case , caused by right handed neutrino decay is @xmath41 ^ 2_{1j}}{(\tilde{y}_\nu \tilde{y}^{\dagger}_\nu)_{11 } } f(\frac{m_1}{m_j } ) \label{nl}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath42 is defined in a basis where righthanded neutrinos are mass eigenstates and their masses are denoted by @xmath43 where @xmath44$]@xcite . in the case where that the right handed neutrinos have a hierarchical mass pattern i.e. @xmath45 , we get @xmath46 . in this approximation , we can write the lepton asymmetry in a simple form@xcite @xmath47_{11}}{v^2(\tilde{y}_\nu \tilde{y}^{\dagger}_\nu)_{11 } } \label{buch}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where using the expression for @xmath29 given above , we can rewrite @xmath1 as : @xmath48_{11}}{v^2|r(z_{ij}){\cal m}_\nu r^{\dagger}(z_{ij})|^2_{11 } } \label{buch1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we will now apply this discussion to calculate the lepton asymmetry in the general case without any symmetries . in the following sections , we follow it up with a discussion of two cases : ( i ) the cases of exact @xmath0 symmetry and ( ii ) the case where this symmetry is only approximate . since the formula in eq .
( 9 ) assumes that there are three right handed neutrinos , we will focus on this case in the next two sections . in a subsequent section ,
we consider the case of two right handed neutrinos @xmath49 , which transform into each other under the @xmath0 symmetry .
both cases are in agreement with the observed neutrino mass differences and mixings .
it follows from eq.[buch1 ] that @xmath50}{v^2|r(z_{ij}){\cal m}_\nu r^{\dagger}(z_{ij})|^2_{11 } } \label{for}\end{aligned}\ ] ] since the matrix @xmath34 is an orthogonal matrix , we have the relation @xmath51 using this equation in eq.[for ] , we get @xmath52}{v^2\sum_j(|r_{1j}|^2 m_j ) } \label{for1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this relation connects the lepton asymmetry to both the solar and the atmospheric mass difference square@xcite .
to make a prediction for the lepton asymmetry , we need to the lengths of the complex quantities @xmath53 .
the out of equilibrium condition does provide a constraint on @xmath54 as follows : @xmath55 it is clear from eq .
( 13 ) that if neutrinos are quasidegenerate i.e. @xmath56 , then using eq . ( 11 ) , we find that the left hand side of eq .
( 13 ) has a lower bound of @xmath57 which is clearly much bigger than the right hand side of the inequality . defining @xmath58
, this means that @xmath59 .
this implies that the right handed neutrinos decays are in equilibrium at @xmath60 .
this will cause dilution of the lepton asymmetry generated with the dilution factor given by @xmath61 . using a parameterization for the dilution factor @xmath62@xcite
, we get @xmath63 which will make the baryon to photon ratio much too small . based on this argument
, we conclude that a degenerate mass spectrum with @xmath64 ev will most likely be in conflict with observations , if type i seesaw is responsible for neutrino masses .
it must however be noted that a more appealing and natural scenario for degenerate neutrino masses is type ii seesaw formula@xcite , in which case the above considerations do not apply .
therefore , it is not possible to conclude based on the leptogenesis argument alone that a quasi - degenerate neutrino spectrum is inconsistent . in a hierarchical neutrino mass picture ,
( 13 ) implies that @xmath65 and @xmath66 .
if we assume that the upper limit in the eq.[equ1 ] is saturated , then we get the atmospheric neutrino mass difference square in eq.[for1 ] to give the dominant contribution .
we will see below that if one assumes an exact @xmath0 symmetry for the neutrino mass matrix , the situation becomes different and it is the solar mass difference square that dominates .
in this section , we consider the case of three right handed neutrino with an exact @xmath0 symmetry in the dirac mass matrix as well as the right handed neutrino mass matrix . in this case , the right handed neutrino mass matrix @xmath30 and the dirac yukawa coupling @xmath29 can be written respectively as : @xmath67 where @xmath68 and @xmath69 are all complex .
an important property of these two matrices is that they can be cast into a block diagonal form by the same transformation matrix @xmath70 on the @xmath71 s and @xmath72 s .
let us denote the block diagonal forms by a tilde i.e. @xmath42 and @xmath73 .
we then go to a basis where the @xmath73 is subsequently diagonalized by the most general @xmath74 unitary matrix as follows : @xmath75 where @xmath76 where @xmath77 is the most general @xmath74 unitary matrix given by @xmath78 .
the @xmath79 case therefore reduces to a @xmath74 problem .
the third mass eigenstate in both the light and the heavy sectors play no role in the leptogenesis as well as generation of solar mixing angle@xcite .
note also that we have @xmath80 .
the seesaw formula in the 1 - 2 subsector has exactly the same form except that all matrices in the left and right hand side of eq .
( 9 ) are @xmath74 matrices .
the formula for the dirac yukawa coupling in this case can be inverted to the form : @xmath81 where @xmath82 . using this
, we can cast @xmath1 in the form : @xmath83 this could also have been seen from eq.([for1 ] ) by realizing that for the case of exact @xmath0 symmetry , we have @xmath84 and @xmath85
. the above result reproduces the direct proportionality between @xmath1 and solar mass difference square found in ref.@xcite . to simplify this expression further ,
let us note that out of equilibrium condition for the decay of the lightest right handed neutrino leads to the condition : @xmath86 \leq 14 \frac{m^2_1}{m_{p\ell}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which implies that @xmath87 since solar neutrino data require that in a hierarchical neutrino mass picture @xmath88 ev , in eq.([equ ] ) , we must have @xmath89 .
if we parameterize @xmath90 , we recover the conclusions of ref.@xcite .
this provides a different way to arrive at the conclusions of ref.@xcite .
in this section , we consider the effect of breaking of @xmath0 symmetry on lepton asymmetry . within the seesaw framework ,
this breaking can arise either from the dirac mass matrix for the neutrinos or from the right handed neutrino sector or both .
we focus on the case , when the symmetry is broken in the right handed sector only .
such a situation is easy to realize in seesaw models where the theory obeys exact @xmath0 symmetry at high scale ( above the seesaw scale ) prior to b - l symmetry breaking as we show in a subsequent section .
we will also show that in this case there is a simple generalization of the lepton asymmetry formula that we derived in the exact @xmath0 symmetric case @xcite symmetric model where the dirac yukawa coupling has the form @xmath91 has been discussed in ref.@xcite .
our discussion applies more generally . ] . in this case
the neutrino yukawa matrix is given in the mass eigenstates basis of the right handed neutrinos by @xmath92 where @xmath93 is the neutrino dirac matrix in the flavor basis ; the notation @xmath94 denotes a unitary @xmath74 matrix in the @xmath95 subspace . in the above equation , @xmath96 .
now if we substitute for @xmath97 the expression in eq .
[ ynu ] and use maximal mixing for the atmospheric neutrino we obtain @xmath98 = v_{1/3}m^{1/2}_r r_{1/2}r_{1/3}m^{1/2}_{\nu}u_{1/2}^{+}u_{1/3}^{+}\ ] ] since the @xmath0 symmetry breaking is assumed to be small and from reactor neutrino experiments @xmath99 we will expand the mixing matrices in the @xmath100 subspace to first order in mixing parameter : @xmath101 where @xmath102\ ] ] to first order in @xmath103 , @xmath104 and @xmath8 we have @xmath105 it is straight forward to show that the perturbation parameters should satisfy the following equations @xmath106 where @xmath107 are the matrix elements of @xmath108 and @xmath109 and @xmath110 are the sine and cosine of the solar neutrino mixing angle .
hence one can see that the parameter @xmath104 is proportional to the @xmath8 neutrino mixing angle and is given to first order by @xmath111\theta_{13}e^{-i\delta}c_{\theta}\ ] ] this proves that the matrix element @xmath112 that goes into the leptogenesis formula is directly proportional to the physically observable parameter @xmath8 .
this enables us to write @xmath113 .
a consequence of this is that if the coefficient of proportionality is chosen to be of order one , then as experimental upper limit goes down , unlike the generic type i seesaw case in section ii , the solar mass difference square starts to dominate for the lma solution to the solar neutrino problem .
in this section , we consider the case of two right handed neutrinos which transform into one another under @xmath0 symmetry .
the leptogenesis in this model with exact @xmath0 symmetry was discussed in @xcite and was shown that it vanishes . in this model
therefore , a vanishing or very tiny @xmath8 would not provide a viable model for leptogenesis . turning this argument around , enough leptogenesis should provide a lower limit on the value of @xmath8 . to set the stage for our discussion ,
let us first review the argument for the exact @xmath0 symmetry case@xcite .
the symmetry under which @xmath114 and @xmath115 whereas the @xmath116 constrains the general structure of @xmath117 and @xmath118 as follows : @xmath119 in order to calculate the lepton asymmetry using eq.(7 ) , we first diagonalize the righthanded neutrino mass matrix and change the @xmath29 to @xmath42 .
since @xmath118 is a symmetric complex @xmath74 matrix , it can be diagonalized by a transformation matrix @xmath120 i.e. @xmath121 where @xmath122 are complex numbers . in this basis
we have @xmath123 .
we can therefore rewrite the formula for @xmath124 as @xmath125 ^ 2_{12 } f(\frac{m_1}{m_2})\end{aligned}\ ] ] now note that @xmath126 has the form @xmath127 which can be diagonalized by the matrix @xmath128 .
therefore it follows that @xmath129 .
let us now introduce @xmath0 symmetry breaking . if we introduce a small amount of @xmath0 breaking in the right handed neutrino sector as follows : we keep the @xmath29 symmetric but choose the right handed neutrino mass matrix as : @xmath130 after the right handed neutrino mass matrix is diagonalized , the @xmath131 @xmath132 takes the form ( for @xmath133 and in the basis where the light neutrino masses are diagonal ) : @xmath134 here @xmath135 are of order one and @xmath136 .
to first order in the small mixing @xmath8 , the complex parameters @xmath137 satisfy the constraint @xmath138 using these order of magnitude values , we now find that @xmath139}{m_2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath140 is a function of order one .
it is clear that very small values for @xmath8 will lead to unacceptably small @xmath1 . in fig . 1 , we have plotted @xmath141 against @xmath8 for values of the parameters in the model that fit the oscillation data and find a lower bound on @xmath142 for two different values of the cp phases ( figure 1 ) . in this figure , we have chosen , @xmath143 gev .
for higher values of @xmath144 the allowed range @xmath8 moves to the lower range . also we note that for values of @xmath145 gev , the baryon asymmetry becomes lower than the observed value .
vrs @xmath8 for the case of two right handed neutrinos with approximate @xmath0 symmetry and cp phases @xmath146 and @xmath147 .
the values of @xmath8 are predicted to be 0.1 and 0.15 respectively .
the horizontal line corresponds to @xmath148@xcite . ]
in this section , we present a simple extension of the minimal supersymmetric standard model ( mssm ) by adding to it specific high scale physics that at low energies can exhibit @xmath0 symmetry in the neutrino sector as well as real dirac masses for neutrinos .
first we recall that mssm needs to be extended by the addition of a set of right handed neutrinos ( either two or three ) to implement the seesaw mechanism for neutrino masses@xcite .
we will accordingly add three right handed neutrinos @xmath149 to mssm .
we then assume that at high scale , the theory has @xmath0 @xmath150 symmetry under which @xmath151 are even and odd combinations ; similarly , we have for leptonic doublet superfields @xmath152 and leptonic singlet ones @xmath153 ; two pairs of higgs doublets ( @xmath154 and @xmath155 ) , and a singlet superfields @xmath156 .
other superfields of mssm such as @xmath157 as well as quarks are even under the @xmath0 @xmath150 symmetry .
now suppose that we write the superpotential involving the @xmath158 fields as follows : @xmath159 then when we give high scale vevs to @xmath160 , then below the high scale there are only the usual mssm higgs pair @xmath161 and @xmath162 that survive whereas the other pair becomes superheavy and decouple from the low energy lagrangian . the effective coupling at the mssm level is then given by : @xmath163 note that the @xmath0 symmetry is present in the dirac neutrino mass matrix whereas it is not in the charged lepton sector as would be required to .
we show below that it is possible to have a high scale supersymmetric theory which would lead to real dirac yukawa couplings ( @xmath164 ) if we require the high scale theory to be left - right symmetric . to show how this comes about , consider the gauge group to be @xmath165 with quarks and leptons assigned to left and right handed doublets as usual@xcite i.e. @xmath166 , @xmath167 ; @xmath168 and @xmath169 ; higgs fields @xmath170 ; @xmath171 ; @xmath172 ; @xmath173 and @xmath174 . the new point specific to our model
is that we have two sets of the higgs fields with the above quantum numbers , one even and the other odd under the @xmath0 @xmath150 permutation symmetry i.e. @xmath175 , @xmath176 , @xmath177 , @xmath178 and @xmath179 ( plus for fields even under @xmath150 and @xmath180 for fields odd under @xmath150 . )
furthermore , we will impose the parity symmetry under which @xmath181 , @xmath182 , @xmath183 ) , @xmath184 .
the higgs sector of the low energy superpotential is determined from this theory after left - right gauge group is broken down to the standard model gauge group by the vev s of @xmath187 .
the phenomenon of doublet - doublet spitting leaves only two higgs doublets out of the four in @xmath188 and is determined by a generic superpotential of type @xmath189 where @xmath190 go over @xmath191 and @xmath180 for even and odd and only even terms are allowed by @xmath0 invariance e.g. @xmath192 are nonzero .
now suppose that @xmath193 but @xmath194 and @xmath195 .
these vevs break the left - right group to the standard model gauge group .
it is then easy to see that below the @xmath196 scale , there are only one higgs pair where @xmath197 and @xmath198 .
here we have denoted the @xmath199 and @xmath200 .
the upshot of all these discussions is that the right handed neutrino yukawa couplings are @xmath0 even and therefore have the form : @xmath201 it is easy to see that redefining the fields appropriately , we can make @xmath29 real .
so the only source of complex phase in this model is in the rh neutrino mass matrix , which in this model are generated by higher dimensional couplings of the form @xmath202 as we discuss now .
the most general nonrenormalizable interactions that can give rise to right handed neutrino masses are of the form : @xmath203 note that since both @xmath204 acquire vevs , the last term in the above expression will give rise to @xmath0 breaking in the rh neutrino sector while preserving it in the @xmath29 .
the associated couplings in the above equations are in general complex .
this leads to a realistic three generation model with approximate @xmath0 symmetry as analyzed in the previous sections . in summary
, we have studied the implications for leptogenesis in models where neutrino masses arise from the type i seesaw mechanism and where the near maximal atmospheric mixing angle owes its origin to an approximate @xmath0 symmetry .
we derive a relation of the form @xmath205 for the case of three right handed neutrinos , which directly connects the neutrino oscillation parameters with the origin of matter .
we also show that if @xmath8 is very small or zero , only the lma solution to the solar neutrino puzzle would provide an explanation of the origin of matter within this framework .
finally for the case of two right handed neutrinos with approximate @xmath0 symmetry , we predict values for @xmath8 in the range @xmath206 for specific choices of the the high energy phase between @xmath207 and @xmath147 .
p. minkowski , phys . lett . *
b67 * , 421 ( 1977 ) ; m. gell - mann , p. ramond , and r. slansky , _ supergravity _
( p. van nieuwenhuizen et al
. eds . ) , north holland , amsterdam , 1980 , p. 315 ; t. yanagida , in _ proceedings of the workshop on the unified theory and the baryon number in the universe _ ( o. sawada and a. sugamoto , eds . ) , kek , tsukuba , japan , 1979 , p. 95 ; s. l. glashow , _ the future of elementary particle physics _
, in _ proceedings of the 1979 cargse summer institute on quarks and leptons _
( m. lvy et al .
eds . ) , plenum press , new york , 1980 , pp . 687 ; r. n. mohapatra and g. senjanovi , phys .
lett . * 44 * 912 ( 1980 ) .
see for instance , a. s. joshipura , e. a. paschos and w. rodejohann , jhep * 08 * , 029 ( 2001 ) ; w. rodejohann and k. r. s. balaji , phys . rev .
d * 65 * , 093009 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0201052 ] ; s. antusch and s. f. king , hep - ph/0405093 . for reviews of earlier literature
see , a. pilaftsis , phys .
* d 56 * , 5431 ( 1997 ) ; t. hambye , arxiv : hep - ph/0412053 ; for a general discussion of the connection between leptogenesis and seesaw parameters , see v. barger , d. a. dicus , h - j .
he and t. li , hep - ph/0310278 . for the case of quasi - degenerate right
handed neutrinjos , see m. flanz , e. a. paschos and u. sarkar , phys .
b345 * , 248 ( 1995 ) . c. s. lam , hep - ph/0104116 ; t. kitabayashi and m. yasue , phys.rev . *
d67 * 015006 ( 2003 ) ; w. grimus and l. lavoura , hep - ph/0305046 ; 0309050 ; y. koide , phys.rev .
* d69 * , 093001 ( 2004 ) ; for examples of such theories , see w. grimus and l. lavoura , hep - ph/0305046 ; 0309050
. r. n. mohapatra , slac summer inst .
lecture ; http://www-conf.slac.stanford.edu/ssi/2004 ; hep - ph/0408187 ; jhep , * 0410 * , 027 ( 2004 ) ; w. grimus , a. s.joshipura , s. kaneko , l. lavoura , h. sawanaka , m. tanimoto , hep - ph/0408123 .
k. anderson _
et al . _ ,
arxiv : hep - ex/0402041 ; m. apollonio _ et al .
_ , eur . phys .
j.c * 27 * , 331 ( 2003 ) arxiv : hep - ex/0301017 ; m. v. diwan _ et al .
_ , phys .
d * 68 * , 012002 ( 2003 ) arxiv : hep - ph/0303081 ; d. ayrea et al .
hep - ex/0210005 ; y. itow et al .
( t2k collaboration ) hep - ex/0106019 ; i. ambats _ et al . _
( nova collaboration ) , fermilab - proposal-0929 ; m. goodman , hep - ph/0501206 . | we show that in theories where neutrino masses arise from type i seesaw formula with three right handed neutrinos and where large atmospheric mixing angle owes its origin to an approximate leptonic @xmath0 interchange symmetry , the primordial lepton asymmetry of the universe , @xmath1 can be expressed in a simple form in terms of low energy neutrino oscillation parameters as @xmath2 , where @xmath3 and @xmath4 are parameters characterizing high scale physics and are each of order @xmath5 ev@xmath6 .
we also find that for the case of two right handed neutrinos , @xmath7 as a result of which , the observed value of baryon to photon ratio implies a lower limit on @xmath8 . for specific choices of the cp phase @xmath9 we find @xmath8
is predicted to be between @xmath10 . |
photons are excellent information carriers in nature , and generally pass through each other without consequence .
the realization of coherent manipulation and controlling of photons allows us to achieve photon quantum information processing @xcite as well as to explore exotic many - body phenomena of photons @xcite .
cavity array mjhf08,aah12,ss13,img14,cn17 , in which each single - mode cavity interacts with a two - level atom , is a promising platform to accomplish the required target and has now been considered extensively adg06,mfa06,mjh07,dga07,mim08,ss09,jk09,kt13,gk13,kkm13,sf14,bb14,mb15,zy15,ks15,ms16,hmj16,am16,alch16 . on one hand , this platform has a novel interplay between strong local nonlinearities and photon hopping of the nearest - neighbor cavities , which has a phenomenological analogy to those of the bose - hubbard model mpa89 realized , for example , by ultracold atoms in optical lattices ib08 .
more importantly , compared with the condensed - matter or atomic physics , cavity array has a unique property that the fundamental many - body phenomena depend crucially on the intrinsic atom - photon coupling strength @xcite . for the weak and moderately - strong coupling regimes ,
the counter - rotating terms of the single - site hamiltonian are usually neglected by employing the rotating - wave approximation . as a result
, the property of cavity array is governed by a jaynes - cummings - lattice model mjhf08,aah12,ss13,img14,cn17 .
since this jaynes - cummings - lattice model preserves a global excitation number , a series of mott insulator ( mi ) phase of photons form a lobe structure and a second - order superfluid(sf)-mi phase transition take place across the edge of each lobe .
this mott - lobe structure makes it a photonic counterpart of the bose - hubbard model @xcite , which simulates massive bosons in lattice and also supports a similar lobe structure .
however , it should be noticed that a complete description of the light - matter interaction should always incorporate the counter - rotating terms , especially considering the fact that recent experiments of circuit quantum electrodynamics ( qed ) have accessed the ultrastrong coupling regime ( i.e. , the atom - photon coupling strength has the same order of the photon frequency ) @xcite , in which the rotating - wave approximation totally breaks down .
in such a case , a proper description of the system dynamics should resort to a rabi - lattice model . since the counter - rotating terms in the rabi - lattice model breaks the conservation of excitation number
, there is , in principle , no similar mi as that of the bose - hubbard model and the transition between the sf and mi should be replaced by the coherent and incoherent type @xcite .
these essential changes of equilibrium properties motivate us to ask a question : could the mott - lobe structure still exist even though all of the counter - rotating terms of the atom - photon coupling are taken into consideration ? in the present paper ,
we try to answer this question by constructing a new type of cavity array , in each cavity of which multiple two - level atoms interact with two independent photon modes .
this system can be totally governed by a two - mode dicke - lattice ( tmdl ) model , which includes all of the counter - rotating terms and therefore works well in the ultrastrong coupling regime . unlike the rabi - lattice model
, the tmdl model has a global conserved excitation and a continuous @xmath0 symmetry .
this distinct change of symmetry via adding an extra photon mode induces some interesting many - body physics of strongly - correlated photons .
specifically , the atom - photon interaction features stable mott - lobe structures of photons and a second - order sf - mi phase transition , which share similarities with the jaynes - cummings - lattice @xcite and bose - hubbard @xcite models .
however , in contrast to these models , the mott - lobe structures predicted here depend crucially on the atom number of each site , reflecting its particularity among lattice models .
we also show that the tmdl model can be mapped into a continuous @xmath2 spin model under proper parameter conditions .
finally , motivated by recent experimental achievements of cavity array @xcite and multimode cavity mm11,nms15,dcm15 in circuit qed , we propose a scheme to realize the tmdl model in a two - mode superconducting stripline cavity array .
this work broadens our understanding of strongly - correlated photons .
we study a photon lattice system composed by an array of identical coupled cavities , inside each of which multiple two - level atoms interact with two degenerate photon modes .
such a system is governed by the tmdl hamiltonian @xmath3where the single - site hamiltonian @xmath4 . \notag\end{aligned}\]]in the hamiltonians ( [ tmdm ] ) and ( [ tdh ] ) , @xmath5 and @xmath6 are the creation and annihilation operators of the @xmath7th photon mode of site @xmath8 , @xmath9 @xmath10 , with @xmath11 being the pauli spin operator , is the collective spin operator of site @xmath8 , @xmath12 is the frequency of the degenerate photon modes , @xmath13 is the atom resonant frequency , @xmath14 is the atom - photon coupling strength , @xmath15 is the hopping rate , and @xmath16 denotes the photon hopping between the nearest - neighbor sites @xmath8 and @xmath17 .
an intriguing feature of the hamiltonian ( [ tdh ] ) is that the spin operator couples to the two independent photon modes via its two orthogonal components @xmath18 and @xmath19 , respectively . without the coupling term @xmath20
, the hamiltonian ( [ tdh ] ) reduces to the standard dicke model @xmath21and the corresponding hamiltonian ( [ tmdm ] ) is thus called the dicke - lattice model @xcite ( rabi - lattice model for @xmath22 hz11,msch12,msch13,tf16,bs13 , with @xmath23 being the atom number of each site ) . obviously , since the rotating - wave approximation is not employed , the tmdl model is able to completely describe potential effects arising from the counter - rotating terms and is therefore reasonable in the ultrastrong coupling regime , which has been achieved in current experiments of circuit qed @xcite .
the emergence of the so - called counter - rotating terms in the dicke hamiltonian ( [ stand ] ) reduces the conservation of its excitation number , @xmath24 @xmath25 , to a parity @xmath26 .
however , by introducing an extra degenerate photon mode @xmath27 , the hamiltonian ( [ tdh ] ) exhibits a special conserved excitation @xcite , @xmath28 , apart from the known conserved parity @xcite , even if the rotating - wave approximation is not applied .
when the photon hopping is triggered on , this conserved local excitation @xmath29 is replaced by a global one , @xmath30which manifests the @xmath0 symmetry of the hamiltonian ( [ tmdm ] ) .
the conserved global excitation @xmath31 and its induced @xmath0 symmetry distinguish the tmdl model from the standard dicke - lattice model ( with a discrete @xmath1 symmetry and without conserved excitation ) .
this complete change of symmetry are expected to deeply impact the behavior of strongly - correlated photons .
since the knowledge of the single - site limit is crucial for a further understanding of many - body physics , before proceeding , we first catch some instructive insights into the hamiltonian ( [ tdh ] ) . in the absence of the photon hopping ( @xmath32 ) , the excitation density @xmath29 commutes with the hamiltonian
( [ tmdm ] ) and each eigenstate is thus characterized by a certain excitation number . with an increasing of the system parameter
, the level - crossings of the lowest eigenstates are expected to take place , switching a definite excitation density of the ground state .
armed with this argument , we plot the ground - state mean excitation density , @xmath33 , of the single - site hamiltonian ( [ tdh ] ) as a function of @xmath34 in fig .
[ meanexcitationg ] .
the evolution of @xmath35 reflects a conspicuous staircase , whose jump points are associated with the crossover points of the lowest energy levels . for @xmath22 , @xmath35 remains a constant , whereas when increasing @xmath23 , the staircase appears and becomes more and more crowded , showing that the level crossing occurs only for @xmath36 .
this property is totally different from the standard dicke model ( [ stand ] ) , where no staircase can be found for any @xmath23 [ see the insert part of fig .
[ meanexcitationg ] ] , due to the nonconservation of its excitation density @xmath37 .
we now pay attention to the tmdl hamiltonian ( [ tmdm ] ) . by applying a mean - field decoupling approximation @xcite
, i.e. , @xmath38 , the many - body hamiltonian ( tmdm ) reduces to an effective mean - field hamiltonian@xmath39 , \label{hmf}\]]where @xmath40 denotes the number of nearest neighbors , and @xmath41 ( @xmath42 ) is the variational sf order parameter , which is taken to be real for simplicity @xcite .
@xmath43 can be determined self - consistently by minimizing the ground - state energy @xmath44 of the mean - field hamiltonian ( [ hmf ] ) adg06 .
the effective mean - field hamiltonian ( [ hmf ] ) reveals an intimate connections between the single - site hamiltonian ( [ tdh ] ) and the many - body properties . in general , even though the global excitation @xmath45 is a conserved quantity , the excitation number @xmath29 of each site does not conserve , due to the photon hopping .
however , as shown in the hamiltonian ( [ hmf ] ) , if both @xmath46 and @xmath47 vanish , the system dynamics is dominated by the single - site hamiltonian ( [ tdh ] ) , and the photons at each site are thus effectively frozen and characterized by a specific excitation number @xmath35 .
we accordingly denote this case as a mi phase , in which the @xmath0 symmetry is preserved . whereas a @xmath0 symmetry - broken phase , associated with the breaking of the conservation of @xmath48 , is symbolized by a nonzero value of @xmath43 and
can be anticipated across a critical hopping rate @xmath49 . in this condition ,
the photon mode @xmath7 governs a macroscopic coherence over the lattice and we have a sf phase of the mode @xmath7 .
it was generally believed that the complete inclusion of the counter - rotating terms would demolish the mi phase since they couple states with different numbers of the dressed photons and therefore inhibit the formation of photon blockade , which is crucially necessary for the mi phase @xcite .
in such a case , the notion sf / mi should be replaced by coherent / incoherent .
nevertheless , the tmdl model we introduced here offers a superb exception @xmath50 although still breaking the conventional conservation of @xmath37 , the counter - rotating terms in the tmdl model preserve the hybridized two - mode excitation @xmath29 , attributed to the special atom - photon coupling scheme in the hamiltonian ( [ tdh ] ) , and thus retain the possibility to form the sf - mi phase transition .
, of the two - mode dicke model ( [ tdh ] ) as functions of @xmath51 for different @xmath23 .
inset : the mean excitation densities , @xmath52 , of the standard dicke model . in these figures , we set @xmath53 . ,
width=302 ] based on above considerations , we plot the ground - state phase diagram in the @xmath54 plane for different @xmath23 in fig .
these results show two typical phases : the @xmath0 symmetry - preserved mi with @xmath55 and the symmetry - broken sf with nonzero @xmath46 and @xmath47 . a further analysis of @xmath43 near the critical point demonstrates that the transition between these two phases is of second order .
according to the landau s theory @xcite , the phase boundary of such a continuous transition can be obtained by a perturbation method , in which the ground - state energy @xmath56 is expanded up to second order in @xmath43 @xcite .
we expand @xmath57 of the @xmath35th mi phase around the critical value of the order parameter @xmath58 .
the expanded ground - state energy in powers of @xmath59 reads @xmath60where the second - order energy correction @xmath61the coefficients @xmath62 and @xmath63 in eq .
( [ ent ] ) are derived from the second - order perturbation theory by @xmath64and@xmath65 } { % 2(e_{n}^{(0)}-e_{k}^{(0)})}. \label{tn}\]]where @xmath66 and @xmath67 arise from the eigenequation @xmath68 .
the critical hopping rate @xmath69 can be obtained by the following procedure .
( i ) we first write a @xmath70 hessian matrix in terms of eq .
( [ ent ] ) , i.e. , @xmath71 , and then derive its two eigenvalues @xmath72 and @xmath73 .
( ii ) these two eigenvalues generate two equations , @xmath74 and @xmath75 , with respect to @xmath15 .
each of these equations , say @xmath76 , supports a trivial solution @xmath77 and a nontrivial solution @xmath78 .
( iii ) the critical transition point is finally given by@xmath79 the obtained boundaries are shown by the black solid curves in fig . [ tg ] .
the most important finding , as expected , is that the missing mott lobes in the standard dicke - lattice model @xcite ( see the red dashed curve in fig . [ tg ] ) reappear .
more interestingly , our predicted mott - lobe structure depends crucially on the atom number @xmath23 , which has no counterpart in the jaynes - cummings - lattice mjhf08,aah12,ss13,img14,cn17 and bose - hubbard @xcite models ( note that the @xmath23-dependent phase diagram for the tavis - cummings - lattice , which is nothing but the dicke - lattice after the rotating - wave approximation , has been investigated previously @xcite . in that case , the atom number @xmath23 only slightly shifts the phase boundary of each lobe , rather than its total structure ) . specifically , when @xmath22 , the atom - photon coupling features only a single mott lobe , as shown in fig . [ tg](a ) . with the increasing of @xmath23 ,
however , more and more mott lobes emerge , as shown in figs .
[ tg](b)-[tg](d ) .
this @xmath23-dependent behavior of the mott lobes is a direct legacy of the @xmath23-dependent staircase of @xmath35 governed by the single - site hamiltonian ( [ tdh ] ) .
in fact , since in the mi phase , the mean - field hamiltonian ( [ hmf ] ) equals to the single - site hamiltonian ( [ tdh ] ) , there exists a one - to - one correspondence between fig .
meanexcitationg and fig .
[ tg ] . as a result , each mott lobe is specified by a definite mean excitation density @xmath35 . ) in the @xmath54 plane ,
when ( a ) @xmath22 , ( b ) @xmath80 , ( c ) @xmath81 , and ( d ) @xmath82 .
the mi phase is characterized by its lobes , each of which supports a constant mean excitation density @xmath83 . for a comparison ,
the phase boundaries of the dicke - lattice model are also shown by the red - dashed curves . in these figures ,
we set @xmath53.,width=302 ] we emphasize that in the tmdl model , on the one hand , no chemical potential is needed to engineer the mott lobes , which is here stabilized by the atom - photon coupling instead @xcite .
this is in sharp contrast to both the cases of the jaynes - cummings - lattice mjhf08,aah12,ss13,img14,cn17 and bose - hubbard @xcite models , which are often studied within the framework of grand canonical ensemble where a chemical potential is introduced to fix the ( conserved ) number of excitations on the lattice @xcite . on the other hand , the standard dicke- or rabi - lattice model
does not support any conserved excitations , due to the inclusion of the counter - rotating terms . this makes the description of grand canonical ensemble irrelevant to some extent and no well - defined chemical potential thus exists @xcite .
however , the conserved excitation in the tmdl model motivates us to introduce a chemical potential @xmath84 and access a theory of grand canonical ensemble .
we now extend eq .
( [ tmdm ] ) to the following hamiltonian in grand canonical ensemble : @xmath85where the on - site two - mode dicke hamiltonian becomes @xmath86 .
following the same mean - field theory , we plot the phase diagram in the @xmath87 plane in fig . excitationmu . as shown in fig .
[ excitationmu](a ) , the engineered chemical potential @xmath84 still features the mott lobes , which is a direct analog of those of the bose - hubbard model @xcite .
once again , a clear interpretation of this lobe structure is still based on the dynamics of the single - site limit , which is governed by the hamiltonian @xmath88 . as the chemical potential couples to a conserved quantity @xmath89 in the hamiltonian @xmath90 , the eigenstates are independent of @xmath84 , due to the simultaneous diagonalization of @xmath91 and @xmath29 .
thus , the ground - state competition leads to a staircase behavior of the excitation density @xmath29 when varying @xmath84 , as shown in fig .
[ excitationmu](b ) . and accordingly , each mott lobe in fig .
[ excitationmu](a ) is characterized by the corresponding plateaux . ) in the @xmath92 plane and ( b ) the corresponding mean excitation density , @xmath83 , of the single - site limit as a function of @xmath93 . in these figures , we set @xmath94 and @xmath22.,width=302 ]
it has been well established that the jaynes - cummings - lattice model , respecting a @xmath0 symmetry , can be mapped to a continuous @xmath2 spin model ( the isotropic @xmath95 spin model ) @xcite , whereas the rabi - lattice model with the counter - rotating terms has been demonstrated to be in the ising universality class , owing to its discrete @xmath1 symmetry msch12,msch13,bs13 .
as revealed in this paper , however , the inclusion of the counter - rotating terms does not always break the continuous symmetry .
especially , for our tmdl model , the @xmath0 symmetry associated with the conserved excitation number is a signature of its intimate connection with the continuous spin model . to confirm this argument , we focus on the system dynamics in the @xmath54 plane , which is governed by the hamiltonian ( [ tmdm ] ) .
we first consider the case of @xmath96 , which supports a multi - lobe structure in the phase diagram .
when parameters are tuned close to the degenerate point in the mi phase with @xmath97 , i.e. , the boundary between two nearest mott lobes , we can truncate the hilbert space to two of the excitation number eigenstates @xmath98 and @xmath99 , where @xmath98 denotes the eigenstate of the excitation density @xmath89 with eigenvalue @xmath35 ( as verified numerically below , @xmath35 varies only by one across the degenerate point ) . utilizing the commutation relations between the photon annihilation operator @xmath6 and the excitation number @xmath29 , we can map @xmath6 in the reduced hilbert space @xmath100 into @xmath101where @xmath102 and @xmath103 are the redefined pauli spin ladder operators , and the coefficients @xmath104 and @xmath105
can be determined numerically ( see appendix a for details ) .
therefore , the effective spin hamiltonian of the tmdl model reads @xmath106where @xmath107 is the energy gap between the two states @xmath98 and @xmath99 and acts as a longitudinal field , and @xmath108 is the isotropic exchange interaction . as expected , we reproduce the continuous @xmath2 model even taking the counter - rotating terms into account .
we now turn to the special case of @xmath22 , where only a single mott lobe exists . in this case , the mapping procedure of @xmath96 can not be employed directly . however , similar to ref .
@xcite , the energy gap between the two lowest energy levels is of higher - order small , compared with the gap to the next energy level in the ultrastrong coupling regime , and the numerical calculation verifies that these two lowest levels are still characterized by two nearest excitation numbers @xmath35 and @xmath109 ( see appendix b ) .
based on these facts , in the ultrastrong coupling regime , we can still obtain the effective hamiltonian ( [ hspin ] ) in the subspace spanned by the two lowest energy levels . .
( b ) the effective circuit diagram of each element .
the fabricated artificial atom ( black dashed line ) is assumed to be placed at a point , which is labeled by the superscript @xmath110 of the flux.,width=283 ]
having revealed some striking features of the two - mode cavity array , we now turn to the experimental implementation of the hamiltonian ( [ tmdm ] ) .
motivated by recent experimental achievements of cavity array jr14,ce14,mf16 and multimode cavity @xcite in circuit qed , we propose a scheme , depicted in fig .
[ striplinecircuit ] , to implement the tmdl model . as shown in fig .
[ striplinecircuit](a ) , the structure we consider is a series of identical circuit qed elements coupled through capacities .
each of these elements simulates the single - site two - mode dicke model ( [ tdh ] ) and the capacitive coupling gives rise to the photon hopping of different elements .
the effective circuit diagram of each element is shown in fig .
[ striplinecircuit](b ) . a josephson junction , acting as an artificial two - level atom ,
is coupled to two different superconducting stripline resonators .
we first focus on the circuit qed element labeled in fig .
striplinecircuit(a ) with @xmath22 . according to the theory of circuit qed , we can regard the flux @xmath111 and the charge @xmath112 as the canonical coordinate and momentum , respectively . in this sense , the lagrangian of a circuit qed element in fig .
[ striplinecircuit](b ) is written as @xmath113 -\sum_{i}\frac{(\phi _ { b}^{i-1}-\phi _ { b}^{i})^{2}}{2l_{b } } \label{lag } \\ & & -\sum_{i\neq s}\left [ \frac{(\phi _ { a}^{i-1}-\phi _ { a}^{i})^{2}}{2l_{a}}-% \frac{(\phi _ { f})^{2}}{2l_{1}}-\frac{(\phi _ { f}-\phi _ { j})^{2}}{2l_{2}}-% \frac{(\phi _ { a}^{s-1}-\phi _ { a}^{s}-\phi _ { f}+\phi _ { j})^{2}}{2l_{a}}\right ] -e_{j}\cos \left ( \frac{\phi _ { j}+\phi _ { ext}}{\phi _ { 0}}\right ) , \notag\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath114 and @xmath115 is the external flux of the josephson junction .
notice that in deriving eq .
( lag ) , the relation @xmath116 has been used .
moreover , in terms of the kirchoff s law at the point , there exists an extra constraint relation @xmath117 , where @xmath118 . using @xmath119
, we obtain the expression of @xmath120 in terms of @xmath121 , i.e. , @xmath122and@xmath123where @xmath124 . by means of eqs .
( [ lag])-([ph2 ] ) , together with the relation between the lagrangian and the hamiltonian , we expand the hamiltonian of the circuit qed element as a sum of three contributions , i.e. , @xmath125 in eq .
( [ hcq1 ] ) , the hamiltonian of the stripline resonator is given by @xmath126 \notag \\ & & + \left ( \frac{\tilde{c}_{g}+c_{j}}{2c_{\sigma } } -\frac{1}{2c_{b}}\right ) ( q_{b}^{s})^{2}-\frac{(q_{a}^{s})^{2}}{2c_{a } } \notag \\ & & + \left ( \frac{\tilde{l}_{s}}{2l_{\sigma } ^{2}l_{2}l_{a}}-\frac{1}{2l_{a}}% \right ) ( \phi _ { a}^{s}-\phi _ { a}^{s-1})^{2}. \label{hcq1a}\end{aligned}\]]since the last three terms in the hamiltonian ( [ hcq1a ] ) do not involve a sum over sites , their contributions can be neglected in the continuous limit , where the number of the sites becomes infinite . based on this consideration , we obtain@xmath127 .
\notag\end{aligned}\]]the hamiltonian of the artificial atom reads @xmath128the interaction between the artificial atom and the resonator is governed by the hamiltonian@xmath129 in eqs .
( [ hcq1a])-([hcq1c ] ) , @xmath130 , @xmath131 , and @xmath132 .
we thus take the continuous limit of the canonical parameters in the superconducting stripline resonators , i.e. , @xmath133 and @xmath134 , and then promote them to quantum operators obeying the canonical commutation relation @xmath135 = i\delta ( x - y)\delta _ { m , n}$ ] . following the standard quantization procedure in circuit qed @xcite ,
the quantized canonical parameters are expressed as @xmath136 @xmath137 where @xmath138 is the eigenfrequency , @xmath139 is the length of the resonator , and @xmath140 and @xmath141 are odd and even integers , respectively .
when the external flux is set to @xmath142 , the two - level approximation of the josephson junction gives that @xcite @xmath143and @xmath144with @xmath145 , where @xmath13 is the resonant frequency of the two - level system , @xmath146 and @xmath147 are the two lowest macroscopic states of the hamiltonian @xmath148 , and @xmath149 ( @xmath150 ) is the pauli spin operator spanned by these two macroscopic states .
at low temperature , we only keep the mode resonate with the artificial atom ( i.e. , @xmath151 ) and neglect other non - resonate terms . under this single - mode approximation of the resonator and the two - level approximation of the artificial atom ,
the hamiltonian of the considered circuit qed element is finally expressed as@xmath152where @xmath153@xmath154@xmath155@xmath156the tunability of the inductance and the capacitance of the two superconducting stipline resonators allows us to set @xmath157 and @xmath158 , under which the hamiltonian ( [ hs ] ) reduces to the single - site two - mode rabi model . using the same procedure ,
the hamiltonian ( [ hs ] ) can be extended straightforwardly to the case with several two - level artificial atoms , i.e. , the single - site two - mode dicke hamiltonian ( [ tdh ] ) . when a series of such circuit qed elements are coupled capacitively with the hopping rate @xmath15
[ see fig .
striplinecircuit(a ) ] , the tmdl hamiltonian ( [ tmdm ] ) can be achieved .
we emphasize that the improvement of current experimental techniques in the ultrastrong - coupling circuit qed @xcite makes our proposal a promising candidate to exhibit relevant physics of the tmdl model .
up to now , our discussions are restricted to the case of the degenerate photon modes ( @xmath159 ) and the equal atom - photon coupling strengths ( @xmath160 ) .
if these conditions are not fulfilled , there would not be a strict conservation law of @xmath31 , and an instructive question is whether the mott - lobe structure still exists in such a case or not . to briefly show the influence of a slight deviation of these two equalities , @xmath159 and @xmath160
, we plot the phase diagrams in the @xmath54 plane for different @xmath161 [ fig .
[ deviphase](a ) ] or @xmath162 [ fig .
[ deviphase](b ) ] , when @xmath80 .
it can be seen clearly from these figures that a slight deviation of the ideal condition does not break the mott - lobe structure but merely shift the phase boundary .
( black solid curve ) , @xmath163 ( red dashed curve ) , @xmath164 ( blue dotted - dashed curve ) , and @xmath165 ( green dotted curve ) , when @xmath166 .
( b ) phase boundaries for @xmath167 ( black solid curve ) , @xmath168 ( red dashed curve ) , @xmath169 ( blue dotted - dashed curve ) , and @xmath170 ( green dotted curve ) , when @xmath171 . in these figures , we set @xmath80.,width=298 ]
in summary , we have constructed a new type of cavity array system , which is governed by the tmdl model .
this model incorporates all of the counter - rotating terms of the atom - photon coupling and therefore works well in the ultrastrong coupling regime achieved in recent experiments . unlike the standard dicke - lattice model
, the tmdl has a global conserved excitation and a continuous @xmath0 symmetry .
this distinct change of symmetry strongly impacts the nature of photon localization / delocalization behavior . specifically , the atom - photon interaction features mott - lobe structures of photons and a second - order sf - mi phase transition , which share similarities with the jaynes - cummings - lattice and bose - hubbard models .
however , the mott - lobe structures predicted here depend crucially on the atom number of each site , reflecting its particularity among lattice models .
we have also shown that the tmdl model can be mapped into a continuous @xmath2 spin model under proper parameter conditions .
finally , we have proposed an experimentally - feasible scheme to realize the tmdl model in a two - mode superconducting stripline cavity array .
this work is supported partly by the nsfc under grants no . 11422433 , no .
11674200 , no .
11604392 , no . 11434007 , and no .
61378049 ; the fanedd under grant no .
201316 ; sfsssp ; oytpsp ; and sscc .
we first notice that the commutation relations between the photon annihilation operator and the excitation number operator satisfy @xmath173 = \hat{a}_{2,j}$ ] and @xmath174 = \hat{a}_{1,j}$ ] . taking these two equations into account ,
the matrix elements of @xmath175 and @xmath176 in the basis of the excitation eigenstates @xmath98 and @xmath177 are expressed respectively as@xmath178 \left\vert m\right\rangle \\ & = & ( m - n)\left\langle n\right\vert \hat{a}_{1,j}+\hat{a}_{2,j}\left\vert m\right\rangle , \notag \\
\left\langle n\right\vert a_{1,j}\!\!-\!\!a_{2,j}\left\vert m\right\rangle & = & -\left\langle n\right\vert \left [ \hat{a}_{1,j}\!-\!\hat{a}_{2,j},n_{e , j}\right ] \left\vert m\right\rangle \\ & = & ( n - m)\left\langle n\right\vert \hat{a}_{1,j}-\hat{a}_{2,j}\left\vert m\right\rangle .
\notag\end{aligned}\]]to obtain a nonzero value of @xmath179 ( @xmath180 ) , we should have @xmath181 ( @xmath182 ) , and in the reduced hilbert space @xmath183 , the operators @xmath175 and @xmath176 thus read@xmath184from which we can straightforwardly obtain @xmath185 @xmath186 and @xmath187 @xmath188 , i.e. , eq .
( [ op ] ) of the main text .
the coefficients @xmath104 and @xmath105 can be determined numerically .
figure [ tocd_energylevel ] shows the low - lying spectrum of the hamiltonian ( [ tdh ] ) with @xmath22 , from which we can see clearly that the two lowest energy levels become quasi - degenerate in the ultrastrong coupling regime .
moreover , as shown in the inset of this figure , both of these two levels support the well - defined excitation numbers , whose difference remains one .
this guarantees the validity of the truncation of the hilbert space to an effective two state subspace @xmath183 for a large @xmath190 .
k. kamide , m. yamaguchi , t. kimura , and t. ogawa , first - order superfluid - mott - insulator transition for quantum - optical switching in cavity - qed arrays with two cavity modes , phys .
a * 87 * , 053842 ( 2013 ) .
y. zhang , j. fan , j. -q .
liang , j. ma , g. chen , s. jia , and f. nori , photon devil s staircase : photon long - range repulsive interaction in lattices of coupled resonators with rydberg atoms , sci .
rep . * 5 * , 11510 ( 2015 ) .
t. niemczyk , f. deppe , h. huebl , e. p. menzel , f. hocke , m. j. schwarz , j. j. garca - ripoll , d. zueco , t. hmmer , e. solano , a. marx , and r. gross , circuit quantum electrodynamics in the ultrastrong - coupling regime , nat . phys .
* 6 * , 772 ( 2010 ) .
p. forn - daz , j. lisenfeld , d. marcos , j. j. garca - ripoll , e. solano , c. j. p.
m. harmans , and j. e. mooij , observation of the bloch - siegert shift in a qubit - oscillator system in the ultrastrong coupling regime , phys .
lett . * 105 * , 237001 ( 2010 ) .
p. forn - daz , j. j. garca - ripoll , b. peropadre , j .- l .
orgiazzi , m. a. yurtalan , r. belyansky , c. m. wilson , and a. lupascu , ultrastrong coupling of a single artificial atom to an electromagnetic continuum in the nonperturbative regime , nat .
doi:10.1038/nphys3905 ( 2016 ) .
m. mariantoni , h. wang , r. c. bialczak , m. lenander , e. lucero , m. neeley , a. d. oconnell , d. sank , m. weides , j. wenner , t. yamamoto , y. yin , j. zhao , j. m. martinis , and a. n. cleland , photon shell game in three - resonator circuit quantum electrodynamics , nat . phys . * 7 * , 287 ( 2011 ) .
a. blais , r .- s .
huang , a. wallraff , s. m. girvin , and r. j. schoelkopf , cavity quantum electrodynamics for superconducting electrical circuits : an architecture for quantum computation , phys .
a * 69 * , 062320 ( 2004 ) . | in this paper we construct a new type of cavity array , in each cavity of which multiple two - level atoms interact with two independent photon modes .
this system can be totally governed by a two - mode dicke - lattice model , which includes all of the counter - rotating terms and therefore works well in the ultrastrong coupling regime achieved in recent experiments . attributed to its special atom - photon coupling scheme , this model supports a global conserved excitation and a continuous @xmath0 symmetry , rather than the discrete @xmath1 symmetry in the standard dicke - lattice model .
this distinct change of symmetry via adding an extra photon mode strongly impacts the nature of photon localization / delocalization behavior .
specifically , the atom - photon interaction features stable mott - lobe structures of photons and a second - order superfluid - mott - insulator phase transition , which share similarities with the jaynes - cummings - lattice and bose - hubbard models .
more interestingly , the mott - lobe structures predicted here depend crucially on the atom number of each site .
we also show that our model can be mapped into a continuous @xmath2 spin model .
finally , we propose a scheme to implement the introduced cavity array in circuit quantum electrodynamics .
this work broadens our understanding of strongly - correlated photons . |
the dynamical control of the transport properties of dirac fermions in the condensed matter realm is currently an intense research topic .
these dirac fermions have been shown to emerge as the low energy excitations of two - dimensional systems with a honeycomb lattice structure as it occurs in graphene @xcite .
recent theoretical@xcite and experimental@xcite works have discussed the role of radiation fields in the manipulation of the transport properties of monolayer graphene samples . by focusing on the terahertz frequency regime particular attention
is paid to the tunability of the induced band gaps .
in addition , the possibility of generating topological insulating behavior was theoretically put forward both in the static@xcite and dynamical regimes.@xcite in presence of a perpendicular quantizing magnetic field @xmath0 , the static spectrum of single layer graphene posseses a @xmath1 field dependence which strikingly contrasts the linear @xmath2 dependence for conventional non relativistic @xcite .
in addition , the @xmath3 landau level ( ll ) has only one sublattice occupied at each dirac point . considering the ll scenario and a topological contribution given by an excitonic gap the authors of reference @xcite predict the appearance of rabi oscillations when the system s initial quantum state is prepared by means of a short electric pulse and the subsequent dynamics
is controlled by the oscillations between the dynamically coupled ll . in this work
we theoretically analyze the dynamical manipulation of the ll structure of charge carriers on suspended monolayer graphene when a periodically driving radiation field is applied perpendicular to the sample .
a similar set up was proposed in reference@xcite , where a gaussian laser pulse is introduced via the dipolar approximation . in that work
, the authors discuss the dynamics of _ zitterbewegung _ which is described in terms of the radiation field emmited by the accelerated charge carriers in graphene . in our proposal
we consider a continuous laser field and thus make use of floquet s theorem to recast the dynamics in an explicitly time - independent fashion but without need to resort to infinite - dimensional fourier - mode expansion .
our approach has the advantage of providing an analytical description of the driven evolution of relevant physical quantities as the pseudospin polarization which is a measure of the angular momentum exchange among the charge carriers and the radiation field@xcite . in the following we
explicitly show how our semi analytical results are relevant at high values of the quantizing magnetic field @xmath2 , where the coupling to the radiation field leads to non trivial qualitative modifications of the dynamical behavior of relevant physical quantities within the perturbative regime . to the best of our knowledge ,
our work constitutes the first approach to the photoinduced modulation of the landau level structure in single - layer graphene in presence of an intense and continuously applied laser field .
however , we would like to mention that a recent work@xcite has addressed the role of intense radiation field . yet
, the authors of this work consider a quantized radiation field and do not address the landau level structure scenario in single - layer graphene .
the paper is organized as follows . in section
ii we present the model and summarize the perturbative results for the quasienergy spectrum . in section iii
we study the dynamics of the autocorrelation function and pseudospin polarization for two initially prepared states .
first we consider an eigenstate of the static hamiltonian that has vanishing pseudospin polarization in the static regime .
next , we present the same analysis for an initially prepared coherent state , with static finite pseudospin polarization and highlight the main differences with respect to the other initial configuration . in section
iv we discuss our main results and in section v we present concluding remarks and argue on the experimental implementation of our proposed theoretical setup .
finally , in the appendix we summarize some mathematical calculations arising during the perturbative analysis .
in this section we focus on the low energy properties of non interacting spinless charge carriers in a suspended monolayer graphene subject to a perpendicular , uniform and constant magnetic field @xmath0 .
the dynamics is governed by dirac s hamiltonian .
in coordinate representation it reads @xmath4 where @xmath5 is the fermi velocity in graphene .
in addition , the canonical momenta @xmath6 ( @xmath7 ) contain the vector potential ( @xmath8 ) , @xmath9 is the electronic charge ( @xmath10 ) , and @xmath11 describes the valley degree of freedom . using the definition of the magnetic length @xmath12 and the cyclotron energy @xmath13 the hamiltonian eq .
( [ dirac ] ) at each k ( k ) dirac point , which corresponds to @xmath14 ( @xmath15 ) , can be written in the form @xmath16 where the annihilation and creation operators are defined by standard relations as @xmath17 the eigenenergies of the hamiltonian ( [ dirac ] ) are then @xmath18 with @xmath19 .
positive ( negative ) values of @xmath20 represents the conduction ( valence ) band at each dirac point .
in addition , the integer quantum number @xmath21 labels the landau level ( ll ) structure of monolayer graphene . using the eigenstates @xmath22 of the operator @xmath23 , the corresponding eigenstates @xmath24 read @xmath25 for @xmath26 .
the zero energy eigenstate ( @xmath3 ) is given in each case by @xmath27 due to time - reversal symmetry , we have @xmath28 .
let us now consider the effect of intense circularly polarized terahertz electromagnetic radiation , incident perpendicularly to the sample .
we assume that the beam radiation spot is large enough compared to the lattice spacing so we can neglect any spatial variation .
according to the standard light - matter interaction formulation , the dynamical effects of a monochromatic radiation field incident perpendicular to the sample can be described by means of a time - dependent vector potential @xmath29 where @xmath30 and @xmath31 are respectively the amplitude and frequency of the electric field given in turn by the standard relation @xmath32 .
in addition , we are using @xmath33 ( @xmath34 ) for right ( left ) circular polarization .
we are using circular polarization because it has been shown to provide the maximal photoinduced bandgap@xcite .
starting from the ordinary dipolar interaction term @xmath35 , introduced to the tight - binding hamiltonian via the peierls substitution , we can evaluate the effects of the driving at each dirac point as @xmath36,\ ] ] which explicitly reads @xmath37 with the effective coupling constant @xmath38 .
this makes the total hamiltonian @xmath39 periodic in time @xmath40 , with @xmath41 the period of oscillation of the driving field .
therefore , if we focus on the k dirac point ( @xmath42 ) , the physics at the k dirac point ( @xmath15 ) can be easily found by the substitutions @xmath43 and @xmath44 .
thus , let us focus on the k point physics and afterwards , we can make the necessary substitutions . in order to simplify the notation we set @xmath45 and @xmath46 .
hence , defining rising @xmath47 and lowering @xmath48 pseudospin operators by the standard formulas @xmath49 the time - dependent interaction potential can be rewritten as @xmath50 now we invoke floquet s theorem which states that the time evolution operator of the system induced by a periodic hamiltonian can be written in the form@xcite @xmath51with @xmath52 a periodic unitary matrix and @xmath53 a time - independent dynamical generator referred to as the floquet hamiltonian .
the eigenvalues of the floquet hamiltonian @xmath54 represent the quasienergy spectrum of the periodically driven system . typically , in order to solve for the quasienergy spectrum
, one can expand each term of the time - dependent schrdinger equation in fourier space and numerically solve an infinite eigenvalue problem .
instead , we will take a perturbative approach as discussed below .
+ accordingly , for our problem we can find approximate solutions to the dynamics by modifying slightly the analytical strategy presented in@xcite .
then , one finds that the excitation number operator @xmath55 , defined as @xmath56 which commutes with the hamiltonian @xmath57 and satisfies the eigenvalue equation @xmath58 @xmath55 generates a time - dependent unitary transformation @xmath59 given as @xmath60 such that the time - dependent schrdinger equation @xmath61 can be transformed with a time - independent operator @xmath53 governing the dynamics of the problem @xmath62 where @xmath53 and @xmath63 are the floquet hamiltonian and floquet eigenstate , respectively . doing the explicit calculation ,
@xmath53 is found to be given by @xmath64 in the following we focus on recent experiments in the far infrared frequency domain@xcite for which @xmath65 mev and we consider values of the electric field intensities @xmath66 mv / m .
then one gets for the coupling constant @xmath67 mev which , for frequencies
@xmath31 in the terahertz domain leads to @xmath68 .
this value is an order of magnitude smaller than the landau level separation @xmath69 mev , for @xmath70 t. for larger frequencies and stronger magnetic field intensities , the ratio @xmath71 tends to be smaller .
therefore , we can perform a perturbative treatment in the effective coupling parameter @xmath72 .
+ we should remark that although our radiation field is intense , it is one order of magnitude smaller than the numerical estimates used in reference@xcite for which one gets @xmath73 mv / m .
yet , the experimental setup used in reference @xcite consisted of infrared radiation field with power @xmath74 mw , sample areas equal to @xmath75 and @xmath76 ; thus , one gets electric field intensities of order @xmath77 kv / m , which in turn leads to @xmath78 mev . in this manner
, our perturbative results would allow for an analytical treatment of future experimental extensions of the work described in @xcite , in case they would include a quantizing magnetic field in their study .
it would also allow for larger values of the radiation field intensity with novel photoinduced features in the landau level structure of single- layer graphene as it is described in the following . for this purpose
we transform the hamiltonian ( [ heff ] ) as @xmath79 , where we have introduced the antihermitian operator @xmath80 .
evaluating up to first order we get @xmath81.\ ] ] evaluation of the commutator gives ( in the appendix we summarize the explicit derivations ) @xmath82=-\hbar\omega_c\big[2n_a+\lambda(a^\dagger+a)\big]\sigma_z,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and defining the shifted operator @xmath83 one gets , to leading order in @xmath84 , the effective hamiltonian @xmath85 where we have introduced the shifted number operator @xmath86 in equation ( [ hfin ] ) we have neglected the additive higher order terms @xmath87 which can be dealt with by higher order perturbation theory . thus , the approximate quasienergies are found to be given as @xmath88 which can be rewritten as @xmath89 then , to this order of approximation , all quasienergies corresponding to the @xmath90 ll are shifted , whereas the @xmath91 remains insensitive to the radiation field .
this shift of all but the @xmath91 quasienergy ll spectrum agrees with the result reported in reference @xcite for bilayer graphene . yet
, a more detailed derivation by means of second order perturbation theory shows that there is a small @xmath92 energy correction due to first nondiagonal terms in equation ( [ pert1 ] ) which couple all adjacent ll .
this higher order corrections could be important at low quantizing magnetic fields for which the condition @xmath93 could be satisfied .
+ let us now analyze some physical consequences of the radiation field on the landau level structure of monolayer graphene with focus on the interplay among the quantizing magnetic field and the light - matter interaction . to begin with , we notice that the quasienergies are defined up to multiples of @xmath31 ; therefore , a better physical characterization of the energy spectrum for the driven system is provided by the mean energies@xcite @xmath94 which are invariant under @xmath95 , for @xmath96 being an integer . doing the explicit calculation the mean energies are found to be given by the expression @xmath97 where we remember the definition of the effective coupling to the radiation field as @xmath38 . + as can be seen in fig .
1 , these mean energies are plotted as function of the quantizing magnetic field @xmath2 , for different values of the landau level index changing the effective coupling @xmath98 .
we notice that , at intermediate light - coupling strength , the energy resolution of these levels becomes much better and could experimentally be tested for not so large quantizing magnetic fields @xmath2 .
moreover , we find that to this order of approximation the ll become gapped , with the striking feature that the photoinduced gap is level dependent .
these gap openings appear except for the @xmath91 level which , as discussed before , remains insensitive to the radiation field . +
below we will deal with the photoinduced dynamical features and therefore , we give the corresponding normalized floquet eigenstates for @xmath90 @xmath99 where we have defined the coefficients @xmath100 with @xmath101 .
in addition , the zero energy eigenstate ( @xmath91 ) is still given by @xmath102 , i. e. , @xmath103
now that we have found the approximate floquet eigenstates and quasienergies , we explore other dynamical features of the driven ll configuration by evaluating the mean values of the pseudospin polarization operator and its relation to the autocorrelation function dynamics@xcite . for this purpose ,
let us first assume that the system is initially prepared in an eigenstate of the hamiltonian @xmath57 @xmath104 ) , the initial state is written as @xmath105 taking into account that the @xmath106 states are degenerate eigenstates of @xmath107 , the unitary operator @xmath108 would just contribute a phase @xmath109 . using the hamiltonian ( [ hfin ] ) the evolved state can be written as @xmath110 where we have introduced the time - dependent coefficients @xmath111 .
let us then consider the dynamics for the autocorrelation function and pseudospin polarization @xmath112 operators from which we can respectively infer the feasibility of manipulating the polarization state of the sample and the dipole moment radiation emmited by the driven sample .
it is important to remark at this point that studying the out of plane pseudospin polarization is a means of detecting the angular momentum exchange between the dirac fermions in graphene and the circularly polarized radiation field , as can be inferred from the discussion in the recent literature about the role of @xmath113 in describing the total angular momentum content of the system@xcite .
+ with these ideas in mind , we first begin by evaluating the pseudospin polarization @xmath114 for the chosen initial state we find @xmath115 .
when expression ( [ szt ] ) is evaluated we find after some algebraic manipulations @xmath116 we note that for vanishing values of the coupling to the radiation field @xmath117 one has @xmath115 .
therefore , once the electromagnetic field is present the pseudospin oscillations are a manifestation of the angular momentum exchange among the radiation field and the charge carriers in graphene @xcite .
as discussed in the case of the quasienergies , we could better quantify the effects of the driving field by evaluating the average @xmath118 with the period of the radiation field given as @xmath41 .
then we get the expression @xmath119 with @xmath120 .
+ in figure fig .
[ fig : figure2 ] we plot the behavior of @xmath121 as a function of the coupling strength @xmath98 . at small @xmath122
we see that the closer the state is to the @xmath91 ll the role of the radiation field in modifying its pseudospin polarization is less relevant and this is correlated to the fact that , within this regime , the gap openings seen in the mean quasienergy spectrum are not so noticeable at different values of the @xmath123 ll index .
in addition , at large values of the quantizing field , @xmath124 , the value of the pseudospin polarization is almost the same at each value of the @xmath123 ll index .
however , we see in the second upper panel that already at intermediate values of the relative coupling strentgh @xmath125 that at large values of the quantizing field @xmath126 t one can discern among the different ll polarization value which serves to separate each level contribution to this quantity dynamical behavior . in the lower two panels
we show that this physical picture becomes more obvious at larger values of @xmath98 , with perfect separation for the contribution from the @xmath127 and @xmath128 , levels .
yet , the corresponding @xmath129 and @xmath130 contributions to the pseudospin polarization remain degenerate at large @xmath2 values
. one would expect that this accidental crossings seen as a degeneracy would be removed by including higher order perturbative contributions , since then the coupling among nearby levels would lead to additional splittings in the quasienergy spectrum that would in turn also lift this accidental pseudospin degeneracy . in order to discuss more general dynamical features
, one should consider a superposition state .
however , in order to do so we must take into account the feasibility of experimentally realizing such a superposition state . a paradigmatic case of such interesting superposition states is given by the coherent state which are minimal uncertainty wave packets relevant for studying the classical states of the radiation field in the sense of being a classical counterpart of the quantum harmonic oscillator
since , as in the quantum harmonic oscillator , the landau levels in graphene are eigenstates of the number operator , one should expect that these coherent state superpositions would be interesting .
indeed , there has been recently some proposals to analyze the dynamics of coherent electronic states in graphene nanomechanical resonators @xcite . by taking advantage of the intrinsic non linear nature of flexural modes in graphene , the authors of reference @xcite
show that cat - like@xcite states can be generated .
we follow a different physical approach . instead of resorting to nonlinearities of flexural modes
we invoke the light - matter coupling as a mechanism for studying the evolution of an initially prepared coherent superposition state built from the landau level eigenstates described in section ii and evaluate the induced pseudospin polarization effects in order to contrast to the results shown in fig .
[ fig : figure2 ] . formally speaking
, the coherent state @xmath131 is defined by means of the eigenvalue equation @xmath132 where @xmath133 . using the expansion @xmath134 with @xmath135 representing a summation for all @xmath136 .
assuming , without loss of generality , the symmetric scenario @xmath137 , one finds that the coherent state is given as @xmath138 which can be shown to be normalized .
if we now evaluate the mean value of the hermitian operator @xmath139 in the coherent state and use the definition given in equation ( [ dqla ] ) , we get @xmath140 . in addition , if we use the coherent state to evaluate the average of the number operator @xmath55 defined in equation ( [ excitations ] ) , it is not difficult to show that we also get @xmath141 . therefore , the coherent state parameter amplitude @xmath142 is a measure of the mean number of landau levels that are excited and corresponds to the mean photon number in the context of quantum optics .
thus , we will use it as a control parameter to discuss the properties of the physical quantities as follows . in this case
, we find for the pseudospin polarization @xmath143 this is plotted in fig .
3 for @xmath122 and four representative values of @xmath142 . in this figure
we notice that for small values of @xmath142 the dynamics of the pseudospin polarization resembles the pattern for rabi oscillations since the main contributions would arise for the interference among the zero and first ll . yet
, no polarization inversion can be achieved within this regime .
however , once @xmath144 the contribution from other ll states becomes increasingly important to the interference pattern and the former rabi oscillations become distorted .
moreover , at this value of @xmath142 , one can achieve the polarization inversion for large enough values of time in the long - term evolution . in the lower panels of fig .
4 we find that for larger values ( @xmath145 and @xmath146 ) , we get a beating pattern showing a dynamical localization effect that is directly related to a collective behavior of the driven charge carries in graphene .
we would like to remark that the problem of the population inversion has already been studied long time ago by eberly et al@xcite .
their model corresponds to a two - level system coupled to a single mode radiation field ( jaynes cummings hamiltonian ) . in our approach , this in turn is given by the static graphene hamiltonian for landau levels written in equation ( 2 ) .
a larger value of the coherent state parameter @xmath142 would imply larger mean landau level occupation , and thus the second term in the numerator of the pseudospin polarization given in expression ( 43 ) would have a larger influence in the pseudospin inversion since larger n landau levels would be occupied which will contribute a higher weight in the pseudospin polarization ( see numerator in equation ( 20 ) . moreover , since the effective light - matter coupling strength @xmath98 also affects the phase , as given by the cosine term in equation ( 20 ) of the polarization , this interesting interplay forbids the inversion which is also a signature of the localization and beating effects shown on panels 3(c ) and 3(d ) and our results extend those found in the context of reference@xcite .
this physical picture for the coherent state dynamics can be complemented by studying the autocorrelation function @xmath147 , which is found to be given as @xmath148 the autocorrelation function provides additional physical information of the system since its fourier transform is related to the local density of states@xcite .
its time evolution is plotted in fig .
4 choosing again an effective coupling strength value of @xmath122 and the same values of @xmath149 as in fig .
3 showing the dynamical behavior of the pseudospin polarization . comparing fig.3 and fig .
4 we see that partial revivals for the autocorrelation function are correlated to the beating or localization behavior of the pseudospin polarization . therefore , one could indirectly gain information on the pseudospin dynamics by measuring the time revivals @xcite which means detecting those times for which the wave packet reconstructs itself . in order to show explicitly the role of the driving field we have plotted in fig .
5 the static autocorrelation function . comparing the lower right panels in fig . 4 and fig . 5
, we find that the radiation field induces additional revivals in accordance to the beating pattern in the pseudospin oscillation , as seen in fig.3 .
we have shown that the radiadion field leads to a quasienergy spectrum with a level dependent gap , except for the @xmath91 ll which , to leading order , remains insensitive to the radiation field effects .
in addition , we have found that a finite out of plane pseudospin polarization value can arise for initial states that possess either a finite or vanishing initial value of @xmath113 . as we saw at the beginning of section ( [ sec1 ] ) in presence of the radiation field ,
the total out of plane angular momentum component @xmath150 of the electrons is no longer a constant of motion .
therefore , the pseudospin oscillations are due to the angular momentum exchange among the driving field and the charge carriers in single layer graphene . for the coherent state a beating pattern emerges in the pseudospin polarization . in spite of the fact that the interaction is dictated by a periodic hamiltonian
we find that the dominant or characteristic time scale for this collective behavior is the cyclotron frequency
. we could expect this behavior of the wave packet at large values of @xmath142 as a measure of the classical behavior associated to the cyclotron problem but now realized with dirac fermions in the ll quantized regime as was discussed by one of the authors in reference@xcite .
we must remark that in order to be able to detect the reported effects an ensemble of coherent states should be prepared each time , because the measurement process destroys the state .
it should also be remembered that the coherent state parameter @xmath142 is determined by choosing appropiate values for the mean values of position and momentum in accordance to the following prescription @xmath151 another point to be highlighted is that for standard two dimensional electron gases the coherent state built from the landau levels would remain coherent , i.e. , it will evolve in time in such a manner that it would just oscillate in time around the prescribed mean values given in eqs .
( [ x ] ) and ( [ p ] ) .
more precisely , its wigner function representation in phase space will oscillate in time without deformation .
this is known to be a consequence of the fact that the dependence with the @xmath152 quantum number is linear . yet , in graphene we have a @xmath153 and this in turn prevents the coherent state to evolve in such a coherent manner .
therefore , the spreading of the wave packet and the corresponding appearance of the additional revival times at shorter time values is a direct consequence of the driving field that even at low coupling can induce interesting dynamical behavior as shown in fig . 3 and fig .
4 . we supported this last statement by evaluating the static ( @xmath154 ) autocorrelation function as shown in fig .
5 and found that the second packet reconstruction ( see lower panel for @xmath146 in fig .
4 ) around @xmath155 is absent in the static regime .
we would also like to comment that graphene subject to electromagnetic radiation without quantizing magnetic field has been discussed in several papers @xcite .
it has been shown that for zero momentum ( k=0 ) , the dynamical equation is exactly solvable and leads to a photoinduced ( zero quantizing magnetic field ) mass term that has opposite signs at the two valleys . yet , at finite momentum the dynamics is no longer exactly solvable and one has to resort to numerical analysis by means of an infinite expansion in fourier modes .
this is why we consider our results to be a valuable tool in analytically describing the photoinduced pseudospin effects in the landau level structure of monolayer graphene .
we now briefly mention that our values of quantizing magnetic fields are within experimentally accesible orders .
for instance , in the pioneering paper by novoselov et al . in reference
@xcite , the authors used a value of quantizing magnetic field @xmath156 t to study the quantum hall effect in graphene .
moreover , in a following classical paper , their results were extended up to values of @xmath157 t and even @xmath158 t for the quantizing magnetic field@xcite .
here it is shown that at these values of magnetic field , the quantum hall effect in graphene could be observed at room temperature that constitutes a breakthrough in the physics of quantum hall phases .
we have analyzed the dynamical modulation of physical quantities for dirac fermions within the landau level quantized regime of single layer graphene subject to intense circularly polarized terahertz radiation . to the best of our knowledge ,
this is the first analysis of the photoinduced manipulation of the ll structure in single - layer graphene subject to a continuously applied intense laser field instead of a pulsed one . by means of a perturbative analytical treatment we found very interesting physical features such as a non trivial level dependent dynamically induced gap structure .
due to the angular momentum exchange among the radiation field and the charge carriers , it also leads to modulation of the oscillations in the dynamics of the out of plane pseudospin polarization , even for superposition states with an initially vanishing pseudospin value .
we also found that localization effects in the time evolution of the pseudospin polarization can be keep track of by measuring the revival times of a wave packet initially prepared as a coherent state .
the reported photoinduced gap modulation and pseudospin oscillations could be detected through the reemitted dipolar radiation from the oscillating charge carriers as it was proposed in reference@xcite .
+ we would also like to mention that for values of @xmath159 , one enters the so called ultrastrong coupling limit in the context of cavity quantum electrodynamics experiments . within this parameter regime
, it has been experimentally shown in reference @xcite that explicit anti - crossings appear in the energy spectrum .
this in turn corresponds to a breakdown of the jaynes cummings approximation that describes resonant processes in the two - level problem coupled to a single mode radiation field .
our exact floquet hamiltonian given in equation ( 20 ) allows us to explore this ultrastrong coupling regime beyond the perturbative results presented and could be the subject of future work where one would expect non linear effects to be relevant in the graphene physics .
for instance , as we already argued in the discussion section , one could expect that the accidental degeneracies seen in the panels of fig .
2 , at large values of the quantizing magnetic field , would be lifted by a stronger coupling to the radiation field .
finally , we would like to mention that although we perform our analysis for neutral undoped graphene . yet , in the graphene literature the role of doping has been given special attention since it might either modify the effective fermi velocity of dirac fermions@xcite .
the first work@xcite shows that the energy spectrum near the charge neutrality point is non linear and no gap is found at energies even as close to the dirac point as @xmath160 mev . on the other hand ,
the authors of paper @xcite show that that electron interactions leave the graphene energy dispersion linear as a function of excitation energy even for energies within @xmath161 mev of the fermi energy .
yet , it has recently been shown that doping effects might also lead to a bandgap opening in the graphene spectrum ( see @xcite and references therein ) .
in particular , the authors of the work@xcite have discussed the tunability of the bandgap energy in single - layer graphene due to manganese oxide nanoparticles by means of an electrochemical method @xcite .
this work reports a maximum value for the induced energy bandgap of @xmath162 ev .
although they do not discuss the quantized ll regime , we could incorporate these doping effects in our model by including a phenomenological diagonal term in the landau level hamiltonian given in equations ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) .
this mass - term would in turn be proportional to @xmath113 and the valley index @xmath163 , as required by time reversal invariance .
thus , one would expect an interesting interplay between the photoinduced gap openings and the static bandgap determined by doping effects .
yet , we considered undoped graphene in order to highlight the photoinduced ll dependent bandgap discussed above .
concerning the actual experimental observation of our predicted results , we consider that these could motive the exploration of larger intensities for the radiation field as given in the experimental setup in reference @xcite when their model enters the landau level regime . in this sense , we consider that our work would contribute to explore a new physical scenario within realistic parameter values to discuss the pseudospin physics in graphene , also taking into account the role of zitterbewegung as it is discussed in reference@xcite , extending their results to initially prepared coherent states when the radiation field is a monochromatic continuous laser field instead of a pulsed laser .
+ _ acknowledgments _ this work has been supported by deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft via grk 1570 and yachay tech via the project `` non dissipative transport in honeycomb lattice materials : interplay of spin - orbit interaction , radiation fields and superconductivity '' .
al thanks the university of lorraine for partial financial support through research visits .
bb thanks yachay tech for financial support for research visits .
in order to get the effective hamiltonian for single layer graphene we need to evaluate the following expression @xmath164 with the antihermitian operator @xmath165 using the baker campbell hausdorff formula we have @xmath166+\frac{1}{2!}\left(\frac{\lambda}{2}\right)^2[i_-,[i_-,h_f]]+\dots\ ] ] the first commutator is worked out explicitly @xmath167=[\hat{a}^\dagger\sigma_--\hat{a}\sigma_+,h_f].\ ] ] since @xmath168 and @xmath169=0 $ ] , with @xmath170 , we only need to evaluate two commutators .
the first one gives @xmath171&=&\nonumber[\hat{a}^\dagger\sigma_--\hat{a}\sigma_+,\hat{a}^\dagger\sigma_-+\hat{a}\sigma_+]\\ & & = \nonumber-2[\hat{a}\sigma_+,\hat{a}^\dagger\sigma_-]\\ & & = \nonumber-2(\hat{a}[\sigma_+,\hat{a}^\dagger\sigma_-]+[\hat{a},\hat{a}^\dagger\sigma_-]\sigma_+)\\ & & = \nonumber-2(\hat{a}\hat{a}^\dagger[\sigma_+,\sigma_-]+[\hat{a},\hat{a}^\dagger]\sigma_-\sigma_+)\\ & & = \nonumber-2(\hat{a}\hat{a}^\dagger\sigma_z+(\mathbb{1}-\sigma_z)/2)\\ & & = \nonumber-2(\hat{a}^\dagger\hat{a}\sigma_z+(\mathbb{1}+\sigma_z)/2)\\ & & = \nonumber-2(\hat{a}^\dagger\hat{a}+(\mathbb{1}+\sigma_z)/2)\sigma_z\\ & & = -2\hat{n}_a\sigma_z,\end{aligned}\ ] ] whereas the second one follows as @xmath172&=&\nonumber[\hat{a}^\dagger\sigma_--\hat{a}\sigma_+,\sigma_-+\sigma_+]\\ & & = \nonumber-\hat{a}[\sigma_+,\sigma_-]+\hat{a}^\dagger[\sigma_-,\sigma_+]\\ & & = \nonumber-(\hat{a}+\hat{a}^\dagger)\sigma_z.\end{aligned}\ ] ] upon substitution of these first - order corrections and introduction of the shifted harmonic oscillator operators we get the effective hamiltonian given in equation ( [ hfin ] ) .
k. s. novoselov , a. k. geim , s. v. morozov , d. jiang , y. zhang , s. v. dubonos , i. v. grigorieva and a. a. firsov , _ science _ * 306 * , 666 ( 2004 ) a. k. geim and k. s. novoselov , _ nature mater .
_ * 6 * , 183 ( 2007 ) a. h. castro neto , f. guinea , n. m. r. peres , k. s. novoselov and a. k. geim , _ rev .
phys . _ * 81 * , 109 ( 2009 ) t. oka and h. aoki , _ phys .
b _ * 79 * , 081406(r ) ( 2009 ) h. l. calvo , h. m. pastawski , s. roche and l. e. f. foa torres , _ appl
* 98 * , 232103 ( 2011 ) y. zhou and m. w. wu , _ phys .
b _ * 83 * , 245436 ( 2011 ) j. karch , p. olbrich , m. schmalzbauer , c. zoth , c. brinsteiner , m. fehrenbacher , u. wurstbauer , m. m. glazov , s. a. tarasenko , e. l. ivchenko , d. weiss , j. eroms , r. yakimova , s. lara - avila , s. kubatkin and s. d. ganichev , _ phys . rev . lett . _ * 105 * , 227402 ( 2010 ) c. l. kane and e. j. and mele , _ phys . rev . lett .
_ * 95 * , 226801 ( 2005 ) t. kitagawa , e. berg , m. rudner and e. demler , _ phys . rev .
b _ * 82 * , 235114 ( 2010 ) t. kitagawa , t. oka , a. brataas , l. fu and e. demler , _ phys . rev .
b _ * 84 * , 235108 ( 2011 ) z. gu , h. a. fertig , d. p. arovas and a. auerbach , _ phys . rev
. lett . _ * 107 * , 216601 ( 2011 ) b. dra , k. ziegler , p. thalmeier and m. nakamura , _ phys . rev .
lett . _ * 102 * , 036803 ( 2009 ) t. m. rusin and w. zawadzki , _ phys . rev .
b _ * 80 * , 045416 ( 2009 ) m. mecklenburg and b. c. regan , _ phys . rev .
lett . _ * 106 * , 116803 ( 2011 ) d. yudin , o. eriksson and m. i. katsnelson , _ phys .
b _ * 91 * , 075419 ( 2015 ) j. cayssol , b. dra , f. simon and r. moessner , _ phys
. status solidi rrl _ * 7 * , 101 ( 2013 ) m. grifoni and p. hnggi , _ physics reports _ * 304 * , 229 ( 1998 ) q .-
j. phys . a : math .
gen . _ * 34 * , 1903 ( 2001 ) d. s. l. abergel and t. chakraborty , _ nanotech .
_ * 22 * , 015203 ( 2011 ) r. w. robinett , _ physics reports _ * 92 * , 1 ( 2004 ) ; v. krueckl and t. kramer , _ new j. phys . _ * 11 * , 093010 ( 2009 ) ; e. romera and f. de los santos , _ phys .
b _ * 80 * , 165416 ( 2009 ) ; e. romera , _ phys . rev .
a _ * 84 * , 052102 ( 2011 ) a. voje , j. m. kinaret and a. isacsson , _ phys .
b _ * 85 * , 205415 ( 2012 ) d. leibfried , e. knill , s. seidelin , j. britton , r. b. blakestad , j. chiaverini , d. hume , w. m. itano , j. d. jost , c. langer , r. ozeri , r. reichle and d. j. wineland , _ nature _ * 438 * , 639 ( 2005 ) j. h. eberly , n. b. narozhny and j. j. sanchez - mondragon , _ phys .
lett . _ * 44 * , 1323 ( 1980 ) j. schliemann , _ new j. phys .
_ * 10 * , 043024 ( 2008 ) k. s. novoselov , a. k. geim , s. v. morozov , d. jiang , m. i. katsnelson , i. v. grigorieva , s. v. dubonos and a. a. firsov , _ nature _ * 438 * , 197 ( 2005 ) k. s. novoselov , z. jiang , y. zhang , s. v. morozov , h. l. stormer , u. zeitler , j. c. maan , g. s. boebinger , p. kim and a. k. geim , _ science _ * 315 * , 1379 ( 2007 ) t. niemczyk , f. deppe , h. huebl , e. p. menzel , f. hocke , m. j. schwarz , j. j. garcia - ripoll , d. zueco , t. hmmer , e. solano , a. marx and r. gross , _ nature phys . _
* 6 * , 772 ( 2010 ) d. c. elias , r. v. gorbachev , a. s. mayorov , s. v. morozov , a. a. zhukov , p. blake , l. a. ponomarenko , i. v. grigorieva , k. s. novoselov , f. guinea and a. k. geim , _ nature phys . _ * 7 * , 701 ( 2011 ) j. chae , s. jung , a. f. young , c. r. dean , l. wang , y. gao , k. watanabe , t. taniguchi , j. hone , k. l. shepard , p. kim , n. b. zhitenev , and j. a. stroscio , _ phys .
* 109 * , 116802 ( 2012 ) x. wang , g. sun , p. routh , d .- h .
kim , w. huang , and p. chen , _ chem .
rev . _ * 43 * , 7067 ( 2014 ) c. s. park , yu zhao , j. h. lee , d. m. whang , y. shon , y. h. song and c. j. lee , _ appl .
lett . _ * 102 * , 032106 ( 2013 ) | we present perturbative analytical results of the landau level quasienergy spectrum , autocorrelation function and out of plane pseudospin polarization for a single graphene sheet subject to intense circularly polarized terahertz radiation . for the quasienergy spectrum
, we find a striking non trivial level - dependent dynamically induced gap structure .
this photoinduced modulation of the energy band structure gives rise to shifts of the revival times in the autocorrelation function and it also leads to modulation of the oscillations in the dynamical evolution of the out of plane pseudospin polarization , which measures the angular momentum transfer between light and graphene electrons . for a coherent state , chosen as an initial pseudospin configuration ,
the dynamics induces additional quantum revivals of the wave function that manifest as shifts of the maxima and minima of the autocorrelation function , with additional partial revivals and beating patterns .
these additional maxima and beating patterns stem from the effective dynamical coupling of the static eigenstates .
we discuss the possible experimental detection schemes of our theoretical results and their relevance in new practical implementation of radiation fields in graphene physics . |
in this paper , we have studied the problem of variational regularization of inverse and ill posed problems for functions on closed riemannian manifolds .
the analysis ( stability , convergence , and rates ) follows from standard results on convex regularization and are reviewed . the main contribution of this paper concerns the numerical analysis of such regularization methods and the numerical implementation .
moreover , three inverse problems appearing in non - destructive evaluation and computer vision are discussed .
the authors acknowledge the support by the austrian science fund ( fwf ) within the national research networks industrial geometry , project 9203-n12 and photoacoustic imaging , project p10505 .
all along this paper we use the notation : * @xmath51 denotes a closed @xmath52-dimensional manifold in @xmath53 .
* @xmath54 denotes a polygonal approximation of @xmath51 . in this paper , typically , it is a polyhedron .
* @xmath19 denotes coordinates on the manifold .
@xmath55 denotes coordinates in the euclidean space .
* @xmath56 denotes the subdifferential , @xmath57 is the gradient in the euclidean setting , @xmath58 and @xmath59 are the covariant derivatives on the riemannian manifolds @xmath60 , @xmath51 , respectively . *
if not specified otherwise @xmath61 denotes an euclidean distance . 1 .
the metric tensor @xmath62 expressed in a coordinate chart @xmath63 is @xmath64 the inverse metric tensor is @xmath65 .
2 . given a smooth , closed riemannian @xmath52-manifold @xmath66 , there is an associated positive radon measure on @xmath51 , the _ riemannian measure _ , which is defined as follows : given an integrable function @xmath67 , an atlas @xmath68 of @xmath51 and a partition of unity @xmath69 , @xmath70 where @xmath71 is the volume of the metric tensor and @xmath72 is the lebesgue volume element on @xmath73 and therefore @xmath74 3 .
the gradient can be expressed with the chart @xmath63 @xmath75 4 .
the adjoint operator of the gradient is the divergence , which satisfies for a given vector field @xmath76 on @xmath51 : @xmath77 in a chart @xmath78 the divergence is obtained by using equation [ eq : nabla ] in equation [ eq : divm ] : @xmath79 5 .
given @xmath66 and @xmath80\mapsto { \mathcal{m}}$ ] a curve on @xmath51 , then @xmath81 is the length of the curve on @xmath51 with respect to @xmath82 . for @xmath83 on @xmath51 with @xmath84 @xmath84 and @xmath85 ,
the distance associated with @xmath82 between two points @xmath86 and @xmath87 is @xmath88 @xmath89 is the space of continuous curves connecting @xmath86 and @xmath87 .
the distance @xmath90 defines a metric on the manifold . in this paper
, we assume that the metric space @xmath91 is always complete .
6 . in a _ closed riemannian manifold _
( without boundary ) the hopf - rinow theorem implies that for every pair of points on the manifold there exists a unique geodesic @xcite .
given a smooth and closed @xmath52-dimensional riemannian manifold @xmath66 , we define ( see @xcite ) @xmath92 where @xmath93 is the @xmath94-norm with respect to the riemannian measure @xmath95 .
the space @xmath96 ( see e.g. @xcite ) is defined as the completion of the space @xmath97 with respect to the norm @xmath98 . in particular for @xmath99 and @xmath100 , we have @xmath101 now , we recall the definition of the space of functions of bounded variation on manifolds .
we define @xmath102 as the space of functions with bounded variation and is the set of functions @xmath103 such that @xmath104 .
the space is endowed with the norm @xmath105 , where @xmath106 denotes the variation of @xmath31 , which is defined by ( [ eq : tv ] ) the space @xmath102 is a banach space endowed with the norm @xmath107 .
it can be understood as the natural ( weak ) closure of @xmath108 . due to the theorem of meyer and serrin
@xcite it is possible to approximate sobolev functions defined on subset of the euclidean space by smooth functions .
for the sake of completeness we provide a proof to show the essential difference in the manifold setting .
[ th : compactness ] let @xmath51 be a closed manifold , and let @xmath116 be a sequence of functions in @xmath102 such that @xmath117 .
then there exists a subsequence of @xmath109 converging strongly in @xmath113 .
abrial , y. moudden , j .- l .
starck , b. afeyan , j. bobin , j. fadili , and m. k. nguyen .
morphological component analysis and inpainting on the sphere : application in physics and astrophysics .
, 13(6):729748 , 2007 .
u. clarenz , u. diewald , and m. rumpf . a multiscale fairing method for textured surfaces . in hans - christian hege and konrad
polthier , editors , _ visualization and mathematics iii _ , pages 245260 , heidelberg , 2003 .
springer - verlag .
( vismath2002 ) .
m. descoteaux , e. angelino , s. fitzgibbons , and r. deriche . a fast and robust odf estimation algorithm in q - ball imaging . in _ biomedical imaging : nano to macro , 2006 .
3rd ieee international symposium on _ , pages 81 84 , april 2006 .
g. dziuk .
finite elements for the beltrami operator on arbitrary surfaces . in s.
hildebrandt and r. leis , editors , _ partial differential equations and calculus of variations _ , volume 1357 of _ lecture notes in mathematics _ , pages 142155 .
springer berlin / heidelberg , 1988 . c. gotsman , x. gu , and a. sheffer
. fundamentals of spherical parameterization for 3d meshes . in j.
hodgins and j. c. hart , editors , _ proceedings of acm siggraph 2003 _ , volume 22(3 ) of _ acm transactions on graphics _ , pages 358363 .
acm press , 2003 . | we consider abstract operator equations @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is a compact linear operator between hilbert spaces @xmath2 and @xmath3 , which are function spaces on _ closed , finite dimensional riemannian manifolds _ , respectively .
this setting is of interest in numerous applications such as computer vision and non - destructive evaluation . in this work
, we study the approximation of the solution of the ill - posed operator equation with tikhonov type regularization methods .
we prove well - posedness , stability , convergence , and convergence rates of the regularization methods .
moreover , we study in detail the numerical analysis and the numerical implementation .
finally , we provide for three different inverse problems numerical experiments .
* key words : * inverse problems , variational regularization on riemannian manifolds , functions of bounded variation [ cols="^,^ " , ] in table [ tab : snr ] we summarized the results on the denoising and delurring problem for a fixed @xmath4 . in order to compare the performance of different choices for @xmath5 we use the signal - to - noise ratio ( snr ) measured in @xmath6 .
the snr is defined as @xmath7 the better performance of the total variation regularization stems from the fact that discontinuities along edges are preserved while the sobolev semi - norm introduces severe blurring of the edges . in a recent work louis et al @xcite discuss a problem of density estimation , which requires the inversion of the funk - radon transform on the @xmath8-sphere . in general , for arbitrary space dimension , the funk - radon transform maps a function defined on the @xmath8-sphere to its means over the great circles .
that is , @xmath9 helgason @xcite provids a closed form for the inverse of the funk - radon transform . in @xcite
an approximate inverse for the efficient numerical inversion of the radon - funk transform on the @xmath8-sphere has been proposed . here
we investigate quadratic tikhonov regularization with sobolev semi - norm regularization term on the @xmath8-sphere .
the method consists in minimization of the functional @xmath10 the proposed numerical minimization algorithm requires real valued spherical harmonics : the functions @xmath11 , where @xmath12 denotes the degree and @xmath13 the order , form an orthonormal basis on @xmath14 : @xmath15 in the following we define a single index @xmath16 for @xmath17 and @xmath18 and identify the coordinates @xmath19 on the sphere with polar coordinates @xmath20 . for the numerical minimization
we use approximations of @xmath21 with real spherical harmonics of maximal degree @xmath22 .
this is @xmath23 therefore from discrete sample values @xmath24
@xmath25 the spherical harmonics expansions can be computed from the following matrix equation : @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the matrix of spherical harmonics basis functions .
the coefficients @xmath28 are the coefficients of the best approximating solution in @xmath29 and are given by @xmath30 figure [ fig : funktransform ] a ) shows the best approximation of a function @xmath31 with a spherical harmonics polynomial of degree @xmath32 . using the funk - henke theorem it has been shown in @xcite that the funk - radon transform of a function @xmath31 , given in a spherical harmonics basis , takes the simple form @xmath33 the legendre polynomial of degree @xmath34 evaluated at @xmath35 is @xmath36
therefore , the discrete funk - radon transform can be written as @xmath37 a diagonal matrix .
an example of the evaluation of the funk - radon transform can be seen in figure [ fig : funktransform ] c ) . in figure
[ fig : funktransform ] d ) , the transformed signal is perturbed by some additive gauian noise with variance @xmath38 . in order to reconstruct the signal from its funk - radon
transform we minimize the tikhonov functional from equation ( [ eq : funkradon ] ) . as in the previous examples the subgradient of the @xmath29-norm of the gradient the laplace - beltrami operator , which in spherical harmonics basis expansion is given by @xmath39 and in matrix notation @xmath40 reconstruction of the inverse funk - radon transform with tikhonov regularization requires solving the linear system @xmath41 this equation can be solved again with a landweber iteration .
this equation has been solved again via a landweber iteration : @xmath42 since the funk transform annihilates odd functions ( see @xcite ) , we take an even function to test our inversion algorithm . as in @xcite
we use the function @xmath43 and evaluate the function at @xmath44 point on the sphere as they are provides in @xcite . in the numerical experiments we used spherical harmonics of degree @xmath32 .
the reconstructions are depicted in figure [ fig : invfunktransform ] .
note that if @xmath45 we can not solve for @xmath46 because the matrix @xmath47 does not have full rank . only by regularizing the inversion with the laplace - beltrami operator
allows the reconstruction of @xmath48 . in figure
[ fig : invfunktransform ] we can observe the smoothing effect of the laplace - beltrami operator on the solution . in the left column of figure
[ fig : invfunktransform ] a low value @xmath49 and in the right column the result with a high value @xmath50 .
we observe a much smoother reconstruction for higher values of @xmath4 . |
the famous bekenstein hawking area law @xcite @xmath0 for the entropy of black holes connects thermodynamics , gravity and relativistic quantum field theory .
this relation remains valid not only in einstein s gravity in four dimensions but in higher dimensions too , as long as the gravitational constant @xmath1 is @xmath2-dimensional and the area @xmath3 is understood as the volume of the horizon surface . in quantum field theory ( qft )
an entanglement entropy can be attributed to any surface formally dividing the system in two parts .
the leading uv contribution of quantum fields to the entanglement entropy is proportional to the area of the dividing surface @xcite .
this property is strikingly similar the bekenstein hawking area law .
the analogy with black hole entropy is not accidental .
one may consider a black hole horizon as a surface separating the interior of the black hole from its exterior . to define a wave function of all quantum fields in the black hole spacetime @xcite one can use an analogue to the hartle - hawking no - boundary proposal . using this wavefunction one can construct the density matrix for the fields inside the black hole and derive the corresponding entanglement entropy , which is proportional to the area of the horizon , but the coefficient of proportionality formally diverges .
however , one has to take into account that quantum fields on a curved background spacetime also contribute to the effective gravitational constant .
it is amazing that quantum contributions to the entropy per unit area of a horizon are described by the same functions as quantum corrections to the gravitational coupling @xcite .
the interpretation of the bekenstein hawking formula as the entanglement entropy becomes even more striking in the framework of induced gravity models @xcite where the gravitational coupling is completely defined by quantum field contributions . in these models the leading uv contribution to the entanglement entropy of the horizon @xcite is given by the formula @xmath4 and is finite as soon as the induced gravitational constant @xmath5 is finite .
it was also proposed @xcite that in generic static spacetimes with horizons , the minimal area surface inside the slice of a constant time may play an important role in the definition of the entanglement entropy of a black hole .
recently , holographic computations of the entanglement entropy in conformal field theory ( cft ) at infinity of the anti - de sitter ( ads ) spacetime have seen a lot of attention and development .
the original conjecture for entanglement entropy by ryu and takayanagi @xcite is that in a static configuration the entanglement entropy of a subsystem localized in a domain @xmath6 is given by the formula system of units . ]
@xmath7 given a static time slice ( the bulk space ) , the domain @xmath8 belongs to an infinite boundary @xmath9 of the bulk and the area @xmath10 in eq . is to be understood as the area of a @xmath11-dimensional minimal surface @xmath12 in the bulk spanned on the boundary @xmath13 of the subsystem ( i.e. , @xmath14 ) . the holographic derivation of the ryu
takayanagi formula for the entanglement entropy was proposed in @xcite using the replica trick . in the replica method there
naturally appears a more general notion of the renyi entanglement entropy .
but the qft derivation of the ryu
takayanagi relation based on the calculation of renyi entropies requires a different approach @xcite . in qft with gravity duals ,
formula was proven for @xmath15 @xcite . in a more general case of euclidean gravity solutions without killing vectors ,
arguments supporting the validity of the ryu - takayanagi formula were given in @xcite .
in the last few years the conjecture by ryu and takayanagi has been generalized to gravity theories with higher curvature interactions @xcite or some other deformations of the gravity theory @xcite .
an excellent up - to - date review of the entanglement entropy and black holes can be found in @xcite .
calculation of entanglement entropy for a subsystem localized in two disjoint regions is particularly interesting , since it can be used as a probe of confinement @xcite .
it was demonstrated @xcite that in confining backgrounds there are generally more solutions for minimal surfaces in the bulk spanned on the boundaries of these disjoint regions .
however , there is a maximum distance between the regions beyond which the tube - like minimal surface connecting both components ceases to exist .
there is also a critical scale beyond which a solution with disconnected minimal surfaces dominates over the connected one . in the qft language
this critical behavior is analogous to a deconfinement transition at a finite temperature . in the case of a few disjoint regions the minimal surfaces connecting their boundaries
are generally not unique and their areas differ .
the conventional wisdom is that the entanglement entropy is related to the surfaces of minimum area .
this choice guarantees the required strong subadditivity property @xcite of the entanglement entropy
. there were some proposals @xcite how to modify this `` least area '' rule while still satisfying the strong subadditivity property .
in this paper we study minimal surfaces in the pure ads spacetime .
we show that many properties of the entanglement entropy , such as the critical behavior @xcite demonstrated for the asymptotically ads spacetimes with black holes in the bulk , exist already in the pure ads .
the main result is that we are able to find exact solutions for all minimal surfaces spanned on one or two spherical boundaries positioned arbitrarily at conformal infinity @xmath16 . in this short paper
we give analytical formulas for the regularized and renormalized area of these minimal surfaces .
the explicit form of the surfaces and its derivation is presented in a more detailed paper @xcite .
we also shortly discuss the spacetime character of a minimal surface spanned on two accelerated spherical domains .
we start with geometrical preliminaries concerning the bulk space and with the characterization of the spherical domains at infinity .
we will discuss only a ads spacetime although most of the discussion can be extended to higher dimensions .
the ads spacetime has many killing symmetries and can be viewed as a static spacetime in various ways .
however , in all cases the spatial section the bulk space has the hyperbolic geometry of lobachevsky space . to describe it
, we use cylindrical coordinates @xmath17 and poincar coordinates @xmath18 in which the metric reads @xmath19 here , @xmath20 is the characteristic scale describing the radius of curvature of ads , as well as of its spatial section .
the coordinates are related by @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 , with @xmath24 .
the conformal infinity @xmath16 of the spatial section is the conformal sphere . in cylindrical
coordinates it is given by @xmath25 , @xmath26 . in poincar
coordinates it is represented by the plane @xmath27 plus one improper point @xmath28 . by the _ circular _ ( in higher dimension , _ spherical _ ) boundary @xmath29 of a ball - like domain @xmath8 at infinity @xmath16 we mean a surface given by infinite points of a hyperplane in the bulk ( hyperplane in the sense of hyperbolic geometry , a hypersurface with zero extrinsic curvature ) .
the circular boundaries at infinity are thus in one - to - one correspondence with hyperplanes in the bulk .
visualization of such a hyperplane and the corresponding circular boundary can be found in fig .
[ fig : hyperplane ] . the boundary @xmath29 can be understood also as the boundary of the complementary domain @xmath30 . * hyperplane corresponding to the circular boundary at infinity . * the hyperplane ( the hypersurface of zero extrinsic curvature ) reaches infinity at the circular boundary which divides infinity into two domains .
the poincar spherical ( left ) and spherical half - space ( right ) representation of hyperbolic space is shown.,title="fig:",width=160]*hyperplane corresponding to the circular boundary at infinity . *
the hyperplane ( the hypersurface of zero extrinsic curvature ) reaches infinity at the circular boundary which divides infinity into two domains .
the poincar spherical ( left ) and spherical half - space ( right ) representation of hyperbolic space is shown.,title="fig:",width=160 ] + from a point of view of the conformally spherical geometry on @xmath16 , all such boundaries are equivalent . it is a reflection of the trivial fact that all hyperplanes in the bulk are isometric .
therefore we do not have any quantity measuring a ` size ' of spherical boundaries at infinity .
however , in many calculations , both in the bulk or at infinity , we need to regularize various quantities . instead of working at @xmath16 we restrict on some cut - off surface at large finite size
. then we can measure the sizea of the circular boundaries using the geometry on the cut - off surface .
but , since the choice of the cut - off can be rather arbitrary , the regularized size of the spherical boundary can be only an intermediate quantity , and physically measurable quantities should be cut - off independent .
two circular boundaries can be in three qualitatively distinct positions : ( i ) disjoint boundaries ( corresponding hyperplanes are ultraparallel ) , ( ii ) boundaries crossing each other ( the hyperplanes intersect in a line ) , and ( iii ) boundaries touching in one point ( the corresponding hyperplanes are asymptotic ) . in the first case we can define the distance of the boundaries as a distance of the corresponding hyperplanes . to the crossing circular boundaries we can assign an angle of the corresponding hyperplanes .
finally , all pairs of touching boundaries are equivalent .
indeed , all pairs of asymptotic hyperplanes in an arbitrary position are isometric to each other . in global hyperbolic space
there is no measure which could distinguish them .
now we review known results for a minimal surface spanned on one circular boundary .
such a minimal surface is trivial : it is the hyperplane which defines the boundary .
if we choose the axis of the cylindrical coordinates perpendicular to the hyperplane , the hyperplane is given by @xmath31 . if we choose the axis inside the hyperplane , the hyperplane is given by @xmath32 . in the poincar coordinates the hyperplane is represented as a plane orthogonal to the infinity surface @xmath33 or as a hemisphere with the center at @xmath33 ( here we used a language of the conformally related euclidian geometry with cartesian coordinates @xmath18 ) . to demonstrate different regularizations used later , we can write down the area of a hyperplane measured up to a cut - off . for the hyperplane othogonal to the axis we have @xmath34\;,\ ] ] where @xmath35 , with @xmath36 , is the circumference of the circular boundary on the cut - off surface @xmath37 . for the hyperplane which contains the axis we have @xmath38\;,\ ] ] where @xmath39 , with @xmath40 , is the length of the boundary at the cut - off surface .
in this case , the circular boundary is represented by two lines @xmath41 , @xmath42 , @xmath32 .
we thus have to introduce two cut - offs : an ultraviolet one , @xmath43 , in the direction away from the axis , and an infrared one , @xmath44 , along the axis .
finally , the area of the hyperplane represented by a half - plane in the poincar coordinates , say @xmath45 , is @xmath46 @xmath47 is again the length of the circular boundary at the cut - off surface @xmath48 .
it is also infrared divergent : one has to cut - off the @xmath49 direction at @xmath50 . in all three cases
we recognize the well - known property that the leading diverging term of the minimal surface is ( up to a constant scale ) given by the regularized size of the boundary at infinity .
clearly , the exact expression for the divergent term depends on the regularization scheme , however , in all cases it can be interpreted as the regularized size of the boundary at infinity @xcite . the area of the trivial minimal surface spanned on one circular boundary can be used to eliminate the infinite contributions to the area for more complicated surfaces .
we define the renormalized area of a surface by subtracting the area of hyperplanes spanned on the same boundaries at infinity . in this sense ,
the trivial minimal surface has vanishing renormalized area .
+ + ( a)(b)(c ) + * * disjoint boundaries.**given two circular boundaries at infinity , we can always find the unique line perpendicular to the corresponding hyperplanes in the bulk .
if we adjust the cylindrical coordinates to this axis , the circular boundaries are represented by two circles @xmath41 , @xmath51 .
it is possible to find @xcite a tube - like minimal surface joining these two boundaries , see fig . [
fig : ms]a .
it is described by the function @xmath52 with @xmath53 , and it is parametrized by @xmath54 , where @xmath55 is the closest approach of the surface to the axis : @xmath56\;. \end{split}\raisetag{4ex}\ ] ] setting @xmath57 we can read out the coordinates @xmath58 of the circular boundaries : @xmath59\;. \end{split}\raisetag{8ex}\ ] ] the distance between both boundaries , @xmath60 , as a function of the parameter @xmath61 is depicted in fig .
[ fig : area]a .
it reveals that the tube exists only for distances smaller than the maximal distance @xmath62 , and for these small distances there actually exist two tube - like minimal surfaces , one shallow one , remaining at large distances from the axis , and a deep one , approaching the axis . if the distance of circular boundaries is enlarged , the tube tears off and the minimal surface discontinuously splits into two trivial hyperplanes spanned on both boundaries . to estimate
which surface is the smallest one , we have to write down the regularized area : @xmath63 the divergent term @xmath64 is given by , the finite part @xmath65 reads @xmath66 + ( a)(b)(c ) + the renormalized area as a function of @xmath61 or of the distance @xmath67 is shown in fig . [ fig : area ] .
we see that the shallow tube has always smaller area than the deeper one .
however , for @xmath68 , the renormalized area of the tube is positive , i.e. , the tube has larger area than the trivial solutions of two hyperplanes .
the tube is thus the smallest minimal surface only for @xmath69 .
all these exact results confirm the previously conjectured properties based on numerical and approximate analysis @xcite . * * crossing circular boundaries.**in the case of two crossing circular boundaries at infinity we naturally adjust the cylindrical coordinates to the axis going through the intersection points .
thus , the semicircles between these intersection points are represented by lines @xmath41 , @xmath70 .
in poincar coordinates they are half - lines in the plane @xmath27 starting at @xmath71 . the minimal surface spanned on two such semicircles
is depicted in fig .
[ fig : ms]b . its explicit form can be found in @xcite .
it exists for any angle @xmath72 between both semicircles and can be parametrized by @xmath73 with @xmath55 corresponding to the closest approach of the surface to the axis .
the relation between of @xmath72 and @xmath74 is one - to - one @xcite .
the regularized area takes form : @xmath75\;. \end{split}\ ] ] the leading term @xmath64 is given by .
it is divergent because of both uv and ir divergences .
the next term is proportional to the ir cut - off @xmath76 .
the reason is that the minimal surface is invariant under the translation along the axis .
however , we can write down the finite renormalized area density @xmath77 : @xmath78\,.\ ] ] it is always negative .
naturally , the surface has always smaller area then two half - hyperplanes starting at the axis reaching the semi - circles at infinity . * * touching circular boundaries**tangent circular boundaries are trivially represented in poincar coordinates .
if oriented in the @xmath49 direction , they are given by @xmath27 , @xmath79 .
the minimal surface spanned on such a ` strip ' is in fig .
[ fig : ms]c , @xcite .
it reaches the maximal value of the coordinate @xmath80 for @xmath81 , which we call the ` top - line ' of the surface .
the constant @xmath82 is given by @xmath83 .
the area regularized at @xmath84 is @xmath85\\ & = a_{{\scriptstyle\mathrm{hp}}}+ l_0 \bigl[-2x_0\ell + o({{\bar{z}}}^3)\bigr]\ , .
\end{split}\raisetag{3ex}\ ] ] the leading divergent term @xmath64 is given by .
the next term is ir divergent since the surface has the horocyclic symmetry @xmath86 .
it is thus proportional to the length @xmath87 measured on the ` top - line ' of the surface .
the renormalized area density @xmath88 is , as expected , a constant independent of the position of the touching circular boundaries .
returning to the conjecture , we can now associate entanglement entropy with any two generally positioned spherical domains at infinity .
the most interesting case occurs for two disjoint domains . for boundaries closer than @xmath89
there are three possible minimal surfaces , which corresponds to three possibilities ( phases ) for the holographic entanglement entropy in cft .
the physical choice would correspond to the surface of the smallest area . inspecting fig .
[ fig : area]b , one can see that the transition between these phases occurs at the distance @xmath90 , when the area of the tube - like surface starts to exceed the area of the trivial solution with two hyperplanes .
if we accept that the entanglement entropy for disjoint subsystems is given by the absolute minimal surface according to , then the renormalized area is directly related to the mutual information @xmath91 which quantifies correlations between the disjoint subsystems . indeed , since the entanglement entropy @xmath92 of a single spherical domain @xmath8 is given by the area @xmath64 of the trivial hyperplaneboundary @xmath29 , , the renormalized area @xmath65 of the tube joining the boundaries of two such domains gives directly the mutual information @xmath93 , provided that the tube does give the minimal area , i.e. , for @xmath94 .
although the entanglement entropy changes continuously with the distance between the boundaries at @xmath90 , the corresponding minimal surface changes discontinuously . to move from the trivial phase to the tube - like phase continuously , one would have to start with two very close hyperplanes . at a point , where they almost touch
, a very deep tube - like surface can appear . by enlarging the distance of the boundaries ,
the tube starts to grow wider .
it follows the upper branch of the curve in fig . [
fig : area]c ( i.e. the non - physical phase ) up to the maximal possible distance @xmath89 of the boundaries . here
, one has to start decreasing the distance of the boundaries in such a way that the tube grows even wider ( following the lower branch in fig .
[ fig : area]c ) . after decreasing the distance under @xmath95 one obtains , in a continuous way , the physical tube - like phase . *
world - sheets of minimal surfaces . *
the vertical cylinder represents a 3 + 1 dimensional ads spacetime with the angular direction @xmath96 suppressed .
the world - sheet of one circular boundary is thus reduced only to two curves at infinity .
one circular boundary is localized in the left static region , the other in the right one .
( a ) two uniformly accelerated hyperplanes spanned on these circular boundaries .
killing horizons are indicated .
( b ) the world - sheet of the tube - like minimal surface joining the same circular boundaries.,title="fig:",width=148]*world - sheets of minimal surfaces . *
the vertical cylinder represents a 3 + 1 dimensional ads spacetime with the angular direction @xmath96 suppressed .
the world - sheet of one circular boundary is thus reduced only to two curves at infinity .
one circular boundary is localized in the left static region , the other in the right one .
( a ) two uniformly accelerated hyperplanes spanned on these circular boundaries .
killing horizons are indicated .
( b ) the world - sheet of the tube - like minimal surface joining the same circular boundaries.,title="fig:",width=148 ] + ( a)(b ) + the fact that the tube - like minimal surface does not exist for too distant boundaries can be explored also in a dynamical way . although we consider only static situations
calculation of the minimal surface area given in a spatial section of a static region of the ads spacetime we can take advantage of the rich structure of ads symmetries and investigate the situation which looks rather dynamical in the global picture .
let us consider a static killing vector with orbits that have an acceleration larger than @xmath97 .
this killing vector has a bifurcation character similar to the boost killing vector in the minkowski spacetime .
its killing horizons divide the ads space into pairs of static regions positioned acausally with respect to each other , with non - static regions between , cf .
[ fig : ads]a . the hyperbolic space in which we found the tube - like solution is a spatial section of both opposite static regions .
we can position one circular boundary at infinity of one static region and the other one at infinity of the opposite static region .
the world - sheets of the corresponding hyperplanes describe uniformly accelerated motion along the killing vector , see fig .
[ fig : ads]a .
the tube - like minimal surface can be also evolved into both static regions .
however , it does reach the killing horizons and there it must be extended into non - static regions .
the resulting surface is depicted in fig .
[ fig : ads]b .
we see that the surface is non - smooth along two spatial edges , one describing the formation of the surface in the past , the other its termination in the future .
if the surface is viewed from the perspective of a globally static observer ( the vertical direction in the figure ) , the future edge can be interpreted as a tear - off line for the boundaries positioned too far from each other and the subsequent motion of the separate pieces . for more details ,
see @xcite . beside the case of two
spherical domains we can investigate even more complicated situations : let us consider spherical domains @xmath98 , each of them a subdomain of all the subsequent ones : @xmath99 for @xmath100 .
they do not have to be all simultaneously concentric .
the circular boundaries of these domains correspond to ultraparallel hyperplanes in the bulk .
for such a configuration we know the minimal surfaces for any pair of the boundaries .
employing we find that the renormalized entropy depends only on the distance of the boundaries , cf . , . we can thus test properties of the entropy for domains obtained by a combination of several subdomains .
namely , one can check the strong subadditivity inequalities to find that they are satisfied , as expected from general considerations @xcite .
similarly one can study systems of strips between several semicircles joined at the same poles . summarizing ,
we have found exact analytical solutions for minimal surfaces in ads for two disjoint domains at infinity .
these classical geometrical solutions reveal the existence of different phases that reflect a phase transition in the corresponding quantum cft , similar to the confinement / deconfinement phase transition at a finite temperature @xcite .
the holographic entanglement entropy becomes an effective tool for testing phase transitions in cft .
note that calculations in purely classical gravity provide an insight to non - trivial quantum properties of the corresponding field theories .
p. k. was supported by grant gar p203/12/0118 and appreciates the hospitality of the tpi of the university of alberta .
a. z. thanks the natural sciences and engineering research council of canada and the killam trust for financial support and appreciates the hospitality of the itp fmp of charles university in prague .
the authors thank don page and martin ofka for usefull comments on the paper .
35ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12&12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1007/bf01877517 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.34.373 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.48.4545 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.71.666 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.51.1741 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.50.2700 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop * * , ( ) @noop ( ) , , link:\doibase 10.1016/s0550 - 3213(96)00678 - 5 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1016/s0920 - 5632(97)00373 - 3 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.96.181602 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/1126 - 6708/2006/08/045 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/1751 - 8113/42/50/504008 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/1126 - 6708/2006/09/018 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop ( ) , , @noop ( ) , , link:\doibase 10.1007/jhep08(2013)090 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop ( ) , , link:\doibase 10.1007/jhep04(2011)025 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1007/jhep05(2011)036 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1007/jhep06(2013)013 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1007/jhep08(2013)012 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1007/jhep08(2011)039 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop * * , ( ) , link:\doibase 10.1016/j.nuclphysb.2007.12.017 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1007/jhep05(2012)032 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/1126 - 6708/2007/02/042 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevd.76.106013 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/1126 - 6708/2008/03/006 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop `` , '' , link:\doibase 10.1007/jhep01(2011)125 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/0264 - 9381/29/15/153001 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop _ _ ( , , ) link:\doibase 10.1007/jhep05(2011)004 [ * * , ( ) ] , | it was proposed by ryu and takayanagi that the entanglement entropy in conformal field theory ( cft ) is related through the ads / cft correspondence to the area of a minimal surface in the bulk .
we apply this holographic geometrical method of calculating the entanglement entropy to study the vacuum case of a cft which is holographically dual to empty anti - de sitter ( ads ) spacetime .
we present all possible minimal surfaces spanned on one or two spherical boundaries at ads infinity .
we give exact analytical expressions for the regularized areas of these surfaces and identify finite renormalized quantities . in the case of two disjoint boundaries
the existence of two different phases of the entanglement entropy is confirmed @xcite .
a trivial phase corresponds to two disconnected minimal surfaces , while the other one corresponds to a tube connecting the spherical boundaries .
a transition between these phases is reminiscent of the finite temperature deconfinement transition in the cft on the boundary .
the exact analytical results are thus consistent with previous numerical and approximate computations
. we also briefly discuss the character of a spacetime extension of the minimal surface spanned on two uniformly accelerated boundaries . |
we live in a dusty universe ( hoover 1998 , private communication ) , and correcting for the dust extinction and reddening affects almost all aspects of optical astronomy . for us , observing from within the milky way , it is of crucial importance to know how much galactic dust there is towards various objects .
burstein & hailes ( 1982 ; hereafter : bh ) constructed an all - sky reddening map , used extensively by the astronomical community .
recently , schlegel , finkbeiner & davis ( 1998 ; hereafter : sfd ) published a new all - sky reddening map , based on the cobe / dirbe and iras / issa maps .
this map is intended to supersede the bh map in both the accuracy and the spatial resolution ( @xmath3 ) .
also , unlike the bh map , which presented the @xmath1 values only for the @xmath4 regions , the sfd map extends all the way to the galactic plane .
there are many instances when one would like to be able to identify low - reddening regions near the galactic plane . as an example , the expected microlensing optical depth increases strongly towards the galactic center ( e.g. stanek et al .
1997 , their figure 12 ) . in this paper
i show the usefulness of the sfd map for selecting low - reddening regions close to the galactic plane . in section 2
i compare the predicted and the observed reddenings and arrive at the approximate scaling relation . in section 3
i show the re - scaled reddening map for central region of our galaxy and discuss its applications for microlensing experiments .
with its high spatial accuracy , the sfd map is potentially very useful for selecting low - reddening windows close to the galactic plane .
however , as discussed by sfd , at low galactic latitudes ( @xmath0 ) most of the contaminating sources have not been removed from their map .
also , no comparisons between the predicted reddenings and observed reddenings have been made in these regions .
it is therefore important to attempt such a comparison .
harris ( 1996 ) surveyed the vast literature on the galactic globular clusters ( gcs ) , producing an electronic catalog of gcs with reasonably well - known properties , among them the reddening @xmath1 .
many galactic globular clusters are extensively studied objects , for which it is possible to accurately determine their extinction and reddening using a variety of methods ( burstein & heiles 1978 ; webbink 1985 ; zinn 1985 ; reed , hesser & shawl 1988 ) . however , many gcs in harris ( 1996 ) compilation have been poorly studied , in which cases the reddening estimates are rather inaccurate . there are 147 gcs in the catalog of harris ( 1996 ) , out of which i selected 32 clusters with @xmath0 .
i then excluded eight clusters with the distance from the galactic plane @xmath5 , to ensure that each cluster remaining in the sample probes most of the reddening along the line of sight ( see discussion in stanek 1998 ) . for the remaining 24 clusters i used the program `` dust_getval '' included with the sfd reddening map to obtain the value of reddening predicted by the sfd , which i hereafter call @xmath6
this was done by obtaining 49 values of @xmath6 on a uniform @xmath7 grid with @xmath8 spacing centered on the cluster ( @xmath9 part of the sky ) , which allowed me to obtain an average value of @xmath6 as well as its standard deviation @xmath10 . at this point
i excluded additional five gcs with @xmath11mag , indicating large reddening gradient across the cluster ( stanek 1998 ) , which might strongly affect the determined reddening .
this leaves me with 19 gcs with which i can test the sfd map for the @xmath0 region .
i denote the gcs reddenings taken from the catalog of harris by @xmath12 .
additional comparison comes from using the reddening map of baade s window ( bw ) region ( stanek 1996 ) .
this map was constructed using the method of woniak & stanek ( 1996 ) and the ogle project data ( szymaski & udalski 1993 ; udalski et al .
the zero point of baade s window reddening map was re - determined recently by gould , popowski & terndrup ( 1998 ) and alcock et al .
i obtained 240 values of @xmath6 on a uniform grid with @xmath8 spacing , falling within the bw map .
for the same grid i also obtained the values of @xmath13 using my map of the reddening . using the relations between the selective extinction coefficients given by sfd ( their table 6 ) and also the coefficient of @xmath14 found by stanek ( 1996 )
, i then converted the @xmath13 reddening to @xmath15 using relation @xmath16 . in figure
[ fig : sfd ] i plot the relation between the observed values of the reddening @xmath17 , obtained using globular clusters with @xmath0 from catalog of harris ( 1996 ) and the reddening map of baade s window ( stanek 1996 ) , and the predicted reddening @xmath6 obtained using the sfd map .
large symbols denote the clusters , with @xmath10 as errorbars , and small symbols denote points from baade s window .
the observed reddenings @xmath12 extend from 0.25 to 1.75 . using linear least - squares fit to both the gcs and the bw samples i obtained the scaling relation @xmath18 , while using only the gcs i obtained a relation @xmath19 .
since the typical error of the @xmath15 values is @xmath20mag ( stanek 1996 ) , i feel that using both samples gives a better estimate of the scaling relation , so hereafter i adopt @xmath21 as representing the `` true '' reddening for the @xmath0 region .
it should be stressed here that there is no physical reason for _ one _ `` universal '' relation of the kind fitted above , so the adopted scaling factor of 1.35 should be applied carefully , only when there are no additional constraints on the reddening .
also , as the comparison range of the @xmath12 extends only to 1.75 , the derived scaling might not apply in high reddening regions very close to the galactic plane ( @xmath22 ) . finally , for regions with @xmath23 this scaling factor _ should not _ be applied ( sfd ; stanek 1998 ) , as the sfd map is cleaned from the point sources in these regions .
i can now apply the sfd map and the scaling factor obtained in the previous section to investigate the reddening close to the galactic plane . in figure
[ fig : dust ] i plot the @xmath1 reddening map of @xmath24 part of the the galactic center .
contours correspond to re - scaled @xmath25mag .
as discussed above , the comparison range of the @xmath12 extends only to 1.75 , so the derived scaling of @xmath2 might not apply in high reddening regions very close to the galactic plane ( @xmath22 ) .
also , the sfd map gives by its construction the total dust reddening along given line of sight , which for regions close to the galactic plane might have significant contribution from dust distributed beyond the observed source .
the spatial structure of reddening seen in figure [ fig : dust ] is very rich , both on large and small scales .
some of the features , such as more dust extinction above the galactic plane than below the plane , are well known and can be observed even with a naked eye .
there is a pronounced `` pinch '' in the reddening at the @xmath26 longitude , where some of the iso - reddening contours are @xmath27 closer to the galactic plane than elsewhere in the map . in a low - reddening window near
@xmath28 the rescaled reddening is as low as @xmath29mag . also worth noticing is low - reddening region near @xmath30 with the rescaled reddening as low as @xmath31mag .
it is interesting to compare the locations of the fields observed towards the galactic bulge by the ogle ii ( figure [ fig : micro ] , upper panel ) and by the macho ( figure [ fig : micro ] , lower panel ) microlensing experiments ( udalski , kubiak & szymaski 1997 ; alcock et al .
both experiments cover similar areas on the sky ( @xmath32 ) and show significant overlap with each other , with ogle ii taking somewhat better advantage of low - extinction regions close to the galactic center ( such as the window near @xmath28 discussed above ) . however , ogle ii fields are much better distributed for applications of their data for the galactic structure studies , such as investigating the properties of the galactic bar with the red clump giants ( stanek et al .
1997 ) . we might attempt to define an `` optimal '' selection of fields to be used for the microlensing studies .
this selection naturally depends on the scientific goal of a given study . to maximize the observed microlensing optical depth during the lifetime of the experiment ,
i define `` reddening - adjusted optical depth '' as @xmath33},\ ] ] where @xmath34 is the standard optical depth for microlensing and the factor @xmath35}$ ] is used to reduce @xmath34 in regions of high reddening ( and hence extinction ) .
the coefficient @xmath36 in the exponent can be adjusted to reflect , for example , a photometric band used for observations . to give an example , the microlensing optical depth is highest towards the galactic center , yet because of the high dust extinction there it is not a good place to monitor microlensing . in figure
[ fig : tau ] i plot @xmath37 , using the rescaled sfd map as the source of reddening @xmath1 and the optical depth from the bar model e2 of stanek et al .
( 1997 , their figure 12 ) as the source of @xmath34 ( the contribution from the galactic disk to the microlensing was not included ) .
i took @xmath38 for simplicity . in practice ,
as current microlensing experiments operate in crowding - limited mode , the reddening - adjusted optical depth defined above is not optimal from their point of view .
however , with the progressing development of image - subtraction techniques ( see recent papers by alard & lupton 1998 and tomaney 1998 ) one will be able to detect the microlensing events regardless of crowding . to summarize , the sfd map overestimates the reddening in @xmath0 regions by a factor of @xmath2 , but it is a very valuable tool in investigating features in the reddening near the galactic plane .
i limited myself to investigating the central part of our galaxy , but the sfd map should be also useful for similar studies in other parts of the galactic plane . | recently schlegel , finkbeiner & davis published an all - sky reddening map based on the cobe / dirbe and iras / issa infrared sky surveys . using the reddening map of baade s window and sample of 19 low - latitude ( @xmath0 ) galactic globular clusters
i find that the dirbe / iras reddening map overestimates @xmath1 at low galactic latitudes by a factor of @xmath2 .
i also demonstrate the usefulness of this high resolution map for selecting low - reddening windows near the galactic plane . |
differential equations with fractional derivatives are used for modeling non - markovian processes in various areas of science such as physics , biology and economics [ 1 - 5 ] .
the methods for analytical solution of ordinary and partial fractional differential equations can be applied to only special types of equations and initial conditions . in practical applications
the solutions of the fractional differential equations are determined by numerical methods .
the development of efficient methods for numerical solution of fractional differential equations is an active research field .
an important approximation for the caputo fractional derivative is the @xmath0 approximation .
it has been successfully used for numerical solution of ordinary and partial fractional differential equations .
when the function @xmath1 is a smooth function , the accuracy of the @xmath0 approximation is @xmath2 . in previous work
@xcite we determined the second order approximation by modifying the first three coefficients of the @xmath0 approximation with the value of the riemann zeta function at the point @xmath3 , and we computed the numerical solutions of the fractional relaxation and subdiffusion equations with sufficiently differentiable solutions .
the solutions of fractional differential equations often have a singularity at the initial point . in this case
the numerical solutions may converge to the exact solution but their accuracy may be lower than the expected accuracy from the numerical analysis . in this paper
we propose a method for improving the accuracy of the numerical solutions of the fractional relaxation equation @xmath4 where @xmath5 , and the fractional subdiffusion equation @xmath6,t>0 , & \\
u(x,0)=\sin x,\;u(0,t)=0,\;u(\pi , t)=0 .
\end{array } \right .\ ] ] when the solutions of the relaxation and subdiffusion equations are smooth functions the accuracy of the numerical solutions using the @xmath0 approximation are @xmath2 and @xmath7 and the numerical solutions using the modified @xmath0 approximation have accuracy @xmath8 and @xmath9 .
the solutions of the fractional relaxation and subdiffusion equations and have differentiable singularities at the initial point . the accuracy of the numerical solutions and of the fractional relaxation equation is @xmath10 and the numerical solutions and of the fractional subdiffusion equation have accuracy @xmath11 .
equations and are linear fractional differential equations .
the form of the equations allows us to compute the miller - ross derivatives of the solutions at the initial point . in section 3 and section 4
we use the fractional taylor polynomials to improve the differentiability properties of the solutions and the accuracy of the numerical methods .
the caputo derivative of order @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is defined as @xmath14 when the function @xmath15 is defined on the interval @xmath16 $ ] , the lower limit of the integral in the definition of caputo derivative is @xmath17 .
the value of the fractional derivative @xmath18 depends on the values of the function on the whole interval of definition .
one approach for discretizing the caputo derivative is to divide the interval to subintervals of small length and approximate the derivative of the function @xmath1 using spline interpolation or a lagrange polynomial @xcite .
let @xmath19 be a small positive number .
denote @xmath20 the @xmath0 approximation for caputo derivative is derived @xcite by approximating the derivative of the function @xmath1 on the interval @xmath21}$ ] with its value @xmath22 at the midpoint of the interval .
@xmath23 where @xmath24 and @xmath25 when the function @xmath1 has a continuous second derivative , the accuracy of the @xmath0 approximation is @xmath26 ( @xcite ) .
the modified @xmath0 approximation for the caputo derivative @xmath27 has coefficients @xmath28 for @xmath29 , @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the riemann zeta function .
the modified @xmath0 approximation has accuracy @xmath32 . by approximating the caputo derivative at the point @xmath33 with and we obtain the numerical solutions and of the fractional relaxation equation . in table 1 and table 2
we compute the maximum error and the order of the numerical solutions and for the following equations @xmath34 @xmath35 equations and have solutions @xmath36 and @xmath37 .
the solution of equation has an unbounded second derivative at @xmath38 . while the numerical solutions of equation converge to the exact solution , their accuracy is smaller than @xmath2 .
99 a. cartea , d. del castillo - negrete , fractional diffusion models of option prices in markets with jumps .
physica a , 374(2 ) ( 2007 ) , 749763 .
o. marom , e. momoniat , a comparison of numerical solutions of fractional diffusion models in finance , nonlinear analysis : real world applications , 140(6 ) ( 2009 ) , 34353442 .
f , mainardi , fractional relaxation - oscillation and fractional diffusion - wave phenomena , chaos , solitons @xmath40 fractals , 7(9 ) ( 1996 ) , 1461 1477
. s. i. muslih , om p. agrawal , d. baleanu , a fractional schrdinger equation and its solution , international journal of theoretical physics , 49(8 ) ( 2010 ) , 17461752 . p. m. lima , n. j. ford , and p. m. lumb , computational methods for a mathematical model of propagation of nerve impulses in myelinated axons , applied numerical mathematics 85 , ( 2014 ) , 3853 .
w. deng , c. li , numerical schemes for fractional ordinary differential equations , in numerical modeling , peep miidla ( editor ) .
intech ; 2012 .
k. diethelm , the analysis of fractional differential equations : an application - oriented exposition using differential operators of caputo type .
springer ; 2010 .
miller , b. ross , an introduction to the fractional calculus and fractional differential equations .
john wiley & sons , new york ; 1993 .
i. podlubny , fractional differential equations . academic press , san diego ; 1999 .
a. el - ajou , o. arqub , z. zhour and s. momani , new results on fractional power series : theory and applications , entropy , 15 , ( 2013 ) , 5305 - 5323
. j. cao , c. xu , a high order schema for the numerical solution of the fractional ordinary differential equations , journal of computational physics , 238(1 ) , ( 2013 ) , 154168 .
y. dimitrov , numerical approximations for fractional differential equations , journal of fractional calculus and applications , 5(3s ) , ( 2014 ) , no .
22 , 145 .
y. dimitrov , a second order approximation for the caputo fractional derivative , arxiv:1502.00719 , ( 2015 ) .
m. glsu , y. ztrk , a. anapal , numerical approach for solving fractional relaxation oscillation equation , applied mathematical modelling 37 , ( 2013 ) 59275937 .
h. hejazi , t. moroney , f. liu , stability and convergence of a finite volume method for the space fractional advection dispersion equation , journal of computational and applied mathematics , 255 , ( 2014 ) , 684 697 .
b.jin , r. lazarov and z. zhou , an analysis of the @xmath0 scheme for the subdiffusion equation with nonsmooth data , arxiv:1501.00253 , ( 2015 ) . c. li , a. chen , j. ye , numerical approaches to fractional calculus and fractional ordinary differential equation , journal of computational physics , 230(9 ) , ( 2011 ) , 3352 3368 .
y. lin and c. xu .
finite difference / spectral approximations for the time - fractional diffusion equation .
journal of computational physics , 225(2 ) , ( 2007 ) , 15331552 .
r. lin , f. liu , fractional high order methods for the nonlinear fractional ordinary differential equation , nonlinear analysis : theory , methods & applications , 66(4 ) , ( 2007 ) , 856869 .
n. f. martins , m. l. morgado and m. rebelo , a meshfree numerical method for the time - fractional diffusion equation , proceedings of the 13th international conference on computational and mathematical methods in science and engineering , cmmse 2013 , 2427 june , 2013 .
yuste , j. quintana - murillo , a finite difference method with non - uniform timesteps for fractional diffusion equations , computer physics communications , 182 , 2594 ( 2012 ) j. quintana - murillo , s.b .
yuste , a finite difference method with non - uniform timesteps for fractional diffusion and diffusion - wave equations , eur .
j. special topics 222 , ( 2013 ) , 19871998 .
b.jin , r. lazarov and z. zhou , two fully discrete schemes for fractional diffusion and diffusion - wave equations , arxiv:1404.3800 , ( 2015 ) .
z. odibat , n. shawagfeh , generalized taylor s formula , applied mathematics and computation 186 , ( 2007 ) , 286293 . t. j. osler , taylor s series generalized for fractional derivatives and applications , siam j. math .
anal . , 2(1 ) , ( 1971 ) , 37-48 .
j. e. peari , i. peri , h.m .
srivastava , a family of the cauchy type mean - value theorems , journal of mathematical analysis and applications , 306(2 ) , ( 2005 ) , 730739 .
m. stynes , j. l. gracia , boundary layers in a two - point boundary value problem with a caputo fractional derivative , comput .
methods appl .
, 15 ( 1 ) , ( 2015 ) , 7995 .
sun , x. wu , a fully discrete scheme for a diffusion wave system , applied numerical mathematics , 56(2 ) , ( 2006 ) , 193209 .
j. rena , z .- z .
sun , maximum norm error analysis of difference schemes for fractional diffusion equations , applied mathematics and computation , 256 , ( 2015 ) 299314 .
trujillo , m. rivero , b. bonilla , on a riemann liouville generalized taylor s formula , journal of mathematical analysis and applications , 231(1 ) , ( 1999 ) , 255265 .
p. zhuang , f. liu , implicit difference approximation for the time fractional diffusion equation , journal of applied mathematics and computing , 22(3 ) , ( 2006 ) , 8799 . | the accuracy of the numerical solution of a fractional differential equation depends on the differentiability class of the solution .
the derivatives of the solutions of fractional differential equations often have a singularity at the initial point , which may result in a lower accuracy of the numerical solutions .
we propose a method for improving the accuracy of the numerical solutions of the fractional relaxation and subdiffusion equations based on the fractional taylor polynomials of the solution at the initial point . + * ams subject classification : * 33f05 , 34a08 , 57r10 + * key words : * fractional differential equation , caputo derivative , numerical solution , fractional taylor polynomial . |
experiments of ultrarelativistic heavy ion collisions performed at bnls relativistic heavy ion collider ( rhic ) create a hot and dense medium of quarks , antiquarks and gluons called the quark - gluon plasma ( qgp ) @xcite .
the understanding of the transport properties of the qgp , and the nature of confinement and the phase transition from this system to interacting hadrons is a central topic of modern high - energy physics .
one of the most important discoveries at rhic is the large elliptic flow in non - central au+au collisions , which is a clear indication of collective behavior .
this implies that the qgp has a very low viscosity - to - entropy ratio @xmath0 not much larger than the ads / cft lower bound @xmath1 @xcite . by now
, it is generally agreed that the qgp thermalizes on times @xmath2 2.5 fm / c and that it behaves as a fluid with one of the lowest viscosity - to - entropy ratios ever observed in nature @xmath3/s @xmath2 0.5 @xcite .
the evolution of the fireball created at rhic has been described efficiently using relativistic hydrodynamics @xcite .
ideal hydrodynamics has been partly successful in explaining the observed collective flow at low transverse momentum and in central collisions @xcite
. however , it is difficult to fit the data with it when a realistic equation of state ( eos ) is used ; see @xcite .
the relativistic generalization of the navier - stokes equation is plagued with causality and stability problems @xcite , so one must use the so - called second - order theories ( sots ) @xcite .
these theories rely on an expansion of the viscous tensor in velocity gradients , neglecting all orders higher than the second .
they are unreliable in situations where these gradients are strong , and indeed they are known to fail , for example , in the description of strong shocks @xcite .
it is then valuable to develop alternative theories , not limited to weak velocity gradients , to provide at least an estimate of the expected accuracy of the gradient expansion . with these aims in mind , in @xcite one of the authors and e. calzetta developed an hydrodynamical description of a conformal field within the framework of the divergence - type theories ( dtt ) developed by geroch @xcite ( see also @xcite ) .
dtts do not rely on velocity gradient expansions and therefore go beyond second - order theories .
this formalism was then applied in @xcite to study au+au collisions , obtaining results in good agreement with sots and with data on elliptic flow .
it was found that the nonequilibrium correction to the particle distribution function ( which is obtained from grad s quadratic ansatz ) is considerably larger in the dtt .
this fact introduces significant uncertainty in the values of @xmath0 that can be inferred by matching the result of different dissipative hydrodynamic theories to hadron multiplicity , @xmath4 and elliptic flow data . in this paper
we focus on the spectra of thermal photons which are produced during the evolution of the fireball created in au+au collisions at @xmath5 gev .
thermal photons are produced during the entire space - time evolution of fireball , but , since they participate only in electromagnetic interactions , they have a larger mean free path compared to the transverse size of the hot and dense matter created in nuclear collisions .
therefore , photons created in the interior of the plasma pass through the surrounding matter without any interaction , providing information on properties of bulk matter and not only on its surface . for these reasons , the emission of photons has become a useful signature of the qgp and is currently being intensively studied .
see @xcite .
thermal photon spectra have been studied within the framework of ideal hydrodynamics ( see @xcite and references therein ) and using the israel - stewart formalism @xcite .
recently , baeuchle and bleicher @xcite have calculated photon spectra using a hydro - kinetic hybrid approach in combination with the ultra - relativistic quantum molecular dynamics ( urqmd ) transport model in 3 + 1 dimensions @xcite . moreover ,
the radial and elliptic flows , as well as the spectra and the correlations of photons are becoming a useful tool to measure or to further constrain the value of @xmath0 of the nuclear matter created at rhic , as has been shown by several recent works @xcite .
our purpose here is to compare the thermal photon spectra obtained using the sot and the dtt 2 + 1 hydrodynamics to model the evolution of the fireball , both for an ideal and a realistic eos which includes a qgp - hadron analytic crossover as suggested by lattice qcd calculations .
to this aim , we calculate the spectra of produced thermal photons in au+au collisions considering the processes of compton scattering , @xmath6-annihilation and bremsstrahlung in the qgp phase , and @xmath7 , @xmath8 and @xmath9 in the hadron phase .
the nonequilibrium contribution to photon production due to finite shear viscosity ( both in the qgp and hadronic phases ) is taken into account through grad s quadratic ansatz .
very recently bhatt , mishra and sreekanth @xcite have calculated photon spectra including viscous corrections during the qgp phase using israel - stewart hydrodynamics and taking into account both shear and bulk viscosity , while dusling @xcite has calculated the nonequilibrium correction to photon production due to compton scattering and @xmath6 annihilation at leading - log order .
we will compare our results to those of @xcite later on .
we find that the use of a realistic equation of state significantly enhances the photon spectra , in line with the results of previous calculations ( see for instance @xcite ) .
the spectrum calculated in the dtt turns out to be considerably larger than the one calculated in the sot .
the difference in the spectra calculated in both formalisms is entirely due to differences in the nonequilibrium correction to photon production , which is considerably larger in the dtt .
our results indicate that differences in hydrodynamic formalisms constitute an important source of uncertainty in the precise determination of @xmath0 from observables , such as photon spectra , that depend on the nonequilibrium distribution function .
it has been shown before @xcite that the nonequilibrium correction to the distribution function has also a strong influence on hadronic observables .
the calculation of photon and hadron observables using different hydrodynamic models and its matching to data may therefore provide a way of constraining the form of the nonequilibrium correction to the distribution function and thus help improve the description of the freeze - out process @xcite .
we note that in our calculations we neglect bulk viscosity , which is known from lattice qcd simulations to become significant near the critical temperature @xcite .
it has been shown in @xcite that bulk viscosity influences the space - time evolution of the fireball created in heavy - ion collisions , thus modifying the thermal photon spectra and increasing photon production @xcite .
the distribution function gets an additional correction coming from the bulk viscosity , which also modifies the spectra and puts severe limitations to the reliability of grad s quadratic ansatz @xcite .
moreover , we do not take into account prompt photons from hard scatterings of partons in the initial nuclei @xcite nor jet - medium photons @xcite and we only consider thermal photons .
for these reasons , we do not attempt to carry out a comparison with rhic data @xcite , but we focus instead on the comparison between different viscous hydrodynamic formalisms and on the influence on thermal photon spectra of the viscous correction to the distribution function . the paper is organized as follows . in section [ th ]
we briefly describe the hydrodynamic formalisms used to model the fireball evolution , and then describe the processes taken into account in the calculation of photon spectra , including viscous corrections .
we present and discuss our results in section [ res ] , and conclude in section [ sum ] .
in this section we present the hydrodynamic equations of the sot and of the dtt for boost - invariant flow in @xmath10 dimensions , for a conformal fluid .
we will consider the sot developed @xcite , which is based on conformal invariance and generalizes the israel - stewart formalism .
we employ milne coordinates defined by proper time @xmath11 and rapidity @xmath12 .
the fluid velocity is @xmath13 and is normalized as @xmath14 .
the stress - energy tensor for dissipative relativistic hydrodynamics is @xmath15 where @xmath16 and @xmath17 are the energy density and the pressure in the local rest frame , and @xmath18 is the viscous shear tensor which is transverse ( @xmath19 ) , traceless and symmetric .
the tensor @xmath20 is the spatial projector orthogonal to @xmath21 . for a conformal fluid we have @xmath22 , so @xmath23 and the bulk viscosity vanishes . in what follows
, latin indices stand for transverse coordinates @xmath24 , @xmath25 is the geometric covariant derivative , @xmath26 and @xmath27 are the comoving time and space derivatives , respectively , @xmath28 are the christoffel symbols and @xmath29 denote the spatial , symmetric and traceless projection of a tensor .
the hydrodynamic equations read @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the speed of sound , @xmath32 is the first - order shear tensor , and @xmath33 in the sot , the evolution of the shear tensor is given by @xcite @xmath34 where @xmath3 is the shear viscosity and @xmath35 are second - order transport coefficients . in a dtt , the description of nonequilibrium hydrodynamic states requires the introduction of a new tensor @xmath36 which is symmetric , traceless and vanishes in equilibrium @xcite .
the evolution for @xmath37 reads @xcite @xmath38 and the shear tensor is calculated from the nonequilibrium tensor @xmath36 as follows @xmath39 as independent variables we choose @xmath40 for the sot and @xmath41 for the dtt .
the @xmath42 component of the velocity follows from normalization , while the other nontrivial components of @xmath18 ( and of @xmath37 ) follow from the transversality and tracelessness conditions .
we use vanishing initial transverse velocity and shear tensor , and set the initialization time @xmath43 1 fm / c and the initial and freeze - out temperatures @xmath44 mev and @xmath45 mev , respectively .
the initial energy density profile is calculated using glauber s model @xcite ( see @xcite for details ) . in all calculations we set the impact parameter @xmath46 3 fm , and we use a 13 fm @xmath47 13 fm transverse plane and values for the second - order transport coefficients corresponding to a strongly - coupled @xmath48 4 super - yang mills ( sym ) plasma @xcite : @xmath49 and @xmath50 , where @xmath51 is the entropy density . in order to calculate the photon spectra , we take the critical temperature to be @xmath52 170 mev which is consistent with recent lattice qcd calculations ( see @xcite and references therein ) . the set of hydrodynamic equations must be closed with an equation of state .
we employ two different eos : the one computed by laine and schrder @xcite , which connects a high - order weak - coupling perturbative qcd calculation at high temperatures to a hadron resonance gas at low temperatures via an analytic crossover ( as suggested by lattice qcd calculations @xcite ) , and an ideal one with @xmath53 . in fig .
[ fig1 ] we reproduce the realistic eos ( which we will call lqcd eos in what follows ) , showing the square of the velocity of sound @xmath54 as a function of temperature .
we note that using the lqcd eos and these values for @xmath55 , @xmath56 and @xmath57 , data on kaon elliptic flow , @xmath4 and total multiplicity can be consistently reproduced both within the sot and the dtt @xcite . in this paper
we consider thermal photon production due to the processes of compton scattering , @xmath6 annihilation and bremsstrahlung in the qgp phase , and @xmath7 , @xmath8 and @xmath9 in the hadron phase . for a review on photon production in the context of heavy - ion collisions
see @xcite .
the compton scattering and @xmath6 annihilation contribution is @xcite @xmath58 where @xmath59 0.23 , @xmath60 and @xcite @xmath61 where @xmath62 is the number of quark flavors . in the summation @xmath63 stands for quark flavor while @xmath64 is the electric charge of the quark in units of the charge of the electron .
the rate due to @xmath6 annihilation with an additional scattering in the thermalized medium is given by @xmath65 where @xmath66 1.11 , @xmath67 1.06 .
the rate of photon production due to bremsstrahlung reads @xcite @xmath68 \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath69 is the zeta function and li@xmath70 are polylogarithmic functions . in order to calculate the photon spectrum from the fireball when the lqcd eos is used ,
one has to know also the photon production rate from the hot hadron gas since photons will also be emitted from this thermal phase following the qgp .
we use the simple estimate for the photon production rate given by steffen and thoma @xcite , which reproduces the sum of production rates for the processes @xmath7 , @xmath8 and @xmath9 calculated in @xcite .
the estimate for the production rate reads @xmath71 the photon production rates just described are calculated with the equilibrium distribution function within boltzmann s approximation , hence the factor @xmath72 .
however , it is well known that viscous effects lead to the modification of the thermal distribution functions which in turn modify observables such as hadronic elliptic flow @xcite .
these modifications may also have significant observational effects on the photon spectra as has been shown recently @xcite .
it is therefore interesting to incorporate the viscous correction to the distribution function and asses its impact on final photon spectra . to this end
, we calculate the photon production rates using the nonequilibrium distribution function coming from grad s ansatz which is given by @xcite @xmath73 with @xmath74 the fermi - dirac function , and compare with the results obtained by using the equilibrium distribution function .
it is known that grad s ansatz becomes unrealible at high transverse momentum @xmath75 3@xmath764 gev @xcite and for this reason we will restrict to lower values of @xmath77 in what follows . the total thermal photon spectrum is obtained by integrating the sum of the production rates for each process given above over the space - time evolution of the fireball created in the collision .
it is given by @xmath78 where @xmath79 are the initial and final time one is interested in , @xmath80 is the rapidity of the nuclei , @xmath81 and @xmath77 is the transverse momentum .
note that the photon energy in the comoving frame is given by @xmath82 .
we now present our results on photon spectra , in all cases at midrapidity @xmath83 . in fig .
[ figspec ] we show the total thermal photon spectra calculated with the sot and the dtt for @xmath84 0.3 , both for the ideal eos and for the lqcd eos , and including or not the nonequilibrium correction to the distribution function .
we do not show the spectra calculated with the dtt for the ideal eos because it is very similar to that obtained in the sot .
it is seen that the spectra strongly depend on the eos used , being two orders of magnitude smaller in the case of the ideal eos .
this is a consequence of the fact that the hydrodynamic evolution of the plasma is slower when the realistic eos is used and hence more thermal photons are produced ( see @xcite ) .
besides , as already shown in @xcite , the effect of the nonequilibrium correction to the distribution function is to harden the spectra .
going over to the comparison between the sot and dtt , it is seen that the differences in the spectra arise entirely from the nonequilibrium corrections that become important only at @xmath85 1 gev .
the spectrum obtained from the dtt is significantly larger , and the difference in spectra increases with increasing @xmath77 .
as we will show in what follows , this is due to the fact that the nonequilibrium corrections to the distribution function are larger in the dtt , and therefore the viscous correction to photon production is larger too ( for a discussion of this point in the context of hadronic elliptic flow see @xcite ) . in fig .
[ speceta ] we compare the total photon spectra obtained with the lqcd eos in the dtt and the sot with @xmath86 0.3 and @xmath86 0.5 .
it is seen that the spectra is strongly dependent on the value of @xmath0 , in agreement with the results of @xcite .
moreover , the difference in spectra corresponding to @xmath86 0.3 and @xmath86 0.5 is slightly larger in the dtt , showing that the latter formalism is more sensitive to changes in the value of the viscosity - to - entropy ratio .
it is interesting to note that the spectra obtained in the sot with @xmath86 0.5 is very similar to that obtained in the dtt with @xmath0 = 0.3 , which clearly indicates that differences in hydrodynamic formalisms constitute a significant source of uncertainty in the extraction of @xmath0 from photon spectra data .
a similar conclusion was found in @xcite with respect to the charged hadron elliptic flow , although in that case differences between the sot and the dtt have a smaller influence on the value of @xmath0 that can be extracted from data by matching to hydrodynamic results . in order to determine the influence of the nonequilibrium contribution on the different processes considered , in figs .
[ figqq]-[figh ] we show this contribution integrated over the evolution of the fireball in the sot and the dtt for @xmath84 0.3 , taking into account only the processes of @xmath6-annihilation and compton scattering , bremsstrahlung , or considering only the hadronic phase , respectively .
it is seen that in all three cases the nonequilibrium correction is significantly larger in the dtt .
the nonequilibrium correction to the spectra is larger in the hadronic phase at low @xmath77 , as is the difference between the dtt and the sot as it can be seen from fig .
[ figh ] . at larger values of @xmath77
the nonequilibrium correction is larger in the qgp phase .
the difference between the spectra calculated in the dtt and in the sot is almost independent of @xmath77 for the @xmath6-annihilation / compton scattering and bremsstrahlung processes , while in the hadronic phase it decreases with increasing transverse momentum .
the differences between the nonequilibrium contribution to photon spectra in the sot and in the dtt can be understood from fig .
[ ftau ] , where we show the nonequilibrium distribution function of eq .
( [ dis ] ) evaluated at @xmath87 and at @xmath88 3 fm / c as a function of @xmath77 for the dtt and the sot with @xmath0 = 0.3 and @xmath0 = 0.5 .
several interesting features , some of which were already discussed when showing our results on spectra , can be seen from the figure .
the difference between the dtt and the sot becomes appreciable at @xmath85 0.5 gev . beyond this value
it is seen that the distribution function in the dtt is considerably larger than the one in the sot .
moreover , the effect of increasing the value of @xmath0 is larger in the dtt , which reflects the fact that the viscous correction to @xmath89 is larger in the dtt . from these results
we conclude that the nonequilibrium contribution to photon production strongly modifies the spectra , even at low transverse momenta , resulting in harder spectra ( this is in line with the results of @xcite ) .
moreover , we have found that the difference between hydrodynamic formalisms leads to significant uncertainty in the extraction of @xmath0 from thermal photon spectra .
it has been shown before @xcite that the nonequilibrium correction to the distribution function has also a strong influence on hadronic observables , especially on the elliptic flow .
therefore , the calculation of photon and hadronic observables using different hydrodynamic models may provide a way of determining or at least constrain , albeit phenomenologically , the form of the nonequilibrium correction to the distribution function .
this may help improve the theoretical description of the freeze - out process , which is currently based on grad s quadratic ansatz ( see @xcite for recent developments ) .
we have calculated the spectra of thermal photons produced in au+au collisions taking into account the processes of compton scattering , @xmath6-annihilation and bremsstrahlung in the qgp phase , and @xmath7 , @xmath8 and @xmath9 in the hadron phase .
the calculation was done using two dissipative hydrodynamics formalisms to model the 2 + 1 evolution of the fireball , namely the second - order theory based on conformal invariance and a divergence - type theory .
we have focused on determining the influence of the nonequilibrium correction to the distribution function on photon production in both formalisms .
we have also compared the results obtained with an ideal and a realistic equation of state based on lattice qcd that includes an analytical crossover between the quark - gluon plasma and a resonance hadron gas . in agreement with previous studies ( @xcite )
we have found that the use of a realistic equation of state enhances the photon spectra , implying that the qgp - hadron crossover can not be neglected in the investigation of thermal photons . besides , the spectra calculated in the dtt is significantly enhanced with respect to the one calculated in the sot . the difference is entirely due to differences in the nonequilibrium corrections to photon production in both formalisms . our results point to the conclusion that differences in dissipative hydrodynamic formalisms are a significant source of uncertainty in the precise determination of @xmath0 from data , particularly from those observables , such as the one studied here , that depend on the nonequilibrium distribution function
. comparing our results with those obtained for the charged hadron elliptic flow and its matching to rhic data @xcite , we find that the difference in hydrodynamic formalisms used to calculate thermal photon spectra leads to a larger uncertainty in the possible extraction of @xmath0 from measured photon spectra .
it is interesting to note that the dependence of hadron or photon observables on the nonequilibrium correction to the distribution function , which leads to uncertainty in the extraction of @xmath0 from data , may in turn serve to constrain the form of the nonequilibrium distribution function . in this way one could gain some insight on the relation between kinetic theory and hydrodynamic models as well as on possible generalizations of grad s quadratic ansatz , and
help improve the theoretical description of the freeze - out process in heavy - ion collisions @xcite .
for this to be feasible , the theoretical uncertainties present in the hydrodynamic description of heavy - ion collisions , for example those regarding the initial conditions , must be under control . in this paper
we have limited ourselves to the case of vanishing bulk viscosity . as mentioned in the introduction ,
lattice qcd results indicate that the bulk viscosity becomes peaked at the critical temperature
. it would be interesting to include bulk viscosity in the dtt to determine its influence on thermal photon spectra in this hydrodynamic model .
99 p. romatschke , int . j. mod
e * 19 * , 1 ( 2010 ) ; u. heinz , arxiv:0901.4355 [ nucl - th ] ; a. muronga , phys .
c * 69 * , 034903 ( 2004 ) .
m. luzum , _ relativistic heavy ion collisions : viscous hydrodynamic simulations and final state interactions _ , phd thesis ( university of washington , 2009 ) , 0908.4100 [ nucl - th ] . h. song , _ causal viscous hydrodynamics for relativistic heavy ion collisions _ , phd thesis ( ohio state university , 2009 ) ,
0908.3656 [ nucl - th ] . k. adcox et al ( phenix collaboration ) , nuclear physics a * 757 * , 184 ( 2005 ) .
p. k. kovtun , d. t. son , and a. o. starinets , phys .
lett . * 94 * , 111601 ( 2005 ) ; d. t. son and a. o. starinets , annual review of nuclear and particle science , * 57 * , 95 ( 2007 )
. s. gavin and m. abdel - aziz , phys .
* 97 * , 162302 ( 2006 ) ; h. j. drescher , a. dumitru , c. gombeaud , and j. y. ollitrault , phys .
c * 76 * , 024905 ( 2007 ) ; a. k. chaudhuri , phys .
b * 681 * , 418 ( 2009 ) .
m. luzum and p. romatschke , phys .
c * 78 * , 034915 ( 2008 ) ; erratum - ibid.c * 79 * , 039903 ( 2009 ) .
j. peralta - ramos and e. calzetta , phys .
c * 82 * , 054905 ( 2010 ) .
e. calzetta and b .-
hu , _ nonequilibrium quantum field theory _
( cambridge university press , great britain , 2008 ) .
d. teaney , j. lauret , and e. v. shuryak , phys .
* 86 * , 4783 ( 2001 ) ; p. huovinen , p. f. kolb , u. w. heinz , p. v. ruuskanen , and s. a. voloshin , phys .
b * 503 * , 58 ( 2001 ) ; t. hirano and k. tsuda , phys .
c * 66 * , 054905 ( 2002 ) ; p. f. kolb and r. rapp , phys .
c * 67 * , 044903 ( 2003 ) ; piotr bozek and iwona wyskiel , phys . rev .
c * 79 * , 044916 ( 2009 ) .
w. israel , ann .
( ny ) * 100 * , 310 ( 1976 ) ; w. israel , and j. stewart , ann .
* 118 * , 341 ( 1979 ) .
r. baier , p. romatschke , d. t. son , a. o. starinets , and m. a. stephanov , j. high energy phys . * 04 * , 100 ( 2008 ) ; s. bhattacharyya , v. e. hubeny , s. minwalla , and m. rangamani , j. high energy phys . *
02 * , 45 ( 2008 ) ; m. natsuume and t. okamura , phys .
d * 77 * , 066014 ( 2008 ) ; erratum - ibid .
d * 78 * , 089902 ( 2008 ) .
i. bouras , e. molnar , h. niemi , z. xu , a. el , o. fochler , c. greiner and d.h .
rischke , arxiv:1006.0387 [ hep - ph ] ; ibid , nucl .
a * 830 * , 741 ( 2009 ) ; s. khlebnikov , m. kruczenski , and g. michalogiorgakis , arxiv:1004.3803 .
j. peralta - ramos and e. calzetta , phys .
d * 80 * , 126002 ( 2009 ) .
r. geroch and l. lindblom , phys
d * 41 * , 1855 ( 1990 ) .
liu , i. muller , and t. ruggeri , ann .
( n.y . ) * 169 * , 191 ( 1986 ) ; t. ruggeri , in _ relativistic fluid dynamics _ , lecture notes in mathematics vol . 1385 , eds .
a. anile and y. choquet - bruhat ( springer - verlag , germany , 1989 ) .
e. calzetta , class .
. grav . * 15 * , 653 ( 1998 ) .
t. peitzmann , and m. h. thoma , phys . rep . *
364 * , 175 ( 2002 ) .
d. de florian , and g. f. r. sborlini , arxiv:1011.0486v1 [ hep - ph ] ; m. a. betemps , and m. v. t. machado , arxiv:1010.4738 ; w .-
sang , and y .- q .
chen , phys .
d * 81 * , 034028 ( 2010 ) ; t. p. stavreva , and j. f. owens , phys .
d * 79 * , 054017 ( 2009 ) ; l. bhattacharya , and p. roy , phys .
c * 78 * , 064904 ( 2008 ) .
a. adare et al .
( phenix collaboration ) , phys .
lett . * 104 * , 132301 ( 2010 ) .
k. dusling , nucl .
a * 839 * , 70 ( 2010 ) .
k. dusling and i. zahed , arxiv:0911.2426 [ nucl - th ]
. j. r. bhatt , h. mishra , and v. sreekanth , arxiv:1005.2756 [ hep - ph ] .
j. r. bhatt , and v. sreekanth , int . j. mod
e * 19 * , 299 ( 2010 ) .
j. r. bhatt , h. mishra , and v. sreekanth , arxiv:1011.1969 [ hep - ph ] .
b. baeuchle and m. bleicher , arxiv:1008.2332 [ nucl - th ] ; ibid , arxiv:1008.2338 [ nucl - th ] ; ibid , phys .
c * 81 * , 044904 ( 2010 ) .
a. dumitru , m. bleicher , s. a. bass , c. spieles , l. neise , h. stoecker , and w. greiner , phys .
c * 57 * 3271 ( 1998 ) . f .-
liu , t. hirano , k. werner , and y. zhu , arxiv:0902.1303 [ hep - ph ] ; r. chatterjee , e. frodermann , u. heinz , and d. k. srivastava , phys .
lett . * 96 * , 202302 ( 2006 ) ; r. chatterjee , and d. k. srivastava , phys .
c * 79 * , 021901 ( 2009 ) ; p. mohanty , j. k. nayak , j .- e .
alam , and s. k. das , phys .
c * 82 * , 034901 ( 2010 ) . c. gale , s. turbide , e. frodermann , and u. heinz , j. phys .
g : nucl . part .
* 35 * , 104119 ( 2008 ) . s. de , d. k. srivastava , and r. chatterjee , arxiv:1008.1475 [ nucl - th ]
qin , j. ruppert , c. gale , s. jeon , and g. d. moore , phys .
c * 80 * , 054909 ( 2009 ) .
m. luzum and j .- y .
ollitrault , arxiv:1004.2023 [ nucl - th ] ; g. s. denicol , t. kodama , t. koide , and ph .
mota , phys .
c * 80 * , 064901 ( 2009 ) ; a. monnai and t. hirano , phys .
c * 80 * , 054906 ( 2009 ) ; k. dusling , g. moore , and d. teaney , phys .
c * 81 * , 034907 ( 2010 ) ; e. calzetta , and j. peralta - ramos , phys .
d * 82 * , 106003 ( 2010 ) .
h. b. meyer , phys .
rev . lett .
* 100 * , 162001 ( 2008 ) .
h. song , and u. w. heinz , phys .
c * 81 * , 024905 ( 2010 ) ; j. w. li , y. g. ma , g. l. ma , chin .
b * 18 * , 4786 ( 2009 ) ; k. rajagopal , and n. tripuraneni , jhep * 1003 * , 018 ( 2010 ) ; g. s. denicol , t. kodama , and t. koide , arxiv:1002.2394 [ nucl - th ] ; p. bozek , arxiv:0911.2397 [ nucl - th ] ; a. monnai and t. hirano , nucl .
a * 830 * , 471 ( 2009 ) .
l. e. gordon , and w. vogelsang , phys .
d * 48 * , 3136 ( 1993 ) .
p. f. kolb , u. w. heinz , p. huovinen , k. j. eskola , and k. tuominen , nucl .
a * 696 * , 197 ( 2001 ) .
s. borsanyi , z. fodor , c. hoelbling , s. d. katz , s. krieg , c. ratti , and k. k. szabo , arxiv:1005.3508 [ hep - lat ] .
m. laine and y. schrder , phys .
d * 73 * , 085009 ( 2006 ) .
y. aoki , g. endrodi , z. fodor , s. d. katz and k. k. szabo , nature * 443 * , 675 ( 2006 ) ; p. huovinen and p. petreczky , nucl .
a * 837 * , 26 ( 2010 ) ; p. huovinen , nucl .
a * 761 * , 296 ( 2005 ) ; t. hirano and m. gyulassy , nucl .
a * 769 * , 71 ( 2006 ) ; u. w. heinz , j. phys .
g * 31 * , s717 ( 2005 ) ; p. huovinen , eur .
j. a * 37 * , 121 ( 2008 ) .
j. kapusta , p. lichard , and d. seibert , phys .
d * 44 * , 2774 ( 1991 ) ; c. t. traxler , h. vija , and m. h. thoma , phys .
b * 346 * , 329 ( 1995 ) . c. t. traxler , and m. h. thoma , phys .
c * 53 * , 1348 ( 1996 ) .
p. aurenche , f. gelis , h. zaraket , and r. kobes , phys .
d * 58 * , 085003 ( 1998 ) .
f.d . steffen , and m.h .
thoma , phys .
b * 510 * , 98 ( 2001 ) .
h. nadeau , j.i .
kapusta , and p. lichard , phys . rev .
c * 45 * 3034 ( 1992 ) , and erratum - ibid c. * 47 * 2426 ( 1993 ) ; c. song , phys . rev .
c * 47 * 2861 ( 1993 ) . h. song and u. heinz , phys .
c * 77 * , 064901 ( 2008 ) ; a. k. chaudhuri , phys
c * 74 * , 044904 ( 2006 ) ; m. luzum and j .- y .
ollitrault , arxiv:1004.2023 [ nucl - th ] ; k. dusling and d. teaney , phys .
rev . c. * 77 * , 034905 ( 2008 ) . | we calculate the spectra of produced thermal photons in au+au collisions taking into account the nonequilibrium contribution to photon production due to finite shear viscosity .
the evolution of the fireball is modeled by second - order as well as by divergence - type 2 + 1 dissipative hydrodynamics , both with an ideal equation of state and with one based on lattice qcd that includes an analytical crossover . the spectrum calculated in the divergence - type theory
is considerably enhanced with respect to the one calculated in the second - order theory , the difference being entirely due to differences in the viscous corrections to photon production .
our results show that the differences in hydrodynamic formalisms are an important source of uncertainty in the extraction of the value of @xmath0 from measured photon spectra .
the uncertainty in the value of @xmath0 associated with different hydrodynamic models used to compute thermal photon spectra is larger than the one occurring in matching hadron elliptic flow to rhic data . |
the x - ray emission from clusters of galaxies is primarily thermal in origin and is produced by a diffuse population of intergalactic electrons in the ionized intracluster medium ( icm ) .
these electrons coexist with a nonthermal , relativistic electron population in at least some clusters inferred from observations in the radio regime which should also radiate at x - ray energies .
while thermal emission clearly dominates in the kilo - electron volt ( kev ) energy range , it declines rapidly outside this range , allowing the detection of a nonthermal spectral signature as soft or hard excess emission .
this possibility is especially promising at hard ( @xmath810 kev ) energies , where the exponential decline of the thermal bremsstrahlung continuum is distinctly steeper than the expected nonthermal spectrum .
measurements of nonthermal x - ray emission are critical to the determination of the total amount of relativistic energy in the icm , which is currently poorly constrained . while no more than @xmath910% of this energy is tied up in nonthermal components ,
amounts at or near this level will affect the dynamics and structure of the thermal gas ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
specifically , studies that attempt to infer the total masses of clusters from the hydrostatic state of the thermal gas will produce biased mass estimates if the pressure support of relativistic particles and fields is not accurately included .
the mass functions built from these estimates can be used to constrain cosmological parameters ; these studies are already underway using observables derived in both the x - ray ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) and microwave ( e.g. , * ? ?
* through the sunyaev - zeldovich effect ) regimes .
a measurement of the total energy in relativistic icm components is possible when x - ray and radio nonthermal fluxes are combined .
diffuse , cluster - wide synchrotron radio emission , called radio halos or relics depending on their morphology , imply that both magnetic fields and relativistic electron populations are present on large scales .
the total luminosity of a synchrotron - emitting electron is given by @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the thomson cross - section , @xmath12 is the speed of light , @xmath13 is the lorentz factor of the electron , and @xmath14 is the energy density of the magnetic field . for a collection of relativistic electrons ,
the value of @xmath15 depends both on the number of electrons and on @xmath16 and can not independently determine either . however , these same electrons will up - scatter cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) photons through inverse compton ( ic ) interactions , which have a luminosity @xmath17 equivalent in form to equation ( [ eq : lsync ] ) but with @xmath18 replaced by the energy density of the cmb .
since both luminosities are proportional to the number of electrons , their ratio gives the volume - averaged magnetic field , @xmath19 where @xmath20 is the radiation constant and @xmath21 is the temperature of the cmb .
the ic radiation should be observable at hard x - ray energies @xcite .
thus far , ic emission has only been detected at low significance @xcite or , in one case at higher significance , in the ophiuchus cluster ( @xcite ; but see also @xcite and @xcite ) , although the diffuse radio emission in this cluster is restricted to a smaller scale mini - halo @xcite .
the measurement of an ic flux from a synchrotron source directly leads to a simultaneous determination of the average value of @xmath16 and the relativistic electron density @xcite .
therefore searches for ic emission coincident with a radio halo or relic are an excellent way to constrain the contribution of relativistic materials in clusters .
the first , and brightest , radio halo was discovered by @xcite in the coma cluster , and its radio properties have perhaps been the best studied ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
coma has been observed by all the major observatories with hard x - ray capabilities @xcite , and more recently non - thermal detections have been claimed by @xcite with _ rxte _ and by @xcite with _ bepposax _ , though the latter detection is controversial @xcite . due to the large field of view ( fov ) of these non - imaging instruments and
the simple characterization of the thermal gas , the source of this emission remains uncertain .
even more recently , long ( @xmath22 msec ) observations with _ integral _ have imaged extended diffuse hard x - ray emission from coma , though it was found to be completely consistent with thermal emission @xcite .
most recently , @xcite performed a joint analysis of spectra from the epic - pn and hxd - pin instruments the most sensitive instruments at soft and hard energies to date of the coma cluster and were unable to detect ic emission .
instead , they found an upper limit 2.5 times below the detections of @xcite and @xcite .
however , the narrower fov of the hxd relative to the collimators of the pca / hexte and pds leaves open the possibility that the spatial distribution of ic photons is highly extended , and therefore much of the flux was missed by the hxd .
the ic would have to be much broader than the size of the radio halo .
a uniform ic surface brightness of at least 30 in radius from the cluster center is sufficient to reconcile these results .
therefore , an imaging analysis at hard x - rays is required to confirm this picture ; unfortunately , no focussing hard ( @xmath810 kev ) x - ray telescope has yet been deployed . in the meantime , it is possible to perform a crude imaging analysis with coded mask instruments , as previously discussed by @xcite . in this work
, we report on the spatial and spectral hard x - ray emission from the coma cluster using the 58month accumulation of the burst alert telescope ( bat ) all - sky survey .
after the first 9 months of the survey , coma was seen to be clearly extended @xcite , so an accurate measurement of its flux must account for its resolved nature ; the standard method of extracting fluxes from coded mask instruments assumes the underlying source to be point - like . using models for the spatial distribution of thermal and potential nonthermal emission , we measure the total , extended flux in the 8 energy bands that make up the survey .
these fluxes are then converted into spectra , which we jointly fit with an epic - pn spectrum from a _ spatially identical region_. in this way , despite poor spatial resolution ( @xmath23 ) , we are sensitive to any large - scale , extended emission above the detection threshold for the survey . while the sensitivity of the bat detector is lower than instruments such as the hxd - pin , the survey s large exposure time
thanks to a fov that sees @xmath24 of the sky in a single pointing gives it a comparable , if not superior , overall sensitivity . in section [ sec : comabat : obs ] , we describe the bat survey in general and the epic - pn and bat observations of the coma cluster specifically .
the extraction of spatially extended fluxes from models , along with the specific models themselves , is discussed in section [ sec : comabat : spatial ] .
spectra constructed from these spatial fits are presented in section [ sec : comabat : specfits ] , along with the results of joint fits with the spectrum . in section [ sec : comabat : uls ] , we provide upper limits on spatially extended , nonthermal emission , and in section [ sec : comabat : disc ] we discuss the implications of our non - detection for the relativistic phase of the icm of the coma cluster . in the appendices ,
we describe the calibration of the survey such that joint fits with are straightforward , and we demonstrate that the bat instrument intrinsically detects extended emission on the scales of interest here , though with higher uncertainty than for a point source .
we assume a flat cosmology with @xmath25 and @xmath26 km / s / mpc and a luminosity distance to coma of 98.4 mpc .
unless otherwise stated , all uncertainties are given at the 90% confidence level .
to achieve the necessary spatial coverage and spectral sensitivity , we take advantage of mosaics of the coma cluster constructed from observations by the and satellites . the high sensitivity and good spectral and spatial resolution of the epic - pn data act as a check on the interpretation of the bat data , allowing the thermal and potentially nonthermal emission at hard energies to be accurately decoupled .
the observations and processed data used herein are identical to that presented in @xcite , where a more detailed description can be found .
the epic - pn mosaic of coma consists of 14 individual pointings , the first set ( 11 pointings ) of which were discussed in @xcite .
the full 14 pointings considered here were first presented in @xcite . for joint
fitting with bat spectra , we extract events from a @xmath27 box centered on the radio halo , which was originally chosen to match the hard x - ray detector field of view ; the region is shown as the outermost contour in figure 3 of @xcite , and also as the box in figure [ fig : comabat : xmmbat ] in the present paper .
the only modification of our analysis procedure compared to that in @xcite is that the spectra were not weighted by the spatial response of the hxd , since they are not being fit simultaneously with that instrument .
no similar weighting is needed to comparison to the bat data since the bat survey covers the entire sky and the vignetting of individual pointings is corrected for during processing .
we also use the temperature map derived from the mosaic and described in @xcite to model the spatial distribution of hard x - ray emission , which is detailed in section [ sec : comabat : spatial : models : thermal ] .
spectra extracted within a @xmath28 contiguous grid of regions of size @xmath29 are fit to single temperature apec models over the energy range @xmath30 kev .
while energies of @xmath31 kev are generally included during spectral fits , these data are primarily used to determine the background and are only included as a check of the background subtraction . because of the low count rate at these energies , their inclusion does not significantly contribute to @xmath32 or the resulting best - fit parameters .
while data from the observation of coma ( obsid 801097010 ) are not part of the current analysis , we do make use of the 27.5 kev spectrum from the 0 chip of the x - ray imaging spectrometer ( xis0 ) for calibration purposes , as described in section [ sec : comabat : cn : xmm ] .
we use the same spectrum that served to cross - calibrate the data in the previous /analysis ( region 10 from * ? ? ?
the mission is primarily to detect and localize gamma - ray bursts , which is accomplished with the very large fov ( @xmath33 of the sky ) , coded mask aperture burst alert telescope ( bat ) . as such
, the nearly random pointing strategy culminates in an almost uniform coverage of the entire sky with an @xmath34 ms of exposure time , made from many @xmath35 minute individual observations .
images of the sky are reconstructed by cross - correlating the shadow pattern of the randomly coded mask in front of the detectors with a detector plane image via a fast fourier transform .
the detectors are sensitive to hard x - ray / soft gamma - ray photons from 14 - 195 kev in 80 native energy channels . as part of the default survey processing , the channels
are combined into 8 broader energy bands : 14 - 20 kev ( e1 ) , 20 - 24 kev ( e2 ) , 24 - 35 kev ( e3 ) , 35 - 50 kev ( e4 ) , 50 - 75 kev ( e5 ) , 75 - 100 kev ( e6 ) , 100 - 150 kev ( e7 ) , and 150 - 195 kev ( e8 ) .
the final survey is built from the individual sky reconstructions , which are summed and resampled onto predetermined image planes of 6 facets , each in the zenith equal area projection .
the detailed processing methodology and survey properties for the 58-month bat all sky survey are nearly identical to those described in @xcite for the 22-month survey .
the only major difference is that for the 58-month survey , the gain of each detector pixel was _ individually _ calibrated with an onboard radioactive source , which had not been done previously .
this better accounts for the sensitivity of low gain pixels , effectively increasing the overall sensitivity . also , the sky images are more finely resampled so that the pixels near the center of the image projection scale @xmath36 instead of @xmath37 as with previous versions of the survey .
the main advantage of this change is to improve the centroiding of sources . because the systematic uncertainties in the survey - averaged spectrum of the crab nebula are smaller than the uncertainties in the bat survey response matrix , bat survey fluxes are tied to the crab fluxes in each band ( see * ? ?
one drawback to this approach is that a source flux is only guaranteed to be correctly determined if its spectrum within the energy band is identical the crab s ( a power - law with a photon index of @xmath38 ) , since the energy response within the band may not be uniform . because we will fit the bat spectrum jointly with the spectrum ,
it is important that the cross - calibration between the bat and be accurate . since the flux calibration of the bat survey
is based on the crab spectrum , we have made sure that the bat and agree on the flux and spectrum of the crab . the cross - calibration between bat and
is discussed in detail in appendix [ sec : comabat : cn ] .
the 6 facets of the bat all sky survey are oriented in galactic coordinates with one facet centered on each of the galactic poles and the other 4 centered uniformly around the galactic plane .
the zenith equal area projection conserves surface brightness but not shapes , so objects far from the center of the projection can be somewhat distorted
. however , the fortuitous location of the coma cluster near the north galactic pole , and thus the center of its facet , means that any such distortions are negligible .
nevertheless , for all parts of the analysis image pixels are referred to in terms of their galactic coordinates so that any image projection effects are completely eliminated .
hard x - ray emission is clearly detected in the first 4 energy bands , up to 50 kev . in figure
[ fig : comabat : xmmbat ] , we present the wavelet - smoothed 27 kev epic - pn image of the coma cluster mosaic overlaid with contours of the crab - normalized bat flux ( see * ? ? ?
* for a description ) , which shows the hard x - ray emission to be elongated in the same east - west direction as the softer emission .
as first noted by @xcite in the bat survey , the coma cluster is partially resolved by the bat , which is explicitly shown in figure [ fig : comabat : comaext ] .
this figure compares the radial surface brightness profile of coma with that of a nearby point source with a comparable flux .
coma is clearly extended .
the points plotted are individual pixels .
the greater width of the distribution for coma indicates that its surface brightness is not circularly symmetric .
as shown in figure [ fig : comabat : xmmbat ] , both the bat and x - ray emission is elongated in a ene - wsw direction .
while coded masks instruments have some difficulty detecting extended emission , this is only true for emission extended on very large scales , when the shadow pattern of the mask on the detector plane becomes sufficiently blurred .
conceptually , as long as at least 1 detector pixel is always shadowed by the mask over the entire extent of emission , no flux can be mistaken for the unmodulated background . the random placement of mask elements results in occasional , continuous clumps of over 5 elements across , which means that over a couple degrees all of the source flux can be recovered since one mask element subtends , on average , about 20 . for the bat
, we performed simple simulations that suggest that the actual scale over which accurate extended fluxes can be recovered , _ in principle _
, approaches the size of the fov if the spatial distribution of the source is known _ a priori_.
the practical problem is that flux from each part of an extended source adds systematic noise to every other part of the source , eventually drowning the signal in noise .
however , for small extensions this additional uncertainty is not overwhelming . in appendix [ sec : comabat : diffuse ] , we show that the bat provides accurate fluxes for extended sources on the scale of interest for the coma cluster ; in particular , fig . [
fig : comabat : diffsrc_recover ] demonstrates that all of the flux of a source extending over several degrees is accurately recovered . because nearby pixels in the bat survey images are correlated , it is more difficult to determine the flux uncertainties for extended sources in the bat than is usually the case for x - ray images . for point sources ,
the flux uncertainties can be determined from the fluctuations in the local background in the bat survey images . for coma
, we calculate the rms fluctuations in the background ( @xmath39 ) around coma in an annulus of radius @xmath40 pixels ( @xmath41 ) , as is typically done for sources in the bat survey .
these values , and the flux uncertainties for extended sources like coma , are derived in appendix [ sec : comabat : err ] .
to extract fluxes for extended sources , we choose to test _ a priori _ model distributions , as opposed to using a method like the `` clean '' algorithm @xcite , which reconstructs fluxes from an unknown underlining distribution assuming the psf shape only .
( see appendix [ sec : comabat : diffuse : tests ] for details about this choice . )
we represent a diffuse source as a collection of point sources , each of which is convolved by the psf ( eqn .
[ eq : comabat : psf ] ) and summed together . throughout this work ,
image data are fit to these spatial models using the mpfit algorithm @xcite , which performs a levenberg - marquardt least - squares minimization to converge on best - fit parameter values .
our goal is to detect ic emission from the same electrons producing the radio halo ; however , the electron spatial distribution need not follow the radio halo if @xmath16 varies spatially within the icm ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
indeed , there is evidence that the magnetic field in coma declines with radius @xcite , which would allow for a more extended relativistic electron population visible through ic interactions with cmb photons . to accurately search for this potential signal , we need to both choose model distributions for this emission and to fully model the thermal emission also present in the bat energy bands .
following the success of the -derived temperature map for explaining the thermal origin of the hxd - pin spectrum @xcite , we use the same map to predict the spatial distribution of thermal emission at hard energies . for each region of the map
, the flux of the best - fit apec model is calculated in each bat energy band and treated as a point source at that location .
note that because the apec and mekal look - up tables are not defined above 50 kev in xspec , we use meka to derive the temperature map fluxes in the 4 highest energy bands .
then , for each band the 232 temperature map region `` points '' are taken together to serve as the diffuse model . to compare this or any of our diffuse models to the bat image data , each point
is assigned the psf shape with its peak value equal to the point flux , and the overlapping psfs are summed together and sampled at the location of the image pixels .
thermal emission is detected in the first 4 bat energy bands e1e4 . since this emission is an extension of the x - ray emission which dominates the image and its distribution
is known , we fix the location of the thermal model to the best - fit position of the model for the e1 band data , where the signal - to - noise ratio is the highest . note that for the thermal model `` fits '' to the bat spatial distribution in various bands , only the normalization of the model in each band is allowed to vary . the spatial distribution within each of the bands is completely determined from the data .
the data will also contain any nonthermal emission within the band .
is it reasonable to use the temperature map and image to determine the spatial distribution of the hard x - ray thermal emission ?
the spectra in the temperature map were fit over the energy range 0.5 kev@xmath42 kev .
while the upper limit of this band is fairly hard , the low energy limit guarantees that the spectra are dominated by softer photons . for any sensible nonthermal spectrum , the spectra are dominated by thermal emission . in fact , if there is cool , dense gas along a given line of sight , the -based model may actually underestimate the thermal hard x - ray emission . in any case , if there is strong nonthermal emission in the spectrum , it will dominate the harder bat energy bands , and will be uncovered in the joint spectral fits to the and bat spectra ( section [ sec : comabat : specfits ] below ) .
the hxd - pin upper limit , which is 2.5 times below the and detections , only excludes those measurements if the ic emission originates from a relatively compact region ( @xmath43 ) .
more extended emission of roughly uniform surface brightness , however , would be consistent with both the detections and upper limit . in most physical models for the ic ,
it is likely that the surface brightness would decline with radius ; one exception is the kw model discussed below .
however , there is no single well - established model for this decline . since our object is to test the possibility that the difference between our hxd - pin upper limit and the and detections is due to the extent of the ic emission , we consider the extreme case of a uniform surface brightness disk .
thus , we assume any nonthermal emission to take the form of a uniform brightness , circular disk with a radius @xmath44 25 ( r25 ) , 30 ( r30 ) , 35 ( r35 ) , 40 ( r40 ) , 45 ( r45 ) , or 60 ( r60 ) .
recently , @xcite proposed another model for the ic emission of the coma cluster which is consistent with both the hxd - pin upper limit and the and detections . in this model ,
the ic hard x - ray emission comes from a separate population of electrons from those in the radio halo .
this new population of electrons are accelerated at the virial accretion shock of the cluster at a very large radius .
these virial shock accelerated electrons lose energy quickly , and form a shell of hard x - ray emission , which projects on the sky as a ring with nearly uniform surface brightness emission in its interior
. we will refer to this as the kw model .
while most of the flux resides in a ring at the cluster virial radius , the amount of flux detected by an instrument pointed at the cluster center will depend sensitively on its fov .
we take all the model parameter values for coma directly from @xcite when comparing their expected flux to the constraints imposed by the bat data , though the only relevant parameter for the spatial distribution is the accretion shock radius @xmath45 .
the radial distribution of flux is simply geometrical in form , assuming an infinitely thin shell at this radius ; the expression is given in ( * ? ?
* eqn . 9 ) . in reality ,
it is unlikely the spatial distribution of emission would be as regular and axisymmetric as portrayed by these models .
however , for the spatial extent we consider relative to the resolution of the bat , deviations from the idealized models will not particularly impact our results .
we do not assume that the center of the nonthermal emission distribution from coma is the same as the center of the thermal emission . instead , for each of the nonthermal models ,
the model center is placed at 81 different positions on a @xmath46 grid with @xmath47 spacings around the centroid of the large - scale thermal emission .
the center of the nonthermal emission is taken as one of the parameters to be varied in the fits of the spatial and spectral distributions below .
the spatial models for the thermal emission alone , or for the thermal emission plus nonthermal emission , were fit to the pixel values in the bat images in each of the 8 bat bands . as noted above ( section [ sec : comabat : spatial : models : thermal ] ) , the center of the thermal model was determined by fitting the center in the e1 band . for the thermal model , only the overall normalization was allowed to vary . for the nonthermal models ,
the center was varied for a grid of positions ( but fixed in each individual fit , see section [ sec : comabat : spatial : models : nonthermal ] ) .
the model normalization ( i.e. , flux ) in each of the 8 bat bands was fit independently for the thermal and nonthermal models .
that is , the spatial fits made no assumptions about the spectrum of either type of emission . in figure
[ fig : comabat : batimgs ] , we present the bat images of coma in all 8 energy bands ( first and third columns ) along with the thermal model - subtracted residuals for bands e1e4 ( center column ) .
the spatial distribution of the thermal models is represented with the contours in the first column .
note that only positively - valued pixels appear in the grayscale , which has a square - root scaling , and that for each band pure black corresponds to a slightly different value .
each panel covers an identical @xmath48 region of the sky .
residuals from the fits are consistent with background fluctuations , as can also be seen in the radial profiles shown in figure [ fig : comabat : proffits ] . as noted above ( section [ sec : comabat : spatial : models : thermal ] ) , these thermal models are solely based on the temperature map .
that is , the spatial distribution is completely determined from the data , fit over the energy range 0.5 kev@xmath42 kev , and only the total normalization , independently measured in each band , is allowed to vary .
ideally , we would use a harder bandpass to derive the temperature map , especially since it is known that such broad band single temperature fits , when performed on a truly multi - temperature spectrum , produces biased results @xcite . in practice
, however , the lower count rate at energies above 2 kev means that temperatures can not be determined in regions with lower temperature gas or lower flux .
we also extract such a temperature map , using the 212 kev band , and find systematically higher temperatures , @xmath49 % larger than the temperatures in the map we use here . taking this map to represent the input spatial distribution ,
we obtain statistically worse fits to the data , especially in the e1 band .
because cooler , less bright gas in coma s outskirts is not included in this temperature map , though it is present in the bat data , the emission at larger radii can not be properly fit . in any case , the fluxes we derive in each bat band do not significantly depend on the absolute temperatures in the map , since only relative temperature differences across the cluster matter , as the total normalization is independently fit for in each band . because _ all _ the temperatures in the map are increased when a higher energy bandpass is used
, the flux in each bat band remains essentially the same regardless of which temperature map is adopted .
we therefore use the map determined from the 0.5 kev@xmath42 kev band in order to include the cooler gas at larger radius .
regardless , this thermal model provides an adequate description of both the spatial and spectral ( discussed in section [ sec : comabat : specfits ] below ) properties of the detected emission in the bat data .
this success justifies our approach and confirms that extended emission is detected with the same efficiency as that from the cluster center .
the good fit of the -based thermal model for the emission in bat bands e1e4 and the lack of obvious excess emission in the harder e5e8 bands suggests that nonthermal emission is not very strong or extended .
the nonthermal model with the most extended emission is the kw model @xcite , in which the ic hard x - ray emission comes from a thin shell at a very large radius . following the methodology in section [ sec : comabat : diffuse : tests ] , we simulate the expected combined thermal and nonthermal flux distribution for this model , and compare to the actual data .
the results for the e1 bat band are shown in the upper panel of figure [ fig : comabat : thkwprof ] .
clearly , we do not detect the nonthermal emission expected by the model .
the lower panel shows the thermal plus kw model compared to a simulation of the bat data assuming the distribution actually followed this model .
it is clear that the statistics in the bat data would allow us to detect the nonthermal emission from the kw model , were it present .
a more quantitative limit is derived in section [ sec : comabat : uls ] .
to search for a nonthermal component in the x - ray spectrum of the coma cluster , spectral models are fit to the data .
the fits were done for the bat spectrum alone , or simultaneously with the spectrum of the cluster .
the bat spectra were binned into 8 spectral channels , given by the 8 standard bat bands e1-e8 . to determine the spectrum in each channel ,
the total measured raw photon fluxes in each band were converted into `` true '' photon fluxes using the calibration determined from the bat crab spectrum ; we also create a generic redistribution matrix to better represent models with spectral shapes that differ from the crab ( see section [ sec : comabat : cn : xmm ] ) .
the uncertainties in each channel were determined from the flux uncertainty for a point source @xmath39 ( see section [ sec : comabat : err : pterr ] ) , and then corrected for the effects of source extent as described in section [ sec : comabat : err : ext ] , equation ( [ eq : comabat : differr ] ) , and table [ tab : comabat : err ] .
the final uncertainty is given by @xmath50 in equation ( [ eq : comabat : differr ] ) .
additionally , a problem with the implementation of the apec , which we use as our thermal description for spectral fitting , and mekal models in xspec is that the look - up tables are undefined above 50 kev .
therefore , for the 4 energy channels above 50 kev , we substitute meka for apec .
this should have no significant effect given the small thermal flux at these energies relative to the errors . for the bat
- only spectra , in which only the nonthermal component of the spatial fit is used to build the spectra , a single power law model is sufficient to measure the nonthermal flux .
we also do joint fits of the bat ( containing both the thermal and nonthermal spatial components ) and spectra . in these fits , the excellent statistics at low energies in the spectra
very strongly constrains the thermal emission .
however , the mosaic covers a smaller area compared to either the bat or most of the nonthermal spatial models .
( the extraction region used for this spectral analysis is indicated by the square in figure [ fig : comabat : xmmbat ] . ) thus , in these fits the models applied to the spectra are reduced by the fraction of the emission in our spectral extraction region .
we first consider a purely thermal model for the x - ray emission in coma , and fit the bat and spectra simultaneously .
the spatial distribution of the emission was assumed to follow the thermal model ( section [ sec : comabat : spatial : models : thermal ] ) as determined from the data . for these and all following fits ,
we restrict ourselves to energies above 2 kev .
this choice ensures that the thermal component is not strongly biased to lower temperatures by cooler gas in these global , multi - phase spectra ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
the resulting single temperature fit is presented in figure [ fig : comabat : specth ] , and the parameters are given in the first row of table [ tab : comabat : fits ] .
the quality of the fit is quite good , indicating that a single component description for the temperature structure is sufficient and that the spectra have been reasonably well cross - calibrated .
a slight ascending trend in the e1-e3 residuals exists , however , which is primarily due to a slightly lower than expected e1 flux .
while not particularly significant , it is worth mentioning several potential causes for the trend .
the most straightforward explanation is that the calibration is slightly wrong .
we presume the true crab spectrum to be a simple power law across the entire 2200 kev interval , but if the spectrum actually steepens around @xmath51 kev as is likely the case @xcite , the higher energy bands will be assigned progressively higher flux conversion factors ( column 3 in table [ tab : comabat : err ] ) ; basically , the flux in an energy band will be more and more overestimated for bands at higher and higher energies . also , because emission is more significantly detected in the lower energy bands , a small change in the overall value of the and cross - normalization factor such that the flux would be raised
could reduce the spread in residuals . from a more physical perspective ,
a single temperature model is not entirely appropriate ; in multi - temperature model fits , the trend in residuals is not as strong . in any case ,
an adjustment to the cross - calibration of 35% is sufficient to account for the trend , which is well within our assumed 90% confidence interval uncertainty of 10% .
llccccc thermal region & single t & @xmath52 & @xmath53 & - & - & 1576.79/1544 + thermal region & 2 t & 7.8 & 0.25 & 9.4 & 0.12 & 1575.77/1542 + thermal region & t@xmath54 & - & - & - & - & 1590.01/1545 + thermal region & t+ic & @xmath55 & @xmath56 & 7.2 & @xmath570.51 & 1576.79/1543 + thermal region & t+ic & @xmath55 & @xmath56 & 2.0 & @xmath570.00148 & 1577.21/1543 + thermal & kw & single t & @xmath58 & @xmath53 & - & - & 1570.32/1544 + thermal & kw & 2 t & 7.8 & 0.25 & 9.7 & 0.12 & 1568.63/1542 + thermal & kw & t@xmath54 & - & - & - & - & 1584.59/1545 + thermal & kw & t+ic & @xmath59 & @xmath60 & -1.5 & @xmath57@xmath61 & 1570.23/1543 + thermal & kw & t+ic & @xmath59 & @xmath56 & 2.0 & @xmath570.00082 & 1570.62/1543 the best - fit temperature is @xmath62 kev .
the systematic term in the error is based on varying the cross - normalization factor by 10% ; the origin of this percentage is discussed in section [ sec : comabat : uls ] below .
this global temperature matches extremely well with previous measurements . for example
, @xcite found @xmath63 kev with a spectrum spanning @xmath64 kev from the _ ginga _ satellite , which had a similar fov ( collimator with 1 - 2 fwhm ) to our aperture , and @xcite found @xmath65 kev over a smaller fov and lower energy range ( @xmath66 kev ) with the epic - mos instruments . including lower energy photons
tends to lower single - temperature fits to multi - component spectra @xcite , and having a smaller fov tends to emphasize the hotter central temperature of @xmath67 kev in coma , which both explains why the _ ginga _ and temperatures agree and why the -analysis of @xcite found a slightly higher @xmath68 kev . while we find good agreement with other measurements , note that our temperature , along with other temperatures derived with , could be systematically cooler by a few tenths of a kev than temperatures obtained with other observatories , given the steeper crab spectrum and the implications for its instrumental response ( see section [ sec : comabat : cn : xmm ] ) .
we also tried a two - temperature thermal model for the and bat data .
however , the two temperatures and normalizations could not be individually constrained by the data ( table [ tab : comabat : fits ] ) ; the temperatures / normalizations listed in the table result when the two - temperature model is fit for with initial temperatures of @xmath69 kev and @xmath70 kev . the two - temperature fit is not a significant improvement on a single temperature fit . while the average spectrum in the square degree region around coma is adequately described with one or two temperatures for the gas , in fact the temperature distribution is quite non - isothermal .
we account for temperature variations in the spatial models used to extract fluxes from the bat images by extrapolating the temperature map from @xcite to higher energies .
this map can also be converted into a spectral model ( labeled `` t@xmath54 '' in table [ tab : comabat : fits ] ) and compared to the joint spectrum . by including the spatial information of the data in the spectral model , we can better account for the thermal contribution in the bat energy bands .
the quality of this fit ( allowing the normalization , but not the shape , of the model to vary ) is reported in table [ tab : comabat : fits ] . in principle
, the `` t@xmath54 '' spectral model should perfectly represent the total spectrum , but due to incomplete coverage of the temperature map with the total region and the imperfect determination of the individual temperatures , the @xmath32 value which is primarily driven by the higher quality data is larger than for the other fits , in which the model shape is free to vary and can account for these minor differences .
even so , the bat data are slightly better described by this model than by any of the other spectral models presented .
although this result is perhaps expected , given that the `` t@xmath54 '' spatial distribution is used to measure the bat fluxes , it does indicate that the method is self - consistent . in all of the thermal models investigated , no evidence for a strong high - temperature component is hinted at by the bat data . to search for evidence of more centrally located nonthermal emission ,
an ic component was first fit to purely thermally - derived spectra
i.e. , spectra created from fits to the bat data using only the thermal spatial model which are reported in rows 4 and 5 of table [ tab : comabat : fits ] . as in section [ sec : comabat : specfits : thermal ] , all fits are to the joint -spectrum extracted from the square region in figure [ fig : comabat : xmmbat ] .
not surprisingly , the thermal model parameters are almost identical to the fits without the ic component , and no significant ic emission is present .
the good single temperature fit to the bat and data already suggests that the nonthermal contribution is not very significant .
if the photon spectral index @xmath71 of the nonthermal component is allowed to vary , it is unconstrained and the best - fitted value is unphysically steep , and in any case , only an upper limit can be placed on the nonthermal flux ( table [ tab : comabat : fits ] ) .
if we assume a photon index of 2.0 for the nonthermal component based on the radio data ( section [ sec : comabat : uls ] below ) , the 90% upper limit on the 20 - 80 kev flux is @xmath72 ergs / s/@xmath73 , which corresponds to @xmath74 of the total flux in the range @xmath75 kev .
our goal is to search for extended nonthermal emission , which is measured with spatial model fits to the unlimited fov bat survey images ( section [ sec : comabat : spatial : fits ] ) .
because the thermal and nonthermal spatial model normalizations are individually and simultaneously allowed to vary to best match the total flux in the bat images , spectra can be created from the sum of both components or separately , and also within any aperture . for each of the 81 grid positions relative to the center of the cluster at which each nonthermal model was fitted for , two spectra are produced .
one consists of the total , unvignetted flux of the nonthermal component only , and the other includes the sum of both the thermal and nonthermal emission inside the extraction region .
the second type of spectrum has the advantage that it can be jointly fit with the epic - pn spectrum , which in the case of a non - detection provides a tighter constraint on the flux of nonthermal emission than the first type , since the nonthermal component must be consistent with the higher quality , lower energy data as well . in none of these cases , for either type of spectrum , is a nonthermal component detected with @xmath76 confidence .
we therefore conclude that , while the bat instrument is certainly sensitive to extended emission , none of a nonthermal origin is observed in the current version of the survey . as an example , the fit parameters for various spectral models are shown in table [ tab : comabat : fits ] for the spatial model nominally positioned ( i.e. centered on the large - scale emission ) . in figure
[ fig : comabat : specul ] , the nonthermal model with the most significant ic component is shown , assuming a fixed photon index @xmath77 for the spectral fits of each nonthermal spatial distribution tried .
note that the model in this figure represents the upper limit for a nonthermal component , not its best - fit value , and that the cross - normalization has been adjusted by 10% in the direction that favors a nonthermal signal .
the bat spectra in figures [ fig : comabat : specth ] and [ fig : comabat : specul ] are quite similar , indicating that even in the most favorable case the data reject a significant ic contribution to the spectrum of the coma cluster , extended or otherwise .
to ensure appropriate upper limits are derived , we must determine and include any important systematic uncertainties in our results . typically , instrumental and/or cosmic backgrounds
can be a serious concern and must be carefully treated . at lower energies where the thermal emission is bright , the background is not comparable to cluster emission until an energy of @xmath78 kev , so even a background uncertainty of a few percent does not significantly impact the epic - pn spectrum .
this background includes both the non - x - ray and cosmic backgrounds .
given the size of the mosaic , the uncertainty in the overall epic - pn background used here ( @xmath79 - 12 kev ) is 2.4% @xcite . increasing the background favors larger nonthermal fluxes since this reduces the temperature slightly , so the background is raised by 2.4% during upper limit derivations .
point sources in the mosaic account for only @xmath80 of the emission and have a spectrum that as a whole does not vary significantly from a @xmath81 power law @xcite , so we do not model their contribution to the spectrum .
while their flux may artificially enhance a nonthermal signal , ignoring them will only result in slightly more conservative upper limits . for the bat survey data , the background is automatically removed as part of the image reconstruction procedure , and systematic variations
are encoded as fluctuations in empty sky regions , which is already included in the error budget .
the more significant systematic uncertainty is in the determination of the cross - calibration between and .
ideally , there should be no uncertainty since we based the bat calibration on the data and the xis0 crab spectrum .
however , the slope of the calibration ( i.e. the assumed photon index of the crab ) is less certain . the total error ,
statistical and systematic , of the photon index in epic crab fits is @xmath82 @xcite , so we adjust our calibration to make the canonical crab spectrum flatter by 0.05 , which acts to increase the bat fluxes ( @xmath83 for e1 , @xmath84 for e8 ) and flatten the bat spectra , thus enhancing nonthermal fluxes .
this approach to the systematic uncertainty is also conservative , as it is known that the crab spectrum steepens above 10 kev ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) . since we have no clear detection of nonthermal emission , we must decide on its photon index from other arguments .
the natural choice is to use the spectral index of the radio halo , or @xmath85
1.52.5 @xcite , though the lower range of the x - ray regime explored here corresponds to lower energy electrons where the emission may have a flatter spectrum .
also , both previous detections using and data found @xmath81 , and the model of @xcite predicts this photon index .
therefore , we fix the nonthermal power law index to @xmath77 , primarily because we are most interested in directly comparing our upper limits with these previous detections and model predictions
. if the spectrum of nonthermal emission is in fact flatter , our upper limits will be low by some amount since the bat errors are large and the data will have less leverage on the fits .
however , the high energy flux will not increase dramatically ; as illustrated in table 3 of @xcite , the 20 - 80 kev flux rises by a factor of 2 from @xmath77 to @xmath86 , and trials show the same behavior for the nonthermal component in this work . for the above systematic uncertainties , we find the 90% confidence upper limits to nonthermal emission for both the nonthermal - only bat and for the joint epic - pn / bat spectra .
the thermal component in the latter case is simultaneously fit with the normalization of the nonthermal component .
we present each individual limit in figure [ fig : comabat : ul ] along with the vignetting corrected fluxes / upper limit from ( * ? ? ?
* upper cross , green ) , ( * ? ? ?
* lower cross , red ) , and ( * ? ? ? * upper limit , blue ) .
the collimator responses for these instruments are convolved with the model flux distributions to give these values or limits .
the hxd - pin instrument is a square collimator with spatial sensitivity of the form given in equation 3 of @xcite , and the pca / hexte and pds instruments are hexagonal collimators with triangular approximation fwhm of 1 and 13 , respectively .
we approximate the nearly axisymmetric response with a 4th - order polynomial of the form : @xmath87 where @xmath88 is the fraction of emission visible to the instrument at off - axis angle @xmath89 and @xmath90 is where emission is no longer detected . for each spatial model ,
our upper limits are ordered in galactic coordinates from the lowest values of @xmath91 and @xmath92 in our grid , incrementing @xmath91 for all positions with that latitude before incrementing @xmath92 , with @xmath91 reset to the minimum value .
it is this ordering that produces the pattern evident in the limits .
the limits for the joint spectral fits are given in the top panel , while the nonthermal - only spectral limits are provided in the bottom panel .
surprisingly , the upper limits derived from extended spatial models and the bat data alone ( bottom panel ) are comparable in sensitivity to the previous detections / limit .
larger models are generally less constrained , due to the greater uncertainty in their estimated flux ( equation [ eq : comabat : differr ] ) , though local fluctuations have a greater impact on smaller models , increasing the spread with position .
stronger constraints are obtained when lower energy emission is simultaneously considered ( top panel ) , and a similar range in upper limits is found for each spatial model distribution .
this result is not surprising , as each model contributes roughly the same amount of flux inside the extraction region , since most of them are extended beyond this region .
interestingly , the model provides the limits most consistent with the detection , which follows from the large pds fov it would observe a higher proportion of the brighter ring emission and the larger errors resulting from the model s size .
however , in all realizations of the joint fit case , our 90% limits lie below the 90% interval of the previous detections / limit .
thus , all of the previous detections are excluded for any of the spatial models when one fully accounts for the differences in spatial sensitivity between instruments .
our upper limits , for the nominal case where the nonthermal distribution is centered on the large - scale thermal emission , are compared to these previous measurements in table [ tab : comabat : uls ] .
lcccc & @xmath57 3.86 & @xmath93 & @xmath94 & @xmath57 6.2 + r60 & @xmath57 2.16 & @xmath95 & @xmath96 & @xmath57 25.1 + r45 & @xmath57 2.34 & @xmath97 & @xmath98 & @xmath57 25.4 + r40 & @xmath57 2.53 & @xmath99 & @xmath100 & @xmath57 24.7 + r35 & @xmath57 2.95 & @xmath101 & @xmath102 & @xmath57 21.7 + r30 &
@xmath57 3.22 & @xmath103 & @xmath100 & @xmath57 16.8 + r25 & @xmath57 3.48 & @xmath104 & @xmath105 & @xmath57 13.3 +
by taking advantage of the crude imaging capabilities of the bat instrument and the impressive sensitivity of the 58month all sky survey , we are able to constrain the amount of nonthermal , hard x - ray emission extended or otherwise from the coma cluster .
we find no evidence for an extended , hard excess that could reconcile recent detections from @xcite and @xcite with the upper limit from @xcite ; note , however , these detections would still be in conflict with the upper limit of @xcite .
generic , uniform surface brightness disks , along with a recently proposed ic model @xcite , were fit to bat survey images , converted to spectra , and investigated for signs of a nonthermal component .
for each spatial model , we compute upper limits on a grid of positions and compare them to previous measurements , being careful to convert detected fluxes into intrinsic source fluxes , given a particular spatial distribution , by accounting for the collimator vignetting functions .
these are direct comparisons , in the sense that the instrumental response of all detectors involved have been fully considered , and as such we , like @xcite , can not confirm the claimed detections of @xcite and @xcite .
their observed hard excesses could have had other reasonable sources , if not diffuse ic emission from the nonthermal phase of the icm .
a common difficulty is an accurate determination of both the cosmic and non - x - ray background , the treatment of which is the primary difference between @xcite and @xcite .
another possibility is the variable nature of nearby point sources , most notably the agn w comae , which was once quite bright but has been fading for many years . the concurrence of the and observations could have simply been unlucky and caught w comae ( or another source ) in a bright state . a somewhat more subtle , and perhaps more likely , explanation concerns the multi - temperature nature of coma s icm .
small amounts of hot gas could dominate the high energy emission , so the extrapolation of an average temperature determined from lower energy data may not be an adequate description of the thermal contribution to the high energy flux .
the effect of the multi - temperature gas in coma is evident in the sw extension at hard energies observed by @xcite and confirmed here ; higher temperatures seen at this location in the temperature map @xcite are sufficient to explain the change in morphology , which points to the increased significance of this gas at higher energies .
even so , single temperature spectral fits do not produce ic detections in this study or in @xcite .
the explanation may simply rest in a slight mischaracterization of the hard energy emission weighted temperature ; in @xcite , the fov of the lower energy hpgspc instrument does not quite match the higher energy pds , and the temperature of @xmath106 kev found in @xcite is significantly below that allowed by the data .
given radio synchrotron emission and an upper limit on the x - ray ic flux , a lower limit on the average icm magnetic field can be estimated , as described by equation ( 13 ) in @xcite and the accompanying text . a diffuse radio flux of 640 mjy at 1.4 ghz
is detected out to a radius of @xmath107 in @xcite . for comparison
, we will use the upper limit of @xmath108 erg s@xmath1 @xmath2 ( @xmath109 kev ) from the @xmath110 disk model .
these values imply @xmath111 @xmath4 g , an increase from @xcite but still well below the equipartition value of @xmath112 @xmath4 g for the coma radio halo @xcite
. a slightly lower limit of @xmath113 @xmath4 g results if a more conservative ic upper limit of @xmath114 erg s@xmath1 @xmath2 is used , which considers the limits from all spatial models tested .
regardless , these limits on @xmath16 fall well below line of sight estimates of several @xmath4 g from faraday rotation measure ( rm ) observations @xcite , though due to geometric effects these measurements may not represent the average cluster magnetic field @xcite . however , the global field may be recovered by combining many rm measurements along different lines - of - sight through the icm with numerical simulations @xcite .
@xcite have applied this method to the coma cluster , deriving a radial profile where the energy density of the magnetic field falls roughly in proportion with the energy density of thermal gas and with a central field strength of @xmath115 @xmath4 g . combining this model of @xmath116 with an approximate representation of the radial density profile of synchrotron emission , implied by a rough @xmath117-model fit to the point source subtracted image of @xcite ( @xmath118 , @xmath119 , and @xmath120 mjy arcmin@xmath121 ) , directly leads to a prediction of the expected ic surface brightness as a function of radius .
our illustrative due to the large uncertainties in all parameters assumed in this exercise
ic surface brightness distribution is flat out to @xmath122 with a 2080 kev flux of @xmath123 erg s@xmath1 @xmath2 arcmin@xmath121 , at which point it nearly linearly drops toward zero , though not reaching it , around a radius of 90 .
this surface brightness is about an order of magnitude below that implied by our upper limits , providing a possible explanation for why we are unable to detect an ic signature .
an order of magnitude lower hard x - ray flux for coma is also predicted by ( * ? ? ?
* see their fig .
5 ) , who have developed the most comprehensive picture yet of radio halo generation by mhd turbulence . on the other hand
, larger ic fluxes would be expected if the radio synchrotron emission falls off more gradually than modeled here , since a flatter radial profile would suggest a higher relativistic electron density given the falling magnetic field with cluster radius .
more accurate maps of coma s radio halo , preferably at lower frequencies where the radio electrons correspond more closely to the ic - emitting electrons , will clarify this issue .
ultimately , a true detection of ic emission from coma will have to wait for upcoming missions with focussing hard x - ray telescopes , namely _ nustar _ and _ astro - h_. for _ nustar _ to achieve a sensitivity comparable to our upper limits , a single pointed observation of at least 100 ks will be required @xcite .
however , the much finer spatial resolution will remove the uncertainty associated with bright background agn and allow multiple spatially - resolved joint fits .
assuming the hottest gas , which produces the largest amount of thermal emission at hard energies , is localized , then these regions can be identified and avoided in order to detect a lower surface brightness , but more uniform , ic component .
similarly , if the ic emission is more localized , it will be easier to identify with spatially - resolved joint fits between and _ nustar _ or _ astro - h _ spectra , as has been done with _
data alone @xcite .
the unambiguous detection of ic emission associated with radio halos and relics is crucial to determining the energy content in the relativistic phase of the icm and how significant of an influence this phase has on the dynamics and structure of the thermal gas in clusters .
we thank w. reich who kindly provided us with the @xcite radio image , c. b. markwardt who explained to us ( and wrote ) many of the bat software analysis routines used in this work , and the referee whose comments helped clarify the discussion of several key points .
drw was supported by a university of virginia gsas dissertation year fellowship and a virginia space grant consortium fellowship .
drw and cls were supported in part by nasa through suzaku grants nnx08az99 g , nnx09ah25 g , and nnx09ah74 g , and xmm - newton grants
nnx08az34 g and nnx08aw83 g . basic research in radio astronomy at the nrl
is supported by 6.1 base funding .
because the systematic uncertainties in the survey - averaged spectrum of the crab nebula are smaller than the uncertainties in the bat survey response matrix , bat survey fluxes are tied to the crab fluxes in each band since the systematic uncertainties in the survey - averaged spectrum of the crab nebula are smaller than the uncertainties in the bat survey response matrix ( see * ? ? ?
this method also requires that the intrinsic crab spectrum be defined since its exact spectrum remains somewhat uncertain ( see sec .
[ sec : comabat : cn : hard ] below ) , particularly at higher x - ray energies . in practice , though , we are less concerned with an accurate absolute calibration for the bat than we are with , in this case , an accurate calibration _ relative to _ our epic - pn spectrum .
therefore , instead of prescribing a canonical crab spectrum as close to the true spectrum as it has been measured thus far , we need to set it to the crab spectrum as measured by the epic - pn instrument _ over the energy range we consider_. otherwise , systematic calibration errors between the instruments could significantly affect our result , since our goal is to detect excess radiation at hard energies due to nonthermal emission .
errors leading to steeper ( flatter ) spectra and flatter ( steeper ) spectra , for example , will reduce ( increase ) the thermal contribution at higher energies and similarly enhance ( suppress ) a nonthermal signal . in other words ,
any systematic miss - calibrations are mimicked in the bat calibration so that thermal and nonthermal models can be simply applied during joint fits of the data .
because of its high x - ray flux , simple spectrum , and lack of significant variability , the pulsar wind nebula of the crab supernova remnant has been proposed as an x - ray standard flux calibrator @xcite . observations over a large range of energies and with many diverse instruments reveal an intrinsic spectrum nearly consistent with a single power law ; however , the photon index and normalization determined by each detector exhibit small but not insignificant differences @xcite . epic - pn measurements , which require that observations are made in burst mode due to s large collecting area , are best fit with a steeper than average photon index ( @xmath124 versus @xmath125 for simultaneous fits to many instrument observations , * ? ? ?
* ) that is driven by the shape of the spectrum from 0.5 - 2 kev . however , the residuals to this fit in their figure 7 suggest that for energies above 2 kev , the photon index is more in line with the average , and since we only consider energies above 2.3 kev , we need to determine what the crab spectrum is measured to be in this range . instead of fitting the crab spectrum directly , we choose to compare the data to xis0 data , which has been well calibrated and consistently fit over its energy range using observations of the crab .
spectra from each instrument are extracted from identical spatial regions at the center of the coma cluster ( specifically , region 10 from * ? ? ?
* ) , where both the gas temperature and surface brightness are roughly constant .
fitting each spectrum from 2.3 - 12 kev with a single temperature apec model , we find the -derived temperature to be slightly , though not insignificantly , lower than the temperature : 8.32 kev versus 8.90 kev .
the lower epic - pn temperature is consistent with an increasingly larger effective area at higher energies relative to s high energy effective area ; positing that s calibration is correct , the relative effective area at larger energies should be increased as a function of energy , which would lower the flux and therefore the temperature .
we model this effect as multiplicative power law component to the fit , which simultaneously accounts for both the gradient and the overall cross - normalization between the two instruments . fixing the apec model parameters to those found with the fit to the spectrum
, we find this modification to the calibration : @xmath126 .
in other words , spectra are flatter than spectra and have similar hard band fluxes ; however , note that the effective area had previously been reduced by 15% , as per the analysis in @xcite , in order to match the 2 - 10 kev epic - pn and xis0 fluxes . dividing the xis0 best - fit crab spectrum of ishida et al .
[ @xmath127 , given in _
memo 2007 - 11 ] by @xmath128 finally yields the correct parameters for the fit to the crab spectrum in the energy range of interest ( @xmath129 kev ) : @xmath130 we take this equation as our canonical crab spectrum .
then , the true flux of a source in each of the 8 bands is given by the bat source count rate in that band divided by the observed crab bat count rate in that band , and multiplied by the spectrum in equation ( [ eq : comabat : crab ] ) integrated over the band ( see * ? ? ?
this conversion factor is reported in table [ tab : comabat : err ] as the `` flux calib . '' .
note that this photon index differs significantly from that assumed in @xcite , @xmath131 .
our goal here is to choose a photon index that agrees with the data and best matches the crab spectrum at the lowest bat energies , where it is flatter than at harder energies ( see the discussion in section [ sec : comabat : cn : hard ] ) .
lccccccccccccc e1 & 1420 & 16.55 & 2.37 & 1.44 & 2.09 & 1.80 & 1.77 & 1.60 & 1.73 & 1.98 & 2.08 & 2.06 & 2.22 + e2 & 2024 & 11.28 & 1.05 & 1.32 & 2.02 & 1.75 & 1.39 & 1.53 & 1.56 & 1.22 & 1.60 & 1.57 & 1.94 + e3 & 2435 & 10.89 & 1.63 & 1.35 & 1.97 & 1.59 & 1.41 & 1.70 & 1.82 & 1.51 & 1.81 & 1.91 & 2.08 + e4 & 3550 & 10.46 & 1.12 & 1.31 & 1.90 & 1.66 & 1.40 & 1.59 & 1.53 & 1.18 & 1.62 & 1.64 & 2.15 + e5 & 5075 & 9.75 & 1.02 & 1.30 & 1.88 & 1.27 & 1.59 & 1.35 & 1.54 & 1.28 & 1.45 & 1.41 & 2.04 + e6 & 75100 & 13.00 & 0.99 & 1.29 & 2.03 & 1.34 & 1.37 & 1.52 & 1.25 & 1.36 & 1.51 & 1.57 & 1.85 + e7 & 100150 & 24.48 & 1.75 & 1.31 & 2.67 & 1.40 & 1.47 & 1.59 & 1.57 & 1.31 & 1.52 & 1.48 & 1.72 + e8 & 150195 & 75.19 & 3.84 & 1.31 & 1.24 & 1.42 & 1.45 & 1.26 & 1.29 & 1.23 & 1.65 & 1.56 & 1.93 + & 1.00 & & & 4.56 & 6.60 & 8.98 & 11.81 & 14.94 & 26.42 & 41.03 while this method is the standard way to create spectra from bat survey data , it is technically only valid for source spectra that have a shape similar to the crab . unfortunately , the bat survey redistribution matrix , which could properly account for arbitrary spectral shapes , is more uncertain than the observed crab fluxes @xcite .
thermal emission above @xmath910 kev is typically much steeper than the spectral index in equation ( [ eq : comabat : crab ] ) , so we would prefer to include an approximate redistribution matrix that will handle other such spectral models correctly . to do this ,
we take a standard response matrix for an on - axis source from a single observation and multiply the input energies by a smooth function so that the flux - converted crab spectrum matches equation ( [ eq : comabat : crab ] ) to @xmath132% in all energy bands .
the addition of this redistribution matrix has a minor effect on spectral fits generally , but it does improve the quality of fits using a thermal model , so we employ it throughout . with this approach ,
accurate conversions from bat count rates to true fluxes are not guaranteed .
the goal instead is to match the bat calibration with the epic - pn calibration , which ensures that spectral models can be applied seamlessly between the and spectra in joint fits . while fluxes quoted hereafter may differ from their true fluxes , the relative amounts of thermal versus nonthermal emission in the joint spectra considering both their cross - normalization factor _ and _ shape
are carefully conserved .
ultimately , because our bat calibration method relies on using the crab as a flux standard , and since the true crab spectrum is not known , the choice of a canonical crab spectrum is at some level arbitrary .
even so , the hard band fluxes derived herein should be consistent with fluxes derived from other missions . using the same power law form as for equation ( [ eq : comabat : crab ] ) ,
@xcite found a range of normalizations and photon indices for several instruments that overlap with the bat energy bands : pds : @xmath133 ; pca : @xmath134 ; hexte : @xmath135 ; isgri : @xmath136 ; and spi : @xmath137 .
these photon indices agree well with the shape of the total crab spectrum determined by an earlier , detailed balloon - borne study , which found @xmath138 @xcite .
also , the pin fit of @xmath139 is consistent with both the scatter in the above results and our adopted spectrum . ignoring the photon indices derived from data
, there seems to be a steepening in the crab spectrum at higher energies , which means that our relatively flat photon index may over - predict harder band fluxes and thus enhance a potential nonthermal signal .
our crab spectrum also has a slightly higher overall flux ( in the 20 - 80 kev band ) , so that fluxes and upper limits may be biased high , though any such biasing would be well within the absolute calibration uncertainties of all the above missions . assuming the spi observations are the most accurate , due to its extensive ground calibration
, we can compare our adopted model with the results of @xcite , which show a clear steepening of the crab spectrum above 100 kev . below 100 kev , they find a photon index of 2.07 , consistent with our value of 2.095 .
their best - fit photon index above 100 kev is 2.24 , which would lead our flux calibration to overestimate fluxes in our two highest energy bands .
however , since we detect no flux in these bands , extended or otherwise , even a large erroneous calibration
which is not the case here would not bias or otherwise affect our results .
@xcite also fit a smoothly varying power law to their crab spectrum .
not surprisingly , this model is sufficiently similar to our adopted crab spectrum , particularly below 50 kev where the flux calibration is more important , that using it instead of our simple power law model would not lead to quantitatively different results .
very extended , diffuse emission is difficult to detect with coded mask instruments , since the shadow pattern of the mask on the detectors gets smeared out and the signal becomes indiscernible from the background .
however , small scale extended emission is detectable , as long as its size is less than the minimum scale necessary to dilute the distinguishability of the mask pattern . in the following ,
we show that , by simulating extended sources as collections of point sources , this minimum scale is larger than our region of interest and that essentially 100% of the diffuse emission can be detected . for on - axis sources in the bat fov ,
the point spread function ( psf ) has a full width half maximum ( fwhm ) of @xmath922 . because the sky image is basically the cross - correlation function of the coded mask with the count rates in the individual detectors , it does not represent the intensity per solid angle ( i.e. within a pixel ) .
instead , a pixel value is proportional to the flux of a point source at that location .
the width of the psf is actually due to oversampling the sky plane , not the scattering of photons inside the instrument , and it depends on the size of individual mask element shadows on the detector relative to the size of detector pixels . as such ,
the psf should not be summed in order to derive the source flux this is provided by the central peak value and its fwhm depends on the off - axis angle of the source .
the distance between the mask and detector increases as the off - axis angle increases , so an angular separation at large off - axis angles produces a more dramatic shift in the shadow pattern across the detector pixels than more on - axis positions , which effectively reduces the oversampling factor and leads to narrower fwhm .
since survey images are created from many `` random '' individual pointings , each with a given source located at a different off - axis angle , the survey psf will have an average fwhm and uniform shape , which is roughly gaussian .
simple gaussian fits to all the @xmath140 sources in all 8 bands yield an average fwhm of @xmath141 , irrespective of s / n or energy band , essentially identical to the value determined in the 22-month survey @xcite .
the psf shape is described by a gaussian to first order , which is not surprising given the non - repeating , randomly filled mask and the many pointings that contribute to the flux at each position .
however , as is clear from the residuals to a gaussian fit to the 1420 kev band crab data and another source ( cyg x-2 ) in figure [ fig : comabat : psffunc ] , deviations on the order of 1% of the flux exist ( and are significantly larger than the root - mean square ( rms ) of the background in this case ) .
while this deviation does not strongly impact the flux of point sources , since only the maximum , central value maps to the flux , a diffuse source is composed of overlapping psfs , where differences in the wings could affect the overall flux . the residual structure in the wings of the psf is mainly eliminated by the addition of the two - part function : @xmath142 + p_1 \ , , \ ] ] where @xmath143 is the distance from the center in arcminutes , @xmath144 and @xmath145 are fit parameters ( the normalization and background , respectively ) , @xmath146 ( @xmath147 has units of radians ) , and @xmath148 . the improved fit for the crab
is illustrated in the very bottom left panel of figure [ fig : comabat : psffunc ] ; while in this case the fit is still not perfect , for other sources the fit is typically better ( bottom right panel of figure [ fig : comabat : psffunc ] ) .
we take @xmath144 to be our measurement of the flux . while the maximum of the psf may not exactly correspond to @xmath144 , since all fluxes are determined this way and are also related to the crab fluxes
, any such bias will cancel out during the conversion from bat count rates to fluxes . note that the most the additional terms to @xmath149 could affect a flux , assuming they , for some reason , poorly represented the true psf shape , is at the @xmath150% level . as discussed in section
[ sec : comabat : spatial ] , we extract fluxes for extended sources by fitting _
a priori _ model distributions , as opposed to using a method like the `` clean '' algorithm @xcite , which reconstructs fluxes from an unknown underlining distribution assuming the psf shape only .
the `` clean '' method requires some fine - tuning , such as the region of extraction ( for clearly detected sources , expanding the region - of - interest even a little beyond the wings of the source can significantly bias the derived flux ) , `` loop gain , '' and completion threshold . in our case , since there are only a few likely spatial distributions for the thermal and any potential nonthermal emission , we are less likely to produce biased fluxes by first assuming a spatial distribution than by using a method like `` clean . ''
we represent a diffuse source as a collection of point sources , each of which is convolved by the psf ( eqn .
[ eq : comabat : psf ] ) and summed together .
we now test whether diffuse sources are detectable over our scales of interest can be evaluated . in general ,
we treat extended emission as a collection of closely - spaced point sources , since existing software is built with these sources in mind .
point sources at any position in the bat fov are straightforward to simulate with the heasoft task batmaskwtimg with the following options set : coord_type = tanxy ; distance=1e7 ; corrections = forward , unbalanced , flatfield ; and rebalance = no .
this task outputs the fraction of each detector pixel which is illuminated by the source given its position relative to the detector axis ; a value of 0.45 means that 55% of the detector area is shadowed by the mask . at this stage
, the detector image can be multiplied by the counts or count rate of the source , and several such detector images representing different sources in the fov can be added together along with a background all including poisson statistics .
the background can then be fit and subtracted with the task batclean , and finally a reconstructed sky image can be produced via the task batfftimage . for now , to isolate the detectability of diffuse emission by the bat , we simply add uniformly bright , perfectly known point source masks without background or source poisson noise , to create circular , extended disks of various radii @xmath151 . images of the sky are constructed with batfftimage for each disk detector image , and the `` observed '' disk surface brightness profile is fit for as a function of radius .
while even large disks ( @xmath152 ) are visibly noticeable , sky images produced in this way include significant systematic effects induced by the large spatial extent of the emission , leading to high rms noise that eventually destroys the disks detectability .
the recovered surface brightness , relative to the input level , of simulated diffuse disks of radius @xmath151 are presented in figure [ fig : comabat : diffsrc_recover ] .
error bars represent the simple error of the mean ( @xmath153 , where @xmath154 is the number of pixels used to determine @xmath155 ) , and the smooth as opposed to random variation around the input surface brightness results from their systematic nature . for sources in the size range of interest to us , @xmath156 , the _ intrinsic _ uncertainty due to
the telescope design is @xmath157 .
as the disk radius increases , the reconstructed surface brightness becomes less and less robust as there are effectively more sources ( other parts of the disk ) contributing systematic noise to a given location .
note , however , that _ all _ of the input source flux is recovered .
the uncertainty in a given flux measurement is encoded in the rms fluctuations in the local background @xcite .
these fluctuations represent both the statistical fluctuations from shot noise ( dominated by the high background rate ) and systematic error contributions from the sky reconstruction process . due to the large number of individual pointings at nearly random positions ,
most systematic effects nearly average out and lead to a symmetric , nearly gaussian distribution for blank sky regions .
we calculate the rms of the background ( @xmath39 ) around coma in an annulus of radius @xmath40 pixels ( @xmath41 ) , as is typically done for sources in the bat survey .
the values of @xmath39 for each band are given in table [ tab : comabat : err ] .
while this annulus partially includes the region within which we are searching for a diffuse nonthermal signal , the lack of any obvious emission indicates that the derived errors could not be significantly biased . to ensure @xmath39
is not biased by low level extended flux , we recalculated it inside an annulus of equal area with an inner radius of 90 and found a nearly identical value of @xmath39 in all 8 bands .
the error for a point source , or more correctly the error in the value of a given pixel , presented in section [ sec : comabat : err : pterr ] does not directly apply to extended sources .
also , we can not take the standard error from spatial @xmath32 fits , using the point source error as the error for the flux in each pixel , because nearby pixels are correlated .
helpfully , the expected error for diffuse sources has already been derived by @xcite for the ibis coded mask instrument onboard . in their appendices
, they derive source fluxes and errors in reconstructed sky images from detector images and find the straightforward result that the error in a flux measurement from an extended source is proportional to its spatial area normalized by the area of the psf function ( * ? ? ?
specifically , @xmath158 where @xmath159 is the area of the source normalized by the psf area . if @xmath160 is the surface brightness of the source convolved with the psf , @xmath161 is its maximum value , @xmath162 is the solid angle , and @xmath163 is the psf , then @xmath164 before we generally apply equation ( [ eq : comabat : differrarea ] ) to bat data , we test whether this prescription does in fact apply to extended sources in the bat . for each of the diffuse thermal ( section [ sec : comabat : spatial : models : thermal ] ) or nonthermal ( section [ sec : comabat : spatial : models : nonthermal ] ) spatial models described above
, we created 121 simulations of the extended source and a number of other point sources in the fov , each with detector counts for the source fluxes and background randomly assigned ( taken from a poisson distribution ) .
each simulated observation is made from a unique position on an @xmath165 grid , with the relative positions of all the sources kept intact .
both the variation of position relative to the telescope axis and the inclusion of point sources are necessary to fully recreate the systematic contribution to the error .
the simulated detector images are then background subtracted and converted into sky images via the procedure outlined in section [ sec : comabat : diffuse : tests ] .
the total flux of the diffuse sources is chosen so that the signal - to - noise ratio is @xmath166 . to check equation ( [ eq : comabat : differrarea ] ) , fluxes of all the sources
are measured in each simulated sky image , and the average standard deviation of the point source fluxes are compared to the standard deviation of the diffuse source flux .
we find that the estimated errors for the diffuse models ( thermal band e1 , disks r25r60 , and kw ) generally fall below the expected trend with @xmath159 in figure [ fig : comabat : differr ] .
this discrepancy may be due to the number of simulations we were computationally limited to performing
the distribution of fluxes is only roughly gaussian or it may represent a true deviation from the results of @xcite . however , to be safe we use equation ( [ eq : comabat : differr ] ) to calculate the error of fluxes extracted with the corresponding model
. there is one additional modification to errors on fluxes extracted with our methodology . because we fit a spatial model , convolved by the psf , to the bat image data , the error in the flux is not just the standard deviation of nearby background pixels , but it depends on how the model is fit to all the pixels .
for example , the distribution of normalizations from many fits of a gaussian function to random data of mean zero and standard deviation @xmath39 will not equal @xmath39 but some value @xmath167 depending on the pixel scale .
a delta function , or gaussian of width zero , will produce a distribution consistent with @xmath39 , since this is identical to measuring the standard deviation , but anything wider finds an average over several pixels , and therefore the distribution of normalizations will tend to be closer to the mean of the random pixels . for our purpose , where the normalization is related to the source flux , the correct error of a flux should come from the distribution of model fits to background ( empty ) regions of the survey , which may not be equivalent to @xmath39 .
unlike in the above example , neighboring pixels in the survey are correlated due to oversampling this is essentially the origin of the psf and so the standard deviation of model normalizations will be affected by this correlation .
generally , the distribution of normalizations will be larger than @xmath39 in this case , as @xmath32 minimization will be more influenced by the larger fluctuations near the flux extraction region .
the net effect does not significantly change the error distribution shape , but simply inflates the effective standard deviation by some factor , @xmath168 , which is both model - dependent ( varying from 1.4@xmath39 for a point source to 2.24@xmath39 for the model ) and energy dependent since the noise properties vary slightly from band - to - band .
the total flux uncertainty for a diffuse source in the bat survey is adjusted from equation ( [ eq : comabat : differrarea ] ) to become @xmath169 the precise value of @xmath168 is determined from the standard deviation of fits to 100 blank sky regions , in which we avoid obvious ( @xmath170 ) sources and the galactic plane ( @xmath171 ) .
these factors are reported for each band in table [ tab : comabat : err ] . not including this factor in the flux error estimate results in spectral fits with unacceptably high @xmath32 values . | the coma cluster of galaxies hosts the brightest radio halo known and has therefore been the target of numerous searches for associated inverse compton ( ic ) emission , particularly at hard x - ray energies where the ic signal must eventually dominate over thermal emission .
the most recent search with the hard x - ray detector ( hxd ) failed to confirm previous ic detections with and , instead setting an upper limit 2.5 times below their nonthermal flux .
however , this discrepancy can be resolved if the ic emission is very extended , beyond the scale of the cluster radio halo . using reconstructed sky images from the 58month bat all sky survey ,
the feasibility of such a solution is investigated .
building on renaud et al . , we test and implement a method for extracting the fluxes of extended sources , assuming specified spatial distributions .
bat spectra are jointly fit with an epic - pn spectrum derived from mosaic observations .
we find no evidence for large - scale ic emission at the level expected from the previously detected nonthermal fluxes .
for all nonthermal spatial distributions considered , which span the gamut of physically reasonable ic models , we determine upper limits for which the largest ( most conservative ) limit is @xmath0 erg s@xmath1 @xmath2 ( 2080 kev ) , which corresponds to a lower limit on the magnetic field @xmath3 @xmath4 g .
a nominal flux upper limit of @xmath5 erg s@xmath1 @xmath2 , with corresponding @xmath6 @xmath7 g , is derived for the most probable ic distribution given the size of the radio halo and likely magnetic field radial profile . |
the study of hadronic resonances , be it baryons or mesons , has never ceased ( with seasonal fluctuations ) to interest the particle and nuclear physics community for several specific and one global reason @xcite .
the latter reason is to be found in the fact that hadrons and their interaction are the low energy manifestations of qcd .
the specific reasons include among others : ( i ) the wish to improve upon standard results ( e.g. resonance parameter extraction ) , ( ii ) the attempt to understand inconsistencies and puzzles , if any , ( iii ) possible new resonances ( of speculative status , enigmatic nature , predicted by models and/or resurrection of previously refuted results ) , ( iv ) exotic resonances like glueballs , hybrids ( named also hermaphrodites and meiktons ) , multiquark states such as @xmath8 , mesonic molecules and @xmath9-exotics , ( v ) the enigmatic scalar sector with the return of the @xmath10-meson into the data book of the particle data group ( pdg ) @xcite .
we shall come back to ( i)-(v ) in the next section . here
it suffices to note that it is very often the existence of a resonance which is at stake .
insufficient data , weak signal and different methods applied to analyze data can result in different conclusions .
the analytical methods to extract resonances and their parameters are well known and well documented .
it then comes as a mild surprise to know that not _ all _ known analytical methods have been fully exploited .
for instance , it is now fifty years since the concept of collision time ( time delay ) was introduced by eisenbud and wigner @xcite .
its connection to resonances is best explained in wigner s own words @xcite : `` close to resonances , where the incident particle is in fact captured and retained for some time by the scattering centre , @xmath11 [ this is the collision time where @xmath12 is the scattering phase shift ] will assume large positive values '' . not much has changed since then , except that the concept of time delay has been further elaborated by many authors [ 9 - 12 ] , incorporated into text books [ 13 - 18 ] and newly rediscovered in a different context @xcite .
in all these references the connection to resonance physics is well documented and stressed .
nowadays , one might not look upon a resonance as a particle being retained by another for a while , but rather as an unstable intermediate state characterized by several quantum numbers . to clarify this point , we quote ref .
@xcite : `` finally we remark that a sharp maximum in the time delay ( essentially condition ( iii ) [ the specific time delay @xmath13 has a sharp maximum ] ) is sufficient for the existence of a resonance ; the argument is given in ref .
12 [ our reference @xcite ] ''
. we could continue quoting text books and papers on time delay , but it would mean repeating more or less one and the same phrase .
the surprise then grows when we learn that only recently the time delay concept has been put to a test in connection with hadron resonances @xcite , with reasonable success . by this
we do not mean that time delay has not been extensively discussed in literature ( see earlier references and for some criticism see @xcite ) , but we are not aware of any work which has made a practical use of the advocated time delay in connection with hadron resonances . time delay analysis for @xmath14-hypernuclear states has been successfully performed in @xcite . a related and less documented but somewhat popular concept , namely the _ speed plot _ ,
is occasionally found in literature @xcite .
however , _ speed plots _ are positive by definition whereas time delay ( as obvious from the citation from wigner s paper ) can assume positive as well as negative values .
hence , regions with a negative bump in the collision time , could come out as positive peaks in the speed plot . in this context , we quote wigner once again : `` one would expect ( on the basis of liouville theorem or completeness relation ) that the two effects [ positive and negative values of time delay ] , on the whole , balance each other , i.e. that the integral of @xmath15 ( in wigner s notation , @xmath12 is phase shift , which is denoted as @xmath16 in the present work ) over the whole energy range is close to zero , ..... hence , if the cross section shows a resonance behaviour , one will expect @xmath12 to decrease slowly between resonances and increase fast at resonances , increase and decrease almost exactly balancing if considered over the whole energy spectrum . ''
a demonstration of the above statement can actually be found in @xcite for a constructed example of seven consecutive breit - wigner resonances .
a detailed comparison between time delay and speed plots can be found in @xcite .
we supplement the above by noting that the connection between time delay and the statistical density of states in scattering has been given in @xcite .
we also note that not every peak in the cross section can be attributed to a resonance @xcite . in view of the above discussion
, it seems worth undertaking an examination of time delay in scattering processes with data , encountering several resonances over a wide energy range . in @xcite
we have applied the time delay method for baryon resonances in @xmath17 scattering . in the present paper , we do the analog for mesonic resonances in @xmath0 and @xmath1 collisions .
indeed , we get very sharp _ positive _ peaks for all established resonances which confirms the statements made by wigner and others in literature .
agreement with the known resonances adds support to the interpretation of the additional peaks we find as new resonances ( indeed , these additional peaks have been a matter of debate for some time ) .
our paper is organized as follows : in the next section we give some necessary facts about mesonic resonances .
these facts will be necessary to interpret our results .
in the subsequent section we briefly discuss the relevant formulae on time delay . in sections 4 and 5
we present the collision times calculated for @xmath0 and @xmath1 scattering .
the last section is devoted to conclusions .
given the seniority of the subject , the number of possible topics worth mentioning , even with the restriction to the points ( i)-(v ) mentioned in the introduction in context with the continuing interest in mesonic resonances , is of course too large to be covered here . therefore the short survey below is coloured by what we thought to be relevant for the results of the present paper .
as an example of the points ( i ) and ( ii ) from the previous section , we quote the case of the @xmath2 mesons . till the year 2000 , the pdg listed a group of @xmath18 mesons with masses around @xmath19 mev discovered in @xmath20 collisions @xcite . in the 2002 edition @xcite
this entry has been removed due to the lack of further evidence supporting the old data . in the same year
this controversy has been revived by an experimental indication of an isovector state with mass around @xmath4 mev @xcite . as noted in @xcite this
is also supported by the @xmath21 reaction , where one finds a mass enhancement in the @xmath22 system which is partly attributed to additional @xmath2 meson @xcite .
additional conclusions regarding the @xmath2 mesons are drawn from ` inconsistencies ' in @xmath23 collisions and @xmath24 decays @xcite .
these seem to indicate the necessity of a vector hybrid @xcite which serves as a good example for the points ( iii)-(iv ) in the @xmath2 mesonic sector .
it is beyond the scope of this work to describe in detail the situation of exotic mesons @xcite .
however , one of the exotics , namely the glueball , has indirectly to do with the findings of our paper .
we say so because , according to lattice theory and other models , the lightest glueball is predicted to be a true scalar with a mass around @xmath25 mev @xcite .
opinion as to which one of the low lying scalars has the largest admixture of glue differs @xcite .
this adds to the other problems encountered in the scalar sector ( point ( v ) ) .
regarding the glue , in the scalar sector , the interpolating field for @xmath10 could be @xmath26 @xcite .
the situation is not unlike the @xmath12 mesons , where through the @xmath27 anomaly , there is a connection between @xmath28 and the @xmath29 field @xcite making us think about a glue content of eta mesons and @xmath29-@xmath30-glue mixing @xcite . in any case ,
the most famous problem beside the glue in the scalar sector is the @xmath10 meson itself , which was removed from pdg in 1974 and reappeared there much later .
this metamorphosis @xcite ( of appearance and disappearance ) is typical for this meson in other respects too . from the experimental point of view
, it is sometimes claimed that this meson behaves differently in different physical situations @xcite i.e. displaying different masses and lifetimes .
this is also reflected by the wide mass range quoted by pdg : @xmath31 mev . from the theoretical side
, we can view the @xmath10 meson as a higgs particle in the context of the linear sigma model @xcite after the spontaneous breaking of chiral symmetry , i.e. , as the real part of this higgs field whose vacuum expectation value breaks the chiral symmetry ( the imaginary part resulting into pseudoscalars ) .
alternatively , one can look upon @xmath10 as a low energy manifestation of the scale invariance breaking in the strong interaction @xcite ( the ` identification ' @xmath32 mentioned above is motivated by this scale invariance breaking since the latter is connected to the trace anomaly in qcd by which the dilaton current is not conserved ; note again the analogy to the eta mesons where the connection to the gluon fields is through another anomaly , namely the @xmath27 ) . hence the question : chiralon , dilaton or both ? in spite of these theoretical insights , there is no general consensus about the parameters of the @xmath10 meson .
the nambu - jona - lasinio model @xcite would require a mass of roughly twice the constituent quark mass i.e. @xmath33 mev .
weinberg s prediction in the framework of mended symmetry is @xmath34 @xcite .
the latter seems also to agree with values required to satisfy the adler sum rule @xcite .
calculations using bethe - salpeter approach @xcite give @xmath35 mev which , however , is rejected by the authors themselves @xcite to be the mass of the @xmath10 meson on account of it being too heavy .
indeed , the pole values predicted in the unitarized chiral perturbation theory @xcite and the unitarized quark model @xcite , give the @xmath10 mass around @xmath36 mev , which is roughly in agreement with potential like models @xcite .
an even lower value for @xmath37 , namely @xmath38 mev is reported by a very recent observation of @xmath39 @xcite .
last but not least , we mention a mysterious low @xmath0 mass enhancement at @xmath40 mev which dates back to 1961 @xcite and is since then coined abc - effect .
it has not vanished during the years , but continues to leave its fingerprints in several scattering processes @xcite till today . above @xmath5
gev , a resonance is often mentioned around @xmath41 mev and was earlier known as @xmath42 @xcite .
it is often stressed that this is not the @xmath43 scalar because of different inelasticities into @xmath0 and @xmath44 .
this problematic region borders to @xmath45 on the one hand and @xmath46 on the other .
therefore strong interference effects are to be expected .
a strong support for a resonance around @xmath47 is given in @xcite .
in @xcite the status of @xmath43 as a genuine resonance is doubted . putting everything together , we recognize three problematic regions in the @xmath48 sector : @xmath49 mev , @xmath50 mev and @xmath41 mev , where one finds strong hints / evidences for unusual activities / resonances . actually these regions are often attributed to a single resonance , the @xmath10 . reproducing the figure in @xcite with new data in fig . 1
, one sees that most data points are grouped around these three regions .
having discussed the unflavoured mesons which we might find in the @xmath0 system , we now turn our attention to strange resonances encountered in @xmath1 scattering .
we are not aware of any problems / controversies in the @xmath51 sector and this problem free zone is also confirmed nicely by our analysis .
there are some uncertain candidates in the @xmath52 spectrum around @xmath53 gev @xcite and we add to this uncertainty two never - heard - of ` candidates ' around @xmath54 and beyond @xmath53 gev .
we will discuss the reliability of these results in section 5 .
however , more importantly , it is again the scalar mesons @xmath55 which stir up controversies and it is again about the lightest strange scalar which right now goes under the name @xmath56 . whereas the first suggestions of @xmath10 date back to early 60 s @xcite
, one can trace back the @xmath56 to early 70 s @xcite . as with the @xmath10 ,
the @xmath56 meson too has met with either an outright refutal for the basis of its existence @xcite or support together with determination of its mass and width .
two often quoted values for its mass are : @xmath57 mev @xcite and close to @xmath58 mev @xcite .
this resembles very much the situation of @xmath10 .
in this section we give the main formulae concerning time delay without derivation and refer the reader to literature for a more detailed account @xcite .
intuitively , a _ positive _ time delay is a measure of how much a reaction is delayed , say due to an unstable intermediate state .
close to the resonance region we would expect to find a _
positive _ peak in the energy distribution of time delay . indeed , since in a resonant process we produce the resonance on - shell , the process itself can be viewed in steps .
the first is the resonance production at the space - time point @xmath59 followed by the resonance decay at @xmath60 with @xmath61 and @xmath62 ( non - localized processes can also be encountered in t - channel @xcite where one of the initial particles is a resonance ) . _
negative _ time delay occurs when the interaction is repulsive and/or a new decay channel opens up @xcite .
the measure for both has been found by wigner and eisenbud @xcite in the form of the energy derivative of the phase shift @xmath16 as , @xmath63 which is valid for elastic processes @xcite .
smith @xcite generalized this to calculate the time delay directly from the @xmath64 matrix ( including also inelastic processes @xmath65 ) giving , @xmath66 \ , .\ ] ] with @xmath67 and @xmath68 equation ( [ 2 ] ) in the elastic case ( @xmath69 ) can be recast into @xmath70,\ ] ] where obviously @xmath71 is the same as in equation ( [ 1 ] ) .
this can be checked by substituting @xmath72 ( where @xmath16 is the real scattering phase shift and @xmath12 the inelasticity parameter ( @xmath73 ) ) which gives , @xmath74 \nonumber \\ & = & \,2\hbar \ , { d\delta \over de}\end{aligned}\ ] ] smith s formalism shows that wigner s expression ( [ 1 ] ) is valid for elastic reactions even if there are non - zero inelasticities .
the generalization of time delay with @xmath75-body interaction was done later in @xcite .
the statistical connection to time delay mentioned in the introduction is given by @xcite @xmath76 where @xmath77 is the difference in the density of states with and without interaction and @xmath78 is the phase shift in the @xmath79th partial wave .
since @xmath80 can be positive as well as negative , some references call it collision time reserving the name time delay for the case @xmath81 and time advancement for @xmath82 .
it is well known that the lifetime of an unstable state depends in principle , on its preparation , i.e. on the energy spread @xmath83 of the initial particles which produce the state .
most of the experiments producing hadron resonances certainly operate in the region where the inequality @xmath84 with @xmath85 , the width of the resonance , holds true . in case of broad resonances ,
the breit - wigner distribution is not necessarily a good parametrization .
moreover , in such cases the mean lifetime is not @xmath86 @xcite , but rather @xmath87 ( where @xmath88 is the energy available in the centre of mass system ) , as given above @xcite .
one can also put it in different words . since for a narrow resonance ,
the breit - wigner is the spectral function @xcite which leads to the exponential decay law , it is reasonable to say that @xmath89 is the right spectral function for a broad resonance ( the fourier transform of this spectral function gives the survival amplitude ) .
it is then clear that time delay is so to say tailored to study broad hadronic resonances , especially the mesonic cases mentioned in the last section ( which we shall confirm in the next two sections ) . before applying the time delay method to the broad mesonic resonances , we give here two words of caution . since the collision time is given as _
derivative _ of the phase shift , a rather good quality of data is required to avoid ` false ' bumps , i.e. signals in the time delay plots which are not genuine resonances but rather an artifact of the fit .
secondly , the phase shift necessary to calculate the collision time , can not be uniquely determined through data .
indeed , one usually gets several solutions which then have to pass certain tests ( involving crossing symmetry , unitarity , analyticity etc . ) in order to decide which solution is the physical one .
even then it is not so clear if one can avoid the so - called continuum ambiguity @xcite . in our case , using time delay , a good check will always be if we can reproduce the well established resonances .
in passing , we note that wigner s intention in @xcite was to find a criterion to distinguish between physical and unphysical phase shifts .
he found @xmath90 which is a causality condition since a time advancement can not be arbitrarily large . in ( [ 7 ] ) @xmath91 is interpreted as interaction range .
a legitimate question is about the relation between resonance parameters defined as poles of the t - matrix and positive peaks in time delay . in this connection
we quote ref .
@xcite where the author says , moreover , if there is an appreciable time delay ( @xmath92 ) , the latter should be interpretable as arising from the propagation of an unstable intermediate particle .
the above requirements , which are readily generalized to multiple scattering processes , are sufficient to derive the pole structure of the s - matrix and the existence of antiparticles " and ref .
@xcite where the authors state , however , the information that gives an indication of a large time delay - typically the fast traversal by the amplitude of a resonance circle as described in the sections elastic resonances " and inelastic resonances `` - is the same information whose extrapolation on to the unphysical sheet informs us as to the existence of a pole '' .
we can also perform a practical test by evaluating time delay using phase shifts calculated within a model and comparing the time delay peaks with the pole values of the t - matrix within that model .
for instance , using the model of kaminski , lesniak and loiseau described in @xcite , for the @xmath0 elastic scattering phase shifts , we get the resonance peaks shown in fig .
2 , which are in good agreement with the pole values found within the model ( see table 3 , of @xcite ) .
we would also like to draw the reader s attention to ref .
@xcite , where a simple model of a coherent sum of seven resonances was made to display the virtues of the time delay method . in the argand diagram plot , these resonances showed up misleadingly as one resonance whereas the time delay plot could differentiate between these resonances with the peak values coinciding with the pole positions ( see fig . 1 and fig . 3 in @xcite ) .
this work indicates that the time delay method is then well - suited for overlapping resonances .
we start our exploration of time delay and resonances , examining the @xmath93 phase shifts .
these phase shifts have been extracted with care and passed several tests @xcite ( among others the roy equations @xcite ) .
hence we have confidence that they represent the true physical situation ( this is also justified because we do confirm all well - established resonances in this case ) .
a note about error bars is in order here .
the errors in the phase shifts get transformed into the errors in time delay and in principle can shift the positions of the time delay peaks . however , the aim of the present work is not a precise determination of resonance parameters but rather showing the usefulness of the time delay method .
hence we do not quote the errors in the peak positions , but we do make a double check by using two different sets of phase shifts whenever possible .
this is an example of the analytical power of the time delay method applied to resonance physics . as fig .
3 nicely demonstrates , we find a prominent peak for the @xmath2 meson where one would expect it to be , at @xmath94 mev .
the phase shifts are from @xcite .
we identify the peak at @xmath95 mev with @xmath96 . the pdg s estimate ( `
educated guess ' ) for this resonance is @xcite @xmath97 mev .
however , in the @xmath0 mode the mass range listed is @xmath98 mev with an average value of @xmath99 mev .
a similar analysis can be applied to the next peak at @xmath100 mev which is due to @xmath101 .
the peak value is close to the pdg estimate of @xmath102 mev .
according to pdg , the mass for this resonance in the @xmath0 mode ranges between @xmath103 and @xmath104 mev .
having confirmed the three known mesons in the time delay plot , it was worrying to find an additional peak at @xmath105 mev .
it does not seem that this is an artifact of the fit or due to poor quality of the data and we had to accept this signal as a genuine one .
we found independent support in @xcite resulting in an accumulated evidence for a @xmath2 resonance around @xmath4 mev .
note that the sources of this evidence are quite different .
the phase shifts in fig .
4 are from @xcite and @xcite .
the time delay calculated from the two different sets of phase shifts gives a similar qualitative picture which shows that the underlying physics should be taken seriously .
the peak on the far right @xmath106 gev is a signal of @xmath46 whose possible mass values listed in pdg are between @xmath107 and @xmath108 gev .
this resonance is overlapping from the left with @xmath43 for which we find peaks at @xmath109 gev ( pdg quotes @xmath110 for the pole position and also for the breit - wigner value ) .
the sharp peaks at @xmath111 are of course the well established @xmath112 bordering at a resonance structure at @xmath113 gev , which in turn in one of the cases overlaps with a bump at @xmath114 gev .
the individual peaks are not well separated due to the large widths of scalar resonances .
nevertheless , the time delay method is able to distinguish between these overlapping cases . due to the successful separation of standard cases
, we do not think that the 2 peaks below @xmath5 gev ( 350 and 700 mev ) are accidental or due to the fit and/or data .
these two regions at @xmath36 and @xmath115 mev are also the most quoted in connection with the @xmath10 meson mass .
it is worth stressing that we have recovered these regions here in one and the same reaction . at the end of this section
, it is instructive to subject the time delay method to yet another test .
the resonances found in the elastic scattering process , @xmath116 , should also manifest themselves in the coupled channel reactions , @xmath117 and @xmath118 , provided they have an appreciable branching ratio for decaying into @xmath119 .
the plots in fig .
5 are just the results of such a test in the mass range from 1 to 1.5 gev . in fig .
5a , we show the data on @xmath120 ( @xmath121 , where @xmath122 and @xmath123 are the elastic scattering phase shifts in the @xmath0 and @xmath119 channels ) obtained in @xcite .
we make a fit to this data and subtract from it , the fit made earlier in fig . 4 to the cern - b @xmath0 data , to obtain the @xmath119 phase shift ( solid line ) shown in fig .
the dashed lines in this figure are the phase shifts obtained in a model calculation in @xcite .
the resonance found at 1.42 gev ( peaks in shaded regions ) using @xmath120 and @xmath123 is to be associated with @xmath124(1370 ) .
we can see that by using the model phase shifts of @xcite which give a peak at 1.4 gev .
note that the data sets of @xmath116 and @xmath125 reactions are different and we do not expect the mass values from the time delay peaks in @xmath116 ( fig .
4 ) and @xmath118 ( fig .
5 ) to be exactly the same .
note also that nothing can be inferred about @xmath124(980 ) and @xmath124(1500 ) since both are just at the edge of the data set in fig .
5 . the data in fig . 5
has the advantage that one can compare the result from time delay with the speed plot shown in @xcite .
the speed plot is actually the energy distribution , @xmath126 , defined as , @xmath127 where @xmath128 is the energy dependent complex @xmath128-matrix . in @xcite
, @xmath126 has been calculated ( fig . 2 in @xcite and fig .
28(b ) in @xcite ) and the speed plot peak appears at 1.425 gev , which is in excellent agreement with our finding of the time delay peak in fig .
we now perform a similar analysis as above in the strange meson sector .
the results confirm all established mesons , the @xmath56 meson and hint in addition to the existence of new strange mesons .
the only well established strange scalar is @xmath129 .
however , over the years there have been claims about the existence of a lighter strange scalar called @xmath56 @xcite .
its mass is thought to be within the range @xmath130 mev @xcite .
the situation resembles the case of the light unflavoured mesons , not only regarding its existence , but also its wide mass range thought to be possible .
it should then come as no surprise , when the broad mass range gets resolved into several peaks .
two sets of phase shifts from @xcite and @xcite are available to study these scalar mesons .
though both of them cover only a small energy region , we can see that they are complementary in a sense . in fig .
6a we see a clear signal for @xmath129 , whereas in fig .
6b , the tendency for a peak in this mass range is present .
the peak at @xmath5 gev ( fig .
6a ) is also accompanied by a tendency towards a lower peak .
this is confirmed by the other time delay plot in fig .
6b where we see two peaks at @xmath131 gev and @xmath132 gev .
these two peaks can be interpreted as a signal of the @xmath56 meson in time delay plots .
since the two peaks are very close to each other , they could have been confused as one single resonance .
the strange vector mesons have been so far a no - problem zone for resonance spectroscopy .
the time delay plots in fig .
7 calculated from the phase shift given in @xcite do confirm this .
clear signals for @xmath133 , @xmath134 and @xmath135 , with pdg mass estimates of @xmath136 , @xmath137 and @xmath138 mev respectively , are seen . alone
a visual inspection of the two phase shift solutions from @xcite reveals that this case is different from the previously discussed cases .
the visual inspection also reveals that there will be four peaks in the corresponding time delay plots which is indeed confirmed in fig .
note that the two solutions give us within errors the same spectrum of the strange spin - two resonances .
the first peaks in figs 8a and 8b can be clearly attributed to @xmath139 .
the peaks at @xmath140 and @xmath141 gev are a confirmation of @xmath142 which is listed in pdg , but omitted from its summary table ( see also @xcite ) .
we find additional peaks around @xmath143 and @xmath144 gev . in @xcite
the authors note that `` ... , but above @xmath5 gev , there is suggestive evidence for phase motion , though little structure in the magnitude . ''
we believe that we have now quantified the expression ` phase motion ' through our time delay analysis . the additional peaks which we found can not be easily waived away once we accept the phase shifts where the quality of the data is sufficiently solid to support them . in the @xmath145 system
, one sees more regions of negative time delay .
this happens very often in the presence of increased inelasticities .
however , it was also pointed out by wigner @xcite that negative time delay is unavoidable over the whole energy region .
in the present work , we have used the method of time delay to investigate the resonances occurring in @xmath0 and @xmath1 reactions . time delay ( in connection with hadronic resonances )
has been advocated since fifty years , but to our knowledge never used in practice . given the available phase shifts , the outcome of such an analysis is beyond our control , and in principle , it was possible that our conclusions regarding the usefulness of time delay in resonance physics would come out to be negative .
however , the contrary is the case . in our time delay plots , the well established resonances always appeared as prominent peaks , in all the cases we examined , which we believe is already quite remarkable .
apart from this we also find additional information . in the scalar sector , the signals at @xmath146 and @xmath147 mev are in regions claimed also by other authors / groups to be regions of resonance activity . in the strange scalar sector
we confirm the @xmath56 meson ; however , we get two neighbouring peaks
. since these peaks are very close to each other , we can not say with certainty if they are really two resonances or artifacts of the fit . in the @xmath2 mesonic sector
, we find evidence of a resonance around @xmath4 mev which again has been and is a matter of debate ( though it has been omitted by pdg in 2002 for lack of evidence , in the same year several groups found the evidence for its existence using different methods ) .
the @xmath3 ( @xmath148 ) resonances would be the case par excellence , since no problems are known in this sector and all that we found are the well established cases too . the only sector where we found never - heard - of resonances ( again in addition to known cases )
is the @xmath149 group .
the phase shifts in this particular case look distinctly different from the other cases we have examined . taking the given phase shifts at face value
, it would certainly be worthwhile looking into the possibility of two new strange tensor resonances .
this is supported by the fact that two different phase shift solutions yield the same resonances in the time delay plot .
in general , it seems to us that the time delay method is a useful analytical tool in studying resonances .
it certainly is not an exclusive tool , but taken together with other methods it allows us to have additional insight into the complicated matter of overlapping and/or broad resonances , as it can apparently resolve individual peaks .
for instance , in the enigmatic scalar sector , two phase shifts from different groups ( not two different solutions ) show the same behaviour : three peaks around @xmath36 , @xmath115 and @xmath4 mev , rather than one broad resonance structure .
0.5 cm acknowledgments we wish to thank v. krey and j. c. sanabria for useful information and discussions .
we are very thankful to prof .
r. kaminski for providing the programs and phase shifts generated in their model @xcite .
0.5 cm 99 to sample some reviews articles over the last 20 years we quote : d. flamm and f. schoberl , _ introduction to the quark model of elementary particles _ , vol . 2 , _ quantum numbers , gauge theories and hadron spectroscopy _ , gordon breach 1982 ; a.
j. g. hey and r. l. kelly 1983 _ phys . rep . _ * 96 * 71 ; s. godfrey and n. isgur 1985 _ phys .
_ d * 32 * 189 ; b. diekmann 1988 _ phys .
rep . _ * 159 * 99 ; t. bressani , a. feliciello and a. filippi ( eds . ) , _ hadron spectroscopy _ , frascati physics series 15 , frascati , italy 1999 ; s. godfrey and j. napolitano 1999 _ rev .
phys . _ * 71 * 1411 e. oset 2002 unitarized chiral perturbation theory of hadrons " , talk given at the panic 2002 conference , osaka , japan 2002 , nucl - th/0211077 ; j. a. oller , e. oset and a. ramos 2000 _ prog .
phys . _ * 45 * 159 , hep - ph/0002193 ; j. r. pelaez , j. a. oller and e. oset 2000 _ nucl .
phys . _ a * 675 * 92c l. montanet 2000 _ nucl . phys .
suppl . _ * 86 * 381 e. klempt , _ meson spectroscopy _ 2001 _ preprint _ hep - ex/0101301 k. hagiwara _
( particle data group ) 2002 _ phys .
_ d * 66 * 010001 ( url : http://pdg.lbl.gov ) .
e. p wigner 1955 _ phys .
rev . _ * 98 * 145 e. p. wigner and l. eisenbud 1947 _ phys .
rev . _ * 72 * 29 l. eisenbud , dissertation , princeton , june 1948 ( unpublished ) d. bohm 1951 _ quantum theory _
( prentice - hall , new york ) ; a. i. baz 1957 _ jetp _ * 33 * 923 ; g. calucci , l. fonda and g. c. ghirardi 1968 _ phys . rev . _
* 166 * 1719 ; h. m. nussenzveig 1972 _ phys .
_ d * 6 * 1534 ; h. m. nussenzveig 1997 _ phys
. rev . _ a * 55 * 1012 ; h. narnhofer 1980 _ phys .
_ d * 22 * 2387 ; f. t. smith 1960 _ phys .
rev . _ * 118 * 349 d. bolle and t. a. osborn 1979 _ j. math .
phys . _ * 20 * 1121 ; _ ibid _ 1975 _ phys
_ d * 11 * 3417 h. c. ohanian and c. g. ginsburg 1974 _ am .
journal of phys . _
* 42 * 310 b. h. bransden and r. gordon moorhouse 1973 _ the pion - nucleon system _ ( princeton university press , new jersey ) .
arno bhm 1979 _ quantum mechanics _ ( springer - verlag ) ; a. messiah 1961 _ quantum mechanics _ ( v. i. north - holland publishing company , amsterdam ) ; h. m. nussenzveig 1972 _ causality and dispersion relations _
( academic press , new york and london ) m. l. goldberger and watson 1964 _ collision theory _
( new york ; john wiley ) a. i. baz , ya .
b. zeldovich , a. m. perelomov 1969 _ scattering reactions and decay in non - relativistic quantum mechanics _ ( israel program of scientific translations , jerusalem ) c. j. joachain 1975 _ quantum collision theory _ ( north - holland ) ; j. r. taylor 1972 _ scattering theory : the quantum theory on non - relativistic collisions _ ( john wiley and sons , inc . ) p. danielewicz and s. pratt 1996 _ phys .
_ c * 53 * 249 ; a. b. larionov _
_ 2001 _ preprint _ nucl - th/0107031 s. leupold 2001 _ nucl .
_ a * 695 * 377 ; c. david , c. hartnack and j. aichelin 1999 _ nucl . phys . _ a * 650 * 358 ; p. w. brouwer , k. m. frahm and c. w. j. beenakker 1997 _ phys
lett . _ * 25 * 4737 ; a concept related to time delay is the so - called arrival time used in tunneling processes , see : ken - ichi aoki , atsushi horikoshi , etsuko nakamura 2000 _ phys .
rev . _ a * 62 * 22101 ; j. g. muga and c. r. leavens 2000 _ phys .
rep . _ * 338 * 353 n. g. kelkar 2002 _ j. phys .
* 29 * l1 , _ preprint _ hep - ph/0205188 n. g. kelkar , marek nowakowski , k. p. khemchandani and s. r. jain 2002 _ preprint _ hep - ph/0208197 r. h. dalitz and r. g. moorhouse 1970 _ proc .
_ a * 318 * 279 j. fraxedas and j. sesma 1988 _ phys .
_ c * 37 * 2016 g. hhler 1998 _ @xmath17 newsletter _ * 14 * 168 ; _ ibid _ 1993 _ @xmath17 newsletter _ * 9 * 1 r. aaron , m. rich , w. l. hogan and y. n. srivastava 1973 _ phys .
_ d * 7 * 1401 ; k. nakajima _
et al_. 1982 _ phys .
_ b * 112 * 80 n. lipshutz 1969 _ phys .
_ * 181 * 1972 n. g. kelkar , m. nowakowski and k. p.
khemchandani 2003 _ j. phys .
g : nucl . part .
* 29 * 1001 .
e. beth and g. e. uhlenbeck 1937 _ physica _ * 4 * 915 ; k. huang 1963 _ statistical mechanics _
( wiley , new york ) ; r. k. bhaduri 1988 _ models of the nucleon : from quarks to soliton _ ( lecture notes and supplements in physics : 22 ; addison - wesley publishing company , inc . ) ; r. f. dashen and r. rajaraman 1974 _ phys . rev .
_ d * 10 * 708 ( on pg .
29 is an example with discussion on resonances with the density of states formula ) d.e . groom _ et al_. 2000 ( particle data group ) _
_ c * 15 * 1 m. achasov 2002 _ aip conf.proc._ * 619 * 30 ; also in * protvino 2001 , hadron spectroscopy * 30 - 39 , _ preprint _ hep - ex/0109035 b. pick ( crystal barrel collaboration ) _ higher vector meson states _ , in * protvino 2001 , hadron spectroscopy a. donnachie and yu
. s. klashnikova 2001 _ light - quark vector - meson spectroscopy _ , in hadron 2001 , protvino , _ preprint _ hep - ph/0110191 j. ballam et al .
1974 _ nucl .
_ b * 76 * 375 ; m. atkinson et al .
1984 _ nucl .
_ b * 243 * 1 ; j. brau et al .
1988 _ phys .
_ d * 37 * 2379 a. donnachie may 2001 _ workshop on @xmath20 physics at intermediate energies _ , slac , _ preprint _ hep - ph/0106197 f. e. close , a. donnachie and yu . s. kalashnikova 2002 _ phys .
_ b * 533 * 277 , _ preprint
_ hep - ph/0201043 a. donnachie and yu .
s. kalashnikova 1993 _ z. phys .
_ c * 59 * 621 ; f. e. close and p. r. page 1997 _ phys .
_ d * 56 * 1584 ; _ ibid _ 1999 _ phys .
_ d * 60 * 114011 f. close 1997 _ nature _ * 389 * 230 ; s. u. chung 1997 _ nucl .
suppl . _ * 56 * 234 ; g. s. adams et al .
2000 _ nucl .
phys . _ a * 680 * 335 ; m. gerber and m. nowakowski 1992 _ nucl
. phys . _ a * 548 * 681 lattice : c. j. morningstar and m. peardon 1999 _ phys .
_ d * 60 * 034509 ; qcd sum rules : s. narison 1998 _ nucl .
_ b * 509 * 312 ; flux tube : n. isgur and j. paton 1983 _ phys .
b * 124 * 241 m. strohmeier - presicek , t. gutsche , r. vin mau and a. faessler 1999 _ phys .
_ d * 60 * 054010 ; l. s. celenza , bo huang , h. wang and c. m. shakin 2000 _ phys .
_ c * 62 * 068201 ; f. e. close and a. kirk 2000 _ phys
_ b * 483 * 345 and references therein p. minkowski and w. ochs 1999 _ eur.phys.j .
_ c * 9 * 283 , _
_ hep - ph/9811518 a. v. anisovich , v. v. anisovich and a. v. sarantsev 1997 _ z. phys . _ a * 359 * 173 ; a. v. anisovich , v. v. anisovich , yu .
d. prokoshkin and a. v. sarantsev 1997 _ z. phys .
_ a * 357 * 123 j. ellis and j. lanik 1985 _ phys . lett .
_ b * 175 * 289 g. t hooft 1976 _ phys . rev .
lett . _ * 37 * 8 ; h. goldberg 1980 _ phys .
lett _ * 44 * 363 ; g. m. shore and g. veneziano 1992 _ nucl .
_ b * 381 * 23 ; t. hatsuda 1990 _ nucl .
_ b * 329 * 376 v. v. anisovich , d. v. bugg , d. i. melikhov and v.a .
nikonov 1997 _ phys .
_ b * 404 * 166 ; c. e. carlson and t. h. hansson 1982 _ nucl .
_ b * 199 * 441 ; h. genz , m. nowakowski and d. woitschitzky 1990 _ phys .
_ b * 250 * 143 m. svec 2002 _ preprint _ hep - ph/0209323 and references therein m. r. pennington 1999 _ preprint _ hep - ph/9905241 ; talk given at workshop on hadron spectroscopy ( whs 99 ) , rome , italy , 8 - 12 mar 1999 , in * frascati 1999 , hadron spectroscopy * 95 - 114 m. gell - mann an m. levy 1960 _ nuovo cim .
_ * 16 * 705 ; m. levy 1967 _ nuovo cim .
_ a * 52 * 23 ; s. gasiorowicz and g. a. geffen 1969 _ rev
phys . _ * 41 * 531 ; e. van beveren , f. kleefeld , g. rupp and m. d. scadron 2002 _ mod .
a * 17 * 1673 g. mack 1968 _ nucl .
_ b * 5 * 499 ; k. g. wilson 1969 _ phys . rev .
_ * 179 * 1499 ; p. carruthers 1971 _ phys .
_ d*3 * 959 y. nambu and g. jona - lasinio 1961 _ phys . rev . _ * 122 * 345 s. weinberg 1990 _ phys .
lett _ * 65 * 1177 f. j. gilman and h. harari 1968 _ phys .
rev . _ * 168 * 1803 c. j. burden , lu qian , c. d. roberts , p. c. tandy and m. j. thomson 1997 _ phys .
_ c * 55 * 2649 c. j. burden and m. a. pichowsky 2002 _ few body syst .
_ * 32 * 119 j. a. oller and e. oset 1997 _ nucl .
phys . _ a * 620 * 438 [ erratum - ibid a * 652 * 407 ] ; j. a. oller and e. oset 1999 _ phys . rev .
_ d * 60 * 074023 ; j. a. oller , e. oset and j. r. pelaez 1999 _ phys .
_ d * 59 * 074001 [ erratum - ibid d * 60 * 099906 ] n. a. trnqvist and m. roos 1996 _ phys .
lett . _ * 77 * 2332 g. janssen , b. c. pearce , k. holinde and j. speth 1995 _ phys .
_ d * 52 * 2690 e. van beveren , t. a. rijken , k. metzger , c. dullemond , g. rupp and j. e. ribeiro 1986 _ z. phys .
_ c * 30 * 615 ; e. van beveren and g. rupp 1999 _ eur .
c * 10 * 469 ning wu 2001 `` bes r measurements and @xmath150 deays '' , in xxxvith recontres de moriond , _ qcd high energy hadronic interactions _ , les arcs ; _ preprint _ hep - ex/0104050 n. e. booth , a. abashian and k. m. crowe 1961 _ phys .
lett . _ * 7 * 35 ; j. banaigs _ et al_. 1973 _ nucl . phys .
_ b * 67 * 1 ; f. plouin _ et al_. 1978 _ nucl
. phys . _ a * 302 * 413 j. yonnet _ et al_. 2001 _ phys .
_ c * 63 * 014001 ; a. gardestig 1999 _ @xmath17 newslett _ * 15 * 315 ; r. wurzinger _
et al_. 1999 _ phys .
_ b * 445 * 423 p. estabrooks _ et al_. 1979 _ phys .
_ d * 19 * 2678 j. schwinger 1957 _ ann .
* 2 * 407 ; v. hagopian and w. selove 1963 _ phys .
* 10 * 533 d. iagolnitzer , j. zinn - justin and j. b. zuber 1973 _ nucl .
_ b * 60 * 233 s. n. cherry and m. r. pennington 2001 _ nucl .
_ a * 688 * 823 see @xcite , @xcite and @xcite ; m. jamin , j. a. oller and a. pich 2000 _ nucl .
_ b * 587 * 331 d. black , a. h. fariborz , f. sannino and j. schechter 1998 _ phys .
_ d * 58 * 054012 ; k. takamatsu ( sigma collaboration ) 2001 _ prog .
* 102 * e52 ; s. ishida et al .
1997 _ prog .
_ * 98 * 621 m. nowakowski and a. pilaftsis 1993 _ z. phys .
_ c * 60 * 121 m. nowakowski 1999 _ int .
phys . _ a * 14 * 589 and references therein .
j. bogdanowicz , m. pindor and r. raczka 1995 _ found .
phys . _ * 25 * 833 i. saba - stefanescu 1987 _ fortschritte der physik _ * 35 * 573 ; j. e. bowbock and h. burkhardt 1975 _ rep .
phys . _ * 38 * 1099 ; d. atkinson , m. de roo and t. j. t. m. polman 1984 _ phys .
b _ * 148 * 361 asher peres 1966 _ annals of physics _ * 37 * 179 r. kaminski , l. lesniak and b. loiseau 1999 _ eur .
c * 9 * 141 r. kaminski , l. lesniak and b. loiseau 2003 _ phys .
_ b * 551 * 241 , _ preprint _ hep - ph/0210334 and references therein ; see also m. r. pennington and s. d. s. d. protopopescu 1973 _ phys .
_ d * 9 * 2591 s. m. roy 1971 _ phys .
_ b * 36 * 353 ; _ ibid _ , 1990 _ helv .
. acta _ * 63 * 621 hyams _ et al_. 1973 _ nucl
_ b * 64 * 134 ; protopopescu _ et al_. 1973 _ phys .
_ d * 7 * 1279 s. bartalucci
_ et al_. 1979 _ nuevo cimento _ a * 49 * 207 r. kaminski , l. lesniak and k. rybicki 1997 _ z. phys .
_ c * 74 * 79 g. grayer _
et al_. 1974 _ nucl .
_ b * 75 * 189 ; phase shifts can also found on the web - site , http://amaterasu.kek.jp/sigma/database/pipip a. b. wicklund _
1980 _ phys .
* 45 * 1469 d. cohen _ et al .
_ 1980 _ phys .
_ d * 22 * 2595 d. aston _
et al_. 1988 _ nucl .
_ b * 296 * 493 p. estabrooks _ et al_. 1978 _ nucl .
_ b * 133 * 490 d. aston _
et al_. oct 1991 _ slac - pub-5682 _ 8pp ; invited talk given at int . conf . on hadron spectroscopy , college park , md , aug 12 - 16 , 1991 d. aston _ et al_. 1987 _ nucl .
_ b * 292 * 693 | using the concept of collision time ( time delay ) introduced by eisenbud and wigner and its connection to on - shell intermediate unstable states , we study mesonic resonances in @xmath0 and @xmath1 scattering .
the time - delay method proves its usefulness by revealing the spectrum of the well - known @xmath2 - and @xmath3- mesons and by supporting some speculations on @xmath2-mesons in the @xmath4 mev region .
we use this method further to shed some light on more speculative meson resonances , among others the enigmatic scalars .
we confirm the existence of chiralons below @xmath5 gev in the unflavoured and strange meson sector .
= cmbx10 scaled1 6.0 in 8.5 in -0.25truein 0.30truein 0.30truein * collision times in @xmath0 and @xmath1 scattering and spectroscopy of meson resonances + * @xmath6departamento de fisica , universidad de los andes , cra.1 no.18a-10 , santafe de bogota , colombia + @xmath7nuclear physics division , bhabha atomic research centre , mumbai 400085 .5 cm pacs numbers : 13.75.lb , 11.55.-m , 14.40.aq , 25.40.ny |
egret detected more than 30 gamma - ray bursts ( grbs ) with gev emission ( schneid et al .
1992 ; sommer et al . 1994 ; hurley et al . 1994 ; schaefer et al . 1998 ; gonzlez et al .
the highest energy photon detected was the 18 gev photon which arrived 4500 seconds after the trigger of grb 940217 ( hurley et al .
these observations motivated many interesting ideas .
some focused on prompt high energy photon emission , e.g. , synchrotron - self - compton ( ssc ) emission or inverse compton scattering of photons emitted by one shell by electrons in another shell @xcite .
others focused on high energy afterglow processes : the interaction of ultra - relativistic protons with a dense cloud ( katz 1994 ) , ssc in early forward and reverse shocks ( mszros & rees 1994 ) , electromagnetic cascade of tev @xmath1rays in the infrared / microwave background ( plaga 1995 ) , synchrotron radiation of ultra - high energy forward shock protons @xcite , and inverse compton scattering of prompt @xmath1rays by reverse shock electrons ( beloborodov 2005 ) .
two kinds of high energy afterglow emission models have been discussed extensively .
the first is ssc emission .
motivated by the successful detection of an optical flash in grb 990123 ( akerlof et al .
1999 ; sari & piran 1999 ; mszros & rees 1999 ) , wang , dai & lu ( 2001a , b ) , peer & waxman ( 2005 ) and kobayashi ( 2007 ) calculated ssc emission from the reverse shock .
granot & guetta ( 2003 ) and peer & waxman ( 2004 ) applied these ideas to grb 941017 .
the high energy ssc component of the forward component was calculated by dermer , chiang & mitman ( 2000 ) , sari & esin ( 2001 ) , and zhang & mszros ( 2001b ) .
the second family of models involves the external inverse compton ( eic ) process .
these include comptonization of the prompt photons by the forward shock electrons ( fan , zhang & wei 2005b ) , and upscattering of far - uv / x - ray flare photons ( assuming that they originate in internal shocks ) by the forward shock ( wang , li & mszros 2006 ; fan & piran 2006b ) .
most of the above calculations were based on the standard afterglow model .
however , recently , _
swift _ has detected numerous grbs whose early ( first @xmath2 s ) afterglow emission can not be reproduced within the standard model @xcite .
various modifications of the standard model have been put forward to explain the observations . however , none are compelling and the validity of the whole model is now in question .
high energy emission provides a new window into afterglow physics and can provide an independent test of models .
motivated by this , we calculate the predicted high energy afterglow emission in different scenarios .
we show that there is a canonical high energy grb afterglow light curve which ought to be observed ( see fig . [
fig : summary ] ) .
the detection of the predicted high energy emission features by observations with glast or ground - based gamma - ray detectors would enable us to test the validity of the overall model as well as the specific modifications that have been put forward to explain _ swift _ observations .
the paper is structured as follows . in section 2
we review _ swift _ grb afterglow observations and their interpretation . in section [ sec
: code ] we describe the methods we employ for careful calculations of the inverse compton effect ; this section may be skipped if one is interested only in the results . in section 4
we calculate the ssc emission of the forward shock , and in section 5 we calculate the possible high energy emission associated with x - ray flares , including both ssc emission from within the flare and eic emission from the forward shock . in section [ sec : det ] we discuss the prospects for detecting high energy afterglows by glast and ground - based telescopes .
we conclude in section 7 with a summary .
in the pre-_swift _ era , most of the afterglow data was collected hours after the grb .
these data were found to be consistent with the external forward shock model , though sometimes energy injection , a wind profile , or structured or patchy jets had to be invoked to account for the observations ( piran 2004 ) .
the _ swift _ satellite has changed the situation . the x - ray telescope ( xrt ) and the uv / optical telescope ( uvot ) onboard this satellite can slew to the direction of a grb in real time and record the early broad band afterglow light curves .
a schematic x - ray afterglow light curve based on the xrt data has been summarized by zhang et al .
( 2006 ) and nousek et al .
( 2006 ) ( see fig . [
fig : cartoon ] ) and consists of the following features : a very early sharp decline ( phase - i ) ; a shallow decline of the x - ray afterglow ( phase - ii ) ; a normal " decay phase ( phase - iii ) , possibly followed by a jet break ( phase - iv ) ; energetic x - ray flares ( phase - v ) , which may show up during any phase . note that not all of these features have been detected in every burst .
we focus here on the most remarkable of the new features : the slow decline ( phase - ii ) and the flares ( phase - v ) .
both are expected to have associated signatures in the high energy emission .
( 0,200 ) ( 0,0 ) in about half of the _ swift _ grbs , the x - ray lightcurves show an extended flattening ( phase - ii ) . in most cases , but not all , there is no change in the spectral slope when the light curve makes a transition from the shallow phase - ii segment to the normal " phase - iii segment .
the usual interpretation of the shallow phase is that it involves energy injection into the blast wave @xcite .
an alternative possibility is that the parameter @xmath3 , which measures the fraction of shock energy transferred to the downstream electrons , varies with time ) .
the interpretation of this chromatic behavior is less clear . in the present work ,
we focus on the cases in which the x - ray and optical light curves break achromatically . ] , as would be the case if this parameter is shock - strength dependent . in either case
the corresponding ssc emission of the forward shock would be different from the one anticipated in the standard afterglow model , as well as from each other .
energetic x - ray flares ( phase - v ) have been detected in several pre-_swift _ grbs and in about half the _ swift _ grbs @xcite .
the rapid decline of the flares suggests that they arise due to late internal shocks " resulting from reactivation of the central engine @xcite .
an alternative interpretation is that the x - ray flares arise due to refreshed shocks @xcite .
once again , the gev emission can serve to distinguish between the models .
if the flares are produced by internal shocks , most of the up - scattered photons would arrive after the far - uv / x - ray flare .
the high energy photons in this scenario will be produced by scattering of the flare photons in the external shock . in the eic process ,
the duration of the high energy emission is stretched by the spherical curvature of the blast wave ( beloborodov 2005 ; wang et al .
2006 ; fan & piran 2006b ) and is further extended by the highly anisotropic distribution of the up - scattered photons ( fan & piran 2006b ; see our fig.[fig : ww ] for a comparison ) . for the latter effect ,
see aharonian & atoyan ( 1981 ) , ghisellini et al .
( 1991 ) and brunetti ( 2001 ) for details .
the relativistic electrons that are present in any synchrotron source will also produce very high energy photons via inverse compton scattering ( either ssc or eic ) .
we turn now to a calculation of this emission . when the energy of the electrons and the seed photons is sufficiently large it is necessary to take into account the klein - nishina correction to the scattering cross section .
we also need to include the inverse compton cooling in calculating the energy distribution of the relativistic electrons .
the essential problem is to calculate carefully the compton parameter , @xmath4 , the ratio between the power loss through inverse compton scattering and synchroton radiation ( @xmath5 and @xmath6 respectively ) : @xmath7 throughout this work , the superscript @xmath8 indicates that the quantity is measured in the rest frame of the emitting region . in the regime of thomson scattering
, @xmath4 is a constant , independent of the electron lorentz factor @xmath9 , and one obtains a constant reduction in the amplitude of the synchrotron emission compared to the case with no inverse compton scattering .
this makes computations relatively easy .
however , in the general case , since the klein - nishina correction to @xmath4 depends on @xmath9 , the effect of inverse compton scattering on the spectrum and on the electron energy distribution is non - trivial .
the power emitted in synchrotron radiation by an electron with lorentz factor @xmath9 is : @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the strength of the magnetic field .
the corresponding spectral energy distribution of the radiation is @xmath12 { d\nu'\over \nu'_{\rm s}(\ge)},\ ] ] where @xmath13 , @xmath14 and @xmath15 is the modified bessel function .
the power emitted via inverse compton scattering is given by : @xmath16 where @xmath17 is the frequency of the photon after scattering .
the quantity @xmath18 is the scattered photon spectrum per electron ( blumenthal & gould 1970 ) .
it is related to the spectral energy distribution of the inverse compton radiation emitted by an electron : @xmath19 we define the auxiliary quantities @xmath20 , @xmath21 and @xmath22 $ ] , where @xmath23 is the photon energy before scattering .
the factor @xmath24 determines the regime of scattering , with the thomson limit corresponding to @xmath25 .
the factor @xmath26 satisfies @xmath27 ( jones 1968 ; blumenthal & gould 1970 ) .
we can express @xmath28 in terms of these quantities and in terms of the frequency distribution of the seed photons @xmath29 : @xmath30 .
\label{eq : jones1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] to complete the calculation we need to know the frequency distribution of seed photons @xmath29 . for eic
this is simple since the photons originate from an external source . for ssc
, however , the situation is more complicated .
this is because the photons are produced via synchrotron emission by the same electrons that are participating in inverse compton scattering .
the additional cooling of these electrons by ic influences their energy distribution and thus their synchrotron emission .
we have solved this problem by two different approaches .
first , we have used a simple `` instantaneous '' approach which involves a single integral equation .
this method , which we describe in section 3.1 , is conceptually simple and computationally fast .
it is , however , approximate .
we then describe in section 3.2 a more detailed and general dynamical approach .
this more accurate method is the one we have used for all the calculations presented later in this paper .
however , the two methods give very similar results in a very wide energy range , as seen in fig.[fig : ramesh_yizhong ] . in this approach
we assume a functional form for the electron energy distribution @xmath31 produced through acceleration in the shock front , and consider its instantaneous modification due to cooling .
an electron of lorentz factor @xmath32 has a cooling time given by @xmath33 if @xmath34 is longer than the dynamical time @xmath35 , where @xmath36 is the radius of the shock front relative to the central engine and @xmath37 is the bulk lorentz factor of the outflow , then the electron produces synchrotron and ic emission for the entire time @xmath38 .
however , when @xmath34 is shorter than @xmath38 , the electron radiates only for a time @xmath34 .
thus , the total spectral radiation density produced by all the electrons in the fluid is given by @xmath39 \ ,
\times { \rm min}[t'_d , t'_c(\ge)]\ , n(\ge)d\ge , \label{inteq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the spectral power distributions @xmath40 and @xmath41 are calculated as described earlier . for the inverse compton power ,
we write eq .
( [ eq : ramesh1 ] ) as @xmath42 , where @xmath43 is the klein - nishina cross - section , which is equal to @xmath44 + { 1\over2g}\ln(1 + 2g)-{(1 + 3g)\over ( 1 + 2g)^2 } \}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] equation ( [ inteq ] ) is an integral equation , since the function @xmath45 inside the integral itself depends on @xmath46 .
the quantity @xmath47 is the smallest @xmath32 down to which electrons are present . in dealing with equation ( [ inteq ] )
we need to consider two cases ( see sari , piran & narayan 1998 for details and for the definitions of quantities ) : * slow cooling * : in this case , electrons with @xmath48 have a cooling time @xmath49 . then , @xmath50 , and we may use equation ( [ inteq ] ) directly with @xmath51 and @xmath52 given by the original energy distribution produced in the shock . *
fast cooling * : here , all electrons with @xmath53 have @xmath54 .
therefore , electrons will continue to cool below @xmath55 to a minimum @xmath47 such that @xmath56 now , for the range @xmath57 , all the electrons are available for radiating .
initially , most of the electrons are at @xmath58 , and as these electrons cool each electron will pass every @xmath9 between @xmath58 and @xmath59 ( where all these electrons accumulate ) .
hence we have @xmath60 as usual , we assume a power - law distribution for the electron lorentz factor : @xmath61 for which @xmath55 is given by ( sari et al . 1998 ) @xmath62 equation ( [ inteq ] ) may be solved numerically via an iterative method .
the algorithm proceeds as follows .
we begin with some reasonable initial approximation for @xmath46 . using this , we compute @xmath63 , @xmath34 and @xmath47 .
then , we compute the spectral distributions @xmath64 and @xmath65 for all @xmath66 and obtain via equation ( [ inteq ] ) a new approximation for @xmath46 .
we take this @xmath46 , or ( for smoother convergence ) a suitable linear combination of the new and old @xmath46 , as the current approximation for @xmath46 and repeat the steps .
the iteration usually converges fairly quickly .
this approach can be combined with any desired model for the grb fireball and afterglow dynamics .
we have used the dynamics described in sari ( 1998 ) , except that we multiplied the calculated fluxes by a factor of 1/4 ( cf . , yost et al .
2003 ) . in this approach
we follow dynamically the electron distribution as a function of time @xcite .
the main uncertainty is from the approximation for the initial distribution of the newly shocked electrons as a function of time . lacking a better model , we assume that the electrons are accelerated at the shock wave initially to a single power law distribution : @xmath67 where the maximal lorentz factor is given by @xmath68 ( wei & cheng 1997 ) .
the normalization factor satisfies : @xmath69 , and @xmath70 is the number density of the medium .
we now follow the evolution of the electron distribution using : @xmath71 where @xmath72\gamma_e^2-{\gamma_e \over r } , \label{eq : fan1}\ ] ] @xmath37 is the bulk lorentz factor of the shocked medium , and @xmath73 , @xmath74 is the magnetic energy density . as usual
, we assume that a fraction @xmath3 ( @xmath75 ) of the shock energy density is converted into energy of relativistic electrons ( magnetic field ) . to complete the calculations we need the location and the lorentz factor of the blast wave as a function of time .
the dynamics of the blast wave is obtained by solving the differential equations presented by huang et al .
the possible ( but poorly understood ) sideways expansion of the ejecta is ignored .
we then calculate the electron distribution using eq .
( [ eq : fan0 ] ) and the supplemental relations . the quantity @xmath29 needed in eq.([eq : jones1 ] ) is calculated via ( for simplicity , we consider only single scattering ) : @xmath76 where @xmath77 ( the term @xmath78 is introduced by the shock jump condition ) , @xmath79 is the time that the synchrotron radiation photons stay within the shocked medium , and @xmath80 is the lorentz factor below which the synchrotron approximation becomes invalid .
once we know the energy distribution of the electrons , we calculate the synchrotron and inverse compton emission , including synchrotron - self - absorption , and we integrate the observed flux over the equal - arrival time surfaces " ( rees 1966 ; waxman 1997 ; sari 1998 ; granot , piran & sari 1999 ) . in the current code , we did not take into account the influence of the synchrotron - self - absorption on the electron distribution , as that done in peer & waxman ( 2005 ) .
however , with typical grb afterglow parameters adopted in this work , for @xmath81 ( at late times , the high energy emission are usually too low to be of our interest ) , it is straightforward to show that the random lorentz factor of the electrons emitting at the synchrotron - self - absorption frequency @xcite is @xmath82 .
the modification of the low energy electron s distribution through the synchrotron - self - absorption is thus unlikely to influence the high energy spectrum significantly . in fig .
2 , we compare the spectral distributions calculated via the simple instantaneous approach of sec .
3.1 and the more detailed dynamical approach of this subsection .
the two methods are clearly consistent with each other .
this gives us confidence in the validity of both calculations .
note that the multiple inverse compton scattering are ignored in our dynamical approach but are included in the instantaneous approximation .
the consistence between these two approaches suggests that the multiple inverse compton scattering is not important , at least for the typical grb afterglow parameters ( see also sari & esin 2001 ) .
( 0,200 ) ( 0,0 ) in the case of eic , the seed photon energy distribution is not influenced by the electron energy distribution . from this point of view
the calculations are simpler .
however there is another complication , viz .
, for the cases of interest to us , the seed photons are highly anisotropic in the rest frame of the blast wave .
the spectrum of radiation scattered at an angle @xmath83 relative to the direction of the photon beam penetrating through this region is @xcite : @xmath84 , \label{eq : aa81}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath85 , @xmath86 , @xmath87 , @xmath88 , @xmath89 is the angle between the line of sight and the emitting point , @xmath90 is the velocity of the emitting point , and @xmath91 . as expected , on integration over @xmath83 , eq .
( [ eq : aa81 ] ) reduces to eq .
( [ eq : jones1 ] ) .
the energy loss rate of the hot electron beam can be estimated by eq .
( [ eq : p_compt ] ) and @xmath92 is governed by eqs .
( [ eq : y_gamma]-[eq : jones1 ] ) for a given @xmath29 ( see [ sec : eic ] for details ) .
the dominant source of long lasting high energy grb afterglow emission is ssc of the hot electrons in the forward external shock . at early stages
when the cooling of most electrons is important , the luminosity of the ssc emission , @xmath93 , is related to the luminosity of the synchrotron radiation , @xmath94 , as @xcite : @xmath95 where @xmath96 is the compton parameter .
the x - ray luminosity @xmath97 is a small fraction of @xmath94 but we can use it as a proxy for the total luminosity . to do
so we define a factor @xmath98 such that @xmath99 and : @xmath100 as long as @xmath98 does not vary significantly with time , we expect the broad - band ssc afterglow light curve and the x - ray light curve to have a similar temporal behavior .
we expect , therefore , that @xmath101 and @xmath102 should be highly correlated .
this is , of course , confirmed by more detailed analysis , as shown below in eq .
( [ eq : lssc_lx ] ) .
the light curve depends on the dynamics of the blast wave and in particular on the evolution with time of @xmath103 , the power given to the shocked electrons ( see eq . [
eq : l_electron ] ) .
we consider first the evolution expected in the standard afterglow model and then discuss various modifications to the model .
we begin with the standard afterglow .
we consider a circumburst medium with a number density profile @xmath104 , @xmath105 ; here , @xmath106 corresponds to a constant density ism , and @xmath107 to a standard stellar wind ( mszros , rees & wijers 1998 ; dai & lu 1998b ; chevalier & li 2000 ) , though @xmath108 is still possible , as found in some supernovae @xcite and in grb 991208 @xcite .
the quantity @xmath109 is the number density at a distance @xmath110 : @xmath111 where @xmath112[v_w/(10 ^ 8{\rm cm}~{\rm s^{-1}})]$ ] , @xmath113 is the mass loss rate of the progenitor , @xmath114 is the velocity of the stellar wind @xcite . following the standard afterglow model , we assume that the dynamical evolution of the ejecta has a blandford - mckee self - similar profile @xcite . the power given to the freshly shocked electrons , @xmath103 , in the blast wave is : @xmath115 where @xmath116 is the equivalent isotropic energy of the ejecta .
we note that @xmath103 depends only weakly on the density profile . here and throughout this text , the convention @xmath117 has been adopted in cgs units .
the ssc luminosity can be estimated as : @xmath118 all the physics in this equation is , of course , hidden in the factor @xmath119 , which depends , in turn , on the synchrotron and cooling frequencies , @xmath120 and @xmath121 @xcite , and on the power law index of the electron distribution , @xmath122 : @xmath123 where @xcite : @xmath124 the ratio of the synchrotron and cooling frequencies satisfies @xcite : @xmath125 where @xmath126 $ ] .
note that , in all analytical relations , the time and the frequency are measured in the burst s frame , that is we ignore cosmological ( 1+z ) corrections .
numerical results are presented for a canonical burst at @xmath127 .
the x - ray band is typically above @xmath128 . in this case
the forward shock x - ray emission can be related to the kinetic energy of the forward shock @xcite : @xmath129 we thus have @xmath130 for a universal @xmath131 , @xmath132 is sensitive only to @xmath133 and @xmath96 and it is only weakly dependent on other parameters . at early times , when the cooling of electrons is important , @xmath134 ( note that in the standard afterglow model , @xmath135 are all constant ) .
therefore a wide band ssc light curve will have a temporal behavior quite similar to that of the x - rays .
roughly speaking , the energy of the ssc emission peaks at a frequency @xmath136 , where @xmath137 and @xmath138 , where @xmath139 is the cooling lorentz factor of shocked electrons . following the standard treatment @xcite , we have @xmath140 @xmath141 note that @xmath142 or @xmath143 .
so @xmath144 or @xmath145 will shift @xmath146 to the x - ray / uv / optical band and in this case the ssc emission will influence the x - ray observations .
it may even cause a flattening of the x - ray light curve due to the emergence of this new component .
an example of such a case is shown in fig.[fig : xrt ] .
one can see a flat x - ray segment , which is rather similar to that detected by _
swift_. however , it is not clear that this can account for the _ swift _ observations because in this case the x - ray spectrum would vary with time ( see the insert of fig.[fig : xrt ] ) .
such variations are not seen in the _ swift _ data .
( 0,200 ) ( 0,0 ) the ( adiabatic ) standard afterglow model assumes that ( i ) the outflow energy is a constant and ( ii ) the shock parameters are constant . as mentioned earlier
this model is inconsistent with the shallow decline phase ( phase - ii ) .
one possibility is that one of these two basic assumptions should be revised @xcite .
we consider energy injection of the form @xmath147 @xcite , where @xmath148 represents no energy injection and @xmath149 corresponds to a pulsar / magnetar - like energy injection ( dai & lu 1998 ; zhang & mszros 2001a ; dai 2004 ; fan & xu 2006 ) .
other @xmath150 values are possible for an energy injection that results from slower material progressively catching up ( rees & mszros 1998 ; kumar & piran 2000 ; sari & mszros 2000 ; granot & kumar 2006 ) or if an energy injection is caused by the fall - back of the envelope of the massive star ( macfadyen , woosley & heger 2001 ; zhang , woosley & heger 2007 ) .
we also explore the situation where the equipartition parameters , @xmath3 and @xmath75 , are shock - strength dependent ( i.e. , time dependent ) is also time - evolving .
however , this is not seen in the data as the spectrum does not vary during this phase .
] , though the underlying physics is far from clear @xcite . instead of exploring the possible physical processes that lead to such a phenomenon , we simply take @xmath151 .
these modifications lead to : @xmath152 it is straightforward to show that @xmath153 @xmath154 @xmath155 equation ( [ eq : gen3a ] ) is one of our main results . as expected , with significant energy injection , or either @xmath3 increasing with time , or both , @xmath156 is flattened .
an @xmath75 decreasing ( increasing ) with time will also flatten ( steepen ) the high energy emission light curve .
however , such a modification seems to be small and it can not give rise to either the observed shallow decline phase of the x - ray light curve or to a detectable signature in the high energy component .
therefore , we focus on models with either time - dependent @xmath116 or @xmath3 .
the shallow decline seen in the x - ray light curve during phase - ii ( fig .
1 ) requires @xmath157 or @xmath158 . in general , for @xmath159 we need ( in the energy injection case ) @xmath160/(p+2)$ ] which yields @xmath161/(p+2)}\propto t^{-\alpha}$ ] for @xmath162 .
the high energy decline is quite similar to the decline of the x - rays . for a varying @xmath3 ( with no energy injection , i.e. , @xmath148 )
, we need @xmath163 $ ] , which in turn results in @xmath164}\propto t^{(1 - 3\alpha)/2 } ~{\rm for}~p\sim 2 $ ] .
the high energy decline is slightly slower than that of the x - rays in this case . at least in principle
, one could combine ir / optical / uv / x - ray and high energy observations to distinguish between the two modifications described above .
for example , we have @xmath165 and @xmath166}$ ] .
if the early x - ray flattening was caused by @xmath167 , @xmath120 and @xmath168 will decline much more slowly than in the energy injection case @xmath169 .
the wide energy range of lat onboard glast ( 20mev-300gev ) might enable us to observe the variations of @xmath170 with time .
it is interesting to note in passing that these modifications provide a possible explanation for some long - term puzzles in grb 940217 .
the long - lasting mev to gev afterglow emission of grb 940217 @xcite showed two remarkable features : ( a ) the count rate of high energy photons was almost a constant ( b ) the typical energy of these photons was nearly unchanged .
these two features can be reproduced with @xmath171 and @xmath172 ( wei & fan 2007 ) .
( 0,300 ) ( 0,0 ) we turn now to numerical computations of the high energy light curves .
we consider , first , the standard afterglow model using typical parameters that seem to fit the average late afterglow : @xmath173 erg , @xmath174 , @xmath175 , @xmath176 and @xmath177 .
we consider a typical burst at @xmath178 .
figures [ fig : ssc1a ] and [ fig : ssc1b ] depict the calculated light curves and spectra for two models of the external medium : a uniform density ism and a stellar wind . in both figures , panel ( a )
shows the ssc emission afterglow light curve and panel ( b ) shows the spectrum .
( 0,300 ) ( 0,0 ) ( 0,170 ) ( 0,0 ) we consider now an energy injection model where the energy injection has the form : @xmath179 for @xmath180 , which corresponds to @xmath181 and @xmath182 erg .
apart from @xmath150 and @xmath116 all other parameters are similar to those used in the standard case above .
the total integrated energy injected is equal to @xmath183 .
the resulting light curve is shown in fig .
[ fig : ssc_inj ] .
the ssc light curve is flattened when the energy injection is strong enough to suppress the deceleration of the outflow .
the numerical light curve has @xmath184 which is consistent with our analytic estimate @xmath185 for @xmath186 and @xmath181 ( see eq .
( [ eq : gen3a ] ) ) .
we turn now to a time - evolving shock parameter @xmath3 , and consider @xmath3 varying as @xmath187 . as shown in eq .
( [ eq : gen3a ] ) and in fig .
[ fig : ssc_evo ] , an increase with time of @xmath3 flattens the high energy emission light curve .
the very small @xmath3 at early time not only lowers the fraction of the shock energy given to the fresh electrons but it also suppresses the ssc emission . the resulting @xmath188 decline depicted in fig . [
fig : ssc_evo ] is consistent with the analytic estimate @xmath189 for @xmath190 ( and @xmath148 ) .
( 0,170 ) ( 0,0 ) to check the consistency of the numerical and analytic results , we plot the two estimates of @xmath93 ( using eq . [ eq : gen5 ] ) in fig .
[ fig : check ] .
the analytic results ( the thick lines ) are a factor of @xmath191 times larger than the corresponding numerical results ( the thin lines ) .
this is reasonable as some important corrections , such as the integration of the emission over equal - arrival surfaces " , have been ignored in the analytic formulae .
( 0,170 ) ( 0,0 )
we turn now to gev flares that might arise from inverse compton scattering of the radiation associated with x - ray ( or uv ) flares . although x - ray flares ( phase - v in fig.[fig : cartoon ] ) were detected even before _ swift _ ,
their frequency became clear only after _
swift _ began its observations .
by now it is known that flares are quite common and can appear at all phases of the afterglow . at times
the energy emitted in a flare can be fairly large .
there are two main ideas to explain the origin of these flares : ( i ) late internal shocks `` ( fan & wei 2005 , burrow et al . 2005 , zhang 2006 ) associated with a long - lived central engine , and ( ii ) refreshed shocks '' @xcite when late shells encounter the external shock and lead to brightening .
inverse compton scattering of photons from an x - ray flare are possible via two distinct mechanisms
. it could be the result of ssc emission from the same electrons that produce the x - ray flares .
if the x - ray flare is produced by late internal shocks , then an additional source of high energy radiation is possible , viz . , eic scattering of flare photons by hot electrons in the external shock .
we consider both possibilities .
ssc within the same shock that produces the x - ray flare will give a high energy flare simultaneously with the low energy flare .
this would arise if the x - ray flare results from either a late internal shock or from a refreshed shock within the forward external shock .
it is difficult to predict the expected ssc emission as we have no robust estimate of the typical lorentz factor of the shocked electrons that produce the x - ray flare .
a critical factor is the location of the shock , which determines the various parameter within the emitting region . for prompt @xmath1rays from an internal shock , the typical radius of the shock is @xmath192 cm @xcite .
if flares are produced by late internal shocks " , @xmath193 cm is possible @xcite , whereas with refreshed external shocks " , @xmath194 may be as large as @xmath195 cm @xcite .
assuming that the soft x - ray flares are powered by the synchrotron radiation of the shocked electrons we can estimate the typical lorentz factor of the electrons , @xmath196 .
the magnetic field , @xmath197 , at @xmath194 can be estimated by : @xmath198^{1/2 } \sim 250~{\rm gauss}~\varepsilon^{1/2 } l_{\rm x,49}^{1/2}\gamma^{-1}r_{\rm flare,17}^{-1},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath199 . for this value of the magnetic field
, the peak energy of the flare photons will be at @xmath200 kev if the typical electron lorentz factor is @xmath201 the energy of a typical inverse compton photon is then @xmath202 thus , high energy emission simultaneous with the x - ray flare is expected if the emitting region is not significantly magnetized . roughly speaking , the total fluence of the ssc emission of the flare shock is comparable to that of the x - ray emission , typically @xmath203 integrated over the aftgerglow . in late internal shocks ( i.e. , @xmath193 cm ) , a gev flash accompanying the x - ray flare is possible ( wei , yan & fan 2006 ) .
this problem was also discussed by wang et al .
( 2006 ) , who assumed that @xmath204 and obtained @xmath205 mev , which they considered as uninteresting .
however , as shown above , @xmath196 can be large to @xmath206 and @xmath207 is two orders of magnitude larger . in refreshed external shocks , a gev - tev flash is predicted because of its very large @xmath208 cm ) , as indicated in eq .
( [ eq : ssc_flare ] ) .
more detailed analysis can be found in galli & piro ( 2007 ) .
a subtle issue that has to be checked is whether the high energy photons will be absorbed by pair production on the high energy tail of the flare .
the pair production optical depth for photons with energy @xmath209 ( absorbed by the flare photons with energy @xmath210 ) can be estimated as ( e.g. , svensson 1987 ) @xmath211 where @xmath212 is the total flare photon number of one pulse satisfying @xmath213 , where @xmath214 is the timescale of the flare pulse and the high - energy power - law index @xmath215 has been used to get the numerical coefficient . clearly , for @xmath216 cm , i.e. , the refreshed shock case , the tens gev high energy photon emission will not be absorbed by the flare photons . for @xmath217
cm , i.e. , the late internal shock case , the small optical depth will not affect the sub - gev flux unless @xmath218 .
we turn now to the scenario in which the x - ray flares are produced by late internal shocks ( fan & wei , 2005 , burrow et al . 2005 , zhang 2006 ) .
we calculate the inverse compton scattering of these seed photons by hot electrons accelerated within the external shock .
we assume that the x - ray flares are accompanied by far - uv emission and calculate the upscattering of these photons as well .
a central ingredient of this scenario is that in the rest frame of the blast wave , the seed photons are highly beamed .
we take care of this effect , following the analysis of aharonian & atoyan ( 1981 ) .
if the eic emission is simultaneous with the x - ray flare ( i.e. , the duration of the eic emission has not been extended significantly ) , the eic luminosity can be estimated by eq .
( [ eq : gen5 ] ) .
however , in the rest frame of the shocked material , the eic emission has a maximum at @xmath219 and it vanishes for small scattering angles @xcite .
this effect lowers the high energy flux in two ways .
first , a fraction of the total energy is emitted out of our line of sight and thus the received power is depressed ( relative to the isotropic seed photon case ) .
this yields a correction by a factor of 2 ( which we ignore henceforth ) .
second and more important , the strongest emission is from , where @xmath220 , depending on the cooling of the electrons .
the observed emission from an angle @xmath89 is thus @xmath221^{-3 } \sin \theta ( 1-\cos \theta_{\rm sc})^{(1+\delta)/2 } \propto \theta^{\delta+2}(1+\gamma^2 \theta^2)^{-(7+\delta)/2}\equiv { \cal f}$ ] since @xmath222 .
the requirement that @xmath223 yields @xmath224 for @xmath225 . ] @xmath226 .
thus the peak time of the high energy eic emission is estimated to be ( fan & piran 2006b ; wang & mszros 2006 ) : @xmath227 where @xmath228 is the time when the x - ray flare ceases .
@xmath229 , which is also proportional to the duration of the high energy peak , could be much longer than @xmath230 , the duration of the soft x - ray flare .
the luminosity of the high energy flare would be lower than the simple estimate by the ratio of the durations : @xmath231 at 100 - 1000 s after the burst , the forward shock emission peaks in the far - uv to soft x - ray band , and the corresponding ssc emission peaks in sub - gev to gev energy range .
a comparison of the ssc luminosity of the forward shock after but around @xmath228 , @xmath93 ( eq . ( [ eq : gen5 ] ) ) , with @xmath232 shows that the ssc emission would be stronger than the eic emission and the wide eic flare would be undetectable .
however , if the forward shock electrons are in the slow cooling regime before the x - ray flare , their ssc emission is weak and the eic flare might be detectable . in this case the total energy available for extraction in the eic process @xmath233 is much larger than @xmath234 , where @xmath235 is the total number of electrons swept by the forward shock at the time @xmath236 and at the same time @xmath93 is much smaller than @xmath237 .
though @xmath238 may still outshine @xmath232 at @xmath239 , since it decreases rapidly with time ( steeper than @xmath240 , as both @xmath133 and @xmath241 are decreasing with time , see eq .
( [ eq : gen5 ] ) ) , the eic high energy emission may still dominate at late times .
if the eic emission dominates over the ssc emission , the high energy light curve will flatten , as we show below ( e.g. , fig .
[ fig : eic_flux ] ) .
such a flattening could arise also as a result of energy injection or due to an increasing @xmath3 .
however , as we argued in the last section , in those two scenarios , the x - ray and the high energy emission light curves are quite similar and flattening should be apparent also in the x - ray signal .
the eic emission should , on the other hand , show an x - ray flare preceding high energy emission and not accompanying a flat x - ray light curve . as an example we consider the giant flare of grb 050502b @xcite and
examine the expected external ic emission that will arise from such a flare .
the flux of the flare , in the 0.2@xmath010 kev energy band , can be approximated as a steep rise : @xmath242 for @xmath243s , a constant plateau lasting until @xmath244s and a subsequent sharp decline which might be due to a curvature emission component @xcite . to calculate the eic emission
we need ( see eq .
[ eq : jones1 ] ) @xmath245 , the distribution of the seed photons in the rest frame of the shocked medium .
if the flare originates from activity of the central engine @xcite one might expect that the radiation process is similar to that of the prompt emission .
lacking exact information on the spectrum of the flare and in particular on its peak energy we assume that it has a typical band function @xcite : @xmath246 where the high - energy power - law index @xmath247 and the low - energy power - law index @xmath248 . as the peak energy
is not known we consider three representative values : @xmath249kev . for a given @xmath250 , the parameter @xmath251 in eq .
( [ eq : band ] ) is obtained from the observed flux : @xmath252 where we used lower and upper limits on @xmath253 of @xmath254 and @xmath255 .
this is because the self - absorption frequency is likely to be in the uv band @xcite and the emission in the hard x - ray band is unknown for nearly all flares .
( 0,260 ) ( 0,0 ) ( 0,260 ) ( 0,0 ) the redshift of grb 050502b is unknown . we assume the canonical value of @xmath127 for which @xmath256 erg because the @xmath1ray fluence is @xmath257 @xcite . for the other parameters we take @xmath258 , @xmath259 , @xmath260 , @xmath261 , and @xmath177 .
figures [ fig : eic_dis ] and [ fig : eic_disb ] depict the electron distributions and the compton parameters as functions of @xmath9 , for @xmath262 kev .
the cooling effect of the x - ray flare photons on the blast wave electrons is seen clearly in these figures .
one sees that the energy of the electrons is depressed between 400 and 700 s and then it increases at 900 s when the cooling effect due to the flare photons ceases .
as expected the higher the flare luminosity , the stronger the eic cooling .
electrons with @xmath263 lose most of their energy via the eic process ( see the large values of the compton parameter for these electrons in figs . [
fig : eic_dis](b ) and [ fig : eic_disb](b ) ) .
the resulting high energy emission is shown in fig .
[ fig : eic_flux ] .
the ssc emission decreases during and after the flare as the electrons are cooled by the eic process . also at a later time we get contributions to the observed spectrum from higher latitude regions from which the emission is weaker .
the eic emission is not simultaneous with the x - ray flare .
it peaks at @xmath264 ( see eq .
( [ eq : t_p ] ) ) , and it lasts much longer than the x - ray flare .
this temporal behavior is determined by the geometry of the emitting surface , the radiation spectrum and the highly anisotropic eic emission .
the lagging behavior is unique and if it is observed , i.e. , if it is not hidden by ssc emission , it would demonstrate that x - ray flares are produced by internal shocks .
note that without the anisotropic correction , the eic light curve is higher and narrower and the peak eic emission is overestimated by one order of magnitude ( see fig.[fig : ww ] ) .
( 0,320 ) ( 0,0 ) ( 0,200 ) ( 0,0 ) for most soft x - ray flares , the peak emission energy seems to be below 0.2 kev , i.e. , they may be intrinsically far - uv flares .
the up - scattering of the far - uv photons in the external blast wave results in strong sub - gev emission .
[ fig : eic_spectrum ] depicts the resulting eic spectrum ( time integral ) for different values of @xmath265 kev other parameters , including the luminosity of the flare in the 0.2 - 10kev band are taken to be the same . for a far - uv flare ( @xmath266 kev )
the seed photons are much more numerous than for an x - ray flare .
consequently the resulting sub - gev photons are much more numerous than those resulting from a kev flare .
therefore the eic emission following a uv flare will be easier to detect .
( 0,320 ) ( 0,0 )
we turn now to the key question : are the gev to tev high energy signals predicted by our models observable with current or soon to be commissioned detectors ? using the calculated high energy spectrum @xmath267 as a function of time for any given model , we can estimate the total number , @xmath268 , of detectable high energy photons , @xmath269 where @xmath270 are the times when the observations begin and end , respectively , @xmath271 is the energy range of the detector , and @xmath272 is the effective area of the detector as a function of @xmath273 . for lat onboard glast , we approximate @xmath274 as ( see http://www-glast.slac.stanford.edu /software / is / glast@[email protected] ) : @xmath276 we consider first the high energy ssc emission in the afterglow , which we estimated in sec .
4 . for the models presented in fig .
[ fig : ssc1a ] fig .
[ fig : ssc_evo ] , we use @xmath277 s ; at earlier time the high energy emission may be dominated by the synchrotron and/or ssc emission of the internal shocks @xcite .
we choose an upper limit of @xmath278 s ; after this time the ssc emission is usually too low to be of interest .
( 0,200 ) ( 0,0 ) figure [ fig : nufnu ] shows the integrated flux expected for the various ssc scenarios discussed in sec .
4 , and table [ tab:1 ] summarizes the expected number of photons that would be detected by lat from a burst with standard parameters ( see figs . [
fig : ssc1a ] - [ fig : ssc_evo ] ) at @xmath127 .
typically , one expects to detect a few photons above 20 mev and very few high energy photons above 100 gev . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] not surprisingly , the modified afterglow models that account for the shallow x - ray light curve in phase - ii give fewer counts than the standard afterglow model .
the reduced x - ray flux in these models ( needed to explain the shallow light curve ) causes a corresponding reduction in the high energy flux .
however , we still expect a weak detection by glast .
such weak signals , of course , can not play an important role on distinguishing between the different models .
but for some extremely bright events , e.g. , grb 940217 , the high energy observation may pose a tight constraint on the underlying physical process ( e.g. , wei & fan 2007 ) .
considering next the high energy emission associated with flares , the time - integrated @xmath279 of the high energy eic component is shown in fig .
[ fig : eic_spectrum ] . in the case of a uniform external ism , for @xmath280 kev , @xmath281 and @xmath282 , respectively .
the eic high energy afterglow component is more easily detected if the flare has a significant uv component .
note that fan & piran ( 2006b ) used a larger effective detection area ( @xmath283 in the energy range of @xmath284 ) .
this overestimates @xmath285 for @xmath286mev where most of the up - scattered photons are expected ( see eq .
[ eq : s_det ] ) . in the case of an external shock in a stellar wind we have for @xmath280 kev , @xmath287 and @xmath288 , respectively .
now the scattered far - uv photons are in the sub - mev band ( fan & piran 2006b ) .
therefore , the far - uv component does not increase the detected signal . as long as
the flare outflow is just weakly or even not magnetized and @xmath289 cm , the gev ssc emission fluence is expected to be comparable to the fluence of the kev flare , typically @xmath290 . with such a fluence ,
the gev flashes ( ssc emission ) accompanying bright flares may be detectable by glast .
if the flare is produced by a late internal shock we expect that the typical ssc photon energy is about 300 mev . at this energy
a fluence @xmath291 corresponds to a detection of 5 photons .
so the ssc emission of a very bright x - ray flare with a fluence @xmath292 should be detected , provided that the compton parameter is unity or larger .
if the flare is produced by a refreshed shock the typical photon energy would be higher , up to tens of gev
. the number of these high energy photons would then be much smaller than in the case of late internal shocks . as a result
, it might not be detectable by glast .
so far we have focused on the detectability of high energy emission by glast . however , there are also other detectors .
magic , whipplewhipple.html ] and h.e.s.s .
are high energy telescopes operating at energies above @xmath293 gev .
these cerenkov detectors have very large effective areas @xmath294 .
the expected fluxes of very high energy ( @xmath295gev ) photons from bursts at @xmath296 should correspond to the detection of @xmath297 photons .
however , this estimate ignores the absorption of the high energy photons by the ir - background @xcite . given that the optical depth for a @xmath293 gev photon from @xmath298 is @xmath299 @xcite , we expect that for most _ swift _ bursts with a typical @xmath300 the number of detectable @xmath295gev photons will be negligible
. our results are thus largely consistent with the null detection of the magic telescope @xcite .
whipple @xcite observed the @xmath301gev afterglow emission of a few grbs with @xmath302 , and in particular grb 030329 , a nearby long burst .
however , the earliest observation was carried out @xmath303 hours after the trigger of grb 030329 when the expected very high energy ssc afterglow emission is quite low ( see also xue et al .
2008 ) . as the optical depth for ir absorption increases strongly with energy and at low redshifts linearly with @xmath304
, we expect a detection of @xmath293 gev or lower energy photons from nearby strong bursts , provided the observations begin very early and last for several hours .
such nearby bursts are , of course , very rare but they do exist and high energy observatories should focus on them .
( 0,250 ) ( 0,0 ) very high energy inverse compton emission is an integral part of the current afterglow model @xcite .
we have calculated the high energy emission in different models of grb afterglows , including the ssc component of the forward shock , the ssc component of the electrons producing x - ray flares and the eic component of flare photons upscattered by relativistic electrons in the forward shock .
our predicted high energy light curves are summarized schematically in the lower panel of fig .
[ fig : summary ] .
high energy ssc emission in the energy range 20 mev 300 gev from bright bursts should lead to a detectable signal of several ( @xmath305 ) photons by the lat onboard glast .
higher energy telescopes such as magic , whipple , h.e.s.s and kangooroo working in the energy range @xmath295gev , could detect strong signals ( few hundred photons ) from nearby bursts at around the lower energy limit of these detectors ( @xmath306gev )
. signals from more distant bursts will be absorbed by the ir background .
the flux from a @xmath307 burst will usually be too low to be detected .
strong gev ssc emission simultaneous with kev flare photons is possible if the emitting region is not highly magnetized .
the eic component of the flare , on the other hand , will be extended and will last up to ten times as long as the x - ray flare ( see fig .
[ fig : eic_flux ] ) .
this is because , in the eic process , the duration of the high energy emission is affected by the spherical curvature of the blast wave and is mainly extended by the highly anisotropic radiation of the up - scattered photons ( see fig.[fig : ww ] ) .
unfortunately , a significant detection is likely only if the ssc emission of the forward shock is very weak .
a high energy detection could be used to probe the spectrum of the low energy flare and in particular the possible existence of a far uv component .
these signatures of the high energy flare are independent of the density profile of the external medium
. a detection of a high energy component , _ in principle _ , will enable us to test current models of grbs and their afterglows .
a detailed comparison of the high energy and low energy light curves , in particular during the shallow decline phase , might even enable us to discriminate between different modifications of the standard afterglow model .
however , given the small number of expected high energy photons , it is unlikely that we can achieve this goal with glast .
it should be noted that the two modifications to the standard model that we considered in this paper , viz .
, extended energy injection and time - evolving @xmath3 , both predict achromatic behavior such that there should be a shallow light curve in the optical band simultaneously with the shallow x - ray light curve .
however , as noted in fig .
1 , this is not always seen .
thus , it is possible that none of our models gives a correct description of afterglow physics .
model that suggest flattening of the light curve due to emergence of an x - ray ssc component ( see fig .
[ fig : xrt ] ) that would arise in a very dense medium may explain the x - ray flattening but this would involve significant variability in the observed x - ray spectrum .
one intriguing possibility is that the standard afterglow model , without energy injection or varying @xmath3 , is indeed the correct model , but the x - ray emission is suppressed during phase - ii because of some radiation physics that we have not yet understood .
this would explain why the optical light curve shows no shallow phase - ii segment or a break from phase - ii to phase - iii .
what kind of high energy emission do we then expect ? in the absence of a real model , we can not say anything definite .
it is possible that the high energy light curve would follow the predictions of the standard model .
perhaps the high energy emission may even be enhanced because the missing x - ray emission is radiated in this band .
these are pure speculations , but they are worth keeping in mind .
it is very important to carry out high energy observations of grb afterglows , independent of model expectations , because the signal may in the end turn out to be stronger than anything predicted .
we thank the second referee for detailed comments .
yzf thanks x. y. wang and z. li for discussions .
this work is supported by us - israel bsf .
tp acknowledges the support of schwartzmann university chair .
yzf and dmw are also supported by the national science foundation ( grant 10673034 ) of china and by a special grant of chinese academy of sciences . 99 aharonian f. a. , atoyan a. m. , 1981 , ap&ss , 79 , 321 akerlof c. , et al . 1999 ,
nature , 398 , 400 albert j. et al . , 2007 , apj , 667 , 358 band d. , 1993 , apj , 413 , 281 beloborodov a. m. , 2005 , apj , 618 , l13 blandford , r. d. , & mckee , c. f. 1976 , phys . fluids . , 19 , 1130 blumenthal g. r. , gould r. j. , 1970 , rev . mod .
phys . , 42 , 237 brunetti g. , 2001 , astroparticle phys . , 13 , 107 burrows d. n. , et al . , 2005 , science , 309 , 1833 chevalier r. a. , li z. y. , 2000 , apj , 536 , 195 chincarini g. , et al . , 2007 ,
apj , submitted ( astro - ph/0702371 ) cohen , e. , piran , t. , 1999 , apj , 518 , 346 connaughton v. , 2002 , apj , 567 , 1028 cusumano g. , 2007 , a&a , 462 , 73 dai z. g. , 2004 , apj , 606 , 1000 dai z. g. , gou l. j. , 2001 , apj , 552 , 72 dai z. g. , lu t. , 1998a , a&a , 333 , l87 dai z. g. , lu t. , 1998b , mnras , 298 , 87 , 2006 , science , 311 , 1127 dermer c. d. , chiang j. , mitman k. e. 2000 , apj , 537 , 785 falcone a. d. , et al .
2006 , apj , 641 , 1010 fan y. z. , piran t. , 2006a , mnras , 369 , 197 fan y. z. , piran t. , 2006b , mnras , 370 , l24 fan y. z. , wei d. m. , 2005 , mnras , 364 , l42 fan y. z. , xu d. , 2006 , mnras , 372 , l19 fan y. z. , zhang b. , proga d. , 2005a , apj , 635 , l129 fan y. z. , zhang b. , wei d. m. , 2005b , apj , 629 , 334 , 1996 , apj , 473 , 998 freedman d. l. , waxman e. 2001 , apj , 547 , 922 galli a. , piro l. , 2006 , a&a , 455 , 413 galli a. , piro l. , 2007 , a&a , 475 , 421 gao w. h. , fan y. z. , 2006 , chin . j. astron .
astrophys , 6 , 513 ghisellini g. , george i. m. , fabian a. c. , done c , 1991 , mnras , 248 , 14 goad m. r. , et al . , 2006 , a&a , 449 , 89 gonzlez m. m. , et al . , 2003 , nature , 424 , 749 gou l. j. , mszros p. , 2007 ,
apj , 668 , 392 granot j. , guetta d. , 2003 , apj , 598 , l11 granot j. , kumar p. , 2006 , mnras , 366 , l13 granot j. , knigl a. , piran t. 2006 , mnras , 370 , 1946 granot j. , piran , t. , sari , r. , 1999 , apj , 513 , 679 , 2007 , a&a , 461 , 95 gupta n. , & zhang b. , 2007 , mnras , 380 , 78 horan d. , et al . , 2007 ,
apj , 655 , 396 huang k. y. , et al .
2007 , apj , 654 , l25 huang y. f. , gou l. j. , dai z. g. , lu t. , 2000 , apj , 543 , 90 hurley k. , et al . , 1994 , nature , 372 , 652 int zand j. j. m. , heise j. , kippen r. m. , woods , p. m. , guidorzi , c. , montanari e. , frontera f. , 2004 , aspc , 312 , 181 ioka k. , toma k. , yamazaki r. , nakamura t. 2006 , a&a , 458 , 7 jin z. p. , fan y. z. , 2007 , mnras , 378 , 1043 jones f. c. , 1968 , phys .
, 167 , 1159 katz j. i. , 1994 , apj , 432 , l27 king a. , obrien p. t. , goad m. r. , obsorne j. , olsson e. , page k. , 2005 , apj , 630 , l113 kobayashi s. , zhang b. , meszaros p. , burrows d. n. , 2007 , apj , 655 , 391 krimm h. a. , 2007 , apj , 665 , 554 kumar p. 2000 , apj , 538 , l125 , 2000 , apj , 541 , l51 kumar p. , piran t. , 2000 , apj , 532 , 286 lazzati d. , & perna r. , 2007 , mnras , 375 , l46 liang e. w. , 2006 , apj , 646 , 351 macfadyen a. i. , woosley s. e. , heger a. , 2001 , apj , 550 , 410 , 2006 , rep .
phys , 69 , 2259 mszros p. , rees m. j. , 1994 , mnras , 269 , l41 mszros p. , rees m. j. , 1999 , mnras , 306 , l39 mszros p. , rees m. j. , wijers r. a. m. j. , 1998 , apj , 499 , 301 moderski r. , sikora m. , bulik t. , 2000 , apj , 529 , 151 molinari e. , et al . , 2007 , a&a , 469 , l13 nikoshov a. i. , 1962 , sov .
jetp , 14 , 393 nousek j. a. , et al . , 2006 , apj , 642 , 389 obrien p. t. , et al . , 2006 , apj , 647 , 1213 , 2006 , mnras 369 , 2059 panaitescu a. , kumar p. , 2002 ,
apj , 571 , 779 peer a. , waxman e. , 2004 , apj , 603 , l1 peer a. , waxman e. , 2005 , apj , 633 , 1018 perna r. , armitage p.j . , zhang b. , 2006 , apj , 636 , l29 plaga r. , 1995 , nature , 374 , 430 pilla r. p. , loeb a. , 1998 , apj , 494 , l167 piran t. , 1999 , phys .
, 314 , 575 piran t. , 2004 , rev .
phys . , 76 , 1143 piran t. , fan y. z. , 2007 , phil .
a. , 365 , 1151 piro l. , et al . , 2005 , apj , 623 , 314 preece r. d. , briggs m. s. , mallozzi r. s. , pendleton g. n. , paciesas w. s. , 2000 , apjs , 126 , 19 primack j. r. , bullock , j. s. , somerville , r. s. , 2005 , aipc , 75 , 23 proga d. , zhang b. , 2006 , mnras , 370 , l61 rees m. j. 1966 , nature , 211 , 468 rees m. j. , mszros p. , 1998 ,
apj , 496 , l1 romano p. et al . , 2006 , a&a , 450 , 59 rybicki g. b. , lightman a. p. , radiative processes in astrophysics ( wiley , new york .
1979 ) sari r. , 1998 , apj , 494 , l49 sari r. , esin a. a. , 2001 , apj , 548 , 787 , 2000 , apj , 535 , l33 sari r. , narayan r. , piran t. , 1996 , apj , 473 , 204 sari r. , piran t. , 1999 , apj , 517 , l109 sari r. , piran t. , narayan r. 1998 , apj , 497 , l17 schaefer b. e. , et al . 1998 , apj , 492 , 696 schneid e. j. , et al . , 1992 , a&a , 255 , l13 sommer m. , et al .
, 1994 , apj , 422 , l63 svensson r. , 1987 , mnras , 227 , 403 takagi r. , kobayashi s. , 2005 , apj , 622 , l25 troja e. , 2007 , apj , 665 , 599 totani t , 1998 , apj , 502 , l13 wang x. y. , dai z. g. , lu , t. , 2001 , apj , 546 , l33 wang x. y. , dai z. g. , lu , t. , 2001 , apj , 556 , 1010 wang x. y. , li z. , mszros p. , 2006 ,
apj , 641 , l89 wang x. y. , mszros p. , 2006 ,
apj , 643 , l95 waston d. , et al . , 2006 , apj , 637 , l69 waxman e. , 1997 , apj , 491 , l19 wei d. m. , cheng k. s. , 1997 , mnras , 290 , 107 wei d. m. , fan y. z. , 2007 , chin . j. astron .
astrophys . , 7 , 509 wei d. m. , yan t. , fan y. z. , 2006 , apj , 636 , l69 weiler , k. w. , panagia , n. , montes , m. j. , sramekwei , r. a. 2002 , ara&a , 40 , 387 wu x. f. , dai z. g. , wang x. y. , huang y. f. , feng l. l. , lu t. , 2006 , apj , submitted ( astro - ph/0512555 ) xue r. r. , et al .
2008 , apj , to be submitted yost s. , harrison f. a. , sari r. , frail d. a. , 2003 , apj , 597 , 459 yu , y. w. , liu , x. w. , & dai , z. g. , 2007 , apj , in press ( arxiv : astro - ph/07063741 ) zhang b. , 2007 , chin . j. astron .
, 7 , 1 ( astro - ph/0701520 ) zhang b. , fan y. z. , dyks j. , kobayashi s. , mszros p. , burrows d. n. , nousek j. a. , gehrels n. 2006 , apj , 642 , 354 zhang b. , mszros p. , 2001a
, apj , 552 , l35 zhang b. , mszros p. , 2001b
, apj , 559 , 110 zhang w. q. , woosley s. e. , heger a. , 2007 , apj , in press ( astro - ph/0701083 ) zou y. c. , dai z. g. , xu , d. , 2006 , apj , 646 , 1098 | we calculate the very high energy ( sub - gev to tev ) inverse compton emission of grb afterglows .
we argue that this emission provides a powerful test of the currently accepted afterglow model .
we focus on two processes : synchrotron self - compton ( ssc ) emission within the afterglow blast wave , and external inverse compton ( eic ) emission which occurs when flare photons ( produced by an internal process ) pass through the blast wave .
we show that if our current interpretations of the swift xrt data are correct , there should be a canonical high energy afterglow emission light curve .
our predictions can be tested with high energy observatories such as glast , whipple , h.e.s.s . and magic .
under favorable conditions we expect afterglow detections in all these detectors .
gamma rays : bursts@xmath0ism : jets and outflows radiation mechanisms : nonthermal |
since the turn of the millennium , we have witnessed a dramatic improvement in the resolution and accuracy of measurements of fluctuations in the temperature of the cosmic microwave background radiation ( cmb ) .
the discovery of features in the power spectrum of the cmb temperature , the acoustic peaks , marked the start of a new , data - rich era in cosmology ( de bernardis et al .
2000 ; hanany et al .
the relative positions and heights of the acoustic peaks encode information about the values of the fundamental cosmological parameters , such as the curvature of the universe or the physical density in cold dark matter and baryons .
perhaps the most striking example of the progress achieved is the first year data from the wmap satellite ( bennett et al .
2003 ; hinshaw et al .
2003 ) . the cmb data alone ,
however , do not constrain all of the fundamental cosmological parameters to high precision .
degeneracies exist between certain combinations of parameters which lead to indistinguishable temperature fluctuation spectra ( efstathiou & bond 1999 ) .
some of these degeneracies can be broken by comparing theoretical models to a combination of the cmb data and other datasets , such as the power spectrum of galaxy clustering . at the same time as the new measurements of the cmb
were obtained , two groundbreaking surveys of galaxies in the local universe were being conducted . the two - degree field galaxy redshift survey ( 2dfgrs ;
colless et al . 2001 ; 2003 ) and the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ; york et al .
2000 ; abazajian et al .
2005 ) are substantially larger than previous redshift surveys and allow the clustering of galaxies to be measured accurately on all scales . on large scales , the connection to theoretical models is most straightforward .
percival et al .
( 2001 ) used the power spectrum of galaxy clustering measured from the 2dfgrs to constrain the ratio of the baryon to matter density , @xmath11 , and the matter density , @xmath12 .
efstathiou et al .
( 2002 ) used a compilation of pre - wmap cmb data and the percival et al .
measurement of the galaxy power spectrum to find conclusive evidence for a non - zero cosmological constant , independent of the hubble diagram of distant type 1a supernovae .
percival et al .
( 2002 ) again used pre - wmap cmb data and the early 2dfgrs power spectrum measurement to place constraints on cosmological parameters in flat models .
the wmap team also used the percival et al .
galaxy power spectrum in their estimation of cosmological parameters ( spergel et al .
other papers have also analyzed the information encoded in the 2dfgrs and sdss power spectra ( tegmark , zaldarriaga & hamilton 2001 ; pope et al .
2004 ; tegmark et al .
2004b ; seljak et al .
2005 ) . in view of the impact of this work , the recent completion by cole et al .
( 2005 ) of the power - spectrum analysis of the final 2dfgrs dataset is an important development .
the cole et al .
results are nearly twice as accurate as those obtained from the part - complete 2dfgrs in 2001 , and a key aim of the current paper is to see how this affects the outcome of joint analyses including cmb data . in view of these rapid improvements in our knowledge of the cosmological parameters ,
it is also important to take stock of precisely which parts of the model are actually being tested .
quite often , restrictive assumptions have been adopted for the background cosmology when claims are made about the constraints on a particular parameter .
it is important to establish how robust the constraints really are when the data are compared with more general cosmological models .
our goal is thus to establish firmly how well the latest cmb and large - scale structure ( lss ) data determine a broad set of cosmological parameters , paying attention to how the choice of priors for parameter values and the combination of different parameters can influence the results .
the outline of the paper is as follows . in section 2 , we describe the data used in our parameter estimation and set out the various parameter spaces studied . in section 3 , we present our main results for the parameter constraints obtained by comparing theoretical models to the cmb data and the galaxy power spectrum of the final 2dfgrs measured by cole et al .
we assess the impact of different choices for priors and parameter sets in section 4 .
we explore the justification for using models with different numbers of free parameters in section 5 . in section 6
, we examine how the parameter constraints change when the sdss galaxy power spectrum measured by tegmark et al .
( 2004b ) is used instead of the 2dfgrs power spectrum .
finally , we summarize our conclusions in section 7 .
we now set out the approach we will take to constrain the values of the basic cosmological parameters . in section [ ssec :
data ] , we list the cmb and lss datasets that we compare against the theoretical models and explain how these datasets are modelled .
the parameter sets that we will consider are defined in section [ ssec : param ] .
the methodology for searching parameter space and placing constraints on parameters is set out in section [ ssec : mechanics ] . in order to constrain the parameters in our cosmological model
, we use a compilation of recent measurements of the cmb and the power spectrum of galaxy clustering in the local universe : * the wmap first year temperature power spectrum for spherical harmonics @xmath13 ( hinshaw et al .
* observations of the temperature spectrum over the spherical harmonic range @xmath14 made up to july 2002 using the arcminute cosmology bolometer array receiver ( acbar ; kuo et al .
* the temperature spectrum for @xmath15 measured using the very small array ( vsa ; dickinson et al .
* two years of temperature correlation data with @xmath16 from the cosmic background imager ( cbi ; readhead et al .
* the wmap first year temperature - polarization power spectrum for spherical harmonics @xmath17 ( kogut et al .
* the power spectrum of galaxy clustering measured from the final 2dfgrs catalogue ( cole et al . 2005 ) .
the four measurements ( i - iv ) of the power spectrum of temperature fluctuations in the cmb extend over the spherical harmonic range @xmath18 .
some of the available datasets extend to higher multipoles .
however , we do not include these scales in our analysis , as the temperature fluctuations on such scales can be strongly affected by secondary sources .
the wmap team adopted a similar approach , augmenting the first year wmap data with other experiments which have better angular resolution ( spergel et al .
however , the vsa data were not available to the wmap team at the time that the paper by spergel et al .
was written .
theoretical temperature - temperature and temperature - polarization spectra are computed for each model using camb ( lewis , challinor & lasenby 2000 ) .
cole et al .
( 2005 ) measured the power spectrum of galaxy clustering from the final 2dfgrs catalogue .
the power spectrum measured for galaxies differs in a number of ways from the power spectrum for the mass predicted in linear perturbation theory : ( i ) nonlinear evolution of density perturbations leads to coupling between fourier modes , changing the shape of the power spectrum .
( ii ) the galaxy power spectrum is distorted by the gravitationally induced peculiar motions of galaxies when a redshift is used to infer the distance to each galaxy .
( iii ) the power spectrum of the galaxies could be a modified version of the power spectrum of the mass .
this phenomenon is known as galaxy bias .
the ratio between the galaxy and matter spectra could also change with scale .
( however , we assume a constant bias over the scales considered in this paper ) .
( iv ) the power spectrum measured by cole et al . from the 2dfgrs
is the direct transform of the data , and is thus what cmb researchers would term a pseudo - spectrum . as such
, it yields a convolution of the underlying galaxy power spectrum with the modulus squared of the fourier transform of the window function of the survey . in order to constrain cosmological parameters ,
these effects need to be modelled .
the accuracy of the modelling requires that the comparison between theory and observation should be restricted to a limited range of scales .
we use the 2dfgrs power spectrum data for @xmath19 and discard measurements with @xmath20 which could be affected by uncertainties in the mean density of galaxies within the survey .
we follow the scheme used by cole et al . who applied a correction for non - linearity and scale - dependent bias to the shape of @xmath21 of the form @xmath22 where @xmath23 and @xmath24 are the preferred values and b is a constant bias factor .
this formula is deduced by comparison with detailed numerical galaxy - formation models : these show that the value of @xmath25 is robust , but the exact value of @xmath26 depends on galaxy type and also has some uncertainty depending on how the modelling is done .
these results were used to determine a range of allowed values for @xmath26 , from which the value @xmath24 is preferred ; with this choice , robust parameter constraints are obtained if one considers maximum @xmath27 values beyond our limit of @xmath28 . for this limit , neglecting the correction entirely and simply fitting linear theory yields almost identical results to those presented here . in particular
, it has no impact on the marginal indication of a deviation from @xmath6 . in this paper
, we make the basic assumption that the primordial density fluctuations were adiabatic , gaussian and had a power law spectrum of fourier amplitudes . as pointed out by leach & liddle ( 2003a ) ,
the cmb data prior to wmap were of insufficient quality to justify the rejection of this simple hypothesis .
following the release of the wmap first year results , which do have the precision required to test this model , our assumptions remain well motivated .
komatsu et al . ( 2003 ) found that the wmap sky maps are consistent with gaussian primordial fluctuations to a much higher precision than was attainable with cobe .
peiris et al .
( 2003 ) found that models with a spectral index varying slowly with wavenumber give slightly better fits to the wmap data , particularly when combined with estimates of the power spectrum of the lyman-@xmath29 forest .
however , the evidence for a running spectral index is weak and has been disputed by other groups ( e.g. bridle et al . 2003b ; slosar , seljak & makarov 2003 ; seljak et al .
bennett et al .
( 2003 ) and spergel et al .
( 2003 ) point out that , on large scales , a few modes of the cmb temperature power spectrum measured by wmap lie below the predictions of the standard @xmath30cdm model .
one interpretation of this apparent discrepancy is that new physics may be needed ( e.g. bridle et al .
2003a ; efstathiou 2003 ) .
however , several studies have argued that the disagreement is actually less significant than was first claimed ( gaztaaga et al .
2003 ; de oliveira - costa et al .
2003 ; efstathiou 2004 ) .
> from the above starting point , the cosmological model we consider is defined by eleven parameters : @xmath31 there are eight further basic quantities whose values can be derived given the above set : @xmath32 we now go through the parameters in these lists , defining each one and explaining how the values of the derived parameters are obtained .
the are five quantities that describe the homogeneous background cosmology through various contributions to the mass - energy density .
these are , in units of the critical density : @xmath33 , which describes the curvature of the universe ; @xmath34 , the energy - density of the dark energy ; @xmath35 , the density of the dark matter ( where @xmath36 is the sum of the cold and hot dark matter components and @xmath37 is hubble s constant in units of @xmath38 ) ; @xmath39 , the baryon density ; and @xmath40 the fraction of the dark matter in the form of massive neutrinos .
the sum of neutrino masses is given by @xmath41 .
the matter density parameter is given by @xmath42 .
the value of the hubble constant is derived from @xmath43 .
the energy density of the dark energy is set by @xmath44 .
the dark energy component is assumed to have an equation of state that is independent of redshift , with the ratio of pressure to density given by @xmath45 .
there are four quantities that describe the form of the initial fluctuations ; the spectral indices , @xmath5 and @xmath46 , and the primordial amplitudes , @xmath47 and @xmath48 , of scalar and tensor fluctuations respectively .
these parameter values are quoted at the ` pivot ' scale wavenumber of @xmath49 .
we can translate the results obtained for @xmath47 into a constraint on the more familiar parameter @xmath50 , the _ rms _ linear perturbation theory variance in spheres of radius @xmath51mpc , using the matter fluctuation transfer function .
note that when we consider tensor modes , we make the slow - roll assumption that @xmath52 .
the bias factor , @xmath53 , describes the difference in amplitude between the galaxy power spectrum and that of the underlying dark matter .
the value of @xmath54 is marginalized over , using the analytic expression given in appendix f of lewis & bridle ( 2002 ) .
we assume that the reionization of the neutral intergalactic medium occurred instantaneously , with an optical depth given by @xmath55 ; the redshift of reionization , @xmath56 , depends upon a combination of parameters ( see table 1 of tegmark et al .
the age of the universe is @xmath57 .
finally , @xmath58 gives the ratio of the sound horizon scale at the epoch of decoupling to the angular diameter distance to the corresponding redshift and replaces the hubble constant as a base parameter ( kosowsky , milosavljevic & jimenez 2002 ) .
we have chosen to use this parameter , rather than , for example , the energy density in dark energy , since it has a posterior distribution that is close to gaussian .
this reduces degeneracies between parameters and results in a faster convergence of our search of parameter space ( see section [ ssec : mechanics ] ) , compared with studies in which parameters such as @xmath34 , which does not have a gaussian posterior distribution , are allowed to vary .
this approach is a standard practice even though , usually , the final results are expressed in terms of more familiar parameters such as @xmath34 or @xmath37 .
however , care must be taken when comparing our results with those from studies which have assumed flat priors on different parameters in their bayesian analysis .
such choices may affect the final results in a way that is difficult to quantify .
we do not attempt to vary all eleven parameters of the model at once .
such an approach would lead to a mixture of poor estimates of the values of individual parameters and constraints on various combinations of parameters .
as we are primarily interested in deriving the best possible constraints on individual parameters , we instead consider subsets of parameter space , varying five , six or seven parameters at a time . of the remaining parameters ,
some are held at fixed values and the others are referred to as derived parameters . the values of the derived parameters follow from the values of other parameters , once the assumptions made in each parameter space have been taken into account
. we will now set out each of our parameter spaces in turn , stating which parameters are varied and which are held fixed .
in all cases , the bias parameter , @xmath54 , is marginalized over , so we do not include this in the list of parameters whose values are constrained . in the simplest case , we vary five parameters which we refer to as the ` basic - five ' ( b5 ) parameter set .
the following parameters are allowed to float : @xmath59 the values of the fixed parameters in the basic - five model are : @xmath60 the results of this model are discussed in section 3.2 .
the basic - five set is expanded to allow the value of the scalar spectral index to float , giving the basic - six ( b6 ) model ( see section 3.3 ) : @xmath61 the fixed parameters in the basic - six model are : @xmath62 . the parameter space probed in our analysis .
we assume a flat prior in each case .
we do not vary the values of all parameters at the same time ; the parameter spaces that we consider are set out in section [ ssec : param ] .
[ cols="^,^",options="header " , ] in this section , we replace the 2dfgrs @xmath21 measured by cole et al .
( 2005 ) with the power spectrum of sdss galaxies estimated by tegmark et al .
( 2004a ) and examine the impact that this change has upon the values of the recovered cosmological parameters .
there are a number of differences between the two measurements of the galaxy power spectrum .
firstly , the sdss is a red - selected survey , while the 2dfgrs is blue - selected .
secondly , tegmark et al .
used a sophisticated eigenmode deconvolution apparatus to attempt to remove the effects of the survey window and redshift - space distortions ; in contrast , cole et al .
used a simpler fourier approach that compares to window - convolved models and quantifies redshift - space effects directly by comparison with realistic simulations .
tegmark et al .
( 2004b ) used the wmap first year data and the sdss galaxy power spectrum to constrain cosmological parameters .
these authors modelled the galaxy power spectrum with a non - linear model for the matter fluctuations multiplied by a scale independent bias factor .
the power spectrum data were used on scales larger than @xmath63 .
it is not clear that a constant bias is a good approximation on scales for which the density fluctuations have become non - linear .
we adopt a simpler approach and assume that the galaxy power spectrum can be related to the linear perturbation theory power spectrum of the mass through a constant shift in amplitude . as discussed earlier , the simulations used by cole et al .
indicate that redshift - space effects and other nonlinearities are unimportant for the 2dfgrs to our imposed limit of @xmath64 .
we repeat the study of parameter space previously carried out using the cmb data plus the 2dfgrs @xmath21 and present our results using the sdss @xmath21 instead in table 5 . for the most part ,
the results obtained with the sdss @xmath21 are compatible with those found using the 2dfgrs @xmath21 .
there are , however , some cases in which the results are quite different .
this point is illustrated using the results of the basic - six model in fig .
[ fig : b6_sdss ] . in this plot
, we compare the parameter constraints obtained using cmb data alone ( dashed line ) with the results for cmb data plus the 2dfgrs @xmath21 ( solid line ) and for cmb data plus the sdss @xmath21 ( dot - dashed line ) . for
three out of the six parameters presented , @xmath65 , @xmath55 and @xmath5 , there is impressive agreement between the sets of results ; the peaks in the likelihood distributions coincide in the cmb only and cmb plus @xmath21 cases , and the results are consistent to better than the 68% confidence intervals .
the agreement between the sets of results for the scalar spectral index in particular is excellent .
however , for the other three parameters plotted , @xmath66 , @xmath37 and @xmath50 , the agreement is less impressive ; the differences in the recovered values of @xmath37 and @xmath50 are driven by the change in @xmath66 .
the peak in the likelihood distributions for the cmb only and cmb plus 2dfgrs @xmath21 cases are in good agreement , as remarked upon in section 3 .
there is a clear discrepancy , however , with the preferred parameter values when using cmb data plus the sdss @xmath21 .
this is most marked for the physical density of dark matter , @xmath66 .
cole et al .
( 2005 ) noted that the sdss @xmath21 has a slightly bluer slope than that of the 2dfgrs , favouring higher values of @xmath67 .
there are two other notable discrepancies between the results obtained with the sdss and 2dfgrs @xmath21 in our basic - six plus one additional free parameter models . when the assumption of a flat universe is relaxed , we find that the constraints on @xmath33 are weaker in the sdss case , @xmath68 ; the allowed range is nearly twice as broad as in the case of the 2dfgrs @xmath21 .
this is because on the scales used in our analysis , the sdss power spectrum does a poorer job of constraining @xmath67 compared with the 2dfgrs @xmath21 , and hence is not as effective at breaking the geometrical degeneracy . in the basic - six plus dark energy equation of state parameter set ,
we find @xmath69 using the sdss @xmath21 , much higher than we found in the case of the 2dfgrs @xmath21 and inconsistent with a cosmological constant . if we also include the snia data from riess et al .
( 2004 ) , then we obtain a value for the equation of state that is consistent with our previous results : @xmath70 . again
, the discrepancy in the result for the equation of state can be traced back to the preferred values of @xmath66 .
we note that mactavish et al .
( 2005 ) find similar results to ours for the equation of state of the dark energy using the sdss galaxy power spectrum .
8 shows the degeneracy in the @xmath71 plane for cmb data alone . adding information from the galaxy power spectrum breaks this degeneracy . if the galaxy @xmath21 data prefer a high value of @xmath67 , as is the case for the sdss data , then a high value of @xmath45 will result
. it may be that these differences between 2dfgrs and sdss amount to no more than an unlucky amount of cosmic variance , but clearly it would be more reassuring if the results showed greater consistency
. it will therefore be important to see each dataset subjected to analysis by a variety of algorithms and codes , as happened following the percival et al .
( 2001 ) 2dfgrs power - spectrum analysis ( tegmark , zaldarriaga & hamilton 2001 ) .
this older comparison found consistent results , but the comparison will now be more demanding , given the smaller errors arising from current datasets .
we have placed new constraints on the values of the basic cosmological parameters , using an up - to - date compilation of cmb data and the galaxy power spectrum measured from the final 2dfgrs by cole et al .
we have carried out a comprehensive exploration of parameter space , considering five , six and seven parameter models , making different assumptions about the priors used for certain parameters .
our main results can be summarized as follows : * a model in which five parameters are allowed to vary does a remarkably good job of describing the currently available cmb and lss data .
* there is an impressive level of agreement between the results obtained for cmb data alone and for cmb data plus the 2dfgrs power spectrum data .
if the 2dfgrs @xmath21 is replaced by the sdss @xmath21 , there is some tension between the parameter values preferred by the cmb and sdss datasets .
* for some parameters , for example the physical density of dark matter , hubble s constant and the amplitude of density fluctuations , there is a significant tightening of the allowed range of parameter space when the 2dfgrs @xmath21 is included in the analysis .
in particular , we infer a density significantly below @xmath72 . *
we find some evidence for a departure from a scale invariant primordial spectrum of scalar fluctuations .
our results for the scalar perturbation spectral index are only marginally consistent with the scale invariant value @xmath6 ; this spectrum is formally excluded at the @xmath7 confidence level . however , this conclusion is weakened if we drop the assumption that the universe is flat or allow neutrinos to have a mass . *
we place new limits on the mass fraction of massive neutrinos : @xmath9 and @xmath10 ev at the 95% level .
* several parameters are sensitive to the choice of prior for the optical depth to the last scattering surface , @xmath55 .
* we find that a wide range of closed universes are consistent with the cmb data .
this range is restricted if we also consider the 2dfgrs @xmath21 data .
if we further assume a prior of @xmath73 , then the preferred spatial curvature is close to flat .
* we confirm the evidence previously reported by efstathiou et al .
( 2002 ) for a non - zero dark energy contribution to the energy - density of the universe . *
we find a redshift - independent equation of state for the dark energy of @xmath74 , consistent with a cosmological constant . * inflationary models with a scalar field potential with a @xmath75 term
are ruled out by our analysis .
the final message of this analysis is that meaningful comparison of the parameter constraints from different studies requires a clear listing of the free parameters and their prior distributions .
although current datasets measure many parameter combinations extremely well , important degeneracies remain .
as we have discussed , there is a good chance that current measurements may be poised on the brink of rejecting the simplest 5-parameter model in favour of something more complicated .
however , even if this step is taken , it will require much work before any such deviation from the standard model could have a unique interpretation .
we would like to thank sarah bridle for her kind and invaluable help and useful discussions and the referee , andrew jaffe , for a constructive report .
we also aknowledge andrew liddle for discussions about bayesian evidence .
ags acknowledges the hospitality of the department of physics at the university of durham where part of this work was carried out ; he would also like to thank the scientists throughout the world who submit their articles to the arxiv preprint data base , thereby making them freely available to scientists in developing countries .
ags acknowledges a fellowship from conicet ; cmb is funded by a royal society university research fellowship ; jap holds a pparc senior research fellowship ; wjp acknowledges receipt of a pparc fellowship ; ndp is funded by fondecyt project number 3040038 ; pn acknowledges receipt of a eth zwicky fellowship .
this work was supported by the european commission s alfa - ii programme through its funding of the latin - american european network for astrophysics and cosmology , lenac , and by pparc .
abazajian k. et al . , 2005 ,
aj , 129 , 1755 | we derive constraints on cosmological parameters using the power spectrum of galaxy clustering measured from the final two - degree field galaxy redshift survey ( 2dfgrs ) and a compilation of measurements of the temperature power spectrum and temperature - polarization cross - correlation of the cosmic microwave background radiation .
we analyse a range of parameter sets and priors , allowing for massive neutrinos , curvature , tensors and general dark energy models . in all cases ,
the combination of datasets tightens the constraints , with the most dramatic improvements found for the density of dark matter and the energy - density of dark energy .
if we assume a flat universe , we find a matter density parameter of @xmath0 , a baryon density parameter of @xmath1 , a hubble constant of @xmath2 , a linear theory matter fluctuation amplitude of @xmath3 and a scalar spectral index of @xmath4 ( all errors show the 68% interval ) .
our estimate of @xmath5 is only marginally consistent with the scale invariant value @xmath6 ; this spectrum is formally excluded at the @xmath7 confidence level .
however , the detection of a tilt in the spectrum is sensitive to the choice of parameter space . if we allow the equation of state of the dark energy to float , we find @xmath8 , consistent with a cosmological constant .
we also place new limits on the mass fraction of massive neutrinos : @xmath9 at the 95% level , corresponding to @xmath10 ev .
large scale structure of the universe - cosmic microwave background , cosmological parameters |
graphene is a subject of numerous investigations motivated by its unique electronic and lattice properties , interesting both conceptually and for applications ( for reviews , see refs . ) .
single layer graphene ( slg ) is the two - dimensional crystalline form of carbon with a linear electronic spectrum and chiral ( a - b sublattice ) symmetry , whose extraordinary electron mobility and other unique features hold great promise for nanoscale electronics and photonics .
bilayer and trilayer graphenes , which are made out of two and three graphene planes , have also been produced by the mechanical friction and motivated a lot of researches on their transport properties natphys , falko2006,gcnt2006,ohta2006,mccann2006,koshino2006,santos2007 , katsnelson_bilayer , castro2007,castro2008,nilsson2007,morozov2008,nilsson2008 , nilsson2006,nilsson2006b , zhuw2009,dassarma2010,xiaos2010,lv2010,zhangf2010 , zhu2010,pereira2009,ribeiro2008,mallet2007,bostwick2007,gorbachev2007,linym2008,nakamura2008,feldman2009,trushin2010 .
the charge - carrying quasiparticles in bilayer graphene ( blg ) obey parabolic dispersion with non - zero mass , but retain a chiral nature similar to that in slg ( with the berry phase @xmath1 instead of @xmath2 ) natphys , falko2006 .
furthermore , an electronic bandgap can be introduced in a dual gate blg mccann2006,castro2007,oostinga2008,zhangyb2009,castro2010,taychatanapat2010 , and it makes blg very appealing from the point of view of applications .
the trilayer graphene ( tlg ) is shown to have different electronic properties which is strongly dependent on the interlayer stacking sequence craciun2009,koshino2009 .
nevertheless , graphene layers in real experiments always have different kinds of disorder , such as ripples , adatoms , admolecules , etc .
one of the most important problems in the potential applications of graphene in electronics , is understanding the effect of these imperfections on the electronic structure and transport properties .
the scattering theory for dirac electrons in slg is discussed in refs . .
long - range scattering centers are of special importance for transport properties of slg , such as charge impurities r6,nomura2006,ando2006,hwang2007,adama2009 , ripples created long - range elastic deformations @xcite , and resonant scattering centers peres2006,katsnelson2007,katsnelson2008,ostrovsky2006,stauber2007,titov2010,robinson2008,wehling2010,yuan2010,ni2010 .
recently , the impact of charged impurity scattering on electronic transport in blg have been investigated theoretically katsnelson_bilayer , dassarma2010,lv2010 and experimentally @xcite .
the linear density - dependent conductivity at high density and the minimum conductivity behavior around the charge neutrality point are expected katsnelson_bilayer , dassarma2010,lv2010 and confirmed @xcite , but the experimental results also suggest that charged impurity scattering alone is not sufficient to explain the observed transport properties of pristine blg on sio@xmath3 before potassium doping @xcite
. one possible explanation of the experimental results might be the opening of a gap at the dirac point in biased blg @xcite .
on the other hand , some recent experimental @xcite and theoretical robinson2008,wehling2010,yuan2010 evidences appeared that the resonant scattering due to carbon - carbon bonds between organic admolecules and graphene ( or by hydrogen impurities which are almost equivalent to c - c bonds in a sense of electron scattering @xcite ) is the main restricting factor for electron mobility in slg on a substrate .
these results suggest that the resonant impurity could also be the dominant factor of the transport properties of blg and tlg .
in the present paper , we study the effect of different types of impurities on the transport properties of graphene layers by direct numerical simulations in a framework of the single - electron tight - binding model .
we consider four different types of defects : resonant ( hydrogen ) impurities , vacancies , gaussian on - site potentials and gaussian nearest carbon - carbon hoppings .
the resonant impurities / vacancies and the centers of the gaussian potentials / couplings are randomly introduced in the graphene layers .
our numerical calculations are based on the time - evolution method @xcite , i.e. , the time - evolution of the wave functions according to the schrdinger equation with additional averaging over a random superposition of basis states .
the main idea is that by performing fourier transform of various correlation functions , such as the wave function - wave function and current - current correlation functions ( kubo formula ) , one can calculate the electronic structure and transport properties such as the density of states ( dos ) , quasieigenstates , ac ( optical ) and dc conductivities .
the details of the numerical method are presented in ref . .
the advantages of the time - evolution method is that it allows us to carry out calculations for very large systems , up to hundreds of millions of sites , with a computational effort that increases only linearly with the system size .
the paper is organized as follows .
section ii gives a description of the tight - binding hamiltonian of multilayer graphene . in section iii ,
iv , v and vi , we focus on four different types of disorders respectively : resonant impurities , vacancies , potential impurities , and nearest carbon - carbon hopping impurities . finally a brief discussion is given in section vii .
in general , the tight - binding hamiltonian of multilayer graphene is given by @xmath4where @xmath5 is the hamiltonian of slg for @xmath6th layer and @xmath7 describes the hopping between layers @xmath6 and @xmath8 .
the single - layer hamiltonian @xmath5 is given by@xmath9where @xmath10 derives from the nearest neighbor hopping between the carbon atoms:@xmath11@xmath12 denotes the on - site potential of the carbon atoms:@xmath13and @xmath14 describes the resonant impurities ( adatoms or admolecules):@xmath15 the interlayer hamiltonian @xmath16 of bilayer graphene with ab bernal stacking is given by@xmath17 -\gamma _ { 3}\sum_{j , j^{\prime } } \left [ b_{l , j}^{+}a_{l+1,j^{\prime } } + h.c.% \right ] , \]]where @xmath18 ( @xmath19 ) annihilates an electron on sublattice a ( b ) , in plane @xmath20 , at site @xmath21 ( see the atomic structure in fig .
multilayer3d ) .
thus , the second layer in blg is rotated with respect to the first one by @xmath22 . for the third layer
there are two options : either the third carbon layer will be rotated with respect to the second layer by @xmath23 ( than it will be exactly under the first layer ) or by @xmath22 . in the first case we have aba - stacked trilayer graphene , and in the second we have abc - stacked ( rhombohedral ) graphene .
the atomic structures of the aba- and abc - stacked trilayer graphene are shown in fig .
[ multilayer3d ] .
these stacked sequences can be extended to multilayers , i.e. , the direct extension of aba- and abc - stacked sequences from trilayer to quartic - layer are abab and abcd .
the spin degree of freedom contributes only through a degeneracy factor and , for simplicity , is omitted in eq .
( hamiltonian ) .
the density of states is obtained by fourier transformation of the wave function at time zero and time @xmath24 : @xmath25where @xmath26 is an initial random superposition state of all the basis states and @xmath27 is calculated numerically according to the time - dependent schrdinger equation ( we use units with @xmath28 ) .
a detailed description of this method can be found in refs . .
the charge density is obtained by the intergral of the density of states , i.e. , @xmath29 the static ( dc ) conductivity is calculated by using the kubo formula @xmath30 \right\ } .
\label{conduc2}\]]where @xmath31 is the current operator and @xmath32 is the sample area .
the main idea of the calculation is to perform the time evolution of @xmath33 .
then , we can extract not only the dos but also the _ quasieigenstates _
@xcite , which are superpositions of degenerated energy - eigenstates .
the conductivity at zero temperature can be represented as @xmath35 , \label{conducappr}\]]where @xmath36 is defined as@xmath37 the accuracy of the numerical results is mainly determined by three factors : the time interval of the propagation , the total number of time steps , and the size of the sample . in the numerical calculations , the integrals in eq .
( [ dosf ] ) and ( [ conducappr ] ) are calculated using the fast fourier transform ( fft ) . according to the nyquist sampling theorem , employing a sampling interval @xmath38 , where @xmath39 are the eigenenergies , is sufficient to cover the full range of eigenvalues . in practice
, we do not know @xmath40 exactly but it is easy to compute an upperbound ( for instance the 1-norm of @xmath41 ) such that @xmath42 can be considered as fixed . in the present paper , the time evolution
is calculated by the chebyshev polynomial method , which has the same accuracy as the machine s precision independent of the value of time interval @xmath42 .
alternatively , one could use suzuki s product formula decomposition of the exponential operators for the tight - binding hamiltonian @xcite , introducing another time step that has to be ( much ) smaller than @xmath42 to obtain accurate results @xcite . in both cases ,
the accuracy of the energy eigenvalues is determined by the total number of the propagation time steps @xmath43 that is the number of the data items used in the fft .
eigenvalues that differ less than @xmath44 can not be identified properly .
however , since @xmath45 is proportional to @xmath46 we only have to extend the length of the calculation by a factor of two to increase the accuracy by the same factor .
the third factor which determines the accuracy of our numerical results is the size of the sample .
a sample with more sites in the real space will have more random coefficients in the initial state @xmath47 , providing a better statistical representation of the superposition of all energy eigenstates .
this , however , is not a real issue in practice as it has be shown that the statistical fluctuations vanish with the inverse of the dimension of the hilbert space @xcite , which for our problem , is proportional to the number of sites in the sample .
a comparison of the dos calculated from different samples size was shown in ref . , which clearly shows that larger sample size leads to better accuracy , and the result calculated from a slg with @xmath48 lattice sites matches very well with the analytical expression @xcite .
more details on the numerical method itself can be found in ref . .
the values of conductivity presented in this paper are normalized per layer and are expressed in units @xmath49 .
obviously , computer memory and cpu time evidently limit the size of the graphene system that can be simulated . the required cpu time is mainly determined by the number of operations to be performed on the state of the system , but this imposes no hard limit
. however , the memory of the computer does . in the tight - binding approximation , a state @xmath50 of a sample consisting by @xmath51 atoms
is represented by a complex - valued vector of length @xmath52 . for numerical accuracy ( and
in view of the large number of arithmetic operators performed ) , it is advisable to use @xmath53 digit floating - point arithmetic ( corresponding to @xmath54 bytes per real number ) . thus , to represent the state @xmath55 we need at least @xmath56 bytes .
for example , for @xmath57 we need @xmath58 mb of memory to store a single arbitrary state @xmath55 .
this amount of memory is not a problem for the calculation of dos on a modest desktop pc or notebook , but it limits the calculation of the dc conductivity on such machines . to calculate one value of @xmath59 one
needs storage of the corresponding quasieigenstate @xmath36 , and with typically @xmath60 of such quasieigenstates in our simulations , a sample of @xmath61 sites requires at least @xmath62 gb memory for the storage , which is still reasonable for present - day computer equipment . ,
@xmath63 , and @xmath64 ( @xmath65 is fixed as @xmath66 ) .
inner panel : normalized dos and energy in units of @xmath67 and @xmath68 .
each layer in blg contains @xmath48 carbon atoms.,width=283 ]
resonant impurities are introduced in reality by the formation of a chemical band between a carbon atom from graphene sheet and a carbon atom from an adsorbed organic molecule ( ch@xmath69 , c@xmath3h@xmath70 , ch@xmath3oh ) , as well as h atoms @xcite ; vacancies are another option but in natural graphene their concentration seems to be small .
the adsorbates are described by the hamiltonian @xmath14 in eq .
( [ hamiltonian ] ) . from _ ab initio _
density functional theory ( dft ) calculations @xcite , it follows that the band parameters for various organic groups ( and for hydrogen atoms ) are almost the same : @xmath71 and @xmath72 .
the hybridization strength @xmath73 being a factor @xmath74 larger than @xmath24 is in accordance with the hybridization for hydrogen adatoms from ref . , but the on - site energies @xmath75 are significantly smaller than the value @xmath75
@xmath76 used for h in ref . which makes our results for the transport properties in slg qualitatively different @xcite .
the adoption of these band parameters successfully explained the resonant scattering in slg @xcite and we continue to use them in the modeling of blg and tlg . in refs .
, we used the algorithm presented in the previous section to calculate the dc conductivity of slg with resonant impurities or vacancies .
we found that there is plateau of the order of the minimum conductivity @xcite @xmath77 in the vicinity of the neutrality point , in agreement with theoretical expectations @xcite . beyond the plateau ,
the conductivity is inversely proportional to the concentration of the impurities , and approximately proportional to the carrier concentration @xmath78 .
this is consistent with the approach based on the boltzmann equation , which in the limit of resonant impurities with @xmath79 , yields for the conductivity @xcite @xmath80where @xmath81 is the number of charge carriers per carbon atom , and @xmath82 is of order of the bandwidth .
note that for the case of the resonance shifted with respect to the neutrality point the consideration of ref .
leads to the dependence @xmath83where @xmath84 corresponds to electron and hole doping , respectively , and @xmath21 is the effective impurity radius .
the boltzmann approach does not work near the neutrality point where quantum corrections are dominant ostrovsky2006 , katsnelson2006 , auslender2007 . in the range of concentrations , where the boltzmann approach is applicable , our numerical results of the conductivity of slg as a function of energy fits very well to the dependence given by eq .
( [ fitting ] ) @xcite .
electron scattering in blg has been proven to differ essentially from slg in ref .
: for a scattering potential with radius much smaller than the de broglie wavelength of electrons , the phase shift of @xmath85-wave scattering @xmath86 tends to a constant as @xmath87 .
therefore , within the limit of applicability of the boltzmann equation , the conductivity of a bilayer should be just linear in @xmath78 , instead of sublinear dependence ( [ fitting ] ) for slg .
the difference is that in slg , due to vanishing dos at the dirac point , the scattering disappears at small wave vectors as @xmath88 ( with @xmath89 on the order of 10 for typical amounts of doping ) for resonant and as @xmath90 for the nonresonant impurities .
in contrast , in blg there are no restrictions on the strength of the scattering and even the unitary limit ( @xmath91 ) can be reached at @xmath92 . however , these conclusions are based on the use of an approximate parabolic spectrum for the bilayer which is valid for the energy interval @xmath93 in the opposite case @xmath94the effects of the interlayer hopping are negligible and one should expect a behavior of the conductivity similar to that of slg .
our first set of numerical calculations of blg are performed for similar concentrations of resonant impurities ( @xmath95 $ ] ) as those used for slg in refs . . the interlayer hopping parameters are taken as @xcite @xmath96 . as shown in fig .
[ ximp ] , finite concentrations of the resonant impurities lead to the formation of a low energy impurity band ( see increased dos at low energies in fig .
[ ximp ] ) .
the impurity band can host two electrons per impurity , and for impurity concentrations in the range of @xmath97 $ ] , this leads to a plateau - shaped minimum of width @xmath98 in the conductivity vs. @xmath78 curves around the neutrality point .
as one can see from the dos in fig .
[ ximp ] , even for @xmath99 , the width of the impurity band around the neutrality point is comparable to the limits of applicability of the parabolic approximation for the spectrum ( ineqq1 ) , therefore for the concentrations of the impurities presented in fig .
[ ximp ] one can not use the theory @xcite . for small electron concentrations we are beyond the limit of the boltzmann theory at all , and for the larger electron concentration we are , rather , in the regime ( [ ineqq2 ] ) so one could expect a sublinear behavior similar to that in slg . indeed , the conductivity of blg as a function of charge density @xmath78 follows almost exactly the same dependence as for the slg ( see the direct comparisons of conductivities in fig .
[ ximp ] ) .
that is , the density - dependence of conductivity in blg is not linear but sublinear ( [ fitting ] ) as in slg .
actually , as shown in fig .
[ ximpslbltri ] , the sublinear dependence is quite general for multilayer graphene , i.e. , it is also true for trilayer and quartic - layer graphene with the same concentration of resonant impurities , independent on the stacking sequence , which is , of course , not surprising assuming that the condition ( [ ineqq2 ] ) holds . here for the trilayer ( quartic - layer ) we consider two types of stacking sequence : aba ( abab ) and abc ( abcd ) .
this general property of the conductivity can be easily understood by comparison of their dos in fig .
the dos of single - layer , bilayer , trilayer and quartic - layer graphene are exactly the same except near the edge of the spectrum , indicating the similar band structure , independent on the number of layers and stacking sequence .
in fact , since the couplings between the carbon atoms and organic admolecules are twenty times larger than the interlayer coupling ( @xmath100 ) in our model , the unique bonds generated by the relevant weaker interlayer interactions are more easily to be destroyed by the impurity bonds generated by the much stronger adsorbed resonant impurities . in order to check the symmetry of the presence of the impurities , we limit the adsorption of organic admolecules to one layer of blg ( @xmath101 , case ii ) .
to compare the results of the adsorption on both sides ( @xmath102 , case i ) , we fix the total number of resonant impurities and therefore the concentration on one layer ( case ii ) is doubled ( @xmath103 ) .
we find ( see last panel in fig .
[ ximp ] ) that for the low concentration ( @xmath104 ) , the electron - density dependence of the conductivity in blg follows the same law in both cases ; at high concentration ( @xmath105 ) , the conductivity in case ii is larger than in case i. this is because in case ii the difference of mobility of electron in the two layers , with or without impurities , is larger than in the case of large concentrations of adsorbed admolecules .
next we consider the region of parameters which can be described by the boltzmann equation plus parabolic spectrum @xcite . in blg ,
the approximations of massive valence and conduction bands with zero gap : @xmath106 , where the effective mass is given by @xmath107 , are only true in the low - energy dispersion close to the neutrality point .
there are two ways to place the impurity bands within the region of low - energy dispersion ( ineqq1 ) : decreasing the concentration @xmath102 of impurities or expanding the quadratic band by increasing @xmath108 .
smaller concentration of impurities leads to less random states for the averaging in the kubo formula of eq .
( [ conducappr ] ) , which means that it is numerically more expensive because we need to extend the sample size to keep the same accuracy .
therefore increasing @xmath108 is computationally more convenient from the point of view of cpu time and physical memory ; one can assume that physical results should be the same : it is only the ratio @xmath109 which is important . in fig .
[ dosblgemma1 ] , we compare numerical results of dos of blg with different band parameter @xmath108 : @xmath110 and @xmath111 ( @xmath112 is fixed as @xmath66 ) .
one can see that the width of the parabolic band with the energy - independent local density of states proportional to @xmath108 , and the normalized energy ( in units of @xmath108 ) dependencies of dos ( in the units of @xmath113 ) within the parabolic band are consistent for different @xmath108 ( see the inner panel of fig .
[ dosblgemma1 ] ) .
therefore we can simply use @xmath108 with the value of @xmath111 instead of @xmath66 to extend the width of the parabolic band approximation without changing the structure of the spectrum .
the numerical results form a system with @xmath114 times larger of @xmath108 , are qualitatively comparable to those for a system of @xmath115 times smaller concentration @xmath102 of impurities . the numerical results for the dos and conductivities of blg and tlg in the presence of resonant impurity with larger interlayer interactions ( @xmath116 ) are shown in fig .
[ ximpslbltri ] .
we see that for an impurity concentration of @xmath117 , the impurity band is located around the neutral point and far from the edge of the quadratic band ( @xmath118 ) . in the region of the impurity band
( @xmath119 ) , there is a plateau in the order of @xmath120 ( per layer ) in blg , as well as in tlg .
this values is slightly larger than the minimum conductivity @xmath77 of slg .
it is worthwhile to note that an explanation of the origin of plateau around the neutrality point is beyond the applicability of boltzmann equation , just as in the case of slg wehling2010,yuan2010 . analyzing experimental data of the plateau width ( similar to the analysis for n@xmath3o@xmath121 acceptor states in ref . )
can therefore yield an independent estimate of the impurity concentration , both in single - layer and multilayer graphene . within the parabolic band but beyond the impurity band , the conductivities in blg and aba - stacked tlg exhibit
very well the linear dependence on the charge density @xmath78 .
the abc - stacked tlg is different from the others because of its unique band structures with a cubic touching of the bands @xcite ( see the difference of dos in fig .
[ ximpslbltri ] ) .
finally we check the role of @xmath112 in the conductivity of blg .
theoretically , the influence of @xmath112 to the band structure is negligible , and so it is for the conductivity .
this is confirmed by our numerical results in fig .
[ ximpgemma1 ] . for the fixed concentration of impurities @xmath117 with @xmath122 , the values of the conductivity corresponding to the same electron concentration @xmath78 are quite close for @xmath123 , @xmath66 , and @xmath111 .
a vacancy in a graphene sheet can be regarded as an atom ( lattice point ) with an on - site energy @xmath124 or with its hopping parameters to other sites being zero . in the numerical simulation ,
the simplest way to implement a vacancy is to remove the atom at the vacancy site .
introducing vacancies in slg will create a zero energy modes ( midgap state ) peres2006,pereira2006,pereira2008,wehling2010,yuan2010 . the exact analytical wave function associated with the zero mode induced by a single vacancy in slg
was obtained in ref .
, showing a quasilocalized character with the amplitude of the wave function decaying as inverse distance to the vacancy .
slg with a finite concentration of vacancies was studied numerically in refs . .
it was shown that the number of the midgap states increases with the concentration of the vacancies peres2006,pereira2008,wehling2010,yuan2010 , and _ quasieigenstates _ are also quasilocalized around the vacancies @xcite . the inclusion of vacancies brings an increase of spectral weight to the surrounding of the dirac point ( @xmath125 and smears the van hove singularities peres2006,pereira2008,wehling2010,yuan2010 .
the effect of the vacancies on the transport properties of slg is quite similar to that of the adsorbed organic molecules .
the main difference is the position of the impurity band in the spectrum : its center is located at the neutrality point in the presence of vacancies , whereas it is biased in the presence of realistic resonant impurities because of the nonzero on - site potential on the organic carbon ( or hydrogen ) atom .
the vacancy band contributes to the conductivity and leads to a plateau of minimum conductivity in the midgap region .
the width of the plateau is @xmath126 ( @xmath127 is the concentration of the vacancies ) in the conductivity vs. @xmath78 curves around the neutrality point , showing the same dependence ( @xmath128 ) as the case of resonant impurities @xcite
. for the range of concentrations where the boltzmann approach is applicable , the conductivity of slg as a function of energy fits very well to the dependence given by eq .
( fitting ) , with @xmath129 for the vacancies and @xmath130 for the resonant impurities @xcite .
previous studies of the vacancies in blg focused mainly on the properties of the local density of states ( ldos ) around a single or a pair of vacancies , and it was shown that the ldos in the neighboring lattice sites of the impurity site is normally enhanced , depending on the lattice site ( a or b sublattices ) of the vacancy @xcite .
recently , a new type of zeromodel state in blg is found in ref .
, in the absence of a gap it is quasilocalized in one of the layers and delocalized in the other , and in the presence of a gap it becomes fully localized inside the gap .
these observations are different from slg , where the impurity state is insensitive to the position of vacancies .
the differences in the spectrum of ldos around the vacancies in slg and blg lead to different electron - density ( fermi energy ) dependence of the conductivity .
as the vacancies and resonant impurities have similar effects on the electronic structure and transport properties in slg @xcite , it suggests that their contributions to the bilayer and trilayer graphene should also be comparable .
we consider here the results for the vacancies in the range that the boltzmann approach is applicable . in fig .
[ dcvacancy ] , we show the numerical results of the dos and conductivities of slg , blg and tlg with fixed concentration of vacancies ( @xmath131 )
. the parameters of the interlayer coupling are @xmath122 and @xmath132 .
these results are directly comparable with the results of the same concentration of resonant impurities represented in fig .
ximpslbltri , and demonstrate similar density - dependence of the conductivities , just as we expected . for conciseness , we do not discuss these vacancies as their effect on the transport properties of graphene are quite similar to those of the resonant impurities .
the impurities in the hamiltonian of eq .
( [ hamiltonian ] ) are represented by random on - site potentials .
short - rang and long - range gaussian potentials are given by @xmath133where @xmath134 is the number of the gaussian centers , which are chosen randomly distributed on the carbon atoms , @xmath135 is uniformly random in the range @xmath136 $ ] and @xmath137 is interpreted as the effective potential radius .
the typical values of @xmath137 used in our model are @xmath138 and @xmath139 for short- and long - range gaussian potential , respectively . here
@xmath140 is the carbon - carbon distance in the monolayer graphene .
the value of @xmath134 is characterized by the value @xmath141 , where @xmath142 is the total number of carbon atoms of the sample . a typic contour plot of the on - site potentials in the central part of a graphene layer with short- or long - range gaussian potential is shown in fig .
[ contourpotential ] .
the sum in eq .
( [ vgaussian ] ) is limited to the sites in the same layer , i.e. , we do not consider the overlapping of the gaussian distribution in different layers .
numerical results of the density of states and dc conductivities of blg ( @xmath143 ) with short- ( @xmath144 @xmath138 ) and long - range ( @xmath145 @xmath146 ) gaussian potentials are shown in fig .
similar to the case of resonant impurities , the singularities in the spectrum are also suppressed in the presence of random potentials , and the conductivity as a function of charge density follows a sublinear dependence .
the difference is that there is no impurity band around the neutrality point ( see the dos in fig .
[ gaussian ] ) .
this leads to totally different transport properties : no plateau around the dirac point in the conductivity vs. @xmath78 curves .
similar to the case of resonant impurities , the regime of parabolic band in blg expands by increasing @xmath108 from @xmath66 to @xmath111 , the results being shown in fig .
[ gaussian_gemma1 ] .
now the difference of transport properties in blg with short- and long - range gaussian potentials are more significant within the parabolic band : the density - dependence of conductivity is sublinear in the case of short - range , but linear in the case of long - range potentials .
actually , these sublinear and linear dependencies are also observed in tlg , independent on the stacking sequence ( see fig .
gaussian_gemma1 ) .
the same value of the minimum conductivity ( @xmath0 ) at the charge neutrality point is observed for both blg and tlg with @xmath147 .
as we discussed in the case of resonant impurities , the adoption of larger @xmath108 is equivalent to the use of smaller disorder , and therefore our results indicate that the minimum conductivity in order of @xmath0 is common in blg and tlg with small concentration of random gaussian potentials
. these numerical results are consistent with the analytical result for blg in ref . .
the origin of disorder in the nearest neighbor coupling could be substitutional impurities like n or b instead of c , or distortions of graphene sheet . to be specific ,
we introduce the disorder in the hopping by a gaussian distribution in a similar way as random gaussian potential , namely , the distribution of the nearest neighbor hopping parameters reads@xmath148where @xmath149 is the number of the gaussian centers , @xmath150 is uniformly random in the range @xmath151 $ ] and @xmath152 is interpreted as the effective screening length . similarly , the typical values of @xmath152 are the same as for the gaussian potential , i.e. , @xmath153 and @xmath139 for short- and long - range gaussian random hopping , respectively , and the values of @xmath149 are characterized by the value @xmath154 .
similar as in eq .
( [ vgaussian ] ) , the sum in eq .
( [ tgaussian ] ) does not include the overlapping of the gaussian distribution in different layers .
like in the case of gaussian potentials , the presence of random gaussian hopping in blg and tlg also suppresses the van hove singularities in the spectrum , but does not introduce a new impurity band ( midgap states ) and there is also no plateau in the conductivity vs. electron density curves ( see fig . [ trgaussian ] and [ trgaussianc ] ) .
the unique feature characteristic for the presence of random gaussian hopping is that in the region near the neutrality point , the conductivity is always linearly dependent on the electron density , with no influence from the concentration of gaussian centers ( different @xmath155 in fig .
[ trgaussian ] ) , range of gaussian coupling ( @xmath153 or @xmath139 ) , strength of the interlayer coupling ( @xmath156 in fig .
[ trgaussian ] and @xmath111 in fig .
trgaussianc ) , number of layers ( bilayer or trilayer ) and stacking sequence ( aba or abc in tlg ) .
the differences of short- or long - range cases are only obvious in the energy region far from the neutrality point ( high concentration of charge density ) : the increase of conductivity as a function of charge density is monotonic only for the long - range disorder . furthermore , like in the case of random gaussian potential , a common minimum conductivity in the order of @xmath120 on charge neutrality point is also observed for both blg and tlg .
we have presented a detailed numerical study of the electronic transport properties of bilayer and trilayer graphene within the framework of a noninteracting tight - binding model .
various realistic types of disorder are considered , such as resonant impurities , vacancies , random gaussian on - site potentials , and random gaussian hopping between nearest carbon atoms .
our results give a consistent picture of the electronic structure and transport properties of bilayer and trilayer graphene in a broad range of concentration of impurities or other sources of disorder .
linear or sublinear electron - density dependent conductivity at high enough density is observed , depending on the type and strength of the disorder and the stacking sequence .
the minimum conductivity @xmath157 ( per layer ) on charge neutrality point is common for blg and tlg , independent of the type of the impurities , but the plateau of minimum conductivity around the neutrality point is unique when resonant impurities or vacancies are present . in the presence of resonant impurities or vacancies ,
the dependence of the conductivity as a function of electron density is affected by the relevant width of the impurity band and the band created by the interlayer hopping . using blg with vacancies as an example : introducing @xmath158 as the density of electrons on the boundary of the parabolic band , and considering the case that the concentration of vacancies ( @xmath127 ) is smaller than @xmath159 , i.e.
