id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13348v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13348v1 | Textual Unlearning Gives a False Sense of Unlearning | 2024-06-19T08:51:54 | 2024-06-19T08:51:54 | Jiacheng Du, Zhibo Wang, Kui Ren | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Language models (LMs) are susceptible to "memorizing" training data,
including a large amount of private or copyright-protected content. To
safeguard the right to be forgotten (RTBF), machine unlearning has emerged as a
promising method for LMs to efficiently "forget" sensitive training content and
mitigate knowledge leakage risks. However, despite its good intentions, could
the unlearning mechanism be counterproductive? In this paper, we propose the
Textual Unlearning Leakage Attack (TULA), where an adversary can infer
information about the unlearned data only by accessing the models before and
after unlearning. Furthermore, we present variants of TULA in both black-box
and white-box scenarios. Through various experimental results, we critically
demonstrate that machine unlearning amplifies the risk of knowledge leakage
from LMs. Specifically, TULA can increase an adversary's ability to infer
membership information about the unlearned data by more than 20% in black-box
scenario. Moreover, TULA can even reconstruct the unlearned data directly with
more than 60% accuracy with white-box access. Our work is the first to reveal
that machine unlearning in LMs can inversely create greater knowledge risks and
inspire the development of more secure unlearning mechanisms. | [
0.13087870180606842,
-0.8585813641548157,
0.19919736683368683,
-0.45317965745925903,
-0.31216922402381897,
0.36535775661468506,
0.0830305963754654,
-0.1873612254858017,
-0.5214149951934814,
0.878145158290863,
-0.49526968598365784,
-0.1740531176328659,
-0.6426811218261719,
-0.5104647278785706,
-0.6891734004020691,
1.0787715911865234,
0.21864449977874756,
-0.07620819658041,
-0.23764120042324066,
-0.23848600685596466,
-0.6812163591384888,
-0.6482120156288147,
-0.3953739404678345,
-0.492800235748291,
0.2503722310066223,
0.3236254155635834,
0.5799799561500549,
0.347545325756073,
0.01782224327325821,
0.3209206461906433,
-0.03141596168279648,
0.1381295919418335,
-0.7052218914031982,
0.3336241543292999,
-0.3478392958641052,
-0.8186889886856079,
0.047816284000873566,
-0.13172030448913574,
0.5613939762115479,
0.526461124420166,
-0.2565354108810425,
0.18717600405216217,
0.3594166934490204,
1.3539793491363525,
-0.8575078845024109,
-0.1422673612833023,
-1.2170765399932861,
0.15623366832733154,
-0.32636791467666626,
-0.2981852889060974,
-0.9554101228713989,
0.1153203696012497,
-0.04233790561556816,
-0.4373091757297516,
0.18850697576999664,
-0.12331293523311615,
0.878234326839447,
0.5128194093704224,
-0.19604776799678802,
-0.27424153685569763,
-0.7443749904632568,
0.7657595276832581,
-0.475570946931839,
0.35796058177948,
0.6627516150474548,
0.30200377106666565,
-0.271897554397583,
-0.6703060269355774,
-0.4855395257472992,
0.19714926183223724,
-0.09928029775619507,
0.04936544969677925,
-0.5900634527206421,
-0.30274641513824463,
0.26973557472229004,
0.04324084892868996,
-0.45438525080680847,
0.10529811680316925,
-0.6869223117828369,
-0.17023684084415436,
0.46441084146499634,
-0.18440201878547668,
0.4955429434776306,
-0.11240193992853165,
-0.6363599300384521,
-0.06774695217609406,
-1.0705668926239014,
0.1206948310136795,
0.42044317722320557,
0.19697168469429016,
-0.17948204278945923,
0.6455574631690979,
0.36601510643959045,
0.4503510594367981,
-0.30836600065231323,
0.134494349360466,
0.2015533447265625,
0.08863180875778198,
-0.4780033826828003,
0.16303983330726624,
0.889919102191925,
0.02398652955889702,
0.49016493558883667,
-0.5612379312515259,
-0.1047431230545044,
-0.012382136657834053,
0.5436947345733643,
-0.5328935384750366,
0.041905127465724945,
0.23048736155033112,
-0.2739809453487396,
-0.4332299530506134,
0.3880874514579773,
-0.9734542369842529,
-0.5989980101585388,
0.018650678917765617,
0.6289675235748291,
-0.6730563640594482,
-0.17051947116851807,
-0.06133095175027847,
-0.16814768314361572,
-0.28509604930877686,
-0.15676838159561157,
-0.5095221400260925,
0.06102997437119484,
0.6446924209594727,
0.5719960927963257,
0.13707222044467926,
-0.35186338424682617,
-0.7051886320114136,
0.3526234030723572,
-0.2398744821548462,
0.4241320490837097,
-0.4063448905944824,
-0.6848338842391968,
0.12898153066635132,
0.13415488600730896,
-0.16196481883525848,
-0.40801993012428284,
0.10017373412847519,
-0.7572399973869324,
0.5169318914413452,
0.1121295616030693,
-0.7329328656196594,
-0.2854140102863312,
-0.19644752144813538,
-0.6607092618942261,
0.9285973310470581,
-0.11765598505735397,
-0.8621299266815186,
0.09392715245485306,
-0.47082796692848206,
-0.29091155529022217,
-0.17388685047626495,
-0.05802096053957939,
-0.7971416115760803,
0.019068151712417603,
-0.08724810928106308,
0.38739919662475586,
0.06661383807659149,
0.4314805865287781,
-0.2802056074142456,
-0.3446158766746521,
0.7832707762718201,
-0.7118729948997498,
1.1327967643737793,
0.40521153807640076,
-0.5056552886962891,
-0.35378846526145935,
-0.7334726452827454,
0.005091462749987841,
0.2754596769809723,
-0.056259993463754654,
-0.7167202830314636,
-0.08940751850605011,
-0.6030057668685913,
0.059636011719703674,
0.11939315497875214,
-0.4305782914161682,
0.03801703825592995,
-0.44059526920318604,
0.4308769702911377,
0.7281452417373657,
0.2333250790834427,
0.6338720321655273,
-0.5352914929389954,
0.3932405412197113,
0.07640470564365387,
-0.15852132439613342,
-0.3635346591472626,
-0.3212377429008484,
-0.5800885558128357,
-0.002303542336449027,
0.35512775182724,
0.6052877902984619,
-0.6905100345611572,
0.10291717201471329,
0.24412335455417633,
-0.6846952438354492,
-0.868161678314209,
0.26447197794914246,
0.8931586742401123,
0.5448951125144958,
0.3845415413379669,
0.06634046137332916,
-0.4871618449687958,
-0.4317871034145355,
-0.6316500306129456,
-0.21529065072536469,
-0.019184179604053497,
-0.09358230233192444,
0.4711221754550934,
-0.36687299609184265,
0.7277861833572388,
-0.3601320683956146,
-0.5309615731239319,
-0.1043909341096878,
0.2181236445903778,
-0.222014918923378,
0.4816518723964691,
0.2950507700443268,
-0.6286866068840027,
-0.11544358730316162,
-0.050250399857759476,
-1.006126880645752,
0.0853123888373375,
-0.22079941630363464,
-0.10950187593698502,
0.6267342567443848,
0.6353886127471924,
-0.5104986429214478,
0.7238344550132751,
0.5118963122367859,
-0.39677271246910095,
0.22642862796783447,
-0.5409350991249084,
-0.3093341886997223,
-1.100040316581726,
0.1564907282590866,
-0.6423786282539368,
-0.07253837585449219,
-0.7673566937446594,
0.0023077032528817654,
0.23683491349220276,
-0.16138294339179993,
-0.6226931810379028,
0.5800053477287292,
-0.5447614789009094,
0.04176647588610649,
-0.32701539993286133,
0.1106925904750824,
0.1887027472257614,
0.5369459390640259,
-0.21304257214069366,
0.6786494255065918,
0.386534184217453,
-0.6408460140228271,
-0.3134457767009735,
0.22070807218551636,
-0.2671166956424713,
0.1696554720401764,
-0.4394878149032593,
0.5554466843605042,
-0.4622928500175476,
-0.07884933054447174,
-0.6726217865943909,
0.3497481346130371,
0.029416101053357124,
-0.789417564868927,
0.5549190044403076,
-0.1964026391506195,
-0.1881987750530243,
0.1551041156053543,
-0.348385214805603,
0.03513818234205246,
0.4869576394557953,
-0.44028082489967346,
0.43257027864456177,
0.6975690126419067,
0.2078428864479065,
-1.1332664489746094,
-0.9027533531188965,
-0.08738787472248077,
-0.32185620069503784,
-0.13832315802574158,
0.2554156184196472,
0.055789366364479065,
-0.2570876181125641,
0.12580379843711853,
0.00623804796487093,
-0.19986946880817413,
0.3809191584587097,
0.6756572723388672,
0.2781570851802826,
0.1708485186100006,
0.35013946890830994,
-0.15148410201072693,
-0.2745044231414795,
0.21623395383358002,
-0.2976611852645874,
0.6301975846290588,
0.14967525005340576,
-0.3817027509212494,
-0.3705349266529083,
0.21116870641708374,
0.6150156259536743,
-0.3325444459915161,
0.9661847949028015,
0.4180348515510559,
-0.7813192009925842,
-0.44718268513679504,
-0.25433021783828735,
-0.15804553031921387,
-0.4724726676940918,
0.35902857780456543,
0.014696061611175537,
-0.5190954804420471,
0.22461485862731934,
0.06380951404571533,
0.2791684865951538,
0.2707005441188812,
0.37527894973754883,
-0.4611899256706238,
0.5662023425102234,
0.7937771677970886,
-0.1413305699825287,
0.2540532052516937,
-0.44541487097740173,
-0.0029635783284902573,
-0.6239583492279053,
-0.6495542526245117,
-0.7299451231956482,
-0.18385738134384155,
-0.6045542359352112,
-0.13588762283325195,
-0.050716910511255264,
0.2391541451215744,
-0.4255948066711426,
0.36159181594848633,
-0.29218703508377075,
0.6573927402496338,
0.6586630344390869,
0.1770726889371872,
0.5285165905952454,
0.25566035509109497,
-0.4274212121963501,
-0.14601904153823853,
-0.49252644181251526,
-0.6740861535072327,
1.307464361190796,
0.37148696184158325,
0.5965307354927063,
0.07839584350585938,
0.5583912134170532,
0.6172167658805847,
0.0354372039437294,
-0.32447513937950134,
0.21984121203422546,
-0.26453790068626404,
-0.6513616442680359,
-0.41246265172958374,
-0.4528280198574066,
-1.2157460451126099,
0.14180174469947815,
-0.2806210517883301,
-0.9302306175231934,
0.13434001803398132,
0.19426298141479492,
-0.04678758233785629,
0.9182357788085938,
-0.8760975003242493,
0.8797941207885742,
-0.12054771929979324,
-0.25750428438186646,
-0.0788988322019577,
-0.539120614528656,
0.3287988007068634,
-0.5736696124076843,
0.5505670309066772,
0.060632333159446716,
0.15494772791862488,
0.8352249264717102,
-0.4059118926525116,
1.1600162982940674,
-0.2671343684196472,
-0.022222308441996574,
0.26306018233299255,
0.6021398901939392,
0.49278929829597473,
0.10583198070526123,
-0.04553331062197685,
0.15152528882026672,
-0.05943800136446953,
-0.3987729549407959,
-0.5964557528495789,
0.31640899181365967,
-0.9762629866600037,
-0.39833536744117737,
-0.4614262580871582,
-0.3967496454715729,
-0.23489736020565033,
0.2822767496109009,
0.6155986785888672,
0.3082953691482544,
-0.16867756843566895,
0.3257242441177368,
0.6986402869224548,
-0.10079150646924973,
0.6123964190483093,
0.782954216003418,
-0.1186528354883194,
-0.00685131223872304,
1.2125794887542725,
0.09367949515581131,
0.5129327178001404,
0.7237751483917236,
0.16724631190299988,
-0.3182567358016968,
-0.405310720205307,
-0.330637663602829,
0.28558191657066345,
-0.42419570684432983,
-0.4396582841873169,
-0.6436676979064941,
-0.3329141139984131,
0.05502544716000557,
-0.015129586681723595,
-0.45048362016677856,
-0.4177289307117462,
-0.272836834192276,
-0.2061561644077301,
0.21229900419712067,
0.8634456396102905,
0.14074259996414185,
0.46923646330833435,
-0.9994662404060364,
0.07160303741693497,
0.2672135531902313,
0.09678814560174942,
0.11949864029884338,
-0.867645263671875,
-0.0565016008913517,
0.3552466332912445,
-0.5468006730079651,
-0.969959557056427,
0.5600664019584656,
-0.009239674545824528,
0.40725648403167725,
0.5713154673576355,
0.32877349853515625,
0.3539801836013794,
-0.47445791959762573,
0.32773709297180176,
0.17812316119670868,
-0.8215858340263367,
0.3114285469055176,
-0.018154945224523544,
0.25136885046958923,
0.5199071168899536,
0.3523065149784088,
-0.5361788272857666,
-0.5884607434272766,
-1.0906250476837158,
-0.5032404065132141,
0.7126386761665344,
0.08888601511716843,
0.10188044607639313,
0.435960054397583,
0.05722203850746155,
0.2674659788608551,
0.46115776896476746,
-0.7988020181655884,
-0.44958093762397766,
-0.35158905386924744,
-0.0434882752597332,
-0.01315650437027216,
-0.4559629261493683,
0.13132524490356445,
0.23688457906246185,
0.8211244940757751,
0.34911978244781494,
0.1285272240638733,
-0.17152652144432068,
-0.6059032082557678,
-0.31810522079467773,
0.46836182475090027,
0.24952754378318787,
0.5325221419334412,
-0.08059631288051605,
0.27549564838409424,
0.31786054372787476,
-0.6687273979187012,
0.23946893215179443,
-0.1566465198993683,
-0.5369600057601929,
0.032394587993621826,
0.42323291301727295,
0.6257800459861755,
0.20906813442707062,
-0.7953978776931763,
0.32027652859687805,
0.04337751492857933,
0.0005194431869313121,
-0.4217084050178528,
0.08665717393159866,
0.16462451219558716,
-0.022665871307253838,
0.2900090515613556,
0.16043934226036072,
-0.3845348060131073,
-0.7312160134315491,
0.5572381615638733,
0.4899909496307373,
-0.9522562026977539,
-0.3073606789112091,
0.5269480347633362,
-0.28447914123535156,
-0.4598856270313263,
0.4735742509365082,
0.10064753890037537,
-0.4978460371494293,
0.4108695685863495,
0.7202350497245789,
0.5902326703071594,
-0.6350579261779785,
0.3489427864551544,
0.039090193808078766,
0.5136514902114868,
0.18861424922943115,
-0.04557880759239197,
0.29737985134124756,
-0.6552289724349976,
-0.045496273785829544,
-0.2895089089870453,
-0.1643139123916626,
0.5047717094421387,
-0.5673673748970032,
0.1406206637620926,
-0.32311657071113586,
0.18973764777183533,
-0.0673089399933815,
-0.09887170046567917,
-0.39341700077056885,
0.05180801451206207,
-0.28185272216796875,
0.43097275495529175,
-0.40849459171295166,
0.9334791898727417,
0.5110632181167603,
-0.3083709478378296,
-0.6024438142776489,
-0.14509829878807068,
0.3367713987827301,
-1.1811853647232056,
0.4102114737033844,
0.13008035719394684,
-0.043585289269685745,
-0.21367542445659637,
-0.06507614254951477,
-0.41095978021621704,
0.9907335638999939,
0.5680350661277771,
-0.6274681091308594,
-0.09610345959663391,
0.6183763742446899,
0.16885574162006378,
-0.04299847409129143,
0.03945440053939819,
0.4142535924911499,
0.14859765768051147,
-0.26236456632614136,
-0.381026029586792,
-0.033526793122291565,
-0.15011462569236755,
-0.46504777669906616,
0.44394776225090027,
-0.31124427914619446,
0.7236409783363342,
-0.4377329647541046,
-0.5308893322944641,
-0.27102530002593994,
0.45915350317955017,
-0.037358805537223816,
0.45656174421310425,
0.6128600239753723,
0.5383742451667786,
1.1449049711227417,
0.13865356147289276,
0.705626904964447,
0.007166665978729725,
0.06941594928503036,
1.0730552673339844,
-0.0062073394656181335,
0.8222776651382446,
0.25801020860671997,
0.05401695892214775,
0.32312193512916565,
-0.047823335975408554,
0.16919898986816406,
0.5221757292747498,
0.054838646203279495,
-0.09841565787792206,
0.07245857268571854,
-0.04846139997243881,
-0.47101783752441406,
0.5768701434135437,
0.4096065163612366,
-0.2692165672779083,
-0.30432212352752686,
-0.06106876581907272,
0.7752450108528137,
0.6505820155143738,
-0.12691070139408112,
0.9230287075042725,
0.3143160045146942,
-0.4672325849533081,
0.6750737428665161,
-0.07554991543292999,
0.29079103469848633,
-0.6299813985824585,
0.10045923292636871,
-0.23391211032867432,
0.45434466004371643,
-0.25984135270118713,
-0.6628397107124329,
0.37620407342910767,
0.2995654046535492,
-0.10724882036447525,
-0.009725979529321194,
0.7949122786521912,
-0.6275256872177124,
-0.3616037666797638,
0.43213504552841187,
0.8065809011459351,
-0.12984265387058258,
-0.19214577972888947,
-0.644230306148529,
-0.3068585693836212,
0.2618812322616577,
-0.04250749200582504,
0.6918919682502747,
0.7020281553268433,
-0.17294231057167053,
0.9519595503807068,
0.7896708250045776,
0.0372304804623127,
-0.018836267292499542,
-0.03315669298171997,
0.6710257530212402,
-0.6082660555839539,
-0.3688977360725403,
-1.1556644439697266,
0.49999016523361206,
-0.022008497267961502,
-0.04076658934354782,
0.6152288317680359,
0.4223674535751343,
0.9861895442008972,
0.11881519109010696,
0.7933349609375,
0.594390332698822,
0.5875074863433838,
-0.7799688577651978,
1.2843118906021118,
-0.5850828289985657,
0.5138425230979919,
-0.28806185722351074,
-0.5121578574180603,
-0.06496238708496094,
-0.03749649599194527,
0.022494453936815262,
-0.09561358392238617,
0.9484308362007141,
0.651408851146698,
0.07758700847625732,
0.19774237275123596,
0.48057183623313904,
0.24721848964691162,
0.22798199951648712,
0.48283201456069946,
0.8418267965316772,
-0.32025372982025146,
0.9391596913337708,
-0.2949214577674866,
-0.00839028786867857,
0.1844933032989502,
-0.767037034034729,
-1.2215454578399658,
-0.7457017302513123,
-0.026579882949590683,
-0.4214445650577545,
0.4170664846897125,
0.31159597635269165,
0.19561244547367096,
-0.6787181496620178,
-0.22373594343662262,
0.0353657566010952,
0.41883546113967896,
-0.0445115752518177,
-0.19852903485298157,
0.5283100605010986,
-0.40300452709198,
-0.40901845693588257,
0.2933260202407837,
-0.007957251742482185,
0.25249049067497253,
-0.14721564948558807,
-0.05959644913673401,
-0.24856910109519958,
-0.13824833929538727,
0.25443223118782043,
0.6542768478393555,
-0.28485000133514404,
0.1664724349975586,
-0.054794806987047195,
0.10120730102062225,
-0.17461277544498444,
0.8804754018783569,
-1.0160199403762817,
0.275928795337677,
0.18967005610466003,
0.9830436706542969,
0.3172234296798706,
-0.17858819663524628,
0.5914144515991211,
-1.0759104490280151,
0.37294334173202515,
-0.09715910255908966,
0.5720922350883484,
0.24615313112735748,
-0.34874722361564636,
0.3624449670314789,
0.22206832468509674,
-0.30776679515838623,
-1.197782039642334,
0.14194339513778687,
-0.3145083785057068,
-0.7304023504257202,
0.8409502506256104,
-0.12351025640964508,
-0.4050469696521759,
-0.35223153233528137,
-0.06641590595245361,
0.5255650877952576,
-0.4143263101577759,
0.9428430795669556,
0.3514672517776489,
0.7610405683517456,
0.12325751781463623,
-0.7936881184577942,
0.6622328162193298,
0.5225571990013123,
-0.7387303113937378,
0.45625388622283936,
0.0004767191712744534,
0.028799517080187798,
0.14109502732753754,
0.36688604950904846,
-0.48185184597969055,
0.1970185488462448,
-0.4288586676120758,
-0.11762357503175735,
-0.5845257639884949,
-0.5119403004646301,
-0.17812208831310272,
0.25651100277900696,
-0.1985168755054474,
-0.3375798165798187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13342v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13342v1 | ZeroDL: Zero-shot Distribution Learning for Text Clustering via Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T08:48:05 | 2024-06-19T08:48:05 | Hwiyeol Jo, Hyunwoo Lee, Taiwoo Park | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have brought
significant progress in solving NLP tasks. Notably, in-context learning (ICL)
is the key enabling mechanism for LLMs to understand specific tasks and
grasping nuances. In this paper, we propose a simple yet effective method to
contextualize a task toward a specific LLM, by (1) observing how a given LLM
describes (all or a part of) target datasets, i.e., open-ended zero-shot
inference, and (2) aggregating the open-ended inference results by the LLM, and
(3) finally incorporate the aggregated meta-information for the actual task. We
show the effectiveness of this approach in text clustering tasks, and also
highlight the importance of the contextualization through examples of the above
procedure. | [
-0.032315563410520554,
-0.8294946551322937,
0.7605636119842529,
-0.01882714219391346,
-0.521124005317688,
-0.11371583491563797,
-0.35127270221710205,
-0.041366878896951675,
0.10217850655317307,
0.3120616674423218,
-0.4612138271331787,
-1.1598256826400757,
-0.4493960440158844,
-0.09046245366334915,
-0.6644421219825745,
1.180863380432129,
0.08295313268899918,
-0.19942568242549896,
-0.28290605545043945,
-0.18583159148693085,
-0.41114577651023865,
-0.46994316577911377,
-0.4212231934070587,
-0.3267461657524109,
0.6346823573112488,
0.5681470632553101,
0.06430047005414963,
0.616024911403656,
0.21249283850193024,
0.1685734987258911,
-0.23498249053955078,
-0.16377495229244232,
-0.6019678115844727,
0.2895646095275879,
-0.20694516599178314,
-0.5937203764915466,
-0.1012994721531868,
-0.0887562707066536,
0.9049535393714905,
0.9105672240257263,
-0.20715509355068207,
0.1606477051973343,
0.0726998820900917,
0.20684170722961426,
-0.8333797454833984,
-0.024213900789618492,
-0.7776753306388855,
0.27248284220695496,
-0.1652299016714096,
-0.27049729228019714,
-0.7361993193626404,
0.06667689234018326,
0.11826924234628677,
-0.3565981686115265,
0.3119141757488251,
-0.14103437960147858,
0.2749526798725128,
0.36567702889442444,
-0.6900980472564697,
-0.3881545960903168,
-0.7961111664772034,
1.0622283220291138,
-0.702735960483551,
-0.004027011338621378,
0.09661662578582764,
0.3200828731060028,
0.13326577842235565,
-0.4118525981903076,
-0.6035499572753906,
0.1298431009054184,
-0.18384361267089844,
0.14621604979038239,
0.15960906445980072,
-0.07844208180904388,
-0.11925020813941956,
0.15109582245349884,
-0.4825389087200165,
0.1811368614435196,
0.1113513708114624,
0.49957501888275146,
0.3949727714061737,
0.012062572874128819,
0.17675615847110748,
0.1273564249277115,
-0.4487120807170868,
-0.06738919019699097,
-0.7124578356742859,
-0.22696715593338013,
-0.26218411326408386,
0.43377432227134705,
-0.3638589680194855,
0.6387379765510559,
-0.13747580349445343,
0.8255648612976074,
0.09642387181520462,
-0.2554194927215576,
0.30534204840660095,
-0.1353486329317093,
-0.5279371738433838,
0.32375380396842957,
0.5277369022369385,
0.17798590660095215,
-0.09275876730680466,
-0.34489575028419495,
-0.022222233936190605,
-0.3328981101512909,
0.09044983983039856,
-0.7554031014442444,
0.3536261320114136,
0.41617071628570557,
-0.3696840703487396,
-0.4475429058074951,
0.06546046584844589,
-0.6394728422164917,
-0.21498630940914154,
-0.11687754839658737,
0.4409521520137787,
-0.1254446655511856,
-0.11122321337461472,
0.010477139614522457,
-0.06129014492034912,
0.24183271825313568,
0.1824960708618164,
-0.9858681559562683,
0.0029695716220885515,
0.6659504771232605,
1.088383674621582,
-0.274610310792923,
-0.29675784707069397,
-0.6485501527786255,
0.6718555092811584,
-0.49721086025238037,
0.8895478248596191,
-0.4476250410079956,
-0.36306437849998474,
0.18206270039081573,
-0.06769845634698868,
-0.20937766134738922,
-0.39767658710479736,
0.29545438289642334,
-0.2996163070201874,
0.17433972656726837,
0.0953415036201477,
-0.6549754738807678,
-0.17816855013370514,
0.48075851798057556,
-0.25258517265319824,
0.9377081990242004,
0.06697916984558105,
-0.7722291946411133,
0.5134376883506775,
-0.5937114357948303,
-0.4082089364528656,
0.17543618381023407,
-0.2455354779958725,
-0.33866772055625916,
0.31933125853538513,
0.1518910974264145,
0.9683968424797058,
0.11259505152702332,
0.3610450327396393,
-0.37502360343933105,
-0.396521657705307,
0.05885932222008705,