, the impurity band is within the region of the parabolic conduction band , there are three regions of electron - density dependence of the conductivity : \(i ) @xmath160 , a central minimum conductivity plateau ( @xmath120 per layer ) with width equals to @xmath126 ; \(ii ) @xmath161 , linear dependence , as predicted by the analytical treatment using the boltzmann equation for parabolic spectrum @xcite ; \(iii ) @xmath162 , sublinear dependence , as the effects of the interlayer hopping are negligible in this region and one should expect a behavior of the conductivity similar to that of slg . on the opposite case @xmath162 , region ( ii ) simply disappears and therefore we can only observe the minimum conductivity plateau and sublinear dependence on the high concentration of electron densities . actually , the sublinear dependence beyond the parabolic band is a general property of slg , blg and mlg with large enough concentration of resonant impurities or vacancies , independent on the number of layers and the stacking sequence . in the presence of random gaussian on - site potentials ,
the electron - density dependences of conductivity of blg or tlg are sublinear and linear in the low concentration of charges , for short- and long - range disorders , respectively but are always sublinear in the high concentration .
on the other hand , in the case of random gaussian carbon carbon couplings , the density - dependence of conductivity in the region close to the neutrality point is more simple : there is only a linear dependence , with no effect of the strength and range of disorder , the number of layers and stacking sequence .
note added : after this paper was submitted , a paper which also discusses the effect of resonant scatterers on the dc conductivity of single - layer and bilayer graphene appeared @xcite , with results that are consistent with ours .
the support by the stichting fundamenteel onderzoek der materie ( fom ) and the netherlands national computing facilities foundation ( ncf ) are acknowledged .
m. lv and s. wan , phys .
b * 81 * , 195409 ( 2010 ) .
s. xiao , j. chen , s. adam , e. d. williams , and m. s. fuhrer , phys . rev .
b * 82 * , 041406 ( 2010 ) .
f. zhang , b. sahu , h. min , and a. h. macdonald , phys .
b * 82 * , 035409 ( 2010 )
. w. zhu , d. neumayer , v. perebeinos , and p. avouris , nano letters * 10 * 3572 ( 2010 ) .
j. b. oostinga , h. b. heersche , x. liu , a. f. morpurgo , and l. m. k. vandersypen , nature mater .
* 7 * , 151 ( 2008 ) .
t. taychatanapat and p. jarillo - herrero , phys .
lett . * 105 * , 166601 ( 2010 ) .
m. f. craciun , s. russo , m. yamamoto , j. b. oostinga , a. f. morpurgo , s. tarucha , nature nanotechnology , * 4 * , 383 ( 2009 ) .
s. h. m. jafri , k. carva , e. widenkvist , t. blom , b. sanyal , j. fransson , o. eriksson , u. jansson , h. grennberg , o. karis , r. a. quinlan , b. c. holloway and k. leifer , j. phys .
phys . * 43 * , 045404 ( 2010 ) .
z. wang , q. li , h. su , x. wang , q. shi , j. chen , j. yang , and j. hou , phys .
b 75 , 085424 ( 2007 ) .
h. p. dahal , a. v. balatsky , and j. x. zhu , phys .
b * 77 * , 115114 ( 2008 ) .
e. v. castro , m. p. lopez - sancho , and m. a. h. vozmediano , phys .
* 104 * , 036802 ( 2010 ) . | we present a detailed numerical study of the electronic transport properties of bilayer and trilayer graphene within a framework of single - electron tight - binding model .
various types of disorder are considered , such as resonant ( hydrogen ) impurities , vacancies , short- or long - range gaussian random potentials , and gaussian random nearest neighbor hopping .
the algorithms are based on the numerical solution of the time - dependent schrdinger equation and applied to calculate the density of states and conductivities ( via the kubo formula ) of large samples containing millions of atoms . in the cases under consideration , far enough from the neutrality point , depending on the strength of disorders and the stacking sequence , a linear or sublinear electron - density dependent conductivity is found .
the minimum conductivity @xmath0 ( per layer ) at the charge neutrality point is the same for bilayer and trilayer graphene , independent of the type of the impurities , but the plateau of minimum conductivity around the neutrality point is only observed in the presence of resonant impurities or vacancies , originating from the formation of the impurity band . |
the approach of lhc turn - on has renewed interest in dynamical electroweak symmetry breaking ( dewsb ) , whether in the traditional form of technicolor models @xcite , or that of its possible 5d dual description @xcite and related moose models @xcite . yet , only a handful of non - supersymmetric models of electroweak symmetry breaking have so far been implemented in monte - carlo generators @xcite . to pave the way for more simulations of dewsb
, we define a flexible framework with resonances and more generic interactions than have previously been considered . at the same time
, we strive to limit the number of parameters in this lagrangian , to make the parameter space manageable . dialing the parameters then allows to describe a sampling of strong interaction models , as msugra did for the mssm : our framework is intended to work in a similar way , applied to dewsb .
we have already presented some phenomenological applications in @xcite ; the present paper details the inner workings of our framework . in practice
, our approach extends attempts to model strong interactions , based on the ideas of hidden local symmetry and mooses @xcite as well as 5d warped models @xcite ( themselves inspired by ads / cft @xcite ) .
these approaches have been used for qcd @xcite with some accuracy , and thus tend to describe strong interactions which closely follow qcd behavior up to a rescaling of @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
for instance , they all predict the following : 1 ) the spectrum consists of an alternance of states with definite parity , implying that only half of the neutral resonances couple to @xmath2 scattering , 2 ) the lightest resonance has vector parity , and 3 ) the photon couplings to two different particles vanish ( the equivalent of @xmath3 vanishing in qcd ) . to explore different scenarios ,
we will build on a previous construction holographic technicolor ( htc ) @xcite in which the new strong interactions can differ from rescaled qcd .
in addition to their allowing new phenomena , deviations from qcd may help alleviate difficulties with electroweak precision tests ( ewpts ) @xcite .
htc uses 5d language but , compared to higgsless models @xcite , it adds deviations from pure ads 5d geometry in the form of effective warp factors which differ for the various fields .
as the name _ effective warp factors _ implies , we are only borrowing 5d language to describe a 4d scenario .
therefore , it does not matter that simple 5d models do not reproduce these effective warp factors by using bulk scalars @xcite .
indeed , the same physics could be obtained in a purely 4d context by using moose notation @xcite . in the present paper ,
we use the htc language to model the resonances and sm gauge boson sectors .
the main constraint on such interactions comes from experimental bounds on trilinear gauge - couplings ( tgcs ) .
however , a phenomenological study also requires modeling the fermion - resonance interactions . in the present phenomenological description ,
these couplings are simply assigned by hand : we fix the couplings between fermions and resonances to pass current limits .
( modelling the fermions in 5d would unnecessarily increase the number of parameters in our study . on the other hand
, it may bring interesting consequences , such as a preferential coupling of the resonances to third generation fermions . ) the present paper deals with the low - energy lagrangian and its relation with the 5d description .
phenomenological studies for a few benchmark points were presented previously @xcite .
we start in section ii by describing the interactions in an effective lagrangian of spin-1 resonances . in section iii
, we then discuss our htc framework for reducing the number of parameters as compared to a generic effective lagrangian , and its relation to 5d modelling . in section iv
, we detail some important properties of the model relative to the parity of resonances . in section
v , we study the constraints that tgc bounds from lep impose on the parameter space of htc .
section vi explores the predictions of the model for two interesting regions of parameter space .
we consider a spectrum consisting of the sm spin-1 fields ( @xmath4 ) , two triplets of resonances , as well as the sm quarks and leptons , but no physical higgs particle .
we refer to the resonances as @xmath5 rather than @xmath6 since they will turn out to lack a definite parity , see section [ sec_parity ] . in this section , we detail the cubic couplings of dimension 4 between spin-1 fields .
we restrict ourselves to cubic vertices involving one resonance and quartic vertices with sm fields , as is sufficient to study the production of new heavy states at the lhc . even at this level , we need to make assumptions to limit the independent parameters to a manageable number
. we will use htc to this effect in section [ sec_framework ] .
the presence of a new sector affects the self - couplings of sm gauge fields , introducing deviations from the sm in the tgcs . in this paper
, we will consider constraints from the following tgcs @xcite @xmath7 } w^{+ \mu } a^{\nu } + \partial_{[\mu } w^+_{\left .
\nu \right ] } a^{\mu } w^{- \nu } \right ) + \kappa_{\gamma } \partial_{\left [ \mu \right . }
\nu \right ] } w^{- \mu } w^{+ \nu } \right ) \nonumber\\ & - & ie \frac{c}{s } \left ( g_1^z \left ( \partial_{\left [ \mu \right . } w^-_{\left .
\nu \right ] } w^{+ \mu } z^{\nu } + \partial_{[\mu } w^+_{\left .
\nu \right ] } z^{\mu } w^{- \nu } \right ) + \kappa_z \partial_{\left [ \mu \right . }
\nu \right ] } w^{- \mu } w^{+ \nu } \right ) , \label{tgvs}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath8 can differ from their sm value ( equal to 1 ) .
@xmath9 and @xmath10 in equation ( [ tgvs ] ) are the cosinus and sinus of the weinberg angle . from ( [ tgvs ] ) above , we see that the @xmath11 interaction is in general built up of two separate lorentz structures with independent couplings ( @xmath12 and @xmath13 ) .
the @xmath14 interactions also contains two independent couplings ( @xmath15 and @xmath16 ) .
most scenarios of dewsb impose @xmath17 and @xmath18 ( see section [ sec_permutation ] ) .
current bounds on the tgcs ( [ tgvs ] ) will restrict the parameters in our description of strong interactions ( section [ sec_tgcs ] ) . introducing the spin-1 resonances as massive gauge fields generically called @xmath19 , we consider the following dimension-4 cubic couplings @xmath20 } c^{+ \mu } d^{0 \nu } + g_{b c d 2 } \partial_{[\mu } c^+_{\left .
\nu \right ] } d^{0 \mu } b^{- \nu } + g_{b c d 3 } \partial_{\left [ \mu \right .
} d^0_{\left .
\nu \right ] } b^{- \mu } c^{+ \nu } \right ) , \label{cubics}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the three independent couplings @xmath21 are consistent with all the low - energy symmetries .
the number of free couplings thus increases quickly as we include more resonances : we find 45 new couplings if we limit ourselves to the @xmath22 and two triplets of resonances .
specializing to photon couplings , i.e. @xmath23 , the unbroken @xmath24 gauge invariance imposes on ( [ cubics ] ) the following relation @xmath25 while there is no constraint on the third coupling in ( [ cubics ] ) @xmath26 this yields 7 cubic couplings involving the photon .
the presence of a coupling between the photon and two different particles of unequal masses , explored recently @xcite , produces striking signals in collider studies @xcite .
although we have restricted ourselves to cubic vertices , the number of parameters is already @xmath27 , far too large for a collider study .
section [ sec_framework ] will introduce holographic technicolor ( htc ) @xcite , the framework we use to reduce the number of parameters . in this paper
we _ define _ the interactions of the fermions by setting their couplings to the @xmath28 mass eigenstates by hand to obey the sm relations .
usually , @xmath29 and @xmath30 are defined from two - point functions of @xmath31 and @xmath32 , or from operators in an effective lagrangian like @xmath33 . here
we follow a different procedure by working directly in the mass basis where there are no mixing operators which would contribute to the @xmath29 and @xmath30 parameters . moreover , by imposing sm couplings between fermions and @xmath31 , @xmath32 and @xmath34 ,
we ensure that the amplitudes extracted experimentally satisfy @xmath35 .
this can be read off from the expression for the neutral current amplitude @xcite @xmath36 our phenomenological study is not intended to present a uv completion that would resolve the clashes between dewsb and oblique corrections .
rather , it tries to present the possible phenomenological consequences of a scenario that would pass the oblique and tgc constraints ( section [ sec_tgcs ] ) .
we set the couplings of fermions to the resonances to be compatible with experimental bounds from lep and tevatron @xcite .
to keep the study manageable in the spin-1 sector , we use 5d techniques , trading the plethora of resonance couplings in ( [ cubics ] ) for a few extra - dimensional parameters .
the usual reason for using 5d models to describe 4d strongly interacting theories is the ads / cft correspondence @xcite .
although rigorous derivations of this duality have only been obtained for very specific cases , we do not need an exact equivalence in order to study lhc phenomenology .
indeed , provided the essential properties of the 5d model are the same as the strong interaction scenario , we can use the 5d description as a physical guide and organizing scheme .
the 5d description also allows for the introduction of deviations from rescaled qcd , using for instance holographic technicolor ( section [ sec_htc ] ) .
we quickly review the extra - dimensional properties and language we need .
the geometry of the extra - dimension is described by the warp factor @xmath37 , as in the line element @xmath38 the @xmath39-coordinate is finite , extending from @xmath40 ( uv brane ) to @xmath41 ( ir brane ) .
a gauge field propagating in the 5d space - time , @xmath42possesses five indices @xmath43 , and can be decomposed as an infinite sum of 4d excitations @xmath44 @xmath45 is the wavefunction , or profile , of the 4d field @xmath46 along the extra - dimension @xmath39 ( in the _ bulk _ ) .
this fourier decomposition is called in this context _ kaluza - klein _ ( kk ) decomposition , and the infinite tower of kk excitations , the kk - tower .
the wavefunctions @xmath45 are obtained by solving the equation of motion of the field @xmath47 in the background given by @xmath37 .
the wavefunctions also depend on the boundary conditions ( bcs ) imposed at @xmath40 and @xmath41 .
one can choose bcs to partly or completely break the 5d gauge symmetries at low energies . specifically ,
if the bcs do not allow massless ( i.e. flat ) modes in the spectrum , then there is no remaining 4d gauge invariance .
once the wavefunctions are known , the interactions between 4d fields can be derived from overlap integrals .
for example , the coupling of the @xmath32 and @xmath31 bosons to a resonance @xmath48 is the integral of their wavefunctions along the @xmath39-coordinate , @xmath49 such couplings can be computed easily , yielding from the lagrangian ( [ linit ] ) the value of all the cubic couplings of sm gauge fields ( [ tgvs ] ) and resonances ( [ cubics ] ) . for a given choice of gauge group , bcs and geometry , a 5d model uses only a few pararmeters to describe a complex scenario of many particles . in the simplest version ( ads ) , these parameters are : the length @xmath41 , the dimensionless gauge coupling @xmath50 and the form of the geometry @xmath51 . in the following we introduce _ two _ more parameters in the functional shape of the warp factors .
these two new parameters are an essential ingredient to achieve a departure from qcd - like physics ( section [ nonqcd ] ) while maintaining 5d relations such as ( [ tri0 ] ) . to model dewsb
, we place @xmath52 gauge fields in the 5d bulk .
the lightest kk excitations of these 5d gauge fields correspond to the sm elecroweak gauge bosons , while the higher kk excitations of the same 5d fields will be interpreted as resonances .
htc corresponds to the following choice of bulk action @xmath53 where @xmath54 labels the @xmath55 generator .
we chose to write a bulk lagrangian invariant under @xmath56 , i.e. parity . in that case , it is convenient to work in terms of the vector and axial combinations of gauge fields @xmath57 , to get @xmath58 where @xmath59 + \left [ a_m , a_n \right ] \right ) , \\ f_{a , m n } & = & \partial_m a_n - \partial_n a_m - \frac{i}{\sqrt{2 } } \left ( [ v_m , a_n ] + \left [ a_m , v_n \right ] \right ) . \end{aligned}\ ] ] we use higgsless bcs in the ir @xmath60 the uv bcs appropriate for ewsb break parity , which will have consequences later on ( section [ sec_parity ] ) @xmath61 the third bc in ( [ bcsuv ] ) is achieved by adding a brane - localized @xmath62 kinetic term @xcite @xmath63 } \partial^{\left [ \mu \right . }
\nu \right ] 3 } \right ) , & & \end{aligned}\ ] ] and requiring that the variation of the action vanish under any variation of @xmath64 .
this allows for a @xmath65 brane field .
would introduce more neutral resonances , as in higgsless models . in either case , an extra parameter enters the lagrangian . ]
the above combination of bcs ensures that the only surviving symmetry at low energies is @xmath66 .
other than the photon massless mode , the spectrum contains the massive @xmath67 and an infinite tower of heavier resonances @xmath68 . for given warp factors
@xmath69 , @xmath41 sets the mass of the lightest resonance in the kk tower with respect to @xmath70
. we will be interested in cases where the lightest resonance is lighter than @xmath71 , and we will truncate the kk tower after the lightest two triplets .
one consequence of adding a sizeable @xmath72 term in ( [ linit ] ) is that the two first triplets can have comparable masses , and therefore must both be kept in the spectrum . as mentioned above , 5d models in ads ,
in which there is only one warp factor with a fixed expression @xmath73 , exhibit features similar to a rescaled version of qcd ( alternating spectrum with selection rules for couplings ) . allowing two different warp factors which deviate from ads in the infrared , as in htc ( [ linit ] ) , lifts these restrictions . for computations ,
we need to pick an explicit expression form for the warp factors : we choose the positive - definite @xmath74 we use the name _ effective warp factors _ because @xmath75 do not correspond to an actual geometry in 5d @xcite .
rather , @xmath75 parameterize different scenarios of technivectors : varying @xmath76 amounts to changing the masses and couplings of the vector and axial resonances .
the exact power of @xmath39 in ( [ wav ] ) is not crucial : a modification of the power could be partly absorbed in a modification of @xmath77 . what matters is that the effective metrics deviate from ads in the ir , and thus modify the wave - functions and overlap integrals ( [ tri0 ] ) from which the couplings are obtained . beyond the breaking by ir bcs , familiar from higgsless theories @xcite ) , the different effective metrics felt by the @xmath78 and @xmath79 fields introduce symmetry breaking in the bulk ( @xmath39-dependence ) .
brane - breaking corresponds to the choice of bcs in ( [ bcsir ] ) , while bulk - breaking is introduced on top of ( [ bcsir ] ) as different effective metrics in ( [ linit ] ) @xmath80 in the case of brane - breaking , the only distinction between the broken ( axial ) and unbroken ( vector ) generators comes from the ir bcs . in a `` dual '' interpretation , where the fifth space coordinate is inversely related with an energy scale
, this corresponds to the symmetry breaking occuring suddenly at the resonance scale @xcite .
the localization of the breaking at a point in the extra - dimension suppresses effects at any scale above that .
such hard - wall breaking is the crudest 5d model of spontaneous symmetry breaking . if the symmetry breaking is turned on progressively along the 5th dimension rather than at the ir brane alone , we have bulk breaking .
the strength of the breaking , and therefore the difference between the properties of vector and axial states , is governed by the @xmath39-dependence of the breaking term .
the standard way to accomplish bulk breaking is to add a scalar bulk field , and to let it obtain a vacuum expectation value .
however , the kk decomposition of the bulk scalar would introduce 4d scalar resonances , which we want to avoid for simplicity in the present paper .
rather , in the htc lagrangian ( [ linit ] ) , we introduced a position dependent kinetic term mixing @xmath81 and @xmath82 gauge fields , which is invariant under the vector gauge symmetry and parity .
obviously , many more terms besides @xmath72 could be added to the lagrangian and may lead to different phenomenology , but @xmath72 is the operator with lowest dimension and number of derivatives and no new fields . from the effective field theory point of view , what matters is that bulk - breaking allows a more general spectrum and structure for the cubic interactions of ( [ cubics ] ) ,
see section [ sec_permutation ] .
our parameterization of the spin-1 sector is economical .
three combinations of parameters are set by imposing the physical value of @xmath83 .
the remaining parameters can be chosen as : the size @xmath41 of the extra dimension ( closely related to the mass of the lightest resonance , @xmath84 ) and the two parameters @xmath85 and @xmath86 describing the functional shape of the effective background felt by the spin-1 fields .
for the fermion sector , we choose the couplings of the fermions to the @xmath87 to follow the sm relations . as to the couplings of fermions to resonances , they do not influence the results of this paper , as long as these are suppressed by a factor compared to the couplings to sm gauge fields . or @xmath88 to be equal to the coupling between the same fermions and the @xmath31 or @xmath32 respectively , rescaled by a common factor @xmath89 , independent of the fermion or the resonance multiplet .
for the specific points studied in @xcite with 500 and 600 gev resonances , we chose @xmath90 and @xmath91 in order for the resonances to have avoided detection at tevatron @xcite.[footnote - about - kappa ] ] let us point out the basic effects of varying one of the parameters @xmath85 .
a negative @xmath85 in the effective warp factor ( [ wav ] ) acts as an ir cutoff , effectively shortening the space in which @xmath78 fields live , but leaving axial masses untouched .
figure [ fig_level - crossing ] shows this explicitely in a simpler scenario with uv dirichlet bcs for @xmath78 and @xmath79 fields ( @xmath92 at the uv brane ) . with such bcs
, the first axial resonance would be lighter than the vector one for @xmath93 .
for applications to ewsb , the situation is more complicated due to the different bcs , see section [ sec_parity ] .
mass of the lightest vector ( @xmath94 ) and lightest axial ( @xmath95 ) resonances as a function of @xmath85 , for @xmath96 , @xmath97 .
this plot uses dirichlet bcs in the uv.,width=377 ]
the htc lagrangian ( [ linit ] ) is invariant under parity ( @xmath98 ) .
one would thus expect the spin-1 resonances to have definite parity . in the 5d language , the eigenfunctions would then split into two distinct sectors : @xmath78 or @xmath79 wavefunctions , not admixtures of them .
however , the coupling to electroweak @xmath99 interactions breaks parity . in the 5d language
, this effect comes from the uv bcs which mix the vector and axial sectors ( [ bcsuv ] ) .
the mixing effects depicted in figure [ fig_level - repulsion ] become especially important for nearly - degenerate resonances , the region we want to look at .
this mixing is not an artifact of our framework and will hold for any model of nearly - degenerate resonances coupled to the electroweak sector .
as can be seen in figure [ fig_level - repulsion ] , the level repulsion also affects the higher kk modes .
masses of the four lightest charged resonances in tev , as a function of @xmath85 , for @xmath96 , and fixing @xmath97 with @xmath70 at its physical value.,width=377 ] due to the mixing , each eigenstate is a linear combination of a vector and an axial wavefunction , without definite parity .
the eigenfunctions are thus two - component objects @xmath100 , where @xmath101 and @xmath102 are the vector and axial component . to follow what happens as we vary the effective warp factors , we define the continuous parity of eigenstate @xmath103 by @xmath104 and plot the parity of the states as we vary @xmath85 in figure [ fig_parity ] .
parity , as defined in ( [ parity ] ) , of the various charged modes as a function of @xmath85 , for @xmath96 and @xmath105 , and @xmath97.,width=377 ] figure [ fig_parity ] shows that the lightest resonance goes adiabatically from a mostly - vector state for @xmath106 , to a mostly axial one for large negative @xmath85 , and vice - versa for the second level .
figure [ fig_parity ] also shows that the @xmath31 , whose uv bc ( [ bcsuv ] ) imposes it to be predominantly @xmath107 in the uv , contains nearly - equal admixtures of @xmath78 and @xmath79 for most of the parameter space .
the resonances change parity near @xmath108 .
the fact that @xmath78 and @xmath79 mix to yield mass eigenstates without definite parity will have important consequences later on in section [ sec_permutation ] for the scenarios we consider . on the other hand , the mixing is not relevant for higgsless models , since it decreases with the mass separation between states .
in the present section , we examine the limits set by tgcs on resonance masses , and point to regions in the remaining two - dimensional parameter space @xmath109 where @xmath110 is allowed . to avoid numerical difficulties encoutered
when studying the whole parameter space , we restrict ourselves to two curves within the @xmath111 plane , along which we illustrate the constraints from tgcs in this section .
our choices are : line a ( @xmath96 ) and line b ( @xmath112 ) , where @xmath113 is the longhitano coefficient of the @xmath33 term ( see appendix [ app ] for details ) .
the two curves ( line a and line b ) are depicted in the @xmath111 space in figure [ fig_alpha1_0 ] , where the origin of the plot represents ads space .
the curve aso shows how the physical predictions depend not only on the difference @xmath114 , but on both effective warp factors . the @xmath111 plane , with lines a and b ( dotted and continuous , respectively ) studied in the text .
the approximation @xmath115 has been used to determine line b. the origin of the axes corresponds to the pure ads higgsless model.,width=377 ] line b imposes a relation between @xmath86 and @xmath85 , and we will plot the various couplings as a function of @xmath86 along that curve .
the tgcs are the main constraint on htc , since oblique corrections @xmath116 vanish by our choice of fermion couplings to gauge fields . in figure
[ fig_tgcs - constraints ] , we depict the @xmath117 constraints on @xmath84 imposed by the bounds on each of the tgcs .
figure [ fig_tgcs - constraints ] shows that resonances as light as 500 gev are allowed by the tgc constraints , but only for @xmath118 . on the other hand
, we see that a model in a pure ads background ( @xmath119 ) is incompatible with the tgc bounds at @xmath117 unless @xmath84 is raised above 700 gev .
@xmath117 bounds imposed by @xmath8 in the space of @xmath84 ( horizontal axis ) and @xmath85 ( vertical axis ) , along line a ( @xmath96 ) .
darker areas are excluded , and the central value is depicted as a dashed line.,width=604 ] we study the line for which the longhitano coefficient @xmath113 vanishes .
our motivation for studying this line is twofold .
first , a vanishing @xmath113 limits the deviations of the tgcs from the sm , see ( [ kappagamma]-[kappaz ] ) in appendix [ app ] .
this is illustrated in figure [ fig_tgcs - alpha1 ] , where the tgcs are plotted along the line of @xmath112 , for @xmath120 .
additionally , since @xmath113 describes the mixing between @xmath121 and the hypercharge gauge field @xmath122 , @xmath123 means that no additional contributions are required to cancel the @xmath29 parameter .
tgcs along line b , for @xmath124 , with all other parameters at their physical value .
the horizontal axis depicts the central value measured at lep , while the shaded bands depict the @xmath117 errors.,width=642 ]
in this section , we set the mass of the lightest resonance to @xmath120 .
we then extract predictions for resonance couplings along the two lines a and b described in section [ sec_tgcs ] .
this particular choice is arbitrary , but exemplifies the phenomenology that can be obtained in htc . in practice
, we will truncate the kk tower , explicitly keeping in the lagrangian only the first two multiplets of resonances : with the lightest resonance at 500 gev , the third multiplet would usually come in above one tev ( see figure [ fig_level - repulsion ] ) , still interesting for the lhc purposes but outside the scope of the present paper .
the splitting between multiplets determines the decays of the heavy resonance .
a splitting larger than @xmath125 gev allows for the @xmath126 to decay into @xmath127 .
figure [ fig_spectrum ] depicts the mass of @xmath126 when @xmath84 is set to @xmath128 .
the left plot for line a corresponds to the one of figure [ fig_level - repulsion ] above , but rather than keeping @xmath41 fixed , it is rescaled to maintain @xmath120 .
along this line ( line a ) , the splitting between resonances decreases from the ads ( @xmath129 ) as we dial a non - zero value of @xmath85 . along line
b ( @xmath112 ) , the separation between the two lightest resonances remains about 150 gev .
along the same two lines , we can examine the isospin splitting within the lightest two triplets of resonances , as plotted in figure [ fig_isospin ] .
this mass splitting affects the @xmath130 parameter , which will remain close to unity as long as the couplings of fermions to resonances are small enough . here , as it depends on the value of these couplings ( in particular , it depends on @xmath89 in the example mentioned in footnote [ footnote - about - kappa ] ) . since we have already assigned sm couplings between the fermions and the @xmath28 , the @xmath30 parameter vanishes .
] the neutral resonances are always heavier than the charged ones , due to the uv bc ( [ bcsuv ] ) , which lifted the @xmath32 with respect to the @xmath31 . in this section ,
we discuss how a selection rule that was valid in previous models does not apply to htc . in the limit where the sm gauge couplings vanish * * ,
the system recovers a @xmath56 symmetry under which all resonances are either even or odd under parity . in this parity - limit
, only the vector resonances would couple to two @xmath31 s @xmath131 and thus only the vector resonances help unitarizing @xmath132 scattering .
as seen in section [ sec_parity ] , once the sm gauge interactions are turned on , the @xmath133 parity is violated : the axial or vector labels become meaningless as both towers of resonances acquire both components .
given that all resonances have a vector component , they all couple to the @xmath31 and @xmath32 .
this means that both sets of resonances participate in unitarizing longitudinal gauge boson scattering .
figure [ fig_gwwr3-vertical ] shows , along the two usual lines in parameter space , the coefficient @xmath134 in the term @xmath135}_i
w^-_{\mu } w^+_{\nu } . & & \label{def - gwwr3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] since both light resonances have cubic couplings with two sm gauge fields , they can both be searched for in @xmath136 final states @xcite . in the case of ads , we recover that the vector resonances couple predominantly to @xmath137 , while the axial ones nearly decouples . making @xmath85 negative
partially reverses the situation , as expected from figures [ fig_level - crossing ] and [ fig_parity ] : the second lightest resonance is now more coupled to @xmath2 than the first one is . in the present section ,
we detail how different effective warp factors affect the cubic couplings . in particular
, it turns out that @xmath138 allows for new couplings with interesting phenomenological consequences .
when the two effective warp factors are equal , the tgcs ( [ tgvs ] ) satisfy @xmath139 more generally , equality of the two effective warp factors implies that , for any three spin-1 particles @xmath140 the three couplings @xmath141 are equal , according to @xmath142 where we have already used @xmath143 . applied to photon couplings , this implies that the photon can not mediate a transition between two different particles .
deviating from a standard 5d ads set - up allows for a richer structure . in htc , plugging in @xmath144 for the vector ( axial ) component profile of field @xmath145 , we find @xmath146 where @xmath147c are charged fields , and @xmath148 is neutral . in the most general scenario , where the vector and axial warp factors are different and @xmath149 , the couplings of the three permutations can all be different @xmath150 when @xmath122 and @xmath151 are antiparticles of each other , @xmath122 and @xmath151 share the same profile , so the two couplings with the derivative acting on a charged field are equal @xmath152 when the neutral field is the photon , there is an additional constraint on the triboson couplings from @xmath153 gauge invariance @xmath154 this result derives from the @xmath34 wavefunction being flat : the cubic overlap integrals ( [ triboson1]-[triboson2 ] ) then reduce to a quadratic overlap corresponding to the orthogonality relations @xmath155 on the other hand , the third photon coupling ( i.e. ( [ triboson ] ) with @xmath156 ) does not reduce to such an orthogonality relation : it would be written as ( [ ortho ] ) , but with the warp factors swapped @xmath157 .
therefore , couplings such as @xmath158 vanish in higgsless models , but not in htc .
the new coupling is shown in figure [ fig_vertical - couplings ] along the usual lines .
we see two effects at play : first , unequal warp factors @xmath138 allow for a coupling of the axial resonance to @xmath159 , and second , the mixing also allows a coupling of the vector resonance to @xmath159 . hence both resonances can decay to @xmath159 , as studied in @xcite .
we take a pragmatic approach to the description of dynamical electroweak symmetry breaking , providing a resonance lagrangian simple enough to be implemented in monte - carlo simulations , yet complex enough to incorporate phenomena beyond those usually considered .
our description of new strong interactions does not rely on an explicit model , but rather introduces phenomenological parameters describing the interactions of new states visible at the lhc .
such an effective description usually comes at a price , namely the large number of unknown parameters to be varied .
we deal with this problem by imposing relations between the constants appearing in the effective lagrangian : we construct our effective lagrangian using rules from extra - dimensional model - building in order to impose constraints ( we could equally well have retained a fully 4d formulation by relying on mooses ) . on the other hand ,
we also want to lift some of the 5d constraints that seem too restrictive . to avoid the alternating spectrum and selection rules usually predicted by the usual 5d or moose approach , we work with an extension of the 5d framework : holographic technicolor ( htc ) , which starts as a 5d model , but adds as a new ingredient an effective bulk - breaking term without introducing new states other than spin-1 resonances .
we do not try to reproduce specific models in the literature , but instead study the phenomenology of new scenarios that evade some of the usual constraints on technicolor models .
the uv completions of such scenarios are unknown , but we assume in our effective description that the problem of oblique corrections is solved , and set the couplings of fermions to @xmath28 accordingly .
we also choose the couplings of sm fermions to resonances to pass experimental bounds .
we rely on bounds from the trilinear gauge couplings to restrict our three free parameters , and find that low - mass resonances ( @xmath160 ) are allowed .
working in this low - mass assumption , we consider two interesting curves in the remaining two - parameter space .
two new couplings that our lagrangian generally includes turn out to be relevant in these regions , allowing both light resonances to be seen in the @xmath161 channel ( as well as in the @xmath2 channel ) , and to decay to @xmath159 ( observable at lhc ) .
regarding future developments , we point out that our choice of effective description ( drawing on the 5d formalism ) allows for an easy inclusion of additional fields , such as scalars , technipions or the isospin - singlet techni - omega .
we thank t. appelquist , r. s. chivukula and w. skiba for helpful comments .
jh and am are supported by doe grant de - fg02 - 92er-40704 ; vs is supported by de - fg02 - 91er40676 .
jh and vs acknowledge the hospitality of the kavli institute for theoretical physics in santa barbara , ca , where part of this work was completed .
in this appendix , we detail a subtlety in the derivation of tgcs in our framework as compared to other approaches . the electroweak chiral lagrangian @xcite describes the electroweak sector without higgs at low energies .
it is constructed by coupling the yang - mills action of @xmath162 @xmath163 to a chiral lagrangian for the three goldstone bosons ( gbs ) of the breaking @xmath164 this is the minimal custodial sector that feeds 3 gbs without introducing technipions .
this gb chiral lagrangian , ordered by the number of derivatives , starts with the operator vanishes , therefore we do not write the corresponding operator . ]
@xmath165 where @xmath166 means @xmath167 trace and the covariant derivative applied to the gb unitary matrix @xmath168 reads @xmath169 the covariant derivative couples the weak @xmath170 gauge fields to the gbs .
this can be checked by going to unitary gauge , i.e. @xmath171 , which yields the appropriate masses for the @xmath172 and @xmath173 . at the next order in the derivative expansion , there are extra quadratic ( @xmath113 ) , cubic ( @xmath174 ) and quartic ( @xmath175 ) couplings among the @xmath176 @xmath177 \right\rangle \nonumber\\ & + & \alpha_4 \left\langle d_{\mu } ud_{\nu } u^{\dag } \right\rangle^2 + \alpha_5 \left\langle d_{\mu } ud^{\mu } u^{\dag } \right\rangle^2 .
\label{op4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] assuming that the underlying strong dynamics respect parity symmetry results in @xmath178 .
are related to the gasser - leutwyler @xmath179 couplings ( which assume parity invariance ) by @xmath180 , @xmath181 .
the @xmath182 coefficients with @xmath183 introduce isospin breaking at tree level , and will therefore not be generated in our framework . ]
the @xmath113 term introduces the mixing of @xmath184 and @xmath185 , even though the quadratic lagrangian may have been diagonalized at the previous order ; @xmath113 is thus an oblique correction .
one may choose to diagonalize the full quadratic lagrangian at this order ( i.e. including @xmath113 ) in order to work in the mass basis , thereby shifting the deviation from the sm into fermion couplings @xcite .
the cubic terms in @xmath113 as well as @xmath174 in the lagrangian ( [ op4 ] ) produce deviations from the sm in the tgcs ( [ tgvs ] ) , given by @xcite ( assuming @xmath178 ) @xmath187 this derivation uses the standard relation @xmath188 which is valid for the electroweak chiral lagrangian , but not true in general .
indeed , relation ( [ gff ] ) assumes that @xmath189 appearing in the covariant derivative ( [ dmuu ] ) is strictly equal to the fermion-@xmath31 coupling , something which does not hold in our framework , nor in standard 5d models @xcite .
we chose to _ define _ the interactions of the fermions by assigning them couplings to the physical mass eigenstates that satisfy the sm relations .
therefore , the @xmath29 and @xmath30 parameters will vanish . on the other hand , we model the interactions of spin-1 fields , imposing experimental values for the parameters @xmath190 , and predicting the tgcs . as a consequence ,
relations between fermion couplings ( which are set by hand ) and quantities involving @xmath34 , @xmath28 ( which are predicted from a 5d lagrangian ) are modified .
for example @xmath191 does not hold at tree level if @xmath189 means the fermion-@xmath31 coupling this coupling is set by hand outside any 5d modelling , whereas @xmath70 and @xmath192 are an output of the 5d model .
in other words , we have in general @xmath193 as a consequence , we find that , while relation ( [ kappagamma ] ) holds in our framework , the same is not true of ( [ g1z]-[kappaz ] ) .
this is because these latter two definitions depend on the value of the weinberg angle , defined as @xmath194 the extraction of the tgcs thus involves @xmath195 and not @xmath192 whereas eqs .
( [ kappagamma]-[kappaz ] ) assumed a relation between the two , eq .
( [ gff ] ) .
the definition of the weinberg angle ( [ weinberg - angle ] ) feeds into the extraction of the tgcs from the lagrangian ( [ tgvs ] ) .
figure [ fig_relation - holdom ] compares the exact prediction of the tgcs with the one that would be derived from ( [ kappagamma]-[kappaz ] ) .
tgcs along line a , for @xmath124 , with all other parameters at their physical value .
the horizontal axis depicts the central value measured at lep , while the shaded bands depict the @xmath117 errors .
the continuous lines depict the tgcs as a function of @xmath85 , for @xmath96 and @xmath120 .
dashed lines represent values computed from blindly using ( [ kappagamma]-[g1z ] ) .
the discrepancy in the @xmath196 plot comes from having used the @xmath115 approximation for the dashed line.,width=642 ] to understand the discrepancy , we must go back to the definitions of @xmath195 @xmath197 where @xmath198 are the fermion - spin-1 couplings , and @xmath192 @xcite @xmath199 there is no connection between @xmath192 and @xmath195 unless the fermions are modeled in 5d in a particular way .
if , for example , the fermions were placed on the uv brane , then there would be a relation between the @xmath200 s of ( [ exactgf ] ) and the wavefunctions @xmath201 of the resonances on the uv brane .
cdf collaboration .
searching for anomalous production of z bosons with high transverse momentum in 0.94 fb@xmath206 at the tevatron .
cdf note 8452 , 2007 , http//www - cdf.fnal.gov / physics / exotics / r2a/20060817.heavy_obj_wz_paramonov / highpt_z.html | we construct an effective lagrangian for new strong interactions at the lhc , including as a first step the two lightest triplets of spin-1 resonances .
our parametrization is general enough to allow for previously unstudied spectrum and couplings . among available frameworks to describe the spin-1 sector , we rely on an extra - dimensional description .
our approach limits the number of parameters , yet is versatile enough to describe the phenomenology of a wide range of new scenarios of strong electroweak symmetry breaking . |
+ + * * +
we observe that + + + + + + 2 . for a given initial ratio , except for the light quarks and anti - quarks
, the output does not depend much on the initial baryon number density .
for the light quarks and antiquarks this variation is due to the presence of the exponentiated non - zero chemical potentials .
+ 3 . for a given initial baryon number density we can recast the equation for baryon number density in the form @xmath25 + @xmath26 ... (27 ) where c is a constant for a given temperature , light quark fugacity and given baryon number density . here
d is the light quark to antiquark initial fugacity ratio . for a fixed light quark fugacity and temperature , as d falls clearly the rhs of the above equation increases which indicates a rise in the chemical potential .
again for a system of higher chemical potential , the temperature has to drop at a slower rate due to the constraint imposed .
hence we observe that + + i ) the temperature falls at a slower rate for a smaller value of the light quark to antiquark initial fugacity ratio .
+ ii ) as the temperature falls at a slower rate , it would imply a lesser expenditure of energy to produce particles in general .
this would show up in the slower rise of all fugacity values except the light antiquark , which would show a higher growth rate .
this is due to the exponentiated chemical potential part .
+ 4 . for inclusion of the quark - flavour - changing process
we observe the following : + + due to the additional production of s - quarks from massless quarks via qfcp , we see an additional increase in fugacity of the strange quark while , the rate of equilibration falls for non - strange fermions . | parton equilibration studies for a thermally equilibrated but chemically non - equilibrated quark - gluon plasma ( qgp ) , likely to be formed at the relativistic colliders at bnl and cern is presented .
parton equilibration is studied enforcing baryon number conservation .
process like quark - flavour interchanging is also taken into consideration .
the degree of equilibration is studied comparatively for the various reactions / constraints that are being considered . |
in the past years the bose - hubbard model @xcite has been extensively investigated and a lot of interest has been generated thanks to ultracold atom experiments on optical lattices @xcite , which provide an ideal realization of the model .
recently , much theoretical and experimental work has been performed on mixtures with several species of particles .
for instance , bose - fermi mixtures on lattices have been studied @xcite .
another mixture that is likely of interest involves atoms and molecules , in which conversion between the two species is possible .
such conversion processes can describe , for instance , long - lived bound states of atoms ( diatomic molecules ) occuring in ultracold atom experiments where a feshbach resonance is used to tune the scattering length of the atoms @xcite . in those experiments , the hyperfine interaction between two spin polarized atoms can flip the spin of one of the atoms , reducing sensitively their scattering length .
the two atoms are virtualy bound into a `` molecular '' state until the hyperfine interaction flips again the spin of one of the atoms .
with the motivation above , we propose to study a two - boson species model with an additional conversion term allowing two particles from the first species to turn into one particle of the second species , and vice - versa .
we denote the first species as `` atoms '' , and the second species as ( diatomic ) `` molecules '' .
atoms and molecules can hop onto neighboring sites , interact , and conversion between two atoms and a molecule can occur .
several atoms can reside on the same site , their interaction being described by an on - site repulsion potential . a second on - site
repulsion potential describes the interactions between molecules and atoms being on the same site .
this leads us to consider the following hamiltonian @xmath0 with @xmath1 the @xmath2 , @xmath3 , and @xmath4 operators correspond respectively to the kinetic , potential , and conversion energies .
the @xmath5 and @xmath6 operators ( @xmath7 and @xmath8 ) are the creation and annihilation operators of atoms ( molecules ) on site @xmath9 , and @xmath10 ( @xmath11 counts the number of atoms ( molecules ) on site @xmath9 .
those operators satisfy the usual bosonic commutation rules @xmath12=\delta_{ij}$ ] and @xmath13=\delta_{ij}$ ] . in order to simplify the model and reduce the space of parameters , we impose a hard - core constraint on molecules .
this is done by adding the condition . for a minimal model
, we set a maximum of two atoms per site by imposing .
the sums @xmath14 run over pairs of nearest - neighboring sites @xmath9 and @xmath15 .
we restrict our study to one dimension and we choose the atomic hopping parameter @xmath16 in order to set the energy scale , while we choose the molecular hopping parameter @xmath17 , motivated by the continuous - space behavior of the hopping as a function of the mass ( @xmath18 ) , a molecule being twice heavier than an atom .
smaller values of @xmath19 ( as mapping of experimental systems to bose - hubbard models would suggest @xcite ) are not expected to lead to qualitatively different behavior .
the parameter @xmath20 controls the interaction strength between atoms , and @xmath21 controls the interaction between atoms and molecules .
the conversion between atoms and molecules is controlled by the positive parameter @xmath22 .
this parameter can be related to the `` hyperfine interaction '' parameter in the feshbach resonance picture @xcite .
finally , the parameter @xmath23 acts as a chemical potential for molecules , and allows to tune the energy difference between atomic and molecular states .
this parameter can be related to the `` detuning '' in the feshbach resonance example . in the remainder of the paper we will not expand on the connection to the feshbach resonance problem , nor attempt to reproduce feshbach resonance physics .
we concentrate on taking the model given in ( [ hamiltonian])([conversion ] ) at face value and determining its phase diagram .
a similar model for the one - dimensional continuum has been analysed in ref @xcite , and for optical lattices in the mean field approximation @xcite .
it is important to note that the hamitonian ( [ hamiltonian ] ) does not conserve the number of atoms @xmath24 , nor the number of molecules @xmath25 , because of the conversion term ( [ conversion ] ) .
however we consider that a molecule is made of two particles , so the total number of particles @xmath26 in the system is conserved : @xmath27
in order to make the model suitable for simulations , we perform a mapping of the hamiltonian describing two species of bosons on a 1d lattice ( [ hamiltonian ] ) onto a hamiltonian describing single species of bosons evolving on a ladder ( fig .
[ mapping ] ) . in the 1d space ,
the two species live together .
they can hop onto neighboring sites , and the interaction between the two species is described by an on - site potential @xmath21 .
the conversion between the two species occurs on a single site . in the ladder space ,
the atoms ( molecules ) live on the top ( bottom ) side of the ladder .
the interaction between the two species is described by a potential @xmath21 acting between vertical neighboring sites .
two atoms living on the same atomic site can be destroyed at the same time , with the creation of a molecule on the corresponding molecular site ( and vice - versa ) .
quantum monte carlo simulations are performed for the ladder model by making use of the world line algorithm @xcite .
it is essential to emphasize that this algorithm works in the canonical ensemble , meaning here that the total number of particles @xmath28 is conserved .
indeed , simulations using a grand canonical algorithm ( stochastic series expansion ) @xcite turned out to be difficult to handle , because it is numerically very hard to control the number of particles of each species using two chemical potentials , the number of particles of each species depending on both chemical potentials . defining the continuous product of evolution operators in imaginary time , @xmath29
one starts by writing the partition function as the trace of the evolution operator @xmath30 @xmath31 using the occupation number representation for the states @xmath32 .
then we use the so - called `` checkerboard decomposition '' for the hamiltonian , @xmath33 , with @xmath34 where @xmath35 and @xmath36 are defined by @xmath37 \\ \nonumber & + & u_{am}\big(\hat n_i^a \hat n_i^m+\hat n_{i+1}^a \hat n_{i+1}^m\big ) \\
\nonumber & + & d\big(\hat n_i^m+\hat n_{i+1}^m\big ) \\
\label{sign } \hat c_i & = & -g\big(m_i^\dagger a_i^{\phantom\dagger } a_i^{\phantom\dagger}+a_i^\dagger a_i^\dagger m_i^{\phantom\dagger}\big ) \\
\nonumber & - & g\big(m_{i+1}^\dagger a_{i+1}^{\phantom\dagger } a_{i+1}^{\phantom\dagger}+a_{i+1}^\dagger a_{i+1}^\dagger m_{i+1}^{\phantom\dagger}\big).\end{aligned}\ ] ] we attract here the attention of the reader to eq.[sign ] , in which we have added a minus sign to the conversion term .
the energy of the model is independent of the sign in ( [ sign ] ) , so ( [ sign ] ) and ( [ conversion ] ) are equivalent .
this can be seen by realizing that flipping the sign of the conversion term just results in a redefinition of the phase of the molecular creation and annihilation operators , @xmath38 and @xmath39 .
we work with a minus sign in ( [ sign ] ) in order to ensure that all matrix elements @xmath40 are positive . those positive matrix elements normalized by @xmath41 define the probability of transition from the state @xmath42 to the state @xmath43 , which is required for a monte carlo sampling .
it is important to note that @xmath44 and @xmath45 are written each as a sum of operators @xmath46 that commute ( but @xmath44 and @xmath45 do not commute ) . using the trotter - suzuki formula at second order , @xmath47 and using properties of the trace
we get @xmath48 the error due to the trotter - suzuki decomposition vanishes because of the continuous product making @xmath49 going to zero ( in the case of a discrete product the trotter error becomes @xmath50 instead of @xmath51 , due to the accumulation of errors in the product ) . introducing complete sets of states
@xmath52 between each pair of exponentials leads to @xmath53_0^\beta } \prod_{0\to\beta}^{d\tau } \left\langle\psi(\tau\!\!+\!\!d\tau)\right|e^{-d\tau\hat h_e}\left|\psi(\tau\!\!+\!\!d\tau/2)\right\rangle \\
\nonumber \!\!\ ! \times \left\langle\psi(\tau\!\!+\!\!d\tau/2)\right|e^{-d\tau\hat h_o}\left|\psi(\tau)\right\rangle,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the sum runs over all sets of states @xmath54 for all values of @xmath55 in @xmath56 $ ] . finally , each operator @xmath57 and @xmath58 is a product of independent four - site operators @xmath59 ( 2 sites @xmath9 and @xmath60 in the atomic space and 2 sites in the molecular space ) . with the hard - core constraint on molecules and a maximum of two atoms per site ,
the size of the hilbert space of the four - site problem is 36 .
thus each matrix element in ( [ partition ] ) can be computed by evaluating numerically @xmath61 matrices . as a result
, the quantum problem has been mapped onto a classical problem with an extra imaginary time dimension , and the algorithm consists in generating configurations of states @xmath54 using standard classical monte carlo techniques . for more details , see references @xcite .
in addition to the atomic and molecular densities , @xmath62 we also define the total density @xmath63 by analogy with ( [ totalnumber ] ) , where @xmath64 is the number of sites in the lattice . in order to identify insulating phases , it is useful to look at the behavior of the total density @xmath65 as a function of the chemical potential @xmath66
. it is common to define the chemical potential in the canonical ensemble at zero temperature by the energy cost to add one particle to the system , .
however , for our present model , it is better to define it by the energy cost to add successively 2 particles to the system divided by 2 , @xmath67 indeed , this allows to keep an even total number of particles , preventing an extra single particle to be out of the atoms / molecules conversion process .
another quantity of interest for the characterization of a phase is the superfluid density .
an easy way to access this quantity is to make use of pollock and ceperley s formula @xcite that relates the superfluid density to the fluctuations of the winding number @xmath68 , @xmath69 , where @xmath70 is the hopping of the considered species , @xmath71 the inverse temperature , and @xmath64 the number of lattice sites .
usually , this winding number @xmath68 is perfectly well - defined for systems with @xmath72 species of particles . for a given configuration
, it is defined by the number of times that the world lines cross the boundaries of the system from the left to the right , minus the number of times they cross the boundaries from the right to the left ( fig . [ mixturewinding]a ) .
but in our case , the atomic and molecular windings , @xmath73 and @xmath74 , are ill - defined because the world lines associated to each of the species may be discontinous if conversions between atoms and molecules occur ( fig .
[ mixturewinding]b ) .
it is then no longer possible to determine whether a particle is flowing to the right or to the left as a function of imaginary time .
however we can define atomic and molecular pseudo - windings , @xmath75 and @xmath76 , by the number of right jumps minus the number of left jumps , normalized by the number of sites @xmath64 .
non - zero values of such pseudo - windings are signatures of superfluidity of the particles . when no conversion between atoms and molecules occurs , the definition of pseudo - winding coincides with that of true winding .
in addition , the _ correlated _ winding is well - defined for the mixture of particles , @xmath77 because the composite atomic and molecular world lines are continuous ( if one considers that a molecular world line represents two atomic world lines ) .
this correlated winding is relevant for the superfluid density of the mixture because it corresponds to the winding of particles , without looking at their individual nature ( atom or molecule ) .
it is also interesting to consider the _ anti - correlated _ winding , @xmath78 which allows to determine if atoms and molecules are flowing in opposite directions or not .
the definitions of correlated winding ( [ correlatedwinding ] ) and anti - correlated winding ( [ anticorrelatedwinding ] ) are similar to those used in bose - fermi mixtures @xcite .
it is useful to start the investigation of the model by considering first the one - site problem with a total number of particles @xmath79 ( @xmath80 ) .
figure [ rhovsg1 ] shows the atomic and molecular densities as functions of the conversion parameter @xmath22 and different values of the detuning @xmath23 for @xmath81 ( the value of @xmath21 does not play any role since there is only 2 atoms or 1 molecule ) . for @xmath82 and small @xmath22 , the 2 particles are mainly bound in the molecular state , because the creation of the molecule has a vanishing energy cost while having 2 atoms costs @xmath83 . as @xmath22 increases
, it becomes energetically favorable to make conversions atoms / molecule , so the atomic density starts to grow , reducing the molecular density .
when @xmath22 is large , the system maximizes the conversion process .
thus the system is in the molecular state with 1 molecule half of the time , and in the atomic state with 2 atoms the rest of the time . as a result
, the atomic and molecular densities converge to and . for @xmath84
the same behavior holds , but the molecular density decreases faster to the large @xmath22 limit because the energy associated to the molecular state is higher and closer to that of the atomic state .
for @xmath85 we have the inverse behavior , the molecular density increases with @xmath22 and the atomic density decreases , because it is now cheaper energetically to have 2 atoms rather than 1 molecule .
the transition point between those two cases is @xmath86 for which the atomic state has exactly the same energy as the molecular state .
those states have the same probability , and varying @xmath22 just changes the rate of conversion between them .
thus the expectation values of the atomic and molecular densities do not depend on the value of @xmath22 , and remain equal to the values that optimize the conversion process : @xmath87 and @xmath88 . for differents values of the detuning @xmath23 , for @xmath81 .
, scaledwidth=45.0% ] we now turn to the full problem with @xmath64 lattice sites .
we have performed simulations for @xmath89 and determined by extrapolation to @xmath90 that finite size effects associated to the choice of working with lead to errors smaller than our statistical error bars , these latter being smaller than the size of the symbols displayed in the figures of this paper ( unless otherwise stated ) . in the same manner
, we have determined that using @xmath91 allows to get the physics relevant to the ground state ( @xmath92 ) , for the measured quantities . as for the one - site problem
, we start by looking at the atomic and molecular densities as functions of @xmath22 , for different values of the detuning @xmath23 , with @xmath81 , @xmath93 , and @xmath80 ( fig .
[ rhovsg2 ] ) .
we can see that going from @xmath94 to @xmath95 ( equivalent to turning on the hopping parameters @xmath96 and @xmath19 ) just leads to small differences at small @xmath22 . for large @xmath22
the hopping can be neglected , and results for @xmath95 converge to those for @xmath94 .
nevertheless it is crucial to keep working with the full lattice problem instead of the one - site problem , since this is required to access global quantities such as the superfluid density .
it is also the only way to get results for nearly - continuous values of @xmath65 . and
different values of the detuning @xmath23 , for @xmath81 , @xmath93 , and total density of particles @xmath80 .
, scaledwidth=45.0% ] a completely different behavior occurs when considering a non - commensurate density , for instance @xmath97 ( fig .
[ rhovsg3 ] ) .
we consider here the case @xmath98 for simplicity .
for this density , atoms can be placed on the lattice without increasing the interaction energy .
the same holds for the molecules if @xmath99 .
but for small @xmath22 and @xmath100 it is energetically more favorable to have atoms only , because 2 atoms have kinetic energy 4 times more negative than 1 molecule ( @xmath101 ) . as a result
the molecular density is vanishing for @xmath102 and @xmath103 and grows when turning on @xmath22 , until reaching the optimal density for large @xmath22 , , in contrast to fig .
[ rhovsg2 ] , where for @xmath104 the density @xmath105 decreases with increasing @xmath22 .
the atomic density follows the inverse behavior , starts for and converges to the optimal value , . at different values of the detuning @xmath23 .
@xmath81 , @xmath93 , and total density of particles @xmath97 .
, scaledwidth=45.0% ] having analyzed the system for two specific values of the total density , it is now interesting to perfom a scan of all values of @xmath65 .
figure [ rhovsrho ] shows the atomic and molecular densities as functions of the total density @xmath65 . at low filling
, the particles are dilute and the on - site repulsion between atoms prevent double occupancies , so no binding between atoms can occur and the number of molecules remains zero for all values of @xmath23 considered .
thus the atomic density increases linearly with the total density . as the filling increases , double occupancies occur leading to the creation of molecules , and decreasing the atomic density . increasing the filling further leads to an `` inversion of population '' where the number of molecules is greater than the number of atoms .
this inversion of population is optimal at @xmath80 for the chosen parameters because double atomic occupancies have an energy cost of @xmath83 , whereas the creation of a molecule has an energy cost of @xmath23 .
adding more particles to the system produces a saturation of molecules , and extra atoms just see a constant potential . at different values of the detuning @xmath23 .
@xmath81 , @xmath93 , and @xmath106 .
, scaledwidth=45.0% ] in order to identify incompressible phases , it is useful to look at behavior of @xmath107 for different values of @xmath23 and @xmath22 ( fig . [ rhovsmu ] ) .
let us recall that the slope of this curve , @xmath108 , is proportional to the isothermal compressibility @xmath109 .
thus each horizontal plateau indicates an incompressible mott phase .
this does not imply that this phase is insulating , as will be shown below . for @xmath110 or @xmath82 and small conversion @xmath106
one can identify two incompressible phases by the presence of mott plateaus at @xmath80 and @xmath111 .
for those parameters the usual mott plateau occuring in pure bosonic systems at @xmath112 is absent .
this is because extra particles can be added beyond @xmath112 without the need of creating double occupancies , by converting atoms into molecules . for @xmath80 ,
the phase is incompressible because any site is occupied by a molecule . thus adding an extra atom requires the formation of an atom / molecule pair , which has an energy cost of @xmath21 . for @xmath111 , each site
is occupied with an atom / molecule pair , and adding extra atoms leads to double occupancies with energy costs of @xmath20 .
thus the phase is also incompressible . for @xmath84 and @xmath106
, we recover a mott plateau at @xmath112 because creating a molecule has an energy cost of @xmath23 that can not be overcome by the associated negative kinetic and conversion energies . for large @xmath22
however , the mott plateaus at @xmath112 and @xmath111 disappear .
indeed , in this regime the conversions between atoms and molecules occur and overcome the energy cost of having two atoms on a single site , as well as the energy cost of creating a molecule
. thus extra atoms at @xmath112 and @xmath111 can go either into a molecule or doubly occupied sites , without changing the energy by a value greater than the finite - size - lattice gap , which vanishes in the thermodynamic limit .
however @xmath80 is still incompressible because any site is occupied either by two atoms or by a molecule .
thus an extra atom can go only on a site occupied by a molecule , leading to an energy cost of @xmath21 .
moreover a conversion process can no longer take place on this site , and the system has to pay the price of having a molecule all the time with the associated chemical potential @xmath23 .
this explains the large width of the corresponding mott plateau : approximately @xmath113 . and
@xmath22 , for @xmath81 , and @xmath93 .
the slope of these curves is proportional to the isothermal compressibility , and horizontal plateaus indicate phases that are incompressible but not necessarily insulating ( see text ) . ,
scaledwidth=45.0% ] we now study the potential superfluidity of the mixture by analysing the fluctuations of the atomic and molecular pseudo windings @xmath114 and @xmath115 , and the correlated and anti - correlated windings @xmath116 and @xmath117 ( fig . [ windingvsrho ] ) , defined in section iv . to discuss the results ,
it is useful to consider the corresponding curve in fig .
[ rhovsmu ] ( @xmath84 , @xmath106 ; green curve ) . for @xmath112 and @xmath111 all windings and pseudo windings vanish , showing that the system is frozen for those densities .
the corresponding phases are mott insulators .
however for @xmath80 only the correlated winding vanishes , meaning that there is no global flow of particles , regardless of being atoms or molecules .
but individual species are flowing , each in the opposite direction of the other , leading to a large value of the anti - correlated winding .
the phase is incompressible like a mott insulator , but a supercurrent occurs for each of the species .
we will refer to this phase as `` super - mott '' .
we show in the following that this phase extends deep into the large-@xmath22 region of the phase diagram . , @xmath93 , @xmath106 , and @xmath84 .
error bars of the order of the symbol sizes . , scaledwidth=45.0% ] finally , by reproducing fig.[rhovsmu ] for different sets of parameters @xmath22 and @xmath23 we are able to draw two phase diagrams , one in the @xmath118-plane ( fig .
[ phasediagramvsg ] ) and one in the @xmath119-plane ( fig .
[ phasediagramvsd ] ) .
we can identify the three incompressible phases discussed above , namely two mott phases for @xmath112 and @xmath111 , and the super - mott phase for @xmath80 .
those phases extend over regions of the phase diagram separated by superfluid regions . for small @xmath22 ,
all incompressible phases are present . as @xmath22 increases
, the super - mott phase takes over the two mott phases ( fig .
[ phasediagramvsg ] ) . for small or negative @xmath23
the super - mott phase takes over the @xmath112 mott phase , whereas for large @xmath23 it is the @xmath111 mott phase which yields to the super - mott phase ( fig .
[ phasediagramvsd ] ) . plane , for @xmath81 , @xmath93 , and @xmath84 . ,
scaledwidth=45.0% ] plane , for @xmath81 , @xmath93 , and @xmath106 .
, scaledwidth=45.0% ]
we have studied a two - species bose - hubbard model including a conversion term between the two species .
our model can be of interest for ultracold atom experiments using feshbach resonances .
the competition between the kinetic , potential , and conversion terms leads to rich phase diagrams .
we have shown that increasing the number of particles of the first species can lead to an inversion of population , resulting in the number of molecules greater than the number of atoms .
in addition to the usual superfluid and mott phases occuring in boson models , we have identified an exotic `` super - mott '' phase , characterized by a vanishing compressibility and a superflow of both species but with anticorrelations such that there is no global supercurrent . finally , we have produced two phase diagrams as a potential guide to detect the exotic super - mott phase .
since the super - mott phase occupies a big part of the phase diagrams , we expect it to be observable in experiments .
we are currently investigating the model using a newly developed algorithm @xcite that provides access to green functions and momentum distribution functions , which can be measured in experiments .
this will allow a direct comparison between theory and experiments .
this work is part of the research program of the stichting voor fundamenteel onderzoek der materie ( fom) , which is financially supported by the nederlandse organisatie voor wetenschappelijk onderzoek ( nwo). we would like to thank a. parson for his project .
10 m.p.a .
fisher , p.b .
weichman , g. grinstein , and d.s .
fisher , phys .
b * 40 * , 546 ( 1989 ) .
d. jaksch , c. bruder , j.i .
cirac , c.w .
gardiner , and p. zoller , phys .
81 * , 3108 ( 1998 ) .
h. ott , e. de mirandes , f. ferlaino , g. roati , g. modugno , and m. inguscio , phys .
lett . * 92 * , 160601 ( 2004 ) .
k. gnter , t. stferle , h. moritz , m. khl , t. esslinger , phys .
lett . * 96 * , 180402 ( 2006 ) .
s. ospelkaus , c. ospelkaus , l. humbert , k. sengstock , and k. bongs , phys . rev
. lett . * 97 * , 120403 ( 2006 ) .
l. pollet , m. troyer , k. van houcke , and s.m.a .
rombouts , phys .
96 * , 190402 ( 2006 ) .
p. sengupta and l.p .
pryadko , phys .
b * 75 * , 132507 ( 2007 ) .
f. hbert , f. haudin , l. pollet , and g.g .
batrouni , phys .
a * 76 * , 043619 ( 2007 ) .
e. timmermans , p. tommasini , m. hussein , and a. kerman , physics reports * 315 * , 199 ( 1999 ) .
dickerscheid , u. al khawaja , d. van oosten , and h.t.c .
stoof , phys .
a * 71 * , 043604 ( 2005 ) .
v. gurarie , phys .
a * 73 * , 033612 ( 2006 ) .
k. sengupta and n. dupuis , europhys . lett . *
70 * , 586 ( 2005 ) .
batrouni , r.t .
scalettar , and g.t .
zimanyi , phys .
* 65 * , 176 ( 1990 ) .
batrouni and r.t .
scalettar , phys .
b * 46 * , 9051 ( 1992 )
sandvik , j. phys .
a * 25 * , 3667 ( 1992 ) ; phys .
b * 59 * , r14 157 ( 1999 ) .
rousseau , r.t .
scalettar , and g.g .
batrouni , phys .
b * 72 * , 054524 ( 2005 ) .
pollock , and d.m .
ceperley , phys .
b * 36 * , 8343 ( 1987 ) . v.g . rousseau , arxiv:0711.3839 | we investigate the phase diagram of a two - species bose - hubbard model including a conversion term , by which two particles from the first species can be converted into one particle of the second species , and vice - versa .
the model can be related to ultracold atom experiments in which a feshbach resonance produces long - lived bound states viewed as diatomic molecules .
the model is solved exactly by means of quantum monte carlo simulations .
we show that an `` inversion of population '' occurs , depending on the parameters , where the second species becomes more numerous than the first species .
the model also exhibits an exotic incompressible `` super - mott '' phase where the particles from both species can flow with signs of superfluidity , but without global supercurrent .
we present two phase diagrams , one in the ( chemical potential , conversion)-plane , the other in the ( chemical potential , detuning)-plane . |
planetary nebulae ( pne ) these magnificent cosmic bubbles that light up the universe in a colourful way @xcite are generally considered to be the swan song of low- and intermediate - mass ( i.e. 1 to 8 m@xmath0 ) stars , before becoming white dwarfs . as such
, the central stars of pne ( cspne ) are the precursors of white dwarfs and their study provides us with the initial conditions to study the latter .
they therefore fully deserve to be part of a workshop dedicated to white dwarfs . the classical scenario to form a pn is as follow : at the end of the asymptotic giant branch ( agb ) , the star has lost most of its envelope ( and thus its mass ) through a slow but fierce wind and the hot central star is being exposed .
the latter is also undergoing mass loss through a fast , hot wind , which drags along the left - over material of the agb envelope in a narrow shell , which is then ionised by the hot star .
this scenario known as the interacting wind model @xcite should produce a spherical pn . and
indeed , the original and misleading name of this class of object , _ planetary _ nebula , arose because of the roundish aspect of the earliest members discovered .
however , with better telescopes , it has soon become clear that a great majority of pne are not spherical .
many are ellipticals or bipolars , with some presenting clear jet - like structures and/or `` ansae '' , while others even appear multipolars @xcite . as such , planetary nebulae with their intricate and vivid shapes are amazing treats for the eye , but also treasures for the mind , as one need to explain how a spherical star leads to such non - spherical nebulae .
this is a critical question , whose corollary can be formulated as _
`` are we sure that all ( or at least most ) white dwarfs go through a pn stage or is there a need to have something else to make a pn ? '' _
i am of the opinion that , after several decades of debate , it is now safe to assert that the origin of the non - spherical , axisymmetric morphology of pne lies in the presence of a ( sub-)stellar companion @xcite .
this has led to the so - called _ binary hypothesis _ for pne ( * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* see also paczynski 1985 ) .
its weak variant asserts that `` pne derive from binary progenitors more easily than from single progenitor '' , where `` binary '' should be understood here in a general term , i.e. the central star may have a star , a brown dwarf or even a giant planet as a companion . the number of non - spherical pne amounts to at least 80% @xcite .
can we explain such a high fraction ?
recent surveys ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) indicate that the fraction of binaries among solar - like stars is about 50% , but given that one should ignore all systems with a separation greater than , say , 200 au ( as these are likely not really interacting binaries ) , this fraction becomes 30% .
this value includes brown dwarfs .
the same authors find that @xmath1% of single stars have a planet , so that in total , one can account for @xmath240% of all stars to have at least a companion , stellar or substellar , with which to interact .
in addition , one should note that even if the object now appears single , it does not mean it was not a binary at first , as some objects will go through a merger phase @xcite .
thus , from these arguments alone , it appears that one can explain the binary ( and , by extension , the non - spherical morphology ) of at least 40% of all pne .
the fact that we _ apparently _ see a fraction of such aspherical pne twice as large may be due to the existence of a population of `` hidden '' , low - surface brightness , spherical pne @xcite .
the fraction of these hidden pne should be between 0 and 50% of all pne , depending on the number of mergers , in order not to need the binary hypothesis .
whether such a population exist is still not clear and no conclusion can yet be drawn at this time , except for the fact that the morphology of many pne is clearly influenced by a companion .
this latter point is certainly proven by the fact that there is now a handful of pne with binary central stars for which it was possible to reliably compare the inclinations of both binary orbital plane and nebular symmetry axis , and in all cases , these two angles were similar @xcite .
the conclusion is inescapably that the central binary is the cause of the shaping of the nebula .
an agb star in a binary system will , unless the system is really very wide , interact in some way with its companion .
it will transfer mass by wind @xcite and , if the orbital period is smaller than some limiting value , it will overflow its roche lobe , a process that will generally lead to a common envelope and a spiral - in of the companion @xcite
. the final orbit will be very tight , with an orbital period in the range of a few hours to a few days . in this case ,
the envelope which is ejected is the nebula that will be ionised by the white dwarf .
@xcite found that the close binary fraction , i.e. the faction of binary cspne with orbital period below about 3 days , is about 1221% .
this value may be slightly underestimating the real close binary fraction due to observational biases , as the photometric method they use will only pick binaries ( recognised in the light curves through eclipses , irradiation or elongation effects ) if the signal is strong enough , which depends on the time sampling , the inclination of the system , the relative brightness of the nebula and the orbital period .
it should , however , provide a good first estimate .
one can do a rough calculations to see if such a value is compatible with what we know about binary stars .
if we take as a rough estimate that the maximum radius an agb star can reach is about 1000 r@xmath0 , we can estimate that all systems with a period below about 2130 years ( @xmath3 ) depending on the total mass of the system and the mass ratio will lead to a common envelope and thus to a short period binary system .
@xcite determined the distribution of orbital periods for solar - like binaries and found that it could be approximated as a gaussian ( in logarithm of the period when expressed in days ) , centred around 4.8 and with a standard deviation of 2.3 .
the more recent study of @xcite finds similar results , i.e. a gaussian , centred around 5.03 and with a standard deviation of 2.28 . using these last numbers , this implies that about 30 to 32% of all solar - like binary systems would go through a common envelope phase .
taking into account the 50% fraction of binaries for solar - like stars , we obtain a close binary fraction of 1516% , not unlike what is observed .
this may also be a lower limit , however , as systems with initially longer periods may also shrink during the wind mass transfer episodes that will precede @xcite .
of course , this back - of - the - envelope calculation should be confirmed by detailed population synthesis estimates , but it already provides some good reason to think that the close binary fraction does not require the pn binary hypothesis to be valid .
this , is turn , would imply the existence of a huge population of hidden , spherical pne . in this respect
, it is useful to note that @xcite found that 35% of all white dwarf - main sequence ( wd - ms ) binaries are post - ce systems , in agreement with the rough calculation made above .
in the last few years , the number of close binary cspne ( i.e. post - ce ) has dramatically increased from the dozen known at the turn of the 21st century @xcite .
dave jones is collecting the list of all planetary nebulae with binary central stars and at the time of writing there are now 50 post - ce pne known and for which an orbital period has been determined .
thus , in addition to providing useful information on the role of binarity in the shaping and , possibly , formation of pne , these binary cspne can be very useful to study binary populations in general , as binary cspne can be thought of as `` fresh out of the oven '' .
this is particularly true for post - ce systems and their study should increase our knowledge on the poorly - constrained common envelope process . in particular , the distribution of orbital periods of post - ce cspne ( fig .
[ hb_fig1 ] ) should be a necessary tool to constrain models .
the availability of 50 systems allows already to have a sizeable sample that can be compared to the outcome of binary populations as well as to other post - ce samples . in this regard ,
it is noteworthy that the observed period distribution drops dramatically for orbital periods above 1 day .
this could partly be due to observational biases , but could as well indicate that the energy efficiency parameter , @xmath4 , should be much smaller than unity @xcite . the difference with the sample of wd+ms from the sdss survey @xcite may also indicate some fundamental issues in the formation of post - ce pne .
post - ce pne allow us also to study the process of mass transfer .
the presence of collimated outflows or jets surrounding several systems ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) possibly launched from an accretion disc that is no longer present is most likely indirect evidence for accretion , either prior to the common envelope phase via wind accretion from the agb primary , during the start of the ce infall phase or perhaps even after the ce phase .
observations indicate the jets were probably ejected before the main nebula @xcite .
another fundamental clue comes from point - symmetric outflows of pne .
simulations can recreate these complex outflows with a precessing accretion disc around the secondary launching jets , with fleming 1 @xcite being certainly the prototype .
the characteristics of fleming 1 indicate that wind accretion ( with the formation of a disc ) must have happened _ before _ a ce episode .
more convincing still is the detection by @xcite of a carbon dwarf secondary in the post - ce central star binary in the necklace planetary nebula . to reproduce the observed carbon enhancement , one need to accrete between 0.03 and 0.35 m@xmath0 , depending on the mass of the star , in a binary system with initial orbital period between 500 and 2000 days .
the current period of the system , 1.16 d , clearly proves that the system underwent a common - envelope phase .
the most advanced simulations of the spiral - in part of the ce phase predict a negligible amount of mass accretion , @xmath5 m@xmath0 ( see references in * ? ? ?
the accretion is therefore most likely to have occurred before the ce phase via wind accretion , a process that simulations predict to form an accretion disc around the companion .
since the jets of the necklace are also observed to be older than the main pn , they were probably launched from such a disc .
balick , b. , & frank , a. 2002 , ara&a , 40 , 439 boffin h.m.j . , miszalski b. , rauch t. et al . , 2012 , science 338 , 773 boffin h. m. j. , jones d. , beletsky y. et al . , 2012 , the messenger , 148 , 25 boffin h.m.j
, 2015 , to appear in ecology of blue straggler stars , h.m.j .
boffin , g. carraro & g. beccari ( eds . ) , astrophysics and space science library , springer ; arxiv:1406.3473 bond h. e. , 2000 , in kastner j. h. , soker n. , rappaport s. , eds , asp conf . ser . , vol .
199 , asymmetrical planetary nebulae iii : from origins to microstructures .
, san francisco , p. 115 de marco o. , 2009 , pasp , 121 , 316 duquennoy a. , mayor m. , 1991 , a&a , 248 , 485 ivanova n. , 2015 , to appear in ecology of blue straggler stars , h.m.j .
boffin , g. carraro & g. beccari ( eds . ) , astrophysics and space science library , springer ; arxiv:1406.3475 jones d. , santander - garcia m. , boffin h.m.j . , miszalski b. , & corradi r.l.m . , 2014 , in asymmetrical planetary nebulae vi conference , c. morisset , g. delgado - inglada and s. torres - peimbert ( eds . ) kwok s. , purton c.r . , fitzgerald p.m. , 1978 , apj , 219 , l125 miszalski b. , acker a. , moffat a.f.j . , parker q.a . , udalski a. , 2009 , a&a , 496 , 813 miszalski b. , boffin h.m.j . , corradi r.l.m . , 2013 , mnras 428 , l39 moe m. , de marco o. , 2006 , apj , 650 , 916 nandez , j. l. a. , ivanova , n. , & lombardi , j. c. , jr .
2014 , apj , 786 , 39 nie j.d . ,
, nicholls c.p . , 2012 , mnras , 423 , 2764 nordhaus j. , blackman e. g. , 2006 , mnras , 370 , 2004 paczynski b. , 1985 , in cataclysmic variables and low - mass x - ray binaries , dordrecht , d. reidel publishing co. , p. 1
raghavan d. , mcalister h.a .
, henry t.j .
et al . , 2010 ,
apjs 190 , 1 rebassa - mansergas a. , nebot gmez - morn a. , schreiber m. r. et al .
, 2012 , mnras , 419 , 806 schreiber m.r .
, gnsicke b.t . , southworth j. , schwope a.d . , koester d. , 2008 , a&a , 484 , 441 soker n. , 1997 , apjs 112 , 487 webbink r. f. , 1976 , apj , 209 , 829 + | binarity and mass transfer appear to play a key role in the shaping and , possibly , formation of planetary nebulae ( pne ) , thereby explaining the large fraction of axisymmetric morphologies .
i present the binary hypothesis for pne and its current status .
recent discoveries have led to a quadrupling of the number of post - common envelope binary central stars of pne compared to the end of the last century , thereby allowing us to envisage statistical studies . moreover
, these binary systems let us study in detail the mass transfer episodes before and after the common envelope , and i present the evidences for mass transfer and accretion prior to the common envelope phase . |
the detection of photons emitted by an extrasolar planet is a landmark feat in the history of astronomy .
ten years after the initial discovery of the first extrasolar giant planet ( egp ) 51 peg b @xcite , @xcite report a dectection of infrared flux from tres-1 and @xcite report a similar detection for hd209458b .
both observations were made with the _
spitzer space telescope _ as each planet passed behind its parent star . while a number of papers have aimed at predicting the optical and infrared spectra of hot egps @xcite , these results are the first infrared detections ( rather than upper limits ) that can be compared with models .
tres-1 , discovered by @xcite , is similar to the well - known planet hd209458b
@xcite in mass and orbital period but it receives less stellar irradiation and has a significantly smaller radius .
@xcite and @xcite have recently placed tighter constraints on the planet s mass and radius by improving our knowledge of the physical parameters of the parent star .
tres-1 and hd209458b are members of the class of `` pegasi planets '' ( or `` hot jupiters '' ) that orbit their parent stars at less than @xmath3 0.1 au and are presumed to be tidally locked . unlike brown dwarfs of similar effective temperature , the luminosity of pegasi planets is dominated by absorbed and re - radiated stellar flux , rather than intrinsic luminosity due to cooling of its interior .
atmospheric dynamics will redistribute this absorbed energy around the planet with an efficiency that is currently unknown @xcite . because of the dominance of absorbed flux over intrinsic flux , the planet s effective temperature @xmath4 , is equal to its equilibrium temperature , @xmath5 , given by : @xmath6 where @xmath7 is 1 if the absorbed radiation is able to be radiated away over the entire planet ( @xmath8 steradians ) or 2 if it only radiates on the day side ( @xmath9 steradians ) .
@xmath10 is the planet s bond albedo , @xmath11 is the luminosity of the star , @xmath2 is the stefan - boltzmann constant , and @xmath12 is the planet s orbital distance .
@xcite used the infrared array camera ( irac ) aboard _ spitzer _ to observe the emission of the combined tres-1 planet / star system .
the timing of the observations included time before , during , and after the secondary eclipse ( when the planet s light is blocked by the star ) .
the observations were performed simultaneously in bands 2 and 4 , centered on 4.5 and 8.0 @xmath0 m , respectively .
the planet+star system was indeed brighter in both bands when the planet was visible , indicating thermal emission from the planet was detected .
the observed eclipse depths , in units of relative flux , were 0.00066 @xmath13 0.00013 at 4.5 @xmath0 m and 0.00225 @xmath13 0.00036 at 8.0 @xmath0 m .
the hd209458b observations by @xcite utilized this same method , except that their observation used the multiband imaging photometer for spitzer ( mips ) instrument at 24 @xmath0 m .
the observed flux ratio was 0.00260 @xmath13 0.00046 . from their observations
@xcite derived brightness temperatures in each of the two bands , @xmath14 k and @xmath15 k. it is important to notice that @xmath16 , which was not predicted by models of pegasi planets cited above , nor for brown dwarfs of similar @xmath4 @xcite , nor is it observed in the mid infrared spectra of brown dwarfs to date @xcite .
@xcite also derive a planetary @xmath17 k and @xmath18 , but as the planet is not a blackbody , the values found are only suggestive . for hd209458b , @xcite determine a brightness temperature @xmath19 k.
to obtain our atmospheric pressure - temperature ( _ p - t _ ) profiles and spectra for the planets we employ a 1d model atmosphere code that has been used for a variety of planetary and substellar objects .
the code was first used to generate profiles and spectra for titan by @xcite .
it was significantly revised to model the atmospheres of brown dwarfs @xcite , uranus @xcite , and egps @xcite .
it explicitly includes both incident radiation from the parent star and thermal radiation from the planet s atmosphere .
the basic radiative transfer solving scheme was developed by @xcite .
we use the elemental abundance data of @xcite and compute chemical equilibrium compositions following @xcite and @xcite .
in addition we maintain a large and constantly updated opacity database .
we predict all cloud properties using the model of @xcite with a sedimentation efficiency parameter @xmath20 , which fits spectral observations of cloudy l - dwarfs @xcite .
this model places 90% of the optical depth of a cloud within 1 scale height of the cloud base .
further details can be found in @xcite and marley et al .
( in prep ) .
we model the impinging stellar flux from 0.26 to 10.0 @xmath0 m and the emitted thermal flux from 0.26 to 325 @xmath0 m .
all the relevant planetary parameters for tres-1 are taken from @xcite .
those for hd209458b are taken from @xcite .
for the tres-1 stellar model we use the kurucz k0v model atmosphere computed for the @xcite paper . for hd209458b
we use a @xcite g0v model ( l@xmath21l@xmath22 ) with parameters described in @xcite .
the planet s radiative - convective _ p - t _ profile is arrived at iteratively until the net flux is conserved to at least one part in @xmath23 .
we compute all band - averaged flux density ratios using eq .
( 1 ) from @xcite .
our model atmosphere code computes the _ p - t _ profile and low resolution spectra covering our full wavelength range . to generate a high - resolution spectrum we take
the generated _ p - t _ profile and use a full line - by - line radiative transfer code , using the same chemistry and opacity database used in determining the _ p - t _ profile and low - resolution spectrum @xcite .
our computed atmosphere profiles are shown in .
two cloudless profiles for tres-1 are shown , one under the assumption that absorbed stellar radiation is reradiated from the entire planet , and one for the assumption that the planet can only reradiate this energy on the day side . for these cases
we derive a @xmath4 of 1134 k and 1352 k , respectively .
both of these profiles assume solar metallicity and an intrinsic temperature , @xmath24 of 250 k. this @xmath24 is the @xmath4 the planet would have if it were in isolation . for the @xmath8 case we also plot a profile for @xmath25 k , which leads to a deeper radiative zone , but has no effect on the emitted spectrum .
the presence of an outer radiative zone is predicted for the atmospheres of all pegasi planets and is a caused by the dominance of external ( stellar ) radiation over internal heat flux @xcite .
the planet s
current @xmath26 can only be derived from thermal evolution models of the planet , which we do not compute here . for the @xmath8 tres-1 profile
we show the model s range of brightness temperatures in 4.5 and 8.0 @xmath0 m bands .
we also plot our derived _
profile for hd209458b .
this profile assumes @xmath8 reradiation , solar metallicity , and @xmath27 k. for hd209458b we find @xmath28 k , @xmath3 300 k hotter than that for tres-1 . the model s brightness temperature at 24 @xmath0 m is shown as a plus on this profile .
we also plot the boundary where co and ch@xmath29 have the same abundance .
we predict co will be the dominant ( but not exclusive ) carrier of carbon for both planets . also shown
are the condensation curves for na@xmath30s , enstatite ( mgsio@xmath31 ) , forsterite ( mg@xmath30sio@xmath29 ) and iron ( fe ) .
clouds form deep in the atmosphere of tres-1 and therefore have no effect on the planet s spectrum . for hd209458b
, we find that a potential enstatite cloud layer does affect the _ p - t _ profile and spectrum , as shown by the dash - dot profile .
high clouds in the atmosphere of hd209458b are compatible with the available data from atmospheric transmission spectroscopy @xcite , although the clouds in those studies are at mbar pressures .
our profile for hd209458b is very similar to the @xmath8 model of @xcite , although our profiles show hints of stratospheric temperature inversions due to absorption by near infrared water bands , which to our knowledge other authors have not found .
our computed flux ratios for the hd209458b model atmospheres match the @xcite observation well .
we find @xmath32 for a cloudless model or with clouds of iron and forsterite , which is within the 1@xmath2 error bar .
if the silicate cloud is not forsterite , but enstatite , which forms higher in the atmosphere , we find @xmath33 .
models computed assuming 2@xmath34 reradiation would be brighter at 24 @xmath0 m , leading to a poorer fit to the datum . for tres-1
we will examine our model atmospheres in detail .
in we show three panels of results .
panel a shows the surface flux of the model k0v stellar spectrum along with two computed surface fluxes of planet tres-1 .
these spectra are for @xmath9 and @xmath8 reradiation and solar metallicity .
as expected , the @xmath9 spectrum is brighter
. note that between 4 - 10 @xmath0 m we find that emitted planetary flux is @xmath3 7 - 9 orders of magnitude brighter than reflected stellar flux .
the lower two panels of show the planet / star flux ratio , as would be seen by a distant observer , which folds in the factor of @xmath3 60 difference in surface area of the planet and star .
these panels compare our computed ratios to those measured by @xcite . for @xmath9 reradiation
our ratio at 4.5 @xmath0 m is 4.5@xmath2 too high , indicating the planet model is far too luminous at these wavelengths .
however , the fit at 8.0 @xmath0 m is quite good . for the @xmath8 model
, the flux at 4.5 @xmath0 m is a reasonable fit , falling just above 1@xmath2 error bars , while at 8.0 @xmath0 m the model falls below the 2@xmath2 error bar .
both of these models have approximately the same infrared spectral slope , which is obviously not as steep as @xcite observed .
this slope is mainly controlled by h@xmath30o absorption on the blue side of the 4.5 @xmath0 m band and strong co absorption on the red side . at 8.0 @xmath0 m , h@xmath30o and
ch@xmath29 are the dominant absorbers . based on these results , we rule out the 2@xmath34 model and
examine the sensitivity of the spectral slope to model parameters .
our computed brightness temperatures for the @xmath8 models are @xmath35 k and @xmath36 k , while @xcite found @xmath16 . compared to a blackbody
, the planet is redder while the models are bluer .
a flux deficit at 4.5 @xmath0 m , relative to atmosphere models using equilibrium chemistry , is a common feature of jupiter and t dwarfs @xcite .
this is likely due to dredging of co from deeper layers , which absorbs flux from 4.5 - 5 @xmath0 m @xcite .
we find this process can not affect the atmosphere of tres-1 as co is already the dominant carbon - bearing molecule in the planet s atmosphere .
we also varied the metallicity of the planet s atmosphere .
we computed chemistry and opacity grids at metallicities of 3.2 ( [ m / h]=0.5 ) and 5.0 ( [ m / h]=0.7 ) times solar . recall that jupiter s atmosphere is enhanced in heavy elements by factors of @xmath3 2 - 4 . with 3.2@xmath37 or 5@xmath37 solar metallicity
the models fall within the 1@xmath2 error bar at 4.5 @xmath0 m and 2@xmath2 at 8.0 @xmath0 m .
panel c of shows the flux ratios for the 5@xmath37 solar abundance model . increasing the metallicity by 3.2@xmath37 decreases the ch@xmath29/co ratio by an order of magnitude .
( the position of ch@xmath29/co=1 curve varies inversely proportional to the metal / hydrogen ratio . ) this in turn increases the 8.0 @xmath0 m band flux by weakening the strong ch@xmath29 band at 7.8 @xmath0 m . increasing the metallicity also increases the amount of h@xmath30o , which decreases the flux on the blue side of the 4.5 @xmath0 m band .
we also considered whether we could further improve the fit by increasing the c / o ratio from 0.5 ( solar ) to 0.7 , therefore increasing co absorption at 4.5 @xmath0 m and decreasing h@xmath30o absorption at 8.0 @xmath0 m .
however , increasing the c / o ratio ( by increasing the carbon abundance ) _ increases _ the ch@xmath29 abundance relative to co ( and h@xmath30o ) and flux actually decreases in the 8.0 @xmath0 m band . increasing [ m / h ] from 0 to + 0.5 or increasing the c / o ratio from 0.5 to 0.7 has very little effect on the strength of the co band .
this is because the band is formed very high in the atmosphere and is already saturated at solar abundances .
another avenue we pursued was increasing the temperature of the upper atmosphere . in our models the pressures at which optical depth unity occurs in the 8.0 @xmath0 m band are slightly smaller than those in the 4.5 @xmath0 m band , although there is considerable overlap .
( see . ) therefore , increasing the temperatures at lower pressures preferentially increases the @xmath38 relative to @xmath39 .
we deposited additional energy in the form of a chapman function ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , into the upper atmosphere at pressures ranging from 1 to 10 mbar .
possible unmodeled energy sources include conduction downward from a hot thermosphere @xcite , the breaking of gravity waves , or an unmodeled optical absorber , such as photochemical products .
profiles that warm the atmosphere at 10 mbar by @xmath3 200 k ( requiring @xmath3 @xmath40 erg @xmath41 sec@xmath42 , or 2.5% of the incoming stellar flux ) generate more flux in the 8.0@xmath0 m band , and reach the 2@xmath2 error bars in both bands .
reprentative flux ratios of one of these models is shown in panel c of . in another trial ( not shown )
we modeled a strong continuum opacity source from 2 - 6 @xmath0 m .
an appropriately strong absorber cuts down the flux in the 4.5 @xmath0 m band while increasing flux in the 8.0 @xmath0 m band , which allows the model to fit the 1@xmath2 error bars in both bands .
it is unclear what this mystery opacity source could be .
@xcite found that hd209458b should be free of hydrocarbon hazes as atmospheric temperatures are too high for hydrocarbons to condense .
their conclusion should hold for tres-1 , although it is @xmath3 300 k cooler .
we note that the photochemical destruction of ch@xmath29 @xcite would lead to slightly weaker absorption at 8.0 @xmath0 m .
we find that a solar metallicity atmosphere for tres-1 marginally fits the _ spitzer _ observations .
models with enhanced metallicity are promising as they fall within the 1@xmath2 error bar in the 4.5 @xmath0 m band and 2@xmath2 error bar in the 8.0 @xmath0 m band .
solar metallicity models with extra energy deposition into the stratosphere fit at the 2@xmath2 level .
as shows , observations with irac at 3.6 @xmath0 m look most promising for further separating the predictions of standard solar abundance models from others . for the model phase space
we explore it is extremely difficult to obtain brightness temperatures of @xmath16 .
one possible remedy would be for the planet to have a cooler troposphere than we predict here , but a much hotter stratosphere , which could cause the planet s absorption features to become emission features , and vice versa
. we can recover this behavior with an ad - hoc _ p - t _ profile .
we note that in jupiter the 7.8 @xmath0 m ch@xmath29 feature is seen in emission , not absorption .
as shown above , standard solar abundance models fit the @xcite mips observation well .
however , with this one data point _ metal enhanced atmospheres are not excluded_. the known differences between hd209458b and tres-1 are the former s larger radius and higher @xmath4 .
it is not yet clear if these atmospheres are substantially different in character .
possibilities include opacity due to silicate condensates in hd209458b but not tres-1 , and opacity due to photochemical products in tres-1 but not hd209458b .
_ spitzer _ observations in additional bandpasses for both planets will help to characterize these atmospheres .
observations of the depth of the primary eclipse with _ spitzer _ will allow the measurements of nightside fluxes of the planet , which would place strong constraints on atmospheric dynamics and on the energy redistribution between the day / night hemispheres .
in we collect our computed planet / star flux ratios for a variety of tres-1 and hd209458b models in all four irac bands and the mips 24 @xmath0 m band .
since models of the mid infrared spectra of brown dwarfs match observations to date @xcite , we suggest that while atmospheric composition plays a role , a complete explanation for the red spectral slope of tres-1 likely will involve energy from the parent star . whether this is due to unknown photochemical processes , unmodeled energy sources that dramatically modify the _ p - t _ profile , or some other process is not yet clear .
we thank kevin zahnle , joe harrington , david charbonneau , and sara seager for comments .
we acknowledge support from an nrc postdoctral fellowship ( jjf ) , nasa grants nag2 - 6007 and nag5 - 8919 ( msm ) , and nsf grant ast-0406963 ( kl ) . this work was supported in part by the us department of energy under contract w-7405-eng-36 .
cccccccc tres-1 & 4@xmath34 & 1134 & 0.46 & 0.81 & 1.11 & 1.48 & 2.93 + tres-1 & 2@xmath34 & 1352 & 1.06 & 1.30 & 1.69 & 2.24 & 3.69 + tres-1 & 4@xmath34,3.2@xmath37solar & 1144 & 0.58 & 0.78 & 1.15 & 1.62 & 3.02 + tres-1 & 4@xmath34,5@xmath37solar & 1148 & 0.61 & 0.78 & 1.17 & 1.66 & 3.06 + tres-1 & 4@xmath34,heating & 1165 & 0.56 & 0.90 & 1.24 & 1.71 & 3.19 + hd209458b & 4@xmath34 & 1442 & 0.96 & 1.12 & 1.45 & 1.90 & 3.05 + hd209458b & 4@xmath34,cloudy & 1448 & 1.02 & 1.22 & 1.56 & 2.01 & 3.16 + | we present new self - consistent atmosphere models for transiting planets tres-1 and hd209458b .
the planets were recently observed with the _ spitzer space telescope _ in bands centered on 4.5 and 8.0 @xmath0 m , for tres-1 , and 24 @xmath0 m , for hd209458b .
we find that standard solar metallicity models fit the observations for hd209458b . for tres-1 , which has an @xmath1 k cooler
, we find that models with a metallicity 3 - 5 times enhanced over solar abundances can match the 1@xmath2 error bar at 4.5 @xmath0 m and 2@xmath2 at 8.0@xmath0 m . models with solar abundances that included energy deposition into the stratosphere give fluxes that fall within the 2@xmath2 error bars in both bands .
the best - fit models for both planets assume that reradiation of absorbed stellar flux occurs over the entire planet .
for all models of both planets we predict planet / star flux ratios in other _ spitzer _
bandpasses . |
diffractive scattering of energetic electrons on various nuclei allowed hofstadter and collaborators to determine the radius and the surface thickness of electric charge distribution inside the nuclei , and also resulted in two simple phenomenological formulae : namely , that the charge radius scales with increasing mass number as ( 1.07 @xmath1 0.02)@xmath2 fm , while the surface thickness , within the errors of the observation , is a constant of ( 2.4 @xmath1 0.3 ) fm @xcite . by increasing the momentum of the elastically scattered particle one can probe deeper and deeper details of matter , due to the de broglie duality @xmath3 between particle properties like momentum @xmath4 and wave - like properties like wavelength @xmath5 . to resolve the internal charge distribution inside atomic nuclei , hofstadter and colleagues used electrons with bombarding energies of @xmath6 mev , corresponding to spatial resolutions of @xmath7 fm .
currently , elastic scattering of protons on protons has been experimentally investigated by the cern lhc experiment totem , at the colliding energies of @xmath0 tev , corresponding to a spatial resolution in the center of mass system of @xmath8 fm , which is sufficiently small to study the internal structure of protons . in the present paper
we exploit these experimental results and check how far can one progress with the qualitative as well as quantitative description of the differential cross section of elastic proton - proton scattering at isr as well as at cern lhc colliding energies , covering an impressive range from @xmath9 gev to 7 tev .
our investigations were motivated not only by the first experimental results of totem on elastic proton - proton collisions @xcite , but also by an inspiring series of theoretical papers by a. bialas and a. bzdak @xcite , that considered pion - proton , proton - proton and nucleus - nucleus scattering using a geometrical picture . in the present investigation , following and improving the model of bialas and bzdak @xcite a quark - diquark based geometrical model is used to describe the isr and the recent lhc totem data
. we will refer to this bialas bzdak model as the bb model or bb , for convenience .
note also that a diquark or correlated quark - quark structure has to be considered , given that a similar model with three independent , uncorrelated constituent quarks was not able to describe the elastic pp scattering data , as pointed out already in ref .
@xcite . by definition
, the earlier considered bb model has no real part , and consequently it is singular at the diffractive minimum .
the diffractive minimum , the _ dip _ , was first seen in the data collected with the cern intersecting storage rings ( isr ) @xcite .
the totem data shows that the dip is shifted towards smaller @xmath10 values at @xmath11 tev , consequently with smaller experimental errors , and these data also exclude a possible vanishing value of the differential cross - section at this dip position . therefore to describe the data , including the dip , is a challenging task .
we were able to fit the singular bb model to the isr data only in the case , when 3 data points were left out from the data at the dip , and even this did not help at lhc energies : the bb model simply failed in the dip region of totem data @xcite . a recent study @xcite , which extended the parton approach , using gluon cascades , from hard processes to describe high - energy soft and semihard processes , was also not able to describe the totem data .
its 3-channel eikonal extension with only one pomeron missed a quantitative data description at lhc energies @xcite just as well .
however , as it was demonstrated recently in ref . @xcite using the good - walker formalism with a single , effective pomeron , it is possible to describe the pp elastic differential cross - section and the energy dependence of the total cross - section @xmath12 , as well as proton dissociation into low mass system in a large energy range from cern - isr to lhc energies . in another recent study ,
that we become aware during the finalization phase of our manuscript , totem data on the differential cross - section of elastic pp scattering at @xmath13 tev were described by a relatively simple parametrization @xcite that includes two exponentials and a phase , where the first exponential is suitably modified to take into account the detailed structure of forward scattering and to include the description of the electromagnetic form - factor of the protons .
a multi - channel eikonal model was considered and found to describe well totem elastic scattering data @xmath14 at 7 tev and also pp scattering at 53 gev isr energies with some interesting physics conclusions : in particular , ref .
@xcite pointed out that elastic , diffractive and total pp scattering cross - sections at 7 tev within errors saturate the so - called miettinen - pumplin bound @xcite , namely that @xmath15 .
this result is consistent with very large parton - parton scattering cross - sections at these energies .
a detailed analysis of the real and the imaginary part of the forward scattering amplitude was presented recently in ref .
@xcite , where a regular dependence of the fit parameters as a function of @xmath16 was observed , and this behaviour was found to be nearly continuous even at the lower , isr energies , but pointing out the opening of a new mechanism in the energy range of @xmath17 gev as indicated by a perturbation of the otherwise smooth energy dependence of the model parameters .
a qualitatively similar observation was also made in ref .
@xcite , that noted that the geometrical picture of pp collisions should be modified considerably when entering the domain of ultra - high energy collisions , and pointed out that totem data at @xmath18 tev already indicate the onset of a transition to this region . in our present study
, we investigate in detail a geometrical model of proton - proton collisions , and indeed find that a qualitative change in elastic pp scattering can be observed when moving from the top isr energy of 63 gev to the lhc energy of 7 tev , which is particularly important when the study is focusing on the dip region .
we perform our analysis using a generalized bialas - bzdak model .
the bb model originates in glauber models , which were successfully developed to provide a geometrical as well as quantum - optical picture of nucleus - nucleus collisions @xcite .
the cross - section is calculated by taking into account all possible combinations of individual inelastic processes @xcite . in the present work the bb model
is supplemented with real part following ref .
therefore the ratio of the real to imaginary part of the forward scattering amplitude at zero momentum transfer , @xmath19 is not zero .
we refer to our model version as @xmath20 . in total four free model parameters
are used in @xmath20 , which is rather small .
the qcd - based , well - known model of ref .
@xcite , where the totem data is refitted successfully with the help of hard pomeron exchange , uses 15 free parameters . another relevant qcd inspired model applies 9 free parameters , where the pomeron intercept and the interesting dynamical gluon mass are the most important @xcite .
we present two , intuitively found phenomenological relations also .
the first one suggests that the total cross - section can be estimated using an effective proton radius , which is a combination of our three radius fit parameters .
we tested this formula with the singular , original version of the bb model earlier @xcite and now we present its test with the non - singular , generalized @xmath20 model . similarly to the relation of the nuclear radius to the mass number found by hofstadter , this relation is found to be only approximate , but giving a good estimate of the total cross section and also its increase with increasing energies can be related to the modification of the internal structure of protons with increasing colliding energies .
the second relation shows that the position of the dip , @xmath21 , is related to the total cross - section , so given the total pp scattering cross - section the position of the dip can be predicted .
proton - proton scattering is described in the bb model as a collision of two composite objects .
each of them is assumed to contain a constituent quark and a diquark .
the parametrization of the scattering situation is illustrated on fig .
[ singlecoll ] . in the original bb model
the interaction between quarks and diquarks is assumed to be purely absorptive , therefore the forward scattering amplitude of the bb model has no real part . in the present paper their formula is supplemented with real part .
this modification significantly improves the ability of the model to describe elastic @xmath22 scattering @xmath14 in the dip region .
the inelastic proton - proton cross - section in the impact parameter space for a fixed impact parameter @xmath23 is given by the following integral @xmath24 where @xmath25 and the integral is taken over the two - dimensional transverse position vectors of the quarks @xmath26 , @xmath27 and diquarks @xmath28 , @xmath29 .
the integral describes the convolution of the quark - diquark distributions of the two incoming protons with a @xmath30 function which in the original bb model provides the probability of inelastic interaction at given impact parameter vector @xmath23 and at given quark , diquark transverse positions . in the present work this function is generalized to complex values , indicated by the subscript @xmath31 , with the more detailed motivation given after entailing the functional form of @xmath30 .
the complex valued @xmath30 function in the @xmath32 case reduces to the real valued @xmath33 function of the original bb model @xcite .
the introduction of the @xmath31 parameter is motivated by the glauber - velasco model @xcite .
bialas and bzdak in ref .
@xcite supposed that the quark - diquark distribution of the proton follows a gaussian shape @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the variance of the quark and diquark distance inside the proton and the @xmath36 parameter is the mass ratio of the quark and diquark .
the value of @xmath37 would indicate a weakly bound diquark .
the center of mass in the transverse plane is preserved with the help of a two - dimensional delta function .
the original bb model supposes that protons are scattered elastically if and only if all of its constituents are scattered elastically @xcite @xmath38\ , , \label{glauber expansion } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the inelastic differential cross - sections of the constituents are parametrized with gaussian distributions as well @xmath39 a detailed study of the unmodified bb model , corresponding to the @xmath32 case of our present work and also to a probabilistic interpretation of the forward scattering amplitude , has been completed recently in ref .
it was shown that this model describes the main features of the @xmath14 data well in the isr energy range of @xmath40 gev , except three data points around the dip of the @xmath14 distribution , which were omitted from the optimalization @xcite .
clearly , the original bb model neglects the real part of the forward scattering amplitude , which results in @xmath41 around the diffractive minimum , a feature that does not correspond to the shape of pp elastic scattering data . from this point forward , a generalized version of the bb model is discussed which is able to describe the dip region of elastic scattering @xmath14 at isr energies , by modifying expression ( [ glauber expansion ] ) .
it takes into account , with a phenomenologically introduced parameter @xmath31 , that the proton is not always scattered elastically even if all of its constituents are scattered elastically .
this generalized model is referred to as @xmath31bb model .
the @xmath31bb model is introduced with a purely imaginary factor in the formula @xmath42 the new parameter @xmath31 is determined from the analysis of data .
the @xmath32 case corresponds to a situation , when the proton always scatters elastically if its constituents scatter elastically .
parameter @xmath31 is introduced in a way that is motivated by the @xmath31 parameter of the glauber - velasco model of refs .
parameter @xmath31 can be considered as the @xmath19 parameter of parton - parton level scattering where @xmath19 is the ratio of the real to imaginary part of the forward scattering amplitude at zero momentum transfer . from unitarity
the elastic amplitude is the following @xmath43 where the elastic amplitude @xmath44 is a complex valued function in our case ; note that an imaginary unit is suppressed in the notation of the original bb model @xcite .
important to note also that the domain of the square root in eq .
( [ telastic ] ) remains @xmath45 even if @xmath32 .
recently , the important role of the real part of the elastic scattering amplitude in shaping @xmath14 at the dip and in the orear region was highlighted in @xcite . in momentum transfer representation
the amplitude of elastic scattering is given with the fourier - transformation @xmath46 where @xmath47 and @xmath48 is the zeroth bessel - function of the first kind .
finally the differential cross - section is obtained as @xmath49 the real and imaginary part combine together to describe the dip region of the differential cross section @xmath14 , even if @xmath31 is only slightly different from 0 .
the results , as we shall also demonstrate below , will be qualitatively different from the bb model .
this subsection is devoted to describe the remaining parts of the bb model when the diquark in the proton is assumed to scatter as a single entity . in this case
the two model parameters @xmath51 and @xmath52 can be expressed with the help of @xmath53 if one supposes an idealized situation where the constituent diquark contains twice as many partons than the constituent quark without shadowing effects .
this assumption may decrease the number of free parameters by two .
the inelastic cross - sections @xmath54 are supposed to be proportional to the parton numbers . according to the assumption @xmath55 which corresponds to the case of no shadowing effect in the proton - proton scattering .
consequently @xmath56 with these ingredients the computation of eq . (
[ elsoegyenlet ] ) reduces to perform gaussian integrals .
two of the dirac delta functions simply express the transverse diquark coordinates with the corresponding quark coordinate using the mass ratio @xmath36 @xmath57 the remaining four gaussian integrals lead to the following expression for each term in the inelastic proton - proton cross - section formula ( [ elsoegyenlet ] ) @xmath58 where @xmath59+\left(1-\lambda\right)^2 d_{qd , dq}\,,\notag\\ \gamma&=c_{qd , dq}d_{qq , dd } + c_{qq , dd}d_{qd , dq } \label{master_formula1 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath60 where the @xmath61 parameters are abbreviations . formulas ( [ master_formula ] ) , ( [ master_formula1 ] ) and ( [ master_formula2 ] ) are equivalent with the corresponding formulas of the original bb model @xcite , although they are presented in a terser form .
the collision of the protons in @xmath22 scattering is illustrated on fig .
[ qqcoll ] , in case the diquark scatters as a composite object including two constituent quarks .
bialas and bzdak @xcite supposed that the two quarks follow a gaussian distribution inside the diquark @xmath63 where the transverse positions of the quarks are indicated with @xmath64 , @xmath65 .
the distance @xmath66 is the rms of the separation of the quarks inside the diquark .
it is defined as @xmath67 which expresses that the diquark is composed of two quarks which are separated by a distance @xmath66 . in the present case
the inelastic cross - sections @xmath68 , @xmath69 and @xmath70 have to be factorized using the @xmath71 inelastic cross - section using expansion ( [ glauber expansion ] ) .
the formula for @xmath68 and @xmath69 is the following @xmath72 @xmath70 is more complicated , and is given in details in refs .
the inelastic cross - section ( [ elsoegyenlet ] ) can be calculated using the master formula ( [ master_formula ] ) as before .
bialas and bzdak originally used the total cross - section , the slope parameter @xmath73 , the position of the dip and the position of the first diffractive maximum after the dip to determine the value of the fit parameters by solving 4 equations with 4 unknowns @xcite .
they found , that the resulting parameters provide a good overall description of elastic scattering data at isr energies .
however , neither the errors of the parameters nor the fit quality description with a @xmath74 test were provided . in ref .
@xcite to determine the errors of the original bb model parameters a different method was applied , utilizing all the information in the data set by a multiparameter fit . in the present study we improved not only the fitting method , but also the bb model itself .
we introduced the real part of the forward scattering amplitude with parameter @xmath31 motivated by the glauber - velasco model of @xcite .
this resulted in a new feature of the @xmath31bb model , namely the ability to describe the data also around the diffractive minimum .
second , we have used the cern minuit fitting package @xcite to determine the best values of the model parameters together with their errors . in the next section our results
are presented , while we discuss the findings and compare them with earlier results in the discussion part .
in this section the results of our minuit fits are presented for the isr @xcite and totem @xcite proton - proton elastic scattering data .
the scenario when the diquark is assumed to scatter as a single entity is considered first , which is followed by the fit results for the case when the diquark is considered as composite object . to provide a fair comparison among the model descriptions on the different dataset at different @xmath76 ,
the @xmath10 region of the fits is limited to the first totem publication . in the discussion section ,
the fit quality is also studied in special fits to the totem data in the low @xmath10 region .
as we shall see , even the improved bb model can not describe the totem data in the whole @xmath77 region .
the results show that thanks to the new parameter @xmath31 , which generates the real part of the forward scattering amplitude , the fits improve significantly and describe the data also in the dip region , as compared to the @xmath32 case presented in refs @xcite .
this phenomenon can be interpreted such that the proton does not necessarily scatter elastically even if all its constituents are scattered elastically .
this effect is small at lower collision energies , however it becomes , as we shall detail , more and more prominent with increasing energies .
in this subsection the fit results are collected in case the diquark is assumed to scatter as a single entity .
this version of the model was fitted to the proton - proton elastic scattering data both at isr @xcite and at lhc @xcite energy as well .
the results are illustrated on figs .
[ single23]-[single7000 ] and a visualization of the model parameters is provided on fig .
[ single_visualization ] .
the confidence levels , and model parameters with their errors are summarized in table [ tab : singleparameters ] .
the figures contain two phenomenological relations below the legend .
the first relation suggests that the total - cross section is proportional to the area of a disk with an effective radius @xmath78 , which is the square root of the quadratic sum of @xmath79 , @xmath80 and @xmath35 @xmath81 @xmath82 this formula was originally proposed for the bb model in @xcite , and was found to be model independently valid in both the @xmath50 and in the @xmath83 models with a precision of @xmath84 . in the current paper
we validate this formula for the @xmath85 case .
numerically , we have found another phenomenological formula , which indicates that the @xmath86 position of the first diffractive minimum @xmath87 multiplied with the total - cross section @xmath12 is nearly constant @xmath88 where @xmath89 mb gev@xmath90 .
the test of these relations for each energy with both the @xmath50 and @xmath83 models is given on the figures and the results are collected and described in our discussion part .
gev in case the diquark is assumed to be a single entity .
note that although @xmath31 is not significantly different from @xmath91 , a tiny value of @xmath31 makes the fit behavior in the dip region significantly better , than the @xmath32 case , indicated by a dashed line .
the lower panel shows the deviation of the fitted theory ( solid line ) from the experimental data at that point .
note that below the legend we show also the test of two phenomenological relations which are discussed in the text .
the total - cross section @xmath92 refers to the value of ref .
@xcite . ] , but at @xmath93 gev . ] , but at @xmath94 gev . ] , but at @xmath95 gev . ]
tev in case the diquark is assumed to interact as a single entity .
note that the @xmath50 version of the @xmath20 model fails in the low-@xmath10 region , where @xmath92 of ref .
@xcite is underestimated .
this may be the reason why @xmath96 is only 42% close to 1 . ]
.the @xmath76 dependence of the confidence levels and the fit parameters in case the diquark is assumed to be a single entity , where the parameters @xmath97 and @xmath98 are fixed .
the diquark size , as well as the inelasticity parameter @xmath31 increase significantly with @xmath76 , indicating that the proton became larger and less elastic as @xmath76 is increased to lhc energies . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] one can ask the question , why and at what range of four momentum transfer @xmath86 such a simple model should work .
apparently , for sufficiently large @xmath86 we start to probe a distance that becomes smaller than @xmath99 fm , the size of a constituent quark in the bialas - bzdak picture , or , the even larger diquark scale .
thus , for a large enough @xmath86 the simple bialas - bzdak model , and even its generalized version presented in the current manuscript , is expected to fail .
indeed , totem observed that above the dip structure the functional form of the differential cross - section changes , and can be described with a power law @xmath100 with an exponent @xmath101 for @xmath86-values between 1.5 gev@xmath90 and 2.0 gev@xmath90 @xcite .
this totem result on the large @xmath86 elastic scattering is consistent with the perturbative qcd prediction , based on a spin-1 gluon exchange picture , that predicted an energy independent power - low tail of the @xmath14 distribution with @xmath102 @xcite .
in this work we have generalized the geometrical bialas - bzdak model of elastic proton - proton scattering by allowing for a real part of the forward scattering amplitude using the same geometrical picture , but assuming that a proton - proton scattering may become inelastic even in the case when all scattering of the constituents of the colliding protons is elastic ( but not completely collinear ) .
this generalization resulted in a successful description of the dip region of elastic proton - proton scattering in the isr energy region and resulted in a significant , qualitative improvement of the ability of this model to describe elastic proton - proton scattering at 7 tev colliding energies as measured by the totem collaboration at cern lhc .
we have also found that the generalized bialas - bzdak model can describe only the small @xmath86 data set and therefore the total cross - section @xmath12 at lhc , if the fit range is limited to a relatively low @xmath86 range
. however , even this generalized bialas - bzdak model fails , if the large @xmath86 region data of totem is included , more precisely we find no good quality fits in the @xmath103 gev@xmath75 region , where @xmath104 gev .
this result can be interpreted as a qualitative change in elastic proton - proton scattering at the 7 tev lhc energies as compared to the top isr energies , due to the opening of a new channel in this reaction .
it would be interesting to collect data at rhic and at lower lhc energies to determine the energy region where this transition happens and the new physics channel opens .
based on the geometrical picture behind the bialas - bzdak model , we have identified and tested the validity of two simple phenomenological formulas .
our first formula relates the total proton - proton scattering cross - section to an effective radius , that is the quadratic sum of the radii of a quark and a diquark as well as the distance between the center of mass of the diquark and the quark inside the proton .
regardless of the detailed structure of the diquarks , and independently of the values of the real part of the forward scattering amplitude , this formula gives a model independent estimate for the total cross - section with a typical 10 % precision at isr energies , that becomes worse at lhc energies , but our data analysis nevertheless suggests that the increase of the total cross - section of proton - proton scattering is mainly due to the increase of the quark - diquark separation with increasing colliding energies , while the size of the constituent quarks and diquarks is approximately independent of the colliding energies .
our second formula establishes a relation between the total cross - section of proton - proton scattering and the position of the dip in the differential cross - section : in particular , we find that the product of these two quantities is a model independent constant .
we also demonstrated that this formula is remarkably precise , it is satisfied by the isr data within one standard deviations , while at lhc the formula is also satisfied by the data within 3 standard deviations . given
that the energy dependence of the total cross - section is very well described by linear or quadratic polynomials in @xmath105 , or by glauber monte - carlo simulations in case of proton - nucleus and nucleus - nucleus collisions , our result can in principle be well used to predict the position of the dip in the differential cross section of elastic scattering at various energies and colliding systems .
a detailed application of this relation to predict the dip position in p - pb elastic scattering will be presented elsewhere @xcite .
t.cs . would like to thank prof .
r.j.glauber inspiring discussions and for his kind hospitality at harvard university .
the authors are also grateful to g. gustafson and m. csand for valuable discussions .
the authors would like to thank also to m. giordano for valuable comments , criticism and suggestions .
99 b. hahn , d. g. ravenhall and r. hofstadter , phys .
* 101 * , 1131 ( 1956 ) .
g. antchev _ et al . _
[ totem collaboration ] , europhys .
lett . * 95 * , 41001 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1110.1385 [ hep - ex ] ] .
g. antchev _ et al._totem collaboration , europhys .
* 96 * ( 2011 ) 21002 [ arxiv:1110.1395 [ hep - ex ] ] .
a. bialas and a. bzdak , acta phys .
b * 38 * ( 2007 ) 159 [ hep - ph/0612038 ] .
a. bzdak , acta phys . polon .
b * 38 * ( 2007 ) 2665 [ hep - ph/0701028 ] .
a. bialas and a. bzdak , phys .
b * 649 * ( 2007 ) 263 [ nucl - th/0611021 ] .
a. bialas and a. bzdak , phys .
c * 77 * ( 2008 ) 034908 [ arxiv:0707.3720 [ hep - ph ] ] .
a. bialas , k. fialkowski , w. slominski and m. zielinski , acta phys .
b * 8 * ( 1977 ) 855 .
e. nagy , r. s. orr , w. schmidt - parzefall , k. winter , a. brandt , f. w. busser , g. flugge and f. niebergall _ et al .
_ , nucl .
b * 150 * ( 1979 ) 221 .
u. amaldi and k. r. schubert , nucl .
b * 166 * ( 1980 ) 301 .
f. nemes and csrg , int .
j. mod .
a * 27 * ( 2012 ) 1250175 [ arxiv:1204.5617 [ hep - ph ] ] .
v. a. khoze , a. d. martin and m. g. ryskin , arxiv:1306.2149 [ hep - ph ] .
d. a. fagundes , a. grau , s. pacetti , g. pancheri and y. n. srivastava , arxiv:1306.0452 [ hep - ph ] .
lipari and m. lusignoli , arxiv:1305.7216 [ hep - ph ] .
h. i. miettinen , and j. pumplin , phys .
d * 18 * , 1696 ( 1978 ) a. k. kohara , e. ferreira and t. kodama , arxiv:1305.3589 [ hep - ph ] .
e. ferreira , t. kodama and a. k. kohara , eur .
j. c * 73 * , 2326 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1212.3652 [ hep - ph ] ] .
r. j. glauber , nucl .
a * 774 * ( 2006 ) 3 [ nucl - th/0604021 ] .
r. j. glauber , lectures in theoretical physics , ed .
w. e. brittin and l. g. dunham ( interscience publishers , new york , 1959 ) , vol . 1 ,
p. 315 .
d. a. fagundes , e. g. s. luna , m. j. menon and a. a. natale , arxiv:1108.1206 [ hep - ph ] .
d. a. fagundes , e. g. s. luna , m. j. menon and a. a. natale , nucl . phys .
a * 886 * ( 2012 ) 48 [ arxiv:1112.4680 [ hep - ph ] ] .
arxiv:1204.1914 [ hep - ph ] . w. czyz and l. c. maximon , annals phys .
* 52 * ( 1969 ) 59 .
i. m. dremin and v. a. nechitailo , phys .
d * 85 * ( 2012 ) 074009 [ arxiv:1202.2016 [ hep - ph ] ] .
i. m. dremin , arxiv:1204.1914 [ hep - ph ] .
i. m. dremin , phys .
usp . * 56 * , 3 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1206.5474 [ hep - ph ] ] .
f. james and m. roos , comput .
commun .
* 10 * ( 1975 ) 343 .
v. m. grichine , n. i. starkov and n. p. zotov , eur .
j. c * 73 * ( 2013 ) 2320 [ arxiv:1212.2111 [ hep - ph ] ] .
m. m. block , phys .
* 436 * ( 2006 ) 71 [ hep - ph/0606215 ] .
a. donnachie and p. v. landshoff , z. phys .
c * 2 * ( 1979 ) 55 [ erratum - ibid .
c * 2 * ( 1979 ) 372 ] .
m. csand , t. csrg , f. nemes and t. novk , manuscript in preparation . | the bialas - bzdak model of elastic proton - proton scattering is generalized to the case when the real part of the parton - parton level forward scattering amplitude is non - vanishing .
such a generalization enables the model to describe well the dip region of the differential cross - section of elastic scattering at the isr energies , and improves significantly the ability of the model to describe also the recent totem data at @xmath0 tev lhc energy . within this framework , both the increase of the total cross - section , as well as the decrease of the location of the dip with increasing colliding energies ,
is related to the increase of the quark - diquark distance and to the increase of the fragility " of the protons with increasing energies .
in addition , we present and test the validity of two new phenomenological relations : one of them relates the total p+p cross - section to an effective , model - independent proton radius , while the other relates the position of the dip in the differential elastic cross - section to the measured value of the total cross - section . |
there have been many classical calculations of the energy of a plasma @xcite .
they are based on perturbation theory of an ideal gas , in terms of the plasma parameter @xmath5 ( which usually is a small value ) .
the treatment , to the first order in @xmath5 , is the debye - hckel theory .
however , in the calculations that have been made it is assumed that @xmath3 ( @xmath4 ) . this is a very strong assumption .
for example , in our previous analysis @xcite , we showed that only by not assuming @xmath3 , is the blackbody spectrum obtained .
we evaluate the energy of a plasma , studying the electromagnetic fluctuations in a plasma without assuming that @xmath3 .
a plasma in thermal equilibrium sustains fluctuations of the magnetic and electric fields .
the electromagnetic fluctuations are described by the fluctuation - dissipation theorem @xcite .
the evaluation of the electromagnetic fluctuations in a plasma has been made in numerous studies @xcite .
recently , cable and tajima @xcite ( see also @xcite ) studied the magnetic field fluctuations in a cold plasma description with a constant collision frequency as well as for a warm , gaseous plasma , described by kinetic theory . using a model that extends the work of cable and tajima @xcite
, we study an electron - proton plasma of temperature @xmath6 with densities @xmath7 .
the condition for a classical analysis is that @xmath8 , where @xmath1 is the de broglie wavelength for a thermal electron and @xmath9 , the distance of closest approach .
this condition is satisfied for @xmath10 and for the plasmas studied . in section [ sec : flu ]
we recall the expressions for the electromagnetic fluctuations in a plasma , and in section [ sec : ene ] , the electromagnetic energy is computed .
finally , we discuss our results in section [ sec : co ] .
the spectra of the electromagnetic fluctuations in an isotropic plasma are given by @xcite , @xmath11 @xmath12 ( @xmath13 ) , where @xmath14 and @xmath15 are the longitudinal and transverse dielectric permittivities of the plasma .
the first and second terms of eq .
( [ ele ] ) are the longitudinal and transverse electric field fluctuations , respectively . by using the fluctuation - dissipation theorem , we can estimate the energy in the electromagnetic fluctuations for all frequencies and wave numbers .
the calculation includes not only the energy of the fluctuations in the well defined modes of the plasma , such as plasmons in the longitudinal component and photons in the transverse component , but also the energy in fluctuations that do not propagate . for the description of the plasma
, we use the model described in detail in opher and opher @xcite .
the description includes thermal and collisional effects .
it uses the equation of vlasov in first order , with the bgk ( bhatnagar - gross - krook ) collision term that is a model equation of the boltzmann collision term @xcite .
we used the bgk collision term as a rough guide for the inclusion of collisions in a plasma . from this description , the dielectric permittivities for an isotropic plasma
are easily obtained : @xmath16 @xmath17 where @xmath18 is the label for the species of particles , @xmath19 the thermal velocity for the species and @xmath20 , the fried and conte function .
in order to estimate the electromagnetic energy , we use the dielectric permittivities , given by eqs .
( [ el ] ) and ( [ et ] ) , and calculate the magnetic and the electric field spectra from eqs .
( [ ele ] ) and ( [ magn ] ) . integrating the spectra in wave number and frequency ( and dividing by @xmath21 ) , we obtain the energy densities of the magnetic field @xmath22 and of the transverse and longitudinal electric fields @xmath23 and @xmath24 . usually , when estimating the energy stored in the electromagnetic fluctuations from eqs .
( [ ele ] ) and ( [ magn ] ) , it is assumed that @xmath3 ( @xmath4 ) . with this assumption , the kramers - kronig relations
can then be used , and a simple expression for the energy is obtained @xcite . however , the assumption that @xmath3 is very restrictive .
for example , a large part of the fluctuations which create the blackbody electromagnetic spectrum has @xmath25 @xcite .
it is therefore necessary to perform the integration of the spectra over frequency and wave number without using this assumption .
our model uses kinetic theory with a collision term that describes the binary collisions in the plasma .
a cutoff has to be taken since , for very small distances , the energy of the coulomb interaction excedes the kinetic energy .
this occurs for distances @xmath26 , which defines our maximum wave number , @xmath27 .
a large @xmath27 is needed in order to reproduce the blackbody spectrum . in this study , we used a @xmath27 equal to the inverse of the distance of closest approach , which we previously found is able to do this @xcite .
any smaller @xmath27 was unable to reproduce the entire blackbody spectrum .
in the usual classical calculations , the correction to the energy due to correlations between the particles , is made through the _ correlation energy_. to the first order in the plasma parameter @xmath5 , the correlation energy depends on the two - particle correlation function @xmath28 , @xmath29 where the second term is the energy of the particles due to their own fields .
@xmath28 can be estimated by the fluctuation - dissipation theorem or by the bbgky hierarchy equations @xcite .
generally , it is assumed that @xmath3 ( so the kramers - kronig relation can be used ) and @xmath28 is obtained as @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the inverse of the debye length . with this
, the energy density of a plasma to first order in @xmath5 is given as @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the number density of the particles .
thus , the correlation energy , to the first order in @xmath5 is @xmath34 we define the energy of a plasma as @xmath35 with this definition , @xmath36 , for the previous classical analysis ( eq .
( 7 ) ) , where the subscript `` 0 '' means that the assumption @xmath3 has been used .
higher order calculations of the correlation energy have been made , for example by oneil and rostoker @xcite .
however , in all treatments , the assumption @xmath3 has been made . as we commented above , the assumption @xmath3 is very strong .
a large part of the fluctuations has @xmath25 . to obtain the interaction energy
, we need to subtract the energy of the particles due to their own fields , the second term of eq .
( 5 ) , from the longitudinal energy density , @xmath24 .
we thus have @xmath37 . using eq .
( 9 ) , the interaction energy can be written as @xmath38 , where @xmath39 is the equivalent of the correlation energy .
in fact , using the approximation @xmath3 , @xmath39 is equal to the second term of eq .
( [ corr ] ) . in order to compare @xmath39 with @xmath40
, we define the parameter , @xmath41 we previously found @xcite that the transverse energy ( summing the transverse electric and magnetic field energies , @xmath23 and @xmath22 ) has an additional energy , compared to the blackbody energy density in vacuum .
the additional transverse energy is @xmath42 where @xmath43 is the photon energy density , estimated as the blackbody energy density in vacuum . adding the interaction energy @xmath39 to @xmath44
, we obtain the total change in the energy density due to the transverse and longitudinal components , @xmath45 we calculate @xmath46 and @xmath39 for an electron - proton plasma at @xmath47 , @xmath48 and @xmath47 for densities ranging from @xmath49 .
the densities were chosen so as to assure that the plasma parameter , @xmath50 , in order that kinetic theory is valid .
for these plasmas , the de broglie wavelength is less than the distance of closest approach of thermal electrons , which justifies our classical treatment . in figure 1 , we plot @xmath51 as a function of the density @xmath52 for the temperatures @xmath53 , @xmath54 , and @xmath55 .
we extended each plot until the density for which @xmath56 was reached .
for each of the temperatures , the value of @xmath5 increases with the density . in the case of @xmath47 , for example , for @xmath57 , @xmath58 and for @xmath59 , @xmath60 .
when @xmath56 , @xmath61 . in the case of @xmath53 , for @xmath57 , @xmath60 and for @xmath62 , @xmath63 .
when @xmath56 , @xmath64 .
we found a very good fit for the results of figure 1 , using a fermi - dirac functional form for the density dependence of @xmath51 , @xmath65 + 1)$ ] , with @xmath66 and @xmath67 ; @xmath68 and @xmath69 . from figure 1 , we obtain @xmath70 , @xmath71 and @xmath72 .
the curves ( filled , dashed and dotted ) are evaluated from the analytic expression ; the filled squares are the calculated values of @xmath51 from eqs .
( 1)-(4 ) .
the fit can be seen to be excellent . in figure 2 , we plot @xmath73 as a function of the density , for the temperatures @xmath53 , @xmath54 and @xmath55 , which shows how @xmath51 differs from the usual correction @xmath74 .
the values of @xmath51 that we obtained are positive and larger in absolute value than @xmath74 , whereas @xmath74 is negative .
this indicates that the energy in the fluctuations dominates the interaction energy of the particles .
we observe that @xmath75 can reach values of a thousand or greater .
the additional transverse energy @xmath44 is completely negligible for these temperatures and densities .
for example , for @xmath47 and @xmath61 , @xmath76 .
for this temperature and density , @xmath77 and @xmath46 is completely dominated by @xmath78 .
for example , for @xmath47 and @xmath79 , @xmath80 . as a check , we calculated @xmath39 , integrating in frequency only up to @xmath81 , the plasma frequency @xmath82 , and integrating in wavenumber up to @xmath83 .
as expected , we then found that @xmath51 is equal to @xmath74 , the value obtained in previous analysis .
we calculated @xmath46 and @xmath39 for an electron - proton plasma as a function of density for @xmath84 . for many interesting plasmas
, we found that @xmath85 .
we used the bgk collison term as a rough guide to the inclusion of collisions .
the bgk is a model collision term for the boltzmann collision term .
collisions , however , change the results very little . for example , for @xmath47 and @xmath62 , the difference in @xmath86 , with or without collisions , is less than @xmath87 . since there is no significant difference between the energy density , with or without the collision term , the use of a more acurate collision term than the bgk collision term is not necessary .
appreciably different values than the usual ones are obtained , for the interaction energy of a plasma , by not assuming @xmath3 . to the first order in @xmath5
, we found that the energy of an ideal gas needs to be corrected by a positive value , approximately @xmath88 .
this results in very different values from the usual ones @xmath89 .
our results may be applied to the plasma before the recombination era , when the plasma had a temperature @xmath90 and a density @xmath91 . since the expansion rate of the universe ( the hubble parameter ) is proportional to the square root of the plasma energy density ,
our results indicate that the universe before the recombination era was expanding appreciably faster than previously thought .
the authors would like to thank the anonymous referees for helpful comments .
m.o . would like to thank the brazilian agency fapesp for support ( no .
97/13427 - 8 ) and r.o .
the brazilian agency cnpq for partial support .
both authors would like to thank the brazilian project pronex / finep ( no .
41.96.0908.00 ) for support .
a. g. sitenko , _ electromagnetic fluctuations in plasma _
( academic press , ny , 1967 ) ; a. i. akhiezer , i. a. akhiezer , r. v. plovin , a. g. sitenko , and k. n. stepanov , _ plasma electrodynamics _ ,
vol . 2 ( pergamon press , oxford , 1975 ) .
n. rostoker , r. aamodt , and o. eldridge , ann . phys . * 31 * , 243 ( 1965 ) ; j. m. dawson , adv .
plasma phys . , * 1 * , 1 ( 1968 ) ; a. i. akhiezer , i. a. akhiezer , and a. g. sitenko , jetp * 14 * , 462 ( 1961 ) ; a. g. sitenko and a. a. gurin , jetp * 22 * , 1089 ( 1966 ) . | when @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is the de broglie wavelength and @xmath2 , the distance of closest approach of thermal electrons , a classical analysis of the energy of a plasma can be made .
in all the classical analysis made until now , it was assumed that the frequency of the fluctuations @xmath3 ( @xmath4 ) . using the _ fluctuation - dissipation theorem _ , we evaluate the energy of a plasma , allowing the frequency of the fluctuations to be arbitrary .
we find that the energy density is appreciably larger than previously thought for many interesting plasmas , such as the plasma of the universe before the recombination era . |
studies of the evolution of late - type close binary systems reveal that the evolution of detached , semi - detached and contact systems are closely related ( yakut & eggleton 2005 , eggleton 2010 and reference therein ) .
the more massive star in a detached binary system fills its roche lobe first because it has shorter evolutionary timescale before its companion .
the system is semi - detached binary .
in addition to nuclear evolution and mass loss , mass transfer has a crucial role in driving a binary towards a contact phase of evolution .
the observations of detached , contact and semi - detached binaries are crucial to our further understanding of the evolution of close binary systems .
we therefore , include ( hd 196628 , gsc 02694 - 00550 , @[email protected] , a0v ) into our close binary stars observation programme ( see ula et al . 2011 , kse et al .
the system is a @xmath12-lyr type ( short period [email protected] ) binary system and observations of the binary cover eighty years .
following its discovery by schneller ( 1928 ) the system has been extensively studied by many authors .
( payne - gaposchkin , 1935 ; pierce , 1939 and popper , 1957 ) .
ovenden ( 1954 ) ; mannino ( 1963 ) ; rovithis et al .
( 1990 ) ; sezer et al .
( 1993 ) ; jassur ( 1997 ) ; rovithis - livanou et al .
( 1997 ) ; edalati & atighi ( 1997 ) ; oh et al ( 2000 ) , and zabihinpoor et al .
( 2006 ) studied the system photometrically .
using different methods in analysis most studies agree with the primary filling its roche lobe .
asymmetry in the secondary minimum have been discussed in previous studies ( e.g. edalati & atighi 1997 , zabihinpoor et al .
pearce ( 1933 ) found the mass function and mass ratio of @xmath14 for .
later studies have reported higher mass ratios .
pribulla et al .
( 2009 ) examined the binary and classified it as a member of a group called _ difficult binary stars_. in this group accurate radial velocities are not available .
pribulla et al .
( 2009 ) concluded that the temperature difference between the components makes the system a difficult candidate in determination of the ideal broadening function .
a velocity value of @xmath15 km / s for a third body was given in pribulla et al .
( 2009 ) .
period variation of has been studied by many investigators .
period increase was discussed in a number of studies ( e.g. sezer et al .
1985 , rovithis et al .
1997 , edalati & atighi 1997 , zabihinpoor et al .
jones et al . ( 1994 ) reported a sinusoidal variation superimposed on a parabolic trend .
elkhateeb ( 2005 ) noted a period increase of @xmath16 which is close to that of oh et al.s ( 2000 ) value of @xmath17 .
hall & louth ( 1990 ) discussed a magnetic cycle by studying the period decrease between the year 1934 and 1984 .
chochol et al .
( 2006 ) represented the @xmath18 curve by a sinusoidal fit by using the cracow database and their data .
a third body with an orbital period of 90 years and a mass of 0.62@xmath8 has been proposed . in the following sections , we present our new observations of .
we preformed photometric analysis , period variations and compare our results with its previously published works .
all the available light curves were collected from the literature and studied for various physical processes ( e.g. magnetic activity , mass transfer , third light ) and their variations .
the @xmath18 variation with recently obtained times of minima revealed the discrepancy between the results of the light curve solution and period study of earlier studies . in this study , therefore , we investigate different possibilities that cause period variation in order to reveal the most accurate structure and behavior of the components .
the physical parameters of the system are given with a discussion on the evolutionary status of the binary .
the light variation and minima times of obtained in the bessel @xmath19 , @xmath10 , and @xmath20 bands in 16 nights between june august 2007 and one night in april 2011 .
the observations carried out at tbitak national observatory ( tug ) and ege university observatory with the 40 cm telescope using an apogee ccd u47 .
comparison and check stars are selected as gsc 02694 - 00280 and gsc 02694 - 00733 , respectively .
the total number of the points obtained during the observations are 3715 in @xmath19 , 3726 in @xmath10 , and 3698 in @xmath20 band .
iraf ( digiphot / apphot ) packages are used in data reduction .
standard deviations of the data are estimated as [email protected] , [email protected] , and [email protected] for @xmath19 , @xmath10 , and @xmath20 bands , respectively . in fig . 1 we show the @xmath19 , @xmath10 , and @xmath20 light curves of .
in this study , we do not find the apparent asymmetry in 0.6 - 0.7 orbital phase previously reported by edalati & atighi ( 1997 ) and zabihinpoor et al .
( 2006 ) . in data our reduction and analysis
, we used the linear ephemeris described by sezer et al .
cester et al . ( 1979 ) reported an orbital increase of @xmath22 based on seven nights observational data obtained between 1972 - 1975 .
sezer et al .
( 1985 ) also reported an increase with a @xmath23 value of @xmath24 days .
hall & louth ( 1990 ) consider the @xmath18 curve and split it in three region .
the first and the third region of the curve showed sudden variation .
therefore the authors analysed these regions under linear assumption while the second part was presented by a quadratic fit with a period increase of @xmath25 .
the authors concluded that this behavior of the @xmath18 curve can be attributed to a magnetic cycle .
jones et al . ( 1994 ) showed that the residuals of the parabolic fit show a sine - like variation with a period of 38.9 years .
a period increase was also discussed by rovithis - livaniou et al .
a period with @xmath26 was noted by edalati & atighi ( 1997 ) .
oh et al . ( 2000 ) also represented the @xmath18 curve by an upward parabola with @xmath27 .
elkhateeb ( 2005 ) found that the period is increasing with a value of @xmath28 .
the parabolic and third order polynomial fits were compared by zabihinpoor et al .
the authors give the quadratic term as @xmath29 .
zabihinpoor et al . (
2006 ) also discussed the inconsistency between geometric configuration and period variation rate .
recently , chochol et al . ( 2006 ) suggested the light time effect for the period variation .
the authors discussed that in a binary system where the primary fills its roche lobe and loses mass a decrease in orbital period can be expected .
recently we obtained two times of minima 24 54318.54864@xmath30 . and 24 55676.56220@xmath31 .
the times of minima obtained in this study show that the @xmath18 curve changes shape from early - assumed upward parabola to a sinusoidal variation that supports the previous discussion about a third body in the system .
the period variation is studied using a total of 194 data points obtained by photometric / ccd observations .
the times of minima are obtained from the literature ( kreiner et al . , 2001 and erkan et al . , 2010 ) and those yielded by this study .
the weighted least - squares method is used in order to determine the orbital elements of the third body .
sinusoidal variation in the o - c curve , where both the primary and the secondary minima follow the same trend suggests a light - time effect because of the presence of a third component that can be represented by following formula ( irwin 1959 , kalomeni et al .
2007 ) : @xmath32\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath33 is the starting epoch for the primary minimum , @xmath34 is the integer eclipse cycle number , @xmath35 is the orbital period of the eclipsing binary @xmath36 , @xmath37 , @xmath38 , and @xmath39 are the semi - major axis , inclination , eccentricity , and the longitude of the periastron of eclipsing binary about the third body , and @xmath40 denotes the true anomaly of the position of the center of mass .
time of periastron passage @xmath41 and orbital period @xmath42 are the unknown parameters in eq .
our result from our analysis are shown in fig .
2a shows the consistency between the observational and model prediction in the assumption of a third body .
2b shows the residuals from a sinusoidal variation .
the orbital elements of a third component are listed in table 2 .
it can be clearly seen from the figure that any investigation of any detailed variation in @xmath43 points makes no sense .
we have also investigated orbital period variation of the system with a different method from the @xmath18 analysis .
we have re analysed the light curves from the available eighty years and we discussed further in section 5 below .
we conclude that if the @xmath18 variation shows a downward parabola its period that is too long to determine from available times of minima .
the light curve of the system has been analysed by numerous researchers . ovenden ( 1954 ) obtained two - colour light curve and solved them by using russell s method .
the author assumed that the primary dominates observed light .
this results in a reflection effect that makes difficult to identify the secondary in the spectrum .
asymmetry between maxima discussed as an intrinsic variation .
mannino ( 1963 ) solved the photoelectric @xmath19 and @xmath10 light curves of the system with the russell merill method .
rovithis et al .
( 1990 ) analysed the light curves and estimated the geometric elements by using frequency domain techniques .
the authors reported no difference between the level of maxima . the @xmath44 light curve combined with holmgren s radial velocity curve
was solved by sezer et al .
( 1993 ) by using wilson
devinney ( wd ) method .
the result indicated a semi detached configuration where the primary is filling its roche lobe .
a standard iterative optimization technique was used by jassur ( 1997 ) to solve the @xmath45 light curves .
rovithis - livaniou et al . (
1997 ) determined the absolute parameters and the geometrical elements by applying the wood s model .
edalati & atighi ( 1997 ) compared some parameters of their solution with previous works and confirmed that the system s geometrical configuration is a reverse algol .
oh et al . (
2000 ) discussed that the system is at poor thermal contact phase of the thermal relaxation oscillation .
recently , zabihinpoor et al . ( 2006 ) analyzed the light curve and suggested new observations to uncover the discrepancy between the suggested geometric shape and the orbital period variation .
the shapes of the radial velocity curves of the system are controversial and no reliable spectroscopic mass ratio exist in the literature . in this study , therefore , we started to the solution by searching the appropriate photometric mass ratio .
@xmath46 values between @xmath47 and @xmath48 are investigated on the @xmath10 light curve by increasing the value by @xmath49 .
we reached the minimum residual when @xmath50 which is then taken as an initial value for our simultaneous solution .
the uncertainties of the spectral types also required to search for a suitable temperature for the primary component using the light curve .
@xmath51=10350 k turned out to be a suitable mean temperature of the hot component and has been used in other studies .
simultaneous solutions obtained with phoebe ( prsa & zwitter 2005 ) , which uses the wd code ( wilson & devinney 1971 ) , was applied to our observations ( 476 points in @xmath19 and @xmath10 , and 474 in @xmath20 ) .
the gravity darkening coefficients @xmath52 and @xmath53 are obtained from von zeipel ( 1924 ) and lucy ( 1967 ) .
the albedos @xmath54 and @xmath55 are adopted from rucinski ( 1969 ) .
the logarithmic limb - darkening law is used with coefficients adopted from van hamme ( 1993 ) for a solar composition ( table 2 ) .
the adjustable parameters are orbital inclination _
i _ , temperature of secondary component @xmath56 , surface potential of secondary component @xmath57 , luminosity @xmath58 , and mass ratio @xmath46 .
the analysis results are summarized in table 2 .
the computed light curves are shown with solid lines in fig . 1 .
all available light curves of the system between 19362007 are also collected from the literature and analysed separately ( table 3 ) .
these light curves are solved by using the initial values that are determined in this study .
in addition , light contribution of the third body is set as a fixed parameter since no variation is expected in a period of eighty years .
the results are shown in fig . 3 and listed in table 4 .
all available data are provided in table 5 .
some light curves ( lc8 , lc12 , lc15 ) show slight asymmetry in the secondary minimum while it is not detected in the others ( lc3 , lc7 , lc14 ) . in this study
we also investigate any evidence of a magnetic activity as it was discussed in earlier studies ( hall & louth 1990 ) .
either physical structure of the stars or the shape of the light curves did not let us to analyse the curves with spotted model assumption .
some light curves ( lc8 , lc15 ) , however , can be represented theoretically by a hot surface on the cooler companion .
the presence of a hot region , that may be attributed to a mass transfer other than a magnetic activity , could not be proved with the long - term data .
long term photometric light and period variation of the close binary system are studied in detail .
the physical parameters we have determined and listed in table 6 . because of poor quality data in the previous studies the @xmath18 curve was inferred to be parabolic one . in this study with our data we show that the system has a third body with a 92.3 years orbital period . since the primary component filled its roche lobe we searched for a clue for the mass transfer by a technique other than the @xmath18 analysis . separate solutions of six available light curves starting from 1950 to present indicate a period decrease .
the period change variation vs. years shows a downward parabola .
this can be considered as a mass transfer from the more massive companion to the less massive one .
this solution yields the amount of the period decrease as @xmath59 d / yr with a mass transfer rate of @xmath60 m@xmath61/yr .
in addition , the period of this parabolic variation is too long to detect in the @xmath18 curve constructed with the available data .
the system has been studied spectroscopically but no accurate radial velocity study of it is available in the literature . in systems like
go cyg the luminous primary star makes it difficult to treat the system as a double - lined binary .
determination of the physical parameters requires the knowledge of accurate mass ratio and the mass of the primary component . the best result obtained by a _ q_-search technique in the light curve analysis . in
what follows solution to allowed the mass ratio to vary allowing with other parameters when the solve for an orbital the light curves .
our solutions all have similar results for all nine light curves .
our results are given in table 2 - 3 .
spectral studies of ncb systems ( e.g. go cyg ) are quite difficult because of their nature .
the mass of the primary , therefore , estimated according to their colors , spectral types _
etc_. in this study , we used recently published astrophysical data of well known stars ( e.g. , torres et al . , 2010 ,
yakut & eggleton , 2005 , drilling & landolt 2000 ) to estimate the primary s ( the massive and lumonious one ) mass . by studying stars with similar luminosities and spectral types ,
the mass of the primary is assumed to be 3.0 m@xmath61 .
this is also consistent with the values given in the literature .
the physical parameters of the system is given in table 6 , the results are consistent with the similar systems on the @xmath62 , @xmath63 and the hertzsprung
russell diagrams given by yakut & eggleton ( 2005 ) .
our results shows that go cyg has the most massive components among the known ncb systems .
we collected physical parameters of the ncb systems whose primary components are relatively massive ( table 7 ) .
mass - luminosity diagram of binaries listed in table 7 is shown in fig 4 .
the locations of go cyg a and b in the @xmath63 diagram are consistent with the other ncb systems .
observational results of semi - detached systems show that while in some cases the primary component fills its roche lobe ( go cyg ) in other cases the secondary fills its roche lobe ( v836 cyg , yakut et al . , 2005 ) .
these differences are a sign for the evolutionary stage of the binary system ( for details we refer yakut & eggleton 2005 , eggleton 2006 , eggleton 2010 ) .
the orbital , geometrical , and physical parameters of go cyg presented in this study indicate the roche lobe filling star is the primary ( the massive and the hotter one ) .
we show that the primary may even transfer mass with at a low rate .
contrary to the very low mass stars , mass loss rate due to the magnetic stellar winds can be expected since the convective layer is small in the systems with intermediate / low mass components ( e.g. go cyg ) .
the results indicate the system go cyg evolves under the proximity effect , low rate mass transfer between the components ( @xmath64 m@xmath65/yr ) and the third body can also remove angular momentum from the binary orbit .
this study was supported by the turkish scientific and research council ( tbitak 109t047 and 111t270 ) and ege university research fund .
ky+vk acknowledges support by the turkish academy of sciences ( tba ) .
we thank to an anonymous referee , j.j .
eldridge and e.r .
peknl for their valuable comments and suggestions .
cester b. , giuricin g. , mardirossian f. , mezzetti m. , 1979 , acta astron .
, 29 , 433 chochol d. , et al . , 2006 , ap&ss , 304 , 93 drilling , j. s. , & landolt , a. u. 2000 , allen s astrophysical quantities , 381 edalati m. t. & atighi m. , 1997 , ap&ss , 253 , 107 eggleton , p. 2006
, evolutionary processes in binary and multiple stars , cambridge astrophysics series no .
40 eggleton p. p. , 2010 ,
newar , 54 , 45 elkhateeb m. m. , 2005 , jkas , 38 , 13 erdem , a. , zola , s. , winiarski , m. 2011 , newa , 16 , 6 erkan n. , erdem a. , akin t. , aliavu f. , soydugan f. , 2010 , ibvs , 5924 , 1 hall d. s. , louth h. , 1990 , japa , 11 , 271 irwin j. b. , 1959 , aj , 64 , 149 jassur d. m. z. , 1997 , ap&ss , 249 , 111 jones r. a. , snyder l. , frey g. , dalmau f. j. , aloy j. , bonvehi l. , 1994 , iappp , 54 , 34 kalomeni b. , yakut k. , keskin v. , deirmenci . l. , ula b. , kse o. , 2007 , aj , 134 , 642 kse o. , kalomeni b. , keskin v. , ula b. , yakut k. , 2011 , an , 332 , 626 kreiner j. m. , kim c .- h .
, nha i .- s . , 2001 ,
aocd.book lee j. w. , kim c .- h . ,
, lee c .- u . , han w. , koch r. h. , 2008 , pasp , 120 , 720 lee j. w. , kim s .-
, lee c .- u .
park j .- h . , park s .-
r . , koch r. h. , 2009 , pasp , 121 , 104 liau s. p. , 1935 ,
polyo , 1 lucy , l. b. , 1967 , z. astrophys . , 65 , 89 mannino g. , 1963 , mmsai , 34 , 191 oh k .-
d . , kang y. w. , ra k. s. , park h. s. , 2000 , ap&ss , 271 , 303 oprescu g. , dumitrescu a. , suran m. d. , rovithis p. , rovithis - livaniou h. , 1996 , roaj , 6 , 119 ovenden m. w. , 1954 , mnras , 114 , 569 payne - gaposchkin c. , 1935 , bharo , 898 , 3 pearce j. a. , 1933 , jrasc , 27 , 62 pierce n. l. , 1939 , aj , 48 , 113 pols o. r. , tout c. a. , eggleton p. p. , han z. , 1995 , mnras , 274 , 964 popper d. m. , 1957 , apjs , 3 , 107 pribulla t. , et al . , 2009 , aj , 137 , 3655 pra , a. , zwitter , t. , 2005 , apj , 628 , 426 rovithis p. , rovithis - livaniou h. , niarchos p. g. , 1990 , a&as , 83 , 41 rovithis - livaniou h. , rovithis p. , oprescu g. , dumitrescu a. , suran m. d. , 1997 , a&a , 327 , 1017 rucinski , s. m. , 1969 , acta astron . , 19 , 245 schneller , h. , 1928 , an , 235 , 85 sezer c. , glmen o. , gdr n. , 1985 , ibvs , 2743 , 1 sezer c. , glmen o. , gdr n. , 1993 , ap&ss , 203 , 121 torres g. , andersen j. , gimnez a. , 2010 , a&arv , 18 , 67 ulas b. , kalomeni b. , keskin v. , kose o. , yakut k. , 2011 , arxiv , arxiv:1107.0277 van hamme , w. , 1993 , aj , 106 , 2096 von zeipel , h. , 1924 , mnras , 84 , 665 vukasovi m. , 1997 , iappp , 67 , 11 wilson , r.e . ,
devinney , e.j .
, 1971 , apj , 166 , 605 wronka m. d. , gold c. , sowell j. r. , williamon r. m. , 2010 , aj , 139 , 1486 yakut k. , eggleton p. p. , 2005
, apj , 629 , 1055 yakut k. , ula b. , kalomeni b. , glmen . , 2005 , mnras , 363 , 1272 zabihinpoor
s. m. , dariush a. , riazi n. , 2006 , ap&ss , 302 , 27 zhang l .- y . , 2010 ,
pasp , 122 , 309 | in this study , we present long term photometric variations of the close binary system .
modelling of the system shows that the primary is filling roche lobe and the secondary of the system is almost filling its roche lobe .
the physical parameters of the system are @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 , @xmath5 , and @xmath6 .
our results show that is the most massive system near contact binary ( ncb ) .
analysis of times of the minima shows a sinusoidal variation with a period of @xmath7 years due to a third body whose mass is less than 2.3@xmath8 .
finally a period variation rate of @xmath9 d / yr has been determined using all available light curves .
stars : binaries : eclipsing stars : binaries : close stars : binaries : general stars : fundamental parameters stars : low - mass |
the @xmath1 model of the nucleus @xcite is a relativistic quantum field theory which describes the nuclear interaction using three fields . they are neutral scalar meson , neutral vector meson and baryon fields .
the scalar meson field couples to the scalar density , @xmath2 , while the vector meson field couples to the conserved baryon current , @xmath3 . in the relativistic mean - field approximation ( rmft )
where the sources are large , the meson fields can be replaced by classical fields and the linearized dirac equation solved exactly . this model has had several successes , properly describing : bulk properties of nuclear matter , ground state properties of nuclei , the excitation spectrum of nuclei , low energy nucleon - nucleus scattering observables , as well as collective motion .
all except the first of the preceding list incorporate spatial dependence for the meson fields and their sources .
the last item , collective motion , incorporates a slow time dependence in addition to the spatial dependence .
it is here proposed to use this model to calculate vector meson production during relativistic heavy - ion collisions like those to be seen at rhic .
all of the above successes of the @xmath1 model have been for low and intermediate energy phenomena .
therefore , some justification is necessary for use of this model in a radically different physical situation .
first , using ground state wave - functions calculated from this model and empirical nucleon - nucleon scattering amplitudes one can obtain excellent agreement with experimental nucleon - nucleus scattering observables in the relativistic impulse approximation up to energies of the order 1 gev @xcite ; second , the longitudinal response for @xmath4fe(@xmath5,@xmath6 ) at momentum transfer of @xmath7 gev has been calculated by frank @xcite in this model and agrees well with data ; in addition , the @xmath1 model taken in rmft has been employed to describe the nuclear equation of state up to the quark - gluon phase transition @xcite .
furthermore , the presence of many quanta of the meson fields here serves to validate the classical approximation .
it is not clear what the appropriate degrees of freedom actually are for the rhic - like collisions .
although the ( @xmath8 ) model deals with hadrons , these results will turn out to be more general .
we consider a process whereby two conserved baryon currents pass through each other , are slowed , and thus radiate energy via bremsstrahlung in the form of vector mesons . in the end ,
the only requirements for this calculation are an empirical knowledge of the initial and final rapidities of the baryon currents , conservation of these currents , and a vector meson that couples to the conserved baryon currents . in the final analysis , it is irrelevant whether the baryon current is carried by nucleons or quarks during the collision , as long as the vector meson couples to the baryon current . it should be noted that in the work of mishustin _ et .
@xcite , where the @xmath1 model is employed to calculate baryon
anti - baryon production via virtual vector meson bremsstrahlung under rhic conditions , it is suggested that real @xmath9-mesons should be produced via bremsstrahlung and that this process should be relatively soft .- meson can be generated in the bremsstrahlung process when the four - momenta of quanta satisfy the mass shell constraint @xmath10 . ...
these channels are characterized by lower threshold and , therefore , by smaller momentum transfers .
since the corresponding coupling constants are also large , one can expect high multiplicities of mesons coherently produced in ultra - relativistic nuclear collisions . '' ] in this work only central collisions of identical heavy nuclei are considered .
therefore , the lab and equal - velocity frames are equivalent . in ref .
@xcite hanson shows evidence that for central high - energy collisions ( rapidity larger than 3 ) , the nuclei are expected to be slowed by the collision , but not completely stopped .
this slowing occurs over the short time of the collision .
this gives rise to a large deceleration . in this model ,
the decelerating sources radiate the classical meson fields .
this is the same process as classical electromagnetic bremsstrahlung for an accelerated charge .
due to lorentz contraction , the scalar meson radiation is greatly suppressed relative to the vector meson radiation .
most of the vector meson radiation is in the form of high energy mesons whose mass is therefore neglected .
an attenuation factor is included to account for the strong interaction between the vector mesons and the baryons .
the attenuation factor is constructed in a lorentz invariant manner to maintain the covariance of the theory .
this model contains three adjustable parameters : the deceleration time , the rapidity loss and the total cross section for the vector meson - nucleon interaction .
the angular distribution of energy flux is characteristic , varying only in magnitude for variations in the cross section and deceleration time .
variations in rapidity loss affect both the magnitude and width of the angular distribution ; however , the general shape is robust for parameter variations .
this work indicates that the bremsstrahlung of vector mesons could contribute significantly to the total radiated energy during relativistic heavy - ion collisions .
the model used here is very simple ; it depends only on the vector mesons coupling to a conserved baryon current .
the fact that this model predicts an appreciable amount of radiation with a characteristic angular distribution that is robust against parameter variation suggests that it is deserving of further investigation .
this radiation of mesons during relativistic heavy - ion collisions has been considered before .
@xcite examined the dynamics of relativistic heavy - ion collisions using the ( @xmath8 ) model in mean field theory .
they modeled the collisions within the relativistic boltzmann - uehling - uhlenbeck model using full solutions to the meson - field equations . at the energies they studied (
1 - 20 gev / a ) , they found meson radiation to be negligible ( @xmath11 3 mev / nucleon ) .
however , the amount of energy radiated increases as the acceleration squared , so their work does not rule out appreciable radiation at higher energies .
the production of pions and photons via bremsstrahlung was investigated in refs .
ivanov @xcite calculated @xmath9-meson radiation due to filamentation instability .
the behavior of the meson fields during relativistic heavy - ion collisions was explored in refs .
@xcite ; however , these are at much lower bombarding energies and did not directly look at meson radiation .
it is expected that at the energies available at rhic these central collisions will produce a quark - gluon plasma .
the question then arises , what effect will the creation of the plasma have on this model that uses baryons and mesons ?
indeed , would any sign of this hadronic process survive under these conditions ? it has been suggested that as individual quarks interact during the collision , color strings or flux tubes will form @xcite .
these flux tubes are stretched out behind the nuclei as they pass through each other ( see , for example , figure 4 of ref .
the breaking of these flux tubes then provides an important contribution to the formation of the quark - gluon plasma .
the meson production described in the present work comes exclusively from the forward going baryons that constitute the initial colliding nuclei .
even if the mesons must pass through part of the baryon - rich quark - gluon plasma , there is theoretical evidence that meson - like modes can propagate through a quark - gluon plasma @xcite .
such a physical situation may alter the attenuation but could still leave a detectable sign of this mechanism . this paper attempts to test the limits of the @xmath1 model in rmft for a strong time - dependence .
section [ sec : formal ] introduces the framework for the @xmath1 model and classical bremsstrahlung .
sections [ sec : current ] to [ sec : attenuation ] discuss the model for the baryon current , the degree of incoherence in the radiation and the attenuation of the vector meson radiation .
the energy spectrum is investigated in section [ sec : massless ] .
sections [ sec : results ] and [ sec : conclusions ] discuss the results and conclusions .
the basic @xmath1 model is defined by the lagrangian density , . in these units
0.197 gev = 1 @xmath12 .
the metric is that of bjorken and drell and ref .
@xmath13 \nonumber \\ & & + \bar{\psi } \left [ { \ensuremath{\mathrm{i}}}\gamma_{\mu } ( \frac{\partial}{\partial x_{\mu } } - g_{v}v^{\mu } ) - ( m_{n } - g_{s}\phi ) \right ] \psi , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath14 is the vector field , @xmath15 is the scalar field and @xmath16 is the baryon field .
the masses of the nucleon , vector meson and scalar meson are @xmath17 , @xmath18 and @xmath19 respectively .
the field tensor is defined as @xmath20 this lagrangian neglects non - linear self - couplings of the scalar field . in the nuclear ground state ,
the vector and scalar fields are of comparable strength @xcite . under a lorentz boost
the scalar density is invariant ; however , the vector density is enhanced by a factor of @xmath21 , defined as @xmath22 with @xmath23 the velocity . for the dynamics of the collisions investigated in this paper , this factor varies between 10 and 100 .
the radiated energy is proportional to the field squared ; therefore , the vector meson radiation is at least a factor of 100 greater than the scalar meson radiation .
consequently , _ the scalar field can be neglected_. the energy - momentum tensor is , @xmath24 this form of the energy - momentum tensor works well for calculating the total energy and momentum of the system .
however , it contains total divergences that will give incorrect results for the energy flux .
therefore , the symmetric energy - momentum tensor must be used @xcite , @xmath25 the power radiated is @xmath26_{{\rm ret}}\ ] ] where @xmath27 is the power radiated at time @xmath28 and @xmath29 is the poynting vector . the observer is located a distance @xmath30 from the source of the radiation along the unit vector @xmath31 .
the notation , @xmath32_{\rm ret}$ ] , means evaluate at @xmath33 .
the equation of motion for the vector meson field is @xmath34 since the baryon current is conserved , this reduces to @xmath35 .
this is the inhomogeneous klein - gordon equation for a massive particle which has the solution , @xmath36 in the above equation , @xmath37 is the four - position @xmath38 , @xmath39 is the four - momentum ( @xmath40 ) and @xmath41 is the fourier transform of the current . a convergence factor , @xmath42 ,
is introduced to eliminate the singularity at @xmath43 .
the choice of @xmath44 gives the retarded solution .
the solution above can be converted to an integral over @xmath45 and gives where @xmath46 where @xmath47 and @xmath48 .
@xmath49 is the first order bessel function and @xmath50 is the heavyside step function defined as @xmath51 .
if the baryon current is replaced by the electromagnetic current , the coupling constant changed to the fine structure constant , @xmath52 , and the mass , @xmath18 , goes to zero , this reduces to electromagnetic bremsstrahlung .
note that as @xmath53 the second term in equation ( [ green ] ) vanishes .
it is argued in section [ sec : massless ] that neglecting the mass of the vector meson does not alter the results appreciably , and we will take @xmath54 for the rest of this work .
the above solution for @xmath55 and equation ( [ en - mom ] ) gives a distribution of energy as a function of outgoing energy , @xmath56 , and angle of , ( compare equation ( 14.70 ) of ref .
@xcite ) @xmath57 \ , \e^{{\ensuremath{\mathrm{i}}}\varepsilon ( t - \vec{n } \cdot \vec{x } ) } \ ; \right|^{2}.\ ] ] again , @xmath31 is the unit vector from the point of radiation to the observer .
the radiation is strongly peaked in the direction of the baryon cluster s motion .
thus , we concentrate now on just one of the incident nuclei . assuming the current is that of a collection of point baryons traveling with identical velocity , @xmath58 we may do the spatial integration .
the baryon s position is given as @xmath59 where @xmath60 is the position of the center - of - mass and @xmath61 is the baryon s position relative to the center - of - mass .
the relative position of the baryon will vary with time , for example , due to changing lorentz contraction and the empirically seen spreading of final rapidity ; however , in this simple model this motion will be neglected relative to the much more important center - of - mass motion .
the baryons will this be considered as `` frozen '' relative to the baryon clusters as they pass through each other and decelerate .
the baryon s position thus becomes , @xmath62 separating out the dependence on @xmath63 we may write , @xmath64 \ , \e^{{\ensuremath{\mathrm{i}}}\varepsilon ( t - \vec{n } \cdot \vec{x}(t ) ) } \ ; \sum_j \e^{-{\ensuremath{\mathrm{i}}}\varepsilon \vec{n } \cdot \vec{r}_j } \right|^{2}.\ ] ] taking the sum outside the square gives a coherence factor @xmath65 one must now take a statistical average over the positions of the baryons in the incident nucleus ; this average is weighted by the square of the ground state wave - function .
if the exponent is large , as argued in section [ sec : incoherence ] , the off - diagonal elements average to zero and the coherence factor is approximately @xmath66 , the number of baryons .
we now wish to find the angular distribution of energy flux and the total energy radiated .
equation ( [ eq : freq3 ] ) must therefore be integrated over all frequencies .
equation ( [ eq : freq3 ] ) may be rewritten as @xmath67}{(1 - \vec{n } \cdot \vec{\beta}(t))^2 } \e^{{\ensuremath{\mathrm{i}}}\varepsilon ( t - \vec{n } \cdot \vec{x}(t ) ) } \right|^2.\ ] ] where we have assumed the velocity and acceleration are collinear to write @xmath68}{1- \vec{n } \cdot \vec{\beta}(t ) } \right ] = \frac{\vec{n } \times [ \vec{n } \times \vec{\dot{\beta}}(t ) ] } { ( 1- \vec{n } \cdot \vec{\beta}(t))^2}.\ ] ] changing variables to @xmath69 and expanding the square we may now do the @xmath56 integration .
the integration should be over positive energies ; however , the integrand is even in @xmath56 so we take @xmath70 the integral over all energies .
the angular distribution of energy flux is @xmath71 \right|^2 } { ( 1- \vec{n } \cdot \vec{\beta}(t))^5}.\ ] ] the angular integration can also be done and this gives @xmath72 note that the last two results are just the single particle result ( see equations ( 14.38 ) and ( 14.43 ) of ref .
@xcite ) times the coherence factor , @xmath73 .
the only quantity required to evaluate equation ( [ freq ] ) is the baryon current , @xmath74 . in the present covariant approach , this is related to the particles velocity , @xmath75 , in the lab frame by @xmath76 where 1 and 2 are the two nuclei , @xmath77 is the rest - frame baryon density and @xmath78 is the four - velocity of the nucleus . the baryon current is conserved ; @xmath79 and transforms as a four - vector , @xmath80 . the baryon density should be determined from the ground - state nuclear wave - functions , computed in the dirac - hartree approximation , summed over the occupied orbitals .
this procedure is explained in detail in ref .
@xcite and implemented in ref .
@xcite ; however , it is argued in sections [ sec : formal ] and [ sec : incoherence ] of this paper that the nucleons radiate incoherently and the energy flux is insensitive to the exact baryon distribution .
therefore , one can approximate the true baryon density by a constant density inside the nuclear radius , @xmath81 .
the motion of the baryons will be modeled as having a smooth transition from their initial speed to their final speed .
a fermi - type parameterization of the speed is used @xcite : @xmath82 where @xmath83 is the stopping parameter . call the unit vector along the beam axis @xmath84 .
therefore , the first nucleus is traveling with velocity @xmath85 and the second with @xmath86 .
the initial and final speeds are fixed from experimental results and the stopping parameter is allowed to vary in this model .
the beam energy per nucleon is @xmath87 .
the initial rapidity is related to the beam energy by @xmath88 , and the initial speed by @xmath89 .
the energy lost during the collision is characterized by the rapidity loss , @xmath90 .
@xcite claim a rapidity loss of @xmath91 for central au+au collisions at rhic energies of @xmath92 gev .
the same value is used for this study of pb+pb at the same energy .
the stopping parameter is allowed to vary between @xmath93 and @xmath94 fm .
the initial speed of the nucleons for @xmath92 gev is @xmath95 .
the velocity of the nucleons relative to the center - of - mass is small compared to the velocity of the center - of - mass .
this means that the collision time between nuclei will be much shorter than the interaction time between nucleons in the same nucleus .
the nuclei then can be treated as static collections of nucleons with uniform longitudinal motion .
this is similar to the frozen approximation used in the parton model .
the baryon current can be represented as a collection of point particles : @xmath96 + \vec{\beta}^{(2)}(t ) \sum_{j=1}^{a } \delta [ \vec{x } - \vec{x}_{2}(t ) - \vec{r}_{j}]\ ] ] where the first ( second ) term represents the first ( second ) nucleus , @xmath97 is the position of the center of mass of the @xmath98 nucleus and @xmath99 is the position of the @xmath100 baryon relative to the center of mass at @xmath101 . since the lab frame coincides with the equal - velocity frame , @xmath102 .
the position is the integral of the velocity with the boundary condition that the velocity asymptote to the free particle solution at @xmath103 .
the exact form used is @xmath104 using this form of the current in equation ( [ freq ] ) gives @xmath105 [ \beta(t ' ) \sin \psi(t ' ) ] \e^{{\ensuremath{\mathrm{i}}}\varepsilon ( t - t ' ) } \\ \nonumber & & \ ; \ ; \times \sin [ \varepsilon \phi(t ) ] \sin [ \varepsilon \phi(t')]\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath106 at time @xmath107 , @xmath108 and @xmath109 is the coherence factor defined in equation ( [ eq : p ] ) . if in the coherence factor , @xmath110 then the phases are all near zero . if , on the other hand , then the phases are large and nearly random . in the end ,
when a statistical average over all possible configurations is taken using the ground - state wave - functions , the first case leads to @xmath111 corresponding to the nucleons radiating as one large baryon of `` baryonic charge '' @xmath66 . for the latter case
the coherence factor becomes @xmath73 corresponding to each nucleon radiating independent of its neighbors .
since neither of these conditions hold absolutely , the coherence factor will be some power of the atomic weight , @xmath112 where . to neglect the vector meson mass
, its outgoing energy must be on the order of several gev .
the inter - particle distance is on the order of 1 fm .
the latter condition holds and the nucleons should radiate incoherently , @xmath113 .
throughout this work the vector meson field has been treated analogously to the electromagnetic field with just a change in coupling strength .
however , there is one aspect where there is a significant difference .
the vector mesons interact strongly with the baryons ; therefore , there will be an attenuation of vector mesons as they pass through either the nucleus from which they are radiated or the other nucleus .
the attenuated energy flux can appear as radiation through another channel or could be used to heat the nuclear material . since
most of the radiation will occur early during the collision [ equation ( [ eq : angular ] ) is dominated by the denominator which increases during the collision ] and is directed in the forward direction , this attenuation is non - negligible .
this reduction is accounted for by including a multiplicative factor , @xmath114 , in the radiated power , @xmath115_{\rm ret}.\ ] ] forms of equations ( [ eq : angular ] ) and ( [ eq : totale ] ) involving the attenuation factor follow the development in section [ sec : formal ] .
this attenuation factor is taken as , @xmath116 where @xmath117 and @xmath118 are the distances traveled through the radiating nucleus and the second nucleus respectively , @xmath119 is the vector meson - nucleon total cross - section , and @xmath120 is the baryon density . equation ( [ atten ] ) can be evaluated in the rest frame of the radiating nucleus making @xmath117 time - independent . to maintain the covariance of the model the attenuation factor
is evaluated along the axis of motion and taken to be independent of outgoing angle . since most of the radiation is in the far forward direction , this results in only a small overestimation of the attenuation . to evaluate equation ( [ atten ] ) , consider the radiation coming from the nucleus traveling in the positive @xmath84 direction ( the argument is identical for the other nucleus ) .
move the origin for the integration to the center of mass in nucleus rest frame .
the distance traveled inside this nucleus depends only on where the radiation originates ( remember , the attenuation is assumed independent of outgoing angle ) .
using cylindrical coordinates @xmath121 to take advantage of the azimuthal symmetry , we find @xmath122 where @xmath123 is the nuclear radius .
since the radiation must come from inside the nucleus the following condition _ always _ holds : @xmath124 .
the form of the equation for the distance through the target nucleus is more involved since the nucleus is moving . defining the distance between the two centers of mass as @xmath125
, the distance traveled through the moving nucleus is @xmath126 where @xmath127 is the lorentz factor for the target moving in the rest frame of the radiating nucleus .
it is related to the lorentz factor in the lab frame [ equation ( [ lorentz ] ) ] by @xmath128
throughout this paper the vector meson mass has been assumed small compared to the particles outgoing energy , and hence neglected .
it is the purpose of this section to justify this assumption .
equation ( [ freq2 ] ) gives the energy distribution of the radiated mesons .
if the observer is assumed far away , the angle to the observer , @xmath129 , will change little over the time of interest .
the @xmath130 factor may be taken outside the time integral as a constant .
we define the meson energy spectrum by keeping only the energy and time dependent factors in equation ( [ freq2 ] ) , @xmath131 \ ; \right|^{2}.\ ] ] note that @xmath132 is dimensionless . again assuming the angle to the observer changes little and the velocity remains near one , the integral
can be evaluated analytically giving : @xmath133 \right .
\nonumber \\ & & + \left .
b[{\ensuremath{\mathrm{i}}}\varepsilon \tau ( 1 + \beta_{i } \cos \psi ) , -{\ensuremath{\mathrm{i}}}\varepsilon \tau ( \beta_{f } \cos \psi + 1 ) ] \ ; \rule{0mm}{5 mm } \right|^{2},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath134 $ ] is the beta function which is related to the gamma or factorial function by @xmath135 \equiv \frac{\gamma(x ) \gamma(y)}{\gamma(x+y)}.\ ] ] as can be seen in figure [ fig : spectrum ] the peak occurs at @xmath136 , and decreases slowly as @xmath56 increases .
this slow decrease means that most of the radiation is above the vector meson mass and that the massless assumption is acceptable . cutting the spectrum off at the meson mass @xmath137 gev ,
reduces the integrated spectrum by less than @xmath138 .
throughout this work , only central collisions of identical nuclei at a bombarding energy achievable at rhic of @xmath139 gev @xcite have been considered .
a short discussion is still needed concerning the value of the required coupling constant , @xmath140 .
there is no solid evidence to direct a choice of the coupling constant for the type of reaction that this work describes .
a value that reproduces static nuclear properties has been chosen @xcite ; @xmath141 . using a value of @xmath142 between eight and nine , gross ,
van orden and holinde @xcite were able to reproduce free nucleon - nucleon phase shifts to several hundred mev . since the @xmath1 model is not an asymptotically - free theory , the coupling constant may even increase at higher energy and momentum transfer ; this would lead to even more radiation than is shown below .
the paper by mishustin _ et .
@xcite , uses a coupling constant of @xmath143 , stronger than what is used here . as long as the coupling constant
is of at least order 1 , this model predicts appreciable amounts of energy radiated through this channel .
this is a crude model that has incorporated several simplifying assumptions
. it would be inconsistent to think of the predicted numbers here as more than a rough guide to the order of magnitude of what may actually be seen . to remove any ambiguity in the coupling constant ,
the angular distributions are shown with the coupling constant divided out .
figures [ fig : stopping ] , [ fig : cross ] and [ fig : rapidity ] show the angular distribution of radiated energy in the form of vector mesons . following the analysis of section [ sec : incoherence ] ,
the energy flux is calculated as the incoherent sum of @xmath144 nucleons radiating as point particles , @xmath145 the factor @xmath146 is divided out in the figures to remove any ambiguity .
= 0.197 gev . ] in each of the figures , two of the parameters are held constant while the third is varied over reasonable values .
the peak of energy flux occurs around @xmath147 off the beam - axis .
it is seen that variations in the stopping time , @xmath83 , and the cross - section , @xmath119 , only affect the magnitude and not the characteristic angular distribution shape .
changes in the rapidity loss , @xmath148 , affect both the magnitude and shape of the distribution with larger rapidity losses in this range causing less radiation and causing the peak to be moved further off axis and broadened .
it is interesting to note that the smallest rapidity loss used in this study , @xmath149 , results in the most energy being radiated .
this can be explained by considering the circumstances under which most of the energy is radiated . at relativistic speeds ,
the energy radiated is dominated by the factor of @xmath150 in equation ( [ eq : angular ] ) . a smaller rapidity loss results in the nucleus spending more time traveling faster , resulting in more radiation .
of course this only holds over a small region . at some point
the smallness of the acceleration overcomes the smallness of the denominator and at zero rapidity lost , there is no radiation . for the intermediate values of the parameters ( @xmath151 fm ,
@xmath152 mb and @xmath153 ) and @xmath154 ( pb beams ) the total energy radiated , @xmath155 , is @xmath156 gev .
the total energy available to be radiated in this collision is @xmath157 gev . reducing the stopping parameter to @xmath158 fm gives @xmath159 gev . a rapidity loss of @xmath149 and a stopping parameter of @xmath151 fm gives @xmath160 gev out of a total available energy of @xmath161 gev .
on the order of 1% of the total energy loss is through this channel .
in this paper a model for treating the bremsstrahlung radiation of neutral vector mesons coupled to a baryon current during central relativistic heavy - ion collisions has been developed .
this model treats the nuclei as clusters of baryons frozen in relative position over the time of the collision .
the clusters velocities are modeled as changing smoothly with time .
lorentz contraction greatly increases the baryon density relative to the scalar density ; hence , the scalar meson radiation becomes negligible at high energies .
most of the energy is radiated as highly energetic vector mesons , allowing for their mass to be neglected .
the vector mesons interact strongly with the baryons and therefore , an attenuation factor is included . to maintain the covariance of the model , this attenuation factor
is assumed independent of angle .
the modeling of the flow of the baryon current is the only freedom in the model . by using a smooth connection between the initial rapidity of the nuclei with the experimentally measurable final rapidity , the baryon current depends on just two parameters , the rapidity loss ( obtained from the initial and final rapidities ) and a stopping parameter which is allowed to vary freely .
although this model is used well outside its tested domain , in the end only the vector field coupling to the conserved baryon current is seen .
the model predicts a characteristic shape for the angular distribution of radiation that is robust against parameter variations .
it appears this mechanism may contribute to meson production in the next generation of relativistic heavy - ion collisions like those at rhic .
this possibility would seem to be worth exploring experimentally .
the author wishes to thank j. dirk walecka for many thought - provoking discussions and comments throughout this work and s. pratt for a helpful observation .
this work was supported in part by the department of energy grant no .
defg0594er40829 and a sura / cebaf fellowship .
99 j. d. walecka , _ theoretical nuclear and subnuclear physics _ , ( oxford univ . press , oxford , 1995 ) .
b. d. serot , and j. d. walecka , adv .
* 16 * , ( 1986 ) 1 .
cooper , b.c .
clark , r. kozack , s. shim , s. hama , j.i .
johansson , h.s .
sherif , r.l .
mercer , b.d .
serot , phys .
* c36 * , ( 1987 ) 2170 .
m. r. frank , phys .
* c49 * , ( 1994 ) 555 .
s. a. chin , phys . lett .
* 78b * , ( 1978 ) 552 ; j. kuti , b. lukcs , j. polnyi and k. szlachnyi , phys .
lett . * 95b * , ( 1980 ) 75
. i. n. mishustin , l.m .
satarov , h. stcker , and w. greiner , phys .
* c52 * , ( 1995 ) 3315 .
o. hanson , nucl .
* a574 * , ( 1994 ) 33c .
k. weber , b. blttel , v. koch , a. lang , w. cassing and u. mosel , nucl .
* a515 * , ( 1990 ) 747 .
d. vasak , b. mller , and w. greiner , phys .
* 22 * , ( 1980 ) 25 .
t. stahl , m. uhlig , b. mller , w. greiner , and d. vasak , z. phys .
a * 327 * , ( 1987 ) 311 .
b. ivanov , nucl .
* a495 * , ( 1989 ) 633 .
r. y. cusson , p. g. reinhard , j. j. molitoris , h. stcker , m. r. strayer , and w. griener , phys . rev .
* 55 * , ( 1985 ) 2786 .
j. j. bai , r. y. cusson , j. wu , p. g. reinhard , h. stcker , w. greiner , and m. r. strayer , z. phys .
a * 326 * , ( 1987 ) 269 .
a. bialas , w. czyz and l. lesniak , phys . rev . * d25 * , ( 1982 ) 2328 .
a. bialas and w. czyz , phys . rev .
* d31 * , ( 1985 ) 198 .
m. kataja and t. matsui , ann .
phys . * 192 * , ( 1989 ) 383 ; m. kataja , phys .
* t32 * , ( 1990 ) 150 .
t. hatsuda and t. kunihiro , phys .
lett . * 55 * , ( 1985 ) 158 .
j. adams , phd .
thesis , university of maryland ( 1990 ) .
j. d. jackson , _ clasical electrodynamics _ ,
( john wiley & sons , new york 1975 ) . c. j. horowitz , and b. d. serot , nucl .
* a368 * , ( 1981 ) 503 . c. j. horowitz , d. p. murdock , and b. d. serot , in _ computational nuclear physics i : nuclear structure _ , eds .
k. langanke , j. a. maruhn and s. e. koonin ( springer - verlag , berlin , 1991 ) , p. 128
s. ozaki , nuc .
* a525 * , ( 1991 ) 125c .
f. gross , w. van orden and k. holinde , phys .
* c45 * , ( 1992 ) 2094 . | the ( @xmath0 ) model in mean - field approximation where the meson fields are treated classically , describes much of observed nuclear structure and has been employed to describe the nuclear equation of state up to the quark - gluon phase transition .
the acceleration of the meson sources , for example , in relativistic heavy - ion collisions , should result in bremsstrahlung - like radiation of the meson fields .
the many mesons emitted serve to justify the use of classical meson fields .
the slowing of the nuclei during the collision is modeled here as a smooth transition from initial to final velocity . under ultra - relativistic conditions , vector radiation dominates .
the angular distribution of energy flux shows a characteristic shape .
it appears that if the vector meson field couples to the conserved baryon current , independent of the baryonic degrees of freedom , this mechanism will contribute to the radiation seen in relativistic heavy - ion collisions . the possible influence of the quark - gluon plasma is also considered .
relativistic heavy - ion collisions ; vector meson production ; bremsstrahlung ; quantum hadrodynamics ; relativistic mean - field theory 25.75.-q , 24.10.jv , 13.60.le |
recently , there has been considerable theoretical and experimental progress in the study of mesoscopic systems consisting of a finite number of charged particles which are confined into an artificial circular symmetric potential . in 1934
, wigner suggested that a liquid to solid phase transition should occur in a three - dimensional ( 3d ) fermi system at low densities @xcite .
typical experimental model systems for the study of this system are electrons on the surface of liquid helium @xcite , electrons in quantum dots @xcite , colloidal suspensions@xcite and in confined plasma crystals@xcite . on the other hand , various similar systems , like the vortex clusters in an isotropic superfluid @xcite , vortices in superfluid he@xmath0@xcite , vortices in a bose - einstein condensate stirred with a laser beam @xcite and in mesoscopic superconducting disks
@xcite have many common features with those of 2d charged particles .
colloidal particles dissolved in water @xcite are another example of an experimental system where classical particles exhibit wigner crystallization . recently , macroscopic
2d wigner islands , consisting of charged metallic balls above a plane conductor were studied and ground state , metastable states and saddle point configurations were found experimentally @xcite . such a system with a finite number of particles , initially studied by thomson as a classical model for the atom @xcite , has been extensively studied during the past few years . for a small number of particles ( typically @xmath1 ) they are arranged in rings @xcite and a mendeleev - type of table was constructed in ref .
@xcite which gives the distribution of those particles over the different rings .
moreover , the configurations of the ground state , the metastable states and saddle point states were obtained , from which the transition path and the geometric properties of the energy landscape were given in ref .
the spectral properties of the ground state configurations were presented in ref .
@xcite and generalized to screened coulomb @xcite and logarithmic @xcite interparticle interactions .
the excitation of normal modes of 2d coulomb clusters in laboratory complex plasmas were recently observed @xcite .
the melting properties of this system have been studied experimentally @xcite and by monte carlo(mc ) @xcite and molecular dynamics @xcite simulations . in a hard wall
confined system with short - range inter - particle interaction , the melting behavior was found even more interesting .
reentrant melting of 2d colloidal clusters in a hard wall potential was obtained in both experimental @xcite and theoretical work @xcite .
the defect structure in crystals is of paramount importance for the stability and the strength of materials .
topological defects in wigner crystals @xcite and its effect on particle melting were investigated in refs .
thermal defect mediated melting was proposed as the microscopic mechanism for melting in an infinite 2d triangular wigner crystal .
it is well known that the kthny scenario(kosterlitz - thouless - halperin - nelson - young ) describes 2d melting as a defect - mediated phenomenon and melting occurs in two stages through two continuous phase transitions @xcite . a clear case of two - stage melting was observed in a film of paramagnetic colloidal particles @xcite .
in this paper we study topological defects which are induced by the confinement potential , i.e. which are a result of the finite size of the system .
next we investigate how these defects influence the melting of the mesoscopic 2d island .
the present paper is organized as follows . in sec .
ii , we describe the model system and the numerical approach . sec .
iii is devoted to the structural properties of the topological defects at zero temperature . in sec .
iv , we discuss the eigenmode spectrum for these large clusters .
the discussion on the non - homogeneous melting is presented in sec . v.
our conclusions are given in sec .
the model system was defined in ref . @xcite and
the hamiltonian for such a system is given by @xmath2 the confinement potential @xmath3 is taken circular symmetric and parabolic , where @xmath4 is the effective mass of the particles , @xmath5 is the particle charge , @xmath6 is the radial confinement frequency and @xmath7 is the dielectric constant of the medium the particles are moving in . to exhibit the scaling of the system , we introduce the characteristic scales in the problem : @xmath8 for the length , @xmath9 for the energy and @xmath10 for temperature . after the scaling transformations ( @xmath11 )
, the hamiltonian can be rewritten in a simple dimensionless form as @xmath12 which only depends on the number of particles @xmath13 .
the numerical values for the parameters @xmath14for some typical experimental systems were given in ref .
@xcite .
the mc simulation technique @xcite is relatively simple and rapidly convergent and it provides a reliable estimation of the total energy of the system in cases when relatively small number of metropolis steps is sufficient .
however , the accuracy of this method in calculating the explicit states is poor for systems with a large number of particles , which have significantly more metastable states . to circumvent this problem we employed the newton optimization technique which was outlined and compared with the standard monte carlo technique in ref .
the structure and potential energy of the system at @xmath15 @xmath16 are found by the standard metropolis algorithm @xcite in which at some temperature the next simulation state of the system is obtained by a random displacement of one of the particles .
we allow the system to approach its equilibrium state at some temperature @xmath15 , after executing @xmath17 `` mc steps '' .
each mc step is formed by a random displacement of all particles . if the new configuration has a smaller energy it is accepted , but if the new energy is larger the configuration is accepted with probability @xmath18 where @xmath19 is a random number between 0 and 1 and @xmath20 is the increment in the energy @xcite .
it is well known that the hexagonal lattice is the most energetically favored structure for classical point charges in a two - dimensional infinite plane at low temperature @xcite . for a system consisting of a finite number of repelling particles restricted to 2d , which are held together by a circular harmonic potential ,
the cluster patterns are determined by the need to balance the tendency to form a triangular lattice against the formation of a compact circular shape .
the configuration is determined by these two competing effects , namely circular symmetry and triangular structure ( wigner lattice ) .
this competition leads to intrinsic defects in the 2d circular coulomb cluster which are _ geometry _ ( of the confinement potential ) _
induced defects_. this ground state is not a defect free system .
the symmetry breaking is due to the packing of the triangular lattice into a region with a circular boundary .
a hexagonal lattice which is cut by a circle without the introduction of any defect has an energy @xmath21 which is larger than the ground state energy @xmath22 for @xmath23 particles . in the first part of this paper
, we investigate the form and position of the defects in large clusters .
therefore we make use of the voronoi construction @xcite .
the voronoi construction of a collection of particles consists of a partition of space into cells .
each cell consists of those points which are closer to the given particular particle than to any other particles .
examples of voronoi constructions are shown in fig .
[ fig1 ] where the ground state configuration for @xmath24 and @xmath25 are shown .
one can see that there are two kinds of defects , i.e. dislocations and disclinations .
disclinations are orientational defects with five ( indicated by ` ' ) or seven ( indicated by ` + ' ) fold coordination number ( the number of sides of the polygon around the particles is nothing else then the coordination number ) . a dislocation is a pair of two disclinations consisting of a defect with 5-fold ( ) and a defect with 7-fold ( + ) coordination number . in the latter case
the ordering at long distances is not disrupted and consequently such a bound pair has a much lower energy @xcite .
the total number of 5-fold @xmath26 and 7-fold @xmath27 disclinations depends on the particular configuration .
the number of disclinations in this system is determined by euler s theorem and ca nt be changed , so the net topological charge @xmath28 is always equal to six as was already demonstrated in refs .
the reason is that every ` '
defect can bend the lattice clockwise over @xmath29 from a straight lattice and thus six ` ' defects can bend a straight line into a circle .
dislocations will appear when it decreases the energy of the system . from fig .
1 it is apparent that this is more so for larger clusters . in refs .
@xcite , the defects in clusters with a logarithmic inter - particle interaction were studied .
we want to stress that their way of visualizing the defects is different : nearest neighbours are connected by a line , without making crossings .
however , this does not lead to a unique picture : the total number of 5-fold , @xmath30 and 7-fold , @xmath31 disclinations can vary in the same configuration , only the net topological charge @xmath28 is always equal to six . in these large clusters ,
the defects are located on a hexagon , i.e. they form a hexagonal structure . as can be seen in fig .
[ fig1 ] the defects are approximately situated at the six corners of a hexagon , each corner with a net topological charge of ` 1 ' .
notice from fig .
[ fig1 ] that a single 5-fold disclination can appear , but never a single 7-fold disclination . for the large strain energy around ` 1 ' topological charge , some dipole defects(i.e .
dislocation with ` 1 ' and ` + 1 ' defects ) will be generated to shield the ` 1 ' topological charge .
those shielding dipole defects do not change the topology of the system .
a clearer example is shown in fig .
[ fig2 ] for the @xmath23 groundstate configuration .
we considered the @xmath23 system as it minimizes the number of defects .
the reason is that for this particle number the configuration has 42 particles in the outer ring , which is a multiple of the topological charge .
there are three rings at the border with an equal number ( @xmath32 ) of particles ( the 1d wigner lattice ) , the central hexagonal structure ( the 2d wigner lattice ) and the defects indicated by triangles ( @xmath33 ) and squares ( @xmath34 ) are situated : ( i ) around the six corners of a hexagon and ( ii ) in the transition region between the outer rings and the central hexagon .
it should be noted that the search for the global minimum configuration is a difficult problem for large systems because of the existence of a large number of local - minimum configurations , with energy very close to the global minimum .
thus one is never @xmath35 sure to have found the real ground state .
therefore , we investigated the different metastable states . in an experiment
, those metastable states may be reached by thermal excitation if the energy barrier between them and the ground state is comparable to or smaller than @xmath36 .
the saddle points between those metastable states were investigated in an earlier paper @xcite for @xmath37 . in fig .
[ fig3 ] the energy and the total number of defects of different metastable states are shown for @xmath38 the results for the different metastable configurations are ordered with increasing energy . note from fig .
[ fig3](b ) that on average the total number of defects increases with energy , but it shows strong local variations . only an even number of defects are obtained , because the net topological charge is always six , and the dipole defects ( i.e. one dislocation with ` 1 ' and ` + 1 ' defects ) always appear in pairs .
also the hexagonal position of the defects disappears ( see fig . [ fig3](1 ) ) and more free dislocations are found .
these defects move from the transition region to the border ( see fig . [ fig3](2 ) ) or to the central region ( see fig .
[ fig3](3 ) ) . for configurations with higher energy ,
the defects arrange themselves in long chains , i.e. dislocation lines . on average
the configurations with defects at the border have a lower energy than those with defects in the center .
we also investigated whether or not it is possible to have a configuration with only six 5-fold disclinations and no other defects ( like for example for the @xmath39 configuration with 24 particles at the outermost ring @xcite ) .
therefore , we started our mc procedure with a perfect hexagonal structure without any defect and then allowed it to relax to its energy minimum .
we did this for @xmath40 up to @xmath41 particles , because we noted that for these particle numbers the configuration has about 42 particles in the outer ring , which is a multiple of six , i.e. the net topological charge .
only in such a case one can have the situation in which just six 5-fold disclinations are present .
we found that our result ( from @xmath40 up to @xmath41 particles ) never converges to a configuration with only six 5-fold disclinations .
however , this procedure indeed favorably relaxes to configurations with 42 particles in the outer ring , often resulting in a configuration which has less total number of defects than the corresponding groundstate .
the effect of the geometry induced defects on the eigenfrequencies ( i.e. the eigenmode spectrum ) were also investigated for these large clusters . in this system
, it is well known that there are three eigenfrequencies which are independent of @xmath13 @xcite : @xmath42 and @xmath43 , which correspond to the rotation of the system as a whole , the center of mass mode and the breathing mode , respectively .
the above modes were recently observed experimentally @xcite .
the smallest frequency no longer correspond to intershell rotation as in small clusters @xcite but to the excitation of a vortex / antivortex pair , of which a typical mode is shown in fig .
[ fig4](a ) .
slightly larger excitation energies may consist of multiples of such pairs ( see fig .
[ fig4](b ) ) .
modes with higher eigenfrequencies often show a hexagonal structure similar to the ordering of the defects .
the motion can be concentrated around ( see fig . [ fig4](c ) ) or between the defects ( see fig .
[ fig4](d ) ) .
the local modes can be found at the six corners of the hexagon where the defects are exactly situated ( see fig . [
fig4](e ) ) .
the modes in which the inner particles have larger amplitudes than the outer particles have the largest eigenfrequencies ( see fig .
[ fig4](f ) ) .
the lowest eigenfrequencies of the excitation spectrum corresponding to the ground - state configuration of the system is shown in fig .
[ fig5 ] , as function of the number of particles for @xmath13 ranging from @xmath44 to @xmath45 .
the labels in fig .
[ fig5 ] denote the total number of defects present in the ground state .
notice that only an even number of defects are obtained as explained before . on average , configurations with a large number of defects
have a smaller lowest eigenfrequency and are thus less stable , and vice versa . in this 2d lattice , all behaviors of the cluster modes can be classified as shear - like or compression - like modes . in order to characterize the compressional and shear parts of these eigenmodes
, we calculated respectively the divergence @xmath46 and the vorticity @xmath47 of the velocity field . to calculate the velocity field , we interpolated the displacements of fig . 4 on a @xmath48 grid ( thus neglecting the constant eigenfrequency ) .
the `` divergence and vorticity maps '' were then calculated at every point of this matrix .
notice that pure shear or compressional modes do not exist in the circular boundary of finite cluster .
6(b ) shows the vorticity and thus displays the shear part of the eigenmode of fig .
the two vortex / antivortex pairs are clearly seen .
the `` divergence map '' for this eigenmode is practically zero everywhere , as there is no compressional part ( fig .
this is not the case for the eigenmodes ( c ) and ( d ) of fig .
6(c ) and ( e ) show the `` divergence maps '' for both eigenmodes , in which the compression and rarefaction can be clearly seen .
both cases show no shear part ( figs .
6(d ) and ( f ) ) . figs .
6(c ) and 6(e ) ( see also the 3d plots at the bottom of fig .
6 ) exhibit clearly dipole type of compressional oscillations between ( fig .
6(c ) ) and at ( fig .
6(e ) ) the defect regions .
understanding the microscopic mechanism of melting has intrigued scientists since the late nineteenth century .
special interest has been devoted to 2d melting @xcite .
most works address infinite systems consisting of a single layer .
however , whether melting of a 2d crystal is a first order transition and proceeds discontinuously or is a continuous transition in which the crystal first transits into a hexatic phase retaining quasi - long - range orientational order and then melts into an isotropic fluid , is still an open question and a controversial issue . in the present work we consider a finite 2d system where we take @xmath23 for our numerical simulation . here
we present a calculation of the melting phase diagram by performing mc simulations . in ref .
@xcite molecular dynamics was used to investigate the melting of a cluster of particles interacting through a logarithmic interaction . as compared to our coulomb interaction where the geometry induced defects are situated in the 3@xmath49 and 4@xmath49 outer shells ( i.e. the transition region ) and around the six corners of the `` defect '' hexagon , in the logarithmic interacting system @xcite those defect are mainly situated in the outer two shells . in ref .
@xcite , the number and type of defects were studied as function of the noise ( i.e. temperature ) . here
we will use several different criteria such as the total energy , the radial dependent mean square displacement , the bond - angular order factor and the angular square deviation to characterize the melting behavior of the cluster .
there are several different criteria that can be used to find the melting temperature . in order to determine the melting transition point , we calculated the potential energy of the system as a function of temperature ( see fig .
[ fig7 ] ) . in the crystalline state the potential energy of
the system increases almost linearly with temperature and then after the critical temperature is reached ( @xmath50 for @xmath23 ) , it increases more steeply as shown in fig .
this is a signature of melting and is related to the unbinding of dislocation pairs . the dotted assurgent line in fig .
7 indicates the linear temperature dependence of the potential energy for low temperatures before melting . in the upper inset fig .
[ fig7](a ) , we plot @xmath20 which is the difference between the numerical obtained energy and the linear t - behavior . after the melting point , @xmath51 increases sup - linear .
the lower inset , fig . [ fig7](b ) , shows the averaged number of defects as function of temperature @xmath52 .
the number of defects were obtained as follows .
we considered 40 configurations for every temperature @xmath52 .
every 500 mc steps a new configuration was obtained .
for all these configurations the number of defects were counted .
finally we averaged over the 40 configurations , which is the reason why the number of defects can be non - integer .
with increasing temperature , the system generates more and more defects and after the melting point the defect number grows very fast .
notice that two clear critical temperatures emerge from this figure at the crossing points of the dotted lines , i.e. @xmath50 and @xmath53 . in fig .
8 we plot typical particle trajectories for different temperatures which shows that the melting of this system is very complex and non - homogeneous .
it clearly indicates that the melting starts around the six corners of the hexagon which are exactly the defect regions . with increasing temperature ,
the particles in the defect region start to move radially and destroy order locally . with further increase of temperature
the total system completely melts and the order is destroyed . in order to better describe the spatial dependence of the melting process in our system , we separate the configuration into three regions as shown in fig . [ fig2 ] .
region i ( dark grey colored hexagonal area ) is comprised of the defect - free hexagonal center ; region ii is a transition region with the defects ( light grey colored area ) , and region iii consists of the outermost two rings . for the case of @xmath23 particles region
i consists of @xmath54 particles , region ii consists of @xmath55 particles and region iii of @xmath56 particles .
we calculate for each region the mean square displacement @xmath57 , which was introduced in ref .
@xcite , @xmath58 with @xmath59 the average distance between the particles .
[ fig9 ] shows the @xmath60 as a function of the reduced temperature @xmath52 for the three different regions . at low temperatures the particles exhibit harmonic oscillations around their @xmath61 equilibrium position , and
the oscillation amplitude increases linearly and slowly with temperature : the particles are well localized and display still an ordered structure .
this linear dependence is accentuated by the thin straight lines in fig .
, we already notice that the amplitude of the local particle thermal vibrations in these different regions are different .
the amplitude is largest at the defect region and lowest in the center of the cluster .
melting occurs when @xmath60 increases very sharply with @xmath15 . because of the finite number of particles one has rather a melting region , instead of a well - defined melting temperature . after the melting `` point '' ,
the particles exhibit liquid - like behavior .
[ fig9 ] exhibits three different melting temperatures corresponding to the three different regions .
firstly region ii , i.e. the transition region containing the defects , starts to melt , then the outermost two rings melt , and finally the hexagonal region melts .
following ref .
@xcite , we can `` define '' a melting temperature at the point where @xmath62 which results into the melting temperatures @xmath63 and @xmath64 for the defect region , the outer rings and the center region , respectively . in order to investigate the melting in the defect region in further detail we consider two new small regions as shown in the inset of fig .
[ fig10 ] .
one region is around the defect , the other does nt contain a defect and is situated between two defect regions . for @xmath23
each of the two regions contains respectively eight and seven particles . in fig .
[ fig10 ] , the @xmath57 of these two different regions show a different melting temperature : the melting clearly starts first around the defect as expected .
the particle motion is strongly influenced by the topological defects , i.e. the particles in the defect regions are less well interlocked and have a larger diffusion constant than the undistorted lattice regions and their thermal motions are easier to be excited @xcite .
notice , that for the two separate regions a much sharper melting behavior is found than for the intermediate region as a whole ( see fig . [ fig9 ] ) .
the reason of course is that in fig .
[ fig9 ] one averages over defect and defect - free regions .
the criterion @xmath65 results into @xmath66 for the defect and the defect - free regions , respectively .
these two melting temperatures are very similar to the melting temperature of the transition region and the hexagonal region of fig .
the third independent parameter is the bond - orientational correlation function .
this quantity determines the type of melting transition and the melting point for an infinite system .
our finite system is too small in order to have a reliable analysis of the asymptotic decay of the density correlation function .
therefore , we calculate the bond - angular order factor which was originally presented in ref .
@xcite , but following ref .
@xcite we modified it into , @xmath67 this quantity is calculated only for region i which exhibits a hexagon structure , where @xmath68 means the @xmath69 nearest neighbors of particle @xmath70 , for ideal hexagonal lattice @xmath71 , where @xmath72 is the angle between some fixed axis and the vector which connects the @xmath73 particle and its nearest @xmath74 neighbor . for a perfect hexagonal system @xmath75 in our system for @xmath23 , the initial value of @xmath76 is 0.96 , which means that the structure in region i is almost perfect hexagonal .
our numerical results ( see open dots in fig . [ fig9 ] ) show that @xmath77 decreases linearly with increasing temperature .
when @xmath76 is around @xmath78 , it more rapidly drops to zero with increasing temperature .
@xmath76 should be zero for the liquid state .
this can be compared with the infinite system where a universal melting criterion was found in ref .
@xcite : melting occurs when the bond - angle correlation factor becomes @xmath79 @xmath80 , which was found to be independent of the functional form of the interparticle interaction . for our system
the value @xmath79 @xmath80 is probably not correct because in our finite system @xmath76 does not drop to zero at @xmath81 , but is smeared out around @xmath81 .
therefore , the midpoint @xmath82 is expected to describe better the melting temperature .
this leads to @xmath83 which is similar to the result @xmath84 obtained from the radial displacement criterion .
in contrast to bulk systems , the melting scenario of small laterally confined 2d systems was found earlier @xcite to be a two step process . upon increasing the temperature ,
first intershell rotation becomes possible where orientational order between adjacent shells is lost while retaining their internal order and the shell structure . at even higher temperatures
, the growth of thermal fluctuations leads to radial diffusion between the shells , which finally destroys the positional order . to characterize the relative angular intrashell and the relative angular intershell
, we use the functions as defined in ref .
the relative angular intrashell square deviation @xmath85 /\varphi _ { 0}^{2},\ ] ] and the relative angular intershell square deviation @xmath86 /\varphi _ { 0}^{2},\ ] ] where @xmath87 indicates the nearest particle from the same shell , while @xmath88 refers to the nearest - neighbor shell , @xmath89 where the number in the outermost two rings @xmath90is the same and equals 42 for our @xmath23 system . only the two outermost rings have a clear shell structure .
both two outer rings are strongly interlocked which is a consequence of the 1d wigner lattice arrangement of the two rings . from the inset of fig .
[ fig11 ] , one can see that the inner ring will melt before the outermost ring .
we find that the result for @xmath91 of the inner ring is almost the same as @xmath92 which is the relative angular intershell square deviation .
it means that when the inner ring loses its order , the relative order is lost simultaneously .
the outermost ring can still keep its order and it will melt at even higher temperature . comparing this with fig .
9 , we see that the radial and angular displacements start to increase rapidly at approximately the same temperature .
thus for large clusters intershell rotation will not occur below the melting temperature , but appears at the same temperature when the radial displacements increase .
the configurational and melting properties of large two - dimensional clusters of charged classical particles interacting with each other via the coulomb potential were investigated through the monte carlo simulation technique . for the ground state configuration ,
a hexagonal wigner lattice is formed in the central area while at the border of the cluster the particles are arranged in rings . in the transition region between them
defects appear as groups of dislocations and disclinations at the six corners of the hexagonal - shaped inner domain .
many different arrangements and types of defects are possible as metastable configurations with a slightly higher energy . the particles motion is found to be strongly related to the local topological structure .
our results clearly show that the melting of the clusters starts near the geometry induced defects , and that three melting temperatures can be obtained : @xmath63 and @xmath93 for the defect region , the outer rings and the center region , respectively .
these values are for the @xmath23 cluster . taking a different value for @xmath13 does not lead to any qualitative differences
, it only influences slightly the values for the three melting temperatures .
this work was supported by the flemish science foundation ( fwo - vl ) , the belgian inter - university attraction poles ( iuap - v ) , the `` onderzoeksraad van de universiteit antwerpen''(goa ) , and the eu research training network on `` surface electrons on mesoscopic structures '' .
we are very grateful to dr . i. v. schweigert for helpful discussions . stimulating discussions with prof .
a. matulis and m. miloevi are gratefully acknowledged .
b. partoens is a post - doctoral researcher of the flemish science foundation ( fwo - vl ) . | the configurational and melting properties of large two - dimensional ( 2d ) clusters of charged classical particles interacting with each other via the coulomb potential are investigated through the monte carlo simulation technique .
the particles are confined by a harmonic potential . for a large number of particles in the cluster ( n150 )
the configuration is determined by two competing effects , namely in the center a hexagonal lattice is formed , which is the groundstate for an infinite 2d system , and the confinement which imposes its circular symmetry on the outer edge . as a result
a hexagonal wigner lattice is formed in the central area while at the border of the cluster the particles are arranged in rings . in the transition region defects
appear as dislocations and disclinations at the six corners of the hexagonal - shaped inner domain .
many different arrangements and type of defects are possible as metastable configurations with a slightly higher energy . the particles motion is found to be strongly related to the topological structure .
our results clearly show that the melting of the clusters starts near the geometry induced defects , and that three different melting temperatures can be defined corresponding to the melting of different regions in the cluster .
pacs numbers : 45.05.+x , 61.46.+w , 73.22.-f |
symmetry plays an important role in our understanding of nature and is the primary ingredient that goes into shaping of physical laws .
symmetry dictates the dynamics in nature @xcite .
this simple _ and _ powerful insight has shaped our current knowledge of physics , right from the galilean invariance of newtonian mechanics , through the lorentz invariance of special relativity , to the reparametrization or diffeomorphism invariance of general relativity .
so understanding the role and systematic construction of symmetries through their generators is an important aspect in the study of any physical theory . given an action ,
a symmetry is some transformation of the fields of the theory involving arbitrary functions of time that leaves the action off - shell invariant .
rotations and translations in global space - time consist two important examples of such symmetries that are observed in nature .
together , these operations constitute the poincar group .
to implement this poincar symmetry at the local level , whereby arbitrary functions of time and space are involved in the variations , new fields must be introduced which compensate for terms in the action not remaining invariant under this localization . these additional fields then are shown to represent the gravitational fields and the theory which describes this procedure and the corresponding dynamics is known as the poincar gauge theory ( hereafter referred to as pgt ) @xcite .
a lot of work has been done since then till recent times studying various aspects of the theory .
[ fig1 ] the symmetries involved in pgt are motivated and derived by considering changes occurring due to local lorentz rotations and infinitesimal coordinate changes ( i.e. diffeomorphism ) . however , no canonical procedure of generating this symmetry through a set of generators exists till now .
this problem was initially addressed in @xcite by computing the hamiltonian ( gauss ) generator following the approach of @xcite .
however the off - shell symmetries that were obtained as a result , were different from the pgt symmetries .
the two sets matched only on - shell .
this mismatch was thought to be a consequence of the approach @xcite which , strictly speaking , is not a completely off - shell approach .
recently , an attempt to remedy this situation was given in @xcite .
a systematic and completely off - shell analysis of this issue was done in 2 + 1 dimensions , taking the 3d gravity model with torsion ( modelled on the mielke - baekler action @xcite ) and the dirac hamiltonian generator was computed . alas
, the original conclusions of @xcite remained unaltered . here in this article , we adopt a totally different ( lagrangian ) approach and show how to systematically construct generators of the pgt symmetries .
the symmetries obtained from these generators reproduce the pgt symmetries without using any equations of motion .
the task of finding the symmetries of a given action is , in general , not trivial .
they can not always be found on inspection , as is possible , say , in electrodynamics .
there exist two approaches to systematically construct the symmetries inbuilt in a given action ; the hamiltonian approach and the lagrangian approach . in the hamiltonian approach @xcite ,
one first undertakes the dirac classification of all constraints into first - class and second - class .
then the generators of the symmetries are obtained as some suitable combination of first - class constraints containing time derivatives of arbitrary functions .
the poisson bracket of the fields with these generators give us the symmetries as transformations .
the lagrangian method @xcite , on the other hand , hinges on the condition that the existence of symmetries necessarily implies the existence of certain identities involving quantities given by variations of the action w.r.t .
the basic fields the euler derivatives .
the lagrangian generators can then be found through comparison with the general expressions of such identities derived from a theory involving general symmetry transformation of fields in terms of arbitrary functions of time .
we have used this later method of constructing generators here , after modifying it suitably for our model with vielbeins and connections as basic fields , that are written both in holonomic ( global coordinate ) and an - holonomic ( local coordinate ) indices .
having constructed the generators first in 2 + 1 dimensions , we then repeat the process in 3 + 1 dimensions .
the construction of symmetries through the hamiltonian approach in 3 + 1 dimensions itself is a very difficult task and pure dirac analysis and classification of constraints is non - trivial for , say , just the einstein - cartan theory .
however it is shown that the lagrangian version can be carried out more easily , leading to a systematic derivation of the symmetries even in 3 + 1 dimensions . to do this ,
we first lift the gauge identities corresponding to pgt symmetries from 2 + 1 to 3 + 1 dimensions and then carry out the lagrangian analysis . however , at the end of the day , the symmetries obtained are the same as that found by directly lifting the 2 + 1 pgt symmetries in 3 + 1 dimensions .
this shows that the pgt symmetries , arising out of geometrical considerations of reparametrization and local lorentz symmetry , are beautifully consistent and useful in an extended sense .
the organization of the paper is as follows . in section [ sec : genform ]
we give a general formulation of the lagrangian method to find out generators , starting from known gauge identities of a model .
next , in section [ sec:2 + 1laggen ] , we identify the gauge identities , calculate the generators in 2 + 1 dimensions and thus systematically reproduce the pgt symmetries in a mielke - baekler type model in 2 + 1 dimensions . for finding symmetry generators in 3 + 1 dimensions ,
we then lift the 2 + 1 dimensional gauge identities to 3 + 1 in section [ sec:3 + 1laggen ] and find out the lagrangian generators .
these are shown to generate the usual pgt symmetries in 3 + 1 dimensions .
subsequently , we also demonstrate that the 2 + 1 dimensional generators , when stripped of their dimension dependant form containing dual fields , have the same form as in 3 + 1 dimensions .
this suggests that our results may be extrapolated to any higher dimensions .
the whole scheme is summarized in figure [ fig1 ] .
our conclusions are given in section [ sec : conclu ] .
besides this , we have also included [ sec : appuseslaggen ] , where we comment on other possible applications of lagrangian generators . [ [ conventions ] ] conventions : + + + + + + + + + + + + the coordinate frame or holonomic indices are written in greek while latin indices refer to the an - holonomic local lorentz frame .
the time and space bifurcation is indicated by choosing the beginning letters of both greek @xmath0 and latin @xmath1 indices to run over the space indices , i.e. @xmath2 and choosing the middle letters of both greek @xmath3 and latin @xmath4 indices to run over both time and space indices @xmath5 .
the totally antisymmetric tensor densities @xmath6 are all normalized so that @xmath7 are unity .
the spacetime signature chosen is @xmath8 . in specifying spacetime points ,
we have denoted by ` @xmath9 ' both the time and space parts together while ` @xmath10 ' indicates only the spatial part of ` @xmath9 ' . thus @xmath11 .
the action functional for a typical first - order theory invariant under the pgt symmetries in 2 + 1 dimensions , may be written by taking the triad @xmath12 and connection @xmath13 as independent variables , while constructing the configuration space @xcite .
so in general , we have the action functional @xmath14.\end{aligned}\ ] ] arbitrary variations of the basic fields give rise to variation of the action in the following form @xmath15 where @xmath16 and @xmath17 are the euler derivatives .
the corresponding equations of motion are just @xmath18 now let us propose the following symmetries of the fields @xmath19\\ \delta \omega^i_{\ \mu}(x)=\displaystyle\sum_{s=0}^n ( -1)^s\int \mathrm{d}^2{\bf z}~\left[\frac{\partial^s\xi^\sigma(z)}{\partial \mathrm{t}^s}\bar{\rho}^i_{\ \mu\sigma(s)}(x , z ) + \frac{\partial^s\theta^k(z)}{\partial \mathrm{t}^s}\bar{\zeta}^i_{\ \mu k(s)}(x , z ) \right ] \end{aligned}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the functions @xmath20 , @xmath21 , @xmath22 and @xmath23 are known as ` lagrangian generators ' that generate variations in the basic fields while the six quantities @xmath24 , @xmath25 are functions of space and time serving as infinitesimal gauge parameters .
note that their number is governed by the poincar symmetry group , which in 2 + 1 dimensions has six independent symmetries .
these variations of fields are symmetries in the sense that @xmath26=s\left[b^i_{\ \mu},\omega^i_{\ \mu}\right]$ ] , or equivalently @xmath27 under these variations .
substituting the variations of @xmath28 and @xmath29 in yields the variation of the action as @xmath30\\ & \ & \!\!-\int \!\!\mathrm{d}^2{\bf x } \int \!\!\mathrm{d}^2{\bf z } \,\displaystyle\sum_{s=0}^n ( -1)^s \!\int \!\!\mathrm{d}\mathrm{t } \left[\frac{\partial^s\xi^\sigma(z)}{\partial \mathrm{t}^s } \bar{\rho}^i_{\ \mu\sigma(s)}(x , z ) \bar{l}_i^{\ \mu}(x ) + \frac{\partial^s\theta^k(z)}{\partial \mathrm{t}^s } \bar{\zeta}^i_{\ \mu k(s)}(x , z ) \bar{l}_i^{\ \mu}(x)\right ] .
\end{aligned}\end{aligned}\ ] ] to simplify the above expression , let us take a representative term the first term in the first line from .
the other terms , having similar structure , can then be handled by a similar technique . @xmath31 . \end{aligned}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we now interchange derivatives ( wherever applicable ) by using partial integrals , throwing away the boundary terms by assuming the fields to be well behaved at infinity . also note that we have precisely the same number of negative signs before each term through the @xmath32 factor , as required for carrying out partial integrals ` @xmath33 ' times .
so , simplifying the above equation yields @xmath34\\ & \!\!= \;-\int \!\!\mathrm{d}^2{\bf z } \int \!\!\mathrm{d}\mathrm{t } ~\xi^\sigma(z)~\left[\displaystyle \sum_{s=0}^n\int \mathrm{d}^2{\bf x } ~\frac{\partial^s}{\partial\mathrm{t}^s } \left\lbrace \rho^i_{\ \mu\sigma(s)}(x , z ) l_i^{\ \mu}(x ) \right\rbrace\right ] .
\end{aligned}\end{aligned}\ ] ] substituting this back in the variation of the action , we get @xmath35\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath36 and @xmath37 are defined as : @xmath38 since each of the gauge parameters @xmath39 and @xmath40 are independent quantities , the invariance of the action @xmath41 implies the following conditions @xmath42 these are known as ` _ _ gauge identities _ _ ' .
they are identities in the sense that on substituting the euler derivatives @xmath43 and @xmath44 in , all terms cancel out and we see that the relations are zero identically . note that until now we have only used the definition of the euler derivatives in terms of variation of fields @xmath45 , but
we have not set the euler derivative to zero , i.e. we have not used any equations of motion .
in fact , using the equations of motion trivializes the gauge identities as @xmath46 relations .
now the algorithm for finding out the lagrangian symmetry generators is simple . given an action , we can easily find the euler derivatives by varying the action w.r.t .
the basic fields . using the euler derivatives
, we can then try to build a set of independent , identically vanishing equations - the gauge identities .
alternatively , we can also explicitly check any set of identities proposed to hold as gauge identities from physical considerations .
the number of these gauge identities is identical to the number of independent symmetries . in this particular case of pgt , they are six in number and are stated compactly in .
once we obtain a set of _ independent _ gauge identities for the action , we then finally compare the given identities with the general form presented in , and find out the generators @xmath47 .
gravity in 2 + 1 dimensions is widely studied , both as a simplified problem in comparison to 3 + 1 dimensions , and also as a field which is interesting in its own right . among various models
studied , one is the mielke - baekler model which explicitly includes a torsion term , along with the chern - simons action and the usual einstein - cartan piece .
the particular mielke - baekler type action of recent interest @xcite that we study here is : @xmath48,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath49 , @xmath36 , @xmath50 and @xmath51 are arbitrary parameters , @xmath52 is the curvature tensor defined as @xmath53 and @xmath54 is the torsion given by , @xmath55 the first term proportional to ` @xmath49 ' is the einstein - hilbert action written in three dimensions using the identity @xmath56 where @xmath57 and @xmath58 .
the second term is the cosmological constant part , the third one is the chern - simons action while the fourth includes torsion .
these terms can be manipulated with the help of the adjustable parameters @xmath49 , @xmath36 , @xmath50 and @xmath51 .
the action is known to be invariant under the following pgt symmetries @xcite @xmath59 a set of independent gauge identities corresponding to pgt symmetries for the action is already known @xcite @xmath60 here @xmath43 and @xmath44 are the euler derivatives obtained from the action , and are given by , @xmath61\\ \bar{l}_i^{\ \mu } & : = -\frac{\delta \mathcal{l}}{\delta \omega^i_{\ \mu } } = -\epsilon^{\mu\nu\rho}\left[\alpha_3r_{i\nu\rho } + at_{i\nu\rho } - \lambda\epsilon_{ijk}b^j_{\ \nu}b^k_{\ \rho}\right ] .
\end{aligned}\end{aligned}\ ] ] substituting these in it may easily be checked that all terms cancel and they are indeed identities .
now the lagrangian symmetry generators which will give us a set of symmetries of the action may be found by comparing these identities with the general gauge identities derived before in .
we have employed the following strategy in comparing the two relations in question .
any sum over greek ( holonomic ) indices is broken into the time and space part , _
i.e. _ say , @xmath62 ; the gauge identity @xmath63 is also broken into sets @xmath64 and @xmath65 ; and finally coefficients ( in general field dependant ) of the euler derivatives @xmath66 , @xmath67 , etc .
are matched between the two relations and .
let us now illustrate the details for one particular term : coefficient of @xmath67 in @xmath65 .
an inspection of reveals that there occur terms either with zero or a single time derivative .
this implies that the summation over ` @xmath33 ' in is restricted to only two values , @xmath68 so , the relevant terms from are , @xmath69 while those from are @xmath70 the above expression may be recast in the form @xmath71 to facilitate comparison with .
this comparison yields the generators @xmath72 and @xmath73 .
the other generators may also be found in a similar manner .
we list all the non - zero ones below : @xmath74 @xmath75 @xmath76 @xmath77 thus , having obtained all the lagrangian generators , it is now possible to generate the transformations of the basic fields @xmath28 and @xmath29 through .
we illustrate the process for @xmath78 .
@xmath79\\ & \qquad-\int \mathrm{d}^2{\bf z } ~\left
[ \partial_0\xi^0(z)\,\rho^i_{\ \alpha 0(1)}(x , z ) + \partial_0\xi^\beta(z)\,\rho^i_{\ \alpha\beta(1)}(x , z ) + \partial_0\theta^k(z)\,\zeta^i_{\ \alpha k(1)}(x , z ) \right ] \end{aligned}\end{aligned}\ ] ] using the form of the generators @xmath80 given in and , one obtains , @xmath81 \ - \ \int \mathrm{d}^2{\bf z } ~\left[\ 0 + 0 + 0\ \right]\\ = & -\epsilon^i_{\ jk}\,b^j_{\ \alpha}\,\theta^k - \partial_\alpha\xi^\mu\,b^i_{\ \mu } - \xi^\mu\,\partial_\mu b^i_\alpha , \end{aligned}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which corresponds to the @xmath82 ( space ) component of the pgt symmetry @xmath83 given in .
all other pgt symmetries given in are easily reproduced by this procedure .
the same pgt symmetries , being constructed out of local lorentz and general diffeomorphism symmetries , are respected by a wide class of lagrangians @xcite . in 3 + 1 dimensions , the chern - simons term of 2 + 1 dimensions automatically drops out .
the other terms have their counterparts in 3 + 1 dimensions , in addition to some other new possible terms .
however , for simplicity , it suffices our aim of constructing the generators of pgt symmetries , to consider only the most important part of the gravitational action the einstein - cartan term .
thus we take the following action in 3 + 1 dimensions , @xmath84 where @xmath85 and the curvature scalar @xmath86 . the curvature tensor and the torsion tensor
are defined as : @xmath87 the corresponding euler derivatives can be found in the standard way @xmath88 to find the appropriate gauge identities here , we will now take help of the identities found previously for 2 + 1 dimensions .
the 2 + 1 dimensional model was constructed using the basic fields @xmath12 and @xmath13 , where the latter was a dual construct of the field @xmath89 , valid only in 2 + 1 dimensions .
we would now like to write the gauge identity in terms of the fields @xmath12 and @xmath89 , thus getting rid of the use of special 2 + 1 dimensional properties .
the resultant identities will then be proposed for 3 + 1 dimensions and a lagrangian analysis will be carried out to find out the corresponding symmetries .
now let us consider the @xmath90 identity in .
contracting it with the levi - civita symbol , we find , @xmath91 next , introducing relations between the dual fields and their corresponding counterparts through @xmath92 and using the following identity for levi - civita symbols @xmath93 we are able to write the gauge identity completely in terms of the fields @xmath12 and @xmath89 .
the other gauge identity @xmath63 in the set of the 2 + 1 dim identities can also be ridden of the duals through a similar procedure .
the resultant set of identities are : @xmath94 since these are now written independent of any dimensionally dependant dual fields , we may propose that they also hold in 3 + 1 dimensions .
an explicit check , using the expressions for the euler derivatives confirms the proposition . expressing the action in terms of basic fields , rather than the duals
, we have @xmath95.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the symmetry transformations of this action are now given by @xmath96\\ \delta \omega^{ij}_{\ \ \mu}(x ) & = \displaystyle\sum_{s=0}^n ( -1)^s\int \mathrm{d}^3{\bf z}~\left[\frac{\partial^s\xi^\sigma(z)}{\partial \mathrm{t}^s}\bar{\rho}^{ij}_{\ \ \mu\sigma(s)}(x , z ) + \frac{\partial^s\theta^{lk}(z)}{\partial \mathrm{t}^s}\bar{\zeta}^{ij}_{\ \
\mu lk(s)}(x , z ) \right ] , \end{aligned}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which are the 3 + 1 dimensional versions of .
now adopting identical steps as in section [ sec : genform ] , we obtain the analogues of the gauge identities with @xmath63 and @xmath97 given by , @xmath98 next , we compare these with the set of identities term by term as explained in the discussion above eq . to find out the relevant lagrangian generators .
the non - zero ones are listed below @xmath99
~\delta({\bf x}-{\bf z}),\\ \end{aligned}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath102\delta({\bf x}-{\bf z})\\ \bar{\zeta}^{ij}_{\ \
\alpha lk(0)}(x , z ) & = -\frac{1}{2}\left [ \delta^i_l\omega^j_{\ k\alpha } - \delta^i_k\omega^j_{\ l\alpha } - \delta^j_l\omega^i_{\ k\alpha } + \delta^j_k\omega^i_{\ l\alpha } \right]\delta({\bf x}-{\bf z } ) - \frac{1}{2}\left [ \delta^i_l\delta^j_k - \delta^i_k\delta^j_l \right ] \,\partial_\alpha^{(\bf x)}\delta({\bf x}-{\bf z})\\ \bar{\zeta}^{ij}_{\ \ 0lk(1)}(x , z ) & = { \ \ } \frac{1}{2 } \left [ \delta^i_l\delta^j_k - \delta^i_k\delta^j_l \right ] ~\delta({\bf x}-{\bf z}).\\ \end{aligned}\end{aligned}\ ] ] these generators will yield the symmetries of the action through the transformation . an explicit calculation , leads to the symmetries @xmath103 it may be easily checked that these transformations are indeed symmetries of the einstein - cartan action in 3 + 1 dimensions @xcite
. we would now like to make a comparative remark on the structure of the lagrangian generators in 2 + 1 and 3 + 1 dimensions .
let us consider the 2 + 1 dimensional generator @xmath104 from @xmath105 multiplying appropriately with levi - civita symbols and using the map for @xmath106 from , we get @xmath107 finally using the identity for contraction of levi - civita symbols and rearranging terms yield the following relation @xmath108\,\delta(x - z ) \\ & - \left [ \delta^m_h\delta^n_p-\delta^m_p\delta^n_h \right]\,\partial_\alpha^{({\bf x})}\delta(x - z ) , \end{aligned}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have defined the map @xmath109 thus we have re - written the 2 + 1 dimensional generator @xmath104 in terms of the original fields , getting rid of all duals .
the object @xmath110 defined in , however is functionally identical to the corresponding 3 + 1 dimensional generator .
thus the map expresses the 2 + 1 dimensional generator in a form that remains structurally the same even in 3 + 1 dimensions .
similarly , all the other generators from 2 + 1 dimensions , can be stripped off the dual fields @xmath111 .
these dual fields were defined for the special case of 2 + 1 dimensions . once having removed them , and expressed all basic fields in terms of their dimension independent form , we see that the same generators also hold in 3 + 1 dimensions .
below , we list all the non - trivial maps , in the sense described above , between the lagrangian generators .
@xmath112 observation of this structural similarity of the generators across dimensions , from 2 + 1 to 3 + 1 , indicates that in higher dimensions , similar results are expected to hold .
in this paper we have succeeded in systematically computing the generators of the pgt ( _ i.e. _ poincar gauge theory ) symmetries , which is a new result .
the lagrangian method of finding generators was employed , and in the case of first - order formulations of gravity , was seen to be much simpler than its hamiltonian counterpart . to begin with
, we took a 2 + 1 dimensional model of a pgt - invariant lagrangian which has been of recent interest @xcite the 3d gravity model with torsion and a cosmological term .
the starting gauge identities involving the euler derivatives that were required for the lagrangian analysis , were taken from a recent analysis @xcite .
the lagrangian generators were subsequently computed and pgt symmetries were recovered using the same .
we next repeated the procedure for 3 + 1 dimensions , where we took only the representative and most important einstein - cartan term in the action .
we lifted the 2 + 1 dimensional gauge identities to 3 + 1 dimensions .
the validity of the lifted gauge identities in 3 + 1 dimensions was explicitly checked .
then the same method was adopted to calculate the generators giving rise to pgt symmetries for this case .
the lagrangian generators themselves were also shown to preserve their structure across the 2 + 1 to 3 + 1 dimension transition .
the pgt symmetries were shown to be consistent throughout this process as has been shown in figure [ fig1 ] .
finding the generators that yield the pgt symmetries systematically , through a canonical method , was necessary to put this much studied symmetry at a firm level as it was not even known whether it was possible to generate the pgt symmetries by a canonical and completely off - shell process . a recent attempt @xcite to generate the symmetries of a pgt invariant 2 + 1 dimensional mielke - baekler @xcite type model through pure dirac hamiltonian generator construction in a completely off - shell manner ( following @xcite ) had given symmetries which were distinctly different from pgt symmetries .
the two sets only matched on - shell , _
i.e. _ after imposition of equations of motion
. a similar conclusion was also noted in @xcite by following a modified dirac hamiltonian approach @xcite where second class constraints were accounted by solving for the lagrange multipliers rather than by using dirac brackets .
however , in this work , we have successfully shown that based on the lagrangian generators we have constructed , one can now put this tetrad - connection formulation of symmetries on the same footing with the metric formulations @xcite , pertaining to the canonical method of constructing the symmetries .
in this article , we demonstrated the role of lagrangian generators in investigating gauge symmetries .
in particular , the _ off - shell _ poincar gauge theory symmetries were reproduced through lagrangian generators for the 2 + 1 and 3 + 1 dimensional mielke baekler type models of gravity .
one might wonder about other possible applications of these generators . in this appendix
we briefly comment on the issue .
as is well known , the canonical generators derived in the hamiltonian formalism , apart from yielding the gauge symmetries , are also used to find the conserved charges and central terms in the poisson algebra of spacetime symmetries @xcite .
since the hamiltonian and lagrangian formulations complement one another , it is expected that the lagrangian generators will also have a similar , though not necessarily identical , role .
we now elaborate on this and related points . the crucial ingredient in abstracting the lagrangian generators are the gauge identities .
construction of these identities can be made from physical considerations .
however , there also exist systematic schemes for arriving at these gauge identities from algorithms employing lagrangian constraints @xcite .
so , given a model with some lagrangian , we can arrive at the gauge identities and the lagrangian generators systematically .
now , some insight into these identities is gleaned from their connection with the bianchi identities of a model @xcite . in what follows
, we adopt the einstein - hilbert action in 3 + 1 dimensions for the demonstration of this connection .
the calculation follows @xcite closely .
the einstein - hilbert action in 3 + 1 dimensions is written in terms of the basic field @xmath113 the metric as : @xmath114 where the ricci tensor @xmath115 is defined in terms of the christoffel connections @xmath116 in the usual way as in einstein general relativity : @xmath117 varying the action with respect to the metric @xmath113 we get the euler derivative @xmath118 @xmath119 where , @xmath120 invariance of the action leads to the usual einstein s equation @xmath121 .
the gauge identity may be subsequently defined as @xmath122 which may also be expressed as , @xmath123 now , the bianchi identity for einstein general relativity is well known and is written in terms of the riemann tensor @xmath124 as : @xmath125 contracting @xmath126 with @xmath127 and @xmath128 with @xmath129 in the above identity ( the metricity condition @xmath130 holds in einstein general relativity ) , we reproduce the gauge identity .
this immediately shows that the gauge identity is nothing but a suitably contracted form of the bianchi identity in this model . the gauge identity , or the contracted version of the bianchi identity , plays a significant role in the obtention of the noether central charges .
as in the hamiltonian description , here too surface terms are important . if these terms are not dropped , then takes the form , @xmath131.\end{aligned}\ ] ] explicitly using @xmath132 we obtain , @xmath133 = 0\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the first term in the integrand vanishes due to the gauge identity .
this also implies the vanishing of the second term in the integrand .
effectively , this leads to the covariant conservation of the noether current , @xmath134 corresponding to each vector @xmath39 it is now possible to construct a conserved noether charge from .
this yields the standard komar s integral in general relativity @xcite
. a comment on the surface terms might be useful . in the hamiltonian approach ,
these terms are determined by requiring the functional differentiability of the generators .
the corresponding criterion in the present lagrangian formulation is to retain all surface terms in the variation of the action under a general coordinate transformation , eventually leading to the gauge identity .
this is clearly manifested in where the first term in the integrand yields the gauge identity while the second is the cherished surface term .
we thus observe how the gauge identity , which is directly connected with the lagrangian generators , leads to conserved noether charges .
also , the complementary aspects of lagrangian and hamiltonian generators , vis-@xmath135-vis the construction of conserved charges gets illuminated .
d. j. gross , `` the role of symmetry in fundamental physics , '' proc .
usa * 93 * 14256 ( 1996 ) .
r. utiyama , `` invariant theoretical interpretation of interaction , '' phys .
* 101 * 1597 ( 1956 ) .
t. w. b. kibble , `` lorentz invariance and the gravitational field , '' j. math .
* 2 * 212 , ( 1961 )
. d. w. sciama , `` on the analog between charge and spin in general relativity , '' p-415 , _
recent developments in general relativity , festschrift for leopold infeld , pergamon press , new york ( 1962)_. f. w. hehl , p. von der heyde , g. d. kerlick and j. m. nester , `` general relativity with spin and torsion : foundations and prospects , '' rev .
* 48 * , 393 ( 1976 ) . m. blagojevic , `` gravitation and gauge symmetries , '' _ bristol , uk : iop ( 2002 ) 522 p_. m. blagojevic and m. vasilic , `` asymptotic symmetries in 3d gravity with torsion , '' phys . rev .
d * 67 * , 084032 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/0301051 ] .
m. blagojevic and b. cvetkovic , `` canonical structure of 3d gravity with torsion , '' _ trends in gr and qc , * 2 * , ed .
benton , ny : nova science ( 2006 ) 103 - 123 _ [ arxiv : gr - qc/0412134 ] .
l. castellani , `` symmetries in constrained hamiltonian systems , '' annals phys .
* 143 * , 357 ( 1982 ) .
r. banerjee , s. gangopadhyay , p. mukherjee and d. roy , `` symmetries of the general topologically massive gravity in the hamiltonian and lagrangian formalisms , '' jhep * 1002 * , 075 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0912.1472 [ gr - qc ] ] .
e. w. mielke and p. baekler , `` topological gauge model of gravity with torsion , '' phys .
a * 156 * , 399 ( 1991 ) .
m. henneaux , c. teitelboim and j. zanelli , `` gauge invariance and degree of freedom count , '' nucl .
b * 332 * , 169 ( 1990 ) .
r. banerjee , h. j. rothe and k. d. rothe , `` master equation for lagrangian gauge symmetries , '' phys .
b * 479 * , 429 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9907217 ] .
r. banerjee , h. j. rothe and k. d. rothe , `` hamiltonian approach to lagrangian gauge symmetries , '' phys .
b * 463 * , 248 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9906072 ] .
r. banerjee , h. j. rothe and k. d. rothe , `` recursive construction of generator for lagrangian gauge symmetries , '' j. phys .
a * 33 * , 2059 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9909039 ] .
a. m. frolov , n. kiriushcheva and s. v. kuzmin , `` hamiltonian formulation of tetrad gravity : three dimensional case , '' arxiv:0902.0856 [ gr - qc ] .
n. kiriushcheva , s. v. kuzmin and r. nowbakht ghalati , `` two - dimensional metric and tetrad gravities as constrained second order systems , '' mod .
. lett .
a * 22 * , 17 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0605193 ] .
n. mukunda and g. sudarshan , `` classical dynamics : a modern perspective , '' _ wiley , new york , 1974_. d. m. gitman and i. v. tyutin , `` quantization of fields with constraints , '' _ berlin , germany : springer ( 1990 ) 291 p. ( springer series in nuclear and particle physics)_. m. chaichian and d. louis martinez , `` on the noether idenities for a class of systems with singular lagrangians , '' j. math .
phys . * 35 * , 6536 ( 1994 ) .
a. shirzad , `` gauge symmetry in lagrangian formulation and schwinger models , '' j. phys . a * 31 * , 2747 ( 1998 ) .
r. banerjee , b. chakraborty , s. ghosh , p. mukherjee and s. samanta , `` topics in noncommutative geometry inspired physics , '' found .
* 39 * , 1297 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0909.1000 [ hep - th ] ] .
r. banerjee and s. samanta , `` gauge generators , transformations and identities on a noncommutative space , '' eur .
j. c * 51 * , 207 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0608214 ] .
s. samanta , `` diffeomorphism symmetry in the lagrangian formulation of gravity , '' int .
j. theor .
phys . * 48 * , 1436 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0708.3300 [ hep - th ] ] .
r. basu and s. k. paul , `` 2 + 1 quantum gravity with barbero - immirzi like parameter on toric spatial foliation , '' class .
* 27 * , 125003 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0909.4238 [ gr - qc ] ] .
m. blagojevic , b. cvetkovic and o. miskovic , `` nonlinear electrodynamics in 3d gravity with torsion , '' phys .
d * 80 * , 024043 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0906.0235 [ gr - qc ] ] .
p. mukherjee and a. saha , `` gauge invariances vis - - vis diffeomorphisms in second order metric gravity , '' int .
j. mod .
a * 24 * , 4305 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0705.4358 [ hep - th ] ] .
t. ortin , `` gravity and strings , '' _ cambridge unversity , cambridge university press , 2004_. s. weinberg , `` gravitation and cosmology : principles and applications of the general theory of relativity , '' _ john wiley & sons , inc , 1972_. , m. blagojevic and b. cvetkovic , `` black hole entropy from the boundary conformal structure in 3d gravity with torsion , '' jhep * 0610 * , 005 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/0606086 ] .
179180 _ ) _ of _ @xcite . | we have systematically computed the generators of the symmetries arising in poincar gauge theory formulation of gravity , both in 2 + 1 and 3 + 1 dimensions .
this was done using a completely lagrangian approach .
the results are expected to be valid in any dimensions , as seen through lifting the results of the 2 + 1 dimensional example into the 3 + 1 dimensional one . |
collisionless shocks are important phenomena in the universe ; they heat and compress interstellar or intergalactic plasmas and often accelerate charged particles or cosmic rays .
the dissipation mechanism of the collisionless shocks is highly complex and generally involved with instabilities in the collisionless plasma .
the weibel instability is driven in anisotropic or counter - streaming collisionless plasmas @xcite and generates strong magnetic fields .
collisionless shocks inevitably generate an anisotropy within their transition region , where the upstream and downstream plasmas are mixed up , therefore , the weibel instability can develop and generate strong magnetic fields there if the background magnetic field is weak .
@xcite considered such a process in non - relativistic collisionless shocks and @xcite discussed the magnetic field generation by the weibel instability in relativistic collisionless shocks of gamma - ray bursts . in this context , the weibel instability in relativistic counter - streaming plasmas has been investigated extensively by means of particle - in - cell simulations ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
recent research with simulations showed that the `` weibel - mediated '' collisionless shocks can form at relativistic propagation speed in electron - positron plasmas @xcite and also in electron - ion plasmas @xcite without background magnetic field ; in these shocks the dissipation mechanism is effectively provided by the magnetic fields generated by the weibel - type instability in the shock transition region . in the universe , these shocks can be driven associated with relativistic phenomena , such as gamma - ray bursts , jets from active galactic nuclei , or pulsar winds .
there is also a possibility that these weibel - mediated shocks are driven even in non - relativistic phenomena , e.g. , shocks of supernova remnants whose propagation speed is typically @xmath2 km s@xmath3 .
however , in this case , the weibel instability can be inefficient because the linear growth rate of the instability is proportional to the flow velocity @xmath4 .
therefore , it is not clear yet whether this kind of shocks can exist in non - relativistic regime . in this paper , however , we show that the weibel - mediated collisionless shocks propagating at non - relativistic speed can form in unmagnetized electron - ion plasmas by performing numerical simulations .
this also suggests a possibility to proof the formation of these shocks in laboratory plasmas with large - scale laser facilities .
in order to investigate the collisionless shocks in electron - ion plasmas without background magnetic fields , we performed numerical simulations . the simulation code is a relativistic and electromagnetic particle - in - cell code with two spatial and three velocity dimensions ( 2d3v ) which was developed based on a standard method described by @xcite .
the basic equations are the maxwell s equations and the ( relativistic ) equation of motion of particles .
the simulation plane is the @xmath5 plane .
the @xmath6 axis is perpendicular to the plane .
since we consider collisionless shocks in unmagnetized plasmas , the electromagnetic fields are initially set to zero over the entire simulation box .
the boundary condition of the electromagnetic field is periodic to each direction . in the simulations
a collisionless shock is driven by means of the `` injection method . ''
there are two rigid walls at the left - hand side ( smaller @xmath7 ) and right - hand side ( larger @xmath7 ) of the simulation box and these walls reflect particles specularly .
initially , both electrons and ions are uniformly loaded in the region between the two walls at the bulk flow velocity of @xmath4 in the @xmath8-direction . at the early stage of the simulations , the particles located near the right wall
were reflected by the wall and then interacted with the incoming particles , i.e. , the upstream plasma , via some instabilities .
such instabilities induce strong electric or magnetic fields that provide dissipation mechanism of the shock and , eventually , a collisionless shock is formed .
note that the frame of the simulation corresponds to the downstream rest frame .
we have carried out a series of simulations with upstream bulk velocities of @xmath9 , @xmath10 , and @xmath11 , where @xmath12 is the speed of light .
the thermal velocity of electrons is typically taken as one - tenth of the bulk velocity and that of ions is determined so that the temperatures of electrons and ions are same .
because of the computational power , we used a reduced ion mass of @xmath13 . here , we take @xmath14 as the unit of time and the electron skin depth @xmath15 as the unit of length , where @xmath16 is the electron plasma frequency defined for the electron number density of the upstream plasma , @xmath17 .
we also define the ion inertial length , @xmath18 .
the units of electric and magnetic fields are both taken as @xmath19 .
the simulation for @xmath9 was performed on a grid of @xmath21 with @xmath22 particles per cell per species .
the size of the simulation box is @xmath23 .
( we choose the grid size so that the system is stable against the cold beam nonphysical instability , c.f .
@xcite . ) the number density of ions obtained from the simulation at @xmath24 is shown in fig .
[ fig : npv045 ] .
the color shows the number density normalized by the upstream value , namely , @xmath17 .
the upstream plasma flows from the left to the right and goes through the transition region which has a filamentary structure and then reaches the almost uniform downstream state ( @xmath25 ) .
figure [ fig : npv045dev ] shows the time evolution of the number density of ions . the number density shown in color
is averaged over the @xmath26-direction .
the transition region , or `` shock front '' , which is visible as a steep increase in the number density , propagates upstream at an almost constant speed ( @xmath27 measured in the downstream frame ) after @xmath28 .
note that the particles that are reflected at the right wall at the early stage of the simulation , which are remains of the initial condition , eventually fade away at later times .
figure [ fig : profiles_v045 ] shows profiles of quantities averaged over the @xmath26-direction at @xmath24 : ( a ) the ion number density , ( b ) the mean velocity in the @xmath7-direction , and ( c ) the energy densities of electric and magnetic fields . both number density and
mean velocity rapidly change to reach the downstream values through the transition region which extends with the width of @xmath29 .
it is remarkable that a strong magnetic field is generated within the shock transition region .
the energy density of the magnetic field reaches approximately @xmath30 of the upstream bulk kinetic energy density ( measured in the downstream rest frame ) , @xmath31 .
this strong magnetic field deflects and isotropize the particles coming from upstream ; this provides an effective dissipation mechanism for this collisionless shock .
figure [ fig : jxbz_v045 ] shows the current density in the @xmath7-direction , @xmath32 , and the @xmath6-component of the magnetic field , @xmath33 , at @xmath24 .
it is evident that a number of current filaments exist within the transition region .
these filaments consist of ions which are surrounded by the diffuse electrons similar to the case of the relativistic counter - streaming plasmas @xcite .
the filamentary structure seen in the number density in fig .
[ fig : npv045 ] reflects the existence of them . as seen in the figure ,
these filaments generate the strong magnetic field around themselves which is also observed in fig .
[ fig : profiles_v045 ] ( c ) .
this structure would be formed through the weibel - type instability like the relativistic shocks in unmagnetized plasmas @xcite .
we also performed simulations with the bulk velocities of @xmath10 and @xmath11 . in both cases we confirmed that the structure of the shock is qualitatively identical to that of @xmath20 case . the ion number density and
the magnetic field obtained for @xmath34 are shown in fig .
[ fig : npbzv01 ] .
it should be noted that these weibel - mediated shocks have similarities in the profiles of some quantities under changing the upstream bulk velocity @xmath4 .
figure [ fig : npvprofile ] shows the profiles as fig .
[ fig : profiles_v045 ] at different upstream bulk velocities : @xmath9 , @xmath10 and @xmath11 . here , the horizontal axes are the @xmath7-coordinate normalized by the ion inertial length including the relativistic effect , @xmath35 , where @xmath36^{-1/2}$ ] is the lorentz factor of the upstream bulk velocity .
it is remarkable that the profiles in ( a ) and ( b ) are almost identical independent of @xmath4 . in particular , the widths of the shock transition region are @xmath37 in _ all _ cases .
the energy densities of magnetic fields within the transition region also reach typically 1 - 2% of the upstream bulk kinetic energy density at maximum independent of @xmath4 . in order to see the effect of the mass ratio
, we performed simulations for @xmath38 and @xmath39 with @xmath9 .
the normalized ion number densities for the different three mass ratios are shown in fig .
[ fig : m_profile ] as in fig .
[ fig : npvprofile ] ( a ) .
the width of the transition region is approximately @xmath37 in all cases and this suggests the width may be the same order even for the real mass ratio .
however , there is a slight difference in the profiles and this will be investigated in detail in the forthcoming paper .
the similarities in the normalized profiles shown in fig . [ fig : npvprofile ] can be explained as follows .
the structure of the transition region is essentially determined by the coalescence history of the ion current filaments . here , we simply approximate the coalescence of two filaments as that of two straight currents . in this approximation ,
the current in each filament is proportional to the bulk velocity @xmath4 , and a dimensional analysis of the equation of motion of the filaments shows the time scale of the coalescence of two filaments due to the lorentz force , @xmath40 , is proportional to @xmath41 .
thus , if we consider that the width in which the scale of the filamentary structure becomes twice is given by @xmath42 , it is independent of @xmath4 . on the other hand ,
the downstream end of the transition region is determined by the saturation of the magnetic field of the ion current filaments ; i.e. , the typical gyro - radius of ions becomes comparable with the filament size , @xmath43 , like the case of electron - positron current filaments @xcite .
this gives the condition @xmath44 , which is independent of @xmath4 .
therefore , if we consider the initial scale of the ion current filaments is on the order of the electron skin depth @xmath45 , the total width of the transition region is also independent of @xmath4 .
though the results described in the previous section were obtained for unmagnetized plasmas , these weibel - mediated shocks can also be driven in magnetized plasmas if the magnetic field is sufficiently weak .
one of the criteria for neglecting the upstream background magnetic field , @xmath46 , may be given by @xmath47 , where @xmath48 is the typical gyro - radius of ions defined for @xmath46 and @xmath49 is the typical width of the shock transition region .
if we define the magnetization parameter @xmath50 as @xmath51 / [ n_{e0 } ( m_i + m_e ) v^2 /2]$ ] and use the result obtained in the previous section @xmath37 , the criterion can be rewritten @xmath52 . for shocks in supernova remnants ( snrs ) of @xmath53 years
old , typical parameters are @xmath54 @xmath55 , @xmath56 km s@xmath3 , and @xmath57 g . in this case , the magnetization parameter becomes @xmath58 and therefore there is a possibility that the weibel - mediated shocks are driven in snrs . for younger snrs with higher shock speeds of @xmath59 km s@xmath3 ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , these shocks would be formed more easily . if the weibel - mediated shocks are driven even at the velocity of @xmath53 km s@xmath3 , they can be investigated in laboratories because laser experiments are capable of generating collisionless plasma flow at this velocity @xcite . for this plasma flow with @xmath60 @xmath55 ( even at this density
, the plasma can be collisionless during the shock formation ) , the width of the shock transition region is estimated to be @xmath61 mm .
this is a reasonable value as the plasma size produced with the present - day large - scale laser facilities . to demonstrate the shock formation in laboratories is a challenging attempt but it would be particularly worthwhile as one of the key subjects for laboratory astrophysics ( e.g. , *
birdsall , c. k. , & langdon , a. b. 1991 , plasma physics via computer simulation ( iop publishing : bristol ) .
chang , p. , spitkovsky , a. , & arons , j. 2008 , , 674 , 378 frederiksen , j. t. , hededal , c. b. , haugblle , t. , & nordlund , .
2004 , , 608 , l13 fried , b. d. 1959 , phys .
fluids , 2 , 337 gruzinov , a. 2001 , , submitted ( astro - ph/0111321 ) haruki , t. , & sakai , j. 2003 , phys .
plasmas , 10 , 392 kato , t. n. 2005 , phys .
plasmas , 12 , 080705 kato , t. n. 2007 , , 668 , 974 kazimura , y. , sakai , j. i. , neubert , t. , & bulanov , s. v. 1998 , , 498 , l183 medvedev , m. v. , & loeb , a. 1999 , , 526 , 697 moiseev , s. s. , & sagdeev , r. z. 1963 , j. nucl .
energy c , 5 , 43 nishikawa , k .-
i , hardee , p. , richardson , g. , preece , r. , sol , h. , & fishman , g. j. 2003 , , 595 , 555 nishimura , h. , et al .
1981 , , 23 , 2011 reynolds , s. p. , borkowski , k. j. , green , d. a. , hwang , u. , harrus , i. , petre , r. 2008 , , in press ripin , b. h. , et al . 1990 , laser part . beams , 8 , 183 silva , l. o. , fonseca , r. a. , tonge , j. w. , dawson , j. m. , mori , w. b. , & medvedev , m. v. 2003 , 596 , l121 spitkovsky , a. 2005 , in aip conf . proc .
801 , astrophysical sources of high energy particles and radiation , ed .
t. bulik , b. rudak , & g. madejski ( new york : aip ) , 345 spitkovsky , a. 2008 , , 673 , l39 takabe , h. 2004 , nucl .
fusion , 44 , s149 weibel , e. s. 1959 , , 2 , 83 | we show that the weibel - mediated collisionless shocks are driven at non - relativistic propagation speed ( @xmath0 ) in unmagnetized electron - ion plasmas by performing two - dimensional particle - in - cell simulations .
it is shown that the profiles of the number density and the mean velocity in the vicinity of the shock transition region , which are normalized by the respective upstream values , are almost independent of the upstream bulk velocity , i.e. , the shock velocity .
in particular , the width of the shock transition region is @xmath1 ion inertial length independent of the shock velocity . for these shocks
the energy density of the magnetic field generated by the weibel - type instability within the shock transition region reaches typically 1 - 2% of the upstream bulk kinetic energy density .
this mechanism probably explains the robust formation of collisionless shocks , for example , driven by young supernova remnants , with no assumption of external magnetic field in the universe . |
the electron - electron energy - relaxation time determines a number of parameters of nonequilibrium superconductors such as the relaxation times for the amplitude and the phase of the order parameter @xcite .
it is also important for nonequilibrium superconducting radiation detectors based on the resistive and inductive responses .
the electron - electron relaxation time is responsible for the quasiparticle multiplication coefficient which in turn determines the responsivity and detectivity of the detector and its noise characteristics @xcite .
the energy relaxation time also serves as a pair - breaking parameter in the superconducting density of states which is measured in the tunneling experiment @xcite .
recently the energy relaxation time was measured in cuprate superconductors by studying an electronic instability at high vortex velocities in the mixed state @xcite .
the electron - electron relaxation time of clean superconductors was calculated for the three - dimensional case in ref .
@xcite and for the two - dimensional case in ref .
@xcite . in the last work all channels of the electron - electron interaction not only
the coulomb interaction was taken into account by using the matrix classification of the interaction channels developed earlier in refs . @xcite and @xcite .
the importance of considering all channels of interaction was realized long ago for the problem of gauge invariance in superconductors @xcite .
it was also emphasized in ref .
@xcite that interference between different channels of interaction cancels divergences in the interaction correction to the superconducting order parameter .
it is known that in normal impure and low dimensional metals the diffusive motion of electrons leads to enhancement of the electron - electron relaxation @xcite , @xcite .
the purpose of the present paper is to calculate the electron - electron relaxation time in impure two - dimensional superconductors using the formalism of refs . @xcite and @xcite .
earlier attempt to study electron - electron relaxation in impure two - dimensional superconductors @xcite took into account only the coulomb electron - electron interaction and therefore ignored the other relevant interaction channels . as we will show in the present paper including all channels of
the interaction is very important for the electron - electron relaxation , and leads to results qualitatively different from that of ref .
another difference is that we found important contributions to the scattering relaxation time from gapless collective excitations which where mised in ref .
note also that we derived the quasiparticle energy relaxation time from the quantum kinetic equation , not as an imaginary part of the self - energy as in ref .
@xcite .
then we study the superconductor - normal metal two - layer system .
such a system was already studied in ref .
@xcite for a clean system .
we consider a disordered case in the present work and show that recombination relaxation rate is strongly enhanced due to inter - layer electron - electron interaction .
we use the keldysh diagram technique for nonequilibrium processes in which the electron green s functions , along with the electron - electron interaction potential , the electron self energy and the polarization operator are represented by supermatrices @xmath0 the matrix electron green s function in an impure superconductor in the nambu representation has the form @xmath1^*= { -\xi_p\hat\tau_3-\epsilon^r\hat\tau_0+\delta^r\hat\tau_1 \over
\xi_p^2-(e^r)^2},\cr p=({\bf p},\epsilon),\ \ \ \xi_p={p^2-p_f^2\over 2 m } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath2 are the pauli matrices , @xmath3 is the electron mass , and @xmath4 where @xmath5 is the energy gap , @xmath6 is the electron - impurity relaxation time , and @xmath7 in a spatially uniform system the kinetic components @xmath8 and @xmath9 are satisfied the equations @xmath10,\cr
\hat\sigma(p)=s(\epsilon)[\hat \sigma^a(p)-\hat \sigma^r(p ) ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath11 , and @xmath12 is the fermi distribution function .
similar relations hold for matrix interaction potentials and polarization operators : @xmath13,\cr \hat\pi^c(q)=(2n(\omega)+1)[\hat\pi^r(q)-\hat\pi^a(q)],\ \ \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath14 and @xmath15 is the bose distribution function . for averaging over impurity position it is convenient to introduce the following expressions @xmath16 where @xmath17 is the two - spin electron density of states .
calculations give e.g. @xmath18 , \cr \eta_3^{aa}={\zeta_+\over 2}[(1-a)\hat\tau_3+bi\hat\tau_2 ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath19 @xmath20 values of @xmath21 for different matrices @xmath22 are presented in tab .
1 . note also that the following identities hold : @xmath23 and @xmath24 . treating the electron - electron interaction in superconductors we use the matrix formalism developed in refs .
the bare vertices for the electron - electron interaction are classified in terms of the pauli matrices .
physical meaning of the corresponding operators @xmath25 is the following .
matrix @xmath26 corresponds to the order parameter amplitude @xmath5 , matrix @xmath27 corresponds to the order parameter phase @xmath28 , matrix @xmath29 corresponds to the electron density , and the vector matrix @xmath30 corresponds to the electric current , the later will not be considered in the present paper(see ref .
note also that each impurity vertex carries the matrix @xmath29 .
therefore each interaction vertex operates in both keldysh and nambu spaces and has the form @xmath31 , where @xmath22 indicates the component in the nambu space and tensor @xmath32 stands for the keldysh space , @xmath33 is a boson index and @xmath3 and @xmath34 are the electron indices . in the representation corresponding to eq .
1 the nonzero components of tensor @xmath32 are @xmath35 we will omit coefficient @xmath36 in intermediate equations for the impurity renormalized vertices and restore it in final equations for the polarization operators and the electron self energies
. impurity averaging leads to the ladder equation for the scalar vertex @xmath37 shown in fig .
1 . such an equation should be written for each bare matrix @xmath22 in the nambu space .
the solution of these equations for the vertex @xmath37 in the keldysh - nambu space is obtained following ref .
we start with the equation for the vertex @xmath38 , @xmath39 the solution of this equation is @xmath40 note that renormalized vertex @xmath38 has components proportional not only to to matrix @xmath29 but also to matrix @xmath27 . the other vertices
@xmath41 and @xmath42 are presented in tab .
the vertices with the other keldysh indices are obtained from the equations @xmath43,\cr
\hat \gamma^1_{21}(\hat\tau_i)=-s(\epsilon+\omega ) [ \hat \gamma^1_{22}(\hat\tau_i)- \hat \gamma^2_{21}(\hat\tau_i)],\cr \hat \gamma^2_{11}(\hat\tau_i)=s(\epsilon)\hat \gamma^2_{21}(\hat\tau_i ) -s(\epsilon+\omega)\hat \gamma^2_{12}(\hat\tau_i)\cr -[s(\epsilon)-s(\epsilon+\omega)](\hat\gamma^1_{22}(\hat\tau_i))^*. \end{aligned}\ ] ] note also that index structure of the renormalized vertices in the keldysh space is different from the index structure of the bare vertex described by eq .
it is important that the complex conjugate in eq .
( 14 ) operates only in the keldysh space , thus any @xmath44 in tab .
2 originating from @xmath22 matrix algebra are not affected by the complex conjugate , e. g. ( compare with eq .
( 13 ) ) @xmath45 the effective screened electron - electron interaction in a superconductor according to refs .
6 - 8 is shown in fig .
the solution of this equation in @xmath46 matrix form is @xmath47/\cal d & \pi_{23}/\cal d\cr 0 & \pi_{32}/\cal d & -(2/\lambda+\pi_{22})/\cal d } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath48- \pi_{23}\pi_{32 } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath49 is the bcs coupling constant ( @xmath50 ) , @xmath51 is the nonscreened two - dimensional coulomb potential .
the polarization operators renormalized by impurities are expressed through the vertex @xmath52 by the equation @xmath53 using eq .
( 14 ) for @xmath54 and tab .
2 we find the polarization operators , @xmath55\biggr ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath56\biggr ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath57\biggr ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath58 to calculate the electron relaxation we need the imaginary part of the potentials ( the polarization operators ) in the quasiparticle representation . making a transformation from the electronic representation to the quasiparticle representation we use eq .
( 4 ) . as a result
we separate out the processes of scattering and recombination of quasiparticles in eqs .
( 18)-(21 ) . for the imaginary part of the polarization operators we have @xmath59c_{ii}(q,\epsilon,\omega ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath60c_{ii}(q,\epsilon,-\omega ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath61 are @xmath62 @xmath63 @xmath64 for the off - diagonal polarization operator we have @xmath65 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath66 .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] as we will see in the next chapter , calculating the electron relaxation time we need the imaginary part of the propagators @xmath67 .
the imaginary part of the propagators may originate from the poles of the propagators which correspond to collective excitations or from the imaginary part of the polarization operators @xmath68 , which correspond to real processes of scattering and recombination of quasiparticles .
we will restrict our calculations to low temperatures @xmath69 , where large frequencies @xmath70 , are important for both recombination and scattering processes and small frequencies @xmath71 are important only for the scattering processes .
the imaginary part of diagonal polarization operators for in these regions are presented in tab .
real parts of the polarization operators are analyzed in appendix a. now we study in detail each of the matrix elements of @xmath72 . following eq .
( a17 ) the imaginary part of the potential @xmath73 for scattering processes and for small arguments @xmath74 and @xmath75 is @xmath76 this approximation is justified because there is no singularity in the order parameter amplitude propagator @xmath73 at small frequency and momentum for any finite @xmath5 , which means that fluctuations of the amplitude of the order - parameter are massive .
for the recombination processes , large frequencies @xmath77 are important , and according to tab .
3 @xmath78 may be neglected . as was shown in appendix
a , the propagators @xmath79 and @xmath80 for @xmath74 and @xmath75 have the form @xmath81 @xmath82 thus the imaginary part of the propagators @xmath79 and @xmath80 for small arguments comes from the pole corresponding to the phase mode , not from the imaginary part of the polarization operators . for large frequencies @xmath83 we use the following approximation , @xmath84 @xmath85 where @xmath86 is the statically screened coulomb potential in the normal state , which was presented above for the two - dimensional case
, @xmath87 is the screening momentum .
such an approximation is justified due to absence of collective excitation in this frequency region .
the kinetic equation for nonequilibrium distribution function in a spatially uniform system is @xmath88[\hat\sigma^c(p)-s(\epsilon)(\hat\sigma^a(p ) -\hat\sigma^r(p ) ) ] .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] the electron energy relaxation time @xmath89 is determined from the equation @xmath90 the electron self - energy is shown in fig .
3 . using the results of section 2
, we have @xmath91\cr \times{\delta\over \delta s(\epsilon ) } \lbrace{\rm im}v^a_{ii}(q){\rm re}[{\rm pr}_{\hat\tau_i}(\hat\gamma^2_{11 } ( \hat\tau_i))]-2{\rm im}v^a_{23}{\rm im}[{\rm pr}_{\hat\tau_3 } ( \hat\gamma^2_{11}(\hat\tau_2))]\rbrace , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath92 means the component proportional to matrix @xmath22 ( projection on @xmath22 ) . in eq .
( 37 ) summation on repeated indices is implied . using tab . 2 and relation @xmath93 we present eq .
( 37 ) in the form @xmath94\cr
\times\biggl[{\rm im}v_{11}^a(q ) \biggl(\biggl({\xi_\epsilon\over \epsilon } + { \epsilon(\epsilon+\omega)+\delta^2\over \epsilon\xi_{\epsilon+\omega}}\biggr ) { dq^2\over ( \xi_{\epsilon+\omega}+\xi_\epsilon)^2+(dq^2)^2}\cr -\biggl({\xi_\epsilon\over \epsilon } -{\epsilon(\epsilon+\omega)+\delta^2\over \epsilon\xi_{\epsilon+\omega}}\biggr ) { dq^2\over ( \xi_{\epsilon+\omega}-\xi_\epsilon)^2+(dq^2)^2}\biggr)\cr + { \rm im}v_{22}^a(q ) \biggl(\biggl({\xi_\epsilon\over \epsilon } + { \epsilon(\epsilon+\omega)-\delta^2\over \epsilon\xi_{\epsilon+\omega}}\biggr ) { dq^2\over ( \xi_{\epsilon+\omega}+\xi_\epsilon)^2+(dq^2)^2}\cr -\biggl({\xi_\epsilon\over \epsilon } -{\epsilon(\epsilon+\omega)-\delta^2\over \epsilon\xi_{\epsilon+\omega}}\biggr ) { dq^2\over ( \xi_{\epsilon+\omega}-\xi_\epsilon)^2+(dq^2)^2}\biggr)\cr + { \rm im}v_{33}^a(q ) \biggl(\biggl({\xi_\epsilon\over \epsilon } -{\epsilon(\epsilon+\omega)-\delta^2\over \epsilon\xi_{\epsilon+\omega}}\biggr ) { dq^2\over ( \xi_{\epsilon+\omega}+\xi_\epsilon)^2+(dq^2)^2}\cr -\biggl({\xi_\epsilon\over \epsilon } + { \epsilon(\epsilon+\omega)-\delta^2\over \epsilon\xi_{\epsilon+\omega}}\biggr ) { dq^2\over ( \xi_{\epsilon+\omega}-\xi_\epsilon)^2+(dq^2)^2}\biggr)\cr + 2i{\rm im}v^a_{23}{\omega\delta\over\epsilon\xi_{\epsilon+\omega } } \biggl({dq^2\over ( \xi_{\epsilon+\omega}+\xi_\epsilon)^2+(dq^2)^2 } + { dq^2\over ( \xi_{\epsilon+\omega}-\xi_\epsilon)^2+(dq^2)^2}\biggr)\biggr].\end{aligned}\ ] ] in order to separate out the processes of scattering and recombination of quasiparticles we need to make a transformation from the electronic representation to the quasiparticle representation in eq .
note that the presence of imaginary factor @xmath44 in the last term in eq .
( 38 ) means that for the contribution of the nondiagonal channels of interaction requires the states under the gap to be taken into account according to the equation : @xmath95^{1/2},\ \ |\epsilon+\omega|<\delta$ ] .
such states should also be included in equations for the polarization operator @xmath96 , in eqs .
( 28 ) and ( 29 ) only the states above the gap were included .
the analysis similar to that presented in ref . 6 for the clean case shows that contribution from the nondiagonal channels of interaction may be neglected . for electrons on the fermi surface , @xmath97 , @xmath98 { dq^2\over \omega^2-\delta\omega + ( dq^2)^2}\cr \times\biggl[[{\rm im}v_{22}^a(q)_{recom } + { \rm im}v_{33}^a(q)_{recom } ] \biggl({\delta\over 2\omega}\biggl)^{1/2}\biggr]\cr + { 2\over \pi^3}\int_0^\infty d\omega\int_0^\infty dqq[n(\omega)+n(\omega+\delta ) ] { dq^2\over 2\delta\omega+\omega^2 + ( dq^2)^2}\cr \times\biggl[{\rm im}v_{11}^a(q)_{scatt } \biggl({2\delta+\omega\over \omega}\biggr)^{1/2}+[{\rm im}v_{22}^a(q)_{scatt}+ { \rm im}v_{33}^a(q)_{scatt } ] \biggl({\delta\over 2\omega}\biggl)^{1/2}\biggr],\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath99 { dq^2\over \omega^2-\delta\omega + ( dq^2)^2}\cr \times\biggl[{\rm im}v_{11}^a(q)_{scatt } \biggl({\omega-2\delta\over \omega}\biggr)^{1/2}+[{\rm im}v_{22}^a(q)_{scatt } + { \rm im}v_{33}^a(q)_{scatt } ] \biggl({\delta\over 2\omega}\biggl)^{1/2}\biggr]\cr + { 2\over \pi^3}\int_{2\delta}^\infty d\omega\int_0^\infty dqq[n(\omega)+n(\omega+\delta ) ] { dq^2\over 2\delta\omega+\omega^2 + ( dq^2)^2}\cr \times\biggl[[{\rm im}v_{22}^a(q)_{recom}+ { \rm im}v_{33}^a(q)_{recom } ] \biggl({\delta\over 2\omega}\biggl)^{1/2}\biggr ] .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] eqs .
( 39 ) and ( 40 ) describe processes of scattering `` two into two '' and `` three into one '' quasiparticles correspondingly .
further calculations will be performed for low temperatures @xmath69 .
it may be shown that the most important contribution to the recombination time originates from terms @xmath100 and @xmath101 in eq .
( 40 ) , @xmath102 calculating the scattering relaxation time from terms @xmath100 and @xmath101 in eq .
( 38 ) we use the approximation of eqs . ( 33 ) and ( 34 ) and we use tab . 3 for the imaginary parts of the polarization operators . as a result
we get @xmath103 as for the contribution to the scattering relaxation time from terms @xmath104 and @xmath105 in eq .
( 38 ) we note that for small energy transfers , @xmath71 the imaginary part of the propagators @xmath79 and @xmath80 originates from the poles corresponding to the phase mode as seen in eqs .
( 31 ) and ( 32 ) ) . integrating these poles over the momentum
@xmath106 we get @xmath107 note that the main contribution comes from the propagator @xmath80 corresponding to the fluctuation of the phase of the order parameter .
the term @xmath108 does not have poles corresponding to the collective mode , thus using eq .
( 30 ) we find that the scattering relaxation time has a power law divergence , @xmath109 this divergence is similar to the logarithmic divergence of the phase or energy relaxation times in the normal impure two - dimensional case@xmath110 .
according to ref .
14 the cutoff frequency @xmath111 is defined by the relaxation time @xmath89 , which physically means that the kinetic equation can not be applied for energy transfers less than @xmath112 , thus the self - consistent solution of eq .
( 44 ) is @xmath113 the low - frequency singularity in the scattering relaxation time mentioned above is for electrons exactly at the fermi surface , @xmath97 .
we note that for the electrons above the fermi surface , @xmath114 the singularity in the scattering relaxation time associated with the potential @xmath108 is weaker but it does not disappear .
more accurately such a divergence must be regularized directly in the physically measurable quantity e.g. the tunneling conductance .
however it is not necessary because the contribution to the scattering relaxation time from the phase collective mode , eq .
( 43 ) , is more important because it does not have a small exponential factor such as that presented in eqs .
( 42 ) and ( 45 ) .
the appearance of the nonexponential scattering relaxation at low temperature is a direct consequence of the gapless phase mode in two dimensions . in three dimensions
the phase mode have a gap and the main contribution to the scattering relaxation comes from the potential @xmath73 .
@xmath115 where @xmath116 is the three - dimensional density of states .
again after regularization of singularity in eq .
( 46 ) we have @xmath117 the recombination relaxation time is obtained similar to eq .
( 41 ) , @xmath118
we consider a system of two disordered electron layers with different density of states , @xmath119 , elastic scattering times , @xmath120 , mean free paths , @xmath121 , and diffusion coefficients @xmath122 .
the layers are coupled by the coulomb potentials , there is no superconducting coupling between the layers .
first we consider the screened coulomb potentials in the normal state .
the nonscreened coulomb potentials within the layer , @xmath123 , and between electrons in different planes , @xmath124 , are @xmath125 where @xmath126 and @xmath127 are the dielectric constants of the electron layer and the inter - layer media , @xmath128 is the distance between layers .
we assume that @xmath129 and we absorbed @xmath126 into @xmath130 in all further calculations small momentum transfers are important , thus we assume @xmath131 , @xmath132 in this chapter the lower indices of the potentials and the polarization operators refer to the layer , e.g. @xmath73 means the coulomb potential between electrons in the layer 1 , etc .
the screened potentials are satisfied the equations @xmath133 we will use the definitions : @xmath134 , @xmath135 , and @xmath136 .
the solution of eq .
( 3 ) is @xmath137 the polarization operators in each layers for @xmath138 and @xmath139 are chosen in the form corresponding to a normal state , because for recombination processes large frequencies @xmath77 are important , while collective excitations in a superconductor exist only for @xmath74 .
@xmath140 the potentials are @xmath141 @xmath142 where @xmath143 we assume that layer 1 is in the superconducting state and layer 2 is in the normal state .
we will calculate the recombination relaxation time in the superconducting layer due to inter - layer electron - electron interaction @xmath144 . from eq .
( 40 ) we have @xmath145 { d_1q^2\over \omega^2-\delta\omega + ( d_1q^2)^2}\cr { \rm im}u^a(q)\biggl({\delta\over 2\omega}\biggl)^{1/2}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] for the imaginary part of the iner - layer interaction we use the approximation similar to eq . ( 33 ) , @xmath146 corresponds to the electron scattering in the normal layer and thus does not have a small exponential factor typical for a superconductor . as a result @xmath147
we see that relaxation rate in a superconductor - normal metal two - layer system is increased by an exponential factor in comparison with the recombination rate in a single layer , see eq .
we derived the kinetic equation describing the electron relaxation in two - dimensional impure superconductors . for electrons at the fermi surface , @xmath97 ,
the recombination and scattering relaxation time were calculated for low temperatures , @xmath69 .
we took into account all channels of the electron - electron interaction in the superconductor .
we found that the recombination relaxation rate comes from the quasiparticle scattering ( recombination processes ) associated with the fluctuations of the electron density and the phase of the order parameter , the propagators @xmath79 and @xmath80 . the recombination relaxation rate has double exponential smallness at low temperatures ( see eq .
( 41 ) ) , associated with exponentially small number of available quasiparticles .
the scattering relaxation rate has a power law temperature dependence ( see eq .
( 43 ) ) due to singularity in the propagators @xmath80 and @xmath79 associated with the gapless collective mode , the phase mode .
the contribution to the scattering relaxation rate from the fluctuations of the amplitude of the order parameter , @xmath73 has an infrared divergence similar to the phase relaxation time in the two - dimensional normal metal @xcite , however after regularization the corresponding contribution to the scattering relaxation rate has a small exponential factor and therefore is less important that the contribution from the collective excitations .
we also shown that in the superconductor - normal metal two - layer system the recombination relaxation rate in the superconducting layer due to the inter - layer coulomb interaction is strongly increased at low temperatures @xmath69 by an exponential factor @xmath148 in comparison with a single superconducting layer .
this fact may be important for constructing superconducting radiation detectors @xcite .
in this appendix we obtain equations for the polarization operators for some limiting cases and prove some identities for them . though some of the results were already presented in ref .
8 , for matsubara frequencies and in ref . 15 for @xmath149
the analysis for continious frequencies has some advantages and helps us to estimate the imaginary parts of the interaction propagators .
we start with the polarization operators for @xmath150 .
@xmath151 may be taken directly from eq .
( 21 ) , @xmath152 where @xmath153 then we take @xmath154 from eq .
( 19 ) , @xmath155 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and transform it using the identities @xmath156 @xmath157 to the form @xmath158 now recalling the bcs selfconsistancy equation @xmath159 we see that @xmath160 to transform @xmath161 , @xmath162 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] we use the identities @xmath163 @xmath164 and get @xmath165 now we recall another identity , @xmath166 and get @xmath167 we see from eqs .
( a5 ) , ( a8 ) , and ( a13 ) that the following identity holds @xmath168 at low temperatures , @xmath69 and for small arguments @xmath74 and @xmath75 , the polarization operators are @xmath169,\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath170,\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath171 . \end{aligned}\ ] ] thus for small arguments the following relation holds @xcite @xmath172 using eq .
( a16 ) we have for the propagator @xmath73 @xmath173 we see that @xmath73 is not singular which means that fluctuations of the amplitude of the order parameter are massive , thus the imaginary part of the propagator @xmath73 originates from @xmath174 .
the screened coulomb potential is presented in the form @xmath175 where @xmath176 the propagator @xmath80 may be written in a similar way @xmath177 the poles in the propagators @xmath79 and @xmath80 correspond to the collective excitation , the phase mode , which in two dimensions is @xcite given by equation @xmath178 . in quasi - one - dimensional superconductors
the nonscreened coulomb potential is @xmath179 , @xmath180 , where @xmath181 is a cross - sectional size , and the density of states is @xmath182 , thus the spectrum of the pase mode is @xcite @xmath183 it is interesting to see how the spectrum of the phase mode changes in different two - layer systems .
first we consider a system of two identical impure superconducting planes coupled by the coulomb interaction , but no josephson coupling between the planes , thus the order parameters are independent in each planes . for the screened coulomb potential in each layer we have from eq .
( 52 ) @xmath184\tilde\pi(q)\over [ 1-v_0(q)\tilde\pi(q)]^2-[u_0(q)\tilde\pi(q)]^2}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] to avoid confusion we dropped lower indices in the coulomb potential @xmath185 .
the spectrum of the phase modes is defined by equations @xmath186 and @xmath187 .
the solution of these equations for @xmath188 is @xmath189 and @xmath190 .
these new phase modes are similar to in - phase and out - of - phase plasmons in symmetric two - layer clean normal metal system , see @xcite and @xcite .
now we consider a two - layer superconductor - normal metal disordered system .
the polarization operators in the superconducting and normal layers according to eqs .
( a22 ) and ( 53 ) are @xmath192 @xmath193 the spectrum of collective excitations is determined from the equation @xmath194 for small momenta @xmath195 , @xmath196 eq .
( b4 ) leads to @xmath197 the solution of eq .
( b5 ) is a phase mode with small damping @xmath198 the last inequality is satisfied provided @xmath199 and @xmath200 .
this result was independently obtained in @xcite . if the opposite inequality is valid , the solution of eq .
( b6 ) is a diffusion mode , @xmath201.\end{aligned}\ ] ] , ed . by d. n. langenberg and a. i. larkin , elsevier ( 1986 ) .
a. v. sergeev and m. reizer , int .
b * 10 * , 635 ( 1996 ) .
d. s. pyun and t. r. lemberger , phys .
b * 43 * , 3732 ( 1991 ) .
s. g. doettinger , s. kittenberger , r. p. huebener , and c. c. tsuei , phys .
b * 56 * , 14157 ( 1997 ) .
reizer , phys .
b * 39 * , 1602 ( 1989 ) .
reizer , phys .
b. * 57 * , 1147 ( 1998 ) .
i. o. kulik , o. entin - wohlman , and r. orbach , j. low temp . phys . * 43 * , 591 ( 1981 ) .
r. a. smith , m. reizer , j. w. wilkins , phys . rev .
b * 51 * , 6470 ( 1995 ) .
j. r. shrieffer , _ theory of superconductivity _ , chapter 8 , addison - wesley , redwood city , 1988 .
a. schmid , z. phys .
* 271 * , 251 ( 1974 ) .
b. l. altshuler and a. g. aronov , pisma zh .
* 30 * , 514 ( 1979 ) ; [ sov .
jetp lett .
* 30 * , 482 ( 1979 ) ] . for a review see b. l. altshuler and a. g. aronov , _ electron - electron interaction in disordered systems _ , edited by a. l. efros and m. polak north - holland , amsterdam , 1985 .
t. p. devereaux and d. belitz , phys .
44 * , 4587 ( 1991 ) ; j. low temp . phys . * 77 * , 319 ( 1989 ) .
m. yu . reizer and a. v. sergeev , zh .
fiz . * 90 * , 1056 ( 1986 ) [ sov .
zetp * 63 * , 616 ( 1986 ) ] .
b. l. altshuler , a. g. aronov , and d. e. khmelnitskii , j. phys .
c * 15 * , 7367 ( 1982 ) .
u. eckern and f. pelzer , j. low temp .
phys . * 73 * , 433 ( 1988 ) .
y. takada , j. phys .
. jpn . * 43 * , 1627 ( 1977 ) ; s. das sarma and a. madhukar , phys . rev .
b * 23 * , 805 ( 1981 ) .
j. e. mooij and g. schn , phys .
* 55 * , 114 ( 1985 ) .
b. n. narozhny , i. l. aleiner , and b. l. altshuler , phys .
b ( 1999 ) . | the electron - electron relaxation in impure two - dimensional superconductors is studied .
all channels of the electron - electron interaction classified in the nambu representation are taken into account .
it is shown that the recombination relaxation rate originates from quasipartical processes associated with fluctuations of the electron density and the phase of the order parameter . at low temperatures
the recombination relaxation rate has a double exponential temperature dependence .
the scattering relaxation rate at low temperatures has a power law temperature dependence due to contributions from gapless collective excitations , the phase modes .
two - layer superconductor - normal metal system is also considered .
it is shown that the recombination relaxation rate in the superconducting layer has a single exponential factor at low temperatures in comparison with a one layer superconducting system .
this increase in the recombination relaxation rate originates from the inter - layer coulomb interaction and may be used in constructing of superconducting radiation detectors . |
let @xmath0 be the divided power algebra in a variable @xmath4 over the commutative ring @xmath1 . recall that @xmath0 is free as a @xmath1-module with basis @xmath5 } , x^{[1 ] } , \ldots$ ] , and multiplication is defined by @xmath6 } x^{[m ] } = \binom{n+m}{n } x^{[n+m]}.\ ] ] if @xmath7 then @xmath0 is isomorphic to the polynomial ring @xmath8 $ ] via @xmath9 } \mapsto \frac{x^n}{n!}$ ] .
however , in general @xmath0 is quite different from the polynomial ring : for example , if @xmath10 then @xmath0 is not even noetherian .
this paper is an investigation of the theory of @xmath0-modules . even though @xmath0 is typically non - noetherian
, we show that finitely presented @xmath0-modules are well - behaved , and prove a variety of results concerning them . in the remainder of the introduction , we summarize our results and explain our motivation for studying @xmath0-modules .
recall that a ring @xmath11 is * coherent * if every finitely generated ideal is finitely presented .
equivalently , @xmath11 is coherent if the kernel of any map of finitely presented modules is again finitely presented ; this ensures that the category of finitely presented modules is abelian .
our first result about @xmath0 is : [ mainthm : coh ] if @xmath1 is noetherian then @xmath0 is coherent
. in fact , our results are more precise , in two ways .
first , we give a complete characterization of the rings @xmath1 for which @xmath0 is graded - coherent ( meaning any finitely generated homogeneous ideal is finitely presented ) : namely , @xmath0 is graded - coherent if and only if @xmath1 is coherent and for any finitely generated ideal @xmath12 of @xmath1 , the torsion submodule of @xmath13 has finite exponent .
and second , when @xmath1 is noetherian , we actually prove that @xmath0 is * grbner - coherent*. this is a notion we introduce in @xcite , which basically means that there is a good theory of grbner bases for finitely generated ideals in @xmath0 .
in particular , this means that calculations with finitely presented @xmath0-modules are algorithmic , at least in principle .
we next investigate the structure of finitely presented @xmath0-modules , working under the assumption that @xmath1 is noetherian .
we first construct certain nice resolutions . in general , finitely presented @xmath0-modules do not have finite projective dimension .
there are two obsturctions .
first , if @xmath14 is a @xmath1-module with infinite projective dimension then @xmath15 has infinite projective dimension as a @xmath0-module . and second , if @xmath16 is
non - zero and @xmath17 is a power of @xmath18 then @xmath19}\ ] ] is naturally a @xmath0-module , and does not have finite projective dimension .
we therefore introduce a class of modules that includes the above two counterexamples : we say that a @xmath0-module @xmath14 is * special * if it has a finite length filtration such that the graded pieces have the form @xmath20 , where @xmath14 is a finitely generated @xmath1-module , @xmath2 is a power of a prime @xmath18 , and @xmath21 if @xmath22 .
we then prove : [ intro : sr ] every finitely presented @xmath0-module @xmath14 admits a finite resolution @xmath23 by special modules .
in fact , one can take @xmath24 to be free and @xmath25 to be special , and one can bound @xmath26 in terms of the krull dimension of @xmath1 ( if it is finite ) . as consequence of this theorem , we obtain a useful spanning set for the grothendieck group @xmath27 of finitely presented @xmath0-modules . with more work ,
we prove : [ intro : intk ] there is a canonical short exact sequence @xmath28 where the direct sum is taken over all prime numbers .
this sequence splits if and only if for every prime @xmath18 the natural map @xmath29 is zero .
we next investigate the injective dimension of @xmath0-modules .
we begin by completely characterizing the injective dimension of @xmath0 over itself when @xmath1 is a field .
we next show that if @xmath30 is a bounded complex of @xmath1-modules with finitely generated homology and injective amplitude @xmath31 $ ] then @xmath32 has injective amplitude @xmath33 $ ] , and show that @xmath34 can be lowered to @xmath35 or even @xmath36 in certain cases .
using this , we show that if @xmath37 is a dualizing complex for @xmath1 then @xmath38 is one for @xmath0 . in particular ,
if @xmath1 admits a dualizing complex then the bounded derived category of finitely presented @xmath0-modules is self - dual .
next we study the relationship between torsion modules and finitely presented modules . here , an element @xmath39 of a @xmath0-module @xmath14 is said to be * torsion * if @xmath9 } m=0 $ ] for all @xmath40 , and @xmath14 is said to be * torsion * if all of its elements are . if @xmath1 contains a field of characteristic 0
then @xmath41 $ ] , and finitely presented @xmath0-modules can have torsion , e.g. , @xmath8/(x)$ ] .
however , this is essentially the only example : the following conditions are equivalent : 1 .
every finitely presented @xmath0-module is torsion - free . 2 .
every maximal ideal of @xmath1 has positive residue characteristic .
when @xmath1 is @xmath18-adically complete , we can say much more , at least for graded modules : [ intro : torext ] suppose @xmath1 is @xmath18-adically complete .
let @xmath14 and @xmath42 be graded @xmath0-modules , with @xmath14 finitely presented and @xmath42 torsion
. then @xmath43 for all @xmath44 .
here @xmath45 denotes a graded version of @xmath46 , see [ ss : notation ] .
the above theorem is false without the completeness hypothesis , see remark [ rmk : ext - torsion ] .
it is also false in the non - graded case , as example [ ex : ext ] ( with @xmath10 ) shows .
finally , motivated by certain applications ( see [ ss : motivation ] ) , we study `` nearly finitely presented '' ( nfp ) @xmath0-modules .
a graded @xmath0-module @xmath14 is nfp if there exists a finitely presented @xmath0-module @xmath47 ( called a * weak fp - envelope * of @xmath14 ) such that @xmath48 as @xmath0-modules , where @xmath49 denotes truncation to degrees @xmath50 ( see [ s : nfp ] ) .
when @xmath1 is complete , nfp modules are very well behaved : suppose @xmath1 is @xmath18-adically complete .
then the kernel , cokernel , and image of a map of nfp modules is again nfp , and so the category of nfp modules is abelian .
furthermore , the weak fp - envelope @xmath47 of an nfp module @xmath14 is unique up to canonical isomorphism , and there exists a canonical map @xmath51 that is universal among maps from @xmath14 to finitely presented modules . as with the previous theorem ,
this one is false without the completeness assumption , see proposition [ prop : counter - example ] .
when @xmath1 is not complete , we can at least prove uniqueness of the weak fp - envelope in some cases : suppose that every maximal ideal of @xmath1 has residue characteristic @xmath18 , for some fixed prime number @xmath18 .
then the weak fp - envelope of an nfp module is unique up to isomorphism .
the isomorphism in the above theorem is not canonical , and the weak fp - envelope of @xmath14 is not functorial in @xmath14 .
the above theorem can fail without the hypothesis on @xmath1 : if @xmath1 is a number ring with non - trivial class group then weak nfp - envelopes are necessarily non - unique , see proposition [ prop : class - group ] .
let @xmath52 .
one then defines @xmath53_q = 1+q+\cdots+q^{n-1 } = \frac{q^n-1}{q-1}\ ] ] and @xmath53_q !
= [ n]_q [ n-1]_q \cdots [ 1]_q , \qquad { n \brack m}_q = \frac{[n]_q!}{[n - m]_q !
[ m]_q!}.\ ] ] the quantity @xmath54 is a polynomial in @xmath2 , and called the * @xmath2-binomial coefficient * ( or * gaussian binomial coefficient * ) .
one can modify the definition of the divided power algbera by replacing the usual binomial coefficients with their @xmath2- counterparts .
the result is called the * @xmath2-divided power algbera*. all of the results in this paper apply to , and are proved for , @xmath2-divided power algebras . , for which we only have partial results . ] in fact , we work even more generally .
let @xmath55 be a sequence of elements in @xmath1 that is `` admissible '' in the sense that if @xmath56 and @xmath57 belong to a common maximal ideal then @xmath58 or @xmath59 .
we define @xmath60 and @xmath61 the above coefficients are called * @xmath62-binomial coefficients*. one can modify the definition of the divided power algebra by replacing the usual binomial coefficients with their @xmath62 counterparts .
the resulting algebra is denoted @xmath63 and called a * generalized divided power algebra * ( gdpa ) .
see proposition [ prop : chargdpa ] for an intrinsic characterization of these algebras and proposition [ prop : gcd - morphic ] for an enlightening description of admissible sequences when @xmath1 is a pid . as one would expect , the main examples of interest fit into this general setup : 1 . if @xmath64 for all @xmath65 then @xmath66 $ ] .
2 . define @xmath56 to be @xmath18 if @xmath65 is a power of a prime @xmath18 , and 1 if @xmath65 is not a prime power .
then @xmath63 is the usual divided power algebra over @xmath1 .
( in the context of gdpa s , we refer to this as the * classical divided power algebra*. ) 3 .
suppose @xmath67 where @xmath68 is the @xmath65th cyclotomic polynomial
. then @xmath63 is the @xmath2-divided power algebra .
in fact , by taking @xmath69 or @xmath70 , example ( c ) reverts to ( a ) or ( b ) .
all of the results of this paper are proved for arbitrary gdpa s .. ] working in this generality actually makes the structure of many arguments more clear and is no more difficult than treating the @xmath2-divided power algebra .
a famous theorem of nakaoka asserts that the cohomology of symmetric groups stabilizes : for any coefficient ring @xmath1 , the restriction map @xmath71 is an isomorphism for @xmath72 . motivated by applications to the cohomology of configuration spaces , the first author @xcite generalized nakaoka s theorem to allow for non - trivial coefficients , as follows .
an * fi - module * over @xmath1 is a sequence @xmath73 , where @xmath74 is a @xmath75$]-module , equipped with certain transition maps @xmath76 .
the main theorem of @xcite states that if @xmath1 is a field of characteristic @xmath18 and @xmath14 is a finitely generated @xmath77-module over @xmath1 then , for fixed @xmath78 , the dimension of @xmath79 is periodic in @xmath65 with period a power of @xmath18 . in the forthcoming paper @xcite
, we generalize this periodicity theorem and greatly simplify its proof . for an @xmath77-module @xmath14 ,
define @xmath80 then @xmath81 naturally has the structure of a graded @xmath0-module , where @xmath0 is the univariate classical divided power algebra over @xmath1 .
the main theorem of @xcite states that when @xmath1 is noetherian and @xmath14 is finitely generated , the @xmath0-module @xmath81 is nearly finitely presented .
when @xmath1 is a field , this immediately implies the periodicity result of @xcite . it would be natural to attempt to generalize the results of this paper to divided power algebras in several variables .
unfortunately , the basic coherence property fails in multiple variables ( see [ ss : two - variable ] ) , so it is not clear to us what one could hope to say .
( we note , however , that coherence still holds when @xmath1 is a field . ) by a graded ring or module , we will always mean one graded by the integers .
our rings are almost always concentrated in non - negative degrees .
suppose @xmath82 is a graded module .
for integers @xmath2 and @xmath83 , we let @xmath84 be the direct sum of the graded pieces @xmath85 with @xmath86 , and we omit the @xmath83 when @xmath87 . if @xmath11 is a graded ring then @xmath88 is again a graded ring , and each @xmath89 is an @xmath88-module . by the * regrade * of @xmath90 we mean the module that is @xmath91 in degree @xmath65 .
we write @xmath92 for the sum of the @xmath93 with @xmath94 .
let @xmath95 be a graded ring .
we write @xmath96 for the category of graded @xmath95-modules and @xmath97 for the category of non - graded modules .
let @xmath14 and @xmath47 be graded @xmath95-modules .
we write @xmath98 for the set of all modules maps @xmath99 \to n$ ] where the grading is respected , and we put @xmath100 this is a graded @xmath95-module .
we write @xmath101 for the set of all module maps @xmath51 , ignoring the grading .
there is a natural map @xmath102 which is an isomorphism if @xmath14 is finitely generated .
we write @xmath45 for the derived functor of @xmath103 .
in [ s : adm ] , we introduce and study @xmath104-sequences , and in [ s : gdpa ] we use them to define gdpa s . in [ s : coh ] , we prove coherence results for gdpa s , including a much more general version of theorem [ mainthm : coh ] . in [ s : sr ] , [ s : groth ] , [ s : inj ] , [ s : tor ] , [ s : nfp ] , we study finitely presented and nearly finitely presented @xmath0-modules . finally , [
s : prob ] lists some open problems .
the second author thanks bhargav bhatt for helpful conversations .
a * divisible sequence * is a sequence of positive integers @xmath105 , either infinite or finite in length , such that @xmath106 properly divides @xmath107 , whenever @xmath107 is defined .
every integer @xmath108 can be written uniquely in the form @xmath109 where @xmath110 ( we assume that @xmath111 if @xmath112 is the least integer such that @xmath106 is not defined ) .
we call this the * base @xmath113 representation * of @xmath65 . carries in base @xmath113 addition
will play a prominent role in this paper . for an integer @xmath114 ,
put @xmath115 one easily sees that @xmath116 is either 0 or 1 : in fact , @xmath116 can be interpreted as the carry produced in the one s place when adding @xmath65 and @xmath39 in base @xmath83 .
thus @xmath117 is the carry in the @xmath112th place when adding @xmath65 and @xmath39 in base @xmath113 .
a * @xmath104-sequence * in a ring @xmath1 is simply a sequence @xmath118 of elements of @xmath1 . by convention
, we always put @xmath119 .
let @xmath120 be the ring @xmath121_{n \ge 2}$ ] , where the elements @xmath122 are indeterminates .
then the @xmath104-sequence @xmath123 in @xmath120 is universal : if @xmath62 is any @xmath104-sequence in a ring @xmath1 then there is a unique ring homomorphism @xmath124 such that @xmath125 .
a * @xmath104-invariant * is a rule @xmath126 assigning to every @xmath104-sequence @xmath62 in any ring @xmath1 an element @xmath127 of @xmath1 such that if @xmath128 is a ring homomorphism then @xmath129 .
we have @xmath130 for some polynomial @xmath131 , and thus @xmath132 for every @xmath104-sequence @xmath62 in any ring @xmath1 .
conversely , if @xmath133 then @xmath134 defines a @xmath104-invariant .
suppose @xmath126 and @xmath135 are @xmath104-invariants such that @xmath136 divides @xmath137 in @xmath120 .
we then define @xmath138 to be the @xmath104-invariant associated to @xmath139 . by abuse of notation , we typically write @xmath140 for the value of @xmath138 on @xmath62 . if @xmath141 is a non - zero divisor then @xmath140 is equal to @xmath142 , where the division is performed in @xmath1 . however , if @xmath143 is a zero - divisor then one can not determine @xmath140 from @xmath127 and @xmath143 . for @xmath144 define @xmath104-invariants @xmath145 and @xmath146 by @xmath60 and @xmath147
we remark that mbius inversion gives the identity @xmath148 and so @xmath56 can be recovered from the @xmath149 s provided they are not zero - divisors . for @xmath150 , we define a @xmath104-invariant @xmath151 by @xmath152 we think of @xmath145 as the @xmath62-analog of @xmath65 , @xmath146 as the analog of @xmath153 , and @xmath151 as the analog of the binomial coefficient @xmath154 .
this last point is justified by the following observation : we have @xmath155 the power of @xmath156 in @xmath145 is 1 if @xmath65 is a multiple of @xmath83 , and 0 otherwise .
thus the power of @xmath156 in @xmath146 is the number of multiples of @xmath83 between 1 and @xmath65 , namely @xmath157 .
therefore , the power of @xmath156 in the above fraction is @xmath158 , and this proves the identity
. the following property of @xmath159 will be important later : [ prop : binom ] for @xmath160 we have @xmath161 since @xmath162 is a coboundary , it satisfies the cocycle identity @xmath163 the proposition follows directly from this .
let @xmath165 be an integer .
we define the * @xmath164-transform * of the @xmath104-sequence @xmath62 to be the @xmath104-sequence @xmath166}_{\bullet}$ ] given by @xmath167}_n=\prod_{d \mid h , ( h / d , n)=1 } \pi_{dn}\ ] ] we write @xmath168}(n)$ ] in places of @xmath169}_{\bullet})$ ] , and similarly for @xmath170}$ ] , @xmath171}$ ] , etc .
the motivation for this construction is not immediately clear , but example [ ex : q - dgpa ] should provide some intuition .
we have @xmath168}(n)=\ { a(hn)/a(h ) \}$ ] .
it suffices to prove @xmath168}(n)=a(hn)/a(h)$ ] for the universal @xmath104-sequence .
we have @xmath172}_{\bullet } ) = \prod_{d \mid n , d \ne 1 } \pi_d^{[h ] } = \prod_{\substack{d \mid n , d ' \mid h \\
d \ne 1 , ( h / d ' , d)=1 } } \pi_{dd'}.\ ] ] multiplying both sides by @xmath173 , we obtain @xmath174}_{\bullet } ) = \prod_{\substack{d \mid n , d ' \mid h \\ dd ' \ne 1 , ( h / d ' , d)=1 } } \pi_{dd ' } = \prod_{d \mid nh , d \ne 1 } \pi_d = a(hn),\ ] ] where in the second step we use the following lemma .
this proves the result .
let @xmath65 and @xmath164 be positive integers
. then every divisor of @xmath175 can be written uniquely as @xmath176 , where @xmath135 divides @xmath65 , @xmath177 divides @xmath164 , and @xmath178 .
let @xmath39 be a divisor of @xmath175 .
then @xmath179 is a divisor of @xmath164 and @xmath180 is a divisor of @xmath65 such that @xmath181 and @xmath182 . to show uniqueness
, suppose that @xmath183 with @xmath184 .
then @xmath185 , so @xmath186 , which shows that @xmath187 , and so @xmath188 .
[ dbltrans ] we have @xmath189}_{\bullet})_{\phantom \bullet}^{[h']}=\pi^{[hh']}_{\bullet}$ ] .
again , it suffices to work in the universal case .
we have @xmath190}_{\bullet})_{\phantom \bullet}^{[h ' ] } ) = \frac{a(h'n ; \pi^{[h]}_{\bullet})}{a(h ' ; \pi^{[h]}_{\bullet } ) } = \frac{a(hh'n ; \pi_{\bullet})/a(h ; \pi_{\bullet})}{a(hh ' ; \pi_{\bullet})/a(h ; \pi_{\bullet } ) } = \frac{a(hh'n ; \pi_{\bullet})}{a(hh ' ; \pi_{\bullet})}.\ ] ] thus the two sequences @xmath189}_{\bullet})_{\phantom \bullet}^{[h']}$ ] and @xmath191}_{\bullet}$ ] define the same @xmath192 s , and are therefore equal by mbius inversion ( which is allowed here since in the universal case the @xmath56 s are not zero - divisors ) .
we say that the @xmath104-sequence @xmath62 is * admissible * if the following condition holds : if @xmath193 is not the unit ideal of @xmath1 then either @xmath58 or @xmath59 .
equivalently , @xmath62 is admissible if whenever @xmath56 and @xmath57 belong to some maximal ideal @xmath194 either @xmath58 or @xmath59 .
suppose @xmath62 is admissible , and let @xmath12 be a proper ideal of @xmath1 .
define a sequence @xmath195 inductively as follows .
first , @xmath196 . having defined @xmath197 , let @xmath198 be the smallest integer @xmath65 greater than @xmath197 such that @xmath199 ; if no such integer exists , @xmath198 is undefined and the sequence has finite length . the sequence @xmath195 is divisible ( as defined in
[ subsec : divisible - sequence ] ) .
[ seq : adimg ] let @xmath200 be a ring homomorphism , let @xmath62 be an admissible @xmath104-sequence in @xmath1 , and let @xmath201 be its image in @xmath202 .
then @xmath201 is also admissible .
if @xmath203 is not the unit ideal of @xmath202 then certainly @xmath193 is not the unit ideal of @xmath1 , and so @xmath58 or @xmath59 .
if @xmath62 is admissible so is @xmath166}_{\bullet}$ ] , for any @xmath165 .
let @xmath194 be a maximal ideal of @xmath1 , and suppose @xmath166}_n$ ] and @xmath166}_m$ ] belong to @xmath194 .
then @xmath204 for some @xmath205 with @xmath206 , and similarly @xmath207 for some @xmath208 with @xmath209 .
since @xmath62 is admissible , either @xmath210 or @xmath211 ; without loss of generality , assume the former .
we claim @xmath58 , which will complete the proof .
it suffices to show @xmath212 for all primes @xmath18 , where @xmath213 is the @xmath18-adic valution .
thus let @xmath18 be given .
if @xmath214 there is nothing to prove , so suppose @xmath215 .
the divisibility @xmath210 translates to the inequality @xmath216 if @xmath217 then @xmath218 , and so @xmath212 .
now suppose @xmath219
. then the condition @xmath206 implies @xmath220 .
thus @xmath221 and so @xmath212 .
this completes the proof .
[ gdpa : elt ] suppose @xmath62 is admissible and @xmath222 belongs to the jacobson radical of @xmath1 . then : 1 .
if @xmath56 is a non - unit of @xmath1 then either @xmath164 divides @xmath65 or @xmath65 divides @xmath164 .
2 . for @xmath223
, we have @xmath166}_n=\pi_{hn}$ ] up to units .
\(a ) since @xmath56 is a non - unit , it belongs to some maximal ideal @xmath194 .
since @xmath222 belongs to the jacobson radical , it also belongs to @xmath194 .
thus @xmath224 or @xmath225 by admissibility .
\(b ) we have @xmath167}_n = \prod_{d \mid h , ( h / d , n)=1 } \pi_{dn}.\ ] ] this has @xmath226 as a factor , and we claim that all other factors are units .
suppose @xmath227 is a non - unit appearing in the product .
then , by ( a ) , @xmath228 or @xmath229 . the condition @xmath230 is equivalent to @xmath231 .
thus if @xmath228 then @xmath232 and @xmath233 , which is not the case , while if @xmath229 then @xmath234 , as claimed .
let @xmath14 be a @xmath1-module , and let @xmath235 .
we say that @xmath39 is * @xmath62-torsion * if it is annihilated by @xmath145 for some @xmath144 .
equivalently , @xmath39 is @xmath62-torsion if it is annihilated by a product of the form @xmath236 , where @xmath237 is a finite subset of @xmath238 .
we write @xmath239 for the set of @xmath62-torsion elements .
it is a submodule of @xmath14 .
we say that @xmath240 is * bounded * if it is annihilated by @xmath145 for some @xmath144 .
if @xmath14 is noetherian then @xmath240 is bounded .
let @xmath241 be the submodule killed by @xmath242 .
then @xmath240 is the ascending union of the @xmath74 , and so , by noetherianity , @xmath243 for some @xmath65 .
suppose now that @xmath1 is a pid ( or just a bzout domain ) .
a sequence @xmath244 in @xmath1 is * gcd - morphic * if it satisfies the identity @xmath245 for all @xmath246 .
the following proposition seems to be well - known ( e.g. , see @xcite or @xcite ) , but we include a proof to be self - contained . [ prop : gcd - morphic ] giving a never - zero admissible @xmath104-sequence @xmath62 is the same as giving a never - zero gcd - morphic sequence @xmath244 ; precisely , @xmath247 provides a bijection between these two classes of sequences .
let @xmath244 be a never - zero gcd - morphic sequence .
let @xmath248 be minimal such that @xmath249 is not a unit .
define @xmath250 then @xmath251 is gcd - morphic .
we must show @xmath252 .
this is immediate if @xmath26 divides both of @xmath65 and @xmath39 , and also if @xmath26 divides neither @xmath65 nor @xmath39 .
thus assume @xmath253 but @xmath254 .
then @xmath255 since @xmath256 and @xmath26 is minimal such that @xmath249 is not a unit .
thus @xmath257 is coprime to @xmath249 , and so @xmath258 this completes the proof .
let @xmath244 be a never - zero gcd - morphic sequence .
then @xmath259 for a unique never - zero @xmath104-sequence @xmath62 . by mbius
inversion , @xmath260 is the unique sequence @xmath62 , if it exists : we must show that this product belongs to @xmath1 .
let @xmath62 be a maximal never - zero sequence such that @xmath261 is a gcd - morphic sequence in @xmath1 . here by `` maximal '' we mean that if @xmath201 is another other sequence with this property and @xmath262 for all @xmath263 then @xmath264 up to units .
it is easy to see that a maximal sequence exists : start by maximizing @xmath265 , then go to @xmath266 , and so on .
put @xmath267 .
we claim that @xmath268 is a unit for all @xmath65 . indeed ,
suppose not and let @xmath26 be minimal such that @xmath269 is not a unit .
define @xmath201 by @xmath270 for @xmath271 and @xmath272 .
then , by the previous lemma , @xmath273 is gcd - morphic .
this contradicts the maximality of @xmath62 , and thus proves the claim .
we thus see that @xmath259 up to units for all @xmath65 , and so @xmath274 is equal to @xmath56 up to units , and thus belongs to @xmath1 .
let @xmath62 be a never - zero @xmath104-sequence in @xmath1 and put @xmath259 . then @xmath62 is admissible if and only if @xmath244 is gcd - morphic .
let @xmath275 .
working from the definition of @xmath149 , we find @xmath276 suppose @xmath62 is admissible .
if @xmath135 and @xmath277 are indices in the products , then @xmath278 and @xmath279 , and so @xmath280 by admissibility .
it follows that the gcd on the right is 1 , and so @xmath281 is gcd - morphic .
conversely , suppose @xmath281 is gcd - morphic .
then the gcd on the right side above is 1 , and so @xmath280 for all indices @xmath135 and @xmath277 in products .
suppose now @xmath135 and @xmath277 are given such that @xmath278 and @xmath279 .
taking @xmath282 and @xmath283 , we find @xmath284 , and so @xmath62 is admissible . we now give some examples to illustrate the definitions in this section . [
ex : classical - dgpa ] take @xmath285 and define @xmath286 if @xmath83 is a power of a prime @xmath18 and @xmath287 otherwise . then @xmath288 and @xmath289 and @xmath290 , the usual binomial coefficient .
we have @xmath168}(n)=a(hn)/a(h)=n$ ] .
thus @xmath170}=a$ ] and @xmath171}=c$ ] as well .
it is clear that the sequence @xmath62 is admissible .
[ ex : fibonomial - dgpa ] take @xmath285 and define @xmath291 where @xmath292 is the @xmath65th fibonacci number .
it is well - known that this sequence is gcd - morphic , and so , by proposition [ prop : gcd - morphic ] , there exists a unique admissible sequence @xmath62 such that @xmath259
. more information on the sequence @xmath62 can be found at ( * ? ? ?
* https://oeis.org/a061446[a061446 ] ) .
the coefficients @xmath151 are the so - called `` fibonomial coefficients . ''
[ ex : q - dgpa ] take @xmath293 $ ] and define @xmath294 to be the @xmath83th cyclotomic polynomial .
this is admissible by the following lemma .
we have @xmath295_q = \frac{q^n-1}{q-1}\ ] ] and @xmath296_q!$ ] and @xmath297 , the @xmath2-binomial coefficient .
we have @xmath168}(n)=[hn]_q/[h]_q=[n]_{q^h}$ ] and @xmath170}(n)=[n]_{q^h}!$ ] .
thus @xmath171}(n , m)={n \brack m}_{q^h}$ ] is the @xmath298-binomial coefficient .
the @xmath104-sequence in @xmath299 $ ] given by @xmath67 is admissible .
let @xmath194 be a maximal ideal of @xmath299 $ ] containing @xmath68 and @xmath300 .
let @xmath301/\fm$ ] be the quotient field , which is necessarily finite , say of characteristic @xmath18 , and let @xmath302 be the image of @xmath2 in @xmath303 .
write @xmath304 and @xmath305 with @xmath306 and @xmath307 prime to @xmath18
. then @xmath308 modulo @xmath18 , and similarly for @xmath300 .
we thus see that @xmath309 , and so it follows that @xmath302 is both a primitive @xmath306 and @xmath307 root of unity .
we conclude that @xmath310 , and so @xmath58 or @xmath59 according to whether @xmath311 or @xmath312 .
given a divisible sequence @xmath113 and a ring @xmath1 , we define a ring @xmath313 as follows .
first suppose that @xmath113 has infinite length
. then @xmath314/(y_i^{b_{i+1}/b_i})$ ] .
now suppose @xmath315 .
then @xmath316/(y_i^{b_{i+1}/b_i})$ ] , where the relations are imposed for @xmath317 . in particular , @xmath318 is not nilpotent .
we give @xmath319 degree @xmath106 which makes @xmath320 a graded @xmath1-algebra .
let @xmath108 be an integer and let @xmath321 be its base @xmath113 expansion .
we define @xmath9 } \in \bs$ ] to be the element @xmath322 .
it is clearly non - zero of degree @xmath65 , and the only element of degree @xmath65 up to scalar multiples .
let @xmath323 be a second integer .
then @xmath9 } x^{[m]}$ ] is non - zero if and only if @xmath324 for all @xmath112 , that is , there is no base carry when computing @xmath325 in base @xmath113 .
assuming there is no carry , @xmath326 is the base @xmath113 expansion of @xmath325 , and so @xmath9 } x^{[m ] } = x^{[n+m]}$ ] .
the following proposition summarizes the above discussion : [ prop : gdpa - modulo - maximal - ideal ] as a @xmath1-module , we have @xmath327}$ ] . in this basis , multiplication is given by @xmath6}x^{[m ] } = \begin{cases } x^{[n+m ] } & \text{if there is no base $ b_{\bullet}$ carry in $ n+m$ } \\ 0 \qquad & \text{if there is a base $ b_{\bullet}$ carry in $ n+m$ } \end{cases}\ ] ] let @xmath1 be a ring and let @xmath62 be a @xmath104-sequence in @xmath1 .
we define a graded @xmath1-algebra @xmath328 as follows . as a graded @xmath1-module
, @xmath0 is free with basis @xmath329}$ ] for @xmath330 , where @xmath329}$ ] has degree @xmath112 .
multiplication is defined by @xmath331 } x^{[m ] } = c(n , m ) x^{[n]}$ ] .
proposition [ prop : binom ] ensures that multiplication is associative , while commutativity follows from the obvious relation @xmath332 .
the element @xmath5}$ ] is the unit , and so we write @xmath5}=1 $ ] . as usual , @xmath333}$ ] denotes @xmath334}_{\bullet})$ ] .
a * generalized divided power algebra * ( gdpa ) over @xmath1 is a graded @xmath1-algebra isomorphic to @xmath335 for some admissible sequence @xmath62 .
[ ex : gdpa ] some examples of gdpa s : 1 . if @xmath64 for each @xmath223 then @xmath336 $ ] .
2 . if @xmath62 is as in example [ ex : classical - dgpa ] then @xmath0 is the classical divided power algebra .
3 . if @xmath62 is as in example [ ex : q - dgpa ] then @xmath0 is the @xmath2-divided power algebra .
[ gdpa : bc ] let @xmath202 be a @xmath1-algebra , and let @xmath337 be the image of @xmath156 in @xmath202 .
then @xmath338 is isomorphic to @xmath339 . in particular , the base change of a gdpa is still a gdpa .
it is clear that @xmath340 is isomorphic to @xmath339 .
if @xmath62 is admissible then so is @xmath201 , by proposition [ seq : adimg ] , and so @xmath340 is a gdpa .
we say that two sequences @xmath62 and @xmath201 in @xmath1 are * associate * if @xmath56 is associate to @xmath341 for all @xmath65 ( that is , @xmath56 is a unit times @xmath341 ) . in this case , one is admissible if and only if the other is .
[ gdpa : assoc ] suppose @xmath62 is an arbitrary @xmath104-sequence and @xmath201 is an admissible @xmath104-sequence
. then @xmath328 is isomorphic to @xmath342 as graded @xmath1-algebras if and only if @xmath62 and @xmath201 are associate .
first suppose that @xmath62 and @xmath201 are associate , and write @xmath343 with @xmath344 a unit . for @xmath108 , define @xmath345 which is also a unit .
then @xmath346 , where @xmath159 is computed with @xmath62 and @xmath347 with @xmath201 .
thus the map @xmath348 taking @xmath9}$ ] to @xmath349}$ ] is an isomorphism of graded @xmath1-algebras .
now suppose that @xmath0 and @xmath340 are isomorphic .
it suffices to check that @xmath62 and @xmath201 are associate locally , so we assume that @xmath1 is local .
let @xmath113 be the divisible sequence associated to @xmath201 .
we note that the isomorphism @xmath350 implies that @xmath151 and @xmath351 are associate for all @xmath65 and @xmath39 .
assume that @xmath156 and @xmath337 are associate for @xmath352 , and let us prove that @xmath56 and @xmath341 are associate .
we consider two cases : * _ case 1 : @xmath353 for any @xmath112 . _
write @xmath354 with @xmath355 such that there is no base @xmath113 carry .
then @xmath356 is a unit , and so @xmath357 is a unit .
since @xmath56 divides @xmath357 , it follows that @xmath56 is a unit , and thus associate to @xmath341 . *
_ case 2 : @xmath358 .
_ in the addition @xmath359 there is only a carry into @xmath106 s place .
we thus see that @xmath360 is a unit , and so , by the inductive hypothesis , so is @xmath361 thus @xmath341 is associate to @xmath362 , which is associate to @xmath363 , which is associate to @xmath56 .
[ cor : adm ] if @xmath364 is a gdpa then @xmath62 is admissible .
[ gdpa : poly ] suppose that @xmath56 is a unit of @xmath1 for all @xmath263 .
then the natural map @xmath8 \to \bd$ ] sending @xmath4 to @xmath365}$ ] is an isomorphism of graded @xmath1-algebras .
this follows from proposition above and example [ ex : gdpa](a ) .
[ prop : gdpa - field ] the gdpa s over a field @xmath1 are exactly the algebras @xmath366 from [ ss : salg ] .
let @xmath62 be an admissible @xmath104-sequence . by proposition [ gdpa : assoc ]
, we may as well assume @xmath367 for all @xmath65 .
by admissibility , there is a divisible sequence @xmath113 such that @xmath368 if and only if @xmath358 for some @xmath112 .
it now follows directly from the definition that @xmath151 is 0 if there is a base @xmath113 carry in computing @xmath369 , and 1 otherwise . thus @xmath0 is isomorphic to @xmath370 by proposition [ prop : gdpa - modulo - maximal - ideal ] .
now suppose @xmath113 is a given divisible sequence .
define @xmath368 if @xmath358 for some @xmath112 and @xmath64 otherwise .
then @xmath370 is isomorphic to @xmath364 , and so the former is a gdpa .
in fact , over any ring @xmath1 the @xmath366 are exactly the gdpa s
@xmath364 for which @xmath56 is either 0 or a unit for all @xmath65 . for this section
we fix a gdpa @xmath328 and establish some basic results , mostly concerning what happens when @xmath371 for some @xmath164 .
we denote the @xmath1-subalgebra of @xmath0 generated by @xmath9}$ ] with @xmath225 by @xmath372 .
[ prop : regrade ] suppose @xmath222 belongs to the jacobson radical of @xmath1 .
then : 1 . for @xmath373 ,
the module @xmath374 is free over @xmath372 and generated by @xmath375}$ ] .
the natural map @xmath376 is an isomorphism of graded @xmath372-modules .
the regrade of @xmath372 is isomorphic to @xmath333}$ ] .
\(a ) suppose @xmath65 is a multiple of @xmath164 , @xmath373 , and @xmath39 either divides @xmath164 or is a multiple of @xmath164
. then one finds @xmath377 .
combined with proposition [ gdpa : elt](a ) , this shows that @xmath378 is a unit .
we thus see that @xmath374 is free of rank one over @xmath372 , generated by @xmath375}$ ] .
\(b ) follows from ( a ) .
\(c ) let @xmath379 , let @xmath380 , and let @xmath237 be the set of positive integers that do not divide @xmath164 or are not divisible by @xmath164 .
define @xmath381 this is a unit by part ( a ) .
we have @xmath382 the first product is equal to @xmath383 .
the second product is 1 since @xmath384 when @xmath83 divides @xmath164 .
the final product is @xmath385 .
thus we have @xmath386 .
let @xmath387 with basis @xmath388}$ ] .
then the map @xmath389 given by @xmath388 } \mapsto u_k x^{[hk]}$ ] is an isomorphism of @xmath1-algebras , and respects the grading after regrading @xmath372 . by proposition [ gdpa : elt](b ) , @xmath201 and @xmath166}_{\bullet}$ ]
are associate , and so @xmath340 is isomorphic to @xmath333}$ ] ( by proposition [ gdpa : assoc ] ) , which completes the proof .
[ gdpa : transcoh ] suppose @xmath222 belongs to the jacobson radical of @xmath1
. then @xmath0 is ( graded- , grbner- , or [ no adjective ] ) coherent if and only if @xmath333}$ ] is . by proposition [ prop : regrade](c ) , @xmath333}$ ]
is isomorphic to a regrade of @xmath372 , and
so it is enough to shows that @xmath0 is ( graded- , grbner- , or [ no adjective ] ) coherent if and only if @xmath372 is . by proposition [ prop : regrade](a ) ,
@xmath0 is homogeneous and free of rank @xmath164 as a module over @xmath372 , and so the result follows from standard ( and easily proved ) basic facts about coherence .
[ gdpa : ideal ] suppose @xmath222 belongs to the jacobson radical of @xmath1 , let @xmath390 be a homogeneous ideal , and let @xmath373
. then there exists an ideal @xmath391 of @xmath372 such that @xmath392 $ ] as @xmath372-modules .
furthermore , if @xmath393 is generated in degrees @xmath394 then @xmath391 is generated in degrees @xmath395 .
the assertion that @xmath391 exists and is an ideal follows directly from proposition [ prop : regrade](a ) . for the degree bound
, we may assume without loss of generality that @xmath393 is generated in degree @xmath135 .
let @xmath396 be such that @xmath397 .
it is enough to show that @xmath398 $ ] is generated in degree @xmath399 . to see this ,
let @xmath400 for some @xmath401 .
the product @xmath402 } x^{[n - d]}$ ] differs from @xmath402}x^{[d']}x^{[n - d - d']}$ ] by a factor of @xmath403 .
it suffices to show that this factor is a unit .
since @xmath222 is in the jacobson radical of @xmath1 , @xmath164 belongs to @xmath404 for every maximal ideal @xmath194 of @xmath1 and there are no carries in the addition @xmath405 in any base containing @xmath164 , and so @xmath403 is a unit .
[ gdpa : subalg ] suppose that @xmath368 .
then @xmath406 is a subalgebra of @xmath0 , and the natural map @xmath407 is an isomorphism of graded @xmath1-algebras . to show that @xmath406 is a subalgebra
, it suffices to show that if @xmath408 then @xmath329 } x^{[j ] } \in \bd_{<n}$ ] .
this is clear if @xmath409 .
if @xmath410 then @xmath411 , and so @xmath412 since @xmath56 appears as a factor of it ; thus , in this case , @xmath329 } x^{[j]}=0 $ ] , which does indeed belong to @xmath406 .
the map @xmath407 is an isomorphism of graded @xmath1-modules by proposition [ prop : regrade](b ) . in the present situation ,
it is clearly compatible with multiplication .
[ gdpa : coh ] suppose @xmath368 for infinitely many @xmath65 . if @xmath1 is coherent ( resp
noetherian ) then @xmath0 is coherent ( resp .
grbner - coherent ) .
let @xmath413 be the indices with @xmath414 ; note that @xmath415 by proposition [ gdpa : elt](a ) .
it follows from proposition [ gdpa : subalg ] that the map @xmath416 is an isomorphism of rings , and so @xmath417 is flat ( even free ) as a @xmath418-module . thus if @xmath1 is coherent then so is @xmath418 , being finite free over @xmath1 .
since @xmath0 is the union of the @xmath418 , it too is coherent ( ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 20 ) ) . now suppose @xmath1 is noetherian .
then each @xmath419 is a noetherian module , and thus grbner - coherent . as with coherence ,
grbner - coherence passes to the limit ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 5.3 ) .
[ prop : h - free ] suppose @xmath62 be an admissible sequence with @xmath420 for infinitely many @xmath65 , and let @xmath421 be a gdpa . if @xmath14 is finitely presented ( graded ) @xmath0-module then there exists an @xmath164 such that @xmath422 and @xmath423 as @xmath372-modules for some ( graded ) @xmath424-module @xmath47 .
in particular , if @xmath1 is a field then @xmath14 is free as a @xmath372-module .
let @xmath425 be a presentation of @xmath14 with @xmath426 free of finite rank over @xmath0 .
suppose that , in a suitable basis , the matrix entries of the map @xmath427 ( as in the presentation above ) only involve variables @xmath5 } , x^{[1 ] } , \ldots , x^{[t]}$ ] .
pick an @xmath428 such that @xmath429 . by proposition [ gdpa : subalg ]
, @xmath424 is a subalgebra of @xmath0 and @xmath430 as graded @xmath1-algebras .
let @xmath431 be a free @xmath424-module with the same basis as @xmath432 , and define @xmath433 using the same matrix that defines @xmath434
. then @xmath434 is obtained from @xmath435 by applying the exact functor @xmath436 .
thus @xmath437 as required .
we defined gdpa s by explicit construction .
however , they can also be characterized intrinsically : [ prop : chargdpa ] let @xmath0 be a graded @xmath1-algebra .
then @xmath0 is a gdpa if and only if ( 1 ) each graded piece of @xmath0 is free of rank 1 over @xmath1 ; and ( 2 ) for every maximal ideal @xmath194 of @xmath1 , the quotient @xmath438 is isomorphic to @xmath439 for some divisible sequence @xmath113 .
if @xmath0 is a gdpa then ( 1 ) holds by definition , while ( 2 ) follows from propositions [ gdpa : bc ] and [ prop : gdpa - field ] .
it thus suffices to prove the converse .
let @xmath9}$ ] be a basis of @xmath440}$ ] , and define @xmath441 by @xmath331 } x^{[m ] } = c(n , m ) x^{[n+m]}$ ] .
we choose @xmath5}=1 $ ] , so that @xmath442 for all @xmath65 .
it suffices to prove the following statement : * given elements @xmath443 for @xmath444 such that @xmath445 for all @xmath446 , there exists an element @xmath447 such that @xmath448 for all @xmath449 . indeed ,
if this were true then we could construct a @xmath104-sequence @xmath62 for which @xmath445 for all @xmath450 , and so @xmath335 would be isomorphic to @xmath0 . furthermore , condition ( 2 ) would imply ( by corollary [ cor : adm ] ) that @xmath62 is admissible in each quotient @xmath451 , and therefore admissible .
[ char1 ] the condition @xmath452 holds when @xmath1 is local .
let @xmath194 be the unique maximal ideal of @xmath1 and let @xmath113 be a divisible sequence such that @xmath453 .
note that if there is no base @xmath36 carry in the addition @xmath369 then @xmath454 is nonzero modulo @xmath194 , and thus a unit of @xmath1 .
let @xmath47 and @xmath56 be given as in @xmath452 .
note that if @xmath455 is not of the form @xmath106 then @xmath56 is a unit .
indeed , we can write @xmath456 for some @xmath457 with no carry , and so @xmath445 is a unit . as @xmath151 is a multiple of @xmath56
, it follows that @xmath56 is a unit .
first suppose that @xmath47 is not of the form @xmath106 , and let @xmath112 be maximal such that @xmath106 divides @xmath47 .
note that the @xmath112th base @xmath36 digit of @xmath47 is nonzero , and all digits in lower places are 0 . clearly then , there are no carries in the addition @xmath458 .
it follows that @xmath459 has no factor of the form @xmath460 , and so @xmath461 is a unit of @xmath1 .
we define @xmath462 by @xmath463 thus , by construction , @xmath464 .
we now show that @xmath448 for all @xmath449 .
if @xmath465 or @xmath466 the equality is clear , so assume @xmath467 .
put @xmath468 . by assumption , the @xmath112th base @xmath36 digit of @xmath47 is nonzero .
suppose that the @xmath112th base @xmath36 digit of @xmath65 or @xmath39 is nonzero , say @xmath65
. then we can write @xmath469 without carry . we then
have @xmath6 } x^{[m ] } = c(n , b_i)^{-1 } x^{[b_i ] } x^{[n ' ] } x^{[m ] } = c(n , b_i)^{-1 } c(n - b_i , m ) c(n , b_i ) x^{[n]},\ ] ] and so @xmath470 we get a similar identity for @xmath159 .
since we know the @xmath126 s and @xmath159 s on the right agree , this gives @xmath471 .
now suppose that the @xmath112th base @xmath36 digits of @xmath65 and @xmath39 are each zero .
there must then be a carry that produces a nonzero @xmath112th digit in @xmath325 .
write @xmath472 and @xmath473 where @xmath474 and @xmath475 , and write @xmath476 ; all of these decompositions are without carry .
we then have @xmath6 } x^{[m ] } = c(n , n_1)^{-1 } c(m , m_1)^{-1 } c(n_1+m_1 , n_1 ) c(n_2+m_2 , n_2 ) x^{[n_1+m_1 ] } x^{[n_2+m_2]}\ ] ] and @xmath477 } = c(n_2+m_2 , b_i)^{-1 } x^{[\ell ] } x^{[b_i ] } , \qquad x^{[n_1+n_2 ] } x^{[\ell ] } = c(n - b_i , \ell ) x^{[n - b_i]},\ ] ] and so @xmath478 again , there is a similar identity for @xmath159 , which yields @xmath448 .
now suppose @xmath479 with @xmath480 . in the sum @xmath481 there is exactly one carry , in the @xmath112th place .
thus @xmath461 has no factor of @xmath460 with @xmath482 , and is therefore a unit .
we define @xmath463 once again , @xmath464 by construction .
we now show that @xmath448 for @xmath449 .
again , we assume @xmath483 , and put @xmath468 .
since @xmath65 and @xmath39 are less than @xmath106 and they sum to @xmath106 , the @xmath484st digit of @xmath65 or @xmath39 ( say @xmath65 ) must be nonzero .
we can therefore write @xmath485 , with no carry .
we have @xmath6 } x^{[m ] } = c(n , b_{i-1})^{-1 } x^{[b_{i-1 } ] } x^{[n ' ] } x^{[m ] } = c(n , b_{i-1})^{-1 } c(n - b_{i-1 } , m ) c(n , b_i ) x^{[n]}.\ ] ] we have a similar identity for @xmath159 , which shows @xmath448 , and completes the proof . [ char2 ] let @xmath1 be a commutative ring and let @xmath486 and @xmath487 be elements of @xmath1 .
suppose that for each maximal ideal @xmath194 of @xmath1 there exists an element @xmath488 such that @xmath489 holds in @xmath490 for all @xmath112 .
then there exists an element @xmath491 such that @xmath492 holds in @xmath1 for all @xmath112 .
write @xmath493 with @xmath494 and @xmath495 .
choosing @xmath496 and @xmath497 appropriately , we can assume that @xmath498 holds in @xmath1 for all @xmath112 .
( here it is important that there are only finitely many @xmath499 and @xmath319 . )
the @xmath497 generate the unit ideal of @xmath1 , and therefore finitely many of them do .
let @xmath500 be a finite set of maximal ideals such that the @xmath497 with @xmath501 generate the unit ideal , and choose an expression @xmath502 with @xmath503 .
then putting @xmath504 , we find @xmath492 for all @xmath112 .
[ char3 ] the condition @xmath452 holds in general .
suppose @xmath47 as in @xmath452 is given .
we must find @xmath462 such that @xmath448 for all @xmath467 ( the @xmath505 cases being automatic ) .
that is , we must find @xmath462 that simultaneously solves the equations @xmath506 for @xmath467 .
we can find a solution after localizing at each maximal ideal by lemma [ char1 ] .
we can therefore find a solution by lemma [ char2 ] . in this section
we prove the following result : [ prop : tor1 ] let @xmath0 be a gdpa over @xmath1
. then @xmath508.\ ] ] we note that this proposition gives another way to see that the @xmath56 are intrinsic to @xmath0 , up to units .
we recall that @xmath119 by convention .
let @xmath62 be an admissible sequence in @xmath1 , and let @xmath144 .
then the ideal @xmath12 generated by the element @xmath509 for @xmath510 is the principal ideal @xmath511 .
it suffices to prove this when @xmath1 is local .
assume this , and let @xmath512 be the associated divisible sequence .
if @xmath353 for some @xmath112 then there is an decomposition @xmath513 that involves no base @xmath113 carries . thus @xmath509 is a unit , and so @xmath12 is the unit ideal , and so @xmath514 since @xmath56 is a unit .
now suppose @xmath515 .
then in every decomposition @xmath513 with @xmath516 , there is a carry in the @xmath26th digit , and so @xmath56 divides @xmath509 for all such @xmath112 .
let @xmath517 . then in the decomposition @xmath456
, there is only a carry in the @xmath26th place , and so @xmath518 up to units .
it follows that @xmath514 , completing the proof .
let @xmath393 be the ideal generated by the @xmath9}$ ] with @xmath144 , so that @xmath519
. then @xmath520 .
the degree @xmath65 piece of @xmath521 is spanned , as a @xmath1-module , by all products of the form @xmath329 } x^{[j]}$ ] with @xmath522 and @xmath523 ; it is thus equal to @xmath524}$ ] where @xmath12 is the ideal generated by the @xmath509 with @xmath510 . by the lemma , @xmath514 , and so the degree @xmath65 piece of @xmath525 is @xmath526 .
in [ s : coh ] we prove two main results .
the first , in
[ ss : grobcoh ] , states that gdpa s over noetherian rings are coherent .
the second , in
[ ss : grcoh ] gives more precise results about graded - coherence of gdpa s over non - noetherian rings .
the second result depends on work in [ ss : torbd ] and [ ss : relbd ] where we establish bounds on the degrees of relations for ideals in a gdpa .
these bounds could be useful even when @xmath1 is noetherian , although they are not needed to prove any coherence results in that case .
finally , in [ ss : two - variable ] we show that coherence fails for multivariate divided power algebras .
recall from @xcite that a graded module is * grbner - coherent * if it is graded - coherent and every finitely generated inhomogeneous submodule admits a finite grbner - basis ; this implies coherent , but is stronger .
the following is our main theorem on coherence of gdpa s .
[ thm : grobcoh ] a gdpa over a noetherian ring @xmath1 is grbner - coherent
. if @xmath1 is noetherian then the classical divided power algbera over @xmath1 , as well as its @xmath2-analogs , are grbner - coherent ( and thus coherent as well ) .
in fact , we can conclude grbner - coherence for a larger class of coefficient rings using some of the basic properties of grbner - coherence .
two examples : 1 .
suppose that @xmath1 is a direct limit of noetherian rings @xmath527 with flat transition maps , and let @xmath0 be a gdpa such that the @xmath56 belong to the initial ring @xmath528 .
then @xmath0 is grbner - coherent . indeed ,
if @xmath529 then @xmath530 is grbner - coherent by the theorem , and @xmath0 is the direct limit of the @xmath530 ( and the transition maps are still flat ) , and thus grbner - coherent by ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 5.3 ) .
for example , if @xmath1 is a polynomial ring in infinitely many variables over a noetherian ring then the classical divided power algebra over @xmath1 is grbner - coherent .
2 . suppose that @xmath1 is locally noetherian ( meaning @xmath531 is noetherian for all maximal ideals @xmath194 ) and @xmath0 is a gdpa over @xmath1 that is graded - coherent .
then @xmath0 is grbner - coherent .
indeed , @xmath532 is grbner - coherent by the theorem , and so @xmath0 is grbner - coherent by ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 5.1 ) .
for example , if @xmath1 is a boolean ring then the classical divided power algbera over @xmath1 is grbner - coherent .
( the graded coherence of @xmath0 follows easily from corollary [ cor : grcohdp ] in this case . )
the heart of the proof is contained in the following lemma : let @xmath1 be a domain and let @xmath328 be an admissible gdpa .
suppose that @xmath533 for all @xmath263 and that @xmath534 is grbner - coherent for all non - zero principal ideals @xmath12 of @xmath1 .
then @xmath0 is grbner - coherent .
let @xmath535 be a finitely generated ideal of @xmath0 . since @xmath536 $ ] ( corollary [ gdpa : poly ] ) , the ideal @xmath537 is principal ; let @xmath538 be a generator .
write @xmath539 with @xmath540 and @xmath491 .
since the @xmath499 generate the ideal @xmath541 over @xmath542 , we have an expression @xmath543 with @xmath544 and @xmath545 . expressing the @xmath499 in terms of the @xmath319
, we see that the ideal @xmath546 contains the non - zero element @xmath547 of @xmath1 .
note that multiplication by @xmath548 defines an isomorphism @xmath549 of @xmath0-modules .
let @xmath550 be the image of @xmath551 in @xmath552 . since @xmath553 is coherent by assumption and @xmath550
is finitely generated , we see that @xmath550 is finitely presented as a @xmath553-module , and thus as a @xmath0-module as well .
the exact sequence @xmath554 shows that @xmath551 is finitely presented .
since @xmath393 is isomorphic to @xmath551 as a @xmath0-module , it too is finitely presented .
we have thus shown that every finitely generated ideal of @xmath0 is finitely presented , and so @xmath0 is coherent .
we now do a bit more work to show that @xmath0 is grbner - coherent .
we have shown that @xmath0 is graded - coherent , so it remains to show that the initial ideal @xmath555 is finitely generated whenever @xmath393 is a finitely generated ideal of @xmath0 .
maintain the previous notation .
one easily sees that we have a short exact sequence @xmath556 since @xmath553 is grbner - coherent , it follows that @xmath557 is finitely generated , and so @xmath558 is as well . from the equality of ideals @xmath559
, we obtain @xmath560 .
since @xmath561 is clearly finitely generated , it follows that @xmath562 is finitely generated .
but @xmath562 is isomorphic to @xmath555 via multiplication by @xmath192 , and so @xmath555 is finitely generated .
let @xmath1 be a noetherian ring and let @xmath328 be a gdpa .
we will show @xmath0 is grbner - coherent . by noetherian induction
, we can assume that @xmath534 is grbner - coherent for all nonzero ideals @xmath12 of @xmath1 .
first suppose that @xmath1 is not a domain , and let @xmath563 with @xmath564 and @xmath565 .
we have a short exact sequence @xmath566 the rightmost ring is grbner - coherent by hypothesis , and thus grbner - coherent as a module over @xmath0 . the leftmost term is a finitely presented as a @xmath0-module , being isomorphic to @xmath567 , and thus finitely presented as a @xmath568-module .
it follows that @xmath569 is grbner - coherent as a @xmath570-module , and thus as a @xmath0-module as well .
thus @xmath0 is an extension of grbner - coherent modules , and thus grbner - coherent .
now suppose that @xmath1 is a domain .
if @xmath368 for infinitely many @xmath65 then @xmath0 is grbner - coherent by proposition [ gdpa : coh ] .
thus we assume that only finitely many @xmath56 are 0 .
let @xmath164 be maximal so that @xmath371 .
by proposition [ gdpa : transcoh ] , it suffices to prove that @xmath333}$ ] is grbner - coherent .
note that @xmath166}_n \ne 0 $ ] for all @xmath263 ( this follows directly from the definition of the @xmath164-transform ) .
if @xmath12 is a nonzero ideal of @xmath1 then @xmath534 is grbner - coherent by assumption , and so @xmath571}$ ] is grbner - coherent by proposition [ gdpa : transcoh ] .
thus @xmath333}$ ] is grbner - coherent by the lemma , which completes the proof
. let @xmath11 be a graded algebra supported in non - negative degrees and put @xmath572 .
we regard @xmath1 as an @xmath11-module by letting positive degree elements act by 0 . for a non - zero graded object @xmath14 , let @xmath573 denote the maximum integer @xmath65 such that @xmath74 is non - zero , or @xmath574 if no maximum exists
. for a graded @xmath11-module @xmath14 , put @xmath575 .
[ prop : relatively - projective ] suppose @xmath576 for some graded @xmath1-module @xmath82 .
then @xmath577 for @xmath578 .
let @xmath579 be a free resolution of @xmath82 as a @xmath1-module .
then @xmath580 is a free resolution of @xmath14 as an @xmath11-module .
we can thus compute @xmath581 by tensoring this complex with @xmath1 .
but this just recovers the complex @xmath582 , which is exact in positive degrees .
[ prop : tor2 ] let @xmath14 be an @xmath11-module and let @xmath583 be an exact sequence with @xmath584 .
then @xmath585 the long exact exact sequence in @xmath507 gives an exact sequence @xmath586 ( since @xmath584 ) , from which the stated inequalities are clear . [
prop : tor3 ] suppose that @xmath587 is a graded subring with @xmath588 such that @xmath11 is finite projective over @xmath237 .
let @xmath14 be an @xmath11-module .
then @xmath589 and @xmath590 let @xmath583 be an exact sequence of @xmath11-modules such that @xmath591 is projective and @xmath592 .
then @xmath591 is also projective as an @xmath237-module .
thus @xmath593 the outer two inequalities come from proposition [ prop : tor2 ] , while the middle one is clear .
similarly , @xmath594 the stated inequality follows from this and the identity @xmath595 .
[ prop : tor - vanishing ] let @xmath14 be a finitely presented graded @xmath11-module . then @xmath596 for @xmath597 .
suppose @xmath14 is generated in degrees @xmath598 , and @xmath65 is the minimal integer such that @xmath599 .
let @xmath600 .
we then have a natural surjection @xmath601 .
moreover , this map is an isomorphism in degree @xmath65 , and so the kernel is supported in degrees @xmath602 .
applying the same reasoning to the kernel and proceeding inductively , we obtain a resolution @xmath603 where the degree @xmath135 piece of @xmath604 vanishes for @xmath597 . by proposition [ prop : relatively - projective ] the modules
@xmath605 are acyclic for the functor @xmath606 , and so @xmath607 is computed by the complex @xmath608 , which proves the result .
the following theorem is our main result on bounding the presentation of ideals in a gdpa .
the proof occupies the entire section .
[ thm : torbd ] let @xmath0 be a gdpa over a ring @xmath1 , and let @xmath390 be a homogeneous ideal of @xmath0 generated in degrees @xmath394 .
write @xmath609}$ ] where @xmath610 is an ideal of @xmath1 .
suppose that @xmath47 is such that @xmath611}(\bk/(\fa_i+t(\bk)))$ ] is killed by @xmath168}(n)$ ] for all @xmath612 and all @xmath613
. then @xmath614 .
it suffices to prove the theorem when @xmath1 is local .
suppose the result holds when @xmath1 is local , and let us prove it in general .
let @xmath194 be a maximal ideal of @xmath1 , and indicate by a prime localization at @xmath194 . since @xmath42 commutes with localization , @xmath611}(\bk'/(\fa_i'+t(\bk')))$ ]
is killed by @xmath168}(n)$ ] for all @xmath612 and @xmath613 .
thus @xmath615 by the local case of the theorem .
that is , @xmath616 for @xmath617 . but @xmath507 commutes with localization , so we find that the @xmath1-module @xmath618 localizes to 0 at all maximal ideals @xmath194 .
it is therefore 0 , and so @xmath614 , as was to be shown . for the rest of the section , we assume that @xmath1 is local .
we let @xmath194 be the unique maximal ideal of @xmath1 , and we let @xmath512 when we have an admissible sequence @xmath62 . for an element @xmath619 of @xmath1 and a @xmath1-module @xmath14 , we let @xmath620 be the submodule consisting of elements annihilated by @xmath621 for some @xmath144 . [ degdb1 ] let @xmath393 be a homogeneous ideal of @xmath0 generated in degrees @xmath394 , where @xmath622 .
fix an element @xmath619 of @xmath1 .
suppose that @xmath623 is killed by @xmath624 , for all @xmath625 .
let @xmath78 be maximal subject to @xmath626 .
then @xmath627 unless @xmath628 for some @xmath629 , and @xmath630 .
let @xmath631 $ ] , let @xmath632 be its standard basis , and let @xmath633 be the map defined by @xmath634}$ ] .
let @xmath635 \otimes_{\bk } \fa_i$ ] , thought of as a @xmath0-submodule of @xmath636 , let @xmath637 be the restriction of @xmath638 to @xmath591 , and let @xmath639 .
we have a short exact sequence @xmath640 and so @xmath641 is identified with @xmath642 .
let @xmath643 } e_i$ ] be an element of @xmath644 of degree @xmath65 , and let @xmath645 be the corresponding element of @xmath646 .
write @xmath647 , where @xmath39 is a multiple of @xmath648 and @xmath649 .
we must show that @xmath650 unless @xmath651 for some @xmath629 and @xmath652 .
we proceed in six steps .
_ step 1 : excluding @xmath465 .
_ suppose @xmath465 , i.e. , @xmath653 .
since @xmath654 , we can write @xmath655 } r'$ ] for some @xmath656 and some @xmath657 .
write @xmath658}$ ] with @xmath659 and @xmath660}$ ] . then @xmath661 .
since @xmath662 is a unit ( as @xmath653 ) , it follows that @xmath663 .
thus @xmath664 , and so @xmath665 , and so @xmath650 .
in what follows , we assume @xmath666
. _ step 2 : bounding @xmath667 .
_ now suppose @xmath668 .
then @xmath669 is a unit for all @xmath625 , and so @xmath670}}{c(n - i,\ell - i ) } e_i\ ] ] is a well - defined element of @xmath591 .
note that @xmath671}r'$ ] . if @xmath658}$ ] and @xmath672}$ ] then @xmath673 . since @xmath674 is a unit and @xmath659
, it follows that @xmath663 , and so @xmath664 .
thus @xmath665 , and so @xmath650 .
in what follows , we assume @xmath675 .
_ step 3 : reduction to two - term relations .
_ we now show that it suffices to consider elements @xmath11 of a simple form .
this step is not strictly necessary , but will simplify notation in what follows .
put @xmath676 note that @xmath677 is a unit , and , in the second sum , both @xmath678 and @xmath679 are the same product of @xmath104 s , up to units , and so the expressions make sense .
note also that @xmath680 , and so @xmath681 and @xmath682 .
we can thus consider the element @xmath683}e_{\ell}+\beta x^{[n - d]}e_d\ ] ] of @xmath591 .
it is clear that @xmath684 , and so @xmath664
. we claim @xmath685 modulo @xmath686 . to see this ,
put @xmath687}}{c(n - i,\ell - i ) } e_i - \alpha e_{\ell}\ ] ] and @xmath688}}{c(n - i,1 ) } e_i - \frac{\beta x^{[n - d-1]}}{c(n - d , 1 ) } e_d.\ ] ] all the @xmath159 s in these expressions are units , and so @xmath689 and @xmath690 are well - defined elements of @xmath591 .
we have @xmath691 } r_1 = \sum_{i=0}^{\ell } \gamma_i x^{[n - i ] } e_i - \alpha x^{[m ] } e_{\ell } , \qquad x^{[1 ] } r_2 = \sum_{i=\ell+1}^d \gamma_i x^{[n - i ] } e_i - \beta x^{[n - d ] } e_d,\ ] ] and so @xmath692 } r_1 + x^{[1 ] } r_2.\ ] ] from the definitions of @xmath693 and @xmath694 , it is clear that @xmath695 } r_1)$ ] and @xmath696 } r_2)$ ] vanish . writing @xmath697}$ ] and @xmath698}$ ] , we find @xmath699 and @xmath700 .
thus @xmath701 and @xmath702 is at least torsion , and so @xmath689 and @xmath690 belong to @xmath703 .
thus @xmath704 , as claimed . in
what follows , we assume @xmath705 } e_{\ell}+\beta x^{[n - d ] } e_d$ ] .
_ step 4 : reduction to @xmath706 . _
suppose @xmath39 is not of the form @xmath707
. then we can write @xmath473 where @xmath708 and @xmath709 are positive multiples of @xmath710 such that there is no carry when computing either @xmath711 or @xmath712 .
put @xmath713}}{c(m , m_1 ) } e_{\ell } + \frac{\beta x^{[m_2+\ell - d]}}{c(n - d , m_1 ) } e_d.\ ] ] both the @xmath159 s here are units : for the second one , observe that @xmath714 since @xmath715 and @xmath708 and @xmath716 are multiples of @xmath2 , there are no carries .
thus @xmath717 is an element of @xmath591 , and @xmath718 } r'$ ] .
writing @xmath658}$ ] and @xmath719}$ ] , we see that @xmath720 .
since @xmath721 is a unit , this shows that @xmath702 is torsion .
thus @xmath664 and @xmath722 and @xmath650 . in
what follows , we assume @xmath706 for some @xmath248 .
_ step 5 : bounding @xmath26 .
_ suppose now that @xmath723 and @xmath724 .
put @xmath725}$ ] , where @xmath659 .
we have @xmath726 note that @xmath674 is a unit and @xmath727 is equal to @xmath728 up to units .
we thus see that the image of @xmath694 in @xmath729 is killed by @xmath728 .
it is therefore killed by @xmath730 , by our assumption : note that @xmath731 , up to units .
let @xmath732 and @xmath733 , so that @xmath734 is @xmath735 , up to units .
the above discussion shows that we can write @xmath736 for some @xmath737 and @xmath738 .
now consider @xmath739 } e_{\ell } + \beta x^{[n'-d ] } e_d.\ ] ] clearly @xmath740 , and so @xmath664 . we have @xmath741 } r ' = \alpha ' c(m , m ' ) x^{[m ] } e_{\ell } + \beta c(n - d , n'-d ) x^{[n - d ] } e_d.\ ] ] we thus find @xmath742 } r ' = \delta x^{[m ] } e_{\ell}\ ] ] for some @xmath743 .
since both @xmath11 and @xmath717 belong to @xmath703 , so does @xmath744 } e_{\ell}$ ] . as @xmath745 } e_{\ell } ) = c(n , \ell ) \delta x^{[n]}$ ] , we see that @xmath746 belongs to @xmath747 . but
@xmath748 is a unit , and so @xmath702 itself belongs to @xmath747 .
thus @xmath744 } e_{\ell } \in \bd_+ k$ ] .
this shows that @xmath742 } r ' \in \bd_+ k.\ ] ] of course , @xmath749 } r ' \in \bd_+ k$ ] as well , and @xmath750 is a unit , so we find @xmath722 and @xmath650 .
_ step 6 : the @xmath751 case .
_ finally , suppose that @xmath723 and @xmath751 .
note then that @xmath752 , and so @xmath753 has no torsion .
from @xmath754 we see that @xmath755 belongs to @xmath756 .
thus the image of @xmath694 in @xmath753 is killed by @xmath727 , and is therefore torsion , and therefore vanishes .
we can therefore write @xmath757 for some @xmath737 and @xmath758 . consider @xmath759}}{c(m,1 ) } e_{\ell}+\frac{\beta x^{[n - d-1]}}{c(n - d,1 ) } e_d\ ] ] note that @xmath727 and @xmath760 are same product of @xmath104 s , up to units , and @xmath761 is a unit .
we have @xmath762 } r'=\alpha'c(n , d ) x^{[m ] } e_{\ell}+\beta x^{[n - d ] } e_d = r+\epsilon '' x^{[m ] } e_{\ell}\ ] ] where @xmath763 .
write @xmath764}$ ] with @xmath765 and @xmath766}$ ] .
we claim that @xmath767 .
first suppose @xmath768 .
then the above equation shows @xmath769 . since @xmath768
we have that @xmath770 is a unit , and so @xmath771 is torsion .
now suppose @xmath772 .
then computing @xmath773 directly from the definition of @xmath717 , we find @xmath774 ( note @xmath775 since @xmath772 ) .
all the @xmath159 s above are units , and the two fractions are equal since @xmath776 ; thus @xmath771 is a unit times @xmath757 , and is thus torsion .
we have thus shown that @xmath771 is torsion in all cases , and so @xmath664 . since @xmath777 } e_{\ell } \in \bd_+ k$ ] , this shows @xmath665 .
[ degbd2 ] let @xmath778 for @xmath779 and let @xmath393 be a homogeneous ideal of @xmath372 generated in degrees @xmath394 , where @xmath780 .
suppose @xmath611}(\bk/(\fa_i+t(\bk)))$ ] is killed by @xmath168}(n)$ ] , for all @xmath625 .
let @xmath78 be maximal subject to @xmath626 .
then @xmath781 unless @xmath628 for some @xmath782 and @xmath783 .
in particular , @xmath784 . the regrade of @xmath372 is isomorphic to @xmath333}$ ] .
the regrade of @xmath393 is an ideal of @xmath333}$ ] generated in degres @xmath785}_1 $ ] .
let @xmath786 . then @xmath787}_{\bullet})=t(- ; \pi_{\bullet})$ ] . with these identifications ,
the result follows from the lemma [ degdb1 ] .
let @xmath788 be maximal subject to @xmath789 .
first suppose that @xmath790 .
put @xmath778 .
we have an isomorphism of @xmath372-modules @xmath791 $ ] , where @xmath391 is an ideal of @xmath372 . put @xmath792 . then by proposition [ gdpa :
ideal ] , the ideal @xmath391 is generated in degrees @xmath793 and satisfies @xmath794}$ ] ( for @xmath112 a multiple of @xmath164 ) .
note that @xmath795 , so @xmath796 and @xmath797 .
the module @xmath611}(\bk/(\fa_i+t(\bk)))$ ] is killed by @xmath168}(n)$ ] for @xmath798 , as @xmath799 , and so @xmath800 by lemma [ degbd2 ] .
thus @xmath801/t(j_k[k ] ) ; \bd^{(h ) } ) \le n+d_k+k \le n+3d$ ] , and so @xmath802
. thus @xmath614 by proposition [ prop : tor3 ] . now suppose that @xmath803 ; note that this implies @xmath804 . put @xmath805 . as @xmath372-modules
, we have @xmath791 $ ] , where once again @xmath391 is an ideal of @xmath372 . if @xmath806 then @xmath391 is generated in degrees 0 and @xmath164 , while if @xmath807 then @xmath391 is generated in degree 0 .
we have @xmath808 for @xmath809 .
now suppose @xmath806 .
the module @xmath611}(\bk/(\fa_i+t(\bk)))$ ] is killed by @xmath168}(n)$ ] for @xmath810 and @xmath811 , as @xmath812 .
thus @xmath813 by lemma [ degbd2 ] . the same reasoning as in the previous paragraph gives @xmath614 .
let @xmath62 be a @xmath104-sequence in @xmath1 .
we define a * @xmath104-ideal * to be an ideal of @xmath1 generated by some of the @xmath56 s .
we will consider the following three conditions : * the ring @xmath1 is coherent .
* for any finitely generated ideal @xmath12 of @xmath1 and any @xmath165 , the torsion @xmath611}(\bk/\fa)$ ] is bounded , that is , annihilated by @xmath168}(n)$ ] for some @xmath65 ( depending on @xmath164 and @xmath12 ) .
* given any strictly ascending chain of finitely generated @xmath166}$]-ideals @xmath814 there is some @xmath112 for which the quotient @xmath333}/\fa_i \bd^{[h]}$ ] is graded - coherent .
note that ( a3 ) is vacuously true if there are no strictly ascending chains of @xmath166}$]-ideals .
this is the case , for instance , if the @xmath56 s belong to the image of a ring homomorphism @xmath815 with @xmath528 noetherian .
our main result on graded - coherence of gdpas is the following theorem .
[ thm : grdcoh ] let @xmath328 be a generalized divided power algebra . then @xmath333}$ ] is graded - coherent for all @xmath165 if and only if conditions ( a1 ) , ( a2 ) , and ( a3 ) hold .
[ cor : grcohdp ] let @xmath0 be the classical divided power algebra over @xmath1 . then @xmath0 is graded - coherent if and only if @xmath1 is coherent and for all finitely generated ideals @xmath12 of @xmath1 the module @xmath816 is annihilated by some nonzero integer . to conclude that @xmath0 is graded - coherent ,
it is enough to know that ( a3 ) holds for @xmath817 .
one still needs ( a2 ) for all @xmath165 , however .
the rest of this section is devoted to the proof of the theorem .
we fix @xmath328 .
[ grcoh1 ] suppose ( a1 ) and ( a2 ) hold .
then for any finitely generated ideal @xmath12 of @xmath1 and any @xmath165 the @xmath1-module @xmath611}(\bk/\fa)$ ] is finitely presented . by ( a2 ) , @xmath611}(\bk/\fa)$ ] is equal to the kernel of the multiplication - by-@xmath145 map @xmath818 for some @xmath65 . since @xmath13 is finitely presented and @xmath1 is coherent , this kernel is again finitely presented .
[ grcoh2 ] suppose ( a1 ) and ( a2 ) hold .
let @xmath393 be a finitely generated ideal of @xmath0
. then @xmath819 is finitely presented . by ( a2 ) and theorem [ thm : torbd ] , @xmath820 . by ( a1 ) , @xmath618 is finitely presented as a @xmath1-module for each @xmath65 . combining these two statements , we see that @xmath821 is finitely presented as a @xmath1-module , and this implies that @xmath822 is finitely presented as a @xmath0-module .
[ grcoh3 ] suppose that conditions ( a1 ) and ( a2 ) hold .
suppose also that for any @xmath263 the quotient @xmath823 is graded - coherent
. then @xmath0 is graded - coherent .
let @xmath393 be a finitely generated ideal of @xmath0 .
then @xmath819 is finitely presented by lemma [ grcoh2 ] .
it follows that @xmath824 is finitely generated , and to prove the proposition it is enough to show that it is finitely presented .
suppose @xmath825 is killed by @xmath624 , and let @xmath826 .
the following lemma shows that @xmath340 is graded - coherent .
the natural map @xmath827 is an isomorphism . by lemma [ grcoh1 ] , @xmath825 is finitely presented as a @xmath1-module , and so @xmath828 is finitely presented as a @xmath0-module . since @xmath624 kills @xmath828 , it follows that @xmath828 is finitely presented as a @xmath340-module . as @xmath824 is a finitely generated @xmath340-submodule of @xmath828 ,
it is therefore finitely presented as a @xmath340-module , and therefore as a @xmath0-module .
[ grcoh4 ] let @xmath1 be a coherent ring , let @xmath11 be a graded @xmath1-algebra that is flat over @xmath1 , and let @xmath4 and @xmath829 be elements of @xmath1 such that @xmath830 and @xmath831 are graded - coherent
. then @xmath832 is graded - coherent .
consider the 4-term exact sequence @xmath833 since @xmath1 is coherent the ideal @xmath393 is finitely generated .
tensoring up with @xmath11 , we find @xmath834 this shows that @xmath832 maps onto the graded - coherent ring @xmath831 with finitely presented kernel ( the left two terms gives a presentation for the kernel ) , and is thus graded - coherent .
[ grcoh5 ] suppose that conditions ( a1 ) and ( a2 ) hold .
suppose also that there is a positive integer @xmath164 such that @xmath222 belongs to the jacobson radical of @xmath1 and the quotient @xmath823 is graded - coherent for all proper multiples @xmath65 of @xmath164
. then @xmath0 is graded - coherent .
it suffices to show that @xmath372 is graded - coherent .
of course , it is the same to show that its regrade is coherent , and this is isomorphic to @xmath333}$ ] . conditions ( a2 ) still holds for @xmath166}_{\bullet}$ ] , since @xmath835}(- , \pi^{[h]}_{\bullet})=t^{[hh']}(- , \pi_{\bullet})$ ] by proposition [ dbltrans ] .
since @xmath836 is graded - coherent for @xmath223 , it follows that @xmath837 is graded - coherent ( by proposition [ gdpa : transcoh ] ) for @xmath223 .
since @xmath166}_n$ ] is associate to @xmath226 by proposition [ gdpa : elt](b ) , it follows that @xmath333}/(\pi^{[h]}_n)$ ] is graded - coherent for @xmath223 as well .
thus @xmath333}$ ] is graded - coherent by lemma [ grcoh3 ] .
[ grcoh6 ] suppose ( a1 ) , ( a2 ) , and ( a3 ) hold . then @xmath333}$ ] is graded - coherent for all @xmath165 .
it suffices to treat the @xmath817 case .
let @xmath500 be the set of @xmath104-ideals @xmath12 for which @xmath838 is not graded - coherent .
it suffices to show that @xmath500 is empty , for then @xmath838 is graded - coherent for every @xmath104-ideal @xmath12 , including @xmath839 .
thus suppose for the sake of contradiction that @xmath500 is non - empty .
let @xmath12 be a maximal element of @xmath500 , which exists by ( a3 ) , and put @xmath840 .
now , @xmath12 contains only finitely many of the @xmath56 s , for otherwise @xmath340 would be coherent by proposition [ gdpa : coh ] .
let @xmath164 be the largest integer such that @xmath841 .
( note that @xmath119 is in @xmath12 , so this makes sense . )
if @xmath65 is a proper multiple of @xmath164 then @xmath56 does not belong to @xmath12 , and so @xmath842 is not in @xmath500 , and so @xmath843 is graded - coherent .
thus @xmath340 is graded - coherent by lemma [ grcoh5 ] , a contradiction .
we thus see that @xmath500 is empty , which completes the proof .
[ grcoh7 ] suppose @xmath0 is graded - coherent .
then for any finitely generated ideal @xmath12 of @xmath1 the torsion @xmath844 is bounded .
let @xmath12 be given , and let @xmath393 be the ideal of @xmath0 generated by @xmath845}$ ] and @xmath365}$ ] .
use notation as in the first paragraph of the proof of lemma [ degdb1 ] . since @xmath0 is graded - coherent ,
@xmath703 is finitely generated .
suppose it is generated in degrees @xmath394 .
let @xmath846 be killed by @xmath145 .
let @xmath847 be a lift of @xmath848 , and let @xmath849 , so that @xmath850 .
let @xmath851 } e_0+\beta x^{[n-1 ] } e_1 $ ] .
then @xmath754 , so @xmath852 .
since @xmath703 is generated in degrees @xmath394 , we can write @xmath853 } r_i$ ] , where @xmath854 is a degree @xmath112 element of @xmath703 .
( note that @xmath855 . )
write @xmath856 } e_0+\beta_i x^{[i-1 ] } e_1 $ ] with @xmath857 . since @xmath858 , we find @xmath859 , so , writing @xmath860 for the image of @xmath861 in @xmath13 , we find @xmath862 . from the expression relating @xmath11 and the @xmath854
, we find @xmath863 .
thus if @xmath864 is a common multiple of @xmath865 ( e.g. , @xmath866 ) then @xmath867 .
therefore , @xmath844 is killed by @xmath868 , which completes the proof . if ( a1 ) , ( a2 ) , and ( a3 ) hold then @xmath333}$ ] is graded - coherent for all @xmath165 by lemma [ grcoh6 ]
conversely , if @xmath333}$ ] is graded - coherent then ( a1 ) necessarily holds , as does ( a3 ) , since any quotient of @xmath333}$ ] by a finitely generated homogeneous ideal is graded - coherent , and ( a2 ) holds at @xmath164 by lemma [ grcoh7 ] . thus if @xmath333}$ ]
is graded - coherent for all @xmath165 then ( a2 ) holds as well .
let @xmath1 be the classical divided power algebra over @xmath869 in a single variable @xmath829 , regarded as a non - graded ring , and let @xmath0 be the classical divided power algebra over @xmath1 in a single variable @xmath4 .
note that as an non - graded ring , @xmath0 is just the classical divided power algebra over @xmath1 in @xmath4 and @xmath829 .
let @xmath12 be the principal ideal of @xmath1 generated by @xmath870}$ ] .
then the image of @xmath871}$ ] in @xmath13 is annihilated by @xmath872 but no smaller power of @xmath18 .
thus condition ( a2 ) fails , and so @xmath0 is not graded - coherent , and therefore not coherent either .
here is an explicit example demonstrating the failure of coherence .
consider the ideal @xmath393 of @xmath0 generated by @xmath870}$ ] and @xmath365}$ ]
. then @xmath873 } x^{[p^r ] } ) y^{[1 ] } - ( y^{[p^r ] } x^{[p^r-1 ] } ) x^{[1 ] } = 0\ ] ] is a linear relation of between the generators , and does not come from lower degree relations .
thus @xmath393 is not finitely presented .
note that if we remember the grading on @xmath1 and regard @xmath0 as bigraded then @xmath393 is bihomogeneous .
this shows that @xmath0 is not even graded - coherent with respect to its bigrading .
let @xmath0 be a gdpa over @xmath1 .
let @xmath14 be a @xmath0-module .
we say that @xmath14 is * principal special * if it is isomorphic to a module of the form @xmath874 for some integer @xmath165 and ideal @xmath12 of @xmath1 containing @xmath222 .
we say that @xmath14 is * special * if it admits a finite length filtration where the graded pieces are principal special .
a * special resolution * of a @xmath0-module @xmath14 is a resolution @xmath875 where each @xmath876 is special .
the * special dimension * of @xmath14 , denoted @xmath877 or just @xmath878 , is the minimum integer @xmath65 for which there exists a special resolution @xmath875 with @xmath879 for all @xmath880 , or @xmath574 if no such resolution exists .
note that @xmath881 if and only if @xmath14 is special .
[ thm : sd ] suppose @xmath1 is noetherian and @xmath14 is a finitely presented @xmath0-module .
then @xmath882 , that is , @xmath14 admits a finite length special resolution .
moreover , if @xmath1 has finite krull dimension @xmath135 then @xmath883 .
the proof will take the entire section .
the basic idea is as follows .
first suppose @xmath1 is a field .
if infinitely many @xmath56 s vanish then every finitely presented module is special . if not ( e.g. , if @xmath41 $ ] ) this need not be the case , but at least every submodule of a finitely generated free module is special . now suppose @xmath1 is a domain with fraction field @xmath542 , let @xmath14 be a finitely presented @xmath0-module , and choose short exact sequence @xmath884 with @xmath591 finite free . then , as stated above , @xmath885 is special as a @xmath886-module .
we show that there is a special @xmath0-module @xmath887 such that @xmath888 .
scaling this isomorphism appropriately , we can assume @xmath889 and that the quotient is a torsion @xmath1-module .
the result now follows from noetherian induction and the fact that in a short exact sequence the special dimension of one term can be controlled by the that of the other two .
the notions of special module and special resolution can easily be adapted to the case of graded modules .
the above theorem remains true in the graded case , and the proof we give applies without change .
in fact , everything still goes through if the coefficient ring @xmath1 is equipped with a grading , though in this case some minor adjustments in our proof must be made ( specifically when using the fraction field of @xmath1 ) .
we begin by proving some basic facts about special resolutions and special dimension .
[ sp1 ] suppose that @xmath890 is a surjection of principal special @xmath0-modules .
then @xmath891 is special .
suppose @xmath892 and @xmath893 .
we proceed by a number of reductions .
first , since @xmath434 is surjective , every element of @xmath47 is annihilated by @xmath12 . but
the annihilator of @xmath894 is exactly @xmath895 , and so @xmath896 .
replacing @xmath1 by @xmath13 , we may as well assume @xmath897 .
the map @xmath434 obviously factors as @xmath898 for some @xmath435 .
we have a short exact sequence @xmath899 the module @xmath900 is special ( filter @xmath895 so that the graded pieces are cyclic @xmath1-modules ) , and so it suffices to show that @xmath901 is special .
thus we may as well replace @xmath14 with @xmath902 .
furthermore , replacing @xmath1 with @xmath903 , we may assume @xmath904 .
we have thus reduced to the case @xmath905 and @xmath906 .
we claim @xmath907 . indeed
, suppose @xmath908
. then @xmath909}$ ] annihilates @xmath14 , and therefore annihilates @xmath47 . but
this is not the case , since @xmath909 } \cdot 1 \ne 0 $ ] in @xmath47 .
now , since @xmath910 , we must have @xmath911 or @xmath912 , and so , by the inequality @xmath907 , we have @xmath911
. we may as well regrade and replace @xmath913 with @xmath0 .
in other words , we may assume @xmath914 and @xmath906 .
now , @xmath915 , where @xmath393 is the ideal @xmath916 } , \ldots , x^{[s-1]})$ ] .
thus @xmath434 factors as @xmath917 for some @xmath435 .
since @xmath918 is equal to @xmath47 , we may as well regard @xmath435 as an endomorphism of @xmath47 .
since it is surjective and @xmath47 is finitely generated , it is necessarily an isomorphism ( * ? ? ?
* http://stacks.math.columbia.edu/tag/05g8[tag 05g8 ] ) .
thus @xmath919 .
one easily sees that @xmath393 has a finite length filtration with successive quotients @xmath920 , and is therefore special .
[ sp2 ] let @xmath14 be a special @xmath0-module .
then there exists a finite free @xmath0-module @xmath591 and a surjection @xmath921 such that @xmath891 is special .
let @xmath922 be a short exact sequence where @xmath923 is principal special and @xmath924 is special and built out of fewer principal specials than @xmath14 ( e.g. , @xmath924 is the last piece in the filtration that @xmath14 is required to have ) . by induction , we can find a short exact sequence @xmath925 with @xmath926 finite free and @xmath927 special .
let @xmath928 be a short exact sequence with @xmath929 finite free .
then @xmath930 is special by the previous lemma .
lift @xmath931 to a map @xmath932 .
the map @xmath933 is then surjective .
if @xmath703 denotes its kernel then we have a short exact sequence @xmath934 and so @xmath703 is special .
[ sp3 ] let @xmath14 be a @xmath0-module with @xmath935 .
then we can find a surjection @xmath921 with @xmath591 finite free such that @xmath936 .
let @xmath23 be a resolution with @xmath937 special for all @xmath112 .
let @xmath938 be a short exact sequence with @xmath591 finite free and @xmath939 special ; this exists by the previous lemma .
consider the short exact sequence @xmath940 let @xmath941 be the kernel of the surjection @xmath942 .
we have a short exact sequence @xmath943 which shows that @xmath941 is special .
the projection map @xmath944 induces a surjection @xmath945 , and one easily verifies that @xmath946 is a resolution of @xmath703 .
thus @xmath947 . from the obvious inequality @xmath948
, we conclude @xmath949 .
[ sp4 ] let @xmath14 be a @xmath0-module with @xmath950 . then there is a resolution @xmath951 where @xmath432 is finite free and @xmath952 is special . [ sp5 ] let @xmath864 be a ring , let @xmath953 and @xmath954 be resolutions of the same length @xmath26 such that @xmath955 are free . then any map @xmath890 can be lifted to a map of resolutions @xmath956 , that is , we can fill in the following diagram : @xmath957 & q_r \ar[r ] \ar@{ .. >}[d ] & q_{r-1 } \ar[r ] \ar@{ .. >}[d ] & \cdots \ar[r ] & q_0 \ar[r ] \ar@{ .. >}[d ] & m \ar[d]^f \ar[r ] & 0 \\ 0 \ar[r ] & p_r \ar[r ] & p_{r-1 } \ar[r ] & \cdots \ar[r ] & p_0 \ar[r ] & n \ar[r ] & 0 } \ ] ] when @xmath958 is also free , this is a standard result about free resolutions .
the proof of that result applies here as well : the point is that one never needs to lift maps from @xmath958 .
[ sp6 ] suppose that @xmath959 is a short exact sequence of @xmath0-modules
. then 1 .
2 . @xmath961 .
3 . @xmath962 . in particular ,
if two of the modules admit finite length special resolutions then so does the third .
\(a ) let @xmath963 .
first suppose @xmath964 .
let @xmath965 and @xmath966 be special resolutions of length @xmath26 such that @xmath24 and @xmath955 are free . lift the @xmath967 to a map of resolutions @xmath968 .
then we have a resolution @xmath969 since @xmath970 is a surjection of free modules , its kernel is free , and so the above is a special resolution of @xmath971 of length at most @xmath26 .
now suppose @xmath751 .
let @xmath972 be a special resolution with @xmath973 free .
let @xmath974 be a special resolution with @xmath636 free .
lift @xmath975 to a map @xmath976 and lift @xmath977 to a map @xmath978 .
let @xmath979 , and let @xmath980 be the kernel of the natural surjection @xmath981 .
we have a short exact sequence @xmath982 and so @xmath980 is special .
the square @xmath983 \ar[d ] & q_0 \ar[d ] \\
m_2 \ar[r ] & m_3 } \ ] ] commutes , and all maps are surjective . thus @xmath984 maps @xmath980 into @xmath985 .
we thus have a resolution @xmath986 since @xmath984 is surjective , its kernel is free , and we have a short exact sequence @xmath987 and so @xmath988 is special .
thus @xmath989 .
\(b ) let @xmath990 .
if @xmath991 then @xmath992 is clearly special , so assume @xmath248 .
let @xmath993 and @xmath966 be special resolutions of length @xmath26 such that @xmath955 are free .
following the proof of the `` horseshoe lemma , '' we can build a partial resolution @xmath994 where @xmath703 is by definition the kernel of the map @xmath995 ( or the map @xmath996 if @xmath751 ) . by the snake lemma
, we have a short exact sequence @xmath997 and so @xmath703 is special .
thus the above is a special resolution of @xmath992 , and so @xmath998 .
\(c ) let @xmath999 , and let @xmath993 and @xmath1000 be special resolutions of length @xmath26 such that @xmath24 are free .
lift the map @xmath1001 to a map of resolutions @xmath968 .
then we have a resolution @xmath1002 and so @xmath1003 .
we now start on the proof of theorem [ thm : sd ] .
suppose @xmath1 is a field and infinitely many of the @xmath56 vanish .
then any finitely presented ( graded ) @xmath0-module is special .
let @xmath14 be a finitely presented @xmath0-module . by proposition [ prop : h - free ]
, there exists @xmath164 and a finitely generated @xmath424-module @xmath47 such that @xmath1004 as a module over @xmath430 . since @xmath424 is a local artinian ring
, @xmath47 admits a finite filtration such that each graded piece gets annihilated by the maximal ideal .
tensoring with the exact funtor @xmath436 , we see that @xmath14 has a filtration such that each graded piece is a free @xmath372-module and so @xmath14 is special .
[ spfield ] suppose @xmath1 is a field and @xmath591 is a finite free @xmath0-module . then any finitely generated ( graded )
submodule of @xmath591 is special .
the case when infinitely many of the @xmath56 vanish follows from the previous lemma and so we may assume that only finitely many of the @xmath56 are zero .
let @xmath164 be the largest such that @xmath429 and let @xmath1005 .
then @xmath0 is isomorphic to @xmath1006 $ ] where @xmath829 is an indeterminate of degree @xmath164 .
let @xmath393 be a submodule of @xmath591 . since @xmath11 is a local artinian ring ( say with maximal ideal @xmath194 ) there exists a finite filtration of @xmath393 such that the graded pieces are of the form @xmath1007 . clearly , each such graded piece is a torsion - free @xmath1008$]-module . since @xmath1008 $ ] is a principal ideal domain the result follows from the structure theorem of finitely generated modules over a principal ideal domain .
let @xmath1 be a domain and let @xmath1009
. then every special @xmath1010-module @xmath952 has the form @xmath1011 for some special @xmath0-module @xmath939 . by a `` lattice '' in a @xmath1010 module @xmath952 , we mean a @xmath0-submodule @xmath939 of @xmath952 such that @xmath1012 .
thus the lemma states that every special @xmath1010-module admits a special lattice , that is , one that is special as a @xmath0-module .
first suppose @xmath952 is principal special .
then @xmath1013 for some @xmath164 with @xmath371 .
one can then take @xmath1014 .
thus the lemma holds in this case .
now suppose @xmath952 is an arbitrary special module .
choose an exact sequence @xmath1015 where @xmath1016 is principal special and @xmath1017 is special and built out of fewer principal specials than @xmath952 .
let @xmath1018 be a special lattice , which exists by the previous paragraph , and let @xmath1019 be a special lattice , which exists by induction .
let @xmath1020 be a finitely generated @xmath0-submodule of @xmath952 that surjects onto @xmath1021 .
( one can construct @xmath1022 by lifting generators of @xmath1021 and taking the @xmath0-module they span . )
then @xmath1023 is a finitely generated @xmath0-submodule of @xmath1017 , as it coincides with @xmath1024 and @xmath1021 is finitely presented .
since @xmath941 is a lattice in @xmath1017 , it follows that @xmath1023 is contained in @xmath1025 for some nonzero @xmath1026 .
let @xmath1027 .
then we have a short exact sequence @xmath1028 and so @xmath939 is special .
it is clear that @xmath939 is a lattice in @xmath952 , and so the result follows .
we first show that @xmath878 is finite .
we proceed by noetherian induction , so we assume the result holds if @xmath14 has nonzero annihilator in @xmath1 .
note that if @xmath952 is special as a @xmath534-module then it is also special as a @xmath0-module , and so if @xmath14 is annihilated by @xmath1029 then @xmath1030 .
we now consider two cases .
_ case 1 : @xmath1 is not a domain .
_ let @xmath563 with @xmath1031 .
we have an exact sequence @xmath1032 and so by proposition [ sp6](b ) , we have @xmath1033 since @xmath1034 and @xmath1035 have non - zero annihilators , the right side is finite by the inductive hypothesis , and so @xmath882 .
_ case 2 : @xmath1 is a domain .
_ let @xmath1036 .
let @xmath1037 be a short exact sequence with @xmath591 finite free .
then @xmath1038 , and so @xmath1039 is special by the lemma [ spfield ] .
we can therefore find a special @xmath0-module @xmath952 and an isomorphism @xmath1040 . scaling this isomorphism
, we can assume that @xmath923 maps into @xmath952 .
let @xmath47 and @xmath887 be the kernel and cokernel of the map @xmath1041 , so that we have a 4-term exact sequence @xmath1042 breaking this up into two short exact sequences and applying proposition [ sp6 ] , we find @xmath1043 and so @xmath1044 but @xmath47 and @xmath887 have nonzero annihilator in @xmath1 , and so have finite special dimension by the inductive hypothesis . thus @xmath882
. now suppose @xmath1 has finite krull dimension @xmath135 , and let us show @xmath883 .
we proceed again by noetherian induction .
if @xmath1 is not a domain , then with notation as in case 1 , we have @xmath1045 and @xmath1046 by the inductive hypothesis , and so gives @xmath883 .
now suppose @xmath1 is a domain , and use notation as in case 2 . if @xmath1047 , i.e. , @xmath1 is a field , then @xmath923 is special and @xmath1048 .
now suppose @xmath1049 .
then the support of @xmath47 and @xmath887 has dimension strictly less than @xmath135 , and so @xmath1050 and @xmath1051 by the inductive hypothesis , and so gives @xmath883 .
for a coherent ring @xmath864 , we let @xmath1052 denote the category of finitely presented @xmath864-modules , and we let @xmath1053 be the grothendieck group of @xmath1052 . if @xmath864 is graded then we let @xmath1054 denote the category of finitely presented graded @xmath864-modules , and we let @xmath1055 be its grothendieck group .
we also apply these definitions to non - graded rings by regarding them as graded and concentrated in degree 0 .
the group @xmath1055 is naturally a module over the ring @xmath1056 $ ] via @xmath1057=[m[1]]$ ] .
we define @xmath1058 to be @xmath1059 , thought of as an @xmath11-submodule of @xmath1060 , and put @xmath1061 .
fix a gdpa @xmath0 .
the purpose of [ s : groth ] is to study @xmath27 and @xmath1062 .
the existence of special resolutions gives us a spanning set for both of these groups , and the main difficulty lies in understanding the relations these classes satisfy . for this
, we need to construct interesting maps out of the grothendieck group .
we first concentrate on the graded case . in [ ss : groth - ratl ] we construct the most obvious map out of @xmath1062 , the hilbert series @xmath1063 .
it turns out that this is enough to obtain a description of @xmath1062 up to @xmath11-torsion .
based on the nature of the hilbert series , in [ ss : groth - conj ]
we formulate a plausible description of @xmath1062 ( conjecture [ conj : k ] ) .
the hilbert series is not powerful enough to prove this conjecture , so in [ ss : grothl ] we define a subtler invariant , denoted @xmath1064 . in
[ ss : groth - proof ] , we manage to prove conjecture [ conj : k ] under a certain hypothesis using @xmath1063 and @xmath1064 ( theorem [ thm : k ] ) . in
[ ss : groth - compare ] , we show that @xmath27 can be obtained from @xmath1062 in a straightforward manner , and thus conjecture [ conj : k ] also predicts the structure of @xmath27 . in [ ss : groth - classical ] we apply the results to the classical divided power algebra .
we show that the hypothesis of theorem [ thm : k ] is met , and thus deduce a complete description of the grothendieck group . finally , in [ ss : kq ] , we show that the hypothesis of theorem [ thm : k ] is not met for the @xmath2-divided power algebra over @xmath299 $ ] , and so our results do not give a full description of the grothendieck group in this case .
we begin by recording a useful spanning set for the grothendieck group and some obvious relations they satisfy . for an ideal @xmath12 of @xmath1 containing @xmath222 ,
let @xmath1066 be the @xmath0-module @xmath874 .
note that any ideal contains @xmath119 , and @xmath1067 .
[ prop : mah ] let @xmath12 be an ideal of @xmath1 containing @xmath222 .
then : 1 . the classes @xmath1065 $ ] span both @xmath27 and @xmath1062 .
now suppose @xmath1068 and @xmath12 also contains @xmath156 ( e.g. , @xmath1069 ) .
then : 1 .
we have @xmath1070=[m(\fa , k)]$ ] in @xmath27 .
we have @xmath1071=[m(\fa , k)]$ ] in @xmath1062 .
\(a ) follows immediately from the theorem on special resolutions ( theorem [ thm : sd ] ) . for ( b ) and ( c ) ,
note that @xmath1072 and @xmath1073 admits a filtration where the successive quotients are @xmath1074 , \ldots , \bk[(h-1)k]$ ] .
let @xmath14 be a finitely presented graded @xmath0-module .
define the * hilbert series * of @xmath14 , denoted @xmath1075 , by @xmath1076 t^n,\ ] ] where @xmath1077 $ ] denotes the class of the @xmath1-module @xmath74 in @xmath1078 .
it is clear that the hilbert series construction factors through the grothendieck group and defines an @xmath11-linear map @xmath1079 our main result about the hilbert series is the following proposition : [ prop : hilb ] let @xmath14 be a finitely presented graded @xmath0-module .
then there there exists @xmath1080 and elements @xmath1081 such that @xmath1082 by proposition [ prop : mah](a ) , it suffices to check this for the module @xmath1083 .
we have @xmath1084 thus @xmath1085}{1-t^h}$ ] , and the result follows .
we now describe @xmath1062 up to @xmath11-torsion .
consider the map @xmath1086
\mapsto ( t-1 ) [ \bd \otimes_{\bk } m]\ ] ] let @xmath237 be the @xmath11-subalgebra of @xmath1060 generated by @xmath1087 for @xmath144 .
we then have : [ prop : kgp ] the map @xmath1088 induced by @xmath1089 is an isomorphism .
define @xmath1090 by @xmath1091)=\rh_m(t)$ ] .
this map is well - defined by the previous proposition .
we claim that @xmath1092 is inverse to the map @xmath1093 in the statement of the theorem .
we first check that @xmath1094 is the identity .
thus let @xmath14 be a finitely generated @xmath1-module
. then @xmath1095)=(1-t ) [ m \otimes_{\bk } \bd]$ ] .
we have @xmath1096}{1-t}$ ] , and so @xmath1097))=[m]$ ] .
we now check that @xmath1098 is the identity .
it suffices to check @xmath1099))=[m]$ ] when @xmath1100 , since these span @xmath27 .
we have @xmath1091)=\frac{1}{1-t^h } [ \bk/\fa]$ ] , and so @xmath1099))=\frac{1-t}{1-t^h }
[ \bd/\fa \bd]$ ] , which equals @xmath1101 $ ] by proposition [ prop : mah](c ) .
this completes the proof .
suppose @xmath14 is a finitely presented graded @xmath0-module then , by proposition [ prop : hilb ] , we can write @xmath1102 where @xmath1103 .
if we express @xmath1101 $ ] as an @xmath11-linear combination of classes of the form @xmath1065 $ ] then only those classes with @xmath224 can contribute to @xmath1104 ( assuming we do not artifically insert canceling factors into the numerator and denominator ) .
that is , @xmath1104 is an @xmath11-linear combination of classes of the form @xmath1105 $ ] , where @xmath47 belongs to the category @xmath1106 of finitely generated @xmath1-modules supported on @xmath1107 .
this suggests that @xmath1104 might be well - defined in @xmath1108 .
we conjecture that this is the case , and that , moreover , it completely explains the structure of @xmath1062 . we now give a precise statement . for notational ease ,
let @xmath1109 .
for @xmath1110 we write @xmath1101_n$ ] for its class in @xmath1111 .
note that @xmath1112 is the category of all finitely generated @xmath1-modules , and for @xmath58 we have an inclusion @xmath1113 .
we define @xmath1114 to be the quotient of the @xmath11-module @xmath1115 by the relations @xmath1116_m}{1-t^n } = \frac{[m]_n}{1-t^n}\ ] ] for @xmath1117 and @xmath58 , where here the left side belongs to the @xmath39th summand and the right side to the @xmath65th summand .