-0.332817018032074,
0.6929268836975098,
0.01483729388564825,
-0.45339784026145935,
0.3090726137161255,
-0.3369129002094269,
-0.27162739634513855,
0.02654281258583069,
-0.19443221390247345,
-0.6996105313301086,
0.27102354168891907,
-0.02850250154733658,
0.012204797007143497,
0.03855258226394653,
-0.55255526304245,
0.18290555477142334,
-0.6852139830589294,
0.029445158317685127,
0.49307486414909363,
0.030524635687470436,
0.9457817077636719,
0.11407994478940964,
0.347543329000473,
0.22612647712230682,
-0.08579490333795547,
-0.47367605566978455,
-0.27920225262641907,
-0.44318047165870667,
-0.36639371514320374,
0.15477903187274933,
0.541064977645874,
-0.7722054123878479,
0.7058146595954895,
-0.08931650966405869,
-0.4692589342594147,
-0.14746767282485962,
0.04193989560008049,
0.33379194140434265,
0.6935820579528809,
0.32851865887641907,
0.10522793978452682,
-0.05842095613479614,
-0.4786487817764282,
-0.06394748389720917,
0.16488027572631836,
-0.2767813801765442,
0.2833659052848816,
0.3747236430644989,
-0.30206021666526794,
1.1666330099105835,
-0.834086000919342,
-0.5604628324508667,
-0.6276761889457703,
0.22273944318294525,
0.4554578959941864,
0.2431381195783615,
0.7328289151191711,
-0.7378721237182617,
-0.9474508166313171,
0.2645828127861023,
-0.924018144607544,
-0.14975546300411224,
-0.12795792520046234,
-0.16907162964344025,
0.20809197425842285,
0.7405890822410583,
-0.5167760252952576,
0.5106800198554993,
0.49914196133613586,
-0.5217075347900391,
0.2761531174182892,
-0.32504406571388245,
-0.29716911911964417,
-1.2304002046585083,
0.09767594933509827,
0.158717080950737,
-0.43512749671936035,
-0.9993966221809387,
0.13387137651443481,
0.04303507134318352,
0.07975873351097107,
-0.48186638951301575,
0.8890833854675293,
-0.3788624107837677,
-0.0971967875957489,
-0.3417016565799713,
0.31043174862861633,
-0.32747989892959595,
0.36659541726112366,
0.24039585888385773,
0.4732377529144287,
0.7062174677848816,
-0.42815902829170227,
0.08659455180168152,
0.1571521908044815,
-0.38554608821868896,
0.7607440948486328,
-0.4837677478790283,
-0.267763614654541,
-0.631312370300293,
0.4501563012599945,
-1.0152357816696167,
-0.10226554423570633,
0.1760261505842209,
-0.1985013484954834,
0.23430325090885162,
0.03444185480475426,
-0.3565233647823334,
0.09142148494720459,
-0.28458160161972046,
0.6136968731880188,
0.3580515384674072,
-0.6588239669799805,
0.4434145390987396,
0.352677583694458,
0.018984124064445496,
-0.714336633682251,
-0.6800807118415833,
-0.059666890650987625,
-0.483824759721756,
0.00255696102976799,
0.48566415905952454,
-0.2603355646133423,
-0.3629857003688812,
-0.0261723343282938,
0.1676630973815918,
-0.20441247522830963,
0.009940110146999359,
0.14424099028110504,
-0.09453993290662766,
-0.03455153480172157,
0.3599059283733368,
0.03538231924176216,
-0.3093682527542114,
-0.3593854606151581,
-0.34307965636253357,
0.4802604913711548,
0.24334567785263062,
-0.369619756937027,
-0.12341994047164917,
0.4171830117702484,
0.19059742987155914,
-0.01287459209561348,
1.023218035697937,
0.5659992098808289,
-0.31916385889053345,
-0.7670335173606873,
-0.18212954699993134,
-0.1744537204504013,
-0.3896338939666748,
0.17807434499263763,
-0.010748139582574368,
-0.9537365436553955,
0.19333571195602417,
-0.09701734036207199,
0.16879664361476898,
0.26024526357650757,
0.7140678763389587,
-0.2869546115398407,
0.9348958134651184,
1.0228781700134277,
-0.37944045662879944,
0.5425450801849365,
-0.3382507860660553,
0.4869992434978485,
-0.6201128363609314,
-0.11635855585336685,
-0.45952320098876953,
-0.28546959161758423,
-0.12088406831026077,
-0.650704562664032,
0.5202010273933411,
0.23459458351135254,
-0.09222962707281113,
0.008597788400948048,
-0.31871500611305237,
0.752796471118927,
0.4693048298358917,
0.08115271478891373,
0.2932392656803131,
0.09222820401191711,
-0.21695654094219208,
0.25646135210990906,
-0.6956808567047119,
-0.1475277543067932,
0.9327959418296814,
0.16626398265361786,
0.48595163226127625,
0.07271816581487656,
0.764582097530365,
0.19275949895381927,
0.5286939144134521,
-0.8222116827964783,
0.4231087863445282,
-0.34711846709251404,
-0.45886102318763733,
-0.5662725567817688,
-0.2565777003765106,
-0.7890582084655762,
0.4404439926147461,
-0.05891667678952217,
-0.7534931302070618,
0.17448340356349945,
0.007763114292174578,
-0.16000664234161377,
0.30218321084976196,
-0.5177450180053711,
1.0198296308517456,
0.1767427921295166,
0.10531038045883179,
-0.21948587894439697,
-0.5532494187355042,
0.3345848321914673,
-0.16921217739582062,
0.4206559658050537,
-0.06976977735757828,
-0.26543593406677246,
0.36444559693336487,
-0.19347204267978668,
1.2050812244415283,
-0.273009330034256,
-0.1455431431531906,
0.20653580129146576,
-0.16385257244110107,
0.3956843316555023,
-0.028490250930190086,
-0.07511497288942337,
0.058596234768629074,
-0.1601485013961792,
-0.4245833158493042,
-0.5918959975242615,
0.7361096739768982,
-0.42799103260040283,
-0.07530821859836578,
-0.3861425817012787,
-0.6242803931236267,
0.03500327095389366,
0.1941143274307251,
0.11106611043214798,
0.5370146632194519,
-0.21409821510314941,
0.47191086411476135,
0.707771360874176,
-0.3659132719039917,
0.9422481656074524,
0.6104893684387207,
-0.22205914556980133,
-0.11202699691057205,
0.7166368365287781,
-0.020144930109381676,
0.17855499684810638,
0.741140604019165,
0.27027627825737,
-0.3443169593811035,
-0.5074169039726257,
-0.34421369433403015,
0.3952438533306122,
-0.7949397563934326,
-0.22769860923290253,
-0.6718738079071045,
-0.014187715016305447,
-0.220640167593956,
-0.6684355139732361,
0.010499141179025173,
0.026963189244270325,
-0.5412298440933228,
-0.18950378894805908,
0.0834496021270752,
0.7650853991508484,
0.15059678256511688,
0.7846847176551819,
-0.5360339283943176,
0.24395446479320526,
0.104329414665699,
0.31075194478034973,
0.1647171825170517,
-0.3528406620025635,
-0.5218339562416077,
-0.12253600358963013,
-0.08953261375427246,
-0.8039653897285461,
0.5861034393310547,
0.3170327842235565,
0.533955991268158,
0.7665063738822937,
0.10890799760818481,
0.4675893783569336,
-0.6934926509857178,
0.7968926429748535,
0.19788652658462524,
-0.9440550208091736,
0.4823049008846283,
-0.5149484276771545,
0.6282040476799011,
0.468611478805542,
0.5181161165237427,
-0.692836582660675,
-0.3573995530605316,
-0.38884294033050537,
-0.7669599652290344,
0.6304571628570557,
-0.1150362491607666,
0.2034197598695755,
-0.4084163010120392,
0.47818276286125183,
-0.010379491373896599,
0.3584078848361969,
-1.0906091928482056,
-0.26191583275794983,
0.29035231471061707,
-0.5850154757499695,
-0.5561322569847107,
-0.46072259545326233,
-0.07123161107301712,
-0.2499716430902481,
0.5361683964729309,
-0.6068581342697144,
0.05719340965151787,
0.09234894067049026,
-0.3401431143283844,
-0.04113657400012016,
0.1525343954563141,
0.6390669941902161,
0.6737406849861145,
-0.2685920298099518,
0.2796461880207062,
0.3056664764881134,
-0.18642652034759521,
0.20104926824569702,
-0.3624900281429291,
-0.49876317381858826,
0.24044519662857056,
0.5516871809959412,
0.5535269379615784,
0.5176188945770264,
-0.8325758576393127,
0.9484556317329407,
0.20765173435211182,
-0.17617058753967285,
-0.19378674030303955,
-0.22383888065814972,
0.09318550676107407,
0.3663499057292938,
0.5451006293296814,
-0.45392540097236633,
0.004147911909967661,
-0.6099889874458313,
0.2469898909330368,
0.7107492089271545,
-0.5887792110443115,
-0.1926347017288208,
0.46579137444496155,
-0.00672207260504365,
-0.1255926787853241,
0.1242009699344635,
-0.2892409861087799,
-0.22910404205322266,
0.5085812211036682,
0.8698751330375671,
1.0546696186065674,
-0.35797980427742004,
0.6326398253440857,
0.1995309591293335,
0.01826135627925396,
-0.08373153209686279,
-0.060213420540094376,
-0.33894848823547363,
-0.709711492061615,
-0.8678131699562073,
-0.7283350825309753,
-0.3292338252067566,
-0.2277960330247879,
-0.388071745634079,
0.2937234342098236,
-0.18956191837787628,
0.3480144441127777,
-0.2551186978816986,
-0.2946816682815552,
-0.16036373376846313,
0.22835417091846466,
0.018599148839712143,
0.7585768699645996,
-0.9629202485084534,
1.0077263116836548,
0.4897395074367523,
0.012504737824201584,
-0.25160783529281616,
0.3008192479610443,
-0.06825313717126846,
-0.5572689175605774,
0.7034053802490234,
0.22623014450073242,
0.32800722122192383,
0.10111921280622482,
-0.5970447659492493,
-0.9050621390342712,
1.1915220022201538,
0.15176594257354736,
-0.4098895490169525,
0.10269054770469666,
0.1501963585615158,
0.5271137356758118,
-0.7201007008552551,
0.3836050033569336,
0.25562286376953125,
0.17048527300357819,
0.34374353289604187,
-0.515713095664978,
-0.17654235661029816,
0.28830209374427795,
-0.06177763268351555,
0.3586750328540802,
-0.29861438274383545,
0.777571976184845,
0.01813213713467121,
-0.23184150457382202,
-0.2754233181476593,
0.5753626227378845,
0.14579512178897858,
0.5579028725624084,
0.6695438027381897,
0.5553499460220337,
0.525551974773407,
0.212959885597229,
0.9028162956237793,
-0.1709253042936325,
0.568964958190918,
1.1021710634231567,
-0.4109707176685333,
1.0887025594711304,
0.37935009598731995,
0.18813705444335938,
0.3349323272705078,
0.3273424506187439,
0.22964942455291748,
0.8774381279945374,
0.01925315335392952,
-0.7609606385231018,
-0.01300619076937437,
-0.3422161340713501,
0.008564588613808155,
0.2951677739620209,
0.3805142641067505,
-0.30829790234565735,
-0.8895142674446106,
0.3151523172855377,
-0.023397544398903847,
0.05800068378448486,
-0.3680249750614166,
1.0659942626953125,
0.019958723336458206,
-0.2600034773349762,
0.25478774309158325,
0.06154235079884529,
0.8301538825035095,
-0.4597720801830292,
-0.04945394769310951,
-0.11390355229377747,
0.2320924997329712,
-0.13278479874134064,
-0.7561361193656921,
0.6710925102233887,
0.09938180446624756,
-0.3612147569656372,
-0.5092639327049255,
0.6193258166313171,
-0.7621522545814514,
-0.603652834892273,
0.5065135359764099,
0.3233165442943573,
0.31900033354759216,
-0.35873761773109436,
-0.32054588198661804,
-0.24521327018737793,
-0.009573151357471943,
-0.1658288985490799,
0.5683239102363586,
0.5186859965324402,
-0.09040415287017822,
0.5132777094841003,
0.4074153006076813,
0.05966181680560112,
-0.12304099649190903,
0.011183003894984722,
0.6177794337272644,
-0.6888579726219177,
-0.5545037984848022,
-1.139430046081543,
0.5839325785636902,
-0.11248689889907837,
-0.06065187230706215,
0.8196784853935242,
0.4974443018436432,
0.7661369442939758,
-0.031689610332250595,
0.7573509216308594,
0.0388839915394783,
0.7437265515327454,
-0.34221819043159485,
0.6084266304969788,
-0.6328967809677124,
0.04870833083987236,
-0.188589945435524,
-1.1027570962905884,
-0.734499454498291,
0.4694496691226959,
-0.31439703702926636,
-0.28752854466438293,
0.751474142074585,
0.5887911915779114,
-0.24476219713687897,
-0.4838089942932129,
0.6077526807785034,
0.29597553610801697,
0.318080872297287,
0.3351310193538666,
0.347590833902359,
-0.10459700971841812,
0.4004662334918976,
-0.31830713152885437,
-0.4360783100128174,
-0.25439637899398804,
-1.1708825826644897,
-1.0779792070388794,
-0.5005884766578674,
-0.10515668988227844,
0.2239575833082199,
-0.21628914773464203,
0.751695454120636,
0.7829084992408752,
-0.7957165241241455,
-0.4544217884540558,
-0.07431478798389435,
0.363043874502182,
-0.2160617858171463,
-0.18733954429626465,
0.3965952396392822,
-0.5594020485877991,
-0.7595195770263672,
0.5800448060035706,
0.5457959175109863,
-0.09663588553667068,
-0.18131066858768463,
0.16101212799549103,
-0.3603765666484833,
-0.006593823432922363,
1.051645278930664,
-0.00327326194383204,
-0.5936036109924316,
-0.1503259390592575,
-0.2932843863964081,
0.04323752596974373,
-0.05416835844516754,
0.617761492729187,
-0.7546262741088867,
0.26833096146583557,
0.3793223798274994,
0.5675463676452637,
0.6272103190422058,
0.17355608940124512,
0.5620365738868713,
-1.199276089668274,
0.4714250862598419,
0.062095027416944504,
0.09300762414932251,
0.07162024825811386,
-0.343454509973526,
0.5746443867683411,
0.09020841121673584,
-0.5554986596107483,
-0.9330443739891052,
-0.018174700438976288,
-0.8892605900764465,
-0.663906991481781,
1.1332604885101318,
-0.08323929458856583,
-0.27926063537597656,
-0.023518986999988556,
-0.06543686240911484,
0.048270463943481445,
-0.1278921663761139,
0.5688080191612244,
0.4002251625061035,
0.08006516098976135,
-0.29502347111701965,
-0.6346601247787476,
0.2569654881954193,
0.2929060161113739,
-1.00902259349823,
-0.013353575021028519,
0.2570771872997284,
0.15472859144210815,
0.052422016859054565,
0.7020289301872253,
0.3660648763179779,
-0.23069804906845093,
-0.3478703796863556,
0.06285739690065384,
0.46226951479911804,
-0.5608315467834473,
-0.6473353505134583,
0.41898396611213684,
-0.1659305989742279,
-0.04866837337613106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13340v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13340v1 | SD-Eval: A Benchmark Dataset for Spoken Dialogue Understanding Beyond Words | 2024-06-19T08:46:29 | 2024-06-19T08:46:29 | Junyi Ao, Yuancheng Wang, Xiaohai Tian, Dekun Chen, Jun Zhang, Lu Lu, Yuxuan Wang, Haizhou Li, Zhizheng Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Speech encompasses a wealth of information, including but not limited to
content, paralinguistic, and environmental information. This comprehensive
nature of speech significantly impacts communication and is crucial for
human-computer interaction. Chat-Oriented Large Language Models (LLMs), known
for their general-purpose assistance capabilities, have evolved to handle
multi-modal inputs, including speech. Although these models can be adept at
recognizing and analyzing speech, they often fall short of generating
appropriate responses. We argue that this is due to the lack of principles on
task definition and model development, which requires open-source datasets and
metrics suitable for model evaluation. To bridge the gap, we present SD-Eval, a
benchmark dataset aimed at multidimensional evaluation of spoken dialogue
understanding and generation. SD-Eval focuses on paralinguistic and
environmental information and includes 7,303 utterances, amounting to 8.76
hours of speech data. The data is aggregated from eight public datasets,
representing four perspectives: emotion, accent, age, and background sound. To
assess the SD-Eval benchmark dataset, we implement three different models and
construct a training set following a similar process as SD-Eval. The training
set contains 1,052.72 hours of speech data and 724.4k utterances. We also
conduct a comprehensive evaluation using objective evaluation methods (e.g.
BLEU and ROUGE), subjective evaluations and LLM-based metrics for the generated
responses. Models conditioned with paralinguistic and environmental information
outperform their counterparts in both objective and subjective measures.
Moreover, experiments demonstrate LLM-based metrics show a higher correlation
with human evaluation compared to traditional metrics. We open-source SD-Eval
at https://github.com/amphionspace/SD-Eval. | [
-0.3827032148838043,
-0.6896555423736572,
0.6784301400184631,
0.12596939504146576,
-0.18524424731731415,
0.19131705164909363,
-0.4014737010002136,
-0.11274966597557068,
-0.13844099640846252,
0.611434280872345,
-0.6651356816291809,
-0.6554561853408813,
-0.30765533447265625,
-0.14059516787528992,
-0.3506333827972412,
0.969801127910614,
0.22401568293571472,
0.24816513061523438,
-0.36867716908454895,
-0.2645280361175537,
-0.2423328012228012,
-0.3571236729621887,
-0.5317177176475525,
-0.051619358360767365,
0.32203978300094604,
0.20977111160755157,
0.37236395478248596,
0.3838334083557129,
0.270984411239624,
0.2895326018333435,
-0.2533641457557678,
0.16127561032772064,
-0.6909520626068115,
0.0622844398021698,
-0.15175268054008484,
-0.4370177984237671,
-0.3011818528175354,
0.022856399416923523,
0.8006963729858398,
0.8184975385665894,
-0.4470866322517395,
0.3469161093235016,
0.17206436395645142,
0.5413854122161865,
-0.639460563659668,
0.5735477209091187,
-0.7267966270446777,
-0.23864711821079254,
-0.11293722689151764,
-0.03427472710609436,
-0.3004567623138428,
-0.2912660241127014,
0.17429114878177643,
-0.4801924526691437,
0.1278379112482071,
-0.14651206135749817,
0.5117858052253723,
0.35295370221138,
-0.29629963636398315,
-0.38467103242874146,
-0.7472130060195923,
0.7941348552703857,
-0.9078764915466309,
0.7436234951019287,
0.2917116582393646,
0.273570716381073,
-0.08298708498477936,
-0.34439098834991455,
-0.7103258371353149,
-0.35941046476364136,
0.300321489572525,
0.255321741104126,
-0.2475140392780304,
0.3049897253513336,
0.3126221001148224,
0.07645143568515778,
-0.5016942620277405,
0.1793743520975113,
-0.5082581043243408,
-0.027944190427660942,
0.7817468047142029,
0.47293317317962646,
-0.044373102486133575,
-0.31776148080825806,
-0.40717464685440063,
-0.21833689510822296,
-0.6786016225814819,
0.17387765645980835,
0.35795700550079346,
0.5172106027603149,
-0.3930242657661438,
0.5472499132156372,
-0.24842125177383423,
0.6219393014907837,
-0.33509910106658936,
-0.2664889693260193,
0.4028088450431824,
-0.5670162439346313,
-0.14754386246204376,
-0.14353077113628387,
0.7043426632881165,
0.5182117819786072,
0.12476275116205215,
0.09505751729011536,
-0.2623552978038788,
0.12669828534126282,
0.22418349981307983,
-0.5997483134269714,
0.01745542325079441,
0.31794142723083496,
-0.42407166957855225,
-0.14189265668392181,
-0.24573232233524323,
-0.8154504895210266,
-0.49484267830848694,
-0.833299458026886,
0.1939876824617386,
-0.42054319381713867,
-0.41297563910484314,
-0.14241933822631836,
-0.035739339888095856,
0.16343599557876587,
0.3456539809703827,
-0.3369942605495453,
0.43690240383148193,
0.7703217267990112,
0.8448972105979919,
-0.1905069649219513,
-0.18664316833019257,
-0.6767600774765015,
-0.1464252769947052,
-0.45937463641166687,
0.6525191068649292,
-0.7562627792358398,
-0.47951456904411316,
-0.13940685987472534,
-0.27960604429244995,
-0.2546224594116211,
-0.5989197492599487,
0.6796417236328125,
-0.10264187306165695,
-0.13624882698059082,
-0.14818893373012543,
-0.6861851811408997,
-0.14711323380470276,
-0.20213894546031952,
-0.4384436011314392,
0.8414677381515503,
0.05671904981136322,
-0.4225420653820038,
0.26224780082702637,
-0.8047706484794617,
0.0435744933784008,
0.3170260787010193,
-0.29625073075294495,
-0.027254067361354828,
0.3003900349140167,
0.14846257865428925,
0.5116973519325256,
-0.5335438847541809,
0.4015764892101288,
-0.3742653727531433,
-0.31561580300331116,
0.3372763991355896,
-0.6302335858345032,
0.4474564790725708,
0.2704728841781616,
0.03903477266430855,
0.08920745551586151,
-0.9634329676628113,
0.2618102729320526,
-0.061916787177324295,
-0.2813112139701843,
-0.18329626321792603,
0.23541708290576935,
0.12890048325061798,
0.16128095984458923,
-0.021658852696418762,
-0.764855682849884,
-0.40008020401000977,
-0.3174322247505188,
0.5106692910194397,
0.7976826429367065,
-0.057146016508340836,
-0.04278365522623062,
-0.16697588562965393,
0.5313234329223633,
0.05990080162882805,
-0.10317105799913406,
-0.4686482846736908,
-0.19516919553279877,
-0.6116873621940613,
-0.37378406524658203,
0.1364019215106964,
0.46198770403862,
-0.6723467111587524,
0.48566728830337524,
-0.47227784991264343,
-0.6647852063179016,
-0.8819363117218018,
0.05664348602294922,
0.6560196876525879,
0.4440169334411621,
0.20635569095611572,
-0.19737154245376587,
-0.46065303683280945,
-0.874291718006134,
-0.023896170780062675,
-0.3718019425868988,
-0.27997881174087524,
0.7261316180229187,
0.3334773778915405,
-0.043055858463048935,
1.0092908143997192,
-0.5186421275138855,
-0.007801188621670008,
-0.36295440793037415,
0.21236927807331085,
0.10397938638925552,
0.07834701985120773,
0.2193169891834259,
-0.6223522424697876,
-0.28300073742866516,
-0.1280902773141861,
-0.4953499436378479,
-0.28504708409309387,
-0.011614225804805756,
0.3342480957508087,
0.03128061071038246,
0.2829185724258423,
-0.5390790700912476,
0.3084811568260193,
0.6560942530632019,
-0.04709247499704361,
0.7092549204826355,
-0.18140707910060883,
0.1493965983390808,
-0.8931158185005188,
0.0858331024646759,
0.28003063797950745,
-0.06920686364173889,
-0.8937273025512695,
-0.1818610280752182,
0.0007987330900505185,
-0.44022509455680847,
-0.6818811893463135,
0.560705840587616,
-0.014845680445432663,
-0.3100797235965729,
-0.18436457216739655,
0.45429354906082153,
-0.07727189362049103,
0.612486720085144,
0.24399976432323456,
1.0175676345825195,
0.44555118680000305,
-0.47472599148750305,
0.40382885932922363,
0.2541002631187439,
-0.7127984166145325,
0.8911528587341309,
-0.7314109802246094,
0.24659477174282074,
-0.2929714322090149,
0.3662700057029724,
-1.0248910188674927,
-0.14426755905151367,
-0.04799431934952736,
-0.2519318759441376,
-0.028615621849894524,
-0.02469688467681408,
-0.2308233082294464,
-0.25226765871047974,
-0.03981573134660721,
0.14350634813308716,
0.43827152252197266,
-0.5680273771286011,
0.4178137183189392,
0.47805166244506836,
-0.5535356402397156,
-0.19729790091514587,
-0.21743544936180115,
0.007124058436602354,
-0.36045023798942566,
-0.6030282378196716,
0.03935519605875015,
-0.2730468213558197,
-0.5026450157165527,
-0.339541494846344,
-0.2614489495754242,
-0.21539771556854248,
-0.15994447469711304,
0.33017316460609436,
0.2995244562625885,
-0.21004435420036316,
0.17661689221858978,
-0.18487519025802612,
-0.055976007133722305,
0.14205899834632874,
0.2606823146343231,
0.5535920858383179,
-0.2139333337545395,
-0.4461017847061157,
-0.6527940630912781,
0.3227754533290863,
0.6751626133918762,
-0.20967504382133484,
0.5072274208068848,
0.2966456115245819,
-0.09923410415649414,
-0.1949184089899063,
-0.543095052242279,
0.08978018909692764,
-0.44198623299598694,
0.6066255569458008,
-0.3622303009033203,
-0.5798320174217224,
0.31421592831611633,
-0.11086622625589371,
0.10061132907867432,
0.21425116062164307,
0.4539215564727783,
-0.18665291368961334,
0.9664254784584045,
0.25814089179039,
0.031733132898807526,
0.32370489835739136,
-0.08133898675441742,
0.12003132700920105,
-1.1742651462554932,
-0.2406105250120163,
-0.5165020227432251,
0.11081758886575699,
-0.28528493642807007,
-0.6120395660400391,
0.3348817825317383,
-0.1144510805606842,
-0.14255747199058533,
0.42877668142318726,
-0.10393665730953217,
0.35180068016052246,
0.1439719796180725,
0.12847399711608887,
-0.03251044452190399,
-0.38980501890182495,
0.014901883900165558,
-0.13348369300365448,
-0.42519572377204895,