( note that @xmath1118 , so that the left side above does indeed belong to the @xmath39th summand . )
we now define an @xmath11-linear map @xmath1119 suppose @xmath224 and @xmath12 is an ideal containing @xmath222 .
we then put @xmath1120_n}{1-t^n } \right ) = \frac{1-t^h}{1-t^n } [ m(\fa , h)].\ ] ] since @xmath1111 is spanned by the classes @xmath1121 $ ] as above , this specifies @xmath1093 uniquely .
we leave it to the reader to verify that @xmath1093 is well - defined .
it follows from proposition [ prop : mah](a ) that @xmath1093 is surjective .
our conjectural description of @xmath1062 is : [ conj : k ] the map @xmath1093 is an isomorphism .
let @xmath1122 be the category of finitely generated @xmath1-modules supported on @xmath1123 , and let @xmath1124 .
for @xmath1125 , let @xmath1101_+$ ] be the class of @xmath14 in @xmath1126 .
we extend this notation to all @xmath1-modules @xmath14 by putting @xmath1101_+=0 $ ] if @xmath1127 . for a graded @xmath1-module @xmath14
, we define @xmath1128 as @xmath1129_+ t^n$ ] . for a finitely
presented graded @xmath0-module @xmath14 , we define @xmath1130_+ \in \ck_+ { ( \!(}t { ) \!)}.\ ] ] for any fixed @xmath135 we have @xmath1131 for @xmath1132 ( proposition [ prop : tor - vanishing ] ) .
it follows that in the above sum , any fixed power of @xmath78 occurs only finitely many times , and so the sum is well - defined .
we also put @xmath1133 our main result on @xmath1064 is the following : [ prop : l ] we have a well - defined @xmath11-module homomorphism @xmath1134 \mapsto \rl_m(t)\ ] ] we need some lemmas before proving this . in
what follows , all @xmath0-modules are finitely presented and graded .
[ lem : l1 ] let @xmath14 be a @xmath0-module
. then @xmath1135 belongs to @xmath1122 for @xmath1132 . if @xmath1136 then the @xmath507 in question vanishes for @xmath578 ( proposition [ prop : relatively - projective ] ) .
if @xmath1100 for some @xmath1137 then all the @xmath507 s are annihilated by @xmath222 .
the result now follows from the theorem on special resolutions ( theorem [ thm : sd ] ) .
[ lem : l2 ] suppose that @xmath959 is a short exact sequence of @xmath0-modules .
then @xmath1138 for some @xmath1139 . if each @xmath1140 supported on @xmath1123 as a @xmath1-module then @xmath1141 .
let @xmath47 be such that @xmath1142 belongs to @xmath1122 for all @xmath1143 and all @xmath1144 .
this exists by lemma [ lem : l1 ] .
let @xmath1145 be the maximal degree occurring in the groups @xmath1142 for @xmath1146 and @xmath1144 .
consider the degree @xmath1147 piece of the long exact sequence in @xmath507 : @xmath1148 this is an exact sequence in the category @xmath1122 , and so the alternating sum of the classes in @xmath1126 is zero .
it follows that the coefficient of @xmath1149 in @xmath1150 vanishes for all @xmath1147 , and so @xmath1151 .
if each @xmath1140 is supported on @xmath1123 then all the @xmath507 s in question belong to @xmath1122 , so the above reasoning applies to all @xmath1152 , and so @xmath1141 .
[ lem : l3 ] let @xmath1100 with @xmath165
. then @xmath1153_+}{1-t^h}.\ ] ] we have @xmath1154 = [ \bd/\fa \bd]$ ] in @xmath1155 by proposition [ prop : mah](c ) , and so @xmath1156 ( by the previous lemma if @xmath1137 , and is trivially true for @xmath817 ) . by proposition
[ prop : relatively - projective ] , the group @xmath1157 vanishes for @xmath578 and equals @xmath13 for @xmath1158 , and so @xmath1159_+$ ] .
the result follows . by lemma [
lem : l2 ] , @xmath1064 gives a well - defined homomorphism @xmath1160 .
proposition [ prop : mah](a ) and lemma [ lem : l3 ] show that the image is contained in @xmath1161 . for @xmath263 , we have an inclusion @xmath1162 , and thus an induced homomorphism @xmath1163 .
[ thm : k ] assume the following condition holds : * for all @xmath263 the map @xmath1163 is injective .
then conjecture [ conj : k ] is true .
let @xmath1164 be the @xmath11-span of classes of the form @xmath1165}{t-1}$ ] with @xmath14 a finitely generated @xmath1-module .
then @xmath1166 is identified with @xmath1167 .
let @xmath1168 be the quotient of @xmath1114 by @xmath1166 .
then @xmath1168 is identified with the submodule of @xmath1161 consisting of elements of the form @xmath1169 where @xmath1170 ( this identification uses @xmath452 ) .
we first claim that the map @xmath1171 is well - defined and simply the identity . if @xmath1172 then @xmath1173 by the definition of @xmath1064 .
thus the above map is well - defined .
the module @xmath1168 is generated by elements of the form @xmath1174_+}{t^n-1}$ ] where @xmath12 is an ideal containing @xmath222 and @xmath224 . by definition , we have @xmath1175 $ ] .
thus , by lemma [ lem : l3 ] , we have @xmath1176_+}{1-t^h } = f,\ ] ] and the claim is proved .
we next claim that the map @xmath1177 is the identity .
the module @xmath1166 is spanned by elements of the form @xmath1174}{t-1}$ ] .
we have @xmath1178 $ ] by definition .
thus @xmath1179}{t-1 } = f,\ ] ] and the claim is proved .
we now prove the theorem .
it suffices to show that @xmath1093 is injective .
thus suppose @xmath1180 .
let @xmath1181 be the image of @xmath4 in @xmath1168 .
then @xmath1182 by the first paragraph .
thus @xmath1183 . but
then @xmath1184 by the second paragraph .
this completes the proof .
the forgetful functor @xmath1185 induces a map @xmath1186 that obvious kills @xmath1187 . in fact
: [ prop : kgrade ] the natural map @xmath1188 is an isomorphism .
the proof closely follows the proof of the so - called fundamental theorem of k - theory , as presented in @xcite .
we will make extensive use of the ring @xmath1189 $ ] , which we grade using the usual grading on @xmath0 and setting @xmath1190 .
note that if @xmath1191 then ( ignoring the grading ) @xmath1189=\bd(\bk[u ] , \pi_{\bullet})$ ] , and so @xmath1189 $ ] is coherent since @xmath1192 $ ] is noetherian .
[ lem : kgr1 ] we have an equivalence of categories @xmath1193}^{{\mathrm{fp } } } = \mod_{\bd}^{{\mathrm{fp}}}$ ] .
let @xmath1194_0 $ ] be the map given by @xmath1195 on homogeneous elements @xmath1196 .
then @xmath1093 is an isomorphism .
if @xmath14 is a graded @xmath1197$]-module then its degree 0 piece is a module over @xmath1198}]_0 $ ] and thus , via @xmath1199 , over @xmath0 .
conversely , if @xmath47 is a @xmath1197_0$]-module , then @xmath1200 is a graded @xmath1197$]-module , with @xmath1201 acting in the obvious manner , and @xmath1196 acting by @xmath1202 .
one easily sees that these constructions are inverse to each other .
let @xmath1203)$ ] be the map induced by the functor @xmath1204 $ ] , and let @xmath1205 ) \to { \ul{\rk}}(\bd)$ ] be the map induced by the functor @xmath1206 } \bd$ ] , where here @xmath0 is thought of as a @xmath1189$]-module by @xmath1207/(u)$ ] .
we note that @xmath0 has projective dimension 1 as a @xmath1189$]-module , and so the left - derived functor of @xmath1208 } \bd$ ] does indeed induce a map on k - theory . [
lem : kgr2 ] the maps @xmath693 and @xmath694 are mutually inverse .
it is clear that @xmath1209 , so we must show @xmath1210 . for @xmath165 , consider the following diagram @xmath1211^{\alpha } & { \ul{\rk}}(\bd[u ] ) \\
{ \ul{\rk}}(\bk/(\pi_h ) ) \ar[u]^{f_h } \ar[r]^{i_h } & { \ul{\rk}}(\bk/(\pi_h)[u ] ) \ar[u]_{f'_h } } \ ] ] the map @xmath1212 is induced by the functor @xmath1213 , and @xmath1214 is defined similarly .
the map @xmath1215 is extension of scalars .
the theorem on special resolutions ( theorem [ thm : sd ] ) states that the maps @xmath1214 are jointly surjective , that is , the sum of their images is the entire @xmath1216)$ ] .
the map @xmath1215 is an isomorphism by the following lemma .
it follows from this that @xmath693 is surjective . since @xmath1217 , we have @xmath1218 , and thus @xmath1219 since @xmath693 is surjective .
[ lem : krg3 ] let @xmath1 be a non - graded ring , and regard @xmath1192 $ ] as graded by @xmath1190
. then extension of scalars induces an isomorphism @xmath1220)$ ] .
the map @xmath1221)$ ] induced by extension of scalars is an isomorphism by ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 5.4 ) .
however , we have an obvious identification @xmath1222 since @xmath1 is non - graded .
let @xmath1223}^0 $ ] denote the category of finitely presented graded @xmath1189$]-modules annihilated by a power of @xmath1201 , and let @xmath1224)$ ] be its grothendieck group .
we then have the localization sequence @xmath1225 ) \to { \ul{\rk}}(\bd[u ] ) \to { \ul{\rk}}(\bd[u , u^{-1 } ] ) \to 0.\ ] ] by dvissage , @xmath1224)={\ul{\rk}}(\bd)$ ] . combining this and
lemmas [ lem : kgr1 ] and [ lem : kgr2 ] with the above sequence gives the diagram @xmath1226 ) \ar[r ] & { \ul{\rk}}(\bd[u ] ) \ar[r ] & { \ul{\rk}}(\bd[u , u^{-1 } ] ) \ar[r ] & 0 \\ { \ul{\rk}}(\bd ) \ar@{=}[u ] \ar[r ] & { \ul{\rk}}(\bd ) \ar@{=}[u ] \ar[r ] & \rk(\bd ) \ar@{=}[u ] \ar[r ] & 0 } \ ] ] we claim that the bottom left map is multiplication by @xmath1227 , which will complete the proof
. thus let @xmath1228 .
starting with @xmath1101 $ ] in the bottom left group and going up and right , we obtain the class in @xmath1216)$ ] obtained by treating @xmath14 as a @xmath1189$]-module with @xmath1201 acting by 0 .
we now want to move this class down under @xmath694 . by definition , @xmath1229)$ ]
is the class of @xmath1230 } \bd$ ] . using the resolution @xmath1189[1 ]
\stackrel{u}{\to } \bd[u]$ ] of @xmath0 ( where @xmath1231 $ ] indicates shift in grading ) , we see that @xmath1229)$ ] is the class of the complex @xmath1232 \to m$ ] , i.e. , @xmath1233 $ ] .
combining the above result with proposition [ prop : kgp ] yields a rational description of @xmath27 : the map @xmath1234 taking @xmath1101 $ ] to @xmath1235 $ ] is an isomorphism .
we also give a conjecutral description of @xmath27 .
define @xmath1236 to be the quotient of @xmath1237 by the relations @xmath1238_m = [ m]_n$ ] for @xmath1117 and @xmath58 , where the left side belongs to the @xmath39th summand and the right to the @xmath65th summand .
then @xmath1239 is identified with @xmath1236 , and so the map induces a natural map @xmath1240 . thus proposition [ prop : kgrade ] gives us : suppose conjecture [ conj : k ] holds for @xmath0 .
then the natural map @xmath1240 is an isomorphism .
we now assume that @xmath0 is the classical divided power algebra over @xmath1 .
[ prop : classast ] the condition @xmath452 of theorem [ thm : k ] holds . by definition , @xmath1122 is the category of finitely generated @xmath1-modules that are torsion as abelian groups .
if @xmath263 is a power of the prime @xmath18 then @xmath1106 is the category of finitely generated @xmath1-modules that are annihilated by a power of @xmath18 . by the chinese remainder theorem ,
@xmath1106 is a summand of @xmath1122 , and so @xmath1163 is injective . if @xmath263 is not a prime power then @xmath1241 . for a prime number @xmath18 , let @xmath1242 .
[ cor : groth - class ] we have short exact sequences @xmath1243 and @xmath28 where in both lines the sum is over all prime numbers @xmath18 .
these sequences simply come from computing @xmath1114 and @xmath1236 . in the notation of the proof of theorem [ thm : k ] ,
the first short exact sequence is simply @xmath1244 [ ex : ktors ] let @xmath1245 , let @xmath1246 be the maximal ideal of @xmath1 , and let @xmath1247 be a power of @xmath18 .
note that @xmath1248 . we have @xmath1249=[\bd]-[\bd]=0 $ ] , and so @xmath1250 $ ] is killed by @xmath1251 by proposition [ prop : mah](c ) .
however , we have @xmath1252_+}{1-t^h}$ ] and @xmath1253_+$ ] is not zero in @xmath1126 ; thus @xmath1254 is non - zero in @xmath1161 , and so @xmath1255 $ ] is non - zero in @xmath27 .
we therefore have an example of a non - zero class in @xmath27 that is killed by a non - zero element of @xmath11 .
[ rmk : dercat ] let @xmath1256 be the bounded derived category of finitely presented non - graded @xmath0-modules .
let @xmath1257 be the full subcategory on objects that can be represented by bounded complexes whose terms have the form @xmath15 with @xmath14 a finitely presented @xmath1-module .
let @xmath1258 be the full subcategory of @xmath1256 on objects represented by bounded complexes of finitely presented @xmath0-modules that are torsion as @xmath1259-modules .
then @xmath1260 and @xmath1261 thus corollary [ cor : groth - class ] suggests an equivalence @xmath1262 such an equivalence also seems plausible due to the form of special resolutions .
( this remark is not specific to the classical divided power algebra , and should apply to any gdpa . ) let @xmath0 be the @xmath2-divided power algbera over @xmath299 $ ] .
we now study the groups @xmath1111 and @xmath1126 , and ultimately show that condition @xmath452 of theorem [ thm : k ] does not hold . for an integer @xmath144
, we write @xmath1263 $ ] for the quotient @xmath299/(\phi_n)$ ] , where @xmath1264 is the image of @xmath2 , a primitive @xmath65th root of unity .
the group @xmath1265)$ ] canonically decomposes as @xmath1266 , where @xmath1259 is generated by the class of @xmath1263 $ ] itself , and @xmath1267 is the class group of the number field @xmath1268 , which is finite .
now , it is a general fact that if @xmath12 and @xmath895 are ideals in a noetherian ring @xmath1 then we have an exact sequence @xmath1269 taking @xmath1270 and @xmath1271 yields @xmath1272/(\phi_n,\phi_m ) ) \to \rk(\bz[\zeta_n ] ) \oplus \rk(\bz[\zeta_m ] ) \to \rk(\bz[q]/(\phi_n \phi_m ) ) \to 0.\ ] ] applying the above sequence repeatedly and taking a direct limit yields a presentation @xmath1273/(\phi_t , \phi_s ) ) \stackrel{\alpha}{\to } \bigoplus_{n \mid t } \rk(\bz[\zeta_t ] ) \to \ck_n \to 0.\ ] ] now , observe that @xmath1274 is a height 2 prime of @xmath299 $ ] , and so the image of @xmath693 lands in the sum of the class groups . in particular , after tensoring with @xmath1275 we see that @xmath693 is 0 . thus @xmath1276 has a natural basis indexed by the multiples of @xmath65 .
a similar analysis holds for @xmath1277 : it has a natural basis indexed by integers @xmath1278 .
we thus find : [ prop : qdprat ] the condition @xmath452 of theorem [ thm : k ] holds rationally .
thus the map @xmath1279 induced from the map @xmath1093 in conjecture [ conj : k ] is an isomorphism . for @xmath1280 ,
let @xmath1281 ) \to \rk(\bz[\zeta_n])$ ] be the norm map . on the @xmath1259 summand , this is multiplication by the degree @xmath1282 $ ] , while on the class group summand it is the usual norm map on ideals . summing these maps
yields a map @xmath1283 ) \to \rk(\bz[\zeta_n]).\ ] ] we claim that @xmath1284 kills the image of @xmath693 .
thus let @xmath1285 be multiples of @xmath65 .
the ideal @xmath1274 is the unit ideal unless @xmath1286 for some prime @xmath18 , so assume this is the case .
let @xmath194 be a maximal ideal of @xmath299 $ ] containing @xmath1274 , and let @xmath1287 and @xmath1288 be the images of @xmath194 in @xmath1289 $ ] and @xmath1290 $ ] .
then @xmath1287 is totally ramified in @xmath1290 $ ] , and @xmath1288 is the unique prime above it .
thus the norm of @xmath1288 down to @xmath1289 $ ] is @xmath1287 . by the compatibility of norms in towers
, we see that @xmath1287 and @xmath1288 have the same norm down to @xmath1263 $ ] .
this establishes the claim .
we thus see that @xmath1284 induces a map @xmath1291).\ ] ] it follows immediately from the definition that @xmath1292 is left - inverse to the canonical map @xmath1265 ) \to \ck_n$ ] , and so we find : [ prop : qdpinj ] the canonical map @xmath1265 ) \to \ck_n$ ] is a split injection .
we now come to the main point : the condition @xmath452 of theorem [ thm : k ] does not hold .
in fact , the map @xmath1293 is not injective . fix a primitive cube root of unity @xmath1294 , and give @xmath1295 the structure of a @xmath299$]-module by letting @xmath2 act by @xmath1296 .
the module @xmath14 is killed by @xmath1297 and @xmath1298 , and can thus be regarded as a module over @xmath1299 $ ] and @xmath1300 $ ] .
let @xmath1246 be the prime of @xmath1299 $ ] over 13 corresponding to @xmath1296 , i.e. , @xmath1301 , and let @xmath1302 be the unique prime of @xmath1300 $ ] over @xmath1246 .
then @xmath1303/\fp$ ] as a @xmath1299$]-module and @xmath1304/\fq$ ] as a @xmath1300$]-module . now , the ideal @xmath1246 is principal since @xmath1305 has class number 1 , and so the class of @xmath14 in @xmath1306)$ ] is zero .
it follows that the class of @xmath14 vanishes in @xmath1307 , and thus in @xmath1126 as well . on the other hand
, @xmath1302 is non - principal ( see @xcite ) .
thus the class of @xmath14 in @xmath1308)$ ] is non - zero , and therefore the class of @xmath14 in @xmath1309 is non - zero by proposition [ prop : qdpinj ] .
this class is therefore a non - zero element of the kernel of @xmath1293 .
throughout this section , @xmath1 denotes a field and @xmath0 a gdpa over @xmath1 . our goal is to prove the following theorem : [ thm : selfinj ] the injective dimension of @xmath0 as a @xmath0-module is at most 1 , in both the graded and ungraded cases . more precisely : 1 .
if infinitely many of the @xmath56 vanish then @xmath0 is injective as a graded @xmath0-module .
if infinitely many of the @xmath56 vanish then @xmath0 has injective dimension 1 in the category of all @xmath0-modules , and @xmath1310 for all finitely presented @xmath14 and all @xmath578 .
if only finitely many of the @xmath56 vanish then @xmath0 has injective dimension 1 in both the graded and ungraded categories .
[ lem : dualfree ] ( in this lemma , @xmath1 can be any ring . )
suppose @xmath371 .
then @xmath1311 is free of rank one as a @xmath424-module . as a @xmath1-module , @xmath424 is free with basis @xmath5 } , \ldots , x^{[h-1]}$ ]
. thus @xmath1311 is also free .
let @xmath1312 be the dual basis , so that @xmath1313})=\delta_{i , j}$ ] .
we have @xmath329 } \lambda_{h-1}=u \lambda_{h-1-i}$ ] , where @xmath1314 is given by @xmath329 } x^{[h-1-i ] } = u x^{[h-1]}$ ] .
we claim that @xmath1201 is a unit . indeed ,
if @xmath194 is any maximal ideal of @xmath1 then @xmath1315 for some @xmath112 , and so there are no carries in the sum @xmath1316 when working in base @xmath1317 .
it follows that @xmath1201 is a unit in @xmath531 for all @xmath194 , and thus a unit .
this proves the claim .
it now follows that @xmath1318 is a basis for @xmath1311 as a @xmath424-module .
[ lem : truncinj ] suppose @xmath368 .
then @xmath406 is injective as a module over itself , both in the graded and non - graded settings .
let @xmath1319 , and let @xmath14 be an arbitrary @xmath864-module .
we have @xmath1320 the first isomorphism comes from lemma [ lem : dualfree ] , while the second is a standard adjunction . since the functor @xmath1321 is exact , it follows that @xmath864 is injective as an @xmath864-module .
the same proof works in the graded case .
we first prove the @xmath46 vanishing statement . by dimension shifting , it suffices to treat the @xmath1322 case . by dvissage
, it suffices to treat the case where @xmath1323 with @xmath393 a finitely generated ideal . for this , it is enough to show that a given map @xmath1324 extends to a map @xmath1325 .
let @xmath1326 be generators for @xmath393 .
pick @xmath40 such that @xmath368 and the elements @xmath1327 and @xmath1328 all belong to @xmath406 .
let @xmath1329 be the ideal generated by the @xmath434 s , and let @xmath1330 be the restriction of @xmath1093 .
we have an isomorphism @xmath1331 , under which @xmath393 corresponds to @xmath1332 and @xmath1093 corresponds to @xmath1333 .
since @xmath406 is injective as a module over itself by lemma [ lem : truncinj ] , the map @xmath1089 extends to a map @xmath1334 .
then @xmath1335 is an extension of @xmath1093 .
we now show that the injective dimension of @xmath0 is at most one .
this follows from the previous paragraph by general considerations , as follows .
first , suppose that @xmath1323 is a cyclic @xmath0-module .
since @xmath0 has countable dimension over @xmath1 , the ideal @xmath393 is countably generated .
write @xmath1336 with @xmath1337 finitely generated , and put @xmath1338 so that @xmath14 is the direct limit of the @xmath74 and each @xmath74 is finitely presented .
we have @xmath1339 since @xmath1340 for @xmath578 and @xmath1341 for @xmath1342 , we find that @xmath1343 for @xmath1342 .
it follows from this that @xmath1310 for @xmath1342 for any @xmath0-module @xmath14 ( see ( * ? ? ?
* http://stacks.math.columbia.edu/tag/0a5t[tag 0a5 t ] ) ) , and so @xmath0 has injective dimension at most one .
example [ ex : ext ] below shows that the injective dimension is exactly 1 .
the first two paragraphs of the above argument can be easily adapted to prove the following statement .
let @xmath1344 be a family of finite dimensional ( not necessarily commutative ) @xmath1-algebras such that for any finite subset @xmath1345 the algebra @xmath1346 is self - injective , and suppose @xmath1347 .
then the algebra @xmath1348 has injective dimension at most @xmath1349 over itself .
for instance , if @xmath1350 is a family of finite groups and @xmath1351 is the subgroup where all but finitely many coordinates are the identity then @xmath1352 $ ] has injective dimension at most @xmath1349 .
[ ex : ext ] suppose infinitely many @xmath56 vanish and let @xmath393 be the ideal @xmath916 } , x^{[2 ] } , \ldots)$ ] of @xmath0 .
we show that @xmath1353 in the ungraded category , where @xmath519 . to do this
, it suffices to construct a homomorphism @xmath1324 that does not extend to @xmath0 .
let @xmath1354 be a strictly increasing sequence with @xmath1355 for all @xmath112 , and define @xmath1356},\ ] ] regarded as a formal sum . for any @xmath144
we have @xmath9 } x^{[b_i-1]}=0 $ ] for all @xmath1132 ; in fact , as soon as @xmath1357 there is necessarily a carry when computing @xmath1358 in base @xmath113 , and then the product will vanish .
it follows that the product @xmath1359 is a well - defined element of @xmath0 for all @xmath1360 , and one easily sees that putting @xmath1361 gives a well - defined module homomorphism @xmath1362 .
suppose that @xmath1093 extended to @xmath0 .
then we would have @xmath1363 for all @xmath1360 , where @xmath1364 is an actual element of @xmath0 .
but this is clearly impossible , since @xmath1365}$ ] is a sum of @xmath112 monomials , while the number of monomials in @xmath1366}$ ] is bounded as @xmath112 varies .
let @xmath393 be a non - zero finitely generated homogeneous ideal and let @xmath1367 \to \bd$ ] be a map of graded modules .
the argument in the first paragraph of the proof of theorem [ thm : selfinj](b ) applies and shows that @xmath1093 extends to a map @xmath1368 \to \bd$ ] .
since the space @xmath1369 is at most one - dimensional , it follows that @xmath1092 is unique .
it follows from this that if @xmath551 is a finitely generated homogeneous ideal containing @xmath393 then @xmath1093 extends uniquely to @xmath551 ; indeed , any two extensions to @xmath551 would further extend to @xmath0 , and therefore coincide .
now suppose @xmath393 is an arbitrary non - zero homogeneous ideal and let @xmath1367 \to \bd$ ] be a map of graded modules . write @xmath1336 with @xmath1337 finitely generated and @xmath1370 .
let @xmath1368 \to \bd$ ] be an extension of @xmath1371 .
then @xmath1372 and @xmath1373 are two extensions of @xmath1371 to @xmath1337 , and therefore must coincide .
it follows that @xmath1374 , and so @xmath1093 extends to @xmath0 . by a graded version of baer s criterion
, it follows that @xmath0 is injective as a graded @xmath0-module .
we give the proof in the non - graded case , the argument in the graded case being identical .
let @xmath65 be maximal such that @xmath368 .
then @xmath1375 , where @xmath1376 is finite dimensional and @xmath1377 $ ] . for a @xmath1378-module @xmath14 ,
let @xmath1379 .
this functor is right adjoint to the forgetful functor from @xmath0-modules to @xmath1378-modules , and therefore takes injectives to injectives . since @xmath0 is projective as a @xmath1378-module , the functor @xmath591 is exact .
we have @xmath1380 where in the first step we used an adjunction , in the second we used that @xmath95 is finite dimensional , and in the third we used lemma [ lem : dualfree ] .
in particular , we see that @xmath1381 .
now , it is well - known that @xmath1378 has injective dimension 1 as a module over itself .
let @xmath1382 be an injective resolution .
applying @xmath591 , we obtain a length one injective resolution of @xmath0 as a @xmath0-module , and so @xmath0 has injective dimension at most one . on the other hand , @xmath1383 is a non - split extension , and is easily seen to remain non - split after applying @xmath1384 , and so the injective dimension is exactly one .
[ rmk : noninj - free ] suppose infinitely many of the @xmath56 vanish .
then @xmath0 is not noetherian , and so the bass
papp theorem asserts that some infinite direct sum of injective @xmath0-modules is non - injective .
we give an explicit example in the graded case .
let @xmath413 be an infinite divisible sequence with @xmath414 for all @xmath112 .
let @xmath393 be the ideal generated by the @xmath329}$ ] with @xmath480 .
let @xmath1385 $ ] and @xmath1386 be the direct sum .
define @xmath1387 by using multiplication by @xmath1388}$ ] on the @xmath112th factor .
one then verifies the following that @xmath1389 maps into @xmath1390 but that @xmath1389 can not be extended to a map @xmath1391 . thus @xmath1390 is not injective
therefore , not all free @xmath0-modules are injective .
let @xmath11 be a ring .
let @xmath1392 be the derived category of @xmath11-modules , and let @xmath1393 be the full subcategory of complexes @xmath14 such that @xmath1394 is finitely presented for all @xmath112 and non - zero for only finitely many @xmath112 .
we say that an object of @xmath1392 has * injective amplitude * @xmath1395 $ ] if it is isomorphic in @xmath1392 to a complex of injectives @xmath1396 with @xmath1397 for @xmath1398 $ ] .
this is equivalent to @xmath1399 for all ( or even just cyclic ) modules @xmath47 and @xmath1398 $ ] ( * ? ?
* http://stacks.math.columbia.edu/tag/0a5t[tag 0a5 t ] ) .
we say that @xmath14 has * finite injective dimension * if it has injective amplitude @xmath31 $ ] for some @xmath1400 .
similar definitions apply in the graded case .
suppose @xmath1 is a noetherian ring and @xmath30 is a complex of @xmath1-modules with injective amplitude @xmath31 $ ] .
then @xmath1401 $ ] has injective amplitude @xmath1402 $ ] as a complex of @xmath8$]-modules , see ( * ? ? ?
* http://stacks.math.columbia.edu/tag/0a6j[tag 0a6j ] ) .
the following theorem generalizes this statement to gdpa s : [ thm : injdim ] let @xmath1 be a noetherian ring and let @xmath0 be a gdpa over @xmath1 .
let @xmath30 be a complex of @xmath1-modules with finitely generated cohomology and injective amplitude @xmath31 $ ] , and put @xmath32 . then : 1 .
if @xmath14 is a finitely presented @xmath0-module then @xmath1403 for @xmath1404 $ ] .
@xmath1405 has injective amplitude @xmath33 $ ] as a complex of @xmath0-modules .
the same statements hold in the graded case .
suppose that @xmath1 is a gorenstein noetherian ring of finite krull dimension and let @xmath0 be a gdpa over @xmath1 .
then @xmath0 has finite injective dimension as a ( graded or ungraded ) @xmath0-module .
statement ( a ) implies statement ( b ) using an argument similar to that in the proof of theorem [ thm : selfinj](b ) .
thus it is enough to prove ( a ) .
we assume , by noetherian induction , that the statement is true for every proper quotient of @xmath1 .
we now prove it for @xmath1 , in several steps .
_ we first prove the result assuming @xmath14 has non - zero annihilator @xmath12 .
we have @xmath1406 by ( * ? ? ? * http://stacks.math.columbia.edu/tag/0a6a[tag 0a6a ] ) , we have @xmath1407 let @xmath1408 .
then @xmath1409 has injective amplitude @xmath1395 $ ] and finitely generated cohomology .
let @xmath1410 . by the above
, we have @xmath1411 by the inductive hypothesis , the right side only has cohomology in degrees @xmath1412 $ ] , and so the same is true of the left side .
_ we now prove the result assuming @xmath1 is not a domain . let @xmath1413 be non - zero such that @xmath563 .
we have a short exact sequence @xmath1032 and thus a triangle @xmath1414 both @xmath1034 and @xmath1035 are finitely presented and have non - zero annihilator , and so the outside terms only have cohomology in degrees @xmath1412 $ ] by step 1 .
thus the same is true of the middle term .
_ we now prove the result assuming @xmath1 is a domain .
fix @xmath1415 .
let @xmath1416 be non - zero .
consider the exact sequence @xmath1417 \to m \stackrel{x}{\to } m \to m / xm \to 0.\ ] ] both @xmath1418 $ ] and @xmath1035 are finitely presented with non - zero annihilator , and so @xmath1419 , e)$ ] and @xmath1420 vanish for @xmath1421
$ ] by step 1 .
it follows that the map @xmath1422 is surjective , and an isomorphism if @xmath1423 .
however , @xmath1424 is a finitely generated @xmath0-module , and so a surjective endomorphism of it is necessarily an isomorphism ( * ? ? ?
* http://stacks.math.columbia.edu/tag/05g8[tag 05g8 ] ) ; thus multiplication by @xmath4 is an isomorphism for @xmath1425 as well .
we have thus shown that every non - zero element of @xmath1 acts invertibly on @xmath1424 , that is to say , @xmath1424 is in fact a vector space over @xmath1036 .
we thus have @xmath1426 where the primes denote extension to @xmath542 .
we have @xmath1427 , and @xmath1409 is ( represented by ) a complex of finite dimensional @xmath542 vector spaces in degrees @xmath31 $ ] .
thus @xmath1428 is a complex of finitely generated free @xmath340-modules in degrees @xmath31 $ ] .
since @xmath340 has injective dimension at most 1 ( theorem [ thm : selfinj ] ) , it follows that @xmath1428 has injective amplitude @xmath1402 $ ] .
thus @xmath1429 , and the result is proved .
as stated , the above theorem holds in the graded case as well .
however , in that case we can prove a stronger result with additional assumptions : [ thm : injdim2 ] let @xmath1 , @xmath0 , @xmath30 , and @xmath1405 be as in theorem [ thm : injdim ] , though now @xmath30 is graded .
assume that every maximal ideal of @xmath1 contains infinitely many of the @xmath56 s .
then : 1 . if @xmath14 is a finitely presented graded @xmath0-module then @xmath1430 for @xmath1398 $ ] .
@xmath1405 has injective amplitude @xmath1402 $ ] as a complex of graded @xmath0-modules . as in the proof of theorem [ thm : injdim ]
, it suffices to prove ( a ) , which we again do by noetherian induction .
steps 1 and 2 from that proof apply here , so it suffices to treat the case where @xmath1 is a domain .
we consider two cases . _ case 1 : @xmath1 is a field .
_ we then have that @xmath0 is injective as a graded @xmath0-module ( theorem [ thm : selfinj](a ) ) .
we can represent @xmath30 by a complex of finite dimensional @xmath1-vector spaces concentrated in degrees @xmath31 $ ] , and so we find that @xmath1405 is a complex of injective @xmath0-modules concentrated in the same degrees .
thus @xmath1405 has injective amplitude @xmath31 $ ] , which certainly implies the required @xmath45 vanishing .
_ case 2 : @xmath1 is not a field . _ fix @xmath1431 . as in step 3 of the proof of theorem [ thm : injdim
] , we find that every non - zero element of @xmath1 acts bijectively on @xmath1432 .
it follows that each graded piece @xmath1433 is both a @xmath1434 vector space and a finitely generated @xmath1-module , and thus vanishes .
this proves the theorem .
theorems [ thm : injdim ] and [ thm : injdim2 ] both require @xmath30 to have finitely generated cohomology .
we are not sure if this is necessary .
also , in part ( b ) of both theorems , the upper bound on the amplitude increases by 1 ; we do not know if this is necessary either .
the following is a slight variant of theorem [ thm : injdim ] where we relax the finiteness condition on @xmath30 at the expense of adding a different hypothesis .
we state only the ungraded version , though it is also true in the graded case .
[ thm : almost - inj ] let @xmath0 be a gdpa over a noetherian ring @xmath1 .
let @xmath1246 be a prime ideal of @xmath1 containing infinitely many of the @xmath56 s .
let @xmath30 be the injective envelope of @xmath1435 and let @xmath32 .
then @xmath1436 for all @xmath144 and all finitely presented @xmath0-modules @xmath14 .
thus @xmath1405 has injective dimension at most 1 .
we just sketch a proof .
first one reduces to the case where @xmath1 is local and @xmath1437 is the unique maximal ideal .
next , as in the proof of theorem [ thm : injdim ] , one can reduce to the case where @xmath1 is a domain and one already knows the result for modules with non - zero annihilators .
if @xmath1 is a field , the result follows from theorem [ thm : selfinj ] .
otherwise , let @xmath4 be a non - zero element of @xmath194 .
as in step 3 of the proof of theorem [ thm : injdim ] , we see that multiplication by @xmath4 is bijective on @xmath1424 for @xmath480 .
let @xmath1438 be a resolution of @xmath14 by finitely generated free @xmath0-modules .
( here is the one place we use that @xmath14 is finitely presented . )
then @xmath1439 is a subquotient of @xmath1440 , which is isomorphic to a finite direct sum of @xmath30 s .
since every element of @xmath30 is killed by some power of @xmath194 , multiplication by @xmath4 can not act bijectively on any nonzero subquotient of @xmath1440 .
we thus find that @xmath1439 vanishes for @xmath480 , which proves the theorem .
[ rmk : almost - inj ] in fact , the module @xmath1405 in theorem [ thm : almost - inj ] is not injective in general . to see this
let @xmath0 be the classical divided power algebra over @xmath3 and let @xmath393 be the ideal generated by elements of positive degree .
then we have a @xmath0-module homomorphism @xmath1441 \to \bd \otimes_{\bz_p } \bq_p/\bz_p$ ] ( note that the injective envelope of @xmath1442 is @xmath1443 ) given by @xmath329 } \mapsto x^{[i-1 ] } \otimes \tfrac{1}{i}$ ] .
clearly this map does not extend to @xmath1444 $ ] because there are no nonzero maps from @xmath1444 \to \bd \otimes_{\bz_p } \bq_p/\bz_p$ ] .
let @xmath11 be a coherent ring .
we say that a complex @xmath1445 is a * dualizing complex * if : 1 .
@xmath1446 has finite injective dimension ; 2 .
@xmath1447 is finitely presented for all @xmath112 ; and 3 .
the natural map @xmath1448 is a quasi - isomorphism .
dualizing complexes are discussed in ( * ? ? ?
* http://stacks.math.columbia.edu/tag/0a7a[tag 0a7a ] ) under the assumption that @xmath11 is noetherian .
some of the basic results remain true in our more general setting : for example , if @xmath1446 is a dualizing complex then @xmath1449 gives a duality of the category @xmath1393 ( the proof given in ( * ? ? ?
* http://stacks.math.columbia.edu/tag/0a7c[tag 0a7c ] ) applies ) .
we note that if @xmath11 is noetherian and admits a dualizing complex then it has finite krull dimension ( * ? ? ?
* http://stacks.math.columbia.edu/tag/0a80[tag 0a80 ] ) .
our main result on duality for gdpa s is the following theorem .
we treat only the ungraded case , but the graded case goes through in exactly the same manner .
[ thm : duality ] let @xmath1 be a noetherian ring with dualizing complex @xmath37 and let @xmath0 be a gdpa over @xmath1 . then @xmath1450 is a dualizing complex for @xmath0 . by theorem [ thm : injdim ] , @xmath1451 has finite injective dimension , and so condition ( a ) holds . since @xmath1452 and @xmath1453 is a finitely generated @xmath1-module , condition ( b ) holds . finally , by ( * ?
* http://stacks.math.columbia.edu/tag/0a6a[tag 0a6a ] ) , the natural map @xmath1454 is an isomorphism . since the left side is isomorphic to @xmath0 via the natural map
, we conclude that ( c ) holds .
this completes the proof . in the context of the theorem ,
the category @xmath1455 is self - dual ( i.e. , equivalent to its opposite ) .
suppose @xmath1 is a regular noetherian ring of finite krull dimension .
then @xmath0 is a dualizing complex for @xmath0 . under the hypotheses on @xmath1
, we can take @xmath1456 .
an element @xmath39 of a @xmath0-module @xmath14 is * torsion * if @xmath9 } m = 0 $ ] for @xmath40 .
a @xmath0-module is * torsion * if all of its elements are , and * torsion - free * if it has no nonzero torsion element .
[ notors ] let @xmath328 be a gdpa over the noetherian ring @xmath1 .
the following are equivalent : 1 .
every finitely presented @xmath0-module ( graded or not ) is torsion - free . 2 .
every maximal ideal of @xmath1 contains infinitely many @xmath56 s . suppose ( b ) does not hold , and let @xmath194 be a maximal ideal containing only finitely many of the @xmath56 .
then @xmath438 has the form @xmath1457 where @xmath95 is a finite dimensional algebra over @xmath451 and @xmath1378 is a polynomial ring in one variable over @xmath451 .
this algebra certainly has finitely presented modules with nonzero torsion ; for example , @xmath95 itself ( with the variable in @xmath1378 acting by 0 ) .
thus ( a ) does not hold .
now suppose ( b ) holds , and let @xmath14 be a finitely presented @xmath0-module .
we must show that @xmath14 is torsion - free .
suppose that @xmath235 is torsion , and let @xmath42 be the @xmath0-submodule of @xmath14 generated by @xmath39 .
then @xmath42 is finitely presented , since it is a finitely generated submodule of a finitely presented module , and torsion .
thus @xmath1458 by the following lemma , which completes the proof
. suppose condition ( b ) of the theorem holds , and let @xmath42 be a finitely presented torsion @xmath0-module
. then @xmath1458 .
first suppose @xmath1 is a field . by proposition [ prop : h - free ] , there is an @xmath1459 with @xmath371 such that @xmath42 is free over @xmath372 .
since @xmath42 is finite dimensional over @xmath1 , it follows that @xmath42 must have rank 0 over @xmath372 , and so @xmath1458 .
we now treat the general case .
if @xmath194 is a maximal ideal of @xmath1 then @xmath1460 by the previous paragraph , and so @xmath1461 by nakayama s lemma ( again , @xmath42 is finitely generated as a @xmath1-module ) . since @xmath1461 for all maximal ideals @xmath194 , it follows that @xmath1458 .
the purpose of this section is to prove the following theorem .
[ thm : ext - torsion ] let @xmath0 be a gdpa over the noetherian ring @xmath1 .
assume that @xmath1 is complete with respect to an ideal @xmath1462 containing infinitely many of the @xmath56 .
let @xmath14 and @xmath42 be graded @xmath0-modules , with @xmath14 finitely presented and @xmath42 torsion .
then @xmath1463 for all @xmath108 .
[ rmk : ext - torsion ] here is an example showing that theorem [ thm : ext - torsion ] can fail without the completeness hypothesis .
let @xmath1464 , let @xmath1465})$ ] , and let @xmath1466 be the submodule of strictly positive degree elements .
note that every homogeneous element of @xmath47 is killed by a power of @xmath18 , and so @xmath47 is naturally a @xmath3-module .
we have an exact sequence @xmath1467 applying @xmath1468 , we obtain an exact sequence @xmath1469 thus @xmath1470 is a @xmath3-module containing a copy of @xmath869 .
it can not be equal to @xmath869 , and so @xmath1471 must be non - zero . to obtain an explicit extension ,
take the push - out of along a map @xmath1472 , where @xmath1473 , and the second map is the inclusion .
we also remark that theorem [ thm : ext - torsion ] can fail in the non - graded case , as example [ ex : ext ] shows .
[ extor1 ] suppose @xmath368 and put @xmath1319 .
let @xmath1474 be an integer and let @xmath14 be a graded @xmath1-module supported in non - negative degrees
. then @xmath1475 . since @xmath864 is noetherian and @xmath1
is finitely generated , the @xmath1476 in question commutes with direct limits in @xmath14 , and so we can assume @xmath14 is finitely generated .
first suppose @xmath1 is a field .
we can then assume @xmath1477 $ ] for some @xmath1478 . since @xmath864 is self - injective ( by lemma [ lem : truncinj ] )
, we have @xmath1479)_d=0 $ ] for @xmath578 . we also have @xmath1480)_d=\uhom_d(\bk[d - e ] , d)_0=0 $ ] , since @xmath1481}$ ] acts non - trivially on @xmath1482}$ ] ( see the proof of lemma [ lem : dualfree ] ) .
thus the result holds when @xmath1 is a field .
we now proceed by noetherian induction .
we thus assume the result holds for every proper quotient of @xmath1 .
suppose @xmath14 has non - zero annihilator @xmath12
. then @xmath1483 where the final equality comes from the inductive hypothesis . from this
, we can reduce to the case where @xmath1 is a domain ( as in step 2 of the proof of theorem [ thm : injdim ] ) and @xmath1484 ( by dvissage it suffices to treat cyclic modules @xmath14 , and the only cyclic module with zero annihilator is @xmath1 ) .
let @xmath192 be a nonzero element of @xmath1 . using the exact sequence @xmath1485 in the @xmath14 variable , we find that multiplication by @xmath192 is bijective on @xmath1486 .
but this @xmath45 group is a finitely generated @xmath1-module .
thus if @xmath1 is not a field then it must vanish .
and we have already treated the field case .
[ extor2 ] suppose @xmath1487
. then @xmath1488 .
let @xmath1489 be a sequence with @xmath414 , and put @xmath1490 .
let @xmath1491 , a subalgebra of @xmath1492 .
we have an isomorphism of algberas @xmath1493 ( see proposition [ gdpa : subalg ] ) .
let @xmath1494 be a projective resolution over @xmath1495 , with @xmath1496 .
then @xmath1497 is a projective resolution of @xmath1 over @xmath1492 , and we have a natural map @xmath1498 coming from the natural @xmath1-linear map @xmath1499 .
one easily sees that the direct limit of the @xmath1500 is a projective resolution of @xmath1 over @xmath0 .
we thus see that @xmath1501 is computed by @xmath1502 .
one easily sees that this is isomorphic to @xmath1503 , where @xmath1504 .
it follows from the construction of @xmath1500 that the natural map @xmath1505 is surjective . by general results on inverse limits of complexes ( see , for instance , ( * ? ? ?
iii , cor .
1.2 ) ) , we thus have a short exact sequence @xmath1506 since @xmath1507 computes @xmath1508 , this yields @xmath1509 in any particular degree , the outer terms vanish for @xmath1132 by lemma [ extor1 ] , and so the outer terms are 0 .
( note : this reasoning does not apply in the ungraded case , and the vanishing does not hold . )
this completes the proof .
[ extor5 ] let @xmath14 be a graded @xmath0-module such that @xmath1510 .
then we have @xmath1511 for all graded torsion modules @xmath42 .
we proceed in three steps .
_ step 1 : @xmath42 is finitely generated and concentrated in degree 0 .
_ thus @xmath42 is just a finitely generated @xmath1-module with @xmath1512 acting by 0 .
let @xmath1513 be a resolution of @xmath42 by finitely generated free @xmath1-modules .
regard @xmath432 as a @xmath0-module by letting @xmath1512 act by zero .
we have a convergent spectral sequence @xmath1514 since each @xmath1515 is a finite direct sum of @xmath1 s , each @xmath1516 vanishes by our hypothesis , and so the result follows .
_ step 2 : @xmath42 is finitely generated .
_ we then have @xmath1517 for sufficiently large @xmath65 .
filtering by powers of @xmath1512 and passing to the associated graded , we can thus assume @xmath1518 .
but then @xmath42 is a finite sum of shifts of modules concentrated in a single degree , and so the result follows from step 1 .
_ step 3 : arbitrary @xmath42 . _
write @xmath1519 with @xmath1520 finitely generated .
then @xmath1521 since @xmath1522 for all @xmath112 , the result follows .
[ extor3 ] theorem [ thm : ext - torsion ] holds if @xmath1487 . by theorem [ thm : sd ]
, it suffices to treat the case where @xmath14 is principal special , say @xmath1523 with @xmath841 .
note that @xmath340 is a quotient ring of @xmath0 , and ( after regrading ) is itself a gdpa . for a torsion @xmath0-module @xmath42
, we have @xmath1524 note that @xmath1525 is a torsion @xmath340-module for all @xmath18 .
thus , renaming @xmath340 to @xmath0 , we have reduced to the case @xmath914 . as @xmath1488 by lemma [ extor2 ]
, the result follows from lemma [ extor5 ] .
[ extor4 ] theorem [ thm : ext - torsion ] holds if @xmath42 is annihilated by a power of @xmath1462 .
filtering by powers of @xmath1462 , it suffices to treat the case where @xmath42 is annihilated by @xmath1462 .
we then have @xmath1526 since @xmath1527 is finitely presented as a @xmath1528-module for all @xmath112 , the result follows from the @xmath1487 case ( lemma [ extor3 ] ) . [ dercompl ]
let @xmath14 and @xmath42 be modules over a ring @xmath95 such that @xmath14 is complete with respect to an ideal @xmath1529 and @xmath1530 for all @xmath578 .
then @xmath1531 similar statements hold in the graded case with @xmath103 .
we have @xmath1532 the first isomorphism follows from the completeness of @xmath14 ; note that the transition maps in the inverse system @xmath1533 are surjective , and so there are no higher inverse limits .
the second isomorphism follows from the ( derived version of the ) universal property of inverse limits . and the third is derived adjunction of tensor and @xmath1534 , combined with the vanishing of the higher @xmath507 s of @xmath42 with @xmath1535 . by lemma [ extor5 ] , it suffices to treat the case @xmath1536 . by lemma [ dercompl ] , we have @xmath1537 since @xmath1538 for all @xmath112 by lemma [ extor4 ] , the result follows .
( note that the hypotheses of lemma [ dercompl ] are satisfied : @xmath42 is free over @xmath1 , so all higher @xmath507 s with it vanish , and each graded piece of @xmath14 is finitely generated over @xmath1 , and thus @xmath1462-adically complete , and so @xmath1539 in the category of graded @xmath0-modules . )
let @xmath0 be a gdpa . for a @xmath0-module @xmath14
, we put @xmath1540 then @xmath1541 is a @xmath0-submodule of @xmath14 , while @xmath1542 is a quotient @xmath0-module of @xmath14 .
a @xmath0-module @xmath14 is * nearly finitely presented * ( nfp ) if each @xmath74 is finitely generated as a @xmath1-module , @xmath1543 for @xmath1544 , and there exists a finitely presented @xmath0-module @xmath47 , called a * weak fp - envelope * of @xmath14 , such that @xmath48 for some @xmath65 .
we let @xmath1545 be the full subcategory of @xmath1546 on the nearly finitely presented modules .
let @xmath14 be a @xmath0-module .
an * fp - envelope * of @xmath14 is a map of @xmath0-modules @xmath890 with @xmath47 finitely presented such that any other map from @xmath14 to a finitely presented @xmath0-module factors through @xmath434 . a map of @xmath0-modules @xmath890 is a * near isomorphism * if @xmath1547 is an isomorphism for all @xmath40 .
throughout this section we fix a gdpa over a noetherian ring @xmath1 .
we assume that @xmath1 is complete with respect to an ideal @xmath1462 containing infinitely many of the @xmath56 s .
we show , in this setting , that there is a very good theory of nfp modules .
[ lem : exttau ] let @xmath1548 be a near isomorphism of @xmath0-modules and let @xmath47 be a finitely presented @xmath0-module .
then the restriction map @xmath1549 is an isomorphism for all @xmath112 .
consider the 4-term exact sequence @xmath1550 where @xmath703 and @xmath159 are the kernel and cokernel of @xmath1093 . since @xmath1093 is a near isomorphism ,
both @xmath703 and @xmath159 are torsion . by theorem [ thm : ext - torsion ]
, we have @xmath1551 for all @xmath112 .
the result follows .
[ prop : fpenv ] the notions of `` weak fp - envelope '' and `` fp - envelope '' coincide for nfp modules .
precisely : 1 .
suppose @xmath14 is an nfp module and @xmath923 is a weak fp - envelope , so that we have an isomorphism @xmath1552 for some @xmath65 .
then there exists a unique map @xmath1553 restricting to the given isomorphism in degrees @xmath50 , and this makes @xmath923 into an fp - envelope of @xmath14 .
2 . suppose @xmath14 is an nfp module and @xmath1553 is an fp - envelope .
then this map is a near isomorphism , and so @xmath923 is a weak fp - envelope of @xmath14 .
in particular , every nfp module admits an fp - envelope , and any two weak fp - envelopes are canonically isomorphic .
\(a ) let @xmath14 be an nfp module and let @xmath923 be a weak fp - envelope , so that we are given an isomorphism @xmath1554 for some @xmath65 .
by lemma [ lem : exttau ] , the map @xmath1555 extends uniquely to a map @xmath1548 .
note that @xmath1093 is a near isomorphism .
thus if @xmath47 is finitely presented then the map @xmath1556 is an isomorphism by lemma [ lem : exttau ] , which exactly says that @xmath1093 is an fp - envelope .
\(b ) let @xmath1553 be an fp - envelope of the nfp module @xmath14 , and let @xmath924 be a weak fp - envelope of @xmath14 . by ( a )
, @xmath924 is canonically an fp - envelope of @xmath14 . since any two fp - envelopes are canonically isomorphic , we see @xmath923 is also a weak fp - envelope . for an nfp module @xmath14 , let @xmath1557 denote its fp - envelope .
then @xmath1558 defines a functor @xmath1559 , and there is a natural transformation @xmath1560 .
the category @xmath1545 is an abelian subcategory of @xmath1546 .
let @xmath890 be a map of nfp modules .
then we have a commutative square @xmath1561^f \ar[d ] & n \ar[d ] \\
\phi(m ) \ar[r]^{\phi(f ) } & \phi(n ) } \ ] ] the vertical maps are near isomorphisms .
it follows that the map @xmath1562 is also a near isomorphism , and so @xmath891 is nfp .
similarly for the cokernel and image of @xmath434 .
this shows that @xmath1545 is an abelian subcategory of @xmath1546 .
the functor @xmath1558 is exact .
suppose that @xmath959 is an exact sequence of nfp modules .
then the sequence @xmath1563 is isomorphic to the original one in all sufficiently high degrees .
thus the homology of this sequence is both torsion and finitely presented , and therefore vanishes .
let @xmath1564 denote the category of finitely generated torsion modules .
this is a serre subcategory of @xmath1545 .
the inclusion functor @xmath1565 induces an equivalence of categories @xmath1566 .
the functor @xmath1567 induces a quasi - inverse .
since @xmath1558 is exact and kills @xmath1564 , it does factor through the serre quotient .
if @xmath14 is an nfp module , then the kernel and cokernel of @xmath1560 are torsion , and so this map is an isomorphism in the serre quotient .
of course , if @xmath14 is finitely presented , then @xmath1568 .
this proves the claim .
an extension of nfp modules is again nfp .
consider an exact sequence @xmath959 with @xmath971 and @xmath1569 nfp .
we must show that @xmath992 is nfp .
let @xmath1570 and @xmath1571 be the fp - envelopes of @xmath971 and @xmath1569 .
pusing out the above extension along the map @xmath1572 , we obtain a new extension @xmath1573 the map @xmath1574 is a near isomorphism , so it suffices to show @xmath1575 is nfp . by lemma [ lem : exttau ] ,
the pullback map @xmath1576 is an isomorphism .
thus there is an extension @xmath1577 such that @xmath1575 is the pullback of @xmath1578 along @xmath1579 .
since @xmath1578 is an extension of finitely presented modules , it is finitely presented .
the map @xmath1580 is a near isomorphism , and so @xmath1575 is nfp .
the result follows . in this section
we prove some results about completions that are needed in the following section .
we fix a noetherian ring @xmath11 and an ideal @xmath12 of @xmath11 .
we assume that @xmath11 is @xmath12-adically separated , or equivalently , that @xmath12 is contained in the jacobson radical of @xmath11 . for a @xmath11-module @xmath14
, we write @xmath1581 for its @xmath12-adic completion .
let @xmath14 and @xmath47 be finitely generated @xmath11-modules .
then there exists an integer @xmath1582 such that for any @xmath1583 the natural map @xmath1584 is an isomorphism .
the map in the proposition is clearly injective , so it suffices to prove it is surjective .
let @xmath1585 be the blow - up algebra , a graded noetherian @xmath11-algebra , and let @xmath1586 , a graded @xmath1378-module .
let @xmath1587 be a surjection with @xmath591 a finite free @xmath11-module , and define @xmath1588 similarly but with @xmath591 in place of @xmath14 .
then @xmath1589 is naturally a @xmath1378-submodule of @xmath1588 .
however , @xmath1588 is just a finite direct sum of copies of @xmath1590 , and thus a finitely generated @xmath1378-module . by noetherianity ,
@xmath1589 is finitely generated as a @xmath1378-module .
suppose @xmath1589 is generated in degrees @xmath1591 .
then , since @xmath1378 is generated in degree 1 ( as a @xmath11-algebra ) , we find that the natural map @xmath1592 is surjective for any @xmath1583 .
this proves the proposition .
[ prop : complhom ] let @xmath14 and @xmath47 be finitely generated @xmath11-modules . then the natural map @xmath1593 is an isomorphism .
we first prove that @xmath1558 is injective .
suppose @xmath1594 , and let @xmath1595 be a sequence converging to @xmath434 in the @xmath12-adic topology . since @xmath1594 , we have @xmath1596 .
thus , for any @xmath108 , we have @xmath1597 for all @xmath1598 .
fix such an @xmath112 .
thus @xmath1327 maps @xmath14 into @xmath1599 , and so @xmath1600 . by the previous proposition ,
we find @xmath1601 for some @xmath83 depending only on @xmath14 and @xmath47 .
this shows that @xmath1602 in @xmath1603 for the @xmath12-adic topology , and so @xmath1604 .
we now prove that @xmath1558 is surjective .
let @xmath1605 be given .
it suffices to find a sequence @xmath1606 in @xmath1603 converging to @xmath434 .
let @xmath583 be a presentation for @xmath14 with @xmath591 finite free , and let @xmath1607 be a basis for @xmath591 .
let @xmath1608 and choose @xmath1609 such that @xmath1610 .
define @xmath1611 by @xmath1612 .
we have @xmath1613 .
let @xmath1589 be the image of the restriction map @xmath1614 .
let @xmath1582 be such that @xmath1615 for @xmath1583 , and let @xmath667 be such that @xmath1616 for @xmath1583 .
the number @xmath83 exists by the previous proposition , while the number @xmath667 exists by the artin
rees lemma .
we have @xmath1617 and so @xmath1618 . in other words
, we can find maps @xmath1619 and elements @xmath1620 , for @xmath112 in some index set @xmath1337 , such that @xmath1621 and @xmath1622 have the same restriction to @xmath703 .
let @xmath1623 .
then @xmath1624 restricts to 0 on @xmath703 , and thus defines an element of @xmath1603 .
we have @xmath1625 modulo @xmath1626 , and @xmath1627 modulo @xmath1628 . thus @xmath1629 maps into @xmath1630 ,
that is , @xmath1631 .
another application of the previous proposition now gives @xmath1632 , which completes the proof .
let @xmath14 and @xmath47 be finitely generated @xmath11-modules .
then @xmath1633 is open in @xmath1634 for the @xmath12-adic topology . if @xmath14 and @xmath47 are not isomorphic then @xmath1633 is empty , and thus open
. thus assume @xmath14 and @xmath47 are isomorphic .
it suffices to treat the case where @xmath1635 .
furthermore , since @xmath1636 is a group , it suffices to show that some open neighborhood of @xmath1637 in @xmath1638 is contained in @xmath1636 .
in fact , @xmath1639 . to see this ,
let @xmath1640 be an endomorphism such that @xmath1641 .
then @xmath1642 is surjective , and so @xmath434 is surjective by nakayama s lemma ( here it is important that @xmath12 is contained in the jacobson radical of @xmath11 ) .
surjectivity of @xmath434 implies injectivity ( * ? ? ?
* http://stacks.math.columbia.edu/tag/05g8[tag 05g8 ] ) , and so @xmath1643 .
let @xmath890 be a map of finitely generated @xmath11-modules .
if @xmath1644 is an isomorphism , then @xmath434 is an isomorphism .
consider the sequence @xmath1645 since completion is exact , we find @xmath1646 , and so @xmath1647 .
thus @xmath434 is an isomorphism .
[ prop : decompl ] let @xmath14 and @xmath47 be finitely generated @xmath11-modules . if @xmath1648 then @xmath1649 .
identify @xmath1650 with a subset of @xmath1651 .
we have shown that @xmath1652 is the @xmath12-adic completion of @xmath1653 , and so @xmath1653 is dense in @xmath1652 .
the set of isomorphisms in @xmath1652 is open , and non - empty by hypothesis .
since @xmath1653 is dense in @xmath1652 , it follows that @xmath1653 meets the locus of isomorphisms .
thus there is a map @xmath51 that induces an isomorphism on completions , and is therefore itself an isomorphism .
fix a gdpa @xmath0 over a noetherian ring @xmath1 .
we assume that the jacobson radical @xmath1462 of @xmath1 contains infinitely many of the @xmath56 s .
our main result is : [ thm : weakfp ] let @xmath14 and @xmath47 be finitely presented @xmath0-modules such that @xmath1541 is isomorphic to @xmath1654 for some @xmath65
. then @xmath14 is isomorphic to @xmath47 .
[ cor : weakfp ] any two weak fp - envelopes of an nfp module are isomorphic . beware that the isomorphism provided by the theorem is not canonical !
we require a few lemmas before proving the theorem .
we write @xmath1581 for the @xmath1462-adic completion of @xmath14 .
note that if @xmath14 is a graded @xmath1-module then @xmath1581 is the direct sum of the completions of the graded pieces of @xmath14 .
[ lem : trunchom ] let @xmath14 and @xmath47 be @xmath0-modules with @xmath14 finitely presented .
let @xmath65 be larger than the degrees of generators and relations of @xmath14 .
then the natural map @xmath1655 is an isomorphism . informally , to give a map @xmath51 one
says where the generators go and checks that relations to go to 0 , and all of this can be done by looking up to degree @xmath65 .
we now give a formal argument .
we have an exact sequence @xmath1656 applying @xmath1657 , we find @xmath1658 note that @xmath1659 , since the generators of @xmath14 must map to 0 for degree reasons .
now , consider an exact sequence @xmath583 with @xmath591 free .
the map @xmath1660 is surjective .
but once again , this @xmath103 is 0 for degree reasons .
we have thus shown that the natural map @xmath1661 is an isomorphism .
it is clear that the natural map @xmath1662 is also an isomorphism , and so the result follows .
[ lem : truncisom ] let @xmath14 and @xmath47 be finitely presented @xmath0-modules .
let @xmath65 be larger than the degrees of generators and relations of both @xmath14 and @xmath47 .
then the natural map @xmath1663 is an isomorphism .
injectivity follows immediately from the previous proposition .
let @xmath1664 be an isomorphism , and let @xmath1665 be its inverse .
by the previous proposition , @xmath1666 and @xmath1667 . since @xmath1668 , the previous proposition gives @xmath1669 .
similarly @xmath1670 , and the result follows .
let @xmath14 and @xmath47 be finitely presented @xmath0-modules with @xmath48 .
suppose that the generators and relations of @xmath14 and @xmath47 are in degrees @xmath394 .
let @xmath1671 and @xmath1672 , both of which are finitely generated modules over the noetherian ring @xmath1673 . since @xmath48 , we find @xmath1674 .
proposition [ prop : fpenv ] yields an isomorphism @xmath1648 of @xmath1675-modules . applying @xmath1676
, we obtain an isomorphism @xmath1677 of @xmath1678-modules .
proposition [ prop : decompl ] now gives an isomorphism @xmath1679 of @xmath11-modules .
( here we use @xmath1680 . )
finally , lemma [ lem : truncisom ] gives @xmath1649 , completing the proof .
we now give some examples showing that the hypotheses in some of our results are necessary .
let @xmath1464 , let @xmath0 be the classical divided power algebra over @xmath1 , and let @xmath1465})$ ] .
[ prop : counter - example ] the nfp module @xmath1681 does not have an fp - envelope . since @xmath74 is torsion for @xmath144
, we see that @xmath1681 is naturally a @xmath3-module .
furthermore , since there is no bound on the exponent of the group @xmath74 , it follows that @xmath3 acts faithfully on @xmath1681 .
now , suppose that @xmath47 is an fp - envelope of @xmath1681
. then @xmath1682 the first equality is elementary , while the second comes from the definition of fp - envelope .
we have shown that the left group above contains @xmath3 , while the right group is a finitely generated @xmath869-module .
this is a contadiction , and so the result follows .
this shows that the completeness assumption in place in proposition [ prop : fpenv ] can not be removed .
let @xmath1 be the ring of integers in a number field @xmath542 , let @xmath0 be the classical divided power algbera over @xmath1 , and let @xmath1465})$ ] .
[ prop : class - group ] if the class group of @xmath542 is non - trivial then the nfp module @xmath1681 admits non - isomorphic weak fp - envelopes
. each graded piece of @xmath1681 is torsion as a @xmath1-module , and is thus a module over @xmath1683 .
let @xmath12 be an ideal of @xmath1 .
then @xmath1684 is isomorphic to @xmath1685 .
thus @xmath1686 is isomorphic to @xmath1681 .
it follows that both @xmath14 and @xmath1687 are weak fp - envelopes of @xmath14 . if @xmath12 is not principal then these modules are not isomorphic , since their degree 0 pieces are not isomorphic .
we thus see that in corollary [ cor : weakfp ] , the hypothesis that infinitely many of the @xmath56 s belong to the jacobson radical is necessary .
( note that in the above example , the jacobson radical of @xmath1 is 0 , and @xmath56 is nonzero for all @xmath144 . ) in fact , there is a simpler , though less interesting , counterexample : taking @xmath41 $ ] , the nfp module @xmath0 itself admits non - isomorphism fp - envelopes , such as @xmath0 and @xmath1688 .
.5 does there exist a graded - coherent gdpa @xmath0 such that @xmath333}$ ] is not graded - coherent for some @xmath164 ?
.5 in proposition [ prop : tor1 ] we computed @xmath1690 .
can one compute @xmath1691 as a co - algebra ?
if @xmath14 is a finitely presented @xmath0-module , does @xmath1692 admit a nice structure as a co - module ?
.5 conjecture [ conj : k ] on the structure of @xmath1062 when @xmath452 does not hold , e.g. , for the @xmath2-divided power algbera . to prove this
, it would be useful to have a refined version of the @xmath1064 invariant that picks off the @xmath1111 piece of a class in @xmath1062 , much as @xmath1064 picks off the @xmath1126 piece . at the very least
, there should be a `` residue map '' @xmath1693 $ ] for each @xmath144 , where @xmath1264 is primitive @xmath65th root of unity , corresponding to taking the residue of an element of @xmath1114 at @xmath1694 .
one can construct this map for the @xmath2-divided power algebra over @xmath299 $ ] using proposition [ prop : qdprat ] , but for a general gdpa we do not know how to construct it . | we study modules for the divided power algebra @xmath0 in a single variable over a commutative noetherian ring @xmath1 .
our first result states that @xmath0 is a coherent ring . in fact , we show that there is a theory of grbner bases for finitely generated ideals , and so computations with finitely presented @xmath0-modules are in principle algorithmic .
we go on to determine much about the structure of finitely presented @xmath0-modules , such as : existence of certain nice resolutions , computation of the grothendieck group , results about injective dimension , and how they interact with torsion modules .
our results apply not just to the classical divided power algebra , but to its @xmath2-variant as well , and even to a much broader class of algebras we introduce called `` generalized divided power algebras . '' on the other hand , we show that the divided power algebra in two variables over @xmath3 is not coherent . |
the analysis of the role of strangeness in nuclear structure in the aspect of multi - strange system is of great importance for relativistic heavy - ion collisions and for astrophysics for the description of hyperon star matter . at the core of a neutron star the matter density ranges from a few times the density of normal nuclear matter to about an order of a magnitude higher .
thus exotic forms of matter such as hyperons are expected to emerge in the interior of a neutron star .
the appearance of these additional degrees of freedom and their impact on a neutron star structure have been the subject of extensive studies @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite .
properties of matter at such extreme densities are of particular importance in determining forms of equations of state relevant to neutron stars and successively in examining their global parameters .
+ the existence of bound strange hadronic matter which in addition to nucleons contains also hyperons has profound consequences for astrophysics .
the starting point in studying the role of strangeness in nuclear structure is the knowledge of the properties of a single hypernucleus .
quantum chromodynamics should be applied to the theoretical description of hadronic systems owing to the fact that it constitutes the fundamental theory of strong interactions . however , at the hadronic energy scale where the experimentally observed degrees of freedom are not quarks but hadrons the direct description of nuclei in terms of qcd become inadequate and thus alternative approaches had to be formulated .
one of them is quantum hadrodynamics ( qhd ) @xcite , @xcite which gives quantitative description of the nuclear many body problem .
qhd is a relativistic quantum field theory in which nuclear matter description in terms of baryons and mesons is provided . the original model ( qhd - i ) contains nucleons interacting through the exchange of simulating medium range attraction @xmath0 meson and @xmath1 meson responsible for short range repulsion .
extension ( qhd - ii ) of this theory @xcite,@xcite includes also the isovector meson @xmath2 .
theoretical description of strange hadronic matter , which satisfactorily reproduces nucleon - nucleon and hyperon - nucleon data , has been given within the non - relativistic and relativistic mean field models .
this approach is based on the notion of the meson - exchange model in which baryons interact through the exchange of mesons .
in addition to the @xmath0 , @xmath1 and @xmath3 mesons these models contain @xmath4 and @xmath5 mesons , introduced in order to reproduce the strong attractive hyperon - hyperon interactions @xcite .
+ the vector coupling constants are chosen according to su(6 ) symmetry whereas the scalar coupling constants are fixed to hypernuclear data
. recent reports on observations of a @xmath6 hypernucleus made by takahashi et al .
@xcite provided information on the @xmath7 interaction energy @xmath8 mev .
this allows one to determine the value of the @xmath9 well depth in @xmath9 matter at density @xmath10 ( @xmath11 denotes the saturation density ) at the level of @xmath12 mev @xcite .
the results of earlier experiments @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite give the value of @xmath13 estimated with the use of nijmegen model d at the level of @xmath14 mev @xcite .
this paper examines the implications of the strength of hyperon - hyperon coupling constants on the @xmath15-equilibrated hyperon star matter , hence doing all calculations within the framework of relativistic mean field model with two parameterizations , namely the standard tm1 @xcite and tma @xcite .
the results have been obtained for two cases : the weak and strong @xmath16 interactions .
first , the properties of the isospin symmetric strange hadronic matter have been investigated .
the obtained saturation curves resemble those obtained by song et al.@xcite .
the results for the two models ( tm1 and tma ) are very similar .
the extension of the considered model to the @xmath15 equilibrated asymmetric hyperon star model has been done in the subsequent section . as a result of this the composition
, the equation of state and the hyperon star structure for the two parameterizations have been obtained .
information on single hypernuclei can be summarized in the following points : * @xmath9 hypernuclei : there is a large amount of data on the binding energies @xmath17 of @xmath9 s bound in various single particle orbitals in hypernuclei .
this enables us to study deeply bound states inside the nucleus over an extensive range of mass number .
an analysis of these data with the use of skyrme - hartree - fock @xcite model gives the potential depth of a single @xmath9 in nuclear matter at the value of @xmath18 which corresponds to 1/3 - 1/2 of the nucleon well depth @xmath19 ( in this text all potentials are considered as attractive but the convention of positive sign has been used ) .
* @xmath20 hypernuclei @xcite : the experimental status of @xmath20 nucleus potential still remains controversial .
the calculations of @xmath20 hypernuclei have been based on analysis of @xmath21 atomic data .
phenomenological analysis of level shifts and widths in @xmath21 atoms made by batty et al .
@xcite indicates that the @xmath20 potential is attractive only at the nuclear surface changing into repulsive one in increasing density .
the small attractive component of this potential is not sufficient to form bound @xmath20-hypernuclei .
balberg et al . in their paper @xcite
show that the system which includes @xmath20 , @xmath9 hyperons and nucleons will be unstable with respect to strong reactions @xmath22 ( 78 mev ) , @xmath23 ( 156 mev ) , @xmath24 ( 50 mev ) , @xmath25 ( 80 mev ) @xcite , in parenthesis the @xmath26 values for each reaction are given . *
@xmath27 hypernuclei - for the @xmath27 hypernuclei there exist a few emulsion events reported in literature indicating the existence of a bound system .
the interpreted data give the potential of a @xmath27 in nuclear matter with a depth of @xmath28 * @xmath29 hypernuclei : the properties of single hypernuclei are one aspect of studying strangeness in nuclear systems ; the other is connected with multi - strange systems .
the extrapolation to a multi - strange system is based on the data concerning double @xmath9-hypernuclei .
data on @xmath29 hypernuclei are extremely scarce .
observation of double - strange hypernuclei @xmath29 provide information about the @xmath7 interaction .
several events have been identified which indicate an attractive @xmath29 interaction .
the analysis of the data allows one to estimate the binding energies of @xmath30 , @xmath31 and @xmath32 .
the measurement of the masses of double-@xmath9 hypernuclei gives information on the sum of the binding energy of the two @xmath9 hyperons @xmath33 and the @xmath7 interaction energy @xmath34 .
these two quantities can be defined as @xmath35 table [ tab : lambda ] compiles experimental values of the two observables mentioned above @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite .
+ .the value of @xmath36 and @xmath33 of the known double @xmath9-hypernuclei . [ cols="<,<,<,<",options="header " , ] the value of densities , masses and radii collected in the table [ tab : xi ] indicate that @xmath27 hyperons do not appear in stable hyperon star configurations for both parameter sets .
thus only @xmath9 hyperon will be present in the composition of hyperon star matter for the considered models .
fig.[fig : rm ] shows the position of the configurations , which parameters are presented in table [ tab : xi ] , on the mass - radius relations .
+ neutron stars are purely gravitationally bound compact stars .
the gravitational binding energy of a relativistic star is defined as a difference between its gravitational and baryon mass . @xmath37 where @xmath38 of considerable relevance is the numerical solution of the above equation for the selected equations of state .
[ fig : mb ] depicts the gravitational mass which includes interactions versus the baryonic mass for all the considered models .
the main goal of this paper was to study the influence of the strength of hyperon - hyperon interactions on the properties of the hyperon star matter and on a hyperon star structure .
it has been shown that replacing the strong @xmath16 interaction model by the weak one introduces large differences in the composition of a hyperon star matter both in the strange and non - strange sectors .
there is a considerable reduction of @xmath9 hyperon concentration whereas the concentrations of @xmath39 and @xmath40 hyperons are enhanced . in the non - strange sector
the populations of protons and electrons are changed .
the weak model permits larger fractions of protons and electrons .
the presence of hyperons in general leads to the softening of the equation of state . for the employed weak @xmath16 interaction model
there is a density range for which the obtained equation of state is stiffer than the one calculated with the use of the strong model .
this is clearly visible in the case of tm1 parameter set . for higher densities the weak model gives less stiff equation of state .
the behavior of the equation of state is directly connected with the value of the maximum star mass .
equilibrium conditions namely charge neutrality and @xmath15-equilibrium determine the composition of the star . for both parameterizations
the onset points for @xmath41 and @xmath42 hyperons are localized at high densities which are relevant to unstable branches of the mass - radius relations .
thus the obtained stable hyperon star model is composed of neutrons , protons , @xmath9 hyperons and leptons .
the appearance of @xmath41 and @xmath42 hyperons in neutron star interior will be possible in a very special configuration .
a protoneutron star model with very high central density can lead to a hyperon star with @xmath27 and @xmath9 hyperons in its interior .
the possibility of the existence of such protoneutron star model will be the subject of future investigations .
one can compare the obtained results with those presented in the paper by schaffner et al .
@xcite , where the analysis of the existence of the third family of stable compact stars has been performed for highly attractive hyperon - hyperon interaction .
however , recent experimental data indicate for much weaker strength of @xmath16 interaction . employing these data and the estimated value of the @xmath9 well depth @xmath43 mev the result of the paper @xcite can not be confirmed .
99 glendenning n.k . 1985 _ astrophys.j . _ * 293 * 470 ; also see in _ compact stars _ by n.
k glendenning sringer - verlag , new york 1997 | an equation of state of neutron star matter with strange baryons has been obtained .
the effects of the strength of hyperon - hyperon interactions on the equations of state constructed for the chosen parameter sets have been analyzed .
numerous neutron star models show that the appearance of hyperons is connected with the increasing density in neutron star interiors .
the performed calculations have indicated that the change of the hyperon - hyperon coupling constants affects the chemical composition of a neutron star .
the obtained numerical hyperon star models exclude large population of strange baryons in the star interior . |
in relation to the formation mechanism of compact binary systems such as double neutron star systems , double black hole systems or black hole neutron star systems , hypercritical accretion flows onto neutron stars in envelopes of massive stars of close binary systems have been investigated by several authors @xcite . the mass accretion rate ( @xmath2 ) of the hypercritical accretion flow amounts to @xmath3 times as high as the eddington s mass accretion limit .
chevalier found that for rather small values of the viscosity parameter , @xmath4 , the accretion flow which cools via neutrino radiation could be realized .
recently bethe et al .
pointed out that the flow with much larger and conservative values of the viscosity parameter , @xmath5 , does not become so hot as to emit neutrinos during the accretion process but that the accretion will proceed to the advection dominated accretion flow ( adaf ) . in their model , the accreted matter onto the neutron star surface is processed there by nuclear reactions and cools via neutrino emission .
the hypercritical accretion increases the mass of the star rapidly and induces the collapse of the neutron star to a black hole .
thus the supernova explosion of the massive companion will lead to the formation of a black hole
neutron star binary system or a double black hole binary system .
the merging event of such a system might be one of the important targets for the gravitational wave astronomy . in the accretion process , a non - negligible amount of angular momentum is carried into the neutron star .
this potentially could spin up the star to the kepler limit , i.e. to the state where the stellar rotational frequency equals to the orbital frequency at the equatorial surface .
the star rotating at the kepler limit deforms significantly from the spherical configuration and the subsequent collapse of the rapidly rotating star to a black hole might radiate a substantial fraction of the binding energy of the system in the form of gravitational waves .
this seemingly straightforward conclusion , however , has to be reexamined from the standpoint of stability of rotating neutron stars .
the gravitational radiation driven instability of rotating stars might prevent the stellar rotational frequency to increase above a certain limit .
in particular , the recently discovered r - mode instability @xcite might be sufficiently strong to suppress the spin frequency in some range of the stellar temperature . in this paper , in order to see how this instability influences
the accretion induced spin - up of the neutron star in the hypercritical accretion , we will employ the hypercritical adaf model based on the analysis of bethe et al . and investigate the evolution of the temperature and the rotational frequency of the neutron star .
it should be noted that the study in this paper is done in the framework of newtonian dynamics and newtonian gravity .
the gravitational radiation reaction on stellar oscillations is evaluated by the lowest order post - newtonian approximation @xcite . furthermore to simplify our analysis ,
stellar configurations are assumed to be spherical polytropes , @xmath6 , with the polytropic index @xmath7 .
here @xmath8 and @xmath9 are the pressure and the density , respectively . by choosing the polytropic coefficient @xmath10 appropriately ,
the stellar mass is @xmath11 and its radius is @xmath12 km .
note that the radius of the polytropes with index @xmath7 is independent of the central density and thus of the mass if the constant @xmath10 is fixed .
the hypercritical accretion flow which we employ in this paper is proposed by bethe et al . .
the characteristics of that flow are summarized as follows .
( 1 ) the flow is hypercritical because the accretion rate is typically @xmath13 . ( 2 ) since the flow is advection dominated @xcite and its temperature is relatively low ( @xmath14mev ) , the adiabatic exponent of the gas equals to @xmath15 ( radiation dominated mixture of photon , electron , positron and nuclei ) . ( 3 ) the accreted matter touches down on the surface of the star ` softly ' and burns to produce as heavy nuclei as @xmath16 . on the other hand ,
the matter is cooled by neutrino emission .
consequently the whole process acts as a ` thermostat ' which keeps the neutrino temperature @xmath17mev . the mass accretion rate @xmath18 , which is the rate of mass attachment to the star , is assumed to be constant during the evolution .
in general the mass accretion rate should be distinguished from the mass inflow rate @xmath19 , which is the total amount of the incoming mass per unit time to the neutron star .
this is because some kinds of outflow may coexist with the accreting flows . in this paper
we simplify the situation by assuming that both rates are the same , i.e. @xmath20 .
we will discuss this assumption further in _
the evolution of the neutron star mass @xmath21 is written as : @xmath22 where @xmath23 is the initial mass of the star ( in units of the solar mass ) , time @xmath24 is measured in units of second , and @xmath25 is defined as : @xmath26 \ .\ ] ] the accreted matter landing on the surface layer is processed by nuclear burning and emits neutrinos .
we will assume that roughly a half of them escapes from the star freely and that some fraction of the rest of them interacts with stellar matter and heats it up .
the mean free path @xmath27 of inelastic scattering of neutrinos with electrons in the neutron star matter is written as @xcite , @xmath28^{7/6 } \left[\frac{0.1 \mbox{mev}}{e_\nu}\right]^{5/2 } \mbox{cm } \ , \ ] ] where @xmath29 is the ` nuclear density ' ( @xmath30 ) and @xmath31 is the neutrino energy .
the density @xmath32 means the averaged density of the star , which is related in our polytropic stellar models to the mass @xmath21 as follows : @xmath33 the neutrino energy @xmath31 is fixed to @xmath34mev .
we simply assume the scattering ( thus heating ) rate as @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the stellar radius and @xmath37 is an efficiency factor of @xmath38-heating through the inelastic scattering .
as the flow is adiabatic and radiation dominated , the specific internal energy of the accreted matter @xmath39 is written as , @xmath40 with these expressions , the heating rate of the whole star @xmath41 is , @xmath42\left[\frac{m}{m_{\odot}}\right]^{13/6 } \mbox{erg } \
\mbox{s}^{-1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here we choose @xmath43 .
heating rate above is proportional to the multiplication of @xmath2 and @xmath37 .
thus the reduction of @xmath37 is equivalent to that of @xmath2 with @xmath37 being fixed .
as shown later in discussion , the dependence of the results on @xmath37 is weak . as the cooling mechanism of the star ,
we assume the modified urca process to be dominant @xcite . its cooling rate @xmath44 is , @xmath45^{2/3 } t_9 ^ 8 \ , \ ] ] where @xmath46 is the stellar temperature , which is assumed to be uniform , in units of @xmath47k . the heat capacity @xmath48 of the neutron star which is approximated by the following formula if the neutron star is assumed to consist of degenerate free nucleons , @xmath49\left[\frac{\bar{\rho}}{\rho_{\rm nuc}}\right]^{-2/3 } t_9 \ , \ ] ] where @xmath50 is the boltzmann constant .
then the equation of the thermal balance of the star can be written as , @xmath51 this is transformed to the equation of the evolution of the temperature as follows : @xmath52^{1/3}t_9 ^ 2\right ) & = & 6.5\times10^{-5 } \left[\frac{\dot{m}}{1 m_{\odot}\mbox{y}^{-1}}\right]\left[\frac{m}{m_{\odot}}\right]^{13/6}\nonumber\\ & - & 8.7\times 10^{-9}\left[\frac{m}{m_{\odot}}\right]t_9 ^ 8 \ .
\label{eq - thermal}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the angular momentum of the star is changed by two torques induced by accretion and by gravitational radiation if the r - mode oscillation is unstable .
the accretion torque is estimated as @xmath53 , where @xmath54 is the specific angular momentum of the accreted matter : @xmath55 here the adaf solution by narayan & yi is employed to evaluate the rotational velocity of the accreted matter at the stellar surface . as for the gravitational radiation torque , we use the simple formula used in lindblom et al . which also incorporates the damping effect by viscosity .
this corresponds to the assumption that the r - mode quickly grows to saturate in the non - linear regime of its amplitude and the angular momentum of the mode is a substantial fraction of the stellar angular momentum .
let us introduce the rate @xmath56 of the angular momentum of the mode to the stellar angular momentum . by using the moment of inertia of the star @xmath57 and the stellar rotational angular frequency @xmath58 ,
the torque due to gravitational wave emission can be written as @xmath59 .
the factor @xmath56 is related to the dimensionless amplitude of the oscillation of the r - mode ` @xmath60 ' , which is used in the simplified discussion of the non - linear evolution of the r - mode by owen et al .
( 1998 ) , as @xmath61 .
the time scale of the r - mode instability @xmath62 is then defined as , @xmath63 where @xmath64 is the energy dissipation time scale by the gravitational radiation , @xmath65 is that of the shear viscosity due to neutron - neutron collision and @xmath66 is that of the bulk viscosity due to the lag of the @xmath67reaction and the stellar oscillation .
the negative value of @xmath62 signals the onset of the instability .
we set @xmath68 to be zero when this value is positive , i.e. for damping oscillations .
the time scale of gravitational wave dissipation is obtained as , @xmath69 ^ 2}\left(\frac{l+2}{l+1}\right)^{2l+2}\nonumber\\ & & \times \omega^{2l+2}\rho_c r^{2l+3}\int_0 ^ 1 \tilde{\rho}(x)x^{2l+2 } dx.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath70 is the density distribution normalized by the central density @xmath71 .
the central density is related to the stellar mass @xmath21 for @xmath72 polytropes as , @xmath73 thus for @xmath74 modes for which the instability is the strongest , @xmath75 ^ 6 \left[\frac{m}{m_{\odot}}\right].\ ] ] here @xmath76 is the rotational frequency of the star ( @xmath77 ) .
the damping time scales due to shear and bulk viscosities are , @xmath78 and , @xmath79 ^ 2 \left[\frac{m}{m_{\odot}}\right]^{-1 } t_9 ^ 6.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the equation for the evolution of the rotational frequency is written as , @xmath80\left[\frac{f}{100\mbox{hz}}\right]\right ) = \tau_r^{-1 } \left[\frac{m}{m_{\odot}}\right]\left[\frac{f}{100\mbox{hz}}\right ] \delta\nonumber\\ & + & 2.0\times 10^{-6}\left[\frac{\dot{m}}{1 m_{\odot}\mbox{y}^{-1}}\right ] \left[\frac{m}{m_{\odot}}\right]^{1/2}. \label{eq - freq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is important to note that the thermal balance as well as the angular momentum balance determines the approximate terminal values of the temperature and the rotational frequency of the star , if the accretion rate is fixed and the mass is regarded as nearly constant in the evolution . by setting the right hand side of eq .
( [ eq - thermal ] ) to be zero , the temperature can be solved as , @xmath81^{1/8 } \left[\frac{m}{m_{\odot}}\right]^{7/48 } \ . \label{t9expr}\ ] ] thus for the star with mass @xmath82 and the accretion rate with @xmath83 , the ( uniform ) temperature will be about @xmath84k , which is near the most susceptible temperature for the r - mode instability to grow @xcite .
the equation of the angular momentum balance gives the terminal value of the rotational frequency of the star by setting the right hand side of eq.([eq - freq ] ) to be zero .
if we omit the contributions of viscous damping whose effect is smallest near at the temperature obtained above , we get the expression for the terminal rotational frequency as : @xmath85 = 1.3~\left[\frac{\dot{m}}{1 m_{\odot } \mbox{y}^{-1}}\right]^{1/7 } \left[\frac{m}{m_\odot}\right]^{-3/14 } \delta^{-1/7}. \label{f100expr}\ ] ] given the mass accretion rate and the initial values of the stellar mass , temperature and frequency , the evolution of the corresponding quantities can be followed by integrating eqs .
( [ eq - mass ] ) , ( [ eq - thermal ] ) and ( [ eq - freq ] ) .
we have computed several evolutionary sequences by choosing different sets for the initial values .
we will show how the evolution depends on the initial values . in fig .
[ fig1 ] the rotational frequency is plotted against the mass of the star which serves as the ` time ' variable because the mass accretion rate is assumed to be constant . with
the mass accretion rate fixed , solutions with different values of the initial frequency converges to a certain value rather quickly compared with the mass accretion time scale .
this behaviour is expected from the rapid temperature saturation seen in fig .
[ fig2 ] by swift establishment of the thermal balance between heating and cooling .
it should be pointed out that the omission of the r - mode instability would lead to very rapid increase of the rotational frequency and that the star would reach its mass - shedding limit before the accretion induced collapse occurs .
the mass accretion rate dependence of the frequency evolution is shown in fig .
[ fig3 ] . as seen in fig .
[ fig2 ] the temperature of the star quickly saturates at the limiting value which depends on the mass accretion rate . since the strength of the r - mode instability depends on the temperature as well as the stellar rotational frequency , the rotational frequency also quickly saturates . as the time scale of the angular momentum change is longer than that of the temperature change ,
the frequency saturation is reached slightly later compared with the temperature saturation .
we have shown that the r - mode instability sets a severe limit on the rotational frequency of the hypercritically accreting neutron stars proposed by bethe et al . .
as the mass accretion rate dependence of the rotational frequency ( eq . ( [ f100expr ] ) ) is rather weak , the rotational frequency of the star is well below its mass - shedding limit . even if the mass accretion rate rises to @xmath86 , the rotational frequency increases only to @xmath87hz .
thus the gravitational collapse of neutron stars due to mass accretion to low mass black holes in these systems will proceed almost spherically and black holes formed just after the collapse will rotate so slowly that the rotational parameter is not large either , i.e. @xmath88 for @xmath89 . the amount of gravitational radiation from the system can be evaluated as follows .
the process discussed in this paper is similar to that studied by wagoner .
a neutron star in an x - ray binary system emits gravitational wave so as to balance the accretion torque with the gravitational radiation torque of the f - mode ( ` wagoner star ' ) . for our models the f - mode must be replaced by the r - mode and the accretion rate is considerably different , i.e. increased .
the standard formula of the luminosity of gravitational radiation can be expressed as @xcite , @xmath90 where @xmath91 are the eigenfrequency of the mode , the dimensionless strain of the gravitational field and the distance from the source , respectively . using the terminal rotational frequency @xmath76
obtained above and the relation of the eigenfrequency and the angular velocity for @xmath92 modes , @xmath93 we get @xmath94^{3/7}\left[\frac{m}{m_\odot}\right]^{5/14}\left[\frac{d}{1\mbox{kpc}}\right]^{-1 } \delta^{1/14}.\ ] ] as seen from the result obtained in this paper , the rotational frequency becomes almost constant after a short time of accretion .
thus it is rather easy to detect signals of the gravitational wave by integrating it for an appropriate interval of time .
we here define the fourier component of the squared dimensionless strain @xmath95 as @xmath96 . then from the parseval s relation , @xmath97 where @xmath98 is the number of cycles of the oscillation in the interval of observation , @xmath99 .
frequency width @xmath100 and @xmath99 are related by the uncertainty principle as , @xmath101 as @xmath102 , the r.m.s . of the fourier component of the strain
is , @xmath103 the event rate @xmath104 of the hypercritical accretion is quite uncertain .
the maximum value is expected to be @xmath105 , which is the birth rate of the close black hole
neutron star binary @xcite .
in order to detect @xmath106 events per year , we have to observe the region with the distance as follows : @xmath107 where @xmath108 @xcite . here
@xmath109 is the number density of the massive galaxies ( @xmath110 )
. then fourier component of the strain is , @xmath111^{3/7}\\\nonumber & & \times\left[\frac{m}{m_\odot}\right]^{5/14}\left[\frac{{\cal r}}{10^{-4}\mbox{galaxy}^{-1}\mbox{y}^{-1}}\right]^{1/3 } n_0^{-1/3}\left[\frac{t_{\rm obs}}{1~{\rm month}}\right]^{1/2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] comparing this with the expected sensitivity of the _ laser interferometer gravitational - wave observatory _ ( ligo ) , the integration of one month is sufficient for the detection by the ligo ii facility ( see shoemaker 2000 for the sensitivity curves of the ligo ) . as the dependence of the strain on @xmath104 is weak , the ligo ii can see the signal by the integration of one month , even if @xmath104 is reduced by two orders of magnitude
. typical frequency of the source may be around @xmath112hz . in this investigation
we have applied the ` one zone ' approximation for simplicity .
it means that the variables such as the stellar temperature or the rotational frequency are represented by some ` averaged ' values throughout the whole star .
it premises that the viscosity works very efficiently compared to the time scale of the evolution of the system , typically about one year .
the adjustment time scale of shear viscosity to smooth out the differential flow can be estimated for the neutron - neutron scattering dominant matter @xcite as follows : @xmath113 assuming the stellar radius @xmath114 km and the averaged density @xmath115 , this amounts to @xmath116 y for @xmath117k .
the rotation law of the star can deviate from the uniform rotation if this time scale is comparable or longer than the spin - up time . in that case ,
behaviour of ( classical ) r - modes is uncertain and their characteristics may be drastically changed .
we here _ assume _ that they can be approximated by some kind of average of the rotational angular velocity .
the validity of this assumption should be confirmed elsewhere .
it has been pointed out that in the hypercritical accretion process , explosive outflows driven by neutrino heating @xcite or jet formation @xcite may significantly reduce the mass attachment onto the neutron star .
if it is the case , it is more probable that double neutron star binary systems will be formed through this channel . in such accretion inefficient situations ,
the mass accretion rate @xmath18 is lower than the mass inflow rate @xmath19 from the envelope of the companion star .
if the accretion inefficient flows behave similarly as the accretion efficient flows , evolution of the stars may be approximated by our models with lower @xmath2 and with a shorter duration , for the same value of @xmath19 .
this results in smaller terminal rotational frequencies of the star .
thus neutron stars which survive after mass accretion in this process would have even lower rotational frequencies .
it is a surprise that the possibility of observation of gravitational waves from the systems seems unexpectedly large .
this might encourage the ongoing detection experiments of gravitational waves .
however we have to be careful in concluding the significance of the hypercritically accreting neutron stars as sources of gravitational waves .
our analysis here might be too simplified and naive to get conclusive answers to the observational possibility .
some simplified assumptions may influence the result significantly .
for instance , more realistic behaviour of the accretion flow and the accreted matter may drastically change the efficiency of the accretion torque .
angular momentum re - distribution in the realistic star may modify the r - mode characteristics significantly , which may affect the strength of the instability .
thus the uncertainty included in our assumptions must be investigated more intensively in the future .
we would like to express our gratitude to dr .
n. andersson , the referee , for his suggestion that the detectability of the gravitational wave signals may be rather high .
andersson n. , 1998 , apj , 502 , 708 andersson n. , kokkotas k. , stergioulas n. , 1999 , apj , 516 , 307 armitage p. j. , livio m. , 1999 , apj submitted ( astro - ph/9906028 ) bethe h. a. , brown g. e. , 1998 , apj , 506 , 780 bethe h. a. , brown g. e. , lee c .- h . , 1999 ,
apj submitted ( astro - ph/9909132 ) brown g. e. , 1995 , apj , 440 , 270 chevalier r. a. , 1993 , apj , 411 , l33 chevalier r. a. , 1996 , apj , 459 , 322 efstathiou g. , ellis r. s. , peterson b. , 1988 , mnras , 232 , 431 friedman j. l. , morsink s. m. , 1998 , apj , 502 , 714 fryer c. l. , benz w. , herant m. , 1996 , apj , 460 , 801 levin y. , 1999 , apj , 517 , 328 lindblom l. , owen b. j. , morsink s. m. , 1998 , phys .
, 80 , 4843 narayan r. , yi i. , 1994 , apj , 428 , l13 owen b. j. , lindblom l. , cutler c. , schutz b. f. , vecchio a. , andersson n. , 1998 , phys .
d58 , 084020 rezzolla l. , lamb f. k. , shapiro s. l. , 2000 , apj , 531 , l139 shapiro s. l. , teukolsky s. , 1983 , _ black holes , white dwarfs and neutron stars _ , wiley , new york shoemaker d. , 2000 , in _ matters of gravity , no.15 _ ( http://gravity.phys.psu.edu/mog/mog15/node14.html ) thorne k. s. , 1980 , rev .
phys , 52 , 299 wagoner r. v. , 1984 , apj , 278 , 345 | we have investigated an influence of the r - mode instability on hypercritically accreting ( @xmath0 ) neutron stars in close binary systems during their common envelope phases based on the scenario proposed by bethe et al . .
on the one hand neutron stars are heated by the accreted matter at the stellar surface , but on the other hand they are also cooled down by the neutrino radiation . at the same time , the accreted matter transports its angular momentum and mass to the star .
we have studied the evolution of the stellar mass , temperature and rotational frequency .
the gravitational - wave - driven instability of the r - mode oscillation strongly suppresses spinning - up of the star , whose final rotational frequency is well below the mass - shedding limit , typically as small as @xmath1 of that of the mass - shedding state . on a very short time
scale the rotational frequency tends to approach a certain constant value and saturates there as far as the amount of the accreted mass does not exceed a certain limit to collapse to a black hole .
this implies that the similar mechanism of gravitational radiation as the so - called wagoner star may work in this process .
the star is spun up by accretion until the angular momentum loss by gravitational radiation balances the accretion torque .
the time - integrated dimensionless strain of the radiated gravitational wave may be large enough to be detectable by the gravitational wave detectors such as ligo ii .
accretion binaries : close stars : neutron stars : rotation stars : oscillations |
the origin of fine - grained dust rims surrounding chondrules in carbonaceous chondrites is still debated .
analyses of cm chondrite thin sections by optical and scanning electron microscopy ( metzler et al .
1992 ) , as well as detailed theoretical models ( morfill et al .
1998 , henceforth mdt ; cuzzi 2004 ; ormel et al .
2008 , henceforth oct ) suggest that these dust mantles could very well have formed in the gaseous environment of the primitive solar nebula , as a result of accretion processes .
nevertheless , advocates of a non - nebular origin of these rims favor their formation on the cm parent asteroids , through the impact and compaction of matrix material around chondrules ( trigo - rodrguez et al .
2006 ) , followed by aqueous alteration .
this interpretation arises mostly because the porosity of observed dust mantles that envelop chondrules is lower than what , presumably , could be produced by agglomeration of dust in the solar nebula .
the non - nebular scenario still requires further quantitative analysis .
for example , numerical techniques similar to those employed in the study of collisions between kuiper belt objects ( leinhardt and stewart 2009 ) could be used to measure shock stresses in asteroidal collisions .
theoretical modeling of the formation of fine - grained dust rims assumes that two populations , chondrules and dust , both free floating in the gas of the primitive solar nebula , come into contact .
mdt put forward the notion that sweep - up of dust by chondrules in a confined volume of the nebula , prior to the formation of meteorite parent bodies , reproduces the near - linear relation between chondrule radius and rim thickness ( e.g. metzler et al .
1992 , paque and cuzzi 1997 ) .
mdt do not make specific assumptions about the nature of the gas flow .
cuzzi ( 2004 ) goes further and incorporates the role of turbulence in the sweep - up process , showing that the initial relative abundance of chondrules is an important parameter that determines both the rate at which dust is depleted locally , and the rate of growth of rimmed particles .
the analytical model of cuzzi ( 2004 ) predicts that chondrule - sized particles will acquire their observed rim volumes in @xmath110@xmath710@xmath8 years , subject to the values of the dimensionless turbulent viscosity parameter @xmath9 ( shakura and sunyaev 1973 , balbus and hawley 1998 ) , which is a measure of the stresses in an accretion disk .
the precise value of @xmath9 in protoplanetary disks ( including the solar nebula ) is uncertain , and authors often consider values ranging from @xmath10 to 0.1 . for disks around t tauri stars , @xmath11@xmath12 has been inferred ( hartmann et al . 1998 ) .
assuming high values of @xmath9 , the cuzzi ( 2004 ) model yields chondrule rimming times as low as a few years .
the effect of parametrized turbulence has been included by oct in a numerical scheme to study inter - chondrule sticking via dust rims .
their monte carlo algorithm contains a detailed treatment of the collisions among porous dust grain aggregates , and their results evidently show a difference in the evolution of rimmed - chondrule size for two values of @xmath9 , @xmath13 and @xmath14 .
the lower @xmath9 value allows for rimmed - particle radii growth by a factor of 7 , compared to a factor of @xmath1 2 for @xmath15 , before the effects of dust compaction set in .
this occurs in @xmath16 years in the former case , and in @xmath17 years in the latter case .
the final relation between chondrule and rim masses that oct obtain is , once again , nearly linear .
a key ingredient in the above calculations is the collision velocity between solid particles of different sizes . in a protoplanetary disk
, the following sources of relative velocities may operate : 1 ) thermally - induced brownian motion , important for micron - sized dust grains ; 2 ) drift towards the central star and difference in azimuthal ( orbital ) velocities ( the latter also known as `` transverse '' velocity ) , both due to a radial pressure gradient in the disk gas ( e.g. weidenschilling 1977 ) ; 3 ) settling towards the disk midplane , as a result of the vertical component of the star s gravity ; and 4 ) turbulence .
it was only recently that accurate analytical expressions for turbulent relative velocities were obtained ( ormel and cuzzi 2007 ) .
these formulae show that turbulence can dominate mutual velocities for chondrule- and smaller - size particles in the solar nebula at 3 au , over systematic radial drift , provided @xmath18 ( oct , their figure 1 ) .
our understanding of the evolution of protoplanetary disks is significantly improved when their vertical structure is taken into account .
for example , numerical simulations show that the gas velocity dispersion ( fromang and papaloizou 2006 ) , viscous stress ( turner et al .
2007 ) , and accretion rate ( turner et al . 2010 ) depend on height @xmath19 above the disk midplane . furthermore , this vertical dependence bears directly on the dynamical behavior of solid bodies .
for instance , the increase of gas velocities at high @xmath19 ( where gas densities are lower ) produce higher particle relative velocities .
while it is recognized that protoplanetary disks must be in a turbulent state , there is no general consensus regarding the mechanism responsible for the production of turbulence .
however , workers in the field acknowledge that a magnetic field , coupled to the differential rotation of the disk gas , could be the crucial driver of disk turbulence . the outcome of the ensuing magnetorotational instability ( or mri ; balbus and hawley 1998 ) is self - sustained turbulence that supplies the necessary viscous stresses for the disk angular momentum to be transported outwards .
hydrodynamic and magnetic stresses ( the latter greater than the former by a factor of a few ) both contribute to the turbulent viscosity in a disk . there is a caveat associated with the saturation of the mri in the solar nebula : gas ionization may be too low , and electrical resistivity too high , in dense regions of the nebula to allow coupling of the gas to the magnetic field .
these regions remain nearly laminar and are sandwiched between conducting layers where turbulence does develop , owing to ionization by cosmic rays and stellar x - rays that are absorbed before they reach the midplane .
furthermore , recombination of free electrons on micron - sized dust grains is efficient and reduces the ionization fraction below that necessary to sustain turbulence ( turner et al . 2010 ) .
dust abundance is therefore important in establishing levels of turbulent activity . notwithstanding
the significance of gas resistivity , in this study it is set to zero to focus on the growth of rimmed , chondrule - sized solid particles as they accrete dust in a local neighborhood of the solar nebula , in which all of the gas flow is turbulent due to the mri and the turbulent intensity varies with time and position .
the ideal magnetohydrodynamic ( mhd ) numerical set - up used allows us not only to determine the final size distribution of dust - mantled objects , but in the process it performs a self - consistent calculation of the dust abundance as a function of time and spatial location , with turbulence and vertical settling as the sources of relative velocities between dust and chondrules .
section 2 presents a semi - analytical argument regarding the importance of turbulence in dust - chondrule dynamics .
section 3 describes the numerical technique used to model the solar nebula and the solids , including the interaction between chondrules and dust .
this section also lists the simulations that were carried out .
section 4 presents the results of the mhd calculations , and a discusion follows in section 5 .
a summary and conclusions are given in section 6 .
for a minimum - mass solar nebula ( mmsn ) model , one can compute the magnitudes of the particle relative velocities as the aerodynamic coupling of the solids to the gas changes , due to the decreasing gas density with height .
figure 1 plots the magnitudes of relative velocities between a 1-mm particle ( a typical chondrule size ) , and a 1-@xmath20 m grain , at 3 au , due to turbulence ( _ black solid curve _ ) , vertical settling ( _ dark gray solid curve _ ) and radial drift ( _ light gray solid curve _ ) as a function of @xmath19 ( normalized by the disk scale height @xmath21 ) .
the turbulent curve was obtained from the closed - form analytical formulae of ormel and cuzzi ( 2007 ) : @xmath22 @xmath23\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath24 in these expressions , @xmath25 is the particle stokes number of particle @xmath26 , which measures the degree of aerodynamic coupling of particles to the gas , with @xmath27 the frequency of the largest turbulent eddies [ here assumed to be equal to the disk keplerian frequency , to a good approximation ( carballido et al .
2010 ) ] , and @xmath28 is the particle stopping time ( i.e. , the time in which a particle equilibrates with the gas when moving relative to it ) , which for a particle radius @xmath29 smaller than the mean free path @xmath30 of the gas molecules is given by @xmath31 , with @xmath32 the particle solid density , @xmath33 the gas sound speed , and @xmath34 the gas density .
furthermore , @xmath35 and @xmath36 are relative velocities induced by eddies that decay in a time longer ( class i ) or shorter ( class ii ) than @xmath37 ; @xmath38 is a quantity that defines the boundary between classes i and ii [ obtained as in section 3 of ormel & cuzzi ( 2007 ) ] ; @xmath39 is the turbulent gas velocity ; and @xmath40 is the flow reynolds number ( with @xmath41 and @xmath42 the turbulent and molecular viscosities , respectively ) . for the purpose of fig .
1 , the stokes numbers @xmath43 and @xmath44 are chosen to correspond to particle radii @xmath29=1 mm and 1 @xmath20 m , respectively , with @xmath32=3 g @xmath45 . the gas density is assumed to decrease with height as in eq .
( 8) below . note that @xmath37 ( and hence @xmath46 ) increases with height as the gas density decreases .
the reynolds number is @xmath47 , with @xmath48 , @xmath49 , and @xmath30=16.7 cm ( armitage 2010 ) .
the vale of @xmath9 is a vertical profile ( _ dotted curve _ in fig .
1 ) obtained by adding together radial and azimuthal averages of the reynolds and maxwell stresses from a mhd simulation ( section 3 ) , normalizing the sum by the initial midplane gas pressure , and furter averaging over time . the turbulent gas velocity @xmath39 in eqs . (
[ eq : oc1 ] ) and ( [ eq : oc2 ] ) is also obtained from the mhd run , and is averaged in a similar way .
two features are evident from fig .
1 : first , the contribution of radial drift to relative velocities is minor , and the main sources are vertical settling and turbulence .
second , turbulent activity , as described by the value of @xmath9 , depends considerably on distance from the midplane .
it may appear as if there exist odd anticorrelations between the turbulent relative velocity and @xmath9 at certain heights ( for example , around @xmath50 ) ; however , the fluctuations in both curves result from the intrinsic variability of mri turbulence , and in fig .
1 the time average for @xmath9 was performed over a different time interval than for @xmath39 , so these fluctuations are uncorrelated .
the overall trend is for @xmath51 to increase with increasing @xmath9 .
[ fig : fig1 ] numerical simulations of mri turbulence , in which solid particles are modeled with a lagrangian approach , show that relative velocities between chondrules and dust can be as high as @xmath1 10@xmath52 cm / s ( carballido et al .
2008 ) , higher than what is shown by the semi analytical black curve in fig .
1 . the intrinsic strength of the velocities produced by the mri reinforces the main point of fig .
1 , that is , turbulence is a major contributor to dust chondrule dynamics .
the model of chondrule - dust compound growth consists of two components : the gaseous ( disk ) phase and the solid ( chondrule , dust and chondrule - dust ) phase . throughout this work
, the term particle will be used to denote either a rimless or a rimmed chondrule .
the disk is modeled by the shearing box approximation of hawley et al .
( 1995 ) : a rectangular cartesian coordinate system represents a local neighborhood inside the disk , located at an arbitrary orbital radius @xmath53 from the central star .
the dimensions of this neighborhood are assumed to be much smaller than @xmath53 .
the @xmath54 , @xmath55 and @xmath19 directions in the box represent the radial , azimuthal and vertical directions of the disk , respectively .
both the radial and vertical components of stellar gravity are included , and the differential rotation of the disk gas is replaced by a shear flow along the @xmath55 direction . in this work ,
the eulerian zeus-3d code ( stone and norman 1992a , b ) is used to solve the equations of ideal mhd in the shearing box : @xmath56 @xmath57 @xmath58 @xmath59 where @xmath60 , @xmath61 and @xmath62 are the gas velocity , density and pressure , respectively , @xmath63 is the magnetic field , @xmath64 is the disk angular frequency , @xmath65 is the isothermal speed of sound , and @xmath66 and @xmath67 are unitary radial and vertical vectors .
the box setup is that of fromang and papaloizou ( 2006 ) .
the gas density depends initially on height as @xmath68 where @xmath69 is the gas density at the midplane , and the disk scale - height @xmath70 .
the box has `` shearing periodic '' radial boundary conditions , meaning that whenever a parcel of fluid exits one of the @xmath54 box walls , it reappears through the opposite wall with a different azimuthal ( @xmath55 ) position and velocity given by the shear value .
periodic boundaries are applied along @xmath55 and @xmath19 , but the vertical component of stellar gravity is only included inside a region away from the top and bottom boundaries , to avoid spurious disturbances throughout the box .
small dust grains , which are aerodynamically well coupled to the gas , are represented by a passive contaminant that follows the gas motions .
this passive scalar is defined as a fraction of the gas density .
the initial dust density is set to 0.1@xmath61 , equivalent to about 30 times the solar abundance of silicate dust , since chondrule formation is believed to have taken place in regions of high dust - to - gas ratios ( krot et al .
the particular value of 10% is somewhat arbitrary , but is intended to represent this enhanced solar abundance . the solid density of dust
is assumed to be 3 g @xmath45 .
both rimless and rimmed chondrules are represented by individual particles that interact with the gas through variable drag forces .
the particles are smaller than the mean free path of the gas molecules , and their equation of motion is @xmath71 where @xmath72 is the particle velocity and @xmath73 is the stopping time ( with the internal density @xmath74 set to 3 g @xmath45 ) .
the initial chondrule sizes are either monodisperse ( @xmath29=300 @xmath20 m ) or drawn from a lognormal distribution with a mean diameter of 622 @xmath20 m and a standard deviation of 453 @xmath20 m , as measured in the l3 chondrite alha77011 ( rubin and keil 1984 ) . as pointed out by oct , measured chondrule size distributions may not necessarily reflect the true initial distributions before chondrules were incorporated into chondrite parent bodies . yet
, the process of turbulent concentration in the solar nebula leads to nearly lognormal size distributions that are consistent with those of disaggregated chondrules from ordinary chondrites ( cuzzi et al .
2001 ) .
whenever a chondrule enters a region permeated by dust , it is assumed to accrete a dust mantle , subject to the local dust abundance .
the effect of collisions between fractal dust aggregates , and between aggregates and chondrules , is not treated here .
instead , we follow the approach of mdt , in which the radius of a rimmed chondrule grows according to @xmath75 where @xmath76 is the spatial mass density of the dust population , @xmath77 , and @xmath2 is the sticking efficiency between a dust grain and a chondrule ( see below ) . strictly speaking , the chondrule speed @xmath78 should be measured relative to the dust , but since dust is firmly tied to the gas , @xmath79 can be used .
the corresponding depletion of dust is given by @xmath80 where @xmath81 is the particle size distribution function .
sticking between dust - rimmed chondrules is not investigated here , but previous experimental ( gttler et al .
2010 and references therein ) and numerical ( carballido et al . 2010 , zsom et al . 2010 ) work indicates that approximately equal - sized compact particles will not stick at the relative velocities prevalent in ideal - mhd turbulence .
note , however , that oct show that there is sticking between dust - rimmed chondrules when @xmath9 becomes large .
the shearing box is located at @xmath53=3 au , and has dimensions @xmath82 , with the disk scale - height @xmath21 at 3 au equal to 0.186 au .
the box contains 32 grid cells in the @xmath54 direction , 100 cells in the @xmath55 direction , and 196 cells in the @xmath19 direction .
the number of particles that can be introduced in the numerical disk model is many orders of magnitude less than the actual number in the solar nebula . for the purpose of sampling a large enough region of the turbulent flow , 1.4 @xmath83 individual particles
are introduced with zero velocity and spread uniformly across the box at @xmath84=52 years . in particular , the input vertical particle coordinates are uniformly distributed between @xmath19=0 and @xmath85 , and are then randomly initialized .
the formal approach would have their initial heights be proportional to the vertical gas density profile , but it would make little difference since the mixing time for such small particles is very short .
the chondrule abundance is introduced through the ratio @xmath86 of chondrule volume density @xmath87 to dust density @xmath76 .
this ratio is a key quantity that determines the final thickness of the dust rims ( oct ) . as @xmath86 is a free parameter , for the purpose of the present numerical runs it
is assigned values ranging from @xmath1 10@xmath88 to @xmath1 10@xmath7 .
table 1 lists the actual values employed in each run ( labeled a , b , c , d and e ) .
also listed in table 1 are the corresponding chondrule _ number _ densities @xmath89 [ note that chondrule number densities in regions of the solar nebula where these silicate spherules formed may range from @xmath90 2.5@xmath91 @xmath45 ( ciesla et al .
2004 ) to @xmath92 @xmath45 ( cuzzi & alexander 2006 ) ] , along with a description of the initial size distribution and the value of the sticking efficiency @xmath2 .
four runs ( a through d ) use a constant efficiency @xmath2=0.3 , while for the last run ( e ) the following criterion for sticking is introduced : dust sticks with 100% efficiency if its relative velocity @xmath3 with respect to a chondrule is less than a critical sticking velocity @xmath93 34 cm / s , given by eq .
( 14 ) of oct .
if @xmath94 , then @xmath2 is set to a small , finite value of @xmath95 .
additionally , in run e one half of the chondrule population is started at the midplane ( @xmath96 ) and the other half at @xmath97 .
the latter case may represent chondrule injection through the surface layers due , for instance , to an x - wind ( shu et al .
2000 ; however , see comments in this regard in section [ sec : discussion ] below ) .
the properties of gas and dust used in the simulations ( density at the midplane @xmath98 , surface density @xmath99 and dust solid density @xmath100 ) are summarized in table 2 .
the time step for the evolution of the solid component is the same as the one for the gas , and is typically @xmath101 years .
.simulation features [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ]
figure 2 shows the dust abundance in runs c ( top row ) and d ( bottom row ) at two different times : the instant when dust is introduced in the gas ( left panels ) and after @xmath102=83.2 years have elapsed ( right panels ) .
each panel contains the amount of dust in the @xmath55@xmath19 plane , averaged over the radial direction .
the effect of different chondrule abundances can clearly be distinguished ; a higher chondrule density depletes dust more rapidly ( top right panel ) , and this is more evident close to the midplane , since rimmed chondrules have a higher tendency to settle due to vertical gravity , and therefore spend more time oscillating around @xmath19=0 ( see below ) .
however , with a chondrule abundance that is 40 times smaller ( bottom right panel ) , dust depletion is only starting to become noticeable at the same @xmath102 , once again close to the midplane . [
fig : fig2 ] the reduction of dust density over time varies significantly if the chondrule abundance differs by a factor of 250 , along with a distinct initial chondrule size distribution , as in runs a and d. this is apparent from a vertical profile of @xmath103 , shown in fig .
3 . the curves are @xmath54@xmath55 averages of the dust density .
runs a and d are represented by the _
solid _ and _ dot - dashed _ curves , respectively .
black and gray curves correspond to two different snapshots in the evolution of the sytem , @xmath102=83.2 years ( as in fig .
2 ) and @xmath102=306.8 years , respectively . dust density in run a has decreased by a factor of @xmath110 over a 224-year period ( mostly around the midplane ) , whereas in run d it has been reduced by up to five orders of magnitude .
the chondrule abundance in run c ( _ dashed _ curve ) is so high that after 83 years the dust close to the midplane is practically depleted .
[ fig : fig3 ] depletion times are more clearly seen in fig .
4 , where the history of volume - averaged @xmath104 , with @xmath105 the initial dust density , is shown for all runs . note that in run c , @xmath76 has fallen to 10% of its initial value in @xmath1065 years .
that same fall - off occurs for runs a , b and d after 473 , 244 and 68 years , respectively .
there exists an analytical expression to estimate the time @xmath107 for a dust grain to collide with a chondrule [ oct , their eq .
( 27 ) ] , which for the parameters used in the mhd simulations gives @xmath108 yr ( run a ) and @xmath10 yr ( run c ) .
the discrepancy between these values of @xmath107 and the depletion times inferred from fig .
4 arises from the spatial average of @xmath109 , which is taken over the whole vertical extent of the box , while most of the dust - sweeping process takes place close to the midplane ( fig .
[ fig : fig4 ] growth of particle radii proceeds at different rates in our simulations , and in all cases an asymptotic size is reached .
this size depends strongly on chondrule abundance , as shown by cuzzi ( 2004 ) .
furthermore , the final particle size determines the disk height to which particles settle .
figure 5 contains data on particle size and height as a function of time .
the black curves describe the behavior of the mass - averaged particle radius for each run , measured on the left vertical axis , while the gray curves depict the evolution of the corresponding root - mean - square particle height , on the right axis .
the decrease of the rms particle height is a consequence of the initially assigned vertical positions . the low chondrule concentration in run a leads to a large rimmed - chondrule radius of almost 1 cm , or more than 30 times the original core size ( _ black solid curve _ ) .
to the author s knowledge , such large rimmed particles have not been reported .
chondrules in this run attain such large sizes at relatively late times , having more dust available to sweep up than in the cases with higher chondrule concentration . during the period of maximum growth ,
between 0 and @xmath1 200 years , these particles experience considerable vertical settling from their initial rms height ( _ gray solid curve _ ) , and oscillate thereafter around @xmath110 0.059 au above and below the midplane .
[ fig : fig5 ] in contrast , the particles in run c ( _ dashed curves _ ) exhibit a radius increase of only 0.1% , imperceptible on the scale of fig .
they undergo a @xmath1100-year period of settling and remain at about @xmath111 , or 0.126 au .
this is a similar final height as that of run d particles ( _ dot - dashed curves _ , @xmath112 au ) , which acquire a radius of roughly 0.25 cm , or 34% larger than their chondrule cores , in @xmath150 years .
it is interesting to make comparisons among the final particle size distributions that result from these simulations .
figure 6 shows probability distribution functions of particle radius at the end of each run .
the histograms consist of 100 radius bins each ( with equidistant bin spacing ) , and each bin contains @xmath113 particles out of @xmath114 .
not surprisingly , the low chondrule abundance run ( _ black curve _ ) exhibits a distribution that peaks towards the high end of the size range .
both runs a and b produce a size distribution even though they begin with a monodispersion ( the _ black , dashed _ vertical line represents the distribution in runs a and b at @xmath102=0 years ) .
the initial lognormal distributions in runs c and d are indistinguishable from the curve that corresponds to run c ( which is the run that exhibits the least growth ) . in run d ( _ lightest - gray curve _ ) , particle sizes remain lognormal - distributed , with a 37% increase in modal radius .
[ fig : fig6 ] runs a d show a moderate dependence of particle radius with disk height , as shown in fig . 7 .
the curves were obtained by binning particle radii at different values of @xmath19 , and averaging over time .
the radii values for run a ( _ black curve _ ) have been scaled by a factor of 4.5 to make comparison with the other runs easier . in run
a , particle radii at the midplane are @xmath117% larger than at @xmath115 , which is the highest location in that run where rimmed chondrules can be found . likewise , average radii values in run c ( the fastest - growing particles ) are larger by approximately the same amount at the midplane than in the upper layers . for the case of run
d ( top curve ) , the difference in mean radii at these two locations is @xmath112% .
[ fig : fig7 ] the data in fig . 7
have a typical scatter of @xmath120% ( error bars have been omitted for clarity ) .
this means that in run d dust envelopes around chondrules can be as small as 1.8 mm in radius in the upper layers , and as large as 3 mm at the midplane , a 67% difference . on the other hand
, the relatively large dispersion also means that particles can be found whose sizes are larger in the upper layers by 70% , compared to the lowest regions of the solar nebula . the evolution of the mass - averaged particle radius ( _ black curves _ ) in run e , for the first 300 years , is shown in fig .
the chondrule population that starts at the upper layer is represented by the dashed curves , whereas the solid curves correspond to the midplane population . the higher dust abundance at the disk midplane results in a systematically greater @xmath116 for the chondrules that are originated at that location , compared to the radius of the upper - layer particles .
the mean difference is 1% . the very low sticking efficiency , which is prevalent due to high relative speeds between chondrules and dust , leads to the slowest radius growth rate of the five runs .
these relative speeds can reach up to @xmath1 10@xmath52 cm / s , well above the critical value for sticking of 34 cm / s derived from eq .
( 14 ) of oct .
[ fig : fig8 ] the root - mean - square particle heights in fig . 8
( _ gray curves _ ) for both populations converge at 0.7@xmath21 .
the early sharp rise of the dashed gray curve reflects the fast vertical spreading ( i.e. , increase in chondrule sheet thickness ) of the upper - layer chondrules due to more vigorous turbulent activity in those regions . dust density , measured either through its vertical profile or through the time evolution of its volume - averaged value , does not show significant variation during the course of run e , indicating that dust deplenishment occurs on time scales longer than 300 years for the parameters used , in contrast to the results of figs . 3 and 4 .
of course , this can change for higher chondrule abundances .
this is a first attempt at understanding the acquisition of dust mantles by chondrules in a magnetohydrodynamic environment .
the numerical solar nebula model used here contains several simplifications , of which perhaps its local character is the most restrictive , because potentially important global dynamics are absent .
one example is the meridional flow pattern that transports passive species over radial distances of several tens of au ( wehrstedt and gail 2008 , ciesla 2009 ) , with inward motion in the upper layers and outward drift close to the midplane .
ciesla ( 2009 ) found that the concentration of 500-@xmath20 m particles has a maximum at @xmath110 au in the midplane of a protoplanetary disk with a mass accretion rate corresponding to that of a t tauri system , @xmath117 yr@xmath88 .
this maximum is 57% greater than the abundance at 3 au , and it comes about as a result of the radial transport of material in a @xmath118-year old disk . although the timescales for dust rimming of chondrules are significantly shorter than global transport of sub - millimeter particles ( and likely also shorter than transport of millimeter - sized particles ) , the end result of solid matter transfer between the inner and outer regions of the solar nebula may alter the chondrule abundance at the orbital radius of interest .
oct calculate the evolution of dust density as porous aggregates accrete onto chondrules , for their two nominal values of @xmath9 , @xmath14 and @xmath13 ( their fig .
6 ) . in their numerical model
, @xmath76 decreases to 0.1% of its initial value in @xmath13000 ( @xmath119 ) and 1000 ( @xmath15 ) years .
while such long times may seem at odds with the collision time scales mentioned in section [ sec : constq ] , it is important to bear in mind that the low values of @xmath120 originate from the high relative velocities imparted by mri turbulence , which oct do not model . in our simulations , with @xmath9 between 3.5@xmath121 and 2@xmath122 ( fig .
1 ) being a function of position and time , long depletion times of @xmath1 1000 years occur only for very low chondrule abundance , run a ( fig .
run d depletes dust to @xmath123 in 400 years .
clearly , @xmath9 plays a significant role in how much dust is available for chondrule rim growth .
in fact , rapid growth can be understood by considering the dependence on @xmath9 of the relative velocity @xmath3 between particles and gas [ a proxy for the relative velocity between particles and dust in eq .
( 7 ) ] , @xmath124 ( oct )
. the importance of @xmath9 will become more evident in calculations that allow for the development of a disk dead zone , the nearly - laminar region of low viscous stresses mentioned in section 1 that results from non - ideal mhd effects .
the degree of coupling of magnetic fields to the disk gas will determine whether the flow is susceptible to the mri .
magnetically - active regions , which are ionized by stellar x - rays or interstellar cosmic rays , will be in a turbulent state , whereas dense zones in which recombination processes are fast , such as the disk interior , will be quiescent . however , minimum - mass solar nebula models with time - dependent gas ionization chemistry ( e.g. turner et al .
2007 ) show that ionized gas can reach the disk interior through turbulent mixing and , under certain conditions , this will allow a weak coupling to magnetic fields and an increase in turbulent intensity .
the assumption of a wholly turbulent disk used in this work relies on such results , as well as on the fact that electron fractions as low as @xmath125 can render the flow unstable to the mri ( balbus 2009 ) . in any case
, a marked vertical gradient of turbulent activity is expected at some point .
variable - ohmic - resistivity calculations by turner et al .
( 2007 ) yield mean magnetic stresses that are 20 times larger in the upper layers than at the midplane , at an orbital radius of 1 au .
a variation by a factor of 100 is found at 5 au .
the original computations of dead zone evolution in a shearing box ( fleming and stone 2003 ) obtained @xmath126 at the midplane and @xmath127 at heights @xmath128=2@xmath21 .
based on these figures , the work of oct is likely to describe conditions inside a solar nebula dead zone , which may have a limited lifetime . increasing turbulent activity that originates at the top and bottom layers of the nebula can augment @xmath9 close to the midplane by a factor of @xmath1 37 ( turner et al . 2007 ) .
the well - documented linear relation between dust rim thickness and chondrule radius is evident at the end of run d ( fig .
9 , _ black circles _ ) and e ( _ asterisks _ and _ squares _ , which correspond to miplane and upper - layer chondrules , respectively ) .
data from disaggregated rimmed chondrules in cv chondrites ( paque & cuzzi 1997 , _ triangles _ ) are shown for comparison .
the straight line has a slope of unity .
the scatter in the disaggregation data reflects the range of values that can be measured in real chondrites .
the linear trend derived from runs d and e would need to be verified , once again , with the inclusion of shattering processes that may produce a realistic scatter of rim thicknesses .
it is worthwhile noting that trigo - rodrguez et al . (
2006 ) found only a modest correlation between dust rim thickness and size of the enclosed core in cm chondrites .
the separation of chondrules into two distinct populations in run e , according to their initial vertical position @xmath19 ( 0 or 2.3@xmath21 ) , served the purpose of making a dynamical comparison between chondrules formed in the disk interior and those that could have been dumped in the upper layers after an x - wind carried them from the nebular x region .
however , the very formation of chondrules at the x point has been called into question due to dynamical and thermal inconsistencies within the x - wind model ( desch et al .
it is therefore important to bear in mind that a population of dust - rimming chondrules deposited high up in the solar nebula may not come about easily .
in this work , accretion of dust by chondrule - sized particles is modeled using a mhd representation of a turbulent solar nebula .
mhd processes are a viable mechanism to produce and sustain turbulent viscosity in protoplanetary disks , and the dynamical evolution of the ionized gas in the solar nebula must depend crucially on its ability to couple to different magnetic field configurations .
relative velocities between chondrules and micron - sized dust grains can be excited by several sources , and here we focused on the effect imparted by mri turbulence and vertical settling due to stellar gravity , in a local neighborhood of the nebula .
an important parameter in determining the rate of depletion of dust due to sweep - up by chondrules is the latter s volume density .
the mhd simulations show that chondrules accrete dust mostly within @xmath1 1 scale - height ( @xmath21 ) of the nebula midplane , since the growth of dust rims decreases aerodynamic coupling of particles to the gas , and increases their response to vertical gravity .
time scales to deplete dust to 1% of its initial abundance vary from 10 to @xmath1 800 years , roughly the same times in which chondrules reach their mass - averaged , asymptotic radius .
if the sticking efficiency of dust to chondrules is below @xmath12 , the growth time scale could be @xmath16 years .
low sticking eficiencies ( i.e. , very little dust rim growth ) can be common due to very high , mri driven , turbulent relative velocities between chondrules and dust .
vertical stratification of the nebular gas density allows to compare the dust rimming process at different nebula heights , and this has been done by initially placing one chondrule population at the nebula midplane and another population at a height of 2.3@xmath21 .
the growth rate of dust rims in these two cases is very similar , at least for the first 300 years of evolution , with the midplane population having a mass averaged radius @xmath1 1 % larger than the upper layer population during the course of the numerical run .
size distributions of rimmed chondrules obtained from the mhd simulations could be used for comparison with data from actual chondrites .
the aerodynamic properties of chondrules suspended in nebular gas are reasonably well understood , and such comparison would provide further insight into the mhd conditions in the primitive solar nebula . in particular , the level of turbulence , and hence the ionization state of the gas , could be constrained .
sweep - up of dust by chondrules is likely to influence the evolution of a laminar dead zone in the solar nebula .
future mhd calculations should incorporate explicit ionization processes ( such as those due to stellar x - rays and radionuclide decay ) to obtain a more complete , layered flow structure in which chondrule rimming at different locations can be characterized .
the vertical variation of turbulent intensity and dust abundance leads to a modest dependence of rimmed - chondrule size on disk height .
whether this variation could be imprinted and identified on the meteoritic record will require further analysis to account for processes such as fragmentation and compaction of dust structures .
compaction of initially fractal dust aggregates can result from collisions , and compact dust rims can play a role in the sticking between rimmed chondrules .
monte carlo ( mc ) methods ( oct , zsom and dullemond 2008 ) provide a robust procedure to investigate coagulation of chondrule compounds , since they treat interactions _ between _ dust
rimmed chondrules , providing an extension to the present work .
these codes take as one of their inputs particle particle relative velocities @xmath51 , which could be taken directly from a mhd simulation ( e.g. , by measuring @xmath51 between lagrangian particles located inside an eulerian grid cell , as in carballido et al .
although a mc code does not resolve the spatial structure of the protoplanetary disk , it contains all the physics of particle particle collisions . on the other hand
, the mhd run provides the spatial structure of the nebula plus position
dependent relative velocities , which can be plugged back into the mc code to provide self
consistency to rimmed chondrule chondrule collisions .
furthermore , if non
ideal mhd effects are allowed for ( e.g. , a dead zone ) , the growth of chondrule compounds in both turbulent and nearly laminar regions could be characterized and related to the time and space dependent ionization state of the gas , which may be useful in chemical studies of chondrule compounds .
the use of larger shearing boxes now allows to study locations of protoplanetary disks that reach up to 30 scale heights in radial extent ( stone and gardiner 2010 ) .
thus , in addition to turbulence and vertical settling , the contribution of radial drift to relative velocities between chondrules and dust could be incorporated self - consistently in a mhd - monte carlo numerical scheme .
the combination of these two techniques is likely to set the nebular origin of dust mantles on a stronger footing .
i am grateful to jeffrey cuzzi for comments and suggestions on an early version of this manuscript .
data from chondrule disaggregation work were kindly provided by julie paque and jeffrey cuzzi .
valuable remarks by the referees , chris ormel and fred ciesla , greatly improved the contents and structure of the paper .
this work was supported by dgapa at unam .
cuzzi , j. n. , hogan , r. c. , paque , j. m. , dobrovolskis , a. r. , 2001 . size - selective concentration of chondrules and other small particles in protoplanetary nebula turbulence .
j. 546 , 496508 .
cuzzi , j. n. , weidenschilling , s. j. , 2006 .
particle - gas dynamics and primary accretion . in : lauretta , d. s. , mcsween jr . ,
h. y. ( eds . ) , meteorites and the early solar system ii .
the university of arizona press , tucson , pp .
353381 .
gttler , c. , blum , j. , zsom , a. , ormel , c. w. , dullemond , c. p. , 2010 . the outcome of protoplanetary dust growth : pebbles , boulders , or planetesimals ?
i. mapping the zoo of laboratory collision experiments .
. astrophys .
513 , a56 .
krot , a. n. , nagashima , k. , ciesla , f. j. , meyer , b. s. , hutcheon , i. d. , davis , a. m. , huss , g. r. , scott , e. r. d. , 2010 .
oxygen isotopic composition of the sun and mean oxygen isotopic composition of the protosolar silicate dust : evidence from refractory inclusions .
j. 713 , 11591166 .
shu , f. h. , najita , j. r. , shang , h. , li , z .- y . , 2000 .
x - winds : theory and observations . in : mannings , v. , boss , a. p. , russell , s. s. ( eds . ) , protostars and planets iv .
the university of arizona press , tucson , pp .
789813 . stone , j. m. , norman , m. l. , 1992a .
zeus-2d : a radiation magnetohydrodynamics code for astrophysical flows in two space dimensions
. i. the hydrodynamic algorithms and tests . astrophys .
80 , 753790 . stone , j. m. , norman , m. l. , 1992b .
zeus-2d : a radiation magnetohydrodynamics code for astrophysical flows in two space dimensions .
ii . the magnetohydrodynamic algorithms and tests .
80 , 791818 .
zsom , a. , ormel , c. w. , gttler , c. , blum , j. , dullemond , c. p. , 2010
, the outcome of protoplanetary dust growth : pebbles , boulders , or planetesimals ? ii . introducing the bouncing barrier .
513 , a57 . | numerical magnetohydrodynamic ( mhd ) simulations of a turbulent solar nebula are used to study the growth of dust mantles swept up by chondrules .
a small neighborhood of the solar nebula is represented by an orbiting patch of gas at a radius of 3 au , and includes vertical stratification of the gas density .
the differential rotation of the nebular gas is replaced by a shear flow .
turbulence is driven by destabilization of the flow as a result of the magnetorotational instability ( mri ) , whereby magnetic field lines anchored to the gas are continuously stretched by the shearing motion .
a passive contaminant mimics small dust grains that are aerodynamically well coupled to the gas , and chondrules are modeled by lagrangian particles that interact with the gas through drag .
whenever a chondrule enters a region permeated by dust , its radius grows at a rate that depends on the local dust density and the relative velocity between itself and the dust .
the local dust abundance decreases accordingly .
compaction and fragmentation of dust aggregates are not included .
different chondrule volume densities @xmath0 lead to varying depletion and rimmed - chondrule size growth times .
most of the dust sweep up occurs within @xmath1 1 gas scale height of the nebula midplane .
chondrules can reach their asymptotic radius in 10 to 800 years , although short growth times due to very high @xmath0 may not be altogether realistic .
if the sticking effiency @xmath2 of dust to chondrules depends on their relative speed @xmath3 , such that @xmath4 whenever @xmath5 34 cm / s ( with @xmath6 a critical sticking velocity ) , then longer growth times result due to the prevalence of high mri turbulent relative velocities .
the vertical variation of nebula turbulent intensity results in a moderate dependence of mean rimmed - chondrule size with nebula height , and in a @xmath120% dispersion in radius values at every height bin .
the technique used here could be combined with monte carlo ( mc ) methods that include the physics of dust compaction , in a self - consistent mhd - mc model of dust rim growth around chondrules in the solar nebula .
origin , solar system ; disks ; meteorites ; planetary formation |
among special functions , the hypergeometric function has perhaps the widest range of applications . for instance , several well - known classes of mathematical physics are particular or limiting cases of it . for real numbers @xmath4 and @xmath5 with @xmath6 , the gaussian hypergeometric function is defined by [ eq1.1 ] f(a , b;c;x ) : = _ 2 f_1(a , b;c;x)= _ n=0^ for @xmath7 , where @xmath8 for @xmath9 , and @xmath10 for @xmath11 . for many rational triples
@xmath12 the function can be expressed in terms of elementary functions and long lists of such particular cases are given in @xcite .
it is clear that small changes of the parameters @xmath13 will have small influence on the value of @xmath14 . in this paper
we shall study to what extent some well - known properties of the complete elliptic integral of the first kind [ eq1.2 ] ( x ) f ( , ; 1;x^2 ) = _ 0^/2(1-x^2 ^ 2t)^-1/2dt , x ( 0,1 ) , can be extended to @xmath15 for @xmath16 close to @xmath17 . recall that @xmath18 is called _ zero - balanced _ if @xmath19 .
in the zero - balanced case , there is a logarithmic singularity at @xmath20 and gauss proved the asymptotic formula [ eq1.3 ] f(a , b;a+b;r)~- ( 1-r ) as @xmath21 tends to @xmath22 , where [ eq1.4 ] b(z , w ) , re z>0 , re w>0 is the classical beta function .
note that @xmath23 and @xmath24 see ( ( * ? ? ?
6 ) ) . ramanujan found a much sharper asymptotic formula [ eq1.5 ] b(a , b)f(a , b;a+b;r)+(1-r)=r(a , b)+o((1-r)(1-r ) ) as @xmath21 tends to @xmath22 ( see also @xcite . ) here and in the sequel , [ eq1.6 ] \ { rl r(a , b ) & -(a)-(b)-2 , r(1 / 2 , 1 / 2 ) = 16 , + ( z ) & re z>0 , + . and @xmath25 is the euler - mascheroni constant .
ramanujan s formula ( [ eq1.5 ] ) is a particular case of another well - known formula given in ( @xcite ) .
we shall use in the sequel the following assertion which is a mixture of biernacki - krzyz and related results on the ratio of formal power series ( @xcite,@xcite ) .
[ l1 ] suppose that the power series @xmath26 and @xmath27 have the radius of convergence @xmath28 and @xmath29 for all @xmath30 .
denote also @xmath31 \1 .
if the sequence @xmath32 is monotone increasing then @xmath33 is also monotone increasing on @xmath34 .
if the sequence @xmath32 is monotone decreasing then @xmath33 is also monotone decreasing on @xmath34 .
if the sequence @xmath35 is monotone increasing ( decreasing ) for @xmath36 and monotone decreasing ( increasing ) for @xmath37 , then there exists @xmath38 such that @xmath33 is increasing ( decreasing ) on @xmath39 and decreasing ( increasing ) on @xmath40 .
some of the most important properties of the elliptic integral @xmath41 are the landen identities @xcite : [ eq1.7 ] ( ) = ( 1+r)(r),()=(r ) , where @xmath42 in @xcite , the following problem was raised : [ prob1.8 ] find an analog of landen s transformation formulas in ( [ eq1.7 ] ) for @xmath43 .
in particular , if @xmath44 and @xmath45 , is it true that @xmath46 for some constant @xmath47 and all @xmath48 ?
since @xmath49 for @xmath50 , @xmath47 must be greater than 1 . in @xcite and ( * ? ? ? * theorem 1.4 ) gauss asymptotic formula @xmath51 was refined by finding the lower and upper bounds for @xmath52 when @xmath45 or @xmath53 .
our second result gives a full solution to the open problem [ prob1.8 ] .
we wish to point out that in ( * ? ? ?
* thm 1.2(1 ) ) it was claimed that for @xmath54 the function @xmath55 is increasing in @xmath56 . as pointed out by a. baricz @xcite the proof contains a gap and the correct proof will be given here .
we also found another area in @xmath2 plane where the function @xmath57 is monotone decreasing in @xmath58 .
our first result shows that landen inequalities hold not only in the neighborhood of the point @xmath59 but also in some unbounded parts of @xmath2 plane .
[ s1thm ] for all @xmath60 with @xmath61 we have that the inequality @xmath62 holds for each @xmath58 . also , for @xmath63 , the reversed inequality @xmath64 takes place for each @xmath50 . in the remaining region
@xmath65 neither of the above inequalities hold for each @xmath66 .
the disjoint regions in @xmath2 plane @xmath67 and @xmath68 , where landen inequalities hold , are shown on the figure [ lifig ]
. visualized .
[ lifig ] ] the only common point of the graphs in figure [ lifig ] is @xmath69 where equality sign holds .
two - sided bounds for the ratio of target functions are also possible .
[ t1 ] for each @xmath50 and @xmath70 , we have @xmath71 for @xmath72 the inequalities are reversed , @xmath73 some numerical estimations of the constant @xmath47 in open problem [ prob1.8 ] follows .
let @xmath74 be defined as in the open problem [ prob1.8 ] .
then , for each @xmath58 and @xmath70 , we have @xmath75 in the region @xmath76 we have @xmath77 two - sided bounds for the difference exist in a smaller region @xmath78 ( see the picture ) , where @xmath79 and in @xmath76 .
[ t2 ] let @xmath80 be the classical beta function and @xmath81 be defined by [ eq1.6 ] . for @xmath82 , we have @xmath83 if @xmath84 , then @xmath85 the second landen identity has the following counterpart for hypergeometric functions .
the resulting inequalities might be called landen inequalities for zero - balanched hypergeometric functions .
[ t3 ] let @xmath86 . for @xmath70 and each @xmath3
, we have @xmath87 if @xmath88 , then @xmath89.\ ] ] for @xmath72 , we have @xmath90 and @xmath91
throughout this section we denote @xmath92 where @xmath93 are fixed positive parameters and @xmath94 with the regions @xmath95 defined as above . since @xmath118
, it follows that both @xmath119 are non - positive .
therefore @xmath120 because both constants can not be zero simultaneously . by lemma [ l1 ]
, we conclude that the function @xmath121 is monotone decreasing in @xmath66 .
\4 . if @xmath72 , i.e. , @xmath84 , then @xmath122 , hence @xmath123 .
also @xmath124 . therefore @xmath125 and @xmath126 .
as above , we conclude that @xmath112 and @xmath121 is monotone increasing in this case .
it is easily seen by that in the remaining region the sequence @xmath101 decreases and then increases . by lemma [ l1 ] , part 3 , this means that the function @xmath109 , for some @xmath133 , decreases in @xmath134 and increases in @xmath135 .
therefore , putting @xmath136 and @xmath137 , one concludes that neither of given inequalities hold for each @xmath50 . : _ ramanujan and hypergeometric and basic hypergeometric series _ , ramanujan internat .
symposium on analysis , december 2628 , 1987 , ed . by n.
k. thakare , 183 , pune , india , russian math .
surveys 451 ( 1990 ) , 3786 . | for zero - balanced gaussian hypergeometric functions @xmath0 @xmath1 we determine maximal regions of @xmath2 plane where well - known landen identities for the complete elliptic integral of the first kind turn on respective inequalities valid for each @xmath3 . thereby an exhausting answer is given to the open problem from @xcite .
keywords .
log - convexity ; hypergeometric functions ; inequalities . 2010 mathematics subject classification . |
massive stars are ubiquitous in many star - forming regions , and their feedback processes have significant impacts on the surrounding interstellar medium ( ism ) .
uv / fuv radiation photoionizes / photodissociates molecular gas , and the h ii and photodissociation regions ( pdr ) expand around the massive star .
the stellar winds and supernovae explosions give rise to expanding bubbles in ism .
the role of these feedback processes in relation to ism has been studied from two competing perspectives on their effects on star - formation activity .
the expanding h ii region and bubble erode the parental molecular clouds and suppress star formation ( _ negative feedback _ ) . on the other hand ,
the shock front ( sf ) emerges as the high - pressure region expands .
the sf compresses the ism and star formation can be triggered in very dense layers ( _ positive feedback _ ) . in this paper , we focus on the h ii regions and their feedback processes .
the role of the expanding h ii regions is also discussed in terms of negative and positive feedback processes .
most of the massive stars are born in the giant molecular clouds ( gmcs ) and h ii regions begin to expand in the dense cores and clumps in gmcs ( ultra compact h ii regions , e.g. , * ? ? ?
as the h ii region expands , the molecular gas is gradually eroded . when the if reaches the cloud surface , the ionized gas spouts from the cloud ( `` champagne flow '' , see tenorio - tagle 1979 ) .
the molecular material around massive stars is dispersed , so that star formation is quenched ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . on the other hand
, the sf emerges in front of the if owing to the pressure excess of the h ii region .
the sf sweeps up the ism to form a shell and star formation will be induced by the instability of the shell .
the sf also compresses pre - existing globules through their photoevaporation and star formation will be triggered ( radiative implosion ; see , e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the hydrodynamical expansion of the h ii regions has been studied numerically ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
these efforts have successfully shown the various dynamical aspects of the expansion in both homogeneous and inhomogeneous ambient media .
however , these do not include the outer pdr and thermal processes that should be dominant there .
@xcite have analytically shown that the dissociation fronts ( dfs ) initially expand outside the sf , but finally slow down to be taken into the shell . @xcite and @xcite studied the expansion of the h ii region and outer pdr around a single massive star , solving the radiative transfer of uv and fuv photons .
although the hydrodynamics has not been included , they have shown that a significant amount of the molecular gas is not ionized but photodissociated . @xcite
have pointed out that the photodissociation of the molecular gas reduces the star - forming capacity of the cloud @xcite have provided a good simple example to investigate the role of the expanding h ii region .
they have observed the molecular fragments around the galactic h ii region , sharpless 104 ( sh104 ) , and found a young cluster within the core of one fragment .
they have argued that this is clear evidence of the `` collect and collapse '' model . in our previous paper ( * ? ? ? * hereafter , paper i ) , we have modeled sh104 performing the hydrodynamical calculation including the pdr and the swept - up shell as well as the h ii region .
our calculation has shown that the molecular shell forms around the h ii region shielding the fuv radiation .
the abundance of the accumulated molecules shows excellent agreement with the observation .
we have also suggested a role for the expanding h ii regions as a positive feedback process .
the swept - up mass remains in the shell and the shell can be dominated by the cold molecular gas shielding uv and fuv photons .
recently , @xcite have reported dozens of galactic h ii regions similar to sh104 , which show that such triggering is a common process in some situations .
so , the next interesting questions to answer are the following : * how does the time evolution change with differing ambient number density and mass of the central star ?
is the molecular gas always accumulated in the shell ?
if the evolution change with a different ambient density or central star , why so ? to answer these questions , we investigate the time evolution of the h ii region , pdr , and the swept - up shell with various ambient number densities and central stars . as in paper
i , the uv- and fuv - radiative transfer and the thermal and chemical processes are solved using a time - dependent hydrodynamics code .
we show the numerical results of some representative models and explain what causes the differences among models .
we can show that , in many cases , the fuv photons are shielded and the molecular gas is finally gathered in the shell .
the organization of this paper is as follows : in 2 , we explain the input physics of our code .
the subsequent 3 is devoted to showing the procedures of the numerical calculation .
4 and 5 are the main part of this paper , where the numerical results are shown .
the dependence on the ambient number density , and on the luminosity ( mass ) of the central star is studied in each section . 6 and 7 are assigned to discussions and conclusions .
in this paper , we consider the spherical expansion of the h ii region .
the hydrodynamic equations of the system are written as , @xmath1 @xmath2 @xmath3 @xmath4 @xmath5 where @xmath6 is the mass coordinate defined as @xmath7 , @xmath8 is the mass density , @xmath9 is the number density of the hydrogen nucleon , @xmath10 is the velocity , @xmath11 is the gas pressure , and @xmath12 is the total energy , including the kinetic energy ( @xmath13 ) and the thermal energy ( @xmath14 ) per unit mass .
we adopt @xmath15 for simplicity . in the above equations , @xmath16 @xmath17 is the number ratio defined as @xmath18 @xmath19 , and @xmath20 is the abundance of he atoms . in the energy equation ,
@xmath21 and @xmath22 represent the heating and cooling rates per hydrogen nucleon , and @xmath23 is the heat transfer by thermal conduction .
we include 5 heating processes and 12 cooling processes to calculate @xmath21 and @xmath22 ( see [ ssec : thm ] ) .
the thermal conduction is needed to satisfy the `` field condition '' ( see appendix [ sec : field ] ) .
we do not include the self - gravity of the gas to study the simple situation of the hii region expanding into a homogeneous medium . even if we include the gas self - gravity , the h ii region quickly expands at the velocity of @xmath24 , and the smaller inward velocity caused by the self - gravity does not significantly affect our results .
the gravity of the central star does not affect the evolution of h ii regions , unless the h ii region is very small .
the radius where the velocity of escape from the star is comparable to the sound speed of the h ii region is @xmath25 , where @xmath26 is the stellar mass .
this is much smaller than the initial strmgren radius , @xmath27 with the number density considered in this paper , @xmath28 .
the procedure to calculate a whole set of equations is explained in [ ssec : outline ] .
[ tb : phrate ] table 1 .
properties of massive stars with solar metallicity @xcite + [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] a : mass of the central star , b : number density of the ambient gas , c : initial strmgren radius , d : dynamical time , @xmath29 , where @xmath30 is the sound speed at @xmath31 k. e : our model for sh104 ( paper i ) .
in this section , we show how the time evolution of the h ii region , pdr , and the swept - up shell changes with different ambient number densities . for comparison ,
we calculate the expansion of the h ii region around the @xmath32 star , which is the central star of sh104 modeled in paper i , but with different ambient number densities .
as we have adopted the ambient number density of @xmath33 in paper i , we show the results of the higher density case , @xmath34 and the lower density case , @xmath35 below .
the initial strmgren radius and the dynamical time for the calculated models are listed in table 4 .
all the other conditions are the same as those in our model of sh104 ( s41 in table 4 ) except for the number density .
first , we show some scaling relations that are very useful to interpret the numerical results .
the initial strmgren radius depends on the ambient number density , and other relevant quantities are also scaled as , @xmath36 @xmath37 @xmath38 @xmath39 @xmath40 where @xmath41 and @xmath42 is the mass and the column density of the shell , @xmath43 is the incident fuv flux at the if at a given @xmath44 . to derive the above relations
, we assume that most of the swept - up gas remains in the shell , which is a good approximation for expansion in a homogeneous ambient medium . as
( [ eq : rst_nsc ] ) and ( [ eq : tdy_nsc ] ) show , the larger h ii region expands in the lower density ambient medium over a longer timescale .
equation ( [ eq : msh_nsc ] ) shows that the swept - up mass is larger with the lower density medium .
the shell structure is mainly determined by the column density of the shell , @xmath42 and the fuv flux at the if , @xmath43 .
the detailed properties of the shell are explained with equation ( [ eq : sig_nsc ] ) and ( [ eq : jfuvi_nsc ] ) in [ ssec : rlt_n ] .
figures [ fig : hev_5000 ] and [ fig : hev_50 ] show the hydrodynamical evolution of models hd - s41 and ld - s41 respectively .
since the strmgren radius is smaller for the higher ambient density , the h ii region expands to the region of @xmath45 pc in hd - s41 , and @xmath46 pc in model ld - s41 in @xmath47 .
as expected with equation ( [ eq : tdy_nsc ] ) , the timescale of the evolution is longer for the lower density model .
the time of @xmath48 corresponds to @xmath49 myr for hd - s41 , and @xmath50 myr for model ld - s41 .
the basic time evolution is the same as that of model s41 ( paper i ) .
the sf emerges when the if reaches the initial strmgren radius .
the gas density within the shell is about 10 - 100 times as high as that of the ambient medium , though the detailed structure of the shell differs between hd - s41 and ld - s41 ( explained below ) .
the time evolution after the sf emerges is also similar to that of model s41 .
the time evolution of the radial expansion is well approximated with , @xmath51 which is derived from the equation of motion of the shell , @xmath52 where @xmath53 is the mass density of the ambient medium , and @xmath54 is the gas pressure in the h ii region .
equation ( [ eq : exlaw ] ) is different from the well - known expansion law ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) by a factor of @xmath55 , but shows better agreement with the numerical results . as equation ( [ eq : eomshell ] ) shows , equation ( [ eq : exlaw ] ) does not involve the detailed structure and the chemical composition of the shell , which we analyze with our numerical calculations . the swept - up mass in the shell is larger for the lower ambient number density , as equation ( [ eq : msh_nsc ] ) shows . for example , @xmath56 in model ld - s41 and @xmath57 in model hd - s41 at @xmath47 respectively .
the upper panels of fig.[fig : fev_5000 ] and [ fig : fev_50 ] show the time evolution of various front positions . initially , the dfs expand more rapidly than the sf and the if , then the pdr appears in front of the sf .
as the h ii region expands , the if and the sf gradually overtake the preceding dfs of h@xmath58 and co in turn . finally the dfs are taken up into the shell .
the sf enters the molecular region , and the molecular gas is accumulated within the shell .
the rapid reformation within the shell also helps to accelerate the accumulation of the molecular gas .
the main difference among these models is the time ( or @xmath44 ) when the dfs are taken into the shell . in the higher density model , hd - s41 , the if and the sf catch up with both dfs of h@xmath58 and co by the time of @xmath59 . in the lower density model , ld - s41 , the df of h@xmath58 is quickly taken into the shell , but the accumulation of co molecules is delayed .
the df of co is taken into the shell at @xmath60 in model ld - s41 .
about 70% ( 90% ) of carbon ( hydrogen ) atoms within the shell exist as co ( h@xmath58 ) molecules in model hd - s41 at @xmath47 , but 20% ( 90% ) in model ld - s41 at the same time step .
we explain the reasons for this difference below . with the higher ambient number density ,
the incident fuv flux at the if is strong , as equation ( [ eq : jfuvi_nsc ] ) shows .
although the fuv photons are available to photodissociate molecules , our calculation shows that the fuv photons are quickly shielded in model hd - s41 .
this is because the column density of the shell , @xmath42 is larger for the higher density model , as equation ( [ eq : sig_nsc ] ) shows .
fig.[fig : dscale_schem ] is a schematic picture showing the density - dependence of @xmath42 and @xmath43 .
the incident fuv flux is attenuated enough by the dust extinction through the shell , and the molecular gas is reliably protected in the outer part of the shell . though the density - dependence of @xmath42 , @xmath61 , is weaker than that of @xmath43 , @xmath62 , the dust absorption becomes significant with a high number density owing to the attenuation law of @xmath63 .
the lower panels of fig.[fig : fev_5000 ] shows the time evolution of the column density of each region in model hd - s41 .
the column density of the shell at @xmath64 is already @xmath65 ( @xmath66 ) in this model . in model
ld - s41 , on the other hand , the incident fuv flux is weak , but the column density of the shell is low . since the co molecules are mainly shielded by the dust absorption , it is not until @xmath42 becomes somewhat large ( @xmath67 ) that co molecules are accumulated in the shell .
however , even in the early phase when @xmath68 , h@xmath58 molecules can be quickly accumulated in the shell , as fig.[fig : fev_50 ] shows .
this is due to the efficient self - shielding of h@xmath58 molecules .
@xcite have briefly shown that h@xmath58 molecules can be self - shielded , if @xmath69 at the if . in our calculations , @xmath70 in model ld - s41 and @xmath71 in model hd - s41 at @xmath64 .
therefore , h@xmath58 molecules are mainly self - shielded in model ld - s41 , and shielded by the dust in model hd - s41 respectively . the self - shielding effect for co molecules
is not so efficient , owing to the small abundance of carbon atoms .
the detailed structure of the shell differs significantly among these models .
fig.[fig : over_5000 ] ( fig.[fig : over_50 ] ) shows the detailed structure of the density and the temperature within the shell at @xmath72 in model hd - s41 ( ld - s41 ) .
these figures show that the gas temperature in the inner region of the shell is higher in the model with the higher ambient density ; @xmath73 k in model hd - s41 and @xmath74 k in model ld - s41 .
this is because the fuv flux at the if , @xmath43 is larger for the higher ambient density owing to the smaller strmgren radius ( see eq.([eq : jfuvi_nsc ] ) ) .
the fuv radiation field , @xmath75 defined by eq.([eq : fuvg ] ) at the if is @xmath76 in ld - s41 and @xmath77 in hd - s41 at the time step of both figures , @xmath72 . within the shell
, the temperature has a negative gradient and the density has a positive gradient , which is similar to model s41 ( paper i ) .
figs.[fig : over_5000 ] and [ fig : over_50 ] show that the changes in gas temperature and density are milder in model ld - s41 .
the gas temperature decreases from 500 k to 25 k through the shell in model hd - s41 and from 50 k to 25 k in model ld - s41 .
these differences are also explained in equation ( [ eq : sig_nsc ] ) and ( [ eq : jfuvi_nsc ] ) . in model hd - s41 ,
the fuv flux is strong and the column density is high .
the intense fuv radiation is shielded by the shell with the large column density . in model
ld - s41 , the incident fuv flux at the if is relatively weak and the column density of the shell is low . the gas temperature within the shell is lower and nearly constant .
the fuv flux is attenuated from @xmath78 to 0.1 through the shell in hd - s41 , and from @xmath76 to 1.5 in ld - s41 at the time of fig.[fig : over_5000 ] and [ fig : over_50 ] . in model hd - s41
, the gas temperature significantly decreases toward the outer part of the shell , because the photoelectric heating becomes inefficient .
conversely , the gas density of the outer region of the shell rises to @xmath79 .
the collisional heat transfer between the gas and dust is efficient there , and the gas temperature is almost equal to the dust temperature .
the the swept - up shell is geometrically thicker in model hd - s41 .
figs.[fig : over_5000 ] and [ fig : over_50 ] also show that the density jump at the if is larger with the lower ambient density .
this can be explained by the analytic jump condition at the weak d - type if , @xmath80 @xcite , where @xmath81 and @xmath82 are the sound speed ahead and behind the if , and @xmath83 is the quantity less than unity . since the temperature @xmath84 is lower for the lower ambient density , the density at the inner edge of the shell is higher in model ld - s41 .
it is important to know whether or not the swept - up molecular layer fragments , as the triggered star formation scenario predicts .
we do not consider the dynamical instability , but only the gravitational instability for the fragmentation of the shell , as discussed in paper i. in the lower panels of figs.[fig : fev_5000 ] and [ fig : fev_50 ] , the shaded region is the expected unstable region , where @xmath85 . the swept - up shell in each model is expected to suffer from gravitational instability .
the unstable region spreads from the outer edge of the shell , which is the same as in model s41 ( paper i ) . in model hd - s41
, the density is relatively low in the inner part of the shell .
the unstable region appears at @xmath86 myr ( @xmath87 ) and gradually extends from the cold molecular layer , as fig.[fig : fev_5000 ] shows . as explained in the previous subsection , both h@xmath58 and co molecules are shielded by the dust , and the shell is dominated by these molecules when the shell becomes unstable . in model ld - s41 ,
the swept - up shell is relatively cold and dense ( see fig.[fig : over_50 ] ) .
the unstable region rapidly spreads in the whole shell at @xmath88 myr ( @xmath89 ) . in this model ,
the shell is dominated by h@xmath58 molecules due to the efficient self - shielding effect by the time of the shell - fragmentation . however , the column density of the shell is still not high enough to protect co molecules by the dust extinction in the early expansion phase .
the accumulation of co molecules begins after the shell becomes unstable , which is different from model hd - s41 .
regardless of some differences , the expanding h ii region can sweep up the molecular gas , and the fragmentation of the shell is finally expected with different number densities .
the star formation will be triggered in the fragmented shell along the lines of a `` collect and collapse '' scenario .
in this section , we investigate how the time evolution of the h ii region , pdr , and the shell depends on the uv / fuv luminosity ( mass ) of the central star . for this purpose , we calculate the expansion around the central star of @xmath90 , @xmath91 and @xmath92 as representative cases .
we use the same ambient number density , @xmath93 , as in model s41 ( paper i ) .
model parameters of these calculated models are listed in table 4 .
the less massive central star has smaller uv and fuv luminosities , but a large luminosity ratio , @xmath94 ( see table 1 ) .
the strmgren radius depends on the uv photon number luminosity , @xmath95 , as well as the number density , so that other relevant quantities also depend on @xmath95 .
the scaling relations which are similar to equation ( [ eq : rst_nsc ] ) ( [ eq : jfuvi_nsc ] ) are derived as , @xmath96 @xmath97 @xmath98 @xmath99 @xmath100 where @xmath41 , @xmath42 , and @xmath43 are the quantities at a given @xmath44 . as equation ( [ eq : rst_ssc ] ) and ( [ eq : tdy_ssc ] ) show
, the h ii region expands into the larger region on a longer timescale , as the mass of the central star increases . the fuv flux at the if , @xmath43 depends on both the luminosity ratio , @xmath94 and the fuv luminosity , @xmath101 .
since the dependence on the luminosity ratio is stronger than that on the fuv luminosity , the fuv flux , @xmath43 becomes larger for the lower mass central star .
the calculated shell structure reflects the column density , @xmath42 ( eq.([eq : sig_ssc ] ) ) and the fuv flux at the if , @xmath43 , ( eq.([eq : jfuvi_ssc ] ) ) which is explained in
[ ssec : rlt_s ] .
figs.[fig : hev_s1 ] , [ fig : hev_s5 ] , and [ fig : hev_s8 ] show the hydrodynamical evolution of models s101 , s19 , and s12 respectively .
the basic time evolution features are similar among these models .
when the if reaches the initial strmgren radius , the sf emerges in front of the if
. in all these models , the h ii region expands into the region of @xmath102 pc over a timescale of @xmath45 myr .
however , the time normalized with @xmath103 differs considerably among these models , because @xmath103 decreases as the uv luminosity decreases ( eq .
( [ eq : tdy_ssc ] ) ) .
for example , the time of 1 myr corresponds to @xmath104 in model s101 , @xmath105 in model s19 , and @xmath106 in model s12 .
figs.[fig : hev_s1 ] - [ fig : hev_s8 ] all show that the pdr initially appears in front of the sf and is finally taken into the shell over a timescale of @xmath107 myr ; such evolution is largely different in terms of time normalized with @xmath103 .
these differences are explained using equations ( [ eq : sig_ssc ] ) and ( [ eq : jfuvi_ssc ] ) .
as equation ( [ eq : jfuvi_ssc ] ) shows , the fuv flux at the if at a given @xmath44 , @xmath108 is larger with the less massive star .
conversely , the column density of the shell , @xmath42 is smaller for the less massive star , shown in equation ( [ eq : sig_ssc ] ) . at @xmath109 , for example ,
@xmath110 at the if and @xmath111 in model s19 , and @xmath112 and @xmath113 in model s12
. therefore , the strong fuv radiation is not shielded , and the reformed molecules are easily photodissociated .
fig.[fig : sscale_schem ] is the schematic picture showing the luminosity - dependence of @xmath42 and @xmath43 .
the accumulation of molecular gas in the shell is significantly delayed on @xmath114 .
the upper panels of figs.[fig : fev_s1 ] - [ fig : fev_s8 ] show the time evolution of the various front positions in each model .
both dfs of h@xmath58 and co molecules are taken into the shell by the time of @xmath115 in model s101 , @xmath116 in model s19 , and @xmath117 in model s12 .
the times of the front overtaking are totally different at @xmath44 , but these times differ only by a factor of a few at time @xmath118 ; @xmath119 myr in model s101 , @xmath120 myr in model s19 , and @xmath121 myr in model s12 .
eventually , sufficient molecular gas always gathers in the outer region of the shell in a few myrs with the ambient number density of @xmath93 .
the total mass of the swept - up shell ( between the if and the sf ) is @xmath122 , @xmath123 , and @xmath124 in models s101 , s19 , and s12 respectively at the final time step of figs.[fig : fev_s1 ] - [ fig : fev_s8 ] . at that time step ,
more than 85% of hydrogen atoms are included in h@xmath58 molecules in all models .
the fraction of co molecules is 55% , 40% , and 20% in each respective model .
the upper panel of fig.[fig : star_dep ] shows the time evolution of the maximum density of the shell in models s101 , s41 , s19 and s12 .
as this figure shows , the swept - up shell is always denser with the more massive central star .
this is explained with the time evolution of the velocity of the shell .
the expansion of the h ii region approximately follows equation ( [ eq : exlaw ] ) , and the expansion velocity decreases as , @xmath125 because the gas pressure of the h ii region decreases . in model s101 , the fuv radiation is easily shielded because of the high column density of the shell . the photoelectric heating outside the shell becomes inefficient , and the gas temperature in front of the sf quickly decreases . at that time , @xmath44 is still small , and the expansion velocity is still large according to equation ( [ eq : exvel ] ) .
the mach number of the sf is large , @xmath126 . in model s12 , it takes hundreds of @xmath103 to shield the fuv radiation by the dust extinction through the shell .
the expansion velocity significantly decreases by ( [ eq : exvel ] ) , and the mach number is only about a few .
this difference causes a different shell density in each model , because the density jump at the isothermal sf is proportional to @xmath127 .
the lower panel of fig.[fig : star_dep ] presents the time evolution of the mach number in each model .
this figure clearly shows that the mach number is larger in the model with the more massive central star . during the expansion ,
the pressure gradient in the pdr outside the shell hardly affects the hydrodynamics .
the pressure gradient outside the shell gradually disappears as the fuv photons are shielded by the dust in the shell .
the sf does not emerge in front of the dfs in our calculations . even with different central stars , the molecular gas is finally accumulated in the swept - up shell .
the lower panels of figs.[fig : fev_s1 ] , [ fig : fev_s5 ] , and [ fig : fev_s8 ] show the time evolution of the column density of each region in models s101 , s19 , and s12 respectively . in all these models ,
the number density of the molecular layer finally becomes over ten times as high as the ambient density , and gravitational fragmentation is expected there . in figs.[fig : fev_s1 ] - [ fig : fev_s8 ] , the shaded region is the unstable region expected in each model , where @xmath85 .
as shown in these figures , the unstable region spreads in the shell , as the dfs of co are taken into the shell .
the unstable region appears at @xmath128 myr in model s101 , @xmath129 myr in model s19 , and @xmath130 myr in model s12 . as explained in the previous subsections , these times are largely different at @xmath44 ; @xmath121 in model s101 , @xmath46 in model s19 , and @xmath131 in model s12 . the fuv flux at the if is stronger with the less massive star , and it takes a long time in @xmath103 units to form the dense molecular layer shielding the fuv radiation field .
in the above calculations , we have not included the dust grains in the h ii regions to avoid uncertainties ( e.g. , size distribution ) , but some observations indicate their presence ( e.g.,see * ? ? ? * ) .
the dust absorption of the uv and fuv radiation will decelerate the propagation of the if and dfs and affect the structure of the swept - up shell .
@xcite have noted that the photoelectric heating can be as important as the photoionization heating , even in the h ii region .
the importance of the dust absorption in the h ii region is often evaluated with the column density of the dust - free static h ii region , @xmath132 @xcite , where @xmath133 is the dust - free strmgren radius , @xmath9 is the ambient number density , and @xmath95 is the uv photon number luminosity of the central star . the radius of the corresponding dusty h ii region is smaller for larger @xmath134 .
@xcite has also shown that the dust absorption in the h ii region gradually becomes inefficient , as the h ii region dynamically expands . in order to evaluate the effect of the dust in the h ii region ,
we have calculated some models including the dust in the h ii region as well as the outer pdr . in models s41-hd and s41-ld , the radius of the h ii region and pdr decreases only by 10% and 3% compared with the dust - free counterparts . in models s101 and s41 , the reduction of each region is 20% and 5% of the dust - free radius .
these results agree with equation ( [ eq : nhii ] ) , which shows that the dust absorption in the h ii region becomes significant with the higher ambient number density , or the more massive central star . in all of the above calculations , however , the dust absorption in the h ii region is not so significant .
furthermore , the dust in the h ii region also absorbs fuv photons in addition to uv photons .
as briefly mentioned in paper i , this only slightly promotes the accumulation of molecules in the shell . therefore
, dust grains in the h ii region hardly affect our conclusions .
the dust absorption in the h ii region is more important in the denser and more compact region ( e.g. , ultra compact h ii region ) , where the detailed treatment of grains is required .
the reformation of h@xmath58 molecules on the grain surface is one of the key processes in our calculations .
the fuv radiation is consumed in photodissociating the reformed molecules in the shell , which accelerates the accumulation of h@xmath58 molecules .
however , there still remain uncertainties in the reformation rate , which depends on the detailed behavior of h atoms and h@xmath58 molecules on the grain surface . at high dust temperatures , for example ,
h atoms absorbed on the grain surface evaporate before the reformation of h@xmath58 molecules .
the critical temperature , @xmath135 , is about 20 k on pure grains , but @xcite have shown that the irregular surface with impurity sites raises @xmath135 to @xmath136 .
recently , @xcite have refined the absorption process of h atoms on the grain surface , and obtained a much higher critical temperature of @xmath137 k. in our calculations presented in 4 and 5 , we have not included the high - temperature cut - off in the reformation rate , for simplicity .
we analyze the validity of this treatment here .
we calculate some models including the cut - off using the functional form given by @xcite ( hm79 ) . in each model ,
two cases of @xmath138 k ( hm79 ) and 35 k are applied . with @xmath138 k ,
however , the h@xmath58 molecular abundance in the shell is hardly affected in all examined models . with @xmath139
k , the accumulation of h@xmath58 molecules in the shell is slightly delayed , but the shell is finally dominated by h@xmath58 molecules . the h@xmath58 abundance in the shell is reduced only by 2% in model s41 ( paper i ) and 5% in model s41-hd at @xmath47 . in the region where h@xmath58 molecules accumulate , the fuv radiation is well shielded and the dust temperature is low .
therefore , even if the reformation is inefficient above several ten k , our conclusions do not change .
our calculations do not include detailed energy and ionization balance of the small grains such as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons ( pahs ) .
the ionization rate and size distribution of small grains are important factors for the pdr structure .
the photoelectric heating rate depends on the abundance and ionization rate of pahs , and the dust attenuation law of fuv photons may be slightly affected by the change of the grain size distribution .
we have calculated some models with different photoelectric heating rates given by @xcite based on the different abundance of small grains .
the temperature profile in the pdr would be modified by a factor of less than 2 , but this does not affect our conclusions .
some recent observations detect the strong pah emission around the h ii region .
this emission sometimes shows the clear ring - like structure , which should trace the shell ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) . the expected pah emission related to the time evolution of the shell will be very useful for these observations , which should be included in future modeling .
the actual molecular clouds have complex structures rather than the homogeneous density distribution assumed in this paper .
below , we briefly discuss how realistic density structures affect the time evolution of the swept - up shell , pdr , as well as the h ii region . when the h ii region forms near the edge of a molecular cloud , or in a cloud with the density gradient ( e.g. , @xmath140 ) , its time evolution is different from that in a homogeneous medium .
the high - pressure ionized gas is hardly trapped , and flows out of the cloud @xcite .
such `` blister - like '' or `` champagne flow '' features have been observed in some h ii regions . in these regions ,
only a small fraction of the swept - up gas remains in the shell , and the expanding if finally destroys the parental molecular cloud .
as argued by @xcite and @xcite , the rapid ionization of the molecular gas will quench the star formation activity in the clouds .
furthermore , we note that the star - forming capacity of the clouds will be limited by fuv photons as well as uv photons .
unless the swept - up gas remains in the shell , stellar fuv radiation is hardly attenuated through the shell .
such unshielded fuv photons dissociate molecules efficiently over a much wider region than the h ii region , which reduces the star formation efficiency of the clouds .
the dynamical expansion of the h ii region , pdr , and the shell in a cloud with a density gradient has not been studied well , and this will be explored in our forthcoming papers .
real molecular clouds generally have clumpy or hierarchical structures .
the pre - existing density inhomogeneity in molecular clouds can modify the structure and the evolution of the h ii region , pdr , and the swept - up shell . in the h ii region
, the pre - existing clumps are gradually photoevaporated by stellar uv radiation .
these clumps are basically smoothed out in the sound crossing time of each clump , which is much shorter than the dynamical time of the h ii region , @xmath141 . outside the h ii region ,
the pdr structure depends on how deep the fuv radiation penetrates into the molecular region . some previous work ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) has shown that the radiative transfer in a clumpy medium can be reduced to that of a homogeneous medium with the same average density and lower effective extinction . in the pdr around the h ii region ,
the fuv photons will easily seep into the molecular region , threading the clumpy structure .
this will delay the sf and if overtaking the dfs , and the accumulation of molecules in the shell . in clumpy molecular clouds , on the other hand , most of the gas
is thought to be contained in optically thick clumps .
molecules in these opaque clumps will be protected against the fuv radiation by the self - shielding of these clumps . in order to study these two competing effects ,
multi - dimensional and time - dependent calculations are needed .
note , however , that our 1-d calculation has successfully explained the observed molecular abundance around sh104 ( paper i ) .
thus we expect that our 1-d calculations should be a good approximation for the averaged physical quantities .
observation shows that there are the supersonic turbulent motions in molecular clouds ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
since the velocity dispersion increases with the lengthscale ( @xmath142 a few km / s at about 10 pc ) , the effect becomes important with the lower ambient density .
the expanding shell actually dissolves when the shell velocity becomes less than the velocity dispersion of the turbulent motion . in 5 ,
we have shown that the shell velocity becomes less than a few km / s when the molecular gas accumulates in the shell with the lower - mass star . in this case
, the shell will dissolve without gathering the molecular material , and the triggered star formation will not occur .
we study the net feedback effect in the turbulent molecular cloud in a subsequent paper . in this paper ,
we have considered only the expanding h ii region in the molecular cloud , which can trigger the propagation of star formation activity within the cloud .
after the molecular cloud disperses due to the negative feedback from massive stars and/or the external turbulent motion , stellar uv photons spread into the diffuse neutral medium .
the h ii regions expand in the ambient neutral medium , but the sf preceding the if should also compress the neutral gas to enable the rapid reformation of molecules ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) .
the role of the giant h ii regions expanding in the diffuse neutral medium will be explored in our next paper , hosokawa & inutsuka ( 2006 , in preparation ) .
in this paper , we have studied the time evolution of the h ii region , pdr , and the swept - up shell around a massive star , performing the numerical calculation of radiation - hydrodynamics .
following paper i , we have investigated how the time evolution changes with the different ambient number density and the luminosity ( mass ) of the central star .
the basic evolution with different parameters is qualitatively similar to the fiducial one explained in paper i , but quantitatively different .
we have derived some simple scaling relations , ( [ eq : rst_nsc])-([eq : jfuvi_nsc ] ) and ( [ eq : rst_ssc])-([eq : jfuvi_ssc ] ) , with which we can well understand what causes the differences among models .
first , we have analyzed the dependence on the ambient number density .
our results are summarized as follows : * at the typical ambient number density of gmcs , @xmath143 , the molecular gas is finally accumulated in the shell , and gravitational fragmentation is expected . *
the timescale of the evolution , size of the h ii region , and the swept - up mass in the shell quantitatively change with the different ambient number densities . with the lower number density
, the h ii region expands into the larger region over a long timescale , so that the swept - up mass in the shell is larger .
the expected timescale within which the layer becomes gravitationally unstable is also longer with the lower ambient number density . *
the h@xmath58 molecules rapidly accumulate in the shell , but co molecules are more sensitive to the shielding effect of fuv photons . with the lower number density , the accumulation of co molecules in the shell is delayed owing to the small column density of the shell . at @xmath144 ,
the shell is dominated by co molecules before the fragmentation . at @xmath145 , however , the shell - fragmentation is expected to take place before the accumulation of co molecules . if the shell fragments into clumps with high column density , co molecules will be formed there owing to the self - shielding of clumps .
next , we have analyzed the dependence on the luminosity ( mass ) of the central stars .
our results are the following : * with the central stars of @xmath146 , the molecular gas is finally accumulated in the shell , and gravitational fragmentation is expected . *
the timescale of the shell - fragmentation is relatively insensitive to the luminosity of the central star . at @xmath93 ,
the unstable region spreads in the shell over @xmath147 myrs with the central star of @xmath146 , whose uv and fuv luminosities differ by 2 - 4 orders of magnitude . *
the maximum density of the shell is always higher with the more massive central star .
this is due to the difference in the mach number of the sf . with the higher - mass star
, the fuv radiation is easily shielded and the temperature in front of the sf quickly decreases , which raises the mach number . according to the above results
, we can conclude that an expanding h ii region in homogeneous molecular gas should be an efficient trigger for star formation . once the massive star is ignited in the cloud
, the star formation can propagate to the remaining molecular material around the exciting massive star .
we are grateful to shin mineshige , takashi nakamura , toru tsuribe , kazu omukai , hiroshi koyama , and akira mizuta for their useful comments and encouragement .
we also owe thanks to the yitp and naoj computer systems for the numerical calculations .
si is supported by the grant - in - aid ( 15740118 , 16077202 ) from the ministry of education , culture , sports , science , and technology ( mext ) of japan .
in this section , we explain the difference method for the ionization equation and the energy equation , ( [ eq : egy_ite ] ) . other rate equations are differenced in the same way as the ionization equation . for simplicity , we temporarily omit all indices and drop the frequency - dependence of the radiation field in the ionization equation , @xmath148 where @xmath149 means some processes other than photoionization ( e.g. , recombination etc )
. the simplest difference form of ( [ eq : ion_simple ] ) is , @xmath150 where all physical quantities are defined at the cell center .
the time average , @xmath151 for a quantity , @xmath152 is defined as @xmath153 using the radiative transfer equation , ( [ eq : juv ] ) , the uv photon number flux in the @xmath154-th cell , @xmath155 is written in time steps , @xmath156 eliminating @xmath157 in equation ( [ eq : ion_s_dif ] ) with ( [ eq : j_simple ] ) , we can calculate @xmath158 iteratively with other rate equations and the energy equation .
however , this differenced form provides no reliable results .
if the optical depth through the @xmath154-th cell is thick enough , @xmath159 , the uv flux at the @xmath154-th cell center , @xmath155 , significantly decreases from the uv flux at the previous cell center , @xmath160 .
even if a sufficient number of uv photons reaches the cell interface at @xmath161 , only a few photons may reach the @xmath154-th cell center and the @xmath154-th cell will not be photoionized .
this situation occurs at the ionization front ( if ) , where the optical depth changes sharply .
the quick way to improve the scheme is to define the flux at the inner cell interface , not in the cell center .
however , we adopt another more sophisticated differenced form for rate equations . with equation ( [ eq : ion_simple ] ) and radiative transfer equation ( [ eq : uvtr ] ) ,
the ionization equation becomes , @xmath162 first , equation ( [ eq : rate_dif_1 ] ) is differenced for the spatial grids , @xmath163 } { n_j ( r_{j+1/2}^3 - r_{j-1/2}^3 ) /3 }
+ r_j \ .\ ] ] in the right - hand side , the first term represents the consumption rate of uv photons for the photoionization per unit volume .
this equation assures that the number of ionized atoms per unit time is equal to that of the consumed photons per unit time in the @xmath154-th cell , if other processes , @xmath164 , are neglected . since the ionization rate sharply changes at the if , @xmath165 should be calculated with some precision ( e .. g , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
we approximate the time evolution of the ionization rate between two time steps with the power - law form , @xmath166 and analytically integrate ( [ eq : rate_dif_2 ] ) by time , @xmath118 from @xmath167 to @xmath168 .
other terms are calculated in the same manner . with the frequency - dependence of the radiation field and the dust extinction
, we can derive the differenced form in a similar way .
we use the same differenced form to calculate the photodissociation rate of h@xmath58 and co molecules .
the self - shielding effect works with the low column density ; @xmath169 for h@xmath58 molecules
@xcite and @xmath170 for co molecules @xcite
. the column density of one cell can be much higher than these values in our time - dependent calculations , and we do not use the shielding function given by @xcite and @xcite .
the energy equation ( [ eq : egy_ite ] ) is differenced as , @xmath171 with differenced ionization equation ( [ eq : rate_dif_2 ] ) , other similar rate equations , and the energy equation ( [ eq : egy_dif ] ) , we iteratively solve the new temperature , @xmath172 and chemical compositions , @xmath173 .
we include the heat transfer by thermal conduction in the energy equation ( [ eq : egyeq ] ) .
recently , @xcite have shown that the thermal conduction must be included to calculate the gas - dynamics with the thermal instability ( ti ) .
the conduction stabilizes the ti for the short wavelength and the critical wavelength is called the field length , @xmath174 @xcite where @xmath175 is the conductivity and @xmath22 is the cooling rate per hydrogen atom . @xcite
have shown that the field length must be resolved with several spatial cells to converge the calculation , increasing the number of spatial grids . in our calculations ,
the ti occurs around @xmath176 k mainly at the if . if we do not include the thermal conduction , unphysical oscillation spreads from the if and the calculation does not converge
therefore , we need to include the thermal conduction in the energy equation .
since the field length is generally much shorter than the characteristic length scale ( e.g. , strmgren radius ) in our calculations , we adopt another available method to resolve field length .
we first determine the width of the cell , @xmath177 and calculate the conductivity , @xmath178 so that the field length is longer than the given width of the cell .
the index @xmath154 means the difference step in space .
if we set @xmath179 , such conductivity is calculated as , @xmath180 the conductivity , @xmath178 is calculated every time step with equation ( [ eq : cduc ] ) . if we set 100 cells per initial strmgren radius for the ambient number density , @xmath181 , the calculated conductivity is , @xmath182 , which is significantly larger than the standard value . however , the conduction with equation ( [ eq : cduc ] ) smooths out the temperature structure only on the field length scale , which covers a few cells ( @xmath179 ) .
since the meaningful temperature profile changes over a much longer length scale , we use the equation ( [ eq : cduc ] ) to calculate the conductivity .
the dominant cooling processes in the pdr are the radiative loss by the fine - structure transitions , [ oi ] 63.1@xmath183 and [ cii ] 157.7@xmath183 @xcite .
these lines can be optically thick at @xmath184 @xcite , and we use the escape probability for these lines @xcite .
since the swept - up shell expands at a supersonic velocity relative to the ambient gas , a few - 10 km / s , we take account of the doppler shift for the trapping effect .
the gas velocity in the shell is usually almost constant , and we separately calculate the escape probability for the gas in the shell and ahead of the shell . for the gas in the shell , photons can escape from the inner ( if ) and outer edge ( sf ) of the shell , @xmath185 where @xmath186 is the escape probability , @xmath187 and @xmath188 are the optical depth averaged over the line to the if and the sf respectively , and @xmath189 is defined as , @xmath190^{0.5 } \right\}^{-1 } \ \ \ \ \tau \geq 7 \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xcite . for the gas ahead of the shell , we assume that only half of the photons can escape from the sf , @xmath191 where @xmath192 is the optical depth to the sf .
the co molecules are another important coolant in the pdr .
we do not solve the non - lte rotational level population , to save the computational time , but adopt the analytical formulae given by @xcite including the trapping effect .
we take account of the doppler shift for the trapping effect in the same manner as the fine - structure lines . in our calculations ,
the rovibrational lines of h@xmath58 molecules are reliably optically thin .
the fuv photons emitted from the central star photodissociate the molecules , both in the swept - up shell and in the unshocked ambient medium .
however , we do not include the doppler effect for the photodissociating lines of h@xmath58 and co molecules .
below , we briefly verify this approximation .
the doppler shift in the fuv energy range is , @xmath193 , where @xmath194 is the characteristic energy of fuv photons , @xmath195 is the typical velocity of the shell , and @xmath196 is the speed of light .
the doppler shift is larger than the doppler width of lines owing to the supersonic velocity of the shell . as noted in
[ ssec : beq ] , however , the absorption of fuv photons in the doppler core is not important . in our calculations , for example , the column density of h@xmath58 molecules easily exceeds @xmath197 , and the fuv photons are mainly absorbed in the lorentz wings after that . since the energy range of the lorentz wings is much wider than that of the doppler core , the doppler shift of the core is not so important .
( co ) , where @xmath202 and @xmath203 .
we plot the position of dfs only before the sf catches up with each dfs . after the dfs
are taken in the shell , the positions of dfs are close to that of the sf . _
lower panel : _ the time evolution of the column density of each region in model hd - s41 , where the vertical axis , @xmath204 is the column density of the hydrogen nuclei included in all species of h@xmath205 , h and h@xmath58 from the central star .
thin contour lines represent the position where @xmath206 ( _ dashed contours _ ) and @xmath207 ( _ dot - dashed contours _ ) = 0.2 , 0.5 , and 0.8 .
the shaded region corresponds to the expected unstable region , where @xmath85 . ] but for model s12 . in each panel
, five snapshots represent the profiles at @xmath213 , 0.75 , 1.25 , 1.75 and 2.25 myr respectively .
we add two early snapshots of the density profile at @xmath214 , and 0.125 myr . ] | we analyze the dynamical expansion of the h ii region , photodissociation region , and the swept - up shell , solving the uv- and fuv - radiative transfer , the thermal and chemical processes in the time - dependent hydrodynamics code .
following our previous paper , we investigate the time evolutions with various ambient number densities and central stars .
our calculations show that basic evolution is qualitatively similar among our models with different parameters .
the molecular gas is finally accumulated in the shell , and the gravitational fragmentation of the shell is generally expected .
the quantitative differences among models are well understood with analytic scaling relations .
the detailed physical and chemical structure of the shell is mainly determined by the incident fuv flux and the column density of the shell , which also follow the scaling relations .
the time of shell - fragmentation , and the mass of the gathered molecular gas are sensitive to the ambient number density . in the case of a low density ,
the shell - fragmentation occurs over a longer timescale , and the accumulated molecular gas is more massive than in the case of a high density .
the variations with different central stars are more moderate .
the time of the shell - fragmentation differs by a factor of several with the various stars of @xmath0 . according to our numerical results ,
we conclude that the expanding h ii region should be an efficient trigger for star formation in molecular clouds if the mass of the ambient molecular material is large enough . |
comparative genomics has been an important source of combinatorial and algorithmic questions during the last 20 years , especially the computation of genomic distances and ancestral genomes , as illustrated by the recent book of fertin _ et al .
_ @xcite . among these problems ,
the _ median _
problem is of particular interest : while the distance problem is tractable in many models , the median problem is its simplest natural extension ( a distance is a function of two genomes , while the median score is a function of three genomes ) and is computationally intractable in most models .
computing median is at the heart of inferring gene order phylogenies and ancestral gene orders @xcite .
this motivated research on tractability issues of genomic median problems , well summarized in the recent paper @xcite , as well as on practical algorithms to address it ( see @xcite and references there ) . roughly speaking ,
the median problem is as follows : given three genomes @xmath1 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 and a genomic distance model @xmath4 , find a genome @xmath5 that minimizes the _ cost _ of @xmath4 over @xmath6 defined by @xmath7 .
it is in fact an ancestral genome reconstruction problem , as @xmath5 can be seen as the last - common ancestor of @xmath1 and @xmath2 , with @xmath3 acting as _ outgroup _ ( i.e. a genome whose last common ancestor with @xmath1 and @xmath2 is an ancestor of @xmath5 ) . in @xcite ,
tannier _ et al .
_ explored several variants , based on different models of genomes ( linear , circular or mixed , see section [ sec : prelim ] ) and of genomic distances ( breakpoint , double - cut - and - join , reversals , ) .
in particular , they showed that if @xmath4 is the double - cut - and - join ( dcj ) distance , which is currently the most widely used genomic distance , then computing a circular or mixed median is np - complete . in fact , the only known tractable median problem is the mixed breakpoint median : @xmath4 is the breakpoint distance and the median can contain both linear and circular chromosomes . from a combinatorial point of view , the central object in the dcj model is the _ breakpoint graph _ : the dcj distance between two genomes with @xmath8 genes is indeed easily obtained from the number of cycles and paths containing odd number of vertices ( odd paths ) in this graph @xcite .
recent progress in understanding properties of this graph , and especially of the family of _ adequat subgraphs _ , lead xu to introduce algorithms to compute dcj median genomes which are efficient on real data , but do not define well characterized classes of tractable instances @xcite . in the present work ,
we show the following result : if the breakpoint graph of three genomes contains a constant number of vertices of degree 3 , then computing a dcj circular median is tractable . to the best of our knowledge , this is the first result defining an explicit non - trivial class of tractable instances related to the dcj median problem . in section [ sec :
prelim ] , we define precisely combinatorial representations of genomes , the dcj distance , breakpoint graphs and the problem we addressed here . in section [ sec : results ] , we state and prove our main result .
[ [ genes - genomes - and - breakpoint - graph ] ] genes , genomes and breakpoint graph + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + let @xmath9 represent a set of @xmath8 _
genes_. each gene @xmath10 has a _ head _ @xmath11 and a _ tail _
@xmath12 . from now , we assume @xmath13 always contains @xmath8 genes .
a _ genome _ @xmath14 , with gene set @xmath13 , is encoded by the order and orientation of its genes along its chromosomes ( i.e. its _ gene order _ ) , or equivalently by the set of the adjacencies between its gene extremities , that can naturally be represented by a _ matching _ on the set of vertices @xmath15 ( fig .
[ genomebreak ] ( a ) ) .
the connected components of the graph whose vertices are @xmath16 and edges are the disjoint union of the edges of @xmath14 and the edges @xmath17 ( forcing gene extremities for a given gene to be contiguous ) form the _ chromosomes _ of @xmath14 ( fig .
[ genomebreak ] ( b ) ) .
a chromosome is _ linear _ if it is a path and _ circular _ if it is a cycle .
@xmath14 is _ circular _ if it contains only circular chromosomes ( perfect matching ) , _ linear _ if it contains only linear chromosomes , and _
mixed _ otherwise .
[ genomebreak](a , b ) illustrates this view of genomes as matchings .
the _ breakpoint graph _
@xmath18 of @xmath19 genomes @xmath20 on @xmath13 is the disjoint union of these genomes , i.e. the graph with vertex set @xmath21 and edges given by the matchings defining these @xmath19 genomes .
following the usual convention , we consider that edges in this graph are colored , with color @xmath22 assigned to genome @xmath10 ( @xmath23 ) ; it results that @xmath18 can have multiple edges of different colors ( see fig .
[ genomebreak ] ( c ) ) . and one linear chromosome with gene order @xmath24 , where the sign @xmath25 indicates a reverse orientation .
( b ) the same genomes with added dashed edges connecting gene extremities : every connected component of the resulting graph is a chromosome .
( c ) the breakpoint graph of three genomes ( whose edges are respectively light gray , thin black and thick black ) on 4 genes . ] [ [ dcj - distance - and - median ] ] dcj distance and median + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + given two genomes @xmath14 and @xmath5 on @xmath13 , with @xmath5 being a circular genome , the _ dcj distance _
@xmath26 is given by @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the number of cycles in @xmath29 .
so larger @xmath30 implies smaller distance @xmath31 .
the general definition of the dcj distance ( when both @xmath14 and @xmath5 are mixed genomes ) also requires to consider the odd paths of the breakpoint graph @xcite , but it is easy to see that the breakpoint graph does not contain odd path if at least one genome is circular .
note that the edges on a cycle in @xmath32 are alternatively from @xmath5 and @xmath14 .
@xmath33-alternating cycle _ is an even cycle with edges in @xmath5 and @xmath14 alternatively . for simplicity ,
we may sometimes only call such cycles _ alternating cycles_. a _ dcj circular median _ for three genomes @xmath1 , @xmath2 , and @xmath3 , or alternatively for their breakpoint graph @xmath34 , is a circular genome @xmath5 which minimizes @xmath35 .
so a circular genome @xmath5 which maximizes the the total number of @xmath36-alternating cycles ( for an @xmath37 ) is a dcj circular median .
[ [ terminology ] ] terminology + + + + + + + + + + + from now , by _ median _
we always mean _ dcj circular median_. we denote also by @xmath38 the sum @xmath39 for a median @xmath5 .
let @xmath40 be a breakpoint graph , and let @xmath5 be a median of @xmath41 .
the graph @xmath42 ( also denoted by @xmath43 when the context is clear ) is called the _ median graph _ of @xmath41 with the dcj circular median genome @xmath5 ( using disjoint union ) .
the edges in @xmath44 are called _ colored edges _ , and edges in @xmath5 are called _
median edges_. a @xmath45-cycle in @xmath43 is an @xmath46-alternating cycle of length @xmath45 , for some @xmath10 , in @xmath43 .
we denote the total number of alternating cycles for a median graph @xmath5 of a breakpoint graph @xmath41 by @xmath47 does not depend only on the topology of @xmath41 , but also on the colors of its edges .
moreover , for different medians @xmath5 of @xmath41 , @xmath43 has the same number of alternating cycles , so @xmath47 does not depend of a particular median . ] .
if @xmath48 is a subgraph of @xmath41 , then @xmath49 is the maximum number of alternating cycles composed of edges in @xmath48 , taken over all matchings in @xmath48 .
a terminal vertex in a graph is a vertex of degree @xmath50 .
a subgraph of @xmath41 is said to be _ isomorphic to @xmath51 ( resp .
@xmath52 ) _ if it is a cycle ( resp .
path ) on @xmath45 vertices .
the problem we consider in the present work is to compute a dcj circular median of three given genomes , or equivalently to find a matching in @xmath41 that maximizes the number of alternating cycles . from this point of view
this is a purely graph theoretical problem that can be extended naturally to any edge - colored graph , with the convention that if the graph has an odd number of vertices , then exactly one vertex does not belong to the matching .
[ [ shrinking - in - a - breakpoint - graph ] ] shrinking in a breakpoint graph + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + _ shrinking _ a pair of vertices @xmath53 or an edge with end vertices @xmath54 and @xmath55 was defined in @xcite .
it consists of three steps : _ ( 1 ) _ removing all edges between @xmath54 and @xmath55 ( if there is any ) , _ ( 2 ) _ identifying the remaining edges incident to both @xmath54 and @xmath55 and with same color , _ ( 3 ) _ removing @xmath54 and @xmath55 .
we denote the resulting graph by @xmath56 ( fig .
[ shrink ] ) . of vertices of a breakpoint graph .
] [ shrink ] let @xmath41 be the breakpoint graph of genomes @xmath57 , and @xmath58 .
suppose that there are @xmath45 colored edges between @xmath54 and @xmath55 . if there exists a median @xmath5 containing the edge @xmath59 , then @xmath60 .
consider a median @xmath5 which contains the edge @xmath59 ( which implies that both @xmath54 and @xmath55 are in the same alternating cycle in @xmath43 ) .
let @xmath61 , @xmath62 ( the graph obtained from @xmath5 by removing @xmath54 , @xmath55 and the edge @xmath59 ) .
let @xmath63 be an alternating cycle in @xmath43 .
if @xmath63 does not contain @xmath54 and @xmath55 , then , obviously , @xmath63 does not contain any of the @xmath45 edges between @xmath54 and @xmath55 .
thus , @xmath63 remains unchanged in @xmath64 .
assume now that @xmath63 contains @xmath59 . if the length of @xmath63 is larger than 2 , shrinking @xmath53 results in a cycle with smaller length in @xmath64 ( the length decreases by @xmath65 )
otherwise , if @xmath63 has length 2 , it disappears in @xmath64 .
thus the number of alternating cycles which disappear in @xmath66 is @xmath45 , since there are @xmath45 edges between @xmath54 and @xmath55 .
therefore , @xmath67 .
now suppose @xmath68 is a median of @xmath69 . by a similar argument ,
if @xmath70 , then @xmath71 has @xmath72 alternating cycles .
so , @xmath73 , and , as @xmath60 , we have that @xmath74 ( resp .
@xmath75 ) is a median of @xmath69 ( resp .
@xmath41 ) .
our main theoretical result is the definition of a large class of tractable instances for the median problem , namely the ones whose breakpoint graph contains few vertices of degree @xmath0 .
obviously , the median problem for three genomes involves a breakpoint graph with maximum degree @xmath0 .
we show here that the hardness of the problem is due to these vertices of degree @xmath0 .
[ thm : main ] let @xmath76 , and @xmath3 be three genomes .
if there exists a median of @xmath77 with at most @xmath78 edges whose both end - vertices are of degree @xmath0 in @xmath41 , then computing such a median can be done in time @xmath79 , where @xmath19 is the number of vertices of degree @xmath0 , and @xmath8 is the number of genes in @xmath80 .
[ rem : corollaries ] note that , as corollaries of this theorem , we have in particular that , 1 .
if @xmath19 is bounded , then computing a median is tractable , 2 .
if @xmath78 is bounded , then computing a median is fixed - parameter tractable ( fpt ) ( see @xcite for a reference on fpt algorithms ) with parameter @xmath19 .
moreover , if @xmath19 is not bounded , we can remove some edges incident to vertices of degree @xmath0 , so that in the new instance the number of vertices of degree @xmath0 is bounded .
now , by point 1 above , there is a polynomial time algorithm which computes the median of the new instance .
informally , to prove theorem [ thm : main ] , we first consider the case where @xmath41 is a collection of cycles and paths ( i.e. has maximum degree @xmath65 ) and show that a median can be computed in polynomial time .
next , we consider all possibilities ( configurations ) for matching vertices of degree @xmath0 as median edges .
for each configuration , we reduce the breakpoint graph by shrinking and removing some edges to obtain a graph whose connected components are paths or cycles . having computed all possible configurations for vertices of degree @xmath0 and being able to compute a median for all resulting graphs lead to theorem [ thm : main ] . from now ,
@xmath1 , @xmath2 , and @xmath3 are mixed genomes on @xmath8 genes , and @xmath5 is a median of these genomes , unless otherwise specified .
we denote their breakpoint graph by @xmath41 , and the median graph by @xmath43 .
we first introduce two useful lemmas that give lower bounds on the function @xmath81 in various cases .
[ subpc ] if @xmath41 is isomorphic to @xmath52 or @xmath82 , for @xmath83 , then for every subgraph @xmath84 , @xmath85 .
consider the path @xmath86 .
let @xmath5 be the matching consisting of the edges @xmath87 , and @xmath88 , where @xmath89 .
obviously , the number of alternating cycles in @xmath90 is @xmath91 , so @xmath92 .
similarly @xmath93 .
see fig .
[ pc ] .
any proper subgraph @xmath94 or @xmath82 is a union of disjoint paths
. if we take the union of matchings described above for each of these paths and call it @xmath5 , there are at least @xmath95 alternating cycles in @xmath96 .
therefore for any subgraph @xmath97 , @xmath85 .
let @xmath98 and @xmath99 be two subgraphs of @xmath41 .
@xmath99 is an _ alternating - subdivision _ of @xmath98 if we can obtain an isomorphic copy of @xmath99 from @xmath98 as follows : subdivide each edge @xmath100 by an even ( possibly zero ) number of vertices resulting in a path @xmath101 , then remove every second edge , i.e. , @xmath102 .
we call the removed edges a _ completing matching _ for @xmath99 respective to @xmath98 . in the previous definition ,
note that there might be more than one way to obtain an isomorphic copy of @xmath99 from @xmath98 , and consequently , completing matching is not necessarily unique .
[ alsub ] if @xmath99 is an alternating - subdivision of @xmath98 , then @xmath103 .
let @xmath5 be a median of @xmath98 , @xmath74 an arbitrary completing matching for @xmath99 respective to @xmath98 and @xmath104 .
@xmath105 is a perfect matching of @xmath99 , and each alternating cycle in @xmath106 defines a unique alternating cycle in @xmath107 which implies that @xmath108 ( see fig . [ proofalsub ] ) .
\(a ) as an alternating - subdivision of @xmath98 .
( b ) obtaining a matching of @xmath99 from a median of @xmath98 ( the dashed edges are the median edges and the edges of a completing matching for @xmath99 respective to @xmath98).,title="fig : " ] + ( b ) as an alternating - subdivision of @xmath98 .
( b ) obtaining a matching of @xmath99 from a median of @xmath98 ( the dashed edges are the median edges and the edges of a completing matching for @xmath99 respective to @xmath98).,title="fig : " ] [ proofalsub ] in this section we introduce the fundamental notion of _ independence _ of connected components of cycles and paths in a breakpoint graph .
[ def : crossing - indep ] let @xmath48 be a subgraph of @xmath41 .
@xmath48-crossing edge _ in a median graph @xmath43 is a median edge which connects a vertex in @xmath109 to a vertex in @xmath110 .
@xmath48-crossing cycle _ is an alternating cycle which contains at least one @xmath48-crossing edge .
the subgraph @xmath48 is _ @xmath45-independent _ if there is a median @xmath5 for @xmath41 such that the number of @xmath48-crossing edges in @xmath43 is at most @xmath45 .
[ indep ] let @xmath48 be a connected component of @xmath41 . if @xmath48 is isomorphic to @xmath111 or @xmath82 , for @xmath83 , then @xmath48 is 0-independent .
let @xmath5 be a median of @xmath41 .
suppose @xmath5 has @xmath78 @xmath48-crossing edges in @xmath43 .
if @xmath112 , then we are done , so assume that @xmath113 .
since @xmath48 has an even number of vertices , @xmath78 is even and @xmath114 .
because @xmath48 is a connected component in @xmath41 , each @xmath48-crossing cycle contains an even number of @xmath48-crossing edges .
let @xmath115 be the set of all @xmath48-crossing cycles in @xmath43 , and @xmath116 be the set of all @xmath48-crossing edges in @xmath43 .
let @xmath117 be the set of colored edges in all cycles of @xmath115 , and @xmath118 be the set of all @xmath48-crossing edges in all cycles of @xmath115 .
_ if there is no @xmath48-crossing cycle , i.e. , @xmath119 , we modify @xmath5 by removing all @xmath48-crossing edges , and re - matching the vertices inside of @xmath48 together and outside of @xmath48 together .
since @xmath78 is even , this is always possible and we get a median with no @xmath48-crossing edge .
_ from now , we assume that there exists at least one @xmath48-crossing cycle .
the remainder of the proof relies on a transformation on @xmath5 that reduces the number of edges in @xmath48-crossing cycles , leading to a median with no @xmath48-crossing edge .
_ the first step consists of choosing , for each @xmath48-crossing cycle , an arbitrary colored edge in @xmath48 incident to an @xmath48-crossing edge from this cycle .
let @xmath98 be the subgraph of @xmath41 induced by these chosen colored edges and @xmath120 .
_ claim 1 .
@xmath99 is an alternating - subdivision of @xmath98 .
_ for a vertex @xmath121 let @xmath122 be the neighbor of @xmath123 in @xmath5 .
if @xmath124 and @xmath125 then , by definition , @xmath59 is a colored edge of an @xmath48-crossing cycle which is incident to an @xmath48-crossing edge .
therefore , there is an alternating path from @xmath126 to @xmath127 , with alternating colored and median edges from that cycle .
if this path has @xmath128 colored edges , we subdivide the edge @xmath59 using @xmath129 vertices and remove every second edge . proceeding in this way for every edge @xmath125
we obtain an alternating - subdivision @xmath99 of @xmath98 .
_ claim 2 .
@xmath130 . _
first , as every colored edge is in at most one alternating cycle and two edges of the same color are not incident to each other , @xmath131 .
also @xmath132 , and by lemma [ subpc ] , @xmath133 .
finally , from lemma [ alsub ] , @xmath134 .
_ now we remove all the edges in @xmath116 .
let @xmath135 be an arbitrary median of @xmath98 , @xmath136 the matching for @xmath99 defined by the union of @xmath135 and an arbitrary completing matching for @xmath99 respective to @xmath98 , and @xmath137 .
_ claim 3 .
@xmath74 is a median of @xmath41 . _
first , by removing the edges in @xmath138 , the total number of alternating cycles decreases by @xmath139 .
next , @xmath135 and @xmath136 contain at least @xmath140 alternating cycles each ( claim 2 above ) .
hence , the new matching @xmath74 contains at least the same number of alternating cycles than @xmath5 . by definition of a median , @xmath74 can not contain more alternating cycles than @xmath5 , so it contains the same number of alternating cycles , and is a median of @xmath41 .
note that this also implies that @xmath141 .
_ claim 4 .
@xmath142 and @xmath143 .
_ if there exists @xmath144 then there would be at least one @xmath48-crossing cycle induced by @xmath74 which is not induced by @xmath135 or @xmath136 , this implies @xmath145 would contain more alternating cycles than @xmath146 , which contradicts the fact that @xmath43 and @xmath145 have the same number of alternating cycles .
next , @xmath147 , as @xmath148 and @xmath149 ( the vertices in @xmath98 are matched to themselves ) .
therefore , @xmath150 . by iterating the above steps we obtain a median with no crossing cycle .
then , by case 1 , we can modify this median to a median without @xmath48-crossing edge .
[ 1dep ] let @xmath48 be a connected component of @xmath41 . if @xmath48 is isomorphic to @xmath151 , for @xmath152 , then @xmath48 is 1-independent .
we follow the same proof strategy than for proposition [ indep ] .
the number of @xmath48-crossing edges is odd .
if there is no @xmath48-crossing cycle , we can remove an even number of them as in case 1 of the proof of proposition [ indep ] , leaving only one @xmath48-crossing edge .
otherwise , if we assume that there are @xmath48-crossing cycles , we can apply the transformation defined in case 2 of the proof of proposition [ indep ] .
it has similar properties , as , from lemma [ subpc ] , for every subgraph @xmath153 , @xmath154 , which implies again that @xmath155 .
[ themedian ] if @xmath41 contains only cycles and paths , there exists a median of @xmath41 in which even components have no crossing edge , and each odd path has exactly one crossing edge .
this result follows from applying , on an arbitrary median graph , the transformation introduced in the proof of in proposition [ indep ] to each even / odd path or even cycle of the breakpoint graph , reducing then the number of crossing edges for each of them , without increasing the number of crossing edges in other components .
the results of the previous section open the way to computing a median of a breakpoint graph with maximum degree @xmath65 by considering each path or even cycle independently , and matching odd paths into pairs ( each defined by a single crossing edge ) .
the main point of the current section is to show that paths and even cycles are easy to consider when computing a median .
[ cycp ] if @xmath156 is isomorphic to @xmath52 , for some @xmath83 , then @xmath157 .
moreover , there exists a median whose edges in @xmath48 define @xmath158 alternating 2-cycles , and one crossing edge incident to a terminal vertex of @xmath48 if @xmath45 is odd . from lemma [ subpc ] , @xmath159 .
we use induction on @xmath45 to show that @xmath160 .
this obviously holds for @xmath161 .
so we assume that @xmath162 , and consider a median @xmath5 for @xmath48 .
if there is no 2-cycle ( an alternating cycle consisting of two parallel edges ) in @xmath163 , each alternating cycle has length at least @xmath164 , and hence at least 2 colored edges .
so @xmath165 .
now assume that the median @xmath5 contains a 2-cycle , with vertices @xmath54 and @xmath55 .
shrinking @xmath53 results in @xmath166 that is either a single path with @xmath167 vertices or two paths with @xmath168 and @xmath169 vertices such that @xmath170 . in both cases , using induction and the fact that all paths are 0-independent or 1-independent , we can conclude that , * if @xmath166 contains one path , @xmath171 , * if @xmath166 contains two paths , @xmath172 . to obtain a median with exactly @xmath158 alternating cycles in @xmath48
, we can simply define median edges by linking successive vertices in @xmath48 ( as in the proof of lemma [ subpc ] ) .
if @xmath45 is odd this forces the unique @xmath48-crossing edge ( proposition [ 1dep ] ) to contain the last end vertex of @xmath48 ( one of its two end vertices ) , which has no impact on the number of alternating cycles as , by definition , this crossing edge will not belong to any alternating cycle .
[ cycc ] if @xmath41 is isomorphic to @xmath82 , for some @xmath83 , then either @xmath173 or @xmath174 .
obviously , @xmath175 .
so , we assume that @xmath176 .
let @xmath5 be an arbitrary median of @xmath41 .
following the proof of proposition [ cycp ] , if all alternating cycles in @xmath43 have length at least 4 , then the number of alternating cycles is at most @xmath177 , so there must exist at least one 2-cycle in @xmath43 .
let @xmath59 be a colored edge in a 2-cycle : @xmath178 ( proposition [ shrink ] ) .
moreover @xmath179 is a path , or a cycle , and it is a cycle if and only if the two edges incident to the ends of @xmath59 have the same color . if it is a path , proposition [ cycp ] implies that @xmath180 and @xmath173 , which contradicts the assumption that @xmath176 .
so @xmath179 is a cycle and the edges incident to @xmath59 have same color . by induction on @xmath45 (
note that @xmath181 and @xmath182 ) we can find a median of @xmath179 with @xmath183 or @xmath184 , alternating cycles . hence , @xmath185 or @xmath186 .
some definitions below assume that cycles of @xmath41 are oriented , so we assume from now that edges of every cycle of @xmath41 are consistently oriented , clockwise or counterclockwise . fig .
[ cyckind ] provides an illustration .
[ def : kind - cyc ] a cycle @xmath82 of @xmath41 is of the _ first kind _ if @xmath187 , and it is of the _ second kind _ if @xmath188 . [
def : signature ] let @xmath63 be a cycle of @xmath41 .
the _ signature _ of a vertex of @xmath63 is an ordered pair @xmath189 such that @xmath190 and @xmath191 are the colors of the edges incident to that vertex : @xmath190 is the color of the incoming edge and @xmath191 the color of the outgoing edge .
two vertices @xmath54 and @xmath55 are _ diagonal _ if their signatures are of the form @xmath189 and @xmath192 .
[ def : cross ] let @xmath5 be a median of an even cycle @xmath63 , and @xmath59 and @xmath193 be edges in @xmath5 : @xmath59 and @xmath193 _ cross _ if @xmath194 appear in this order along @xmath63 .
cross - free diagonal _ matching for @xmath63 is a matching whose edges connect pairs of diagonal vertices and no two edges cross . of the first kind
( right ) a cycle @xmath195 of the second kind ; the matched vertices are diagonal ] [ 2ndkind ] let @xmath41 be isomorphic to an even cycle of the second kind , and @xmath5 be a median of @xmath41 .
( 1 ) each edge in @xmath5 joins two diagonal vertices , and ( 2 ) the edges in @xmath5 do not cross .
let @xmath196 .
we first prove point ( 1 ) by contradiction .
assume that @xmath197 and that @xmath54 and @xmath55 are not diagonal .
let @xmath189 and @xmath198 be the respective signatures of @xmath54 and @xmath55 .
our assumption implies that @xmath199 , and we can distinguish two cases : @xmath200 and @xmath201 . * if @xmath200 , by shrinking the pair @xmath53 we obtain a smaller cycle @xmath202 , and by proposition [ shrink ] , @xmath203 which is a contradiction , since @xmath41 is of the second kind . note that in this case @xmath54 and @xmath55 can not be consecutive vertices on @xmath41 . *
if @xmath201 , by shrinking the pair @xmath53 , the resulting graph can be either a path with @xmath204 vertices , or a cycle and a path , together with @xmath204 vertices . in the first case , vertices @xmath54 and @xmath55 must be consecutive on @xmath41 .
but now @xmath205 , which is a contradiction , since @xmath41 is of the second kind . in the second case @xmath206 , since paths are either 0- or 1-independent and @xmath207 ( note that in the latter case @xmath54 and @xmath55 can not be consecutive ) .
this is again a contradiction , as @xmath41 is of the second kind .
we now prove point ( 2 ) .
@xmath41 is of the second kind , as shown in the proof of lemma [ cycc ] , there is a 2-cycle containing a colored edge @xmath193 .
moreover , by point ( 1 ) , vertices @xmath208 and @xmath209 are diagonal .
so @xmath210 is isomorphic to @xmath202 and it must be of the second kind , as otherwise @xmath211 . obviously , @xmath193 does not cross with any median edge of @xmath5 .
by shrinking this pair and , by induction on the length of the cycle , applied to @xmath212 , the proof is complete .
[ 2ndkindcyc ] let @xmath41 be isomorphic to @xmath82 .
@xmath41 is of the second kind if and only if there exists a matching @xmath5 of @xmath41 that is cross - free diagonal .
the necessity follows from lemma [ 2ndkind ] .
now assume that there exists a cross - free diagonal matching @xmath5 on vertices of @xmath41 .
it is easy to see that @xmath5 contains at least one edge @xmath59 where @xmath54 and @xmath55 are consecutive on @xmath41 ( note that @xmath5 is a perfect matching , since @xmath41 has even number of vertices ) .
if we shrink the pair @xmath213 , the resulting graph is @xmath202 and the remaining edges of @xmath5 are a cross - free diagonal matching for @xmath202 .
we can complete the proof by induction on @xmath45 , since @xmath214 , and the statement of the lemma is obviously true for @xmath161 and @xmath215 .
[ whatkind ] let @xmath41 be isomorphic to @xmath82 .
deciding if @xmath41 admits a cross - free diagonal matching can be done in time @xmath216 .
let @xmath217 .
we rely on a simple greedy algorithm , which is in fact a classical algorithm for deciding if a circular parenthesis word is balanced ; we present it for the sake of completeness .
the key point was given in the proof of lemma [ 2ndkindcyc ] : any cross - free diagonal matching contains at least one pair of consecutive vertices that are matched .
given the circular nature of @xmath41 , we can extend this property as follows : if @xmath54 and @xmath55 are consecutive diagonal vertices and @xmath41 admits a diagonal cross - free matching , then there exists a matching where @xmath54 and @xmath55 are matched .
this leads immediately to a greedy algorithm that matches such vertices as soon as they are visited , using a simple stack data structure : the time complexity of this algorithm is obviously linear in @xmath45 .
[ cycles ] if @xmath41 is isomorphic to an even cycle of size @xmath45 ( @xmath218 ) , then computing @xmath219 can be done in time @xmath216
. immediate consequence of lemma [ cycc ] , lemma [ 2ndkindcyc ] , and lemma [ whatkind ] .
we now have all the elements to prove our main result , theorem [ thm : main ] .
we first prove that computing a median of a breakpoint graph of maximum degree two is tractable .
[ linkage ] if @xmath41 has maximum degree @xmath65 , then there exists a median of @xmath41 such that every odd connected component of @xmath41 is connected by median edges to exactly one other odd connected component .
let @xmath5 be a median as described in the proof of proposition [ themedian ] : every even connected component has no crossing edge and each odd path has exactly one crossing edge .
moreover , odd cycles have at least one crossing edge .
let @xmath48 be an odd connected component and @xmath220 one of its crossing edges , connecting @xmath48 to another odd component @xmath166 . shrinking @xmath220 results into @xmath221 which is a set of even components and it is then @xmath222-independent .
moreover , as @xmath48 and @xmath166 were distinct connected components of @xmath41 , from proposition [ shrink ] ( with @xmath223 ) , @xmath224 . repeating this argument for other odd components and the fact that the number of odd components is even ( because the number of vertices in the breakpoint graph is even ) completes the proof .
[ pair ] if @xmath41 has maximum degree @xmath65 and consists of two odd connected components @xmath225 and @xmath226 , of respective sizes @xmath227 and @xmath228 , then computing a median of @xmath41 can be done in time @xmath229 . for parity reasons ,
a median @xmath5 contains at least one edge @xmath220 between @xmath225 and @xmath226 ( @xmath220 is a @xmath225-crossing edge ) . by shrinking @xmath220
we obtain either one even connected component or two even connected components , and , from proposition [ themedian ] , we can compute a median for each connected component independently .
this computation requires linear time ( propositions [ cycp ] and [ cycles ] ) .
there are at most @xmath230 possible candidates for @xmath220 . hence computing a median of @xmath41 is tractable in time @xmath229 .
[ odds ] if @xmath41 is a breakpoint graph with @xmath231 vertices with maximum degree @xmath65 , then computing a median of @xmath41 can be done in @xmath232 .
we first consider the case where @xmath41 contains only odd connected components .
we define a complete edge - weighted graph @xmath233 as follows : 1 .
each connected component @xmath63 defines a vertex @xmath234 ; 2 .
each edge @xmath235 has weight @xmath236 by lemma [ pair ] , @xmath233 is computable in polynomial time .
we claim it is computable in @xmath232 .
suppose @xmath41 has @xmath128 components and @xmath237 are the number of vertices in each component .
so we have @xmath238 . the time to construct @xmath233
is of order @xmath239 finally , by lemma [ linkage ] we only need to find a maximum weight matching for @xmath233 , which can be done in @xmath240 by using edmonds s algorithm @xcite .
if the breakpoint graph @xmath41 has maximum degree @xmath65 , its connected components are paths or cycles . from proposition [ themedian ] and proposition [ cycles ]
we can find the median edges for even components independently .
finally for odd components we find the median edges as described in the first part of the proof .
_ proof of theorem [ thm : main ] .
we now assume that @xmath41 has maximum degree @xmath0 .
the main idea is to consider all possibilities for matching the vertices of degree @xmath0 of @xmath41 .
a vertex @xmath54 of degree @xmath0 can be matched in two ways . *
if it is matched to another vertex of degree @xmath0 , by shrinking these two vertices we obtain a smaller graph with fewer vertices of degree @xmath0 , and , from proposition [ shrink ] , we know precisely the number of alternating cycles ( here @xmath65-cycles ) lost in the shrinking process , given by the number of genome edges between the two shrinked vertices . *
if it is matched to a vertex of degree less than 3 , then one of the edges incident to @xmath54 is not in any alternating cycle , and we can remove this edge and transform @xmath54 into a vertex of degree @xmath65 ( fig .
[ 3edge ] ) .
now for each @xmath10 , @xmath241 , we can select @xmath242 vertices among all @xmath19 vertices of degree @xmath0 ( there are @xmath243 possibilities ) , compute an arbitrary perfect matching on these @xmath242 vertices , and , for each each remaining vertex of degree @xmath0 , remove an edge incident to this vertex ( there are @xmath244 possibilities ) .
the resulting breakpoint graph @xmath69 is of maximum degree @xmath65 and a median can be computed in time @xmath232 , whose number of alternating cycles needs only to be augmented by the number of edges between matched vertices of degree @xmath0 in @xmath41 .
the number of all such configurations is in @xmath245 ( the term @xmath246 is needed to account for the case @xmath247 ) , which leads to the stated complexity .
in this work , we characterized a large class of tractable instances for the dcj median problem ( with circular median and mixed genomes ) .
in fact , we showed that only the vertices of degree @xmath0 make the problem intractable .
also , by removing @xmath45 edges from the breakpoint graph and decreasing its maximum degree , cost of its median is not bigger than @xmath45 plus the cost of the main median ( i.e. the current cost @xmath248 is a lower bound for the cost of the main median ) .
finally , we showed there is an fpt algorithm for the dcj median problem , if there exists a median such that the number of its edges connecting two vertices of degree @xmath0 is bounded .
our work also shows that the multiplicity of solutions ( i.e. medians ) is likely to happen when dealing with breakpoint graphs with long paths or even cycles , as we showed that such components can admit several optimal medians .
hence , our results , as they stand now , are of interest more for computing the score of a median than for computing actual medians that can be seen as realistic ancestral genomes .
however , the problem of uniform sampling of optimal median is worth being explored , even in the simpler setting of breakpoint graphs of maximum degree @xmath65 in a first time . from a theoretical point of view
, our work raises several questions .
first , it leaves open the possibility that the dcj median problem is fpt . using the number of vertices of degree @xmath0 as a parameter is a a natural approach , although this seems to be a difficult question to address .
the next obvious problem is to extend our approach to the case of a mixed or linear median .
this would require to better understand the combinatorics of odd paths in the breakpoint graphs in relation to medians .
the simpler problem to find an optimal way to remove exactly one edge from each circular chromosome of a circular median while minimizing the number of destroyed alternating cycles is also open .
extending our results to the related _ dcj halving problem _
@xcite is also a natural question .
another interesting question is about expanding the breakpoint distance toward the dcj distance : for two genomes @xmath1 and @xmath2 on @xmath8 genes , their breakpoint distance is equal to @xmath249 the parameters @xmath250 and @xmath251 are also equal the number of 2-cycles and 1-paths ( @xmath252 ) in the breakpoint graph @xmath253 , respectively .
the dcj distance of these genomes is : @xmath254 where @xmath255 and @xmath256 are the number of ( even ) cycles and odd paths in the @xmath253 , respectively .
this motivates us to define a dissimilarity function as follows : @xmath257 where @xmath258 is the number of ( even ) cycles with at most @xmath242 vertices , and @xmath259 is the number of odd paths with at most @xmath260 vertices . by considering this dissimilarity measure , the median problem is tractable when @xmath261 , since @xmath262 . by taking @xmath263
we have @xmath264 , and the median problem would be intractable .
a natural question is then to understand for which values of @xmath10 and/or @xmath265 the median problem is tractable , or fpt .
xu , d. sankoff .
decompositions of multiple breakpoint graphs and rapid exact solutions to the median problem . in _ algorithms in bioinformatics ( wabi 2008 ) _ ,
5251 of _ lecture notes comput .
_ , pp . 2537 .
dcj median problems on linear multichromosomal genomes : graph representation and fast exact solutions . in _ comparative genomics ( recomb - cg 2009 ) _ , vol .
5817 of _ lecture notes comput .
_ , pp . 7083 . | the circular median problem in the double - cut - and - join ( dcj ) distance asks to find , for three given genomes , a fourth circular genome that minimizes the sum of the mutual distances with the three other ones .
this problem has been shown to be np - complete .
we show here that , if the number of vertices of degree @xmath0 in the breakpoint graph of the three input genomes is fixed , then the problem is tractable . |
the busemann - petty problem asks the following question . given two convex origin - symmetric bodies @xmath4 and @xmath5 in @xmath0 such that @xmath6 for every central hyperplane @xmath7 in @xmath0 , does it follow that @xmath8 the answer to this problem in @xmath0 is known to be affirmative if @xmath2 and negative if @xmath3 .
the solution appeared as the result of work of many mathematicians ( see @xcite or @xcite for historical details ) . in this paper
we consider the busemann - petty problem in hyperbolic and spherical spaces in place of the euclidean space .
we prove let @xmath4 and @xmath5 be centrally symmetric convex bodies in the spherical space @xmath9 , @xmath10 ( more precisely in a hemisphere ) such that @xmath11 for every central totally - geodesic hyperplane @xmath7 in @xmath12 .
then @xmath13 on the other hand , if @xmath3 there are convex symmetric bodies @xmath4 , @xmath14 that satisfy ( [ eqn : condition ] ) but @xmath15 so , the answer to the busemann - petty in @xmath9 is exactly the same as in the euclidean space
. however , the situation in the hyperbolic space is different .
trivially , the answer is affirmative if @xmath16 , since the condition ( [ eqn : condition ] ) in this case is equivalent to @xmath17 , but for higher dimensions we have the following : there are convex centrally symmetric bodies @xmath4 , @xmath18 , @xmath19 that satisfy the condition @xmath20 for every central totally - geodesic hyperplane @xmath7 in @xmath21 , but @xmath22 the idea to find analogs of known results in non - euclidean spaces is not new .
for example in @xcite the authors study intrinsic volumes in hyperbolic and spherical spaces . the brunn - minkowski inequality in different spaces is discussed in @xcite .
also a number of papers is concerned with other generalizations of the busemann - petty problem . in our proof
we will be using results from @xcite , where a.zvavitch studied the busemann - petty problem for arbitrary measures .
for other generalizations of the busemann - petty problem see @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite .
let @xmath9 be the unit sphere in @xmath23 . using the stereographic projection ( from the north pole onto the hyperplane containing the equator ) we can think of it as @xmath24 equipped with the metric of constant curvature @xmath25 : @xmath26 where @xmath27 , ... , @xmath28 are the standard euclidean coordinates in @xmath24 .
( see ( * ? ? ?
* , 10 ) , and @xcite for details about the spherical and hyperbolic spaces ) .
it is well - known that geodesic lines on the sphere are great circles .
later on , in order to define convexity , we will need the uniqueness property of geodesics joining given 2 points .
but this is not the case on the sphere .
however if we restrict ourselves to an open hemisphere , then for any two points there exists a unique geodesic segment connecting them . under the stereographic projection the open south hemisphere
gets mapped onto the open unit ball @xmath29 in @xmath24 .
this is the model we will be working in .
the geodesics in this model are arcs of the circles intersecting the boundary of the ball @xmath29 in antipodal points and straight lines through the origin .
also it is well - known that the hyperbolic space @xmath21 can be identified with the interior of the unit ball in @xmath24 with the metric : @xmath30 this is the poincar model of the hyperbolic space in the ball .
note that it can be also obtained from the pseudeosphere in the lorentzian space via the stereographic projection .
the geodesic lines in this model are arcs of the circles orthogonal to the boundary of the ball @xmath29 and straight lines through the origin .
since both geometries are defined in the unit ball in @xmath24 , we will treat them simultaneously , considering the open ball @xmath31 with the metric @xmath32 where @xmath33 for the hyperbolic case , @xmath25 for the spherical space .
in addition if we consider @xmath34 we get the original case of the euclidean space .
the definition of convexity in hyperbolic and spherical spaces ( recall that we work in an open hemisphere ) is analogous to that in the euclidean space ( see ( * ? ? ?
* chapter i , 12 ) ) . a body @xmath4
( compact set with non - empty interior ) is called * convex * if for every pair of points in @xmath4 the geodesic segment joining them also belongs to the body @xmath4 . for our definition of convexity in @xmath9 it
is crucial that we work in an open hemisphere , since in this case we have a unique geodesic segment through any two points .
let @xmath4 be a body in the open unit ball @xmath29 .
in order to distinguish between different types of convexity we will adopt the following system of notations .
the body @xmath4 is called s - convex ( or @xmath25-convex ) , if it is convex in the spherical metric defined in the ball @xmath29 .
similarly it is called h - convex ( or @xmath35-convex ) if it is convex with respect to the hyperbolic metric .
e - convex bodies ( or 0-convex ) are the bodies convex in the usual euclidean sense .
analogously s-(h-,e-)geodesics are the straight lines of the spherical ( hyperbolic , euclidean ) metric .
( in this terminology we follow @xcite .
note that in the literature there are other definitions of h - convexity or @xmath36-convexity which have absolutely different meaning ) .
shown below are some examples of convex hulls of 4 points with respect to hyperbolic , euclidean and spherical metrics correspondingly .
figure 1 clearly , any s - convex body containing the origin is also e - convex and any e - convex body containing the origin is h - convex .
( see for example @xcite ) .
a submanifold @xmath37 in a riemannian space @xmath38 is called * totally geodesic * if every geodesic in @xmath37 is also a geodesic in the space @xmath38 . in the euclidean space
the totally geodesic submanifolds are euclidean planes , on the sphere they are great subspheres . in the poincar model of the hyperbolic space described above the totally geodesic submanifolds
are represented by the spheres orthogonal to the boundary of the unit ball @xmath29 and euclidean planes through the origin . in a sense , totally geodesic submanifolds
are analogs of euclidean planes in riemannian spaces . for elementary properties of totally geodesic submanifolds
see ( * ? ? ?
* chap.5 , 5 ) .
the * minkowski functional * of a star - shaped origin - symmetric body @xmath39 is defined as @xmath40 the * radial function * of @xmath4 is given by @xmath41 . if @xmath42 then the radial function @xmath43 is the euclidean distance from the origin to the boundary of @xmath4 in the direction of @xmath44 .
for a centrally - symmetric @xmath36-convex body @xmath45 ( @xmath46 ) consider the section of @xmath4 by the hypersurface @xmath47 , where @xmath48 is the euclidean scalar product .
clearly such a hypersurface is a totally geodesic hyperplane in the metric ( [ eqn : metric ] ) for any @xmath46 .
this hyperplane passes through the origin with the normal vector @xmath49 .
the volume element of the metric ( [ eqn : metric ] ) equals @xmath50 therefore the volume of a body @xmath4 is given by the formula : @xmath51 note that in polar coordinates the latter formula looks as follows : @xmath52 similarly the volume element of the hypersurface @xmath53 is @xmath54 therefore the @xmath55-volume of the section of @xmath4 by the hyperplane @xmath53 is given by the formula : @xmath56 one of the tools of this paper is the fourier transform of distributions .
the fourier transform of a distribution @xmath57 is defined by @xmath58 for every test function @xmath59 from the space @xmath60 of rapidly decreasing infinitely differentiable functions on @xmath61 .
a distribution is called * positive definite * if for every test function @xmath59 @xmath62 by l.schwartzs generalization of bochner s theorem , a distribution is positive definite if and only if its fourier transform is a positive distribution ( in the sense that @xmath63 for every non - negative test function @xmath59 ; see , for example , @xcite ) .
the spherical radon transform @xmath64 is defined by @xmath65 the following lemma , due to a.koldobsky , gives a relation between the spherical radon transform and the fourier transform .
[ lem : radon](@xcite , lemma 4 ) let @xmath66 be an even homogeneous function of degree @xmath67 on @xmath68 , @xmath69 , so that @xmath70 then @xmath71 the latter equality means that @xmath72 is a homogeneous function of degree @xmath35 on @xmath0 , whose values on @xmath73 are equal to @xmath74 .
now we derive a formula for the function @xmath75 using the fourier transform , similar to @xcite .
for @xmath34 this is the formula from ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 1 ) .
[ lem : main ] let @xmath4 be an origin - symmetric @xmath36-convex body in @xmath29 with minkowski functional @xmath76 .
let @xmath77 and @xmath53 be the hyperplane through the origin orthogonal to @xmath49
. then the volume of the section of the body @xmath4 by the hyperplane @xmath53 in the metric ( [ eqn : metric ] ) equals @xmath78 * proof . *
passing to spherical coordinates we get : @xmath79 we can rewrite the integral above as follows ( note that @xmath80 , since @xmath42 ) : @xmath81 the function under the spherical integral is a homogeneous function of @xmath44 of degree @xmath67 and therefore by lemma [ lem : radon ] : @xmath78
first we construct counterexamples to the busemann - petty problem in @xmath82 and @xmath83 for @xmath3
. * proof .
* we will show the proof only for the case of the spherical space , the hyperbolic case is similar .
the idea here is to use the property that any riemannian space locally looks as almost " euclidean .
let @xmath4 and @xmath5 be convex origin - symmetric bodies in @xmath61 that give a counterexample to the original busemann - petty problem .
that is @xmath85 for every central hyperplane @xmath7 , but @xmath86 ( here we denote the usual euclidean volume by evol to avoid confusion with the spherical volume . ) in fact , since the inequality ( [ eqn : vol ] ) is strict , we can dilate one of the bodies a little to make the inequality ( [ eqn : sections ] ) strict .
recall also , that in the original counterexample the body @xmath5 was strictly convex , and the body @xmath4 was obtained from the body @xmath5 by small perturbations .
note that @xmath4 can also be made strictly convex . in view of the latter remarks
, we will assume that @xmath4 and @xmath5 are strictly convex origin - symmetric bodies that satisfy the strict version of ( [ eqn : sections ] ) .
moreover , there exists an @xmath87 such that @xmath88 for all @xmath7 and @xmath89 clearly , any dilations @xmath90 and @xmath91 also provide a counterexample .
we can take @xmath92 so small that both bodies @xmath4 and @xmath5 lie in a ball of radius @xmath93 that satisfies the inequality : @xmath94 to finish the proof we only need to show that if @xmath4 is a strictly e - convex body , then @xmath90 is s - convex for sufficiently small @xmath92 . consider the boundary of the body @xmath4 .
define @xmath97 where @xmath98 , @xmath99 , ... , @xmath100 , are the principal curvatures at the point @xmath44 on the boundary of @xmath4 .
since @xmath4 is strictly e - convex the quantity defined above is strictly positive : @xmath101 . for the body
@xmath90 it is equal to @xmath102 . on the other hand in a small neighborhood of the origin
the totally geodesic s - planes are the spheres with almost zero curvature ( from the euclidean point of view ) .
consider all the spheres , which are totally geodesic in the spherical metric and tangent to the body @xmath90 , and let @xmath103 be the smallest radius of all such spheres .
we can choose an @xmath92 so small that @xmath104 and therefore the body @xmath90 lies on one side with respect to any tangent totally geodesic s - hyperplane .
hence @xmath90 is s - convex . in 1988
e.lutwak @xcite introduced the concept of intersection body and proved that the busemann - petty problem has affirmative answer if the body with smaller sections is an intersection body .
later , in @xcite a.koldobsky proved that a body @xmath4 is an intersection body if and only if @xmath105 is a positive definite distribution .
then in @xcite a.koldobsky generalized lutwak s connection using the following parseval s formula on the sphere : [ cor : parseval ] let @xmath57 and @xmath108 be functions on @xmath0 , continuous on @xmath73 and homogeneous of degree @xmath35 and @xmath67 respectively .
suppose that @xmath57 represents a positive definite distribution .
then there exists a measure @xmath109 on @xmath73 such that @xmath110 later , a.zvavitch ( @xcite ) solved the busemann - petty problem for arbitrary measures .
namely , let @xmath111 be a locally integrable function on @xmath0 , and @xmath112 a function on @xmath0 , locally integrable on central hyperplanes .
then let @xmath113 be the measure on @xmath0 with density @xmath111 and @xmath114 be the @xmath55-dimensional measure on central hyperplanes with density @xmath112 such that @xmath115 is an increasing function of @xmath116 for any fixed @xmath44 .
then if @xmath117 is a positive definite distribution on @xmath0 then the busemann - petty problem for these measures has affirmative answer , i.e. @xmath118 implies @xmath119 .
our next result is a particular case of zvavitch s theorem , but for the sake of completeness we include a proof .
let @xmath4 and @xmath5 be @xmath120convex origin - symmetric bodies in @xmath29 such that @xmath121 is a positive definite distribution . if @xmath122 for every totally geodesic hyperplane through the origin , then @xmath123 so we only need to show that @xmath135 but this follows from the assumption of the theorem , the parseval s formula on the sphere ( corollary [ cor : parseval ] ) and formula for the volume of central sections ( lemma [ lem : main ] ) .
indeed , let @xmath109 be the measure from corollary [ cor : parseval ] corresponding to the fourier transform of the positive definite distribution @xmath136 , then @xmath137 since @xmath105 is positive definite for any convex origin - symmetric body in @xmath0 , @xmath2 ( see @xcite ) , the previous theorem implies the affirmative part of the original busemann - petty problem in @xmath0 . * proof .
* i ) consider a h - convex origin - symmetric body @xmath141 , @xmath2 .
define a body @xmath142 by the formula : @xmath143 it is enough to show that @xmath142 is e - convex .
if we pass to polar coordinates then the map @xmath144 transforms the body @xmath4 into the body @xmath142 .
take two points in @xmath4 and connect them by a hyperbolic segment .
this segment belongs to @xmath4 since @xmath4 is h - convex .
consider the 2-dimensional plane through the origin and these 2 points .
the section of the body @xmath4 by this plane is a 2-dimensional h - convex body .
introduce polar coordinates on this plane and ( without loss of generality ) assume that the h - geodesic segment has the equation @xmath145 . applying the above transformation one can see that this h - segment gets mapped into an e - segment given by the equation @xmath146 . therefore the body @xmath142 is e - convex and @xmath147 is positive in dimensions @xmath2 ( see @xcite ) .
[ thm : gks](@xcite , theorem 1 ) let @xmath4 be an origin - symmetric star body in @xmath0 with @xmath151 boundary , and let @xmath152 , @xmath153 .
suppose that @xmath77 , and let @xmath154 be the corresponding parallel section function of @xmath4 : @xmath155 .
( a ) if @xmath156 is even , then @xmath157 ( b ) if @xmath156 is odd , then @xmath158 where @xmath159 stands for the derivative of the order @xmath156 and the fourier transform is considered in the sense of distributions .
let @xmath5 be a circular cylinder of radius @xmath164 with @xmath27 being its axis of revolution .
( see fig.2 ) to the top and bottom of the cylinder attach spherical caps , that are totally geodesic in the spherical metric .
clearly the body @xmath5 constructed this way is e - convex and therefore h - convex . using the formula latexmath:[\[\label{eqn : m } clearly the body @xmath142 is the image of @xmath5 under the map ( [ eqn : map ] ) .
it can be checked directly that the cylinder is mapped into the surface of revolution obtained by rotating the hyperbola @xmath166 about the @xmath27-axis , and the top and bottom spherical caps are mapped into flat disks .
in fact the body @xmath5 constructed above is not smooth .
but we can approximate it by infinitely smooth e - convex bodies that differ from @xmath5 only in a small neighborhood of the edges . since the body @xmath142 is obtained from @xmath5 by ( [ eqn : m ] ) , and the denominator in ( [ eqn : m ] )
is never equal to zero , the body @xmath142 is also infinitely smooth .
( now that the bodies @xmath5 and @xmath142 are smooth , figure 2 might be confusing , but we wanted to make it as simple as possible , just to emphasize the idea ) .
let the height of the cylindrical part of @xmath5 be equal to @xmath171 and the hight of its image under ( [ eqn : map ] ) equal to @xmath172 .
if @xmath173 tends to zero , the top and bottom parts of the body @xmath5 get closer to the sphere @xmath174 . recalling the definition of the radial function of @xmath142 :
@xmath175 one can see that the the body @xmath142 becomes larger in the direction of @xmath27 as @xmath176 , and therefore its height @xmath172 approaches infinity .
now apply a standard argument to construct another body @xmath4 which along with the body @xmath4 provides a counterexample to the hyperbolic busemann - petty problem ( cf .
@xcite , theorem 2 or @xcite , theorem 2 ) . by continuity of @xmath147
there is a neighborhood of @xmath49 where this function is negative .
let @xmath185 choose a non - positive infinitely - smooth even function @xmath186 supported on @xmath187 .
extend @xmath186 to a homogeneous function @xmath188 of degree @xmath35 on @xmath0 . by lemma 5 from @xcite
we know that the fourier transform of @xmath189 is equal to @xmath190 for some infinitely smooth function @xmath108 on @xmath73 .
note that in our construction @xmath5 is e - convex , but we can perturb it a little ( by adding @xmath195 small enough ) , so we can assume that l is strictly e - convex .
therefore one can choose @xmath173 small enough such that @xmath4 is also e - convex ( for details see @xcite , proposition 2 ) .
hence we can assume that both @xmath5 and @xmath4 are h - convex .
proceeding as in the proof of theorem [ thm : main ] we can show the opposite inequality for volumes .
since the body @xmath5 is infinitely smooth , one can use the parseval s formula in the form of lemma [ lem : parseval ] : @xmath197 j.bourgain , gaoyong zhang , _ on a generalization of the busemann - petty problem _ , convex geometric analysis ( berkeley , ca , 1996 ) , 65 - 76 , math .
publ . , * 34 * , cambriddge univ.press , cambridge , 1999 .
b.a.dubrovin , a.t.fomenko , s.p.novikov , _ modern geometry - methods and applications .
part i. the geometry of surfaces , transformation groups , and fields .
second edition _
, springer - verlag , new york , 1992 . | the busemann - petty problem asks whether origin - symmetric convex bodies in @xmath0 with smaller central hyperplane sections necessarily have smaller @xmath1-dimensional volume .
it is known that the answer to this problem is affirmative if @xmath2 and negative if @xmath3 .
we study this problem in hyperbolic and spherical spaces . |
it has been recognized that important particle physics ingredients including gauge symmetry and chiral matter can be realized in type ii superstring models using the mechanism of intersecting d - branes @xcite .
more recently , this method has been extensively progressed and it is now possible to investigate some stringy effects which could give rise to deeper details seen in particle physics . in particular , d - brane instantons wrapping non trivial cycles in the internal manifold have been particularly explored in this regard @xcite .
they give non - perturbative superpotential corrections which could explain the large mass hierarchies including the smallness of neutrino masses in the standard model ( sm ) @xcite .
many works have been done along these lines using configurations realizing mssm - like orientifolded models based on quiver approach . in this way , rather than considering full string theory models , working at the level of quivers allow for dealing with many important physical effects .
indeed , one could examine the possible presence or absence of couplings and other physical effects by considering quantum numbers associated with the quiver configuration data .
more precisely , many investigations have been performed for mssm - like orientifolded models satisfying necessary constraints allowing for hierarchical mass terms for all three families of quarks and leptons .
this can be approached using either extra singlet fields that string theory compactifications contain or via euclidean d - brane wrapping non trivial cycles producing e - instantons which we are interested in here @xcite .
they exhibit the so called uncharged modes consisting of fermion modes @xmath5 preserving half of the bulk supersymmetry breaking @xmath6 to @xmath7 and the four bosonic modes @xmath8 , which are associated with breakdown of four - dimensional poincar invariance .
these kinds of uncharged zero modes appear if the instantons wrap non - rigid three - cycles in the internal manifold
. however , the charged fermionic zero modes @xmath9 appearing at the intersection between e - instantons and d - branes are crucial in the determination of superpotential corrections to four dimensional effective field theories .
the non - perturbative contributions are given by performing the path integral over all fermionic zero modes .
to get superpotential terms , one must ensure that all uncharged fermionic zero modes , apart from @xmath8 and @xmath10 , are projected out or lifted . in type iia superstring for instance
, this can be done by considering e2-instantons obtained from d2-branes wrapping rigid orientifold - invariant 3-cycles embedded in the internal space @xcite .
these are referred to as rigid @xmath11 instantons , which will be discussed here . in this picture , when instanton effects do not give rise to phenomenological inconveniences , they therefore represent a way in which one can give rise to viable mass hierarchies for the quarks and leptons as well as the smallness of neutrino masses . in this paper
we contribute to these activities by performing a discussion of mass hierarchies based on a type iia four - stack quiver orientifolded model in the presence of e2-instanton effects .
more precisely , we focus on @xmath12 quiver gauge theory based on intersecting d6-brane configurations with instanton corrections to the corresponding effective superpotential . for simplicity , we consider @xmath11-instantons wrapping rigid oriontifold - invariant cycles and carrying the right global @xmath13 charges through the @xmath14 . then we give the corresponding mssm - like quiver with the instanton corrections .
compared to perturbatively allowed superpotential terms of the heavy fields , the scales of the induced terms of the light fields depend on the suppression factors of e2-instantons which may induce them with some combinations with the string scale @xmath15 through higher order terms .
this mechanism offers a stringy framework to explain the fermion mass hierarchies in the quiver method . including the left - handed neutrino masses in the analysis
, we get the order of magnitude of the relevant instanton effects and recover the string scale upper bound @xmath16 .
the organization of this paper is as follows . in section 2
, we build a quiver gauge theory realizing mssm - like orientifolded models based on four stacks of intersecting d6-branes . in section 3
, we study the fermion mass hierarchies by introducing the possible stringy corrections to the corresponding superpotential using o(1 ) e2-instantons then we give the corresponding quiver .
their suppression magnitudes have been estimated .
section 4 will be devoted to our discussions .
in this section , we will give a quiver model based on four - stack of d6-branes embedded in iia superstring moving on orientifolded geometry .
the gauge theory lives on d6-branes wrapping four - dimensional minkowski space and non trivial 3-cycles in the internal manifold @xcite .
it is recalled that d6-branes carry ramond - ramond charges that should be cancelled by the introduction of orientifold geometries related to fixed point loci of an antiholomorphic involution acting on the internal space . in such quiver models ,
the bifundamental chiral matter arises at the non - trivial intersection of two generic d6-branes .
it turns out that , one can have symmetric or anti - symmetric tensor representations where a d6-brane intersects its image brane under the orientifold action .
furthermore , two given d6-branes might intersect in multiple points on the compact internal space , giving rise to multiple families , where the number of families is the topological intersection number of two 3-cycles belonging to middle dimensional cohomology .
indeed , a stack of @xmath17 d6-branes wrapping 3-cycles gives rise to @xmath18 gauge symmetry .
however , @xmath17 d6-branes wrapped on cycles which are homologically - fixed or pointwise - fixed by the orientifold action give rise to @xmath19 and @xmath20 gauge symmetry , respectively .
since @xmath21 is isomorphic to @xmath22 , the @xmath23 of the mssm - like models can be realized as a @xmath21 arising from a d6-brane stack wrapping an orientifold invariant 3-cycle . in this regard ,
the sm gauge symmetry and the matter content can be accommodated in the gauge group @xmath24 ) obtained from three stacks of d6-branes . enlarging the gauge group can make the model richer .
this can be done by assuming that one has an appropriate middle dimensional cohomology generated by non trivial 3-cycles .
the model we consider here relies on a four stacks of d6-branes giving rise to the following gauge symmetry @xmath25with a gauged flavor group @xmath26 distinguishing various quarks from each others .
roughly , the tadpole conditions imply the vanishing of non - abelian anomalies , while abelian and mixed anomalies are canceled via the green - schwarz mechanism .
generically , the anomalous @xmath27 acquire a mass and survive only as global symmetries , which forbid various couplings on the perturbative level .
since the sm gauge symmetries contain the abelian symmetry @xmath28 , and the @xmath21 does not exhibit a @xmath29 which could contribute to the hypercharge , one requires that a linear combination of @xmath30 remains massless .
thus , the resulting gauge group in four - dimensional spacetime can be written as @xmath31given the above gauge symmetry based on d6-brane configurations , we can construct a quiver describing mssm - like orientifolded model .
indeed , vanishing of anomalies which we require to be satisfied are used to fit the matter content involving two up quarks , one down quark charged under the @xmath32 gauge symmetry and the opposite arrangement charged under @xmath33 the model we present here relies on a particular intersection numbers of 3-cycles in middle dimensional cohomology . for that
, we choose the following intersections ] @xmath34the other intersection numbers are set to zero .
the chiral spectrum and the gauge symmetry can be represented in the table 1 together with their identification with sm matter fields .
.the spectrum and their @xmath35 charges for @xmath36 .
the index @xmath37 denotes the family index [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] in this description , all leptons and the two higgs doublets are charged under @xmath38 symmetries while for quarks only their right handed partners are . the model with four stacks can be encoded in a quiver where each node represents a d6-brane and the links between them indicate their chiral intersections .
the quiver summarizing the above spectrum with the two higgses is shown in figure 1 ) gauge group .
, width=340 ] since any realistic string vacua has to exhibit the phenomenologically desired terms in four dimensional effective superpotential , we require the presence of all the mssm yukawa couplings and the absence of the phenomenologically undesired couplings terms on perturbative level . in
what follows , the @xmath38 symmetries will be used to select the candidate terms for the superpotential . taking into account the charges presented in the table 1 , we can write down the all allowed interaction terms generating the possible yukawa couplings .
it turns out that , the only fields involved in the allowed perturbative interaction terms are those charged under the @xmath39 gauge symmetry .
we interpret them as the the heavy quarks @xmath40 , leptons @xmath41 and the @xmath42 term for @xmath43 @xmath44 .
this could be seen at the level of their associated quantum numbers @xmath45here the index @xmath46 denotes the family index and the subscript indicates the charge under the @xmath47 symmetries .
our quiver naturally allows for the following couplings @xmath48where @xmath49 are coupling constants accounting for hierarchies between these terms .
the absent couplings , which are phenomenologically desired , corresponding to fermions charged under @xmath26 violate the @xmath38 symmetries .
these will be refered to the light fermions @xmath50 that will be yielded massless , unless some kind of new effects in the defined effective field theory break the remnants abelian symmetries @xmath38 . in string theory , the natural candidate
non - perturbative effects to violate these @xmath38 symmetries are instantons arising from euclidean d - branes coupling to these fields @xcite .
they can potentially destabilize the vacuum or lead to new effects in the four - dimensional effective action . in what follows
, we will discuss the implication of such non perturbative effects in our quiver model .
in particular , we will consider orientifolded invariant 3-cycles on which d2-branes can wrap to make rigid @xmath11 instantons .
then , we discuss fermion mass hierarchies in such instanton configurations .
in this section we introduce the effects of spacetime instantons on the above described model . in type iia superstring model , such non - perturbative effects are generated in principle from d0 , d2 and d4-branes wrapping one , three and five - cycles respectively . however , since a calabi - yau manifold does not have any continuous one and five - cycles , the only relevant instantons are d2-branes wrapped on three - cycles in the internal manifold @xcite .
roughly , the resulting d2-instanton action takes the follwing form @xmath51 in this equation , @xmath52 describes all terms involving fermionic instanton zero modes and four dimensional charged matter fields @xmath53 while @xmath54 is the dirac born - infeld action on d2-brane wrapping a 3-cycle @xmath55 in the presence of the wz term .
this action reads as @xmath56where @xmath57 is the r - r 3-from coupled to the d2-brane . in four dimensions , the instanton contributions to the low energy
effective theory can be obtained by performing the grassmann path integral over all fermionic zero modes @xmath58 : @xmath59 e^{-s_{e}}={\underset{n}{\pi } } \phi _ { n}e^{-s_{e}^{cl}}. \label{eq8}\]]the classical instanton action @xmath60 can absorb the @xmath61 s charge excess of the matter fields operator @xmath62 @xcite . under such abelian symmetries
the transformation property of the exponential instanton action is @xmath63where @xmath64 represents the amount of the u(1)-charge violation by the @xmath65-instantons .
their microscopic origin is in the extra fermionic zero modes @xmath58 living in the intersection of the e2-branes with the @xmath66 branes . instead of being general ,
let us consider a concrete configuration with @xmath65-intantons wrap rigid orientifold - invariant 3-cycles . in this case
, the @xmath67 and @xmath68 are identified .
so , an @xmath65-instanton intersecting @xmath69-branes can induce the desired couplings of the matter fields operator @xmath70 @xmath71 @xmath72 .
the @xmath38 charges which are carried by the instanton action have their origin in the intersection @xmath73 pattern .
for an instanton wrapping a 3-cycle with an appropriate number of times , this can be made exactly opposite to the total charge of the operator @xmath74 , so the coupling ( 8) is also @xmath38-invariant .
examining the @xmath75 charge - excess for each term , we determine the intersection @xmath73 pattern giving rise to the right charged fermionic zero modes @xmath76 @xmath77 compensating the @xmath75 charge - excess of the desired couplings .
indeed , the up - quark coupling term @xmath78violate the @xmath38 symmetries by one unit as @xmath79 then is generated by an instanton @xmath80 intersecting @xmath69 branes with the following intersection numbers @xmath81which gives rise to two charged modes @xmath82
@xmath83 @xmath84these charges compensate the charge - excess of the up - quark term . in this case
, the corresponding e2-instanton action takes the following form @xmath85performing the integration over the all fermionic zero mode , one get the desired term @xmath86analogous analysis can be done for the down and strange quark coupling terms @xmath87this can be generated by an @xmath88-instanton intersecting the @xmath69-branes with the following intersection numbers @xmath89and producing the two charged modes @xmath90 @xmath91 .
for the sector of neutrinos , the following higher order term @xmath92could be generated by a @xmath93-instanton intersecting @xmath69-branes .
the corresponding intersection numbers are given by @xmath94this leads to the charged modes @xmath95 @xmath96 .
integrating over the all above fermionic zero modes as in ( eq14 ) , we get the missing superpotential terms at the four - dimensional theory @xmath97where the coupling constants @xmath98 can account for hierarchies between the @xmath99 and @xmath100 quarks having the same instanton suppression . the neutrinos superpotential term is highly suppressed by @xmath101 factor and once higgs fields get a vev @xmath102 this operator gives rise directly to majorana masses for the left - handed neutrinos depending on the scale @xmath15 taken as the low string scale at which neutrino masses have origin . the quiver illustrating these instanton intersection patterns with their appropriate charged fermionic zero modes is depicted in the figure2 .
-instantons and dotted lines indicate their intersections with the @xmath69-branes.,width=340 ] recall that the exponential suppression effects can be derived from the classical instanton actions .
their magnitudes depend on the internal geometry on which the quiver model is based .
in particular , they depend on the complex structure moduli space described by the volume of the 3-cycles wrapped by the relevant instantons .
to have an idea about the induced mass hierarchies , we need to estimate the different instanton factors .
although such approach forces to consider deeper details of the fully defined string model , we can get an order of magnitude of the different suppression factors by refereing to the known data . effectively , after the higgs fields break the electroweak symmetry at the usual scale @xmath103 @xmath104 , we take the quark couplings terms of eq([eq19 ] ) together with the quark coupling terms of eq ( [ eq5 ] ) with some assumption on their scalar - fermion couplings to derive the expected magnitudes . for that , using some combination of the quark masses where their net scalar - fermion couplings effect could be neglegted , one allows for getting approximate values of the corresponding suppression factors . for the @xmath105-quark suppression factor , assuming @xmath106 and @xmath107 , we find @xmath108while for the @xmath99 and @xmath100-quark suppression factors with @xmath109 , we get @xmath110similarly , using the known data with neutrino masses upper bound @xmath111 @xmath112 we find the neutrino high suppression factor@xmath113considering the usual value of the string scale , namely @xmath114 , the e2-instanton induced operator only leads to subleading corrections to the neutrino masses . their observed order can be obtained by lowering the string scale due to large internal dimensions @xcite . lowering the string scale down to the @xmath115 scale ,
this leads to the interesting features at the lhc . from ( [ eq21 ] )
, we can deduce the string scale upper bound @xmath116investigating the above instanton suppression factors ( [ eq20 ] ) and ( eq21 ) and specializing the case that the d6-branes and the e2-branes wrap factorizable three - cycles of toroidal orientifolds , the volume of these instantons could give an insight of the detailed description of geometric background of the internal manifold .
we believe that this connection deserves to be studied further .
in this paper , we have discussed the fermion mass hierarchies in a local four - stack intersecting mssm - like d - brane quiver models using non perturbative stringy effects .
more precisely , we have focused on a four - stack of d6-brane configurations in type iia orientifolded geometries giving rise to the mssm - like spectrum without right handed - neutrinos including rigid o(1 ) e2-instantons . in particular , we have given a quiver model from which we have shown that some perturbatively absent coupling terms can be generated from d2-branes wrapping 3-cycles belonging to middle dimensional cohomology of the internal space .
analyzing the quiver allows for the determination of perturbatively and non - perturbatively contributions to the superpotential using the abelian symmetries obeyed at the perturbative regime . in this approach , attributing the perturbatively realized terms to the heavy fermions and the remaining missing desired terms to the light fermions reflects interesting hierarchies .
the latters are induced and exponentially suppressed by e2-instantons carrying the right charged fermionic zero modes appearing at the e2-d6 intersections .
these stringy corrections do not induce the perturbatively forbidden dangerous proton decay terms through the dimension 5 operators @xmath117 and @xmath118 .
such kinds of local intersecting d - brane models have been discussed extensively in @xcite .
these models , which include phenomenological constraints of fast proton decay are listed in @xcite .
however , the presented model does not appear in that classification since it does not involve right - handed neutrinos in addition to the lepton number violation that arises through @xmath119 and @xmath120 terms induced by the @xmath80 instanton required to generate the missing up - quark mass term . despite
, it should be interesting to make contact with the models given in @xcite .
we believe that this connection deserves more study .
this will be reported elsewhere . using the known data with neutrino masses
@xmath1 @xmath2 @xmath3 @xmath121 , we have given the magnitudes of the relevant instanton effects and the string scale upper bound @xmath122
@xmath123 imposed to match with the observed order of the known data . in the end of this work
, a possible discussion could be done in terms of middle dimensional cohomology of the internal space describing its complex structure .
the analysis depends on the volume of the 3-cycles on which d2-branes wrap to make rigid o(1 ) instantons .
it should be very nice to find a geometrical interpretation in terms of quiver data encoded in the middle dimensional cohomology .
we believe that it will be useful to explore extended dynking geometries involving more than bosonic vertices .
this seems to be promising in type iib d5-branes set - up in the presence of d - strings wrapping 2-cycles making instantons . | using instanton effects , we discuss the problem of fermion mass hierarchies in an mssm - like type iia orientifolded model with @xmath0 gauge symmetry obtained from intersecting d6-branes . in the corresponding four - stack quiver , the different scales of the generated superpotential couplings offer a partial solution to fermion mass hierarchies . using the known data with neutrino masses
@xmath1 @xmath2 @xmath3 @xmath4 , we give the magnitudes of the relevant scales .
* keywords * : type iia superstring , instanton effects and yukawa couplings . |
the question of coexistence of singlet superconductivity and magnetism has been adressed for many years .
it was found that the superconducting order parameter is destroyed by a magnetic field both via the orbital effect @xcite and the paramagnetic effect.@xcite in the usual case of an isotropic three - dimensional ( 3d ) superconductor under an external magnetic field , the orbital effect prevails and leads to the well - known temperature - field phase diagram of conventional type i or ii superconductors.@xcite in contrast , superconductivity is essentially suppressed by the paramagnetic effect in presence of a ferromagnetic exchange interaction .
this is also true for quasi - two - dimensional ( 2d ) superconductors under in - plane magnetic field and for heavy fermions materials wherein the orbital effect is partially quenched . in the whole paper ,
the magnetism is characterized by an internal exchange field @xmath1 ( given in energy units ) which may arise either from an externally applied magnetic field or from ferromagnetic ordering .
note that ferromagnetism must be weak in order to avoid complete suppression of superconductivity .
this is realized in rare - earth metals or actinides in which the indirect exchange interaction leads to curie temperatures of a few degrees .
superconductors with internal homogeneous exchange field @xmath1 exhibit a very special behaviour . according to chandrasekhar@xcite and clogston,@xcite at zero temperature uniform superconductivity should be destroyed when the polarization energy of the free electron gas exceeds the energy gain due to cooper pairing in the bcs ground state .
this criterion gives the exchange field @xmath2 where the superconductor should undergo a first - order transition to the normal state , @xmath3 being the zero temperature superconducting gap .
larkin and ovchinnikov @xcite and fulde and ferrell @xcite ( fflo ) predicted the existence of a nonuniform superconducting state with higher critical exchange field @xmath4 and second - order transition to the normal state .
this prediction was made for 3d superconductors . in quasi-2d superconductors
the critical exchange field of the fflo state is even higher , namely @xmath5,@xcite while in quasi - one - dimensional systems there is no paramagnetic limit at all.@xcite the appearance of the modulated fflo state is related to the pairing of electrons with opposite spins which do not have the opposite momenta anymore due to the zeeman splitting . from now on we focus on the 2d case for which a generic temperature - exchange field phase diagram has been established.@xcite at low field and temperature , the ground state is characterized by a uniform superconducting order parameter .
a tricritical point , located at @xmath6 and @xmath7 , is the meeting point of three transition lines separating the normal metal , the uniform and the nonuniform superconductors . at @xmath8 , the ( low - field ) uniform superconductor
is separated from the ( high - field ) normal metal by a narrow fflo nonuniform superconducting phase .
in contrast , at @xmath9 , the system undergoes merely a second - order phase transition from the uniform superconductor to the normal metal when increasing the exchange field .
the nonuniform fflo state is settled in a small region of the phase diagram and is very sensitive to impurities,@xcite making it difficult to observe experimentally .
nevertheless , several evidences of the fflo state have been obtained recently in organic superconductors @xcite and in heavy fermions compounds , see martin _ _ et al.__@xcite and references therein . in the context of organic and high-@xmath10 superconductors , layered systems made of conducting atomic planes
have been extensively studied.@xcite in order to investigate the interplay of superconductivity and magnetism in such anisotropic systems,@xcite andreev _ et al . _ considered a periodic array of alternating ferromagnetic and superconducting 2d planes.@xcite solving the corresponding gorkov equations , these authors established the existence of a @xmath0 state wherein each f layer separates superconducting planes with opposite order parameter .
this is relevant for the ruthenocuprate compound rusr@xmath11gdcu@xmath11o@xmath12 which comprises cuo@xmath11 superconducting planes and ruo@xmath11 magnetic planes.@xcite a related system is an isolated f / s / f trilayer which exhibits the so - called superconducting spin - valve effect .
namely , its critical temperature is higher in the antiparallel ( ap ) orientation of the layers magnetizations than in the parallel ( p ) orientation both for thick layers@xcite and atomic size layers.@xcite surprisingly , in the atomic thickness limit , the superconducting gap at zero temperature is higher for p orientation of the magnetizations.@xcite hence one expects a transition from ap to p orientation by cooling the system below a finite crossing temperature .
the recent progress in molecular beam epitaxy@xcite enables to fabricate such f / s / f trilayer with atomic thicknesses . in this paper
, we consider a periodic array of sf bilayers .
each bilayer is made of two atomic planes coupled by single electron tunneling .
both exchange fields and bcs superconducting pairing are present in each sf plane .
the possibility of @xmath13 phase difference between the planes inside each bilayer is also taken into account . in the whole paper , we assume that the coupling @xmath14 between successive bilayers is considerably weaker than the intra - bilayer coupling @xmath15 .
our study is performed within the framework of the bcs theory of s - wave superconductivity .
solving exactly the gorkov equations in the limit @xmath16 , we first derive the critical temperature and the superconducting gap both for parallel ( p ) and antiparallel ( ap ) orientation of the magnetizations .
we show that the critical temperature is higher for the ap orientation than for the p orientation whereas it is the opposite for the zero temperature gap .
we also investigate the interlayer josephson current in the small coupling limit : the current increases as a function of the exchange field for ap orientation whereas it is field - independent for the p orientation .
furthermore , we find that for low exchange fields and high temperatures , the ground state corresponds to identical superconducting order parameters on adjacent layers . for high enough fields and/or low enough temperatures
, the @xmath0 phase ground state is favoured and compete with the fflo state . for the p orientation ,
the full temperature - exchange field phase diagram is constructed in the two limits of extremely low and high coupling between the planes . as expected , for perturbative coupling between two sf planes ,
the phase diagram is very close to the quasi-2d superconductor s phase diagram .
nevertheless an important change arises .
indeed a new @xmath17phase is inserted inside the usual fflo phase close to the tricritical point . for higher
tunneling coupling @xmath18 , this @xmath17 phase is pushed to low temperatures @xmath19 and high fields @xmath20 . in this unusual superconducting phase ,
the zeeman splitting is compensated by the bonding / antibonding energy splitting due to single - electron tunneling between the planes.@xcite as a result , field - induced superconductivity and enhanced paramagnetic limit are realized in this simple model .
these new phenomena are encountered due to the introduction of an additional discrete degree of freedom , here the layer index @xmath21 .
the layer index acts as a pseudo - spin and thus enlarges the usual spin - space for singlet pairing .
this idea was introduced by kulic and hofmann@xcite in the context of two - bands superconductivity for which the pseudo - spin was the band index .
nevertheless , these authors did not investigate the presently studied @xmath0 state .
the outline of the paper is the following .
in sec.ii , we present the model , derive the corresponding gorkov equations and give their exact solutions . in sec.iii , we investigate the critical temperature , the gap and the interlayer josephson current in the small exchange field regime for which there are only uniform superconducting phases . in the last two sections
the temperature - exchange field phase diagram of the bilayer is studied thoroughly . in sec.iv
, we first construct a ginzburg - landau functional to determine the transitions between the different phases in the low interlayer coupling limit .
sec.v is devoted to the opposite limit of strong interlayer coupling . in conclusion
, we discuss the conditions for the observation of field - induced superconductivity .
we consider a superconducting ferromagnetic bilayer ( see fig.1 ) constituted of two superconducting atomic layers , labeled as @xmath22 and @xmath23 . in the whole article , we assume @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the interlayer coupling energy and @xmath26 the fermi energy . as a consequence
, cooper pairs are localized within each plane.@xcite each layer @xmath21 supports a superconducting singlet bcs coupling with the energy gap @xmath27 and an internal exchange field @xmath28 .
the hamiltonian of the system can be written as @xmath29 + h_{t}\text { , } \label{hamiltonien}%\ ] ] where @xmath30 is the attractive bcs interaction constant and @xmath31 is the two - dimensional coordinate within each layer . for the layer @xmath21 the kinetic and zeeman parts of the hamiltonian are written together as @xmath32 in which summation over repeated spin indexes @xmath33 and @xmath34 is implied .
creation ( resp .
annihilation ) operator of an electron with spin @xmath33 and two - dimensional momentum @xmath35 in the layer @xmath21 is denoted @xmath36 ( resp .
@xmath37 ) .
the exchange fields @xmath28 are assumed to be either equal ( @xmath38 ) or opposite ( @xmath39 ) . as a consequence
the matrix @xmath40 is spin - diagonal , and the zeeman effect manifests itself in breaking the spin degeneracy of the electronic energy levels according to @xmath41 \text{,}%\ ] ] where @xmath42 .
the s - wave singlet superconductivity is represented by the standard mean - field hamiltonian @xmath43 \text{,}%\ ] ] and the layers are coupled together by the hopping hamiltonian @xmath44 \text { .}%\ ] ] in order to investigate the occurence of modulated superconducting phases ( fflo ) , we choose the following spatial dependence for the superconducting order parameter @xmath45 where @xmath46 is the fflo modulation wave vector and @xmath47 the superconducting phase difference between the layers .
the above model can be solved exactly using the green functions @xmath48 where @xmath21 and @xmath49 are the layer s indexes .
the brackets mean statistical averaging over grand - canonical distribution.@xcite we obtain the following gorkov equations in the fourier representation:@xmath50 where @xmath51 are the fermionic matsubara frequencies . in quasi-2d superconductors @xcite
the maximal fflo modulation amplitude is of the order of @xmath52 , @xmath53 being the typical superconducting coherence length .
this means that with a good approximation we can consider @xmath54 , @xmath55 being the fermi velocity vector in the plane . solving the gorkov equations ( [ equationgorkov ] ) yields the anomalous gorkov green function for the @xmath22 sf layer @xmath56 where @xmath57 with @xmath58 and @xmath59 similar equation holds for @xmath60 note that in the case where a lattice made of such sf / sf bilayers is considered , the generalized anomalous green function is obtained by replacing @xmath61 by @xmath62 in eq.([fcroix ] ) , @xmath63 being the projection of the momentum @xmath35 along the @xmath64 axis and @xmath65 the period of the lattice . as a consequence
, a finite inter - bilayer coupling @xmath66 introduces an anisotropy in the dispersion relation which leads to a broadening of the electronic excitation levels . in the absence of tunneling @xmath67 we retrieve from eq.([fcroix ] ) the anomalous green function of a quasi-2d superconductor with the exchange field @xmath68 @xmath69 although the dependence on momentum has been removed for simplicity , notice that @xmath70 and @xmath71 the set of basic equations ( [ equationgorkov ] ) must be completed by the self - consistency equation @xmath72 close to the critical temperature @xmath10 of the second - order phase transition , the order parameters @xmath27 are small and eq.([self ] ) can be written as @xmath73 where @xmath74 is the critical temperature for the 2d superconducting single layer in the absence of exchange field , namely for @xmath75 . at zero temperature
, it is convenient to write eq.([self ] ) as @xmath76 where @xmath77 is the superconducting order parameter at @xmath78 in the absence of exchange field and interlayer coupling .
in this section , we investigate phases with uniform superconductivity within each layer . we obtain the critical temperature of the second - order superconducting ( @xmath79 ) to normal metal ( @xmath80 ) phase transition and the order parameter @xmath81 as a function of the temperature , the exchange field @xmath1 and the interlayer coupling @xmath25 .
we consider both parallel ( p ) and antiparallel ( ap ) orientations of the magnetizations , the superconducting phase difference being either @xmath82 or @xmath13 .
we also calculate the josephson interlayer current when the bilayer is connected to external superconducting leads .
most of these results are obtained in the perturbative limit of small coupling between the layers @xmath83 .
the field is also assumed to be sufficiently small to prevent the occurence of a spatial modulation of the superconductivity within the planes .
study of nonuniform phases and strong coupling @xmath84 are respectively postponed to sec .
iv and sec .
v. we consider the second - order phase transition between the normal metal and the uniform bcs superconductor .
thus the order parameters @xmath85 and @xmath86 are small and the anomalous gorkov green function ( [ fcroix ] ) can be linearized in the following form @xmath87 where @xmath88 .
similar equation may be found for @xmath89 .
we first consider _ the parallel ( p ) orientation of the magnetizations , _ namely _
@xmath90_. the first possibility is @xmath82 wherein the layers have the same superconducting order parameters @xmath91 . in this situation
the anomalous green function obtained from eq.([fcroixlinearisee ] ) is denoted @xmath92 .
the identity @xmath93 and eq.([selftnonnul ] ) yield the following implicit equation for the critical temperature @xmath94 @xmath95 where @xmath96 denotes the euler digamma function .
therefore the interlayer coupling disappears from the self - consistency equation and eq.([tcp0 ] ) is identical to that for the 2d monolayer in a uniform exchange field : the bilayer is equivalent to a single layer in the neighborhood of superconducting to normal state transition.@xcite the critical temperature of the bilayer decreases when the exchange field @xmath1 increases .
the equation ( [ tcp0 ] ) describes the second - order phase transition between the normal metal and the uniform superconductor which is realised only for fields smaller than the tricritical one @xmath6 . for larger fields ,
superconductivity becomes nonuniform .
a second possibility is _ the p orientation with @xmath13 phase difference between the layers_. now the anomalous gorkov green function is denoted @xmath97 .
then @xmath98 , \ ] ] and the self - consistency relation eq.([selftnonnul ] ) yield a critical temperature @xmath99 given by @xmath100 from this expression one may notice that superconductivity in the @xmath0 state is destroyed by a combination of two effective exchange fields @xmath101
. in the small interlayer coupling limit @xmath102 , eq.([tcppi ] ) becomes @xmath103 where the function @xmath104 is defined and represented in appendix a. in the regime of low magnetic fields , namely for @xmath105 , the factor @xmath106 is positive and thus the critical temperature is smaller in the @xmath0 superconducting state than in the @xmath107 state .
however the situation may be inverted if @xmath108 . moreover , along the critical line , the value @xmath109 corresponds to the tricritical point , @xmath110 and @xmath111 , where fflo nonuniform states appear . as a consequence one expects competition between the @xmath0 superconducting phase and fflo phases in the neighborhood of the tricritical point .
this competition will be detailed in sec .
iv . let us focus on the case of _ ap orientation @xmath112_. following the same procedure as previously , the equations for the critical temperatures @xmath113 are obtained . in the limit @xmath83
, it reads @xmath114 for @xmath82 , and @xmath115 for @xmath13 . from eqs.([tcap0petitt],[tcappi ] ) the critical temperature is clearly higher in the @xmath107 phase than in the @xmath0 phase .
therefore the @xmath107 phase is the more stable in this region of the @xmath116 phase diagram , _
i.e. _ in the vicinity of the critical temperature and for low fields @xmath117 in conclusion , the bilayer is always in the @xmath107 superconducting state for temperatures close to the critical temperature , whatever the relative orientation of magnetizations is .
a spin - valve effect is also present : the critical temperature is higher for the ap orientation than for the p orientation of the magnetizations . for @xmath67 and low fields @xmath118 it is well - known that the zero temperature gap @xmath119 is field - independent.@xcite for small interlayer coupling @xmath120 , the anomalous green function ( [ fcroix ] ) may be expanded to the second order in @xmath25 as @xmath121 where the full nonlinear dependence on @xmath122 is kept in @xmath123,@xmath124 and @xmath125 then self - consistency relation ( [ selft=0 ] ) becomes @xmath126 where @xmath127 and @xmath82 or @xmath13 . using the preceding equation in _ the p orientation _ we obtain @xmath128 , either for @xmath107 or @xmath0 phase difference . as a result
, the superconducting gap @xmath129 is not affected by a small interlayer coupling , at least at the order of @xmath61 .
the superconducting condensation energy gain has also been calculated and the zero state found to be more stable than @xmath0 state .
_ for the ap orientation _
, the superconducting gap @xmath130 is given by @xmath131 \text { , } \label{gapapzero}%\ ] ] for _ zero phase difference .
_ the unphysical divergence at @xmath132 is removed by terms of higher order in @xmath25 .
expression ( [ gapapzero ] ) is the main result of this paragraph and reduces to @xmath133 in the small field regime @xmath134__. _ _ therefore in the @xmath82 state and for ap orientation , the order parameter is suppressed by the exchange field in the small coupling limit .
this is surprising because ap orientation was expected to weaken the effective exchange field and thus enhance superconducting properties .
nevertheless such a decrease of the superconducting order parameter has already been found in a ballistic atomic - scaled f / s / f trilayer.@xcite _ for the ap orientation and _ @xmath135 _ phase difference , _ the gap @xmath136 is field and coupling independent .
moreover the energy of the @xmath13 state does not depend on the relative orientation of the magnetizations .
to summarize , the lowest energy corresponds to the @xmath137 phase .
the @xmath138 and @xmath139 phases are degenerate with a somewhat higher energy than the @xmath137 phase .
although we have not performed the energy calculation in the case where the magnetizations are antiparallel and the phase difference is @xmath107 , we believe that the highest energy corresponds to the @xmath140 phase since its order parameter is the smallest one . we now extend our investigation of the superconducting gap to finite temperatures . in order to determine the gap @xmath81 as a function of temperature @xmath141 , exchange field @xmath1 and coupling @xmath25 , we analyse numerically the self - consistency relation ( [ selft=0 ] ) using the exact anomalous gorkov green function ( [ fcroix ] ) .
the result is shown schematically in fig.2 .
_ for the p orientation and @xmath82 _ , the superconducting gap @xmath142 is the same as the gap @xmath143 of a single layer whereas _ for @xmath13 _ the superconducting gap @xmath144 is lowered by finite interlayer coupling . _ for the ap orientation and @xmath82 _ , the gap is smaller than @xmath143 for @xmath145 and larger for @xmath146 where the inversion temperature @xmath147 depends only on the exchange field in the small interlayer coupling limit ( see fig.2 inset ) .
this phenomenon has been called inversion of the proximity effect.@xcite moreover , the gap @xmath148 is larger than @xmath149 for all temperatures . according to these results
, one may suggest several experiments .
first we consider a bilayer with magnetizations pinned in the ap mutual orientation . by lowering the temperature ,
a @xmath107-@xmath0 transition is expected at some temperature @xmath150 . in the small interlayer coupling limit , this temperature @xmath151 is a function of the exchange field only ( see fig.2 inset ) .
in contrast , the @xmath107 state is more favorable energetically for all temperatures in the case of magnetizations pinned in the p orientation . as another illustration
we consider samples where the relative orientation of magnetizations is free .
then the orientation is chosen by the system to minimize its energy .
cooling such a bilayer will result in a switching from the ap orientation to the p orientation at the inversion temperature @xmath152 .
the same prediction was made recently in a ballistic f / s / f trilayer.@xcite here we consider that the sf / sf bilayer is connected to superconducting electrodes . in this set - up
, one may impose an arbitrary superconducting phase difference @xmath47 between the sf layers , and thus a non dissipative josephson current flows through the bilayer in the direction perpendicular to the planes .
this interlayer josephson current is evaluated here in the tunneling limit @xmath153 and at zero temperature .
within the green functions formalism , the general formula for the interlayer josephson current is @xmath154 where @xmath155 is the two - dimensional density of state per spin direction and unit surface . solving exactly the gorkov equations ( [ equationgorkov ] ) leads to @xmath156 the function @xmath157 is obtained from eq.([g21 ] ) by permuting the layer indexes @xmath158 the corresponding anharmonic current - phase relationship
is given by@xmath159 in the tunneling limit @xmath160 the interlayer josephson current becomes sinusoidal as a function of the phase difference , @xmath161 where @xmath162 .
the second harmonic @xmath163 has also been evaluated and is smaller than the first one by a factor @xmath164 . the preceding equation ( [ courant1 ] )
yields the current - phase relation both for parallel ( p ) and antiparallel ( ap ) orientation of magnetizations .
_ in the parallel case _
the critical current does not depend on the field as already reported in other systems since @xmath165.@xcite _ for the antiparallel orientation _ and to the lowest order in @xmath25 , the current - phase relation reads @xmath166 where @xmath167 @xmath168 .
therefore the critical current increases with the exchange field @xmath1 and even diverges for @xmath169 of course this divergence is unphysical and should disappear if all orders in @xmath25 were taken into account . in fig.3 ,
the critical current is shown as a function of the exchange field both for p and ap orientations .
recently , the issue of the josephson coupling between two clean sf layers through an insulating layer was considered using eilenberger equations @xcite or bogoliubov - de gennes formalism.@xcite similar results as ours were obtained : the critical current increases with @xmath1 only if three conditions are met : low temperature , very weak coupling between the sf layers and ap orientation .
otherwise the presence of an exchange interaction suppresses the josephson current . using usadel equations
, krivoruchko demonstrated that this statement holds in the diffusive regime for which the divergence for @xmath170 is remplaced by a regular peak.@xcite
from now on , we consider the sf / sf bilayer only for the parallel ( p ) orientation . hence the results obtained in the next sections may be also applied to a superconducting bilayer in an external in - plane magnetic field .
the present section is devoted to the weak coupling regime @xmath171 in contrast to the low field restriction of sec .
iii , regions of the phase diagram with @xmath172 are also investigated here . then competition between the fflo and @xmath0 phases
is expected to take place .
particular attention is paid to the vicinity of the tricritical point given by @xmath173 and @xmath174@xcite in order to examine this narrow region of the @xmath175 plane , we construct a ginzburg - landau ( gl ) functional from the gorkov equations used in the previous sections . in the past buzdin and
kachkachi @xcite derived a generalized ginzburg - landau ( gl ) functional for a single sf layer that describes the fflo superconducting state near the tricritical point .
here we extend this functional to a sf / sf bilayer for which it is possible to have not only fflo modulation within the planes but also @xmath13 superconducting phase difference between the planes .
for @xmath82 , the physics of the bilayer is independent of the coupling and thus the buzdin - kachkachi gl functional is retrieved .
in contrast for @xmath13 , we obtain a free energy functional which depends on the interlayer coupling @xmath25 and leads to the presence of a superconducting @xmath0 phase .
the free energy of the sf / sf bilayer in a uniform superconducting state with @xmath82 ( @xmath176 state ) is given by ( see details in appendix b ) @xmath177 with @xmath178 where @xmath179 and @xmath180 are respectively the reduced exchange field and the reduced order parameter . here
we retrieve the well - known case of a single sf layer .
for reduced exchange fields lower than the tricritical one @xmath181 , the transition between the superconducting and the normal states is a second - order one since @xmath182 .
the critical line is given by the equation @xmath183 for higher fields , the transition becomes a first - order one because @xmath184 and @xmath185 .
as for any first - order transition , two conditions must be fullfilled .
on one hand , the free energy ( [ freezero ] ) is minimized , ( @xmath186 , and on the other hand the free energies of the superconducting and normal phases are equal , @xmath187 hence in the @xmath175 plane the equation for this first - order line is @xmath188 @xmath189 , and the jump of the superconducting gap at the transition is given by @xmath190 .
it is well - known that this scenario is not realized because it is replaced by a transition between normal metal and nonuniform superconductivity.@xcite nevertheless , this first - order transition provides a useful energy scale @xmath191 and a reference line in the @xmath175 plane that will be used to construct a universal phase diagram , namely a @xmath25-independent phase diagram valid for any weakly coupled sf / sf bilayers , see sec .
the sf / sf bilayer may support opposite order parameters on the layers , superconductivity being still uniform within each sf plane . in this so - called @xmath192 state ,
the free energy of the bilayer depends on the reduced interlayer coupling @xmath193 according to @xmath194 for low reduced fields @xmath195 @xmath196 .
hence the uniform superconducting phase with @xmath82 is more stable than the @xmath0 phase , as already found in the sec .
interestingly for higher reduced fields @xmath197 this @xmath0 phase is in competition with fflo nonuniform superconducting phases having either @xmath82 ( @xmath198 ) or @xmath13 ( @xmath199 ) . according to buzdin and
kachkachi the order parameter @xmath200 leads to the lowest energy.@xcite for the @xmath198 phase , the corresponding free energy reads @xmath201 whereas for the @xmath199 phase , the free energy depends on the interlayer coupling @xmath25 in the following manner @xmath202 the notation @xmath203 is introduced in appendix b. now we proceed to analyse the above free energies in order to determine the critical line between the normal and the superconducting states .
we will also describe the nature of the various superconducting states and what kinds of transitions are encountered .
we focus on the vicinity of the tricritical point . then @xmath204 is a linear function of the exchange field with @xmath205 , whereas @xmath185 is nearly field and temperature independent . for high reduced fields @xmath206
, it appears that the @xmath176 and the @xmath199 never lead to the highest critical temperature .
then we emphasize the competition between the two remaining phases , namely @xmath192 and @xmath207 the minimization of the gl functional ( [ fflozero1 ] ) leads to a modulation wave vector given by @xmath208 in the limit @xmath209 , _
i.e. _ near the critical line .
the @xmath192 phase is more stable than the @xmath198 phase under the energy condition @xmath210 or equivalently for @xmath211 therefore the uniform @xmath0 phase is `` inserted '' within the usual fflo superconducting state .
the upper and lower values of @xmath212 between which this new @xmath0 phase is stable depend on the particular value of the coupling @xmath25 .
it is convenient to define a dimensionless generalized coordinate @xmath213 @xmath214 that quantifies the `` distance '' from the tricritical point along the s / n transition line .
indeed @xmath215 at the tricritical point and the @xmath0 phase is settled in the region @xmath216 as shown on fig .
4 , going along the critical line from low to high fields , one expects the sequence of superconducting states : uniform in the planes with @xmath82 for @xmath217 , fflo modulation along the planes with @xmath82 for @xmath218 then uniform @xmath0 state for @xmath219 and finally fflo modulation along the planes with @xmath82 for @xmath220 . in all cases ,
the sign of the @xmath221 coefficient in the gl free energy is always positive and thus transitions between these superconducting states and the normal metal are second - order ones .
we now construct the phase diagram around the tricritical point . because each value of the coupling leads to different transition lines , we introduce the following mapping of the thermodynamic variables @xmath223 in order to obtain a universal phase diagram valid in the small coupling regime .
this mapping makes use of the energy scale @xmath191 and of the function @xmath224 related to the first - order transition between the normal state and the uniform superconducting state , see sec . iv.a .
then the free energies for the uniform superconducting phases eqs.([freezero],[freepi ] ) become @xmath225 and @xmath226 where @xmath227 first it is straightforward to minimize @xmath228 and @xmath229 with respect to @xmath230 . then replacing the reduced gap @xmath230 by its equilibrium value , one obtains the equilibrium energies @xmath231 and @xmath232 of each superconducting phase .
these energies are functions of both field and temperature via the dimensionless thermodynamical variables @xmath233 and @xmath234 . using the same scaling eq.([scaling ] ) the free energies of the @xmath198 phase , @xmath235 and of the @xmath199 phase ,
@xmath236 are also obtained for the order parameter @xmath237 .
the equilibrium energies @xmath238 and @xmath239 of the modulated phases are obtained after minimization of eqs.([energyfflozero],[energyfflopi ] ) with respect to @xmath230 and @xmath240 .then eq.([energyfflozero ] ) enables to study the second - order phase transition between the normal metallic state and the nonuniform fflo state@xmath241 under the assumption of second - order phase transition , it is sufficient to consider the gl free energy up to the @xmath242 order . then the free energy ( [ energyfflozero ] ) is minimal for @xmath208 . for this particular modulation , the critical fflo / n line is given by @xmath243 we now consider the transition lines between the various superconducting states obtained in the previous paragraph , in particular the @xmath198/@xmath192 , the @xmath198/@xmath176 and the @xmath244 transitions .
let us focus on the transition between the uniform phases @xmath176 and @xmath192 .
solving @xmath245 , we obtain the critical line @xmath246 which corresponds to a first order @xmath247 phase transition .
however , this transition is not realized ( see fig.4 ) because the transition to the nonuniform superconducting state occurs before .
the @xmath248 transition line is obtained in a similar way . the equation @xmath249 has the solution @xmath250 . at this value of @xmath233 ,
the system undergoes a first order phase transition from the uniform state to the modulated fflo state . adding higher harmonics to the order parameter @xmath251 gives a more accurate evaluation , namely @xmath252 .
finally , the @xmath253 transition line is obtained from @xmath254 and shown in fig.4 in the @xmath255 plane .
this transition is a first - order one . using the mapping @xmath256 of the thermodynamical variables ,
we have obtained a universal phase diagram fig.4 of all weakly coupled sf / sf bilayers in the vicinity of the tricritical point .
an important feature of this phase diagram is the presence of a superconducting @xmath257-phase . as an example , the phase diagram has been redrawn in the @xmath175 plane on fig.5 for a particular value of the coupling @xmath25 .
now we consider the ballistic sf / sf bilayer in the regime of strong interlayer coupling limit @xmath84 and low temperature .
a very unusual @xmath257-superconducting state is found between a lower @xmath258 and an upper @xmath259 critical exchange field , and below a maximal temperature of the order of @xmath260 .
therefore field - induced superconductivity is obtained above @xmath261 within the bcs theory of superconductivity .
the underlying physical mechanism is the compensation of the zeeman splitting by the energy splitting between bonding and antibonding electronic states of the bilayer , see fig.6.@xcite thus the new zero temperature paramagnetic limit @xmath259 may be tuned far above the usual one @xcite @xmath262 merely by increasing the interlayer coupling .
this compensation also occurs for small coupling , but the @xmath257-superconducting state is then less energetically favorable than the usual @xmath107-superconducting phase as demonstrated in sec.iv
. therefore the @xmath175 phase diagrams are topologically distinct in the opposite limits of small ( sec.iv ) and strong ( sec.v ) coupling .
we first analyse the second - order superconducting / normal phase transition in sec.v.a .
then the first - order transition between uniform superconductivity and the normal state is discussed in sec.v.b . here
we study the second - order phase transition between the @xmath0 superconducting state and the normal metal state , as a function of the field .
we start from the the linearized anomalous green function ( [ fcroix ] ) for arbitrary coupling @xmath25 and @xmath0 superconducting phase difference , @xmath263 .\left [ t^{2}% -(i\omega+h+\xi)^{2}\right ] } \text{. } \label{fcroixgrandt}%\ ] ] from this equation and the self - consistency relation ( [ self ] ) , the critical exchange field @xmath1 is shown to satisfy @xmath264 where @xmath265 , and @xmath266 is the critical exchange field for the second - order superconducting phase transition in a two - dimensional monolayer .
one must then find the value of @xmath267 which maximizes the critical field @xmath268 . if the @xmath0 phase is assumed to be uniform inside each plane , namely if @xmath269 , eq.([hcritfflo1 ] ) merely reduces to @xmath270 the lower and upper critical fields are respectively given by @xmath271 , in the limit @xmath272 .
thus at zero temperature and strong enough coupling , the superconductivity destruction follows a very special scenario . at low fields ,
superconductivity is first suppressed as usual at the paramagnetic limit @xmath273 leading to the normal metal phase
. then further increase of the field leads to a normal to superconducting phase transition at the lower critical field .
this superconducting @xmath0 phase is finally suppressed at the upper critical field .
this is a new paramagnetic limit which may be tuned far above the usual one merely by choosing the coupling @xmath25 greater than @xmath274 .
thorough analysis of eq.([hcritfflo1 ] ) shows that the upper critical field is even increased by an in - plane modulation in analogy with the case of the two - dimensional fflo phase.@xcite the upper critical field is maximal for the choice @xmath275 , and then eq.([hcritfflo1 ] ) reduces to @xmath276 that gives the upper and lower fields @xmath277 in the @xmath278 limit .
note that the period of the modulated order parameter @xmath279 is larger than the corresponding period in the two - dimensional fflo phase which coincides with the ballistic coherence length @xmath280 @xcite furthermore one may derive the full temperature - field phase diagram using eqs.([selftnonnul],[fcroixgrandt ] ) and the result is shown in fig.7 . when the temperature is increased , the lower critical field increases whereas the upper one decreases . along the upper ( resp .
lower ) critical line the fflo modulation is lost at some temperature @xmath281 ( resp .
@xmath282 ) . for higher temperatures
a uniform @xmath0 phase ( @xmath192 ) is recovered and the temperature dependence of the critical field is given by @xmath283 , \label{hcriticaltemperature}%\ ] ] where @xmath284 is the digamma function and @xmath285 , @xmath286 being the euler constant .
finally the lower and upper critical lines merge at field @xmath287 and temperature @xmath288 in the limit @xmath289 . therefore the field - induced @xmath0 superconductivity is confined to temperatures lower than @xmath290 .
the structure of these @xmath192 and the @xmath199 phases is reminiscent of the corresponding @xmath176 and the @xmath198 phases although the former are shifted to higher fields and lower temperatures than the later . above results
were obtained for relatively strong coupling . for lower coupling @xmath291 , the @xmath192 and the @xmath199 phases merge continuously into the usual @xmath82 phases as shown in fig.8 , and finally disappear for @xmath25 slightly smaller than @xmath274 . from an experimental point of view , one might choose a system with intermediate coupling @xmath25 small enough to settle the @xmath0 phase island in an available range of temperatures but also large enough to separate the @xmath0 phase island from the usual superconducting phases with @xmath82 .
in the general sf multilayer case the inter - bilayer coupling constant @xmath66 needs to be sufficiently high to prevent from superconductivity destruction by 2d fluctuations but also sufficiently low to preserve the effect of field - induced superconductivity.@xcite in the following we investigate the first - order @xmath292 transition to determine whether it is more or less favorable than the above studied second - order transition .
the zero - temperature superconducting order parameter @xmath293 is calculated from the self - consistency equation ( [ selft=0 ] ) for p orientation of magnetizations and @xmath13 phase difference . at zero temperature ,
the difference between the energy @xmath294 of the superconducting state and the energy @xmath295 of the normal metal state is given by @xcite@xmath296 d\delta\label{energieself}%\ ] ] in the limit @xmath297 we retrieve the well - known case of the single sf layer.@xcite then the self - consistency relation ( [ selft=0 ] ) admits two branches of solutions .
the lower branch @xmath298 , labelled ( 2 ) in the inset of fig.9 , corresponds to a positive energy cost @xmath299 .
thus this superconducting solution is never realized .
the actual superconducting gap is given by the upper horizontal branch @xmath300 , ( 1 ) in the inset of fig.9 , which corresponds to the energy difference @xmath301 hence the superconducting phase is settled for low fields @xmath302 with a field - independent order parameter @xmath303 . for higher fields @xmath304 , the system is in the normal phase @xmath305 .
finally the zero temperature gap exbibits a jump at @xmath306 which reveals the first - order transition from the uniform superconducting phase to the normal phase . in the opposite limit of strong interlayer coupling ,
we have obtained in sec.v.a .
that field - induced superconductivity with @xmath13 phase difference occurs for fields close to @xmath25 and at low temperatures . from the self - consistency equation ( [ selft=0 ] )
one obtains several possible solutions for the zero - temperature superconducting gap @xmath307 as a function of the exchange field @xmath1 , see fig.9 .
for relatively low fields @xmath308 and for high fields @xmath309 , the bilayer is in the normal phase @xmath310 the limiting fields @xmath311 are solutions of @xmath312 for intermediate fields ranging between @xmath313 and @xmath314 there are three superconducting branches .
two of them , ( 2 ) and ( 2 ) are never realized owing to their energy cost @xmath315 the third branch ( 1 ) requires more detailed analysis .
namely , it is given by the equation @xmath316 and the corresponding energy cost is @xmath317 \nonumber\\ & + \frac{\pi(h - t)^{2}}{2}. \label{energiemoyen}%\end{aligned}\ ] ] analysis of these equations reveals that @xmath299 is negative for @xmath318 where @xmath319 and @xmath320 hence the sf bilayer undergoes first - order transition at @xmath321 and @xmath322 .
this scenario is quite similar than the one for @xmath67 , but with a smaller order parameter jump at the transition .
moreover there are two first - order transitions , respectively at @xmath323 and @xmath324 instead of one at @xmath325 . in order to generalize the above gap calculations to finite temperatures and
determine the first - order s / n transition line , we have solved numerically together the self - consistency equation ( [ selftnonnul ] ) and the condition @xmath326 .
the result is given in the inset of fig.7 .
collecting results from sec.v.a and b. we obtain the full @xmath175 phase diagram for the field - induced @xmath0 superconductivity .
note that this @xmath0 superconductivity reproduces the structure of the phase diagram in quasi-2d superconductors @xcite although it is shifted to higher fields and lower temperatures .
in this paper we have studied a periodic array of sf / sf bilayers in the limit of small coupling between the different bilayers .
the corresponding gorkov equations have been solved exactly , taking into account both in - plane fflo modulation and arbitrary superconducting phase difference between sf layers .
the superconducting state with zero phase difference is always settled in the low field regime , @xmath327 for parallel ( p ) orientation of the magnetizations . for antiparallel
( ap ) orientation , the @xmath0 state predominates at low temperatures over the @xmath107 state which is settled in the neighborhood of the critical line .
consequently if the system is pinned in the antiparallel orientation , we predict a transition from the usual @xmath82 superconducting state to the @xmath0 state by cooling .
while the critical temperature is higher for the ap orientation , the zero temperature order parameter is larger for the p orientation .
this results in a crossing temperature @xmath152 below which the p orientation is more suitable for superconductivity .
this temperature has been calculated as a function of the exchange field . in an experiment where the magnetizations might be easily reversed ,
one therefore expects a transition from the ap to the p orientation by cooling the system below this crossing temperature
. in the low interlayer coupling limit , a ginzburg - landau functional has been derived from the exact expression of the anomalous gorkov green function . as a main result
, we have obtained a @xmath0 superconducting state located in the vicinity of the tricritical point @xmath328 .
details of the bilayer phase diagram are obtained in this framework , including the first - order transition lines between superconducting phases . since increasing the interlayer coupling
enlarges the @xmath0 phase region , experimental observation of such details of the phase diagram requires the use of sf layers with large enough interlayer coupling , namely @xmath329 . finally the case of even stronger interlayer coupling , namely @xmath330 has been also investigated .
it appears that at low temperatures the @xmath0 superconducting state is settled for exchange fields of the order of @xmath25 , which are well above the chandrasekhar - clogston paramagnetic limit .
thus this new paramagnetic limit may be tuned by varying the interlayer coupling . in the present article
we have reported the detailed structure of the phase diagram in this regime of high magnetic field . the first - order @xmath292 transition line is also derived .
we expect that our results may be applicable to compounds like bi@xmath11sr@xmath11cacu@xmath11o@xmath12 under a magnetic field .
indeed such perovskite superconductors comprise tightly coupled superconducting cuo planes separated by bio layers .
however observing the field - induced superconductivity in a reasonable range of magnetic field requires relatively low critical temperatures which are realized in the heavily doped or underdoped regimes .
finally the latter effect is solely related to the compensation of the energy shift in the two layers systems by the zeeman splitting .
so it should be quite general and might appear also in two band superconductors or in weakly coupled superconducting grains .
note that the inhomogeneous superconductivity has been obtained in the absence of magnetic field in two - bands superconductors.@xcite however since the @xmath0 state was not considered in this latter work no field - induced superconductivity had been noticed .
bulaevskii @xcite studied thoroughly josephson coupling in periodic layered structures with one sf plane as unit cell .
here we have demonstrated that systems with several sf planes as unit cell exhibit qualitatively new phenomena like field - induced superconductivity .
the simplest case , two planes per unit cell , has been studied here .
it may be regarded as a basic approach to understand the properties of more complex ferromagnetic superconducting compounds or artificial heterojunctions .
we thank m. daumens , m. faure , m. houzet and m. kulic for useful discussions and comments .
this work was supported , in part , by esf pi - shift program .
we define the function @xmath332 by @xmath333 , \ ] ] and for any integrer @xmath334 the function @xmath331 is given by@xmath335 the variations of @xmath336 , @xmath337 , @xmath338 , with @xmath212 are represented in fig.10 .
one can notice that in the vicinity of the tricritical point , _ i.e. _ @xmath339 , the functions @xmath332 and @xmath340 are negative and of the order of unity .
@xmath341 cancels exactly at @xmath342 and becomes negative in the domain @xmath343 , which is studied sec.iv .
this part of the appendix refers to sec .
iv of the paper . in the ginzburg - landau theory ,
the free energy is expanded in terms of the gap @xmath122 , _ i.e. _ the order parameter , assuming the temperature close to @xmath10 .
originaly it was introduced as a phenomenological theory for superconductivity before the bcs theory . here
we derive the ginzburg - landau free energy from the full microscopic knowledge of our model in order to analyze the vicinity of the tricritical point . to do this , we consider the simplest case where the fflo gap modulation is exponential , namely @xmath344 , @xmath345 being the in - plane modulation wave vector .
it is known that this modulation structure is not realized to the benefit of the cosine modulation discussed in the article s body . however , in sec.ii , the gorkov green functions of the sf / sf bilayer were derived for a modulated order parameter @xmath344 and @xmath82 or @xmath346 this modulation structure is then convenient to calculate the coefficients of the generalized gl functional because the exact expression of the anomalous green function ( see eq.([fcroix ] ) ) is valid for this gap modulation structure , whereas it is unknown with the cosine structure .
we first expand the exact anomalous green function ( [ fcroix ] ) and the self - consistency relation in powers of the gap @xmath122 and the fflo wave vector @xmath347 then this self - consistency relation is interpreted as the stationarity condition for the ginzburg - landau free energy , which allows ( by identification ) to determine the coefficient of every term of the gl functional . in the @xmath82 case ,
the expansion of the anomalous green function reads @xmath348 where @xmath349 .
we first consider the case of uniform superconductivity , _ i.e. _ @xmath350 .
after integration over @xmath351 , we obtain:@xmath352 with @xmath353 .
note that the interlayer coupling @xmath25 has disappeared in eq.([gna ] ) .
we are now able to write down the self - consistency equation ( [ selftnonnul ] ) as an expansion in powers of @xmath122 @xmath354 where the functions @xmath355 are those defined in appendix a , and @xmath180 .
this self - consistency relation may be interpreted as the stationnary condition @xmath356 for the ginzburg - landau free energy with uniform order parameter within each superconducting plane and @xmath82 phase difference between the planes .
close to the tricritical point , @xmath357 is small and it is enough to retain only the first term in this infinite expansion as @xmath358 where @xmath179 . by identification with eq.([minim ] ) we obtain the gl free energy for the @xmath176 phase as a function of the variational parameter @xmath357 and the thermodynamical variable @xmath359 : @xmath360 \left\vert \tilde{\delta}\right\vert ^{2}+b_{1}% k_{3}(\tilde{h})\frac{\left\vert \tilde{\delta}\right\vert ^{4}}{2}-b_{2}% k_{5}(\tilde{h})\frac{\left\vert \tilde{\delta}\right\vert ^{6}}{3}\nonumber\\ & = \left [ \ln\frac{t}{t_{c0}}-k_{1}(\tilde{h})\right ] \left\vert \tilde{\delta}\right\vert ^{2}+\frac{k_{3}(\tilde{h})}{4}\left\vert \tilde{\delta}\right\vert ^{4}-\frac{k_{5}(\tilde{h})}{8}\left\vert \tilde{\delta}\right\vert ^{6 } \label{energyzero}%\end{aligned}\ ] ] which corresponds to eq.([freezero ] ) .
note that in this usual @xmath107 state the same coefficients have been already reported in ref.@xcite the same procedure may be followed when the phase difference is @xmath0 .
the anomalous green function is then @xmath361 and leads to the self - consistency relation which contains explicitely the coupling @xmath25 , via the normalized coupling @xmath193:@xmath362 \left\vert \tilde{\delta } \right\vert ^{2n}=0\text{.}%\ ] ] from the latter expression we deduce that the coefficients of the gl free energy for the @xmath13 state can be directly obtained using the coefficient of @xmath363 in which we replace @xmath364 by @xmath365 . finally the free energy of the @xmath192 state is @xmath366 \left\vert \tilde{\delta}\right\vert ^{2}\nonumber\\ & + \frac{k_{3}(\tilde{h}+\tilde{t})+k_{3}(\tilde{h}-\tilde{t})}{8}\left\vert \tilde{\delta}\right\vert ^{4}\nonumber\\ & -\frac{k_{5}(\tilde{h}+\tilde{t})+k_{5}(\tilde{h}-\tilde{t})}{16}\left\vert \tilde{\delta}\right\vert ^{6 } \label{energypi}%\end{aligned}\ ] ] which yields eq.([freepi ] ) in the small interlayer coupling limit @xmath367 .
we have developped in a similar way the gl free energy in the case where the order parameter is modulated within each superconducting plane . using the expressions ( [ fzeroannexe ] ) and ( [ fpiannexe ] ) for the anomalous green function of the bilayer with @xmath344 fflo modulation respectively in the @xmath82 and @xmath13 cases ,
one obtains the expansion of the self - consistency equation in powers of @xmath122 and of the fflo wave vector @xmath46 . finally , after averaging over all possible orientations of the fflo modulation vector , the self - consistency equation reads:@xmath368 for @xmath82 .
the coefficients @xmath369 are symmetric with respect to the expansion indexes @xmath370 and @xmath371@xmath372 and related to the coefficients @xmath373 by @xmath374 . from eq.([yoyo ] ) the gl free energy can be constructed using the method described in the previous paragraph for uniform phases .
we retrieve all the coefficients already obtained by buzdin and kachkachi,@xcite including the coefficients of the gradient terms of the generalized functional . to derive the free energy of the @xmath198 phase , we have therefore used the bk functional with the cosine modulation which is effectively realized in each superconducting layer . as a result
, it reads @xmath375 where @xmath203 . in the @xmath13 state
the free energy has been derived from the bk functional in which the replacement @xmath376 has been done in order to obtain the modified coefficients . finally the free energy of the @xmath199 phase can be written as@xmath377 in the article body more convenient forms of eqs.([energyfflozeroannexe],[energyfflopiannexe ] ) involving the reduced quantities @xmath233 , @xmath230 and @xmath234 are used in order to derive the universal phase diagram . 99 v. l. ginzburg , zh . eksp .
. fiz . * 31 * , 202 ( 1956 ) [ sov .
jetp * 4 * , 153 ( 1957 ) ] .
d. saint - james , d. sarma and e. j. thomas , _ type ii superconductivity _
( pergamon press , new york , 1969 ) .
a. a. abrikosov , _ fundamentals _ _ of the theory of metals _
( north holland , netherlands , 1988 ) .
b. s. chandrasekhar , appl .
. lett . * 1 * , 7 ( 1962 ) .
a. m. clogston , phys .
* 9 * , 266 ( 1962 ) .
a. i. larkin and y. n. ovchinnikov , zh .
. fiz . * 47 * , 1136 ( 1964 ) [ sov .
jetp * 20 * , 762 ( 1965 ) ] .
p. fulde and r. a. ferrell , phys . rev . *
135 * , a550 ( 1964 ) .
bulaevskii , zh .
. fiz . * 64 * , 2241 ( 1973 ) [ sov .
jetp * 37 * , 1133 ( 1973 ) ] .
buzdin and v.v .
tugushev , zh .
. fiz . * 85 * , 735 ( 1983 ) [ sov .
jetp * 58 * , 428 ( 1983 ) ] .
aslamazov , zh .
* 55 * , 1477 ( 1968 ) [ sov .
jetp * 28 * , 773 ( 1969 ) ] .
buzdin and s. v. polonskii , zh .
. fiz . * 93 * , 747 ( 1987 ) [ sov .
jetp * 66 * , 422 ( 1987 ) ] .
et al . _ ,
nature * 410 * , 908 ( 2001 ) .
a. m. tanatar , t. ishiguro , h. tanaka and h. kobayashi , phys .
b * 66 * , 134503 ( 2002 ) . c. martin _ et al . _ ,
b * 71 * , 020503(r ) ( 2005 ) l.n .
bulaevskii and m.v .
zyskin , phys .
b * 42 * , 10230 ( 1990 ) .
a. i. buzdin , rev .
phys . * 77 * , 935 ( 2005 ) .
andreev , a. i. buzdin , and r. m. osgood , iii phys .
b * 43 * , 10124 ( 1991 ) .
a. c. mclaughlin , w. zhou , j. p. attfield , a. n. fitch , and j. l. tallon , phys .
b * 60 * , 7512 ( 1999 ) .
t. nachtrab , d. koelle , r. kleiner , c. bernhard and c.t .
lin , phys .
92 , 117001 ( 2004 ) a. i. buzdin , a. v. vedyayev and n. v. ryzhanova , europhys
. lett . * 48 * , 686 ( 1999 ) .
i. baladie and a. buzdin , phys .
b * 67 * , 014523 ( 2003 )
. a. buzdin and m. daumens , europhys
. lett . * 64 * , 510 - 516 ( 2003 ) .
s. tollis , m. daumens and a. buzdin , phys .
b * 71 * , 024510 ( 2005 ) .
v. apinyan and r. melin , eur .
j. b * 25 * , 373 - 389 ( 2002 ) .
h. jirari , r. melin , and n. stefanakis , eur .
j. b * 31 * , 125 - 139 ( 2003 ) .
i. bozovic , ieee .
supercond . * 11 * , 2886 ( 2001 ) .
a. buzdin , s. tollis , j. cayssol , cond - mat/0505726 ( 2005 ) . to be published in prl .
m. l. kulic and u. hofmann , solid state communications * 77 * , 9 , 717 ( 1991 ) .
abrikosov , l. p. gorkov , and i. e. dzyaloshinski , _ methods of quantum field theory in statistical physics _
( dover , new york ) ( 1963 ) .
m. houzet and a. buzdin , phys .
b * 63 * , 184521 ( 2001 ) .
f. s. bergeret , a. f. volkov , k. b. efetov , phys .
lett * 86 * , 3140 ( 2001 ) .
l. xiaowei _
et al . _ ,
phys . rev .
b * 65 * , 134507 ( 2002 ) . v. n. krivoruchko and e. a. koshina , phys . rev .
b * 64 * , 172511 ( 2001 ) .
a. i. buzdin , h. kachkachi , phys .
lett . a * 225 * , 341 ( 1997 )
. l. i. glazman and a. e. koshelev , zh .
* 97 * , 1371 ( 1990 ) [ sov .
jetp * 70 * , 774 ( 1990 ) ] .
fig.1 : sf / sf bilayer . the interlayer coupling constant
is denoted @xmath25 .
the exchange fields @xmath28 can be either equal ( parallel orientation ) or opposite ( antiparallel orientation ) .
the superconducting phase difference between @xmath85 and @xmath86 can be either @xmath107 ( @xmath378 ) or @xmath0 ( @xmath379 ) .
fig.2 : schematic representation of the superconducting gap as a function of temperature for p orientation and @xmath82 ( thicker solid line ) , ap orientation and @xmath82 ( intermediate thickness line ) , and ap orientation and @xmath13 ( thiner line ) .
all curves are given for the same value of the exchange field that is smaller @xmath10 ( in energy units ) .
the inversion of the proximity effect occurs at the temperature @xmath152 and the transition from @xmath107 state to @xmath0 state in the ap orientation at the temperature @xmath380 .
temperatures @xmath152 and @xmath151 as a function of the field are shown in the inset .
fig.4 : universal phase diagram for weakly coupled bilayers , in @xmath255 coordinates .
the critical line ( solid line ) corresponds either to a @xmath292 or to a @xmath382 transition depending on @xmath234 .
the transition between the nonuniform @xmath198 superconducting phase and uniform @xmath176 ( resp.@xmath383 ) phase is represented with dash - dotted ( resp .
dashed ) line .
fig.5 : phase diagram in @xmath175 coordinates , for @xmath384 . only the neighborhood of the tricritical point is represented .
the lines have the same meaning than in fig.4 .
note that the @xmath0 phase is settled in a very narrow region of the phase diagram .
fig.6 : excitation spectrum .
usual singlet pairing ( thin line circles ) between opposite - spin electrons occupying the same orbital is affected by zeeman effect . in contrast , @xmath0 coupling ( thick line ) between two electrons occupying a bonding and an antibonding orbitals may lead to the cancellation of the zeeman splitting .
fig.7 : phase diagram for @xmath385 .
thick ( resp .
thin ) solid lines represents second - order transition between @xmath386 ( resp .
@xmath387 ) and normal metal phase ( @xmath80 ) for @xmath82 and @xmath0 .
we expect the @xmath388 transition lines ( not calculated ) to be in the vicinity of the ( virtual ) first order @xmath389 lines ( dash - dotted ) . | we present the detailed theoretical study of a heterostructure comprising of two coupled ferromagnetic superconducting layers . our model may be also applicable to the layered superconductors with alternating interlayer coupling in a parallel magnetic field .
it is demonstrated that such systems exhibit a competition between the nonuniform larkin - ovchinnikov - fulde - ferrel ( fflo ) state and the @xmath0 superconducting state where the sign of the superconducting order parameter is opposite in adjacent layers .
we determine the complete temperature - field phase diagram . in the case of low interlayer coupling
we obtain a new @xmath0 phase inserted within the fflo phase and located close to the usual tricritical point , whereas for strong interlayer coupling the bilayer in the @xmath0 state reveals a very high paramagnetic limit and the phenomenon of field - induced superconductivity . |
the observational data coming from type ia supernovae in the late 90 s @xcite indicated that in addition to the radiation and matter domination eras , there is also a late - time acceleration era , which occurred after the matter domination era and the universe is expanding in an accelerating way ever since .
this observation utterly changed our perception for the universe cosmological evolution , and it is a challenge for theoretical cosmologists to consistently describe the evolution of the universe . with regards to the radiation domination era , at the beginning of this era it is believed that the universe experienced a rapid acceleration era known nowadays as the inflationary era . during this era
the universe increased its size significantly and after the end of this era , the universe continued its expansion in a decelerating way , with the effective equation of state of the universe being described by a radiation perfect matter fluid .
it is therefore compelling to find a model which can harbor all the evolution era of the universe , in the same theoretical framework .
modified gravity @xcite , in all its aspects and variant models , can describe consistently the evolution of the universe , so it is one of the most appealing candidates for the cosmological theory of everything , at least in the context of classical evolution .
recently we have demonstrated in ref .
@xcite , that it is possible to describe in a unified way all the cosmological eras of the universe .
the vital feature of the cosmological evolution which we realized , was the appearance of two type iv singularities occurring at the end of the inflationary era and at the end of the matter domination era respectively .
the resulting cosmological model had quite appealing features , since near the second type iv singularity , the deceleration - acceleration transition occurred . also , the hubble radius decreased in a rapid way at early times , then it started to increase during the radiation and matter domination era , and finally it started to decrease at late times .
the behavior of the hubble radius is exactly what is expected from a correct description of the universe evolution , since the primordial quantum modes exited the horizon at early times and reentered the horizon during the expansion of the hubble radius .
in addition to this , we demonstrated that the model generates a nearly scale invariant power spectrum of primordial curvature perturbations .
having in mind that the study performed in ref .
@xcite was realized in the context of an @xmath1 gravity , in this paper we will realize the cosmological evolution of ref .
@xcite , but in the context of @xmath0 gravity @xcite , see also refs .
@xcite for reviews . in @xmath0 gravity , instead of
the ricci scalar @xmath2 , used in einstein - hilbert and @xmath1 gravity , the gauss - bonnet invariant is used , that is @xmath3 , where @xmath4 , denotes the ricci tensor , while @xmath5 denotes the riemann tensor .
the basic questions we want to address with this study are the following : firstly , what is the @xmath0 gravity which realizes the cosmological evolution of ref .
@xcite and secondly , is this cosmology compatible with the latest planck @xcite observations ?
particularly , we will investigate if the resulting power spectrum is scale or nearly scale invariant , as was in the @xmath1 gravity case ?
the answer to the second question is not obvious and with our study we will quantitatively answer this question . as we demonstrate , the resulting spectrum is not scale invariant , and hence this shows that even it is possible to realize the same cosmological evolution by using different theoretical frameworks , the observational implications of each model is not necessarily compatible with observational data . for similar studies using the framework of modified gravity in order to unify all acceleration eras of the universe , see @xcite .
the singularity structure of the model we shall study contains no crushing singularities , since it contains two type iv singularities .
the latter ones are the mildest singularities , firstly classified in ref .
@xcite , and recently intensively studied in @xcite .
the first novel study on mild singularities was performed in ref .
@xcite , and later on these were developed in @xcite and see also @xcite .
the interesting feature of the type iv singularities is that it is possible for the universe to smoothly pass through these , without any catastrophic implications on the physical quantities that can be defined on the three dimensional spacelike hypersurface defined at the time instance that the singularity occurs .
however , the mild singularities affect significantly the dynamics of the cosmological evolution , with the most interesting case being the possibility that mild singularities can generate graceful exit from inflation @xcite .
we need to stress that the cosmological model which we shall study does not describe the pre - inflationary era , where a cosmic singularity at @xmath6 might occur .
in fact , in the literature there exist various cosmological scenarios for this pre - inflationary era , in which case a crushing singularity might or might not occur , see for example @xcite .
however , in our case the focus will be on later times and particularly for times near the beginning of inflation and after .
this paper is organized as follows : in section ii we present all the essential features of the unified cosmological model , and particularly how it succeeds to describe the early - time acceleration era , the late - time acceleration era , the radiation domination era and the matter domination era .
we also describe in brief the origin of primordial curvature perturbations and the behavior of the hubble horizon . in section iii
we investigate how the unification evolution can be described by a vacuum @xmath0 gravity and in section iv , using well known techniques @xcite , we calculate in detail the resulting power spectrum of the primordial curvature perturbations and the corresponding spectral index .
in addition , we investigate how the primordial perturbations evolve after the horizon crossing .
the conclusions follow in the end of the paper .
in this section we describe in some detail the cosmological model which was developed in ref .
@xcite , in order to understand the qualitative features of the cosmological evolution described by it .
as we now demonstrate , the model describes in a unified way the inflationary era , in terms of an initial quasi - de sitter evolution , the radiation domination and matter domination era , and the late - time acceleration era .
as we shall see , certain fine - tuning of the free parameters is needed so that a late - time acceleration era is achieved .
the hubble rate of the unified cosmological evolution is appears below @xcite , @xmath7 where the parameter @xmath8 is chosen to be of the order @xmath9sec and it characterizes the transition from the radiation domination to the matter domination era .
also the parameter @xmath10 is assumed to characterize the late - time era and also @xmath11 characterizes the early - time era .
particularly , at the time instances @xmath12 and @xmath13 , finite time singularities occur , which depending on the values of the parameters @xmath14 and @xmath15 , can be one of the following types , * if @xmath16 , then the cosmological evolution develops two big rip singularities . *
if @xmath17 , then the cosmological evolution develops two type iii singularities .
* when @xmath18 , then the cosmological evolution develops two type ii singularities . * when @xmath19 , then the cosmological evolution develops two type iv singularities .
it is conceivable that certain combinations can occur , if the parameters @xmath14 and @xmath15 are chosen appropriately , for example we can have a big rip singularity at late times and a type iv singularity at early times , if @xmath20 and @xmath21 , but we shall assume that both @xmath14 and @xmath15 are chosen as @xmath22 .
so this means that two type iv singularities occur for the cosmological model ( [ newmodel ] ) .
particularly , the time instance @xmath12 is assumed to occur at early times and at the end of the inflationary era , while @xmath13 is assumed to occur at late times , near the deceleration - acceleration transition . in order to avoid certain instabilities which might be generated for certain values of @xmath14 and @xmath15 @xcite
, we further assume that @xmath23 .
also we assume that the parameters have the following values , @xmath24 and as we show the parameter @xmath25 crucially determines the late - time behavior of the model .
for the parameters chosen as in ( [ parameterschoicegeneral ] ) , the cosmological evolution of the model ( [ newmodel ] ) at early times is described by the first term of ( [ newmodel ] ) .
when we refer to the early times , it is meant that early times correspond to the inflationary era and right after that , in which case , the function @xmath26 , for @xmath27sec , and for @xmath28 , is approximately equal to , @xmath29 consequently , the last term of the hubble rate ( [ newmodel ] ) is approximated at early times as follows , @xmath30 owing to the fact that during the slow - roll inflationary phase , we have @xmath31 .
consequently , the hubble rate of the cosmological evolution at early times is approximated by a quasi de sitter evolution of the form , @xmath32 the effective equation of state ( eos ) of the cosmological evolution , which for modified gravity models is equal to @xcite , @xmath33 takes the following form at early times , @xmath34 where we took into account that @xmath35 .
since the term @xmath36 , the eos corresponds to a nearly de sitter evolution at early times , since @xmath37 .
after the inflationary era , which ends at approximately @xmath38sec , the universe is described by the radiation domination era which will last until @xmath39sec , as we now demonstrate . for the values of the cosmic time chosen in the interval @xmath40sec ,
the function @xmath41 is approximately equal to @xmath42 , and owing to the fact that @xmath43 , the only dominant term is the hubble rate ( [ newmodel ] ) is the last term , which is approximated by , @xmath44 since in this case , @xmath45 , clearly this corresponds to a radiation domination era , with the eos being equal to @xmath46 .
the behavior around the cosmic time @xmath47 is a bit peculiar , since it describes an intermediate era between the radiation domination and matter domination era . in this case , for @xmath48sec , the function @xmath41 is approximately equal to zero , that is , @xmath49 , and therefore , the hubble rate ( [ newmodel ] ) becomes , @xmath50 which corresponds to an eos approximately equal to , @xmath51 .
clearly , the value of the eos @xmath52 describes an intermediate era between the matter and radiation era , and it is conceivable that the eos continuously deforms from @xmath53 to @xmath54 . in some sense
, this could describe a new matter form , which is collisional @xcite , that is , weakly self - interacting . after the radiation to matter domination transition , and in the cosmic time interval @xmath55sec , the function @xmath56 is approximated by @xmath57 , so the hubble rate is approximated by the following expression , @xmath58 which corresponds to a matter domination era , with an eos @xmath59 .
finally , after the time instance @xmath60 , the second term of the hubble rate ( [ newmodel ] ) starts to dominate , so this term generates the late - time acceleration era , with an eos parameter , @xmath61 which for @xmath62 describes a nearly de sitter acceleration era .
now we describe in brief the behavior of the hubble horizon radius @xmath63 , corresponding to the model ( [ newmodel ] ) , and we discuss the qualitative features that render the model a successful approximation of a viable cosmology . in figs .
[ hubradiusnew ] and [ hubradiusnew1 ] , we have plotted the time dependence of the hubble radius corresponding to the model ( [ newmodel ] ) , for three values of the parameter @xmath25 , namely for @xmath64 ( fig .
[ hubradiusnew ] ) , for @xmath65 ( left plot of fig . [ hubradiusnew1 ] ) , and for @xmath66 ( fig .
[ hubradiusnew1 ] ) . as a function of the cosmic time , for @xmath67 @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 , @xmath71 , @xmath72 , @xmath73 , @xmath27sec . ] before analyzing the behavior , let us note that the resulting picture of the late - time behavior is crucially affected by the parameter @xmath25 , as it can be seen from fig .
[ hubradiusnew1 ] .
actually as @xmath25 decreases , the deceleration - acceleration transition occurs at later and later times .
so we focus on the case depicted in fig .
[ hubradiusnew ] , so for @xmath73 . for this case ,
the hubble radius at early times decreases in a nearly exponential way ( recall it is a quasi de sitter accelerating era ) , then it increases during the radiation and matter domination era and it decreases again after the second type iv singularity which occurs at @xmath74sec .
clearly this is a viable cosmological behavior , when primordial quantum fluctuating modes are taken into account .
particularly , the primordial vacuum quantum modes are initially well inside the hubble radius , at the beginning of the inflationary era , at which point their wavenumber satisfies @xmath75 . as a function of the cosmic time , for @xmath67 @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 , @xmath71 , @xmath72 , @xmath27sec and for @xmath76 (
left plot ) and @xmath77 ( right plot),title="fig : " ] as a function of the cosmic time , for @xmath67 @xmath68 , @xmath69 , @xmath70 , @xmath71 , @xmath72 , @xmath27sec and for @xmath76 ( left plot ) and @xmath77 ( right plot),title="fig : " ] then , during inflation the hubble radius decreases and effectively the modes exit the hubble radius when @xmath78 , and after that these modes go outside the horizon . after the inflationary era , and during the radiation and matter domination era , the hubble radius increases again , and effectively the modes re - enter the horizon , and this is why these modes are relevant for present day observations .
then , the hubble horizon increases until after the second type iv singularity , where the deceleration to acceleration transition occurs , and the hubble horizon starts to decrease again .
note that the behavior we just described characterizes a viable inflationary cosmology @xcite . in conclusion the model ( [ newmodel ] )
has the following appealing qualitative features : * it describes in a unified way all the cosmological eras of the universe , namely , the late and early - time acceleration era and the matter and radiation domination eras . *
it is predicted that there is an intermediate era between the radiation and matter domination transition , where the eos of the universe continuously deforms from a radiation dominated value to a matter domination value .
note that such an eos describes collisional matter fluids @xcite .
* the hubble horizon behaves in the correct way , as is expected for a viable cosmological evolution .
what remains unanswered for the moment is the question if the power spectrum that is generated during inflation is scale invariant and secondly , if the primordial modes , after the horizon exit evolve or these are described by a constant stochastic mean value .
these questions shall be addressed in detail in a later section of this article .
note that the answer to these questions strongly depends on the modified gravity model which realizes the cosmological evolution we just described , so these are of fundamental importance , since this will determine if the @xmath0 gravity approach we shall use in this paper is consistent with observations .
before we answer these , in the next section we investigate how the cosmological evolution ( [ newmodel ] ) can be realized in the context of @xmath0 gravity .
we now proceed to the realization of the unification cosmology ( [ newmodel ] ) by vacuum @xmath0 gravity . to this end
we shall use well known reconstruction techniques @xcite , and we investigate which @xmath0 gravity can approximately generate each era of the model ( [ newmodel ] ) . consider the following jordan frame vacuum @xmath0 gravity action , @xmath79 with @xmath80 , and @xmath81gev . upon variation of the action ( [ actionfggeneral ] ) with respect to the metric , we obtain the following field equations , @xmath82 where @xmath83 is the gauss - bonnet invariant , which in terms of the hubble rate reads , @xmath84 for a flat friedmann - robertson - walker ( frw ) metric of the form , @xmath85 the field equations ( [ fgr1 ] ) become , @xmath86 by introducing the auxiliary functions @xmath87 and @xmath88 , the action ( [ actionfggeneral ] ) becomes , @xmath89 and upon variation with respect to @xmath90
, we acquire the following equation , @xmath91 in effect , by solving eq .
( [ auxeqnsvoithitiko ] ) , with respect to @xmath92 , then by substituting the result in the following equation , @xmath93 this will give the resulting @xmath0 gravity which realizes the given hubble rate @xmath94 .
practically , the vital element of the reconstruction technique is to find the functions @xmath87 and @xmath88 , so we now present how to find these in a direct way . upon combining eq .
( [ ebasc ] ) with the first of the equations of eq .
( [ eqnsfggrav ] ) , we get , @xmath95 which yields the function @xmath88 as a function of @xmath87 . then by substituting eq .
( [ ak ] ) in eq .
( [ ebasc ] ) , we get the following differential equation , @xmath96 the solution of which gives the function @xmath87 .
finding @xmath87 , we also have @xmath88 and then we can obtain the function @xmath92 . finally , upon substitution of the resulting expression in eq .
( [ ebasc ] ) , we obtain the @xmath0 gravity . in the following sections we make extensive use of this method for finding the @xmath0 gravity that realizes each era . at early times
, the hubble rate is approximated by the expression appearing in eq .
( [ approxearlynew ] ) , so the differential equation ( [ diffept ] ) becomes approximately equal to , @xmath97 where we took into account that @xmath98 , at early times . by solving the differential equation ( [ diffept2 ] )
we obtain the function @xmath87 , @xmath99 where @xmath100 and @xmath101 are arbitrary integration constants and also the parameters @xmath102 can be found in the appendix .
accordingly , upon substituting eq .
( [ dfesolu ] ) in eq .
( [ ak ] ) , we acquire the function @xmath88 , which reads , @xmath103 where the parameters @xmath104 can also be found in the appendix . then by substituting @xmath87 and @xmath88 in eq .
( [ auxeqnsvoithitiko ] ) , and by solving with respect to @xmath90 we get , @xmath105}{\kappa_2}\ , .\ ] ] so finally , the @xmath0 gravity reads , @xmath106}{2 \kappa_1 \kappa_2}\ , .\ ] ] we can further simplify the resulting @xmath0 gravity , by taking into account that the gauss - bonnet invariant ( [ gausbonehub ] ) at early times is approximately equal to , @xmath107 and since @xmath108 and @xmath35 , this means that at early times , @xmath109 .
so the resulting @xmath0 gravity at leading order is , @xmath110 where the parameters @xmath111 can be found in the appendix .
the approximate expression for the @xmath0 gravity shall play a crucial role in the calculation of the power spectrum of the primordial curvature perturbations , so we will make extensive use of eq .
( [ fgearly ] ) in the sections to follow . in a similar way
, we can find the approximate expressions for the @xmath0 gravities that realize the rest cosmological eras , and we omit most of the details for brevity .
particularly , for the radiation domination era , in which case the hubble rate is approximately equal to @xmath45 , so the resulting @xmath87 function is , @xmath112 where @xmath113 are arbitrary integration constants . by choosing for simplicity @xmath114 ,
the function @xmath88 reads , @xmath115 and therefore the function @xmath116 reads , @xmath117 consequently , the resulting @xmath0 gravity is , @xmath118 before proceeding to the matter domination era , we need to note that in the case of @xmath1 gravity description of the radiation domination era we needed to find leading order approximations of the hubble rate , since in the case that the hubble rate is exactly given by @xmath45 , the ricci scalar was equal to zero , see @xcite for more details on this leading order expansion . in the gauss - bonnet description however , this problem no longer persists , since in this case the gauss - bonnet invariant is @xmath119 , which is non - zero .
we now proceed to the matter domination era @xmath0 gravity description , with the hubble rate being in this case equal to @xmath120 , so the resulting @xmath87 function is , @xmath121 where @xmath122 are again arbitrary integration constants . by choosing for simplicity @xmath123
, the function @xmath88 reads in this case , @xmath124 and consequently the function @xmath116 reads , @xmath125 and as in the radiation domination case , the resulting @xmath0 gravity description reads , @xmath126 which has the same power dependence with respect to the gauss - bonnet invariant as in the radiation domination case . finally , following the same procedure , the resulting @xmath0 gravity that realizes the late - time behavior is , @xmath127 where the parameters @xmath128 , can be found in the appendix . in table
[ table1 ] , we gathered the resulting expressions for the @xmath0 gravity in all the cosmological eras .
@|c|r|rrrrrrrrrr@ cosmological era & @xmath0 gravity realization + early - time era & @xmath129 + radiation domination era & @xmath130 + matter domination era & @xmath131 + late - time era & @xmath132 +
as we demonstrated in the previous sections , the @xmath0 gravity theoretical framework can successfully produce the cosmological eras corresponding to the evolution ( [ newmodel ] ) and now the question is if the corresponding evolution is compatible with the observational data .
as was shown in @xcite , in the context of @xmath1 gravity the cosmological evolution was compatible with the observational data , since the early - time @xmath1 gravity was described by the @xmath133 starobinsky inflation model , so the primordial cosmological perturbations have a nearly scale invariant power spectrum . in this section
we explicitly calculate in detail the power spectrum of primordial curvature perturbations , and as we demonstrate , the resulting power spectrum is not scale invariant , indicating that not all modified gravity realizations of the same cosmological evolution are successful when confronted with observational data . in addition , another interesting issue which we address in this section has to do with the evolution of the primordial curvature perturbations that exit the hubble horizon at early times .
particularly the question is if these evolve in time after the initial horizon crossing . in the @xmath1 gravity description ,
once these modes exited the horizon during inflation , they froze and therefore were described by a stochastic mean value with no time dependence .
however , this is not granted for any cosmological evolution , for example in matter bounce cosmologies the perturbations that exited the horizon evolve in time , see @xcite . as we demonstrate in the @xmath0 gravity case , these modes decay exponentially in time .
we shall calculate the power spectrum of scalar primordial curvature perturbations , so we consider the following linear scalar perturbations of the frw background ( [ metricformfrwhjkh ] ) , @xmath134 where the functions @xmath135 , @xmath136 , @xmath14 and @xmath137 quantify the smooth scalar perturbations of the frw metric . by using the linearly perturb frw metric ( [ scalarpertrbubations ] ) , the calculation of the power spectrum is straightforward and for details we refer to @xcite .
the perturbations can be evaluated quantitatively in an elegant way if gauge invariant quantities are considered , so we shall make use of the following gauge invariant quantity , @xmath138 which is known as the comoving curvature perturbation , where the function @xmath139 stands for @xmath140 .
the master equation that determines the evolution of the scalar perturbation modes in the context of @xmath0 gravity is @xcite , @xmath141 and it can be seen that the @xmath142 modes determine the evolution at early times .
the function @xmath143 corresponds to the propagation speed and in the @xmath0 gravity case it is equal to , @xmath144 while the function @xmath145 in eq .
( [ perteqnmain ] ) is equal to , @xmath146 where @xmath147 , and with the dot denoting as usual differentiation with respect to the cosmic time , while the prime differentiation with respect to the gauss - bonnet scalar @xmath83 .
we are interested in finding an approximation of the power spectrum at early times , so the @xmath0 gravity is approximately equal to the expression given in eq .
( [ fgearly ] ) , while the hubble rate at early times is given in eq .
( [ approxearlynew ] ) . by taking into account that @xmath98 at early times , the differential equation that determines
the evolution of primordial curvature perturbations ( [ perteqnmain ] ) becomes approximately equal to , @xmath148 and by solving it , we obtain the following expression which describes the evolution of the comoving perturbations at early times , @xmath149 where @xmath150 are arbitrary integration constants . note that since we are interested in finding the behavior at early times , this corresponds to the large wavenumber limit , that is @xmath151 , so in this limit , the comoving perturbation ( [ solutionevolutionnewpap ] ) becomes , @xmath152 where for simplicity we chose the integration constants to satisfy @xmath153 .
having the time dependence of the comoving curvature perturbation at hand , we can easily compute the power spectrum , which in terms of @xmath154 is equal to , @xmath155 and it is defined at the horizon crossing .
so by substituting eq .
( [ solutionevolution ] ) to ( [ powerspecetrumfgr ] ) , the power spectrum reads , @xmath156 and this has to be evaluated at the horizon crossing . by taking into account the horizon crossing condition @xmath78 ,
the power spectrum becomes , @xmath157 so what remains is to calculate the @xmath158-dependence of the integration constant @xmath159 , which can be easily done by taking into account the initial conditions for the comoving curvature perturbation .
particularly we assume that the comoving perturbation @xmath154 is related to a bunch - davies initial vacuum state , in a way we now demonstrate .
for convenience we use a canonical scalar field @xmath160 and the conformal time @xmath161 , which is related to the cosmic time as @xmath162 . at early times , since @xmath35 , the exponential scale factor describing the nearly de sitter evolution is approximately equal to @xmath163 , so practically @xmath161 and @xmath90 at early times are approximately the same .
the canonical scalar @xmath160 is defined in terms of the comoving curvature @xmath154 as @xmath164 , where @xmath165 , so at early times we have , @xmath166 where @xmath145 is given in eq .
( [ gfgdhbhhyhjs ] ) . the action corresponding to the canonical scalar field @xmath160 is equal to , @xmath167\ , , \ ] ] with the prime this time indicating differentiation with respect to the conformal time , which at early times is approximately identical to the cosmic time .
we therefore assume that the canonical scalar is identical to a bunch - davies vacuum state before inflation , so @xmath168 , at early times , and hence the integration constant @xmath159 is approximately equal to , @xmath169 so by combining the above results we obtain the @xmath158-dependence of the power spectrum @xmath170 at early times , @xmath171 which is not scale invariant , but the question is if it can be nearly scale invariant . in order to see this
, we now calculate the spectral index of the primordial curvature perturbations , which is defined in terms of the power spectrum @xmath170 as follows , @xmath172 so by inserting the result of eq .
( [ powerspectrumfinal ] ) , the resulting spectral index reads , @xmath173 and it can be checked that the resulting spectrum can not produce a spectral index compatible the recent planck observational data @xcite .
therefore , the comoving curvature perturbations corresponding to the @xmath0 gravity theory do not produce a scale invariant spectrum .
before closing , note that the resulting picture might be an artifact of the approximate expressions we used for obtaining the early - time @xmath0 gravity .
hence , it could be possible that a loop quantum cosmology corrected @xmath0 gravity theory @xcite could produce a scale invariant spectrum .
this can produce however a red spectrum , so it might be doubtful how the quantum corrections could alter the resulting picture .
we hope to address this issue in detail in the future .
a last issue we want to address before we close thus section , is the evolution of the primordial perturbations after these exit the hubble horizon during inflation . in standard inflationary cosmology ,
the primordial perturbations do not evolve in time after the horizon crossing and these are described by a stochastic mean value , and hence these are conserved and remain unaltered until these enter the horizon at a later stage .
this is a crucial feature of the standard inflationary scenario , since the conservation of the primordial modes enables us to make predictions about inflation .
this is due to the fact that when these modes reenter the horizon , these reveal us the form of perturbations when these exited the horizon at early times .
there are scenarios in cosmology for which the perturbations evolve in time , like for example in the matter bounce scenario case @xcite .
as we now demonstrate , the primordial perturbations do not grow in the present case , but exponentially decay at times after the horizon crossing . in order to proceed ,
we will focus on primordial modes for which the wavenumber satisfies @xmath174 . in that case ,
the differential equation ( [ perteqnmain ] ) becomes , @xmath175 the solution of which is , @xmath176 where @xmath145 is defined in eq .
( [ gfgdhbhhyhjs ] ) , and @xmath150 are arbitrary integration constants .
we shall be interested in cosmic times just after the end of inflation , so the scale factor can be approximated by @xmath177 , and also @xmath145 is approximately equal to , @xmath178 where we kept only dominant terms .
so by inserting @xmath179 and @xmath180 in eq .
( [ soldiffeqn ] ) , we acquire , @xmath181 where the parameter @xmath182 is , @xmath183 therefore , the functional form of the evolution ( [ finalresultforpertevol ] ) indicates that the evolution of the perturbations much later than the horizon crossing exponentially decay .
we need to note that the behavior we just described is very common in all the inflationary scenarios , so this result was in some sense expected , so the @xmath0 case generates primordial perturbations which are conserved after the horizon crossing .
in this article we investigated which vacuum @xmath0 gravity can realize a cosmological evolution which can approximately describe the four evolution eras of our universe . particularly , we were interested in finding which @xmath0 gravity can realize each cosmological era , and we calculated the power spectrum of primordial curvature perturbations corresponding to early - time evolution . as we demonstrated
, the @xmath0 gravity description differs from the @xmath1 gravity description , because the resulting power spectrum is not compatible with the latest observational data .
thus , this quantitatively proves that not all modified gravity descriptions are equivalent and successful , when these are confronted with observations .
of course , this is not obvious without explicitly calculating the power spectrum corresponding to each modified gravity description , so it would be interesting to address the problem we studied in this paper , in the context of more general modified gravity theories , like for example @xmath184 gravity @xcite . in that case , as was demonstrated in @xcite , @xmath185-powers of the wavenumber appear in the master equation which governs the power spectrum of primordial curvature perturbations , and thus superluminal modes appear in the spectrum .
this behavior could alter the resulting picture for the cosmological evolution we studied in this paper , and we intend to address in a future work . in the same fashion ,
the @xmath186 gravity @xcite case should also be investigated .
an interesting question is whether the holonomy corrected @xmath0 theory @xcite can make the power spectrum nearly scale invariant .
particularly , if we include the loop quantum cosmology effects , the question is whether the power spectrum is rendered scale invariant .
this problem could be addressed in the way it was treated in @xcite , so the calculation of the power spectrum for the holonomy corrected theory is straightforward .
this work is supported by min . of education and science of russia ( v.k.o ) .
here we present the detailed form of the various parameters we used in the text .
the parameters @xmath102 appearing in eq .
( [ dfesolu ] ) are equal to , @xmath187 also the parameters @xmath104 appearing in eq .
( [ qt ] ) , are equal to , @xmath188 and also the parameters @xmath111 appearing in eq .
( [ fgearly ] ) are equal to , @xmath189\right)}{2 \kappa_1 \kappa_2 } \\
\notag & \rho_2=\left(\omega_1+\frac{h_i \omega_3}{2 \kappa_2 \kappa_3}+\frac{\omega_2 \ln\left[\frac{h_i}{2 \kappa_2 \kappa_3}\right]}{\kappa_2}\right ) \\ \notag & \rho_3=\frac{\kappa_1 ( 2 \kappa_3 \omega_2+h_i \omega_3)^2}{4 \left(h_i \kappa_2 \kappa_3 ^ 2\right)}\ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally , the parameters @xmath128 , appearing in eq .
( [ latetimefg ] ) are equal to , @xmath190 y. cai , y. t. wang and y. s. piao , phys .
d * 92 * ( 2015 ) 2 , 023518 [ arxiv:1501.01730 [ astro-ph.co ] ] .
y. s. piao , b. feng and x. m. zhang , phys .
d * 69 * ( 2004 ) 103520 [ hep - th/0310206 ] .
y. s. piao , phys .
d * 71 * ( 2005 ) 087301 [ astro - ph/0502343 ] .
j. mielczarek , m. kamionka , a. kurek and m. szydlowski , jcap * 1007 * ( 2010 ) 004 [ arxiv:1005.0814 [ gr - qc ] ] . | in this paper we demonstrate that with vacuum @xmath0 gravity it is possible to describe the unification of late and early - time acceleration eras with the radiation and matter domination era .
the hubble rate of the unified evolution contains two mild singularities , so called type iv singularities , and the evolution itself has some appealing features , such as the existence of a deceleration - acceleration transition at late times .
we also address quantitatively a fundamental question related to modified gravity models description of cosmological evolution : is it possible for all modified gravity descriptions of our universe evolution , to produce a nearly scale invariant spectrum of primordial curvature perturbations ? as we demonstrate , the answer for the @xmath0 description is no , since the resulting power spectrum is not scale invariant , in contrast to the @xmath1 description studied in the literature .
therefore , although the cosmological evolution can be realized in the context of vacuum @xmath0 gravity , the evolution is not compatible with the observational data , in contrast to the @xmath1 gravity description of the same cosmological evolution . |
membrane hemifusion is a possible pathway ( see @xcite for an alternative view ) to the complete fusion of membranes @xcite .
current theories associate the initiation of hemifusion with the formation of a contact zone between the membranes in which the two proximal monolayers are connected by a stalk - shaped neck .
the stalk then expands and a region is formed ( region c in fig .
[ fig : setup ] ) , in which the two distal monolayers form a single bilayer . in general
, the energetic cost of the splay of the lipid chains in the stalk , prohibits its spontaneous expansion .
however , the presence of additional , external forces ( e.g. pressure , surface tension gradients , electrostatic effects ) can lead to expansion of the stalk into a hemifusion region and to the growth of this zone .
clear evidence for the existence of these two distinct pre - fusion stages , stalk formation and hemifusion , was found for peg mediated fusion of vesicles @xcite .
a recent theoretical paper @xcite suggested that the flow of lipids from region b to region a can be caused by an increase of the surface tension in region a due to the presence ( in that region only ) of additional polymer in solution .
the tension gradient between these regions induces a flow of lipids , that leads to the growth of region c. a different scenario , where hemifusion can be an alternative pathway to fusion was found in influenza hemagglutinin - mediated fusion @xcite .
the initial local stalk may evolve to a fusion pore @xcite , or it may expand to hemifusion . in the latter case ,
no fusion occurs . in this paper
, we predict the dynamics of the expansion of the initial stalk and its role in the growth of a mesoscopic hemifusion diaphragm .
the nucleation of a stalk by thermal fluctuations was recently shown to be thermally accessible @xcite . a detailed description of the kinetics of this nucleation event ( that typically describes the formation of a stalk of several nanometers in extent ) is outside the scope of our work . instead , we focus on estimates of the conditions that facilitate stalk expansion into hemifusion .
we discuss the implications of our theory on biological fusion mechanisms and on in - vitro experiments .
in addition , we predict the growth of the hemifusion region ( e.g. from nanometers to microns ) as a function of time and discuss the physical parameters that can be used to control the time scale for hemifusion .
this dynamic part is relevant mainly to in - vitro experiments , since biological fusion events generally remain at the microscopic scale of the stalk .
if hemifusion is an intermediate state of fusion then it is important to contrast the time scales of hemifusion diaphragm expansion and pore formation , in order to determine the rate limiting step .
@xcite predicted that pore expansion is exponential in time , with a time scale of @xmath0 sec , where @xmath1 is the membrane viscosity and @xmath2 is the surface tension difference ( both are estimated below ) .
however , if pore nucleation is slow enough significant expansion of the hemifusion diaphragm can occur before pore formation .
this is the case considered here , where we predict that the hemifusion diaphragm expands as the square root of time .
our theoretical model is motivated by and consistent with the experiments described by @xcite , where two bilayers supported on mica surfaces were brought into contact in the presence of a peg - water solution .
hemifusion , that eventually extended over a distance of @xmath3 was observed in a time of about 10 minutes , while the time it took the initial stalk to form was less then 3 minutes .
this suggest that , at least in this experiment , the rate limiting step for hemifusion is the expansion of the fusion zone , as opposed to stalk formation .
this paper presents a simple theoretical model relevant to this experimental system @xcite , and predicts the time dependence of hemifusion expansion . the overall time scale we find is comparable with the measurements of @xcite while the details of the predicted temporal dependence have yet to be tested experimentally .
our theoretical model is illustrated in fig .
[ fig : setup ] that is a simplification of the experimental system of @xcite wherein two bilayers deposited on mica cylinders are brought together in a solution of peg and water .
the lipids of the distal monolayers are physisorbed on the mica ; this fixes their lateral density . from here
on in this paper , the term lipid
density relates to the lateral density of the proximal monolayers ( see fig . [
fig : setup ] ) .
we assume that the lipids are in _ local _ equilibrium , so at a particular location @xmath4 , the free energy per lipid ( in the proximal monolayers ) @xmath5 , does not depend on the lipid microstate , but only on the lipid density @xmath6 .
this assumption of local equilibrium is consistent with our results that predict an overall time scale for hemifusion expansion that is much larger than the local diffusion time of a single lipid molecule . the experimental system we consider is macroscopically cylindrically symmetric and we therefore assume cylindrical symmetry of all the physical quantities at mesoscopic length scales .
this is justified because all flows ( of water and lipids ) are laminar , and there are no mechanisms that might induce angular fluctuations or instabilities .
we distinguish between three regions , illustrated in fig .
[ fig : setup ] : * * region a * - where the distance @xmath7 between the bilayers is typically much larger than the polymer correlation length @xmath8 @xcite . in this region ,
the outer lipid monolayer is in contact with the peg in the solution .
the free energy per molecule in this region is given by @xmath9 , and is different ( in its functional form ) from the free energy @xmath10 of the monolayer in the absence of peg .
* * region b * - where @xmath11 . for these values of @xmath7 ,
the peg density near the bilayers is negligible and our model assumes that there is no peg in contact with the bilayers in this region .
the free energy per lipid in this zone is @xmath12 .
in addition we assume that the distance between the mica surfaces is constant ( the mica surfaces in the experiment are deformed and flattened under pressure ) , and that this region is ring - shaped with an outer radius @xmath13 , and an inner radius @xmath14 . * * region c * - the region where the distal bilayers are in contact .
the bilayers are langmuir - blodgett deposited in water , without peg , which is added later .
the energy per lipid when the monolayers are in contact with water is @xmath10 and the proximal monolayers are initially langmuir - blodgett deposited with a density @xmath15 that minimizes @xmath16 .
when peg is added , it induces an effective attraction between the polar heads @xcite , and changes the functional form of the energy as function of the lipid density to @xmath17 .
the effect of lipid condensation in the presence of peg @xcite hasa been discussed in terms of the the dehydration of the bilayer by the peg @xcite .
this dehydration affects the lipids in region a that are in microscopic proximity to the peg , but has no effect on the lipids in region b. in sec .
[ sec : pressure ] we demonstrate that the osmotic pressure induced by the peg is too small to induce hemifusion .
this stands in contrast to the surface tension effects that are the main focus of our work .
if equilibrium could be reached , the lipid density in region a would tend to increase in the presence of peg .
however , the number of lipids in the monolayers can not increase to any significant degree within the time scale of the experiments , since the concentration of lipids in the bulk solution is negligible and the number of lipids that can be transported from region b to region a is much smaller than that of region a. thus , the lipid density is unchanged and the energy per lipid in region a is now @xmath18 , with the derivative @xmath19 due to the induced head attraction .
this condensation effect thus leads to a _ negative tension _ in the proximal monolayers that ideally would cause them to contract in extent .
they can not do this without exposing the chains of the inner monolayers to the water and this is energetically prohibitive .
the outer monolayers are therefore stressed and one way of relieving that stress is for additional lipid to enter this region ; this will allow the local lipid density to increase , while still covering the original area occupied by the outer monolayer .
the peg concentration near the outer monolayers in region b is given by @xmath20 , where @xmath21 is the peg concentration near the outer monolayers in region a , @xmath8 is polymer correlation length , and @xmath7 is the distance between the bilayers in region b @xcite . since by the definition of region b , the bilayer spacing in that region is small , @xmath11 , we have @xmath22 and the peg concentration in region b is negligible ; we thus take this concentration to be zero . the energy per lipid in region
b is _ initially _ given by @xmath23 , where @xmath15 is the lipid density in the absence of polymer .
since the free energy per lipid , @xmath16 , is minimized when the density @xmath24 and the tension in region b initially vanishes , since either expansion or compression of the lipids will increase their energy .
the tension gradient between regions a ( initially at negative tension ) and b ( initially at zero tension ) induces a flow of lipids from region b to region a. since region a is much larger than region b , we can treat it as a reservoir , and assume that even though lipid is flowing from region b to region a , the lipid density in region a is not changed from its initial value of @xmath15 .
the system is a dynamical one and the chemical potential ( equivalent in our single component system to the free energy per lipid , @xmath16 ) is not constant in all of space at the mesoscopic scale ; this results in lipid flow and dynamics .
however , since local equilibrium _ is _ maintained , we must have equal chemical potentials at any given point in the system .
in particular , at the boundary between regions a and b , the chemical potentials of the lipids must be equal : @xmath25 , where @xmath26 is the lipid density at the edge of region b. we note that this equality of chemical potentials determines the lipid density at the boundary of region b , @xmath27 ; the functional form of the two free energies @xmath10 and @xmath17 are not the same , since in region a , the lipids are in contact with polymer . the initial lipid density in region b ( @xmath15 , which is the density at which the lipids self - assemble in water in the absence of polymer ) is higher than the lipid density at the ab boundary : @xmath28 .
this inequality is a consequence of the fact that the tension at the boundary is negative , as shown in section [ sec : boundcond ] .
more intuitively , the negative tension in region a tends to pull in additional lipids from the boundary region of region b into region a as explained above .
this lipid flow reduces the lipid density at the boundary @xmath29 from @xmath15 to @xmath27 . in turn
, the reduced lipid density at the boundary of regions a and b , ( @xmath30 ) induces a flow of lipids from the rest of region b towards the boundary .
this is because the minimum energy state in region b is one where @xmath31 ; thus lipids from the entirety of region b flow to the boundary in an attempt to restore the lipid density there to values closer to @xmath15 .
this flow , in turn , reduces the lipid density at the boundary between regions b and c ( the hemifusion region ) at @xmath32 , and lead to a negative tension that tends to expand region c. at the boundary of regions b and c , the lipid density is determined by a force balance between the membrane negative tension ( arising from the lipids flowing to the ab boundary ) , that tends to expand region c , and the force exerted by the boundary ring around region c that tends to shrink it .
the main contribution to the energy of this ring is of the tilt of the lipid tails imposed by the toroidal geometry .
this tilt is needed in order to form the three - way junction of the boundary ring cross section while avoiding an intra - membrane void , which has a much higher energetic cost @xcite .
the energetic cost of the tilt can be considered through the related intra - membrane strain and the adjacent stress tensor @xcite .
we assume that for @xmath33 the energetic cost @xmath34 for a cross section of the bc boundary ring is independent of @xmath14 .
thus , the ring energy is given by @xmath35 .
the force per unit length that the ring exerts on region b of the membrane tends to shrink region c and pull region b in the @xmath36 direction .
this force ( per unit length ) is @xmath37 and tends to shrink the boundary ring ; that is , the expansion of region c is energetically costly . in local equilibrium , this force is balanced by the surface tension @xmath38 , which may be considered as a two dimensional lateral lipid pressure , in region b of the monolayer that tends to expand the ring : @xmath39 negative tension in region b tends to cause this region to contract and thus provides a force in the @xmath40 direction , balancing the force due to the bc boundary .
in this section we derive the dynamics that govern the expansion of the hemifusion region and predict the flow of lipids within the monolayer as a function of the lipid density and of time .
there are three local , dissipative forces that oppose any lipid motion .
* the stress , or force per unit area due to the viscosity of the water that is moved along with the lipids is given by @xmath41 , where @xmath42 is the water velocity and @xmath43 erg s/@xmath44 is the viscosity of water .
the stress is of order @xmath45 , where @xmath46 is the lipid velocity and @xmath7 is the spacing between the bilayers in region b. * the stress , or force per unit area due to the monolayer viscosity is given by @xmath47 , where @xmath1 is the monolayer friction coefficient @xcite .
for a laminar flow we estimate this stress as @xmath48 ; that is , the relevant dimension is the size of region b in which there is monolayer flow . * the stress , or force per unit area that is due to the friction _ between _ the monolayers is given by @xmath49 , where @xmath50 is the friction coefficient .
this stress depends only on the motion of the outer relative to the inner monolayer where there is no flow ; there is therefore no dependence of the length scale related to the geometry of the different regions .
the friction between a dmpc monolayer and a supporting hts monolayer at @xmath51 is @xmath52erg s/@xmath53 , while for a supported ots monolayer the friction is @xmath54 erg s/@xmath53 @xcite .
the experiments of @xcite were carried out at @xmath55 .
it has been observed that the diffusion coefficient of a molecule in a dmpc monolayer increases about three folds when @xmath56 is increased from @xmath55 to @xmath57 @xcite , which suggest a corresponding decrease in @xmath50 . in this work
we use an estimated value of @xmath58 erg s/@xmath53 . for dmpc bilayers at @xmath59
the bilayer viscosity is @xmath60 erg s/@xmath61 @xcite .
the values relevant to the experiments of @xcite are @xmath62 cm and @xmath63 cm . with the estimates for the stress given above
, we find that the frictional force due to relative motion of the two monolayers is much larger than either the lipid or water viscosity contributions to the stress .
we thus neglect these latter two effects and predict the dynamics for a system where the only relevant dissipation is due to the relative friction between the monolayers .
the lipid flow is induced by the tension gradient @xmath64 , and is opposed by the frictional @xmath65 .
the force balance equation is @xmath66 in appendix [ ap : local ] we derive the lipid local dynamics using eq .
[ eq : fb ] and the continuity equation .
we consider the dynamics only to first order in the lipid density variations @xmath67 , which is known from experiments to be small . in @xcite a variation of @xmath68 was measured .
to first order in @xmath69 the local dynamics has the form of a diffusion equation @xmath70 where @xmath71 is the harmonic spring constant of the monolayer . for a small density variation
@xmath72 the surface energy cost is @xmath73 , and the related tension difference is @xmath74 .
we note that the _ surface energy _ @xmath75 is the gibbs free energy per unit area , and is different then the _ surface tension _ @xmath76 , which has the thermodynamic role of the two dimensional pressure .
we estimate @xmath77 using the phenomenological form @xmath78 where @xmath79 is the effective surface tension of the hydrocarbon - water interface @xcite . the second term in eq .
[ eq : musigma ] accounts for the ( electrostatic ) effective head - group repulsion , while the first term represents the effective hydrocarbon - water repulsion .
we note that this effective repulsion is smaller than the repulsion of the bare hydrocarbon - water interface , and has been estimated as @xmath80 erg/@xmath61 @xcite . from eq .
[ eq : musigma ] we obtain @xmath81 erg/@xmath61 . for @xmath58 erg s/@xmath53 the effective diffusion constant is @xmath82 @xmath83sec .
this quantity is larger than the actual , microscopic diffusion constant measured for free liquid bilayers above the gel transition , that are of the order of @xmath84 @xmath83sec @xcite .
the einstein relation is not applicable in our case , since the flow ( that happens to scale like diffusion ) of the lipids from the high to low density regions is not due to the random motion of the molecules , but due to the tension gradient @xmath85 .
indeed , for a characteristic molecular area @xmath86 @xmath61 we find that the related energy per molecule is @xmath87 .
the boundary conditions for the lipid density were already discussed in section [ sec : thmod ] and we review them here for convenience . the local tension equilibrium at the boundary with region a determines the local lipid density @xmath27 at @xmath13 .
in appendix [ ap : local ] we show that the tension in the monolayer is given by @xmath88 since the tension in region a is negative , from the tension equality at the boundary we see that @xmath89 is negative .
moreover , because the function @xmath10 has a minimum at @xmath15 it is convex in a neighborhood of @xmath15 .
if @xmath27 is in that neighborhood , then the condition @xmath90 yields that @xmath91 . the boundary ring near the hemifusion region at @xmath14 exerts a force that opposes hemifusion expansion ; this is because the boundary energy of the hemifusion region is increased as this region grows .
this force is locally balanced by the negative tension in region b where lipids are flowing towards region a. as lipids pass from region b to a the lipid density in region b decreases ; the tension in region b , and in particular near its boundary with region c , becomes more negative and pulls on region c causing its expansion .
the density of lipids in region b at the boundary @xmath14 is determined from the force balance eq .
[ eq : fbeq ] . using eq .
[ eq : pl ] we may write eq .
[ eq : fbeq ] as @xmath92 before the flow begins , the initial lipid density in region b is @xmath15 , which implies that @xmath93 . for this value of the lipid density
there is zero tension in region b , the stalk does not expand and hemifusion does not develop . due to
the tension gradient between region b and a , lipids flow out of region b and a negative tension is built up .
if at a certain time the lipid density at @xmath32 is low enough so that eq .
[ eq : bc1 ] is satisfied , the stalk begins to expand .
after the flow of lipids is initiated , lipids are removed from region b as they flow towards region a and the lipid density in region b is lower than @xmath15 . the lipid density in region b can not , however , be smaller than the value of @xmath27 , because when @xmath94 the free energies per lipid in regions a and b are equal , and the flow stops .
thus , we require @xmath95 in all of region b if there is to be flow and stalk expansion that leads to hemifusion . at an early time after the stalk formation , while the stalk does not expand , the lipid density in all of region b approaches the equilibrium density profile @xmath96 . using eq .
[ eq : bc1 ] , the condition for the stalk to begin to expand with a finite amount of time is : @xmath97 where @xmath98 and @xmath99 is the radius of the stalk . in our model , we consider the process for @xmath14 much larger than the molecular size @xmath99 that characterizes the size of the stalk .
the tilt energy @xmath34 is in general positive . from eqs .
[ eq : pl ] and [ eq : inicond ] , for @xmath100 we have @xmath101 .
since we consider all quantities only to first order in @xmath102 we use the approximation @xmath103 . in appendix
[ ap : global ] we use the integral continuity equation , that expresses the conservation the lipid number in the system , in order to obtain a dynamic equation for the hemifusion radius @xmath14 . in appendix
[ ap : adiabatic ] we show that the time scale that governs the local dynamics is much faster then the rate of change of @xmath14 .
we use an adiabatic approximation in order to solve the dynamics .
first , we fix @xmath14 and find the asymptotic ( @xmath104 ) lipid density profile @xmath105 we use this density profile to obtain the dependence of the hemifusion radius @xmath14 on the time @xmath106 to find : @xmath107 this predicts an approximately square root dependence of the hemifusion region size on time ( with logarithmic corrections ) . the same temporal dependence was obtained by @xcite under the assumption of constant lateral lipid density .
however , their result is quantitatively different from ours since they have considered the monolayer viscosity as the main dissipative force , while we have showed that it is negligible compared to the friction @xmath50 . from eq .
[ eq : taur ] we find that the time it takes the hemifusion region to evolve from the initial stalk radius @xmath108 to a final radius of @xmath109 is @xmath110 . with @xmath111 and @xmath112 @xmath83sec
, we predict that the time for expansion of the hemifusion zone to a scale of @xmath113 m is @xmath114 sec .
this is consistent with the experiment of @xcite where a time of @xmath115 sec was measured .
the time @xmath116 found here can also be derived ( up to a numerical factor ) from a simple scaling argument , that does not depend on the specific details of our model .
as hemifusion is initiated , the tension difference between the bulk ( at @xmath13 ) and the hemifusion front ( at @xmath14 ) is @xmath117 . when @xmath118 the average tension gradient is @xmath119 . for a fully damped flow with a friction coefficient
@xmath50 the average lipid velocity is @xmath120 .
the hemifusion front ( bc boundary ) advances with the velocity @xmath121 of the lipids near it .
the time to advance a distance of @xmath13 with a velocity @xmath122 is @xmath123 .
the change in the monolayer surface energy due to the presence of peg in region a is @xmath124 , where @xmath23 is the free energy per lipid in the absence of peg , and @xmath125 is the free energy per lipid in the presence of peg . since we have defined @xmath27 by the condition @xmath126 , we can expand @xmath16 around its minimal value @xmath24 , and find that to lowest order in @xmath102 the surface energy difference @xmath127 and the tension difference @xmath2 induced by the peg are @xmath128 in @xcite a change of @xmath129 in lipid density was deduced from the measured thinning of the bilayer . using the value @xmath130 erg/@xmath61 we estimate @xmath131 erg/@xmath61 ; @xmath132 erg/@xmath61 .
initiation of stalk expansion is relevant not only to events of mesoscopic fusion , but also to in - vivo fusion events , where a fusion pore is formed soon after stalk expansion .
in many cases of biological interest , the fusion process is regulated by fusion proteins that promote stalk formation and expansion .
one hypothesized bio - molecular mechanism that promote expansion is the penetration of hydrophobic fusion protein domains into the membrane and its subsequent destabilization @xcite .
the protein domains may increase the membrane surface energy by inducing an effective attraction of the hydrophobic head groups , similar to the effect of peg @xcite ; they may also penetrate the membrane , increasing the intra - membrane tension .
our theory suggests that the former mechanism , which work to increase in @xmath127 , may be more effective energetically than the latter , which increases @xmath2 .
that is , for a given change in lipid density , @xmath102 , a smaller energy is involved ( eq . [ eq : tendiff ] ) .
snare proteins that promote exocytosis in nerve synapses are thought to induce stalk expansion through a conformational change by which the protein pull on the stalk to widen it @xcite .
another possible cause for stalk expansion is calcium ions induced membrane tension @xcite .
we conclude from our theory that the latter mechanism may be more effective energetically .
in section [ sec : boundcond ] we found that in order for expansion of the hemifusion region to occur , the driving force due to the negative tension in region b must be large enough to overcome the tendency of the boundary of region c to shrink .
we thus deduced that the normalized lipid density at @xmath13 must obey @xmath133 from this condition , we estimate the minimum stalk radius @xmath99 for which the lateral tension in the monolayer can induce expansion
. the energy of the lipid tails tilt at the hemifusion front is estimated by @xcite as @xmath134 erg / cm .
for the values of @xmath77 and @xmath102 given above , we find that the mechanism described here is sufficient to cause hemifusion for @xmath135 nm , which is of the order of the typical radius of a thermally nucleated stalk @xcite .
note that if @xmath102 vanishes ( that is , no polymer is present in region a ) hemifusion will not be initiated for any finite ( reasonable ) stalk radius .
experiments have demonstrated that hemifusion may be caused by sufficiently large normal pressure @xcite or by negative pressure in the water layer @xcite .
we shall now determine the conditions under which pressure induced in region b can in and of itself ( i.e. with no surface tension effects as induced by the added polymer ) cause hemifusion expansion by forcing water to flow out of the contact zone .
we do this by using the simplifying assumption that the water in region b is under a constant pressure @xmath136 , where @xmath137 is the normal pressure on the bilayers and @xmath138 is the osmotic pressure induced by the solute in the bulk .
the finite thickness of the water layer in region b ( whose thickness is on the order of a nanometer ) is always maintained because of hydration forces : the water molecules are organized around the polar head groups of the lipids in order to partially cancel their electric dipole ; removing the water layer would increase the free energy because of the energetic cost of these electric dipoles whose normal components , in general , point to the same direction due to the hydrophobic nature of the lipid layer .
thus the water flow out of region b and into region a is possible only by the expansion of region c. the energy ( per unit area ) difference associated with a pressure difference of @xmath139 is @xmath140 , where @xmath7 is the distance between the two proximal monolayers .
this should be compared with the energy difference @xmath127 associated with the free energy gradient in the monolayer . in the experiment of @xcite that yield
@xmath141 erg/@xmath61 , which is of the same order of @xmath127 .
nevertheless , we show below that the external normal pressure has only a minor effect on the pressure in the monolayer and on its density
. we will thus show that under the experimental conditions of @xcite , the external pressure is _ insufficient _ to cause hemifusion expansion . in the experiment of @xcite
the applied normal pressure is @xmath142 atm and the osmotic pressure is @xmath143 atm , so the total pressure between the bilayers is @xmath144 atm .
we now estimate the contribution of this pressure to the lipid density variation in the experiment . for a fluid membrane ,
the relation between the tension @xmath38 - the two dimensional pressure in the membrane - to the three dimensional pressure @xmath139 , is @xmath145 , where @xmath146 is the thickness of the monolayer . in order to induce the observed density variation @xmath147
the tension needed is @xmath148 erg/@xmath61 . for @xmath149
nm the pressure required to induce such tension is 5 atm much larger than the actual pressure in the experiment .
thus , the contribution of the normal and the osmotic pressures to the density variation is negligible compared with the surface tension effects due to the peg - lipid interactions that result in densification of the lipids .
this result underscores the point made in sec .
[ sec : init ] : changes in the pressure are much less effective than surface energy variation for the initiation of stalk expansion .
we now estimate the pressure @xmath139 needed to initiate hemifusion , without a lipid density gradient ( that is , with @xmath150 ) . the radial force per unit
length on the boundary at @xmath14 due to the external normal pressure is @xmath151 from eq .
[ eq : fbc ] , the condition for spontaneous fusion is @xmath152 . for the values given above
, we require @xmath153dyne/@xmath154 atm . experimental results in different conditions are within that range .
the pressure needed for the hemifusion of bilayers directly supported on mica ( with no added polymer or other mechanisms that give rise to lipid density gradients ) was found by @xcite to be @xmath155 atm .
@xcite used a surface forces apparatus to apply pressure on dmpc bilayers supported on polymer layers .
the polymer layer allowed the bilayers some lateral conformational freedom , thus permitting more freedom for the adjustment of stalk shape and size @xcite . in that case , where the stalk geometry could easily adjust
, the cost for forming the stalk was reduced and hemifusion was observed at a much lower pressure of @xmath156 atm . in the experiment of @xcite the pressure @xmath157 atm is too low to be the driving force for hemifusion .
pressure in itself is not enough to cause hemifusion , but it is sometimes necessary .
@xcite showed that the amount of pressure needed for hemifusion is directly related to the lipid density near the contact area . in that experiment , two bilayers were brought into contact using a surface forces apparatus .
when ca@xmath158 ions were introduced , there was a phase separation in the bilayers .
the density of lipids in the bilayer regions that were brought into contact was characterized by the hydrophobic adhesion energy .
when thinner regions were brought together ( characterized by adhesion energy of @xmath159 erg/@xmath61 ) they either hemifused spontaneously , or required only a small amount of pressure ( @xmath160 atm ) to induce hemifusion . for denser bilayers ( @xmath161 erg/@xmath61 ) a pressure of @xmath162 atm was required for hemifusion .
@xcite induced negative osmotic pressure on the water layer between the bilayers by lowering the relative humidity of the environment of dphpc . at 80% humidity
the lipids were at the lamellar phase .
as the relative humidity was decreased the water were expelled from between the bilayers by the osmotic pressure and the lamella were connected by stalks , directly observed by x - ray diffraction . in this experiment
the dehydration was due to negative pressure of the water layer induced by the reduced relative humidity , and not by normal pressure , but the physical effect of the two is similar .
in this paper we used a model based on lipid density gradients induced by surface energy variation that occur far from the hemifusion zone , to predict the the conditions for the initiation of hemifusion by stalk expansion and the dynamics of mesoscopic hemifusion .
our theory was motivated by the experiments of @xcite . however , the quantitative scheme presented here can be generalized to any system of two lipid bilayers initially connected by a stalk , where a perturbation in region a , mesoscopically far from the stalk , causes tension in the membrane in that region .
for example one can apply our results to tension induced by the electrostatic interactions caused by calcium ions @xcite , tension induced by laser tweezers @xcite , or the effective tension induced by the attraction of oppositely charged bilayers @xcite .
we have compared the effect of the friction of the two monolayers , the the water viscosity and the intra - monolayer viscosity on the two dimensional lipid motion and showed that the friction dominates .
thus , the lipid dynamics depend on the friction and not on hydrodynamics .
this means that the spacing between the two layers is irrelevant for the lipid dynamics .
experiments similar to those of @xcite can test the predictions of the model for the time scales as functions of the lipid density and friction as well as the value of the driving force due to the tension induced in region a. one could vary each of the parameters @xmath102 ( the relative change in lipid density ) , @xmath77 ( related to the induced tension ) and @xmath50 ( the interlayer friction ) independently , and measure the hemifusion radius @xmath163 , the final radius @xmath13 and the time to complete the process @xmath116 as functions of these parameters .
in particular , the friction @xmath50 can be varied independently of @xmath77 by changing the composition of the distal bilayers while maintaining the same composition of the proximal bilayers .
the friction can be varied by changing the interactions between the chains that is responsible for most of the friction , via chain length changes or temperature changes @xcite .
once an empirical , temporal profile for the hemifusion expansion , @xmath163 , is measured for systems with known parameters , one can use the same experiment to estimate the effective diffusion constant for the lipid flow , @xmath164 , for _ different _ lipid bilayers .
one can easily vary the lipid density at the boundary , @xmath27 by changing the polymer ( or calcium ions ) concentration since the density @xmath27 is determined by the equality of the chemical potentials of the lipids exposed to the polymer and those exposed only to the water .
the static part of our theory deals with the initial conditions required for stalk expansion .
we have evaluated the necessary density variation @xmath165 and demonstrated that the related surface energy @xmath166 is much smaller then the surface tension @xmath167 .
this result is not surprising , since it is a general result of a first order expansion around an energetic minimum .
still , it does give a new insight regarding biological fusion mechanisms .
it suggest mechanisms working through the change of the surface energy @xmath127 are much more effective than mechanisms that exert force or normal pressure on the stalk .
the predicted dependence of stalk expansion on the lipid density can be tested by measuring the critical density @xmath102 at which stalk expansion occurs .
the results may serve to learn more about the stalk structure and energetics .
we expect that near the end of the process of hemifusion expansion , when @xmath168 experimental results may differ from our predictions , since the density profile of the polymer ( or calcium ions in the case of @xcite ) may vary in a gradual manner around @xmath13 ; in our theory we assumed a sharp ( step function ) decrease of the polymer density at @xmath13 .
we also expect a deviation from our theory when the radius @xmath163 of the hemifusion region is close to its initial , molecular stalk radius @xmath99 , due to microscopic details of the lipid structure in the stalk .
we distinguish between hemifusion induced by surface tension gradients , which we consider in our model , and hemifusion induced by pressure .
hemifusion may be induced by normal pressure on the bilayers @xcite or by dehydration which induces negative pressure in the water layer between them @xcite .
we showed that this pathway to hemifusion requires much more energy ( per unit area ) than fusion that is induced by surface tension gradients .
we have shown that the induced pressure @xmath139 in the experiment of @xcite can not be the primary direct cause of hemifusion .
still , pressure does play an important role in stalk formation .
it may also effect stalk expansion through its effect on the lipid tilt energy @xmath34 and on the initial stalk radius @xmath99 .
we bring here the full calculation of the local lipid dynamics . note
that though in our final result we leave only the terms linear in @xmath69 , one may also calculate in the same framework the non linear terms in the case @xmath69 is not small .
the force balance equation is @xmath169 and the continuity equation is @xmath170 writing the energy per lipid as @xmath10 the surface tension is @xmath171 where @xmath172 is the a macroscopic area and @xmath173 is the number of lipids in this area . from eqs .
[ eq : a_fb ] , [ eq : a_cont ] and [ eq : a_pl ] we have @xmath174 to first order in the density variation @xmath69 , eq .
[ eq : a_lpdyn ] has the form @xmath175 where @xmath71 .
in sec . [ sec : boundcond ] we consider the boundary conditions for the lipid density . in order to fully predict the dynamics of hemifusion expansion , we also need to determine the flow at the boundaries . for this
we use the integral form of the continuity equation : @xmath176 the left hand side of eq .
[ eq : a_bc2 ] describes the rate of change of the lipid number in region b while the right hand side gives the flow of lipids through the boundary @xmath13 .
we assume cylindrical symmetry , so @xmath177 . from eqs .
[ eq : a_fb ] and [ eq : a_pl ] we obtain @xmath178 we now use eq .
[ eq : a_eqmot ] to calculate the left hand side of eq .
[ eq : a_bc2 ] : @xmath179 if we take only terms linear in @xmath69 , eq . [ eq : a_bc2 ] gives : @xmath180
equations [ eq : a_bc3 ] and [ eq : a_eqmot ] along with the boundary conditions completely determine the time evolution of the monolayers to first order in @xmath69 . from these equations
we can calculate @xmath163 , and predict the temporal profile of hemifusion expansion .
we write these two equations using dimensionless variables and scale the spatial variables so that they are of order of unity , in order to get an estimate of the time scales .
the natural spatial scale is the final size of the hemifusion region , @xmath13 . we thus define : @xmath181 , @xmath182 , @xmath183 as well as two time variables : a `` fast '' time @xmath184 at which the local lipid flow occurs , and a `` slow '' ( since @xmath102 is small ) time @xmath185 which is the scale over which the hemifusion region expands .
[ eq : a_bc3 ] and [ eq : a_eqmot ] become @xmath186 @xmath187 since all the variables that appear on the right hand side of eqs .
[ eq : a_nsc1 ] and [ eq : a_nsc2 ] are of order unity , the units of @xmath188 and @xmath189 suggest the time scales of the processes described by the equations .
for @xmath190 we have @xmath191 , which implies that we can use an adiabatic approximation : the local lipid flow occurs quickly so that the lipid density is instantaneously given by the asymptotic equilibrium solution of eq .
[ eq : a_nsc1 ] for @xmath192 .
we then use this solution to determine the slower time evolution of the hemifusion radius @xmath14 from eq .
[ eq : a_nsc2 ] . at asymptotically long times , both sides of eq .
[ eq : a_nsc1 ] vanish .
the adiabatic density profile reached is @xmath193 plugging this solution into eq .
[ eq : a_nsc2 ] we obtain @xmath194 the solution of this equation is implicitly given by @xmath195 ben - shaul , a. 1995 . molecular theory of chain packing , elasticity and lipid - protein interaction in lipid bilayers .
handbook of biological physics , vol .
r. lipowsky , and e. sackman , editors .
elsevier , amsterdam .
chernomordik , l. v. , v. a. frolov , e. leikina , p. bronk , and j. zimmerberg .
the pathway of membrane fusion catalyzed by influenza hemagglutinin : restriction of lipids , hemifusion , and lipidic fusion pore formation . 140:13691382 .
kuhl , t. , y. guo , j. l. alderfer , a. d. berman , d. leckband , j. israelachvili , and s. w. hui .
1996 . direct measurement of polyethilene glycol induced depletion attraction between lipid membranes . . | one approach to the understanding of fusion in cells and model membranes involves stalk formation and expansion of the hemifusion diaphragm .
we predict theoretically the initiation of hemifusion by stalk expansion and the dynamics of mesoscopic hemifusion diaphragm expansion in the light of recent experiments and theory that suggested that hemifusion is driven by intra - membrane tension far from the fusion zone .
our predictions include a square root scaling of the hemifusion zone size on time as well as an estimate of the minimal tension for initiation of hemifusion .
while a minimal amount of pressure is evidently needed for stalk formation , it is not necessarily required for stalk expansion .
the energy required for tension induced fusion is much smaller than that required for pressure driven fusion . |
wfpc2 pure parallel images from the hst medium deep survey key project ( @xcite hereafter mds ) cover a very wide range of signal - to - noise . for the few brightest galaxies observed , detailed structures such as spiral arms and bright regions of star - formation are well exposed and the morphology can be easily classified by eye and measured by traditional interactive one - dimensional profile fitting procedures . at these brighter magnitudes the two - dimensional light distributions of galaxies are not well fitted by simple parameterized models which are necessarily crude fits to the broad continuum using smooth image profiles . however , as the images get fainter and smaller ( undersampled ) , the morphology is less apparent and requires a model - based two - dimensional image analysis to derive quantitative estimates . for the extreme faint and small objects there is very little morphological information in the observations .
the mds procedure described in this paper has been optimized for the intermediate ( medium deep ) galaxies , in the rough magnitude range between v @xmath4 to 24 mag .