-0.6373654007911682,
1.1196800470352173,
0.5113633275032043,
0.8999009132385254,
-0.15196283161640167,
0.5522071719169617,
0.3618710935115814,
-0.10951486229896545,
-0.615220844745636,
0.7064100503921509,
-0.08781741559505463,
-0.08274870365858078,
-0.32442381978034973,
-0.579332709312439,
-0.7622396945953369,
0.44194188714027405,
0.1023472249507904,
-0.9396957755088806,
-0.0016388726653531194,
-0.09617028385400772,
-0.4414837658405304,
-0.0460461750626564,
-0.9142870306968689,
0.5665106177330017,
-0.27917975187301636,
-0.09932763874530792,
-0.5208740830421448,
-0.5269453525543213,
0.2365352362394333,
-0.3048627972602844,
0.4729415476322174,
-0.5882701277732849,
0.01835642009973526,
0.7229253649711609,
-0.21918177604675293,
0.8060630559921265,
-0.3693811893463135,
-0.29599425196647644,
0.11453932523727417,
-0.2548120319843292,
0.3608386218547821,
0.053936246782541275,
-0.19021101295948029,
0.34845107793807983,
0.1806870996952057,
-0.07795879244804382,
-0.7268035411834717,
0.6326523423194885,
-0.6788512468338013,
-0.5117309093475342,
0.005514825694262981,
-0.5367713570594788,
-0.3570595383644104,
-0.219501793384552,
-0.25335487723350525,
0.6990698575973511,
-0.4685790538787842,
0.38483932614326477,
0.5890450477600098,
-0.47739335894584656,
0.22186996042728424,
0.9248819947242737,
-0.03546753525733948,
-0.31090548634529114,
1.0533024072647095,
0.06198829039931297,
0.6012116074562073,
0.11013957113027573,
0.15213283896446228,
-0.5296953320503235,
-0.4391206204891205,
-0.36601558327674866,
-0.044213782995939255,
-0.7520888447761536,
-0.09602498263120651,
-0.5809147953987122,
-0.4842130243778229,
-0.25052011013031006,
0.1203666552901268,
-0.47411197423934937,
-0.16710445284843445,
-0.14102181792259216,
-0.09004566073417664,
0.15284061431884766,
0.6917647123336792,
-0.04368053749203682,
0.23753219842910767,
-0.7566638588905334,
0.47077247500419617,
0.055656444281339645,
0.39642906188964844,
0.06632237881422043,
-0.3311414122581482,
-0.09941988438367844,
0.5750893950462341,
-0.21254464983940125,
-0.6529731750488281,
0.35804641246795654,
0.4514232277870178,
0.7714740037918091,
0.42705971002578735,
0.07852489501237869,
0.7328075766563416,
-0.6118220090866089,
1.018941044807434,
0.15927915275096893,
-1.1482969522476196,
0.7025850415229797,
-0.3063073754310608,
0.3166229724884033,
0.44662103056907654,
0.13157305121421814,
-0.6945517063140869,
-0.5089399814605713,
-0.6362301111221313,
-0.6925846934318542,
0.9054000377655029,
0.3746778666973114,
0.16039162874221802,
-0.014969232492148876,
-0.08964385837316513,
0.25599151849746704,
0.2923433184623718,
-0.2384076863527298,
0.05672953650355339,
-0.05591177940368652,
-0.028275782242417336,
-0.3986712396144867,
0.0021380456164479256,
-0.18873576819896698,
-0.14960429072380066,
0.38570892810821533,
-0.1785062700510025,
0.1686800718307495,
-0.15727736055850983,
-0.06955328583717346,
0.153285413980484,
0.4735492169857025,
0.6181820631027222,
0.7426103353500366,
-0.15716466307640076,
-0.19675950706005096,
0.4228265583515167,
-0.208966463804245,
0.07242276519536972,
0.1758265197277069,
0.3907453119754791,
-0.059967316687107086,
0.3433780074119568,
1.1997709274291992,
0.29764431715011597,
-1.1701557636260986,
0.49969151616096497,
-0.09219423681497574,
-0.049650050699710846,
-0.14845037460327148,
0.3581646978855133,
0.08179662376642227,
0.34080711007118225,
0.18097993731498718,
-0.13813090324401855,
0.16722285747528076,
-0.46188127994537354,
0.0882924422621727,
0.4276161789894104,
-0.28917112946510315,
-0.3272665739059448,
0.48953425884246826,
0.41419604420661926,
-0.3896017372608185,
0.624733567237854,
0.13156330585479736,
-0.29500678181648254,
0.6345028281211853,
0.3237133026123047,
0.7850080132484436,
-0.29988884925842285,
0.425250768661499,
0.26845550537109375,
-0.0475505068898201,
0.25919589400291443,
0.3433193862438202,
-0.4392067492008209,
-0.581263542175293,
-0.2703176736831665,
-0.816969633102417,
-0.6171173453330994,
0.3887004256248474,
-0.7896512150764465,
0.20289327204227448,
-0.15133829414844513,
0.009629527106881142,
0.32921499013900757,
-0.04049026593565941,
-1.0155471563339233,
0.11651600897312164,
0.23872466385364532,
0.8273075819015503,
-0.9683701992034912,
0.7169560194015503,
0.22834917902946472,
-0.24449434876441956,
-0.500079870223999,
0.01651408150792122,
0.25644251704216003,
-0.8705973625183105,
0.6171743869781494,
0.24664269387722015,
-0.036145567893981934,
-0.1594143807888031,
-0.405298113822937,
-0.8984315991401672,
0.9217265248298645,
0.3648292124271393,
-0.8515512943267822,
0.12336567789316177,
0.326337605714798,
0.7064458727836609,
-0.44014084339141846,
0.4546014070510864,
0.8762973546981812,
0.30155593156814575,
0.2347489893436432,
-1.1577050685882568,
-0.2507905662059784,
-0.18346649408340454,
0.3522869646549225,
0.0930810496211052,
-0.5944545865058899,
0.5377967953681946,
-0.14686381816864014,
-0.3373428285121918,
0.22852090001106262,
0.3002430200576782,
0.3497900366783142,
0.3112557530403137,
0.5764537453651428,
0.4825478196144104,
0.8297492861747742,
-0.1610083132982254,
0.8483778238296509,
-0.1923893243074417,
0.14532244205474854,
1.3336657285690308,
-0.670234203338623,
1.1156349182128906,
0.21601055562496185,
-0.42423248291015625,
0.11515596508979797,
0.44399112462997437,
0.04389464110136032,
0.6210088133811951,
0.47267815470695496,
-0.45592162013053894,
-0.09168194979429245,
-0.4381959140300751,
-0.17856259644031525,
0.7283982634544373,
0.8152989745140076,
-0.17693735659122467,
-0.37228143215179443,
0.24396459758281708,
-0.39965933561325073,
-0.047140538692474365,
-0.18459023535251617,
1.0393295288085938,
0.026077598333358765,
-0.498340904712677,
0.5144888162612915,
-0.38397401571273804,
0.300754576921463,
-0.7171605229377747,
-0.11864976584911346,
0.023968691006302834,
0.09647965431213379,
-0.0292549766600132,
-1.0807794332504272,
0.2998684048652649,
0.1968192458152771,
0.12608860433101654,
-0.16769853234291077,
0.4221310317516327,
-0.48266252875328064,
-0.3156052231788635,
0.25585678219795227,
0.443887323141098,
0.45259174704551697,
0.10091333091259003,
-0.6488230228424072,
0.4299641251564026,
-0.007544602267444134,
-0.11969398707151413,
0.17151355743408203,
0.2157001793384552,
0.19929610192775726,
0.6986710429191589,
0.7229477763175964,
0.1899043172597885,
-0.17879922688007355,
0.17627564072608948,
0.8446609973907471,
-0.3660537302494049,
-0.3997763693332672,
-0.6359229683876038,
0.5983096957206726,
-0.11809959262609482,
-0.3656271994113922,
0.5642239451408386,
0.6518530249595642,
0.7346149682998657,
0.16540011763572693,
1.043713927268982,
0.08931462466716766,
0.7722755670547485,
-0.5770446062088013,
0.49772119522094727,
-0.2927629351615906,
0.2675756514072418,
-0.40475133061408997,
-1.0573583841323853,
0.3754688799381256,
0.526530921459198,
-0.2802760899066925,
-0.04795404151082039,
0.3469945788383484,
0.7810547351837158,
0.0967424139380455,
0.40425777435302734,
0.42998751997947693,
0.08234994858503342,
0.4534642994403839,
0.40492719411849976,
0.9370445013046265,
0.09670641273260117,
0.38789018988609314,
-0.06810277700424194,
-0.21262229979038239,
0.14892946183681488,
-0.6981834173202515,
-0.788618266582489,
-0.8801106214523315,
-0.22463886439800262,
-0.12344742566347122,
0.23954617977142334,
1.1070666313171387,
0.7821536064147949,
-0.6303629279136658,
-0.41397061944007874,
-0.022006496787071228,
-0.18789567053318024,
-0.18352381885051727,
-0.2514039874076843,
0.2310279756784439,
-0.3610861897468567,
-0.7675245404243469,
0.8595312833786011,
0.34315186738967896,
-0.18957079946994781,
-0.4357452094554901,
-0.2344670295715332,
0.14414171874523163,
0.4508081078529358,
0.6009949445724487,
0.13683228194713593,
-0.9790957570075989,
-0.25785282254219055,
-0.3005531430244446,
0.14707762002944946,
0.13624927401542664,
0.6203126311302185,
-0.7488918304443359,
0.6880618333816528,
0.26942479610443115,
0.5486466288566589,
0.4376187324523926,
0.024749208241701126,
0.7503018379211426,
-0.7982690930366516,
-0.11712886393070221,
0.24091465771198273,
0.2846185863018036,
0.38817307353019714,
-0.050136253237724304,
0.49682968854904175,
-0.19599789381027222,
-0.5385894775390625,
-0.9462677836418152,
0.13694296777248383,
-0.8297846913337708,
-0.01198333129286766,
1.2738385200500488,
-0.2768317759037018,
0.047857463359832764,
-0.05414867773652077,
-0.4142051041126251,
-0.0039656516164541245,
-0.6191412210464478,
0.5944303274154663,
0.9005005955696106,
-0.25653722882270813,
-0.297387033700943,
-0.6669566035270691,
0.31111347675323486,
0.00901007279753685,
-0.9806713461875916,
0.5452458262443542,
0.5213695168495178,
0.19004109501838684,
0.05552712082862854,
0.552408754825592,
0.21912050247192383,
0.16939841210842133,
0.11183580011129379,
-0.26314228773117065,
0.17259301245212555,
-0.3132215738296509,
-0.4130367040634155,
-0.13497184216976166,
-0.2663930356502533,
-0.24172919988632202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13337v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13337v1 | Medical Spoken Named Entity Recognition | 2024-06-19T08:39:09 | 2024-06-19T08:39:09 | Khai Le-Duc | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Spoken Named Entity Recognition (NER) aims to extracting named entities from
speech and categorizing them into types like person, location, organization,
etc. In this work, we present VietMed-NER - the first spoken NER dataset in the
medical domain. To our best knowledge, our real-world dataset is the largest
spoken NER dataset in the world in terms of the number of entity types,
featuring 18 distinct types. Secondly, we present baseline results using
various state-of-the-art pre-trained models: encoder-only and
sequence-to-sequence. We found that pre-trained multilingual models XLM-R
outperformed all monolingual models on both reference text and ASR output. Also
in general, encoders perform better than sequence-to-sequence models for the
NER task. By simply translating, the transcript is applicable not just to
Vietnamese but to other languages as well. All code, data and models are made
publicly available here: https://github.com/leduckhai/MultiMed | [
-0.14498962461948395,
-0.5046855211257935,
0.5493131875991821,
-0.16632132232189178,
-0.233076810836792,
0.03678988665342331,
-0.22623459994792938,
-0.5277630686759949,
0.45240503549575806,
0.8994941115379333,
-0.08511477708816528,
-0.6869451403617859,
-0.9080199003219604,
0.5096854567527771,
-0.5099068284034729,
0.9298847317695618,
0.18959841132164001,
0.5506267547607422,
-0.04715374484658241,
-0.39225512742996216,
-0.2547990381717682,
-0.8960618376731873,
-1.0249096155166626,
-0.37684330344200134,
0.6286571025848389,
0.4242151379585266,
0.214340478181839,
0.46523141860961914,
0.6122881770133972,
0.3216533660888672,
0.003268800675868988,
0.2539176642894745,
-0.20317313075065613,
0.00029537759837694466,
0.11153542250394821,
-0.2675839960575104,
-0.6136342287063599,
-0.1746663600206375,
0.7132536768913269,
0.31020379066467285,
-0.24754095077514648,
0.06938719749450684,
-0.23806364834308624,
0.4765987694263458,
-0.15467031300067902,
0.1294335275888443,
-0.4257543087005615,
0.023635856807231903,
-0.09832127392292023,
-0.30599701404571533,
-0.531477689743042,
-0.3483056128025055,
0.5642748475074768,
-0.5918956398963928,
-0.055926479399204254,
-0.10576877743005753,
1.0944393873214722,
0.4496914744377136,
-0.7794173955917358,
-0.41521966457366943,
-0.8340973258018494,
0.4830889105796814,
-0.5542882084846497,
0.6558245420455933,
0.18616236746311188,
0.5512691140174866,
0.03876028209924698,
-0.9046916365623474,
-0.5335409641265869,
-0.14344942569732666,
-0.1513703167438507,
0.13595502078533173,
-0.40532201528549194,
0.10256560891866684,
0.1419946253299713,
0.19234442710876465,
-0.6508245468139648,
0.18982349336147308,
-0.5364308953285217,
-0.19108901917934418,
0.4495586156845093,
-0.05246991291642189,
0.5278192758560181,
-0.3553217053413391,
-0.4300570785999298,
0.2322809398174286,
-0.536614716053009,
-0.48841848969459534,
-0.16926272213459015,
0.38109496235847473,
-0.35405075550079346,
0.707677960395813,
0.03925478085875511,
0.8166409134864807,
-0.082332544028759,
-0.3427531123161316,
0.45900291204452515,
-0.14699959754943848,
-0.33954864740371704,
0.44535934925079346,
0.7327582836151123,
0.12077927589416504,
0.46521392464637756,
-0.09621088951826096,
-0.15488912165164948,
-0.1491629183292389,
0.0941401943564415,
-0.7682691216468811,
-0.2495364546775818,
0.16837462782859802,
-0.5690140128135681,
0.09909570217132568,
0.06891298294067383,
-0.5941575765609741,
-0.34984034299850464,
-0.6328084468841553,
0.36723026633262634,
-0.5000833868980408,
-0.4513046145439148,
0.2306450456380844,
0.03591974452137947,
0.2037230283021927,
0.15129119157791138,
-0.27568280696868896,
0.6449551582336426,
0.6130391955375671,
0.7508317232131958,
-0.17176131904125214,
-0.007214889861643314,
-0.7555030584335327,
-0.022707881405949593,
-0.016758982092142105,
0.7849023342132568,
-0.30199944972991943,
-0.30552777647972107,
-0.23866626620292664,
0.054660677909851074,
-0.15660686790943146,
-0.9253246188163757,
0.3654496967792511,
-0.3690757155418396,
0.185892716050148,
0.14526033401489258,
-0.6953195333480835,
-0.28671109676361084,
0.10687442868947983,
-0.8833088278770447,
0.49049222469329834,
0.14053656160831451,
-0.7766373157501221,
0.5625708699226379,
-0.6238630414009094,
-0.3324640691280365,
0.37433189153671265,
-0.5050307512283325,
-0.3025891184806824,
0.001762563013471663,
0.2881990373134613,
0.4247247278690338,
-0.4629836976528168,
0.41573190689086914,
0.3230443000793457,
0.005195744335651398,
0.22461988031864166,
-0.25702980160713196,
0.5322118997573853,
0.21752172708511353,
-0.04045930877327919,
0.2365715056657791,
-1.0104900598526,
0.040272217243909836,
0.19554400444030762,
-0.3286297917366028,
-0.4803599715232849,
-0.21060626208782196,
0.2560228705406189,
0.40902331471443176,
-0.10799789428710938,
-0.6712442636489868,
-0.023240989074110985,
-0.47134432196617126,
0.4875394105911255,
0.11282176524400711,
0.22645050287246704,
0.1908595710992813,
-0.18278098106384277,
0.45586106181144714,
0.31687131524086,
-0.09306944161653519,
-0.13971760869026184,
-0.44987401366233826,
-0.6983116865158081,
-0.5673226118087769,
0.6304618716239929,
0.855601966381073,
-0.8902513384819031,
0.20250265300273895,
-0.48742103576660156,
-0.5768436789512634,
-0.978762149810791,
-0.41000640392303467,
0.5269829034805298,
0.7933809757232666,
0.5111822485923767,
-0.16542363166809082,
-0.9139952063560486,
-0.9000540375709534,
-0.05777658149600029,
-0.20532427728176117,
0.0627218633890152,
0.5917685031890869,
0.442142516374588,
-0.7048398852348328,
0.6708168387413025,
-0.42130598425865173,
-0.492626816034317,
-0.3160492181777954,
-0.0879100114107132,
0.38917529582977295,
0.36534973978996277,
0.2787294089794159,
-0.9557645916938782,
-0.4618075489997864,
0.21161650121212006,
-0.7638847231864929,
-0.06381280720233917,
0.1415526121854782,
0.23257917165756226,
0.1959664225578308,
0.5496273636817932,
-0.5211176872253418,
0.4169355034828186,
0.6629084348678589,
-0.07578933238983154,
0.3162577152252197,
-0.3588924705982208,
0.12564145028591156,
-1.363667607307434,
0.01680930331349373,
-0.1356091946363449,
-0.35207200050354004,
-0.8191618323326111,
-0.4065621793270111,
-0.056310445070266724,
-0.2971782684326172,
-0.522260844707489,
0.7805534601211548,
-0.6654413342475891,
0.12936271727085114,
-0.26135164499282837,
-0.11467784643173218,
-0.09972331672906876,
-0.13045793771743774,
0.44839563965797424,
0.6202736496925354,
0.8432449102401733,
-0.8807032108306885,
0.39649587869644165,
0.43559762835502625,
-0.3191119134426117,
0.606187105178833,
-0.8770105838775635,
0.3127676844596863,
-0.3730846345424652,
0.011684409342706203,
-0.37199005484580994,
-0.21761882305145264,
0.2688591182231903,
-0.5681397318840027,
0.6666156053543091,
-0.3645232617855072,
-0.3296855092048645,
-0.36326470971107483,
0.6208785772323608,
0.34686076641082764,
0.17981939017772675,
-0.42767998576164246,
0.5796656012535095,
0.8624962568283081,
-0.32973504066467285,
-0.37901657819747925,
-0.61997389793396,
0.17338241636753082,
-0.29312244057655334,
-0.16597868502140045,
0.44901201128959656,
0.1611611396074295,
-0.17752157151699066,
-0.13505445420742035,
-0.07122282683849335,
-0.5634322762489319,
-0.43300962448120117,
0.2472672015428543,
0.25547173619270325,
-0.5866634845733643,
0.37735211849212646,
-0.22862452268600464,
-0.44770437479019165,
-0.1445818692445755,
-0.25196585059165955,
0.542493462562561,
-0.12463894486427307,
-0.21257080137729645,
-0.4488658905029297,
0.4847849905490875,
0.521296501159668,
-0.293552041053772,
0.5426603555679321,
0.46095964312553406,
-0.8851504325866699,
0.29445338249206543,
-0.5996134281158447,
-0.03020738624036312,
-0.34454572200775146,
0.5138822197914124,
-0.4269491732120514,
-0.8910139799118042,
0.11518504470586777,
-0.19591352343559265,
-0.26432880759239197,
0.3387816846370697,
0.3484056890010834,
0.21791186928749084,
0.7691237330436707,
0.6754142642021179,
-0.134735107421875,
0.21247272193431854,
0.0032692765817046165,
0.17840510606765747,
-0.6981590390205383,
-0.3381422758102417,
-0.520645022392273,
0.055605653673410416,
-0.9160091280937195,
-0.5034805536270142,
0.42809242010116577,
-0.23673756420612335,
-0.05336659029126167,
0.5573129653930664,
-0.7341249585151672,
0.1635422557592392,
0.37370970845222473,
0.08298562467098236,
0.19030028581619263,
-0.15620045363903046,
-0.05583750829100609,
-0.20944727957248688,
-0.5408838987350464,
-0.7095835208892822,
0.8874583840370178,
0.2722945213317871,
0.6587343811988831,
-0.17014175653457642,
1.1478939056396484,
-0.07283607870340347,
0.2830073833465576,
-0.8266215920448303,
0.4118671417236328,
-0.408463716506958,
-0.3995155692100525,
-0.229516863822937,
-0.5582476854324341,
-1.1747428178787231,
0.028172964230179787,
-0.23652131855487823,
-0.35548293590545654,
0.33032482862472534,
-0.1351626217365265,
-0.3555110991001129,
0.20225174725055695,
-0.5129836201667786,
0.6877430081367493,
-0.6815285682678223,
0.5554822087287903,
0.14972469210624695,
-0.7347831726074219,
-0.07199333608150482,
-0.09276089072227478,
0.22031603753566742,
-0.04821852967143059,
-0.16344869136810303,
0.7246875166893005,
-0.2156534641981125,
0.29976892471313477,
-0.16705311834812164,
0.13838978111743927,
0.09782357513904572,
-0.4263981282711029,
0.019960755482316017,
0.37642228603363037,
-0.20690813660621643,
0.4989183843135834,
-0.04790186509490013,
-0.1017199158668518,
-0.19673535227775574,
0.4271200895309448,
-0.6462415456771851,
-0.17819038033485413,
-0.6407880187034607,
-0.016597265377640724,
0.07782558351755142,
0.5800032615661621,
0.6872456669807434,
0.6117786169052124,
-0.6478137969970703,
0.0532851442694664,
0.7021920084953308,
-0.6241629719734192,
-0.022618409246206284,
0.7711374759674072,
-0.4102255702018738,
-0.8499646782875061,
0.9251527190208435,
0.25141942501068115,
-0.019778572022914886,
0.8812575340270996,
-0.02179613709449768,
-0.0900043472647667,
-0.44424980878829956,
-0.5163348317146301,
0.4220019578933716,
-0.5215739011764526,
-0.252533882856369,
-1.1504238843917847,
-0.7634177803993225,
-0.4496856927871704,
0.23727601766586304,
-0.4849430024623871,
-0.14961186051368713,
-0.5373762845993042,
-0.28974634408950806,
0.4293477237224579,
0.927437424659729,
-0.0026473221369087696,
0.2246784269809723,
-1.015027642250061,
0.600108802318573,
0.1503114104270935,
0.15538185834884644,
-0.43568190932273865,
-0.3160214126110077,
-0.12400852143764496,
-0.03849738463759422,
0.2670770287513733,
-1.0317180156707764,
0.9063162207603455,
0.4585036039352417,
0.5662949681282043,
0.41444987058639526,
-0.09445054084062576,
0.6903687715530396,
-0.738617479801178,
0.31695878505706787,
0.21141648292541504,
-0.5635800957679749,
0.7818973064422607,
0.05663203075528145,
0.28615954518318176,
0.573449969291687,
0.5948214530944824,
-0.7424013614654541,
0.05633968859910965,
-0.48113706707954407,
-0.9036404490470886,
0.5031673908233643,
-0.10228797048330307,
-0.08407098054885864,
-0.37896400690078735,
0.3063955008983612,
0.34783050417900085,
0.21770095825195312,
-0.42335474491119385,
-0.5874668955802917,
-0.10032007098197937,
-0.13193675875663757,
-0.3780372440814972,
-0.2723647654056549,
0.2437051236629486,
-0.3609951436519623,
0.4670928120613098,
0.11332102119922638,
0.5383680462837219,
0.5310257077217102,
-0.3412202298641205,
0.12802933156490326,
0.52708500623703,
0.5674216747283936,
0.418552964925766,
0.027502764016389847,
0.0798448771238327,
0.22234444320201874,
-0.648003339767456,
0.20428280532360077,
0.4286189675331116,
-0.14776431024074554,
0.6282707452774048,
0.12696343660354614,
1.0623713731765747,
0.33298736810684204,
-0.7013470530509949,
0.36330825090408325,
-0.38116395473480225,
0.032326534390449524,
-0.6447392702102661,
-0.22221136093139648,
-0.09821510314941406,
0.04828260838985443,
0.21144719421863556,
-0.0474676787853241,
0.3319401741027832,
-0.1937083899974823,
0.5545234680175781,
-0.0013234205543994904,
-0.8436294198036194,
-0.30845871567726135,
0.45849165320396423,
-0.0016824037302285433,
-0.5516173839569092,
0.9758166670799255,
0.20109374821186066,
-0.5523964762687683,
0.5716638565063477,
0.6583499908447266,
0.7747346758842468,
-0.4588920772075653,
0.2908918857574463,
0.6691089868545532,
0.27366986870765686,
0.11956071108579636,
0.6169599294662476,
0.3287699222564697,
-0.6030517816543579,
-0.2304617464542389,
-0.47977519035339355,
-0.43197357654571533,
0.15706564486026764,
-0.957904040813446,
0.5865312814712524,
-0.03927287831902504,
-0.511162519454956,
0.3209332823753357,
-0.26233553886413574,
-0.8663889169692993,
0.4440566897392273,
0.26642346382141113,
0.8442257642745972,
-0.39326420426368713,
0.9007559418678284,
1.0382109880447388,
-0.34875884652137756,
-0.7508965730667114,
-0.2055719941854477,
0.0007881874917075038,
-0.7737104296684265,
0.6914402842521667,
0.44706347584724426,
0.1361902505159378,
0.30648061633110046,
-0.22812852263450623,
-1.0504649877548218,
0.9271546006202698,
0.3331491947174072,
-0.6919149160385132,
-0.23106683790683746,
0.11801840364933014,
0.5149169564247131,
-0.5821805596351624,
0.24045032262802124,
0.4586598873138428,
0.3754826486110687,
-0.21068881452083588,
-1.233668327331543,
-0.31905660033226013,
-0.3602832555770874,
-0.24871070683002472,
0.4212416708469391,
-0.26487794518470764,
0.6966244578361511,
-0.5192720890045166,
-0.3735989034175873,
0.010454943403601646,