, as imaged in exposures of about one hour .
this has yielded a significantly large catalog of quantitative morphological and structural parameter estimates .
this magnitude range is now accessible for spectroscopic determination of redshifts via the new generation of 8 - 10 meter class ground based telescopes .
decomposition of the images into disk and bulge has been a difficult task even at bright magnitudes with well sampled images ( @xcite ) .
interactive procedures ( @xcite ) are also impractical for a large survey and in any case they do not generate an uniform catalog suitable for statistical analysis .
the image analysis adopted is similar to that in stellar photometry programs like daophot ( @xcite ) .
but unlike stellar photometry where the image can be characterized by the centroid , magnitude and the point spread function ( psf ) , there is no simple model which will intrinsically fit all of the galaxy images .
we adopt axisymmetric scale - free models which have been shown to fit the image continuum of normal galaxies ( @xcite ) .
the procedure will average over any bright regions , as typically occurs in the data themselves at fainter magnitudes where the objects are smaller and less resolved .
the residuals to these simple galaxy model fits at brighter magnitudes are the subject of a separate study ( @xcite ) . to limit the complexity of the analysis
, we assume that an image pixel is associated with a single object or background sky as is typical of the mds wfpc2 images .
we do not deal with the problems of crowding or image overlap , which are the major issues in programs for stellar photometry .
the number and choice of parameters fitted to an extended image is clearly important .
fitting too few parameters to a well exposed image could significantly bias the estimates of the parameters fitted , by the implicit choice of the parameters that are not fitted .
however , fitting too many parameters to faint and/or compact unresolved images could cause the fit to converge to a false local minimum of a likelihood function which is very noisy in that multidimensional space . for practical reasons , and to ensure statistical uniformity of the resulting catalog , we require an automated procedure which will select and fit those ( necessary and sufficient ) parameters which are constrained by each particular image . we have developed two - dimensional `` maximum likelihood '' image analysis software that attempts to automatically optimize the model and the number of parameters fitted to each image .
we apply the ockham s razor : _ non sunt multiplicanda entia praeter necessitatem ; i.e. , _ entities are not to be multiplied beyond necessity ( ockham 1285 - 1348 ) .
the model varies from a simultaneous decomposition of disk and bulge components of galaxy images ( hereafter models ) at the bright end to circularly symmetric sources at the faint end .
however , this choice of parameters creates selection effects which depend on the signal - to - noise of the image and needs to be included explicitly in any statistical analysis of the mds database .
the success of the procedure depends on the ability to efficiently generate smooth subpixelated galaxy images which can be convolved with an adopted point spread function ( psf ) , such that precise derivatives can be evaluated with respect to all the parameters which need to be estimated .
we will outline the procedure here but will avoid giving all the details of the numerical algorithm , since they are probably not of interest to the general reader .
the algorithm is documented by comments in the software and the interested reader should contact the first author .
a brief outline of the mds pipeline is given in the appendix .
this paper is also the primary reference to the medium deep survey database which has been made available on the mds website in the hst archive and also mirrored at the canadian astronomy data center ( cadc ) .
we avoid duplicating extensive tables since those can only be a snapshot of the present mds database and we wish to ensure that users will always refer to the latest version which will be maintained on the internet .
the mds website has a cgi - interface written in f77 which allows the database to be searched using coordinates or galaxy parameters , or looked at interactively by clicking on objects on an image - map of each stack .
direct access is also provided to the mds database which is on cdroms in a ` jukebox ' .
the database contains wfpc2 pure parallel observations taken for the medium deep survey ( mds - hst go program ids 5369 , 5370 , 5371 , 5372 , 5971 , 6251 , 6802 , 7203 ) and for the gto observers
( hst program ids 5091 , 5092 , 5201 , 6252 , 6254 , 6609 , 6610 , 7202 ) as well as hst archival observations of randomly selected wfpc2 fields like that of the groth - westphal strip ( hst gto program ids 5090 5109 - hereafter gws ) and the hubble deep field ( hst dd program i d 6337 - hereafter hdf ) , and selected galaxy cluster fields ( hst archival program i d 7536 ) and will continue to be expanded as more fields are processed ( hst archival program i d 8384 ) .
the hst mds and gto pure parallel observations were taken with the wfpc2 after january 1994 , following the sm93 repair mission , and continued for four years until january 1998 . before the sm97 second servicing mission in february 1997
, the instruments used for the associated hst primary observations were the fgs , foc and fos ; after this mission , the primary instruments were fgs , stis and nicmos . we illustrate in figure [ fig1 ] the difference in pointing between the parallel and primary observations for all pure parallel fields in the mds database , using different symbols for each primary instrument . the wfpc2 field is on average 4.5 , 8.2 , 12.1 , 7.1 , and 5.3 arc min away from the foc , fos , fgs , stis , and nicmos primary target respectively .
about 25 hours of pure parallel exposure was obtained each month , giving a steady flow of observations .
the database was supplemented using the archival data from primary observations which satisfied the survey criteria .
the observation history is illustrated in figure [ fig2 ] as an indication of the quantity of hst data that was available for the survey .
there was a significant drop in the number of wfpc2 parallels after sm97 as a result of the dithered observing strategy of nicmos and stis primary observations .
the pure parallel gto data was available to reg as a wfpc2 investigation definition team member and windhorst s blue survey data ( wbs ) was available from the hst archive 3 months after observation .
the hst mds ( @xcite ) , with over 400 random wfpc2 fields distributed over the full sky , the gws ( @xcite ) with 28 contiguous wfpc2 fields and the hubble deep field ( hdf @xcite ) are datasets which give three very complementary samples of field galaxies at faint magnitude .
the hdf gives depth in a single wfpc2 field , the gws gives a larger area uniformly observed , and the mds samples the whole sky as illustrated in figure [ fig3 ] .
all three sets have been analyzed uniformly through the mds pipeline analysis software system .
c l priority & description + + 1 & 3 or more images in each of 2 or more filters + 2 & 2 or more images in each of 2 or more filters + 3 & 3 or more images in 1 filter + 4 & 2 images in one and 1 image in other filter + 5 & 1 image each in 2 filters + 6 & 2 images in 1 filter + 7 & 1 image only + 8 & bad exposure + 9 & failed observation + mds and gto observations were primarily done with the f814w and f606w broadband filters .
when more than 3 exposures could be taken with each of these filters , then f450w observations were taken in addition to those in the first two . in order to achieve a similar signal - to - noise ratio in the images taken in all three filters , the exposure times in f814w and f606w
were requested to be about equal while in f450w the requested exposure was about twice as long .
however , all wfpc2 observations in the mds were taken in `` non - interference '' pure parallel mode ( @xcite ) , with the result that exposure times were of varied duration , with a variable number of exposures in the stack used for cosmic ray removal . each field
was given a priority based on the number of exposures available , as listed in table [ tbl-1 ] .
the total hours of exposure and the number of fields at each priority in each of the 3 selected wfpc2 filters is illustrated in figure [ fig4 ] .
practically all of the higher priority data has been processed through the mds pipeline and made available in the mds website . the single exposure , single filter fields were given lowest priority because of the inability to remove cosmic rays and the lack of any color information .
after october 1995 , the mds used only pure parallel opportunities in which a minimum of two exposures with total exposure time longer than 20 min could be taken in each of two filters , or one exposure with a total exposure time longer than 30 min in each of two filters .
special data processing code was developed to perform cosmic ray rejection using exposures through different filters .
this procedure , although better than attempting to clean cosmic rays from a single exposure , is performed at the cost of losing any objects of extreme color .
the pure parallel observations _ per se _ have therefore been the biggest challenge in the task of building a database using a clean statistical analysis .
we will use the gws for many of the illustrated distributions , in order to avoid complicating the discussion with effects due to changes in data quality .
to characterize the ability of our method to extract quantitative parameter estimates we define an information index based on the signal - to - noise in the image .
since we are dealing with mostly extended images , the definition of the index is different from the signal - to - noise ratio generally used for point sources .
we first define a contour around an object by selecting the subset of contiguous pixels which each contain a signal that is at least @xmath6 above the estimated local sky ( see appendix for details ) .
the signal - to - noise ratio of each of these pixels is computed individually .
we define the signal - to - noise index @xmath5 as the decimal logarithm of the integral sum of these ratios , and we have found this dimensionless quantity to be a good measure of the information content of the image , and we have used it to define thresholds within the image analysis procedure . for any particular field , exposure time and wfpc2 filter ,
@xmath5 is linearly correlated with the magnitude of an extended image .
furthermore , it has the expected slope of 1 magnitude per 0.4dex , as shown in figure [ fig5 ] for gws observations through f606w .
point - like stars follow a different sequence at brighter magnitudes . in most of the discussion on image analysis we will refer to @xmath5 rather than magnitude since it is a measure of image quality which can be used without reference to exposure time , sky background and filter used .
the mds detection limit is at @xmath7 , but the sample does contain some images with a smaller index , _ viz . _ those objects detected in the image of a different filter of the same region of sky .
the completeness limit is at @xmath8 which is a half magnitude brighter than the detection limit .
the morphology ( disk - like or bulge - like ) of galaxies can be determined for @xmath9 and models can be done for @xmath10 , which is 2 magnitudes brighter than the detection limit . to avoid any contamination by image noise
the detection limit is set at a conservative level since that was already much fainter than the image quality needed to estimate morphology . in figure [ fig6 ]
we illustrate the limiting magnitude ( @xmath8 ) as a function of total exposure time for all the mds fields processed from wfpc2 pure parallel observations from hst cycles 4 through 6 , the gws , the hdf , and archival cluster fields .
the gws comprises 27 wfpc2 fields , each observed uniformly with 4 exposures in each of the i ( f814w ) and v ( f606w ) filters , with total integration times of 4400 and 2800 seconds respectively and one deep wfpc2 field with @xmath11 seconds in each filter .
our object catalog for the gws has 12,800 objects in the 27 wfpc2 fields .
the percentage of images with @xmath12 is @xmath13 respectively . in these survey images
, @xmath14 corresponds to i=24.5 mag and to v=25.2 mag . from a catalog of @xmath15 galaxy images with @xmath16 in both f814w and f606w ,
11% of the images are fitted with two - component models , 7% are classified as stars , 61% are classified as either disk - like or bulge - like , 20% are classified as generic galaxies ( of uncertain disk or bulge nature ) and less than 1% remain unclassified . as illustrated in figure [ fig7 ] , we find empirically that on average there are @xmath17 pixels above the @xmath6 contour , and @xmath18 pixels above @xmath19 . when @xmath20 we thus have typically an image with 40 pixels above @xmath6 and 4 pixels above @xmath19 . at the detection limit of our object - finding algorithm ( @xmath21 ) , we have typically an image with 15 pixels above @xmath6 and 1 pixel above @xmath19 .
most images with @xmath22 are of regions corresponding to objects which were detected in another filter and model fits on them are typically very poor . in figure
[ fig8]a we show empirically that the fraction of images for which we can use the likelihood ratio ( see sec 7 ) to determine whether the galaxy is more disk - like or bulge - like follows the relation @xmath23 . of these galaxies ,
the fraction of images for which we can fit a significant two - component model follows the relation @xmath24 .
both these relations were derived by fitting a straight line to the slopes in this figure .
we can classify about 60% of the galaxies with a @xmath25 , and all of them with @xmath26 .
hardly any galaxy with @xmath27 has sufficient signal to fit a two - component model , while 70% of them can be fitted at @xmath28 , of which however there are only very few examples in the mds database . at @xmath29 ,
about 40% of the galaxies are modeled as .
the saturation of the fraction at about 70% is probably the intrinsic percentage of galaxies which have a significant component in both disk and bulge . in figure [ fig8]b
, we show a plot similar to figure [ fig8]a , as a function of the half - light radius in pixels for images with @xmath30 . for over 90% of the images with a half - light radius @xmath31 pixels , the image can be classified statistically using the likelihood ratio ( see sec 7 ) to determine whether the galaxy is more disk - like or bulge - like .
we can fit a significant two - component model to 20% , 25% , and 40% of the galaxy images with @xmath32 2 , 5 and 10 pixels respectively .
none of the galaxies with @xmath33 pixels had sufficient sampling to fit a two - component model fit . the ability and success of fitting models to an observed galaxy depend of course on both the integrated signal - to - noise index @xmath5 , as well as the half - light radius of the galaxy in pixels @xmath34 .
these two quantities are related to each other and to the morphology of the image .
systematic ( or evolutionary ) changes in the mean size and morphology as a function of apparent magnitude could slightly change figure [ fig8 ] if it were to be drawn for wfpc2 fields at significantly different limiting magnitudes .
figure [ fig8 ] is applicable to exposures of about 1-hour in f814w and f606w .
the difference in zero point magnitude for these filters is about the same as the mean color of galaxies , and therefore we can expect similar @xmath5 for the typical galaxy .
we have excluded in this figure the galaxies imaged on the pc camera in order to keep the spatial resolution constant .
each wfc pixel is @xmath35 .
estimates of the centroid , magnitude , size , orientation and axis ratio of the observed galaxy image are initially evaluated using simple moments of the flux above the mean estimated sky , using those pixels within the @xmath6 contour .
we next select an elliptical region around the object , ensuring that there are sufficient pixels to define the mean sky background to @xmath36 0.5% accuracy ( 0.005 mag ) .
any pixels within the elliptical region which are associated with some other object and which are @xmath6 above the mean sky are cut out from the region analyzed , together with any pixels which have been flagged as `` bad '' in the calibration procedure ( @xcite ) . the procedure for the estimation of parameters via `` maximum likelihood '' starts by initial estimates of the model parameters from the observed moments of the image . for a given set of model parameters , the software creates a model image of the object and compares this image with the observations within the selected region ( including the error image ) .
the `` likelihood function '' is defined as the product of the probabilities for each model pixel value with respect to the observed pixel value and its error distribution ; this function is evaluated as the integral sum of the logarithm of these probabilities . the likelihood function
is then maximized by using a modified imsl minimization routine ( see @xcite ) .
the 2d - image analysis used an improved version of the software developed for pre refurbishment wf / pc data ( @xcite ) , the catalog of which was presented in @xcite .
there are many types of empirical models that have been suggested over the years to represent galaxy profiles .
we have decided in particular to use scale - free axisymmetric models with an exponential power - law profile which have been shown to fit the broad continuum of normal galaxies ( @xcite ) .
this choice has many numerical advantages which are desirable in leading towards the development of a practical maximum likelihood fitting algorithm .
elliptical galaxies are assumed to have a @xmath37 ( bulge - like ) profile , and disk galaxies a @xmath38 ( disk - like ) profile .
each profile is characterized by a major axis half - light radius and axis ratio .
some well exposed images need to be modeled as the sum of two elliptical components . for about 4% of the galaxy images with no central concentration ,
the images are better fit by a @xmath39 ( gaussian ) or even @xmath40 profile in which the light distribution is both less centrally peaked and has no extended tail .
the isophotes of some ellipticals may be _ boxy - distorted _ ( ) rather than the elliptical models which have been currently adopted .
we will explore these and alternative models for fitting the continuum of irregular galaxies in a future paper .
for a point - like stellar image ( star or qso ) , we need four parameters : sky background , centroid ( x , y ) , and magnitude . for the extended images of galaxies ,
we need at least one extra parameter which measures the size of the image . taking into account the image jitter ( see discussion above ) and any errors in the psf ,
we have found it useful to adopt a gaussian profile and to estimate a size parameter even for the point - like images , to be used as a star - galaxy separation index .
this procedure also takes the stellar image analysis through the same convolutions as those done for galaxy images , enabling the likelihood functions to be compared , with some caveats .
errors in the adopted psf would appear as an extended residual image following the model fit .
this could make a bright stellar image significantly better fitted with a model image which includes an extended component .
this is a particularly important issue when attempting to detect underlying galaxies in qso images ( see @xcite ) . in figure
[ fig9 ] , we show for the gws dataset a plot of half - light radius in seconds of arc as a function @xmath41 . for most stellar images the estimated @xmath42 or @xmath43 wfpc2 pixel . at brighter magnitudes with @xmath28 we notice some larger objects ( but @xmath44 1 pixel ) which are very well separated from the sizes of galaxies .
the psf approximation adopted in the analysis is insufficient at these bright magnitudes .
they could also be cases of stellar binaries which are just resolved and which at fainter magnitudes could contaminate the sample of objects classified as galaxies .
we describe here the full list of model parameters in the order in which they are introduced as we increase the number fitted to an image .
these are the intrinsic galaxy model parameters which are introduced before any psf convolution or allowance for other instrumental effects such as ( the small amount of ) photon scattering in the ccd before detection .
\(1 ) sky background .
the sky background is a very important part of the model estimates .
a bias in the sky estimate could translate to a bias in the estimated morphology . unlike for example @xcite we have therefore chosen to derive a maximum likelihood estimate for the mean sky background _
simultaneous _ with the other image parameters .
we use sufficient pixels to ensure that the mean background sky is determined to an accuracy of 0.5% .
typical fluctuations of order 1% are seen in a single wfc frame .
some of this variation may be caused by the extragalactic background light ( ebl ) from faint unresolved galaxies .
much larger fluctuations are occasionally caused by the faint halos of nearby images , or by charge transfer problems caused by bright stars .
the estimated sky backgrounds are seen to follow these variations very well .
sky background is assumed to be flat over the small region selected for analysis of each object . in the procedure
we have adopted , disk - like or bulge - like model fits could possibly converge with slightly different sky backgrounds within the measurement errors . by allowing the sky to vary
, we are not imposing some prior choice of sky background .
the error in the sky background is then properly reflected in the error estimates for the galaxy parameters and the likelihood ratio used for morphological classification .
( 2,3 ) centroid the @xmath45 centroid of the model image is in most cases very close to the centroid of the observed image .
the mean errors for @xmath46 2.0 and 1.6 are 0.1 and 0.2 pixels respectively .
the error becomes much larger for images fainter than the detection limit ( i.e. @xmath47 ) .
for the models we assume the same centroid for both components .
the software does allow an independent offset for the center of the bulge from that for the disk ( parameters ( 12,13 ) ) , but this has not yet been fully investigated .
the extra degree of freedom resulted in poor convergence in many more galaxies than in the few which justified it .
\(4 ) total magnitude .
the adopted magnitude is the analytical total magnitude of the galaxy model .
this estimate has the advantage of not needing an aperture correction as is required for a fixed aperture or isophotal magnitude .
however , since the magnitude integration is over a smooth galaxy image , small errors could arise from the fact that the model may not average properly over bright regions of star formation , for example . for models
the magnitude is the total for both components , a quantity better defined than the magnitudes of the individual components .
the magnitudes of the individual disk and bulge components can be derived using the flux ratio ( @xmath48 see below ) .
note that the total magnitude is integrated theoretically out to infinity . for disk galaxies practically all ( 99% ) of the light falls within 4 half - light radii .
however for bulge - like galaxies only 85% of the light is within 4 half - light radii , and the model needs to extend out to 19 half - light radii to contain 99% of it .
the total magnitude for an elliptical could therefore be @xmath49% brighter than when calculated by integration out to a typical isophotal detection radius , and correspondingly for the @xmath48 .
\(5 ) half - light radius .
this is the radius within which half the light of the unconvolved model would be contained if it were radially symmetric ( an axis ratio of unity ) . for axisymmetric galaxies ,
this definition is independent of the observed axis ratio of the galaxy , a parameter which depends on the intrinsic axis ratio and its inclination to the line - of - sight .
for point - like sources we fit a gaussian profile with an exponent of 2.0 , and the half - light radius is then 0.69 times the scale length . for disk - like galaxies with a profile exponent of 1.0 , it is 1.68 times the exponential scale length . for bulge - like galaxies with a profile exponent of 0.25 , it is the effective radius or 7.67 times the scale length . for models
it is by definition still the major axis radius within which half the light of the combined profile is contained . like the total magnitude ,
this is a quantity better defined than the half - light radii of the individual components . as a direct consequence of allowing the sky background to be a free parameter
, we need to impose a maximum half - light radius in order to avoid this parameter from becoming meaninglessly large when a galaxy with no central concentration is fitted with a disk - like or bulge - like model .
this limit has been set conservatively to equal half the maximum radius of the region selected for analysis . for @xmath50% of the galaxy images ,
the half - light radius converges on this limit , and those models need to be rejected and flagged for fitting with a less centrally concentrated model . from numerical considerations we impose a minimum half - light radius of a tenth of a pixel on both the major and minor axes of a galaxy . for models this minimum
is imposed independently for each component .
this assumption does not put any significant constraints on the axis ratio distribution of galaxies with a half - light radius larger than one pixel .
the quantity fitted is the logarithm of the half - light radius in seconds of arc .
the half - light radius of the individual disk and bulge components can be derived using the bulge/(disk+bulge ) flux ratio @xmath48 and bulge / disk half - light radius ratio ( see @xmath51 below ) .
\(6 ) orientation .
the adopted position angle is that of the axis of symmetry of the galaxy model .
measured in radians in the range @xmath52 $ ] , this is set equal to zero when the source is assumed to be azimuthally symmetric with an axis ratio of unity . for pre - refurbishment data with a highly asymmetric psf , the observed orientation of the image could be significantly different from the intrinsic orientation of the fitted model . during the minimization procedure
, the angle is measured clockwise from positive y to positive x of the relevant ccd .
it is then translated into a position angle as measured clockwise from north towards east using 3 of the hst attitude ( pointing ) vectors and the wfpc2 ccd plate - scale distortion map . for models
we generally assume that the orientations of the disk and bulge components are the same .
since the bulge axis ratio is expected to be close to unity , any difference in orientation could be expected to be insignificant except in the brightest galaxy images .
the software does allow for a difference in the orientation of the bulge from that of the disk ( parameter(11 ) ) , but this too has not yet been fully investigated .
\(7 ) axis ratio this is the ratio of the minor axis half - light radius to that of the major axis .
this parameter has no units and is constrained to be smaller than unity to ensure proper definition of the major axis . for models
it is defined independently for each component .
if the axis ratio can not be shown to be significantly different from unity then it is held at unity ; for the one - component case , the position angle can then also be dropped as a free parameter .
the size of individual pixels also imposes limits on the ability to usefully constrain an axis ratio .
note that we adopt a minimum minor axis half - light radius of 0.1 pixel ; i.e. for a galaxy with a half - light radius of 05 this imposes a lower limit on the axis ratio of 0.02 since wfpc2 has a pixel size of 01 . in a few rare cases ,
this limit was useful for the prevention of the minimization procedure from converging on an unrealistically low axis ratio .
this observationally imposed limit could be taken into consideration in an analysis of the axis ratio distribution , but can practically be ignored for galaxies with half - light radii larger than 1 pixel .
\(8 ) bulge/(disk+bulge ) flux ratio this is the fractional flux contribution of the bulge - like component to the ( disk+bulge ) light ( @xmath48 ) in the galaxy image .
it has no units and ranges from zero for pure disk - like galaxies to one for pure bulge - like galaxies .
the ability to estimate this quantity depends on the integrated signal - to - noise index @xmath53 in the image .
a larger @xmath5 is needed to separate out a second component with smaller fractional contribution to the total light ( see figure [ fig17 ] ) . a second component is only fitted when there is a significant improvement to the likelihood ratio to compensate for the increased number of parameters .
the definition has used ( disk+bulge ) rather than total to allow for the possible extension of the model parameter set to a third component such as a central point source ( see @xcite ) .
\(9 ) bulge axis ratio this is the ratio of the half - light radius of the minor axis to that of the major axis of the bulge - like component . in models it is often a poorly defined quantity when the disk component dominates the galaxy image , and the ratio is then adopted to be unity .
we could not determine any meaningful relation between the bulge axis ratio and the disk axis ratio .
such a relation might have been expected if most disks and bulges have a typical axis ratio and were related by the common inclination to the observed line of sight .
the latter does not seem to be the case .
( 10 ) the ratio of the half - light radii ( @xmath51 ) bulge / disk this is the ratio of the half - light radius of the bulge - like component to that of the disk - like component .
we observed that the logarithm of this ratio has a weak correlation with the @xmath48 flux ratio ( see figure [ fig12 ] ) .
this correlation has been reported also by @xcite . for disk - like
galaxies this ratio is about 0.25 and for bulge - like galaxies the ratio is about 1.6 , i.e. on average , disk dominated galaxies have a disk half - light radius which is larger than the bulge half - light radius . such is the case for our own galaxy where this ratio is estimated to be about 0.65 .
however , there is a factor of 2.5 rms ( i.e. one magnitude cosmic scatter ) about the mean relation
. it will be interesting to understand this relation using galaxy structure formation theories like those published by @xcite .
( 11 ) orientation difference of bulge from disk see discussion above on orientation .
( 12,13 ) centroid difference of bulge from disk see discussion above on centroid .
in brief outline the procedure is as follows : the initial guess is typically far removed in parameter space from the final maximum likelihood model fit . at this point
it is not useful to make any judgment about the selection of the model or the parameters to be fitted .
however , testing has shown us that for 70% of a typical catalog with @xmath54 , we are never able to fit a significant model .
these images are analyzed only as stars or pure disks or pure bulge - like galaxies and the better model is selected . in figure [ fig8 ]
we show a histogram of the number of galaxies as a function of @xmath5 . we have highlighted the fraction fitted as and the fraction for which we can classify the object as being significantly disk - like or bulge - like .
we first start with a disk - like model , or if @xmath55 we attempt a 10-parameter model fit .
the first fit is a special quick mode of the minimization routine ( modified imsl 9.2 zxmin subroutine that uses a quasi - newton method ) .
this mode of minimization is fairly fast since it does not attempt to check full convergence .
it reaches a point in the multi - dimensional parameter space which is close enough to the final answer to investigate the likelihood function and make some intelligent decisions .
these investigations are made after each minimization , and depend on the number of parameters that were fitted .
the quick mode does not use a higher resolution center ( see appendix ) .
if a default resolution image had been used for the models , we investigate whether a high - resolution center will change the likelihood function . in over 75% of the tests in a typical catalog reaching down to the detection limit , the absolute change in the likelihood function is less than three , which can be considered as insignificant justification for the introduction of a higher resolution center .
since we are merging parts of two independently convolved images , the high - resolution center option is only used when needed .
if the half - light radius is less than @xmath56 arc seconds , the program branches to test if the object is point - like .
as discussed above , we fit a symmetric 5-parameter gaussian model to allow for image jitter and any errors in the psf . for most images
the cut is at @xmath35 or one wfc pixel with a small increase for the brightest images ( see fig 9 ) .
this test is done for about 30% of the objects in the sample , although only about 8% of the sample are eventually classified as probable point - like stellar sources , either stars or quasars . the star - galaxy classification is based on both the likelihood ratio for the best - fit galaxy model as well as the evaluated half - light radius for the object , which is typically 0.2 pixels ( equal to the resolution used for the sub - pixel definition of the psf ) .
the next check is to see if a two - component model , if being considered , is significantly better than a single - component model with less parameters . in 60% of the cases ( for @xmath41 ) the numerical difference is less than 6 and this is insufficient justification for the fitting of a model .
if the half - light radius is less than two pixels we again select a single - component fit . in figure
[ fig8]b we show the fraction of galaxies as a function of half - light radius for which we can fit models and the fraction for which we can classify the object as being significantly disk - like or bulge - like .
the peak of the distribution for which we can fit models is at about 5 pixels , and for obvious reasons we are not able to do so for galaxies with a half - light radius of less than 2 pixels . even if the minimization gave a significant fit for a few of the latter galaxies , these fits are unlikely to be realistic models of these extremely under - sampled galaxy images . for single component galaxies we next check if the axis ratio is significantly different from unity . if not
, then it is set equal to unity , and a five - parameter symmetric model is fitted to the data . for all galaxies we fit both a pure disk as well as a pure bulge model , selecting the better fit model .
if the absolute value of the likelihood ratio is smaller than four , then the classification as disk or bulge is not significant and these objects are classified as generic `` galaxy '' .
if the object had been classified at a longer wavelength as disk or bulge , then the model output is selected to be that of the nearest wavelength for which the image was definitively classified . otherwise , the model output is based formally on the likelihood ratio , ignoring the significance of it . for images with a sub - pixel half - light radius for which the likelihood ratio does not give a preference between star and galaxy , such objects are classified merely as `` object '' . the star - galaxy separation at sub - pixel half - light radii needs more detailed investigation , particularly for the purpose of attempting to isolate an uncontaminated sample of stars needed for modeling our own milky - way galaxy . the image in each filter is modeled independently since the parameters in each filter need not be the same . in figure [ fig10 ]
we compare the classification of images in gws with @xmath30 in both the filters f606w and f814w .
most of the objects received the same classification in the two filters .
as expected from figure [ fig9 ] there is very little ambiguity in the star - galaxy classification . in figure [ fig11 ]
we compare the parameter estimates for about 150 galaxies in gws for which there is a full 10 parameter fit in both filters and a rms error estimate smaller than 0.5 in @xmath57 .
the orientation ( pa ) is clearly the best defined parameter and this has proven very useful for studies of weak lensing ( @xcite ) .
the deviation for the total magnitude ( mag ) is the color of the galaxy .
the half - light radius ( hlr ) is the equal in the two filters for most galaxies .
the axis ratios [ for the disk components ] ( dar ) and for the bulge components ( bar ) show scatter mostly from measurement error .
the scatter in @xmath48 flux ratio is real , and is caused by the different colors of the bulge and disk components . for galaxies which demonstrably have two components , i.e. disk and bulge ,
the least well defined parameter is @xmath51 the ratio of the half - light radii . after a lot of effort
, we have optimized an automated procedure to identify those cases for which a significant model can be fitted .
we are now able to select and converge ( with over 90% success ) on an unbiased estimate of the ratio of half - light radii for about half of these cases .
the program determines if this quantity is unconstrained , by searching for a change in the likelihood as a function of this parameter .
if the fainter component contributes less than 10% of the light , or if the axis ratio of both components is unity , then we have generally found this parameter to be poorly constrained . in figure [ fig12 ]
we show that the logarithm of this parameter is a linear function of the @xmath48 flux ratio with a correlation coefficient of about 0.5 .
bulge dominated galaxies have a systematically larger bulge / disk half - light radius ratio ( @xmath51 ) than disk dominated galaxies .
however the surface brightness limit for detection of the fainter component ( see fig .
20 ) probably contributes most of the observed correlation .
the scatter of 0.4 dex rms about the adopted mean relation ( solid line ) is equivalent to a cosmic scatter of one magnitude .
if in the preliminary convergence the flux ratio @xmath58 , @xmath59 or if the likelihood function was evaluated at extremes @xmath60 dex showed that the ratio of the half - light radius ratio was not constrained by the data , it is held fixed at the nominal value derived from the empirical relationship @xmath61 such relationships , although needed to facilitate convergence of the model fits at fainter magnitudes , are at best a rough approximation .
however , when a parameter is unconstrained and the errors become comparable to the expected range of parameter space , this assumption does not significantly change the estimates of better defined parameters . the justification for the application of such
a relationship is that it helps the routine to converge on a better defined minimum .
the program may also choose to fix the bulge axis ratio , or less frequently , the disk axis ratio at unity , if either of them is determined to be not different statistically from unity .
the covariance matrix is the inverse of the hessian i.e. the second - order derivatives evaluated at the peak of the likelihood function . when it is normalized to have unit diagonal elements , the cross - terms then give the correlation coefficients between the estimated model parameters .
if the cross - correlation terms are not large , we can expect to derive reliable error estimates for the parameters from the diagonal elements .
the parameters were selected to try to minimize the covariance between the fitted parameters described above . in mle theory , if the image being modeled is the same as the simple model assumed , then the parameter estimates and associated errors will be unbiased
. however , real galaxy images which are well resolved are more complex than the simple axisymmetric image models that are assumed for mle .
the effects of spiral arms and bars on the parameter estimates are complicated and difficult to quantify using simulations . in general
, we can expect that , given a sufficiently large sample , the cosmic dispersion caused by image peculiarities will be averaged out . in figure [ fig13 ]
we illustrate a running mean of rms errors for parameters as a function of @xmath5 . to first order
, the logarithm of the rms error appears to increase linearly with @xmath5 .
the errors for single component and two component fits are illustrated independently : in general , the latter errors are larger .
there are a few points to notice .
firstly the sky error , of order 0.005 magnitude , is practically independent of @xmath5 and is defined by our choice of the number of sky pixels to include in the mle .
the orientation and centroid position , which were held the same for both components , show no significant increase in error than a single component fit at the same @xmath5 .
the errors in the bulge axis ratio are much larger for the two component fits .
since the rms of a random distribution between 0.13 and 1.00 is 0.25 , rms errors larger than @xmath62 convey little useful information about the axis ratio .
this occurs at a @xmath5 of 1.93 and 2.12 for single component disk - like and bulge - like galaxies and @xmath63 and 2.72 for the disk and bulge components in model fits .
the @xmath48 errors do not become larger than 0.1 since a two - component model would not be significant if they did .
the error in half - light radius is given in @xmath64 units .
the error is 0.1 dex or 26% at @xmath5 values of 2.15 and 2.37 for single component and two - component models respectively .
the @xmath51 ratio , given in @xmath64 units , is clearly the worst constrained parameter , requiring @xmath65 for the expected error to be less than 0.1 dex or 26% rms .
the hdf superstack consisted of eleven individual hdf field pointings , and we can therefore use these to test the mle method .
we compare the mle results for the hdf super - stack with the mle results of the independent fits to the images of the same galaxies in each of the 11 sub - stacks .
we limit the comparison to those galaxy images where the output from the sub - stacks resulted in the same morphology classification as that from the super - stack in the same filter . in the fits to all of the sub - stacks
, we used the same object definition mask ( see appendix ) as that derived from object detection in the super - stack , together with the appropriate shifts . in figure [ fig14 ]
we compare the mle parameters derived from the super - stack with the weighted means from the individual sub - stacks .
we notice a small systematic bias : the axis ratios in the super - stack are slightly rounder and the half - light radii slightly larger , with a slightly larger @xmath51 ratio .
our adopted approach to stack after shifting by closest integer number of pixels modifies the appearance of the peaked bulges .
it will be instructive to see if the process of `` drizzling '' ( @xcite ) and stacking with sub - pixel shifts helps to remove this effect completely .
the errors in flux values of pixels in drizzled images are not independent and to use our mle approach , the covariance error matrix for each pixel needs to be included in the evaluation of the likelihood function .
software to do this has yet to be developed . for the brighter galaxy images in the hdf
it is probably better to use a weighted mean estimate of the galaxy parameters from the individual hdf sub - stacks rather than the mle values derived for the super - stack .
although the image bias in our hdf super - stack is disappointing , it does show the power of mle estimates to be sensitive to the true nature of the images analyzed .
of course , all these problems can be avoided by not stacking the images at all and , instead , by summing the likelihood over the individual images ( @xcite ) .
this latter approach , however , is computationally impractical as yet . figure [ fig13 ] allowed us to easily estimate an expected error for a given @xmath5 .
if the error estimate from inverting the hessian is significantly smaller then it is unlikely to be real .
this could happen for many reasons .
there could be a sufficient covariance between parameters to make the diagonal only a small part of the error .
the non - axisymmetric features of the galaxy image could have made a sharper dip in the likelihood function .
the expected error could in fact be built into the evaluation of the hessian at the peak of the likelihood function in order to pass over any sharp dips in the function .
however , these relationships had not been derived at the time of the 1996 - 98 mds pipeline processing .
we find that a reasonable compromise for the current ( october 1998 ) version of the database is to adopt a nominal expected error of half a magnitude brighter object if that is larger than the mle error estimate from the hessian .
we find this is appropriate for all parameters except the orientation parameter , for which the original error estimates appear to be good .
the orientation is not correlated with any of the other image parameters . in figure [ fig15 ]
we show a histogram of the resulting normalized deviations of the parameter estimates evaluated in the individual sub - stacks from the value derived from the super - stack , and we compare the results with the expected standard normal distribution . the small bias caused by stacking the parameter estimates discussed above
is clearly emphasized .
we see a significant tail larger than normal for the @xmath48 flux ratio and for the @xmath51 ratio because of the residual covariance in these parameters .
the overall accuracy of the mle parameter error estimates seems reasonable if we recognize that the simple galaxy model fitted does not include the structural detail seen in the real galaxy images at brighter magnitudes .
since the adopted procedure fits the minimum number of parameters which are required to get a best mle fit which is statistically significant , the parameter estimates reflect that decision . in figure [ fig16 ] we show the distributions of disk and bulge axis ratios as a function of @xmath5 . for illustration , the face - on case ( axis ratio = unity )
has been distributed randomly in the finite range [ 1.00,1.05 ] outside the fitted range [ 0.01,1.00 ] .
the disk axis ratio appears to be randomly distributed within the range [ 0.10,1.00 ] for @xmath5 brighter than @xmath66 .
as images get fainter the axis ratios close to unity are found to be insignificantly different from unity .
for example at @xmath67 , axis ratios in the range [ 0.8,1.0 ] get set equal to unity , thus removing two parameters from the mle fit .
the same increase in errors produces a scattering of the observed axis ratios below 0.10 .
the bulge axis ratios show a similar distribution except that they are expectedly larger than the disk axis ratios .
we also notice a number of small bulge axis ratios which are spurious and caused by barred galaxies which have not been properly included in the current mle models . in figure [ fig17 ] we show the distributions of @xmath48 flux ratio as a function of @xmath5 . for illustration
, single component fits as pure disks @xmath68 and pure bulges @xmath69 have respectively been distributed randomly in the finite ranges [ -0.05,0.00 ] and [ 1.00,1.05 ] outside the fitted range [ 0.00,1.00 ] .
the @xmath48 flux ratio is distributed within the fitted range [ 0.00,1.00 ] for @xmath5 brighter than about 3.0 , with the understood excess of disk like galaxies .
as images get fainter , ratios close to zero and unity are not observed since these galaxies do not show a significant second component . the disk component in ellipticals
is ` lost ' before small bulges are lost in disk - like galaxies .
for example at @xmath70 , the observed @xmath48 flux ratios are in the approximate range [ 0.1,0.6 ] in figure [ fig18 ] we show the distributions of @xmath48 flux ratio as a function of half - light radius .
the distribution for single component fits are as those in figure [ fig17 ] .
as galaxy images get smaller , the @xmath48 flux ratios close to zero and unity are not observed since for these galaxies a significant second component can not be resolved .
not unexpectedly , small bulge components in spirals can be inferred to have been lost from the mle models of galaxies with half - light radii of a few pixels . in figure [ fig19 ]
we show the distributions of the @xmath51 ratios as a function of @xmath5 . for @xmath5 brighter than about 3.0
the ratio is seen to be distributed over a wide range .
as images get fainter than those corresponding to @xmath71 , the mle routine does not estimate ratios larger than unity .
this is because , as seen in figure [ fig17 ] , the mle program does not resolve disk - like components in faint galaxy images dominated by bulges .
we now look at the mean surface brightness within the central half - light radius ellipse .
this has a constant magnitude offset from the central surface brightness of @xmath72 mag for disks and @xmath73 mag for bulges .
the central surface brightness is a commonly quoted quantity , independent of axis ratio and inclination for our simple galaxy models .
the advantage of discussing mean surface brightness here is that we find that the limiting mean surface brightness for morphological classification is a quantity which is about the same for disk - like and bulge - like components of the galaxy . on the left - side of figure [ fig20 ]
we show the mean surface brightness within the half - light radius ellipse as a function of the estimated major - axis half - light radius . in the case of models ,
each of the components are considered separately .
there is clearly a limiting magnitude for morphological classification which appears to be the same in each case , i.e. independent of whether it was a component of a galaxy model , or a single component .
we illustrate this for the gws 4-stack images of 2800 seconds in f606w . a very similar graph is seen for f814w .
there appears to be a slight numerical bias for mle to converge on integer or half - integer half - light radii at the smaller values .
this bias is presumably caused by our attempt to merge in a high - resolution center ( see appendix ) .
on the right - side of figure [ fig20 ] we show the same surface brightness estimates within the half - light radius ellipse as a function of the total magnitude of the galaxy . within the half - light radius ellipse of a galaxy or component ,
morphological classification can be done to a limit in surface brightness which is independent of the total magnitude of the galaxy up to certain magnitude limits .
these two magnitude limits will be very useful as simple selection criteria in future models used to interpret the observed @xmath48 distribution of galaxies and surface brightness dimming for cosmology .
preliminary versions of the mds catalog have been the source of many scientific investigations : see , for example the papers on the size - redshift relation ( @xcite ) ; angular size evolution ( @xcite ) axis ratio distribution ( @xcite ) ; weak gravitational lensing ( @xcite ) ; luminosity functions of elliptical galaxies ( @xcite ) ; morphological classification ( @xcite ) ; galaxy interactions and mergers ( @xcite ) ; compact nuclei ( @xcite ) the hst mds cluster sample ( @xcite ) and a study of high - redshift clusters ( @xcite ) .
the catalog used in these analyses was mostly based on the star , disk or bulge model that best fit each object .
most of the previous analyses can be repeated on the new catalog and refined using the models for the brighter sample .
we do not , however , expect any significant changes to these previously reported results .
it is especially interesting to look at results on the two observables which have not been previously measured for large numbers of galaxies , especially in the magnitude range observed here , viz .
the @xmath48 flux ratio and the bulge / disk half - light radius ratio ( @xmath51 ) .
in fact we need to apply the same procedure to a large sample of bright nearby galaxies like those from the sloan digital sky survey ( @xcite ) in order to establish the behavior of these parameters on galaxies in the local universe .
we have made plots similar to figure [ fig20 ] for much deeper observations such as the hubble deep field ( hdf ) . in figure [ fig21 ]
we show a running mean of surface brightness as a function of total magnitude for the gws galaxies on the left - side and compare it with those estimated for the hdf on the right - side .
this graph illustrates freeman s result for disk galaxies ( @xcite ) ; the mean is the same , indicating that the observed distribution of surface brightness is intrinsic to the galaxies , with a cosmic dispersion of only about 1-magnitude .
the expected trend of surface brightness dimming as the mean redshift increases for galaxies with fainter total magnitude is also seen .
correcting by @xmath74 mag . , we estimate that the mean central surface brightness of disk galaxies is 20.6 , 21.4 mag in f814w , f606w for the gws and 21.0 , 21.8 , 22.4 mag in f814w , f606w , f450w for the hdf .
it is interesting that the mean surface brightness is the same for galaxies fitted as pure disk , as it is for the disk component of galaxies . for bulges the scatter appears to be very much larger and our observations in gws do not reach the limiting mean surface brightness bulges
consequently , the mean for bulges in the hdf is about 2-magnitudes fainter than for bulges in the gws fields .
in figure [ fig22 ] we look at the color of gws galaxies as a function of the f606w apparent magnitude .
we have shown all 6 classifications .
the dotted vertical line is drawn at the observed completeness magnitude ( @xmath14 ) .
most of the objects which were not classified morphologically are fainter than this limit .
furthermore , some of the images fainter than this limit and which have been classified as point - like are probably faint galaxies rather than stars .
we have chosen not to filter the mds catalogs brighter than this limit in order to avoid additional censorship of the sample in statistical analyses .
all parameter estimates for galaxies fainter than this limit ( i.e. magnitudes corresponding to @xmath27 ) can be used for statistical analyses only , i.e. studies should not be focused on individual galaxies , particularly any outliers of such a distribution . in figure [ fig23 ]
we compare the color of the bulge - components of galaxies with the corresponding disk - components for gws galaxies which were fitted with models in both f814w and f606w .
it appears that the colors of disk and bulge components of many galaxies are similar ( the dotted line ) , although bulges are observed to be systematically redder , as expected , except for a few isolated cases . in figure [ fig24 ]
we look at the color of disk and bulge components of galaxies as a function of the @xmath48 flux ratio .
as may be expected , the disk components of galaxies appear to become @xmath75 mag redder as we follow the plot from disk - like to bulge - like galaxies , with a cosmic scatter of 0.45 mag .
the colors of bulges remain practically the same @xmath76 mag . , with a larger cosmic scatter of 0.6 magnitudes . in figure [ fig25 ]
we look at the color of galaxies as a function of the @xmath51 ratio .
it appears that redder galaxies have a smaller ratio .
careful statistical analysis is needed to ensure that this is `` real '' and is not caused by a selection effect in which the gws galaxies were sufficiently bright that models could be fitted to images in both f814w and f606w filters .
an automated maximum likelihood procedure has been developed to calibrate , detect and quantitatively measure objects in the hst wfpc2 fields .
the procedure measures the parameters of faint galaxies , despite the potential difficulties related to the undersampling in wfpc2 .
models are now fitted routinely to the brighter galaxy images as a part of the mds pipeline .
a galaxy model , a pure disk , a pure bulge or a star model is chosen automatically using likelihood ratio tests .
classification is done for images with significant confidence .
most hst mds fields observed in 1994 - 1997 have been processed , resulting in a catalog of over 200,000 objects which have been put on the mds website with a searchable browser interface .
clicking on a stack image will pick out and display the maximum likelihood model fit and the parameters for that object .
the statistical properties of the hst - mds catalog has resulted in many publications and comparisons with models of galaxy evolution will continue .
this paper is based on observations with the nasa / esa _ hubble space telescope _
, obtained at the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc .
, under nasa contract nas5 - 26555 .
the medium deep survey was funded by stsci grant g02684 _ et seqq . _ and by the hst wfpc2 science team under jpl subcontract 960772 , under nasa contract nas7 - 918 .
some of the data was also processed under the stsci archival grants go6951 , go7536 , and go8384 .
we acknowledge the multiple contributions of dr .
stefano casertano , dr .
myungshin i m , mr .
adam knudson and dr .
lyman neuschaefer who were associated with the mds pipeline processing and analysis .
we also thank the rest of the original mds co - i team , including dr .
richard ellis , dr .
gerard gilmore , dr . john huchra , dr .
garth illingworth , dr .
david koo , dr .
antony tyson and dr .
rogier windhorst for their contributions to the program . * appendix - mds pipeline
the mds database was maintained and updated using starview ( @xcite ) .
observations are assigned an alphanumeric 5-character name that is based on galactic coordinates as described below such that fields which are from the same region of the sky are associated by name .
the choise of the individual characters in the name is as follows :
\1 ) the first letter of the name , u , is the hst instrument letter assigned to wfpc2 observations .
it was w for older wf / pc data .
\2 ) galactic latitude from ` a ' in the south to ` z ' in the north in equal steps of sin(latitude ) , using numeric index [ 6 - 9,0 - 5 ] within 161 from the galactic plane .
\3 ) galactic longitude using sequence ` 1 - 5,a - z,6 - 9,0 ' in steps of 100 such that numeric indexed fields are towards the galactic center .
the galactic caps within 39 from pole are assigned `` a- '' and `` z _ '' sgp for ngp respectively .
\4 ) chronological sequence of primary target within the 31 degree@xmath77 cells defined above , based on coordinates .
observations within a 05 radius are assumed to be of the same target .
\5 ) chronological sequence of association around the same primary target set .
these fields may overlap each other .
the program using a list of all pure parallel wfpc2 go and gto observations assigns the names .
we have not included the stsci uv - survey program ( pid=6253 ) or the current archive program ( pid=7909 ) for all parallel wfpc2 data since february 1998 .
every dataset in an associated group is allowed to be a maximum of 80 ( 10% of wfc ccd width ) from any other dataset in the same association .
this range is sufficient to associate all wfpc data taken in parallel with a stis or nicmos observations , which are dithered , say within a 56 square . for most cases the 3 orientation is identical .
if it is not , then we ensure that the difference in rotation is less than 003 .
this ensures a 1 - 1 mapping of the pixels , keeping any effect caused by the small rotation or differential distortion to be under about 0.5 pixels , the maximum error made by adopting integer truncated pixel shifts between images in a stack . around some objects such as the fos calibration star bd+28 - 4211 mds
has many repeat observations as illustrated on figure [ figa1 ] .
briefly , the calibration procedure is as follows .
the wfpc2 images are calibrated using the best available calibration data .
we adopt the stsci static mask , super - bias and super - dark and flat field calibration files created for the hdf .
tables of hot pixels from stsci are used to correct fluxes in fluctuating warm pixels for the period of observation .
correction is made to ensure that the noise from any residual warm current is smaller than the read noise .
hot pixels , which can not be corrected to that accuracy , are rejected .
saturated pixels and pixels with large dark current are flagged as bad and ignored .
no attempt is made to interpolate over them .
the software has been specifically developed to recognize the existence of missing pixel values .
in general we have more than one exposures in the same filter , in the same field , to reject the numerous cosmic rays by stacking exposures with a @xmath78 clip .
we use a corrected version of the iraf / stsdas combine task . see @xcite for a detailed discussion of various aspects of the stacking procedure and the statistical errors which are corrected in the `` combine '' algorithm .
a error image is also generated which computes the rms error from the noise model , taking proper account of pixels rejected by cosmic rays , the dark current , flat - field .
shifts between images were determined by cross - correlation of the images . the coordinates listed in hst wfpc2 image and/or jitter file headers
are often found to be insufficiently precise for the process of image stacking ( @xcite ) .
the shifts are determined to an estimated rms accuracy of 0.1 wfc pixels .
to avoid interpolation ( which spreads the charge from cosmic rays , charge that is otherwise well confined ) , exposures are stacked with shifts corresponding to the nearest integer number of pixels , without any rotation or drizzling .
drizzled images ( @xcite ) are most useful for very deep exposures like the hdf , which do not occur in pure parallel observations .
drizzling causes the errors in adjacent pixels in the image to become correlated and significantly complicates a proper statistical analysis of the image .
a mode offset is employed to allow for changes in the sky background in different exposures due to changes in the fluorescent glow and scattered sun / earth light .
the calibration accuracy is partly limited by the fluorescent glow .
this can contribute as much as 50% of the dark current , and is strongly correlated with the cosmic ray activity during the wfpc2 exposure , which in turn depends on the particular orbit . however , except for very deep stacks like the hdf , the noise created by improper correction of this fluorescent glow results in a term which is small compared to other noise terms .
we next remove any large - scale gradient from the faint outer regions of bright galaxies , for which the nucleus was probably the target of the primary observation .
the four ccd images of the wfpc2 are first oriented and merged along the pyramid edge and a single 2nd order 6-parameter polynomial surface is fitted across all four . this surface
is then subtracted from each of the individual images and this automated procedure is iterated 2 or 3 times until no gradient is visible . only about 4% of the processed mds observations required this gradient removal . after stacking ,
the image is multiplied by a selected factor , which is a power of 2 , followed by an integer truncation and division by the same factor .
this makes the images compressible without any loss of useful information , since the differential values before and after this process are much smaller than either the accuracy of the calibration or the averaged read - noise .
the selected power depends on ncomb , the number of images stacked and we adopt the function @xmath79 , i.e. @xmath80 for a single image and @xmath81 for a deep 6-stack .
the estimated rms error has an expected dynamic range of 0 to 25 adu and the accuracy is unlikely to be better than 0.01 adu .
therefore the rms adu error image is multiplied by 100 and truncated to the nearest integer , in order to generate a short integer image which is half the size when uncompressed than the size of the corresponding image of real numbers .
the mds pipeline was used to process only the typical field in which crowding was not a problem .
we selected sparse fields in which the number of pixels @xmath82 or more above sky is typically under 5% of the total pixels in the field .
we classified as non - survey and excluded from the mds pipeline image analysis all low galactic latitude fields with lots of stars , and those fields close to globular clusters and local group galaxies with , say , more than about 1600 objects detected .
non - survey mds fields were analyzed independently by other members of the team . in figure [ figa2 ]
we illustrate the number of objects detected as a function of the number of pixels above @xmath82 .
the figure shows that most of the fields selected as part of the mds survey have a smaller fraction of pixels over @xmath82 and a smaller number of objects detected than in non - survey fields . in both cases , images with no cosmic - ray split
have been indicated with crosses and show a systematic smaller number of object detections because of the attempted cosmic ray clean out .
objects are located independently on each image using a ` find ' algorithm developed for hst - wfpc data .
this algorithm does not do any pre - convolution of the data , so that it is specifically designed to be insensitive to hot pixels and missing pixel values .
it is based on finding local maxima and mapping nearby pixels to the central object , and then selecting those detections which are significantly above noise .
the detection threshold algorithm originally developed for pre - refurbishment wf / pc data was optimized for wfpc2 .
this resulted in the location of a practically identical list of objects in the overlapping region of three wfpc2 mds parallel fields usa0[1 - 3 ] observed in june 1994 . to ensure that we do not break up bright galaxies into small regions of star formation
, we adopted an object resolution of @xmath83 , and small regions within this radius were allowed to merge with a brighter center .
a larger radius of @xmath84 was used for wf / pc data .
this algorithm has been observed to locate real objects with as much or better efficiency as the focas algorithm ( @xcite ) , which was developed mainly for ground - based data .
the mds ` find ' algorithm generates both a catalog and a ` mask ' image , which associates each pixel with one object .
this is a short integer file since the mds pipeline assumes that there are less than 10k objects in a single wfpc2 field suitable for analysis .
the stacking and initial object location procedure is a fully automated first step of the mds pipeline .
after the initial find , we have the only interactive part of the operation .
we first look at the exposure , and confirm that it satisfies our requirements on inclusion into the mds .
a typical mds survey field is uncrowded , with about 400 - 800 objects detected in the 5 arc - min@xmath77 field .
we also exclude from the mds catalogs those objects with a centroid within 10 pixels ( @xmath84 ) from the pyramid and ccd edge , thus reducing the area surveyed by about 5% from 5.03 arc - min@xmath77 to 4.77 arc - min@xmath77 per wfpc2 field , and causing a @xmath85 wide gap in the shape of a cross in the center of each field .
rapid changes in the image distortion and the psf ( a residual consequence of the original hst spherical aberration ) make the edge a very difficult region for reliable quantitative analysis .
the next operation is to fix up the mask for any bright objects which have been over resolved , or to delete any ghost images or extremities of bright stellar diffraction spikes which have been spuriously detected as objects .
the detection algorithm has been optimized to work best at intermediate to faint magnitudes at the cost of over resolving a few bright objects .
the numbers plotted in figure [ figa2 ] are raw counts before cleanup .
the spurious detections are flagged with an interactive cursor for rejection or merger with the central image .
this interactive operation takes about 30 min per stack and is done with a well defined set of guidelines which were originally developed for wf / pc data and modified appropriately for wfpc2 .
the object detections in the various filters are then matched by software , and a single catalog is created , together with a revised mask for each image , so that corresponding pixels in the different filters are associated with the same object .
looking at a grid of the individual object detections , the final masks are inspected and the procedure is iterated as required to ensure that the object definitions as encoded by the final masks are acceptable .
this is the conclusion of the calibration and object detection phase of the mds pipeline .
the object detection algorithm and search thresholds were kept unchanged over the four years of the mds .
when new calibration data became available we recalibrated the data and created a new stack to obtain a slightly lower noise in the image .
we however do not redetect objects , however .
the masks remain constant , and after the field has been setup in the mds database , model fits to any objects can be reprocessed with practically no human intervention .
when there has been a significant improvement in the calibration or the fitting software , the whole database is reprocessed to obtain an improved version of the catalog , which is uniform over the whole period of observation .
this has , however , become practical only after we obtained a sparc ultra-1 , which on its own can do the reprocessing of the current database of over 400 fields in about two months .
all of the mds fields have been reprocessed with the last ( july 1996 ) version of the mds image analysis software .
the shifted stacks were refitted after they were improved in july 1997 using inter - image shifts derived from cross - correlation analysis .
most galaxies are analyzed by picking out a 64-pixel square region centered on the galaxy .
the very few images ( on average about 3 galaxies per wfpc2 field or 0.67% of the catalog ) which are larger are analyzed as 128-pixel square images and in an extreme case as 256-pixel square region .
the integral power of two in the region size in pixels was chosen for efficient convolution of models by fast fourier transforms ( fft ) .
an initial guess of the local sky background is determined from an algorithm that determines the sky using an adaptation of the iterative , asymmetric clipping procedure as described by @xcite . in the very few cases for which it is detected that the local sky is poorly defined ( large rms and skew in distribution )
then the global sky is adopted as the initial guess .
we next use the mask of detected objects generated by the mds ` find ' program in order to define a @xmath6 contour around the object .
this is done by selecting the subset of pixels which are next to each other and are @xmath6 above the estimated local sky .
despite careful ` dark ' calibration and correction for suspected hot and warm pixels , pixels with fluctuating dark current are seen to leave a few `` hot '' pixels in the image . since they could contribute significant flux compared with the flux of some of the faint images , any isolated pixels in the region outside the @xmath6 contour and over @xmath19 above immediate neighbors were located and were assumed to be hot pixels and rejected .
this algorithm detected hot pixels in only 25% of the images and in these cases found on average only 5-pixels in a 64 pixel square region ( see figure [ fig7 ] ) .
these values are for the gws taken with the wfpc2 before it was cooled down from @xmath86 in april 1994 , and for which warm - pixel corrections are not available .
there are many less hot pixels in the newer data taken at @xmath87 .
the initial guess of the local sky and the choice of pixels within the @xmath6 contour associated with the object are factors which influence only the region picked out for analysis .
the pixels within the @xmath6 contour get no different treatment when the likelihood function is integrated .
the presence of cosmic rays makes the observational error distribution of the raw observation non - gaussian .
we have found that the cosmic ray contamination can be represented by a weibull distribution with index 0.25 . in theory , the likelihood function can be defined by taking the model all the way back through the calibration procedure in order to make the comparison by summing over independent raw observations without any stacking . if this is done , one can take proper account of the effect of telescope `` breathing '' which results in slight changes to the observed psf .
one can also allow for contamination by faint cosmic rays and even any analog to digital conversion errors ( a problem mainly for old wf / pc data ) on the observational error distribution ( @xcite ) .
however , after extensive software development and investigation using simulations , we found that this analysis of raw observations and the use of a complex error distribution gained only about 0.15 magnitudes in quality of morphology classification over the very much simpler analysis of calibrating and stacking the image to remove cosmic rays and the assumption of a gaussian error distribution . with the latter approximation
the log likelihood function is equal to @xmath88 maximizing the likelihood function is then identical to minimization of @xmath89 .
we have currently chosen to use the simpler analysis since the very slight improvement in results does not justify the very large increase in computation .
the creation of the model image is the most technical and computer intensive part of the procedure . on average , of order 700 model images are used by the minimization routine to converge on the best - fit model of a single object . since our minimization routine uses derivatives , an efficient high precision algorithm is required . for under - sampled images like those from wfpc2 ,
sub - pixelation is very important , particularly close to the central peak of the galaxy image .
we have developed a procedure which is automatically optimized by the algorithm by testing the evaluated likelihood function on the image being analyzed .
we find that for many images the central pixels of the model image convolution needs to be done in sub - pixel space , and then block averaged for comparison with observation .
in order to ensure that the evaluated likelihood is a smooth function of all the model parameters , require computation of the model image at much higher resolution than that observed , particularly in under - sampled regions close to the center .
the image models we have adopted are scale free and have an axis of symmetry . in order to minimize computation and make use of this symmetry
, we therefore first evaluate the image by adopting an origin at the middle of central pixel of the array .
the outer regions of the image are evaluated without sub - pixelation .
if the models are scale free , then the outer regions can be multiplied by a constant factor to obtain sub - pixeled values for the inner pixels .
for example , we generate an 81 pixel square image by first computing pixels outside the inner 27 pixel square . using the axis of symmetry , only half these pixels need to be computed .
then each pixel outside the inner 9 pixel square and within the 27 pixel square region is integrated with 3x3 subpixelation by integrating the 9 pixels at 3 times the radius and using a scale factor appropriate for the selected model . following this step
, each pixel outside the inner 3 pixel square and within the 9 pixel square can be integrated with an effective 9x9 subpixelation , and the region outside the central pixel and within the inner 3 pixel square can be integrated with an effective 27x27 subpixelation .
finally the central pixel with an 81x81 subpixelation is integrated from the rest of the whole image and the contribution for the very central subpixel . in this way
the model image that is created has a very high degree of subpixelation for the inner pixels at practically no extra computation . in this example , the central 64-pixel square region used gets computed as a 280 pixel square image with increasing subpixelation towards the center .
the image is effectively computed at 39200 points at the cost of 2917 evaluations , more than an order of magnitude increase in speed .
this approach of sub - pixelation can be used on any scale free model , even if not elliptical .
selection of the point spread function ( psf ) is not easy .
the choice is between , using observed psf s of well - exposed stars , or model psf s from programs such as tinytim ( @xcite ) .
observed stellar psf s are under - sampled , have random observational errors , and are not always available close to the image being analyzed .
a compiled grid of stellar psf s from various observations has systematic errors comparable to the small systematic errors seen in model psf s . tinytim psf images have the added advantage of being able to be generated as a sub - sampled image without observational jitter or the scattering in the wfpc2 ccd photon detection ( see below for details ) .
convolution of the wfpc2 model image is best done in sub - pixel space where it is less under - sampled .
tinytim ( @xcite ) psf s are evaluated with 3 and 5 times sub - sampling for the pc and wfc ccd chips respectively .
the 267 square psf images are stored in the same data file format as the observations in a 3 by 3 psf grid for each chip , and centered on the image at the pixel for which they were evaluated .
a psf grid image data file is made for each filter used in the observations . in the image analysis
we choose from the grid the psf for which the center is nearest to the location of the object .
a 3 by 3 grid is sufficient for the corrected optics of wfpc2 . a 11 by 11 grid with no sub - sampling was used for pre - refurbishment wf / pc data for which under - sampling of the extended psf due to the spherical aberration was relatively less of a problem than the rapidly changing psf as a function of the location on the chip .
we have so far ignored the changes to the psf caused by the gradual shift of the mean focus between resets ( maximum of 6 microns ) and the telescope breathing which has a rms of ( 3 microns ) .
this in itself is a complicated issue when a stacked image is used in the analysis .
the focus of every exposure in the stack can not be assumed to be the same .
simulations have shown that for typical extended images with a half - light radius larger than say 2-pixels , model parameters derived using slight changes to the psf are well within the parameter error estimates . for extended images , deviation of a galaxy from the simple model assumed could give larger errors to the parameter estimates .
convolution is done with imsl 9.2 fft routines . for most images
a 64 pixel square array is used .
we correct for any aliasing by generating a 16 pixel square image with a factor of 4 lower resolution and convolving it at the center of a 32 pixel square image where the region outside the central 16 pixel square is set equal to zero .
the flux which gets convolved out to this border region is a sufficient estimate of the alias , and subtracted appropriately from the convolution of the original 64 pixel square array which is not surrounded by a zero border to prevent aliasing .
this correction procedure takes only 1.25 times longer , rather than the 4 times increase needed to surround the 64 pixel square array with a zero buffer , and doing a 128 pixel square array convolution .
the subpixelation chosen is such that the region of the image selected for analysis will fit within a 64-pixel square array at the subpixel resolution .
however , for wfpc2 images this was found to be insufficient for many highly peaked images that also covered most of the 64-pixel square array without any subpixelation . in these cases ,
we generate a second image for just the central pixels at the sub - pixelation used for psf and then convolve this image as a 32-pixel square array , and correct it for aliasing effects using a similar procedure as for the main image .
the high - resolution image replaces the central 5-pixel square region of the model image .
since the center region after convolution is at 5-pixel subpixelation , the image can be shifted to the required center and block - averaged to the observed pixel scale using a simple algorithm that assumes a uniform flux distribution within each subpixel .
including such a higher - resolution center takes factor of 1.25 longer in cpu time , and used as required based on changes to the likelihood function .
there is a non - negligible probability that a photon will be counted in a pixel adjacent to that in which it should have been detected . for a highly peaked source such as a stellar image , the location of the centroid within a pixel will govern the spill over to the adjacent pixels .
the photon detection scattering of the model image therefore needs to be done at the observed image resolution and can not be incorporated within a sub - sampled psf . after shifting the center and block averaging down to the size of the observed pixels , the image is convolved by a 3-pixel square kernel to allow for the photon detection scattering in wfpc2 data .
the symmetric kernel adopted has [ center , side , corner ] values of [ 0.75,0.05,0.0125 ] and is as recommended in tinytim 4.1 .
we have compared this kernel with an azimuthally averaged kernel like that which was recommended in tinytim 4.0 with elements [ 0.5628,0.0937,0.0156 ] .
we find that the revised , more centrally peaked kernel yields better model fits to a sample of stars .
however , the combination of psf and scattering is still not perfect and leaves residuals of about 5% to 10% which are significant in the brighter images .
since the tinytim psf models are generated without including any contribution from telescope jitter , the intrinsic half - light radius estimated for a point source is non - zero . for a wfpc2 primary pointing in fine lock we expect about 10 mas ( milli - arc - seconds ) of telescope jitter .
however , for parallel wfpc2 observations it could be larger because aberration corrections made for the primary instrument are slightly different from those required for the wfpc2 . since jitter data is still not available for all wfpc2 observations , they have as yet not been incorporated them into the mds pipeline ( see @xcite for details ) .
shifts between images were determined by cross - correlation of the images .
any small sub - integer shifts between the images that are ignored in the stacking procedure would also increase the effective jitter in the stacked image . pointing errors of 10 mas are possible at the times of target reacquisition between consecutive orbits of the hst and 20 mas if the target is reacquired after some other observation .
any systematic radial errors between the actual psf for the observation and the tinytim psf model would also translate to a larger effective half - light radius .
we typically estimate about 20 mas for unsaturated stellar images , growing to as large as 60 mas for the very bright saturated stars . the half - light radius computed by the program is not corrected as yet for jitter this correction which not have any significant effect , except on those images with a half - light radius smaller than a pixel .
the input data for the program are four stsdas / geis images for each filter , the calibrated image , corresponding error image , object definition mask image , the psf grid image , and an ascii data file with keyword information about the pointing and global noise characteristics of each calibrated stack . these files are identified in the header of the catalog that then identifies the object to be analyzed by the group and coordinate of the centroid , together with the mask number . in a special mode , it is possible if necessary to identify a small group of adjacent objects resolved with different mask numbers as a single object in the analysis .
the program fits all available images of the object in the different filters and outputs an ascii data file with the fitted parameters , covariance matrix and other information about the likelihood ratio , and the sequence of intermediate results and tests .
catalogs for all objects in a field or a number of fields can be obtained using a keyword search of these data files .
also created is a fits data image for each object .
this file has the format of a grid with a single row of 7 images for each filter , starting from the longest wavelength at the top and progressively shorter wavelengths below it . to make the fits files short integer and compressible ,
the sky subtracted stack images and the residuals are multiplied by 10 and transformed to short integer .
the error image and mask are in the integer format used for these images ( see sec 15 ) .
we show on figure [ figa3 ] an example of a well exposed galaxy image from the mds database as displayed on the mds website .
note that even the fainter f606w image which has @xmath90 is in the range signal - to - noise index which gives reasonable decomposition .
analysis of an image as a star , disk - like or bulge - like galaxy is fairly straightforward .
the only parameter that may be dropped is the axis ratio and in that case the orientation parameter is also not needed and the number of parameters fitted drops from 7 to 5 .
the software can also use any profile index or even attempt to optimize its value as was done for images in the uppsala galaxy catalog ( @xcite ) .
however numerical simulations have shown that the profile index gives a measure of the @xmath48 flux ratio only if the axis ratio of the two components are very similar .
else , the minimization procedure computes an index which is not within the range of one ( for pure disk - like ) and a quarter for ( pure bulge - like ) .
the value is often larger than two , as seen for the uppsala galaxy catalog in which the index seems to have been constrained to be smaller than three for the same reason .
the analysis is much more complicated .
from the very choice and definition of the fitted parameters , to the automated selection of them to ensure convergence , has been a long investigation based on both fits to real data and to realistic simulations . almost like the minimization process , getting close to the answer was much faster than checking and ensuring that the algorithm was optimum .
getting an algorithm that worked on a majority of the images has been tested and in use for sometime .
the final optimization became practical with the aid of a sparc ultra-1 which is more than an order of magnitude faster than a sparc-2 on which the programs were developed .
automation gives uniformity at the cost of a few complicated cases ( particularly at bright magnitudes ) where a decision made by human eye would probably be different .
the program was improved constantly till about july 1996 to reduce the percentage ( currently about 2% ) of fits which are in error .
all of the mds database has been reprocessed with the improved version of the program logic .
bahcall , j. n. , kirhakos , s. & schneider , d. p. 1995
, , 450 , 486 bender , r. , surma , p. , doebereiner , s. , moellenhoff , c. & madejsky , r. 1989 , , 217 , 35 boroson , t. 1981 , , 46 , 177 byun , y. i. & freeman , k. c. 1995 , , 448 , 563 casertano , s. , ratnatunga , k. u. , griffiths , r. e. , i m , m. , neuschaefer , l. w. , ostrander , e. j. & windhorst , r. a. 1995 , , 453 , 599 vaucouleurs , g. de .
1959 , hdb .
d. phys . , 53 , 275 freeman , k. c. 1970 , , 160 , 811 fruchter , a. hook , r. n. , busko , i. c. & mutchler , m. 1997 in 1997 hst calibration workshop , ed .
s. casertano , r. jedrzejewski .
t , keyes , & m. stevens , p. 518 fruchter , a. 1994 , hst archive manual version 5.0 griffiths , r. e. , et al .
1994 , , 435 , l19 griffiths , r. e. , et al .
1994 , , 437 , 67 griffiths , r. e. , casertano , s. , i m , m. & ratnatunga , k. u. 1996 , , 282 , 1159 groth , e. j. , kristian , j. a. , lynds , r. , oneil , e. j. , jr . , balsano , r. , rhodes , j. & idt , w. 1994 , , 185 , 5309 gunn , j. e. , et al 1998 , , 116 , 3040 i m , m. , ratnatunga , k. u. , griffths , r. e. & casertano , s. 1995 , , 445 , l15 i m , m. , casertano , s. , griffiths , r. e. , ratnatunga , k. u. & tyson , j. a. 1995 , , 441 , 494 i m , m. , griffiths , r. e. , ratnatunga , k. u. & sarajedini , v. l. 1996 , , 461 , l79 i m , m. , griffiths , r. e. , naim , a. , ratnatunga , k. u. roche , n. green , r. f. & sarajedini , v. l. 1999 , , 510 kent , s. m. 1984 , , 56 , 105 kent , s. m. 1985 , , 59 , 115 astro kormendy , j. 1977 , , 217 , 406 krist , j. 1992 , the tinytim user s manual stsci lauberts , a. & valentijn , e. a. 1989 in _ the surface photometry catalogue of the eso - uppsala galaxies _ lubin , l. m. , postman , m. , oke , j. b. , ratnatunga , k. u. , gunn , j. e. , hoessel , j. g. , & schneider , d. p. 1998
, , 116 , 584 mao , s. & mo , h. j. 1998 , _
preprint -ph/9805094 _ mutz , s. b. , et al .
1994 , , 434 , l55 naim , a. , ratnatunga , k. u. & griffiths , r. e. 1997 , , 476 , 510 naim , a. , ratnatunga , k. u. , & griffiths , r. e. 1997 , , 111 , 357 neuschaefer , l. w. , i m , m. , ratnatunga , k. u. , griffiths , r. e. & casertano , s. 1997 , , 480 , 59 ostrander , e. j. , nichol , r. c. , ratnatunga , k. u. & griffiths , r. e. 1998 , , 116 , 2644 owens , e. a. , griffiths , r. e. & ratnatunga , k. u. 1996 , , 281 , 153p ratnatunga , k. u. , griffiths , r. e. & casertano , s. 1994 , in restoration of hst images and spectra ii , edited by r. j. and r. l. white , p. 333
griffiths ratnatunga , k. u. , ostrander , e. j. , & griffiths , r. e. 1997 in 1997 hst calibration workshop , ed .
s. casertano , r. jedrzejewski , t. keyes , & m. stevens , p. 361 ratnatunga , k. u. & casertano , s. 1991 , , 101 , 1075 ratnatunga , k. u. & newell , e. b. 1984 , , 89 , 176 ratnatunga , k. u. , griffiths , r. e. casertano , s. , neuschaefer , l. w. , & wyckoff , e. w. 1993 , in calibrating hubble space telescope , ed . j. c. blades & s. j. osmer , p. 59
ratnatunga , k. u. , griffiths , r. e. , casertano , s. , neuschaefer , l. w. & wyckoff , e. w. 1994 , , 108 , 2362 ratnatunga , k. u. , griffiths , r. e. neuschaefer , l. w. , & ostrander , e. j. 1995 , in hst calibration workshop ii , ed .
a. koratkar , a. & c. leitherer , p. 351
roche , n. , ratnatunga , k. , , r. e. , , m. & neuschaefer , l. 1996 , , 282 , 1247 roche , n. , ratnatunga , k. , griffiths , r. e. & i m , m. 1997 , , 288 , 200 roche , n. , ratnatunga , k. , griffiths , r. e. , i m , m. & naim , a. 1998 , , 293 , 157 sarajedini , v. l. , green , r. f. , griffiths , r. e. & ratnatunga , k. 1996 , , 471 , l15 schade , d. , lilly , s. j. , le fevre , o. hammer , f. , & crampton , d. 1996 464 , 79 stetson , p. b. 1987 , , 99 , 191 tyson , j. a. & jarvis , j. f. 1979 , , 230 , l153 williams , r. e. , et al . 1996 , , 112 , 1335 yee , h. k. c. 1981 , , 103 , 396 | quantitative morphological and structural parameters are estimated for galaxies detected in hst observations of wfpc2 survey fields .
a modeling approach based on maximum likelihood has been developed for two - dimensional decomposition of faint under - sampled galaxy images into components of disk and bulge morphology .
decomposition can be achieved for images down to f814w ( i ) @xmath0 , f606w ( v ) @xmath1 and f450w ( b ) @xmath2 magnitudes in wfpc2 exposures of one hour .
we discuss details of the fitting procedure , and present the observed distributions of magnitude , color , effective half - light radius , disk and bulge axis ratios , bulge/(disk+bulge ) flux ratio , bulge / disk half - light radius ratio and surface brightness .
we also discuss the various selection limits on the measured parameters .
the medium deep survey catalogs and images of random pure parallel fields and other similar archival primary wfpc2 fields have been made available via the internet with a searchable browser interface to the database .
3 @xmath3 |
recently , krauss , nasri and trodden ( @xcite , knt in the following ) proposed an interesting model , where a right - handed neutrino of mass on the order of a few tev plays a crucial role in giving mass to the otherwise massless standard model neutrinos through a high - order loop mechanism .
this is a version of the zee model @xcite , which has been quite successful is reproducing the observed mass and mixing pattern of solar and atmospheric neutrinos ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) .
the particle content of the zee model is given by two higgs doublets @xmath0 and @xmath1 , and a charged field @xmath2 which transforms as a singlet under @xmath3 , with lagrangian @xmath4 knt consider a variant where neutrino masses appear only at the three loop level . to achieve this they supplement the sm fields with two charged singlet scalars @xmath5 and @xmath6 and one right handed neutrino @xmath7 .
lepton number is broken explicitly by including a majorana mass term for the right - handed neutrino , and imposing a discrete @xmath8 symmetry under which the sm fields and @xmath5 are singlets but @xmath6 and @xmath7 transform as @xmath9 forbidding dirac masses for the neutrinos .
this gives the lagrangian @xmath10 in which the potential @xmath11 contains a @xmath12 coupling .
it is assumed a mild hierarchy of masses @xmath13 tev and that the yukawa couplings @xmath14 , @xmath15 are of order unity , making @xmath7 stable in view of the discrete symmetry .
left - handed majorana neutrino masses are induced at three - loop order . for @xmath16 tev ,
knt find an effective dimension - five effective mass scale of @xmath17 gev , giving neutrino masses at the @xmath18 ev scale without involving fundamental mass scales significantly larger than a tev .
the discrete symmetry and the fact that @xmath7 is lighter than the charged scalars means that @xmath7 becomes stable and therefore a natural dark matter candidate . through @xmath6 exchange it coupled to charged leptons in the early universe strongly enough to give the correct relic density , but extremely weakly today .
current direct dark matter detectors employ scattering on nucleons , and will not be sensitive to the available leptonic interactions .
one could imagine techniques based on atom level transitions @xcite , but a simple estimate shows that the rate is typically less than one event per ton per year , thus several tons of active detector material would be needed a very difficult task given that a gaseous phase detector will probably be necessary .
similarly , indirect detection through neutrinos from the earth or the sun will not be possible , since the cross section for capture is negligibly small .
we therefore turn to indirect detection through annihilation in the galactic dark matter halo .
first , it may be useful to review the thermal production mechanism in the early universe .
since the @xmath7 is a majorana particle , its annihilation into a lepton pair shows the usual helicity suppression @xmath19 for the s - wave . repeating the original calculation of goldberg for photinos @xcite
, the cross section can be written @xmath20 , \label{eq : freezeout}\ ] ] where @xmath21 is the charged lepton mass , @xmath22 the @xmath6 mass and @xmath23 the limp ( @xmath7 ) mass .
note that for @xmath24 not too much larger than unity , the factor in square brackets is typically close to @xmath25 .
this means that for @xmath23 in the tev range , the p - wave cross section ( the term proportional to @xmath26 in eq .
( [ eq : freezeout ] ) ) will determine the freeze out temperature @xmath27 and therefore the relic abundance @xcite .
as usual for a wimp , one finds @xmath28 , and so @xmath29 .
the requirement that the limp be the dark matter particle , with relic abundance @xmath30 , as indicated from a joint analysis of cosmic microwave background and large scale structure data ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) , then fixes the cross section at freeze out to be @xcite @xmath31 for a given @xmath7 of mass @xmath23 , this fixes the normalization of the combination @xmath32 which appears in many annihilation formulas .
we can then estimate the total annihilation rate into lepton pairs @xmath33 at rest ( i.e. in s - wave ) putting @xmath34 in eq .
( [ eq : freezeout ] ) .
we find @xmath35 in the remainder of this paper we will assume flavor universality , namely @xmath36 . for a tev limp , this looks like a phenomenally small annihilation rate for the @xmath37 and @xmath38 channels . even for @xmath39 ,
the helicity suppression is of the order of @xmath40 ( at that level , the p - wave term in the galactic halo starts to contribute since typical galactic velocities correspond to @xmath41 ) .
one would therefore be tempted to conclude that the limp , despite being a good dark matter candidate , has little chance to be detected in any direct or indirect detection experiment .
we note that in order that the couplings @xmath42 not be much larger than unity , for nearly degenerate @xmath7 and @xmath6 , @xmath23 can not be too much heavier than 1 tev , but could be significantly lighter .
the small annihilation rate , unlike the small scattering rate ( which is caused by the leptonic nature of the candidate ) , is due to the majorana nature of @xmath7 which implies the absence of large s - wave two - body annihilation at tree level @xcite .
any higher order process which does not have this helicity suppression will have a chance to dominate the annihilation rate completely .
this is precisely the kind of interesting situation investigated many years ago for the case of a pure photino coupling through light selectrons to electrons , positrons and photons @xcite .
( that particular candidate is now less plausible in view of results from the lep accelerator . ) in particular , we can immediately take over the results of @xcite to write the differential cross section for the radiative , non - helicity suppressed process @xmath43 as ( here the annihilation rate @xmath44 ) @xmath45 where we have neglected the lepton masses ( a good approximation also for the @xmath46 for tev limps ) , and where @xmath47 note that the total rate for gamma rays of this process is fixed by the cross section giving the relic density - it is independent of the values of the individual @xmath42 in this massless limit . the strength of this process is seen to be of the order of @xmath48 times the annihilation rate at freeze - out , which is orders of magnitude larger than the helicity - suppressed two - body s - wave annihilation rate .
this will mean , as we shall see , that there is a hope of detecting the limp in gamma - rays , and perhaps also in an anomalous positron component of the cosmic rays .
on the other hand , since all three charged sm leptons are too light to decay into baryons , indirect detection through antiprotons ( or antideuterons ) is not expected for the limp .
a nice feature of the result ( eq . [ eq : result ] ) is its model independence . for any dark matter candidate of this type ( a majorana particle coupling mainly to leptons through charged scalar exchange )
we expect this strength of the radiative annihilation signal .
this is to be contrasted with the situation in the mssm , where the predicted gamma - ray signal for a susy wimp of any given mass depends strongly on a large number of additional supersymmetric parameters .
however , there are astrophysical uncertainties which make the expected absolute fluxes difficult to estimate despite this robustness of the particle physics properties . by integrating eq .
[ eq : result ] over @xmath49 ( with lower and upper integration limits @xmath50 and @xmath23 , respectively ) we get the differential photon spectrum .
similarly , by integrating over @xmath51 between @xmath52 and @xmath23 the differential lepton spectrum ( and the identical anti - lepton spectrum ) is obtained .
apart from the overall normalization , which is fixed by the relic density and contains a factor @xmath53 strongly favoring a scenario with at most a mild hierarchy of these masses , the shapes of these distributions depend only on the scaled energies @xmath54 and the ratio @xmath55 .
since all leptons can be treated as massless , the distributions are identical for @xmath56 , @xmath57 and @xmath58 , so from the point of view of this gamma - ray signature , it is of no importance whether the @xmath7 couples universally to leptons or not .
there are in principle a significant number of hard photons in the tau decay chain from pion decays , but we have checked that the direct photons from @xmath59 strongly dominate in all cases we illustrate . for , e.g. , the positron signal there may be differences , since muons and taus give positrons with softer spectra in their decays , as discussed in the next section . in fig . [ fig : fig1 ] ( a ) and ( b ) we show examples of these distributions for @xmath60 and @xmath61 , plotted on logarithmic and linear scales , respectively . as can be seen ,
both the gamma and the lepton spectra are exceptionally hard , peaking near the maximum energy ( which in both cases is equal to @xmath23 ) .
this is optimal from the point of view of detection , as most conceivable sources of background tend to give soft spectra , rapidly falling with energy .
the obvious place to search for the gamma - ray signal is in the direction of the galactic center , where the dark matter distribution is expected to be strongly enhanced .
n - body simulations indicate that cold dark matter , of which the limp is an example , is even likely to form a density cusp @xmath62 near the center ( the so - called navarro - frenk - white or nfw profile @xcite ) .
the observational situation concerning rotation curves and the distribution of dark matter in spiral galaxies , including our own , is however far from clear at the moment , and the same is true for the n - body calculations where different groups still seem get different results @xcite .
even more unclear is the interesting possibility of the massive black hole transforming the cusp into a very sharp spike with dramatically enhanced density @xcite .
the best we can do at the moment is to assume an nfw profile , keeping in mind that the predicted rates can be either much lower ( in the case of the absence of both a cusp and a spike ) or much higher ( in the case of a steeper cusp , as some n - body simulations indicate , or a spike , or a clumpy halo @xcite as also indicated by simulations @xcite ) .
here we note the importance of the clumpiness of the halo : since the annihilation rate is proportional to the square of the density @xmath63 , it is enhanced over the prediction for a smooth halo by a clumpiness parameter @xmath64 .
the rate of gamma - rays from a given halo profile has been elaborated in @xcite .
combining the results of that work with those given here , we predict a gamma - ray flux from the galactic center ( treated as a point source , so the units are in @xmath65 ) @xmath66 where the line - of - sight integral @xmath67 is defined in @xcite , and @xmath68 is the average of this line - of - sight integral over the acceptance @xmath69 of a gamma - ray telescope ; for a nfw profile , the maximal value of the product @xmath70 for @xmath71 @xcite ( similar , or larger , values would be obtained for the moore profile @xcite @xmath72 ) .
the background is difficult to estimate ( in fact , much of the presently perceived diffuse `` background '' may turn out to be part of the kind of signal discussed here ) . for the sake of the argument
, we will take the simple estimate given in @xcite , extrapolated from the flux measured by egret towards the galactic center : @xmath73 an inevitable consequence of the limp coupling to a charged scalar is that the loop - induced process @xmath74 should also occur @xcite , with cross section @xmath75 note that since all leptons contribute coherently to the loop amplitude , the rate is more favorable for a universal lepton coupling . in the case
@xmath36 , the value for @xmath76 becomes @xmath77 which is quite sizable .
note that this result is independent of the @xmath7 and @xmath6 masses @xcite .
( one may also note that since @xmath6 is an su(2 ) singlet , there is no corresponding @xmath78 final state . ) the line flux then becomes @xmath79 this would appear as a sharp spike ( with relative width of the order of the doppler broadening due to limp motion , i.e. of the order of @xmath80 ) , in an instrument with perfect energy resolution .
however , acts have an energy resolution of the order of @xmath81% at best .
if we assume 5% , the gamma spike for a tev limp spreads out over 50 gev , a differential rate near a tev similar to the radiative processes discussed above . for smaller limp masses of the order of 100 gev
, one gets into the mass range where the glast gamma - ray telescope @xcite will be operative ( it will detect gamma - rays up to 300 gev ) .
the energy resolution for glast will depend on the angle of incidence and may reach a few percent , making it possible for the line to stand out against background .
the detection of such a line would eliminate all possible confusion with plausible astrophysical backgrounds . in fig .
[ fig : fig2 ] ( a ) we show the flux predicted from eq .
( [ eq : contgammas ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : linegammas ] ) together with the background estimate eq .
( [ eq : bkggammas ] ) for a 100 gev limp , and 110 gev @xmath6 , nfw profile and @xmath82 .
for this energy range , we have used an energy resolution of 3% .
it may be difficult to push the @xmath7 mass much below 100 gev without fine tuning the parameters of the knt model ( and the @xmath6 mass is also bounded by lep results to be larger than around 100 gev ) .
we note that with the @xmath6 ( and thus @xmath5 ) only 10% higher in mass than the @xmath7 , a careful analysis should really take coannihilations with @xmath6 into account when estimating the relic density , and thereby fixing the interaction strength . in analogy to susy models where r - parity stabilizes the lightest superpartner , in this model the @xmath8 symmetry stabilizes the lightest odd state ; a complete calculation would include all odd states , in this case @xmath7 and @xmath6 .
however , coannihilations are unlikely to change the relic density by more than a factor of a few , a small correction compared with the very large astrophysical uncertainties related to the radial distribution of dark matter near the galactic center . the natural mass range for the limp is around 1 tev , where glast runs out of sensitivity but where ground - based arrays of air erenkov telescopes with large collecting area can detect a signal . indeed , there are already such arrays of telescopes planned or in operation such as cangaroo @xcite , hess @xcite , veritas @xcite and magic @xcite .
in particular , cangaroo and hess are well located to observe the galactic center for a sizable fraction of their observing time .
as can be seen from the figure , the signal with these assumptions would stand out from the gamma - ray background .
( we do not enter here into the more technical issue of rejecting other types of background , such as from hadrons and electrons , where there is a steady improvement in the techniques employed . ) in fig .
[ fig : fig2 ] ( b ) and ( c ) , the curves are shown for a limp of mass @xmath83 tev , @xmath84 tev , and @xmath85 tev , @xmath86 tev , respectively .
these should be clearly observable with a very conspicuous `` bump '' in the spectrum , for the halo parameters chosen .
we note with interest that preliminary results from the cangaroo collaboration indeed show an excess flux of tev gamma - rays from the galactic center @xcite .
the absolute flux level for this possible signal seems higher than that predicted in eq .
( [ eq : contgammas ] ) , so an enhancement beyond that provided by the nfw profile would then be indicated .
an interesting question is what would happen to the leptons . to be specific ,
assume that there is lepton universality in the @xmath7 couplings .
then there will be equal amounts ( apart from very small lepton mass corrections ) of @xmath46 , @xmath87 and @xmath88 leptons .
the produced @xmath46 and @xmath87 will decay into lower - energy electrons and positrons ( see next section ) , and the primary high - energy electrons and positrons will quickly radiate due to synchrotron and inverse compton processes .
in fact , an analysis by bertone , sigl and silk @xcite points to the existence of a radio signal that may be caused by just the kind of tev - scale dark matter particles discussed here , if the magnetic field near the galactic center is strong enough . in any case , this would be a signal to search for , were a tev gamma - ray excess to be confirmed .
in the previous section the annihilation process @xmath89 was discussed with the idea of detecting the high energy photons produced .
we can also make a prediction for the cosmic ray positron flux from this process . as shown below
, the positron flux is quite low , and not likely to be detectable unless the clumpiness factor of the galactic halo is quite large .
positrons might come from any of the three leptonic channels . in the direct process
@xmath90 the positrons are quite energetic .
the energy is downgraded somewhat in the muon channel , since some of the energy goes to neutrinos : @xmath91 .
the spectrum is softest for the tau channel @xmath92 , since there are many hadronic modes with longer decay chains yielding positrons ( and electrons ) in the end .
we also include the simpler processes @xmath93 . for electrons this is negligible
unless @xmath94 is very small and @xmath95 is much larger .
however , for muons and especially taus , the simple process can be important as the helicity suppression is less severe .
all of this can be accounted for with standard tools ; in particular we have used results from the pythia event generator @xcite as tabulated in darksusy @xcite for the positron spectra from the muon and tau decay chains .
folding in the annihilation cross section , we can then compute the volume production rate of positrons in the galactic halo ( @xmath96 ) in units of @xmath97 s@xmath98 gev@xmath98 .
the propagation of positrons in the galactic environment is complex .
the gyroradii of charged particles in the tangled magnetic fields are quite small , and the motions can be modeled as a diffusion process .
furthermore , positrons lose energy rapidly to both synchrotron radiation , and in addition to inverse compton scattering with the cosmic microwave background and with diffuse starlight .
we use the propagation model in ref .
@xcite to calculate the observed flux at the earth .
the model includes diffusion in an infinite slab , a reasonable approximation given the fact that detectable positrons are produced within a few kpc , thus an outer radial boundary is unimportant .
the energy losses to synchrotron and inverse compton processes are included .
this model is in rough agreement with earlier work @xcite , though the inclusion of inverse compton scattering from starlight doubles the energy loss rate .
more sophisticated models give similar results @xcite .
we note here that the question of the halo profile is much less important in calculating the positron flux , as their effective range is only a few kpc .
thus , it is the less uncertain local dark matter density that is important for the positron flux .
the heat collaboration has in fact reported an excess of positrons above about 10 gev in the cosmic ray positron fraction @xmath99 @xcite , later confirmed in a different instrument by heat - pbar @xcite .
we now discuss the possibility that this excess might be due to annihilating limps .
the fluxes of positrons are typically too small by a factor of @xmath100 if a smooth halo is assumed .
this might seem hopeless , but the clumpiness parameter could be this large , boosting the signal accordingly . in order to produce an excess at 10 gev
, lighter limps are preferred .
assuming that the limp must be heavier than 100 gev to escape discovery ( actually , it is the heavier charged scalars @xmath5 and @xmath6 which would be seen at e.g. lep ) , we illustrate some limp models that give an acceptable positron flux to explain the heat results in fig .
[ fig : fig3 ] ( albeit with the very large clumpiness parameter ) . other explanations for this excess
have been put forward elsewhere @xcite . in the second panel of fig .
[ fig : fig3 ] we show some limp models with larger masses that do not do well in explaining the current excess
. however , future experiments such as ams @xcite and pamela @xcite may be able to probe such models with higher accuracy , and we estimate that boost factors a factor of five or ten smaller ( of order @xmath101 ) would still produce an interesting signal for such experiments .
we have discussed the possibility of astrophysically detecting a right handed neutrino cold dark matter candidate arising in a recently proposed modified zee model . as the interactions are only leptonic , current elastic scattering experiments are not sensitive to this particle .
annihilations in the galactic halo , with both two and three body final states , may provide detectable numbers of high energy photons or positrons , though these predictions rely heavily on the structure of the galactic halo , both in core profile and in spectrum of substructure .
we would like to thank l. krauss and j. edsj for interesting conversations .
we thank the organizers of cmb02 at the kavli institute for theoretical physics , where this research was done .
this research was supported in part by the nsf under grant phy99 - 07949 at kitp .
the work of lb was also supported by the swedish research council ( vr ) .
99 l. m. krauss , s. nasri and m. trodden , hep - ph/0210389 .
a. zee , phys .
b * 93 * , 389 ( 1980 ) [ erratum - ibid .
b * 95 * , 461 ( 1980 ) ] . c. jarlskog , m. matsuda , s. skadhauge and m. tanimoto , phys .
b * 449 * , 240 ( 1999 ) g. d. starkman and d. n. spergel , phys .
lett . * 74 * 2623 ( 1995 ) .
h. goldberg , phys .
lett . *
50 * , 1419 ( 1983 ) .
j. l. sievers _ et al .
_ , g. jungman , m. kamionkowski and k. griest , phys
. rept .
* 267 * , 195 ( 1996 ) l. bergstrm , rept .
phys . *
63 * , 793 ( 2000 ) l. bergstrm , phys .
b * 225 * , 372 ( 1989 ) .
j. f. navarro , c. s. frenk and s. d. white , astrophys .
j. * 462 * , 563 ( 1996 ) .
b. moore , astro - ph/0103100 .
j. r. primack , astro - ph/0205391 .
p. gondolo and j. silk , phys
. rev .
lett . * 83 * , 1719 ( 1999 ) .
p. ullio , h. zhao and m. kamionkowski , phys .
d * 64 * , 043504 ( 2001 ) .
d. merritt , m. milosavljevic , l. verde and r. jimenez , phys .
lett . * 88 * , 191301 ( 2002 ) .
l. bergstrm , j. edsj , p. gondolo and p. ullio , phys .
d * 59 * , 043506 ( 1999 ) . | weakly interacting massive particles ( wimps ) are among the favored candidates for cold dark matter in the universe .
the phenomenology of supersymmetric wimps has been quite developed during recent years . however , there are other possibilities which have not been discussed as much .
one example is a right - handed massive neutrino , which has recently been proposed in the context of a version of the zee model for massive neutrinos .
this tev - scale , leptonic wimp ( or limp , for short ) may at first sight appear to be essentially undetectable .
however , we point out that the radiatively induced annihilation rate into leptons and photons is bound to be substantial , and provides a conspicuous gamma - ray signature for annihilations in the galactic halo .
this gives a window of opportunity for air erenkov telescopes with ability to observe the galactic center , such as the hess and cangaroo arrays , and also for the glast space telescope .
in addition , the contribution to the positron cosmic ray flux is in principle detectable , but this would require very strong local density enhancements in the dark matter halo distribution .
nsf - itp-02 - 165 + hep - ph/0211325 |
rare meson decays are expected to serve as harbinger for new physics ( np ) in experiments at the intensity frontier @xcite .
better measurements or upper limits on a plethora of rare ( semi)leptonic and radiative @xmath6 and @xmath7 meson decays in forthcoming experiments , compared to precise standard model ( sm ) predictions , eventually will provide indirect indications of heavier particles with new interactions . particularly sensitive for np searches are those decays dominated by short - distance ( sd ) dynamics where the hadronic uncertainties are well under control .
conversely , precise measurements of these rare decays , combined with non - observation of np effects , will furnish a better determination of flavor mixing parameters .
very recently , the lhcb collaboration has reported a deficit in the ratio of muon to electron pairs produced in @xmath8 decays , in the @xmath9 gev@xmath5 region for the squared invariant - mass of the lepton pair @xcite .
this energy region is cleverly chosen as it excludes long - distance ( ld ) contributions associated to charmonium and light vector resonance production in @xmath10 decays followed by their conversion to lepton pairs ( for definiteness , hereafter we will focus on decays of negatively charged @xmath7 mesons , unless otherwise indicated ) .
the measured ratio @xmath11 @xcite , if confirmed in more refined measurements , would call for lepton universality violating interactions since in the sm @xmath12 @xcite for the energy region reported by lhcb @xcite .
possible explanations involving np interactions have been suggested as the source of non - universal leptonic interactions @xcite .
interestingly , other anomalies have been reported in angular observables of related @xmath13 decays @xcite which have been widely discussed in the literature @xcite . in the sm ,
the semileptonic @xmath14 ( @xmath15 ) decays are dominated by the sd @xmath16 transition @xcite .
this elementary process is induced by the electromagnetic and weak penguin ( figure 1a ) , as well as @xmath17 boson box ( figure 1b ) diagram contributions , which are dominated by loops involving the top quark . in these exclusive processes ,
ld chiral corrections to the hadronic matrix element have been computed for soft momenta of light pseudoscalars ( i.e. high - momentum @xmath18 of dilepton pairs ) , where they amount to rather large @xmath19 corrections @xcite .
our point here is that , although this kind of corrections will be much smaller on the other energy end ( large recoil region for the heavy - to - light b - meson form factors @xcite ) , the high precision of measurements as well as the sharp predictions of the dominating sd contributions suggests ld effects associated to resonance dynamics at the gev scale be taken into account as well for these more energetic @xmath20 mesons .
contributions of four - quark operators giving rise to tree - level wa amplitudes with virtual photon emission are also possible for exclusive @xmath14 processes and are the main concern of this paper . as far as we know , the one - photon exchange feynman diagrams ( arising from wa operators ) shown in figures 1c-1d provide a so far neglected ld contribution that must be included in the calculation of these exclusive semileptonic rare decays . neutrino - exchange amplitude .
this one was checked to give a highly suppressed effect in @xmath21 decays @xcite . ]
these additional ld contributions could in principle modify the @xmath22 value due to kinematical effects @xcite . according to chiral effective theories of qcd @xcite , for photon four - momenta below @xmath23 gev ,
photon - hadron interactions are best formulated in terms of the relevant ( pseudo-)scalar and ( axial-)vector hadronic degrees of freedom . as it was shown long ago @xcite , the @xmath21
rare semileptonic decays are dominated by the one - photon exchange contributions analogous to the ones of figure 1c and 1d ; the sd top - quark loop penguin and w - box contributions in that case are negligible small @xcite . owing to gauge - invariance
, this ld contribution vanishes at lowest order in chiral perturbation theory but this is not the case at higher orders @xcite .
according to the respective ckm mixing factors in the sd and ld amplitudes of @xmath14 decays , one can envisage a correction at the percent level for @xmath24 but a slightly higher effect could be expected for @xmath25 depending on the limits of the integrated observables .
it is worth noticing that wa contributions were previously considered for @xmath26 @xcite and @xmath27 @xcite decays in the framework of the qcd factorization ( qcdf ) scheme @xcite .
recently , non - local effects in @xmath28 decays have been computed in ref .
@xcite using the method developed in ref .
@xcite and previously used in ref .
@xcite for @xmath29 decays for low dilepton invariant masses . at large
hadronic recoil ( corresponding to low values of the squared virtual photon momentum @xmath30 ) , the light - meson energy ( @xmath31 ) is much larger than the energy scale of hadronic binding : @xmath32 .
then , the virtual photon exchange between the hadrons and the dilepton pair and hard gluon scattering can be systematically expanded in powers of @xmath33 using qcdf .
however , the @xmath34 amplitude suffers from nonperturbative corrections due to @xmath35 and @xmath36 intermediate states , which form the @xmath37 , @xmath38 , @xmath39 , ... resonances @xcite ( similarly , in @xmath40 processes @xmath41 and @xmath42 can be excited and the @xmath43 meson plays a prominent role @xcite ) .
therefore , a clean qcdf prediction shall be limited to an energy range which excludes these resonant contributions , conservatively @xmath44 gev@xmath5 . on the contrary
, the extension of these limits requires the inclusion of near - threshold @xmath35 and @xmath36 ( @xmath41 and @xmath42 ) resonances .
let us recall ref .
@xcite where these are accounted for studying the @xmath45 processes leading to a relevant effect of the charmonium resonances in the inclusive decay width .
also , ref .
@xcite considered resonance effects from @xmath46 excitations in @xmath47 processes , where @xmath43 exchange basically saturates the decay width . in the analyzed @xmath48 decays , cutting at a maximum @xmath49 value well below the charmonium region kills the effects of the @xmath36 resonances and we have checked that the remaining contributions of @xmath35 resonances are negligible .
there are , however , other resonance contributions that may be relevant in our case : the ones where the photon is attached to the initial and final state mesons in wa contributions ( fig . 1c-1d ) . in the spirit of the phenomenological lagrangians
, we would like to focus in the @xmath50 gev@xmath5 region by adding the effect of the lowest - lying light - flavoured resonances and pseudoscalar mesons as active degrees of freedom as it is done in the ( resonance ) chiral lagrangians .
this is the approach that we follow to ensure the applicability of the qcdf analysis of the @xmath51 decays down to threshold . here we treat the photon - meson interaction by considering the exchange of resonances in the framework of two different models which have shown to give a very accurate description of experimental data for @xmath49 values up to @xmath52 gev@xmath5 .
this agreement shows that up to those energies , the photon does not resolve the quark structure of mesons and only probes their electromagnetic structure . in order to avoid potential double counting of effects from wa contributions ( in the qcdf approach and ours )
, we will consider our ld wa contribution only for photons with @xmath53 gev@xmath5 and match it to the qcdf contribution for @xmath54 gev@xmath5 as discussed in section [ matching ] .
the purpose of this paper is to quantify these expectations and evaluate the contributions given by diagrams in figures 1(c , d ) for the @xmath14 decays for low and intermediate values of the invariant mass of di - lepton pair ( other diagrams present in figure 2 vanish due to gauge invariance , see below ) .
we use two different approaches for the @xmath55 and @xmath56 electromagnetic form factors in order to estimate the systematic error of our computation . for these rare
@xmath7 decays , it is found that the one - photon exchange diagrams do not modify lepton universality for the energy range measured by lhcb @xcite and that they turn out to be very small in the @xmath24 case , although their effects in the @xmath25 rates are more significant .
the wa contribution that we study has a different dependence on ckm mixing elements than the dominant sd one and also carries a sizable strong phase , leading to possible cp violating effects .
the dominant source of cp violation , both in our paper and in the qcdf approach , arises from the interference between the sd top - mediated loop and the wa diagrams .
however , the strong phase in our case is provided by the imaginary parts of the light resonance shapes , while in the qcdf approach it arises from the on - shell spectator @xmath57 quark in the @xmath7 meson after having emitted the photon .
we find measurable effects both for @xmath58 on the integrated cp asymmetry and encourage the lhcb and belle - ii collaborations to measure such asymmetries which could be useful to validate the models employed in the description of exclusive @xmath59 decays at low photon virtualities .
decays are shown in @xmath60 ( penguin ) and @xmath61 ( @xmath17 box ) diagrams .
the one - photon , ld , wa contributions are shown in @xmath62 and @xmath63 .
the full circle denotes the electromagnetic form factor of the charged pseudoscalar mesons . other long - distance structure - dependent vector and axial - vector terms ( shown in fig .
2 ) do not contribute due to gauge invariance @xcite . ]
in the standard model , observables like direct cp asymmetry in @xmath64 have shown to be particularly sensitive to the interference of top dominated loops and wa amplitudes , which carry different weak and strong phases .
both amplitudes have been evaluated within the framework of qcdf where the strong phase in the wa amplitude , at relatively low photon virtualities , arises mainly from the on - shell @xmath57 spectator quark in the @xmath7 meson after having emitted the photon . in this section
we provide an alternative evaluation of this wa amplitude using the resonance chiral theory within a factorization approximation , which we expect to be valid for @xmath65 gev@xmath5 . in a later section
we will show how to match this contribution to the corresponding wa amplitude calculated within qcdf , which will be used for larger @xmath49 values .
since the strong phase in our calculation stems from the pseudoscalar electromagnetic form factors , our approach provides an independent evaluation of the cp asymmetry for low and intermediate values of the lepton - pair invariant masses . for completeness and later use , we will consider first the description of these decays within qcdf as given in ref .
let us choose the following convention for the particle s momenta : @xmath66 the contributions of the diagrams in figures ( 1a , b ) , including higher order qcd corrections , to the decay amplitude can be written , to a very good approximation as @xcite : @xmath67\ , \ ] ] where @xmath68 is the total momentum of the lepton pair , the subindex in the ckm matrix element stands for @xmath69 in the case of @xmath70 transitions .
the factors @xmath71 and @xmath72 denote the vector and axial wilson coefficients at nnlo @xcite corresponding to the @xmath73 and @xmath74 operators in the effective weak hamiltonian for the @xmath75 transition .
the wa contributions induced by four quark operators are conventionally absorbed into the effective @xmath76 coefficient , by replacing its numerical value given above by @xmath77 . for the @xmath25 case , the product of ckm matrix elements for loops involving all up - type quarks ( @xmath78 ) scale as @xmath79 .
however , the loop function favors the top quark as the dominant contribution ) , see ref . @xcite . ] owing to the hierarchy of up - type quarks .
although we are aware that more refined heavy - to - light meson form factors have been developed @xcite , we will use the classical ball and zwicky form factors @xcite for our estimates and include the corresponding uncertainty in the errors , as discussed below .
the expressions for the @xmath49-dependent form factors are @xmath80 ^ 2 } + { \cal p}_k(q^2)\nonumber , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the polynomials @xmath81 as well as the needed gegenbauer moments at the required energy scale can be found in refs .
@xcite . in this section , we would like to consider specifically light - resonance effects in the wa contribution to @xmath83 for the @xmath84 gev@xmath5 region .
we assume that in this energy range the relevant degrees of freedom are these light mesons and resonances ( and not the quark and gluon fields ) , according to the methodology of phenomenological lagrangians .
low - energy phenomenology supports widely this hypothesis @xcite .
applying this method to the process under consideration requires further hypothesis about the strong and electromagnetic interactions of @xmath7 mesons which , we argue , play a subleading role in our description
. the decay amplitude corresponding to wa is given by @xmath85 where @xmath86 denotes the effective hadronic electromagnetic current coupled to the leptonic current .
conservation of the electromagnetic current demands @xmath87f(q^2 ) \ , \ ] ] where only the first term within square brackets gives a non - vanishing contribution owing to the condition @xmath88 ( for the same reason , we can also replace @xmath89 ) .
the factor @xmath90 encodes the information about the dynamics of weak and electromagnetic interactions in the hadronic blob . owing to gauge - invariance , most of the diagrams ( shown in figure [ newfig ] ) contributing to wa , vanish . to illustrate this
, we insert a complete set of intermediate states in the relevant hadron matrix element and take into account the t - ordering of the electromagnetic and weak interactions , which gives rise to the leading order factorizable contributions @xmath91 where the sum over virtual intermediate states @xmath92 and @xmath93 that are allowed by the quantum numbers of the weak and electromagnetic interactions , should be understood .
some of the feynman diagrams that contribute to @xmath94 are depicted in fig .
[ newfig ] .
non - factorizable contributions , like the ones shown in figure [ newfig]k , are sub - leading in the @xmath95 expansion and will not be considered in our calculationt is an expansion in @xmath95 ] . at lower photon virtualities , where resonance degrees of freedom may be neglected
, it was shown that non - factorizable ( local ) contributions partially cancel among themselves@xcite , leaving the form factors of @xmath6 and @xmath97 as the dominant contributions in @xmath98 .
single lines stand for pseudoscalar mesons , double lines for ( axial-)vector resonances and wavy lines for the virtual photon ( due to the spin - one nature of the weak current , spin - zero resonance contributions are suppressed ) .
filled squares denote the weak / electromagnetic vertex , while the empty rectangles denote the wa hamiltonian .
all contributions to the @xmath99 decays ( including the pointlike interactions in the first line ) vanish due to gauge invariance @xcite or are suppressed , except diagrams ( i ) and ( j ) which contribute to the electromagnetic form factors of pseudoscalar mesons .
odd - intrinsic parity violating vertices are also considered in the calculation . ] under the above approximations , which justify the naive factorization of the hadronic matrix element of the weak hamiltonian , the leading order one - photon exchange ( wa ) amplitude corresponding to figure [ newfig](i , j ) can be computed taking into account that @xmath100[derivativecouplings ] and is given by ( neglecting the contribution of diagram 1c which is of order @xmath101 with respect to 1d is , however , a good approximation ) . ] )
@xmath102 p_b^{\mu}\bar{\ell}\gamma_{\mu}\ell\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath103 denotes the decay constant of the pseudoscalar meson @xmath92 according to the pdg @xcite conventions for @xmath104 and @xmath105 is the electromagnetic form factor of the corresponding meson .
note that the pure scalar qed ( point meson approximation ) , as well as the structure - dependent vector and axial - vector terms , do not contribute to the amplitude as required by gauge invariance @xcite . or @xmath106 vertices for the @xmath107 transition ( and analogous vertices for the @xmath6 case ) .
] thus , the one - photon exchange contribution is sensitive to the intermediate @xmath49 region of the pseudoscalar form factor , and eventually to their resonance structure . due to the vector nature of the one - photon exchange contribution
, its amplitude can be absorbed into the contribution of the @xmath108 operator in the qcdf amplitude under the replacement @xmath109,\ ] ] where @xmath110 note that @xmath111 so that its influence is governed by the ratio of ckm factors which is @xmath112 for @xmath25 and @xmath113 for @xmath24 .
this suggests a larger effect for @xmath114 transitions but a detailed analysis of the electromagnetic meson form factors is needed to confirm these expectations .
for the electromagnetic form factors of the light pseudoscalar mesons ( @xmath58 ) we have considered two approaches . on the one hand we have used form factors that are obtained within the frame of resonance chiral theory ( r@xmath82 t ) @xcite and , on the other hand , the phenomenological form factors used by the babar collaboration which employs the gounaris - sakurai ( gs ) parametrization @xcite .
the first approach has the advantage of providing a low - energy behaviour complying with the chiral limit of qcd @xcite , which is a must if we want to get close to thresholds in some of our evaluations .
alternatively , the gs parametrizations include more excited resonances and , for this reason , are expected to give a closer description of data at higher energies . in the cases at hand , the bulk of the contribution ( even for integrated observables starting at @xmath115 gev@xmath5 ) will be given by the @xmath116 ( @xmath117 ) meson exchange in the k ( @xmath97 ) cases .
therefore , we should expect very similar results for the two approaches , @xmath118 being more reliable for observables starting near thresholds and the gs for the much less important higher energy range ( up to @xmath119 or @xmath120 gev@xmath5 depending on the channel ) .
the minimal lagrangian of @xmath118 was derived in ref .
@xcite upon the requirement of chiral symmetry for the pseudogoldstone fields and flavor symmetry for the light - flavored resonances .
@xcite supplements the @xmath121 lagrangian at lowest order ( @xmath122 ) in the chiral counting @xcite @xmath123 with the following interaction terms between a light spin - one resonance and the pseudogoldstone fields @xcite @xmath124 the real couplings @xmath76 , @xmath125 and @xmath126 are unrestricted by symmetries and encode the dynamics .
one can proceed similarly for the spin - zero resonances @xcite and include terms with more resonance fields and excited resonances , extending also to the odd - intrinsic parity sector @xcite . within the single resonance approximation
, the evaluation of the @xmath20-vector form factor using the @xmath118 lagrangian yields @xmath127 by demanding a brodsky - lepage behaviour @xcite to @xmath128 one gets the relation @xmath129 , which gives a parameter - free expression .
this naive result can be improved by including the next - to - leading order effect in the @xmath95 counting , _
i. e. _ the meson ( off - shell ) width according to chiral constraints ( the corresponding real part of the chiral loops is also included ) , and adding the effect of higher excitations and ( in the @xmath97 case ) including the dominant isospin - breaking effect given by the @xmath130 mixing . specifically for @xmath131 ,
we have used the parametrizations in the last two refs . in @xcite , which include three isovector resonances ( @xmath117 , @xmath132 and @xmath133 ) and the resummation of final state interactions encoded in the chiral loop functions .
these representations provide good quality fits to belle data @xcite for @xmath134 decays .
additionally , we have included the characteristic @xmath135 interference appearing in the neutral channel by multiplying the @xmath117 term by the factor @xmath136 with @xmath137 gev@xmath5 @xcite .
other isospin breaking corrections are neglected .
this parametrization is compared to babar data @xcite in figure 2 , which are available for the energy region @xmath138 gev . there
, the phenomenological gs parametrization includes an additional @xmath37-like excitation .
tiny differences between both parametrizations are seen in the region where the destructive interference between the @xmath132 and the @xmath133 resonances is stronger .
the comparison also shows the effect of the @xmath118 parametrization lacking of the @xmath139 meson , which is clearly visible in the @xmath140 gev region .
these minor differences are taken into account in the final quoted errors .
analogously , we have employed two parametrizations of @xmath141 form factor . since this form factor
is completely dominated by the extremely narrow @xmath116 meson , we have considered the @xmath118 prediction with only one multiplet of resonances @xcite . on the other hand , the babar collaboration @xcite has reported measurements of the kaon form factor from threshold up to @xmath142 gev .
since @xmath143 drops by 6 orders of magnitude in going from the peak to @xmath142 gev ( see figure 3 ) , it should be sufficient to include only the @xmath116 resonance in its parametrization .
as it can be observed in figure 3 , experimental data for @xmath143 are reasonably well described from threshold up to approximately @xmath144 gev .
deviations at higher energies have a negligible impact in the integrated observables of rare @xmath7 decays . above this energy , other resonance structures with very small ( and alternating ) peaks and dips around the single resonance queue
can be observed .
these , in turn , are well described using the parameterization quoted in the babar paper @xcite ( which we fitted to the babar data ) , which includes two @xmath43 , three @xmath37 and three @xmath38 excitations in addition to the single lightest vector meson multiplet included in the @xmath118 form factor . mixing the former state
does not contribute to @xmath141 and only @xmath117 and @xmath116 remain , with a prominent role of the latter . ] because of its relevance in the study of cp violating observables , we plot in fig .
[ reimparts ] the real and imaginary parts of the light - meson electromagnetic form factors according to the two different descriptions that we used . while models agree nicely for the @xmath97 case , they do not in the @xmath6 case around the @xmath117 peak .
since the corresponding phase shift has been validated by data in the case of the @xmath118 description , we attribute this to an incorrect phase of the @xmath145 kaon form factor .
finally , the @xmath7-meson electromagnetic form factor contribution is suppressed by a factor @xmath146 in eq .
( [ eqld ] ) with respect to the ones of lighter mesons .
in addition , a dynamical suppression of the form factor itself is expected according to the reduced charged radius of heavy mesons . just in order to confirm this , meson form factor at small values of the momentum transfer , would be by means of elastic electron-@xmath7 meson scattering . given the difficulty to produce a @xmath7 meson target / beam , it becomes rather complicated to test this low energy behavior of the @xmath7 meson form factor .
] we consider the effective lagrangian coupling @xmath147-mesons to lighter mesons and external sources in ref .
@xcite generalized to include @xmath7 mesons .
it can be seen that , upon requiring a brodsky - lepage behaviour @xcite of this form factor at infinite momentum transfer , the shape of @xmath148 is given just by flavour symmetry , yielding @xmath149 where @xmath150 can be found in refs .
our numerical evaluations confirm that the effect of this form factor will be completely negligible in rates of rare @xmath10 mesons .
the spectra of the lepton pair , normalized to the @xmath10 meson decay width are plotted in figure [ fig : leptonpair ] for low values of the lepton - pair invariant mass .
we observe that above the muon - pair threshold both spectra are identical .
clearly , the integrated rates in the whole kinematical range would exhibit a trivial breaking of leptonic universality owing to the lower electronic threshold and its enhancement due to the @xmath151 dependence in the ld wa amplitude .
however , this will happen both in the well - known qcdf as well as in the new ld wa contributions ; thus only the numerical evaluation will tell if there is any additional measurable breaking of universality due to ld wa effects in the considered processes .
the ld ( one - photon exchange ) contribution to the @xmath14 decays that we have discussed in previous sections and the one evaluated in the qcdf approach originate from the wa four - quark operator of the effective hamiltonian .
then it naturally arises the question whether there is some double - counting between both contributions or not . for low enough values of @xmath49 ( @xmath30 ) ,
the qcdf expansion in 1/@xmath31 is the best way to organize the perturbative series .
however , when approaching the @xmath35 threshold ( @xmath152 ) light - resonance effects need to be included explicitely as active degrees of freedom in the action as done in the resonance chiral lagrangians . within the interval from threshold to @xmath153
, we expect that chiral lagrangians give an adequate description for low @xmath49 values , while qcdf be more appropriate for the higher @xmath49 region .
we thus assume there is an intermediate energy scale where both descriptions are good approximations and search for this matching scale where the ( complex ) effective wilson coefficient @xmath154 smoothly matches both descriptions for the @xmath97 and @xmath6 meson channels .
we have found such matching scale at @xmath155 gev@xmath5 , as it can be seen in figs .
[ fig : matching ] .
then we have consider our ld one - photon exchange diagrams as the wa contribution for @xmath50 gev@xmath5 and the sd qcdf counterpart ( where the photon is radiated by the valence quarks in the @xmath7 and @xmath20 mesons ) for @xmath156 gev@xmath5 .
we have used this separation scale between the ld and sd ( qcdf ) descriptions of wa contributions in the following and a slight variation of the matching scale has been taken into account in the error estimates . in the following , whenever we use qcdf
it is understood that the corresponding result for wa is only used above @xmath52 gev@xmath5 .
searches for new physics at large hadronic recoil in the @xmath157 decays are restricted to the @xmath158 gev@xmath5 range of @xmath49 @xcite . thus we will stick to this region for this channel .
the @xmath107 decays have just been observed @xcite and such studies have not taken place yet .
we therefore include our results both for a range starting at @xmath159 gev@xmath5 ( basically the muon threshold ) and at @xmath160 gev@xmath5 . in either case we cut the phase - space integration at @xmath120 gev@xmath5 to avoid the charmonium region . in table
[ table1 ] we show the corresponding branching ratios of ld wa , qcdf and their interference contributions by considering these different kinematical integration domains .
values for required input parameters are taken from the pdg @xcite except for the ckm matrix elements which come from ref .
@xcite .
.integrated branching ratios of @xmath48 decays for @xmath25 ( left hand side ) and @xmath24 ( right hand side ) for different @xmath49 ranges .
we tabulate separately the qcdf , long - distance wa ( ld ) and their interference contributions for the kinematical ranges of interest . [ cols="<,<,<,<",options="header " , ] [ table2 ] this @xmath161 cp violating figures shall enhance the case for their measurements .
current values at the pdg are well compatible with zero @xcite in @xmath162 ( and also in @xmath163 ) decays , while this observable is not yet reported in the @xmath164 case .
the most recent measurement reported by the lhcb collaboration for the integrated cp asymmetry , namely @xmath165 @xcite , is still consistent with the different theoretical predictions .
therefore , despite the fact that the tree - level one - photon exchange diagrams give a small contribution to the decay rates ( specially for the @xmath6 case ) , they can generate a non - negligible cp asymmetry within the standard model .
this cp asymmetry altogether with measurements of the decay rates can be used as a test of new physics in the rare @xmath166 decays .
this makes us emphasize the need of a dedicated measurement of these observables in the next lhc run at lhcb and in the forthcoming belle - ii experiment .
in this paper we have considered the one - photon exchange contribution to the rare @xmath167 decays , with @xmath25 or @xmath6 .
its effects in the decay rates of the @xmath24 case turn out to be of order 1@xmath168 with respect to the ( top quark loop dominated ) sd contribution for the range @xmath169 gev@xmath5 of the squared lepton pair invariant mass .
we do not foresee forthcoming measurements being sensitive to this contribution in the near future . on the contrary
, this fact confirms the suitability of this range for new physics searches .
in the case of a @xmath170 meson in the final state , the corresponding effect turns out to be significant in integrated observables starting close to threshold .
this suggests to take in analogy to the case of a final state with @xmath6 the range @xmath171 gev@xmath5 for precision measurements , since the ld wa contribution is reduced to less than 10@xmath168 with a negligible uncertainty in that interval . on the other hand , more refined measurements of the fully integrated branching fraction for this decay could be sensitive to our contribution once the error is reduced below a half of the current uncertainty
interestingly , the different weak and strong phases of the qcdf and ld wa ( one - photon exchange ) contributions are capable to generate a cp asymmetry . again , this cp asymmetry is large in the case of a pion in the final state for @xmath172 gev@xmath5 values of the lepton - pair invariant mass , but also sizable and worth to measure in the @xmath173 gev@xmath5 interval . for the kaon case ,
the range @xmath174 gev@xmath5 is optimal for such a search .
our cp violation results are smaller than those obtained within qcdf because of the different description of the wa amplitudes at low energies .
future measurements shall be sensitive to this kind of contribution and shed light on its appropriate description .
more refined measurements of this cp asymmetry and of the magnitudes of the decay rates at lhcb and future @xmath7-superfactories can provide another non - trivial test of the standard model or may furnish indications of new physics . *
acknowledgements * : the authors would like to thank conacyt ( mxico ) for financial support .
we appreciate very much helpful correspondence with bogdan malaescu concerning the babar parametrization of the kaon electromagnetic form factor .
we thank javier virto for useful discussions on the topic of this article .
g. buchalla , a. j. buras and m. e. lautenbacher , rev .
* 68 * , 1125 ( 1996 ) . v. cirigliano , g. ecker , h. neufeld , a. pich , and j. portols , rev .
phys . * 84 * , 399 ( 2012 ) .
t. hurth and m. nakao , ann .
nucl . part .
* 60 * , 645 ( 2010 ) .
r. aaij _ et al .
_ [ lhcb collaboration ] , phys . rev . lett . * 113 * , 151601 ( 2014 ) . c. bobeth , g. hiller and g. piranishvili , j. high energy phys .
* 12 * , 040 ( 2007 ) . c. bobeth , g. hiller , d. van dyk and ch .
wacker , j. high energy phys . * 01 * , 107 ( 2012 ) .
g. hiller and f. krger , phys .
rev . d**69 * * , 074020 ( 2004 ) .
g. hiller and m. schmaltz , phys .
d**90 * * , 054014 ( 2014 ) .
r. alonso , b. grinstein and j. martn camalich , phys .
* 113 * ( 2014 ) 24 , 241802 ; d. ghosh , m. nardecchia and s. a. renner , jhep * 1412 * ( 2014 ) 131 ; s. biswas , d. chowdhury , s. han and s. j. lee , jhep * 1502 * ( 2015 ) 142 ; t. hurth , f. mahmoudi and s. neshatpour , jhep * 1412 * ( 2014 ) 053 ; s. l. glashow , d. guadagnoli and k. lane , phys
. rev .
* 114 * ( 2015 ) 9 , 091801 ; w. altmannshofer and d. m. straub , arxiv:1411.3161 [ hep - ph ] ; g. hiller and m. schmaltz , jhep * 1502 * ( 2015 ) 055 ; b. gripaios , m. nardecchia and s. a. renner , arxiv:1412.1791 [ hep - ph ] ; b. bhattacharya , a. datta , d. london and s. shivashankara , phys .
b * 742 * ( 2015 ) 370 ; a. crivellin , g. dambrosio and j. heeck , arxiv:1501.00993 [ hep - ph ] ; s. sahoo and r. mohanta , arxiv:1501.05193 [ hep - ph ] ; i. d. m. varzielas and g. hiller , arxiv:1503.01084 [ hep - ph ] ; a. crivellin , g. dambrosio and j. heeck , arxiv:1503.03477 [ hep - ph ] ; c. niehoff , p. stangl and d. m. straub , arxiv:1503.03865 [ hep - ph ] ; d. a. sierra , f. staub and a. vicente , arxiv:1503.06077 [ hep - ph ] ; s. m. boucenna , j. w. f. valle and a. vicente , arxiv:1503.07099 [ hep - ph ] . t. aaltonen _ et al .
_ [ cdf collaboration ] , phys . rev . lett .
* 108 * ( 2012 ) 081807 ; j .- t .
wei _ et al . _ [ belle collaboration ] , phys . rev .
* 103 * ( 2009 ) 171801 ; j. p.
lees _ et al .
_ [ babar collaboration ] , phys .
d * 86 * ( 2012 ) 032012 ; r. aaij _ et al .
_ [ lhcb collaboration ] , jhep * 1305 * ( 2013 ) 159 ; * 1308 * ( 2013 ) 131
. s. descotes - genon , j. matas and j. virto , phys .
d * 88 * ( 2013 ) 7 , 074002 ; w. altmannshofer and d. m. straub , eur .
j. c * 73 * ( 2013 ) 12 , 2646 ; r. gauld , f. goertz and u. haisch , phys .
d * 89 * ( 2014 ) 1 , 015005 ; c. hambrock , g. hiller , s. schacht and r. zwicky , phys .
d * 89 * ( 2014 ) 7 , 074014 ; a. j. buras and j. girrbach , jhep * 1312 * ( 2013 ) 009 ; r. gauld , f. goertz and u. haisch , jhep * 1401 * ( 2014 ) 069 ; a. datta , m. duraisamy and d. ghosh , phys . rev .
d * 89 * ( 2014 ) 7 , 071501 ; f. beaujean , c. bobeth and d. van dyk , eur .
j. c * 74 * ( 2014 ) 6 , 2897 [ erratum - ibid .
c * 74 * ( 2014 ) 12 , 3179 ] ; r. r. horgan , z. liu , s. meinel and m. wingate , phys .
* 112 * ( 2014 ) 212003 ; a. j. buras , f. de fazio and j. girrbach , jhep * 1402 * ( 2014 ) 112 ; t. hurth and f. mahmoudi , jhep * 1404 * ( 2014 ) 097 ; f. mahmoudi , s. neshatpour and j. virto , eur .
j. c * 74 * ( 2014 ) 6 , 2927 ; w. altmannshofer , s. gori , m. pospelov and i. yavin , phys .
d * 89 * ( 2014 ) 9 , 095033 ; j. lyon and r. zwicky , arxiv:1406.0566 [ hep - ph ] .
a. khodjamirian , t. mannel and y. m. wang , jhep * 1302 * ( 2013 ) 010 .
j. j. wang , r. m. wang , y. g. xu and y. d. yang , phys .
d * 77 * , 014017 ( 2008 ) .
w - f . wang and z - j .
xiao , phys .
d * 86 * ( 2012 ) , 114025 .
a. ali , a. ya .
parkhomenko and a. v. rusov , phys .
d * 89 * , 094021 ( 2014 ) .
a. f. falk and b. grinstein , nucl .
b * 416 * ( 1994 ) 771 ; b. grinstein and d. pirjol , phys .
d * 70 * ( 2004 ) 114005 ; j. bijnens and i. jemos , nucl .
b * 840 * ( 2010 ) 54 [ erratum - ibid .
b * 844 * ( 2011 ) 182 ] ; * 846 * ( 2011 ) 145 .
j. charles , a. le yaouanc , l. oliver , o. pene and j. c. raynal , phys .
d * 60 * ( 1999 ) 014001 ; m. beneke and t. feldmann , nucl .
b * 592 * ( 2001 ) 3 .
d. n. gao and y. c. yu , mod .
lett . a**29 * * , 1450001 ( 2014 ) .
p. roig , a. guevara and g. lpez castro , phys .
d * 88 * ( 2013 ) 3 , 033007 .
s. weinberg , physica a * 96 * ( 1979 ) 327 ; j. gasser and h. leutwyler , annals phys .
* 158 * ( 1984 ) 142 ; nucl .
b * 250 * ( 1985 ) 465 .
g. ecker , a. pich and e. de rafael , nucl .
phys . b**291 * * , 692 ( 1987 ) . c. bruno and j. prades , z. phys . c**57 * * , 585 ( 1993 ) ; g. dambrosio , g. ecker , g. isidori and j. portols , j. high energy phys . * 08 * , 004 ( 1998 ) ; j. bijnens and k. ghorbani , arxiv:0711.0148 [ hep - ph ] ; s. friot , d. greynat , and e. de rafael , phys .
b**595 * * , 301 ( 2004 ) .
m. beneke , th .
feldmann and d. seidel , nucl .
phys . b**612 * * , 25 ( 2001 ) ; eur .
j. c**41 * * , 173 ( 2005 ) .
w. s. hou , m. kohda and f. xu , phys .
d * 90 * ( 2014 ) 1 , 013002 .
m. beneke , g. buchalla , m. neubert and c. t. sachrajda , phys .
rev . lett .
* 83 * ( 1999 ) 1914 ; nucl .
b * 591 * ( 2000 ) 313 . c. hambrock , a. khodjamirian and a. rusov , arxiv:1506.07760 [ hep - ph ] .
a. khodjamirian , t. mannel , a. a. pivovarov and y .- m .
wang , jhep * 1009 * ( 2010 ) 089 .
c. s. lim , t. morozumi and a. i. sanda , phys .
b * 218 * ( 1989 ) 343 .
g. burdman , e. golowich , j. l. hewett and s. pakvasa , phys .
d * 66 * ( 2002 ) 014009 .
a. v. manohar , hep - ph/9802419 .
a. pich , hep - ph/9806303 .
both published in the proceedings of the summer school in theoretical physics , nato advanced study institute , 68th session , les houches , france , july 28-september 5 , 1997 .
pt . 1 , 2 . eds .
r. gupta , a. morel , e. de rafael , f. david . c. g. boyd , b. grinstein and r. f. lebed , phys .
lett . *
74 * ( 1995 ) 4603 ; d. becirevic and a. b. kaidalov , phys .
b * 478 * ( 2000 ) 417 ; g. duplancic , a. khodjamirian , t. mannel , b. melic and n. offen , jhep * 0804 * ( 2008 ) 014 ; a. khodjamirian , t. mannel , n. offen and y .- m .
wang , phys .
d * 83 * ( 2011 ) 094031 ; h. n. li , y. l. shen and y. m. wang , phys .
d * 85 * ( 2012 ) 074004 ; a. bharucha , jhep * 1205 * ( 2012 ) 092 ; c. bouchard _ et al .
_ [ hpqcd collaboration ] , phys . rev .
* 111 * ( 2013 ) 16 , 162002 [ erratum - ibid .
* 112 * ( 2014 ) 14 , 149902 ] ; c. bouchard _ et al . _
[ hpqcd collaboration ] , phys .
d * 88 * ( 2013 ) 5 , 054509 [ erratum - ibid .
d * 88 * ( 2013 ) 7 , 079901 ] ; r. r. horgan , z. liu , s. meinel and m. wingate , phys .
d * 89 * ( 2014 ) 9 , 094501 ; s. aoki , y. aoki , c. bernard , t. blum , g. colangelo , m. della morte , s. drr and a. x. el khadra _ et al .
_ , eur .
j. c * 74 * ( 2014 ) 9 , 2890 ; a. bharucha , d. m. straub and r. zwicky , arxiv:1503.05534 [ hep - ph ] .
p. ball and r. zwicky , phys .
d * 71 * ( 2005 ) 014015 .
k. a. olive _
[ particle data group ] , chin .
c * 38 * , 0190001 ( 2014 ) .
g. ecker , j. gasser , h. leutwyler , a. pich and e. de rafael , phys .
b * 223 * ( 1989 ) 425 ; g. ecker , j. gasser , a. pich and e. de rafael , nucl .
b * 321 * ( 1989 ) 311 .
g. j. gounaris and j. j. sakurai , phys .
* 21 * ( 1968 ) 244 .
d. ruiz - femena , a. pich and j. portols , jhep * 0307 * ( 2003 ) 003 .
v. cirigliano , g. ecker , m. eidemller , a. pich and j. portols , phys .
b * 596 * ( 2004 ) 96 ; v. cirigliano , g. ecker , m. eidemller , r. kaiser , a. pich and j. portols , jhep * 0504 * ( 2005 ) 006 .
d. g. dumm , p. roig , a. pich and j. portols , phys .
d * 81 * ( 2010 ) 034031 .
k. kampf and j. novotny , phys .
d * 84 * ( 2011 ) 014036 .
p. roig and j. j. sanz - cillero , phys .
b * 733 * ( 2014 ) 158 .
g. p. lepage and s. j. brodsky , phys .
d * 22 * ( 1980 ) 2157 ; s. j. brodsky and g. r. farrar , phys . rev .
* 31 * ( 1973 ) 1153 .
f. guerrero and a. pich , phys .
b * 412 * ( 1997 ) 382 ; o. shekhovtsova , t. przedzinski , p. roig and z. was , phys .
d * 86 * ( 2012 ) 113008 ; d. gmez dumm and p. roig , eur .
j. c * 73 * ( 2013 ) 8 , 2528 .
m. fujikawa _ et al . _ [ belle collaboration ] , phys .
d * 78 * ( 2008 ) 072006 .
a. pich and j. portols , nucl .
suppl . * 121 * ( 2003 ) 179 .
j. p. lees et al [ babar collaboration ] , phys .
d*88 * , 032013 ( 2013 ) .
f. guerrero and j. a. oller , nucl .
b * 537 * ( 1999 ) 459 [ erratum - ibid .
b * 602 * ( 2001 ) 641 ] ; e. arganda , m. j. herrero and j. portols , jhep * 0806 * ( 2008 ) 079 .
j. p. lees _ et al .
_ [ babar collaboration ] , phys .
d * 88 * ( 2013 ) 3 , 032013 .
g. amors , s. noguera and j. portols , eur .
j. c * 27 * ( 2003 ) 243 .
r. aaij _ et al . _
[ lhcb collaboration ] , jhep * 1212 * ( 2012 ) 125 . | we propose an alternative evaluation of the long - distance weak annihilation ( wa , also called one - photon exchange in this paper ) contribution to the rare semileptonic @xmath0 ( @xmath1 ) decays .
this hadronic description at low energies is matched at intermediate energies to its short - distance counterpart in terms of quark and gluon degrees of freedom .
although the wa contribution does not contribute to solve the possible breaking of lepton - universality observed by lhcb in the @xmath2 ratio , nor provides an important hadronic contamination to their decay rates , its contribution to the branching ratios ( and direct cp asymmetry ) of the @xmath3 transitions turns out to be significant . this hadronic pollution should be taken into account when looking for new physics effects in decays into pions , which suggests to restrict these searches to squared lepton - pair invariant mass in the @xmath4 gev@xmath5 range .
the interference of the one - photon exchange contribution with the dominant short - distance one - loop amplitude induces a sizable cp asymmetry in these rare decays , which calls for dedicated measurements . |
in bridging the gap between classical mechanics and thermal phenomena , the founding fathers of statistical mechanics realized that a statistical characterization of macrostates in terms of microstates is essential for understanding the typical time evolution of thermodynamic systems .
but statistical reasoning requires proper counting , starting from a set of _ a priori _ equivalent microstates .
that is different in quantum statistics from what is done in classical statistics .
nevertheless the same concepts can be put in place . in this paper , we show for the quantum case what has been proven useful in the classical case : that entropy production measures the breaking of time - reversal invariance . more exactly , we show that the logarithmic ratio of the probability of a trajectory and its time - reversal coincides with the physical entropy production . + we continue with an introduction about entropy , both classical and quantum , to specify what we mean by entropy production .
the main message is contained in sections 2 and 3 where the relation between entropy production and time - reversal is demonstrated .
section 2 deals with a unitary evolution ( one initial preparation and one final measurement ) and can be considered as a special case of section 3 where the unitary evolution is further interrupted with measurements of the macrostate .
the paper is based on elementary mathematical manipulations and the emphasis is on the conceptual framework .
suppose a classical closed and isolated system of @xmath0 particles . a complete description consists in specifying its microstate , that is a point @xmath1 in its phase space , @xmath2 of positions and momenta .
the dynamics is hamiltonian and energy is conserved .
each microstate @xmath1 determines a macrostate @xmath3 corresponding to a much coarser division of phase space . to be specific
, we consider the surface @xmath4 of constant energy and we suppose that the macrostates induce a finite partition @xmath5 of @xmath4 .
the different macroscopic values thus specify a ( finite ) number of regions in phase space .
we emphasize that this reduced description is in terms of macroscopic variables ( in contrast with the partitions as used e.g in constructions of dynamical entropies ) , such as position or velocity profiles and we denote by @xmath6 the corresponding phase space volume . + the boltzmann entropy ( also called boltzmann - planck - einstein or microcanonical or configurational entropy ) is , up to multiplicative and additive constants , defined by @xmath7 equals the thermodynamic entropy defined operationally by clausius . but also out of equilibrium , say when a constraint is lifted and the system is free to evolve , the boltzmann entropy remains relevant as it will typically increase towards equilibrium .
it gives in fact the microscopic foundation of the second law of thermodynamics .
+ there is another entropy that generalizes .
suppose we only specify a distribution of macrovalues .
this means that we do not know the exact macrostate , perhaps not even initially .
the statistics of macroscopic values is then given by a probability distribution @xmath8 ; e.g. our best guess about the position and velocity profile . in the absence of any further information
, there is a natural probability density , written @xmath9 , on @xmath4 which gives equal probability to each microstate compatible with a macrostate @xmath10 : @xmath11 the functional @xmath12 is appropriately called gibbs entropy as it is , since gibbs , the usual statistical mechanical entropy for constrained equilibrium is called the gibbs entropy of @xmath13 .
there is however another name for that functional : the shannon entropy .
a way out would be to call @xmath14 the boltzmann - gibbs - shannon entropy as in @xcite but that sounds overdone . ] .
put differently , by gibbs variational principle , @xmath15 where the supremum is taken over all phase space densities @xmath13 with the same macro - statistics as @xmath16 , i.e. , the projection @xmath17 of @xmath13 on @xmath18 coincides with @xmath19 : @xmath20 and the supremum is reached for @xmath21 .
equivalently , by a simple calculation , the gibbs entropy equals @xmath22 obviously , if @xmath16 concentrates on just one macrostate @xmath10 , @xmath23 , then @xmath24 which is the boltzmann entropy for that macrostate .
more generally , the first term in is the expected or estimated entropy , being unsure as we are about the exact macrostate .
the second term in is non - negative and is most often negligible , certainly upon dividing by the number of particles .
+ when we start the system from a microstate that is randomly drawn ( according to the liouville measure ) from @xmath10 with probability @xmath25 and we record the statistics @xmath26 on the macrostates after time @xmath27 , then , always , @xmath28 this is not the second law ( e.g. it does not imply that @xmath29 is non - decreasing in @xmath27 , see @xcite for more discussion ) . to bring it closer to the second law
, one needs to explain under what conditions @xmath29 approximates the boltzmann entropy @xmath30 with @xmath31 the time - evolved phase point .
looking back at the first term in , that implies understanding how and when the empirical distribution for the macrovariables becomes peaked , as the number of particles increases , at a fixed macroscopic trajectory as described e.g. by hydrodynamic equations of irreversible thermodynamics .
+ in @xcite we have discussed at length how these entropies relate to time - reversal .
the main result there was that both for closed systems and for open systems , be it in the transient regime or in the steady state regime , the entropy production equals the source term of time - reversal breaking in the action functional for the distribution of the histories ( on some thermodynamic scale ) of the system .
this representation gives the entropy production as a function of the trajectories and it allows simple manipulations for taking the average ( to prove that it is positive ) and for studying its fluctuations ( to understand symmetries under time - reversal ) . in the present paper
we begin explaining a similar reasoning for finite quantum systems .
we take the simplest mathematical set - up for describing a quantum system within conventional quantum mechanics .
we denote by @xmath32 the hilbert space of the system , assumed finite dimensional .
the system is described in terms of a wavefunction @xmath33 , or perhaps better , a normalized vector in @xmath32 .
the variables defining the macrostate are not different from that in the classical situation . for example , they specify ( again to some appropriate accuracy ) the particle number and the momentum profiles by associating numbers to a family of macroscopically small but microscopically large regions of the volume occupied by the system .
therefore , the macrostate is given in terms of the values of a set of macroscopic observables represented by commuting operators . the macroscopic partition in the classical case above is replaced by the orthogonal decomposition @xmath34 into linear subspaces .
the macrovariables are represented by the projections @xmath35 on the respective @xmath36 i d .
we write @xmath37 for the dimension of @xmath38 ; it is the analogue of the phase space volume @xmath6 in the classical case .
we can think of the macrostates as labeled by the running index @xmath39 . for a given macrostate @xmath39 represented by the projection @xmath35 above
, we stretch the notation of and write its boltzmann entropy as @xmath40 so far , the above does not depart essentially from the classical set - up except for the important difference that is defined on microstates and is defined on macrostates . at this moment the treatment starts to differ . following von neumann , page 411 in his well - known book @xcite , as discussed e.g. in @xcite ,
the formula is changed to @xmath41 where @xmath42 is the probability of finding the system described via the wavefunction @xmath33 in the macrostate @xmath39 ( values corresponding to @xmath38 ) .
observe that very much resembles , eventhough is the quantum analogue of , both defined as they are for the microstate .
the reason is of course quantum mechanics itself : the wavefunction can still correspond to different ( mutually exclusive ) macrostates . if not initially , still later in time , superpositions in terms of wavefunctions of different macrostates are possible .
this in contrast with the classical set - up where a unique macrostate is associated to each microstate .
just as the second term in the classical arises from additional uncertainty as to the exact macrostate , here , even when the microstate is given ( in terms of @xmath33 ) , we still have a distribution on the macrostates . instead of taking a pure state in ,
we may want to consider the system in a mixed state and described by a density matrix .
in fact , as we are interested in the thermodynamic time - evolution , we construct a special class of density matrices by specifying the macroscopic statistics just as we did for .
we thus start from a probability distribution @xmath43 on the possible macrovalues and we randomize within .
more precisely , we consider density matrices @xmath44 defined by @xmath45 for given @xmath46
. then , @xmath47\ ] ] is the probability to find the system in macrostate @xmath39 . for the choice @xmath48 where , for normalization , @xmath49 is the dimension of @xmath32 , @xmath50 id@xmath51 .
+ in the other direction , given a general density matrix @xmath52 , we can take its projection @xmath53 on the macroscopic states : @xmath54\ ] ] and of course , @xmath55 .
we now apply the same principle as in to obtain the ( gibbs - von neumann ) quantum entropy @xmath56\ ] ] with solution ( reached at @xmath57 ) @xmath58 which looks exactly like .
again , @xmath59 equals @xmath60 when @xmath43 concentrates on the macrostate @xmath39 and , up to some irrelevant constants , @xmath59 equals the relative entropy of @xmath44 with respect to the equilibrium density matrix id@xmath51 .
+ more generally , we call @xmath61 \log d_\alpha - \sum_\alpha \mbox { tr } [ p_\alpha\ , \rho]\,\log \mbox{tr } [ p_\alpha\ , \rho]\ ] ] the macroscopic quantum entropy of the ( mixed ) state @xmath52 , reducing to for the choice and to for a pure state .
the goal of this section is to show that the total change of entropy under a quantum conservative evolution , that is the entropy production , can be given in terms of a logarithmic ratio of probabilities .
we suppose a quantum dynamics generated via a real hamiltonian @xmath62 .
this means that the hamiltonian is time - reversal invariant , @xmath63 where @xmath64 is an anti - linear involution ( kinematical time - reversal ) which would be just complex conjugation for wavefunctions .
the unitary evolution @xmath65 $ ] where @xmath27 is time ( and planck s constant is set equal to one ) then satisfies @xmath66 an expression of dynamic reversibility .
we also assume that the macrostates are mapped into each other via the involution @xmath64 , i.e. , @xmath67 for some @xmath68 , for each @xmath39 and we write @xmath69 .
let the system be initially prepared with macro - statistics @xmath44 , see .
we now leave the system alone , undergoing its quantum evolution . the probability to see the system at the initial time in macrostate @xmath70 and at time @xmath27 in macrostate @xmath71 is given by @xmath72 = \mbox{tr } [ u(t)p_{\alpha_0}\rho(\hat\mu)p_{\alpha_0 } u(t)^\star p_{\alpha_t}]\ ] ] its marginal at time @xmath27 is @xmath73 = \mbox{tr } [ u(t)\rho(\hat\mu ) u(t)^\star p_\alpha]\ ] ] we consider the logarithmic ratio of probabilities @xmath74}{\mbox{prob}_{\hat\mu_t\pi}[\pi\alpha_t , \pi\alpha_0]}\ ] ] where the denominator gives the probability of the time - reversed order of measurement results starting from @xmath75 with @xmath76 .
we make two observations .
first , when @xmath48 , then also at later times @xmath77 and moreover @xmath78 = \mbox{prob}_{\hat\mu_t}[\pi\alpha_t,\pi\alpha_0]\ ] ] expressing the time - reversal invariance when started from the time - invariant macro - statistics that assigns to macrostates probabilities proportional to the exponential of their boltzmann entropy , see . + secondly , for other choices of the initial macro - statistics , the @xmath79 of reproduces the change of entropy : @xmath80 where we recognize the change of boltzmann entropies in the first two terms . upon taking the expectation @xmath81 \ ,
r_{\hat\mu}(\alpha_0,\alpha_t ) = s(\hat\mu_t ) - s(\hat\mu)\ ] ] we recover the change in entropy .
note that @xmath82 defined in for @xmath83 , @xmath84 so that the right - hand side of is really the change of macroscopic quantum entropy under the unitary evolution .
the left - hand side of is a relative entropy , hence is non - negative .
in contrast with the classical evolution , the unitary evolution can be non - trivially interrupted by measurements that reduce the state . we follow here the theory of von neumann ( or , convential quantum mechanics ) that adds a dynamic interpretation to the projections .
we extend here the results of the previous section to include interactions with a measurement apparatus .
+ suppose that we start the system described by a density matrix @xmath52 at time 0 and that we measure the macroscopic value @xmath39 at time @xmath85 .
then , the new density matrix is @xmath86}\ ] ] where @xmath87 $ ] .
this reduction takes place with probability @xmath88\ ] ] we can generalize this to a sequence of measurements .
we consider a sequence of times @xmath89 ( evenly spaced for convenience ) .
a macroscopic trajectory @xmath90 assigns to each of these times a value for the macroscopic observables .
in short , @xmath91 with each @xmath92 being equal to some projection @xmath35 on the linear subspace @xmath38 of .
we consider the operator @xmath93 and , for a given density matrix @xmath52 on @xmath32 , the matrix @xmath94\ ] ] this resembles the correlation matrix that is used in the definition of quantum dynamical entropy , see p. 189 in @xcite , but again , here our partitioning corresponds to macrostates .
+ it is easy to verify that @xmath95 is non - negative and has trace one .
we call it the path - space density matrix .
+ @xmath95 depends on the initial density matrix @xmath52 and it also gives the probability to find the system after time @xmath96 of ( measurement-)free evolution in the macrostate @xmath39 : @xmath97\ ] ] where @xmath98 .
+ more importantly , the probability to measure the trajectory @xmath90 , i.e. , to see the system at the initial time in the macrostate represented by @xmath99 , at time @xmath100 in macrostate @xmath101 , and so on till time @xmath102 , is given by the diagonal element @xmath103 = \cal{d}_\rho(\omega,\omega)\ ] ] its marginal at time @xmath96 , @xmath104\ ] ] is the probability of macrostate @xmath39 when the unitary evolution was interrupted by @xmath105 measurements .
it equals in case @xmath106 . on trajectories ,
the time - reversal transformation @xmath107 is @xmath108 since the microscopic dynamics is time - reversal invariant , we immediately deduce that @xmath109 and it is easy to verify that for @xmath110 id@xmath51 in @xmath111 in particular , for with @xmath110 id@xmath51 , prob@xmath112=$ ] prob@xmath113 $ ] .
this identity has two related interpretations .
first , it is the expression of ( quantum ) detailed balance or microscopic reversibility for the trajectories sampled from the time - invariant density matrix id@xmath51 corresponding to equilibrium .
it is the generalization of .
secondly , it generalizes the observation of @xcite that measurements do not introduce a time - asymmetric element ( or , the reduction of the wave packet does not lead to irreversibility ) .
+ yet , in general , the system could start in a nonequilibrium state and evolve towards equilibrium .
this involves a change of entropy ; that is , for closed and thermally isolated systems , its total entropy production .
+ the time - reversal of the density matrix @xmath95 , written @xmath114 , is defined as @xmath115 so that by , @xmath116 .
this last equality is broken for a general @xmath117 and it seems natural to estimate this breaking via the relative entropy @xmath118\ ] ] in view of the classical results of @xcite , it is to be expected that this relative entropy is related to the entropy production for the appropriate choices of @xmath119 ( as initial state ) and of @xmath120 ( as time - reversal of the final state ) .
we start again from @xmath43 as initial probability distribution ( i.e. , @xmath44 is the initial density matrix ) and the final probability distribution @xmath121 is defined in .
the main result is now readily obtained starting with the analogue of : the logarithmic ratio of probabilities of a macroscopic trajectory , one started from @xmath43 and the other started from @xmath122 , is abbreviated as @xmath123}{\mbox{prob}_{\hat\mu_t\pi}[\theta\omega]}\ ] ] this object will not always be well - defined for all @xmath90 .
we can suppose however that the @xmath124 so that a little calculation of yields @xmath125 in the notation of , the first difference in the right - hand side of equals the change of boltzmann entropy @xmath126 for a trajectory that starts in macrostate @xmath70 and ends in macrostate @xmath71 . if the system is initially prepared in essentially one macrostate , @xmath127 , and if the evolution on the level of macrostates is quasi - autonomous till time @xmath27 in the sense that @xmath128 , then only that change in boltzmann entropies survives .
+ taking the expectation of , we get , similar as in , @xmath129\,r_{\hat\mu}(\omega ) = s(\hat\mu_t ) - s(\hat\mu ) \geq 0\ ] ] equal to the change of quantum entropy .
the non - negativity follows from jensen s inequality applied to the left - hand side of .
+ one can easily check that this expectation ( the left - hand side of ) and hence , the change of quantum entropy ( the right - hand side of ) , also coincides with the relative entropy on the level of density matrices for trajectories @xmath130\ ] ] as announced in .
entropy production , also for the quantum situation , has been under intense investigation in recent years .
a list of related references , even restricted to the last 5 years would soon fill an extra couple of pages . in the classical case ,
there have been essentially two types of approaches , dynamical versus statistical . in the dynamical approach ,
entropy production is connected with the fractal or singular nature of a class of natural stationary measures .
a key - notion is the phase space contraction rate and with some extrapolations , nonequilibrium statistical mechanics becomes a branch of the theory of smooth dynamical systems .
it was partially motivated by numerical work and it has given wonderful insights , guiding towards a study of fluctuations of the entropy production , possibly generalizing close to equilibrium relations .
the statistical approach emphasizes the sharp contrast between the microscopic and macroscopic scales and stochasticity enters the dynamical evolutions because of the reduced description . on space - time
the histories have a distribution that share the essential properties of gibbs measures .
the entropy production can then be identified with the source term of time - reversal breaking in the action ( or space - time lagrangian ) of the space - time distribution ; the gibbs formalism reproduces and extends the results for the fluctuations of the entropy production obtained in the purely dynamical approach .
the projections on equal time surfaces reproduce the time - evolved measure . in the quantum case
, the modern dynamical approach does not seem to have a natural generalization .
instead , the old machinery of operator - algebra and spectral theory , directly applied on infinite volume systems , has been providing encouraging results for relaxation to equilibrium and the positivity of entropy production in driven quantum systems . again however , the conceptual framework and the essential distinction between microstates and macro - statistics is , at least to our taste , most often blurred in non - intuitive dynamical assumptions and in the heavy mathematical formalism .
the present paper offers an alternative and starts the statistical approach for quantum systems .
the first step indeed is to be quite clear as to the relation between time - reversal and entropy production . as in the classical case
, we consider this important for constructing nonequilibrium statistical mechanics .
specifically , we hope that the characterizations of and will prove useful for deriving general fluctuation and response identities going beyond close to equilibrium .
+ we add some general remarks . \1 . for reversible systems
the entropy production is a state function .
it does not depend on the actual path but can be written as a difference of the same quantity evaluated at the initial and the final time , see or .
this can be different for driven or irreversible systems .
a similar treatment for such systems in the classical regime can be found in @xcite .
one of the main consequences of the identities that correspond there to or is that certain symmetries in the fluctuations of the entropy production rate are easily established .
the quantum case is in preparation .
nothing of the previous mathematical identities depends on the assumption that the system is large , of macroscopic size , containing a huge number of particles . of course , to meaningfully discuss macroscopic variables or macrostates and their trajectories
one has in mind a clear separation between micro and macro scales but the results of sections 2 and 3 are true without . yet again , their interpretation as thermodynamic entropy production and the relation with the second law can only be made when dealing with macroscopic systems .
see also appendix a in @xcite for these considerations in the classical case .
the use of the projections @xmath35 in the construction of the path - space density matrix of section [ psm ] refers to the so called von neumann measurements .
one can imagine more _ fuzzy _ measurements ( and more rounded - off macrostates ) and a corresponding decomposition of unity as @xmath131 the treatment above was restricted to the case @xmath132 .
this extension is very much related to the dynamics of open systems , see e.g. @xcite .
the involvement of measurements interrupting the unitary evolution already points to the interaction with the outside world .
the question of isolation , even as an idealization , of a quantum system is much more subtle than for a classical system . | we consider conservative quantum evolutions possibly interrupted by macroscopic measurements . when started in a nonequilibrium state , the resulting path - space measure is not time - reversal invariant and the weight of time - reversal breaking equals the exponential of the entropy production .
the mean entropy production can then be expressed via a relative entropy on the level of histories .
this gives a partial extension of the result for classical systems , that the entropy production is given by the source term of time - reversal breaking in the path - space measure .
, , , , quantum systems , entropy production , time - reversal 05.30.ch , 05.70.ln |
the increased interest in the field of spin electronics attracts strong attention to the magnetic systems suitable for the realization of spin injection into a semiconductor @xcite .
the heusler alloys are considered as a promising class of materials that can possess the necessary combination of properties . among the features useful for applications
are high curie temperature , high electron spin polarization at the fermi level and very small lattice mismatch with widely employed semiconductors @xcite . some of the heusler compounds were found to have half - metallic ground state @xcite characterized by a 100% spin - polarization of the charge carriers .
an interesting combination of physical properties makes heusler alloys the subject of intensive experimental and theoretical investigations @xcite . in full heusler compounds characterized by
the formula x@xmath0yz the mn atoms usually enter as the y element .
the compounds where mn assumes the x positions are very rare . up to our knowledge
there are only two systems of this type studied experimentally : mn@xmath0val @xcite and mn@xmath0vga @xcite .
mn@xmath0val received much experimental and theoretical attention .
the neutron diffraction experiment by itoh et al . @xcite gave the ferrimagnetic state of compound with mn magnetic moment of @xmath1 and v moment @xmath2 .
jiang _ _ e__t al .
examined the magnetic structure of mn@xmath0val by x - ray diffraction and magnetization measurements @xcite .
they found that mn@xmath0val was nearly half - metallic with the total magnetic moment of 1.94@xmath3 at 5 k. the curie temperature of the sample was found to be about 760 k and the loss of half - metallic character was attributed to the small amount of disorder .
the electron structure calculation by ishida _
performed within the local - density approximation ( lda ) to the density functional theory resulted in a ground state of mn@xmath0val close to half - metallicity @xcite . recently a detailed theoretical study of the magnetism of mn@xmath0val was reported by weht and pickett @xcite who used the generalized gradient approximation ( gga ) for the exchange correlation potential and have shown that mn@xmath0val is a half - metallic ferrimagnet with the atomic moments of 1.5@xmath3 and -0.9@xmath3 on mn and v in very good agreement with experiment .
the fermi level was found to lie in the minority spin band .
the main purpose of the present work is a detailed study of the exchange interactions in two half - metallic mn@xmath0vz compounds : mn@xmath0val and mn@xmath0vge .
( mn@xmath0vge is not yet synthesized .
its half - metallicity is predicted theoretically @xcite . )
both intra - sublattice and inter - sublattice exchange interactions are calculated .
we show that the pattern of exchange interactions in these systems deviates from the physical picture that can be expected on the basis of the experimental information available .
indeed , the mn - mn distance of 2.96(3.04 ) in mn@xmath0val ( mn@xmath0vge ) is substantially smaller than the mn - mn distance of about 4 in the x@xmath0mnz - type heusler alloys @xcite .
( for mn@xmath0vge we use the interatomic distance of mn@xmath0vga @xcite ) . on the other hand
, it is comparable with the mn - mn distance in the antiferromagnetic fcc mn ( 2.73 ) @xcite . according to the bethe - slater curve @xcite
there are physical reasons to expect that smaller distances between the 3d atoms stimulate the formation of the antiferromagnetic structure whereas larger distances make the ferromagnetic structure energetically preferable . among the heusler alloys ,
a smaller distance between pairs of the mn atoms is obtained in the case of random occupation by mn and z atoms of the y and z sublattices ( see , e.g. , the system with the b2-type crystal structure in ref .
@xcite ) . indeed
, the experiment gives for such systems the antiferromagnetic ordering @xcite .
therefore in the case of mn@xmath0val an antiferromagnetism of the two mn sublattices can be expected .
our study shows , however , that the situation is more complex . the nearest - neighbor ( nn ) mn mn exchange interaction is found to be ferromagnetic whereas the next nn mn
mn interaction is antiferromagnetic . as a result
the contributions of different mn atoms into the exchange field experienced by a given mn atom compensate strongly not giving substantial contribution into the curie temperature .
the main role in the formation of the magnetic structure and the magnetic transition temperature is played by the strong mn v exchange interaction .
we show that also in mn@xmath0vge the ferromagnetic ordering of the mn subsystem is governed by the mn v exchange interaction . the paper is organized as follows . in section
ii we present the calculational approach .
section iii contains the results of the calculations and discussion .
section iv gives the conclusions .
the calculations are carried out with the augmented spherical waves ( asw ) method @xcite within the generalized gradient approximation ( gga ) @xcite for the exchange correlation potential .
we use the experimental lattice parameter of mn@xmath0val @xcite .
the radii of all atomic spheres are chosen equal .
we describe the interatomic exchange interactions in terms of the classical heisenberg hamiltonian @xmath4 in eq.([eq : hamiltonian2 ] ) , the indices @xmath5 and @xmath6 label different sublattices and @xmath7 and @xmath8 are the lattice vectors specifying the atoms within sublattices , @xmath9 is the unit vector pointing in the direction of the magnetic moment at site @xmath10 . the systems considered contain three 3_d _ atoms in the unit cell ( see fig.[crystal_structure ] ) .
we employ the frozen magnon approach @xcite to calculate interatomic heisenberg exchange parameters .
the calculations involve few steps . in the first step ,
the exchange parameters between the atoms of a given sublattice @xmath5 are computed .
the calculation is based on the evaluation of the energy of the frozen magnon configurations defined by the following atomic polar and azimuthal angles @xmath11 the constant phase @xmath12 is always chosen equal to zero .
the magnetic moments of all other sublattices are kept parallel to the z axis . within the heisenberg model ( [ eq : hamiltonian2 ] )
the energy of such configuration takes the form @xmath13 where @xmath14 does not depend on * q * and the fourier transform @xmath15 is defined by @xmath16 in the case of @xmath17 the sum in eq .
( [ eq : j_q ] ) does not include @xmath18 . calculating @xmath19 for a regular @xmath20mesh in the brillouin zone of the crystal and performing back fourier transformation one gets exchange parameters @xmath21 for sublattice @xmath5 .
the determination of the exchange interactions between the atoms of two different sublattices @xmath5 and @xmath6 is discussed in ref .
@xcite . structure .
the lattice consists of four interpenetrating fcc sublattices with the positions @xmath22 and @xmath23 for the mn and @xmath24 and @xmath25 for the v and z , respectively . ]
.magnetic moments ( in @xmath3 ) of mn@xmath0vz ( z= al , ge ) .
@xmath26 is the lattice parameter ( in ) . [
cols="<,<,<,<,<,<,<",options="header " , ]
in conclusion , we have systematically studied exchange interactions and curie temperatures in two half metallic ferrimagnetic full heusler alloys mn@xmath0vz ( z= al , ge ) .
the calculations are performed within the parameter
free density functional theory .
we show that various mn mn exchange interactions compensate each other and the ferromagnetism of the mn subsystem
is favored by very strong antiferromagnetic mn v interactions .
good agreement with experiment is obtained for the curie temperature of mn@xmath0val .
we give prediction for the curie temperature of mn@xmath0vge . the financial support of bundesministerium fr bildung und forschung is acknowledged .
h. ohno , science * 281 * , 951 ( 1998 ) .
p. j. webster and k. r. a. ziebeck , in _ alloys and compounds of d - elements with main group elements _ , part 2 , edited by h. r. j. wijn , landolt - brnstein , new series , group iii , vol .
19/c ( springer , berlin , 1988 ) , pp .
75 - 184 . to our knowledge
, mn@xmath0vge has not been studied experimentally .
we perform calculations of mn@xmath0vge using the lattice constants of mn@xmath0val and mn@xmath0vga . in the lattice constant of mn@xmath0vga we found it half metallic , while it was nearly half metallic with the lattice constant of mn@xmath0val .
we will present the results of calculation for the former case .
p. w. anderson , _ theory of magnetic exchange interactions : exchange in insulators and semiconductors _ , in _ solid state physics _ , edited by f. seitz and turnbull ( academic press , new york ) , vol . | we report the parameter - free , density functional theory calculations of interatomic exchange interactions and curie temperatures of half - metallic ferrimagnetic full heusler alloys mn@xmath0vz ( z = al , ge ) . to calculate the interatomic exchange interactions we employ the frozen - magnon approach .
the curie temperatures are calculated within the mean field approximation to the classical heisenberg hamiltonian by solving a matrix equation for a multi - sublattice system .
our calculations show that , although a large magnetic moment is carried by mn atoms , competing ferromagnetic ( inter sublattice ) and antiferromagnetic ( intra sublattice ) mn - mn interactions in mn@xmath0val almost cancel each other in the mean - field experienced by the mn atoms . in mn@xmath0vge
the leading mn - mn exchange interaction is antiferromagnetic . in both compounds
the ferromagnetism of the mn subsystem is favored by strong antiferromagnetic mn - v interactions .
the obtained value of the curie temperature of mn@xmath0val is in good agrement with experiment .
for mn@xmath0vge there is no experimental information available and our calculation is a prediction . |
the deep inelastic lepton - nucleon scattering ( dis ) process , in which a point - like lepton probes a single , initial state hadron , is an ideal environment in which to study quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) , and constrain the parton distribution functions ( pdfs ) of the proton .
the hera collider ceased running in june 2007 , following 15 years of successful operation .
during hera i running ( 1992 - 2000 ) , the h1 and zeus experiments each collected approximately @xmath3 @xmath4 of @xmath0 and @xmath5 @xmath4 of @xmath1 data .
this has allowed precision measurements of inclusive neutral ( nc ) and charged ( cc ) current dis cross sections , which have already proved fundamental to the rapid development in understanding of qcd and the structure of the proton . in these proceedings , a joint h1 and zeus analysis
is presented , in which previously published nc and cc inclusive dis cross section measurements from the two collider experiments are combined . the combination method @xcite uses an iterative @xmath6 minimisation , which carefully takes into account the correlations within the data that result from different sources of uncertainty .
the key assumption is that the measurements from h1 and zeus represent a common truth .
thus , forcing them to agree results in a strong constraint which cross - calibrates the measurements , resulting in significantly reduced overall uncertainties .
the combined hera data have subsequently been used as the sole input to a next - to - leading ( nlo ) qcd fit to determine the proton pdfs .
this analysis is also discussed in the present contribution .
the results on the combined hera data , as presented here , were first released to the lp conference in 2007 @xcite , and the nlo qcd analysis was first presented at dis 2008 @xcite .
both analyses should be seen as part of a mid - term strategy .
they will be followed by future data combinations , including even more accurate data from both hera i and hera ii , and by further qcd analyses to extract the proton pdfs .
lepton - proton dis can proceed either via the neutral current ( nc ) interaction ( through the exchange of a @xmath7 or @xmath8 ) , or via the charged current ( cc ) interaction ( through the exchange of a @xmath9 ) .
the kinematics of lepton - proton dis are described in terms of the bjorken scaling variable , @xmath10 , the negative invariant mass squared of the exchanged vector boson , @xmath11 , and the fraction of energy transferred from the lepton to the proton system ( in the rest frame of the proton ) , @xmath12 .
the three quantities are related by @xmath13 , where @xmath14 is the centre - of - mass energy squared . at leading order ( lo ) in the electroweak interaction , the reduced cross section , @xmath15 , for the @xmath16 nc dis process
can be expressed in terms of proton structure functions , @xmath17 where @xmath18 is the fine structure constant and @xmath19 describes the helicity dependence of the electroweak interaction .
the structure functions , which depend on @xmath2 , are directly related to pdfs of the proton , and their @xmath11 dependence is predicted by perturbative qcd . in particular ,
@xmath20 and @xmath21 depend directly on the quark distributions . for @xmath22 @xmath23 ,
@xmath20 dominates the @xmath24 scattering cross section and for @xmath25 , @xmath20 itself is dominated by sea quarks while the @xmath11 dependence is driven by gluon radiation .
@xmath20 has been measured over 4 orders of magnitude in @xmath2 , to a precision of @xmath26 at hera i. therefore , hera data have already provided vital information on the sea - quarks and gluon at low @xmath10 . at high @xmath27 ,
the contribution from @xmath21 becomes increasingly significant and gives information on the valence quarks . at lo ,
the cc cross sections are given by , @xmath28 ~~ \nonumber \\
\frac{{\rm d}^2\sigma_{\rm cc}^{e^{-}p}}{{\rm d}x{\rm d}q^2 } = \frac{g_f^2m_w^4}{2\pi(q^2+m_w^2)^2 } \left [ { u}+{c}+(1-y)^2(\bar{d}+\bar{s } ) \right ] ~~ \nonumber \vspace{-0.2 cm } \label{eqn : cc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] so that a measurement of the @xmath0 and @xmath1 cross sections provides information on the @xmath29- and @xmath30-valence quarks , respectively , thereby allowing the separation of flavour .
in this section , the joint h1 and zeus combined data analysis is described .
the goal of the study is to obtain dis cross sections of best possible accuracy in order produce precise extractions of the proton pdfs .
a new nlo qcd analysis , in which the results of the combination are used as the sole input , is described in sec . [
sec : qcdanalysis ] .
the averaging procedure uses the lagrange multiplier ( or hessian ) method @xcite .
the only theoretical input to the combination is that there is a true value of the cross section for each process , at each @xmath2 value @xcite .
the correlated systematic uncertainties are floated coherently such that each experiment calibrates the other one .
this results in a significant reduction of the correlated systematic uncertainty over much of the kinematic plane . in the combination procedure , the following probability distribution of a measurement quantity , @xmath31 , represented as a @xmath6 function , is minimised : @xmath32 ^ 2}{\delta_i^2 } + \sum_j \frac{\alpha_j^2}{\delta^2_{\alpha_j}}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath33 are the measured central values , and @xmath34 are the statistical and uncorrelated systematic uncertainties of the quantity @xmath31 .
the @xmath35 are their true values ; @xmath36 are parameters for the @xmath37 sources of systematic uncertainty and @xmath38 denotes the sensitivity of point @xmath39 to source @xmath37 . for the cross section measurements ,
the index @xmath39 labels a particular measurement at a given @xmath2 .
equation [ eqn : chi2 ] represents the correlated probability distribution function for the quantity @xmath35 and for the systematic uncertainties @xmath36 .
the @xmath6 defined in eq .
[ eqn : chi2 ] has , by construction , a minimum @xmath40 for @xmath41 and @xmath42 .
the total uncertainty for @xmath35 determined from the formal minimisation of eq .
[ eqn : chi2 ] is equal to the quadratic sum of the statistical and systematic uncertainties .
the covariance matrix cov(@xmath43 ) quantifies the correlation between experimental points . in the analysis of more than one data set , a total @xmath6 function , @xmath44 ,
is constructed from the sum of the @xmath6 functions for each data set .
the @xmath44 function can be minimised with respect to @xmath35 and @xmath36 : this minimisation corresponds to a generalisation of the averaging procedure which takes account of correlations between different data sets . [ cols="<,>,<,>,<,>,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the hera combined @xmath16 nc and cc inclusive data , described in sec . [
sec : combineddata ] , have been used as the experimental input to the present qcd analysis in that only data with @xmath45 were transformed in @xmath46 . ] .
the consistency of the combined hera data set , as well as its small systematic uncertainties , allow the experimental uncertainties on the pdfs to be calculated using a @xmath6 tolerance of @xmath47 .
this is compared to previous global fits where increased tolerances of @xmath48 have been used in order to account for data inconsistencies .
for the present qcd fit , the role of correlated systematics is no longer crucial since the uncertainties are relatively small . in particular
, this means that similar results are obtained whether the correlated systematic uncertainties are treated using the offset or hessian method in the qcd fit , or by simply combining statistical and systematic uncertainties in quadrature .
for the central fit the choice was made to combine the 43 systematic uncertainties ( resulting from the separate h1 and zeus data sets ) in quadrature and to offset the 4 sources of uncertainty which arise from the combination procedure .
this was found to result in the most conservative uncertainty estimate on the extracted pdfs . despite the conservative procedure adopted , as mentioned above , the experimental uncertainties on the resulting pdfs were still found to be impressively small . therefore , a thorough consideration of further uncertainties due to model assumptions was necessary . for the present analysis ,
six sources of model uncertainty were considered , as listed in tab .
[ tab : model ] .
the parameters were varied up and down from the central value , and the differences in the resulting pdfs from the central fit were added in quadrature to the total experimental pdf uncertainty .
further cross checks were also performed .
in particular , the dependence on the choice of parameterisation was investigated by repeating the fit using the h1-style @xcite and zeus - style @xcite parameterisations .
all fits gave acceptable @xmath6 and were found to be consistent with each other .
note , however , that the parameterisation chosen for the central fit ( described in sec . [ sec : qcdfit - analysis ] ) gave the best @xmath6 as well as the most conservative experimental uncertainties .
the nlo qcd analysis described above has been named the herapdf0.1 fit .
figure [ fig : nccc - herafit ] shows the results of the hera fit superimposed on the combined high-@xmath11 nc and cc @xmath16 data sets , showing the excellent description of the data by the hera pdfs .
figure [ fig : herapdf ] shows the herapdf0.1 pdfs @xmath49 , @xmath50 , @xmath51 ( total sea ) and @xmath52 as a function of @xmath10 at @xmath53 @xmath23 and @xmath54 @xmath23 .
fractional uncertainty bands are shown beneath each plot , with the experimental and model uncertainties being shown separately .
the variation of the strange fraction , @xmath55 , dominates the model uncertainty on the sea , while variations of @xmath56 and @xmath57 dominate those on the gluon and valence quarks .
comparison of the results for @xmath53 @xmath23 and @xmath54 @xmath23 shows that , as @xmath11 increases , the pdf uncertainties become impressively small .
the summary plots shown in fig .
[ fig : herapdfsummary ] illustrate that the total uncertainty of the pdfs obtained from the hera combined data set is much reduced compared to the those of the pdfs extracted from separate analyses of the h1 and zeus data sets .
the dramatic improvement is a result of the data combination .
figure [ fig : globalpdfs ] compares the herapdf 0.1 pdfs to those of the cteq6.1 @xcite and mrst01 @xcite global fits confidence level , while the global fits show a @xmath58 confidence level band . ] .
the results indicate that the precision of the herapdf0.1 pdfs for the low @xmath10 sea and gluon is impressive .
a new , model - independent method of combining cross section measurements has been presented , in which a coherent treatment of systematics results in a substantial reduction in the overall uncertainties .
the method has been demonstrated on the complete set of published hera i nc and cc inclusive dis data .
the combined hera data have subsequently been included in a new nlo qcd analysis .
the consistent treatment of systematic uncertainties in the combined data set ensures that the experimental uncertainties on the pdfs can be calculated without need for an increased @xmath6 tolerance .
this results in pdfs with greatly reduced experimental uncertainties compared to separate analyses of data from the h1 and zeus experiments .
model uncertainties have also been carefully considered .
the resulting pdfs ( called herapdf0.1 ) have impressive precision .
they are now publicly available in lhapdf @xcite ( v5.6 onwards ) .
high statistics data from the hera ii running period are being analysed by the two collaborations and will be included in subsequent analyses devoted to precision determinations of the proton parton densities .
i would like to thank the organisers of ringberg 2008 for a very productive and enjoyable workshop , the members of the hera combined structure function working group for useful information and comments , and the uk science and technology facilities council for support .
9 s. glazov , proceedings of dis 2005 , aip conf .
proc . * 792 * , 237 ( 2005 ) .
h1 and zeus collaboration , h1prelim-07 - 007 , zeus - prel-07 - 036 .
a. m. cooper - sarkar , proceedings of dis08 , doi:10.3360/dis.2008.25 .
c. pascaud and f. zomer , lal preprint , lal/95 - 05 ( 1995 ) , c. pascaud and f. zomer , hep - ph/0104013 .
j. feltesse , proceedings of dis 2008 , doi:10.3360/dis.2008.24 .
, c. adloff et al . , eur .
j. * c 21 * , 33 ( 2001 ) .
, c. adloff et al . , eur .
j. * c 13 * , 609 ( 2000 ) .
, c. adloff et al .
j. * c 19 * , 269 ( 2001 ) .
, c. adloff et al .
j. * c 30 * , 1 ( 2003 ) .
zeus coll .
, s. chekanov et al . , eur .
j. * c 21 * , 443 ( 2001 ) .
zeus coll .
, j. breitwig et al . , eur .
j. * c 12 * , 411 ( 2000 ) [ erratum - ibid .
* c 27 * , 305 ( 2003 ) ] .
zeus coll .
, s. chekanov et al . , eur .
j. * c 28 * , 175 ( 2003 ) .
zeus coll .
, s. chekanov et al . , phys .
* b 539 * , 197 ( 2002 ) .
zeus coll .
, s. chekanov et al . , phys . rev .
* d 70 * , 052001 ( 2004 ) .
zeus coll .
, s. chekanov et al . , eur .
j. * c 32 * , 1 ( 2003 ) . | previously published data on inclusive neutral and charged current @xmath0 and @xmath1 deep inelastic scattering from hera have been combined .
the new , model - independent method of combining the measured cross sections takes full account of correlated systematics in a coherent way , leading to significantly reduced uncertainties in the combined measurement across the @xmath2 plane .
the combined cross section data have been used as the sole input for a new next - to - leading order qcd fit to extract the parton distribution functions ( pdfs ) of the proton .
the pdfs extracted have greatly reduced experimental uncertainties , compared to separate qcd analyses on data from h1 and zeus .
model uncertainties , including those arising from the parameterisation dependence , have also been carefully considered .
the resulting hera pdfs have impressive precision . |
the main consequence of inflation is the generation of primordial cosmological perturbations @xcite and the production of long wavelength gravitational waves ( tensor perturbations ) @xcite .
the predicted slightly red - tilted spectrum of the scalar perturbations is at present in excellent agreement with the measurements of the cmb fluctuations @xcite .
the detection of a small deviation of the spectrum from flat together with the observation of primordial gravitational waves would make us completely confident in early - time cosmic acceleration .
the detection of primordial gravitational waves is not easy , but they can be seen indirectly in the b - mode of the cmb polarization ( see , for example , @xcite ) . in standard slow - roll inflationary scenarios
@xcite the amplitude of the tensor perturbations can , in principle , be large enough to be discovered .
however , it is only on the border of detectability in future experiments .
there is no problem to modify the inflationary scenarios in a way to suppress the tensor component produced during inflation . in particular , in models such as new inflation @xcite and hybrid inflation @xcite , tensor perturbations are typically small @xcite .
moreover , in the curvaton scenario @xcite and k - inflation @xcite , they can be suppressed completely .
an interesting question is whether the gravitational waves can be significantly enhanced compared to our naive expectations .
recently it was argued that the contribution of tensor perturbations to the cmb anisotropy can be much greater than expected @xcite .
however , it was found in @xcite that in the models considered in bartolo:2005jg , sloth:2005yx one can not avoid the production of too large scalar perturbations and therefore they are in contradiction with observations .
it is also possible to produce blue - tilted spectrum of gravitational waves in a so - called superinflation @xcite , which is , however , plagued by graceful exit problem . at present
there exists no inflationary model with graceful exit where the b - mode of polarization would exceed that predicted by simple chaotic inflation .
the purpose of our paper is to show that such models can be easily constructed even within the class of simple slow - roll inflationary scenarios if we allow a nontrivial dependence of the lagrangian on the kinetic term .
these models resemble k - inflation with only difference that here inflation is due to the potential term in the lagrangian .
the generic action describing a scalar field interacting with the gravitational field is@xmath0 , \label{1}\]]where @xmath1 is the ricci scalar and @xmath2 is a function of the scalar field @xmath3 and its first derivatives @xmath4we use planck units , where @xmath5 in the case of the usual scalar field the @xmath6dependence of @xmath7 is trivial , namely , @xmath8 while k - inflation and k - essence k - inflation , k - essence , book are based on the non - trivial dependence of @xmath7 on @xmath9 for @xmath10 , variation of the action ( [ 1 ] ) with respect to the metric gives the energy momentum tensor for the scalar field in the form of an ideal hydrodynamical fluid : @xmath11here the lagrangian @xmath2 plays the role of pressure , the energy density is given by @xmath12where @xmath13 and the four - velocity is@xmath14 let us consider a spatially flat friedmann universe with small perturbations : @xmath15 dx^{i}dx^{k } , \label{4}\]]where @xmath16 is the gravitational potential characterizing scalar metric perturbations and @xmath17 is a traceless , transverse perturbations describing the gravitational waves .
the scale factor @xmath18 satisfies the friedmann equation@xmath19where the dot denotes the derivative with respect to time @xmath20 taking into account that for the homogeneous background scalar field @xmath21 and that the energy conservation law is @xmath22we obtain the following equation for the scalar field@xmath23where the speed of sound is @xmath24 ^{-1 } .
\label{ss}\]]considering small scalar metric perturbations one can show that @xmath25 is in fact the speed of propagation of the cosmological perturbations @xcite .
the stability condition with respect to the high frequency cosmological perturbations requires @xmath26 .
it follows from ( [ 3 ] ) that inflation can be realized if the condition @xmath27 is satisfied for a sufficiently long time interval .
this can be done in two ways .
considering the canonical scalar field with @xmath28 , one can take a flat potential @xmath29 so that @xmath30 for more than 75 e - folds .
this is the standard slow - roll inflation @xcite and in this case @xmath31 the other possibility is the k - inflation @xcite , where @xmath7 is a weakly dependent function of @xmath32 , so that @xmath33 is small . here
inflation is entirely based on the kinetic term and it can take place even if the field is running very fast ( @xmath34 is large ) ; typically @xmath35 for k - inflation . in this paper we consider a slow - roll inflation with a flat potential but in theories with a nontrivial kinetic term .
to best of our knowledge this possibility has been ignored in the literature until now .
however such models are very interesting because , as we will see , they allow us to have @xmath36 during inflation and thus enhance the tensor - to - scalar ratio for the perturbations produced .
the lagrangian @xmath37 is manifestly lorentz - invariant and a superluminal speed of cosmological perturbations does not contradicts the principles of relativity .
in fact , the superluminal propagation is possible only in the presence of the time - dependent homogeneous scalar field , which determines a preferable coordinate frame . only in this frame
the speed can exceed the speed of light . as a result
no violation of causality is possible . for simplicity let us consider theories with lagrangian @xmath38 in this case @xmath39and the equation for scalar field becomes
@xmath40it is clear that if the slow - roll conditions @xmath41are satisfied for at least 75 e - folds then we have a successful slow - roll inflation due to the potential @xmath42 in contrast to ordinary slow - roll inflation one can arrange here practically any speed of sound @xmath43 by taking an appropriate kinetic term . for example , for@xmath44we obtain from ( [ ss])@xmath45and if @xmath46 , then @xmath47 therefore by considering nontrivial kinetic terms @xmath48 one can have , in principle , an arbitrarily large @xmath49 which thus becomes an additional free parameter of the theory .
the crucial point is that the amplitude of the final scalar perturbations ( during the postinflationary , radiation - dominated epoch ) depends on @xmath25 ( see , @xcite ) : @xmath50while the ratio of tensor to scalar amplitudes on supercurvature scales is given by @xmath51here it is worthwhile reminding that all physical quantities on the right hand side of eqs .
( [ scp ] ) and ( [ tsr ] ) have to be calculated during inflation at the moment when perturbations with wave number @xmath52 cross corresponding horizon : @xmath53 for ( [ scp ] ) and @xmath54 for ( [ tsr ] ) respectively .
the amplitude of the scalar perturbations @xmath55 is a free parameter of the theory which is taken to fit the observations .
therefore , in models where @xmath36 , the energy scale of inflation must be higher than in ordinary slow - roll inflation with canonical kinetic term .
moreover , it follows from ( [ tsr ] ) that the tensor - to - scalar ratio can be arbitrarily enhanced in such models .
as a concrete example from the class of theories with enhanced tensor contribution let us consider a simple model with lagrangian @xmath56 -\frac{% 1}{2}m^{2}\phi ^{2 } , \label{sm1}\]]where constant @xmath57 is a free parameter . for @xmath58
one recovers the lagrangian for the usual free scalar field .
the function @xmath7 is a monotonically growing concave function of @xmath59@xmath60and the corresponding energy density , @xmath61 + \frac{1}{2}m^{2}\phi ^{2 } , \label{sm2}\]]is always positive . the effective speed of sound,@xmath62is larger than the speed of light , approaching it as @xmath63 in the slow - roll regime and for @xmath7 given in ( [ sm1 ] ) , equations ( [ fe ] ) , ( [ esf ] ) simplify to@xmath64taking into account that @xmath65 , we infer that during inflation @xmath66 is constant and @xmath67the speed of sound @xmath68can be arbitrarily large during inflation if we take @xmath69 .
note , however , that @xmath70 is necessary for the existence of the slow - roll solution .
hereafter we will use @xmath71 as a parameter instead of @xmath72 .
one can easily find that during the slow - roll regime @xmath73and the pressure and energy density are given by @xmath74respectively .
the inflation is over when @xmath75becomes of order unity , that is , at @xmath76 after that the field @xmath3 begins to oscillate and decays .
the detailed analysis of dynamics and stability of the model will be given in @xcite .
here we restrict ourselves to illustration of the above analysis by a phase diagram fig .
[ phase ] obtained numerically .
[ bl]@xmath77 [ bl]@xmath78 [ bl]@xmath79 [ br]@xmath80 [ l]@xmath81 [ br]@xmath82 numerically obtained phase portrait for the system with the parameters @xmath83 , @xmath84 .
the field value @xmath85 corresponds to the end of acceleration when @xmath86 . ] to determine @xmath87 we use ( [ sm8 ] ) to rewrite the first equation in ( [ sm5 ] ) as@xmath88and obtain@xmath89where @xmath90 and @xmath91 are the values of the scale factor and the scalar field at the end of inflation .
given a number of e - folds before the end of inflation @xmath92 we find that at this time @xmath93and , hence , @xmath94does not depend on @xmath95 thus , for a given scale , which crosses the hubble scale @xmath96 e - folds before the end of inflation , the tensor - to - scalar ratio is @xmath97it is clear that by choosing @xmath57 close to the critical value @xmath98 we can have a very large @xmath71 and consequently enhance this ratio almost arbitrarily .
we have shown above that in theories where the lagrangian is a nontrivial , nonlinear function of the kinetic term , the scale of inflation can be pushed to a very high energies without coming into conflict with observations . as a result
, the amount of produced gravitational waves can be much larger than is usually expected . if such a situation were realized in nature then the prospects for the future detection of the b - mode of cmb polarization are greatly improved .
of course , the theories where this happens are somewhat fine - tuned .
namely , the corresponding lagrangian @xmath99 must generically satisfy the condition , @xmath100 during inflation . for the particular model ( [ sm1 ] ) this means that @xmath101 .
this fine - tuning of the parameters of the theory should not be confused , however , with the fine - tuning of the initial conditions .
in fact , the true theory of nature is unique and , for example , lagrangian ( [ sm1 ] ) , where @xmath102 is not very different from @xmath103 looks even more attractive because it has fewer free parameters .
therefore , future observations of the cmb fluctuations are extremely important since they will restrict the number of possible candidates for the inflaton .
the other peculiar properties of the generalized slow - roll inflation will be considered in @xcite .
we are grateful to matthew parry for very useful discussions and marco baldi , fabio finelli , sabino matarrese for useful correspondence .
a. d. linde and v. mukhanov , phys .
d * 56 * , 535 ( 1997 ) ; d. h. lyth and d. wands , phys .
b * 524 * , 5 ( 2002 ) ; d. h. lyth , c. ungarelli and d. wands , phys .
d * 67 * , 023503 ( 2003 ) ; d. h. lyth and d. wands , phys .
d * 68 * , 103516 ( 2003 ) ; k. dimopoulos , g. lazarides , d. lyth and r. ruiz de austri , phys.rev .
d * 68 * , 123515 ( 2003 ) ; b. a. bassett , s. tsujikawa and d. wands , arxiv : astro - ph/0507632 ; a. linde and v. mukhanov , arxiv : astro - ph/0511736 . | we show that in theories with a nontrivial kinetic term the contribution of the gravitational waves to the cmb fluctuations can be substantially larger than that is naively expected in simple inflationary models .
this increase of the tensor - to - scalar perturbation ratio leads to a larger b - component of the cmb polarization , thus making the prospects for future detection much more promising .
the other important consequence of the considered model is a higher energy scale of inflation and hence higher reheating temperature compared to a simple inflation .
lmu - asc 78/05 |
understanding the collective behaviour of quantum many - body systems remains a central topic in modern physics , as well as one of the greatest computational challenges in science .
quantum monte carlo sampling techniques are capable of addressing a large class of ( unfrustrated ) bosonic and spin lattice models , but fail when applied to other models such as frustrated antiferromagnets and interacting fermions due to the so - called sign problem .
variational approaches , on the other hand , are sign - problem free but are typically strongly biased towards specific many - body wavefunctions .
an important exception is given by the density matrix renormalization group,@xcite a variational approach based on the matrix product state ( mps),@xcite which is capable of providing an extremely accurate approximation to the ground state of most one - dimensional lattice models .
the success of dmrg is based on the fact that an mps can reproduce the structure of entanglement common to most ground states of one - dimensional lattice models . in order to extend the success of dmrg to other contexts ,
new tensor networks generalizing the mps have been proposed .
for instance , the multi - scale entanglement renormalization ansatz ( mera),@xcite with a network of tensors that extends in an additional direction corresponding to length scales , is particularly suited to address quantum critical systems .
most significant has also been the proposal of tensor networks for systems in two and higher dimensions , where the mps becomes inefficient .
scalable tensor networks include the projected entangled - pair states peps@xcite ( a direct generalization of the mps to larger dimensions ) and higher dimensional versions of the mera.@xcite they can be used to address frustrated antiferromagnets and interacting fermions , since they are free of the sign problem experienced by quantum monte carlo approaches . in a tensor network state , the size of the tensors is measured by the bond dimension @xmath2 .
this bond dimension @xmath2 indicates how many variational coefficients are used .
crucially , it also regulates both the cost of the simulation , which scales as @xmath3 for some large power @xmath4 , and how much ground state entanglement the many - body ansatz can reproduce . in the large @xmath2 regime , peps and mera
are essentially unbiased methods , but with a huge computational cost that is often unaffordable .
more affordable simulations are obtained in the small @xmath2 regime , but there these methods are biased in favour of weakly entangled phases ( e.g. symmetry - breaking phases ) and against strongly entangled phases ( e.g. spin liquids and systems with a fermi surface ) . identifying more efficient strategies for tensor network contraction ,
so that larger values of the bond dimension @xmath2 can be used and the bias towards weakly entangled states is suppressed , is therefore a priority in this research area
. refs . , proposed the use of monte carlo sampling as a means to decrease computational costs in tensor network algorithms .
[ we note that there are other variational anstze , such as so - called correlated product states , entangled plaquette states , and string - bond states , whose contractibility relies on sampling ; see the introduction of ref . for a review ] . in a tensor network approach such as mps , mera or peps ,
sampling over specific configurations of the lattice allows to reduce the cost of contractions ( for single samples ) from @xmath3 to @xmath5 , where @xmath6 is significantly smaller than @xmath4 , typically of the order of @xmath7 .
needless to say , sampling introduces statistical errors .
however , if less than @xmath8 samples are required in order to achieved some pre - established accuracy , then overall sampling results in a reduction of computational costs . the proposal of refs . ,
is based on computing the overlap of the tensor network state with a product state ( representing the sampled configuration ) .
as such , it can not be directly applied to the mera , because the overlap of a mera with a product state can not be computed efficiently .
luckily , as discussed in ref . , a sampling strategy specific to unitary tensor networks ( such as mera and unitary versions of mps and tree tensor networks ) is not only possible , but it actually has several advantages .
most notably , sampling takes place over configurations of a reduced , effective lattice ; and it is possible to perform perfect sampling , by means of which uncorrelated configurations are drawn directly according to the correct probability . of a translation invariant lattice
@xmath9 made of @xmath10 sites and with periodic boundary conditions .
the tensors on each layer are identical and their labels are displayed to the left .
the @xmath11 tensors ( green rectangles ) are unitary operators ( acting top - to - bottom ) , @xmath12 ( cyan triangles ) are isometric , and @xmath13 ( red circle ) is a normalized ` wavefunction ' .
[ fig_mera],width=245 ] the main goals of this paper are to propose a variational monte carlo scheme for the mera and to demonstrate its feasibility .
we also discuss possible future applications .
let us briefly list some of the highlights of the approach .
( i ) in a lattice of size @xmath0 , the sampled configurations correspond to an effective lattice of size @xmath14 ; in this way , the cost of evaluating the expectation value of a local observable scales just as @xmath15 and not as @xmath16 as in refs . , . ( ii )
we employ the perfect sampling strategy of ref . , thus avoiding the loses of efficiency in the markov chain monte carlo of refs . , due to equilibration and autocorrelation times .
( iii ) variational parameters are optimized while explicitly preserving the unitary constraints that the tensors in the mera are subjected to .
this is accomplished by a steepest descent method within the set of unitary tensors , which is much more robust to statistical noise than the singular value decomposition methods employed in mera algorithms without sampling.@xcite we demonstrate the performance of our approach by computing an approximation to the ground state of a finite ising chain with transverse magnetic field . for the binary mera under consideration
, sampling lowers the costs of elementary contractions from @xmath17 to @xmath18 .
we find that the resulting ( approximate ) ground state energy decreases as the number of samples is increased , thus obtaining a demonstration of principle of the approach .
we also notice that the number of samples required to achieve a given accuracy increases as the transverse magnetic field approaches its critical value . to our knowledge ,
this is the first instance of sampling - based optimization of a relatively complex tensor network .
previous similar optimizations included that of an mps,@xcite which is a considerably simpler tensor network ( with only three - legged tensors ) , and of tensor networks that under sampling break into smaller , simpler tensor networks ( e.g. into mps , single plaquette states , etc).@xcite in more complex tensor networks , such as mera and peps , the optimization becomes much harder due to high sensitivity to statistical noise .
thus , for instance , ref
. spells out a full variational monte carlo approach for peps but uses an alternative method , not based on sampling , in order to optimize the tensors . indeed , in ref .
sampling is only used to aid in the computation of expectation values . here , instead , we use sampling both to optimize the mera and to compute expectation values .
we emphasize , however , that our results only demonstrate a gain over optimization schemes based on exact contractions ( i.e. without sampling ) in the low accuracy regime , where only a relatively small number of samples are required .
the specific mera ( namely binary mera for a one - dimensional lattice ) and low value of @xmath2 ( @xmath19 ) considered here for illustrative purposes implies that the cost per sample is @xmath20 times smaller than an exact contraction .
recall that the statistical error decreases only as @xmath21 with the number @xmath22 of samples .
if more than @xmath23 samples are required in order to obtain a sufficiently accurate approximation of the exact contraction , then the sampling scheme may be overall less efficient than the exact contraction scheme .
the advantage of sampling over exact contraction schemes is expected to be more evident in mera settings where the cost @xmath3 scales with a larger exponent @xmath4 , and for larger values of @xmath2 .
in particular , we envisage that the method described in this paper , possibly with further improvements , will improve the range of applicability of mera in two and higher dimensions .
the content of this paper is distributed in five more sections . in sec .
[ sec_approach ] , we discuss methods for sampling with the mera . in sec .
[ sec_optimize ] we propose an optimization scheme using sampling techniques . in sec .
[ sec_application ] we benchmark the approach with the quantum ising model . in sec .
[ sec_discussion ] we discuss future applications including extensions to higher dimensions and extracting long - range correlations , before concluding in sec . [ sec_conclusion ] .
in this section we explain how to use sampling in order to speed - up the computation of expectation values with the mera .
we present both complete and incomplete perfect sampling strategies , building on the proposals of ref . for generic unitary tensor networks .
we also discuss the importance of the choice of local basis in sampling .
we start by reviewing some necessary background material on the mera . of the local operator @xmath24 ( yellow rectangle ) , which acts on ( at most )
three neighboring sites .
the flipped tensors , on the bottom half of the diagram , are the hermitian conjugates of the respective tensors above .
the ` causal cone ' is delimited by the dotted line in the left diagram , corresponding to @xmath25 .
the tensors outside the causal cone cancel , significantly simplifying the diagram on the right , corresponding to @xmath26 .
[ fig_causal_cone ] ] the mera@xcite is a variational wavefunction for ground states of quantum many - body systems on a lattice .
the state @xmath27 of a lattice @xmath9 made of @xmath0 sites is represented by means of a tensor network made of two types of tensors , called _
disentanglers _ and _ isometries_. the tensor network is based on a real - space renormalization group transformation , known as _ entanglement renormalization _ :
disentanglers are used to remove short - range entanglement from the system , whereas isometries are used to coarse - grain blocks of site into single , effective sites .
an example of a mera on a periodic 1d lattice with @xmath28 sites is depicted in fig .
[ fig_mera ] . this structure is called ` binary ' mera because of the 2-to-1 course - graining transformation in each repeating layer . ascending upwards in the figure , the disentanglers @xmath11 remove short - range entanglement in between each course - graining transformation , implemented by isometries @xmath12 until the remaining hilbert space is small enough to deal with directly with some wavefunction @xmath13 .
the mera can also be viewed in the reverse starting from the top of fig .
[ fig_mera ] , we descend downwards in a unitary quantum circuit , adding ( initially unentangled ) sites in each layer . for instance , let us flow downwards in fig .
[ fig_mera ] . to a three - site system in state @xmath13
, we first add three additional unentangled sites , turning it into a six - site system ; and later we add another six unentangled sites , producing the final twelve - site system . this unitary structure can be exploited when calculating the expectation value @xmath29 of a local operator @xmath24 acting on a few neighboring sites . specifically , all tensors not ` causally ' connected to the few sites supporting @xmath24 cancel , as depicted in fig .
[ fig_causal_cone ] .
the resulting diagram is significantly simpler and can be interpreted as the expectation value @xmath26 of @xmath24 for a state @xmath30 of an effective lattice @xmath31 made of @xmath32 sites ( see fig .
[ fig_sampled_wavefunction ] ) .
we emphasize that , by construction , @xmath33 therefore , we can evaluate the expectation value @xmath25 by contracting the tensor network corresponding to @xmath26 .
the numerical cost of performing this contraction grows linearly with the number of sites in @xmath31 , and thus only logarithmically with the number of site @xmath0 in the original lattice @xmath9 .
the dimension of the hilbert space after each course - graining transformation is an adjustable parameter , the _ bond dimension _
@xmath2 , which plays a central role in the present discussion .
increasing the bond dimension @xmath2 implies including a larger fraction of the original hilbert space and leads to greater accuracy , but also requires greater computational resources .
optimization algorithms to approximate ground states , and to evaluate local expectation values and correlators , are present in the literature.@xcite the numerical cost of finding an expectation value or performing a single optimization iteration using the binary mera scales as @xmath34 for a translation invariant system .
for more complex mera structures , such as those representing 2d lattices , the power of @xmath2 for the cost increases dramatically .
for instance , the 2d mera presented in ref . has a numerical cost of @xmath35 , which on current computers restricts @xmath36 . for many systems ,
this does not allow for enough entanglement to accurately describe the ground state , limiting the accuracy of the approach . here
we hope to alleviate this problem by reducing the numerical cost as a function of @xmath2 using monte carlo techniques .
we will find that the cost of a single sample scales as @xmath18 for binary 1d mera , compared to the @xmath17 cost of the ` exact ' contraction . and @xmath30 represented by the mera .
( a ) tensor network for the state @xmath27 of the original lattice @xmath9
. the causal cone is delimited by a discontinuous line .
( b ) tensor network for the state @xmath37 of the effective lattice @xmath31 .
sites further from the center effectively represent increasingly large length scales in the original lattice .
[ fig_sampled_wavefunction ] ] .
the dashed lines indicate the indices that will be sampled . on the right - hand - side
we explicitly write the tensor contractions outside the causal cone as a sum over a complete , orthonormal set of ` wavefunctions ' @xmath38 ( pink circles ) .
monte carlo sampling will be performed over this set .
each term of the sum can be expressed as the product @xmath39 .
[ fig_mera_structure ] ] our goal is to compute the expectation value @xmath29 by contracting the tensor network corresponding to @xmath26 , see fig .
[ fig_causal_cone ] .
the first step is to re - express the tensor network contraction as a summation over indices corresponding to the sites of the effective lattice , as shown in fig .
[ fig_mera_structure ] .
we then get @xmath40 where @xmath41 is an orthonormal basis of product states @xmath42 on the effective lattice @xmath31 .
we will approximately evaluate the sum in eq .
( [ energy ] ) by using monte carlo sampling over the states @xmath43 .
notice that in the effective lattice , the sites away from the support of @xmath24 have undergone one or more course - graining transformations . in other words , sites
further from the center represent increasingly larger length - scales .
thus , sampling over sites of the effective lattice corresponds to sampling the system _ at different length scales_. this property is reminiscent of global or cluster updates used in existing monte carlo methods to solve critical systems . a nave scheme for approximating the sum in eq .
( [ energy ] ) would be to choose @xmath44 at random from @xmath41 , and evaluate @xmath39 according to the tensor networks in fig .
[ fig_mera_structure ] .
the cost of obtaining a single sample scales as @xmath45 .
however , the statistical variance of a sampling scheme can be substantially reduced by implementing importance sampling in this case choosing configurations @xmath44 that are more likely .
more precisely , sampling is implemented according to the wavefunction _ weight _ , @xmath46 , which can be calculated efficiently as indicated in fig .
[ fig_weight ]
. we can express eq .
( [ energy ] ) in a form more convenient for importance sampling , @xmath47 where @xmath48 note that because the mera is normalized by construction , and therefore the weights sum to one , @xmath49 .
however , during sampling only some subset @xmath50 of the configurations are considered .
one needs to renormalize the weights accordingly , so that the expectation value @xmath51 is approximated as @xmath52 in the case of mera , and indeed any state that can be written as a unitary quantum circuit , a ` perfect ' sample can be generated according to the probability distribution @xmath53 in a single sweep.@xcite this makes markov chain monte carlo unnecessary , simplifying the algorithm and eliminating a source of statistical error ( i.e. autocorrelation effects ) .
this is one advantage of this technique over other tensor network sampling methods in the literature.@xcite the sample can be constructed by sampling just one index at a time .
beginning at the top layer of the mera , and aiming to sample just the first index ( left - most in fig .
[ fig_mera_structure ] ( b ) ) , we can construct the one - site reduced density matrix @xmath54 by the tensor contraction in fig .
[ fig_weight ] ( b ) .
the probability @xmath55 can then be found _ for all possible _ @xmath56 .
a value of @xmath56 is then randomly selected according to any complete basis of our choosing .
after this selection is made , we can then sample the next ( top - most ) index , according to the conditional weights @xmath57 as calculated by the diagram in fig .
[ fig_weight ] ( b ) ( we refer to ref . for further details ) .
we continue to sample the state of each site , until we have sampled every site .
each of the diagrams in fig . [ fig_weight ] can be calculated with cost @xmath18 , while there are @xmath58 layers to the mera .
a single sample can therefore be generated with cost @xmath45 , compared to @xmath34 for the exact contraction .
so long as the number of samples @xmath22 is significantly less than @xmath59 , monte carlo sampling will be faster than exact contraction . in practice
, we will perform @xmath60 samples in order to get a good estimate of @xmath51 . as
the samples are completely uncorrelated , the variance of @xmath61 @xmath62 \equiv \sum_{\mathbf{r } } p(\mathbf{r } ) \left ( a^{\mathcal{c}}(\mathbf{r})-\bar{a^{\mathcal{c}}}\right)^2\ ] ] can be used to estimate statistical error @xmath63 , @xmath64 / n } , \label{std_error}\ ] ] while @xmath65 $ ] is itself upper bounded by the variance of the operator to be measured , @xmath62 \le \langle \hat{a}^2 \rangle - \langle \hat{a } \rangle^2 .
\label{std_error2}\ ] ] it is easy to show that the upper bound is saturated when sampling in the diagonal basis of @xmath24 .
however , the actual value of this variance is dependent on the choice of basis @xmath66 , as well as the state being sampled .
therefore , it is worth spending some effort in order to minimize this quantity .
the statistical noise is caused by monte carlo sampling of the tensor contraction , and it stands to reason that sampling _ less _ indices in the tensor network diagram ( see fig .
[ fig_mera_structure ] ) would reduce the statistical error .
indeed , it is possible to exactly contract the three physical indices at the lowest level ( those connected to operator @xmath24 ) while keeping the computational cost at @xmath45 , as depicted in fig .
[ fig_alt_samp_scheme ] .
that is , we sample over configurations @xmath67 of the effective lattice @xmath31 _ minus _ the three central sites on which @xmath24 is supported .
this method effectively generates ( unnormalized ) three - site wave functions @xmath68 from the reduced density operator ( as seen in fig .
[ fig_weight ] ( e , f ) ) .
conversely , the reduced density matrix for the three central sites is @xmath69 .
importance sampling is now achieved by selecting @xmath70 according to the weight @xmath71 in turn , perfect sampling of the sites proceeds exactly as before , but it stops before the three central sites , which are not sampled .
we define the estimator @xmath72 whose expectation value obeys , @xmath73 in analogy with eq .
( [ energy2pre ] ) .
notice that , by construction , the statistical variance @xmath74 $ ] is smaller or equal than @xmath65 $ ] in eq .
( [ std_error2 ] ) , and therefore the numerical accuracy is increased without affecting the computational cost . and ( b ) @xmath75 with incomplete sampling .
[ fig_alt_samp_scheme ] ] in general , we are free to choose any complete basis @xmath41 ( or @xmath76 ) from which to draw individual samples .
a good choice is one that produces a small statistical error , eqs .
( [ std_error],[std_error2 ] ) . intuitively , the goal of importance sampling is to decrease the statistical variance by choosing configurations @xmath77 ( or @xmath70 ) with a large overlap with the state @xmath30 . with this in mind
, one could aim to maximize the ` average ' weight , @xmath78 it is easy to show that for a given quantum probability distribution , specified by a density matrix , the above quantity is maximized in the diagonal basis of the density matrix .
inspired by this fact , here we choose to sample site @xmath79 in the basis in which the reduced density matrix @xmath80 is diagonal .
the @xmath81 density matrices @xmath80 , calculated in fig
. [ fig_weight ] , can be diagonalized with cost @xmath82 .
note that the chosen basis will depend on previously sampled sites , and that the resulting sampling basis is still a complete , orthonormal basis of product states .
we have found that this approach can radically increase the average value of the weight , eq .
( [ eq : weight ] ) with the effect becoming stronger for larger systems and values of @xmath2 .
more importantly , we find that the statistical variance in the observables is decreased ( see sec .
[ sec_application_expectation ] and fig .
[ fig_variance ] ) .
this technique to select the sampling basis is not specific to unitary tensor networks nor perfect sampling methods , and could thus be of benefit to other variational quantum monte carlo algorithms .
finally , we may wish to compute the expectation value of an operator that is the sum of local terms , such as a hamiltonian made of nearest - neighbor interactions : @xmath83 in this case we sample each local term @xmath84 as indicated previously , noticing that the causal cone of each @xmath84 depends on the location of the sites of lattice @xmath9 where the local operator is supported .
one can either choose to ( uniformly ) sample the position @xmath79 in the lattice , or systematically sweep through all the positions @xmath79 .
a complete sweep , where each site @xmath79 is visited once , costs @xmath85 .
in order to find an approximation to the ground state , we need to minimize the energy of the mera .
the direction of steepest _ ascent _ is given by the complex derivative with respect to the conjugate @xcite of each element of each tensor .
inserting eq .
( [ estimator ] ) ( or eq . ( [ eofs ] ) ) into eq .
( [ energy2 ] ) and differentiating gives @xmath86 , \label{derivative}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the derivative with respect to a tensor is element - wise , and similar expressions hold for @xmath12 and @xmath13 .
the derivatives on the right - hand - side of eq .
( [ derivative ] ) can be found by using the usual rules for calculating derivatives in the diagrams , see figs .
[ fig_alt_samp_scheme ] and [ fig_derivatives ] . ) arises from the change in the normalization of the wave function .
although we are dealing with unitary / isometric tensors which ensure @xmath87 , small changes in arbitrary directions may break the unitarity and modify the norm . interestingly , even when projecting into the unitary tangent space ( see below ) where this term averages to zero , its inclusion is important to reduce the sampling error sometimes by several orders of magnitude . ] in practice @xmath88 and @xmath89 will be estimated simultaneously by sampling .
multiple approaches are possible for updating the mera to minimize the energy and find a good approximation to the ground state .
one approach often used iteratively optimizes each tensor in the mera according to the following algorithm@xcite .
@xmath90 in the above @xmath91 and @xmath92 are unitary , while @xmath93 is diagonal and positive , thus representing the singular value decomposition ( svd ) of the derivative .
this algorithm finds the unitary tensor @xmath11 that minimizes the trace value of its product with the above , called environment with the requirement that @xmath94 is negative - semidefinite .
similar steps apply to @xmath12 and @xmath13 , where the svd ensures that they remain isometric or normalized , respectively .
unfortunately , the above scheme is extremely sensitive to the statistical noise inherent to monte carlo sampling , and results in very poor optimization .
ideally , we would prefer a method in which the statistical noise is able to average out over many iterations .
the most obvious scheme satisfying this requirement is straightforward steepest descent .
again , one must ensure that the tensors obey the unitary / isometric constraints characteristic of the mera , so one can utilize the svd to find the unitary tensor closest ( with respect to the @xmath95norm ) to the usual downhill update . with this method ,
the @xmath79th step is given by @xmath96 where @xmath97 is a number modulating the size of change at the step @xmath98 .
in this paper we avoid using the svd entirely by explicitly remaining in the unitary subspace , along the lines of ref . .
we define the tangent vector @xmath99 as the derivative projected onto the tangent space of all unitaries located about @xmath11 , @xmath100 the matrix @xmath101 is within @xmath102 of a unitary matrix . noting that @xmath103 is anti - hermitian , then the update @xmath104\ ] ] both travels in the direction of the tangent vector while @xmath11 remains precisely unitary .
the same approach works for @xmath105 isometric matrices , taking care that @xmath106 , with computational cost scaling similarly to the svd approach as @xmath107 ( see appendix ) .
the performance of the algorithm is highly dependent on the behaviour of @xmath97 , as well as the number of monte carlo samples , @xmath108 , taken in each step .
simple schemes will keep @xmath97 and @xmath108 constant , which is the approach we take here . on the other hand
, one may choose to increase @xmath108 with @xmath98 so that harmful noise is reduced when approaching the optimal solution ; or to decrease @xmath97 with @xmath98 for much the same reason ; or a combination of both .
in this section we demonstrate the above techniques with the well - known transverse - field quantum ising model , @xmath109 such a hamiltonian can be expressed as a sum of nearest - neighbour terms @xmath84 , such that @xmath110 we will pay particular attention to the region around the critical point at @xmath111 , which is the most demanding computationally . for concreteness , we use a three - layer binary mera with periodic boundary conditions , resulting in a lattice of 24 sites in the bottom of the mera structure
. however , each of these sites corresponds to a block of @xmath112 physical spins , making a total of 72 spins .
we choose this blocking so that for @xmath113 the bond dimension only ever decreases when ascending through the mera . in
what follows , we employ incomplete perfect sampling where three sites at the bottom of the mera are contracted exactly .
we now analyze the effectiveness of extracting expectation values from the mera using monte carlo sampling . for perfect sampling techniques
, the accuracy can be easily extracted from the variance using eq .
( [ std_error ] ) .
the scaling of the error in the energy , @xmath114 , is shown explicitly for the critical ( @xmath115 ) system in fig .
[ fig_variance ] ( a ) .
the variance of the energy estimator @xmath116 as a function of @xmath117 is shown in fig .
[ fig_variance ] ( b ) .
here we have used mera wavefunctions previously optimized using standard techniques@xcite _ without _ monte carlo sampling , that is , sampling is only employed to extract the expectation values . as a function of the number of samples @xmath22 follows the classic @xmath118 scaling .
( b ) variance of the energy estimator ( normalized to the expectation value @xmath119 ) for optimized meras with bond - dimension @xmath120 for various values of @xmath117 ( red crosses ) .
estimates of the statistical uncertainty are smaller than the symbols .
the grey area is eliminated by inequality eq .
( [ std_error2 ] ) , bounded by the variance of @xmath94 . for comparison , we include the variances expected from several hypothetical samplings of @xmath121 .
variances from sampling the spins in the @xmath122 ( or @xmath123 ) basis is indicated by a blue , dash - dot ( or green , dashed ) line .
our numerical results ( red crosses ) show remarkable similarity with sampling in the diagonal basis of @xmath121 ( black , solid line ) .
( c ) the entanglement entropy of @xmath121 . in ( b ) and
( c ) , the critical point at @xmath111 is indicated with a red dotted vertical line .
, title="fig : " ] as a function of the number of samples @xmath22 follows the classic @xmath118 scaling .
( b ) variance of the energy estimator ( normalized to the expectation value @xmath119 ) for optimized meras with bond - dimension @xmath120 for various values of @xmath117 ( red crosses ) .
estimates of the statistical uncertainty are smaller than the symbols .
the grey area is eliminated by inequality eq .
( [ std_error2 ] ) , bounded by the variance of @xmath94 . for comparison
, we include the variances expected from several hypothetical samplings of @xmath121 .
variances from sampling the spins in the @xmath122 ( or @xmath123 ) basis is indicated by a blue , dash - dot ( or green , dashed ) line .
our numerical results ( red crosses ) show remarkable similarity with sampling in the diagonal basis of @xmath121 ( black , solid line ) .
( c ) the entanglement entropy of @xmath121 . in ( b ) and ( c ) , the critical point at @xmath111 is indicated with a red dotted vertical line .
, title="fig : " ] as a function of the number of samples @xmath22 follows the classic @xmath118 scaling .
( b ) variance of the energy estimator ( normalized to the expectation value @xmath119 ) for optimized meras with bond - dimension @xmath120 for various values of @xmath117 ( red crosses ) .
estimates of the statistical uncertainty are smaller than the symbols .
the grey area is eliminated by inequality eq .
( [ std_error2 ] ) , bounded by the variance of @xmath94 . for comparison , we include the variances expected from several hypothetical samplings of @xmath121 .
variances from sampling the spins in the @xmath122 ( or @xmath123 ) basis is indicated by a blue , dash - dot ( or green , dashed ) line .
our numerical results ( red crosses ) show remarkable similarity with sampling in the diagonal basis of @xmath121 ( black , solid line ) .
( c ) the entanglement entropy of @xmath121 . in ( b ) and ( c ) , the critical point at @xmath111 is indicated with a red dotted vertical line .
, title="fig : " ] notice that the variance is maximal near the critical point at @xmath111 . as the monte carlo code effectively samples wavefunctions from the reduced three - site ( i.e. nine - spin ) density operator
, one would expect the energy variance to increase with the amount of entanglement in the system .
for reference we have included the entropy of the three - site density matrix @xmath121 in fig .
[ fig_variance ] ( c ) .
this entropy mostly and @xmath121 share a @xmath124 symmetry which is broken by the mera wavefunction for @xmath125 , and the _ exact _ ground state should have @xmath126 entanglement entropy as @xmath127 . ]
corresponds to the entanglement entropy of three sites with the remainder of the system .
we see a strong correlation between the amount of entanglement and the size of the variance of the energy estimator @xmath116 .
let us emphasize that fig .
[ fig_variance ] ( b ) shows that our scheme performs significantly better than directly sampling @xmath121 in either the @xmath123 or @xmath122 spin basis .
the measured variances are very similar to a diagonal sampling of @xmath121 ( i.e. in its diagonal basis ) .
this indicates that the sampling scheme is performing as intended in sec .
[ sec_diagonal ] .
in general , an accurate representation of wavefunctions with greater amounts of entanglement will require greater bond dimension @xmath2 .
these results suggest that the statistical variance generated by this scheme will also increase with the entanglement . to achieve a certain precision in the expectation value of local observables
, the number of required samples grows with this variance , and thus with the amount of entanglement and with the minimum suitable value of @xmath2 .
therefore , although a _ single _ sample has cost @xmath18 , the _ total _ cost to obtain a certain precision may have some additional dependence on @xmath2 .
nevertheless , no additional dependence was clearly manifest in our simulations at fixed @xmath117 .
finally , we combine monte carlo sampling with our unitary - subspace steepest descent algorithm to obtain optimized wavefunctions . in fig .
[ fig_optimize ] we plot the energy of the mera during the optimization process at @xmath111 and @xmath128 , where the simulation progresses through a range of different number of sweeps @xmath22 per optimization step . in all cases
the step size is fixed at @xmath129 .
we observe that increasing @xmath22 improves the quality of the optimized wavefunction and for large values of @xmath22 the simulation tends to converge towards the same energy obtained with exact contractions , as expected .
like all tensor network optimizations , care must be taken to ensure the wavefunction has fully converged to the lowest energy state . for instance , in fig .
[ fig_optimize ] ( a ) we see a plateau in energy before around the 4000th iteration that could be mistaken for convergence ( whereas the simulation is actually navigating a stiff region , i.e. a long narrow valley in the energy landscape ) .
non - deterministic features due to statistical fluctuations can also be seen such as the sudden increase of energy of the @xmath130 simulation around the 13000th iteration . beyond this , accuracy could be improved by increasing @xmath2 .
it should be noted that we have observed that the steepest descent method ( with either exact contractions or sampling ) will not always produce wavefunctions of the same quality as the svd method as it may be more susceptible to local minima or extreme stiffness .
however , accuracy can still be systematically improved by increasing @xmath2 . during optimization .
each iteration is update using @xmath22 sweeps , where @xmath22 is @xmath131 in the black crosses , red pluses , green diamonds and blue points respectively .
every 100 iterations , we calculate the exact energy corresponding to the current wavefunction , which is plotted here .
the solid horizontal line indicates the energy of an optimized @xmath19 mera using exact contractions and steepest descent ( which remains @xmath132 above the the true ground state energy , indicated by the dashed line ) .
the simulation converges for large @xmath22 , but @xmath2 may need to increase for greater accuracy .
( b ) difference to the above solid line plotted on a logarithmic scale .
the difference reduces with increasing @xmath22 , and although statistical fluctuations are decreasing , they remain evident on the logarithmic scale.,title="fig : " ] during optimization .
each iteration is update using @xmath22 sweeps , where @xmath22 is @xmath131 in the black crosses , red pluses , green diamonds and blue points respectively .
every 100 iterations , we calculate the exact energy corresponding to the current wavefunction , which is plotted here . the solid horizontal line indicates the energy of an optimized @xmath19 mera using exact contractions and steepest descent ( which remains @xmath132 above the the true ground state energy , indicated by the dashed line ) .
the simulation converges for large @xmath22 , but @xmath2 may need to increase for greater accuracy .
( b ) difference to the above solid line plotted on a logarithmic scale .
the difference reduces with increasing @xmath22 , and although statistical fluctuations are decreasing , they remain evident on the logarithmic scale.,title="fig : " ] in the previous section we noted that the statistical uncertainty peaked around the critical point at @xmath111 , where the entanglement is maximal , and one might expect the optimizations to be most difficult around this point . plotted in fig .
[ fig_optimize_vs_h ] is the difference in energy between our wavefunctions and the exact , analytic solution for a range of @xmath117 .
we observe that the error decreases away from the critical point , and that there is a clear relationship between the quality of the wavefunction and the number of samples per step , @xmath22 . .
the markers indicate the number of monte carlo sweeps taken between updates , @xmath133 for the black cross , red diamond , green circle and blue square , respectively .
there is a clear trend for improved ground state energy as @xmath22 increases , and away from the critical point at @xmath111 ( vertical red dotted line ) . ]
there are several possible limiting factors in variational monte carlo optimizations of mera wavefunctions .
one must balance the cost of increasing @xmath22 , @xmath2 and the total number of iterations , to produce results of the desired accuracy . on top of this ,
the ansatz presents a complicated optimization landscape and one must be careful not to be stuck in local minima .
there is much scope to improve on the above optimization scheme by using more sophisticated approaches .
most obviously , the step - size @xmath97 and number of samples @xmath108 performed in each iteration could be adjusted as the simulation progresses .
for example by choosing the step size to decrease as @xmath134 , with @xmath22 fixed and @xmath135 we are guaranteed convergence to some local minimum@xcite .
equivalently , the noise could be reduced at each step by increasing @xmath136 , or some combination of both . in ref .
it was found that using just the sign of the derivative , as well as properties resulting from translational invariance , was sufficient for optimizing a periodic mps with monte carlo sampling .
other approaches existing in the literature may result is significant gains , though it should be noted that approaches requiring the second derivative or hessian matrix would increase the order of the numerical cost as a function of @xmath2 , and would have to be made robust to statistical noise .
there are several situations where it is most natural to use monte carlo sampling to speed - up mera algorithms .
let us briefly review them . in this work we have considered in detail the binary mera for a 1d lattice with translation invariance .
however , even in a translationally invariant , 1d lattice , one has freedom to choose between a large variety of entanglement renormalization schemes , leading to mera structures with different configurations of isometries and disentanglers .
-to-@xmath137 mera described in ref . .
[ fig_other_meras],title="fig:",width=188]-to-@xmath137 mera described in ref . .
[ fig_other_meras],title="fig:",width=132 ] the ternary mera , shown in fig . [ fig_other_meras ] ( a ) , has a narrower causal cone , with a width of just two sites , and the traditional algorithms for optimizing it have a cost that scales as @xmath138 . as a result , the ternary mera is sometimes favored over the binary mera .
note that this does not necessarily translate into an improved accuracy in expectation values the ternary mera is in general less accurate than binary mera for the same value of @xmath2 .
it is interesting to note that , in the ternary mera , the perfect sampling algorithm presented here again has cost @xmath18 , while markov chain monte carlo , as well as expectation value and environment estimation , is possible with cost @xmath139 .
it is unclear whether after including autocorrelation effects the markov chain method performs better , similar , or worse overall compared to the perfect sampling algorithm .
another possible 1d mera includes two layers of disentanglers to account for entanglement over larger distances , as depicted in fig .
[ fig_other_meras ] ( b ) .
this mera has a causal cone that is five sites wide , and traditional algorithms would have numerical cost @xmath140 and require memory @xmath141 limiting @xmath2 to rather small values .
however , a sampling technique will only require @xmath142 time per sample and @xmath18 memory overall a huge saving .
note that the power roughly halves when we change from an exact contraction which effectively rescales density matrices from higher layers to lower , to a monte carlo scheme which samples wavefunctions from this distribution .
the scaling of computational cost in @xmath2 in 2d lattices is even more challenging , mostly because the width of the causal cone ( or number of indices included in a horizontal section of the causal cone ) is much larger . once again
, sampling wavefunctions will require roughly square - root the number of operations ( and memory ) needed to calculate the exact reduced - density matrix .
for instance , in the @xmath143-to-@xmath137 mera presented in ref .
, the cost of an exact contraction scales as @xmath35 , while with monte carlo sampling it is possible with just @xmath144 operations per sample ( depicted in fig .
[ fig_other_meras ] ( c ) ) .
memory might be a limiting factor in 2d mera algorithms , while the temporary memory required for this algorithm is less than that to store the disentanglers and isometries .
another challenge with mera calculations is the numerical cost of long - range correlations .
take for instance the two - site operator @xmath145 , for arbitrary sites @xmath79 and @xmath146 .
the cost required to contract the corresponding tensor network within the binary mera scheme can scale as much as @xmath140 significantly more than the @xmath17 cost for neighbor and next - nearest - neighbor correlations .
however , an estimate of the correlator can be obtained using monte carlo sampling at a reduced cost ( per sample ) . in fig .
[ fig_long_range ] , we depict the causal cone structure of two single - site operators separated by @xmath147 sites in a binary mera . the cost of monte carlo sampling for @xmath148 is just @xmath149 . .
an exact contraction of the expectation value costs @xmath140 .
[ fig_long_range ] ] this technique can be extended to 2d lattice systems , where calculating long - range correlations exactly quickly becomes infeasible , even for modest values of @xmath2 .
note again that memory constraints are particularly challenging for 2d mera calculations and monte carlo sampling can alleviate this burden .
we have outlined and tested a scheme for monte carlo sampling with the mera .
uncorrelated samples can be efficiently generated directly from the wavefunction overlap probability distribution , without needing to resort to markov chain monte carlo methods . from this , expectation values can be extracted and we have demonstrated techniques to reduce the statistical error . we have also presented and demonstrated an algorithm to optimize mera wavefunctions using sampled energy derivatives . the numerical results presented here were not intended to be state - of - the - art solutions of the 1d quantum ising model , but rather to demonstrate feasibility and motivate subsequent applications to 2d systems . in general , monte carlo sampling becomes more advantageous for systems with large numbers of degrees of freedom , and we expect 2d mera to be no exception . because the reduction in cost in two ( and higher ) dimensions is so significant , monte carlo techniques are a very attractive way to achieve reasonable values of @xmath2 with current computers .
obvious improvements to the code include utilizing symmetries and parallelization to supercomputers , which is straightfoward with our perfect sampling algorithm .
further research into optimization strategies may lead to other improvements ( e.g. by reducing the number of iterations or the tendency to find local minima ) .
reweighting techniques@xcite may make the optimization more efficient when approaching the ground state .
the authors would like to thank philippe corboz and anders sandvik for useful discussions .
support from the australian research council ( ff0668731 , dp0878830 , dp1092513 ) , the visitor programme at perimeter institute , nserc and fqrnt is acknowledged .
in this appendix we explain how to compute , with cost @xmath150 , the @xmath151 isometric matrix @xmath152 where @xmath153 is an @xmath151 isometric matrix , @xmath154 is a general @xmath155 matrix , and @xmath156 .
the nave approach would be to evaluate the @xmath157 matrix @xmath158 and compute its exponential , with cost @xmath159 , before multiplying by @xmath153 .
however , noting that the exponent does not have full rank ( the rank is at most @xmath160 ) , we can hope to find a faster method . taking the taylor expansion @xmath161 we observe that the result can be achieved with a series of multiplications between @xmath162 matrices @xmath163 , @xmath164 and @xmath165 , post - multiplied by either @xmath153 or @xmath154 , requiring total cost @xmath107 . in the binary mera , where isometries are @xmath178 matrices ( i.e. @xmath179 , @xmath180 )
, the cost of this algorithm scales as @xmath139 , compared with the cost @xmath181 of the nave approach .
this algorithm becomes particularly important for a tree tensor network and for the mera in two dimensions , where the nave approach becomes more expensive , in powers of @xmath2 , than a sampling ( thus becoming the bottle neck of an optimization based on sampling ) , whereas the above algorithm remains competitive . | monte carlo sampling techniques have been proposed as a strategy to reduce the computational cost of contractions in tensor network approaches to solving many - body systems .
here we put forward a variational monte carlo approach for the multi - scale entanglement renormalization ansatz ( mera ) , which is a unitary tensor network .
two major adjustments are required compared to previous proposals with non - unitary tensor networks .
first , instead of sampling over configurations of the original lattice , made of @xmath0 sites , we sample over configurations of an effective lattice , which is made of just @xmath1 sites .
second , the optimization of unitary tensors must account for their unitary character while being robust to statistical noise , which we accomplish with a modified steepest descent method within the set of unitary tensors .
we demonstrate the performance of the variational monte carlo mera approach in the relatively simple context of a finite quantum spin chain at criticality , and discuss future , more challenging applications , including two dimensional systems . |
in recent years advances in the cooling and trapping of ions have led to a situation in which the centre - of - mass ( cm ) motion of trapped ions has to be treated quantum mechanically @xcite .
this motion can be coherently controlled by coupling the ion s external and internal degrees of freedom through laser irradiation @xcite .
systems of trapped ions have been employed to demonstrate experimentally the generation and measurement of non - classical states of the ion s cm motion @xcite .
furthermore trapped ions have been used to implement quantum logic gates @xcite .
most of the previous investigations have focussed on the one - dimensional quantum motion of trapped ions . recently ,
gou _ et .
@xcite considered the generation of particular two - mode states of an ion . in this paper
we address the issue of how to engineer a class of interactions between two of the quantized motional degrees of freedom of a single trapped ion .
we assume that the ion is confined within a trap potential that can be closely approximated by a two - dimensional harmonic well . in this case
the cm motion of the ion is completely equivalent to that of a two - dimensional harmonic oscillator , characterized by two frequencies of oscillation @xmath3 and @xmath4 in orthogonal directions @xmath0 and @xmath5 and the corresponding operators @xmath6 and @xmath7 create ( annihilate ) vibrational excitations in the @xmath0- and @xmath1-directions .
the interaction that we want to engineer is of the parametric form @xmath8 where @xmath9 and @xmath10 are positive integers and @xmath11 is a complex coupling constant .
in particular , we note that the powers @xmath12 and @xmath13 can be independently controlled to take on any positive integer numbers , and the phase of the coupling constant @xmath14 is freely adjustable . to give specific examples of this class of interactions between the two vibrational modes @xmath15 and @xmath16 we address the two coupling hamiltonians , @xmath17 the hamiltonian ( [ 6 ] ) generates an active rotation of the two - dimensional quantized motional state of the ion at a frequency @xmath14 where @xmath11 is real .
here @xmath18 is the kind of hamiltonian associated with a linear coupler or beam splitter in optics ( see e.g. @xcite and refs .
therein ) . there , a photon in mode @xmath15 is annihilated and a photon in mode @xmath19 is created , and vice versa . in a trapped ion , vibrational anticorrelated su(2 ) states of motion characteristic of this kind of linear coupling can be generated @xcite .
the linear coupling , @xmath20 makes it possible to transfer the motional state of the ion from , say the @xmath0-direction into the @xmath1-direction _ without prior knowledge _ of that motional state and irrespective of whether it is a pure or a mixed state .
in the situation in which one may want to use the quantized motion in the @xmath0-direction for quantum computation @xcite , perhaps later entangling the quantum state of motion with internal electronic states , the @xmath1-direction can then be employed as a quantum memory element .
note the key point here is that states of motion in the @xmath0-direction can be transferred entirely to the @xmath1-direction without reading out their nature , entirely non - destructively .
the hamiltonian @xmath21 is of the three - photon down - conversion kind : in optics , it represents a process in which one pump photon in mode @xmath19 is annihilated and three photons in mode @xmath15 are created , and vice versa .
this process is known to be highly peculiar : unlike its two - photon down - conversion cousin , quantization of the pump is essential to avoid pathological divergences @xcite .
these are avoided in a fully quantized treatment , where the pump and down - converted field modes become highly entangled @xcite . in section [ generalraman ]
, we first introduce a two - mode raman transition which couples the electronic and motional degrees of freedom of the ion . choosing the initial state of the ion to be a direct product of an arbitrary motional state and a specific electronic state
, we then decouple the electronic and motional dynamics of the ion through a particular configuration of laser beams ( section [ specificcoupling ] ) . in the lamb - dicke approximation and in the limit of suitable trap anisotropy
we obtain the above hamiltonian ( [ 5 ] ) for various sideband detunings of the lasers .
we then examine the severity of the approximations made to obtain the hamiltonian ( [ 5 ] ) . in section
[ limits ] we obtain analytical estimates regarding the effects of off - resonant and higher on - resonant processes . in section [ rotation ]
we specialize to the case @xmath22 and show that the hamiltonian @xmath18 rotates the motional quantum state of the ion .
finally , we perform a numerical analysis of the complete quantum dynamics and find that the hamiltonian ( [ 6 ] ) can be accurately engineered over a range of parameters .
in the following we describe the raman coupling which we use to engineer the hamiltonian given in ( [ 5 ] ) .
we consider an effective three - level ion in a @xmath23-configuration , confined within a two - dimensional harmonic trap as illustrated in fig.[fig1 ] .
the trap is characterized by the two frequencies @xmath3 and @xmath24 which describe the harmonic potential in @xmath0- and @xmath1-direction respectively .
as shown in fig.[fig1 ] , the ion is excited by two linearly polarized laser beams which propagate in the @xmath0- and @xmath1-directions connecting levels @xmath25 and @xmath26 these beams are far detuned from the excited state @xmath27 in order to generate a stimulated raman transition between the two states @xmath28 and @xmath29 we assume states @xmath28 and @xmath30 to be ground state hyperfine sublevels .
we do not include decoherence effects in our model for the following reason .
the raman coupled energy level scheme greatly suppresses the spontaneous emission between the two ground state levels @xmath31 and @xmath32 as these states are coupled by m1 and e2 transitions at best . at the same time
we neglect the effects of spontaneous emission from level @xmath33 as the coupling to the excited state can be effectively eliminated over the timescales of interest to us here when the laser beams are far detuned .
another source of decoherence in ion trap experiments is classical noise in the laser beams and trapping potential .
this may be described using so - called intrinsic decoherence models , e.g. @xcite , of dephasing .
the effects of this kind of decoherence have been seen in a recent experiment by meekhof et .
al . @xcite .
however , they expect to significantly reduce decoherence from classical noise sources in future experiments @xcite .
we thus do not include any decoherence effects in our model . treating the laser excitations classically
, the two electric fields are described by @xmath34 } + { \rm h.c . } \right\}\ , , \nonumber \\ \underline{{\cal e}}_{23 } ( \hat{y},t ) & = & \underline{e}_{23 } \left\ { e_{23}\,e^{-i[k_{23}\hat{y } - \omega_{23 } t ] } + { \rm h.c . } \right\}\ , , \label{8}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath35 and @xmath36 are polarization vectors , @xmath37 and @xmath38 are wavenumbers , and @xmath39 and @xmath40 are the frequencies of the lasers .
we assume the laser phases to be absorbed in the complex amplitudes @xmath41 and @xmath42 in dipole approximation this leads to the hamiltonian @xmath43 & & - \ \underline{d}_{12}. \underline{{\cal e}}_{12 } - \underline{d}_{23}. \underline{{\cal e}}_{23 } \ , , \label{10}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have denoted the dipole moments of the @xmath44 and @xmath45 respectively .
the frequencies @xmath46 and @xmath47 are associated with the energies of the electronic states @xmath48 and @xmath49 and the operators @xmath50 and @xmath51 are the annihilation ( creation ) operators for vibrational quanta in the @xmath0- and @xmath1-directions .
these operators are related to the position of the ion in the @xmath0-@xmath1 plane through @xmath52 where @xmath53 and @xmath54 are the widths of the ground state in the two - dimensional harmonic oscillator potential in @xmath0- and @xmath1-directions , and @xmath55 is the mass of the ion .
if the laser beams are sufficiently far detuned , i.e. @xmath56 the two ground states @xmath28 and @xmath30 are coupled via a stimulated raman transition and the excited state @xmath57 can be adiabatically eliminated . in the above inequality
we have defined the laser detunings @xmath58 and the dipole coupling constants @xmath59 as described in appendix a , the adiabatic elimination procedure leads to the hamiltonian @xmath60 & & + \hbar \nu_{\scriptstyle a } \ , ( \left.\!\hat{a}^\dagger\!\right .
\hat{a}% ) + \hbar \nu_{\scriptstyle b } \ , ( \left.\!\hat{b}^\dagger\!\right . \hat{b } ) \nonumber \\[1ex ] & & - \hbar g_{13 } \ , e^{-i\left[k_{12}\hat{x } - k_{23}\hat{y } - ( \omega_{12 } - \omega_{23})t \right ] } \otimes |1\rangle \langle3| \nonumber \\[1ex ] & & - \hbar g_{13}^ * \ , e^{i \left[k_{12}\hat{x } - k_{23}\hat{y } - ( \omega_{12 } - \omega_{23})t \right ] } \otimes |3\rangle \langle1| \ , , \label{40}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have dropped the term describing the free energy of the excited state @xmath57 as in the far detuned limit ( [ 30 ] ) the excited state is no longer connected to the two ground states .
furthermore , we have defined the raman coupling constant @xmath61 and the energies @xmath62 and @xmath63 of the ground state levels @xmath28 and @xmath49 which are stark shifted as a result of the adiabatic elimination of the excited state , are @xmath64 in order to proceed , we will consider the raman coupling hamiltonian ( [ 40 ] ) in the interaction picture of @xmath65 and transform to the new hamiltonian @xmath66 in doing so and replacing the position operators @xmath67 and @xmath68 by ( [ 20 ] ) we obtain the interaction hamiltonian @xmath69 \
|1\rangle \langle3| \nonumber \\[1.5ex ] & & \otimes \sum_{m,\mu , n,\nu } \frac{(-i \eta_{12})^{m+\mu}}{m!\ , \mu ! } \frac { ( i\eta_{23})^{n+\nu } } { n!\ , \nu!}\ , \left.\!\hat{a}^\dagger\!\right.^m a^\mu\ , \left.\!\hat{b}^\dagger\!\right.^\nu b^n \nonumber \\[1.5ex ] & & \times \ , \exp \big [ \,i\,\big ( \nu_{\scriptstyle a } [ m-\mu ] + \nu_{% \scriptstyle b } [ \nu - n ] + \delta_{13 } \big ) \,t\,\big ] \ + \ { \rm h.c.}\ , , \nonumber \\[1.5ex ] & & \label{60}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have defined the raman detuning , @xmath70 and the lamb - dicke parameters in @xmath0- and @xmath1-direction , @xmath71 and @xmath72 the square of the lamb - dicke parameter gives the ratio of the single photon recoil energy to the energy level spacing in the harmonic oscillator potential .
in this section we construct a particular configuration of raman lasers to decouple the electronic and motional dynamics of the trapped ion for suitably - chosen initial electronic states .
this is done by symmetrically combining two raman transitions as described below .
we then obtain the hamiltonian ( [ 5 ] ) in the lamb - dicke approximation and in the limit of suitable trap anisotropy for specific sideband detunings of the lasers .
the electronic and motional dynamics can be decoupled in general for the hamiltonian @xmath73 where @xmath74 may be any operator that acts on the motional degrees of freedom only .
this is done through the addition of another interaction generated by @xmath75 combining both interactions , we have @xmath76 so that the combined hamiltonian , @xmath77 factorizes . for the case where @xmath78 is given by ( [ 60 ] )
, @xmath79 can be generated by an extra pair of raman lasers with suitable detunings , propagation directions and phases . to be more specific , we require a symmetric combination of two raman transitions , so that @xmath80 \eta_{12}^\prime & = & - \eta_{12}\ , , \nonumber \\ \eta_{23}^\prime & = & - \eta_{23}\ , , \label{77 } \\[1.5ex ] g_{13}^\prime & = & g_{13}^*\ , , \label{78}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where all quantities without primes correspond to the first pair of raman lasers and all primed quantities refer to the second pair . if , for the first pair of lasers , the raman detuning @xmath81 is given by ( [ 70 ] ) , then the first condition ( [ 76 ] ) , requires an appropriate choice of the frequencies @xmath82 and @xmath83 for the second pair , so that @xmath84 this is illustrated in fig.[fig2 ] .
the second condition ( [ 77 ] ) , is satisfied by choosing the second pair of beams to be counter - propagating with respect to the first pair , so that @xmath85 and @xmath86 as seen from the definition of the lamb - dicke parameters , @xmath87 and @xmath88 here , we have neglected the differences @xmath89 and @xmath90 this restriction can be lifted if one chooses the second pair of lasers to be not exactly counter - propagating with the first . the third condition ( [ 78 ] ) , requires a suitable choice of laser phases for the two pairs of raman beams which can be easily read from ( [ 50 ] ) .
the symmetric combination of the two raman transitions as specified by ( [ 76])([78 ] ) then leads to the interaction hamiltonian @xmath91 \right .
\sum_{m,\mu , n,\nu } \frac{% ( -i \eta_{12})^{m+\mu}}{m!\ , \mu ! } \frac{(i\eta_{23})^{n+\nu } } { n!\ , \nu!}\ , \left.\!\hat{a}^\dagger\!\right.^m a^\mu\ , \left.\!\hat{b}% ^\dagger\!\right.^\nu b^n \nonumber \\[2ex ] & & \times \ , \exp \big[\,i\ , ( \nu_{\scriptstyle a } [ m-\mu ] + \nu_{% \scriptstyle b } [ \nu - n ] + \delta_{13 } ) \,t\,\big ] \
{ \rm h.c . }
\bigg \ } % \otimes \big \ { |1\rangle\langle3| + |3\rangle\langle1| \big \ } \ , , \label{80}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which factorizes .
we now assume the ion to be initially in a direct product of its motional and electronic state with the electronic state prepared as @xmath92 by applying a resonant @xmath93-pulse @xmath94 , if the ion is confined within the lamb - dicke limit , i.e. @xmath95 @xcite .
the dynamics generated by eq.([80 ] ) acting on this state factors and leaves the electronic state unchanged .
this allows us to reduce the dynamics to that of the motional degrees of freedom only , and we write @xmath96 \quad \sum_{m,\mu , n,\nu } \frac{(-i \eta_{12})^{m+\mu}}{m!\ , \mu ! } \frac{(i\eta_{23})^{n+\nu } } { n!\ , \nu!}\ , \left.\!\hat{a}^\dagger\!\right.^m a^\mu\ , \left.\!\hat{b}% ^\dagger\!\right.^\nu b^n \nonumber \\[2ex ] & & \times \ , \exp \big [ \,i\ , ( \nu_{\scriptstyle a } [ m-\mu ] + \nu_{% \scriptstyle b } [ \nu - n ] + \delta_{13})\,t\,\big ] \ + \ { \rm h.c . }
\label{90}\end{aligned}\ ] ] ' '' '' ' '' '' 2 we now discuss the sideband detunings which , in the lamb - dicke approximation and in the limit of suitable trap anisotropy , lead to the desired interaction ( [ 5 ] ) . in particular , detuning the two pairs of raman lasers to specific vibrational sidebands allows us to choose specific values for @xmath9 and @xmath10 in ( [ 5 ] ) .
since we require the two raman transitions to be symmetric , it is sufficient to consider the first pair of raman lasers . therefore , we return to the vibronic raman coupling hamiltonian ( [ 60 ] ) . from eq.([60 ] ) it is clear that by fixing the size of the detuning @xmath97 i.e. by choosing the frequencies of the two coupling lasers , we can tune to a resonance between specific vibronic levels .
as illustrated in fig.[fig3 ] we introduce a virtual level @xmath98 with energy @xmath99 to help visualize the raman transitions between the ion s vibronic levels .
if we let @xmath100 and @xmath101 then with respect to level latexmath:[$% @xmath9-th red sideband of the ion s vibration in the @xmath0-direction , the second laser is tuned to the @xmath10-th red sideband of the vibration in the @xmath2-direction and the raman detuning is @xmath103 this situation is illustrated in fig.[fig3 ] for the specific example , @xmath104 now , if only on - resonant terms in ( [ 60 ] ) are retained , we have @xmath105 and @xmath106 and we obtain the hamiltonian @xmath107 where we have defined the coupling constants @xmath108 \nonumber \\[2ex ] & & \times \frac{(-i \eta_{12})^{2 \mu + { k_{\scriptstyle a}}}}{\mu!\ , ( \mu + { k_{\scriptstyle a } } ) ! }
\frac{(i\eta_{23})^{2 \nu + { k_{\scriptstyle b}}}}{% \nu!\ , ( \nu + { k_{\scriptstyle b}})!}\ , . \label{115}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this is a two - mode generalization of the non - linear jaynes - cummings model introduced by vogel _ et .
it is important for the trap frequencies @xmath3 and @xmath24 to be non - commensurate to arrive at this result .
this becomes clear from fig.[fig3 ] .
if the trapping potential is isotropic , @xmath109 and the energy levels become degenerate .
consequently , the raman transition hamiltonian ( [ 60 ] ) contains on - resonant terms in addition to the ones retained in ( [ 110 ] ) . in the example @xmath110
this leads to a coupling hamiltonian @xmath111\otimes |1\rangle \langle3| + { \rm h.c.}\,,$ ] where we have assumed the lamb - dicke parameters to be of the same order of magnitude , @xmath112 in general , if the frequencies @xmath113 and @xmath24 are commensurate the raman transition hamiltonian ( [ 60 ] ) contains resonances in addition to the ones considered in eq.([110 ] ) . as we will show in the next section , in the lamb - dicke limit
, the coupling constants corresponding to these additional resonances can be greatly reduced by increasing the ratio of the trap frequencies , @xmath114 the symmetric raman transition ( [ 110 ] ) is generated by a second pair of lasers as specified in eqs.([76])([78 ] ) . in particular
, we note that ( [ 76 ] ) can be satisfied with the choice @xmath115 and @xmath116 for the frequencies of the second pair of lasers . with respect to the virtual level @xmath117 for the motional dynamics of the trapped ion as discussed above . in the last step
, we now assume the lamb - dicke limit , where @xmath118 in this limit we approximate eq.([130 ] ) by keeping only the lowest order terms in @xmath119 and @xmath120 from eq.([115 ] ) , these are the terms @xmath121 and we obtain @xmath122 where @xmath123 is given in ( [ 115 ] ) .
the above hamiltonian ( [ 140 ] ) realizes the desired interaction ( [ 5 ] ) , between the two modes @xmath124 and @xmath19 of the ion s motion in the @xmath0- and @xmath1-direction .
we note that the coupling constant @xmath11 depends on the lamb - dicke parameters through the factor @xmath125 consequently for fixed laser power , i.e. fixed @xmath126 and @xmath127 and small lamb - dicke parameters , the coupling strength may be very small .
one can increase the coupling constant @xmath11 by increasing the laser power while at the same time maintaining inequality ( [ 30 ] ) .
this permits us to ignore the spontaneous emission from the excited state @xmath57 on a timescale @xmath128 where @xmath129 is the rate of spontaneous decay from level @xmath57 @xcite .
this is important as the decoupling of the motional and electronic dynamics relies on maintaining the coherence of the electronic degrees of freedom . in section [ rotation ]
we will compare the timescales for spontaneous emission and the raman - generated motional dynamics for the specific case of rotation ( [ 6 ] ) , given the parameters of recent experiments @xcite .
in this section we further discuss the approximations under which the hamiltonian ( [ 140 ] ) , gives a valid description of the system dynamics .
first , we address the size of the corrections that we have neglected in the lamb - dicke approximation .
we then show that the coupling constants of the additional resonances in the case of commensurate trap frequencies can be made as small as these corrections for a suitably large ratio of the trap frequencies , @xmath114 finally , we discuss the limitations imposed on our hamiltonians from neglecting off - resonant transitions . from the previous section it is clear that the lamb - dicke limit is an important requirement for us to engineer the desired interaction ( [ 140 ] ) .
the lamb - dicke approximation led us from ( [ 130 ] ) to ( [ 140 ] ) under the assumption @xmath130 we note that both ( [ 130 ] ) and ( [ 140 ] ) couple the same vibrational states @xmath131 where @xmath132 denotes the usual number state basis for the two - dimensional harmonic oscillator .
therefore , we do not neglect any additional resonances between other states than the ones given in ( [ 170 ] ) by making the lamb - dicke approximation .
we define the lamb - dicke approximation for suitably small @xmath119 , @xmath133 to be the approximation where all terms in ( [ 130 ] ) of order @xmath134 smaller than the leading term are neglected i.e. @xmath135 where we have assumed the lamb - dicke parameters to be of the same order of magnitude , @xmath112 it is important to note that the orthogonality of the raman laser beams shown in fig.[fig1 ] is not essential . in fact , the size of the lamb - dicke parameters can be reduced by changing the geometry of the lasers and choosing the two raman beams to be almost counter - propagating . in this situation
the wave vectors @xmath136 and @xmath137 of the two raman beams have to be added and the numbers @xmath37 and @xmath38 in ( [ 40 ] ) are then the projections of @xmath138 onto the @xmath0- and @xmath1-axes respectively . as we have mentioned in the previous section , even in the case of an anisotropic trap ,
there are on - resonant terms in addition to the ones included in ( [ 110 ] ) when the trap frequencies are commensurate .
this is illustrated in fig.[fig4 ] , where @xmath139 and again , @xmath140 in addition to the @xmath141 transition shown in fig.[fig3 ] , the @xmath142 transition is resonantly coupled as in fig.[fig4 ] . in the following
we show that in the lamb - dicke limit , the coupling constants @xmath143 corresponding to these additional resonances satisfy @xmath144 if the ratio of the trap frequencies is chosen large enough .
these additional terms can thus be neglected in the lamb - dicke approximation .
we start by deriving the resonances that occur if the two trap frequencies @xmath145 and @xmath146 are multiples of each other . without loss of generality
we choose @xmath147 where @xmath148 is a positive integer number . in deriving the interaction ( [ 140 ] )
the laser frequencies were chosen to give the detunings @xmath149 and @xmath150 for the two pairs of coupling beams respectively .
we will explicitly consider only the first of these two cases , i.e. @xmath151 since the second follows analogously by interchanging the operators @xmath152 and @xmath153 and leads to the same limits for the trap ratio @xmath154 now , with ( [ 4000 ] ) , the resonance condition in ( [ 60 ] ) becomes @xmath155 where all numbers are positive integers . in order to simplify the discussion we categorize the resonances by introducing an integer number @xmath156 and rewrite ( [ 4010 ] ) , so that @xmath157 following this categorization , we divide the resonances determined by ( [ 4010 ] ) into the three cases , [ _ 1 _ ] @xmath158 [ _ 2 _ ] @xmath159 positive , and [ _ 3 _ ] @xmath159 negative .
we subdivide case [ _ 2 _ ] further into @xmath160\quad ( { \it i\/ } ) & \qquad & 0<n\leq { k_{\scriptstyle a}}% \quad \mbox{and}\quad 0<n\,l\leq { k_{\scriptstyle b}}\ , , \nonumber \\ ( { \it ii\/ } ) & \qquad & 0<n\leq { k_{\scriptstyle a}}\quad \mbox{and}\quad n\,l>% { k_{\scriptstyle b}}\ , , \nonumber \\[2ex ] \lbrack { \it 2b\/}]\quad ( { \it i\/ } ) & \qquad & n>{k_{\scriptstyle a}}\quad % \mbox{and}\quad 0<n\,l\leq { k_{\scriptstyle b}}\ , , \nonumber \\ ( { \it ii\/ } ) & \qquad & n>{k_{\scriptstyle a}}\quad \mbox{and}\quad n\,l>{k_{% \scriptstyle b}}\ , . \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] below we will examine the cases [ _ 1 _ ] and [ _ 2a_](_ii _ ) in detail as the later case contains resonances with the largest contribution besides the required resonance at @xmath161
. we have examined the other cases and will not repeat their analysis except to note that they all give rise to leading order corrections of order higher than those found in case [ _ 2a_](_ii _ ) in @xmath162 .
thus , to obtain the desired hamiltonian ( [ 140 ] ) , the resonances in case [ _ 2a_](_ii _ ) will impose the most stringent condition on the size of the trap ratio @xmath163 throughout this discussion we will consider only the lowest order terms in the lamb - dicke parameters , since we have already addressed the size of the corrections to the lamb - dicke approximation in the above . in case
[ _ 1 _ ] , we have @xmath158 so that from the resonance condition in ( [ 4020 ] ) we obtain @xmath164 and @xmath165 this is the case which leads us to the desired interaction ( [ 140 ] ) , and which we have discussed in the previous section .
we now consider case [ _ 2a_](_ii _ ) . here
, we have @xmath166 and @xmath167 so that from ( [ 4020 ] ) we obtain @xmath168 inserting these identities into ( [ 60 ] ) and keeping only the lowest order terms in the lamb - dicke approximation , i.e. @xmath169 we obtain @xmath170 where we have defined the coupling constant @xmath171 \frac { ( -i \eta_{12})^{{k_{\scriptstyle a}}-n } } { ( { k_{% \scriptstyle a } } - n ) ! } \frac{(i\eta_{23})^{l\,n-{k_{\scriptstyle b } } } } { % ( l\,n - { k_{\scriptstyle b}})!}\ , . \label{4170}\ ] ] we require the coupling constants of the above resonances ( [ 4150 ] ) to be smaller than or equal to the coupling constants of the terms that we have neglected in the lamb - dicke limit ( [ 3990 ] ) .
therefore , we have the condition @xmath172 where again , we assume both lamb - dicke parameters to be of the same order of magnitude , @xmath112 in order to derive a limit for the trap ratio @xmath148 from the above expression , we consider the factor containing the lamb - dicke parameters and the one containing the factorials separately . if @xmath173 we have @xmath174 which is satisfied if , @xmath175 since this condition has to hold for all @xmath159 in the range @xmath176 this leads to the requirement @xmath177 for the trap ratio @xmath178 next , we consider the term including the factorials .
we require this term to be smaller or equal to unity as under the above condition ( [ 4200 ] ) the factor containing the lamb - dicke parameters already satisfies ( [ 4190 ] ) .
we have @xmath179 where in the first inequality we made use of the fact that for the resonances we are discussing here , @xmath180 and the second inequality holds since , @xmath181 for all positive integers @xmath9 and @xmath182 from the above inequality ( [ 4210 ] ) the factor containing the lamb - dicke parameters is smaller or equal to unity if , @xmath183 and since this has to be satisfied for all @xmath159 in the range @xmath180 we require @xmath184 depending on the interaction that we want to generate , i.e. depending on the number @xmath12 the inequality ( [ 4200 ] ) or ( [ 4220 ] ) will impose the stronger limit on the trap anisotropy .
for the two examples given in ( [ 6 ] ) and ( [ 7 ] ) , we have @xmath185 and @xmath186 respectively . therefore , in order to generate the linear coupling hamiltonian ( [ 6 ] ) we require the trap ratio @xmath187 ( [ 4200 ] ) . for the cubic interaction ( [ 7 ] ) a trap ratio of @xmath188 is needed from ( [ 4220 ] ) . for the remaining cases [ _ 2a_](_i _ ) , [ _ 2b_](_i _ ) , [ _ 2b_](_ii _ ) and
[ _ 3 _ ] a similar analysis shows that the requirements ( [ 4200 ] ) and ( [ 4220 ] ) are sufficient to limit the strength of these resonances to ( [ 3990 ] ) .
although in the above discussion we have explicitly assumed the two trap frequencies @xmath189 and @xmath146 to be multiples of each other , the limits ( [ 4200 ] ) and ( [ 4220 ] ) also hold for commensurate trap frequencies . in this case
the trap ratio is a rational number , i.e. @xmath190 where @xmath191 and @xmath192 are positive integers .
since in the resonance condition ( [ 4020 ] ) all numbers need to be integers , the number @xmath159 which categorizes the resonances can only take on multiple values of @xmath193 so that @xmath194 is an integer . as we have discussed all integer values of @xmath156 any trap ratio @xmath190 which satisfies the inequalities ( [ 4200 ] ) and ( [ 4220
] ) suffices for the unwanted resonances to satisfy ( [ 3990 ] ) .
hence , for given values of @xmath195 and @xmath10 , the coupling constants of all additional resonances due to energy level degeneracies in the case of commensurate trap frequencies are at least a factor of @xmath196 smaller than the coupling constant of the desired resonance ( [ 140 ] ) , if the trap ratio is chosen large enough according to the limits in ( [ 4200 ] ) and ( [ 4220 ] ) . as pointed out by gardiner _ et .
@xcite , dropping all off - resonant terms in going from ( [ 90 ] ) to ( [ 140 ] ) imposes a limit on the time @xmath197 for which the hamiltonian ( [ 140 ] ) is a valid approximation .
this limit can be calculated in second order perturbation theory to be @xmath198 where @xmath199 is the effective coupling to the nearest off - resonant transition in ( [ 90 ] ) and @xmath200 is the corresponding detuning . if @xmath201 is a characteristic state which represents the highest energy state that we allow to be acted upon , the transitions @xmath202 are the strongest coupled off - resonant terms . for these two transitions
the limit becomes @xmath203 where we have assumed the lamb - dicke limit to calculate the coupling @xmath199 between the states ( [ 2050 ] ) .
we will further investigate the significance of the limitations discussed here in the section below where we concentrate on the linear coupling hamiltonian @xmath204 given in ( [ 6 ] ) .
in the following we use the above formalism to target the linear coupling hamiltonian @xmath20 given in ( [ 6 ] ) and show how this generates a rotation of the two - dimensional quantum motional state of the ion .
we then examine the validity of the approximations discussed in the previous section through a numerical analysis of this specific example .
the linear coupling @xmath18 is obtained from the symmetrically combined two - mode raman hamiltonian ( [ 90 ] ) through the particular choice @xmath205 for the raman detuning and adjusting the relative phase of the lasers such that the raman coupling constant @xmath206 is purely imaginary .
this leads to the hamiltonian ' '' '' ' '' ''
@xmath207 \quad \sum_{m,\mu , n,\nu } \frac{(-i \eta_{12})^{m+\mu}}{m!\ , \mu ! } \frac{(i\eta_{23})^{n+\nu } } { n!\ , \nu!}\ , \left.\!\hat{a}^\dagger\!\right.^m a^\mu\ , \left.\!\hat{b}% ^\dagger\!\right.^\nu b^n \nonumber \\[2ex ] & & \times\,\exp \big [ \,i\ , ( \nu_{\scriptstyle a } [ m-\mu-1 ] + \nu_{% \scriptstyle b } [ \nu+1-n ] + \delta_{13})\,t\,\big ] \ + \ { \rm h.c.}\ , , \label{5990}\end{aligned}\ ] ] ' '' '' ' '' '' 2 which , in the limits discussed in the previous section , results in the linear coupling @xmath208 the coupling constant @xmath11 in ( [ 6 ] ) is then given by @xmath209 the hamiltonian @xmath210 effects a rotation of the two - dimensional quantum motional state of the ion about the centre of the trap .
this can be seen by examining the action of the hamiltonian @xmath18 on the operators @xmath211 and @xmath212 using the baker - campbell - hausdorff theorem , we have @xmath213 where the angle @xmath214 and @xmath215 is the unitary transformation generated by the hamiltonian @xmath20 i.e. @xmath216 from ( [ 20 ] ) it is clear that the transformation in ( [ 6000 ] ) corresponds to a rotation of the rescaled coordinate system @xmath217 and @xmath218 through an angle @xmath219 so that in the rotated coordinate system we have @xmath220 now an arbitrary pure or mixed motional state of the ion is characterized by a density operator @xmath221 which can be written as @xmath222 & = & \sum_{m , n,\mu,\nu } \
\rho_{m , n}^{\mu,\nu } \ \frac{\left.\!\hat{a}% ^\dagger\!\right.^m \left.\!\hat{b}^\dagger\!\right.^n}{\sqrt{m!\,n ! } } \ |{0% } \rangle_{\scriptstyle a}|{0}\rangle_{\scriptstyle b } \langle{0}|_{% \scriptstyle a}\langle{0}|_{\scriptstyle b } \
\frac{\hat{a}^\mu \hat{b}^\nu}{% \sqrt{\mu!\,\nu!}}\ , .
\label{6030}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the time evolution of this state under the action of the hamiltonian @xmath223 is then given by @xmath224 & = & \sum_{m , n,\mu,\nu } \
\rho_{m , n}^{\mu,\nu } \ \frac{\left.\!\hat{a}% ^\dagger_{\theta}\!\right.^m \left.\!\hat{b}^\dagger_{\theta}\!\right.^n}{% \sqrt{m!\,n ! } } \ |{0}\rangle_{\scriptstyle a}|{0}\rangle_{\scriptstyle b } \langle{0}|_{\scriptstyle a}\langle{0}|_{\scriptstyle b }
\ \frac{\hat{a}% _ { \theta}^\mu \hat{b}_{\theta}^\nu}{\sqrt{\mu!\,\nu ! } } \nonumber \\[1ex ] & = & \sum_{m , n,\mu,\nu } \
\rho_{m , n}^{\mu,\nu } \
|{m}\rangle_{\scriptstyle % a}^\theta|{n}\rangle_{\scriptstyle b}^\theta \langle{\mu}|_{\scriptstyle % a}^\theta\langle{\nu}|_{\scriptstyle b}^\theta\ , , \label{6040}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used ( [ 6000 ] ) and @xmath225 is the number state basis for the two - dimensional harmonic oscillator but now in the rotated coordinates @xmath226 and @xmath227 as given in ( [ 6020 ] ) .
therefore the motional state of the ion given by @xmath228 is identical to @xmath229 but rotated through an angle @xmath230 in particular , this is accomplished without prior knowledge of the motional state @xmath231 having convinced ourselves that the linear coupling hamiltonian @xmath210 does rotate an arbitrary motional state of the ion we now examine the validity of the approximations discussed in the previous section for this specific example of the general coupling hamiltonian ( [ 140 ] ) .
we consider a state rotation through the angle @xmath232 so that @xmath233 is the required time to rotate the state .
for this case , the limitations due to off - resonant terms ( section [ offresonant ] ) as given in eq.([2060 ] ) take the form @xmath234 in the limit of small @xmath173 and where we have assumed @xmath24 to be the smaller of the two trap frequencies . here ,
@xmath235 in ( [ 2060 ] ) . from eq.([6050 ] ) it is clear that the ratio of the lower trap frequency over the raman coupling constant , @xmath236 determines the significance of off - resonant terms in the system dynamics . from our discussion of the significance of additional on - resonant terms ( section [ anisotropy ] )
we require a trap ratio @xmath237 for the linear coupler where @xmath110 ( [ 4200 ] ) . the estimates used to determine this minimal trap ratio essentially compare the coupling strengths of the different terms appearing in the hamiltonian ( [ 5990 ] ) with no reference to the actual state on which it acts .
although this method of estimation is used in the literature , it can only serve as a rough guide . a more rigorous measure of how the unitary time evolution @xmath238 , generated by the symmetrically combined two - mode raman hamiltonian ( [ 5990 ] ) , deviates from the desired unitary evolution @xmath239 , generated by the linear coupling hamiltonian ( [ 6 ] ) , can be quite complicated .
a fully rigorous state independent measure of the difference between two unitary operators can be constructed @xcite , but we will not consider this here . in order to examine the validity of the approximations discussed in the previous section we adopt the overlap @xmath240 as a measure of the deviation between the two unitary evolutions @xmath241 and @xmath215 for an initially pure quantum state @xmath242 gives the unitary evolution of the initial state @xmath243 under the action of the symmetrically combined raman hamiltonian ( [ 5990 ] ) , and the state @xmath244 gives the desired evolution of the initial state under the action of the linear coupling hamiltonian ( [ 6 ] ) .
this can not be calculated analytically .
to go beyond the analytics we numerically compute the unitary evolution ( [ 6056 ] ) , including the higher on - resonant and off - resonant terms , on the initial pure state , @xmath245 , where @xmath246 are coherent states in the vibrational modes @xmath15 and @xmath19 respectively . in this case
the desired state ( [ 6057 ] ) , rotated through @xmath247 , is given by @xmath248 .
there we plot the overlap @xmath249 as a function of the scaled time @xmath250 for different values of the parameter @xmath251 given by ( [ 6055 ] ) and a coherent state amplitude @xmath252 before we discuss our results we note the following on our choice of parameters . in fig.[fig5](a)(d ) , @xmath129 takes on the values @xmath253 where @xmath254 in unit steps , and the raman coupling constant @xmath255 is kept constant . for simplicity
, we assume the geometry of the laser excitation to be arranged so that the lamb - dicke parameters @xmath256 and @xmath257 are equal . here
it is important to note that the values of the lamb - dicke parameters @xmath119 and @xmath258 depend on the size of the trap frequencies @xmath3 and @xmath259 through @xmath260 and @xmath261 therefore the size of the lamb - dicke parameters depends on @xmath129 and varies from fig.[fig5](a ) to ( d ) . to incorporate this dependency in our numerical analysis we put @xmath262 which gives @xmath263 when @xmath264 these are values for the lamb - dicke parameters and the ratio @xmath129 which have been demonstrated in cold ion experiments @xcite .
following our discussion of the trap anisotropy we choose the trap ratio @xmath265 our numerical analysis was performed in a finite ( truncated ) number state basis ( @xmath266 ) with a cutoff chosen such that an increase of this cutoff does not significantly alter the result of our integration .
fig.[fig5](a ) shows the time evolution of the overlap @xmath249 for the lowest value of @xmath267 here the off - resonant terms in eq.([5990 ] ) cause strong modulations in @xmath268 for higher values of @xmath129 these modulations become much less pronounced as the off - resonant terms contribute less on these timescales ( fig.[fig5](b)(d ) ) .
the time evolution of @xmath249 for the highest value of @xmath129 is shown with the solid line in fig.[fig5](d ) .
the plot reaches a maximum of @xmath269 at @xmath270 it shows almost no deviation from the dashed line in fig.[fig5 ] ( d ) which is a numerical integration of the system dynamics where we only include the desired resonances in the hamiltonian as in ( [ 130 ] ) .
the numerical analysis shows that for low system excitation the hamiltonian @xmath271 can be engineered with high accuracy within present ion traps .
to investigate the system dynamics for higher energies becomes computationally very expensive . to achieve the same accuracy as obtained for @xmath272 for higher values of @xmath273
the number state basis must be greatly enlarged . in the above
, we neglected decoherence . from our final comments in section [ specificcoupling ] , using the experimental parameters @xcite for @xmath274 with @xmath275mhz , @xmath276khz , @xmath277ghz and @xmath263 we find @xmath278 this is to be compared with the time to rotate the motional state through the angle @xmath279 @xmath280 this confirms our initial assumption that decoherence through spontaneous emission can be neglected for this process .
however , this may not be the case when engineering higher order interactions .
one can shorten the interaction time by increasing the laser power while maintaining inequality ( [ 30 ] ) by increasing the detunings @xmath281 and @xmath282 the fundamental limit is then given by the detunings that one can realize and the accessible laser power .
in this work we showed how one can engineer a class of hamiltonians for the motional dynamics of an ultra - cold ion in a harmonic trap .
the process uses a stimulated raman transition in a @xmath283-configuration with the two lasers propagating along the @xmath0- and @xmath1-directions . to decouple the internal electronic dynamics from the external motional dynamics we constructed a hamiltonian in which these evolutions factored .
this was done through the addition of a second pair of lasers which generated the symmetric counter - part to the hamiltonian generated by the first pair of lasers . by preparing the electronic states in a particular superposition , the internal and external dynamics completely separated and we could treat the motional dynamics alone . in the lamb - dicke limit and with suitable sideband detunings ,
we could `` target '' a particular term to be of leading order in the hamiltonian .
however , we found that besides the term we wanted to dominate , other , higher on - resonant terms appeared .
we could manipulate the strengths of the couplings to these unwanted terms by altering the trap frequency ratio and found that we could neglect these unwanted terms in the lamb - dicke approximation for large enough trap anisotropies . finally , we did a numerical evaluation of the full hamiltonian as a check on the analytical estimates .
although we have primarily concentrated on the linear rotation hamiltonian ( [ 6 ] ) , higher order dynamics can be generated i.e. @xmath284 given by eq.([7 ] ) .
the nonlinear hamiltonian @xmath285 has been much studied in the quantum optical literature as a model of nonlinearly - coupled field modes @xcite .
we know from this work that such hamiltonians generate a rich nonlinear dynamical structure reflecting the strong mode entanglement characteristic of those couplings .
their optical realization is difficult , but may well be more straightforward in trapped ion dynamics , as resonances can then be used to isolate chosen nonlinearities . finally , we note the recent publication of two papers @xcite which examine types of non - linear interaction hamiltonians in the motion of trapped ions which are closely related to the work presented here .
this work was supported in part by the uk engineering and physical sciences research council and the european community .
j. steinbach is supported by the german academic exchange service ( daad - doktorandenstipendium aus mitteln des zweiten hochschulsonderprogramms ) .
we thank dr .
gou for helpful discussions and s. schneider for her helpful comments on the manuscript .
in this appendix we derive the effective hamiltonian given in ( [ 40 ] ) which follows from the adiabatic elimination of the excited level @xmath57 and describes the raman coupling between the two ground state levels @xmath286 ) becomes @xmath287 & & - \
|1\rangle \langle2| \otimes \hbar g_{12 } \,\,e^{-i\ , ( k_{12}\hat{x } - \omega_{12 } t ) } - |2\rangle \langle1|\otimes\hbar g_{12}^ * \ , \,e^{i\ , ( k_{12}\hat{x } - \omega_{12 } t ) } \nonumber \\[2ex ] & & - \ |3\rangle \langle2|\otimes\hbar g_{23 } \ , \,e^{-i\ , ( k_{23}\hat{y } - \omega_{23 } t ) } - |2\rangle \langle3|\otimes \hbar g_{23}^ * \ , \,e^{i\ , ( k_{23}\hat{y } - \omega_{23 } t ) } \ , , \label{1000}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have defined the dipole coupling constants @xmath288 and @xmath289 in order to compare the timescales of the transitions induced by the two laser beams we consider the heisenberg equations of motion for the transition operators @xmath290 and @xmath291 @xmath292 i \frac{d}{dt } \ , \hat{\overline{\sigma}}_{13 } & = & ( \omega_3 - \omega_1 ) \ , \hat{\overline{\sigma}}_{13 } - g_{23 } \,e^{-i\ , ( k_{23}\hat{\overline{y } } - \omega_{23 } t)}\,\hat{\overline{\sigma}}_{12 } + g_{12}^*\,e^{i\ , ( k_{12}\hat{% \overline{x } } - \omega_{12 } t)}\,\hat{\overline{\sigma}}_{23}\ , .
\label{1010}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , all operators ( denoted by overbars ) are taken in the heisenberg picture , i.e. @xmath293 where @xmath294}$ ] is the time ordered evolution operator . using the transformation @xmath295 to remove the explicit time dependencies from ( [ 1010 ] ) we have @xmath296 i \frac{d}{dt } \ ,
\hat{\widetilde{\sigma}}_{13 } & = & ( \delta_{12 } - \delta_{23})\,\hat{\widetilde{\sigma}}_{13 } - g_{23 } \,e^{-i\,k_{23}\hat{% \overline{y}}}\,\hat{\widetilde{\sigma}}_{12 } + g_{12}^*\,e^{i\,k_{12}\hat{% \overline{x}}}\,\hat{\widetilde{\sigma}}_{23}\ , .
\label{1030}\end{aligned}\ ] ] under the assumption of large detunings , as given in ( [ 30 ] ) , we obtain the adiabatic solution for @xmath297 by setting @xmath298 @xcite so that after restoring the rapidly oscillating time dependence , we obtain @xmath299 for the @xmath300 transition we find in an analogous manner @xmath301 upon inserting these adiabatic solutions for @xmath302 and @xmath303 into ( [ 1000 ] ) , we have @xmath304 & & - \hbar g_{13 } \ , e^{-i(k_{12}\hat{x } - k_{23}\hat{y } - ( \omega_{12 } - \omega_{23})t ) } \,\otimes |1\rangle \langle3| - \hbar g_{13}^ * \ , e^{i(k_{12}\hat{x } - k_{23}\hat{y } - ( \omega_{12 } - \omega_{23})t ) } \ , \otimes|3\rangle \langle1| \ , , \label{1050}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have dropped the term describing the free energy of the excited state @xmath57 since in this adiabatic approximation it is no longer connected to the two ground states .
furthermore we have defined the raman coupling constant as given in ( [ 50 ] ) , and the energies @xmath305 and @xmath306 ( [ 55 ] ) of the ground state levels @xmath28 and @xmath49 which are stark shifted as a result of the adiabatic elimination of the excited state .
f. diedrich , j.c .
bergquist , w.m .
itano , and d.j .
wineland , phys .
lett . * 62 * , 403 ( 1989 ) ; c. monroe , d.m .
meekhof , b.e .
king , s.r .
jefferts , w.m .
itano , and d.j .
wineland , phys .
* 75 * , 4011 ( 1995 ) .
d. leibfried , d.m .
meekhof , b.e .
king , c. monroe , w.m .
itano , and d.j .
wineland , phys . rev .
lett . * 77 * , 4281 ( 1996 ) . for theoretical work on state reconstruction for trapped ions ,
see r.l .
de matos filho and w. vogel , phys .
lett . * 76 * , 4520 ( 1996 ) ; s. wallentowitz and w. vogel , phys .
lett . * 75 * , 2932 ( 1995 ) , j.f .
poyatos , r. walser , j.i .
cirac , p. zoller , and r. blatt , phys .
a * 53 * , r1966 ( 1996 ) ; p.j .
bardroff , c. leichtle , g. schrade , and w.p .
schleich , phys .
* 77 * , 2198 ( 1996 ) ; c. dhelon and g.j .
milburn , phys .
a * 52 * , 4755 ( 1995 ) ; c. dhelon and g.j .
milburn , phys .
a * 54 * , r25 ( 1996 ) ; c. dhelon and g.j .
milburn , phys .
a * 54 * , 5141 ( 1996 ) .
g. drobny and i. jex , phys .
a * 45 * , 4897 ( 1992 ) ; v. buek and g. drobny , phys .
a * 47 * , 1237 ( 1993 ) ; g. drobny , i. jex , and v. buek , acta phys .
slov . * 44 * , 155 ( 1994 ) ; k. banaszek and p.l .
knight , phys .
a * 55 * , 2368 ( 1997 ) . | we describe how two vibrational degrees of freedom of a single trapped ion can be coupled through the action of suitably - chosen laser excitation .
we concentrate on a two - dimensional ion trap with dissimilar vibrational frequencies in the @xmath0- and @xmath1-directions of motion , and derive from first principles a variety of quantized two - mode couplings , concentrating on a linear coupling which takes excitations from one mode to another .
we demonstrate how this can result in a state rotation , in which it is possible to transfer the motional state of the ion from say the @xmath0-direction to the @xmath2-direction without prior knowledge of that motional state . 2 |
in the study of periodic crystalline solids , the electronic ground - state wave function is usually described in terms of bloch functions , delocalized on the whole system . as a consequence , for a long time , the understanding of electron localization in crystalline solids was mainly based on approximate pictures .
nevertheless , the basics of a quantitative characterization of electron localization had already been formulated by w. kohn @xcite in 1964 . recently
this problematic was renewed , thanks to the development of the theory of polarization based on berry phases @xcite , and the rigorous definition of the position operator in periodic systems @xcite .
these ideas have been further developped using a cumulant generating function approach @xcite .
following these advances , sgiarovello and co - workers @xcite , have computed the localization lengths for different cubic semiconductors , in the framework of the kohn - sham density functional theory @xcite ( dft ) .
they showed that the degree of electron localization is quite different for the various investigated materials .
these results encourage to pursue the study to other insulating crystals .
the localization tensor @xmath2 , can be computed from the periodic part of the bloch functions @xmath3 and their first derivatives with respect to their wavevector : @xmath4 where @xmath5 is the volume of the primitive unit cell , @xmath6 the number of doubly occupied bands and @xmath0 , @xmath7 are two cartesian directions .
the localization tensor is a _
quantity that characterizes the occupied kohn - sham manifold as a _ whole _
( all k - points and all bands ) .
this statement calls for two comments .
first , applications of dft to solids often make use of the frozen - core and pseudopotential approximations , while eq.([eq_tens1 ] ) requires an all - electron calculation .
second , the behavior of core and valence electrons is treated globally while both kinds of electrons are expected to exhibit strongly different localization properties interesting to identify independently . the localization tensor has been shown @xcite to give a lower bound for the spread of maximally localized wannier functions ( wf ) as defined by marzari and vanderbilt @xcite ( hereafter cited as mv ) . in order to get some insight into the physics of the chemical bonds in molecules and solids , such wf
are usually constructed considering only a restricted number of electronic bands close to the fermi level .
the spread of the resulting wf is strongly dependent of the electronic states included in the minimization process . in this context
, it seems interesting to try to identify the intrinsic localization of the electrons in a specific set of bands and to understand how this quantity is affected when including other bands . this would allow to solve the problem associated to the use of pseudopotentials and to characterize separately the behavior of core and valence electrons .
this paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ sec_bbb ] , we propose a decomposition of the localization tensor into contributions originating from isolated sets of bands composing the energy spectrum of a solid . using a simple model , we then illustrate the role of the covalent interactions on the different terms of the decomposition .
we also make a connection between the localization tensor and the born effective charges and we discuss the relation between pseudopotential and all - electron calculations . in sec .
[ sec_method ] , we give the technical details underlying our first - principles calculations and we point out the differences between our method and that applied in ref . .
in sec . [ sec_res ] and [ sec_disc ] , we present the results obtained on two ferroelectric perovskites ( batio@xmath1 and pbtio@xmath1 ) as well as on two binary oxides ( bao and @xmath0-pbo ) .
we investigate the variation of electron localization during the phase transitions of batio@xmath1 and show that the evolution is compatible with the electronic structure of this compound .
contrary to the polarization and the born effective charges , for which band - by - band decompositions have been previously reported @xcite , the localization tensor ( eq .
( [ eq_tens1 ] ) ) involves scalar products between bloch functions of different bands , making the identification of the contribution of isolated sets of bands less straightforward . in order to explain this fact , we have to remember that the localization tensor is related to the second moment of wf while the born effective charges and the spontaneous polarization are linked to their first moment . from standard statistics
, it is well known that these two quantities do not add the same way : when considering two random variables @xmath8 and @xmath9 , the mean value of the sum @xmath10 is simply the sum of the mean values while the variance of the sum is the sum of the variances _ plus _ an additional term , the covariance .
these considerations can be transposed in the simple context of a confined model system made of two orthonormalized states @xmath11 and @xmath12 .
the total many - body wavefunction @xmath13 is a slater determinant constructed on the one - particle orbitals .
the center of mass is given by the expectation value of the position operator @xmath14 @xmath15 while the total spread ( two times the localization tensor ) is related to @xmath16 , @xmath17 we see that the first moments of the one - particle orbitals add to form the total dipole of the many - body wavefunction . on the contrary ,
the total spread is not equal to the sum of the individual spreads of @xmath18 and @xmath19 but involves also matrix elements of the one - particle position operator @xmath20 between @xmath18 and @xmath19 .
the additional term would be absent if the many - body wavefunction was a simple product of the one - particle orbitals .
it arises from the anti - symmetry requirement . in analogy with the language of statistics
, we will name it the _
covariance_. based on these arguments , we can now define a band - by - band decomposition of eq .
( [ eq_tens1 ] ) .
suppose that the band structure is formed of @xmath21 groups labelled @xmath22 , each of them composed of @xmath23 bands ( @xmath24 ) .
the variance of a particular group @xmath22 is defined as @xmath25 where the sums have to be taken over the bands of group @xmath22 .
the covariance of two groups @xmath22 and @xmath26 ( @xmath27 ) is given by the following relationship : @xmath28 using these definitions , the total tensor , associated to the whole set of occupied bands , can be written as @xmath29 the variance @xmath30 is intrinsic to an isolated set of bands .
it is related @xcite to the quantity @xmath31 introduced by mv through the relation @xmath32 in a one - dimensional crystal , @xmath31 is simply the lower bound of the total spread @xmath33 of the wf represents the expectation value over the @xmath34 occupied wannier function in the unit cell ] , @xmath35,\ ] ] that can be realized by choosing an adequate phase factor for the bloch functions . in a three - dimensional crystal ,
it is no more possible to construct wf that are simultaneously maximally localized in all cartesian directions .
it is only possible to minimize their spread in one given direction as realized for the so - called hermaphrodite orbitals introduced in ref . :
these particular functions are localized ( wannier - like ) in a given direction @xmath0 and delocalized ( bloch - like ) in the two others .
the variance of a particular group of bands @xmath36 is the lower bound of the _ average _ spread @xmath37 $ ] where the sum is taken over all wannier - like functions in the unit cell belonging to group @xmath22 .
this lower bound is reached for wf that are maximally localized in direction @xmath0 .
the variance therefore gives some insight on the localization of the electrons within a specific set of bands taken independently .
this localization is affected by the hybridizations between atomic orbitals giving rise to the formation of the considered electronic bands within the solid so that the variance can act as a probe to characterize these hybridizations .
the covariance is no more related to an isolated set of bands .
it teaches us how the construction of wf including other bands can improve the localization . as discussed by mv ,
the definition of groups of bands in a solid is not unique and sometimes there is a doubt about which bands have to be considered together . if we consider two sets of bands @xmath22 and
@xmath26 as one single group , its total variance is the sum of the individual variances _ and _ covariances , that have to be rescaled by the number of bands in each group @xmath38 + n_j \left [ \langle r_{\alpha } r_{\beta } \rangle_c(g_j ) + n_i \langle r_{\alpha } r_{\beta } \rangle_c(g_j , g_i ) \right ] \right \}.\ ] ] until now , we considered separately the two cartesian directions @xmath0 and @xmath7 .
stronger results can be obtained when diagonal elements of the localisation tensor are considered , or when this localication tensor is diagonalized , and the eigenvalues are considered .
different inequalities can be derived . in particular , from eq .
( [ eq_bbb5 ] ) , it appears that the covariances for @xmath39 are always _ negative_.
this means that the diagonal elements of the full tensor are always smaller than those obtained by the sum of the diagonal variances . in other words , it is always possible to obtain more strongly localized orbitals by constructing wf considering more than one group of bands . as a consequence the covariance appears as a tool to identify which bands have to be considered together in the construction of wf in order to improve their localization . in appendix [ sec_opticalc ]
we give an interpretation of the variance and covariance in terms of the optical conductivity .
it illustrates from a different viewpoint the influence of the fermionic nature of the electrons on the localization tensor : the appearance of the covariance in eq .
( [ eq_bbb6 ] ) is a direct consequence of the pauli principle . in this section
we will investigate a one - dimensional model system .
this will help us to understand the role of the covalent interactions on the electron localization length and related quantities like the born effective charges .
we will deal with a confined system for which the localization tensor can be computed from matrix elements of the position operator and its square as described in ref . .
let us consider a diatomic molecule xy .
in order to describe the chemical bonds of this model system we adopt a tight - binding scheme @xcite defined by the hopping integral @xmath40 and the on - site terms @xmath41 and @xmath42 . we will call @xmath43 the interatomic distance and @xmath44 , @xmath45 the s - like atomic orbitals that are used as basis functions
. the hamiltonian can be rescaled by @xmath41 ( a = t/@xmath41 ) in order to become a one parameter hamiltonian defined by @xmath46 we further assume that @xmath44 is centered at the origin , @xmath45 in @xmath43 and that these two functions do not overlap at any @xmath47 @xmath48 the eigenfunctions of the hamiltonian correspond to @xmath49 where the coefficients @xmath50 and @xmath51 can be expressed in terms of the bond polarity @xcite @xmath52 ( @xmath53 ) : @xmath54 in order to see the meaning of the different terms appearing in the band by band decomposition of the localization tensor and the born effective charges let us first consider the molecular orbitals independently . the variance of state @xmath55 can be computed from the coefficients @xmath56 and @xmath57 .
it writes @xmath58 where @xmath59 and @xmath60 are the second central moments of @xmath44 and @xmath45 .
the variance of @xmath61 is given by a similar expression .
this quantity is composed of three positive terms that summarize the mechanisms that are able to delocalize the electrons with respect to the atomic orbitals . on one hand , the electronic cloud on a particular atom is not a delta - dirac function but presents a degree of delocalization related to @xmath59 and @xmath60 ( first and second term ) .
when the state @xmath55 is made entirely of @xmath44 , that is , when @xmath52 equals one , the localization length is correctly equal to @xmath59 ( first term ) . incorporating more @xmath45 changes the localization length in proportion of @xmath52 ( the balance between first and second terms ) . on the other hand ,
the electrons can occupy two sites @xmath62 and @xmath63 that are separated by a distance @xmath43 ( third term ) .
this term scales as @xmath64 .
even a small covalent interaction is thus able to induce an important delocalization if it acts on a sufficiently large distance .
the born effective charge of atom @xmath62 is defined as the derivative of the dipole moment @xmath65 with respect to @xmath43 .
this dipole moment is the sum of the nuclear and static electronic charges multiplied by the interatomic distance .
the contribution coming from the electrons occupying state @xmath55 is equal to @xmath66 where @xmath67 is the module of the electronic charge .
the derivative of eq .
( [ eq_dip ] ) with respect to @xmath43 gives the contribution of these electrons to the total effective charge @xmath68 the first term is the ( static ) effective atomic charge @xcite of atom x while the second term represents an additional dynamical contribution due to a transfer on electrons between @xmath62 and @xmath63 during a relative atomic displacement .
the contribution of the electrons occupying state @xmath61 is given by a similar expression @xmath69 this simple model illustrates how both the variance of the localization tensor and the born effective charges depend on the covalent interactions defined by the parameter @xmath70 . the variance is a
quantity depending on the amplitude of the covalent interations only while the the born effective charges are _ dynamical _ quantities that also depend on the variations of these interactions during a relative atomic displacement .
if we now consider the states @xmath55 and @xmath61 as a single group we have to add their variances and covariances to get the whole localization tensor .
the covariance reduces to @xmath71 by adding this covariance to the variance in eq .
( [ eq_model_var ] ) , we remove in some sense the delocalization induced by the covalent interactions .
the total localization tensor becomes independent of the hopping @xmath70 and the interatomic distance @xmath43 .
it reduces to the mean spread of the atomic orbitals @xmath44 and @xmath45 : @xmath72 eq .
( [ eq_model_loctens ] ) defines the mean spread of the wf constructed as linear combinations of @xmath55 and @xmath61 that minimize the spread functional @xmath33 ( see eq .
( [ eq_mvspread ] ) ) . as shown by mv , these wf diagonalize the position operator @xmath20 projected on the subspace of occupied states .
they are thus equal to the atomic orbitals since the hypothesis of zero overlap ( eq . ( [ eq_model2 ] ) ) implies @xmath73 .
the total born effective charge of atom @xmath62 can be obtained by adding the nuclear charge @xmath74 to the terms ( [ eq_zast ] ) and ( [ eq_zast2 ] ) .
it is easy to check that for this model @xmath75 is equal to zero .
this result can be interpreted in two ways .
the point of view usually adopted is to say that the two molecular orbitals are of the opposite polarity so that the total dipole of the molecule vanishes .
based on the results of the preceeding paragraph , we can also affirm that each maximally localized wf is confined on a single atom so that no interatomic charge transfer can take place .
this result suggests that the variance gives more informations about the localization of electrons of particular chemical bonds than the total localization tensor .
it also illustrates the observation of ghosez _ et al . _
@xcite that anomalous effective charges mainly come from hybridizations between occupied and unoccupied states .
in fact , the different chemical bonds generate opposite effects so that a net charge transfer is possible only if some of them are unoccupied . in summary ,
we have illustrated the mechanisms that govern the variance of the localization tensor and the born effective charges in the particular case of a one dimensional model system .
the observations made in this section give us an intuitive understanding of how delocalized electrons can generate _ anomalous _ effective charges .
hybridizations between occupied states generate opposite effects that tend to cancel out when they are summed . because of the simplicity of the above adopted picture
, we have however to be careful when we apply this model to real materials .
first , we considered only hybridizations between two types of atomic orbitals , while the chemical bonds in real systems generally result from more complicated interactions .
in particular , we neglected on - site hybridizations that are also able to generate _ anomalous _ effective charges but that induce a stronger localization on the electronic cloud . second , the hypothesis of zero overlap ( [ eq_model2 ] ) is not always fullfilled so that maximally localized wf constructed on the whole set of occupied states generally not reduce to the atomic orbitals .
nevertheless , this simple model will allow us to interpret some results in sections [ sec_res ] and [ sec_disc ] . as mentioned in the introduction
, there is a fundamental problem in the computation of the total localization tensor when pseudopotentials are used .
this is due to the fact that the localization tensor is related to the bands of the system as a whole : first , there is no cancellation between the core electrons and the nuclear charge , as it is the case in the computation of the total polarization ; second , the localization tensor is a kind of mean over all bands , that combines strongly localized ( core ) states , and weakly localized ( valence ) states .
this is clearly seen in eq.([eq_tens1 ] ) , where the number of bands explicitely appears both as the denominator of the prefactor and in the two summations .
the band - by - band decomposition allows us to overcome this problem partly , by focusing only on the variances of isolated groups of bands .
thanks to eq .
( [ eq_bbb7 ] ) it is also possible to get some insight into the physics of the all - electron localization tensor when pseudopotentials are used . in this section , we focus on the diagonal elements of the electron localization tensor @xmath39 ( of course , any direction can be chosen as @xmath0 ) . in an all - electron calculation ,
let us consider separately two sets of bands : core bands ( labelled as co ) , and valence bands ( labelled as va ) .
the total localization tensor can be obtained from the localization tensors of each group of bands , combined with the covariance between the two groups of bands : @xmath76 both variances @xmath77 and @xmath78 are positive quantities .
the covariance times the product of the number of bands @xmath79 , a negative quantity , must always be smaller in magnitude than each of the related variances multiplied by the corresponding number of bands .
this translates to bounds on the diagonal elements of the total localization tensor : @xmath80 in the frozen - core approximation , @xmath77 can be obtained from separate all - electron calculations for each atom of the system .
the localization tensor of the valence bands is ( likely ) computed accurately in the pseudopotential approximation : the spread of the wannier functions should be quite similar if estimated from all - electron valence wavefunctions or from pseudo - wavefunctions .
thus , a _ bound _ on the diagonal elements of the localization tensor _ can be computed _ from the atomic wavefunctions of the core electrons and the pseudo - valence wavefunctions . in order to compute the covariance more
accurately it is necessary to reconstruct the all - electron wavefunctions .
this could be done following the ideas exposed in ref . .
in the remaining part of this paper , we apply the previous formalism to various oxides .
the electronic wavefunctions are obtained within dft @xcite and the local density approximation ( lda ) thanks to the abinit @xcite package . at variance with a previous work on semiconductors @xcite ,
the first derivatives of the wave functions with respect to their wavevector are not computed from finite differences but from a linear - response approach @xcite within the parallel - transport gauge .
the wave functions are further transformed to the diagonal gauge @xcite .
both ground - state and first - order wavefunctions are expanded in plane waves up to a kinetic - energy cutoff of 45 hartree .
integrations over the bz are replaced by sums over a @xmath81 mesh of special k - points @xcite . with these parameters ,
the convergence of the localization tensor for the investigated compounds is better than 10@xmath82 bohr@xmath83 .
the ionic - core electron potentials of the ba , pb , ti and o atoms are replaced by ab initio , separable , extended norm - conserving pseudopotentials , as proposed by m. teter @xcite .
ba 5s , 5p and 6s electrons , pb 6s , 5d and 6p electrons , ti 3s , 3p and 3d electrons , o 2s and 2p electrons are considered as valence states . beside calculating the localization tensor on bulk - materials , we also computed it on the isolated atomic systems ba@xmath84 , pb@xmath84 and o by placing each atom at the origin of a periodic supercell of 20 bohrs .
as shown by sgiarovello _
et al . _
@xcite , the localization tensor and thus the variances and covariances , are real .
moreover , they are obviously symmetric in @xmath0 and @xmath7 .
consequently there exists a set of cartesian axes where they are diagonal and their eigenvalues are also real numbers . in the discussion of our results we will always work in this particular frame so that we do not need to consider the off - diagonal elements of the localization tensor .
we will consider the two binary oxides bao and @xmath0-pbo as well as the ferroelectric perovskites batio@xmath1 and pbtio@xmath1 .
bao has a rocksalt structure while the tetragonal @xmath0 phase of lead oxide is formed of parallel layers of pb and o atoms . batio@xmath1 and pbtio@xmath1 have a high - temperature cubic perovskite structure with five atoms per unit cell . as the temperature is lowered , the former compound undergoes a sequence of three ferroelectric phase transitions transforming to tetragonal , orthorhombic and rhombohedral structures while the latter compound only undergoes one single transition from the cubic to the tetragonal phase .
we will consider explicitely the cubic , tetragonal and rhombohedral phases of batio@xmath1 as well as the cubic phase of pbtio@xmath1 .
the electronic structures of these compounds have been previously studied @xcite and are illustrated in fig .
[ fig_bdstr ] .
they are formed of well separated groups of bands .
each of them has a marked dominant orbital character and can be labeled by the name of the atomic orbital that mainly composes the energy state in the solid .
the bands at the fermi level are mainly composed of o 2p states that show significant interactions with other atomic orbitals like the well known o 2p - ti 3d hybridization in batio@xmath1 and pbtio@xmath85 .
the bandstructures in the ferroelectric phases of batio@xmath1 are similar to that of the cubic phase .
the phase transitions principally affect the bandgap and the spread of the o 2p bands while the positions of the deeper lying bands remain quite constant .
the main difference in the electronic structures of bao and batio@xmath1 on one hand and pbo and pbtio@xmath1 on the other hand comes from the presence or absence of pb 6s electrons ( that form the so called lone - pair in pbo ) .
these electrons show a strong hybridization with the o 2p states . as a consequence the o 2p and pb 6s bands are degenerate at the @xmath86 point in pbtio@xmath1 and around the @xmath87 point in pbo .
consequently , we have to consider them as one single group of bands in the decomposition of the localization tensor .
band structures of bao , cubic batio@xmath1 , cubic pbtio@xmath1 and @xmath0-pbo.,width=302 ] as the total localization tensor is meaningless in pseudopotential calculations that do not include covariances with the core states , we focus on the variances of the different groups of bands .
the values can be found in the tables [ tab_ba ] and [ tab_pb ] where they are compared to the variances of the dominant atomic orbitals .
we do not report any values associated to the deepest lying ti 3s and ti 3p bands although they have been included in our pseudopotential calculation .
their variances are in fact close to the atomic ones and they do not show any sizeable covariance with other bands in both batio@xmath1 and pbtio@xmath1 . lcccccc system & str .
& element & + & & & ba 5s & o 2s & ba 5p & o 2p + atom & @xmath88 & @xmath89 & 1.011 & 0.929 & 1.370 & @xmath88 + bao & @xmath88 & @xmath89 & 1.065 & 1.552 & 2.023 & 2.199 + batio@xmath1 & c & @xmath89 & 1.091 & 0.950 & 2.189 & 1.875 + & t & @xmath90 & 1.091 & 0.945 & 2.180 & 1.852 + & & @xmath91 & 1.088 & 0.965 & 2.175 & 1.842 + & r & @xmath90 & 1.092 & 0.963 & 2.196 & 1.862 + & & @xmath91 & 1.092 & 0.949 & 2.189 & 1.804 + lcccc system & element & + & & o 2s & pb 5d & pb 6s + o 2p + atom & @xmath89 & 0.929 & 0.657 & @xmath88 + pbtio@xmath1 & @xmath89 & 1.874 & 1.490 & 1.749 + pbo & @xmath90 & 2.234 & 1.142 & 2.178 + & @xmath91 & 1.724 & 0.990 & 1.968 + in the cubic crystals bao , batio@xmath1 and pbtio@xmath1 as well as in the atomic systems , the reported tensors are isotropic so that we only mention their principal values @xmath89 .
this is no more true in the ferroelectric phases of batio@xmath1 where a weak anisotropy can be observed .
the tensors have an uniaxial character as the corresponding dielectric ones : they are diagonal when expressed in the principal axes and the elements @xmath92 and @xmath93 refer to cartesian directions perpendicular and parallel to the optical axis ( that has the direction of the spontaneous polarization ) .
a much stronger anisotropy is observed in @xmath0-pbo where the localization tensor has the same symmetry as in the ferroelectric phases of batio@xmath1 .
due to its particular structure formed of atomic pb - o planes the electrons of each group of bands
are more delocalized in a direction parallel ( @xmath92 ) to the atomic planes - pbo , the optical axis is perpendicular to the atomic layers . ] than perpendicular ( @xmath93 ) to them .
this observation agrees with our intuitive picture that the covalent interactions between atoms inside a layer are stronger than between atoms of different layers . examining the variances of the different groups of bands we see that
the ba 5s electrons show a similar degree of localization both in bao and batio@xmath1 also equivalent to that of the corresponding atomic orbital . on the contrary ,
the o 2s electrons behave differently in the materials under investigation : in batio@xmath1 , their variance is close to the atomic one while they show a significant larger delocalization in the three other compounds .
it is in fact surprising to see the degree of delocalization of the inner bands like the o 2s , ba 5p or pb 5d bands . in some cases like batio@xmath1 ,
the electrons of these bands are even more strongly delocalized than those of the bands at the fermi level .
these results suggest that the corresponding atomic orbitals are chemically not inert but present non negligible covalent interactions .
an interesting observation can be made for the o 2s and pb 5d bands in pbtio@xmath1 and @xmath0-pbo .
the delocalization induced by the covalent interactions that generate these bands tends to disappear when we consider them as one single group . in order to compute the variance of the whole o 2s and pb 5d bands
, we have to use eq .
( [ eq_bbb7 ] ) . as an example
let us consider pbtio@xmath1 .
the different elements can be summarized in a matrix where the diagonal elements are the variances ( bohr@xmath83 ) and the off - diagonal elements the covariances ( bohr@xmath83 ) of the individual groups @xmath94 the total variance of the ( o 2s + pb 5d ) group considered as a whole reduces to 0.734 bohr@xmath83 . for @xmath0-pbo
, we obtain similar values of 0.732 bohr@xmath83 for @xmath92 and 0.701 bohr@xmath83 for @xmath93 .
these values can be compared to the mean spread of the atomic orbitals @xmath95 the results presented above suggest that inner orbitals like o 2s , ba 5p or pb 5d are chemically not inert in the materials under investigation .
this observation seems in contradiction with the conclusions drawn from partial density of states analysis @xcite that these states are rather inert .
nevertheless the inspection of the born effective charges in bao or batio@xmath1 @xcite confirms our observations that will now be illustrated for @xmath0-pbo and pbtio@xmath1 .
this points out that the global shape of the bandstructure is less sensitive to the underlying covalent interactions than the variance of the localization tensor or the born effective charges . in order to investigate the connection between the localization tensor and the born effective charges we report in table [ tab_zstar ] the band by band decomposition of @xmath96 in pbtio@xmath1 and @xmath0-pbo . in the perovskite
, this tensor is isotropic while in @xmath0-pbo it has the same symmetry as the localization tensor .
the contribution of each group of bands has been separated into a reference nominal value and an _ anomalous _ charge . for @xmath0-pbo , we observe the same anisotropy as for the localization tensor : the covalent interactions inside an atomic layer ( @xmath97 ) generate larger _ anomalous _ contributions than the interactions involving atoms of different layers ( @xmath98 ) . by looking at the o 2s and pb 5d bands we see that they generate important anomalous charges that confirm our observations concerning the variances of these bands .
interestingly , in both materials these contributions cancel out when they are summed .
we observe thus the same tendencies for the born effective charges and the localization tensor : the effects induced by the covalent interactions between inner orbitals tend to disappear when the resulting bands are considered together .
lrrrrr & & & & + band & & @xmath96 & & @xmath97&@xmath98 + core & & 14.00 & & 14.00 & 14.00 + o 2s & & 0 + 3.47 & & 0 + 1.89 & 0 + 0.26 + pb 5d & & -10 - 3.36 & & -10 - 1.80 & -10 - 0.40 + pb 6s + o 2p & & -2 + 1.78 & & -2 + 1.06 & -2 + 0.48 + tot .
& & 2 + 1.89 & & 2 + 1.15 & 2 + 0.34 +
based on the simple model exposed in sec .
[ sec_modeldiat ] we can suggest the following mechanism to explain the results presented in the preceeding section . the atomic orbitals o 2s and pb 5d ( for which the hypothesis of zero overlap ( [ eq_model2 ] ) is reasonable ) present weak covalent interactions that generate the corresponding energy bands in pbtio@xmath1 and @xmath0-pbo . when we construct maximally localized wf for each individual group , the resulting orbitals are delocalized on pb and o atoms so that during an atomic displacement an interatomic transfer of charges @xmath88 generating _ anomalous _ born effective charges @xmath88 is possible . the fact that the variance of the global ( o 2s + pb 5d ) group of bands is close to the mean spread of the atomic orbitals suggests that the maximally localized wf constructed on these bands are similar to the original atomic orbitals . in other words , they are confined on a single atom .
this confinement also suppresses the interatomic charge transfer so that the anomalous charges disappear .
we can make similar observations for the ba 5p and o 2s bands in bao and batio@xmath1 , although , in the latter compound , the cancellation in the born effective charges and the variance is not as complete as in the three remaining ones .
this suggests that in the lead oxides as well as in bao , the inner bands pb 5d and o 2s ( resp .
ba 5p and o 2s ) mainly result from hybridizations between two types of atomic orbitals . at the opposite , in batio@xmath1 the ba 5p and o 2s bands
are formed of more than two types of atomic orbitals .
looking now at the bands at the fermi level , we see that their variance is significantly larger in bao and @xmath0-pbo than in the corresponding perovskites and that it remains nearly constant in the different phases of batio@xmath1 .
this latter observation seems surprising for two reasons .
( i ) the lda bandgap presents drastic changes when passing from the cubic ( 1.72 ev ) to the rhombohedral ( 2.29 ev ) phase .
this increase suggests a much stronger localization of the o 2p electrons in the ferroelectric phases .
( ii ) the giant born effective charges observed in the paraelectric phase @xcite imply an important reorganization of the electronic cloud during an atomic displacement .
it appears surprising that this reorganization has such small effects on the localization tensor .
these small variations are not restricted to batio@xmath1 but similar observations have been made in other ferroelectric compounds like linbo@xmath1 @xcite .
considering point ( i ) , we note that the correlation between the bandgap and the localization tensor is not as tight as one might think .
the variance of the o 2p bands for instance is significantly larger in bao than in batio@xmath1 in spite of the fact that its lda bandgap ( 1.69 ev ) is close to the gap in the cubic phase of batio@xmath1 .
considering point ( ii ) , we note that it is possible to have an important reorganization of the electronic charge _ without _ affecting the localization tensor a lot .
following the ideas of the harrison model @xcite , the giant effective charges in perovskite ferroelectrics result from dynamical orbital hybridizations changes generating interatomic transfers of charges . in fig .
[ fig_wannier ] ( a ) we have drawn shematically an o centered wf in the cubic phase of batio@xmath1 along a ti - o chain . due to the o 2p - ti 3d hybridization , this wf has a finite probability on the neighbouring ti@xmath99 and ti@xmath100 atoms .
oxygen centered wf in the cubic phase ( solid line ) of batio@xmath1 ( a ) and its variation during the transition to the tetragonal phase ( dashed line ) ( b).,width=226 ] according to the harrison model , a fraction of electrons is transferred from ti@xmath99 to ti@xmath100 during a displacement @xmath101 of the o atom ( fig .
[ fig_wannier ] ( b ) ) .
even if the quantity of charges involved in this process is small , the large scale on which this transfer takes place ( of the order of the lattice parameter ) implies a shift of the wf center larger than the underlying atomic displacement and explains the _ anomalous effective charges_. during the transition from the cubic to the tetragonal phase , the central o atom is displaced by few percents of the lattice constant @xmath43 ( @xmath102 ) with respect to ti@xmath99 and ti@xmath100 . the resulting shift of the wf center generates the spontaneous polarization in the ferroelectric phase .
based on this simple picture the origin of the small variations of the o 2p variance during the phase transitions becomes more obvious : when the electrons are transferred from ti@xmath99 to ti@xmath100 their distance to the initial wf center remains unaffected and their distance to the displaced wf center slightly decreases due to its shift towards ti@xmath100 .
mathematically speaking , due to the fact that the variations do not depend on the direction of the atomic displacement , they are of the second order in @xmath103 . in order to get a numerical estimate of the charges transferred during this process and its impact on the localization tensor we can consider a one dimensional model wf whose square is the sum of three delta - dirac functions @xmath104
+ z'_o \delta(x ) \right \}.\ ] ] this model only takes into account the delocalization of the electrons on different atoms ( third term of eq .
( [ eq_model_var ] ) ) while it completely neglects the delocalization of the electronic cloud on the individual atoms ( first and second term of eq .
( [ eq_model_var ] ) ) . in this particular case
we can identify the localization tensor to the second moment of the wf .
this is no more true in a real , three dimensional crystal . in batio@xmath1 for instance , the o 2p group contains 9 different wf per unit cell located on three different o atoms .
these wf extend in different spatial directions so that their _ average _ spread in the @xmath47-direction is lower than the spread of one single wf as the one shown in fig .
[ fig_wannier ] . in eq .
( [ eq_model ] ) , @xmath105 represents the probability of the electrons to be found on the o atom .
it can be computed from the value of the o 2p variance in the paraelectric phase of batio@xmath1 and the lattice constant @xmath43 using the relation @xmath106 this yields @xmath107 .
this quantity allows an estimate of the static charge of the o atom in batio@xmath1 by substracting three times @xmath105 from the charge due to the nucleus and the core electrons o 1s and o 2s .
this yields @xmath108 . when the o atom is displaced , the shift of the wf center is directly related to the quantity of charges @xmath109 transferred from ti@xmath99 to ti@xmath100
. the value of @xmath109 can be computed from the value of the effective charge generated by the o 2p electrons ( @xmath110 ) in the cubic phase @xcite by taking into account that the _ anomalous _ charges are generated by three wf located on the same o atom @xcite . to get the polarization due to one single wf
, we have to divide this quantity by 3 since each of them brings a similar contribution to @xmath111 .
in the tetragonal phase , the model wf writes @xmath112 by identifying twice its first moment to @xmath113 one gets @xmath114 at the transition from the cubic to the tetragonal state .
it implies a decrease in the spread of the model wf of 0.18 bohr@xmath83 . this variation is larger than the observed one ( 0.023 bohr@xmath83 ) .
part of the discrepancy is probably due to the fact that we considered @xmath111 to be constant along the path of atomic displacement from the paraelectric to the ferroelectric phase . using the value of @xmath111 in the tetragonal phase
we obtain a value of 0.0467 for @xmath109 while the variance decreases of 0.12 bohr@xmath83 .
moreover , one has to bear in mind that the localization tensor in batio@xmath1 is an average value that has to be taken over 9 wf .
six of them are centered on o atoms that ly in a plane perpendicular to the direction of the spontaneous polarization .
they are probably less affected by the phase transition . as a consequence ,
the variation of the wf located on the remaining o atom ( the one represented on fig .
[ fig_wannier ] ) is expected to be larger than the variation of the localization tensor . in summary , even if there is no formal connection between the real wf in batio@xmath1 and eq .
( [ eq_model ] ) , this simple model shows that small variations of the localization tensor are compatible with giant effective charges and their interpretation in terms of the harrison model .
as illustrated with the model wf , the transfer of charges along the ti@xmath88o chains only implies a slight decrease in the spread of one single wf . this _ decrease _
is expected to be larger than the decrease in the variance because this latter quantity is an average value over 9 wf that are not modified to the same extent during the phase transition .
using a plane wave - pseudopotential approach to dft we computed the electron localization tensor for various oxides .
our study was based on the work on semiconductors performed by sgiarovello and co - workers but used linear - response techniques to compute the first - order wavefunctions . in order to investigate the properties of electrons occupying individual groups of bands
independently , we first set - up a band by band decomposition of the localization tensor . in analogy with the field of statistics we had to distinguish between variance and covariance in this decompositon .
the significance of these new concepts was illustrated in terms of wf and explained on a simple model .
the variance allows to get some insight into the hybridizations of atomic orbitals .
the covariance can be useful to help constructing maximally localized wf : it identifies the bands that have to be considered together in order to improve their localization .
we also made a connection between the localization tensor and the born effective charges and we discussed the difference between all - electron and pseudopotential calculations .
we applied these techniques to binary oxides ( bao and @xmath0-pbo ) as well as perovskite ferroelectrics ( batio@xmath1 and pbtio@xmath1 ) . by considering first the electrons of the inner bands we showed that some of them present a strong delocalization with respect to the situation in an isolated atom .
this observation suggests that the underlying atomic orbitals are chemically not inert but present non negligible covalent interactions .
this fact had been confirmed from an inspection of the born effective charges .
finally , the variations of the o 2p variance during the ferroelectric phase transitions of batio@xmath1 were found to be very small .
this surprizing result was explained in terms of the electronic structure of this compound as it is interpreted in the harrison model .
we think that , when combined with born effective charges , the band - by - band decomposition of the localization tensor could provide a powerful tool for the qualitative characterization of bonds in solids
. however , more studies are needed , for different classes of materials , in order to make it fully effective .
m. v. and x. g. are grateful to the national fund for scientific research ( fnrs - belgium ) for financial support .
. g. acknowledges support from fnrs - belgium ( grant 9.4539.00 ) and the universit de lige ( impulsion grant ) .
this work was supported by the volkswagen - stiftung ( www.volkswagenstiftung.de ) within the program `` complex materials : cooperative projects of the natural , engineering , and biosciences '' with the title : `` nano - sized ferroelectric hybrids '' under project number i/77 737 .
it was also supported by the communaut franaise through the `` action de recherche concerte : interaction electron - vibration dans les nanostructures '' , and the belgian federal government , through the pai / iuap p5 `` quantum phase effects in nanostructured materials '' w. kohn , phys .
133 * , a171 ( 1964 ) .
r. d. king - smith and d. vanderbilt , phys .
b * 47 * , 1651 ( 1993 ) .
d. vanderbilt and r. d. king - smith , phys .
b * 48 * , 4442 ( 1993 ) .
r. resta , rev .
* 66 * , 899 ( 1994 ) .
g. ortiz and r. m. martin , phys .
b * 49 * , 14202 ( 1994 ) .
r. resta , phys .
lett . * 80 * , 1800 ( 1998 ) .
r. resta and s. sorella , phys .
. lett . * 82 * , 370 ( 1999 ) .
a. a. aligia and g. ortiz , phys .
lett . * 82 * , 2560 ( 1999 ) .
r. resta , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 14 * , r625 ( 2002 ) .
i. souza , t. wilkens and r. m. martin , phys .
b * 62 * , 1666 ( 2000 ) . c. sgiarovello , m. peressi and r. resta , phys . rev .
b * 64 * , 115202 ( 2001 ) .
p. hohenberg and w. kohn , phys . rev . *
136 * , b864 ( 1964 ) .
w. kohn and l. j. sham , phys . rev . *
140 * , a1133 ( 1965 ) .
n. marzari and d. vanderbilt phys .
b * 56 * , 12847 ( 1997 ) .
n. marzari and d. vanderbilt , in _ first - principles calculations for ferroelectrics _ , edited by r. e. cohen , aip conf .
436 ( aip , woodbury , 1998 ) , p. 146 .
m. posternack , a. baldereschi , h. krakauer and r. resta , phys .
b * 55 * , 15983 ( 1997 ) .
ghosez , j .-
michenaud and x. gonze , phys .
b * 58 * , 6224 ( 1998 ) .
ghosez , x. gonze , ph .
lambin and j .- p .
michenaud , phys .
b * 51 * , 6765 ( 1995 ) .
ghosez and x. gonze , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 12 * , 9179 ( 2000 ) .
x. gonze , phys .
a * 52 * , 1096 ( 1995 ) .
abinit is a common project of the universit catholique de louvain , corning incorporated , and other contributors ( url http://www.abinit.org ) .
it relies on an efficient fast fourier transform algorithm @xcite for the conversion of wavefunctions between real and reciprocal space , on the adaptation to a fixed potential of the band - by - band conjugate gradient method @xcite and on a potential - based conjugated - gradient algorithm for the determination of the self - consistent potential @xcite .
in addition to usual ground - state calculations it allows linear - response computations of the phonon frequencies , born effective charges and dielectric constants @xcite .
s. goedecker , siam j. on scientific computing * 18 * , 1605 ( 1997 ) .
m. c. payne , m. p. teter , d. c. allan , t. a. arias et j. d. joannopoulos , rev .
phys * 64 * , 1045 ( 1992 ) .
x. gonze , phys .
b * 54 * , 4383 ( 1996 ) . x. gonze and c. lee , phys . rev .
b * 55 * , 10355 ( 1997 ) .
x. gonze , phys .
b * 55 * , 10337 ( 1997 ) . h. j. monkhorst and j. d. pack , phys . rev .
b * 13 * , 5188 ( 1976 ) .
m. p. teter , phys .
b * 48 * , 5031 ( 1993 ) .
ghosez , x. gonze and j .- p .
michenaud , ferroelectrics * 220 * , 1 ( 1999 ) .
p. pertosa and f. m. michel - calendini , phys .
b * 17 * , 2011 ( 1978 ) .
g. w. watson , s. c. parker and g. kresse , phys .
b * 59 * , 8484 ( 1999 ) .
r. d. king - smith and d. vanderbilt , phys .
b * 49 * , 5828 ( 1994 ) . harrison w. a. , `` electronic structure and the properties of solids '' , w. h. freeman and co , san fransisco , 1980 . c. b. van de walle and p. e. blchl , phys . rev .
b * 47 * , 4244 ( 1993 ) .
m. veithen , x. gonze and ph .
ghosez , to appear in _ fundamental physics of ferroelectrics _ , edited by r. e. cohen , aip conf .
( washington 2002 ) .
f. bassani and g. pastori parravicini , ( pergamon , oxford , 1975 ) .
the optical conductivity ( imaginary part of the optical dielectric tensor ) of a given material is related to its absorption coefficient , the probability of the valence electrons to perform optical transitions to the _ unoccupied _ conduction bands under the influence of an electromagnetic field . if we consider only `` vertical '' band - to - band transitions ( thus neglecting elementary excitations like the electron - hole interaction or the electron - phonon coupling ) this quantity writes in the dipolar approximation @xcite @xmath115 where _ m _ is the electron mass , @xmath116 and @xmath117 .
the matrix elements of the momentum operator can equivalently be expressed as @xmath118 .
it has been shown by souza , wilkens and martin @xcite that @xmath119 is related to the localization tensor by the relation @xmath120 in order to see the effect of the band by band decomposition , we will write @xmath119 as @xmath121 where the first sum of eq .
( [ eq_bbb12a ] ) has to be taken over the bands of group @xmath22 while the second sum extends over all bands ( unoccupied or not ) except those of group @xmath22 . in eq .
( [ eq_bbb12b ] ) , the two sums extend over the bands of group @xmath22 and @xmath26 .
it is easy to show that @xmath123 and @xmath124 are related to the variances and covariances by the relations thanks to these definitions , the physical meaning of the covariance becomes now obvious : if the total localization tensor was simply the sum of the variances @xmath126 , the expression of the dielectric tensor ( [ eq_bbb9 ] ) would not only contain transitions between occupied and unoccupied states , but also transitions between occupied states themselves .
it is by adding the covariances @xmath127 that one compensates the effect of these forbidden transitions in order to get a physically correct quantity . | using a plane wave pseudopotential approach to density functional theory we investigate the electron localization length in various oxides . for this purpose , we first set up a theory of the band - by - band decomposition of this quantity , more complex than the decomposition of the spontaneous polarization ( a related concept ) , because of the interband coupling .
we show its interpretation in terms of wannier functions and clarify the effect of the pseudopotential approximation .
we treat the case of different oxides : bao , @xmath0-pbo , batio@xmath1 and pbtio@xmath1 .
we also investigate the variation of the localization tensor during the ferroelectric phase transitions of batio@xmath1 as well as its relationship with the born effective charges . |
observed galaxies exhibit substantial diversity in their morphological appearances and structure .
early - type , namely elliptical and lenticular , galaxies ( etgs ) are more massive on average among galaxy types and are thought to originate from mergers of late - type galaxies and smaller etgs under the paradigm of hierarchical galaxy formation and evolution ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
the empirical properties of etgs hold important clues to the physical processes shaping properties of the most massive galaxies .
etgs also play a crucial role in modern cosmology including dark energy phenomenology .
owing to their large masses and high central densities etgs dominate observed population of strong lenses and are also important for weak lensing which provide both geometric ( through cosmological distances ) and dynamical ( through growth of structures ) probe of dark energy ( @xcite ) .
massive etgs , or similarly luminous red galaxies by colour selection , are also excellent targets of the baryonic acoustic oscillation studies that provide an independent cosmological probe of the distance scale in the universe ( e.g. , @xcite ) . for both astrophysical and cosmological studies involving etgs , their density structure , in particular the radial profile ,
is of great importance for several reasons .
first of all , as the radial mass profile encodes the combined distribution of luminous and dark matter , it is a key quantity to constrain galaxy formation and evolution models .
an important question is whether there is a simple natural attractor of radial density profile such as the navarro - frenk - white ( nfw ) profile ( e.g. , @xcite ) or the isothermal profile ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
secondly , because there is no empirical method to directly measure dark matter ( dm ) distribution in a galaxy , accurate determination of the total mass profile is the crucial first step toward the inference of dm distribution ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
finally , the radial mass profile is a crucial factor in gravitational lensing ( both strong and weak ) .
strong lensing image flux ratios depend largely on the radial density slope at the einstein radius .
weak lensing by individual haloes and large - scale structures depend on the global radial profile of galaxies and clusters .
the radial total mass profile of a galaxy can be constrained using dynamic probes such as stellar or gas dynamics , or gravitational lensing . for nearby etgs stellar dynamics
has been the most fruitful probe because detailed stellar kinematic data as well as photometric data are available .
detailed dynamical models based on the observed luminosity distributions and stellar velocity moments have been constructed for tens to hundreds etgs ( e.g. , @xcite ) . for nearby @xmath9-ray bright massive ellipticals ,
hydrostatic equilibrium equation has been used to infer mass profiles ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
the inferred mass profiles from these studies in general exhibit significant variation of the logarithmic slope with radius , although the density profiles are close to isothermal around the half - light radius of stellar distribution . nevertheless , the sample sizes of dynamical and lensing studies of mass distribution in the etgs have been fairly small to allow systematic study of profile variation in a wide radial range .
strong lensing studies have been used to constrain the total mass profile of distant galaxies at various redshifts ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
strong lensing effectively constrains the density slope ( absolute value ) @xmath10 or , more precisely , the slope of the projected 2-dimensional density @xmath11 , at the einstein radius @xmath12 , which increases with redshift at fixed @xmath2 : e.g. , @xmath13 at @xmath14 but @xmath15 at @xmath16 ( @xcite ) . for systematic analyses of samples of tens of strong lens systems constant-@xmath17 models have usually been adopted and the constrained values of @xmath17 have mean slopes close to the isothermal value @xmath18 for @xmath19 ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
however , recently it was noticed that the value of @xmath17 appeared to evolve significantly with @xmath20 based on combined samples that contain both low @xmath21 lenses and intermediate @xmath22 lenses ( @xcite ) .
assuming @xmath17 was independent of radius in the optical region , the apparent redshift evolution of @xmath17 was interpreted in terms of galaxy evolution .
notably , the apparent evolution implies @xmath23 at @xmath24 ( @xcite ) .
finally , stellar dynamics , strong and weak lensing were combined to infer the total mass profile for a large radial range for several individual systems ( @xcite ) or stacked data ( @xcite ) .
the former work focused on galaxy clusters , while the latter study used only the de vaucouleurs stellar mass profile and the nfw dm profile without taking into account halo contraction effects by baryonic physics ( e.g. , @xcite ) . from recent dynamical analyses of etgs
it is not clear whether the isothermal model is a good approximation to the average profile for some radial range or whether the average profile is systematically varying with redshift or some other parameter .
here we investigate galaxy mass profile through jeans dynamical analyses based on sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ; @xcite ) galactic luminosity distributions and aperture velocity dispersions in conjunction with published velocity dispersion profiles and empirical properties and relations for etgs and their haloes .
sdss photometric data and aperture velocity dispersions have been useful in addressing several issues including estimating dynamical masses and dark matter contents within @xmath2 ( e.g. , @xcite ) , testing halo contraction / expansion models and stellar initial mass functions ( imfs ) ( @xcite ) .
these studies confirm that non - negligible amount of dark matter is generally required within @xmath2 and suggest that the dm fraction within @xmath2 is correlated with properties such as surface brightness and @xmath2 and galaxies require non - universal imfs or / and non - universal dark halo response to galaxy formation .
our present study of sdss etgs has the following aspects .
first , we select nearly spherical and disk - less galaxies for our analyses by the spherical jeans equation so that any possible systematic errors due to non - spherical shapes , which were ignored in all previous analyses , can be minimized .
second , the main focus of our work is galaxy total mass profile and for that purpose we use an empirical distribution of velocity dispersion profiles ( vps ) within @xmath2 .
third , we use newly measured luminosity profile parameters , sersic index @xmath25 and effective radius @xmath2 .
fourth , we take into account recently published systematic imf variation in early - type galaxies . finally , our analyses are based on real data and auxiliary empirical inputs excluding simulation or theoretical inputs .
our present work has a different focus and is an improvement with updated and more reliable inputs compared with @xcite which considered vps but focused on dm profiles with inputs from n - body simulations . for our jeans analyses we assume parametric functional forms for the total mass profile .
when a model is fitted to the aperture velocity dispersion , it predicts a velocity dispersion profile .
we then compare the predicted distribution of vps with the empirical distribution to test the model .
our successful models are two - component models in which stellar mass distribution is assumed to follow the photometrically derived luminosity profile and the coupled dm distribution is assumed to follow the gnfw or einasto model , which are motivated from cosmological hydrodynamic simulations of galaxy formation , with the constraint that they match weak lensing observations at large radii .
our model set is at least an order of magnitude larger than any previous set of empirical ( as opposed to simulation or semi - empirical ) models for etgs .
in addition , it covers a large radial range extending from @xmath26 to the halo virial radius .
the outline of this paper is as follows . in section 2
we describe our data and other empirical results from the literature that are needed for our analyses . in section 3
we describe mass model parametrisation and method of jeans dynamical analyses . in section 4
we describe statistical results for mass profiles based on standard empirical inputs and then in section 5 we consider systematic variations of the statistical results . in section 6
we compare our results with recent results based on sdss photometric data and aperture velocity dispersions . in sections 7 & 8 we discuss implications of our results for galaxy formation and strong lensing .
we conclude in section 9 .
we carefully define a sample of nearly spherical ( projected minor - to - major axis ratio @xmath27 ) and disk - less ( disk mass is within the measurement error of total mass ) galaxies with mean redshift @xmath28 selected from the sdss ( @xcite ) .
this selection excludes all lenticular and later - type galaxies , while retaining galaxies spanning two orders of magnitude in stellar mass ( @xmath29 ) , and was chosen to minimize biases in analyses based on the spherical jeans equation ( see section 3 ) .
therefore , our resulting mass profiles will apply strictly to nearly spherical galaxies only .
however , we will also consider modelling a general sample of etgs to estimate any systematic difference in mass profile between our nearly spherical sample and a general sample . because each galaxy in our sample has a nearly spherical component only ,
its luminosity profile can generally be well described by a single - component @xcite profile , except possibly for the sub - kiloparsec central region ( see below ) .
each galaxy has the surface brightness srsic - fit effective radius @xmath2 , the srsic index @xmath25 , the luminosity - weighted line - of - sight velocity dispersion ( losvd ) within the sdss aperture of radius 1.5 arcsec @xmath30 and the total stellar mass @xmath31 converted from the measured luminosity using the chabrier(@xcite ) stellar initial mass function ( imf ) or equivalently mass - to - light ( @xmath32 ) ratio .
recent observational studies have found that imfs of etgs are not universal but show galaxy - to - galaxy scatter and systematic trends with some parameters such as stellar velocity dispersion ( vd ) @xmath33 . to encompass the current likely range we use three independently inferred @xmath33-dependent imfs ( e.g. , @xcite ; see section 2.3 ) .
it is well - known that the central sub - kiloparsec region of etg light profile exhibits large variation giving rise to either the central missing light due to the shallower core or the central extra light due to the steeper power - law profile compared with the main body profile extrapolation ( e.g. , @xcite ) . this central extra or missing light can have non - negligible effects for small @xmath2 galaxies .
however , sdss photometric data do not have enough resolution for the central regions of our @xmath34 galaxies . to allow for the observed deviations in the central regions from the overall srsic profiles for etgs we use the central profile properties , i.e. the break radius and the slope at a fiducial central radius as a function of stellar mass , extracted from published data including the _ hubble space telescope _ data ( see section 2.8 ) .
each galaxy is further assigned its halo mass @xmath35 within the virial radius @xmath36 , which is defined to be the radius of the sphere within which the mean density is 200 times the cosmic mean matter density ( equation 6 of @xcite ) , @xmath37 assuming a flat @xmath38-dominated universe with @xmath39 and @xmath40 ( @xcite ) .
for this we use the empirical @xmath41-@xmath35 relations from sdss satellite kinematics ( @xcite ) and weak lensing ( @xcite ) , as well as the abundance matching relation ( @xcite ) to encompass the current likely range ( see section 2.4 ) .
the halo assigned to each galaxy is then assigned a mass profile at large radii ( @xmath42 ) using the weak lensing observations of the sdss galaxies , which not only show that the outer halo profile can be well described by the nfw profile but also give the mean halo mass ( @xmath35)-nfw concentration ( @xmath43 ) relation derived from stacked profiles ( @xcite ) .
we use an intrinsic scatter of @xmath44 dex and allow @xmath45 of systematic errors . to constrain the mass profile in the optical region of each nearly spherical galaxy we need not only the aperture vd @xmath30 but also the vd profile .
we do not have a measured vd profile for each galaxy in our sample .
however , we can use an empirical statistical distribution of vd profiles from the literature ( @xcite ) as described in section 2.6 . in the following subsections
we describe in detail our data and all empirical results from the literature that are needed for our analyses . to describe the observed light distribution of an etg we use the srsic model or a two - component ( ` serexp ' ) model that contains a srsic bulge and an exponential disk . from the light distribution we derive the volume distribution of stellar mass using
empirically derived stellar imfs ( see below section 2.3 ) .
the srsic surface brightness distribution on the sky given by @xmath46 with @xmath47 ( @xmath48 being the two dimensional radius ) and @xmath49 ( for @xmath50 ) ( @xcite ) allows a more accurate description of a dispersion - supported system than the traditional de vaucouleurs model which is the special case of @xmath51 .
more recently it has been recognized that most etgs are better described by a compound model composed of two distinct components , namely a bulge and a disk , although the bulge is dominating ( @xcite ) .
when a two - component system with the non - negligible disk is fitted by a single srsic model , the resulting parameters , in particular galaxy size @xmath2 , can be biased compared with the actual bulge parameters ( @xcite ) .
the bias in @xmath2 is less than 0.05 dex for stellar mass @xmath52 but can be as large as 0.08 dex near the high mass tail ( @xcite ) . for our jeans analyses
we select nearly spherical and disk - less systems that are well - described by the single - component srsic profiles ( see , however , section 2.8 for the profiles of the central sub - kpc regions ) .
however , we also consider modelling general etgs to estimate possible systematic difference of our results from those for general etgs . in this case
we use the single srsic fit to the total light distribution .
when we use the single srsic fit for a galaxy having a non - negligible disk , we are using a biased @xmath2 as mentioned above .
we select a sample of 28,259 etgs from the sdss main galaxy sample satisfying light concentration @xmath53 and @xmath54 where @xmath55 is the ratio of the radius containing 90 percent of the petrosian luminosity in the @xmath56-band to that containing 50 percent ( @xcite ) and @xmath57 is the bulge srsic index in the serexp fit of the total light distribution .
a subsample of 20,210 etgs satisfies @xmath58 .
each galaxy in the sample has aperture velocity dispersion @xmath30 and ellipticity @xmath59 ( @xmath60 with @xmath61 being the projected minor - to - major axis ratio ) as well as fitted parameters of both the srsic and the serexp models along with corresponding stellar masses based on the chabrier imf .
the srsic - fit parameters are @xmath31 ( total stellar mass based on the chabrier imf ) , @xmath2 ( effective radius ) and @xmath25 ( srsic - fit index ) .
the serexp - fit parameters are @xmath62 ( bulge stellar mass based on the chabrier imf ) , @xmath63 ( bulge effective radius ) , @xmath57 ( bulge srsic - fit index ) as well as @xmath31 and @xmath2 for the total ( bulge plus exponential ) profile .
( 16,8)(0,0 ) ( -0.5,10.5 ) based on the observed light distributions and the model fitted parameters we select a @xmath58 subsample of 2,054 nearly spherical and disk - less ellipticals using the criteria @xmath64 ( single srsic - fit ellipticity ) and @xmath65 ( the sum of the estimated measurement errors for @xmath2 in the single srsic fit and @xmath63 in the serexp fit ) .
galaxies in this sample have the following properties @xmath66 , @xmath67 and @xmath68 .
the distribution of redshifts and the physical aperture to effective radius ratios @xmath69 can be found in fig .
the redshift distribution has a mean of @xmath70 with a root - mean - square ( rms ) dispersion of @xmath71 while the @xmath69 distribution has @xmath72 and @xmath73 .
another important feature of this sample is that galaxies have higher srsic indices compared with other etg samples in the literature : we have @xmath74 ( with @xmath75 ) compared with @xmath76 for 260 atlas@xmath77 galaxies ( @xcite ) .
( see further section 6 . )
this sample will be our standard ( fiducial ) choice because our analysis is based on the spherical jeans equation .
other samples will be used to estimate systematic errors of galaxy sampling . in particular
, we also consider a @xmath53 subsample of 2,607 nearly spherical and disk - less ellipticals to see the effects of varying the etg selection criterion .
the @xmath53 subsample has a somewhat lower srsic mean , @xmath78 . the above measured parameters
are uncertain to varying degrees .
our formal estimates of the measurement errors are : @xmath79 ; @xmath80 , @xmath81 ; @xmath82 at @xmath83 varying to @xmath84 at @xmath85 for the galaxy ( i.e. a single srsic - fit galaxy or a bulge plus a disk in the serexp - fit case ) ; but , @xmath86 at @xmath83 varying to @xmath87 at @xmath85 for the bulge component in the serexp fit . since these errors are our formal estimates , we consider increasing them by 0.05 dex .
as discussed in appendix a of @xcite the estimate of @xmath88 depends on the method used .
our fiducial choice is that by @xcite which is similar to @xcite but gives @xmath89 dex systematically larger @xmath88 compared with @xcite .
furthermore , stellar imfs are not universal as described in section 2.3 .
hence stellar mass is relatively more uncertain than other parameters and should be treated with caution .
the aperture velocity dispersion @xmath30 has the smallest error and is the most reliable parameter out of our measurements .
a number of recent studies ( e.g. , @xcite ) find that the stellar imfs for etgs show significant galaxy - to - galaxy scatter and are in general different from the imfs inferred for the milky way and other nearby galaxies ( @xcite ) .
this means that the stellar masses derived for our galaxies using the chabrier imf should be corrected .
here we do not intend to describe recent imf results comprehensively but just list some results that we use to encompass the current likely range .
( 11,8)(0,0 ) ( -1.,8 . ) the imfs of etgs show systematic trends with galaxy parameters such as velocity dispersion , mass - to - light ratio ( @xmath32 ) and magnesium - to - iron abundance ratio [ mg / fe ] .
we use the vd - dependent imf derived by the atlas@xmath77 project from detailed dynamical modelling of 260 nearby etgs using observed light distributions and velocity moments ( @xcite ) .
the atlas@xmath77 imf for each galaxy corresponds to the global imf for the galaxy ( i.e. for a region of radius @xmath90 ) .
the atlas@xmath77 imfs are heavier than the chabrier and kroupa imfs for most range of vd and become heavier slowly with increasing vd ( fig . [ imf ] ) .
an independent imf distribution is obtained by detailed stellar population synthesis ( sps ) modelling of the spectra of 34 nearby etgs ( @xcite ) .
the sps modelling has nothing to do with galaxy dynamics so that the result is independent of the unknown dm distribution .
the sps modelling result corresponds to the central cylindrical region of radius @xmath91 .
the sps linear relation shown in fig .
[ imf ] is a least - square fit result based on the data including measurement errors ( c. conroy , personal communications ) .
this result is similar to the atlas@xmath77 result indicating that the imf does not significantly vary radially within the galaxy .
imfs varying more rapidly than these are obtained by the spider project through a combined dynamical and sps modelling of a large number ( @xmath92 ) of etgs ( @xcite ) . considering the agreement between the atlas@xmath77 and the sps results we assume that there is no radial gradient of imf within a galaxy .
we use the atlas@xmath77 imf distribution as our standard choice and use the others to estimate systematic errors due to imf uncertainties .
although there are many observational and abundance matching results for the stellar mass ( @xmath93)halo mass ( @xmath35 ) relation for the total population of galaxies , the results for etgs are relatively few .
we use the @xmath93-@xmath35 relations for red galaxies or etgs obtained by the satellite kinematics of the sdss galaxies ( @xcite ) , weak lensing of the sdss galaxies ( @xcite ) and abundance matching of the sdss galaxies ( @xcite ) with the bolshoi @xmath94-body simulation haloes ( @xcite ) .
the results from the satellite kinematics and abundance matching include intrinsic system - to - system scatter .
these results are shown in fig .
the satellite kinematics result is consistent with the more recent weak lensing result by @xcite , while the abundance matching result with the earlier weak lensing result by @xcite .
our standard choice is the satellite kinematics result while we use the weak lensing and abundance matching results to estimate systematic errors .
( 8,10)(0,0 ) ( -0.5,0 . )
one of the current robust results from weak lensing is that the outer halo can be well described by the nfw or einasto profile ( @xcite ) . the scale radius or equivalently
the concentration of this outer nfw / einasto halo has been determined empirically by weak lensing but can be also predicted by cosmological @xmath94-body simulations .
our standard choice is the weak lensing result ( equation 7 and fit 2 in table 2 of @xcite ) given by @xmath95 with @xmath96 , @xmath97 and @xmath98 .
since some @xmath94-body simulation results can differ by @xmath99 from the weak lensing result , we use @xmath100 ( @xmath101 ) errors of the mean concentration to estimate systematic errors .
our adopted range is consistent with recent weak lensing measurements ( e.g. @xcite ) as well as recent @xmath94-body simulation results ( e.g. @xcite ) .
we assume an intrinsic halo - to - halo scatter of 0.1 dex from the mean relation as @xmath94-body simulations predict similar scatter .
our results have little sensitivity on the precise value of the intrinsic scatter .
the measured luminosity - weighted losvds of etgs can be , in most cases , well described by a simple power - law profile ( see equation [ eq : lwvd ] below ) in the optical region .
we collect available data and do a uniform least - square - fit of losvd profiles .
we consider the profile data for 48 nearby etgs by @xcite , the on - line data for 35 coma cluster etgs by @xcite and the published data for 7 bcgs at a mean redshift of @xmath102 by @xcite .
the fitted values of @xmath103 ( profile slope ; equation [ eq : lwvd ] below ) for all 90 etgs are displayed in fig .
[ vpdist ] .
( 10,7)(0,0 ) ( -1.,7.2 ) we note some features from fig .
[ vpdist ] .
first , two independent samples , black points ( @xcite ) and blue points ( @xcite ) , have indistinguishable distributions of @xmath103 .
second , low vd ( @xmath104 ) etgs appear to have a higher mean of @xmath103 .
these low-@xmath105 etgs tend to have relatively less dominating bulges ( m. cappellari , personal communications ) meaning that they may not match well with our bulge - dominating etgs .
third , all @xmath106 bcgs have positive values of @xmath103 ( mean @xmath107 ) in contrast to coma cluster cd and d galaxies ngc 4874 ( @xmath108 ) , ngc 4889 ( @xmath109 ) and ngc 4839 ( @xmath110 ) .
the difference between the @xmath106 bcg sample and the coma cd / d galaxies can be largely attributed to systematic size difference and redshift evolution .
the @xmath106 bcgs have much larger sizes than the coma cd / ds : 5 out of the 7 bcgs have @xmath111 while 2 out of the 3 coma cd / ds have @xmath112 .
evolution effects can not be neglected for the @xmath106 clusters because of the rapid redshift evolution of massive clusters .
fourth , other than the low @xmath105 etg and @xmath106 bcg peculiarities
@xmath103 does not vary with @xmath105 .
finally , 8 nearly spherical ( @xmath113 ) etgs ( marked by open stars ) with little rotation have a mean consistent with that for all etgs .
excluding the @xmath106 bcgs , we have a mean value @xmath114 with an intrinsic scatter of @xmath115 for 83 etgs and a slightly different value @xmath116 with @xmath117 for 77 etgs with @xmath118 .
for the 8 nearly spherical and slowly rotating etgs we have @xmath119 with @xmath120 .
these values are consistent with one another .
our fiducial choice is @xmath121 with @xmath122 .
this value is somewhat higher than the value @xmath123 by @xcite but the intrinsic scatter is identical .
we take the difference between the two values ( i.e. @xmath124 ) as our estimate of the systematic error .
detailed dynamical modelling results of nearby etgs show that vd anisotropies are varying in general with @xmath56 in the optical region ( e.g. , @xcite ) . despite the radial variations anisotropy @xmath125 ( see below equation [ eq : jeans ] and the subsequent text ) values are bounded within the range @xmath126 for the entire radial range for most etgs . for the case of using constant anisotropies
we use an asymmetric pseudo - gaussian probability density distribution given by @xmath127 \hspace{1ex } ( \beta<\mu_\beta ) \smallskip
\\ \exp\left[-\frac{(\beta-\mu_\beta)^2}{2s_{\rm h}^2}\right ] \hspace{1ex } ( \beta\ge\mu_\beta ) \end{array } \right .
\label{eq : pdfbet}\ ] ] with @xmath128 ( peak value ) , @xmath129 ( higher value dispersion ) and @xmath130 ( lower value dispersion ) derived by @xcite using 40 unoverlapping etgs in the literature .
the distribution has a mean of @xmath131 .
we take this constant value distribution as our fiducial choice . as a way of estimating systematic effects of radially varying anisotropies we use a smoothly varying function of the form ( appendix b , @xcite ) @xmath132 with the central anisotropy @xmath133 , @xmath134 , mean anisotropy within @xmath2 taking the distribution of equation ( [ eq : pdfbet ] ) , and the anisotropy at large radii @xmath135 motivated from n - body simulations ( e.g. @xcite ) .
while the main bodies of etgs can be well described by the srsic ( or serexp ) model , the central sub - kiloparsec regions are known to deviate from the the srsic extrapolation ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
there can be missing or extra light compared with the srsic extrapolation of the bulge component ( or the galaxy ) depending on the nature of the galaxy .
the galaxies with missing central light are mostly giant etgs ( sometimes referred to as the core galaxies ) , while those with extra central light are less luminous etgs ( sometimes referred to as the power - law galaxies ) . on average , core galaxies have much shallower central slopes compared with power - law galaxies .
recent detailed _ hubble space telescope _
observations of the centres of etgs for a wide range of luminosities show that the central slope varies systematically with luminosity ( @xcite ) .
furthermore , the central slope varies radially in the central region of a galaxy .
[ gammbms ] shows three - dimensional central slope @xmath136 ( @xmath137 ) values at four different radii , @xmath138 , @xmath139 , @xmath140 and @xmath141 for 79 etgs with @xmath142 ( @xcite ) , or @xmath143 using @xmath144 , @xmath145 ( @xcite ) and @xmath146 ( @xcite ) . the slope at @xmath147 scales as @xmath148 ( black line in fig . [ gammbms ] ) .
( 10,7)(0,0 ) ( -0.6,7.1 ) the break radius at which the luminosity profile starts to deviate from the main - body srsic profile is typically @xmath149 ( @xcite ) but varies systematically from @xmath150 up to @xmath151 according to a more recent study by @xcite .
[ rb ] shows a systematic trend of @xmath152 based on 21 etgs of the virgo cluster brighter than @xmath153 ( @xcite ) .
stellar mass @xmath31 for each galaxy is obtained using a photometric conversion @xmath154 ( @xcite ) .
we obtain a least - square fit relation @xmath155 with @xmath156 and @xmath157 .
( 10,7)(0,0 ) ( -0.5,7.1 ) the central missing or extra light can not affect significantly our modelling results for the mass profile outside the central region . nevertheless , we take into account the central light distribution as follows to obtain as accurate as possible results particularly for the central region .
we assume a linearly varying slope @xmath158 with the corresponding density @xmath159 $ ] for @xmath160 . for each galaxy in our sample
we determine @xmath161 and @xmath162 by requiring that the slope is continuous with the srsic slope at @xmath163 and the slope at @xmath147 matches the empirical mean value @xmath164 given above .
our fiducial choice for @xmath163 is @xmath165 . to estimate systematic errors we consider alternatively the varying @xmath163 shown in fig .
[ rb ] . [ cols="^,^,<",options="header " , ] in table 2 we list various input variations and the predicted values of @xmath6 and @xmath5 ( population mean slopes for the radial range @xmath166 ) .
the important points are as follows :
1 . _ the spherical symmetry assumption and galaxy sample choice _ : we have a large number of galaxies selected by @xmath55 , but empirical information for each galaxy is relatively limited compared with well - studied local etgs ( e.g. @xcite ) . because of the limit of our data we have assumed the spherical symmetry .
we have then selected nearly spherical galaxies ( @xmath167 ) to minimize the error arising from the spherical symmetry assumption . in reality ,
even nearly spherical galaxies have in some cases non - negligible disk components in their light distributions .
because the presence of non - negligible disk components can invalidate the spherical symmetry assumption , we have further narrowed our selection by rejecting galaxies that have non - negligible disks .
our final sample of 2,054 nearly spherical , disk - less and @xmath168 galaxies can be legitimately modelled relying on the spherical symmetry assumption .
+ however , there still remain a couple of issues .
first , as we are modelling nearly spherical and disk - less galaxies only , our results may not hold for the general population of etgs .
for example , it is possible that intrinsic shapes of galaxies can increase the intrinsic scatter of the mass profile .
+ second , all auxiliary empirical properties of etgs ( e.g. the imf distribution , the @xmath169 relation , the distributions of @xmath170 and @xmath103 ) are for general populations of etgs or red galaxies .
if these properties are systematically different for spherical galaxies , then our results will be biased .
however , we do not find any systematic difference between all etgs and nearly spherical etgs based on the literature data ( see , e.g. , fig .
[ vpdist ] for the case of @xmath103 ) . + as a way of estimating the systematic effects of non - spherical shapes we consider two samples of random etgs .
one sample is drawn randomly from the @xmath58 sample and the other sample from a sample with a relaxed criterion of @xmath53 .
we also consider a @xmath171 sample of nearly spherical and disk - less galaxies to see the pure effects of changing the @xmath55 criterion .
the results for the random @xmath58 sample ( fit # 3 in table 2 ) have almost the same mean values of the slopes @xmath103 and @xmath172 compared with the standard nearly spherical and disk - less sample ( fit # 1 ) but have larger scatters in good agreement with the observed scatters for random etgs . the @xmath171 samples ( fit # 4 & # 5 ) have shallower mean slopes and larger scatters .
in particular , the predicted values of the mean vp slope @xmath6 are marginally discrepant with the empirical value @xmath173 . moreover , the random @xmath171 sample ( fit # 5 ) has larger scatter than observed .
the assumption of parametric functional forms for dm distribution _ : one of our underlying assumption is that the unknown dm distribution varies smoothly in radius and can be modelled by parametric functional forms motivated by @xmath94-body simulations combined with baryonic effects . because it is an empirical fact that the outer halo where baryonic effects are negligible follows well the nfw functional form
, we chose the gnfw model with a generalized central slope as our standard model . to see possible systematic errors of this assumption we also consider the einasto model that is equally well motivated .
we have checked that contracted haloes due to baryonic effects produced by state - of - the - art cosmological hydrodynamic simulations can be well approximated by the gnfw or the einasto profile , as can be checked numerically using the contra code ( @xcite ) .
this means that if baryon - induced halo contraction effects are real , our models can mimic those effects .
also , note that our models can mimic effects of halo expansion as well if that occurs ( for some galaxies ) .
the result based on the the einasto model ( fit # 6 ) has somewhat shallower mean slopes compared with the standard result ( fit # 1 ) based on the gnfw model and interestingly larger scatter .
although the scatter of @xmath103 is more consistent with the observed scatter than the standard result , the mean @xmath6 is marginally shallower than the observed mean .
3 . _ various empirical inputs _ : we consider alternative choices of various empirical inputs , fit # 7 # 14 in table 2 .
the largest possible systematic differences are @xmath174-@xmath124 in @xmath6 and @xmath175-@xmath176 in @xmath5 arising from the @xmath88-@xmath35 relation and the @xmath35-@xmath43 relation .
it is interesting to note that for the result using wildly varying vd anisotropies based on equation [ eq : varbet ] has unchanging mean slopes but have almost twice larger scatter in @xmath103 ( @xmath177 compared with @xmath178 ) while keeping the scatter in @xmath172 nearly unchanged .
this shows that anisotropy shapes can only affect the scatter of @xmath103 but probably not the mean slopes .
_ correlations among empirical input parameters _ :
in our approach each galaxy with measured parameter values ( @xmath30 which is on average closest to @xmath105 , @xmath2 , @xmath25 , @xmath88 ) is assigned various other parameter values [ imf variation with respect to the chabrier imf expressed in terms of @xmath179 , halo mass @xmath35 , outer halo profile concentration expressed using the nfw profile @xmath43 , anisotropy @xmath170 ( and velocity dispersion profile slope @xmath103 for the chi - square approach ) ] using observed two - parameter relations including intrinsic scatter based on a wealth of empirical information . however , we ignored any possible multiple correlations among input parameters . here ,
we examine / discuss possible correlations and investigate how the mass profile results are affected .
+ ( 10,7)(0,0 ) ( -0.8,7 . ) + first , when we assigned @xmath35 to each galaxy , we used the observed @xmath88-@xmath35 relation only . in doing
so we ignored any possible correlations , in particular with @xmath105 . to see possible effects of the ignored correlation with @xmath105 we compare in fig .
[ mhv ] our posterior @xmath35-@xmath105 relation with the recent abundance matching output for which @xmath88 and @xmath105 which has been converted to @xmath105 here . ]
were simultaneously assigned to @xmath180 taking into account correlations ( @xcite ) .
our posterior @xmath105-@xmath35 relation ( data points and black line ) deviates somewhat from the abundance matching relation ( red line ) in @xcite , but the difference is certainly smaller than systematic differences due to the change of the @xmath88-@xmath35 relation .
+ second , when we assigned @xmath181 and @xmath43 we used empirical relations respectively with @xmath105 and @xmath35 only . similarly to the above case these assignments will have some systematic errors due to ignored correlations with other parameters .
however , again the systematic errors arising from uncertainties of the @xmath105-@xmath181 and @xmath35-@xmath43 relations themselves are likely to be dominating .
+ ( 10,7)(0,0 ) ( -0.3,7 . ) + finally , when we assigned @xmath170 ( and @xmath103 for the chi - square approach ) we assumed no correlations at all .
as shown in fig .
[ vpdist ] , @xmath103 has no correlation with @xmath105 for the etgs that can match with our etg samples .
[ vpren ] shows @xmath103 against @xmath2 and @xmath25 using available data in the literature .
there is possibly a weak trend with @xmath2 as shown by a solid line but no correlation is found with @xmath25 .
[ bet3 ] shows @xmath170 against @xmath105 , @xmath2 and @xmath25 for 24 etgs from @xcite
. there appears a trend with @xmath2 only but sample size is too small to be meaningful .
[ etabeta ] shows @xmath103 against @xmath170 and no correlation is found based on this small sample . to account for the effects of possible correlations of both @xmath170 and @xmath103 with @xmath2 we consider as an alternative choice the least - square fit relations shown in fig .
[ vpren ] and fig .
+ ( 10,5)(0,0 ) ( -0.3,6.1 ) + ( 10,6)(0,0 ) ( -0.3,6 . ) + ( 8,9)(0,0 ) ( -0.3,-0.8 ) fig .
[ etagam ] shows the resulting distribution of @xmath5 against @xmath6 for all 15 fits in table 2 . there is a good correlation between the two parameters .
the tight correlation is remarkable considering that each result ( or set of results ) was obtained by varying a different ingredient . caring little about all the details of the inputs
@xmath5 is essentially dictated by @xmath6 .
this means that we can reliably estimate @xmath5 just by measuring @xmath6 for an etg sample without detailed dynamical modelling .
the least - square fit relation is given by @xmath182 with @xmath183 and @xmath184 . from our
considered 15 different fits @xmath185 and @xmath186 along with @xmath187 and @xmath188 .
( 9,7)(0,0 ) ( -0.7,7.3 ) with our measured @xmath173 from section 2.6 , we have @xmath189 .
the value @xmath123 measured by @xcite corresponds to @xmath190 .
hence our results suggest a super - isothermal mean profile in the optical region with an intrinsic scatter of @xmath191 .
@xcite have recently carried out stellar dynamics plus strong lensing analyses of dozens of etgs at @xmath192 . for 14 etgs from @xcite at a redshift range @xmath193 similar to our sample , we find @xmath194 with @xmath195 .
this result is even more steeper but consistent at a @xmath196 level with our results .
our results are somewhat ( @xmath99 ) steeper than the mean profile of 16 coma cluster etgs , @xmath197 with @xmath198 ( @xcite ) . however , if we consider only 9 normal ellipticals excluding lenticular and cd / d galaxies from the coma cluster , the mean profile is @xmath199 with @xmath200 in closer agreement with our results .
our results are also somewhat steeper than , but consistent at a @xmath196 level with , the slacs results ( e.g. @xcite ) : constant slope @xmath201 with @xmath202 ( @xcite ) . however , unlike the @xcite result quoted above this result is for redshift range of @xmath203 . as is discussed by @xcite and in section 8 below
, the inferred @xmath17 may depend on the redshift range , so that caution should be taken in comparing the slacs results with our result .
sdss aperture velocity dispersions and photometric data have been widely used in the literature to infer dynamical masses and dark matter fractions in the optical region ( e.g. @xcite ) and to test halo contraction / expansion models and stellar imfs ( e.g. @xcite ) .
it has been found that the sdss data require non - universal imfs and/or non - universal halo response to baryonic physics ( @xcite ) . however ,
none of these studies have tried to predict mass profiles or considered velocity dispersion profiles , although @xcite have used the slacs mass profile slope distribution ( @xmath204 , @xmath205 ; @xcite ) to further study imfs and halo response .
@xcite argue that for massive ellipticals with mean @xmath206 similar to the slacs systems , uncontracted nfw haloes combined with the salpeter imf can reproduce the slacs slope distribution .
however , their argument depends on two assumptions that the slacs slope distribution at higher redshifts can match low-@xmath20 sdss galaxies and the fiducial stellar mass based on the chabrier imf is correct ( remember that @xmath88 itself is uncertain as mentioned in section 2.2 ) .
nevertheless , the @xcite result differs by just @xmath99 from our best estimate and is within our systematic errors ( cf .
table 2 ) .
in particular , it appears that if one fully considers realistic systematic errors halo contraction effects are inconclusive yet largely due to uncertainties in stellar masses involving imfs ( in preparation ) .
recently a jeans analysis of etgs has been carried out by @xcite based on abundance matching between sdss etgs and the bolshoi @xmath94-body simulation haloes ( @xcite ) and previously available statistical empirical properties of etgs .
the focus of that analysis was to compare the resulting dm profile ( baryonic effects included ) with the dm - only @xmath94-body simulation profile .
a by - product was that mass profile slope values measured at @xmath207 were on average close to isothermal .
this is in contradiction with our steeper - than - isothermal profiles presented above .
specifically , for the case of using the same abundance matching @xmath88-@xmath35 relation our new result @xmath208 ( fit # 10 , table 2 ) is steeper than @xmath209 ( the lower red point in fig .
[ etagam ] ) for a total of 3,000 etgs ( 1,000 etgs respectively of @xmath210 , @xmath211 and @xmath212 ) .
several factors can account for this difference .
first of all , as shown in fig .
[ nser ] our newly measured values of srsic index @xmath25 are higher than the previously adopted values ( @xcite ) for @xmath213 .
this is in part due to the difference in sample definitions .
the @xcite sample includes low concentration spheroidal galaxies at low stellar masses while our sample includes only high concentration ( i.e. @xmath58 ) galaxies . when the semi - empirical approach is carried out with our new distribution of @xmath25 for all etgs ( green curve ) and the atlas@xmath77 imf distribution we have a higher @xmath214 ( the upper red point in fig .
[ etagam ] ) . the remaining difference of @xmath175 can be attributed to other factors including differences in the posterior distribution of parameters ( in particular @xmath2 ) and their correlations owing to the different modelling procedure . in particular
, in the semi - empirical approach the posterior distribution of @xmath103 always had a mean shallower than @xmath215 and was tried to approximately match @xmath216 .
[ etagam ] shows that the revised semi - empirical result falls right on the empirical @xmath6@xmath5 line while the original result deviates somewhat . in other words
, whatever factors contributed to the difference in @xmath5 it can be explained by the difference in the posterior value of @xmath6 . despite the large difference in @xmath5 we find that total mass profiles from the semi - empirical analysis show similar curvature in the mean density slope profiles .
the radial systematic pattern of each mass profile ( fig .
[ rhogamex ] , fig . [ rhogam ] ) and the systematic variation of the characteristic slopes ( fig . [ gamvar ] ) as a function of some parameters ,
in particular the size and the projected effective surface density , implies that there is no natural attractor or strict conspiracy for total mass profiles of etgs .
the isothermal model is good only as a constant - slope approximation to the mean inner halo of the etg population .
etgs are complex systems of luminous and dark matter and the interplay between them may create super - isothermal and sub - isothermal regions .
when predictions of galaxy formation theories are compared with observed galaxies , the same radial ranges should be used and more importantly radially varying slopes may need to be considered .
the tight correlation between total mass and stellar vd slopes shown in fig . [ etagam ] is reminiscent of the pseudo phase - space density profile for dm distribution produced by @xmath94-body simulations ( @xcite ) .
a universal power - law behaviour of the pseudo - phase - space density of dm ( @xcite ) given by @xmath217 ( @xmath218 ) implies @xmath219 where @xmath220 is the vd in the 3-dimensional physical space , @xmath221 , and @xmath222 .
a different slope of @xmath223 in our relation @xmath224 can be attributed to the fact that @xmath6 is for the losvd . indeed , if we consider radial stellar vd @xmath225 ( cf .
equation [ eq : jeans ] ) we recover a slope of @xmath226 . fig .
[ etagam ] shows distributions of @xmath172 ( total mass absolute slope within @xmath2 ) and @xmath227 ( @xmath225 slope within @xmath2 ) for our fiducial model .
there is some intrinsic scatter but the least - square fit linear relation is @xmath228 and @xmath229 for the fixed slope of @xmath230 which are very similar to the above relation for dm .
this implies that there may exist a universal profile of pseudo phase - space density - like quantities in any collisionless components in dynamical equilibria ( @xcite ) .
radially varying mass profiles of etgs call for a careful interpretation of gravitational lensing , in particular strong lensing .
strong lensing depends on the projected 2-dimensional density slope @xmath11 at the einstein radius @xmath12 .
the redshift evolution of @xmath12 in conjunction with the radial variation of the density slope ( fig .
[ rhogam ] ) can produce an apparent redshift evolution of a mass profile from an analysis of a strong lensing sample .
let us make a quantitative prediction based on a strong lens sample recently analysed by @xcite .
the observed mean ratio @xmath231 evolves from @xmath232 at @xmath233 to @xmath234 at @xmath235 with a slope @xmath236 while @xmath237 remains nearly unchanged ( @xcite ) . according to our results for etg mass profiles the mean density slope @xmath238 varies as @xmath239 between @xmath240 and @xmath2 ( fig .
[ rhogam ] ) , which gives @xmath241 .
suppose we are using a constant - slope model for the lensing galaxy to fit the lensed image geometry and magnification ratios , then we would get @xmath242 ( note that for the constant slope profile @xmath243 ) .
the magnitude of this evolution is consistent ( within @xmath99 ) with the reported evolution @xmath244 from a combined analysis of strong lensing and stellar dynamics using a constant - slope model ( @xcite ) .
it is unclear whether this means the reported evolution is an artefact due to the radially varying slope or real because it was also based on stellar dynamics .
however , our results indicate that it is possible that the reported evolution is due , at least in part , to the radially varying slope
. the density slopes at @xmath2 we derive are close to isothermal for massive ellipticals , though super - isothermal within @xmath2 , and are consistent with lens modelling results ( @xcite ) for intermediate redshift ( @xmath245 ) strong lensing galaxies whose einstein radii are on average close to @xmath2 .
assembling statistically significant numbers of mass models of sdss concentration - selected elliptical galaxies we find the following : * two - component mass models reproduce simultaneously the aperture velocity dispersion and the observed velocity dispersion profile slope distribution , but single - component mass models with constant or monotonically varying slope can not successfully predict the observed velocity dispersion profile slope distribution without biasing the aperture velocity dispersion .
* for the region within @xmath2 there is a tight correlation between the mass density profile mean absolute slope @xmath5 and the velocity dispersion profile mean slope @xmath6 as @xmath4 with little sensitivity to the details of the inputs and modelling procedures . from this relation
one can estimate @xmath5 from a measurement of @xmath6 without detailed dynamical modelling . *
the tight correlation between the density and vd profile slopes implies an approximately universal pseudo phase - space density power - law profile @xmath246 with @xmath247 , where @xmath248 is the total mass profile and @xmath225 is the radial stellar vd .
* the radial variation of the total density slope we find in this study may result in an apparent redshift evolution of mass profile in strong lensing observations .
the findings presented in this paper can provide interesting constraints on galaxy formation models . in future studies it would be interesting to compare density and velocity dispersion profiles for galaxies forming in the concordance @xmath38cdm model and test whether they exhibit radial variation and correlation of slopes similar to those found in this study for observed galaxies .
we are grateful to michele cappellari , charlie conroy and surhud more for providing their published and unpublished empirical results as tables .
we thank them and drew newman for assistance in understanding their empirical results .
we also thank joshua frieman for past collaboration and useful comments on an early draft .
we gratefully acknowledge the anonymous referee s comments that helped us improve the manuscript significantly .
mb acknowledges support from nasa grant adp / nnx09ad02 g .
avk acknowledges support by nsf and nasa via grants oci-0904482 and
nnx13ag81 g and by the kavli institute for cosmological physics at the university of chicago through grants nsf phy-0551142 and phy-1125897 and an endowment from the kavli foundation and its founder fred kavli . | we assemble a statistical set of global mass models for @xmath0 2,000 nearly spherical sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) galaxies at a mean redshift of @xmath1 based on their aperture velocity dispersions and newly derived luminosity profiles in conjunction with published velocity dispersion profiles and empirical properties and relations of galaxy and halo parameters .
when two - component ( i.e. stellar plus dark ) mass models are fitted to the sdss aperture velocity dispersions , the predicted velocity dispersion profile ( vp ) slopes within the effective ( i.e. projected half - light ) radius @xmath2 match well the distribution in observed elliptical galaxies . from a number of input variations the models exhibit for the radial range
@xmath3 a tight correlation @xmath4 where @xmath5 is the mean slope absolute value of the total mass density and @xmath6 is the mean slope of the velocity dispersion profile , which leads to a super - isothermal @xmath7 for @xmath8 in observed elliptical galaxies .
furthermore , the successful two - component models appear to imply a typical slope curvature pattern in the total mass profile because for the observed steep luminosity ( stellar mass ) profile and the weak lensing inferred halo profile at large radii a total mass profile with monotonically varying slope would require too high dm density in the optical region giving rise to too large aperture velocity dispersion and too shallow vp .
galaxies : kinematics and dynamics galaxies : structure galaxies : haloes galaxies : formation |
shape coexistence in atomic nuclei has become a very active field of research during the last decades and clear signals of its existence have been obtained at and near proton or neutron closed shells @xcite , more in particular in light nuclei with a closed neutron shell at n = 8 , 20 , 28 and 40 closed shells as well as in heavy nuclei such as the sn and the pb nuclei .
it seems that , without exception , shape coexistence is associated with the presence of low - lying excited @xmath2 states @xcite .
the pb region is a very well - documented example of shape coexistence , both experimental and theoretically ( see @xcite and references therein )
. starting at the neutron closed shell ( at n=126 ) , decreasing in mass until reaching the very neutron - deficient nuclei , even going beyond the mid - shell point at n=104 , there is ample experimental evidence for shape coexisting bands in both the pb ( z=82 ) and hg ( z=80 ) nuclei .
a question that arises is whether or not this structure , in which two or more bands coexist , survives when moving away from the closed proton shell at z=82 . in particular ,
the pt nuclei seem to be a good example to test the survival of the coexisting families of states .
it is highly illuminating to compare the systematics of the low - lying states in the energy spectra of the z=82 proton closed - shell pb nuclei , the z=80 hg nuclei , and the z=78 pt nuclei . whereas the intruder bands are easily singled out for the pb and hg nuclei in which the excitation energies display the characteristic parabolic pattern as a function of neutron number n , with a minimal excitation energy around the n=104 neutron mid - shell nucleus , the intruder structure seems `` lost '' in the pt nuclei .
focusing on the systematics of the energy spectra in the pt nuclei , one observes a rather sudden drop in the excitation energy of the 0@xmath3 , 4@xmath4 , 2@xmath5 , and 6@xmath4 states between n=110 and n=108 , followed by a particularly flat behaviour in excitation energy as a function of neutron number n until the energy of those states start to move up again around neutron number n=100 . to study shape coexistence , there are several approximations available .
among them we have the nuclear shell - model @xcite for light nuclei or the selfconsistent mean - field methods for medium and heavy masses mostly of the hartree - fock - bogoliubov ( hfb ) types @xcite , as well as their beyond mean - field extensions in the spirit of the generator coordinate method ( gcm ) . in the nuclear shell - model , shape coexistence is obtained by incorporating many - particle many - hole excitations across known closed shells in the model spaces used , while in selfconsistent mean - field methods shape coexistence arises in the form of competing configurations based on different nuclear shapes labelled by the corresponding intrinsic deformations @xcite .
we should mention that total energy surface calculations have also been carried out for heavy nuclei in the pb region , starting from a deformed wood - saxon potential @xcite .
constrained mean - field calculations are nowdays routinely perfomed with several effective interactions and different levels of sophistication @xcite .
on the other hand , zero point quantum fluctuations not explicitly considered at the mean - field level can be systematically taken into account within the symmetry - projected gcm @xcite . very recently
several works have been carried out in the pb mass region either starting from skyrme functional @xcite , using the gogny interaction @xcite or the relativistic mean - field ( rmf ) approach @xcite .
a third alternative comes from a symmetry dictated truncation of the large shell - model space , such as the interacting boson model ( ibm ) @xcite .
the ibm starts from the assumption that the low - lying nuclear collective excitations can be described in terms of bosons with angular momentum @xmath6 ( @xmath7 bosons ) and @xmath8 ( @xmath9 bosons ) .
these building blocks are considered to capture the most important nucleon - nucleon correlations in the formation of nucleon pairs ( pairing property and quadrupole collectivity ) corresponding to pairs of nucleons either coupled to angular momentum @xmath10 or @xmath11 .
the number of valence bosons is counted as half the number of valence nucleons , irrespective of their charge ( neutrons or protons ) or particle / hole character , as shown by otsuka _
et al . _
@xcite . in the case of the ibm ,
shape coexistence arises including two - particle two - hole ( 2p-2h ) ( or even higher np - nh ) excitations across the closed shells , but considering them as extra bosons , _
i.e. _ , pairs of nucleons .
this extension is called ibm configuration mixing ( ibm - cm for short ) @xcite .
an advantage of using the ibm is the connection with both the shell - model and the mean - field approach .
the extension of the model space in both the nuclear shell - model and the ibm is based on enlarging the model space with multi - particle multi - hole excitations .
a drawback of the ibm results from the fact that an increasing number of parameters need to be fitted .
they are determined by adjusting to the large body of experimental data , including both excitation energies and b(e2 ) reduced transition probabilities , using a @xmath12 fitting procedure .
thereby , the ibm predictive power becomes curtailed . a possibility to improve
the approach is to rely on the ability of the ibm to derive energy surfaces ( mean - field energy ) associated with a given hamiltonian @xcite .
as the mean field parameters are usually adjusted to global properties like binding energies or nuclear matter properties the range of applicability of the mean field extends over the whole periodic table and makes it a good candidate to be used to fit the parameters defining the ibm hamiltonian .
it is in this spirit that nomura _ et .
al . _ have recently explored the connection between the ibm hamiltonian and the mean - field @xcite , mapping the selfconsistent mean - field energy surfaces onto the ibm space . in the present paper
, we exploit the possibility of studying the ibm - cm energy surfaces starting from a hamiltonian that describes the spectroscopic properties of the chain of isotopes @xmath0pt .
this way to proceed is very different to nomura s method , because in that case the hamiltonian s parameters are fixed from the mean - field energy surface , while in the present work from the spectroscopic properties . in two previous papers @xcite
, we used the ibm - cm to extensively study the pt nuclei .
we carried out a detailed analysis of the energy spectra and absolute b(e2 ) values for states up to an energy @xmath13 @xmath14 mev .
this study allowed us to extract the parameters describing the ibm - cm hamiltonian in a precise way and we concluded that the presence of intruder configurations does not show up explicitly in the pt isotopes inspecting the systematics of the experimental data on energy spectra and b(e2 ) reduced transition probabilities ( up to an energy of @xmath13 1.5 mev ) , as compared to the pb or hg isotopes .
a conclusion was that in the case of the pt nuclei , the configuration mixing is somehow `` hidden '' .
attempts to describe the @xmath0pt nuclei without invoking the effect of intruder excitations have been carried out by mccutchan _
et al . _
@xcite . in the present paper
we will use the parameters given in @xcite without any change .
our goal is to study the energy surfaces of @xmath0pt extracted from phenomenological ibm - cm hamiltonians , using the intrinsic state formalism including configuration mixing and to compare with selfconsistent mean - field calculations , _ i.e. _ , a hfb calculation with a gogny - d1s interaction @xcite . a successful comparison , even at a qualitative level ,
will assess the validity of both viewpoints in the description of shape coexistence .
this particular mass region ( including the pt nuclei ) has been also studied in the framework of the ibm by nomura _
et al . _
without @xcite and with the use of configuration mixing @xcite using as input the total energy surfaces derived from hfb calculations ( gogny - d1 m interaction ) , with the aim of mapping the mean - field energy surfaces onto ibm energy surfaces and , therefore , to obtain a set of parameters defining the ibm hamiltonians .
the ibm - cm allows the simultaneous treatment and mixing of several boson configurations which correspond to different particle hole ( p h ) shell - model excitations @xcite . in the approach that is used in the present study no distinction
is made between particle- and hole - bosons .
thus , the hamiltonian describing the interacting system of two configurations , one called the `` regular '' configuration , corresponding to n bosons and the other called the `` intruder '' configuration , corresponding to n+2 bosons , including the mixing term between the [ n ] and [ n+2 ] boson systems , can be written as @xmath15 where @xmath16 and @xmath17 are projection operators onto the @xmath18 $ ] and the @xmath19 $ ] boson spaces respectively , @xmath20 describes the mixing between the @xmath18 $ ] and the @xmath19 $ ] boson subspaces , and @xmath21 is the extended consistent - q hamiltonian ( ecqf ) @xcite , with @xmath22 , @xmath23 the @xmath9 boson number operator , @xmath24^{(1)}_\mu , \label{eq : loperator}\ ] ] the angular momentum operator , and @xmath25^{(2)}_\mu+\chi_i[d^\dag\times\tilde{d}]^{(2)}_\mu~,\label{eq : quadrupoleop}\ ] ] the quadrupole operator .
pt as a function of the @xmath26 deformation parameter ( ibm - cm parameters as given in @xcite).,scaledwidth=90.0% ] the parameter @xmath27 can be associated with the energy needed to excite two particles across the @xmath28 shell gap , corrected for the pairing interaction energy gain and including monopole effects @xcite .
the operator @xmath20 describes the mixing between the @xmath18 $ ] and the @xmath19 $ ] configurations and is defined as @xmath29 the considered hamiltonian is not the most general one in each hilbert space , [ n ] and [ n+2 ] , but this approach has been shown to be a rather good approximation in many realistic calculations @xcite . in particular , in the present study , we have taken the parameters obtained in @xcite .
these parameters are quite different from the ones obtained by nomura _
et al . _ in @xcite mostly due to the following reasons : first , the present ibm - cm makes no distinction between proton and neutron bosons , while @xcite do not use configuration mixing but take into account the distinction between protons and neutrons , _ i.e. _ , they use ibm-2 @xcite .
second , we obtain the hamiltonian s parameters directly from experimental spectroscopic properties , while in @xcite the authors extract them from a selfconsistent mean - field energy surface , through a mapping procedure .
pt as a function of the axial quadrupole deformation parameter @xmath26 ( see also ref .
in the eighty s a geometric interpretation of the ibm was proposed by ginocchio and kirson @xcite , using the so - called intrinsic state formalism . to define the intrinsic state
, one assumes that the dynamical behavior of the system can be described using independent bosons moving in an average field .
the ground state of the system is a condensate @xmath30 of n bosons ( the @xmath31 subindex stands for boson , as used in ref .
@xcite ) , occupying the lowest - energy phonon state , @xmath32 , @xmath33 @xmath34 corresponds to the @xmath35 component of the @xmath36 operator , @xmath37 and @xmath38 are variational parameters related with the shape variables in the geometrical collective model @xcite , and the reference boson vacuum state , containing no s nor d bosons is denoted by the ket vector @xmath39 .
the expectation value of the hamiltonian in the intrinsic state ( [ gs ] ) provides the energy surface of the system , latexmath:[$e(n,\beta_b,\gamma_b)=\langle n ; \beta_b,\gamma_b @xmath37 and @xmath38 which minimize the expectation value of the energy , _
i.e. _ , the equilibrium values , provide the shape of the nucleus .
the extension of the ibm geometrical picture in order to include configuration mixing was proposed by frank _
_ @xcite by means of a matrix coherent - state method that allows to describe shape coexistence phenomena .
the way to proceed is to define a model space with states @xmath41 , @xmath42 and to diagonalize the hamiltonian ( [ eq : ibmhamiltonian ] ) .
therefore , one needs to construct the @xmath43 matrix : @xmath44 the diagonal terms @xmath45 and @xmath46 only contain the @xmath47 and the @xmath48 contributions of the hamiltonian ( [ eq : ibmhamiltonian ] ) , respectively , while @xmath49 corresponds to the matrix element describing the mixing of the @xmath18 $ ] and @xmath19 $ ] boson configurations .
the expressions for both the diagonal and non - diagonal matrix elements ( see ref .
@xcite ) are : @xmath50 to obtain the energy surface one has to diagonalize ( [ surf - cm ] ) and to consider the lowest eigenvalue . for ibm - cm and for selfconsistent hfb .
we also plot the value of @xmath26 corresponding with the unperturbed `` regular '' , @xmath18 $ ] , and the unperturbed `` intruder '' , @xmath19 $ ] , boson configurations .
( b ) : energy of the unperturbed regular and intruder ibm bandheads , compared with the ground state energy ( full ibm - cm diagonalization ) . ] in the present study , with the aim to obtain the corresponding mean - field surfaces for the considered nuclei , we have resorted to the hfb @xcite approximation based on the parametrization d1s of the gogny interaction @xcite . in the calculation of the total energy surfaces for the pt nuclei @xcite
, the hfb quasiparticle operators have been expanded in a harmonic oscillator basis containing enough shells ( n@xmath51=13 major shells in the present case ) in order to guarantee convergence for all values of the mass quadrupole operator and for all the pt isotopes . in order to construct the total energy contour plots in the @xmath52 plane
, we have to constrain the different components of the quadrupole operator : @xmath53 @xmath54 @xmath55 @xmath56 the relationship between @xmath57 and @xmath26 can be found in @xcite and results to be , @xmath58 where @xmath59 ( @xmath60 fm ) .
further details can be found in @xcite . to compare ibm - cm and hfb total energy surfaces one needs to establish a relationship between ( @xmath61 ) and ( @xmath62 ) .
this problem was first studied by ginocchio and kirson @xcite with as a result that @xmath63 and the semi - quantitative relationship , @xmath64 the latter provides the functional dependence between @xmath26 and @xmath37 and establishes that @xmath26 is much smaller than @xmath37 , however the precise mapping is an involved task . moreover , expression ( [ beta ] ) should be modified because of the presence of two different configurations with different number of active bosons , @xmath47 and @xmath48 , respectively .
extending eq .
( [ beta ] ) to the ibm - cm approach , one should sum up the contributions from both configurations weighted with the square of the amplitude of the wave function in the @xmath47 space , @xmath65 ( see @xcite ) , @xmath66 comparing the value of @xmath26 resulting from both approaches one can not expect an exact agreement ( according to @xcite `` we should not take the actual numerical values ( of @xmath26 ) too seriously '' ) . to improve the results we will use as an _ ansatz _ , @xmath67 we have performed a least - squares fit between the ibm and hfb @xmath26 equilibrium values , obtaining @xmath68 and @xmath69 . in section [ sec : results ] all the results presented for the ibm - cm make use of the above scale transformation ( [ beta2 ] ) . in @xcite , the authors established the connection between @xmath37 and @xmath26 through a mapping procedure among the mean - field and the ibm energy surfaces .
in fig . [ fig - ibm - axial - curves ] , we show for every pt isotope ( covering the mass interval 172 @xmath1 a @xmath1 194 ) the ibm - cm energy curves along the axial symmetry axis , as a function of the deformation parameter , @xmath26 .
prolate shapes correspond to @xmath70 while oblate shapes to @xmath71 .
these curves correspond to the lowest eigenvalue of the matrix ( [ surf - cm ] ) .
the lightest isotopes , @xmath72pt , present two very shallow degenerate minima , oblate and prolate , respectively , that correspond to a small value of @xmath26 , with a rather modest barrier at @xmath73 . consequently , in the present approach
, these isotopes are close to exhibiting a spherical shape .
the next isotope , @xmath74pt , starts to develop a more pronounced deformed minimum .
indeed two prolate and an oblate minimum are observed for this isotope , the deeper minimum corresponding to the more deformed minimum with @xmath75 .
the @xmath76pt isotopes show a similar structure , with a well - deformed prolate minimum , @xmath75 , a large barrier at @xmath73 , of about @xmath14 mev , and an oblate local minimum .
finally , the @xmath77pt isotopes exhibit two quasi - degenerate minima , at the same value of @xmath26 , the first prolate while the second oblate , with an equilibrium value of @xmath26 which decreases from @xmath78 for @xmath79pt towards @xmath80 in @xmath81pt . the height of the central barrier remains almost constant for @xmath82pt at a value @xmath83 1 mev , but is strongly reduced to @xmath84 mev in @xmath81pt . in order to carry out a comparison with the selfconsistent mean - field hfb calculations using the gogny - d1s interaction , we show in fig .
[ fig - hfb - axial - curves ] the energy curves along the axial symmetry axis ( see also fig . 1 of ref
. @xcite ) for the same set of pt isotopes as shown in fig .
[ fig - ibm - axial - curves ] .
the lightest isotope @xmath85pt shows a prolate deformed ground state with @xmath86 , though less deformed than its neighbours , and also presents an oblate local minimum ( see fig .
[ fig_hfb_ener_surph ] ) .
the isotopes @xmath87pt present a rather similar structure with a deep prolate minimum at @xmath75 and an oblate local minimum .
they display a large spherical barrier whose height increases from @xmath88 mev in @xmath89pt to more than @xmath90 mev in @xmath91pt .
for these isotopes , we also observe a reduction in the excitation energy of the oblate local minimum point with respect to the prolate ground state . on the other hand
the spherical barrier starts to decrease and the prolate and oblate axial minima become almost degenerate , in particular for @xmath79pt . from this isotope
onwards the ground state turns out to be oblate while the prolate minimum lies higher in energy .
finally , the height of the spherical barrier steadily decreases and the equilibrium value of @xmath26 changes from @xmath92 in @xmath79pt to @xmath93 in @xmath81pt . comparing both approaches , ( i ) we first of all
notice a different energy scale , in particular regarding the height of the spherical barrier . in the case of the ibm - cm ,
this height amounts for @xmath94 mev in the largest case , while in the mean - field hfb approach , this energy becomes as large as @xmath90 mev , ( ii ) on the other hand , the onset of deformation does not happen precisely at the same masses . in particular ,
@xmath72pt appear to be almost spherical in the ibm - cm calculations , while in the mean - field hfb calculations , a well deformed shape is obtained , ( iii ) in spite of the previous differences , the similarity between both approaches is remarkable for @xmath95pt , for which the spherical barrier heights ( up to an energy scale ) , the prolate - oblate energy differences , and the position of the corresponding minima agree reasonably well .
we remark that for @xmath79pt , both approaches result in degenerate prolate and oblate minima .
finally , for @xmath96pt the ibm produces prolate and oblate minima that are degenerate , while mean - field hfb calculations indicate an oblate minimum , even though the prolate - oblate energy difference is quite small all the time .
it is worth noticing that serious differences result between both approaches concerning the energy scale .
a similar situation is observed by kotila _
et al . _
@xcite where selfconsistent hf+bcs , mapped ibm , and phenomenological ibm energy surfaces are compared .
the first two present a much larger energy scale as compared with the phenomenolocical ibm energy surface , which has been obtained from a fit to the experimental excitation energies and b(e2 ) transitions rates .
therefore , these two cases point towards the existence of quite different energy scales resulting from the microscopic and phenomenological calculations .
a very convenient way to compare the overall outcome of both approaches is to plot the value of @xmath26 of the ibm - cm with the one of hfb as a function of the mass number . in fig .
[ fig - comp - beta ] ( a ) we depict the @xmath26 deformation parameter provided by the ibm - cm and the one obtained within the gogny - d1s hfb framework . in additon , in the same panel (
a ) , we also plot the @xmath26 value corresponding to the unperturbed regular @xmath18 $ ] and the intruder @xmath19 $ ] configurations as `` reference '' values ( see also ref .
as can be seen , there is an overall agreement between the mean - field hfb and the ibm approaches .
both approaches point towards large values of the deformation @xmath26 around neutron mid shell , though the precise neutron number where a sudden onset of deformation arises is different in both cases : the nucleus @xmath89pt for the hfb calculation and @xmath74pt for the ibm - cm calculation , respectively . in fig .
[ fig - comp - beta ] ( b ) , we plot the ibm - cm bandhead energy for both unperturbed structures besides the value of the ground - state energy ( full ibm - cm calculation ) .
note that these unperturbed energies correspond to the diagonalization of the ibm hamiltonian . analyzing these energy curves
, one observes a crossing at @xmath97pt and at @xmath98pt .
these points delimit the area where the intruder configuration becomes the ground state . taking into account
that the intruder configuration corresponds to a more deformed shape than the regular one ( see the unperturbed curves in the top panel ) , it becomes evident why the pt isotopes around the mid - shell n=104 ( a=182 ) are more deformed . in the mean - field approximation , deformation results from the spontaneous breaking of the rotational symmetry @xcite in the considered nuclei .
it is quite remarkable that only one symmetry - broken mean - field configuration already accounts for the trend that is otherwise only obtained within the ibm - cm by invoking the [ n+2 ] boson intruder configurations . on the other hand ,
we see how both approximations are complementary with the ibm - cm providing an intuitive geometrical picture for the onset of deformation around the neutron mid - shell .
even though the calculations along the @xmath26 axis ( only considering the axially symmetric shapes ) already give a clear view of the shape evolution , it is the calculation in the full ( @xmath99 ) plane which provides the more realistic `` image '' of the nuclear shape .
indeed , we will see that for the heaviest pt isotopes the triaxial degree of freedom , @xmath100 , plays a notable role @xcite . before starting with the analysis of the pt ( @xmath99 ) total energy contour plots , it is worth to mention some characteristics of the ibm - cm parameterization . in order to determine the ibm parameters , as described in @xcite
, we imposed a number of constraints to reduce the number of free parameters .
in particular , we have considered @xmath101 as well as @xmath102 to be equal to zero for the whole isotopic chain .
this latter constraint has an immediate consequence on the energy surfaces , _
i.e. _ , whenever the regular configuration describes the ground state of a given pt nucleus , the resulting energy surface will be flat in the @xmath100 direction , or , @xmath100 unstable .
therefore , in the present ibm - cm approach , the possibility to generate triaxiallity or oblate shapes is absent . in the standard ibm the triaxiallity is easily accommodated through the inclusion of three - body terms in the hamiltonian @xcite . in ibm-2 @xcite and ibm - cm triaxiallity can be generated with two orthogonal ellipsoids for protons and neutrons @xcite and with the mixing of two configurations with different prolate / oblate character @xcite , respectively .
et al . _
@xcite have shown that including a three - boson interaction within the ibm-2 formulation , treating proton and neutron bosons explicitely , naturally leads to cover the full ( @xmath99 ) plane .
this turns out not to form a major drawback of the present ibm - cm approach when comparing with the mean - field hfb energy surfaces for the pt isotopes .
the reason being , as discussed later , that the heaviest isotopes , though oblate in the mean - field hfb approach , are not very far removed from being @xmath100 unstable . in fig .
[ fig_ibm_ener_surph ] we depict the ibm - cm energy surfaces for the chain of isotopes @xmath0pt . in @xmath72pt , we observe a flat minimum at @xmath73 , which indeed corresponds to a slightly deformed @xmath100-unstable minimum as was observed in the corresponding axial energy plot ( see fig .
[ fig - ibm - axial - curves ] ) . in the nucleus @xmath74pt
, one observes the onset of a more deformed minimum , resulting in the coexistence of a @xmath100-unstable and a prolate deformed minimum .
this isotope is the only in which two minima coexist . in @xmath76pt
the isotopes present a well - pronounced prolate minimum around @xmath103 .
finally the nuclei @xmath77pt become less deformed than the medium - mass isotopes and turn out to be @xmath100-unstable .
note that in the present ibm - cm approach , no genuine triaxial shapes can appear for the pt isotopes , although , as mentioned before , triaxiallity can be generated through the use of more general hamiltonians . in fig .
[ fig_hfb_ener_surph ] we present the energy contour plots computed with the gogny - d1s interaction for the isotopes @xmath0pt ( see also fig . 2 of ref
. @xcite ) . in this case , the nuclei @xmath72pt have a slightly triaxial shape . on the other hand
, the isotope @xmath74pt appears as more deformed than the lighter ones with a prolate shape .
prolate deformed shapes are also predicted for @xmath104pt while a triaxial shape develops in @xmath105pt . in particular , for @xmath106pt the shape corresponds to @xmath107 .
finally , @xmath108pt still present triaxial shapes but the heavier isotopes come close to exhibit an oblate shape
. in summary , in the ibm - cm approach , the lightest pt isotopes , _
i.e. _ , @xmath72pt , are slightly deformed . in @xmath74pt a prolate and a @xmath100-unstable minimum coexist , but quickly , a well deformed prolate minimum develops in @xmath109pt , becoming the most pronounced prolate minimum at the mid - shell , _
i.e. _ , in @xmath91pt with the prolate shape remaining well pronounced up to @xmath110pt . moving towards heavier mass pt isotopes , @xmath100-flat energy surfaces start to develop .
indeed , for @xmath79pt , a very extended energy surface develops in the @xmath100 direction , becoming completely @xmath100-unstable when reaching @xmath96pt . for the set of ibm - cm parameters used in this work no genuine triaxial shapes can be generated although this can be done using three - body terms in the hamiltonian , having orthogonal proton and neutron ellipsoids in ibm-2 or mixing configurations with different prolate / oblate character in ibm - cm . in the mean - field hfb approach ,
the lightest pt isotopes are slightly prolate . moving to the larger masses ,
the pt isotopes become more deformed , but at the same time the total energy surface starts to flatten in the @xmath100 direction .
passing mid - shell ( at n = 104 , a = 182 ) , the nuclei become triaxial and the heaviest pt isotopes already correspond to oblate shapes . therefore , the evolution of the ibm - cm energy surfaces correspond , to a large extent , with the corresponding total energy surfaces obtained from a mean - field hfb approach .
the most pronounced difference appears for the heaviest pt isotopes , in which the mean - field hfb approach results in triaxial shapes while the ibm - cm parameterization results in @xmath100-unstable shapes .
a similar analysis was carried out by morales _
et al . _
@xcite for the even - even pt nuclei from @xmath111 up to @xmath112 .
they started from the set of ibm parameters obtained in the schematic study of harder _ et al . _
the latter study was performed with the aim of providing a schematic description of the @xmath113pt energy spectrum and , indeed , the agreement with the experimental excitation energies is only qualitative . in ref .
@xcite it was shown that the absolute minimum in the energy surface evolves from a prolate into an oblate shape , finally turning into a spherical shape with increasing neutron number , starting at n=104 and ending at the closed shell value of n=126 .
indications for shape coexistence result in the isotopes @xmath114pt .
a comparison with the results we derive from the present ibm - cm hamiltonian gives an idea about the sensitivity of the energy variations in the ibm parameters .
it is also interesting to compare the present ibm - cm energy surfaces with the ones resulting from the mapping of the selfconsistent mean - field hfb calculations carried out by nomura _
et al . _
@xcite . in this latter case ,
the extracted ibm energy surfaces match very well with the hfb results by obvious reasons and , therefore , reproduce the shape evolution from a prolate to an oblate shape passing through a triaxial region .
this is expected because the mapped hamiltonian was determined through a mapping of the hfb total energy surfaces as closely as possible onto the corresponding ibm mean - field surfaces .
the agreement between both ibm approaches is reasonable , but once more a large difference in the energy scale ( heigth of the spherical barrier ) between is observed .
the origin of this difference deserves further investigation . finally , it is also of interest to compare with previous phenomenological mean - field studies .
calculations by bengtsson _
et al . _
@xcite , starting from a deformed woods - saxon potential , show that the energy surfaces obtained for the pt nuclei turn out to exhibit a more complex behavior when comparing with results obtained for the hg nuclei , covering the region @xmath115 @xmath116 region .
the prolate minimum is lowest in the mass interval @xmath117 , whereas the oblate minimum becomes lowest for @xmath118 and onwards to heavier pt nuclei .
the transition at @xmath119 and , at the lower mass side , at @xmath120 , passes through a @xmath100-soft energy surface .
et al . _
@xcite , who calculated total routhian surfaces also using a deformed woods - saxon potential , arrive at very much the same results .
both of these results are largely consistent with the present ibm - cm matrix coherent - state mean - field results discussed before .
furthermore , calculations within the framework of the relativistic mean - field approximation have been carried out by fossion _
et al . _
@xcite for the pt nuclei in the mass region @xmath121 .
the results point out towards a transition from a prolate , as the lowest one in @xmath122 , towards an oblate minimum , as the lowest one in @xmath123 , with both minima present in the region @xmath124 . beyond @xmath81pt ,
the energy surface becomes rather flat , evolving towards a spherical minimum at @xmath125pt and beyond .
the possibility of triaxial deformation was not considered .
in summary we have carried out a detailed comparison of nuclear total energy surfaces obtained using two approaches : the ibm - cm , formulated within a laboratory frame , and the selfconsistent mean - field hfb approach , starting from the gogny - d1s interaction , which is an intrinsic frame formulation .
the total energy surfaces resulting from both approaches are qualitatively similar even though they have totally different starting point .
the first one is a more phenomenological approach in which the parameters that determine the ibm - cm hamiltonian and , consequently also define the resulting energy surfaces , are obtained making a careful comparison between the large set of spectroscopic properties and the corresponding theoretical results .
the second approach is a mean - field one based on the gogny - d1s effective interaction whose predicted power all over the nuclear chart has been shown in previous studies both at the mean - field level and beyond @xcite .
both approaches result in a consistent description of the nuclear energy landscape which is at the origin of shape evolution in the pt isotopes .
the common results point towards the fact that the lightest pt isotopes are slightly deformed and prolate , becoming more strongly deformed shapes , while at the same time the potential in the @xmath100 direction starts to flatten , developing a triaxial shape once having passed mid shell ( at n=104 , a=182 ) and finally becoming oblate for @xmath108pt ( @xmath100-unstable in the ibm - cm case ) . even though total energy surfaces from the above approaches are very similar in structure for the pt nuclei discussed in the present paper , the final comparison between these approaches has , of course , to be made at the level of the nuclear observables : energy spectra , electromagnetic properties , ground - state properties ( charge radii ) , ... the ibm , being an algebraic model , has an intrinsic geometric structure related to the particular hamiltonian used . as discussed in sect .
[ sec : energy ] , and amply illustrated in the present paper , the crucial ingredient is the use of coherent states resulting in energy surfaces that can be compared with the results calculated using a selfconsistent mean - field hfb approach , starting from a microscopic basis .
it is most interesting to observe a very similar overall description of the energy surfaces describing the long series of pt isotopes .
a next step in comparing both approaches will be situated on the level of beyond mean - field calculations ( bmf ) , that allow for the calculation of energy spectra , electromagnetic properties , ... , which should be compared with the results obtained from the ibm - cm calculations . in this way
, the effect of the collective inertia , inherent to the gcm , will be explicitly taken into account . comparing a large set of observables , as outlined before ,
obtained from a bmf calculation using the gogny interaction , with the corresponding observables calculated using the mapped ibm hamiltonian @xcite will form a major step in order to understand the connection between both approaches . this could be a topic of further study .
we thank m. huyse , p. van duppen for continuous interest in this research topic and j.l .
wood for stimulating discussions in various stages of this work . financial support from the `` fwo - vlaanderen '' ( kh and jegr ) and the interuniversity attraction poles programme - belgian state - federal office for scientific , technical and cultural affairs ( iap grant no .
p7/12 , is acknowledged .
this work has also been partially supported by the spanish ministerio de economa y competitividad and the european regional development fund ( feder ) under project nos .
fis2011 - 28738-c02 - 02 , fpa2012 - 34694 , fis2012 - 34479 and by junta de andaluca under project no .
fqm318 , and p07-fqm-02962 , as well as by spanish consolider - ingenio 2010 ( cpancsd2007 - 00042 ) . | the evolution of the total energy surface and the nuclear shape in the isotopic chain @xmath0pt are studied in the framework of the interacting boson model , including configuration mixing .
the results are compared with a self - consistent hartree - fock - bogoliubov calculation using the gogny - d1s interaction and a good agreement between both approaches shows up .
the evolution of the deformation parameters points towards the presence of two different coexisting configurations in the region 176 @xmath1 a @xmath1 186 . |
during the last years important efforts have been devoted to study ultra - cold fermi gases , both experimentally and theoretically ( for a review see for example ref .
@xcite ) . by means of feshbach resonance
it is possible experimentally to adjust the interaction between atoms .
the system can be tuned to a bcs state where fermions are weakly interacting , to the so called unitary regime where the two - body scattering length is infinite , or to form a bec condensate of bosons . theoretically , ultra - cold fermi gases have become an important testing ground for a host of many - body methods , as well as an avenue to studying new physics .
the study of ultra - cold fermi gases is very intriguing , and the unitary limit became a very interesting many - body problem to solve for several reasons .
these systems can be experimentally studied at very low temperatures of the order of 0.1 t@xmath1 , essentially zero temperature .
they are very dilute , and their properties are independent of the form of the hamiltonian used to describe the system , the results given by any model satisfying the limits of large scattering length and small effective range must be identical .
moreover these systems are very strongly interacting , methods based on perturbation theory , mean - field , or expansions of small parameters are not obviously convergent , and the calculation of the properties of the unitary fermi gas is very challenging .
the properties scale with powers of the fermi momentum @xmath2 .
the interparticle separation @xmath3 is approximately given by @xmath4 , and the dilute regime is guarantee by imposing @xmath5 , where @xmath6 is the effective range of the two - body interaction . the universal regime is given when @xmath7 , where @xmath8 is the scattering length , and the unitary limit correspond to the case of @xmath9 . in the limit of @xmath10 the only scale of the system is @xmath3 or more conveniently the fermi momentum @xmath11 .
thus a natural unit for the energy if given by the fermi - gas energy @xmath12 , and there are no other free parameters .
for this reason , these systems are called universal .
ultra - cold fermi gases can also be realized with population imbalance , and the system can eventually exhibit different phases @xcite where superfluid and normal phases may coexist or phase separate @xcite , or other intriguing more exotic phases like loff or @xmath13-wave superfluidity could appear @xcite . in the last few years
a new direction of research has been undertaken : the realization of trapped two component fermi gases with the mixture of fermions with different masses , in particular the @xmath14 mixture has been addressed @xcite .
the properties of systems with mass imbalance can be very different from the equal masses case ; for example , for majority light population the chandrasekhar
clogston limit is very small and close to zero @xcite .
then , at unitarity , the two components fermi gas with different masses may exhibit very different properties with respect to the equal mass case @xcite , even in the bcs limit @xcite .
several predictions for equal mass fermi gases were made possible through quantum monte carlo techniques ( qmc ) , later confirmed by experiments @xcite .
the variational monte carlo ( vmc ) and the diffusion monte carlo ( dmc ) enable accurate calculations of the ground state of strongly interacting fermions at unitarity , and to study its properties @xcite .
in addition , the unbalanced two - component fermi gases with equal masses do not exhibit a sign problem using the auxiliary field monte carlo ( afmc ) @xcite , and this permits a very accurate calculation to benchmark other many - body calculations .
experiments are possible at very low temperatures of the order of fractions of @xmath15 , and then the zero temperature properties can be directly obtained from experiments . in this paper
we will review several properties calculated using qmc methods , including the exact calculation of the energy , the role of the effective range , the bcs - bec crossover , and other properties including the contact parameter and the static structure factor .
[ sec : ham ] the afmc performed on a lattice through the use of auxiliary fields does not suffer of the fermion sign problem and permits to calculate exactly the energy of the unpolarized fermi gas @xcite .
the afmc method uses a bcs wave function as a trial wave function . in this section
we describe the variational wave function and the dmc method in the continuum .
in our study we model the ground state of the system in the continuum using the hamiltonian @xmath16 where @xmath17 and @xmath18 is the number of particles with mass @xmath19 and @xmath20 .
since we want to model a system that is dilute , particles interact only in @xmath21-wave , and the potential @xmath22 is non - zero only between particles with opposite spin state or with different mass .
several forms of the potential @xmath22 has been explored , and provided to be equivalent in the limit of small effective range @xcite . in most of our studies
we have used the pschl - teller already employed in several previous qmc calculations @xcite : @xmath23 where @xmath24 is the reduced mass , and the parameters @xmath25 and @xmath26 tune respectively the effective range @xmath27 and the scattering length @xmath8 of the interaction . for this potential ,
the unitary limit corresponding to the zero - energy ground state between two particles is with @xmath28 and @xmath29 .
most of the results presented in this work have been obtained by fixing @xmath30 but in several cases we considered different values to check effects due to the effective range of the potential .
it is also possible to use other forms of the potential @xmath31 , and the results are universal in the limit of small effective range as we shall discuss in the next sections .
the qmc calculations are performed using the jastrow - bcs form of the wave function of refs .
@xcite : @xmath32 the antisymmetric part @xmath33 is a particle - projected bcs wave function including pairing correlations .
it is given by @xmath34 \,.\ ] ] the operator @xmath35 is an anti - symmetrization operator , the unprimed coordinates are for spin - up or heavy particles and the primed are for spin - down or light particles , and @xmath36 for the unpolarized case .
the pairing function is parametrized as @xmath37 + \beta(r ) \ , , \nonumber\\ \beta(r)&= & \tilde{\beta}(r)+\tilde{\beta}(l - r)-2 \tilde{\beta}(l/2)~ , \nonumber\\ \tilde{\beta } ( r ) & = & [ 1 + c b r ] \ [ 1 - \exp ( -d b r ) ] \frac{\exp ( - b r ) } { dbr}~.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the infinite volume limit @xmath38 is a function of one scalar variable , the product @xmath39 .
the simulations use periodic boundary conditions in a finite volume . in this finite volume
, the function @xmath40 has a range of @xmath41 , @xmath42 is the size of the simulation box , the value of @xmath43 is chosen such that @xmath40 has zero slope at the origin , and @xmath44 , @xmath45 and @xmath46 are variational parameters .
note that if @xmath47 , and @xmath48 for @xmath49 , @xmath50 , where the latter is the wave function describing the non interacting fermi gas in the normal phase .
as @xmath51 and @xmath33 are orthogonal , we can study the fermi gases both in the superfluid and in the normal phase @xcite .
the pairing wave function used here contains several free parameters that have been optimized by minimizing the energy of the system using vmc and following the strategy of ref .
@xcite . in the bec side of the transition ,
when @xmath52 , we found that using the pairing function as described in ref .
@xcite , i.e. the two body wave function instead of the function of eq .
[ eq : pairfn ] , gives lower energies .
instead , in the bcs case for @xmath53 , the bcs wave function @xmath54 gives almost the same energy of @xmath51 as the pairing becomes less important to the equation of state .
the polarized systems can be simulated by extending the wave function to include single - particle states for the unpaired particles @xcite .
note that the wave function previously described can not reproduce more exotic phases like loff or @xmath13-wave pairing .
the jastrow @xmath55 includes a short- and a long - range part .
the short - range term is given by @xmath56 where the function @xmath57 acts only between particles with different spin or mass , and it is obtained by solving the equation @xmath58 the parameter lambda is obtained by imposing the boundary condition @xmath59 , where the healing distance @xmath60 is a variational parameter , and the quenching @xmath61 is adjusted to be less than one only in the bec regime . the correct boundary conditions to the wave function
are guaranteed by constraining @xmath62 where @xmath42 is the size of the simulation box , but we found that a typical good choice is given by taking @xmath63 . by solving eq .
[ eq : jas ] we also assure the correct behavior of the wave function at small distances so that the jastrow function @xmath64 is defined to have @xmath65=0 at the origin . the calculation in the deep bec can be also improved by adding a short - range function @xmath57 between particles with same spin or mass , and solving the equation above with a repulsive interaction . in order to precisely calculate the static structure function at low momenta ,
it is important to include the effect of phonons as long - distance correlations . in our calculation , we include a term @xmath66 \,,\ ] ] where @xmath67 and @xmath68 are new variational parameters @xcite .
the vmc algorithm is then used to optimize over wave functions of this form .
diffusion monte carlo ( dmc ) is then used to project out the ground state from : @xmath69 where @xmath70 the factor @xmath71 is a constant used to control the normalization of the ground state .
the propagation is achieved using a many - body propagator defined as @xmath72 and @xmath73 a good approximation of @xmath74 can be obtained using a trotter expansion , and iterating the above equation for small values of @xmath75 .
note that for a zero - range interaction the exact two - body propagator could also be used to sample the many - body green s function @xcite . in the case of fermions
there is a sign problem that needs to be taken care .
a common approach combined with the dmc method is the fixed - node approximation .
the sampling of paths is restricted to regions where the trial wave function is positive , and the problem is then recasted into a bosonic problem ( without sign problem ) in a restricted subspace .
this approximation results in providing an upper bound to the exact energy of the system , whose accuracy depends to the quality of the variational wave function .
more details on the implementation of the vmc and dmc algorithms can be found in ref .
the bcs - bec crossover has been calculated extensively over the past ten years .
the unitary limit is very interesting because perturbative methods can not be applied . in addition
, there are no small parameters to expand , and thus using numerical calculations is the only way to accurately explore the properties of the system .
the energy of these systems is given by @xmath76 where @xmath77 is called bertsch parameter .
there have been several calculations of @xmath77 based on qmc techniques , and recently we used the afmc method to calculate exactly the energy of the system @xcite , the results are summarized in fig .
[ fig : lattice ] .
since the lattice space provides a natural regularization of the hamiltonian , it is possible to test different models of kinetic energy or dispersion relations . in the figure
, we show the results obtained using different regularization of the kinetic energy .
all the results correspond the case of infinite scattering length , and in the case of @xmath78 and @xmath79 , the results are obtained at finite values of effective range and need to be extrapolated .
results obtained using different number of particles are included in the figure .
we note that finite size effects are basically absent , as using 38 , 48 or 66 fermions yields to the same energy .
this fact is because the interaction is very short - range , and because pairing of the system is very strong .
particles behave like bosons , and finite size effects associated to the kinetic energy vanish .
the absence of sizeable finite size effects for more than @xmath8040 particles has been also shown with a dmc calculation @xcite . by extrapolating the results to zero effective range
gives the result of @xmath81 @xcite that is in excellent agreement with a subsequent experiment performed at mit @xcite .
the best upper bound estimate using the fixed - node dmc method is @xmath82 @xcite . as a function of the lattice size for various particle numbers @xmath83 and hamiltonians , @xmath61 is the lattice spacing .
see ref .
@xcite for more details.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] another quantity of interest is the dependence of the energy to the effective range : @xmath84 at unitarity the parameter @xmath21 has been calculated using dmc and afmc , and the different calculations yield @xmath85 and @xmath86 @xcite . in fig .
[ fig : reff ] we show the results obtained using dmc with various potentials for the equal mass case , and for a mass ratio @xmath87 corresponding to the @xmath0 mixture .
it is pretty interesting that the value of @xmath21 does not depend to the mass ratio of the two species . as a function of @xmath88 calculated using dmc for the two - components with equal and unequal masses unitary fermi gas . in the case of equal masses ,
the results obtained using different two - body potentials are presented .
see ref .
@xcite for more details.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] the knowledge of the energy dependence to the effective range is important to compare properties of neutron matter and cold atoms . at low - densities ,
neutron matter has similar properties to cold atoms : the interaction is mainly @xmath21-wave , the effective range is small , and the scattering length is large @xcite . in order to make qualitative comparisons between cold atoms and neutron matter it is important to take into account the fact that the neutron - neutron interaction has a small but finite @xmath27 . using the estimate of @xmath21 as a function of @xmath89 opens the possibility to compare these two different systems .
an example of this comparison is reported in fig .
[ fig : nmat ] . in the figure
we compare the cold atoms results corresponding to @xmath10 , the neutron matter equation of state calculated using the @xmath21-wave component of realistic nuclear forces @xcite , and the results obtained by extrapolating the cold - atoms results to the effective range of neutron - neutron potential using eq .
[ eq : reff ] .
-wave part of a realistic neutron - neutron potential , and those obtained by extrapolating the cold - atoms results to large effective ranges .
see the text for details .
this figure is taken from ref .
@xcite.,scaledwidth=80.0% ] in the bcs - bec crossover , the two limits correspond to the bcs where fermions are weakly attractive and to the bec regime with very strong coupling . in the weak coupling limit ,
the energy of the interacting fermi gas is given by @xcite @xmath90 where @xmath8 is the scattering length and k@xmath1 is the fermi momentum of the system . in the very strong coupling limit , when @xmath91 , the system becomes made of bosonic molecules , formed by one spin - up or heavy and one spin - down or light fermion , that are weakly repulsive .
their energy is given by @xcite @xmath92 \,,\ ] ] where @xmath93 is the boson - boson scattering length that can be obtained from a few - body calculation @xcite , or even by fitting qmc results @xcite .
the bcs - bec crossover for a two - component @xmath0 fermi - fermi mixture is shown in fig .
[ fig : crossover ] . in the figure
, the blue and black points correspond to the qmc results obtained using two different values of @xmath27 in the two - body interaction . in the unitary limit
, the energy can be expanded as @xmath94 the fit to qmc results , extrapolated to @xmath10 , gives @xmath95 , @xmath96 and @xmath97 .
the values of @xmath98 and @xmath99 are very similar to the case of equal masses reported in ref .
@xcite . in fig .
[ fig : crossover ] we also show the two limits given by eq .
[ eq : bcs ] and [ eq : bec ] that agree with the qmc results .
the crossover corresponding to the @xmath0 mixture is qualitatively similar to the equal masses case @xcite .
the two different set of points correspond to the results obtained using different values of @xmath27 .
the dashed lines correspond to the perturbative calculation of weakly attractive fermi gas in the bcs , and of the weakly repulsive bose gas in the bec.,scaledwidth=70.0% ]
one of the most intriguing properties of strongly interacting fermi gases is the contact parameter .
shina tan showed that several quantities , including the pair distribution function , momentum distribution , and the static structure factor in the limit of small distances or high momenta are fully described by the contact parameter @xcite .
also the equation of state is related to the contact parameter .
this particular property is very interesting because the contact can be calculated in different ways , and , more important , can be measured in different experiments ( see for example refs .
@xcite ) . in ref .
@xcite several observables related to the contact have been calculated using qmc methods .
we note that , apart the fixed - node approximation , any other observable depends to the choice of @xmath100 . within dmc ,
we have computed observables with @xmath101 where @xmath102 and @xmath103 note that the energy is a special case , because the operator @xmath104 commutes with the propagator @xmath74 , and in this case it s easy to see that @xmath105 .
the fact that several operators basically describe the same contact parameter is a proof of tan s relations but also of the very good quality of the trial wave function employed in our calculations .
we have calculated the contact parameter in the bcs - bec crossover using the adiabatic relation that relates the contact to the equation of state : @xmath106 the contact parameter is shown in fig .
[ fig : contact ] , and compared with recent measurements and with the result obtained by enss _
et al . _
@xcite . in the inset
we show the equation of state .
the experimental measurements based on the bragg spectroscopy are in a very good agreement with our calculations , both at unitarity and in the bec limit @xcite
. obtained from the equation of state calculated using dmc ( shown in the inset ) .
the experimental points of refs .
@xcite and the result of ref .
@xcite are also shown.,scaledwidth=70.0% ] one of the quantities related to the contact is the static structure factor @xmath107 , that corresponds to the sum - rule of the density - response function : @xmath108 the density - response function @xmath109 has been measured by means of the bragg spectroscopy @xcite . at high momenta , this quantity is related to the contact through the relation @xmath110.\ ] ] at low momenta @xmath107 is related to the long - wavelength phonons in the system . the quantity
@xmath107 has been calculated using qmc for different values of @xmath89 in ref .
@xcite , and the agreement with experimental data is within 1% .
the calculation of @xmath107 at small @xmath111 requires extra care . due to the phonon dispersion
, we found it very important to include long - range correlations in the variational wave function as discussed in sec .
[ sec : ham ] . in fig
[ fig : sq ] we show the vmc results for @xmath107 obtained by including ( or not ) the long range correlations in the jastrow .
we note that when the dmc algorithm is also used , the expectation value of @xmath107 is less dependent to the presence of long - range correlations though even in this case the accuracy of the calculated s(q ) is much greater with the improved trial function
. it would be very interesting to measure the behavior of @xmath107 at small momenta , where collective modes are expected to be important . .
the results have been obtained with the vmc , with and without long - range correlations in the jastrow .
, scaledwidth=70.0% ]
in this paper we present recent results obtained using qmc methods for two - component strongly interacting fermi gases .
the energy and its dependence on the product of the effective range and fermi momentum have been precisely determined theoretically and compared to experiment across the bcs - bec crossover .
other properties related to the contact have also been computed , in particular the static structure factor , and the results are in very good agreement with experimental data .
future directions include dynamic response of the unitary fermi gas , inhomogeneous systems and the transitions from three- to two - dimensions , and multi - component fermi gases .
10 url # 1#1urlprefix[2][]#2 giorgini s , pitaevskii l p and stringari s 2008 _ rev .
phys . _ * 80 * 12151274 wille e , spiegelhalder f m , kerner g , naik d , trenkwalder a , hendl g , schreck f , grimm r , tiecke t g , walraven j t m , kokkelmans s j j m f , tiesinga e and julienne p s 2008 _ phys .
lett . _ * 100 * 053201 | in recent years quantum monte carlo techniques provided to be a valuable tool to study strongly interacting fermi gases at zero temperature .
we have used qmc methods to investigate several properties of the two - components fermi gas at unitarity and in the bcs - bec crossover , both with equal and unequal masses corresponding to the @xmath0 fermi mixture . in this paper we present several recent qmc results , including the energy at zero and finite effective range , the contact parameter and the static structure factor , which , at low momentum , depends strongly on the phonons in the unitary fermi gas . |
the supersymmetry ( susy ) is one of the most attractive theories beyond the standard model ( sm ) .
therefore , the susy has been expected to be observed at the lhc experiments .
however , no signals of the susy have been discovered yet .
the present searches for the susy particles give us important constraints for the susy .
since the lower bounds of the superparticle masses increase gradually , the squark and the gluino masses are supposed to be at the higher scale than @xmath15 tev @xcite . on the other hand ,
the susy model has been seriously constrained by the higgs discovery , in which the higgs mass is @xmath16 gev @xcite .
based on this theoretical and experimental situations , we consider the high - scale susy models , which have been widely discussed with a lot of attention @xcite-@xcite . if the squark and slepton masses are at the high - scale @xmath17-@xmath18 tev , the lightest higgs mass can be pushed up to @xmath16 gev , whereas susy particles are out of the reach of the lhc experiment .
therefore , the indirect search of the susy particles becomes important in the low energy flavor physics @xcite .
the flavor physics is also on the new stage in the light of lhcb data .
the lhcb collaboration has reported new data of the cp violation of the @xmath3 meson and the branching ratios of rare @xmath3 decays @xcite-@xcite . for many years
the cp violation in the @xmath19 and @xmath2 mesons has been successfully understood within the framework of the standard model ( sm ) , so called kobayashi - maskawa ( km ) model @xcite , where the source of the cp violation is the km phase in the quark sector with three families .
however , the new physics has been expected to be indirectly discovered in the precise data of @xmath2 and @xmath3 meson decays at the lhcb experiment and the further coming experiment , belle - ii .
there are new sources of the cp violation if the sm is extended to the susy models .
the soft squark mass matrices contain the cp violating phases , which contribute to the flavor changing neutral current ( fcnc ) with the cp violation @xcite .
therefore , we can expect the susy effect in the cp violating phenomena .
however , the clear deviation from the sm prediction has not been observed yet in the lhcb experiment @xcite-@xcite .
actually , we have found that the cp violation of @xmath2 and @xmath3 meson systems are suppressed if the susy scale is above @xmath0 tev @xcite . on the other hand
, the ckmfitter group presented the current limits on new physics contributions of @xmath10 in @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 systems @xcite .
they have also estimated the sensitivity to new physics in @xmath2 and @xmath3 mixing achievable with @xmath20 of belle - ii and @xmath21 of lhcb data .
therefore , we should carefully study the sensitivity of the high - scale susy to the hadronic fcnc . in this work
, we discuss the high - scale susy contribution to the @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 meson systems .
furthermore , we also discuss the sensitivity to the @xmath5 meson and the electric dipole moment ( edm ) of the neutron and the mercury . for these modes ,
the most important process of the susy contribution is the gluino - squark mediated flavor changing process @xcite- @xcite .
the cp violation of @xmath19 meson , @xmath6 , provides a severe constraint to the gluino - squark mediated fcnc @xcite .
in addition , the recent work have found that the chromo - electric dipole moment ( cedm ) is sensitive to the high - scale susy @xcite .
it is noted that the upper - bound of the neutron edm ( nedm ) @xcite gives a severe constraint for the gluino - squark interaction through the cedm @xcite-@xcite .
it is also remarked that the upper bound of the mercury edm ( hgedm ) @xcite can give an important constraint @xcite . in order to estimate the gluino - squark mediated fcnc of the @xmath19 , @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath5 mesons
, we work in the basis of the squark mass eigenstate with the non - minimal squark ( slepton ) flavor mixing .
there are three reasons why the susy contribution to the fcnc considerably depends on the squark mass spectrum .
the first one is that the gim mechanism works in the squark flavor mixing , and the second one is that the loop functions depend on the mass ratio of squark and gluino .
the last one is that we need the mixing angle between the left - handed sbottom and right - handed sbottom , which dominates the @xmath22 decay processes .
therefore , we discuss the squark mass spectrum , which is consistent with the recent higgs discovery . taking the universal soft parameters at the susy breaking scale , we obtain the squark mass spectrum at the matching scale where the sm emerges , by using the renormalization group equations ( rges ) of the soft masses . on the other hand ,
the @xmath23 mixing matrix between squarks and quarks is taken to be free at the low energy . in section 2
, we discuss the squark and gluino mass spectrum and the squark mixing . in section 3
, we present the formulation of the fcnc with @xmath24 in @xmath19 , @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath5 meson systems together with nedm and hgedm .
we present numerical results and discussions in section 4 .
section 5 is devoted to the summary .
the relevant formulations are presented in appendices a , b , c and d.
the low energy fcncs depend significantly on the spectrum of the susy particles , which depend on the model .
as well known , the lightest higgs mass can be pushed up to @xmath16 gev if the squark masses are expected to be @xmath25 tev .
therefore , let us consider the heavy susy particle mass spectrum in the framework of the minimal supersymmetric standard model ( mssm ) , which is consistent with the observed higgs mass .
the discussion how to obtain the susy spectrum have been given in refs .
@xcite .
we outline how to obtain the susy spectrum in our work .
the details are presented in appendix a. at the susy breaking scale @xmath26 , we write the quadratic terms in the mssm potential as @xmath27 then , the higgs mass parameter @xmath28 is expressed in terms of @xmath29 , @xmath30 and @xmath31 as : @xmath32 after running down to the @xmath33 scale , in which the sm emerges , by the one - loop susy renormalization group equations ( rges ) @xcite , the scalar potential is the sm one as follows : @xmath34 here , the higgs coupling @xmath35 is given in terms of the susy parameters at the leading order as @xmath36 and @xmath37 is the top yukawa coupling of the sm .
the parameters @xmath38 and @xmath35 run with the two - loop sm rges with @xmath39 scheme @xcite down to the electroweak scale @xmath40 , and then give @xmath41 when @xmath42 gev is put , @xmath43 and @xmath44 are obtained .
this input constrains the susy mass spectrum of the mssm . in our work
, we take the universal soft breaking parameters at the susy breaking scale @xmath26 as follows : @xmath45 by inputting @xmath42 gev and taking the heavy scalar mass @xmath46 ( see appendix a ) , we can obtain the susy spectrum for the fixed @xmath33 and @xmath31 .
the details and numerical results are presented in appendix a. let us consider the squark flavor mixing . as discussed above , there is no flavor mixing at @xmath26 in the mssm .
however , in order to consider the non - minimal flavor mixing framework , we allow the off diagonal components of the squark mass matrices at the @xmath47 level , which leads to the flavor mixing of order @xmath48 .
we take these flavor mixing angles as free parameters at low energies .
now we consider the @xmath23 squark mass matrix @xmath49 in the super - ckm basis . in order to move the mass eigenstate basis of squark masses , we should diagonalize the mass matrix by rotation matrix @xmath50 as @xmath51 where @xmath50 is the @xmath23 unitary matrix , and we decompose it into the @xmath52 matrices as @xmath53 in the following expressions : @xmath54 where we use abbreviations @xmath55 , @xmath56 , @xmath57 and @xmath58 . here
@xmath59 is the left - right mixing angle between @xmath60 and @xmath61 , which is discussed in appendix a. it is remarked that we take @xmath62 due to the degenerate squark masses of the first and second families as discussed in appendix a. the gluino - squark - quark interaction is given as @xmath63q_j+\text{h.c.}~,\ ] ] where @xmath64 , @xmath65 , and @xmath66 denotes the gluino field , @xmath67 are three left - handed ( i=1,2,3 ) and three right - handed quarks ( i=4,5,6 ) .
this interaction leads to the gluino - squark mediated flavor changing processes with @xmath24 and @xmath68 through the box and penguin diagrams .
the chargino ( neutralino)-squark - quark interaction can be also discussed in the similar way .
in our previous work @xcite , we have probed the high - scale susy , which is at @xmath0-@xmath69 tev scale , in the cp violations of @xmath19 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 mesons .
it is found that @xmath6 is most sensitive to the susy even if the susy scale is at @xmath69 tev .
the susy contributions for the time dependent cp asymmetries of @xmath2 and @xmath3 with @xmath22 are suppresses at the susy scale of @xmath0 tev .
furthermore , the susy contribution for the @xmath70 process is also suppressed since the left - right mixing angle , which induces the chiral enhancement , is very small as discussed in appendix a. therefore , we discuss the neutral meson mixing @xmath71-@xmath72 , which are fcncs with @xmath24 . in those fcncs , the dominant susy contribution is given through the gluino - squark interaction .
then , the dispersive part of meson mixing @xmath73 are written as @xmath74 where @xmath75 are given by the squark mixing parameters in eq.([mixing ] ) and its explicit formulation is given in appendices b and c. at first , we discuss the @xmath76 process , that is , the mass differences @xmath77 and @xmath78 , and the cp - violating phases @xmath79 and @xmath80 . in general , the contribution of the new physics ( np ) to the dispersive part @xmath81 is parameterized as @xmath82 where @xmath83 are the np contributions .
the generic fits for @xmath2 and @xmath3 mixing have given the constraints on @xmath84 @xcite , where it is assumed that the np does not significantly affect the sm tree - level charged - current interaction , that is , the absorptive part @xmath85 is dominated by the decay @xmath86 . at present , the np contribution @xmath87 are @xmath0-@xmath88 and @xmath89-@xmath90 depending on @xmath91 for @xmath2 and @xmath3 , respectively .
thus , we can expect the sizable np contribution of @xmath92 .
we will discuss whether the high - scale susy can fill in the magnitude of the present np contribution of @xmath92 .
next , we discuss @xmath93 process , @xmath94 and the cp - violating parameter in the @xmath19 meson , @xmath6 . by the similar parametrization in eq.([np ] ) , the allowed region of @xmath95 has been estimated in ref.@xcite .
the np contribution is at least @xmath96 although there is the strong @xmath97 dependence .
therefore , it is important to examine carefully the cp violating parameter @xmath6 , which is given as follows : @xmath98 with @xmath99 being the isospin zero amplitude in @xmath100 decays . here , @xmath101 is the dispersive part of the @xmath4-@xmath102 mixing , and @xmath103 is the mass difference in the neutral @xmath19 meson .
the effects of @xmath104 and @xmath105 give suppression effect in @xmath6 , and it is parameterized as @xmath106 and estimated by buras and guadagnoli @xcite as : @xmath107 in the sm , the dispersive part @xmath101 is given as follows , @xmath108 where @xmath109 .
the @xmath110 s are the one - loop functions @xcite and @xmath111 are the qcd corrections @xcite .
then , @xmath112 is given in terms of the wolfenstein parameters @xmath35 , @xmath113 and @xmath114 as follows : @xmath115 with @xmath116 note that @xmath112 depends on the non - perturbative parameter @xmath117 in eq.([epsilonksm ] ) .
recently , the error of this parameter shrank dramatically in the lattice calculations @xcite . in our calculation
we use the updated value by the flavor lattice averaging group @xcite : @xmath118 let us write down @xmath6 as : @xmath119 where @xmath120 is induced by the imaginary part of the gluino - squark box diagram , which is presented in appendices b and c. since @xmath121 vanishes in our scheme , @xmath122 is given in the second order of the squark mixing @xmath123 .
in addition to the above fcnc processes , the neutron edm , @xmath124 arises through the cedm of the quarks , @xmath125 due to the gluino - squark mixing @xcite-@xcite . by using the qcd sum rules ,
@xmath124 is given as @xmath126 where @xmath127 and @xmath125 denote the edm and cedm of quarks @xmath125 defined in appendix d. on the other hand , by using the chiral perturbation theory @xmath128 therefore , the experimental upper bound @xcite @xmath129 provides us a strong constraint to the gluino - squark mixing .
the hgedm can also probe the gluino - squark mixing @xcite .
the qcd sum rule approach gives @xcite @xmath130 and the chiral lagrangian method gives @xcite @xmath131 the experimental upper bound @xcite @xmath132 constrains the gluino - squark mixing . at the last step ,
we discuss the charm sector , which is a promising field to probe for the new physics beyond the sm .
the @xmath133 mixing is now well established @xcite as follows : @xmath134 where @xmath13 and @xmath135 are the differences of the masses and the decay widths between the mass eigenstates of the @xmath5 meson , respectively , and @xmath136 is the averaged decay width of the @xmath5 meson . since the sm prediction of @xmath13 at the short distance is much suppressed compared with the experimental value due to the bottom quark loop , the susy contribution may be enhanced .
let us estimate the susy contribution of the low energy fcnc .
we calculate the susy mass spectrum at @xmath137 tev and interpolate the each mass of the susy particle in the region of @xmath138-@xmath1 tev .
this approximation is satisfied within @xmath10 .
therefore , our numerical results should be taken with the ambiguity of @xmath10 .
the mass spectrum at @xmath138 tev is presented in appendix a. see refs.@xcite , @xcite for the mass spectrum at @xmath139 tev .
then , we have four mixing angles @xmath140 and @xmath141 , five phase @xmath142 , @xmath143 , @xmath144 .
we reduce the number of parameters by taking @xmath145 for simplicity . in the numerical calculations , we scan the phases of eq .
( [ mixing ] ) in the region of @xmath146 for fixed @xmath147 , where the cabibbo angle @xmath148 and the large angle @xmath149 are taken as the typical mixing .
other relevant input parameters such as quark masses @xmath150 , @xmath151 , the ckm parameters @xmath152 , @xmath153 , @xmath154 , @xmath155 and @xmath156 , @xmath157 , etc . have been presented in our previous paper ref .
@xcite , which are referred from utfit collaboration @xcite and pdg @xcite . at first
, we examine the susy contribution in the @xmath76 process .
we show the susy scale @xmath158 dependence of the susy contributions of @xmath77 and @xmath78 in figure 1(a ) and ( b ) , where the experimental central value is shown by the red line .
the experimental error - bars are @xmath159 and @xmath160 levels for @xmath77 and @xmath78 , respectively .
we take @xmath161 .
there is no phase dependence in our predictions .
it is found that the susy contributions in @xmath77 and @xmath78 are at most @xmath162 and @xmath160 at @xmath163 tev , respectively .
namely , the high - scale susy can not explain the np contributions of @xmath164-@xmath165 and @xmath166-@xmath167 , which have been discussed in eq.([np ] ) . as @xmath168 increases ,
the susy contributions of both @xmath77 and @xmath78 decrease approximately with the power of @xmath169 .
thus , there is no hope to observe the susy contribution in the @xmath76 process for the high - scale susy .
it should be noted that the sm predictions are comparable to these experimental data .
the related phenomena are the cp violation of the non - leptonic decays @xmath170 and @xmath171 .
the recent experimental data of these phases are @xcite @xmath172 in which the contribution of the gluino - squark - quark interaction may be included .
the np contributions in @xmath79 and @xmath80 are expressed in terms of the parameters of eq.([np ] ) as @xcite : @xmath173 where @xmath174 is the one angle of the unitarity triangle giving by the ckm matrix elements of the sm .
however , @xmath175 and @xmath176 in the high - scale susy are much suppressed compared with @xmath164-@xmath165 and @xmath166-@xmath167 of eq.([np ] ) , one can not find signals of the high - scale susy in the cp violating decays @xmath170 and @xmath171 . and ( b ) @xmath78 versus @xmath168 for @xmath177 ( cyan ) and @xmath149 ( blue ) .
the horizontal red line denotes the experimental central value.,title="fig:",width=8 ] and ( b ) @xmath78 versus @xmath168 for @xmath177 ( cyan ) and @xmath149 ( blue ) .
the horizontal red line denotes the experimental central value.,title="fig:",width=8 ] -11.5 cm ( a ) 8.5 cm ( b ) at the second step , we examine the neutral @xmath19 meson .
we show the susy contributions of @xmath94 and @xmath6 versus @xmath158 in figure 2(a ) and ( b ) , where the experimental central value is shown by the horizontal red line .
the experimental error - bars are @xmath178 and @xmath179 levels for @xmath94 and @xmath6 , respectively . since @xmath180 , the susy flavor mixing arise from the second order of @xmath181 , where @xmath161 are put .
it is found in figure 2(a ) that the susy contribution in @xmath94 can be comparable to the experimental value in the case of @xmath182 whereas it is suppressed in the case of @xmath177 at @xmath163 tev .
thus , @xmath94 constrains the squark mixing of @xmath183 and @xmath184 around @xmath163 tev .
when the susy scale increases to more than @xmath185 tev , no susy contribution is expected .
on the other hand , @xmath6 is very sensitive to the susy contribution up to @xmath8tev as seen in figure 2(b ) .
the plot is scattered due to the random phases of the squark mixing .
the experimental data of @xmath6 constrains the squark mixing and phases considerably .
actually , we have already pointed out that the susy contribution in @xmath6 could be @xmath7 and @xmath88 at @xmath186 tev , respectively @xcite .
it is found that this seizable susy contribution still exist up to @xmath8 tev in this work . in the sm ,
there is only one cp violating phase .
therefore , the observed value of @xmath187 in eq.([phisusy ] ) , should be correlated with @xmath6 in the sm . according to the recent experimental results
, it is found that the consistency between the sm prediction and the experimental data of @xmath188 and @xmath6 is marginal .
this fact was pointed out by buras and guadagnoli @xcite and called as the tension between @xmath6 and @xmath188 . considering the effect of the susy contribution @xmath10 in @xmath6
, this tension can be relaxed even if @xmath189 tev .
the precise determination of the unitarity triangle of @xmath2 is required in order to find the susy contribution of this level .
it is noted that the susy contribution of both @xmath94 and @xmath6 also decrease approximately with the power of @xmath169 as @xmath168 increases up to @xmath1 tev . and ( b ) @xmath190 versus @xmath168 for @xmath177 ( cyan ) and @xmath149 ( blue ) .
the horizontal red line denotes the experimental central value.,title="fig:",width=8 ] and ( b ) @xmath190 versus @xmath168 for @xmath177 ( cyan ) and @xmath149 ( blue ) .
the horizontal red line denotes the experimental central value.,title="fig:",width=8 ] -11.5 cm ( a ) 8.5 cm ( b ) and ( b ) versus @xmath9 for @xmath177 ( cyan ) and @xmath149 ( blue ) for the case of the qcd sum rule .
the horizontal red line denotes the experimental upper bound of @xmath191 and the vertical one is the experimental central value of @xmath190.,title="fig:",width=8 ] and ( b ) versus @xmath9 for @xmath177 ( cyan ) and @xmath149 ( blue ) for the case of the qcd sum rule .
the horizontal red line denotes the experimental upper bound of @xmath191 and the vertical one is the experimental central value of @xmath190.,title="fig:",width=8 ] -11.5 cm ( a ) 8.5 cm ( b ) and ( b ) versus @xmath9 for @xmath177 ( cyan ) and @xmath149 ( blue ) for the case of the qcd sum rule .
the horizontal red line denotes the experimental upper bound of @xmath192 and the vertical one is the experimental central value of @xmath190.,title="fig:",width=8 ] and ( b ) versus @xmath9 for @xmath177 ( cyan ) and @xmath149 ( blue ) for the case of the qcd sum rule .
the horizontal red line denotes the experimental upper bound of @xmath192 and the vertical one is the experimental central value of @xmath190.,title="fig:",width=8 ] -11.5 cm ( a ) 8.5 cm ( b ) the nedm and hgedm are also sensitive to the susy contribution @xcite .
the gluino - squark interaction leads to the cedm of quarks , which give the nedm as shown in eqs.([cedmqcd ] ) and ( [ cedmchiral ] ) .
we show the predicted nedm versus @xmath168 for the case of the qcd sum rules of eqs.([cedmqcd ] ) in figure 3(a ) , where the upper bound of @xmath191 is shown by the red line .
the plot is scattered due to the random phases of the squark mixing as well as in the case of @xmath6 .
we find that the contribution of edm , @xmath193 and @xmath194 occupy around @xmath90 of the neutron edm .
the susy contribution is close to the experimental upper bound up to @xmath69tev .
since the predicted nedm depends on the phases of the squark mixing matrix significantly , we plot the nedm versus @xmath9 in figure 3(b ) .
it is found that the predicted nedm is roughly proportional to @xmath9 .
if the susy contribution is the level of @xmath10 for @xmath6 , the nedm is expected to be discovered in the region of @xmath195-@xmath12ecm . on the other hand ,
if the nedm is not observed above @xmath11ecm , the susy contribution of @xmath6 is below a few @xmath196 .
thus , there is the correlation between @xmath124 and @xmath197 .
we also show the predicted hgedm versus @xmath168 for the case of the qcd sum rules of eq.([cedmhgqcd ] ) in figure 4(a ) , where the upper bound of @xmath192 is shown by the red line .
the susy contribution is close to the experimental upper bound up to @xmath198tev , which is much higher than the one of the nedm . in figure 4(b ) , we plot the hgedm versus @xmath9 . it is found that the experimental upper bound of the hgedm excludes completely @xmath9
which is inconsistent with the experimental data .
if the susy contribution is the level of @xmath10 for @xmath6 , the nedm is expected to be discovered in the region of @xmath195-@xmath12ecm . if the hgedm is not observed above @xmath199ecm , the susy contribution of @xmath6 is below a few @xmath196 .
thus , the mercury edm gives more significant information for the gluino - squark interaction compared with the neutron edm . however , these correlations strongly depend on the assumptions of @xmath200 and @xmath201 .
the deviation from these relations destroys these correlations .
for instance , for the case of @xmath202 with @xmath201 , @xmath197 is much suppressed whereas the nedm and hgedm are still sizable . on the other hand ,
if @xmath203 or @xmath203 is realized , the cedms are suppressed because they require the chirality flipping . in conclusion ,
the careful studies of the mixing angle relations are required to test the correlations between edms and @xmath197 .
we should comment on the hadronic model dependence of our numerical result . for both nedm and hgedm
, we show the numerical result by using the hadronic model of the qcd sum rules in eqs.([cedmqcd ] ) and ( [ cedmhgqcd ] ) .
we have also calculated the edms by using the hadronic model of the chiral perturbation theory in eqs.([cedmchiral ] ) and ( [ cedmhgchiral ] ) . for the neutron edm ,
the prediction of the chiral perturbation theory is larger than the one of the qcd sum rule at most of factor two .
however , for the mercury edm , the prediction of the qcd sum rule is more than three times larger compared with the one of the chiral perturbation theory .
thus , predicted edms have the ambiguity with the factor @xmath204 from the hadronic model . since the sm prediction of @xmath13 at the short distance is @xmath206 gev , which is very small compared with the experimental value due to the bottom quark loop , it is important to estimate the susy contribution of @xmath13 .
the mixing angle @xmath207 also appears in the up - type squark mixing matrix whereas the down - type squark mixing matrix contributes to @xmath4 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 meson systems induced by the gluino - squark - quark interaction .
we show the susy component of @xmath208 and @xmath209 versus @xmath168 for @xmath161 in figure 5 . at the susy scale of @xmath0 tev ,
the susy component may be comparable to the observed value .
although the accurate estimate of the long - distance effect is difficult , cheng and chiang estimated @xmath209 of order @xmath210 from the two body hadronic modes @xcite .
this obtained value is consistent with the experimental one .
therefore , we should take into account the long - distance effect properly in order to constrain the susy contribution from @xmath13 . before closing the presentation of the numerical results ,
we add a comment on the other gaugino contribution .
there are additional contributions to the fcnc induced by chargino exchanging diagrams .
the chargino contribution to the gluino one is approximately @xmath47 in the above numerical study of @xmath24 .
thus , the chargino contributions are the sub - leading ones . and ( b)@xmath209 versus @xmath168 for @xmath177 ( cyan ) and @xmath149 ( blue ) .
the horizontal red line denotes the experimental central value .
, title="fig:",width=8 ] and ( b)@xmath209 versus @xmath168 for @xmath177 ( cyan ) and @xmath149 ( blue ) .
the horizontal red line denotes the experimental central value .
, title="fig:",width=8 ] -11.5 cm ( a ) 8.5 cm ( b )
we discussed the sensitivity of the high - scale susy at @xmath0-@xmath1 tev in the @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 meson systems .
furthermore , we have also discussed the sensitivity to the @xmath5-@xmath205 mixing , the neutron edm and the mercury edm . in order to estimate the contribution of the squark flavor mixing to these fcnc
, we calculate the squark mass spectrum , which is consistent with the recent higgs discovery .
the susy contributions in @xmath77 and @xmath78 are at most @xmath162 and @xmath160 at @xmath163 tev , respectively . as @xmath168 increases
, the susy contributions of both @xmath77 and @xmath78 decrease approximately with the power of @xmath169 .
therefore , the susy scale increases to more than @xmath0 tev , no signal of the susy is expected . on the other hand ,
the susy contribution in @xmath94 can be comparable to the experimental value in the case of @xmath182 whereas it is suppressed in the case of @xmath177 at @xmath163 tev .
furthermore , the susy contribution in @xmath6 could be large , around @xmath7 in the region of the susy scale @xmath0-@xmath8 tev . by considering the effect of the susy contribution @xmath10 in @xmath6
, the tension between @xmath6 and @xmath188 can be relaxed even if the susy scale is @xmath8 tev .
the neutron edm and the mercury edm are also sensitive to the susy contribution induced by the gluino - squark interaction .
the @xmath191 is expected to be close to the experimental upper bound even if the susy scale is @xmath69 tev .
the predicted nedm is roughly proportional to @xmath9 .
if the susy contribution is the level of @xmath10 for @xmath6 , the @xmath191 is expected to be discovered in the region of @xmath195-@xmath12 cm . for the @xmath192 ,
the susy contribution is close to the experimental upper bound up to @xmath198tev , which is much higher than the one of the nedm .
if the hgedm is not observed above @xmath199 cm , the susy contribution of @xmath6 is below a few @xmath196 .
thus , the mercury edm gives more significant information for the gluino - squark interaction compared with the neutron edm .
it may be important to give a comment that these predictions depend strongly on the assumptions of @xmath200 and @xmath201 .
the deviation from these relations destroys these correlations . in conclusion ,
the careful studies of the mixing angle relations are required to test the correlations between edms and @xmath197 .
the predicted edms have also the ambiguity with the factor @xmath204 from the hadronic model .
since the sm prediction of @xmath13 at the short distance is @xmath206 gev , which is very small compared with the experimental value , it is important to estimate the susy contribution of @xmath13 . in conclusion , the more detailed studies of @xmath4 meson system , the edms of the neutron and mercury are required in order to probe the high - scale susy at @xmath0-@xmath1 tev .
* acknowledgment * 0.3 cm this work is supported by jsps grand - in - aid for scientific research , 24654062 and 25 - 5222 .
in the framework of the mssm , one obtains the susy particle spectrum which is consistent with the observed higgs mass .
the numerical analyses have been given in refs . @xcite .
at the susy breaking scale @xmath26 , the quadratic terms in the mssm potential is given as @xmath27 the mass eigenvalues at the @xmath211 and @xmath212 system are given @xmath213 suppose that the mssm matches with the sm at the susy mass scale @xmath214 .
then , the smaller one @xmath215 is identified to be the mass squared of the sm higgs @xmath216 with the tachyonic mass .
the larger one @xmath217 is the mass squared of the orthogonal combination @xmath218 , which is decoupled from the sm at @xmath33 , that is , @xmath46 .
therefore , we have @xmath219 with @xmath220 which leads to the mixing angle between @xmath211 and @xmath221 , @xmath222 as follows : @xmath223 thus , the higgs mass parameter @xmath28 is expressed in terms of @xmath29 , @xmath30 and @xmath31 : @xmath32 below the @xmath33 scale , in which the sm emerges , the scalar potential is the sm one as follows : @xmath34 here , the higgs coupling @xmath35 is given in terms of the susy parameters at the leading order as @xmath36 and @xmath37 is the top yukawa coupling of the sm .
the parameters @xmath38 and @xmath35 run with the sm renormalization group equation down to the electroweak scale @xmath40 , and then give @xmath41 it is easily seen that the vev of higgs , @xmath224 is @xmath225 , and @xmath226 , taking account of @xmath227 and @xmath228 , where @xmath229 gev .
let us fix @xmath42 gev , which gives @xmath43 and @xmath44 .
this experimental input constrains the susy mass spectrum of the mssm .
we consider the some universal soft breaking parameters at the susy breaking scale @xmath26 as follows : @xmath45 therefore , there is no flavor mixing at @xmath26 in the mssm .
however , in order to consider the non - minimal flavor mixing framework , we allow the off diagonal components of the squark mass matrices at the @xmath47 level , which leads to the flavor mixing of order @xmath48 .
we take these flavor mixing angles as free parameters at low energies .
now , we have the susy five parameters , @xmath26 , @xmath31 , @xmath230 , @xmath231 , @xmath232 , where @xmath233 .
in addition to these parameters , we take @xmath234 . inputing @xmath42 gev and taking @xmath46 ,
we can obtain the susy spectrum for the fixed @xmath33 and @xmath31 .
we present the susy mass spectrum at @xmath138 tev .
the input parameter set and the obtained susy mass spectra at @xmath33 are summarized in table 1 , where we use @xmath235 gev @xcite .
these parameter sets are easily found from the work in ref.@xcite .
0.5 cm .input parameters at @xmath26 and the obtained susy spectra at @xmath138 tev . [ cols="<,<",options="header " , ] as seen in table 1 , the first and second family squarks are degenerate in their masses , on the other hand , the third ones split due to the large rge s effect .
therefore , the mixing angle between the first and second family squarks vanishes , but the mixing angles between the first - third and the second - third family squarks are produced at the @xmath33 scale .
the left - right mixing angle between @xmath60 and @xmath61 is given as @xmath236 which is very small , @xmath237 at @xmath0 tev .
the lightest squark is the right - handed stop and the lightest gaugino is the bino .
the @xmath24 effective lagrangian from the gluino - sbottom - quark interaction is given as @xcite : @xmath238 -\frac{1}{2}\sum _ { i=1}^2 \left [ c_{sll}^{(i)}o_{sll}^{(i)}+c_{srr}^{(i)}o_{srr}^{(i)}+c_{slr}^{(i)}o_{slr}^{(i)}\right ] , \label{lagrangian - deltaf=2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath239 with @xmath240 .
the @xmath241 denote @xmath242 , and @xmath243 are color indices .
then , the @xmath71-@xmath244 mixing , @xmath245 , is written as : @xmath246 the hadronic matrix elements are given in terms of the non - perturbative parameters @xmath247 as : @xmath248 where @xmath249 the wilson coefficients for the gluino contribution in eq .
( [ lagrangian - deltaf=2 ] ) are written as @xcite : @xmath250}(x_i^{\tilde g},x_j^{\tilde g } ) + \frac{2}{9}g_{1[1]}(x_i^{\tilde g},x_j^{\tilde g})\right ] , \nonumber \\
c_{vrr}(m_{\tilde g})&=c_{vll}(m_{\tilde g})(l\leftrightarrow r),\nonumber \\
c_{srr}^{(1)}(m_{\tilde g})&=\frac{\alpha _
s^2}{m_{\tilde g}^2}\sum _ { i , j=1}^6 ( \lambda _ { glr}^{(d)})_i^{ij}(\lambda _ { glr}^{(d)})_j^{ij } \frac{17}{9}g_{1[1]}(x_i^{\tilde g},x_j^{\tilde g}),\nonumber \\
c_{sll}^{(1)}(m_{\tilde g})&=c_{srr}^{(1)}(m_{\tilde g})(l\leftrightarrow r),\nonumber \\
c_{srr}^{(2)}(m_{\tilde g})&=\frac{\alpha _
s^2}{m_{\tilde g}^2}\sum _ { i , j=1}^6 ( \lambda _ { glr}^{(d)})_i^{ij}(\lambda _ { glr}^{(d)})_j^{ij } \left ( -\frac{1}{3}\right ) g_{1[1]}(x_i^{\tilde g},x_j^{\tilde g}),\nonumber \\ c_{sll}^{(2)}(m_{\tilde g})&=c_{srr}^{(2)}(m_{\tilde g})(l\leftrightarrow r),\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath251}(x_i^{\tilde g},x_j^{\tilde g } ) \nonumber \\ & \hspace{2cm}+(\lambda _ { gll}^{(d)})_i^{ij}(\lambda _ { grr}^{(d)})_j^{ij } \left [ \frac{14}{3}g_{1[1]}(x_i^{\tilde g},x_j^{\tilde g } ) -\frac{2}{3}g_{2[1]}(x_i^{\tilde g},x_j^{\tilde g})\right ] \bigg \ } , \nonumber \\ c_{slr}^{(2)}(m_{\tilde g})&=\frac{\alpha
_ s^2}{m_{\tilde g}^2}\sum _ { i , j=1}^6 \bigg \ { ( \lambda _ { glr}^{(d)})_i^{ij}(\lambda _ { grl}^{(d)})_j^{ij } \left ( -\frac{5}{3}\right ) g_{2[1]}(x_i^{\tilde g},x_j^{\tilde g } ) \nonumber \\ & \hspace{2cm}+(\lambda _ { gll}^{(d)})_i^{ij}(\lambda _ { grr}^{(d)})_j^{ij } \left [ \frac{2}{9}g_{1[1]}(x_i^{\tilde g},x_j^{\tilde g } ) + \frac{10}{9}g_{2[1]}(x_i^{\tilde g},x_j^{\tilde g})\right ] \bigg \ } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath252 here we take @xmath253 which correspond to @xmath2 , @xmath3 , and @xmath4 mesons , respectively .
the loop functions are given as follows : * if @xmath254 ( @xmath255 ) , @xmath256}(x_i^{\tilde g},x_j^{\tilde g})&=\frac{1}{x_i^{\tilde g}-x_j^{\tilde g } } \left ( \frac{x_i^{\tilde g}\log x_i^{\tilde g}}{(x_i^{\tilde g}-1)^2 } -\frac{1}{x_i^{\tilde g}-1}-\frac{x_j^{\tilde g}\log x_j^{\tilde g}}{(x_j^{\tilde g}-1)^2 } + \frac{1}{x_j^{\tilde g}-1}\right ) , \nonumber \\
g_{2[1]}(x_i^{\tilde g},x_j^{\tilde g})&=\frac{1}{x_i^{\tilde g}-x_j^{\tilde g } } \left ( \frac{(x_i^{\tilde g})^2\log x_i^{\tilde
g}}{(x_i^{\tilde g}-1)^2 } -\frac{1}{x_i^{\tilde g}-1}-\frac{(x_j^{\tilde g})^2\log x_j^{\tilde g}}{(x_j^{\tilde g}-1)^2 } + \frac{1}{x_j^{\tilde g}-1}\right ) .\end{aligned}\ ] ] * if @xmath257 , @xmath256}(x_i^{\tilde g},x_i^{\tilde g})&= -\frac{(x_i^{\tilde g}+1)\log x_i^{\tilde g}}{(x_i^{\tilde g}-1)^3}+\frac{2}{(x_i^{\tilde g}-1)^2}~,\nonumber \\
g_{2[1]}(x_i^{\tilde g},x_i^{\tilde g})&= -\frac{2x_i^{\tilde g}\log x_i^{\tilde g}}{(x_i^{\tilde g}-1)^3}+\frac{x_i^{\tilde g}+1}{(x_i^{\tilde g}-1)^2}~.\end{aligned}\ ] ] taking account of the case that the gluino mass is much smaller than the squark mass scale @xmath33 , the effective wilson coefficients are given by using the rges for higher - dimensional operators in eq.([lagrangian - deltaf=2 ] ) at the leading order of qcd as follows : @xmath258 where @xmath259 @xmath260 for the parameters @xmath261 of @xmath262 mesons , we use values in @xcite as follows : @xmath263 on the other hand , we use the most updated values for @xmath264 and @xmath265 as @xcite : @xmath266 for the paremeters @xmath267 , we use following values @xcite , @xmath268 and we take recent value of eq.([bk ] ) for deriving @xmath269 . for the paremeters @xmath270
, we use following values @xcite , @xmath271
the loop functions @xmath273 are given in terms of @xmath274 as follows : @xmath275}(x_{\tilde g}^i , x_{\tilde g}^i)~.\end{aligned}\ ] ]
we present the edm of the strange quark from the gluino contribution as the typical example @xcite : @xmath276,\ ] ] where @xmath277 on the other hand , the chromo - edm ( cedm ) of the strange quark from gluino contribution is given as : @xmath278,\ ] ] where @xmath279 including the rge effect of qcd @xcite , the cedm of the strange quark is given as @xmath280 on the other hand , the edm operator is mixied with the cedm operator during rge evolution .
then , one obtains @xmath281 .
\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] s. chatrchyan _ et al .
_ [ cms collaboration ] , phys .
b * 716 * ( 2012 ) 30 [ arxiv:1207.7235 ] ; g. aad _ et al . _
[ atlas and cms collaborations ] , arxiv:1503.07589 [ hep - ex ] . g. f. giudice , m. a. luty , h. murayama and r. rattazzi , jhep * 9812 * , 027 ( 1998 ) [ hep - ph/9810442 ] . s. f. king , jhep * 1009 * ( 2010 ) 114 [ arxiv:1006.5895 [ hep - ph ] ] . m. endo , s. shirai and t. t. yanagida , prog . theor .
* 125 * ( 2011 ) 921 [ arxiv:1009.3366 [ hep - ph ] ] .
m. endo and n. yokozaki , jhep * 1103 * ( 2011 ) 130 [ arxiv:1012.5501 [ hep - ph ] ] .
j. kubo and a. lenz , phys . rev .
d * 82 * ( 2010 ) 075001 [ arxiv:1007.0680 ] .
y. kaburaki , k. konya , j. kubo and a. lenz , phys .
d * 84 * ( 2011 ) 016007 [ arxiv:1012.2435 ] .
j. virto , jhep * 0911 * ( 2009 ) 055 [ arxiv:0907.5376 [ hep - ph ] ] .
p. ko and j. -h .
park , phys .
d * 80 * ( 2009 ) 035019 [ arxiv:0809.0705 [ hep - ph ] ] .
p. ko and j. -h .
park , phys .
d * 82 * ( 2010 ) 117701 [ arxiv:1006.5821 [ hep - ph ] ] .
r. -m .
wang , y. -g .
xu , q. chang and y. -d .
yang , phys .
d * 83 * ( 2011 ) 095010 [ arxiv:1102.2031 [ hep - ph ] ] .
j. k. parry , phys .
b * 694 * ( 2011 ) 363 [ arxiv:1006.5331 [ hep - ph ] ] .
a. hayakawa , y. shimizu , m. tanimoto and k. yamamoto , phys .
b * 710 * ( 2012 ) 446 [ arxiv:1202.0486 [ hep - ph ] ] .
y. shimizu , m. tanimoto and k. yamamoto , prog .
* 128 * ( 2012 ) 273 [ arxiv:1205.1705 ] .
j. hisano and y. shimizu , phys .
b * 581 * ( 2004 ) 224 [ hep - ph/0308255 ] .
j. hisano and y. shimizu , phys .
d * 70 * ( 2004 ) 093001 [ hep - ph/0406091 ] .
j. hisano , m. nagai and p. paradisi , phys .
d * 80 * ( 2009 ) 095014 [ arxiv:0812.4283 ] .
j. hisano , j. y. lee , n. nagata and y. shimizu , phys .
d * 85 * ( 2012 ) 114044 [ arxiv:1204.2653 [ hep - ph ] ] . | we discuss the sensitivity of the high - scale susy at @xmath0-@xmath1 tev in @xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 and @xmath5 meson systems together with the neutron edm and the mercury edm . in order to estimate the contribution of the squark flavor mixing to these fcncs ,
we calculate the squark mass spectrum , which is consistent with the recent higgs discovery .
the susy contribution in @xmath6 could be large , around @xmath7 in the region of the susy scale @xmath0-@xmath8 tev .
the neutron edm and the mercury edm are also sensitive to the susy contribution induced by the gluino - squark interaction .
the predicted edms are roughly proportional to @xmath9 . if the susy contribution is the level of @xmath10 for @xmath6 , the neutron edm is expected to be discovered in the region of @xmath11-@xmath12ecm .
the mercury edm also gives a strong constraint for the gluino - squark interaction .
the susy contribution of @xmath13 is also discussed .
kek - th-1830 * sensitivity of high - scale susy + in low energy hadronic fcnc * + + _ @xmath14department of physics , niigata university , + niigata 950 - 2181 , japan + @xmath14institute of particle and nuclear studies , + high energy accelerator research organization ( kek ) , + tsukuba 305 - 0801 , japan + _ |
the current metallicity of the galactic disk represents a fossil record of chemical enrichment since the birth of the milky way and during its subsequent evolution . as stars continually enrich the interstellar medium with their nucleosynthetic products , the metallicity of the disk increases over time . by investigating the relative abundance of chemical elements as a function of time and position within the galaxy , it is possible to constrain models of galaxy formation and evolution .
much work has been done on tracking the chemical evolution of the solar neighbourhood as a function of time using age - metallicity relations and element abundance ratios in cool f and g - type stars .
the seminal work by edvardsson et al .
( @xcite ) showed the potential of using samples of nearby stars with an age spread to trace the temporal evolution of the disk and the halo , and such work has been extended by , for example , fuhrmann ( @xcite ) and israelian et al .
( @xcite ) .
these types of metallicity ratios have been modelled by many authors ( e.g. carraro et al .
1998 , pilyugin & edmunds 1996 and references therein ) , in order to constrain our galaxy s history .
the photospheric abundances of massive stars ( viz .
stars with zams @xmath2 10 m@xmath3 ) do not have the potential to provide us with temporal information as they are by nature short - lived objects ( with typical lifetimes of the order of @xmath410 - 50myrs )
. however , their high intrinsic luminosities mean that we can spectroscopically observe them at large distances from the solar neighbourhood ; ob - type main - sequence stars are typically 8@xmath5 visually brighter than early g - type dwarfs .
their photospheres are representative of the interstellar material from which they were born due to their relative youth .
hence , we can spatially and radially sample the metallicity of the galactic disk by determining abundances in distant , luminous blue stars .
the radial variation of different elements provides a further key constraint on the formation and evolutionary mechanisms of the galactic disk ( matteucci & francois @xcite , matteucci & chiappini @xcite , prantzos & aubert @xcite , portinari & chiosi @xcite , pagel & tautvaiin @xcite ) .
these models require further observational constraints to restrict the possible influence of their many free parameters such as initial mass function , gas fraction variations , star formation rates , infall and outflow rates and metallicity dependent stellar yields .
previous work has shown that the metallicity of the galactic disk decreases as galactocentric distance increases .
this metallicity gradient has been reproduced quantitatively using a number of different methods .
for example , extensive studies of optical emission lines in hii regions by shaver et al .
( @xcite ) and fich & silkey ( @xcite ) have derived an oxygen abundance gradient of @xmath6dexkpc@xmath7 ; within the region @xmath8kpc ( where @xmath9 refers to galactocentric distance throughout this paper ) .
good agreement was also found by maciel & kppen ( @xcite ) and maciel & quireza ( @xcite ) from pn studies , and by afflerbach et al .
( @xcite ) in a study of ultra - compact hii regions .
several studies of b - type main - sequence stars throughout the disk had given discrepant results , and a much shallower gradient than that derived from the nebular studies ( e.g fitzsimmons et al .
@xcite , and references therein ) .
however smartt & rolleston ( @xcite ) , in a consistent re - analysis of an extensive data - set of b - type stars covering @xmath10kpc , showed that previous b - type star studies produced spurious gradient determinations , and derived an oxygen abundance gradient of @xmath6dexkpc@xmath7 in excellent agreement with the nebular studies .
as a follow up to this , rolleston et al .
( @xcite ; hereafter rsdr ) carried out a more detailed and exhaustive survey of the large data - set gathered by the group at queen s university and have confirmed this result , while also producing abundance ratios of different elements along the disk .
further work by gummersbach et al .
( @xcite ) also indicates that the nebular and stellar results are in agreement within the errors of measurement .
however , most studies of the chemical composition of the galactic disk have concentrated on the solar neighbourhood , and the anti - centre direction .
optical extinction rises steeply in the direction toward the galactic centre , and restricts the optical observation of disk stars more than a few kiloparsecs away . in the anti - centre direction we have previously probed out to @xmath1118kpc , experiencing a@xmath123 ( smartt et al .
@xcite ) , but have only managed to observe open clusters towards the centre approximately 2@xmath13kpc away ( rsdr ) with a reddening of a@xmath122 .
the metallicity within the solar galactic radius is poorly sampled , with only a few ir studies available .
rudolph et al .
( @xcite ) and afflerbach et al .
( @xcite ) have used similar observational methods for far - ir emission lines in hii regions ( of differing sizes ) as ism abundance probes .
this far - ir technique has allowed observation of some inner galactic regions .
these studies suggest that the abundance gradients for both nitrogen and sulphur do tend to increase towards the galactic centre , but both indicate that their oxygen abundance derivations may suffer some uncertainties ( see section[discussion_i ] ) .
carr et al .
( @xcite ) have achieved a first determination of stellar abundances ( in an m - type supergiant ) directly at the galactic centre in the spectacular star forming region within the central few hundred parsecs .
they find an fe abundance close to that of the solar neighbourhood , which at first may seems surprising given the wealth of evidence of a strong abundance gradient in the milky way ( and also in other spirals ) .
however as we discuss in section[dist_discuss ] , this region may be unrelated to the starforming galactic disk ( @xmath13kpc ) as a whole , and its evolution may have proceeded independently .
the metallicity of the inner disk therefore has not been investigated in any great detail , and lacks information on a variety of elemental abundances .
spectra of b - type stars provide the potential to sample many more chemical elements than is possible through emission line studies . as discussed above ,
massive b - type main - sequence stars are excellent probes of the current interstellar medium and sample particularly well the @xmath14-processed elements ( o , mg , and si ) as well as c and n ( smartt et al . 1996 ) .
this paper describes observations of metal - rich massive stars lying towards the galactic centre together with detailed model atmosphere and abundance analyses .
this allows the comparison of abundance ratios in this interesting regime with those in the rest of the disk , as a key probe of the evolution of our galaxy .
the main difficulty in optically probing the inner regions of the galactic disk is of course the high extinction encountered .
this section describes how we identified targets for optical photometry and spectroscopy which are in regions of low extinction , but which have probably originated in the inner disk region .
the catalogue of reed ( @xcite ) provides a database of published ubv@xmath15 photoelectric photometry for objects in the stephenson and sanduleak catalogue _ luminous stars in the southern milky way _ ( @xcite ) .
this catalogue is a fairly complete record of ob - type stars and a- & f - type supergiants and giants within 10@xmath16 of the galactic plane and with longitude limits @xmath17 , down to a limiting photographic magnitude of approximately 12.5 . in order to identify ob - type stars near the galactic centre , which also have moderate galactic latitudes and hence suffer from low extinction , stars from the reed catalogue were selected which satisfied all of the criteria listed below: 1 .
stars within @xmath18 ; hence restricting the sample to objects towards the galactic centre .
stars which are more than 4@xmath16 above or below the plane ; in order to limit the effects of interstellar extinction .
stars which are fainter than v = 11.0 , to sample the more distant objects .
stars with a colour factor between @xmath10.90 @xmath19 q @xmath19 @xmath10.66 ; appropriate for early b - type stars ; + .
stars with a b v of less than 0.5 @xmath1 which implies a reddening of @xmath20 ( for early b - type intrinsic colours ) . the combination of these criteria should produce targets which are potentially normal early b - type dwarfs ( or _ near _ main - sequence objects ) lying within @xmath44kpc of the galactic centre and twelve such stars were found .
the database of reed & beatty ( @xcite ) contains published spectral types for a subset of the objects in reed ( @xcite ) .
however , the fainter objects of the earlier study ( which were the most promising distant b - type stellar candidates ) did not have an entry in reed & beatty ( 1995 ) . as a result we had to rely on colours as a primary selector .
the spectroscopic data presented in this paper were taken on two different runs .
all twelve candidates were observed at the anglo - australian telescope in august 1994 at intermediate resolution .
the rgo spectrograph along with the 1200b diffraction grating , 82 cm camera and the tek1k ccd were used to give a resolution of approximately 0.7 ( fwhm ) .
two grating positions were employed with central wavelengths of 4020 and 4580 , each giving a wavelength coverage of 240 .
the primary motivation of these observations was to identify normal stars for further , higher resolution observations at a higher signal - to - noise ratio , and to provide reliable hi profiles for the stars which did turn out to be normal .
six of the stars observed appeared to be normal main - sequence early - type b - stars .
however one of these was a fast rotator with a lack of metal line features , while another appeared to be a double - lined spectroscopic binary ( composed of two early - type components ) with the metal lines severely blended .
the nature of the other six peculiar stars is discussed in venn et al .
( @xcite ) .
the four apparently normal stars ( see table [ photometry_tab1 ] ) were further observed with the eso 3.6 m telescope using the caspec chelle spectrograph during july 1995 .
the central wavelength was 4500 with a wavelength coverage of near 1300 ( 3920 5240 ) at a resolution of @xmath40.1 .
.photometric details of galactic centre b - type main - sequence stars .
our estimated spectral types are quoted [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] in order to constrain the regions of the disk where these stars were formed , we follow the arguments of smartt et al .
( @xcite ) . for each of the stellar spectra
we have determined a radial velocity , and we compare this velocity to that expected if the stars were co - rotating with the disk at their current projected positions ( assuming a flat rotation curve and r@xmath3 = 8.5kpc , @xmath21 km s@xmath7 from kerr & lynden - bell @xcite ) . we calculate a peculiar radial velocity ( prv ) which is the difference between these two , as a representative measure of the dynamics of the stars with respect to the galaxy rotation .
this prv is only one component of the total peculiar space velocity , with the other two components unknown ( directed along axes mutually perpendicular to the prv ) .
we assume that the second component of velocity is perpendicular to the galactic plane ( which , given the small galactic latitudes of these stars is a reasonable assumption ) .
house & kilkenny ( @xcite ) have given an expression for the force field normal to the galactic plane ( @xmath22 ) , but this is probably only valid for @xmath23kpc .
given that these stars have origins closer to the galactic centre , we have assumed a simple relation which is an approximation to the shape of the house & kilkenny form of @xmath22 , but which is always greater in magnitude ( with a peak of twice the house & kilkenny maximum ) .
we assume that within @xmath24pc the force field @xmath22 is approximated by @xmath25 ( with @xmath26cms@xmath27pc@xmath7 ) and for @xmath28pc then @xmath29 .
analytical expressions for the initial velocity ( v@xmath30 ) and time required for the stars to reach their present @xmath31 distance , could then be deduced .
the initial ejection velocity perpendicular to the galactic plane needs to be no more than 100 km s@xmath7 ( see table[distance_data ] ) for these stars to reach their present positions , and significantly less for three of the objects .
velocities of this order are well within those plausible for common ejection methods ( leonard @xcite ) .
the prv of each star is also relatively low , indicating that the initial space velocities of these stars were probably directed mostly in the @xmath31-direction .
however without proper motion information we can not definitively constrain their space velocity . if we assume that the mean ejection velocity in the sample ( v@xmath32 60 km s@xmath7 ) is indicative of the maximum value of any one velocity component
, then we can calculate a circular locus within which the star probably formed . in 20myrs , a star could have moved 1.7kpc within ( or parallel to ) the galactic disk , and this is a reasonable error on the birth sites of the stars .
[ galactic_pos ] figure [ galactic_pos ] illustrates the estimated stellar birth sites and also schematically draws attention to features of galactic structure in this region .
bertelli et al .
( @xcite ) have discussed the possibility that a ` stellar ring ' exists , which surrounds the galactic centre at a distance of 3.5kpc , with a 0.5kpc half - width .
the nature of this ring is still somewhat uncertain , but bertelli et al .
claim that assuming it to be a region of increased stellar disk density would produce synthetic colour - magnitude diagrams closely matching those they have observed in fields towards the galactic centre .
they suggest that it is associated with active star formation , and that the cross - section through this ring is at a maximum when viewed at @xmath33 .
they further suggest that this is consistent with an observed peak in oh maser sources ( blommaert et al .
@xcite ) around @xmath34 , a signature of relatively recent star formation . whether this is a complete ring surrounding the inner galaxy , or part of an inner spiral arm , is still debatable ( ortiz & lpine @xcite ) .
clemens et al .
( @xcite ) have mapped the distribution of molecular gas in the first quadrant of the galaxy , and found an h@xmath35 ring at approximately 4kpc from the centre .
this would appear to correlate with the stellar ring found by bertelli et al .
, but the latter suggest that the stellar and molecular ring are not necessarily co - incident . rather that the molecular ring maybe the result of a `` bow - shock of propagating star formation '' .
although some galaxy models ( bahcall & soneira 1980 ; bahcall 1986 ) adopt a relation for the number density of disk stars which falls off exponentially with increasing distance from the galactic centre , it appears that at [email protected] from the galactic centre there is a sharp decrease in the stellar disk density ( bertelli et al 1995 , paczynski et al .
this has been interpreted as the transition between the disk and the bulge .
figure [ galactic_pos ] suggests that the four b - type stars have their origins in this stellar ring , or where the molecular ring dynamics are causing current star formation . indeed
if there is a disk / bulge transition , early - type stars may be relatively rare within this inner region , although current and spectacular star formation is certainly on - going in the inner few hundred parsecs ( serabyn et al .
1998 ; najarro et al .
the above indicates that our b - type stars probably formed around [email protected] in the galactic disk and were subsequently ejected .
carr et al .
( @xcite ) have presented ir spectra of a red m - type supergiant ( irs7 ) lying in the central cluster , and compared the metal line spectra with that of a similar star in the solar neighbourhood .
a differential abundance analysis of the star indicates that it has an fe abundance very close to solar , and certainly does not appear metal enhanced in any significant way ( although it does appear to show cno - abundances typical of severe dredge - up after core h - burning ) . at first this may seem a surprising result given that one might expect a linear galactic abundance gradient in the thin disk to keep rising towards the centre , and that the central regions would thus show super - metal rich abundances .
however there is lack of molecular gas , young stars and hii regions within the inner 3.5kpc , until one gets to the central cluster .
hence , whatever the evolutionary history of the massive stellar clusters at the centre , it seems to have occurred independently of the milky way disk ( @xmath38kpc ) .
there is no reason therefore too assume that the disk and central cluster are chemically linked , and one should consider them as separate entities in evolutionary scenarios .
as discussed in sections[ls5130_dis][ls5127_dis ] , all four stars have relatively normal oxygen abundances . if the oxygen abundance gradients derived in the solar neighbourhood and outer disk are extrapolated inwards ( smartt & rolleston 1997 , rsdr ; @xmath10.07 dexkpc@xmath7 ) their o abundances would be [email protected] above the solar neighbourhood value .
ls5130 and ls4419 show no evidence at all of oxygen - rich photospheres , and both sample the oii line spectra extremely well , with 43 and 28 features measured respectively .
if the statistical errors are normally distributed around the mean , then the random error in our mean differential abundance ( @xmath39 ; where @xmath40 is the standard deviation quoted in tables[ls5130_abundances ] and [ ls4419_abundances ] ) may be as small as @xmath410.04 for both these stars .
furthermore , a systematic error in the atmospheric parameters significantly greater than that quoted in table[typical_errors ] would be required to make these stars o - rich which would have major consequences for the other elements and for the continuum fitting of the @xmath0 indices .
the large number of oii lines well observed in these stars and the possible error sources in table[typical_errors ] make this a robust result .
the other two stars ls4784 and ls5127 show marginal evidence for oxygen abundances higher than their comparison stars , with standard errors of the mean @xmath410.1dex .
however again these results appear to be incompatible with an o abundance that is [email protected] above solar .
a number of previous authors have speculated that the oxygen abundance gradient ( in particular ) may steepen towards the centre ( vlchez & esteban @xcite , shaver et al .
@xcite ) . however , we can find no evidence that this is the case .
figure[osimg_gradients ] shows the oxygen abundances of our stars together with those of the large galactic b - star sample of rsdr .
the low metallicity stars in the outer galaxy ( @xmath42kpc ) are clearly evident , but between 6@xmath19kpc there is little evidence of o abundance variations .
the four new stellar points toward the centre accentuate this relation , and it would appear that the o abundance gradient in the galaxy flattens off at around 9kpc and does not significantly increase at smaller galactocentric distances .
afflerbach et al .
( @xcite ) have carried out an extensive study of the n , s and o abundances in hii regions with @xmath43kpc . in fig.[on_hii_comp ] , their o abundances are plotted together with those for our stars and the stellar sample of rsdr with @xmath43kpc .
the results from the hii regions and the rsdr data - set in the outer galaxy are in excellent agreement ( see rsdr and smartt @xcite for further details ) .
however differences appear at smaller galactocentric distances .
in particular while the hii region data is consistent with a linear gradient @xmath10.06dexkpc@xmath7 , no significant variations are apparant for the b - stars .
one possible explanation is that the zero - points for the two studies is somewhat different .
for example , if the afflerbach et al .
data were shifted upwards by @xmath40.2dex ( the difference in the mean results within @xmath44kpc ) , then good agreement would be found within the solar neighbourhood , but the b - stars towards the centre would not reflect the hii region results . the cause of this discrepancy is unclear and appears to be limited to oxygen ( see sect .
[ discussion_ii ] and [ discussion_iii ] ) .
we note that afflerbach et al .
is the only hii region study of the inner galaxy to quote oxygen abundances .
rudolph et al .
( 1997 ) were unable to independently determine s and o , while shaver et al .
( 1983 ) point out that their two inner galaxy objects ( @xmath11 4kpc ) are somewhat peculiar , and that their radio and optical sources may not be the same .
afflerbach et al .
have recalculated n abundances from the data of simpson et al .
( @xcite ) and find differences of a factor of @xmath42 in some of the highest metallicity regions .
additionally , on average there seems to be a 50% discrepancy in the sulphur abundances .
therefore it appears that the nebular abundances in the inner galaxy require further study to constrain their absolute values , while a more extensive sample of b - stars is required .
smartt et al .
( @xcite ) have discussed the problem of determining reliable absolute nebular abundances in regions of solar abundance and above in m31 , and find significant discrepancies across different analysis methods . in terms of effective radius ( where @xmath45kpc , from de vaucouleurs & pence @xcite ) , the break in the observed o abundance gradient occurs at @xmath46 .
the spiral galaxy ngc2403 has been studied by garnett et al .
( @xcite ) who estimated hii region abundances at 12 points across the disk . in fig[mw_ngc2403_grads ] the oxygen abundance is plotted as a function of effective radius for both these galaxies .
a similar gradient change may be present in ngc2403 , although the sampling is relatively sparse .
this would imply that a two component model for the radial variation of oxygen is not exclusive to our own galaxy and suggests indirect evidence that it is a real effect .
certainly the data suggests that for both galaxies , at @xmath47 , there is little evidence for increasing oxygen abundances .
however , the well studied galaxy m33 ( garnett et al .
@xcite , henry & howard @xcite , monteverde et al .
@xcite ) which is similar in size , mass and metallicity to ngc2403 does not appear to show such a break . additionally , m101 and ngc4303 are other examples of extensively studied galaxies ( kennicutt & garnett @xcite , martin & roy @xcite ) , with 30@xmath180 hii region data points sampled in each .
neither show evidence for anything other than a linear relation across the whole disk .
the magnesium and silicon abundances for the galactic centre stars and the corresponding rsdr dataset are plotted in fig[osimg_gradients ] . for oxygen and silicon
we note that the absolute abundances derived in our two solar neighbourhood standard stars are similar to the mean of the rsdr data set within 1kpc of the sun .
hence the absolute results of the galactic centre stars are on a consistent scale to the rest of the data .
however with mg , the abundance derived in @xmath48 peg and @xmath49 her is 7.2dex , whereas in rsdr the mean local value is 7.85 dex ( again estimated from the mean of stellar values within 1kpc of the sun ) .
the stars analysed in this paper have effective temperatures in the range @xmath50k , while the rsdr sample have a mean temperature of 25275k and it is possible that the modelling of this line is temperature dependent .
it is important to use homogeneous datasets when looking for abundance trends and that is indeed what was done in rsdr .
they showed that although the zero - point of any particular abundance may be in the error , any gradient biasing is removed by using suitable sub - samples of stars . hence to put the four galactic centre stars onto the same scale as rsdr , we have added 7.85dex to their _ differential _ mg abundances .
this assumes that @xmath48 peg , @xmath49 her and the stars within 1kpc of the sun in rsdr have similar abundances and that any offset is due to temperature dependent modelling inaccuracies .
it appears that the galactic centre stars are richer in mg than their local counterparts ( see also sect[ls5127_mgii_line ] ) . from table[typical_errors ] an underestimate of the microturbulence ( @xmath51 ) in each star could reduce this mg overabundance as it is based on a relatively strong line .
however an increase in @xmath51 by 5 km s@xmath7 or more in each star would be required .
while observational uncertainties might cause a particular determination of @xmath51 to have such an error , there is no evidence that we have _ systematically _ underestimated the microturbulence in each star .
the mg abundance gradient in fig .
[ osimg_gradients ] hence appears to steadily increase towards the centre . a value of @xmath52dexkpc@xmath7is derived by fitting all points , which is slightly larger the rsdr result , although they agree within the uncertainties .
the silicon abundances of the galactic centre stars are also plotted in fig.[osimg_gradients ] , and again appear compatible with a steadily increasing abundance gradient towards the centre . a fit through all the si points
gives a gradient of @xmath53dexkpc@xmath7 , again in good agreement with the rsdr value for the outer galaxy only .
the differential abundances derived for each star are between [email protected] higher than their respective standards , strongly supporting the idea that these stars are richer in si than solar neighbourhood material . in fig.[fig_sal_grads ] the al abundances of the galactic centre stars are plotted again with the data from rsdr .
aluminium appears to increase steadily toward the centre , and a gradient of @xmath54 dexkpc@xmath7 is derived from the whole data set , similar to that produced by rsdr for the anti - centre direction .
sulphur abundances for our stars are also available , although we have no similar data at greater radii from rsdr . in fig[fig_sal_grads ] our stellar abundances are compared with with those from afflerbach et al .
reasonable agreement is found with these stars appearing to be s - rich and having abundances similar to those found in nebular studies towards the centre ( although the caveat regarding the nebular absolute values discussed in the previous section may be important ) .
the correlation of of o , mg , and si abundances found in the outer galaxy ( see rsdr ) and in the low metallicity magellanic clouds ( rolleston et al .
@xcite ) is theoretically expected as these elements are all produced and returned to the ism through supernovae typeii .
one would expect that this trend should continue towards the inner galaxy , and it is surprising that our o abundances show no sign of increase , while mg and si appear significantly higher than their comparison stars .
the s abundances in these stars are also higher than normal , although the dataset is somewhat less robust given the weakness of the absorption features of this element .
prantzos et al .
( @xcite ) have investigated the effect of metallicity dependent yields ( taken from the model calculations of maeder @xcite ) on the galactic chemical evolution of c and o and concluded that oxygen yields from massive stars tend to decrease towards higher metallicities .
this is due to mass loss in low metallicity stars , resulting in most of the star s mass being retained up until the final explosion . however , at high metallicities significantly more mass is ejected in the stellar wind ( which is rich in helium and carbon ) , and leaves a smaller mass fraction which can be converted into oxygen .
the relatively high carbon and low oxygen abundances derived here are in qualitative agreement with the situation predicted by these models .
a full study of the evolution of elements heavier than oxygen has not been undertaken using metallicity dependent yields .
however maeder ( 1992 ) has discussed how the combined yield of `` heavy elements '' ( defined as ne , mg , si , s , ca & fe ) from massive stars varies with original metal composition .
interestingly , he finds that the `` heavy element '' contributions of the stellar models at high metallicity ( @xmath55 ) are not as low as is the case for oxygen .
the situation is further complicated by the fact that chemical yields are dependent on the conditions for black hole formation since the final yield of a pre - supernova massive star ( pictured in the conventional onion - skin model ) depends on what fraction of the stellar layers are retained during core collapse .
the observational findings presented here should provide a stimulus to investigations of the evolution of the galaxy at high metallicities , given the probability that stellar yields are highly variable with metallicity , and dependent on the limits of black hole formation .
furthermore , we should attempt to determine the true quantitative variation in the ratios of the @xmath14-elements in the inner galaxy to investigate if this trend is real . the recent chemical evolution models of portinari & chiosi ( @xcite , @xcite ) do indicate that the o abundance gradient may indeed flatten off in the region @xmath56kpc , which is encouraging .
however their sn typeii yields would suggest that the other @xmath14-processed elements ( mg and si ) should follow a similar trend , which we do not observe .
boissier & prantzos ( @xcite ) also suggest that their evolutionary models for the milky way predict a flattening of the metallicity gradient with time , and that saturation is reached in the inner galaxy .
this is in reasonable quantitative agreement with what we find for oxygen abundances , but does not explain the behaviour of the other elements .
each of the four stars do appear to have nitrogen abundances significantly higher than their solar neighbourhood counterparts .
the result for ls5130 is more marginal than the others , but with 19 features measured an error in the mean ( @xmath57 ) of 0.03dex would suggest that the enrichment is real although small .
figure4(b ) shows the nitrogen abundances of the galactic centre stars plotted along with a sample of stars from rsdr , and the hii regions from afflerbach et al .
the gradient found in rsdr appears to continue towards the centre ; certainly the abundance estimates do not appear to flatten as for oxygen .
reasonably good agreement with the absolute values of the hii region analyses is found , and we calculate quite a significant gradient for @xmath58n / o . the full sample of rsdr yielded a gradient in n / o of @xmath59dexkpc@xmath7 , and this is increased slightly by the inclusion of the four galactic centre stars .
the latter effect is clearly due to the stars showing enhanced nitrogen in their atmospheres , but normal oxygen .
we have previously discussed the possibility of n - rich core gas contaminating the surface of young massive stars , and hence polluting the natal photospheric material ( rsdr ) .
however due to the lack of a strong anti - correlation of c and n , rsdr found no evidence for such contamination and the same argument holds for the four stars analysed here .
an explanation of the n / o gradient was discussed in rsdr , based on the original ideas of vila - costas & edmunds ( @xcite ) . at metallicities higher than @xmath60 o / h @xmath48.3 , @xmath58
n / o would be proportional to @xmath58 o / h , because n enrichment would be dominated by secondary production , i.e. from c and o seed nuclei in the natal interstellar material through the cno - cycle . primary production would play a minimal role in contributing to the ism abundance of n , and simple closed - box models in which the production of n is dominated by secondary production do predict a linear trend . at low metallicities
the secondary component becomes less important ( due to its inherent dependence on metallicity ) , and the dominant mechanism for the production of nitrogen is primary .
the metallicity at which this happens is around 8.3dex , close to the value found in the outer most regions of the galactic disk .
these ideas stem from the fact that the n / o ratios in low metallicity dwarf galaxies show a very large scatter , with little discernable trend . as primary nitrogen orginates in low - intermediate mass stars
there is a time delay between is enrichment and that of primary oxygen ( from short - lived massive stars ) , hence the scatter at low metallicitities is often interpreted as time dependent delays between oxygen and nitrogen enrichments .
however at the high metallicities we are dealing with , it is likely that secondary production ( in massive stars is dominant ) , and there would thus be no delay between n and o production .
our n / o ratios toward the galactic centre tend to support the conclusions of rsdr that the n / o gradient in the galaxy is real , and due to secondary n production dominating across the disk . in fig.[fig_co_grads ]
carbon abundances for the four galactic centre stars and from the rsdr compilation are plotted .
as three of our new points are c - rich , it is not surprising that the abundances appears to steadily increase toward the centre . as discussed for nitrogen , because the stars are not rich in oxygen the c / o ratio is greater than normal , hence producing a larger ( and statistically more significant ) gradient than that given in rsdr .
as discussed by maeder ( 1992 ) this would be consistent with c being produced at a greater rate than o in metal - rich stars ( section[discussion_ii ] ) , due to the increased mass - loss in the post he - burning phase .
the analysis of high - quality data for four blue stars lying towards the galactic centre , and a comparison with young stars throughout the galactic disk , leads to the following conclusions 1 .
the four stars appear to be normal , young , massive , early b - type stars .
they lie slightly out of the galactic plane and their calculated distances indicate that they are at distances from the disk of @xmath61kpc .
a kinematic analysis indicates that they were probably born in the disk within @xmath62kpc of the galactic centre and then subsequently ejected .
comparison with galactic structure models suggests they may have originated in the stellar or molecular ring at @xmath63kpc .
2 . a differential line - by - line abundance analysis of the four stars with two bright stars near
the sun indicates a surprising abundance pattern : * two of the stars ( ls5130 and ls4419 ) have oxygen abundances very similar to stars in the solar neighbourhood .
the other two ( ls4784 and ls5130 ) show only marginal evidence for enhanced oxygen . in all cases
any enhancement is significantly below the @xmath64dex that would be expected given the galactic position of the stars and the gradient from rsdr .
oxygen is a very reliably determined abundance in these particular types of stars . * the relatively well measured abundances of si , al , mg and s however
do indicate that these stars have enhanced abundances in most other elements .
however , the physical cause of the natal gas having a `` normal '' oxygen content and enriched @xmath14-processed elements is unclear .
the si and mg abundances are consistent with the continuation of the linear gradient derived by rsdr for stars in the solar neighbourhood and the outer galaxy .
* the four stars also appear rich in both c and n , again in agreement with a continuation of the rsdr gradients towards the centre .
* we discuss the possible errors in our analysis , and conclude that it is unlikely that these stars have higher oxygen abundances than those typically found in the solar neighbourhood .
it is also very likely they are rich in all the other elements studied ( c , n , mg , si , s , al ) although the physical pocesses that produces such a pattern is unclear .
* appendix a : table9 and 10 are the lists of equivalent widths of all metal lines measured in the spectra of the galactic centre stars and the standards @xmath49her , and @xmath48peg . and is available electronically * afflerbach a. , churchwell e. , werner m.w .
, 1997 478 , 190 anders e. , grevesse n. , 1989 , geochim .
acta 53 , 197 bahcall j.n . , 1986 , ara&a 24 , 577 bahcall j.n . , soneira r.m . , 1980 ,
apjs 44 , 73 baldwin j.a . ,
ferland g.a .
, martin p.g . , et al .
1991 , apj 374 , 580 bertelli g. , bressan a. , chiosi c. , ng y.k . ,
ortolani s. , 1995 , a&a 301 , 381 blommaert j.a.d.l .
, langevelde van h.j . , michiels w. , 1994 , a&a 287 , 479 brown p.j.f . , 1987 , phd thesis , queens university of belfast boissier s. , prantzos n. , 1999 , mnras 307 , 857 cardelli j.a . ,
meyer d.m . , jura m. , savage b.d . , 1996 ,
apj 467 , 334 carr j.s . , sellgren k. , balachandran s.c . , 2000 , apj 530 , 307 carraro g. , ng y.k . , portinari l. , 1998 , mnras 296 , 1054 clemens d.p .
, sanders d.b . , scoville n.z . , 1998 ,
apj 327 , 139 cunha k. , lambert d. , 1994 , apj 426 , 170 davis l.e . , 1994 , a reference guide to the iraf / daophot package , noao laboratory deutschman w.a . ,
davis r.j .
, schild r.e . , 1976 , apjs 30 , 97 de vaucouleurs g. , pence w. d. , 1978 , aj 83 , 1163 edvardsson b. , andersen j. , gustafsson b. , et al .
1993 , a&a 75 , 101 fich m. , silkey m. , 1991 , apj 366 , 107 fitzsimmons a. , dufton p.l . , rolleston w.r.j . , 1992 ,
mnras 259 , 489 fuhrmann k. , 1998 , a&a 338 , 161 garnett d.r .
, shields g.a .
skillman e.d .
, sagan s.p . ,
dufour r.j . , 1997 ,
apj 489 , 63 gies d.r . ,
lambert d.l . , 1992 , apj 387 , 673 grevesse n. , noels a. , 1993 in origin and evolution of the elements , ed . n. prantzos , e. vangioni - flam , & m. casse ( cambridge : cambridge univ . press ) , 14 gummersbach c.a .
, kaufer a. , shfer d.r .
, szeifert t. , wolf b. , 1998 , a&a 338 , 881 henry r. b. c. , howard j. w. , 1995 , apj 438 , 170 heger a. , langer n. , 2000 , apj in press , ( astro - ph/0005110 ) .
house f. , kilkenny d. , 1980 , a&a 81 , 251 howarth i.d .
, murray j. , mills d. , berry d.s .
, 1998 starlink user notice , no.50.21 israelian g. , garcia lopez r.j . , rebolo r. , 1998 , apj 507 , 805 jeffery c.s . , 1991 , in : newsletter on analysis of astronomical spectra no .
16 , pg .
17 kennicutt r.c .
, garnett d.r . , 1996 ,
apj 456 , 504 kerr f.j . , lynden - bell d. , 1986 , mnras 221 , 1023 kilian j. , 1994 , a&a 282 , 867 kilkenny d. , balona l.a .
, carter d.b . ,
ellis d.t . ,
woodhouse g.f.w . , 1998 ,
mnassa 47 , 69 kurucz r.l . , 1979 ,
apjs 40 , 1 kurucz r.l . , 1991 , in precision photometry : astrophysics of the galaxy , ed .
davis - philip , a.r .
upgren , & p.l .
janes ( schenectady : davis ) leonard p. j. t. , 1993 , in luminous high - latitude stars , ed .
d. sasselov ( san francisco : asp ) lester j.b .
, gray r.o .
, kurucz r.l . , 1986 ,
apjs 61 , 509 maciel w. j. , quireza 1999 , a&a 345 , 629 maciel w.j . , kppen j. , 1994 , a&a 282 , 43 maeder a. , 1992 , a&a 264 , 105 maeder a. , & meynet g. , 2000 , astro - ph/0006405 martin p. , roy j .-
, 1992 , apj 397 , 63 massey p. , 1992
, a user s guide to ccd reductions with iraf , noao laboratory matteucci f. , francois p. , 1989
, mnras 239 , 885 matteucci f. & chiappini c. , 1999 , in proc .
eso conf . on chemical evolution from zero to high
redshift , springer conference series , eds .
j. walsh & m. rosa meyer d. m. , jura m. , cardelli j. a. , 1998 , apj 493 , 222 monteverde i. , herrero a.h . , lennon d.j . , 2000 , apj , submitted mooney c.j . ,
rolleston w.r.j .
, keenan f.p .
, et al . 2000 , a&a 357 , 553 najarro f. , krabbe a. , genzel r. , et al .
1997 , a&a 325 , 700 napiwotzki r. , schonberner d. , wenske v. , 1993 , a&a 268 , 653 ortiz r. , lpine j.r.d . , 1993 , a&a 279 , 90 paczynski b. , stanek k.z .
, udalski a. , et al .
1994 , aj 107 , 2060 pagel b.e.j . , tautvaiin g. , 1995 , mnras 276 , 505 peters g.j . , 1976 ,
apjs 30 , 551 pilyugin l.s . , edmunds m.g .
, 1996 a&a 313 , 792 portinari l. , chiosi c. , 1999 , a&a 350 , 827 portinari l. , chiosi c. , 2000 , a&a 355 , 929 prantzos n. , vangioni - flam e. , chauveau s. , 1994 , a&a 285 , 132 prantzos n. , aubert o. , 1995 , a&a 302 , 69 reed b.c . , beatty a.e . , 1995 , apjs 97 , 189 reed b.c . , 1993 ,
apjs , 87 , 367 rolleston w.r.j . ,
smartt s.j . ,
dufton p.l .
, ryans r.s.i . , 2000 ,
a&a , in press rolleston w.r.j . ,
hambly n.c . , keenan f.p . ,
dufton p.l . ,
saffer r.a . , 1999 ,
a&a 347 , 69 rolleston w.r.j . , hambly n.h , dufton p.l . , et al . 1997 , mnras 290 , 422 rolleston w.r.j . ,
brown p.j.f .
, dufton p.l . ,
howarth i.d . , 1996 , a&a 315 , 95 ryans r.s.i , hambly n.c . , dufton p.l . ,
keenan f.p .
, 1996 , mnras 278 , 132 rudolph a.l . ,
simpson j.p . , haas m.r . , erickson e.f . ,
fich m. , 1997 , apj 489 , 94 seaton m.j .
, 1979 , mnras 187 , 73 serabyn e. , shupe d. , figer d. , 1998 , nature 394 , 448 schaller g. , schaerer d. , meynet g. , maeder a. , 1992 , a&as 96 , 269 shaver p.a . , mcgee r.x . ,
newton m.p . , danks a.c . ,
pottasch s.r . , 1983 , mnras 204 , 53 shortridge k. , meyerdierks h. , currie m. , clayton m. , lockley j. , 1997 , starlink user note 86.14 simpson j. p. , colgan s. w. j. , rubin r. h. , erickson e. f. , haas m. r. , 1995 , apj 444 , 721 smartt s.j . , rolleston w.r.j . , 1997 , apj 481 , l47 smartt s.j . ,
dufton p.l .
, lennon d.j . , 1997 ,
a&a 326 , 763 smartt s.j . ,
dufton p.l .
, rolleston w.r.j .
1996 , a&a 305 , 164 smartt s.j . , 2000 , in the chemical evolution of the milky way : stars vs. clusters , rome - trieste workshop , es f. matteucci , f. giovanelli smartt s.j . ,
crowther p.a . ,
dufton p.l . , et al . ,
2000 mnras , to be submitted snow t.p . , witt a.n . , 1996 ,
apj 468 , l65 stephenson c.b .
, sanduleak n. , 1971 , publ .
warner & swasey obs .
, 1 , 1 venn k.a , smartt s.j .
, lennon d.j .
, dufton p.l . , 1998 , a&a 334 , 987 vlchez j. m. , esteban c. , 1996 , mnras 280 , 720 vila - costas m. b. , edmunds m. g. , 1993 , mnras 265 , 199 rcccc species and line & ls5130 & ls4419 & ls4784 & @xmath48peg + oii 3911.96 & 57a & 96c & 76b & 50a + + cii 3918.98 & 138a & 130a & 261a@xmath65 & + nii 3919.01 & & & & + oii 3919.28 & & & & + + cii 3920.69 & 127a & 113a & & + + oii 3945.04 & 30b & 63b & 58c & + + oii 3954.37 & 51a & 63b & 74b & 48a + + hei 3964.73 & 177a & 187a & 188a & 155a + + oii 3982.72 & 29c & 72b@xmath66 & 60a@xmath66 & 31a + + siii 3983.77 & 28c & & & 14a + + nii 3995.00 & 102a & 104a & 93a & 78a + + nii 4035.08 & 35b & 46a & 42c & 25a + + nii 4041.31 & 44b & 51a & 60b & 37a + + oii 4069.62 & 95a & 115a & 97b & 94 + oii 4069.89 & & & & + + oii 4072.16 & 62a & 75a & 43c & 65a + + cii 4074.48 & 48b & 147a@xmath67 & 141b@xmath67 & 42a + cii 4074.85 & & & & + + cii 4075.85 & & & & + oii 4075.86 & 124a & & & + cii 4076.53 & & & & + nii 4076.91 & & & & + + oii 4078.84 & 24c & 19c & & 26a + + oii 4085.11 & 32c & 39b & 34b & 26a + + oii 4087.15 & 22c & & & 12a + + siiv 4088.85 & 37c & 44b & 61a & + oii 4089.28 & & & & + + siiv 4116.10 & 20c & & &
+ + oii 4119.22 & 62a & & & + + oii 4120.28 & 291a & & & + hei 4120.81 & & & & + hei 4120.99 & & & & + oii 4121.46 & & & & + + siii 4128.07 & 53a & 38c & 65b & 33a + + siii 4130.89 & 54a & 86c@xmath68 & 70c@xmath68 & 34a + + arii 4131.71 & 38b & & & 17a + + oii 4132.80 & 33b & & 54c@xmath68 & 30a + + aliii 4149.50 &
& 56b & 64a & + aliii 4150.14 & & & & + + sii 4153.10 & 60a & 125b & 105a & + oii 4153.30 & & & & + + sii 4162.70 & 47b & & & + + feiii 4164.79 & 45c & 32b & & + + feiii 4166.86 & 26c & & & 13a + + hei 4168.97 & 99a & 99a & 104a & + oii 4169.22 & & & & + + sii 4174.24 & 40b & 28c & & + + nii 4179.67 & 14c & 21c & & + + oii 4185.45 & 36b & 43b & & 30a + + oii 4189.79 & 46b & 54b & 65b & + + piii 4222.15 & 21c & 20c & & 21a + + nii 4227.74 & 30b & 55b & 61b & 18a + + nii 4236.86 & 51a & 55a & 66c & 28a + nii 4236.98 & & & & + + nii 4241.78 & 49a & 86a & 105b & + + rcccc species and line & ls5130 & ls4419 & ls4784 & @xmath48peg + siii 4253.59 & & 118a & & + oii 4253.90 & & & & + oii 4254.13 & & & & + + cii 4267.02 & 262a & 245a & 305a & + cii 4267.27 & & & & + oii 4267.71 & & & & + + oii 4275.56 &
& 97b & 123a@xmath69 &
+ + oii 4277.40 & & 72b & & 16a + + siii 4284.99 & & & 47c & 28a + + sii 4294.43 & 35b & 50b & 37c & + oii 4294.79 & & & & + + oii 4303.84 & 30c & 62a & 54c & 26a + + cii 4313.30 & 17c & & & + +
oii 4317.14 & 58a & 76a & 64b & 56a + cii 4317.26 & & & & + + oii 4319.63 & 48a & 78a & 63b & 52a + + oii 4325.76 & 40b & 23b & 29c & 20a + + oii 4345.56 & 30c & & & 24a + + oii 4347.42 & 26c & & & 21a + + arii 4348.11 & 32c & & & + + oii 4349.43 & 66b & & & 63a + + oii 4351.26 & 31c & & & 41a + + oii 4366.89 & 60a & 61a & 32c & 48a + + oii 4369.27 & & & & 14a + + cii 4372.49 & 52a & 91a & 67c@xmath70 & + + cii 4374.27 & 32b & & & + + rcccc species and line & ls5130 & ls4419 & ls4784 & @xmath48peg + feiii 4395.78 & 40b & 60a & 58b & + oii 4395.94 & & & & + + cii 4411.20 & 38b & 63b & & + cii 4411.52 & & & & + + oii 4414.90 & 84a & 95a & 52c & 75a + + oii 4416.97 & 64a & 76a & 28c & 61a + + feiii 4419.59 & 44b & 32c & 35c & 34a + + feiii 4430.95 & 33c & & 39c & 24a + + nii 4432.74 & 38c & & 51c & 20a + + hei 4437.55 & 126a & 103a & 135a & 118a + + nii 4442.02 & & & 38c & 9a + + nii 4447.03 & 60a & & 72b & 15a + oii 4448.19 & & & & + + oii 4452.37 & 31c & & 29c & 25a + + aliii 4479.89 & 55a & & & 38a + aliii 4479.89 & & & & + + mgii 4481.13 & 202a & 196a & 265a & 160a + mgii 4481.33 & & & & + + aliii 4512.54 & 57a & 65a & 63a & 39a + + aliii 4528.91 & 73a & 144a@xmath71 & 135a@xmath71 & 66a + aliii 4529.20 & & & & + + nii 4530.40 & 29c & & & 25a + + nii 4552.53 & 174a & 199a & 187a & 114a + siiii 4552.62 & & & & + + siiii 4567.82 & 150a & 152a & 151a & 102a + + siiii 4574.76 & 81a & 97a & 90a & 69a + + oii 4590.97 & 52a & 87a & 67a & + + oii 4596.18 & 59a & 74a & 52a & 47a + + nii 4601.48 & 62b & 107a & 90a & 37a + oii 4602.13 & & & & 15a + + rcccc species and line & ls5130 & ls4419 & ls4784 & @xmath48peg + nii 4607.16 & 56a & 64a & 68a & 35a + + oii 4609.44 & 41b & 63a & 50a & 30a + + nii 4613.87 & 55a & 79a & 56a & 27a + + cii 4618.40 & 137c & 82a & 213a@xmath72 & + cii 4619.23 & & & & + + nii 4621.29 & 41b & 73a & & 26a + + nii 4630.54 & 92a & 122a & 123a & + + oii 4638.86 & 61b & 81a & 71a & 54a + + oii 4641.82 & 74b & 171a@xmath73 & 172a@xmath73 & 76a + + nii 4643.09 & 58b & & & 42a + + ciii 4647.42 & & 230a @xmath74 & 192a@xmath74 & + + oii 4649.14 & 90a & & & 92a + + oii 4650.84 & 64b & & & 52a + + oii 4661.63 & 67a & 94a & 75a & 54a + + oii 4673.74 & 26c & & & 19a + + oii 4676.24 & 44c & 45c & & 46a + + nii 4678.10 & 24c & & & + + nii 4694.70 & 15c & & & 9a + + oii 4696.35 & 15c & & & 12a + + oii 4699.00 & 42a & 69c & 37a & + oii 4699.22 & & & & + oii 4703.16 & & 66a@xmath74 & 53a@xmath74 &
+ + oii 4705.35 & 47b & & & + + oii 4710.01 & 30b & 40c & & 20a + + hei 4713.14 & 289a & 283a & 250a & 271a + hei 4713.37 & & & & + + rcccc species and line & ls5130 & ls4419 & ls4784 & @xmath48peg + siiii 4716.65 & 41b & 52b & & 12a + + nii 4779.67 & 18c & 36c & 44b & 10a + + cii 4802.70 & 28c & & & 15a + + nii 4803.29 & 37c & 61a & 74a & 18a + + arii 4806.07 & 29c & 21c & & 18a + + siiii 4813.30 & 31b & 41a & 75b@xmath75 & 21a + + sii 4815.52 & 54b & 27b & & 27a + + siiii 4819.72 & 55b & 55a & 50a & 40a + + sii 4824.07 & 12c & & 18c &
+ + siiii 4828.96 & 44b & 64a & 59a & + + arii 4879.14 & 28b & & 19c & + + oii 4890.93 & 21c & 22b & & 11a + + oii 4906.83 & 38b & & 29b & + + oii 4941.07 & 25b & 38b & 14c & 15a + + oii 4943.00 & 39b & 52b & 45c & 28a + + sii 4991.94 & 16c & & 24c & 22a + + nii 4994.36 & 31b & 55a & 59b &
+ + sii 5009.62 & 32b & & & + + nii 5010.62 & 40b & 40c & & + + sii 5014.03 & 52b & & & + + hei 5015.68 & 322a & 319a & 354a & + + sii 5032.41 & 66b & 56a & 91a & + + siii 5041.03 & 24c & & 30c & 15a + + rcccc species and line & ls5130 & ls4419 & ls4784 & @xmath48peg + nii 5045.09 & 54b & 59a & 47c & + + hei 5047.74 & 207a & 163a & 179b & + + siii 5055.98 & 35c & & 56b & 22a + siii 5056.31 & & & & + + sii 5103.30 & & & 20c & + + cii 5132.96 & 97a & 74a & 99a & + cii 5133.29 & & & & + + oii 5159.94 & 23a & 38a & 37a & + notes : + 1 .
blend of oii 3982.72 and siii 3983.77 .
+ 2 . includes the oii , nii and cii lines at 40754076aa .
+ 3 . blended with arii 4131.71 .
+ 4 . blended with nii 4643.09 .
blended with oii 4649.14 & 4650.84 .
+ 6 . blended with oii 4705.35 .
+ 7 . also includes cii 3920.69 .
blended with oii 4277.40 .
+ 9 . blended with cii 4374.27 .
blended with nii 4530.40 .
+ 11 . blended with nii 4621.29 .
+ 12 . blended with sii 4815.52 .
+ rcc species and line & ls5127 & @xmath49her + oii 3911.96 & 50c & 12a + + cii 3918.98 & 340b & 72a + nii 3919.01 & & + oii 3919.28 & & 8a + cii 3920.69 & & 88a + + oii 3954.37 & 44c & 20a + + hei 3964.73 & 210c & 132a + + nii 3995.00 & 108a & 40a + + nii 4041.31 & 57b & 19a + + nii 4043.53 & 59b & 9a + + oii 4069.62 & 182a & 16a + oii 4069.89 & & 19a + oii
4072.16 & & 27a + + cii 4074.48 & 185a & 15a + cii 4074.85 & & 9a + oii 4075.86 & & 32a + cii 4076.53 & & + nii 4076.91 & & + + oii 4119.22 & 324a & + oii 4120.28 & & + hei 4120.81 & & + hei 4120.99 & & + oii 4121.46 & & + feiii 4122.06 & & + feiii 4122.98 & & +
+ hei 4168.97 & 70b & 81a + + nii 4241.78 & 67a & 16a + + siii 4253.59 & 69a & 13a + oii 4253.90 & & 4a + oii 4254.13 & & 2a + + cii 4267.02 & 338a & 184a + cii 4267.27 + oii 4267.71 & & + siiii 4267.80 & & 26a + rcc species and line & ls5127 & @xmath49her + sii 4294.43 & 43a & 24a + oii 4294.79 & & 3a + + oii 4303.84 & 39a & 9a + + oii 4325.76 & 55c & 6a + cii 4325.83 & & + cii 4326.16 & & + + siii 4361.53 & 39c & 4a + + oii 4366.89 & 42c & 16a + + cii 4372.49 & 48c & + + feiii 4395.78 & 43b & 15a + + oii 4414.90 & 101b & 28a + oii 4416.97 & & 23a + + feiii 4419.59 & 53a & 23a + + hei 4437.55 & 101a & 102a + + nii 4447.03 & 65b & 18a + + sii 4463.58 & 36b & 14a + + mgii 4481.13 & 423a & 205a + mgii 4481.33 & & + + aliii 4512.54 & 60a & 20a + + sii 4524.95 & 47b & 22a + + aliii 4528.91 & 100b & 6a + aliii 4529.20 & & 28a + nii
4530.40 & & 7a + + rcc species and line & ls5127 & @xmath49her + feii 4549.47 & 49b & + + sii 4552.38 & 191a & 71a + siiii 4552.62 & & + + siiii 4567.82 & 156a & 59a + + siiii 4574.76 & 93a & 27a + + feii 4583.83 & 39b & 12a + + oii 4590.97 & 39c & 17a + + oii 4596.18 & 32c & 12a + + nii 4601.48 & 49c & 15a + + nii 4607.16 & 47c & 14a + + cii 4618.40 & 114c & + cii 4619.23 & & + nii 4621.29 & & + siii 4621.42 & & + siii 4621.72 & & + + feii 4629.34 & 107a & + nii 4630.54 & & + + oii 4638.86 & 43a & 21a + + oii 4641.82 & 108a & 24a + nii 4643.09 & & 17a + + sii 4648.17 & 170a & 5a + oii 4649.14 & & 34a + oii 4650.84 & & 17a + + sii 4656.74 & 26b & 10a + + oii 4661.63 & 65b & 15a + aliii 4663.05 & & 13a + + hei 4713.14 & 306a & 239a + hei 4713.37 & & + + siiii 4813.30 & 81b & 8a + sii 4815.52 & & 40a + + siiii 4819.72 & 47c &
+ + sii 5014.03 & 522a & 38a + hei 5015.68 & & 233a + + sii 5032.41 & 128a & 47a + + siii 5041.03 & 85a & 42a + + nii 5045.09 & 190a & + sii 5047.28 & & + hei 5047.74 & & + + siii 5055.98 & 182a & 82a + siii 5056.31 & & + + | high - resolution , high signal - to - noise spectral data are presented for four young b - type stars lying towards the galactic centre .
determination of their atmospheric parameters from their absorption line profiles , and @xmath0 photometric measurement of the continua indicate that they are massive objects lying slightly out of the plane , and were probably born in the disk between 2.5@xmath15kpc from the centre .
we have carried out a detailed absolute and differential line - by - line abundance analyses of the four stars compared to two stars with very similar atmospheric parameters in the solar neighbourhood .
the stars appear to be rich in all the well sampled chemical elements ( c , n , si , mg , s , al ) , _ except for oxygen_. oxygen abundances derived in the atmospheres of these four stars are very similar to that in the solar neighbourhood . if the photospheric composition of these young stars is reflective of the gaseous ism in the inner galaxy , then the values derived for the enhanced metals are in excellent agreement with the extrapolation of the galactic abundance gradients previously derived by rolleston et al .
( 2000 ) and others .
however , the data for oxygen suggests that the inner galaxy may not be richer than normal in this element , and the physical reasons for such a scenario are unclear . |
nova cephei 2014 was discovered as a transient by nishiyama and kabashima ( 2014 ) at a magnitude of 11.7 on unfiltered ccd frames ( limiting magnitude 13.7 ) taken around 2014 march 8.792 ut .
the object was confirmed to be a classical nova by munari et al .
( 2014 ) who obtained a low - resolution spectrogram ( range 395 - 852 nm , 0.21 nm / pixel ) on 2014 march 9.792 ut .
the spectrum showed a red continuum with strong emission lines from the balmer series , o i 777.4 and 844.6 nm , ca ii 849.8 nm , and fe ii multiplets 42 , 48 , and 49 .
all emission lines showed strong p - cyg absorptions which were blue - shifted by 660 km s@xmath4 for the balmer lines , 780 km s@xmath4 for the fe ii lines , and 900 km s@xmath4 for the o i lines .
the emission lines had a width of about 800 km s@xmath4 .
the intensity of the o i 844.6 nm emission line was seen to be about twice that of o i 777.4 nm , indicating that there was fluorescent pumping from hydrogen lyman@xmath5 photons .
photometry on 2014 march 10.094 ut showed a large value of the color b - v = + 1.27 which indicated significant reddening consistent with the red slope of the continuum observed in the spectrum .
the object s spectrum showed it to be a highly reddened fe ii class nova observed close to maximum brightness .
no detailed study of this nova , in any wavelength regime , has been presented till date .
nova sco 2015 was discovered as a bright transient on 2015 february 11.8367 ut at an unfiltered ccd magnitude of 8.2 by tadashi kojima using a 150-mm f/2.8 lens @xmath6 a digital camera ( nakano 2015 ) .
nothing was visible on a frame from the same camera on feb .
10.827 ut .
( vsnet - alert 18276 : ; aavso special notice no . 397 ) .
the object was designated pnv j17032620 - 3504140 on the cbat transient object confirmation page ( tocp ) . an echelle spectrum on 2015 february 13 at 09:38ut ( walter 2015 ) confirmed that the object was a nova .
h@xmath0 had an equivalent width of -14 nm and full width at half maximum ( fhwm ) @xmath72000 km s@xmath4 .
there were symmetrically displaced emission features at about @xmath8 4500 kms@xmath4 which resembled those seen in fast he / n novae . h@xmath0 and h@xmath5 showed p cyg absorption features at about -4200,-3200 , and -2300 km s@xmath4
o i 777 nm and 845 nm were in emission . a strong emission line at 588 nm with a prominent p cyg absorption was either he i 587 nm or modestly blue shifted na i. broad ( 2000 km s@xmath4 fwzi ) he i 706 nm emission was possibly also present .
similarly broad emission was seen in the prominent fe ii multiplet 42 lines at 492 , 502 , and 517 nm , though the first two may have had some he i contribution .
the apparently rapid fading and bright possible near - ir counterpart suggested this was a system with an m giant donor ( walter 2015 ) , like v745 sco or nova sco 2014 . and
@xmath9 light curves of nova cep 2014 and nova sco 2015 from aavso data in black and gray symbols respectively .
the outburst dates are taken as 2014 march 8.792 ut ( jd 2456725.2920 ) and 2015 february 11.8367 ut ( jd 2457065.3333 ) respectively.,width=336,height=432 ] .log of the photometry@xmath10 from mount abu ir telescope [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] [ table_obsspec ] a , b : the spectroscopic observation of nova sco 2015 on 2015 march 23.63 ut was made from the irtf telescope .
the rest of the spectra were obtained from mt .
abu .
early x - ray and radio observations of nova sco 2015 by nelson et al ( 2015 ) implicated strong shocks against a red giant wind .
their observations of nova sco 2015 were carried out at x - ray , uv and radio wavelengths .
the x - ray observations were carried out with the swift satellite between 2015 february 15.5 and 16.3 ut ( about 4 days after discovery ) .
an x - ray source was clearly detected at the position of the nova .
the spectrum was hard and could be modeled as a highly absorbed , hot thermal plasma ( n(h ) @xmath7 6@xmath81 x 10@xmath11 @xmath12 ; kt greater than 41 kev ) .
however , a significant excess of counts over the model prediction was observed between 1 and 2 kev , possibly indicating the presence of a second , softer emission component .
nelson et al .
( 2015 ) also observed nova sco 2015 at radio wavelengths with the karl g. jansky very large array ( vla ) on 2015 february 14.5 , approximately 3 days after optical discovery .
the nova was detected at frequencies from 4.55 to 36.5 ghz with a spectrum typical of non - thermal synchrotron emission ( spectral index between -0.7 and -0.9 ) .
the presence of hard , absorbed x - rays and synchrotron radio emission at this early stage of the outburst suggested that the nova - producing white dwarf was embedded within the wind of a red - giant companion , with collisions between the ejecta and this wind shock - heating plasma and accelerating particles ( as in , e.g. rs oph , v407 cyg and v745 sco ( banerjee et al .
2009 , munari et al .
2011 , banerjee et al .
this interpretation is supported by our nir observations .
in this paper we present our nir spectroscopic and photometric observations of nova cep 2014 and of nova sco 2015 , preliminary reports of which were made in ashok et al .
( 2014 ) and srivastava et al.(2015 ) .
the observations of nova cep 2014 span 9 epochs covering 5 to 90 days after the outburst and the observations of nova sco 2015 span 11 epochs covering 7 to 47 days after the outburst .
we present the observations in section [ sec_observations ] .
the analysis and results for nova cep 2014 and nova sco 2015 are described in section [ sec_ncep_results ] and section [ sec_nsco_results ] respectively .
near - ir spectroscopy in the 0.85 to 2.4 @xmath13 m region at resolution @xmath14 @xmath7 1000 was carried out with the 1.2 m telescope of the mount abu infrared observatory using the near - infrared camera / spectrograph ( nics ) equipped with a 1024x1024 hgcdte hawaii array .
spectra were recorded with the star dithered to two positions along the slit with one or more spectra being recorded in both of these positions .
the co - added spectra in the respective dithered positions were subtracted from each other to remove sky and dark contributions .
the spectra from these sky - subtracted images were extracted using iraf tasks and wavelength calibrated using a combination of oh sky lines and telluric lines that register with the stellar spectra . to remove telluric lines from the target s spectra , it was ratioed with the spectra of a standard star ( sao 18998 spectral type a2iv in case of nova cep 2015 and sao 206599 , spectral type a0/a1v in the case of nova sco 2015 ) from whose spectra the hydrogen paschen and brackett absorption lines had been removed .
the spectra were finally multiplied by a blackbody at the effective temperature of the standard star to yield the resultant spectra .
all spectra were covered in three settings of the grating that cover the @xmath15 and @xmath16 regions separately .
a spectrum of nova sco 2015 was obtained using the 3 m irtf telescope on 2015 march 23.625ut covering the 0.8 to 2.5 @xmath13 m region .
this spectrum was obtained using spex ( rayner et al .
2003 ) in the cross - dispersed mode using the @xmath17 slit ( @xmath18 ) and a total integration time of 360s .
the spex data were reduced and calibrated using the spextool software ( cushing et al .
2004 ) , and corrections for telluric absorption were performed using the idl tool xtellcor ( vacca et al .
the log of the observations are given in tables [ table_obsphot ] and [ table_obsspec ] .
fig [ fig_lightcurves ] shows the @xmath19 and @xmath9 band light curves of the nova cep 2014 using data from american association of variable star observers ( aavso ) .
the nova showed a climb to maximum that lasted for 5 days before peaking at @xmath7 11.05 mag in @xmath19 on 2014 march 13.9198 ( jd2456730.4198 ) . from the light curve
we determine t@xmath20 and t@xmath21 - the time for the brightness to decline by 2 and 3 magnitudes respectively from maxima - to be 22@xmath8 2d and 42 @xmath8 1d thereby putting it in the fast speed class .
the observed @xmath22 values at maximum and at t@xmath20 equal 1.18 and 0.9 respectively in contrast to the expected values of 0.23 @xmath8 0.06 and -0.02 @xmath8 0.04 respectively at these epochs ( van den bergh & younger 1987 ) .
the large values of @xmath22 imply considerable reddening ; the excess @xmath23 values are equal to 0.95 and 0.92 respectively .
we adopt a mean value of 0.935 for the reddening and thus an extinction @xmath24 . for @xmath25 ,
the mmrd relation of della valle & livio ( 1995 ) gives m@xmath26 = -7.84 @xmath8 0.5 which implies a distance to the nova of 15.8 @xmath8 4 kpc .
similarly , the mmrd relations for t@xmath20 and t@xmath21 by downes & duerbeck ( 2000 ) yield similar m@xmath26 magnitudes of -7.90 @xmath8 0.66 and -7.87 @xmath8 0.92 respectively .
these translate to a mean distance estimate of 17.2 @xmath8 7 kpc . clearly , a large distance to the nova is suggested .
the possibility is unlikely that the distance estimate is being boosted up because of a low choice of extinction @xmath27 in the distance - modulus relation @xmath28 .
the extinction of 2.9 that we have used is close to the total galactic extinction of 2.995 mag in the direction of the nova as estimated by schlafly & finkbeiner ( 2011 ) from dust extinction maps .
our choice of a@xmath26 is also consistent with the extinction modeling of marshall et al ( 2006 ) who find that the extinction a@xmath26 rapidly rises , in the direction of the nova , to 3.36 @xmath8 0.33 by a distance of 1.23 kpc and remains at this value for larger distances .
the j , h and k band spectra for nova cep 2014 are shown in fig [ ncep14_spec_jhk ] .
these show that the outburst and evolution of nova cep 2014 was that of a conventional fe ii class nova .
the spectra of such novae , in the near - ir , are characterized by strong hi lines of the paschen and brackett series but what differentiates them from the he / n class is the presence of several strong ci lines seen around maximum and during the early decline ( banerjee & ashok , 2012 ) .
these ci lines are all prominently seen in the spectrum of nova cep 2014 ( examples being ci 1.0685 , 1.165 , 1.176 @xmath13 m and a strong blend of ci lines in the region 1.73 to 1.78 @xmath13 m ) .
the detailed identification of the lines is presented in fig [ fig_ncep_lineid ] and is discussed in the appendix and table [ table_linelist ] .
p - cygni absorption components are seen in many of the lines in the spectra taken during 2014 march .
the line profile widths do not vary much over time ; for e.g. the fwhm of the paschen @xmath5 1.2818 @xmath13 m line changes from @xmath71200 km@xmath29 to @xmath71500 km@xmath29 between the epochs 2014 march 14 ( 5.22d ) to 2014 april 7 ( 29.20d ) .
@xmath30 ( small dash - dotted lines ) , 10@xmath31 @xmath30 ( solid lines ) , 10@xmath32 @xmath30 ( big dash lines ) , 10@xmath33 @xmath30 ( small dash lines ) , 10@xmath34 @xmath30 ( dotted lines ) , and 10@xmath35 @xmath30 ( dash - dotted lines ) . ,
scaledwidth=50.0% ] we do not find any evidence of dust formation in this nova , as manifested by an ir excess , during the early decline stage . to check
whether dust formation may have occurred later , photometry was done recently ( 2015 april 28 , jd 2457140.5 ) .
however the nova was not detected in any of the j , h or k bands .
the limiting magnitudes of our observations in j , h and k band are @xmath715.0 .
this , taken in conjunction with the latest v magnitudes of 18.943 on 2015 april 6.87 ut ( jd 2457119.36553 ) from the aavso database , yields @xmath36 @xmath37 3.9 .
the small value of the @xmath36 color indicates that dust formation is very unlikely to have occurred .
a recombination case b analysis was done , but only for selected dates of 2014 march 15.02 , april 05.00 and april 07.99 ( i.e. 6 , 27 and 30 days after the outburst ) when contemporaneous photometric observations were available for flux calibrating the spectra .
the measured line fluxes for the h i brackett lines are given in table [ table_lineluminosity_ncep2014 ] and fig [ ncep14_recombanalysis ] shows the brackett line strengths with respect to br 12 set to unity .
we find that the line fluxes do not match predicted case b recombination values . in particular , it is seen from fig [ ncep14_recombanalysis ] that the br7 ( br@xmath38 ) line strength is significantly lower than the predicted values of storey & hummer ( 1995 ) . though expected to be stronger than the other br series of lines , it is found to be significantly weaker than for e.g br10 and br11 .
such behavior is expected in the early phase of outbursts signifying that br@xmath38 is optically thick and so possibly are the other br lines .
such optical depth effects in the brackett lines are also seen in several other novae systems e.g. nova oph 1998 ( lynch et al . 2000 ) , v2491 cyg and v597 pup ( naik at al . 2009 ) , rs oph ( banerjee et al . 2009 ) and t pyx ( joshi et al . 2014 ) .
lccc + emission line & & integrated line flux & + and wavelength & & at days after outburst & + ( @xmath13 m ) & & ( @xmath39 watt/@xmath40 ) & + & 6.23d & 27.21d & 30.19d + br17 1.5439 & 35.0 & - & 7.44 + br16 1.5556 & 81.4 & 28.1 & 33.5 + br15 1.5701 & 50.1 & 9.04 & + br14 1.5881 & 72.5 & 27.9 & 19.0 + br13 1.6109 & - & 25.5 & 30.8 + br12 1.6407 & 92.8 & 46.0 & 41.5 + br11 1.6807 & 88.5 & 137.0 & 118.0 + br10 1.7362 & 94.1 & 147.0 & 158.0 + br7 2.1655 & 82.4 & 85.5 & 108.0 + [ table_lineluminosity_ncep2014 ]
although the lines are optically thick , we can estimate the emission measure @xmath2 of the ejecta following the opacity data given by hummer & storey ( 1987 ) and storey & hummer ( 1995 ) and using the fact that br@xmath38 line is found to be optically thick .
the optical depth at line - center @xmath41 is given by @xmath42 , where @xmath3 , @xmath43 , @xmath44 and @xmath45 are the electron number density , ion number density , path length and opacity corresponding to the transition from upper level @xmath46 to lower level @xmath47 , respectively .
further , the opacity factor @xmath45 does not vary significantly within the density or temperature range that is expected to prevail in the ejecta . for e.g. , from storey & hummer 1995 , the opacity @xmath45 for br@xmath38 line for the temperature @xmath48 k , and number densities @xmath49 to @xmath50 @xmath51 vary only between 1.3 @xmath52 10@xmath53 to 7.46 @xmath52 10@xmath53 .
we will assume that the densities in the early stage of the nova outburst are high and lie in the in the above range of @xmath49 to @xmath50 @xmath51 .
as @xmath54 the emission measure @xmath2 for above values is estimated to be in the range of @xmath55 to @xmath56 @xmath57 .
we constrain the electron density by taking @xmath44 as the kinematical distance @xmath58 traveled by the ejecta where @xmath59 is the velocity of ejecta and @xmath60 is the time after outburst .
we consider a typical ejecta velocity of @xmath59 @xmath7 1000 kms@xmath4 as measured from half the fwzi of the pa@xmath5 1.2818 @xmath13 m line and @xmath60 to range from 6 to 30 days . with the constraints that @xmath61 , the lower limit on electron density @xmath3 is found to be in the range @xmath62 @xmath51 to @xmath63 @xmath51 ( assuming @xmath64 ) .
it should be noted that these derived lower limits are likely to be smaller than the actual @xmath3 values because @xmath65 ( br@xmath38 ) can be considerably @xmath66 .
the density in the nova ejecta remains significantly high over the entire duration of our observations .
lynch et al .
( 2000 ) showed that high densities of @xmath67 @xmath51 or more tend to thermalize the level populations through collisions and thereby bring about deviations from case b predictions .
the same has been observed here in hi lines .
the gas mass of the ejecta may be estimated by @xmath68 = @xmath69@xmath19@xmath3@xmath70 where @xmath19 is the volume ( = 4/3@xmath71@xmath72 ) , @xmath69 is the volume filling factor and @xmath70 is the proton mass .
for @xmath44 varying between the distance traversed in 6d to 30d and the corresponding lower limits on @xmath3 as estimated above , the mass @xmath68 varies between ( @xmath73 @xmath74)@xmath69 m@xmath75 .
this is a wide range and the mass is poorly constrained but nevertheless the mass range is consistent with the typical ejecta masses estimated in novae of @xmath76 to @xmath77 m@xmath75 .
the v and b band light curves are shown in the lower panel of fig [ fig_lightcurves ] using the data from aavso .
the nova showed a monotonic decline and we determine t@xmath20 and t@xmath21 values of 14@xmath82 d and 19@xmath81 d which puts the nova sco 2015 in the fast speed class similar to nova cep 2014 discussed earlier in subsection [ subsec_ncep_lightcurve ] . the observed ( b - v ) value near the optical maximum and t@xmath20 are 0.87 and 0.79 respectively .
comparing these values with the expected values of 0.23 @xmath8 0.06 and -0.02 @xmath8 0.04 respectively at these epochs from van den bergh & younger ( 1987 ) , we get an average value of 0.72 for the color excess e(b - v ) and interstellar extinction @xmath78 . by using the mmrd relation of della valle & livio ( 1995 ) we get @xmath79 for @xmath80 d which implies a distance of @xmath81 kpc for @xmath78 . similarly by using the mmrd relations for t@xmath20 and t@xmath21 of downes & duerbeck ( 2000 ) we get m@xmath26 values of @xmath82 and @xmath83 and these translate to a mean distance of @xmath84 kpc , which is adopted as the distance to nova sco 2015 . the extinction value of @xmath78 used in these calculations is slightly larger than the total galactic extinction of 1.99 in the direction of the nova as estimated by schlafly & finkneiner ( 2011 ) from the dust extinction maps .
the near - infrared spectra of nova sco 2015 at different epochs are shown in fig [ nsco15_spec_jhk ] and fig [ fig_nsco_irtf ] .
the prominent spectral features in these spectra are the brackett and paschen recombination lines of h i and he i lines at 1.0831 , 1.7002 and 2.0581 @xmath13 m , with the 1.0831 @xmath13 m line being overwhelmingly strong .
the n i blend at 1.2461 and 1.2469 @xmath13 m and the lyman @xmath5 fluoresced o i lines at 0.8446 & 1.1287 @xmath13 m are also present .
these spectra are typical of of the he / n class of nova with strong lines of he i seen starting from the first set of observations on 7.16 d after the outburst .
the absence of c i lines all through the span of present observations is also consistent with the he / n class ( banerjee & ashok , 2012 ) .
the p cygni absorption features are clearly seen in the higher resolution irtf spectra obtained on 2015 march 23.625 ut .
another notable feature seen in the irtf spectra is the presence of blue emission components in the profiles of pa @xmath38 , pa @xmath5 and br @xmath38 hi emission lines .
the magnified sections of the selected lines from the irtf spectra are shown in figs [ fig_nsco_irtf ] and [ fig_nsco_irtf_magnified ] to highlight the p cygni features and the weak blue components .
a detailed list of emission lines observed in the spectra is given in the appendix and table [ table_linelist ] .
with the help of the present near - ir observations , we establish that the secondary component of nova sco 2015 is a late type cool giant star ( see section [ subsec_secondarynature ] ) . the evolution of the velocity profiles seen in the emission lines of nova sco 2015 spectra suggests and supports this possibility .
the t crb sub class of recurrent novae ( rne ) with a giant cool red companion typically show a significant decrease in the width of the emission line profiles with time after outburst ( banerjee et al .
this behavior is expected as the high velocity ejecta thrown out during the eruption moves through the wind of the companion and thereby undergoes a deceleration .
such a deceleration causes a fast temporal decrease of the expansion velocity resulting in the narrowing of the emission line widths .
this behavior has been well documented in the nir in the case of 4 other similar symbiotic systems viz .
in the 2006 outburst of rs oph ( das , banerjee & ashok 2006 ) , in v407 cyg ( munari et al . 2011 ) where the donor is a high mass losing mira variable , in the recurrent nova v745 sco ( banerjee et al .
2014 ) and in nova sco 2014 ( joshi et al . 2015 ) .
our near ir observations of nova sco 2015 show a similar behavior .
fig [ pabeta_timeevol ] shows the evolution of the pa@xmath5 1.2818 @xmath13 m line profile during our observations .
the narrowing of the line profile is clearly observed here .
fig [ fig_nsco_fwhmvstime ] shows the time evolution of the observed line widths ( fwhm ) of the pa@xmath5 1.2818 @xmath13 m line .
the intrinsic fwhm of the profiles have been obtained by deconvolving the observed profiles from instrumental broadening by assuming a gaussian profile for both the observed and instrumental profiles ( a reasonable assumption ) from which it follows that the fwhms will combine in quadrature ( @xmath85 + @xmath86 = @xmath87 ) .
the fwhm of the instrumental profile for 2015 february 19 to 2015 march 8 data from nics on mt .
abu telescope is measured to be 560 kms@xmath4 .
for the 2015 march 23 data from the irtf telescope , the same is measured to be 150 kms@xmath4 from an argon lamp arc spectrum which is equivalent to the resolution of 2000 cited for spex
. a power law fit to the evolving intrinsic line widths , of the form @xmath88 , is shown in fig [ fig_nsco_fwhmvstime ] which is seen to give a reasonable fit for a value of @xmath89 .
the impact of the high - velocity nova ejecta with the wind of the giant companion is known to produce a strong shock which can heat the gas to high temperatures .
this hot , shocked gas can be the site of hard x - rays ( sokolski et al . 2006 ; bode et al . 2006 ) and also @xmath38-ray production created by diffusive acceleration of particles across the shock to tev energies .
the accelerated protons can subsequently either inverse - comptonize ambient low - energy radiation to the @xmath38 ray regime or participate in production of neutral pions which decay with the emission of gamma rays . the early x - ray and radio observations of nova sco 2015 by nelson
et al ( 2015 ) implicate the presence of such a strong shock forming in the red giant wind .
bode & kahn ( 1985 ) , for e.g. , have discussed the propagation of such a shock wave into the dense ambient medium surrounding the white dwarf .
it may be described as a three stage process viz .
a free expansion or ejecta dominated stage where the ejecta expands freely into the red giant wind .
this phase lasts till the mass of the swept - up material from the donor wind is smaller than the mass of the the nova ejecta . a constant velocity of the shock is seen during this time . 2 .
an adiabatic phase or sedov - taylor stage where the majority of the ejecta kinetic energy has been transferred to the swept - up ambient gas and there is negligible cooling by radiation losses .
this phase is characterized by the temporal evolution of shock velocity @xmath59 as @xmath90 , assuming a @xmath91 dependence for the decrease in density of the wind .
3 . in phase 3 ,
the shocked material has cooled by radiation , and here the expected dependence of the shock velocity is @xmath92 . in the case of nova sco 2015 the free expansion stage ,
if it occurred in the first instance , is clearly missed .
this is possibly because our observations began late viz .
our earliest spectrum being recorded 7 days after the outburst .
the deceleration that accompanies phases 2 or 3 is seen but the decay is too fast and the index @xmath93 that we get deviates substantially from that expected in either phase 2 or 3 .
such deviations were also noticed in other recurrent novae as well e.g. rs oph ( das et al .
2006 ) , v745 sco ( banerjee et al . 2014 ) .
this likely happens due to the propagation of ejecta into a non - symmetrical wind . in such cases ,
the ejecta would be slowed down more effectively in the parts moving in the direction of the giant due to the increasing density in that direction .
in addition there could be anisotropic distribution of the material over the equatorial plane .
thus as a combination , the mass distribution of the ejecta around the white dwarf would be anisotropic and the shock front would then propagate as an aspherical one ( chomiuk et al .
2012 , fig 6 therein ) .
this nova possibly has a bipolar flow associated with it based on the description of the early optical spectrum by walter ( 2015 ) where , apart from the main central feature , symmetrically displaced emission features at about @xmath8 4500 kms@xmath4 were seen in the h@xmath0 profile .
such a profile structure is typical of a bipolar flow and has been seen in quite a few novae viz .
rs oph ( banerjee et al . 2009 ) , kt eri 2009 ( ribeiro et al , 2013 ; raj et al .
2013 ) , t pyx ( joshi et al .
( 2014 ) . from our own data ,
indication for an asymmetrical ejecta flow also comes from the velocity profiles of the pa@xmath38 @xmath94 m , pa@xmath5 @xmath95 m and br@xmath38 @xmath96 m lines shown in fig [ fig_nsco_velplot ] . here a weak blue component is seen in each of the profiles , separated from the principal profile , by -650 , -765 , -690 @xmath97 for pa@xmath38 , pa@xmath5 and the br @xmath38 lines respectively .
this could be the blue symmetrically displaced component found by walter ( 2015 ) which has undergone considerable deceleration from its original value of -4000 km / s down to the present value of @xmath7 -600 to -700 km / s .
the intensity of its counterpart red component could have dropped below detection limits . in short , indications are clearly present for deviations from spherical symmetry in the velocity kinematics seen in nova sco 2015 .
this could be one of the reasons for the deviation of the deceleration index @xmath0 from model values .
we have performed the recombination case b analysis following the same lines as done earlier for nova cep 2014 .
we analyze observed spectra spanning 6 epochs covering the first 33 d of our observations .
the measured line strengths from the flux calibrated spectra of n sco 2015 are given in table [ table_lineluminosity ] .
flux calibrations of the spectra are done using near ir photometric observations from smarts consortium .
fig [ nsco15_recombanalysis ] shows the observed relative line strengths for the brackett lines which have been normalized with respect to br12 set to unity .
br22 and br23 line values ( as given in table [ table_lineluminosity ] ) are not considered for this analysis as they are not resolved properly .
the predicted case b values are shown in fig [ nsco15_recombanalysis ] for a representative temperature 10000 k and for electron number densities of @xmath3 = 10@xmath98 , 10@xmath99 , 10@xmath100 , 10@xmath101,10@xmath102 and 10@xmath103 @xmath104 . as can be seen , in this nova also , the br@xmath38 line is weaker than expected implying it is optically thick .
thus , using the same formalism described for nova cep 2014 , the emission measure @xmath2 is estimated to be in the range of @xmath55 to @xmath56 @xmath57 , the corresponding lower limit of the electron density @xmath3 is in the range @xmath105 @xmath51 to @xmath106 @xmath51 and the mass @xmath68 is between ( @xmath107 @xmath108 ) @xmath69 m@xmath75 where @xmath69 is the filling factor .
the electron density and mass estimates are again reasonably consistent with expected values .
@xmath30 ( small dash - dotted lines ) , 10@xmath31 @xmath30 ( solid lines ) , 10@xmath32 @xmath30 ( big dash lines ) , 10@xmath33 @xmath30 ( small dash lines ) , 10@xmath34 @xmath30 ( dotted lines ) , and 10@xmath35 @xmath30 ( dash - dotted lines ) . ,
scaledwidth=50.0% ] lllclll + emission line & & & line flux on & & & + and wavelength & & & days after outburst & & & + ( @xmath13 m ) & & & ( @xmath39 w/@xmath40 ) & & & + + & 7.16d & 8.16d & 9.17d & 14.18d & 15.18d & 40.0d + + + pa9 0.9226 & 414.0 & 396.0 & 301.0 & 102.0 & 171.0 & 2.07 + pa8 0.9546 & 158.0 & 182.0 & 145.0 & 41.1 & 22.4 & 1.36 + pa7 1.0049@xmath10 & 349.0 & 427.0 & 391.0 & 84.8 & 71.2 & 1.44 + hei + pa6 @xmath109 & 2890.0 & 2970.0 & 2380.0 & 624.0 & 568.0 & 9.79@xmath110 + oi 1.1287 & 246.0 & 194.0 & 185.0 & 49.5 & 23.8 & 3.31 + pa5 1.2818 & 680.0 & 862.0 & 635.0 & 161.0 & 158.0 & 3.95 + br22 + br23 @xmath111 & - & & 9.87 & - & 1.65 & 0.37 + br21 1.5133 & 5.62 & - & 7.71 & 5.42 & 2.04 & 0.20 + br20 1.5192 & 5.83 & 6.11 & 4.83 & 2.73 & - & 0.22 + br19 1.5261 & 10.9 & 11.5 & 7.19 & 4.85 & 1.88 & 0.22 + br18 1.5342 & 17.9 & 15.6 & 12.1 & 5.85 & 3.69 & 0.26 + br17 1.5439 & 32.9 & 25.9 & 19.3 & 11.2 & 4.81 & 0.23 + br16 1.5556 & 41.8 & 39.3 & 28.0 & 7.59 & 4.07 & 0.26 + br15 1.5701 & 46.6 & 58.5 & 36.7 & 8.15 & 6.76 & 0.31 + br14 1.5881 & 77.0 & 62.9 & 43.6 & 8.00 & 10.2 & 0.30 + br13 1.6109 & 89.3 & 58.2 & 55.3 & 10.8 & 5.59 & 0.30 + br12 1.6407 & 109.0 & 79.1 & 76.3 & 9.94 & 9.01 & 0.33 + br11 1.6807 & 123.0 & 93.2 & 81.9 & 12.0 & 6.56 & 0.40 + hei 1.7002 & 54.5 & 31.3 & 31.0 & 4.70 & 3.92 & 0.19 + br10 1.7362 & 201.0 & 167.0 & 110.0 & 16.1 & 13.4 & 0.44 + hei 2.0581 & 79.7 & 71.2 & 56.8 & 7.10 & - & 0.19 + hei 2.112 & 20.3 & 17.5 & 13.2 & 1.62 & - & 0.08 + br7 2.1655 & 125.0 & 162.0 & 87.5 & 22.5 & 8.59 & 0.63 + [ table_lineluminosity ] a : blended with other lines b : hei 1.0831 is blended with hi pa6 1.0938 c : the integrated line flux of hei and pa6 d : integrated line flux of br22 and br 23 our near - ir observations along with the archival data from 2mass survey indicate that nova sco 2015 presents a strong case to belong to the class of symbiotic system consisting of a wd and and a late type giant companion .
as symbiotic systems are rare among novae , identification of a new object likely to belong to this group is of much significance .
the bright near ir counterpart of nova sco 2015 from the 2mass archival database ( 2mass j17032617 - 3504178 ) is likely to be a symbiotic system based on its 2mass magnitudes of @xmath112 , @xmath113 & @xmath114 .
these magnitudes are transformed to bessel & brett ( 1988 ) homogenized system using transformation equations given by carpenter ( 2001 ) and corrected for interstellar extinction using the relations given by rieke & lebofsky ( 1985 ) .
the ir color indices are thus obtained as @xmath115 , and @xmath116 .
these colors are consistent with the values of 0.68 and 0.14 expected for k3 iii / k4 iii respectively ( bessel & brett 1988 ) .
on the other hand the sed in quiescence suggests a slightly different class for the secondary . for constructing the sed
, the wavelength coverage was extended on the either size of the 2mass coverage by using wise w1 and w2 bands data and denis i band data .
it may be noted that the denis magnitudes of @xmath117 = 13.45 @xmath8 0.07 and @xmath118 = 12.20 @xmath8 0.10 are in good agreement with the corresponding 2mass values of 13.40 @xmath8 0.03 and 12.22 @xmath8 0.03 respectively .
the wise w3 and w4 magnitudes were not used for the sed because the star is not seen as a point source in the wise images in these bands , only the background diffuse ir cirrus is being picked up .
the extremely low snr ( between 3 to 6 ) and the poor quality flags of the w3 and w4 data show that they should not be used .
all magnitudes were corrected for interstellar extinction using a@xmath119 = 2.23 .
the sed shown in fig [ nsco2015_sed ] , using i(0.79 @xmath13 m ) = 15.25 @xmath8 0.04 , w1(3.3 @xmath13 m ) = 11.24 @xmath8 0.03 and w2(4.6@xmath13 m ) = 11.46 @xmath8 0.03 , is well fit by a black body of temperature @xmath120 k , suggesting a spectral class of m4 - 5 iii . considering the spectral class of k3 iii / k4 iii suggested earlier from the near - infrared @xmath121 colors it appears that the determination of the spectral type of the companion is uncertain to few sub - classes @xmath122 at best we can say that range of the likely spectral class is either k or m. to have a more definitive classification , the spectral lines of the secondary must be recorded in a good snr spectrum in quiescence .
further support for the secondary to be in the giant class comes from its absolute magnitude estimation . assuming that the quiescent k band brightness is dominated by the secondary ( i.e m@xmath123 of the secondary = 12.22 from 2mass ) and using the mmrd distance estimate to the nova of @xmath7 14.7 kpc , the k band absolute magnitude of the secondary , is calculated as @xmath124 . whereas using the intricsic color @xmath125 ( bessell & brett 1988 ) and absolute magnitude @xmath126 ( lang 1990 ) for k5 iii spectral class , the corresponding @xmath127 is determined as @xmath128 . as the two are in good agreement , it further strengthens the classification of the secondary as a red giant . on the other hand ,
the possibility of the companion being a dwarf instead of a giant can be ruled out from the following consideration . for a mid - k to mid - m spectral class dwarf as suggested by our previous analyses , the k absolute magnitudes is in the range of @xmath129 respectively ( pecaut & mamajek 2013 ; see online version of table 5 therein ) .
using the distance modulus relation , the corresponding distance range comes out to be @xmath130 pc .
this is severely in disagreement with the distance estimated earlier using mmrd relations .
further for such a close distance range of @xmath130 pc , the extinction versus distance models of marshall et al .
( 2006 ) suggest that we should get an extinction value of 0.45 for a@xmath119 which is again inconsistent with the observed estimate of 2.23 . an additional confirmation for the symbiotic nature of nova sco 2015 comes from the comparison of its h@xmath0 and r band images .
the supercosmos archive/ ] h@xmath0 image is considerably brighter than the r band counter part indicating the presence of strong h@xmath0 emission .
the supercosmos values of h@xmath0 and short - r band magnitudes are 15.48 and 16.33 respectively , whereas the mean value of the ( h@xmath0 - short r ) magnitude for about 275 listed sources in a 3 arc - minute square field around the object is found to be @xmath131 . that is , the source is considerably bright in h@xmath0 .
in fact , pronounced h i emission is used as one of the principal criteria for the classification of symbiotic stars ( belczynski et al . , 2000 ) .
this can be seen from the spectra of symbiotic stars , for e.g. in the catalogue of munari & zwitter ( 2002 ) , wherein they are seen to exhibit strong h@xmath0 emission .
however in addition to the presence of hi lines , the other criteria for a definitive symbiotic star classification requires the presence of higher excitation lines ( e.g. [ oiii ] , heii ) . after the system has returned to quiescence , and the nova ejecta faded , it may be checked whether such lines are seen .
we estimate the outburst amplitude of nova sco 2015 by associating the optical counter part nomad-1 0549 - 0492872 with @xmath19 = 17.0 as the progenitor suggested by guido & howes ( 2015 ) .
the @xmath19 = 9.492 near the maximum from the smarts database gives an outburst amplitude ( a ) of @xmath77.5 in the @xmath19 band which is relatively small .
it lies @xmath7 4.5 magnitude below the outburst amplitude ( a ) vs log ( @xmath132 ) plot for classical novae ( warner 1995 ; fig 5.4 ) . in an extensive study of a large sample of classical novae and the recurrent novae pagnotta & schaefer ( 2014 )
have identified the characteristics common to recurrent novae to identify the potential recurrent novae among the known classical novae .
the data discussed earlier shows that most of these characteristics , namely , small outburst amplitude , near ir colors resembling the colors of late type giant , expansion velocity exceeding 2000 kms@xmath4 and the presence of high excitation lines are fulfilled by nova sco 2015 , thus it presents a strong case for to be a potential recurrent nova .
it is worth noting the similar case of nova sco 2014 , wherein joshi et al ( 2015 ) have shown that the outburst occurred in a symbiotic binary system and also suggested that it could be a recurrent nova .
no @xmath38-ray emission was detected by the fermi observatory from nova sco 2015 or nova sco 2014 ( joshi et al . 2015 ) which are both similar systems .
on the other hand , two other similar symbiotic systems were detected in @xmath38 rays viz .
v407 cyg and v745 sco .
the non - detections in nova sco 2014 and nova sco 2015 could be a consequence of both objects being sufficiently distant that any emission from them falls below the detection threshold of fermi .
but it is desirable to check the fermi data from both these novae carefully for any weak or suggested signs of detection .
this has bearings on the origin of @xmath38-ray emission from novae where the latest paradigm suggests that @xmath38-ray emission could be a generic property of all novae and not intrinsic to just symbiotic systems ( ackermann et al .
novae from which @xmath38-ray emission has been detected , but which are not symbiotic systems , are nova sco 2012 , nova mon 2012 , nova del 2013 and nova cen 2013 .
we present near - infrared photometric and spectroscopic observations of nova cep 2014 and nova sco 2015 which were discovered in outburst on 2014 march 8.79 ut and 2015 february 11.84 ut respectively .
our observations for nova cep 2014 cover 9 epochs from 5 to 90 days after outburst and for nova sco 2015 cover 11 epochs covering 7 to 47 days after outburst .
nova cep 2014 shows the conventional characteristics of a fe ii class characterized by strong ci lines together with hi and o i lines , whereas nova sco 2015 is classified as he / n class , shows strong he i emission lines together with hi and oi emission features . using mmrd relations for the novae
, we estimate the distances for nova cep 2014 and nova sco 2015 as @xmath133 kpc and @xmath134 kpc respectively . for nova sco 2015 ,
the presence of a decelerative shock seen through a narrowing of the line profiles , presents a strong case for it to be a symbiotic system .
we discuss the evolution of the strength and shape of the emission line profiles .
the ejecta velocity shows a power law decay with time ( @xmath1 ) and case is presented for asymmetric ejecta flow in the winds of a cool giant companion star .
the sed of the secondary in quiescence shows it to be a late cool type giant and the h@xmath0 excess seen from the system in quiescence is also indicative of the symbiotic nature of the system .
constraints are put on the spectral type of the companion star .
a case b recombination analysis shows the brackett lines to be optically thick . this in turn helps us to estimate , for nova sco 2015 , that the emission measure @xmath2 is in the range of @xmath55 to @xmath56 @xmath57 , the corresponding lower limit of the electron density @xmath3 is in the range @xmath105 @xmath51 to @xmath106 @xmath51 and the mass @xmath68 of the ejecta is between ( @xmath135 @xmath136)@xmath69 m@xmath75 where @xmath69 is the filling factor . for nova cep 2014 ,
the corresponding estimates are @xmath55 to @xmath56 @xmath57 for the emission measure , @xmath62 @xmath51 to @xmath63 @xmath51 for the electron density and ( @xmath73 @xmath74)@xmath69 m@xmath75 for the mass of the ejecta where @xmath69 is the filling factor .
the research work at the physical research laboratory is funded by the department of space , government of india .
we acknowledge the use of data from the aavso , smarts , 2mass , wise and denis databases .
we wish to thank v. venkataraman and vishal joshi for taking some of the observations of nova cep 2014 from mt .
helpful comments from the anonymous referee are acknowledged with thanks .
ds is a visiting astronomer at the infrared telescope facility which is operated by the university of hawaii under contract nnh14ck55b with the national aeronautics and space administration .
ds would like to thank michael cushing for his efforts in keeping the spectool reduction code up to date .
99 ackermann m. , ajello m. , albert a. , baldini l. , ballet j. , barbiellini g. , bastieri d. , bellazzini r. , bissaldi e. , blandford r. d. , et al .
2014 , science , 345 , 554 ashok n. m. , banerjee d. p. k. , 2003 , a@xmath137a , 409 , 1007 ashok n. m. , banerjee d. p. k. , venkataraman v. , joshi v. , 2014 , astron .
telegram , 5996,1 banerjee d. p. k. , das r. k. , ashok n. m. , 2009 , mnras , 399 , 35 banerjee d. p. k. , ashok n. m. , 2012 , basi , 40 , 243 banerjee d. p. k. , joshi v. , venkataraman v. , ashok n. m. , marion g. h. , hsiao e. y. , raj a.,2014 , apjl , 785 , l11 belczynski k. , mikolajewska j. , munari u. , ivison r. j. , friedjung m.,2000 , a&as,146,407 bessell m.s . , brett j.m . , 1988 ,
pasp , 100 , 1134 bode , m. f. , kahn , f. 1985 , mnras , 217 , 205 bode , m. f. , obrien , t. j. , osborne , j. p. , et al 2006 , apj , 652 , 629 carpenter j.m . , 2001 , aj , 121 , 2851 chomiuk , l. , krauss , m. i. , rupen , m. p. , et al . 2012 ,
apj , 761 , 173 cushing , m. c. , vacca , w.d . , rayner , j. t. , 2004 , pasp , 116 , 362 das r. k. , banerjee d. p. k. , ashok n. m. , 2006 , apj , 653 , l141 das r. k. , banerjee d. p. k. , ashok n. m. , chesneau o. , 2008 , mnras , 391 , 1874 della valle m. , livio m. , 1995 , apj , 452 , 704 downes r.a .
, duerbeck h.w . , 2000 , aj , 120 , 2007 guido e. , howes h. , 2015 , cbet , 4078,1 hummer d. g. , storey p. j. , 1987 , mnras , 224 , 801 jose j. , hernanz m. , 1998 , apj , 494 , 680 joshi v. , banerjee d. p. k. , ashok n. m. , 2014 , mnras , 443 , 559 joshi v. , banerjee d. p. k. , ashok n. m. , venkataraman v. , walter f.m . , 2015 , preprint arxiv:1507.02487 ; to appear in mnras lang k.l . , 1990 , astrophysical data : planets and stars , springer - verlag publishers .
lynch d. k. , rudy r. j. , mazuk s. , puetter r. c. , 2000 , apj , 541 , 791 marshall d. j. , robin a. c. , reyle c. , schultheis m. , picaud s. , 2006 , a&a , 453 , 635 munari u. , joshi v. h. , ashok n. m. , banerjee d. p. k. , valisa p. , milani a. , siviero a. , dallaporta s. , castellani f. , 2011 , mnras , 410 , l52 munari u. , zwitter t. , 2002 , a&a , 383 , 188 munari u. , milani a. , valisa p. , castellani f. , belligoli r.,2014,cbet , 3825 , 1 nakano , 2015 , cbet , 4078,1 naik s. , banerjee d. p. k. , ashok n. m. , 2009 , mnras , 394 , 1551 nelson t. , linford j. , chomiuk l. , sokoloski j. , mukai k. , finzell t. , weston j. , rupen m. , mioduszewski a. , 2015 , astron .
telegram , 7085,1 nishiyama , k. , kabashima , f. , 2014 , cbet 3825,1 pagnotta a. , schaefer b. e. , 2014 , apj , 788 , 164 pecaut m. j. , mamajek e. e. , 2013 , apjs , 208 , 9 raj a. , banerjee d. p. k. , ashok n. m.,2013 , mnras,433 , 2657 rayner j. t. , toomey d. w. , onaka p. m. , denault a. j. , stahlberger w. e. , vacca w. d. , cushing m. c. , wang , s.,2003 , pasp,115 , 805,362 ribeiro , v. a. r. m. ; bode , m. f. ; darnley , m. j. ; barnsley , r. m. ; munari , u. ; harman , d. j. ; 2013 , mnras , 433 , 1991 .
rieke g.h . ,
levofsky m.j.,1985 , apj , 368 , 468 schlafly e. , finkbeiner d.p . , 2011 ,
apj , 737 , 103 sokoloski , l. j. , luna , g. j. m. , mukai , k. , et al .
2006 , nature , 442 , 276 srivastava m. , ashok n. m. , banerjee d. p. k. , venkataraman v. , astron .
telegram , 7236,1 starrfield s. , gehrz r. d. , truran j. w. , 1997 , in bernatowicz t. j. , zinner e. , eds , astrophysical implications of the laboratory study of presolar materials .
, new york , p. 203
storey p. j. , hummer d. g. , 1995 , mnras , 272 , 41 vacca , w. d. , cushing , m. c. , rayner , j. t. , 2003 , pasp , 115 , 389 van den berg s. , younger p.s .
, 1987 , a&as , 70 , 125 walter f. , astron .
telegram , 7060,1 warner b. , 1995 , cataclysmic variable stars .
cambridge astrophysics series , cambridge univ . press ,
cambridge , new york ; williams , r.e . , 2012 ,
aj , 144 , 98
most of the nir lines that appear in the spectra of novae have been identified in das et al ( 2008 ) . however , the spectra presented there were in the 1.08 to 2.4 @xmath13 m region , whereas the present spectra are taken with a newer instrument extend up to 0.85 @xmath13 m .
a robust identification of the numerous lines that appear in the 0.85 to 1.08 @xmath13 m ( ij band region ) is thus desirable . to identify the lines that contribute to a nova s spectrum
, we use an lte model to build synthetic spectra as in das et al ( 2008 ) and ashok & banerjee ( 2003 ) .
assumptions of lte may not strictly prevail in an nova environment although , around maximum and the early decline stage , when the particle density can be high ( up to even @xmath138 ) collisions will be a dominant mechanism and will tend to drive the gas towards a boltzmann distribution and lte . yet , in spite of the limitations of the lte assumption we find that the model - generated spectra , greatly aid in a more secure identification of the lines observed . briefly
( more details in das et al , 2008 ) the model spectra are generated by considering only those elements whose lines can be expected at discernible strength . since nucleosynthesis calculations of elemental abundances in novae ( starrfield et al .
1997 ; jose @xmath137 hernanz , 1998 ) show that h , he , c , o , n , ne , mg , na , al , si , p , s are the elements with significant yields in novae ejecta , only these elements have been considered .
the saha ionization equation was applied to calculate the fractional percentage of the species in different ionization stages and subsequently the boltzman equation was applied to calculate level populations . by switching off or greatly increasing the abundance of an element , it is easy to identify the positions where the lines of that element disappear or build up .
fig [ fig_ncep_lineid ] shows the ij band spectrum of nova cep 2014 of 2014 march 20 in black and a typical synthetic lte spectrum in gray below .
the lte spectrum has been computed for @xmath3 = 10@xmath139 @xmath30 , @xmath140 = 8000k and abundances typically found in co novae as given in starrfield et al .
( 1997 ) and jose @xmath137 hernanz ( 1998 ) .
a total of @xmath7 2500 of the strongest lines were considered for these elements compiled from the kurucz atomic line list and national institute of standards and technology ( nist ) line list database .
based on the line identifications done here , and lines in novae spectra known from earlier studies ( williams , 2012 ; das et al .
2008 ) , the observed line list is given in the table [ table_linelist ] .
lrrrrlrrrr + wavelength & species & other con- & nova cep & nova sco & wavelength & species & other con- & nova cep & nova sco + ( @xmath141 m ) & & tributors/ & & & ( @xmath141 m ) & & tributors/ & & + & & remarks & & & & & remarks & & + 0.8359 & hi pa22 & & & x & 1.2527 & he i & & & x + 0.8374 & hi pa 21 & & & x & 1.2562,1.2569 & c i & & x & + 0.8392 & hi pa20 & & & x & 1.2620 & c i & & x & + 0.8413 & hi pa 19 & & & x & 1.2755 & u.i & & & x + 0.8446 & o i & pa18 0.8438 & & x & 1.2763 & u.i & & & x + 0.8467 & pa17 & & & x & 1.2818 & hi pa5 & & x & x + 0.8498 & ca ii & pa16 0.8502 & & x & 1.2963 & u.i & & & x + 0.8542 & ca ii & pa15 0.8545 & & x & 1.3164 & o i & & x & x + 0.8598 & hi pa14 & & & x & 1.34 - 1.38 & n i & blend of many & x & + & & & & & & & ni lines & & + 0.8665 & hi pa13 & ca ii 0.8662 & & x & 1.4420 & c i & & x & + 0.8680 & ni & & x & & 1.4543 & c i & & x & + 0.8750 & hi pa12 & & & x & 1.4539 & u.i & ci 1.4543 ? & & x + 0.8802 & u.i & 0.8807 mg i ? & & x & 1.4757 & n i & & x & + 0.8863 & hi pa11 & & & x & 1.4906 & hi br27 & & & x + 0.8909 & u.i & & & x & 1.4938 & hi br26 & & & x + 0.8923 & u.i & & & x & 1.4967 & hi br25 & & & x + 0.9015 & hi pa10 & & & x & 1.5000 & hi br24 & & & x + 0.9021 & ni & & x & & 1.5039 & hi br23 & & & x + 0.9089 & ci & & x & & 1.5083 & hi br22 & & & x + 0.9174 & u.i & & & x & 1.5133 & h1 br21 & & & x + 0.9226 & hi pa9 & & & x & 1.5192 & hi br20 & & x & x + 0.9264 & oi & & x & & 1.5261 & hi br19 & & x & x + 0.9396 & ni & & x & & 1.5342 & hi br18 & & x & x + 0.9406 & ci & & x & & 1.5439 & hi br17 & & x & x + 0.9402 & u.i & ci 0.9406 ? & & x & 1.5556 & hi br16 & & x & x + 0.9546 & hi pa8 & & & x & 1.5701 & hi br15 & & x & x + 0.9863 , 0.9872 & ni & & x & & 1.5881 & hi br14 & & x & x + 0.9993 & u.i & & & x & 1.6005 & c i & & x & + 1.0049 & hi pa7 & & & x & 1.6109 & hi br13 & & x & x + 1.0112 & ni & ci 1.0119 & x & & 1.6407 & hi br12 & & x & x + 1.0124 & he ii & & & x & 1.6807 & hi br11 & & x &
x + 1.0308 & u.i & & & x & 1.6872 & fe ii & & & x + 1.0399 & u.i & & x & & 1.6890 & c i & & x & x + 1.0457 & u.i & & & x & 1.7002 & he i & & & x + 1.0497 & u.i & & & x & 1.7362 & hi br10 & & x & x + 1.0534 & ni & & x & & 1.7200 - 1.7900 & c i & blend of many & x & + & & & & & & & ci lines & & + 1.0685 & c i & & x & x & 1.7413 & feii & & & x + 1.0831 & he i & & x & x & 1.8174 & hi br9 & & & x + 1.0938 & hi pa6 & & x & x & 1.9446 & hi br8 & & & x + 1.1287 & o i & & x & x & 1.9722 & c i & & x & + 1.1330 & c i & & x & & 2.0581 & he i & & x & x + 1.1659 & c i & & x & & 2.0703 & u.i & & & x + 1.1753 & c i & & x & x & 2.1023 & c i & & x & + 1.1828 & mg i & & & x & 2.1120 , 21132 & he i & & & x + 1.1880,1.1896 & c i & & x & x & 2.1156 - 2.1295 & ci & blend of & x & + & & & & & & & ci lines & & + 1.1969 & he i & & & x & 2.1361 & u.i & & & x + 1.2028 & u.i & & & x & 2.1425 & u.i & & & x + 1.2249,1.2264 & c i & & x & & 2.1655 & hi br7 & & x & x + 1.2281 & u.i & & & x & 2.2906 & c i & & x & + 1.2461 , 1.2469 & n i & & x & x & 2.3438 - 2.4945 & hi pf30 to 17 & & & x + | we present multi - epoch near - infrared photo - spectroscopic observations of nova cephei 2014 and nova scorpii 2015 , discovered in outburst on 2014 march 8.79 ut and 2015 february 11.84 ut respectively .
nova cep 2014 shows the conventional nir characteristics of a fe ii class nova characterized by strong ci , hi and o i lines , whereas nova sco 2015 is shown to belong to the he / n class with strong he i , hi and oi emission lines .
the highlight of the results consists in demonstrating that nova sco 2015 is a symbiotic system containing a giant secondary .
leaving aside the t crb class of recurrent novae , all of which have giant donors , nova sco 2015 is shown to be only the third classical nova to be found with a giant secondary .
the evidence for the symbiotic nature is three - fold ; first is the presence of a strong decelerative shock accompanying the passage of the nova s ejecta through the giant s wind , second is the h@xmath0 excess seen from the system and third is the spectral energy distribution of the secondary in quiescence typical of a cool late type giant .
the evolution of the strength and shape of the emission line profiles shows that the ejecta velocity follows a power law decay with time ( @xmath1 ) .
a case b recombination analysis of the h i brackett lines shows that these lines are affected by optical depth effects for both the novae . using this analysis we make estimates for both the novae of the emission measure @xmath2 , the electron density @xmath3 and the mass of the ejecta .
[ firstpage ] infrared : spectra - line : identification - stars : novae , cataclysmic variables - stars : individual nova cephei 2014 , nova scorpii 2015 - techniques : spectroscopic , photometric . |
globular clusters ( gcs ) are among the oldest known stellar systems .
they typically have ages similar to those of their host galaxies , making them ideal probes into galaxy formation and evolution .
the properties of gcs vary significantly .
however , individual clusters contain populations of stars with similar ages and metallicities .
this makes them unique locations for studying stellar evolution . the milky way s gcs still represent the best studied gc system . while the study of these clusters has led to many advances , the milky way contains relatively few gcs ( @xmath0150 gcs : * ? ? ?
* ) , many of which have high foreground extinction , making them hard to study . by determining the properties of extragalactic gcs
, we are able to study a more diverse population and ensure our current conclusions are not biased by the milky way s clusters being atypical . for extragalactic gcs
, it is very difficult to resolve individual stars in the clusters .
however , it is possible to estimate many properties of a gc from its integrated light .
for example : the masses of gcs can be estimated by assuming a mass to light ratio ; combined optical and near infrared colours of gcs can be used to ( at least partially ) break the age and metallicity degeneracy and estimate these parameters ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) ; and their structural parameters can be estimated by fitting their density profiles ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the colours of gcs and gc candidates are also very useful in selecting genuine gcs from stellar asterisms and background galaxies .
good multi - wavelength photometry of gcs is therefore highly desireable .
the proximity of m31 , and its relatively large gc population compared with the milky way ( @xmath0400@xmath1 * ? ? ?
* ) , makes it the ideal location to study extragalactic globular clusters .
its clusters have been the focus of many studies dating back to the early work of @xcite and @xcite .
however , attempts to study its clusters have faced several challenges .
photometry of these clusters is complicated by many of them being projected against the bright and non - uniform structure of m31 itself .
the galaxy s proximity also results in the gc system extending over a wide region of the sky , with clusters recently found beyond 4@xmath2 from the centre of the galaxy @xcite .
this means that surveys with large fields of view are required in order to study the gc system .
it is also difficult to confirm gcs in m31 based on spectroscopy alone .
this is because the velocity distribution of its gc system overlaps that of milky way halo stars . over the past decades
there have been several large catalogues of m31 s gcs including those of : @xcite .
in addition to these catalogues many new clusters and candidates have been proposed ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
these studies have made considerable progress in removing contamination from the cluster catalogues due to either background galaxies ( e.g. * ? ? ?
? * ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) or stars and asterisms both in the milky way and m31 itself ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
however , despite this work , it is likely that there remains significant contamination in the current catalogues of m31 clusters , especially at the faint end of the gc luminosity function .
these studies have also resulted in a large number of unconfirmed candidate clusters ( currently over 1000 : * ? ? ?
* ) whose true nature remains uncertain .
it has been known for many years that some of the proposed gcs in m31 have very blue colours .
recent work has identified that a large number of the clusters in the current catalogues are young clusters ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . a comprehensive catalogue of young clusters in m31 has recently been published from the spectroscopic survey of @xcite .
compared with the young open clusters in the milky way , these clusters have relatively high masses ( @xmath3 ) , akin to the young clusters observed in the large magellanic cloud . a recent _ hubble space telescope ( hst ) _ study of 23 of these young clusters suggested that on average they are larger and more concentrated than typical old clusters @xcite .
most of the clusters studied by @xcite are found to have dissolution timescales of less than a few gyr and are therefore not expected to evolve into typical old globular clusters . whether these clusters are massive open clusters , young globular clusters or a mix of both , it is clear that they represent a different population to the classical old gcs also observed in m31 ( which are the focus of this study ) .
we therefore distinguish between the two populations in our classifications and conclusions .
while these previous studies have provided a wealth of information on the m31 gc system they have also resulted in a rather heterogeneous sample .
for example , the excellent and commonly used revised bologna catalogue ( hereafter rbc ) of m31 gcs by @xcite includes photometry from many different authors using different telescopes and in some cases different ( homogenised ) filters .
this has been previously noted by @xcite ( hereafter c09 ) who recently published new v - band photometry for many rbc sources which were located in the local group galaxy survey images of m31 ( lggs : * ? ? ?
while this work provides excellent deep v - band photometry , the survey does not cover the outer clusters and candidates and does not provide colour information .
the most complete set of optical colours , derived in a consistent manner , are still that of the barmby catalogue @xcite .
this work presented self - consistent ubvri colours for many of their clusters .
however , it is incomplete in some of these bands and only provides new photometry 285 clusters . for these reasons we chose to produce new , self - consistent , optical photometry for the proposed gcs and gc candidates in the rbc using images from the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) .
the excellent calibration and large field of view of this survey is ideal for studying such an extended system . details of this photometry are presented in section 2.2 .
the study of m31 s gcs in the near infrared ( nir ) is very useful both for confirming genuine gcs and for estimating their ages and metallicities ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the first major survey of m31 s gcs in the nir was by @xcite who used pointed observations of individual clusters to obtain k - band photometry of 228 of their clusters .
more recently @xcite obtained nir photometry in the j , h and k - bands of 279 of their confirmed gcs from the 2 micron all sky survey ( 2mass ) .
the spatial coverage of 2mass makes it ideal for such a project .
however , the survey is relatively shallow and has relatively poor spatial resolution .
we have obtained new deep k - band photometry using the wide field camera on the uk infrared telescope to determine the k - band magnitude of m31 s gcs across the entire gc luminosity function .
some results of this survey are already published in @xcite .
in addition to providing the first k - band photometry for 126 gcs marked as confirmed in the rbc , the excellent spatial resolution of these images is very useful for removing stellar sources from genuine clusters , and for investigating the density profiles of the clusters .
details of this new k - band photometry are presented in section 2.3 , while the classifications of the proposed clusters and candidates are considered in section 3 .
the proximity of m31 makes it the ideal location for studying the structure of extragalactic gcs .
determination of the size and density of gcs is very useful in investigating : stellar evolution ; galaxy formation and evolution ; constraining n - body simulations ; and investigating exotic objects in gcs like x - ray binaries , blue stragglers and horizontal branch / extreme horizontal branch stars .
the structural parameters for some of m31 s gcs have been measured using _
hubble space telescope ( hst ) _ : faint object camera ( foc ) images of 13 clusters @xcite ; wide field planetary camera ( wfpc2 ) images of 50 clusters @xcite ; and advanced camera for surveys ( acs ) and space telescope imaging spectrograph ( stis ) images of 15 and 19 clusters respectively @xcite . in @xcite
we presented the results of fitting psf convolved king models @xcite to the ground based wfcam images used here in order to estimate the structural parameters for 239 clusters . in section 4
we discuss the structure of m31 s gcs .
in the following analysis we consider all the gcs and gc candidates listed the rbc ( their class 1@xmath48 and 2 objects respectively ) .
based on the original catalogue of @xcite , this catalogue has been regularly updated to include the results from most new studies .
this version of the catalogue ( v3.5 ) includes the newly discovered gcs in the outer regions on m31 @xcite and the new gcs and candidates from @xcite ( hereafter k07 : their class a and b@xmath4c objects respectively ) .
we also consider the catalogue of c09 which includes some additional clusters and gives updated locations and classifications for many of the objects in the rbc based on images from the lggs or digital sky survey and/or hectospec spectroscopy .
this combined catalogue is used to identify the known gcs and candidates in the following analysis . to obtain self - consistent optical photometry of m31 s clusters and candidates we extracted images of m31 from the sdss archive .
since m31 is at a relatively low galactic latitude of -21@xmath2 , it is not included in the standard survey field .
however drift scan images of m31 were obtained by the sdss 2.5 m telescope @xcite in 2002 as part of a special run during a period when the survey s primary field was not available @xcite .
the runs used ( 3366 , 3367 , 6426 and 7210 ) provide images in the five sdss bandpasses ( _ ugriz _ : * ? ? ?
each of the observations takes images in these bands simultaneously meaning that they are taken under the same atmospheric conditions .
the seeing for different observations varied significantly between 1.1 - 2.1@xmath5 in _ g _ ( meaning that faint gcs could appear as point sources in some of these images ) .
the 3@xmath6 detection limits of these images were verified to be similar to the standard survey ( @xmath7 ) .
these data were found to cover and detect 92@xmath8 ( _ gri _ ) , 90@xmath8 ( _ z _ ) and 73@xmath8 ( _ u _ ) of the 1558 clusters and candidates in the current rbc .
two of these gcs were saturated in the _ r _ and _ i _ bands and one was saturated in the _ g_-band .
we do not provide new photometry for these clusters but good photometry is already available for these very bright clusters from previous studies .
we extracted all images covering the locations of confirmed and candidate clusters from the sdss supplemental archive .
figure [ fig : images ] shows the coverage of these data and demonstrates that most known clusters and candidates ( red circles ) are covered .
these images have been processed through the standard sdss pipeline @xcite which both reduces the raw images and produces a catalogue of sources in each image .
since the sdss extraction and photometry routines are not designed to work in crowded fields ( like m31 ) , the default catalogues produced by the pipeline can not be used for photometry of the clusters .
instead we performed photometry on the images as described in the next section .
the photometric zero points for these images were calculated using the calibration coefficients produced by the pipeline .
these calibrations place the magnitudes on the ab photometric system [ @xcite ; the _ u_-band zeropoint has previously been found to be slightly offset from the ab system by @xmath9 mag @xcite , this correction is _ not _ applied to our photometry ] .
this calibration is known to give magnitudes accurate to @xmath00.01 mag .
, height=317 ] catalogues of all sources in each of the _ ugriz _ images were produced using the program sextractor @xcite .
this detected and located every source in each filter , performed initial aperture photometry , and gave an estimate of the stellarity of each source based on the psf of its host image .
sources were identified using a minimum detection area ( detect@xmath10minarea ) of 3 pixels and a detection ( detect@xmath10thresh ) and analysis threshold ( analysis@xmath10thresh ) of 1.5@xmath6 .
this threshold was chosen to ensure that the majority of the clusters profiles were included in the analysis and to help to separate genuinely extended objects from merged sources .
this source catalogue was matched to our combined catalogue of known m31 gcs and candidates ( described in section 2.1 ) based on astrometry .
we identified all objects within 3@xmath5 of the locations quoted in the rbc and ( separately ) to their locations in c09 .
some genuine clusters in the sdss images may not appear extended due to the poor angular resolution of some of the images . also , we wish to provide photometry for potentially misclassified stars in addition to the extended clusters .
the m31 gc catalogue was therefore matched to sources with stellar profiles in addition to those with extended profiles . in the few cases where
multiple sources were located within 3@xmath5 of the quoted location , priority was given first to sources flagged as extended and then to the closest source to the quoted location .
figure [ fig : pos_error ] shows the difference between our positions and the positions quoted in rbc ( solid ) and c09 ( open ) .
we find excellent agreement between our locations and those of c09 but find that the difference in the positions of many sources in the rbc are greater than 1@xmath5 .
the errors in the positions of some sources in the rbc were noted and discussed by c09 .
we note the strong agreement between our locations and those of c09 and use their locations to identify gcs and candidates .
photometry of all clusters and candidates was obtained using sextractor s simple aperture photometry .
we also considered using the iraf : apphot routines to perform the aperture photometry but sextractor was found to deal better with contamination from neighbouring sources .
this is a significant problem when using aperture photometry to obtain magnitudes of extended sources in a crowded region like m31 . to minimise the effects of neighbouring sources within the gc aperture , sextractor masks all other sources detected in the aperture and replaces them with pixels from symmetrically opposite the source . for background estimation we considered the use of both local and global solutions .
to produce a global estimate of the background sextractor produces a smoothed background map for each image .
we chose to create this with a back@xmath10filtersize of 3 and a back@xmath10size of 64 pixels . by examination of the background maps produced by sextractor ,
this method was found to give a good estimation of genuine background variation ( due mainly to structure in m31 itself ) without subtracting flux from the sources of interest .
this was compared with the photometry produced using local backgrounds ( calculated around the isophotal limits of the sources ) . in most cases
good agreement was found between the two methods .
however the local background estimates were found to deal better with the most strongly varying background regions ( near the center of the galaxy and its spiral arms ) .
for this reason local background estimation was used for the final photometry . to determine the total luminosity of each cluster , we produced curves of growth from _
g_-band photometry obtained through apertures with a radii in the range @xmath11 with 0.6@xmath5 increments .
these were used to determine the aperture size required to enclose the total cluster light .
the best aperture was determined independently for each object .
this method ensures that we measure the total cluster luminosity correctly for the largest clusters .
while the use of smaller apertures for smaller clusters maximises the signal to noise and minimises the contamination from nearby sources .
the aperture size used to determine the total magnitude of each cluster is quoted in table 1 .
the average aperture radius used was @xmath05.8@xmath5 , with 87@xmath8 of the apertures @xmath128.2@xmath5 .
the _ ugriz _
colours of the clusters were measured through 4@xmath5 apertures .
we also measured the colours using the aperture determined for the total _
g_-band magnitude .
this confirmed that there were no significant aperture effects due to the use of smaller apertures .
for the final colours we chose to use the smaller aperture size in order to maximise the signal to noise and minimise the contamination from nearby sources . the statistical errors across the gc luminosity function are in most cases less than 0.05 mag in _
gri_. in general the _ u _ and _ z _ bands have slightly larger errors as they have slightly lower signal to noise . however , there are additional systematic errors which need to be considered .
firstly , the errors on the zero point calculation are estimated at 0.01 mag .
this error dominates over the statistical errors for many of the bright clusters .
the other significant source of error for some of the clusters is due to contamination from nearby sources and the error on the background estimation . in the bluer wavelengths there is significant small scale structure in m31 . for clusters projected against the densest regions of the galaxy ,
this makes background subtraction difficult as it can vary on scales smaller than the cluster of interest .
the issue of background estimation is found to be particularly significant for the _ g_-band photometry . in this filter
there is significant small scale structure across m31 ( this structure is less significant in the shallower _
u_-band images where the statistical errors are larger ) . in order to estimate the error on our background estimation we repeated our photometry with apertures 1.8@xmath5 larger than the aperture used for the total magnitudes . with perfect background estimation
, the determined flux should be the same through both apertures ( within the photometric errors ) .
the difference in luminosity of the cluster through each aperture can therefore be used to give an estimation of the error on the background estimation . in most cases
this estimated error is quite small , with a median value @xmath00.015 mag , but for a few clusters it can reach @xmath00.1 mag .
this additional error is combined with the calibration and statistical error and included in table 1 as @xmath13 .
the error on the _ ugriz _ colours should be less affected by these effects .
this is because they are often taken through smaller apertures , also we expect that possible errors on the background level in each filter should , at least partially , cancel .
for this reason the errors on the colours quoted in table 1 are only the statistical errors . [ cols="<,<,^,>,>,>,>,<",options="header " , ] + @xmath14 many of these rbc _ class 1 _ clusters are flagged separately in the rbc as potentially young clusters . these colours clearly identify the population of very blue clusters that have been noted by previous studies .
it can be seen that our colours are in excellent agreement with the spectroscopic classifications of c09 .
we also find good agreement with the confirmed clusters in the rbc which are flagged as potential young clusters ( flag yy@xmath151,2 or 3 in the rbc ) .
this flag is based on the work of @xcite .
most of the previously identified young clusters are much bluer in _
g - r _ than any gc in the milky way . using a similar method to @xcite , we define all objects with _ _ g - [email protected] to be young clusters
. some of the proposed young clusters have colours which are consistent with being old clusters .
however , these objects are also consistent with being young clusters with reddened colours .
these clusters are also found in high density regions of m31 and look similar to the other young clusters we have observed .
we therefore choose to keep the previous ( spectroscopic ) classification for these clusters and suspect that their colours may be reddened .
it can also be seen from figure [ fig : colours ] that two clusters classified as old by c09 ( b386 and phf7 - 1 ) have very blue colours .
we reclassify these two objects as young clusters .
figure [ fig : colours_final ] shows the colours of all confirmed and candidate clusters following the removal of all stellar objects based on their stellarity flag or visual examination of the cluster images .
we have also removed those objects identified in the previous section as being as young clusters .
it can be seen that , having removed these objects , the colours of the confirmed clusters are now consistent with the colours of the old gc system of the milky way .
the clusters extend to much redder colours , but this is consistent with the expected reddening due to extinction from m31 .
the grey points in the bottom panels of figure [ fig : colours_final ] show the colours of the remaining candidate clusters after the removal of non - extended objects .
comparison with the confirmed old clusters shows that many of the candidates have colours consistent with being old clusters .
these clusters are flagged as old candidates in table 1 and should be considered the strongest candidate clusters .
we also identify candidates with very blue colours , consistent with the other young clusters identified .
these are flagged as young candidate clusters in table 1 .
it can be seen that , despite removing objects identified as stars , the colours of many of the candidate clusters are inconsistent with being either old or young clusters .
as we are uncertain of the classification of these objects , we retain their classification as candidates .
however , it is likely that many of these candidates are either background galaxies or unresolved asterisms .
recent studies of the halo of m31 have identified a population of very extended clusters @xcite .
these clusters have half light radii much greater than the majority of clusters in m31 . for a description of these clusters
we refer the reader to @xcite .
seven of these clusters are located in our sdss images and can be identified in table 1 from their names which have the prefix hec ( ` halo extended cluster ' ) .
our colours of these clusters were found to be less reliable than the other clusters studied .
this is because they are resolved , due to the diffuse nature of the clusters , into multiple sources .
the colours for these clusters were therefore re - measured through 12@xmath5 apertures using the iraf : apphot task phot . a smaller aperture of 8@xmath5
was used for hec11 due to a bright neighbouring star .
this method gives reliable results for clusters in the halo of m31 where there is little contamination from neighbouring sources and the background is relatively smooth .
none of these extended clusters are identified in the inner regions of m31 , although detecting such extended and faint objects in front of the m31 would be very difficult .
these clusters are identified in figure [ fig : colours_final ] as open green points .
it can be seen that the colours of these clusters are now consistent with the other old gcs in m31 .
the errors on the colours of the hec clusters are larger than those of the other gcs .
this is due to their diffuse nature and the use of large apertures , which increases the total sky background .
our final classification is based on : the stellarity of the object ; its colours ; visual examination of the object in our 6 bands ; velocity information and classifications from previous studies .
table 1 lists these classifications for all gcs and candidates . for comparison
we also include the previous classifications from the rbc and c09 . for consistency
we have tried to keep our classifications similar to those used in the rbc .
if we have no reason to reclassify the sources , we keep the original classifications ( where available from c09 , which were found to agree best with our classifications , otherwise from the rbc ) . the classifications used are : + + _ 1 : old globular cluster : _ extended and has colours consistent with the milky way s gcs . its velocity is confirmed from previous work ( k07 , c09 or the rbc ) to be consistent with being in the m31 gc system , or the object is confirmed from high resolution _ hst _ images .
+ _ 2 : candidate cluster : _ not confirmed , but previously proposed as being a cluster or candidate and is found here to be extended ( or have uncertain stellarity ) .
candidate is sub - divided , depending on whether its colours are consistent with being an old cluster ( _ 21 _ ) , consistent with being a young cluster ( _ 23 _ ) or inconsistent with being a cluster ( _ 2 _ ) .
+ _ 3 : young cluster : _ has colours consistent with being young . if previously classified , may appear as a resolved asterism in k , but looks like a cluster in the sdss images .
+ _ 4 : background galaxy : _ previously classified from spectroscopy by c09 or identified from our visual examination . +
_ 5 : hii region : _ from previous classification of c09 .
+ _ 6 : stellar source : _ object appears to be a single stellar source or a previously unresolved asterism of stellar sources
. + the total number of sources of each class are shown in table [ tab : compare_class ] .
for reference we include whether these objects were previously classified as : clusters or candidates in the rbc ( rbc 1 and rbc 2 respectively ) ; clusters or candidates by k07 ( k07 a and k07 b@xmath4c respectively ) ; old or young clusters by c09 ( c09 old and c09 young respectively ) .
it can be seen that we have reclassified 10 previously confirmed clusters in the rbc as likely stellar sources .
we also reclassify 6 of these objects as candidate clusters , as we are uncertain of they nature , or they lack spectroscopic confirmation .
some of the candidate clusters in the rbc are confirmed to be old or young clusters .
this is based on the new spectroscopic confirmations by c09 .
we are also able to classify many of the candidate clusters in the rbc as stars . in most cases we find good agreement with the new classifications of c09 .
their catalogue includes fewer objects because they do not provide classifications for the whole gc system .
all objects classed as young clusters by c09 are retained in our classification .
we have reclassified many of the confirmed clusters from k07 as likely stellar sources .
we have also been able to classify nearly half of the cluster candidates from this catalogue as being stellar .
we believe this is due to our improved spatial resolution compared with the images used for this previous catalogue .
we identify and remove 8 objects from the catalogue of k07 which are within 2@xmath5 of another previously identified object in the rbc and we believe are now duplicated in the rbc .
a further 5 objects from the catalogue of k07 appear to be associated with objects in the catalogue of c09 .
the names for these objects in table 1 are the combination of their identifications in each catalogue .
figure [ fig : gclf ] shows the gc luminosity function ( gclf ) for all confirmed gcs ( solid bars ) and young clusters ( open bars ) with k - band photometry .
these clusters are not corrected for extinction . however , extinction is not very significant in the k - band where the maximum correction for the most extreme case of b037 is only 0.5 mag ( the width of the bins used ) .
the peak of the gclf is found to be at [email protected] mag .
the k - band luminosity of a cluster is a useful estimate of its mass .
this is because , in addition to being less effected by extinction , the k - band mass to light ratio ( @xmath17 ) is less effected by metallicity than optical bands .
the mass to light ratio of a 12 gyr cluster in the k - band has previously been estimated to be 0.9@xmath16__m
/ [email protected] for metallicities in the range 0@xmath18[fe
/ h]@xmath18 - 2 @xcite . to estimate the peak mass of the old gcs in m31
, we assume a k - band @xmath17 ratio of 1.1 for all clusters ( as the metallicities are not known for all of the clusters ) . at the distance of m31
( 780 kpc : * ? ? ? * ) and assuming the k - band magnitude of the sun to be m@xmath19=3.29 mag [ m@xmath20=3.33 : @xcite ; m@xmath19=m@xmath20 - 0.04 : @xcite ] , this implies a peak mass of m@xmath21 .
this is slightly higher than that found for milky way gcs ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) . however , this difference is relatively small compared with the expected uncertainty in the peak mass .
this is due to errors in accurately estimating the peak in the gclf combined with errors on the distance to m31 and the value used for the mass to light ratio . for the fainter gcs ,
it is likely that masses estimated from their integrated k - band luminosities are less accurate due to stochastic effects .
stars at the tip of the red giant branch at the distance of m31 are expected to reach magnitudes of k=17.5 @xcite . while stars this bright are relatively rare , the integrated light of some fraction of these faint clusters can therefore be dominated by a relatively low number of these stars .
it is also likely that some of the faintest clusters in m31 are missing from our catalogue .
these clusters should be detected in our data .
however , identifying these faint clusters in front of m31 would be very difficult . as expected the proposed young clusters peak at fainter magnitudes than the old gcs .
some of these clusters are found to be relatively bright , reaching luminosities similar to the peak of the gclf .
this suggests they are more massive than typical young open clusters in the milky way . while this is in agreement with the conclusions of other work ( e.g. *
* ) , it should be noted that our conclusions based on this k - band luminosity are limited .
the @xmath17 ratio of these clusters is likely to be significantly lower than the @xmath17 ratio for the older clusters in the galaxy .
also stochastic effects in these young and faint clusters are likely to be significant in the k - band .
the excellent spatial resolution of these wfcam images allows us to investigate the structure of m31 s old gcs .
this can be done by fitting psf convolved king models to their profiles .
the results of this fitting to 239 _ class 1 _ clusters from the rbc are already presented in @xcite ( hereafter p09 ) . for convenience ,
we have included these structural parameters , where available , in table 1 . here
we review these data and use it to consider the structure of m31 s gc system . from our new classifications
it is found that 186 of the 239 clusters studied by p09 are confirmed as old gcs .
we have also determined the structural parameters for an additional 27 , newly confirmed , gcs with wfcam images .
these parameters were determined using exactly the same method as p09 .
this results in a sample of the 213 old gcs with structural parameters ( representing over half the confirmed gcs identified in m31 ) .
the reliability of these structural parameters , was investigated by p09 and they were found to be consistent with those obtained for 33 clusters whose parameters had already been measured using higher spatial resolution _ hst _ images
they also found that the structural parameters obtained from fitting different wfcam images of the same gc were consistent .
however , the reliability of the parameters was found to decrease significantly for clusters with k@xmath1815 mag .
we note that this decrease in reliability for the fainter clusters is in agreement with the signal to noise limit proposed by @xcite .
the half light radii of the clusters was found to be the most reliable parameter ( as found by other studies e.g. * ? ? ?
errors are not available for these parameters , but we believe them to be relatively reliable for most clusters with k@xmath1615 mag . figure [ fig : param ] shows the concentration [ @xmath22log@xmath23 , core radii ( @xmath24 ) , half light radii ( @xmath25 ) , tidal radii ( @xmath26 ) and core density ( @xmath27 ) of m31 s old gcs . for comparison the same parameters for the milky way s gcs are shown on the bottom row @xcite . before comparing these populations
there are two important differences which need to be considered .
firstly , the m31 parameters are based on the k , rather than the v - band luminosity of the clusters . as a result
we expect offsets in parameters such as the core luminosity density due to the different mass to light ratios .
however , this is unlikely to have a significant effect on the size of the clusters @xcite .
secondly , due to a lack of wfcam data , the sample of m31 gcs does not include the most central or distant gcs in the galaxy .
it can be seen from figure [ fig : param ] that there are a lack of core collapsed gcs in our sample compared with the milky way .
this can be partially explained by the exclusion of the innermost gcs ( where most core collapsed gcs are located in the milky way ) .
taking this into account , we still find fewer of these clusters than expected .
potentially some faint core collapsed clusters may be missed by gc surveys as they would be the most difficult clusters to resolve .
however , it is likely that these clusters are present , but have their concentrations underestimated .
this is because their core radii will be much smaller than the psf of our images , making it very hard to deconvolve and measure them .
comparison of the core radii of the clusters does show that we are missing , or overestimating , the core radii of some of the very smallest core radii clusters .
a lack of core collapsed clusters can also be seen in similar profile fits to _ hst _ images of cen a clusters @xcite . allowing for these effects ,
we see no strong evidence for differences between the structure of the old gcs in m31 and milky way . ) .
bold points show the median values for clusters binned on @xmath28 .
the line demonstrates the relationship found by @xcite between r@xmath29 and @xmath28 .
, height=321 ] in the milky way , it is known that some gc properties are related to position in the galaxy . in figure
[ fig : rgcp_param ] we plot the structural parameters of m31 s gcs as a function of their projected galactocentric radius ( @xmath30 taken from the rbc ) . to help identify potential trends in these data
, we have binned the clusters into groups of 25 and determined the median value of their parameters for each group ( bold points ) .
it can be seen that the luminosity of the gcs appears to decrease slightly with @xmath28 .
this is mainly driven by a deficit of faint clusters in this region combined with the most massive clusters being centrally located .
the relatively low number of faint clusters in the central regions is likely due to selection effects , as it is very difficult to identify these clusters projected against the dense central regions of m31 .
it is therefore likely that some of these clusters are missing from our catalogue .
selection effects can not explain the lack of very massive clusters in the outer regions . however , there are very few of these very bright clusters .
the distribution also suggests that more central clusters have smaller , more concentrated cores .
this relationship may be expected from the evolution of the gc system as central gcs are expected to evolve more quickly due to greater interactions with their host galaxy .
this effect is observed in the milky way s gcs @xcite .
however , we again caution that this is a weak trend , and that the same selection effects could potentially prejudice us against extended , low density clusters in the inner regions .
the half light radius of the clusters can be seen to increase with @xmath28 .
this has previously been observed for a smaller number of gcs in m31 but over a greater range of @xmath28 by @xcite .
the line included in this plot is the relationship found by @xcite not a fit to our data .
this demonstrates the excellent agreement between the trend they identify and that found here for a larger number of clusters .
a similar trend is also found for gcs in the milky way @xcite and in virgo cluster galaxies @xcite . unlike other cluster sizes
, the half light radius of a cluster is thought to be largely unaffected by evolution .
therefore this relationship may be related to the properties of the globular cluster system at the time of formation .
our final catalogue includes 416 old gcs . where detected , we provide self consistent _ ugriz _ and k - band photometry for the proposed clusters and candidate clusters .
we note the difficulty in providing accurate photometry for some of these clusters due to the complex background of m31 .
we highlight the need for good spatial resolution in order to remove contamination from non cluster light when obtaining integrated magnitudes .
where available , we find our photometry to be consistent with that previously published . from our multicolour photometry ,
we confirm the population of very blue clusters identified previously .
we show that these colours are consistent with their spectroscopic classification by c09 as young clusters .
we note that many of these clusters look like resolved asterisms in our k - band images .
however , some of these are confirmed by hst images to be genuine clusters .
higher spatial resolution optical images than available here are required in order to confirm their nature as genuine young clusters .
we have identified that many of the confirmed clusters from @xcite are likely stellar sources ( we retain only 27 of their 111 confirmed clusters as old clusters ) .
we also identify 10 confirmed clusters in the rbc as likely stellar sources .
while we have considered the classifications from k07 and the rbc separately in this paper , we caution that _ all _ of the objects confirmed by k07 to be clusters are included as confirmed clusters in the current version of the rbc ( v3.5 ) .
we also provide new classifications for many of the cluster candidates proposed by this previous work .
we identify many of these candidates to be stars and reduce the number of unclassified candidate clusters to 357 . taking extinction and selection effects into account
, we find both the colours and structure of the old m31 gc system are consistent with the milky way s .
we note a potential lack of both core collapsed and very extended gcs in our m31 sample .
we caution that some ( or all ) of this effect may be due to selection effects in identifying these clusters , or difficulties in accurately measuring their parameters , rather than an intrinsic difference in the populations .
we thank the referee of this paper , michele bellazzini , for his prompt , constructive , and helpful comments .
we would like to thank mark rawlings , andy adamson and mike irwin from the ukirt / casu for obtaining these wfcam observations and assisting with questions related to the wfcam pipeline .
we would also like to thank sebastian jester for his advise regarding the sdss and brian warner and alan shafter for useful communication regarding novae .
adelman - mccarthy j. k. , et al .
, 2007 , apjs , 172 , 634 barmby p. , huchra j. p. , brodie j. p. , forbes d. a. , schroder l. l. , grillmair c. j. , 2000 , aj , 119 , 727 barmby p. , holland s. , huchra j. p. , 2002
, aj , 123 , 1937 barmby p. , mclaughlin d. e. , harris w. e. , harris g. l. h. , forbes d. a. , 2007 , aj , 133 , 2764 barmby p. , et al .
, 2009 , arxiv , arxiv:0909.4053 battistini p. , bonoli f. , braccesi a. , federici l. , fusi pecci f. , marano b. , borngen f. , 1987 , a&as , 67 , 447 battistini p. l. , bonoli f. , casavecchia m. , ciotti l. , federici l. , fusi - pecci f. , 1993 , a&a , 272 , 77 beasley m. a. , brodie j. p. , strader j. , forbes d. a. , proctor r. n. , barmby p. , huchra j. p. , 2004
, aj , 128 , 1623 bellazzini m. , pasquali a. , federici l. , ferraro f. r. , pecci f. f. , 1995 , apj , 439 , 687 bertin e. , arnouts s. , 1996 , a&as , 117 , 393 bohlin r. c. , dickinson m. e. , calzetti d. , 2001 , aj , 122 , 2118 bruzual g. , charlot s. , 2003 , mnras , 344 , 1000 caldwell n. , harding p. , morrison h. , rose j. a. , schiavon r. , kriessler j. , 2009 , aj , 137 , 94 carlson m. n. , holtzman j. a. , 2001 , pasp , 113 , 1522 carpenter j. m. , 2001 , aj , 121 , 2851 cohen j. g. , matthews k. , cameron p. b. , 2005 , apj , 634 , l45 cohen j. g. , hsieh s. , metchev s. , djorgovski s. g. , malkan m. , 2007 , aj , 133 , 99 cox a. n. , 2000 , asqu.book , djorgovski s. , meylan g. , 1994 , aj , 108 , 1292 dye s. , et al . , 2006 , mnras , 372 , 1227 fan z. , ma j. , de grijs r. , yang y. , zhou x. , 2006 , mnras , 371 , 1648 fan z. , ma j. , de grijs r. , zhou x. , 2008 , mnras , 385 , 1973 ferraro f. r. , montegriffo p. , origlia l. , fusi pecci f. , 2000 , aj , 119 , 1282 forbes d. a. , lasky p. , graham a. w. , spitler l. , 2008 , mnras , 389 , 1924 fruchter a. s. , hook r. n. , 2002 , pasp , 114 , 144 fukugita m. , ichikawa t. , gunn j. e. , doi m. , shimasaku k. , schneider d. p. , 1996
, aj , 111 , 1748 fusi pecci f. , et al . , 1994 , a&a , 284 , 349 fusi pecci f. , bellazzini m. , buzzoni a. , de simone e. , federici l. , galleti s. , 2005 , aj , 130 , 554 galleti s. , federici l. , bellazzini m. , fusi pecci f. , macrina s. , 2004 , a&a , 416 , 917 galleti s. , federici l. , bellazzini m. , buzzoni a. , fusi pecci f. , 2006 , a&a , 456 , 985 galleti s. , bellazzini m. , federici l. , buzzoni a. , fusi pecci f. , 2007 , a&a , 471 , 127 harris w. e. , 1996 , aj , 112 , 1487 hempel m. , zepf s. , kundu a. , geisler d. , maccarone t. j. , 2007 , apj , 661 , 768 henze m. , et al . , 2009 , a&a , 500 , 769 hewett p. c. , warren s. j. , leggett s. k. , hodgkin s. t. , 2006 , mnras , 367 , 454 hodgkin s. t. , irwin m. j. , hewett p. c. , warren s. j. , 2009 , mnras , 394 , 675 hogg d. e. , 1964 , jrasc , 58 , 203 hubble e. , 1932 , apj , 76 , 44 huxor a. p. , tanvir n. r. , irwin m. j. , ibata r. , collett j. l. , ferguson a. m. n. , bridges t. , lewis g. f. , 2005 , mnras , 360 , 1007 huxor a. p. , tanvir n. r. , ferguson a. m. n. , irwin m. j. , ibata r. , bridges t. , lewis f. , 2008 , mnras , 385 , 1989 jester s. , et al . , 2005 ,
aj , 130 , 873 jiang l. , ma j. , zhou x. , chen j. , wu h. , jiang z. , 2003 , aj , 125 , 727 jordn a. , et al . , 2005 ,
apj , 634 , 1002 jordn a. , et al . , 2007 , apj , 671 , l117 kim s. c. , et al . , 2007 , aj , 134 , 706 king i. , 1966 , aj , 71 , 64 kundu a. , whitmore b. c. , 1998 , aj , 116 , 2841 lupton r. h. , gunn j. e. , szalay a. s. , 1999 , aj , 118 , 1406 massey p. , olsen k. a. g. , hodge p. w. , strong s. b. , jacoby g. h. , schlingman w. , smith r. c. , 2006 , aj , 131 , 2478 mackey a. d. , et al .
, 2006 , apj , 653 , l105 mclaughlin d. e. , barmby p. , harris w. e. , forbes d. a. , harris g. l. h. , 2008 , mnras , 384 , 563 mcconnachie a. w. , irwin m. j. , ferguson a. m. n. , ibata r. a. , lewis g. f. , tanvir n. , 2005 , mnras , 356 , 979 mochejska b. j. , kaluzny j. , krockenberger m. , sasselov d. d. , stanek k. z. , 1998 , aca , 48 , 455 margon b. , anderson s. f. , downes r. a. , bohlin r. c. , jakobsen p. , 1991 ,
apj , 369 , l71 oke j. b. , gunn j. e. , 1983 , apj , 266 , 713 peacock m. b. , maccarone t. j. , waters c. z. , kundu a. , zepf s. e. , knigge c. , zurek d. r. , 2009 , mnras , 392 , l55 perrett k. m. , bridges t. j. , hanes d. a. , irwin m. j. , brodie j. p. , carter d. , huchra j. p. , watson f. g. , 2002 , aj , 123 , 2490 pier j. r. , munn j. a. , hindsley r. b. , hennessy g. s. , kent s. m. , lupton r. h. , ivezi .
, 2003 , aj , 125 , 1559 pogson n. , 1860 , mnras , 21 , 32 puzia t. h. , zepf s. e. , kissler - patig m. , hilker m. , minniti d. , goudfrooij p. , 2002
, a&a , 391 , 453 quimby r. , et al . , 2007 , atel , 1118 , 1 racine r. , 1991 , aj , 101 , 865 reed l. g. , harris g. l. h. , harris w. e. , 1992 , aj , 103 , 824 reed l. g. , harris g. l. h. , harris w. e. , 1994 , aj , 107 , 555 rey s .- c .
, et al . , 2007 , apjs , 173 , 643 schlegel d. j. , finkbeiner d. p. , davis m. , 1998 , apj , 500 , 525 shafter a. w. , quimby r. m. , 2007 , apj , 671 , l121 shara m. m. , zurek d. r. , baltz e. a. , lauer t. r. , silk j. , 2004 , apj , 605 , l117 sharov a. s. , liutyi v. m. , 1983 , ap&ss , 90 , 371 sharov a. s. , lyutyj v. m. , esipov v. f. , 1987 , pazh , 13 , 643 sharov a. s. , lyutyj v. m. , ikonnikova n. p. , 1992 ,
sval , 18 , 41 sharov a. s. , lyutyi v. m. , esipov v. f. , 1995 , astl , 21 , 240 stoughton c. , et al . , 2002 ,
aj , 123 , 485 tabur v. , kiss l. l. , bedding t. r. , 2009 , apj , 703 , l72 van den bergh s. , morbey c. , pazder j. , 1991 , apj , 375 , 594 vetenik m. , 1962 , baicz , 13 , 180 warner b. , 1995 , cvs .. book , wehlau a. , butterworth s. , hogg h. s. , 1990 , aj , 99 , 1159 zucker d. b. , et al . , 2004 , apj , 612 , l117 | we present an updated catalogue of m31 globular clusters ( gcs ) based on images from the wide field camera ( wfcam ) on the uk infrared telescope and from the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) .
our catalogue includes new , self - consistent _ ugriz _ and k - band photometry of these clusters .
we discuss the difficulty of obtaining accurate photometry of clusters projected against m31 due to small scale background structure in the galaxy .
we consider the effect of this on the accuracy of our photometry and provide realistic photometric error estimates . we investigate possible contamination in the current m31 gc catalogues using the excellent spatial resolution of these wfcam images combined with the sdss multicolour photometry .
we identify a large population of clusters with very blue colours .
most of these have recently been proposed by other work as young clusters .
we distinguish between these , and old clusters , in the final classifications .
our final catalogue includes 416 old clusters , 156 young clusters and 373 candidate clusters .
we also investigate the structure of m31 s old gcs using previously published king model fits to these wfcam images .
we demonstrate that the structure and colours of m31 s old gc system are similar to those of the milky way .
one gc ( b383 ) is found to be significantly brighter in previous observations than observed here .
we investigate all of the previous photometry of this gc and suggest that this variability appears to be genuine and short lived .
we propose that the large increase in its luminosity my have been due to a classical nova in the gc at the time of the previous observations in 1989 .
[ firstpage ] galaxies : individual : m31 - galaxies : star clusters - globular clusters : general |
the wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe ( wmap ) has made the most precise measurements to date of the anisotropies of the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) over a wide range of angular scales .
these measurements have been invaluable in constraining a wide range of cosmological parameters @xcite .
additionally , this data has been used to study standard interstellar medium emission mechanisms , including thermal dust , spinning dust , ionized gas , and synchrotron .
after known foregrounds are subtracted from the wmap data , there remains an unexplained excess of microwave emission within the inner @xmath5 around the center of the milky way , distributed with approximate radial symmetry .
this microwave emission has been dubbed the `` wmap haze '' @xcite .
although the origin of the wmap haze is uncertain , there are compelling reasons to suspect that it may have been generated through the annihilations of dark matter in the form of weakly interacting , massive particles ( wimps ) @xcite .
wimp annihilations can produce a wide range of possible final states , each of which decay and fragment into a combination of gamma rays , neutrinos , protons , electrons and their antimatter counterparts . a wimp with an electroweak scale mass will produce relativistic electrons and positrons which , in the presence of the galactic magnetic field , emit synchrotron photons in the frequency range of wmap . in previous work , it was shown that the angular distribution of the haze is consistent with dark matter annihilations with a halo profile scaling as @xmath6 in the inner kiloparsecs of our galaxy .
the synchrotron spectrum predicted for an electroweak scale wimp was also found to be consistent with the observations of wmap .
furthermore , to normalize the dark matter annihilation rate to the observed intensity of the haze , a dark matter annihilation cross section on the order of @xmath7 @xmath1/s is required @xcite .
this is remarkably similar to the value required for an electroweak scale relic to be thermally produced with the observed dark matter abundance .
no exotic astrophysical parameters or annihilation boost factors are required to generate the wmap haze through this mechanism .
if the wmap haze is in fact generated through the annihilation of dark matter particles in the inner galaxy , then the intensity and angular distribution of the haze can be used to estimate the annihilation rate and spatial distribution of dark matter in the inner halo .
this can , in turn , be used to estimate the flux of gamma rays and other annihilation products which are expected to accompany the electrons and positrons responsible for the haze . in this article
, we assume that the wmap haze results from wimp annihilation and calculate the corresponding gamma ray spectrum and consider the prospects for the upcoming satellite - based gamma ray telescope glast to detect this signal .
we find that wimps annihilating in the inner 0.1@xmath2 around the galactic center to heavy quarks or gauge bosons will be detectable by glast with 5@xmath3 ( @xmath4 ) significance if they are lighter than approximately 320 - 500 gev ( 500 - 750 gev ) . if a somewhat wider angular window is observed ( out to @xmath80.5@xmath2 ) , glast will be capable of detecting angular extension of the dark matter halo profile . in directions somewhat away from the galactic center , the astrophysical background from the tev gamma ray source observed by hess is significantly reduced , enabling glast to identify the dark matter annihilation radiation associated with the wmap haze with high significance .
the only case we find in which glast would not be expected to identify the dark matter associated with the wmap haze is if the dark matter annihilates largely to @xmath9 or @xmath10 final states , resulting in a high ratio of synchrotron to gamma ray radiation .
to confirm or refute the hypothesis that dark matter annihilations are responsible for the wmap haze , some set of complementary observations will certainly be required .
wimp annihilations are expected to deposit energy into a variety of forms , several of which are potentially observable .
wimps with electroweak scale masses annihilating into the most commonly assumed final states ( such as gauge bosons or heavy quarks ) transfer most of their energy ( @xmath11 ) into neutrinos , and smaller fractions into gamma rays ( 13 - 20% ) , electron - positron pairs ( 10 - 13% ) and proton - antiproton pairs ( 2 - 5% ) . due to their weak interactions ,
the resulting neutrinos are likely to be the most difficult to observe , despite their greater luminosity @xcite ( the exception to this conclusion being the case of wimp annihilations taking place in the core of the sun , from which other annihilation products can not escape @xcite ) .
gamma rays and charged particles produced in dark matter annihilations in the mikly way halo , in contrast , each provide promising opportunities for observation .
gamma rays , once produced , do not interact significantly over galactic distances . as a result , they can be studied as direct probes of dark matter annihilation by space or ground based gamma ray telescopes , assuming that the annihilation rate is sufficiently high .
charged annihilation products , in contrast , undergo interactions in the interstellar medium which alter their trajectories and lead to significant energy loses .
electrons and positrons , in particular , lose energy through inverse compton scattering off of starlight , cmb photons and far infrared emission from dust .
interactions with the galactic magnetic field also cause them to undergo synchrotron energy losses .
the relative importance of these processes depends on the energy densities of radiation and magnetic fields .
the electron - positron energy loss rate from these two processes is given by @xcite : @xmath12 , \label{loss}\ ] ] where @xmath13 is the thompson scattering cross section , @xmath14 is the energy density in radiation fields ( starlight , etc . ) and @xmath15 is the energy density in magnetic fields . in calculating the synchrotron rate ,
we have averaged over the pitch angle .
the energy density of cmb photons is approximately 0.3 ev/@xmath1 . in the solar neighborhood , starlight is roughly twice as prevalent . at small galactrocentric distances ,
however , the density of starlight is expected to be considerably larger @xcite , which is reflected in our nominal estimate of 5 ev/@xmath1 used in eq .
[ loss ] .
the processes of synchrotron radiation and inverse compton scattering each lead to potentially observable byproducts @xcite .
synchrotron photons with microwave frequencies , as we have stated before , may constitute the observed wmap haze .
the inverse compton scattering of highly relativistic electrons and positrons with starlight photons , on the other hand , can generate mev - gev photons with a total luminosity @xmath16 times brighter than the wmap haze . in fig .
[ icplot ] , we show the spectrum of inverse compton emission from the inner galaxy ( @xmath17 , @xmath18 ) associated with the electrons / positrons responsible for the observed wmap haze . in this calculation , we have used the starlight spectrum of porter and strong @xcite and an injected spectrum of relativistic electrons / positrons given by @xmath19 with a spatial distribution proportional to @xmath20 , where @xmath21 is the distance from the galactic center . this electron spectrum and distribution
were chosen to approximately yield the observed synchrotron haze .
for comparison , we also show the measurements of the diffuse gamma ray spectrum from this region , as measured by egret @xcite . shown as dotted lines
is the much smaller and negligible contribution from bremsstrahlung radiation .
although the observation of inverse compton photons from the electrons / positrons responsible for the wmap haze could potentially provide a confirmation of the synchrotron nature of the haze , it would not help to clarify the origin of those relativistic electrons and positrons . to confirm the dark matter origin of these particles , annihilation products independent of the @xmath9 population need to be identified .
the most promising channel in which to make such a confirmation is the gamma ray spectrum produced directly in wimp annihilations ( as opposed to gamma rays from inverse compton ) .
unlike inverse compton photons , these direct gamma rays will originate from the highly concentrated central region of our galaxy , where the dark matter density is greatest .
furthermore , for typical wimps the total luminosity in prompt gamma rays is expected to be comparable to , or ( if @xmath22 ) somewhat brighter than , the contribution from inverse compton .
a bright source of energetic gamma rays from this angular region , as we will show , is expected if the wmap haze is produced through dark matter annihilations .
the next generation satellite - based gamma ray telescope glast is scheduled to begin its mission later this year and is expected to take data for a minimum of five years .
glast will have a peak effective area of 11,000 @xmath23 ( or about 60% of this value when averaged over its field - of - view @xcite ) and a single photon angular resolution of 0.45@xmath2 at 1 gev , which improves to 0.1@xmath2 at 10 gev and to 0.035@xmath2 at 100 gev . in each of these respects , glast represents a considerable improvement on its predecessor , egret .
in contrast to ground based gamma ray telescopes , glast is designed to perform an all - sky survey .
emission from the galactic center region is expected to be within glast s observable field - of - view during 50.8% of its mission @xcite .
the galactic center has long been considered to be one of the most promising regions of the sky in which to search for gamma rays from dark matter annihilations @xcite .
the prospects for this depend , however , on a number of factors including the nature of the wimp , the distribution of dark matter in the region around the galactic center , and the presence of any astrophysical backgrounds .
the gamma rays produced through dark matter annihilations are described by @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the wimp annihilation cross section ( multiplied by the relative velocity of the two wimps , in the low velocity limit ) , @xmath26 is the mass of the wimp , @xmath27 is the angle observed relative to the direction of the galactic center , @xmath28 is the dark matter density as a function of distance to the galactic center , and the integral is performed over the line - of - sight .
@xmath29 is the gamma ray spectrum generated per wimp annihilation .
the spectrum of photons produced in dark matter annihilations depends on the details of the wimp being considered .
supersymmetric neutralinos , for example , typically annihilate to final states consisting of heavy fermions ( @xmath30 , @xmath31 , @xmath32 ) and gauge or higgs bosons ( @xmath33 , @xmath34 , @xmath35 , @xmath36 , @xmath37 , @xmath38 ) @xcite . with the exception of the @xmath32 channel , each of these annihilation modes result in a very similar spectrum of gamma rays . the gamma ray spectrum from wimps annihilating to light leptons can be quite different , however
. this can be significant in the case of kaluza - klein dark matter in models with one universal extra dimension , for example , in which dark matter particles annihilate significantly to @xmath9 and @xmath10 @xcite . in models with two universal extra dimensions , however , annihilations to gauge bosons dominate @xcite . in fig .
[ spectra ] we plot the predicted gamma ray spectrum , per annihilation , for several wimp annihilation modes . assuming that the wmap haze is , in fact , the product of dark matter annihilations , and given reasonable assumptions regarding the galactic magnetic field and radiation fields ( see sec .
[ caveats ] ) , we can use the observed intensity to estimate the annihilation rate of dark matter in the region of the galactic center . in ref .
@xcite , the required wimp annihilation cross section was calculated for several possible annihilation modes . in fig .
[ sigma ] , we show the required cross sections ( adapted from ref .
@xcite ) which we will use to normalize the annihilation rate and resulting gamma ray spectrum . averaging over a solid angle centered around a direction , @xmath27 , we arrive at @xmath39 where @xmath40 is the solid angle observed .
the quantity @xmath41 depends only on the dark matter distribution , and is the average over the solid angle of the quantity , @xmath42 @xmath43 is normalized such that a completely flat halo profile , with a density equal to the value at the solar circle , integrated along the line - of - sight to the galactic center would yield a value of one . in ref .
@xcite , it was shown that the angular distribution of the wmap haze is well described by dark matter annihilations with a halo profile approximately given by @xmath44 ^ 2 } , \label{1pt2}\ ] ] where @xmath45 gev/@xmath1 is the dark matter density in the solar neighborhood and @xmath46 kiloparsecs is the scale radius .
this distribution is essentially a navarro - frenk - white ( nfw ) profile @xcite with a slightly steeper inner slope : @xmath47 rather than @xmath48 .
this steepening is not unexpected and could naturally result , for example , from the adiabatic contraction of the halo profile @xcite , or from other effects which are not easily accounted for in n - body simulations . over a solid angle of @xmath49 sr ( a circle of approximately 0.1@xmath2 radius ) around the dynamical center of the milky way
, this profile leads to a value of @xmath50 , which is approximately 15 times larger than is found in the nfw case .
attempting to identify gamma rays from dark matter annihilations taking place near the galactic center has been made more challenging by the discovery of a bright , very high - energy gamma ray source in that region , observed by hess @xcite , magic @xcite , whipple @xcite and cangaroo - ii @xcite .
this source appears to be coincident with the dynamical center of the milky way ( sgr a@xmath51 ) and has no detectable angular extension ( less than 1.2 arcminutes ) .
its spectrum is well described by a power - law , @xmath52 , where @xmath53 over the range of 160 gev to 20 tev .
although speculations were initially made that this source could be the product of annihilations of very heavy ( @xmath54 tev ) dark matter particles @xcite , this now appears to be very unlikely .
the source of these gamma rays is more likely an astrophysical accelerator associated with our galaxy s central supermassive black hole @xcite .
this gamma ray source represents a formidable background for glast and other experiments searching for dark matter annihilation radiation from the galactic center region @xcite . by studying the gamma rays from directions somewhat away from the galactic center ,
however , it is possible to dramatically reduce the background from the hess source . for the halo profile shape favored by the angular distribution of the wmap haze
, there is a sufficient degree of extension to be observed by glast . in fig .
[ angle ] , we plot the relative gamma ray intensity as a function of the angle away from the galactic center observed by glast . here
, we have treated the point spread function of glast as a gaussian of width @xmath55 , which is the approximate width at 10 gev .
the dashed and solid lines denote the cases of a point source ( the hess background ) and a distribution corresponding to dark matter distributed with the profile of eq .
[ 1pt2 ] , respectively . within approximately 0.2@xmath2 of the galactic center ,
the behavior is dominated by glast s point spread function , and angular information can not be used to distinguish the astrophysical point source background from extended dark matter annihilation radiation . at larger angles , however , the extension of the dark matter halo profile becomes important . by observing at angles beyond 0.2@xmath2
, the ratio of signal to background is considerably enhanced .
in figures [ gcspec ] and [ gcspec2 ] we plot the gamma ray spectrum from dark matter annihilations near the galactic center for several wimp annihilation modes and masses . in each of the left frames , we have considered observations averaged over a solid angle of @xmath56 sr centered around the galactic center . in the right frames
, we have considered the spectrum observed from the ring between 0.3 and 0.5@xmath2 away from the galactic center . in each case , the results reflect the point spread function of glast . in the right portion of each of the left frames ,
we show the current measurements ( error bars ) from the hess experiment and , as a dotted line , the extrapolated power - law spectrum corresponding to this astrophysical background .
the dark matter annihilation spectra are shown separately and combined with this background .
error bars projected for five years of glast operation are also shown for the lightest wimp s mass in each frame .
+ + + + from these results , it is clear that significant departures from the background power - law spectrum could be identified by glast in many of the cases shown . in particular , relatively light wimps annihilating mostly to gauge bosons or bottom quarks generate especially distinctive signatures .
even if only the observations of the inner @xmath56 sr are considered , we find that wimps annihilating largely to gauge bosons or heavy quarks will be identifiable by glast with high precision ( 5@xmath3 ) if they are lighter than approximately 320 - 500 gev and be detected with 3@xmath3 or greater significance if lighter than 500 - 750 gev .
if observations at angles away from the galactic center are also considered , much heavier wimps can also be identified .
annihilations to tau pairs are somewhat more difficult to observe , but are still well within the reach of glast . annihilations to muons or electrons are , in contrast , unlikely to be detected by glast .
the reasons for this conclusion are two fold .
firstly , annihilations to light leptons generate fewer gamma rays than other modes , especially at low to moderate energies ( see fig .
[ spectra ] ) .
additionally , as can be seen from fig . [ sigma ] , annihilations to light leptons produce a larger flux of energetic electrons and positrons , and therefore require a smaller annihilation cross section to produce the observed intensity of the wmap haze .
there are a number of astrophysical assumptions which we have adopted throughout our calculations .
firstly , we have adopted the dark matter halo profile described by eq .
[ 1pt2 ] , which was found in ref .
@xcite to fit the angular distribution of the wmap haze .
as we have seen , the dark matter distribution in the most inner galaxy ( within @xmath57 parsecs of the gc ) is the most relevant for dark matter searches using gamma rays .
the dark matter density in the inner parsecs is only indirectly constrained by the wmap haze data , which is limited to angles greater than 6@xmath2 from the gc ( at angles within a few degrees of the galactic center , the microwave foregrounds are too complicated to facilitate a robust measurement of the haze ) .
the signal to be observed by glast depends critically on the slope of the halo profile at distances from the gc far smaller than the 900 parsecs which corresponds to 6@xmath2 .
dark matter annihilations which occur in the inner parsecs of our galaxy , however , produce electrons and positrons which diffuse over kiloparsec scales as they generate the haze
. therefore , at an angle of 6@xmath2 , the intensity of the wmap haze provides us with a measure of the overall annihilation rate in the inner kiloparsecs of the milky way .
in fact , using a halo profile which scales as @xmath6 , more than 60% of the annihilation power in the inner two kiloparsecs comes from within 100 parsecs of the gc .
therefore , if the the slope of the halo profile were to significantly flatten in the region most important to glast , the angular distribution of the intensity of the wmap haze would also be effected .
secondly , our results depend somewhat on the treatment of the propagation of electrons and positrons in the inner galaxy . in ref .
@xcite , the diffusion - loss equation was solved using specific values of the diffusion constant , energy loss rate and diffusion zone boundary conditions : @xmath58 @xmath23/s , @xmath59 s@xmath60 and a slab of half - width 3 kiloparsecs , respectively ( see also ref .
@xcite ) . as the characteristics of the magnetic and radiation fields in the inner galaxy
are not well known , significant variation of these parameters from these values is certainly possible .
variations in the diffusion parameters could potentially modify the angular distribution , spectrum and intensity of the synchrotron emission from dark matter annihilation products .
although it is somewhat difficult to estimate the range of values these parameters could plausibly take , it seems highly unlikely that the true values are more than a factor of a few different from those used here .
if both the diffusion constant and energy loss rate were increased by a factor of a few , it would have the same effect of reducing the annihilation rate by the same factor .
this would unlikely change the overall conclusions of our study .
thirdly , astrophysical gamma ray backgrounds other than the hess source discussed earlier are likely to exist in the inner degree surrounding the galactic center . in particular , an unidentified egret source is known to be present approximately 0.2@xmath2 from the galactic center @xcite .
the angular windows around such point sources could be subtracted from the glast spectrum , however .
alternatively , an energy cut could be made on the glast data to reduce the impact of such backgrounds .
if the wmap haze is , in fact , synchrotron emission from relativistic electrons and positrons produced in dark matter annihilations , then other annihilation products are likely to be potentially observable as well .
in particular , gamma rays from dark matter annihilations in the inner parsecs of the milky way are potentially within the reach of the upcoming satellite - based gamma ray telescope glast . in this article
, we study the prospects for glast to detect gamma rays from dark matter annihilations in the inner galaxy , assuming that such annihilations are also responsible for the observed microwave excess known as the wmap haze .
we find that if the dark matter particles annihilate largely to heavy fermions , or gauge or higgs bosons , then their gamma ray spectrum should be easily identified by glast .
only if dark matter annihilations proceed largely to muons or electrons will such a detection not be possible .
it is also interesting to note that the planck satellite is expected to begin its mission in 2008 . with its much broader frequency coverage
, planck will be capable of determining the properties of the wmap haze with much greater precision .
the combined scrutiny of glast and planck should clearly resolve the nature of the haze and determine whether it is of dark matter origin once and for all .
dh is supported by the us department of energy and by nasa grant nag5 - 10842 .
df and gb are partially supported by nasa grant nags-12972 .
discussions of the inverse compton signal with nikhil padmanabhan were helpful .
d. p. finkbeiner , arxiv : astro - ph/0409027 .
d. hooper , d. p. finkbeiner and g. dobler , arxiv:0705.3655 [ astro - ph ] .
g. bertone , e. nezri , j. orloff and j. silk , phys .
d * 70 * , 063503 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0403322 ] .
l. bergstrom , j. edsjo and p. gondolo , phys .
d * 55 * , 1765 ( 1997 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9607237 ] ; phys .
d * 58 * , 103519 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9806293 ] ; v. d. barger , f. halzen , d. hooper and c. kao , phys .
d * 65 * , 075022 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0105182 ]
. m. longair , _ high energy astrophysics _ , vol .
2 , cambridge university press , cambridge ( 1981 ) .
e. a. baltz and l. wai , phys .
d * 70 * , 023512 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0403528 ] ; s. colafrancesco , s. profumo and p. ullio , astron .
astrophys . * 455 * , 21 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0507575 ] ; l. bergstrom , m. fairbairn and l. pieri , phys .
d * 74 * , 123515 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0607327 ] .
t. a. porter and a. w. strong , proc .
of the 29th international cosmic ray conference , pune , india ( 2005 ) , arxiv : astro - ph/0507119 .
n. gehrels and p. michelson , astropart .
* 11 * , 277 ( 1999 ) ; s. peirani , r. mohayaee and j. a. de freitas pacheco , phys .
d * 70 * , 043503 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0401378 ] ; a. cesarini , f. fucito , a. lionetto , a. morselli and p. ullio , astropart .
* 21 * , 267 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0305075 ] .
l. bergstrom , p. ullio and j. h. buckley , astropart .
* 9 * , 137 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/9712318 ] ; l. bergstrom , j. edsjo and p. ullio , phys .
lett . * 87 * , 251301 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0105048 ] ; v. berezinsky , a. bottino and g. mignola , phys .
b * 325 * , 136 ( 1994 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9402215 ] ; a. cesarini , f. fucito , a. lionetto , a. morselli and p. ullio , astropart .
* 21 * , 267 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0305075 ] ; p. ullio , l. bergstrom , j. edsjo and c. g. lacey , phys .
d * 66 * , 123502 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0207125 ] .
g. jungman , m. kamionkowski and k. griest , phys .
rept . * 267 * , 195 ( 1996 ) .
g. servant and t. m. p. tait , nucl .
b * 650 * , 391 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0206071 ] ; h. c. cheng , j. l. feng and k. t. matchev , phys .
lett . * 89 * , 211301 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0207125 ] ; d. hooper and s. profumo , phys .
, in press , arxiv : hep - ph/0701197 . b. a. dobrescu , d. hooper , k. kong and r. mahbubani , arxiv:0706.3409 [ hep - ph ] . j. f. navarro , c. s. frenk and s. d. m. white , astrophys .
j. * 462 * , 563 ( 1996 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/9508025 ] ; j. f. navarro , c. s. frenk and s. d. m. white , astrophys .
j. * 490 * , 493 ( 1997 ) .
f. prada , a. klypin , j. flix , m. martinez and e. simonneau , arxiv : astro - ph/0401512 ; g. bertone and d. merritt , mod .
a * 20 * , 1021 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0504422 ] ; g. bertone and d. merritt , phys .
d * 72 * , 103502 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0501555 ] .
k. kosack _ et al . _
[ the veritas collaboration ] , astrophys .
j. * 608 * , l97 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0403422 ] .
j. albert _ et al . _
[ magic collaboration ] , astrophys .
j. * 638 * , l101 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0512469 ] . k. tsuchiya _ et al .
_ [ cangaroo - ii collaboration ] , astrophys .
j. * 606 * , l115 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0403592 ] .
d. hooper and j. march - russell , phys .
b * 608 * , 17 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0412048 ] ; d. hooper , i. de la calle perez , j. silk , f. ferrer and s. sarkar , jcap * 0409 * , 002 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0404205 ] ; s. profumo , phys .
d * 72 * , 103521 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0508628 ] ; l. bergstrom , t. bringmann , m. eriksson and m. gustafsson , phys .
lett . * 94 * , 131301 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0410359 ] .
f. aharonian and a. neronov , astrophys .
j. * 619 * , 306 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0408303 ] ; arxiv : astro - ph/0503354 ; aip conf . proc . * 745 * , 409 ( 2005 ) ; a. atoyan and c. d. dermer , astrophys . j. * 617 * , l123 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0410243 ] . i. v. moskalenko and a. w. strong , phys .
d * 60 * , 063003 ( 1999 ) ; e. a. baltz and j. edsjo , phys .
d * 59 * ( 1999 ) 023511 ; s. profumo and p. ullio , jcap
* 0407 * , 006 ( 2004 ) ; d. hooper and j. silk , phys .
d * 71 * , 083503 ( 2005 ) .
d. hooper and b. l. dingus , phys .
d * 70 * , 113007 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0210617 ] ; d. hooper and b. dingus , proc . of the 34th cospar scientific assembly , houston , texas ( 2002 ) , arxiv : astro - ph/0212509 . | observations by the wmap experiment have identified an excess of microwave emission from the center of the milky way . it has previously been shown that this `` wmap haze '' could be synchrotron emission from relativistic electrons and positrons produced in the annihilations of dark matter particles . in particular , the intensity , spectrum and angular distribution of the wmap haze is consistent with an electroweak scale dark matter particle ( such as a supersymmetric neutralino or kaluza - klein dark matter in models with universal extra dimensions ) annihilating with a cross section on the order of @xmath0 @xmath1/s and distributed with a cusped halo profile .
no further exotic astrophysical or annihilation boost factors are required .
if dark matter annihilations are in fact responsible for the observed haze , then other annihilation products will also be produced , including gamma rays . in this article
, we study the prospects for the glast satellite to detect gamma rays from dark matter annihilations in the galactic center region in this scenario .
we find that by studying _ only _ the inner 0.1@xmath2 around the galactic center , glast will be able to detect dark matter annihilating to heavy quarks or gauge bosons over astrophysical backgrounds with 5@xmath3 ( @xmath4 ) significance if they are lighter than approximately 320 - 500 gev ( 500 - 750 gev ) .
if the angular window is broadened to study the dark matter halo profile s angular extension ( while simultaneously reducing the astrophysical backgrounds ) , wimps as heavy as several tev can be identified by glast with high significance .
only if the dark matter particles annihilate mostly to electrons or muons will glast be unable to identify the gamma ray spectrum associated with the wmap haze . |
valuable information about globular clusters and galaxy formation can be obtained by investigating the extent to which the properties of globular clusters belonging to different galaxies are similar .
for example , differences in initial mass function during cluster formation and/or in susbsequent cluster dynamical evolution , which may both depend on galactic environment , would translate into differences in present - day stellar content .
the globular cluster stellar content can be characterized by the mass - to - light ( @xmath2 ) ratio , which can now be determined for relatively remote globular clusters . collecting all the available data from the literature , pryor & meylan ( 1993 ) derive @xmath1 ratios for 56 galactic globular clusters using king - michie dynamical models .
they obtain _ global _
@xmath1 ratios ranging from about 1 to 5 with a mean of 2.3 ( in solar units ) , and found no significant correlations ( apart from a possible weak one between @xmath1 and cluster mass ) between the _ global _ @xmath1 ratios and other parameters such as metallicity , concentration , half - mass relaxation time , or distance from either the galactic center or the galactic plane .
@xmath1 ratios similar to those obtained for galactic clusters have been obtained in studies of globular clusters belonging to the magellanic clouds ( dubath et al .
1996b ) and to the fornax dwarf spheroidal galaxy ( dubath et al .
1992 ) .
another way of investigating globular cluster similarities , in terms of structure and @xmath1 ratio , is to look at the correlations between velocity dispersion , luminosity and a physical size scale .
these correlations , which are analogous to the fundamental plane correlations for elliptical galaxies , have already been discussed for galactic clusters by several authors ( e.g. , meylan & mayor 1986 , paturel & garnier 1992 , djorgovski & meylan 1994 , djorgovski 1995 ) .
the tight correlation between the velocity dispersion , the core radius and the central surface brightness obtained for galactic clusters ( djorgovski 1995 ) is consistent with expectations from the virial theorem assuming that galactic globular cluster cores have a universal and constant @xmath1 ratio to within the measurement errors .
because of its relative proximity and large size , the m31 globular cluster system is an obvious target for the study of extragalactic clusters .
previous studies of various aspects of the m31 globular cluster system have been reviewed by fusi pecci et al .
( 1993 ) , huchra ( 1993 ) , tripicco ( 1993 ) , and cohen ( 1993 ) .
the only velocity - dispersion determinations of m31 clusters published so far are by peterson ( 1988 ) .
corresponding @xmath1 ratio estimates are given for two clusters and are found to be similar to those typically obtained for galactic clusters .
a limitation in this work , however , arises from the difficulty of measuring m31 cluster structural parameters from the ground . in m31
the angular sizes of core and half - light radii are typically @xmath002 and @xmath01 , respectively . in this work ,
we present new velocity dispersion and @xmath1 ratio determinations for a sample of m31 globular clusters , for which structural parameters derived from hst observations are available in the literature .
the @xmath1 ratio estimates are based on simple relations derived from the virial theorem and from king models .
our velocity dispersion estimates are also key observational constraints for more detailed dynamical analyses , e.g. , based on fokker - plank or king - michie multi - mass models , which are beyond the scope of this paper . the spectroscopic observations and the data reduction are presented in sect . 2 .
numerical simulations used for deriving velocity dispersions from the integrated - light spectra and the corresponding results are described in sect .
section 4 discusses the structural parameters , and @xmath1 estimates are given in sect .
the relations between velocity dispersion , luminosity and different physical scales are discussed in sect . 6 for our m31 cluster sample together with samples of clusters belonging to the galaxy , the magellanic clouds , the fornax dwarf spheroidal galaxy , and centarus a. we summarize our findings in sect .
we obtained 12 high - resolution integrated - light spectra of 10 globular clusters belonging to m31 .
the observations were made september 9 - 11 , 1994 ( see table [ tabsig ] ) , with the hamilton echelle spectrograph ( vogt 1987 ) operated at the coud focus of the 3-m shane telescope of the lick observatory .
the detector was a thinned , backside - illuminated ti ccd , with 800 800 pixels of 15 15 @xmath3 m each , and with a readout noise of about 6 electrons . during the first night , a relatively wide entrance slit of 20 50 was used to match poor seeing conditions .
a slit of 15 50 was used during the second and the third nights . as a consequence ,
the instrumental resolution , as estimated from the fwhm of the emission lines of thorium calibration spectra , was slightly lower during the first night ( 31000 or 9.7 ) than during the second and the third ones ( 35000 or 8.6 ) .
both slits used have widths larger than the apparent half - light radii ( see table [ tabmol ] ) of all our clusters .
table [ tabsig ] gives the date of the observations , the exposure time ( texp ) and the signal - to - noise ( s / n ) ratio of the cluster spectra . during each observing night
, many radial velocity standard stars were also measured .
spectra of a thorium - argon lamp were taken 6 - 8 times through each of the three nights .
the spectra were reduced with inter - tacos , a new software package developed in geneva by d. queloz and l. weber .
the first - night spectra contain 50 useful orders ranging from 4800 to 8300 , and those obtain the second and third night contain 49 orders ranging from 4600 to 7500 .
the different orders do not overlap , i.e. , the echelle spectra exhibit holes in the wavelength coverage .
the orders are never rebinned , nor merged together .
the shifts in velocity between the different thorium - argon lamp spectra taken during one particular night are always smaller than 1 .
however , a velocity shift as large as 5 is observed between the second and the third nights . as a first step , for each night ,
one wavelength solution is computed from a thorium - argon spectrum , and applied to all the spectra taken during that particular night .
the cluster spectra also contain numerous strong night - sky oh and o2 emission lines , because of the long exposure time on relatively faint objects .
the residual velocity zero - point shift of each globular cluster spectrum is then derived by measuring the mean shift ( in velocity ) of the emission lines compared to their accurate rest wavelengths ( taken from osterbrock et al .
1996 ) . as a second step of the wavelength calibration , all the _ globular cluster _
spectra are corrected according to these velocity zero - point shifts .
the reduced spectra are cross - correlated with an optimized numerical mask , used as a template ( see dubath et al .
1990 for the details of the cross - correlation technique ) .
in short , our template contains lower and upper wavelength limits for each line from a selected sample of narrow spectral lines . for a particular radial velocity ,
the value of the cross - correlation function ( ccf ) is given by the sum , over all spectral lines , of the integral of the considered spectrum within the lower and the upper line limits shifted according to the given velocity .
the ccf is thus built step by step over the velocity range of interest .
the ccf is not affected by the fact that the spectra are composed of a succession of independent orders , with holes in the wavelength coverage .
the ccf is a kind of mean spectral line over the approximately 1400 useful lines spread over the spectral ranges of the different orders .
the lower and upper limits of the lines are computed from a mix of observed and theoretical high - resolution spectra of k2 giants , in such a way as to optimize the ccf ( see dubath et al.1996a ) . when the number of considered lines is large enough ( @xmath4 several hundreds ) , this cross - correlation technique produces a ccf which is nearly a perfect gaussian .
a gaussian function is fitted to each derived ccf in order to determine three physical quantities : ( 1 ) the location of the minimum equal to the radial velocity , ( 2 ) its depth @xmath5 , and ( 3 ) its standard deviation , related to line broadening mechanisms .
figure [ ccf ] displays the ccfs of the integrated - light spectra obtained for the m31 globular clusters in our sample .
we have a total of 32 measurements of 11 standard stars , mostly giant stars of spectral type g8 to k4 , collected during the same observing run .
the comparison of the standard - star radial velocities with reference values provided by coravel measurements ( mayor , private communication ) shows that the instrumental radial velocity accuracy is of order 0.5 and that the zero - point shift between the two datasets is not significant . in the case of the m31 clusters ,
the accuracy of the radial velocity zero - point is very probably even better owing to our use of the night - sky emission lines to calibrate the zero point of each cluster spectrum .
the mean value of the widths ( ) of the ccfs obtained for our sample of standard stars is 5.80.3 for the first night , and 5.50.2 for the two others .
this difference is the direct consequence of the different slit widths used .
we see no dependence of the ccf width on spectral type over the range considered here ( g8 to k4 ) .
we also know that the ccf width does not depend on the star metallicity from previous measurements of a large number of various types of metal - deficient stars ( see fig .
6 of dubath et al .
the _ projected _ velocity dispersions can be derived from the broadening of the cluster ccfs .
this broadening results from the doppler line broadening present in the integrated - light spectra because of the random spatial motions of the stars .
since the spectrograph slit used is large compared to the the m31 globular clusters apparent size , a very large number of stars contributes significantly to the integrated light .
quantitatively , recent numerical simulations ( dubath et al . 1994 , 1996a ) show that statistical errors , which can be very important for integrated - light measurements of some galactic globular clusters because of the dominance of a few bright stars , are negligible in the present case .
an integrated light spectrum of an m31 globular cluster is well approximated by the convolution of the spectrum of a typical globular cluster star with the projected velocity distribution .
since the ccf is a kind of mean spectral line , the above property also hold for ccfs .
the ccf of an integrated - light spectrum of a globular cluster is the convolution of the ccf of the spectrum of a typical globular cluster star by the projected velocity distribution .
since the ccfs have a gaussian shape , an estimate of the projected velocity dispersion in the integration area of a globular cluster is given by the quadratic difference , @xmath6 where is the width of the gaussian fitted to the cluster ccf and is the average width of the obtained for a sample of standard stars , as representative as possible of the cluster stars which contribute most to the integrated light .
we do not use this formula directly in the present study . in order to derive the cluster projected velocity dispersion ,
we carry out a large number of numerical simulations .
the results of these simulations confirm , however , the validity of eq . [ sigest ]
( see sect . [ gene ] ) . in order to simulate the integrated - light spectrum and the ccf obtained for globular cluster , we proceed in several steps . in the first row of fig .
[ simuill ] , the integrated - light spectrum ( left ) and the ccf ( right ) obtained for the cluster bo 218 are displayed .
corresponding simulation results are displayed in the last row , while the intermediate steps of the simulation are illustrated in the middle row of this figure .
the simulation input parameter is the cluster velocity dispersion ( ) .
the simulation starts with a high signal - to - noise spectrum of a standard star of appropriate spectral type , e.g. , a k2 giant . to simulate the doppler line broadening ,
this spectrum is convolved with a gaussian function of standard deviation equal to the input velocity dispersion .
a portion of the standard - star spectrum , before and after convolution , is shown in the panel ( c ) of fig .
[ simuill ] . \2 . in general
, the spectral lines of the convolved standard - star spectrum do not have the same depths as those of a given cluster spectrum , mainly because of possible metallicity difference .
the next step is thus to adjust the depth of the standard - star spectral lines .
this is done by scaling the convolved standard - star spectrum so that its ccf is of the same depth as the cluster ccf .
( with our cross - correlation technique , there is a clear relationship between the average depth of the spectral lines of a spectrum and the depth of the spectrum ccf ) . in fig .
[ simuill ] for example , the spectra and the ccfs displayed in the middle row are linearly scaled so that the convolved spectrum ccf ( the broad ccf in panel d ) be of the same depth as the cluster ccf ( in panel b ) .
a noiseless template of a cluster spectrum for one particular velocity dispersion results from the second step .
random noise is added to this template spectrum to simulate the photon counting and ccd readout noises of observed cluster spectra .
a portion of the template spectrum for bo 218 ( c ) and of one example of simulated noisy spectrum are displayed in panel ( e ) of fig .
[ simuill ] .
we then cross - correlate the simulated noisy spectrum and derive the radial velocity ( ) and the sigma ( ) of the resulting ccf .
this third step is repeated a large number of times ( 100 to 150 times ) to observe the influence of the noise on and .
panel ( f ) of fig .
[ simuill ] shows three examples of simulated ccfs taken at random .
the comparison of the upper and the lower panels of this figure shows how well our simulations reproduce the integrated - light spectrum and the ccf obtained for bo 218 . in order to derive the best estimates of the projected velocity dispersion ( ) in the clusters , we proceed as follows . for each cluster , a set of different input velocity dispersions ( ) , varying by step of 0.5 or 1 around the expected cluster `` true '' velocity dispersion ( first evaluated with eq .
[ sigest ] ) are considered . for each ,
100 or 150 simulations are carried out and the relative number of times that the width of the simulated ccfs is consistent with the width of the observed ccf is reported .
consistent means here that the sigma of the simulated ccf must be within 0.2 - 0.5 ( depending on the different cases ) of the sigma of the observed ccf .
figure [ simudis ] shows , in the case of bo 218 , the distribution of these numbers as a function of the input velocity dispersions ( ) of the simulations .
this distribution is a kind of probability distribution ; the best estimate of the `` true '' cluster velocity dispersion is given by the which leads most often , through the simulations , to a ccf consistent with the observed one .
for example , among 100 simulations carried out with = 16 , 47 have a width consistent with the width of the observed ccf obtained for bo 218 , while none of the 100 simulations with = 13 is successful in reproducing the observed ccf .
a similar distribution is derived for each cluster , and a gaussian is fitted to each of them . the resulting means and sigmas , which provide the most probable cluster velocity dispersions ( ) and their uncertainties , are given in column ( 11 ) of table [ tabsig ] .
this section presents a generalization of the simulation results ( which can be skipped by less concerned readers ) . for each of the 9 clusters ,
simulations are carried out for a set of input velocity dispersions ( ) . in the simulations , a particular cluster is characterized by the spectrum s / n ratio and by the depth ( @xmath5 ) of the cluster ccf . therefore in general ,
the input parameters are the spectrum s / n , the ccf depth @xmath5 , and the input velocity dispersion . for each set of input parameters ,
100 to 150 simulated ccfs are computed , and distributions of the resulting radial velocities and ccf sigmas are thus produced .
the standard deviations of these distributions @xmath7 ( ) for the radial velocities and @xmath7 ( ) for the sigmas provide estimates of the uncertainties due to the spectrum noise . the following formula
, @xmath8 where @xmath9 and @xmath10 are two constants , is fitted to the results of the simulations . with @xmath11 and @xmath12 ,
this equation gives in , ( 1 ) @xmath7 ( ) with an accuracy of order of 10% , and ( 2 ) @xmath7 ( ) ) with an accuracy of about 20% .
it can then be used to estimated the uncertainties due to the spectrum noise in a more general way , for any set of parameters s / n , @xmath5 , and .
equation [ epsi ] is a generalization of eq .
( 3 ) of dubath et al . ( 1990 ) to broad ccfs .
the constant @xmath9 is lower in the present paper than in this previous study because the larger wavelength range , and consequently larger number of spectral lines , taken into account in the cross - correlation process ( @xmath9 scales roughly with the square root of the number of lines ) .
figure [ simusig ] displays , for each cluster , the sigma ( ) of the ccfs of the observed spectrum as a function of the corresponding estimates of the velocity dispersion ( ) resulting from the simulations .
( [ sigest ] ) is illustrated in this figure by the continuous line , and the good agreement with the simulation results indicates that this equation is a valid model .
rrcccrrrcrr & & [ fe / h ] & date & & s / n & & @xmath5 & & + & & & 94 sept . & & & & ( % ) & & + ( 1)&(2 ) & ( 3 ) & ( 4 ) & ( 5 ) & & ( 7 ) & & ( 9 ) & & + 6 & 58 & 15.8 & @xmath130.57 & 9 & 100 & 13 & @xmath13236.90.2 & 4.9 & 12.10.3 & 10.60.4 + 20 & 73 & 14.6 & @xmath131.07 & 11 & 100 & 18 & @xmath13350.80.3 & 3.2 & 16.20.4 & 15.30.5 + 45 & 108 & 15.8 & @xmath130.94 & 9 & 85 & 11 & @xmath13425.10.3 & 3.9 & 10.40.4 & 8.70.5 + 147 & 199 & 15.5 & @xmath130.24 & 11 & 80 & 26 & @xmath1350.70.1 & 7.3 & 6.00.3 & star ? + 158 & 213 & 14.5 & @xmath131.08 & 10 & 50 & 10 & @xmath13186.51.0 & 2.1 & 22.21.1 & 21.91.3 + 218 & 272 & 14.7 & @xmath131.18 & 11 & 50 & 11 & @xmath13220.20.6 & 2.7 & 17.20.7 & 16.30.8 + 225 & 280 & 14.3 & @xmath130.70 & 9 & 120 & 31 & @xmath13164.80.3 & 2.8 & 26.50.4 & 26.90.5 + 343 & 105 & 16.3 & @xmath131.49 & 11 & 100 & 8 & @xmath13359.61.7 & 1.1 & 11.31.7 & 10.21.7 + " & " & " & " & 10 & 63 & 4 & @xmath13357.54.0 & 0.7 & 7.74.1 & ... + 358 & 219 & 15.1 & @xmath131.83 & 10 & 90 & 12 & @xmath13315.11.8 & 0.6 & 8.81.8 & 7.11.8 + " & " & " & " & 9 & 50 & 6 & @xmath13317.53.1 & 0.8 & 12.03.1 & ... + 384 & 319 & 15.7 & @xmath130.66 & 11 & 100 & 10 & @xmath13363.80.3 & 4.4 & 10.50.4 & 9.10.5 + [ tabsig ] for each observation , table [ tabsig ] lists the cluster identification from battistini et al .
( 1980 ) in column ( 1 ) , and from sargent et al .
( 1977 ) in column ( 2 ) , the cluster apparent v magnitude in column ( 3 ) , the cluster [ fe / h ] in column ( 4 ) , the date of the observation in column ( 5 ) , the exposure time in column ( 6 ) , the signal - to - noise ratio of the integrated - light spectrum in column ( 7 ) , the heliocentric radial velocity in column ( 8) , the depth of the ccf in column ( 9 ) , the sigma of the ccf in column ( 10 ) , and the projected velocity dispersion in column ( 11 ) . the cluster apparent v magnitudes are taken from battistini et al . ( 1987 ) , and [ fe / h ] are taken from huchra et al .
( 1991 ) .
the radial velocity errors given in column ( 8) of table [ tabsig ] are computed using eq .
( [ epsi ] ) .
this equation provides an estimate of the error due to the spectrum noise ( photon counting and ccd readout noises ) but does not take into account the uncertainty of the zero - point corrections computed from measurements of the night - sky emission lines .
consequently , the radial velocity errors smaller than @xmath00.3 are probably underestimated .
the errors given in column ( 8) of table [ tabsig ] are the square root of the quadratic sum of the errors due to the noise ( estimated using eq .
( [ epsi ] ) ) , and of an instrumental error of 0.25 , derived from standard - star measurements .
two cluster spectra are too noisy to provide useful velocity dispersion estimate .
the ccf obtained for bo 147 is as narrow as the ccfs obtained for individual standard stars , and much narrower that the value expected from its absolute magnitude .
consequently , bo 147 is almost certainly a foreground star .
rrccccccccc & @xmath14 & @xmath15 & @xmath16 & m@xmath17 & @xmath18 & @xmath19 & e(b - v ) & @xmath1 & @xmath20 + & pc & pc & & & m@xmath21 & m@xmath21 & & m@xmath22l@xmath23 & m@xmath22l@xmath23 + ( 1)&(2 ) & ( 3 ) & ( 4 ) & ( 5 ) & ( 6 ) & ( 7 ) & ( 8) & ( 9 ) & ( 10 ) & ( 11 ) + 6 & 58 & 0.62 & 2.8 & 1.76 & -9.0 & @xmath24 & @xmath25 & 0.11 & 1.4 & 2.2 + 20 & 73 & 1.18 & 4.7 & 1.71 & -10.2 & @xmath26 & @xmath27 & 0.11 & 1.7 & 2.5 + 45 & 108 & 0.92 & 3.6 & 1.70 & -9.0 & @xmath28 & @xmath29 & 0.12 & 1.2 & 1.8 + 158 & 213 & 1.54 & 5.0 & 1.59 & -10.2 & @xmath30 & @xmath31 & 0.08 & 3.7 & 5.5 + 218 & 272 & 0.47 & 2.0 & 1.74 & -10.0 & @xmath32 & @xmath33 & 0.09 & 0.9 & 1.4 + 225 & 280 & 1.42 & 4.9 & 1.63 & -10.4 & @xmath34 & @xmath35 & 0.09 & 4.4 & 6.5 + 343 & 105 & 0.34 & 2.9 & 2.02 & -8.3 & @xmath36 & @xmath37 & 0.06 & 2.1 & 4.0 + 358 & 219 & 1.82 & 4.7 & 1.46 & -9.5 & @xmath38 & @xmath39 & 0.06 & 0.7 & 1.0 + 384 & 319 & 0.57 & 2.2 & 1.69 & -8.9 & @xmath40 & @xmath41 & 0.06 & 0.9 & 1.4 + [ tabmol ] m31 is at a distance where the core radii of typical globular clusters are considerably smaller in angular size than the typical , ground - based seeing disk .
this makes measurements of @xmath14 difficult , as attested to by the large range of values obtained by different authors for the same clusters .
fortunately , six of the clusters in our sample have recently been observed with the hubble space telescope ( hst ) , and accurate values of @xmath14 have been published ( fusi - pecci 1994 [ bo218 , 384 ] ; grillmair 1996 [ bo6 , 45 , 343 , 358 ] ) .
the values obtained span a large range but are typical for the brighter globulars in our own galaxy . for the remaining 3 clusters in table 1 ,
we use the ground - based measurements of battistini ( 1982 ) and crampton ( 1985 ) . for two clusters ( bo6 , 45 ) common to all three samples , the agreement between the ground - based values and those measured by grillmair is typically quite good , with the worst cases differing by no more than 30% .
the surface density profiles of these clusters have also been difficult to characterize from the ground owing the very low surface brightness relative to the m31 background and the inability to resolve individual stars .
however with the advent of hst we now know that globular clusters in m31 are structurally similar to those found in our own galaxy .
these clusters can generally be characterized by king models , though departures from king models in the form of collapsed cores ( bo343 , bendinelli 1993 ; grillmair 1996 ) and tidal tails ( bo6 , 343 , 358 , grillmair 1996 ) have also been found . in all respects
, it seems that globular clusters in m31 as a group are of the same breed as the clusters belonging to our own galaxy . for the clusters observed by grillmair ( 1996 ) , we have determined the half - light radii @xmath15 ( the radii within which half the total light of the clusters is contained in projection ) by integrating over king models with appropriate core radii and concentration parameters ( @xmath42 ) . for the 2 clusters observed by fusi pecci ( 1994 )
we have used their core and half - light radii and integrated over a grid of king models to infer the corresponding concentration parameter .
for the three clusters for which we have only ground - based measurements of @xmath14 , we follow battistini ( 1982 ) in assuming a uniform value of @xmath43pc . our adopted values of @xmath14 and @xmath15 are tabulated in table 2 . in all cases , the published values of @xmath14 have been scaled in accordance with our adopted distance to m31 of 770kpc ( ajhar 1996 ) .
if we assume that the clusters are reasonably well represented by king models then , following queloz ( 1995 ) , we can compute the total mass using @xmath44 values of @xmath45 , and @xmath46 have been tabulated for a range of concentration parameters by king ( 1966 ) and peterson & king ( 1975 ) .
the @xmath47 in eq .
[ mass ] refers to the _ central _ velocity dispersion of the cluster .
given the small angular size of the clusters and our use of 1.5 and 2.0 arcsecond - wide slits , it is clear that our dispersion measurements will have been influenced by light from moderately large radii .
we tested the effect of our slit - widths on the measured velocity dispersions by integrating luminosity - weighted , king model velocity dispersion profiles over the area subtended by our slit .
we found that , over a large range in @xmath16 , and for both slit - widths used , the measured velocity dispersion would be lower than the central velocity dispersion by about 5% .
hence , for the purposes of computing masses , we increased the measured dispersions in table [ tabsig ] accordingly .
the resulting cluster masses we obtain using eq .
[ mass ] are listed in column 7 of table [ tabmol ] .
an alternative to the somewhat model - specific method used above is a straightforward application of the virial theorem : @xmath48 where we have assumed an isotropic velocity distribution and @xmath49 ( spitzer 1987 ) , where @xmath50 is the half - mass radius . the masses computed using this equation are given in column 8 of table [ tabmol ] .
owing to m31 s low galactic latitude , obscuration of the globular clusters by foreground galactic dust varies significantly from one side of m31 to the other . using the extinction maps of burstein & heiles ( 1982 ) , e(b - v )
was estimated for each cluster and is given in column 9 of table [ tabmol ] . using the @xmath51-magnitudes given by battistini ( 1987 ) , we adopt @xmath52 = 3.2 e(b - v ) ( dacosta & armandroff 1990 ) , and @xmath53 to compute total cluster @xmath51-band luminosities .
the corresponding values for @xmath1 are given in column 10 and 11 of table [ tabmol ] .
the @xmath1 ratios given in table [ tabmol ] are remarkably similar to those typically found in galactic globulars ( pryor & meylan 1993 ) .
bo158 and 225 might seem a trifle high , but we note that both these clusters have only ground - based measurements of @xmath14 .
it is entirely possible that these estimates of @xmath14 suffer from incomplete removal of the effects of seeing and are consequently too high .
the largest source of uncertainty in @xmath1 is generally in the estimation of @xmath14 , being of the order of 15% even for the hst - imaged clusters .
uncertainties in the magnitude estimates of battistini , in our estimates of the local extinction , and in the velocity dispersion measurements contribute @xmath54 each to the final uncertainty . bo343 and 358 are exceptions to this general rule , having
reasonably well - measured core radii , but rather less well - determined velocity dispersions .
the formally estimated uncertainties in @xmath1 are @xmath55 for those clusters observed with hst , and probably closer to 50% for those clusters imaged only from the ground .
table [ tabmol ] shows that the @xmath1 ratios derived with eq .
[ virial ] ( column 11 ) are systematically @xmath050% larger than those obtained with eq .
[ mass ] ( column 10 ) .
this gives a rough idea on how model dependent are our estimates .
another way to investigate similarities among different globular cluster populations is to look at the relation between velocity dispersion , luminosity , and a physical size scale . in such a parameter space ,
systematic differences between two systems of globular clusters , in terms of structure or @xmath2 ratio , would result in either different mean relations or in different degrees of scatter about a given relation .
we do not attempt here to derive mean relations through bivariate fits ( e.g. djorgovski 1995 ) as they turn out to be rather unstable because of both the small number of data points as well as the weak correlation between the physical size parameter and the luminosity and velocity dispersion .
instead , we fit to the data the relations expected from the virial theorem , or from the king models . assuming a constant @xmath1 ratio , the virial theorem predicts the relation @xmath56 between the _ global _ velocity dispersion @xmath57 , the half - light radius @xmath15 , and the absolute visual magnitude .
similarly , king models predict @xmath58 where @xmath59 is the _ central _ velocity dispersion , @xmath3 a dimensionless parameter which varies with cluster concentration @xmath16 , @xmath14 the core radius , and the absolute visual magnitude .
figure [ fp ] shows the relations between @xmath60 vs. @xmath61 ( uppermost row of panels ) , @xmath62 vs. @xmath61 ( second row ) , and @xmath63 vs. @xmath61 ( third row ) , for different data sets .
for the galactic clusters we use velocity dispersion measurements based on radial velocities of individual stars , taken from the compilation of pryor and meylan ( 1993 ) .
for the other clusters , we use velocity dispersions derived from integrated - light observations , taken from dubath et al .
( 1996a ) for 8 old magellanic clusters , from dubath et al .
( 1992 ) for 3 clusters belonging to the fornax dwarf spheroidal galaxy , from the present study for 9 m31 clusters , and from dubath ( 1994 ) for 10 centaurus a clusters .
the continuous lines represent the relation @xmath64 ( uppermost row ) , and the relations ( [ virial_2 ] ) and ( [ king_2 ] ) , in the second and third rows respectively , with constants derived by fitting the _ galactic _ cluster data .
the dashed lines show the relations obtained when central velocity dispersions ( extrapolated for these clusters by pryor and meylan [ 1993 ] using king models ) are considered instead of the _ global _ velocity dispersion .
it is worth mentioning that correlations resulting from bivariate fits do not differ much from the relations expected from the virial theorem ( djorgovski 1995 ) , and that fig . [ fp ] would look very similar if slightly different projections were used .
the scatter of the data points probably results to a large extent from measurement errors , and it is quite remarkable that this scatter is of the same order in all panels of fig .
the similarity of the different panels of fig .
[ fp ] indicates both that there is no large systematic differences in globular cluster @xmath1 ratios between one galaxy to another , and that measurement errors are comparable , and even smaller , for extragalactic clusters than for galactic clusters . in the first row of fig .
[ fp ] , we expect a higher degree of scatter since the physical scale of each cluster ( which acts as a second parameter ) is not taken into account .
notably , a few large - size / low - concentration galactic clusters lie well below the other clusters in the upper left panel .
the fact that similar large clusters are not present in our m31 and cen a samples is due to a selection bias which favors brighter and generally more compact clusters . in any case , the relatively small spread of the data points around the straight lines in the uppermost panels points to an additional similarity in terms of physical size range between the clusters of these different galaxies , with the possible exception of the old magellanic clusters .
this is particularly interesting in the case of the centaurus a clusters since these clusters are brighter than the galactic ones , but their physical scales have not yet been measured . for the old magellanic clusters , the products @xmath3 @xmath14 are systematically _ smaller _ than the galactic average .
this can perfectly explain why the magellanic clusters appear above the galactic relation in the upper panel in fig .
[ fp ] , while the magellanic and galactic middle panels are similar .
the lower panel is , however , rather puzzling .
unexpectedly , the data points all lie above the galactic relation , as if the half - light radii used here and taken from van den bergh ( 1994 ) were about 40% too large .
this point is further discussed in another paper ( dubath et al .
1996b ) .
the two m31 clusters ( bo158 & 225 ) with large @xmath1 ratio estimates from last section stand out above the galactic relation in fig . [ fp ] . as already pointed out
, these clusters only have ground - based measurements of @xmath14 which may be overestimates .
the scatter of the other clusters is remarkably small compared to the scatter of galactic clusters . as illustrated in fig .
[ fp ] , the absolute magnitude of an individual globular cluster can be derived from its velocity dispersion and physical scale with an accuracy of @xmath00.5 magnitude . for a given parent galaxy , providing there is no systematic differences in @xmath1 , an accurate distance modulus can in principle be computed using the mean distance modulus of a moderate number ( 10 20 ) of its associated globular clusters . in other word , plotting apparent instead of absolute magnitude in fig .
[ fp ] , the difference between the distance modulii of two parent galaxies is given by the horizontal shift required to bring the two ( dereddened ) data sets in agreement . combining the capabilities of the hst and of 10-m class , ground - based telescopes , this method could be applied for galaxies out as far as the virgo cluster .
in this paper , we present projected velocity dispersion measurements from integrated - light spectra for a sample of 9 m31 globular clusters . by means of comprehensive numerical simulations ,
we show that the typical relative uncertainty of our measurements is @xmath05% . because of the relatively large distance of m31 and the aperture angular size used our integrated - light observations sample a large fraction of these very bright clusters .
consequently , statistical uncertainties due to small samples of bright dominant stars which can affect integrated - light measurements of nearby galactic clusters are completely negligible .
this is confirmed by numerical simulations presented in dubath et al .
( 1996a ) .
paradoxically , it is in some respects easier to measure the _ global _ velocity dispersion of a m31 cluster than that of a galactic clusters .
for the brightest m31 clusters , reliable velocity dispersions can be measured with a 3-m - class telescope using single exposures of order one hour long .
previous velocity dispersion measurements are available from peterson ( 1988 ) for 3 of our clusters .
the agreement is good for the cluster bo20 , while we obtain significantly lower and more accurate values for bo158 and 225 . combining the new velocity dispersions with structural parameters , we compute the cluster @xmath1 ratios using relations derived from king models and the virial theorem .
these @xmath1 ratios appear remarkably similar to those found for galactic clusters ( see e.g. , pryor & meylan 1993 ) .
two clusters ( bo158 & 225 ) having only ground - based measurements of @xmath14 have @xmath1 ratio estimates somewhat above the range of galactic values .
it is entirely possible that these estimates of @xmath14 suffer from incomplete removal of the effects of seeing and are consequently too high .
another way to investigate similarities of globular clusters located in different parent galaxies is to look at the relation between velocity dispersion , luminosity and a physical scale ( fig [ fp ] ) . using additional data from previous papers , we find remarkable similarities , in terms of @xmath1 ratios and structures , between the globular clusters located in our galaxy , the magellanic clouds , the fornax dwarf spheroidal , m31 , and centaurus a. it is worth emphasizing that our samples include some of the brightest m31 and centaurus a clusters , which are both brighter and more massive than any galactic cluster , as expected because of the larger number of clusters in both these galaxies .
our m31 cluster sample is not large enough to investigate possible correlations between the @xmath1 ratio estimates and other cluster parameters .
only a weak correlation is observed with galactic data ( pryor & meylan 1993 ) , and it is possible that the variations of the current @xmath1 estimates from one cluster to another result to a large extent from measurement errors . p.d .
acknowledge support through a grant from the swiss national science foundation .
warmly thanks graeme smith for providing free use of his workstation during a postdoctoral stay at the lick observatory .
ajhar , e.a , grillmair , c.j . , lauer , t.r . ,
baum , w.a . ,
faber , s.m . ,
holtzman , j.a . , lynds , c.r . , &
oneil , e.j .
1996 , aj , 111 , 1110 battistini , p. , bnoli , f. , braccesi , a. , federici , l. , fusi pecci , f. , marano , b. , & borngen , f. 1987 , a&as , 67 , 447 battistini , p. , bnoli , f. , braccesi , a. , fusi pecci , f. , malagnini , m. & marano , b. 1980 , a&as , 42 , 357 battistini , p. , bnoli , f. , buonanno , r. , corsi , c.e . , &
fusi pecci , f. , 1982 , a&a , 113 , 39 bendinelli , o. , cacciari , c. , djorgovski , s. , federici , l , ferraro , f.r . , fusi pecci , f. , parmeggiani , g. , weir , n. , & zavatti , f. 1993 , apj letters , 409 , l17 burstein , d. , & heiles , c. 1982 , aj , 87 , 1165 cohen , j.g .
1993 in asp conf .
48 , the globular cluster galaxy connection , g. smith & j. brodie(san francisco : asp ) , 438 crampton , d. , schade , d.j . ,
chayer , p. , & cowley , a.p .
1985 , apj , 288 , 494 dacosta , g.s .
, & armandroff , t.e .
1990 , aj , 100 , 162 djorgovski , s. , & meylan , g. 1994 , aj , 108 , 1292 djorgovski , s. 1995 , apjl , 438 , l29 dubath , p. 1994 ,
baas , 185 , 5203 dubath , p. , meylan , g. , mayor , m. , & magain , p. 1990 , a&a , 239 , 142 dubath , p. , meylan , g. , & mayor , m. 1992 , apj , 400 , 510 dubath , p. , meylan , g. , & mayor , m. 1994 , apj , 426 , 192 dubath , p. , meylan , g. , & mayor , m. 1996a , a&a , in press dubath , p. , meylan , g. , & mayor , m. 1996b , a&a , submitted fusi pecci , f. , cacciari , c. , federici , l. , & pasquali , a. 1993 , in asp conf .
48 , the globular cluster galaxy connection , g. smith & j. brodie(san francisco : asp ) , 410 fusi pecci , f. , battistini , p. , bendinelli , o. , bonoli , f. , cacciari , c. , djorgovski , s. , federici , l. , ferraro , f.r . ,
parmeggiani , g. , weir , n. , & zavatti , f. 1994 , a&a , 284 , 349 grillmair , c.j . ,
ajhar , e.a . ,
faber , s.m . ,
baum , w.a . ,
holtzman , j.a . ,
lauer , t.r .
, lynds , c.r . , &
oneil , e.j .
1996 , aj , 111 , 2293 huchra , j. 1993 , in asp conf . ser .
48 , the globular cluster galaxy connection , g. smith & j. brodie(san francisco : asp ) , 420 huchra , j. , brodie , j.p . , &
kent , s.m .
1991 , apj , 370 , 495 king , i.r . 1966 , aj , 71,64 meylan , g. , & mayor , m. 1986 , a&a , 166 , 122 osterbrock , d.e . ,
fulbright , j.p . ,
martel , a.r . ,
keane , m.j . , trager , s.c . , & basri , g. 1996 , pasp , 108 , 277 paturel , g. , & garnier , r. 1992 , a&a , 254 , 93 peterson , c.j . , & king , i.r .
1975 , aj , 80 , 427 peterson , r. 1988 , in dynamique of dense stellar system , ed .
d. merritt(cambridge : cambridge university press ) , 161 pryor , c. , & melan , g. 1993 , in asp conf .
50 , structure and dynamics of globular clusters , s. djorgovski & g. melan(san francisco : asp ) , 357 queloz , d. , dubath , p. , & pasquini , l. 1995 , a&a , 300 , 310 sargent , w.l . ,
kowal , c.t . ,
hartwick , f.d.a . , &
van den bergh , s. 1977 , aj , 82 , 947 spitzer , l. 1987 , _ dynamical evolution of globular clusters _ , princeton university press , princeton .
tripicco , m. 1993 , in asp conf .
48 , the globular cluster galaxy connection , g. smith & j. brodie(san francisco : asp ) , 432 van den bergh , s. 1994 , aj , 108 , 2145 vogt , s. 1987 , pasp , 99 , 1214 _ note added in proof. _ as this paper was beeing accepted for publication , we became aware of a similar work by djorgovski et al .
( apjl , in press ) .
they derive velocity dispersions from keck observations for a sample of 21 m31 globular clusters , which includes our 9 clusters .
their results are in good agreement with ours , e.g. , the difference in velocity dispersion values is always @xmath65 1.4 for all clusters .
they point out an interesting trend between the ratio mass - to - luminosity in the k band and the cluster metallicity , which has not been observed before . | we present internal velocity dispersion determinations from high - resolution spectroscopic observations of a sample of nine globular clusters in m31 .
comprehensive numerical simulations are used to show that the typical uncertainty of our velocity dispersion measurements is @xmath05% . using these new velocity dispersions together with structural parameters derived from hst observations , we estimate the @xmath1 ratios of these clusters and find that they are typical of those measured for galactic clusters .
we show relations between velocity dispersion , luminosity and physical scales for globular clusters belonging to the galaxy , the magellanic clouds , fornax , m31 , and centaurus a. the mean relations and the degree of scatter are similar in all galaxies .
this reveals remarkable similarities , in term of structure and @xmath1 ratio , between the globular clusters belonging to these different galaxies .
we briefly discuss the possible use of individual globular clusters as extragalactic distance indicators .
# 1#20=1=0=10by-1.2pt1.300 - 0.701 # 1#20=1=0=10by-1.2pt1.200 - 00.601 # 1#2 # 1 # 1#2=#1 # 1#2=#1 -1.5 cm |
for certain hierarchical structures , one can study the percolation problem using the renormalization - group method in a very precise way .
we show that the idea can be also applied to two - dimensional planar lattices by regarding them as hierarchical structures .
either a lower bound or an exact critical probability can be obtained with this method and the correlation - length critical exponent is approximately estimated as @xmath0 .
the percolation problem is a question about how a global connection can be made possible by randomly filling local components by a certain probability @xmath1 .
while it can be explained in purely geometric terms without any interaction , when a global connection actually appears , the macroscopic behavior of the system exhibits all the characteristic features of a continuous phase transition with a diverging correlation length , just as we observe in other interacting spin systems such as the two - dimensional ( 2d ) ising model @xcite .
this analogy is given a precise meaning by the fortuin - kasteleyn representation of the @xmath2-state potts model @xcite , where the percolation turns out to be equivalent to the limit of @xmath3 .
since the percolation transition at a critical probability @xmath4 has a diverging correlation length , every microscopic length scale becomes irrelevant with respect to the critical phenomena , and the system behaves as if it does not have any specific length scale .
this is a qualitative explanation of the reason why a percolating cluster connecting two opposite sides of a 2d plane has a fractal dimension at @xmath5 .
the lack of a specific length scale implies that the system remains statistically invariant even if we zoom the system up or down , and this scale invariance readily lends itself to a renormalization - group ( rg ) study of the percolation problem @xcite . in certain cases where the underlying structure itself is fractal , it is possible to carry out the rg calculation to a good approximation or exactly , exploiting this fractal property @xcite .
such fractal structures usually contain groups of bonds which connect longer and longer distances in a regular fashion .
for this reason , one can sometimes arrange the groups of bonds in a hierarchical way according to their connection lengths .
( a ) is an example of a hierarchical structure called the enhanced binary tree , which is obtained by adding horizontal bonds to the simple binary tree .
it is hierarchical in the sense that filling a horizontal bond is comparable to a very long connection along the bottom layer and the connection length is dependent on the level of the horizontal bond @xcite .
that is , a horizontal bond in the highest level can connect two points at distance 7 along the bottom layer at maximum .
for a horizontal bond at the next highest level , this maximum connection distance is only as large as 3 lattice spacings .
an rg scheme for the enhanced binary tree is described in @xcite as shown in ( b ) : we calculate the probability for any of the leftmost points to connect to any of the rightmost points within the cell as a function of the bare coupling @xmath1 and a coarse - grained effective coupling @xmath6 , and then replace this probability by a new effective bond with strength @xmath7 .
the resulting expression for @xmath7 is written as @xmath8.\ ] ] by asking when @xmath9 becomes 1 , we obtained a lower bound of the percolation threshold as @xmath10 @xcite , which is consistent with the conclusion in @xcite that @xmath11 .
note that we get a lower bound since in iterating @xmath6 to @xmath7 , there is a small chance to regard a layer as percolated when it is actually not [ see , e.g. , ( c ) ] , whereas the opposite is not possible . .
( c ) this layer is not connected from left to right even though the cells inside it appear as filled according to the recursion scheme in ( b ) .
the solid and dotted lines represent filled and empty bonds , respectively . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=35.0% ] .
( c ) this layer is not connected from left to right even though the cells inside it appear as filled according to the recursion scheme in ( b ) .
the solid and dotted lines represent filled and empty bonds , respectively .
, title="fig:",scaledwidth=28.0% ] + .
( c ) this layer is not connected from left to right even though the cells inside it appear as filled according to the recursion scheme in ( b ) .
the solid and dotted lines represent filled and empty bonds , respectively .
, title="fig:",scaledwidth=41.0% ] although the above rg scheme is devised to investigate a hierarchical structure , we show in this work that it can be applied to non - hierarchical planar lattices as well . in ( a )
, we present a variation of the rg scheme shown above .
the similarity is obvious : we have taken away only one bond out of those in ( b ) , and this is meant to describe the triangular lattice .
it leads us to the following recursion , @xmath12 ^ 2 .
\label{eq : rec1}\ ] ] again , the bond connection in _ lower _ levels , composed of @xmath1 and @xmath6 , is converted to a single bond with @xmath7 at a _ higher _ level .
this distinction of levels might look arbitrary since the bonds in the plane do not have any hierarchy .
however , the important point is that all the argument above to find a lower bound remains still legitimate from this viewpoint . solving for @xmath13
, we find that @xmath14 and consequently , @xmath15 at @xmath16 . comparing this to the exact bond - percolation threshold in the triangular lattice , @xmath17 @xcite , we see that our method indeed yields a lower bound .
we now extend the cells to be renormalized by adding one more level .
that is , let us denote the width of the cell as @xmath18 and consider the case of @xmath19 .
for the triangular lattice , the shape of such a larger cell is given in ( b ) . by enumerating all the possible cases ,
the recursion relation is obtained as @xmath20 and we find its limiting value as @xmath21 with @xmath22 , @xmath23 , and @xmath24 .
the solution of @xmath25 is found at @xmath26 , which is an improved lower bound compared to the previous one , @xmath27 , even though the convergence turns out to be rather slow . .
( b ) a larger cell with @xmath19 for the triangular lattice . the rg scheme for the honeycomb lattice with ( c ) @xmath28 and ( d ) @xmath19 can be constructed in the same way , as well as that for the square lattice with ( e ) @xmath28 and ( f ) @xmath19 .
the double lines represent coarse - grained effective bonds and the dotted lines in ( c ) to ( f ) mean that the connections do not correspond to any bare interaction .
, title="fig:",scaledwidth=28.0% ] .
( b ) a larger cell with @xmath19 for the triangular lattice . the rg scheme for the honeycomb lattice with ( c ) @xmath28 and ( d ) @xmath19 can be constructed in the same way , as well as that for the square lattice with ( e ) @xmath28 and ( f ) @xmath19 .
the double lines represent coarse - grained effective bonds and the dotted lines in ( c ) to ( f ) mean that the connections do not correspond to any bare interaction . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=28.0% ] + .
( b ) a larger cell with @xmath19 for the triangular lattice . the rg scheme for the honeycomb lattice with ( c ) @xmath28 and ( d ) @xmath19 can be constructed in the same way , as well as that for the square lattice with ( e ) @xmath28 and ( f ) @xmath19 .
the double lines represent coarse - grained effective bonds and the dotted lines in ( c ) to ( f ) mean that the connections do not correspond to any bare interaction . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=28.0% ] .
( b ) a larger cell with @xmath19 for the triangular lattice . the rg scheme for the honeycomb lattice with ( c ) @xmath28 and ( d ) @xmath19 can be constructed in the same way , as well as that for the square lattice with ( e ) @xmath28 and ( f ) @xmath19 .
the double lines represent coarse - grained effective bonds and the dotted lines in ( c ) to ( f ) mean that the connections do not correspond to any bare interaction .
, title="fig:",scaledwidth=28.0% ] + .
( b ) a larger cell with @xmath19 for the triangular lattice .
the rg scheme for the honeycomb lattice with ( c ) @xmath28 and ( d ) @xmath19 can be constructed in the same way , as well as that for the square lattice with ( e ) @xmath28 and ( f ) @xmath19 .
the double lines represent coarse - grained effective bonds and the dotted lines in ( c ) to ( f ) mean that the connections do not correspond to any bare interaction . , title="fig:",scaledwidth=28.0% ] .
( b ) a larger cell with @xmath19 for the triangular lattice . the rg scheme for the honeycomb lattice with ( c ) @xmath28 and ( d ) @xmath19 can be constructed in the same way , as well as that for the square lattice with ( e ) @xmath28 and ( f ) @xmath19 .
the double lines represent coarse - grained effective bonds and the dotted lines in ( c ) to ( f ) mean that the connections do not correspond to any bare interaction .
, title="fig:",scaledwidth=28.0% ] if we also regard the honeycomb lattice as hierarchical , we can consider an rg scheme as depicted in ( c ) . by calculating the probabilty for any of the leftmost points to connect to any of the rightmost points within the cell ,
we find @xmath29 ^ 2 .
\label{eq : honey}\ ] ] by a little algebra as above , we find @xmath30 , which becomes one at @xmath31 . again
, this is lower than the exact value @xmath32 @xcite .
one may expect an improved estimate by considering a larger cell shown in ( d ) , which leads to @xmath33 the limiting solution is @xmath34 where @xmath35 , @xmath36 , and @xmath37 .
we find that @xmath38 at @xmath39 .
using the duality relation @xmath40 @xcite , we may turn this result to an _ upper _ bound of the bond - percolation threshold for the triangular lattice .
that is , our method gives a possible region of the threshold as @xmath41 , or equivalently , @xmath42 .
a more interesting case is found by considering the horizontal bonds in ( a ) and ( b ) as fictitious [ ( e ) and ( f ) ] .
this corresponds to the square lattice , and the interaction in the horizontal direction will appear only as an effective one mediated by shorter bonds
. then we can simplify as @xmath29 ^ 2,\ ] ] which happens to be the same as .
therefore , we find @xmath31 once again , but this value is identical to the exact value for the bond - percolation problem in the square lattice @xcite . since this method is supposed to give a lower bound , it should not be possible to improve this result further , so it will be worth checking whether this value really remains unchanged for a larger cell . from a larger cell depicted in ( f ) , we obtain a recursion @xmath43 and find its limiting value as @xmath44 with @xmath45 , @xmath46 , and @xmath47 .
the critical value making @xmath15 is also @xmath31 , as expected .
the fact that @xmath48 does not change with @xmath18 could be an evidence that the bond - percolation threshold is located exactly at @xmath49 for the square lattice .
in addition , we can argue that the connection probability over distance @xmath50 would be roughly determined by @xmath51 near the critical point .
in other words , the correlation length would be written as @xmath52 .
the slope of @xmath53 around @xmath5 does not vanish in every case considered above , so it generally behaves as @xmath54 where @xmath55 at @xmath56 with positive @xmath57 .
therefore , we see that @xmath58}\\ & \approx & ( p_c - p)^{-1},\end{aligned}\ ] ] by using @xmath59 . since the correlation length is assumed to diverge as latexmath:[$\xi \sim critical exponent as @xmath0 , which is an underestimate compared to the exact value , @xmath61 @xcite .
it is worth noting that this rg scheme does not make use of any explicit scaling transformation : we do not zoom up or zoom down the system at criticality as usually found in rg studies @xcite . in arguing the value of @xmath62 , therefore , we evaluate it directly in units of the given lattice spacing instead of any zooming ratio . by setting @xmath63 , in a sense ,
it is the translational invariance that we are actually exploiting in this study . in summary
, we have shown that the rg scheme devised for a hierarchical structure can be also applied to the 2d lattices even though they are not hierarchical .
it generally yields a lower bound , but correctly predicts the bond - percolation threshold for square lattice .
we have also approximately estimated @xmath0 .
this method is more related to the translational invariance rather than to the scaling invariance at criticality .
we are grateful for support from the swedish research council with grant no . 621 - 2008 - 4449 . |
|
more than a decade has passed since spin - torque effects were demonstrated experimentally by the switching of the magnetization of a thin ferromagnetic film when current is passed between it and a pinned ferromagnetic layer @xcite .
a spin - polarized current passing through a small magnetic conductor will deposit spin - angular momentum into the magnetic system .
this in turn causes the magnetic moment to precess and in some cases even switch direction .
this has led to sweeping advances in the field of spintronics through the development and study of spin - valves and magnetic tunnel junctions ( see , for example , @xcite ) .
the theoretical approach to such a problem has conventionally been to treat the thin ferromagnetic film as a single macrospin in the spirit of brown @xcite .
spin - torque effects are taken into account phenomenologically by modifying the macrospin s llg dynamical equation @xcite . a thorough understanding of the phenomena , however
, can not proceed without taking into account the effect of thermal fluctuations .
this is of particular experimental relevance since spin - transfer effects on nanomagnets are often conducted at low currents , where noise is expected to dominate .
recent debate in the literature over the proper exponential scaling behavior between mean switching time and current shows how the thermally assisted properties of even the simplest magnetic setups leave much to be understood @xcite .
the interplay between spin - torque and thermal effects determine the dynamical properties of recent experimental studies on nanopillar devices @xcite . except at very high currents where the dynamics are predominantly deterministic
, the switching appears to be thermal in nature .
fitting to experimental data requires accurate knowledge of the energetics which , in the realm of spin - torque , are hard to come by due to the inherently non - conservative nature of the spin - torque term .
theoretical progress has been hindered by the computational power needed to run numerical simulations to the desired degree of accuracy .
the llg equation , modified into its set of coupled stochastic equations can be studied in one of two ways : either by concentrating on the associated focker - planck equation or by constructing a stochastic langevin integrator to be used enough times to gather sufficient statistics on the phenomena @xcite .
the latter approach , however , has been unable to extrapolate to long enough times to capture the dynamical extent of the thermal regime .
a recent paper by taniguchi and imamura @xcite , suggests that previous analytics of the thermally assisted dynamics should be revisited .
nonetheless , no numerical simulation has yet been able to evaluate the accuracy of the taniguchi and imamura results @xcite . in our paper
, we will show that simulations run harnessing the vast computational parallelization capabilities intrinsic in graphics processing unit ( gpu ) technology for numerical modeling can allow a deeper probing of such a thermally activated regime .
a simple model of a ferromagnet uses a stoner - wohlfarth monodomain magnetic body with magnetization @xmath0 .
the body is assumed to have a size @xmath1 along the @xmath2 direction , and size @xmath3 in both the @xmath4 and @xmath5 directions .
the total volume of the object is then @xmath6 .
the shape of the body is assumed to be isotropic and the energy landscape experienced by @xmath0 is generally described by three terms : an applied field @xmath7 , a uniaxial anisotropy energy @xmath8 with easy axis along @xmath9 in the @xmath10 making an angle @xmath11 with the @xmath5 axis , and an easy - plane anisotropy @xmath12 in the @xmath13 plane , with normal direction @xmath14 perpendicular to @xmath9 . the magnetization @xmath0 is assumed to be constant in magnitude and for simplicity normalized into a unit direction vector @xmath15 .
a spin - polarized current @xmath16 enters the magnetic body in the @xmath17 direction , with spin polarization factor @xmath18 , and spin direction along @xmath5 .
the current exits in the same direction , but with its average spin direction aligned to that of @xmath0 .
the self - induced magnetic field of the current is ignored here as the dimension @xmath3 is considered to be smaller than @xmath19 , where the spin - current effects are expected to become dominant over the current induced magnetic field .
the standard landau - lifshitz - gilbert ( llg ) equation used to describe the dynamics is then written as : @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the gilbert ratio , @xmath22 is the usual gyromagnetic ratio and @xmath23 is the spin - angular momentum deposited per unit time with @xmath24 the spin - polarization factor of incident current @xmath16 .
the last two terms describe a vector torque generated by current polarized in the direction @xmath25 .
these are obtained by assuming that the macrospin absorbs angular momentum from the spin - polarized current only in the direction perpendicular to @xmath26 .
@xcite to write @xmath27 explicitly , we must construct a proper energy landscape for the magnetic body .
there are three main components that need to be considered : a uniaxial anisotropy energy @xmath8 , an easy - plane anisotropy @xmath28 and a pure external field interaction @xmath29 .
these are written as follows : @xmath30 in these equations , @xmath31 is the saturation magnetization , @xmath32 is the easy - plane anisotropy , @xmath33 and @xmath34 is the stoner - wohlfarth switching field ( in units of teslas ) . in
what follows , we consider the simplified model where we ignore the effects of easy - plane anisotropys and all external magnetic fields are absent .
the full energy landscape then becomes @xmath35 and reads : @xmath36,\ ] ] where @xmath37 , @xmath9 is the unit vector pointing in the orientation of the uniaxial anisotropy axis , and effects due to external magnetic fields are included for reasons which will be explained in the next section .
such an energy landscape generally selects stable magnetic configurations parallel and anti - parallel to @xmath9 .
the effective interaction field @xmath27 is then given by @xmath38.\ ] ] the symmetries of the problem lead to slightly simplified equations and the deterministic llg dynamics can then be expressed as : @xmath39-\alpha\mathbf{m}\times\left[\mathbf{m}\times\left((\mathbf{\hat{n}}_k\cdot\mathbf{m})\mathbf{\hat{n}}_k+\mathbf{h}\right)\right]\nonumber\\ & -\alpha i\mathbf{m}\times\left(\mathbf{m}\times\mathbf{\hat{k}}\right)+\alpha^2 i\mathbf{m}\times\mathbf{\hat{k}},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have defined for future convenience @xmath40 and introduced the natural timescale @xmath41 .
thermal effects are included by considering uncorrelated fluctuations in the effective interaction field : @xmath42 .
these transform the llg equation into its langevin form .
we model the stochastic contribution @xmath43 by specifying its correlation properties , namely : @xmath44 the effect of the random torque @xmath43 is to produce a diffusive random walk on the surface of the @xmath0-sphere .
an associated focker - planck equation describing such dynamics was constructed by brown @xcite . at long times ,
the system attains thermal equilibrium and , by the fluctuation - dissipation theorem we have : @xmath45 it is convenient to introduce the notation @xmath46 , representing the natural barrier height of the uniaxial anisotropy energy .
setting now the external magnetic field to zero and considering only thermal fluctuations , the stochastic llg equation reads : @xmath47 where @xmath48\nonumber\\ & -&(\mathbf{\hat{n}}_k\cdot\mathbf{m})\left[\mathbf{m}\times\mathbf{\hat{n}}_k-\alpha\left(\mathbf{\hat{n}}_k-(\mathbf{\hat{n}}_k\cdot\mathbf{m})\mathbf{m}\right)\right],\nonumber\\ b_{ik}(\mathbf{m})&=&-\epsilon_{ijk}m_j-\alpha(m_i m_k - \delta_{ik}).\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] and ` @xmath49 ' means to interpret our stochastic dynamics in the sense of stratonovich calculus in treating the multiplicative noise terms @xcite .
we numerically solve the above langevin equations by using a standard second order heun scheme to ensure proper convergence to the stratonovich calculus . at each time step ,
the strength of the random kicks is given by the fluctuation - dissipation theorem .
statistics were gathered from an ensemble of @xmath50 events with a natural integration stepsize of @xmath51 . for concreteness
, we set the landau damping constant @xmath52 .
different barrier heights were explored although the main results in this paper are shown for a barrier height of @xmath53 . to explore the simulations for long time regimes , the necessary events were simulated in parallel on an nvidia tesla c2050 graphics card . to generate the large number of necessary random numbers , we chose a proven combination @xcite of the three - component combined tausworthe taus88 " @xcite and the 32-bit quick and dirty " lcg @xcite .
the hybrid generator provides an overall period of around @xmath54 .
in experiments , one is generally interested in understanding how the interplay between thermal noise and spin torque effects switch an initial magnetic orientation from parallel to anti - parallel and vice versa . the role of spin - torque can be clarified by considering how energy is pumped in the system , from an energy landscape point of view . as in the previous section ,
the magnetic energy of the monodomain is : @xmath55 the change in energy over time can be obtained after some straightforward algebra and is found to be : @xmath56\cdot\left(\mathbf{m}\times\mathbf{h}_{\mathrm{eff}}\right).\ ] ] this expression shows how current pumps energy into the system . in the absence of current , the damping dissipates energy and , as one would expect , the dynamical flow is toward the minimum energy configuration .
the sign preceeding the current term allows the expression to become positive in certain regions of magnetic configuration space .
furthermore , by averaging over constant energy trajectories , one can construct an equivalent dynamical flow equation in energy space .
this kind of approach has already been used in the literature @xcite and can lead to the appearance of stable limit cycles at currents less than the critical current as can be intuitively inferred by considering which constant energy trajectories lead to a canceling of the flow in ( 11 ) .
starting from an initially stable magnetic state , spin - torque effects will tend to drive the magnetization toward the current s polarization axis . once the current is turned off ,
the projection of the magnetization vector along the uniaxial anisotropy axis will almost surely determine which stable energy state ( parallel or anti - parallel ) the magnetic system will relax to as long as the energy barrier @xmath57 is large enough . as such , switching dynamics are best studied by projecting equations ( 8) along the uniaxial anisotropy axis @xmath9 .
one then obtains a stochastic differential equation describing the dynamics of such a projection : @xmath58\nonumber\\ & + & \alpha^2in_xm_y+\sqrt{\frac{\alpha}{\xi}(1-q^2)}\circ\dot{w}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the above equation , we have defined @xmath59 ; @xmath60 and @xmath61 are the projections of the uniaxial anisotropy axis respectively on the @xmath62 and @xmath63 axes .
furthermore , the multiple stochastic contributions are assumed to be gaussian random variables with identical average and space dependent variance .
@xmath64 is a standard mean zero , variance 1 , wiener process , and its prefactor explicitly expresses the strength of the stochastic contribution @xcite . as will be shown in the following subsections , ( 12 ) is a convenient analytical tool in specific scenarios . in general , though , it is not useful as it explicitly depends on the dynamics of both the @xmath65 and @xmath66 components of the magnetization .
numerically , we can solve ( 8) directly . in all our simulations , the initial ensemble of magnetizations
was taken to be boltzmann - distributed along the anti - parallel orientation .
we assume that the energy barrier height is so large that , before current effects are activated , thermalization has only been achieved within the antiparallel energy well and no states have had time to thermally switch to the parallel orientation on their own .
a typical histogram of magnetic orientations at a given time is shown in figure 1 .
after letting the magnetic system relax to thermal equilibrium ( @xmath67 natural time units ) .
the overlayed red dashed line is the theoretical equilibrium boltzmann distribution . in the inset
we show a semilog - plot of the probability vs. @xmath68 dependency .
as expected , the data scales linearly.,width=384 ] we now turn on a current and allow the system to evolve for a fixed amount of time .
once this time has passed , we use the projection rule expressed above to evaluate what fraction of the ensemble has effectively switched from the anti - parallel to the parallel state .
having derived the necessary expressions for our macrospin model dynamics , it is useful to consider the following simplification . let us take the uniaxial anisotropy and spin - current axes to be collinear , namely , @xmath69 . in such a scenario ,
the stochastic llg equation simplifies significantly .
in particular , ( 11 ) reduces to the simplified form : @xmath70 in this symmetric scenario , @xmath71 coincides with @xmath65 and magnetization reversal has been reduced to a straightforward 1-d problem . for a general value of @xmath72 , the evolution of @xmath71 has two local minima and a saddle .
the two stable configurations are at @xmath73 and @xmath74 , while the saddle is located at @xmath75 . for currents
@xmath76 there is only one stable minimum . above critical current
, spin torque pushes all magnetic configurations toward the parallel @xmath74 state .
in the high current regime @xmath77 we expect the deterministic dynamics to dominate over thermal effects .
we refer to this also as ballistic evolution interchangeably . the determistic contribution of ( 12 ) can then be solved analytically given an initial configuration @xmath78 .
the switching time @xmath79 will simply be the time taken to get from some @xmath80 to @xmath81 and reads : @xmath82\nonumber\\ & & -\log\left[1-m_0 ^ 2\right]-2\log\left[\frac{i}{i - m_0}\right]\bigg\}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] since the magnetic states are considered to be in thermal equilibrium before the current is turned on , one should average the above result over the equilibrium boltzmann distribution in the starting well to obtain the average switching time @xmath83 . for @xmath57 large enough , such an initial distribution will be : @xmath84}{f[\sqrt{\xi}]}\exp[\xi m^2],\ ] ] where @xmath85=\exp(-x^2)\int_0^x\exp(y^2)dy$ ] is dawson s integral .
this expression can be used to compute the average switching time numerically . as the intensity of spin - currents becomes closer to @xmath86
, thermal effects increasingly contribute .
moreover , diffusion gradients add to the deterministic drift , which can be shown explicitly by writing ( 13 ) in its equivalent to form .
doing so leads us to a first correction of the ballistic dynamics due to thermal influences .
the z - component behavior then reads : @xmath87 the first term on the right hand side is still the ballistic flow that we have just discussed .
the second term is the desired diffusion - gradient drift term .
the contribution of such a term generates a net motion away from the stable minima of the ballistic equations as one expects to see under the influence of thermal effects .
again , we can solve the drift dominated flow analytically to compute the switching time . considering diffusion - gradient drift ,
this reads : @xmath88}{3 w_j^2 - 2 i w_j-(1-\frac{1}{2\xi } ) } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the @xmath89 are the three zeros of the cubic equation @xmath90 . as before , the average switching @xmath91 time
will simply be given by averaging numerically over the boltzmann distribution @xmath92 . in figure 2
, the reader can see how well these two limiting results fit the simulation data . as expected
both expressions coincide in the limit of high currents . ) where @xmath93 stands for tesla : real time is obtained upon division by @xmath34.,width=384 ]
in the high current regime ( @xmath77 ) , where @xmath94 ( i.e. the uniaxial tilt is aligned with the z - axis ) , the ballistic equation for @xmath65 was shown to decouple from the other components , and the dynamics became one dimensional and deterministic .
for the more general case where the uniaxial anisotropy axis may have any tilt with respect to the z - axis , such a critical current is not as intuitively defined . unlike the collinear limit , a critical current , above which all magnetic states perceive a net flow towards an increasing projection , does not exist .
one can plot @xmath95 over the unit sphere to see what regions allow for an increasing and decreasing projection as the current is changed .
an example of this is shown in figure 3 .
: green @xmath96 , red @xmath97 for applied current @xmath98 .
the plane dissecting the sphere is perpendicular to the uniaxial anistropy axis .
its intersection with the sphere selects the regions with highest uniaxial anisotropy energy.,width=384 ] unfortunately , regions characterizing negative projection flow can be shown to persist at all currents .
the approach is refined by requiring that on average , over constant - energy precessional trajectories , the flow is toward the positive uniaxial anisotropy axis : @xmath99 .
such trajectories are found by solving the flow equations with @xmath100 .
solutions correspond to circular libations about the uniaxial anisotropy axis .
the critical current is then redefined to be the minimum current at which the average projectional flow is positive at all possible precessional energies .
this is easily done and results in : @xmath101 = \frac{1}{\cos(\omega ) } = i_{crit},\ ] ] thus allowing for a direct comparison of dynamical switching results between different angular configurations of uniaxial tilt . in our discussion of ( 12 ) we mentioned how in the general case , presenting uniaxial tilt , there is no way to reduce the dimensionality of the full dynamical equations .
in fact , in the presence of tilt , precessional trajectories might allow for a magnetization state to temporarily transit through a @xmath102 , switched " configuration , even though it might spend the majority of its orbit in a @xmath103 , unswitched " configuration .
this allows for a much richer mean switching time behavior , especially above critical current , as shown in figure 4 and discussed more in depth later . .
angular tilts are shown in the legend in units of @xmath104 such that the smallest angular tilt is @xmath105 and the largest is @xmath106 .
times are shown in units of ( @xmath107 ) where @xmath93 stands for tesla : real time is obtained upon division by @xmath34.,width=384 ]
for currents @xmath108 the switching relies on thermal effects to stochastically push the magnetization from one energy minimum to the other .
it is of interest to understand how switching probabilities and switching times depend on temperature and applied current .
this is easily done in stochastic systems with gradient flow . in such cases
an energy landscape exists and a steady state probability distribution can be constructed to be used via kramer s theory in deriving approximate low - noise switcing probabilities . unfortunately , though , spin - torque effects introduce a non - gradient term , and the resulting llg equation does not admit an energy landscape in the presence of applied current . the collinear simplification , however , is an exception . as already described , in the absence of uniaxial tilt the dynamics become effectively one dimensional since the @xmath65 component decouples from the other magnetization components .
consider then ( 13 ) : because it is decoupled from the other degrees of freedom , we can construct a corresponding one - component focker - planck equation .
the evolution in time of the distribution of @xmath71 is then : @xmath109(q , t),\nonumber\ ] ] where @xmath110=-\alpha\partial_q \left[(q+i)(1-q^2)-\frac{1}{2\xi}(1-q^2)\partial_q\right]f.\nonumber\ ] ] for high energy barriers and low currents , the switching events from one basin to the other are expected to be rare .
the probability of a double reversal should be even smaller .
we therefore model the magnetization reversal as a mean first passage time ( mfpt ) problem with absorbing boundaries at the saddle point .
the mfpt will then be given by @xcite the solution of the adjoint equation ( @xmath111 ) : @xmath112\partial_q\tau(q)=-1\nonumber\ ] ] subject to the boundary condition @xmath113 .
this can be solved to give : @xmath114 the rightmost integral can be computed explicitely . retaining only dominant terms , the final integral
can be computed by saddlepoint approximation to give : @xmath115 such a square exponential dependence has recently been derived by taniguchi and imamura @xcite , although a @xmath116 dependence , proposed elsewhere in the literature @xcite , has also been successfully used to fit experimental data @xcite . to decide between these experimental dependences
, we fit the scaling behaviors in figure 5 , along with the theoretical prediction from ( 24 ) .
the square exponential dependence fits the data better , confirming our analytical results .
furthermore , comparison to the full theoretical prediction demonstrates that even for mean switching times of the order @xmath117 milliseconds , asymptoticity still is not fully achieved . ) where @xmath93 stands for tesla : real time is obtained upon division by @xmath34 . the red and green line
are born by fitting to the data the functional form @xmath118 , where @xmath119 is the debated exponent ( either @xmath120 or @xmath121 ) and @xmath122 is deduced numerically .
the red curve fits the numerical data asymptotically better the green curve.,width=384 ] all that remains is to consider the effects of angular tilt on the switching properties in the thermally activated regime .
insight into this problem can be obtained by invoking ( 12 ) again . for small values of @xmath123 ,
the term in square brackets is of leading order over the second ballistic term depending on @xmath66 .
this allows us , in the small @xmath123 regime , to neglect the second ballistic term altogether .
we now concentrate on the behavior of the term in square brackets . for low sub - critial currents , switching will depend on thermal activation for the most part .
we expect an initially anti - parallel configuration to not diffuse very far away from its local energy minima .
we expect it to remain that way until a strong enough thermal kick manages to drive it across the energy barrier . because of this , the second term appearing in the square brackets will generally be close to zero as the particle awaits thermal switching . to make the statement more precise
, one can imagine the magnetic state precessing many times before actually making it over the saddle .
the second term can then be averaged over a constant energy trajectory and shown to vanish identically .
hence , in the subcritical regime , ( 12 ) can be rewritten in the following approximate form : @xmath124 this , is reminiscent of the 1d projectional dynamics discussed in relation to the collinear limit , and shown explicitly in ( 13 ) .
the only difference between the two is the substitution @xmath125 ; recall because @xmath126 , @xmath127 . in other words , the thermally activated dynamics are the same for all angular separations up to a rescaling by the critical current .
we then expect that the mean switching time dependences remain functionally identical to the collinear case for all uniaxial tilts .
we have confirmed this by comparison with data from our simulations , and the results are shown in figure 6 .
as predicted , all mean switching time data from different uniaxial tilts collapses on top of each other after a rescaling by each tilt s proper critical current . in comparing our scaling relationships between current and mean switching time with the previous literature , a subtle issue must be addressed .
results obtained by apalkov and visscher @xcite rely upon an initial averaging of the dynamics in energy space over constant energy trajectories ( limit for small damping ) and only subsequently applying weak noise methods to extrapolate switching time dependences .
the small damping and weak noise limits are singular and the order in which they are taken is important .
both limits radically alter the form of the equations : whereas both limits suppress thermal effects , the first also severely restrains the deterministic evolution of the magnetic system .
our approach considers the weak noise limit and , only in discussing the effects of an angular tilt between polarization and easy axes do we employ the small damping averaging technique to obtain functional forms for the mean switching time .
the switching time data shown seems to justify , in this particular , an interchangeability between these two limits .
more generally , however , one should not expect the two limits to commute . ) where @xmath93 stands for tesla : real time is obtained upon division by @xmath34.,width=384 ]
up until now , we have analyzed the main properties of spin - torque induced switching dynamics by concentrating solely on the mean switching times . in experiments , though , one generally constructs full probability curves .
the probability that a given magnetic particle has a switching time @xmath128 can be explicitely written as : @xmath129&=&\int_0^{m(\tau)}dx\rho_b(x)\nonumber\\ & = & \exp[-\xi(1-m(\tau)^2)]\frac{f[\sqrt{\xi}m(\tau)]}{f[\sqrt{\xi}]},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath130 is the initial magnitization that is switched deterministically in time @xmath131 .
once one has evaluated @xmath130 , the probability curve follows . ideally , in the ballistic regime
, one would like to invert the ballistic equations .
unfortunately , though , the solutions of such ballistic equations are generally transcendental and can not be inverted analytically . even in the simpler collinear case , as can be seen from equations ( 14 ) and ( 18 ) , no analytical inversion is possible .
one must instead compute the inversion numerically .
nonetheless , one can construct appropriate analytical approximations by inverting the dominant terms in the expressions . in the case of ( 14 ) , for example , one has that for currents much larger than the critical current : @xmath132\ ] ] which can be inverted to give : @xmath133.\ ] ] plugging into expression ( 25 ) for the @xmath131 probability curve , one has : @xmath134=\exp\left[-\frac{\xi}{\cosh^2[\alpha\tau\frac{i^2 - 1}{i}]}\right]\frac{f[\sqrt{\xi}\tanh[\alpha\tau\frac{i^2 - 1}{i}]]}{f[\sqrt{\xi}]},\ ] ] this expression can be truncated to a simpler form by noting that the leading exponential term dominates over the ratio of dawson functions . furthermore ,
if one considers the limit of large values for @xmath131 ( or , analogously , @xmath135 ) , the ` @xmath136 ' can be also approximated by its leading exponential term .
we are finally left with : @xmath129&\simeq&\exp\left[-\frac{\xi}{\cosh^2[\alpha\tau\frac{i^2 - 1}{i}]}\right]\nonumber\\ & \sim&\exp\left[-4\xi\exp[-2\alpha\tau\frac{i^2 - 1}{i}]\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is very similar in form to what has already been reported and used for fitting in the literature @xcite . in the low current regime ,
one constructs probability curves by considering the mean switching time and modeling a purely thermal reversal as a decay process with rate given by equation ( 24 ) .
the fraction of switched states then vary in time as : @xmath137 upon introducing uniaxial tilt , precessional effects can be witnessed directly on the switching probability curves in the super - critical regime .
one expects that in the initial phases of switching , the fraction of switched states is sensitive to the time at which the current is turned off .
one may accidentally turn off the current during a moment of transient passage through the switched region along the precessional orbit .
this was checked and verified from our numerical simulations ( see figure 7 ) .
more generally , effects similar to the waviness " seen in the mean switching time curves can be seen in the probability curves as well as the angle of uniaxial tilt is allowed to vary ( see figure 8) .
only a numerical solution of the llg equation can bring such subtleties to light .
subject to a current intensity of @xmath138 times the critical current .
the non - monotonicity in the probability curve shows the existence of transient switching.,width=384 ] was used).,width=384 ]
we have constructed the theory underlying the dynamics of a uniaxial macrospin subject to both thermal fluctuation and spin - torque effects .
we then studied the subtle interplay between these two effects in aiding magnetization reversal between energy minima in a magnetically bistable system .
two regimes stand out in such a theory : a ballistic regime dominated by the deterministic flow and a thermally activated regime where reversal is dominated by noise . in the ballistic regime
we discussed how to approximate the mean switching time behavior and found that corrections due to the diffusion - gradient term , arising from the stochastic equations , allow one to model the dynamics more accurately . in the thermally activated regime , we solved the relevant mean first passage time problem and obtained an expression for the dependence of mean switching time on applied current . in doing so , the correct scaling was shown to be @xmath139 , in contrast to the prevailing view that @xmath140 .
analytical results were then compared with detailed numerical simulations of the stochastic llg equation .
the massively parallel capabilities of our gpu devices has allowed us to explore the behavior of macrospin dynamics over six orders of temporal magnitude . comparing to our analytical results
, we suggest that the thermal asymptotic behavior is achieved very slowly with respect to the switching timescales that have been probed experimentally .
different geometrical configurations of the uniaxial anisotropy axis with respect to the spin - current axis were shown to influence the thermally activated regime very minimally inasmuch as the currents were rescaled by the proper critical current of the angular setup . only in the super - critical regime were distinctions shown to exist due to complex precessional and transient switching behavior .
these results have important implications for the analysis of experimental data in which measurements of the switching time versus current pulse amplitude are used to determine the energy barrier to magnetization reversal .
clearly use of the correct asymptotic scaling form is essential to properly determine the energy barrier to reversal .
the energy barrier , in turn , is very important in assessing the thermal stability of magnetic states of thin film elements that are being developed for long term data storage in stt - mram .
further work should address how these results extend to systems with easy plane anisotropy and situations in which the nanomagnet has internal degrees of freedom , leading to a break down of the macrospin approximation .
we also note that current flow is a source of shot noise , which at low frequencies acts like a white - noise source in much the same way as thermal noise .
it is therefore interesting to understand when this additional source of noise plays a role .
for a magnetic layer coupled to unpolarized leads , the current induced noise on the magnetization dynamics was found to be @xmath141 @xcite , where @xmath142 is the voltage drop across the magnetic layer , while @xmath143 is a dimensionless ratio characterizing the coupling strength of the magnetic layer to the left ( l ) and right ( r ) leads .
thus the noise is maximal ( @xmath144 ) for perfectly symmetrical couplings , and is smaller in the limit of highly asymmetric contacts .
this basic behavior , and the order of magnitude of the effect , is not likely to be modified by polarized leads .
we argue that the temperatures at which the experiments have been performed current noise effects are not important .
the experiments are performed at room temperature where @xmath145 k. for an all - metallic device , such as a spin - valve nanopillar , the couplings are nearly symmetrical and at the critical current a typical voltage drop across the magnetic layer is less than @xmath146v or , equivalently , @xmath120 k. for a magnetic tunnel junction device @xmath142 can be @xmath147 v. however , in this case the coupling is asymmetric .
one lead ( l ) forms a magnetic tunnel junction with the nanomagnet , while the other ( r ) a metallic contact .
this gives @xmath148 and a relevant energy @xmath147 k , again far lower than room temperature .
it appears that current induced noise can only be important at room temperature for a nanomagnet coupled symmetrically between two tunnel barriers .
the authors would like to acknowledge a. macfadyen , aditi mitra and j. z. sun for many useful discussions and comments leading to this paper .
this research was supported by nsf - dmr-100657 and phy0965015 .
j. slonczewski , j. magn .
magn . mater . *
159 * , l1 ( 1996 ) .
l. berger , physical review b * 54 * , 9353 ( 1996 ) .
j. a. katine , f. j. albert , and r. a. buhrman , phys .
* 84 * , 31493152 ( 2000 ) b. zyilmaz , a. d. kent , j. z. sun , m. j. rooks , and r. h. koch , phys .
lett . * 93 * , 176604 ( 2004 ) w. f. brown , phys . rev . *
135 * , 5 ( 1963 ) .
a. brataas , a. d. kent , h. ohno , nature materials * 11 * , 372 ( 2012 ) .
r. h. koch , j. a. katine , and j. z. sun phys .
lett * 92 * no .
8 , ( 2004 ) .
j. z. sun , phys .
b * 62 * , 1 ( 2000 ) .
d. m. apalkov and p. b. visscher , phys .
b * 72 * , 180405r ( 2005 ) .
z. li and s. zhang , phys .
b * 69 * , 134416 ( 2004 )
. r. h. koch , j. a. katine , and j. z. sun , phys .
* 92 * , 8 ( 2004 ) .
d. pinna , aditi mitra , d. l. stein , and a. d. kent , arxiv:1205.6509 ( 2012 ) .
d. bedau _ et al .
. lett . * 97 * , 262502 ( 2010 ) .
j. l. garcia - palacios and f. j. lazaro , phys . rev .
b * 58 * , 22 ( 1998 ) .
t. taniguchi and h. imamura , phys .
b * 83 * , 054432 ( 2011 ) .
t. taniguchi and h. imamura , appl .
express * 5 * , 063009 ( 2012 ) .
i. karatsas and s. shreve , _ brownian motion and stochastic calculus , 2nd ed._(springer - verlag , new york , 1997 ) .
h. nguyen , _
gpu gems 3 _ ( addison - wesley professional , 2007 ) .
p. lecuyer , operations research * 44 * , 5 ( 1996 ) , pp .
816 - 822 .
w.h . press , s.a .
teukolsky , w.t .
vetterling and b.p .
flannery , _ numerical recipes in c : the art of scientific computing _
( cambridge university press , 1992 ) .
r. zwanzig , _ nonequilibrium statistical mechanics _ ( oxford univerity press , oxford , uk , 2001 ) .
t. taniguchi and h. imamura , phys .
b * 85 * , 18440 ( 2012 ) .
r. kubo , n. hashitsume , supp .
. phys . * 46 * , pp .
210 - 220 ( 1970 ) .
w. rmelin , siam journal on numerical analysis * 19 * , 3 ( 1982 ) , pp .
604 - 613 w. t. coffey , phys .
b * 58 * , 3249 ( 1998 ) .
aditi mitra , so takei , yong baek kim , and a. j. millis , phys . rev
. lett . * 97 * , 236808 ( 2006 ) | we consider the general landau - lifshitz - gilbert ( llg ) dynamical theory underlying the magnetization switching rates of a thin film uniaxial magnet subject to spin - torque effects and thermal fluctuations ( thermal noise ) . after discussing the various dynamical regimes governing the switching phenomena , we present analytical results for the mean switching time behavior .
our approach , based on explicitly solving the first passage time problem , allows for a straightforward analysis of the thermally assisted , low spin - torque , switching asymptotics of thin film magnets . to verify our theory ,
we have developed an efficient gpu - based micromagnetic code to simulate the stochastic llg dynamics out to millisecond timescales .
we explore the effects of geometrical tilts between the spin - current and uniaxial anisotropy axes on the thermally assisted dynamics .
we find that even in the absence of axial symmetry , the switching times can be functionally described in a form virtually identical to the collinear case .
we further verify that asymptotic behavior is reached fairly slowly , thus quantifying the role of thermal noise in the crossover regime linking deterministic to thermally assisted magnetization reversal . |
bl lacs are a rare subclass of active galactic nuclei ( agn ) characterized by nearly featureless optical spectra , multiwavelength emission , marked variability and strong polarization ( e.g. , see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
their spectral energy distributions ( seds ) tend to be dominated by synchrotron radiation , with a component due to inverse compton scattering at higher frequencies .
the standard paradigm describes bl lacs in the context of agn unification as fr i radio galaxies with their relativistic jets pointed toward the observer ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
in this scenario the observed jets are brightened through beaming effects , making bl lacs powerful probes of agn jet physics and radio - loud agn in general .
their rarity and lack of strong spectral features historically render many traditional quasar selection techniques ( e.g. , uv - excess or objective prism surveys ) inefficient .
still , large bl lac samples are eagerly sought but until relatively recently have remained elusive ; given their strong multiwavelength continuous emission and rarity , broad - band recovery methods over large regions of the sky tend to be the most efficient .
bl lac studies are sensitive to selection biases and historically have been limited by small number statistics .
for example , a now disfavored dichotomy between radio selected bl lacs ( rbls ) and x - ray selected bl lacs ( xbls ) was initially suggested from a comparison between the small and relatively shallow but complete 1 jy radio sample @xcite and an x - ray selected sample from the _ einstein _ observatory extended medium - sensitivity survey ( emss ; * ? ? ? * ) .
in addition to xbls appearing to have less rapid variability and smaller nuclear to host galaxy flux ratios , rbls and xbls were thought to populate distinctly different regions of parameter space ( e.g. , see figure 5 of * ? ? ?
xbls are also more weakly polarized on average , and the majority of xbls have constant polarization position angles ( within 20@xmath0 ) over timescales of at least 3 years @xcite .
but @xcite argue against two distinct bl lac populations , and they instead propose that the observed differences between rbls and xbls could be explained via different energy cutoffs in the beamed synchrotron radiation component of their seds .
they suggest a more physical naming scheme of _ low - energy cutoff bl lac _ ( lbl ) and _ high - energy cutoff bl lac _ ( hbl ) to replace rbl and xbl .
lbls have energy cutoffs in the near - infrared / optical , while hbls have energy cutoffs in the uv / x - ray .
most but not all rbls are lbls in this scenario , and similarly most xbls are hbls .
deeper surveys have subsequently found many objects , aptly named _ intermediate - energy cutoff bl lacs _
( ibl ) , that bridge this lbl / hbl gap ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , thereby demonstrating the apparent dichotomy s emergence as a selection effect .
however , any model advocating a single bl lac population is still challenged with explaining the phenomenological differences between rbls and xbls described in the previous paragraph .
large and deep samples are clearly essential for advancing our knowledge on bl lacs ( e.g. , see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , and much progress has been made over the past 10 - 15 years : the number of known bl lacs has ballooned from only a couple hundred @xcite to about 1100 catalogued in @xcite .
numerous selection techniques have been used to assemble sizable bl lac samples .
one multifrequency selection approach identifies candidates based on flat radio spectra , followed by requisite optical spectroscopy ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , while another popular technique assembles catalogs via the indentification of optical counterparts to radio and/or x - ray error circles in various surveys ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
while these combined radio / x - ray selected samples include a significant fraction of ibls in addition to lbls and hbls , they are of course sensitive to the varying flux limits and biases inherent to each multiwavelength survey . one practical limitation to recovering a large uniform sample from imaging surveys as described above is performing the necessary optical spectroscopic follow - up for ( easily ) thousands of candidates , among which only @xmath1 are typically actual bl lacs .
it has been noted that bl lacs tend to have characteristic x - ray - to - optical and optical - to - radio flux ratios differentiating them ( at least statistically ) from other radio / x - ray sources ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
this feature has been exploited to increase the efficiency of bl lac search algorithms by targeting radio / x - ray sources with broad - band flux ratios indicative of known bl lacs .
notably , the _ einstein _ slew survey @xcite and the sedentary multifrequency survey @xcite adopted this approach to recover large uniform bl lac samples ( @xmath260 in the case of the _ einstein _ survey and @xmath2150 in the final sedentary sample . )
while such broad - band color selection approaches can recover lbls , ibls and hbls , it has been noted that the broad - band sed of bl lacs can vary largely from object to object , and this selection approach is prone to missing some bl lac subpopulations potentially in large numbers @xcite .
it should be noted however that the _ einstein _ slew survey produced the first _
bl lac sample containing a sizable number of lbls , ibls _ and _ hbls from a single selection technique ; the sedentary sample intentionally only attempted to recover hbls , and it nicely complements other surveys more sensitive to lbls ( particularly the deep x - ray radio blazar survey ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) the recent advent of digital large scale spectroscopic optical surveys has eased the difficulties of optical follow - up incurred by previous bl lac surveys .
a purely optically selected sample was assembled from the 2df and 6df quasar surveys @xcite , and @xcite additionally recovered hundreds of optically spectroscopically selected bl lac candidates from the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss , * ? ? ?
these optically selected samples do not entirely rule out the existence of radio - quiet bl lacs ; however , if such a population exists they must be extremely rare ( e.g. , see * ? ? ?
the @xmath210@xmath3 currently known bl lacs were derived from many different surveys , each with slightly different selection criteria and biases . in this paper
, we present a 501 object radio sample with homogeneous data coverage selected jointly from the sdss and from the faint images of the radio sky at twenty - centimeters ( first , * ? ? ?
* ) survey .
this sample is one of the largest bl lac samples yet assembled .
we also recently published in @xcite a 266 object x - ray sample selected jointly from sdss spectroscopy and from the rosat all sky survey ( rass , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
our x - ray sample recovered lbls , ibls and hbls , and a post - selection correlation with first and the nrao vla sky survey ( nvss ) revealed only 7 objects currently lacking radio detections ( possibly , but not certainly , because their radio emission lies below the first / nvss catalog flux limits . )
both our separate sdss / first and sdss / rass samples are large with similar systematics given their similar recovery methods in sdss .
these samples therefore provide an interesting opportunity for comparing radio and x - ray selected bl lacs in a uniform manner .
the sheer size of our sdss / first sample , when supplemented by a rigorous understanding of selection biases among the different wavebands , may eventually permit application to a range of bl lac topics , from agn unification , to host galaxy properties , to bl lac evolution .
our purpose here is to present our radio selected sample with some preliminary analysis .
we defer detailed investigations and comparisons with other samples to a later paper . in [ sec : sampsel ] we present our selection criteria .
potential contaminants to our sample are discussed in [ sec : contaminants ] , and our catalog is given in
[ sec : catalog ] .
some preliminary results and future applications of our sample are discussed in
[ sec : disc ] , with a summary in
[ sec : summary ] . throughout we use @xmath4 km s@xmath5 mpc@xmath5 , @xmath6 , and @xmath7 .
we select bl lac candidates from the combination of the sdss data release 5 ( dr5 ) spectroscopic database @xcite in the optical , and from the first survey catalog @xcite in the radio .
the sdss is a multi - institutional effort to image @xmath8 deg@xmath9 of the north galactic cap in 5 optical filters covering 3800 to 10,000 ( e.g. , see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , with follow - up moderate resolution spectroscopy ( @xmath10@xmath2@xmath11 ) of 10@xmath12 galaxies , 10@xmath13 qsos , and 10@xmath13 unusual stars ( e.g. , see * ? ? ?
data is taken with a special purpose 2.5-meter telescope located at apache point observatory ( see * ? ? ?
* ) , with astrometric accuracy at the @xmath2100 milli - arcsec level at the survey limit of @xmath14 @xcite and typical photometric precision of approximately 0.02 - 0.03 mag @xcite ; 640 simultaneous spectra are obtained over a 7 deg@xmath9 field with a multifiber optical spectrograph .
further technical details can be found in @xcite .
the sdss dr5 spectroscopic database contains spectra for @xmath2@xmath15 objects over @xmath2@xmath16 deg@xmath9 , and the dr5 quasar catalog @xcite contains 77,429 quasars with reliable spectroscopic redshifts .
our selection process identifies a very small fraction of objects ( @xmath17 ) in the dr5 quasar catalog as bl lacs ( see [ sec : catalog ] ) .
the first radio survey imaged approximately the same 10@xmath18 deg@xmath9 of the north galactic cap in the vla s b configuration ( 5@xmath19 resolution ) at 1.4 ghz .
three - minute snapshots were co - added together , and sources were extracted via specialized algorithms ( see * ? ? ? * ) with a catalog flux limit of 1 mjy and positional uncertainties better than @xmath20 .
the first survey is by design well suited both in sky coverage and depth for matching optical counterparts in sdss , and about one - third of first sources have detectable optical counterparts in the sdss photometric survey @xcite .
there are 37,456 objects in the sdss dr5 spectroscopic database that are flagged as first radio sources .
the target selection algorithms for follow - up sdss spectroscopy are well suited for recovering bl lacs .
please refer to @xcite for a thorough discussion .
briefly , one goal of the sdss is to identify optical counterparts to @xmath210@xmath18 rass x - ray sources .
at least one source with @xmath21 or @xmath22 within many @xmath2@xmath23 rass error circles is targeted for spectroscopy .
this x - ray counterpart algorithm targets many bl lacs , as sources whose sdss positions additionally match within 2@xmath19 to a first source are given highest priority , followed by objects with quasar - like or otherwise strange sdss colors .
the sdss spectroscopic sample is even more advantageous for bl lac recovery in that bl lac spectra are additionally obtained through other quasar , serendipity , or galaxy spectroscopic target selection algorithms ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
although one might initially expect that our emphasis on radio detection for inclusion would bias our sample toward excess lbls , we do not believe this is an important concern .
it is true that by requiring a detection in first we are prone to missing some bl lacs .
for example , some regions of the sky might not have data coverage in first ; and , some bl lacs with sdss spectroscopy might have been in a low flux state during the first observations and would therefore be missed ; also , we are not highly sensitive to the radio - weak / quiet tail of the bl lac population .
while very interesting , radio - weak / quiet bl lacs must be extremely rare if they exist ( e.g. , see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) ; omission of a few would not affect our sample in a statistical sense .
however , most bl lacs at the faint flux limit for sdss spectroscopy ( @xmath24 , @xmath25 , or @xmath26 ) will have radio fluxes larger than the 1 mjy flux limit of the first survey at 1.4 ghz . figure [ fig : sed ] shows typical seds for an lbl , an ibl , and an hbl ( seds were kindly provided by elina nieppola , see * ? ? ?
* ) as a solid line , dotted line , and dashed line respectively ; the seds are normalized to @xmath27 .
overplotted as black squares with arrows are typical flux limits for first , sdss spectroscopy , and rass from left to right , respectively .
so , while it is likely there are some bl lacs with sdss spectroscopy not detected in first , we do not appear to be significantly biasing our sample toward or against one particular bl lac subclass by applying the radio flux limit to our selection criteria .
note , however , that applying the rass flux limit ( taken from @xcite as 2.5@xmath2810@xmath29 erg s@xmath5 @xmath30 from 0.1 - 2.4 kev ) would bias our sample toward hbls .
while we do not explicitly apply this flux limit , it does play a role in determining which objects are targeted for sdss spectroscopy .
therefore , objects in bl lac samples derived from sdss spectroscopy could be biased toward hbls ( see [ sec : disc ] and also @xcite ) .
the relatively higher rass flux limit could also explain why we recover almost twice as many bl lac candidates from first / sdss as @xcite did from rass / sdss over the same area of the sky .
approximate flux limits for first in the radio ( 1 mjy at 1.4 ghz ) , sdss spectroscopy in the optical ( @xmath31 ) , and rass in the x - ray ( @xmath22.5@xmath2810@xmath29 erg s@xmath5 @xmath30 from 0.1 - 2.4 kev , see @xcite ) are shown as squares with arrows from left to right , respectively . at the optical spectroscopic flux limit
, we do not expect to miss many bl lacs by imposing a radio flux limit , unless the sdss object does not overlap with the first survey s sky coverage , or if the object was in a low flux state during the first observations .
note that applying the rass flux limit could bias our sample toward hbls .
although we do not formally impose an x - ray flux limit to our sample , the rass flux limit is implicit in the sdss spectroscopic target algorithms .
the rass flux limit therefore could affect the makeup of our sample ( see [ sec : disc ] ) .
our conclusion remains unchanged if we choose to normalize each sed to @xmath24 or @xmath32 . ]
following the process detailed below , we impose the following criteria for bl lac selection : 1 ) the sdss position matches within 2@xmath19 to a first radio source ; 2 ) sdss spectroscopy shows no emission line with a rest - frame equivalent width ( @xmath33 ) larger than 5 ( see [ sec : maninspect ] ) ; and 3 ) the h / k break ( if present ) has a measured depression @xmath34 .
the h / k depression parameter @xmath35 describes the fractional change in continuum blueward and redward of 4000 ( e.g. , see * ? ? ?
* ) : @xmath36 where @xmath37 and @xmath38 refer to the average fluxes per unit frequency just blueward ( 3750 - 3950 ) and just redward ( 4050 - 4250 ) of the h / k break respectively . the quantities @xmath39 and @xmath40 similarly refer to the average fluxes per unit wavelength .
these spectral constraints are commonly used in the recent literature , and they are consistent with , albeit more restrictive than , those introduced by @xcite .
we also take additional precautions to reject objects that might formally pass these criteria but are not bl lacs ( e.g. , stars , post - starburst galaxies , obvious broad absorption line quasars , etc . ; see [ sec : contaminants ] ) .
we note that our adopted selection criteria are empirically based and thus somewhat arbitrary ( e.g. , see @xcite and @xcite for relevant discussions pertaining to selection issues ) . for example
, there is no definitive h / k break value that serves as an obvious transition between beamed and unbeamed radio galaxies . and
, we could be missing some nearby low - luminosity bl lacs , as described by the browne - march effect @xcite : weakly beamed bl lacs could be so dominated by starlight from their host galaxies that they are misidentified as radio galaxies or as clusters of galaxies . as the h / k break cutoff instead of the more restrictive value of 0.25 used in some older samples .
] we discuss potential contamination from radio galaxies and clusters of galaxies in sections [ sec : radgal ] and [ sec : clustgal ] respectively .
also , bl lacs with significant host galaxy contamination can have @xmath33 s that are measured to be larger than 5 when referenced to their starlight contaminated continua instead of only their agn continua @xcite .
our selection approach misses such objects . despite these well - studied issues ,
our adopted spectral criteria are also commonly applied in much of the recent literature .
the sdss pipeline s measurements of spectral features ( e.g. , redshifts , line equivalent widths , h / k breaks , etc . )
are of course only useful if the pipeline estimates the correct redshift .
the pipeline redshifts are quite reliable for objects with strong spectral features ( e.g. , over 98% of the pipeline redshifts were accurate for the objects in the dr5 quasar catalog ) , but one should not blindly trust the redshifts for such weak - featured objects as bl lacs .
we therefore placed lenient restrictions on our initial database query to ensure high completeness at the cost of an initially large false positive rate .
we ran the following two - part query ( followed by manual inspection of all sdss spectra , see [ sec : maninspect ] ) : 1 .
we return all sdss spectra within 2@xmath19 of a first source for which the pipeline has little confidence in the measured redshift .
this is achieved by selecting all spectra ( that are not blank sky for calibration ) that the database flags speczstatus as ` not_measured ' or ` failed ' .
this query returned 589 spectra .
2 . for those objects with more confident pipeline redshifts ( i.e. , speczstatus @xmath41 ` not_measured ' or ` failed ' ) , we return all spectra within 2@xmath19 to a first source with the conservative constraints that ( i ) no emission line ( of ly@xmath42 , , ] ,
, h@xmath43 , [ ] , or h@xmath42 ) has a pipeline measured @xmath44 , and ( ii ) the h / k break ( if present ) has a pipeline measured @xmath45 . this query returned 1803 spectra .
not every spectrum in this set has a reliable pipeline redshift .
however , as expected , essentially all spectra lacking reliable pipeline redshifts also have very weak spectral features , and our query correctly retains these objects . objects with spectral features too strong to be considered bl lacs have correct pipeline redshifts in the vast majority of cases and are therefore rejected by the query as intended . out of @xmath237,000 total first matches in the dr5 spectroscopic database ,
our query yielded 2392 spectra as potential bl lac candidates .
we do not consider x - ray information for selection .
however , if an sdss source matches within @xmath23 to a rass source , we also keep track of its x - ray properties listed in the dr5 database .
we run two tests to check that our database query returns the vast majority of previously - known sdss bl lacs .
first , we compare our query results to @xcite s 183 probable sdss optically selected bl lac candidates that are additionally flagged as first radio sources in their catalog .
@xcite similarly require @xmath46 and @xmath47 , but their exact recovery method differs from ours .
172 of their 183 first / sdss objects appear in the dr5 database as first sources and pass our signal - to - noise cut ( see [ sec : signoise ] ) . of these 172 sources
, our database query fails to recover only a single spectrum .
we miss this spectrum because the pipeline measured a rew larger than 10 for an assumed feature that is likely just noise .
second , we perform an identical query for x - ray selection by replacing the 2@xmath19 match to a first source with a 1@xmath48 positional match to a rass source .
we then compare results from this x - ray query to the @xcite sdss / rass x - ray selected agn sample .
@xcite queried the dr5 spectroscopic database for sdss spectra that matched within 1@xmath48 to a rass source , placing no additional constraints on the pipeline measured spectral feature strengths or redshift flags .
their manual inspection of the resulting 15,129 spectra yielded 266 x - ray selected bl lac candidates ( also defined by @xmath47 and @xmath49 ) .
our revamped x - ray query ( i.e. , including cuts on equivalent width and h / k break ) weeds the @xmath210@xmath18 sdss / rass positional coincidences in dr5 to @xmath22000 objects ; we recovered all but 3 spectra included in the @xcite bl lac sample .
the missed objects include a borderline bl lac candidate with @xmath50 exactly ( as measured by @xcite ; the sdss pipeline measured @xmath51 ) , and two examples where the pipeline overestimated a single emission line s @xmath33 because the line lies in an abnormally noisy spectral regime .
although our database query is by design inefficient , we conclude that it is excellent in producing a manageable number of candidates while retaining essentially all previously - identified bl lac objects in the dr5 spectroscopic database .
we apply a signal - to - noise cut to the sdss spectra of potential bl lacs , similar to @xcite .
we calculate the signal to noise over three separate 500 wavelength regions centered on 4750 , 6250 , and 7750 ( each wavelength region typically contains approximately 450 , 350 and 300 pixels respectively ) ; these spectral regions are typically high - quality and fall within the @xmath52 and @xmath53 filters respectively . over each spectral region
we calculate the signal ( s ) and the noise ( n ) such that @xmath54 , where @xmath55 and @xmath56 represent the flux density and the estimated uncertainty in each spectral element @xmath53 respectively .
we retain all objects with @xmath57 in at least one of these spectral regions .
this constraint roughly corresponds to fiber magnitudes @xmath58 , @xmath59 , or @xmath60 for a typical spectroscopic plate , and it truncates our list from 2392 to 1560 objects .
we manually inspect the remaining 1560 spectra , including visual verification that our @xmath61 cut did indeed only reject objects with poor signal to noise .
first , we flag each pipeline measured redshift as either reliable , as tentative , as a lower limit , or as bad .
we define reliable pipeline redshifts as those based on at least two spectral features at the same pipeline redshift .
tentative pipeline redshifts are defined as those showing either only a single spectral feature , typically an emission line assumed to be , or showing multiple weak yet potentially real spectral features at the same pipeline redshift .
for spectra only showing absorption features typically associated with intergalactic medium absorption lines ( i.e. , doublets like @xmath622796,2803 , @xmath622374,2382 , etc . )
, we assign redshifts equal to the lower limit derived from the absorption feature and mark those objects redshifts as lower limits .
note that these objects could have redshifts equal to the limit values .
bad pipeline redshifts either show no spectral features , or the pipeline simply assigned an incorrect redshift ( as judged in the visual verification process ) . for objects with tentative and bad pipeline redshifts , we attempt to find a redshift that fits the spectrum better than the pipeline redshift . if we find a better redshift ( i.e. , @xmath632 spectral features at the same redshift , ) then we change that spectrum s redshift status to reliable .
the small number of spectra that show only a single emission line are assigned tentative redshifts assuming the lone emission is .
remaining objects with bad pipeline redshifts are then reclassified as having unknown redshifts .
for spectra with reliable and tentative redshifts we measure the strongest emission line s @xmath33 with iraf , retaining all objects for which this line s
@xmath64 ( assuming tentative redshifts are correct . ) a handful of objects with redshift lower limits from intervening absorption show a single emission feature ; we measure this emission feature s @xmath33 assuming the limit value is the correct redshift .
we fit any blended lines with multiple gaussian components as needed
. we do however reject candidates with h@xmath42/ [ ] complexes that show broad h@xmath42 , even if our deblended line measurements show components with @xmath65 , under the assumption that we underestimate the h@xmath42 line flux and overestimate the [ ] line flux .
most objects with tentative redshifts have such weak features that they undeniably pass the equivalent width cut , especially since they tend to have _ observed - frame _ equivalent widths @xmath66 .
exceptions might be the small number of spectra that show only a single emission line .
for these objects , we estimate _ rest - frame _
@xmath67 by assuming the lone emission is @xmath68
. objects with adequate @xmath61 but unknown redshifts pass our equivalent width cut almost by definition . for objects with reliable , tentative , or lower limit redshifts , we remeasure the h / k break parameter @xmath35 ( if present ) through an automated process , rejecting all objects with measured @xmath69 ( assuming tentative redshifts and derived lower limits are correct . )
we also examine the sdss finding charts of each surviving object to ensure none are obviously blended or contaminated by a nearby object .
finally , we classify each remaining object as either a higher confidence bl lac candidate ( ` bl ' ) or as a lower confidence bl lac candidate ( ` bl ? ' ) .
we require objects classified as ` bl ' to have slightly higher quality spectra , that is @xmath70 in at least one of the three spectral regions described in [ sec : signoise ] .
objects can be classified as ` bl ? ' for any of the following reasons : ( 1 ) the largest calculated @xmath61 , as described in [ sec : signoise ] , has @xmath71 ; ( 2 ) the spectrum passes all criteria , but the object appears close enough to another bright object in its sdss finding chart that flux contamination of the fiber spectrum might be a concern ; or ( 3 ) it is unclear where to define the continuum near an emission line , and the line s
@xmath33 is measured as larger or smaller than 5 depending on the continuum choice .
we classify 426 objects as ` bl ' and 75 as ` bl ? ' .
some sample spectra for objects classified as ` bl ' and ` bl ? '
are shown in figures [ fig : smpbl ] and [ fig : smpmaybe ] respectively .
415351.9 , an example candidate with a reliable redshift ( @xmath72 ) and prominent host galaxy contamination ( h / k depression @xmath73 ) .
_ top right : _
sdss [email protected] , an example of a nearly featureless object with a lower limit redshift ( @xmath75 ) derived from absorption doublets . here ,
absorption lines from @xmath76 and @xmath77 are all observed at the redshift quoted above .
most objects in our sample with redshifts derived from absorption doublets typically only show a single absorption feature . _
bottom left : _
sdss [email protected] , an example of a featureless object with unknown redshift .
_ bottom right : _
sdss [email protected] , an example of a candidate with a reliable redshift ( @xmath78 ) and moderate host galaxy contamination ( @xmath79 ) .
we are careful not to reject objects based on weak features near night sky lines such as 5577 . ] 231217.6 , classified as ` bl ? ' due to low signal - to - noise .
this source has an unknown redshift and does not match to an x - ray source . _ top right : _
sdss [email protected] , potentially shows moderate host galaxy contamination ( @xmath80 ) at a tentative redshift @xmath81 .
this object is classified as ` bl ? ' due to low signal - to - noise , and it has an x - ray match in rass . _ bottom left : _
sdss [email protected] , shows moderate host galaxy contamination ( @xmath82 ) at a reliable redshift @xmath83 .
this source is classified as ` bl ? ' because a broad h@xmath42 feature can have @xmath33 larger or smaller than 5 depending on the continuum level chosen near the feature .
this source has an x - ray match in rass . _ bottom right : _
sdss [email protected] , classified as ` bl ? ' due to low signal - to - noise .
this source has a tentative redshift ( @xmath84 ) and does not have an x - ray match in rass . ]
we estimate rest - frame monochromatic luminosities per unit frequency in the radio , optical and x - ray at 5 ghz , 5000 , and 1 kev , respectively .
we adopt a radio spectral index @xmath85 , the average of the 1 jy radio sample @xcite ; and we assume @xmath86 in the optical ( typical of @xcite s probable bl lac candidates ) and @xmath87 in the x - ray ( a value approximately intermediate between lbls and hbls , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
all spectral indices are defined as @xmath88 .
we choose the above reference frequencies and spectral indices for consistency with the bulk of the literature .
radio flux densities at 1.4 ghz are taken from the integrated first flux densities in the sdss database . the sdss filter that includes 5000 in each object s rest frame
is used to estimate optical flux densities .
we assume tentative and lower limit redshifts are correct , and we use the @xmath25 filter for spectra with unknown redshifts ( as 5000 would fall in the @xmath25 filter at the median redshift of our sample . ) extinction corrected magnitudes ( using the @xcite dust maps ) are converted to flux densities using a zero - point of 3631 jy and effective wavelengths 4686 , 6165 , 7481 , and 8931 for @xmath24 , @xmath25 , @xmath53 , and @xmath89 respectively .
we use point spread function ( psf ) magnitudes to reduce potential host galaxy contamination in our optical luminosity calculations , but we note that we might still be overestimating optical luminosities for some nuclei . for the x - ray , we use the @xcite maps and the colden tool in ciao @xcite to estimate the hydrogen column density along each sightline .
we then use these column densities and the portable , interactive multi - mission simulator ( pimms , * ? ? ?
* ) to convert rosat pspc x - ray count rates to absorbed and unabsorbed broad - band ( 0.1 - 2.4 kev ) fluxes .
for each spectrum lacking an x - ray detection we estimate its rass exposure time as the exposure time for the x - ray source in the rass catalog closest to the sdss source s position .
upper limits on rass count rates are then set as 6 counts ( the limit for inclusion in the rass faint source catalog , * ? ? ?
* ) divided by the exposure time , and limits on x - ray fluxes are calculated as described above .
monochromatic luminosities are then calculated from the above radio and optical flux densities and the unabsorbed x - ray fluxes , assigning a redshift z=0.297 ( the median reliable redshift of our 426 higher confidence candidates ) to objects with unknown redshifts .
we then calculate the broad - band spectral indices @xmath90 , @xmath91 , and @xmath92 . , is defined as @xmath93 . here , @xmath94 , @xmath95 , and @xmath96 , where @xmath97 , @xmath98 , and @xmath99 are the specific luminosities ( per unit frequency ) at 5 ghz , 5000 , and 1 kev respectively . ] throughout , we make no attempt to correct luminosities for the effects of relativistic beaming .
we have very little contamination from random mismatches between sdss and first source positions .
figure [ fig : dist ] ( top ) shows differences between sdss and first positions for our 501 bl lac candidates .
@xcite find first positions to be accurate to @xmath100 at the 90% confidence level , and @xmath101 of our sdss / first bl lac candidates have sdss source positions within @xmath20 of the first radio position . while x - ray emission is not a criterion for inclusion in our sample
, the bottom panel of figure [ fig : dist ] pleasantly confirms that we have a low false x - ray match rate as well : of our 230 x - ray matches , 89% have positional differences less than @xmath102 .
this is consistent with expectations from @xcite , who find 90% of objects in the rass catalog with stellar optical counterparts to have x - ray source positions within @xmath102 of the optical counterparts positions . as another test on the level of contamination , we recorrelate all 501 bl lac candidates to the first and rass catalogs after randomly offsetting the sdss source positions by up to @xmath103 and @xmath104 respectively ( i.e. , 10 times the corresponding match radii . ) we perform the recorrelation 10 times , requiring each offset to be larger than each match radius . on average
we obtain only 6 random matches to a first or to a rass source in each offsetting test , reaffirming a very low level of potential contamination ( @xmath105 ) due to positional mismatches .
of each first position .
_ bottom panel : _ differences between sdss and rass source positions for the 230 candidates with x - ray detections ; 89% of objects with x - ray detections have sdss positions within @xmath102 of each rass position .
these percentages are consistent with little contamination from positional mismatches between first , sdss , and rass . ]
since our database queries do not include cuts on absorption features other than h / k break strength , we need to remove potential stellar contaminants during manual inspection of the spectra .
manual inspection revealed hundreds of radio stars of various spectral classes identified via common stellar features consistent with zero redshift .
most of these objects would formally fulfill our bl lac selection criteria , but they are rejected since they clearly possess stellar spectra .
we defer substantive discussion of the radio emitting stars for a later publication . as an example
however , we show the spectrum of a previously known cataclysmic variable ( first j102347.6@xmath74003841 , * ? ? ? * ) in the top left panel of figure [ fig : smpcontam ] that was rejected during manual inspection based on emission line strength . to test the potential level of stellar contamination in our final sample , we examine proper motion information from the sdss+usno - b proper motion catalog @xcite .
proper motions are available for @xmath260% of our sample , and we assume objects with proper motion information are representative of the rest of our sample .
@xcite find 95% of a sub - sample of spectroscopically confirmed quasars with @xmath106 in the sdss+usno - b catalog to have proper motions @xmath107 milli - arcsec year@xmath5 .
figure [ fig : pm ] shows a histogram of proper motions for 279 bl lac candidates with proper motion detections and @xmath108 ; @xmath109 show @xmath110 milli - arcsec year@xmath5 . about half of our bl lac candidates with measured @xmath111 milli - arcsec year@xmath5 have reliable or tentative redshifts .
we therefore do not believe galactic sources to be important contaminants to our final sample .
we list 13 bl lac candidates with large cataloged proper motions ( @xmath112 milli - arcsec yr@xmath5 ) and unknown redshifts in table [ tab : bigpm ] .
we give object names in column ( 1 ) , our classifications as a higher confidence ( ` bl ' ) or lower confidence ( ` bl ? ' ) candidate in column ( 2 ) , the measured proper motions ( in milli - arcsec yr@xmath5 ) from the sdss dr5 database in column ( 3 ) , psf - magnitudes in the @xmath25 filter in column ( 4 ) , and integrated radio fluxes from first in mjy in column ( 5 ) .
only one object ( sdss j094432.33 + 573536.1 ) has an x - ray detection in rass .
these sources could potentially be unusually featureless radio stars , and they deserve careful follow - up , such as , for example , proper motion measurements with very long baseline interferometry .
we do not reject these sources , however , since we do not have proper motion information for every sdss object and the number of objects with large proper motion measurements is consistent with random expectations from @xcite .
ccccc [email protected] & bl ? & 11.7 & 19.76 & 2.63 + [email protected] & bl & 52.5 & 19.87 & 1.86 + [email protected] & bl ? & 54.5 & 19.89 & 24.67 + [email protected] & bl ? & 13.9 & 20.36 & 2.02 + [email protected] & bl & 12.1 & 19.23 & 7.09 + [email protected] & bl & 22.4 & 18.53 & 13.29 + [email protected] & bl & 14.2 & 18.57 & 41.81 + [email protected] & bl & 14.1 & 19.21 & 468.49 + [email protected] & bl & 38.8 & 18.64 & 53.64 + [email protected] & bl & 40.6 & 19.22 & 83.40 + [email protected] & bl ? & 13.3 & 20.16 & 3.35 + [email protected] & bl & 25.1 & 18.51 & 22.21 + [email protected] & bl ?
& 11.2 & 18.68 & 31.63 + 003841 ( sdss [email protected] ) , a previously known cataclysmic variable ( cv , see [ sec : radiostars ] ) . this is the only cv recovered by our database query , and it was rejected during manual inspection based on emission line strength . _
top right : _
sdss [email protected] ( @xmath113 ) , an e+a galaxy ( see [ sec : radgal ] ) .
this object is rejected as a post star forming galaxy based on h@xmath114 absorption . _
bottom left : _
sdss [email protected] ( @xmath115 ) .
this object is rejected as a broad absorption line quasar ( balqso , see [ sec : bal ] ) . ] ; these 279 candidates all have proper motion information available in the sdss database , and 91% show @xmath116 milli - arcsec year@xmath5 , consistent with little stellar contamination in our final sample .
about half of the objects with @xmath111 milli - arcsec year@xmath5 have reliable or tentative redshifts . ]
radio emitting galaxies are contaminants returned in relatively large numbers by our database query .
most contaminating radio galaxies are easily identified through emission lines with @xmath117 and are rejected during manual inspection .
some radio galaxies however can be more challenging to recognize .
for example , some objects show spectra with a weak h / k break due to an increased blue continuum not from nuclear activity but rather from a recent episode of star formation ( e.g. , e+a ellipticals or other post - starburst galaxies . ) post - starburst galaxies with weak emission lines would formally pass our selection criteria .
we therefore reject post - starburst galaxies if h@xmath114 shows a @xmath33 larger than 5 in absorption absorption is a common proxy for post - starbust galaxies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
] , and/or if h+h@xmath118 is significantly stronger than k ( as suggested by @xcite to reduce galaxy contamination in bl lac samples ) .
a sample spectrum of an e+a galaxy that is rejected during manual inspection based on strong h@xmath114 absorption is shown in the top right panel of figure [ fig : smpcontam ]
. a small fraction of spectra might show small h / k breaks that are not weakened by either nuclear activity or star formation , but they could rather be passive elliptical galaxies with intrinsically small h / k breaks ; this does not appear to be a strong source of contamination however , as @xcite point out that the @xcite sample of over 700 early type galaxies has a mean h / k break of @xmath119 and less than 5% show @xmath120 . while requiring the more stringent ( and historical ) criterion of @xmath121 for inclusion in bl lac samples would essentially eliminate any concern of contamination from passive elliptical galaxies ( e.g. ,
see * ? ? ?
* ) , @xcite argue that doing so misses some weakly beamed bl lacs .
there appears to be a smooth transition between bl lac and radio galaxy spectra , and as noted in [ sec : sampsel ] , the exact h / k break cutoff used to define bl lacs is thus somewhat arbitrary .
bl lac selection criteria are commonly extended to include objects with @xmath34 , as this h / k break cutoff would include most beamed agn , but it is not large enough to produce significant contamination from elliptical galaxies with intrinsically small h / k breaks .
we therefore follow the bulk of the recent literature and use @xmath34 , acknowledging that this might allow a small number of contaminating passive elliptical galaxies into our sample .
polarization and variability follow - on of objects with @xmath122 would be helpful for confirming their classification as bl lacs .
see @xcite for a discussion on recognizing bl lacs from clusters of galaxies .
we investigate in a preliminary fashion potential contamination from non - bl lac objects residing in nearby clusters of galaxies by correlating our bl lac candidates to the @xcite sdss maxbcg cluster catalog .
the @xcite catalog contains 13,823 photometrically selected clusters with velocity dispersions @xmath123 km s@xmath5 from @xmath124 over 7500 deg@xmath9 .
photometric redshifts are given for each cluster , which are estimated to be accurate to @xmath125 from comparison to available spectroscopic redshifts .
we perform the matching with a fixed projected physical linear aperture of radius 0.5 mpc at the photometric redshift of each cluster . among our bl lacs ,
12 higher confidence candidates and 1 lower confidence candidate match to a maxbcg cluster . of these 13 matches , 4 of the bl lac candidates
have no reliable redshift , 5 have reliable redshifts within @xmath126 of the cluster s photometric redshift , and 4 have reliable , tentative or lower limit redshifts larger than the cluster s photometric redshift by at least 0.01 .
table [ tab : clust ] gives the sdss name for these 13 bl lac candidates , our classification ( ` bl ' or ` bl ? ' ) , the angular separation between the bl lac position and the brightest cluster galaxy , each bl lac candidate s spectroscopic redshift , and each cluster s photometric redshift .
all objects pass our selection criteria , even the more stringent constraints aimed toward rejecting post star forming radio galaxies ( see [ sec : radgal ] ) ; only 3 objects have measured h / k break depressions @xmath127 ( the largest is 0.35 ) . thus , contamination from post star forming galaxies or radio galaxies with weak
h / k breaks residing in clusters is likely small , and we retain all 13 objects in our final sample .
bl lacs tend to avoid rich clusters at low redshifts ( @xmath128 , see * ? ? ?
* ) , and it is therefore reassuring that only a very small number of bl lac candidates were returned by our cluster correlation .
we estimate the expected number of chance superpositions by randomly offsetting our bl lac positions by @xmath129 ( the largest angular radius used in our original correlation was @xmath130 ) and recorrelating to the cluster catalog 10 times ; we find 5 chance superpositions on average , and it is reasonable that the 8 bl lac candidates in table [ tab : clust ] with unknown redshifts or redshifts very different than each cluster s redshift could be chance superpositions .
some of the 13 matches ( especially those with a bl lac redshift similar to a cluster redshift ) might be examples of clusters of galaxies hosting a bl lac .
ccccc [email protected] & bl & 27 & 0.226 & 0.224 + [email protected] & bl & 82 & & 0.278 + [email protected] & bl ?
& 186 & & 0.116 + [email protected] & bl & 126 & & 0.151 + [email protected] & bl & 147 & 0.360 & 0.167 + [email protected] & bl & 64 & 0.870 & 0.246 + [email protected] & bl & 63 & 1.812 & 0.197 + [email protected] & bl & 128 & 0.172 & 0.176 + [email protected] & bl & 52 & 0.163 & 0.159 + [email protected] & bl & 68 & 0.199 & 0.205 + [email protected] & bl & 173 & 0.734 & 0.159 + [email protected] & bl & 210 & & 0.122 + [email protected] & bl & 73 & 0.192 &
0.203 + a follow - on polarization study of a subset of 42 of the @xcite optically - selected bl lac candidates revealed all nine @xmath131 objects in that subset lack strong optical polarization ( e.g. , below 3% ) , thereby raising doubts as to whether they should be classifed as bl lacs @xcite .
we note that these results might not be entirely relevant to our sample , as only two of their nine @xmath131 objects with follow - on polarization observations were radio sources .
however , sdss has revealed a number of similar objects at very high redshift , often termed weak - lined quasars , whose optical spectra lack strong emission ( like bl lacs ) , but which also display low polarization and a range of radio emission extending to quite low values ( unlike bl lacs ) ; see @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite for discussions on sdss weak - lined quasars .
thirty - one of our higher confidence bl lac candidates and 14 of our lower confidence bl lac candidates have @xmath131 ( assuming tentative redshifts are correct . ) of our 31 higher confidence bl lac candidates with reliable or tentative redshifts at @xmath131 , there are 5 that appear relatively radio weak ( @xmath132 ) , suggesting that some of our high-@xmath89 candidates are indeed atypical of bl lacs .
given our lack of polarization information we retain all @xmath131 objects .
polarization , variability , and multiwavelength investigations would be enlightening in confirming their classification .
we also recover several objects that formally fulfill our bl lac criteria but are rejected upon manual inspection of their spectra as obvious broad absorption line quasars ( balqsos , see bottom left panel of figure [ fig : smpcontam ] ) .
@xcite discovered two objects , sdss j010540.75 - 003313.9 ( @[email protected] ) and sdss j220445.26 + 003141.9 ( @[email protected] ) , that show a very strange continuum drop - off blueward of a absorption doublet ; both are first radio objects and neither are rass x - ray sources .
both objects also show broad h@xmath42 in the near - infrared ( hall et al .
2008 , in preparation ) .
@xcite were aware of only 2 other objects previously reported in the literature with similar spectra , fbqs 1503 + 2330 ( @[email protected] ) and fbqs 1055 + 3124 ( @[email protected] ) , both of which are also radio sources @xcite . initially , no entirely satisfactory explanation was found for these unusual objects ( see @xcite s 6.1 ) . however , one promising possible explanation suggested by @xcite is that they are extraordinarily unusual balqsos .
interestingly , both the @xcite objects , sdss j0105 - 0033 and sdss j2204 + 0031 , were recovered in our database query , and they formally satisfy all our bl lac selection criteria .
our database query also revealed two additional radio sources whose sdss spectra appear very similar and may be related : sdss j130941.36 + 112540.1 ( @[email protected] ) and sdss j145045.56 + 461504.2 ( @[email protected] ) .
both are again first sources , and again neither new object matches to a rass source .
the sdss spectra of all four objects are shown in figure [ fig : oddbals ] , and table [ tab : oddbal ] displays some basic properties .
redshifts for sdss j0105 - 0033 and sdss j2204 + 0031 are taken from @xcite , while the redshifts for sdss j1309 + 1125 and sdss j1450 + 4615 are estimates based on absorption .
neither of the two new cases , sdss j1309 + 1125 and sdss j1450 + 4615 , ultimately survive as bl lac candidates during manual inspection : they both appear to show broad emission features near /.
we hence exclude the two new cases from our final bl lac catalog , although we retain the original two @xcite objects as lower confidence bl lac candidates .
whatever their nature , this set of radio objects are almost certainly agn and very rare . .
spectra are ordered by increasing redshift and boxcar smoothed with a width of 9 .
none match to a rass x - ray source .
_ top left : _
sdss [email protected] ( @xmath135 ) , published in @xcite this object formally passes our selection criteria , and so it is included as a lower confidence bl lac candidate , though @xcite have suggested it may be a balqso of extreme type .
_ top right : _
sdss [email protected] ( @xmath136 ) , published in @xcite this object again formally passes our selection criteria , and so it is included in our final catalog as a lower confidence bl lac candidate .
_ bottom left : _ sdss [email protected] ( @xmath137 ) .
this new object appears similar , but was ultimately rejected as a bl lac based on emission line strength . _
bottom right : _
sdss [email protected] ( @xmath138 ) .
this new object was also rejected based on emission line strength . ]
cccccccc [email protected] & 1.179 & 20.16 & 19.04 & 17.98 & 17.73 & 17.49 & 4.84 + [email protected] & 1.362 & 21.23 & 19.75 & 18.57 & 17.89 & 17.82 & 0.83 + [email protected] & 1.877 & 21.00 & 20.31 & 19.54 & 18.80 & 18.30 & 1.51 + [email protected] & 1.353 & 19.78 & 18.65 & 17.35 & 16.76 & 16.65 & 3.03 +
table [ tab : stat ] summarizes the number of objects in our final sample , the number with x - ray detections in rass , and some highlighted redshift information .
thus far , from this and previous programs , the sdss spectroscopic survey has already provided several hundred new bl lac candidate identifications ; about 60% of our sample were previously identified as bl lacs by the sdss ( primarily in @xcite or @xcite ) , and @xmath220% of our sample were originally discovered by non - sdss observations .
only 33 of our bl lac candidates appear as quasars in the dr5 quasar catalog @xcite .
although the dr5 quasar catalog does not include bl lac objects , some overlap is expected between our bl lac sample and the quasar catalog , as our bl lac definition can include some very weak emission line objects .
distributions of observed radio flux densities at 1.4 ghz ( in mjy ) , observed optical magnitudes ( sdss @xmath53 ) , and estimated absorbed x - ray fluxes from 0.1 - 2.4 kev ( in erg s@xmath5 @xmath30 , see [ sec : fluxcalc ] ) for all 501 bl lac candidates are shown in figure [ fig : fluxhist ] . ) . _
bottom left : _ estimated log absorbed x - ray fluxes from 0.1 - 2.4 kev in erg s@xmath5 @xmath30 ( see [ sec : fluxcalc ] ) .
_ open histogram : _ all 501 candidates .
_ shaded histogram : _ limits ( denoted with arrows ) for the 271 objects lacking rass detections . ]
data are given in tables [ tab : empdata ] and [ tab : deriveddata ] for our 501 bl lac candidates ( 426 higher confidence and 75 lower confidence candidates . )
table [ tab : empdata ] presents primarily empirical information .
column ( 1 ) gives the sdss source name ( _ sdss [email protected]_ ) , sorted by right ascension .
column ( 2 ) gives our classification as a higher confidence bl lac ( ` bl ' ) or as a lower confidence bl lac ( ` bl ? ' ) candidate .
column ( 3 ) notes whether each source is identified as a bl lac in ned . `
s ' means the source is listed as a bl lac discovered by sdss , ` o ' means the source is listed as a bl lac discovered by a survey other than sdss , and ` n ' means it is not listed as a bl lac in ned
. columns ( 4 ) and ( 5 ) give the sdss coordinates ra and dec ( j2000 ) .
columns ( 6)-(10 ) present @xmath140,@xmath24,@xmath25,@xmath53,@xmath89 psf magnitudes .
column ( 11 ) gives the estimated redshift of each object ( unknown redshifts are left blank ) , and column ( 12 ) presents our redshift flag : ` r ' means we believe the redshift to be reliable , ` t ' is a tentative redshift , ` l ' means the redshift is derived from foreground absorbing gas and should be interpreted as a lower limit , and ` u ' designates an unknown redshift .
column ( 13 ) gives each object s measured h / k break depression c as derived by us ( not the sdss pipeline measure . )
column ( 14 ) gives the first integrated radio flux listed in the sdss dr5 database in mjy @xcite .
finally , additional comments may appear in column ( 15 ) .
we explain in column ( 15 ) why each lower confidence candidate is classified as ` bl ? ' : ` lowsn ' signifies the optical spectrum has measured signal - to - noise @xmath141 ; ` contam ? '
means the spectrum might be contaminated by a nearby source ; and ` ew ' marks the objects with unclear continua , and emission lines can have measured @xmath33 larger or smaller than 5 depending on where one chooses to measure the continuum near each line .
not all sdss discovered bl lac candidates from @xcite and @xcite are identified as bl lacs in ned .
we thus mark such objects in column ( 3 ) as not being listed in ned as a bl lac , but we identify all objects that appear in @xcite and/or @xcite as ` c05 ' and ` a07 ' , respectively , in column ( 15 ) .
table [ tab : deriveddata ] emphasizes derived multiwavelength information for each object ( see [ sec : fluxcalc ] ) .
we repeat sdss source names and redshifts in columns ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) for easy reference to table [ tab : empdata ] .
the 1.4 ghz first integrated radio flux density ( in mjy ) is repeated in column ( 3 ) , with the corresponding 5 ghz rest - frame monochromatic luminosity in column ( 4 ) .
column ( 5 ) gives the extinction corrected optical magnitude in the sdss filter whose center is closest to rest - frame 5000 , taken from the @xmath25 filter for objects with unknown redshift .
column ( 6 ) gives the estimated monochromatic optical luminosity at rest - frame 5000 .
column ( 7 ) is an x - ray match flag , where ` y ' means there is a match to a rass source , and ` n ' means there is no match .
column ( 8) gives the x - ray count rate ( in counts s@xmath5 ) from 0.1 - 2.4 kev @xcite .
the estimated monochromatic unabsorbed x - ray luminosity at rest - frame 1 kev is given in column ( 9 ) .
all monochromatic luminosities have units
erg s@xmath5 hz@xmath5 .
the x - ray count rates and luminosities presented in columns ( 8) and ( 9 ) are upper limits if the x - ray match flag in column ( 7 ) is set to _
n_. finally , columns ( 10 ) , ( 11 ) , and ( 12 ) give the logarithmic broad - band spectral indices @xmath90 , @xmath91 , and @xmath92 respectively .
lower limits to @xmath91 and @xmath92 are given if the x - ray match flag is set to ` n ' .
as discussed in [ sec : queryeff ] , 171 of the @xcite optically selected probable bl lac candidates that match to a first radio source are recovered by our dr5 database query and additionally pass our signal - to - noise cut .
two of these objects however are not included in our final sample .
one object is rejected because it shows broad h@xmath42 in an h@xmath42/ [ ] complex with blended @xmath33 slightly larger than 5 .
the second object is rejected because it shows + with @xmath33 slightly larger than 5 . the @xcite x - ray selected sample contains 244 objects that match to a first source in the dr5 spectroscopic database .
( after a cross - correlation to nvss , only 7 objects in the @xcite sample lack radio detections . )
our database query recovers 241 of these objects , of which 223 additionally pass our @xmath61 cut .
only 2 of these 223 objects do not appear in our final radio - selected sample .
both these objects were rejected here based on [ ] emission with @xmath33 slightly larger than 5 .
thus , our final sample reassuringly contains essentially all first sources previously identified as bl lac candidates from sdss spectroscopy .
lccc number of objects & 426 & 75 & 501 + match to rass source & 217 & 13 & 230 + reliable redshifts & 166 & 29 & 195 + tentative redshifts & 58 & 17 & 75 + lower limit redshifts & 32 & 5 & 37 + unknown redshifts & 170 & 24 & 194 + lccrrccccccccrl [email protected] & bl & n & 0.48850 & -10.52148 & 20.66 & 19.74 & 18.77 & 18.26 & 17.86 & 0.252 & r & 0.367 & 32.97 & + [email protected] & bl ? & n & 0.73824 & -0.41315 & 21.10 & 20.63 & 19.89 & 19.22 & 18.85 & 0.523 & r & 0.289 & 159.13 & lowsn + [email protected] & bl & n & 5.42608 & -9.01234 & 20.15 & 19.79 & 19.32 & 18.82 & 18.52 & 0.648 & t & 0.217 & 41.96 & c05 + [email protected] & bl & o & 5.50396 & 0.11610 & 20.48 & 20.04 & 19.28 & 18.87 & 18.55 & 0.306 & r & 0.357 & 1.73 & c05,a07 + [email protected] & bl & n & 9.53543 & 0.22683 & 20.15 & 19.70 & 19.30 & 18.96 & 18.63 & & u & & 89.71 & c05 + lcrccccccccc [email protected] & 0.252 & 32.97 & 31.82 & 18.65 & 29.29 & n & 0.019 & 25.91 & 0.50 & 1.30 & 0.77 + [email protected] & 0.523 & 159.13 & 33.15 & 19.15 & 29.76 & n & 0.015 & 26.63 & 0.67 & 1.20 & 0.85 + [email protected] & 0.648 & 41.96 & 32.75 & 18.46 & 30.16 & n & 0.018 & 26.94 & 0.51 & 1.24 & 0.76 + [email protected] & 0.306 & 1.73 & 30.71 & 19.21 & 29.27 & y & 0.097 & 26.85 & 0.28 & 0.93 & 0.50 + [email protected] & & 89.71 & 32.40 & 19.25 & 29.23 & n & 0.019 & 26.02 & 0.63 & 1.23 & 0.83 +
the following analysis conservatively focuses on the 426 higher confidence bl lac candidates .
results remain virtually unchanged when all 501 candidates are included .
figure [ fig : redshift ] shows a histogram for the 256 higher confidence bl lac candidates with either reliable , tentative or lower limit redshifts . a sizable fraction ( 30% )
have redshifts larger than 0.5 ( 18% with @xmath142 ) , making this a useful sample for testing bl lac properties at @xmath143 .
all objects with @xmath144 have a measured h / k break , but note that we observe a sharp decrease at @xmath145 in the distribution of measured redshifts .
it is possible that some objects with unknown redshifts are examples of highly beamed nearby bl lacs ; however , given the likelihood of detecting host galaxy spectral features from lower redshift objects , it is probable that a significant fraction of these objects are higher redshift between @xmath146 .
( spectra with @xmath147 would start to show ly@xmath42 forests . )
also , highly beamed objects require a low probability geometry and may therefore be less likely to be recovered at lower redshifts where a smaller volume is probed .
are derived from host galaxy features .
the relative number of objects with measured redshifts decreases drastically for redshifts larger than @xmath145 .
however , a sizable fraction ( 30% ) still have measured redshifts larger than 0.5 , making this a useful sample for constraining higher redshift bl lac properties . ] a color - color diagram for our 426 higher confidence bl lac candidates is shown in figure [ fig : optcol ] . objects with rass x - ray detections are marked as blue asterisks , and those lacking x - ray detections are shown as black circles . note that x - ray detected and non - detected bl lac candidates cover the same range of optical colors
that is , the types of bl lacs that can show x - ray emission are not limited to one specific subclass .
the dashed lines mark the region ( @xmath24@xmath134@xmath148 , @xmath25@xmath134@xmath149 ) where @xcite found most stellar contaminants in their optically selected bl lac sample .
we find only 11 objects in this `` _ gri _ box '' ; none show significant proper motion and 8 have tentative or reliable extragalactic redshifts .
this affords added confidence that any potential stellar contamination to our radio sample is extremely small , and it supports the notion that requiring multifrequency information improves bl lac selection efficiency .
however , we note that multifrequency approaches are not as capable of recovering potentially rare ( if extant ) and extremely interesting bl lac sub - populations such as , for example , radio - quiet bl lacs . of a rass source .
we recover x - ray detections at all ranges of optical colors . the _ green star _ depicts the median colors of objects not showing a h / k break in their spectra .
the _ yellow triangle _ marks the median colors of objects with small measured h / k breaks @xmath121 .
the _ red square _ indicates the median colors of objects showing larger h / k breaks @xmath150 .
as expected , objects with more prominent host galaxy features show redder optical colors on average .
the _ dashed lines _ mark the `` _ gri _ box '' identified by @xcite where most stellar contaminants would be expected .
eight of the 11 objects recovered in this box have measured redshifts , supporting our conclusion of little stellar contamination to our sample .
three objects with @xmath151 and/or @xmath152 due to poor flux measurements are omitted from this figure . ]
spectra showing larger h / k depressions tend to have redder optical colors on average .
the red square in figure [ fig : optcol ] marks the median colors of objects whose spectra show larger h / k depressions ( @xmath150 ) , the yellow triangle marks the median colors of spectra showing smaller depressions ( @xmath153 ) , and the green star marks the median colors of spectra that do not show h / k breaks ( either because the break is completely washed out by the agn flux or because the h / k break is redshifted out of the optical spectrum . )
this trend can be seen more directly by examining h / k break strength vs. color for our higher confidence candidates ( figure [ fig : cvgr ] ) .
our optical spectra are the combination of two distinct radiation sources : the host galaxy ( typically an elliptical ) and a typically blue power law continuum from the agn . in the standard bl lac beaming paradigm , objects with their jets
pointed less directly at the observer show less non - thermal continua ( due to less doppler boosting ) , and therefore they exhibit more prominent host galaxy features and redder optical colors .
the open histogram at the bottom of figure [ fig : cvgr ] shows all 192 higher confidence candidates for which we have no measured h / k break ( either because the h / k break is redshifted out of the optical spectrum , or because the object has an unknown redshift so it is impossible to locate 4000 rest - frame . ) the objects without a measured h / k break tend to be bluer on average than those with a larger break ( e.g. , @xmath154 ) .
also note in figure [ fig : cvgr ] that x - ray detected objects are shown as filled circles in the top panel and as a filled histogram in the bottom panel ; we detect x - rays from objects at all ranges of @xmath24@xmath134@xmath25 and h / k break strength . vs. @xmath155 for our higher confidence candidates .
_ top panel : _ objects ( 234 ) with a measured h / k break .
the _ filled circles _ depict objects that match to a rass x - ray source , while the _ open circles _ show those without an x - ray match . _
bottom panel : _ objects without a measured h / k break either because 4000 rest - fame is redshifted out of the sdss spectra or because the objects have unknown redshifts . _
open histogram : _ all 192 higher confidence candidates lacking a measured h / k break .
the _ shaded histogram _ shows the 79 objects with an x - ray detection in rass that also lack h / k break measurements .
objects with more prominent host galaxy contamination ( i.e. , larger @xmath35 ) tend to be redder , as expected in the standard beaming paradigm for the bl lac phenomenon . also note that objects with x - ray detections are recovered at all ranges of @xmath35 and @xmath155 .
two objects with @xmath151 due to poor flux measurements are omitted from this plot . ]
the standard beaming paradigm is further supported through an anti - correlation between h / k break strength and the log specific luminosity , shown in figure [ fig : hkplts ] for the x - ray ( top left ) , optical ( top right ) , and radio ( bottom left ) .
we find linear pearson correlation coefficients @xmath156 and @xmath157 for the logarithm of radio and optical luminosities respectively ; both anti - correlations are significant at the @xmath15899.999% level .
that is , bl lacs appear to be more luminous as we view them more directly along their jet axes .
even though there is an observed trend , the large scatter in figure [ fig : hkplts ] would seem to prohibit the use of h / k break as a sole proxy for predicting accurate luminosities . also , while our sample generally supports the beaming scenario , we note that it is still possible that a minority of sources might have alternative explanations for exhibiting bl lac type characteristics .
detailed investigations of such a possible ( albeit likely rare ) sub - population are beyond the scope of this paper .
we do not show the luminosity distributions in figure [ fig : hkplts ] for objects without a measured h / k break , as only 22 such objects have measured redshifts . the average x - ray , optical and radio luminosities of 10@xmath159 , 10@xmath160 , and 10@xmath161 ( erg s@xmath5
hz@xmath5 ) for these 22 objects however do lie toward toward the bright end of their respective luminosity distributions , as expected .
we note though that all 22 objects are high redshift ( @xmath162 ) and therefore may be observationally biased toward higher luminosities .
the scatter in optical luminosity vs. h / k break is smaller than in the radio or x - ray , as is expected for two optical measures .
bl lacs can have diverse seds , as the peak of the synchrotron component can fall within a range spanning close to 10 orders of magnitude in frequency ( e.g. , see * ? ? ?
for example , two bl lac jets with identical optical brightnesses can have very different radio ( or x - ray ) luminosities depending on the specific shape of each object s sed .
this plausibly introduces excess scatter into the radio and x - ray panels in figure [ fig : hkplts ] , especially since we use the same spectral indices for all objects when estimating luminosities .
also , given the non - simultaneity of our multifrequency data , variability is likely responsible for some of the observed scatter . .
_ top right : _ logarithm of specific optical luminosity at 5000 vs. @xmath35 . _ bottom left : _ logarithm of specific radio luminosity at 5 ghz vs. @xmath35 .
bl lacs tend to appear more luminous at all observed frequencies when viewed more directly along their jet axes ( i.e. , for smaller values of @xmath35 ) .