0.6919447779655457,
0.29121100902557373,
0.5128744840621948,
0.30535513162612915,
0.5408828258514404,
1.0404399633407593,
-0.11383399367332458,
0.9318143725395203,
-0.21479173004627228,
-0.10346636176109314,
1.3016964197158813,
-0.522249698638916,
0.8075600862503052,
0.3044668734073639,
0.17320992052555084,
0.3797188997268677,
0.471331924200058,
0.0796273872256279,
0.4918837547302246,
0.2505544424057007,
-0.29333773255348206,
0.08924663811922073,
-0.36140722036361694,
-0.5962903499603271,
0.8584405183792114,
0.43255162239074707,
-0.4763096272945404,
0.1318289339542389,
0.4611634314060211,
-0.04918612912297249,
-0.1392422467470169,
-0.23971311748027802,
1.279226303100586,
0.48520153760910034,
-0.4289481043815613,
0.45886239409446716,
-0.1539260447025299,
0.6699721217155457,
-0.5607021450996399,
-0.2943733036518097,
0.34192955493927,
0.1308201253414154,
-0.16315579414367676,
-0.4501667320728302,
0.25956401228904724,
-0.04652544856071472,
-0.2675027549266815,
0.016821254044771194,
0.9578492045402527,
-0.6184201240539551,
-0.35452505946159363,
0.5732434988021851,
0.6780284643173218,
0.5885592103004456,
-0.12450481206178665,
-0.4535687267780304,
-0.28788697719573975,
-0.3826948404312134,
0.10873652249574661,
0.11116623878479004,
0.5173994898796082,
0.0585719533264637,
0.5959593057632446,
0.5170890092849731,
0.41052401065826416,
0.08411393314599991,
0.30974239110946655,
0.5909348130226135,
-0.8194053769111633,
-0.3561672270298004,
-0.6913743019104004,
0.25970539450645447,
0.05111674219369888,
-0.4247196614742279,
0.420334130525589,
0.8590930104255676,
0.8060778379440308,
-0.14370429515838623,
0.6368906497955322,
0.13053350150585175,
0.8533613085746765,
-0.36797744035720825,
0.9834235906600952,
-0.42243891954421997,
-0.23708057403564453,
-0.3275800347328186,
-0.5080573558807373,
-0.3215884864330292,
0.445405513048172,
0.049874238669872284,
-0.05529916286468506,
0.5173909664154053,
0.5093608498573303,
0.2069419026374817,
-0.15691952407360077,
0.5230496525764465,
0.21643081307411194,
-0.03388315811753273,
0.5437636971473694,
0.6920554637908936,
-0.530002236366272,
0.30412590503692627,
-0.05545252561569214,
-0.037396177649497986,
-0.18927930295467377,
-0.60353684425354,
-0.547883927822113,
-0.5431915521621704,
-0.4335232377052307,
-0.2217174768447876,
0.11090333759784698,
1.149751901626587,
0.8964357376098633,
-0.965785801410675,
-0.02350243553519249,
0.19576704502105713,
0.05819597840309143,
-0.20764127373695374,
-0.13450248539447784,
0.2412606030702591,
0.4334433674812317,
-0.5782559514045715,
0.5859328508377075,
0.42288652062416077,
0.20106397569179535,
0.36996525526046753,
-0.28910893201828003,
-0.26864445209503174,
-0.11470282077789307,
0.6212875247001648,
0.3884817957878113,
-0.6742967367172241,
0.0020810298155993223,
0.29312601685523987,
-0.46447083353996277,
0.3141780197620392,
0.6960636377334595,
-0.8904847502708435,
0.5949373841285706,
0.2385876178741455,
0.5835764408111572,
0.32807379961013794,
-0.22919151186943054,
0.4700765013694763,
-0.41086530685424805,
-0.08690227568149567,
0.6055317521095276,
0.4483579397201538,
0.469088077545166,
-0.32517486810684204,
0.5242679119110107,
-0.0678924173116684,
-0.5648363828659058,
-0.8388539552688599,
0.08343496918678284,
-1.0188031196594238,
0.22345134615898132,
0.9841435551643372,
-0.02957575023174286,
0.11140173673629761,
-0.49204882979393005,
-0.4204546809196472,
0.7386782765388489,
-0.32287707924842834,
0.16431133449077606,
0.3886848986148834,
-0.1669994592666626,
-0.29475051164627075,
-0.6869154572486877,
0.2635611593723297,
-0.059863511472940445,
-1.0863174200057983,
-0.49346813559532166,
0.38074538111686707,
0.37198978662490845,
0.07003424316644669,
1.0549046993255615,
-0.28868886828422546,
0.3093220591545105,
-0.18595139682292938,
0.21435625851154327,
0.06823837757110596,
-0.5600855946540833,
-0.5564435720443726,
-0.09336750954389572,
0.014451835304498672,
-0.24143357574939728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13332v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13332v1 | How effective is Multi-source pivoting for Translation of Low Resource Indian Languages? | 2024-06-19T08:31:52 | 2024-06-19T08:31:52 | Pranav Gaikwad, Meet Doshi, Raj Dabre, Pushpak Bhattacharyya | cs.CL | cs.CL | Machine Translation (MT) between linguistically dissimilar languages is
challenging, especially due to the scarcity of parallel corpora. Prior works
suggest that pivoting through a high-resource language can help translation
into a related low-resource language. However, existing works tend to discard
the source sentence when pivoting. Taking the case of English to Indian
language MT, this paper explores the 'multi-source translation' approach with
pivoting, using both source and pivot sentences to improve translation. We
conducted extensive experiments with various multi-source techniques for
translating English to Konkani, Manipuri, Sanskrit, and Bodo, using Hindi,
Marathi, and Bengali as pivot languages. We find that multi-source pivoting
yields marginal improvements over the state-of-the-art, contrary to previous
claims, but these improvements can be enhanced with synthetic target language
data. We believe multi-source pivoting is a promising direction for
Low-resource translation. | [
-0.21538738906383514,
-0.48804014921188354,
0.4551413655281067,
0.301050066947937,
-0.6224440932273865,
0.33700302243232727,
-0.5309760570526123,
-0.2218889445066452,
0.15867270529270172,
0.241725891828537,
-0.47635534405708313,
-0.0006579884793609381,
-0.8224561214447021,
0.44373607635498047,
-0.55582594871521,
0.7412509918212891,
-0.07147865742444992,
0.2565782368183136,
0.16982288658618927,
-0.6539161205291748,
-0.8289746642112732,
-0.5813672542572021,
-0.16465170681476593,
0.07237517088651657,
0.48617973923683167,
0.6681637167930603,
0.8026218414306641,
0.5884590148925781,
0.8442872166633606,
0.2920166850090027,
0.17466162145137787,
0.5614801645278931,
-0.2510896325111389,
0.39248573780059814,
-0.2820647060871124,
-0.6103795170783997,
0.03255227580666542,
0.149532750248909,
0.7921169996261597,
0.6710978746414185,
-0.1737794578075409,
0.21848845481872559,
0.14542828500270844,
1.0472145080566406,
-0.7245442271232605,
0.029750075191259384,
-0.722178041934967,
-0.05659956857562065,
-0.8069189786911011,
-0.08838813006877899,
-0.5878942012786865,
-0.223853200674057,
-0.49338746070861816,
-0.20887798070907593,
-0.05808443948626518,
0.31084343791007996,
0.4020843803882599,
0.47875869274139404,
-0.418623685836792,
-0.24643251299858093,
-0.9945048093795776,
0.9699011445045471,
-0.4101756811141968,
0.31574922800064087,
0.2413276731967926,
0.6457421779632568,
0.21385575830936432,
-0.15612363815307617,
-0.40424683690071106,
0.11753416806459427,
-0.393390953540802,
-0.032444391399621964,
-0.0015245768008753657,
-0.7185527682304382,
0.063451386988163,
0.34510862827301025,
-0.29385805130004883,
-0.20021532475948334,
-0.8452098965644836,
0.028017040342092514,
0.3885786235332489,
-0.00861036404967308,
0.5837675929069519,
-0.32366281747817993,
-0.28449931740760803,
-0.32021385431289673,
-0.7775560617446899,
-0.19289915263652802,
0.11422670632600784,
1.0248345136642456,
-0.04749895632266998,
1.062321662902832,
0.010074452497065067,
0.8485879302024841,
-0.037418581545352936,
-0.0992526188492775,
0.2672703266143799,
-0.8407911658287048,
0.15377682447433472,
0.27929821610450745,
0.7163732647895813,
0.13732148706912994,
-0.0757494866847992,
-0.14343324303627014,
0.26017990708351135,
-0.16286510229110718,
0.08190637826919556,
-0.3908329904079437,
0.303970605134964,
-0.004647364839911461,
-0.5716926455497742,
0.2598011791706085,
-0.2778036296367645,
-0.7158008217811584,
-0.3257273733615875,
-0.2279115915298462,
-0.01781558245420456,
-0.7964345812797546,
-0.5047726035118103,
-0.5119106769561768,
0.13421517610549927,
0.44694584608078003,
0.11947896331548691,
-0.8662912845611572,
-0.14331753551959991,
0.645331859588623,
1.45078444480896,
-0.44402724504470825,
-0.5634152293205261,
-0.8281568288803101,
0.23074525594711304,
-0.3416242301464081,
1.0083341598510742,
-0.8084025382995605,
-0.429965078830719,
-0.16377420723438263,
-0.21130327880382538,
-0.23040151596069336,
-0.35020551085472107,
0.44925767183303833,
-0.2691114842891693,
0.2100505530834198,
-0.2916291058063507,
0.1936669647693634,
-0.12703250348567963,
0.1606743186712265,
-0.5642844438552856,
0.6396301984786987,
-0.0928981751203537,
-0.49317193031311035,
0.12201583385467529,
-0.7006492614746094,
-0.7496033906936646,
-0.07317085564136505,
0.05805210769176483,
-0.23721428215503693,
0.3408912122249603,
0.32393112778663635,
0.24756412208080292,
-0.4010854661464691,
-0.010116701014339924,
-0.18661965429782867,
-0.16490888595581055,
0.23703926801681519,
-0.6022831201553345,
0.8047738075256348,
0.617581307888031,
0.03661513328552246,
-0.06138166785240173,
-0.5245720744132996,
-0.027005204930901527,
0.08034143596887589,
-0.22683069109916687,
-0.6473755836486816,
-0.027972396463155746,
-0.04556075483560562,
0.5293891429901123,
-0.01360244583338499,
-0.45773178339004517,
0.42695164680480957,
-0.4786035120487213,
0.4655188322067261,
0.21771831810474396,
-0.1912728101015091,
0.9548320174217224,
0.03667794540524483,
0.22807200253009796,
0.08884084224700928,
-0.0953575149178505,
-0.18260230123996735,
-0.6254939436912537,
-0.41282179951667786,
-0.2427164763212204,
0.3178100883960724,
0.5149031281471252,
-1.027795672416687,
-0.4509558081626892,
-0.378377765417099,
-0.5609334707260132,
-1.1429378986358643,
0.36107495427131653,
0.489627867937088,
0.3384215533733368,
0.6410011053085327,
-0.07789919525384903,
-0.18655335903167725,
-0.9755805730819702,
-0.6168162822723389,
0.2407786250114441,
0.1885078102350235,
-0.39657554030418396,
-0.06338322162628174,
0.1032346561551094,
0.7460196018218994,
-0.41415083408355713,
-0.43814435601234436,
-0.391496479511261,
0.21411986649036407,
0.17470130324363708,
0.3994273841381073,
0.37408211827278137,
-1.091646432876587,
-1.1289199590682983,
0.12911419570446014,
-0.4628423750400543,
0.0627705380320549,
-0.1429845690727234,
-0.530097246170044,
0.41512057185173035,
0.3309503197669983,
-0.6472470760345459,
0.3184942305088043,
0.7958144545555115,
0.02082344889640808,
0.12529149651527405,
-0.32998785376548767,
0.4916672110557556,
-1.3131320476531982,
0.0566299632191658,
-0.22018222510814667,
-0.2259736955165863,
-0.5560159087181091,
0.08838904649019241,
0.09063814580440521,
-0.3984236419200897,
-0.8342128396034241,
0.3158787488937378,
-0.7319232225418091,
-0.17954498529434204,
-0.45742160081863403,
0.22711531817913055,
-0.3881712555885315,
0.3849434554576874,
-0.05958041176199913,
1.2054946422576904,
0.16095080971717834,
-0.3557262420654297,
0.24681389331817627,
0.353231817483902,
-0.03674433007836342,
0.9223631620407104,
-0.02799214981496334,
0.0871320590376854,
0.03385727480053902,
-0.30115944147109985,
-0.6349997520446777,
0.047578904777765274,
0.6430577635765076,
-0.49484574794769287,
0.39839106798171997,
-0.2994079887866974,
-0.5189697742462158,
0.11231783032417297,
-0.17031605541706085,
0.34976649284362793,
0.267330139875412,
-0.31586700677871704,
0.4848335087299347,
0.39429694414138794,
-0.4804304540157318,
-0.40351784229278564,
-1.0652174949645996,
0.23263749480247498,
-0.12014975398778915,
-0.34038180112838745,
0.1518631875514984,
-0.004776027053594589,
-0.41969215869903564,
0.2659798264503479,
-0.07708297669887543,
-0.2710135281085968,
-0.34422552585601807,
0.11058607697486877,
0.23148790001869202,
-0.04068111628293991,
0.12210243940353394,
0.1744648665189743,
-0.4141736328601837,
-0.48728400468826294,
-0.1520814597606659,
0.6132688522338867,
-0.2700672447681427,
-0.7076671123504639,
-0.06433801352977753,
0.8745390176773071,
0.7369934320449829,
-0.516706645488739,
0.9945796728134155,
0.6639753580093384,
-0.12338598817586899,
0.15189172327518463,
-0.38238394260406494,
0.09870778769254684,
-0.316911518573761,
0.24173837900161743,
-0.5373564958572388,
-0.3228369951248169,
0.04812806844711304,
-0.471284419298172,
-0.04746955633163452,
0.8192300796508789,
0.8999708294868469,
-0.12657618522644043,
0.9099306464195251,
0.7726921439170837,
-0.08206108212471008,
0.38585951924324036,
-0.12463147938251495,
0.6409847140312195,
-0.8707989454269409,
-0.01704706810414791,
-0.7274991273880005,
-0.3401228189468384,
-0.8450696468353271,
-0.6125776171684265,
0.46690529584884644,
0.06462500244379044,
0.282535582780838,
0.6564430594444275,
-0.7916104793548584,
0.44803810119628906,
0.8419153094291687,
-0.06090238317847252,
0.5750298500061035,
0.37112826108932495,
-0.03729891777038574,
-0.3326781392097473,
-0.7375043630599976,
-0.4662281572818756,
0.9046832919120789,
-0.28686589002609253,
0.1750376969575882,
0.27619102597236633,
0.5083591938018799,
0.20249424874782562,
0.6097280979156494,
-0.5639731884002686,
0.20228879153728485,
-0.4072362184524536,
-0.7615842223167419,
-0.6424018740653992,
-0.3564920723438263,
-0.7004258632659912,
0.7598960399627686,
-0.38561075925827026,
0.07152044773101807,
0.08831582963466644,
-0.02556227706372738,
-0.0882939025759697,
0.4662345349788666,
-1.1279866695404053,
0.6693270206451416,
-0.6224159002304077,
-0.368900328874588,
-0.6715550422668457,
-0.546897828578949,
0.3698089122772217,
-0.33088424801826477,
0.6574925780296326,
-0.2222958207130432,
0.029881512746214867,
0.16957351565361023,
-0.5863441228866577,
0.30073559284210205,
-0.10018865019083023,
0.3920515775680542,
0.26682382822036743,
0.03838583081960678,
0.1688319891691208,
-0.13715752959251404,
-0.27815595269203186,
0.41606900095939636,
-0.056276217103004456,
-0.7588661909103394,
-0.5152511596679688,
0.5629962682723999,
-0.6278571486473083,
-0.4699191153049469,
-0.7132183313369751,
-0.5841595530509949,
-0.2833550274372101,
0.42043712735176086,
0.23087957501411438,
-0.1263866424560547,
0.29564186930656433,
0.2731737494468689,
-0.01779981143772602,
-0.04538144916296005,
0.7480880618095398,
0.3859196901321411,
0.02937105856835842,
-0.4238903522491455,
0.9901032447814941,
0.22613206505775452,
0.24194160103797913,
0.4403352737426758,
0.11502862721681595,
-0.24140901863574982,
-0.5829586386680603,
-0.9305057525634766,
0.34446781873703003,
-0.3436901271343231,
-0.3668719530105591,
-0.11983150243759155,
-0.07749179750680923,
-0.20418721437454224,
-0.10950344800949097,
-0.802374005317688,
-0.47787952423095703,
0.2646554708480835,
0.39651429653167725,
0.21496237814426422,
0.41049009561538696,
-0.19146010279655457,
0.20761463046073914,
-1.2061519622802734,
0.23323170840740204,
0.16966357827186584,
0.2145635485649109,
-0.28090739250183105,
-0.35360339283943176,
-0.5326710939407349,
0.3376196026802063,
-0.29826679825782776,
-0.8953174352645874,
0.6917290687561035,
0.14554190635681152,
0.4319162368774414,
-0.1295342743396759,
0.08365736156702042,
0.7203348278999329,
-1.0252057313919067,
0.5874043107032776,
0.6219609975814819,
-0.7488278746604919,
0.5372099280357361,
0.014442174695432186,
0.3701532483100891,
0.669001042842865,
0.45255574584007263,
-0.7043424248695374,
-0.35670408606529236,
0.1277865618467331,
-0.7921426892280579,
0.6847160458564758,
0.36182790994644165,
0.17032183706760406,
0.28456223011016846,
0.11792636662721634,
0.2931528389453888,
0.31296804547309875,
-0.5278049111366272,
-0.2702820897102356,
-0.36959588527679443,
0.0043016159906983376,
-0.3798106014728546,
-0.007856089621782303,
0.01537228375673294,
-0.11371245980262756,
0.36648768186569214,
0.12397449463605881,
0.07375741004943848,
-0.012284228578209877,
-0.424285888671875,
-0.14890868961811066,
0.7180449366569519,
0.7369489073753357,
0.5991518497467041,
-0.06264214217662811,
0.1281544715166092,
0.16124291718006134,
-0.4225896894931793,
0.26069262623786926,
0.0013509596465155482,
-0.18027788400650024,
0.1995200216770172,
0.2714533805847168,
0.5951603651046753,
-0.0009162953938357532,
-0.16979002952575684,
0.27150213718414307,
0.14280785620212555,
0.3645326793193817,
0.06294648349285126,
-0.28009310364723206,
0.13061684370040894,
0.18963024020195007,
0.5172182321548462,
0.6816761493682861,
-0.17386597394943237,
-0.7036239504814148,
-0.2373458594083786,
0.3102181851863861,
0.004122654441744089,
-0.25159284472465515,
0.7064820528030396,
0.3290834128856659,
-0.6987395882606506,
0.7036229372024536,
-0.2666660249233246,
-0.335899293422699,
-0.14974336326122284,
0.3785237967967987,
0.643650472164154,
-0.3683392107486725,
0.12060728669166565,
0.3147523105144501,
0.5025192499160767,
-0.1892535388469696,
-0.14726342260837555,
0.005904541816562414,
-0.2564646005630493,
-0.8429686427116394,
-0.3757270574569702,
-0.7607145309448242,
-0.47928640246391296,
-0.49453142285346985,
0.38287222385406494,
0.19142505526542664,
-0.16863344609737396,
-0.22532354295253754,
-0.1449861079454422,
-0.550987184047699,
-0.43698862195014954,
0.15337111055850983,
0.5851588249206543,
-0.8602456450462341,
1.0375417470932007,
0.7393929958343506,
-0.8452234864234924,
-0.49399250745773315,
0.05312223732471466,
0.05998003110289574,
-0.7043293118476868,
0.8605871796607971,
-0.1726377308368683,
-0.30747270584106445,
-0.26542651653289795,
-0.37034621834754944,
-0.9823101758956909,
0.7222945690155029,
0.5692179799079895,
-0.5640884041786194,
0.06572460383176804,
0.6262125968933105,
0.5102488398551941,
-0.279676228761673,
-0.07272163778543472,
0.15987549722194672,
0.5376721024513245,
-0.01800931803882122,
-0.9854448437690735,
-0.18787403404712677,
-0.23240211606025696,
0.0666598454117775,
0.3792549669742584,
-0.8347047567367554,
0.9127196073532104,
-0.03390543907880783,
-0.3286227583885193,
-0.3783473074436188,
0.5042287111282349,
0.20510566234588623,
0.3826187551021576,
0.4117881953716278,
0.15425190329551697,
0.4013969302177429,
-0.05392013117671013,
1.0156795978546143,
-0.6410716772079468,
0.11165158450603485,
1.002938151359558,
-0.2305184006690979,
1.3484395742416382,
0.9521608948707581,
-0.29272592067718506,
0.3531249165534973,
0.1922309845685959,
0.24753187596797943,
0.869910717010498,
-0.26905345916748047,
0.13031946122646332,
-0.2154463678598404,
0.013167239725589752,
-0.43788382411003113,
0.6366384625434875,
0.25277280807495117,
0.15752123296260834,
-0.29023709893226624,
0.42705005407333374,
-0.0010075351456180215,
0.4089925289154053,
-0.20486150681972504,
0.4004735052585602,
0.15805472433567047,
-0.6739189624786377,
0.6201546788215637,
0.18082091212272644,
0.6149629950523376,
-0.3140217065811157,
-0.21896065771579742,
-0.4095250070095062,
0.04017798602581024,
-0.019968565553426743,
-0.5567584037780762,
1.2212022542953491,
0.29911693930625916,
-0.3834948241710663,
-0.8223133087158203,
0.6809590458869934,
-0.549710750579834,
-0.6466645002365112,
0.18915440142154694,
0.9245039224624634,
0.2169947624206543,
-0.2457471489906311,
-0.4639785885810852,
0.14308053255081177,
-0.14290127158164978,
0.2212699055671692,
0.5722196102142334,
0.32448136806488037,
-0.07683011144399643,
0.4841225743293762,
0.7961256504058838,
0.5639278888702393,
0.19919109344482422,
-0.519369900226593,
0.5518710613250732,
-0.5636864304542542,
-0.2515966594219208,
-0.8320691585540771,
0.563016414642334,
-0.23552991449832916,
0.07753876596689224,
0.8544012904167175,
0.6383170485496521,
0.9812159538269043,
-0.14261993765830994,
0.6565815806388855,
-0.08511506766080856,
0.8878551721572876,
-0.33224597573280334,
0.723846435546875,
-0.4753722548484802,
0.18442614376544952,
0.0446048229932785,
-1.1796141862869263,
-0.35445570945739746,
0.45837774872779846,
-0.4505992531776428,
-0.555185854434967,
0.9624500274658203,
0.38908064365386963,
-0.2179788202047348,
-0.41830480098724365,
0.2846415042877197,
-0.0051319655030965805,
0.08434685319662094,
0.3223545253276825,
0.5567463636398315,
-0.30825406312942505,
1.2910420894622803,
-0.3437053859233856,
-0.24231913685798645,
-0.09116800874471664,
-0.6916388273239136,
-0.30696412920951843,
-0.7565831542015076,
-0.03417143225669861,
-0.19396314024925232,
-0.1832652986049652,
0.9030492901802063,
0.7169191837310791,
-1.0378648042678833,
-0.24843384325504303,
0.4241904318332672,
0.3713374137878418,
-0.42300426959991455,
-0.08119603246450424,
0.3721890449523926,
-0.5632919669151306,
-1.098504662513733,
0.5900897979736328,
0.7046226859092712,
-0.35647866129875183,
-0.2768333852291107,
-0.00602627731859684,
-0.5338514447212219,
-0.2412256896495819,
0.9006326794624329,
0.41683098673820496,
-0.5647630095481873,
0.01858985610306263,
0.08393796533346176,
-0.40471339225769043,
0.3035307824611664,
0.9613732695579529,
-0.4247731864452362,
0.45995447039604187,
0.4411828815937042,
0.7475184202194214,
0.5039692521095276,
0.05457097291946411,
0.4486830234527588,
-0.6178275942802429,
0.36528611183166504,
-0.08752091228961945,
0.16572102904319763,
0.6329212188720703,
-0.14403663575649261,
0.6253485679626465,
0.39417582750320435,
-0.26609137654304504,
-0.8150320053100586,
0.13997019827365875,
-0.6134613156318665,
-0.3341854214668274,
1.022046685218811,
0.21893619000911713,
-0.2721967399120331,
0.05553737282752991,
-0.37103012204170227,
0.4828309118747711,
-0.14883795380592346,
0.6639089584350586,
0.7860042452812195,
-0.2910631000995636,
-0.26646095514297485,
-0.6375377774238586,
0.10325071960687637,
0.3177758455276489,
-0.6663073301315308,
0.02503850869834423,
0.2934373915195465,
-0.11852551996707916,
0.7611351013183594,
0.5338226556777954,
-0.28061047196388245,
-0.23723259568214417,
-0.040296658873558044,
-0.14558985829353333,
-0.128628671169281,
-0.13599304854869843,
-0.36936572194099426,
0.2529987394809723,
0.048593226820230484,
-0.6246687173843384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13331v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13331v1 | Improving Zero-shot LLM Re-Ranker with Risk Minimization | 2024-06-19T08:29:54 | 2024-06-19T08:29:54 | Xiaowei Yuan, Zhao Yang, Yequan Wang, Jun Zhao, Kang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) system, advanced Large Language
Models (LLMs) have emerged as effective Query Likelihood Models (QLMs) in an
unsupervised way, which re-rank documents based on the probability of
generating the query given the content of a document. However, directly
prompting LLMs to approximate QLMs inherently is biased, where the estimated
distribution might diverge from the actual document-specific distribution. In
this study, we introduce a novel framework, $\mathrm{UR^3}$, which leverages
Bayesian decision theory to both quantify and mitigate this estimation bias.
Specifically, $\mathrm{UR^3}$ reformulates the problem as maximizing the
probability of document generation, thereby harmonizing the optimization of
query and document generation probabilities under a unified risk minimization
objective. Our empirical results indicate that $\mathrm{UR^3}$ significantly
enhances re-ranking, particularly in improving the Top-1 accuracy. It benefits
the QA tasks by achieving higher accuracy with fewer input documents. | [
0.022233393043279648,
-0.5563318729400635,
0.7751922607421875,
-0.11357809603214264,
-0.25832271575927734,
0.08478028327226639,
0.16963790357112885,
0.06911332160234451,
0.10209426283836365,
0.6132562160491943,
-0.25705665349960327,
-0.7869825959205627,
-0.5431588292121887,
-0.12006529420614243,
-0.1784561276435852,
1.006557822227478,
0.28767579793930054,
-0.09488430619239807,
-0.09688284993171692,
-0.03944297879934311,
-0.139449343085289,
-0.2926159203052521,
-0.7111296057701111,
-0.23671330511569977,
0.8987160921096802,
0.49295905232429504,
0.8547238707542419,
0.4850894510746002,
0.6481645703315735,
0.13488708436489105,
0.06431106477975845,
-0.12476959824562073,
-0.6865603923797607,
0.5227435231208801,
-0.03580265864729881,
-0.7848495244979858,
-0.4444025754928589,
0.09049680829048157,
0.8680180311203003,
0.7573719620704651,
-0.26109007000923157,
0.0779341533780098,
-0.03996967896819115,
0.8853155970573425,
-1.1122061014175415,
-0.2761099636554718,
-0.6872027516365051,
-0.11397777497768402,
-0.4099435806274414,
-0.4931095540523529,
-0.5446922183036804,
-0.40377184748649597,
-0.180342435836792,
-0.5089530944824219,
0.42014092206954956,
0.08956863731145859,
0.7544307112693787,
0.16115404665470123,
-0.4949965178966522,
0.6727604269981384,
-0.7885038256645203,
0.8835774660110474,
-0.6110360622406006,
0.44925615191459656,
0.3028462529182434,
0.3208325505256653,
-0.5461366772651672,
-0.2048964947462082,
-0.25825732946395874,
0.10416018217802048,
0.32817342877388,
0.3287200331687927,
-0.32217249274253845,
0.08885396271944046,
0.14339378476142883,
0.14564724266529083,
-0.5831066370010376,
0.20682722330093384,
-0.2022080421447754,
-0.07202018052339554,
0.7300933003425598,
0.016350192949175835,
0.08507967740297318,
-0.08427908271551132,
-0.10955847799777985,
-0.2002457231283188,
-0.9764366149902344,
-0.27359309792518616,
0.5468279123306274,
0.12710922956466675,
0.3938407003879547,
0.5712559819221497,
-0.4741966426372528,
0.7332117557525635,
-0.056019559502601624,
-0.3243490755558014,
0.10368797928094864,
0.04762456193566322,
-0.3099703788757324,
-0.33407333493232727,
0.683855414390564,
0.4384496510028839,
-0.12980523705482483,
-0.17977257072925568,
-0.12040497362613678,
-0.2742272615432739,
0.6433275938034058,
-0.6567198038101196,
-0.004449041560292244,
0.2808194160461426,
-0.3196718990802765,
-0.5848037004470825,
0.23140913248062134,
-0.6350887417793274,
-0.3200661838054657,
0.1490330994129181,
0.6228362321853638,
-0.23626142740249634,
0.04086117073893547,
0.13139796257019043,
-0.048449158668518066,
0.2157900035381317,
0.42072492837905884,
-0.5473178029060364,
-0.01980861835181713,
0.4370645582675934,
0.566839337348938,
-0.2229522317647934,
-0.08785679936408997,
-0.6969426274299622,
0.5967909097671509,
-0.6375396251678467,
1.1521379947662354,
-0.23717935383319855,
-0.639643669128418,
0.06036917492747307,
-0.32356637716293335,
0.08267206698656082,
-0.4362556040287018,
0.7763252854347229,
-0.6961278319358826,
0.3217355012893677,
0.15611815452575684,
-0.41841262578964233,
0.004863739013671875,
0.16674207150936127,
-0.6382067799568176,
1.0053235292434692,
0.20143383741378784,
-0.6278751492500305,
0.6306676268577576,
-0.3193560838699341,
-0.20679430663585663,
0.0649959146976471,
-0.16259120404720306,
-0.6670444011688232,
0.361465185880661,
0.3484285771846771,
0.27027931809425354,
-0.38892051577568054,
0.09994449466466904,
-0.3549033999443054,
-0.521307647228241,
0.08585911244153976,
-0.44557419419288635,
0.4591677486896515,
0.2134890854358673,
-0.21095901727676392,
0.09498313814401627,
-0.6912345290184021,
0.16778871417045593,
0.08390950411558151,
-0.6896979212760925,
-0.43046820163726807,
-0.05370182916522026,
-0.20178107917308807,
-0.26503461599349976,
0.08148552477359772,
-0.6796144247055054,
0.3385116159915924,
-0.42133206129074097,
-0.35788822174072266,
0.5504067540168762,
0.40176138281822205,
0.7546462416648865,
-0.4598707854747772,
0.5529516935348511,
-0.17565317451953888,
0.38985776901245117,
0.1972135603427887,
-0.5571861863136292,
-0.8039326071739197,
-0.396145224571228,
0.49118539690971375,
0.5295607447624207,
-0.544120728969574,
0.2485710233449936,
-0.3624657988548279,
-0.48406702280044556,
-0.6183338165283203,
0.18206949532032013,
0.36120399832725525,
0.22833774983882904,
0.31207990646362305,
-0.06421134620904922,
-0.13132280111312866,
-0.8887526988983154,
-0.4462721049785614,
-0.391656756401062,
-0.38539549708366394,
0.0817563459277153,
-0.18374578654766083,
-0.2012726217508316,
0.8045670390129089,
-0.7011703252792358,
-0.484639972448349,
-0.4375968277454376,
0.36839208006858826,
0.33760955929756165,
0.4426816701889038,
0.27955177426338196,
-0.6579219698905945,
-0.2955397367477417,
-0.3435158431529999,
-0.5273049473762512,
-0.4002714157104492,
-0.062008149921894073,
-0.5342149138450623,
0.5792226195335388,
0.32820501923561096,
-0.48417413234710693,
0.6775313019752502,
-0.01827520877122879,
-0.09039226174354553,
0.2341393679380417,
-0.28930097818374634,
0.20152732729911804,
-1.0028976202011108,
-0.08369874209165573,
0.11806858330965042,
-0.06688138097524643,
-0.5502225160598755,
0.32711341977119446,
0.1312912404537201,
-0.052247095853090286,
-0.41084152460098267,
0.6057417392730713,
-0.4998593330383301,
-0.15637153387069702,
-0.4960152208805084,
0.3429187834262848,
0.08649414032697678,
0.2642916142940521,
-0.10908007621765137,
0.4824516177177429,
0.32446911931037903,
-0.35661372542381287,
-0.2672003507614136,
0.08855848014354706,
-0.17262962460517883,
0.6892998814582825,
-0.42994511127471924,
-0.201677605509758,
-0.29655593633651733,
0.24315957725048065,
-0.9448942542076111,
-0.017324507236480713,
0.04820777475833893,
-0.5687599182128906,
0.6047049760818481,
-0.3382164239883423,
-0.4467346966266632,
-0.32085078954696655,
-0.7461616396903992,
0.2851366698741913,
0.49658259749412537,
-0.3218177855014801,
0.3510374128818512,
0.3699060082435608,
-0.16521301865577698,
-0.750817596912384,
-0.37726354598999023,
-0.03851144760847092,
-0.0414922796189785,
-0.39238986372947693,
0.48590371012687683,
0.031467538326978683,
-0.16621610522270203,
-0.11319540441036224,
-0.3639010787010193,
0.14095312356948853,
0.10775300860404968,
0.2208276391029358,
0.4049462378025055,
0.10663018375635147,
0.04474777355790138,
0.1833065152168274,
-0.405015766620636,
-0.2552720010280609,
-0.16394975781440735,
0.14012856781482697,
0.323093980550766,
-0.5527013540267944,
-0.3569246530532837,
0.31171682476997375,
0.39603525400161743,
0.09045234322547913,
0.4824957549571991,
0.4893207550048828,
-0.10965142399072647,
-0.08007995039224625,
-0.9204882979393005,
-0.040664900094270706,
-0.3565133512020111,
0.09449918568134308,
-0.3328712582588196,
-0.9041207432746887,
0.23383010923862457,
0.1585332602262497,
0.12237337231636047,
0.5197276473045349,
0.3982105255126953,
-0.2622632682323456,
1.174905776977539,
0.7685997486114502,
-0.2308674305677414,
0.4020795524120331,
-0.2991519868373871,
0.2848415970802307,
-1.1437464952468872,
-0.25065284967422485,
-0.6564731597900391,
-0.22285906970500946,
-0.8874862790107727,
-0.6160905361175537,
0.6309219598770142,
0.399659126996994,
-0.3211292326450348,
0.040781062096357346,
-0.41171374917030334,
0.33997055888175964,
0.826717734336853,
0.009807473048567772,
0.2924022078514099,
0.2842031419277191,
-0.3444228172302246,
0.05487867444753647,
-0.7976234555244446,
-0.34938710927963257,
1.507234811782837,
0.16865825653076172,
1.126907467842102,
0.4960901141166687,
1.2172493934631348,
0.26760876178741455,
0.4156303405761719,
-0.5260151624679565,
0.36225348711013794,
0.07301540672779083,
-0.46565359830856323,
-0.42677241563796997,
-0.4983414113521576,
-1.1379778385162354,
0.6020877957344055,
-0.38203153014183044,
-0.7282392382621765,
0.3005603551864624,
-0.15015381574630737,
-0.5978584885597229,
0.25950077176094055,
-0.15636977553367615,
0.47219425439834595,
0.03342996537685394,
-0.6960210204124451,
-0.018072882667183876,
-0.3097032904624939,
0.33157747983932495,
-0.08885089308023453,
0.13709309697151184,
-0.2409532219171524,
-0.39407217502593994,
0.6754809617996216,
-0.2533557713031769,
0.44840824604034424,
-0.10175976157188416,
-0.15622694790363312,
0.20296671986579895,
0.3647320568561554,
0.5191004276275635,
0.3613473176956177,
-0.3480497896671295,
-0.093610979616642,
-0.10108235478401184,
-0.626122772693634,
-0.6613475680351257,
0.8089263439178467,
-0.7830305099487305,
-1.0268665552139282,
-0.5349172949790955,
-0.5295435190200806,
-0.34370705485343933,
0.28129586577415466,
0.19561196863651276,
0.1789645403623581,
-0.1362731009721756,
0.20687492191791534,
0.563129186630249,
-0.3066321015357971,
0.22727909684181213,
0.9764038920402527,
-0.33062946796417236,
-0.49562427401542664,
0.7986989617347717,
0.06956862658262253,
0.0915505439043045,
0.672924280166626,
0.022664466872811317,
-0.4114643335342407,
-0.8163463473320007,
-0.29223790764808655,
0.38069403171539307,
-0.4766096770763397,
-0.5916134119033813,
-0.8286105990409851,
-0.1828160136938095,
-0.5472829341888428,
-0.2866789698600769,
-0.004038392100483179,
-0.5468912124633789,
-0.2890259623527527,
-0.20377317070960999,
0.141376793384552,
0.5893039107322693,
-0.2770597040653229,
0.5475069284439087,
-0.7580092549324036,
0.4118969738483429,
0.2931758165359497,
0.47450271248817444,
-0.35439759492874146,
-0.7315362095832825,
-0.08159562200307846,
-0.199674591422081,
-0.5275065898895264,
-0.8323014378547668,
0.46341148018836975,
-0.051239918917417526,
1.0131014585494995,
0.2823662757873535,
0.08974237740039825,
0.28028735518455505,
-0.3627966642379761,
0.6045590043067932,
-0.009591246023774147,
-0.46321287751197815,
0.7822608947753906,
-0.6395800113677979,
0.4134746491909027,
0.7481125593185425,
0.40986743569374084,
-0.041194118559360504,
-0.6938415765762329,
-0.7564242482185364,
-0.9217669367790222,
0.5545855164527893,
0.29479414224624634,
0.025384625419974327,
-0.24335196614265442,
0.5218394994735718,
-0.15352511405944824,
0.0265666451305151,
-0.6375311017036438,
-0.22159023582935333,
0.17556221783161163,
0.00036075414391234517,
0.09792811423540115,
-0.7236988544464111,
0.06488533318042755,
0.021448755636811256,
0.9998592138290405,
-0.14781658351421356,
0.2054169923067093,
0.14218096435070038,
-0.0863627940416336,
-0.3636360466480255,
0.4411248564720154,
0.4947015047073364,
0.4608282148838043,
-0.8428272008895874,
0.06056860461831093,
-0.10046715289354324,
-0.3696690499782562,
0.39469999074935913,
0.11077150702476501,
-0.5481284856796265,
0.020979616791009903,
0.14160498976707458,
0.4231012761592865,
0.4394668638706207,
-0.22874949872493744,
0.4999408423900604,
0.007952120155096054,
-0.12757286429405212,
0.04804430156946182,
0.15870141983032227,
-0.21579641103744507,
0.19405597448349,
0.7945472002029419,
-0.19147871434688568,
0.2561625838279724,
-0.29088160395622253,
0.3577289581298828,
0.603898286819458,
-0.29344990849494934,
0.18732336163520813,
0.7082920074462891,
0.20257876813411713,
-0.14846208691596985,
0.30761203169822693,
-0.19922654330730438,
-0.2029571533203125,
0.16508226096630096,
0.6390874981880188,
0.9140570163726807,
-0.24335092306137085,
0.3861265182495117,
0.5146116614341736,
0.29703038930892944,
-0.19362638890743256,
0.38222265243530273,
0.12817490100860596,
-0.6435887813568115,
-0.2112436592578888,
-0.928974449634552,
-0.4477809965610504,
0.04062153771519661,
-0.6431341171264648,
0.14425303041934967,
-0.3652978241443634,
-0.30587196350097656,
-0.2115204930305481,
0.15006129443645477,
-0.4318508803844452,
0.10864719748497009,
-0.08934994041919708,
0.6985942721366882,
-0.3081802427768707,
0.7379252910614014,
0.42643165588378906,
-0.6812317967414856,
-0.47064775228500366,
0.22298620641231537,
0.0075417133048176765,
-0.5969653725624084,
0.6364229917526245,
-0.2166328728199005,
-0.15722601115703583,
0.2975021302700043,
-0.21002782881259918,
-1.193578839302063,
1.2607110738754272,
0.28889986872673035,
-0.46247875690460205,
0.1845988929271698,
-0.01600578799843788,
0.2736157178878784,
-0.2580873668193817,
0.3426930010318756,
0.4448010325431824,
0.24421817064285278,
0.021098358556628227,
-0.3905130624771118,
-0.10347963869571686,
-0.04268433153629303,
0.3861340880393982,
0.4484976530075073,
-0.28767073154449463,
0.4904364347457886,
-0.4812406599521637,
-0.34050530195236206,
0.2595282793045044,
0.5702276229858398,
0.6176311373710632,
0.02575470320880413,
0.19736593961715698,
0.8254976868629456,
0.4575761556625366,
-0.06059132143855095,
1.298026442527771,
-0.0777229517698288,
0.22925540804862976,
1.1356016397476196,
-0.40995484590530396,
1.0877954959869385,
0.31643497943878174,
-0.3616122305393219,
0.5333383679389954,
0.48189839720726013,
0.038747627288103104,
0.5028111338615417,
0.3158588707447052,
-0.37935179471969604,
-0.34498316049575806,
-0.09531445056200027,
-0.18357422947883606,
0.2894901633262634,
0.0009597336174920201,
-0.20935122668743134,
-0.5158353447914124,
-0.24939687550067902,
0.028671804815530777,
-0.01161929965019226,
-0.17401960492134094,
0.8813192844390869,
-0.1891029179096222,
-0.5449168682098389,
0.5161753296852112,
0.13534903526306152,
0.6666517853736877,
-0.30242982506752014,
0.09269271790981293,
-0.7793165445327759,
-0.02808968909084797,
-0.047996360808610916,
-0.744331955909729,
0.01554455328732729,
-0.05194570869207382,
-0.34574684500694275,
-0.06041785329580307,
0.8335467576980591,
-0.25502482056617737,
-0.8178989291191101,
0.125551238656044,
0.7437207698822021,
0.22270889580249786,
-0.2432604730129242,
-0.5537331700325012,
0.1226801797747612,
-0.18971848487854004,
-0.38962990045547485,
0.6428617835044861,
0.2593463361263275,
-0.23636358976364136,
0.6955001354217529,
0.8315103054046631,
0.24096426367759705,
-0.09714693576097488,
0.47372791171073914,
0.5053737163543701,
-0.6950417757034302,
-0.17633482813835144,
-0.5567755103111267,
0.30415818095207214,
-0.10294069349765778,
0.1235024556517601,
0.775397539138794,
0.5984259247779846,
0.6638755202293396,
0.09647063910961151,
0.7155050039291382,
0.3095035254955292,
0.6910153031349182,
-0.3165963590145111,
0.9113253355026245,
-0.8148281574249268,
0.40320196747779846,
-0.27136117219924927,
-1.1667996644973755,
-0.8564292788505554,
0.4791068732738495,
-0.2438426911830902,
-0.005380029324442148,
0.48159104585647583,
0.9256594777107239,
0.2872990667819977,
-0.6026890873908997,
0.7828163504600525,
-0.15415240824222565,
0.2884281873703003,
0.39562827348709106,
0.5225275158882141,
-0.6754636168479919,
0.5618188977241516,
-0.2679915428161621,
-0.2737216353416443,
-0.484588086605072,
-0.7930654287338257,
-0.5063150525093079,
-0.15857712924480438,
-0.319257915019989,
-0.11268053203821182,
0.2035166621208191,
0.4756501317024231,
0.5248183012008667,
-0.47562506794929504,
-0.10793239623308182,
0.12039437144994736,
0.5169731378555298,
0.043573036789894104,
-0.24403780698776245,
0.2807353436946869,
-0.5767119526863098,
-0.5663175582885742,
0.4242170453071594,
0.6199589967727661,
0.11590901762247086,
-0.22898606956005096,
0.09329309314489365,
-0.4811980128288269,
0.26585641503334045,
0.6096998453140259,
0.2098405510187149,
-0.781464695930481,
-0.27579572796821594,
-0.10428432375192642,
-0.24406293034553528,
-0.03625411540269852,
0.5800983905792236,
-0.8670884370803833,
0.3629595637321472,
0.47939178347587585,
0.47974106669425964,
0.34766608476638794,
0.172439843416214,
0.719439685344696,
-0.7054567933082581,
-0.08729066699743271,
0.07918880134820938,
0.2966245412826538,
0.35504886507987976,
-0.4621426463127136,
0.9502151608467102,
0.18752963840961456,
-0.5994468331336975,
-0.7753591537475586,
0.1546451300382614,
-0.9164009094238281,
-0.28455209732055664,
1.2989107370376587,
0.09011546522378922,
-0.16155587136745453,
0.018822846934199333,
-0.10493625700473785,
0.2997288703918457,
-0.4546026885509491,
0.7417207360267639,
0.11976339668035507,
-0.35955652594566345,
-0.2789269685745239,
-0.6827141046524048,
0.44770634174346924,
0.6249608397483826,
-0.7015480399131775,
-0.13123954832553864,
0.6594973802566528,
0.4531017541885376,
0.17360585927963257,
0.803195059299469,
-0.36395731568336487,
0.4013161063194275,
-0.29046913981437683,
0.23374970257282257,
0.08791212737560272,
-0.3489266633987427,
-0.34103724360466003,
0.272758811712265,
0.3884531259536743,
-0.12642699480056763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13282v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13282v1 | Understanding the RoPE Extensions of Long-Context LLMs: An Attention Perspective | 2024-06-19T07:23:33 | 2024-06-19T07:23:33 | Meizhi Zhong, Chen Zhang, Yikun Lei, Xikai Liu, Yan Gao, Yao Hu, Kehai Chen, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Enabling LLMs to handle lengthy context is currently a research hotspot. Most
LLMs are built upon rotary position embedding (RoPE), a popular position
encoding method. Therefore, a prominent path is to extrapolate the RoPE trained
on comparably short texts to far longer texts. A heavy bunch of efforts have
been dedicated to boosting the extrapolation via extending the formulations of
the RoPE, however, few of them have attempted to showcase their inner workings
comprehensively. In this paper, we are driven to offer a straightforward yet
in-depth understanding of RoPE extensions from an attention perspective and on
two benchmarking tasks. A broad array of experiments reveals several valuable
findings: 1) Maintaining attention patterns to those at the pretrained length
improves extrapolation; 2) Large attention uncertainty leads to retrieval
errors; 3) Using longer continual pretraining lengths for RoPE extensions could
reduce attention uncertainty and significantly enhance extrapolation. | [
-0.4976312220096588,
-0.6048640608787537,
0.5367969274520874,
0.13170473277568817,
-0.5588383674621582,
0.07257867604494095,
-0.363824725151062,
-0.8329964280128479,
0.3807883560657501,
0.40505659580230713,
-0.4751395881175995,
-0.2960823178291321,
-0.7298558354377747,
0.010524221695959568,
-0.5958414673805237,
1.2456419467926025,
-0.19117315113544464,
-0.49225470423698425,
-0.22431570291519165,
-0.4353369474411011,
-0.33729398250579834,
-0.6996840238571167,
-0.361252099275589,
-0.2562485635280609,
0.8504952788352966,
0.15924756228923798,
0.5551334023475647,
0.7066987156867981,
0.5971019268035889,
0.179382786154747,
-0.17971739172935486,
0.21280160546302795,
-0.6687684655189514,
-0.003651347942650318,
-0.11914518475532532,
-0.5064891576766968,
-0.5926626920700073,
0.1321610063314438,
0.7795664668083191,
0.7541312575340271,
0.15601640939712524,
0.3033486008644104,
0.38751187920570374,
1.0182931423187256,
-0.7597413659095764,
-0.11769585311412811,
-0.3055262863636017,
0.24847863614559174,
-0.15681549906730652,
-0.384818434715271,
-0.18567492067813873,
-0.17725898325443268,
0.6111672520637512,
-0.41660434007644653,
0.11805707961320877,
0.12171538919210434,
0.6683726906776428,
0.34367817640304565,
-0.8665910959243774,
-0.29810068011283875,
-0.6715224385261536,
0.9262530207633972,
-0.29854127764701843,
0.4622642397880554,
0.2506796717643738,
0.26085352897644043,
-0.03523746132850647,
-0.820443868637085,
0.025273680686950684,
-0.19060179591178894,
-0.14360854029655457,
0.2793462574481964,
0.5283833742141724,
0.2040742188692093,
0.5564876794815063,
0.26710259914398193,
-0.12384291738271713,
0.020213039591908455,
-0.4757635295391083,
0.370106041431427,
0.8505944609642029,
-0.07097979635000229,
-0.2414758950471878,
0.18683305382728577,
-0.754372239112854,
0.01685265079140663,
-0.9038423299789429,
0.32566186785697937,
0.1855366975069046,
-0.35548046231269836,
-0.07820577174425125,
0.4254545569419861,
-0.12166991829872131,
0.8618896007537842,
0.01142959389835596,
0.1616339087486267,
0.05360660329461098,
0.15511618554592133,
-0.154360830783844,
0.176151305437088,
0.206432044506073,
0.6598649621009827,
0.46103551983833313,
-0.10501658171415329,
-0.09809793531894684,
-0.5247029662132263,
0.4215927720069885,
-0.34326499700546265,
0.11566980928182602,
0.15400086343288422,
-0.2813488245010376,
0.03671048581600189,
0.10535120964050293,
-0.48523658514022827,
-0.15550555288791656,
-0.6241927742958069,
0.186479389667511,
-0.23333090543746948,
0.2435995191335678,
0.2613964080810547,
-0.07946080714464188,
0.5172619223594666,
0.4077167212963104,
-0.6721504926681519,
0.10488419234752655,
0.9494947791099548,
0.7524068355560303,
-0.6571053266525269,
-0.3191778361797333,
-0.706312894821167,
0.6727345585823059,
-0.24918103218078613,
0.7233261466026306,
-0.2530178725719452,
-0.13702331483364105,
0.107094407081604,
0.2463211864233017,
0.10324323177337646,
-0.24850790202617645,
0.8373279571533203,
-0.920197069644928,
0.07872867584228516,
0.03527846187353134,
-0.7858171463012695,
-0.40454763174057007,
0.4480709731578827,
-0.5926488637924194,
1.0489599704742432,
0.10258177667856216,
-0.4970005750656128,
0.22789539396762848,
-0.4502832293510437,
-0.4935464859008789,
-0.24363330006599426,
-0.06964283436536789,
-0.13626958429813385,
0.5541943311691284,
0.20210708677768707,
0.4241528809070587,
-0.3032976984977722,
0.04931196942925453,
-0.3461601436138153,
-0.5226211547851562,
0.5195397734642029,
-0.31067660450935364,
0.13892044126987457,
-0.18252693116664886,
-0.10250770300626755,
-0.03492750599980354,
-0.4382476210594177,
0.20113445818424225,
-0.4802336096763611,
-0.4194613993167877,
-0.469159871339798,
-0.10157143324613571,
-0.05004261061549187,
0.29456204175949097,
0.09200683981180191,
-0.18871428072452545,
0.13082437217235565,
-0.5532158017158508,
0.3194524347782135,
0.7002779841423035,
-0.1416061818599701,
0.35153037309646606,
-0.3285287320613861,
0.6823999881744385,
-0.1738882213830948,
0.060944814234972,
-0.37054163217544556,
-0.09464435279369354,
-0.8490835428237915,
-0.006045544520020485,
0.33568137884140015,
0.17981061339378357,
-0.4944796860218048,
0.3796292543411255,
-0.6675710082054138,
-0.18124090135097504,
-0.2525005638599396,
0.16597317159175873,
0.3653169274330139,
0.23680812120437622,
0.5392497777938843,
-0.4994860887527466,
-0.47758352756500244,
-0.8027285933494568,
-0.595058262348175,
0.2864381968975067,
-0.2766616940498352,
0.1953468918800354,
0.43789908289909363,
0.028843015432357788,
1.1212764978408813,
-0.6920117139816284,
-0.4107285737991333,
-0.03946741670370102,
-0.21834680438041687,
0.45248568058013916,
0.5056742429733276,
0.24086381494998932,
-0.8561999797821045,
-0.6524918079376221,
-0.06905148923397064,
-0.7660439610481262,
0.435355544090271,
-0.4717826247215271,
-0.07762312144041061,
-0.0893642008304596,
0.6992552876472473,
-0.5606440305709839,
0.5411441922187805,
0.49602657556533813,
0.2531299889087677,
0.671428382396698,
-0.2341318130493164,
-0.27669820189476013,
-0.6633263826370239,
-0.03939495235681534,
0.06961428374052048,
-0.46683910489082336,
-0.46956315636634827,
0.2588813006877899,
0.2895103394985199,
0.20357182621955872,
-0.4895322024822235,
0.43558576703071594,
-0.9394543170928955,
-0.588534414768219,