_ bottom right : _ logarithm of radio to optical specific luminosity ratio vs. @xmath35
. the large range of radio to optical luminosity ratios does not appear to be an orientation effect and rather probably reflects agn jet physics ( e.g. , variability and/or differing seds among bl lac objects . )
note that we obtain x - ray detections at all values of h / k break strength and radio and optical luminosities . ] the bottom right panel of figure [ fig : hkplts ] shows the log of the ratio of radio to optical specific luminosity vs. measured h / k break .
here , we observe no obvious linear trend ( a 28% two - sided probability of randomly finding a stronger correlation ) , but we do see a relatively large scatter .
the large scatter likely confirms either variability and/or that bl lacs do not have a universal sed .
we omit objects lacking h / k break measurements for consistency with the other panels .
the lack of an obvious observed trend with h / k break strength suggests that the large observed range of radio to optical luminosity ratios is not a strong orientation effect and perhaps reflects agn jet physics .
the bottom right panel of figure [ fig : hkplts ] also illustrates one reason that multifrequency surveys should be well matched in depth . a radio survey that is shallower than an optical survey ,
for example , will be biased toward recovering objects with larger radio to optical luminosity ratios ( i.e. , extreme lbls ) .
one needs _ both _ a deep radio and a deep optical survey to recover objects toward the bottom of the bottom right panel of figure [ fig : hkplts ] and to obtain a sample with luminosity ratio distributions more representative of the underlying population .
figures [ fig : optcol]-[fig : hkplts ] demonstrate that bl lacs display continuous distributions in their properties , supporting the notion that the observed dichotomy between radio and x - ray selected bl lacs in the 1 jy and emss samples was indeed plausibly a selection effect induced by small sample size and bright survey flux limits .
this is further supported when examining the @xmath163 plane in figure [ fig : alpha ] ( which shows our 426 higher confidence bl lac candidates . )
blue squares represent objects with x - ray detections ; arrows designate limits on @xmath91 for objects lacking a rass detection . here , large ( small ) values of @xmath90 ( @xmath91 ) correspond to being radio ( x - ray ) bright .
as expected , we observe a continuous transition between lbl and hbl objects corresponding to @xmath164 with the x - ray flux in erg s@xmath5 @xmath30 and the radio flux in jy @xcite .
the dividing line is also sometimes quoted as the similar @xmath165 where both fluxes are in jy @xcite . ] , with plenty of ibl - type objects bridging the transition .
although this preliminary analysis seems to support the notion of a single bl lac population , there are still some differences between historically radio selected and x - ray selected bl lacs that require further attention . for example , xbls appear to have more starlight contamination from their host galaxies , lower polarization levels , and constant polarization position angles ( see [ sec : intro ] ) .
also , xbls and rbls might have very different cosmological evolution .
we see an obvious and expected bias toward rass detected sources preferentially filling the hbl parameter space in figure [ fig : alpha ] : 83% of x - ray emitters appear to be hbls , likely due to the relatively high flux limit of the rass survey
. perhaps counter intuitively however , 66% of our entire higher confidence radio sample ( and 47% of objects lacking rass detections ) still have broad - band colors indicative of hbls .
this may be an artifact of the sdss spectroscopic target selection algorithms , which are biased toward selecting objects near rass sources for spectroscopy ( see [ sec : sampsel ] and figure [ fig : sed ] ) .
keep in mind however that the above percentages are tentative for several reasons .
about half our data points only have limits on their x - ray luminosites ; the non - simultaneity of our multiwavelength data and our monochromatic luminosity estimates also introduce excess scatter .
we also note x - ray detections from some lbls in figure [ fig : alpha ] .
that is , as is similarly observed in figures [ fig : optcol]-[fig : hkplts ] , x - ray emission is detected from objects at nearly all ranges of observed parameters ( objects with @xmath166 being the notable exception , see below . )
while it is certainly plausible that some fraction of radio bright objects lacking x - ray detections are real examples of extreme lbls , the recovery of x - ray sources at all parameters suggests that we do not have evidence for a significant population of x - ray quiet bl lacs .
deeper x - ray observations are necessary for testing this assertion , and selection effects and survey biases need to be examined thoroughly . there is a small population of 7 higher confidence candidates with extremely small @xmath132 , of which only a single ( low - redshift ) object shows x - ray emission , implying that some bl lacs might have atypical broad - band colors .
however , as described in
[ sec : qso ] , five of these objects have redshifts @xmath131 , potentially making their classification as bl lac candidates suspicious .
the other 26 objects in our higher confidence bl lac candidate sample with @xmath131 , however , do not show atypical broad band colors .
we include all @xmath131 objects in our sample without prejudice , as all formally pass our bl lac criteria ; follow - on polarization , variability , and multiwavelength studies of these higher redshift bl lac candidates ( or weak lined quasars ) would be useful . vs. @xmath91 .
radio brightness increases toward the top , and x - ray brightness increases toward the left .
the _ blue squares _ show objects that match to a rass x - ray source while the _ filled circles _ depict objects without an x - ray match ( with arrows designating limits ) .
we again obtain x - ray detections at essentially all ranges of parameters ( with the radio weak @xmath90 tail being the notable exception ) . we observe a continuous distribution of broad - band spectral indices with plenty of ibl and lbl - type objects .
however , we do see a potential bias toward recovering hbls ( @xmath167 ) from sdss spectroscopy , a perhaps unexpected result for a radio - selected sample .
this is maybe an artifact from the sdss spectroscopic target algorithms . ]
looking forward to future applications , the very large size of our homogeneous sdss / first selected sample may ( when coupled with a detailed understanding of selection issues ) permit a number of subsequent bl lac studies ranging from the potentially unusual evolution of the luminosity function of bl lacs ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , to tests of the unification paradigm .
as just one specific future application , consider the standard model that interprets bl lacs as fr i radio galaxies with their jets pointed toward the observer .
ground and space - based observations that resolve bl lac host galaxies tend to support this unification scheme at least for the majority of objects .
an hst survey ( primarily with wfpc2 snap observations ) found strong direct evidence at lower redshifts supporting this scheme @xcite .
however , it is not yet clear whether it holds for every single bl lac
. suggested modifications range from some fraction of bl lacs being hosted by fr ii radio galaxies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) to some fraction being microlensed ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) ; any requisite modifications are likely more significant at higher redshifts
. moreover , some caution may be appropriate when extrapolating the urry et al .
hst survey results to higher redshifts , as only 6 host galaxies with @[email protected] were actually resolved due to limited wfpc2 snap exposure times .
even if one conservatively disregards our 75 lower confidence bl lac candidates and all bl lac candidates with @xmath131 , our sample still contains a sizable number ( 46 ) of higher confidence bl lac candidates with confirmed @xmath168 suitable for host galaxy investigations .
if observed with current and upcoming _ hst _ instruments , our sample could potentially provide an important extension to the @xmath168 regime of the well - established low redshift unification results .
we have assembled a 501 object sample of bl lac candidates selected jointly from sdss dr5 optical spectroscopy and first radio imaging : there are 426 higher confidence candidates and 75 lower confidence candidates .
all 501 objects emerge with homogeneous multi - wavelength data coverage from first , sdss and rass . after imposing a signal to noise cut on the sdss spectra
, we require all emission features to have @xmath169 and , if present , a h / k depression @xmath34 .
special attention is given to remove radio galaxies , radio stars , broad absorption line quasars , and other weak - featured objects that might otherwise formally pass our selection criteria .
of particular interest , in addition to recovering 2 unusual radio agn reported previously in @xcite , we found 2 additional objects possibly of the same class .
we recover essentially all previous sdss selected bl lac candidates that match to first sources in @xcite and @xcite , increasing confidence in our selection technique . of our 501 bl lac candidates , approximately 80% are sdss discoveries
( including objects first reported by @xcite , @xcite , or @xcite ) . approximately 60% of our 501 bl lac candidates have either a reliable redshift ( derived from at least 2 spectral features at the same redshift ) , a tentative redshift ( derived from a single emission line assumed to be , or from multiple weak spectral features at the same redshift ) , or a redshift lower limit derived from common intervening absorption line doublets . of our 256 higher confidence candidates with spectroscopic redshifts measured from sdss spectroscopy ,
30% have @xmath143 , and 18% have @xmath168 , making this an excellent sample for constraining higher redshift bl lac properties .
almost half of our higher confidence candidates match within @xmath23 to a rass x - ray source .
we find x - ray detections for bl lacs at practically all ranges of parameter space ( i.e. , optical colors , multi - wavelength luminosities , h / k break strengths , etc . ) , suggesting that there is not a significant population of x - ray quiet bl lacs .
perhaps surprisingly , only about one - third of our higher confidence radio - selected candidates have broad - band spectral indices indicative of lbls .
this may be an artifact of the sdss spectroscopy targeting algorithms that could bias spectroscopic observations in favor of objects near x - ray sources .
however , we still recover a large number of ibl / lbl - type objects ; follow - up of this sample will therefore probe a wide range of bl lac physics .
our sample supports the general concurrence that bl lacs display a continuous distribution of properties , but we stress that the historical differences between xbls and rbls still need to be accounted for and require further attention .
a preliminary analysis seems consistent with the standard beaming model , in that more highly beamed ( i.e. , more luminous ) objects show weaker host galaxy features .
we also see indirect evidence for variability and/or diverse sed shapes , and we note that multi - wavelength surveys should be well - matched in depth to recover unbiased bl lac samples .
our sdss / first bl lac sample constitutes one of the largest homogeneous samples to date , with the attractive attribute that all objects emerge with the same high - quality radio , optical , and x - ray data . a thorough investigation of the selection effects that shape this sample s composition may allow follow - on studies to place useful constraints on bl lac properties ranging from evolution to unification models , especially extending to the high - redshift tail of the bl lac population .
we gratefully thank the referee for providing excellent suggestions for improving this manuscript .
r.m . plotkin and s.f .
anderson acknowledge support from nasa / adp grant nng05gc45 g .
funding for the sdss and sdss - ii has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , the national science foundation , the u.s .
department of energy , the national aeronautics and space administration , the japanese monbukagakusho , the max planck society , and the higher education funding council for england .
the sdss web site is http://www.sdss.org/. the sdss is managed by the astrophysical research consortium for the participating institutions .
the participating institutions are the american museum of natural history , astrophysical institute potsdam , university of basel , cambridge university , case western reserve university , university of chicago , drexel university , fermilab , the institute for advanced study , the japan participation group , johns hopkins university , the joint institute for nuclear astrophysics , the kavli institute for particle astrophysics and cosmology , the korean scientist group , the chinese academy of sciences ( lamost ) , los alamos national laboratory , the max - planck - institute for astronomy ( mpia ) , the max - planck - institute for astrophysics ( mpa ) , new mexico state university , ohio state university , university of pittsburgh , university of portsmouth , princeton university , the united states naval observatory , and the university of washington . , e. s. , padovani , p. , landt , h. , stocke , j. t. , costamante , l. , rector , t. , giommi , p. , & schachter , j. f. 2001 , in astronomical society of the pacific conference series , vol .
227 , blazar demographics and physics , ed .
p. padovani & c. m. urry , 200 , j. t. , morris , s. l. , gioia , i. m. , maccacaro , t. , schild , r. e. , & wolter , a. 1989 , in lecture notes in physics , berlin springer verlag , vol .
334 , bl lac objects , ed .
l. maraschi , t. maccacaro , & m .- h .
ulrich , 242 | we present a large sample of 501 radio - selected bl lac candidates from the combination of the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) data release 5 optical spectroscopy and from the faint images of the radio sky at twenty - centimeters ( first ) radio survey ; this is one of the largest bl lac samples yet assembled , and each object emerges with homogeneous data coverage .
each candidate is detected in the radio from first and confirmed in sdss optical spectroscopy to have : ( 1 ) no emission feature with measured rest equivalent width larger than 5 ; and ( 2 ) no measured h / k depression larger than 40% .
we subdivide our sample into 426 higher confidence candidates and 75 lower confidence candidates .
we argue that contamination from other classes of objects that formally pass our selection criteria is small , and we identify a few very rare radio agn with unusual spectra that are probably related to broad absorption line quasars .
about one - fifth of our sample were known bl lacs prior to the sdss .
a preliminary analysis of the sample generally supports the standard beaming paradigm .
while we recover sizable numbers of low - energy and intermediate - energy cutoff bl lacs ( lbls and ibls , respectively ) , there are indications of a potential bias toward recovering high - energy cutoff bl lacs ( hbls ) from sdss spectroscopy .
such a large sample may eventually provide new constraints on bl lac unification models and their potentially peculiar cosmic evolution ; in particular , our sample contains a significant number of higher redshift objects , a sub - population for which the standard paradigm has yet to be rigorously constrained . |
consider a bounded subset @xmath0 of @xmath8 .
we would like to find an arrangement of @xmath11 affine hyperplanes in @xmath8 that cut through @xmath0 as evenly as possible ; see figure [ fig : tessellation ] for an illustration .
the intuitive notion of an `` even cut '' can be expressed more formally in the following way : the fraction of the hyperplanes separating any pair @xmath2 should be proportional ( up to a small additive error ) to the euclidean distance between @xmath3 and @xmath4 . what is the smallest possible number @xmath12 of hyperplanes with this property ? besides having a natural theoretical appeal , this question is directly motivated by a certain problem of information theory which we will describe later . in the beginning
it will be most convenient to work with subsets @xmath0 of the unit euclidean sphere @xmath13 , but we will lift this restriction later .
let @xmath14 denote the normalized geodesic distance on @xmath13 , so the distance between the opposite points on the sphere equals @xmath15 .
a ( linear ) hyperplane in @xmath8 can be expressed as @xmath16 for some @xmath17 .
we say that points @xmath18 are separated by the hyperplane , so we define it as @xmath19 for @xmath20 and @xmath21 for @xmath22 . ] if @xmath23 .
consider a subset @xmath24 and an arrangement of @xmath11 hyperplanes in @xmath8 .
let @xmath25 denote the fraction of the hyperplanes that separate points @xmath3 and @xmath4 in @xmath8 .
given @xmath26 , we say that the hyperplanes provide a _
@xmath27-uniform tessellation _ of @xmath0 if @xmath28 the main result of this paper is a bound on the minimal number @xmath29 of hyperplanes that provide a uniform tessellation of a set @xmath0 .
it turns out that for a fixed accuracy @xmath27 , an almost optimal estimate on @xmath11 depends only on one global parameter of @xmath0 , namely the mean width .
recall that the _ gaussian mean width _ of @xmath0 is defined as @xmath30 where @xmath31 is a standard gaussian random vector in @xmath8 .
[ thm : tessellations ] consider a subset @xmath24 and let @xmath32 .
let @xmath33 and consider an arrangement of @xmath11 independent random hyperplanes in @xmath8 uniformly distributed according to the haar measure .
then with probability at least @xmath34 , these hyperplanes provide a @xmath27-uniform tessellation of @xmath0 . here and later
@xmath35 denote positive absolute constants . by the rotation invariance of the haar measure
, it easily follows that @xmath36 for each pair @xmath18 .
theorem [ thm : tessellations ] states that with high probability , @xmath25 almost matches its expected value _
uniformly _ over all @xmath2 .
this observation highlights the principal difference between the problems studied in this paper and the classical problems on random hyperplane tessellations studied in stochastic geometry .
the classical problems concern the shape of a _ specific _ cell ( usually the one containing the origin ) or certain _ statistics _ of cells ( e.g. `` how many cells have volume greater than a fixed number '' ? ) , see @xcite .
in contrast to this , the concept of uniform tessellation we propose his paper concerns _ all _ cells simultaneously ; see section [ s : cells ] for a vivid illustration . theorem [ thm : tessellations ] has an equivalent formulation in the context of metric embeddings .
it yields that _ every subset @xmath24 can be almost isometrically embedded into the hamming cube @xmath9 with @xmath5_. to explain this statement , let us recall a few standard notions .
an @xmath37-isometry ( or almost isometry ) between metric spaces @xmath38 and @xmath39 is a map @xmath40 which satisfies @xmath41 and such that for every @xmath42 one can find @xmath43 satisfying @xmath44 .
a map @xmath40 is an @xmath37-isometric embedding of @xmath45 into @xmath46 if the map @xmath47 is an @xmath37-isometry between @xmath38 and the subspace @xmath48 .
it is not hard to show that @xmath45 can be @xmath49-isometrically embedded into @xmath46 ( by means of a suitable map @xmath50 ) if @xmath45 has the gromov - haussdorff distance at most @xmath37 from some subset of @xmath46 .
conversely , if there is an @xmath37-isometry between @xmath45 and @xmath51 then the gromov - haussdorff distance between @xmath45 and @xmath51 is bounded by @xmath37 . finally , recall that the hamming cube is the set @xmath9 with the ( normalized ) hamming distance @xmath52 the fraction of the coordinates where @xmath53 and @xmath54 are different . an arrangement of @xmath11 hyperplanes in @xmath8
defines a _ sign map _
@xmath55 which sends @xmath56 to the sign vector of the orientations of @xmath3 with respect to the hyperplanes .
the sign map is uniquely defined up to the isometries of the hamming cube .
let @xmath57 be normals of the hyperplanes , and consider the @xmath58 matrix @xmath59 with rows @xmath60 .
the sign map can be expressed as @xmath61 where @xmath62 denotes the vector of signs of the coordinates @xmath63 of @xmath64 .
the fraction @xmath25 of the hyperplanes that separate points @xmath3 and @xmath4 thus equals @xmath65 then looking back at the definition of uniform tessellations , we observe the following fact : [ fact : embeddings ] consider a @xmath27-uniform tessellation of a set @xmath24 by @xmath11 hyperplanes .
then the set @xmath0 ( with the induced geodesic distance ) can be @xmath27-isometrically embedded into the hamming cube @xmath9 .
the sign map provides such an embedding .
this allows us to state theorem [ thm : tessellations ] as follows : [ thm : embeddings ] consider a subset @xmath24 and let @xmath32 .
let @xmath66 then @xmath0 can be @xmath27-isometrically embedded into the hamming cube @xmath9 .
moreover , let @xmath59 be an @xmath58 random matrix with independent @xmath67 entries .
then with probability at least @xmath34 , the sign map @xmath68 is an @xmath27-isometric embedding .
the image of the sign map @xmath50 in has a special meaning .
when the hamming cube @xmath9 is viewed as a graph ( in which two points @xmath53 , @xmath54 are connected if they differ in exactly one coordinate ) , the image of @xmath50 defines a subgraph of @xmath9 , which is called the _ tessellation graph _ of @xmath0 .
the tessellation graph has a vertex for each cell and an edge for each pair of adjacent cells , see figure [ fig : tessellation - graph ] .
notice that the graph distance in the tessellation graph equals the number of hyperplanes that separate the two cells
. therefore the definition of a uniform tessellation yields : [ fact : graph ] consider a @xmath27-uniform tessellation of a set @xmath24 .
then @xmath0 is @xmath27-isometric to the tessellation graph of @xmath0 .
hence we can read the conclusion of theorem [ thm : tessellations ] as follows : _
@xmath0 is @xmath27-isometric to the graph of its tessellation by @xmath11 random hyperplanes , where @xmath69_. powerful methods to estimate the mean width @xmath6 have been developed in connection with stochastic processses .
these methods include sudakov s and dudley s inequalities which relate @xmath6 to the covering numbers of @xmath0 in the euclidean metric , and the sharp technique of majorizing measures ( see @xcite ) .
mean width has a simple ( and known ) geometric interpretation . by the rotational invariance of the gaussian random vector @xmath70 in
, one can replace @xmath70 with a random vector @xmath71 that is uniformly distributed on @xmath13 , as follows : @xmath72 here @xmath73 are numbers that depend only on @xmath74 and such that @xmath75 and @xmath76 .
we may refer to @xmath77 as the _ spherical mean width _ of @xmath0 .
let us assume for simplicity that @xmath0 is symmetric with respect to the origin .
then @xmath78 is the width of @xmath0 in the direction @xmath71 , which is the distance between the two supporting hyperplanes of @xmath0 whose normals are @xmath71 .
the spherical mean width @xmath77 is then twice the average width of @xmath0 over all directions .
our results are already non - trivial in the particular case @xmath79 . since @xmath80 ,
theorems [ thm : tessellations ] and [ thm : embeddings ] hold with @xmath81 . but more importantly
, many interesting sets @xmath82 satisfy @xmath83 and therefore make our results hold with @xmath84 . in such cases
, one can view the sign map @xmath85 in theorem [ thm : embeddings ] as a dimension reduction mechanism that transforms an @xmath74-dimensional set @xmath0 into a subset of @xmath9 .
a heuristic reason why dimension reduction is possible is that the quantity @xmath86 measures the _ effective dimension _ of a set @xmath24 .
the effective dimension @xmath86 of a set @xmath24 is always bounded by the algebraic dimension , but it may be much smaller and it is robust with respect to perturbations of @xmath0 . in this regard ,
the notion of effective dimension is parallel to the notion of effective rank of a matrix from numerical linear algebra ( see e.g. @xcite ) . with these observations in mind ,
it is not surprising that the `` true '' , effective dimension of @xmath0 would be revealed ( and would be the only obstruction according to theorem [ thm : embeddings ] ) when @xmath0 is being squeezed into a space of smaller dimension .
let us illustrate dimension reduction on the example of finite sets @xmath82 .
since @xmath87 ( see e.g. ( * ? ? ?
* ( 3.13 ) ) ) , theorem [ thm : embeddings ] holds with @xmath88 , and we can state it as follows .
[ cor : jl ] let @xmath82 be a finite set .
let @xmath26 and @xmath89 .
then @xmath0 can be @xmath27-isometrically embedded into the hamming cube @xmath9 .
this fact should be compared to the _ johnson - lindenstrauss lemma _ for finite subsets @xmath90 ( @xcite , see ( * ? ? ?
* section 15.2 ) ) which states that if @xmath91 then @xmath0 can be lipschitz embedded into @xmath92 as follows : @xmath93 here @xmath94 is the rescaled random gaussian matrix @xmath59 from theorem [ thm : embeddings ] . note
that while the johnson - lindenstrauss lemma involves a lipschitz embedding from @xmath8 to @xmath92 , it is generally impossible to provide a lipschitz embedding from subsets of @xmath8 to the hamming cube ( if there are points @xmath95 that are very close to each other ) ; this is why we consider @xmath27-isometric embeddings . like the johnson - lindenstrauss lemma ,
corollary [ cor : jl ] can be proved directly by combining concentration inequalities for @xmath25 with a union bound over @xmath96 pairs @xmath97 .
in fact , this method of proof allows for the weaker requirement @xmath98 .
however , as we discuss later , this argument can not be generalized in a straightforward way to prove theorem [ thm : embeddings ] for general sets @xmath0 .
the hamming distance @xmath25 is highly discontinuous , which makes it difficult to extend estimates from points @xmath99 in an @xmath37-net of @xmath0 to nearby points .
we mentioned two nice features of uniform tessellations in facts [ fact : embeddings ] and [ fact : graph ] .
let us observe one more property : all cells of a uniform tessellation have small diameter .
indeed , @xmath100 iff points @xmath99 are in the same cell , so by we have : [ fact : cells ] every cell of a @xmath27-uniform tessellation has diameter at most @xmath27 . with this , theorem [ thm : tessellations ] immediately implies the following : [ cor : cells ] consider a tessellation of a subset @xmath24 by @xmath101 random hyperplanes .
then , with probability at least @xmath102 , all cells of the tessellation have diameter at most @xmath27 .
this result has also a direct proof , which moreover gives a slightly better bound @xmath103 .
we present this `` curvature argument '' in section [ sec : curvature ] .
so far , we only worked with subsets @xmath24 .
it is not difficult to extend our results to bounded sets @xmath90 .
this can be done by embedding such a set @xmath0 into @xmath104 ( the sphere in one more dimension ) with small bi - lipschitz distortion .
this elementary argument is presented in section [ sec : rn ] , and it yields the following version of theorem [ thm : tessellations ] : [ thm : tessellations rn ] consider a bounded subset @xmath90 with @xmath105 .
let @xmath106 then there exists an arrangement of @xmath11 affine hyperplanes in @xmath8 and a scaling factor @xmath107 such that @xmath108 here @xmath25 denotes the fraction of the affine hyperplanes that separate @xmath3 and @xmath4 .
[ rem : k - k ] while the quantity @xmath109 appearing in is clearly bounded by @xmath110 , it is worth noting that the quantity @xmath109 captures more accurately than @xmath6 the geometric nature of the `` mean width '' of @xmath0 .
indeed , @xmath111 where @xmath112 is the distance between the two parallel supporting hyperplanes of @xmath0 orthogonal to the random direction @xmath70 , scaled by @xmath113 .
the main object of our study is @xmath114 , the smallest number of hyperplanes that provide a @xmath27-uniform tessellation of a set @xmath24 .
one has @xmath115 where @xmath116 denotes the covering number of @xmath0 , i.e. the smallest number of balls of radius @xmath27 that cover @xmath0 .
the upper bound in is the conclusion of theorem [ thm : tessellations ] .
the lower bound holds because a @xmath27-uniform tessellation provides a decomposition of @xmath0 into at most @xmath117 cells each of which lies in a ball of radius @xmath27 by fact [ fact : cells ] . to compare the upper and lower bounds in , recall sudakov s inequality ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 3.18 ) that yields @xmath118 while sudakov s inequality can not be reversed in general , there are many situations where it is sharp . moreover , according to dudley s inequality ( see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 11.17 ) and ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 2.33 ) ) , sudakov s inequality can always be reversed for some scale @xmath26 and up to a logarithmic factor in @xmath74 .
( see also @xcite for a discussion of sharpness of sudakov s inequality . )
so the two sides of are often close to each other , but there is in general some gap .
we conjecture that the optimal estimate is @xmath119 so the mean width of @xmath0 seems to be completely responsible for the uniform tessellations of @xmath0 .
note that the lower bound in holds in greater generality .
namely , it is not possible to have @xmath120 for _ any _ decomposition of @xmath0 into @xmath117 pieces of diameter at most @xmath27 .
however , from the upper bound we see that with a slightly larger value @xmath121 , _ an almost best decomposition of @xmath0 is achieved by a random hyperplane tessellation_. in this paper we have not tried to optimize the dependence of @xmath122 on @xmath27 .
this interesting problem is related to the open question on the optimal dependence on distortion in dvoretzky s theorem .
we comment on this in section [ sec : dvoretzky ] .
embeddings of subsets @xmath24 into normed spaces were studied in geometric functional analysis @xcite . in particular , klartag and mendelson @xcite
were concerned with embeddings into @xmath123 .
they showed that for @xmath124 there exists a linear map @xmath125 such that @xmath126 one can choose @xmath59 to be an @xmath58 random matrix with gaussian entries as in theorem [ thm : embeddings ] , or with sub - gaussian entries .
schechtman @xcite gave a simpler argument for a gaussian matrix , which also works for embeddings into general normed spaces @xmath45 .
in the specific case of @xmath127 , schechtman s result states that for @xmath124 one has @xmath128 this result also follows from lemma [ lem : concentration ] below .
our present work was motivated by the development of _ one - bit compressed sensing _ in @xcite where theorem [ thm : embeddings ] is used in the following context .
the vector @xmath3 represents a signal ; the matrix @xmath59 represents a measurement map @xmath129 that produces @xmath130 linear measurements of @xmath3 ; taking the sign of @xmath64 represents quantization of the measurements ( an extremely coarse , one - bit quantization ) .
the problem of one - bit compressed sensing is to recover the signal @xmath3 from the quantized measurements @xmath85 .
the problem of one - bit compressed sensing was introduced by boufounos and baraniuk @xcite .
jacques , laska , boufounos and baraniuk @xcite realized a connection of this problem to uniform tessellations of the set of sparse signals @xmath131 , and to almost isometric embedding of @xmath0 into the hamming cube @xmath9 . for this
set @xmath0 , they proved corollary [ cor : cells ] with @xmath132 and a version of theorem [ thm : embeddings ] for @xmath133 .
the authors of the present paper analyzed in @xcite a bigger set of `` compressible '' signals @xmath134 and proved for @xmath135 a version of corollary [ cor : cells ] with @xmath136 . since the mean widths of both sets @xmath0 and @xmath135 are of the order @xmath137 , theorem [ thm : embeddings ] holds for these sets with @xmath138 .
in other words , apart from the dependence of @xmath27 ( which is an interesting problem ) , the prior results follow as partial cases from theorem [ thm : embeddings ] .
it is important to note that theorem [ thm : embeddings ] addresses only the theoretical aspect of one - bit compressed sensing problem , which guarantees that the quantized measurement map @xmath85 well preserves the geometry of signals .
but one also faces an algorithmic challenge how to efficiently recover @xmath3 from @xmath139 , and specifically in polynomial time .
we will not touch on this algorithmic aspect here but rather refer the reader to @xcite and to our forthcoming work which is based on the results of this paper .
_ locality - sensitive hashing _ is a method of dimension reduction .
one takes a set of high - dimensional vectors in @xmath8 and the goal is to hash nearby vectors to the same bin with high probability .
more generally , one may desire that the distance between bins be nearly proportional to the distance between the original items .
there have been a number of papers which suggest to create such mappings onto the hamming cube @xcite , some of which use a random hyperplane tessellation as defined in this paper .
the new challenge considered herein is to create a locality - sensitve hashing for an infinite set .
let us briefly describe our proof of the results stated above . since the distance in the hamming cube @xmath9 can be expressed as @xmath140 , the hamming cube is isometrically embedded in @xmath141 . before trying to embed @xmath24 into the hamming cube as claimed in theorem [ thm : embeddings ]
, we shall make a simpler step and embed @xmath0 almost isometrically into the bigger space @xmath141 with @xmath142 .
a result of this type was given by schechtman @xcite . in section [ sec : into ell1 ] we prove a similar result by a simple and direct argument in probability in banach spaces .
our next and non - trivial step is to re - embed the set from @xmath141 into its subset , the hamming cube @xmath9 . in section [ sec : curvature ]
we give a simple `` curvature argument '' that allows us to deduce corollary [ cor : cells ] on the diameter of cells , and even with a better dependence on @xmath27 , namely @xmath103 .
however , a genuine limitation of the curvature argument makes it too weak to deduce theorem [ thm : tessellations ] this way .
we instead attempt to prove theorem [ thm : tessellations ] by an @xmath37-net argument , which typically proceeds as follows : ( a ) show that @xmath143 holds for a fixed pair @xmath2 with high probability ; ( b ) take the union bound over all pairs @xmath99 in an finite @xmath37-net @xmath144 of @xmath0 ; ( c ) extend the estimate from @xmath144 to @xmath0 by approximation .
unfortunately , as we indicate in section [ sec : soft ] the approximation step ( c ) must fail due to the discontinuity of the hamming distance @xmath25 .
a solution proposed in @xcite was to choose @xmath37 so small that none of the random hyperplanes pass near points @xmath145 with high probability .
this strategy was effective for the set @xmath131 because the covering number of this specific set @xmath0 has a mild ( logarithmic ) dependence on @xmath37 , namely @xmath146 .
however , adapting this strategy to general sets @xmath0 would cause our estimate on @xmath11 to increase by a factor of @xmath74 .
the solution we propose in the present paper is to `` soften '' the hamming distance ; see section [ sec : soft ] for the precise notion .
the _ soft hamming distance _ enjoys some continuity properties as described in lemmas [ lem : continuity ] and [ lem : continuity l1 ] . in section [ sec : proof tessellations ]
we develop the @xmath37-net argument for the soft hamming distance .
interestingly , the approximation step ( c ) for the soft hamming distance will be based on the embedding of @xmath0 into @xmath141 , which incidentally was our point of departure . throughout the paper , @xmath147 , @xmath148 , @xmath149 , etc
. denote positive absolute constants whose values may change from line to line . for integer @xmath74 ,
we denote @xmath150 = \{1,\ldots , n\}$ ] .
the @xmath151 norms of a vector @xmath56 for @xmath152 are defined as is not a norm on @xmath8 . ]
@xmath153 : x(i ) \ne 0 \ } | , \ ; \|x\|_1 = \sum_{i=1}^n |x_i| , \ ; \|x\|_2 = \big ( \sum_{i=1}^n x_i^2 \big)^{1/2 } , \ ; \|x\|_\infty = \max_{i \in [ n ] } |x_i|.\ ] ] we shall work with normed spaces @xmath154 for @xmath155 . the unit euclidean ball in @xmath8 is denoted @xmath156 and the unit euclidean sphere is denoted @xmath157 . as usual
, @xmath67 stands for the univariate normal distribution with zero mean and unit variance , and @xmath158 stands for the multivariate normal distribution in @xmath8 with zero mean and whose covariance matrix is identity @xmath159 .
[ lem : concentration ] consider a bounded subset @xmath90 and independent random vectors @xmath161 in @xmath8 .
let @xmath162 \(a ) one has @xmath163
\(b ) the following deviation inequality holds : @xmath164 where @xmath165 .
\(a ) note that @xmath166 for all @xmath167 .
let @xmath168 be a sequence of iid rademacher random variables .
a standard symmetrization argument ( see ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 6.3 ) ) followed by the contraction principle ( see ( * ? ? ? * theorem 4.12 ) ) yields that @xmath169 by the rotational invariance of the gaussian distribution , @xmath170 is distributed identically with @xmath171 where @xmath172 .
therefore @xmath173 this proves the upper bound in .
\(b ) we combine the result of ( a ) with the gaussian concentration inequality . to this end
, we must first show that the map @xmath174 is lipschitz where @xmath175 is considered as a matrix in the space @xmath176 equipped with frobenius norm @xmath177 ( which coincides with the euclidean norm on @xmath176 ) .
it follows from two applications of the triangle inequality followed by two applications of the cauchy - schwarz inequality that for @xmath178 we have @xmath179 thus @xmath180 has lipschitz constant bounded by @xmath181 .
we may now bound the deviation probability for @xmath180 using the gaussian concentration inequality ( see ( * ? ? ? * equation 1.6 ) ) as follows : @xmath182 the deviation inequality now follows from the bound on @xmath183 from ( a ) .
[ rem : rmt ] one can state lemma [ lem : concentration ] in terms of random matrices .
indeed , let @xmath59 be an @xmath58 random matrix with independent @xmath67 entries .
then its rows @xmath60 satisfy the assumption of lemma [ lem : concentration ] , and we can express @xmath180 as @xmath184 using this remark for the set @xmath185 , we obtain a linear embedding of @xmath0 into @xmath160 : [ cor : into l1 ] consider a subset @xmath186 and let @xmath26 .
let @xmath187 then , with probability at least @xmath188 , the linear map @xmath189 defined as @xmath190 is a @xmath27-isometry .
thus @xmath0 can be linearly embedded into @xmath141 with gromov - haussdorff distortion at most @xmath27 .
let @xmath59 be the random matrix as in remark [ rem : rmt ] .
using lemma [ lem : concentration ] for @xmath185 and noting the form of @xmath180 in , we conclude that the following event holds with probability at least @xmath188 : @xmath191 the above argument shows in fact that corollary [ cor : into l1 ] holds for @xmath192 as we noticed in remark [ rem : k - k ] , the quantity @xmath109 more accurately reflects the geometric meaning of the mean width than @xmath6 . note that for the subspace @xmath193 we have from that @xmath194
. then lemma [
lem : concentration ] implies that @xmath195 by rotation invariance of gaussian distribution , inequality holds for a random subspace @xmath196 in @xmath8 of given codimension @xmath197 , uniformly distributed according to the haar measure .
this result recovers ( up to the absolute constant @xmath198 which can be improved ) the so - called _
low m@xmath199 estimate _ from geometric functional analysis , see ( * ? ? ?
* section 15.1 ) .
as we emphasized in the introduction , for many sets @xmath90 one has @xmath200 .
in such cases corollary [ cor : into l1 ] works for @xmath130 .
the embedding of @xmath0 into @xmath141 yields dimension reduction for @xmath0 ( from @xmath74 to @xmath201 dimensions ) .
for example , if @xmath0 is a finite set then @xmath87 ( see e.g. ( * ? ? ? * ( 3.13 ) ) ) , and so corollary [ cor : into l1 ] applies with @xmath88 .
this gives the following variant of the _ johnson - lindenstrauss lemma _ : every finite subset of a euclidean space can be linearly embedded in @xmath141 with @xmath202 and with small distortion in the gromov - haussdorff metric .
stronger variants of johnson - lindenstrauss lemma are known for _ lipschitz _ rather than gromov - haussdorff embeddings into @xmath123 and @xmath141 @xcite . however , for general sets @xmath0 ( in particular for any set with nonempty interior ) a lipschitz embedding into lower dimensions is clearly impossible ; still a gromov - haussdorff embedding exists due to corollary [ cor : into l1 ] .
in this section we give a short argument that leads to a version of corollary [ cor : cells ] with a slightly better dependence of @xmath11 on @xmath27 .
[ thm : cells ] consider a subset @xmath24 and let @xmath32 .
let @xmath203 and consider an arrangement of @xmath11 independent random hyperplanes in @xmath8 that are uniformly distributed according to the haar measure . then , with probability at least @xmath204 , all cells of the tessellation have diameter at most @xmath27 .
the argument is based on lemma [ lem : concentration ] .
if points @xmath2 belong to the same cell , then the midpoint @xmath205 also belongs to the same cell ( after normalization ) . using lemma [ lem : concentration ] one
can then show that @xmath206 . due to the curvature of the sphere , this forces the length of the interval @xmath207 to be small , which means that the diameter of the cell is small .
the formal argument is below .
we represent the random hyperplanes as @xmath208 , where @xmath161 are independent random vectors in @xmath8 .
let @xmath209 be as in the assumptions of the theorem .
we shall apply lemma [ lem : concentration ] for the sets @xmath0 and @xmath210 and for @xmath211 , where we set @xmath212 . since the diameters of both these sets are bounded by @xmath15
, we obtain that with probability at least @xmath204 the following event holds : @xmath213 assume that the event holds .
consider a pair of points @xmath2 that belong to the same cell of the tessellation , which means that @xmath214.\ ] ] to complete the proof is suffices to show that @xmath215 .
this will give desired diameter @xmath27 in the euclidean metric .
furthermore , since for small @xmath27 the euclidean and the geodesic distances are equivalent , the conclusion will hold for the geodesic distance as well .
we shall use for @xmath216 and for the midpoint @xmath217 .
clearly @xmath218 , hence @xmath219.\ ] ] therefore we obtain from that @xmath220 - \e \\ & \ge \frac{1}{2 } ( \|x\|_2-\e + \|y\|_2-\e ) - \e = 1 - 2\e .
\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] by the parallelogram law , we conclude that @xmath221 this completes the proof . unfortunately , the curvature argument does not lend itself to proving the more general result , theorem [ thm : tessellations ] on uniform tessellations . to see why ,
suppose @xmath2 do not belong to the same cell but instead @xmath222 for some small @xmath223 .
consider the set of mismatched signs @xmath224:\ ; \operatorname*{sign}\ < a_i , x\ > \ne \operatorname*{sign}\ < a_i , y\ >
\big\ } ; \qquad \frac{|t|}{m } = d.\ ] ] these signs create an additional error term in the right hand side of , which is @xmath225 by analogy with lemma [ lem : concentration ] , we can expect that this term should be approximately equal @xmath226 .
if this is true , then becomes in our situation @xmath227 , which leads as before to @xmath228 .
ignoring @xmath37 , we see that the best estimate the curvature argument can give is @xmath229 rather than @xmath230 that is required in theorem [ thm : tessellations ] .
the weak point of this argument is that it takes into account the size of @xmath231 but ignores the nature of @xmath231 . for every @xmath232 ,
the hyperplane @xmath208 passes through the arc connecting @xmath3 and @xmath4 .
if the length of the arc @xmath14 is small , this creates a strong constraint on @xmath60 .
conditioning the distribution of @xmath60 on the constraint that @xmath232 creates a bias toward smaller values of @xmath233 and @xmath234 . as a result
, the conditional expected value of the error term should be smaller than @xmath235 .
computing this conditional expectation is not a problem for a given pair @xmath99 , but it seems to be difficult to carry out a uniform argument over @xmath2 where the ( conditional ) distribution of @xmath60 depends on @xmath99 .
we instead propose a different and somewhat more conceptual way to deduce theorem [ thm : tessellations ] from lemma [ lem : concentration ] .
this argument will be developed in the rest of this paper .
the unusual dependence @xmath236 in theorem [ thm : cells ] is related to the open problem of the optimal dependence on distortion in the dvoretzky theorem .
indeed , consider the special case of the tessellation problem where @xmath79 and @xmath237 .
then lemma [ lem : concentration ] in its geometric formulation ( see equation and corollary [ cor : into l1 ] ) states that @xmath238 embeds into @xmath141 whenever @xmath239 , meaning that @xmath240 where @xmath241 .
equivalently , there exists an @xmath74-dimensional subspace of @xmath141 that is @xmath242-euclidean , where @xmath243 .
this result recovers the well known dvoretzky theorem in v. milman s formulation ( see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 4.2.1 ) ) for the space @xmath141 , and with the best known dependence on @xmath37 .
however , it is not known whether @xmath244 is the optimal dependence for @xmath141 ; see @xcite for a discussion of the general problem of dependence on @xmath37 in dvoretzky theorem .
these observation suggest that we can reverse our logic .
suppose one can prove dvoretzky theorem for @xmath141 with a better dependence on @xmath37 , thereby constructing a @xmath242-euclidean subspace of dimension @xmath245 with @xmath246
. then such construction can replace lemma [ lem : concentration ] in the curvature argument .
this will lead to theorem [ thm : cells ] for @xmath79 with an improved dependence on @xmath27 , namely with @xmath247 .
concerning lower bounds , the best possible dependence of @xmath11 on @xmath27 should be @xmath248 , which follows by considering the case @xmath249 .
this dependence will be achieved if dvoretzky theorem for @xmath141 is valid with @xmath250 .
this is unknown .
our proof of theorem [ thm : tessellations ] will be based on a covering argument .
a standard covering argument of geometric functional analysis would proceed in our situation as follows : a. show that @xmath143 with high probability for a fixed pair @xmath99 .
this can be done using standard concentration inequalities .
b. prove that @xmath143 uniformly for all @xmath99 in a finite @xmath37-net @xmath144 of @xmath0 .
sudakov s inequality can be used to estimate the cardinality of @xmath144 via the mean width @xmath6 .
the conclusion will follow from step 1 by the union bound over @xmath251 . c. extend the estimate @xmath143 from @xmath145 to @xmath2 by approximation . while the first two steps are relatively standard , step ( c ) poses a challenge in our situation .
the hamming distance @xmath25 is a discontinuous function of @xmath99 , so it is not clear whether the estimate @xmath143 can be extended from a pair points @xmath145 to a pair of nearby points .
in fact , for some tessellations this task is impossible . figure [ fig : non - uniform - tessellation ] shows that there exist very non - uniform tessellations that are nevertheless very uniform for an @xmath37-net , namely one has @xmath252 for all @xmath145 .
the set @xmath0 in that example is a subset of the plane @xmath253 , and one can clearly embed such a set with into the sphere @xmath254 as well .
\times [ -\frac{\e}{2},\frac{\e}{2}]$ ] is very non - uniform , as all cells have diameter at least @xmath15 .
the tessellation is nevertheless very uniform for the @xmath37-net @xmath255 , as @xmath256 for all @xmath145.,height=83 ] to overcome the discontinuity problem , we propose to work with a soft version of the hamming distance .
recall that @xmath11 hyperplanes are determined by their normals @xmath257 , which we organize in an @xmath58 matrix @xmath59 with rows @xmath60 .
then the usual ( `` hard '' ) hamming distance @xmath25 on @xmath8 with respect to @xmath59 with can be expressed as @xmath258 consider an @xmath58 matrix @xmath59 with rows @xmath259 , and let @xmath260 .
the _ soft hamming distance _
@xmath261 on @xmath8 is defined as @xmath262 both positive and negative @xmath263 may be considered . for positive @xmath263
the soft hamming distance counts the hyperplanes that separate @xmath99 well enough ; for negative @xmath263 it counts the hyperplanes that separate or nearly separate @xmath99 .
clearly @xmath261 is a non - increasing function of @xmath263 .
moreover , @xmath264 the soft hamming distance for a fixed @xmath263 is as discontinuous as the usual ( hard ) hamming distance .
however , some version of continuity emerges when we allow @xmath263 to vary slightly : [ lem : continuity ] let @xmath265 , and assume that @xmath266 , @xmath267 for some @xmath268 .
then for every @xmath260 one has @xmath269 consider the events @xmath270 from the definition of the soft hamming distance . by the assumptions
, we have @xmath271 , @xmath272 for all @xmath273 $ ] .
this implies by the triangle inequality that @xmath274 the conclusion of the lemma follows .
we are ready to state a stronger version of theorem [ thm : tessellations ] for the soft hamming distance .
[ thm : tessellations soft ] consider a subset @xmath24 and let @xmath32 .
let @xmath33 and pick @xmath260 .
consider an @xmath58 random ( gaussian ) matrix @xmath59 with independent rows @xmath161 . then with probability at least @xmath102 ,
one has @xmath275 note that if we take @xmath276 in the above theorem , we recover theorem [ thm : tessellations ] . however , we find it easier to prove the result for general @xmath263 , since in our argument we will work with different values of the @xmath263 for the soft hamming distance . theorem [ thm : tessellations soft ] is proven in the next section .
we will follow the covering argument outlined in the beginning of section [ sec : soft ] , but instead of @xmath25 we shall work with the soft hamming distance @xmath261 . at the first step , we will check that @xmath277 with high probability for a fixed pair @xmath99 .
let us first verify that this estimate holds in expectation , i.e. that @xmath278 .
one can easily check that @xmath279 so we may just compare @xmath280 to @xmath281 .
here is a slightly stronger result : [ eq : edt ed ] let @xmath59 be a random gaussian matrix be as in theorem [ thm : tessellations soft ] .
then , for every @xmath260 and every @xmath18 , one has @xmath282 the first inequality follows from and jensen s inequality .
to prove the second inequality , we use the events @xmath283 and @xmath284 from equations , defining the hard and soft hamming distances , respectively .
it follows that @xmath285 now we upgrade lemma [ eq : edt ed ] to an concentration inequality : [ lem : concentration dist ] let @xmath59 be a random gaussian matrix as in theorem [ thm : tessellations soft ] .
then , for every @xmath260 and every @xmath18 , the following deviation inequality holds : @xmath286 by definition , @xmath287 has the binomial distribution @xmath288 . the parameter @xmath289 satisfies by lemma [ eq : edt ed ] that @xmath290 a standard chernoff bound for binomial random variables states that @xmath291 see e.g. ( * ?
* corollary a.1.7 ) .
the triangle inequality completes the proof .
let us fix a small @xmath268 whose value will be determined later .
let @xmath144 be an @xmath37-net of @xmath0 in the euclidean metric .
by sudakov s inequality ( see ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 3.18 ) ) , we can arrange the cardinality of @xmath144 to satisfy @xmath292 we can decompose every vector @xmath7 into a _ center _
@xmath293 and a _ tail _
@xmath294 so that @xmath295 we first control the centers by taking a union bound in lemma [ lem : concentration dist ] over the net @xmath144 : [ lem : concentration net ] let @xmath59 a random gaussian matrix be as in theorem [ thm : tessellations soft ] .
let @xmath144 be a subset of @xmath13 whose cardinality satisfies .
let @xmath26 , and assume that @xmath296 let @xmath260 .
then the following holds with probability at least @xmath297 : @xmath298 by lemma [ lem : concentration net ] and a union bound over the set of pairs @xmath299 , we obtain @xmath300 where the last inequality follows by and .
the proof is complete .
now we control the tails @xmath301 in decomposition .
[ lem : tails ] consider a subset @xmath24 and let @xmath268 .
let @xmath302 consider independent random vectors @xmath161 .
then with probability at least @xmath303 , one has @xmath304 let us apply lemma [ lem : concentration ] for the set @xmath305 instead of @xmath0 , and for @xmath306 .
since @xmath307 , we obtain that the following holds with probability at least @xmath308 : @xmath309 note that @xmath310 . so using the assumption on @xmath11 we conclude that the quantity in is bounded by @xmath37 , as claimed .
now we establish a way to transfer the distance estimates from an @xmath37-net @xmath144 to the full set @xmath0 .
this is possible by a continuity property of the soft hamming distance , which we outlined in lemma [ lem : continuity ] .
this result requires the perturbation to be bounded in @xmath311 norm .
however , in our situation the perturbations are going to be bounded only in @xmath312 norm due to lemma [ lem : tails ] .
so we shall prove the following relaxed version of continuity : [ lem : continuity l1 ] let @xmath265 , and assume that @xmath313 , @xmath314 for some @xmath268 .
then for every @xmath260 and @xmath315 one has @xmath316 consider the events @xmath270 from the definition of the soft hamming distance . by the assumptions , we have @xmath317 therefore , the set @xmath224:\ ; |\ < a_i , x'\ >
| \le m\e , \ ; |\ < a_i ,
y'\ > | \le m\e \big\ } \quad \text{satisfies } \quad |t^c| \le 2m / m.\ ] ] by the triangle inequality , we have @xmath318 therefore @xmath319 this proves the first inequality in .
the proof of the second inequality is similar .
now we are ready to combine all the pieces and prove theorem [ thm : tessellations soft ] .
to this end , consider the set @xmath0 , numbers @xmath27 , @xmath11 , @xmath263 , and the random matrix @xmath59 as in the theorem .
choose @xmath320 and @xmath321 .
consider an @xmath37-net @xmath144 of @xmath0 as we described in the beginning of section [ sec : over net ] .
let us apply lemma [ lem : concentration net ] that controls the distances on @xmath144 along with lemma [ lem : tails ] that controls the tails . by the assumption on @xmath11 in the theorem and by our choice of @xmath37 , both requirements on @xmath11 in these lemmas hold . by a union bound , with probability at least @xmath322
the following event holds : for every @xmath323 and @xmath324 , one has @xmath325
let @xmath2 . as we described in
, we can decompose the vectors as @xmath326 the bounds in guarantee that the continuity property in lemma [ lem : continuity l1 ] holds .
this gives @xmath327 furthermore , using we have @xmath328 it follows that @xmath329 finally , by the choice of @xmath37 and @xmath330 we obtain @xmath331 a similar argument shows that @xmath332 we conclude that @xmath333 this completes the proof of theorem [ thm : tessellations soft ] .
in this section we deduce theorem [ thm : tessellations rn ] from theorem [ thm : tessellations ] by an elementary lifting argument into @xmath334 .
we shall use the following notation : given a vector @xmath56 and a number @xmath260 , the vector @xmath335 is the concatenation of @xmath56 and @xmath263 .
furthermore , @xmath336 denotes the set of all vectors @xmath337 where @xmath7 .
fix a large number @xmath341 whose value will be chosen later and consider the set @xmath342 where @xmath343 denotes the spherical projection map @xmath344 .
we have @xmath345 where the last inequality holds because @xmath346 by .
arbitrary vectors @xmath3 and @xmath4 in @xmath0 and the corresponding vectors @xmath350 and @xmath351 in @xmath135 .
let us relate the distances between @xmath294 and @xmath352 appearing in to corresponding distances between @xmath3 and @xmath4 .
let @xmath353 denote normals of the hyperplanes . clearly ,
@xmath294 and @xmath352 are separated by the @xmath167-th hyperplane if and only if @xmath337 and @xmath354 are .
this in turn happens if and only if @xmath3 and @xmath4 are separated by the affine hyperplane that consists of all @xmath56 satisfying @xmath355 .
in other words , the hyperplane tessellation of @xmath135 induces an _ affine _ hyperplane tessellation of @xmath0 , and the fraction @xmath356 of the hyperplanes separating @xmath294 and @xmath352 equals the fraction of the affine hyperplanes separating @xmath3 and @xmath4 . with a slight abuse of notation ,
we express this observation as @xmath357 next we analyze the normalized geodesic distance @xmath358 , which satisfies @xmath359 denoting @xmath360 and @xmath361 and using the triangle inequality , we obtain @xmath362 note that yields that @xmath363 .
it follows that @xmath364 and the same bound holds for the other two similar terms in . using this and
we conclude that @xmath365 . putting this into and using the triangle inequality twice ,
we obtain @xmath366 finally , we use this bound and in , which gets us @xmath367 now we can assign the values @xmath368 and @xmath369 so the right hand side of is bounded by @xmath27 , as required . note that the condition @xmath347 that we used above in order to apply theorem [ thm : tessellations ] is satisfied by .
this completes the proof of theorem [ thm : tessellations rn ] .
a. e. litvak , v. d. milman , a. pajor , n. tomczak - jaegermann , _ on the euclidean metric entropy of convex bodies _ , geometric aspects of functional analysis , 221235 , lecture notes in math .
, 1910 , springer , berlin , 2007 .
s. mendelson , _ a few notes on statistical learning theory_. in : advanced lectures in machine learning .
edited by s. mendelson and a. j. smola .
lecture notes in computer science 2600 , 140 .
springer , 2003 . | given a subset @xmath0 of the unit euclidean sphere , we estimate the minimal number @xmath1 of hyperplanes that generate a uniform tessellation of @xmath0 , in the sense that the fraction of the hyperplanes separating any pair @xmath2 is nearly proportional to the euclidean distance between @xmath3 and @xmath4 .
random hyperplanes prove to be almost ideal for this problem ; they achieve the almost optimal bound @xmath5 where @xmath6 is the gaussian mean width of @xmath0 . using the map that sends @xmath7 to the sign vector with respect to the hyperplanes , we conclude that every bounded subset @xmath0 of @xmath8 embeds into the hamming cube @xmath9 with a small distortion in the gromov - haussdorff metric . since for many sets @xmath0
one has @xmath10 , this yields a new discrete mechanism of dimension reduction for sets in euclidean spaces . _
keywords : _ embedding ; dimension reduction ; hyperplane tessellations ; mean width ; near isometry |
small bodies in the inner solar system are historically classified based on their appearance .
comet refers to an object with extended appearance and sometimes one or several tails ; while asteroid refers to an object that is much smaller than the major planets and appears star - like .
classification by orbital dynamics of these bodies shows that the dynamical characteristics of the two groups of objects differ as well : comets usually possess highly elliptical , parabolic or hyperbolic orbits , while asteroids usually possess more circular orbits .
bodies which deviate from these trends ( i.e. comets in asteroidal orbits , or asteorids in cometary orbits ) are of significant interest , as their dynamical evolution and/or physical properties are apparently exceptional .
although the first such outlier was officially recognized no later than 1989 ( e.g. the case of 95p/(2060 ) chiron , c.f .
* ) , most outliers were not found until recently with the commissioning of a number of near - earth asteroid searching / follow - up programs . due to their distinct appearance , comet - like objects in asteroid - like orbits , or `` active asteroids '' @xcite , are more straightforward to recognize due to their significant morphological change during the transition to comet - like state , and so the recognition is usually robust .
in contrast , their counterparts , asteroid - like objects in cometary orbits ( acos ) , due to their nature , are considerably more difficult to identify . from an orbital perspective , acos are most easily interpreted to be comets that have exhausted their volatiles ( or have their volatiles permanently buried by their crusts ) so that they appear asteroidal , i.e. they become `` dormant comets '' .
however , dynamical studies have shown that a significant fraction of acos could be asteroids leaking out from the main - belt that are temporarily residing in comet - like orbits @xcite , therefore complicating the effort on disentangle orbital properties from physical properties of these bodies .
one approach to identify dormant comets in the aco population is to look at comets at an intermediate state between active comets and dormant comets , sometimes labeled as comet - asteroid transition objects ( catos ; e.g. * ? ? ?
a handful of such objects have been suggested , such as 107p/(4015 ) wilson - harrington @xcite , 209p / linear @xcite and ( 3552 ) don quixote @xcite .
however , these objects are usually faint and produce little dust , presenting a challenge for further investigation of their surface and dust properties .
15p / finlay , a jupiter - family comet ( jfc ) , has been reportedly faint and tail - less since its discovery in 1886 @xcite .
the comet has a small minimum orbit intersection distance ( moid ) of 0.0094 au to the earth s orbit , but has never been associated with any known meteor shower @xcite .
coupled with the fact that 15p / finlay has shown a systematic decrease of maximum brightness at each perihelion passage in the past century it has been suggested that the comet is approaching a state of complete dormancy @xcite
. however , during its current perihelion passage , 15p / finlay exhibited two outbursts , each producing a parabolic `` shell '' around the original coma accompanied by a straight , freshly - formed `` tail '' in the anti - sunward direction .
this resembles the historic outburst of 17p / holmes in 2007 @xcite albeit at a much smaller scale .
however , it is notable that 17p / holmes s outbursts took place at a larger heliocentric distance ( 2.4 au ) than those of 15p / finlay ( @xmath11 au ) , therefore the underlying mechanism may not be necessarily the same although the similarity of their overall appearances is striking .
the outbursts of 15p / finlay are significant in another context : as an earth - approaching comet , the outburst ejecta may find their way to the earth , creating a meteor outburst .
previously , numerical simulation by mikhail maslov has suggested that the material released in 2014 will have a direct encounter with the earth in 2021 , which may produce a meteor outburst with zenith hourly rate ( zhr ) up to 50 .
recent calculation by mikiya sato also arrived at similar results .
an outburst from the parent comet may result in a stronger meteor event depending on the ejection velocity and planetary perturbation .
potential meteor observations allow us to directly sample materials from a dormant comet candidate without a dedicated space mission , which may help in understanding the comet itself as well as the dormant comets as a population .
in particular , meteor activity from acos can help establish prior periods of activity and constrain the dust production history of acos .
in this work , we present an analysis of the observations of 15p / finlay taken during the two 2014/2015 outbursts .
the goal is to understand the underlying nature of the outburst as well as the evolutionary status of the comet .
we also examine the yet - to - be - discovered finlayid meteor shower and especially the potential 2021 meteor outburst .
non - detection of the shower places constraints on past dust production history of 15p / finlay .
the first outburst of 15p / finlay took place in the late hours of 2014 dec .
15 , the timing being constrained by reports from christopher wyatt ( walcha , australia ; dec .
15.43 ut ) and slooh.com chile observatory ( la dehesa , chile ; dec . 16.04 ut ) . during the outburst ,
the comet brightened by about 3 magnitudes and developed a spiky tail .
the tail diluted into the background with the brightness returning to its normal range by dec .
2122 ( figure [ fig : report]a , [ fig : morp1 ] ) .
the second outburst took place around 2015 jan .
16.0 ut as noted by alan hale ( cloudcroft , nm ) at jan . 16.07 who noted `` very bright , almost star - like central condensation '' that was absent in the earlier observations .
the last negative observation comes from the solar wind anisotropies all - sky hydrogen ly-@xmath12 camera ( swan ) on - board the solar and heliospheric observatory ( soho ) @xcite around jan .
15.5 ut . the outburst was subsequently noted independently by guo zheng - qiang ( shenyang , china ; jan .
16.43 ut ) and michael mattiazzo ( swan hill , australia ; jan . 16.45 ut ) , as well as on the swan image taken near jan .
16.5 ut ( next to the last non - detection image ) . the comet brightened by about 45 magnitudes during the second outburst , again with a freshly - formed tail .
the brightness returned to the normal range around jan .
20 ( figure [ fig : report]b ) , but the tail lingered for a few more days until around jan .
30 ( figure [ fig : morp2 ] ) . after receiving the reports of the outbursts , 15p / finlay was monitored using the facilities at f(/ph)otometric robotic atmospheric monitor ( fram ) located at pierre auger observatory ( argentina ) , xingming observatory ( china ) and vicksburg ( u.s . ) .
the fram observations were conducted with a 0.3-m f/6.6 telescope equipped with a kodak kaf-1603me sensor , which gives a resolution of @xmath13 ; the xingming observations were conducted with a 0.35-m f/6.9 telescope with a kodak kaf-8300 sensor , images are binned by 2 , which gives a resolution of @xmath14 .
the vicksburg observations were conducted with a 0.3-m f/10 telescope equipped with kodak kaf-1600 sensor which gives a resolution of @xmath15 .
the observations at fram and vicksburg are intended for dust modeling , as such they were conducted with a cousins @xmath16 filter that blocks flux from major cometary gaseous emissions ( such as cn , c@xmath17 , c@xmath18 ) .
the xingming observations were conducted with wider temporal coverage but without a filter , intended as a continuous monitor of the development of the outburst .
details of the observations are summarized in table [ tbl : obs - summary ] .
the images are processed using standard procedure ( bias subtraction , dark subtraction , flat division ) , with plate constants solved using ucac 4 catalog @xcite .
the images are then medianly combined following the motion of the comet .
the composite images from fram and vicksburg are collapsed into a 1-dimensional profile .
this is necessary as the considerable irregularities of the near - nucleus dust ( i.e. localized jets ) complicate the modeling work .
the orbital plane angle at the two outbursts were also shallow enough ( @xmath19 ) to minimize the information loss during the image collapse .
the 1-dimensional profile is simply derived from averaging a @xmath20 wide strip along the sun - comet axis , with the width of @xmath20 corresponding to the maximum width of the tail .
the composite images from the monitoring observations at xingming ( figure [ fig : morp1 ] and [ fig : morp2 ] ) show that the morphologies and evolution of both outbursts are comparable : both outbursts produced a newly - formed dust shell that is slightly asymmetric with respect to the comet - sun axis ; the dust shell expands as time goes by and fades into the background within @xmath21 week .
we perform aperture photometry with the xingming data .
this is motivated by the considerable scatter shown on the magnitudes provided by the minor planet center ( mpc ) , possibly due to different instrumental and measurement settings adopted by different observers .
data from fram and vicksburg is not used at this stage to avoid the complication due to instrumental differences .
we use an aperture of @xmath22 km as projected at the distance of the comet centered at the nucleus .
both 0.35-m and mpc magnitudes are reduced to `` normalized '' magnitudes at @xmath23 au using @xmath24 , where @xmath25 and @xmath26 are normalized and observed nuclear magnitudes , @xmath27 and @xmath28 are heliocentric and geocentric distances in au , and @xmath29 is the canonical brightening rate exponent @xcite .
the photometric calibration is performed using the v - band data from the aavso all - sky photometric survey ( apass ) catalog @xcite as the xingming system is most sensitive at v - band .
as shown in figure [ fig : report ] , the characteristic outburst decay time ( i.e. the time elapsed from the peak of the outburst to the point that the brightness reaches @xmath30 of the peak brightness ) is estimated to be at the order of 1 d. to understand the dust produced by the outburst event , we model the observations using a monte carlo dust model developed in our earlier works ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the dynamical evolution of the cometary dust is controlled by the ratio between radiation pressure and solar gravity , @xmath31 , where @xmath32 is the bulk density of the dust and @xmath33 the diameter of the dust , both in si units @xcite , as well as the initial ejection velocity of the dust .
the latter is defined as @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the mean ejection speed of a dust particle of @xmath36 and @xmath37 follows a gaussian probability density function : @xmath38 where @xmath39 is the standard deviation of @xmath37 , used to account for the physical spread @xmath37 due to the shape of the dusts . in this work
we use @xmath40 following exploration by , e.g. @xcite and @xcite .
we assume the dust size follows a simple power - law with a differential size index of @xmath41 , and the that observed flux is solely contributed by scattered light from the dust particles .
hence , the dust production rate is expressed as @xmath42 where @xmath43 is the mean dust production rate of @xmath44 particles .
simulated particles are symmetrically released from the nucleus . for both outbursts ,
two possible outburst epochs are tested , each correspond to either the epochs of the last negative ( non - outburst ) report or the first positive report .
for the first outburst , outburst epochs of 2014 dec .
15.4 ut ( as indicated by wyatt s negative report ) and 16.0 ut ( indicated by slooh.coms positive report ) are tested ; for the second outburst , outburst epochs of 2015 jan .
15.5 ut ( indicated by soho / swan s negative report ) and 16.0 ut ( indicated by hale s positive report ) are tested .
the production rate peaks at the outburst epoch and decays exponentially at a characteristic time of 1 d as discussed in
[ sec : morphology ] .
the size distribution is set to the interval of @xmath45 to an upper size limit constrained by the escape speed @xmath46 where @xmath47 is the total mass of the nucleus , @xmath48 the bulk density of the nucleus , @xmath49 km the effective nucleus radius @xcite , and @xmath50 the characteristic distance that gas drag become negligible @xcite .
we only consider @xmath45 as ( 1 ) optical observations are most sensitive to @xmath51 ( micron - sized ) particles ; ( 2 ) larger particles stay closer to the nucleus ( as gravitational force dominates ) , models with @xmath52 are incompatible with the observations as they are not able to reproduce the obscured extended dust tails ; and ( 3 ) complications arise for the dynamics of @xmath53 ( submicron - sized ) particles as there are also subjected to lorentz forces .
we use the mercury6 package @xcite to integrate particles from the start epoch ( i.e. the outburst epoch ) to the observation epoch , using the 15th order radau integrator @xcite . to accommodate the uncertainty in the exact epoch of the outburst , multiple outburst epochs , cued by the reports discussed in
[ sec : obs - reports ] , are tested in the simulation .
the production of simulated particles peaks at the assumed outburst epoch and decays exponentially afterwards , with a characteristic decay time of 1 d as found earlier in
[ sec : morphology ] .
gravitational perturbations from the eight major planets ( the earth - moon system is represented by a single mass at the barycenter of the two bodies ) , radiation pressure and poynting - robertson effect are included in the integration .
15p / finlay s orbital elements are extracted from the jpl small body database elements k085/15 ( http://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/sbdb.cgi ) as listed in table [ tbl : mdl - orb ] .
the resulting modeled image is convolved with a 2-dimensional gaussian function ( with fwhm equal to the fwhm of the actual images ) to mimic observational effects such as the instrumental point spread effect and atmospheric seeing .
the modeled image is then collapsed into a 1-dimensional profile as what was done with the observations ( [ sec : obs - morphological ] ) .
observed and modeled surface brightness profiles are normalized to 3 fwhms beyond the nucleus along the sun - comet axis .
we mask out the region within 1 fwhm from the nucleus to avoid contamination of the signal from the nucleus .
the region that is dominated by submicron - sized dust ( i.e. the tailward region that is too far from the nucleus for @xmath54 dust to reach ) is also masked , as we are focused on @xmath55 to mm - sized dust .
to evaluate the degree of similarity between the observed and the modeled profiles , we calculate the normalized error variance ( nev ) as defined by @xmath56 where @xmath57 is the number of pixels , @xmath58 and @xmath59 are the pixel brightness from the modeled and observed brightness profile respectively .
we set the tolerance level of nev to 10% .
the input parameters , test grids and best - fit results are tabulated in table [ tbl : mdl - orb ] , [ tbl : mdl - parameter ] and figure [ fig : mdl ] .
it is encouraging that the best - fit models under the respective outburst epochs are largely consistent .
we conclude that the characteristic ejection speed @xmath0 to @xmath60 for the ejecta of the first outburst , while @xmath2 to @xmath61 for the ejecta of the second outburst .
the dust size index is at the range of @xmath62 .
the ejection speed is comparable or is slightly larger than the one derived from the classic @xcite model ( which gives @xmath63 in our model ) , while the size index is comparable to the classic value , @xmath64 @xcite .
it also appears that the characteristic ejection speed of the second outburst is higher than that of the first outburst , which seemingly support the idea that the second outburst was a more energetic event than the first one .
the total mass of the dust emitted in the two outbursts are related to the effective scattering cross - section of the materials , @xmath65 , that can be calculated by @xmath66 where @xmath67 , the phase angle corrected geometric albedo , is calculated using the compound henyey - greenstein model by @xcite , assuming @xmath68 , and @xmath69 , @xmath70 are the apparent magnitudes of the sun and the comet .
this yields @xmath71 for the first outburst and @xmath72 for the second outburst , using the photometric measurements in figure [ fig : report ] .
the total mass of the ejecta can then be calculated via @xmath73 , where the mean dust size @xmath74 can be derived from the dust model discussed in
[ sec : kinematics ] .
considering the variances among the best - fit models , we derive @xmath4 to @xmath75 for the first outburst and @xmath6 to @xmath76 for the second outburst ( depending on the exact timing of the individual outburst ) , corresponding to less than @xmath8 of the nucleus mass assuming a spherical nucleus . with this mass , the specific energy of the two outbursts
is calculated to be @xmath9 to @xmath77 using the speed component derived from the dust model .
this value is comparable to the value derived for 17p / holmes s 2007 outburst ( @xmath78 , c.f . * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
for the case of 17p / holmes , the large distance to the sun at the time of its outburst , as well as the closeness of the derived specific energy to the specific energy of the amorphous ice to crystalline , are compatible with the idea that the comet s mega - outburst was triggered by the nergy released by the crystallization of amorphous ice .
however , 15p / finlay was much closer to the sun at its two outbursts than 17p / holmes at its 2007 outburst ( 1.0 au versus 2.5 au ) such that solar heat may be sufficient to drive the outburst to some degree , hence we consider it difficult to assess the role of crystallization for 15p / finlay s outburst at this stage .
15p / finlay is puzzling in the sense that despite its occasional proximity to the earth s orbit , the hypothetical finlayid meteor shower has never been observed .
this matter has been discussed in depth by @xcite , who concluded that the perturbation of jupiter has effectively dispersed the meteoroid stream , such that @xmath79 of the meteoroids released @xmath80 orbits ago would end up with distant _ nodal _ passages ( @xmath81 au ) from the earth s orbit .
however , we think that this conclusion is unconvincing as the nodal plane approximation for earth impact may not be valid for 15p / finlay due to its shallow orbital plane ( @xmath82 ) .
additionally , new astrometric observations of 15p / finlay in the last decade has reduced the uncertainty of the orbital elements by an order of magnitude ; hence the issue of the long term evolution of the finlayid meteoroid stream is worth revisiting .
we first investigate the orbital stability of 15p / finlay .
this is done by generating 100 clones of 15p / finlay using the orbital covariance matrix provided in jpl k085/15 , and integrating all of them @xmath83 yr backwards .
the integration is performed with mercury6 using the bulirsch - stoer integrator .
the evolution of the perihelion distance of all clones is shown in figure [ fig : comet - dyn ] .
it can be seen that the perihelion distance of the clones are highly compact until 1613 a.d .
, when a close encounter ( miss distance of the order of 0.1 au ) between 15p / finlay and jupiter occurred .
this implies that any backward meteoroid stream simulation will be physically meaningful only as long as the starting date is after 1613 ad .
next , we then simulate a total of 39,000 ( a randomly chosen number ) hypothetical particles released by 15p / finlay during its 1886 , 1909 and 1960 perihelion passage and examine their distribution in 2001 , to directly compare to @xcite s simulations .
the simulation is performed using the same collection of subroutines described in [ sec : kinematics ] except that the ejection model by @xcite is used and only @xmath84 ( millimeter - sized ) particles are simulated .
the minimum orbit intersection distance vector @xmath85 between the earth and each meteoroid is calculated using the subroutine developed by @xcite to assess the likelihood of an earth encounter .
the original moid is defined as a scalar ; here i define the direction of @xmath85 to be the same as @xmath86 , where @xmath87 , @xmath88 are the heliocentric distance of the meteoroid and the earth at the moid point .
we find as much as @xmath89 of the particles stay within 0.01 au from the earth s orbit as of 2001 , different from @xcite s finding .
in addition , the dust trail is able to overlap with the earth s orbit ( figure [ fig : met-2001 ] ) , further supporting the idea that a significant number of particles released by 15p / finlay 1020 orbits ago may still have direct encounters with the earth .
the background meteoroid flux originating from 15p / finlay may be estimated in an order - of - magnitude manner .
the absolute magnitude of 15p / finlay is @xmath90 times brighter than low - activity comet 209p / linear for which the meteoroid production capacity has been measured to be @xmath91 meteoroids per orbit @xcite .
hence , in 10 orbits , 15p / finlay would generate @xmath92 meteoroids . assuming the meteoroids distribute uniformly along the orbit with an orbital period of 5 yr , as well as a delivery efficiency of @xmath93 to the region @xmath94 au from the earth s orbit and a characteristic duration of meteor activity of 1 week
, the flux can be calculate by @xmath95 , which should be detectable by modern meteor survey systems . to look for any undetected finlayid activity , we conduct a `` cued '' search in the canadian meteor orbit radar ( cmor ) database .
cmor is an interferometric radar array located near london , canada operating at 29.85 mhz with a pulse repetition frequency of 532 hz ( c.f .
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
since its commission in 2002 , cmor has measured 12 million meteoroid orbits , making it suitable for the search for weak meteor showers such as the finlayids .
we first calculate the characteristics of the hypothetical finlayid radiant using the simulation results above , which yields @xmath96 , @xmath97 at sun - centered ecliptic coordinates , and a geocentric speed of @xmath98 .
we then combine 14 years of cmor data into a stacked `` virtual '' year and look for any enhanced activity at the location of the theoretical radiant , using a wavelet - based search algorithm @xcite with probe sizes tuned to the expected radiant characteristics ( radiant probe size @xmath99 , velocity probe size @xmath100 ) .
as shown in figure [ fig : met - cmor ] , no significant enhancement can be found at the expected period of activity ( solar longitude @xmath101 ) .
@xcite has calculated that the detection limit for the wavelet algorithm applied on cmor is at the order of @xmath102 ; however , cmor sensitivity is also an order of magnitude less at a southerly radiant at @xmath103 comparing to northerly radiants , so the shower flux limit is probably closer to @xmath104 . hence , the existence and intensity ( or derived upper - limit ) of the finlayid meteor shower is not definitive , but favors southern hemisphere meteor surveys ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the potential 2021 encounter with the 2014 trail from 15p / finlay is of particular interest given the additional dust released from the two outbursts , as it offers an excellent opportunity to examine 15p / finlay s ejecta .
the encounter is studied by simply extending the numerical integration described in [ sec : kinematics ] to the year of 2021 .
similar to the meteoroid trail model presented in @xcite , we assigned a _ space criterion _ to select earth - approaching meteoroids , defined by @xmath105 where @xmath106 is the relative velocity between the meteoroid and the earth and @xmath107 and @xmath108 is called the _ time criterion _ that is the characteristic duration of the event , typically @xmath109
d. similar to the dust model discussed in
[ sec : kinematics ] , we test two sets of outburst epochs that correspond to either the epochs of the last non - outburst report or the first positive report . the simulation result confirms the general findings by maslov and sato , that a direct encounter of the 2014/2015 meteoroid trail will occur on 2021 oct .
6/7 ( table [ tbl : met-2021 ] , figure [ fig : met-2021 ] ) with a full - width - half - maximum ( fwhm ) of about 1 hour .
the uncertainty in outburst epochs results in about 0.5 hour uncertainty in the peak time in 2021 .
the ejecta from the second outburst are calculated to arrive around 2021 oct .
6 at 22 h ut , followed by those from the first outburst which are expected to arrive around 2021 oct . 7 at 1 h ut
. the radiant is at geocentric equatorial coordinates of @xmath110 , @xmath111 or in the constellation of ara , favoring the observers in the southern tip of africa .
as 15p / finlay was @xmath112 times more active during the two outbursts compared to its normal dust production level as indicated by figure [ fig : report ] , the meteor activity may also be significantly stronger than previously expected .
however , we also note that the range of the meteoroid sizes delivered to the earth s vicinity seems to be concentrated at the order of @xmath113 , which translates to a visual magnitude of @xmath114 @xcite considering the very low encounter speed .
this indicates that the meteor activity in 2021 may only be visible to meteor radars and low - light video cameras .
we present an analysis of the two outbursts of the potentially comet - asteroid transition object , 15p / finlay , at its 2014/2015 perihelion passage .
these outbursts took place between 2014 dec .
15.416.0 ut and 2015 jan .
15.516.0 ut as constrained by ground - based and spacecraft observations .
as seen in monitoring images , both outbursts produced a newly - formed dust shell that expands and fades in @xmath21 week .
the images from five observing nights ( two for the first outburst , three for the second outburst ) were studied using a monte carlo dust model , and yield a characteristic ejection speed of @xmath0 to @xmath60 for the ejecta of the first outburst and @xmath2 to @xmath61 for that of the second outburst , taking into account the uncertainty in the determination of outburst epoch .
the dust size index is in the range of @xmath62 .
we derive the mass of the ejecta to be @xmath4 to @xmath75 for the first outburst and @xmath6 to @xmath76 for the second outburst , corresponding to less than @xmath8 of the nucleus mass .
the specific energy of the two outbursts is calculated to be @xmath9 to @xmath77 , comparable to the specific energy produced by the crystallization of amorphous ice , but does not prove the latter as the driving force for 15p / finlay s outbursts .
we also revisited the long - standing puzzle of the non - detection of the finlayids , the hypothetical meteor shower generated by 15p / finlay , as well as the future possibility for meteor activity generated by the 2014/2015 outbursts .
we find the efficiency of meteoroid delivery to the earth s orbit is @xmath115 times higher than previously reported by @xcite .
assuming 15p / finlay s recent ( last @xmath112 orbits ) activity is comparable to its contemporary level , the meteoroid flux of the finlayids should be high enough to be detected by modern meteor surveys .
however , a cued search with the 12 million meteor orbits gathered by the canadian meteor orbit radar over the past 13 years does not reveal any positive detection .
the encounter with the 2014/2015 outburst ejecta may provide an answer to the finlayid puzzle , as the earth is expected to pass though the ejecta trails directly around 2021 oct .
6 at 22 h ut to oct . 7 at 1 h ut , with a chance for some significant meteor activity in the video or radio range .
the timing and the southerly radiant in the constellation of ara will favor observers in the southern tip of africa .
the recent outburst episode of 15p / finlay seems to suggest that the comet , originally thought to be quiet and largely inactive , does possess the ability for significant activity . whether the recent outbursts are the overtures of a resurrection of the comet or a finale of its career remains to be seen .
cometary observations in the forthcoming perihelion passage in july 2021 , as well as observations during the potential meteor outburst , will likely provide more information .
we thank an anonymous referee for his / her comments .
we also thank paul wiegert for permission to use his computational resource , margaret campbell - brown for her meteoroid ablation code , zbigniew krzeminski , jason gill , robert weryk and daniel wong for helping with cmor operations .
the operation of the robotic telescope fram is supported by the eu grant gloria ( no .
283783 in fp7-capacities program ) and by the grant of the ministry of education of the czech republic ( msmt - cr lg13007 ) .
funding support from the nasa meteoroid environment office ( cooperative agreement nnx11ab76a ) for cmor operations is gratefully acknowledged .
this work would not be possible without the inputs from the amateur community and their contributions are gratefully acknowledged .
, e. 1985 , in dynamics of comets : their origin and evolution , proceedings of iau colloq .
83 , held in rome , italy , june 11 - 15 , 1984 . edited by andrea carusi and giovanni b. valsecchi .
dordrecht : reidel , astrophysics and space science library .
volume 115 , 1985 , p.185 , ed .
a. carusi & g. b. valsecchi , 185 | jupiter - family comet 15p / finlay has been reportedly quiet in activity for over a century but has harbored two outbursts during its 2014/2015 perihelion passage . here
we present an analysis of these two outbursts using a set of cometary observations .
the outbursts took place between 2014 dec .
15.416.0 ut and 2015 jan .
15.516.0 ut as constrained by ground - based and spacecraft observations .
we find a characteristic ejection speed of @xmath0 to @xmath1 for the ejecta of the first outburst and @xmath2 to @xmath3 for that of the second outburst using a monte carlo dust model .
the mass of the ejecta is calculated to be @xmath4 to @xmath5 for the first outburst and @xmath6 to @xmath7 for the second outburst , corresponds to less than @xmath8 of the nucleus mass . the specific energy of the two outbursts is found to be @xmath9 to @xmath10 .
we also revisit the long - standing puzzle of the non - detection of the hypothetical finlayid meteor shower by performing a cued search using the 13-year data from the canadian meteor orbit radar , which does not reveal any positives .
the earth will pass the 2014/2015 outburst ejecta around 2021 oct .
6 at 22 h ut to oct . 7 at 1 h ut , with a chance for some significant meteor activity in the radio range , which may provide further clues to the finlayid puzzle .
a southerly radiant in the constellation of ara will favor the observers in the southern tip of africa . |
in recent years , the effect of underlying inhomogeneities in superconductors has attracted many researchers . in the context of high temperature superconductors ( htsc ) , checkerboard local density of states ( ldos ) oscillations and strong nanoscale gap inhomogeneity
have been observed in scanning tunnelling spectroscopy ( sts ) experiments @xcite , and signals in dynamical susceptibility measured by neutron scattering have been interpreted as stripelike nanoscale modulations of charge and spin degrees of freedom @xcite . while it is still not clear whether these modulations are intrinsic in nature or driven entirely by disorder , others have pointed out that the very existence of inhomogeneity may enhance @xmath1 , and implicitly suggested that the phenomenon of high critical temperatures may rely on it @xcite . in particular ,
martin et al .
@xcite studied a simple model , in which they included a 1d inhomogeneous pair potential varying on an arbitrary length scale @xmath2 , where @xmath3 is the lattice spacing , and argued for an increase of the critical temperature with inhomogeneity , with a maximum enhancement obtained for @xmath4 , where @xmath5 is the coherence length of the analog homogeneous system .
similar results were obtained by loh and carlson , where they found however that an increase in the transition temperature occurred at the cost of reduced superfluid density @xcite .
aryanpour et al .
@xcite performed a systematic numerical study of @xmath6-wave superconductivity on checkerboard , stripe and random patterns of pairing potentials in an attractive hubbard model ; they also found a positive correlation between critical temperature and inhomogeneity for many situations .
it is also known that models with enhanced @xmath1 and significant inhomogeneity are associated with unusual features in electronic structure .
for example , recent calculations of high - quality ultrathin s - wave superconducting films have shown that the surface - driven inhomogeneity can enhance @xmath1 due to weakly dispersive low - energy subgap states in the system@xcite .
the above studies were primarily considerations of bcs type models .
recently , however , tsai et al.@xcite have studied small size repulsive hubbard models with a checkerboard "- like
modulation of hopping matrix elements using exact diagonalization , and also concluded that the inhomogeneous models could lead to pairing at very high binding energy scales .
nunner et al .
@xcite underlined the importance of this phenomenon for cuprates by explaining many of the correlations between the measured local gap and other observables in bi-2212 by assuming a @xmath7-wave pairing interaction @xmath8 varying on a unit cell size , and driven by dopant disorder .
if the effective pair interaction can vary on an atomic scale , and the bcs coherence length is sufficiently short , one can imagine situations where in a complex periodic crystal with large unit cell the pairing interaction varies over an atomic length scale in the absence of disorder , i.e. a periodic , modulated @xmath8 , which will give rise to a periodic , modulated order parameter @xmath9 .
the properties of such a system are important to understand , because it represents the simplest type of nanoscale pairing modulation , and one may study the relationship between superconducting properties and inhomogeneity easily .
aryanpour et al .
@xcite considered systems of this type within a purely numerical approach , and obtained a variety of interesting results .
nevertheless , in such a treatment it is sometimes difficult to extract simple conclusions and understand exactly which aspects of superconductivity are really enhanced or suppressed by inhomogeneity , and why . in this paper
, we consider the simplest such model , a bipartite lattice in two dimensions with two different values of @xmath10 on two interpenetrating sublattices . the homogeneous version of the model has a superconducting ground state on a bipartite lattice in arbitrary dimension and filling @xcite . here
we calculate the ground state and thermodynamics of this system for any values @xmath11 , where @xmath12 and @xmath13 represent the two sublattices .
we distinguish however two cases : one , where both @xmath10 s have the same sign ; and a second , where they differ .
situations like the latter case where the pairing potential changes sign abruptly over a unit cell distance have been considered in the impurity context @xcite , but not in periodic cases , and it is not clear whether true superconducting solutions can exist in such a situation . in section
ii , we introduce the sublattice pairing model and give exact expressions for the order parameter and critical temperature @xmath1 within the generalized bcs scheme .
we show that @xmath1 can indeed be enhanced by detuning the coupling constants from the bcs point @xmath14 .
we then derive in section iii the quasiparticle excitations and thermodynamic properties of the model .
when the average pairing strength is held constant but inhomogeneity is increased , the model displays a shrinking spectral gap in the total dos . in the case of opposite sign coupling constants ,
the excitation spectrum becomes gapless , and the mean field solution corresponds to an order parameter which oscillates in sign from point to point . in section iv
, we calculate the superfluid density @xmath15 for the model , and show that for the case of same - sign coupling constants inhomogeneity preserves a robust @xmath15 at @xmath0 . in the case of opposite signs , however , @xmath15 is suppressed by the onset of a residual normal fluid .
the variations of superconducting phenomenology found in our solution to the model is summarized in the phase diagram shown in fig .
[ fig : phsd ] .
mean field phase diagram in the space of two coupling constants @xmath16 and @xmath17 found in this paper .
the solid lines represent transitions between normal metal ( defined by @xmath18 ) , gapped and gapless superconducting phases .
the dashed - dotted line represents the line of constant average pairing @xmath19 studied in the text .
the dashed line represents the homogeneous bcs case with @xmath20 .
finally , the dotted line represents the normal - gapless superconducting transition line as calculated analytically within the approximation described in the text using the window " density of states ( wdos ) .
, scaledwidth=45.0% ]
the hamiltonian is given by eq .
( [ eq : mdl ] ) , where @xmath21 are the electron annihilation and creation operators .
@xmath22 is the strength of hopping energy between the nearest neighbors and @xmath23 is the mean field gap at site @xmath24 .
the sum in the hamiltonian is over all sites and spins denoted by @xmath25 .
the unit cell of the bipartite lattice is shown in fig .
[ fig : bz ] , and the fourier transformation in eq .
( [ eq : ft ] ) is defined with respect to this cell .
we first consider the case of half - filling , for which the chemical potential @xmath26 is set to zero .
@xmath27 in anticipation of the doubling of the unit cell due to an interaction specified on each sublattice , we fourier transform fermionic operators as @xmath28 where the sum now runs over the arising for staggered ordering ( `` antiferromagnetic '' ) half - brillouin zone specified by @xmath29 for @xmath30 , with directions specified in fig .
[ fig : bz ] .
the hamiltonian now becomes @xmath31 where we have assumed @xmath6-wave pairing and the dispersion relation is given by @xmath32 the matrix @xmath33 may be expressed as @xmath34 \label{eq : mat}\ ] ] in the staggered particle - hole space spanned by @xmath35 . after performing the canonical transformation
@xmath36 with @xmath37 , we find the quasiparticle energies @xmath38 , with @xmath39 which reduce to the usual @xmath40 for @xmath41 .
the eigenstates of the problem , of the form @xmath42 , are given by @xmath43 { \frac{1}{\sqrt{2\left(x^2_1+x^2_2\right ) } } } \label{eq : v1},\\ & |\lambda_{2},-e_{2}>=[-x_{2},-x_1,x_{2},-x_1 ] { \frac{1}{\sqrt{2\left(x^2_1+x^2_2\right ) } } } \label{eq : v2 } , \\ & |\lambda_{3},e_{2}>=[-x_{2},x_1,-x_{2},-x_1 ] { \frac{1}{\sqrt{2\left(x^2_1+x^2_2\right ) } } } \label{eq : v3 } , \\ & |\lambda_{4},e_{1}>=[-x_{1},x_2,x_{1},x_2 ] { \frac{1}{\sqrt{2\left(x^2_1+x^2_2\right ) } } } \label{eq : v4},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath44 using the definition of the gap functions , @xmath45 we can write down the gap equation for the @xmath46 @xmath47 note that within our convention a positive @xmath10 corresponds to an attractive on - site interaction .
we now calculate @xmath1 by linearizing the gap equations . to obtain analytical results
, we estimate the integrals involved using the approximate window density of states ( wdos ) @xmath48 which is a good approximation for the tight binding model for qualitative purposes .
then @xmath49 takes the form @xmath50 plotted vs. difference of sublattice coupling constants @xmath51 for fixed @xmath19 .
squares : window density of states .
circles : exact .
insert : @xmath52 vs. @xmath53 for fixed @xmath54 . ] the dimensionless effective interaction @xmath55 plays the same role as the single attractive coupling constant in bcs weak - coupling theory .
the phase transition to the normal state takes place as @xmath56 , determining the dotted line in fig .
[ fig : phsd ] .
note that the mathematical expression for @xmath1 ( [ eq : tcwdos ] ) actually diverges as @xmath57 , i.e. as one approaches the phase transition from the normal state side , again in perfect analogy with bcs .
the apparent nonzero value for @xmath1 on this side is of course spurious , as there is no ordering below this temperature , as will be shown below .
this estimate for @xmath1 is compared in figs .
[ fig : phsd ] and [ fig : tc ] with the exact numerical solution for the normal state instability temperature from eqs .
[ eq : gaps ] . in order to judge the extent to which inhomogeneity enhances superconductivity , in this work we keep the average pairing interaction per site , @xmath58 , fixed unless otherwise stated , and plot @xmath1 vs. the difference @xmath59 .
we see that the numerical discrepancies between the exact evaluation and the window dos approximation are in fact quite large , due to the presence of the van hove singularity at the fermi level in the simple 2d band , together with the exponential dependence of @xmath1 on the density of states , but that the approximation captures the qualitative dependence of @xmath1 on inhomogeneity .
it is clear that , as in other mean field models of inhomogeneous pairing , the inhomogeneity enhances the critical temperature .
we return in sec .
[ sec : superfluid ] to the question of when this result breaks down .
if , instead of holding the average interaction @xmath60 fixed , we fix the attractive interaction on one sublattice @xmath61 and progressively decrease @xmath62 , we find a rapidly decreasing @xmath1 ( see insert to fig .
[ fig : tc ] ) . depending on the magnitude of @xmath62 ,
we either see only an exponential decrease of @xmath1 or , for very small @xmath62 , an instability to the metallic state at a critical value determined by the change of sign of the effective interaction .
this determines the solid line in the phase boundary corresponding to the transition to the normal state shown in fig .
[ fig : phsd ] .
we now consider the order parameters @xmath63 which develop below @xmath1 on the two sublattices .
it turns out that there are two different cases , which we discuss separately , corresponding to coupling constants on the two sublattices of identical or opposite sign . in general
, we can write using eqs .
( [ eq : gaps ] ) , @xmath64 \label{eq : gapdiff}\ ] ] we first assume both coupling constants positive , @xmath65 . if both gaps are positive , then @xmath66 are positive .
therefore in limit @xmath67 the right hand side of eq . (
[ eq : gapdiff ] ) will vanish , which gives the solution : @xmath68 which is exact for the case of both @xmath69 attractive .
now if we employ the window density of states given by eq .
( [ eq : windos ] ) , we obtain @xmath70 for @xmath71 , within weak coupling approximation ( @xmath72 ) , this gives @xmath73 , which is the standard bcs result .
vs. @xmath74 for weak inhomogeneous pairing interaction @xmath75 ; ( b ) strong inhomogeneity cases , with @xmath76 ( note @xmath77 ) . ( c )
ratio @xmath78 vs. @xmath79 for @xmath37 ( solid line : full numerical evaluation ; dashed - dotted line : wdos ) ; ( d ) comparison of full numerical evaluation of @xmath80 ( solid line ) with wdos approximation ( dashed - dotted line ) .
for all plots , the average coupling is fixed to @xmath81 .
note in ( c),(d ) that the gapless phase discussed in sections [ sec : condensate ] and [ sec : dispersion ] correspond , for the parameters given here , to @xmath82 . ]
the exact solution for the temperature dependence of the gap is shown for the case of weak inhomogeneity in fig .
[ fig : gaps_vs_t](a ) .
now we consider the other case when one of the coupling constants is negative , @xmath83 . from ( [ eq : gaps ] )
we see that @xmath84 is forced to be negative .
the variation of gap as a function of temperature found numerically and displayed in fig .
[ fig : gaps_vs_t](b ) is somewhat unusual .
as the temperature increases from zero , the gap increases in magnitude and then after attaining a maximum value begin to decrease . in the case of opposite sign coupling constants ,
relation ( [ eq : gapratio ] ) is no longer valid . in this case one can obtain an approximate analytical expression for @xmath85 using the wdos ( [ eq : windos ] ) , but it is quantitatively inaccurate .
a more accurate approximation is obtained by replacing the exact contour of zero quasiparticle energy with a square of side @xmath86 .
this turns out to be equivalent to a renormalized wdos approximation where the bare bandwidth @xmath87 is replaced by @xmath88 .
we find @xmath89 in figs .
[ fig : gaps_vs_t ] ( c ) and ( d ) we illustrate the utility of the wdos and renormalized wdos approximations with which analytical results were obtained above . while fig .
[ fig : gaps_vs_t](d ) shows that the inaccuracies arising from the wdos also influence the value of the @xmath0 order parameters on the two sublattices , the qualitative tendencies with @xmath79 are well reproduced .
furthermore , the ratios @xmath90 agree quantitatively with the exact numerical results over a wide range of inhomogeneities ( fig . [
fig : gaps_vs_t](c ) ) , as the errors introduced in the dos are largely cancelled by taking the ratio . the normal state region shown in the phase diagram of fig .
[ fig : phsd ] represents the metallic phase where , within the current mean field treatment , the only solution found has both order parameters @xmath91 .
there are several measures of the strength of superconductivity " in a material which become distinct when the material is inhomogeneous .
one is the order parameter , which we have discussed above .
a second is the pair wave function , or condensate amplitude @xmath92 , such that @xmath93 . to illustrate the differences , it is useful to consider first an interesting if artificial special case where the coupling is attractive on one sublattice and vanishes on another .
we therefore take @xmath94 and @xmath95 , and plot both the order parameters and condensate amplitudes in fig .
[ fig : condensate ] . vs. @xmath97 for special case @xmath98 , @xmath60=t @xmath99 ; ( b ) condensate amplitude @xmath100 for same case as ( a ) ; ( c ) variation of @xmath101 with inhomogeneity @xmath102 for three different temperatures @xmath103 .
] in other words , although the pairing interaction on the b sublattice is zero , the proximity effect is so strong that a uniform condensate fraction is induced over the entire system .
this degeneracy is broken at finite temperatures , where the b condensate is weakened relative to that on the a sublattice .
of course , the order parameter on the b sublattice is zero at all temperatures due to the absence of coupling on these sites .
these differences are illustrated in fig .
[ fig : condensate](a ) and ( b ) .
it is also interesting to study the dependence of the subdominant condensate on inhomogeneity .
the point where one of the coupling constants changes sign is clearly a singular point of the theory , such that at @xmath0 this condensate is immediately depleted as soon as the subdominant coupling ( b sublattice ) becomes negative .
we now discuss the reasons for this abrupt change in behavior . ) in momentum space along @xmath104 ( on x- axis ) , with @xmath105 for average coupling @xmath19 and various values of inhomogeneity @xmath106 .
( a)spectrum when @xmath20 .
dashed curve represents normal state @xmath107 for reference .
( b ) spectrum for @xmath108 ( c ) spectrum for @xmath98 , at transition to gapless state .
( d ) spectrum for @xmath76 , in gapless state .
all spectra are shown at temperature @xmath109 . ] in eqs .
( [ eq : e1 ] ) , we have given the quasiparticle eigenenergies for this simple model ; we now plot them in fig .
[ fig : spectra ] along @xmath110 for various representative cases .
of course the full quasiparticle spectrum retains the fourfold symmetry of the underlying lattice .
panel a ) shows the dispersion in both the normal and homogeneous bcs case , respectively . adding a small inhomogeneity with two attractive couplings leads to a splitting of these states , into four distinct eigenenergies ( panel ( b ) ) , thereby reducing the overall spectral gap in the system .
when one of the couplings passes through zero , a level crossing occurs at zero energy at the zone face ( panel ( c ) ) .
it is this level crossing which is responsible for the singular behavior in some observable quantities as one of the couplings becomes repulsive .
it is accompanied by a filling of the gap by the states near the zone face .
when the two couplings @xmath16 and @xmath17 have opposite signs , the eigenvalues change sign over the brillouin zone . for example , in panel ( d ) of fig .
[ fig : spectra ] , @xmath111 is always positive , but @xmath112 is positive except in a narrow range @xmath113 .
gapless behavior in @xmath6-wave superconductors with magnetic impurities@xcite can be associated with individual low - energy quasiparticle resonances , which arise near each magnetic impurity and then overlap to form an impurity band .
the band appears as a residual density of states for sufficiently high impurity concentration similarly , the gapless superconductivity arising due to microscopically inhomogeneous sign - changing order parameters , which is found in the present paper , is reminiscent of respective low - energy andreev states around so - called off - diagonal or phase impurities @xcite .
one might imagine an ordinary @xmath6-wave superconductor into which a dilute lattice of phase impurities is introduced . as the lattice constant of such bound states
is decreased , the bound state wave functions will interfere and the bound state energies will split , leading to a kind of gapless superconductivity related to that we find here for the dense case .
( red ) and @xmath13 ( blue ) .
( a ) ldosin homogeneous case , @xmath114 ; ( b ) @xmath108 , @xmath115 ; ( c ) @xmath116 , @xmath115 ; ( d ) @xmath76 , @xmath115 .
the dashed line represents the normal state 2d tight binding band . ] to observe this directly and trace the spectral features back to their respective sublattices , we construct the local density of states on a and b sites , @xmath117.\ ] ] fig . [
fig : dos ] exhibits the ldos on the two sublattices . in panels ( a ) and ( b ) ,
when both couplings are positive , we clearly see a full spectral gap .
but when one of the couplings tends to zero , as in ( c ) , a sharp peak develops at the fermi level on the associated sublattice .
the system remains gapless as the coupling constant on this sublattice is made negative , as in ( d ) .
it should be noted , however , that the subgap states are not located at zero energy , as seen in fig .
[ fig : spectra]d , where the dispersion is seen to flatten at the zone edge away from zero .
this is reflected in a narrowly split resonance in the ldos , as seen in fig .
[ fig : dos ] . of inhomogeneous system vs. @xmath97 .
solid line : bcs homogeneous superconductor with 2d tight - binding band .
circles : weak homogeneity @xmath118 .
triangles : strong homogeneity @xmath119 .
average coupling fixed to @xmath19 . ] to exhibit the consequences of the sublattice pairing inhomogeneity for thermodynamics , we calculate the specific heat from the temperature derivative of the entropy , @xmath120 here @xmath121 for the free quasiparticles is given by @xmath122 where @xmath123 , and the sum runs only over positive eigenvalues . in figure
[ fig : dcv ] , we plot these results for a few examples . for a superconductor with a small amount of inhomogeneity again keeping the average coupling fixed
it is clear that the critical temperature increases relative to the bcs case , the low-@xmath124 temperature dependence remains exponential . on the other hand , when one of the coupling constants goes negative , the figure shows the existence of the residual density of states via a linear term in the specific heat at the lowest temperatures .
it is clear that the fractional jump in the specific heat , reflecting the condensation energy , decreases with increasing inhomogeneity , and is approximately constant for the gapless regime .
note that this ratio for the homogeneous case is not the conventional bcs value of @xmath125 , due to the non - parabolic band used here .
as aryanpour et al . have emphasized @xcite , models of inhomogeneous pairing can lead to a variety of ground states , including insulating ones . to show that the states we discuss here are indeed superconducting
, we use the criteria developed by zhang et .
al . @xcite for lattice systems .
we calculate the superfluid density @xmath15 , which is the sum of the diamagnetic response of the system ( kinetic energy density ) and paramagnetic response ( current - current correlation function ) @xmath126 the current - current response is defined as @xmath127 where the current at @xmath128 site is given by @xmath129 after evaluating the expectation value using the bogoliubov operators in ( [ eq : ctran ] ) , we find the following relatively simple expression for the analytic continuation of the static homogeneous response : @xmath130^{2 } \\ & & \times \left(\frac{f(e_1)-f(e_2)}{e_1-e_2}\right ) \nonumber \label{eq : cucuco}\end{aligned}\ ] ] if the @xmath131 do not change sign over the brillouin zone , as is the case for the gapped phase @xmath132 , it is clear that this expression vanishes as @xmath133 as in the clean bcs case .
this is no longer the case in the gapless regime @xmath134 , where a finite value of @xmath135 , corresponding to a residual density of quasiparticles , is found at zero temperature . vs. inhomogeneity @xmath79 with
fixed average coupling @xmath136 at different temperatures @xmath0 ( solid ) @xmath137 ( dashed ) , and @xmath138 ( dotted line ) . the range of inhomogeneities @xmath139 corresponds to gapless superconductivity .
, scaledwidth=48.0% ] the other term we need to evaluate is the expectation value of the lattice kinetic energy density operator , which in the homogeneous bcs case is directly proportional to the superfluid weight @xmath140 at @xmath0 .
the kinetic energy operator is defined as , @xmath141 in fourier space , it can be written as : @xmath142+h.c.\right ) \label{eq : kxf}\ ] ] after performing the canonical transformation and taking the expectation values we find @xmath143 f(e_{n})+ \right.\\ \left .
+ \left[v^{a}_{n}v^{b*}_{n}e^{i\frac{k_{x}}{\sqrt{2}}}+ v^{a*}_{n}v^{b}_{n}e^{-i\frac{k_{x}}{\sqrt{2}}}\right ] \left(1-f(e_{n})\right)\right\ } \label{eq : expkx}\end{gathered}\ ] ] which is , remarkably , the same for sites a or b , corresponding to the uniform proximity - induced condensate amplitude found in section [ sec : condensate ] . in terms of the eigenvectors and eigenvalues given by eqs .
( [ eq : v1 ] ) , ( [ eq : v2 ] ) , ( [ eq : v3 ] ) and ( [ eq : v4 ] ) , we can write @xmath144 . \left\langle{k_{x}(i)}\right\rangle = 2\sum_{\bar{k } } \xi_\k \frac{x_{1}x_{2}}{x_{1}^{2}+x_{2}^{2 } } \left[\tanh\left(\frac{\beta{e_{1}}}{2}\right)+\right.\\ \left . \tanh\left(\frac{\beta{e_{2}}}{2}\right)\right ] \label{eq : fnkx}\end{gathered}\ ] ] for the case when @xmath145 at @xmath0 , we can simplify this expression as @xmath146 which is manifestly positive ; hence , the system is a superconductor and displays a conventional meissner effect at @xmath0 .
the expression also shows explicitly that the superfluid density on each site corresponds to the average superconducting order parameter over the system .
[ fig : kx ] show how the superfluid weight @xmath147 changes as the inhomogeneity is increased
. at @xmath0 , @xmath15 for this model is a constant and equal to the value for the homogeneous system , whenever the system is fully gapped , since the average gap remains the same . in the same system , recall ,
the transition temperature increases monotonically with inhomogeneity .
as one increases the inhomogeneity further with fixed average coupling , there is a critical value @xmath148 for which the system enters the gapless phase , at which the superfluid density drops abruptly .
the temperature dependence of such a case is exhibited , along with others , in fig .
[ fig : rhovst ] , and we see that this discontinuity corresponds to the creation of a finite residual normal fluid of uncondensed quasiparticles . exactly at @xmath148 ( @xmath149 in fig .
[ fig : rhovst ] ) , this behavior is marginal , but for any @xmath150 in the figure , the residual normal fluid density @xmath151 is nonzero . as a function of temperature for various inhomogeneity parameters @xmath102= 0 ( black ) , 1.2 ( red ) , 2 ( green ) and @xmath152 ( magenta ) .
the lower panel shows the current current correlation @xmath153.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] if @xmath60 is held fixed and inhomogeneity @xmath79 increased further , there is no mean - field transition to the metallic state , as indicated e.g. by the dashed - dotted line in fig .
[ fig : phsd ] which we have investigated in this paper . instead , @xmath1 increases monotonically while the superfluid density begins to fall at @xmath0 when the system enters the gapless phase at @xmath148 .
eventually , the decrease in @xmath15 must lead to large phase fluctuations and the breakdown of the mean field theory described here . to estimate
when this occurs , we follow emery and kivelson @xcite and define a characteristic phase ordering temperature @xmath154 which will now decrease in the gapless phase , following the superfluid density . for quasi two - dimensional superconductors ,
the length scale @xmath155 is a larger of the average spacing between layers @xmath7 or @xmath156 , where @xmath157 is the superconducting coherence length perpendicular to the layers .
although a determination of @xmath155 is beyond our simple model , it is qualitatively irrelevant in the presence of significant abrupt drop of the superfluid density .
taking simply @xmath158 , which is within a factor of 2 - 3 of both @xmath7 and @xmath159 in the cuprates , we may now obtain a crude measure of the _ optimal inhomogeneity _ needed to maximize the true ordering temperature in this model . in fig .
[ fig : optimaltc ] , we now plot both the mean field @xmath1 and the putative phase ordering temperature as a function of inhomogeneity @xmath79 .
we see that the two curves cross very close to the phase boundary @xmath148 ( at @xmath98 in the figure ) , due to the steep drop in @xmath15 there .
it therefore appears that the optimal inhomogeneity _ within the current scheme _ occurs for a checkerboard - like pairing interaction with attractive interaction on one sublattice and zero interaction on the other .
( dashed - dotted line ) and phase ordering temperature @xmath160 ( dashed line ) vs. inhomogeneity @xmath79 for fixed average interaction @xmath19 .
the solid line is the minimum of the two curves at any @xmath79.,scaledwidth=48.0% ]
we have presented and solved a simple mean - field model of a superconductor with inhomogeneous pairing varying on an atomic scale .
the model simply takes a different value for pairing on each of two interpenetrating sublattices .
the inhomogeneity can be increased while keeping the average pairing in the system fixed , thus allowing the effect of inhomogeneity on various properties to be discussed .
many results for this model were presented in analytic form .
as pointed out by earlier workers , we find that increasing pairing inhomogeneity enhances @xmath1 .
we have presented analytical results reflecting this effect , and calculated the spectrum and thermodynamic properties as well .
the enhancement of @xmath1 is accompanied by a closing of the spectral gap and eventually by the appearance of gapless phase in the quasiparticle spectrum of the @xmath6-wave " superconductor .
while these results have been obtained at the mean field level , because the length scale of the variation of the pairing interaction is so short we do not expect fluctuations to change them significantly @xcite , at least until the superfluid density is substantially suppressed .
the last caveat does not seem to be particularly restrictive , however .
the enhanced @xmath1 found in the inhomogeneously paired system is accompanied by a reduction in condensation energy , but the system maintains a constant @xmath0 superfluid density until a critical value of the inhomogeneity , when a level crossing of two quasiparticle energies forces the system into the gapless phase . until this point ,
the condensate at @xmath0 is spatially homogeneous for any value of the interaction inhomogeneity , even when the interaction on a given sublattice is zero ; this reflects the strong proximity coupling between the sublattices . as inhomogeneity increases further
, we have argued that the decrease in the superfluid density leads fairly rapidly to a decrease in the phase ordering temperature ; we find , therefore , that the optimal inhomogeneity is reached close to the checkerboard pattern of interactions , with attractive pairing on one sublattice and zero on the other .
k. aryanpour , e. r. dagotto , m. mayr , t. paiva , w. e. pickett and r. t. scalettar , phys .
rev b , * 73 * , 104518 ( 2006 ) ; k. aryanpour , t. paiva , w. e. pickett and r. t. scalettar , phys . rev .
b 76 , 184521 ( 2007 ) . | we study a toy model for a superconductor on a bipartite lattice , where intrinsic pairing inhomogeneity is produced by two different coupling constants on the sublattices .
the simplicity of the model allows for analytic solutions and tests of the consequences of atomic - scale variations in pairing interactions which have been considered recently in the cuprates .
we present results for the transition temperature , density of states , and thermodynamics of the system over a phase diagram in the plane of two pairing coupling constants . for coupling constants of alternating sign ,
a gapless superconducting state is stable .
inhomogeneity is generally found to enhance the critical temperature , and at the same time the superfluid density is remarkably robust : at @xmath0 , it is suppressed only in the gapless phase . |
magnetic nanoparticles are of great interest because of their nanoscale physical properties and many current and potential applications .
these applications range from high - density storage media@xcite and spintronic devices@xcite to biomedical applications like drug delivery , cell separation , cancer treatment and many others ( for a review , see refs . ) .
since the physical properties of nanoparticles play a decisive role in all these applications , their study is of fundamental importance . in particular , for high - density storage media , e.g. , bit - patterned media@xcite where each nanoparticle is a carrier of information ,
the thermal stability of a given direction ( or magnitude ) of the nanoparticle magnetic moment is one of the most important problems .
the reason is that under thermal fluctuations the magnetic moment can be randomly switched to a new state leading to the loss of information . in the case of ferromagnetic nanoparticles ,
the fluctuation dynamics of the nanoparticle magnetic moment can be described by the stochastic landau - lifshitz equation .
if the noise term in this equation is approximated by the gaussian white noise , then the probability density of the magnetic moment satisfies the fokker - planck equation whose properties are well known.@xcite this approach , introduced by brown@xcite almost five decades ago , has become an important tool in the study of stochastic magnetic dynamics ( see ref . and references therein ) . to characterize the thermal stability in the case of uniaxial nanoparticles , it is often enough to determine the lifetimes of the nanoparticle magnetic moment in the up " and down " states . in the above approach ,
the lifetime in a given state is usually interpreted as the relaxation time . however , from a theoretical point of view , the lifetime is reasonable to associate with the mean first - passage time ( mfpt ) , i.e. , average time that a random process dwells in a prescribed state .
an additional advantageous feature of this definition of the lifetime is that the mfpt method is mathematically well developed.@xcite this approach was first applied to study the magnetic relaxation in systems of noninteracting@xcite and dipolar interacting@xcite nanoparticles subjected to a constant magnetic field .
in general , the lifetime depends on both intrinsic properties of nanoparticles and external magnetic fields .
the case when the external fields contain a rotating magnetic field applied perpendicular to the easy axes of nanoparticles has a particular interest . on the one hand , this is because the rotating field plays a key role in the microwave - assisted switching@xcite and , on the other hand , because the corresponding dynamical equations ( without accounting the thermal fluctuations ) can often be solved analytically.@xcite specifically , it has been shown@xcite ( see also ref . ) that the rotating field can induce two types of the stable precessional modes of the magnetic moment , namely , the periodic ( p ) and quasi - periodic ( q ) modes . under certain conditions,@xcite one mode can exist in the up state of the magnetic moment and the other in the down state .
the thermal fluctuations make the random transitions between these modes possible , and the problem of the lifetime of the p and q modes appears .
some aspects of this problem have already been considered previously in the context of magnetic relaxation and induced magnetization.@xcite but the dependence of the lifetime on the parameters of the rotating field has not been studied systematically . at the same time , the effect of strong dependence of the lifetime on the rotating field frequency , which is expected to exist in the vicinity of the larmor frequency , could be important for applications .
therefore , in this paper we present a detailed analytical and numerical analysis of the above mentioned problem .
the paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ life ] , we describe the model and define the lifetime of both the p and q modes . here
we also derive the boundary conditions and transformation properties of the lifetime . in sec .
[ anres ] , we develop an analytical method for calculating the frequency dependence of the lifetime of the p mode in the case of high anisotropy barrier . our numerical results obtained by the simulation of the deterministic and stochastic landau - lifshitz equations are presented in sec .
[ numres ] .
specifically , the features of the p and q modes at zero temperature are studied in sec .
[ prec ] and the effects of thermal fluctuations are considered in sec .
[ simulat ] . finally , in sec .
[ con ] we summarize our findings .
to study the influence of the rotating magnetic field on the thermal stability of the nanoparticle magnetization , we use a minimal model with coherent spin dynamics . within this model , which is applicable to particles whose
exchange energy is comparatively large , the magnetic state of each particle is completely characterized by the magnetic moment @xmath0 of a fixed magnitude @xmath1 .
due to its interaction with a heat bath , @xmath2 is a vector random process which can be described by the stochastic landau - lifshitz equation@xcite @xmath3 where @xmath4 is the gyromagnetic ratio , @xmath5 is the damping parameter , the cross denotes the vector product , and @xmath6 and @xmath7 are the effective magnetic fields .
the first field is given by @xmath8 , where @xmath9 is the magnetic energy of the particle which , in the case under consideration , contains only the uniaxial anisotropy energy @xmath10 and the zeeman energy @xmath11 , i.e. , @xmath12 . here ,
the @xmath13-axis of a cartesian coordinate system @xmath14 with unit vectors @xmath15 , @xmath16 and @xmath17 is chosen to be parallel to the easy axis of magnetization , @xmath18 is the anisotropy field , @xmath19 , the dot denotes the scalar product , and @xmath20 is the rotating magnetic field .
we assume that @xmath20 is applied perpendicular to the @xmath13-axis , so that @xmath21 where @xmath22 is the field amplitude , @xmath23 is the angular rotation frequency , and @xmath24 ( for clockwise rotation ) or @xmath25 ( for counterclockwise rotation ) .
it is this field that induces the precessional modes of @xmath2 . the effective field @xmath26 accounts for the thermal fluctuations .
it is assumed that the cartesian components @xmath27 @xmath28 of @xmath26 are independent gaussian white noises with zero means and correlation functions @xmath29 . here , the angular brackets denote averaging over all realizations of @xmath26 , @xmath30 is the noise intensity , @xmath31 is the boltzmann constant , @xmath32 is the absolute temperature , and @xmath33 is the dirac @xmath34 function . in accordance with this definition of @xmath26 , the random process
@xmath2 is markovian and can be described within the fokker - planck formalism . because eq .
( [ l - l ] ) preserves the length of the magnetic moment @xmath2 , it is convenient to write the fokker - planck equation that corresponds to eq .
( [ l - l ] ) in spherical coordinates . introducing the polar and azimuthal angles @xmath35 and @xmath36 of @xmath2 , the forward and backward fokker - planck equations for the conditional probability density @xmath37 ( @xmath38 ) can be written as@xcite @xmath39 & \displaystyle -\frac{2a}{\lambda } \frac{\partial } { \partial\psi } [ v(\theta,\psi ) - \rho \tilde{\omega}]p = \frac{2a}{\lambda } \frac{\partial p}{\partial \tilde{t } } & \label{f - pfw}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath40 & \displaystyle + \frac{2a}{\lambda } [ v(\theta',\psi ' ) - \rho \tilde{\omega}]\frac{\partial p}{\partial\psi ' } = -\frac{2a}{\lambda } \frac{\partial p}{\partial \tilde{t } ' } , & \label{f - pbw}\end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively . here , @xmath41 is the dimensionless time , @xmath42 is the larmor frequency , @xmath43 is the dimensionless frequency of the rotating field , and @xmath44 is a dimensionless parameter that characterizes the anisotropy barrier height in the units of the thermal energy @xmath45 . finally , the variables @xmath46 and @xmath47 are associated with @xmath48 and @xmath49 , respectively , and the functions @xmath50 and @xmath51 are expressed through the dimensionless magnetic energy @xmath52 ( @xmath53 ) as follows : @xmath54 v(\theta,\psi ) \!&=&\ ! \frac{1}{\sin^{2 } \theta } \bigg ( \sin \theta \frac{\partial}{\partial \theta } - \lambda \frac{\partial}{\partial \psi } \bigg ) \tilde{w } \nonumber\\ \!&=&\ ! \cos\theta - \tilde{h}\cot\theta\cos\psi - \lambda\tilde{h}\frac{\sin\psi}{\sin\theta}. \label{def uv}\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is assumed that the probability density @xmath55 satisfies the initial condition @xmath56 . moreover , if the absorbing boundary conditions are not imposed , then @xmath55 is properly normalized : @xmath57 .
the system of two stochastic differential equations @xmath58 & \displaystyle \frac{d}{d\tilde{t}}\psi(\tilde{t } ) = v\big(\theta(\tilde{t } ) , \psi(\tilde{t})\big ) - \rho \tilde{\omega } + \sqrt{\frac{\lambda } { a}}\,\frac{1}{\sin \theta(\tilde{t } ) } \ , \eta_{2}(\tilde{t}),&\qquad \label{l - l2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath59 @xmath60 denote independent gaussian white noises with zero means and correlation functions @xmath61 , leads to the same fokker - planck equation ( [ f - pfw]).@xcite this means that the above system is stochastically equivalent to the stochastic landau - lifshitz equation ( [
l - l ] ) . in
what follows , we will use eq .
( [ l - l2 ] ) to numerically study the thermal stability of the precessional modes of the magnetic moment @xmath2 . at zero noise intensity
, the rotating magnetic field @xmath20 can induce stable precessional modes of @xmath2 of two types.@xcite in the first , p mode , the precession angle @xmath62 is a constant and @xmath2 in the laboratory frame is a periodic function of time . in the second ,
q mode , the precession angle varies periodically and @xmath2 becomes a quasi - periodic function of time ( because the periods of @xmath62 and @xmath20 are in general not commensurable ) .
some properties of these modes related to the steady - state will be considered in sec .
[ prec ] . here , we use only the fact that , depending on the parameters @xmath63 and @xmath64 , one or two precessional modes may exist in steady state . in the latter case ,
one mode occurs in the up state ( @xmath65 ) and the other in the down state ( @xmath66 ) of @xmath2 .
we assume that for a given set of the above parameters the magnetic moment @xmath2 is in the state @xmath67 if @xmath68 tends to @xmath69 as @xmath70 _ slowly _ decreases to zero .
it should be noted that the last condition is important because a sharp decrease of @xmath70 can switch @xmath2 to another state . in steady - state ,
the reference modes are stable and transitions between them are impossible .
however , these transitions can occur under thermal fluctuations . in this case
the precessional modes become metastable and the magnetic moment remains in a given state @xmath67 for some ( dimensionless ) random time @xmath71 . the average value of this time , i.e.
, the lifetime @xmath72 of the metastable state , can be determined using the mfpt method.@xcite the basis of this method is the backward fokker - planck equation ( [ f - pbw ] ) , which should be written for a given state @xmath67 . to this end , we add the index @xmath67 to all angle variables , replace the conditional probability density @xmath55 by @xmath73 , @xmath74 and @xmath75 . here , the angle @xmath76 ( @xmath77 ) should be chosen so that the time average of the precession angle @xmath78 [ we recall that @xmath79 for the p modes does not depend on @xmath80 is relatively close to @xmath76 and to @xmath81 for @xmath66 and + 1 , respectively . to meet these requirements , in our numerical simulations
we assume that @xmath82 . in accordance with the mfpt approach
, we consider a circular cone with the cone angle @xmath83 as the absorbing boundary for the magnetic moment in the @xmath67 state , i.e. , @xmath84 . in this case , taking into account that @xmath85 ( @xmath86 ) , the lifetime can be defined as @xmath87 , where @xmath88 is the probability that the magnetic moment stays in the state @xmath67 up to a given value of the time difference @xmath89 .
finally , using the relations @xmath90 and @xmath91 is governed by the partial differential equation @xmath92 & \displaystyle + \frac{2 a}{\lambda } [ v(\theta ' _ { \sigma } , \psi'_{\sigma } ) - \rho \tilde{\omega } ] \frac{\partial \mathcal { t}_{\sigma } } { \partial\psi ' _ { \sigma } } = -\frac{2a}{\lambda}. & \label{mfpt1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] at the absorbing boundary , the solution of this equation must satisfy the condition @xmath93 one more important property of the lifetime is that it is a finite function of @xmath94 and @xmath95 . in order to prove this statement ,
let us first approximate the stochastic dynamics of the magnetic moment by a random walk on the sphere characterized by a dimensionless discrete time @xmath96 , where @xmath97 and @xmath98 is the time step .
then , denoting @xmath99 the probability that the magnetic moment stays in the state @xmath67 after the @xmath100th step , we can write @xmath101 . if the maximal element of the set @xmath102 equals @xmath103 then @xmath104 and , as a consequence , @xmath105 . finally , taking into account that the condition @xmath106 implies that @xmath107
, we obtain the desired result : @xmath108 .
it should also be noted that since the maximum angular distance to the absorbing boundary occurs at @xmath109 , i.e. , @xmath110 , the condition of finiteness of the lifetime can be written in the form @xmath111 the above result shows the importance of knowing the solution of eq .
( [ mfpt1 ] ) in a small vicinity of the point @xmath112 .
assuming that @xmath113 ( @xmath114 ) , this equation at @xmath115 reduces to @xmath116 & \displaystyle + \lambda \sin \psi'_{\sigma } ) \frac{\partial \mathcal { t}_{\sigma } } { \partial \psi'_{\sigma } } = -\frac{2a}{\lambda}. & \label{aseq_mfpt1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] its solution can be represented as @xmath117 where @xmath118 and @xmath119 are constant parameters , and the functions @xmath120 satisfy the ordinary differential equations @xmath121 and @xmath122 with @xmath123 and @xmath124 being the kronecker delta . according to eq .
( [ sol_aseq ] ) , the finiteness condition ( [ fint ] ) takes the form @xmath125 , which in turn is equivalent to @xmath126 .
we note that at @xmath125 the derivative @xmath127 in the point @xmath109 , in general , does not vanish : @xmath128 . however , if @xmath129 then @xmath130 ( this is so because in this case @xmath131 does not depend on @xmath132 ) , and the finiteness condition ( [ fint ] ) reduces to the reflecting boundary condition @xmath133 it should also be noted that at @xmath134 the same reflecting boundary condition holds for the average lifetime @xmath135 , since @xmath136 .
now , using the general equation ( [ mfpt1 ] ) , we can establish the transformation properties of its solution @xmath137 ( for clarity , the dependence of @xmath131 on @xmath138 is shown explicitly ) , which is assumed to obey the conditions ( [ abst ] ) and ( [ fint ] ) . toward this end , let us introduce the change of variables @xmath139 taking into account that @xmath140 and @xmath141 , one can make sure that eq .
( [ mfpt1 ] ) in the new variables @xmath142 and @xmath143 becomes @xmath144 \displaystyle \times \frac{\partial \mathcal { h } _ { \sigma } } { \partial\theta'_{-\sigma } } + \frac{2 a } { \lambda } [ v(\theta'_{-\sigma } , \psi'_{-\sigma } ) + \rho \tilde{\omega } ] \frac{\partial \mathcal { h}_{\sigma } } { \partial \psi'_{-\sigma } } = -\frac{2a}{\lambda } , \end{array } \label{mfpt2}\ ] ] where @xmath145 . in accordance with the transforms ( [ change ] ) , the conditions ( [ abst ] ) and ( [ fint ] ) for @xmath146 take the form @xmath147 and @xmath148 , respectively . therefore , comparing eqs .
( [ mfpt1 ] ) and ( [ mfpt2 ] ) and the corresponding absorbing and finiteness conditions , one can conclude that @xmath149 is equal to @xmath150 , i.e. , @xmath151 for the average lifetime @xmath152 this transformation property reads : @xmath153 . in general
, the arguments @xmath154 and @xmath155 of @xmath131 are arbitrary and can be properly chosen to best suit the problem . in this paper
we are interested in the lifetime of the precessional modes _ reaching _ the steady state .
therefore , the angles @xmath156 and @xmath155 should be associated with the solution of deterministic ( when @xmath157 ) landau - lifshitz equations ( [ l - l2 ] ) at some time @xmath158 , i.e. , @xmath159 and @xmath160 . to be sure that the magnetic moment is near the steady state
, we assume that @xmath161 , where @xmath162 is the time of increasing the rotating field amplitude from @xmath163 to a given value @xmath70 , and @xmath164 is the relaxation time .
it should be emphasized that the time @xmath165 must be chosen large enough to prevent the dynamical switching from the state @xmath67 to the state @xmath166 . in the p mode , the angles @xmath167 and @xmath168 approach the limiting precession angle @xmath169 and the limiting difference of phases @xmath170 , respectively . as a consequence , the lifetime of this mode @xmath171
does not depend on the precise choice of @xmath172 .
in contrast , in the q mode the precession angle @xmath173 is a periodic function of time @xmath174 with a period @xmath175 and the difference of phases is given by @xmath176 , where @xmath177 and @xmath178 is also a periodic function with the same period @xmath179 ( see sec . [ prec ] ) .
thus the lifetime of the q mode , in general , depends on @xmath180 : @xmath181 however , at @xmath182 this dependence is very weak and can be safely neglected ( see sec .
[ simulat ] ) . in the case of p mode the limiting angles @xmath183 and @xmath184 depend also on the parameters @xmath70 , @xmath185 , @xmath64 and @xmath138 .
however , for brevity , we keep only the parameter @xmath138 , i.e. , @xmath186 $ ] and @xmath187 $ ] , which together with the state parameter @xmath67 describes the transformation properties of these angles . to find them , we use eq .
( [ def uv ] ) for representing the stationary landau - lifshitz equations @xmath188 , \psi_{\sigma}[\rho])=0 $ ] and @xmath189 , \psi_{\sigma } [ \rho ] ) = \rho \tilde { \omega}$ ] as @xmath190 - \rho \kappa \tan\theta_{\sigma}[\rho ] ) , & \nonumber\\[3pt ] & \displaystyle \sin \psi_{\sigma}[\rho ] = - \frac{\rho \lambda \kappa}{\tilde{h } } \sin \theta_{\sigma}[\rho ] , & \label{st1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath191 . from these equations , it is straightforward to obtain the desired result : @xmath192 = \pi - \theta_{-\sigma}[-\rho ] , \qquad \psi_{\sigma}[\rho ] = 2\pi - \psi_{-\sigma}[-\rho ] .
\label{sym_sol}\ ] ] because the transformation properties ( [ sym_sol ] ) are similar to those in eq .
( [ change ] ) , from eq .
( [ transf1 ] ) one gets the transformation property of the lifetime of the p mode @xmath193,\psi _ { \sigma}[\rho];\rho ) = \mathcal { t}_{-\sigma } ( \pi - \theta_{\sigma}[\rho ] , 2\pi - \psi_{\sigma}[\rho];-\rho ) .
\label{transf2}\ ] ] it shows that the lifetimes characterized by the pairs @xmath194 and @xmath195 are the same .
the analytical determination of the lifetimes of the precessional modes implies the solution of eq .
( [ mfpt1 ] ) with the absorbing and finiteness conditions ( [ abst ] ) and ( [ fint ] ) .
since the lifetime @xmath196 is a periodic function of @xmath155 with the period @xmath197 , it can be expressed as the fourier series @xmath198 to guarantee the reality of @xmath196 , we assume that the coefficients @xmath199 of the series satisfy the condition @xmath200 ( the asterisk denotes complex conjugation ) . substituting this series into eq .
( [ mfpt1 ] ) and introducing the differential operators @xmath201 & & \ ! + \ , i\frac{2an}{\lambda } ( \cos \theta'_{\sigma } - \rho \tilde{\omega } ) , \nonumber\\[4pt ] \hat{n}_{n } \!&=&\ ! ( \lambda \cos \theta'_{\sigma } - i ) \frac{d}{d\theta'_{\sigma } } + \frac{\lambda n } { \sin \theta'_{\sigma } } - i n \cot \theta'_{\sigma } , \label{l , n}\end{aligned}\ ] ] one obtains for @xmath202 an infinite set of coupled equations @xmath203 like @xmath204 , the coefficients @xmath205 must satisfy both the absorbing boundary condition @xmath206 and the finiteness condition @xmath207 . in the three - mode approximation , when @xmath208 for all @xmath209 , an infinite set of equations ( [ tn ] ) reduces to a set of three equations for @xmath210 , @xmath211 and @xmath212 . since @xmath204 is real , it is convenient to consider instead of @xmath213 and @xmath214 the real and imaginary parts of @xmath213 , i.e. , @xmath215 and @xmath216
. then , in this approximation , the lifetime ( [ solt ] ) is given by @xmath217 and , denoting the real and imaginary parts of an operator @xmath218 as @xmath219 and @xmath220 , respectively , from eqs .
( [ tn ] ) and ( [ l , n ] ) one obtains a set of three coupled equations for @xmath210 , @xmath221 and @xmath222 : @xmath223 & \displaystyle \hat{l}_{1}^{+ } \mathcal{t}_{\sigma 1}^{+ } - \hat{l}_{1}^{- } \mathcal{t}_{\sigma 1}^{- } = - \frac{a \tilde{h}}{\lambda } \hat{n}_{0}^{+ } \mathcal{t}_{\sigma 0 } , & \label{eqt+ } \\[4pt ] & \displaystyle \hat{l}_{1}^{+ } \mathcal{t}_{\sigma 1}^{- } + \hat{l}_{1}^{- } \mathcal{t}_{\sigma 1}^{+ } = \frac{a \tilde{h}}{\lambda } \hat{n}_{0}^{- } \mathcal{t}_{\sigma 0}. & \label{eqt-}\end{aligned}\ ] ] using eq .
( [ eqt0 ] ) , the function @xmath224 can be expressed through @xmath225 and @xmath226 .
indeed , considering @xmath227 as a given function of @xmath156 , one can write a formal solution of eq .
( [ eqt0]).@xcite from this solution , by satisfying the absorbing and reflecting boundary conditions @xmath228 and @xmath229 ( since @xmath230 does not depend on @xmath94 , the last condition is equivalent to the finiteness condition @xmath231 , see sec .
[ def ] ) , we obtain @xmath232 e^{ay^{2}}. \label{t0}\ ] ] substituting this result into eqs .
( [ eqt+ ] ) and ( [ eqt- ] ) , one can readily get the coupled integro - differential equations for @xmath221 and @xmath222 which , however , are too complicated to be solved in the general case .
moreover , these equations are not closed because , in accordance with eqs .
( [ deff ] ) , ( [ eqt+ ] ) and ( [ eqt- ] ) , the function @xmath233 depends on @xmath230 .
fortunately , an important case of high anisotropy barrier can be studied in detail . in the case of high anisotropy barrier ( or low temperatures ) , when the condition @xmath234 holds , the main contribution to the first integral in eq .
( [ t0 ] ) comes either from a small vicinity of the point @xmath235 ( if @xmath94 is not too close to @xmath236 and @xmath237 ) or from the vicinity of the point @xmath238 ( if @xmath239 ) .
it should be noted that the latter situation can be realized only in the case of q mode with @xmath240 or @xmath241 .
here , we restrict our theoretical analysis by considering small amplitudes of the rotating field that do not exceed the threshold amplitude of the q mode .
such rotating field can induce only the p mode and , as a consequence , the former situation is always realized ( see also sec .
[ prec ] ) .
therefore , taking into account that in this case the integrals @xmath242 and @xmath243 at @xmath244 can be approximated by @xmath245 and @xmath246 , respectively , eq . ( [ t0 ] ) reduces to @xmath247 in order to evaluate the integral in eq .
( [ t02 ] ) , we note that small vicinities of the limits of the integration determine the asymptotic behavior of this integral at @xmath248 .
more precisely , the lower limit is responsible for the high - frequency behavior of this integral and the upper one for its behavior in the resonant case .
hereafter , we call the rotating field resonant if @xmath249 and the direction of its rotation coincides with the direction of the natural precession of the magnetic moment , i.e. , if @xmath250 . to study these cases in a unified way , it is convenient to write the integral in eq .
( [ t02 ] ) as a sum of two terms , @xmath251 and @xmath252 , which correspond to the resonant and high frequencies , respectively .
thus , taking into account that @xmath253 and @xmath254 , eq .
( [ t02 ] ) yields @xmath255 . \label{ast0}\ ] ] it is important to stress at this point that eq .
( [ ast0 ] ) is not an exact asymptotic formula for @xmath230 because the terms @xmath256 and @xmath257 correspond to different frequencies . to calculate @xmath256
, we need to solve eqs .
( [ eqt+ ] ) and ( [ eqt- ] ) in the vicinity of the point @xmath259 .
assuming that @xmath260 ( @xmath261 ) and @xmath262 , these equations can be rewritten as @xmath263 & \displaystyle \hat{l}_{1}^{+}\mathcal{t}_{\sigma 1}^{- } + \frac{2a}{\lambda } ( \sigma - \rho \tilde{\omega } ) \mathcal{t}_{\sigma 1}^{+ } = -\sigma \frac{a\tilde{h}}{\lambda}\frac{d\mathcal{t}_{\sigma 0 } } { d\eta_{\sigma } } , & \label{eqst+-a}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath264 since the approximate formula ( [ ast0 ] ) does not depend on @xmath265 , it can not be used to determine the derivative @xmath266 .
therefore we use an exact result : @xmath267 e^{ay^{2 } } , \label{dert0}\ ] ] following from eq .
( [ t0 ] ) , which at @xmath268 gives @xmath269\ ! \eta_{\sigma}.
\label{t0a}\ ] ] it is not difficult to verify that an exact solution of eq .
( [ eqst+-a ] ) that vanishes as @xmath270 has the form @xmath271 } \frac{d\mathcal{t}_{\sigma 0 } } { d\eta_{\sigma } } , & \nonumber \\[4pt ] & \displaystyle \mathcal{t}_{\sigma 1}^{- } = \sigma \frac{\lambda ( 2-\sigma\rho\tilde{\omega } ) \tilde{h } } { 2[(1-\sigma\rho \tilde{\omega})^{2 } + \lambda^{2 } ] } \frac{d\mathcal{t}_{\sigma 0 } } { d\eta_{\sigma } } , & \label{solt+-}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath266 is given by eq .
( [ t0a ] ) . according to this equation
, the solution ( [ solt+- ] ) contains an unknown parameter @xmath272 , which can be determined from the fitting condition @xmath273 [ see eq .
( [ deff ] ) ] . taking into account
that @xmath274 and @xmath275 , this condition reduces to @xmath276 finally , substituting eq .
( [ t0a ] ) into eq .
( [ fitt ] ) and imposing the commonly used condition @xmath277 , one gets @xmath278 to find @xmath280 , we assume that @xmath281 ( @xmath282 ) and , as before , @xmath283 . since in this case @xmath284 , @xmath285 and @xmath286 , eqs .
( [ eqt+ ] ) and ( [ eqt- ] ) take the form @xmath287 & \displaystyle \hat{l}_{1}^{+}\mathcal{t}_{\sigma 1}^{- } - \frac{2a}{\lambda}(\xi_{\sigma } + \rho\tilde{\omega } ) \mathcal{t}_{\sigma 1}^{+ } = -\frac{a\tilde{h } } { \lambda}\frac{d\mathcal{t}_{\sigma 0}}{d\xi_{\sigma } } , & \label{eqst+-b}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath288 and , as it follows from eq .
( [ dert0 ] ) , the derivative @xmath289 at @xmath290 is given by @xmath291 .
\label{t0b}\ ] ] in general , the solution of eq .
( [ eqst+-b ] ) can be represented in the form of the taylor series : @xmath292 . however , since the main quantity of our interest is @xmath293 ( here , @xmath294 and @xmath295 ) , we can restrict ourselves to the linear approximation , i.e. , @xmath296 . assuming that @xmath297 , after straightforward calculations one obtains @xmath298 and @xmath299 therefore , the fitting condition @xmath300 can be reduced to the following one : @xmath301 which together with eq .
( [ t0b ] ) at @xmath277 yields @xmath302 \tilde{h}^{2 } } { 2[g(\tilde { \omega } ) + \sigma \rho a\tilde{h}^{2 } ] } , \label{f2b}\ ] ] where @xmath303 and @xmath304 is defined in eq .
( [ f1 ] ) .
now we are in a position to determine the lifetime ( [ pmod ] ) of the p mode . using eq .
( [ appr ] ) and the fact that @xmath210 does not depend on @xmath94 and @xmath95 , the desired lifetime can be expressed as @xmath305 - \mathcal{t}_{\sigma 1}^{- } \sin \psi_{\sigma}[\rho]\big ) \big|_{\theta_{\sigma } ' = \theta_{\sigma}[\rho]}. \label{lt1}\ ] ] if the field amplitude @xmath70 is small enough , then @xmath306 $ ] in eq .
( [ st1 ] ) can be replaced by @xmath67 .
one can easily check that in this case @xmath307 = -\rho \frac{\lambda \tilde { \omega } } { 1+\lambda^{2}- \sigma \rho \tilde{\omega } } , \label{psi}\ ] ] and the precession angle @xmath308 $ ] is given by @xmath192 = \frac{\pi}{2}(1 - \sigma ) + \sigma \tilde{h } \sqrt { \frac{1+\lambda^{2 } } { ( 1-\sigma \rho \tilde{\omega})^{2}+\lambda^{2}}}. \label{theta}\ ] ] the last result shows that the functions @xmath309 in eq .
( [ lt1 ] ) must be taken from eq .
( [ solt+- ] ) with @xmath310 + \pi(1- \sigma)/2 $ ] .
but , according to eq .
( [ ast0 ] ) , the term @xmath311 contains an additional factor @xmath312 , and so the second term in eq .
( [ lt1 ] ) which describes the dependence of @xmath131 on @xmath313 $ ] can be safely neglected at @xmath182 .
thus , using eqs .
( [ ast0 ] ) , ( [ f1 ] ) , and ( [ f2b ] ) , for the lifetime of the p mode we obtain @xmath314 where @xmath315 and @xmath316 if @xmath250 then eq . ( [ lt2 ] ) correctly describes the frequency dependence of the lifetime in the vicinity of the point @xmath317 and at @xmath318 .
since @xmath319 , @xmath277 and @xmath320 , in the former case we obtain @xmath321 . to put it differently , the rotating magnetic field
whose direction of rotation coincides with the direction of the natural precession decreases the lifetime in a resonant manner , i.e. , a resonant suppression of the thermal stability of the p mode occurs .
taking into account that @xmath322 and @xmath323 , in the latter case eq .
( [ lt2 ] ) yields @xmath324 .
in contrast , at @xmath325 eq .
( [ lt2 ] ) describes only the high - frequency behavior of the lifetime : @xmath326 . combining the last two results
, we obtain the expression @xmath327 ( @xmath328 ) , which shows that while at @xmath329 the rotating field suppresses the lifetime of the p mode , the rotating field with @xmath325 enhances it . for the evaluation of the lifetime at @xmath330 it is convenient to use the one - dimensional approximation , which consists in replacing @xmath47 by @xmath163 in the magnetic energy ( [ defw ] ) .
in this case @xmath331 , the lifetime @xmath131 does not depend on @xmath155 , and the partial differential equation ( [ mfpt1 ] ) reduces to the ordinary one : @xmath332 its exact solution satisfying the conditions ( [ abst ] ) and ( [ reflt ] ) [ we note that for this equation the finiteness condition ( [ fint ] ) is equivalent to the reflecting boundary condition ( [ reflt ] ) ] can be written in the form @xmath333 where @xmath334 ( @xmath335 ) is the symmetric function with @xmath336 , @xmath337 , and @xmath338 .
as before , we are interested in the behavior of @xmath72 at @xmath182 . in this case a small vicinity of the point @xmath235 gives the main contribution to the first integral in eq .
( [ tzer1 ] ) .
this contribution depends not only on @xmath339 but also on the parameter @xmath340 . in particular , if @xmath262 then , putting @xmath235 everywhere except for @xmath341 , representing @xmath341 in the vicinity of the point @xmath235 as @xmath342 and extending the limits of integration to infinity , eq .
( [ tzer1 ] ) yields @xmath343 then , taking into account that @xmath344 \!&=&\ !
\frac{e^{a } } { 2a}\,(1 + \sqrt{\pi a}\,\tilde{h } ) \label{relc1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] ( @xmath244 , @xmath262 ) and neglecting terms proportional to @xmath345 , from eqs .
( [ tzer2 ] ) and ( [ relc1 ] ) one finds @xmath346 comparing this result with eq .
( [ thigh3 ] ) , we conclude that @xmath347 , and so at @xmath348 the frequency dependence of the lifetime has a maximum exceeding the limiting value @xmath349 .
it should be noted that the lifetime @xmath350 strongly decreases with increasing @xmath70 .
for example , if @xmath351 then , instead of eq .
( [ tzer2 ] ) , we obtain @xmath352 to evaluate the integral in eq .
( [ tzer4 ] ) , it is convenient to divide the interval of integration @xmath353 into two parts , @xmath354 and @xmath355 , and apply the laplace method.@xcite by this way , the corresponding integrals can easily be evaluated yielding @xmath356 \!&=&\ ! \frac{\tilde{h}}{2 } \sqrt{\frac{\pi } { a}}\ , e^{a(1 + \tilde{h } ^{2 } ) } \mathrm{erf } \bigg ( \frac{\sqrt{a}}{\tilde{h}}\bigg ) \label{relc2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath357 \!&=&\ !
\frac{\tilde{h}}{2 } \sqrt{\frac{\pi } { a}}\ , e^{a(1 + \tilde{h } ^{2 } ) } \mathrm{erf } \bigg ( \frac{\sqrt{a}\tilde{h}}{2}\bigg ) , \qquad \label{relc3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath358 is the error function . finally , using eqs .
( [ tzer4])([relc3 ] ) and the approximate formula @xmath359 ( @xmath360 ) , we find the following expression for the lifetime at @xmath361 : @xmath362 , \label{tzer5}\ ] ] which is valid if @xmath244 and @xmath70 is of the order of @xmath363 .
it is not difficult to see that for these conditions the strong inequality @xmath364 holds . taking into account also eq .
( [ thigh3 ] ) , we can conclude that @xmath72 as a function of @xmath185 at @xmath365 has a local maximum ( see sec .
[ simulat ] ) .
the analytical results suggest that the numerical analysis of the lifetimes of the precessional modes should start with the study of these modes without thermal fluctuations .
more precisely , it is necessary ( i ) to determine the conditions when for a given rotating field one precessional mode exists in the up state of the magnetic moment and one in the down state , and ( ii ) to study the steady - state properties of these modes . to solve these problems
, we use the landau - lifshitz equation written in the form of eq .
( [ l - l2 ] ) with @xmath157 . in general ,
the finite state of the magnetic moment ( i.e. , state at @xmath366 ) depends not only on the parameters @xmath70 , @xmath185 and @xmath138 characterizing the rotating field , but also on how this field is switched on . in particular , a sharp switching of the rotating field induces dynamical effects that may result in a change of the initial state @xmath67.@xcite although these effects can be important for applications , they are out of our scope here .
therefore , to minimize the role of dynamical effects , we assume that the switch - on of the rotating field is slow enough . in order to determine the character of the precessional modes for a given rotating field , the following numerical scheme is used .
first , the field amplitude is discretized as @xmath367 , where @xmath368 and @xmath369 is the amplitude increment . then , putting @xmath370 and using the initial conditions @xmath371 and @xmath372 , the fourth order runge - kutta method with a time step @xmath373 is applied to solve eq .
( [ l - l2 ] ) at @xmath374 on the time interval @xmath375 $ ] ( @xmath376 ) .
it is assumed that at @xmath377 the field amplitude jumps from @xmath369 to @xmath378 , i.e. , @xmath100 becomes equal to two , and eq .
( [ l - l2 ] ) is solved again on the interval @xmath379 $ ] .
but now the initial conditions are the solutions obtained for @xmath380 at the previous stage : @xmath381 . continuing this procedure , eq .
( [ l - l2 ] ) can be solved for an arbitrary @xmath100 .
it is worth to note that since @xmath382 the solutions of this equation at @xmath383 are expected to be quite close to the steady - state solutions @xmath384 and @xmath385 . using the above procedure with @xmath386 , @xmath387 and @xmath388 [ this value of @xmath64 , which belongs to the interval @xmath389 of typical values of the damping parameter in the case of co samples,@xcite
is used in all our numerical calculations ] , we determined the character of the precessional modes for a wide range of parameters characterizing the rotating field .
it is established that if @xmath325 then only the p mode is realized for all @xmath70 and @xmath185 .
in contrast , the precessional modes at @xmath250 exhibit a much more complex behavior .
the results related to the character of these modes are summarized in the diagram shown in fig .
we note that the difference between two p modes , which exist in the regions @xmath390 and @xmath391 , is that the precession angle @xmath183 as a function of @xmath70 is discontinuous at the boundary between them .
it should also be emphasized that the transitions between the modes with @xmath329 , which occur under changing the field amplitude @xmath70 , are reversible .
for clearness of presentation , this fact is illustrated by the horizontal bidirectional arrows .
in contrast , the transitions to the p mode with @xmath325 are irreversible ( they are depicted by the horizontal unidirectional arrows ) .
( color online ) diagram of the precessional modes for @xmath250 .
the regions in the @xmath70-@xmath185 plane where different p modes exist at @xmath250 are denoted as @xmath390 ( white ) and @xmath391 ( light - green ) .
the q mode is realized in the white shaded region . in the region
denoted as @xmath392 ( blue ) the stable precessional modes with @xmath250 do not exist . here , only the p mode with @xmath325 is realized .
the vertical dotted lines ( a ) , ( b ) , ( c ) and ( d ) correspond to @xmath393 and @xmath394 , respectively . ] moreover , using eq .
( [ st1 ] ) and the stability criterion for the p mode,@xcite we independently confirmed the correctness of this diagram by calculating the lines that separate the regions with @xmath250 .
since the rotating field is switched on during the time interval of duration @xmath395 , the above procedure is time consuming .
however , in view of the importance of the diagram of the precessional modes for the problem of lifetimes , its use for the precise determination of this diagram is quite acceptable . at the same time , the application of this method to the study of the steady - state properties of a given mode , whose character is already known from the diagram , is clearly redundant .
therefore , to reduce the computational time , next we use a modified numerical procedure with @xmath396 and @xmath397 leading to @xmath398 .
figure [ fig2 ] shows the frequency dependence of the precession angle @xmath399 for different precessional modes .
( color online ) frequency dependence of the precession angle @xmath399 for different modes that exist at @xmath400 .
the frequencies @xmath401 , @xmath402 and @xmath403 are the coordinates of the points in which the vertical dotted line ( d ) , see fig .
[ fig1 ] , crosses the boundaries of the diagram ( @xmath404 , @xmath405 , and @xmath406 depend on @xmath70 ) .
the green line ( with squares ) and brown line ( with triangles ) show the frequency dependence of @xmath407 and @xmath408 , respectively , in the case of q mode . ]
the dashed ( black ) and solid ( blue ) lines correspond to the p modes with @xmath365 and @xmath409 , respectively . in accordance with fig .
[ fig1 ] , the q mode occurs at @xmath410 ( we recall that this mode can exist only if @xmath409 ) .
for this mode , the time dependence of the precession angle @xmath411 and the time dependence of the difference of phases @xmath412 are illustrated in figs .
[ fig3 ] and [ fig4 ] .
( color online ) time dependence of the precession angle @xmath413 in the case of q mode .
the parameters of the rotating field are as follows : @xmath414 , @xmath415 , and @xmath400 . ]
( color online ) time dependence of the difference of phases @xmath416 in the case of q mode .
insert : time dependence of the function @xmath417 .
the parameters of the rotating field are the same as in fig .
[ fig3 ] and @xmath418 . ]
we note that for a given set of parameters @xmath419 , i.e. , the precession angle @xmath173 in the case of q mode can cross the anisotropy barrier .
moreover , since @xmath420 and @xmath421 have the same period @xmath422 , the parameter @xmath423 and the period @xmath422 ( its frequency dependence illustrates figs . [ fig5 ] ) are connected by the condition @xmath424 , where @xmath425 is a nonnegative integer ( color online ) frequency dependence of the period @xmath422 of the precession angle @xmath411 in the case of q mode .
the rotating field parameters are taken as @xmath426 and @xmath400 . ]
that depends on @xmath70 and @xmath427 . in particular , if @xmath400 then @xmath428 at @xmath429 , where @xmath430 is the solution of the equation @xmath431 at @xmath432 .
it should also be stressed that in the last case the function @xmath433 shows a cosine - like behavior , in contrast to that shown in fig .
[ fig4 ] .
as it was mentioned earlier , the thermal fluctuations can cause the transitions between different precessional modes induced by a given rotating field . according to the diagram in fig .
[ fig1 ] , these modes , one in the up state of the magnetic moment and the other in the down state , exist only if the amplitude and frequency of the rotating field belong to the region @xmath434 , @xmath435 or q. in this case , the lifetime of a given mode can be calculated from the numerical solution of the stochastic equations ( [ l - l2 ] ) .
our testing calculations showed that the solution of these equations by the euler method gives practically the same lifetime obtained by the fourth order runge - kutta method .
but in the first case the calculation time is almost four times less .
therefore , because the procedure of determining the frequency dependence of the lifetime is extremely time - consuming , we used the euler method .
the time step @xmath436 is chosen to be @xmath437 and the initial conditions are given by @xmath438 and @xmath439 . to prevent the appearance of singularities in eq .
( [ l - l2 ] ) at @xmath440 , we assume that the point @xmath441 acts on the process @xmath442 as a reflecting screen . since our interest here is the lifetimes of the precessional modes _ reaching _ the steady state , the thermal fluctuations are switched on at @xmath443 ( see sec . [ def ] ) with @xmath444 ( see fig . [ fig6 ] ) . in the case of p modes we chose @xmath445 ,
while for the q mode @xmath446 $ ] . in the latter case , the thermal fluctuations can be switched on at a certain instant of time , e.g. , when the precession angle @xmath447 reaches maximum or minimum .
finally , in all our numerical simulations the parameter @xmath44 is chosen to be ten .
( color online ) schematic time dependence of the polar angle @xmath448 in the regions @xmath390 and @xmath391 shown in fig .
the change of the magnetic moment state @xmath67 from @xmath25 to @xmath449 occurs at @xmath450 , when @xmath451 reaches the angle @xmath452 ( the horizontal dashed line ) for the first time . for a given trajectory @xmath448 , the lifetime of the p mode in the state
@xmath453 is equal to @xmath454 . running @xmath455 trajectories ,
the mean lifetime can be evaluated as @xmath456 . ] in fig .
[ fig7 ] , we show the frequency dependencies of the lifetime @xmath457 for the rotating field amplitudes indicated in fig .
each point of these curves is determined by running @xmath458 trajectories of the polar angle @xmath448 ( see the caption to fig .
[ fig6 ] ) .
( color online ) frequency dependencies of the lifetime of the precessional modes induced by the rotating field with @xmath414 in the up state ( @xmath459 ) of the magnetic moment . ] if @xmath460 then the dependence of @xmath457 on @xmath185 is continuous and exhibits a resonant minimum at @xmath461 .
the plot of the resonant frequency @xmath462 versus the field amplitude @xmath70 is shown in fig .
in contrast , if @xmath463 then @xmath457 is discontinuous : at @xmath464 the function @xmath457 does not exist .
this result is a consequence of the fact that in the region @xmath392 ( see fig .
[ fig1 ] ) there are no stable precessional modes with @xmath465 .
( color online ) dependence of the resonant frequency of the lifetime @xmath457 on the rotating field amplitude . ] one more important feature of the lifetime @xmath457 is that it is practically not sensitive to changing the character of the precessional modes .
in particular , for @xmath466 the frequency dependence of @xmath457 ( see the red line with circles in fig . [ fig7 ] ) is continuous at the point @xmath467 ( i.e. , point separating the regions @xmath390 and @xmath468 at @xmath466 ) , while the precession angle @xmath469 is discontinuous .
this insensibility of the lifetime to changing the precessional modes with changing the field frequency @xmath427 is especially surprising when the q mode appears .
for example , even at @xmath400 , when the precession angle can cross the anisotropy barrier ( see fig .
[ fig3 ] ) , the character of the frequency dependence of @xmath457 ( see the green line with stars in fig . [ fig7 ] ) is changed at @xmath470 so small that it is not visible on this scale .
moreover , the lifetime of the q mode does almost not depend on @xmath471 $ ] .
this result is counterintuitive because different @xmath472 may correspond to very different values of the precession angle @xmath473 .
therefore , in order to get more insight into the problem , we calculated the probability density function @xmath474 of the lifetime of the q mode for two special values of @xmath475 which correspond to @xmath476 and @xmath477 , respectively .
as seen from fig .
[ fig9 ] , these density functions are somewhat different from each other only if @xmath478 . in this region
the probability density @xmath479 depends on @xmath472 and exhibits local minima and maxima which come from a complex behavior of the q mode .
in contrast , at @xmath480 the memory about the chosen value of @xmath472 and periodicity of @xmath411 and @xmath481 is lost . as a consequence , in this region the difference between density functions vanishes and the local minima and maxima disappear .
such behavior of @xmath474 on @xmath482 confirms that the lifetime @xmath483 practically does not depend on @xmath472 .
( color online ) probability density functions of the lifetime of the q mode for two values of @xmath475 .
the blue solid and red dashed lines correspond to such @xmath475 that @xmath484 and @xmath485 , respectively .
insert : the same density functions in a larger time scale .
the parameters of the rotating field are as follows : @xmath414 , @xmath486 , and @xmath400 . ] finally , the influence of the direction of field rotation on the frequency dependence of the lifetime of the precessional modes is illustrated in fig .
[ fig10 ] . in accordance with our analytical results ,
the rotating field with @xmath414 and @xmath487 influences the lifetime @xmath457 in a different way .
specifically , @xmath457 as a function of @xmath427 at @xmath414 displays a deep minimum , while at @xmath487 it shows a pronounced maximum .
( color online ) frequency dependencies of the lifetime of the precessional modes in the up state ( @xmath459 ) of the magnetic moment .
it is assumed that @xmath400 for both clockwise ( @xmath487 ) and counterclockwise ( @xmath414 ) rotation of the magnetic field . ]
this difference in the behavior of the lifetime results from that the rotating fields with different @xmath138 act on the magnetic moment in a given state @xmath67 quite differently . from a physical point of view
, the reason is that the magnetic moment has a definite direction of the natural precession .
we note also that the numerical data @xmath488 and @xmath489 are in a good agreement with the analytical results @xmath490 and @xmath491 obtained from the asymptotic formulas ( [ thigh3 ] ) and ( [ tzer5 ] ) , respectively . some difference between them can be caused by that the asymptotic formulas , which were obtained at @xmath248 , are applied to @xmath492 .
we have studied in detail the thermal stability of the precessional modes of the nanoparticle magnetic moment induced by the rotating magnetic field whose plane of rotation is perpendicular to the easy axis of the nanoparticle .
if the direction of field rotation and the direction of the natural precession of the magnetic moment are opposite , i.e. , if the condition @xmath325 holds , then only periodic ( p ) stable mode is induced by this field . in contrast , if the above mentioned directions coincide , i.e. , if @xmath250 , then the magnetic moment exhibits a much more complicated behavior .
the numerical solution of the deterministic landau - lifshitz equation in the long - time limit has shown that , depending on the rotating field amplitude and frequency , in this case the magnetic moment can be in one of two p modes , in the quasi - periodic ( q ) mode , or even be unstable .
these results obtained in the absence of thermal fluctuations have been collected in the diagram shown in fig . 1 .
if the amplitude and frequency of the rotating field are chosen so that a stable precessional mode exists in both up ( @xmath459 ) and down ( @xmath493 ) states of the magnetic moment , then the thermal fluctuations can cause transitions between these modes .
one of the most important parameters characterizing these transitions is the lifetime of a given mode .
since it can be naturally associated with the mean first - passage time for the magnetic moment , we have used the fokker - planck formalism to define this quantity and calculate its properties . in particular
, we have determined the boundary conditions and transformation properties of the lifetime and have developed an analytical method for finding its frequency dependence in the case of high anisotropy barrier and small amplitudes of the rotating field . using this method
, it has been shown that the rotating field ( a ) slightly decreases ( if @xmath250 ) or increases ( if @xmath494 ) the lifetime of the p mode at large frequencies and ( b ) strongly decreases it ( if @xmath250 ) in the vicinity of the larmor frequency .
we have also established that at zero frequency the lifetime is always less than in the limit of large frequencies .
these analytical findings for the lifetime of the p mode have been confirmed by our numerical simulations of the stochastic landau - lifshitz equation .
moreover , the numerical simulations of this equation for not too small amplitudes of the rotating field permitted us to solve the problem of the lifetime of the q mode . since in this case
the precession angle is a periodic function of time which can cross the anisotropy barrier , the solution of this problem is of particular interest .
it has turned out that , although the precessional angle depends on time , the lifetime of the q mode practically does not depend on this time , i.e. , on the precession angle .
we have also verified this result by calculating the lifetime from the first - passage time distributions that correspond to different values of the precession angle .
we are grateful to the institute of applied physics nas of ukraine for granting us access to their computing facilities .
i. uti , j. fabian , and s. das sarma , rev . mod .
phys . * 76 * , 323 ( 2004 ) .
s. a. wolf , d. d. awschalom , r. a. buhrman , j. m. daughton , s. von molnr , m. l. roukes , a. y. chtchelkanova , and d. m. treger , sciense * 294 * , 1488 ( 2001 ) .
s. laurent , d. forge , m. port , a. roch , c. robic , l. vander elst , and r. n. muller , chem .
rev . * 108 * , 2064 ( 2008 ) .
m. ferrari , nat .
cancer * 5 * , 161 ( 2005 ) .
q. a. pankhurst , j. connolly , s. k. jones , and j. dobson , j. phys .
d : appl .
* 36 * , r167 ( 2003 ) .
p. hnggi , p. talkner , and m. borkovec , rev .
phys . * 62 * , 251 ( 1990 ) . c. w. gardiner , _ handbook of stochastic methods _ , 2nd ed .
( springer - verlag , berlin , 1990 ) .
s. redner , _ a guide to first - passage processes _ ( cambridge university press , cambridge , 2001 ) . c. thirion , w. wernsdorfer , and d. mailly , nat .
* 2 * , 524 ( 2003 ) .
z. z. sun and x. r. wang , phys .
b * 73 * , 092416 ( 2006 ) .
z. z. sun and x. r. wang , phys .
b * 74 * , 132401 ( 2006 ) .
j. podbielski , d. heitmann , and d. grundler , phys .
* 99 * , 207202 ( 2007 ) .
g. woltersdorf and c. h. back , phys .
lett . * 99 * , 227207 ( 2007 ) .
g. bertotti , c. serpico , and i. d. mayergoyz , phys .
lett . * 86 * , 724 ( 2001 ) .
g. bertotti , i. d. mayergoyz , and c. serpico , physica b * 343 * , 325 ( 2004 ) .
s. i. denisov , t. v. lyutyy , p. hnggi , and k. n. trohidou , phys .
b * 74 * , 104406 ( 2006 ) .
g. bertotti , i. d. mayergoyz , c. serpico , m. daquino , and r. bonin , j. appl .
* 105 * , 07b712 ( 2009 ) .
l. chotorlishvili , p. schwab , and j. berakdar , j. phys .
: condens .
matter * 22 * , 036002 ( 2010 ) .
s. i. denisov , t. v. lyutyy , p. hnggi , phys .
lett . * 97 * , 227202 ( 2006 ) .
s. i. denisov , k. sakmann , p. talkner , and p. hnggi , europhys .
lett . * 76 * , 1001 ( 2006 ) .
s. i. denisov , k. sakmann , p. talkner , and p. hnggi , phys .
b * 75 * , 184432 ( 2007 ) . | we study the thermal stability of the periodic ( p ) and quasi - periodic ( q ) precessional modes of the nanoparticle magnetic moment induced by a rotating magnetic field .
an analytical method for determining the lifetime of the p mode in the case of high anisotropy barrier and small amplitudes of the rotating field is developed within the fokker - planck formalism . in general case
, the thermal stability of both p and q modes is investigated by numerical simulation of the stochastic landau - lifshitz equation .
we show analytically and numerically that the lifetime is a nonmonotonic function of the rotating field frequency which , depending on the direction of field rotation , has either a pronounced maximum or a deep minimum near the larmor frequency . |
this paper is part of a program aimed at increasing the number of galaxies with accurate distance determinations via ground - based multicolor ccd photometry of cepheid variables . in the first paper of the series , capaccioli , piotto and bresolin ( 1991 , cpb ) presented new @xmath3 photometry of the cepheids belonging to the sample of variables already identified by sandage and carlson ( 1988 , sc ) in ngc 3109 . in that work
, cpb derived a new zero point for the photometric scale .
the new data gave a distance modulus @xmath4 mag , @xmath5% shorter than previously measured by sc .
the availability of only two photometric bands ( @xmath6 and @xmath7 ) did not allow cpb to apply the multicolor method discussed by freedman ( 1985 , f85 ) to directly estimate the internal absorption of the cepheids in ngc 3109 .
actually , bresolin , capaccioli , and piotto ( 1993 , bcp ) pointed out that the internal absorption in some of the fields studied by cpb could be greater than the adopted average value e(b - v)=0.04 .
besides improving the photometry of the cepheids previously discovered on photographic plates , ccd data allow us also to obtain more accurate and deeper photometry in crowded fields , enabling the discovery of new fainter cepheids .
the consequent extension of the period luminosity relation ( @xmath8 ) to shorter periods permits a more accurate determination of its zero point .
for instance , in the second paper of this series , piotto , capaccioli and pellegrini ( 1994 , pcp ) found five new cepheids in sextans a and four in sextans b , in addition to the five variables in sextans a and the three in sextans b already discovered by sandage and carlson ( 1982 , 1985 ) .
the new variables extended the faint end of the @xmath8 relation of these two galaxies by one magnitude .
pcp observed these two galaxies in three passbands : @xmath6 , @xmath7 and @xmath9 , again obtaining a new zero point for the photometric calibration . using the multiwavelength photometry method ( f85 ) they derived a true distance modulus , corrected for interstellar extinction , of @xmath10 for sextans a and of @xmath11 for sextans b , assuming a distance modulus @xmath12 for the large magellanic cloud ( lmc ) . in the framework of this program , here we present a new determination of the distance to the galaxy ngc 3109 based on a new @xmath13 photometry of the cepheids located in the field f1 of bcp .
the data set and the reduction procedures are illustrated in the section 2 . in section 3
we present the already known variables and our 16 new cepheid candidates on which the present distance determination of ngc 3109 is based .
the determination of the cepheid parameters is discussed in section 4 , while section 5 is devoted to the determination of the distance to ngc 3109 . a comparison of the pl and period - color relations for the cepheids in a few nearby galaxies is presented in section 6 . a brief discussion and a comparison with the previous determinations of the distance to ngc 3109 is in section 7 .
this study is a follow up of the work by cpb . in that paper
it was impossible to identify new cepheids due to the limited time coverage and small number of data points ( six at most ) .
we then collected , in december 1991 , march 1992 and february 1993 , a series of @xmath6 , @xmath7 , @xmath14 , and @xmath9band images of a @xmath15 field ( fig .
1 ) of ngc 3109 coded as f1 ( table [ table1 ] for the log of the observations ) .
rcccc 1 - 12 - 1991 & i & 24 & @xmath16&0.051 - 12 - 1991 & r & 12 & @xmath17&0.051 - 03 - 1992 & b & 40 & @xmath18&0.03 1 - 03 - 1992 & v & 20 & @xmath19&0.032 - 03 - 1992 & b & 40 & @xmath20&0.033 - 03 - 1992 & b & 40 & @xmath21&0.037 - 03 - 1992 & b & 40 & @xmath22&0.038 - 03 - 1992 & b & 40 & @xmath23&0.039 - 03 - 1992 & b & 40 & @xmath24&0.039 - 03 - 1992 & r & 18 & @xmath25&0.0717 - 02 - 1993 & b & 30 & @xmath23&0.0318 - 02 - 1993 & b & 30 & @xmath26&0.0320 - 02 - 1993 & b & 25 & @xmath27&0.0320 - 02 - 1993 & i & 13 & @xmath28&0.05 the @xmath9 and @xmath14 band images of december 1991 were taken with efosc2 + ccd # 17 at the eso / mpi 2.2 m telescope at la silla in chile .
the ccd format is @xmath29 pixels of @xmath30 .
the set of the @xmath6 , @xmath7 , and @xmath14 band images of march 1992 was obtained with the rca # 8 ccd camera at the cassegrain focus of the eso / mpi 2.2 m telescope with a ccd format of 640@xmath311024 pixels and a pixel size of @xmath32 .
furthermore , three @xmath6band frames at the blue arm of emmi equipped with the tektronix # 31 ccd and one in the @xmath9band at the red arm of emmi with the tektronik # 18 ccd have been collected at the eso - ntt telescope on february , 1993 .
ccd dimensions is @xmath29 pixels and the pixel sizes in blue and red are @xmath33 and @xmath34 respectively . during these observing runs , at least thirteen landolt s ( 1983a
, b ) standard stars were observed in each color in order to transform the instrumental photometry into the landolt standard system . a large set of bias , dark , and flat field frames have been collected , particularly during the observing runs at the 2.2 m telescope .
indeed , the columns of the high resolution eso - rca chip # 8 have not a constant bias as it depends on the total intensity of the light which falls over the column .
the procedure used for the image cleaning and calibration is as in pcp and pellegrini ( 1993 ) .
the ccd data have been reduced with daophot and allstar .
particular attention has been devoted in tying the stellar photometry to landolt s ( 1983a , b ) standard system . for the calibration of the @xmath6 and @xmath7 colors we used the previous cpb calibration , while for the calibration of the @xmath14-band and @xmath9-band we observed 16 landolt ( 1983a , b ) standard stars in each color in december of 1991 and 13 landolt standard stars for the @xmath9 band in february of 1993 . as in piotto
( 1990 ) , in order to obtain the @xmath35 , @xmath36 and @xmath37 calibrated magnitudes we adopted linear color terms . for the calibration of the @xmath38 magnitudes we applied the same calibration parameters of @xmath35 , after having obtained the linear relation between @xmath35 and @xmath38 .
the uncertainty on the calibration of the @xmath6 and @xmath7 photometry is @xmath39 mag .
this value represents the combination of the error in the cpb calibration and of the error on the zero point difference between our photometry and that of cpb . for the @xmath14 and @xmath9 bands we obtained a zero point error in the calibration equation of 0.01 mag
however , the largest error source in the calibration procedure comes from the transformation of the zero point of the point - spread - function ( psf ) fitting photometry of ngc 3109 stars into the standard star aperture photometry zero point ( cpb ) . in our frames
all of the stars are distributed over a very inhomogeneous background , making the aperture photometry quite uncertain . for the @xmath9 band
we have two independent calibrations ( one from the 2.2 m telescope and one from the ntt telescope ) .
the average zero point differences from night to night were of 0.05 mag .
the same ( average ) zero point calibration has been adopted for the two @xmath9 frames . in @xmath14
we could not use the same method , since the calibration equation was available for one night only .
for @xmath35 we obtained an error of @xmath40 mag on the difference between the aperture photometry and the psf fitting photometry .
finally , we obtained an uncertainty of @xmath41 mag on the calibration of the @xmath38 magnitude determinations summing the error on the linear relation between @xmath35 and @xmath38 magnitudes to the calibration error of the @xmath35 calibration . throughout the paper ,
whenever needed , we took into proper account the fact that the zero point calibration of @xmath35 is more accurate then the @xmath38 one .
the calibration zero point errors for each image are reported in table [ table1 ] , col .
the internal error on the photometry can be easily evaluated by comparing the independent magnitude determinations of the not variable stars in each color . for each color ,
table [ table2 ] , gives the mean internal errors ( identified with _ error _
, cols . 2 , 4 , 6 and 8) and the number of stars ( identified with _ stars _ , cols . 3 , 5 , 7 and 9 ) at different magnitude intervals ( col
1 ) in the four photometric bands .
the accuracy of the ccd light curves of the cepheids can be obtained from the uncertainties quoted in this table .
ccrccrccrccr 19.75 & 0.04 & 12 & & 0.02 & 23&&0.02&42&&0.02&5520.25 & 0.04 & 28 & & 0.04 & 38&&0.03&66&&0.03&8420.75 & 0.04 & 83 & & 0.04 & 108&&0.04&140&&0.04&12121.25 & 0.04 & 118 & & 0.05 & 172&&0.05&150&&0.06&12121.75 & 0.05 & 157 & & 0.06 & 208&&0.06&163&&0.08&9522.25 & 0.06 & 189 & & 0.07 & 227&&0.10&76&&0.12&1722.75 & 0.07 & 192 & & 0.09 & 136&&0.20&18&&0.29&823.25 & 0.08 & 134 & & 0.14 & 50&&&&&&23.75 & 0.13 & 33 & & 0.30 & 6&&&&&& 24.25 & 0.17 & 8 & & 0.32 & 1&&&&&&
sc have identified 29 cepheids in ngc 3109 .
cpb selected only 21 of them , excluding candidate cepheids with high photometric uncertainties or those that did not show significant light variations during the period covered by their observations ( cpb for more details ) .
this work is based on the same selection of 21 cepheids .
six of them ( marked as v in fig . [ fig1 ] ) fall in field f1 monitored in the present study . as in cpb
, we applied a zero point shift of @xmath42 mag to the sc data ( sc data are fainter ) .
the new ccd data in the @xmath6band for the six cepheids located in the field f1 were plotted together with cpb and sc photometry , and the periods were interactively adjusted in order to obtain the best phase match among these three data sets .
the new , complete light curves of these six cepheids are reproduced in fig .
differences between our and cpb periods are very small , @xmath43 days for v72 and @xmath44 days for the other variables ( table [ table5 ] ) . for each of these variables , we could also add another point in the @xmath7band light curve , and one or two magnitude determinations in the @xmath9 and @xmath14 bands .
in addition , also sc v36 and v45 variables fall within our larger @xmath14 and @xmath9 frames , allowing us to measure their @xmath14 and @xmath9 magnitudes .
the new magnitude determinations for the sc cepheids are reported in the table [ table3 ] .
rccccccccc & & & 2448591.825 & & & & & & & & 21.13 & 20.948683.579 & & 22.37 & & & & 22.65 & 21.92 & & 8684.779 & 21.85 & & & & & 23.08 & & & 8685.561 & 22.20 & & & & & 23.11 & & & 8688.789 & 23.10 & & & & & & & & 8689.794 & 22.84 & & & & & & & & 8690.786 & 21.91 & & 21.11 & & & & & 21.72 & 9036.804 & 22.20 & & & & & 22.83 & & & 9037.688 & 22.46 & & & & & 23.00 & & & 9039.734 & & & & 20.90 & & & & & & & & 2448591.825 & & & 20.54 & 20.27 & & & & 21.40 & 21.208683.579 & 22.39 & & & & & 22.90 & 22.07 & & 8684.779 & 22.55 & & & & & & & & 8685.561 & 22.53 & & & & & 22.84 & & & 8688.789 & 22.42 & & & & & & & & 8689.794 & & & & & & 22.76 & & & 8690.786 & 22.31 & & 20.42 & & & 22.93 & & 22.66 & 9036.804 & 22.06 & & & & & 23.21 & & & 9037.688 & 21.52 & & & & & 22.91 & & & 9039.734 & 21.91 & & & 20.00 & & 22.28 & & & 21.08 & & & 2448591.825 & & & 20.22 & 19.90 & & & & 22.41 & 21.548683.579 & 22.10 & 21.18 & & & & 22.90 & & & 8684.779 & 22.22 & & & & & 22.83 & & & 8685.561 & 22.02 & & & & & 22.77 & & & 8688.789 & 21.43 & & & & & 22.31 & & & 8689.794 & 21.60 & & & & & & & & 8690.786 & 21.69 & & 20.23 & & & 22.58 & & & 9036.804 & 22.14 & & & & & 22.37 & & & 9037.688 & 22.16 & & & & & 22.82 & & & 9039.734 & 21.29 & & & 19.96 & & 22.72 & & & & & & 2448591.825 & & & 22.41 & 21.54 & & & & 22.50 & 8683.579 & & & & & & & & & 8684.779 & & & & & & & & & 8685.561 & & & & & & & & & 8688.789 & & & & & & & & & 8689.794 & & & & & & & & & 8690.786 & & & & & & & & & 9036.804 & & & & & & & & & 9037.688 & & & & & & & & & 9039.734 & & & & & & & & & in order to search for new candidate cepheid variables , we used both cpb raw data and the photometry presented in this paper .
we computed for each star , for both the @xmath6 and @xmath7 magnitude determinations , the _ normalized _ standard deviation ( @xmath45 ) , i.e. the standard deviation divided by the mean photometric internal error in each magnitude intervals of 0.5 mag .
we considered as possible variables only those stars satisfying the relation : @xmath46 by this procedure , we isolated 129 stars .
the possible cepheids were selected from these candidates on the basis of their light curve , excluding spurious objects in which only one or two points contributed to the large deviation .
we ended with a list of 29 stars . among these
there were all the cepheids previously discovered by sc .
of the remaining variable candidates , only 16 had colors and light curves ( after rephasing ) typical of a cepheid colors have proven to be a valuable aid in discriminating cepheids from other variables , allowing the rejection of many objects with colors differing significantly from those typical of cepheids ( also fig .
[ fig11 ] ) . ] .
the 16 new cepheid candidates located in field f1 are marked with a circle and coded as p in fig .
[ fig1 ] ; their photometry is reported in table [ table4 ] .
the most probable periods of the new cepheids have been determined by the usual fourier analysis .
more data are needed to confirm the periods , though the light curves seem well enough covered to allow a fair determination of the parameters of the pl relation .
the light curves of these new candidates are plotted with their tentative periods in fig .
[ fig3 ] . *
a ) * * b ) * rccccccccc & & & 2447967.588 & 22.56 & 22.02 & & & & 22.81 & 22.40 & & 7968.559 & 22.97 & 22.14 & & & & 22.08 & 21.88 & & 7969.581 & 23.23 & 22.44 & & & & 22.16 & 21.98 & & 7970.551 & 23.38 & 22.49 & & & & 22.38 & 22.02 & & 7971.570 & 23.57 & 22.63 & & & & 22.78 & 22.36 & & 8591.825 & & & 22.30 & 22.07 & & & & 22.01 & 8683.579 & & & & & & & & & 8684.779 & & & & & & & & & 8685.561 & & & & & & & & & 8688.789 & 23.68 & & & & & 22.48 & & & 8689.794 & 22.57 & & & & & 22.87 & & & 8690.786 & & & & & & 22.80 & & & 9036.804 & 22.76 & & & & & 22.53 & & & 9037.688 & 23.03 & & & & & 22.68 & & & 9039.734 & & & & 21.90 & & & & & 21.83 & & & 2447967.588 & 22.04 & 21.27 & & & & 22.94 & 23.16 & & 7968.559 & 22.12 & 21.28 & & & & 23.12 & & & 7969.581 & 22.13 & & & & & 23.15 & & & 7970.551 & 22.40 & 21.40 & & & & 23.20 & 22.83 & & 7971.570 & 22.37 & 21.55 & & & & 23.61 & 23.03 & & 8591.825 & & & 20.65 & 20.42 & & & & & 8683.579 & 21.66 & 20.97 & & & & 23.02 & & & 8684.779 & 21.59 & & & & & & & & 8685.561 & 21.68 & & & & & 22.89 & & & 8688.789 & 21.97 & & & & & 23.21 & & & 8689.794 & 22.22 & & & & & 22.87 & & & 8690.786 & & & 20.94 & & & 23.27 & & & 9036.804 & 21.90 & & & & & 22.85 & & & 9037.688 & 21.63 & & & & & 23.16 & & & 9039.734 & 21.81 & & & 20.36 & & 22.67 & & & & & & 2447967.588 & 22.00 & 21.29 & & & & 22.36 & 21.91 & & 7968.559 & 22.34 & 21.53 & & & & 22.81 & 21.95 & & 7969.581 & 22.29 & 21.51 & & & & 22.00 & 21.51 & & 7970.551 & 22.41 & & & & & 21.90 & 21.70 & & 7971.570 & 22.76 & 21.96 & & & & 22.24 & 21.69 & & 8591.825 & & & & 20.74 & & & & 21.36 & 21.008683.579 & 22.36 & 21.55 & & & & 22.48 & & & 8684.779 & & & & & & 21.76 & & & 8685.561 & 22.68 & & & & & 21.84 & & & 8688.789 & 21.77 & & & & & 21.93 & & & 8689.794 & 21.83 & & & & & 21.80 & & & 8690.786 & 22.27 & & 21.07 & & & 22.00 & & 21.37 & 9036.804 & 22.94 & & & & & 22.36 & & & 9037.688 & 22.93 & & & & & 21.68 & & & 9039.734 & 21.62 & & & 20.64 & & 22.15 & & & 21.04 & & & 2447967.588 & 23.07 & 21.71 & & & & 23.05 & 22.64 & & 7968.559 & & & & & & 23.44 & & & 7969.581 & & 21.62 & & & & 23.06 & 22.84 & & 7970.551 & 22.85 & 21.64 & & & & 23.17 & & & 7971.570 & 23.65 & 21.59 & & & & 23.01 & 23.02 & & 8683.579 & 22.64 & 21.48 & & & & 22.74 & & & 8684.779 & 22.55 & & & & & & & & 8685.561 & 22.69 & & & & & & & & 8688.789 & 22.60 & & & & & 22.97 & & & 8689.794 & 22.43 & & & & & 23.31 & & & 8690.786 & 22.57 & & & & & 23.29 & & & 9036.804 & 22.36 & & & & & 22.82 & & & 9037.688 & 22.70 & & & & & 22.90 & & & 9039.734 & & & & & & 22.81 & & & & & & 2447967.588 & 22.15 & 21.69 & & & & 23.09 & & & 7968.559 & 21.93 & & & & & 22.74 & & & 7969.581 & 22.34 & & & & & 22.64 & 21.69 & & 7970.551 & 22.44 & 21.76 & & & & 23.27 & 21.91 & & 7971.570 & 22.78 & 21.80 & & & & 22.64 & 21.66 & & 8591.825 & & & 21.00 & & & & & & 20.48 + 8683.579 & 22.05 & 21.50 & & & & 22.54 & 21.61 & & + 8684.779 & 21.99 & & & & & 22.62 & & & + 8685.561 & 22.21 & & & & & 22.96 & & & + 8688.789 & 22.05 & & & & & & & & + 8689.794 & & & & & & 22.93 & & & + 8690.786 & & & 20.99 & & & 22.39 & & 21.29 & + 9036.804 & 21.79 & & & & & 22.22 & & & + 9037.688 & 22.05 & & & & & 22.41 & & & + 9039.734 & & & & 20.77 & & 21.86 & & & 20.35 + & & & 2447967.588 & 22.32 & 21.59 & & & & 22.77 & & & 7968.559 & 21.54 & 21.01 & & & & & & & 7969.581 & 22.06 & 22.12 & & & & 22.85 & 22.74 & & 7970.551 & 22.31 & 21.78 & & & & 22.97 & 22.98 & & 7971.570 & & 21.59 & & & & 23.37 & 22.92 & & 8591.825 & & & & & & & & 22.49 & 8683.579 & 21.94 & 21.73 & & & & 22.70 & 22.32 & & 8684.779 & 21.51 & & & & & 23.02 & & & 8685.561 & 21.74 & & & & & 22.72 & & & 8688.789 & 21.92 & & & & & & & & 8689.794 & 22.87 & & & & & 23.05 & & & 8690.786 & 21.53 & & 21.38 & & & 22.69 & & 22.24 & 9036.804 & 20.97 & & & & & & & & 9037.688 & 22.05 & & & & & 22.70 & & & 9039.734 & 20.91 & & & & & 22.11 & & & & & & 2447967.588 & 22.26 & 21.80 & & & & 22.64 & 22.37 & & 7968.559 & 22.29 & 21.57 & & & & 22.41 & 22.24 & & 7969.581 & 22.67 & 21.78 & & & & 22.43 & 22.08 & & 7970.551 & 22.74 & 22.22 & & & & 22.40 & 22.04 & & 7971.570 & 21.98 & 21.63 & & & & 22.42 & 21.87 & & 8591.825 & & & 21.35 & 21.11 & & & & 22.20 & 8683.579 & 22.65 & & & & & 22.71 & & & 8684.779 & & & & & & & & & 8685.561 & 22.51 & & & & & 22.76 & & & 8688.789 & 22.64 & & & & & 23.06 & & & 8689.794 & 22.62 & & & & & & & & 8690.786 & 22.76 & & 21.65 & & & 23.08 & & 22.41 & 9036.804 & 22.36 & & & & & 22.93 & & & 9037.688 & 22.65 & & & & & 23.01 & & & 9039.734 & 21.99 & & & & & 22.71 & & & 20.55 & & & 2447967.588 & 21.88 & 21.15 & & & & 23.97 & 23.28 & & 7968.559 & 22.02 & 21.44 & & & & 23.06 & 22.69 & & 7969.581 & 22.39 & & & & & 23.45 & 22.85 & & 7970.551 & 22.02 & 21.42 & & & & & 23.20 & & 7971.570 & 21.47 & 21.09 & & & & 22.72 & 22.33 & & 8591.825 & & & 21.16 & & & & & 22.51 & 8683.579 & & & & & & 23.72 & 23.36 & & 8684.779 & 21.75 & & & & & & & & 8685.561 & 22.19 & & & & & & & & 8688.789 & 21.73 & & & & & 23.44 & & & 8689.794 & 21.12 & & & & & & & & 8690.786 & 21.76 & & & & & 22.73 & & & 9036.804 & 21.85 & & & & & 24.10 & & & 9037.688 & 21.23 & & & & & 24.01 & & & 9039.734 & 21.73 & & & & & 23.75 & & & 22.18
the old photographic and the new ccd @xmath6band data provide a good coverage of the blue light curves .
it is therefore straightforward to derive the magnitudes at maximum ( @xmath47 ) and the mean magnitudes ( @xmath48 ) listed in cols . 4 and 5 of table [ table5 ] . the parameters for the sc cepheids
have been estimated giving more weight to the ccd than to the photographic photometry , particularly at the minimum light .
we also attempted to obtain the phase weighted mean magnitude using the relation ( 4 ) in saha et al .
( 1994 ) after transform the magnitudes into intensities .
as discussed by saha & hoessel ( 1990 ) , this method takes care of the bias introduced by the loss of faint measurements .
unfortunately , the phase sampling of the light curves is not sufficiently even ; thus , we preferred to compute the mean directly from the light curve drawn by hand trough the available points and use the phase weighted mean only for a comparison . in order to obtain the mean @xmath7band magnitude we used the same method as for the @xmath6band .
these values are reported in col .
7 of table [ table5 ] .
rccccccccccc v6 & 7.0223 & 7.02120 & 21.78 & 22.46 & 0.04&21.80 & 0.04 & 20.92 & 0.29 & 20.77 & 0.23v7 & 5.9879 & 5.98810 & 21.71 & 22.43 & 0.05&21.98 & 0.05 & 21.22 & 0.32 & 20.91 & 0.24v8 & 14.4500& & 20.85 & 21.45 & 0.10&&&& v9 & 7.7670& & 22.10 & 22.90 & 0.10&21.90 & 0.10 & && v11 & 7.9298& & 21.85 & 22.40 & 0.10&&&& v12 & 8.1183& & 21.70 & 22.43 & 0.10&21.86 & 0.10 & && v18 & 8.3707& & 21.60 & 22.38 & 0.10&21.68 & 0.10 & && v20 & 8.2718& & 21.90 & 22.40 & 0.10&22.20 & 0.10 & && v34 & 17.2320&17.22550 & 21.43 & 22.12 & 0.04&21.28 & 0.05 & 20.62 & 0.30 & 20.12 & 0.23v35 & 8.1928 & 8.19190 & 21.65 & 22.45 & 0.05&21.80 & 0.05 & 21.53 & 0.35 & 21.22 & 0.27 v36 & 7.1290& & 21.90 & 22.25 & 0.10&21.82 & 0.10 & 21.62 & 0.15 & 21.40 & 0.12v44 & 9.0970& & 21.10 & 21.80 & 0.10&21.27 & 0.10 & && v45 & 8.7620& & 21.50 & 22.05 & 0.10&21.36 & 0.10 & 21.04 & 0.19 & & v57 & 7.2595& & 21.35 & 21.70 & 0.10&&&& v64 & 19.5745&19.57070 & 21.05 & 21.79 & 0.04&20.93 & 0.04 & 20.44 & 0.32 & 20.02 & 0.25v72 & 8.6805 & 9.09400 & 21.72 & 22.32 & 0.04&21.76 & 0.04 & 21.34 & 0.26 & 21.02 & 0.20v77 & 5.8170& & 22.10 & 22.60 & 0.10&22.00 & 0.10 & && v79 & 8.2480& & 21.95 & 22.55 & 0.10&21.70 & 0.10 & && v81 & 19.9570& & 21.15 & 21.88 & 0.10&21.12 & 0.10 & && v92 & 13.3165& & 21.45 & 21.93 & 0.10&21.15 & 0.10 & && p1 & & 8.61700 & 22.30 & 22.99 & 0.05&22.28 & 0.05 & 22.07 & 0.30 & 21.76 & 0.23p2 & & 5.27800 & 22.00 & 22.50 & 0.04&22.18 & 0.04 & 22.10 & 0.22 & 21.87 & 0.17p3 & &13.60000 & 21.50 & 22.00 & 0.03&21.24 & 0.03 & 20.77 & 0.22 & 20.36 & 0.17p4 & & 2.32980 & 22.55 & 23.13 & 0.04&23.06 & 0.06 & && p5 & &10.62600 & 21.60 & 22.30 & 0.04&21.64 & 0.04 & 20.91 & 0.30 & 20.30 & 0.24 p6 & & 4.70380 & 21.65 & 22.23 & 0.03&21.68 & 0.04 & 21.40 & 0.25 & 21.00 & 0.20p7 & & 5.34060 & 22.31 & 23.00 & 0.04&21.65 & 0.04 & && p8 & &2.54200 & 22.71 & 23.07 & 0.03&22.79 & 0.04 & && p9 & & 5.34250 & 21.74 & 22.42 & 0.04&21.73 & 0.04 & 20.93 & 0.30 & 20.61 & 0.23 p10 & & 3.20620 & 21.85 & 22.63 & 0.04&21.68 & 0.05 & 21.13 & 0.34 & 20.53 & 0.26p11 & & 2.78930 & 21.10 & 22.00 & 0.05&21.58 & 0.06 & 21.12 & 0.40 & & p12 & &10.85540 & 21.80 & 22.57 & 0.04&22.27 & 0.05 & 21.86 & 0.34 & & p13 & & 6.00240 & 21.89 & 22.33 & 0.03&21.81 & 0.04 & 21.26 & 0.19 & 21.00 & 0.15p14 & &17.29510 & 22.20 & 22.65 & 0.03&& & 22.09 & 0.20 & & p15 & &
7.10590 & 21.10 & 21.80 & 0.04&21.30 & 0.04 & 21.19 & 0.31 & & p16 & & 3.54310 & 22.70 & 23.41 & 0.06&22.89 & 0.06 & 22.32 & 0.31 & 21.85 & 0.24 finally , even though there are only random phase data available in @xmath14 and @xmath9 bands , it is always possible to use the information from the blue light curves to correct these observations to the mean @xmath49 , @xmath50 light ( freedman 1988 , f88 ) .
the cepheid light curves in blue differ from those at longer wavelength in two respects : _
( i ) _ the amplitude decreases with increasing wavelength , and _
( ii ) _ there is a phase shift moving from the @xmath6 to the @xmath9band . after transforming the blue photographic light curves into the ccd photometric scale , a correction for both the amplitude scale and the phase shift was applied as in f88 in order to obtain the mean magnitudes for the @xmath14 and @xmath9 data ( cols . 9 and 11 of table [ table5 ] ) . here
, we took into proper account that the @xmath35 magnitude determinations are more accurate then the @xmath38 ones . in order to estimate the uncertainty associated with the mean magnitudes , we considered all the independent sources of errors acting on this quantity : the amplitude of the light curve that was converted into its equivalent variance ( see freedman et al .
1991 , 1992 ) , the internal photometric errors , and the zero - point errors in the calibrated magnitudes ( see table [ table1 ] and table [ table2 ] ) .
for the bands @xmath6 and @xmath7 , the total error was obtained adding in quadrature these errors and dividing by the reduced number of degrees of freedom . for the bands @xmath14 and @xmath9 , we have so few points ( no more than two ) that we consider more reasonable assuming as error on the mean magnitudes the half - amplitude of the light curve , as predicted from the @xmath6 light curve ( f88 ) . obviously , this uncertainty must be considered as an upper limit of the error to be associated to the mean magnitude .
the resulting errors are shown in table 5 cols .
6,8,10 , and 12 .
recently , it has been repeatedly pointed out that the principal source of systematic errors in the calibration of the primary distance indicators is in the uncertainty in determination of the zero points of the cepheid period - luminosity and period - luminosity - color ( plc ) relations ( freedman & madore 1993 , fukugita et al .
for this reason we prefer to derive the distance modulus of ngc 3109 by comparison with the large magellanic cloud cepheids , as we did in the other papers of this series ( cpb , pcp ) and as it was originally suggested by f88 .
indeed the distance modulus of the lmc can be derived using several independent methods ( and owing to the large number of known cepheids in the magellanic clouds , these galaxies represent almost ideal laboratories for the calibrations of pl and plc relations ) .
the method has the advantage of leaving the relative distance unaffected by whatever improvement there will be in the distance of the lmc . according to hunter & gallagher ( 1985 )
, the metal content of ngc 3109 should be just @xmath51 times higher than in the lmc .
therefore , we do not expect significant effects on the pl relations for the two galaxies .
in fact , freedman & madore ( 1990 ) have shown that the distance moduli obtained via cepheid pl relation in a study of three fields of m31 with metal content from 0.5 to 2.5 times the solar metallicity range over less than 0.27 mag .
figures [ fig4 ] , [ fig5 ] , [ fig6 ] and [ fig7 ] present the pl relations from the mean @xmath6 , @xmath7 , @xmath14 and @xmath9 magnitudes of the cepheids listed in table [ table5 ] .
_ filled circles _ represent both sc and our cepheids in the field f1 of ngc 3109 , while _ open circles _
refer to the sc cepheids located in the other fields .
_ crosses _ reproduce the photoelectric data for the lmc cepheids ( sandage 1988 , madore & freedman , 1991 ) , shifted by the zero point difference between the ngc 3109 pl relation and the lmc one .
the slopes of these two relations appear similar in all four colors , in agreement with the postulate on which the use of the cepheids as distance indicators rests , i.e. that their properties are independent of the host galaxy ( also section 7 ) . for each color we built a pl relation with all the cepheids ( upper plot ) and one in which we used only the cepheids with a well defined light curve and a uniform phase coverage ( referred to as `` selected '' from here on ) .
this last selection allows us to include only those cepheids with the most reliable light curve parameters as period , minimum , and mean magnitude . in this paper , for consistency with cpb , we adopt a true distance modulus to the lmc of 18.50 mag ( van den bergh , 1996 ) mag . ] and a mean total extinction to the lmc cepheids @xmath2 mag ( discussion in cpb ) .
note that bessel ( 1991 ) obtained a foreground reddening of the lmc which ranges from 0.04 to 0.09 mag , while the mean internal reddening is 0.06 mag , though in some regions it reaches values as high as 0.3 mag . in this picture , it is very difficult to estimate the mean total reddening of the sample of the lmc cepheids .
as it will be discussed below , the adopted reddening for the lmc has no effect on the determination of the relative ( to the lmc ) and absolute distance modulus of ngc 3109 : it only affects the estimate of the total average reddening of its cepheids . in order to calculate the apparent distance moduli relative to the lmc in all four bands
, we obtained the best fit ( least squares method ) for the pl relation of the lmc and then we calculated the best match of the pl relation of ngc 3109 imposing the same slope of the pl relation of the lmc . for an additional internal check of our results
, we repeated these calculations using different approaches .
first , we considered the two different samples of cepheids in ngc 3109 defined above .
moreover , while the pl relation for the lmc was fitted with a straight line over the range of periods @xmath52 are excluded from the least - squares fit since both the evolutionary status and the reddening of these longer period cepheids are controversial .
] , the two samples of ngc 3109 cepheids were fitted both in the entire range of periods and in the range @xmath53 in order to minimize the effects of the faint end selection bias in the small number data set of the more distant galaxy ngc 3109 .
the resulting relative distance moduli are all consistent within the errors .
thus we adopted the relative distance moduli obtained with the cepheids of the selected sample of ngc 3109 without any constraint on @xmath54 . in this way
we make use of the same range of periods for both the lmc and ngc 3109 , but we exclude those cepheids with inaccurate parameters which might affect the reliability of the fit ( almost all of them are in the fainter part of the pl relation ) .
the resulting apparent distance moduli relative to the lmc ( @xmath55 ) are reported in the table [ table6 ] . the total error on these apparent distance moduli
is obtained adding in quadrature the error of the fit and the mean internal photometric error ( obtained for each band as a mean of the errors in table 2 up to magnitude 23.75 ) . in order to determine the true distance modulus ( tdm=@xmath56 ) to ngc 3109 , the total ( foreground plus internal ) extinction for the cepheids must be evaluated .
ccc b & 6.81 & 0.12v & 6.91 & 0.11r & 6.95 & 0.15 i & 7.01 & 0.15 taking advantage of the multicolor apparent distance moduli ( see table [ table6 ] ) and assuming that all of the wavelength dependence of these moduli is due to the extinction , it is possible to fit all the data simultaneously with an interstellar extinction law . in particular , we assume that the reddening law for the lmc and ngc 3109 is the same as in the galaxy , and use the law derived by cardelli et al .
( 1989 , c89 ) .
figure [ fig8 ] shows the relative distance moduli plotted as a function of the inverse wavelength characteristic of each band . as in f88
, the estimated errors were scaled as a function of the increasing wavelength to reflect the decreasing strip width .
the solid line is the weighted least square best fit of the adopted extinction law to the moduli .
following c89 , we have adopted @xmath57 , where @xmath58 is the extinction in magnitudes in the @xmath7 band . with this assumption , we obtained a reddening free relative distance modulus ( rdm ) @xmath59 and a relative reddening @xmath60 between the lmc and ngc 3109 .
this rdm corresponds to a tdm @xmath61 , adopting @xmath12 for the lmc .
a relative color excess @xmath62 would imply a negative total mean reddening ( tr ) @xmath63 for ngc 3109 , if we assume , as discussed above and in cpb , @xmath2 for the total reddening of the lmc cepheids .
a negative reddening @xmath64 has been obtained by freedman ( 1992 ) for ngc 300 .
of course , a negative reddening has no physical meaning , in terms of what we know about the interstellar medium .
first , we must note that in our case the uncertainty on the @xmath65 is of the order of 0.04 magnitudes ( see below ) , and therefore we can assume that the tr is compatible with zero . still , we would remain with the unlikely situation of a _
zero _ total extinction for the cepheids in ngc 3109
. there might be many explanations for such a result .
systematic calibration errors can play a role in the determination of the relative extinction , though we can exclude systematic errors larger than @xmath66 mag .
another interesting possibility is that the intrinsic color of the cepheids in ngc 3109 is systematically bluer than those in the fiducial sample of the lmc , therefore leading to an underestimation of their reddening .
however , we believe that the largest uncertainty is still on the adopted total reddening for the lmc . we have already discussed ( previous section ) the difficulties in estimating the mean internal and external extinction toward the lmc cepheids . according to bessel s ( 1991 ) results , the e(b - v)=0.08 mag for
the lmc that we have adopted in this series of papers might be too low .
the comparison between the lmc and ngc 3109 cepheids seems to confirm that an @xmath67 mag ( see also freedman et al . , 1991 ) or higher might be more appropriate . the total error on the tdm of ngc 3109 is the combination of 1 ) the error on the best fit of the extinction law of c89 , 2 ) the uncertainty on the absolute distance to the lmc , 3 ) the error on the photometric zero point , and 4 ) the error due to the assumption of @xmath68 .
the lmc best distance determination are based on the cepheids ( _ cf . _
the compilation of feast & walker , 1987 ) , and the associated uncertainty is @xmath69 mag ; smaller errors seem too optimistic ( see van den bergh 1996 ) .
this is still the dominant source of errors .
the uncertainty on the zero point calibration is @xmath70 mag ( a mean of the errors estimated in sect .
2 ) . finally
, c89 have shown that @xmath71 can range from 2.75 to 5.3 within the galaxy .
adopting this range in @xmath71 for ngc 3109 , the reddening value and the relative distance modulus would be in the interval @xmath72 and @xmath73 , respectively .
in other words , a plausible error estimates for the distance modulus as a consequence of the extinction law uncertainties is @xmath74 mag . in summary
, we have that the true distance modulus of ngc 3109 is @xmath75 mag and the total reddening is @xmath76 mag . in the previous sections we have used the information from several photometric bands and the fit of an interstellar extinction law to the data in order to make an extrapolation to infinitely long wavelengths and estimate the total extinction and the true distance modulus .
however , even without solving explicitly for the reddening , it is still possible to obtain an estimate of the distance modulus which is independent of reddening .
this can be done by defining the reddening - free magnitude @xmath77 ( freedman et al . , 1992 ) .
figure [ fig9 ] displays the @xmath78 relation for ngc 3109 ( selected sample ) and for the lmc . from this relation
we obtain a true relative distance modulus @xmath79 which is consistent with the true relative modulus obtained in the previous section .
the disadvantage of this reddening free method is that the uncertainties on the @xmath80 magnitudes are larger than the single errors on the original @xmath6 and @xmath7 magnitudes , as @xmath80 results from a combination of the two .
for this reason we obtain an error on the true relative modulus which is one order of magnitude larger than that on the modulus obtained by the multiwavelength method .
moreover , @xmath80 depends on two of the four available colors only , making the distance based on it statistically less accurate . for this reason
we have constructed a new parameter @xmath81 analog to the @xmath80 , but depending on @xmath14 and @xmath9 .
the two reddening free parameters ( @xmath80 from @xmath6 and @xmath7 and @xmath81 from @xmath14 and @xmath9 ) are statistically uncorrelated and could be used as a further , independent estimate of the distance modulus .
@xmath81 was derived generalizing the definition of @xmath80 , and applying it to the @xmath14 and @xmath9 bands . in fact
, we can substitute the parameter @xmath71 by @xmath82 , and then define the new parameter @xmath83 .
@xmath84 can be easily derived by the c89 law .
figure [ fig10 ] displays the @xmath85 relation for ngc 3109 ( selected sample ) and for the lmc . from this relation
we obtain a true relative distance modulus @xmath86 which is in a very good agree with that obtained from the @xmath78 relation .
this result is a proof of the utility and reliability of this method .
the use of both @xmath80 and @xmath81 can be used as a test of self consistency , and a way of assessing external errors .
in the figs . [ fig11 ] , [ fig12 ] , and [ fig13 ] , we compare the period - color relations ( @xmath87 ) for the lmc and ngc 3109 for the three colors @xmath88 , @xmath89 and @xmath90 ; for ngc 3109 the selected sample has been used ( the errors for the colors @xmath89 and @xmath90 are larger because we use the maximum expected value and represent an upper limit , see sect . 4 for details ) .
in each figure , the data in the _ upper panel _ are without reddening correction and those in the _ lower panel _ are corrected according to the reddening effects .
[ fig14 ] shows the same three absorption - corrected pc relations for the lmc , ngc 3109 , sextans a ( pcp ) , sextans b ( pcp ) , and ic 1613 ( f88 ) . the slopes of these pc relations are the same , within the uncertainties .
the data of ngc 3109 , sextans a , sextans b , and ic 1613 have a larger scatter than for the lmc , consistent with the lower accuracy in the determination of the mean magnitudes . in order to obtain the zero point difference between the pc relations for the lmc and the other galaxies ,
the lmc pc relations were fitted with a straight line over the range of periods @xmath91 , and a linear fit of the pc relations was performed for the other galaxies imposing the same slope of the lmc . in this way
we could calculate the mean color difference between the cepheids in the lmc and in the other four galaxies .
figure [ fig15 ] shows that the mean color difference after the reddening corrections is consistent with zero .
this result shows that , if we suppose that the colors of the cepheids are independent of the parent galaxy , the law by c89 allows to calculate relative reddenings in a consistent way . with the data set presented in this paper
, we can check whether the cepheids in ngc 3109 have the same average colors as in the lmc .
figure [ fig16 ] displays the reddening
free parameter @xmath92(v - i)$ ] as a function of @xmath93 for both the selected sample of cepheids in ngc 3109 ( _ filled circles _ ) and in the lmc ( _ crosses _ ) ( see freedman , 1992 ) .
the slopes of the two distributions are the same as well as the zero point .
the larger scatter for the ngc 3109 cepheids is consistent with the larger photometric errors .
the similarity of these two distributions suggest that the colors of the cepheids in these galaxies are the same . finally , in fig .
[ fig17 ] we compare the amplitude of the @xmath6 light curves of the cepheids in ngc 3109 and in the lmc .
also in this case we obtain that the trend and the dispersion of the points for the two populations of cepheids are similar , suggesting similar properties .
in conclusion , an extended pl relation and the multicolor photometry provide a new , more accurate , de - reddened distance of ngc 3109 relative to the lmc . adopting @xmath12 for the lmc
, we obtain a true distance modulus @xmath94 for ngc 3109 ; if we assume a reddening e(b - v)=0.08 for the lmc , the total reddening of the cepheids in ngc 3109 is @xmath95 .
the new reddening free distance modulus corresponds to @xmath1 mpc .
this new distance is consistent , within the errors , with the value @xmath96 given by cpb , though , formally , now ngc 3109 is placed @xmath97 further away . it is instructive to inspect the origin of this difference . in cpb
we had only b and v - band data .
it was difficult to apply the multiwavelength method to this data set , in view of the closeness of the two bands and of the poor coverage in the v band .
for this reason , cpb preferred to adopt a mean reddening e(b - v)=0.04 for ngc 3109 and estimate the true distance modulus with this assumption in mind .
the reddening estimate ( from burstein & heiles , 1992 ) contour maps was admittedly poor ( as noted also by bpc ) .
the difference between the reddening adopted by cpb and the present direct estimate of the mean reddening toward ngc 3109 completely explains the difference in the final absolute modulus . as further evidence
, we can refer to the exercise presented by piotto et al .
( 1995 ) , where we used the two b and v apparent relative distance moduli of ngc 3109 for a rough estimate of the true relative distance moduli with the multiwavelength method applied also in the present paper . even with a poorer data set piotto et al .
( 1995 , cf .
their fig .
2 ) obtained a true relative distance modulus @xmath98 , much closer to the present estimate .
this discussion shows by itself the importance of extending the cepheid light curves to the largest possible wavelength interval .
for this reason , we are observing these same cepheids of ngc 3109 in the jhk bands .
we expect to reduce the error in the distance and reddening estimate . for the importance of the jhk observations of cepheids ,
see madore and freedman ( 1991 ) finally , we want to briefly comment on the similarity of _
( i ) _ the slopes of the cepheid pl and pc relations , _ ( ii ) _ the average color , and _ ( iii ) _ of the properties of the amplitude - period relations which result from a direct comparison of the data from five galaxies ( cf .
discussion in section 5.1 , and 6 ) .
this is consistent with the fundamental assumption on which the entire extragalactic distance scale stands .
however , we must also point out the large uncertainties still present in the determination of all the above parameters ( also the discussion in section 5.2 ) , in part as a consequence of the nature of this kind of research , which requires a huge amount of telescope time .
it is clear that the dispersion ( intrinsic and as a consequence of the observational uncertainties ) of the relations presented in figs .
4 - 7 , and in figs .
11 - 17 are too large for a firm conclusion on the universality of the cepheid properties .
a lot of work on the theoretical and observational side is still needed .
in particular , we must take advantage of the recent improvement in the near - ir detectors , where the pl and plc relations are much narrower .
we wish to thank wendy freedman for providing us with her lmc cepheid data set in a computer readable form and barry madore for the useful comments .
+ the authors acknowledge the support by the agenzia spaziale italiana .
i m acknowledges the partial support of the istituto italiano per gli studi filosofici , napoli . | we extended to the r and i bands the light curve coverage for 8 cepheids already studied in b and v by capaccioli [ aj , 103 , 1151 ( 1992 ) ] .
sixteen additional cepheid candidates have been identified and preliminary periods are proposed .
the new cepheids allow the period - luminosity relation to be extended one magnitude fainter .
apparent b , v , r , and i distance moduli have been calculated . combining the data at different wavelengths , and assuming a true distance modulus of 18.50 mag for the lmc
, we obtain for ngc 3109 a true distance modulus @xmath0 , corresponding to @xmath1 mpc . adopting @xmath2 for the lmc ,
the interstellar reddening for the cepheids in ngc 3109 is consistent with 0 .
a discussion on the possible implications of this result is presented .
a comparison of the period - color , period - amplitude , and period - luminosity relations suggests similar properties for the cepheids in the lmc , ngc 3109 , sextans a , sextans b , and ic 1613 , though the uncertainties in the main parameter determination are still unsatisfactorily high for a firm conclusion on the universality of the period - luminosity relation .
= 9.0 in |
both optical studies of sky - projected cluster galaxy distributions ( e.g. baier 1979 ; geller & beers 1982 ) and studies of cluster x - ray morphologies ( e.g. mohr , fabricant & geller 1993 ; buote & tsai 1996 ) reveal the presence of significant substructure in clusters of galaxies .
subgroup velocity statistics ( e.g. dressler & shectman 1988 ; bird 1994 ; girardi et al . 1997 ; solanes , salvador - sol & gonzlez - casado 1999 ) confirm these results , and are in substantial agreement in showing that some 3040% of clusters have statistically significant substructure . numerical simulations also show that subclustering is a typical property of cluster formation in hierarchical theories of structure formation .
such subclustering is expected for a broad range of cosmologies , and its predicted extent is in agreement with that observed ( e.g. knebe & mller 2000 ) .
its prevalance indicates that clusters are young objects , since such substructure is expected to be smoothed out over a few cluster crossing times .
moreover the existing substructure indicates that recent major mergers have occurred in many clusters .
the evolution of cluster substructure is potentially of great importance for its influence on the star formation histories and morphological evolution of cluster galaxies ( e.g tully & shaya 1984 ; lavery & henry 1988 ; gnedin 1999 ; bekki 1999 ) .
however , until very recently this potential influence has largely been neglected ( cf .
bekki 1999 ) . of particular interest , is its relevance to the evolution of disk galaxies in clusters .
as is well known , butcher & oemler ( 1978 ) found that the cores of intermediate redshift clusters contain a higher fraction of blue , star - forming galaxies than similar environments at the present .
these galaxies have been shown to be normal spiral or irregular galaxies , a fraction of which are obviously interacting or disturbed ( e.g. dressler et al .
1994 ; oemler , dressler & butcher 1997 ; smail et al .
1997 ) . in rich clusters
they constitute up to 50% of the population , but by the present epoch have been depleted by a factor of two and replaced by a corresponding increase in s0s ( e.g. dressler et al .
wang & ulmer ( 1997 ) have found a correlation between the fraction of blue galaxies in intermediate redshift clusters and the cluster x - ray ellipticities .
they interpret the latter as an age sequence , and conclude that the younger clusters have a higher fraction of blue , star - forming galaxies . as the authors note , this interpretation is in accord with a hierarchical clustering scenario , in which a typical distant cluster is assembled from smaller units which tend to contain more gas - rich , late type galaxies .
the relative depletion of such star - forming galaxies in older , more relaxed clusters , suggests that the process of sub - cluster merging plays a crucial role in the transformation of an initial population of cluster spirals to a subsequent s0 population .
what effect is the sub - cluster merging process likely to have on a population of gas - rich , star - forming disk galaxies ?
bekki ( 1999 ) using numerical simulation of a merger between a small group of galaxies and a cluster , shows that the time - dependent tidal gravitational field of the merger gives strong nonaxisymmetric perturbations to the disk galaxies in the group , inducing simultaneous moderate secondary starbursts in the central regions of the galaxies .
similarly , gnedin ( 1999 ) using self - consistent cluster simulations , demonstrates that for substantial infall of additional material into a cluster , the time - varying gravitational potential causes a sequence of tidal shocks on individual galaxies over a wide area of the cluster .
these shocks enhance galaxy galaxy interactions as well as amplifying galaxy merger rates . again the effect is also likely to induce simultaneous starbursts in gas - rich infalling disk galaxies over a wide area of the cluster . moreover ,
the tidal shocks are shown to typically thicken the disks of large spirals by a factor of two , making it unlikely that spiral structure and gaseous shocks in the inner regions of the galaxies will form .
a significant amount of the dark matter halo is stripped , possibly removing the resevoir of fresh gas which maintains the star formation activity ( cf .
larson , tinsley & caldwell 1980 ) . while gas in the outer regions of the disk can be stripped by the ram pressure of the ambient medium , interpenetrating collisions with neighbouring galaxies
could remove all their gas .
the effect of all these tidal transformations is the conversion of spirals to s0s .
the theoretical considerations discussed above suggest that ( moderate ) tidally - induced starbursts should be widespread in cluster gas - rich disk galaxies in clusters which show evidence of on - going or recent merger activity .
together with enhanced starburst activity , enhanced galaxy galaxy interactions and mergers are also expected .
in fact , there is considerable observational evidence to support this scenario , both from studies of early - type and late - type galaxies in nearby clusters , and from evidence of poststarburst galaxies in intermediate redshift clusters .
this evidence is now briefly reviewed .
caldwell et al .
( 1993 ) have surveyed early - type galaxies in the coma cluster and found an unusually high number with spectra that reflect recent enhanced star formation activity in a substructure of the cluster .
as noted by bekki ( 1999 ) , this may readily be explained as due principally to tidal gravitational effects of a group - cluster merger with rather large relative velocity .
caldwell & rose ( 1997 ) also found a larger fraction of poststarburst galaxies in nearby clusters with obvious double structure . in a similar fashion ,
bekki notes that these results can also be explained by the tidal effects of cluster mergers .
moss & whittle ( 2000 ) have undertaken an h@xmath0 survey of a magnitude - limited complete sample of 320 galaxies of types sa and later within 1.5@xmath1 mpc of the centres of 8 nearby abell clusters .
some 116 of the sample were detected in emission .
a subset of the emission - line galaxies are found to have tidally - induced circumnuclear starburst emission , as evidenced from the particular h@xmath0 morphology , and its strong correlation with a disturbed galaxy morphology .
starburst emission is found to be most prevalent in the richest clusters in the survey .
the percentage of the total sample of late - type galaxies with starburst emission is @xmath2 40% for the two richest clusters , coma and abell 1367 .
in contrast , the corresponding percentage for field galaxies in the sample is only a few percent .
moreover x - ray morphologies and temperature structures for coma and abell 1367 indicate that both these clusters are recent post - merger systems ( cf . donnelly et al . 1998 ; honda et al . 1996 ) . again
, a plausible explanation for the enhanced starburst activity seen in the clusters , is tidal effects of subcluster merging .
moss & whittle also identify a class of late - type galaxies in their sample which are likely to be on - going mergers , in which the companion is indistinguishable from its merger partner .
these on - going mergers are most prevalent in the coma cluster .
they are likely to represent a later stage of close double , interacting systems with tidally induced emission which comprise a significant fraction ( @xmath2 14% ) of the galaxies they detect with starburst emission . for intermediate redshift clusters , there is also evidence of an enhancement of starburst emission .
galaxies with spectra showing strong balmer lines in absorption , indicative of a poststarburst phase , are an order of magnitude more frequent in the cluster environment as compared to the high redshift field ( e.g. dressler et al .
1999 ; poggianti et al .
1999 ) . a surprising fraction of the star - forming galaxies at intermediate redshift show signs of morphological disturbance , of which many are suggestive of merging systems , virtually always involving a disk galaxy ( cf .
ellis 1999 ) .
this suggests a tidal origin for the starburst phase , although no clear difference in the incidence of disturbed morphology between the high redshift field and cluster environments has been established ( cf .
dressler et al . 1999 ) .
strong theoretical and observational data suggest that sub - cluster merging plays a crucial role in the transformation of spirals to s0s in the process of cluster formation , due to the strong tidal forces on the disk galaxy members of an accreting sub - group .
theoretical studies predict simultaneous moderate starbursts in disk galaxies of the accreting sub - group due to tidal forces .
this prediction is supported by observational data for both nearby and intermediate redshift clusters .
tidal shocks due to the time - varying potential associated with sub - cluster merging are expected to effect morphological transformation of star - forming disk galaxies to s0s .
thus these can explain the transformation of the majority of the spiral population in younger , less relaxed clusters to a population of s0s in older , more relaxed clusters as an integral part of the process of cluster formation .
baier , f. 1979 , astron .
, 300 , 85 bekki , k. 1999 , , 510 , l15 bird , c.m .
1994 , , 107 , 1637 buote , d.a . & tsai , j.c .
1996 , , 458 , 27 butcher , h. & oemler , a. 1978 , , 219 , 18 caldwell , n. & rose , j. 1997 , , 113 , 492 caldwell , n. , rose , j. , sharples , r.m , ellis , r.s . & bower , r.g .
1993 , , 106 , 473 donnelly , r.h .
1998 , , 500 , 138 dressler , a. & shectman , s.a .
1988 , , 95 , 985 dressler , a. , oemler , a. , butcher , h.r . & gunn , j.e .
1994 , , 430 , 107 dressler , a. et al .
1997 , , 490 , 577 dressler , a. et al .
1999 , , 122 , 51 ellis , r.s .
1999 , in iau symp .
183 , the formation and evolution of galaxies , ed .
k. sato , ( dordrecht : boston ) , 107 geller , m.j . , & beers , t.c .
1982 , , 94 , 421 girardi , m. et al .
1997 , , 482 , 41 honda , h. et al .
1996 , , 473 , l71 gnedin , o.y .
1999 , ph.d .
thesis , princeton univ .
knebe , a. & mller , v. 2000 , 354 , 761 larson , r.b . ,
tinsley , b.m . & caldwell , c.n .
1980 , , 237 , 692 lavery , r.j . & henry , j.p .
1988 , , 330 , 596 mohr , j.j . ,
fabricant , d.g . & geller , m.j .
1993 , , 413 , 492 moss , c. , & whittle , m. 2000 , , 317 , 667 oemler , a. , dressler , a. & butcher , h.r .
1997 , , 474 , 561 poggianti et al .
1999 , , 518 , 576 smail , i. , dressler , a. , couch , w.j . ,
ellis , r.s . , oemler , a. , butcher h. & sharples , r.m .
1997 , , 110 , 213 solanes , j.m .
, salvador - sol , e. & gonzlez - casado , g. 1999 , , 343 , 733 tully , r.b . & shaya , e.j .
1984 , , 281 , 31 wang , q.d . &
ulmer , m.p .
1997 , , 292 , 920 | optical and x - ray studies have established the prevalence of significant substructure in clusters of galaxies , indicating that clusters are young systems , and that recent major mergers have occurred in many clusters .
numerical simulations show that sub - cluster merging will result in significant tidal forces on disk galaxies in accreting sub - groups , which is likely to lead to the transformation of spirals to s0s in clusters .
simulations predict simultaneous moderate starbursts in gas - rich disk galaxies in clusters which show on - going or recent merger activity , as well as enhanced galaxy galaxy interactions and mergers .
observational data from studies of spectral indicators , both of starburst activity in late - type galaxies in nearby clusters , and of poststarburst activity in early - type galaxies in nearby and intermediate redshift clusters , support this scenario . |
the ability to manipulate liquids on microfluidic chips is essential to the functionality of micro total analysis systems @xcite and recently there has been quite some interest in utilizing ac electrical surface potentials for pumping , manipulating , and mixing electrolytes . for an overview of electro - hydrodynamics and ac electro - osmosis we refer to refs . and references therein .
in this paper we consider the rc model in ref . of an electrolyte confined by an insulating surface with an applied external potential of the general form @xmath7 here , @xmath8 is the driving frequency and @xmath9 is a dimensionless function representing the amplitude variations along the surface . for simplicity
we consider a binary electrolyte with permeability @xmath10 , viscosity @xmath11 , and conductivity @xmath12 . assuming a low pclet number we may neglect convection so that the electrodynamics can formally be solved independently of the hydrodynamics . on the other hand the hydrodynamics of course still depends on the electrodynamics through the body force which effectively may be taken into account through a finite slip velocity , see e.g. refs . and references therein .
for the electrodynamics we follow ajdari @xcite with the surface and the debye layer each represented by a capacitive element while the bulk - liquid is represented by an ohmic element .
the model applies to the situation where spatial variations along the surface are slow on the length scale of the debye screening length @xmath13 , the driving frequency is small compared to the debye frequency @xmath14 , and the electrostatic energy is small compared to the thermal energy @xmath15 , i.e. the debye
hckel approximation is valid .
as shown by many , the model may be justified in detail starting from a non - equilibrium electro - hydrodynamic continuum description . for more details
we refer to refs . as well as and references therein . in the bulk of the liquid
there is charge neutrality and the electrical potential @xmath16 thus fulfills the laplace equation @xmath17 subject to the relation between surface charge @xmath18 and the potential drop across the capacitive element @xmath19 as well as a continuity equation @xmath20 relating the change in surface charge to the electrical ohmic current @xmath21 . above
, @xmath22 is a series capacitance with @xmath23 being the intrinsic surface capacitance and @xmath24 being the debye layer capacitance .
we formally solve this problem by introducing the inverse fourier transform @xmath25 of @xmath9 , see eq .
( [ eq : vext ] ) , @xmath26 from the solution of the spatially harmonic problem @xcite we may write the general solutions for the potential and the surface charge as @xmath27 and @xmath28 above , we have introduced the frequency dependent effective length scale @xmath29 given by @xmath30 where @xmath31 is the capacitance ratio and @xmath32 is the debye frequency .
the slip velocity is given by @xcite @xmath33_{x=0},\ ] ] where it is implicit that real values of @xmath18 and @xmath16 must be taken . from eqs .
( [ eq : phi ] ) and ( [ eq : sigmad ] ) we now formally get @xmath34 and for the time - averaged slip - velocity @xmath35 we use that @xmath36 as well as @xmath37 so that @xmath38 eqs .
( [ eq : vs ] ) and ( [ eq : vs_t ] ) are our general results for the surface - potential induced hydrodynamics .
velocity and pressure fields may be obtained by solving the navier stokes equation without body - forces subject to a slip - velocity condition . before turning our attention to specific potentials
we may already extract some general properties of the model . from eq .
( [ eq : vs_t ] ) it is clear that @xmath39 is a spatially dependent function of finite magnitude .
this in turn also means that the external potential can induce a finite time - averaged velocity field in the fluid .
however , it is also clear that the induced net flow rate will be zero since @xmath39 has no spatial dc - component , as may be seen by substituting the general expression for @xmath25 .
spatial asymmetry in the applied potential is thus not a sufficient condition to achieve pumping and as also indicated in ref .
, asymmetry in the surface capacitance is required .
formal studies of the model for @xmath40 will be an interesting subject for future studies , but here we will follow the lines were @xmath23 is constant along the surface . the case of @xmath41
was first studied in ref . .
the fourier transform is then a simple sum of two dirac delta functions , @xmath42 , and substituting into eqs .
( [ eq : vs ] ) or ( [ eq : vs_t ] ) we easily arrive at results fully consistent with those reported previously .
in order to draw some general conclusions about the frequency dynamics of the hydrodynamics , apart from the frequency doubling @xcite , we imagine that the surface potential has a characteristic length scale @xmath43 . since we have made an rc description of the electro - hydrodynamics it follows quite naturally that the system will have a resonance behavior at a frequency comparable to the inverse rc time of the system . above resonance
the system has an asymptotic power - law frequency response as we will illustrate below for a surface potential of even symmetry . in that case @xmath25
is a real and even function of @xmath44 , so that eq .
( [ eq : vs_t ] ) with @xmath45 becomes @xmath46 where we have introduced a characteristic resonance frequency @xmath47 as well as a characteristic flow velocity @xmath48 , @xmath49 since @xmath50[\omega^2+(s')^2]}\\&=(s - s ' ) \omega^{-2}+{\cal o}\left(\omega^{-4}\right)\end{aligned}\ ] ] we expect with @xmath51 that @xmath52 likewise , for surface potentials of odd symmetry we arrive at the same conclusion . making a similar expansion for
the below - resonance asymptote one might speculate that @xmath53 with a power @xmath54 .
however , with such an expansion the integrals are in general no longer convergent which in turn indicates that the power @xmath2 is below 2 depending on the actual surface potential under consideration . in the following
we will illustrate this by the aid of two explicit examples .
recently , a circulating flow was observed experimentally using two adjacent electrodes and an ac field @xcite and in ref .
@xcite the problem was studied theoretically by assuming that the two electrodes are infinitely close corresponding to a step - like model potential .
however , such a potential is somewhat unphysical since the electric field diverges and instead one should take the electrode gap into account @xcite . in the following we model such an electrode configuration with a smooth external potential of the form @xmath55 which incorporates the built - in electrode gap in terms of the length scale @xmath43 .
fourier transforming and substituting into eq .
( [ eq : vs_t ] ) we get @xmath56 where the resonance frequency is given by @xmath57 . in order to study the maximal value of @xmath39 as a function of frequency we note
that when @xmath39 is maximal so is its slope at @xmath58 .
if we define @xmath59 we get @xmath60 where we have introduced @xmath61 .
panel ( a ) of fig .
[ fig1 ] shows the time - averaged slip velocity at resonance evaluated numerically from eq .
( [ eq : vs_t_tanh ] ) and its slope at @xmath58 , based on a numerical evaluation of eq .
( [ eq : gamma_tanh ] ) , is also included .
panel ( b ) shows @xmath62 as a function of frequency .
the plot confirms eq .
( [ eq : aboveresonance ] ) and suggests a linear dependence @xmath63 for the below - resonance frequency response .
this may also confirmed by an asymptotic analysis by first noting that @xmath64 .
for @xmath65 we note that @xmath66 ^ 2\simeq -4\omega/\pi \int_0^\infty ds\ , s/[\omega^2 + 4s^2]^2=-1/2\pi\omega$ ] so that @xmath67 . for @xmath68
we similarly note that @xmath69 so that @xmath70 . when collecting terms we thus get a @xmath8-dependence to lowest order . as a second example we consider single - electrode driven electro - hydrodynamics and as a model potential we use @xmath71 to mimic the potential of a single electrode with a characteristic width @xmath43 .
fourier transforming and substituting into eq .
( [ eq : vs_t ] ) we get @xmath72 where in this case @xmath73 is the resonance frequency . in analogy with the previous example we get @xmath74 panel ( c ) in fig .
[ fig1 ] shows the time - averaged slip velocity at resonance evaluated numerically from eq .
( [ eq : vs_t_sech ] ) and the slope at @xmath58 based on a numerical evaluation of eq .
( [ eq : gamma_sech ] ) is also included .
panel ( d ) shows the frequency response confirming eq .
( [ eq : aboveresonance ] ) for the above - resonance response while for the below - resonance response @xmath75 with a power @xmath76 . for the asymptotic analysis
we note that @xmath77 and @xmath78 where @xmath79 is catalan s constant . for @xmath80
it follows that @xmath81 ^ 2 \simeq -2\omega \int_0^\infty ds\ , s/[\omega^2 + s^2]^2= - \omega^{-1}$ ] so that @xmath82 .
there will thus be a logarithmic correction @xmath83 to the @xmath84 dependence .
in this work we have used a fourier transform approach to make a general analysis of the frequency dynamics of ac - induced electro - hydrodynamics within the rc model of ref . .
in the case with a spatially constant intrinsic surface capacitance we generally prove that the net flow rate is zero .
a finite net flow rate will require a spatially inhomogeneous capacitance so that the charge and electrical field dynamics are mutually out of phase . for the frequency dynamics
we observe a resonance behavior at a frequency corresponding to the inverse rc time of the system and different surface potentials share the common feature that the resonance frequency is inversely proportional to the characteristic length scale of the surface potential . above resonance
we in general find a @xmath0 power law for surface potentials with either even or odd symmetry .
below resonance we likewise find a power - law dependence @xmath1 with @xmath2 being positive and dependent of the properties of the surface potential . as two examples
we have compared @xmath3 ( odd symmetry ) and @xmath4 ( even symmetry ) surface potential .
unexpectedly , we qualitatively find the same slip velocity , while the frequency dynamics is very different for the below - resonance frequency response where power law asymptotics with @xmath5 and @xmath76 , respectively , are found .
our study illustrates how the frequency dynamics carries strong fingerprints of the driving surface potential and we believe that detailed analysis of the frequency dynamics would be a way to extract more information from experimental data .
recent related work @xcite also suggests the possibility for a strong frequency dependence in ac electroosmosis also in the flow topology .
we thank l. h. olesen for stimulating discussions .
k. s. is supported by c : o : n : t and teknologisk institut .
n. a. m. is supported by the danish technical research council ( grant no .
26 - 03 - 0073 ) . | using a fourier approach we offer a general solution to calculations of slip velocity within the circuit description of the electro - hydrodynamics in a binary electrolyte confined by a plane surface with a modulated surface potential .
we consider the case with a spatially constant intrinsic surface capacitance where the net flow rate is in general zero while harmonic rolls as well as time - averaged vortex - like components may exist depending on the spatial symmetry and extension of the surface potential .
in general the system displays a resonance behavior at a frequency corresponding to the inverse rc time of the system .
different surface potentials share the common feature that the resonance frequency is inversely proportional to the characteristic length scale of the surface potential . for the asymptotic frequency dependence above resonance
we find a @xmath0 power law for surface potentials with either an even or an odd symmetry .
below resonance we also find a power law @xmath1 with @xmath2 being positive and dependent of the properties of the surface potential . comparing a @xmath3 potential and a @xmath4 potential we qualitatively find the same slip velocity , but for the below - resonance frequency response the two potentials display different power law asymptotics with @xmath5 and @xmath6 , respectively . |
asymptotic giant branch ( agb ) stars dominate the return of processed materials to the interstellar medium ( ism ) and therefore are an important component of galaxy evolution .
high mass - loss rate objects are heavily obscured , so they can be missed in optical surveys and need to be observed in the infrared ( ir ) .
we have conducted a study using the _ spitzer space telescope _ infrared spectrograph ( irs ;
@xcite ) of a sample of luminous 8 @xmath0 m sources in the large magellanic cloud ( lmc ) .
our sample was selected from a compilation of _
2mass / msx _ sources @xcite , using near - infrared color and magnitude criteria to target high mass - loss , evolved objects .
irs low - resolution spectra of 62 targets were obtained in cycle 1 .
an atlas of the spectra has been presented in @xcite .
the spectra reveal continuum and spectral features that allow the dominant chemistry of the dust circumstellar envelope to be determined .
figure [ fig : egspec ] shows typical spectra of oxygen - rich ( o - rich ) , carbon - rich ( c - rich ) , and emission - line objects .
we find that almost all the o - rich stars are red supergiants ( rsgs ) with infrared luminosities l@xmath1 l@xmath2 ( figure [ fig : lumhist ] ) .
the lack of lower luminosity o - rich agb stars suggests that massive supergiants do not have long enough he - burning lifetimes to produce c - rich surfaces ( and hence c - rich ejecta ) , despite the low metallicity of the lmc .
the c - rich stars are all agb stars with l@xmath3 l@xmath2 . the large number of c - rich agb stars stands in stark contrast to the lack of o - rich agb stars found .
this result is consistent with the hypothesis that c - rich stars form more easily than o - rich ones due to the low metallicity environment of the lmc .
we find that the emission - line objects are all hii regions with l@xmath4 l@xmath2 .
these objects were all expected to be planetary nebulae ( pne ) based on _
2mass / msx _ colors @xcite , but optical and ir images reveal diffuse nebulae around the objects , and the irs spectra show a jump in flux density between the short - low ( 5.2 14 @xmath0 m , slit width 3.6@xmath5 ) and long - low ( 14.0 38 @xmath0 m , slit width 10.5@xmath5 ) modules indicating the emission is extended on parsec scales .
the spectra also show a lack of high - ionization narrow emission lines common in pne ( e.g. , @xcite ) .
photometric tools such as color - color diagrams are invaluable for identifying and classifying stellar objects . however , photometric diagnostics must first be reliably associated with spectral properties using spectroscopy .
we used our irs spectra to revise the _
2mass / msx _ classification criteria of @xcite . in figure
[ fig : nircols ] we present _
2mass / msx _ color - color diagrams showing our improved photometric classification criteria .
one of the primary goals of our _ spitzer _ program was to provide a spectroscopic basis for irac and mips photometric classifications of ir sources in external galaxies . to that end , we derived synthetic irac and mips magnitudes using the irs spectra and the imaging filter spectral response functions .
figure [ fig : sstcols ] shows the resulting color - color diagrams and diagnostics for identifying spectroscopic classes .
we have obtained low - resolution irs spectra of a sample of 60 luminous 8 @xmath0 m sources in the lmc and classified the sources according to their spectral properties .
almost all of the agb stars in the sample are c - rich , while the o - rich objects are luminous rsgs .
we use our spectroscopic classifications to develop revised infrared photometric diagnostics to classify luminous ir sources , thus correcting inaccuracies in current widely - used criteria .
we propose new photometric diagnostics to identify ir sources in other galaxies , based on synthetic _ spitzer _ photometry and existing _
2mass / msx _ photometry .
a full discussion of the data analysis and additional results will appear in @xcite .
thanks to the conference organizers for a great meeting .
this work is based on observations made with the _
spitzer space telescope _ , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology under a contract with nasa .
support for this work was provided by nasa through awards issued by jpl / caltech .
the irs was a collaborative venture between cornell university and ball aerospace corporation funded by nasa through the jet propulsion laboratory and ames research center .
bernard - salas , j. , houck , j. r. , morris , p. w. , sloan , g. c. , pottasch , s. r. , & barry , d. j. 2004 , , 154 , 271 buchanan , c. l. , kastner , j. k. , forrest , w. j. , hrivnak , b. j. , sahai , r. , egan , m. , frank , a. , & barnbaum , c. 2006 , , submitted egan , m. p. , van dyk , s. d. , & price , s. d. 2001 , , 122 , 1844 houck , j. r. , et al .
2004 , , 154 , 18 kastner , j. h. , buchanan , c. l. , sargent , b. , & forrest , w. j. 2006 , , 638 , l29 kraemer , k. e. , sloan , g. c. , price , s. d. , & walker , h. j. 2002 , , 140 , 389 | we have produced an atlas of spitzer infrared spectrograph ( irs ) spectra of mass - losing , evolved stars in the large magellanic cloud .
these stars were selected to have high mass - loss rates and so contribute significantly to the return of processed materials to the ism .
our high - quality spectra enable the determination of the chemistry of the circumstellar envelope from the mid - ir spectral features and continuum .
we have classified the spectral types of the stars and show that the spectral types separate clearly in infrared color - color diagrams constructed from 2mass data and synthetic irac / mips fluxes derived from our irs spectra .
we present diagnostics to identify and classify evolved stars in nearby galaxies with high confidence levels using spitzer and 2mass photometry .
comparison of the spectral classes determined using irs data with the ir types assigned based on nir colors also revealed a significant number of misclassifications and enabled us to refine the nir color criteria resulting in more accurate nir color classifications of dust - enshrouded objects . |
a quantum dot ( qd ) is a structure in which electrons can be confined to small length scales , comparable to their fermi wavelength . a set of electrons held in such a structure is conceptually similar to a set of atomic electrons bound to a nucleus , and for this reason quantum dots are sometimes termed `` artificial atoms '' @xcite .
unlike real atoms , the physical properties of quantum dots can be easily varied , which gives theorists and experimentalists the opportunity to study novel quantum effects in a well - controlled system . to extend the atomic analogy further , we can consider linking qds together to form `` artificial molecules '' . by allowing electrons to tunnel between the qds , the electronic states on the qds can hybridize , and form new states that extend over the whole system @xcite .
the degree of the tunneling determines the strength of this hybridization .
if the tunneling is weak the electrons remain essentially localised on the qds in analogy with ionic bonding states .
conversely , if the tunneling is strong then the electrons form delocalised states with a covalent character .
recent transport experiments using ac potentials @xcite have been performed on double qd systems , and have indeed revealed the ionic or covalent character of the electronic states by measurement of the induced photo - current . ever since the pioneering work of anderson @xcite , it has been known that random spatial disorder can cause electronic states to become localised in quantum systems .
more recently it has been found that an ac driving field can produce a similar intriguing effect termed _ dynamical localisation _ , in which the tunneling dynamics of a particle can be destroyed .
one of the first systems in which this effect was predicted is that of a particle moving in a double - well potential @xcite .
a physical realization of this could consist of two coupled qds containing a single electron the simplest type of artificial molecule possible .
if this system is prepared with the electron occupying one of the qds , we can expect it to tunnel across to the other qd on a time scale set by the rabi frequency .
however , if an ac field of the correct strength and frequency is applied to the system , the tunneling is destroyed , and the particle will remain trapped in the initial well .
weak time - dependent fields are generally treated as small perturbations , which produce transitions between the eigenstates of the unperturbed quantum system .
this approach , however , is not applicable to treat the strong driving fields required to produce dynamical localisation , and instead the technique of floquet analysis @xcite , which is valid in all regimes of driving , has proven to be extremely effective . in this approach , which we briefly outline in the next section , the important quantities to calculate are the _ quasi - energies _ , which play a similar role in driven systems to the eigenenergies in the undriven case .
in particular , dynamical localisation occurs when two quasi - energies of states participating in the dynamics approach each other , and become either degenerate ( a crossing ) or close to degenerate ( an avoided crossing ) . using this formalism ,
analytic and numerical studies of the double - well system have shown @xcite that in the limit of high frequencies , quasi - energy crossings occur when the ratio of the field strength to the frequency is a root of the bessel function @xmath0 . adding a second electron to the coupled qd system
, however , introduces considerable complications . at the low electron densities
typically present in qds , strong correlations produced by the coulomb interaction can significantly influence the electronic structure .
one of the most dramatic consequences of this is the formation of _ wigner molecule
_ states @xcite .
understanding the interplay between electron correlations and the driving field is , however , extremely desirable , as the ability to rapidly control electrons using ac fields @xcite has immediate applications to quantum metrology @xcite and quantum information processing .
in particular , manipulating entangled electrons on short timescales is of great importance to the field of quantum computation @xcite .
we study this problem here by applying the floquet formalism to systems of _ interacting _ particles .
the first system we consider is that of two interacting electrons confined to a pair of coupled qds .
a consequence of the interaction is that the system only responds strongly to the field when the field frequency is in resonance with the coulomb interaction energy .
when this condition is satisfied we find that , as for the single - particle case , coherent destruction of tunneling ( cdt ) can again occur , but that it governed by the roots of the higher - order bessel functions .
we then go on to consider a _ two - dimensional _ qd in the wigner regime , which may also be described by a lattice model of hubbard - type @xcite .
using the same approach we show that cdt can again occur when similar conditions are satisfied , and we clarify how an applied ac field can drive charge redistributions within a strongly correlated qd .
finally we summarize our results and give some brief conclusions .
we consider a general quantum system driven by a periodic electric field , described by a time - dependent hamiltonian which we can divide in the following way : @xmath1 here @xmath2 holds the tunneling terms , @xmath3 holds the electron - electron interaction terms and @xmath4 describes the interaction of the system with the @xmath5-periodic driving field .
the periodicity of the driving field allows us to use the floquet theorem to write solutions of the schrdinger equation as @xmath6 \phi_j(t)$ ] where @xmath7 is called the quasi - energy , and @xmath8 is a function with the same period as the driving field , called the floquet state .
this type of expression is familiar in the context of solid - state physics , where _ spatial
_ periodicity permits an analogous rewriting of the spatial wavefunction in terms of quasi - momenta and bloch states ( bloch s theorem ) .
the floquet states provide a complete basis , and thus the time - evolution of a general state may be written as : @xmath9 which is formally analogous to the standard expansion in the eigenvectors of a time - independent hamiltonian . indeed , in the adiabatic limit , @xmath10
, the quasi - energies evolve to the eigenenergies , and the floquet states to the eigenstates .
it is important to note that in this expansion both the basis vectors ( the floquet states ) and the expansion coefficients explicitly depend on time .
the nature of this time - dependence is very different however , and the superposition of the @xmath5-periodicity of the floquet states with the phase factors arising from the quasi - energies produces a highly complicated , quasi - periodic time - dependence in general . as the floquet states have the same period as the driving field , they are only able to produce structure in the time - dependence on short time - scales .
consequently , the dynamics of the system on time - scales much larger than @xmath5 is essentially determined by _ just _ the quasi - energies , and hence evaluating the quasi - energies provides a simple and direct way of investigating this behavior . in particular , when two quasi - energies approach degeneracy the time - scale for tunneling between the states diverges , producing the phenomenon of cdt . as we shall see for the specific quantum systems we consider , it is frequently the case that the total hamiltonian is invariant under the generalized parity operation : @xmath11 . as a result
the floquet states can also be classified into parity classes , depending whether they are odd or even under this parity operation .
quasi - energies belonging to different parity classes may cross as an external parameter ( such as the field strength ) is varied , but if they belong to the same class the von neumann - wigner @xcite theorem forbids this , and the closest approaches possible are avoided crossings . identifying the presence of crossings and avoided crossings in the quasi - energy spectrum
thus provides a necessary ( though not sufficient ) condition for cdt to occur . although the quasi - energies are extremely useful for interpretation of the time - dependence of a quantum system , they are usually difficult to calculate and numerical methods must be employed . when the driving field dominates the dynamics , however , it is possible to use a form of perturbation theory introduced by holthaus @xcite , in which the time - dependent part of the problem is solved exactly , and tunneling part of the hamiltonian , @xmath12 , acts as the perturbation .
this was generalized to treat interacting systems in refs.@xcite and was found to be very successful in the high - frequency regime , where @xmath13 is the dominant energy - scale .
we now give a brief outline of this method .
the floquet states and their quasi - energies may be conveniently obtained from the eigenvalue equation : @xmath14 where we consider the operator @xmath15 $ ] to operate in an _ extended _ hilbert space of @xmath5-periodic functions @xcite .
the procedure consists of dividing the hamiltonian as in eq.[divide ] , and finding the eigensystem of the operator @xmath16 $ ] , while regarding the tunneling hamiltonian @xmath2 as acting as a perturbation .
standard rayleigh - schrdinger perturbation theory can now be used to evaluate the order - by - order corrections to this result , requiring only that we define an appropriate inner product for the extended hilbert space : @xmath17 here @xmath18 denotes the usual scalar product for the spatial component of the wavevectors , and @xmath19 is the integration over the compact time coordinate .
we shall show in later sections how this method can be used to obtain analytical forms which accurately describe the behavior of the quasi - energies for the systems we study .
to study the time - evolution of each system , we used a fourth - order runge - kutta method to evolve a given initial state in time typically of the order of fifty periods of the driving field . throughout the time - evolution
, physical quantities such as the number occupation of a given site were measured , and it was ensured that the unitarity of the wavefunction was accurately preserved . a number of different methods can be used to numerically calculate the quasi - energies of a quantum system , and a detailed description of them is given in ref.@xcite .
one technique well - suited to our approach is to evaluate the unitary time - evolution operator for one period of the driving field @xmath20 , and then to diagonalize it .
it may be easily shown that the eigenvectors of this operator are equal to the floquet states , and its eigenvalues are related to the quasi - energies via @xmath21 $ ] .
this method is particularly convenient for our purposes , as @xmath22 can be obtained by propagating the unit matrix in time over one period of the field , using the same runge - kutta method described above .
we consider a simplified model of this system , in which each qd is replaced by a single site .
electrons are able to tunnel between the sites , and we include the effect of interactions by means of a hubbard-@xmath23 term : @xmath24 here @xmath25 is the hopping parameter , and for the remainder of this work we shall take @xmath26 equal to one , and measure all energies in units of @xmath25 .
@xmath27 is the external electric potential applied to site @xmath28 .
clearly only the potential difference , @xmath29 , is of physical importance , so we may choose to take the symmetric parametrization : @xmath30 the hilbert space of hamiltonian ( [ hubbard ] ) is six - dimensional , comprising three singlet states and a three dimensional triplet space .
measurements on semiconductor qds have shown that the spin - flip relaxation time is typically extremely long @xcite , and so we have chosen not to include any spin - flip terms in the hamiltonian .
consequently the singlet and triplet sectors are completely decoupled , and so if the initial state possesses a definite parity this will be retained throughout its time - evolution , and only states of the same parity need to be included in the basis . to study the time evolution of the system
, we used the ground state of the static hamiltonian ( a singlet ) as the initial state , and evolved it in time as described in section [ num ] .
three probability functions were measured throughout the time evolution : @xmath31 , @xmath32 and @xmath33 , which are respectively the probability that both electrons are in the left qd , both are in the right qd , and that one electron is in each of the qds .
the coulomb interaction favors separating the electrons , and thus for strong interactions the ground - state has a large value of @xmath34 , and relatively small values of @xmath35 and @xmath36 .
we show in fig.[two - site ] the time evolution of these quantities for @xmath37 and @xmath38 , at two different values of electric potential . in both cases
the detailed form of the time - evolution is highly complicated , but it is clear that the system behaves in two distinct ways . in fig.[two - site]a the value of @xmath34 periodically cycles between its initial high value ( indicating that each dot holds approximately one electron ) to nearly zero , while the values of @xmath35 and @xmath36 correspondingly rise and fall at its expense .
this behavior is very different to that shown in fig.[two - site]b , where @xmath34 never drops below a value of 0.78 , and the other two probabilities oscillate with a very small amplitude .
it thus appears that cdt is occurring in the second case , and that the system s time evolution is essentially frozen .
we shall term the minimum value of @xmath34 attained during the time - evolution @xmath39 , and use this to quantify whether cdt occurs , as a high value of @xmath39signifies that tunneling has been destroyed , while a low value indicates that the electrons are free to move between the qds . and @xmath40 .
( a ) electric potential , @xmath41 ; ( b ) @xmath42 .
thick solid line = @xmath33 , dotted line = @xmath31 , dashed line = @xmath32 . ] in fig.[interact]b we present a contour plot of @xmath39as a function of both of the frequency and strength of the ac field .
dark areas correspond to low values of @xmath39 , and it can be seen that they form horizontal bands , indicating that the system is excited strongly by the ac field only at `` resonant '' values of @xmath43 .
close examination of this plot reveals that these bands occur at frequencies @xmath44 , at which the system can absorb an integer number of photons to overcome the coulomb repulsion between electrons , thereby enabling tunneling processes such as latexmath:[$| \uparrow , \downarrow \rangle \ \rightarrow \ that these bands are punctuated by narrow zones in which cdt occurs
. their form can be seen more clearly in the cross - section of @xmath39given in fig.[quasi]a , which reveals them to be narrow peaks .
these peaks are approximately equally spaced along each resonance , the spacing increasing with @xmath43 . in fig.[interact]a
we show another contour plot of @xmath39 , this time obtained from a full simulation of detailed physical model of two interacting electrons confined to a pair of coupled gaas qds ( for more details on this simulation see ref.@xcite ) .
the striking similarity between these results clearly indicates that our simple , effective model ( [ hubbard ] ) indeed captures the essential processes occurring in the full system . as a function of the strength @xmath46 and energy @xmath13 of the ac field : ( a ) for a full simulation of a qd system ( @xmath13 in units of mev ) ( b ) for the two - site model with @xmath37 ( both axes in units of @xmath25 ) . ]
we emphasize that these results are radically different to those obtained for non - interacting particles . in this case
an analogous plot of delocalisation shows a fan - like structure @xcite , in which localisation occurs along lines given by @xmath47 , where @xmath48 is the @xmath49-th root of the bessel function @xmath50 . as a test of our method , we repeated our investigation with the inter - electron coulomb repulsion @xmath51 set to zero , and found that the fan structure was indeed reproduced . in fig.[quasi]a
we show the floquet quasi - energies as a function of the field strength for @xmath52 , one of the resonant frequencies visible in fig.[interact]b .
we see that the system possesses _ two _ distinct regimes of behavior , depending on whether the driving potential is weaker of stronger than @xmath51 . for weak fields @xmath53 ,
as studied previously in ref.@xcite , the floquet spectrum consists of one isolated state ( which evolves from the ground state ) and two states which make a set of exact crossings .
although in this regime @xmath39shows little structure , these crossings do in fact influence the system s dynamics . to demonstrate this , we show in fig.[transition ] the floquet quasi - energies in the weak - field regime for the case of @xmath54 , and plot beneath it the minimum value of @xmath35 attained during the time - evolution , where this time the state @xmath55 has been used as the initial state .
it can be seen that for this choice of initial condition , the crossings of the quasi - energies again produce cdt and freeze the initial state despite the coulomb repulsion between the electrons .
this surprising result may be understood as follows . for large values of @xmath51 ,
the singlet eigenstates of the undriven system consist of the ground state , separated by the hubbard gap @xmath51 from two almost degenerate excited states . for small values of the driving potential ,
the two excited states remain isolated from the ground state , and constitute an effective two - level system with a level - splitting of @xmath56 .
thus if the system is prepared in an initial state which projects mainly onto the excited states , its dynamics will be governed by the two - level approximation @xcite , and cdt will occur at the roots of @xmath0 .
we show in fig.[transition]a the quasi - energies obtained from the two - level approximation , which give excellent agreement with the actual results with _ no _ adjustable parameters . as @xmath46 becomes comparable to the hubbard gap , however , the two excited states are no longer isolated from the ground state , and all three levels must be taken into account .
this can be seen in the progressive deviation of the quasi - energies from the two - level approximation as the electric potential approaches @xmath51 . when the electric potential exceeds @xmath51 , the system displays a very different behavior , in which @xmath39remains close to zero except at a series of narrow peaks , corresponding to the close approaches of two of the quasi - energies .
a detailed examination of these approaches ( see fig.[quasi]b ) reveals them to be _ avoided crossings _ between the floquet states which evolve from the ground state and the higher excited state , and have the same generalized parity .
the remaining state , of opposite parity , makes small oscillations around zero , but its exact crossings with the other two states do not correlate with any structure in @xmath39 . and
@xmath52 , circles = exact results , lines = perturbation theory , ( b ) magnified view of exact results for a single avoided crossing .
beneath are the corresponding plots of @xmath39 . ] and @xmath52 , circles = exact results , solid line = two - level approximation , @xmath57 .
( b ) solid line = minimum value of @xmath31 , starting from the initial configuration @xmath55 .
the dotted line denotes @xmath39 , which shows little structure . in both plots the vertical dotted line marks the transition to the strong - driving regime . ] to interpret this behavior in the strong - field regime , we now obtain analytic expressions for the quasi - energies via the perturbation theory described in section [ method ] .
the first step is to solve the eigenvalue equation ( [ floqeq ] ) in the absence of the tunneling component @xmath12 . in a real - space representation the interaction terms are diagonal , and so it can be readily shown that an orthonormal set of eigenvectors is given by : @xmath58 , \
0 \right ) \nonumber \\ - i \frac{e}{\omega } \sin \omega t \right ] \right)\end{aligned}\ ] ] imposing @xmath5-periodic boundary conditions reveals the corresponding eigenvalues ( modulo @xmath43 ) to be @xmath59 and @xmath60 .
these eigenvalues represent the zeroth - order approximation to the floquet quasi - energies , and for frequencies such that @xmath61 all three eigenvalues are degenerate .
this degeneracy is lifted by the perturbation @xmath12 , and to first - order , the quasi - energies are obtained by diagonalizing the perturbing operator @xmath62 . by using the well - known identity : @xmath63 = \sum_{m=-\infty}^{\infty } j_m ( \beta ) \exp \left[-i m \omega t \right],\ ] ] to rewrite the form of @xmath64 , the matrix elements of @xmath65 can be obtained straightforwardly , and its eigenvalues subsequently found to be @xmath59 and @xmath66 .
fig.[quasi]a demonstrates the excellent agreement between this result ( with @xmath67 ) and the exact quasi - energies for strong and moderate fields , which allows the position of the peaks in @xmath39to be found by locating the roots of @xmath68 .
similar excellent agreement occurs at the other resonances . for weak fields , however
, the interaction terms do not dominate the tunneling terms and the perturbation theory breaks down , although we are still able to treat the system phenomenologically by using the effective two - level approximation .
as we remarked in the introduction , the coulomb interaction between the electrons can significantly affect the electronic structure of a qd .
such strongly correlated problems are notoriously difficult to treat , and the addition of a time - dependent field complicates the problem even further .
when the mean inter - electron separation exceeds a certain critical value , however , a surprising simplification occurs , as the coulomb interaction dominates the kinetic energy and drives a transition to a quasi - crystalline arrangement which minimizes the total electrostatic energy . in analogy to the phenomenon of wigner crystallization in bulk two - dimensional systems @xcite such a state is termed a _ wigner molecule _ @xcite . as the electrons in the wigner state
are sharply localised in space , the system can be naturally and efficiently discretized by placing lattice points just at these spatial locations . a many - particle basis
can then be constructed by taking slater determinants of single - particle states defined on these lattice sites , from which an effective hamiltonian of hubbard - type can be generated to describe the low - energy dynamics of the system @xcite .
a major advantage of this technique over standard discretization @xcite schemes , in which a very large number of lattice points is taken to approximate the continuum limit , is that the dimension of the effective hamiltonian is much smaller ( typically by many orders of magnitude ) , which permits the investigation of systems which would otherwise be prohibitively complex .
this approach has proven to be extremely successful in treating a variety of static problems , including one - dimensional qds @xcite , two - dimensional qds with polygonal boundaries @xcite , and electrons confined to quantum rings @xcite .
we further develop this method here by including a time - dependent electric field , and study the temporal dynamics of the system as it is driven out of equilibrium .
we consider a system of two electrons confined to a square qd with a hard - wall confining potential a simple representation of a two - dimensional semiconductor qd .
such a system can be produced by gating a two - dimensional electron gas confined at a heterojunction interface , and by placing a gate split into four quadrants over the heterostructure @xcite , the potentials at the corners of the qd can be individually regulated . in fig.[states]a
we show the ground - state charge - density obtained from the exact diagonalization of a square qd @xcite , for device parameters placing it deep in the wigner molecule regime .
it can be seen that the charge - density is sharply peaked at four points , located close to the vertices of the qd .
this structure arises from the coulomb interaction between the electrons , which tends to force them apart into diagonally opposite corners of the dot .
as there are two such diagonal states , degenerate in energy , we can understand the form of the ground - state by considering it to be essentially a superposition of these two states ( with a small admixture of higher energy states ) .
the four points at which the peaks occur define the sites on which the effective lattice - hamiltonian operates , as shown in fig.[states]b .
we take an effective lattice - hamiltonian of the form : @xmath69 + \sum_{i } \left [ { \tilde u}\ n_{i \uparrow } n_{i \downarrow } + e_i(t ) n_i \right ] .
\label{hamiltonian}\ ] ] here @xmath70 represents the coulomb repulsion between electrons occupying neighboring sites , and @xmath51 is the standard hubbard-@xmath23 term , giving the energy cost for double - occupation of a site .
as before , @xmath27 denotes the electric potential at site @xmath28 , which in general can have a static and a time - dependent component . in experiment ,
static offsets can arise either from deviations of the confining potential of the qd from the ideal geometry , or by the application of gating voltages to the corners of the qd . applying corner potentials in this way would substantially enhance the stability of the wigner molecule state , and could also be used to ensure that the multiplet of states included in the effective lattice - model is well - separated from the other excited states of the qd system . in this work , however , we do not explicitly consider the effects of static gates , and we neglect the influence of small , accidental offsets encountered in experiment as we expect them to have only minor effects , and indeed may even stabilize cdt @xcite . for convenience ,
we consider applying an ac field aligned with the @xmath71-axis of the qd , which can be parameterized as : @xmath72 where a , b , c , d label the sites as shown in fig.[states]b .
we emphasize that although we have the specific system of a semiconductor qd in mind , the effective - hamiltonian we are using can describe a wide range of physical systems , including @xmath73 arrays of connected qds @xcite , and our results are thus of general applicability . as for the case of the double qd ,
we include no spin - flip terms in ( [ hamiltonian ] ) and so the singlet and triplet sectors are again decoupled .
we choose to use initial states with singlet symmetry , which corresponds to the symmetry of the system s ground - state .
simple state counting reveals that the singlet sector has a dimension of ten , and can be spanned by the six states shown schematically in fig.[basis ] , together with the four states in which each site is doubly - occupied .
we begin our investigation by taking the hubbard-@xmath23 term to be infinitely large that is , to work in the sub - space of states with no double occupation .
our hilbert space is thus six - dimensional , and we use the states shown in fig.[basis ] as a basis .
we show in fig.[uinf ] the time - dependent number occupation of the four sites at two different values of @xmath46 , in both cases using state @xmath74 as the initial state , and setting the ac frequency to @xmath75 . in fig.[uinf]a @xmath46
has a value of 100.0 , and it can be clearly seen that the electrons perform driven rabi oscillations between the left side of the qd and the right .
accordingly , the occupation number of the sites varies continuously between zero and one . in fig.[uinf]b , however , we see that changing the electric potential to a value of @xmath76 produces dramatically different behavior .
the occupations of sites a and d only vary slightly from unity , while sites b and c remain essentially empty throughout the time - evolution .
only a small amount of charge can transfer per period of the driving field between the left and right sides of the system , producing the small spikes visible in this figure .
the amplitude of these features is extremely small , however , indicating that the tunneling between left and right sides has been almost totally destroyed .
infinite , @xmath77 and @xmath78 : ( a ) electric potential , e = 100.0 ( b ) e = 115.7 .
solid line indicates the occupation of sites a and d , the dotted line the occupation of sites b and c. ] to confirm that cdt is occurring , we present in fig.[uinf_floq ] a comparison of the amplitude of the oscillations of @xmath79 with the quasi - energy spectrum , as a function of the electric potential @xmath46 . similarly to the double qd system , we can see in fig.[uinf_floq]a that the quasi - energies have two different regimes of behavior .
the first of these is the weak - field regime , @xmath80 , at which the driving field does not dominate the dynamics . in this regime
the quasi - energy spectrum , and correspondingly , the amplitude of oscillations shows little structure .
the second regime occurs at strong values of potential , @xmath81 , for which the quasi - energy spectrum clearly shows a sequence of close approaches .
in fig.[uinf_floq]c we show an enlargement of one of these approaches which reveals it to be an _ avoided crossing_. employing the perturbative method described in section [ method ] demonstrates that the two quasi - energies involved in these avoided crossings are described by @xmath82 , where @xmath83 is equal to @xmath84 .
we may thus again think of @xmath83 as signifying the number of photons the system needs to absorb to overcome the coulomb repulsion between the electrons occupying neighboring sites .
the results in fig.[uinf_floq]b and fig.[uinf_floq]d clearly show that the locations of the avoided crossings correspond exactly to quenching of the oscillations in @xmath79 , and so confirm that cdt indeed occurs at these points .
infinite , @xmath77 and @xmath78 : circles = exact results , lines = perturbative solution [ @xmath85 .
( b ) amplitude of oscillation of the occupation of site a. ( c ) detail of quasi - energy spectrum , showing an avoided crossing .
( d ) detail of amplitude of oscillations . ]
we now take the most general case , and consider the competition between the @xmath51 and @xmath70 terms . setting @xmath51 to a finite value
means that the four doubly - occupied basis states are no longer energetically excluded from the dynamics , and accordingly we must take the full ten - dimensional basis set .
although it is difficult to obtain precise estimates for the values of parameters of the effective hamiltonian , it is clear that in general @xmath86 .
accordingly we choose the parameters @xmath87 to separate the two energy - scales widely for our investigation .
we again set the frequency of the ac field to @xmath78 , and in fig.[u160_1]a we show the quasi - energy spectrum obtained by sweeping over the field strength .
it is immediately clear from this figure that for electric potentials @xmath53 the form of the spectrum is extremely similar to the infinite-@xmath51 case .
performing perturbation theory confirms that , as in the previous case , the behavior of the quasi - energies is given by @xmath82 where @xmath88 .
we show in fig.[u160_1]b the amplitude of the oscillations of @xmath79 when the system is initialized in state @xmath74 , which demonstrates that at the locations of the avoided crossings the tunneling parallel to the field is again quenched . and @xmath89 , @xmath78 : circles = exact results , lines = perturbative solution [ @xmath90 .
( b ) amplitude of oscillation of the occupation of site a , with ( 6 ) as the initial state . ]
when the electric potential exceeds the value of @xmath51 , however , new structure appears in the quasi - energy spectrum .
a group of four quasi - energies , that for weaker fields cluster around zero , become `` excited '' and make a sequence of avoided crossings as the field strength is increased .
perturbation theory predicts that these high - field quasi - energies are given by @xmath91 , where @xmath92 , and thus these avoided crossings arise when the absorption of @xmath93 photons equates to the electrostatic energy difference between the two electrons being on neighboring sites , and doubly - occupying one site .
this then indicates that this structure arises from the coupling of the ac field to the doubly - occupied states . to probe this phenomenon , we time
- evolve the system from an initial state consisting of _ two _ electrons occupying site a. in fig.[u160_2]b it can be seen that for electric potentials weaker than @xmath51 the amplitude of the oscillations in @xmath79 remains small , and shows little dependence on the field . as the potential exceeds @xmath51 , this picture changes , and the ac field drives large oscillations in @xmath79 , and in fact mainly forces charge to oscillate between sites a and b. at the high - field avoided crossings , however , the tunneling between a and b is suppressed , which shuts down this process . instead , the only time - evolution that the system can perform consists of _ undriven _ rabi oscillations between sites a and d , perpendicular to the field . as these oscillations
are undriven they have a much longer time - scale than the forced dynamics , and thus during the interval over which we evolve the system the occupation of a only changes by a small amount , producing the very sharp minima visible in fig.[u160_2]b , centered on the roots of @xmath94 . and @xmath89 , @xmath78 : circles = exact results , lines = perturbative solution [ @xmath95 .
( b ) amplitude of oscillation of the occupation of site a , with site a doubly - occupied as the initial state . ] as the tunneling perpendicular to the field is undriven , it is straightforward to evaluate the time evolution of the initial state , if we assume that the left side of the qd is completely decoupled from the right side .
the occupation of sites a and d is then given by : @xmath96 where @xmath97 .
in fig.[decohere ] we display the occupations of sites a and d as a function of time , for two values of electric potential . at the first value , @xmath98 , tunneling between the left and right sides of the qd
is not quenched , and accordingly the occupation of the two sites varies rapidly between zero and two as the electrons are driven by the ac field around the system .
the second value , @xmath99 , corresponds to the first high - field avoided crossing .
it can be clearly seen that the charge oscillates between sites a and b , with a frequency of @xmath100 .
these rabi oscillations are damped , however , indicating that the isolation between the left and right sides of the qd is not perfect . in this sense
we can regard the two sites @xmath101 and @xmath102 as providing an environment , causing the quantum system composed of sites a and d to slowly decohere in time .
when the tunneling between the left and right sides of the qd is strong , for example at @xmath98 , this decoherence occurs very rapidly . by moving to an avoided crossing , however , and suppressing the tunneling ,
the rate of mixing between the two sides of the qd can be considerably reduced , and is just limited by the separation in energy between the two quasi - energies .
tuning the parameters of the driving field therefore gives us a simple and controllable way to investigate how a two - electron wavefunction can decohere in a qd . and @xmath89 system for @xmath78 : ( a ) electric potential , e = 200.0 ( no cdt ) ( b ) e = 185.8 ( cdt ) .
thick solid line indicates the occupation of site a , the thick dotted line the occupation of site d. dotted lines in ( b ) show the rabi oscillations of the isolated two - site system , eq.[rabi ] . ]
in this work we have studied the interplay between coulomb interactions and an ac driving field in two different configurations of qds . for the case of the double qd system
we have found that the system presents two different types of behavior , depending on whether the driving field dominates the interaction energy . for weak driving
, we have found the surprising result that a suitable ac field can nonetheless freeze the time - evolution of a doubly - occupied qd _ despite _ the coulomb interaction , and that this can be understood by means of an effective two - level model . at high field strengths the system
is only driven strongly by the field at frequencies for which an integer number of quanta , @xmath83 , is equal to the interaction energy .
when this condition is satisfied cdt is again able to occur at certain well - defined parameters of the field , and by using floquet theory we have shown that these points correspond to the roots of @xmath103 .
strong electronic correlations allowed us to use an effective lattice model of just four sites to treat the square qd , by taking advantage of the natural discretization of the system in a wigner molecule state . in the effective model , the inter - electron coulomb interaction is described by two parameters , @xmath51 and @xmath70 , and the dynamics of the system consists essentially of tunneling from corner to corner , along the perimeter of the qd . we find again that when the frequency of the driving field is in resonance with the coulomb gap ( that is , @xmath104 or @xmath105 ) charge is able to circulate freely around the system , except at sharply defined field strengths at which tunneling parallel to the field is destroyed .
floquet theory again proved an excellent tool to understand this behavior , and revealed that these points correspond to the roots of @xmath94 .
we have thus shown that ac - fields may not only be used as a spectroscopic tools to probe the electronic structure of qd systems , but can also be used to dynamically control the time - evolution of the system .
possible applications of cdt range from stabilising the leakage of trapped electrons in physical realisations of quantum bits , to acting as `` electron tweezers '' by destroying or restoring tunneling between regions of a mesoscopic device .
the tunability of the cdt effect , and its ability to discriminate between doubly - occupied and singly - occupied states , make it an excellent means for rapid manipulation of the dynamics of strongly correlated electrons in mesoscopic systems .
this work was supported by the spanish dges grant mat2002 - 02465 , by the european union tmr contract fmrx - ct98 - 0180 and by the european community s human potential programme under contract hprn - ct-2000 - 00144 , nanoscale dynamics . | we investigate the dynamics of interacting electrons confined to two types of quantum dot system , when driven by an external ac field .
we first consider a system of two electrons confined to a pair of coupled quantum dots @xcite by using an effective two - site model of hubbard - type . numerically integrating
the schrdinger equation in time reveals that for certain values of the strength and frequency of the field the tunneling between the dots can be destroyed , thus allowing the correlated two - electron states to be manipulated .
we then show how floquet theory @xcite can be used to predict the field parameters at which this effect occurs .
we then consider the case of confining the electrons to a single two - dimensional quantum dot in the limit of low particle - density . in this system
the electrons form strongly correlated states termed wigner molecules , in which the coulomb interaction causes them to become highly localised in space . again using an effective model of hubbard - type
, we investigate how the ac field can drive the dynamics of the wigner states @xcite . as before , we find that the ac field can be used to control the tunneling between various charge configurations , and we relate this to the presence of avoided crossings in the floquet quasi - energy spectrum .
these results hold out the exciting possibility of using ac fields to control the time evolution of entangled states in mesoscopic devices , which has great relevance to the rapidly advancing field of quantum information processing . |
an understanding of scattered radiation is deeply embedded within such scientific disciplines as astronomy , meteorology , climatology , and more recently biomedical imaging @xcite .
measurement of this radiation allows for the remote detection of object properties , through inspection of both the spectral , and spatial redistribution of energy .
notably , the inclusion of polarization in this analysis serves to enrich the source of available information .
an area of immense interest concerning such behavior , is the study of optical radiation scattering within biological media @xcite .
it was first realized that through appropriate filtering , polarized light could enable the selective imaging of either surface , or subsurface tissue layers @xcite . since then
, similar applications have helped to improve imaging modalities such as optical coherence tomography @xcite , and light scattering spectroscopy @xcite .
in addition to the advancement of existing techniques , the recovery of physical properties solely based on the observed transformation of polarized light is the objective of much research @xcite . interestingly , in media consisting of particles comparable to the wavelength in size ( mie regime ) , circular polarization can survive many more scattering events than linear polarization due to excessive forward scattering .
linear states depolarize once the direction of the incident photon stream is eventually isotropized @xcite . on the other hand , due to the preference of shallow angle scattering which generally preserves helicity , incident circularly or elliptically
polarized states persist on a longer length scale .
this effect is known as polarization memory @xcite .
the extent of the polarization memory is strongly dependent on the size parameter @xcite , and on the refractive index mismatch between the particles and background medium @xcite .
this offers an additional gauge by which to characterize medium properties , as measurements of the polarization state of multiply scattered light contain this information , even beyond the distance required to randomize photon direction , known as the transport length @xmath0 . in this article
, we address the dynamic relationship between circular polarization memory and the particles present in the scattering medium .
recent studies have shown that the survival of linear polarization exceeds that of circular polarization in many biological tissues @xcite .
such behavior is characteristic of smaller rayleigh scattering particles , although these tissues exhibit anisotropic scattering typical of the mie regime .
this has suggested an inability to predict depolarization rates in complex media based purely on bulk scattering properties such as the reduced scattering coefficient @xmath1 , the absorption coefficient @xmath2 , and the anisotropy @xmath3 factor @xcite .
here , we demonstrate a quantitative description of circular polarization memory in media consisting of a variety of independent scattering spheres , with total generality in particle size , and refractive index distribution . our method uses direct analysis of the single scattering behavior attained from mie theory , and a flexible integral approach towards characterizing the depolarization rate within complex media .
this will allow for additional information to be gathered from diffusing light measurements , and clarify the connection between particle distribution , and the observed crossover between scattering regimes .
mie theory offers an exact solution for scattering of a plane wave by a single spherical particle of any size .
the relationship between the incoming , and scattered stokes vectors describing polarization can be expressed in terms of the scattering matrix @xcite : @xmath4 where the elements of the scattering matrix are dependent on the scattering angle @xmath5 , and the stokes vectors are both defined with an orientation aligned to the scattering plane . for an incident
right - circularly polarized state , with @xmath6 , @xmath7 , the stokes vector for the partial wave scattered in the @xmath5 direction , with @xmath8 azimuth is : @xmath9 which is identical for all @xmath8 due to the rotational invariance of the input stokes vector .
the expression for the degree of circular polarization of this partial wave is : @xmath10 while the ensemble average of this quantity , denoted @xmath11 , over all scattering angles , weighted by the intensity of each partial wave is thus , @xmath12 after any arbitrary number of scattering events @xmath13 from identical independent spheres , the value of @xmath11 for all partial waves can be shown to follow an exponential decay @xcite . here
we will define the characteristic helicity survival parameter @xmath14 , which is a measure of the number of scattering events required to depolarize an incident circular state .
the average degree of circular polarization as a function of scattering order @xmath13 is then : @xmath15 where @xmath14 can be found from the single scattering behavior calculated in eq .
( [ integral ] ) and the natural logarithm of eq .
( [ exponential ] ) with @xmath16 .
this procedure can be carried out for a monodisperse system for any size parameter @xmath17 , and any refractive index ratio @xmath18 , where @xmath19 and @xmath20 are the refractive indices of the sphere , and background respectively , and @xmath21 is the particle radius .
figure [ depolarization ] shows the calculated survival parameter for a range of sphere sizes , and refractive indices .
the value of @xmath14 can be seen to fluctuate on both large and small scales with respect to a change in the size parameter @xmath22 .
for a medium consisting of a range of particle sizes , eq .
( [ exponential ] ) must be generalized to a distribution of exponentials : @xmath23 where @xmath24 is appropriately normalized such that , @xmath25 @xmath24 is the fraction of total intensity scattered , on average , by particles of size @xmath22 with corresponding helicity survival parameters given by @xmath26 .
this function is directly proportional to the scattering coefficient of each particle size , @xmath27 . in other words ,
the resulting circular depolarization rate of a polydisperse system is dependent on not only the helicity survival parameters of the constituent particles , but also the relative scattering cross sections @xmath28 , and number densities @xmath29 .
we then have : @xmath30 and finally , in terms of the volume fraction distribution @xmath31 : @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the single particle volume for spheres of size parameter @xmath22 .
equation ( [ integral ] ) integrates over the helicity survival parameters of all particles present in the medium , with each @xmath34 being calculated from the single scattering behavior .
thus , with a database of values stored for @xmath26 , and @xmath28 , the effective helicity survival parameter for any polydisperse system of spheres defined by the distribution function @xmath24 can be found immediately , a key advantage of this approach .
narrow polydispersion in scattering media effectively washes out the short scale fluctuations of particle size on the helicity survival @xmath14 .
for example , media with particle number densities @xmath35 obeying a normal distribution with a small ( @xmath36 ) coefficient of variance in particle size are shown in fig .
[ poly ] . here
the ratio @xmath37 is used to show the extent of the circular polarization memory , where @xmath38 is the number of scattering events required to randomize photon direction _
i.e. _ the number of scattering events in one transport length @xmath0 .
narrow polydisperse distributions shown in fig .
[ poly ] are common in media such as solutions of polystyrene microspheres in water ( @xmath39 ) , where the coefficient of variance is typically @xmath40 .
these solutions are widely used as simulating media , or phantoms " , due to their well defined bulk scattering properties .
= 8.5 cm scattering from more complex materials such as biological tissue can include contributions from a wide array of particle sizes .
disagreement between measurements of circularly polarized light scattered from tissue samples , and from matched phantoms has been reported @xcite .
this is likely due in part to the presence of both large mie scattering structures in tissue such as cell nuclei ( typically @xmath41 @xmath42 m ) , as well as smaller rayleigh - gans scatterers ( mitochondira , lysosomes _ etc .
_ @xmath43 @xmath42 m ) @xcite .
these phantom studies often use a monodisperse solution with particle size and concentration chosen to match the reduced scattering coefficient @xmath44 , and the scattering anisotropy @xmath3 , to another more complex medium .
however this is an oversimplification , and fails to reproduce the depolarization behavior , as we shall demonstrate . to approximate scattering from cell nuclei with smaller interspersed cellular organelles ,
we have calculated @xmath14 for media where the volume fraction contributions from small scatterers , and large scatterers have been varied . here , @xmath31 is chosen to take a bimodal form , with one normally distributed contribution with size parameter @xmath45 , and another normally distributed contribution at @xmath46 .
the fraction of the total volume of scattering material taken by the small scatterers is varied from @xmath47 ( nuclei only scattering ) to @xmath48 ( small organelle only scattering ) .
the refractive index ratio used is @xmath49 which is typical of biological media with @xmath50 ( organelles ) , and @xmath51 ( cytoplasm ) @xcite .
the results are shown in fig .
[ cell ] .
= 8.5 cm it can be seen that the circular polarization memory rapidly deteriorates with the addition of small scatterers to the medium . for relative volume fractions of small particles above @xmath36 ,
the effectiveness of the medium to preserve multiply scattered circularly polarized light is significantly diminished . to emphasize the importance of adequately accounting for polydispersion in scattering media ,
we have also calculated the circular polarization memory ( @xmath37 ) for a set of media with only one dominant size .
these points on the graph ( fig .
[ cell ] ) represent typical monodisperse " optical phantoms with a @xmath36 size distribution about the mean diameter . in each case
, these phantoms have been chosen to match the scattering anisotropy of the bimodal distribution used to model tissue .
the circles represent phantoms consisting of particles with @xmath49 .
the squares are calculated with @xmath39 , to represent polystyrene phantoms .
the branching of these points is due to the multiple possibilities in particle size for certain anisotropy @xmath3 values , and the partial absence of data points expresses that the upper limit of scattering anisotropy for polystyrene microspheres is @xmath52 ( in water ) .
it is clear from the figure that a significant overestimation is made of circular polarization memory when such phantoms are used , even if they are chosen such that @xmath53 , @xmath3 , and hence @xmath1 are equivalent .
the shortcomings of monodisperse phantoms evident here are in direct agreement with the previously mentioned studies @xcite .
it is important to note that the ability of small scatterers to reduce the polarization memory of larger constituent particles is heavily dependent on the relative scattering cross section @xmath54 . in the example
situation shown in fig .
[ cell ] , @xmath55 spheres were chosen because they are more effective at reducing circular polarization memory than smaller ( @xmath56 ) spheres , which have intrinsically lower values of @xmath14 .
this is due to the trade off between faster depolarization , but lower scattering efficiency as size is reduced .
this demonstrates that depolarization of incident circular states within polydisperse media is an intricate process dependent on the specific size and refractive indices of each contributing particle .
equation ( [ integral ] ) can be generalized further to include variations in particle refractive index mismatch @xmath57 : @xmath58 where @xmath59 now represents the fraction of total intensity scattered by particles for which @xmath60 .
the effective helicity survival parameter of the polydisperse medium can once again be found by inverting eq .
( [ exponential ] ) after evaluating this integral . to further highlight the flexibility of the approach presented here , fig .
[ heatmap ] shows the magnitude of circular polarization memory for a wide range of size parameters @xmath22 , and refractive index ratios @xmath57 .
each point on the image represents @xmath37 for a @xmath36 particle size distribution about the mean size parameter @xmath22 .
incident circularly polarized light is seen to be preserved most in media where both @xmath61 , and particle size is large .
such properties are consistent with large cellular structures in tissue . a complex cellular model could be proposed by the integration over all types of organelles present , including vacuoles with @xmath62 . however , the closely packed nature of scattering centers in many biological tissues may cause discrepancies from such models when dependent scattering arises , as shown in ref .
thus , care is required when generalizing these findings which are a result of the independent scattering approximation for spherical particles .
in summary , we have presented here a method for characterizing circular polarization memory in polydisperse media , where the particle distribution has been demonstrated to intricately determine the decay rate of incident circularly polarized light : narrow polydispersion about one dominant size parameter has the effect of smoothing out the short scale fluctuations seen with theoretical solutions containing perfectly identical centers .
this type of polydispersion is typical of phantom media such as polystyrene microspheres , and demonstrates that models using pure monodispersion can differ somewhat from realistic media where statistical variations in particle size are unavoidable ( see fig .
[ poly ] ) .
in complex media , where size distribution spans from the rayleigh regime to the mie regime , the extent of circular polarization memory is shown to be greatly impacted by only a small volume fraction of sub - wavelength scatterers . in our particular example ( fig .
[ cell ] ) we showed that circular polarization decays within approximately two transport lengths ( @xmath63 ) for media consisting of over @xmath64 relative volume fraction of small @xmath65 particles . with the method put forward here , it is now possible to rapidly calculate the helicity survival parameter @xmath14 for a medium with any general form of polydispersion in both size parameter @xmath22 , and refractive index ratio @xmath57 .
thus , recovery of this parameter from degree of polarization measurements of semi - diffuse light can provide an alternate means towards characterizing particle distribution .
furthermore , although circular polarization memory is a manifestation of anisotropic scattering , we have demonstrated the important distinction that it can not be characterized solely by the scattering anisotropy @xmath3 parameter .
we acknowledge support from the william evans fellowship provided by the university of otago for professor steven jacques , the dodd - walls center for photonic and quantum technologies , and the department of physics at the university of otago .
w. cai , _ et al .
, _ analytical cumulant solution of the vector radiative transfer equation investigates backscattering of circularly polarized light from turbid media " , phys .
e * 74 * , 056605 ( 2006 ) . | we investigate the survival of circularly polarized light in random scattering media .
the surprising persistence of this form of polarization has a known dependence on the size and refractive index of scattering particles , however a general description regarding polydisperse media is lacking . through analysis of mie theory , we present a means of calculating the magnitude of circular polarization memory in complex media , with total generality in the distribution of particle sizes and refractive indices .
quantification of this memory effect enables an alternate pathway towards recovering particle size distribution , based on measurements of diffusing circularly polarized light . |
today the @xmath2-scheme is the _ de facto _ standard used for comparisons of qcd predictions as well as experimental results .
it was introduced for practical reason , as an offspring of dimensional regularisation , whereas the method of effective charges ( ech ) and the corresponding renormalisation scheme are motivated physically .
the ech method has been in some detail discussed in the talk of maxwell @xcite . for completeness here the basic formulae and results
are assembled in view of the later interpretation of the data .
ech has been originally introduced in @xcite , a clear access , taking the observable itself as perturbative expansion parameter ( called renormalisation group improved perturbation theory , rgi ) is given in @xcite .
with respect to ech i follow the arguments of @xcite which applies the ech method directly to @xmath3data .
the results especially apply to mean values ( or moments ) of the event shape distributions which depend on a single energy scale , the centre - of - mass energy , @xmath4 , only .
the general next - to - leading order ( nlo ) expression for event shape distributions of an observable @xmath5 reads : @xmath6 + { \cal{o}}(\alpha_s)^3 \label{eq : secondorder}\ ] ] here @xmath7 and @xmath8 are the first and second order coefficients of the perturbative expansion .
note that due to the normalisation to the total cross - section the integral of eqn .
[ eq : secondorder ] is normalised to 1 .
the @xmath9 ( or alternatively the @xmath10 ) dependence reflects the dependence of the prediction on the renormalisation scheme . in nlo
the change of renormalisation scheme is fully equivalent to the change of the renormalisation scale .
weighting eqn .
[ eq : secondorder ] with and integrating over the observable then yields the mean value @xmath11 which can be directly measured .
normalising @xmath11 to the leading order coefficient @xmath7 a measurable quantity @xmath12 is obtained .
such quantities are called effective charges .
the idea of the ech method is now to chose ( in any order of perturbation theory ) a scheme such that all higher order coefficients for @xmath12 vanish .
this implies that @xmath12 coincides with the strong coupling extracted in a leading order analysis and explains the name ech as such observables are directly comparable to other observables of this kind as well as to the coupling . in nlo this leads to the following scale : @xmath13 an effective charge @xmath12 obeys the renormalisation group equation ( rge ) : @xmath14\quad + \quad k_0\cdot e^{-s / r}r^{\delta}+\dots \label{eq : rge}\ ] ] as the observables @xmath12 are directly measurable in dependence of the energy the @xmath15-functions are measurable quantities .
the leading coefficients of the @xmath1-functions , @xmath16 and @xmath17 are universal ( the same as for the coupling ) , the higher coefficients are observable dependent but free of renormalisation scheme ambiguities .
non - perturbative contributions , invisible in perturbation theory , lead to the term with the exponential .
@xmath18 is proportional to the factor multiplying a power term in the usual power model expressions . omitting for simplicity the non - perturbative term eqn .
[ eq : rge ] can be integrated yielding : @xmath19 where @xmath20 is defined by the square bracketed term in eqn .
[ eq : rge ] .
the constant of integration , @xmath21 , should have _ physical significance _ and is related to @xmath22 by an * exact * expression @xcite .
thus @xmath23 can be calculated from @xmath21 practically without additional uncertainty . besides the derivation of the above fundamental equations the paper @xcite includes a broad discussion of the extraction of @xmath24 from @xmath3data and shows the following : * the _ ech formalism
... is more general than the adoption of a particular scheme ... _ it can be derived _
non - perturbatively _ assuming only that the high energy behavior of the observable is given by the leading order perturbative expression . * ... _ higher orders can be split into a predictable contribution _ ( of known `` rg predictable '' terms @xmath25 ) _ and a remaining piece containing all the genuinely unknown aspects . _ ... _ the choice @xmath26 _ removes the predictable scatter and provides genuine information on the interesting ... higher - order _ _ terms . *
_ one can exhibit the relative size of the _ ( truly ) _ uncalculated higher - order corrections for different quantities_. these corrections _ are related to how the energy dependence of the quantity differs from its asymptotic dependence as @xmath27 .
_ * _ ... by comparing with data one can test how well the first few _ perturbative terms _ represent the observed running .
_ marked discrepancies indicate the importance of _ higher order terms , or ... non - perturbative contributions .
_ these findings imply that the ech scheme offers exceptional experimental control of higher order contributions by comparing different effective charge observables or measuring their energy evolution . the later discussion is mainly based on precise data of shape distributions obtained at the z - peak and of their mean values in the full range of @xmath3 experiments above the b - threshold .
some more recent results @xcite refer to the energy range @xmath2820 - 202 ge-0.2exv and comprise data on events with a radiated hard photon ( @xmath29 ) @xcite .
all experimental results correspond to simple @xmath3 annihilation and are fully corrected for experimental effects .
it has been realised @xcite , that hadron mass effects have a particularly strong influence for the so - called jet mass observables .
this strong mass dependence has been avoided in @xcite by redefining the particle four momenta using the so called p - scheme : ( @xmath30 ) or e - scheme : ( @xmath31 ) .
moreover in @xcite extra transverse momentum from b - hadron decays was corrected for by using monte carlo .
this correction is power behaved and can have influence on the energy evolution of the observables .
a figure displaying the correction is included in @xcite .
b - decays also influence event shape distributions . for 2-jet like topologies the distributions are depleted .
these events are shifted towards 3-jet topologies by the extra transverse momentum from the decay . for observables calculated from the whole event ( like @xmath32 ) the decay from the narrow event side contributes for all values of the observable leading to visible effects in the whole range of the observable . in principle
, the differences between the observables due to b - decays need to be corrected when applying power correction models to shape distributions .
plots of such corrections are again included in @xcite .
0.48 0.9 0.9 from @xmath33 as function of @xmath34 for @xmath35=1 and for the experimentally optimised value of @xmath35 . ]
0.72 from @xmath33 as function of @xmath34 for @xmath35=1 and for the experimentally optimised value of @xmath35 . ]
analyses of event shape distributions performed by experimental collaborations mainly employed the @xmath2-scheme with @xmath36 ; information about the explicit use of the ech scheme @xcite is sparse .
several experiments attempted , however , to determine optimal scales by fitting @xmath0 and @xmath35 simultaneously to the data . in view of this , so called experimental optimisation , it is instructive to discuss the influence of @xmath35 on the prediction eqn .
[ eq : secondorder ] . in fig .
[ f : thrxmu ] the data on @xmath33 is compared with the prediction eqn .
[ eq : secondorder ] for @xmath37 and the optimised scale ( @xmath38 ) .
evidently the change of scale leads to a `` turn '' of the prediction . for @xmath37 the slope of the data
is barely described .
other observables show a similar though often less pronounced discrepancy . as a consequence
the quality of the fits for @xmath35=1 is , in general , unsatisfactorily bad and the fitted values of @xmath0 depend on the interval chosen for the fit .
this is shown in fig .
[ f : asthrxmu ] e.g. for the thrust @xcite .
this behavior is basically known since petra @xcite or the early days of lep and has been observed at small values of the event shape observables ( in the 2-jet region ) where the perturbative @xmath39 predictions are presumed little reliable .
it should be noted , however , that due to the normalisation of the event shape distributions @xmath40 , the misfit between data and prediction must persist at large @xmath5 if present at small @xmath5 .
this has indeed been seen @xcite .
the optimisation of a single scale value for a distribution has been criticised @xcite as , in principle , the scale is expected to be @xmath5-dependent ( compare eqn .
[ eq : xech ] ) . however , the change of scale expected in the typical fit ranges of the data is moderate ( compare fig . [
f : correl ] ) .
experimental optimisation therefore presents a fair compromise between theoretical prejudice or request and experimental feasibility .
results on experimental optimisation are included in @xcite .
the first reference , which is discussed below , comprises 18 observables and is based on high statistics data . moreover in this analysis the dependence of the event shape distributions on the polar angle of the event axis with respect to the beam has been exploited .
this is advantageous in view of experimental systematics and leads to a large number of statistically independent data points .
* consequences for matched nlla @xmath39 analyses * + the mismatch of the slope of data and @xmath39 prediction has consequences also for the analysis of event shape distributions with matched nlla/@xmath39predictions .
0.9 -fit from opal @xcite ( lines added by the author ) . ]
the matching from an experimental point of view represents a kind of `` averaging '' of both predictions where in the 2-jet regime the nlla part and in the 3-jet regime the @xmath39 part dominates . as in the matching the @xmath39 prediction
is used with a renormalisation scale value @xmath35=1 the slope of the data is , for many observables , imperfectly described . in consequences the same problems
as discussed above for the pure @xmath39 prediction persist , though diminished by the matching with the nlla part . in consequence the @xmath41 is often in - acceptably bad when applying standard rules .
additional theory errors are introduced to regain consistency . as in the @xmath39case
the fitted value of @xmath23 often shows a marked dependence on the observable . to illustrate this in fig .
[ f : opalratio ] the ratio of the data and the fitted matched predictions is shown for several observables from the concluding opal analysis on event shape distributions @xcite . in order to make the discrepancies directly visible straight lines are additionally put to the data points . for @xmath42 , @xmath43 and @xmath32 a clear increase of the ratio with increasing values of the observables
is seen corresponding to an increase of @xmath0 ( @xmath44 ) . for @xmath45 and @xmath46
the ratio is almost constant , while for @xmath47 the ratio decreases with increasing observable .
this more complicated pattern correlates with the importance of higher order corrections in the @xmath39 part of the prediction or simply with the ratio @xmath48 .
the three observables with increasing ratio also show a large ratio @xmath49 , for @xmath45 and @xmath46 the ratio is smaller .
for @xmath50 it is negative .
the mismatch of the slope of the data and the prediction also deteriorates the initial @xmath41 .
the constructed error bands ( dominated by `` theory errors '' ) restore consistency of the fits .
the best stability is obtained for @xmath46 and justifies the small error obtained for this observable ( see fig . [
f : opalratio ] and @xcite ) . still the @xmath23 values depend on the fit range for some observables and are thus biased .
this observable dependent biases is even present in the overall lep combination ( see fig . [
f : aslep ] , @xcite ) .
the ( correlated ) @xmath0 values from @xmath42 and @xmath51 are high , @xmath46 and @xmath47 are low compared to the average .
@xmath43 is close to the average and seems to form an exception .
it is likely that the imperfect description of the slope by the matched prescription similarly influences analyses of power terms introduced in order to describe the hadronisation .
e.g. in the corresponding delphi analysis @xcite the @xmath0 values for @xmath51 and @xmath52 ( e - scheme ) are markedly smaller compared to the results from @xmath47 , @xmath42 and @xmath53 .
0.480.80.88 results obtained from @xmath39 fits of 18 event shape distributions for @xmath35=1 and @xmath35=@xmath54 . ] 0.8 results obtained from @xmath39 fits of 18 event shape distributions for @xmath35=1 and @xmath35=@xmath54 . ] in fig .
[ f : chiasxmu ] the @xmath55 and @xmath23 as function of @xmath35 as obtained from several event shape distributions is shown @xcite . the fit quality for these fits is satisfactory when including experimental and hadronisation errors only .
marked minima in @xmath55 are observed scattered over a wide range of @xmath35 .
the clear minima imply that the optimised scale values are statistically well determined .
the @xmath23 results corresponding to these scales show a much smaller scatter as for fixed @xmath35=1 .
this is more clearly shown in fig .
[ f : asboth ] .
the spread reduces from @xmath56 for @xmath35=1 to 2.2% with optimised scales , @xmath54 .
.6 values with the ech expectation @xmath57 .
the errors of @xmath54 are fit errors , for @xmath57 they indicate the expected change in the fit range . ]
it is particularly interesting to study the correlation of the fitted @xmath54 with the values expected from ech , @xmath58 , shown in fig . [
f : correl ] .
the @xmath54-errors are from the fit , the error bars for @xmath58 indicate the range of scales expected within the fit interval of the data .
a significant correlation @xmath59 is observed .
the wide spread of experimentally optimised scales which has been often criticised is in fact slightly smaller than the range expected from ech .
regarding the distribution of individual observables ( indicated by the letters in the plot ) it is seen that observables calculated from the whole event ( e.g. the thrust ) tend to populate the region of small @xmath58 , observables sensitive mainly to the wide side of the events ( e.g. @xmath60 ) populate the center while observables from the difference of the wide and narrow side show large scales .
this ordering corresponds ( via eqn .
[ eq : xech ] ) to large ( for small @xmath58 ) and small second order @xmath2 contributions ( for big @xmath58 ) .
overall the observed large range of @xmath54 can be considered as understood in ech theory .
it may be worth noting that the rms spread as @xmath61 .
] of @xmath54 with respect to @xmath58 is only 2.5 ( i.e. similar to the range used for naive @xmath2 theory error estimates ) .
this may be taken as a justification of an ech theory error estimate by a corresponding scale change .
however , the corresponding @xmath0 uncertainty will be far smaller than in the @xmath2 case as the optimal scales often correspond to the minima of the @xmath23(@xmath35 ) curves ( compare fig .
[ f : chiasxmu ] ) .
0.73 results obtained from several event shape means or integrals over the jcef or eec using @xmath2 theory plus monte carlo or power hadronisation corrections and rgi theory with and without non - perturbative terms . ] results obtained from several event shape means or integrals over the jcef or eec using @xmath2 theory plus monte carlo or power hadronisation corrections and rgi theory with and without non - perturbative terms . ]
some relevant data on mean values of shape distributions as function of the centre - of - mass energy @xcite is shown in fig .
[ f : rgifits ] .
the data is compared to fits of eqn .
[ eq : dg ] shown as full lines .
the dashed lines represent the @xmath2-prediction for the same @xmath23 .
it turned out that the data can be well described by the ech / rgi fits with a single value of @xmath23 ( @xmath62 ) and negligible additional non - perturbative terms . in fig .
[ f : rgias ] the @xmath23 results obtained from this data with @xmath2 prediction and monte carlo or power hadronisation corrections and ech / rgi theory with and without power terms are compared . evidently the spread of the results is far smaller for the ech / rgi results .
the inclusion of power terms leaves the spread almost unchanged but lowers the average value of @xmath23 to @xmath63 .
this result implies that the differences due to non - trivial uncalculated higher order terms or non - perturbative terms is small , of @xmath64 .
note that higher order corrections differing by about a factor 2 ( in @xmath2 ) are expected ratios in fig .
14 of @xcite .
] for event shape observables calculated from the full event or the wide hemisphere of an event only .
this is also reflected e.g. in the perturbatively calculated ratio of the power terms of thrust and @xmath60 .
the bigger differences seen in the @xmath2 compared to the ech results then should be due to `` rg predictable '' @xmath65 terms .
the better agreement of the ech result is also illustrated by fig .
[ f : a0rgi ] where the measured size of the power terms for some observables as parameterised by @xmath66 is compared to the ech / rgi expectation which has been calculated by setting the @xmath2+power terms expression equal to the ech prediction .
it is evident that the rgi / ech prediction describes the data better than a universal value of @xmath66 presumed by power correction models .
0.160.40.58 as determined from power model fits compared to ech expectation ( grey bands ) .
, title="fig : " ] as determined from power model fits compared to ech expectation ( grey bands ) .
, title="fig : " ] + .results on @xmath67 obtained from rgi / ech fits to delphi data @xcite .
the first error is statistical , the second is systematic and the third is due to the b - hadron decay correction .
the uncertainty due to possible non - pert .
contributions is small . [
cols="<,^,^",options="header " , ] besides the comparison of the @xmath0 results from different observables the energy dependence of these observables i.e. the observed @xmath15-functions can be compared to the nlo expectation . as the nlo terms present
only a small @xmath68 correction @xmath69 has been set to the qcd expectation .
then the @xmath67 values obtained from the different observables can be directly compared . in order to allow full control of the systematic uncertainties
this comparison was made for seven observables determined from delphi data only .
the measured @xmath67 values agree among each other within part of the correlated statistical uncertainty and with the qcd expectation @xmath70 ( see tab . 1 ) .
the possible influence of power terms ( @xmath71 at the z ) on the @xmath1-function is small as the energy dependencies of the power terms and the @xmath1-function are similar . especially in view of a measurement of the @xmath1-function
the analysis has been repeated including reliable low energy data on the thrust .
the resulting fit is shown in fig .
[ f : rgithrustfit ] , and corresponds to 1 _ 0 & = 7.86 0.32 .
this measurement of the @xmath1-function is the most precise presented so far and allows to strongly constrain the qcd gauge group to su(3 ) in combination with measurements of the multiplicity ratio of gluon and quark jets @xcite and four jet angular distributions @xcite ( see fig .
[ f : wimplot ] ) .
this agreement in turn lends further support to the measurements using the ech scheme .
0.430.47 and @xmath72 from measurements of the @xmath1-function , the multiplicity ratio in gluon to quark jets and four jet angular distributions.,height=359 ] and @xmath72 from measurements of the @xmath1-function , the multiplicity ratio in gluon to quark jets and four jet angular distributions .
] as a final check it has been tried to infer the possible size of @xmath73 from the overall thrust data by fitting the corresponding expression with @xmath67 and @xmath69 fixed to the qcd expectation .
the resulting value of @xmath73 was found to be small and consistent with 0 .
the above quoted results imply that the running of @xmath3data already in the energy range above the b - threshold is well described by the leading two coefficients of the qcd @xmath1-function expansion .
neither important nnlo contributions nor important non - perturbative terms are observed from the running of the observables or from the comparison of @xmath0 obtained from different observables . in turn
this gives confidence to the ech / rgi measurements of @xmath23 from event shape means .
the extraction of @xmath23 from seven event shape distribution mean values ( corrected for mass effects ) using the ech / rgi formalism shows a far better consistency between the individual results ( spread @xmath71 ) compared to the ones obtained using the conventional @xmath2 @xmath39 analysis combined with monte carlo or power model hadronisation corrections ( spread @xmath74 ) .
moreover the energy evolution of these observables , the @xmath15-functions are well described by the two - loop qcd expression and a universal value of @xmath23 .
possible non - perturbative contributions turn out to be small ( @xmath71 at the z ) .
a fit to the precise data on thrust in the energy range 15 - 205 ge-0.2exv precisely confirms the two loop qcd expectation . these experimental result support the theoretical prejudice that the ech scheme is more general than a particular renormalisation scheme as it can be derived non - perturbatively .
moreover large logarithmic terms @xmath75 are avoided in ech .
this fact and the possibility to directly measure the @xmath15-functions and thereby to judge the importance of genuine higher order and non - perturbative terms single out the ech scheme for experimental tests .
the inciting results obtained for mean values are corroborated by studies of event shape distributions with experimentally optimised scales .
these scales turn out to be similar to the ech expectation . also here
the spread of the @xmath23 results is strongly reduced although additional logarithmic dependencies on the observables are to be expected . in studies employing @xmath2 theory and the so - called physical scale @xmath35=1
the slope of the distribution is often badly described .
this leads to a dependence of the extracted @xmath23 value on the fit range , thus to a biased result .
due to the normalisation of the event shape distributions to one such a dependence must be present , though to reduced extent , in the state - of - the - art matched @xmath39/nlla analyses and most likely causes part of the spread of the @xmath23 results extracted using this prescription .
despite the technical problems encountered @xcite studies to match ech and nlla calculations should therefore proceed . in
the concluding talk of the workshop @xcite the question was raised why both ech and @xmath2/power models lead to a reasonable description of the energy evolution of mean values .
taking the ech results for granted this question can be answered : the @xmath2 perturbative part of the power ansatz will fulfill the rge . to leading order
this is also true for the power contribution as its energy dependence is similar to that of the coupling .
as the size of the power term is fit to the data the discrepancy to the ech expectation must be small . still the predictability of the size of the power terms ( see fig . [
f : a0rgi ] ) using a single value of @xmath23 as input gives preference to the ech description for mean values .
it is likely that a large part of the annoying and unsatisfactorily large spread of the @xmath23 results obtained from different event shape observables using standard analyses is due to perturbing logarithmic terms induced by the choice of the so - called physical scale and the @xmath2 renormalisation scheme . given the above quoted positive ech results experimentalists should be encouraged to also analyse their data using the ech scheme where possible and not regard this alternative to the @xmath2 convention as a heretical digression .
i would like to thank the organisers of the frif workshop , gavin salam , mrinal dasgupta and yuri dokshitzer for creating the pleasant and truly `` workshoppish '' atmosphere at jussieu and for the possibility to summarise work prepared over the lifetime of lep and delphi .
i thank j.drees and d.wicke for comments to the manuscript .
d. t. barclay , c. j. maxwell and m. t. reader , phys .
d * 49 * ( 1994 ) 3480 .
w. celmaster and r. j. gonsalves , phys .
d * 20 * , 1420 ( 1979 ) .
j. abdallah _ et al .
_ [ delphi collaboration ] , eur .
j. c * 29 * ( 2003 ) 285 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0307048 ] .
r. reinhardt , dissertation , bergische univ .
wuppertal , wub - dis 2001 - 6 , june 2001 , see archiv of the deutsche bibliothek , http://www.ddb.de/sammlungen/kataloge/opac_dbf.htm p. pfeifenschneider _ et al . _
[ jade collaboration ] , eur .
j. c * 17 * ( 2000 ) 19 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0001055 ] .
a. movilla fernandez _
[ jade collaboration ] , eur .
j. c * 1 * ( 1998 ) 461 [ arxiv : hep - ex/9708034 ] .
g. p. salam and d. wicke , jhep * 0105 * , 061 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0102343 ] .
p. abreu _ et al .
_ [ delphi collaboration ] , eur . phys .
j. c * 14 * ( 2000 ) 557 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0002026 ] .
s. hahn , dissertation , bergische univ .
wuppertal , wub - dis 2000 - 6 , september 2001 , see archiv of the deutsche bibliothek , http://www.ddb.de/sammlungen/kataloge/opac_dbf.htm p.
n. burrows _ et al .
_ , phys .
b * 382 * ( 1996 ) 157 [ arxiv : hep - ph/9602210 ] .
the fac result discussed in this paper corresponds to ech .
the conclusion differs from the one of this talk or @xcite as the results obtained for @xmath51 and oblateness are far outlieing .
omitting these results reduces the spread in @xmath23 from 0.008 to 0.004 .
n. magnussen , dissertation , bergische univ .
wuppertal , wub - dis 1988 , desy - f22 - 89 - 01 .
p. abreu _ et al .
_ [ delphi collaboration ] , z. phys .
c * 54 * ( 1992 ) 55 .
d. acton _ et al . _
[ opal collaboration ] , z. phys .
c * 55 * ( 1992 ) 1 .
g. abbiendi _ et al .
_ [ opal collaboration ] , eur .
j. c * 40 * ( 2005 ) 287 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0503051 ] .
m. t. ford , ph.d .
thesis , cambridge univ .
, arxiv : hep - ex/0405054 .
a. heister _ et al .
_ [ aleph collaboration ] , eur . phys .
j. c * 27 * ( 2003 ) 1 .
the lep qcd working group , a combination of @xmath0 values derived from event shape variables at lep , to be published .
preliminary results are included in @xcite .
j. abdallah _ et al .
_ [ delphi collaboration ] , eur . phys .
j. c * 44 * ( 2005 ) 311 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0510025 ] .
p. abreu _ et al .
_ [ delphi collaboration ] , phys .
b * 414 * ( 1997 ) 401 .
g. abbiendi _ et al .
_ [ opal collaboration ] , eur .
j. c * 20 * ( 2001 ) 601 [ arxiv : hep - ex/0101044 ] .
a. mueller , talk given at this meeting . | experimental results on event shapes obtained within ( or related to ) the method of effective charges are discussed in view of measurements of the strong coupling , @xmath0 , the @xmath1-function and non - perturbative contributions to event shapes .
the data strongly advocate to use of the ech scheme instead of the conventional @xmath2 scheme . |
quantum entanglement plays an important role in various fields of quantum information , such as quantum computation [ 1 ] , quantum cryptography [ 2 ] , quantum teleportation [ 3,4 ] , dense coding [ 5 ] and quantum communication [ 6 ] , etc .
it has been recognized [ 7,8 ] that quantum teleportation can be viewed as an achievable experimental technique to quantitatively investigate quantum entanglement .
there exists a class of states called maximally correlated states , which have an interesting property , i.e. , the ppt distillable entanglement is exactly the same as the relative entropy of entanglement [ 9 ] . both two - mode squeezed vacuum states and pair cat states [ 10 ] belong to this class . in continuous variable teleportation
the entanglement resource is usually the two - mode squeezed state , or the einstein - podolsky - rosen ( epr ) states .
continuous variable quantum teleportation of arbitrary coherent states has been realized experimentally by employing a two - mode squeezed vacuum state as an entanglement resource [ 7 ] .
theoretical proposals of teleportation scheme based on the other continuous variable entangled states have already been discussed [ 11 ] .
update now , little attention has been paid to the entanglement properties of the pair cat state and its possible application of quantum information .
gou et al .
have proposed a scheme for generating the pair cat state of motion in a two - dimensional ion trap [ 12 ] . in their scheme
, the trapped ion is excited bichromatically by five laser beams along different directions in the x - y plane of the ion trap .
four of these have the same frequency and can be derived from the same source , reducing the demands on the experimentalist .
it is shown that if the initial vibrational state is given by a two - mode fock state , pair cat states are realized when the system reaches its steady state .
their work motivates us to investigate the entanglement properties of the pair cat state and its possible application in quantum information processes , such as quantum teleportation .
the motivation is two - fold : ( 1 ) the storage of continuous variable entangled states in two - dimensional motional states of trapped ions is feasible in current experimental techniques .
( 2 ) the mapping of steady state entanglement to optical beams is also realizable [ 13 ] .
+ on the other hand , quantum entanglement is a fragile nature , which can be destroyed by the interaction between the real quantum system and its environment .
this effect , called decoherence , is the most serious problem for all entanglement manipulations in quantum information processing .
there have several proposals for entanglement distillation and purification in continuous variable systems [ 14 ] . in this paper
, we firstly investigate the relative entropy of entanglement of pair cat states in the phase damping channel , and show that the pair cat states can always be distillable in the phase damping channel .
then , we explore possible application of pair cat states in quantum information processing , such as quantum teleportation .
the fidelity of teleportation protocol in which the mixed pair cat state is used as a entangled resource , is analyzed .
+ this paper is organized as follows . in section ii ,
based on the exact solution of the master equation describing phase damping , we give the numerical calculations of relative entropy of entanglement for pair cat states in the phase damping channel and investigate the influence of the initial parameters of these states on the relative entropy of entanglement . in section iii , we analyze the fidelity of teleportation for the pair cat states by using joint measurements of the photon - number sum and phase difference .
the influence of phase damping on the fidelity is discussed .
a conclusion is given in section iv .
the relative entropy of entanglement is a good measure of quantum entanglement , it reduces to the von neumann entropy of the reduced density operator of either subsystems for pure states . for a mixed state @xmath0 ,
the relative entropy of entanglement [ 15 ] is defined by @xmath1 , where @xmath2 is the set of all disentangled states , and @xmath3 $ ] is the quantum relative entropy .
it is usually hard to calculate the relative entropy of entanglement for mixed states .
recently , it has been shown [ 27 ] that the relative entropy of entanglement for a class of mixed states characterized by the following density matrix @xmath4 can be written as @xmath5 the separate state @xmath6 that minimizes the quantum relative entropy @xmath7 is @xmath8 where , @xmath9 and @xmath10 are orthogonal states of each subsystem .
the states in eq.(1 ) are also called maximally correlated states and are known to have some interesting properties .
for example , the ppt distillable entanglement is exactly the same as the relative entropy of entanglement [ 9 ] .
+ now , we consider the phase damping model .
the density matrix satisfies the following master equation in the interaction picture @xmath11 with @xmath12 , \eqno{(5)}\ ] ] where , @xmath13(@xmath14 ) is the ith mode phase damping coefficient , and @xmath15 ( @xmath16 ) is the creation ( annihilation ) operator of the ith mode field . for arbitrary initial states described by the density matrix @xmath17 , the solution of eq.(4 )
can be obtained , @xmath18 where @xmath19 .
\eqno{(7)}\ ] ] if we assume the initial density matrix @xmath17 is arbitrary two - mode continuous variable pure states , i.e. , @xmath20 where @xmath21 is two - mode particle number state .
then , the time - evolution density matrix with the initial condition is calculated as @xmath22|n , m\rangle\langle{n^{'}},m^{'}| . \eqno{(9)}\ ] ] if the density matrix @xmath23 in eq.(9 ) can be expressed as the similar form of eq.(1 ) , i.e. , @xmath24 where , @xmath25 and @xmath26 are orthogonal states of modes 1 and 2 , the relative entropy of entanglement of @xmath23 in eq.(10 ) can be expressed as , @xmath27 and the separate state @xmath6 that minimizes the quantum relative entropy is @xmath28 in what follows , we investigate the relative entropy of entanglement of pair cat states in phase damping channel .
firstly , we will briefly outline the definition of pair cat states and the closely related pair coherent states . for two independent boson annihilation operators @xmath29 , @xmath30
, a pair coherent state @xmath31 is defined as an eigenstate of both the pair annihilation operator @xmath32 and the number difference operator @xmath33 [ 16 ] , i.e. , @xmath34 where @xmath35 is a complex number and @xmath36 is a fixed integer . without loss of generality ,
we may set @xmath37 and the pair coherent states can be explicitly expanded as a superposition of the two - mode fock states , i.e. , @xmath38 where @xmath39^{-1/2}$ ] is the normalization constant and @xmath40 is the modified bessel function of the first kind of order @xmath36 .
it has been suggested by reid and krippner that the non - degenerate parametric oscillator transiently generates pair coherent states , in the limit of very large parametric nonlinearity and high - q cavities[17 ] .
recently , munro _ et al .
_ have shown that the pair coherent states can be used to improve the detection sensitivity of weak forces[18 ] .
pair cat states @xmath41 are proposed by gerry and grobe [ 10 ] , which are defined as superposition of two different pair coherent states , i.e. , @xmath42 , \eqno{(15)}\ ] ] where the normalization constant @xmath43 is given by @xmath44^{-\frac{1}{2}}. \eqno{(16)}\ ] ] it is easy to verify that the states @xmath41 are eigenstates of the operator @xmath45 with eigenvalue @xmath46 .
gou et al .
have proposed a scheme for generating the pair cat state of motion in a two - dimensional ion trap [ 12 ] . in their scheme
, the trapped ion is excited bichromatically by five laser beams along different directions in the x - y plane of the ion trap .
four of these have the same frequency and can be derived from the same source , reducing the demands on the experimentalist .
it is shown that if the initial vibrational state is given by a two - mode fock state , pair cat states are realized when the system reaches its steady state .
our following calculation show that pair cat states hold controllable entanglement .
so , it is reasonable to regard the controlled two - dimensional trapped ion as a reliable source of entanglement .
recent achievements concerning the transfer of entangled state have provided us a possible way to map the pair cat state of the motional freedom of two dimensional trapped ions into freely propagating optical fields [ 13 ] . when the free photon propagates in the optical fibre , one of the encountered decoherence mechanisms is the phase damping . in the following ,
we discuss the entanglement of pair cat states in phase damping channel .
we assume that the initial state is prepared in pair cat states @xmath41 . by making use of eqs.(6 ) and
( 7 ) , we obtain @xmath47\xi^n\xi^{\ast{m}}(1+(-1)^ne^{i\phi})(1+(-1)^me^{-i\phi } ) } { \sqrt{n!m!(n+q)!(m+q)!}}|n+q , n\rangle\langle{m+q},m| .
\eqno{(17)}\ ] ] the relative entropy of entanglement for @xmath23 is calculated as @xmath48 @xmath49 of the pair cat state as a function of the parameter @xmath50 and the degree of damping @xmath51 for @xmath52 with @xmath53 .
[ fig.1 ] ] of the pair cat state as a function of the degree of damping @xmath51 and the parameter @xmath54 for @xmath52 with @xmath55 .
[ fig.2 ] ] of the pair cat state as a function of the parameter @xmath50 and the parameter @xmath54 for @xmath52 with @xmath56 .
[ fig.3 ] ] of the pair cat state as a function of the parameter @xmath54 for three values of @xmath57 and @xmath58 with @xmath56 and @xmath55 .
[ fig.4 ] ] in numerical computations throughout this paper , the parameters @xmath59 , @xmath60 are chosen and the truncated photon number has been taken to be @xmath61 , the value of which is sufficiently large for numerical convergence .
figures 1,2 and 3 show that the relative entropy of entanglement @xmath62 of the pair cat state increases with @xmath50 and decreases with degree of damping @xmath51 , and can be controlled by adjusting the relative phase @xmath54 .
this results can be explained as follows : the entanglement of pair cat states heavily depend on the photon number distribution which can be modified by the relative phase via the interference .
similar results have been obtained in ref.[19 ] . in fig.4
, we plot the relative entropy of entanglement @xmath62 of the pair cat state as a function of the relative phase @xmath54 for three values of the parameter @xmath36 .
recently , hiroshima has numerically calculated the relative entropy of entanglement of two - mode squeezed vacuum states , defined by @xmath63|vac\rangle$ ] , in phase damping channel [ 20 ] .
it has been shown [ 21 ] that the two - mode squeezed vacuum state in phase damping channel is always distillable ( and inseparable ) . in the following ,
we show that the pair cat states are always distillable ( and inseparable ) in phase damping channel . + for two - mode continuous variable states @xmath64 , @xmath65 where @xmath9 and @xmath10 are orthogonal particle number states of each subsystem and @xmath66 satisfy the normalization condition @xmath67 .
the density matrix with the initial condition @xmath68 can be written as @xmath69|\phi_n,\psi_n\rangle\langle\phi_m,\psi_m| .
\eqno{(20)}\ ] ] according to ref.[22 ] , if operator @xmath70 is not positive definite , there is always a scheme to distill @xmath23 . here
, we find @xmath71 .
if there are two nonzero @xmath72 , @xmath73 , it is always possible to choose four vectors @xmath74 , @xmath75 , @xmath76 , @xmath77 .
then , we have @xmath78\textrm{re}(f_if^{\ast}_j),\ ] ] @xmath79\textrm{re}(f_if^{\ast}_j),\ ] ] @xmath80\textrm{im}(f_if^{\ast}_j),\ ] ] @xmath81\textrm{im}(f_if^{\ast}_j ) , \eqno{(21)}\ ] ] which satisfy @xmath82 @xmath83(f_if^{\ast}_j)\neq0,\ ] ] @xmath84(f_if^{\ast}_j)\neq0 , \eqno{(22)}\ ] ] eqs.(22 ) show that there is at least one of @xmath85 ( @xmath86 ) , which is negative for any finite @xmath87 . from the above
, we obtain the following conclusion : the two - mode continuous variable state @xmath88 , in which @xmath9 and @xmath10 are orthogonal particle number states of each subsystem , is always distillable ( and inseparable ) in phase damping channel , if there are at least two nonzero values of coefficiences @xmath66 .
obviously , pair coherent states and pair cat states which belong to the family of states in eq.(20 ) is always distillable in phase damping channel
. it should be interesting to consider a slightly modified purification protocol similar to the protocol in ref.[14 ] to distill maximal entangled states from the mixed pair cat states or mixed pair coherent states due to phase damping .
recently , cochrane et al . have presented a teleportation protocol by making use of joint measurements of the photon number sum and phase difference on two field modes [ 11 ] .
various kinds of two modes entangled states used as the entanglement resource have been discussed and the respective teleportation fidelities have been investigated . in this section , we adopt the protocol of cochrane et al . to investigate the fidelity of teleportation , in which the pair cat state is utilized as the entanglement resource .
the influence of phase damping on the fidelity is also discussed .
+ consider arbitrary target state sent by alice to bob @xmath89 where @xmath90 is the fock state .
initially , alice and bob share the two - mode fields in the pair cat state .
then , the total state is @xmath91}{\sqrt{n!(n+q ) ! } } of this teleportation protocol can be decomposed as two steps : alice makes a joint measurement of the photon number sum and phase difference of the target state and her component of the pair cat state ; the results of the joint measurement are sent to bob via the classical channel , and bob reproduce the target state after appropriate amplification and phase shift operations according to the results of the joint measurement .
the joint measurement of the photon number sum and phase difference has attracted much attention due to its extensive potential applications both in quantum optics and quantum information [ 23,24 ] . in ref.[24 ] , luis et al .
introduced the hermitian phase - difference operator @xmath92 with @xmath93 and @xmath94 where @xmath95 is an arbitrary angle .
it is obvious that the joint measurement projects the two - mode quantum state onto @xmath96 . in ref.[25 ] , a physical scheme of the joint measurement of the photon number sum and phase difference of two - mode fields was proposed , in which only the linear optical elements and single - photon detector are involved .
+ if alice measure the number sum @xmath97 of the target and her component of the pair cat state with result @xmath98 , the state of the total system is projected onto @xmath99^{-1/2}\sum^{n}_{l = q } \frac{d_{n - l}\xi^{l - q}[1+(-1)^{l - q}e^{i\phi } ] } { \sqrt{l!(l - q)!}}|l\rangle_a|l - q\rangle_b|n - l\rangle_t , \eqno{(28)}\ ] ] where @xmath100}{l!(l - q ) ! } , \eqno{(29)}\ ] ] is the probability of obtaining the result @xmath98 .
further measurement of phase difference with the result @xmath101 performed by alice will project bob s mode onto the pure state @xmath102^{-1/2 } \sum^{n - q}_{n=0}\frac{d_{n - q - n}(e^{-i\theta_{-}}\xi)^n[1+(-1)^ne^{i\phi } ] } { \sqrt{n!(n+q)!}}|n\rangle_b . \eqno{(30)}\ ] ] alice sends the values @xmath98 and @xmath101 to bob , and then bob amplifies his mode so that @xmath103 [ 26 ] and makes a operation @xmath104 for phase shifting his mode .
the teleportation protocol is then completed and bob finally has the state in @xmath105^{-1/2 } \sum^{n - q}_{n=0}\frac{d_{n - q - n}\xi^n[1+(-1)^ne^{i\phi}]}{\sqrt{n!(n+q)!}}|n - q - n\rangle_b . \eqno{(31)}\ ] ] the fidelity of this protocol depends on the result @xmath98 and can be obtained as follows @xmath106^{-1}|\sum^{n - q}_{n=0 } \frac{|d_{n - q - n}|^2\xi^n[1+(-1)^ne^{i\phi}]}{\sqrt{n!(n+q)!}}|^2 . \eqno{(32)}\ ] ] the average fidelity defined by @xmath107 is @xmath108}{\sqrt{n!(n+q)!}}|^2 .
\eqno{(33)}\ ] ] let the target state be a coherent state @xmath109 .
then , the average fidelity can be expressed as @xmath110}{(n - n ) !
\sqrt{n!(n+q)!}}|^2 . \eqno{(34)}\ ] ] with @xmath52 and @xmath111 for different values of @xmath112 , @xmath113 ( solid line ) , @xmath114 ( dash line ) , @xmath115 ( dot line ) .
[ fig.5 ] ] in fig.5 , we have plotted the average fidelity as the functions of the parameters @xmath35 for different values of @xmath112 .
it is shown that the average fidelity increases with the value of @xmath35 .
furthermore , the average fidelity defined above heavily depends on the teleported states . if the teleported state is a coherent state , the smaller the amplitude of coherent states , the higher the average fidelity .
its physical reason can be elucidated by two facts : one fact is that this protocol works perfectly if the target is a number state [ 11 ] ; the other fact is that the smaller the amplitude of a coherent state , the closer the state distance between the coherent state and a specific number state , i.e . , the vacuum state . in what follows ,
we discuss the influence of phase damping on the fidelity of the above teleportation protocol . in this case
, the state of the total system can be written as follows @xmath116[1+(-1)^me^{-i\phi } ] e^{-\gamma{t}(n - m)^2}}{\sqrt{n!m!(n+q)!(m+q)!}}|k\rangle_{tt}\langle{l}| \otimes|n+q , n\rangle\langle{m+q},m| .
\eqno{(35)}\ ] ] after completing the protocol described above , bob finally achieves the state in his mode expressed by @xmath117^{-1}\sum^{n^{\prime}}_{n , m=0 } \frac{d_{n^{\prime}-n}d^{\ast}_{n^{\prime}-m}\xi^n\xi^{\ast{m}}[1+(-1)^ne^{i\phi}][1+(-1)^me^{-i\phi } ] e^{-\gamma{t}(n - m)^2}}{\sqrt{n!m!(n+q)!(m+q)!}}|n^{\prime}-n\rangle_{bb}\langle{n^{\prime}-m}| , \eqno{(36)}\ ] ] where @xmath118 and @xmath98 is the measured number sum of alice s joint measurement .
then , the fidelity of this protocol depends on the result @xmath98 and is @xmath119^{-1}\sum^{n^{\prime}}_{n , m=0 } \frac{|d_{n^{\prime}-n}|^2|d_{n^{\prime}-m}|^2\xi^n\xi^{\ast{m}}[1+(-1)^ne^{i\phi}][1+(-1)^me^{-i\phi } ] e^{-\gamma{t}(n - m)^2}}{\sqrt{n!m!(n+q)!(m+q)!}}. \eqno{(37)}\ ] ] the average fidelity is @xmath120[1+(-1)^me^{-i\phi } ] e^{-\gamma{t}(n - m)^2}}{\sqrt{n!m!(n+q)!(m+q)!}}. \eqno{(38)}\ ] ] for a coherent state @xmath121 teleported by alice , the average fidelity can be rewritten as @xmath122[1+(-1)^me^{-i\phi } ] e^{-\gamma{t}(n - m)^2}}{(n^{\prime}-n)!(n^{\prime}-m)!\sqrt{n!m!(n+q)!(m+q)!}}. \eqno{(39)}\ ] ] in fig.6 , the average fidelity for the coherent states is plotted as a function of @xmath123 for different values of amplitude @xmath112 .
it is shown that the phase damping deteriorate the average fidelity of teleportation basing on the pair cat state , which is qualitatively consistent with the behavior of its relative entropy of entanglement in the phase damping channel . as mentioned above , the essential parts of this teleportation protocol are the preparation of the pair cat state and the joint measurement of the number sum and phase difference .
the direct preparation of pair cat states in two modes optical fields is still a open question .
however , we can map the pair cat state of the motional freedom of two dimensional trapped ions into freely propagating optical fields .
the details will be discussed elsewhere .
recently , the physical implementation of joint measurement of photon number sum and phase difference of two - mode optical fields is shown to be possible by using only the linear optical elements and the single - photon detector [ 25 ] .
so we can conclude that the physical realization of this teleportation protocol is feasible at the present technology .
in this paper , we investigate the entanglement of pair cat states in the phase damping channel by employing the relative entropy of entanglement . we give the numerical calculations of the relative entropy of entanglement of this state with @xmath35=30 , @xmath52 and @xmath111 for different values of @xmath112 , @xmath113 ( solid line ) , @xmath114 ( dash line ) , @xmath115 ( dot line ) .
[ fig.6 ] ] in the phase damping channel and study the influence of the parameters on the relative entropy of entanglement .
we find that the relative phase of the pair cat state can control the relative entropy of entanglement .
then , we show that the pair cat states can always be distillable in the phase damping channel .
finally , we analyze the fidelity of teleportation for the pair cat states by using joint measurements of the photon - number sum and phase difference .
the influence of phase damping on the fidelity is discussed .
the behavior of average fidelity for teleporting a coherent based on the pair cat state is qualitatively consistent with its relative entropy of entanglement .
it is interesting to investigate the entanglement and teleportation fidelity of pair cat states in the amplitude damping channel .
this project was supported by the national natural science foundation of china ( project no.10174066 ) .
divincenzo , science * 270 * , 255 ( 1995 ) ; l.k .
grover , phys .
lett . * 79*(2 ) , 325 ( 1997 ) ; a. ekert and r. jozsa , phil .
a * 356 * , 1769 ( 1998 ) ; r. jozsa , in _ the geometric universe _ , edited by s. huggett , l. mason , k.p .
tod , s.t .
tsou , and n.m.j .
woodhouse ( oxford university press , oxford , 1998 ) , p.369 .
bennett , g. brassard , and n.d .
mermin , phys .
68*(5 ) , 557 ( 1992 ) ; j. kempe , phys .
a * 60*(2 ) , 910 ( 1999 ) .
bennett , g. brassard , c. crepeau , r. jozsa , a. peres , and w.k .
wootters , phys .
lett . * 70*(13 ) , 1895 ( 1993 ) ; c.h .
bennett , g. brassard , s. popescu , b. schumacher , j.a .
smolin , and w.k .
wootters , phys .
76*(5 ) , 722 ( 1996 ) ; s.l .
braunstein , g. m. dariano , g.j .
milburn , and m.f .
sacchi , phys .
* 84*(15 ) , 3486 ( 2000 ) .
s.l . braunstein and h.j .
kimble , phys .
lett . * 80*(4 ) , 869 ( 1998 ) .
s.l . braunstein and h.j .
kimble , phys .
a * 61 * ( 2000 ) .
bennett , p.w .
shor , j.a .
smolin , and a.v .
thapliyal , phys .
rev . lett . * 83*(15 ) , 3081 ( 1999 ) ; b. schumacher and m.a .
nielsen , phys .
a * 54*(4 ) , 2629 ( 1996 ) .
a. furusawa , j.l .
sorensen , s.l .
braunstein , c.a .
fuchs , h.j .
kimble , and e.s .
polzik , science * 282 * , 706 ( 1998 ) .
d. boschi , s. branca , f.d .
martini , l. hardy , and s. popescu , phys .
lett . * 80*(6 ) , 1121 ( 1998 ) .
rains , ieee trans .
theory * 47 * , 2921 ( 2001 ) .
gerry and r. grobe , phys .
a * 51 * , 1698 ( 1995 ) .
cochrane , g.j .
milburn , and w.j .
munro , phys .
a * 62 * , 062307 ( 2000 ) .
gou , j. steinbach , and p.l .
knight , phys .
a * 54*(5 ) , 4315 ( 1996 ) .
a. peng and a.s .
parkins , phys .
a * 65 * , 062323 ( 2002 ) .
duan , g. giedke , j.i .
cirac , and p. zoller , phys .
lett . * 84 * , 4002 ( 2000 ) ; t. opatrny , g. kurizki , and d .-
welsch , phys .
a * 61 * , 032302 ( 2000 ) ; s. parker , s. bose , and m.b .
plenio , phys . rev . a * 61 * , 032305 ( 2000 ) .
v. vedral and m.b .
plenio , phys .
rev . a * 57*,1619 ( 1998 ) .
agarwal , phys .
. lett . * 57 * , 827 ( 1986 ) ; j. opt .
b * 5 * , 1940 ( 1988 ) .
m. reid and l. krippner , phys .
a * 47 * , 552 ( 1993 ) .
w. j. munro , k. nemoto , g. j. milburn , and s. l. braunstein , phys .
a * 66 * , 023819 ( 2002 ) .
li , j .- b .
xu , phys .
a * 309 * , 321 ( 2003 ) . t. hiroshima , phys .
a * 63 * , 022305 ( 2001 ) .
x.b . wang , m. keiji , t. akihisa , phys .
lett . * 87 * , 137903 ( 2001 ) .
m. horodecki , p. horodecki , phys .
a * 59 * , 4206 ( 1999 ) .
noh , a. fougeres , and l. mandel , phys .
* 67 * , 1426 ( 1991 ) ; phys .
a * 45 * , 424 ( 1992 ) .
a. luis and l.l .
sanchezsoto , phys .
a * 48 * , 4702 ( 1993 ) ; * 53 * , 495 ( 1996 ) .
x.b zou , k. pahlke , and w. mathis , phys .
a * 68 * , 043819 ( 2003 ) .
wiseman , ph.d .
thesis , the university of queensland ( 1994 ) .
e. rains , phys .
a * 60 * , 179 ( 1999 ) . | the entanglement of pair cat states in the phase damping channel is studied by employing the relative entropy of entanglement .
it is shown that the pair cat states can always be distillable in the phase damping channel .
furthermore , we analyze the fidelity of teleportation for the pair cat states by using joint measurements of the photon - number sum and phase difference
. + pacs number : 03.67.-a , 03.65.ud , 42.50.dv |
the fomalhaut debris system is a natural laboratory for testing planet formation theories .
the nearby ( 7.69 pc , * ? ? ?
* ) a3v star @xcite is surrounded by an eccentric debris ring with a peak brightness in scattered optical light at a semi - major axis @xmath0 au ( * ? ? ?
* henceforth k05 ) . the inner edge is sharply truncated , which , along with the ring s eccentricity , suggests that a planet is shaping the ring s morphology @xcite .
a candidate for the reputed planet ( fom b ) has been discovered in the optical @xcite .
the observations are consistent with a super - earth mass planet embedded in a planetesimal swarm @xcite .
independent of direct detection of any planet , observations of the ring s morphology can constrain the dynamical history of the fomalhaut system , including properties of any planets near the ring . the effect of radiation pressure on a dust grain
s orbital eccentricity , assuming an initially circular orbit , is @xmath1 , where @xmath2 is the grain s internal density and @xmath3 the grain radius .
@xcite . here ,
we present high - resolution 850 @xmath4 alma images that resolve the northern section of fomalhaut s ring .
fomalhaut s ring was observed using alma cycle 0 in the compact configuration , measuring projected baselines from 14 to 175 m ( table [ table : obs ] ) .
centered on the expected position of fom b at ra = 22h:57m:38.65s and @xmath5 = -29d:37:12.6 ( j2000 , proper motion included ) .
the total on - source integration time was 140 min .
the observations were taken at 357 and 345 ghz ( in the upper and lower sidebands ) using the frequency domain mode in dual polarization with @xmath61875 mhz bandpasses ( 2 in each of the sidebands ) .
neptune was used as an absolute flux calibrator , and j1924 - 292 for bandpass calibration .
atmospheric variations at each antenna were monitored continuously using water vapor radiometers ( wvr ) , as well as regular hot / ambient load measurements . for time - dependent gain calibration ,
the nearby quasar j2258 - 279 was observed every 8 minutes .
data were reduced using casa 3.4 @xcite : calibration involved removing the effects of rapid atmospheric variations at each antenna using the wvr data , correcting the time- and frequency - dependence of system temperature , and correcting for the complex antenna - based bandpass and time - dependent gain .
amplitude calibration used the casa butler - jpl - horizons 2010 model for neptune , which gives an estimated systematic flux uncertainty of @xmath710% .
the calibrated measurement set was spectrally binned to a channel spacing of 49mhz , and then cleaned using the cotton - schwab algorithm , combining all channels to give the final continuum image .
the primary beam correction was performed using the voltage pattern for an airy function in with an effective dish diameter of 10.7 m , a blockage diameter of 0.75 m , a maximum radius of @xmath8 , and a reference frequency of 1 ghz .observing log : target fomalhaut s ring and fomalhaut b. the precipitable water vapor ( pwv ) is given in mm .
[ table : obs ] [ cols="<,<,^,^,^ " , ]
+ in figure 1 we present the cleaned and primary beam - corrected images . we refer to these as the uncorrected and corrected images , respectively . in the uncorrected image ,
the peak brightness is @xmath9 , the total flux density of the image is 20.5 mjy , and the rms is @xmath10 ( 0.32 mk ) .
flux densities are only expected to be good to about 10% . ] .
the corrected image shows all emission to 7% power , which includes the ring and all apparent emission related to the star .
the total flux in the corrected image is 45.5 mjy . the projected image accounts for approximately half of the ring , so assuming equal brightness for the second half and accounting for the expected contribution from the star ( 3 mjy ) , we find a total flux density of @xmath11 mjy , reasonably consistent with previous measurements ( @xmath12 and @xmath13 mjy * ?
* ; * ? ? ?
_ almost all of the emission is confined to a thin ring . _ the ring s surface brightness reaches a maximum of @xmath14 near the _ ansa _ and remains bright through the inferred apocenter .
there also appears to be a reduction in the ring brightness to the sw .
we will discuss the significance of these azimuthal variations below .
the star s peak brightness is @xmath15 and has a flux density @xmath16 mjy ( 3 mjy expected ) , which suggests possible excess emission .
we caution that the measurement of total stellar flux is strongly dependent on the pbc .
nonetheless , a detection of excess emission is consistent with the results of @xcite .
the pbc error would need to be 47% at the 10% power point to account for the excess , more than 4 times the alma beam specification which has yet to be completely verified . without the second _ ansa _ , we can not reliably determine the ellipse .
we show in figure 1 two ellipse segments that are based on fits to optical images ( k05).the center for both ellipses , denoted by the plus sign , is 0.29 w and 1.7 n of the star .
the ellipses have a @xmath17 and a position angle ( @xmath18 ) . assuming the ellipses represent sky - projected circles
, the red ellipse has an inclination of @xmath19 ( k05 ) and the blue @xmath20 , which more closely corresponds to our best - fit sky models ( below ) .
surface brightness profiles of the ring ( fig . 2 ) are taken along the 7 slices shown in figure 1 using bilinear interpolation .
each slice can be fit by a single gaussian except slice 4 , which requires a double gaussian due to elongated emission .
altogether the slices , excluding slice 4 , have a combined fwhm @xmath21 , corresponding to a projected parent body width @xmath22 au , well - resolved by the synthesized beam .
deprojected slices through the corrected and uncorrected images at the ring s _ ansa _ are shown in figure 2 , which includes all points within @xmath23 of the pa .
the @xmath24 and @xmath25 for the corrected and uncorrected profiles , respectively .
the surface brightness in the corrected image peaks at @xmath26 ( 141.5 au ) .
the peak is similar to that found for the small grains seen in the optical light radial brightness profile ( k05 ) , but the mm grains are much more tightly confined , consistent with radiation pressure effects .
we estimate the mm grain mass by assuming the ring is optically thin and comprised of grains with @xmath27 mm and @xmath28 g / cc .
the grain temperature @xmath29 , where @xmath30 k and @xmath31 are the stellar temperature and radius @xcite , respectively . at @xmath32
au , @xmath33 k. the ring s total flux density of 82 mjy ( excluding the expected 3 mjy from the star ) , so @xmath34 .
if collisions are the main removal mechanism of mm grains , then a lower limit can be placed on the parent body mass @xmath35 for ring age @xmath36 and mm - grain collision timescale @xmath37 . the vertical optical depth through the ring
can be estimated by @xmath38 .
the peak of the ring s surface brightness is @xmath39 .
the synthesized beam effective area is @xmath40 at 7.69 pc . for @xmath27 mm and @xmath41 , @xmath42 . at 140 au
, @xmath43 myr . combined with the above mass estimate
, the ring should be losing mass at a rate of @xmath44 @xmath45 , the best - fit models with a gaussian distribution have a scale height corresponding to an opening angle of @xmath46 , a @xmath47 au , and an inner radial half - maximum at @xmath48 au . models with @xmath49 and a total flux density of 80 mjy
are preferred .
most of the dimming in the sw is consistent with a loss of sensitivity ( fig . 1 ) .
the appearance of a hole may be due to brightening in the southern - most part of the ring , which may be due to noise .
the ne is not subtracted in the residual image ( fig . 1 , bottom - right ) and contains contiguous excess surface brightness .
the star is also not well - subtracted , suggesting possible excess .
some of the extended surface brightness noted in slice 4 of fig .
1 remains , but is consistent with a high - noise peak .
some select , steep power law surface density profiles are also consistent with the data .
these are limited to a surface density @xmath50 , an inner edge of @xmath51 au , an opening angle @xmath52 , and a preferred @xmath53 .
for these power laws , the half - maximum width is about 11.4 au . ,
title="fig:",width=302 ] , title="fig:",width=302 ]
any formation mechanism for fomalhaut s ring must address the following constraints : ( a ) the ring has an eccentricity @xmath54 .
( b ) the vertical scale height of the parent bodies is consistent with an opening angle of @xmath55 from the midplane .
( c ) the fwhm of the parent bodies for the gaussian model is @xmath56 au , giving a width - to - height aspect ratio @xmath57 .
( d ) the outer edge of the parent bodies is consistent with being as sharply truncated as the inner edge .
( e ) the micron grains are more radially extended than the parent bodies , but this is satisfied for a variety of models due to radiation pressure .
we consider three formation models .
one is that the ring is sculpted by a single interior planet @xcite . to account for requirement ( d )
, this solution requires an abrupt truncation of the outer disk through , for example , a stellar flyby @xcite .
we will return to this scenario below .
another possible model is that the ring is a remnant from a collision between two planets @xcite .
unless constrained , the radial width of the ring will slowly spread due to collisions between ring particles with different semi - major axes .
take the vertical velocity dispersion @xmath58 for keplerian orbital speed @xmath59 .
if the radial velocity dispersion is of the same order , then the typical @xmath60 difference between two colliding particles is @xmath61 to factors of order unity , which for free eccentricity @xmath62 is the scale height of the disk , @xmath63 .
the effective collisional viscosity of the ring @xmath64 . using a scale height of 2.5 au and a collisional time between mm grains of 2 myr , @xmath65 @xmath66/s , which means the ring is diffusing on timescales @xmath67 myr .
if the ring is younger than the star , no planetary influence is necessary apart from the dynamics that led to the collision .
however , shattering gravitationally bound objects requires impact speeds several times the mutual escape speed ( @xmath68 , for bodies with masses @xmath69 and @xmath70 and radii @xmath71 and @xmath72 ) .
@xcite .
finally , we propose a third formation model in which the ring s morphology is dominated by shepherd planets , analogous to the shepherd moons cordelia and ophelia of uranus s @xmath73 ring @xcite . here , the ring is confined by angular momentum exchange between ring particles and the planets .
we explore this possibility with n - body simulations , using the bulirsch - stoer algorithm in mercury @xcite . in each simulation ,
two planets of mass @xmath74 and @xmath75 are placed at @xmath76 and @xmath77 .
their relative inclinations are set to zero .
planet eccentricities are set to force the planetesimals ( see method in * ? ? ?
* ) at @xmath78 to have the eccentricity observed for the ring ( @xmath79 ) .
for each run , @xmath80 massless particles are placed between @xmath81 and @xmath82 with a surface density profile @xmath83 , where @xmath84 and @xmath85 .
the integrations run for @xmath86 years .
massless particles are removed from simulations if the particle collides with a planet or if its radius from the star exceeds @xmath87 .
the masses of the planets set the steepness and skew of the ring s radial profile ( fig .
mutual perturbations will cause the system to evolve , which narrows parameter space by demanding that interactions between the planets do not destroy the ring . in the massless ring - particle limit , either both planets must be @xmath88 , or they must have an extreme mass ratio .
the planets do not need to be in resonance . a super - earth and a mars - mass planet produce the most narrowly - peaked gaussian for the radial parent body distribution among the simulations presented here .
as the masses for shepherd candidates are comparable to the _ minimum _ estimated parent body mass in the ring , self - gravity of the ring may play a role in the system s evolution .
if the scattered optical light observations have detected fom b , then the candidate could be the innermost shepherd , although there is a discrepancy of @xmath89 au between fom b s proposed @xmath60 and the inner shepherd in our models .
fomalhaut s debris has some similarities to the kuiper belt .
both systems are thin rings , @xmath90 , which seem to owe their morphologies , at least in part , to the presence of planets .
there are nonetheless substantial differences .
the outer edge of the kuiper belt is near the 2:1 resonance with neptune @xcite . for the outer edge of fomalhaut s ring to be at the 2:1 resonance with an interior planet
, the planet would need to have an @xmath91 au . to truncate the ring at this location
, the planet would need to be @xcite and could have been decected by _ spitzer _
if the ring had formed due to outward migration of an interior planet , we would expect particles to be trapped in resonances , like the plutinos in the 3:2 resonance with neptune .
we detect only a single ring .
the kuiper belt has a dynamically hot and cold population with gaussian widths @xmath92 and @xmath93 , respectively @xcite .
while the kuiper belt object inclination distribution seems to be consistent with truncation due to a stellar flyby @xcite , fomalhaut s parent body population may be too cold to be explained by this mechanism .
this leads us to favor shepherd planets as the explanation for the ring s morphology .
we thank paul kalas and alma naasc for technical support .
a.c.bs support was provided under contract with the california institute of technology funded by nasa through the sagan fellowship program . m.j.p.s and
e.c.b.s contributions are supported by the national science foundation ( nsf ) under grant no .
m.s.s support was provided in part by the national radio astronomy observatory ( nrao ) through award sospa0 - 007 .
the nrao is a facility of the nsf operated under cooperative agreement by associated universities , inc .
this paper makes use of the following data from the atacama large millimeter / submillimeter array ( alma ) : ads / jao.alma#2011.0.00191.s .
the joint alma observatory is a partnership of the european organization for astronomical research in the southern hemisphere , the national astronomical observatory of japan ( on behalf of the national institutes of natural sciences and academia sinica ) , and the nrao ( managed by associated universities , inc . on behalf of the nsf and the national research council of canada ) in cooperation with the republic of chile .
, j. p. , waters , b. , schiebel , d. , young , w. , & golap , k. 2007 , in astronomical society of the pacific conference series , vol .
376 , astronomical data analysis software and systems xvi , ed .
r. a. shaw , f. hill , & d. j. bell , 127 | optical images trace micron - sized grains , which are strongly affected by stellar radiation and need not coincide with their parent body population . here
we present alma 350 ghz observations of the fomalhaut debris ring .
these observations demonstrate that the parent body population is 13 - 19 au wide with a sharp inner and outer boundary .
we discuss three possible origins for the ring , and suggest that debris confined by shepherd planets is the most consistent with the ring s morphology . |
the term ` back - reaction ' is often used in cosmology to mean ` the effect that structure has on the large - scale evolution of the universe , and observations made within it ' .
implicit within this statement are a number of fundamental problems that have yet to be fully understood .
these include : * what is meant by the large - scale expansion of space in an inhomogeneous universe , and how should it be calculated ? * how should we link the large - scale expansion of an inhomogeneous space - time with the observations made within it ? *
how can we create relativistic cosmological models sophisticated enough to investigate these problems ?
let us now briefly consider each of these points , before moving on to discuss recent attempts to understand them .
point 1 above alludes to the fact that in relativistic theories what we mean by the spatial separation of any two astrophysical objects depends on how we choose to foliate the universe with hyper - surfaces of constant time . in a spatially homogeneous universe , or a universe with an irrotational matter content
, natural - looking choices might present themselves . in general , however , we should be free to make any number of choices .
this then presents a problem : if the distance between any two astrophysical objects is in general foliation dependent , and we have no preferred foliation , then how should we go about defining the rate of change of distance between objects , and hence the expansion of the universe ? in the end , the answer to this question will depend on exactly what one is trying to achieve , and is complicated considerably by the fact that in cosmology one is often interested in non - local averages ( a notoriously difficult concept to define in general relativity ) . below we will consider several different cases of interest .
point 2 is a subsequent problem that needs to be addressed , once a concept of ` large - scale expansion ' exists that one is prepared to consider .
it is not in general the case that observations made in an inhomogeneous geometry will have a straightforward correspondence with the observables that one would measure in a spatially homogeneous and isotropic universe with the same rate of expansion on large scales .
that is , even if one succeeds in finding a good description for the large - scale expansion of the universe , then one still needs to do further work in order to relate this to observations made in the underlying inhomogeneous space - time . once again , this is complicated considerably by the fact that we are often interested in the average of observables .
this is in general a highly non - trivial problem , and below we will review some recent progress towards understanding it .
finally , point 3 is related to the fact that in order to test proposed solutions to the problems posed in points 1 and 2 it is of considerable interest to have cosmological models that are sophisticated enough to allow at least some of the interesting behavior that we expect in general .
this is an extremely difficult problem .
although many inhomogeneous cosmological solutions to einstein s equations are known@xcite , most of these solutions are restricted either because they are required to exhibit a high degree of symmetry , or because they are algebraically special .
constructions such as the swiss cheese " models allow some potential progress to be made , but are themselves severely restricted by the boundary conditions at the edge of each hole " .
new approaches are required to make further progress in this area , and , once again , we will discuss some recent progress below .
in section [ space ] we consider approaches based on averaging over a set of prescribed spatial hyper - surfaces . in section [ spacetime ]
we consider approaches based on averaging in four dimensions .
section [ models ] contains a discussion of some models that may be of use for studying averaging , and in section [ discussion ] we provide a few closing comments .
one way to proceed with the study of back - reaction is to consider the expansion of regions of space in a given foliation . the equations that govern this expansion can then be found , and compared to the friedmann equations .
this often leads one to consider the volume - weighted average of quantities such as energy density and pressure .
the equations that result are therefore often referred to as the ` averaged field equations ' . while simple , this approach has a number of obvious drawbacks .
firstly , it is manifestly not foliation invariant . secondly , there is a freedom in how one chooses to specify that two spatial volumes at different times are the same region . and
thirdly , the averaging of quantities over the spatial volume being considered is often only well defined for scalars .
one can specify choices for the first and second of these that may initially appear natural , but that could in the end lead one to consider hyper - surfaces in the inhomogeneous space - time that become arbitrarily , and increasingly , distorted .
the third of these problems is of more fundamental difficulty , as tensors can not in general be compared at different points .
nevertheless , this approach provides a useful framework to investigate , and can be shown to give a straightforward correspondance to the average of observables in some situations .
the most well studied set of averaged equations that result from this approach are those found by buchert after averaging the hamiltonian , raychaudhuri and conservation equations @xcite : @xmath0 where @xmath1 and @xmath2 are the scale factor " and average ricci curvature of the region of space @xmath3 being considered , angular brackets denote a volume average throughout that region , and @xmath4 is the back - reaction term that quantifies differences from the friedmann equations that one might otherwise construct from these quantities .
these are defined as @xmath5 where @xmath6 and @xmath7 are the expansion and volume - preserving shear of the set of curves orthogonal to the hyper - surfaces containing @xmath3 , and @xmath8 and @xmath9 are the proper time measured along this set of curves and the spatial coordinates in the hyper - surfaces of constant @xmath8 , respectively .
the quantity @xmath10 is the value of @xmath8 on some reference hyper - surface ( usually taken to be the one that contains us at present ) .
one may note that equations ( [ buchert1])-([buchert3 ] ) do not form a closed set .
extra information is therefore required , which can be given by specifying @xmath11 .
presumably this requires either extra equations , or some knowledge of the inhomogeneous space - time being averaged .
as previously stated , one may also note that the averaging procedure given here by the angular brackets is foliation dependent and only applicable to scalars ( this is particularly problematic for the term @xmath12 in equation ( [ q ] ) , as the evolution equation for @xmath13 will contain tensors ) .
finally , while the expansion of the spatial domain @xmath3 may not itself be directly observable , we will explain below that in some cases it can be linked to observables . the term ` observables ' can cover a wide array of different possibilities in cosmology . here
we will mainly be concerned with the luminosity distance - redshift relation .
this is itself a direct observable of considerable interest for the interpretation of , for example , supernova observations . beyond this
, it is also often required in the interpretation of other observables as it is very often the case that one needs to transform from redshift space " to some concept of position space ( i.e. the position of astrophysical objects on some spatial hyper - surface ) .
the usual method for calculating luminosity distances in an inhomogeneous space - time is to first find the angular diameter distance to the emitting object as a function of some affine parameter , measuring distance along past - directed null geodesics .
this can be achieved by integrating the sachs optical equations@xcite . in these equations
the ricci curvature of the space - time sources the evolution of the expansion of the past - directed null geodesics , and the weyl curvature sources the evolution of their volume - preserving shear ( which itself acts as a source for their expansion ) .
the angular - diameter distance can then be straightforwardly related to the luminosity distance@xcite , and the redshift can be calculated as a function of the affine distance ( once the world - lines of the objects emitting the radiation have been specified ) .
this then provides the luminosity distance as a function of redshift at all points on an observer s past - light cone , provided that geometric optics remains a good approximation , and that the light emitted from the distant object is not obscured by some intermediate matter before it reaches the observer .
although the method outlined above is , in general , a complicated problem involving a number of subtleties , it was recently shown by rsnen@xcite that progress can be made in space - times that display statistical homogeneity and isotropy on large scales . in this case
one can estimate the average luminosity distance as a function of the average redshift that an observer in such a space - time may expect to reconstruct from observations made over cosmologically interesting distances . assuming that the matter content is irrotational , that the shear in the null trajectories can safely be assumed to be small , that structures evolve slowly , and that hyper - surfaces of constant proper time can also be taken to be the same hyper - surfaces that display statistical homogeneity and isotropy , rsnen made a convincing case that the average luminosity distance - redshift relation in the inhomogeneous space - time should be well approximated by observables calculated in a homogeneous and isotropic model with a scale factor that evolves according to equations ( [ buchert1])-([buchert3 ] ) .
an alternative approach to this problem was taken by clarkson and umeh@xcite .
these authors considered expressions for measures of distance expanded as a power series in redshift , as derived for general space - times by kristian and sachs@xcite .
they then performed a decomposition into spherical harmonics , and constructed the following deceleration parameter , based on an analogy between the monopole of this expansion and the corresponding relations in a friedmann universe : @xmath14_0,\ ] ] where @xmath15 is the isotropic part of the hubble rate , and subscript ` @xmath16 ' denotes a quantity evaluated at @xmath17 . using this expression they could consider the average deceleration within either a region of space , or a region of space - time
however , for matter obeying the strong - energy condition it can be seen from equation ( [ cu ] ) that the average of @xmath18 will always be non - negative , and so the space - time ( according to this measure ) will always be inferred to be decelerating ( in the absence of @xmath19 ) .
this is in contrast to the averaged evolutions possible from equations ( [ buchert1])-([buchert3 ] ) , and at first glance would appear to contradict the results of rsnen described above .
in fact , there is no contradiction between these two sets of results@xcite .
that is , the observable calculated by clarkson and umeh should be expected to be a good approximation to the deceleration that one would infer from observations made within a small region around an observer .
this measure is closely related to the acceleration of space within that region , as specified by einstein s equations ( as long as shear is small ) , and not by equations ( [ buchert1])-([buchert3 ] ) .
the observational measures considered by rsnen , however , are only expected to approach the evolution described by equations ( [ buchert1])-([buchert3 ] ) when the distances over which observations are made are much larger than the homogeneity scale of the space - time under consideration .
this is , of course , the regime in which cosmological observations are usually made .
using example space - times it has been explicitly demonstrated that it is entirely possible for a set of observers in a given region of the universe to infer deceleration from clarkson and umeh s measure , while inferring acceleration from buchert s measure@xcite .
this clearly demonstrates that the acceleration inferred from cosmological observations does _ not _ have to be closely related to the local acceleration of space itself .
it also demonstrates that quantities that are uniquely defined in an exactly homogeneous and isotropic universe ( such as @xmath18 ) can bifurcate into multiple different quantities in space - times that are only statistically homogeneous and isotropic , and that in general these new quantities can take very different values from each other .
one must therefore proceed with care .
an alternative approach to considering the volume weighted average of quantities within 3-dimensional spatial regions is to instead consider averaging geometric quantities within 4-dimensional regions of space - time .
such a process is in general difficult to define in a covariant way , and so far has required the application of bi - local operators .
these allow tensors to be compared at different points by transporting them along prescribed sets of curves .
this then leads to the problems of how the curves in question should be prescribed , and exactly which transport method should be used .
various proposals exist as to the best way to address these issues@xcite . while complicated , the idea of averaging quantities in 4-dimensional regions of space - time inherently avoids any foliation dependence .
these approaches are also often aimed at averaging tensors directly , rather than just scalars .
this has obvious advantages for gravitational theories constructed from tensors , such as general relativity .
probably the most well known attempt at averaging in space - time , and constructing a set of effective field equations that the averages should obey , is that of zalaletdinov@xcite . the first step in this approach is to construct the following average for a tensor @xmath20 : @xmath21 where primed coordinates are those used in the 4-dimensional region @xmath22 , which is the averaging domain associated with the point @xmath23 .
the quantities @xmath24 are the bi - local operators , which are functions of both @xmath23 and @xmath25 , and the quantity @xmath26 is the volume of @xmath22 . each point , @xmath23 ,
is expected to have associated with it its own averaging domain , @xmath22 , which is related to other averaging domains by being transported around the manifold . by applying this averaging technique to the connection , and by using some `` splitting rules ''
, zalaletdinov is able to use einstein s equations to derive a set of field equations that the averaged connection must obey .
the are called the macroscopic field equations , and are written@xcite @xmath27 where bars denote averaged quantities , and @xmath28 and @xmath29 and @xmath30}$ ] , where @xmath31 } \rangle - \langle \gamma^{\alpha}_{\phantom{\alpha } \beta [ \gamma } \rangle \langle \gamma^{\mu}_{\phantom{\mu } \underline{\nu } \sigma ] } \rangle , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and where underlined indices are not included in symmetrization operations .
the tensor @xmath32 is known as the 2-point correlation tensor , and obeys its own algebraic and differential constraints@xcite . the macroscopic field equations ( [ mg ] )
can be used to describe the behavior of a particular inhomogeneous space - time after averaging has been performed , but they can also be used as a set of field equations to which one can look for solutions directly .
this latter approach has so far been taken in the cases of macroscopic geometries , @xmath33 , that are spatially homogeneous and isotropic@xcite , and geometries that are spherically symmetric and static@xcite .
this work has allowed some possible behaviors of averaged space - times to be found _ without _ specifying the underlying microscopic geometry .
however , it has also so far required a number of assumptions to be made about the correlations that are present .
these include the vanishing of the three - point and four - point correlation tensors , and the vanishing of the ` electric ' part of the 2-point correlation tensor@xcite .
the particular situations in which these assumptions are valid remains to be determined , as is also the case for the assumptions that go into the derivation of the macroscopic field equations ( [ mg ] ) . nevertheless , this is an interesting approach that deserves further study . under the assumption that the macroscopic geometry is spatially homogeneous and isotropic ( that is , after the averaging procedure has been applied , and the averaged " geometry displays these symmetries ) , then coley , pelavas and zalaletdinov find the following to be a solution of the macroscopic field equations ( [ mg])@xcite : @xmath34,\ ] ] where @xmath35 is a constant , and where @xmath36 and @xmath37 obeys the friedmann - like equations @xmath38 where @xmath39 is a constant ( not necessarily equal to @xmath35 ) , and where @xmath37 and @xmath40 are the macroscopic energy density and pressure ( obtained after averaging the right - hand side of einstein s equations ) .
superficially , the geometry given in equations ( [ mgfrw])-([mgdrho ] ) looks a lot like the spatially homogeneous and isotropic solutions of einstein s equations in the presence of a perfect fluid .
there is , however , a very significant difference : the spatial curvature constant that appears in the macroscopic geometry , @xmath35 , is not in general the same as the term that looks like spatial curvature in the friedmann - like equation ( [ mgfried ] ) ( i.e. the one that contains @xmath39 ) .
that is , spatially curvature can take different values depending on the situation being considered . if one measured the angles at the corners of triangle , and determined the curvature of space in this way , then this would give a different result to that which would be obtained by measuring the recessional velocities of astrophysical objects and inferring the spatial curvature through the dynamical ( friedmann - like ) equation ( [ mgfried ] ) .
this behavior is impossible within the spatially homogeneous and isotropic solutions of einstein s equations , and so could provide some potentially observable phenomena that could be used to test this approach .
the difference between @xmath35 and @xmath39 is determined by terms that appear in the correlation tensor , @xmath32 , and so by attempting to determine the difference between @xmath35 and @xmath39 observationally we could attempt to constrain @xmath32 , and hence some of the possible effects of averaging .
a first step towards investigating this possibility has recently been taken@xcite .
the authors of this work assume that average observables are determined by null trajectories in the average geometry , as specified in equation ( [ mgfrw ] ) , and that redshifts are represented by the average scale factor , @xmath36 .
they then find that luminosity distances are given by the following equation : @xmath41 where the matter content of the macroscopic space - time has been assumed to be well approximated by non - interacting dust and @xmath19 , where @xmath42 , and where the @xmath43 are defined as @xmath44 where @xmath45 is the present energy density in dust , and @xmath46 is the effective energy density in @xmath19 .
the expression for luminosity distance given in equation ( [ mgdl ] ) can now be used to interpret cosmological observations , and to obtain constraints on the @xmath43 . using data from the hubble space telescope ( hst)@xcite , the wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe ( wmap)@xcite , observations of the baryon acoustic oscillations ( baos)@xcite , and the union2@xcite and sdss@xcite supernova data sets , the parameters @xmath47 , @xmath48 and @xmath49 were constrained to take the values given in table [ table1 ] below@xcite .
the additional freedom of allowing @xmath50 in this analysis means that the cmb+@xmath51 is now no longer sufficient to constrain the spatial curvature of the universe significantly .
observations of the cmb+@xmath51 alone are also no longer sufficient to require @xmath52 .
this simple extra degree of freedom therefore undermines two of the most important results of modern observational cosmology . by adding further data sets the constraints on @xmath47 and @xmath48
are improved , but still remain much weaker than in the standard friedmann models that satisfy einstein s equations .
even so , however , it was still found that the results of using all available observables were sufficient to require @xmath53 to high confidence , and that a spatially flat universe was consistent with observations .
finally , although the combination of _ some _ data sets excluded the possibility @xmath54 at the 95% confidence level , it was found that the special case @xmath54 was compatible with _ most _ combinations of these data sets . in general one might also consider the possibility of not just allowing @xmath47 and @xmath48 to be different , but also allowing them to functions of scale .
such a result might arise , for example , from performing averaging over domains of different sizes , a process which is implicitly carried out when consider different cosmological observables .
such a possibility allows for considerable extra freedom@xcite .
we have so far considered attempts to describe the large - scale behavior of the universe by averaging over regions of space or space - time . in the end
, the particular approach that one should use when performing this type of operation should probably be guided by the phenomena that one is trying to create a model to interpret .
different observable phenomena may require different approaches , and so one needs to know the limits of any particular approach , as well as the situations in which it reliably reproduces the required results .
for this it is useful to have inhomogeneous cosmological models that are of sufficient generality to allow some of the interesting behavior that is expected in general .
such models can then be used to test ideas about averaging , back - reaction , and the large - scale evolution of space .
unfortunately it is extremely difficult to construct such models .
this does _ not _ mean that there is an absence of any interesting behavior to study , only that we need to become more sophisticated in our model building to quantify and constrain the different possibilities in a reliable way .
some of the principal difficulties involved with this are how to model over - dense regions of the universe without having to deal with the rapid formation of singularities , how to introduce structure into the universe without assuming a friedmann background or matching onto a friedmann model at a boundary , and how to allow structure to form on different scales without assuming linearity in the field equations . for further discussion of inhomogeneous cosmological solutions the reader
is referred to the contribution to these proceedings by krasiski @xcite , and to the comprehensive texts @xcite .
it is currently almost beyond hope to construct a model that allows for all of the possibilities discussed above , while simultaneously maintaining sufficiently generality to model realistic distributions of matter .
we are therefore forced to investigate toy models that we hope may reflect some of the features of the real universe , even if they are not realistic in every way .
once toy models have been constructed we can then consider the averaging problem by applying some of the methods discussed above to them , or by fitting or comparing them to friedmann models directly .
their existence also makes more advanced models a more realistic proposition .
it is for these reasons that it is of interest to consider simple @xmath55-body solutions of einstein s equations .
such solutions , if they can be found , will allow over - dense regions to be studied without rapid collapse occurring , and without recourse to the assumption of a friedmann background or linearity in the gravitational field equations .
this will be the subject of section [ bhsec ] .
the simplest configuration of @xmath55 bodies that one can imagine is a regularly arranged set of points .
although such a configuration limits the behaviors that are possible , it does allow for the most straightforward possible comparison to smoothed - out friedmann - like universes .
that is , by ` zooming out ' in order to consider large numbers of points , and by performing some kind of coarse graining or smoothing , one could easily imagine such a situation looking more and more like a spatially homogeneous and isotropic universe , which could then be compared to the friedmann solutions of einstein s equations .
regularity of the distribution also provides a limited number of preferred spatial planes and curves that can have their area and length compared to those of the friedmann solutions . here
we will consider spatially closed universes . these are known to admit hyper - surfaces of time symmetry at the maximum of expansion of the space - time that allow the constraint equations to be solved in a particularly simple way@xcite .
the method that we will deploy to ensure that our massive bodies are regularly arranged is to tile the hyper - surface of maximum expansion with a number of regular polyhedra . a mass is then placed at the center of each polyhedron , which by symmetry will be an equal distance from each of its nearest neighbors .
these polyhedra will be referred to in what follows as ` cells ' .
there are seven such tilings that are possible in three spatial dimensions , as listed in table [ table2 ] . also displayed in this table
are the schlfli symbols of the polychora that these tilings constitute@xcite .
once the arrangement of masses has been chosen , the geometry of the hyper - surface of maximum - of - expansion can be found . with the exception of the 2-cell ,
this has been done for each of the structures described above@xcite .
the 2-cell is special in that the time - symmetric geometry at the maximum of expansion of this structure is simply a slice through the global schwarzschild solution .
the geometry of the full space - time is therefore already known exactly in this case , and is not of cosmological interest here ( by including a non - zero @xmath19 , however , other structures are also possible@xcite ) .
an illustration of the geometry at the maximum of expansion in the case of the 8-cell and the 120-cell is given in figure [ f1 ] , below .
each of the illustrations here corresponds to a single 2-dimensional slice through the 3-dimensional geometry . in the case of the 8-cell
this slice contains 6 masses , while in the 120-cell it contains many more ( although not all 120 ) .
the geometry of the 3-space of maximum of expansion in each case is conformally related to the geometry of a 3-sphere , with a scale factor that is a function of position .
the distance from the origin in the illustrations in figure [ f1 ] is proportional to this scale factor , and it can be seen that as the number of the masses in the lattice is increased , the bulk of the space approaches homogeneity .
it is only in the vicinity of the masses themselves that inhomogeneities exist ( as depicted by the tube - like structures ) .
once we have the geometry of the hyper - surface of maximum of expansion , we can take a measure of the scale of the solution , and compare this to the scale of a spatially closed friedmann universe that contains the same amount of `` proper mass@xcite '' .
the friedmann solutions will , of course , have this mass evenly distributed throughout space , and so by comparing to the scale of the inhomogeneous geometry we can obtain a measure of back - reaction . for the choice of scale in the inhomogeneous space on could choose a number of different measures . here
we consider the proper length of the edge of a cell .
this corresponds to the scale of curvature for the sphere that appears to emerge when the number of masses becomes large ( as can be seen from the illustration in figure [ 120fig ] ) .
the difference in scale in each case is given in the last column of table [ table2 ] .
it can be seen that the broad trend is for the scale of the homogeneous and inhomogeneous space - times to approach each other as the number of cells becomes large .
however , for only a small number of cells ( @xmath56 to @xmath57 ) the difference in scale can be of order @xmath58 .
in any case , this method provides an exact quantification of back - reaction , and provides an arena for testing formalisms designed for more general configurations of energy and momentum .
a numerical evolution of the 8-cell has now been performed@xcite , and other methods have also been used to address problem of understand the evolution of this type of structure@xcite .
various approaches to back - reaction and averaging already exist in the literature , but much work remains to be done if we are to fully understand their observational consequences in the real universe .
motivation for taking these problems seriously comes from the apparent necessity of including dark energy when we interpret observations within a linearly perturbed friedmann model , as well as the requirement to understand all possible sources of error and uncertainty in precision cosmology . to fully address this problem
it is likely that we will need to develop more sophisticated models of inhomogeneous space - times , as well as developing a more sophisticated understanding of averaging in general relativity .
research in this area should be considered exceptionally timely , with large amounts of resources currently being invested into observational probes designed to improve our understanding of dark energy , and the universe around us .
i acknowledge the support of the stfc . | we introduce the concept of back - reaction in relativistic cosmological modeling . roughly speaking ,
this can be thought of as the difference between the large - scale behaviour of an inhomogeneous cosmological solution of einstein s equations , and a homogeneous and isotropic solution that is a best - fit to either the average of observables or dynamics in the inhomogeneous solution .
this is sometimes paraphrased as ` the effect that structure has of the large - scale evolution of the universe ' .
various different approaches have been taken in the literature in order to try and understand back - reaction in cosmology .
we provide a brief and critical summary of some of them , highlighting recent progress that has been made in each case . |
critical phenomena in gravitational collapse were first reported in the seminal work of chopuik @xcite . shortly after this original discovery , which was based on studies of massless scalar fields in spherical symmetry ,
similar behavior was found in other matter models , including vacuum ( i.e. pure gravitational waves ) @xcite , and radiation fluids @xcite ( see the excellent reviews @xcite for a much more comprehensive discussion . ) critical collapse can be observed in the evolution of generic initial data close to the threshold of black - hole formation .
we again refer to @xcite for thorough reviews , and briefly summarize only the most important characteristics here .
consider initial data that are parametrized by some parameter @xmath0 , with the evolution of data with @xmath0 greater than some critical parameter @xmath1 leading to black - hole formation .
close to the critical parameter the following critical phenomena can then be observed in the resulting spacetimes . for @xmath2 ,
the mass of the newly formed black holes scales with @xmath3 where the critical exponent @xmath4 depends on the matter model , but not on the specific choice or parametrization of the initial data . in the strong - field region prior to black - hole formation the spacetime approaches a self - similar critical solution , which again depends on the matter model only . for some matter models , including massless scalar fields
, the critical solution features a discrete self - similarity , while others , including perfect fluids , feature a continuous self - similarity .
numerous studies , both numerical and analytical , have followed up on the above initial reports of critical phenomena .
most of this work , however , has focused on spherical symmetry , where the demand for high spatial resolution of increasingly small features can be met most easily . as a consequence , aspects of critical collapse that can be studied only in the absence of spherical symmetry remain largely unexplored , for example the effects of angular momentum ( but see @xcite , as well as @xcite for a summary of results from perturbative calculations . )
another important question remains unresolved : studying linear perturbations of the spherically symmetric critical solution for scalar fields , martn - garca and gundlach @xcite found that all non - spherical perturbations decay , while choptuik _ et.al .
_ @xcite found numerical evidence for the existence of an aspherical growing mode .
given the richness of the subject , the number of numerical studies of critical collapse in the absence of spherical symmetry is surprisingly small ( some recent examples of numerical studies of critical collapse in the absence of spherical symmetry include @xcite . ) as gundlach and martn - garca observed in their review @xcite , there has been less progress in going beyond spherical symmetry than we anticipated . " in the meantime , numerical relativity simulations in three spatial dimensions have made tremendous progress following the first successful simulations of the inspiral of binary black holes @xcite .
while these newly available codes have been used to study many interesting astrophysical processes , they have rarely been applied to studies of critical collapse ( see @xcite for two examples . )
one possible reason is that most of these codes are based either on cartesian coordinates or more complicated coordinate patches , neither one of which are well suited for simulations of the small spatial structures encountered in critical collapse simulations .
presumably , spherical polar coordinates are better suited to study critical phenomena , in particular the behavior of deviations from the spherically symmetric critical solution ( see , e.g. , the discussion in @xcite . )
we have recently developed a numerical code that solves einstein s equations in spherical polar coordinates @xcite , and in this paper we use this code to study the critical collapse of radiation fluids .
the original discovery of critical phenomena in the collapse of a radiation fluid by evans and coleman @xcite was quickly followed by a number of both analytical ( e.g. @xcite ) and numerical studies ( e.g. @xcite . ) to the best of our knowledge , however , all of these studies were performed under the assumption of spherical symmetry . here
we generalize some of these results by relaxing this assumption ; in particular we compute scaling laws of the form ( [ scaling ] ) for axisymmetric data .
as first discussed in @xcite , the critical solution encountered in the collapse of radiation fluids features a continuous self - similarity ( css ) , rather than the discrete self - similarity found in many other matter models .
we identify this critical solution in our spherically symmetric numerical solutions , and study the approach to this critical solution in our aspherical simulations .
close to criticality , the aspherical solutions perform a damped oscillation around the spherical critical solution in a manner very similar to that described by gundlach @xcite at least for the cases that we considered .
we believe that this is the first confirmation of this behavior in a non - linear numerical simulation .
in addition to analyzing critical phenomena in the collapse of a radiation fluid in the absence of spherical symmetry , this paper serves to test and calibrate the performance of a free ( i.e. unconstrained ) evolution code in the context of critical collapse .
traditionally , most codes used in simulations of critical collapse were specifically designed for that purpose : they made symmetry assumptions , adopted specific slicing conditions ( e.g. maximal or polar slicing ) and used constrained evolution , in which einstein s constraint equations are used to replace at least some of the evolution equations .
many more recently developed codes used in simulations of binary coalescence , on the other hand , are designed very differently : they do not make any symmetry assumptions and use free evolution , in which the constraint equations can be monitored but are not solved .
in general these codes can be run with different slicing and gauge conditions , but the 1+log " and gamma - driver " conditions ( see eqs .
( [ 1+log ] ) and ( [ gamma - driver ] ) below ) have proven particularly useful for simulations of spacetimes containing black holes .
how suitable these codes are for simulations of critical collapse , however , remains a somewhat open question ( see also @xcite for recent discussions . )
our findings here demonstrate that , at least for some matter models , unconstrained evolution codes with the 1+log and gamma - driver coordinate conditions can indeed be used to study critical phenomena .
our paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec : setup ]
we describe the setup of the problem , including a brief description of our numerical methods and the form of our initial data .
we discuss our numerical results in section [ sec : results ] . in section [ sec : ss_centered ] we focus on centered " initial data , which take their maximum density at the origin of the coordinate system .
these simulations allow us to compare directly with the findings of @xcite . in order to study deviations from spherical symmetry
, however , it also makes sense to study off - centered " initial data , which take their maximum away from the origin .
we first consider such data in spherical symmetry in section [ sec : ss_offcenter ] , and then generalize these to axisymmetry in section [ sec : axi ] .
we conclude with a brief discussion in section [ sec : discussion ] .
we also include an appendix with some details on the logarithmic radial grid used in this paper .
in the following we construct numerical solutions of einstein s equations @xmath5 for the stress - energy tensor @xmath6 describing a perfect fluid , where we have adopted geometrized units with @xmath7 . here
@xmath8 is the einstein tensor , @xmath9 is the total energy density , @xmath10 is the pressure , @xmath11 is the fluid four - velocity , and @xmath12 is the spacetime metric . we specialize to a radiation fluid , for which @xmath13 .
we solve einstein s equations ( [ einstein ] ) using the baumgarte - shapiro - shibata - nakamura ( bssn ) formulation @xcite .
the bssn formulation employs a 3 + 1 decomposition of the spacetime , by which the spacetime metric @xmath12 induces a spatial metric @xmath14 on the spatial slices ( see , e.g. , @xcite for a textbook treatment . ) here @xmath15 is the normal on the spatial slice , which , in terms of the lapse function @xmath16 and the shift vector @xmath17 , may be written as @xmath18 ( here and in the following indices @xmath19 denote spacetime indices , while @xmath20 denote spatial indices . )
another important quantity is the extrinsic curvature , which may be written as @xmath21 where @xmath22 denotes the covariant derivative associated with @xmath23 , as well as its trace @xmath24 .
the formalism also adopts a conformal rescaling of the spatial metric @xmath23 , @xmath25 where @xmath26 is the conformal factor and @xmath27 the conformally related metric . in the bssn formalism
the conformal factor is usually written as @xmath28 . in order to implement the bssn formalism in spherical polar coordinates
we also employ a reference - metric approach @xcite .
in such a reference - metric approach , some geometric objects associated with the conformally related metric @xmath27 are expressed in terms of the difference between these objects and their counterparts associated with a reference metric @xmath29 ( see equation ( [ lambda ] ) below for an example ) . for our applications
it is natural to choose @xmath29 to be the flat metric expressed in spherical polar coordinates .
we further scale out appropriate powers of the geometric factors @xmath30 and @xmath31 from all tensorial quantities , so that for regular spacetimes all dynamical variables used in the code remain regular . we do not , however , attempt to regularize the equations , which still contain inverse powers of @xmath30 and @xmath31 and hence become singular at the origin and on the axis .
we adopt a finite - differencing method and evolve the resulting equations with a partially implicit runge - kutta ( pirk ) time integration method @xcite .
details of our numerical implementation can be found in @xcite . for all simulations reported in this paper we impose
moving puncture " coordinate conditions , i.e. the 1+log condition for the lapse function @xmath16 @xmath32 ( see @xcite ) together with a version of a gamma - driver condition @xmath33 with @xmath34 for the shift vector @xmath17 ( see @xcite . ) here the @xmath35 play the role of the conformal connection functions , @xmath36 where @xmath37 and @xmath38 are the connection symbols associated with the conformally related metric @xmath27 and the flat reference metric @xmath29 , respectively .
we solve the fluid equations by applying a similar reference - metric approach to the valencia "- form @xcite of the equations of relativistic hydrodynamics ( see also @xcite . ) for the purposes in this paper the equations simplify , since , for a radiation fluid , the rest density @xmath39 vanishes , and the total energy density @xmath9 is given by the internal energy density alone .
we solve the resulting equations using a high - resolution shock - capturing technique as described in @xcite .
while our code was originally designed for three spatial dimensions without any symmetry assumptions , we here specialize to axisymmetric spacetimes , so that our solutions depend on a radius @xmath30 and an angle @xmath40 only .
we also impose equatorial symmetry , so that we can restrict our computations to one hemisphere . one significant enhancement used in this paper
concerns the radial differencing . while we used a uniform grid in all coordinates in the above references ,
we here allow for a logarithmic grid in the radial directions .
we provide more details on both the grid setup and the finite differencing stencils in appendix [ app : log ] . for the simulations presented in this paper we impose outer boundary conditions at @xmath41 ( in our code units ;
see below ) , and choose each radial grid cell to be larger than its smaller - radius neighbor by a factor of @xmath42 .
we also use two different radial grid resolutions . in what we refer to as
high - resolution `` runs we use @xmath43 , which results in a grid spacing of @xmath44 across the origin ( see fig .
[ fig : grid ] ) and a grid spacing at the outer boundary of 0.634 . to put this into perspective ,
an amr application , in which each refinement level has twice the grid resolution of the previous level , would require about 12 nested grid levels to achieve a similar range in grid resolution . in
our ' ' low - resolution " runs we use @xmath45 , for which @xmath46 , and the grid spacing at the outer boundary is 0.636 .
the structure of our gird is also visible in figs .
[ fig : rho_axi ] and [ fig : omega_profiles ] below .
we start our simulations with initial data that are both conformally flat , i.e. @xmath47 , and time - symmetric , i.e. @xmath48 .
we then specify the initial density distribution as follows , @xmath49 where we have abbreviated @xmath50 and where @xmath51 is the second - order legendre polynomial . in the above expression
, @xmath52 parameterizes the overall amplitude of the density , while @xmath53 determines deviations from spherical symmetry . in @xmath54
we have multiplied the ( isotropic ) radius @xmath30 with the square of the conformal factor , @xmath55 , so that , in spherical symmetry , the product can be identified with the areal radius @xmath56 .
the density distribution is then centered on an areal radius of approximately @xmath57 , while its length - scale is approximately @xmath58 . in the following
we will consider different choices for @xmath52 , @xmath53 and @xmath57 , but will always use @xmath59 , which determines our code units . in the following , all dimensional quantities are expressed in units of @xmath58 .
the density distribution ( [ rho_init ] ) depends on the conformal factor , which is found by solving the hamiltonian constraint @xmath60 in practice we iterate between the two equations ( [ rho_init ] ) and ( [ hamiltonian ] ) until convergence has been achieved . for spherically symmetric and centered data , i.e. @xmath61
, the density distribution ( [ rho_init ] ) reduces to @xmath62 which is the initial density distribution adopted in @xcite ( see their equation ( 6 ) . ) the total gravitational mass @xmath63 can then be computed analytically , @xmath64 which shows that @xmath65 serves as a non - dimensional measure of the strength of the gravitational fields . in generalizing the density ( [ evanscoleman ] ) to the aspherical distributions ( [ rho_init ] ) we have introduced extra factors that ensure that the density is smooth at the origin .
finally , we initialize the lapse function @xmath16 and the shift vector @xmath17 according to @xmath66
, interpolated to the center at @xmath69 , as a function of time @xmath70 , for spherically symmetric ( @xmath67 ) and centered ( @xmath68 ) initial data .
we include results for two values of the parameter @xmath52 that bracket the critical value @xmath71.,width=336 ] we start our discussion with spherically symmetric ( @xmath67 ) and centered ( @xmath68 ) data .
as explained above , the initial data ( [ rho_init ] ) then reduce to those of evans and coleman @xcite , but we evolve these data with a completely independent numerical code , and different coordinate conditions . for all simulations shown in this section we used a `` high - resolution '' grid ( see section [ subsec : basics ] for details . )
we perform numerical simulations for numerous different values of @xmath52 and , as expected , find that the simulations result in black - hole formation for sufficiently large values of this parameter . in fig .
[ fig : lapse_centered ] , for example , we show examples for two values of @xmath52 that , at least for the grid set - up used in these simulations , bracket the critical value @xmath71 .
the two values of @xmath52 are so similar that , at early times , the two resulting curves are indistinguishable . at late times
, however , the lapse evolves very differently . in the subcritical case ( @xmath72 )
the lapse returns to approximately unity as the matter is dispersing to infinity , leaving behind flat space , while in the supercritical case ( @xmath73 ) the lapse drops to approximately zero , which is an indication of black - hole formation .
we plot values that are interpolated to the origin at @xmath74 . this fourth - order interpolation using grid points on both sides of the origin leads to spuriously negative values after a black hole has formed , even though the lapse remains positive on all grid points . ]
this bracketing of the critical parameter @xmath71 is in excellent agreement with the findings of @xcite , who reported @xmath75 .
unless the forming black hole is too small in comparison to our grid resolution , we can also detect the newly forming apparent horizon with our apparent horizon finder , and compute an approximate black - hole mass from the proper area of this apparent horizon . for @xmath73
, for example , we found that an apparent horizon forms at a coordinate radius of about 2.94 @xmath76 , meaning that the interior of the black hole is covered by only 11 grid points ( on our `` high - resolution '' grid . ) accordingly , our error in the masses of small black holes is rather large . for larger black holes ,
the apparent horizon grows a little after it first forms , as more matter falls into the black hole , but then settles down to an approximately constant value , which we take as the black hole mass @xmath77 . for subcritical evolutions ( top panel ) , and
the black hole mass @xmath77 for supercritical evolutions ( bottom panel ) , for spherically symmetric ( @xmath67 ) and centered ( @xmath68 ) data .
the crosses denote our numerical results , while the solid lines represent the fits ( [ mass_scaling ] ) and ( [ rho_scaling ] ) .
the dashed line in the inset shows the gravitational mass ( [ adm_mass]).,width=336 ] in the bottom panel of fig .
[ fig : scaling_centered ] we graph these black hole masses @xmath77 for supercritical evolutions ( @xmath78 ) as a function of @xmath79 . here
we have determined the critical parameter @xmath80 by fitting our numerical values to the scaling law @xmath81 which is included in the figure as a solid line .
this fit also suggests @xmath82 , in good agreement with the value of @xmath83 reported by @xcite .
we note , however , that our black hole masses are smaller than those reported in @xcite by about a factor of three .
our code , including the apparent horizon finder , has passed many tests for example , we verified that the black - hole mass approaches that of the spacetime s gravitational mass ( [ adm_mass ] ) as @xmath52 is increased ; see the inset in fig .
[ fig : scaling_centered ] . we are not aware of any problems , but we will continue to search for possible causes of this inconsistency . in either case ,
none of our analysis in what follows relies on the masses of the forming black holes . as pointed out by garfinkle and duncan @xcite , the critical scaling exponent @xmath4
can also be determined from the maximum value of the spacetime curvature attained in subcritical evolutions .
since this curvature is related to the density @xmath9 by einstein s equations ( [ einstein ] ) , we measure the maximum value of the density @xmath9 and , on dimensional grounds , fit to the scaling law @xmath84 our numerical results , together with the fit , are shown in the top panel of fig .
[ fig : scaling_centered ] . using the data included in the plot , this fit results in @xmath85 and @xmath86 .
various sources of error contribute to the uncertainties in our reported values .
one source of error is the truncation error in our finite - difference calculation . to estimate this error we performed simulations for a fixed value of @xmath87 with different resolutions and
conclude that , for our high - resolution grid , the error in the resulting black - hole mass is a fraction of one percent .
closer to the critical point , however , the solution develops smaller spatial features , so that our truncation error is larger ( see also the discussion above . ) fitting to the scaling laws ( [ mass_scaling ] ) and ( [ rho_scaling ] ) introduces additional systematic errors , as they hold strictly only in the immediate neighborhood of the critical point ( see the inset in fig . [
fig : scaling_centered ] . ) including or excluding data very close to the critical point ( where numerical error will be larger ) or further away from the critical point ( where the scaling laws start to break down ) will change our estimate for the critical exponent by a few percent .
we therefore estimate the error in the critical exponents at least those derived from the maximum density to be about 2 or 3% .
this means that our results are in good agreement with those reported by @xcite ( @xmath88 ) as well as the analytical results of @xcite , who found @xmath89 .
we believe that our results for the critical parameter @xmath71 are more accurate ; in section [ sec : ss_offcenter ] below we compare results for both a high - resolution and a low - resolution grid and find agreement to within less than 0.1% .
( see eq .
( [ omega ] ) ) as identified from our numerical solution for @xmath90 at coordinate times @xmath91 , 10.17 , 10.49 10.80 and 11.11 ( compare the inset in fig . [
fig : lapse_centered ] . )
the corresponding proper times at the center are @xmath92 , 2.429 , 2.479 , 2.527 and 2.572 , and we have adopted @xmath93 in the construction of the self - similar variable @xmath94 ( see eq .
( [ xi ] ) . )
while the density @xmath9 itself changes significantly between these times ( see the inset ) , the function @xmath95 displays the expected self - similar behavior and depends on @xmath94 only ( compare also fig . 1 in @xcite.),width=336 ]
we also examine the self - similarity of the critical solution . in the strong - field region of the spacetime , close to criticality and prior to black - hole formation , as the spacetime tries to decide " whether or not to collapse to a black hole , the solution contracts to a focal point or rather focal event " in a self - similar fashion ( see fig . 1 in @xcite for an illustration . ) in order to analyze this behavior we first define a variable @xmath96 in spherical symmetry ( for which @xmath97 ) , @xmath56 becomes independent of @xmath40 and may be interpreted as the areal radius .
we then define a self - similar coordinate in the definition @xmath98 .
evans and coleman @xcite considered the latter , but also defined @xmath94 in terms of coordinate time rather than proper time at the center ( see also the discussion in @xcite . ) ] @xmath99 where @xmath100 is the proper time measured by an observer at the origin , @xmath69 , and @xmath101 is the value of this proper time for the focal event ( which , a priori , is not known . ) a self - similar solution can then be expressed as a function of @xmath94 . as an example of a self - similar variable we follow @xcite and define a measure of the density , @xmath102 in fig .
[ fig : omega_centered ] we graph the function @xmath95 versus @xmath94 for an evolution with @xmath90 , which is close to the critical parameter .
we construct @xmath95 and @xmath94 from data at different times just prior to either black - hole formation or dispersal ( see the inset in fig .
[ fig : lapse_centered ] . )
choosing @xmath103 the resulting curves are so similar that they can hardly be distinguished in fig .
[ fig : omega_centered ] as expected for a self - similar solution . ,
but for off - center ( @xmath104 ) , spherically symmetric ( @xmath67 ) data .
here we include numerical results obtained both on high and low - resolution grids .
the solid lines represent the fits ( [ mass_scaling ] ) and ( [ rho_scaling ] ) , fitted to the high - resolution results.,width=336 ] before turning to axisymmetric simulations in section [ sec : axi ] , we discuss spherically symmetric ( @xmath67 ) off - center data with @xmath104 . qualitatively ,
the results are very similar to those for the centered data in section [ sec : ss_centered ] , except that now the fluid first has to propagate to the origin before it can collapse there .
the fluid therefore collapses at a later time than for the centered data . as the fluid converges toward to the origin its density increases ; accordingly , the critical parameter @xmath71 is smaller for off - center data than for centered data . in fig .
[ fig : scaling_offcentered ] we show both subcritical and supercritical scaling for the off - centered data , similar to fig . [ fig : scaling_centered ] for centered data . here
, however , we include results obtained both on a high - resolution and a low - resolution grid ( see section [ subsec : basics ] . ) the solid line is a fit based on the high - resolution data ; for the subcritical data we found the best fit for @xmath105 , while for the supercritical data we found @xmath86 both in excellent agreement with the expected values . for the high - resolution data we found @xmath106 , while for the low - resolution data @xmath107 .
as found in the evolution of centered initial data ( @xmath68 , compare fig .