-0.4531223177909851,
0.5871376395225525,
0.11504922807216644,
0.767703115940094,
0.08255098760128021,
0.5042641162872314,
0.43286529183387756,
-0.7058271169662476,
0.5855122208595276,
0.16073907911777496,
-0.526603102684021,
0.49886542558670044,
-0.996826708316803,
0.3770359754562378,
-0.03271687403321266,
0.45090600848197937,
-0.8454247713088989,
-0.23293043673038483,
-0.10184258967638016,
-0.4062212109565735,
0.528263509273529,
-0.3391622006893158,
-0.1045786589384079,
-0.5862607359886169,
-0.9579111933708191,
0.6168071031570435,
0.4955902397632599,
-0.6431557536125183,
0.3847685158252716,
0.2762831151485443,
0.0410802997648716,
-0.8639334440231323,
-0.7191577553749084,
0.11154619604349136,
-0.579216718673706,
-0.33596232533454895,
0.6163070201873779,
0.06295976042747498,
-0.010473102331161499,
-0.2024042308330536,
-0.4857412874698639,
-0.14841899275779724,
-0.017791852355003357,
0.12685169279575348,
-0.0035444176755845547,
-0.22819462418556213,
0.31453487277030945,
0.20790991187095642,
-0.10934324562549591,
0.2781656086444855,
-0.3403010368347168,
0.24667476117610931,
0.035525429993867874,
-0.5712584257125854,
-0.3003932237625122,
0.3530369997024536,
0.3414478898048401,
-0.16389942169189453,
0.4242124557495117,
0.40531980991363525,
-0.09863042831420898,
-0.21607699990272522,
-0.4553045630455017,
-0.0825149193406105,
-0.5356906652450562,
0.5204399228096008,
-0.3679972290992737,
-0.8610041737556458,
0.20692549645900726,
-0.33806756138801575,
-0.04863559454679489,
0.1046893522143364,
0.04331355541944504,
-0.5433450937271118,
0.7538880705833435,
1.0200263261795044,
-0.007923915982246399,
0.5046961307525635,
-0.2448747456073761,
-0.12223656475543976,
-1.6756597757339478,
-0.028564751148223877,
0.04356580600142479,
-0.6824990510940552,
-0.4930473864078522,
-0.7628849744796753,
0.40293487906455994,
0.687978982925415,
0.07882601767778397,
0.5268215537071228,
-0.31346315145492554,
0.6097358465194702,
0.1931023895740509,
0.22062204778194427,
0.1451246589422226,
0.08174370229244232,
0.09486102312803268,
-0.10946078598499298,
-0.6308243274688721,
-0.40103960037231445,
1.1703845262527466,
0.4406411349773407,
0.8477572798728943,
-0.06597249209880829,
0.3863523602485657,
0.09138043969869614,
0.5145866870880127,
-1.1234841346740723,
0.27221715450286865,
0.18800275027751923,
-0.41486409306526184,
-0.3936566710472107,
0.2829844355583191,
-0.9968374967575073,
0.19299651682376862,
0.3158983588218689,
-0.7159280180931091,
-0.019029296934604645,
0.27048560976982117,
-0.3420117199420929,
-0.0268802922219038,
-0.3867437541484833,
0.3465583622455597,
-0.4414258599281311,
-0.7073507905006409,
-0.4000197947025299,
-1.0273406505584717,
0.24130871891975403,
-0.17050717771053314,
0.20991376042366028,
-0.08455885946750641,
-0.5100926756858826,
0.7375141382217407,
-0.08085311204195023,
0.7121083736419678,
0.27606135606765747,
-0.43369871377944946,
0.3763192296028137,
-0.45977386832237244,
0.7681546807289124,
0.24455563724040985,
-0.017485620453953743,
-0.17575961351394653,
-0.36215102672576904,
-0.3692265748977661,
-0.7988337874412537,
0.7482306361198425,
-0.4843476414680481,
-1.063876986503601,
-0.2996422052383423,
-0.6424541473388672,
-0.4067249000072479,
-0.10590361058712006,
-0.09804408252239227,
0.4830309748649597,
0.04211371764540672,
0.49735239148139954,
0.7437549233436584,
-0.11393678188323975,
0.49092790484428406,
0.24735459685325623,
-0.18397031724452972,
-0.2159014344215393,
0.4303141236305237,
0.15421324968338013,
0.23337286710739136,
0.6828887462615967,
-0.24531632661819458,
-0.517166793346405,
-0.5829017162322998,
-0.24022158980369568,
0.3124162256717682,
-0.9664201736450195,
0.06476174294948578,
-0.7460260987281799,
-0.12784874439239502,
-0.23489505052566528,
-0.32977819442749023,
-0.12335629016160965,
-0.695915162563324,
-0.09254805743694305,
-0.3406413495540619,
0.4851721525192261,
0.6454705595970154,
-0.026798643171787262,
0.5136702060699463,
-1.0527408123016357,
0.12308180332183838,
0.4925643503665924,
0.2744174301624298,
0.10837472975254059,
-0.7038751244544983,
-0.7688727974891663,
-0.03747749701142311,
-0.43109554052352905,
-0.6039533019065857,
0.2795153856277466,
0.4638727009296417,
0.5999876260757446,
0.3908079266548157,
0.20706336200237274,
0.9107646942138672,
-0.7092276215553284,
0.5730515718460083,
0.27075573801994324,
-0.820461630821228,
0.481842041015625,
-0.1873379498720169,
0.28763777017593384,
0.22811856865882874,
0.75776606798172,
-0.6670868396759033,
-0.1612958163022995,
-0.46357637643814087,
-1.0939916372299194,
0.6786708831787109,
0.1578349471092224,
0.22594435513019562,
0.12478922307491302,
0.6561126112937927,
-0.02520788460969925,
0.1513071209192276,
-0.4796413779258728,
-0.28798606991767883,
0.18634144961833954,
-0.026469143107533455,
-0.450408935546875,
-0.44011610746383667,
-0.46291130781173706,
-0.2897184193134308,
0.21961218118667603,
-0.36940497159957886,
0.3460860550403595,
0.3364155888557434,
-0.573987603187561,
0.212898388504982,
-0.02799387089908123,
0.7200679183006287,
0.8892607092857361,
-0.026520026847720146,
0.32443663477897644,
0.7370354533195496,
-0.271493524312973,
0.2028231918811798,
-0.12152905762195587,
0.3398534953594208,
0.09439650177955627,
0.7711431980133057,
0.7188645005226135,
0.3369500935077667,
-0.5316811800003052,
0.3205394744873047,
0.30791929364204407,
0.2758159041404724,
-0.491192489862442,
0.05813264101743698,
0.26946356892585754,
0.16298280656337738,
0.6481813192367554,
-0.1560496985912323,
0.21482478082180023,
-0.2691321074962616,
0.414436936378479,
0.2796313166618347,
-0.925057053565979,
-0.4759373962879181,
0.47128838300704956,
0.4761194884777069,
-0.3787456750869751,
0.10275749862194061,
0.5205496549606323,
-0.6783897876739502,
0.9580851197242737,
0.2658197283744812,
0.659311056137085,
0.023279212415218353,
-0.28766703605651855,
0.33443453907966614,
0.05437121167778969,
0.030804870650172234,
-0.25760218501091003,
-0.5205725431442261,
-0.32679688930511475,
-0.6788837909698486,
-0.41145938634872437,
-0.3206113576889038,
-0.1293633133172989,
-1.1177468299865723,
0.42651015520095825,
-0.1631901115179062,
-0.15261836349964142,
-0.40234822034835815,
-0.036772724241018295,
-0.5107179880142212,
0.3992758095264435,
0.09688528627157211,
0.9597166776657104,
-0.15962839126586914,
1.1052294969558716,
0.7558198571205139,
0.21026259660720825,
-0.3690548539161682,
0.23940585553646088,
-0.3178776204586029,
-0.8624809980392456,
0.7805441617965698,
0.7426358461380005,
-0.4685184061527252,
0.09479748457670212,
-0.3932305574417114,
-1.0480332374572754,
1.2020498514175415,
0.06510385870933533,
-0.7515512108802795,
-0.23772865533828735,
0.2597338855266571,
0.6069208979606628,
-0.3443355858325958,
0.3091681897640228,
0.45436227321624756,
0.05474892631173134,
-0.25300005078315735,
-0.6243208646774292,
0.03883033245801926,
0.1602247804403305,
0.29556581377983093,
0.0646064355969429,
-0.7637708187103271,
0.37639328837394714,
-0.24927285313606262,
-0.12795206904411316,
0.06143397465348244,
0.853520929813385,
0.14770442247390747,
0.17471924424171448,
0.36366257071495056,
0.20700113475322723,
0.3593721091747284,
0.19067929685115814,
1.1942098140716553,
-0.6270179152488708,
0.7573328018188477,
1.5488736629486084,
-0.31221696734428406,
0.7950035929679871,
0.8239043354988098,
-0.1878921091556549,
0.41085121035575867,
0.8104898929595947,
0.2906742990016937,
0.4738691747188568,
0.32573410868644714,
-0.23468853533267975,
-0.16223613917827606,
-0.11305920779705048,
-0.778929591178894,
0.049971599131822586,
0.666982114315033,
-0.6176637411117554,
-0.06574923545122147,
0.1052870824933052,
-0.3969508707523346,
-0.1900480091571808,
-0.2940133810043335,
0.5209358930587769,
0.5332497954368591,
-0.9346363544464111,
0.6301517486572266,
-0.23465809226036072,
0.707363486289978,
-0.5182739496231079,
0.13408617675304413,
-0.16129210591316223,
0.49013552069664,
0.09851764887571335,
-1.0503774881362915,
0.3292180299758911,
-0.17858007550239563,
0.03096068650484085,
-0.434306800365448,
0.6538655757904053,
-0.4879595935344696,
0.0026727295480668545,
0.48503780364990234,
0.23821227252483368,
0.1788237988948822,
-0.0234285369515419,
-0.5591264367103577,
0.04365432634949684,
-0.1240050420165062,
-0.6318493485450745,
0.39374229311943054,
0.5615996718406677,
-0.10374143719673157,
0.7997843623161316,
0.3400980830192566,
-0.40223172307014465,
0.12907901406288147,
-0.3660739064216614,
1.0163344144821167,
-0.7607384324073792,
-0.3583492040634155,
-0.8951879739761353,
0.36002975702285767,
-0.27936339378356934,
-0.46457478404045105,
0.8725789189338684,
0.44551199674606323,
0.892544150352478,
-0.2850750982761383,
0.3816099762916565,
0.305213987827301,
0.1777782440185547,
-0.6930767893791199,
0.5088302493095398,
-0.6023491621017456,
0.11601997166872025,
-0.021646495908498764,
-0.967499315738678,
-0.175869882106781,
0.4249957203865051,
-0.43583500385284424,
-0.07593582570552826,
0.9344106912612915,
0.34574320912361145,
-0.15476998686790466,
-0.2618529498577118,
0.34123679995536804,
-0.0010172377806156874,
0.18712793290615082,
0.9282958507537842,
1.3271708488464355,
-0.46605366468429565,
0.6452734470367432,
-0.08530592918395996,
0.007924464531242847,
-0.39350464940071106,
-1.011256456375122,
-0.8297224044799805,
-0.040632568299770355,
-0.3095227777957916,
0.07270082831382751,
0.1159307137131691,
0.8643011450767517,
0.9301351308822632,
-0.4870271384716034,
-0.37052127718925476,
0.12103728204965591,
0.19720686972141266,
-0.20124366879463196,
-0.13606637716293335,
0.5418956279754639,
-0.33227717876434326,
-0.8273711800575256,
0.2649681866168976,
0.5090903639793396,
0.053984906524419785,
-0.01992020197212696,
-0.19405099749565125,
-0.4097076654434204,
-0.11436937749385834,
0.9582459926605225,
0.22987207770347595,
-0.5393474102020264,
-0.4682784080505371,
-0.10945439338684082,
0.016915710642933846,
0.27801525592803955,
0.8920556306838989,
-0.8985175490379333,
0.10141705721616745,
0.2655346393585205,
0.633142352104187,
0.966319739818573,
0.24238410592079163,
0.86976557970047,
-1.1833428144454956,
0.26497963070869446,
0.1630477011203766,
0.15908290445804596,
0.16171559691429138,
-0.2708742320537567,
0.8167664408683777,
0.016266217455267906,
-0.5102876424789429,
-0.7475035786628723,
0.564338743686676,
-0.9539756774902344,
-0.03589900583028793,
1.1333978176116943,
-0.7679816484451294,
-0.27564674615859985,
-0.22362367808818817,
-0.22010236978530884,
0.3540712594985962,
0.08735120296478271,
0.7295922040939331,
0.6865671873092651,
-0.40890079736709595,
-0.06772635132074356,
-0.65989089012146,
0.6878278255462646,
0.778139054775238,
-0.7025617957115173,
0.07852938771247864,
0.06891956925392151,
0.10365497320890427,
0.15507075190544128,
0.20520390570163727,
0.14769873023033142,
0.2784220278263092,
-0.7222811579704285,
-0.5880047678947449,
0.16039270162582397,
-0.4551914632320404,
-0.4937860667705536,
0.23479479551315308,
-0.058843351900577545,
-0.1528318226337433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13274v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13274v1 | In-Context Learning on a Budget: A Case Study in Named Entity Recognition | 2024-06-19T07:09:46 | 2024-06-19T07:09:46 | Uri Berger, Tal Baumel, Gabriel Stanovsky | cs.CL | cs.CL | Few shot in-context learning (ICL) typically assumes access to large
annotated training sets. However, in many real world scenarios, such as domain
adaptation, there is only a limited budget to annotate a small number of
samples, with the goal of maximizing downstream performance. We study various
methods for selecting samples to annotate within a predefined budget,
specifically focusing on the named entity recognition (NER) task, which has
real-world applications, is expensive to annotate, and is relatively less
studied in ICL setups. Across different models and datasets, we find that a
relatively small pool of annotated samples can achieve results comparable to
using the entire training set. Moreover, we discover that random selection of
samples for annotation yields surprisingly good performance. Finally, we
observe that a diverse annotation pool is correlated with improved performance.
We hope that future work adopts our realistic paradigm which takes annotation
budget into account. | [
-0.787627637386322,
-0.13572059571743011,
0.30818644165992737,
-0.0796065554022789,
-0.3458629846572876,
-0.12596552073955536,
-0.20755712687969208,
-0.8602827787399292,
-0.053335919976234436,
0.3848167657852173,
-0.5011492967605591,
-0.08535916358232498,
-0.35183247923851013,
0.3277328312397003,
-0.20096908509731293,
1.1674346923828125,
-0.02869848534464836,
0.1552908718585968,
-0.23563581705093384,
-0.5296687483787537,
-0.3974584639072418,
-0.38394561409950256,
-0.9912035465240479,
-0.35274001955986023,
0.6179606318473816,
0.6457621455192566,
-0.1437709629535675,
0.47984209656715393,
0.6302501559257507,
0.09805894643068314,
0.09350523352622986,
0.21814675629138947,
-0.4089187979698181,
-0.07454253733158112,
-0.15478725731372833,
-0.3048572838306427,
0.05609019100666046,
0.06368047744035721,
0.6908642649650574,
0.600561261177063,
0.25735709071159363,
0.3532543480396271,
0.1506529003381729,
0.5443775653839111,
-1.0193445682525635,
0.09249407798051834,
-0.8889708518981934,
0.23724991083145142,
-0.34257936477661133,
0.019458819180727005,
-0.33088868856430054,
-0.013896753080189228,
0.7213341593742371,
-0.9805088639259338,
0.12967996299266815,
0.2866789996623993,
0.9438496828079224,
0.383171409368515,
-0.08571512997150421,
-0.3586316406726837,
-0.7222317457199097,
0.7917430996894836,
-0.244686096906662,
0.3258749544620514,
0.5594883561134338,
0.46922338008880615,
0.0880250632762909,
-0.7329264879226685,
-0.33806031942367554,
-0.07746764272451401,
-0.018374834209680557,
-0.04849734529852867,
-0.041807837784290314,
0.010111854411661625,
0.6443806290626526,
-0.008890416473150253,
0.05992381274700165,
0.11741291731595993,
-0.21695519983768463,
-0.053518787026405334,
0.5996986031532288,
-0.12218692898750305,
0.03903575241565704,
0.032757457345724106,
-0.7193499803543091,
-0.16354146599769592,
-0.7784206867218018,
0.16462500393390656,
-0.07543526589870453,
0.6426827907562256,
-0.056306712329387665,
0.2547686994075775,
-0.28082481026649475,
0.6367566585540771,
0.14616715908050537,
-0.3930935561656952,
0.08196151256561279,
-0.09584397822618484,
-0.4430149793624878,
0.46804869174957275,
0.08950232714414597,
0.09582601487636566,
0.4982703924179077,
-0.2071334272623062,
-0.614855945110321,
-0.457780659198761,
0.16228385269641876,
-0.9149162769317627,
-0.5666953921318054,
-0.058335475623607635,
-0.1579332947731018,
0.025940291583538055,
-0.1280897706747055,
-0.612491250038147,
-0.43609631061553955,
-0.6125616431236267,
0.6539223194122314,
-0.41555312275886536,
0.28994783759117126,
-0.6213453412055969,
-0.29918068647384644,
0.03527088090777397,
0.5881913304328918,
-0.8879134654998779,
0.415997713804245,
0.28205350041389465,
0.8072807192802429,
0.08108823746442795,
-0.1183311939239502,
-0.7063276171684265,
0.15668295323848724,
-0.30741775035858154,
1.1741834878921509,
-0.3647404909133911,
-0.27317529916763306,
-0.20085960626602173,
-0.3531094789505005,
-0.06579390168190002,
-0.7933697700500488,
0.0700056254863739,
-0.5405990481376648,
-0.3135617673397064,
-0.45361757278442383,
-0.7029879689216614,
-0.11908120661973953,
0.1371961385011673,
-0.8578648567199707,
0.7424043416976929,
0.25336340069770813,
-0.921853244304657,
1.3874366283416748,
-0.68580162525177,
-0.31440696120262146,
0.4637461304664612,
-0.3395649194717407,
-0.4078245162963867,
0.12803883850574493,
0.14501041173934937,
0.4844282865524292,
-0.10338937491178513,
-0.03425157815217972,
-0.21708473563194275,
-0.576423168182373,
0.3533657491207123,
-0.10848934203386307,
0.5901433229446411,
0.2367708384990692,
-0.3359541893005371,
-0.24962621927261353,
-0.9086654782295227,
-0.1323540359735489,
-0.19879242777824402,
-0.5338558554649353,
-0.6643556356430054,
-0.037227846682071686,
0.3966290056705475,
-0.03994688019156456,
-0.2714957296848297,
-0.4360131621360779,
0.12080225348472595,
-0.3956303298473358,
0.32326406240463257,
0.6319742202758789,
0.2231997847557068,
0.881835401058197,
-0.11753486096858978,
0.16253173351287842,
0.04927109181880951,
-0.19490362703800201,
0.020731668919324875,
-0.0056872921995818615,
-0.6513980031013489,
-0.8184248805046082,
0.7657329440116882,
0.3025558888912201,
-0.6703459620475769,
-0.21660250425338745,
-0.006266759242862463,
-0.19260577857494354,
-0.16496750712394714,
0.03234272822737694,
0.253257155418396,
0.6948909163475037,
0.5089693665504456,
-0.2551151514053345,
-0.7216452956199646,
-0.993497371673584,
-0.1882980614900589,
-0.05104455724358559,
-0.03986566886305809,
0.8571599721908569,
0.7748249769210815,
0.2845675051212311,
1.2306592464447021,
-0.34993496537208557,
-0.6934720873832703,
-0.1533932089805603,
0.07761018723249435,
-0.1815578043460846,
0.4384521543979645,
0.6806644797325134,
-0.8832883238792419,
-0.4049834609031677,
-0.17475755512714386,
-0.3645029366016388,
0.1513347029685974,
-0.47909635305404663,
0.06343697756528854,
0.07423265278339386,
0.5318604707717896,
-0.16838949918746948,
0.413851797580719,
0.06739472597837448,
0.11075256019830704,
0.13701581954956055,
-0.06093638390302658,
-0.27562472224235535,
-0.7999188303947449,
-0.030741460621356964,
0.2404146045446396,
-0.27076008915901184,
-0.23662106692790985,
-0.10083024203777313,
0.2033226191997528,
-0.008143841288983822,
-0.6081060171127319,
0.841810941696167,
-0.718895673751831,
-0.1399431675672531,
-0.28406113386154175,
0.23350605368614197,
-0.18764229118824005,
0.2993088364601135,
0.2791415750980377,
1.0116440057754517,
0.35673364996910095,
-0.8308260440826416,
-0.12334802746772766,
0.11554832756519318,
-0.6291176676750183,
0.800019383430481,
-0.1927318423986435,
0.101531982421875,
-0.23833782970905304,
0.5037679672241211,
-0.5302663445472717,
-0.5351376533508301,
0.24913716316223145,
0.033550288528203964,
0.5232613682746887,
-0.45329412817955017,
-0.28300830721855164,
0.2330995351076126,
0.09085682034492493,
0.44957032799720764,
0.21082943677902222,
-0.9193206429481506,
0.294181764125824,
0.7585890889167786,
0.30838680267333984,
-0.3843468129634857,
-0.8185974359512329,
0.003460041480138898,
-0.583004355430603,
0.2773817479610443,
0.4504082500934601,
0.03085567057132721,
-0.40905728936195374,
0.039723921567201614,
-0.14672337472438812,
-0.356695294380188,
0.42179691791534424,
0.30997252464294434,
0.07705419510602951,
-0.2502569854259491,
0.5481001734733582,
-0.16781526803970337,
-0.017084293067455292,
-0.1661507785320282,
-0.6029496788978577,
-0.04190780967473984,
0.11654344946146011,
-0.1075693741440773,
-0.07045112550258636,
0.1648029386997223,
-0.07495003938674927,
-0.20210081338882446,
0.5162344574928284,
0.3133760690689087,
-0.9687818288803101,
-0.6972812414169312,
-0.4398224651813507,
-0.18741998076438904,
-0.34360355138778687,
0.28958043456077576,
-0.6131065487861633,
-0.6719899773597717,
0.2832834720611572,
-0.3833109140396118,
0.11390135437250137,
0.40151166915893555,
0.12643863260746002,
-0.3316163718700409,
0.2613373398780823,
0.5855371356010437,
-0.05752375349402428,
0.7519690990447998,
-0.36328187584877014,
0.2866935729980469,
-1.0307986736297607,
-0.1405792385339737,
-0.4568774700164795,
-0.6721602082252502,
-0.3973711133003235,
-0.2039179652929306,
0.27771618962287903,
0.24588413536548615,
-0.14945870637893677,
0.4709566831588745,
-0.40663665533065796,
0.8477868437767029,
0.7452000379562378,
0.07855798304080963,
-0.0934014543890953,
-0.07728710025548935,
-0.015315573662519455,
-0.07624929398298264,
-0.5429642796516418,
-0.48745739459991455,
1.02517569065094,
0.03962089121341705,
0.29813021421432495,
-0.11593801528215408,
1.0307331085205078,
-0.0048992447555065155,
0.5908293128013611,
-0.7320181131362915,
0.4651000201702118,
-0.0352204330265522,
-0.7828479409217834,
-0.4098774194717407,
-0.20415350794792175,
-0.777678906917572,
0.19473975896835327,
-0.4150537848472595,
-1.0019162893295288,
0.5876688361167908,
0.23679713904857635,
-0.7211145758628845,
0.31294748187065125,
-0.556363582611084,
0.6730853915214539,
-0.045373450964689255,
-0.21234655380249023,
0.01670892909169197,
-0.49568963050842285,
0.08837283402681351,
-0.41670045256614685,
-0.0570448637008667,
-0.3497616946697235,
-0.1505848914384842,
0.6995906233787537,
0.022353651002049446,
0.5799461603164673,
-0.3657527565956116,
0.5548470616340637,
0.4632749557495117,
-0.1426602452993393,
0.4167245626449585,
0.46999025344848633,
0.0852462500333786,
0.095981664955616,
-0.006234388332813978,
-0.3093583285808563,
-0.2597241997718811,
0.6241950392723083,
-0.48063069581985474,
-0.2371261566877365,
-0.5358684659004211,
-0.6180799007415771,
-0.30827510356903076,
0.20918439328670502,
0.44571831822395325,
0.6379238367080688,
-0.17897017300128937,
0.1453268826007843,
0.6627105474472046,
-0.029177339747548103,
0.8661935329437256,
0.01124864723533392,
0.16650182008743286,
-0.37758344411849976,
0.7971521615982056,
0.6868566274642944,
-0.004385602194815874,
0.6271697282791138,
-0.045810554176568985,
-0.042268093675374985,
-0.7241921424865723,
-0.754319429397583,
-0.10261645913124084,
-0.9182558059692383,
-0.4072226881980896,
-0.5272231698036194,
-0.10596951842308044,
-0.051642321050167084,
-0.3101303279399872,
-0.30853134393692017,
-0.40297383069992065,
-0.6037559509277344,
-0.12984761595726013,
0.3389507234096527,
0.295026570558548,
0.06363912671804428,
0.1892324686050415,
-0.4016892611980438,
0.05082787945866585,
0.36416447162628174,
0.25143492221832275,
-0.004408543463796377,
-0.3121419847011566,
-0.6141884326934814,
-0.21050682663917542,
0.002648969180881977,
-0.6434075236320496,
0.30442309379577637,
0.5944920778274536,
0.5499762892723083,
0.31550851464271545,
0.20806148648262024,
1.006898283958435,
-0.5834713578224182,
0.4386981725692749,
-0.20014451444149017,
-0.7025358080863953,
0.395744264125824,
0.11008229851722717,
0.24243424832820892,
1.1847890615463257,
0.37424564361572266,
-0.1351492702960968,
0.1759643256664276,
-0.6495394110679626,
-0.9217038154602051,
0.7246808409690857,
-0.06266377866268158,
0.16348543763160706,
-0.030022921040654182,
0.5538762807846069,
0.10820908099412918,
0.1438886523246765,
-0.7136011719703674,
-0.09210772812366486,
0.19372224807739258,
0.0010749303037300706,
0.05523601919412613,
-0.1417241096496582,
-0.19828711450099945,
-0.14580745995044708,
0.6599645018577576,
-0.36205676198005676,
0.18728986382484436,
0.5092661380767822,
-0.5199266672134399,
-0.0007230857154354453,
0.02279251627624035,
0.5147934556007385,
0.691595196723938,
-0.2662467956542969,
0.2681727409362793,
0.7465998530387878,
-0.2383178323507309,
-0.055002570152282715,
0.15076623857021332,
-0.32192757725715637,
0.02827686071395874,
0.36386045813560486,
1.0529024600982666,
0.6652190089225769,
-0.867914080619812,
0.46012431383132935,
-0.005391223356127739,
-0.05289800465106964,
-0.6170591711997986,
0.009643319994211197,
-0.09433778375387192,
0.6699181795120239,
0.4544517695903778,
0.22648665308952332,
0.383699506521225,
-0.3051605224609375,
0.2910156548023224,
0.4907588064670563,
-0.5924341082572937,
-0.003276627045124769,
0.494301438331604,
-0.046585049480199814,
-0.27423009276390076,
0.7945256233215332,
-0.5060052275657654,
-0.22524413466453552,
0.6073626279830933,
0.5323814153671265,
1.0242950916290283,
0.4524693191051483,
-0.06271814554929733,
0.5891652703285217,
0.07202795892953873,
-0.11585350334644318,
-0.1314052790403366,
-0.4979354739189148,
-0.6675369143486023,
-0.04621439427137375,
-0.5967987775802612,
-0.5837529897689819,
0.05628249794244766,
-0.554918646812439,
0.5777472257614136,
-0.7435635924339294,
-0.14991362392902374,
0.1851045936346054,
0.2008262723684311,
-1.0004653930664062,
0.522911787033081,
0.5359993577003479,
1.0073760747909546,
-0.5753175616264343,
0.9578570127487183,
0.8950926661491394,
-0.5590838193893433,
-0.9063250422477722,
0.13242122530937195,
-0.03536713123321533,
-0.48813071846961975,
1.077467918395996,
0.296612024307251,
0.2023525834083557,
0.013344969600439072,
-0.36722424626350403,
-1.0892845392227173,
1.2000473737716675,
0.23821265995502472,
-0.7489913702011108,
-0.10206473618745804,
-0.30242154002189636,
0.2915991544723511,
-0.7732617855072021,
0.11985104531049728,
0.35954153537750244,
0.1786104291677475,
-0.06193726137280464,
-0.6359025835990906,
-0.22774721682071686,
0.18138360977172852,
-0.01819421537220478,
0.32146763801574707,
-0.445243775844574,
0.7967105507850647,
-0.32720232009887695,
-0.3466542065143585,
-0.2946038544178009,
0.773026704788208,
0.40073347091674805,
0.8406590819358826,
0.6569356918334961,
0.43899285793304443,
0.8858124613761902,
0.034906793385744095,
1.0757782459259033,
-0.10296061635017395,
0.35368838906288147,
1.2975858449935913,
-0.2979986071586609,
0.9421554207801819,
0.7120041251182556,
-0.12647870182991028,
0.045469000935554504,
0.9693908095359802,
-0.2156076431274414,
0.8621783256530762,
0.4073871076107025,
-0.4170788526535034,
-0.1900743693113327,
-0.31712326407432556,
0.12288746982812881,
0.3433639705181122,
0.15644702315330505,
-0.26761892437934875,
-0.19359615445137024,
0.25642091035842896,
-0.1712251752614975,
-0.35277342796325684,
-0.37092459201812744,
1.0325833559036255,
0.4400734007358551,
-0.4788697063922882,
0.023714227601885796,
-0.27269989252090454,
0.398369163274765,
-0.29962554574012756,
-0.07217005640268326,
-0.13028015196323395,
0.2038942128419876,
-0.14149095118045807,
-0.2569054067134857,
0.17486722767353058,
0.01371293980628252,
-0.12227528542280197,
-0.05009560286998749,
0.7828922867774963,
-0.19505812227725983,
-0.4166618287563324,
0.047515664249658585,
0.08961064368486404,
0.30234837532043457,
-0.1933346688747406,
-0.39810535311698914,
-0.2917192876338959,
-0.27607589960098267,
-0.19408877193927765,
0.79446941614151,
0.410892516374588,
-0.3604845702648163,
0.39481520652770996,
0.43089643120765686,
0.24528947472572327,
-0.07327999174594879,
-0.02104710042476654,
0.5810390710830688,
-0.40827706456184387,
-0.4600183069705963,
-0.8038240075111389,
0.40966299176216125,
-0.15387214720249176,
-0.7587128281593323,
0.4059605002403259,
0.5737804770469666,
1.585351824760437,
0.020373715087771416,
0.7337686419487,
0.19748009741306305,
0.40690547227859497,
-0.5106920003890991,
0.3533635139465332,
-0.6223141551017761,
0.16675794124603271,
-0.28536751866340637,
-0.986897885799408,
-0.5937989950180054,
0.944158673286438,
-0.44466689229011536,
-0.19335047900676727,
0.4772419333457947,
0.2992590069770813,
-0.1610850840806961,
0.17612051963806152,
0.2802269756793976,
-0.44091978669166565,
0.059050481766462326,
0.5160750150680542,
0.7645771503448486,
-0.3462677001953125,
0.16177362203598022,
-0.631120502948761,
0.1414739340543747,
-0.2841394543647766,
-1.0451997518539429,
-0.7534854412078857,
-0.6817381978034973,
-0.5902589559555054,
-0.02352357655763626,
0.13765163719654083,
1.551720142364502,
1.0008071660995483,
-0.8991580009460449,
-0.10260900855064392,
0.023844923824071884,
-0.16218137741088867,
-0.3276716470718384,
-0.14041221141815186,
0.25977155566215515,
-0.36014047265052795,
-0.8484172821044922,
0.34125059843063354,
0.3491351306438446,
-0.020361240953207016,
0.11774331331253052,
0.20591509342193604,
-0.28847238421440125,
0.00044965199776925147,
0.3856467008590698,
0.3697759211063385,
-0.6866834163665771,
-0.5497674942016602,
-0.322886198759079,
-0.09943981468677521,
0.17036543786525726,
0.8633902072906494,
-0.9900821447372437,
0.33874747157096863,
0.2929993271827698,
1.1486380100250244,
0.7285239696502686,
-0.21021264791488647,
0.014453711919486523,
-0.7925900816917419,
0.08300542086362839,
0.45265501737594604,
0.47369280457496643,
0.3429502844810486,
-0.3646584451198578,
0.6185010075569153,
0.1746034175157547,
-0.5916060209274292,
-1.0643742084503174,
-0.04553749039769173,
-0.8544163107872009,
-0.2547864317893982,
0.8277797102928162,
-0.23554754257202148,
-0.05724930763244629,
-0.018918080255389214,
-0.18527841567993164,
0.0981287956237793,
-0.3893267810344696,
0.5536917448043823,
0.6642500758171082,
-0.4956282377243042,
-0.2403644174337387,
-0.7387728691101074,
0.7051283121109009,
0.042946211993694305,
-0.6380643248558044,
-0.22268696129322052,
0.4987158179283142,
0.32269975543022156,
0.06536997109651566,
0.5867195725440979,
0.37284308671951294,
0.08962564915418625,
0.11697912961244583,
-0.06274838745594025,
0.11206711083650589,
-0.5536171197891235,
-0.3623107373714447,
0.3582703769207001,
0.4061361253261566,
-0.45545265078544617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13275v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13275v2 | Enhancing Automated Audio Captioning via Large Language Models with Optimized Audio Encoding | 2024-06-19T07:09:46 | 2024-06-25T08:07:36 | Jizhong Liu, Gang Li, Junbo Zhang, Heinrich Dinkel, Yongqing Wang, Zhiyong Yan, Yujun Wang, Bin Wang | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Automated audio captioning (AAC) is an audio-to-text task to describe audio
contents in natural language. Recently, the advancements in large language
models (LLMs), with improvements in training approaches for audio encoders,
have opened up possibilities for improving AAC. Thus, we explore enhancing AAC
from three aspects: 1) a pre-trained audio encoder via consistent ensemble
distillation (CED) is used to improve the effectivity of acoustic tokens, with
a querying transformer (Q-Former) bridging the modality gap to LLM and compress
acoustic tokens; 2) we investigate the advantages of using a Llama 2 with 7B
parameters as the decoder; 3) another pre-trained LLM corrects text errors
caused by insufficient training data and annotation ambiguities. Both the audio
encoder and text decoder are optimized by low-rank adaptation (LoRA).
Experiments show that each of these enhancements is effective. Our method
obtains a 33.0 SPIDEr-FL score, outperforming the winner of DCASE 2023 Task 6A. | [
-0.4472235143184662,
-0.46395349502563477,
0.5491535067558289,
0.05866575241088867,
-0.5747398734092712,
0.4450889527797699,
-0.19215799868106842,
-0.5523742437362671,
0.2263263612985611,
0.3109339773654938,
-0.2215195596218109,
-0.6239873766899109,
-0.8499639630317688,
0.5131853818893433,
-0.39681705832481384,
0.7934073209762573,
-0.023825185373425484,
0.2476736307144165,
-0.084261454641819,
-0.24798622727394104,
-0.5514340400695801,
-0.5320186018943787,
-0.8247764110565186,
-0.08355291187763214,
0.2594972550868988,
0.43377360701560974,
0.6245577335357666,
0.7334482669830322,
0.5290923714637756,
0.3192198574542999,
-0.06837918609380722,
0.31361958384513855,
-0.12052023410797119,
0.00807155855000019,
0.22509123384952545,
-0.5468897819519043,
-0.6666639447212219,
-0.20475856959819794,
0.6142066121101379,
0.6414737105369568,
-0.3022804260253906,
-0.12818509340286255,
0.03667207807302475,
0.7976946234703064,
-0.6449599266052246,
0.4532870650291443,
-0.6386021971702576,
-0.042686060070991516,
0.06657128781080246,
-0.5452978610992432,
-0.38277342915534973,
-0.08943624049425125,
-0.07773050665855408,
-0.7354003190994263,
-0.09857124835252762,
0.3977886140346527,
0.6024985313415527,
0.8199366331100464,
-0.26733720302581787,
-0.3765716850757599,
-0.7905148267745972,
0.6595999598503113,
-0.7756688594818115,
0.2522796392440796,
0.5935167074203491,
0.39012134075164795,
-0.00022857345174998045,
-0.44229304790496826,
-0.7122290730476379,
-0.27478933334350586,
0.3185141086578369,
0.25061842799186707,
-0.2803597152233124,
0.36467444896698,
0.1284237653017044,
0.6237002015113831,
-0.2608324885368347,
0.3174266219139099,
-0.27057600021362305,
-0.1971849799156189,
0.8569697141647339,
-0.020033271983265877,
0.2507820427417755,
0.21007882058620453,
-0.09126932919025421,
-0.4107379615306854,
-0.5491230487823486,
-0.1399008184671402,
0.4256402850151062,
0.15844325721263885,
-0.21121706068515778,
0.40118408203125,
-0.1483689844608307,
0.3960396945476532,
0.26356250047683716,
-0.02297462895512581,
0.436323344707489,
-0.259995698928833,
0.15670236945152283,
0.48006725311279297,
0.6227098703384399,
0.37203091382980347,
0.29995667934417725,
-0.10976449400186539,
-0.36433538794517517,
-0.003455118741840124,
0.2997433841228485,
-0.3681110441684723,
-0.2199918031692505,
0.34987396001815796,
-0.3924570679664612,
-0.23911847174167633,
0.17099304497241974,
-0.48254576325416565,
-0.3822368085384369,
-0.6281831860542297,
0.6367702484130859,
-0.1548343300819397,
0.12619607150554657,
0.3033970296382904,
-0.11804728955030441,
0.20209746062755585,
0.3601657450199127,
-0.9181421399116516,
0.526716947555542,
0.3237287998199463,
0.8418023586273193,
-0.4844612777233124,
0.038666967302560806,
-0.8899911642074585,
0.3403379023075104,
-0.3695627450942993,
0.8307698965072632,
-0.45271557569503784,
-0.385843425989151,
0.06152113154530525,
-0.23233765363693237,
0.10809815675020218,
-0.6114378571510315,
0.5571750998497009,
-0.6130104064941406,
-0.15694043040275574,
0.10995776206254959,
-0.5824602842330933,
-0.09257149696350098,
-0.17277975380420685,
-0.9939155578613281,
0.4840478003025055,
-0.11925865709781647,
-0.35093095898628235,
0.23292995989322662,
-0.9119694828987122,
-0.6129969954490662,
-0.06474921107292175,
0.046555738896131516,
-0.34481605887413025,
0.09636479616165161,
0.8173120617866516,
0.2903589904308319,
-0.14196045696735382,
-0.029268663376569748,
0.01832818239927292,
-0.5025612711906433,
0.25578922033309937,
-0.6301538348197937,
0.4259391129016876,
0.26496759057044983,
-0.32463186979293823,
0.2154635190963745,
-0.7544797658920288,
-0.32439401745796204,
-0.03624856099486351,
-0.5365288257598877,
-0.05019117146730423,
0.03813741356134415,
0.07633675634860992,
-0.2666184604167938,
0.05610005930066109,
-0.35594499111175537,
0.009917889721691608,
-0.5845304131507874,
0.5907326340675354,
0.6215178966522217,
0.08284349739551544,
0.6967160701751709,
-0.328949511051178,
0.6223853826522827,
-0.11400973051786423,
-0.02024933695793152,
-0.28578779101371765,
-0.22464561462402344,
-0.6310820579528809,
-0.3601350486278534,
0.46820515394210815,
0.5702041983604431,
-0.7370701432228088,
0.8576997518539429,
-0.2630665898323059,
-0.3206959366798401,
-0.6855462193489075,
-0.009123045951128006,
0.20270007848739624,
0.14914853870868683,
0.5504634380340576,
-0.6389232277870178,
-0.429341197013855,
-0.6542497277259827,
0.1441272497177124,
-0.1844499260187149,
-0.23816587030887604,
0.2268635779619217,
0.16176153719425201,
-0.12452226132154465,
0.7470322251319885,
-0.3672802448272705,
-0.6430470943450928,
-0.2797098755836487,
0.17561493813991547,
0.2352624535560608,
0.526861310005188,
0.3951641023159027,
-0.7845795750617981,
-0.4235658049583435,
-0.21606168150901794,
-0.31679102778434753,
-0.32741063833236694,
-0.26975175738334656,
0.07209357619285583,
0.31118518114089966,
0.8007521629333496,
-0.6240783333778381,
0.3068903982639313,
0.6153355240821838,
0.06451629102230072,
0.6173235177993774,
-0.26896873116493225,
0.4891306161880493,
-0.8122736811637878,
-0.17799977958202362,
-0.22799091041088104,
-0.31569287180900574,
-0.3405835032463074,
-0.11288526654243469,
-0.24594034254550934,
-0.00016999059880618006,
-0.33342278003692627,
0.2668869197368622,
-0.5962726473808289,
-0.18908663094043732,
-0.6208874583244324,
0.22807884216308594,
0.010751771740615368,
0.3884328007698059,
0.1986706703901291,
0.8573686480522156,
0.6903891563415527,
-0.3918873965740204,
0.4443453252315521,
0.3465173542499542,
-0.3887380063533783,
0.26132526993751526,
-0.4986363649368286,
0.35072433948516846,
-0.07355325669050217,
0.568821370601654,
-1.0543259382247925,
-0.16003075242042542,
-0.03495790809392929,
-0.4854492247104645,
0.5518925786018372,
0.029568273574113846,
-0.5825101733207703,
-0.15504008531570435,
-0.22635555267333984,
0.4787150025367737,
0.5825191140174866,
-0.7461078763008118,
0.7409382462501526,
0.3512330651283264,
-0.29826417565345764,
-0.21239694952964783,
-0.5068194270133972,
0.4140767455101013,
-0.3436790108680725,
-0.2648722529411316,
0.5043734908103943,
-0.26134970784187317,
-0.21085338294506073,
-0.34035512804985046,
-0.3666978180408478,
-0.0935453251004219,
-0.019078945741057396,
0.08620452880859375,
0.2034875452518463,
-0.18499445915222168,
0.13462825119495392,
0.24794329702854156,
-0.11803213506937027,
0.148863285779953,
-0.2420886754989624,
0.5698570013046265,
-0.1219063326716423,
-0.325338751077652,
-0.7503269910812378,
0.42654553055763245,
0.5130237936973572,
-0.3892890512943268,
0.5053034424781799,
0.3255447447299957,
-0.15495093166828156,
-0.07620926946401596,
-0.49676695466041565,
-0.33161064982414246,
-0.5017430782318115,
0.4596603214740753,
-0.19100722670555115,
-0.8441957831382751,
0.43714791536331177,
-0.031933851540088654,
-0.07138276845216751,
0.322666734457016,
0.2856298089027405,
-0.36679697036743164,
1.2153829336166382,
0.4520452320575714,
-0.32954344153404236,
0.4680142402648926,
-0.1793043613433838,
0.01895762048661709,
-0.649064838886261,
0.07107838243246078,
-0.6088324189186096,
-0.12188694626092911,
-0.4021719992160797,
-0.41544896364212036,
0.39070940017700195,
0.05912284553050995,
-0.08384750783443451,
0.3308054804801941,
-0.4437314569950104,
0.5184392333030701,
0.453172504901886,
0.04935695603489876,
0.48543429374694824,
0.1307041049003601,
0.23743022978305817,
0.22411541640758514,
-0.6084532141685486,
-0.5970993638038635,
1.2414661645889282,
0.6338018774986267,
0.6956326365470886,
0.18945211172103882,
0.7021339535713196,
0.6087132096290588,
-0.12511754035949707,
-0.836419403553009,
0.301874041557312,
-0.20346054434776306,
-0.37267276644706726,
-0.5020292401313782,
-0.17949974536895752,
-0.7280155420303345,
0.07223013788461685,
-0.3664480745792389,
-0.506777286529541,
0.14409734308719635,
0.33498379588127136,
-0.46732133626937866,
-0.011688842438161373,
-0.5708913803100586,
0.4158148169517517,
-0.3743220269680023,
-0.07311446964740753,
-0.45073315501213074,
-0.7316994667053223,
-0.16572584211826324,
-0.21609888970851898,
0.5152378678321838,
0.18087393045425415,
-0.2168724685907364,
0.7341558933258057,
-0.30374786257743835,
0.5526630878448486,
-0.24325460195541382,
-0.3544219136238098,
0.34766656160354614,
-0.18653328716754913,
0.6624674797058105,
-0.026141485199332237,
0.002732606139034033,
0.3090682029724121,
0.06522534042596817,
-0.227025106549263,
-0.48912134766578674,
0.27043265104293823,
-0.747548520565033,
-0.7142055630683899,
-0.24390575289726257,
-0.5848240256309509,
-0.4268939197063446,
-0.012822969816625118,
0.03015761263668537,
0.46877872943878174,
0.08985383063554764,
0.39466822147369385,
0.621345043182373,
-0.2970716953277588,
0.6883665323257446,
0.25067636370658875,
0.24301300942897797,
-0.6097971796989441,
0.6093418002128601,
-0.3222380578517914,
0.4435746371746063,
0.57012939453125,
0.1044507846236229,
-0.4089946448802948,
-1.060234546661377,
-0.5417196750640869,
0.03256091848015785,
-0.8728424310684204,
-0.24045930802822113,
-0.41234657168388367,
-0.09095698595046997,
-0.4727111756801605,
-0.09929123520851135,
-0.5352665185928345,
-0.43226492404937744,
-0.4806947708129883,
-0.22098186612129211,
0.3952135741710663,
0.35617318749427795,
-0.1790487915277481,
0.6929988861083984,
-0.9639133214950562,
0.5397239327430725,
0.18954914808273315,
0.09833060950040817,
-0.01729162596166134,
-0.8496662974357605,
-0.34268859028816223,
-0.044821787625551224,
-0.025881577283143997,
-0.7267147302627563,
0.3733270764350891,
0.5035473108291626,
0.5612344145774841,
0.447868674993515,
0.22554458677768707,
0.5659438371658325,
-0.7305903434753418,
0.7167418003082275,
0.3192424476146698,
-0.9325937628746033,
0.4310328960418701,
-0.3313950002193451,
0.4921521246433258,
0.6398717761039734,
0.2257932871580124,
0.04984889179468155,
-0.45503127574920654,
-0.2908707559108734,
-1.0431467294692993,
0.43065282702445984,
0.34938615560531616,
0.3015576899051666,
0.03358742594718933,
0.28018292784690857,
0.061411820352077484,
0.1314762532711029,
-0.6775679588317871,
-0.13712331652641296,
-0.32638823986053467,
-0.4992727041244507,
-0.21263276040554047,
-0.12828263640403748,
-0.011041643097996712,
-0.28931981325149536,
0.7266573905944824,
-0.23916175961494446,
0.08555419743061066,
0.27507880330085754,
-0.16044624149799347,
-0.07661636918783188,
0.33526331186294556,
0.4498100280761719,
0.33323806524276733,
-0.0929497629404068,
0.03989608213305473,
0.29680997133255005,
-0.647103488445282,
0.20090366899967194,
0.25577062368392944,
0.35254019498825073,
-0.15871064364910126,
0.7526872754096985,
0.7968761324882507,
-0.04277672618627548,
-0.812076210975647,
0.3474394977092743,
0.016646243631839752,
-0.2169536054134369,
-0.587963342666626,
0.14273710548877716,
-0.08628154546022415,
0.15737013518810272,
0.83643639087677,
-0.03329763934016228,
0.5135486721992493,
-0.5144972801208496,
0.13744844496250153,
0.19330987334251404,
-0.2920534014701843,
0.03717441111803055,
0.7271323800086975,
0.4778991937637329,
-0.1574191451072693,
0.23698920011520386,
-0.01593293994665146,
-0.35475534200668335,
0.6350651383399963,
0.400267630815506,
0.7983880639076233,
-0.1992114931344986,
-0.2841011583805084,
0.39274880290031433,
0.3118261694908142,
-0.027330825105309486,
-0.026324618607759476,
-0.461990088224411,
-0.5018208026885986,
-0.6736114621162415,
-0.7689823508262634,
-0.3832290768623352,
-0.05760185047984123,
-0.7116739153862,
0.20747092366218567,
-0.18382051587104797,
-0.018431078642606735,
-0.08333335071802139,
-0.04431014135479927,
-0.40318357944488525,
0.296787828207016,
0.3249686360359192,
0.7611929774284363,
-0.856447160243988,
0.716765284538269,
0.4703501760959625,
-0.41761958599090576,
-0.9299824237823486,
0.017819538712501526,
-0.15210163593292236,
-0.3712683320045471,
0.30733323097229004,
0.04926005005836487,
-0.3389681279659271,
0.19274283945560455,
-0.6552861928939819,
-0.9599320888519287,
1.0422409772872925,
0.13642670214176178,
-1.207773208618164,
0.1252947449684143,
0.3108896315097809,
0.5346835255622864,
-0.6805511116981506,
-0.03435838967561722,
0.6525852084159851,
0.45551571249961853,
0.09068311750888824,
-1.1823692321777344,
-0.20299836993217468,
-0.1286497265100479,
-0.16619394719600677,
-0.30861151218414307,
-0.14175653457641602,
0.23294773697853088,
-0.18309974670410156,
-0.02565741539001465,
0.17796272039413452,
0.7526228427886963,
0.4029676020145416,
0.23425887525081635,
0.8883865475654602,
0.2750359773635864,
0.47729963064193726,
0.05944446101784706,
1.0638725757598877,
-0.146606907248497,
-0.21064181625843048,
1.1770262718200684,
-0.2118011862039566,
0.8758797645568848,
0.6697192192077637,
-0.22905755043029785,
0.4361553192138672,
0.661041259765625,
-0.04540028050541878,
0.8288629651069641,
0.30649039149284363,
-0.22411924600601196,
-0.38603633642196655,
0.024855826050043106,
-0.12934459745883942,
0.7643656730651855,
0.15393950045108795,
-0.3655981421470642,
0.3290368616580963,
0.43044668436050415,
-0.29427284002304077,
0.4432816803455353,
-0.5237446427345276,
1.099544882774353,
0.24690817296504974,
-0.4265661835670471,
0.5335934162139893,
-0.15400809049606323,
0.6854023933410645,
-0.2858298420906067,
-0.20762085914611816,
-0.11592229455709457,
-0.04624350741505623,
-0.22006158530712128,
-0.42156463861465454,
0.1505044400691986,
0.116972915828228,
-0.1970711499452591,
0.007335611153393984,
0.389910489320755,
-0.4225374460220337,
-0.337955504655838,
0.24482083320617676,
0.03673297166824341,
0.4696741998195648,
-0.21097145974636078,
-0.3193686902523041,
0.351098895072937,
-0.18660160899162292,
0.035859089344739914,
-0.003089119680225849,
0.15632161498069763,
-0.027618685737252235,
0.48983073234558105,
0.6864423751831055,
0.363432377576828,
-0.1172608733177185,
0.6467005610466003,
0.6504473090171814,
-0.38746175169944763,
-0.6826236248016357,
-0.6275675892829895,
0.44413721561431885,
-0.01161585096269846,
0.22697071731090546,
0.5070202946662903,
0.5823427438735962,
0.6081054210662842,
-0.26355016231536865,
0.7307586073875427,
0.18757855892181396,
0.3212653696537018,
-0.8154798746109009,
0.9198639988899231,
-0.5380393266677856,
0.6091857552528381,
-0.39227354526519775,
-1.2863818407058716,
-0.34563174843788147,
0.505591869354248,
-0.06063362583518028,
0.10589861869812012,
0.6250881552696228,
0.6516015529632568,
0.22833606600761414,
-0.04595125466585159,
0.1642913520336151,
0.013279146514832973,
0.3849259316921234,
0.44808968901634216,
0.8005192875862122,
-0.5437018275260925,
0.7824834585189819,
-0.14568112790584564,
-0.20801039040088654,
0.033906545490026474,
-0.904954195022583,
-0.7932115197181702,
-0.563000500202179,
-0.7071769833564758,
0.03422639146447182,
0.14320673048496246,
0.8811857104301453,
0.680465042591095,
-0.9237543344497681,
-0.11418552696704865,
-0.17095723748207092,
-0.18653428554534912,
-0.22620847821235657,
-0.14822505414485931,
0.5172217488288879,
-0.20249813795089722,
-0.8767184615135193,
0.6453467607498169,
0.12245909124612808,
0.1799463927745819,
-0.07211589068174362,
-0.4388706386089325,
0.02489682100713253,
0.2000378519296646,
0.5533062815666199,
0.004379017744213343,
-0.6685053706169128,
-0.5414476990699768,
-0.28084632754325867,
0.23739151656627655,
0.2672805190086365,
0.283941388130188,
-0.4896926283836365,
0.3980678617954254,
0.1611446589231491,
0.4472241699695587,
0.549637496471405,
0.16893060505390167,
0.6956170797348022,
-0.5761223435401917,
0.04405216872692108,
0.42002439498901367,
0.31171393394470215,
0.45887860655784607,
-0.13347816467285156,
0.3292563557624817,
-0.23762625455856323,
-0.5491459369659424,
-0.7277169823646545,
-0.16267231106758118,
-1.2692036628723145,
-0.2582191526889801,
1.3257702589035034,
0.11839662492275238,
-0.09957554936408997,
-0.17496342957019806,
-0.45721954107284546,
0.4180368483066559,
-0.5339734554290771,
0.9026699662208557,
0.5507178902626038,
-0.04724698141217232,
-0.33658239245414734,
-0.5624288320541382,
0.5490012168884277,
0.31021273136138916,
-0.7960238456726074,
0.04778089001774788,
0.7218473553657532,
0.01695415936410427,
0.1948985904455185,
0.4627562165260315,
-0.39379021525382996,
0.5721295475959778,
0.04548793286085129,
0.1798599809408188,
-0.251222163438797,
-0.3466689884662628,
-0.6352049708366394,
-0.006207605358213186,
0.3223654627799988,
-0.42956241965293884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13269v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13269v1 | Investigating Low-Cost LLM Annotation for~Spoken Dialogue Understanding Datasets | 2024-06-19T06:59:57 | 2024-06-19T06:59:57 | Lucas Druart, Valentin Vielzeuf, Yannick Estève | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, eess.SP | In spoken Task-Oriented Dialogue (TOD) systems, the choice of the semantic
representation describing the users' requests is key to a smooth interaction.