[ fig : omega_centered ] ) , with that found in the evolution of off - centered data ( @xmath104 ) .
the two solutions agree very well , demonstrating the universality of the critical solution . for the off - centered data we show results obtained on both high - resolution ( @xmath43 ) and low - resolution ( @xmath45 ) grids.,width=336 ] evolutions closer to the critical parameter develop structures on a smaller spatial scale ( in particular smaller black holes for supercritical evolutions ) and hence require higher resolution ; it is therefore not surprising that simulations with a higher radial resolution remain reliable closer to the critical parameter . while we can not perform simulations quite as close to the critical parameter on the low - resolution grid as with the high - resolution grid , it is evident from fig .
[ fig : scaling_offcentered ] that the low - resolution grid is still perfectly adequate for the observation of critical scaling . similar to our analysis in section [ sec : ss_centered ] we also identify the critical solution in these evolutions ; adopting a proper time @xmath108 for the focal event our results are very similar to those shown for the centered data in fig .
[ fig : omega_centered ] . in fig .
[ fig : omega_comp ] we show a comparison between the critical solutions found in the centered and off - centered simulations .
the two solutions can hardly be distinguished , which demonstrates the universality of the critical solution . in the same plot
we also include the critical solution as observed on a low - resolution grid .
the excellent agreement demonstrates that the low - resolution grid is sufficient to identify the critical solution , and we therefore will use a low - resolution grid only in the axisymmetric simulations of section [ sec : axi ] . at different instances of coordinate time @xmath70 for data with @xmath110 and @xmath104 .
the black wireframe shows the density for a subcritical evolution with @xmath111 , while the colored surface shows results for a supercritical evolution with @xmath112 . in the first two panels
the two surfaces can not be distinguished , but in the last panel the density keeps increasing for the supercritical evolution , while for the subcritical evolution the density has dropped to very small values . note the vastly different scales in the different panels.,title="fig:",width=336 ] at different instances of coordinate time @xmath70 for data with @xmath110 and @xmath104 .
the black wireframe shows the density for a subcritical evolution with @xmath111 , while the colored surface shows results for a supercritical evolution with @xmath112 . in the first two panels
the two surfaces can not be distinguished , but in the last panel the density keeps increasing for the supercritical evolution , while for the subcritical evolution the density has dropped to very small values . note the vastly different scales in the different panels.,title="fig:",width=336 ] at different instances of coordinate time @xmath70 for data with @xmath110 and @xmath104 .
the black wireframe shows the density for a subcritical evolution with @xmath111 , while the colored surface shows results for a supercritical evolution with @xmath112 . in the first two panels
the two surfaces can not be distinguished , but in the last panel the density keeps increasing for the supercritical evolution , while for the subcritical evolution the density has dropped to very small values . note the vastly different scales in the different panels.,title="fig:",width=336 ] for a subcritical ( @xmath113 ) axisymmetric ( @xmath110 ) evolution for three different angular resolutions , @xmath114 , 12 and 16 .
even though these are all quite coarse resolutions , we see that the difference between the two higher resolutions is already relatively small.,width=336 ] we now turn to the aspherical collapse of radiation fluids , and consider evolutions with @xmath109 and 0.5 .
all results presented in this section are for off - centered data with @xmath104 , evolved with a low - resolution radial grid with @xmath45 .
as an example of our evolutions we show profiles of the density @xmath9 at three different coordinate times in fig .
[ fig : rho_axi ] .
we show results for a subcritical evolution with @xmath111 ( represented as a wireframe ) , as well as a supercritical evolution with @xmath112 ( represented as a colored surface ) , both for @xmath110 . at the earlier two times
the two profiles can not be distinguished , but at the latest time the density for the supercritical evolution continues to increase , while the density for the subcritical evolution has dropped down to much smaller values .
these simulations were carried out with a very modest angular resolution of @xmath115 ( since we impose equatorial symmetry , these grid points cover only one hemisphere . ) in order to evaluate whether such a coarse resolution is adequate , we show in fig .
[ fig : ang_convergence ] results for a subcritical evolution with @xmath113 and @xmath110 for three different resolutions , @xmath114 , 12 and 16 grid points . even though these are still very small resolutions , we see that the difference in the two higher resolutions is relatively small , in part because the deviations from sphericity remain relatively small throughout the evolution . as a compromise between accuracy and computing time we therefore chose @xmath115 for all simulations presented in this section . , but for both spherical and axisymmetric data .
the solid lines represent the fits ( [ mass_scaling ] ) and ( [ rho_scaling ] ) .
the spherical data for @xmath67 are the same as the low - resolution data in fig .
[ fig : scaling_offcentered].,width=336 ] in fig .
[ fig : scaling_axi ] we show the critical scaling of the maximum density ( for subcritical evolutions ) and black - hole mass ( for supercritical evolutions ) in our simulations .
the spherical data for @xmath67 are identical to the low - resolution results shown in fig .
[ fig : scaling_offcentered ] .
the aspherical data for @xmath109 and 0.5 follow remarkably similar scaling laws for both the maximum density and the black - hole masses ; fits to these different data sets can hardly be distinguished in fig .
[ fig : scaling_axi ] . to within the accuracy of our simulations
, the critical exponent @xmath4 appears to be the same for our choices of @xmath53 it is possible , of course , that larger deformations from sphericity would lead to a change in @xmath4 ( compare @xcite . )
the critical parameter @xmath71 , on the other hand increases slightly with @xmath53 ; for @xmath109 we found @xmath116 , and for @xmath110 about @xmath117 , compared to about @xmath107 for the the low - resolution spherical data with @xmath67 . at three different instances of
coordinate time @xmath70 for near - critical evolutions .
the colored surface shows results for @xmath110 and @xmath118 , while the wireframe shows results for spherical data with @xmath67 and @xmath119 ( see fig .
[ fig : omega_comp ] . )
the aspherical collapse leads to damped oscillations around the critical solution ; we show these oscillations approximately at times when their difference from sphericity is greatest.,title="fig:",width=336 ] at three different instances of coordinate time @xmath70 for near - critical evolutions .
the colored surface shows results for @xmath110 and @xmath118 , while the wireframe shows results for spherical data with @xmath67 and @xmath119 ( see fig .
[ fig : omega_comp ] . )
the aspherical collapse leads to damped oscillations around the critical solution ; we show these oscillations approximately at times when their difference from sphericity is greatest.,title="fig:",width=336 ] at three different instances of coordinate time @xmath70 for near - critical evolutions .
the colored surface shows results for @xmath110 and @xmath118 , while the wireframe shows results for spherical data with @xmath67 and @xmath119 ( see fig .
[ fig : omega_comp ] . )
the aspherical collapse leads to damped oscillations around the critical solution ; we show these oscillations approximately at times when their difference from sphericity is greatest.,title="fig:",width=336 ] we now turn to the approach of aspherical collapse to the critical solution . in fig .
[ fig : omega_profiles ] we show profiles of the function @xmath95 , defined in eq .
( [ omega ] ) , for a spherical and aspherical evolution close to criticality . in these profiles , the colored surfaces show profiles of @xmath95 for an aspherical collapse with @xmath110 , while the wireframes show profiles for a spherical collapse .
the radial contours for the spherical collapse are similar to those shown in figs .
[ fig : omega_centered ] and [ fig : omega_comp ] , except that @xmath95 is shown as a function of the self - similar variable @xmath94 there , while we graph @xmath95 as a function of @xmath120 and @xmath121 here . in the aspherical evolution
the density function @xmath95 appears to slosh " back and forth between the poles and the equator in damped oscillations around the spherical critical solution . in fig .
[ fig : omega_profiles ] we show these oscillations at times that more or less correspond to the largest deviations from sphericity . along the axis ( @xmath122 ) and in the equatorial plane ( @xmath123 ) , as a function of time , for subcritical evolutions close to the critical parameter @xmath71 .
the spherical self - similar contraction shown in fig .
[ fig : omega_comp ] occurs while the @xmath124 is approximately constant . here
we include results for @xmath109 and @xmath125 ; it can be seen that these maxima oscillate around the respective spherical values.,width=336 ] the oscillations can be seen more clearly in fig .
[ fig : omega_max ] , where we show the maxima of @xmath95 , both along the axis and in the equatorial plane , as a function of time .
the spherical data form a plateau between times of approximately @xmath126 and @xmath127 ; it is during this time that the solution contracts in a self - similar fashion as shown in fig .
[ fig : omega_comp ] . for the aspherical evolutions
we observe oscillations around these spherical results ; these oscillations appear to be damped , and to have a decreasing period , as one might expect from an oscillation around a self - similarly contracting solution .
, with the same symbols used for the respective lines , except that here we show the differences between the aspherical and the spherical data .
we also show these data as a function of the time coordinate @xmath128 ( see eq .
( [ t ] ) ) , in terms of which the focal event occurs at positive infinity .
the dotted lines are fits based on ( [ mg]).,width=336 ] in order to analyze these oscillations more quantitatively , we plot in fig .
[ fig : omega_diff ] the differences in the maximum values of @xmath95 between aspherical and spherical data .
we also display these differences as a function of a time coordinate @xmath129 appropriate for self - similar collapse . in terms of this coordinate ,
the focal event at @xmath130 , which we take to be @xmath108 as found in section [ sec : ss_offcenter ] , occurs at a time of positive infinity .
gundlach @xcite found that perturbations of a critical solution perform damped oscillations that , up to another periodic function , can then be written in the form @xmath131 here @xmath132 is a damping coefficient , @xmath133 the frequency of the oscillations , and @xmath134 a phase shift . in order to test this ,
we include in fig .
[ fig : omega_diff ] fits based on ( [ mg ] ) as the dotted lines .
that allows for a non - zero off - set in eq .
( [ mg ] ) , so that @xmath135 equals the right - hand side of ( [ mg ] ) .
we always found this parameter to be small . ] for @xmath109 we obtain excellent fits with values of @xmath133 within one percent of @xmath136 for both the axis and equatorial data , while the values for @xmath132 are within 10% of @xmath137 .
the fits for @xmath110 are not quite as clean as those for @xmath109 possibly these deviations are caused by nonlinear effects .
the values of @xmath133 based on fits for @xmath110 are still very similar to those found for @xmath109 , but the value of @xmath132 found from a fit for the axis data is somewhat smaller ( @xmath138 . ) we caution , however , that the exact value of these fits again depends on how early or late data points we include .
earlier data points are affected by the solution not having entered the self - similar contraction yet , while later data points show more numerical noise as the solution contracts to very small spatial scales and we lose sufficient resolution .
quite reassuringly , the above values of @xmath133 and @xmath132 are close to those found by gundlach @xcite for aspherical perturbations of the critical collapse of perfect fluids . for polar @xmath139 perturbations ( see his section iv.f ) , and for a radiation fluid , his results can be read off from his fig . 11 , with @xmath140 and @xmath141 .
both values are within about 10% of the values that we identified from our fully nonlinear simulations .
we perform numerical simulations of radiation fluids close to the onset of black - hole formation and study critical phenomena for spherically symmetric as well as aspherical initial data .
we find critical scaling for both subcritical and supercritical evolutions , and for both spherical and aspherical data .
we also identify the critical solution in spherical evolutions , find evidence for its universality , and demonstrate how , in aspherical evolutions , near - critical data perform a damped oscillation around the spherical critical solution at least in the cases we consider . our results are consistent with those of gundlach @xcite , who used perturbation techniques to show that all aspherical perturbations of the critical solution decay in damped oscillations ( see also @xcite , as well as @xcite for similar calculations for scalar fields . ) matching our numerical results to damped oscillations of the form ( [ mg ] ) we find damping coefficients and frequencies that are within about 10% of those reported in @xcite .
however , our results also do not rule out the existence of a growing nonspherical mode as reported by choptuik _ et.al .
_ @xcite , since those modes may only appear for larger deviations from sphericity , closer to the critical point , or perhaps they may appear only for some matter models , but not for others .
it is also possible that the grid resolutions adopted in this paper are not sufficient to detect this mode .
we plan to further pursue this issue in future studies .
in addition to studying critical phenomena in the aspherical collapse of radiation fluids , this paper serves as a demonstration that an unconstrained evolution code , using `` moving - puncture '' coordinates , is suitable for the study of critical collapse , at least for some matter models ( see also @xcite for recent discussions of this issue . )
it is a pleasure to thank steve liebling and frans pretorius for helpful conversations , and chuck evans both for conversations and for sharing numerical data from @xcite .
we would also like to thank carsten gundlach for pointing us to reference @xcite , and for several very useful comments .
twb would like to thank the max - planck - institut fr astrophysik in garching ( germany ) for its hospitality .
this work was supported in part by nsf grant phy-1402780 to bowdoin college , and by the max - planck - institut fr astrophysik .
in this appendix we describe the structure of our logarithmic radial grid together with some of the finite - difference stencils that we use . we denote gridpoints with @xmath142 and define @xmath143 ( see the schematic drawing in fig .
[ fig : grid ] . )
since we use finite - difference stencils that , for each gridpoint , use up to two nearest neighbors on both sides , we define the first two ghost - points , @xmath144 and @xmath145 , with negative values of the radius ( see also fig . 1 in @xcite . )
we further choose the location of @xmath145 and @xmath146 so that the origin , at @xmath74 , is half - way between these two points , i.e. @xmath147 for a uniform grid the grid spacing @xmath148 is constant across the entire grid .
here we instead allow for a logarithmic grid and choose @xmath149 with @xmath150 .
we would now like to represent derivatives of a function @xmath151 , say , in terms of finite - differencing stencils involving the function values at a gridpoint @xmath142 as well as its two nearest neighbors on both sides .
to this end , we express the function values at those gridpoints in terms of a taylor expansion up to fourth order about the central point , and write all distances in terms of @xmath148 . for @xmath152 , for example , we have @xmath153 where @xmath154 and where @xmath155 denotes the @xmath156-th derivative of the function @xmath151 evaluated at @xmath157 .
we write similar expressions for @xmath158 , @xmath159 and @xmath159 , as well as @xmath160 , and observe that we can combine the resulting five equations into a single matrix equation @xmath161 where the matrix @xmath63 is given by @xmath162 1 & \displaystyle c \delta_i & \displaystyle \frac{c^2}{2 } \delta_i^2 & \displaystyle \frac{c^3}{6 } \delta_i^3 & \displaystyle \frac{c^4}{24 } \delta_i^4 \\ 1 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 \\ 1 & \displaystyle - \delta_i & \displaystyle \frac{1}{2 } \delta_i^2 & \displaystyle - \frac{1}{6 } \delta_i^3 & \displaystyle \frac{1}{24 } \delta_i^4 \\[2 mm ] 1 & \displaystyle - \frac{(1+c)}{c } \delta_i & \displaystyle \frac{(1+c)^2}{2c^2 } \delta_i^2 & \displaystyle \frac{(1+c)^3}{6c^3 } \delta_i^3 & \displaystyle \frac{(1+c)^4}{24c^4 } \delta_i^4 \end{array } \right).\ ] ] we now invert the matrix equation ( [ matrix_equation ] ) to obtain @xmath163 from which we can read off finite - difference expressions for the first four derivatives of the function @xmath151 in terms of the function values at @xmath142 and its nearest neighbors .
in particular , we have @xmath164 and @xmath165 for the first two derivatives , where the coefficients @xmath166 and @xmath167 are listed in table [ table : stencil ] ( see also @xcite ) . for a uniform grid , with @xmath168 ,
the finite - difference stencils reduce to the more familiar expressions @xmath169 and @xmath170 for uniform girds the leading - order error terms in the taylor expansion ( [ taylor ] ) cancel out exactly when they are combined to form the expressions ( [ first_uniform ] ) and ( [ second_uniform ] ) , so that in both of these expressions the error scales with @xmath171 .
this cancellation does not occur for a logarithmic grid with @xmath172 , so that the leading - order error term is one order lower .
40ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop ( ) , @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , ) in @noop _ _ ( , ) pp . @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1086/303604 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) _ _ , @noop master s thesis , ( ) | we study critical phenomena in the gravitational collapse of a radiation fluid .
we perform numerical simulations in both spherical symmetry and axisymmetry , and observe critical scaling in both supercritical evolutions , which lead to the formation of a black hole , and subcritical evolutions , in which case the fluid disperses to infinity and leaves behind flat space .
we identify the critical solution in spherically symmetric collapse , find evidence for its universality , and study the approach to this critical solution in the absence of spherical symmetry . for the cases that we consider , aspherical deviations from the spherically symmetric critical solution decay in damped oscillations in a manner that is consistent with the behavior found by gundlach in perturbative calculations .
our simulations are performed with an unconstrained evolution code , implemented in spherical polar coordinates , and adopting moving - puncture " coordinates . |
the success of the relativistic hydrodynamics in describing the rhic data @xcite suggests that the hot and dense matter produced at rhic behaves like an almost perfect fluid @xcite . in this paper
we discuss how the boost - invariant and cylindrically asymmetric relativistic hydrodynamic equations for baryon - free perfect fluid may be very conveniently reduced to only two coupled partial differential equations .
our presentation is based on the recent investigations published in refs .
we argue that the effects of the cross - over phase transition may be included by the use of the temperature dependent sound velocity @xmath0 . as long as the function @xmath0 satisfies the stability condition against the shock formation
, the resulting equations may be solved with the help of standard numerical methods and used to describe the expansion of matter produced in the central region of ultra - relativistic heavy - ion collisions , such as studied in the present rhic or future lhc experiments .
the presented formalism is a direct generalization of the approach introduced by baym , friman , blaizot , soyeur , and czyz @xcite where the boost - invariant and cylindrically symmetric systems were considered , and the numerical calculations were performed only for the case of the constant sound velocity .
the relativistic hydrodynamic equations of the perfect fluid follow from the energy - momentum conservation law and the assumption of the local thermal equilibrium . for baryon - free matter
they have the following form @xmath1 where @xmath2 is the temperature , @xmath3 is the entropy density , and @xmath4 is the four - velocity of the fluid . for boost - invariant systems eqs .
( [ h1 ] ) may be reduced to three independent equations @xcite [ hyd2 ] @xmath5 in eqs .
( [ h3 ] ) - ( [ h5 ] ) the quantities @xmath6 , and @xmath7 are space - time coordinates which parameterize the plane @xmath8 .
the quantity @xmath9 is the magnitude of the fluid velocity , @xmath10 is the lorentz factor , and @xmath11 is the function describing direction of the flow , @xmath12 , see fig . [
fig : alpha ] . the differential operator @xmath13 in ( [ h5 ] ) is defined by the expression @xmath14 . in our approach
we use the magnitude of the flow @xmath9 and the angle @xmath11 as two independent quantities.,scaledwidth=30.0% ] equations ( [ hyd2 ] ) are three differential equations for four unknown functions : @xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath9 , and @xmath11 . to solve them one has to use also the equation of state ,
, the relation connecting @xmath2 and @xmath3 . in our approach , the equation of state is taken into account by the use of the temperature dependent sound velocity @xmath15 and by the use of the potential @xmath16 defined by the differential equation @xmath17 the form of the function @xmath18 used in our calculations is defined and discussed in more detail in ref .
@xcite . here
we only note that the form of our sound velocity function automatically satisfies the condition against the shock formation @xcite .
the integration of eq .
( [ phi ] ) allows us to express @xmath19 in terms of the temperature , @xmath20 , or to express temperature in terms of @xmath19 , @xmath21 .
these two functions may be used to rewrite the hydrodynamic equations in the very concise form .
in fact , with the help of the substitutions : @xmath22 the sum and the difference of the equations ( [ h3 ] ) and ( [ h4 ] ) may be rewritten as @xmath23 \,a_{\pm } = 0 , \label{apmeq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] while the third equation in ( [ h5 ] ) is @xmath24 equations ( [ apmeq ] ) and ( [ alphaeq ] ) are three equations for three unknown functions : @xmath25 , @xmath26 , and @xmath27 .
we note , that the velocity @xmath9 and the potential @xmath19 are functions of @xmath28 and @xmath29 , @xmath30 also the sound velocity may be expressed as the function of @xmath28 and @xmath29 , however , through a more complicated formula , see ref .
and @xmath26 with the help of the function @xmath31 .
the function @xmath27 is symmetrically extended to negative values of @xmath32 .
, scaledwidth=45.0% ] in this paper we consider the collisions of identical nuclei with atomic number @xmath33 which collide moving initially along the @xmath34-axis . the impact parameter @xmath35 points in the @xmath36-direction .
the center of the first nucleus in the transverse plane is placed at @xmath37 , and of the second nucleus at @xmath38 .
in such a case we require that the magnitude of the flow vanishes at @xmath39 .
this condition is fulfilled naturally by the ansatz [ adefwe ] @xmath40 we supplement the ansatz ( [ adefwe ] ) by the definition of the function @xmath27 for the negative arguments , see fig . [
fig : rsym ] , @xmath41 with the help of the definitions ( [ adefwe ] ) and ( [ alphadefwe ] ) , eqs . ( [ apmeq ] ) may be reduced to a single equation for the function @xmath31 , @xmath42 \,a = 0 , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , similarly to the cylindrically symmetric case , the range of the variable @xmath32 is extended to negative values .
( [ aeq ] ) should be solved together with eq .
( [ alphaeq ] ) , where the range of @xmath32 may be also extended trivially to negative values ( definitions ( [ adefwe ] ) and ( [ alphadefwe ] ) imply that this equation is in fact invariant under transformation : @xmath43 ) .
the use of the polar coordinates in the transverse plane requires also that all functions at @xmath44 and @xmath45 are equal : @xmath46 .
in the following we assume that the hydrodynamic evolution starts at a typical time @xmath47 fm .
we assume also that the initial temperature profile is connected with the number of participating nucleons @xmath48 the idea to use eq .
( [ tt0 ] ) follows from the assumption that the initially produced entropy density @xmath49 is proportional to the number of the nucleons participating in the collision at the position @xmath50 .
since the considered systems are initially very hot ( with the temperature exceeding the critical temperature @xmath51 ) , they may be considered as systems of massless particles , where the entropy density is proportional to the third power of the temperature . in this way we arrive at eq .
( [ tt0 ] ) .
the initial form of the functions @xmath52 and @xmath27 is @xmath53 where @xmath54 is a parameter defining the initial transverse flow formed in the pre - equilibrium stage . in the present calculations we use a very small value @xmath54 = 0.001 @xmath55 .
the two initial conditions , eqs .
( [ tt0 ] ) and ( [ initv ] ) , may be included in the initial form of the function @xmath56 if we define @xmath57 \right\ } \frac{\sqrt{1 + v^{\,0}(r)}}{\sqrt{1 - v^{\,0}(r ) } } , \label{initat}\ ] ]
in this section we give an example of our results describing the collisions with the impact parameter @xmath58 = 7.6 fm , typical for centrality class @xmath59 @xcite . in this case the initial central temperature @xmath60 equals 2.5 @xmath51 , where @xmath51 is the critical temperature , @xmath61 .
the part a ) of fig . [
fig : res1 ] shows the temperature profiles for different values of time : @xmath62 fm .
the solid lines represent the temperature profiles along the @xmath36-axis ( @xmath44 ) , while the dashed lines represent the profiles along the @xmath63-axis ( @xmath64 ) .
one can observe that during the whole considered evolution time , 1 fm @xmath65 16 fm , the @xmath63-extension of the system remains larger than the @xmath36-extension .
however , the relative magnitude of this effect decreases with time , indicating that the cylindrical symmetry is gradually restored as the time increases . in this part of fig .
[ fig : res1 ] one can also notice the effect of the phase transition ; initially the system cools down rather rapidly , later the cooling down is delayed and the main visible effect is the increase of the volume of the system .
we note that this behavior is related to the sudden decrease of the sound velocity in the region @xmath66 .
the part b ) of fig . [
fig : res1 ] shows the isotherms in the @xmath67 space , again for @xmath44 ( solid lines ) and @xmath64 ( dashed lines ) .
the pairs of isotherms indicate different values of the temperature .
they start at @xmath68 and go down to @xmath69 , with a step of @xmath70 .
it is interesting to observe that the solid and dashed lines cross each other .
this effect means that the central ( relatively hotter ) part of the system acquires a pumpkin - like shape during the evolution of the system .
such pumpkin - like regions , however , shrink and disappear during further expansion . in the part c ) of fig .
[ fig : res1 ] the profiles of the function @xmath27 are shown for @xmath62 fm and @xmath71 . for @xmath44 and @xmath64
the function @xmath27 vanishes due to the symmetry reasons . in the first and third quadrant
the values of @xmath11 are predominantly negative , while in the second and fourth quadrant the values of @xmath11 are positive .
this behavior characterizes the direction of the flow which has the tendency to change the initial almond shape into a cylindrically symmetric shape . in the part
d ) the velocity profiles are shown , again for @xmath72 = 1 , 4 , 10 , 16 fm . similarly to the previously discussed figures , the solid lines are the profiles for @xmath44 ( @xmath36-direction ) , whereas the dashed lines are the profiles for @xmath64 ( @xmath63-direction ) .
one can observe that the magnitude in the @xmath36-direction is larger than the magnitude in the @xmath63-direction , which is an expected hydrodynamic behavior caused by larger pressure gradients in the @xmath36-direction .
exactly this effect is responsible for the observed azimuthal asymmetry of the transverse - momentum spectra , quantified by the values of the @xmath73 coefficient .
finally , in the part e ) we show the contour lines of the temperature , again for different values of time .
these plots visualize the time development of the system .
the arrows describe the magnitude and the direction of the flow ( for better recognition the angle @xmath11 is magnified by a factor of 3 ) .
in this paper we presented a new and concise treatment of the boost - invariant and cylindrically asymmetric relativistic hydrodynamic equations .
the presented formalism is a direct generalization of the approach introduced by baym et al . in ref .
@xcite . in the studied case ,
the symmetry of the problem allows us to rewrite the hydrodynamic equations as only two coupled partial differential equations , ( [ alphaeq ] ) and ( [ aeq ] ) , which automatically lead to the fulfillment of the requested boundary conditions for the velocity and the temperature at the center of the system .
the effects of the phase transition are included in this scheme by the use of the temperature dependent sound velocity .
the presented results of the hydrodynamic calculations , supplemented with the appropriate freeze - out model ( , the single - freeze - out model of refs .
@xcite ) , may be used to calculate different physical observables . to achieve this task , in the closest future
we intend to combine our hydrodynamic approach with the statistical monte - carlo model therminator @xcite .
10 url # 1`#1`urlprefix d. teaney , j. lauret , e. v. shuryak , nucl - th/0110037 .
p. huovinen , p. f. kolb , u. w. heinz , p. v. ruuskanen , s. a. voloshin , _ phys .
lett . _ * b503 * , 58 ( 2001 ) .
p. huovinen , _ acta phys .
polon . _ * b33 * , 1635 ( 2002 ) .
p. f. kolb , r. rapp , _ phys .
rev . _ * c67 * , 044903 ( 2003 ) . t. hirano , k. tsuda , _ phys .
rev . _ * c66 * , 054905 ( 2002 ) .
t. hirano , y. nara , _ nucl .
_ * a743 * , 305 ( 2004 ) . t. hirano , m. gyulassy , _ nucl . phys . _ * a769 * , 71 ( 2006 ) .
u. w. heinz , nucl - th/0512051 .
m. chojnacki , w. florkowski , t. csorgo , _ phys .
rev . _ * c71 * , 044902 ( 2005 ) .
m. chojnacki , w. florkowski , nucl - th/0603065 .
g. baym , b. l. friman , j. p. blaizot , m. soyeur , w. czyz , _ nucl .
phys . _ * a407 * , 541 ( 1983 ) .
a. dyrek , w. florkowski , _ acta phys .
polon . _ * b15 * , 653 ( 1984 ) .
b. mohanty , j .- e .
alam , _ phys .
rev . _ * c68 * , 064903 ( 2003 ) .
j. p. blaizot , j .- y .
ollitrault , _ phys .
lett . _ * b191 * , 21 ( 1987 ) .
w. broniowski , w. florkowski , _ phys .
rev . _ * c65 * , 024905 ( 2002 ) .
w. broniowski , w. florkowski , _ phys . rev
. lett . _ * 87 * , 272302 ( 2001 ) .
w. broniowski , w. florkowski , _ phys .
* c65 * , 064905 ( 2002 ) .
a. kisiel , t. taluc , w. broniowski , w. florkowski , _ comput .
. commun . _ * 174 * , 667 ( 2006 ) . | we show that the boost - invariant and cylindrically asymmetric hydrodynamic equations for baryon - free matter may be rewritten as only two coupled partial differential equations . in the case where the system exhibits the cross - over phase transition , the standard numerical methods may be applied to solve these equations .
an example of our results describing non - central gold on gold collisions at rhic energies is presented . |
sine - gordon ( sg ) models and their coulomb gas representations appear as a low energy effective theory for many types of physical systems .
the so - called `` bulk '' sg model describes the berezinskii - kosterlitz - thouless ( bkt ) transition in two - dimensional superfluids @xcite and the superfluid to insulator transition of cooper pairs in a chain of josephson junctions @xcite .
the so - called `` boundary '' sg model @xcite can be used to describe the chakravarty - schmid transition in a single josephson junction with dissipation @xcite and a quantum impurity problem @xcite in one dimension ( 1d ) .
powerful theoretical techniques have been developed for studying such sg models including bethe ansatz solutions @xcite , renormalization group analysis ( see e.g. , ref .
@xcite ) , and functional renormalization group @xcite .
recent theoretical work suggested that there is another class of sg models which is important for several kinds of physical systems .
such models can be described by the action @xmath0 where the interaction term @xmath1 is present in the spatial region @xmath2 ( or space - time region for quantum problems ) , which is only a part of the domain @xmath3 over which the noninteracting part @xmath4 is defined .
this should be contrasted to the bulk sg models , in which the interaction term is present in the entire region @xmath3 , and to the boundary sg models , in which the interaction term is present on a line .
we note that models with inhomogeneous @xmath5 can be considered using methods developed in the paper as well , but for concreteness we will consider only constant @xmath6 model ( [ s_gordon_finite ] ) interpolates between the bulk and boundary sg models , and we will refer to it as the interior sine - gordon ( isg ) model . here
are a few examples of physical systems that can be described by such models .
the first example is the problem of interwire coherence
@xcite in which wires are brought together over a finite length @xmath7 and separated on both ends .
the @xmath8-term describes the correlated umklapp electron scattering in the two wires ( @xmath9 scattering in one wire accompanied by @xmath10 scattering in the other wire ) .
the quantum space - time action of this system has the form of eq .
( [ s_gordon_finite ] ) with @xmath11_x \times [ 0,\beta]_\tau$ ] and @xmath12_x \times [ 0,\beta]_\tau$ ] .
another example comes from a system of quantum particles in one dimension ( e.g. , electrons or cooper pairs in a wire , or ultracold atoms in a weak optical trap ) with a periodic potential present in a finite region of the system .
the @xmath8-term comes from the umklapp scattering on the external potential and is limited to the finite region in the interior of the system .
the third example is the problem of distribution functions of interference fringe amplitudes ( dfifa ) for a pair of independent low - dimensional condensates @xcite .
individual moments of the distribution function can be represented as a microcanonical partition function of coulomb gases @xcite , with positions of coulomb charges restricted to the part of the system from which interference patterns have been extracted .
the latter is typically smaller than the total system size .
for example , in the case of large 2d condensates we have @xmath11_x \times [ -\infty,\infty]_\tau$ ] , and when the interference pattern is extracted from the area @xmath13 , we have @xmath14_x \times [ -l/2,l/2]_\tau$ ] . the relation between the dfifa and the partition function of the isg model
will be outlined below and has also been discussed in refs .
@xcite . in this paper
we develop a nonperturbative approach to calculating partition functions of a wide class of sg models and coulomb gases , which relies on the mapping of their partition functions to certain problems of statistics of random surfaces .
we point out that our method does not rely on the existence of the exact solutions of sg models , but uses the structure of the multi - point correlation functions in the absence of interactions .
we also note that a suitable extension of our method can be used to compute correlation functions of sg models in equilibrium and non - equilibrium situations
. the particular strength of our approach is that it can be applied to study isg models , which _ can not be analyzed by other theoretical methods_. as a concrete application of our method we calculate dfifa for both 1d and 2d condensates .
we point out that earlier theoretical work on interference experiments focused on 1d systems with periodic boundary conditions ( pbc ) @xcite .
while these boundary conditions are extremely artificial from the point of view of realistic experiments , they allow one to relate the dfifa to the quantum impurity problem @xcite and use certain exact results about the latter @xcite .
methods used in ref .
@xcite can not be generalized either to the realistic case of open boundary conditions ( obc ) ( i.e. , interference patterns extracted from the interior of a large system ) or 2d systems , but these cases can be analyzed using the method discussed in this paper .
we emphasize , however , that the main goal of this paper is to introduce an approach to the analysis of sg models and the problem of dfifa is just one example that illustrates the power of the new method .
the partition function corresponding to the action ( [ s_gordon_finite ] ) is given by @xmath15 . by expanding @xmath16 in powers of @xmath17
we arrive at the grand canonical partition function of the coulomb gas @xcite @xmath18 here , @xmath19 is a microcanonical partition function of a classical two - component neutral coloumb gas of @xmath20 particles , and @xmath21 is an interaction potential , which is proportional to green s function of the laplace operator on @xmath22 the most familiar case is when @xmath23_x \times [ -\infty,\infty]_\tau$ ] and @xmath24 . to evaluate @xmath16 nonperturbatively in @xmath25 we introduce an auxiliary function @xmath26 , which should be understood as a certain distribution function , and is defined in such a way that its @xmath27 moment equals @xmath28 @xmath29 one can use the hankel transformation @xcite to compute @xmath16 from @xmath26 as @xmath30 this equation equation can be verified using the taylor expansion of the modified bessel function @xmath31 and eq .
( [ walpha ] ) .
formulation of the auxiliary problem of moments allows one to avoid calculating @xmath16 order by order , and can be viewed as a tool to sum the perturbation series in eq .
( [ z2n ] ) to all orders .
function @xmath21 is real and symmetric , so it can be diagonalized on @xmath2 by solving the eigenvalue equations @xmath32 here @xmath33 is an integer index , which goes from @xmath34 to @xmath35 @xmath36 can be chosen to be real and normalized according to @xmath37 then , @xmath21 is given by @xmath38 such decomposition is similar to the diagonalization of a symmetric matrix using its eigenvectors and eigenvalues .
we have @xmath39}= \nonumber\\
\int_{\omega} ... \int_{\omega } d^2\vec u_1 ... d^2\vec v_n\prod_{f=1}^{f=\infty } \frac { \int_{-\infty}^{\infty}d t_{f}e^{-\frac{t_{f}^2}2 } e^{\sum_{i } t_f\sqrt{\frac{g(f)}{k}}\left(\psi_{f}(\vec
u_i)-\psi_{f}(\vec v_i ) \right)-\frac{g(f)}{2k}\left(\psi_{f}(\vec u_i)^2+\psi_{f}(\vec v_i)^2 \right ) } } { \sqrt{2\pi}}. \label{decoupling}\end{aligned}\ ] ] to go from the first to the second line in eq .
( [ decoupling ] ) we introduced the hubbard - stratonovich variables @xmath40 integration over @xmath41 is now straightforward since all @xmath42 and @xmath43 integrals are identical .
@xmath44 where @xmath45 from a comparison of eqs .
( [ walpha ] ) and ( [ 10 ] ) we obtain @xmath46 .
\label{walpha}\end{aligned}\ ] ] equations ( [ gt ] ) and ( [ walpha ] ) have a simple physical interpretation .
consider @xmath36 to be the eigenmodes of the surface vibrations , @xmath47 the fluctuating mode amplitudes , and @xmath48 the noise power .
infinite dimensional integral over @xmath49 variables can be understood as an averaging over fluctuations of the surface . for a particular realization of noise variables
@xmath50 a complex valued surface coordinate at point @xmath51 is given by @xmath52 for each realization of a random surface @xmath50 @xmath53 is obtained as an integral ( [ gt ] ) , which can also be written as @xmath54 hence eq .
( [ walpha ] ) can be interpreted as the mapping between the partition function of the sg model ( [ s_gordon_finite ] ) and the statistics of random surfaces subject to classical noise .
this mapping is the central result of this paper . in general
, @xmath53 is a complex number , thus in general , @xmath55 is defined on a complex plane .
simplifications occur : if all eigenvalues @xmath56 are negative , then @xmath57 and @xmath55 is always real and positive .
function @xmath26 can be computed efficiently using eq .
( [ walpha ] ) and monte carlo simulations . in the first step one solves integral equations ( [ inteqs ] ) numerically to obtain eigenfunctions @xmath36 and eigenvectors @xmath58 then one samples random numbers @xmath49 from the gaussian ensemble , and plots the histogram of the results for @xmath59 each point on a histogram requires a computation of only two integrals , and @xmath26 can be evaluated to arbitrary precision .
note , that this simple numerical evaluation of @xmath26 allows one to extract @xmath16 for _ all _ values of @xmath17 using eq .
( [ hankeleq ] ) .
while conventional large - scale monte carlo simulations @xcite can be used to extract properties of sg models , they require separate simulation for each value of @xmath6 application of such methods to the calculation of dfifa described below would also require analytic continuation of numerical results to imaginary values of @xmath17 @xcite , which is numerically unstable .
in addition , the mapping in eqs .
( [ gt ] ) and ( [ walpha ] ) does not only simplify numerical simulations , but can also be used to obtain analytical results ( see below ) .
we now apply a general formalism developed to a particular problem of the interference of low - dimensional bose gases @xcite . typical experimental setup for interference of low - dimensional gases with open boundary conditions ( obc )
is shown in fig .
[ setup ] .
two parallel condensates are extended in the @xmath60 direction .
after atoms are released from the trap , clouds expand predominantly in the transverse direction . after sufficient time of flight clouds overlap , and the laser beam propagating along
the @xmath61 axis takes an absorption image .
fluctuations of the relative phase result in fluctuations of the minima positions for different @xmath62 for each @xmath63 the image can be integrated along the @xmath60 direction to obtain the integrated fringe amplitude @xmath64 one experimental image can be used to extract information for different values of @xmath65 many images are still required to obtain distribution functions for each @xmath65 for two identical 1d clouds higher moments of the fringe amplitude @xmath66 can be written as @xcite @xmath67 here @xmath68 is the density , @xmath69 is the imaging length , @xmath70 is the healing length , and @xmath71 is a constant of the order of unity . for obc @xmath19 is given @xcite by eq .
( [ z2n ] ) with @xmath72_x \times[0,\beta]_\tau$ ] ( and periodic boundary conditions in @xmath73 ) and @xmath74_x$ ] ( and fixed @xmath73 ) .
equation ( [ a0 ] ) has been derived neglecting the shot noise , which arises due to a finite number of particles in the interfering clouds @xcite . in what follows
, we will be interested in the distribution functions @xmath26 of a positive variable @xmath75 defined by eq .
( [ walpha ] ) , or of its normalized version @xmath76 defined by @xmath77 for zero temperature @xmath19 depends only on the luttinger parameter @xmath78 which describes @xcite the long - distance behavior of boson correlation functions , given by @xmath79 . for bosons @xmath80 ranges from @xmath81 ( strong interactions ) to @xmath82 ( weak interactions ) . for obc and zero temperature @xmath21
equals @xmath83 while for pbc considered in ref .
@xcite , @xmath84 while @xmath85 depends on @xmath86 for zero temperature distribution @xmath87 does not depend on @xmath86 but depends only on @xmath88 for nonzero temperature , @xmath19 depends on @xmath80 and the thermal length @xmath89 where @xmath90 is the sound velocity : @xmath91 for 2d , one can use a similar approach to describe the contrast distribution at finite temperature below the bkt transition . in this case ,
correlation functions are given by @xmath92 where @xmath93 depends on the temperature and the superfluid density @xmath94 the bkt transition happens at the universal value @xmath95 to keep a connection to the 1d case , we will use @xmath96 and restrict our attention to @xmath97 for 2d with the aspect ratio of the imaging area equal to unity , @xmath98 and @xmath99 in eq .
( [ z2n ] ) are defined on a square @xmath74_{x}\times[0,1]_{\tau}$ ] with @xmath100 distribution functions of the normalized interference amplitude @xmath87 at @xmath101 for 1d gases with open boundary conditions , shown for luttinger parameters @xmath102 and @xmath103 the inset shows a comparison between open ( solid ) and periodic ( dashed ) boundary conditions for @xmath104 . ] in the limit @xmath105 one can expand the exponent of eq .
( [ gt ] ) in the taylor series . then @xmath106 is linearly related to roughness , or mean square fluctuation of the surface , as defined in ref .
@xcite . for pbc
the noise has a @xmath107 power spectrum , since @xmath108 this results in the gumbel statistics of the roughness @xcite : @xmath109 where @xmath110 and @xmath111 is the euler constant .
this provides the _ analytical _ proof of the conjecture made in ref .
@xcite , that the distribution function in this case is given by one of the extreme value statistical distributions , the gumbel function @xcite . in what follows we perform simulations of @xmath26 with up to @xmath112 realizations of @xmath49 and smoothen the data .
we use a finite value of @xmath113 and check for convergence with @xmath114 typically @xmath115 @xmath116 is always kept within @xmath117 from its expected value . for most of the presented results , all eigenvalues
@xmath56 are negative , and eq .
( [ walpha ] ) can be directly applied .
special care should be taken of the 1d case with nonzero temperatures , since one of the eigenvalues can be positive .
this situation can be handled by subtracting a sufficiently large positive constant @xmath71 from @xmath118 which makes all eigenvalues negative . according to eqs .
( [ z2n ] ) and ( [ walpha ] ) , this leads to rescaling of @xmath55 by a factor @xmath119 which can be easily taken into account . in fig .
[ 1dzerot ] we show distribution functions of the normalized interference amplitude @xmath87 at @xmath101 for 1d gases with obc for various @xmath88 the inset shows a comparison between obc and pbc for @xmath120 in fig .
[ 1dnztfig ] , we show distribution functions of the normalized interference amplitude for a 1d gas with obc at nonzero temperature and @xmath120 for @xmath121 distribution is poissonian @xcite and wide , while for @xmath122 and @xmath123 it is very narrow .
evolution of the full distribution function of the visibilities as @xmath69 is varied can be used to precisely measure the thermal length @xmath124 and to extract the temperature . as seen in fig .
[ 1dnztfig ] , at @xmath125 the distribution function has characteristic features , i.e. , it is generally nonsymmetric and can have a _
minimum_. these features can be used to distinguish the intrinsic noise due to fluctuations of the phase from technical noise . finally , in fig .
[ 2dfig ] we show distribution functions of the normalized interference amplitude for a 2d gas with an aspect ratio of imaging area equal to unity and obc below the bkt temperature . above the bkt temperature ,
distribution functions become poissonian for @xmath126 where @xmath127 is the correlation length . in 2d
one can not describe the crossover at @xmath128 similar to 1d , since the action which describes the fluctuations of the phase is not quadratic in this region , and eq .
( [ z2n ] ) does not hold .
distribution functions of the normalized interference amplitude @xmath87 for a 1d bose gas with open boundary conditions at nonzero temperature and @xmath120 different curves correspond to ratios @xmath129 and @xmath130 @xmath131 is the thermal correlation length , @xmath80 is the luttinger parameter , and @xmath69 is the imaging length . ]
distribution functions of the normalized interference amplitude @xmath87 for a two - dimensional bose gas with the aspect ratio of the imaging area equal to unity and open boundary conditions .
temperature is below the berezinskii - kosterlitz - thouless ( bkt ) transition temperature .
different curves correspond to @xmath132(the bkt transition point , solid ) , @xmath133 ( dashed line ) , and @xmath134 ( dotted line ) . above the bkt transition temperature
the distribution function is poissonian ( dot - dashed line ) . ]
to summarize , we introduced a class of sine - gordon models , for which an interaction term is present in a spatial region different from the domain over which the noninteracting part is defined .
we developed a general mapping of such sine - gordon models and related coulomb gases to statistical properties of random surfaces , which can be used to calculate their partition functions _
nonperturbatively_. as a specific application of our approach , we considered interference experiments with two independent low - dimensional bose gases .
we calculated full distribution functions of the interference amplitude for 1d and 2d gases with open boundary conditions and nonzero temperatures .
full distribution functions of interference fringe visibilities can be used for thermometry .
we thank m. mueller and a. polkovnikov for useful discussions .
this work was partially supported by nsf grant no .
dmr-0705472 , mit - harvard cua , and afosr .
is also partially supported by swiss national science foundation , grant no .
pbfr2 - 110423 .
a. o. gogolin , a. a. nersesyan and a. m. tsvelik , _ bosonization and strongly correlated systems _
( cambridge university press , cambridge , england , 1998 ) .
g. refael , e. demler , y. oreg , and d. s. fisher , phys .
b * 75 * , 014522 ( 2007 ) .
p. fendley , h. saleur , and n. p. warner , nucl .
b * 430 * , 577 ( 1994 ) .
s. chakravarty , phys .
lett . * 49 * , 681 ( 1982 ) ; a. schmid , phys .
lett . * 51 * , 1506 ( 1983 ) . c. l. kane and m. p. a. fisher , phys .
b * 46 * , 15233 ( 1992 )
. t. schumm _
et al . _ ,
nature physics * 1 * , 57 ( 2005 ) .
s. hofferberth _
_ , nature physics * 2 * , 710 ( 2006 ) .
z. hadzibabic _
et al . _ ,
nature * 441 * , 1118 ( 2006 ) .
a. polkovnikov , e. altman and e. demler , proc .
usa * 103 * , 6125 ( 2006 ) .
v. gritsev , e. altman , and e. demler and a. polkovnikov , nature physics * 2 * , 705 ( 2006 ) .
a. imambekov , v. gritsev , and e. demler , in _ proceedings of the 2006 enrico fermi summer school on ultracold fermi gases , varenna , italy , june 2006 , _ organized by m. inguscio , w. ketterle and c. salomon ; arxiv : cond - mat/0703766v1 . | we introduce a new class of sine - gordon models , for which the interaction term is present in a region different from the domain over which the quadratic part is defined .
we develop a _ nonperturbative _ approach for calculating partition functions of such models , which relies on mapping them to statistical properties of random surfaces . as a specific application of our method
, we consider the problem of calculating the amplitude of interference fringes in experiments with two independent low dimensional bose gases .
we calculate full distribution functions of interference amplitude for one - dimensional and two - dimensional gases with nonzero temperatures . |
non - adiabatic generation of current in coherent quantum rings on the nanometer scale has attracted attention recently.@xcite a one - dimensional ( 1d ) quantum ring in its ground state exhibits a circulating current ( persistent current ) if the ring is placed in an external magnetic field perpendicular to the plane of the ring .
the magnetic field breaks the left / right symmetry and the occupation of states carrying equal but opposite current is distorted . by subjecting the ring to a strong perturbation
the persistent current can be changed non - adiabatically as the occupation of the single - electron states changes@xcite .
here we consider two models of a one - dimensional ring , continuous and discrete , and investigate the response to a short - lived thz perturbation .
the electrons confined to the ring are spinless and coulomb interactions are neglected .
the main objective is to see whether a current can be induced in the ring at a zero magnetic field by introducing a left / right asymmetry in the radiation pulse .
the comparison between the two models shows identical results at least for the system parameters considered in the present work .
we will also look at how impurities and ratchet - like potentials affect the resulting current .
we consider a 1d quantum ring of radius @xmath0 containing a few noninteracting , spinless electrons .
the ring is described by the following unperturbed hamiltonian in polar coordinates : @xmath1 where @xmath2 is the effective mass of electrons .
the hamiltonian is symmetric under any rotation transformation .
consequently @xmath3 commutes with the angular momentum operator @xmath4 .
the common set of the eigenfunctions for the two commuting operators @xmath3 and @xmath5 are @xmath6 with @xmath7 .
the eigenvalue equations for the two operators are @xmath8 except for @xmath9 all the states are doubly degenerate and carry a net persistent current that is normally quantified by the expectation value of the orbital magnetization operator @xmath10 the discrete hamiltonian of the 1d ring@xcite is @xmath11,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the angular momentum operator @xmath12.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the vectors @xmath13 with @xmath14 define the @xmath15 points of the ring of radius @xmath0 separated by a linear distance @xmath16 .
the energy unit is @xmath17 .
the common set of eigenvectors of the two commuting operators , @xmath3 and @xmath5 , is @xmath18 with @xmath19 ( for n even ) and @xmath20 is the angle corresponding to the point @xmath21 of the ring ( in polar coordinates ) .
the eigenvalue equations for the two operators are @xmath22 in the limit @xmath23 the eigenvalue set from the previous equations recover the values from the continuous model ( eqs .
( [ evh0 ] ) and ( [ evlz ] ) ) .
if the ring contains impurities or ratchets , its hamiltonian will be completed with the diagonal energies @xmath24 @xmath25 at chosen points on the ring .
we define impurities by adding a diagonal energy @xmath26 at three selected points @xmath27 . in case of ratchets@xcite ,
four equidistant saw - tooth potentials are placed at the points @xmath28 of the ring .
the saw - tooth potential is defined by a series of three consecutive energies : @xmath29 the net current in the discrete model is also calculated from the expectation value of the orbital magnetization ( eq . ( [ mz ] ) ) . at @xmath30 the quantum ring is radiated by a short thz pulse of duration @xmath31 and frequencies @xmath32 , @xmath33 : @xmath34 the spatial component of the external pulse @xmath35 is given by a combination of a dipole and a rotated quadrupole with amplitude @xmath36 : @xmath37 the deflection angle @xmath38 between the dipole and quadrupole fields makes the external perturbation asymmetric for any values @xmath39 . the perturbation is shown in fig
. [ fig1 ] . and ( b ) @xmath40 .
the parameter values are listed in the caption of fig .
bright / yellow regions indicate maxima in the potential.,width=302 ] to follow the time - evolution of the system we use the density matrix to specify the state of the system .
the ground - state density operator @xmath41 is constructed in terms of a given set of the eigenvectors @xmath42 of the initial time independent hamiltonian @xmath43 with the fermi distribution @xmath44 .
the equation of motion for the density operator @xmath45\ ] ] is inconvenient for numerical evaluation so we resort instead to the time - evolution operator @xmath46 , defined by @xmath47 , leading to a simpler equation of motion @xmath48 with the initial condition @xmath49 .
we solve the equation in the truncated basis of eigenvectors @xmath50 ( eq .
( [ esh0 ] ) ) for the continuous hamiltonian ( eq . ( [ h0 ] ) ) or in the finite basis of eigenvectors of the discrete hamiltonian ( eqs . ( [ esh1 ] ) or ( [ himp ] ) ) using the crank - nicholson scheme.@xcite we calculate the time evolution of the system and extend especially the calculation of the induced current in the ring to times after the dependent perturbation vanishes . for quantifying the currents induced by @xmath51 we calculate the expectation value of the orbital magnetization @xmath52 ( eq . [ mz ] ) in terms of the density matrix @xmath53.\ ] ] when the perturbation vanishes the time evolution of the system will be described by the time - evolution operator generated by the non - perturbed ( and time independent ) hamiltonian @xmath3 .
the energy of the system will be constant @xmath54={\textstyle \sum}_l~ e_l \rho_{ll}(t_f),\end{aligned}\ ] ] and also the magnetization for a 1d pure ring @xmath55=-\mu_b{\textstyle \sum}_l~ l\rho_{ll}(t_f).\end{aligned}\ ] ] we note that the non - zero values of the induced magnetization in eq.([indm ] ) can be obtained only by different occupation of opposite current carrying states @xmath50 and @xmath56 ( @xmath57 at @xmath58 ) . on the other hand ,
the magnetization for a ring with a finite width will oscillate in time in the presence of a perpendicular magnetic field due to coupling of radial and angular modes of density oscillations , plasma oscillations.@xcite
we use the effective mass of an electron in a gaas , @xmath59 . for modeling the ring with @xmath60 electrons we set the radius to @xmath61 nm and in the discrete model use @xmath62 points .
initially the system is in its ground state where right and left rotating states , @xmath63 and @xmath64 , are equally occupied and the current consequently zero ( @xmath65 ) . in fig .
[ fig2 ] we see that if the external pulse applied to the ring , like the ring itself , is left / right symmetric ( @xmath66 ) a current can not be induced since the occupation of states remains symmetric .
however , by introducing an asymmetry to the perturbation a constant current along the ring appears in both the continuous and discrete models . calculated with the discrete model ( upper ) and continuous model ( lower ) for the 1d ring described in the text .
three values of the deflection angle are presented , @xmath67 .
the parameters of the external perturbation are @xmath68mev , @xmath69mev , @xmath70mev and @xmath71mev .
the frequencies are tuned to be comparable with the bohr frequencies @xmath72mev and @xmath73mev .
the inset presents the time evolution of the absorbed energy ( in mev ) of the discrete system for @xmath74 and the time dependent part of the external perturbation w(t ) .
, title="fig:",width=302 ] calculated with the discrete model ( upper ) and continuous model ( lower ) for the 1d ring described in the text .
three values of the deflection angle are presented , @xmath67 .
the parameters of the external perturbation are @xmath68mev , @xmath69mev , @xmath70mev and @xmath71mev .
the frequencies are tuned to be comparable with the bohr frequencies @xmath72mev and @xmath73mev .
the inset presents the time evolution of the absorbed energy ( in mev ) of the discrete system for @xmath74 and the time dependent part of the external perturbation w(t ) .
, title="fig:",width=283 ] for a weak excitation a perturbation analysis to 2nd order ( in no external magnetic field ) reveals that , for a single electron initially in the ground state @xmath75 , the difference between the transition probabilities to the states @xmath76 and @xmath77 is proportional to @xmath78 @xmath79 where @xmath80 is a double integral depending on the parameters of the external perturbation .
this implies that for a deflection angle of @xmath81 the resulting current is at maximum .
[ fig4 ] shows the induced magnetization ( continuous model ) after the perturbation vanishes ( @xmath82 ) as a function of the deflection angle @xmath38 for three values of @xmath83 . vs. the deflection angle @xmath38 for three different values of @xmath83 ( continuous model ) .
the external perturbation parameters are the same as in fig . 2 .
the scale of the two lower curves has been magnified as indicated .
the inset depicts the time dependent part of the external perturbation for the three situations .
, width=283 ] as a function of time calculated with the discrete model of the 1d ring .
the external perturbation is asymmetric ( @xmath81 ) with the same parameters as in fig . 2 ( except for @xmath36=135mev ) .
the ring contains four ratchets with @xmath84 ( explained in text ) .
the almost constant blue line is the time evolution of @xmath85 for a pure ring .
( b ) the ring with ratchets plus impurities present ( @xmath86 ) .
, width=272 ] clearly for strong excitation ( lower @xmath83 in fig . [ fig4 ] )
the results do not depend on @xmath38 as eq .
( [ probsin ] ) shows , but have a more complex dependence on the exact form of the perturbation .
as @xmath83 decreases the maximum of the current shifts away from @xmath81 .
the identical behavior is seen in the discrete model .
the constant magnitude of the current generated in the system by a left / right asymmetric excitation can be destroyed by the inclusion of ratchets and impurity potential as can be seen in fig .
[ fig5 ] . in fig .
[ fig6 ] we see that the frequency of current oscillations depends heavily upon the strength of the ratchet potential .
as the height of the ratchets increases the frequency grows .
furthermore the reduction of the current occurs even though the ratchet potential is very weak .
it is interesting that the period of oscillation can be much larger than that of the applied perturbation . as a function of time calculated with the continuous model of the 1d ring .
the external perturbation is asymmetric ( @xmath81 ) with the same parameters as in fig . 2 .
the ring contains four ratchets ( explained in text ) .
the strength of ratchet potential @xmath88 in ( a ) and @xmath89 in ( b ) .
the dashed red curve is the time evolution of @xmath85 for a pure ring . @xmath90mev .
, width=257 ] calculated with the discrete model .
the ring is radiated with a symmetric pulse ( @xmath91 ) .
the perturbation parameters are the same as in fig . 2 ( except for @xmath36=135mev ) . ( a )
four sticks symmetrically placed on the ring .
each stick is defined by adding a diagonal energy @xmath92 at points @xmath93 of the ring .
the constant line is the time evolution of @xmath85 for a pure ring .
( b ) four ratchets on the ring ( @xmath84 ) .
( c ) same as ( b ) plus impurities present ( @xmath86 ) .
, width=272 ] the reader may now wonder if it would be possible to excite a current in the system by applying a left / right symmetric external electric field , but at the same time having an asymmetric static potential on the ring .
we have tried several asymmetric potentials on the ring and different strength of the external excitation , but have not been successful in generating a steady dc current .
some results are seen in fig .
clearly , as we have drawn attention to above , the frequency of the current oscillations can be made very low compared to the dominant frequencies included in the excitation pulse .
for a quantum ring in no external magnetic field a left / right asymmetric excitation is essential for the appearance of a circulating current . in an external magnetic field
the energy of states whose orbital angular momentum is aligned with the field is lowered , thus breaking the symmetry and generating a dc current .
here we have seen that a similar effect can be accomplished by an asymmetric excitation pulse at zero magnetic field , but a dc current can not be generated by a left / right symmetric excitation even though the ring itself is made asymmetric by a static potential or by change to the geometry , breaking the perfect circular symmetry .
the introduction of a ratchet potential in the ring that is excited by an asymmetric external field changes the dc current created into an ac current with arbitrary low frequency depending on the intensity of the ratchet .
this is a clear nonlinear behavior that could not be observed by traditional linear response methods .
the research was partly funded by the icelandic natural science foundation , and the university of iceland research fund .
m.n . was supported by a nato science fellowship and ceres .
we acknowledge instructive discussion with dr .
cheng - hung chang , and prof .
a. aldea . | we study a non - adiabatic excitation of an electron system in a 1d quantum ring radiated by a short thz pulse .
the response of two models , a continuous and discrete , is explored . by introducing a spatial asymmetry in the external perturbation
a net current can be generated in the ring at a zero magnetic field .
effect of impurities and ratchets are investigated in combination with symmetric and asymmetric external excitation . |
numerical simulations indicate that the majority of massive galaxies at @xmath1=13 , the epoch when galaxies were most rapidly growing their stellar mass , are continuously fed by gas which promotes and maintains star formation @xcite .
the accretion of gas from the halo , through minor mergers or by cold streams from the inter - galactic medium appears to dominate over that from major mergers and suggests that the star formation within the inter - stellar medium ( ism ) of high - redshift galaxies are driven by internal dynamical processes @xcite .
the observational challenge is now to quantitatively measure the internal properties ( e.g. gas surface density , disk scaling relations , chemical abundances , distribution and intensity of star - formation ) and so test whether the prescriptions developed to describe star - formation processes within disks at @xmath1=0 are applicable in the rapidly evolving ism of gas rich galaxies at high - redshift @xcite .
high - spatial resolution observations of star - forming galaxies around @xmath1212 have shown that a large fraction of the population have their ionised gas in large , rotating disks ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
in contrast to low - redshift , these disks have high gas fractions ( @xmath13=2080% ) and so are turbulent , with much higher velocity dispersions given their rotational velocity ( @xmath14=30100kms@xmath3 , v@xmath15/@xmath160.21 ) compared to the thin disks of local spirals @xcite . if low- and high- redshift disks can be linked in a single evolutionary model , then the redshift evolution of disk scaling relations ( i.e. between size , luminosity , rotational speed and gas fraction ) providing a diagnostic of the relationship between the recent- and past averaged- star - formation with the dark halo and the dominant mode of assembly .
the pioneering work of @xcite and @xcite provided the first systematic study of the evolution of the stellar luminosity ( m@xmath8 ) versus circular velocity ( tully - fisher ; @xcite ) relation , deriving an increase in luminosity at a fixed circular velocity of @xmath6l@xmath8=1.7@xmath17 up to @xmath121 , reflecting the change in star formation efficiency over this period ( see also @xcite and @xcite ) .
since the @xmath5-band luminosity is sensitive to recent star formation , attempts have also been made to measure the evolution of the stellar mass ( m@xmath18 ) tully - fisher relation which reflects the relation between the past - average star - formation history and halo mass .
although the current samples sizes are drawn from a heterogeneous mix of populations , evidence is accumulating that there is only modest evolution in the stellar - mass tully - fisher relation to @xmath121.5 , with stronger evolution above @xmath121.5 @xcite .
theoretical mode of galaxy formation have struggled to reproduce the zero - point and slope of the tully - fisher relation , tending to produce disks that rotate too fast given their luminosities ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , although some of this discrepancy has been alleviated by improving the recipes for starburst driven feedback ( e.g. * ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
a second potential observational consequence of differences in fueling mechanisms for disk galaxies is their chemical abundance distributions .
the primary indicator of chemical evolution is typically traced by oxygen as its relative abundance surpasses all elements heavier than helium and it is present almost entirely in the gas phase @xcite . in the thin disk of the milky - way and other local spirals
, there is a negative radial metallicity gradient ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
in contrast , the thick disk of the milky way displays no radial abundance gradient @xcite .
thick disks are ubiquitous in spiral galaxies , and typically contain 1025% of their baryonic mass , yet the thick disk of the milky - way contains no stars younger than 8gyr @xcite .
thick disks are comparable in many physical properties to the apparently turbulent disks of high - redshift galaxies , and so determining the early form of their abundance gradient ( positive or negative ) will provide a key indication of how quickly enrichment proceeds in inner and outer regions , as well as the interplay between star formation , clump migration and gas accretion from the halo or igm @xcite . indeed , if the majority of the gas accretion in high - redshift galaxies is via accretion from the igm along filaments which intersect and deposit pristine material onto the galaxy disk at radii of 1020kpc , then the inner disks of galaxies should be enriched by star - formation and supernovae whilst the the outer - disk continually diluted by pristine gas , leaving strong negative abundance gradients @xcite which will flatten as the gas accretion from the igm becomes less efficient , and the gas redistributed , at lower redshift . to gain a complete census of how galaxies assemble the bulk of their stellar mass ,
it is clearly important to study the dynamics , chemical properties and internal star - formation processes in a well - selected sample of high - redshift galaxies . to this end
, we have combined panoramic ( degree - scale ) imaging with near - infrared narrow - band filters , to carry out the high - z emission line survey ( hizels ) survey , targeting h@xmath0 emitting galaxies in four precise ( @xmath19=0.03 ) redshift slices : @xmath1=0.40 , 0.84 , 1.47 & 2.23 @xcite .
this survey provides a large , luminosity - limited sample of _ identically _ selected h@xmath0 emitters at epochs spanning the apparent peak of the cosmic star - formation rate density , and provides a powerful resource for studying the properties of representative galaxies ( i.e. star - formation rates @xmath410sm@xmath20/yr ) which will likely evolve into @xmath21 galaxies by @xmath1=0 , but are seen at a time when they are assembling the bulk of their stellar mass , and thus at a critical stage in their evolutionary history .
one of the key benefits of selecting a high - redshift galaxy population using h@xmath0 alone is the simplicity in comparison to similar luminosity - limited samples of star - forming galaxies in the local universe .
together , these comparison samples can be used to search for differences in the physical properties of the ism that potentially provide insight into the factors influencing star formation at high redshift . in this paper
, we present adaptive optical assisted ( @xmath4kpc scale ) integral field spectroscopy with sinfoni of nine star - forming galaxies selected from the hizels survey in the redshift range @xmath1=0.842.23 the sinfoni - hizels ( shizels ) survey .
we use these data to investigate the dynamical properties of the galaxies , the evolution of the luminosity and stellar mass scaling relations ( through the tully - fisher relation ) , and the star formation and enrichment within their ism .
we use a cosmology with @xmath22=0.73 , @xmath23=0.27 , and h@xmath24=72kms@xmath3mpc@xmath3 . in this cosmology , at the median redshift of our survey , @xmath1=1.47 , a spatial resolution of 0.1@xmath25 corresponds to a physical scale of 0.8kpc .
all quoted magnitudes are on the ab system and we use a chabrier imf @xcite .
.notes : ee denotes the encircled energy within a radius of 0.1@xmath25 . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ]
all nine galaxies display velocity gradients in their h@xmath0 kinematics , with peak - to - peak velocity gradients ranging from 40400kms@xmath3 and a ratio of peak - to - peak difference ( @xmath26 ) , to line of sight velocity dispersion ( @xmath14 ) of @xmath26/@xmath14=0.32.9 .
although a ratio of @xmath26/@xmath14=0.4 has traditionally been used to crudely differentiate rotating systems from mergers @xcite , more detailed kinematic modelling is essential to reliably differentiate rotating systems from mergers @xcite .
we therefore begin by modelling each velocity field with a rotating disk in order to estimate the disk inclination and true rotational velocity ( we exclude shizels4 & 12 from this analysis as their velocity fields are only marginally resolved by our data ) .
although there have been several functional forms to describe rotation curves ( such as the `` multi - parameter fit '' ; e.g. @xcite or the universal rotation curve ; @xcite ) , the simplest model which provides a good fit to most rotation curves on @xmath4kpc scales is the arctan fit of the form @xmath27=@xmath28@xmath29@xmath30 , where @xmath29 is the asymptotic rotational velocity and r@xmath31 is the effective radius at which the rotation curve turns over @xcite . to fit the two - dimensional velocity fields of the galaxies in our sample , we construct a two - dimensional kinematic model with six free parameters ( v@xmath32 , r@xmath33 , [ x / y ] centre , position angle ( pa ) and disk inclination ) and use a genetic algorithm @xcite to find the best model . during the fitting ,
we limit the parameters ranges to those allowed by the data ( e.g. the [ x / y ] center and turn over radius , r@xmath33 , must be within the sinfoni field of view ; the maximum circular velocity must be @xmath342@xmath17 the maximum velocity seen in the data ; pa=0180@xmath35 , and @xmath36=090 ) .
we then generate 10@xmath37 models within random initial parameters between these ranges and find the lowest @xmath38 .
this process is repeated ( up to 100 times ) , but in each new generation we remove ( up to ) 10% of the worst fits and contract the remaining parameter space search by up to 5% centered on the best - fit .
we examine whether the fit has converged by examining whether all of the models in a generation are within @xmath39=1 of the best - fit model .
the errors on the final parameters ( table 3 ) reflect the range of acceptable models from _ all _ of the models attempted .
the best - fit kinematic maps and velocity residuals are shown in fig .
[ fig:2dmaps ] , whilst the best - fit inclinations and disk rotation speeds are given in table 2 , along with the @xmath38 .
all galaxies show small - scale deviations from the best - fit model , as indicated by the typical r.m.s , @xmath34data@xmath10model@xmath40=30@xmath1110kms@xmath3 , with a range from @xmath34data@xmath10model@xmath40=1570kms@xmath3 .
these offsets could be caused by the effects of gravitational instability , or simply due to the unrelexed dynamical state indicated by the high velocity dispersions ( @xmath14=96@xmath1124kms@xmath3 ) .
the goodness of fit and small scale deviations from the best - fit models are similar to those of 18 galaxies in the sins survey which show the most prominent rotational support ( r.m.s of 1080kms@xmath3 and @xmath38=0.220 ; @xcite ) , as well as to the high - resolution studies of gravitationally lensed galaxies from @xcite and @xcite ( which have an average @[email protected] ) .
we therefore conclude that the disk model provides an adequate fit to the majority of these galaxies and that the velocity fields of most galaxies are consistent with the kinematics of turbulent rotating disks .
we use the best - fit dynamical model to identify the major kinematic axis , and extract the one dimensional rotation curve and velocity dispersion profiles , and show these in fig .
[ fig:1dprofiles ] .
we define the zero point in the velocity using the dynamical center of the galaxy , whilst the error bars for the velocities are derived from the formal @xmath41 uncertainty in the velocity arising from the gaussian profile fits to the h@xmath0 emission .
we note that in the one - dimensional rotation curves in fig .
[ fig:1dprofiles ] alternate points show independent data .
we also note that the data have not been folded about the zero velocity , so that the degree of symmetry can be assessed . whilst this modelling provides a useful test of whether the dynamics can be described by disk - like rotation , a better criterion for distinguishing between motion from disturbed kinematics is the `` kinemetry '' which measures the asymmetry of the velocity field and line - of - sight velocity dispersion maps for each galaxy . this technique has been well calibrated and tested at low redshift ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) , whilst at high redshift it has been used to determine the strength of deviations of the observed velocity and dispersion maps from an ideal rotating disk @xcite . in this modelling ,
the velocity and velocity dispersion maps are described by a series of concentric ellipses of increasing semi - major axis length , as defined by the system center , position angle and inclination . along each ellipse , the moment map as a function of angle is extracted and decomposed into its fourier series which have coefficients @xmath42 at each radii ( see @xcite for more details ) . in a noiseless , idealised disk , the coefficients of
the fourier expansion would be zero .
any deviations from the ideal case that occur in a disturbed disk ( e.g. warps , spiral structures , streaming motions or mergers in the extreme cases ) induce strong variations in the higher - order fourier coefficients . to ensure that reliable measurements of the kinemetry parameters can be made , we first construct a grid of 2000 model disks and mergers with noise and spatial resolution appropriate for our sinfoni observations . for the model disks , we allow disk scale lengths and rotation curve turn over lengths ( r@xmath33 ) from 0.53kpc , rotation speeds and peak velocity dispersions from 10300kms@xmath3 and random inclinations and sky position angles .
the model mergers typically comprise 23 of these galaxy - scale components separated by 120kpc in projection .
the dynamics of each of these components randomly ranges from dispersion dominated to rotating systems .
we then use the kinemetry code from @xcite and measure the velocity and velocity dispersion asymmetry for all of these models .
following @xcite , we define the velocity asymmetry ( k@xmath43 ) as the average of the @xmath42 coefficients with @xmath44=25 , normalised to the first cosine term in the fourier series ( which represents circular motion ) ; and the velocity dispersion asymmetry ( k@xmath45 ) as the average of the first five coefficients ( @xmath44=15 ) also normalised to the first cosine term . for
an ideal disk , k@xmath46 and k@xmath45 will be zero . in a merging system ,
strong deviations from the idealised case causes large k@xmath46 and k@xmath45 values , which can reach k@xmath47k@xmath4810 for very disturbed systems .
the total asymmetry , k@xmath49 is @xmath50=k@xmath51+k@xmath52 . for our mock sample of model disks , we recover k@[email protected] compared to k@xmath54=2@xmath111 for the mergers . for the shizels galaxies in our sample , we measure the velocity and velocity dispersion asymmetry , ( shizels4 & 12 have too few independent spatial resolution elements across the galaxy so we omit these from the kinemetry analysis ) .
@xcite show that an incorrect choice of centre induces artificial power in the derived kinemetry coefficients .
we therefore allow the dynamical center to vary over the range allowed by the family of best - fit two dimensional models and measure the kinemetry in each case .
we also perturb the velocity and dispersion maps by the errors on each pixel and re - measure the asymmetry , reporting the velocity and dispersion asymmetries , ( k@xmath55 and k@xmath45 respectively ) along with their errors in table 3 .
we use the total asymmetry , k@xmath49 to differentiate disks ( [email protected] ) from mergers [email protected] ) . for the galaxies in our sample ,
five have are classified as disks ( d ) , whilst two more indicate mergers ( m ) , and the final two are compact ( c ) .
as expected , the two galaxies that are classified as mergers from the kinemetry ( shizels10 & 14 ) have the highest @xmath38 ( @xmath589 ) from the dynamical modelling .
both of these systems are noteworthy ; the one - dimensional rotation curve of shizels10 ( extracted from the major kinematic axis ) appears regular and suggests rotation , but the two - dimensional velocity field reveals extended ( @xmath45kpc ) emission to the east , which may be due to a companion or tidal material .
the dynamics of the other galaxy classified as a merger , shizels14 , are clearly more complex .
the h@xmath0 is extended across @xmath414kpc with a peak - to - peak velocity gradient of @xmath4480@xmath1140kms@xmath3 .
qualitatively , the one- and two - dimensional velocity field of shizels14 are consistent with an early stage prograde encounter , with each component in the merger displaying approximately equal peak - to - peak velocity gradients .
the northern most component is also more highly obscured than the southern component ( as evident from the _ hst _ @xmath59-band imaging ; fig .
[ fig:2dmaps ] ) .
overall , the fraction of rotating systems within our sample , @xmath455% , is consistent with that found from other h@xmath0 ifu surveys of high - redshift star - forming galaxies ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
since our two dimensional dynamical data resolve the turn over in the rotation curves ( as evident from fig .
[ fig:1dprofiles ] ) , we can use our results to investigate how the disk scaling relations for the galaxies in our sample compare to galaxy disks at @xmath1=0 .
the relation between the rest - frame @xmath5-band luminosity ( m@xmath60 ) and rotational velocity and that between the total stellar - mass ( m@xmath18 ) and rotational velocity define the tully - fisher relations @xcite .
the first of these relations has a strong contribution from the short - term star - formation activity whilst the second provides a better proxy for the integrated star - formation history . indeed the latter relationship may reflect how rotationally - supported galaxies formed , perhaps suggesting the presence of self - regulating processes for star - formation in galactic disks .
the slope , intercept and scatter of the tully - fisher relations and their evolution are therefore key parameters that any successful galaxy formation model must reproduce ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
since we wish to compare our dynamical measurements with those of other high - redshift galaxies where similar data exist , it is important to measure the rotational velocity in a consistent manner . whilst the _ arctan _ function is useful for describing the overall shape of the rotation curve ( in both one and two - dimensional data ) , it provides an extrapolation of the rotational velocity , which may not be warranted especially if the rotation curve does not flatten in the data .
equally , since any measurement of the observed peak - to - peak rotational velocity ( v@xmath61 ) is sensitive to the radius at which it has been possible to detect the dynamics , this measurement varies from both object - to - object depending on both the extent of the galaxy and signal - to - noise of the observations and can therefore give biased measurements when comparing samples .
a more robust measurement is that of the velocity at 2.2 times the disk scale length ( v@xmath62 ) .
this has a better physical basis since it measures the peak rotational velocity for a pure exponential disk @xcite and provides the closest match the radio ( 21 cm ) line widths for local galaxies @xcite .
of course , the light profile of high - redshift galaxies are unlikely to follow pure exponential disk profiles , but it provides a reasonable estimate of where the rotation curve flattens , and as we will see below , is a good approximation of both v@xmath61 and v@xmath32 in our data . to measure v@xmath62 in our data , we therefore measure the h@xmath0 intensity as a function of radius in our galaxies ( centered at the dynamical center and using the inclination and position angle set by the best fit two - dimensional kinematic model ) and infer the disk scale length ( which ranges from 0.72.7kpc and has a median of [email protected] ) .
we then measure the rotational velocity at 2.2 disk scale lengths and report these in table 3 .
the errors on these quantities are derived from both the errors on the observed velocity at this radius and the formal errors on the two - dimensional model velocity fields .
for reference , we note that owing to the high resolution and signal - to - noise of our data , we have been able to resolve the flattening in the rotation curves , the ratio of the maximum ( observed ) peak - to - peak velocity ( v@xmath61 ) to v@xmath63 in our sample is v@xmath64/v@[email protected] whilst the ratio of asymptotic velocity ( v@xmath32 ) to v@xmath62 is v@xmath65/v@[email protected] . in fig .
[ fig : tf_b ] we show the @xmath1=0 tully - fisher relation from @xcite and overlay the @xmath1=0.842.23 measurements from our sample ( using v@xmath63 as the preferred measured of rotational velocity ) .
we also include the field sample ( @xmath66=0.33 ) from @xcite , the @xmath121 field samples from @xcite and @xcite , the @xmath1=13 lensed samples from @xcite and @xcite and the @xmath122 and @xmath123 star - forming galaxies from @xcite and @xcite respectively .
it is clear from fig .
[ fig : tf_b ] that the @xmath1=0 @xmath5-band tully - fisher relation provides a poor fit to high - redshift data , with most of the high - redshift galaxies lying above the local relation .
since the high - redshift sample represents a heterogeneous mix of populations , all with different and complex selection functions , we limit our search for the evolution in the tully - fisher to its zero - point only .
we therefore fix the slope to the @xmath1=0 relation and in each of the seven redshift bins from @xmath1=0.03 we derive the zero - point offset using a non - linear least squares regression ( weighted by the velocity errors in each galaxy ) and show these results in fig .
[ fig : tf_b ] . for a fixed slope
, the strongest evolution occurs between @xmath1=01 , and in this range the zero - point evolution follows @xmath67=(@[email protected])@xmath1 up to @xmath121 and then significantly flattens above @xmath1=1 to @xmath6m@xmath68=(@[email protected])@xmath69([email protected] ) up to @xmath123 .
since the rest - frame @xmath5-band is dominated by recent star - formation activity , the strong evolution in the rest - frame @xmath5-band tully - fisher zero - point between @xmath1=0 and @xmath1=1 ( 2magnitudes or a factor @xmath46 in luminosity ) and then flattening to @xmath123 , is consistent with the evolution of the star - formation volume density with redshift @xcite .
we can compare this evolution to galaxy formation models , and in fig .
[ fig : tf_b ] we also overlay the predicted zero - point offset from the semi - analytic models from @xcite and @xcite .
the @xcite semi - analytic models suggest that for a fixed circular velocity , the luminosity of a galaxy at @xmath121 should be a factor up to @xmath42.5@xmath17 higher than today @xcite , although the data are suggestive of markedly stronger evolution than predicted by the models @xmath121 .
in contrast the predictions from the @xcite model predicts very little evolution in the @xmath5-band tully - fisher relation ( @xmath700.2 magnitudes between @xmath1=04 ) . in this model ,
the apparent lack of evolution in the @xmath5-band tully - fisher relation in the galaxy formation models occurs because the specific star - formation rate evolves rapidly with both mass and redshift .
although the model approximately matches the evolution of the star - formation rate density with redshift , this is offset by an increase in the specific star - formation rate in low mass galaxies .
moreover , since the dark halos are more concentrated at high - redshift , a fixed v@xmath71 does not select the same mass halo at the two epochs ( for a fixed v@xmath72 , a halo at @xmath1=0 is a factor @xmath41.7@xmath17 more massive than at @xmath1=2 ) .
this combination of the evolution of the specific star - formation rate with mass and redshift , and the evolution in the halo densities for a fixed v@xmath73 approximately cancel to predict that there should be very little evolution in the @xmath5-band tully - fisher relation .
the rest - frame @xmath5-band tully - fisher relation is sensitive to recent star formation , and so perhaps the more fundamental relation is the stellar mass tully - fisher relation ( m@xmath18 versus v@xmath32 ) which reflects the time - integrated star - formation history . the @xmath1=0 stellar mass tully - fisher relation is well established @xcite , and in fig .
[ fig : tf ] we combine the stellar mass estimates with the inclination - corrected rotation speed of our galaxies to investigate how this varies as a function of redshift . again , in this plot , we also include a number of high - redshift measurements ; at @xmath120.6 and @xmath121.3 from @xcite and @xcite , the @xmath1=13 lensed galaxy surveys @xcite as well as the the @xmath122 sins and @xmath743 sinfoni ifu surveys @xcite .
where necessary , we have corrected the samples to use v@xmath62 using v@xmath62/v@xmath64=0.93 if only v@xmath61 is given in the literature ( see also @xcite ) . in comparison to the rest - frame @xmath5-band tully - fisher relation , fig .
[ fig : tf ] shows that the the redshift evolution in the stellar mass tully - fisher relation is weak . due to the heterogeneous selection functions of these various surveys
, we again restrict the search to the evolution in the zero - point with redshift .
we therefore construct the same seven redshift bins from @xmath1=03 as in [ sec : btf ] and measure the zero - point offset in each bin ( using a non - linear least squares regression weighted by the velocity errors in each galaxy ; ( fig .
[ fig : tf ] ) .
the data suggest that the zero - point offset from @xmath1=2.5 to @xmath1=0 is @xmath6m@xmath75/m@[email protected] ( i.e. at a fixed circular velocity the stellar mass of galaxies has increased by a factor @xmath42.0 between @xmath1=2.5 and @xmath1=0 ) .
the weak evolution in the stellar mass tully - fisher relation ( in particular below @xmath121 ) is due to the fact that individual galaxies evolve roughly along the scaling relation rather than due to weak evolution in the galaxies themselves ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
this indicates that the baryon conversion efficiency , @xmath76=(m@xmath18/m@xmath77)/(@xmath78/@xmath79 , is fixed with redshift . in fig .
[ fig : tf ] we also compare the zero - point evolution in the tully - fisher relation to that from semi - analytic models from @xcite and @xcite and the cosmological hydrodynamic galaxies intergalactic medium interaction calculation ( gimic , @xcite ) .
the @xcite and gimic simulations both use the same underlying dark matter distribution , although the gimic simulation follows the hydrodynamical evolution of gas , radiative cooling , star formation and chemo - dynamics , and includes a prescription for energetic feedback from supernovae .
in contrast to simulations of small periodic volumes , gimics unique initial conditions enable it to follow , at high - resolution , cosmologically representative volumes to @xmath1=0 ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . to search for evolution in the tully - fisher zero - point in the simulations , we only consider galaxies with star - formation rates @xmath401m@xmath2yr@xmath3 ( at all redshifts ) so that a reasonable comparison to observational data can be made
both the semi - analytic and hydrodynamic simulations shown in fig . [ fig : tf ] predict strong evolution , with the gimic simulation suggesting that , at a fixed circular velocity the stellar mass of galaxies should increase by [email protected]@xmath17 between @xmath1=2 and @xmath1=0 .
this evolution is matched by the semi - analytic model from @xcite .
however , the semi - analytic model from @xcite predicts somewhat stronger evolution in the stellar mass for a fixed circular velocity .
it is interesting to note that the gimic simulation predicts that the scatter in the tully - fisher relation should not evolve strongly with redshift ( for a fixed circular velocity , the scatter is 25@xmath115% over the redshift range @xmath1=03 ) . our dynamical measurements ,
particularly when combined with those from @xcite and @xcite , are sufficiently large in number to compare to the models , and fig .
[ fig : tf ] shows that the scatter in the observations is consistent with the models ( for all but the last bin in redshift where the number of data - points is @xmath348 ) , , suggesting that the samples may now be sufficiently large ( with rotation curves well enough sampled ) that the scatter is intrinsic .
another route to examine the evolution in the @xmath5-band and stellar mass tully - fisher relations is to combine the offsets and measure the evolution of the mean mass - to - light ratio with redshift .
we caution that the conversion of zero - point offsets to offsets in mass - to - light assumes that star - forming galaxies form a homologous family and that the evolution is a manifestation of underlying relations between mass - to - light ratio and other parameters , such as star - formation history , gas accretion and stellar feedback . under these assumptions , in fig .
[ fig : mlz ] we show the evolution of the rest - frame @xmath5-band mass - to - light ratio .
as expected from the zero - point tully - fisher offsets , this figure shows that the average mass to light ratio of star - forming galaxies decreases strongly from @xmath1=0 up to @xmath1=1 and then flattens .
this behavior is consistent with the previous demonstration that star - forming galaxies at high - redshift have lower stellar masses and higher @xmath5-band luminosities .
the strongest evolution occurs up to @xmath121 , @xmath6m@xmath18/l@[email protected] , consistent with previous studies @xcite ( the fractional change in mass - to - light ratio over this period is @xmath6(m / l@xmath80)/(m / l@xmath8)@xmath93.5 between @xmath1=1.5 and @xmath1=0 , with most of the evolution occuring below @xmath1=1 ) .
we note that we examined whether the evolution in the mass - to - light ratio could be reproduced using simple star - formation histories , ranging from i ) a constant star - formation rate ( with a formation redshift , @xmath81=48 ) ; or ii ) a set of exponentially decreasing star - formation rates with @xmath82-folding times ranging from 0.2510gyr ( and formation redshifts ranging from @xmath81=210 ) .
however , using these simple star - formation histories ( adopting a chabrier imf with 0.51 solar metallicities and the padova ( 1994 ) stellar evolution tracks ) , we are unable to find a acceptable fit with a single star - formation history .
this could be because the `` average '' star - formation history is more complex than a simple star - formation model , or because the current low and high - redshift data can not be linked by a simple evolutionary model .
however , in fig .
[ fig : mlz ] we also overlay the predicted evolution of the @xmath5-band mass - to - light ratio from the semi - analytic models of @xcite and @xcite , both of which predict a sharp decline to @xmath121 and then flattening to higher redshift , which provides a reasonable match to the observations . in a @xmath83cdm cosmology
, the sizes of galaxy disks and their rotational velocities should be proportional to their parent dark halos , and since the halos are denser at higher redshift , for fixed circular velocity the disk sizes should scale inversely with hubble time @xcite . in this scenario , disks at @xmath1=1 and @xmath1=2 should be 1.8 and 3.0@xmath17 smaller respectively at fixed circular velocity . with the high - resolution measurements for the galaxies in our sample we can measure the extent of the h@xmath0 ( and together with the dynamics ) compare these relations at @xmath121.5 to star - forming disks at @xmath1=0 . in fig .
[ fig : rh_vmax ] we show the relation between the h@xmath0 half - light radius and rotational velocity for the galaxies in our sample ( using the asymptotic velocity as measured from the disk modeling ) . in this plot
, we also include the measurements from the sins galaxies from @xcite .
first , we note that the h@xmath0 half - light radii for the shizels galaxies ( @[email protected] ) are comparable to the average rest - frame uv / optical half light radii of star - forming galaxies at this redshift ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
in order to compare to @xmath1=0 data , we show the measurements of local disks from @xcite ( which is based on a compilation from @xcite and @xcite ) , but converting the disk scale length ( r@xmath85 ) to half - light radius using r@xmath86=1.68r@xmath85 , as appropriate for a disk with an exponential profile .
as can be seen from this figure , the high - redshift galaxies have half - light sizes ( deconvolved for seeing ) which are smaller for fixed circular velocity than those at @xmath1=0 .
fitting the local the @xmath1=0 relation to the high - redshift data ( only allowing a zero - point shift and inverse weighting the fit by the errors on each data - point ) suggests that this offset is a factor @xmath87/r@[email protected] , which is consistent ( given the smaller number statistics in the high - redshift measurements ) with that predicted from halo
disk scaling arguments ( @xcite ; see also @xcite ) .
the product of the rotational velocity and size of the disk define the specific angular momentum , and the evolution ( at a fixed circular velocity ) with redshift also encodes information on the relation between the star - formation processes in the disk and the halo spin parameters ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the offsets seen in the r@xmath86v@xmath32 relation compared to local scaling relations in fig .
[ fig : rh_vmax ] translate directly into offsets in the specific angular momentum for disks between @xmath1=0 and @xmath122 .
indeed , the offsets in r@xmath86v@xmath32 suggest that , for fixed circular velocity the specific angular momentum of disks at @xmath1=2 is a factor [email protected] lower than those at @xmath1=0 @xcite . thus ,
if high - redshift disks evolve into local disk galaxies , then the specific angular momentum must be increased , either by removing material with low specific angular momentum through outflows , or the galaxy disk must decouple from the halo and acquire angular momentum from accreting gas . finally , in fig .
[ fig : rh_vmax ] we also show the relation between stellar mass and h@xmath0 half light radius for the galaxies in our sample compared to the @xmath1=0 relation from @xcite .
the high - redshift galaxies are offset from the local relation by @xmath89/r@[email protected] for a fixed stellar mass .
although this is consistent with no evolution , we note that the predicted evolution for a fixed stellar mass between @xmath1=02 from the semi - analytic model from @xcite is @xmath91/r@xmath90=1.2 .
the internal enrichment ( and radial abundance gradients ) of high - redshift star - forming galaxies provides a tool for studying the gas accretion and mass assembly process such as gas exchange ( inflows / outflows ) with the intergalactic medium .
however , the small sizes of high redshift galaxies ( typically r@xmath9223kpc ; e.g. @xcite ) mean that sub - kpc resolution observations are required to measure the abundances reliably . at high redshifts the gas - phase metallicity of individual galaxies
can only be measured with limited accuracy , usually through the [ nii]/h@xmath0 emission - line ratio as an indicator of oxygen abundance and calibrations between gas phase emission line and stellar absorption metallicities , such as those obtained by @xcite .
recently , the first reliable spatially resolved measurements of [ nii]/h@xmath0 have been made in two highly amplified galaxies at @xmath121.52.5 , measuring strong , negative gradients and suggesting that if @xmath122 starbursts evolve into spiral disks today , then the gradients must flatten by @xmath6log(o / h)/@[email protected] over the last 810gyr @xcite .
other studies at lower resolution have derived weaker gradients that are negative , or consistent with zero for rotating and interacting galaxies @xcite .
positive gradients for interacting systems may be a signature of the redistribution of the metal - rich gas produced from a central starburst ; @xcite , or possibly as a result of inflow of relatively unenriched gas from the halo ( or igm ) if it is able to intersect the central regions of the disk galaxy without being disrupted . with our high - resolution ( and high signal - to - noise )
resolved observations we can measure the spatially resolved emission line ratios and hence the distribution of chemical abundances .
first , we note that the average galaxy integrated [ nii]/h@xmath0 ratio for the galaxies in our sample is [ nii]/h@xmath0 = [email protected] , which corresponds to 12+log(o / h)[email protected] ( equivalently , @[email protected]@xmath2 where z@xmath2 is 12+log(o / h)[email protected] ; @xcite ) .
we caution that the [ nii]/h@xmath0 ratio is sensitive to shock excitation , the ionization state of the gas , and the hard ionization radiation field from an active galactic nucleus @xcite
. however , our galaxy - integrated [ nii]/h@xmath0 ratios are consistent with star formation throughout the disk ( fig .
[ fig:1dspec ] ) . of the nine galaxies in our high - redshift sample , seven have [ n ii]@xmath936583 emission which is sufficiently strong ( s / n@xmath4010 in the combined spectra ) to allow spatially resolved studies of the chemical abundance gradients
. first we subtract the large - scale velocity motions from the data - cube ( as defined by the best - fit dynamical model ) .
we then use the disk inclination and position angle to define @xmath41kpc annuli ( centered at the dynamical center ) and integrate the spectrum in each annulus to measure the [ n ii]/h@xmath0 ratio . in fig .
[ fig : shizels_gradient ] we show the h@xmath0 emission line maps as well as the spatially resolved [ nii]/h@xmath0 ratio and overlay the best - fit linear regression in each case .
we report the gradients individually in table 2 . in all cases ,
the metallicity gradients are negative or consistent with zero , with an average @xmath6log(o / h)/@[email protected]@xmath110.005dexkpc@xmath3 , and similar to those recently found for a sample of @xmath121 starbursts @xcite .
this average gradient is steeper , but consistent with the thick disk of the milky - way , @xmath6log(o / h)/@[email protected]@xmath110.02dexkpc@xmath3 @xcite , which has a mass weighted age of 812gyr ( equivalently , a formation redshift @xmath1=24 ; @xcite ) . in fig .
[ fig : zgrad ] we compare the metallicity gradients to those from the gimic simulation ( which include cold gas accretion from the igm ) .
we calculate the disc phase metallicity in cylindrical coordinates ( along the disc ) at @xmath1=0 , 1 , 2 & 3 in radial bins of width 1kpc for all galaxies in the simulation with masses between m@xmath18=10@xmath94m@xmath2 . at @xmath122 , the model disk galaxies from the gimic simulation display negative metallicity gradients which are consistent with our observations
. moreover , between @xmath1=2 and @xmath1=0 the gimic simulation predicts that the gradient should flatten by a factor @xmath42 . in the simulation , this is a consequence of the outer disk enrichment increasing with decreasing redshift ( as the gas inflow rates decline and gas is redistributed ) progressively flattening the radial gradient within the thick disk .
this is qualitatively similar to the numerical models of @xcite and where the `` cold streams '' ( which are most prevalent around @xmath122 ) penetrate the halo and intersect and deposit relatively unenriched gas at onto the galaxy disks at @xmath415kpc @xcite .
we have presented ao - assisted , spatially resolved spectroscopy of nine star - forming galaxies at @xmath1=0.842.23 selected from the ukirt , wide - field narrow - band , hizels survey @xcite .
our main results can be summarised as : @xmath95 using h@xmath0 emission line dynamics , we find that the ratio of dynamical - to - dispersion support for the sample is @xmath26sin(@xmath36)/@xmath14=0.33 , with a median of [email protected] , which is consistent with similar measurements for both ao and non - ao studies of star - forming galaxies at this epoch(e.g . * ? ? ?
at least six galaxies have dynamics that suggest that their ionised gas is in a large , rotating disk ( in at least four of these we detect the turn over in their rotation curves ) . for these galaxies that resemble rotating systems , we model the galaxy velocity field and derive the inclination - corrected , asymptotic velocity .
@xmath95 we combine our dynamical observations with a number of previous studies of intermediate- and high - redshift galaxies ( in particular from @xcite and @xcite ) to investigate the evolution of the tully - fisher relation .
we show that there is strong evolution in the zero - point of the rest - frame @xmath5-band tully - fisher relations with redshift such that at a fixed circular velocity , the @xmath5-band luminosity increases by @xmath6m@xmath8=2mags up to @xmath122 ( a change in luminosity of a factor @xmath46 ; e.g. see also @xcite ) .
@xmath95 in contrast , the stellar mass tully - fisher relation shows much more modest evolution ; for a fixed circular velocity the average stellar masses has increased by a factor [email protected] between @xmath1=2 and @xmath1=0 ( e.g. see also @xcite ) .
the weak evolution in the stellar mass tully - fisher relation ( in particular below @xmath121 ) is due to the fact that individual galaxies evolve along the scaling relations rather than due to weak evolution in the galaxies themselves ( e.g. * ? ? ?
? * ; * ? ? ?
* ) , and indicates that the baryon conversion efficiency , @xmath76=(m@xmath96/m@xmath77)/(@xmath78/@xmath79 ) , is fixed with redshift .
the observations also suggest that the scatter in high - redshift tully - fisher relation is comparable to that predicted by the models , suggesting that the samples may now be sufficiently large ( with rotation curves well enough sampled ) that the scatter is intrinsic .
@xmath95 combining the rest - frame @xmath5-band and stellar mass tully - fisher relations we show that the mass - to - light ratio of star - forming galaxies evolves strong with redshift , decreasing by @xmath6m / l@[email protected] between @xmath1=0 and @xmath1=1 , but then ceases to evolve further above @xmath1=1 .
this change in mass - to - light ratio in the @xmath5-band is a factor @xmath6(m / l@xmath8)/(m / l@xmath8)@xmath973.5 .
we show that the evolution in the tully - fisher relations and mass - to - light ratio is in line with both cosmologically - based hydrodynamic simulations and semi - analytic models of galaxy formation .
@xmath95 using the h@xmath0 half light radius and circular velocity , we also find that the shizels galaxies are a factor [email protected]@xmath17 smaller for fixed circular velocity than for disks at @xmath1=0 .
if the @xmath122 and @xmath1=0 disks are linked in a simple evolutionary scenario then high - redshift disks must acquire specific angular momentum , either by removing material with low specific angular momentum ( e.g. through outflows ) , or through acquisition of angular momentum from accreted gas at late times .
@xmath95 finally , we measure the spatially resolved [ n ii]/h@xmath0 to measure the metallicity gradients . in all cases ,
the metallicity gradients are negative or consistent with zero , with an average @xmath6log(o / h)/@[email protected]@xmath110.005dexkpc@xmath3 , which is consistent with that seen in the thick disk of the milky - way .
we show that these metallicity gradients are comparable to those predicted for the gas disks of star - forming galaxies in the cosmologically based hydrodynamic simulations . in these models ,
the inner disk undergoes initial rapid collapse and star - formation with gas accretion ( either from the halo and/or igm ) depositing relatively unenriched material at the outer disk , causing negative abundance gradients . at lower redshift ( when gas accretion from the igm is less efficient )
the abundance gradients flatten as the outer disk becomes enriched by star - formation ( and/or the redistribution of gas from the inner disk ) .
overall , we demonstrate that well - sampled , dynamical measurements of high - redshift star - forming galaxies can constrain the rotation curves , measure the evolution of the basic disk scaling relations and their radial abundance gradients .
we show that the current observational samples with well resolved data are now approaching sufficiently large samples that it is possible to refine or refute models of disk galaxy formation .
we would like to thank the anonymous referee for their constructive report which significantly improved the content and clarity of this paper .
we thank mario van der ancker for help and support with the sinfoni planning / observations , and richard bower , natascha frster - schreiber , phil hopkins and john helly for a number of very useful discussions .
ams gratefully acknowledges an stfc advanced fellowship .
ds is supported by a nova fellowship .
irs acknowledges support from stfc and a leverhume senior fellowship and tt acknoledges support from the national science foundation under grant number nsf phy11 - 25915 .
the data presented are based on observations with the sinfoni spectrograph on the eso / vlt under program 084.b-0300 . ,
f. , abuter , r. , bickert , k. , biancat - marchet , f. , bonnet , h. , brynnel , j. , conzelmann , r. d. , & delabre , b. , et al .
2003 , in instrument design and performance for optical / infrared ground - based telescopes . edited by iye , masanori ;
moorwood , alan f. m. proceedings of the spie , volume 4841 , pp . 1548 - 1561 ( 2003 ) . ,
m. iye & a. f. m. moorwood , 15481561 , j. , contini , t. , kissler - patig , m. , epinat , b. , amram , p. , garilli , b. , le fvre , o. , moultaka , j. , paioro , l. , tasca , l. , tresse , l. , vergani , d. , lpez - sanjuan , c. , & perez - montero , e. 2012 , , 539 , a93 | we present adaptive optics assisted , spatially resolved spectroscopy of a sample of nine h@xmath0-selected galaxies at @xmath1=0.842.23 drawn from the hizels narrow - band survey .
these galaxies have star - formation rates of 127m@xmath2yr@xmath3 and are therefore representative of the typical high - redshift star - forming population .
our @xmath4kpc - scale resolution observations show that approximately half of the sample have dynamics suggesting that the ionised gas is in large , rotating disks .
we model their velocity fields to infer the inclination - corrected , asymptotic rotational velocities .
we use the absolute @xmath5-band magnitudes and stellar masses to investigate the evolution of the @xmath5-band and stellar mass tully - fisher relationships . by combining our sample with a number of similar measurements from the literature ,
we show that , at fixed circular velocity , the stellar mass of star - forming galaxies has increased by a factor 2.5 between @xmath1=2 and @xmath1=0 , whilst the rest - frame @xmath5-band luminosity has decreased by a factor @xmath46 over the same period . together , these demonstrate a change in mass - to - light ratio in the @xmath5-band of @xmath6(m / l@xmath7)/(m / l@xmath8)@xmath93.5 between @xmath1=1.5 and @xmath1=0 , with most of the evolution occuring below @xmath1=1 .
we also use the spatial variation of [ nii]/h@xmath0 to show that the metallicity of the ionised gas in these galaxies declines monotonically with galactocentric radius , with an average @xmath6log(o / h)/@[email protected]@xmath110.005dexkpc@xmath3 .
this gradient is consistent with predictions for high - redshift disk galaxies from cosmologically based hydrodynamic simulations .
galaxies : evolution galaxies : formation galaxies : high - redshift |
dwarf elliptical galaxies ( de ) are the most ubiquitous type of galaxy in the local universe @xcite . despite their plenitude , we still do not understand fully the formation mechanism of these low mass , gas poor systems .
one clue to the evolution of dwarf elliptical galaxies is the morphology density relation : similar to giant elliptical galaxies , dwarf elliptical galaxies are found primarily in high density regions such as galaxy clusters , compact groups , and loose groups @xcite .
however , unlike their giant cousins , the stellar distribution in dwarf elliptical galaxies is exponential in nature @xcite , indicating that dwarf elliptical galaxies are not just lower mass versions of giant elliptical galaxies .
thus , the evolutionary scenarios proposed for giant elliptical galaxies may not be relevant for the dwarf elliptical class . while some aspects of galaxy evolution undoubtedly arise from initial conditions , on - going evolution is likely accelerated and affected by different mechanisms in dense cluster environments .
as the nearest such location , the virgo cluster serves as the best laboratory for exploring the details of evolution under intracluster conditions , providing access to spatial scales and mass and luminosity ranges that are not achievable in more distant systems . as discussed in @xcite , the galaxy population in virgo
is dominated by dwarf galaxies which , because of its proximity , can be identified in large numbers .
thus , virgo provides an ideal setting for the study of dwarf galaxy evolution in the cluster environment .
a multitude of evolutionary scenarios have been proposed to explain the relationship between gas poor dwarf elliptical galaxies and gas rich dwarf irregular galaxies ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
. the key component of these models is the gas removal process : gas is removed either through a ` blow out' following a starburst episode , or via ram pressure stripping as the galaxy encounters the hot intergalactic medium ( igm ) or intracluster medium ( icm ) .
note that the latter method provides a natural explanation to the density - morphology relationship observed in the dwarf galaxies of the local group @xcite and in clusters @xcite , while the former method has difficulty explaining this phenomenon .
interestingly , if either of the above scenarios are correct , the stellar remnant ( de ) should have the same kinematic properties as the progenitor ( di ) . however , the ground breaking kinematic work by @xcite on de s in virgo and @xcite on three de companions of m31 suggested that this may not be the case for des : of the 5 dwarf elliptical galaxies in these two early studies , none are supported by rotation ( v@xmath3@xmath4 20 km s@xmath0 ) ; in contrast , most dwarf irregular galaxies of comparable mass ( or luminosity ) are rotationally supported .
recently , however , @xcite have shown that `` tidal stirring '' or repeated tidal shocks suffered by dwarf satellite galaxies can convert a di into a de by both removing its gas and changing it into a dynamically hot galaxy .
thus , lack of rotation in de galaxies does not exclude the conversion of di to de , but may indicate a more catastrophic evolutionary pathway than blow out or ram pressure stripping alone .
the number of dwarf elliptical galaxies with spatially resolved rotation curves is still quite small , however .
stellar kinematics of large samples of dwarf elliptical galaxies are needed to investigate fully kinematic constraints on evolutionary scenarios .
several projects with modest sample sizes have recently appeared in the literature ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . here , we present the first results from a program to measure the stellar kinematics of dwarf galaxies ; rotation curves and velocity dispersions of sixteen dwarf elliptical galaxies in the virgo cluster are discussed in this paper . the paper is organized as follows .
the spatially resolved kinematic observations are described in section 2 . in section 3 , the observed kinematic properties
are compared to those of giant elliptical galaxies and dwarf irregular galaxies .
in contrast to previous studies of des , seven of the sixteen galaxies in this sample have clear evidence of rotational support .
these results are discussed in the context of dwarf galaxy evolution in section 4 .
the conclusions of the paper are summarized in section 5 .
we selected a moderate sized sample of nearby dwarf elliptical galaxies for spatially resolved kinematic observations from the virgo cluster catalog ( vcc , * ? ? ? * ) .
the target galaxies were selected based on their apparent magnitude ( m@xmath5 ) , morphological classification ( de ) , and on their apparent ellipticity ( @xmath6 ) .
the latter criterion was imposed to mitigate the affects of disk projection in the measurement of rotational velocities , and it should be noted that its adoption biases the sample toward objects with higher apparent rotation velocity . the implication of this bias in terms of the galaxy evolution scenarios described in section 4 is uncertain .
the sample was further restricted to the luminous dwarf elliptical galaxies in the vcc with measured recessional velocities that place them within the virgo cluster ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , at a distance of approximately 16.1 mpc ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
dynamically young , virgo is known to contain several substructural units @xcite and appears to be elongated along the line - of - sight @xcite . recent observations of surface brightness fluctuations @xcite have shown that the de population is stretched in depth similarly to the bright elliptical population @xcite but not as extended as claimed previously by @xcite .
figure [ fig : virgo ] shows the location of the selected galaxies within the virgo cluster ; the targeted galaxies were selected to include a range of environments within the cluster , sampling both the cluster core and the outer field .
the observational properties of the selected galaxies are tabulated in table [ tab : global ] . included in table
[ tab : global ] are the morphological class from the vcc @xcite and group assignments from @xcite . the tabulated position angle , ellipticity , apparent magnitude , central surface brightness , and scale length
are derived from ellipse fitting of ubvri images obtained with the vatt 1.8 m telescope @xcite .
we note that the newly derived ellipticities are in excellent agreement with those values previously published for vcc 543 , vcc 990 , vcc 1122 , vcc 1308 , vcc 1514 , vcc 1743 , and vcc 2019 @xcite .
high resolution optical spectra of the target galaxies were obtained with the double spectrograph on the 5 m palomar telescope on the nights of 2001 march 19 - 21 and 2002 apr 8 - 10 .
the 6800 dichroic was used to split the light to the two sides ( blue and red ) of the spectrograph .
both sides of the spectrograph were equipped with 1200 l / mm gratings ( blazed at 5000 on the blue side and blazed at 9400 on the red side ) .
the thinned tek 1024 @xmath7 1024 ccd on the blue side of the spectrograph had a read noise of 8.6 e@xmath8 , a system gain of 2.13 , and an angular scale of 0.624 arcsec / pix .
the thinned tek 1024 @xmath7 1024 ccd on the red side of the spectrograph had a read noise of 7.5 e@xmath8 , a system gain of 2.0 , and an angular scale of 0.482 arcsec / pix .
the blue side was centered at the mg ib triplet , with wavelength coverage of 4800 5700 and an effective resolution of 2.3 ( 0.88 / pix ) . the red side was centered at the ca triplet , with wavelength coverage of 8250 8900 and an effective resolution of 1.6 ( 0.64 / pix ) . a summary of the observations is tabulated in table [ tab : obs ] .
the 2 long slit was oriented along the optical major axis of each galaxy .
since the galaxies in this sample are faint and low surface brightness , the telescope was centered on a nearby bright star and then offset to the galaxy position .
the slit viewing camera provided confirmation that the slit was aligned and centered appropriately . to improve the sensitivity ,
the slit was set to a width of 2 for all observations ; the seeing was approximately 1 during all 6 nights .
due to the low surface brightness nature of the de galaxies , long integration times ( on the order of 2 3 hours per pointing ) were necessary to have sufficient signal to noise in the absorption lines to trace the stellar kinematics to large radii .
observations of standard stars were obtained at the beginning and end of the night .
flux calibration was derived from observations of feige 34 , bd + 75 325 , and bd + 33 2642 @xcite .
the nights were non - photometric , but generally transparent .
at least 6 radial velocity standards ( f7 - k2 giants ) were also observed each night in order to create stellar templates for cross - correlation analysis .
the radial velocity standards are tabulated in table [ tab : stars ] . during the 2002 april observing run ,
several stars with low metallicities were targeted in order to verify that spectral differences between the template stars ( typically solar metallicity ) and the low metallicity dwarf elliptical galaxies did not introduce systematic errors .
as expected , we did not find that the metallicity of the template star had a significant effect on the derived redshift or velocity dispersion for these modest dispersion observations .
the spectra were reduced and analyzed with the iraf package .
the spectral reduction included bias subtraction , scattered light corrections , and flat fielding with both twilight and dome flats . the 2dimensional ( 2-d )
images were rectified based on arc lamp observations ( blue ) or night sky lines ( red ) and the trace of stars at different positions along the slit .
confirmation of the wavelength solution was provided by comparing the observed heliocentric velocities of the radial velocity standards with those found in the literature .
a small systematic offset ( 2 km s@xmath0 , or 0.1 pixel ) was found between the blue and red spectra and the literature values , which is well within the expected error for these relatively high signal - to - noise stellar observations .
the accuracy of the spatial rectification was confirmed by measuring the location of the each galaxy s center of light at several different wavelengths ; spatial offsets from one end of the spectra to the other were minimal for both sides of the spectrograph . each galaxy observation consisted of multiple 1200 sec exposures .
night sky lines were removed from the two dimensional images before the individual images were averaged together .
the final combined images were flux calibrated based on the sensitivity function derived from the flux standards observed each night .
one - dimensional ( 1-d ) spectra of the stars and galaxies were extracted from the 2-d spectra using the task apall .
integrated spectra for each galaxy are shown in figure [ fig : spec ] .
several different techniques were used to extract kinematic data from the observed spectra .
the first technique employed was a straight forward gaussian fit to the strongest lines ( the 3 mg ib lines on the blue side and the ca triplet on the red side ) . to improve the signal to noise ratio
, the 2-d images were boxcar smoothed to a spatial resolution of 1.87/pix for the blue camera ( binned by 3 pixels ) and 2.41/pix for the red camera ( binned by 5 pixels ) . the rotation curves were determined from the centroid of the gaussian fits and velocity dispersions were determined by subtracting the instrumental width ( derived from the standard star observations ) in quadrature from the observed line widths . while the values obtained from this simplistic measurement technique are not reported here , the gaussian fitting procedure provided a baseline value for the rotation curves and velocity dispersion measurements described below .
fourier analysis provides a more robust measure of the stellar kinematics , particularly when line shapes are not expected to be perfect gaussian profiles .
the rotation curves for each galaxy were derived from cross correlation analysis of the observed spectra with radial velocity template stars ( table [ tab : stars ] ) . in order to determine which of the radial velocity standards provided the best template match to the galaxy spectra , all of the radial velocity standards observed during the same observing run were cross - correlated with the 1-d galaxy spectra ( figure [ fig : spec ] ) using the task fxcor in the rv package .
the radial velocity standards were then rank ordered based on the derived tonry - davis ratio ( tdr , * ? ? ?
* ) for each galaxy .
the later spectral types ( g5 iii - k2 iii ) proved to have the best correlation coefficients when cross correlated with the dwarf elliptical galaxy spectra ; in fact , the best template match for both observing runs was hd 65934 , a star classified as a g8 iii . for both observing runs ,
the seven stars with the highest average tdr were used in the subsequent analysis . prior to further cross
correlation analysis , the 2-d images were boxcar smoothed to a spatial resolution of approximately 2/pix ( see above ) , 4/pix , and 8/pix to increase the signal to noise ratio .
each row of each 2-d image was cross correlated with the selected subset of radial velocity standards using xcor in the contributed redshift package of stsdas .
the task xcor was selected for the final analysis because it returned both a redshift and a velocity dispersion measurement . in this analysis ,
the derived centroid values were not sensitive to the spectral type of the template star ; typical individual differences between the systemic velocity measured by each of the templates were on the order of 6 km s@xmath0 on the red side and 12 km s@xmath0 on the blue side and relative velocity differences were much smaller than that .
the systemic heliocentric velocities for each galaxy are tabulated in table [ tab : results ] .
the error estimates quoted in table [ tab : results ] are derived from the dispersion of results from the different analysis techniques and cross correlation of the galaxy spectra with different template stars .
these errors should be considered indicative of both systematic and random errors ; typically , the quoted errors are larger than the formal errors returned by the iraf tasks .
in general , when smoothed to a spatial resolution of 2/pix , the galaxy rotation curves could be traced to radii of approximately 20 or 1.56 kpc at the distance of virgo .
there were no significant differences between the rotation curves derived from the mg ib and those derived from the ca triplet lines .
the derived rotation curves are shown in figure [ fig : rot ] , with the maximum velocity width denoted by dashed lines . except for vcc 1075 and vcc 1857 ,
all of the plots in figure [ fig : rot ] are from the data binned to 2 resolution .
seven of the sixteen galaxies have clear evidence of a velocity gradient across the stellar component ; the rotational component is easily discernible in the raw image for all of these galaxies .
the slope of the rotation curve was derived from linear regression analysis of all of the data points ( both blue and red cameras ) and is tabulated in table [ tab : results ] .
the representative maximum rotation velocity ( v@xmath3 ) was derived from the fitted rotation curve and the maximum radius at which the rotation curve could be measured .
the rotation velocities are tabulated in table [ tab : results ] .
five of the galaxies in the present sample are also included in @xcite ; in all cases , the present rotation curves trace the galaxy kinematics to a significantly larger radius due to both the limited slit length of the keck observations and to signal to noise ratio concerns . thus , the derived maximum rotation velocities are larger than previously reported . the same cross - correlation analysis yielded a velocity dispersion measurement for each galaxy .
the velocity dispersion measurements were calibrated by analyzing the artificially broadened spectra of one of the template stars . based on
the stellar template , observations with the blue camera did not have sufficient resolution to provide accurate velocity dispersion measurements of these galaxies , while the ca line observations had sufficient resolution to measure velocity dispersions greater than 35 km s@xmath0 .
the measured velocity dispersions are shown in figure [ fig : rot ] and the central ( @xmath9 ) and median ( @xmath10 ) values are tabulated in table [ tab : results ] .
the median velocity dispersion is derived from the average of the measurements at all radii .
the typical velocity dispersion for the galaxies in this sample is 44 @xmath2 5 km s@xmath0 . in general , given the relatively poor spectral resolution of both cameras and low velocity dispersions of the galaxies , the reported velocity dispersions should be considered indicative upper limits .
for comparison , three of these galaxies have velocity dispersions in the published literature [ vcc 543 and vcc 1122 , @xcite and @xcite ; vcc 917 , @xcite ] .
the mean velocity dispersion for vcc 1122 reported in @xcite is larger than the value reported here , but is consistent with the central velocity dispersion measurement .
figure [ fig : comp ] shows a direct comparison of the line shape expected for a template star broadened by the velocity dispersion for the integrated spectrum of vcc 1122 ; the derived velocity dispersion is clearly a good match to the observed spectra .
the velocity dispersion of vcc 543 reported here is comparable to that of @xcite ; similar good agreement is found between the new observations of vcc 917 and those reported in @xcite , although the reported systemic velocity of vcc 917 is significantly different than that reported here .
the derived rotation velocities and velocity dispersions indicate that several dwarf elliptical galaxies in the virgo cluster have significant rotation components .
the ratio of the rotation velocity to velocity dispersion for the virgo dwarf elliptical galaxies is shown in figure [ fig : anisotrop ] and tabulated in table [ tab : results ] .
note , however , that the anisotropy parameters , ( v/@xmath10 ) * , listed in table [ tab : results ] and shown in figure [ fig : anisotrop ] should be considered representative lower limits for the des .
not only are the derived velocity dispersions representative upper limits , the present observations only sampled the kinematics along the major axis ; if the des have a significant velocity gradient along a different axis , such as found in some di galaxies [ e.g. , ngc 625 , @xcite and ngc 5253 , @xcite ] , the derived anisotropy parameters will be underestimates of their true values . also shown in figure [ fig : anisotrop ] are the anisotropy parameters for giant elliptical galaxies from @xcite and the dwarf elliptical galaxies in @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite .
five of the dwarf elliptical galaxies in the virgo sample have a significant rotation component .
these galaxies overlap the locus of anisotropy parameters found in giant elliptical galaxies , where the lower luminosity ellipticals tend to have large anisotropy parameters .
eight of the remaining dwarf elliptical galaxies have modest anisotropy parameters , while only one , vcc 1261 , has an extremely low value . these results are significantly different than those reported by @xcite and the early studies of @xcite and @xcite where it appeared that dwarf elliptical galaxies had no significant rotation component
. however , the recent observations by @xcite and @xcite revealed a handful of dwarf elliptical galaxies with significant rotation .
thus , it appears that the kinematics of some dwarf elliptical galaxies are dominated by rotation , not random motions . while this result is counter to the results reported in earlier studies , it should not be surprising . the dwarf elliptical galaxies in this sample
are all located in the region of strong overdensity that characterizes the virgo cluster .
it is well known that galaxies located near the cluster center are deficient in neutral hydrogen relative to their counterparts in the field ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . for giant spiral galaxies , the loss of their ism may result in modest morphological changes , including suppression of their star formation activity ( e.g. , * ?
however , despite these changes , gas - deficient giant spiral galaxies are likely still to be classified as spiral galaxies since there are striking morphological differences between giant spiral and elliptical galaxies .
this is not the case for dwarf galaxies .
dwarf elliptical galaxies and dwarf irregular galaxies share common morphological parameters ; both have approximately exponential surface brightness profiles and have similar central surface brightnesses and scale lengths ( see section 4 for further discussion of the similarities between des and dis ) .
thus , their structural parameters do not provide a strong morphological distinction between dwarf elliptical galaxies and dwarf irregular galaxies ; rather , their morphological classification is highly dependent on the patchy appearance ( or absence thereof ) due to irregular star formation activity across the surface of the galaxy .
if star formation ceases in a dwarf galaxy , the resulting system is likely to be classified as a dwarf elliptical galaxy once the massive stars , which provide the patchy contrast , have evolved off of the main sequence .
in fact , it is this morphological commonality that first led to the idea that dwarf elliptical galaxies could evolve passively from dwarf irregular galaxies after a starburst episode ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) .
if the dwarf elliptical galaxies in this sample are the end products of dwarf irregular galaxies which have been stripped of their ism , the observed rotation velocities should be similar to the rotation velocities of normal dwarf irregular galaxies .
the correlation between rotation width ( corrected for inclination ) and absolute magnitude for the dwarf elliptical galaxies is shown in figure [ fig : tf ] .
also shown in figure [ fig : tf ] are the values for dwarf irregular galaxies compiled in @xcite and the correlation derived for spiral galaxies @xcite
. in general , dwarf irregular galaxies have a large scatter in the tully - fisher diagram , in part due to uncertain inclination and velocity dispersion corrections .
however , there is still a general trend that more luminous dwarf irregular galaxies have larger rotation widths .
many of the dwarf elliptical galaxies also appear to follow this trend ; the exceptions are vcc 917 , 1122 , 1261 , 1308 , 1514 , and 2050 , which are under - rotating for their observed luminosity .
these galaxies all have kinematic slopes which are less than 20 km s@xmath0 kpc@xmath0 ; we designate these galaxies as the `` non - rotating '' sample .
those that follow the tully - fisher relation ( vcc 178 , 437 , 543 , 965 , 990 , 1036 , 2019 ) are designated the `` rotationally supported '' sample . note that vcc 1743 and vcc 1857 also appear to be rotationally supported , but their observations are too poor quality to include in the statistics .
these groupings are similar to those seen in the anisotropy diagram ( figure [ fig : anisotrop ] ) , with the exception that vcc 178 and 965 fall in the `` modest '' ( v/@xmath10 ) * grouping .
we elect to separate the kinematic samples based on the amplitude of the slope of the rotation curve and location in the tully - fisher diagram since the velocity dispersion measurements are not as secure as the rotation curve measurements for these observations .
note that figure [ fig : tf ] compares stellar ( de ) and gaseous ( di and spirals ) rotation curves . while the stars and gas are expected to be kinematically coupled in normal galaxies , it is necessary to consider whether the stellar rotation curves sample fully the rotation velocities of these galaxies .
as mentioned above , the observations were limited to the optical major axis ; for most galaxies , this is the axis with the largest velocity gradient , and thus it is reasonable to assume that the rotation curves measured here are representative .
however , the stellar rotation curves were traced out to only a modest radius whereas the neutral gas velocity widths include emission from gas that extends well beyond the optical galaxy .
nonetheless , if the dwarf elliptical galaxies and dwarf irregular galaxies have similar kinematic properties , it should be possible to correct for this effect on a statistical basis .
for comparison , we consider the neutral gas distribution and kinematics for a sample of 20 galaxies selected from the optical imaging samples of @xcite and @xcite , i.e. , a subset of the dwarf irregular galaxies shown in figure [ fig : tf ] . the resolved hi distribution and kinematics
were obtained with very large array during several observing runs from 1993 - 2000 .
while the majority of the hi synthesis data is as yet unpublished , the di sample includes the galaxies in @xcite with distances scaled to an h@xmath11 of 75 km s@xmath0 mpc@xmath0 .
a histogram of the extent of the hi distribution to optical scale length for the di sample is shown in figure [ fig : slope]a . to determine the statistical correction to convert from a stellar rotation width to a neutral gas rotation width , we measured the ratio of the maximum rotation velocity to the slope of the rotation curve .
a histogram of the v@xmath12/slope for dwarf irregular galaxies is shown in figure [ fig : slope]b , where the slope of the rotation curve is in units of km s@xmath0 per scale length .
the mean value is 2.45 @xmath2 0.58 scale lengths , which shows remarkable ( and perhaps co - incidental ) agreement with the use of the velocity at 2.2 scale lengths as a fiducial measure of spiral galaxy rotation curves ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
based on these results , it is likely that the stellar rotation curves obtained here underestimate the maximum rotation velocity for the dwarf elliptical galaxies since most were traced out to only 1 - 1.5 scale lengths .
arrows in figure [ fig : tf ] indicate the location of each galaxy if the stellar rotation curves were traced to 2.45 scale lengths and the galaxy dynamics follow similar trends as those of the neutral gas in di galaxies .
given the uncertainties associated with this velocity width correction , it is premature to draw far reaching conclusions from the revised velocity widths .
nonetheless , it is important to note that such measurements could provide significant constraints on the luminosity evolution of de galaxies .
in particular , these rough correction factors indicate that the progenitor galaxies were at most only 2 magnitudes more luminous than the present population ( i.e. , the revised rotation widths are comparable to those of galaxies 2 magnitudes more luminous ) .
if these results are confirmed by observations that fully trace the galaxy dynamics , the progenitor population of virgo des must be restricted to moderate luminosity systems .
in particular , it is unlikely that des evolve from significantly more luminous galaxies .
one of the perplexing issues in galaxy evolution is the remarkable commonality between dwarf elliptical galaxies and dwarf irregular galaxies .
these low mass systems have similar stellar distributions , both in terms of functional form ( exponential ) and in terms of typical central surface brightnesses and scale lengths @xcite .
furthermore , both dis and des follow the same luminosity - metallicity relation , where the more luminous galaxies are more metal rich , regardless of their gas content @xcite .
in fact , aside from their current gas content and star formation activity , the low mass galaxy classes are remarkably similar in stellar content and morphology .
as mentioned in the introduction , the apparent morphological similarity between the low mass galaxy classes led to several possible evolutionary scenarios that linked dwarf irregular galaxies and dwarf elliptical galaxies .
however , the apparent kinematic mis - match between des and dis posed a severe constraint for evolutionary pathways between dis and des since angular momentum must be conserved ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
however , the early studies included only a small number of des .
the new observations presented here indicate a remarkable similarity between the kinematic properties of many dwarf elliptical and dwarf irregular galaxies ; these results re - open the possibility that some des are formed from passive evolution of dis . to some degree ,
the question of whether dwarf elliptical galaxies evolve from dwarf irregular galaxies is tautological since every de _ must _ have been gas - rich and star - forming at some point in the past .
standard morphological classification would identify these gas - rich , low mass galaxies as dis .
thus , the relevant question is not whether a de evolves from a di , but what caused the progenitors of des to stop forming stars and to lose their ism .
one popular scenario is that the progenitors were too low mass to retain their ism after a star formation episode ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) . in this scenario ,
the kinetic energy from supernovae explosions is sufficient to sweep out the remaining ism after a starburst episode .
however , more recent calculations indicate that it may be more difficult to remove the ism of a dark matter dominated galaxy than previously thought ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
furthermore , detailed star formation histories of nearby dwarf spheroidal galaxies indicate these extremely low mass galaxies were able to retain their ism through several star formation episodes ( e.g. , carina dsph , * ? ? ?
thus , internal gas - loss mechanisms face several challenges to explain the diversity of stellar populations , the relative chemical enrichment , and the relative gas - richness of low mass galaxies .
alternatively , the key to the formation of dwarf elliptical galaxies may be an external process .
dwarf elliptical galaxies are the most strongly clustered galaxy type @xcite .
they are predominantly found in high density regions , either in galaxy clusters or located near more massive spiral and elliptical galaxies . given the strong morphology - density relation for dwarf elliptical galaxies
, it is reasonable to assume that the environment may play a crucial role in their evolution .
segregation within the dwarf ellipticals in virgo itself has already been noted by several authors @xcite , who point out that the nucleated de s occupy the cluster core , whereas the majority of non - nucleated ones are found in the peripheral regions .
furthermore , as discussed in section 3 , ram pressure stripping is an efficient mechanism to remove the ism from cluster members , regardless of total mass .
infall of galaxies into the virgo cluster is an ongoing process @xcite ; one thus expects that small groups of galaxies similar to the local group continue to fall into the virgo cluster .
given the simple surface mass density criteria for ram pressure stripping @xcite , essentially all low mass dwarf irregular galaxies falling into the virgo cluster will be stripped of their gas ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
indeed , there is evidence of a very recent case of stripping of a virgo dwarf galaxy ( ugc 7636 , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
unless one imagines that all dwarf galaxies that fall into the virgo cluster are already des ( and the fact that they are falling in from low density environments argues strongly against this ) , then it would appear to be inevitable that some of the des in the virgo cluster are stripped dis .
since dwarf irregular galaxies are dark matter dominated , removal of their ism will have only a modest effect on their kinematics .
however , subsequent passages through the cluster could further disrupt the stellar kinematics via galaxy harassment or merging events . thus ,
if dis are converted into des via ram pressure stripping , one might expect a correlation between the location of dwarf elliptical galaxies with significant rotation and the cluster center . while the present sample is relatively small , figure
[ fig : cluster ] shows a hint of such a relationship , in the sense that galaxies with little - to - no rotation appear to be located predominantly in the cluster core or in high density clumps , while those with significant rotation are in the outskirts of the cluster .
this is consistent with the idea that gas - rich dwarf galaxies are stripped of their gas during a passage through the intracluster medium ; the non - rotating dwarf elliptical galaxies may be remnants of gas - rich systems that have made multiple passes through the icm , or had a catastrophic event occur .
we caution , however , that the present sample size is relatively small and biased toward the more luminous cluster des ; further observations of a larger sample of dwarf elliptical galaxies throughout the cluster environment are needed to investigate this suggestive trend .
although we have argued above that the available observations do not allow us to establish the relative strengths of the rotationally supported and non - rotationally supported de populations , we can not close without some speculation on the presence of non - rotating de galaxies .
following the same line of argument given above , i.e. , that it is almost inescapable that some of the des observed in the virgo cluster must have lost their gas to ram pressure stripping , it is also likely that some dwarf galaxies entered the virgo cluster as des before they encountered sufficient hot gas for stripping
. it also seems inescapable that some di galaxies interact tidally with more massive galaxies , and thereby lose gas in this manner .
given that it is difficult to quantify the relative importance of these three different channels of cluster de galaxy formation , we caution against single channel evolutionary scenarios .
specifically , we note that explanations for the density
morphology relationship in the local group may be irrelevant for the cluster density morphology relationship .
a more comprehensive study of kinematics in de galaxies in both environments is warranted .
based on the data in hand , however , it is clear that environmental pathways for di to de conversion must be considered ; if further observations support the trend indicated in figure [ fig : cluster ] , relevant theories for the formation and evolution of dwarf galaxies must include environmental factors as well as internal processes .
we present long - slit optical spectroscopy along the major axis of 16 dwarf elliptical galaxies in the virgo cluster .
the major results of these observations are as follows : \(2 ) five of the 14 galaxies with measured velocity dispersions have anisotropy parameters ( v/@xmath10 ) * @xmath13 1 . , indicating significant rotational flattening .
only one of the remaining 9 des has ( v/@xmath10 ) * @xmath4 0.3 .
the remainder have modest anisotropy parameters , indicating that rotational flattening may be significant for the majority of dwarf elliptical galaxies in this sample .
these kinematic results re - open the possibility that dwarf elliptical galaxies may be the end products of dwarf irregular galaxies that have lost their ism via ram pressure stripping or other non - catastrophic processes . the morphological similarities between gas - rich dwarf irregular galaxies and gas - poor dwarf elliptical galaxies appear to extend beyond the stellar distributions and metal enrichment ; many gas - rich and gas - poor dwarf galaxies have common dynamical properties , as would be expected for passive evolution models .
we dedicate this paper in memory of j. bev oke , whose spectrographs have enabled a plethora of science for many decades and whose dedication and kindness encouraged several generations of scientists to use those spectrographs well .
lvz thanks elizabeth barton for many thought - provoking conversations about galaxy formation and evolution .
this research has made use of the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration .
lvz acknowledges partial support from the herzberg institute of astrophysics and the national research council of canada ; lvz also acknowledges partial support from indiana university .
eds is grateful for partial support from a nasa ltsarp grant no .
nag5 - 9221 and the university of minnesota .
mph has been supported by nsf grants ast-9900695 and ast-0307396 .
bender , r. , burstein , d. , & faber , s. m. 1992 , , 399 , 462 bender , r. , & nieto , j.l .
1990 , , 239 , 97 bender , r. , paquet , a. , & nieto , j.l .
1991 , , 246 , 349 binggeli , b. , popescu , c. c. , & tammann , g. a. , 1993 , , 98 , 275 binggeli , b. , sandage , a. & tammann , g. a. 1985 , , 90 , 1681 binggeli , b. , sandage , a. & tammann , g. a. 1988 , , 26 , 509 binggeli , b. , tammann , g. a. & sandage , a. & 1987 , , 94 , 251 binggeli , b. , tarenghi , m. , & sandage , a. 1990 , , 228 , 42 conselice , c. j. , oneil , k. , gallagher , j. s. , & wyse , r. f. g. 2003 , , 591 , 167 conselice , c. j. , gallagher , j. s. , & wyse , r. f. g. 2001 , , 559 , 791 ct , s. , carignan , c. , & freeman , k. c. 2000 , , 120 , 3027 courteau , s. & rix , h .- w . 1999 , , 513 , 561 davies , j. i. , & phillipps , s. 1988 , , 233 , 553 de rijcke , s. , dejonghe , h. , zeilinger , w. w. , & hau , g. k. t. 2001 , , 559 , l21 de rijcke , s. , dejonghe , h. , zeilinger , w. w. , & hau , g. k. t. 2003 , , 400 , 119 de young , d. s. , & heckman , t. m. 1994 , , 431 , 598 de young , d. s. , & gallagher , j. s. 1990 , , 356 dekel , a. , & silk , j. 1986 , , 303 , 39 drinkwater , m. , & hardy , e. 1991 , , 101 , 94 ferrara , a. , & tolstoy , e. 2000 , , 313 , 291 ferguson , h. c. , & binggeli , b. 1994 , , 6 , 67 ferguson , h. c. , & sandage , a. 1989 , , 346 , 53 gallagher , j. s. & wyse , r. f. g. 1994 , , 106 , 1225 geha , m. , guhathakurta , p. , & van der marel , r. p. 2002
, , 124 , 3073 geha , m. , guhathakurta , p. , & van der marel , r. p. 2003
, , 126 , 1794 giovanelli , r. , & haynes , m. p. 1983
, , 88 , 881 gunn , j. e. & gott , j. r. i. 1972 , , 176 , 1 james , p. a. 1994 , , 269 , 176 jerjen , h. , binggeli , b. & barazza , f.d .
2004 , , 127 , 771 kelson , d. d. et al .
2000 , , 529 , 768 kobulnicky , h. a. , & skillman , e. d. 1995 , , 454 , l121 koopmann , r. a. , & kenney , j. d. p. 1998
, , 497 , l75 kormendy , j. 1985 , , 295 , 73 lin , d. n. c. & faber , s. m. 1983 , , 266 , l21 loose , h.h . , & thuan , t. x. 1986 , , 309 , 59 mac low , m.m . , & ferrara , a. 1999 , , 513 , 142 marcolini , a. , brighenti , f. , & dercole , a. 2003 , , 345 , 1329 mayer , l. , governato , f. , colpi , m. , moore , b. , quinn , t. , wadsley , j. , stadel , j. , & lake , g. 2001a , , 547 , l123 mayer , l. , governato , f. , colpi , m. , moore , b. , quinn , t. , wadsley , j. , stadel , j. , & lake , g. 2001b , , 559 , 754 neilsen , e.h .
& tsvetanov , z.i .
2000 , , 536 , 155 oh , k.s . & lin , d.n.c 2000 , , 543 , 620 oke , j. b. 1990 , , 99 , 1621 papaderos , p. , loose , h.h . , fricke , k. j. , & thuan , t. x. 1996a , , 314 , 59 patterson , r. j. & thuan , t. x. 1992 , , 400 , l55 pedraz , s. , gorgas , j. , cardiel , n. , snchez - blzquez , p. , & guzmn , r. 2002 , , 332 , l59 richer , m. g. , & mccall , m. l. 1995 , , 445 , 642 ryden , b. s. , terndrup , d. m. , pogge , r. w. , & lauer , t. r. 1999 , , 517 , 650 sancisi , r. , thonnard , n. , & ekers , r. d. 1987 , , 315 , l39 silich , s. a. , & tenorio tagle , g. 1998 , , 299 , 249 silk , j. , wyse , r. f. g. , shields , g. a. 1987 , , 322 , l59 simien , f. & prugniel , p. 2002
, , 384 , 371 skillman , e. d. , & bender , r. 1995 , rev .
aasc , 3 , 25 skillman , e. d. , kennicutt , r. c. , & hodge , p. w. 1989 , , 347 , 875 smecker - hane , t. a. , stetson , p. b. , hesser , j. e. , & lehnert , m. d. 1994 , , 108 , 507 solanes , j
.- m . , manrique , a. , garca - gmez , c. , gonzlez - casado , g. , giovanelli , r. , & haynes , m. p. 2001
, apj , 548 , 97 solanes , j .- m . , sanchis , t. , salvador - sol , giovanelli , r. , & haynes , m. p. 2002
, , 124 , 2440 sung , e.c .
, han , c. , ryden , b. s. , chun , m.s . , & kim , h.i .
1998 , , 499 , 140 tonry , j. , & davis , m. 1979 , , 84 , 1511 tully , r. b. , & pierce , m. j. 2000 , , 533 , 744 tully , r. b. & shaya , e. j. 1984 , , 281 , 31 van den bergh , s. 1994 , , 428 , 617 van zee , l. 2001 , 121 , 2003 van zee , l. , & barton , e. g. 2004 , in prep van zee , l. , haynes , m. p. , & salzer , j. j. 1997a , , 114 , 2479 van zee , l. , haynes , m. p. , salzer , j. j. , & broeils , a. h. 1997b , , 113 , 1618 van zee , l. , salzer , j. j. , & skillman , e. d. 2001 , , 122 , 121 west , m.j . &
blakeslee , j.p . 2000 , , 543 , l27 yasuda , n. , fukugita , m. & okamura , s. 1997 , , 108 , 417 young , c. k. & currie , m. j. 1995 , , 273 , 1141 | new observations of 16 dwarf elliptical galaxies in the virgo cluster indicate that at least seven des have significant velocity gradients along their optical major axis , with typical rotation amplitudes of 20 - 30 km s@xmath0 . of the remaining nine galaxies in this sample , 6 have velocity gradients less than 20 km s@xmath0kpc@xmath0 while the other 3 observations had too low of a signal to noise ratio to determine an accurate velocity gradient .
typical velocity dispersions for these galaxies are @xmath144 @xmath2 5 km s@xmath0 , indicating that rotation can be a significant component of the stellar dynamics of virgo des . when corrected for the limited spatial extent of the spectral data , the rotation amplitudes of the rotating des are comparable to those of similar brightness dis .
evidence for a relationship between the rotation amplitude and galaxy luminosity is found , and , in fact , agrees well with the tully - fisher relation .
the similarity in the scaling relations of dis and des implies that it is unlikely that des evolve from significantly more luminous galaxies .
these observations reaffirm the possibility that some cluster dwarf elliptical galaxies may be formed when the neutral gaseous medium is stripped from dwarf irregular galaxies in the cluster environment .
we hypothesize that several different mechanisms are involved in the creation of the overall population of de galaxies , and that stripping of infalling dis may be the dominant process in the creation of des in clusters like virgo . |
numerous experiments using unstable nuclear beams have succeeded to reveal exotic properties of @xmath15-unstable nuclei , including a neutron halo structure@xcite .
especially , the shift of the closed - shell structure is a characteristic behavior of systems with weakly bound neutrons .
recently , the contributions of the @xmath16 shell have been analyzed in @xmath17 nuclei based on the shell model .
a calculation has shown that the slow @xmath15-decay of @xmath8be to @xmath8b can be explained by an admixture of the @xmath16 shell in @xmath8be ( @xmath17 ) in which the closed @xmath11-shell component must be less than 30@xmath18@xcite .
this shows that the concept of magic numbers is vague in @xmath8be . on the other hand , an @xmath2-@xmath2 structure
is well established in the be and b region . typically in @xmath19be
, a microscopic @xmath2+@xmath2+@xmath3 model has reproduced the properties of low - lying states including the level inversion of @xmath20 in the @xmath11-shell and @xmath13 in the @xmath16 shell@xcite .
also in @xmath1be , the microscopic @xmath2-cluster models have been applied @xcite , and we have quantitively shown the mechanism for the lowering of the @xmath16 orbits related with the clustering of the core@xcite . according to our previous results for @xmath1be ,
the main properties of this nucleus have been well described by the @xmath2+@xmath2+n+n model , where the orbits for the two valence neutrons are classified based on the molecular - orbit ( mo ) model .
the dominant configuration of the two valence neutrons for the second @xmath0 state is @xmath4 , and the level inversion between @xmath20 and @xmath13 in @xmath19be also holds in @xmath1be . here , the two valence neutrons stay along the @xmath2-@xmath2 axis , and reduce the kinetic energy by enhancing the @xmath2-@xmath2 distance ( up to around 4 fm ) .
therefore , the @xmath13 orbit in this case is not a spherical @xmath21-wave , but a polarized orbit with the @xmath22-wave component .
this feature of @xmath16 mixing in the @xmath13 orbit can be qualitatively interpreted in terms of deformed models ( [ 220 ] expression in the nilsson diagram ) .
the main purpose of this paper is to show the mechanism for the appearance of this @xmath4 configuration in low - lying energy in detail . in our previous work
, the calculated excitation energy of the second @xmath0 state has been higher by @xmath75 mev without the spin - orbit interaction than the experimental one@xcite .
the spin - orbit interaction has been found to decrease the excitation energy by 3 mev by adding a single optimal wave function with @xmath23 .
hence , it is necessary to analyze the contribution of the spin - orbit interaction more precisely to clarify the lowering mechanism of the second @xmath0 state .
the other reduction mechanism of the kinetic energy by more accurate description of the neutron - tail should also be taken into account .
firstly , the spin - orbit interaction is able to contribute to the second @xmath0 state , when spin - triplet states for the valence neutrons are included among the basis states .
if the @xmath13 state consists of the pure s - orbit , naturally there is no contribution of the spin - orbit interaction . in
be isotopes , the state contains the @xmath22-orbit component .
however , the spin - orbit interaction again vanishes , when the two valence neutrons occupy along the @xmath2-@xmath2 axis , since two neutrons with the same spatial distribution construct only the spin - singlet state .
this has been the situation in traditional mo models@xcite .
it will be shown that when one of the valence neutrons deviates from the @xmath2-@xmath2 axis , the spin - triplet state can be constructed , and the spin - orbit interaction strongly acts between this state and the original @xmath4 configuration with the spin - singlet .
the extension of the model space also enables us to improve the description of the neutron - tail .
we estimate the reduction of the kinetic energy due to the improvement of the neutron - tail .
these improvements will be shown to largely decrease the excitation energy of the second @xmath0 state , and that the calculated energy just corresponds to the experimental value . using the present extended mo model , negative - parity states in @xmath1be are also investigated .
the mixing of different spin structure @xmath24 is found to also be important in the negative - parity states .
the @xmath25-mixing effect strongly acts on the @xmath6 state , and the calculated small - level spacing between @xmath5 and @xmath6 ( @xmath7300 kev ) agrees with the experimental value . also , in @xmath8be these two important mechanism for lowering the @xmath4 configuration are examined . in @xmath8be , the configuration for four valence neutrons around the @xmath2-@xmath2 core
is considered to correspond to the two pair configurations , @xmath26 and @xmath4 .
these two pair configurations appear in the ground @xmath0 state and the second @xmath0 state of @xmath1be , respectively .
the energy surface for the ground state of @xmath8be will be shown , in which the spin - orbit interaction is seen to make the binding for the @xmath10 configuration properly stronger in comparison with the @xmath12 configuration .
this is related to the breaking of the @xmath17 ( closed @xmath11-shell ) neutron - magic number .
this paper is organized as follows . in sec .
ii , we summarize a description of the single - particle orbits around the two @xmath2 clusters based on the mo model . in sec .
iii , the contribution of the spin - orbit interaction to the @xmath4 configuration and the reduction of the kinetic energy due to an improvement of the neutron - tail are considered .
these effects are discussed in detail for the second @xmath0 state of @xmath1be ( * a * ) , for the negative parity states of @xmath1be ( * b * ) , and for @xmath8be ( * c * ) .
the conclusion is given in sec .
we introduce a microscopic @xmath2+@xmath2+@xmath27 model for @xmath1be and @xmath2+@xmath2+@xmath9 model for @xmath8be .
the neutron configurations are classified according to the molecular - orbit ( mo ) picture@xcite .
the details of the framework are given in ref.@xcite ; here , the essential part is presented .
the hamiltonian is the same as in ref.@xcite , and consists of a kinetic - energy term , a central two - body interaction term , a two - body spin - orbit interaction term , and a coulomb interaction term : @xmath28 the effective nucleon - nucleon interaction is volkov no.2@xcite for the central part and the g3rs spin - orbit term@xcite for the spin - orbit part , as follows : @xmath29 @xmath30 where @xmath31 is a projection operator onto the triplet odd state .
the parameters are @xmath32 mev , @xmath33 mev , @xmath34 @xmath35 and @xmath36 @xmath35 for the central interaction , and @xmath37 = 2000 mev , @xmath38 @xmath35 , and @xmath39 @xmath35 for the spin - orbit interaction .
we employ the majorana exchange parameter , @xmath40 ( @xmath41 ) , the bartlett exchange parameter , @xmath42 , and the heisenberg exchange parameter , @xmath43 , for the volkov interaction ( using @xmath44 and @xmath45 , there is no neutron - neutron bound state ) .
all of these parameters are determined from the @xmath46 and @xmath47 scattering phase shifts and the binding energy of the deuteron@xcite .
the total wave function is fully antisymmetrized and expressed by a superposition of terms centered to different relative distances between the two @xmath2 clusters ( @xmath22 ) with various configurations of the valence neutrons .
the projection to the eigen - states of angular momentum @xmath48 is performed numerically .
all nucleons are described by gaussians with the oscillator parameter @xmath49 equal to 1.46 fm .
the @xmath2 clusters located at @xmath50 and @xmath51 on the @xmath52-axis consist of four nucleons : @xmath53 @xmath54 represents gaussians : @xmath55 , \ \ \ \ \ \ \nu=1/2s^2 , \ \ \ \ \ \ \vec r_\alpha = \ { d\vec e_z/2 , \ \ -d\vec e_z/2\}.\ ] ] each valence neutron ( @xmath56 ) around the @xmath2-@xmath2 core is expressed by a linear combination of local gaussians : @xmath57 @xmath58 , \ \ \ \ \ \ \nu=1/2s^2.\ ] ] the level structure is solved by superposing basis states with different @xmath2-@xmath2 distances and configurations after the angular momentum projection . in the mo model , valence
neutrons are expressed by a linear combination of orbits around two @xmath2 clusters .
the orbit around each @xmath2 cluster is called the atomic orbit ( ao ) . here
, we note that the valence neutrons and neutrons in the @xmath2 clusters are identical particles , and antisymmetrization imposes the ao forbidden space .
the lowest ao has one node and parity minus , which is the @xmath11-orbit .
when a linear combination of two aos ( @xmath11-orbit ) around the left-@xmath2 cluster and the right-@xmath2 cluster is summed up by the same sign , the resultant mo also has negative parity and one node . in this case
, the mo is restricted to spread along an axis perpendicular to the @xmath2-@xmath2 @xmath59 axis , which is the so - called @xmath60-orbit .
it can not spread along the @xmath52-axis where the two @xmath2 clusters are already located .
if two @xmath11-orbits are summed up by different signs , the resultant mo has two nodes and positive parity .
this mo can spread to all directions , and the optimal direction becomes the @xmath52-direction .
this is the so - called @xmath61-orbit , and the energy becomes lower as the distance between two @xmath2 clusters increases . in
be isotopes , the low - lying orbits with @xmath62 , @xmath13 , and @xmath20 are important ; these are classified based on the mo mode1 .
the @xmath13 state is the @xmath61-orbit , and the spin - orbit interaction splits the @xmath60-orbit to @xmath63 and @xmath20 . in the present framework ,
each valence neutron is introduced to have a definite @xmath64 at the zero limit of centers of local gaussians @xmath65 describing the spatial distribution of the orbit .
the precise positions of @xmath66 are determined variationally for each @xmath2-@xmath2 distance before the angular - momentum projection .
since the values of @xmath66 are optimized to be finite , the orbits are not exactly the eigen - state of @xmath64 , and are labeled as @xmath67 . in @xmath1be , when two valence neutrons occupy these single particle orbits , three configurations with the total @xmath68 are generated . for the ground state ,
valence neutrons occupy orbits with @xmath69 and @xmath70 ; these @xmath60-orbits are expressed as linear combinations of @xmath71 and @xmath72 : @xmath73.\ ] ] @xmath74 @xmath75 each mo is constructed from two aos around a left and right @xmath2 cluster .
we introduce a variational parameter @xmath76 on the @xmath2-@xmath2 axis ( @xmath52-axis ) ; and @xmath77 is @xmath78 , whose center is @xmath79 on the @xmath52-axis ; and @xmath80 is @xmath78 , whose center is @xmath81 on the @xmath52-axis . here , the spatial part and the spin part of @xmath82 in eqs .
( 9 ) and ( 10 ) are introduced to be parallel , for which the spin - orbit interaction acts attractively .
the spin - up valence neutron has @xmath83
( @xmath84 ) , and the spin - down valence neutron has @xmath83 ( @xmath85 ) . there @xmath86 , @xmath87 , @xmath88 , and @xmath89 are expressed as the combination of two gaussians , whose centers are shifted by a variational parameter @xmath90 perpendicular to the @xmath52-axis . for example , @xmath91 these parameters @xmath92 and @xmath93 , are optimized by using the cooling method in antisymmetrized molecular dynamics ( amd ) @xcite for each @xmath2-@xmath2 distance .
the @xmath61-orbit pair , @xmath4 , is prepared , where each @xmath61-orbit is expressed by subtracting two aos at @xmath94 and @xmath95 : @xmath96,\ ] ] @xmath97 @xmath98 where , @xmath99 since the @xmath61-orbit has two nodes , the direction of the orbit is not limited due to the pauli principle .
it can thus take all directions .
therefore , the direction and value of parameter @xmath100 for the center of the gaussians are optimized . as a result , it is optimized to the direction of the @xmath2-@xmath2 axis .
this basis state shares the dominant component of the second @xmath0 state .
before giving the results , we summarize the calculated energies and the optimal @xmath2-@xmath2 distance for three configurations ( @xmath26 , @xmath102 , and @xmath4 ) discussed in ref.@xcite . in fig .
1 , the @xmath0 energy curves of @xmath103 , @xmath104 , and @xmath105 in @xmath1be are presented as a function of the @xmath2-@xmath2 distance @xmath106 .
these configurations are the dominant components of the first , second , and third @xmath0 states in @xmath1be , respectively .
+ fig . 1 + + the energy of @xmath107 ) ( dominant component of @xmath108 ) becomes lower as @xmath22 increases , and the energy becomes minimum at an @xmath2-@xmath2 distance of @xmath109 fm .
however , it should be noted that the energy difference between @xmath104 and @xmath103 in fig . 1 is about 11 mev .
this is much larger than the experimental excitation energy of the second @xmath0 state ( 6.26 mev@xcite ) by 5 mev .
there are two reasons for this lack of binding energy by 5 mev in the second @xmath0 state .
one is that the contribution of the spin - orbit interaction is not taken into account ; the other is that the tail of the valence neutron is not correctly described . as for the spin - orbit interaction , in the traditional mo model ,
the spin - orbit interaction has not contributed to the @xmath0 state with this configuration .
this is because , the two valence neutrons occupy the same spatial configurations with opposite spin direction , and construct a spin - singlet state .
since it is impossible for two valence neutrons with the same spin direction to occupy the same @xmath61-orbit along the @xmath2-@xmath2 axis , the spin - triplet state is prepared by making one of the valence neutrons deviate from the @xmath2-@xmath2 axis . as for the tail effect of the valence neutrons , in this analysis ,
the tail behavior is expressed by the superposition of local gaussians .
these two improvements are shown for the @xmath110 configuration with the optimal @xmath2-@xmath2 distance of 4 fm .
the optimized parameter @xmath100 is @xmath111 ( fm)@xcite . as listed in table i , the spin - singlet @xmath110 configuration has a @xmath0 energy of @xmath112 mev . as shown in eqs .
( 12)-(15 ) , each valence neutron is described as a linear combination of four local gaussians .
when we optimize their linear combination , the energy slightly decreases to @xmath113 mev ( noted as @xmath114 @xmath115 in table i ) .
+ table i + + next , the contribution of the spin - orbit interaction is taken into account to this spin - singlet state by preparing the spin - triplet state ( @xmath116 ) .
one of the valence neutrons ( @xmath117 ) occupies the @xmath61-orbit , and another one ( @xmath118 ) with the same spin - direction deviates from the @xmath2-@xmath2 axis .
the later one is described by a local gaussian centered at @xmath119 ; @xmath120 .
the calculated energy surface for the second @xmath0 state as a function of the parameter @xmath119 is given in fig .
2 . the orthogonality of the ground @xmath0 state to the ground @xmath0 state is ensured in this calculation . the point on the @xmath121-@xmath52 plain in fig .
2 shows the position of the parameter @xmath119 , and the contour map shows the total energy obtained by taking into account this coupling with the spin - triplet states . -
+ fig . 2 + - + the lowest energy of @xmath122 mev is seen at @xmath123 ( fm ) on the energy surface .
the contribution of the spin - orbit interaction decreases the energy by more than 3 mev in comparison with the case of the spin - singlet state .
although the energy of such a spin - triplet state , itself , is much higher than that of @xmath110 by about 20 mev , the large coupling between the spin - singlet and spin - triplet states enables the spin - orbit interaction to attractively act . as a result ,
more than half of the under - binding by 5 mev for the second @xmath0 state is explained by this spin - orbit contribution . to see this effect more correctly , a lot of spin - triplet states with different @xmath119 values are adopted .
the employed @xmath119 values are 0.0 , 1.0 , 2.0 ( fm ) for the @xmath121-direction ( perpendicular to the @xmath2-@xmath2 direction ) and 0.0 , 1.0 , 2.0 , 3.0 , 4.0 ( fm ) for the @xmath52-direction ( the @xmath2-@xmath2 direction ) . in table
i , the column noted as spin - orbit gives the energy of the second @xmath0 state when these 15 spin - triplet states with different @xmath119 values are superposed .
the calculated energy is @xmath124 mev ; this is lower than the energy minimum point in fig . 2 by only 300 kev .
this is because , the spin - triplet basis states around the core have a large overlap with each other , and those apart from the core do not contribute to this coupling .
this result shows that the contribution of the spin - orbit interaction for the @xmath4 state is approximately taken into account when we employ only one slater determinant on the energy surface . in this calculation ,
many spin - triplet states are employed ; however , it should be noted that the spin - singlet state is only represented by the @xmath110 configuration .
thus , to improve the tail of the valence neutron in the second @xmath0 state of @xmath1be , it is necessary to superpose further the @xmath125 basis states with many different @xmath119 values , which contain the spin - singlet component .
the distance of @xmath2-@xmath2 is 4 fm , where one of the valence neutrons ( @xmath117 ) occupies the @xmath61-orbit , and the other valence neutrons ( @xmath118 ) with the opposite spin - direction is described by local gaussian centered at @xmath119 .
the later one has the form of @xmath126 .
we superpose 15 basis states with @xmath125 , and the employed @xmath119 values are 0.0 , 1.0 , 2.0 ( fm ) for the @xmath121-direction ( perpendicular to the @xmath2-@xmath2 direction ) and 0.0 , 1.0 , 2.0 , 3.0 , 4.0 ( fm ) for the @xmath52-direction ( the @xmath2-@xmath2 direction ) .
as listed in table i , the energy becomes @xmath127 mev .
these basis states increase the binding of the second @xmath0 state by 1.5 mev compared with @xmath124 mev for the third row . here
, it is noted that these @xmath128 basis states contain both the spin - single and spin - triplet components .
however , the increase of the binding energy by adding these @xmath128 basis states is due to the spin - singlet basis states , since it is considered that the functional space of the spin - triplet states are already exhausted by the @xmath116 states .
these results show that by taking into account both the spin - orbit interaction ( spin - triplet basis states ) and the tail effect ( spin - singlet basis states ) , the under - binding for the second @xmath0 state by 5 mev is fully explained .
the calculated excitation energy of the second @xmath0 state agrees with the experimental one . to confirm the component of the spin - triplet configurations introduced
, the expectation value of the spin - square @xmath129 ) in the second @xmath0 state of @xmath1be was calculated .
the value is 0.26 .
this means that the spin - triplet configuration mixes in this state by about 13@xmath18 . in this analysis ,
the @xmath2-@xmath2 distance is restricted to 4 fm , but we now examine the contribution of the spin - orbit interaction with respect to the @xmath2-@xmath2 distance .
+ table ii +
+ table ii gives the contribution of spin - orbit interaction for the second @xmath0 state with the @xmath2-@xmath2 distance of 3 fm , 4 fm , and 5 fm .
the column noted as @xmath114 @xmath115 gives the energy for the @xmath110 configuration , where the linear combination of gaussians is optimized .
the column noted as @xmath130 gives the energy when we include the spin - orbit interaction by employing the spin - triplet basis states .
the results show that the smaller is the @xmath2-@xmath2 distance , the larger is the contribution of the coupling with the spin - triplet state .
when the @xmath2-@xmath2 distance is 5 fm , the coupling increases the binding energy by about 3 mev ; however , when the @xmath2-@xmath2 distance is 3 fm , the coupling increases the binding energy by about 4.5 mev . therefore , the coupling with the spin - triplet becomes stronger as the @xmath2-@xmath2 distance becomes small .
the column noted as @xmath131 gives the energy when we further include the spin - singlet basis state to express the tail of the valence neutron .
this effect does not have a strong dependence on the @xmath2-@xmath2 distance , and almost constantly decreases the binding energy by 1.5 mev .
finally , the calculation where all of these basis states with different @xmath2-@xmath2 distance are superposed is performed based on the generator coordinate method ( gcm ) .
when we superpose all of the basis states in table ii , the calculated energy of the second @xmath0 state becomes @xmath132 mev .
here , we superpose the basis states with @xmath2-@xmath2 distances of 3 , 4 , 5 , and 6 fm , and the spin - triplet states are represented by one slater determinant for each @xmath2-@xmath2 distance , which correspond to the minimum point on the energy surface ( fig .
this calculated energy of @xmath132 mev is lower than a result calculated with only the @xmath110 configuration ( employed @xmath2-@xmath2 distances are the same ) by 4.6 mev .
we examine this spin - mixing effect for the negative - parity states in @xmath1be . here
, one of the valence neutrons is introduced to occupy a @xmath60-orbit with negative parity ; another one occupies a @xmath61-orbit with positive parity . in this way ,
two configurations with @xmath128 and @xmath116 can be constructed .
the @xmath128 basis state ( @xmath133 ) has @xmath134 .
@xmath135.\ ] ] @xmath74 @xmath136 this basis state gives @xmath113 mev for @xmath5 and @xmath137 mev for @xmath6 at the optimal @xmath2-@xmath2 distance of 3 fm .
this energy splitting between @xmath5 and @xmath6 by 1 mev is much larger than the experimental value of 300 kev ( experimentally , the excitation energies of the @xmath5 state and the @xmath6 state are 5.96 mev and 6.26 mev , respectively ) . at first
, we only examine the tail effect of the valence neutrons with @xmath128 .
we introduce a parameter @xmath119 for @xmath118 , which originally occupies the @xmath61-orbit : @xmath138 however , even if we superpose states with many different positions ( @xmath119 ) , the energy splitting between these states is still about 1 mev ( @xmath5 state is @xmath139 mev and the @xmath6 state is @xmath140 mev ) .
the employed @xmath119 values are 0.0 , 1.0 , 2.0 ( fm ) for the @xmath121-direction ( perpendicular to the @xmath2-@xmath2 direction ) and 0.0 , 1.0 , 2.0 , 3.0 , 4.0 ( fm ) for the @xmath52-direction ( @xmath2-@xmath2 direction ) .
therefore , to improve this discrepancy , we next include the basis states with @xmath116 ; @xmath141 .
the @xmath116 basis state generates @xmath142 band . as a result of the calculation ,
the energy of the @xmath6 state with @xmath143 ( spin triplet ) is found to be accidentally close to the energy of the @xmath6 state with @xmath134 projected from the @xmath128 basis states .
thus , the coupling effect between the @xmath128 basis states and the @xmath116 basis states is larger for the @xmath6 state than for the @xmath5 state , and the energy splitting becomes comparable to the experimental one . to see this effect ,
we superpose many @xmath144 basis states characterized by the gaussian center @xmath119 ; @xmath126 .
when we include many states with different @xmath119 values in our bases states , the energies become @xmath145 mev ( @xmath5 ) and @xmath124 mev ( @xmath6 ) .
the employed @xmath119 values are 0.1 , 1.0 , 2.0 ( fm ) for the @xmath121-direction and 0.0 , 1.0 , 2.0 , 3.0 , 4.0 ( fm ) for the @xmath52-direction .
the experimental small level splitting between @xmath5 and @xmath6 is found to be evidence of the spin vibration in the @xmath6 state .
the large contribution of this spin - orbit interaction will be discussed concerning @xmath8be . in the previous subsection ,
we have discussed for @xmath1be that this effect is more important as the @xmath2-@xmath2 becomes smaller , and in @xmath8be , we show that the distance is smaller than that of the second @xmath0 state of @xmath1be . in @xmath8be ,
four valence neutrons rotate around two @xmath2 clusters and , mainly , two configurations are important for the @xmath0 ground state@xcite .
one is @xmath12 for the four valence neutrons , which corresponds to the closed @xmath11-shell configuration of the neutrons at the zero limit of the @xmath2-@xmath2 distance .
the other configuration is @xmath10 , where two of the four valence neutrons occupy the @xmath61-orbit .
it is necessary to compare the energy of these two configurations as a function of the @xmath2-@xmath2 distance .
the configurations of @xmath12 and @xmath10 are constructed as follows : @xmath146\ ] ] @xmath74 @xmath147 @xmath148 @xmath149 @xmath150\ ] ] @xmath74 @xmath147 @xmath151 @xmath152 the dotted line in fig .
3 shows @xmath0 energies of @xmath10 and the dashed line shows @xmath12 with respect to the @xmath2-@xmath2 distance . -
+ fig . 3 + - + when the @xmath2-@xmath2 distance is small , for example 2 fm , the dominant configuration of the four valence neutrons is @xmath12 for the ground state , which corresponds to the closed @xmath11-shell configuration at the limit of the @xmath2-@xmath2 distance , zero . on the other hand , the @xmath10 configuration for the four valence neutrons becomes lower as the @xmath2-@xmath2 distance is increased .
however , it is still higher than the @xmath12 configuration by a few mev . here
, we show the importance of the coupling between the @xmath10 configuration and the spin - triplet state for the last two neutrons ( @xmath4 ) . the spin - triplet state for @xmath4
is introduced as follows : @xmath153\ ] ] @xmath74 @xmath147 @xmath151 @xmath154 the coupling between the @xmath10 configuration and the spin - triplet states is shown in fig .
4 as a function of the parameter @xmath119 . -
+ fig . 4 + - + the point on the @xmath121-@xmath52 plain in fig .
4 shows the gaussian - center @xmath119 in the spin - triplet state .
the contour map shows the energy calculated by taking into account this coupling with the spin - triplet state .
this @xmath2-@xmath2 distance is 3 fm , and this optimal distance is smaller than that for the second @xmath0 state of @xmath1be by about 1 fm , since two of the four valence neutrons occupy the @xmath26 configuration and increase the binding energy of the system . because of this effect , the coupling effect of the spin - triplet states is more important than in the case of the second @xmath0 state of @xmath1be .
the minimal point of the surface shows that the energy gain due to the couplings is about 4 mev in @xmath8be . the solid line in fig .
3 shows the @xmath0 energy calculated by taking into account the coupling effect between the @xmath10 configuration and the @xmath155 basis states for the last two valence neutrons . due to the spin - orbit coupling ,
the energy is almost the same as that of @xmath12 corresponding to the closed @xmath11-shell configuration .
furthermore , the energy of @xmath10 is suggested to become even lower than @xmath12 when the pairing effect between @xmath26 and @xmath102 is taken into account .
these effects plays crucial roles in accounting for breaking of the @xmath156 magic number .
the second @xmath0 state of @xmath1be has been shown to be characterized by the @xmath61-orbit of the two valence neutrons in terms of the molecular orbit ( mo ) model .
the two valence neutrons stay along the @xmath2-@xmath2 axis ( the @xmath13 orbit ) and reduce the kinetic energy by enlarging the @xmath2-@xmath2 distance .
this simple description for the second @xmath0 state gives a higher excitation energy by 5 mev compared to the experimental one . to improve the description , spin - triplet basis states which have not been included in the traditional mo models
are prepared by allowing a deviation of the neutron orbit from one just along the @xmath2-@xmath2 axis .
thus , the spin - orbit interaction can be taken into account , and the calculated second @xmath0 state becomes lower by 3.5 mev .
the precise description of the neutron - tail also decreases the excitation energy by 1.5 mev .
the discrepancy between the experimental excitation energy and the calculated one is compensated by these two effects .
the spin - mixing effects were studied for the negative parity state of @xmath1be .
if we restrict ourselves to the @xmath128 basis state , this energy splitting between the @xmath5 state and @xmath6 state is about 1 mev , which is much larger than the experimental value of 303 kev . as a result of adding basis states with @xmath116 , where the spin directions of the two valence neutrons are the same
, the @xmath25-mixing occurs especially for the @xmath6 state .
the contribution of the @xmath116 state is larger for the @xmath6 state .
the resultant energy splitting becomes comparable to the experimental one .
therefore , the experimental small level splitting between @xmath5 and @xmath6 is considered to be a result of the spin vibration induced by the spin - orbit interaction in the @xmath6 state .
the coupling with the spin - triplet basis states is also important in the case of @xmath8be . without the spin - triplet basis state ,
the energy of the configuration @xmath157 is much higher than that of the closed @xmath11-shall configuration ( @xmath158 ) by 4 mev .
however , the energy of @xmath157 is drastically decreased by coupling with the spin - triplet states .
this is because the effect becomes stronger as the @xmath2-@xmath2 distance becomes shorter , and @xmath8be has an optimal @xmath2-@xmath2 distance around 3 fm , which is smaller than the second @xmath0 state of @xmath1be by 1 fm .
the study shows that an energy of @xmath157 is almost the same as @xmath158 , or even lower .
this effect is suggested to play a crucial role in accounting for the dissipation of the @xmath17 magic number in @xmath8be .
it is an interesting subject to analyze the binding mechanism and properties of the ground state by taking into account the pairing mixing among states with configurations of @xmath158 , @xmath157 , and @xmath159 .
a detail analysis is going to be performed not only for this state , but also for excited states where new states with cluster structure have been recently observed .
the authors would like to thank prof .
i. tanihata for various effective suggestions .
they also thank other members of ri beam science laboratory in riken for discussions and encouragements .
one of the authors ( n.i ) thanks fruitful discussions with prof .
r. lovas , prof .
h. horiuchi , prof .
t. otsuka , prof .
y. abe , prof .
k. kat , prof .
k. yabana , dr .
a. ohnishi , and dr .
y. kanada - enyo .
i. tanihata , t. kobayashi , o. yamakawa , s. shimoura , k. ekuni , k. sugimoto , n. takahashi , t. shimoda , and h. sato + phys.lett .
b206 , 592 ( 1988 ) .
a588 1 ( 1995 ) + _ proc . of fourth int.conf.on radioactive nuclear beam , omiya _ nucl.phys .
a616 1 ( 1997 ) i. tanihata , j.phys .
g : nucl.part.phys .
* 22 * , 157 ( 1996 )
. t. suzuki and t. otsuka phys .
c*56 * , 847 ( 1997 ) . 279
s. okabe , y. abe , and h. tanaka prog.theor.phys .
57 , 866 ( 1977 ) .
+ s. okabe and y. abe prog.theor.phys .
59 , 315 ( 1978 ) .
s. okabe and y. abe , prog.theor.phys .
61 , 1049 ( 1979 ) .
h. furutani , h. kanada , t. kaneko , s. nagata , h. nishioka , s. okabe s. saito , t. sakuda , and m. seya , prog .
68 , 193 ( 1980 ) .
m. seya , m. kohno , and s. nagata , prog .
65 , 204 ( 1981 ) .
n. itagaki , s. okabe , physical review * c61 * 044306 ( 2000 ) y. abe j. hiura , and h. tanaka , prog.theor.phys.*49 * , 800 ( 1973 ) .
volkov nucl .
74 , 33 ( 1965 ) .
n. yamaguchi , t. kasahara , s. nagata and y. akaishi , prog.theor.phys .
62 1018 ( 1979 ) y. kanada - enyo and h. horiuchi , prog .
93 , 115 ( 1995 ) .
y. kanada - enyo , h. horiuchi and a. ono , phys .
c52 , 628 ( 1995 ) .
y. kanada - enyo and h. horiuchi phys .
c52 , 647 ( 1995 ) .
a.dot , h. horiuchi and y. kanada - enyo , phys .
c*56 * , 1844 ( 1997 ) .
a. ono , h. horiuchi , t. maruyama and a. ohnishi , + prog.theor.phys .
87 1185 , ( 1992 ) ; phys.rev.lett.68 2898 , ( 1992 ) . f.
ajzenberg - selove , nucl.phys .
a490 , 1 ( 1988 ) .
n. itagaki and s. okabe , _ proceedings of @xmath160 international conference on clustering aspects of nuclear structure and dynamics _
( rab , croatia , 1999 ) .the energy convergence of the second @xmath0 of @xmath1be .
the @xmath2-@xmath2 distance is fixed to 4 fm .
the row noted as @xmath110 shows the energy of the @xmath110 configuration , and the row @xmath114 @xmath115 shows the energy when a linear combination of local gaussians is optimized .
the row spin - orbit shows the energy including the coupling with the spin - triplet state .
the row tail shows the calculated energy when the tail of the valence neutron is further expressed by the @xmath125 basis states .
the values in parentheses give the energy differecne with the previous row . [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] | the structure of the second @xmath0 state of @xmath1be is investigated using a microscopic @xmath2+@xmath2+@xmath3+@xmath3 model based on the molecular - orbit ( mo ) model .
the second @xmath0 state , which has dominantly the @xmath4 configuration , is shown to have a particularly enlarged @xmath2-@xmath2 structure .
the kinetic energy of the two valence neutrons occupying along the @xmath2-@xmath2 axis is reduced remarkably due to the strong @xmath2 clustering and , simultaneously , the spin - orbit interaction unexpectedly plays important role to make the energy of this state much lower .
the mixing of states with different spin structure is shown to be important in negative - parity states .
the experimentally observed small - level spacing between @xmath5 and @xmath6 ( @xmath7300 kev ) is found to be an evidence of this spin - mixing effect .
@xmath8be is also investigated using @xmath2+@xmath2+@xmath9 model , in which four valence neutrons are considered to occupy the @xmath10 configuration .
the energy surface of @xmath8be is shown to exhibit similar characteristics , that the remarkable @xmath2 clustering and the contribution of the spin - orbit interaction make the binding of the state with @xmath10 configuration properly stronger in comparison with the closed @xmath11-shell @xmath12 configuration .
* important role of the spin - orbit interaction in forming the @xmath13 orbital structure in be isotopes * + .25 in _ n. itagaki , s. okabe@xmath14 , and k. ikeda _ _ ri beam science laboratory , riken ( the institute of physical and chemical research ) , wako , saitama 351 - 0198 , japan _ @xmath14 _ center for information and multimedia studies , hokkaido university , + sapporo 060 - 0810 , japan _ pacs
number(s ) : 21.10.-k , 21.60.gx |
recent studies of ultracold trapped atomic gases have led to the discovery of intriguing physical phenomena and have attracted more and more attentions to the atomic systems .
the trapped atomic gases have some advantages as a physical system in that any combinations of bosons and fermions can be put together on a lattice , microscopic parameters are tunable in most cases , and the systems can be constructed in various geometries , e.g. one - dimensional chain or two - dimensional plane .
one dimensional systems were constructed with bosons @xcite-@xcite and with bosons and fermions @xcite .
these could be the first case that realized one - dimensional boson / boson - fermion systems , and triggered theoretical studies @xcite-@xcite . at a commensurate filling with the lattice periodicity ,
the mixtures of spinless fermions and bosons in one - dimensional optical lattice were predicted to undergo mott transition at sufficiently large fermion - boson and boson - boson interactions @xcite . in the boson - fermion mixtures at an incommensurate
filling , on the other hand , the only possible instability is mixing - demixing transition .
when the repulsive interactions between fermions and bosons are small , the two components are well mixed and the system is in the mixing state . when the interactions are large enough , each component stays away from the other and the system is in the demixing state .
cazalilla and ho studied the mixing - demixing transition based on a luttinger liquid formalism with a large difference in the number densities of the two components @xcite .
they derived a criterion for the demixing of hardcore bosons and spinless fermions in the form , @xmath0 where @xmath1 is a fermion - boson interaction , @xmath2 is the fermi velocity , and @xmath3 with @xmath4 being the atomic mass of boson and @xmath5 being the boson density .
also there is a rigorous proof that the system always remains in the mixing state as far as the fermion - boson interaction has the same magnitude as the boson - boson interaction @xcite . for a slightly different but more generalized model , batchelor _ et al .
_ found no demixing phase in the bethe anzatz solution @xcite . under these circumstances
we need more evidences for the existence of the mixing - demixing transition to draw clear phase diagrams . in this paper
, we investigated numerically the mixing - demixing transitions of incommensurate fermion - boson mixtures to complete the phase diagrams , and identified the roles of various microscopic parameters in the transition .
the paper is organized as follows . in chapt .
2 we will introduce the model hamiltonian and a correlation function we used as an indicator to determine the phases .
chapter 3 is devoted to the description of calculation results and chapt .
4 to the conclusion of the present study .
we consider a mixture of @xmath6 spinless fermions and @xmath7 bosons on an @xmath8-site lattice .
we employed bose - fermi hubbard hamiltonian to describe the interacting particles , which is defined by @xmath9 \nonumber\\ & & { } + \sum_i \left [ \frac{u_{bb}}{2 } n_{b , i}(n_{b , i}-1)+u_{fb}n_{f , i}n_{b , i } \right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath10 and @xmath11 are respectively creation and annihilation operators for fermions ( @xmath12 ) or bosons ( @xmath13 ) on the @xmath14-th site , and @xmath15 . hopping energy and chemical potential
are denoted respectively by @xmath16 and @xmath17 .
@xmath18 and @xmath19 are on - site boson - boson and fermion - boson repulsive interactions respectively .
to observe the mixing - demixing transition , we define a correlation function @xmath20 the first term gives the correlation in neighboring bosons , and the second term expresses the correlation between bosons and fermions on the same and neighboring sites . in the mixing states fermions and bosons
are spatially mixed and move throughout the system , while in the demixing states fermions and bosons reside separately and move in each restricted area . the correlation function @xmath21 changes drastically at the transition , reflecting these characteristics .
it tends to be smaller , or negatively larger , in mixing states than in demixing states .
the reason we omitted @xmath22 from the first term is that this sometimes dominates the correlation function when multiple bosons stay on the same site , mostly in the demixing states , and hides subtle behavior of the other terms .
many physical quantities change at the transition and we actually calculated other various physical quantities including the @xmath23 dependence of @xmath24 .
however we found the correlation function @xmath21 exhibited the most drastic change near the transition point and decided to use it as an indicator of the transition .
we performed monte carlo simulations with the world - line algorithm @xcite on a one - dimensional @xmath8-site lattice with periodic boundary conditions .
we changed in the simulations the number of fermions and bosons , @xmath6 and @xmath7 respectively , while fixing the total number of particles @xmath25 to 14 .
we used the hopping energy @xmath26 of bosons as an energy unit .
temperature was fixed to @xmath27 and the trotter decomposition number @xmath28 to 100 .
the number of sites @xmath8 was set to 30 . in the following two subsections
we will show the mixing - demixing transitions by changing various parameters with several choices of the difference in the number densities of the fermions and bosons , @xmath29 . [
cols="<,^,<,^ " , ] c the same behavior can be found in fig .
[ fig10 ] where the correlation function @xmath30 of the fermions ( a ) and the bosons ( b ) is calculated .
figure [ fig10 ] should be compared with fig .
as @xmath31 increases the transition points shift to the larger @xmath19 side .
we also drew the phase diagram in fig .
[ fig7 ] with a larger @xmath31 than used in fig .
4 ( a ) . in comparison of fig .
[ fig7 ] with fig .
4(a ) we see the transition area , represented by @xmath32 , clearly shifts to the larger @xmath19 side .
we studied the mixing - demixing transitions of fermion - boson mixtures in one dimension by changing various parameters .
monte carlo calculation showed the mixing - demixing transition occurred at any @xmath33 , the difference in the number densities of the two components , as the repulsive interactions between the fermions and bosons increase . the schematic phase diagram is given in fig . [ phase ] .
also we confirmed the role of each parameter .
the fermion - boson interaction @xmath19 helps demixing , while the boson - boson interaction @xmath18 and the hopping energy @xmath31 help mixing .
the phase boundary of fig .
[ phase ] therefore shifts to the larger @xmath19 side as @xmath18 or @xmath31 increases . in our simulations we could not obtain reliable results at large interactions because of the restriction on the computational time .
we performed the simulations for fermions and hardcore bosons , i.e. with @xmath34 , and found no demixing phase as far as @xmath35 .
although we have no numerical evidence on the absence of the demixing phase at @xmath36 , we believe the fermions and the hardcore bosons would not be demixed at any @xmath19 for the following reason .
suppose we have demixed fermions and hardcore bosons with a finite @xmath19 .
in the vicinity of the boundary , the fermions and bosons move around , interacting with each other .
the fermions ( bosons ) can only move to empty sites or sites occupied by the bosons ( fermions ) , which means that it is energetically favored for each component of the particles to invade the area of the other component rather than to stay in its own area .
in other words the demixing state of the fermions and the hardcore bosons would be unstable against mixing .
in fact there is a rigorous proof that a mixture of fermions and bosons remains in the mixing state when @xmath37 @xcite , indicating finite @xmath19 can not demix the mixture of fermions and hardcore bosons .
14 m. greiner _
et al . _ ,
lett . * 87 * 160405 ( 2001 ) .
j. a. sauer , m. d. barrett and m. s. chapman , phys .
* 87 * 270401 ( 2001 ) .
a. grlitz _
et al . _ ,
lett . * 87 * , 130402 ( 2001 ) .
h. moritz _ et al .
lett . * 91 * , 250402 ( 2003 ) .
g. modugno _
et al . _ ,
a * 68 * , 011601 ( 2003 ) .
a. albus , f. illuminati and j. eisert , phys .
a * 68 * , 023606 ( 2003 ) .
r. roth and k. burnett , phys .
a * 69 * , 021601 ( 2004 ) .
m. lewenstein _
et al . _ ,
lett . * 92 * , 050401 ( 2004 ) .
l. mathey _
et al . _ ,
lett . * 93 * , 120404 ( 2004 ) .
a. imambekov and e. demler , cond - mat/0505632 .
et al . _ , cond - mat/0506478 .
k. k. das , phys .
lett . * 90 * , 170403 ( 2003 ) .
m. a. cazalilla and a. f. ho , phys .
150403 ( 2003 ) . j. e. hirsch _
et al . _ ,
phys . rev .
b * 26 * , 5033 ( 1982 ) .
g. g. batrouni and r. t. scalettar , phys .
b * 46 * , 9051 ( 1992 ) .
g. g. batrouni , r. t. scalettar and t. zimanyi , phys .
* 65 * , 1765 ( 1990 ) . | mixing - demixing transition in one - dimensional mixtures of fermions and bosons is numerically investigated by changing various parameters such as number densities of each component , fermion - boson interactions , boson - boson interactions , and hopping energies . in most cases we found clear evidences of the mixing - demixing transitions and identified the roles of each microscopic parameter in the transitions .
several phase diagrams were obtained . |
the process of accretion is the power source driving the luminosities for a wide range of objects , including protostars , binary systems containing accreting white dwarfs , neutron stars or black holes , gamma ray bursts and supermassive black holes in active galactic nuclei .
a comprehensive review of this process is provided by frank , king & raine ( 2002 ) . in most of these systems ,
most of the time , the accretion process proceeds via an accretion disc which transports angular momentum outwards and matter inwards .
the temperature of this disc increases towards the centre , and is a function of accretion rate and central accretor mass .
the disc may also produce ( or even be partially replaced by ) at various times a relatively cool disc wind , a very hot corona and a collimated relativistic outflow or ` jet ' .
finally , the ` state ' of the accretion flow at the centre of the disc may vary dramatically indicating rapid variations between phases with different geometries , temperatures and outflows .
reviews of observation of accretion onto white dwarfs , neutron stars and black holes in binary systems can be found in e.g. warner ( 2003 ) and lewin & van der klis ( 2006 ) . in x - ray binary systems containing an accreting neutron star or black hole
the region of the accretion disc responsible for the optical continuum and emission lines lies at a large distance from the central accretor ( several light seconds , or @xmath3 gravitational radii
e.g. hynes et al .
many such systems are transients , in that they display phases of very high luminosities lasting typically weeks to months , followed by long periods in quiescence ( e.g. chen , shrader & livio 1997 ) .
such cycles are likely to have their origin in accretion disc instabilities associated with hydrogen ionization ( frank et al .
2002 and references therein ) .
it is widely accepted that the emission lines in such systems arise in the rotating accretion disc flow .
the strongest evidence for this interpretation is in the form of twin - peaked line profiles ( e.g. horne & marsh 1986 ; charles & coe 2006 and references therein ) .
the dominant pumping mechanism for these lines is likely to be irradiation by the central x - ray source at high luminosities , as is observed for the optical continuum ( van paradijs & mcclintock 1994 ) . at lower luminosities viscous heating of the disc
may contribute significantly .
however , the picture may not be so simple .
russell et al .
( 2006 and references therein ) have demonstrated that in black hole x - ray binaries ( bhxbs ) in ` hard ' x - ray states synchrotron emission from the jet dominates the continuum in the near - infrared and can contribute significantly in the optical band .
wu et al . ( 2001 , 2002 ) argue for three distinct origins for the emission line depending on the source luminosity and spectral states . in their model , in bright / soft x - ray states the line arises in the atmosphere of an optically thick disc , whereas in bright / hard x - ray states the h@xmath0 line arises in a dense outflow . in the faintest quiescent states the whole accretion flow is optically thin . in a related work ,
eikenberry et al . (
1998 ) found a near - linear correlation between br@xmath4 ( 2.166 @xmath5 m ) integrated line flux and the adjacent continuum flux density in the black hole x - ray binary grs 1915 + 105 , during phases when the continuum was likely to be synchrotron emission from the powerful jet in this source .
this suggests radiative pumping of the lines by uv emission from the jet .
comparison with phases of soft x - ray spectra with no jet emission in the same study were taken to indicate that the jet is a far better source of photoionising photons than the inner accretion disc , presumably due to the fact that the ultraviolet - emitting region of the jet is raised above the disc and illuminates it very efficiently ( this argument does not work if this region of the jet is moving relativistically away from the disc and therefore strongly doppler de - boosted ) .
however , a strong change in h@xmath0 ew associated with x - ray state , and therefore jet production , is _ not _ observed in gx 339 - 4 ( wu et al .
2001 ; see also fig 1 ) , possibly arguing against strong pumping of h@xmath0 by the jet . in this paper
we have compiled measurements of the strength of h@xmath0 , the most prominent emission line in the optical spectra of x - ray binaries .
our goal was to see how the properties of the emission line varied , if at all , with accretion ` state ' and luminosity of x - ray binary systems , and whether or not there was clear evidence for phases where the lines were formed in an outflow rather than a disc .
what we find is evidence for an anti - correlation between the equivalent width ( ratio of line to local continuum flux ) and overall luminosity of such systems , in particular when in the ` hard ' x - ray state ( at luminosities below about 1% of the eddington limit ) . [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the approach taken in section 2.1 , in plotting h@xmath0 ew as a function of time for bhxbs is a strong but indirect indication of an anti - correlation of the ew with luminosity .
a more direct comparison of luminosity and ew would be desirable , to rule out some unexpected mechanism rather than luminosity changes dominating the observed effect .
unfortunately , the majority of the optical spectroscopic observations do not appear to be well flux - calibrated , so we can not directly compare ew with optical continuum luminosity .
a second possibility is to compare with an x - ray measurement which has been made contemporaneously , which is what we attempt next . in order to be considered , the x - ray and optical spectroscopic measurements had to be made within one day of each other , except at quiescent levels at which we assumed a more or less stable level had been reached ( quiescent variability can reach factors of several , but this not very significant for these logarithmic plots ) . in fig 4
we plot h@xmath0 ew as a function of @xmath6 for the sample of objects discussed previously ( except for v404 cyg for which we do not have contemporaneous x - ray measurements ) , plus the more unusual object gx 339 - 4 .
none of the individual sources show a statistically significant rank ( anti-)correlation ( see table 2 ) . in fig 5
we plot the ensemble of data points , plus a small amount of additional data from the sources v404 cyg , gro j1655 - 40 , 4u 1957 + 11 , gs 2000 + 25 , xte j1650 - 500 and xte j1859 + 226 ( see table 1 for references ) . a spearman rank correlation test for the complete sample plotted in fig 5 results in a spearman rank correlation coefficient of @xmath7 ( a @xmath8 result ) .
this supports the conclusion of section 2.1 .
a single power - law fit to the data presented in fig 5 gives @xmath9 this is close to , but steeper than , the ew @xmath10 estimated in section 2.1 , and indicates a mean x - ray decay e - folding time less than the 30 days given in chen et al .
the apparent anti - correlation seems to be dominated by the difference between measurements at @xmath11 erg s@xmath12 , where all sources are in the hard x - ray spectral state , and those at higher luminosities , where transitions between different spectral states can occur ( see e.g. nowak 1995 ; homan & belloni 2005 ; remillard & mcclintock 2006 for a discussion of these states ) .
it is somewhat puzzling that the anti - correlation stands out much more clearly in the first analysis ( figs 2 and 3 ) than in the second ( figs 4 and 5 ) , which implies that there may not be a simple one - to - one relation between x - ray luminosity and h@xmath0 ew . in this context
it is interesting to note that the low - frequency qpos in some hard state black hole candidates show similar monotonic behaviour with time which is not so simple when compared to x - ray flux ( e.g. xte j1118 + 480 in wood et al .
2001 ) . in any case ,
the anti - correlation , whether simple or not , is clearly there .
far fewer results were available in the literature for neutron star systems ; the details and references are provided in table 1 . in fig 6
we plot the neutron star data alongside the black hole data presented in fig 5 .
what we see is approximately similar behaviour , in that there is a suggestion of a similar trend , with a similar ( or slightly lower ) normalisation .
in fact a spearman rank correlation test indicates that the sample of seven neutron star measurements are anticorrelated at the @xmath13 level ( @xmath14 ) .
so the neutron star data are consistent with , but do not independently establish , the anti - correlation found for the bhxbs . adding the bhxb and neutron star samples results in a spearman rank correlation coefficient of @xmath15 , corresponding to an anticorrelation at the @xmath16 level . in summary ,
although the individual simultaneous @xmath6 and ew measurements do not confirm the anti - correlation further , the effect is significant when considering the ensemble of all data points , moreso when combining neutron star data with the black hole sample .
the upper x - axes of figs 5 and 6 also indicate a rough estimate of the optical infrared luminosities , @xmath17 based on the relations presented in russell et al .
( 2006 ) , and repeated in the figure captions ( without statistical uncertainties ) .
note that the relations are slightly different for black holes and neutron stars ( @xmath18 is larger for black holes at any given x - ray luminosity ) .
this allows us to get a better idea of how the ew varies as a function of the optical continuum .
subject to caveats about the possibly complex nature of the relation to the lines , we can go further . by definition , @xmath19 where @xmath20 and @xmath21 are the line and continuum luminosities respectively . from russell et al .
( 2006 ) , @xmath22 where the value of @xmath23 is slightly different for bh and ns systems .
we also fit a crude relation of the form @xmath24 above .
if we can assume @xmath25 ( i.e. @xmath26 which is justified for a maximum ew of @xmath27 angstroms and a filter width of @xmath28 angstroms , _ and _ a large fraction of the data in russell et al .
( 2006 ) being in the r - band ) we get @xmath29 substituting , we get @xmath30 for the black holes , @xmath31 and @xmath32 , resulting in @xmath33 given the crudeness of the fit to the ew-@xmath34 relation , there seems little point in propagating uncertainties on these relations . while this analysis is crude ,
it does demonstrate that the h@xmath0 line luminosity must vary quite strongly with x - ray luminosity , but not quite as fast as the continuum .
a key diagnostic of the emission site of a spectral line is the line profile itself .
a twin - peaked line profile is a strong indication that the line originates in a rotating flow , such as the atmospheres of geometrically thin accretion discs ( e.g. horne & marsh 1986 ; note however that murray & chiang 1996,1997,1998 have shown that accretion discs with winds can produce single - peaked lines ) . in fig 7
we indicate which lines , from the sample presented in fig 5 , were reported as twin - peaked .
we see that twin - peaked line profiles have been reported at nearly all luminosities , which strongly suggests that the line - emitting region is ubiquitously associated with the rotating accretion flow .
as already noted in the introduction , this is not universally accepted , and a more complex picture is put forward by wu et al .
( 2001 , 2002 ) who argue for three distinct origins for the emission line depending on the source luminosity and spectral states . in all cases , the optical continuum and
lines are likely to be excited by irradiation from a central hot continuum source at least at high luminosities ( see arguments in van paradijs & mcclintock 1994 , and the more recent global study by russell et al . 2006 ) . as noted in the introduction
, however , it has been suggested that the ionising source may in fact be ( at times ) associated with an outflowing jet or corona and not necessarily a static central x - ray source ( see e.g. eikenberry et al .
1998 ; beloborodov et al .
1999 ; markoff et al . 2005 ) .
although we do not think it has an important impact on this analysis , we note that double - peaks may be filled in if the inclination is low or additional components produce low velocity emission .
similarly , single peaked profiles can also be mainly from a disc and vice - versa an intrinsic single peaked profiles with central absorption could give the appearance of a double - peaked line without needing a disc - like flow . the observed anti - correlation between h@xmath0 ew and x - ray luminosity ( both direct and inferred ) implies that as the x - ray luminosity decreases the optical continuum flux drops faster than the line flux .
the analysis in section 2.3 above demonstrates that , over large luminosity ranges at least , all three quantities ( x - ray luminosity , optical luminosity , h@xmath0 line flux ) are dropping , but at different rates ( x - rays drop fastest , line flux slowest ) .
the optical continuum in bhxbs appears to have contributions from both thermal emission from the outer , irradiated , accretion disc plus , in hard x - ray states , a component associated with optically thin synchrotron emission from a jet ( russell et al .
the jet contribution is strongest at longer wavelengths , dominating in the infrared band , but probably contributes no more than 30% of the luminosity in the r - band ( corbel & fender 2002 ; homan et al .
2005 ; russell et al . 2006 ) , which contains the h@xmath0 line . note that at low luminosities the companion star may begin to have a discernible contribution to the continuum luminosity of the systems .
russell et al .
( 2006 ) compile the estimated optical luminosities of several x - ray binaries , and find that in most systems the companion only contributes significantly in quiescence ( i.e. @xmath35 erg s@xmath12 ) .
marsh et al .
( 1994 ) show how in the quiescent system a0620 - 00 the h@xmath0 ew is modulated at the orbital period , presumably due to varying continuum contributions from the tidally distorted companion .
we do not attempt in this paper to subtract such a contribution , noting that ( i ) over the range of luminosities covered in this compilation it is probably not a major effect , ( ii ) any contribution to the continuum by the companion would serve to _ increase _ the true disc ew at low luminosities and strengthen the anti - correlation were it taken into account .
however , it is worth noting that in a regime in which an approximately constant continuum level is set by the companion , the true line flux may be proportional to the measured ew .
based on a wealth of observational data , we have an approximate picture of how the emitted spectra and , to a lesser extent , central accretion / outflow geometry , might vary in bhxbs , principally as a function of luminosity .
for example , it is known that an approximately steady jet is produced at relatively low accretion rates ( @xmath36 ) which are associated with hard x - ray spectra , whereas at higher accretion rates transitions to softer x - ray states with weaker jets can occur ( fender , belloni & gallo 2004 ; homan & belloni 2005 ) . at lower accretion rates
a simple relation between radio and x - ray luminosities appears to hold to at least @xmath37 ( gallo et al .
there is however some evidence that the x - ray spectrum does soften at very low luminosities ( corbel , tomsick & kaaret 2006 ; corbel , krding & kaaret 2008 ) . in the case of accreting white dwarfs in cataclysmic variables , williams ( 1980 )
argued that the outer region of the accretion discs may at some times be optically thick in the line but thin in the continuum .
if a similar situation exists during the decay phase of x - ray transients outbursts , it may well contribute significantly to the observed ew anti - correlation .
the observed anti - correlation is likely to be due to some combination of these changes in the accretion / outflow geometry , the irradiating spectrum , and the optical depth in the outer accretion disc .
a key question is whether or not there are changes in the line properties across the accretion state transitions .
as noted earlier this was one of the key motivations for this research ; however , our findings are inconclusive . on the one hand
the line profile and ew of h@xmath0 in gx 339 - 4 is clearly very similar in bright hard or soft states ( fig 1 ) , but the analysis in section 2.1 suggests that the anti - correlation is better in the hard state below @xmath38 .
results for the black hole transient gro j1655 - 40 presented in shrader et al .
( 1996 ) also suggest a large increase in h@xmath0 ew across a soft @xmath39 hard state transition , although the soft x - ray luminosity of the source would also have been fading during this period . the reader is reminded that wu et al .
( 2001 ) claim that the line profile changes from hard to soft x - ray states .
a possible explanation for the observed anti - correlation is that a large part of the outer disc becomes cold enough to be optically thin in the continuum , not the line , during the decline ( williams 1980 ) . in that case
, the optical continuum drops much more quickly than the ionizing continuum from the inner region ( where the inflow is still optically thick and producing strong continuum emission ) . as a result
the ew of the optical lines from the outer ( optically thin ) region should increase .
such optically thin regions of the outer disc may well exist in x - ray binaries ( e.g. canizzo & wheeler 1984 ) .
shahbaz et al .
( 2004 ) discuss the possibility of regions of different optical depth contributing to the h@xmath0 and h@xmath40 emission from the bhxb a0620 - 00 in quiescence .
it is also possible that there is a saturation effect , in that during outbursts most of the accretion disc becomes too hot for the production of h@xmath0 line emission .
the effect should therefore be different for higher excitation lines such as heii .
although the models mentioned above may well be responsible for the observed anti - correlation , studies over the past decade have indicated that the accretion flow in x - ray binaries , in particular black hole systems , undergo dramatic changes on short timescales which could well have an effect upon observed emission line profiles .
for this reason we summarize this empirical understanding below , and comment on whether or not it might affect the observed anti - correlation .
if , as we assume , the h@xmath0 is a result of irradiation of the outer disc , then the main source of this irradiation will be euv photons with energies between about 13 25 ev .
these photons are not directly observable in nearly all black hole x - ray binaries , which lie at several kpc in the galactic plane and as a result suffer from strong interstellar extinction .
lower energy photons can not ionise hydrogen , and photons with significantly higher energies ( i.e. x - rays ) are more likely to contribute to the reprocessed ( reflection ) continuum ( e.g. ross & fabian 1993 ) .
we do not consider here the possibility of collisional excitation in e.g. an accretion disc hotspot .
how plausible is it that changes in the ionising spectrum are responsible for the observed anti - correlation ?
in bright soft states ( @xmath41 ) the x - ray spectra of bhxbs are dominated by thermal ( accretion disc ) components with kt @xmath42 kev . in less bright , but still very luminous ( @xmath43 ) , hard x - ray states
the x - ray spectrum is dominated by a component which peaks at @xmath27 kev and probably has its origin in a comptonising ` corona ' ( e.g. sunyaev & titarchuk 1980 ) , with some possible contributions from a jet ( e.g. markoff , nowak & wilms 2005 ) .
it should be noted that there can be strong hysteresis between spectral state and luminosity for @xmath44 ( homan & belloni 2005 ) . as a source drops further in luminosity
the accretion disc temperature should drop monotonically until in ` quiescence ' ( @xmath45 ) it is only about 1 ev ( mcclintock , horne & remillard 1995 ; mcclintock et al .
as noted above , at most x - ray luminosities this thermal disc component is essentially unmeasurable as it peaks at ( e)uv wavelengths , in which band most distant galactic plane bhxbs can not be observed . in the case of xte j1118 + 480
( mcclintock et al . 2003 ) this disc component was found to be significantly more luminous than the x - ray component when in quiescence .
therefore , at the lowest x - ray luminosities the bulk of the photons released by the accretion process are not able to ionise hydrogen , which naively should result in a reduced h@xmath0 ew at the lowest luminosities , _ contrary _ to what is observed .
however , the optical continuum is also dominated by reprocessing and so the overall effect on ew will depend upon which component is pumped most effectively by the ionizing continuum , which in some sense returns us to the models dealing with the optical depth of the outer disc ( e.g. williams 1980 ) . what about changes in the geometry of the accretion flow and outflow with luminosity ? some recent sketches of the accretion flow as a function of luminosity for bhxbs ( esin
, mcclintock & narayan 1997 ; done , gierlinski & kubota 2007 ) suggest that as luminosity increases the ability of the central hard x - ray source to illuminate the disc is reduced , as the coronal component shrinks .
geometries which include jets ( e.g. fender , belloni & gallo 2004 ; ferreira et al .
2006 ) may be more complete , although it is unclear how significantly any x - ray emission from the jet could contribute to irradiation of the accretion disc or its atmosphere ( markoff , nowak & wilms 2005 ) .
such x - ray emitting regions near the base of the jet may be essentially indistinguishable from an outflowing corona ( e.g. beloborodov 1999 ) .
nevertheless , it has been suggested that the velocity of the outflow from x - ray binaries may increase with luminosity , and in a more complex way with spectral state .
if the jet or outflowing corona is responsible for some irradiation of the disc , then an increase in velocity with luminosity could result in a reduced h@xmath0 ew as an increasing fraction of the x - rays are beamed along the direction of motion , away from the disc .
a prime motivation for this research was to investigate whether the profiles of optical emission lines change significantly across the accretion state transitions in x - ray binary systems .
such a result may have indicated a strong response to a changing irradiating spectrum and/or geometry of the line - emitting region . however , the results in this respect remain inconclusive . what we did find , and report in detail , is an anti - correlation between the broadband luminosity ( optical x - ray ) and the equivalent width of the h@xmath0 emission line in x - ray binaries .
possibly the most closely related phenomenon already known is a comparable anti - correlation in the h@xmath40 line for cataclysmic variables ( patterson 1984 ; see also witham et al .
2006 ) , accreting binaries hosting a white dwarf rather than a black hole or neutron star .
patterson ( 1984 ) compares this result with the models of tylenda ( 1981 ) , which are similar to those of williams ( 1980 ) in which the outer accretion disc becomes optically thin at low luminosities .
this may also turn out to be the appropriate explanation for the x - ray binaries under discussion here , but the complex and hysteretical accretion state changes about which we have learned much in the past decade caution us against drawing such a conclusion at this time .
more detailed observations of line profiles across state transitions would clearly be of interest .
the reader is further reminded that ( i ) rebrightenings during the decay of transients , ( ii ) the monotonic behaviour of qpos in sources such as xte j1118 + 480 despite varying behaviour in @xmath6 , and ( iii ) the poorer anticorrelation of ew with quasi - simultaneous @xmath6 than with time all suggest that the causal link between luminosity and ew may be complex .
it it worth mentioning in passing the similarity with the baldwin effect observed in accretion flows around supermassive black holes ( baldwin 1977 ; see also e.g. mushotzky & ferland 1984 ) . in this case
an anti - correlation is observed between the ew some lines originating in the broad line region ( blr ) and the continuum luminosity .
a related effect is observed in the x - ray band ( iwasawa & taniguchi 1993 ; page et al .
2004 ) , and maybe also in the strong stellar winds of wolf - rayet stars ( morris et al . 1993 ) . however , there is little evidence for a blr - like region in x - ray binary systems , probably due to the high ionisation state of the gas in the inner disc region ( e.g. proga , kallman & stone 2000 ) .
therefore the physical origins of the two effects are almost certainly rather different .
further observations would obviously be of interest to understand better this effect .
these should include observations of other lines and in other bands .
observations in the near - infrared , where the continuum should have a much stronger jet contribution ( e.g. corbel & fender 2002 ; russell et al .
2006 ) should show a much stronger reaction to accretion state changes ( e.g. we would expect a large jump in ew of a line like br @xmath4 as the jet switches off in a hard @xmath39 soft state transition ) .
it is interesting to note that the spectra in fig 1 hint at a similar anti - correlation for hei , and heii would be even more interesting , given the higher ionisation potentials .
the observed anti - correlation holds the promise of being able to estimate the luminosity of a source from the h@xmath0 ew , something which could prove invaluable in distance determinations for faint x - ray binaries .
however , the relation obviously needs to be significantly improved before that is possible , and may turn out to have enough intrinsic scatter to reduce its usefulness in this aspect ( as is in fact the case for the baldwin effect in agn ) . in any case it is promising that low - luminosity accreting sources should be clearly identifiable in e.g. h@xmath0 surveys by their large equivalent widths . finally , it is interesting to note that observations of the variation of the h@xmath0 line strength with luminosity may in fact be our best way to track the behaviour of the accretion disc component at intermediate luminosities .
below @xmath46 the accretion disc component peaks in the ( e)uv spectral regime and is unobservable for nearly all sources . for two sources
only has it been observed in quiescence , at which point it appears that it no longer extends to the isco but is truncated ( mcclintock et al .
1995 , 2003 ) .
although well - defined models exist ( e.g. dubus , hameury & lasota 2001 ) , exactly how and where this truncation begins is observationally very uncertain ( e.g. miller et al . 2006 ) .
however , since the h@xmath0 line responds preferentially to photons of energies 1325 ev , it may be the best way to study the evolution of this disc component at luminosities @xmath47 .
we would like to thank cristina zurita for providing tables of data for xte j1118 + 480 , and tariq shahbaz and gavin dalton for providing some of the data for fig 1 .
we would like to thank guillaume dubus , daniel proga and kinwah wu for careful reading of , and useful comments on , an earlier version of this work , and the anonymous referee for advice which helped to improve this work .
wu k. , soria r. , johnston h. , hunstead r. , 2002 , in : the ninth marcel grossmann meeting .
proceedings of the mgixmm meeting held at the university of rome `` la sapienza '' , 2 - 8 july 2000 , eds .
: vahe g. gurzadyan , robert t. jantzen , remo ruffini .
singapore : world scientific publishing , p 2274 ( astro - ph/0101390 ) | we report an anticorrelation between continuum luminosity and the equivalent width ( ew ) of the h@xmath0 emission line in x - ray binary systems . the effect is evident both in a universal monotonic increase in h@xmath0 ew with time following outbursts , as systems fade , and in a comparison between measured ews and contemporaneous x - ray measurements .
the effect is most clear for black hole binaries in the low / hard x - ray state , which is prevalent at x - ray luminosities below @xmath1% eddington .
we do not find strong evidence for significant changes in line profiles across accretion state changes , but this is hampered by a lack of good data at such times .
the observed anti - correlation , highly significant for black hole binaries , is only marginally so for neutron star systems , for which there are far less data .
comparison with previously established correlations between optical and x - ray luminosity suggest that the line luminosity is falling as the x - ray and optical luminosities drop , but not as fast ( approximately as @xmath2 ) .
we briefly discuss possible origins for such an effect , including the optical depth , form of the irradiating spectrum and geometry of the accetion flow .
further refinement of the relation in the future may allow measurements of h@xmath0 ew to be used to estimate the luminosity of , and hence the distance to , x - ray binary systems . beyond this , further progress will require a better sample of spectro - photometric data .
accretion , accretion discs x - rays : binaries |
understanding how young stellar objects ( ysos ) assemble themselves and how the accretion process works requires understanding the structure and evolution of the inner disk on size scales @xmath1 0.1 au .
even with the advent of infrared ( ir ) and radio interferometry , imaging of even the nearest ysos to detect structure on these size scales is impractical .
it therefore becomes necessary to infer the spatial structure and composition on these size scales indirectly from , for example , spectral energy distributions ( seds ) , high - resolution spectra , or variability studies .
seds have provided some of the most important insights into the structure and evolution of the inner disks of ysos .
these seds have been used not only to argue for the presence of an inner disk wall , located roughly at the dust sublimation boundary , but also that the upper edge of the wall is in most cases curved ( mcclure et al .
some ysos have both inner and outer optically thick disks separated by an optically thin gap , with the gap likely the result of gravitational sweeping by an embedded giant planet ( quillen et al .
mid - ir spectrophotometric variability seen in a number of ysos suggest that the height of their inner disk wall varies by up to 20% on timescales of days or weeks ( espaillat et al .
2011 ) .
optical or near - ir photometric variability studies offer another path to understanding inner disk structure and to the physics of the interaction between the inner disk and the parent star .
such studies date back more than half a century ( joy 1945 ) , where variability was used as one of the defining characteristics of the new class of young , forming stars .
herbst et al . ( 1994 ) summarized the available information on t tauri star variability , identifying several different classes dominated variously by rotational modulation of cold or hot spots , variable accretion or variable extinction .
variable extinction is particularly attractive as a means to study inner disk structure because in principle it can yield information on very small size scales , if the cadence of the time series photometry is high enough .
bouvier et al .
( 1999 ) showed that aa tau has broad , periodic flux dips whose amplitude and shape vary from epoch to epoch , which they ascribe to variable extinction resulting from a warp in the star s inner disk and to large variation in the amount of material at the inner disk rim on @xmath2week timescales .
photometric surveys of entire star forming regions ( e.g. , carpenter et al .
2001 ; flaherty et al . 2012 ; findeisen et al .
2013 ) with modern 2-d arrays have also allowed other types of variable extinction events both periodic and aperiodic to be identified .
we have recently obtained the highest cadence , highest signal - to - noise ( s / n ) time domain survey of a large population of ysos in a star - forming region during two campaigns in 2008 and 2011 .
we have used those data for ngc 2264 for an initial study of the aa tau - type variables in the cluster ( alencar et al .
2010 ) ; to provide a statistical basis for a new yso light - curve morphology classification scheme ( cody et al .
2014 ) ; and to identify a set of ysos whose light curves are dominated by short duration accretion bursts ( stauffer et al .
2014 ) . in this paper
, we use this dataset to identify a small set of ysos whose light curves exhibit short duration , often near - gaussian shaped , periodic flux dips which must arise from dust structures near the inner disk wall . in a companion paper ( mcginnis et al .
2015 ) , we provide a quantitative analysis of all of the other ysos in our ngc 2264 sample with flux dips due to variable extinction events .
a detailed description of the photometric data we collected in our 2008 and 2011 observing campaigns for the ngc 2264 star - forming region is provided in cody et al .
the subset of the data sources that we use here include several sets of time - series , photometric monitoring data ( the first four items below ) plus additional single - epoch ancillary photometry ( the last two items ) : 0.05truein a 2008 campaign using the _ corot _ ( convection , rotation , and planetary transits ; baglin et al .
2009 ) satellite , designated as sra01 within the _ corot _ mission , with photometry being collected from roughly mjd 54534 to 54556 , a period of 23 days .
the observing cadence was generally every 512 seconds ; however , bright targets and targets of known special interest could be done at 32 second cadence ( and the spacecraft could autonamously switch to 32 second cadence if transit - like events were detected ) .
the passband is set just by the sensitivity curve for the _ corot _ ccd , corresponding to a broad v @xmath3 r filter .
only stars present in an input catalog have _ corot _ light curves .
for each cataloged star , a specific pixel mask was designated to determine which set of pixels was queried to derive the photometry for that star . for the light curves discussed in this paper and illustrated in the figures , typical rms uncertainties in the corot relative photometry range from about 2 mmag at the bright end ( e.g. mon-250 , figure [ fig : sixctts]a ) to about 6 mmag at the faint end ( mon-6975 , figure [ fig : sixctts]f ) . 0.05truein a 2011 campaign designated as sra05 within the _ corot _ mission , with data collected from roughly mjd 55897 to 55936 .
the noise level in these light curves is both higher and more spatially variable due to increased ccd radiation damage . in some cases ,
the same star was observed with different pixel masks in the two epochs , which can also change the derived flux . the observing cadence and basic pipeline reduction steps were , however , the same for the two campaigns .
0.05truein _ spitzer _ ( werner et al .
2004 ) warm mission infrared array camera ( irac ; fazio et al .
2004 ) 3.6 and 4.5 @xmath4 m data obtained simultaneous with the _ corot _ sra05 campaign , roughly from mjd 55900 to 55930 .
the cadence was approximately every 2 hours .
stars near the lower or upper edge of the mapped region have data in only one of the two channels .
all of the spitzer light curves discussed in this paper are for stars that are fairly bright at irac wavelengths , with expected rms uncertainties of order 1% for their relative photometric accuracies .
0.05truein @xmath5-band imaging using the us naval observatory ( usno ) 40 " telescope obtained on clear or partially clear nights during two campaigns ( winter 2010 and winter 2011 ) , roughly mjd 55505 to 55560 and mjd 55890 to 55990 .
typically , 100 - 200 epochs of data were collected in 2010 , and of order 900 epochs in 2011/2012 . for each campaign ,
imaging was obtained for an approximately 23x23 region , centered on the cluster center .
aperture photometry was performed for all stars in all images .
the zero - points for each ccd frame were established by identification of a set of non - variable stars in the region surveyed , and forcing the photometry for these stars to be constant across all images .
each light curve was normalized to a mean relative magnitude of zero .
for the stars in table [ tab : basicinformation ] , the usno relative photometry should have rms uncertainties of less than 1% at the bright end , rising to of order 2% for the faintest of our stars . 0.05truein
single epoch @xmath6 imaging of the entire cluster , with standard sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) filters , obtained using megacam on the canada - france - hawaii telescope ( cfht ) during two observing runs in 2010 and 2012 .
these data are presented in detail in venuti et al .
( 2014 ) . 0.05truein _ spitzer _ irac 3.6 , 4.5 , 5.8 and 8.0 @xmath4 m and mips 24 @xmath4 m single epoch imaging photometry of the entire cluster obtained early in the cryogenic mission , and reported in sung et al .
( 2009 ) and teixeira et al .
if a clump of circumstellar dust passes through our line of sight to a yso , the light from the star will dim by an amount roughly proportional to the column density of dust , modified according to the size distribution of the grains ( if the clump is optically thin ) , or by an amount proportional to the fractional area of the star that is covered ( if the clump is optically thick but small in angular size relative to the star ) .
if the dust clump is long lived and relatively fixed in location , the flux dips it produces should be periodic at the keplerian rotation period for that clump .
for some stars , a warped inner disk has been invoked ( e.g. , aa tau bouvier et al . 1999 ;
flaherty & muzerolle 2010 ) to explain deep flux dips that extend over half or more of the star s rotation period .
dust clumps produced by instability processes in the disk , and levitated above the disk plane into our line of sight , could produce flux dips that do not repeat ( turner et al .
2010 ) . other longer timescale variable extinction events could be associated with keplerian rotation in the outer disk bringing dust into our line of sight ( bouvier et al.2013 ) ; with orbital motion of a binary system causing our line of sight to intersect a circumbinary disk ( plavchan et al .
2008a ) ; or with dust entrained in a spatially or temporally variable disk wind ( bans & knigl 2012 ) .
in our 40 + day monitoring of the star - forming region ngc2264 with _ corot _ and _ spitzer _ , we have identified three different morphological light curve signatures which appear to be associated with variable extinction events .
figure [ fig : sixctts ] shows light curves for ngc 2264 classical t tauri stars ( ctts ) which illustrate each of these different modes .
these three modes are : * aa tau analogs ( examples illustrated in figure [ fig : sixctts]a and b. ) light curves of this type have relatively flat continua , punctuated by deep , broad flux dips occurring at the keplerian orbital period for material near the inner disk rim .
the generally accepted physical explanation is that there is a warp in the inner disk , and that a portion of this warp occults our line of sight ( bouvier et al .
1999 ) ; * aperiodic extinctors ( examples illustrated in figure [ fig : sixctts]c and d. ) light curves of this type have relatively flat continua and deep , narrow and/or broad flux dips but with no obvious periodicity . a possible physical mechanism
is dust levitated relatively high above the disk mid - plane by magneto - resonance instabilities ( mri ) or other instabilities , which then settles back towards the mid - plane , accretes onto the star , or escapes or sublimates on timescales of hours to days .
see mcginnis et al .
( 2015 ) for a discussion of these stars ; * short duration , periodic dippers ( newly identified group - examples illustrated in figure [ fig : sixctts]e and f ) .
light curves of this type have relatively shallow , relatively narrow flux dips with periods generally in the range 3 - 10 days , and with dip shapes often approximately gaussian . sometimes these dips are superposed on a relatively flat continuum , but sometimes the dips are superposed on sine - wave light variations which we attribute to other physical mechanisms . a physical mechanism for these flux dips must also involve dust structures in or near the inner disk rim that are brought into our line of sight by orbital motion .
we discuss options for the origin of these structures in 7 .
there are other types of variables primarily eclipsing binaries ( or systems with transiting exoplanets ) which also have narrow flux dips in their light curves , but their light curves are distinctively different from those illustrated throughout this paper .
figure [ fig : eb_lightcurves ] shows two eclipsing binary ( eb ) light curves from the 2008 ngc 2264 campaign .
figure [ fig : eb_lightcurves]a is the light curve for mon-256 , a dm - dm binary member of ngc 2264 ( gillen et al .
2014 ) that is a borderline ctts ( broad and structured h@xmath7 profile ; modest ir excess ) ; this is the only eb in ngc 2264 with an ir excess presumably due to circumstellar or circumbinary dust . for well - detached systems , eclipses by stellar - sized bodies yield flux dips that are of much shorter duration ( with a gaussian fit width of @xmath8 = 0.045 days for the eclipses of mon-256 ) than those which we study in this paper . the eclipse depths for mon-256 appear to vary considerably with time primarily due to the varying continuum level once that is removed , the depths are quite stable , though slightly different at the primary and secondary eclipse since each star has slightly different radius and effective temperature . figure [ fig : eb_lightcurves]b shows the light curve of a field star projected towards ngc 2264 ; its light curve is that for a near - contact binary ( @xmath9 11 day ) where the continuum variations are primarily due to the ellipsoidal shapes of the stars superposed on which are narrow flux dips from the primary and secondary eclipses .
the gaussian width for the eclipse dip in this case ( @xmath8 = 0.21 days ) is within the range of the widths for the short - duration flux dips we discuss in this paper .
however , the regularity imposed in an eb system yields a very stable light curve which is easily distinguishable from light curves associated with variable circumstellar extinction .
first results from our 2011 - 2012 intensive monitoring of ngc 2264 with _
corot _ and _ spitzer _ have been published in cody et al .
( 2014 ) and stauffer et al .
while working on those papers , we noticed a small set of stars that shared some similarities but did not seem to fit into the primary groupings identified by cody et al . often , the narrow " flux dips in these light curves are superposed on other , larger amplitude , types of variability primarily semi - sinusoidal light curves normally attributed to photospheric spots making identification of this new light curve signature more difficult .
these narrow flux dips presumably arise because some physical structure transits our line of sight to the stellar photosphere .
as mentioned in the previous section , there is already a light curve class ( aa tau analogs ) with periodic , variable extinction events and for which a standard physical model has been developed .
it is possible that this new light curve class can be fit into the same physical model ; however , we believe there are a number of reasons to consider alternate physical models which we will discuss in 7 . to emphasize the primary morphological differences between the classical " aa tau analogs and our proposed new class , figure [ fig : compare_dippers ]
compares the average widths and depths of the flux dips for the new group of stars to those of the aa tau analogs in ngc 2264 identified in the companion paper by mcginnis et al .
while the distribution of points in figure [ fig : compare_dippers ] could be regarded as simply one population with a range of properties , it could also be viewed as two populations whose properties only slightly overlap .
the goal of this paper is to better characterize the light curves with these narrow flux dips , thereby determining if they should be considered as a new class of event or if they should simply be regarded as an extension of the aa tau class . throughout the paper ,
we use the terms narrow " and short - duration " interchangeably to describe the flux - dips of this set of stars , and broad " ( or long - duration ) to describe the flux dips for the classic aa tau light curves , with the dividing line being approximately fwhm / period = 0.25 ( see figure [ fig : compare_dippers ] ) . in table
[ tab : basicinformation ] and table [ tab : basicphotometry ] , we provide basic photometric and spectroscopic data for the nine stars which we believe fall into this narrow - dip " group , compared to a total of 159 ngc 2264 ctts with _
corot _ light curves ( mcginnis et al .
2015 ) . all but one of these stars are previously identified members of ngc 2264 that had been classified as ctts based on either h@xmath7 emission or seds .
spectral types are available for all of these objects , and all are low mass stars with spectral types of k5 or later . in the remainder of this section
, we provide a brief description of each star and its light curve properties . in table
[ tab : quant_information ] , we provide the fitted times , widths and depths of all the flux dips for these stars where those quantities could be determined accurately , and we give a label for each of these dips - the dip i d column of the table - primarily as a means for us to refer to specific dips in the text .
= .99 lccccccccccc csimon-000021 & 06405944 + 0959454 & 223980412 & 223980412 & k5 & -7.4 & 1.6 & 3.2 & 0.96 & 1.69 & 9.7 & 7.3/14.5 + csimon-000056 & 06415315 + 0950474 & 223994760 & 223994760 & k5 & -1.8 & 1.0 & 5.83 & 0.77 & 1.51 & 14.3 & 6.5/13.0 + csimon-000378 & 06405292 + 0944544 & & 616872605 & k5.5 & -8.5 & 2.1 & 11.1 & 0.90 & 1.71 & 21.3 & 7.0/14.0 + csimon-000566 & 06405275 + 0943004 & 400007955 & 400007955 & m3.5 & -19.4 & 0.9 & 4.5 & 0.16 & 1.23 & 7.3 & 2.9/5.9 + csimon-001076 & 06403819 + 0929524 & 400007702 & 605424384 & m1 & -2.6 & 0.6 & 5.85 & 0.26 & 1.25 & 10.4 & 3.8/7.5 + csimon-001131 & 06393441 + 0954512 & 223957455 & 223957455 & m1.5 : & -31.1 & 1.4 & 5.2 & 0.55 & 2.02 & 8.9 & 5.5/11.0 + csimon-001165 & 06404192 + 0943551 & & & m3 : & -7.9 & 1.3 & 5.5 & 0.13 & 1.15 & 8.5 & 2.7/5.3 + csimon-001580 & 06410285 + 1007119 & 223981250 & & m1 : & -17.2 & 0.6 & 7.1 & 0.27 & 1.28 & 11.9 & 3.8/7.7 + csimon-006975 & 06395318 + 1001137 & & 616803898 & m2.5 : & -15 .
& 0.2 & 2.8 & 3.42 & 3.44 & 5.8 & 9.3/18.6 + ccccccccccccc csimon-000021 & 18.174 & 15.835 & 14.810 & 14.452 & 12.781 & 12.093 & 11.685 & 11.248 & 10.936 & 10.707 & 10.052 & 7.556 + csimon-000056 & 18.785 & 16.205 & 15.056 & 14.475 & 12.959 & 12.302 & 12.003 & 11.717 & 11.390 & 11.038 & 10.290 & 7.866 + csimon-000378 & 18.277 & 16.142 & 14.943 & 14.239 & 12.699 & 11.862 & 11.267 & 10.882 & 10.540 & 10.091 & 9.371 & 6.270 + csimon-000566 & 20.988 & 19.109 & 17.747 & 16.418 & 14.318 & 13.588 & 13.279 & 12.823 & 12.576 & 12.140 & 11.132 & + csimon-001076 & 20.754 & 18.336 & 16.896 & 16.012 & 13.931 & 13.194 & 12.891 & 12.485 & 12.289 & 12.025 & 11.278 & 8.566 + csimon-001131 & 18.769 & 17.180 & 15.832 & 14.856 & 12.991 & 12.215 & 11.932 & 11.492 & 11.152 & 10.893 & 10.195 & 6.998 + csimon-001165 & 21.924 & 19.528 & 17.983 & 16.427 & 14.679 & 13.845 & 13.582 & 13.043 & 12.789 & 12.380 & 11.571 & + csimon-001580 & 20.489 & 17.976 & 16.553 & 15.678 & 13.978 & 13.218 & 12.874 & 12.624 & 12.455 & 12.223 & 11.244 & 8.013 + csimon-006975 & & 20.027 & 17.974 & 16.626 & 13.476 & 12.576 & 12.151 & 11.666 & 11.56 & & 11.10 & + mon-21 , also known as v602 mon , is a relatively poorly studied member of ngc 2264 of spectral type k5 ( rebull et al .
2002 ) , with weak h@xmath7 emission ( furesz et al .
2006 ) and a relatively modest ir excess .
it has no discernible ultraviolet ( uv ) excess ( venuti et al .
we obtained _ corot _ light curves for it in both 2008 and 2011 , and an irac light curve for it in 2011 .
lccccc csimon-000021 & 2008 & a1 & 4535.39 & 0.17 & 10% + csimon-000021 & 2008 & a2 & 4536.15 & 0.17 & 7% + csimon-000021 & 2008 & b & 4541.99 & 0.18 & 7% + csimon-000021 & 2008 & c & 4545.07 & 0.18 & 5% + csimon-000021 & 2008 & d & 4548.47 & 0.17 & 12% + csimon-000021 & 2008 & e1 & 4554.73 & 0.16 & 10% + csimon-000021 & 2008 & e2 & 4555.60 & 0.15 & 4% + & & & & & + csimon-000021 & 2011 & a & 5897.65 & 0.22 & 10% + csimon-000021 & 2011 & b1 & 5900.35 & 0.35 & 2.5% + csimon-000021 & 2011 & b2 & 5900.77 & 0.29 & 4.5% + csimon-000021 & 2011 & c & 5910.29 & 0.26 & 8% + csimon-000021 & 2011 & d1 & 5913.10 & 0.33 & 3.5% + csimon-000021 & 2011 & d2 & 5913.30 & 0.11 & 3.5% + csimon-000021 & 2011 & d3 & 5913.64 & 0.18 & 6% + csimon-000021 & 2011 & e & 5916.31 & 0.41 & 4% + csimon-000021 & 2011 & f1 & 5919.23 & 0.38 & 4.5% + csimon-000021 & 2011 & f2 & 5919.73 & 0.25 & 6.5% + csimon-000021 & 2011 & g1 & 5922.51 & 0.25 & 6.0% + csimon-000021 & 2011 & g2 & 5922.96 & 0.20 & 8.2% + csimon-000021 & 2011 & h1 & 5925.04 & 0.34 & 1.5% + csimon-000021 & 2011 & h2 & 5925.86 & 0.29 & 10% + csimon-000021 & 2011 & i1 & 5928.60 & 0.35 & 5.5% + csimon-000021 & 2011 & i2 & 5929.20 & 0.27 & 10% + csimon-000021 & 2011 & j1 & 5931.79 & 0.39 & 4% + csimon-000021 & 2011 & j2 & 5932.37 & 0.23 & 12% + & & & & & + csimon-000056 & 2011 & a & 5912.63 & 0.32 & 12.5% + csimon-000056 & 2011 & b & 5919.00 & 0.25 & 5.5% + csimon-000056 & 2011 & c1 & 5924.30 & 0.25 & 8.3% + csimon-000056 & 2011 & c2 & 5925.08 & 0.27 & 7.7% + & & & & & + csimon-001165 & 2011 & a & 5911.87 & 0.20 & 25% + csimon-001165 & 2011 & b & 5922.83 & 0.15 & 14% + & & & & & + csimon-006975 & 2011 & a1 & 5905.54 & 0.10 & 15% + csimon-006975 & 2011 & a2 & 5905.82 & 0.10 & 12% + csimon-006975 & 2011 & b & 5908.36 & 0.13 & 14% + csimon-006975 & 2011 & c & 5910.94 & 0.10 & 7% + csimon-006975 & 2011 & d & 5919.59 & 0.11 & 11% + & & & & & + csimon-001131 & 2011 & a & 5901.06 & 0.30 & 24% + csimon-001131 & 2011 & b & 5906.14 & 0.30 & 23% + csimon-001131 & 2011 & c1 & 5910.66 & 0.27 & 12% + csimon-001131 & 2011 & c2 & 5911.03 & 0.18 & 10% + csimon-001131 & 2011 & c3 & 5911.56 & 0.36 & 11% + csimon-001131 & 2011 & d & 5926.75 & 0.75 & 13% + csimon-001131 & 2011 & e1 & 5931.66 & 0.34 & 6.5% + csimon-001131 & 2011 & e2 & 5932.04 & 0.14 & 10% + csimon-001131 & 2011 & e3 & 5932.31 & 0.15 & 12% + & & & & & + csimon-001580 & 2008 & a1 & 4541.73 & 0.18 & 13% + csimon-001580 & 2008 & a2 & 4542.15 & 0.24 & 9% + csimon-001580 & 2008 & b1 & 4548.53 & 0.15 & 6% + csimon-001580 & 2008 & b2 & 4548.7 & 0.06 & 5% + csimon-001580 & 2008 & b3 & 4548.98 & 0.17 & 8% + csimon-001580 & 2008 & c & 4554.83 & 0.20 & 25% + & & & & & + csimon-000378 & 2011 & a & 5918.64 & 0.55 & 14% + & & & & & + csimon-001076 & 2008 & a & 4538.65 & 0.17 & 15.7% + csimon-001076 & 2008 & b & 4550.54 & 0.16 & 13% + csimon-001076 & 2008 & c & 4556.20 & 0.15 & 12.5% + & & & & & + csimon-000566 & 2011 & a & 5909.33 & 0.32 & 5% + the as - observed _ corot _ light curve for mon-21 in 2008 ( figure [ fig : mon21_modela]a ) appears relatively complex because , we believe , it is a superposition of two distinctly different waveforms arising from two different physical mechanisms . specifically , we ascribe the broad , semi - sinusoidal variation to rotational modulation due to the presence of a large , high latitude spot group on the star s photosphere .
the narrow flux dips that are also present are the component we wish to isolate and quantify .
the two waveforms appear to have nearly identical periods , and to produce features of very similar amplitude . in order to measure accurately the properties of the flux dips ,
it is necessary to remove the comparatively smoothly varying , semi - sinusoidal pattern .
we construct a model light curve to emulate the sinusoidal variation by taking the _ corot _ data from day mjd 4537.4 to 4540.6 , the portion of the light curve least affected by narrow flux dips , and use those data to produce a sine - wave - like template covering one full period ( 3.22 days ) .
( the light curve interval from @xmath24550 to 4553 is also relatively clean , but we felt that the inflection in the curve presumably due to a narrow dip was harder to eliminate unambiguously compared to the earlier time interval . ) from examination of the light curve , we mark beginning points ( flux and time ) for each cycle , which are indicated as the lower green circles in figure [ fig : mon21_modela]b .
a linear correction term is added to the flux for each replicated template so that its ending flux matches the next cycle s beginning flux .
finally , we slightly adjust the amplitude of each waveform ( by multiplying all the measurements in that replicated waveform by a constant ) so that the maximum brightness matches the observed maximum at that epoch ( upper green circles in figure [ fig : mon21_modela]b ) .
the model light curve is shown in red in figure [ fig : mon21_modela]b ; the result of subtracting this model from the observed light curve and hence our representation of the light curve solely due to variable extinction events is shown in figure [ fig : mon21_modela]c .
we made no further adjustments to the model to better fit the observed data other than the deterministic steps described above .
we note that the first and last of the narrow dips are in fact double - dips , with the second dip being shallower and offset by of order 0.8 days in both cases ( see figure [ fig : mon21_modela]d ) .
we have ascribed the sinusoidal variations to non - axisymmetrically distributed star spots on the stellar photosphere
probably cold spots .
could it instead be ascribed to variable extinction due to a warped disk intersecting our line of sight ?
we offer two arguments in favor of our hypothesis and counter to the alternative .
first , we know what the light curves of ysos with typical warped disks look like because there are many of them in ngc 2264 ( see the companion paper to this , mcginnis et al .
those light curves look nothing like the semi - sinusoidal pattern shown in red in figure [ fig : mon21_modela]b ; the warped disk light curves are much more irregularly shaped and much more time variable .
second , we also know that light curves dominated by non - axisymmetrically distributed , high - latitude spots are common amongst ysos ( herbst 1986 ; bouvier & bertout 1989 ) and their light curves closely resemble the red curve in figure [ fig : mon21_modela]b .
in fact , we have identified one ctts in ngc 2264 mon-103 whose _ corot _ light curve is nearly identical , except for minor scale factors , to the red curve in figure [ fig : mon21_modela]b .
we provide a quantitative comparison of the 2008 mon-21 light curve and that for mon-103 in the appendix .
figures [ fig : mon21_modela]e and f compare a gaussian fit to the observations for the dips that are narrowest and best fit by such a model ( dips b and d - see table [ tab : quant_information ] ) .
the derived times , gaussian widths and dip depths ( as a percentage of the continuum " flux ) are provided in table [ tab : quant_information ] .
most of the dips are well fit , and most have widths in the narrow range from 0.15 to 0.18 days . the semi - sinusoidal pattern and the narrow flux dips both have apparent periodicities of about 3.2 days . however , are the dips exactly periodic ? and , are the periods for the semi - sinusoidal waveform and the dips precisely the same ?
the answer to the first question is no , as can be seen from examination of the data in table [ tab : quant_information ] .
the centroids of each dip can be measured to an accuracy of a few hundredths of a day , yet dip b and c are separated by 3.08 days , while dips c and d are separated by 3.40 days .
applying the period - finding algorithm of plavchan et al.(2008b ) to the light curve for just the flux dips ( figure [ fig : mon21_modela]c ) yields a period of 3.224 days ; a similar estimate of 3.223 days is obtained by subtracting the measured times for dip e1 and a1 and assuming they are separated by six periods .
the lomb - scargle algorithm yields a period of 3.15 days for the semi - sinusoidal pattern ( represented either just by the red curve in figure [ fig : mon21_modela]b or by the residual remaining after subtracting the gaussian fits from the original light curve ) .
given the real variations in the timing of the flux dips and the comparative shortness of our _ corot _ campaign , we can not conclude the two periods are significantly different . by 2011 ,
the _ corot _ light curve for mon-21 changed morphology , as illustrated in figure [ fig : mon21_corot]a .
the semi - sinusoidal pattern is either essentially absent or much reduced in amplitude .
the flux dips appear somewhat broader and in many cases asymmetric .
one possibility is that we are still seeing a blend of a spotted waveform and narrow flux dips from variable extinction , with the spot being responsible for the weaker feature causing the apparent asymmetry in each observed waveform ; another possibility is that spots no longer contribute in any significant way and the observed waveforms are due to the blend of two narrow dips . in order to document the full light curve shape , we have chosen to simply model the observed features with gaussian fits , usually with two components ; the fits to a number of the dips are shown in figure [ fig : mon21_corot ] . on average ,
the primary dip at each epoch has a gaussian sigma width of [email protected] days , about 50% broader than the dips in 2008 .
the weaker secondary dips always precede the deeper dip .
see table [ tab : quant_information ] for the fit parameters .
the average period inferred from the dip centroids is [email protected] days , somewhat different from the dip period in 2008 , but essentially equal to the period for the sinusoidal waveform we attribute to spots on the stellar surface .
a ground - based usno @xmath5-band light curve for mon-21 is available that overlaps in time with the _ corot _ light curve . for a star of mon-21 s i magnitude ,
the expected rms uncertainty in the relative usno photometry is about 0.02 mag .
because the _ corot _ data have significantly lower noise and higher cadence , they provide the best measure of the shape of the flux dips .
however , the usno data extend beyond the _ corot _ campaign by nearly two months , and therefore provide valuable information as to the persistence and amplitude variability of the flux dips .
figure [ fig : mon21_usno]a shows an expanded view of the region of best overlap between the _ corot _ and usno data ; figure [ fig : mon21_usno]b shows the entire usno light curve .
these data illustrate that the same flux dip structure is detected in the ground - based data , and that it persists for at least twenty days after the end of the _ corot _ campaign . because the ground - observing only provided data for about 5 - 6 hours per night , the window function for detecting the flux dips in the usno data is not very good and it is not possible to deduce whether similar depth flux dips persisted beyond mjd 55960 .
we also obtained a _
spitzer_/irac [ 3.6 ] light curve for mon-21 in 2011 . as shown in cody et al .
( 2014 ) , for a star of mon-21 s brighness , the expected rms uncertainty in the relative irac photometry should be of order 1% .
the most obvious feature of the irac light curve is a gradual flux decrease of 0.25 mag beginning around mjd 55910 . on small timescales , there are possible correspondences between the _ corot _ flux dips and features in the irac data , but there are also places where there is no correspondence . given the shallowness of the dips in the _ corot _ data , and that the disk contributes equal or more light at [ 3.6 ] , the lack of distinct dips in the ir is not unexpected . in many respects , mon-56 is a near twin to mon-21 .
it also has a published spectral type of k5 ( dahm & simon 2005 ) , h@xmath7emission with an inverse p - cygni profile but quite small equivalent width ( furesz et al .
2006 ) , essentially no uv excess and ir colors placing it near the center of the class ii population in the irac color - color diagram ( allen et al .
similar to mon-21 , we interpret its _ corot _ light curve in 2011 as also being the superposition of two components with essentially identical periods - a smoothly varying , semi - sinusoidal component , possibly due to star - spots and a system of periodic , shallow , short duration flux dips which are sometimes single and sometimes double . figure [ fig : mon56_corot]a shows the as - observed _ corot _ light curve .
compared to mon-21 , however , the mon-56 light curve is more difficult to deconvolve because the flux dips are generally stronger and broader and in phase with the flux minima of the sinusoidal waveform , thereby making it harder to construct a high quality model for the spotted light curve ( or to be certain that this component is indeed due to spots as opposed to a warped - disk model ) .
we have therefore resorted to a lower fidelity but simpler model for the smoothly varying component of the light curve specifically , we adopt a simple sine - wave , whose phase , amplitude and period we set to yield the best fit ( i.e. to yield a residual light curve with a nearly flat continuum level interspersed with narrow dips ) . figure [ fig : mon56_corot]b shows our final model for the smoothly varying component of the light curve superposed on the observed mon-56 light curve , and figure [ fig : mon56_corot]c shows the result of subtracting this model from the observations , yielding our best visualization of the short - duration flux dips in this star . the full amplitude of the adopted sinusoid is 0.06 mag ( about 6% ) , and the period is 5.83 days ( the same as determined from ground - based monitoring by lamm et al .
because of the approximate nature of the deconvolution , we attempt to derive flux dip fits only for the three strongest features in figure [ fig : mon56_corot]c .
those parameters are provided in table [ tab : quant_information ] and the fits are illustrated for the apparently single flux dips in figure [ fig : mon56_corot]d and e. we note that the mon-56 _ corot _ data are interpreted differently in mcginnis et al .
mcginnis et al .
attribute all of the variability seen in the system to variable extinction , as opposed to a superposition of spot and extinction variability . regardless of these differences , both models agree that the narrow , periodic flux dips are best attributed to extinction and we therefore believe mon-56 fits within the class of variability discussed in this paper .
mon-1165 has spectral type m3 ( see appendix ) . in an irac color - color diagram
, it falls within the box defining the locus for class ii ysos ( allen et al . 2004 ) .
however , as for the previous two ysos , it has essentially no uv excess , and only a weak h@xmath7 emission line .
we do not have a _
corot _ light curve for mon-1165 , but the irac light curve shows distinct , narrow , periodic , short - duration , paired flux dips ( see figure [ fig : mon1165_irac]a ) .
an auto - correlation analysis of the light curve yields a period for the flux dips of 5.5 days .
the lower amplitude dip always precedes the main dip by about 1.2 days ( see figure [ fig : mon1165_irac]b ) .
the flux dips are generally deeper at 3.6 @xmath4 m than at 4.5 @xmath4 m by , on average , about 50% but this is poorly determined due to the shallowness and narrowness of the dips and the relatively low cadence of the observations .
only two of the dips are well - enough defined to accurately measure their shape and width those fits are shown in figure [ fig : mon1165_irac]c and d ; the gaussian @xmath11 values for the two fits are 0.15 and 0.20 days .
we have ground - based , optical , synoptic photometry which only overlap with a small portion of the _ spitzer _ data due to bad weather in arizona in december 2011 .
figure [ fig : mon1165_usno]a shows the entire usno light curve , illustrating that at least a few flux dips are present beyond the end of the _ corot _ campaign .
figure [ fig : mon1165_usno]b overplots the irac and usno data for the time window where we have some optical data that falls at or near the center of one of the strong ir flux dips .
the ratio of the dip depth at 4.5 @xmath4 m to the depth in the i band @xmath12 is about 0.3 . in order to use this ratio to help constrain the occultation geometry ,
we must make a correction for the fraction of the ir light that comes from the disk ( assuming the disk flux is not significantly occulted ) .
based on a fit to the star s sed , our estimate of f@xmath13(disk)/f@xmath13(star ) is 1.3 ; hence the corrected dip depth ratio becomes @xmath14 0.7 .
given the uncertainties , this is consistent with equal dip depths at both wavelengths , as one would expect from dust structures that are optically thick but cover only a small part of the star .
if instead the dust structures are optically thin , this ratio would indicate an extreme deficit of small particles compared to the standard ism mixture where the ratio should be @xmath20.10 ( indebetouw et al.2005 ) .
mon-6975 is another essentially anonymous star that had not even been considered an ngc 2264 member until now .
our attention was drawn to this star by its 2011 _ corot _ light curve ( it was not observed by _ corot _ in 2008 ) .
we have subsequently obtained optical and ir spectra of it from soar ( see appendix ) which indicate a spectral type of m2.5 and moderately strong h@xmath7 emission ( h@xmath7 equivalent width = 15 ) .
good seeing images show it to be a nearly equal brightness optical binary with a separation of order 2.4@xmath15 oriented ne - sw on the sky ; the ne component has a nearly featureless spectrum that is much redder than that of the m2.5 star . despite the very red color
, the ne component has h@xmath7 weakly in absorption , and no other spectral features that are detected with certainty .
we therefore assume it is not a yso and is only a line - of - sight companion to the sw component .
both objects contribute to the _ corot _ light curve , though we assume that the flux dips arise only from the young star .
we do not have a measure of its uv excess , nor a complete set of irac photometry in order to classify its disk .
the _ corot _ light curve for mon-6975 shows a nearly constant continuum " level and a large number of narrow flux dips with a relatively wide range in both depth and width ( figure [ fig : mon6975_corot]a ) .
the periodicity of the flux dips for this star is not as obvious as for mon-21 and mon-1165 , but an auto - correlation function yields a period of 2.8 days . to guide the eye ,
we have placed a cross below the first strong dip in the light curve , and then successive crosses spaced 2.8 days apart for the remainder of the light curve . some of the flux dips for mon-6975 are very narrow , with gaussian @xmath8 values ranging from 0.095 to 0.13 days .
figure [ fig : mon6975_corot]b shows several of these dips , and the gaussian fits we have derived .
we have an irac 3.6 @xmath4 m light curve for mon-6975 it is overlaid on the _ corot _ light curve in figure [ fig : mon6975_irac_corot ] .
the irac light curve is similar in character to the _ corot _ light curve in the sense that it shows a relatively flat continuum level and two probable flux dips at the location of two of the strongest flux dips in the _ corot _ light curve .
the irac light curve is , however , much noisier , making an accurate assessment of the depth of the two flux dips at irac wavelengths difficult .
however , it is clear that the derived ratio , after correction for the contribution to the irac flux from the disk , would be greater than 0.5 and possibly consistent with 1.0 . therefore , as for mon 1165 , the dip depth ratio is either consistent with optically thick occulting structures or with optically thin clouds " whose dust mixture is extremely depleted in small grains .
= .99 mon-1131 , also known as qt mon , has _ corot _
data from both 2008 and 2011 .
the 2008 light curve for this star is very different from the 2011 light curve , and is probably dominated by variable accretion this light curve is shown and discussed in the appendix . the 2011 light curve ( figure [ fig : mon1131_corot]a ) fits within the short - duration flux dip class , although compared to the other prominent members of the class , its flux dips are relatively broad .
the dip period is 5.08 days .
the two narrowest dips have gaussian @xmath8 values of 0.27 and 0.30 days their profiles are shown in figure [ fig : mon1131_corot]b . the irac light curve for mon-1131 is essentially uncorrelated with the _ corot _ light curve .
we also obtained a soar optical spectrum of mon-1131 . based on measures of the depths of the tio bands in that spectrum
, we estimate its spectral type at m1.5 .
the furusz et al .
( 2006 ) multiple - mirror telescope ( mmt ) high resolution spectrum for mon-1131 shows it to have a broad and structured h@xmath7 profile .
both its h@xmath7equivalent width ( @xmath1630 ) and its uv - excess ( figure [ fig : colorcolor_ir ] ) identify it as the most strongly accreting star amongst the short - duration flux dip group .
mon-1580 is another relatively little - studied member of ngc 2264 .
there is no published spectral type , however it is a known h@xmath7emission line yso ( reipurth et al .
1996 ; furesz et al . 2006 ) .
based on the furesz et al .
spectrum , we estimate the spectral type as m1 . we have a 2008 _ corot _ light curve , but no corresponding light curve from the 2011 campaign . the 2008 light curve ( figure [ fig : mon1580]a ) is reminiscent of the 2008 mon-21 light curve , in the sense that it appears to be the superposition of a spotted star light curve and a number of short duration flux dips .
the spot light curve period and the flux dip period are the same ( @xmath177.1 days ) to within our ability to measure the periods .
figure [ fig : mon1580]b shows the gaussian fits to the two strongest flux dips .
mon-378 is another system where the light curve is a superposition of a spotted star light curve and narrow flux dips ( figure [ fig : mon378_obs_mod]a ) .
mon-378 is a ctts with an inverse p cygni h@xmath7 profile ( furesz et al .
2006 ) , spectral type k5.5 ( dahm & simon 2005 ) , and location corresponding to a class ii yso in the irac color - color diagram .
the _ corot _
light curve is from 2011 it was not observed in the 2008 _ corot _ campaign .
the irac light curve shows no flux dips and little correlation with the _ corot _ light curve .
the _ corot _
light curve shows a large amplitude spotted star waveform with a period of about 11 days and with a single prominent , narrow flux dip at mjd @xmath2 55919 .
however , after creating a model of the spotted star light curve as done for mon-21 , and subtracting it from the original light curve , a second prominent , narrow flux dip becomes evident ( figure [ fig : mon378_obs_mod]b ) .
this by itself would be a weak case that the dips are periodic .
however , we also have a 2010 ground - based optical light curve , which shows ( albeit poorly sampled ) three apparently narrow flux dips with the same @xmath211 day period ( figure [ fig : mon378_obs_mod]c ) .
mon-1076 ( aka v338 mon ) is somewhat similar to mon-378 and mon-1580 .
it has a 2008 _ corot _ light curve with low amplitude variations which may be due to star - spots but which are not stable enough to yield an obviously periodic ( sinusoidal ) signature .
the _ corot _
light curve shows three prominent narrow flux dips at mjd 54539 , 54551 and 54556.5 , consistent with a period of @xmath25.8 days ( figure [ fig : mon1076]a ) .
fits to the two best observed flux dips are shown in figure [ fig : mon1076]b .
the published spectral type for mon-1076 is m1 ( dahm & simon 2005 ) .
mon-1076 was observed by _
corot _ in 2011 , but bad systematics in the light curve preclude using it for any analysis .
mon-566 is a relatively late - type ctts member of ngc 2264 , with a published spectral type of m3.5 ( dahm & simon 2005 ) and an h@xmath7equivalent width of 19.4 (dahm & simon 2005 ) .
its location in the irac color - color diagram places it in the class ii yso category .
it was observed by _
corot _ in both 2008 and 2011 .
mon-566 is quite faint in the optical , and therefore the _ corot _ light curves are very noisy which makes interpretation of the light curves difficult .
nevertheless , both the 2008 and 2011 light curves appear to show periodic , narrow , shallow flux dips .
the flux dip period is 4.5 days .
two other sets of data give us confidence that the _ corot _ flux dips are real .
first , a _ spitzer _
2011 light curve also shows low s / n flux dips of similar width and depth at the location of some of the _ corot _ flux dips .
second , we have a usno light curve for mon-566 in 2011 , and that light curve also shows flux dips coincident with those present in the _ corot _ and _ spitzer _ light curves .
all three light curves are shown in figure [ fig : mon566_spitzer_corot_usno ] .
the flux dips in the usno light curve seem to be significantly deeper than those in the _ corot _ light curves .
we suspect this is because mon-566 is very faint for _ corot _
( @xmath18 = 17.7 ) , and in some cases the background subtraction routine that is used in the _ corot _ pipeline results in too small ( or large ) a correction . for mon-566 ,
the correction is probably too small and the apparent flux dip depths are therefore also too small .
most of the stars in our sample are considerably brighter in the optical , so we do not believe their flux dips are significantly affected by imprecision in the background correction for their _ corot _ light curves .
are there stars with light curves exhibiting superposed narrow _ and _ broad , periodic flux dips ? are there stars which have just one or a couple narrow - flux dips over the timescale of the _ corot _ short runs
? do weak - lined t tauri stars ( wtts ) ever show narrow flux dips in their _ corot _ light curves ?
these questions could shed light on both the physical mechanism for the phenomena and the requirements on our line - of - sight to the circumstellar disks in these system . to answer the above questions
, we critically examined the _
light curves for all @xmath2600 ngc 2264 members ( ctts , wtts and unknown classification ) in our catalog for which we have _ corot _ light curves as well as for 600 field stars with _ corot _ light curves obtained simultaneously with the ngc 2264 members .
the member stars included all of the ysos identified in mcginnis et al .
( 2015 ) as aa tau analogs .
we find that two of the stars with aa tau - type light curves do exhibit periodic , narrow flux dips in addition to the broad flux dips required to be members of the aa tau class .
figure [ fig : mixed_dips ] shows these light curves , with the red diamonds marking the location of the periodic , narrow flux dips . in each case , the period inferred from the narrow flux dips is equal ( within the uncertainties ) with that derived from the broad flux dips .
gaussian fits to the narrow flux dips yield widths that are in the same range as those measured for the narrow flux dip stars of table [ tab : basicinformation ] . for these composite light curves ,
the narrow flux dips always occur during the portion of the light curve near the minimum in light for the broad - flux dips .
the amplitudes for the narrow flux dips vary considerably from epoch to epoch , but do not seem to correlate with the amplitudes of the broad flux dips .
we have also identified another type of composite light curve light curves with periodic features that are sometimes narrow and sometimes broad ( defined arbitrarily as fwhm / period @xmath16 0.3 ) .
there are at least four such objects in our ngc 2264 dataset - mon-441 , mon-928 , mon-379 , and mon-14132 ; all are included in mcginnis et al .
( 2015 ) as aa tau analogs .
their light curves are shown in figure [ fig : composite_dips ] .
it could be argued that these four stars should be added to our group of short - duration , periodic flux dip stars .
we prefer not to do that because we prefer to restrict the group to stars where all the dips in a _
campaign are short duration .
however , including these stars in the group would not change any of our conclusions .
based on the fact that the periodic narrow and broad flux dips can be present in the same star and during the same campaign , the most significant deduction one can make is that the requirements for producing these two types of dips overlap .
because the aa tau , warped disk model requires a specific viewing angle to the disk , that same viewing angle must also be compatible with production of the short - duration , periodic flux dips .
our visual re - examination of the other _ corot _ light curves yielded two additional results .
first , none of the stars identified as wtts ( nor any of the non - member stars ) showed any narrow or broad flux dips whose morphology mimicked those of the aa tau light curves or those of the periodic , short - duration flux dip stars .
this is , of course , as one would expect if such dips are due to close - in circumstellar dust , which wtts and non - members should lack .
second , we identified a set of nine stars all ctts whose light curves showed only a single , or in some cases a few , short - duration flux dips ( but with no hint of periodicity ) .
light - curve snippets for a sample of these flux dips are shown in figure [ fig : singledip_dips ] .
the widths and depths of these dips fall within the range found for the stars of table [ tab : basicinformation ] .
the physical properties ( uv excesses ; ir excesses ; spectral types ) of the stars with these single dips are not obviously different from the other types of variable extinction stars .
we assume that the same physical mechanism(s ) for producing the flux dips applies to this set of stars , but in their case other dust raising events either do not lift the dust high enough to occult our line of sight or yield dust opacities insufficient to yield a dip detectable in our data .
however , when considering the statistics of what fraction of ctts show any evidence of line - of - sight extinction events , these objects should also be included in the calculation .
a table of basic information for these stars ( table [ tab : singledippers ] ) is provided in the appendix .
why do the ctts in table [ tab : basicinformation ] show periodic , short - duration , often gaussian shaped flux dips ? if there are common physical characteristics that are shared by this set of nine ysos , perhaps that would help allow us to assign a physical mechanism to the flux dips .
we begin by examining the inferences we can make regarding the orientation of the circumstellar disks to our line of sight .
we then discuss a variety of color - color and color - magnitude diagrams ( cmds ) which sort the ngc 2264 ysos by mass or accretion rate or ir excess .
for the inferred properties in table [ tab : basicinformation ] and for the calculations in this section , we adopt a distance of 760 pc for ngc 2264 ( sung et al.1997 ) .
the sung et al .
distance is in good agreement with a recent vlbi distance for a maser source in the cluster ( @xmath19 = 738@xmath20 pc ; kamezaki et al .
2014 ) and with a recent analysis of data for a newly - identified ngc 2264 pre - main sequence ( pms ) eclipsing binary ( @xmath19 = 756@xmath1096 pc ; gillen et al .
2014 ) .
practically the simplest , most straight - forward , test we can make to constrain the origin of the material causing the flux dips is to determine the inclination of our line of sight to the circumstellar disk for these stars . in order for a yso to show flux dips from disk material passing through our line of sight ,
most models predict that the inclination of the disk to our line of sight must be @xmath21 .
to increase the sample size for this test , we include not only the stars in table [ tab : basicinformation ] but also the other stars discussed in 5 that have both narrow and broad flux dips . in total
, we have eleven stars for which we have all of the relevant information ( luminosity , stellar @xmath22 , @xmath23 , and rotation period ) .
the input data , and our estimates of the line of sight angles are provided in table [ tab : incl - estim ] .
the periods listed in table [ tab : incl - estim ] are those derived from the flux dips . in several cases ( mon-21 , mon-56 , mon-378 , mon-1580 )
, the light curves also show semi - sinusoidal variations plausibly due to photospheric spots , and in those cases the spot periods are indeed essentially the same as the periods derived from the dips ( and thus consistent with
disk locking " ) .
we assume for the other stars that their flux dip periods are also equal to their photospheric rotation periods .
the @xmath23 values are either from vlt - flames or keck - hires spectra we have obtained for this program , or from reanalysis of mmt - hectochelle spectra obtained by furesz et al.(2006 ) .
a description of the spectral analysis is provided in mcginnis et al .
the stellar luminosities are derived from the measured j - band magnitudes , extinctions based on fits to multicolor photometry , the adopted distance of 760 pc , and bolometric corrections from pecaut & mamajek ( 2013 ) ; the derivation of these luminosities is described in venuti et al .
effective temperatures are derived from spectral types either from the literature or from our own spectra as described in the text and the appendix and a conversion from spectral type to @xmath22 appropriate for ysos . in order to illustrate the impact of the temperature scale ,
we show results for two representative temperature scales in table [ tab : incl - estim ] , one from table 6 of pecaut & mamajek ( 2013 ; pm13 ) and one from cohen & kuhi ( 1979 ; ck79 ) .
for many of the stars , the calculation returns a value of @xmath24 @xmath16 1.0 , and in these cases we tabulate an inclination of 90@xmath25 .
a visual summary of the results is provided in figure [ fig : inclination_hist ] .
the mean values and uncertainties are : @xmath26 = 1.16 @xmath10 0.55 ( ck79 ) and @xmath26 = 1.08 @xmath10 0.53 ( pm13 ) when including all eleven stars ; and @xmath26 = 1.03 @xmath10 0.35 ( ck79 ) and @xmath24 = 0.96 @xmath10 0.35 ( pm13 ) if one excludes the highly discrepant values for mon-928 .
these estimates support the hypothesis that we are viewing these systems nearly edge on to their disks , and that the material passing through our line of sight to produce the flux dips plausibly lies within the disk or near the disk surface .
it is clear , however , that individual @xmath24 estimates have large uncertainties , making this result less robust than we had hoped . assuming that @xmath22 and @xmath23 uncertainties dominate , and that they contribute approximately equally , the @xmath24 estimates suggest the true uncertainties in @xmath22 are of order 10% and in @xmath23 are of order 20% .
= .99 lccccccccccc csimon-000021 & 3.20 & 19.2 @xmath10 1.5 & 0.957 & k5 & r02 & 4140.0 & 4395.0 & 1.68 & 0.719 & 39.53 & 45.97 + csimon-000056 & 5.83 & 11.1 @xmath10 2.2 & 0.774 & k5 & ds05 & 4140.0 & 4395.0 & 1.52 & 0.842 & 48.20 & 57.35 + csimon-000378 & 11.1 & 10.4 @xmath10 0.4 & 0.896 & k5.5 & ds05 & 4080.0 & 4295.0 & 1.71 & 1.333 & 90.00 & 90.00 + csimon-001076 & 5.85 & 9.8 @xmath10 2.4 & 0.256 & m1 & ds05 & 3630.0 & 3681.0 & 1.23 & 0.908 & 61.98 & 65.20 + csimon-001131 & 5.18 & 8.8 @xmath10 1.7 & 0.545 & m1.5 : & s14 & 3560.0 & 3590.0 & 1.91 & 0.470 & 27.60 & 28.00 + csimon-001165 & 5.50 & 16.8 @xmath10 2.3 & 0.130 & m3 : & s14 & 3360.0 & 3360.0 & 1.06 & 1.711 & 90.00 & 90.00 + csimon-001580 & 7.10 & 11.4 @xmath10 2.0 & 0.265 & m1 : & s14 & 3630.0 & 3681.0 & 1.26 & 1.260 & 90.00 & 90.00 + csimon-000250 & 8.70 & 9.8 @xmath10 2.2 & 1.229 & k3 & ds05 & 4550.0 & 4775.0 & 1.62 & 1.037 & 70.29 & 90.00 + csimon-000379 & 3.69 & 25.0 @xmath10 1.2 & 2.121 & k2 & ds05 & 4760.0 & 4955.0 & 1.97 & 0.920 & 58.06 & 66.86 + csimon-000811 & 7.88 & 13.5 @xmath10 1.7 & 1.076 & k6 & ds05 & 4020.0 & 4200.0 & 1.96 & 1.070 & 78.50 & 90.00 + csimon-000928 & 9.92 & 20.1 @xmath10 2.8 & 0.576 & m0 & ds05 & 3770.0 & 3915.0 & 1.65 & 2.490 & 90.00 & 90.00 + color - magnitude or color - color diagrams could provide clues to the physical mechanisms driving the photometric variability in our three light curve classes ( aa tau analogs , stars with aperiodic flux dips , and the new short - duration flux dip class ) .
if a mechanism depended on the stellar mass or luminosity , this should be reflected by the location of the class members in a cmd . if the mechanisms depended sensitively on our view angle to the circumstellar disk , then the mean @xmath27 to the system as estimated from a @xmath28 vs. @xmath29 diagram could differ amongst the three classes .
if the mechanism(s ) depend sensitively on the radius of the inner disk wall or the degree of disk flaring , that could be reflected in the irac [ 3.6]@xmath30[4.5 ] vs. [ 5.8]@xmath30[8.0 ] diagram .
figure [ fig : cmdandjhkdiagrams]a compares the location in an optical cmd of the short duration flux dip stars to the set of classical aa tau analogs ( except as noted in footnote 22 ) and the aperiodic extinctor candidates in ngc 2264 as identified in mcginnis et al . (
no reddening correction has been attempted .
the primary conclusion we draw from this diagram is that the aa tau analogs and stars with aperiodic flux dips appear to be bluer and brighter ( higher mass ) , on average , than the narrow dip stars , with only a couple having @xmath31 colors corresponding to m dwarfs .
secondarily , we see no obvious age difference between the three groups of stars or of these stars relative to the entire set of ngc 2264 members .
as illustrated in figure [ fig : sptype.histo ] , the spectral types for the short - duration flux dip stars are also significantly later , on average , than those for the ngc 2264 stars we classify as classic " aa tau analogs , lending support to the belief that they are generally lower in mass . based on a monte carlo simulation , there is less than a 2% chance the two groups are drawn from the same parent spectral type distribution .
= .99 figure [ fig : cmdandjhkdiagrams]b provides the @xmath32 vs. @xmath33 diagram for the same set of stars , as a means to assess their reddening .
since all of the variable extinction stars are ctts , we assume that the meyer et al .
( 1997 ) ctts locus represents their intrinsic ( unreddened ) colors , at least for low mass ctts .
the aperiodic dip star located near @xmath29 = 0.4 , @xmath28 = 0.6 ( mon-325 ) is a high mass star ( spectral type g6 ) , and presumably dereddens back to the ascending portion of the main - sequence locus .
most of the variable extinction stars lie near the meyer et al . ctts locus , and therefore have little additional reddening as inferred from their mean 2mass photometry .
one exception is mon-6975 , whose ir colors of @xmath29 = 0.42 , @xmath28 = 0.90 indicates relatively large inferred reddening .
mon-6975 is also the reddest variable extinction star in the optical cmd ( figure [ fig : cmdandjhkdiagrams]a ) .
we conclude that outside of the flux dips , the other ysos with narrow and broad flux dips have at most modest reddening , and therefore that reddening corrections would not significantly alter their locations in optical cmds such as figure [ fig : cmdandjhkdiagrams]a . figure [ fig : colorcolor_ir]a shows the @xmath34 vs. @xmath35 color - color diagram ( venuti et al .
2014 ; stauffer et al .
2014 ) , discussed extensively in venuti et al .
( 2014 ) as an accretion diagnostic .
ysos lacking active accretion ( wtts ) form a roughly inverted v - shaped locus in this plane , with late f stars located near @xmath35 = 0.6 , @xmath34 = 1.6 and later spectral types becoming redder until about m0 at @xmath35 = 1.4 , @xmath34 = 2.8 .
later type m dwarfs maintain @xmath35 @xmath2 1.4 but have bluer @xmath34 colors for later m subtypes , presumably due to active chromospheres .
accretion hot spots primarily affect the @xmath34 colors , displacing the star towards the bottom of the plot ( bluer @xmath34 colors ) .
the diagram shows that most of the variable extinction stars have weak uv excesses .
the short duration flux dip stars have locations in this diagram indistinguishable from the members of the two other variable extinction light curve classes . figure [ fig : colorcolor_ir]b provides the irac color - color diagram , which allows one to separate stars with ir seds characteristic of class i , ii and iii ysos ( allen et al .
the diagram shows that a significant fraction of the aa tau analogs and aperiodic flux - dip stars have ir colors intermediate between class ii and iii , whereas the short duration flux dip sample all have relatively red colors consistent with the class ii locus .
the red ir colors imply that warm dust near the inner disk wall often provides the majority of the flux in the irac bands ( see column 7 of table [ tab : basicinformation ] ) . that , plus the expected lower selective extinction at 4 @xmath4 m compared to the optical , may help explain why ,
when we do have simultaneous optical and ir light curves , we usually see only hints of the flux dips in the irac data .
in the previous sections , we have attempted to establish quantitative data characterizing the short duration flux dips and the stars whose light curves exhibit these features .
we summarize these properties : * about 5% ( 8 of 159 ) of the ctts in ngc 2264 show this type of light curve ( periodic , short - duration flux dips ) at least some of the time . after removing two objects
we classify here as short - duration flux dip stars , mcginnis et al .
( 2015 ) consider 31 of 159 of the ctts with corot light curves as either aa tau analogs or aperiodic extinctors , corresponding to a 19% occurrence rate . *
another nine ctts show one or a few short - duration flux dips in their corot light curves .
therefore , the total fraction of ctts with some evidence for flux dips due to dust structures intersecting our line of sight is 48/159 or 30% . * for the stars of table [ tab : basicinformation ] , the flux dip durations are typically @xmath36 0.25 days , with a range from about 0.10 to 0.4 days , based on gaussian fits .
* many of the flux dips are well - fit by single gaussian profiles , or in some cases , blends of 2 or 3 gaussians . *
the depths are never large
the largest we have measured is of order 25% ; most are only of order 10% . *
the periods exhibited range from about 3 to about 10 days . in some cases
, we also can derive stellar rotation periods from superposed semi - sinusoidal flux variations in the light curves , and when we do so , the periods are equal or nearly equal to the dip periods .
* there are significant changes in both depth and shape of the dips from epoch to epoch ; in most cases the widths are more constant than the depths . *
the flux dips persist for typically many orbital periods . in at least two cases ,
periodic narrow dips are present in both 2008 and 2011 . * in three cases ( mon-21 in 2008 , first and last dips ; mon-56 , several dips ; and mon-1165 , all dips ) , there are paired flux dips with the dips separated well enough so as not to be blended " .
when this occurs , the separation in time between the two dip centroids stays approximately constant . * where we have estimates of the inclination of the disk to our line of sight , that inclination indicates that we usually view the disk close to edge on . *
compared to the other ctts in ngc 2264 with variable extinction light curves , those with short duration flux dips are , on average , later in spectral type , with the majority being early to mid m dwarfs . * in the irac color - color diagram , the short - duration flux dip stars have colors which place them in the middle of the class ii distribution , whereas the classic aa tau and aperiodic flux dip stars often have mid - ir colors in the transition region between class ii and class iii .
* a small number of stars show both broad ( aa tau - like ) and narrow periodic flux dips ; another small set show one or two narrow flux dips , with no evidence of periodicity .
* for the very small number of events where we have sufficient coverage at both optical and ir wavelengths , the ratio of the flux dip depth in the optical to that at 4 @xmath4 m indicates that either the occulting structures are optically thick , or if the cloud " is optically thin , then the dust grain mixture must be very depleted of small grains compared to the standard ism composition .
we assume that any physical model to explain the short duration flux dips will have as its starting point that the dips are due to our line of sight being intercepted by structures in or near the inner circumstellar disk that rotate through and occult our line of sight .
a fundamental parameter of such structures is their physical size .
we can estimate the average size scale involved from the parameters in table [ tab : basicinformation ] and figure [ fig : compare_dippers ] . from figure
[ fig : compare_dippers ] , the average value of the ratio of the dip fwhm and the period for the short - duration flux dips is about 0.15 . assuming the dips are due to material orbiting the star , that ratio should correspond approximately to the angular size of the structure as seen from the star , in this case indicating an angular size of about 0.95 radians .
the average co - rotation radius for the stars in table [ tab : basicinformation ] is 11.3 r@xmath37 . assuming that the dust structures are located at or near the co - rotation radius , the average physical size of the structures
would then be about 11 r@xmath37 .
for our stars in table [ tab : basicinformation ] , the stellar radius r@xmath38 @xmath2 1.5 r@xmath37 , and hence the physical size of the structure corresponds to about 7 r@xmath38 , or to about 0.05 au .
further , the shallowness of the dips usually just 5 - 10% implies either that only a small part of the star is being occulted , or that the average optical depth through the dust structure is small .
the lack of a flat bottom to the flux dips requires that the dust structure not be very small relative to the star , nor much bigger than the star ( completely occulting it ) and homogenous .
finally , we emphasize again the frequent occurrence of flux dips whose shapes are approximately gaussian . in combination with the preceding two points ,
this characteristic places significant constraints on the geometric structure of the occulting object . with these considerations in mind
, we offer four possible physical models which could produce short duration , periodic flux dips in the light curves of ctts .
classical aa tau light curves usually show considerable structure within their broad flux dips , which is often highly variable from epoch to epoch .
these characteristics presumably attest to physical structures in or near the inner disk wall whose size , shape , and/or optical depth also change considerably on the timescales of the keplerian orbital period at that radius .
the duration of the aa tau flux dips is set by the fraction of the orbital longitude range where the upper edge of the inner wall intersects our line of sight .
even if the height of the upper lip of the disk wall varies smoothly with longitude , there will be certain lines of sight where the longitudinal range which intersects our line of sight is small , resulting in a short - duration , periodic flux dip .
more probably , the height of the inner disk wall will vary irregularly both in time and in longitude , with the highest points being potential sources for short - duration flux dips given an appropriate view angle to the disk .
arguments in favor of this interpretation of the data are that it is the simplest explanation , and it can fairly naturally explain stars with periodic flux dips having a range of ( dip fwhm)/period . the simple mathematical formula proposed by bouvier et al .
( 1999 ) results naturally in there being a width - depth correlation for flux dips produced by disk warps of varying inclination to our line of sight as illustrated in figure [ fig : model_width_depth ] . given the bouvier et al .
formula to describe the disk warp for aa tau , flux dips with maximum depths @xmath16 0.3 magnitudes and fwhm / period @xmath16 0.25 ( classic aa taus ) would be predicted to be somewhat more common than those with shallow but detectable depths , again as observed .
the simple model also yields dip shapes that are reasonably close to gaussian .
= .99 in detail , however , some aspects of the data do not seem to fit with this simple model .
the distribution of variable extinction stars in figure [ fig : compare_dippers ] is somewhat bimodal , with a deficit of objects with fwhm / period @xmath2 0.3 and depth @xmath2 0.3 , perhaps more suggestive of two populations rather than a single population .
the tendency for the classic aa taus to have earlier spectral types and to be bluer and brighter in the optical cmd argue against there being just a geometrical ( view - angle ) difference between the classic aa taus and the short - duration flux dip sample . instead , there could be a mass or temperature effect . for example
, this could be explained by differing magnetic field geometries as a function of mass , over the k1 to m4 range in spectral types for our stars .
also , while the simple geometrical model can produce gaussian flux dip shapes , the actual flux dip shapes for the classic aa taus are highly structured , requiring the material in the disk warp to also have a highly non - uniform and variable distribution .
if the disk warp model were adjusted to yield structured dips to match the classic aa taus , it is not obvious it would yield predicted narrow flux dips that would often still be well - approximated as gaussian in shape .
romanova et al .
( 2004 ; 2008 ) predict that for ysos with relatively low accretion rates , the accretion may occur in stable , relatively long - lived
funnel flows " .
typically , two tongues of gas arise from the inner disk , separated by about 180@xmath25 .
the gas originates from a relatively broad range in longitude and then gathers together into a narrower stream ( it funnels " ) .
some empirical evidence for these types of accretion curtains has been provided through analysis of ctts emission line profiles and their variability ( symington et al .
2005 ; bouvier et al . 2006 ) .
if the gas flow originates from the region near the dust sublimation radius , and that radius is beyond the co - rotation radius , then it will start with a lower angular rotation rate than the star and a trailing spiral pattern will result , as illustrated in figure 1 of romanova & kurosawa ( 2014 ) .
dust could be entrained in this flow and survive briefly as the gas / dust mixture rises above the disk plane ( though the dust will soon sublimate as it flows towards the star ) .
alternatively , bans & knigl ( 2012 ) have advocated that disk winds originating from beyond the dust sublimation radius may levitate sufficient dust to contribute a large fraction of the 3 to 4 micron flux in ysos , and if that wind were significantly non - axisymmetric it could be the source of potentially short - duration flux dips .
we have constructed a toy model of an accretion curtain in order to illustrate constraints that the narrow dip profiles place on such a curtain .
we tune the model to the flux dips in mon-21 .
specifically , the model must produce approximately gaussian shaped flux dips with @xmath39 0.2 days ( fwhm @xmath2 0.45 days ) for a system with @xmath40 = 1.7 @xmath41 , @xmath42 = 3.2 days , and @xmath43 = 9.7 @xmath41 .
we place the curtain at the co - rotation radius . based on the geometrical arguments from 7.1
, we adopt a curtain width of 8 @xmath40 .
we divide the curtain into 8 vertical panels , each of base width 1 @xmath40 ( the left panel of figure [ fig : toy_funnel ] illustrates the geometry of the toy model ) .
the panels are actually triangles , all meeting at a common apex at height @xmath44 above the midpoint of the curtain . for very large @xmath45 ,
the panel is essentially a vertical wall of width 8 @xmath40 . for @xmath44 = 8 @xmath40 ,
the curtain becomes an equilateral triangle .
we adopt a uniform optical depth of 0.1 for dust within the curtain .
finally , we place the bottom of the curtain so that it is aligned with the bottom of the star as viewed from our vantage point .
we place the edge of the curtain near the leading limb of the star , and let orbital motion ( with the mon-21 period ) carry the curtain in front of the star . with the above idealized geometry
, we wish to determine if flux dips like that observed can be reproduced - and if so , what range of convergent point heights is allowed ?
the right panel of figure [ fig : toy_funnel ] shows the flux dips produced for values of the convergent height from 20 @xmath40 ( bottom ) to 1 @xmath40 ( upper blue curve ) . the model with a convergent height of 1 @xmath40 produces an approximately gaussian shaped profile whose fwhm @xmath2 0.4 days , within the range of dip widths observed for mon-21 .
these results emphasize two things : ( a ) in order to produce a flux dip as broad as observed , an accretion curtain must be quite wide ( several times the stellar diameter ) at its base ; and ( b ) in order to produce the gaussian shape , assuming a uniform dust opacity , the curtain must funnel " down to a much smaller region over a very small scale height . the alternative to this would be to assume instead that the curtain has an opacity distribution smoothly varying with longitude , peaking near its midpoint .
what types of limits on opacity variations within the curtain could we detect ?
we constructed one model , for convergent height of 1 @xmath40 , where we set the opacity of one of the panels to half the normal value .
the top model flux dip in figure [ fig : toy_funnel]b shows this result . for many of the flux dips illustrated in this paper , the observed dip shape is more symmetric than this model and we could exclude an opacity fluctuation of this order . however , some of the flux dips we have shown do have asymmetries which could perhaps be indicative of opacity fluctuations ( rather than as a blend of two gaussian waveforms ) .
one criticism of this model is that it could simply be regarded as a reformulation of the first model .
that is , the tip of a warped disk is the place where one might expect an accretion curtain to form , and whether one labels the dust structure there as part of the disk or the base of the accretion flow is , perhaps , only semantics .
one reason to keep the two ideas separate is that if the line of sight inclinations to mon-21 and especially mon-1131 ( table [ tab : incl - estim ] ) are confirmed at a value near our current estimates ( @xmath46 40 and 27 degrees , respectively ) , this could not be accomodated within a warped disk model but could be compatible with the accretion curtain model if dust could survive in the accretion flow to heights of several stellar radii above the disk plane . in this case , the duration of the flux dip would be set by the inclination of the accretion flow relative to the orbital axis .
the , on average , later spectral types and dustier disks for the short - duration flux dip stars are not an obvious feature of the model but could possibly be made to fit .
the lower luminosity of the star and the dustier disk could correspond to allowing the base of the accretion column to be located beyond the dust sublimation radius , whereas the higher luminosity , less dusty disks of the classical aa taus might have their accretion columns be dust free . alternatively , the less dusty nature of the aa tau group s disks may simply reflect their higher stellar mass and the expected dependence of disk evolution timescales on stellar mass ( longer timescales for lower mass stars ) .
the short durations and small amplitudes of the flux dips could arise from mountains on the surface of the disk that is , features standing up above their surroundings .
such features would either be low - relief , sweeping across only the bottom of the star s face but optically thick , or taller , but diffuse and of moderate optical depth .
mountains arising from the disk would naturally cross the star once per local orbit , while varying from one crossing to the next due to the internal turbulence .
the issue is how to lift the mountains above the plains .
one way to produce vertical relief on the disk surface is through vortices driven by rossby wave or baroclinic instabilities .
sub - millimeter and millimeter interferometric imaging of nearby transition - disk ysos has revealed several stars with large azimuthal asymmetries in surface brightness at separations from the star of tens of au ( van der marel et al .
2013 ; isella et al .
2013 ; perez et al.2014 ) .
the asymmetries are interpreted as millimeter - sized particles concentrated in long - lived hydrodynamical vortices rotating in the disk plane ( lyra & mac low 2012 ; lyra & lin 2013 ) .
similar vortices occurring within a fraction of an au of the star might account for the periodic flux dips we observe .
the vortices have higher surface densities than their surroundings and thus could increase the column along lines of sight to the star in some range of viewing angles . however to account for all the narrow dips , the vortices would need to obscure the star in 5 - 10% of all systems , and thus to increase the height of the starlight unit - optical - depth surface near the dust sublimation front by 5 - 10% of the radius or more if not every disk has a vortex near the relevant radius . in the existing hydrodynamical models , the surface density enhancements at the vortices are about a factor of two ( lyra et al .
2009 ; meheut et al .
2010 ; lyra & mac low 2012 ; meheut et al .
we construct a model consisting of a star of 0.5 @xmath47 and 2 @xmath48 , with effective temperature 4000 k. orbiting the star is a disk accreting at @xmath49 yr@xmath50 .
the disk s surface density is 1000 g @xmath51 at 0.1 au and falls off inversely with the radius .
an inner edge is created by rolling off the surface density inside 0.1 au as a gaussian with half - width 0.015 au .
the disk s outer edge is defined by an exponential cutoff with radial scale 40 au . to prevent the outer disk from obscuring the star before the inner edge as the system is tilted over to higher inclinations , we give the outer disk a lower dust abundance .
the dust - to - gas mass ratio is 1% inside 0.2 au and falls off as a gaussian with half - width 0.2 au toward dust - to - gas mass ratio @xmath52 .
the disk material s opacity comes from well - mixed compact spherical grains chosen to match the observed spectra of protostellar sources ( preibisch et al .
we place a vortex at 0.1 au , giving it a surface density contrast of two and profiles in the radial and azimuthal directions that are gaussians with full - widths at half maximum of one - quarter the radius and @xmath53 , respectively .
we translate the disk s surface densities into volume densities using a temperature profile taken from the midplane of a monte carlo radiative transfer calculation in a similar but axially - symmetric density distribution , lacking the vortex .
this places the model disk in approximate hydrostatic equilibrium .
we then carry out a 3-d transfer calculation to obtain the distributions of temperature and radiation intensity in the disk with vortex , using the bjorkman & wood ( 2001 ) algorithm and lucy s ( 1999 ) method as implemented by turner et al .
isotropic scattering is included .
we solve the transfer equation on a grid of rays ( yorke 1986 ) including the scattering and thermal emission source terms , to construct synthetic images of the system as viewed at different points around the vortex s orbit .
we conduct photometry on the images and assemble them into a lightcurve .
the resulting v - band photometric amplitude is 1% or less at all viewing angles .
the model vortex thus has too little vertical relief to explain the dips amplitudes . to account for the possibility that vortices can eventually reach contrasts up to an order of magnitude relative to their surroundings , as suggested by long - duration 2-d hydrodynamical calculations ( regaly et al .
2012 ) , we carry out a further run in which the surface density contrast is increased to ten .
the v - band amplitude exceeds 3% when the system is inclined between 81 and 84@xmath25 , peaking at 7% for inclination 83@xmath25 .
therefore , even this seemingly extreme vortex can not easily explain either the full range of the narrow dip amplitudes or the number of objects in which they occur .
however , vortices concentrate pebble- to boulder - sized rubble ( barge & sommeria 1995 ) , and collisions between the rubble particles could yield fragments that raise the abundance of sub - micron dust even more than by a factor of 10 . determining whether the increase makes vortices a viable explanation for the narrow flux dips will require better models of the dust sources , sinks and transport . a planet embedded in a disk
exerts a gravitational force that raises a spiral arm in the surrounding material .
the pattern co - rotates with the planet and is strongest near the planet s location ( rafikov 2002 ) .
in particular , a planet orbiting interior to the disk s inner rim could raise a bump on the rim that rotates with the planet s orbital period , which is shorter than the period at the rim .
hot jupiters orbiting mature stars cluster near periods 3 - 5 days and eccentricity zero , while less massive planets show no such clustering .
hot gas giants can not easily grow in situ , as reviewed by helled et al.(2013 ) .
instead they probably formed outside the snow line and reached their present orbits either by migrating through the disks that gave them birth , or by later dynamical interactions with third bodies ( baruteau et al .
detecting planets interacting with the disks would help separate these possibilities . to test whether planet - disk interactions could cause the narrow dips , we construct a model using the same 0.5 @xmath47 star and disk as in the vortex picture above .
the vortex is replaced by a 5 @xmath54 planet orbiting at 0.07 au , which raises a spiral overdensity in the disk following the shape of muto et al .
( 2012 ) eq . 1 , which is derived from a linear analysis by rafikov ( 2002 ) and therefore is strictly valid only for planets with masses less than about 1 @xmath55 .
we build the density and temperature distribution using the same procedure as for the vortex model , and again conduct synthetic observations using the radiative transfer code .
the results are shown in figure [ fig : spiral ] , where the head of the spiral arm passing in front of the star produces a narrow dip with optical amplitude 2.3% , in the range observed among the stars in ngc 2264 .
a more massive disk or higher dust abundance would likely yield larger amplitudes . also , the spiral arm s star - facing side is hotter than the axisymmetric model used to set up the approximate hydrostatic equilibrium , so that restoring the balance would make the atmosphere expand , increasing the dip amplitude . however whether there is time to reach hydrostatic equilibrium is unclear , since the spiral arm propagates around the disk at the planet s orbital frequency .
a more serious difficulty with this picture is that it yields dips in less than 5% of all randomly - oriented systems , even if every star has a similar hot planet .
the planet - driven bump simply does not extend high enough above the surrounding disk to obscure the star over a wide range of viewing angles .
a more massive planet could yield a taller bump , but accurate modeling would require non - linear numerical hydrodynamical calculations .
if the amplitude can be made large enough , then among the four pictures we have considered , the planet - raised spiral arms could best explain any individual system in which the dips are regularly - spaced and repeat more often than the orbital period at the dust sublimation radius .
however , unless hot jupiters are much more frequent in ngc 2264 than amongst field stars , this mechanism could not be invoked for the majority of the periodic , narrow , flux dip stars .
this paper , and the others in this series ( alencar et al . 2010 ; cody et al . 2014
; stauffer et al . 2014 ; mcginnis et al .
2015 ) demonstrate how high cadence , long duration , sensitive , photometrically stable light curves can be used to infer physical properties of ysos that are otherwise impossible to investigate . in this paper ,
we have identified a new yso light curve class characterized by short - duration , shallow , periodic flux dips .
depending on which physical mechanism is responsible for producing these short - duration flux dips , detailed study of this set of stars has the potential to significantly improve our understanding of the structure of the inner disks and accretion flows in ysos and the role of instabilities and migrating planets in shaping the inner disks and their dust content .
regardless of the precise physical mechanism for producing the short - duration flux dips , if we are correct in assigning the semi - sinusoidal variations to photospheric spots and the short - duration flux dips to dust in or near the co - rotation radius , then our observations for at least mon-21 ( 2008 ) , mon-378 , and mon-1580 confirm that their stellar rotation rate is locked to the keplerian rotation period at the inner disk .
this has been a long - standing prediction of some models for the angular momentum evolution of ysos ( e.g. , knigl 1991 ; collier - cameron and campbell 1993 ) but with generally only indirect evidence to support it .
we offer here one possible interpretation of our data , which attempts to incorporate as many as possible of the constraints on the physical mechanisms we have described in sec .
assume that extinction events can be produced both by a warped inner disk and by dust entrained within an accretion flow of the sort envisioned in the romanova et al
. models .
assume further that for the youngest , least evolved disks , our line of sight to the inner disk may be obscured by optically thick dust in the outer , flared disk .
adopt the idea proposed in keane et al .
( 2014 ) that transition disks , as well as having partially cleared inner disks , also have less flared ( or less dusty ) outer disks . given those thoughts ,
the stars with isolated , narrow flux dips ( figure [ fig : singledip_dips ] ) could be systems where dust in an accretion flow has survived to an unusually high distance above the disk plane .
we see only one or two of these dips per 40 day light curve because only rarely does the dust survive long enough to reach a height to intersect our line of sight .
these systems are , therefore , viewed at somewhat smaller inclinations than the other variable extinction stars .
the periodic , narrow flux dip stars are systems viewed at larger inclinations where it is more likely the dust will generally be present in the accretion flows . finally , the classic aa tau analogs are the systems with more evolved
less dusty outer disks where we see into the inner disk and where a warped inner disk can then occult our line of sight .
the systems with both broad and narrow flux dips have extinction events produced by dust in both the warped disk and in the accretion funnels .
we offer this scenario primarily as a way to focus future studies .
the main results of this paper are the empirical constraints on the narrow flux - dip light curves and their host stars provided in 6 and 7 , which any model of these events must explain .
a general concern with any model for the variable extinction stars is simply that there seems to be too many of them in ngc 2264 .
there are roughly equal numbers of stars with each of the three light curve types ( aa tau , aperiodic dip , and short - duration dip ) , with about 39 such stars in all , corresponding to about 25% of the total number of ctts for which we have _ corot _ light curves .
if one includes the single - dip stars from figure [ fig : singledip_dips ] , then about 30% of the ctts have some evidence for dust clumps within 0.1 au of the star intersecting our line of sight .
that seems high , given an expectation that the inner disk wall height should be of order 15% of the disk radius at that location ( dullemond et al .
2001 ; muzerolle et al .
2003 ) , even allowing for some ysos having warped disks .
a provocative solution to this concern is suggested by the claim from klagyivik et al .
( 2013 ) that there are many more eclipsing binary members of ngc 2264 than should occur by chance if their axes were randomly oriented , from which they conclude that the eb axes are preferentially aligned and that we are near the plane of their orbital motions .
if this is also true for the angular momentum vectors of the single stars in ngc 2264 , then we would also detect a higher fraction of variable extinction stars than would be true for a random orientation of axes .
other authors have concluded that the rotational velocities ( @xmath23 and periods ) of stars in open clusters are compatible with a random orientation of axes and incompatible with any strong alignment of axes ( e.g. , kraft 1970 ; jackson & jeffries 2013 ) , so this either argues against such an effect in ngc 2264 or that ngc 2264 is unusual in this respect .
_ facility : , , , . _
in 4.1.1 , we used the mon-21 light curve itself to generate a model for the portion of the light curve we attribute to spots , and subtracted that model from the data in order to derive an estimate of the light curve structure due to variable extinction . in order to demonstrate that this procedure is adequate to the task , we offer here another means to estimate the flux dip light curve .
all modern studies agree that the dominant physical mechanism which drives the visual appearance of optical light curves for most wtts is the rotational modulation of star - spots that are distributed asymmetrically over the stellar surface .
when these spots are at moderately high - latitude , which is typical , the light curve shapes can be approximately sinusoidal .
dozens of the ngc 2264 _ corot _ light curves fall into this category .
given that large a library , it seemed reasonable to us that one of those light curves might have a shape that closely resembled the smoothly varying portion of the mon-21 light curve .
we believe that is indeed the case .
figure [ fig : mon103_observed ] shows the 2011 _ corot _ light curve of mon-103 , a yso with spectral type very similar to that for mon-21 ( k6 vs. k5 for mon-21 ) . the period for mon-103 is just very slightly greater than for mon-21 3.3 days vs. 3.15 days .
the red curve in figure [ fig : mon103_observed ] is the template waveform for the mon-21 model , simply shifted in zeropoint to match phase with mon-103 and multiplied in amplitude to match also ; the waveform shapes are indeed very similar .
we can use the mon-103 light curve as a template to remove the spotted - star component from the mon-21 light curve . in order to provide as good a fit as possible
, we make the following slight modifications to the observed light curve : ( a ) we do a zero point shift in time to align the two beginning points in phase ; ( b ) we shift the mon-103 light curve counts by a multiplicative factor and a zero point offset so that the mean magnitude and average amplitude match that of mon-21 ; and ( c ) we multiply the x - axis timescale by 0.935 in order to correct for the slight period difference between the two stars .
figure [ fig : mon21.div.103]a overlays the two light curves , and figure [ fig : mon21.div.103]b shows the mon-21 flux dip light curves that results from subtracting the modified mon-103 light curve from the observed data .
the main dips appear essentially the same as in our original procedure ( figure [ fig : mon21_modela]c ) ; the dip widths and depths ( table [ tab : quant_information ] ) differ by less than 10% between the two renditions . in 2011 ,
the _ corot _ light curve for mon-1131 shows flux dips that recur periodically at p @xmath2 5.1 day intervals .
the light curve shows little other structure except the flux dips .
the 2008 light curve shape is much more complex ( see figure [ fig : mon1131_2008 ] ) and probably owes its shape to several physical mechanisms whose effects are superposed .
yet , the mean magnitude is nearly the same during the two epochs , and the full range of the variations is also nearly the same ( about 0.3 mag ) .
the 2008 light curve simply has very different character . in terms of the quantitative classification scheme of cody et al .
( 2014 ) , the 2008 light curve would be classified as stochastic ( with @xmath56 = 0.12 and @xmath57 = 0.71 ) , meaning the variations are fairly symmetric about the mean and essentially aperiodic .
there is still some power in the auto - correlation function at @xmath42 = 5.1 days , but other variability dominates .
we obtained new spectra for several of the stars discussed in this paper , primarily in order to provide spectral types or @xmath23 for stars for which those data were lacking in the published literature .
in particular , we obtained three keck hires spectra ( all on the same night ) for mon-21 , a single keck hires spectrum for mon-1165 , soar goodman spectrograph medium resolution spectra for mon-1131 and mon-6975 , and an int low - resolution spectrum of mon-1165 .. snippets from these spectra are shown in figure [ fig : new_spectra ] . for mon-21 and mon-1165 , we used the spectroscopy made easy ( sme ; valenti & piskunov 1996 ) and binmag3 ( oleg kochukhov ; http://www.astro.uu.se/oleg ) packages to derive @xmath23 estimates , as described more completely in the companion paper by mcginnis et al .
( 2015 ) . for the lower resolution , int and soar spectra of mon-1131 , mon-1165 and mon-6975
, visual inspection showed that all three stars were early to mid m dwarfs .
we therefore used spectral indices based on the depths of the observed tio bands to infer spectral types ; more specifically , we used the relations in stauffer ( 1982 ) and stauffer & hartmann ( 1986 ) for field m dwarfs and relations in herczeg & hillenbrand ( 2014 ) calibrated for ysos .
the derived spectral types are m1.5 for mon-1131 , m3 for mon-1165 , and m2.5 for mon-6975 . for mon-1131 , the field star relation yields m2 and the yso relation yields m1
we take the average ; for mon-6975 , both relations yield m2.5 .
we consider these spectral types preliminary because the relations are based on flux calibrated spectra , and we did not have the data needed to flux calibrate the soar or int spectra .
[ [ coordinates - and - corot - ids - for - stars - with - single - or - just - a - few - short - duration - flux - dips ] ] coordinates and _ corot _ i d s for stars with single or just a few short - duration flux dips ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ as discussed in 5 , a small number of the ysos in ngc 2264 for which we have _ corot _ light curves have either just one or a couple short - duration , shallow flux dips in their light curves .
they therefore do not fall into any of our previously defined variable extinction classes .
these stars are listed here in table [ tab : singledippers ] .
all of them are class ii systems based on their irac photometry , though in some cases their ir excesses are relatively small .
lccccc csimon-000119 & 06412100 + 0933361 & 223985987 & 223985987 & k6 & 10.6 + csimon-000342 & 06405573 + 0946456 & & 616872592 & m4 & 21.1 + csimon-000577 & 06414382 + 0940500 & & 616895846 & k1 & 5.9 + csimon-000650 & 06410098 + 0932444 & 223980807 & 223980807 & k1 & 6.4 + csimon-001038 & 06402262 + 0949462 & & 602095739 & m0 & 2.7 + csimon-001114 & 06393339 + 0952017 & 223957142 & 223957142 & m1.5 & 19.7 + csimon-001559 & 06393276 + 0904137 & 223956963 & & & + csimon-001568 & 06410684 + 0902161 & 223982299 & 223982299 & & + csimon-006991 & 06392200 + 1006233 & 223953770 & 223953770 & & + alencar , s. et al . 2010 , aa 519 , a88 .
allen , l. et al .
2004 , apjs 154 , 363 .
baglin , a. , auvergne , m. et al .
2009 , iaus 253 , 71 .
bans , a. & knigl , a. 2012 , apj 758 , 100 .
barge , p. & sommeria , j. 1995 , aa 295 , l1 .
baruteau , j. et al .
2013 , apj 778 , 7 .
bjorkman , j. & wood , k. 2001 , apj 554 , 615 .
bouvier , j. & bertout , c. 1989 , aa 211 , 99 .
bouvier , j. et al . 1999 , aa 349 , 619 .
bouvier , j. et al .
2006 , in protostars and planets v , ed .
b. reipurth , d.jewitt & k. keil ( tucson : university of arizona press ) , 479 .
bouvier , j. et al .
2013 , aa 557 , 77 .
carpenter , j. et al .
2001 , aj 121 , 3160 .
cody , a. et al .
2014 , aj 147 , 82 .
cohen , m. & kuhi , l. 1979 , apjsupp 41 , 743 .
collier cameron , a. & campbell , c. 1993 , aa 274 , 309 .
dahm , s. & simon , t. 2005 , aj 129 , 829 .
dullemond , c. et al .
2001 , apj 760 , 957 .
espaillat , c. et al .
2011 , apj 728 , 49 .
fazio , g. , , 2004 , apjs , 154 , 10 findeisen , k. et al .
2013 , apj 768 , 93 .
flaherty , k. & muzerolle , j. 2010 , apj 719 , 1733 .
flaherty , k. et al .
2012 , apj 748 , 71 .
furesz , g. et al .
2006 , apj 648 , 1090 .
gillen , e. et al .
2014 , aa , 562 , a50 .
helled , r. et al .
2013 , astroph 1311.1142 .
herbst , w. 1986 , pasp 98 , 1088 .
herbst , w. et al .
1994 , aj 108 , 1906 .
herczeg , g. & hillenbrand , l. 2014 , apj 786 , 97 indebetouw , r. et al .
2005 , apj 619 , 931 .
isella , r. et al .
2013 , apjlett 783 , l13 .
jackson , r. & jeffries , r. 2013 , mnras 402 , 1380 .
joy , a. 1945 , apj 102 , 168 .
kamezaki , t. et al .
2014 , apjsupp 211 , 18 .
keane , j. et al .
2014 , apj 787 , 153 .
klagyivik , c. et al .
2013 , apj 773 , 54 .
knigl , a. 1991 , apj 370 , l39 .
kraft , r. 1970 , in spectroscopic astrophysics : an assessment of the contributions of otto struve , ed .
herbig ( berkeley : university of california press ) , 385 .
lamm , m. et al .
2004 , a&a 417 , 557 .
lucy , l. b. 1999 , a&a 344 , 282 .
lyra , w. et al .
2009 , a&a 497 , 869 .
lyra , w. & maclow , m. 2012 , apj 756 , 62 .
lyra , w. & lin , m. 2013 , apj 775 , 17 .
van der marel et al .
2013 , science 340 , 1199 .
mcclure , m. et al .
2013 , apj 775 , 114 .
mcginnis et al . 2015 , submitted to a&a .
meheut , h. et al .
2010 , a&a 516 , 31 .
meheut , h. et al .
2012 , a&a 542 , 9 .
meyer , m. , hillenbrand , l. & calvet , n. 1997 , aj 114 , 288 .
monnier , j. & millan - gabet , r. 2002 , 579 , 694 .
muto , t et al .
2012 , apj 748 , l22 .
muzerolle , j et al .
2003 , apj 597 , 149 .
pecaut , m. & mamajek , e. 2013 , apjsupp 208 , 9 .
perez , l. et al .
2014 , apj 783 , 13 .
plavchan , p. et al .
2008a , apj 684 , l37 .
plavchan , p. et al .
2008b , apjsupp 175 , 191 .
preibisch , t. et al .
1993 , a&a 279 , 577 .
quillen , a. et al . 2004 ,
apj 612 , l137 .
rafikov , r. r. 2002 , apj 569 , 997 .
rebull , l. , et al .
2002 , aj 123 , 1528 .
regaly , zs . et al .
2012 , mnras 419 , 1701 .
reipurth , b. et al .
1996 , aasupp 120 , 229 .
romanova , m. et al .
2004 , apj 610 , 920 .
romanova , m. et al .
2008 , apj 673 , l171 romanova , m. & kurosawa , r. 2014 , astroph 1401.4761 .
stauffer , j. 1982 , aj 87 , 899 .
stauffer , j. & hartmann , l. 1986 , apjsupp 61 , 531 .
stauffer , j. et al .
2014 , aj 147 , 83 .
sung , h. , et al .
1997 , aj 114 , 2644 .
sung , h. , stauffer , j. and bessell , m. 2009 , aj 138 , 1116 .
symington , n. et al .
2005 , mnras 356 , 1489 .
teixeira , p. et al .
2012 , aa 540 , 83 .
turner , n. et al .
2010 , apj 708 , 188 .
turner , n. et al .
2012 , apj 748 , 92 .
valenti , j. & piskunov , n. 1996 , a&as 118 , 595 .
venuti , l. et al .
2014 , astroph 1408.0432 .
werner , m. et al .
2004 , apjsupp 154 , 1 yorke , h. w. 1986 , in numerical solutions of the equation of radiation transfer , ed .
winkler and m.l .
norman ( dordrecht : reidel ) , 141 . | we identify nine young stellar objects ( ysos ) in the ngc 2264 star - forming region with optical _ corot _ light curves exhibiting short - duration , shallow , periodic flux dips .
all of these stars have infrared ( ir ) excesses that are consistent with their having inner disk walls near the keplerian co - rotation radius .
the repeating photometric dips have fwhm generally less than one day , depths almost always less than 15% , and periods ( 3 @xmath0 11 days ) consistent with dust near the keplerian co - rotation period .
the flux dips vary considerably in their depth from epoch to epoch , but usually persist for several weeks and , in two cases , were present in data collected on successive years . for several of these stars
, we also measure the photospheric rotation period and find that the rotation and dip periods are the same , as predicted by standard disk - locking " models .
we attribute these flux dips to clumps of material in or near the inner disk wall , passing through our line of sight to the stellar photosphere . in some cases , these dips are also present in simultaneous _ spitzer _
irac light curves at 3.6 and 4.5 microns .
we characterize the properties of these dips , and compare the stars with light curves exhibiting this behavior to other classes of yso in ngc 2264 .
a number of physical mechanisms could locally increase the dust scale height near the inner disk wall , and we discuss several of those mechanisms ; the most plausible mechanisms are either a disk warp due to interaction with the stellar magnetic field or dust entrained in funnel - flow accretion columns arising near the inner disk wall . |
optimizing pinning in superconductors ( sc ) is a problem that is interesting both experimentally and theoretically since pinning is the main viable mechanism for superconductivity in the presence of external magnetic field .
many tools and mechanisms for pinning has already been studied , in particular the use of crystal defects such as holes , non - magnetic impurities and both linear and screw dislocations .
pinning using structural defects suffers from many drawbacks , the most important is that the pins are randomly distributed which results in a low critical current . in recent years
, it was claimed that pinning could be optimized if we employ ferromagnetic ( fm ) nano textures to pin superconducting vortices ( sv ) .
@xcite-@xcite the main obstacles of using ferromagnetic textures to pin superconducting vortices are the proximity effects which destroy superconductivity .
lyuksyutov and pokrovsky noticed that proximity effects could be suppressed if a thin layer of insulator oxide is sandwiched between the fm and the sc.@xcite due to this separation between the fm and sc , the interaction between them is mediated via their magnetic fields .
if the magnetization of the fm structure exceeds a threshold value @xmath1 , the interaction between the fm and sc makes the spontaneous creation of superconducting vortices energy favorable .
the interaction between the fm and sc increases as the temperature reaches the superconducting transition temperature @xmath2 from below .
et.al._@xcite considered a system consisting of a thin ferromagnetic dot embedded in a superconducting thin film .
both the superconductor and the ferromagnet are assumed to lie in the @xmath3-plane and the dot is magnetized along @xmath4-axis . by numerically solving the nonlinear ginzburg - landau equation , they were able to show that a vortex appears in the superconductor when the magnetization of the dot exceeds a critical value .
they also showed that increasing the dot s magnetization leads to a giant vortex state with multiple flux quanta . in ref .
, erdin _ et.al .
_ used london s theory of superconductors to solve the general problem of the interaction between vortices in superconducting thin film with a generic two - dimensional ferromagnetic structure .
they applied their results to the cases when the fm structure is a circular dot whose magnetization is either parallel or perpendicular to the plane of the superconductor .
they calculated the threshold value for the dot s magnetization at which vortices are spontaneously created in the superconductor .
they showed that by increasing the magnetization of the dot a series of phase transitions between phases with different number of vortices take place . , length @xmath5 and magnetization @xmath6.,width=288 ] all these studies focused on cases in which the ferromagnet is either a point - like dipole or an infinitely thin two - dimensional texture whose plane is parallel to the plane of the superconductor .
the problem of interaction between vortices in superconducting thin film with a ferromagnetic columnar defect ( fcd ) has not been studied yet .
this case is both theoretically and experimentally interesting for the following reason .
the magnetic field of the vortex in a superconducting thin film is not confined to the plane of the film but it also exist outside of it .
if the ferromagnet extends in space outside the film and its close proximity then the vortex will be bound more strongly to the ferromagnet due to the interaction of its magnetic field with the magnetization of the ferromagnet .
this enhances vortex pinning and consequently the critical current of the superconductor .
it is also important to note that ferromagnetic columnar defects makes the superconductor has a multiply connected topology which is another source of pinning .
therefore , it would be interesting both theoretically and experimentally to study the statical and dynamical properties of a superconducting thin film pierced by ferromagnetic columnar defects . in this article
, i propose to study the properties of spontaneous vortex phase and pinning in a superconducting thin film pierced by ferromagnetic columnar defects .
this article is organized such as in the first section , the magnetic potential and field distribution produced by a single fcd penetrating a thin superconducting film are calculated . in sections two ,
i calculate the total energy of a system of a superconducting vortex coupled to the magnetic defect .
i generalize these results to the case of a superconducting thin film pierced by a square array of magnetic columnar defects in section four then i summarize the results of this work in section five .
i consider a superconducting thin film in the @xmath3-plane pierced by a finite ferromagnetic nano rod whose radius is @xmath0 and length is @xmath7 as shown in fig .
i also assume that the fcd is uniformly magnetized along its symmetry axis then its magnetization distribution is written as @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the unit vector along the @xmath4-axis .
the magnetic field produced by the fcd penetrates the superconductor and changes the distribution of the screening current . in the london approximation
the fcd - sc system is described by london - maxwell equation @xmath10 the total current @xmath11 is the sum of the supercurrent @xmath12 and the magnetization current @xmath13 .
the supercurrent can be written in terms of the gradient of the superconducting order parameter @xmath14 and the total magnetic vector potential @xmath15 for the fcd - sc system @xmath16 . here
@xmath17 is the superconducting electron density , @xmath18 is planck s constant while @xmath19 and @xmath20 are the electron s mass and charge respectively .
the superposition principle allows us to solve ( [ lm ] ) for @xmath21 and @xmath22 independently .
if the coulomb gauge @xmath23 is imposed then @xmath21 satisfies the following equation @xmath24 where @xmath25 $ ] with @xmath26 $ ] is london s penetration depth . here
@xmath19 and @xmath20 are the electron s mass and its charge while @xmath17 is the superconducting electrons density and @xmath27 is the thickness of the sc film .
the general solution of ( [ glm ] ) is of the form @xmath28 where @xmath29 and @xmath30 are the components of the wave vector along the @xmath4-axis and in the @xmath3-plane . here
@xmath31 is the vector potential in momentum space and is given by @xmath32\hat{\varphi}_q \label{frvp}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath33 is the @xmath34-th rank bessel s function .
the magnetic field produced by the magnetic nano - rod in the presence of the sc film can be calculated using @xmath35 .
the components of the rod s magnetic field are @xmath36dq \\ b_\rho&=&\frac{8\pi m r}{\lambda}\int_0^\infty j_1(qr )
j_1(q\rho ) \left[\frac{\pi}{2q^2}w(q , z , l)-\frac{\sinh(\frac{ql}{2 } ) e^{-q(|z|+\frac{l}{2})}}{1 + 2q}\right]dq\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath37 is @xmath38\nonumber\\ & + & sign(l+2z)\left[1-\cosh(\frac{q(l+2z)}{2 } ) + \sinh(\frac{q|l+2z|}{2})\right ] \label{integ}\end{aligned}\ ] ] however , we are interested in the value of the field at the plane of the superconductor . the @xmath4 component of the magnetic field of the fcd evaluated at the sc plane is @xmath39 similarly the solution for @xmath22 is found .
a general argument made in @xcite shows that the term proportional to @xmath40 ascribes for vortices .
so , in the presence of a vortex with vorticity @xmath41 and center at @xmath42 , the solution for @xmath22 in the coulomb gauge is @xmath43 where @xmath44 is the unit vector along @xmath45 .
the @xmath4-component of the vortex magnetic field at the sc film surface @xcite-@xcite is @xmath46\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath47 and @xmath48 are the zero order struve and neumann functions respectively @xcite .
the interaction between a superconducting vortex and a non magnetic columnar defect was first considered by mkrtchyan and schmidt @xcite and later in the work of buzdin _ et.al .
_ @xcite-@xcite . in these studies
, it was shown that the pinning potential @xmath49 created by a non magnetic columnar defect of radius @xmath50 is @xmath51 , \hspace{0.1 in } r<\rho<\lambda \end{array}\right.\ ] ] where @xmath52 is the sc coherence length and @xmath53 is the energy scale of the vortex self interaction .
if the columnar defect is ferromagnetic , then an extra contribution to the pinning would appear due to the interaction between the superconductor and ferromagnet . in the presence of vortices in the superconductor ,
the total energy of the system is made up of five different contributions and can be written as @xmath54 where @xmath55 is the energy of @xmath56 non - interacting vortices , @xmath57 is the vortex - vortex interaction , @xmath58 is the interaction energy between the fm and the sc , and @xmath59 is the fm dot self interaction . in @xcite , it was shown that the total energy of the system can be written as : @xmath60d^3x \label{eqn11}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath61 is the speed of light .
the vectorial quantities @xmath62 , and @xmath63 are the total vector potential and magnetic field due to the vortices and the ferromagnetic columnar defect . in ref . , buzdin considered the problem of vortex craetion in a superconductor penetrated by non - magnetic columnar defects and placed in external magnetic field .
he found that at high magnetic field giant vortices are more energy favorable when the columnar defect is rather thick .
the case of rather thick defects @xmath64 is experimentally more interesting and easier to realize .
_ @xcite showed the possibility of formation of a giant vortex with multiple flux quanta around the magnetic dot instead of singly quantized vortices .
therefore , i will assume that @xmath65 which make the result of ref .
regarding the formation of giant vortices applicable to our problem .
the phase gradient of the sc order parameter in the presence of a giant superconducting vortex with vorticity @xmath41 is @xmath66 , where @xmath67 is the location of the vortex .
the total energy for a system consisting of a superconducting vortex and a ferromagnetic columnar defect is @xmath68 where @xmath69 and @xmath59 is the self interaction of the fcd is ignored since it does not affect the superconducting state .
it is clear that if the magnetization of the columnar defect is large enough so that the interaction term becomes larger than other terms in ( [ e1v ] ) then the vortex can appear spontaneously in the superconductor .
_ @xcite showed that spontaneous creation of vortices takes place most easily in the proximity of the superconducting transition temperature @xmath2 . the interaction term in eq.([e1v ] )
depends on @xmath7 . in the limit of @xmath70 , the interaction term in eq.([e1v ] )
reduces to the result obtained for infinitely thin magnetic dot.@xcite in the remainder of this work , i will assume @xmath71 .
numerical minimization of the total energy @xmath72 sets @xmath73 , hence the vortex center must be on the axis of the fcd .
nm , @xmath74 nm and the radius @xmath75 nm .. the solid line is for the case when the cd is non - magnetic while the dashed one is for ferromagnetic cd.,width=336 ] the energy of a system of a singly quantized vortex @xmath76 coupled to a columnar defect is shown in fig .
the solid line represents the energy of the system when the columnar defect is non - magnetic , while the dashed line shows the energy of the system when the defect is ferromagnetic .
note that the pinning force , @xmath77 , is not zero for @xmath78 in contrast with the case of non - magnetic columnar defect . for each value of @xmath6
there is a corresponding critical value of @xmath41 which i call it here @xmath79 .
the minimization of @xmath80 with respect to @xmath41 yields @xmath81 where @xmath82 with @xmath83 . the critical value of @xmath41 is the closest integer to the value of @xmath41 given by eq.([nueq ] ) .
the vorticity of the spontaneously created giant vortex is plotted in fig .
[ fig4 ] as a function of @xmath84 and @xmath85 .
note that at when @xmath86 then very large values of @xmath84 are required for the spontaneous creation of a vortex . as a function of @xmath84 and @xmath85.,width=336 ]
note that for any fixed value of @xmath87 , eq.([nueq ] ) gives us the critical value of the magnetization @xmath88 at which a vortex with vorticity @xmath87 appear as a function of the radius @xmath0 .
the dependance of @xmath89 on @xmath0 for @xmath90 is depicted in fig .
the region under the curve in fig .
[ fig3 ] represents a vortexless phase while the one above the curve represents phases with vortices . .
all points above the curve represent a phase with vortices while the region under the curve is vortexless.,width=336 ] note that when the radius of the columnar defect is very close to @xmath91 giant vortices with large flux quanta are expected even at not so large values of @xmath84 .
this is because when @xmath92 , the vortex self energy goes to zero while its energy of interaction with the columnar defect is not zero and negative ; therefore , giant vortices with large value of @xmath41 are energy favorable .
the curve in fig . [ fig3 ] is the curve for the first phase transition ( no vortex phase @xmath93 one vortex phase ) , it should be emphasized here that there is a discrete set of curves above this curve that refer to a series of phase transitions between phases with different number of flux quanta .
the transition from a vortexless phase to a phase with a single vortex for a system in which @xmath94 nm and @xmath95 nm occurs at the approximate value of @xmath96 g.
now , let us consider a superconducting thin film pierced by a square array of @xmath97 ferromagnetic columnar defects . let each fcd be infinitely long ( @xmath98 ) with a radius @xmath99 and magnetization @xmath100 .
the magnetization of the array can be written in fourier space as follows @xmath101 where @xmath102 is the location of the @xmath103-th fm defect and the sum runs over all the lattice sites .
the location of the fcd is defined by two integers @xmath104 and @xmath105 as @xmath106 where @xmath107 is the lattice spacing of the fcd array . solving eq.([glm ] ) for the magnetization ( [ magarray ] ) yields @xmath108 let * q * be a vector of the reciprocal lattice defined as @xmath109 where @xmath34 and @xmath110 are two integers with @xmath111 and @xmath112 .
the @xmath4 component of the array s magnetic field at @xmath113 is @xmath114 where @xmath115 is the density of columnar defects in the array .
the summation over the defect positions is calculated with the help of the identity @xmath116 the magnetic flux which penetrate the superconductor must remain constant ; therefore , the number of vortices and the number of antivortices that are spontaneously created in the superconductor must be equal . in the absence of external magnetic field ,
the equilibrium configuration is the one with vortices pinned at the axes of the fcds and antivortices are located at the centers of the unit cells of the fcd lattice .
the square lattice of antivortices is identical to that of the vortices with a shift by @xmath117 .
note that in the case of a single columnar defect , the antivortex is repelled ( pushed far away ) from the fcd ; therefore , it was not taken into account in the calculations .
however , in the case when the sc is penetrated by an array of fcd in the absence of external magnetic field , one must take antivortices into account on equal footing with vortices . in equilibrium , the force acting on any flux line ( fl ) in the superconductor
pinning forces appear as soon as this equilibrium is disturbed e.g. by passing an electric current to the superconducting film .
the remaining part of this section will focus on the problem of calculating these forces .
the vortex and antivortex lattices are both regular and periodic .
therefore , if a small current is applied to the superconductor then all vortices will move together in one direction and all antivortices will move together in the opposite direction .
let us assume that the vortex lattice is displaced with respect to its equilibrium position by a small amount @xmath118 then the lattice of antivortices will be displaced by an amount @xmath119 .
considering the case when @xmath6 is just above @xmath120 .
the flux line self energy and the fl - fl interaction energy together can be written using eq.([eqn11 ] ) as @xmath121 \label{hva}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath122 is the area of the sc film .
the energy of interaction between the flux lines and the ferromagnetic array is @xmath123 \label{hma}\end{aligned}\ ] ] to simplify the calculations , i use @xmath124 where @xmath125 is the area of the array s unit cell .
therefore , i find the energy per flux line is now dependent on the displacement @xmath126 as follows @xmath127}{1 + 2\lambda q } dq \\ & & - m\phi_0 r\int_0^\infty \frac{j_1(qr)\left[j_0(q|\delta{\bf{\rho}}| ) -j_0(q|\frac{{\bf{a}}}{2 } -\delta{\bf{\rho}}|)\right]}{q(1 + 2\lambda q)}dq \nonumber \label{new2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the number of fcd is @xmath128 while the number of flux lines is @xmath129 .
the pinning force acting on any vortex or antivortex can now be calculated using @xmath130 where @xmath131 with @xmath132 is a constant equals to the energy of the system in equilibrium .
note that i did not include the term due to the mkrtchyan and schmidt in the result i obtained in eq.([new2 ] ) because it is rather straightforward to calculate its effect .
in conclusion , i studied the interaction between superconducting vortices in a thin film pierced by a ferromagnetic columnar defect .
i calculated the magnetic field of the fcd in the presence of the sc and the distribution of screening currents in the superconductor .
if the magnetization of the fcd exceeds a critical value , then the fcd interaction with the vortex will overcome the vortex self energy leading to the spontaneous creation of vortices in the superconductor .
i showed that vortex pinning is strongly enhanced due to the contribution from the interaction between the magnetic field of vortices and the magnetization of the fcd outside the plane of the sc and its close proximity .
this extra contribution to vortex pinning is a major difference between this study and other studies in the literature which focused on dipole - like or two - dimensional ferromagnetic structures .
these results were generalized to include the case when the sc film is pierced by an array of fcd .
a detailed analysis of the dynamical properties of this system will be reported elsewhere .
i would like to thank v. l. pokrovsky , w. m. saslow and d. g. naugle for useful discussions .
i acknowledge partial support by the nsf grant dmr 0321572 and doe grant de - fg03 - 96er45598 during my stay at texas a&m university .
i also would like to thank p. r. montague at baylor college of medicine for his support and encouragement .
van bael mj , bekaert j , temst k , van look l , moshchalkov vv , bruynseraede y , howells gd , grigorenko an , bending sj , borghs g phys .
lett . * 86 * , 155 ( 2001 )
; lange m , van bael mj , van look l , temst k , swerts j , guntherodt g , moshchalkov vv , bruynseraede y europhys .
lett . * 51 * , 110 ( 2001 ) ; bending sj , howells gd , grigorenko an , van bael mj , bekaert j , temst k , van look l , moshchalkov vv , bruynseraede y , borghs g , humphreys rg physica c*332 * , 20 ( 2000 ) ; | this is an analytical study of pinning and spontaneous vortex phase is a system consisting of a superconducting thin film pierced by a long ferromagnetic columnar defect of finite radius @xmath0 .
the magnetic fields , screening currents , energy and pinning forces for this system are calculated .
the interaction between the magnetic field of vortices and the magnetization outside the plane of the film and its close proximity enhances vortex pinning significantly .
spontaneous vortex phase appears when the magnetization of the columnar defect is increased above a critical value .
transitions between phases characterized by different number of flux quanta are also studied .
these results are generalized to the case when the superconductor is pierced by an array of columnar defects . |
the resent discoveries of heavy fermion compounds ( @xmath5=rh , co , and ir ) give a unique opportunity to elucidate the interplay between the magnetism and the superconductivity .
the ground state of these compounds can be tuned by pressure and chemical doping . @xcite and @xcite are superconductors with the transition temperature @xmath7 2.3 k and 0.4 k at ambient pressure , respectively . on the other hand , is an antiferromagnet with @xmath8 3.8 k at ambient pressure and shows superconductivity under pressure.@xcite in and , the thermodynamic and transport properties in the normal state exhibit a striking deviation from conventional fermi liquid behavior,@xcite which is commonly observed in the systems in the vicinity of the antiferromagnetic ( af ) quantum critical point ( qcp ) .
then it is widely believed that the superconductivity in and is closely related to the af fluctuations .
recently , it has been suggested that ceirin@xmath0 should be distinguished from cecoin@xmath0 and cerhin@xmath0 , although all three compounds share similar quasi - two dimensional ( 2d ) band structure.@xcite figure 1 depicts the schematic temperature
@xmath9 ( @xmath10-@xmath9 ) phase diagram of cerh@xmath11ir@xmath12in@xmath0 and temperature pressure ( @xmath10-@xmath13 ) phase diagram of ceirin@xmath0.@xcite in this system the rh substitution for ir increases the @xmath14 ratio , acting as a negative chemical pressure that increases af correlations . in cerh@xmath11ir@xmath12in@xmath0 ,
the ground state continuously evolves from af metal ( @xmath15 ) to superconductivity ( @xmath16 ) .
@xmath6 shows a maximum at @xmath17 and exhibits a cusp - like minimum at @xmath18 0.9 , forming a first dome ( sc1 ) .
the superconductivity nature in sc1 , which occurs in the proximity to af qcp , should be essentially the same as ceco(in@xmath11cd@xmath12)@xmath0 @xcite and cerhin@xmath0.@xcite the strong af fluctuations associated with the af qcp nearby are observed in sc1.@xcite in ceirin@xmath0 ( @xmath9 = 1 ) , @xmath6 increases with pressure and exhibits a maximum ( @xmath6 = 1 k ) at @xmath19 3 gpa , forming a second dome ( sc2 ) .
the af fluctuations in sc2 far from the af qcp are strongly suppressed , compared with those in sc1.@xcite moreover , it has been reported that the nature of the crossover behavior from non - fermi to fermi liquid in strong magnetic fields for ceirin@xmath0 is very different from that for cecoin@xmath0 and cerhin@xmath0.@xcite from the analogy to cecu@xmath20(si@xmath11ge@xmath21)@xmath20 with two distinct superconducting domes,@xcite a possibility that the ce - valence fluctuations play an important role for the normal and superconducting properties in has been pointed out.@xcite for instance , it has been suggested that while the superconductivity in sc1 is magnetically mediated , the superconductivity in sc2 may be mediated by the ce - valence fluctuations.@xcite thus the major outstanding question is whether the ce - valence fluctuations play an important role for the physical properties of in sc2 phase .
our previous studies indicate that the transport coefficients , including resistivity , hall effect , and magnetoresistance , can be powerful tools to probe the af spin fluctuations.@xcite in this paper , we report the systematic pressure study of the transport properties for and , which locates in sc1 and sc2 phase , respectively . we provide several pieces of evidence that all the anomalous transport properties observed in and originate from the af spin fluctuations irrespective of which superconducting phase the system belongs to .
-@xmath9 phase diagram for cerh@xmath11ir@xmath21in@xmath22 and @xmath10-@xmath13 phase diagram for @xcite .,width=302 ]
at ambient pressure , where the resistivity shows a broad maximum .
open circles shown in the insets indicate the resistivity at @xmath23 where @xmath24 shows a minimum . for detail , see the text in
.4.,width=302 ] the high quality single crystals of and were grown by the self - flux method .
we performed all measurements on samples with a typical dimension of @[email protected] mm@xmath27 in the transverse geometry for @xmath28 @xmath29 and the current @xmath30 @xmath31 .
the hall effect and transverse magnetoresistance were measured simultaneously .
we obtained hall resistivity from the transverse resistance by subtracting the positive and negative magnetic field data .
hydrostatic pressure up to 2.41 gpa were generated in a piston - cylinder type high pressure cell with oil as a transmitting fluid ( daphne 7373 : petroleum ether = 1 : 1 ) .
the pressure inside the cell was determined by the superconducting transition temperature of pb .
figures [ rhoxxt](a ) and ( b ) show the temperature dependence of the resistivity @xmath32 in zero field at several pressures for and , respectively .
the overall feature of the temperature dependence for both compounds is typical in ce - based heavy fermion compounds .
on cooling from room temperature , @xmath32 first decreases and then increases due to dominant kondo scattering . at lower temperatures
, @xmath32 exhibits a metallic behavior after showing a broad maximum at around the temperature @xmath33 , shown by arrows .
@xmath33 corresponds to the fermi temperature of @xmath34 electrons and the system becomes coherent below @xmath33 .
@xmath33 increases with pressure .
the insets of figs .
[ rhoxxt](a ) and ( b ) show the low temperature data of @xmath32 for and , respectively .
the resistivities of and are markedly different from the @xmath35-behavior expected in fermi liquid metals . at ambient pressure , @xmath32 varies as @xmath36 with @xmath37 for and @xmath38 for .
@xmath39 increases with pressure for both systems and reaches @xmath40 at 2.4 gpa for and @xmath41 at 2.19 gpa for , indicating that the fermi liquid behavior is recovering by applying pressure .
we note that these @xmath39-value is close to that reported in ref . .
these temperature and pressure dependence of resistivities for and are very similar to those of and .@xcite for at ambient pressure.,width=302 ] figures [ rhoxyh ] depict the hall resistivity @xmath42 as a function of magnetic field at ambient pressure for .
the sign of @xmath42 is negative . at low temperatures
, @xmath42 deviates from the @xmath28-linear dependence .
similar behavior is observed in .
figures [ rht](a ) and ( b ) show the temperature dependence of the hall coefficient @xmath24 in zero field limit defined as @xmath43 at several pressures for and , respectively . for comparison
, @xmath24 of , which has no @xmath34-electron and has similar band structure to , is plotted in the same figure . for , @xmath44 shows a shallow minimum at around 20 k and becomes nearly @xmath10-independent at low temperatures .
the carrier number estimated from @xmath45m@xmath27/c for at low temperatures corresponds to nearly three electrons per unit cell , which is consistent with the number expected from the band structure , indicating @xmath46 where @xmath47 is the carrier number . for at several pressures ( 0 ( @xmath48 ) , 0.56 ( @xmath49 ) , 0.98 ( @xmath50 ) , 1.56 ( @xmath51 ) , and 2.41 gpa ( @xmath52 ) ) and for at ambient pressure ( @xmath53 ) .
@xmath24 is defined by the zero - field limit for derivative of @xmath42 .
inset : temperature dependence of @xmath24 for at 0 ( @xmath48 ) , 1 ( @xmath54 ) , and 5 t ( @xmath26 ) at ambient pressure .
( b)temperature dependence of @xmath24 for at several pressures ( 0 ( @xmath48 ) , 0.49 ( @xmath49 ) , 1.11 ( @xmath50 ) , 1.50 ( @xmath51 ) and 2.19 gpa ( @xmath52 ) ) and for at ambient pressure ( @xmath53 ) .
inset : temperature dependence of @xmath24 for at 0 ( @xmath48 ) , 1 ( @xmath54 ) , and 5 t ( @xmath26 ) at ambient pressure .
down and up arrows in main panels indicate @xmath33 at ambient pressure determined by the resistivity peak and @xmath23 at ambient pressure , where @xmath24 shows a minimum , respectively.,width=264 ] the hall effect in and is distinctly different from that in . the temperature dependence of @xmath24 for and is closely correlated with the resistivity . the down - arrow in figs .
[ rht ] ( a ) and ( b ) indicates @xmath33 at ambient pressure determined by the resistivity peak in figs . 2(a ) and ( b ) , respectively . in the high temperature regime above @xmath33 ,
@xmath24 for and shows weak @xmath10-dependence .
well above @xmath33 , @xmath44 for both compounds well coincides with @xmath24 of , indicating @xmath55 . below @xmath33 , @xmath24 for and
decreases rapidly with decreasing @xmath10 . at lower temperatures
, @xmath44 increases after showing minimum at @xmath23 indicated by up - arrows in figs .
[ rht](a ) and ( b ) . with increasing pressure
, @xmath56 increases and the enhancement of @xmath57 at low temperature regime is reduced for . as a function of @xmath58 for at 0 ( @xmath48 ) , 0.56 ( @xmath53 ) , 0.98 ( @xmath49 )
, 1.59 ( @xmath59 ) , and 2.41 gpa ( @xmath50).,width=264 ] the insets of figs .
[ rht ] ( a ) and ( b ) show the temperature dependence of @xmath24 at @xmath60=0 , 1 , and 5 t at ambient pressure for and , respectively .
@xmath24 is defined by a field derivative of @xmath42 , @xmath61 .
the magnitude of @xmath24 below @xmath33 is strongly suppressed by magnetic fields .
we here comment on the effect of the skew scattering .
usually , @xmath24 in heavy fermion compounds can be written by the sum of the ordinary hall part @xmath62 due to lorentz force and the anomalous hall part @xmath63 due to skew scattering,@xcite @xmath64 the magnitude of @xmath65 is often much larger than that of @xmath66 except for @xmath67 and @xmath68 .
in most ce - based heavy fermion systems , @xmath65 is positive in sign and shows a strong @xmath10-dependence , which is scaled by @xmath69 ( ref . ) or @xmath70.@xcite at around @xmath33 , @xmath71 shows a broad maximum and its amplitude becomes much larger than @xmath72 .
it it obvious that @xmath24 of and are very different from that expected from the skew scattering .
in fact , the sign of @xmath24 is negative in the whole temperature regime .
moreover , @xmath24 is close to @xmath73 at @xmath74 .
a slight increase of @xmath44 observed at @xmath75 in the low pressure regime appears to come from small but finite contribution of the skew scattering .
thus the skew scattering contribution is small in and and the normal part of hall effect is dominant .
we also note that skew scattering is negligibly small in and .@xcite the hall effect in and below @xmath33 , particularly the enhancement of @xmath76 from @xmath77 , is distinctly different from that expected in the conventional metals .
such an enhancement has also been reported in and , and high-@xmath6 cuprates .
there , it has been shown that the hall problem can be simplified when analyzed in terms of hall angle @xmath78 ; @xmath2 well obeys a @xmath3-dependence , @xmath79 where @xmath80 and @xmath81 are constants.@xcite we here examine @xmath2 for .
figure [ cot ] depicts @xmath2 as a function of @xmath3 for . in the all pressure regime ,
@xmath2 well obeys a @xmath3-dependence , except for the low temperature regime , exhibiting a striking similarity with and , and high-@xmath6 cuprates . at ( a )
0 gpa and ( b ) 2.41 gpa.,width=302 ] figures [ rhoxxh ] ( a ) and ( b ) show the magnetoresistance @xmath82 of at ambient pressure and at @xmath13 = 2.41 gpa , respectively .
the magnetoresistance varies as @xmath83 at very low field ( @xmath84 t ) . at ambient pressure ,
the magnetoresistance decreases with @xmath28 at high fields below 5 k. this phenomena has also been observed in at ambient pressure@xcite and is attributed to the spin - flop scattering .
vs @xmath85 for at ( a)0gpa , and ( b)2.41gpa .
modified kohler s plot .
@xmath86 as a function of @xmath87 for at ( c)0gpa and ( d)2.41gpa.,width=302 ] we here discuss the magnetoresistance in the conventional and unconventional metals . in conventional metals ,
the magnetoresistance due to orbital motion of carriers obeys the kohler s rule , @xmath88 where @xmath89 is a function which depends on the details of electronic structure.@xcite it has been shown that the magnetoresistance in larhin@xmath0 with similar electronic structure but with weak electronic correlation well obeys the kohler s rule.@xcite we first test the validity of the kohler s rule in the magnetoresistance of . figures [ mr](a ) and ( b ) depict @xmath86 of as a function of @xmath85 at 0 and 2.41 gpa , respectively .
the data never collapse into the same curve , indicating a violation of the kohler s rule .
a striking violation of the kohler s rule has been reported in and , and high-@xmath6 cuprates .
it has been shown instead that in these systems the magnetoresistance is well scaled by @xmath87 ( modified kohler s rule ) , where @xmath90 is the hall angle;@xcite @xmath91 we then examine the validity of the modified kohler s rule for . in figs .
[ mr](c ) and ( d ) , the same data of magnetoresistance are plotted as a function of @xmath87 . for both cases , the data collapse into the same curve for three orders of magnitude , indicating that the magnetoresistance well obeys modified kohler s rule .
the deviation from the modified kohler s rule is observed at low temperature and high field region , possibly due to the spin - flop scattering .
summarizing the salient features in the transport properties of below @xmath33 , which corresponds to the fermi temperature of @xmath34 electrons , 1 .
the dc - resistivity shows non - quadratic dependence , @xmath92 with @xmath39 close to unity at ambient pressure .
2 . @xmath76 increases with decreasing temperature and reaches a value much larger than @xmath77 well below @xmath33 . the hall angle varies as @xmath93 .
magnetoresistance displays @xmath10- and @xmath28- dependence that strongly violates the kohler s rule , @xmath94 .
magnetoresistance well obeys the modified kohler s rule that indicates a scaling by the the hall angle , @xmath95 .
it should be emphasized that all of these features bear striking resemblance to those observed in , , and high-@xmath6 cuprates .
therefore , it is natural to consider that the transport properties commonly observed in originate from the same mechanism .
our previous studies have shown that the anomalous features in the transport phenomena ( i)(iii ) can be accounted for in terms of the recent theory in which the anisotropic inelastic scattering due to af spin fluctuations are taken into account . in the presence of strong af fluctuations ,
the transport scattering rate strongly depends on the position of the fermi surface .
then the hot spots , at which the electron scattering rate is strongly enhanced by the af fluctuations , appear at the positions where the af brilouin zone intersects with the fermi surface .
the presence of the hot spots has been confirmed in high-@xmath6 cuprates and cein@xmath96.@xcite since the hot spot area does not contribute to the electron transport , it reduces the effective carrier density , which results in the enhancement of the @xmath76 from @xmath77 . in such a situation ,
various transport properties are determined by @xmath97 , where @xmath97 is the scattring time of the cold spots on the fermi surface , at which the electrons are less scattered .
moreover , it has been shown that the transport properties are modified by the _ backflow _ accompanied with the anisotropic inelastic scattering.@xcite according to refs . , the transport properties under magnetic fields are governed by the af correlation length @xmath98 in the presence of backflow effect .
zero - field diagonal conductivity @xmath99 , hall conductivity @xmath100 and magnetoconductivity @xmath101 are given as @xmath102 @xmath103 and @xmath104 here , we have dropped the higher terms with respect to @xmath105 since @xmath106 in the present experiment , which suggests that the relation @xmath107 is satisfied . in the presence of af fluctuation , @xmath98 depends on @xmath10 as @xmath108 , where @xmath109 is the weiss temperature .
moreover , according to af spin fluctuation theory , @xmath97 is nearly inversely proportional to @xmath10 ; @xmath110.@xcite when @xmath111 , we then obtain the temperature dependence of the resistivity , @xmath112 , hall coefficient , @xmath113 , and the hall angle as @xmath114 @xmath115 and @xmath116 by definition , the magnetoresistance is given by @xmath117 using the relation @xmath118 , given by eqs .
( [ eq : sigxy ] ) and ( [ eq : sigxx ] ) , the magnetoresistance is obtained as @xmath119 where @xmath120 is a constant and is @xmath121 10 - 100 for ce@xmath5in@xmath0 .
since @xmath122 at low fields , @xmath123 is well scaled by @xmath124 . thus eqs .
( [ eq : rho ] ) , ( [ eq : rh ] ) , ( [ eq : cot ] ) , and ( [ eq : mag ] ) reproduce the salient features of resistivity , hall coefficient , hall angle , and magnetoresistance observed in , respectively . the @xmath28-dependence of @xmath44 shown in the insets of fig
. [ rht](a ) reinforces the conclusion that the af fluctuations govern the electron transport phenomena in ( also in ) .
the enhancement of @xmath76 below @xmath33 is strongly suppressed by magnetic fields and approaches that of @xmath44 of lairin@xmath0 .
this is consistent with the recovery of the fermi liquid state in magnetic fields in .
similar phenomena have also been reported in and , where the fermi liquid state is recovered in magnetic fields by the suppression of af fluctuations.@xcite the upturn behavior of @xmath24 for and at low temperatures below @xmath23 shown in figs .
[ rht ] ( a ) and ( b ) is also observed in .@xcite this phenomenon can be explained by the reduction of _ backflow _ effect due to the effect of the impurity scattering . below @xmath23 ,
isotropic impurity scattering becomes dominant and the _ backflow _ effect due to anisotropic scattering is relatively reduced.@xcite to obtain more insight into the impurity effect , we compare the resistivity values at @xmath56 .
the small open circles in the insets of figs .
[ rhoxxt ] ( a ) and ( b ) indicate the resistivity at @xmath23 where @xmath24 shows a minimum .
the values of the resistivity at @xmath56 are nearly pressure independent and close to @xmath125 cm and @xmath126 cm in and , respectively .
we note that these values are close to the values of @xmath32 at @xmath23 for .
we here discuss the difference between and cecu@xmath20(si@xmath11ge@xmath21)@xmath20 .
for cecu@xmath20(si@xmath11ge@xmath21)@xmath20 in the second superconducting dome , anomalous behavior in transport and thermodynamic properties are observed near the pressure @xmath127 , where @xmath128 shows a maximum .
for instance , @xmath39 in eq .
( [ eq : rhoxx ] ) approaches unity and residual resistivity @xmath129 exhibits a maximum near @xmath127.@xcite for , on the other hand , @xmath39 approaches the fermi liquid value at @xmath19 3 gpa , where @xmath128 shows a maximum .
moreover , the residual resistivity decreases with pressure as shown in the insets of fig .
[ rhoxxt ] , which could be caused by the backflow or enhancement of impurity scattering near af qcp.@xcite these results indicate that there seems to be crucial differences in the transport phenomena between and cecu@xmath20(si@xmath11ge@xmath21)@xmath20 .
the presence of the af fluctuations in has been reported by the measurements of the nuclear magnetic resonance ( nmr ) relaxation rate @xmath130 . according to nmr results ,
af fluctuations are strongly suppressed with pressure and there is no indication of the af fluctuations at @xmath131 1 gpa.@xcite the present results indicate that the transport measurements are more sensitive to the af fluctuations than nmr experiments .
we finally comment on the superconducting gap structure in .
recent measurements of the anisotropy of the inter- and in - plane thermal conductivity for suggest a hybrid gap structure,@xcite whose symmetry is different from @xmath132 for ( refs . ) and ( most probably ) for
. however , very recent thermal conductivity measurements under rotated magnetic fields suggest that the superconducting gap structure for has @xmath133 symmetry,@xcite which implies that the af spin fluctuations are important for the occurence of the superconductivity for , which is consistent with the present work .
we have investigated the detailed electron transport properties by applying pressure in the normal state of and , which locates in the first and second superconducting dome , respectively .
we observed striking non - fermi liquid behaviors below @xmath33 , including non - quadratic @xmath1dependence of the resistivity , large enhancement of the hall coefficient at low temperatures @xmath134 , and the violation of the kohler s rule in the magnetroresistance @xmath135 .
moreover , we showed that the cotangent of hall angle @xmath2 varies as @xmath3 , and the magnetoresistance is quite well scaled by the hall angle as @xmath4 .
these non - fermi liquid properties , particularly the hall effect , are suppressed by pressure and magnetic fields .
the observed transport anomalies are common features of , , , and high-@xmath6 cuprates .
these results lead us to conclude that the non - fermi liquid behavior observed in the transport properties in originates not from the ce - valence fluctuations but from the low - lying excitation due to the af fluctuations that still remain in the second dome away from the first dome in the proximity to the af qcp .
we thank h. ikeda , k. miyake and s. watanabe for stimulating discussions .
this work was partly supported by a grant - in - aid for scientific reserch from the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology . c. petrovic , p.g .
pagliuso , m.f .
hundley , r. movshovic , j.l .
sarrao , j.d .
thompson , z. fisk and p. monthoux , j. phys . condens .
matter * 13 * l337 ( 2001 ) . c. petrovic , r. movshovich , m. jaime , p.g .
pagliuso , m.f .
hundley , j.l .
sarrao , z. fisk and j.d .
thompson , europhys .
* 53 * 354 ( 2001 )
. h. hegger , c. petrovic , e.g. moshopoulou , m.f .
hundley , j.l .
sarrao , z. fisk and j.d .
thompson , phys .
lett . * 84 * 4986 ( 2000 ) .
t. tayama , a. harita , t. sakakibara , y. haga , h. shishido , r. settai and y. onuki , phys .
b * 65 * , 180504(r ) ( 2002 ) .
v. a. sidorov , m. nicklas , p.g .
pagliuso , j.l .
sarrao , y. bang , a.v .
balatsky and j.d .
thompson , phys .
lett . * 89 * , 157004 ( 2002 ) .
a. bianchi , r. movshovich , i. vekhter , p.g .
pagliuso and j.l .
sarrao , phys .
. lett . * 91 * 257001 ( 2003 ) .
y. haga , y. inada , h. harima , k. oikawa , m. murakawa , h. nakawaki , y. tokiwa , d. aoki , h. shishido , s. ikeda , n. watanabe , and y. onuki , j. phys .
. jpn . * 63 * , 060503 ( 2001 ) .
r. settai , t. takeuchi , and y. onuki , j. phys .
* 76 * , 051003 ( 2007 ) .
m. nicklas , v.a .
sidorov , h.a .
borges , p.g .
pagliuso , j.l .
sarrao , and j.d .
thompson , phys .
b * 70 * 020505(r ) ( 2004 ) .
s. kawasaki , m. yashima , y. mugino , h. mukuda , y. kitaoka , h. shishido , and y. onuki : phys .
* 96 * 147001 ( 2006 ) .
the increase of ir substitution by 0.1 corresponds to @xmath121 0.4 gpa .
2(b ) and ( c ) in y. mugino , s. kawasaki , m. yashima , h. mukuda , y. kitaoka , h. shishido , and y. onuki , j. mag . mag . mat . * 310 * , 584 ( 2007 ) .
l. d. pham , tuson park , s. maquilon , j. d. thompson , and z. fisk , phys .
lett . * 97 * , 056404 ( 2006 ) .
zheng , k. tanabe , t. mito , s. kawasaki , y. kitaoka , d. aoki , y. haga , and y. onuki , phys .
. lett . * 86 * , 4664 ( 2001 ) s. kawasaki , g .- q .
zheng , h. kan , y. kitaoka , h.shishido , and y. onuki : phys .
lett . * 94 * 037007 ( 2005 ) . c. capan , a. bianchi , f. ronning , a. lacerda , j. d. thompson , m. f. hundley , p. g. pagliuso , j. l. sarrao , and r. movshovich , phys .
b * 70 * , 180502(r ) ( 2004 ) .
j. paglione , m. a. tanatar , d. g. hawthorn , e. boaknin , r. w. hill , f. ronning , m. sutherland , l. taillefer , c. petrovic , and p.c .
canfield , phys .
lett . * 91 * , 246405 ( 2003 ) .
t. park , f. ronning , h. q. yuan , m. b. salamon , r. movshovich , j. l. sarrao , and j. d. thompson , nature * 440 * , 65 ( 2006 ) h.q .
yuan , f.m .
grosche , m. deppe , c. geibel , g. sparn and f. steglich , science * 302 * , 2104 ( 2003 ) . s. watanabe , m. imada , and k , miyake , j. phys .
75 * , 043710 ( 2006 ) .
a. t. holmes , d. jaccard , and k. miyake , j. phys .
jpn . * 76 * , 051002 ( 2007 ) .
y. nakajima , k. izawa , y. matsuda , s. uji , t. terashima , h. shishido , r. settai , y. onuki , and h. kontani , j. phys .
jpn . * 73 * 5 ( 2004 )
. y. nakajima , k. izawa , y. matsuda , k. behnia , h. kontani , m. hedo , y. uwatoko , t. matsumoto , h. shishido , r. settai , and y. onuki : j. phys .
. jpn . * 75 * 023705 ( 2006 ) .
y. nakajima , h. shishido , h. nakai , t. shibauchi , k. behnia , k. izawa , m. hedo , y. uwatoko , t. matsumoto , r. settai , y. onuki , h. kontani , and y. matsuda , j. phys .
. jpn . * 76 * 024703 ( 2007 ) .
t. muramatsu , t.c .
kobayashi , k. shimizu , k. amaya , d. aoki , y. haga , and y. onuki , physica c 539 ( 2003 ) .
a. fert and p.m. levy , phys .
b * 36 * , 1907 ( 1987 ) . h. kontani and k. yamada , j. phys . soc .
jpn . * 63 * , 2627 ( 1994 ) .
chien , z.z .
wang , and n.p .
ong , phys .
lett . * 67 * , 2088 ( 1991 ) .
anderson , phys .
lett . * 67 * 2092 ( 1991 ) .
hussey , eur .
j. b * 31 * 495 ( 2003 ) .
pippard , _ magnetoresistance in metals _ ( cambridge university press , cambridge , 1989 ) .
harris , y.f .
yan , p. matl , n.p .
ong , p.w .
anderson , t. kimura and k. kitazawa , phys .
75 * , 1391 ( 1995 ) .
t. ebihara , n. harrison , m. jaime , s. uji and j.c .
lashley , phys .
lett . * 93 * , 246401 ( 2004 ) .
h. kontani , k. kanki and k. ueda , phys .
b * 59*,14723 ( 1999 ) k. kanki and h. kontani , j. phys . soc
. jpn . * 68 * , 1614 ( 1999 ) .
h. kontani , j. phys .
70 * , 1873 ( 2001 ) .
h. kontani , rep .
phys . * 71 * , 026501 ( 2008 ) .
h. shakeripour , m.a .
tanatar , s.y .
li , c. petrovic , and louis taillefer , phys .
* 99 * 187004 ( 2007 ) .
k. izawa , h. yamaguchi , y. matsuda , h. shishido , r. settai and y. onuki , phys .
lett . * 87 * 057002 ( 2001 ) .
y. matsuda , k. izawa , and i. vekhter , j. phys .
: condens .
matter * 18 * , r705 ( 2006 ) .
park , l. h. greene , j. l. sarrao and j.d .
thompson , physica c * 460 - 462 * , 206 ( 2007 ) .
y. kasahara , t. iwasawa , y. shimizu , h. shishido , t. shibauchi , i. vekhter , and y. matsuda , arxiv:0712.2604 . | in quasi - two dimensional ce(ir , rh)in@xmath0 system , it has been suggested that the phase diagram contains two distinct domes with different heavy fermion superconducting states .
we here report the systematic pressure dependence of the electron transport properties in the normal state of and , which locates in first and second superconducting dome , respectively .
we observed non - fermi liquid behavior at low temperatures in both compounds , including non - quadratic @xmath1dependence of the resistivity , large enhancement of the hall coefficient , and the violation of the kohler s rule in the magnetoresistance .
we show that the cotangent of hall angle @xmath2 varies as @xmath3 , and the magnetoresistance is quite well scaled by the hall angle as @xmath4 .
the observed transport anomalies are common features of ( @xmath5=co , rh , and ir ) and high-@xmath6 cuprates , suggesting that the anomalous transport properties observed in are mainly governed by the antiferromagnetic spin fluctuations , not by the ce - valence fluctuations which has been proposed to be the possible origin for the second superconducting dome . |
a few years ago , it was proposed a maxwell - chern - simons ( mcs ) gauge theory with an additional magnetic moment interaction@xcite for which bogomolnyi - type self - dual equations can be derived and vortex - like configurations appear whenever suitable relationships among the parameters of the model are obeyed @xcite .
an important issue that comes about is the claim of a relation between the property of self - duality and the @xmath0 supersymmetric extension of the model , accomplished by means of a relationship between the central charge of the extended model and the existence of topological quantum numbers @xcite .
although a fundamental reason for this connection has not been given so far in the literature , in certain cases it appears to be unavoidable to construct the @xmath0 supersymmetric extension of a given bosonic model in order to obtain the proper higgs potential and self - dual conditions compatible with the euler - lagrange equations . in this regard ,
we have succeeded in deriving an @xmath0 maxwell - chern - simons model with anomalous magnetic moment @xcite .
our strategy consisted in the formulation of an @xmath1 @xmath2 gauge model with a bf - term , free of constraints on the coupling constants dimensions .
similar constraints have also been needed in order to find an @xmath0 susy extension of the maxwell higgs model @xcite and of the chern - simons higgs model @xcite . ] . upon a convenient dimensional reduction of the component - field action from ( 1 + 3 ) to ( 1 + 2 ) dimensions
, we set out an @xmath0 @xmath3 maxwell - higgs model with a chern - simons term and magnetic moment interaction with the matter sector . adopting this viewpoint
, we raised the possibility of freely handling the parameters of the model and , remarkably , it enabled us to obtain topological self - dual solutions , even in the critical regime mentioned above .
this is to be compared with previous attempts where just a @xmath4 higgs potential has been considered so as to find self - dual solutions @xcite . in the present paper ,
we derive the proper self - dual equations and the higgs potential needed to allow topological as well as non - topological vortices in a non - minimally coupled mcs model ; this is our main result .
we perform a gauge - independent calculation which permits a suitable handling of the energy functional , leading to self - dual solutions to the equations of motion in both the symmetric and asymmetric phases of the model ( sections 2 and 3 ) . in section 4
, we discuss the properties of system for the critical value of the magnetic coupling .
the analysis of the self - dual solutions and a wide variety of soliton configurations are presented in section 5 . finally , in section 6
, we draw our conclusions .
in ref.@xcite we have put forward the @xmath0 susy lagrangian including the bosonic model we are going to analyse here . in component - field form
, it exhibits the proper non - minimally coupled mcs extension needed for our main purpose of finding a topological phase in the bosonic theory . for the sake of a better understanding
let us quote below the full expression of the @xmath0 susy lagrangian in terms of components @xmath5\right . \right\ } \label{full3d}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath6 the origin of all the fields appearing in equation eq.([full3d ] ) has been carefully justified in @xcite ; we refer the reader to this reference for the details . here , we are basically concerned with the bosonic sector of the theory , so we will focus our attention to a particular piece as we discuss in what follows .
let us consider the purely bosonic part of the susy lagrangian of eq.([full3d ] ) @xmath7 and @xmath8 corresponds to the fayet - iliopoulos term included in the susy lagrangian in order to allow spontaneous breaking of gauge invariance @xcite .
the equation of motion for the auxiliary @xmath9field gives @xmath10 where for convenience we have written @xmath11 substitution of the above in eq.([lag ] ) , gives the following higgs - type potential @xmath12 which depends on two fields : a real ( @xmath13 ) and a complex ( @xmath14 ) scalar . upon elimination of the auxiliary field @xmath9
, we will work with the following lagrangian @xmath15 which shall play a central role in the present discussion .
let us first define the currents @xmath16 where @xmath17 is a complex scalar parametrized in terms of @xmath13 and @xmath14 as given below @xmath18 as we shall discuss in the next section , the scalar @xmath17 will be identified as the physical field in terms of which the vortices will be specified .
now , the equation of motion for the gauge field can be written as @xmath19 where the time component determines the modified `` gauss law '' @xmath20 the gauge invariant modes are now short - range due to the mass term resulting from eq.([gauss ] ) .
hence , the first term has a vanishing space integral . on the other hand , the third term results in a line integral taken at infinity which also vanishes for finite energy configurations .
therefore , it can be seen from the remaining piece that the charge of the vortex solutions is related to non - zero magnetic fluxes by @xmath21 where @xmath22
the energy functional is given by @xmath23 which can be reorganized as @xmath24derivative , though not explicitly written in the above equation , has an effect which is implicit through @xmath25 .
the terms linear in @xmath26 are not present in the energy because they are metric - independent .
now , the search of the bogomolnyi bound for the energy yields the proper self - dual equations in a natural way @xmath27 using the following identities @xmath28 integrating by parts and dropping surface terms , one finally gets @xmath29 the last two terms vanish whenever integrated over the whole space ; so , using the gauss law and considering static configurations , the lower bound to the energy is clearly attained . to close this section ,
let us express the self - dual equations and the higgs potential in terms of the @xmath17field ; in so doing , we shall get expressions that are more useful for our future purposes .
now , eqs .
( [ dual ] ) and ( [ higgs1 ] ) read @xmath30 and @xmath31 which , for @xmath32 , gives the higgs potential of the minimal mcs model as given by the supersymmetric lagrangian found in ref.@xcite , as expected .
notice that the system has two degenerate minima , a symmetric phase for which @xmath33 @xmath34 and an asymmetric phase where @xmath35 @xmath36
let us now analyze a very special value of the magnetic coupling , namely , @xmath37 for which the equations of motion ( [ motion ] ) reduce down to first order , looking similar to the pure cs model s .
this choice yields fractional statistics describing anyons @xcite .
remarkably enough , this is the value that has to be fixed in order to obtain an @xmath0 mcs non - minimal theory , when working from the outset in @xmath3 @xcite .
it is important to notice that by performing the susy extension without dimensional reduction , only a symmetric , @xmath4 , higgs potential has been found , yielding , consequently , just non - topological solutions @xcite .
hence , for @xmath38 one has @xmath39 whose time - component reads @xmath40 we will now show that , in our model , we can make such a special choice , @xmath38 , without constraining the potential to a symmetric phase
. we shall also find topological vortices , in contrast to previous attempts ( we drop the subscript @xmath41 in what follows ) . using @xmath42 [ see eq.([dual2 ] ) ] and defining @xmath43 by means of @xmath44 @xmath45 to have positive definite energy configurations ) we get @xmath46 on the other hand , self - duality relations provide also @xmath47 thus , for @xmath48 defined as the maximum value of @xmath49 , eqs .
( [ b1 ] ) and ( [ b2 ] ) give @xmath50 notice that the @xmath13 field has decoupled from the other components , i.e. , it can be written in terms of just the higgs field @xmath17 .
another interesting feature of the bosonic model just found is that it still presents together both topological and non - topological phases @xmath51 note that for @xmath52 @xmath53 it behaves like the higgs potential typical of a pure cs model @xcite , as expected .
assuming maximal ( rotational ) symmetry , we take the following ansatz to find self - dual vortices @xmath54 \label{ansatz2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath55 and @xmath56 are real functions of @xmath57 , and @xmath58 an integer indicating the topological charge of the vortex . then , the magnetic field reads @xmath59 and the flux is @xmath60\ ] ] now , since in polar coordinates one has @xmath61 eq .
( [ dual2 ] ) can be written as @xmath62 where we have used ( [ bm ] ) and redefined @xmath63 the natural boundary conditions at infinity result from the requirement of finite energy , while a non - singular behavior determines the values at the origin . in
the _ topological _ phase , @xmath64 and @xmath65 for nontrivial vorticity @xmath58 .
then , for large @xmath57 the asymptotic form of the topological vortices is given by @xmath66 where @xmath67 is a constant whose value is determined by the form of the solutions at the origin . also at the origin , one must expect non - singular fields , implying @xmath68 and @xmath69 .
hence , the magnetic flux is quantized as follows @xmath60 = \frac{2\pi } en.\ ] ] now , we can combine eqs .
( [ dual_ar1],[dual_ar2 ] ) to produce a second order equation @xmath70 so that the behavior of the solutions for small values of @xmath57 , where @xmath71 , can be approximated by a liouville - type function @xmath72 ^{-1 } \label{liousol}\ ] ] where @xmath73 and @xmath74 are arbitrary constants . upon substitution of the above expression in eq.([dual_ar1 ] ) , we find @xmath75 so that using @xmath69 we obtain @xmath76 .
it implies that , near the origin , the form of the vortex is power - like @xmath77 where @xmath78 .
this last relation is obtained by expanding eq.([liousol ] ) around @xmath79 ; however , the precise numerical values of the @xmath80 constants are determined by the shape of the fields at infinity , rather than by their behavior at the origin .
indeed , we have numerically solved the self - dual equations of motion by means of an iterative procedure , giving a tentative value for @xmath80 which is corrected each time by imposing that both limits , @xmath81 and @xmath82 , hold together at infinity . for illustration , we quote some of the results in fig . 1 and fig
. 2 , for the cases @xmath83 notice the ring - type structure of the topological vortices ( see .
fig . 2 and fig .
this profile is analogous to the pure cs magnetic field shape @xcite .
the @xmath84 configurations are related to the @xmath85 ones by the transformation @xmath86 and @xmath87 .
several values of @xmath80 for @xmath88 and @xmath89 .
0.2 cm [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] 0.3 cm as we show in table 2 , the asymptotic values of the gauge field remain constrained , increasingly close to @xmath90 while the magnetic flux approaches the limit @xmath91 as @xmath58 grows . in fig .
9 , we show the ring structure of the non - topological vortices , with the maximum of the magnetic field out of the origin as it happens in the topological phase of the model .
notice that for @xmath92 the radius of the vortices , together with their distance to the origin , are minimal for a given charge @xmath58 , while the higgs field presents a cuspidal profile attaining its maximum value , @xmath93 .
in this work , we have obtained the self - dual soliton solutions of a maxwell chern - simons model with anomalous coupling , in both topological and non - topological sectors . to do this
, we have focused the bosonic part of a @xmath0 @xmath3 supersymmetric model obtained by dimensional reduction from a @xmath1 @xmath2 theory which enabled us finding a topological phase in @xmath3 . as long as we know
, it is the first time that topological self - dual vortices are found in a non - minimal mcs system .
we have also analyzed the non - topological phase in detail for several values of the parameters and magnetic fluxes .
it is worth noting that in contrast to previous reports @xcite the non - topological phase of our model is not given by a simple @xmath94 higgs potential but rather as a fourth order function @xmath95 .
our non - topological solutions are then different from those presented in @xcite although similar in shape . in order to compare our results with the literature at hand we have especially considered the critical anomalous coupling .
remarkably , we have shown that in this case it is possible to obtain a topological phase in the non - minimal maxwell chern - simons model in contrast with foregoing publications .
we have also found that the corresponding non - topological phase is not the one analyzed in previous attempts .
a natural extension of this work would be relaxing the anomalous coupling so as to consider non - critical values of @xmath96 . in principle , such a general situation could also present topological solitons . since analytical as well as computational analyses are
more involved in that case , it is still under investigation and the results shall be soon reported elsewhere .
the authors would like to thank c. nez for useful discussions . h.r.c .
is supported by faperj
rio de janeiro , m.s.c .
, a.l.n . and j.a.h .
brazil , and l.u.m . by capes
brazil .
christiansen , m.s .
cunha , j.a .
helayl - neto , l.r.u .
manssur , a.l.m.a .
nogueira , _
@xmath0 maxwell - chern - simons model with anomalous magnetic moment coupling via dimensional reduction _ ,
a14 * ( 1999 ) 147 . | we find self - dual vortex solutions in a maxwell - chern - simons model with anomalous magnetic moment . from a recently developed @xmath0 supersymmetric extension ,
we obtain the proper bogomolnyi equations together with a higgs potential allowing both topological and non - topological phases in the theory . to be published in the _ int .
j. of mod .
phys .
a ( 1999 ) . _ |
water is one of the most studied substances in all its phases , vapor , liquid and solid ice @xcite due to its ubiquity in nature and great relevance to mankind . despite the apparent simplicity of this molecule
, it shows complex behavior and some of its properties remain poorly understood .
water s hydrogen - bonding and proton - disorder effects lead to a complex phase diagram , which has been progressively extended over many years .
an extensive range of crystalline solid phases or ice polymorphs are known , most of which are stable and/or metastable under extreme conditions . on the other hand , different amorphous solid phases of water , or polyamorphs , have been discovered , including some ices which are identified as the most common water phases in the universe , being those found in interstellar space .
ice polyamorphs are usually distinguished by their characteristic densities .
a low - density amorphous ice ( lda ) was first synthesized in the 1930s by physical vapor deposition @xcite and , more recently , by fast cooling of liquid water @xcite .
the existence of a second amorphous solid phase of high density ( hda ) was established by mishima and co - workers @xcite in their experiments on the abrupt pressure - induced amorphization of hexagonal ice ( ih ; the crystalline solid phase stable under ambient conditions ) at low temperatures .
after this discovery , many experimental and theoretical research efforts have been addressed to the characterization of the structural transitions between different crystalline and amorphous solid phases of water @xcite .
diverse studies suggested the existence of two different mechanisms for the first - order pressure - induced transformation of ih into hda : at moderately low temperatures , the amorphization takes place by means of an endothermic melting of the crystalline morphology , whereas at very low temperatures the amorphous phase is the result of an exothermic structural collapse of the crystal @xcite . a reversible pressure - induced transformation of lda into hda was also first announced by mishima @xcite and subsequently investigated in numerous experimental @xcite and theoretical @xcite studies .
more recently , the existence of another amorphous solid phase with a very high density ( vhda ) has been uncovered @xcite and has become the subject of much research @xcite .
studies on amorphous solid water have played a central role in the great interest on the understanding of the phenomenon of polyamorphism the existence of different well - defined amorphous phases of the same substance that has arisen in recent years @xcite .
solid water polyamorphism has stimulated the search for its liquid counterpart , i.e. , the search for two different liquids separated by a first - order phase transition and an associated liquid liquid critical point @xcite . in this context
, a extremely simple physical mechanism has been proposed as a generic explanation for the phenomenon of solid and liquid polyamorphism : the existence of a double well or , more generically , of two characteristic length scales in the intermolecular potential of a polyamorphic substance @xcite .
the extraordinary complexity of water s behavior has favored the development of a myriad of models intended for the study of distinct specific properties .
investigations on water polyamorphism in particular have taken great advantage of computer simulations based on multiple water models with very different levels of detail .
for instance , there exist numerous studies on pressure - induced amorphization and other related amorphous transitions performed by molecular - dynamics simulations with atomistic water models @xcite
. however , an adequate understanding of the essential mechanisms of water polyamorphism like the validity of the two - length - scales hypothesis may require the exploration of more simple or even minimal modeling approaches .
simple water models have been used for many years to study , for instance , its numerous thermodynamic anomalies and its structural order , phase diagram or solvation properties @xcite .
some simple models for water polyamorphism have also been developed @xcite .
on the other hand , there exist many simple generic models to test the validity of the two - length - scales hypothesis , mostly based on isotropic central potentials @xcite .
models with anisotropic interactions are far more scarce due to the added complexity imposed by the directional bonds @xcite . in the case of water ,
however , the strong impact of the directionality of the hydrogen bond on its properties makes the use of isotropic potentials particularly challenging , imposing a fine tuning of the model parameters in order to reproduce the desired properties @xcite perhaps the simplest model of water that incorporates a directional bonding scheme was introduced by ben - naim in the early 1970s to obtain a qualitative representation of the open hydrogen - bonded network of molecules that makes up liquid water @xcite .
the model represents water molecules as two - dimensional lennard - jones disks with three equivalent hydrogen - bonding arms disposed at 120 degrees , as shown in figure [ fig : model ] .
the similarity of the shape of these simplified water molecules with a well known brand logotype has led to the adoption of the name `` mercedes - benz '' ( mb ) for the model . despite its simplicity , ben - naim s mb model and its successive extensions and improvements
have been shown to reproduce qualitatively different properties of water , including some of its anomalies and the thermodynamic behavior of the melting transition @xcite .
mercedes - benz models have been used to study solvation and hydrophobicity problems @xcite and the properties of water under confinement @xcite . due to its flexibility
, this class of models has been the subject of extensive analytical studies @xcite . on the other hand and to the best of our knowledge
, other more challenging characteristics of water , like the long disputed existence of two liquid phases or the properties of the solid amorphous phases and transitions , have not been explored to date in the minimal mb model .
regarding the main goal of our study , we consider that the mb model may be a useful anisotropic minimal modeling approach to study the essential mechanisms of water polyamorphism .
in addition , bond - bending forces play a key role in many low - dimensional systems , such as in the amorphous freezing of soft polymer coils or silica nanoparticles in langmuir monolayers @xcite . in water
, the interplay between the highly directional hydrogen - bonding network and the geometrical constraints determines the structure of liquid water and ice in two - dimensional layers , either under confinement or at open interfaces @xcite . within this context
, most computational studies have been devoted so far to the liquid structures @xcite , disregarding the behavior of amorphous solid phases . in summary , in this work
we study for the first time the amorphous solid phases of the two - dimensional mb model of water and their transitions .
in particular , we search for the existence of low - density ( lda ) and high - density ( hda ) solid amorphs and the determination of the nature of the transition between either hexagonal ice ( ih ) and hda as well as between lda and hda .
additionally , this approach allow us to study the validity of the two length scales hypothesis when directional bonds and a low dimensionality are introduced in the system .
we place our results in the context of the known experimental results about ice .
combined with three hydrogen - bonding arms of length @xmath0 , here depicted as arrows . ]
the mb pair - interaction potential is expressed as the sum of a radial and a directional term , @xmath1 the radial term , @xmath2 , is simply a lennard - jones potential , @xmath3,\ ] ] with the distance between the centers of the molecules as argument , @xmath4 .
the directional term , @xmath5 , represents the water hydrogen bond and is defined by means of unnormalized gaussian functions , @xmath6 $ ] . in his original model , ben - naim defined @xmath5 to be @xmath7 where @xmath8 and @xmath0 are the depth and position of the bonding potential minimum , respectively , and @xmath9 here @xmath10 and @xmath11 are unitary vectors in the direction of every hydrogen - bonding arm of molecules @xmath12 and @xmath13 , respectively , whereas @xmath14 is the unitary displacement vector between their centers .
more recently , silverstein and co - workers @xcite proposed a computational simplification of the model , by replacing expression ( [ eq : original - hb ] ) by : @xmath15 where @xmath16 according to the previous definitions , the mb model has two different bonding distances given by the minimum of the lennard - jones potential , @xmath17 , and the hydrogen bond length , @xmath0 , introduced in eq .
( [ eq : uhb ] ) . as a consequence of these two bonding mechanisms ,
two crystalline solid morphologies can be found in the model : a low - density hydrogen - bonded honeycomb lattice and a high - density triangular lattice of lennard - jones disks , as shown in figure [ fig : model ] . in particular , it has been shown by means of monte carlo npt simulations that the melting of the mb honeycomb structure reproduces qualitatively the thermodynamic properties of the melting of ice ih @xcite . therefore , it is reasonable to expect the existence in the model of at least two solid amorphs with low and high characteristic densities , which eventually could be associated with the low- and high - density amorphous ices . in order to explore the existence and characteristics of solid amorphs in the two - dimensional mb model
, we performed extensive equilibrium monte carlo npt simulations with a system composed with up to 1200 mb particles in a rectangular cell with periodic boundary conditions .
at least 50 independent runs of @xmath18 steps were performed for every point using the model parameters proposed in previous works @xcite : @xmath19 , @xmath20 , @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 .
after equilibration , measures of the internal energy , volume and structure were taken and averaged over all runs .
as usual , the system enthalpy and heat capacity were calculated as : @xmath24 here @xmath25 denotes averages over runs and the parameters are expressed in reduced units , relative to the hydrogen bond parameters : @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 , @xmath29 , @xmath30 . in the next section we present the results obtained from our simulations . in many cases , they correspond to simulations performed under very low temperature conditions . under such circumstances
one must be aware of the difficulties of obtaining well equilibrated structures at the transition region using simple npt monte carlo simulations ; thus extensive computer work is required to avoid the system being trapped into a local minimum .
in addition , the simplicity of the mb model as with any minimal model makes comparison with the experiments relevant only on a qualitative level .
in our simulations , we tried to reproduce the experimental amorphization paths established by mishima and collaborators in their pioneering works on amorphous ices .
in particular , we focus on the amorphization of ih ice which we identify with the honeycomb lattice into hda by compression at very low temperature @xcite and on the reversible transformation between lda and hda ices obtained by compression and decompression with annealing @xcite . except for the latter case
, we worked well below the melting point of the honeycomb crystal , @xmath31 at @xmath32 @xcite , assuming that the resulting sample structures remain in a solid state or , at least , in a very viscous amorphous phase .
we shall discuss this assumption on the basis of the rigidity percolation theory applied to amorphous solids .
+ the transformation of ice ih into hda is studied by compressing a sample of @xmath33 molecules , disposed initially in the honeycomb lattice , at a very low temperature , @xmath34=0.05 .
figure [ fig : ih - hda ] provides a first insight into the general behavior of the system during this process for @xmath35 mb particles .
as the pressure is increased , the system responds initially with just a slight reduction of the volume and a small displacement of the particles from their equilibrium positions , while keeping the global honeycomb structure .
the typical crystalline morphology at @xmath36 is shown in the inset of fig .
[ fig : ih - hda - volume ] .
consistently , the radial distribution function at @xmath36 ( see fig . [
fig : ih - hda - rdf ] ) identifies two clear maxima corresponding to the first and second nearest neighbor positions in the compressed honeycomb lattice . at around @xmath37 , an abrupt collapse of the stressed honeycomb structure takes place , leading to the arrangement of the particles into a high - density amorphous configuration , which we identify with hda ice . as revealed by its radial distribution function at @xmath38 ( see fig .
[ fig : ih - hda - rdf ] ) , this amorphous structure is associated with a significant formation of lj bonds , corresponding to the peak at around the lj equilibrium distance , @xmath39 , which replace a fraction of the original hb bonds of the honeycomb lattice , indicated by the peaks at around @xmath40 . a snapshot of hda ice at @xmath38 is also shown in the inset plot of fig . [ fig : ih - hda - volume ] to compare with the crystalline structure .
the hda morphology remains with little change when the system is further subjected to an isothermal decompression .
qualitatively , this behavior of the system volume is completely consistent with what can be observed in experiments @xcite and is a clear indication of a pressure - induced phase transition , probably of a first - order kind , as shown by the abrupt drop in the volume even for such a relatively small system .
we have further investigated the nature of the ih@xmath41hda transition by studying different parameters .
the analysis of the probability distribution function of the total configurational energy ( fig .
[ fig : ih - hda - histo ] ) clearly identifies single peaks before ( @xmath42 ) and after ( @xmath43 ) the transition , whereas for pressures close to the transition point ( @xmath44 ) two maxima are found .
this result is a strong indication of the first - order nature of the transition @xcite . , along the ih@xmath41hda transition for @xmath35 ; see the text for the bond - counting criterion used .
lower panel : corresponding evolution of the system enthalpy , @xmath45 , with the projection and intersection of the lines from each side of the transition used to estimate the thermodynamic transition pressure , @xmath46 . ] another way to characterize this transition is by studying the evolution of the bonds within samples as the pressure is increased .
qualitatively , it is evident that the structure must evolve from a rigid honeycomb lattice , connected by just hb bonds , into a completely different rigid structure , presumably independent from the former in the limit of very high pressures , composed of a triangular lattice of particles in close contact and governed by the soft - core barriers of the lj potential . in order to obtain some further insight into how this evolution takes place , we computed for every pressure the mean number of bonds of every type and the connectivity of the network defined by all the bonds .
the criterion used to take bonds into account has been the following : a bond , either of lj or hb type , is considered as established between any two given particles when the strength of the interaction is above 0.75 of its maximum possible value . in the case of the lj potential ,
since it represents a soft - core barrier for high pressure configurations , we also consider the bond established when the interparticle distance is below its optimum value , @xmath47 .
the upper panel of figure [ fig : ih - hda - enthalpy ] shows the evolution for the split mean number of hb and lj bonds obtained for @xmath35 . as expected , there is a sigmoidal - shaped increment of the number of lj bonds and a reduction of the number of hb bonds in the transition region .
the total number of bonds of any kind increases monotonically as one would expect from the different maximum coordination number of both lattices .
however , it is remarkable that the number of hb bonds decreases very slowly after the transition region and remains significant at relatively high pressures , indicating that some hb bonds still exist within compact configurations .
this behavior has an impact on the thermodynamic properties of the transition .
the lower panel of figure [ fig : ih - hda - enthalpy ] shows the system enthalpy per particle for @xmath35 as a function of the pressure .
the notable step down shown by the enthalpy at the transition region is numerically a consequence of the significant persistence of hb bonds after the collapse of the honeycomb structure , leading to a relatively small increase in the internal energy , @xmath48 , in front of the considerable decrease of the system volume , @xmath49 .
thermodynamically , such drop of enthalpy is a clear indication of the release of a hysteresis heat corresponding to the system relaxation from a metastable state : since the temperature is so low , the system gets kinetically trapped into the crystal phase until the overpressurization is high enough to overcome the energy barriers .
therefore , the thermodynamic transition point can be estimated from the intersection of the projected enthalpy lines from each side of the transition , as shown in figure [ fig : ih - hda - enthalpy ] . from this calculation
we get a value for the transition pressure of @xmath50 .
finally , the identification of the bonds allows us to study the clustering of the networks of bonded particles . in all cases we found that the connectivity of the network of bonds is maintained during the transition , so that all the particles remain connected into a single cluster at all pressures . according to the rigidity percolation theory @xcite , this behavior
in combination with the monotonic increase in the mean number of bonds indicates that the solidity of the sample structure is maintained during the transition .
therefore , this suggests that amorphization occurs via mechanical collapse instead of a melting of the crystal structure .
all these observations are consistent with the known experimental and simulation results on the pressure - induced amorphization of ice ih at very low temperatures @xcite .
the second process explored in our simulations with the mb model is the reversible transformation between high- and low - density amorphous structures .
as in the previous case , we apply a procedure equivalent to mishima s experiments to simulate a low - density amorphous solid , or lda ice , and its reversible transformation into hda @xcite .
specifically , the transformation hda@xmath41lda has been obtained by applying decompression with annealing , i.e. , by increasing the temperature of the hda sample as the pressure is lowered , whereas the reverse transformation hda@xmath41lda has been achieved by compressing the lda ice at high pressure under very low temperature conditions . + figure
[ fig : lda - hda ] shows the main results obtained from the indicated transformation procedures on a sample of size @xmath35 .
first , a closed transformation cycle lda@xmath51hda has been successfully achieved , as shown in the lower panel of figure [ fig : lda - hda - volume ] .
the lda structure has been produced by a linear increase of the system temperature from 0.05 to 0.13 as the pressure was reduced from 1.2 to 0.01 ( upper panel of figure [ fig : lda - hda - volume ] ) .
the mean number density of the resulting structure , which is mainly controlled by the final temperature , is @xmath52 , a value slightly lower than that corresponding to the honeycomb lattice , @xmath53 .
its radial distribution function , shown in figure [ fig : lda - hda - rdf ] , confirms that the lda morphology is the amorphous counterpart of the honeycomb lattice , being mainly composed of hb bonds but with many structural defects .
this morphology remains intact when the temperature is set back to @xmath54 . by applying an increasing pressure at such a low temperature , the lda morphology experiences a gradual compaction to arrive once more at the hda structure .
the continuous , smooth nature of the transformation between these amorphous forms is not what is found in experiments and simulations with other more realistic water models , from which it has been well established that its true nature is that of a first - order phase transition , with associated latent heats @xcite .
we tested also other configurations of potential lda structures with a somewhat higher density , produced by reducing the maximum temperature of the annealing process . in all cases
including some with a density even slightly higher than that corresponding to the honeycomb lattice the same qualitative results were obtained . for higher maximum annealing temperatures , a complete melting of the structure
is soon obtained .
therefore , we were unable to find in the two - dimensional mb model any low - density amorphous structure with enough structural stability to produce a pressure - induced discontinuous phase transition into a high - density amorphous form
. indeed , we want to stress that the transformation cycle shown in figure [ fig : lda - hda - volume ] corresponds just to the results qualitatively closer to mishima s experiments that we were able to find in our simulations .
in particular , the shape of the decompression hda@xmath41lda curve is controlled by the annealing temperatures and therefore can be strongly distorted by using different annealing conditions .
we consider that the origin of the apparent mechanical instability of the low - density amorphous phase in this model is most probably related to the low maximum coordination number imposed by the hb bonds and its interplay with the low dimensionality of the system , which geometrically forbids the existence of defects , inherent to any amorphous structure , without an associated reduction of the mean number of directed bonds .
as can be observed in the example of figure [ fig : lda - hda - config ] , most defects of the lda structure are associated with misalignments of the directed bonding arms .
these misalignments have effects at scales larger than the distance of first - nearest neighbors : as can be observed , the formation of non hexagonal cells closed loops of either less or more than six elements is very frequent .
this effect , combined with the limited possibilities of tessellation of the two - dimensional space , imposes the existence of many unbonded arms .
for instance , in the case illustrated by figure [ fig : lda - hda ] , the total mean coordination number calculated by means of the bond - counting criterion introduced in the previous section is 2.70 , or just 2.43 if only the hb bonds are taken into account .
obviously , any significant decrease of the mean number of hb bonds in this model implies a considerable increase in the total configurational energy of the sample : continuing with the example from figure [ fig : lda - hda ] , the mean configurational energy per particle of such an lda structure is approximately -1.34 , almost 15% higher than the energy corresponding to the unstressed honeycomb lattice , -1.57 .
such an energy is still significantly higher than that of the stressed honeycomb lattice at the point of collapse , -1.45 , showing the overall weakness of the structure .
this point represents a significant difference with respect to what is observed in three - dimensional simulations with tetrahedral water models , in which lda ice keeps the fully coordinated network structure @xcite .
we have performed extensive npt monte carlo simulations of the two - dimensional mb model in order to study the essential underlying physical mechanisms behind ice polyamorphism . in particular , we have investigated the validity of the two - length - scales hypothesis , previously suggested as the minimal ingredient for the interaction potential of polyamorphic materials , when directional bonds and a low system dimensionality are considered . to this end
we have investigated , in the first place , the pressure - induced transformation of ice ih into hda at very low temperatures .
our results suggest the existence of a first - order phase transition in which amorphization occurs via mechanical collapse of the crystal honeycomb lattice from a kinetically trapped metastable state into hda ice . this amorphous structure is associated with a significant formation of lj bonds that replace a small fraction of hb bonds in the original crystal .
this mechanism ensures the network connectivity during the transition , thus preventing the system from melting .
this result is in agreement with the experimental observations of pressure - induced amorphization of ice ih under very low temperature conditions @xcite . in the second place
we have explored the transformation between high- and low - density amorphous ices by performing an ( isothermal compression)(annealed decompression ) cycle .
our results indicate the existence of a continuous transformation between such amorphous structures that is in contradiction with the experimental findings @xcite .
we consider that this discrepancy can be attributed to the low coordination of the low - density amorphous phase , which has no significant structural stability .
this low connectivity arises as a consequence of the constraints imposed by the bond directionality and the low dimensionality of the system .
therefore our results provide a clear indication that an effective interaction potential with two characteristic length scales does not guarantee by itself a first - order phase transition between polyamorphs when it is accompanied by strong bonding constraints .
we hope that these results might stimulate new experiments performed in low dimensional systems to study the effect of geometrical constraints and the validity of the predictions of the minimal mb model .
we thank itamar procaccia and valery ilyin for introducing us to the mb model and many useful discussions .
simulations were performed at the ifisc s nuredduna high - throughput computing clusters , supported by the projects grid - csic @xcite and fisicos ( fis2007 - 60327 , funded by the spanish mincnn and the erdf ) .
jhec acknowledges mincinn ( spain ) project fis2010 - 22322 - 528c02 - 02 .
op and pas acknowledge mincinn ( spain ) project fis2010 - 22322 - 528c02 - 01 .
ts acknowledges the aforementioned project fisicos .
81ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.84.885 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1098/rspa.1935.0229 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/288569a0 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/310393a0 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/338638a0 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.462732 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/384546a0 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/23216 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.467103 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.3139007 [ * * , ( ) ] in link:\doibase 10.1007/978 - 3 - 642 - 03309 - 4_3 [ _ _ ] , , vol . ,
( , ) pp
. link:\doibase 10.1021/jp203985w [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.91.115504 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.1624055 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0256 - 307x/24/4/069 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/1674 - 1056/17/6/039 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.cpc.2010.07.039 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1039/b108676f [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.72.031510 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.cplett.2004.07.116 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1021/jp0531558 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1002/cphc.200800539 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.78.224301 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1039/b517775h [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0953 - 8984/18/50/r01 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.2830029 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0953 - 8984/21/28/283101 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.2183/pjab.86.165 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1039/c0cp02600j [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/360324a0 [ * * , ( ) ] `` , '' in link:\doibase 10.1021/bk-1997 - 0676.ch019 [ _ _ ] , ( , ) chap
. , pp . link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.85.334 [ * * , ( ) ]
link:\doibase 10.1038/24540 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1038/35055514 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.95.130604 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.jnoncrysol.2010.07.053 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.92.225702 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.1870852 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0256 - 307x/22/12/062 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1140/epjb / e2010 - 10763-x [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/s0167 - 7322(97)00076 - 7 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.1590645 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.1817924 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.1950628 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1146/annurev.biophys.34.040204.144517 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.1940030 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1209/0295 - 5075/92/46008 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.3521486 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.81.4895 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.63.061509 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.66.031509 [ * * , ( ) ] in @noop _ _ , , vol .
( , ) link:\doibase 10.1016/j.molliq.2007.08.021 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.3354112 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.83.011704 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0953 - 8984/24/3/035103 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.77.042201 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1021/jp205098a [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.1675414 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1080/00268977200101851 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1021/ja973029k [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/s0378 - 3812(98)00278 - 7 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.3183935 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1021/ja026014h [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.1427307 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.3537734 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1021/jp055543f [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.480928 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.2784124 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.3259970 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.3454193 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1140/epje / i2010 - 10554-x [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1021/ja0274608 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1039/b805361h [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0953 - 8984/16/45/005 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1146/annurev - anchem-070109 - 103410 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevb.26.2507 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/0378 - 4371(96)00213 - 0 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1002/3527602798 [ _ _ ] ( , ) link:\doibase 10.1002/cphc.200600011 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop | we investigate ice polyamorphism in the context of the two - dimensional mercedes - benz model of water . we find a first - order phase transition between a crystalline phase and a high - density amorphous phase .
furthermore we find a reversible transformation between two amorphous structures of high and low density ; however we find this to be a continuous and not an abrupt transition , as the low - density amorphous phase does not show structural stability .
we discuss the origin of this behavior and its implications with regard to the minimal generic modeling of polyamorphism . |
there has been a lot of interest in silicene since it shows properties similar to those of graphene@xcite . for example , the theoretical studies on silicene show that the charge carriers in this two - dimensional material behave like massless dirac - fermions due to presence of linear dispersion around fermi energy at a symmetry point k in the reciprocal lattice@xcite .
similar to its carbon counterpart - graphene , silicene is a potential candidate for applications in nanotechnology .
the silicon based nanostructures have an important advantage that they are compatible with the existing semiconductor technology .
therefore , silicene and silicon nanoribbon have received much attention from both experimentalist and theoreticians@xcite .
recently , silicene has been epitaxially grown on a close - packed silver surface ag(111)@xcite . though graphene possesses many novel properties , its applications in nanoelectronic devices
are limited due to its zero band gap and hence it is difficult to control the electrical conductivity of graphene .
however , band gap in graphene may be introduced by chemical doping but chemical doping is uncontrollable and incompatible with device applications .
hence , it is desirable to have band gap in materials in addition to their novel properties . in this letter
, we demonstrate that silicene is one such a material in which the band gap can be opened up as well as varied over a wide range by applying external static electric field in a direction perpendicular to the plane of sheet .
we use siesta package@xcite for performing a fully self - consistent density functional theory ( dft ) calculation by solving the standard kohn - sham ( ks ) equations .
the ks orbitals are expanded using a linear combination of pseudoatomic orbitals proposed by sankey and niklewski@xcite .
all our calculations have been carried out by using triple - zeta basis set with polarization function .
the standard norm conserving troullier - martins pseudopotentials@xcite are utilized . for exchange - correlation potential
generalized gradient approximation given by perdew - burke - ernzerhof@xcite has been used .
a cutoff of 400 ry is used for the grid integration to represent the charge density and the mesh of k - points for brillouin zone integrations is chosen to be 45@xmath045@xmath01 .
the convergence criteria for energy in scf cycles is chosen to be 10@xmath1 ev .
the structures are optimized by minimizing the forces on individual atoms ( below 10@xmath2 ev/ @xmath3 ) .
super - cell geometry with a vacuum of 14 @xmath3 in the direction perpendicular to the sheet of silicene is used so that the interaction between adjacent layers is negligible . the optimized geometry of silicene is shown in fig .
the unitcell has two si atoms ( a and b ) and the space group is p3m1 .
we observed that the minimum energy structure of the silicene is low - buckled with the lattice constant of 3.903 @xmath3 .
the bond length and bond angles between the silicon atoms are 2.309 @xmath3 and 115.4@xmath5 respectively .
the value of bond angle in silicene lies in between those of sp@xmath6 ( 120@xmath5 ) and sp@xmath7 ( 109.47@xmath5 ) hybridized structures .
this clearly shows that the hybridization in silicene is not purely sp@xmath6 but a mixture of sp@xmath6and sp@xmath7 .
the buckling in silicene is due to weak @xmath8 - @xmath8 bond that exists between si atoms since the si - si distance is much larger as compared to that in graphene ( c - c = 1.42 @xmath3 ) .
the system increases its binding energy due to buckling by increasing the overlap between @xmath8 and @xmath9 orbitals .
the presence of buckling may also be explained by jahn - teller distortion .
our results on geometry match well with the previous calculations@xcite .
here , we quantify the amount of buckling in terms of buckling length @xmath4 which is defined as the vertical distance between atoms at sites a and b in the unitcell . the value of @xmath4 in silicene is 0.5 @xmath3 . in case of planar structure , as that of graphene , the value of @xmath4 is zero .
the importance of @xmath4 in determining the electronic structure of silicene under the influence of external electric field will be described later .
+ the band structure along high symmetry points in brillouin zone and density of states ( dos ) of silicene are shown in fig .2 .
the figure clearly indicates the semi - metallic behavior of silicene since the value of dos at e@xmath10 is zero and the conduction and valence band touch each other only at the symmetry k point .
the energy levels and the contribution of density of states just below and above fermi levels are mainly due to @xmath8 and @xmath11 orbitals .
the dispersion around k point near the fermi level is linear ( see insert in fig .
2 ( a ) ) .
the point in e - k diagram where the conduction and valence band touch each other at e@xmath10 is called the dirac point .
the presence of linear dispersion indicates that the charge carriers near dirac point behave like massless dirac fermions since the dynamics of these carriers obey relativistic dirac - like equation .
the relativistic dirac - like hamiltonian which describes the electronic structure of silicene around the dirac point , similar to that of graphene@xcite , can be approximated as @xmath12 where @xmath13 and @xmath14 are momentum and fermi velocity of charge carriers near dirac point .
the quantity @xmath15 is the onsite energy difference between the si atoms at sites a and b. due to the presence of inversion symmetry , the onsite energy difference @xmath15 becomes zero , which leads to the linear dispersion around the dirac point linear i.e. @xmath16 . until now
, the treatment for description of electronic structures of silicene is exactly similar to that of graphene .
the band gap in graphene - like structure can be opened up if one can break the inversion symmetry and hence the value of @xmath15 becomes finite .
then , the dispersion around the dirac point becomes @xmath17 in this case , the value of band gap opened is twice that of the onsite energy difference .
it is possible to make @xmath15 non - zero in graphene by chemical doping which cause the local environment around the sites a and b to be different . as mentioned earlier ,
tuning the value of @xmath15 by chemical doping is a difficult task . in the above
mentioned discussion , the effect of spin - orbit coupling ( soc ) is not included and very small gap of the order of @xmath18ev in graphene and about 1.55 mev in silicene may be opened up due to soc@xcite .
however , presence of small gaps may be useful in studying fundamental properties like quantum spin hall effect and will not be useful in operating or controlling nanoelectronic devices made up of graphene / silicene at ambient conditions . in order to utilize many novel properties of graphene - like materials in nanodevices
, it is desirable that the materials shall possess value of band gap more than the thermal energy kt at room temperature ( @xmath19 25 mev ) .
+ in fig .
3 , we plot the spatial distribution of highest occupied and lowest unoccupied states with and without electric field . both of these states lie at the symmetry k point in brillouin zone . in the absence of external electric field ,
both the highest occupied and lowest unoccupied states ( fig .
3(a ) and 3(b ) ) have same energy and also possess inversion symmetry .
hence the spatial distribution of these states above and below the silicene sheet looks similar .
however , application of external electric field breaks the inversion symmetry in these states .
this makes the spatial distribution of charges above and below the silicence sheet to be different which can be seen clearly from fig .
3(c ) and 3(d ) respectively for highest occupied and lowest unoccupied states .
this leads to the opening up of band gap in silicene .
+ from our calculations on electronic structure of silicene , we observed that a band gap can be opened up at the fermi level due to the influence of external electric field .
the electric field is applied in a direction perpendicular to the plane of silicene sheet .
the calculated band structures of silicene around dirac point for various strengths of external electric field are shown in fig .
4 . for example
, the value of band gap opened with electric filed of 5 volts per nanometer ( v nm@xmath20 ) is 50.9 milli electron volts ( mev ) .
the band gap in silicene is opened due to breaking of inversion symmetry by the electric field since the potential seen by the atoms at the sites a and b are different . in this situation
, the finite value of onsite energy difference arises due to the potential difference and hence , we can write @xmath21 where @xmath22 and @xmath23 ( @xmath24 ) are proportionality constant and the potential seen by the atom at the site a(b ) respectively . when the field applied between the layers
is constant around the sheet , as in the present case , the potential difference becomes @xmath25d@xmath26 , where @xmath27 is strength of electric field and @xmath4 the distance between the atoms at the sites a and b along the field direction .
the finite value of @xmath4 in silicene monolayer plays an important role in breaking symmetry in presence of electric field and cause opening of band gap .
this result leads to an important advantage of silicene over graphene since there is no buckling in latter and hence it is not possible to open up a gap by applying external electric field .
+ we also observed from our dft calculations that band gap can be tuned over wide range by varying strength of external electric field .
the results of variation in band gap of silicene under influence of different strengths of electric field are summarized in given fig .
it is seen from fig .
5 that the band gap varies linearly with the external electric field .
we also observed that both valence and conduction band edges move symmetrically away from fermi level when the electric field is applied .
the presence of linear relationship between the band gap and electric field can be explained as follow . as mentioned earlier ,
the value of band gap opened can be written as @xmath30d@xmath31 , where @xmath32 is proportionality constant and it should be characteristic of the material . from fig .
5 , the value of the @xmath32 is found to be 10.14 ( mev per v / nm ) .
it is remarkable that in silicene monolayer , the band gap can be tuned by simply varying the strength of external electric field .
similar trends have also been observed for germanene monolayer and the results will be published elsewhere@xcite . in summary ,
we have carried out abinitio dft calculations to study geometric and electronic structure of silicene .
our results on the electronic structures of silicene monolayer show that it is a semi - metal and possesses linear dispersion around dirac point similar to graphene and hence the charge carriers in silicene behave like massless dirac - fermions .
we have shown that band gap in silicene monolayer can be opened up by applying external electric field .
the presence of buckling in optimized structure of silicene plays an important role in breaking inversion symmetry .
we also observe that the band gap varies linearly with the strength of electric field .
furthermore , our results predict that the band gap produced can be more than the thermal energy by applying electric field strength of few v / nm and hence , there is a possibility of using silicene monolayer in nanodevice even at room temperature .
authors thank dr .
p. d. gupta and dr .
s. k. deb for encouragement and support .
thanks also to dr .
aparna chakrabarti , dr .
arup banerjee and dr .
j. jayabalan for critical reading of the manuscript .
the support and help of mr .
p. thander and the scientific computing group , computer centre , rrcat is acknowledged .
a. k. geim and k. s. novoselov , nature mater . ,
* 6 * , 183 ( 2007 ) k. s. novoselov , a. k. geim , s. v. morozov , d. jiang , m. i. katsnelson , i. v. grigorieva , s. v. dubonos , and a. a. firsov , nature * 438 * , 197 ( 2005 ) y. b. zhang , y. w. tan , h. l. stormer , p. kim , nature * 438 * , 201 ( 2005 ) .
k. s. novoselov , e. mccann , s. v. morozov , v. i. falko , m. i. katsnelson , u. zeitler , d. jiang , f. schedin and a. k. geim , nature phys .
* 2 * , 177 ( 2006 ) s. cahangirov , m. topsakal , e. akturk , h. sahin , and s. ciraci , phys .
lett . * 102 * , 236804 ( 2009 ) h. sahin , s. cahangirov , m. topsakal , e. bekaroglu , e. akturk , r. t. senger , and s. ciraci , phys .
b , * 80 * , 155453 ( 2009 ) .
b. lalmi , h. oughaddou , h. enriquez , a. kara , s. vizzini , b. ealet and b. aufray , appl .
lett . , * 97 * , 223109 ( 2010 ) b. aufray , a. kara , s. vizzini , h. oughaddou , c. leandri , b. ealet and g. l. lay , appl .
phys . lett . , * 96 * , 183102 ( 2010 ) a. kara , s. vizzini , c. leandri , b. ealet , h. oughaddou , b. aufray and g. l. lay , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 22 * 045004 ( 2010 ) p. d. padova , c. quaresima , c. ottaviani , p. m. sheverdyaeva , p. moras , c. carbone , d. topwal , b. olivieri , a. kara , h. oughaddou , b. aufray , and g. l. lay , appl .
lett . , * 96 * , 261905 ( 2010 ) m. houssa , g. pourtois , v. v. afanasev , and a. stesmans , appl . phys .
lett . , * 97 * , 112106 ( 2011 ) s. lebegue and o. eriksson , phys
b , * 79 * , 115409 ( 2009 ) .
n. y. dzade , k. o. obodo , s. k. adjokatse , a. c. ashu , e. amankwah , c. d. atiso , a. a. bello , e. igumbor , s. b. nzabarinda , j. t. obodo , a. o. ogbuu , o. e. femi , j. o. udeigwe and u. v. waghmare , j. phys . : condens
. matter , * 22 * , 375502 ( 2010 ) d. jose and a. datta , phys
phys . , * 13 * , 7304 ( 2011 ) m. j. s. spencer , t. morishita , m. mikami , i. k. snook , y. sugiyama and h. nakano , phys . chem .
phys.,*13 * , 15418 ( 2011 ) t. h. osborn , a. a. farajian , o. v. pupysheva , r. s. aga , l. c. l. y. voon , chem .
, * 511 * , 101 ( 2011 ) p. ordejon , e. artacho , and j. m. soler , phys . rev
. b , * 53 * , r10441 ( 1996 ) .
d. sanchez - portal , p. ordejon , e. artacho , and j. m. soler , int . j. quantum chem . ,
* 65 * , 453 ( 1997 ) .
j. m. soler , e. artacho , j. d. gale , a. garca , j. junquera , p. ordejon , and d. sanchez - portal , j. phys .
condens . matter .
, * 14 * , 2745 ( 2002 ) ; see also http://www.uam.es/siesta . o. f. sankey and d. j. niklewski , phys .
b * 40 * , 3979 ( 1989 ) .
n. troullier and j. l. martins , phys .
b * 43 * , 1993 ( 1991 ) .
j. p. perdew , k. burke , and m. ernzerhof , phys .
lett.,*77 * , 3865 ( 1996 ) j. b. oostinga , h. b. heersche , x. liu , a. f. morpurgo and l. m. k. vandersypen , nature mater .
* 7 * , 151 ( 2008 ) p. r. wallace , phys
. rev . * 71 * , 622 ( 1947 ) .
y. yao , f. ye , x. l. qi , s. c. zhang , and z. fang , phys .
b * 75 * , 041401 ( 2007 ) . c. c. liu , w. feng , and y. yao , phys . rev .
lett . , * 107 * , 076802 ( 2011 ) c. kamal , et . al .
( manuscript in preparation ) | we study the geometric and electronic structures of silicene monolayer using density functional theory based calculations .
the electronic structures of silicene show that it is a semi - metal and the charge carriers in silicene behave like massless dirac - fermions since it possesses linear dispersion around dirac point .
our results show that the band gap in silicene monolayer can be opened up at fermi level due to an external electric field by breaking the inversion symmetry .
the presence of buckling in geometric structure of silicene plays an important role in breaking the inversion symmetry .
we also show that the band gap varies linearly with the strength of external electric field .
further , the value of band gap can be tuned over a wide range . |
the last decade witnessed a revolution in neutrino physics . it has been observed that neutrinos have nonzero masses , and that leptons mix .
this fact was proven by the observation that neutrinos can change from one type , or `` flavour '' , to another .
almost all the knowledge we have gathered about neutrinos , is only fifteen years old .
but before diving into the recent `` news '' about neutrinos , lets find out how neutrinos were born .
the 20s witnessed the assassination of many sacred cows , and physics was no exception , one of physic s most holly principles , the conservation of energy , appeared not to hold within the subatomic world .
for some radioactive nuclei , it seemed that part of its energy just disappear , leaving no footprint of its existence . in 1920 , in a letter to a conference , pauli wrote , `` dear radioactive ladies and gentlemen , ... as a desperate remedy to save the principle of energy conservation in beta decay , ...
i propose the idea of a neutral particle of spin half '' .
pauli postulated that the energy loss was taken off by a new particle , whose properties were such that it would not yet be seen : it had no electric charge and rarely interacted with matter at all .
this way , the neutrino was born into the world of particle physics . soon afterwards , fermi wrote the four - fermi hamiltonian for beta decay using the neutrino , electron , neutron and proton .
a new field came to existence : the field of weak interactions . and
two decades after pauli s letter , cowan and reines finally observed anti - neutrinos emitted by a nuclear reactor .
as more and more particles were discovered in the following years and observed to participate in weak processes , weak interactions got legitimacy as a new force of nature and the neutrino became a key ingredient of this interactions .
further experiments over the course of the next 30 years showed us that there were three kinds , or `` flavours '' of neutrinos ( electron neutrinos ( @xmath0 ) , muon neutrinos ( @xmath1 ) and tau neutrinos ( @xmath2 ) ) and that , as far as we could tell , had no mass at all .
the neutrino saga might have stop there , but new experiments in solar physics taught us that the neutrino story was just beginning .... within the standard model , neutrinos have zero mass and therefore interact diagonally in flavour space , @xmath3 since they are mass - less , they move at the speed of light and therefore their flavour remains the same from production up to detection .
it is obvious then , that at least as flavour is concerned , zero mas neutrinos are almost not interesting as compared to quarks .
on the other hand , neutrinos masses different from zero , mean that there are three neutrino mass eigenstates @xmath4 , each with a mass @xmath5 .
the meaning of leptonic mixing can be understood by analysing the leptonic decays , @xmath6 of the charged @xmath7 boson .
where , @xmath8 , or @xmath9 , and @xmath10 represents the electron , @xmath11 the muon , or @xmath12 the tau .
we refer to particle @xmath13 as the charged lepton of flavour @xmath14 .
mixing essentially means that when the @xmath15 decays to a given flavour of charged lepton @xmath16 , the neutrino that comes along is not always the same mass eigenstate @xmath17 . _
any _ of the different @xmath17 can show up .
the amplitude for the decay of a @xmath15 to a specific combination @xmath18 is designated by @xmath19 .
the neutrino that is emitted in @xmath15 decay along with the given charged lepton @xmath16 is then @xmath20 this particular combination of mass eigenstates is the neutrino of flavour @xmath14 .
the quantities @xmath21 can be collected in a unitary matrix ( analogue to the ckm matrix of the quark sector ) known as the leptonic mixing matrix @xcite .
the unitarity of @xmath22 guarantees that every time a neutrino of flavour @xmath14 interacts in a detector and produces a charged lepton , such a charged lepton will be always @xmath13 , the charged lepton with flavour @xmath23 .
that is , a @xmath24 indefectibly creates an @xmath25 , a @xmath26 a @xmath27 , and a @xmath28 a @xmath9 .
the relation ( [ eq1 ] ) , describing a neutrino of definite flavour as a linear combination of mass eigenstates , may be inverted to describe each mass eigenstate @xmath17 as a linear combination of flavours : @xmath29 the @xmath14-flavour `` content '' ( or fraction ) of @xmath17 is clearly @xmath30 . when a @xmath17 interacts and generates a charged lepton , this @xmath14-flavour fraction becomes the probability that the emerging charged lepton be of flavour @xmath14 .
a standard neutrino flavour transition , or `` oscillation '' , can be understood as follows .
a neutrino is produced by a source together with a charged lepton @xmath16 of flavour @xmath14 .
therefore , at the production point , the neutrino is a @xmath31 .
then , after birth , the neutrino travels a distance @xmath32 until it is detected .
there , it is where it reaches a target with which it interacts and produces another charged lepton @xmath33 of flavour @xmath34 .
thus , at the interaction point , the neutrino is a @xmath35 .
if @xmath36 ( for example , if @xmath13 is a @xmath37 but @xmath33 is a @xmath9 ) , then , during its trip from the source to the detection point , the neutrino has transitioned from a @xmath31 into a @xmath35 .
this morphing of neutrino flavour , @xmath38 , is a text - book example of a quantum - mechanical effect . because , as described by eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) , a @xmath31 is really a coherent superposition of mass eigenstates @xmath17 , the neutrino that propagates since it is created until it interacts , can be any one of the @xmath17 s , therefore we must add the contributions of all the different @xmath17 coherently . then , the transition amplitude , amp(@xmath38 ) contains a share of each @xmath17 and it is a product of three factors .
the first one is the amplitude for the neutrino born at the production point in combination with an @xmath16 to be , specifically , a @xmath17 .
as we have mentioned already , this amplitude is given by @xmath39 .
the second factor is the amplitude for the @xmath17 created by the source to propagate until it reaches the detector .
we will call this factor prop(@xmath17 ) and will find out its value later .
the third factor is the amplitude for the charged lepton produced by the interaction of the @xmath17 with the detector to be , specifically , an @xmath33 .
as the hamiltonian that describes the interaction of neutrinos , charged leptons and @xmath7 bosons is hermitian , it ensues that if amp(@xmath40 , then amp@xmath41 .
therefore , the third and last factor in the @xmath17 contribution is @xmath42 , and @xmath43 it still remains to be established the value of prop(@xmath17 ) . to determine it , we d better study the @xmath17 in its rest frame .
we will label the time in that system @xmath44 .
if @xmath17 does have a rest mass @xmath5 , then in this frame its state vector satisfies the good old schrdinger equation @xmath45 whose solution is given clearly by @xmath46 then , the amplitude for the mass eigenstate @xmath17 to propagate for a time @xmath44 , is simply the amplitude @xmath47 for observing the original @xmath17 @xmath48 after some time as the evoluted state @xmath49 , i.e. @xmath50 $ ] .
thus prop(@xmath17 ) is only this amplitude where we have used that the time taken by @xmath17 to travel from the neutrino source to the detector is @xmath44 , the proper time . nevertheless ,
if we want prop(@xmath17 ) to be of any use to us , we must write it first in terms of variables in the laboratory system .
the natural choice is obviously the laboratory - frame distance , @xmath32 , that the neutrino covers between the source and the detector , and the laboratory - frame time , @xmath51 , that slips away during the journey .
the distance @xmath32 is set by the experimentalists through the selection of the place of settlement of the source and that of the detector .
likewise , the value of the time @xmath51 is selected by the experimentalists through their election for the time at which the neutrino is created and that when it is detected .
thus , @xmath32 and @xmath51 are chosen ( hopefully carefully ) by the experiment design , and are the same for all the @xmath17 components of the beam .
different @xmath17 do travel through an identical distance @xmath32 , in an identical time @xmath51 .
we still need two other laboratory - frame variables , they are the laboratory - frame energy @xmath52 and momentum @xmath53 of the neutrino mass eigenstate @xmath17 . with the four lab - frame variable and using lorentz invariance , we can obtain the phase @xmath54 in the @xmath55 propagator prop(@xmath17 ) we have been looking for , which ( expressed in terms of laboratory frame variables ) is given by @xmath56 at this point however one may argue that , in real life , neutrino sources are basically constant in time , and that the time @xmath51 that slips away since the neutrino is produced till it dies in the detector is actually not measured .
this argument is right . in real life ,
an experiment averages over the time @xmath51 used by the neutrino to complete its journey .
however , lets consider that two constituents of the neutrino beam , the first one with energy @xmath57 and the second one with energy @xmath58 ( both measured in the lab frame ) , contribute coherently to the neutrino signal produced in the detector . now ,
if we call @xmath51 to the the time used by the neutrino to cover the distance separating the production and detection points , then by the time the constituent whose energy is @xmath59 arrives to the detector , it has raised a phase factor @xmath60 $ ] .
therefore , we will have an interference between the @xmath57 and @xmath58 beam participants that will include a phase factor @xmath61 $ ] .
when averaged over the non - observed travel time @xmath51 , this factor goes away , _ except when @xmath62_. therefore , only components of the neutrino beam that share the same energy contribute coherently to the neutrino oscillation signal @xcite .
specifically , only the different mass eigenstate constituents of a beam that have the same energy contribute coherently to the oscillation signal .
a mass eigenstate @xmath17 , with mass @xmath5 , and energy @xmath63 , has a momentum @xmath53 given by @xmath64 where , we have used that as the masses of the neutrinos are miserably small , @xmath65 for any energy @xmath63 attainable at a realistic experiment . from eqs .
( [ eq6 ] ) and ( [ eq7 ] ) , we see that at energy @xmath63 the phase @xmath66 appearing in prop(@xmath17 ) takes the value @xmath67 as the phase @xmath68 appears in all the interfering terms it will eventually disappear when calculating the transition amplitude .
we can get rid of it already now and use @xmath69 ~~ . \label{eq9}\ ] ] applying this result , we can obtain from eq .
( [ eq3 ] ) that the amplitude for a neutrino born as a @xmath31 to be detected as a @xmath35 after covering a distance @xmath32 through vacuum with energy @xmath63 yields @xmath70 the expression above is valid for an arbitrary number of neutrino flavours and mass eigenstates .
the probability p(@xmath38 ) for @xmath38 can be found by squaring it , giving @xmath71 with @xmath72 in order to get eq .
( [ eq11 ] ) we have used that the mixing matrix @xmath22 is unitary .
the oscillation probability p(@xmath38 ) we have just obtained corresponds to that of a _ neutrino _ , and not to an _ antineutrino _ , as we have used that the oscillating neutrino was produced along with a charged _ antilepton _
@xmath73 , and gives birth to a charged _ lepton _ @xmath74 once it reaches the detector .
the corresponding probability p(@xmath75 ) for an antineutrino oscillation can be obtained from p(@xmath38 ) taking advantage of the fact that the two transitions @xmath75 and @xmath76 are cpt conjugated processes .
thus , assuming that neutrino interactions respect cpt@xcite , @xmath77 then , from eq .
( [ eq11 ] ) we obtain that @xmath78 therefore , if cpt is a good symmetry ( with respect to neutrino interactions ) , eq .
( [ eq11 ] ) tells us that @xmath79{1em}{.1 mm } ) } \\ [ -.7ex ] $ \nu_\alpha $ } \longrightarrow \shortstack{{\tiny ( \rule[.4ex]{1em}{.1 mm } ) } \\ [ -.7ex ] $ \nu_\beta $ } ) & = & \delta_{\alpha\beta } - 4\sum_{i > j } \re ( u^*_{\alpha i } u_{\beta i } u_{\alpha j}u^*_{\beta j } ) \sin^2 \left ( \delta m^2_{ij}\frac{l}{4e } \right ) \nonumber \\ & & \phantom{\delta_{\alpha\beta } } { \rm \poptm}\ ; 2\sum_{i > j } \im ( u^*_{\alpha i } u_{\beta i } u_{\alpha j}u^*_{\beta j } ) \sin\ , \left ( \delta m^2_{ij}\frac{l}{2e } \right ) ~~ . \label{eq15}\end{aligned}\ ] ] these expressions make it clear that if the mixing matrix @xmath22 is complex , p(@xmath80 ) and p(@xmath38 ) will not be identical , in general .
as @xmath81 and @xmath38 are cp conjugated processes , p@xmath82 would be an evidence of cp violation in neutrino oscillations .
so far , cp violation has been observed only in the quark sector , so its measurement in neutrino oscillations would be quite exciting .
so far , we have been working in natural units , if we return now the @xmath83 s and @xmath84 factor ( we have happily left out ) into the oscillation probability we find that @xmath85 having done that , it is easy and instructive to explore the semi - classical limit , @xmath86 . in this limit
the oscillation length goes to zero ( the oscillation phase goes to infinity ) and the oscillations are averaged out .
the same happens if we let the mass difference @xmath87 become large .
this is exactly what happens in the quark sector ( and the reason why we never study quark oscillations despite knowing that mass eigenstates do not coincide with flavour eigenstates ) . in terms of real life units ( which are not `` natural '' units ) , the oscillation phase is given by @xmath88 then , since @xmath89 $ ] can be experimentally observed only if its argument is of order unity or larger , an experimental set - up with a baseline @xmath32 ( km ) and an energy @xmath63 ( gev )
is sensitive to neutrino mass squared differences @xmath90 larger that or equal to @xmath91^{-1}$ ] .
for example , an experiment with @xmath92 km , roughly the size of earth s diameter , and @xmath93 gev is sensitive to @xmath94 down to @xmath95 ev@xmath96 .
this fact makes it clear that neutrino oscillation experiments can test super tiny neutrino masses .
it does so by exhibiting quantum mechanical interferences between amplitudes whose relative phases are proportional to these super tiny neutrino mass squared differences , which can be transformed into sizeable effects by choosing an @xmath97 large enough . but let s keep analysing the oscillation probability and see whether we can learn more about neutrino oscillations by studying its expression .
it is clear from @xmath98{1em}{.1 mm } ) } \\ [ -.7ex ] $ \nu_\alpha $ } \longrightarrow \shortstack{{\tiny ( \rule[.4ex]{1em}{.1 mm } ) } \\ [ -.7ex ] $ \nu_\beta $ } ) $ ] that if neutrinos have zero mass , in such a way that all @xmath99 , then , @xmath100{1em}{.1 mm } ) } \\ [ -.7ex ] $ \nu_\alpha $ } \longrightarrow \shortstack{{\tiny ( \rule[.4ex]{1em}{.1 mm } ) } \\ [ -.7ex ] $ \nu_\beta $ } ) = \delta_{\alpha\beta}$ ] .
therefore , the experimental observation that neutrinos can morph from one flavour to a different one indicates that neutrinos are not only massive but also that their masses are not degenerate .
actually , it was precisely this evidence the one that led to the conclusion that neutrinos are massive .
however , every neutrino oscillation seen so far has involved at some point neutrinos that travel through matter .
but the expression we derived is valid only for flavour change in vacuum , and does not take into account any interaction between the neutrinos and the matter traversed between their source and their detector .
thus , one might ask whether flavour - changing interactions between neutrinos and matter are indeed responsible of the observed flavour changes , and not neutrino masses . regarding this question ,
two points can be made .
first , although it is true that the standard model of elementary particle physics contains only mass - less neutrinos , it provides an amazingly well corroborated description of neutrino interactions , and this description clearly establishes that neutrino interactions with matter do not change flavour .
second , for at least some of the observed flavour changes , matter effects are expected to be miserably small , and there is solid evidence that in these cases , the flavour transition probability depends on @xmath32 and @xmath63 through the combination @xmath97 , as anticipated by the oscillation hypothesis .
modulo a constant , @xmath97 is precisely the proper time that goes by in the rest frame of the neutrino as it covers a distance @xmath32 possessing an energy @xmath63 .
thus , these flavour transitions behave as if they were a progression of the neutrino itself over time , rather than a result of interaction with matter . now
, suppose the leptonic mixings were trivial .
this would mean that in the decay @xmath101 , which as we established has an amplitude @xmath39 , the emerging charged antilepton @xmath16 of flavour @xmath14 comes along always with the _ same _ neutrino mass eigenstate @xmath17 .
that is , if @xmath102 , then @xmath103 becomes zero for all @xmath104 .
therefore , from eq .
( [ eq15 ] ) it is clear that , @xmath98{1em}{.1 mm } ) } \\ [ -.7ex ] $ \nu_\alpha $ } \longrightarrow \shortstack{{\tiny ( \rule[.4ex]{1em}{.1 mm } ) } \\ [ -.7ex ] $ \nu_\beta $ } ) = \delta_{\alpha\beta}$ ] .
thus , the observation that neutrinos can change flavour indicates mixing
. then , there are basically two ways to detect neutrino flavour change .
the first one is to observe , in a beam of neutrinos which are all created of the same flavour , say @xmath14 , some appearance of neutrinos of a new flavour @xmath34 that is different from the flavour @xmath14 we started with .
this is what is called an appearance experiment .
the second way is to start with a beam of identical @xmath31s , whose flux is known , and observe that this known @xmath31 flux is depleted .
this is called a disappearance experiment . as eq .
( [ eq15 ] ) shows , the transition probability in vacuum does not only depend on @xmath97 but also oscillates with it .
it is because of this fact that neutrino flavour transitions are named `` neutrino oscillations '' .
now notice also that neutrino transition probabilities depend only on neutrino squared - mass _ splittings _ , and not on the individual squared neutrino masses themselves .
thus , oscillation experiments can only measure the neutrino squared - mass spectral pattern , but not its absolute scale , i.e. the distance above zero the entire pattern lies .
it is clear that neutrino transitions can not modify the total flux in a neutrino beam , but simply alter its distribution between the different flavours . actually , from eq .
( [ eq15 ] ) and the unitarity of the @xmath22 matrix , it follows that @xmath105{1em}{.1 mm } ) } \\ [ -.7ex ] $ \nu_\alpha $ } \longrightarrow \shortstack{{\tiny ( \rule[.4ex]{1em}{.1 mm } ) } \\ [ -.7ex ] $ \nu_\beta $ } ) = 1 ~~ , \label{eq17}\ ] ] where the sum runs over all flavours @xmath34 , including the original flavour @xmath14 .
( [ eq17 ] ) makes it transparent that the probability that a neutrino morphs its flavour , added to the probability that it does not do so , is one .
ergo , flavour transitions do not change the total flux .
nevertheless , some of the flavours @xmath36 into which a neutrino can oscillate into may be _ sterile _ flavours ; that is , flavours that do not take part in weak interactions and therefore escape detection .
if any of the original ( active ) neutrino flux turns into sterile , then an experiment measuring the total _ active _ neutrino flux that is , the sum of the @xmath106 , and @xmath28 fluxes will find it to be less than the original flux . in the experiments performed up today ,
no flux was ever missed . in the literature ,
description of neutrino oscillation normally assume that the different mass eigenstates @xmath17 that contribute coherently to a beam share the same _ momentum _ , rather than the same _ energy _ as we have argued they must have .
while the supposition of equal momentum is technically wrong , it is an inoffensive mistake , since , as can easily be shown @xcite , it conveys to the same oscillation probabilities as we have found .
a relevant and interesting case of the ( not that simple ) formula for p@xmath107 is the case where only two flavours participate in the oscillation .
the only - two - neutrino scenario is a rather rigorous description of a vast number of experiments .
lets assume then , that only two mass eigenstates , which we will name @xmath108 and @xmath109 , and two corresponding flavour states , which we will name @xmath26 and @xmath28 , are relevant .
there is then only one squared - mass splitting , @xmath110 .
even more , neglecting phase factors that can be proven to have no effect on oscillation , the mixing matrix @xmath22 takes the simple form @xmath111 the @xmath22 of eq .
( [ eq18 ] ) is just a 2@xmath1122 rotation matrix , and the rotation angle @xmath113 within it is referred to as the mixing angle . inserting the @xmath22 of eq .
( [ eq18 ] ) and the unique @xmath87 into the general expression for p@xmath107 , eq .
( [ eq15 ] ) , we immediately find that , for @xmath36 , when only two neutrinos are relevant , @xmath114 moreover , the survival probability , i.e. the probability that the neutrino remains with the same flavour its was created with is , as usual , unity minus the probability that it changes flavour .
when we create a beam of neutrinos on earth through an accelerator and send it up to thousand kilometres away to a meet detector , the beam does not move through vacuum , but through matter , earth matter .
the beam of neutrinos then scatters ( coherently forward ) from particles it meets along the way . such a scattering can have a large effect on the transition probabilities .
we will assume that neutrino interactions with matter are flavour conserving , as described by the standard model .
then a neutrino in matter have two possibilities to enjoy coherent forward scattering from matter particles .
first , if it is an electron neutrino , @xmath24and only in this case can exchange a @xmath7 boson with an electron .
neutrino - electron coherent forward scattering via @xmath7 exchange opens up an extra interaction potential energy @xmath115 suffered exclusively by electron neutrinos . obviously , this additional weak interaction energy has to be proportional to @xmath116 , the fermi coupling constant .
in addition , the interaction energy coming from @xmath117 scattering grows with @xmath118 , the number of electrons per unit volume . from the standard model
, we find that @xmath119 clearly , this interaction energy affects also antineutrinos ( in a opposite way though ) , it changes sign if we replace the @xmath24 by @xmath120 .
the second interaction corresponds to the case where a neutrino in matter exchanges a @xmath121 boson with an matter electron , proton , or neutron .
the standard model teaches us that weak interactions are flavour blind .
every flavour of neutrino enjoys them , and the amplitude for this @xmath121 exchange is always the same .
it also teaches us that , at zero momentum transfer , the @xmath121 couplings to electrons and protons have equal strength and opposite sign .
therefore , counting on the fact that the matter through which our neutrino moves is electrically neutral ( it contains equal number of electrons and protons ) , the electron and proton contribution to coherent forward neutrino scattering through @xmath121 exchange will add up to zero .
then , the effect of the @xmath121 exchange contribution to the interaction potential energy @xmath122 will be equal to all flavors and will depends exclusively on @xmath123 , the number density of neutrons . from the standard model
, we find that @xmath124 as was the case before , for @xmath115 , this contribution will flip sign if we replace the neutrinos by anti - neutrinos .
but we already learnt that standard model interactions do not change neutrino flavour . therefore , unless non - standard - model flavour changing interactions play a role , neutrino flavour transitions or neutrino oscillations points also to neutrino mass and mixing even when neutrinos are propagating through matter .
neutrino propagation in matter is easy to understand when analyzed through a time dependent schrdinger equation in the laboratory frame @xmath125 where , @xmath126 is a multicomponent neutrino vector state , in which each neutrino flavour corresponds to one component . in the same way ,
the hamiltonian @xmath127 is a matrix in flavour space . to make our lives easy ,
lets analyze the case where only two neutrino flavours are relevant , say @xmath24 and @xmath26 .
then @xmath128 where @xmath129 is the fraction of the neutrino that is a @xmath24 at time @xmath51 , and similarly for @xmath130 .
analogously , @xmath127 is a 2@xmath1122 matrix in @xmath131 space .
it will prove to be clarifying to work out the two flavour case in vacuum first , and add matter effects afterwards . using eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) for @xmath132 as a linear combination of mass eigenstates , we can see that the @xmath133 matrix element of the hamiltonian in vacuum , @xmath134 , can be written as @xmath135 where we are supposing that neutrino belongs to a beam where all its mass components ( the mass eigenstates ) share the same definite momentum @xmath136 .
( as we have already mentioned , this supposition is technically wrong , however it leads anyway to the right oscillation probability . ) in the second line of eq .
( [ eq24 ] ) , we have used that @xmath137 with @xmath138 the energy of the mass eigenstate @xmath139 with momentum @xmath136 , and the fact that the mass eigenstates of the hermitian hamiltonian @xmath134 constitute a basis and therefore are orthogonal .
as we have already mentioned , neutrino oscillations are the archetype quantum interference phenomenon , where only the _ relative _ phases of the interfering states play a role .
therefore , only the _ relative _ energies of these states , which set their relative phases , are relevant . as a consequence ,
if it proves to be convenient , we can feel free to happily remove from the hamiltonian @xmath127 any contribution proportional to the identity matrix @xmath140 .
as we have said , this substraction will leave unaffected the differences between the eigenvalues of @xmath127 , and therefore will leave unaffected the prediction of @xmath127 for flavour transitions .
it goes without saying that as in this case only two neutrinos are relevant , there are only two mass eigenstates , @xmath108 and @xmath109 , and only one mass splitting @xmath141 , and therefore the @xmath22 matrix is given by eq .
( [ eq18 ] ) . inserting this matrix into eq .
( [ eq24 ] ) , and applying the high momentum approximation @xmath142 , and removing from @xmath134 a term proportional to the the identity matrix ( a removal we know is going to be harmless ) , we get @xmath143 to write this expression , we have used that @xmath144 , where @xmath63 is the average energy of the neutrino mass eigenstates in our neutrino beam of ultra high momentum @xmath136 .
it is not difficult to corroborate that the hamiltonian @xmath134 of eq .
( [ eq25 ] ) for the two neutrino scenario would give an identical oscillation probability , eq .
( [ eq19 ] ) , as the one we have already obtained in a different way . for example , lets have a look at the oscillation probability for the process @xmath145 . from eq .
( [ eq18 ] ) it is clear that in terms of the mixing angle , the electron neutrino state composition is @xmath146 while that of the muon neutrino is given by @xmath147 now , the eigenvalues of @xmath134 , , read @xmath148 the eigenvectors of this hamiltonian , @xmath149 and @xmath150 , can also be written in terms of @xmath151 and @xmath152 by means of eqs .
( [ eq26 ] ) and ( [ eq27 ] ) .
therefore , with @xmath127 , its vacuum expression , @xmath134 of eq .
( [ eq25 ] ) , the schrdinger equation of eq .
( [ eq22 ] ) tells us that if at time @xmath153 we begin from a @xmath151 , then after some time @xmath51 this @xmath151 will progress into the state @xmath154 thus , the probability p@xmath155 that this evoluted neutrino be detected as a different flavour @xmath26 , from eqs .
( [ eq27 ] ) and ( [ eq29 ] ) , is given by , @xmath156 where we have substituted the time @xmath51 travelled by our highly relativistic state by the distance @xmath32 it has covered . the flavour transition or oscillation probability of eq .
( [ eq30 ] ) , as expected , is exactly the same we have found before , eq .
( [ eq19 ] ) .
we can now move on to analyze neutrino propagation in matter . in this case , the 2@xmath1122 vacuum hamiltonian @xmath134 receives two additional contributions and becomes @xmath157 , which is given by @xmath158 in the new hamiltonian , the first additional contribution corresponds to the interaction potential due to @xmath7 exchange , eq .
( [ eq20 ] ) . as this interaction
is suffered only by @xmath24 , this contribution is different from zero only in the upper left , @xmath159 , element of @xmath157 .
the second additional contribution , the last term of eq .
( [ eq31 ] ) comes from the interaction potential due to @xmath121 exchange , eq .
( [ eq21 ] ) .
since this interaction is flavour blind , it affects every neutrino flavour in the same way , its contribution to @xmath157 is proportional to the identity matrix , and can be safely neglected .
then @xmath160 where ( for reasons that are going to become clear later ) we have divided the @xmath7-exchange contribution into two pieces , one a multiple of the identity matrix ( that we will disregard in the next step ) and , a piece that it is not a multiple of the identity matrix . disregarding the first piece as promised , we have from eqs .
( [ eq25 ] ) and ( [ eq32 ] ) @xmath161 where @xmath162 clearly , @xmath163 shows the size ( the importance ) of the matter effects as compared to the neutrino squared - mass splitting and signal the situations when they become important .
now , if we define @xmath164 and @xmath165 @xmath157 can be given as @xmath166 that is , the hamiltonian in matter , @xmath157 , becomes formally identical to its vacuum counterpart , @xmath134 , eq . ( [ eq25 ] ) , except that the vacuum parameters @xmath87 and @xmath113 are now given by the matter ones , @xmath167 and @xmath168 , respectively . obviously , the eigenstates of @xmath157 are not identical to their vacuum counterparts .
the splitting between the squared masses of the matter eigenstates is not the same as the vacuum splitting @xmath87 , and the same happens with the mixing angle , the mixing in matter the angle that rotates from the @xmath169 basis , to the mass basis is different from the vacuum mixing angle @xmath113 .
clearly however , all the physics of neutrino propagation in matter is controlled by the matter hamiltonian @xmath157 . however , according to eq .
( [ eq37 ] ) , at least at the formal level , @xmath157 has the same functional dependence on the matter parameters @xmath167 and @xmath168 in as the vacuum hamiltonian @xmath134 , eq .
( [ eq25 ] ) , on the vacuum ones , @xmath87 and @xmath113 .
therefore , @xmath167 corresponds to the effective splitting between the squared masses of the eigenstates in matter , and @xmath168 corresponds to the effective mixing angle in matter . in a typical
experimental set - up where the neutrino beam is generated by an accelerator and sent away to a detector that is , say , several hundred , or even thousand kilometers away , it traverses through earth matter , but only superficially , it does not get deep into the earth . the matter density met by such a beam en voyage can be taken to be approximately constant .
therefore , the electron density @xmath118 is also constant , and the same happens with the parameter @xmath163 , and the matter hamiltonian @xmath157 .
they all become approximately position independent , and therefore quite analogue to the vacuum hamiltonian @xmath134 , which was absolutely position independent . comparing eqs .
( [ eq37 ] ) and ( [ eq25 ] ) , we can immediately conclude that since @xmath134 gives rise to the vacuum oscillation probability p@xmath155 of eq .
( [ eq30 ] ) , @xmath157 must give rise to a matter oscillation probability of the form @xmath170 that is , the oscillation probability in matter ( formally ) is the same as in vacuum , except that the vacuum parameters @xmath113 and @xmath87 are replaced by their matter counterparts . in theory
, judging simply its potential , matter effects can have very drastic effects . from eq .
( [ eq36 ] ) for the effective mixing angle in matter , @xmath168 , we can appreciate that even when the vacuum mixing angle @xmath113 is incredible small , say , @xmath171 , if we get to have @xmath172 , then @xmath173 can be brutally enhanced as compared to its vacuum value and can even reach its maximum possible value , one .
this brutal enhancement of a tiny mixing angle in vacuum up to a sizeable one in matter is the `` resonant '' version of the mikheyev - smirnov - wolfenstein effect @xcite . in the beginning of solar neutrino experiments
, people entertained the idea that this brutal enhancement was actually taking place inside the sun .
nonetheless , as we will see soon the solar neutrino mixing angle is quite sizeable ( @xmath174 ) already in vacuum @xcite .
then , although matter effects on the sun are important and they do enhance the solar mixing angle , unfortunately they are not as drastic as we once dreamt .
almost fifteen year have elapsed since we were presented convincing evidence of neutrino masses and mixings , and since then , the evidence has only grown .
superkamiokande ( sk ) was the first experiment to present compelling evidence of @xmath26 disappearance in their atmospheric neutrino fluxes , see @xcite . in fig .
[ f1 ] the zenith angle ( the angle subtended with the horizontal ) dependence of the multi - gev @xmath26 sample is shown together with the disappearance as a function of @xmath97 plot .
these data fit amazingly well the naive two component neutrino hypothesis with @xmath175 roughly speaking sk corresponds to an @xmath97 for oscillations of 500 km / gev and almost maximal mixing ( the mass eigenstates are nearly even admixtures of muon and tau neutrinos ) .
no signal of an involvement of the third flavour , @xmath24 is found so the assumption is that atmospheric neutrino disappearance is basically @xmath176 .
after atmospheric neutrino oscillations were established , two new experiments were built , sending ( man - made ) beams of @xmath26 neutrinos to detectors located at large distances : the k2k experiment @xcite , sends neutrinos from the kek accelerator complex to the old sk mine , with a baseline of 120 km while the minos experiment @xcite , sends its beam from fermilab , near chicago , to the soudan mine in minnesota , a baseline of 735 km .
both experiments have seen evidence for @xmath26 disappearance consistent with the one found by sk .
the results of both are summarised in fig .
[ f2 ] . vs @xmath177 plane for minos data as well as for k2k data and two of the sk analyses .
minos s best fit point is at @xmath178 and @xmath179 .
, width=340 ] the kamland reactor experiment , an antineutrino disappearance experiment , receiving neutrinos from sixteen different reactors , at distances ranging from hundred to thousand kilometers , with an average baseline of 180 km and neutrinos of a few ev , @xcite , has seen evidence of neutrino oscillations .
such evidence was collected not only at a different @xmath97 than the atmospheric and accelerator experiments but also consists on oscillations involving electron neutrinos , @xmath24 , the ones which were not involved before .
these oscillations have also been seen for neutrinos coming from the sun ( the sun produces only electron neutrinos ) . however , in order to compare the two experiments we should assume that neutrinos ( solar ) and antineutrinos ( reactor ) behave in the same way , i.e. assume cpt conservation .
the best fit values in the two neutrino scenario for the kamland experiment are @xmath180 in this case , the @xmath97 involved is 15 km / mev which is more than an order of magnitude larger than the atmospheric scale and the mixing angle , although large , is clearly not maximal .
[ f3 ] shows the disappearance probability for the @xmath181 for kamland as well as several older reactor experiments with shorter baselines.the second panel depicts the flavour content of the @xmath182boron solar neutrino flux ( with gev energies ) measured by sno , @xcite , and sk , @xcite
. the reactor outcome can be explained in terms of two flavour oscillations in vacuum , given that the fit to the disappearance probability , is appropriately averaged over @xmath63 and @xmath32 .
observed by reactor experiments as a function of distance from the reactor .
the flavour content of the @xmath183boron solar neutrinos for the various reactions for sno and sk .
cc : @xmath184 , nc:@xmath185 and es : @xmath186 .
, title="fig:",width=226 ] observed by reactor experiments as a function of distance from the reactor .
the flavour content of the @xmath183boron solar neutrinos for the various reactions for sno and sk .
cc : @xmath184 , nc:@xmath185 and es : @xmath186 . ,
title="fig:",width=226 ] the analysis of neutrinos coming from the sun is slightly more sophisticated because it should include the matter effects that the neutrinos suffer since they are born ( at the centre of the sun ) until they leave it , which are important at least for the @xmath182boron neutrinos .
the pp and @xmath187be neutrinos are less energetic and therefore are not significantly altered by the presence of matter and leave the sun as if it where ethereal .
@xmath182boron neutrinos on the other hand , leave the sun strongly affected by the presence of matter and this is evidenced by the fact that they leave the sun as the @xmath109 mass eigenstate and therefore do not undergo oscillations .
this difference is , as mentioned , due mainly to their differences at birth .
while pp ( @xmath187be ) neutrinos are created with an average energy of 0.2 mev ( 0.9 mev ) , @xmath182b are born with 10 mev and as we have seen the impact of matter effects grows with the energy of the neutrino .
however , we should stress that we do not really see solar neutrino oscillations . to trace the oscillation pattern ,
we need a kinematic phase of order one . in the case of neutrinos coming from the sun
the kinematic phase is @xmath188 therefore , solar neutrinos behave as `` effectively incoherent '' mass eigenstates once they leave the sun , and remains being so once they reach the earth . consequently the @xmath24 survival probability is given by @xmath189 where @xmath190 is the @xmath108 content or fraction of @xmath26 and @xmath191 is the @xmath109 content of @xmath26 and therefore both fractions satisfy @xmath192 however , as we have mentioned , pp and @xmath187be solar neutrinos are not affected by the solar matter and oscillate as in vacuum and thus , in their case @xmath193 and @xmath194 . in the @xmath182b a neutrino case , however , matter effects are important and the corresponding fractions are substantially altered , see fig .
[ f4 ] . in the core but
once they exit the sun thinking about them in the mass eigenstate basis is useful .
the fraction of @xmath108 and @xmath109 is energy dependent above 1 mev and has a dramatic effect on the @xmath182boron solar neutrinos , as first observed by davis.,title="fig:",width=264 ] in the core but once they exit the sun thinking about them in the mass eigenstate basis is useful .
the fraction of @xmath108 and @xmath109 is energy dependent above 1 mev and has a dramatic effect on the @xmath182boron solar neutrinos , as first observed by davis.,title="fig:",width=264 ] in a two neutrino scenario , the day - time cc / nc measured by sno , which is roughly identical to the day - time average @xmath24 survival probability , @xmath195 , reads @xmath196 where @xmath190 and @xmath197 are the @xmath108 and @xmath109 contents of the muon neutrino , respectively , averaged over the @xmath182b neutrino energy spectrum appropriately weighted with the charged current current cross section .
therefore , the @xmath108 fraction ( or how much @xmath191 differs from 100% ) is given by @xmath198 where the central values of the last sno analysis , @xcite , were used .
as there are strong correlations between the uncertainties of the cc / nc ratio and @xmath199 it is not obvious how to estimate the uncertainty on @xmath190 from their analysis .
note , that if the fraction of @xmath109 were 100% , then @xmath200 . using the analytical analysis of the mikheyev - smirnov - wolfenstein ( msw ) effect , provided in @xcite
, one can obtain the mass eigenstate fractions , which are given by @xmath201 with @xmath202 being the mixing angle as given at the @xmath24 production point and @xmath203 is the probability of the neutrino to hop from one mass eigenstate to the second one during the mikheyev - smirnov resonance crossing .
the average @xmath204 is over the electron density of the @xmath182b @xmath24 production region in the centre of the sun as given by the solar standard model and the energy spectrum of @xmath182b neutrinos appropriately weighted with sno s charged current cross section .
all in all , the @xmath182b energy weighted average content of @xmath109 s measured by sno is @xmath205 therefore , it is obvious that the @xmath182b solar neutrinos are the purest mass eigenstate neutrino beam known so far and sk super famous picture of the sun taken ( underground ) with neutrinos is made with approximately 90% of @xmath109 .
on march 8 , 2012 a newly built reactor neutrino experiment , the daya bay experiment , located in china , announced the measurement of the third mixing angle @xcite , the only one which was still missing and found it to be @xmath206 the fact that this angle , although smaller that the other two , is still sizeable opens the door to a new generation of neutrino experiments aiming to answer the open questions in the field .
now that we have understood the physics behind neutrinos oscillations and have learnt the experimental evidence about the parameters driving this oscillations , we can move ahead and construct the neutrino standard model : * it consists of three light ( @xmath5 @xmath208 1 ev ) neutrinos , i.e. it involves only two mass differences + @xmath209 and @xmath210 .
* so far we have not seen any experimental indication ( or need ) for additional neutrinos . as we have measured
long time ago the invisible width of the @xmath121 boson and found it to be 3 , if new neutrinos are going to be incorporated into the model , they can not couple to the @xmath121 boson , they can not enjoy weak interactions , so we call them sterile .
however , as sterile neutrinos have not been seen , and are not needed , our neutrino standard model will contain only the three active flavours : @xmath25 , @xmath37 and @xmath9 .
+ ) .if cpt is conserved , the flavour content must be the same for neutrinos and anti - neutrinos .
notice that oscillation experiments can not tell us how far above zero the entire spectrum lies.,width=377 ] * the unitary mixing matrix , called the pmns matrix , which describes the relation between flavour eigenstates and mass eigenstates , comprises three mixing angles ( the so called solar mixing angle:@xmath211 , the atmospheric mixing angle @xmath212 , and the recently measured reactor mixing angle@xmath213 ) , one dirac phase ( @xmath214 ) and possibly two majorana phases ( @xmath23 , @xmath215 ) and is given by @xmath216 @xmath217 where @xmath218 and @xmath219 .
thanks to the hierarchy in mass differences ( and to a less extent the smallness of the reactor mixing angle ) we are allowed to identify the ( 23 ) label in the three neutrino scenario with the atmospheric @xmath220 we obtained in the two neutrino scenario , identically the ( 12 ) label can be assimilated to the solar @xmath221 .
the ( 13 ) sector drives the @xmath24 flavour oscillations at the atmospheric scale , and the depletion in reactor neutrino fluxes see @xcite . therefore , @xmath222 and the mass splittings are @xmath223 these mixing angles and mass splittings are summarised in fig .
the absolute mass scale of the neutrinos , or the mass of the lightest neutrino is not know yet , but the heaviest one must be lighter than about .5 ev . * as transition or survival
probabilities depend on the combination @xmath224 no trace of the majorana phases could appear on oscillation phenomena , however they can have observable effects in those processes where the majorana character of the neutrino is essential for the process to happen , like neutrino - less double beta decay .
the absolute mass scale of the neutrino can not be obtained in oscillation experiments , however this does not mean we can not have it . direct experiments like tritium beta decay , or neutrinoless double beta decay and indirect ones , like cosmological observations ,
have potential to feed us the information on the absolute scale of neutrino mass , we so desperately need .
the katrin tritium beta decay experiment , @xcite , has sensitivity down to 200 mev for the `` mass '' of @xmath24 defined as @xmath225 decay , in cosmology and in tritium @xmath215 decay versus the mass of the lightest neutrino .
below the dashed lines , only the normal hierarchy is allowed.,title="fig:",width=264 ] decay , in cosmology and in tritium @xmath215 decay versus the mass of the lightest neutrino . below the dashed lines ,
only the normal hierarchy is allowed.,title="fig:",width=14 ] neutrino - less double beta decay experiments , see @xcite for a review , do not measure the absolute mass of the neutrino directly but a combination of neutrino masses and mixings , @xmath226 where it is understood that neutrinos are taken to be majorana particles .
the new generation of experiments seeks to reach below 10 mev for @xmath227 in double beta decay .
cosmological probes measure the sum of the neutrino masses , @xmath228 if @xmath229 ev , the energy balance of the universe saturates the bound coming from its critical density . the current limit ,
@xcite , is a few % of this number , @xmath230 ev .
these bounds are model dependent but they do all give numbers of the same order of magnitude .
however , given the systematic uncertainties characteristic of cosmology , a solid limit of less that 100 mev seems way too aggressive .
[ f6 ] shows the allowed parameter space for the neutrino masses ( as a function of the absolute scale ) for both the normal and inverted hierarchy .
a fermion mass is nothing but a coupling between a left handed state and a right handed one .
thus , if we examine a massive fermion at rest , then one can regards this state as a linear combination of two massless particles , one right handed and one left handed particle .
if the particle we are examining is electrically charged , like an electron , both particles , the left handed as well as the right handed must have the same charge ( we want the mass term to be electrically neutral ) .
this is a dirac mass term .
however , for a neutral particle , like a sterile neutrino , a new possibility opens up , the left handed particle can be coupled to the right handed anti - particle , ( a term which would have a net charge , if the fields are not absolutely and totally neutral ) this is a majorana mass term .
thus a neutral particle does have two ways of getting a mass term , a la dirac or a la majorana , and in principle can have them both , as shown : [ f7 ] in the case of a neutrino , the left chiral field couples to @xmath231 implying that a majorana mass term is forbidden by gauge symmetry
. however , the right chiral field carries no quantum numbers , is totally and absolutely neutral .
then , the majorana mass term is unprotected by any symmetry and it is expected to be very large , of the order of the largest scale in the theory . on the other hand , dirac mass terms
are expected to be of the order of the electroweak scale times a yukawa coupling , giving a mass of the order of magnitude of the charged lepton or quark masses .
putting all the pieces together , the mass matrix for the neutrinos results as in fig . [ f8 ] .
is the dirac mass terms while 0 and @xmath232 are majorana masses for the charged and uncharged ( under @xmath233 ) chiral components.,width=264 ] to get the mass eigenstates we need to diagonalise the neutrino mass matrix . by doing so ,
one is left with two majorana neutrinos , one super - heavy majorana neutrino with mass @xmath234 and one light majorana neutrino with mass @xmath235 , i.e. one mass goes up while the other sinks , this is what we call the seesaw mechanism , @xcite . the light neutrino(s )
is(are ) the one(s ) observed in current experiments ( its mass differences ) while the heavy neutrino(s ) are not accessible to current experiments and could be responsible for explaining the baryon asymmetry of the universe through the generation of a lepton asymmetry at very high energy scales since its decays can in principle be cp violating ( they depend on the two majorana phases on the pnms matrix which are invisible for oscillations ) . if neutrinos are majorana particles lepton number is no longer a good quantum number and a plethora of new processes forbidden by lepton number conservation can take place , it is not only neutrino - less double beta decay .
for example , a muon neutrino can produce a positively charged muon .
however , this process and any processes of this kind , would be suppressed by @xmath236 which is tiny , @xmath237 , and therefore , although they are technically allowed , are experimentally unobservable .
the experimental observations of neutrino oscillations , meaning that neutrinos have mass and mix , answered questions that had endured since the establishment of the standard model .
as those veils have disappeared , new questions open up and challenge our understanding : * what is the nature of the neutrino ? are they majorana or dirac ?
are neutrinos totally neutral ?
* is the spectrum normal or inverted ? * is cp violated ( is @xmath238 ) ? * which is the absolute mass scale of the neutrinos ? * are there new interactions ?
* can neutrinos violate cpt @xcite ? * are these intriguing signals in short baseline reactor neutrino experiments ( the missing fluxes ) a real effect ?
do they imply the existence of sterile neutrinos ?
we would like to answer these questions . for doing it , we are doing right now , and we plan to do new experiments .
these experiments will , for sure bring some answers and clearly open new , pressing questions .
only one thing is clear .
our journey into the neutrino world is just beginning .
i would like to thank the students and the organisers of the european school on hep for giving me the opportunity to present these lectures in such a wonderful atmosphere .
i did enjoy each day of the school enormously .
an analysis of cpt violation in the neutrino sector can be found in : g. barenboim and j. d. lykken , phys .
b * 554 * ( 2003 ) 73 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0210411 ] ; g. barenboim , j. f. beacom , l. borissov and b. kayser , phys .
b * 537 * ( 2002 ) 227 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0203261 ] .
s. p. mikheev and a. y. smirnov ,
neutrino oscillations in a variable - density medium and @xmath239 bursts due sov .
jetp * 64 * , 4 ( 1986 ) [ zh . eksp
. teor .
fiz . * 91 * , 7 ( 1986 ) ] [ arxiv:0706.0454 [ hep - ph ] ] .
y. ashie _ et al . _
[ super - kamiokande collaboration ] , a measurement of atmospheric neutrino oscillation parameters by phys .
d * 71 * , 112005 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0501064 ] ; y. takeuchi [ super - kamiokande collaboration ] , arxiv:1112.3425 [ hep - ex ] .
s. fukuda _ et al .
_ [ super - kamiokande collaboration ] , determination of solar neutrino oscillation parameters using 1496 days of phys . lett .
b * 539 * , 179 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0205075 ] .
s. j. parke and t. p. walker , phys .
lett . * 57 * , 2322 ( 1986 ) [ erratum - ibid . *
57 * , 3124 ( 1986 ) ] . | the standard model has been incredibly successful in predicting the outcome of almost all the experiments done up so far . in it
, neutrinos are mass - less . however , in recent years we have accumulated evidence pointing to tiny masses for the neutrinos ( as compared to the charged leptons ) .
these masses allow neutrinos to change their flavour and oscillate . in these lectures
i review the properties of neutrinos in and beyond the standard model . |
the fenice data @xcite , on the reaction close to threshold , together with earlier analogous measurements for the proton @xcite-@xcite indicate that at threshold . in other words ,
the timelike form factors of the neutron and the proton are approximately equal at @xmath1 .
this is a very surprizing and puzzling result and it is hard to understand in the conventional perturbative picture of baryon - antibaryon production in @xmath0 annihilation , as shown in fig .
[ ee - fig ] .
.,width=321 ] in the naive perturbative description of the @xmath0 annihilation into baryons , the virtual timelike photon first makes a primary " @xmath2 pair , which then dresses up " with two additional quark - antiquark pairs which pop up from the vacuum .
the dressing up " is a qcd process , which does not distinguish between @xmath3 and @xmath4 quarks , since gluon couplings are flavor - blind .
thus in the conventional picture the only difference between proton and neutron is through the different electric charge of the primary @xmath2 pair .
the total perturbative cross - section @xmath5 at a given _ cm _ energy is obtained by superposing the amplitudes with different flavors @xmath6 in the primary @xmath2 pair and squaring the result , @xmath7 where @xmath8 denotes the amplitude at @xmath9 for making the baryon @xmath10 with a given the primary flavor @xmath6 .
these amplitudes are determined by the baryon wavefunctions . since the wave functions of the baryon octet have a mixed symmetry , the amplitudes @xmath8 tend to be highly asymmetric .
thus for example in the chernyak - zhitnitsky proton wave function @xcite the @xmath3 quark dominates , i.e. @xmath11 , @xmath12 and similarly @xmath13 , @xmath14 .
in such a limiting case we have @xmath15 while this is an extreme case , on general grounds we expect that @xmath3 dominates in the proton and @xmath4 in the neutron , so @xmath16 , intuitively one can understand this perturbative result directly from fig .
[ ee - fig ] , by recalling that the average charge squared of quarks in the proton is higher than in the neutron .
thus the naive perturbation theory clearly disagrees with the experimental result @xcite . as the first step , one has to realize that we are dealing with a highly nonperturbative process .
even though the are measured at a momentum transfer which is much higher than @xmath17 , , we are very far from the perturbative regime .
the reason is that all the available energy is very quickly divided among the quarks and antiquarks in the @xmath18 system .
since the total available energy is very close to the rest mass of the @xmath18 system , none of the quarks has any spare " momentum .
there have been several attempts to explain the fenice data by various theoretical proposals utilizing specific nonperturbative mechanisms ( for a recent report on some of this work see ref .
@xcite ) , but to the best of my knowledge , so far there is no satisfactory explanation in terms of conventional mechanisms or their straightforward extensions .
the lack of such a conventional theoretical explanation is part of the motivation for the proposed new asymmetrical @xmath19 high - statistics collider at slac for the regime @xmath20 gev @xcite .
this machine will yield high - precision data on baryon production in @xmath19 annihilation at threshold , providing a check on the fenice data and an accurate benchmark for testing possible theoretical explanations . in this context
it is amusing to note the perturbation theory predictions for the @xmath21 baryon resonance multiplet production in @xmath0 near threshold .
since the @xmath21 has a totally symmetric wave function , the corresponding amplitudes are equal , @xmath22 , for all 4 members of the multiplet , @xmath23 .
thus perturbation theory makes a striking prediction for the neutral member of the multiplet , @xmath24 more generally , the relative yields predicted by perturbation theory are @xmath25
the fenice puzzle is reinforced by the cleo data on baryon - antibaryon production in photon - photon collisions @xcite , as shown in fig .
[ cleo - gg - fig ] ( see also @xcite and @xcite for related experimental work ) .
cleo has compared the @xmath27 cross - sections for @xmath28 and @xmath29 production and they find that close to threshold .
this is quite similar to the fenice puzzle for the @xmath30 ratio . the naive perturbative description of the baryon - production in the photon - photon reaction is given by the feynman diagram in fig . [ gg - fig ] . since there are two photons here , instead of one in fig
[ ee - fig ] , for each flavor of the primary @xmath31 pair the corresponding amplitude scales like the quark charge squared , to be compared with linear dependence of the amplitudes on the quark charge in the @xmath0 case .
thus one would naively expect the ratio @xmath32 to be even larger than the corresponding perturbative prediction for @xmath33 in @xmath0 .
.,width=188 ] the disagreement between the naive theoretical prediction and experiment is striking again . just like in the fenice case , despite several , there is no satisfactory theoretical explanation for this cleo data ( for example , see @xcite for a recent theoretical analysis of @xmath34 in terms of di - quarks ) .
it would be highly interesting to see the data for @xmath35 close to threshold , but such analysis has not yet been done due to some technical difficulties @xcite .
as will be clear from the following discussion , close to threshold we expect the @xmath35 cross - section be the same as @xmath36 .
we urge our experimental colleagues to carry out such an analysis .
the perturbative ratios are even more dramatic for the rates for @xmath37 , which are proportional to the fourth power of the @xmath21 electric charge , if one has symmetric wavefunctions .
thus for @xmath38 near threshold , the analogue of eq .
[ dyieldspt ] is @xmath39 as we shall discuss in more detail in the following section , the mechanism we propose for this type of reactions predicts a completely different result .
in view of these fenice and cleo puzzles , we have proposed @xcite a novel mechanism which might explain the data .
the essential new point in the proposed is that it is a two - stage process , with a coherent state of pions serving as an intermediary between @xmath0 and the baryon - antibaryon system , as shown schematically in fig .
[ pions - fig ] . as a two - stage process , where @xmath0 annihilate into a timelike photon which first couples to an intermediate pion state , which then produces the @xmath18 pair.,width=302 ] we propose to use the skyrme model as a concrete computational framework for a quantitative description of the baryon - antibaryon dynamics . in the skyrme model
@xcite,@xcite baryons appear as solitons in a purely bosonic chiral lagrangian .
the model is formally justified as a low - energy approximation to large-@xmath40 qcd @xcite , @xcite .
it is known to provide a good description of many low - energy properties of baryons ( see @xcite and @xcite for a review ) .
it turns out that it is also possible to obtain a fairly accurate description of low - energy baryon - antibaryon annihilation in terms of skyrmion - antiskyrmion annihilation @xcite-@xcite . instead of asking how a @xmath29 or @xmath41 configuration is formed by a virtual timelike photon , or by two photons ,
it is conceptually easier to consider the reverse processes , i.e. or , as shown schematically in fig .
[ pions1-fig ] , and the analogous processes for two photons .
, i.e. @xmath42 as a two - stage process , where the nucleons first annihilate into pions , which then couple to a a timelike photon to produce the @xmath0 pair.,width=302 ] it is interesting to note that it has been argued @xcite that in perturbation theory the production of extended , such as a soliton - antisoliton configuration , by pointlike particles , such as in @xmath0 annihilation , is suppressed by a large exponential factor @xmath43 .
thus the fact that the reaction @xmath44 has been measured with a small , but finite cross - section is yet another indication of the nonperturbative nature of the process . following the pioneering numerical work of refs .
@xcite and @xcite , we now have the following picture of the @xmath45 annihilation at rest as a skyrmion anti - skyrmion annihilation : just after the skyrmion and anti - skyrmion touch , they unravel " each other , and a classical pion wave emerges as a coherent burst and takes away energy and baryon number as quickly as causality permits .
this observation led the authors of ref .
@xcite to suggest the following simplified version of @xmath45 annihilation at rest .
after a very fast annihilation a spherically symmetric `` blob '' of pionic matter of size @xmath46 fm , baryon number zero and the total energy twice the nucleon rest mass is formed .
the further evolution of the system and the branching rates of various channels are completely determined by the parameters of this `` blob '' . for a very crude toy model of what is going on ,
let s assume that @xmath29 annihilate into two pions which then go to @xmath0 via a timelike photon , @xmath47 clearly , the real process involves an intermediate state with a a much larger number of pions on the average , but two pions are sufficient to understand why within this physical picture we expect the @xmath48 rate to be the same as the @xmath49 rate rate .
the basic argument is that since we have a two - stage process , the crucial issue is the rate @xmath50 vs. the rate @xmath51 . since this is a purely strong interaction process , we expect the two rates to be equal .
the next step is @xmath52 which of does not care whether the pions were produced by @xmath29 or @xmath41 annihilation .
clearly if @xmath53 has the same cross - section as @xmath54 , the same will apply to the reverse processes .
it is tempting to assume that a similar argument can be made for @xmath55 vs. @xmath56 , although one expects the corresponding analysis to be more difficult , as one will have @xmath57 in the intermediate state .
we should stress that the two pion intermediate state is used here only as an illustration . in practice
the two pion channel is very small and most difficult to treat within the approach of ref .
@xcite , since the semiclassical approximation is best suited for coherent states .
a similar comment applies to a possible calculation of @xmath18 annihilation into two photons @xcite .
in addition to the @xmath58 , one can also carry out an analogous analysis for @xmath59 .
the relative yields of @xmath60 and @xmath61 will be determined by the relevant clebsch - gordan coefficients @xcite and by the corresponding reduced matrix elements for isospin 1 and 0 .
we do not know the precise values of these reduced matrix elements , but even without this information , from the clebsch - gordan decomposition we expect @xmath62 as opposed to the perturbative prediction ( [ dyieldspt ] ) .
( [ brratios ] ) hold also for @xmath63 , since @xmath64 , etc .
, to be contrasted with the perturbative prediction ( [ ggdyieldspt ] ) . it would be very interesting to put this to an experimental test !
it is not enough to propose a mechanism which can explain the equality of the observed @xmath29 and @xmath41 rates .
we also have to explain why the proposed mechanism dominates over the standard one .
after all , the reaction can in principle still proceed via the usual naive perturbative mechanism , where quarks couple directly to the virtual photon , like in fig .
[ ee - fig ] , and where the @xmath65 thus a crucial question is why @xmath53 or @xmath53 proceed via intermediate hadronic states , rather than via direct em annihilation . in order to answer this question , it is helpful to consider the relevant time scales . consider @xmath29 on top of each other at rest .
the qcd annihilation occurs at a typical time scale of strong interactions , i.e. @xmath66 sec .
this is much shorter than a typical time scale for em interactions , so that the direct " qed process , where @xmath2 in the @xmath29 annihilate into a virtual photon simply has no chance of occurring : qed here is a johnny come lately " who can not compete with the qcd rate .
qed enters only at the second stage , where the mesonic soup " has a ( small ) chance of going into a virtual photon .
but here we are concerned with the _ relative _ rate of @xmath29 vs. @xmath41 , so the overall smallness of the qed process @xmath67 is not a priori a problem .
the two - pion intermediate state is of course only a toy model which is helpful in understanding the qualitative features of the reaction . in order to obtain a more more realistic description ,
we need to put in a more realistic intermediate state .
the first improvement would be to include intermediate states with @xmath68 pions , where @xmath68 goes over all allowed values , @xmath69 in principle one could compute the @xmath70 rates using the methods of ref .
it is not clear how to obtain the relative phases for different values of @xmath68 , but if one of the intermediate states dominates , this problem will not be of practical significance
. a more sophisticated treatment will involve summing over all allowed intermediate states , not just the @xmath68-@xmath71 . in principle
this could be done by combining the low - energy @xmath72 data with the corresponding data for @xmath73 annihilation at rest .
one would then sum them channel by channel .
there are very precise data from lear for @xmath73 annihilation a rest and there are also good data for @xmath72 .
recently the vepp-2 m collider at novosibirsk provided highly accurate @xmath0 data for @xmath74 gev @xcite , with excellent finite state resolution , as shown in fig .
[ vepp - fig ] .
this energy range is below what we need , but it shows the expected richness of the data . if similar data can be obtained for @xmath75 gev , they could be combined with the lear data to provide an estimate of the @xmath76 rate through our mechanism . again , one remaining difficulty is the issue of relative phases , but as already mentioned , if the intermediate state is dominated but one particular channel , the phase issue will not be of practical significance .
clearly , what is presented here is merely a sketch of the proposed calculation , and in order to convince oneself that it correctly describes the physics , one should actually put in the rates for the relevant intermediate processes , in order to provide a theoretical estimate which can be compared with the measured rate for @xmath77 or @xmath78 .
the work described in this talk was carried out in collaboration with stan brodsky .
we are grateful to rinaldo baldini for many discussions of the fenice data .
we also wish to thank ralph amado , alexander bondar and hans p. paar for communicating and their results with us .
this research was supported in part by a grant from the united states - israel binational science foundation ( bsf ) , jerusalem , israel , and by the basic research foundation administered by the israel academy of sciences and humanities .
d. bisello _ et al . _
[ dm2 collaboration ] , z. phys .
c * 48 * , 23 ( 1990 ) .
v. l. chernyak and a. r. zhitnitsky , phys .
rept . * 112 * , 173 ( 1984 ) .
s. anderson _
[ cleo collaboration ] , phys .
d * 56 * , 2485 ( 1997 ) [ hep - ex/9701013 ] . h. w. hammer , _
`` nucleon form factors in the space- and time - like regions , '' _ hep - ph/0105337 , these _
proceedings_. letter of intent for the proposal for the new asymmetrical @xmath19 collider for the regime @xmath20 gev , http://www.slac.stanford.edu/grp/rd/epac/loi/ .
t. h. skyrme , proc .
a * 260 * ( 1961 ) 127 .
t. h. skyrme , nucl .
* 31 * ( 1962 ) 556 .
e. witten , nucl .
b * 160 * , 57 ( 1979 ) .
g. s. adkins , c. r. nappi and e. witten , nucl .
b * 228 * , 552 ( 1983 ) .
i. zahed and g. e. brown , phys .
* 142 * , 1 ( 1986 ) .
j. schechter and h. weigel , hep - ph/9907554 .
j. j. verbaarschot , t. s. walhout , j. wambach and h. w. wyld , nucl .
a * 461 * , 603 ( 1987 ) .
h. m. sommermann , r. seki , s. larson and s. e. koonin , phys .
d * 45 * , 4303 ( 1992 ) .
a. k. drukier and s. nussinov , phys .
lett . * 49 * , 102 ( 1982 ) .
see e.g. http://www-pdg.lbl.gov/2000/clebrpp.ps in d. e. groom _ et al .
_ [ particle data group collab . ] , eur .
j. c * 15 * , 1 ( 2000 ) .
a. bondar , private communication ; see also scanned transparencies from a talk by a. bondar at ichep-2000 in osaka , http://ichep2000.hep.sci.osaka-u.ac.jp/scan/0728/pa01/bondar/index.html | we sketch some recent ideas proposed as the behind the puzzling experimental results on baryon - antibaryon production in @xmath0 annihilation close to threshold . the essential new point in the proposed
is that it is a two - stage process , with a coherent state of pions serving as an intermediary between @xmath0 and the baryon - antibaryon system .
skyrmion - antiskyrmion annihilation is proposed as a concrete computational framework for a quantitative description of the baryon - antibaryon annihilation .
we also point out the possible connection to similarly puzzling data on baryon - antibaryon production in photon - photon collision . |
an important goal in study of quantum spin systems is the search for novel phases emerging from competing interactions between particles .
low dimensional quantum spin systems typically exhibit strongly correlated effects which drive them toward new regimes with no classical analog .
many properties of the systems in these regimes or `` quantum phases '' can be understood if we explore their ground state and low - lying excitations .
therefore a significant fraction of current research on such systems has focussed on understanding of frustrated systems , which exhibits a variety of exotic quantum states@xcite . in particular , the frustrated spin chains are described by competing interactions between the nearest - neighbor ( @xmath0 ) and next - nearest - neighbor ( @xmath1 ) interactions .
the hamiltonian of the model is given by @xmath2 , \label{j1-j2}\ ] ] where @xmath3 represents the @xmath4 operator at @xmath5-th site of the chain .
the model with both antiferromagnetic interactions @xmath6 is well studied @xcite . also the model ( [ j1-j2 ] ) with ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic interactions ( @xmath7 ) ( frustrated ferromagnetic model )
has been a subject of many studies @xcite .
it is known that the ground state is ferromagnetic for @xmath8 . at @xmath9 the ferromagnetic state
is degenerate with a singlet state .
the wave function of this singlet state is exactly known @xcite . for @xmath10 ,
the ground state is an incommensurate singlet .
it has been long believed that at @xmath10 the model is gapless@xcite but the one - loop renormalization group analysis indicates@xcite that the gap opens to a lorentz symmetry breaking perturbation .
however , existence of the energy gap has not been yet verified numerically@xcite .
using field theory considerations it has been proposed@xcite that a very tiny but finite gap exists which can be hardly observed by numerical techniques . in vicinity of @xmath11 ,
the singlet ground state energy behaves as @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is a critical exponent . using variational approaches@xcite
, it has been shown that the quantum fluctuations definitely change the classical critical exponent@xcite and yields @xmath14 which has been confirmed numerically@xcite . beside a general interest in understanding _
frustrations _ and phase transitions in the model systems described by the hamiltonian in eq(1 ) , it helps people to understand intriguing magnetic properties of a novel class of edge - sharing copper oxides , described by the f - af frustrated model@xcite .
recently some novel magnetic properties were discovered in a variety of quasi - one dimensional materials that are known to belong to the class of dzyaloshinskii - moriya ( dm ) @xmath15 magnet to explain helical magnetic structures .
the relevance of antisymmetric superexchange interactions in spin hamiltonians which describe quantum antiferromagnetic systems was introduced phenomenologically by dzyaloshinskii@xcite .
moriya showed later , that such interactions arise naturally in the perturbation theory due to the spin - orbit coupling in magnetic systems with low symmetry@xcite .
some multiferroics cuprates , such as @xmath16@xcite , @xmath17@xcite and @xmath18 , are expected to be described by dm interaction .
this has stimulated extensive investigations of various properties which are created by the dm interaction .
however , it is difficult to handle the dm interaction _ analytically _ and interpret experimental data . a numerical analysis then helps us to understand experimental observation and even expand our knowledge about many interesting quantum phenomena of low - dimensional quantum magnets . in the present work ,
we address a different problem in the subject of the frustrated ferromagnetic spin-1/2 chains .
we consider the 1d spin-1/2 frustrated ferromagnetic model with added dm interaction and study the classical and quantum magnetic ground state phase diagram of the system .
the outline of the paper is as follows . in the next section
the classical cluster method will be outlined and phases will be obtained . in section
iii we present our numerical results of the exact diagonalization calculations on the ground state properties of the model . in section iv
, the entanglement between different spins will be investigated by calculating the concurrence function .
finally we conclude and summarize our results in section v.
the hamiltonian of the 1d spin-1/2 frustrated ferromagnetic model in presence of a uniform dm interaction is defined as @xmath19 , \label{j1-j2-dm}\ ] ] where @xmath20 .
this hamiltonian shows a model with fully broken spin rotational symmetry .
it is useful to begin with simple classical considerations that shed light on the possible ground state of the fully quantum mechanical problem .
when @xmath21 is large , it is adequate to substitute @xmath22 in eq .
( [ j1-j2-dm ] ) and find solutions that satisfy @xmath23 and @xmath24 for all @xmath5 .
but , here we use the rather unknown cluster method@xcite of lyons and kaplan ( lk method ) .
briefly recall that method with assuming periodic boundary condition
. then we can easily see that eq .
( [ j1-j2-dm ] ) can be rewritten as : @xmath25 where the `` cluster energy '' involve three neighboring spins is @xmath26 it is clear that @xmath27 so easily one can find the minimum of @xmath28 . if the corresponding state propagates , i.e. if there is a state of the whole system such that every set of three successive spins gives the minimum @xmath28 , then according to eq .
( [ cluster-3 ] ) , this state will be a ground state of the hamiltonian .
this is the main idea of the lk cluster method as applied to the present problem .
this method has also been applied for models with higher dimensions or with open boundary conditions@xcite .
now let s minimize @xmath28 .
because the dm vector is selected along the @xmath29 axis , we consider only coplanar ( spin dimensionality d=2 , i.e. xy spins ) state . without loss of generality label the angles made by the end spins with the central spin @xmath30 , @xmath31 ( fig.[schematic ] ) .
so the cluster energy is became @xmath32 where @xmath33 .
differentiating gives the conditions for stationarity @xmath34 before going through the eq .
( [ cluster-4 ] ) , we check two simplified cases as follow .
+ * first case * : we have put @xmath35 and the frustrated ferromagnetic heisenberg model recovered which well studied numerically and analytically . in this case , solutions are : @xmath36 the @xmath37 solution , which leads to the ordinary antiferromagnetic state , is never lowest because we have assumed @xmath38 .
the @xmath39 solution obviously propagates as the ferromagnetic state .
the solutions @xmath40 , @xmath41,i.e .
@xmath42 , @xmath43 plus their degenerate reversed spin counterparts can easily be seen to propagate in the up - up - down - down state@xcite .
we listed the energies for the various stationary solutions : @xmath44 by equating these energies in pairs we found only one critical point , @xmath45 .
the ground state is in the ferromagnetic phase for @xmath46 and is in the chiral phase for @xmath47 . + * second case * : we have put @xmath48 ( or @xmath49 ) which means we have just 1d isotropic ferromagnetic heisenberg model plus a uniform dm interaction . in this case there is only one solution : @xmath50 which means that immediately after turning on the dm interaction , the long range chiral order is created in the classical ground state phase diagram . in principle , as soon as the dm interaction is applied , the ground state of the system undergoes a phase transition from the ferromagnetic phase into a chiral phase .
it is better to emphasis that the induced effects of quantum fluctuations on the 1d antiferromagnetic heisenberg model with dm interaction had been studied theoretically and experimentally@xcite . from quantum point of view
, it has been found that the dm interaction induces the chiral phase which remains stable even in presence of a uniform magnetic field@xcite . +
* third case * : now we consider the 1d frustrated ferromagnetic model with dm interaction .
the solutions for general equations ( [ cluster-4 ] ) are @xmath51 these results show , the ferromagnetic and up - up - down - down orders exist only in the absence of the dm interaction .
as soon as the dm interaction increases from zero , the ground state of the system goes to the chiral phase , independent of the frustrated parameter @xmath52 ( fig.[classical ] ) .
thus , using the cluster lk method , the classical ground state phase diagram of the 1d spin-1/2 frustrated ferromagnetic model with added uniform dm interaction consists of a single phase : `` chiral '' .
in this section , to explore the nature of the spectrum and the quantum phase transition , we used the lanczos method to diagonalize numerically chains with length up to @xmath53 .
first , in different subspaces we have computed the ground state energy of chains with @xmath54 and different values of the dm interaction as a function of the parameter @xmath52 .
the setting of boundary conditions and observation of energy with respect to change of parameters is important for precise analysis of wave state@xcite , but because of our limitation and size effects , we have just set the periodic boundary condition . in fig .
[ energy - gap ] , we present results of these calculations for the value of dm vector @xmath55 and chain size @xmath56 . it can be seen that the ground state energy for weak dm interaction is nearly degenerate up to the first critical frustration @xmath57 , which value is obtained by extrapolation technique .
also degeneracy in the mentioned region shows that in the absence of the frustration , @xmath49 , the spectrum of the model is gapless . by turning on the frustration
, spectrum remains gapless up to the first critical value of the frustration , @xmath57 .
as soon as the frustration increases from @xmath58 , the ground state is non - degenerate and exists in the subspace with total @xmath59 . fig .
[ energy - gap ] is also good analysis , especially for the proof of ferromagnetic sate . from the viewpoint of the symmetry
our model is completely different than the models studied in the literature @xcite .
the latter models have the @xmath60 symmetry . in this case , the absence of the chiral lro is natural , and the spontaneous breaking of the @xmath61 chiral symmetry , which resulted in the chiral lro , is interesting and was indeed the main topic in those studies . on the other hand , in the present model , the @xmath61 chiral symmetry is broken by the dm interaction explicitly . therefore , the appearance of the chiral lro should be natural ; if the lro is absent , it should be regarded as a surprising result and there must be a very interesting mechanism which recovers the symmetry behind the result . in order to recognize the different quantum phases , we have implemented the lanczos algorithm on finite size chains to calculate the lowest eigenstate .
the first insight into the nature of different phases can be obtained studying the chiral order parameter .
it has been shown that the dm interaction can create the chiral phase in the ground state phase diagram of the spin systems@xcite , which is characterized by nonzero value of the chirality @xmath62 where @xmath63 .
one should note that there are two different types of the chiral ordered phases , gapped and gapless@xcite . in fig .
[ chiral - order](a ) , we have presented calculated results on the chiral order parameter as a function of the frustration parameter @xmath52 for a value of dm vector @xmath55 , including different chain lengths @xmath64 . as is clearly seen from this figure , there is no long - range chiral order along the @xmath29 axis in the regions @xmath65 and @xmath66 . however , in the intermediate region , @xmath67 , the ground state shows a profound chiral order in the @xmath29 direction .
since the study of correlation functions can give us deep insight into the characteristics of the ground state , we define the chiral correlation function as @xmath68 it is important that in a phase with true long - range order the correlation functions should diverge as @xmath69 . to check the existence of the chiral long - range order in the thermodynamic limit @xmath70 of the system , we have plotted in the inset of fig .
[ chiral - order](a ) the @xmath71 dependence of @xmath72 for different values of frustration in the regions @xmath73 . as is seen from this figure , only in the intermediate region @xmath67 , there is a diverging behavior which shows that the chiral order in the intermediate region is true long - range order . on the other hand
, the constant value in the region @xmath74 shows that the @xmath75 takes zero value in the thermodynamic limit @xmath69 . for grater emphasis ,
we have plotted in fig .
[ chiral - order](b ) , the correlation function @xmath76 as a function of @xmath77 for a chain length @xmath56 .
clearly is seen that the long distance correlation of the chirality only exist in the region @xmath67 .
the mirror symmetry is the result of the periodic boundary condition .
therefore , by studying the ground state energy and the chiral order parameter , we showed that in the intermediate region @xmath67 , the 1d spin-1/2 frustrated ferromagnetic model with added dm interaction is in the gapped chiral order phase .
in what follows we will present our numerical study about the presence of dimer phase . in order to understand the nature of the dimer phase
let us assume we have a 1d frustrated antiferromagnetic model , where the sign of @xmath0 will be changed through the @xmath78 rotations around the @xmath29 axis of the spins on every second sites and the model will be transformed to the 1d frustrated ferromagnetic model . from the fact that the ground state at the majumdar - ghosh point ( @xmath79 ) is given by the product of singlet dimmers ( @xmath80)@xcite . through the above @xmath78-rotation transformation
, the dimer unit for @xmath81 is replaced by the triplet state @xmath82@xcite . to this reason , to find additional insight into the different phases we are focused on existing of the dimer phase in our 1d frustrated ferromagnetic model .
the order parameter characterizing the dimer phase is given as@xcite @xmath83 this order parameter shows alternating signs along the spin chain .
our results for the dm vector value @xmath55 and different chain sizes @xmath64 are presented in fig .
[ dimer - order ] . as can clearly be seen from this figure , in the luttinger liquid region , @xmath65 , there is not any long - range dimer order .
as soon as the frustration increases from the first critical value , the dimer ordering increases from zero very rapidly .
the oscillations of the dimer order in the intermediate region at finite @xmath71 are the result of level crossing between ground state and excited states of the model .
on the other hand , overlapping of the numerical results in the region @xmath66 , shows a divergent behavior of the correlation function of the dimer order parameter by increasing the size of chain @xmath71 .
this justifies that the true long - range dimer order exists in the region @xmath66 of the ground state phase diagram .
we have to mention that for other values of the dm interaction ( @xmath84 ) , we did the same numerical experiment and found the same quantum picture of the ground state magnetic phase diagram contains of : ( i. ) gapless luttinger liquid phase in the region @xmath65 ( ii . ) gapped chiral phase in the intermediate region @xmath67 and ( iii . ) gapped dimer phase for @xmath66 ( fig.[quantum ] ) .
in this section we study the entanglement of formation as a measure of the entanglement .
entanglement stands some similarity to classical correlation , but it differs in some important respects , including the fact that entangled objects can violate bells inequality @xcite
. may be one of the most characteristic differences is this : if two similar quantum objects are completely entangled with each other , then neither of them can be at all entangled with any other object , but there is no such restriction on classical correlations@xcite .
we compute the entanglement between two sites which is known as the concurrence@xcite @xmath85 where @xmath86 where @xmath87 is magnetization along @xmath29 axis and @xmath88 is the correlation function between spins on sites @xmath89 and @xmath90 .
the numerical lanczos results on the concurrence are shown in fig .
[ concurrence ] . from our numerical results we found that the concurrence of two spins that are nearest neighbor is equal to zero in all regions of the quantum ground state phase diagram . in this figure
the concurrence of one spin and its next nearest neighbor is plotted as a function of the frustration parameter @xmath52 for chain lengths @xmath64 and dm vector @xmath55 . in the luttinger liquid and dimer phases ,
the correlation between different components , @xmath91 , @xmath92 is equal to zero and only in the chiral phase has non - zero value . as it can be seen from fig .
[ concurrence ] , in the luttinger liquid region , @xmath65 , since the correlations @xmath93 , @xmath94 are equal , therefore the concurrence is equal to zero . on the other hand in the intermediate chiral region , @xmath67 , due to non - zero value of the correlations between different components the concurrence increases by increasing the frustration and at the second critical value @xmath95 is maximum . in sector of the dimer ground state ,
@xmath66 , the correlations @xmath93 , @xmath94 are equal and close to the maximum value @xmath96@xcite . in this case , as it is clearly seen from the fig .
[ concurrence ] , the concurrence has the almost constant value that obeys from the equation @xmath97 .
the deviation from the saturation value @xmath98 is a result of the induced quantum fluctuations by dm interaction . in the inset of fig .
[ concurrence ] , the @xmath71-dependence of the concurrence is investigated for different values of the frustration in the dimer sector of the ground state phase diagram .
finite linear extrapolated results show that in the thermodynamic limit @xmath99 , the next nearest neighbors are really entangled in the dimer phase .
thus , in the 1d frustrated ferromagnetic spin-1/2 model in presence of the dm interaction , only the next nearest neighbors are entangled in the gapped chiral and dimer phases .
it is expected that quantum nature of entanglement might provide explanatory and predictive power for the investigation of quantum phase transitions@xcite .
thus concurrence -pairwise entanglement- which refers to quantum correlations has emerged as one of the important tools . in our model eq.([j1-j2-dm ] ) , only the next nearest neighbors quantum correlation lead to concurrence have different nonzero value in the gapped chiral and dimer phases and zero value in the luttinger liquid phase . on the other hand ,
entanglement generation and distribution are problems of central importance in performing quantum - information(qi ) tasks , like teleportation @xcite and quantum cryptography@xcite . from the qi perspective
, it would be attracting to create sizable entanglement between particles that are located at a distance larger than a few sites .
this fact naturally leads to the concepts of long distance entanglement ( lde ) as a sort of quantum order parameter@xcite .
there are some models same as the dimerized - frustrated model , spin-1 heisenberg chain with biquadratic interaction and so on , which able to produce lde@xcite . here
we are interested to check this feature in our model .
as we showed in previous sections our spin frustration model leads to dimerized phase if the parameter @xmath52 exceeds a certain critical value ( @xmath100 , so the process of dimerization with the open boundary condition enables frustrated model to produce lde . in fig .
[ c1-n ] , we give the numerical lanczos results on the long distance entanglement of frustrated heisenberg chain in the presence of the dm interaction , particularly @xmath55 . as it can be seen from fig .
[ c1-n ] , in contrast next - nearest neighbor entanglement , the system has got nonzero lde which increases rapidly by increasing @xmath52 up to @xmath101 and then after that it reaches its saturation value about @xmath102 . in the inset of fig .
[ c1-n ] , the @xmath71-dependence of the lde is investigated for different values of the frustration in the dimer sector of the ground state phase diagram .
linear extrapolated results show that in the thermodynamic limit @xmath99 , the end - spins are entangled in the dimer phase for open boundary conditions .
to summarize , we studied the effect of a uniform dzyaloshinskii - moriya ( dm ) interaction on the ground state phase diagram of the one - dimensional ( 1d ) isotropic frustrated ferromagnetic spin-1/2 model using the analytical cluster method and numerical lanczos technique .
our classical analysis results based on lk method show that immediately after turning on the dm interaction , the ground state of the system goes to the chiral phase , independent of the frustration parameter @xmath103 .
thus , we concluded that the classical ground state phase diagram of the 1d frustrated ferromagnetic spin-1/2 model with added uniform dm interaction consists of a single phase : `` chiral '' . to find the quantum corrections of adding the dm interaction , we did a very accurate numerical experiment .
we implemented the lanczos algorithm to find the ground state in finite chains .
based on the numerical results of the order parameters and correlation functions , we identified three different phases . in the region
@xmath65 , the ground state of the system is in the luttinger liquid phase . in the region
@xmath66 the true long - range dimer order exists in the ground state phase diagram and in the intermediate region @xmath67 , the system finds in the gapped chiral phase . on the other hand , we tried to answer this question : `` are the spins entangled in different sectors of the ground state phase diagram ? ''
our numerical results for the entanglement showed that the nearest neighbor spins are not entangled in all regions of the quantum ground state phase diagram .
but , the next nearest neighbor spins are entangled in the gapped chiral and dimer phases , and became saturate in the region @xmath66 , which can be take it as another witness the presence of dimer phase .
we have even checked this model with open boundary conditions as an candidate for lde model , where calculations showed that the model reaches its saturated value around @xmath101 which is more than next nearest neighbor entanglement case @xmath104 .
it is our pleasure to thank t. kaplan , g. i. japaridze , t. vekua , a. akbari , j. abouie , s. h. sadat , m. r. soltani , g. rigolin , t. nishino , and t. hikihara for very useful comments and useful suggestions .
we are also grateful to s. n. rasouli for reading our manuscript .
highly frustrated magnetism 2008 , j. of phys .
: conference series * 145 * ( 2009 ) ; proceedings of the highly frus- trated magnetism 2003 conference , j. phys .
cond . mat .
* 16 * , n. 11 ( 2004 ) .
f. d. haldane , phys.rev .
b * 25 * , r4925 ( 1982 ) .
t. tonegawa and i. harada , j. phys .
56 * , 2153 ( 1987 ) .
k. nomura and k. okamoto , phys .
a * 169 * , 433 ( 1992 ) .
r. bursill , g. a. gehring , d. j. j. farnell , j. b. parkinson , t. xiang and c. zeng , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 7 * , 8605 ( 1995 ) . c. k. majumdar and d. k. ghosh , j. math .
* 10 * , 1388 ( 1969 ) .
steven r. white , ian affleck , phys . rev .
b * 54 * , 9863 ( 1996 ) .
g. bouzerar , a. p. kampf , and g. i. japaridze , phys .
b * 58 * , 3177 ( 1998 ) .
manoraja kumar , z. g. soos , diptiman sen , and s. ramasesha , phys .
b * 81 * , 104406 ( 2010 ) .
manoraja kumar , s. ramasesha , z. g. soos , phys .
b * 81 * , 054413 ( 2010 ) .
t. tonegawa and i. harada , j. phys .
* 58 * , 2902 ( 1989 ) .
a. v. chubukov , phys .
b * 44 * , r4693 ( 1991 ) .
d. c. cabra , a. honecker and p. pujol , eur .
j. b * 13 * , 55 ( 2000 ) .
krivnov and a. a. ovchinnikov , phys .
b * 53 * , 6435 ( 1996 ) .
t. hamada , j. kane , s. nakagawa and y. natsume , j. phys .
. jpn . * 57 * , 1891 ( 1988 ) .
d. v. dmitriev , v. ya .
krivnov and a. a. ovchinnikov , phys . rev .
b * 56 * , 5985 ( 1997 ) . c. itoi and s. qin , phys . rev .
b * 63 * , 224423 ( 2001 ) .
d. allen and d. senechal , phys .
b * 55 * , 299 ( 1997 ) .
a. a. nersesyan , a. q. gogolin and f. h. l. essler , phys .
* 81 * , 910 ( 1998 ) d. v. dmitriev , v. ya .
krivnov , and j. richter , phys .
b * 75 * , 014424 ( 2007 ) .
s. mahdavifar , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 20 * , 335230 ( 2008 ) .
y. mizuno , t. tohyama , s. maekawa , t. osafune , n. motoyama , h. eisaki and s. uchida , phys .
b * 57 * , 5326 ( 1998 ) .
m. hase , h. kuroe , k. ozawa , o. suzuki , h. kitazawa , g. kido and t. sekin , phys .
b * 70 * , 104426 ( 2004 ) . s. f. solodovnikov and z. a. solodovinkova , j. struct
. chem . * 38 * , 765 ( 1997 ) .
i. dzyaloshinskii , j. phys .
solids * 4 * , 241 ( 1958 ) .
t. moriya , phys .
rev * 120 * , 91 ( 1960 ) .
m. enderle , c. mukherjee , b. fak , r. k. kremer , j .-
broto , h. rosner , s .- l .
drechsler , j. richter , j. malek , a. prokofiev , w. assmus , s. pujol , j .- l .
raggazzoni , h. rakoto , m. rheinstadter and h. m. ronnow : europhys . lett . * 70 * ( 2005 ) 237 .
y. naito , k. sato , y. yasui , y. kobayashi , y. kobayashi and m. sato , j. phys .
jpn . * 76 * 023708 ( 2007 ) .
s. furukawa , m. sato , s. onoda , phys .
* 105 * , 257205 ( 2010 ) d. h. lyons and t. a. kaplan , j. phys .
solids * 25 * , 645 ( 1964 ) .
t. a. kaplan , phys .
b * 80 * , 012407 ( 2009 ) .
s. mahdavifar , m. r. soltani , a. a. masoudi , eur .
j. b * 62 * , 215 ( 2008 ) .
m. r. soltani , s. mahdavifar , a. akbari , j. supercond .
* 23 * , 1369 ( 2010 ) .
i. garate , i. affleck , phys .
b * 81 * , 144419 ( 2010 ) .
r. jafari , a. langari , phys .
b * 76 * , 014412 ( 2007 ) .
d. v. dmitriev , v. ya .
krivnov , phys .
b * 77 * , 024401 ( 2008 ) ; d. v. dmitriev , v. ya .
krivnov , phys .
b * 79 * , 054421 ( 2009 ) ; d. v. dmitriev , v. ya .
krivnov , phys .
b * 81 * , 054408 ( 2010 ) .
f. heidrich - misner , i. p. mcculloch , a. k. kolezhuk , phys .
b * 80 * , 144417 ( 2009 ) .
shunsuke furukawa , mashahiri sato , akira furusaki , phys .
b * 81 * , 094430 ( 2010 ) . a. gendiar and t. nishino phys . rev .
b * 71 * , 024404 ( 2005 ) .
f. heidrich - misner , a. honecker , t. vekua , phys .
b * 74 * , 020403(r ) ( 2006 ) . t. vekua , a. honecker , h - j .
mikeska , f. heidrich - misner , phys .
b * 76 * , 174420 ( 2007 ) . lars kecke , tsutomu momoi , akira furusaki , phys .
b * 76 * , 060407 ( 2007 ) .
toshiya hikihara , lars kecke , tsutomu momoi , akira furusaki , phys .
b * 78 * , 144404 ( 2008 ) .
j. sudan , a. luscher , a. laeuchli , phys .
b * 80 * , 140402(r ) ( 2009 ) . t. hikihara et al . ,
jpn * 69 * , 259 ( 2000 ) .
t. hikihara , m. kaburagi , and h. kawamura , phys .
b * 63 * , 174430 ( 2001 ) .
m. kaburagi , h. kawamura , t. hikihara , j. phys .
jpn * 68 * , 3185 ( 1999 ) .
j. s. bell , physics ( long island city , n.y . ) * 1 * , 195 ( 1964 ) .
k. m. oconnor and w. k. wootters phys .
63 * , 052302 ( 2001 ) .
w. k. wooters , phys .
lett . * 80 * , 2245 ( 1998 ) .
osterloh , r. , amico , l. , falci , g. , fazio , r. : nature ( london ) * 416 * , 608 ( 2002 ) .
l. amico , r. fazio , a. osterloh , and v. vedal , rev .
mod . pys . * 80 * , 517 ( 2008 ) .
d. boschi , s. branca , f. de martin , l. hardy , and s. popescu , phys .
lett , * 80 * , 1121 ( 1998 ) .
n. gisini , g. ribordy , w. tittel , and h. zbindeh , rev .
phys.*74 * , 145 ( 2002 ) l. campos venuti , c. degli espositi boschi , and m. roncaglia , phys .
lett . * 96 * , 247206 ( 2006 ) . | the one - dimensional ( 1d ) isotropic frustrated ferromagnetic spin-1/2 model is considered .
classical and quantum effects of adding a dzyaloshinskii - moriya ( dm ) interaction on the ground state of the system is studied using the analytical cluster method and numerical lanczos technique .
cluster method results , show that the classical ground state magnetic phase diagram consists of only one single phase : `` chiral '' .
the quantum corrections are determined by means of the lanczos method and a rich quantum phase diagram including the gapless luttinger liquid , the gapped chiral and dimer orders is obtained . moreover , next nearest neighbors will be entangled by increasing dm interaction and for open chains , end - spins are entangled which shows the long distance entanglement ( lde ) feature that can be controlled by dm interaction . |
the flavor - changing - neutral - current ( fcnc ) transitions @xmath4 provide potentially stringent tests of standard model ( sm ) in flavor physics and are not allowed at tree level but are induced by the glashow - iliopoulos - miani ( gim ) amplitudes @xcite at the loop level in the sm . in addition , these are also suppressed in sm due to their dependence on the weak mixing angles of the quark - flavor rotation matrix @xmath5 the cabibbo - kobayashi - maskawa ( ckm ) matrix @xcite .
these two circumstances make the fcnc decays relatively rare and hence important for the study of physics beyond the sm commonly known as new physics .
the experimental observation of inclusive @xcite and exclusive @xcite decays , @xmath6 and @xmath7 , has prompted a lot of theoretical interest on rare @xmath8 meson decays . though the inclusive decays are theoretically better understood but are extremely difficult to be measured in a hadron mechine , such as the lhc , which is the only collider , except for a super-@xmath8 factory , that could provide enough luminosity for the precise study of the decay distribution of such rare processes .
in contrast , the exclusive decays are easy to detect experimentally but are challanging to calculate theoretically and the difficulty lies in describing the hadronic structure , which provides the main uncertainty in the predictions of exclusive rare decays . in exclusive
@xmath9 decays the long - distance effects in the meson transition amplitude of the effective hamiltonian are encoded in the meson transition form factors which are the scalar functions of the square of momentum transfer and are model dependent quantites .
many exclusive @xmath10@xcite , @xmath11@xcite , @xmath12@xcite , @xmath13@xcite processes based on @xmath14 have been studied in literature and many fameworks have been applied to the description of meson transition form factors : like constituent quark models , qcd sum rules , lattice qcd , approaches based on heavy quark symmetry and analytical constraints .
rare @xmath8 decay modes also provide imporatant ways to look for physics beyond the sm .
there are various extensions of the sm in the literature , but the models with extra dimensions are of viable interest as they provide a unified framework for gravity and other interactions . in this way
they give some hints on the hierarchy problem and a connection with string theory . among different models of extra dimensions , which differ from one another depending on the number of extra dimensions , the most interesting are the scenario with universal extra dimensions . in these ued models
all the sm fields are allowed to propagate in the extra dimensions and compactification of extra dimension leads to the appearance of kaluza - klein ( kk ) partners of the sm fields in the four dimensional description of higher dimensional theory , together with kk modes without corresponding sm partners .
the appelquist , cheng and dobrescu ( acd ) model @xcite with one universal extra dimension ( ued ) is very attractive because it has only one free parameter with respect to the sm and that is the inverse of compactification radius @xmath2 @xcite . by analyzing the signature of extra dimenions in the different processes
, one can get bounds to the size of extra dimensions which are different in different models .
these bounds are accessible for the processes already known at the particle accelerators or within the reach of planned future facilities . in case of ued these bounds are more sever and constraints from tevatron run i allow to put the bound @xmath15 gev @xcite .
rare @xmath8 decays can also be used to constraint the acd scenario and in this regard buras and collaborators have already done some work .
in addition to the effective hamiltonian they have calculated for @xmath16 decays and also investigated the impact of ued on the @xmath17 mixing as well as on the ckm unitarity triangle @xcite . due to the availability of precise data on the decays @xmath18 , colangelo et al .
have studied these decays in acd model by calculating the branching ratio and forward - backward asymmetry for the decay @xmath19 .
we will study the rare semileptonic decay modes , @xmath20on the same footing as @xmath21 because both are induced by the same quark level transitions , i.e. @xmath22 .
we compare results of forward backward asymmetry for @xmath23 using our form factors with those obtained by colangelo @xmath24 @xcite .
the comparision shows clear distinction as shown in fig 4 .
these decays may provide us step forward towards the study of existance of new physics beyond the sm and therefore deserve serious attention , both theoretically and experimentally .
the paper is organized as follows . in section 2
we will briefly introduce the acd model .
section 3 deals with the study of effective hamiltonian and the corresponding matrix elements for @xmath20 decay .
now the new physics manifest in these decays in two different ways , either through new operators in the in the effective hamiltonian which are absent in the sm or through new contributions to the wilson coefficients @xcite . in acd
no new operator appears at tree level and therefore the new physics comes only through the wilson coefficients which are calculated in literature @xcite and we will summarize them in the same section . finally , in section 4 we will calculate the decay rate and forward - backward asymmetry and summarize our results .
in our usual universe we have 3 spatial @xmath251 temporal dimensions and if an extra dimension exists and is compactified , fields living in all dimensions would menifest themselves in the @xmath26 space by the appearence of kaluza - klein excitations .
the most pertinent question is whether ordinary fields propagate or not in all extra dimensions .
one obvious possibilty is the propagation of gravity in whole ordinary plus extra dimensional universe , the `` bulk '' .
contrary to this there are the models with universal extra dimensions ( ued ) in which all the fields propagate in all available dimensions @xcite and appelquist , cheng and dobrescu model belongs to one of ued scenarios @xcite this model is the minimal extension of the sm in @xmath27 dimensions , and in literature a simple case @xmath28 is considered @xcite .
the topology for this extra dimension is orbifold @xmath29 , and the coordinate @xmath30 runs from @xmath31 to @xmath32 , where @xmath2 is the the compactification radius .
the kaluza - klein ( kk ) mode expension of the fields are determined from the boundary conditions at two fixed points @xmath33 and @xmath34 on the orbifold . under parity transformation @xmath35 @xmath36
the fields may be even or odd .
even fields have their correspondent in the @xmath37 dimensional sm and their zero mode in the kk mode expansion can be interpreted as the ordionary sm field .
the odd fields do not have their correspondent in the sm and therefore do not have zero mode in the kk expansion .
the significant features of the acd model are : * the compactification radius @xmath2 is the only free parameter with respect to sm * no tree level contribution of kk modes in low energy processes ( at scale @xmath38 ) and no production of single kk excitation in ordinary particle interactions is a consequence of conservation of kk parity .
the detailed description of acd model is provided in @xcite ; here we summarize main features of its construction from @xcite .
* gauge group * as acd model is the minimal extension of sm therefore the gauge bosons associated with the gauge group @xmath39 are @xmath40 , @xmath41,@xmath42,@xmath43,@xmath44,@xmath45 and @xmath46 , and the gauge couplings are @xmath47 and @xmath48 ( the hat on the coupling constant refers to the extra dimension ) .
the charged bosons are @xmath49 and the mixing of @xmath50 and @xmath46 give rise to the fields @xmath51 and @xmath52 as they do in the sm .
the relations for the mixing angles are : @xmath53 the weingberg angle remains the same as in the sm , due to the relationship between five and four dimensional constants .
the gluons which are the gauge bosons associated to @xmath54 are @xmath55 .
* higgs sector and mixing between higgs fields and gauge bosons * the higgs doublet can be written as : @xmath56 with @xmath57 .
now only field @xmath58 has a zero mode , and we assign vacuum expectation value @xmath59 to such mode , so that @xmath60 .
@xmath61 is the the sm higgs field , and the relation between expectation values in five and four dimension is : @xmath62
. the goldstone fields @xmath63 , @xmath64 aries due to the mixing of charged @xmath65 and @xmath66 , as well as neutral fields @xmath67 .
these goldstone modes are then used to give masses to the @xmath68 and @xmath69 , and @xmath70 , @xmath71 , new physical scalars .
* yukawa terms * in sm , yukawa coupling of the higgs field to the fermion provides the fermion mass terms .
the diagonalization of such terms leads to the introduction of the ckm matrix . in order to have chiral fermions in acd model , the left and right - handed components of the given spinor
can not be simultaneously even under @xmath72 .
this makes the acd model to be the minimal flavor violation model , since there are no new opeators beyond those present in the sm and no new phase beyond the ckm phase and the unitarity triangle remains the same as in sm @xcite . in order to have 4-d mass eigenstates of higher kk levels ,
a further mixing is introduced among the left - handed doublet and right - handed singlet of each flavor @xmath73 .
the mixing angle is such that @xmath74 giving mass @xmath75 , so that it is negligible for all flavors except the top @xcite .
integrating over the fifth - dimension @xmath76 gives the four - dimensional lagrangian : @xmath77 which describes : ( i ) zero modes corresponding to the sm fields , ( ii ) their massive kk excitations , ( iii ) kk excitations without zero modes which do not corresponds to any field in sm .
feynman rules used in the further calculation are given in ref .
at quark level the decay @xmath20 is same like @xmath78 as discussed by ali _ et al_.@xcite , i.e.@xmath79 and
it can be described by effective hamiltonian obtained by integrating out the top quark and @xmath80 bosons @xmath81 where @xmath82@xmath83 are four local quark operators and @xmath84 are wilson co - effeicents calculated in naive dimensional regularization ( ndr ) scheme @xcite .
one can write the above hamiltonian in the following free quark decay amplitude @xmath85 \left [ \bar{\ell}\gamma ^{\mu } \ell \right ] \\ + c_{10}\left [ \bar{s}\gamma _ { \mu } lb\right ] \left [ \bar{\ell}\gamma ^{\mu } \gamma ^{5}\ell \right ] \\ -2\hat{m}_{b}c_{7}^{eff}\left [ \bar{s}i\sigma _ { \mu \nu } \frac{\hat{q}^{\nu } % } { \hat{s}}rb\right ] \left [ \bar{\ell}\gamma ^{\mu } \ell \right]% \end{array } \right\ } \nonumber \\ & & \label{2.2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath86 , @xmath87 which is just the momentum transfer from heavy to light meson . the amplitude given in eq .
( [ 2.2 ] ) contains long distance effects encoded in the form factors and short distance effects that are hidden in wilson coefficients .
these wilson coeffients have been computed at next - to - next leading order ( nnlo ) in the sm @xcite . specifically for exclusive decays ,
the effective coefficient @xmath88 can be written as @xmath89 where the perturbatively calculated result of @xmath90 is @xcite @xmath91 here the hat denote the normalization in term of @xmath8 meson mass .
for the explicit expressions of @xmath92 s and numerical values of the wilson coefficients appearing in eq .
( [ reson - expr ] ) we refer to @xcite . in acd model
the new physics comes through the wilson coefficients
. buras et al .
have computed the above coefficients at nlo in acd model including the effects of kk modes @xcite ; we use these results to study @xmath93 decay . as it has already been mentioned
that acd model is the minimal extension of sm with only one extra dimension and it has no extra operator other than the sm , therefore , the whole contribution from all the kk states is in the wilson coefficients , i.e. now they depend on the additional acd parameter , the inverse of compactification radius @xmath2 . at large value of @xmath94 the sm phenomenology should be recovered , since the new states , being more and more massive , decoupled from the low - energy theory .
our objective is to calculate the decay rate and forward - backward asymmetry for @xmath0 using the lower bound on @xmath94 provided by colangelo et al . for @xmath78 decay @xcite . in acd model ,
the wilson coefficients are modified and they contain the contribution from new particles which are not present in the sm and comes as an intermediate state in penguin and box diagrams .
thus , these coefficients can be expressed in terms of the functions @xmath95 , @xmath96 , which generalize the corresponding smfunction @xmath97 according to : @xmath98 with @xmath99 and @xmath100 @xcite .
the relevant diagrams are @xmath101 penguins , @xmath102 penguins , gluon penguins , @xmath102 magnetic penguins , chormomagnetic penguins@xmath103and the corresponding functions are @xmath104 , @xmath105 , @xmath106 , @xmath107 and @xmath108 respectively .
these functions can be found in @xcite but to make the paper self contained , we collect here the formulae needed for our analysis .
@xmath109 in place of @xmath110 one defines an effective coefficient @xmath111 which is renormalization scheme independent @xcite : @xmath112 where @xmath113 and @xmath114 the superscript @xmath115 stays for leading @xmath116 approximation .
furthermore : @xmath117 the functions @xmath118 and @xmath119 are given be eq .
( [ wilson3 ] ) with @xmath120 @xmath121 @xmath122 @xmath123 following @xcite one gets the expressions for the sum over @xmath124@xmath125\coth ( \pi m_{w}r\sqrt{y } ) \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{(-2+x_{t})x_{t}(1 + 3x_{t})}{6(x_{t}-1)^{4}}j(r,-\frac{1}{2 } ) \nonumber \\ & & -\frac{1}{6(x_{t}-1)^{4}}% [ x_{t}(1 + 3x_{t})-(-2 + 3x_{t})(1+(-10+x_{t})x_{t})]j(r,\frac{1}{2 } ) \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{1}{6(x_{t}-1)^{4}}[(-2 + 3x_{t})(3+x_{t})-(1+(-10+x_{t})x_{t})]j(r,% \frac{3}{2 } ) \nonumber \\ & & -\frac{(3+x_{t})}{6(x_{t}-1)^{4}}j(r,\frac{5}{2 } ) ] \label{wilson8}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath126 \nonumber \\ & & -\frac{x_{t}(1 + 3x_{t})}{(x_{t}-1)^{4}}j(r,-\frac{1}{2 } ) \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{1}{(x_{t}-1)^{4}}[x_{t}(1 + 3x_{t})-(1+(-10+x_{t})x_{t})]j(r,\frac{1}{% 2 } ) \nonumber \\ & & -\frac{1}{(x_{t}-1)^{4}}[(3+x_{t})-(1+(-10+x_{t})x_{t})]j(r,\frac{3}{2 } ) \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{(3+x_{t})}{(x_{t}-1)^{4}}j(r,\frac{5}{2 } ) ] \label{wilson9}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath127 .
\label{wilson10}\ ] ] @xmath128 in the acd model and in the ndr scheme one has @xmath129 where @xmath130 $ ] and the last term is numerically negligible . besides @xmath131 with @xmath132 \nonumber \\
z_{0}(x_{t } ) & = & \frac{18x_{t}^{4}-163x_{t}^{3}+259x_{t}^{2}-108x_{t}}{% 144(x_{t}-1)^{3 } } \nonumber \\ & & + [ \frac{32x_{t}^{4}-38x_{t}^{3}+15x_{t}^{2}-18x_{t}}{72(x_{t}-1)^{4}}-% \frac{1}{9}]\ln x_{t } \label{wilson13}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath133 \label{wilson14}\ ] ] and @xmath134 \label{wilson15}\ ] ] @xmath135 @xmath136 is @xmath137 independent and is given by @xmath138 the normalization scale is fixed to @xmath139 gev .
wilson coefficients give the short distance effects where as the long distance effects involve the matrix elements of the operators in eq .
( 2.2 ) between the @xmath8 and @xmath1 mesons . using standard parameterization in terms of the form factors we have @xcite : @xmath140 \label{matrix-1 } \\
\left\langle k_{1}(k,\varepsilon ) \left| a_{\mu } \right| b(p)\right\rangle & = & \frac{2i\epsilon _ { \mu \nu \alpha \beta } } { m_{b}+m_{k_{1}}}\varepsilon ^{\ast \nu } p^{\alpha } k^{\beta } a(s ) \label{matrix2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath141 and @xmath142 are the vector and axial vector currents respectively and @xmath143 is the polarization vector for the final state axial vector meson .
the relationship between different form factors which also ensures that there is no kinematical singularity in the matrix element at @xmath144 is @xmath145 in addition to the above form factors there are also some penguin form factors which are : @xmath146 f_{2}(s ) \nonumber \\ & & + ( \varepsilon ^{\ast } \cdot q)\left [ q_{\mu } -\frac{s}{% m_{b}^{2}-m_{k_{1}}^{2}}(p+k)_{\mu } \right ] f_{3}(s ) \nonumber \\ & & \label{matrix-5 } \\
\left\langle k_{1}(k,\varepsilon ) \left| \bar{s}i\sigma _ { \mu \nu } q^{\nu } \gamma _ { 5}b\right| b(p)\right\rangle & = & -i\epsilon _
{ \mu \nu \alpha \beta } \varepsilon ^{\ast \nu } p^{\alpha } k^{\beta }
f_{1}(s ) \label{matrix-6}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath147 form factors are the non - perturbative quantities and are the scalar function of the square of momentum transfer .
different models are used to calculate these form factors .
the form factors we use here in the analysis of physical variables like decay rate and forward - backward asymmetry have been calculated using ward identities .
the detailed calculation and their expressions are given in ref .
@xcite and can be summarized as : @xmath148 with @xmath149 the corresponding values for @xmath150 form factors at @xmath144 are given by @xmath151
in this section we define the decay rate distribution which we shall use for the phenomenological analysis . following the notation from ref.@xcite we can write from eq .
( [ 2.2 ] ) @xmath152 \label{4.1}\ ] ] where @xmath153 the definition of different momenta involved are defined in reference10 , where the auxiliary functions are @xmath154 \nonumber \\ c\left
( \hat{s}\right ) & = & \frac{1}{\left ( 1-\hat{m}_{k_{1}}^{2}\right ) } % \left\ { c_{9}^{eff}(\hat{s})v_{2}(\hat{s})+2\hat{m}_{b}c_{7}^{eff}\left [ f_{3}(\hat{s})+\frac{1-\hat{m}_{k_{1}}^{2}}{\hat{s}}f_{2}(\hat{s})\right ] \right\ } \nonumber \\
d(\hat{s } ) & = & \frac{1}{\hat{s}}\left [ \begin{array}{c } \left ( c_{9}^{eff}(\hat{s})(1+\hat{m}_{k_{1}})v_{1}(\hat{s})-(1-\hat{m}% _ { k_{1}})v_{2}(\hat{s})-2\hat{m}_{k_{1}}v_{0}(\hat{s})\right ) \\ -2\hat{m}_{b}c_{7}^{eff}f_{3}(\hat{s})% \end{array } \right ] \nonumber \\ e(\hat{s } ) & = & -\frac{2a(\hat{s})}{1+\hat{m}_{k_{1}}}c_{10 } \nonumber \\
f(\hat{s } ) & = & \left ( 1+\hat{m}_{k_{1}}\right ) c_{10}v_{1}(\hat{s } ) \nonumber \\
g(\hat{s } ) & = & \frac{1}{1+\hat{m}_{k_{1}}}c_{10}v_{2}(\hat{s } ) \nonumber \\ h(\hat{s } ) & = & \frac{1}{\hat{s}}\left [ c_{10}(\hat{s})(1+\hat{m}% _ { k_{1}})v_{1}(\hat{s})-(1-\hat{m}_{k_{1}})v_{2}(\hat{s})-2\hat{m}% _ { k_{1}}v_{0}(\hat{s})\right ] .
\label{4.4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] considering the final state lepton as muon the branching ratio for @xmath155 is calculated in ref . @xcite and its numerical value is @xmath156 the above value of branching ratio is for the case if one does not include @xmath157 in eq .
( [ reson - expr ] ) .
the error in the value reflects the uncertainty from the form factors , and due to the variation of input parameters like ckm matrix elements , decay constant of @xmath8 meson and masses as defined in table i. by including @xmath159 the central value of branching ratio reduces to @xmath160it is already mentioned that in acd model there is no new opeartor beyond the sm and new physics will come only through the wilson coefficients . to see this ,
the differential branching ratio against @xmath161 is plotted in fig .
1 using the central values of input parameteres .
one can see that their is significant enhancement in the decay rate due to kk contribution for @xmath162 gev whereas the value is shifted towards the sm at large value of @xmath163 .
the enhancemen is prominent in the low value of @xmath161 but such effects are obscured by the uncertainites involved in different parameters like , form factors , ckm matrix elements etc .
the numerical value at these two different values of @xmath94 is @xmath164the effects of ued becomes more clear if we look for the fb asymmetry in the dilepton angular distribution because it depends upon the wilson coefficients .
it is known that in sm , due to the opposite sign of the @xmath165 and @xmath166 , the forward - backward asymmetry passes from its zero position and has very weak dependence on form factors and uncertainities in input parameteres .
the differential forward - backward asymmetry for @xmath167 reads as follows@xcite @xmath168 \label{4.6}\]]where @xmath169the variable @xmath170 corresponds to @xmath171 , the angle between the momentum of the @xmath8 meson and the positively charged lepton in the dilepton c.m .
system frame . in
sm the zero - point of forward - backward asymmetry for @xmath155 is calculated by paracha et al .
24 and it lies at @xmath172 @xmath173 . they have shown that the due to the uncertainities in the form factors zero position of forward - backward asymmetry @xmath174 deviate slightly from the central value in the low @xmath83 region where as in the large @xmath83 region these deviations are highly suppressed and zero of the forward - backward asymmetry became insensitive to these uncertainities and therefore we do not include them while analysing the above decay in ued model . to see the new physics effects due to extra dimension , the differential forward - backward asymmetry with @xmath161 is plotted in fig .
it can be seen that the zero position of forward - backward asymmetry @xmath174 shifts towards the left in acd model with single universal extra dimension and this shifting is more clear for @xmath175 gev . in future , when we have some data on these decays , this sensitivity of the zero position to the compactification parameter , will be used to constrain @xmath176 the method of calculation of the form factors for @xmath0 decay descried in @xcite can be straighforwardly used to calculate the form factors for @xmath78 .
now after calculating these form factors for @xmath177 we have plotted the forward - backward asymmetry with @xmath161 in fig .
we believe that it provides a useful comparsion , if one compares the effect of our form factors to the zero of @xmath174 with the others like @xcite and references therein . again
the zero of @xmath174 is shifted towards the left in acd model with single universal extra dimension and this shifting is more clear for @xmath175 gev
. this paper deals with the study of semileptonic decay @xmath178 in acd model with single universal extra dimension which is strong contender to study physics beyond sm and has received a lot of interest in the literature .
we studied the dependence of the physical observables like decay rate and zero position of forward - backward asymmetry on the inverse of compactification radious @xmath94 .
the value of the branching ratio is found larger then the corresponding sm value .
the zero postion of the fb asymmetry is very sensitive to @xmath94 and it is seen that it shifts significantly to the left . the shifting is large at @xmath175 gev and approaches to the sm value if we increase the value of @xmath94 .
the future experiments , where mora data is expected , will put stringent constraints on the compactification radius and also give us some deep understanding of @xmath8-physics .
t. m. aliev , m. k. cakmak and m. savci , nucl .
b 607 , 305 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0009133 ] ; t. m. aliev , a. ozpineci , m. savci and c. yuce , phys . rev .
* d66 * , 115006(2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0208128 ] ; t. m. aliev , a. ozpineci and m. savci , phys . lett . * b511 * , 49 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0103261 ] ; t. m. aliev and m. savci , phys . lett . * b481*,275 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0003188 ] ; t. m. aliev , d. a. demir and m. savci , phys . rev . * d62 * , 074016 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9912525 ] ; t. m. aliev , c. s. kim and y. g. kim , phys .
* d62 * , 014026 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9910501 ] ; t. m. aliev and e. o. iltan , phys . lett . *
b451 * , 175 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9804458 ] ; c. h. chen and c. q. geng , phys . rev . *
d66 * , 034006 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0207038 ] ; c. h. chen and c. q. geng , phys . rev . *
d66 * , 014007 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0205306 ] .
g. erkol and g. turan , nucl .
* b635 * , 286 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0204219 ] ; e. o. iltan , g. turan and i. turan , j. phys . *
g28 * , 307 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0106136 ] ; t. m. aliev , v. bashiry and m. savci , jhep * 0405 * ,
037 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0403282 ] . w. j. li , y. b. dai and c. s. huang , arxiv : hep - ph/0410317 ; q. s. yan , c. s. huang , w. liao and s. h. zhu , phys . rev . *
d62 * , 094023 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0004262 ]
. s. r. choudhury , n. gaur , a. s. cornell and g. c. joshi , phys . rev . *
d68 * , 054016 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0304084 ] ; s. r. choudhury , a. s. cornell , n. gaur and g. c. joshi , phys . rev .
* d69 * , 054018 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0307276 ] .
s. rai choudhury , n. gaur and n. mahajan , phys . rev . *
d66 * , 054003 ( 2002)[arxiv : hep - ph/0203041 ] ; s. r. choudhury and n. gaur , arxiv : hep - ph/0205076 ; s. r. choudhury and n. gaur , arxiv : hep - ph/0207353 ; t. m. aliev , v. bashiry and m. savci , phys .
rev . * d71 * , 035013 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0411327 ] ; u. o. yilmaz , b. b. sirvanli and g. turan , nucl
692 * , 249 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0407006 ] ; u. o. yilmaz , b. b. sirvanli and g. turan , eur .
j. c 30 , 197 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0304100 ] .
s. r. choudhury and n. gaur , phys . lett . *
b451 * , 86 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9810307 ] ; j. k. mizukoshi , x. tata and y. wang , phys . rev . * d66 * , 115003 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0208078 ] ; t. ibrahim and p. nath , phys .
* d67 * , 016005 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0208142 ] ; g. l. kane , c. kolda and j. e. lennon , arxiv : hep - ph/0310042 ; a. j. buras , p. h. chankowski , j. rosiek and l. slawianowska , nucl . phys . * b659 * , 3 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0210145 ] ; a. j. buras , p. h. chankowski , j. rosiek and l. slawianowska , phys . lett . *
b546 * , 96 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0207241 ] ; a. dedes , h. k. dreiner and u. nierste , phys .
* 87 * , 251804 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0108037 ] p. colangelo , f. de fazio , r. ferrandes , t.n .
pham , phys.rev .
* d73 * , 115006 ( 2006 ) ; p.colangelo , f. de fazio , p. santorelli and e. scrimieri , phys.rev.*d53 * ( 1996 ) 3672 - 3686 ; erratum - ibid .
d57 ( 1998 ) 3186 . c. bobeth , m. misiak and j. urban , nucl
b574 * , 291 ( 2000 ) ; h. h. asatrian , h. m. asatrian , c. greub andm.walker , phys .
* b507 * , 162 ( 2001 ) ; phys . rev .
* d65 * , 074004 ( 2002 ) ; phys . rev . *
d66 * , 034009 ( 2002 ) ; h. m. asatrian , k. bieri , c. greub and a. hovhannisyan , phys . rev . * d66 * , 094013 ( 2002 ) ; a. ghinculov , t. hurth , g. isidori and y. p. yao , nucl . phys . * b648 * , 254 ( 2003 ) ; a. ghinculov , t. hurth , g. isidori and y. p. yao , nucl . phys . * b685 * , 351 ( 2004 ) ; c. bobeth , p. gambino , m. gorbahn and u. haisch , jhep * 0404 * , 071 ( 2004 ) .
1 ) : the differential branching ratio as a function of @xmath161 is plotted using the form factors defined in eq .
( [ form - factors ] ) .
the solid line denotes the sm result , dashed - dotted line is for @xmath175 gev and dashed line is for @xmath179 gev .
all the input parameters are taken at their central values .
2 ) : the differential forward - backward ( fb ) asymmetry as a function of @xmath180 is plotted using the form factors defined in eq .
( [ form - factors ] ) .
the solid line denotes the sm result , dashed - dotted line is for @xmath175 gev and dashed line is for @xmath179 gev .
all the input parameters are taken at their central values .
3 ) : the differential forward - backward ( fb ) asymmetry for @xmath181 as a function of @xmath161 is plotted using the form factors defined in eq .
( [ form - factors ] ) with obvious replacements for @xmath182 .
the solid line denotes the sm result , dashed line is for @xmath162 gev and long - dashed line is for @xmath179 gev .
all the input parameters are taken at their central values .
4 ) : comparision of the differential forward - backward ( fb ) asymmetry for @xmath23 in standard model ( sm ) as a function of @xmath180 is plotted using the form factors defined in eq.([form - factors ] ) vs form factors given in colangelo @xmath24 @xcite .
the solid line denotes the colangelo result and dashed line denotes our result . | decay rate and forward - backward asymmetries in @xmath0 , @xmath1 is the axial vector meson , are calculated in the universal extra dimension ( ued ) model .
the dependence of these physical quantities on the compactification radius @xmath2 , the only unknown paramter in ued model , is studied and it is shown that zero of forward - backward asymmetry is sensitive to the ued model , therefore they can be very useful tool to establish new physics predicted by the ued model .
this work is briefly extended to @xmath3 |
spin dependent semi - inclusive hadronic processes have attracted much interest from both experiment and theory sides in recent years .
these processes provide us more opportunities to study the quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) and internal structure of the hadrons , as compared to the inclusive hadronic processes or spin averaged processes .
measurements have been made in different reactions .
in particular , the single transverse spin asymmetry ( ssa ) phenomena observed in various hadronic processes@xcite have stimulated remarkable theoretical developments . among the theoretical developments ,
two approaches in the qcd framework have been most explored : the higher twist collinear factorization approach @xcite and the transverse momentum dependent ( tmd ) approach . in these two approaches ,
the spin - dependent differential cross sections can be calculated in terms of the collinear twist three quark - gluon correlation functions in the collinear factorization formalism and the tmd distributions in the tmd factorization approach .
such functions generalize the original feynman parton picture , where the partons only carry longitudinal momentum fraction of the parent hadron .
they will certainly provide more information on hadron structure .
further study has shown that the transverse momentum dependence of the naive - time - reversal - odd tmd distributions which are responsible for the ssas can be calculated and expressed in terms of the collinear twist - three correlation functions at the large transverse momentum . by using these results
, it was shown that the above two approaches are consistent in the intermediate transverse momentum region where both apply . in this paper
, we will extend these studies to more general drell - yan processes , in particular the lepton angular distributions in polarized nucleon - nucleon scattering .
the single transverse spin asymmetry in the drell - yan lepton pair production process has been used as an example to demonstrate the consistency between these two approaches @xcite , where the single transverse spin asymmetry is represented as a correlation between the lepton pair transverse momentum @xmath0 and the transverse polarization vector @xmath1 . for this contribution ,
the transverse spin dependent differential cross section is proportional to @xmath2 .
the transverse momentum of the lepton pair is also the transverse momentum of the virtual photon which decays into the lepton pair in the drell - yan process .
therefore , this ssa is related to the quark sivers function , and is the only contribution from the quark - antiquark channel . however ,
if we further study the lepton angular distribution in the drell - yan process @xcite , it will open more contributions to the single spin asymmetries , as well as other spin dependent observables .
more recently , by analyzing the general lorentz structure of the hadronic tensor , the complete spin and transverse momentum dependent angular distribution of lepton pair has been presented in ref .
@xcite , and 48 structure functions will contribute .
one can calculate some of them which are leading power in the context of the tmd factorization and relate them to the tmd distributions @xcite . in this paper , we will study the angular distribution of the lepton pair in the polarized drell - yan process at large transverse momentum of the lepton pair .
the relevant calculations are carried out in the collinear factorization framework .
we mainly focus on the single spin asymmetry @xmath3 and double spin asymmetry @xmath4 , taking into account the contributions from the twist - three quark - gluon correlation functions from one of the incident hadrons . we will limit ourselves up to this order in the calculations . for the single spin asymmetry @xmath3 , the corresponding twist - three quark - gluon correlation functions are those studied in and the calculations will be similar . on the other hand ,
for the @xmath4 asymmetry , more general quark - gluon correlation functions will contribute and the calculations will be different from those in . following the same procedure as that in refs . , we will compare the predictions from the two formalisms and check their consistency . to pursue this aim , we will calculate the tmd quark distributions at large transverse momentum @xmath5 , and express them in terms of the collinear correlation functions .
there are eight leading order tmd quark distributions @xcite : three @xmath6-even tmd distributions @xmath7 ; two naive - time - reversal - odd tmd quark distributions @xmath8 ( sivers function ) , @xmath9 ( boer - mulders function ) ; and three naive - time - reversal - even but @xmath6-odd tmd quark distributions @xmath10 , @xmath11 , @xmath12 .
the transverse momentum dependence of these tmd quark distributions can be calculated from perturbative qcd in the collinear factorization framework . for the @xmath6-even tmd
quark distributions , the results are well - known , and can be expressed in terms of the integrated leading - twist parton distributions ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) . the naive - time - reversal - odd tmd quark distributions ( the sivers function and boer - mulders function )
have also been calculated . in this paper
, we will extend these calculations to the two naive - time - reversal - even but @xmath6-odd tmd quark distributions @xmath13 and @xmath14 .
these results will depend on the the novel twist three distributions @xmath15 , @xmath16 @xcite , and the general twist - three quark - gluon correlation functions @xmath17 ,
@xmath18 , @xmath19 , and @xmath20 @xcite .
the last tmd quark distribution @xmath12 will involve twist - four quark - gluon correlation functions .
we will not discuss it in this paper .
the rest of paper is organized as follows . in sec .
ii , we give a brief review on the twist - three quark - gluon collinear correlation matrix elements and discuss the relation between them and the tmd distributions .
general feature of the tmd quark distributions at large transverse momentum will be presented in sec .
iii . in sec .
iv , we derive the naive - time - reversal - even tmd quark distributions @xmath10 , @xmath11 in the twist - three quark - gluon correlation approach . in sec .
v , we calculate the relevant polarized drell - yan differential cross section using the same collinear factorization and compare to the results from the tmd factorization .
we conclude the paper in sec .
in order to extract more information on hadron structure , various spin dependent and/or transverse momentum dependent parton correlation functions have been introduced based on the qcd factorization theorem . they are universal between sidis and drell - yan processes ( up to a sign for the naive - time - reversal - odd tmd parton distributions ) and can be pinned down by a complete set of experiments .
it has been shown that there exits interesting connections between the twist - three collinear functions and the naive - time - reversal - odd tmd quark distributions @xcite . in this section , we will review the general property of the collinear correlation functions and introduce two novel twist - three functions @xmath21 @xcite .
we will further explore their relations to the naive - time - reversal - even but @xmath6-odd tmd quark distributions @xmath13 and @xmath14 .
let us start by introducing the following collinear quark - antiquark correlation matrix : @xmath22 where @xmath23 are the hadron momentum and spin , respectively , and we have suppressed the light - cone gauge links between different fields .
the hadron momentum @xmath24 is proportional to the light cone vector @xmath25 , whose conjugate light - cone vector is @xmath26 .
@xmath27 is the momentum fraction of the hadron carried by the quark .
up to twist - three level , the above matrix can be expanded as @xcite , @xmath28 \nonumber \\ & + & \frac{m}{2p^+ } \left [ e(x ) { \rm 1 } + g_t(x ) \gamma_5 s\!\!\!/_\perp + h_l(x)\frac{\lambda}{2 } \gamma_5 [ p\!\!\!/,n\!\!\!/ ] \right ] \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath29 represents the helicity for the nucleon for the longitudinal polarized nucleon , @xmath1 is the transverse polarization vector , and @xmath30 the hadron mass .
the first three are the leading - twist quark distributions : spin average @xmath31 , longitudinal spin @xmath32 , and quark transversity @xmath33 distributions .
the twist - three quark distributions : @xmath34 , @xmath35 , and @xmath36 do not have simple interpretations , and belong to more general quark - gluon correlation functions @xcite .
these correlation functions can be defined through the following matrix @xcite , @xmath37 where we have adopted the covariant derivative as @xmath38 .
the expansion of the above matrix contains the following four twist - three quark - gluon correlation functions , @xmath39 \nonumber \\ &
+ & \frac{m}{2p^+ } \left [ h_d(x , x_1 ) \lambda \gamma_5 \gamma_\perp^\mu p\!\!\!/ + e_d(x , x_1 ) \gamma_\perp^\mu p\!\!\!/ \right ] \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] by imposing the hermiticity , parity and time - reversal invariance , we will have the following constrains , @xmath40 and these functions are real .
as mentioned , the twist - three quark distribution @xmath35 , @xmath34 , and @xmath36 can be expressed in terms of the above quark - gluon correlation functions @xcite , @xmath41 \ , \\ & & h_l(x)= \frac{2}{x } \int dx_1 h_d(x , x_1 ) \ , \\ & & e(x)= \frac{2}{x } \int dx_1 e_d(x , x_1 ) \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore , @xmath17 , @xmath18 , @xmath19 , and @xmath20 functions are more fundamental , which becomes evident when we study the scale evolution for the twist - three quark distributions , and the next - to - leading order perturbative corrections to the relevant cross sections . in terms of the twist expansion , of course , @xmath42-type correlations are not the only ones at the twist - three level .
one can also define a set of the @xmath43-type twist-3 correlation matrix elements , @xmath44 again , the expansion of the above matrix defines the following @xmath43-type quark - gluon correlation functions , @xmath45 \nonumber \\ & + & \frac{m}{2 } \left [ \tilde{t}_f^{(\sigma)}(x , x_1 ) i\lambda \gamma_5 \gamma_\perp^\mu p\!\!\!/ + t_f^{(\sigma)}(x , x_1 ) i\gamma_\perp^\mu p\!\!\!/ \right ] \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where , for convenience , we have used different normalization factors for @xmath46 and @xmath47 as compared to ref . , with a relative factor @xmath48 .
similarly , the parity and time - reversal invariance implies , @xmath49 the @xmath43-type correlation functions are usually regarded as an alternative but not independent functions in the calculations to the inclusive dis structure functions , such as @xmath50 structure function @xcite . on the other hand , it has been found that the @xmath43-type correlation functions are more relevant for the single transverse spin asymmetry , and have been intensively studied . by using the equation of motion ,
these two types of the correlation functions can be related to each other , @xmath51 where @xmath52 stands for the principal value , and @xmath53 are given by @xcite , @xmath54 \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] from the above results , we find that indeed the @xmath43-type and @xmath42-type correlation functions are not completely independent , and they form an over - complete set of functions . however , we still need @xmath55 and @xmath56 to completely describe the associated physics at this order , in particular , for the calculation performed in this paper . in the real calculations , we can either use @xmath42-type or @xmath43-type plus @xmath55 and @xmath56 as a complete set of twist - three functions . in the following
, we will further reveal the physical meaning of @xmath55 and @xmath56 , and build the connection between them and the transverse momentum dependent quark distributions .
the tmd parton distributions are important generalization of the conventional feynman parton distributions .
because of additional dependence on the transverse momentum of partons , these distributions open more opportunities to study the partonic structure in nucleon .
the nontrivial correlations between the parton transverse momentum and the polarization vectors of the parent nucleon or the quark itself provide novel consequence in the transverse component in the hadronic processes , for example , the single transverse spin asymmetry . of course
, upon integral over transverse momentum , these tmd parton distributions will naturally connect to the leading - twist and higher - twist parton distributions . in this paper , we will focus on the tmd quark distributions , which are relevant to the drell - yan lepton pair production .
the tmd quark distributions can be defined through the following matrix @xcite , @xmath57 where @xmath27 is the longitudinal momentum fraction and @xmath6 the transverse momentum carried by the quark .
the gauge link @xmath58 is along the direction represented by @xmath59 which is conjugated to @xmath60 . in the case
that we need to regulate the light - cone singularities , we will use an off - light - cone vector : @xmath61 and @xmath62 , and further define @xmath63 .
compared with the integrated parton distributions definition in the above , we find that the two quark fields are not only separated by light - cone distance @xmath64 , but also by the transverse distance @xmath65 , which is conjugate to the transverse momentum of the quark @xmath6 @xcite .
because of this difference , the additional transverse gauge link for the tmd parton distributions has to be contained in order to make the above quark matrix gauge invariant @xcite , and the gauge link direction depends on the process . since we will study the drell - yan lepton pair production in this paper , in the following we will adopt the tmd definition for this process and the gauge link will go to @xmath66 .
the gauge link plays an essential role in the naive time - reversal - odd tmd parton distributions .
the leading order expansion of the quark distribution matrix @xmath67 contains eight quark distributions , @xmath68\ .
\label{tmdpar}\end{aligned}\ ] ] out of the eight tmd distributions , three of them are associated with the @xmath6-even structure : @xmath69 , @xmath70 , and @xmath71 .
they are simple extension of the above integrated quark distributions .
the other five distributions are associated with the @xmath6-odd structures , and hence vanish when @xmath6 are integrated out for @xmath72 . for an unpolarized nucleon target
, one can introduce the unpolarized quark distribution @xmath73 and naive - time - reversal - odd transversely - polarized quark distribution @xmath9 , the boer - mulders function . for a longitudinally - polarized nucleon ,
one introduces a longitudinally - polarized quark distribution @xmath74 and a transversely - polarized distribution @xmath75 .
finally , for a transversely - polarized nucleon , one introduces a quark spin - independent distribution @xmath76 , the sivers function , and a longitudinally - polarized quark polarization @xmath77 , a symmetrical transversely - polarized quark distribution @xmath78 and an asymmetric transversely - polarized quark distribution @xmath79 .
if we weight the integral of @xmath72 with linear dependent transverse momentum , the @xmath6-odd quark distributions will lead to the higher - twist quark - gluon correlation functions @xcite .
four of them will correspond to the four quark - gluon correlation functions introduced above , including @xmath80 , @xmath81 , @xmath13 , @xmath14 .
the last one @xmath82 , as we mentioned , will correspond to a twist - four correlation function .
first , the two naive - time - reversal - odd quark distributions @xmath80 and @xmath81 lead to the following quark - gluon correlations , @xmath83 where the tmd quark distributions follow their definitions in the drell - yan process .
similarly , the two naive - time - reversal - even but @xmath6-odd quark distributions @xmath13 and @xmath14 can be related to the following twist - three matrix element , @xmath84 here , because they are naive - time - reversal - even distributions , they will not change sign between dis and drell - yan processes . in summary , the four @xmath6-odd tmd
quark distributions correspond to the four twist - three quark - gluon correlation functions introduced above eqs .
( 12)-(15 ) . from these relations
, we can further study the scale evolutions for the above twist three correlations .
the above relations are only one aspect of the connections between the tmd quark distributions and higher - twist quark - gluon correlation functions . in the following section
, we will explore another aspect , i.e. , the large transverse momentum behavior for the tmd quark distributions in terms of the collinear leading - twist or twist - three quark - gluon correlation functions .
when the @xmath6 is of the order of @xmath85 , the tmd parton distribution functions are entirely non - perturbative objects .
however , the transverse momentum dependence can be calculated in the perturbative qcd and related to the collinear matrix elements as long as the @xmath6 is much larger than @xmath85 , the typical nonperturbative scale .
the collinear matrix elements are the relevant integrated leading - twist parton distributions or higher - twist quark - gluon correlation functions .
for example , for the three @xmath6-even quark distributions , they will depend on the integrated leading - twist parton distributions .
however , for the @xmath6-odd quark distributions , they depend on the twist - three ( or twist - four ) quark - gluon correlation functions . in general
, we will have the following expression for the quark distributions at large transverse momentum @xcite - space for the tmd distributions .
] , @xmath86 where @xmath87 represents the tmd quark distribution we are interested , @xmath88 represents the integrated quark distribution for the @xmath6-even tmds , and higher twist quark - gluon correlation function for the @xmath6-odd tmds . for the latter case ,
@xmath89 should be understood as two variables for the twist - three quark - gluon correlation functions as we discussed in the last section .
the overall power behavior @xmath90 can be analyzed by the power counting rule @xcite .
the hard coefficient @xmath91 is calculated from perturbative qcd . in this paper , we will show the one - gluon radiation contribution to this hard coefficient .
the @xmath6-even tmd quark distribution functions , @xmath69 , @xmath70 , and @xmath71 can be calculated from the associated integrated quark distributions @xcite and @xmath32 distributions . in this paper
, we will not discuss these contributions . ] .
for the non - singlet contributions , they are expressed as @xcite , @xmath92 , \\
g_{1l}(x_b , k_\perp)&=&\frac{\alpha_s}{2 \pi^2 } \frac{1}{\vec{k}_\perp^2 } c_f \int \frac{dx}{x } g_{1l}(x ) \left [ \frac { 1 + \xi^2 } { ( 1-\xi)_+ } + \delta(1- \xi ) \left ( \ln \frac{x_b^2\zeta^2}{\vec{k}_\perp^2 } -1 \right ) \right ] , \\
h_1(x_b , k_\perp)&=&\frac{\alpha_s}{2 \pi^2 } \frac{1}{\vec{k}_\perp^2 } c_f \int \frac{dx}{x } f_1(x ) \left [ \frac{2 \xi } { ( 1-\xi)_+ } + \delta(1- \xi ) \left ( \ln \frac{x_b^2\zeta^2}{\vec{k}_\perp^2 } -1 \right ) \right ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the color factor @xmath93 with @xmath94 , @xmath95 and @xmath96 . here
, we have adopted an off - light - cone vector @xmath59 to regulate the light - cone singularity associated with the above calculations @xcite . in the same spirit ,
the naive - time - reversal - odd tmd distributions , the quark sivers function @xmath80 and boer - mulders function @xmath81 at large @xmath6 can be calculated perturbatively .
the contributions come from the twist - three correlation matrix elements @xmath97 , @xmath98 , and @xmath99 .
furthermore , it is known that the time - reversal odd tmd distributions is process dependent because the difference on the gauge link directions will lead to a sign difference between the sidis and drell - yan processes@xcite , @xmath100 the quark sivers function and boer - mulders function have been calculated @xcite , @xmath101 , \\ h_{1}^\perp|_{\rm dy}(x_b , k_\perp)&=&\frac{\alpha_s}{\pi } \frac{m^2}{(\vec{k}_\perp^2)^2 } \int \frac{dx}{x } \left [ a_{h_{1}^\perp } + c_f t_f^{(\sigma)}(x , x)\delta(1- \xi ) \left ( \ln \frac{x_b^2\zeta^2}{\vec{k}_\perp^2 } -1 \right ) \right ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the @xmath102 factors are defined as @xmath103 + \frac{c_a}{2 } \tilde{t}_f(x_b , x ) \ , \\
a_{h_{1}^\perp}&=&c_f t_f^{(\sigma)}(x , x)\frac{2 \xi}{(1-\xi)_+ } + \frac{c_a}{2 } \left[\frac{2}{1-\xi}t_f^{(\sigma)}(x , x_b)-\frac{2\xi}{1-\xi}t_f^{(\sigma)}(x , x)\right ] \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the color - factor @xmath104 . from the above results
, we can see that the large transverse momentum tmd quark distributions have a generic structure .
they contain two parts : one part is similar to the splitting kernel for the relevant collinear functions , and one term is a delta function associated with a large logarithm @xmath105 which comes from the light - cone singularity regulated by an off - light cone gauge link discussed above . the splitting kernel may be different for different tmd quark distributions .
however , the logarithmic term is the same for all of them .
this is because this term is related to the soft gluon radiation and is spin - independent .
we can also use this as an important consistent check for all the calculations . in the next section
, we will calculate the two @xmath6-odd but time - reversal even quark distributions @xmath13 and @xmath14 , and we will find that they have the same structure .
the energy dependence of the tmd quark distributions , the derivative respected to @xmath106 , is controlled by the so - called collins - soper evolution equation .
these evolution equations can be used to perform soft - gluon resummation for the final @xmath6 distribution in the cross section and the tmd quark distributions .
it is more convenient to study this resummation in the impact parameter @xmath107-space .
we will address this issue in the future .
in this section , we will calculate the large transverse momentum behavior for the two naive - time - reversal - even but @xmath6-odd quark distributions : @xmath13 and @xmath14 .
these calculations will follow the previous calculations on the naive - time - reversal - odd quark distributions @xmath80 and @xmath81 . however , they differ in a significant way .
as shown in , for the naive - time - reversal - odd distributions , the gauge link contributions play very important roles .
for example , these time - reversal - odd distributions will have opposite signs between sidis and drell - yan processes , because the gauge links go different directions . in the practical calculations
, we have to take pole contributions from the gauge links in these tmd quark distributions .
the calculations for @xmath13 and @xmath14 are different . because they are naive - time - reversal - even
, we do not take the pole contributions from the gauge links .
that makes the calculations a little more involved , as the two - variable dependent correlation functions will enter explicitly . as we mentioned above
, these two tmd quark distributions will depend on the correlation functions , @xmath17 ( @xmath97 ) , @xmath18 ( @xmath108 ) , and @xmath19 ( @xmath109 ) .
moreover , they will have contributions from the twist - three function @xmath55 and @xmath56 . in the following
, we will calculate these contributions . ;
( b)-(d ) for twist - three contributions , ( b ) for @xmath110 , ( c ) for @xmath111 , and ( d ) for @xmath112 .
additional @xmath113 gluon connection between hard partonic part and the non - perturbative nucleon structure part can be added to these diagrams .
this is because they do not change the power counting in these diagrams .
the contributions from these diagrams ( b - d ) are not gauge invariant individually .
however , they will combine into the gauge invariant results in terms of the correlation functions introduced in sec.ii.__,width=340 ] -0.4 cm the twist expansion will be the key step in the calculations .
the technique used to calculate these contributions has been well developed in the last few decades @xcite . in the following , we will sketch the main points of our calculations for the tmd quark distributions @xmath13 and @xmath14 and the drell - yan lepton pair production cross section in the next section . in the twist expansion
, a set of non - perturbative matrix elements of the hadron state will be analyzed according to the power counting of the associated contributions . at the twist - three order , from a generic power counting we have contributions from the following matrix elements
@xcite , @xmath114 where the quark field spin indices have been suppressed for simplicity .
the relevant feynman diagrams can be drawn accordingly .
we illustrate the typical diagrams for the associated contributions from the above matrix elements in fig . 1 . for comparison
, we have also shown the diagram corresponding to the leading - twist contribution from the matrix element @xmath115 in fig .
1b - d represent the contributions up to twist - three quark - gluon correlation matrix elements .
1b corresponds to the contributions from the matrix element @xmath116 , fig .
1c from @xmath111 , and fig .
1d from @xmath117 .
because of additional gluon component in the matrix elements for fig .
1c and d , there will be gluon attachment from the nonperturbative part to the perturbative part as shown in these diagrams . to calculate the contributions from fig .
1b and d , we have to do collinear expansion of the partonic scattering amplitudes in terms of @xmath118 and @xmath119 , respectively
. these expansions , combining with the quark field and gluon field , will lead to the contributions in terms of the matrix elements : @xmath116 , and @xmath117 .
the calculation of fig .
1b is straightforward , without expansion in terms of the transverse momenta of the quarks and gluon .
furthermore , all these calculations have to be combined into the gauge invariant matrix elements , such as @xmath17 , @xmath18 , @xmath19 , @xmath20 , @xmath97 , @xmath108 , @xmath99 , @xmath109 , @xmath55 , and @xmath56 .
however , these functions form an over - complete set of correlation functions at this order ( twist - three ) as we discussed in sec .
ii . therefore
, we can express the results in terms of either @xmath42-type or @xmath43-type correlation functions .
for example , in the calculations of the twist - three @xmath50 structure function , one has to combine the contributions from @xmath116 and @xmath111 into the gauge invariant form @xmath120 which is associated with @xmath17 and @xmath18 .
meanwhile , for the single spin asymmetry observables ( or the naive - time - reversal - odd tmd quark distributions ) , it is more convenient to calculate the contributions in terms of @xmath117 matrix element .
such matrix element is part of the gauge invariant matrix element @xmath121 which is associated with the twist - three correlation functions @xmath97 ,
@xmath108 , and @xmath99 .
the contributions from the diagrams associated with @xmath122 have also been shown to exactly coincide with those from @xmath117 to form a complete result into the form in terms of @xmath121 @xcite . in the above two examples
, it seems that the @xmath55 and @xmath56 functions are not necessary in these calculations , because they do not appear in the final results .
this is only because in these calculations one has chosen a particular set of correlation functions for the final results .
otherwise , @xmath55 and @xmath56 functions will show up if we choose different set of correlation functions .
for example , the structure function @xmath50 can be solely expressed in terms of @xmath17 and @xmath18 . however
, if we rewrite @xmath50 structure function in terms of @xmath97 and @xmath108 , we will have to introduce the @xmath55 function , because of the relation of eq .
similar arguments apply to the single spin asymmetry calculations .
furthermore , the necessary of @xmath55 and @xmath56 will be manifest in the following calculations of the tmd quark distributions @xmath13 and @xmath14 .
as shown below , their roles become so essential that we have to include them in the first place .
this can also be seen from the relations between @xmath13 ( @xmath14 ) and @xmath55 ( @xmath56 ) discussed in sec .
ii . ; ( b1)-(b4 ) , ( e1)-(e4 ) , ( c1 ) and ( c3 ) correspond to the diagrams contributions from @xmath111 ; and ( b1)-(e4 ) for @xmath112 .
_ , width=453 ] -0.4 cm we will take @xmath13 calculation as an example to show how we perform the computation at twist - three level with the quark gluon correlation functions @xmath17
( @xmath97 ) , @xmath18 ( @xmath108 ) , and @xmath55 .
the calculations for the tmd quark distribution @xmath14 and the drell - yan cross sections in the next section will follow accordingly . as outlined above , we first draw the associated feynman diagrams for the large transverse momentum @xmath13 quark distribution . in order to calculate the large transverse momentum behavior for the @xmath13 function , we have to radiate a hard gluon .
the relevant diagrams are plotted in fig . 2 , where the probing quark carries the momentum @xmath123 and the nucleon momentum is denoted by @xmath52 .
the double lines in these diagrams represent the gauge link expansion from the quark distribution definition in eq .
( 17 ) . again
, these diagrams include the contributions from the matrix element @xmath116 ( a1-a4 ) ; from @xmath124 ( b1-e4 ) . to obtain a complete result
, we have to attach the gluon to all possible places as shown in the diagrams ( b1-e4 ) .
this also guarantees that we will get the gauge invariant result .
the mirror diagrams of ( b1)-(e4 ) where the gluon attaches to the right of the cutting line of these diagrams were not shown in fig . 2 , but included in the final results .
part of the diagrams ( b1)-(e4 ) correspond to the contributions from @xmath125 , whereas all of them contribute to that from @xmath126 . to calculate the tmd quark distribution @xmath13 at large transverse momentum
, we first compute the individual contributions from the matrix elements shown in eq .
. then we will combine the individual results into the gauge invariant twist - three quark - gluon correlation functions defined in sec .
we can parameterize the associated matrix elements in eq .
( 32 ) which correspond to our calculations .
for example , the relevant @xmath127 matrix elements are parameterized as @xmath128 \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath129 and @xmath130 correspond to the parts in the gauge invariant functions @xmath17 and @xmath18 , respectively .
similarly , we can define the associated @xmath131 matrix elements , @xmath132 \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] notice that because of additional gluon attachment to the nucleon state , the above matrix elements will depend on two variables @xmath133 which represent the momentum fractions carried by the quarks from left and right sides of cut line in the diagrams . in the case
that there is no gluon attachment like that in eq .
( 33 ) , they are equal and become one variable . from the above matrix elements we can easily define those of @xmath134 , @xmath135 \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] at the same order , we shall also have the following matrix elements , @xmath136 \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] from the definitions in sec .
ii , we will find that the above matrix elements can form the following gauge invariant correlation functions , @xmath137 where we have used the time - reversal invariance to derive the last equation .
there is no similar relation for @xmath129 , which on the other hand can be related to @xmath138 depending on the choice of the boundary conditions for the gauge potential @xcite , @xmath139 it has been shown that the final results on the single spin asymmetries will not depend on the boundary conditions for the gauge potential , although they correspond to different relations between the matrix element @xmath140 and @xmath138 , and different contributions from individual diagrams @xcite .
having sorted out the above relations , it is relative straightforward to perform the calculations . as outlined above
, we will calculate the feynman diagram contributions in terms of the matrix elements at the right hand sides of eqs .
( 37 - 39 ) .
these results will be combined into the gauge invariant correlation functions at the left sides of eqs .
( 37 - 39 ) . in the following
, we will calculate these contributions separately , and show that how we will combine them into the gauge invariant results .
the contributions from @xmath130 and @xmath129 come from the diagrams figs .
2(a1-a4 ) . as mentioned above
, we will perform the collinear expansion to calculate their contributions .
that is , the hard partonic part illustrated in the upper parts of these diagrams can be expanded in terms of the transverse momentum of the quark connecting to the nucleon state in these diagrams ( see also fig .
this momentum can be parameterized as @xmath141 where @xmath27 is the longitudinal momentum fraction of the nucleon and @xmath142 is the transverse momentum .
in the collinear expansion , we take the approximation that @xmath143 , and only keep the leading non - trivial terms which are relevant for our calculations . for example , the hard partonic part @xmath144 can be expanded as @xmath145 where ellipsis stands for higher order expansion terms , @xmath146 is a transverse index @xmath147 .
the first term in the above expansion does not contribute to the tmd quark distribution @xmath148 at large transverse momentum .
the second term will lead to the contribution from the matrix element @xmath130 and @xmath129 . in the calculations , we substitute eq .
( 42 ) into the hard partonic part @xmath149 in the feynman diagrams of figs .
2(a1-a4 ) , and take the linear term in the expansion .
one particular contribution is the so - called derivative term , which comes from the expansion of the on - shell condition for the radiated gluon @xmath150 . to calculate this contribution
, we only keep the @xmath142 dependence in the delta function of the on - shell condition , and set @xmath151 for all other factors in the hard partonic scattering amplitude
. the final result will be proportional to the corresponding born diagram in the collinear limit @xcite , @xmath152 where @xmath95 and @xmath153 behavior comes from the power counting for the @xmath6-odd tmd quark distributions . for the non - derivative terms , we keep all @xmath142 dependence in the hard partonic scattering amplitude , and expand to the linear term in @xmath142 . although it is tedious , the calculation is straightforward , and we obtain @xmath154 \ , \ ] ] where @xmath106 has been introduced in sec .
after partial integrating for the derivative term , we can add these two terms eqs . ( 43 ) and ( 44 ) together , @xmath155 \ .\ ] ] similar calculations can be performed for the contributions from @xmath129 , and we find that it does not contribute to the tmd quark distribution @xmath148 . because the attaching gluon is transversely polarized ( @xmath160 ) , the contributions from the matrix elements @xmath156 and @xmath158 come from the diagrams figs .
2(b1-b4 ) , ( e1-e4 ) , ( c1 ) and ( c3 ) . to calculate the contributions from these diagrams , we take the kinematics illustrated in fig . 1(c ) , where the quark and gluon lines connecting the hard partonic part and the nucleon state only contain collinear momenta , @xmath161 where @xmath162 is the attaching gluon momentum .
these calculations are straightforward , and we obtain the contributions from @xmath156 , @xmath163 where we have used the symmetric property for @xmath164 to combine the results from fig . 2 and their mirrors .
because of additional gluon attachment in these diagrams , we will have two contributions from two different color factors , @xmath165 and @xmath166 .
similarly , we have the contribution from @xmath158 , @xmath167 moreover , the above results can be translated into the contributions from @xmath157 and @xmath159 .
this is because we have the following relations between the above matrix elements , @xmath168 where the imaginary parts in the right hand sides of the above equations have been dropped , because they do not contribute to the @xmath13 and @xmath14 calculations here .
however , when we calculate the single spin asymmetry observables ( such as the time - reversal - odd sivers and boer - mulders functions ) , we have to keep these imaginary parts in the above equations @xcite . substituting the above results into eqs .
( 47,48 ) , we shall obtain the contributions from the matrix elements @xmath157 and @xmath159 . for these contributions , it is the @xmath113 component connecting from the nucleon state to the hard partonic part , and the gluon can attach to the gauge links in the feynman diagrams .
therefore , we will have all diagrams in figs .
2(b1-e4 ) contributing to the final results .
moreover , since these matrix elements involve @xmath171 , we have to perform the collinear expansion of the hard partonic parts in terms of the gluon transverse momentum . in doing so ,
we keep both transverse momenta for the two quark lines connecting the hard part and the nucleon state , @xmath172 clearly , the kinematics tell us that @xmath173 and @xmath174 .
the corresponding collinear expansion of the hard partonic part takes the following form , @xmath175 again , the expansion coefficients in the above equation can be calculated following the same method as we discussed in the above for that for the @xmath130 contribution .
for example , there is also derivative terms associated with @xmath169 matrix element .
this contribution also comes from the expansion of the delta function for the on - shell condition for the radiated gluon @xmath176 .
the derivation for this part is similar , and we obtain the following result , @xmath177 where the same hard coefficient as that for @xmath178 appears as it should be due to the gauge invariance . as we mentioned above , this derivative term comes from the delta function expansion for the on - shell condition of @xmath176 . to calculate this contribution
, we only keep the @xmath179 dependence in this delta function , and set @xmath180 for all other factors in the hard partonic amplitude . because of this and the fact that it is the @xmath113 insertion in the hard part
, we can use the ward identity argument to summarize all diagrams into a simple factorization form : a product of hard partonic part in the born diagram without the gluon insertion and the factor @xmath181 representing the gluon insertion . because they have the same hard coefficient
, we can combine the derivative contributions from @xmath178 and @xmath169 together .
in particular , by using eq .
( 39 ) , we can add the results from eqs .
( 43 ) and ( 52 ) , @xmath182 in term of the gauge invariant correlation function @xmath55 .
this shows how we obtain the gauge invariant results from the individual contributions .
moreover , it also demonstrates that @xmath55 is an independent contribution to the large transverse momentum @xmath13 quark distribution .
the non - derivative contributions from @xmath169 can be calculated accordingly , by keeping all the @xmath179 dependence in the partonic amplitude .
the final result is , @xmath183+c_f \left ( \frac{x_b^2}{x^2}+\frac{x_b}{x_1}-\frac{2x_b^2}{x_1x}-\frac{x_b}{x}-1 \right ) \nonumber\\ & & \left.~~ + \frac{c_a}{2 } \frac{(x_b^2+xx_1)(2x_b - x - x_1)}{(x_b - x_1)(x - x_1)x_1 } \right\ } \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the above results , there are two terms with the color - factor @xmath165 .
clearly , one term will be combined with that of @xmath178 in eq .
( 44 ) to form the contribution from the gauge invariant function @xmath184 , similar to the case for the above derivative contributions . the other term will be combined with that of @xmath185 from eqs .
( 47,49 ) to form the contribution from the gauge invariant function @xmath186 .
similarly , we can calculate the contributions from the matrix element @xmath170 , @xmath187 again , this result will combine with that from @xmath159 from eq .
( 48,49 ) to form the gauge invariant result in terms of the gauge invariant function @xmath188 . combining all these results together
, we will obtain the final results for the tmd quark distribution @xmath148 at large transverse momentum , @xmath189 where @xmath190 is given by , @xmath191\delta(x - x_1 ) \right.\ + p\frac{1}{x - x_1}\tilde{t}_f(x , x_1 ) \nonumber\\ & & \times \left [ c_f \left ( \frac{x_b^2}{x^2}+\frac{x_b}{x_1}-\frac{2x_b^2}{x_1x}-\frac{x_b}{x}-1 \right ) + \frac{c_a}{2 } \frac{(x_b^2+xx_1)(2x_b - x - x_1)}{(x_b - x_1)(x - x_1)x_1 } \right ] \nonumber\\ & & + \left .\ \!\!\ !
p\frac{1}{x - x_1}t_f(x , x_1)\left [ c_f \left ( \frac{x_b^2}{x^2}+\frac{x_b}{x_1}-\frac{x_b}{x}-1 \right ) + \frac{c_a}{2 } \frac{x_b^2-xx_1}{(x_1-x_b)x_1 } \right ] \right \ } \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and we have partial integrated the derivative terms . using the identities eqs .
( 12 ) and ( 13 ) , @xmath192 can be transformed into the @xmath42-type correlation functions , @xmath193\delta(x - x_1 ) \right.\ \nonumber\\ & + & \tilde{g}_d(x , x_1)\left [ c_f \left ( \frac{x_b^2}{x^2}+\frac{x_b}{x_1}-\frac{2x_b^2}{x_1x}-\frac{x_b}{x}-1 \right ) + \frac{c_a}{2 } \frac{(x_b^2+xx_1)(2x_b - x - x_1)}{(x_b - x_1)(x - x_1)x_1 } \right ] \nonumber\\ & + & \left .\ \!\!\ !
g_d(x , x_1 ) \left [ c_f \left ( \frac{x_b^2}{x^2}+\frac{x_b}{x_1}-\frac{x_b}{x}-1 \right ) + \frac{c_a}{2 } \frac{x_b^2-xx_1}{(x_1-x_b)x_1 } \right ] \right \ } \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] this result can also be obtained by directly combining the contributions from @xmath130 in eq .
( 45 ) , @xmath156 in eq . ( 47 ) , and @xmath158 in eq .
( 48 ) . for tmd distribution @xmath11 , the perturbative calculation follow the similar procedure .
it receives contributions from @xmath194 , @xmath16 .
we skip the detailed derivation , and list the final result , @xmath195 where @xmath196 is defined by , @xmath197\delta(x_1-x ) + p \frac{1}{x - x_1 } \tilde{t}_f^{(\sigma)}(x , x_1 ) \right .\
\nonumber\\ & & \times \left .\ \!\!\ !
\tilde{t}_f^{(\sigma)}(x , x_1)\left [ c_f \frac{2(x - x_1-x_b)}{x_1 } + \frac{c_a}{2 } \frac{2x_b(x_b x + x_bx_1 -x^2-x_1 ^ 2)}{(x_b - x_1)(x - x_1)x_1 } \right ] \right \ } \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] similarly , it can be expressed in terms of the d - type function as , @xmath198 \delta(x_1-x ) \right .\
\nonumber\\ & + & \left .\ \!\!\ !
h_d(x , x_1)\left [ c_f \frac{2(x - x_1-x_b)}{x_1 } + \frac{c_a}{2 } \frac{2x_b(x_b x + x_bx_1 -x^2-x_1 ^ 2)}{(x_b - x_1)(x - x_1)x_1 } \right ] \right \ } \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] indeed , the above results for the naive - time - reversal - even but @xmath6-odd distributions also have the same structure as those discussed in sec.iii .
in this section , we will calculate the angular distribution of the lepton pair in the polarized drell - yan process , especially the @xmath3 and @xmath4 asymmetries : one of the incident hadrons is transverse polarized and another is unpolarized or longitudinal polarized .
we focus on the lepton pair production in hadronic scattering , @xmath199 which comes from the virtual photon decays . in the leading order , virtual photon is produced through quark - antiquark annihilation process , @xmath200 in the parton picture @xcite . in the rest frame of the lepton pair
, we can define two angles @xcite : one is the polar angle @xmath201 between one lepton momentum and the incident hadron ; the azimuthal angle @xmath202 is defined as the angle between the hadronic plane and the lepton plane .
the general formalism has been worked out for the angular distributions in the polarized drell - yan process @xcite . for our calculations of @xmath3 and @xmath4 , one can write down the following general structure of the angular distribution of lepton pair in the collins - soper ( cs ) frame @xcite , @xmath203 \nonumber \\ & & \!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\ ! \!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\ !
+ |s_{at}| s_{bl } \left [ \cos \phi_a \left ( ( 1+\cos^2\theta)w_t^{lt}+(1-\cos^2\theta)w_l^{lt}+\sin2\theta\cos\phi w_\delta^{lt } + \sin^2\theta \cos2 \phi w_{\delta\delta}^{lt } \right ) \right .\ \nonumber \\ & & \!\!\!\!\!\!\ ! \left .\ \left
.\ + \sin \phi_a \left ( \sin2\theta\sin\phi w_\delta^{'lt } + \sin^2\theta \sin2 \phi w_{\delta\delta}^{'lt } \right ) \right ] \
\right \ } \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the orientation of the transverse polarization of the hadron @xmath204 is expressed through the cs - angle @xmath205 , and @xmath202 and @xmath201 have been introduced above . in the above expressions ,
@xmath206 and @xmath207 are the hadron @xmath204 transverse polarization vector and hadron @xmath107 longitudinal polarization vector , respectively .
the angular - integrated cross section is expressed in terms of the @xmath208 , @xmath209 , @xmath210 and @xmath211 as @xcite , @xmath212 in particular , the structure function @xmath213 has been calculated@xcite , which represents the sivers contribution to the single transverse spin asymmetry . from the above expression , we also see that the sivers contribution is the only contribution to the single spin asymmetry when we integrate out the lepton angles . in the following
, we will calculate the structure functions @xmath214 and @xmath215 in eq .
( 63 ) in the intermediate transverse momentum region @xmath216 , and will compare the predictions from the collinear factorization and the transverse momentum dependent approaches . for the single spin asymmetry @xmath214 , we follow the previous calculations @xcite .
the only difference is that the calculation in @xcite is equivalent to the virtual photon production in single transversely polarized nucleon - nucleon scattering , whereas we will contract the hadronic tensor to the lepton tensor to obtain the angular distributions of the lepton pair in this process .
however , the technique method is the same . again , as discussed in @xcite , we will have soft pole and hard pole contributions , and they will have cancelation in the intermediated transverse momentum region . for the double spin asymmetry part @xmath215 , we will follow the procedure in sec .
iv to calculate the twist - three contributions to the angular distributions .
the corresponding correlation functions will be @xmath17 ( @xmath97 ) , @xmath18 ( @xmath108 ) , @xmath55 , and so on .
the similar feynman diagrams can be drawn accordingly , which can be organized into the contributions from the twist - three matrix elements @xmath217 , @xmath218 , and @xmath219 .
these contributions are then combined into the contributions for the gauge invariant correlation functions @xmath17 , @xmath18 , @xmath55 , and so on .
in order to calculate the different terms in the angular distribution eq .
( 62 ) , we choose to work in the collins - soper frame @xcite , where four orthogonal unit vectors are defined as , @xmath220 \ , \nonumber \\ & & x^\mu=- \frac{q}{q_\perp } \frac{2}{\sqrt{q^2+q_\perp^2 } } \left [ q_{\bar{p } } \tilde{p}^\mu + q_p \tilde{\bar{p}}^\mu \right ] \
, \nonumber \\ & & y_\mu=\epsilon^{\mu \nu \alpha \beta } t_\nu z_\alpha x_\beta \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath221 is the virtual photon momentum,@xmath222 are the momentum of two hadrons , and we further define @xmath223/ \sqrt{s}$ ] , @xmath224/ \sqrt{s}$ ] with @xmath225 and @xmath226 the total hadron center of mass energy square , respectively . the structure function can be obtained by contracting the hadronic tensor @xmath227 with six symmetric tensors constructed by the four orthogonal vectors , @xmath228 and similar expressions hold for the @xmath229 and @xmath230 structure functions .
furthermore , we are interested in the cross section contributions in the intermediate transverse momentum region , @xmath231 . to obtain the leading order contributions , we only keep the leading terms in @xmath232 , and neglect all higher order terms . with this power counting expansion ,
six leading order structure functions survive and can be simplified as , @xmath233 where @xmath95 , @xmath234 , @xmath235 and @xmath236 are defined as @xmath237 and @xmath238 with @xmath239 the rapidity of the lepton pair in the center of mass frame , respectively .
the functions @xmath240 , @xmath241 , @xmath192 , @xmath196 have been defined in sec .
iii with appropriate variable replacements .
the functions @xmath242 , @xmath243 , @xmath244 , @xmath245 are given by , @xmath246 \ , \\
b_{h_1^\perp}(z)&=&c_f t_f^{(\sigma)}(z , z ) \left [ \frac{2\xi}{(1-\xi)_+ } + 2 \delta(\xi-1 ) \rm{ln}\frac{q^2}{q_\perp^2 } \right ] \ , \\
b_{g_{1t}}(x)&=&c_f \tilde{g}(x ) \left [ \frac{1+\hat{\xi}^2}{(1-\hat{\xi})_+ } + 2 \delta(\hat{\xi}-1 ) \rm{ln}\frac{q^2}{q_\perp^2 } \right ] \ , \\ b_{h_{1l}}(z)&=&c_f \tilde{h}(z ) \left [ \frac{2\xi}{(1-\xi)_+ } + 2 \delta(\xi-1 ) \rm{ln}\frac{q^2}{q_\perp^2 } \right ] \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively .
meanwhile , the transverse momentum dependent factorization can be applied in the small transverse momentum , @xmath247 .
the relevant structure functions can be written as @xcite , @xmath248 where the simple integral symbol represents a complicated integral @xmath249 and @xmath250 , @xmath251 are the soft factor and hard factor , respectively .
in addition , the combinations of structure functions @xmath252
, @xmath253 also receive the leading power contribution from the product of tmd distributions @xmath254 and @xmath255 respectively , which is however beyond the scope of the present paper .
when the transverse momenta @xmath256 and @xmath257 are of order @xmath85 , the tmd distribution functions are entirely non - perturbative objects .
but in the large transverse momentum region @xmath258 , we can calculate the transverse momentum dependence , as shown in sec .
iii , to compare to the results from the collinear factorization calculation , we let one of the transverse momenta @xmath256 , @xmath257 , @xmath259 be of order @xmath0 , and the others are much smaller .
after integrating the delta function , we will obtain @xmath260 it is evident that the above results reproduce the differential cross sections we derived in the collinear factorization framework .
in this paper , we have calculated the naive - time - reversal - even but @xmath6-odd tmd distributions @xmath10 , @xmath261 at large transverse momentum , and they are related to a class of collinear twist - three matrix elements .
we further studied the angular distribution of the lepton pair produced in the polarized drell - yan process for the single spin asymmetry @xmath3 and double spin asymmetry @xmath4 using the higher twist collinear approach . by comparing these results with those from the transverse momentum dependent approach , we found that they are consistent in the intermediated transverse momentum region .
these calculations are not straightforward extensions of the previous calculations for the naive - time - reversal - odd tmd quark distributions @xcite .
this is because , in the previous case , a pole contribution has to be taken in the final results , which will simplify the calculations . in this paper , we have to deal with more complicated kinematics , similar to next - to - leading order perturbative calculations for the @xmath50 structure function @xcite . to carry out the calculations , we have set up the twist expansion framework , and in particular , we have shown that the contributions from twist - three matrix elements will combine into the gauge invariant form .
this shall encourage further developments in the higher - twist calculations .
for example , an extension to calculate the remaining tmd distributions @xmath262 would be possible , though it will be more complicated because it is related the twist four collinear matrix element . the formalism we developed in this paper can also be extended to other semi - inclusive processes , such as the semi - inclusive deep inelastic scattering and back - to - back two hadron production in @xmath263 annihilation processes .
we will address these issues in future publications .
this work was supported in part by the u.s .
department of energy under contract de - ac02 - 05ch11231 and the national natural science foundation of china under the approval no . 10525523 .
we are grateful to riken , brookhaven national laboratory and the u.s .
department of energy ( contract number de - ac02 - 98ch10886 ) for providing the facilities essential for the completion of this work .
is partially supported by china scholarship council .
g. bunce _
et al . _ ,
* 36 * , 1113 ( 1976 ) ; d. l. adams _ et al . _ [ e581 and e704 collaborations ] , phys .
b * 261 * , 201 ( 1991 ) ; d. l. adams _ et al . _
[ fnal - e704 collaboration ] , phys .
b * 264 * , 462 ( 1991 ) ; k. krueger _
et al . _ ,
b * 459 * , 412 ( 1999 ) .
a. airapetian _ et al . _
[ hermes collaboration ] , phys .
lett . * 84 * , 4047 ( 2000 ) ; phys . rev
. lett . * 94 * , 012002 ( 2005 ) . v.
y. alexakhin _ et al . _ [ compass collaboration ] , phys .
* 94 * , 202002 ( 2005 ) .
k. abe _ et al .
_ , phys .
lett . * 96 * , 232002 ( 2006 ) ; r. seidl _ et al . _ [ belle collaboration ] , phys .
d * 78 * , 032011 ( 2008 ) .
i. arsene _ et al . _
[ brahms collaboration ] , phys .
* 101 * , 042001 ( 2008 ) .
z. t. liang and t. c. meng , phys . rev .
d * 42 * , 2380 ( 1990 ) .
d * 49 * , 3759 ( 1994 ) . c. boros ,
z. t. liang and t. c. meng , phys .
lett . * 70 * , 1751 ( 1993 ) .
reviews for early work , see : m. anselmino , a. efremov and e. leader , phys .
rept . * 261 * , 1 ( 1995 ) [ erratum - ibid . *
281 * , 399 ( 1997 ) ] ; z. t. liang and c. boros , int .
j. mod .
a * 15 * , 927 ( 2000 ) ; v. barone , a. drago and p. g. ratcliffe , phys .
rept . * 359 * , 1 ( 2002 ) ; m. anselmino , m. boglione and f. murgia , phys .
b * 362 * , 164 ( 1995 ) ; m. anselmino and f. murgia , phys . lett .
b * 442 * , 470 ( 1998 ) ; m. anselmino , m. boglione , u. dalesio , e. leader and f. murgia , phys .
d * 71 * , 014002 ( 2005 ) .
j. c. collins , phys . lett .
b * 536 * , 43 ( 2002 ) .
x. ji and f. yuan , phys .
b * 543 * , 66 ( 2002 ) ; a. v. belitsky , x. ji and f. yuan , nucl .
b * 656 * , 165 ( 2003 ) .
d. boer , p. j. mulders and f. pijlman , nucl .
b * 667 * , 201 ( 2003 ) .
a. bacchetta , m. diehl , k. goeke , a. metz , p. j. mulders and m. schlegel , jhep * 0702 * , 093 ( 2007 ) .
s. arnold , a. metz and m. schlegel , phys . rev .
d * 79 * , 034005 ( 2009 ) .
a. v. efremov and o. v. teryaev , sov .
j. nucl .
* 36 * , 140 ( 1982 ) [ yad .
fiz . * 36 * , 242 ( 1982 ) ] ; a. v. efremov and o. v. teryaev , phys .
b * 150 * , 383 ( 1985 ) .
qiu and g. sterman , phys .
lett . * 67 * , 2264 ( 1991 ) ; nucl .
b * 378 * , 52 ( 1992 ) ; phys .
d * 59 * , 014004 ( 1998 ) .
x. ji , j. w. qiu , w. vogelsang and f. yuan , phys .
* 97 * , 082002 ( 2006 ) ; phys .
d * 73 * , 094017 ( 2006 ) ; phys .
b * 638 * , 178 ( 2006 ) .
y. koike , w. vogelsang and f. yuan , phys .
b * 659 * , 878 ( 2008 ) .
j. zhou , f. yuan and z. t. liang , phys .
d * 78 * , 114008 ( 2008 ) .
f. yuan and j. zhou , phys .
lett . * 103 * , 052001 ( 2009 ) . s. d. drell and t. m. yan , phys .
* 25 * , 316 ( 1970 ) [ erratum - ibid . *
25 * , 902 ( 1970 ) ] .
j. c. collins and d. e. soper , phys .
d * 16 * , 2219 ( 1977 ) . c. s. lam and w. k. tung , phys .
d * 18 * , 2447 ( 1978 ) ; phys .
b * 80 * , 228 ( 1979 ) ; phys .
d * 21 * , 2712 ( 1980 ) .
r. l. jaffe and x. d. ji , nucl .
b * 375 * , 527 ( 1992 ) .
r. l. jaffe and x. d. ji , phys .
lett . * 67 * , 552 ( 1991 ) .
r. k. ellis , w. furmanski and r. petronzio , nucl .
b * 207 * , 1 ( 1982 ) ; nucl .
b * 212 * , 29 ( 1983 ) .
i. i. balitsky and v. m. braun , nucl .
b * 311 * , 541 ( 1989 ) ; p.
g. ratcliffe , nucl .
b * 264 * , 493 ( 1986 ) ; x. d. ji and c. h. chou , phys .
d * 42 * , 3637 ( 1990 ) ; y. koike and k. tanaka , phys .
d * 51 * , 6125 ( 1995 ) ; j. kodaira , y. yasui , k. tanaka and t. uematsu , phys .
b * 387 * , 855 ( 1996 ) ; a. v. belitsky and d. mueller , nucl . phys .
b * 503 * , 279 ( 1997 ) ; a. v. belitsky , nucl .
b * 558 * , 259 ( 1999 ) ; a. v. belitsky , nucl .
b * 574 * , 407 ( 2000 ) ; a. v. belitsky , x. d. ji , w. lu and j. osborne , phys .
d * 63 * , 094012 ( 2001 ) .
i. i. balitsky , v. m. braun , y. koike and k. tanaka , phys .
lett . * 77 * , 3078 ( 1996 ) .
x. d. ji and j. osborne , nucl .
b * 608 * , 235 ( 2001 ) .
j. zhou , f. yuan and z. t. liang , phys .
d * 79 * , 114022 ( 2009 ) .
j. c. collins , d. e. soper and g. sterman , nucl .
b * 250 * , 199 ( 1985 ) .
s. j. brodsky and g. r. farrar , phys .
lett . * 31 * , 1153 ( 1973 ) ; v. a. matveev , r. m. muradian and a. n. tavkhelidze , lett .
nuovo cim .
* 7 * , 719 ( 1973 ) ; x. ji , j. p. ma and f. yuan , phys .
lett . * 90 * , 241601 ( 2003 ) .
y. koike and t. tomita , arxiv:0903.1923 [ hep - ph ] .
d. boer and w. vogelsang , phys .
d * 74 * , 014004 ( 2006 ) .
e. l. berger , j. w. qiu and r. a. rodriguez - pedraza , phys .
b * 656 * , 74 ( 2007 ) ; phys .
d * 76 * , 074006 ( 2007 ) . | we study the spin - dependent quark distributions at large transverse momentum .
we derive their transverse momentum behaviors in the collinear factorization approach in this region .
we further calculate the angular distribution of the drell - yan lepton pair production with polarized beams and present the results in terms of the collinear twist - three quark - gluon correlation functions . in the intermediate transverse momentum region , we find that the two approaches : the collinear factorization and the transverse momentum dependent factorization approaches are consistent in the description of the lepton pair angular distributions . |
most stars , particularly high - mass stars ( @xmath6@xmath78@xmath8 ) , form in clusters ( lada @xmath9 lada 2003 ) .
stellar clusters form in dense and massive molecular clumps ( size@xmath3@xmath71 pc , mass@xmath3@xmath71001000 @xmath10 , density @xmath310@xmath11 @xmath12 ) @xcite .
the gas in these clumps can be significantly affected by the feedback from newly formed stars , thus blurring our understanding of cluster formation . to explore the initial conditions and details of cluster formation , it is then necessary to study molecular clouds in the early stages of evolution at high - angular resolution ( e.g. , higuchi et al .
high - mass stars are usually deeply embedded in their parent cloud , obscuring their early formative stages .
their formation timescales of @xmath3 10@xmath13 yr are short , and they form in distant clusters and associations ( e.g. , mckee @xmath9 ostriker 2007 ; zinnecker @xmath9 yorke 2007 ) .
these factors also contribute to our poor understanding of their formation processes .
high angular resolution observations are indispensable in the efforts to unveil the mystery of high - mass star formation .
millimeter and sub - millimeter interferometric observations have contributed largely to the current knowledge of high - mass star formation .
the atacama large millimeter / submillimeter array ( alma ) provides the high sensitivity , angular resolution , and dynamic range to improve our understanding of the formation processes of high - mass stars .
iras16547@xmath24247 is a luminous infrared source ( bolometric luminosity of 6.2 @xmath14 10@xmath15 @xmath16 ) , located at a distance of @xmath32.9 kpc @xcite .
single - dish dust continuum observations show that the iras source corresponds to a dense molecular clump with a mass of 1.3 @xmath14 10@xmath17 @xmath10 and a radius of 0.2 pc @xcite .
very large array ( vla ) radio continuum observations revealed the presence of a thermal radio jet located at the center of the core @xcite .
@xcite detected , in addition , several fainter radio sources suggesting that they are probably members of a young cluster .
@xcite identified a large scale bipolar @xmath0co(@xmath18=32 ) outflow , which is roughly oriented in the north - south direction and centered at the position of the jet source . @xcite reported 1.3 mm dust continuum and so@xmath5 observations made with the submillimeter array ( sma ) .
they found that the so@xmath5 emission traces a small molecular structure associated with the jet exhibiting a velocity gradient and proposed the existence of keplerian rotation .
high angular resolution observations of the high - velocity outflows towards iras16547@xmath24247 have not , however , been carried out . in this paper
, we present @xmath305 resolution images of the dust continuum and @xmath0co(@xmath18=32)[hereafter @xmath0co(32 ) ] and ch@xmath1oh(@xmath19=0,@xmath20=7@xmath216@xmath21)[hereafter ch@xmath1oh(76 ) ] line emission using alma .
the goal is to determine the spatial distribution and velocity structure of the gas around the center of iras16547@xmath24247 , in order to explore the dynamical processes associated with the information of high - mass stars formation .
iras16547@xmath24247 was observed with alma @xcite during early science cycle 0 in its extended configuration , using the band 7 receivers .
the observations were done in 4 executions with 32 12-m antennas at an angular resolution of @xmath305 . at the distance of iras16547@xmath24247 ( [email protected] kpc ) , the angular size corresponds to 0.007 pc . in this work , we present results of the 880 @xmath22 m dust continuum emission , @xmath0co(32 ) [ frequency of 345.796 ghz ] and ch@xmath1oh(76 ) [ frequency of 338.409 ghz ] lines ( see figure [ fig1 ] ) .
the alma calibration includes simultaneous observations of the 183 ghz water line with water vapor radiometers that measure the water column in the antenna beam , later used to reduce the atmospheric phase noise .
amplitude calibration was done using titan .
the quasars 3c279 and j1604 - 446 were used to calibrate the bandpass and the complex gain fluctuations , respectively .
the continuum map was obtained from a combination of all the line - free channels .
briggs weighting with a robust parameter of @xmath230.5 was used in both continuum and line images .
data reduction was performed using version 3.4 of the common astronomy software applications package ( http://casa.nrao.edu ) .
the casa task @xmath24 was used to fourier - transform the visibility data and deconvolve the dirty images , at an velocity interval of 0.44 km s@xmath25 .
figure [ fig2](a ) shows the alma 880 @xmath26 dust continuum map at a 05 resolution .
we resolved the sma submillimeter source reported by @xcite into two sources separated by @xmath32@xmath27 ( core - a and core - b in figure [ fig2](a ) ) . by using the casa task @xmath28 ,
a gaussian fit to the continuum emission was performed .
we obtain that the peak flux density at 880 @xmath26 is 420@xmath2930 mjy beam@xmath25 for core - a and 100@xmath2910 mjy beam@xmath25 for core - b .
the deconvolved sizes are 11@xmath1407 with a p.a.=127@xmath30 ( integrated flux : 2.2 jy ) for core - a and 28@xmath1410 with a p.a.=69@xmath30 ( integrated flux : 1.7 jy ) for core - b .
the peak position of core - a , ( @xmath31 , @xmath32)=16@xmath3358@xmath3417@xmath35217 , @xmath2 @xmath3642@xmath3052@xmath3707@xmath3847 , agrees with the peak position derived from the sma observations at 1.3 mm @xcite . assuming that the emission at 880 @xmath26 corresponds to optically thin thermal dust emission , a gas - to - dust ratio of 100 , a dust temperature of 100 k @xcite , a dust mass opacity of @xmath39=1.8 @xmath40g@xmath25 @xcite , and that this object is located at 2.9 kpc
, we estimate total h@xmath5 mass , @xmath41(h@xmath5 ) , of 15 @xmath10 for core - a and 12 @xmath10 for core - b . we stress that both cores have similar masses because core - b is defined over a range with an area of four times larger than that of core - a .
figure [ fig1 ] shows the spectra of the @xmath0co(32 ) and ch@xmath1oh(76 ) lines integrated within a 23@xmath27@xmath1423@xmath27 region centered on the continuum source .
the @xmath0co(32 ) spectrun shows wings " at high velocities that can be attributed to the molecular outflows .
in fact , we found multiple outflows in the integrated intensity maps ( see sections [ out1 ] , [ out2 ] , and figures [ fig2](b ) and [ fig4 ] ) . a broad absorption line , ranging from @xmath4236 to @xmath225 km s@xmath25 with a minimum at @xmath229 km s@xmath25 , and a few narrow absorption lines with the deepest one centered at @xmath221.6 km s@xmath25 are also seen in the @xmath0co(32 ) spectrum .
narrow absorption lines might be caused by the cold cloud at foreground , and broad absorption line might be generated by combination of spatial filtering ( e.g. , resolve out ) and absorption .
the ch@xmath1oh spectrum exhibits emission in a narrower velocity range than that of the @xmath0co(32 ) spectrum . from atacama pathfinder experiment ( apex ) observations ( angular resolution
@xmath3 20 ) , @xcite identified a large scale @xmath0co(32 ) bipolar outflow , with lobes roughly aligned in the north - south direction .
the blue - shifted lobe , velocity range from @xmath260 to @xmath238 km s@xmath25 , extends up to @xmath350@xmath27 to the south from the jet source while the red - shifted lobe , velocity range from @xmath222 to @xmath20.8 km s@xmath25 , extends up to @xmath350@xmath27 to the north .
the spectrum of the spatially integrated @xmath0co(32 ) line emission observed with alma is quite similar to the apex @xmath0co(32 ) spectrum centered on the jet source , and both show broad absorption lines .
the broad absorption line feature is most likely produced by the colder , collapsing envelope surrounding the central sources .
figure [ fig2](b ) shows @xmath0co(32 ) integrated intensity maps of the blue - shifted ( velocity range from @xmath270 to @xmath245.8 km s@xmath25 ) and red - shifted ( velocity range from @xmath215.9 to @xmath238.8 km s@xmath25 ) wing emission .
the dust continuum emission is overlaid in black contours . from figure [ fig2](b ) , we identified two bipolar outflows , one aligned in the northeast - southwest direction ( outflow-1 , r1-b1 in figure [ fig2](b ) ) , and the other aligned in the northwest - southeast direction ( outflow-2 , r2-b2 in figure [ fig2](b ) ) . the velocity ranges were selected to separate distinct features of both outflows lobes .
these outflows appear at considerably smaller angular scales than the wide - angle bipolar outflow detected with apex and their position angles are different .
we found another red - shifted component associated with the s1 h@xmath5o maser cluster to the south of the continuum peak .
for s1 , @xcite suggested the existence of a yso candidate associated with this component from their vla observations .
this yso may have a different systemic velocity from that of the central continuum source , thus the @xmath0co(32 ) component appeared to be dominantly red - shifted with reference to the systemic velocity of the central object .
in fact , we found a faint blue - shifted component , with a velocity range from @xmath255 to @xmath232 km s@xmath25 , associated with s1 .
our observations also support the existence of another source as suggested by @xcite . for the discussion
, we also plot the positions of the h@xmath5o ( g1 and g2 in figure [ fig2](a ) ) and ch@xmath1oh maser clusters ( pink crosses in figure [ fig4 ] ) detected by @xcite and @xcite , respectively .
there are several transitions of ch@xmath1oh between 338.3 ghz and 338.7 ghz and many of them were detected with alma . for the discussion here , we selected the strongest line corresponding to @xmath19=0 , @xmath20=7@xmath216@xmath21 , a - type transition at 338.409 ghz @xcite , hereafter ch@xmath1oh(76 ) .
figure [ fig3](a ) shows the velocity integrated intensity map of the ch@xmath1oh(76 ) emission ( color and contours ) .
the ch@xmath1oh(76 ) emission from the central region is strong and well correlated with the dust continuum emission . at fainter levels , the ch@xmath1oh(76 )
emission appears as weak filaments elongated to the northeast , southeast , northwest , and southwest , forming an hourglass structure . in order to investigate the detailed velocity structure of the ch@xmath1oh(76 ) emission ,
we produced first and second moment maps ( figures [ fig3](b ) and [ fig3](c ) , respectively ) .
in the first moment map , we see towards the central region a similar velocity gradient as is seen in so@xmath5 , which might be keplerian rotation @xcite . in the second moment map ,
the region associated with dust continuum emission exhibits a large velocity dispersion of @xmath310 km s@xmath25 .
ch@xmath1oh is predominantly formed on grain surfaces @xcite .
although small ch@xmath1oh abundances can be found in cold , quiescent environments @xcite , ch@xmath1oh is largely released into the gas phase by processes related to active star - formation : heating from protostars or sputtering of the grain mantles produced by the interaction of molecular outflows and the ambient gas ( e.g. , sakai et al .
2013 ; yanagida et al .
2014 ) . to compare the ch@xmath1oh(76 ) emission with that of the outflows ,
we show the second moment map of ch@xmath1oh(76 ) emission overlaid with the velocity integrated maps of the blue - shifted and red - shifted @xmath0co(32 ) emission in figure [ fig4 ] .
we find that the northeast and southwest walls of the ch@xmath1oh(76 ) hourglass structure are located at the edge of the northeast and southwest lobes of outflow-1 , respectively , suggesting a relationship .
we also find that the red - shifted component of outflow-2 , r1 is associated with the ring - like wall located southeast of the central source . in addition , there is a good correlation between the spatial distribution of the ch@xmath1oh(76 ) emission and the ch@xmath1oh maser spots . from all these results ,
we conclude that the ch@xmath1oh(76 ) emission traces zones of post shocked gas produced by the interaction of multiple outflows with the ambient gas within the iras16547@xmath24247 region .
h@xmath5o masers @xcite and class i ch@xmath1oh maser clusters @xcite have been detected towards the iras16547@xmath24247 region ( see figures [ fig2](a ) and [ fig4 ] ) . in high - mass star - forming regions , h@xmath5o masers
are predominantly located within a few milliarcseconds from the central driving sources , tracing gas motions in the vicinity of the protostar @xcite . on the other hand ,
class i ch@xmath1oh maser clusters are usually excited at the shocked interface between a high - velocity jet , or outflow , and the ambient gas cloud .
the g1 and g2 h@xmath5o masers detected by @xcite are located within the continuum peak and close to the centers of the two bipolar outflows ( see figure [ fig2](a ) and ( b ) ) , suggesting that they could mark the position of the driving sources of the outflows .
higher angular resolution observations are required to identify the driving sources and make a more precise relation with g1 and g2 .
in addition , the h@xmath5o masers located at the position of s1 are most likely excited by a different yso , thus adding to the multiplicity of the protostars in the region .
figure [ fig4 ] indicates the spatial distribution of the four class i ch@xmath1oh maser clusters , @xcite present within the field of the alma observations .
there are four class i ch@xmath1oh maser clusters in figure [ fig4 ] .
the clusters located northeast and southwest of the central source roughly aligns with outflow-1 , while the maser cluster seen towards the northwest aligns with the blue - shifted lobe of outflow-2 , b2 .
the dashed lines in figure [ fig4 ] indicate the directions of the outflows estimated by using the position of ch@xmath1oh maser clusters .
the northern cluster coincides with the location of the the jet knots of @xcite , and may have been excited by the shock influence of the jet . a schematic diagram to visualize the star formation activities in the region based on previous observations and our alma results
is shown in figure [ fig5 ] . in an attempt to explain the observed morphology of the shocks traced by the ch@xmath1oh(76 ) emission , we discuss two possible scenarios that may be responsible for the hourglass structure seen in figures [ fig3 ] and [ fig4 ] .
the first of the plausible scenarios is the precession of the biconical jet reported by @xcite(see figure [ fig4 ] ) .
the interaction of the high - velocity precessing jet with the dense ambient medium results in strong shocks , which will trace a larger biconical structure ( as seen in the morphology of the narrow - angle ch@xmath1oh(76 ) wall ) . assuming that the opening angle of the observed narrow - angle ch@xmath1oh(76 ) wall is the angle subtended by the minor axis at a distance of one - half the major axis
, we derived the opening angle of the narrow - angle ch@xmath1oh(76 ) wall to be @xmath345 @xmath30 .
the jet has an opening angle of 15@xmath30 , implying that the jet will need to precess through 30@xmath30 to create the observed narrow - angle ch@xmath1oh(76 ) wall .
@xcite assumed that the jet seems to be precessing linearly with time , and derived a precession rate , @xmath43 , of [email protected] yr@xmath25 ( @xmath43=@xmath44@xmath45 , with @xmath44@[email protected] arcsec@xmath25 and a jet velocity , @xmath45 , of @xmath3490 km s@xmath25 as in rodrguez et al .
2008 ) . assuming that these rates of the n1 and s1 represent the precession rate of the entire jet
, we estimated that it would take the collimated precessing jet about @xmath3 380 yr to produce the observed morphology .
the second scenario is that of multiple , or at least two , driving sources powering intersecting outflows .
@xcite showed two outflow lobes , which may be suggestive of a single driving source .
but @xmath0co(32 ) at high - angular resolution with alma shows two outflows ; one aligned in northwest - southeast direction , and the other one aligned in the northeast - southwest direction ( figures [ fig2](b ) and [ fig4 ] ) .
this points to the multiplicity of the protostars driving outflows in the region .
this agrees with the distribution of the class i ch@xmath1oh masers of @xcite , which also suggest the presence of more than one outflow source in the region .
the complexity of the outflow structures could be explained by interaction of the outflowing materials from different driving sources .
we thank the anonymous referee for constructive comments that helped to improve this manuscript .
we also thank the alma staff for the observations during the commissioning stage .
g.g . acknowledges support from conicyt project
this letter makes use of the following alma data : ads / jao.alma 2011.0.00419.s .
alma is a partnership of eso ( representing its member states ) , nsf ( usa ) , and nins ( japan ) , together with nrc ( canada ) , nsc , and asiaa ( taiwan ) , in cooperation with the republic of chile .
the joint alma observatory is operated by eso , aui / nrao , and naoj .
data analysis were carried out on common use data analysis computer system at the astronomy data center , adc , of the national astronomical observatory of japan .
finally , we acknowledge masao saito for his contribution to our study . | we present the results of continuum and @xmath0co(32 ) and ch@xmath1oh(76 ) line observations of iras16547@xmath24247 made with the atacama large millimeter / submillimeter array ( alma ) at an angular resolution of @xmath305 .
the @xmath0co(32 ) emission shows two high - velocity outflows whose driving sources are located within the dust continuum peak .
the alignment of these outflows do not coincide with that of the wide - angle , large scale , bipolar outflow detected with apex in previous studies .
the ch@xmath1oh(76 ) line emission traces an @xmath4 structure associated with the cavity walls created by the outflow lobes .
taking into account our results together with the position of the h@xmath5o and class i ch@xmath1oh maser clusters , we discuss two possible scenarios that can explain the hourglass structure observed in iras16547@xmath24247 : ( 1 ) precession of a biconical jet , ( 2 ) multiple , or at least two , driving sources powering intersecting outflows . combining the available evidence , namely , the presence of two cross - aligned bipolar outflows and two different h@xmath5o maser groups , we suggest that iras16547@xmath24247 represents an early formation phase of a protocluster . |
we consider the elliptic system @xmath0 where @xmath1 a nonnegative @xmath2 potential possessing several minima and @xmath3 .
the system is variational with associated functional @xmath4 in what follows , we take @xmath5 to be a bounded , open , and connected set in @xmath6 , with lipschitz boundary .
we introduce the hypothesis * ( h ) * _ let @xmath7 , with @xmath8 , be a strictly increasing function on @xmath9 .
the vector @xmath10 is a global minimum of @xmath11 and @xmath12 is positive and fixed .
_ note that ( h ) is a very weak nondegeneracy hypothesis that was introduced in @xcite .
the main purpose of this note is to establish the following let @xmath5 be as above and let @xmath13 be an open , lipschitz set with @xmath14 .
moreover , suppose that 1 .
@xmath15 , 2 .
@xmath16 on @xmath17 , for some @xmath18 with @xmath19 , 3 .
there is an @xmath20 such that @xmath21
. then , there exists @xmath22 such that @xmath23 we note that in the lemma , no _ a priori _ bound is imposed on the @xmath24 and , thus , the lemma is not of local nature .
its meaning is that from the point of view of minimizing @xmath25 for a function that is in part close to the minimum value of @xmath11 , independently of the structure of @xmath11 , it is more efficient to remain close to the minimum throughout ( see figure [ figure1 ] ) .
( 0,0 ) ( 4597,2059)(3403,-4020 ) ( 3491,-3464)@xmath18 ( 4191,-2815)@xmath26 ( 4191,-3860)@xmath27 ( 3463,-2366)@xmath12 we will illustrate the lemma above by establishing the following pointwise estimate .
let @xmath28 and let @xmath11 have exactly one global minimum at @xmath29 on the right half - plane @xmath30 , while @xmath31 in @xmath32 . consider the family of variational problems @xmath33 with corresponding global minimizers @xmath34 and suppose that 1 .
@xmath35 maps @xmath36 in @xmath37 , ( positivity ) 2 .
@xmath38 , where @xmath39 a universal constant , 3 .
@xmath40 on @xmath41 and @xmath42 on the remaining three sides of @xmath43 .
then , there exist @xmath44 , @xmath45 , and @xmath46 such that @xmath47 for all @xmath48 and @xmath49 .
the proof of the corollary is a two - dimensional measure - theoretic argument , where the kinetic and potential terms in the energy are estimated independently .
it would be very interesting to extend this to higher dimensions .
the one - dimensional version of the lemma above appeared in @xcite , and subsequently in @xcite , where an extension from balls to convex sets was given . for hypotheses ( i ) and ( ii ) see @xcite , @xcite .
we utilize the polar representation @xmath50 and note that @xmath51 now , define @xmath57 as follows .
@xmath58 notice that @xmath57 is continuous on @xmath59
. there also holds @xmath60 in @xmath61 .
it follows that @xmath62 and , moreover , @xmath63 hence , @xmath64 in @xmath65 as @xmath66 , and by weak lower semi - continuity , @xmath67 clearly @xmath68 finally , @xmath69 by ( h ) , ( iii ) , and the hypothesis @xmath70 , @xmath71 therefore , @xmath72 and so , @xmath73 .
_ finally , suppose that @xmath18 is a critical value of @xmath93 in @xmath56 .
we can choose a decreasing and noncritical sequence @xmath94 .
then , the hypotheses ( i ) , ( ii ) , ( iii ) of the lemma are satisfied with @xmath95 and , thus , we obtain a sequence @xmath96 with the following properties : @xmath97 moreover , by construction , @xmath98 hence , by taking possibly a subsequence , there holds @xmath99 in @xmath65 as @xmath100 and thus , @xmath101 by the compactness of the embedding @xmath102 and from @xmath103 we obtain @xmath104 however , @xmath105 thus , it follows that @xmath23 from the definition of @xmath112 , we conclude that for @xmath113 there is an interval @xmath114 of @xmath115 values such that @xmath116 it follows that @xmath117 moreover , we have @xmath118 from ( [ w - w - estimate ] ) and ( [ r - l - estimate ] ) we have @xmath119 consequently , if we take @xmath122 large , we obtain that @xmath123 if we take @xmath124 and fix it , then @xmath125 and therefore there is an @xmath126 , which does not belong to @xmath127 , and such that @xmath128 g. alberti .
variational models for phase transitions , an approach via @xmath136-convergence . in _ calculus of variations and partial differential equations _ ,
l. ambrosio and n. dancer , edited by g. buttazzo , a. marino , and m. k. v. murthy .
springer , 2000 . | we establish a replacement lemma for a variational problem , which is not based on a local argument .
we then apply it to a phase transition problem and obtain pointwise estimates . |
this paper focuses on a random partial differential equation consisting of a parabolic pde with irregular noise in the drift .
formulation , existence ( with uniqueness in a certain sense ) and double probabilistic representation are discussed .
the equation itself is motivated by _
random irregular media models_. let @xmath0 , @xmath1 be a continuous function and @xmath2 a generalized random field playing the role of a noise .
let @xmath3 ,
@xmath4 \times{\mathbb r}\rightarrow{\mathbb r}$ ] be continuous . consider the problem @xmath5 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber v(0,x ) & = & u^0 ( x),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath6 is the derivative in the sense of distributions of a continuous process . among examples of possible @xmath7
, we have in mind not only different possibilities of continuous processes as classical wiener process and ( multi ) fractional brownian motion , but also non - gaussian processes .
the derivative in the sense of distributions @xmath2 will be the associated noise .
( [ ei-0 ] ) is a new type of spde , not yet studied in any real depth even when @xmath7 is a classical brownian motion .
for the situation where @xmath2 is replaced by a space - time white noise @xmath8 , some relevant work was done by nualart and viens ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) . in this article ,
time dependence is useful for the corresponding stochastic integration .
equation ( [ ei-0 ] ) is equivalent to the following _ dual _ problem : @xmath9 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber u(t , x ) & = & u^0 ( x).\end{aligned}\ ] ] formally speaking , setting @xmath10 , @xmath11 solves ( [ ei-0 ] ) if and only if @xmath12 solves ( [ ei-0dual ] ) .
this is rigorously confirmed in section [ s9 ] so that at this stage , the choice of whether to work with equation ( [ ei-0 ] ) or ( [ ei-0dual ] ) is arbitrary .
we have decided to concentrate on equation ( [ ei-0dual ] ) because it corresponds to the standard form for probabilistic representation .
the idea of this paper is to first freeze the realization @xmath13 , to set @xmath14 and then to consider the deterministic cauchy problem associated with ( [ ei-0dual ] ) , @xmath15 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber u(t , x ) & = & u^0 ( x),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath16 is the derivative of the continuous function @xmath17 . since the product of a distribution and a continuous function
is not defined in the theory of schwarz distributions , we must develop some substitution tools .
ideally , we would like to represent the parabolic pde probabilistically through a diffusion which is the solution of the stochastic differential equation ( sde ) @xmath18 with generalized drift .
we will give a meaning to ( [ ei-2 ] ) at three different levels : * the level of a martingale problem ; * the level of a stochastic differential equation in the sense of probability laws ; * the level of a stochastic differential equation in the strong sense .
for each of these levels , we shall provide conditions for equation ( [ ei-2 ] ) , with given initial data , to be well posed .
later , the notion of a @xmath19-solution to the generalized parabolic pde ( [ ei-0det ] ) will be defined ; related to this , existence , uniqueness and probabilistic representation will be shown . when @xmath7 is a strong finite cubic variation process and @xmath20 , the solutions to ( [ ei-0det ] ) obtained for @xmath21 provide solutions to the spde ( [ ei-0 ] ) .
this is shown in the last part of the paper .
a typical example of a strong zero cubic variation process is the fractional brownian motion with hurst index @xmath22 .
equation ( [ ei-0det ] ) will be understood in some _ weak distributional _ sense that we can formally reconstruct as follows .
we freeze @xmath21 as a realization and formally integrate equation ( [ ei-0 ] ) from @xmath23 to @xmath24 in time against a smooth test function @xmath25 with compact support in space .
the result is @xmath26 the integral @xmath27 needs interpretation since @xmath17 is not generally of bounded variation and it involves the product of the distribution @xmath16 and the function @xmath28 ; in general , this function is , unfortunately , only continuous .
as expected this operation is deterministically undefined , unless one uses a generalized functions theory .
however , since @xmath17 is a frozen realization of a stochastic process @xmath7 , we can hope to justify the integral in a stochastic sense .
note that it can not be of it type , even if @xmath7 were a semimartingale , since @xmath29 is not necessarily adapted to some corresponding filtration .
we will , in fact , interpret the stochastic integral element @xmath30 or @xmath31 as a symmetric ( stratonovich ) integral @xmath32 of regularization type ; see section [ s3 ] .
[ dei-1rig ] a continuous random field @xmath33 , x \in{\mathbb r } ) $ ] , a.s . in @xmath340,t [ \times{\mathbb r})$ ] , is said to be a ( _ weak _ ) _ solution _ to the spde ( [ ei-0 ] ) if @xmath35 for every smooth function with compact support @xmath25 .
if we integrate equation ( [ ei-0dual ] ) from @xmath24 to @xmath36 in time against a smooth test function @xmath25 with compact support in space , we are naturally led to the following .
[ dei-1dual ] a continuous random field @xmath37 , x \in{\mathbb r } ) $ ] , a.s . in @xmath340,t [ \times{\mathbb r})$ ] ,
is said to be a ( _ weak _ ) _ solution _ to the spde ( [ ei-0dual ] ) if @xmath38 for every smooth function with compact support @xmath25 .
we will show that the _ probabilistic _
solutions that we construct through stochastic equation ( [ ei-2 ] ) will , in fact , solve ( [ ei-1 ] ) .
diffusions in the generalized sense were studied by several authors beginning with ( at least to our knowledge ) @xcite .
later , many authors considered special cases of stochastic differential equations with generalized coefficients .
it is difficult to quote them all . in particular
, we refer to the case when @xmath17 is a measure @xcite . in all of these cases ,
solutions were semimartingales .
more recently , @xcite considered special cases of nonsemimartingales solving stochastic differential equations with generalized drift ; those cases include examples coming from bessel processes .
@xcite and @xcite treated well - posedness of the martingale problem , it s formula under weak conditions , semimartingale characterization and the lyons zheng decomposition .
the only assumption was the strict positivity of @xmath39 and the existence of the function @xmath40 with appropriate regularizations .
bass and chen @xcite were also interested in ( [ ei-2 ] ) and provided a well - stated framework when @xmath39 is @xmath41-hlder continuous and @xmath17 is @xmath42-hlder continuous , @xmath43 . beside the martingale problem , in the present paper
, we shall emphasize the formulation of ( [ ei-2 ] ) as a stochastic differential equation which can be solved by introducing more assumptions on the coefficients .
several examples are provided for the case of weak and strong solutions of ( [ ei-2 ] ) .
the paper is organized as follows .
section [ s2 ] is devoted to basic preliminaries , including definitions and properties related to young integrals .
section [ s3 ] is devoted to some useful remainder in stochastic calculus via regularization . in section [ s4 ]
, we introduce the formal _ elliptic _ operator @xmath44 and recall the concept of a @xmath45-generalized solution of @xmath46 for continuous real functions @xmath47 .
we further introduce a fundamental hypothesis on @xmath44 for the sequel , called technical assumption , and we illustrate several examples where it is verified . in section [ s5 ] ,
we discuss different notions of martingale problems .
section [ s6 ] provides notions of solutions to _ stochastic differential equations with distributional drift _ and their connections with martingale problems .
the notion of solution is coupled with a property of _ extended local time regularity_. this concept of solution is new , even when the drift is an ordinary function .
section [ s7 ] presents the notion of a @xmath19-solution for a parabolic equation @xmath48 , where @xmath49 is bounded and continuous with @xmath50 .
we also provide existence , uniqueness and probabilistic representations of @xmath19-solutions to @xmath51 .
section [ s8 ] discusses _ mild _ solutions to the previous parabolic pde and useful integrability properties for its solutions . in section [ s9 ]
, we finally show that the @xmath19-solutions provide , in fact , true _
weak _ solutions to the spde ( [ ei-0 ] ) if @xmath20 .
in this paper , @xmath36 will be a fixed horizon time , unless otherwise specified . a function @xmath52 defined on @xmath53 $ ] ( resp .
, @xmath54 ) will be extended , without mention , by setting @xmath55 for @xmath56 and @xmath57 for @xmath58 [ resp .
, @xmath59 for @xmath60 .
@xmath61 will indicate the set of continuous functions defined on @xmath62 @xmath63 the space of real functions with differentiability class @xmath64 .
we denote by @xmath65 [ resp . , @xmath66 the space of continuous ( continuous differentiable ) functions vanishing at zero .
when there is no confusion , we will also simply use the symbols @xmath67 .
we denote by @xmath68 \times{\mathbb r})$ ] the space of real continuous bounded functions defined on @xmath53 \times { \mathbb r}$ ] .
@xmath69 , or simply @xmath70 , indicates the space of continuous bounded functions defined on @xmath71 .
the vector spaces @xmath72 and @xmath73 are topological frchet spaces , or spaces , according to the terminology of @xcite , chapter 1.2 .
they are equipped with the following natural topology . a sequence @xmath74 belonging to @xmath75 [ resp . ,
@xmath73 ] is said to converge to @xmath52 in the @xmath77 [ resp .
, @xmath78 sense if @xmath74 ( resp .
, @xmath74 and all derivatives up to order @xmath79 ) converges ( resp . ,
converge ) to @xmath52 ( resp .
, to @xmath52 and all its derivatives ) uniformly on each compact of @xmath71
. we will consider functions @xmath80 \times{\mathbb r } \rightarrow{\mathbb r}$ ] which are bounded and continuous . a sequence @xmath81 in @xmath82 \times{\mathbb r})$ ]
will be said to converge _ in a bounded way _ to @xmath12 if : * @xmath83 \times{\mathbb r}$ ] ; * there exists a constant @xmath84 , independent of the sequence , such that @xmath85 if the sequence @xmath81 does not depend on @xmath24 , we similarly define the convergence of @xmath86 to @xmath87 in a bounded way . given two functions @xmath88 \times{\mathbb r } \rightarrow { \mathbb r}$ ] , the composition notation @xmath89 means @xmath90 . for positive integers @xmath91 , @xmath92 will indicate functions in the corresponding differentiability class .
for instance , @xmath93 will be the space of @xmath94 functions which are @xmath45 on @xmath95 ( i.e. , once continuously differentiable ) and such that @xmath96 exists and is continuous
. @xmath97 will indicate the set of functions @xmath92 such that the partial derivatives of all orders are bounded .
if @xmath98 is a real compact interval and @xmath990,1[$ ] , we denote by @xmath100 the vector space of real functions defined on @xmath98 which are hlder with parameter @xmath42 .
we denote by @xmath101 , or simply @xmath102 , the space of locally hlder functions , that is , hlder on each real compact interval .
suppose @xmath103 $ ] , @xmath104 being two real numbers such that @xmath105 . here , @xmath36 does not necessarily need to be positive .
recall that @xmath106 belongs to @xmath107 if @xmath108 clearly , @xmath109 defines a norm on @xmath107 which makes it a banach space .
@xmath110 is an f - space if equipped with the topology of convergence related to @xmath100 for each compact interval @xmath98 .
a sequence @xmath111 in @xmath112 converges to @xmath52 if it converges according to @xmath107 for every compact interval @xmath98
. we will also provide some reminders about the so - called _ young integrals _ ( see @xcite ) but will remain , however , in a simplified framework , as in @xcite or @xcite .
we recall the essential inequality , stated , for instance , in @xcite : let @xmath113 be such that @xmath114 . if @xmath115 , then @xmath116 for any @xmath117\subset i$ ] and @xmath1180,\gamma+\beta-1[$ ] , where @xmath119 is a constant not depending on @xmath120 .
the bilinear map sending @xmath121 to @xmath122 can be continuously extended to @xmath123 with values in @xmath124 . by definition , that object
will be called the _ young integral _ of @xmath52 with respect to @xmath125 on @xmath98 .
we also denote it @xmath126 . by additivity
, we set , for @xmath127 $ ] , @xmath128 moreover , the bilinear map defined on @xmath129 by @xmath130 extends continuously to @xmath131 onto @xmath77 .
again , that object , defined on the whole real line , will be called _ young integral _ of @xmath52 with respect to @xmath125 and will again be denoted by @xmath132 .
[ rexvq7 ] inequality ( [ fyoung ] ) remains true for @xmath133 .
in particular , @xmath134 belongs to @xmath135 .
in fact , @xmath136 through the extension of the bilinear operator sending @xmath121 to @xmath137 , it is possible to get the following chain rule for young integrals .
[ pcruley ] let @xmath138 , @xmath103 $ ] .
we suppose that @xmath139 , @xmath140 , @xmath141 with @xmath114 , @xmath142 we define @xmath143 . then @xmath144 if @xmath145 , then the result is obvious .
we remark that @xmath146 . repeatedly using inequality ( [ fyoung ] )
, one can show that the two linear maps @xmath147 and @xmath148 are continuous from @xmath149 to @xmath150 .
this concludes the proof of the proposition . by a _
mollifier _ , we mean a function @xmath151 ( i.e. , a @xmath152-function such that itself and all its derivatives decrease to zero faster than any power of @xmath153 as @xmath154 ) with @xmath155 .
we set @xmath156 .
the result below shows that mollifications of a hlder function @xmath52 converge to @xmath52 with respect to the hlder topology .
[ pyoungreg ] let @xmath157 be a mollifier and let @xmath158 .
we write @xmath159 .
then @xmath160 in the @xmath107 topology for any @xmath161 .
we need to show that @xmath162 converges to zero .
we set @xmath163 .
let @xmath164 .
we will establish that @xmath165 without loss of generality , we can suppose that @xmath166 .
we distinguish between two cases .
_ case _ @xmath167 .
we have @xmath168 _ case _ @xmath169 . in this case
, we have @xmath170 ) is verified with @xmath171 .
this implies that @xmath172 which allows us to conclude . for convenience ,
we introduce the topological vector space defined by @xmath173 it is also a _ vector algebra _ , that is , @xmath174 is a vector space and an algebra with respect to the _ sum and product of functions_. the next corollary is a consequence of the definition of the young integral and remark [ rexvq7 ] .
[ cyoung ] let @xmath175 , @xmath176 with @xmath177 .
then @xmath178 is well defined and belongs to @xmath179 .
@xmath174 is not a metric space , but an inductive limit of the f - spaces @xmath102 ; the weak version of the banach steinhaus theorem for f - spaces can be adapted .
in fact , a direct consequence of the banach steinhaus theorem of @xcite , section 2.1 , is the following .
[ tbs ] let @xmath180 be an inductive limit of f - spaces @xmath181 and @xmath182 another f - space .
let @xmath183 be a sequence of continuous linear operators .
suppose that @xmath184 exists for any @xmath185 . then is again a continuous ( linear ) operator .
we recall here a few notions related to stochastic calculus via regularization , a theory which began with @xcite .
we refer to a recent survey paper @xcite .
the stochastic processes considered may be defined on @xmath53 , { \mathbb r}_+$ ] or @xmath71 .
let @xmath186 be a continuous process and @xmath187 be a process with paths in @xmath188 .
for the paths of process @xmath189 with parameter on @xmath53 $ ] ( resp . , @xmath54 ) , we apply the same convention as was applied at the beginning of previous section for functions .
so we extend them without further mention , setting @xmath190 for @xmath191 and @xmath192 for @xmath58 ( resp .
, @xmath190 for @xmath191 ) .
@xmath193 will denote the vector algebra of continuous processes .
it is an f - space if equipped with the topology of u.c.p .
( uniform convergence in probability ) convergence . in the sequel
, we recall the most useful rules of calculus ; see , for instance , @xcite or @xcite .
the forward symmetric integrals and the covariation process are defined by the following limits in the u.c.p .
sense , whenever they exist : @xmath194_t & : = & \lim_{\varepsilon\to0 + } c^{\varepsilon}(x , y)_t,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath195 all stochastic integrals and covariation processes will of course be elements of @xmath196 .
if @xmath197 $ ] , @xmath198 $ ] and @xmath199 $ ] exist , we say that @xmath200 _ has all of its mutual covariations_. [ r1.0 ] if @xmath201 is ( locally ) of bounded variation , we have : * @xmath202 , where the third integral is meant in the lebesgue
stieltjes sense ; * @xmath203 \equiv0 $ ] .
[ r1.1 ] ( a ) @xmath204 $ ] provided that two of the three integrals or covariations exist .
@xmath205_t $ ] provided that two of the three integrals or covariations exist .
@xmath206 provided that one of the two integrals exists .
[ r1.2 ] ( a ) if @xmath198 $ ] exists , then it is always an increasing process and @xmath201 is called a _ finite quadratic variation process_. if @xmath198 = 0 $ ] , then @xmath201 is said to be a _
zero quadratic variation process_. let @xmath201 , @xmath189 be continuous processes such that @xmath200 has all of its mutual covariations . then @xmath197 $ ]
has locally bounded variation . if @xmath207 , then @xmath208_t = \int_0^t f'(x)g'(y)\,d[x , y].\ ] ] if @xmath209 is a zero quadratic variation process and @xmath201 is a finite quadratic variation process , then @xmath210 \equiv0 $ ] .
a bounded variation process is a zero quadratic variation process .
( _ classical it formula_. ) if @xmath211 , then @xmath212 exists and is equal to @xmath213.\ ] ] if @xmath214 and @xmath215 , then the forward integral @xmath216 is well defined . in this paper ,
all filtrations are supposed to fulfill the usual conditions .
if @xmath217}$ ] is a filtration , @xmath201 an @xmath218-semimartingale and @xmath189 is an @xmath218-adapted cadlag process , then @xmath219 is the usual it integral .
if @xmath189 is an @xmath218-semimartingale , then @xmath220 is the classical fisk stratonovich integral and @xmath197 $ ] is the usual covariation process @xmath221 .
we now introduce the notion of dirichlet process , which was essentially introduced by fllmer @xcite and has been considered by many authors ; see , for instance , @xcite for classical properties . in the present section ,
@xmath222 will denote a classical @xmath223-brownian motion .
[ d81 ] an @xmath224-adapted ( continuous ) process is said to be a _ dirichlet process _ if it is the sum of an local martingale @xmath225 and a zero quadratic variation process @xmath209 . for simplicity
, we will suppose that @xmath226 a.s .
[ r81 ] ( i ) process @xmath227 in the previous decomposition is anadapted process .
an @xmath224-semimartingale is an @xmath223-dirichlet process .
the decomposition @xmath228 is unique .
let @xmath229 be of class @xmath45 and let @xmath201 be an @xmath224-dirichlet process .
then @xmath230 is again an @xmath231-dirichlet process with local martingale part @xmath232 . the class of semimartingales with respect to a given filtration is known to be stable with respect to @xmath233 transformations .
remark [ r1.2](b ) says that finite quadratic variation processes are stable through @xmath45 transformations .
the last point of the previous remark states that @xmath45 stability also holds for dirichlet processes .
young integrals introduced in section [ s2 ] can be connected with the forward and symmetric integrals via the regularization appearing before remark [ r1.0 ] .
the next proposition was proven in @xcite .
let @xmath234 be processes whose paths are respectively in @xmath235 and @xmath236 , with @xmath237 , @xmath238 and @xmath239 .
for any symbol @xmath240 , the integral @xmath241 coincides with the young integral @xmath242 .
[ rexvq7a ] suppose that @xmath201 and @xmath189 satisfy the conditions of proposition [ pexvq7 ]
. then remark [ r1.1](a ) implies that @xmath197=0 $ ] .
we need an extension of stochastic calculus via regularization in the direction of higher @xmath243-variation .
the properties concerning variation higher than @xmath244 can be found , for instance , in @xcite .
we set @xmath245^\varepsilon_t = \frac { 1}{\varepsilon } \int_0^t ( x_{s+\varepsilon}-x_s)^3\ , ds.\ ] ] we also define @xmath246^\varepsilon \|_t = \frac{1}{\varepsilon } \int_0^t @xmath247^\varepsilon_t$ ] when @xmath248 exists for any @xmath24 , we denote it by @xmath247_t$ ] .
if the limiting process @xmath247 $ ] has a continuous version , we say that @xmath201 is a _ finite cubic variation process_. if , moreover , there is a positive sequence @xmath249 converging to zero such that @xmath250^{\varepsilon_n } \|_t < + \infty,\ ] ] then we say that @xmath201 is a ( _ strong _ ) _ finite cubic variation process_. if @xmath201 is a ( strong ) finite cubic variation process such that @xmath247 = 0 $ ] , then @xmath201 will be said to be a ( strong ) zero _ finite cubic variation process_. for instance , if @xmath251 , a fractional brownian motion with hurst index @xmath252 , then @xmath201 is a finite quadratic variation process if and only if @xmath253 ; see @xcite .
it is a strong zero cubic variation process if and only if @xmath254 ; see @xcite .
on the other hand , @xmath255 is a zero cubic variation process if and only if @xmath256 ; see @xcite .
it is clear that a finite quadratic variation process is a strong zero cubic variation process . on the other hand , processes whose paths are h " older continuous with parameter greater than @xmath257 are strong zero cubic variation processes . as for finite quadratic variation and dirichlet processes
, the @xmath45-stability also holds for finite cubic variation processes .
the next proposition is a particular case of a result contained in @xcite .
[ pstacub ] let @xmath201 be a strong finite cubic variation process , @xmath258 a locally bounded variation process and @xmath259 of class @xmath260 .
then @xmath261 is again a strong finite cubic variation process and @xmath262_t = \int_0^t \partial_x f(v_s , x_s)^3\ , d[x , x , x]_s.\ ] ] moreover , an it chain rule property holds , as follows . [ crule ]
let @xmath201 be a strong finite cubic variation process , @xmath263 a bounded variation process and @xmath189 a cadlag process .
let @xmath259 be of class @xmath264
. then @xmath265_s.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we deduce , in particular , that a @xmath45 transformation of a strong zero cubic variation process is again a strong zero cubic variation process .
we conclude the section by introducing a concept of _ definite integral _ via regularization . if processes @xmath266 are indexed by the whole real line , a.s . with compact support , we define @xmath267 where the limit is understood in probability .
integration by parts , proposition [ pexvq7 ] and the chain rule property ( proposition [ crule ] ) can all be immediately adapted to these definite integrals .
let @xmath39 , @xmath268 be such that @xmath269 . without loss of generality , we will suppose that @xmath270 .
we consider a formal pde operator of the following type : @xmath271 if @xmath17 is of class @xmath45 , so that @xmath16 is continuous , we will say that @xmath44 is a _ classical _ pde operator . for a given mollifier @xmath157
, we denote @xmath272 we then consider @xmath273 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber { \mathcal l}_n u & = & \partial_t u + l_n u\qquad\mbox{for } u \in c^{1,2}([0,t[\times{\mathbb r}),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath274 acts on @xmath275 . a priori , @xmath276 , @xmath277 and the operator @xmath274 depend on the mollifier @xmath157 .
previous definitions are slightly different from those in papers @xcite , but a considerable part of the analysis of @xmath44 and the study of the martingale problem can be adapted . in those papers
, there was only regularization but no truncation ; here , truncation is used to study the associated parabolic equations .
[ dc1gen ] a function @xmath278 is said to be a _
@xmath45-generalized solution _ to @xmath279 where @xmath280 if for any mollifier @xmath157 , there are sequences @xmath111 in @xmath233 and @xmath281 in @xmath282 such that @xmath283 [ t24 ] there is a solution @xmath284 to @xmath285 such that @xmath286 for every @xmath287 if and only if @xmath288 exists in @xmath282 , independently of the mollifier .
moreover , in this case , any solution @xmath52 to @xmath289 fulfills @xmath290 this result follows in a very similar way to the proof of proposition 2.3 in @xcite first at the level of regularization and then passing to the limit . for the remainder of this paper
, we will suppose the existence of this function @xmath291 .
we will consider @xmath292 such that @xmath293 in particular , @xmath294 holds . even though we discuss the general case with related nonexplosion conditions in @xcite , here , in order to ensure conservativeness
, we suppose that @xmath295 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber \int_{- \infty}^0 \frac{e^ { \sigma(x)}}{\sigma^2}\ , dx & = & \int^ { \infty}_0 \frac{e^ { \sigma(x)}}{\sigma^2}\ , dx = + \infty.\end{aligned}\ ] ] previous assumptions are of course satisfied if @xmath39 is lower bounded by a positive constant and @xmath17 is constant outside a compact interval
. condition ( [ nonexplo ] ) implies that the image set of @xmath296 is @xmath71 .
[ r2.5 ] proposition [ t24 ] implies uniqueness of the problem @xmath297 for every @xmath298 , @xmath299 .
[ r2.6 ] we present four important examples where @xmath291 exists : if @xmath300 for some @xmath3010,1]$ ] , then @xmath302 and @xmath303 if @xmath304 , the operator @xmath44 can be formally expressed in divergence form as @xmath305 suppose that @xmath17 is locally of bounded variation .
we then get @xmath306 since @xmath307 in the weak-@xmath308 topology and @xmath309 is continuous .
if @xmath39 has bounded variation , then we have @xmath310 in particular , this example contains the case where @xmath20 for any @xmath17 .
suppose that @xmath39 is locally hlder continuous with parameter @xmath42 and that @xmath17 is locally hlder continuous with parameter @xmath311 such that @xmath312 .
since @xmath39 is locally bounded , @xmath313 is also locally h " older continuous with parameter @xmath42 .
proposition [ pyoungreg ] implies that @xmath314 in @xmath315 and @xmath316 in @xmath317 for every @xmath318 and @xmath319 . since @xmath39 is strictly positive on each compact , @xmath320 in @xmath315 . by remark [ rexvq7 ] , @xmath291
is well defined and locally h " older continuous with parameter @xmath321 .
again , the following lemma can be proven at the level of regularizations ; see also lemma 2.6 in @xcite .
[ t27 ] the unique solution to problem ( [ e2.9 ] ) is given by @xmath322 [ r2.3 ] if @xmath323 and @xmath324 is a classical solution to @xmath325 , then @xmath52 is clearly also a @xmath45-generalized solution .
[ r2.9bis ] given @xmath326 , we denote by @xmath327 the unique @xmath45-generalized solution @xmath52 to problem ( [ e2.9 ] ) with @xmath328 , @xmath329 .
the unique solution to the general problem ( [ e2.9 ] ) is given by @xmath330 we write @xmath331 , that is , the solution with @xmath332 [ r2.9 ] let @xmath333 .
there is at most one @xmath334 such that @xmath325 .
in fact , to see this , it is enough to suppose that @xmath335 .
lemma [ t27 ] implies that @xmath336 consequently , @xmath337 is forced to be zero .
this consideration allows us to define without ambiguity @xmath338 @xmath339 , where @xmath340 is the set of all @xmath278 which are @xmath45-generalized solution to @xmath341 for some @xmath280 .
in particular , @xmath342 .
a direct consequence of lemma [ t27 ] is the following useful result .
[ l28bis ] @xmath343 is the set of @xmath333 such that there exists @xmath344 with @xmath345 in particular , it gives us the following density proposition .
[ t29 ] @xmath340 is dense in @xmath45 .
it is enough to show that every @xmath233-function is the @xmath45-limit of a sequence of functions in @xmath340 .
let @xmath346 be a sequence in @xmath45 converging to @xmath347 in @xmath282 .
it follows that @xmath348 converges to @xmath333 and @xmath349 .
we must now discuss technical aspects of the way @xmath44 and its domain @xmath340 are transformed by @xmath296 .
we recall that @xmath285 and that @xmath350 is strictly positive .
condition ( [ nonexplo ] ) implies that the image set of @xmath296 is @xmath71 .
let @xmath351 be the classical pde operator @xmath352 where @xmath353 @xmath351 is a classical pde map ; however , we can also consider it at the formal level and introduce @xmath354 .
[ t212 ] @xmath355 , @xmath356 .
@xmath357 .
@xmath358 holds if and only if @xmath359 .
moreover , we have @xmath360 for every @xmath361 .
this follows similarly as for proposition 2.13 of @xcite .
we will now discuss another operator related to @xmath44 . given a function @xmath52
, we need to provide a suitable definition of @xmath362 , that is , some primitive of @xmath363 .
* one possibility is to define that map , through previous expression , for @xmath364 . *
otherwise , we try to define it as linear map on @xmath233 . for this , first suppose that @xmath16 is continuous . then integrating by parts , we obtain @xmath365 we remark that the right - hand side of this expression makes sense for any @xmath215 and continuous @xmath17 .
we will thus define @xmath366 as follows : @xmath367 one may ask if , in the general case , the two definitions @xmath368 on @xmath369 and @xmath370 on @xmath233 are compatible .
we will later see that under assumption [ a0 ] , this will be the case .
however , in general , @xmath371 may be empty .
thus far , we have learned how to eliminate the first - order term in a formal pde operator through the transformation @xmath296 introduced at ( [ efh ] ) ; when @xmath44 is classical , this was performed by zvonkin ( see @xcite ) .
we would now like to introduce a transformation which puts the pde operator in a divergence form .
let @xmath44 be a pde operator which is formally of type ( [ e2.1 ] ) : @xmath372 we consider a function of class @xmath45 , namely @xmath373 such that @xmath374 according to assumptions ( [ nonexplo ] ) , @xmath375 is bijective on @xmath71 .
if there is no drift term , that is , @xmath376 , then we have @xmath377 .
[ t216 ] we consider the formal pde operator given by @xmath378 where @xmath379 then : @xmath380 if and only if @xmath381 ; for every @xmath380 , we have @xmath382 .
it is practically the same as in lemma 2.16 of @xcite .
we now give a lemma whose proof can be easily established by investigation .
suppose that @xmath44 is a classical pde operator .
then @xmath383 is well defined for @xmath384 functions where @xmath44 acts on the second variable . given a function @xmath385 \times{\mathbb r})$ ] ,
we will hereafter set @xmath386 \times{\mathbb
r}\longrightarrow{\mathbb r}$ ] by @xmath387 .
[ l28 ] let us suppose that @xmath388 .
we set @xmath389 .
we define the pde operator @xmath390 by @xmath391 , where @xmath351 is a classical operator acting on the space variable @xmath275 and @xmath392 if @xmath393 and @xmath394 in the classical sense , then @xmath395 .
we will now formulate a supplementary assumption which will be useful when we study singular stochastic differential equations in the proper sense and not only in the form of a martingale problem .
[ a0 ] let @xmath396 be a topological f - space which is a linear topological subspace of @xmath72 ( or , eventually , an inductive limit of sub - f - spaces ) .
the @xmath396-convergence implies convergence in @xmath282 and , therefore , pointwise convergence .
we say that @xmath44 fulfills assumption if the following conditions hold : @xmath397 , which is dense . for every @xmath398 , the multiplicative operator @xmath399 maps @xmath396 into itself .
let @xmath400 as defined in lemma [ t27 ] , that is , @xmath401 is such that @xmath402 we recall that @xmath401 solves problem @xmath403 with @xmath404 .
we suppose that @xmath36 admits a continuous extension to @xmath396 .
let @xmath405 .
for every @xmath215 with @xmath406 and @xmath407 so that ] , we have @xmath408 and @xmath409 , where @xmath410 denotes the continuous extension of @xmath411 ( see remark [ r2.9bis ] ) to @xmath396 , which exists by .
the set @xmath412 is dense in @xmath413 .
[ r2.21a ] let @xmath405 .
remark [ r2.9bis ] and point ( iii ) above together imply that @xmath414 extends continuously to @xmath396 .
moreover , @xmath415 point ( iv ) above shows that @xmath416 and @xmath417 , where @xmath418 ; in fact , @xmath419 , @xmath420 and ( [ e213a ] ) implies that @xmath421 .
point ( i ) above is satisfied if , for instance , the map @xmath36 is closable as a map from @xmath282 to @xmath45 . in that case , @xmath396 may be defined as the domain of the closure of @xmath45 , equipped with the graph topology related to @xmath422 .
below , we give some sufficient conditions for points ( iv ) and ( v ) of the technical assumption to be satisfied .
we define by @xmath423 the vector space of functions @xmath333 such that @xmath424 .
this will be an f - space if equipped with the following topology .
a sequence @xmath111 will be said to converge to @xmath52 in @xmath423 if @xmath425 and @xmath426 converges to @xmath427 in @xmath396 .
in particular , a sequence converging according to @xmath428 also converges with respect to @xmath45 . on the other hand
, @xmath429 and a sequence converging in @xmath430 also converges with respect to @xmath431 .
moreover , @xmath233 is dense in @xmath431 because @xmath45 is dense in @xmath396 .
[ l2.21 ] suppose that points to of the technical assumption are fulfilled .
we suppose , moreover , that : @xmath432 . for every @xmath215 , @xmath433 , @xmath434 , @xmath435 , we have @xmath408 and .
@xmath436 is well defined and has a continuous extension to @xmath423 , still denoted by @xmath370 , such that @xmath437 .
@xmath438 .
@xmath439 is the identity map on @xmath440 for every @xmath405 are injective and points and of the technical assumption are satisfied .
the injectivity of @xmath36 follows from point ( e ) .
the injectivity of @xmath411 is a consequence of remark [ r2.9bis ] .
we prove point ( iv ) .
point ( c ) says that @xmath437 .
we set @xmath441 , @xmath211 , where @xmath442 , @xmath443 .
clearly , @xmath444 and @xmath445 .
point ( b ) implies that @xmath446 .
hence , @xmath447 and ( iv ) is satisfied .
concerning point ( v ) , let @xmath408 with @xmath448 and set @xmath449 .
since @xmath52 belongs to @xmath423 by ( c ) , @xmath427 belongs to @xmath396 .
point ( i ) of the technical assumption implies that there exists a sequence @xmath426 of @xmath45 functions converging to @xmath427 in the @xmath396 sense and thus also in @xmath282 .
let @xmath111 be the sequence of primitives of @xmath426 ( which are of class @xmath233 ) such that @xmath450 .
in particular , we have that @xmath111 converges to @xmath52 in the @xmath431-sense . by ( c )
, there exists @xmath49 in @xmath396 which is the limit of @xmath451 in the @xmath396-sense .
observe that because of ( b ) , @xmath452 . on the other hand , @xmath453 in @xmath45 . applying @xmath36 and using ( iii ) of the technical assumption ,
we obtain @xmath454 the injectivity of @xmath36 allows us to conclude that @xmath455 .
[ r2.21aa ] under the assumptions of lemma [ l2.21 ] , we have : * @xmath456 ; * @xmath457 , @xmath458 in fact , let @xmath459 . without loss of generality
, we can suppose that @xmath433 .
let @xmath460 and set @xmath461 so that @xmath462 .
setting @xmath463 lemma [ t27 ] implies that @xmath464 , where @xmath465 .
so @xmath466 .
since @xmath467 , it follows that @xmath468 , by additivity .
on the other hand , @xmath469 by point ( e ) of lemma [ l2.21 ] .
[ 4ex ] we provide here a series of four significant examples when technical assumption is verified
. we only comment on the points which are not easy to verify .
the first example is simple .
it concerns the case when the drift @xmath16 is continuous .
this problem , to be studied later , corresponds to an ordinary sde where @xmath470 @xmath44 is _ close to divergence type _ , that is , @xmath471 and where @xmath311 is a locally bounded variation function vanishing at zero .
the operator is of divergence type with an additional radon measure term , that is , we have @xmath472 . in this case
, we have @xmath473 points ( i ) and ( ii ) of the technical assumption are trivial .
we have , in fact , @xmath474 @xmath36 defined at point ( iii ) of the technical assumption is such that @xmath475 , where @xmath433 and @xmath476 consequently , the extension of @xmath36 to @xmath477 , always still denoted by the same letter @xmath36 , is given by @xmath401 with @xmath433 and @xmath478 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber \qquad & & \hspace*{11.2 mm } { } \times \biggl ( \ell(0 ) + \int_0^x \ell(y ) \exp \biggl(2\int_0^y\frac{d\beta}{\sigma ^2 } \biggr ) \frac{1}{\sigma^2(y ) } \,d\beta(y ) \biggr ) \biggr\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] points ( iv ) and ( v ) are seen to be satisfied via lemma [ l2.21 ] .
we have @xmath479 .
point ( a ) is obvious since @xmath480 and so @xmath481 .
let @xmath215 .
using lebesgue
stieltjes calculus , we can easily show that @xmath482 this shows that @xmath483 and therefore the first part of ( b ) .
we remark that we can , in fact , consider @xmath484 because @xmath485 the expression of @xmath486 extends continuously to @xmath333 , which yields the first part of point ( c ) .
moreover , inserting the expression for @xmath350 into @xmath427 in ( [ e2.27a ] ) , one shows that @xmath437 .
suppose , now , that in expression ( [ e2.27a ] ) , @xmath215 , @xmath487 , @xmath434 .
a simple investigation shows that @xmath488 , so the second part of point ( b ) is fulfilled ; point ( d ) is also clear because of ( [ e2.27 ] ) .
finally point ( d ) holds because one can prove by inspection that @xmath439 is the identity on @xmath489 .
we recall the notation @xmath490 which indicates the topological vector space of locally hlder continuous functions defined on @xmath71 with parameter @xmath491 .
we recall that @xmath490 is a vector algebra .
suppose that @xmath492 and @xmath493 ( or @xmath494 and @xmath495 ) .
remark [ r2.6](d ) implies that @xmath291 also belongs to @xmath496 .
we set @xmath497 .
technical assumption [ a0 ] is verified for the following reasons . since @xmath498
, @xmath499 belongs to the same space .
point ( i ) follows because of proposition [ pyoungreg ] and point ( ii ) follows because @xmath496 is an algebra .
corollary [ cyoung ] yields that for every @xmath500 , the function @xmath501 is well defined and belongs to @xmath496 .
this shows that @xmath36 can be continuously extended to @xmath396 and point ( iii ) is established .
concerning points ( iv ) and ( v ) , we again use lemma [ l2.21 ] .
we observe that @xmath502 point ( a ) is obvious since @xmath503 .
let @xmath504 .
considering @xmath17 as a deterministic process and recalling the definition of @xmath370 as in ( [ e213a ] ) , integration by parts in remark [ r1.1](c ) and proposition [ pexvq7 ] together imply that @xmath505 the first part of point ( b ) follows because of proposition [ pcruley ] .
of course , the previous expression can be extended to @xmath468 and this shows the first part of point ( c ) .
showing that the second part of point ( c ) of lemma [ l2.21 ] holds consists of verifying that @xmath437 . substituting @xmath506 into the previous expression , through proposition [ pcruley ]
, we obtain @xmath507 concerning the second part of point ( b ) , let @xmath215 so that @xmath508 .
we want to show that @xmath509 coincides with @xmath52 . since @xmath510 , it remains to check that @xmath511 .
we recall that @xmath512 twice applying the chain rule of proposition [ pcruley ] and using ( [ e1.1b ] ) , the fact that @xmath513 and integration by parts , we obtain @xmath514 point ( b ) is therefore completely established .
point ( d ) follows because in ( [ eimt ] ) , when @xmath408 , it follows that @xmath424 . clearly , as for the previous example , @xmath438 .
it remains to show that @xmath515 is the identity map @xmath516 . for this
, we first remark that @xmath517 in fact , by proposition [ pexvq7 ] and integration by parts contained in remark [ r1.1](c ) , we obtain @xmath518 by the chain rule of proposition [ pcruley ] , we obtain the right - hand side of ( [ eyverif1 ] ) . at this point , by definition , if @xmath519 , we have @xmath520 therefore , ( [ eyverif1 ] ) and proposition [ pcruley ] allow us to conclude that @xmath521 suppose @xmath17 is locally with bounded variation .
then the technical assumption is satisfied for @xmath522 , where @xmath523 is the space of continuous real functions , locally with bounded variation @xmath11 , equipped with the following topology .
a sequence @xmath524 in @xmath523 converges to @xmath11 if @xmath525 the arguments for proving that the technical assumption is satisfied are similar , but easier , than those for the previous point .
young - type calculus is replaced by classical lebesgue stieltjes calculus .
in this section , we consider a pde operator satisfying the same properties as in previous section , that is , @xmath526 where @xmath269 and @xmath17 are continuous . in particular
, we assume that @xmath527 exists in @xmath282 , independently of the chosen mollifier . then @xmath296 defined by @xmath528 and @xmath529 is a solution to @xmath285 with @xmath530 . here
, we aim to introduce different notions of martingale problem , trying , when possible , to also clarify the classical notion . for the next two definitions
, we consider the following convention . let @xmath531 equipped with a filtration @xmath532 fulfill the _
usual conditions _ ; see , for instance , @xcite , definition 2.25 , chapter 1 . [ dmp ] a process @xmath201 is said to solve _ the martingale problem _ related to @xmath44 ( with respect to the aforementioned filtered probability space ) with initial condition @xmath533 , @xmath534 , if @xmath535 is an @xmath536-local martingale for @xmath537 and @xmath533 . more generally ,
for @xmath538 , @xmath539 , we say that @xmath540 solves the martingale problem related to @xmath44 with initial value @xmath275 at time @xmath541 if for every @xmath542 , @xmath543 is an @xmath544-local martingale .
we remark that @xmath545 solves the martingale problem at time @xmath541 if and only if @xmath546 solves the martingale problem at time @xmath23 .
[ dsmp ] let @xmath222 be an @xmath224-classical wiener process .
anprogressively measurable process @xmath547 is said to solve _ the sharp martingale problem _ related to @xmath44 ( on the given filtered probability space ) with initial condition @xmath533 , @xmath534 , if @xmath548 for every @xmath542 . more generally ,
for @xmath538 , @xmath539 , we say that @xmath549 solves the sharp martingale problem related to @xmath44 with initial value @xmath275 at time @xmath541 if for every @xmath542 , @xmath550 [ r3.1a ] let @xmath222 be an @xmath224-wiener process . if @xmath16 is continuous , then a process @xmath201 solves the ( corresponding ) sharp martingale problem with respect to @xmath44 if and only if it is a classical solution of the sde @xmath551 for this , a simple application of the classical it formula gives the result .
[ r3.2 ] ( i ) in general , @xmath552 does not belong to @xmath340 , otherwise a solution to the martingale problem with respect to @xmath44 would be a semimartingale . according to remark [ rsem ] , this is generally not the case . in @xcite , we gave necessary and sufficient conditions on @xmath17 so that @xmath201 is a semimartingale .
\(ii ) given a solution @xmath201 to the martingale problem related to @xmath44 , we are interested in the operators @xmath553 and @xmath554 where @xmath193 is the vector algebra of continuous processes . we may ask whether @xmath555 and @xmath209 are closable in @xmath45 and @xmath282 , respectively .
we will see that @xmath555 admits a continuous extension to @xmath45 .
however , @xmath209 can be extended continuously to some topological vector subspace @xmath396 of @xmath282 , where @xmath396 includes the drift , only when assumption [ a0 ] is satisfied . similarly , as in the case of classical stochastic differential equations
, it is possible to distinguish two types of existence and uniqueness for the martingale problem .
even if we could treat initial conditions which are random @xmath556-measurable solutions , here we will only discuss deterministic ones .
we will denote by @xmath557 [ resp .
@xmath558 the martingale problem ( resp
. sharp martingale problem ) related to @xmath44 with initial condition @xmath559 the notions will only be formulated with respect to the initial condition at time 0 .
[ d112 ] we will say that @xmath560 admits _ strong existence _ if the following holds .
given any probability space @xmath561 , a filtration @xmath562 and an @xmath563-brownian motion @xmath564 , there is a process @xmath565 which solves the sharp martingale problem with respect to @xmath44 and initial condition @xmath566 .
[ d113 ] we will say that @xmath560 admits _ pathwise uniqueness _ if the following property is fulfilled .
let @xmath531 be a probability space with filtration @xmath562 andbrownian motion @xmath567 .
if two processes @xmath568 are two solutions of the sharp martingale problem with respect to @xmath44 and @xmath566 , such that @xmath569 a.s . , then @xmath201 and @xmath570 coincide .
[ d114 ] we will say that @xmath571 _ admits weak existence _ if there is a probability space @xmath531 , a filtration @xmath572 and a process @xmath565 which is a solution of the corresponding martingale problem .
we say that @xmath573 admits weak existence if @xmath571 admits weak existence for every @xmath566 .
[ ( _ uniqueness in law_)][d115 ] we say that @xmath571 has a _ unique solution in law _ if the following holds .
we consider an arbitrary probability space @xmath574 with a filtration @xmath562 and a solution @xmath201 of the corresponding martingale problem .
we also consider another probability space @xmath575 equipped with another filtration @xmath576 and a solution @xmath570 .
we suppose that @xmath577 , and @xmath578 , @xmath579-a.s .
then @xmath201 and @xmath570 must have the same law as a r.v.s with values in @xmath580 ( or @xmath581 $ ] ) .
[ rsclass ] let us suppose @xmath16 to be a continuous function .
we do not suppose @xmath39 to be strictly positive ( only continuous ) . the @xmath560 then admits strong existence and pathwise uniqueness if the corresponding classical sde @xmath582 admits strong existence and pathwise uniqueness . in this case ,
@xmath583 and to establish this , it is enough to use the classical it formula .
it is well known ( see @xcite ) that weak existence ( resp . ,
uniqueness in law ) of the martingale problem is equivalent to weak existence ( resp . ,
uniqueness in law ) of the corresponding sde . for
the rest of the section let @xmath584 $ ] , @xmath585 moreover , let @xmath586 be a fixed filtered probability space fulfilling the usual conditions . the first result concerning solutions to the martingale problem related to @xmath44 is the following .
[ p3.3 ] let @xmath587 a process @xmath201 solves the martingale problem related to @xmath44 with initial condition @xmath275 at time @xmath541 if and only if @xmath588 is a local martingale which solves , on the same probability space , @xmath589 where @xmath590 and where @xmath222 is an @xmath224-classical brownian motion .
let @xmath222 be an @xmath224-classical brownian motion .
if @xmath189 is a solution to equation ( [ e3.3 ] ) , then @xmath591 is a solution to the sharp martingale problem with respect to @xmath44 with initial condition @xmath275 at time @xmath541 .
[ r3.4 ] let @xmath201 be a solution to the martingale problem with respect to @xmath44 and set @xmath592 as in point ( i ) above . since @xmath189 is a local martingale , we know from remark [ r81](iv ) that @xmath593 is an @xmath223-dirichlet process with martingale part @xmath594 in particular
, @xmath201 is a finite quadratic variation process with @xmath595 = [ m^x , m^x]_t = \int_0^t \sigma^2(x_s)\,ds.\ ] ] proof of proposition [ p3.3 ] for simplicity , we will set @xmath596 .
first , let @xmath201 be a solution to the martingale problem related to @xmath44 .
since @xmath597 and @xmath285 , we know that @xmath588 is an @xmath224-local martingale . in order to calculate its bracket , we recall that @xmath355 and @xmath598 hold by proposition [ t212](a ) .
thus , @xmath599 is an @xmath224-local martingale .
this implies that @xmath600_t = \int_0^t ( \sigma h')^2 ( h^{-1}(y_s))\,ds = \int_0^t \tilde\sigma_h^2(y_s)\,ds.\ ] ] finally , @xmath189 is a solution to the sde ( [ e3.3 ] ) with respect to the standard @xmath601-brownian motion @xmath602 given by @xmath603 where @xmath604 is the canonical filtration generated by @xmath189 .
now , let @xmath588 be a solution to ( [ e3.3 ] ) and let @xmath537 .
proposition [ t212](c ) says that @xmath605 , where @xmath606 we can therefore apply it s formula to evaluate @xmath607 , which coincides with @xmath230 .
this gives @xmath608_s.\ ] ] using @xmath609_s = \tilde\sigma_h^2(y_s)\,ds$ ] and taking into account ( [ e3.4 ] ) , we conclude that @xmath610 this establishes the proposition .
[ r3.5 ] from proposition [ p3.3 ] in particular , we have the following .
let @xmath586 be a filtered probability space fulfilling the usual conditions .
let @xmath611 and @xmath201 be a solution to the martingale problem related to @xmath44 with initial condition @xmath566 .
then there exists a classical brownian motion @xmath222 such that @xmath201 is a solution to the sharp martingale problem related to @xmath44 with initial condition @xmath566 .
[ c3.5 ] let @xmath201 be a solution to the martingale problem related to @xmath44 with initial condition @xmath566 .
then map @xmath555 admits a continuous extension from @xmath340 to @xmath45 with values in @xmath612 which we will again denote by @xmath555 .
moreover , @xmath613 is a zero quadratic variation process for every @xmath614 .
@xmath555 has a continuous extension because of ( [ e3.5 ] ) .
@xmath615 is a zero quadratic variation process because @xmath201 is a dirichlet process with martingale part @xmath616 and because of remark [ r81 ] .
[ r3.6 ] the extension of ( [ e3.5 ] ) to @xmath45 gives @xmath617 choosing @xmath618 in ( [ e3.6 ] ) , we get @xmath619 we will see that if there is a subspace @xmath396 of @xmath282 such that technical assumption [ a0 ] is verified , then the operator @xmath209 will be extended to @xmath396 . if @xmath17 is an element of that space , then it will be possible to write @xmath421 and @xmath620 . in that case
, we will be able to indicate that @xmath201 is a solution of the generalized sde with diffusion coefficient @xmath39 and distributional drift @xmath16 .
a similar result to proposition [ p3.3 ] can be deduced for the case of a transformation through function @xmath375 and the divergence - type operator introduced at ( [ efk ] ) .
[ pmardiv ] we consider the transformation @xmath375 and the pde operator @xmath621 introduced at and in lemma , respectively .
a process @xmath201 solves the martingale problem related to @xmath44 with initial condition @xmath566 at time @xmath541 if and only if @xmath622 solves the martingale problem related to @xmath621 with initial condition @xmath623 at time @xmath541 .
this is an easy consequence of lemma [ t216 ] .
let @xmath611 , @xmath624 .
let @xmath625 be as in section [ s4 ] .
we set @xmath626 . from proposition [ p3.3 ]
, we have the following . [ cmp ] strong existence ( resp .
, pathwise uniqueness ) holds for @xmath627 if and only if strong existence ( resp . , pathwise uniqueness ) holds for the sde @xmath628 with initial condition @xmath629 .
an analogous equivalence holds for weak existence ( resp . , uniqueness in law ) .
from proposition [ p3.3 ] , we can deduce two other corollaries concerning the well - posedness of our martingale problem .
[ cwe ] under the same assumptions as the previous corollary , @xmath630 admits weak existence and uniqueness in law .
the statement follows from point ( i ) of corollary [ cmp ] and from the fact that the sde ( [ e3.3 ] ) admits weak existence and uniqueness in law because see theorem 5.7 , chapter 5 of @xcite , or @xcite .
[ rsem ] by corollary 5.11 of @xcite , it is immediate to see that the solution is a semimartingale for each initial condition if and only if @xmath291 is locally of bounded variation .
if @xmath44 is in divergence form [ see remark [ r2.6](a ) with @xmath304 ] , then the solution corresponds to the process constructed and studied by , for instance , stroock @xcite .
[ c3.3ss ] suppose that either @xmath632 or @xmath633 and , moreover , that is satisfied . then @xmath630 admits strong existence and pathwise uniqueness . in this case ,
@xmath291 is well defined [ see remark [ r2.6](d ) ] and @xmath39 belongs to @xmath634 . since @xmath635 is of class @xmath45 , @xmath636 is hlder continuous with parameter @xmath41 .
the sde ( [ e3.3 ] ) admits pathwise uniqueness because of theorem 3.5(ii ) of @xcite and weak existence , again through theorem 5.7 of @xcite .
the yamada
watanabe theorem ( see @xcite , corollary 3.23 , chapter 5 ) also implies strong existence for ( [ e3.3 ] ) .
the result follows from point ( i ) of corollary [ cmp ] .
in this section , we will discuss the case where the martingale problem is equivalent to a stochastic differential equation to be specified .
first , one would need to give a precise sense to the generalized drift @xmath637 , @xmath17 being a continuous function .
we will introduce a property related to a general process @xmath201 .
first , we consider the linear map @xmath638 defined on @xmath639 with values in @xmath640 .
[ deltr ] let @xmath641 be a topological f - space ( or , eventually , an inductive limit of @xmath182-spaces ) which is a topological linear subspace of @xmath642 and such that @xmath643 .
we will say that @xmath201 has _ extended local time regularity with respect to @xmath641 _ if : * @xmath644 admits a continuous extension to @xmath641 , which will still be denoted by the same symbol ; * @xmath645 exists for every @xmath646 and every @xmath647 [ rby ] the terminology related to _ local time _ is natural in this context . to illustrate this
, we consider a general continuous process @xmath201 having a local time @xmath648 , a \in{\mathbb r})$ ] with respect to lebesgue measure , that is , fulfilling the density occupation identity @xmath649,\ ] ] for every positive borel function @xmath650 .
@xmath201 trivially has extended local time regularity , at least with respect to @xmath651 .
let @xmath326 .
suppose for a moment that @xmath652 is a semimartingale in @xmath653 , as is the case , for instance , if @xmath201 is a classical brownian motion .
in that case , one would have @xmath654 clearly , the rightmost integral can be extended continuously in probability to any @xmath655 , which implies that @xmath201 also has extended local time regularity related to @xmath656 .
we remark that @xcite gives general conditions on semimartingales @xmath201 under which @xmath657 is a good integrator , even if @xmath652 is not necessarily a semimartingale in @xmath653 .
[ dsol ] let @xmath658 a filtered probability space , @xmath222 a classical @xmath223-brownian motion and @xmath659 an @xmath660-measurable random variable .
a process @xmath201 will be called a @xmath641-_solution _ of the sde @xmath661 if : * @xmath201 has the extended local time regularity with respect to @xmath641 ; * @xmath662 ; * @xmath201 is a finite quadratic variation process . [ rsol ] suppose that @xmath663 . if @xmath664 , then a @xmath665-solution is also a @xmath641-solution .
the previous definition is also new in the classical case , that is , when @xmath16 is a continuous function .
a @xmath641-solution with @xmath666 corresponds to a solution to the sde in the classical sense . on the other hand , a @xmath641-solution with @xmath641 strictly including @xmath45 is a solution whose local time has a certain additional regularity . even in this generalized framework , it is possible to introduce the notions of _ strong @xmath641-existence _ , _ weak @xmath641-existence _ , _ pathwise @xmath641-uniqueness _ and _ @xmath641-uniqueness in law_. this can be done similarly as in definition [ d115 ] according to whether or not the filtered probability space with the classical brownian motion is fixed a priori .
[ l3.9 ] we suppose that technical assumption is satisfied . if @xmath201 is a solution to a martingale problem related to a pde operator @xmath44 , then it has extended local time regularity with respect to @xmath667 .
let @xmath668 .
since @xmath201 solves the martingale problem with respect to @xmath44 , setting @xmath519 , it follows that @xmath669 continuity of @xmath36 on @xmath396 implies that @xmath644 can be extended to @xmath396 .
now , let @xmath670 and @xmath671 .
since @xmath230 equals a local martingale plus @xmath672 , it remains to show that @xmath673 exists for any @xmath674 .
integrating by parts , the previous integral ( [ e3.8 ] ) equals @xmath675.\ ] ] remark [ r1.2](b ) , ( f ) shows that the rightmost term member is well defined .
[ l3.10 ] let @xmath201 be a process having extended local time regularity with respect to some @xmath182-space ( or inductive limit ) @xmath641 .
suppose that for fixed @xmath214 , the application @xmath676 is continuous from @xmath641 to @xmath641 .
then for every @xmath674 and every @xmath677 , we have @xmath678 where @xmath679 the banach steinhaus - type theorem [ tbs ] implies that for every , @xmath680 is continuous from @xmath641 to @xmath196 .
in fact , expression ( [ e3.11 ] ) is the u.c.p .
limit of @xmath681 note that @xmath157 is a continuous bilinear map from @xmath682 to @xmath641 .
since @xmath683 is continuous , the mapping @xmath684 is also continuous from @xmath641 to @xmath193 . in order to conclude the proof ,
we need to check identity ( [ e3.9 ] ) for @xmath326 . in that case , since @xmath685 both sides of ( [ e3.9 ] ) equal @xmath686 we will now explore the relation between the martingale problem associated with @xmath44 and the stochastic differential equations with distributional drift . [ p3.11 ] let @xmath611 .
suppose that @xmath44 fulfills technical assumption .
let @xmath658 be a filtered probability space fulfilling the usual conditions and let @xmath222 be a classical @xmath231-brownian motion .
if @xmath201 solves the sharp martingale problem with respect to @xmath44 with initial condition @xmath566 , then @xmath201 is a @xmath396-solution to the stochastic differential equation @xmath687 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber x_0 & = & x_0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ r2.21 ] in particular , if @xmath44 is close to divergence type , as in example [ 4ex](ii ) , then @xmath201 is a @xmath282-solution to the previous equation with @xmath688 .
let @xmath201 be a solution to the martingale problem related to @xmath44 .
we know , by lemma [ l3.9 ] , that @xmath201 has extended local time regularity with respect to @xmath641 . on the other hand , by remark [ r3.4 ] , @xmath201 is a finite quadratic variation process .
it remains to show that @xmath689 let @xmath326 and set @xmath690 . by definition of a sharp martingale problem ,
we have @xmath691 according to remark [ r2.21a](i ) concerning the continuity of the map @xmath692 , previous expression can be extended to any @xmath408 . by remark [ r2.21a](ii ) , @xmath693 and @xmath694 . replacing this in ( [ e3.13 ] ) ,
we obtain @xmath695 since @xmath696 , the proof is complete .
[ c3.11 ] let @xmath611 .
suppose that @xmath44 fulfills technical assumption .
if @xmath630 [ resp .
@xmath560 ] admits weak ( resp .
, strong ) existence , then the sde also admits weak ( resp .
, strong ) existence .
the statement concerning strong solutions is obvious .
concerning weak solutions , let us admit the existence of a filtered probability space , where there is a solution to the martingale problem with respect to @xmath44 with initial condition @xmath566 . then according to remark [ r3.5 ] , this solution is also a solution to a sharp martingale problem and the result follows . if @xmath201 is some @xmath641-solution to ( [ e3.12 ] ) , is it a solution to the ( sharp ) martingale problem related to some operator @xmath44 ? this is a delicate question . in the following proposition , we only provide the converse of proposition [ p3.11 ] as a partial answer .
[ c3.12 ] suppose that the pde operator @xmath44 fulfills technical assumption .
let @xmath658 be a filtered probability space fulfilling the usual conditions and let @xmath222 be a classical @xmath231-brownian motion .
let @xmath201 be a progressively measurable process .
@xmath201 solves the sharp martingale problem related to @xmath44 with respect to some initial condition @xmath566 if and only if it is a @xmath396-solution to the stochastic differential equation @xmath698 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber x_0 & = & x_0 .\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ cswequ ] let @xmath611 .
suppose that @xmath44 fulfills technical assumption .
then weak existence and uniqueness in law ( resp .
, strong existence and pathwise uniqueness ) hold for equation if and only if the same holds for @xmath630 [ resp .
@xmath560 ] .
proof of proposition [ c3.12 ] suppose that @xmath201 is a @xmath396-solution to ( [ e3.15 ] ) .
then it is a finite quadratic variation process .
let @xmath699 .
since @xmath201 solves ( [ e3.12 ] ) and @xmath700 always exists by the classical it formula [ see remark [ r1.2](e ) of section [ s1 ] ] , we know that @xmath701 also exists and is equal to @xmath702 therefore , this it formula says that @xmath703 holds . by lemma [ l3.10 ] , the linearity of mapping @xmath644 and ( [ e213a ] )
, we obtain @xmath704 this shows that @xmath705 for every @xmath706 . in reality , it is possible to show the previous equality for any @xmath215 .
in fact , the left - hand side extends continuously to @xmath233 and even to @xmath45 .
the right - hand side is also allowed to be extended to @xmath233 for the following reason . for @xmath707 , let @xmath111 be a sequence of functions in @xmath708 converging to @xmath52 when @xmath709 , according to the @xmath233 topology .
in particular , the convergence also holds in @xmath431 .
since @xmath370 is continuous with respect to the @xmath431 topology with values in @xmath396 , we have @xmath710 in @xmath396 .
finally , @xmath711 u.c.p . because of the extended local time regularity with respect to @xmath396 .
we will , in fact , use the validity of ( [ e3.14 ] ) for @xmath215 with @xmath433 and @xmath460 and @xmath712 according to technical assumption [ a0](iv ) , we have @xmath713 . therefore , ( [ e3.14 ] ) gives @xmath714 again using extended local time regularity with respect to @xmath715 and the continuity of @xmath411 , we can state the validity of the previous expression for each @xmath408 with @xmath716 , in particular , for @xmath326 with @xmath716 .
but in this case , for any @xmath717 with @xmath433 and @xmath718 , we obtain @xmath719 this shows the validity of the identity in definition [ dsmp ] for @xmath717 and that @xmath720 and @xmath721 . if @xmath722 , we replace @xmath52 by @xmath723 in the previous identity and use the fact that @xmath724 for any @xmath725 .
it follows that @xmath201 fulfills a sharp martingale problem with respect to @xmath44 .
this shows the reversed sense of the statement .
the direct implication was proven in proposition [ p3.11 ] .
[ ceqstrong ] we suppose that @xmath492 and @xmath493 , or @xmath494 and @xmath495 , with conditions .
we set @xmath726
. then equation ( [ e3.15 ] ) admits @xmath396-strong existence and pathwise uniqueness .
the result follows from corollaries [ cswequ ] and [ c3.3ss ] .
in this section , we want to discuss the related parabolic cauchy problem with final condition , which is associated with our stochastic differential equations with distributional drift .
we will adopt the same assumptions and conventions as in section [ s4 ] .
we consider the formal operator @xmath50 , where @xmath44 will hereafter act on the second variable .
[ d21 ] let @xmath49 be an element of @xmath727 \times{\mathbb r } ) $ ] and let @xmath728 .
a function @xmath729 \times{\mathbb r})$ ] will be said to be a _
@xmath19-generalized solution _ to @xmath730 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber u(t,\cdot ) & = & u^0,\end{aligned}\ ] ] if the following are satisfied : for any sequence @xmath731 in @xmath732 \times{\mathbb r})$ ] converging to @xmath49 in a bounded way,=1 for any sequence @xmath733 in @xmath734 converging in a bounded way to @xmath735 , such there are classical solutions @xmath81 in @xmath736\times{\mathbb r})$ ] of class@xmath737 to @xmath738 , @xmath739 , then @xmath81 converges in a bounded way to @xmath12 .
[ r21 ] ( a ) @xmath12 is said to solve @xmath740 if there exists @xmath741 such that ( [ f25 ] ) holds .
the previous definition depends in principle on the mollifier , but it could be easily adapted so as not to depend on it .
the regularized problem admits a solution : if @xmath742 and @xmath743 \times{\mathbb r})$ ] , then there is a classical solution @xmath744 in @xmath745\times{\mathbb r})$ ] of @xmath746 for this , it suffices to apply theorem of .
we now state a result concerning the case when the operator @xmath44 is classical .
even if the next proposition could be stated when the drift @xmath16 is a continuous function , we will suppose it to be zero .
in fact , it will later be applied to @xmath747 .
[ p39 ] we suppose that @xmath376 .
let @xmath748\times{\mathbb r } ) , n \in{\mathbb n},$ ] such that @xmath749 , @xmath750 in a bounded way on @xmath71 and @xmath53\times{\mathbb r}$ ] .
let @xmath39 be a strictly positive real continuous function .
suppose that there exist @xmath751\times { \mathbb r } ) $ ] such that @xmath752 then @xmath81 will converge to @xmath753\times{\mathbb r})$ ] in a bounded way , where the function @xmath12 is defined by @xmath754 where @xmath755 is the unique solution ( in law ) to @xmath756 and where @xmath222 is a classical brownian motion on some suitable filtered probability space .
[ r310 ] usual it calculus implies that @xmath757 where @xmath758 is the unique solution in law to the problem @xmath759 theorem ( chapter of ) affirms that it is possible to construct a solution ( unique in law ) @xmath760 to the sde ( [ f310quater ] ) resp .
, @xmath761 to .
suppose that @xmath44 is a classical pde operator .
let @xmath762 be bounded and continuous on @xmath53\times{\mathbb r}$ ] .
again , it calculus shows that @xmath12 can be represented by ( [ f311ter ] ) and ( [ f310quater ] ) .
in particular , a classical solution @xmath12 to @xmath763 is also a generalized solution .
proof of proposition [ p39 ] we fix @xmath584 $ ] , @xmath764 . using the engelbert
schmidt construction ( see , e.g. , the proof of theorem 5.4 , chapter 5 and 5.7 of @xcite ) , it is possible to construct a solution @xmath765 of the sde on some fixed probability space which solves ( [ f310quater ] ) with respect to some classical wiener process @xmath222 .
we set @xmath596 for simplicity .
the procedure is as follows .
we fix a standard brownian motion @xmath766 on some fixed probability space one set @xmath767 @xmath768 is a.s . a homeomorphism on @xmath54 and
we define @xmath209 as the inverse of @xmath768 .
a solution @xmath189 will be then given by @xmath769 ; in fact , it is possible to show that the quadratic variation of the local martingale @xmath189 is @xmath770 the brownian motion @xmath602 is constructed a posteriori and is adapted to the natural filtration of @xmath189 by setting @xmath771 so , on the same probability space , we can set @xmath772 , @xmath773 being the inverse of @xmath774 , where @xmath775 .
consequently , on the same probability space , we construct @xmath776 , where @xmath773 is the inverse of @xmath774 and @xmath775 .
@xmath777 solves equation ( [ f310quinque ] ) with respect to a brownian motion depending on @xmath243 . by construction
, the family @xmath778 converges a.s . to @xmath779 . using lebesgue dominated convergence theorems and the bounded convergence of @xmath780 and @xmath781
, we can take the limit when @xmath709 in expression ( [ f311 ] ) and obtain the desired result .
[ r311a ] in particular , the corresponding laws of random variables @xmath782 are tight .
again , we will adopt the same conventions as in section [ s4 ] .
we set @xmath783 .
@xmath351 is the classical operator defined at ( [ e2.12 ] ) .
let us consider @xmath784 as a formal operator .
[ c311 ] let @xmath785 \times{\mathbb r})$ ] , @xmath786 .
there is a generalized solution @xmath12 to @xmath787 , @xmath788 .
this solution is unique and is given by we now return to the original pde operator @xmath789 with distributional drift .
we again denote by @xmath296 the same application defined in section [ s5 ] and discuss existence and uniqueness of @xmath19-generalized solutions of related parabolic cauchy problems .
a useful consequence of proposition [ p39 ] is the following .
[ t313 ] for @xmath790 \times{\mathbb r})$ ] or @xmath77 , we again set @xmath791 according to the conventions of section .
again , we consider @xmath792 as a formal operator .
let @xmath793 \times{\mathbb r})$ ] , @xmath794 there is a unique solution @xmath753 \times{\mathbb r})$ ] to @xmath795 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber u(t,\cdot ) & = & u^0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] moreover , @xmath796 solves @xmath797 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber \tilde{u } ( t,\cdot ) & = & \tilde{u}^0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in accordance with section [ s4 ] , let @xmath798 be an approximating sequence which is related to @xmath799 .
let us consider the pde operators @xmath800 defined at ( [ e2.2 ] ) .
let @xmath801 be a sequence in @xmath802 such that @xmath803 , @xmath804 in a bounded way and for which there are classical solutions @xmath744 of @xmath805 we recall that those sequences always exist because of remark [ r21](c ) .
we set @xmath806 by lemma @xmath807 , we have @xmath808 where @xmath809 by proposition [ p39 ] , and corollary [ c311 ] , @xmath810 in a bounded way , where @xmath811 this concludes the proof of the proposition .
we now discuss how @xmath19-generalized solutions are transformed under the action of the function @xmath375 introduced at ( [ efk ] ) . a similar result to lemma
[ t216 ] for the elliptic case is the following .
[ p313 ] for @xmath790 \times{\mathbb r})$ ] or @xmath77 , we set @xmath812 .
we set @xmath813 and consider the formal operator @xmath814 informally , we can write @xmath815 let @xmath793 \times{\mathbb r})$ ] , @xmath794 let @xmath12 be the unique @xmath19-generalized solution in @xmath816 \times{\mathbb r})$ ] to @xmath817 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber u(t,\cdot ) & = & u^0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] then @xmath818 solves @xmath819 let @xmath11 be the unique solution to @xmath820 which exists because of theorem [ t313 ] , taking @xmath821 .
we define @xmath822 such that @xmath823 again , ( [ nonexplo ] ) implies that @xmath252 is bijective on @xmath71 .
this case corresponds to example ( a ) in remark [ r2.6 ] with @xmath824 .
we set @xmath825 .
again , by theorem [ t313 ] , we have @xmath826 where @xmath827 and @xmath828 since @xmath829 this yields @xmath830 on the other hand , @xmath831 since @xmath832 we can therefore conclude that @xmath833 . since problem ( [ f316a ] ) has a unique solution , @xmath834 , where @xmath12 solves ( [ f316 ] ) and @xmath835 finally , @xmath836 [ probrep ] the unique @xmath19-generalized solution to admits a probabilistic representation in the sense that @xmath837 where @xmath545 is the solution to the martingale problem related to @xmath44 at time @xmath541 and point @xmath275 .
the result follows from theorem [ t313 ] , corollary [ c311 ] and proposition [ p3.3 ] , which collectively imply the following .
if @xmath201 is a solution to the martingale problem related to @xmath44 at point @xmath275 at time @xmath541 , then @xmath592 solves the stochastic differential equation ( [ e3.3 ] ) with initial condition @xmath838 at time @xmath541 .
we now discuss the existence of a density law for the solutions @xmath545 of the martingale problem related to @xmath44 .
first , we suppose that @xmath44 is an operator in divergence form with @xmath839 and that there are positive constants such that @xmath840 .
we will say , in this case , that @xmath44 _ has the aronson form_. this terminology refers to the fundamental paper @xcite concerning exponential estimates of fundamental solutions of nondegenerate parabolic equations .
we begin with some properties ( partly classical ) stated in @xcite .
we observe that point ( ix ) is slightly modified with respect to @xcite , but this new configuration can be immediately deduced from the proof in @xcite .
this preparatory work will be applied to the operator @xmath621 introduced in ( [ e2.21 ] ) . [ l5.1 ] we suppose that @xmath841 .
let @xmath842 , @xmath843 , be smooth functions such that @xmath844 and @xmath845 in @xmath282 , as at the beginning of section [ s4 ] .
we set @xmath846 .
there exists a family of probability measures @xmath847 [ resp .
, @xmath848 enjoying the following properties : @xmath849 , @xmath850 ; ( aronson estimates ) there exists @xmath851 , depending only on constants @xmath852 , @xmath853 , with @xmath854 we have @xmath855 and @xmath856 where @xmath857 ( resp . , @xmath858 )
is called the related to the previous parabolic linear equation ; we have @xmath859 the map @xmath860 is continuous from @xmath8610,\infty [ \times \mathbb{r}^2 $ ] to @xmath862 ; the @xmath863 are smooth on @xmath8610,\infty [ \times\mathbb{r}^2 $ ] ; we have @xmath864 uniformly on each compact subset of @xmath8610,\infty[\times\mathbb{r}^2 $ ] ; @xmath865 holds for every @xmath866 and every @xmath867 ; @xmath868 the previous lemma allows us to establish the following .
[ tdistr ] let @xmath869 be the solution to the martingale problem related to @xmath44 at time @xmath541 and point @xmath275 .
suppose that @xmath44 to be of divergence type , having the aronson form .
then there is fundamental solution @xmath870 of @xmath871 with the following properties : letting @xmath785 \times{\mathbb r})$ ] , @xmath872 , the @xmath19-generalized solution @xmath12 to @xmath873 , @xmath788 , is given by @xmath874 the law of @xmath875 has @xmath876 as density with respect to lebesgue measure .
let @xmath877 be the fundamental solution corresponding to the parabolic equation associated with @xmath878 , as introduced in section [ s4 ] .
we observe that @xmath879 converges in a bounded way to @xmath880 .
we define @xmath881 points ( vi ) and ( ii ) of lemma [ l5.1 ] imply that functions @xmath744 belong to@xmath882 , so they are classical solutions to @xmath883 according to points ( ii ) and ( vii ) of the same lemma , one can prove that @xmath744 converges in a bounded way to @xmath12 defined by ( [ f312terd ] ) .
in fact , the coefficients @xmath884 are lower and upper bounded with a common constant , related to @xmath852 and @xmath853 .
therefore , this @xmath12 is the @xmath19-generalized solution of the cauchy problem being considered , which is known to exist . by uniqueness ,
point ( i ) is established .
setting @xmath885 , point ( i ) implies that @xmath886 is the @xmath19-generalized solution to @xmath887 with @xmath888 . by proposition [ probrep ] , in particular , using the probabilistic representation , we get@xmath889 .
[ rdistr ] if @xmath44 is in the divergence form , as before , then @xmath890 such that there exists @xmath891 with @xmath892 .
this is a consequence of lemma [ l28bis ] and the fact that @xmath893 .
hereafter , we will consider a general pde operator @xmath44 with distributional drift , as in section [ s4 ] , for which the assumption ( [ aronson ] ) below holds .
we observe that the pde operator in divergence form of the type @xmath895 , where @xmath896 , has the aronson form , so the previous theorem can be applied .
[ tdistr1 ] let @xmath545 be the solution to the martingale problem related to @xmath44 at time @xmath541 and point @xmath275 .
suppose that @xmath44 fulfills assumption .
then there exists a kernel @xmath897 such that : the law of @xmath898 has @xmath899 as density with respect to lebesgue measure for each @xmath900s , t]$ ] ; letting @xmath785 \times{\mathbb r})$ ] , @xmath901 , the @xmath902-generalized solution @xmath12 to @xmath873 , @xmath788 , is given by @xmath903 \(i ) proposition [ pmardiv ] says that @xmath904 solves the martingale problem with respect to @xmath621 .
let @xmath905 be the fundamental solution associated with the parabolic pde @xmath906 .
the first point then follows from the next observation .
[ rcv ] by means of a change of variable , it is easy to see that the density law of @xmath898 equals @xmath907 \(ii ) this is a consequence of point ( i ) , fubini s theorem and proposition [ probrep ] . at this point
, we need a lemma which extends to the kernel @xmath908 the integrability property of the kernel @xmath909 stated in ( [ rdistr ] ) concerning the divergence case .
[ ddistr1 ] let @xmath908 be the kernel introduced in theorem . then
: it is continuous in all variables @xmath9100,t[\ , \times\ , { \mathbb r}^2 $ ] ; it fulfills aronson estimates ; @xmath911 .
we recall , by remark [ rcv ] , that @xmath912 where @xmath913 is the fundamental solution associated with the operator @xmath914 , @xmath915 . this , and point ( v ) of lemma [ l5.1 ] , directly imply the validity of the first point .
taking into account assumption , aronson estimates for @xmath916 and the fact that @xmath917 result ( ii ) follows easily . with the same conventions as before , we have @xmath918 so , for @xmath764 , @xmath919 \(iii ) follows after integration with respect to @xmath24 and because of lemma [ l5.1](ix ) .
[ pdistr1 ] let @xmath785 \times{\mathbb r } ) \cap l^1([0,t ] \times { \mathbb r})$ ] , @xmath920 .
let @xmath921 \times{\mathbb r}\rightarrow{\mathbb r}$ ] be the @xmath19-generalized solution to @xmath763,@xmath922 .
then : @xmath923 ; @xmath924 is absolutely continuous , @xmath925 and in particular , for a.e .
@xmath926 $ ] , @xmath927 is square integrable .
[ rdistr1 ] previous assumptions imply that @xmath125 and @xmath650 are also square integrable .
proof of proposition [ pdistr1 ] we recall the expression given in theorem [ tdistr1 ] , @xmath928 using lemma [ ddistr1 ] and classical integration theorems , we have @xmath929 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber & & { } + \int_t^t dr \int_{\mathbb r } \,ds\ , g(s , x_1)\ , \partial_x p_{t - s } ( x , x_1)\,dx_1 .\end{aligned}\ ] ] using jensen s inequality , we have @xmath930 therefore , @xmath931 using aronson estimates , this quantity is bounded by @xmath932 where @xmath79 is the gaussian @xmath933 density .
this is clearly equal to @xmath934 this establishes point .
concerning point ( b ) , in order to simplify the framework we will suppose that @xmath885 .
expression ( [ f312tera ] ) implies that @xmath935 jensen s inequality implies that @xmath936 integrating with respect to @xmath24 gives @xmath937 this quantity is finite due to lemma .
as in the previous section , we will adopt assumption . at this point
, we wish to investigate the link between @xmath19-generalized solutions and the notion of spde s weak solutions for a corresponding cauchy problem .
we will adopt the same conventions as in section [ s4 ] . in this section
, we will suppose that coefficients @xmath938 are realizations of stochastic processes indexed by @xmath71 .
let us consider the formal operator @xmath383 , where @xmath44 acts on the second variable .
we consider the equation @xmath939 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber u(t,\cdot ) & = & u^0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the aim of this section is to show that a @xmath19-generalized solution to ( [ e3.9quater ] ) provides , when @xmath20 , a solution to the ( stochastic ) pde of the type ( [ ei-0 ] ) , as defined in the definition [ dei-1rig ] , that is , with the help of a symmetric integral via regularization , as defined in section [ s3 ] .
we denote by @xmath940 the linear space of @xmath941 real functions with compact support .
the link between the spde ( [ ei-0 ] ) and ( [ ei-0dual ] ) is given in the following .
[ pspdes ] let @xmath942 , @xmath943 , @xmath926 $ ] , @xmath764 be two continuous random fields a.s . in @xmath9440,t [ \times{\mathbb r } )
$ ] such that @xmath945 .
@xmath11 is a solution to the spde if and only if @xmath11 is a solution to the spde .
we observe that @xmath946 .
the proof is elementary .
the only point to check is the following : @xmath947 this follows by the definition of symmetric integral and the following , obvious , identity : @xmath948 for every @xmath949 .
we continue with a lemma , still supposing @xmath39 to be general .
[ lspdes ] let @xmath49 ( resp . ,
@xmath735 ) be a random field with parameter @xmath950 \times{\mathbb r}$ ] ( resp .
, @xmath764 ) whose paths are bounded and continuous .
let @xmath938 be continuous stochastic processes such that @xmath291 is defined a.s .
and assumption is satisfied .
let @xmath12 be the random field which is a.s .
the @xmath19-generalized solution to ( [ e3.9quater ] ) .
the following then holds : @xmath951 for every @xmath952 .
we fix a realization @xmath13 .
theorem [ tdistr1 ] says that the unique solution to equation ( [ e3.9quater ] ) is given by @xmath953 where @xmath954 is the density law of the solution to the martingale problem related to @xmath44 at point @xmath275 at time @xmath541 .
proposition [ pdistr1](b ) implies that @xmath955 exists and is integrable on @xmath8610,t [ \times{\mathbb r}$ ] .
according to proposition [ p313 ] , we know that @xmath956 is a @xmath19-generalized solution to @xmath957 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber \bar{u } ( t,\cdot ) & = & \bar u^0,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath958 on the other hand , @xmath959 can be represented via ( [ f312terd ] ) in theorem [ tdistr ] through fundamental solutions @xmath960 of @xmath961 since the previous equation holds in the schwarz distribution sense , by inspection , it is not difficult to show that @xmath959 is a solution ( in the sense of distributions ) to ( [ c0div ] ) , which means that we have the following : @xmath962 \\[-8pt ] \nonumber & & \qquad = \int_t^t ds \int_{\mathbb r}\alpha(z ) \bar\lambda(s , z)\end{aligned}\ ] ] for every test function @xmath952 , @xmath963 $ ] .
we recall , in particular , that @xmath964 is in @xmath9650,t [ \times{\mathbb r})$ ] .
we set @xmath966 expression ( [ c0div1 ] ) shows that @xmath967 in the sense of distributions .
so for each @xmath926 $ ] , @xmath968 is of class @xmath45 . for @xmath926 $ ] and @xmath764 , we set @xmath969 , @xmath970 .
we recall that @xmath971 therefore , @xmath972 so that @xmath973 therefore , @xmath974 and so @xmath975 is of class @xmath45 .
since @xmath976 , ( [ ediv1 ] ) gives @xmath977 consequently , @xmath978 we integrate the previous expression against a test function @xmath979 to obtain @xmath980 remark [ r1.0 ] and integration by parts for the symmetric integral provided by remark [ r1.1](c ) allow us to conclude the proof of the lemma . finally , we are able to state the theorem concerning the existence of weak solutions for the spde .
[ tspdes ] let @xmath49 ( resp . ,
@xmath735 ) be a random field with parameter in @xmath950 \times{\mathbb r}$ ] ( resp .
, @xmath764 ) whose paths are bounded and continuous .
we suppose that @xmath981 and that @xmath7 is a ( two - sided ) zero strong cubic variation process such that there are two finite and strictly positive random variables @xmath982 with @xmath983 a.s .
let @xmath12 be the random field which is @xmath13 a.s .
a @xmath19-generalized solution to for @xmath984 .
we set @xmath945 .
then @xmath11 is a ( weak ) solution of the spde .
proposition [ pspdes ] says that it will be enough to verify that @xmath985 for every test function @xmath25 and every @xmath926 $ ] . after making the identification @xmath21 ,
the previous lemma [ lspdes ] says that @xmath986 since @xmath7 is a zero strong cubic variation process , proposition [ pstacub ] implies that @xmath987 is also a zero strong cubic variation process .
then the it chain rule from proposition [ crule ] , applied with @xmath988 and remark [ r1.0 ] say that the right - hand side of previous expression gives @xmath989 this concludes the proof .
we would like to thank an anonymous referee and the editor for their careful reading and stimulating remarks .
the first named author is grateful to dr .
juliet ryan for her precious help in correcting several language mistakes .
flandoli , f. , russo , f. and wolf , j. ( 2004 ) . some sdes with distributional drift .
ii . lyons zheng structure , it formula and semimartingale characterization .
_ random oper .
stochastic equations _ * 12 * 145184 .
gradinaru , m. , russo , f. and vallois , p. ( 2003 ) .
generalized covariations , local time and stratonovich it s formula for fractional brownian motion with hurst index @xmath990 .
probab . _ * 31 * 17721820 . | a new class of random partial differential equations of parabolic type is considered , where the stochastic term consists of an irregular noisy drift , not necessarily gaussian , for which a suitable interpretation is provided . after freezing a realization of the drift ( stochastic process ) ,
we study existence and uniqueness ( in some appropriate sense ) of the associated parabolic equation and a probabilistic interpretation is investigated . and . |
cosmological constant @xmath4 was originally introduced in general relativity with the motivation to allow static homogeneous universe to einstein equations in the presence of matter .
once expansion of the universe was discovered , its role turned out to be unnecessary and it experienced a checkered history .
recent cosmological observations suggest some evidences for the existence of a positive cosmological constant @xcite : from a variety of observational sources , its magnitude is @xmath5 , and both matter @xmath6 and vacuum @xmath7 are of comparable magnitude , @xmath8 in spatially flat universe .
both results are paraphrased as old and new cosmological constant problems @xcite .
inclusion of quantum field theory predicts naturally the energy density via quantum fluctuations even up to the planck scale , so the old problem is to understand why the observed present cosmological constant is so small .
it is the worst fine - tuning problem requiring a magic cancellation with accuracy to 120 decimal places .
the new problem is to understand why the vacuum energy density is comparable to the present mass density of the universe .
though there are several classes of efforts to solve the cosmological constant problem , e.g. , cancellation of vacuum energy based on symmetry principle like supersymmetry , the idea of quintessence , and the anthropic principle , any of them is not widely accepted as the solution , yet . in the early universe , existing cosmological constant also provides an intriguing idea , inflationary cosmology , to fix long - standing cosmological problems in the big - bang scenario .
in addition to the above , detailed properties of the de sitter geometry in arbitrary dimensions raise a debate like selection of true vacuum compatible with its scale symmetry in relation with trans - planckian cosmology @xcite or becomes a cornerstone of a theoretical idea like ds / cft for a challenging problem of quantum gravity in de sitter spacetime @xcite . in the context of general relativity , classical study on the cosmological constant is to understand geometry of de sitter spacetime ( ds@xmath9 ) .
therefore , in this review , we study de sitter geometry and the motion of classical test particle in the background of the de sitter spacetime in detail .
topics include useful coordinate systems , geodesic motions , and penrose diagrams .
one of our purposes is to combine knowledges of classical de sitter geometry , scattered with other subjects in the textbooks or reviews , in one note @xcite .
we tried to make our review self - contained and a technical note by containing various formulas in the appendix .
the review is organized as follows . in section 2 ,
we introduce our setup with notations and signature . in section 3 ,
four coordinates ( global , conformal , planar , and static ) and coordinate transformations among those are explained with the reason why such four of them are frequently used .
killing symmetries are also obtained in each coordinate system . all possible geodesic motions of classical test particle are given in section 4 .
identification of de sitter horizon for a static observer and cosmological evolution to a comoving observer are also included . in section 5 , causal structure of the global de sitter spacetime
is dealt through penrose diagrams , and its quantum theoretical implication is also discussed .
section 6 is devoted to brief discussion .
various quantities are displayed in appendix for convenience .
in this section , we introduce basic setup for studying classical geometry of de sitter spacetime in arbitrary dimensions .
two methods are employed : one is solving directly einstein equations for each metric ansatz , and the other is reading off the specific form of coordinate transformation between two metrics .
we begin with einstein - hilbert action coupled to matters : @xmath10 where @xmath11 stands for the matter action of our interest , which vanishes for limit of the pure gravity , and @xmath4 is a cosmological constant , which sets to be positive for ds@xmath9 .
einstein equations are read from the action ( [ act ] ) @xmath12 where energy - momentum tensor @xmath13 is defined by @xmath14 throughout the paper small greek indices @xmath15 run from @xmath16 to @xmath17 , and our spacetime signature is @xmath18 .
to be specific let us consider a real scalar field @xmath19 of which action is @xmath20.\ ] ] in order not to have an additional contribution to the cosmological constant at classical level , we set minimum value of the scalar potential to vanish , @xmath21
. then its energy - momentum tensor becomes @xmath22 where energy density @xmath23 is positive semi - definite in the limit of flat spacetime .
for the pure ds@xmath9 , the energy - momentum tensor of the matter , @xmath13 , vanishes so that one can regard these spacetimes as solutions of the einstein equations of eq .
( [ eeq ] ) @xmath24 for an empty spacetime with a positive constant vacuum energy @xmath25 : @xmath26 therefore , the only nontrivial component of the einstein equations ( [ 2 ] ) is @xmath27 it means that the de sitter spacetime is maximally symmetric , of which local structure is characterized by a positive constant curvature scalar alone such as @xmath28 since the scalar curvature ( [ 4 ] ) is constant everywhere , the ds@xmath29 is free from physical singularity and it is confirmed by a constant kretschmann scalar : @xmath30 we follow usual definition of tensors as follows . [ cols="^,^",options="header " , ]
when we deal with specific physics in general relativity , we are firstly concerned with appropriate coordinate system . in this section ,
we introduce four useful coordinates and build coordinate transformations among those for tensor calculus : they are global ( closed ) , conformal , planar ( inflationary ) , and static coordinates . for
the detailed calculation of various quantities in systems of coordinates , refer to appendix .
similar to physical issues in flat spacetime , the symmetries of a riemannian manifold is realized through metric invariance under the symmetry transformations .
specifically , let us choose a coordinate system as @xmath31 and take into account a transformation @xmath32 .
if the metric @xmath33 remains to be form - invariant under the transformation @xmath34 for all coordinates @xmath35 , such transformation is called an isometry . since any finite continuous transformation with non - zero jacobian can be constructed by an infinite sum of infinitesimal transformations , study under infinitesimal transformation is sufficient for continuous isometry .
if we consider an infinitesimal coordinate transformation @xmath36 where @xmath37 is small parameter and @xmath38 a vector field , expansion of the form - invariance ( [ fin ] ) leads to killing s equations @xmath39 where @xmath40 denotes a lie derivative .
then , any @xmath38 given by a solution of the killing s equations ( [ keq ] ) is called a killing vector field . in every subsection
we will discuss killing symmetries of each coordinate system .
an intriguing observation about the ds@xmath29 is embedding of the ds@xmath29 into flat @xmath42-dimensional spacetime , which was made by e. schrdinger ( 1956 ) . in @xmath42-dimensional
minkowski spacetime , the einstein equation is trivially satisfied @xmath43 where capital indices , @xmath44 , represent @xmath42-dimensional minkowski indices run from @xmath16 to @xmath45 .
if we set @xmath46 which implies a positive constant curvature of the embedded space , then the @xmath45-dimensional einstein equation ( [ 4 ] ) of ds@xmath29 is reproduced .
a well - known coordinate system to cover entire @xmath45-dimensional hyperboloid is obtained from the following observation : as shown in fig .
[ dsrfig1 ] , the relation between @xmath67 and the spatial length of @xmath68 is hyperbolic and spatial sections of a constant @xmath69 defines a @xmath70-dimensional sphere of radius @xmath71 .
therefore , a convenient choice satisfying eq .
( [ 12 ] ) is @xmath72 where @xmath73 and @xmath74s@xmath75 for the spatial sections of constant @xmath76 satisfy @xmath77 subsequently , we have @xmath17 angle variables @xmath78 , such as @xmath79 inserting eq .
( [ gc ] ) and eq .
( [ omega ] ) into the metric ( [ 11 ] ) , we have a resultant metric rewritten in terms of the above coordinates @xmath80 : @xmath81 where @xmath82 is @xmath70-dimensional solid angle @xmath83 note that singularities in the metric ( [ dome ] ) at @xmath84 and @xmath85 are simply trivial coordinate artifacts that occur with polar coordinates . in these coordinates with a fixed time @xmath76 , the spatial hypersurface corresponds to a @xmath70-dimensional sphere of radius @xmath86 .
thus , its radius is infinitely large at @xmath87 , decreases to the minimum radius @xmath50 at @xmath88 , and then increases to infinite size as @xmath89 .
we again emphasize that the spatial section is compact ( finite ) except for the farthest past and future . in this coordinate system
, @xmath90 is the only killing vector because the metric ( [ gcs ] ) is isometric under the rotation of a coordinate @xmath91 . on the other hand
, @xmath92 is not a killing vector and missing of this killing symmetry breaks the conservation of energy so that hamiltonian is not defined properly and the quantization procedure does not proceed smoothly .
however , @xmath93-matrix of the quantum field theory , if it exists , is known to be unitary because the coordinates cover globally the whole spacetime .
an opposite direction is to assume an appropriate form of metric with an unknown function @xmath94 , @xmath95 and then to try to solve the einstein equations .
curvature scalar of the metric ( [ gcm ] ) is computed as @xmath96 where the overdot denotes derivative of the rescaled time variable @xmath97 in this subsection . with the aid of eq .
( [ len ] ) , the einstein equation ( [ 4 ] ) becomes @xmath98 a particular solution of eq .
( [ gneq ] ) , irrespective of @xmath45 , can be obtained by solving two equations @xmath99 the solution of eq .
( [ triv ] ) is @xmath100 $ ] except unwanted trivial solution ( @xmath101 ) .
since we can choose @xmath102 without loss of generality , via a time translation , @xmath103 , we have @xmath104 which is equivalent to the metric ( [ gcs ] ) found by a coordinate transformation .
the general solution of eq .
( [ gneq ] ) should satisfy the following equations @xmath105 where @xmath106 is an arbitrary function of @xmath107 . according to the search by use of mathematica and a handbook @xcite
, it seems that no other solution than eq .
( [ solg ] ) is known , yet . a noteworthy property of the ds@xmath9 is provided by computation of the weyl ( or conformal ) tensor @xmath109 for @xmath110 , or the cotton tensor @xmath111 for @xmath112 .
) is derived from the gravitational chern - simon action : @xmath113 since this gravitational chern - simon action is composed of cubic derivative terms so that it is dimensionless without any dimensionful constant .
it means that 3-dimensional conformal gravity is described by this chern - simon term . ] substituting the einstein equation ( [ 4 ] ) and eq .
( [ 9 ] ) into the conformal tensors in eqs .
( [ 5 ] ) and ( [ 6 ] ) , we easily notice that they vanish so that ds@xmath9 is proven to be conformally flat : @xmath114 ( g_{\mu\rho } g_{\rho\nu } - g_{\mu\sigma } g_{\rho\nu } ) r = 0,\\ c^{\mu\nu } & = & -\frac{1}{4}\frac{\epsilon^{\mu\nu\rho}}{\sqrt { -g } } \nabla_{\rho } ( r - 4 \lambda ) \stackrel{r\sim\lambda}{=}0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore , the condition ( [ 9 ] ) that the riemann curvature tensor is determined by the scalar curvature alone is equivalent to the condition of vanishing conformal tensor in this system .
consequently the unique scale of the ds@xmath29 , @xmath115 , can be scaled away by a weyl ( scale ) transformation .
the above conformal property of the ds@xmath29 suggests that conformal coordinate system is a good coordinate system .
it is written in terms of conformal time @xmath116 as @xmath117 if we compare the metric of the global coordinates ( [ gcs ] ) with that of the conformal coordinates ( [ cmet ] ) , then coordinate transformation between two is summarized in a first - order differential equation of @xmath118 @xmath119 where @xmath120 provides a boundary condition such as @xmath121 . the unique solution of eq .
( [ foe ] ) is @xmath122 substituting the result ( [ usol ] ) into the metric ( [ cmet ] ) , we have @xmath123 since the metric ( [ cc ] ) is isometric under the rotation of @xmath91 , @xmath124 is a killing vector but there is no other killing vector .
thus , the only symmetry is axial symmetry .
note that there is one - to - one correspondence between the global coordinates ( [ gcs ] ) and the conformal coordinates ( [ cc ] ) , which means that the conformal coordinate system describes also entire de sitter spacetime .
in addition , any null geodesic with respect to the conformal metric ( [ cc ] ) is also null in the conformally - transformed metric : @xmath125 therefore , penrose diagram for the ds@xmath29 can easily be identified from this metric ( [ cct ] ) , which contains the whole information about the causal structure of the ds@xmath29 but distances are highly distorted .
however , we will discuss the penrose diagram for the ds@xmath29 in section [ pendi ] after the kruskal coordinate system is introduced . as mentioned previously ,
topology of the de sitter spacetime is cylindrical @xmath126 so the process to make the penrose diagram is to change the hyperboloid into a @xmath45-dimensional cylinder of a finite height , being @xmath127 @xmath128)$ ] . again
note that the conformal coordinate system ( [ cc ] ) does not include the timelike killing symmetry so that the hamiltonian as a conserved quantity can not be chosen and the quantum theory on these coordinates is also sick .
existence of conformal symmetry also affects much on the choice of field theoretic vacuum in the de sitter spacetime . from now on let us obtain the conformal metric ( [ usol ] ) by solving the einstein equations ( [ 2 ] ) under eq .
( [ cmet ] ) . if we compute the curvature scalar , we have @xmath129 here overdot denotes @xmath130 , and the same overdot in every subsection will also be used as derivative of the rescaled time variable in each corresponding subsection . then the einstein equation ( [ 4 ] ) becomes @xmath131 a particular solution of eq .
( [ einc ] ) , irrespective of @xmath45 , should satisfy the following equations @xmath132 the unique solution of eq .
( [ cneq ] ) with @xmath121 is proven to be the same as eq .
( [ usol ] ) .
the general solution should satisfy the following equations @xmath133 where @xmath134 is an arbitrary function of @xmath135 . according to the search by use of mathematica and a handbook @xcite , no other solution than eq .
( [ usol ] ) is found yet .
a noticed character of the pure ds@xmath29 from eq . ( [ 9 ] ) is the fact that it is maximally symmetric .
suppose a comoving observer in the pure ds@xmath29 , then he or she may find maximally - symmetric spatial hypersurface orthogonal to his or her time direction .
the corresponding planar ( inflationary ) metric takes the form @xmath137 where @xmath138 is cosmic scale factor and @xmath70-dimensional spatial metric @xmath139 of hypersurface should also carry maximal symmetries as a defining property : @xmath140 where @xmath141 .
note that every nonvanishing component of the @xmath45-dimensional riemann curvature @xmath142 is expressed by the @xmath70-dimensional metric ( [ plme ] ) such as @xmath143 where the overdot denotes derivative of the rescaled time variable , @xmath144 .
so does those of the ricci tensor @xmath145\gamma_{ij}\ ; , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and that of the scalar curvature @xmath146 in the de sitter spacetime of our interest , we only have a positive vacuum energy ( or equivalently a positive cosmological constant ) as the matter source given in eq .
( [ sour ] ) .
let us interpret it in terms of a cosmological perfect fluid of which energy - momentum tensor can be written @xmath147 where @xmath148 and @xmath149 are the energy density and pressure respectively as measured in the rest frame , and @xmath150 is the velocity of the fluid . since the fluid is at rest for a comoving observer , the velocity of the fluid @xmath150 is @xmath151 and then @xmath152 . therefore , the equation of state @xmath153 tells it is a perfect fluid with a positive constant density and a negative constant pressure : @xmath154 obviously it is also consistent with conservation of the energy - momentum tensor ( [ sour ] ) , i.e. , @xmath155 .
due to isotropy and homogeneity , spatial part of the metric ( [ plme ] ) @xmath139 is rewritten by well - known robertson - walker metric in terms of @xmath70-dimensional spherical coordinates @xmath156 , @xmath157 : @xmath158,\ ] ] where @xmath159 can have 0 ( flat ) or @xmath160 ( open ) or @xmath161 ( closed ) . under the metric ( [ plms ] ) , the einstein equations ( [ 2 ] ) are summarized by two friedmann equations : @xmath162-\frac{k}{a^2 } = \frac{d-2}{2(d-1)}\lambda-\frac{k}{a^{2 } } , \label{frid1}\\ \frac{\ddot{a}}{a } & = & - 4\pi g \left ( \frac{\rho}{d-1 } + p\right ) = \frac{d-2}{2(d-1)}\lambda .
\label{frid2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the right - hand side of eq .
( [ frid2 ] ) is always positive in the ds@xmath29 of a positive cosmological constant .
thus , the universe depicted by the ds@xmath29 is accelerating or equivalently deceleration parameter @xmath163 is observed to be negative . when @xmath164 or @xmath160 , the right - hand side of eq .
( [ frid1 ] ) is always positive .
it means that , once the universe started expanding , it is eternally expanding . or equivalently ,
once hubble parameter @xmath165 was observed to be positive , the rate of expansion of the universe always remains to be positive .
even for @xmath166 case , once the cosmic scale factor @xmath138 arrives at critical size @xmath167 such as @xmath168 , and then the universe continues eternal expansion .
the exact solutions of the friedmann equations ( [ frid1])([frid2 ] ) are nothing but inflationary solutions consistent with the above arguments @xmath169 if we interpret singularity at @xmath170 as the big bang of the creation of the universe , then open universe of @xmath171 experienced it at @xmath172 and an expanding flat universe of @xmath164 did it at past infinity @xmath173 while closed universe of @xmath166 did not .
the constraint of the hyperboloid ( [ 12 ] ) embedded in @xmath42-dimensional minkowski spacetime can be decomposed into two constraints by introducing an additional parameter @xmath174 , of which one is a 2-dimensional hyperbola of radius @xmath175 @xmath176 and the other is a @xmath70-dimensional sphere of radius @xmath177 @xmath178 where @xmath179 denotes the sum over the index @xmath180 . therefore ,
a nice coordinate system to implement the above two constraints ( [ rrad])([llet ] ) is @xmath181 where range of @xmath182 is @xmath183 and that of @xmath184 is @xmath185 .
since @xmath186 , our planar coordinates ( [ scct ] ) cover only upper - half the ds@xmath29 as shown in fig .
[ dsrfig2 ] .
lower - half the ds@xmath29 can be described by changing the @xmath42-th coordinate @xmath51 to @xmath187 . inserting these transformations ( [ scct ] ) into the flat @xmath42-dimensional minkowski metric ( [ 11 ] )
, we obtain a familiar form of the planar metric of the ds@xmath9 : @xmath188 which coincides exactly with the flat solution ( [ plso ] ) found by solving the einstein equations ( [ frid1])([frid2 ] ) .
since the metric ( [ plm ] ) is not isometric under time translation , @xmath189 is not a timelike killing vector .
this nonexistence implies no notion of conserved energy and hamiltonian , which hinders description of quantum gravity in the planar coordinates .
however , the metric ( [ plm ] ) is independent of @xmath182 , so it satisfies form - invariance ( [ fin ] ) .
therefore , @xmath190 s are spacelike killing vectors and the spatial geometry involves translational symmetries and rotational symmetries .
the constraint of the hyperboloid ( [ 12 ] ) embedded in @xmath42-dimensional minkowski spacetime is again decomposed into two constraints by introducing an additional parameter @xmath192 , of which one is a 2-dimensional hyperbola of radius @xmath193 @xmath194 and the other is a @xmath70-dimensional sphere of radius @xmath195 @xmath196 therefore , a nice coordinate system to implement the above two constraints ( [ radii])([let ] ) is @xmath197 where @xmath198 s were given in eq .
( [ omega ] ) and @xmath199 will be identified with radial coordinate of static coordinate system . since @xmath200 and @xmath201 , the region of @xmath202 covers only a quarter of the whole ds@xmath29 as shown by the shaded region in fig .
[ dsrfig3 ] .
later , @xmath203 will be identified by a horizon of the pure de sitter spacetime . inserting these transformations ( [ sct ] ) into the @xmath42-dimensional minkowski metric ( [ 11 ] )
, we obtain a familiar form of static metric of the ds@xmath9 : @xmath204 dt^{2 } + \frac{dr^2}{\left [ 1 - \left ( \frac{r}{l}\right)^2 \right ] } + r^2 d \omega^2 _ { d-2},\ ] ] where @xmath205 the metric ( [ pcs ] ) is form - invariant ( [ fin ] ) for both time translation and rotation of the coordinate @xmath206 so that we have two killing vectors , @xmath207 and @xmath208 .
correspondingly , spacetime geometry has axial and time translational symmetries .
therefore , hamiltonian is well - defined in the static coordinates ( [ pcs ] ) but unitarity is threatened by existence of the horizon at @xmath203 . in order to describe the system with rotational symmetry in @xmath45-dimensions , a static observer may introduce the static coordinate system where the metric involves two independent functions of the radial coordinate @xmath192 , e.g. , @xmath209 and @xmath210 : @xmath211 curvature scalar of the metric ( [ pc ] ) is computed as @xmath212 -\left[\frac{d^2a}{dr^2}+2a\frac{d^2\omega}{dr^2}+2a\left(\frac{d\omega}{dr}\right)^2 + 3\frac{da}{dr}\frac{d\omega}{dr}\right].\ ] ] from eqs .
( [ sust ] ) and ( [ swst ] ) , simplified form of the einstein equations ( [ 2 ] ) is @xmath213 @xmath214 = \frac{(d-1)(d-2)}{l^2 } .\ ] ] schwarzschild - de sitter solution of eqs .
( [ dneq ] ) and ( [ eneq ] ) is @xmath215 here an integration constant @xmath216 can always be absorbed by a scale transformation of the time variable @xmath217 , @xmath218 , and the other integration constant @xmath219 is chosen to be zero for the pure de sitter spacetime of our interest , which is proportional to the mass of a schwarzschild - de sitter black hole @xcite . then the resultant metric coincides exactly with that of eq . ( [ pcs ] ) .
structure of a fixed curved spacetime is usually probed by classical motions of a test particle .
the shortest curve , the geodesic , connecting two points in the de sitter space is determined by a minimum of its arc - length @xmath220 for given initial point @xmath221 and end - point @xmath222 , and is parametrized by an arbitrary parameter @xmath223 such as @xmath224 : @xmath225 according to the variational principle , the geodesic must obey second - order euler - lagrange equation @xmath226 when the parameter @xmath223 is chosen by the arc - length @xmath220 itself , a force - free test particle moves on a geodesic . in this section , we analyze precisely possible geodesics in the four coordinate systems of the de sitter spacetime , obtained in the previous section .
we also introduce several useful quantities in each coordinate system and explain some characters of the obtained geodesics .
lagrangian for the geodesic motions ( [ arc ] ) is read from the metric ( [ gcs ] ) in the global coordinates : @xmath227 where @xmath223 is an affine parameter .
corresponding geodesic equations ( [ geq ] ) are given by @xmath45-coupled equations @xmath228 @xmath229 since @xmath91 is cyclic , @xmath230 in eq .
( [ geq2 ] ) is replaced by a constant of motion @xmath231 such as @xmath232 let us recall a well - known fact that any geodesic connecting arbitrary two points on a @xmath70-dimensional sphere should be located on its greatest circle .
due to rotational symmetry on the @xmath233 , one can always orient the coordinate system so that the radial projection of the orbit coincides with the equator , @xmath234 of the spherical coordinates .
this can also be confirmed by an explicit check that eq .
( [ fixa ] ) should be a solution of eq .
( [ geq2 ] ) .
it means that a test particle has at start and continues to have zero momenta in the @xmath235-directions ( @xmath236 ) .
therefore , the system of our interest reduces from @xmath45-dimensions to ( @xmath237)-dimensions without loss of generality .
insertion of eq .
( [ fixa ] ) into eq .
( [ am ] ) gives @xmath238 so that the remaining equation ( [ gteq1 ] ) becomes @xmath239 integration of eq .
( [ taud ] ) arrives at the conservation of energy @xmath240 @xmath241 where the effective potential @xmath242 is given by @xmath243 and thereby another constant of motion @xmath240 should be bounded below , i.e. , @xmath244 . eliminating the affine parameter @xmath223 in both eq .
( [ fixb ] ) and eq .
( [ ener ] ) , we obtain the orbit equation which is integrated as an algebraic equation : @xmath245 since the spatial sections are sphere @xmath233 of a constant positive curvature and cauchy surfaces , their geodesic normals of @xmath246 are lines which monotonically contract to a minimum spatial separation and then re - expand to infinity ( see dotted line in fig . [ geo1 ] ) .
another representative geodesic motion of @xmath247 ( dashed line ) is also sketched in fig .
for example , suppose that the affine parameter @xmath223 is identified with the coordinate time @xmath76 .
then , we easily confirm from the above analysis that every geodesic emanating from any point can be extended to infinite values of the affine parameters in both directions , @xmath248 , so that the de sitter spacetime is said to be geodesically complete .
however , there exist spatially - separated points which can not be joined by one geodesic .
similar to the procedure in the previous subsection , we read automatically lagrangian for geodesics ( [ arc ] ) from the conformal metric ( [ cc ] ) : @xmath249,\ ] ] and then corresponding geodesic equations ( [ geq ] ) are @xmath250 @xmath251 since @xmath91 is cyclic , @xmath230 is replaced by a constant of motion @xmath231 such as @xmath252 since the @xmath70-angular coordinates @xmath253 constitute a ( @xmath17)-dimensional sphere , the same argument around eq .
( [ fixa ] ) is applied and thereby the system of our interest reduces again from @xmath45-dimensions to @xmath254-dimensions without loss of generality . substituting of eq .
( [ fixa ] ) into eq .
( [ am2 ] ) , we have @xmath255 and rewrite eq .
( [ coge1 ] ) as @xmath256 eq .
( [ taud2 ] ) is integrated out and we obtain another conserved quantity @xmath240 : @xmath257 in eq .
( [ ener2 ] ) we rescaled the affine parameter @xmath223 in order to absorb a redundant constant .
combining eq .
( [ fixb2 ] ) and eq .
( [ ener2 ] ) , we obtain an orbit equation expressed by elliptic functions : @xmath258 \;,\ ] ] where @xmath259 @xmath260 ( @xmath261 ) represents a cylinder of finite height as shown in fig .
geodesic of zero energy , @xmath262 , ( or equivalently zero angular momentum , @xmath246 ) , is shown as a dotted line , and that of positive energy , @xmath263 , ( or nonvanishing angular momentum , @xmath264 ) , as a dashed line in fig .
[ gd11 ] .
lagrangian for the geodesic motion ( [ arc ] ) for the flat space of @xmath164 is read from the metric ( [ plms ] ) : @xmath265 and the corresponding geodesic equations ( [ geq ] ) are @xmath266 @xmath267 @xmath268 since @xmath206 is cyclic , @xmath269 is replaced by a constant of motion @xmath231 such as @xmath270 if we use a well - known fact that any geodesic connecting arbitrary two points on a @xmath271-dimensional sphere should be located on its greatest circle , one may choose without loss of generality @xmath272 which should be a solution of eq .
( [ plge3 ] ) due to rotational symmetry on the @xmath271-dimensional sphere @xmath273 . therefore , the system of our interest reduces from @xmath45-dimensions to @xmath274-dimensions without loss of generality .
+ insertion of eq .
( [ fixa3 ] ) into eq .
( [ am3 ] ) gives @xmath275 so that the equations ( [ plge1])([plge2 ] ) become @xmath276 @xmath277 eliminating the third term in both eqs .
( [ taud3])([taudd3 ] ) by subtraction , we have the combined equation @xmath278 where @xmath279 is constant .
finally , for @xmath280 , the radial equation ( [ ener3 ] ) is solved as @xmath281 for @xmath246 , eq .
( [ taudd3 ] ) becomes @xmath282 it reduces @xmath283 and @xmath284 is constant .
information on the scale factor @xmath285 is largely gained through the observation of shifts in wavelength of light emitted by distant sources .
it is conventionally gauged in terms of redshift parameter @xmath286 between two events , defined as the fractional change in wavelength : @xmath287 where @xmath288 is the wavelength observed by us here after long journey and @xmath289 is that emitted by a distant source . for convenience , we place ourselves at the origin @xmath290 of coordinates since our de sitter space is homogeneous and isotropic , and consider a photon traveling to us along the radial direction with fixed @xmath291 s .
suppose that a light is emitted from the source at time @xmath292 and arrives at us at time @xmath293 .
then , from the metric ( [ plms ] ) , the null geodesic connecting ( @xmath294 ) and ( @xmath295 ) relates coordinate time and distance as follows @xmath296 if next wave crest leaves @xmath297 at time @xmath298 and reach us at time @xmath299 , the time independence of @xmath300 provides @xmath301 for sufficiently short time @xmath302 ( or @xmath303 ) the scale factor @xmath285 is approximated by a constant over the integration time in eq .
( [ tim ] ) , and , with the help of @xmath304 ( or @xmath305 ) , eq .
( [ tim ] ) results in @xmath306 where @xmath307 from eq .
( [ hub ] ) and @xmath308 from eq ( [ depa ] ) . substituting eq .
( [ fac ] ) into eq .
( [ red ] ) , we have @xmath309 on the other hand , the comoving distance @xmath310 is not measurable so that we can define the luminosity distance @xmath311 : @xmath312 where @xmath313 is absolute luminosity of the source and @xmath314 is flux measured by the observer .
it is motivated from the fact that the measured flux @xmath314 is simply equal to luminosity times one over the area around a source at distance @xmath45 in flat space . in expanding universe
, the flux will be diluted by the redshift of the light by a factor @xmath315 and the difference between emitting time and measured time .
when comoving distance between the observer and the light source is @xmath310 , a physical distance @xmath45 becomes @xmath316 , where @xmath317 is scale factor when the light is observed .
therefore , we have @xmath318 inserting eq .
( [ fl ] ) into eq .
( [ ldis ] ) , we obtain @xmath319 using the expansion ( [ h0 ] ) , eq .
( [ zz ] ) is expressed by @xmath320 for small @xmath321 , eq .
( [ za ] ) can be inverted to @xmath322.\ ] ] when @xmath164 , the right - hand side of eq .
( [ nur ] ) yields @xmath323 and expansion of the left - hand side for small @xmath321 gives @xmath324 \nonumber\\ & = & \frac{1}{a_0h_0}\left[z-\frac{1}{2}(1+q_0)z^2+\cdots\right],\label{rz}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath325 was used in the second line and eq .
( [ zb ] ) was inserted in the third line .
replacing @xmath310 in eq .
( [ dl ] ) by eq .
( [ rz ] ) , we finally have hubble s law : @xmath326\ ] ] which relates the distance to a source with its observed red shift . note that we can determine present hubble parameter @xmath327 and present deceleration parameter @xmath328 by measurement of the luminosity distances and redshifts . as a reference ,
observed value of @xmath327 at present is @xmath329 ( @xmath330 ) so that corresponding time scale @xmath331 is about one billion year and length scale @xmath332 is about several thousand @xmath333 . since the scale factor is given by an exponential function , @xmath334 , for the flat spacetime of @xmath164 , the left - hand side of eq .
( [ nur ] ) is integrated in a closed form : @xmath335 in addition , the redshift parameter @xmath286 is expressed as @xmath336 so the luminosity distance @xmath311 in eq .
( [ dl ] ) becomes @xmath337 comparing eq .
( [ dl2 ] ) with the hubble s law ( [ hl ] ) , we finally confirm that the expanding flat space solution of @xmath164 has present hubble parameter @xmath338 and the de sitter universe is accelerating with present deceleration parameter @xmath339 as expected .
geodesic motions parametrized by proper time @xmath220 are described by the following lagrangian read from the static metric ( [ pcs ] ) : @xmath340\left(\frac{dt}{d\sigma}\right)^2 + \frac{1}{1-\left(\frac{r}{l}\right)^2 } \left ( \frac{dr}{d\sigma}\right)^2 + r^2 \sum_{b=1}^{d-2}\left ( \prod _ { a=1}^{b-1 } \sin ^2 \theta _ { a}\right ) \left ( \frac{d\theta_b}{d\sigma}\right)^2.\ ] ] since the time @xmath217 and angle @xmath206 coordinates are cyclic , the conjugate momenta @xmath240 and @xmath231 are conserved : @xmath341 @xmath342\frac{dt}{d\sigma}\;.\ ] ] by the same argument in the subsection [ pigo ] , the system of our interest reduces from @xmath45-dimensions to ( @xmath343)-dimensions without loss of generality , and then eq .
( [ am4 ] ) becomes @xmath344 from here on let us use rescaled variables @xmath345 , @xmath346 , and @xmath347 .
note that @xmath348 can not exceed @xmath349 due to the limitation of light velocity .
then second - order radial geodesic equation from the lagrangian ( [ sclag ] ) becomes @xmath350 integration of eq .
( [ taud4 ] ) leads to conservation of the energy @xmath351 @xmath352 where the effective potential @xmath242 is given by @xmath353 as shown in fig .
[ geo4 ] , the motion of a particle having the energy @xmath354 can never lower than @xmath355 due to repulsive centrifugal force , which becomes @xmath16 as @xmath348 approaches @xmath16 .
the ranges except @xmath356 are forbidden by the fact that kinetic energy should be positive . for @xmath357 indicated in fig .
[ geo4 ] , a test particle moves bounded orbit within two turning points @xmath358 and @xmath359 .
the perihelion @xmath358 and the aphelion @xmath359 were obtained from @xmath360 @xmath361 if the energy @xmath351 have minimum value of the effective potential @xmath362 , then the motion is possible only at @xmath363 , so that the orbital motion should be circular .
shaded region in fig .
[ geo4 ] is the allowable region for static observer , which is bounded by de sitter horizon ( @xmath364 ) .
it corresponds to one fourth of the global hyperbolic region in fig .
[ pen1 ] . solving for @xmath365 from eq .
( [ ener4 ] ) , we have @xmath366 then the integration of both sides gives @xmath367 where @xmath279 is an integration constant .
if we choose the perihelion @xmath358 given in eq .
( [ semi ] ) for @xmath368 , @xmath279 is fixed by @xmath369 and then the aphelion @xmath359 is given at @xmath370 .
when the energy @xmath351 takes maximum value @xmath371 , position of the aphelion at @xmath364 is nothing but the de sitter horizon .
so the elapsed proper time for the motion from the perihelion to the aphelion , ( @xmath372 ) , is finite .
changing the proper time @xmath220 in eq .
( [ geint ] ) to coordinate time of a static observer @xmath184 by means of eq .
( [ como4 ] ) , we find @xmath373 and the integration for @xmath357 gives @xmath374=\frac{4e-(j^2 - 1 + 2e)(1-x^2)}{\sqrt{-2e}(x^2 - 1 ) \sqrt{2e+(1-x^2)(1-j^2/x^2)}}.\ ] ] note that the ranges are @xmath375 in the case of @xmath376 , the integration of eq .
( [ getime ] ) gives @xmath377 to reach the de sitter horizon at @xmath364 , the energy @xmath351 should have a value @xmath354 irrespective of the value of @xmath348 as shown in fig .
[ radig ] . for @xmath378 , @xmath379
is fixed by @xmath380 .
when a test particle approaches the de sitter horizon , the elapsed coordinate time diverges as @xmath381 by combining eq .
( [ fixb4 ] ) with eq .
( [ geint ] ) and its integration , we obtain an elliptic orbit equation for @xmath357 : @xmath382[(1-j)^2 + 2e ] } } .\ ] ] if we choose @xmath379 as the perihelion at @xmath383 , @xmath384 becomes @xmath369 . from eq .
( [ semi ] ) , the semimajor axis @xmath385 of @xmath386 is given by @xmath387 eccentricity @xmath37 of the ellipse can be written @xmath388 dependence of the orbit for @xmath37 is the followings : @xmath389 this scheme agrees with qualitative discussion by using the effective potential ( [ efpo ] ) and the energy diagram in fig .
[ geo4 ] . in terms of @xmath390 and @xmath37 , eq . ( [ oesol ] ) is rewritten by @xmath391 eq .
( [ gesan ] ) follows @xmath392 at @xmath383 and @xmath393 at @xmath394 as expected from eq .
( [ semi ] ) . as shown in fig .
[ orbit ] , eq .
( [ gesan ] ) satisfies the condition for closed orbits so - called bertrand s theorem , which means a particle retraces its own foot step .
let us begin with a spacetime with physical metric @xmath33 , and introduce another so - called unphysical metric @xmath395 , which is conformally related to @xmath33 such as @xmath396 here , the conformal factor @xmath397 is suitably chosen to bring in the points at infinity to a finite position so that the whole spacetime is shrunk into a finite region called penrose diagram .
a noteworthy property is that the null geodesics of two conformally related metrics coincide , which determine the light cones and , in turn , define causal structure .
if such process called conformal compactification is accomplished , all the information on the causal structure of the de sitter spacetime is easily visualized through this penrose diagram although distances are highly distorted . in this section , we study detailed casual structure in various coordinates in terms of the penrose diagram .
since every penrose diagram is drawn as a two - dimensional square in the flat plane , each point in the diagram denotes actually a @xmath271-dimensional sphere @xmath273 except that on left or right side of the diagram .
let us introduce a coordinate transformation from the static coordinates ( [ pcs ] ) to eddington - finkelstein coordinates @xmath398 such as @xmath399 where the range of @xmath400 is @xmath401 .
as expected , @xmath402 results in a timelike curve for a static object at the origin , @xmath403 .
then the metric in eq .
( [ pcs ] ) becomes @xmath404 though the possible domain of real @xmath195 corresponds to the interior region of the de sitter horizon [ 0,1 ) due to the logarithm of eq .
( [ stoe ] ) , the metric itself ( [ efc ] ) remains to be real for the whole range of @xmath195 since @xmath405 , { \rm tanh } [ ( x^+-x^-)/2l])$ ] has ( 1,0 ) at @xmath402 , ( 0,1 ) at @xmath406 , and @xmath407 at @xmath408 , so it covers the entire @xmath45-dimensional de sitter spacetime as expected .
in order to arrive at penrose diagram of our interest , these coordinates are transformed into kruskal coordinates ( @xmath409 , @xmath410 ) by @xmath411 and then the metric takes the form @xmath412 .\ ] ] the value of @xmath413 has @xmath160 at the origin ( @xmath402 ) , @xmath16 at the horizon ( @xmath406 ) , and @xmath349 at infinity ( @xmath414 ) by a relation @xmath415 .
in addition , another relation @xmath416 tells us that the line of @xmath417 corresponds to past infinity ( @xmath418 ) and @xmath419 does to future infinity ( @xmath420 ) .
therefore , the entire region of the de sitter spacetime is drawn by a penrose diagram which is a square bounded by @xmath421 . at the horizon , @xmath203 so that @xmath415 implies @xmath422 . therefore , as shown in the fig .
[ pen1 ] , the coordinate axes @xmath417 and @xmath419 ( dashed lines ) are nothing but the horizons and the arrows on those dashed lines stand for the directions of increasing @xmath409 and @xmath410 . the shaded region is the causally - connected region for the observer at the origin on the right - hand side of the square ( @xmath423 , @xmath402 ) . in the kruskal coordinates ( [ etok ] ) , a killing vector @xmath424 in the static coordinates is expressed as @xmath425 thus norm of the killing vector is @xmath426 note that the norm of the killing vector becomes null at @xmath422 . in the region of @xmath427 ,
the norm is spacelike , while a half of the region with negative @xmath410 is forbidden .
timelike killing vector is defined only in the shaded region with @xmath428 as shown in fig .
such existence of the killing vector field @xmath429 guarantees conserved hamiltonian which allows quantum mechanical description of time evolution .
however , @xmath429 is spacelike in both top and bottom triangles and points toward the past in right triangle bounded by the southern pole in fig .
[ pen1 ] . therefore
, time evolution can not be defined beyond the shaded region .
the absence of global definition of timelike killing vector in the whole de sitter spacetime may predict difficulties in quantum theory , e.g. , unitarity . as mentioned previously , the conformal metric ( [ cct ] ) describes entire de sitter spacetime and is flat except for a conformal factor @xmath430 because of the scale symmetry ( [ 8 ] ) .
these properties are beneficial for drawing the penrose diagram . by comparing the conformal metric ( [ cct ] ) directly with that of the kruskal
coordinates ( [ kc ] ) , we obtain a set of coordinate transformation @xmath431,\\ v&=&\tan\left[\frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{t}{l}-\theta_{1}+\frac{\pi}{2 } \right)\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where integration constants are chosen by considering easy comparison with the quantities in the static coordinates .
since the range of conformal time @xmath116 is @xmath432 , the horizontal slice @xmath233 at @xmath433 ( @xmath434 ) forms a past ( future ) null infinity @xmath435 ( @xmath436 ) with @xmath437 as shown in fig .
[ pen3 ] . when @xmath438 @xmath439 , it is a vertical line on the left ( right ) side with @xmath423 , which is called by north ( south ) pole . when @xmath440 @xmath441 , @xmath417 @xmath442 corresponding to a null geodesic ( or another null geodesic ) starts at the south ( or north ) pole at the past null infinity @xmath443 and ends at the north ( or south ) pole at the future null infinity @xmath444 , where all null geodesics originate and terminate ( see two dashed lines at @xmath445 degree angles in fig . [ pen3 ] ) .
obviously , timelike surfaces are more vertical compared to the null geodesic lines and spacelike surfaces are more horizontal compared to those .
therefore , every horizontal slice of a constant @xmath116 is a surface @xmath233 and every vertical line of constant @xmath446s is timelike ( see the horizontal and vertical lines in fig .
[ pen3 ] ) .
although this diagram contains the entire de sitter spacetime , any observer can not observe the whole spacetime .
the de sitter spacetime has particle horizon because past null infinity is spacelike , i.e. , an observer at the north pole can not see anything beyond his past null cone from the south pole at any time as shown by the region @xmath447 in fig .
[ pen4]-(a ) , because the geodesics of particles are timelike .
the de sitter spacetime has future event horizon because future null infinity is also spacelike : the observer can never send a message to any region beyond @xmath448 as shown in fig .
[ pen4]-(b ) .
this fact is contrasted to the following from minkowski spacetime where a timelike observer will eventually receive all history of the universe in the past light cone . therefore , the fully accessible region to an observer at the north pole is the common region of both @xmath447 and @xmath448 , which coincides exactly with the causally - connected region for the static observer at the origin in fig .
[ pen1 ] . by comparing the planar coordinates ( [ plm ] ) with the kruskal coordinates ( [ kc ] ) , we again find a set of coordinate transformation @xmath449 here we easily observe @xmath450 from eq .
( [ vv ] ) .
@xmath413 has @xmath160 at both the origin @xmath451 and infinity @xmath452 by a relation @xmath453 . in fig .
[ pen2 ] , the origin corresponds to the boundary line at left side but the infinity to the point at upper - right corner . according to another relation @xmath454
, past infinity @xmath455 has @xmath419 so it corresponds to the diagonal line , and future infinity @xmath456 has @xmath457 so it corresponds to the horizontal line at upper side of the penrose diagram .
therefore , the planar coordinates cover only the half of the de sitter spacetime ( see the shaded region in fig .
[ pen2 ] ) . every dashed line in fig .
[ pen2 ] is a constant - time slice , which intersects with a line of @xmath451 and is ( @xmath17)=dimensional surface of infinite area with the flat metric of @xmath164 . although the whole de sitter spacetime is geodesically complete as we discussed in the subsection [ glogeo ] , half of the de sitter spacetime described by the planar coordinates is incomplete in the past as shown manifestly in fig .
in this review , we have discussed classical geometry of @xmath45-dimensional de sitter spacetime in detail : sections include introduction of four representative coordinates ( global ( or closed ) , conformal , planar ( or inflationary ) , static ) , identification of killing vectors , geodesic motions , cosmological implication , and penrose diagrams .
two important subjects are missing : one is group theoretic approach of the de sitter spacetime and the other is energy because we do believe they have to be systematically dealt with quantum theoretic topics like supersymmetry and hamiltonian formulation of quantum theory .
once we try to supersymmetrize de sitter group , inconsistency is easily encountered , that either a supergroup including both unitary representations and isometries of the de sitter spacetime is absent or any action compatible with de sitter local supersymmetry contains vector ghosts @xcite . in de sitter spacetime
two definitions are known to define the mass of it : one is the abbott - deser mass given as the eigenvalue of zeroth component of virasoro generators and the other is the quasilocal mass obtained from brown - york stress tensor associated to a boundary of a spacetime @xcite .
however , unitarity and conserved energy are not satisfied simultaneously in quantum theory in the de sitter spacetime , and structure of de sitter vacuum seems to ask more discussion @xcite .
strikingly enough recent cosmological observations suggest the existence of extremely - small positive cosmological constant , however it just leads to a new form of terrible cosmological constant problem . in the present stage
, it seems to force us to find its solution by understanding quantum gravity ( in de sitter spacetime ) .
obviously the topics we reviewed form a basis for the following research subjects still in progress , e.g. , de sitter entropy and thermodynamics , ds / cft correspondence , trans - planckian cosmology , understanding of vacuum energy in the context of string theory , and etc , of which ultimate goal should be perfect understanding of the cosmological constant problem as consequence of constructed quantum gravity .
for convenience , various formulas and quantities which have been used in the previous sections are summarized in the following four subsections . from the metric ( [ gcm ] ) of the global coordinates ( @xmath458 )
, nonvanishing components of covariant metric @xmath33 are @xmath459 and its inverse @xmath54 has @xmath460 jacobian factor @xmath461 of the metric ( [ yd1 ] ) becomes @xmath462 nonvanishing components of the connection @xmath56 are @xmath463 for completeness , we mention non - zero components of the riemann curvature tensor @xmath58 , which are consistent with eq . ( [ 9 ] ) : @xmath464 \prod_{j=1}^{i-1}\sin^2\theta_j \;,&\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the ricci tensor @xmath60 : @xmath465\right\ } \prod_{j=1}^{i-1}\sin^2\theta_j \;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] curvature scalar @xmath62 coincides with the formula in eq .
( [ csgo ] ) . from the metric ( [ cmet ] ) of the conformal coordinates ( @xmath466 ) , nonvanishing components of covariant metric @xmath33 are @xmath467 and its inverse @xmath54 has @xmath468 jacobian factor @xmath461 of the metric ( [ zd1 ] ) becomes @xmath469 nonvanishing components of the connection @xmath470 are @xmath471 non - zero components of the riemann curvature tensor @xmath58 consistent with eq .
( [ 9 ] ) are @xmath472 \;,\nonumber\\ r^{i}_{\ ; j i j } & = & \frac{1}{f^2}\left[f^2+\left(\frac{df}{dt}\right)^2 \right ] \prod_{j=1}^{i-1}\sin^2\theta_j \;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and non - zero components of the ricci tensor @xmath60 are @xmath473 \ ; , \nonumber\\ r_{ii } & = & \frac{1}{l^2f^2 } \left [ f\left(\frac{d^2f}{dt^2}\right ) + ( d-3)\left(\frac{df}{dt}\right)^2+(d-2)f^2 \right ] \prod_{j=1}^{i-1}\sin^2\theta_j \;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore , curvature scalar @xmath62 in the conformal coordinates coincides with the formula in eq .
( [ csco ] ) .
y. kim would like to thank m. spradlin for helpful discussions .
this work was the result of research activities ( astrophysical research center for the structure and evolution of the cosmos ( arcsec ) and the basic research program , r01 - 2000 - 000 - 00021 - 0 ) supported by korea science @xmath493 engineering foundation .
a.g . riess _
et al _ , astron .
j. * 116 * , 1009 ( 1998 ) , astro - ph/9805201 , _ observational evidence from supernovae for an accelerating universe and a cosmological constant _ ; + p.m. garnavich _
et al _ , astrophys .
j. * 509 * , 74 ( 1998 ) , astro - ph/9806396 , _ supernova limits on the cosmic equation of state _ ; + s. perlmutter _
et al _ , astrophys .
j. * 517 * , 565 ( 1999 ) , astro - ph/9812133 , _ measurements of omega and lambda from 42 high - redshift supernovae_. for a review , see s. weinberg , rev .
phys . * 61 * , 1 ( 1989 ) , _ the cosmological constant problem_. for reviews , see e. witten , _ marina del rey 2000 , sources and detection of dark matter and dark energy in the universe _ , pp.27 - 36 , hep - ph/0002297 , _ the cosmological constant from the viewpoint of string theory _
carroll , living rev .
rel . * 4 * , 1 ( 2001 ) , astro - ph/0004075 , _ the cosmological constant _ ; + s. weinberg , _ marina del rey 2000 , sources and detection of dark matter and dark energy in the universe _ , pp.18 - 26 , astro - ph/0005265 , _ the cosmological constant problem _ ; + p.j.e .
peebles and b. ratra , to appear in rev .
phys . , astro - ph/0207347 , _ the cosmological constant and dark energy _
; + t. padmanabhan , to appear in phys . rep .
, hep - th/0212290 , _ cosmological constant - the weight of the vacuum _ ; + and references therein .
j. martin and r.h .
brandenberger , phys .
rev . d*63 * , 123501 ( 2001 ) , hep - th/0005209 , _ the trans - planckian problem of inflationary cosmology _ ; + r.h .
brandenberger and j. martin , mod .
a*16 * , 999 ( 2001 ) , astro - ph/0005432 , _ the robustness of inflation to changes in superplanck scale _
niemeyer , phys .
rev . d*63 * , 123502 ( 2001 ) , astro - ph/0005533 , _ inflation with a planck scale frequency cutoff _ ; + for a review , see r.h .
brandenberger , to appear in the proceedings of _ 2002 international symposium on cosmology and particle astrophysics _ , hep - th/0210186 , _ trans - planckian physics and inflationary cosmology_. n. kaloper , m. kleban , a. lawrence , s. shenker , and l. susskind , jhep * 0211 * , 037 ( 2002 ) , hep - th/0209231 , _ initial conditions for inflation _
danielsson , jhep * 0207 * , 040 ( 2002 ) , hep - th/0205227 , _ inflation , holography , and the choice of vacuum in de sitter space_. a. strominger , jhep * 0111 * , 034 ( 2002 ) , hep - th/0106113 , _ the ds / cft correspondence _ ; + for a review , see r. bousso , rev .
phys . * 74 * , 825 ( 2002 ) , hep - th/0203101 , _ the holographic principle_. n.d .
birrell and p.c.w .
davies , _ quantum fields in curved space _
, chapter 5 , cambridge university press .
e.w . kolb and m.s .
turner , _ the early universe _ , chapters 8 @xmath493 11 , addison - wesley publishing company .
s.w . hawking and g.f.r .
ellis , section 5.2 of _ the large scale structure of space - time _
, cambridge university press ; + c.w .
misner , k.s .
thorne , and j.a .
wheeler , _ gravitation _ , chapter 27 , w.h .
freeman and company ; + s. weinberg , _ gravitation and cosmology _ , chapter 16 , john wiley @xmath493 sons .
for lecture notes , see m. spradlin , a. strominger , and a. volovich , hep - th/0110007 , _ les houches lecture on de sitter space_. a.d .
polyanin and v.f .
zaitsev , _ handbook of exact solutions for ordinary differential equations _
, crc press .
gibbons and s.w .
hawking , phys .
rev . d*15 * , 2738 ( 1977 ) , _ cosmological event horizons , thermodynamics , and particle creation_. k. pilch , p. van nieuwenhuizen , and m.f .
sohnius , commun .
* 98 * , 105 ( 1985 ) , _ de sitter superalgebras and supergravity _ ; + c.m .
hull , jhep * 9807 * , 021 ( 1998 ) , hep - th/9806146 , _ timelike t - duality , de sitter space , large @xmath494 gauge theories and topological field theory_. l.f .
abbott and s. deser , nucl .
b*195 * , 76 ( 1982 ) , _ stability of gravity with a cosmological constant _ ; + j.d .
brown and j.w .
york , phys .
rev . d*47 * , 1407 ( 1993 ) , gr - qc/9209012 , _ quasilocal energy and conserved charges derived from the gravitational action_. a. kaiser and a. chodos , phys . rev .
d*53 * , 787 ( 1996 ) , _ symmetry breaking in the static coordinate system of de sitter space - time_. | classical geometry of de sitter spacetime is reviewed in arbitrary dimensions .
topics include coordinate systems , geodesic motions , and penrose diagrams with detailed calculations .
= 16.5 cm -1.85 cm -2 cm = .22 in hep - th/0212326 * classical geometry of de sitter spacetime : + an introductory review * + yoonbai [email protected] ] , chae young [email protected] ] , and namil [email protected] ] + _ @xmath2bk21 physics research division and institute of basic science , sungkyunkwan university , + suwon 440 - 746 , korea + @xmath3school of physics , korea institute for advanced study , + 207 - 43 , cheongryangri - dong , dongdaemun - gu , seoul 130 - 012 , korea _ |
there is currently interest in localizing electrons in quantum dots and utilizing their spin for quantum information processing @xcite . alternatively
, we can view such devices as highly tunable quantum dot molecules , with large numbers of electrons or qubits , with gates and magnetic field used to perform quantum operations .
even with a relatively small number of bits , to understand working of such devices one needs a computational tool suitable for the calculation of wavefunctions of at least tens of electrons confined by complex gate potentials and in magnetic field .
the wavefunctions must capture entanglement , or in condensed matter language , correlations .
the configuration interaction ( ci ) method is a suitable candidate modified here for the problem of quantum dot molecules . in the configuration interaction ( ci ) method the hamiltonian of an interacting system is calculated in the basis of a finite number of many - electron configurations and diagonalized exactly .
exact diagonalization ( ed ) has been an important tool in the context of quantum chemistry of atoms and molecules @xcite . in condensed matter physics ed has been used to investigate the electronic and optical properties of artificial atoms and molecules in quantum dots ( qds ) @xcite and finite size quantum hall systems .
@xcite the direct access to electron correlations in the many - particle wave functions calculated by ci makes ci useful for the purpose of quantitative description of the electron entanglement in the context of solid state quantum information architectures .
the drawback of the method is its slow convergence and applicability to a small number of electrons . while mean - field theories such as hartree - fock ( hf ) @xcite , and density - functional theory ( dft ) @xcite can be applied to large electron numbers , they neglect electron correlations , or entanglement , in the wavefunction . to include electron correlations explicitly in the many - particle wavefunctions one may follow quantum chemistry methods which start with hf or dft calculations of effective single particle orbitals , and use them in the construction of a finite number of many - electron configurations as input in configuration interaction calculations @xcite .
these ideas have been already explored for the calculation of electronic properties of quantum dots with large electron numbers@xcite and quantum dot molecules.@xcite the objective of this work is to present an efficient hf - ci method : ( a ) based on real space calculations of single particle states and hence suitable for complex quantum dot potentials , ( b ) combining complex potentials with strong magnetic field , and ( c ) capable of treating correlations ( entanglement ) in electron wavefunction for large number of electrons .
the urhf - ci method and its performance are illustrated on the example of ten electron confined in a two - dimensional quantum dot molecule .
the paper is organized as follows : in section [ secii ] we present the hamiltonian of electrons confined in the lateral gated quantum dot molecule .
the calculation of the single particle spectrum , including the details of the implementation of the localized gauge , is presented in section [ seciii1 ] . in section [ seciv ] our many electron approach , including the unrestricted hartree - fock approximation , is introduced .
the central results of this study , the calculation of the ground state energy and excitation gap by configuration interaction method using unrestricted hartree - fock urhf - ci basis and non - interacting single particle sp - ci basis , are presented in section [ secv ] .
the paper is summarized in section [ secvi ] .
we consider @xmath0 electrons with effective mass @xmath1 , moving on a plane @xmath2 defined by the gaas / gaalas interface , with complicated confining potential @xmath3 as a function of electron position @xmath4 , created by metallic gates on the surface of the heterostructure .
the magnetic field , defined by vector potential @xmath5 , is perpendicular to the 2d plane .
the effective @xmath0-electron quantum dot molecule hamiltonian in the presence of an external magnetic field can be written as : @xmath6 \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{e^2}{2\epsilon}\sum_{i \neq j}\frac{1}{|\vec{r}_i - \vec{r}_j| } , \label{mph}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath7 is electron charge , @xmath8 is velocity of light , and @xmath9 is the host semiconductor dielectric constant.the zeeman splitting ( very small for gaas ) is neglected here . the first term in eq .
( [ mph ] ) is the sum of single particle hamiltonians and the second term is the coulomb repulsion .
the electron - electron repulsion is screened by the dielectric constant , which for gaas is @xmath10 . in what follows , we present the results in effective atomic units with length unit in effective bohr radii @xmath11 , and energy unit in effective rydberg @xmath12 . using material parameters for gaas with @xmath13 ( @xmath14 is the bare electron mass ) @xmath15 , and @xmath16 .
the single particle schrdinger equation is given by @xmath17 \tilde{\varphi}(\vec{r } ) = \varepsilon \tilde{\varphi}(\vec{r } ) , \label{lse}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath18 is the vector potential seen by electrons , @xmath3 is the confining potential , and @xmath19 is the magnetic field . for a single quantum dot
the potential is often well approximated by an analytical form @xmath20 . for quantum dot molecules the potential will have several minima in which to localize electrons , and the most convenient way to solve
the single particle problem is by discretizing the schrdinger equation . as an example of a complicated molecular quantum dot potential we study a double gaussian potential @xmath21 + v_r~ \exp[{-\frac{(x - a)^2+y^2}{\delta^2 } } ] + v_p \exp[{-\frac{x^2}{\delta_{px}^2}-\frac{y^2}{\delta_{py}^2}}]$ ] , with @xmath22 and @xmath23 measuring the depth of the left and right dot , and @xmath24 controlling the height of the tunneling barrier .
the centers of the two dots are separated by @xmath25 . to describe the typical coupled quantum dots we use the parameters @xmath26 , and @xmath27 , @xmath28 , in effective atomic units . @xmath24 which controls the central potential barrier mimics the plunger gate strength and
is varied between zero and @xmath29 , independent of the locations of the quantum dots .
the choice of gauge @xmath5 plays significant role in improving the numerical accuracy of single particle spectrum .
we use a gauge field which is adopted to the geometry of the confining potential . for a double dot molecule with two minima
, we divide the plane of coupled quantum dots into left and right domains , as shown in fig .
[ comp_box ] . in order to end up with a
well defined left and right quantum dots with increasing barrier height , i.e. with dots with gauge centered in the origin , we define left ( right ) wavefunctions and hamiltonians , and carry out gauge transformation on both hamiltonians and wavefunctions .
the resulting vector potentials localized in centers of each dot are @xmath30 for the left dot ( @xmath31 ) , and @xmath32 for the right dot ( @xmath33 ) .
introducing corresponding wavefunctions in the left ( right ) dot @xmath34 ( @xmath35 ) allows us to write an explicit form of the discrete form of schrdinger equation . in the left - dot
the schrdinger equation can be obtained by expanding @xmath36 around the point @xmath37
@xmath38 \nonumber \\ & & -i\frac{\hbar\omega_c}{4h } \left[(x_i + a ) ( \tilde{\varphi}^l_{i , j+1 } - \tilde{\varphi}^l_{i , j-1 } ) - y_j ( \tilde{\varphi}^l_{i+1,j } - \tilde{\varphi}^l_{i-1,j})\right ] \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{(\hbar\omega_c)^2}{16}\left[(x_i+a)^2+y_j^2\right]\tilde{\varphi}^l_{i , j } + v_{i , j } \tilde{\varphi}^l_{i , j } = \varepsilon \tilde{\varphi}^l_{i , j } \label{dse}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath39 , and @xmath40 , and @xmath41 is the grid spacing .
a similar equation holds for the wavefunction in the right dot . as it is illustrated in fig .
[ comp_box ] , adjacent to the inter - dot boundary , the point @xmath37 in l , is connected to the point @xmath42 in r , via schrdinger equation . in this case @xmath43 in eq.([dse ] ) is already in the right dot and is not known and must be replaced by @xmath44 . one should note that this separation of gauge fields into left and right leads to a uniform magnetic field @xmath45 in both half - planes , but it produces an artifical discontinuity in @xmath19 along @xmath46 . to avoid this unphysical discontinuity , in finite difference method ,
the grids along the @xmath47-axis have been set slightly away from @xmath46 such that @xmath46-line has been excluded from the real space finite difference calculation .
the single particle spectrum @xmath48 and @xmath49 is calculated accurately on a finite mesh of @xmath50 ( @xmath51 mesh points are used in what follows ) using conjugated gradient methods .
the magnetic field dependence of single particle spectrum calculated by this method , is shown in fig .
[ e_sp ] . at zero magnetic field fig .
[ e_sp ] shows the formation of hybridized s , p , and d shells . in high magnetic field
we observe the formation of shells of closely spaced pairs of levels ( with opposite parity ) . in intermediate magnetic field states with opposite parity cross and states with the same parity anticross .
the crossing of many levels at e.g. @xmath52 , marked with dashed line in fig.[e_sp ] , leads to the most computationally challenging many - electron problem . .
the single - particle ( sp ) states calculated in previous section can be used as a basis in configuration - interaction ( ci ) calculation . denoting the creation ( annihilation ) operators for electron in non - interacting sp state @xmath53 by @xmath54
, the hamiltonian of an interacting system in second quantization can be written as @xmath55 where the first term is the single particle hamiltonian , and @xmath56 , is the two - body coulomb matrix element .
alternatively we may use the single particle states to first construct the hartree - fock orbitals . in this
scheme electrons are treated as independent particles moving in a self - consistent hf field .
similar to single particle configuration - interaction ( sp - ci ) method , the hf orbitals can be used as a basis of the interacting hamiltonian in second quantization , and subsequently in the ci calculation . in this method
electron - electron interactions are included in two steps : direct and exchange interaction using hartree - fock approximation , and correlations using hf basis in the configuration interaction method .
hartree - fock approximation is a mean field approach to many body systems which accounts for the direct and exchange coulomb interactions .
combining hfa with more sophisticated many body methods ( such as ci ) allows to isolate the effect introduced by correlations .
the hartree - fock ground state ( gs ) of the electrons with given @xmath57 is a single slater determinant @xmath58 with @xmath59 the permutation operator .
the hf orbitals @xmath60 which describe the state of a dressed quasi - particle in the quantum dot molecule can be determined by minimizing the hf energy @xmath61 with respect to @xmath62 @xmath63 @xmath64 is the non - interacting single particle hamiltonian , and @xmath65 is the coulomb interaction .
this equation is a set of coupled equations , for spin up and spin down states . to find numerical solutions of the hartree - fock equations we expand
the hf orbitals @xmath60 in terms of single particle states @xmath66 : @xmath67 ) , to the self - consistent pople - nesbet equations @xcite : @xmath68 where @xmath69 are coulomb matrix elements calculated using non - interacting single particle states .
this procedure results in @xmath70 hf states .
the @xmath0-lowest energy states form a slater determinant occupied by hf ( quasi ) electrons corresponding to hf ground state .
the rest of orbitals with higher energies are outside of the hf slater determinant ( unoccupied states ) .
the calculated hf eigen - energies for the @xmath71 electrons with @xmath72 as a function of magnetic field are shown in fig .
[ e_hfvsb ] . comparing hf spectrum ( fig .
[ e_hfvsb ] ) with the single particle spectrum ( fig .
[ e_sp ] ) , one observes that a hf gap developed at the fermi level , between the highest occupied molecular state , and the lowest unoccupied molecular state , and the landau level crossing between single particle landau levels has been shifted to lower magnetic fields . .
the hf energy gap between homo ( highest occupied molecular orbital ) , and lumo ( lowest unoccupied molecular orbital ) is clearly visible .
a comparison between sp - ci and urhf - ci calculation will be presented at @xmath52 , and it is shown by the dash line . ]
[ ehfvsn ] illustrates the convergence of hf energy with respect to the number @xmath70 of single particle orbitals used in hf expansion . ) for 10 electrons . ] in the following we study the effect of correlations by including quasielectron - quasihole excitations in the hf wave functions using ci method .
for @xmath73 corresponding to @xmath74 is plotted vs. @xmath75 . here
@xmath76 is an integer number .
@xmath77 is the slater determinant of the configuration @xmath75th , formed by hf basis . @xmath78
( the hf ground state ) if @xmath79 .
the urhf density of states ( @xmath80 ) is shown in inset .
its peak is below the hf energy mean value . ]
corresponding to the @xmath75th diagonal matrix elements in @xmath81 ( see eq.[ir7 ] ) , are shown for various configurations . due to the finite band width @xmath82 of the hf spectrum , they approximately follow a universal functional form . ] .
the pre - calculated direct and exchange energies in urhf - ci improves the ground state energy and the convergence rate . up to @xmath83 the sp - ci and urhf - ci hamiltonian have been diagonalized exactly . above @xmath83
the variational ground state energies are calculated by diagonalizing @xmath84 with @xmath85 . ]
the spin singlet state is the ground state .
, title="fig : " ] the spin singlet state is the ground state . , title="fig : " ] calculated in sp - ci and urhf - ci is shown .
up to @xmath83 the sp - ci and urhf - ci hamiltonian have been diagonalized exactly . above @xmath83
a variational calculation has been used by diagonalizing @xmath84 with @xmath85 . ] in the configuration interaction method the hamiltonian of an interacting system is calculated in the basis of finite number of many - electron configurations . the total number of configurations ( or slater determinants participating in ci calculation )
is determined by @xmath86 [ n_s!/n_\downarrow!(n_s - n_\downarrow)!]$ ] . here
@xmath87 and @xmath88 are the number of spin up and spin down electrons .
this hamiltonian is either diagonalized exactly for small systems or low energy eigenvalues and eigenstates are extracted approximately for very large number of configurations . in urhf - ci ( sp - ci ) , @xmath89 urhf ( single particle ) orbitals are used for constructing the slater determinants . by removing electrons from the occupied urhf state obtained by minimizing the total hartree - fock energy and putting them onto an unoccupied urhf state
, one can construct a number of configurations corresponding to electron - hole excitations .
these excitations contribute to the many body wave functions as correlations . denoting the creation ( annihilation ) operators for urhf quasi - particles by @xmath90 ( @xmath91 ) with the index @xmath92 representing the combined spin - orbit quantum numbers , the many body hamiltonian of the interacting system in the urhf basis can be written as : @xmath93 where @xmath94 are the coulomb matrix elements in the urhf basis .
our method of computing coulomb matrix elements is presented in the appendix . here
@xmath95 where @xmath96 are the urhf eigenenegies , and @xmath97 and @xmath98 are the hartree and exchange operators .
the hamiltonian matrix is constructed in the basis of configurations with definite @xmath99 , and diagonalized using conjugated gradient methods . as the size of urhf basis goes to infinity ,
the method becomes exact . in practice
, one may , however , be able to obtain accurate results using finite number of basis in ci calculation . to introduce a systematic method for constructing the hamiltonian
, we select a class of configurations which have the highest contribution to the ground state wavefunction . because the main contribution to the ground state energy of many electron system comes from the slater determinants formed by the lowest energy hf orbitals
, we accept slater determinants whose hf energies are below an energy cut - off @xmath100 .
the number of such slater determinants is finite , and is given by @xmath75 .
the many body hamiltonian matrix constructed in this way is the following : @xmath101 here @xmath102 are the hf matrix elements with @xmath103 , and @xmath104 ( the coulomb interactions in the diagonal elements account for the direct and exchange interactions ) . to test this method
numerically we set the cyclotron energy to @xmath52 , which corresponds to the crossing and mixing of many orbitals , as shown in fig .
[ dos8 ] shows the evolution of urhf electron - hole excitation spectrum as a function of cut - off @xmath75 .
the energy bandwidth @xmath105 is finite . as it is illustrated in the inset of fig .
[ dos8 ] , the peak of urhf density of states ( dos ) is in the middle of the band . as it is shown in fig .
[ scaling ] , the diagonal elements of the hamiltonian @xmath81 ( urhf eigen - energies ) can be represented approximately by @xmath106 where @xmath107 is a universal function . by increasing @xmath108 ,
the total number of urhf eigen - states @xmath75 ( corresponding to given @xmath100 ) increases . in this case , it is possible to find a lower energy variational wave function if the energy cutoff of @xmath84 is set to a given @xmath100 .
we now turn to investigate the convergence rate of the calculated ground state energy as a function of cutoff @xmath108 and @xmath75 . in fig .
[ e_conv_just_ci15 ] the energies , measured from the hf energy , of the ground and the first excited state for @xmath71 electrons obtained using urhf basis with @xmath83 and with @xmath109 orbitals .
we note that for @xmath71 and @xmath83 the number of configurations @xmath110 while for @xmath109 and @xmath71 , @xmath111 .
hence for @xmath83 the hamiltonian can be diagonalized exactly and the ground and excited states are known up to @xmath112 .
this is not the case for @xmath109 where we were able to extract the ground and excited states up to @xmath113 , and exact energies are not known .
however , in both cases the energies fall off rapidly and very quickly saturate as a function of @xmath114 .
hence it appears sufficient to use only a fraction of low energy configurations to construct the effective hamiltonian @xmath84 in order to achieve satisfactory convergence .
given the convergence criteria established above , we now discuss the advantages of urhf - ci versus much easier to use sp - ci , a central result of this work .
[ e1vsnumbconfig ] shows the dependence of urhf - ci and sp - ci ground state energy on the number of single particle orbitals @xmath89 for @xmath71 electron droplet at magnetic field corresponding to @xmath52 .
up to @xmath83 the sp - ci and urhf - ci hamiltonian have been diagonalized exactly . above @xmath83
the variational ground state energies are calculated by diagonalizing @xmath84 with @xmath85 .
the lowest number of single particle orbitals populated by @xmath71 electrons with @xmath72 is @xmath115 . for @xmath115 in sp - ci electrons
populate the lowest five single particle orbitals while in urhf electrons populate the hf orbitals , which minimize not only single particle energy but also direct and exchange energy .
hence the starting energy of initial single configuration in urhf - ci has significantly lower energy compared to sp - ci . as the number of available states @xmath89 , and hence the number of electron - hole excitations ( configurations ) increases , the ground state energy obtained in urhf - ci decreases very slowly .
it starts with hartree - fock value of @xmath116 for @xmath115 and ends up with @xmath117 for @xmath109 .
this gives our best estimate of total correlation energy of @xmath118 .
we find the correlation energy to be only two percent of coulomb energy .
by contrast with urhf - ci the sp - ci calculations using the single particle basis converge very slowly .
the slow convergence can be understood in terms of large direct and exchange energy contribution which the sp - ci attempts to compute very inefficiently .
hence clear advantage in using urhf - ci versus sp - ci method .
we now turn to the analysis of the excitation gaps .
we focus on the energy gap between the spin singlet @xmath119 ground state and the spin triplet @xmath120 excited state , the exchange energy @xmath121 . in figs .
[ j_conv_just_ci15 ] the convergence of calculated exchange energy @xmath121 as a function of the number of configurations @xmath114 is shown for increasing size @xmath89 of single particle basis .
we see that increasing the size @xmath75 of the effective hamiltonian initially leads to rapid oscillations in @xmath121 followed by a smooth dependence .
these calculations allow us to adjust @xmath122 to extract numerically stable exchange energy @xmath121 for each size of the single particle basis @xmath89 .
this allows us to compare the dependence of calculated exchange energy using the urhf - ci and sp - ci methods .
[ j.vs.numbconfig ] shows clearly fluctuations of @xmath121 , calculated using sp - ci method , with increasing number of configurations .
these fluctuations can be traced back to many level crossings in single particle orbitals .
we are unable to extract reliable value of @xmath121 using the commonly used sp - ci .
by contrast , exchange energy @xmath121 calculated using urhf - ci shows a smooth and convergent behavior as a function of @xmath89 .
for two electrons ( top ) and 4 electrons ( bottom ) at @xmath52 . for two electrons , although , the ground state energy calculated from urhf is lower than single configuration sp - ci ( top - left ) , but as the number of configurations increases , sp - ci method gives lower energy ground state ( top - right ) . for four electrons ,
the urhf - ci ground state energy is lower than the one calculated by sp - ci for small number of configurations .
as the number of configurations increases , the ground state energy calculated by sp - ci becomes the lowest . ]
in contrast to two and four electron numbers , urhf - ci ground state energy is lower than sp - ci ground state energy for all configurations . ] as we discussed in last subsection , computing the spectrum of the ci hamiltonian requires diagonalization of large matrices .
the size of ci hamiltonian matrices can be optimized significantly by a judicious choice of basis . in preceding subsection , we introduced urhf states as a suitable basis for ci method . in this subsection , we present a systematic comparison between the ground state energy calculated by urhf - ci and sp - ci methods to remark that urhf - ci is a superior method to deal with a system with large number of electrons .
we examine this in quantum dot molecules and in single dot parabolic confining potentials . in quantum dot molecules ,
we calculate the ground state energy of a system consisting of two to ten electrons .
to compare urhf - ci and sp - ci , one must study the behavior of the spectrum as a function of @xmath89 , and @xmath123 . with increasing number of configurations ,
this comparison is carried out up to the point that @xmath124 , where all possible hf configurations are being exhausted . in the limit of @xmath124
, there exists a unitary transformation which maps urhf - ci hamiltonian to sp - ci hamiltonian , and thus the spectrum of sp - ci and urhf - ci become identical . because the number of configurations grows rapidly by increasing @xmath89 , and because we would like to reach the limit of @xmath124
, we construct urhf states out of small number of single particle levels . for the purpose of this comparison and without any loss of generality we present the results of our calculation using @xmath125 in figs .
[ civscihf]-[civscihf2 ] . in the case of two electrons ,
urhf energy is lower than the energy of sp - ci with single slater determinant , @xmath126 , ( see the top - left of fig .
[ civscihf ] ) . by increasing the number of configurations we observe that sp - ci quickly lowers the ground state energy until @xmath127 where urhf - ci and sp - ci become equivalent . in the case of four electrons ,
the ground state energy of urhf - ci is lower for small number of configurations .
similar to the two electron system , with increasing number of configurations ( beyond @xmath115 ) sp - ci provides lower ground state energy .
however , with increasing number of electrons from six up to ten , we find that urhf - ci method gives lower ground state energy within the whole range of @xmath89 , as shown in fig .
[ civscihf2 ] .
a similar comparison can be made for electrons in a single dot with parabolic confining potential .
the energy difference calculated by sp - ci and urhf - ci , presented in fig .
[ civscihf_sd ] , reveals that for electron numbers between two and five , the ground state energy of sp - ci is lower than the ground state energy of urhf - ci .
as expected , this order is reversed with increasing number of electrons ( @xmath128 ) .
we therefore find urhf - ci method to work very well for quantum dot systems with large number of electrons .
, @xmath129 for a single dot parabolic potential ( @xmath130 ) with electron numbers between @xmath131 , and 7 . the calculated ground state energy of urhf - ci ( sp - ci ) is lower for a system with large ( small ) number of particles . ]
we have developed real space unrestricted hybrid hartree fock ( hf ) and configuration interaction ( ci ) method ( urhf - ci ) suitable for the calculation of ground and excited states of large number of electrons localized by complex gate potentials in quasi - two - dimensional quantum dot molecules .
the effects of magnetic field and correlations are included in energies and directly in the many - particle wavefunctions making the method an attractive candidate for potential quantum information related applications .
the advantages of urhf - ci method over the commonly used ci method based on single particle orbitals sp - ci are demonstrated .
r.a . and p.h .
acknowledge the support by the nrc high performance computing project and by the canadian institute for advanced research .
in this appendix , we describe an efficient approach to calculate coulomb matrix elements numerically . in the hartree - fock and configuration interaction method ,
the properties of the system are given by the single particle spectrum and by the coulomb matrix elements defined as two - electron integrals ( see eq . [ [ multiparticle ] ] ) .
for the calculation involving 60 hf orbitals the total number of multi - dimensional integrals exceeds @xmath132 .
here we describe an efficient algorithm used in our calculation . in the numerical calculation of urhf - ci ,
the integrals of the coulomb matrix elements are replaced by summation over the grids @xmath133 ( where @xmath134 are integers , and @xmath135 are grid spacing ) @xmath136 we further transform multi - dimensional wave function @xmath137 into a column vector @xmath138 by mapping the multi - dimensional vector @xmath139 onto a one - dimensional index @xmath140 where @xmath141
. then the multi - dimensional integral can be converted into a vector - matrix multiplication @xmath142 where @xmath143 is a vector containing all the possible pairs of single - particle wave functions , and @xmath144 is the matrix with elements @xmath145 times @xmath146 .
the sums in form of do - loops can be further parallelized . due to the large dimension of matrix @xmath144
, one can make use of domain decomposition to divide it into a number of smaller matrices and sum up the result of all the individual multiplications . c. yannouleas and u. landman , phys .
rev . lett . * 82 * , 5325 ( 1999 ) , constantine yannouleas and uzi landman , , 035325 ( 2003 ) , c. yannouleas and u. landman , j. phys . : condens .
matter 14 , l591 ( 2002 ) , c. yannouleas and u. landman , int .
j. quantum chem .
90 , 699 ( 2002 ) . | we present unrestricted hartree fock method coupled with configuration interaction ( ci ) method ( urhf - ci ) suitable for the calculation of ground and excited states of large number of electrons localized by complex gate potentials in quasi - two - dimensional quantum dot molecules .
the method employs real space finite difference method , incorporating strong magnetic field , for the calculating of single particle states .
the hartree - fock method is employed for the calculation of direct and exchange interaction contribution to the ground state energy .
the effects of correlations are included in energies and directly in the many - particle wavefunctions via configuration interaction ( ci ) method using a limited set of excitations above the fermi level .
the urhf - ci method and its performance are illustrated on the example of ten electrons confined in a two - dimensional quantum dot molecule . |
with the discovery of the microwave background radiation ( mbr ) @xcite , it was realized that its effect on the propagation of ultrahigh energy cosmic rays ( uhecr s ) must be considered . the first treatments in 1966 by greisen , zatsepin and kuzmin @xcite indicated a sharp cutoff for cosmic rays with energies above due to the process @xmath1 .
physically , the thermal photons are seen highly blue - shifted by the cosmic rays in their rest frames so that this reaction becomes possible .
recently , several extensive air showers have been clearly observed which imply the arrival of cosmic rays of energies above @xmath2 ev . in particular , the akeno giant air shower array ( agasa ) experiment recorded an event with energy 1.7 - 2.6 @xmath3 ev @xcite , while the fly s eye experiment reported the highest energy cosmic ray ( cr ) event ever detected on earth , with an energy 2.3 - 4.1 @xmath3 ev @xcite .
since the gzk cutoff provides an important constraint on the proximity of uhecr sources , the origin of such energetic particles has became one of the most pressing questions of cosmic ray astrophysics .
the study of the modification of the spectrum of cosmic rays due to their interactions with the mbr _ en route _ to us here on earth , is essential if one is to obtain a deeper understanding of the origin of the highest energy cosmic rays .
various treatments of the propagation of nucleons in the intergalactic medium exist , including purely analytical ones @xcite , as well as purely numerical ones @xcite . in this paper
, we re - analyze the effects of meson photoproduction , the dominant energy loss mechanism , using the continuous energy loss approximation which is expected to be reasonable for the problem at hand .
this allows us to discuss , in a general way , the modification of the spectrum of cr s from nearby sources due to interactions with the cosmic background radiation .
the propagation of cosmic rays through the intergalactic medium is described by a kinetic transport equation which takes into account three mechanisms for energy losses : redshift , pair production , and pion photoproduction . nevertheless , for nearby sources corresponding to propagation times @xmath4 years , or distances of less than 100 mpc , redshift effects can be neglected . if one assumes that the highest energy cosmic rays are indeed nucleons , the fractional energy loss due to interactions with the cosmic background radiation at temperature @xmath5 and redshift @xmath6 , is determined by the integral of the nucleon loss energy per collision times the probability per unit time for a nucleon collision moving through an isotropic gas of photons @xcite .
this integral can be explicitly written as follows , @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the photon energy in the rest frame of the nucleon , and @xmath9 is the average fraction of the energy lost by the photon to the nucleon in the laboratory frame ( i.e. the frame in which the microwave background radiation is at @xmath10 k ) .
n(w)dw stands for the number density of photons with energy between w and dw , following a planckian distribution at temperature @xmath5 @xcite , @xmath11 is the total cross section of interaction , @xmath12 is the usual lorentz factor of the nucleon , and @xmath13 is the maximum energy of the photon in the photon gas . thus , the fractional energy loss is given by @xmath14 where @xmath15 and @xmath16 are boltzmann s and planck s constants respectively , and @xmath17 is the threshold energy for the reaction in the rest frame of the nucleon .
the characteristic time for the energy loss due to pair production at @xmath18 ev is @xmath19 yr @xcite and therefore it does not affect the spectrum of nucleons arriving from nearby sources . consequently , for nucleons with @xmath20ev ( taking into account the interaction with the tail of the planck distribution ) ,
meson photoproduction is the dominant mechanism for energy loss .
notice that we do not distinguish between neutrons and protons ; in addition , the inelasticity due to the neutron @xmath21 decay is negligible . in order to determine the effect of meson photoproduction on the spectrum of cosmic rays , we first examine the kinematics of photon - nucleon interactions . assuming that reactions mediated by baryon resonances have spherically symmetric decay angular distributions @xcite , the average energy loss of the nucleon after n resonant collisions is given by @xmath22 where @xmath23 denotes the mass of the resonant system of the chain , @xmath24 the mass of the associated meson
, @xmath25 is the total energy of the reaction in the centre of mass , and @xmath26 the mass of the nucleon .
it is well established from experiments @xcite that , at very high energies ( @xmath27 above @xmath28 gev ) , the incident nucleons lose one - half their energy via pion photoproduction independent of the number of pions produced . in the region dominated by baryon resonances ,
the cross section is described by a sum of breit - wigner distributions constructed from the experimental data in the table of particle properties @xcite considering the main resonances produced in @xmath29 collisions with @xmath30 final states . for the cross section at high energies we used the fits to the high - energy cross section @xmath31 made by the cern , desy hera , and compas groups @xcite . in this energy range ,
the @xmath32 is to a good approximation identical to @xmath31 . the numerical integration of eq .
( [ ! ] ) is performed taking into account the aforementioned resonance decays and the production of multipion final states at higher centre of mass energies ( @xmath33 gev )
. a @xmath34 fit of the numerical results of equation ( [ ! ] ) with an exponential behaviour , @xmath35 , proposed by berezinsky and grigoreva @xcite for the region of resonances , gives : @xmath36 , @xmath37 ev with a @xmath38 . at high energies
the fractional energy loss was fitted with a constant , @xmath39 .
these results differ from those obtained in @xcite , due to a refined expression for the total cross section . from the values determined for the fractional energy loss it is straightforward to compute the energy degradation of uhecr s in terms of their flight distance .
the results shown in fig . 1 , are consistent with those previously obtained by cronin @xcite , in which just single pion production is considered .
our results therefore support the assumption that the energy loss is dominated by single pion photoproduction .
let us now turn to the modification that the mbr produces in the uhecr spectrum .
the evolution of the spectrum is governed by the balance equation @xmath40 that takes into account the conservation of the total number of nucleons in the spectrum . in the first term on the right , b(e )
is the mean rate at which particles lose energy . the second term , the diffusion in the mbr , is found to be extremely small due to the low density of relic photons and the fact that the average cosmic magnetic field is less than @xmath41 g @xcite and is neglected in the following .
the third term corresponds to the particle injection rate into the intergalactic medium from some hypothetical source .
since the origin of cosmic rays is still unknown , we consider three possible models : 1 ) the universal hypothesis , which assumes that cosmic rays come from no well - defined source , but rather are produced uniformly throughout space , 2 ) single point sources of cosmic rays , and 3 ) sources of finite size approximating clusters of galaxies . in all the cases
it has been assumed that nucleons propagate in a straight line through the intergalactic medium due to the reasons mentioned above that allow us to neglect the diffusion term .
there exists evidence that the source spectrum of cosmic rays has a power - law dependence @xmath42 ( see for instance @xcite ) . with the hypothesis that cosmic rays are produced from sources located uniformly in space , with this power law energy dependence ( which implies a steady state process ) , the solution of eq .
( [ @ ] ) is found to be @xmath43 for the case of a single point source , the solution of equation ( [ @ ] ) reads @xcite , @xmath44 with @xmath45 and @xmath46 the energy of the nucleon when emitted by the source .
the injection spectrum of a single source located at @xmath47 from the observer can be written as @xmath48 and for simplicity , we consider the distance as measured from the source , that means @xmath49 . at very high energies ,
i.e. where @xmath50 ( where @xmath51 is the constant defined above in the discussion of fractional energy loss ) the total number of particles at a given distance from the source is given by @xmath52 or equivalently @xmath53 this means that the spectrum is uniformly damped by a factor depending on the proximity of the source . at low energies , in the region dominated by baryon resonances
, the parametrization of @xmath54 does not allow a complete analytical solution .
however using the change of variables @xmath55 with @xmath56 and @xmath57 , we easily obtain , @xmath58 \,\,d{\tilde t}\ ] ] and then , the compact form , @xmath59 in our case , where we have assumed an exponential behaviour of the fractional loss energy , @xmath46 is fixed by the constraint : @xmath60 , ei being the exponential integral @xcite , and @xmath61 the constant defined above in the parametrization of berezinsky and grigoreva .
studies are underway of the case of a nearby source ( i.e. within about 100 mpc ) for which the fractional energy loss @xmath62 is small . writing @xmath63 , and neglecting higher orders in @xmath64 , it is possible to obtain an analytical solution and the most relevant characteristics of the modified spectrum .
therefore , an expansion of @xmath65 in powers of @xmath64 in eq .
( [ espectro ] ) allows one to obtain , an expression for @xmath64 , @xmath66 - 1 \right\ } \frac{e^2}{(e + b ) } \label{l1}\ ] ] to describe the modification of the spectrum , it is convenient to introduce the factor @xmath67 , the ratio between the modified spectrum and the unmodified one , that results in @xmath68 equations ( [ l1 ] ) and ( [ l2 ] ) describe the spectral modification factor up to energies of @xmath69 eev ( @xmath70 eev ) with a precision of 4% ( 9% ) for a source situated at 50 mpc ( 100 mpc ) . in fig .
2 we plot the modification factors for the case of nearby sources with power law injection ( @xmath71 ) to compare with the corresponding results of ref .
the most significant features of @xmath67 are the bump and the cutoff .
it has been noted in the literature that the continuous energy loss approximation tends to overestimate the size of the bump @xcite .
figure 2 shows how the bump is less pronounced in our treatment .
as the bump is a consequence of the sharp ( exponential ) dependence of the free path of the nucleon on energy , we attribute these differences to the replacement of a cross section approximated by the values at threshold energy @xcite , by a more detailed expression taking into account the main baryon resonances that turn out to be important . another alternative for the particle injection is clusters of galaxies .
these are usually modelled by a set of point sources with spatially uniform distribution , although in reality the distribution of galaxies inside the clusters is somewhat non - uniform . in our treatment
we shall assume that the concentration of potential sources at the center of the cluster is higher than that near the periphery , and we adopt a spatial gaussian distribution . with this hypothesis ,
the particle injection rate into the intergalactic medium is given by @xmath72 a delta function expansion around @xmath47 , with derivatives denoted by lower case roman superscripts , @xmath73 leads to a convenient form for the injection spectrum , which is given by , @xmath74\ ] ] from eqs .
( [ spectrum ] ) and ( [ espectro ] ) , it is straightforward to compute an expression for the modification factor , @xmath75 where @xmath76 and @xmath77 the modification factor for the case of extended sources described by gaussian distributions of widths 2 and 6 mpc at a distance of 18.3 mpc is shown in fig .
3 . these may be taken as very crude models of the virgo cluster @xcite , assuming that there is no other significant energy loss mechanism for cosmic rays traversing parts of the cluster beyond those due to interactions with the cosmic background radiation . a power law injection ( @xmath71 )
was used again , as in the pointlike case .
the curves can be understood qualitatively .
both peaks are in about the same place , occurring around the onset of pion photoproduction . the narrower curve , corresponding to the broader source distribution , reflects the losses suffered by the more remote part of the distribution in traversing a greater distance to us .
we note that the modification factors for nearby extended sources can appear similar to those for more distant narrower sources .
we have presented a recalculation of the effects of the cosmic background radiation on the propagation of cosmic rays using the continuous energy loss approximation first used by berezinsky @xcite and our best knowledge of @xmath78-nucleon cross sections .
this approximation is important as it is the only way to allow semi - analytical treatments in a wide range of situations . while earlier calculations within this approximation suffered from problems described in the main text , these do not appear with our improved treatment of cross sections , and the results are in reasonable agreement with previous calculations using monte carlo methods without the continuous energy loss approximation .
the eventual observation of the gzk cutoff is of fundamental interest in cosmic ray physics , providing constraints on the distance to sources of ultrahigh enery cosmic rays . the future pierre auger project @xcite should provide a decisive test of the ideas discussed in this paper .
we are grateful to huner fanchiotti and carlos garca canal for illuminating discussions , and to james cronin for stimulating our initial interest in this subject .
we would also like to thank carlos feinstein for helpful information on the morphology of the virgo cluster .
this work was partially supported by conicet , argentina . l.a.a .
thanks fomec for financial support . 99 a. a. penzias and r. w. wilson , _ ap .
j _ * 142 * , 419 ( 1965 ) .
k. greisen , _ phys .
* 16 * , 748 ( 1966 ) .
g. t. zatsepin and v. a. kuzmin , _
pisma zh . eksp .
fiz . _ * 4 * , 114 ( 1966 ) . s. yoshida _
et al_. , _ astropart .
phys . _ * 3 * , 105 ( 1995 ) .
n. hashashida _
et al_. , _ phys .
lett . _ * 73 * , 3491 ( 1994 ) .
d. j. bird _
et al_. , _ phys .
lett . _ * 71 * , 3401 ( 1993 ) .
d. j. bird _
et al_. , _ ap . j. _ * 441 * , 144 ( 1995 ) .
v. s. berenzinsky and g. t. zatsepin , _ yad . fiz . _
* 13 * , 797 ( 1971 ) .
f. w. stecker , _ phys .
* 21 * , 1016 ( 1968 ) .
v. s. berezinsky and s. i. grigoreva , _ astron .
_ * 199 * , 1 ( 1988 ) .
f. w. stecker , _ nature _ * 342 * , 401 ( 1989 ) . f. a. aharonian , b. l. kanevsky and v. v. vardanian , _ astrophys .
space sci . _ * 167 * , 93 ( 1990 ) .
j. p. rachen and p. l. biermann , _ astron .
astrophys . _
* 272 * , 161 ( 1993 ) . c. t. hill and d. n. schramm , _ phys .
rev . _ * d31 * , 564 ( 1985 ) .
s. yoshida and m. teshima , _ prog .
phys . _ * 89 * , 833 ( 1993 ) .
f. a. aharonian and j. w. cronin , _ phys .
rev . _ * d50 * , 1892 ( 1994 ) .
s. lee , report no .
fermilab - pub-96/066-a ( unpublished ) .
v. s. berenzinsky , _ yad . fiz . _ * 11 * , 399 ( 1970 ) .
concerning the density of photons , data from the far - infrared absolute spectrometer ( firas ) of the cosmic background explorer ( cobe ) shows that the spectrum of mbr is that of a blackbody of temperature @xmath79 k , with no deviation from a planckian spectrum greater than 0.25 % of the peak brightness and a limit on the compton @xmath80-parameter of @xmath81 ( 95 % cl ) .
see , r. a. shafer _
et al_. , _ bull .
. soc _ * 36 * , 1398 ( 1991 ) ; h. p. gush , m. halpern and e. h. wishnow , _ phys .
_ * 65 * , 537 ( 1990 ) .
g. blumenthal , _ phys .
d * 1 * , 1596 ( 1970 ) . i. golyak , _ mod .
_ * a7 * , 2401 ( 1992 ) , and references therein .
particle data group , l. montanet _
et al_. , _ phys .
rev . _ * d50 * , 1173 , 1335 ( 1994 ) . j. w. cronin , _ in cosmic rays above 10@xmath82 ev _ , proceedings of the international workshop , paris , france , 1992 , edited by j. cronin , a. a. watson , and m. boratav [ nucl .
b ( proc . suppl . )
* 28b * , 213 ( 1993 ) ] .
see also reference @xcite .
p. p. kronberg , _ rep .
_ * 57 * , 325 ( 1994 ) m. abramowitz and i. a. stegun , `` handbook of mathematical functions '' ( dover , new york , 1970 ) .
b. binggeli , g. a. tammann and a. sandage , _ astron .
j. _ * 94 * , 251 ( 1987 ) .
the auger collaboration , pierre auger project design report , 1995 , fermi national accelerator laboratory ( unpublished ) .
energy attenuation length of nucleons in the intergalactic medium .
notice that , independently of the initial energy of the nucleon , the mean energy values approach to 100 eev after a distance of @xmath83 mpc .
modification factor of extended - source energy spectrum for a propagation distance @xmath84 18.3 mpc and power law index @xmath71 .
solid line stands for a gaussian distribution of width @xmath85 mpc , while dashed line a width of @xmath86 mpc . | in this work we re - examine the opacity of the cosmic background radiation to the propagation of extremely high energy cosmic rays .
we use the continuous energy loss approximation to provide spectral modification factors for several hypothesized cosmic ray sources .
earlier problems with this approximation are resolved including the effects of resonances other than the @xmath0 .
pacs numbers : 96.40,13.85.t,98.70.s,98.70.v _ accepted for publication in physical review d. _ |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.