Indeed, the system uses this representation to reason over a database and its
domain knowledge to choose its next action. The dialogue course thus depends on
the information provided by this semantic representation. While textual
datasets provide fine-grained semantic representations, spoken dialogue
datasets fall behind. This paper provides insights into automatic enhancement
of spoken dialogue datasets' semantic representations. Our contributions are
three fold: (1) assess the relevance of Large Language Model fine-tuning, (2)
evaluate the knowledge captured by the produced annotations and (3) highlight
semi-automatic annotation implications. | [
-0.5234663486480713,
-0.6129389405250549,
0.6266497373580933,
-0.0950145497918129,
-0.2297634780406952,
-0.13414324820041656,
-0.2147417962551117,
-0.6312984228134155,
0.004591368138790131,
1.0264694690704346,
-0.8411461710929871,
-0.5305690169334412,
-0.3812726140022278,
0.20114831626415253,
-0.2766876816749573,
0.9263221621513367,
0.20423898100852966,
0.04685463383793831,
-0.10377831012010574,
-0.17508257925510406,
-0.5704707503318787,
-0.3531332015991211,
-0.6912333369255066,
-0.6241553425788879,
0.50562584400177,
0.4939492642879486,
0.7580427527427673,
0.6847797632217407,
0.33012136816978455,
0.23923690617084503,
-0.01528537180274725,
0.3040326237678528,
-0.5718827843666077,
0.29158106446266174,
0.029816001653671265,
-0.6487600803375244,
-0.4839418828487396,
0.012210486456751823,
0.43134087324142456,
0.9793512225151062,
0.20604710280895233,
0.0704028457403183,
0.02898290753364563,
0.4962061643600464,
-0.25341957807540894,
0.4552876055240631,
-0.7019643187522888,
-0.009495612233877182,
-0.20638003945350647,
-0.19401989877223969,
-0.43614476919174194,
0.011844541877508163,
0.4197879731655121,
-0.7216904163360596,
-0.09653185307979584,
0.18242008984088898,
0.6281692385673523,
0.7453086972236633,
-0.3514821529388428,
-0.22887460887432098,
-0.704556941986084,
0.8391334414482117,
-0.6748031973838806,
0.16641896963119507,
0.6290585398674011,
0.27615880966186523,
-0.44496384263038635,
-0.3024444282054901,
-0.49858078360557556,
-0.25388291478157043,
-0.25180238485336304,
-0.0966818630695343,
-0.1117309108376503,
0.6109020113945007,
0.5455437898635864,
0.4424115717411041,
-0.12547168135643005,
0.4208717942237854,
-0.08000258356332779,
-0.4504310190677643,
0.6197249889373779,
0.3927546441555023,
0.06851690262556076,
-0.4584420919418335,
-0.16436812281608582,
0.136529803276062,
-0.7729429602622986,
-0.27101221680641174,
0.015085563063621521,
0.49446967244148254,
-0.23980139195919037,
0.8471664190292358,
-0.5495322942733765,
1.1202290058135986,
-0.11718762665987015,
-0.08394190669059753,
0.05394310504198074,
-0.6044022440910339,
-0.48735037446022034,
0.1280599981546402,
0.630163311958313,
0.5704020857810974,
0.6198968887329102,
-0.13829033076763153,
-0.17829792201519012,
-0.26354798674583435,
-0.05644720792770386,
-0.5299156308174133,
-0.13175047934055328,
0.22950801253318787,
-0.20823191106319427,
-0.08657745271921158,
-0.33265137672424316,
-0.38605037331581116,
-0.5914346575737,
-0.8136736750602722,
0.20562398433685303,
-0.2775830924510956,
0.21414679288864136,
0.12161511182785034,
-0.08516240864992142,
0.047725751996040344,
0.855813205242157,
-0.8208299279212952,
0.1442924290895462,
0.6346792578697205,
0.7916780114173889,
0.038947947323322296,
0.15087972581386566,
-0.5144811272621155,
0.2516855001449585,
-0.2222745269536972,
0.9415826797485352,
-0.5711804032325745,
-0.5588150024414062,
-0.04430834576487541,
0.003874239744618535,
0.0893646702170372,
-0.5855996608734131,
0.5096629858016968,
-0.19726842641830444,
0.04074181243777275,
-0.12893109023571014,
-0.6887820363044739,
-0.33223411440849304,
-0.005223866086453199,
-0.6660273671150208,
0.8979849815368652,
0.1679203361272812,
-0.5483269095420837,
0.5039108395576477,
-0.7768747210502625,
-0.03344380110502243,
-0.012524460442364216,
-0.026868557557463646,
0.07468456029891968,
0.18587952852249146,
0.4763679802417755,
0.6859757304191589,
-0.3240485191345215,
0.14373856782913208,
-0.2942386269569397,
-0.3015735447406769,
0.3400481939315796,
-0.5487202405929565,
0.4829258620738983,
0.14860843122005463,
-0.15955206751823425,
0.04850761592388153,
-0.911507248878479,
-0.14292097091674805,
-0.13325896859169006,
-0.30990901589393616,
-0.4551202356815338,
-0.11369670182466507,
-0.173993781208992,
-0.007217695005238056,
0.18374203145503998,
-0.45437106490135193,
0.17273351550102234,
-0.8297262787818909,
0.23501372337341309,
0.6921780705451965,
0.1430739015340805,
0.41031041741371155,
-0.27367809414863586,
0.12336455285549164,
0.11601272970438004,
-0.03447331115603447,
-0.3132117986679077,
-0.5210228562355042,
-1.0436146259307861,
-0.44523170590400696,
0.4224684238433838,
0.45366302132606506,
-0.8142254948616028,
0.18366537988185883,
-0.29000020027160645,
-0.21847392618656158,
-0.765445351600647,
0.30808010697364807,
0.29522302746772766,
0.3364032208919525,
0.21924521028995514,
-0.17128518223762512,
-0.5674801468849182,
-1.0760893821716309,
-0.11876711994409561,
-0.26955512166023254,
-0.25220587849617004,
0.560990571975708,
0.20863834023475647,
-0.3099476099014282,
1.3206490278244019,
-0.26943787932395935,
-0.3273247182369232,
-0.4147942364215851,
0.35269418358802795,
0.17755334079265594,
0.2519470751285553,
0.3159446120262146,
-0.5251655578613281,
-0.2915427088737488,
0.03679937496781349,
-0.5173439383506775,
-0.40706267952919006,
-0.20328719913959503,
-0.05079200118780136,
0.2573856711387634,
0.24943998456001282,
-0.43139323592185974,
0.6222168207168579,
0.3724830448627472,
-0.021550705656409264,
0.26072633266448975,
-0.15938015282154083,
0.1568608433008194,
-0.7317633628845215,
-0.245416060090065,
0.07205063849687576,
-0.5665708184242249,
-0.7985089421272278,
-0.5822012424468994,
-0.3902728855609894,
-0.17136938869953156,
-0.3583317697048187,
0.5924428105354309,
-0.2070692628622055,
-0.3077293932437897,
-0.2545355260372162,
0.7183632254600525,
-0.05310685932636261,
0.653255045413971,
0.15243341028690338,
0.9447084069252014,
0.3999633193016052,
-0.6722211241722107,
0.38376444578170776,
0.43036800622940063,
-0.3284585773944855,
0.4939349591732025,
-0.5302004814147949,
0.30987802147865295,
0.03752722963690758,
0.2310810685157776,
-0.9333878755569458,
-0.2992614507675171,
0.3252176344394684,
-0.2170775979757309,
0.015483850613236427,
-0.5986011028289795,
-0.5801113843917847,
0.08679327368736267,
-0.018625808879733086,
-0.016571030020713806,
0.09334000200033188,
-0.55312579870224,
0.48785707354545593,
0.5146850943565369,
-0.31061065196990967,
-0.18405944108963013,
-0.6436302065849304,
0.18687643110752106,
-0.14818449318408966,
-0.5642113089561462,
-0.023537689819931984,
0.22547677159309387,
-0.5955855846405029,
-0.28058797121047974,
0.001051726401783526,
0.21891731023788452,
0.29126620292663574,
0.5028542280197144,
0.1593516767024994,
-0.20240280032157898,
0.28608566522598267,
0.042387448251247406,
-0.4425354599952698,
-0.13600671291351318,
-0.356727659702301,
0.5074290633201599,
0.05943877249956131,
-0.46769213676452637,
-0.802617609500885,
0.3081018626689911,
0.39433908462524414,
0.022385386750102043,
0.44498881697654724,
0.4273257255554199,
-0.19020017981529236,
0.013235917314887047,
-0.47166159749031067,
-0.08421950787305832,
-0.4245813488960266,
0.21380488574504852,
-0.4095800220966339,
-1.0167045593261719,
0.47707074880599976,
-0.24361494183540344,
0.1247742772102356,
0.5755735039710999,
0.4907688498497009,
-0.3978351056575775,
1.005717396736145,
0.24151229858398438,
-0.15953180193901062,
0.47513148188591003,
-0.19152159988880157,
0.10076235234737396,
-0.8466360569000244,
-0.15707620978355408,
-0.6479429602622986,
-0.21676823496818542,
-0.6807632446289062,
-0.6609709858894348,
0.23977155983448029,
-0.1333605945110321,
0.039883408695459366,
0.19975920021533966,
-0.19968287646770477,
0.17737483978271484,
0.5784282684326172,
0.11604856699705124,
0.47726669907569885,
0.004351772367954254,
0.15623964369297028,
-0.03241179510951042,
-0.5745851993560791,
-0.7885568737983704,
0.9153356552124023,
0.49738451838493347,
0.9346301555633545,
0.021925823763012886,
0.6510388255119324,
0.5046437382698059,
-0.18574953079223633,
-1.102234959602356,
0.7395503520965576,
-0.06984893232584,
-0.24270617961883545,
-0.5702787041664124,
-0.32512158155441284,
-0.7944719791412354,
0.01644021086394787,
-0.22471320629119873,
-0.9625535607337952,
0.3152417838573456,
0.21319368481636047,
-0.3814042806625366,
-0.12555667757987976,
-0.7904989719390869,
0.574511706829071,
-0.034234657883644104,
-0.054962825030088425,
-0.40358105301856995,
-0.5308514833450317,
-0.004481646232306957,
0.12256510555744171,
-0.0191695224493742,
-0.3609068691730499,
0.12945254147052765,
0.8632782697677612,
-0.5302504301071167,
1.1826725006103516,
-0.4930328130722046,
-0.3186270296573639,
0.21984797716140747,
0.09672413021326065,
0.6770606637001038,
0.17088967561721802,
-0.13926805555820465,
0.14130111038684845,
-0.08810450881719589,
-0.2891242504119873,
-0.667847752571106,
0.44924288988113403,
-0.4385461211204529,
-0.9517673254013062,
-0.05724850669503212,
-0.6750293374061584,
-0.5928197503089905,
-0.13539113104343414,
-0.3057928681373596,
0.7127569317817688,
-0.08608824759721756,
0.04317048192024231,
0.7666248679161072,
-0.03986874595284462,
0.23490427434444427,
0.22389665246009827,
-0.17572645843029022,
-0.2336091250181198,
0.6536674499511719,
0.009206054732203484,
0.5212637782096863,
0.3084479570388794,
-0.04709359630942345,
-0.21785300970077515,
-0.7808789014816284,
-0.5894982814788818,
0.18099133670330048,
-0.8864710927009583,
-0.15517334640026093,
-0.6615152359008789,
0.011989615857601166,
-0.13296498358249664,
0.11337509751319885,
-0.05204734578728676,
-0.904114842414856,
-0.6597886681556702,
-0.2774038314819336,
0.8624535799026489,
0.7783138155937195,
0.07496385276317596,
0.6522678732872009,
-0.7539544105529785,
0.2686896026134491,
0.271786630153656,
0.22299633920192719,
-0.1934376358985901,
-0.4901393949985504,
-0.6253167986869812,
0.35101890563964844,
-0.01749354414641857,
-0.4871473014354706,
0.09904462099075317,
0.39545169472694397,
0.48158735036849976,
0.398455411195755,
0.052087072283029556,
0.8675326108932495,
-0.36402428150177,
0.9442470669746399,
-0.1554589867591858,
-0.9601001739501953,
0.9146612882614136,
-0.38394200801849365,
0.2668676972389221,
0.6915105581283569,
-0.0007356532150879502,
-0.5290475487709045,
-0.5911855101585388,
-0.38341453671455383,
-0.5631911754608154,
0.9962444305419922,
0.16626419126987457,
0.14569878578186035,
0.20719347894191742,
0.37142691016197205,
0.24557682871818542,
-0.04478088393807411,
-0.2738804817199707,
-0.18043376505374908,
-0.09516347199678421,
-0.34965842962265015,
-0.19820444285869598,
-0.36653023958206177,
-0.14988218247890472,
-0.0483957938849926,
0.5908145308494568,
-0.3763880431652069,
0.44429630041122437,
0.15109241008758545,
-0.3788979947566986,
0.15767823159694672,
0.33293044567108154,
0.6206831336021423,
0.3364836275577545,
-0.2247561812400818,
-0.07304611802101135,
0.24541087448596954,
-0.20398913323879242,
-0.1475013941526413,
0.10257280617952347,
0.07516571134328842,
0.20759126543998718,
0.4563398063182831,
1.3003655672073364,
0.35840654373168945,
-0.7342948913574219,
0.21073566377162933,
-0.0014473432675004005,
0.1360815167427063,
-0.16328434646129608,
0.4104524850845337,
-0.14970636367797852,
0.24114446341991425,
0.12588949501514435,
-0.10996288061141968,
0.3129778504371643,
-0.4882447421550751,
0.10426010936498642,
0.42980632185935974,
-0.5814974904060364,
-0.10452757030725479,
0.14718885719776154,
0.4794265329837799,
-0.23767665028572083,
0.4399470090866089,
0.08174047619104385,
-0.4446098804473877,
0.17272867262363434,
0.09597653150558472,
0.6595833897590637,
0.2500354051589966,
0.13329355418682098,
0.0430457778275013,
0.04419729858636856,
0.2644423842430115,
0.057950910180807114,
-0.4688660204410553,
-0.5678095817565918,
-0.4924747943878174,
-0.45666006207466125,
-0.7103846669197083,
-0.21608488261699677,
-0.4626427888870239,
0.404278963804245,
-0.23493541777133942,
-0.2619676887989044,
0.0008276990265585482,
0.13027481734752655,
-0.8111737370491028,
0.31568643450737,
0.2265477329492569,
0.9337964653968811,
-0.5618845820426941,
0.9764335751533508,
0.22710327804088593,
-0.31677690148353577,
-0.630730152130127,
-0.013753988780081272,
0.08004119992256165,
-1.0789015293121338,
0.9379830360412598,
-0.11128738522529602,
-0.23409363627433777,
0.022095784544944763,
-0.29386404156684875,
-0.5872089266777039,
0.8440325260162354,
0.33035239577293396,
-0.6983982920646667,
0.041932668536901474,
0.5542128086090088,
0.47319310903549194,
-0.5418283939361572,
0.37311726808547974,
0.8952800035476685,
0.5190654397010803,
0.0673232227563858,
-1.111133337020874,
-0.13231034576892853,
0.06950921565294266,
0.06257137656211853,
0.1598101109266281,
-0.18339969217777252,
0.176466703414917,
0.008870039135217667,
-0.18656155467033386,
0.17088359594345093,
0.529874324798584,
-0.13588880002498627,
0.4522245526313782,
0.5825327634811401,
0.40565061569213867,
0.7157966494560242,
-0.5279302000999451,
1.0685027837753296,
0.0016441105399280787,
0.1622360795736313,
1.2316222190856934,
-0.157698854804039,
0.6448405981063843,
0.6250289678573608,
-0.1329861730337143,
0.23058883845806122,
0.9171417951583862,
0.1367945522069931,
0.5350303649902344,
0.24837848544120789,
-0.23957860469818115,
-0.3835781514644623,
-0.46872755885124207,
0.07477149367332458,
0.6596910953521729,
0.7962893843650818,
-0.35314562916755676,
-0.1826079934835434,
0.24642935395240784,
-0.1464393585920334,
-0.23445187509059906,
-0.32245728373527527,
1.558320164680481,
0.1423424333333969,
-0.34728339314460754,
0.7096648216247559,
-0.35242509841918945,
0.346987783908844,
-0.3065105080604553,
-0.020713133737444878,
-0.2943395674228668,
-0.39240631461143494,
-0.29042360186576843,
-0.7690215706825256,
0.21145297586917877,
0.18143220245838165,
-0.08342485874891281,
-0.22282098233699799,
0.7142202854156494,
-0.3564445376396179,
-0.17940644919872284,
0.25749489665031433,
0.32304197549819946,
0.35013824701309204,
0.07374732941389084,
-0.48004350066185,
0.10038835555315018,
0.1843145191669464,
-0.12192603945732117,
0.047110091894865036,
0.7572407722473145,
-0.0379052460193634,
0.7212826609611511,
0.4749414026737213,
0.25252920389175415,
-0.1340167373418808,
0.607278048992157,
0.8716689944267273,
-0.6784923076629639,
-0.043943848460912704,
-0.6614776253700256,
0.6907374262809753,
-0.20740407705307007,
-0.055285003036260605,
0.44300535321235657,
0.26351454854011536,
0.6980369687080383,
0.16048605740070343,
0.897315502166748,
0.1558581292629242,
0.6264564990997314,
-0.9464697241783142,
0.370859831571579,
-0.40499913692474365,
0.5470597147941589,
-0.09399798512458801,
-0.7049568891525269,
-0.32182732224464417,
0.4443069100379944,
-0.590440034866333,
-0.1730041801929474,
0.278480589389801,
0.9163028597831726,
0.021420102566480637,
0.38071301579475403,
0.4921036660671234,
0.2733955383300781,
0.24913232028484344,
0.2439717799425125,
0.9740381836891174,
-0.1800166517496109,
0.17337192595005035,
-0.13626600801944733,
-0.044066064059734344,
-0.4686025083065033,
-0.6766379475593567,
-1.0308749675750732,
-0.5971403121948242,
-0.4158490300178528,
-0.07252345234155655,
0.0738203153014183,
1.1326549053192139,
0.6819902062416077,
-0.8027252554893494,
-0.10702160000801086,
0.15576021373271942,
0.2025994509458542,
0.07878690958023071,
-0.1642906665802002,
0.09392815083265305,
-0.5023776888847351,
-0.9199154376983643,
0.48205533623695374,
0.544471263885498,
0.18734999001026154,
-0.28163838386535645,
-0.06913250684738159,
0.06115548312664032,
0.15780822932720184,
0.5500214099884033,
-0.0643259584903717,
-1.081087589263916,
-0.6338030099868774,
-0.3786475658416748,
0.0731101930141449,
0.3412730097770691,
0.9058970808982849,
-0.8716481328010559,
0.5885833501815796,
0.24454045295715332,
0.5821852684020996,
0.5151896476745605,
-0.11920031905174255,
0.7911663055419922,
-0.7289478182792664,
0.24991253018379211,
0.23953589797019958,
0.4316961169242859,
0.4581265449523926,
-0.37580758333206177,
0.40424033999443054,
-0.010495170019567013,
-0.42208167910575867,
-0.7046235203742981,
0.3208127021789551,
-1.2391350269317627,
0.2150876820087433,
1.004791021347046,
-0.22141216695308685,
-0.1354256123304367,
-0.5948163270950317,
-0.5819296836853027,
0.1860567033290863,
-0.5919182300567627,
0.39142924547195435,
0.7365353107452393,
-0.369936466217041,
-0.32124197483062744,
-0.6586077213287354,
0.7092980742454529,
0.28655943274497986,
-0.745918869972229,
0.5670595765113831,
0.6223081350326538,
-0.20938390493392944,
0.05422567203640938,
0.4124029874801636,
0.13895995914936066,
0.07236459106206894,
-0.3524825870990753,
-0.3046385943889618,
0.0377362035214901,
-0.05011643096804619,
-0.3635341227054596,
-0.28056466579437256,
0.43632805347442627,
-0.17893117666244507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13261v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13261v2 | BeHonest: Benchmarking Honesty of Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T06:46:59 | 2024-07-01T15:18:07 | Steffi Chern, Zhulin Hu, Yuqing Yang, Ethan Chern, Yuan Guo, Jiahe Jin, Binjie Wang, Pengfei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Previous works on Large Language Models (LLMs) have mainly focused on
evaluating their helpfulness or harmlessness. However, honesty, another crucial
alignment criterion, has received relatively less attention. Dishonest
behaviors in LLMs, such as spreading misinformation and defrauding users,
eroding user trust, and causing real-world harm, present severe risks that
intensify as these models approach superintelligence levels. Enhancing honesty
in LLMs addresses critical deficiencies and helps uncover latent capabilities
that are not readily expressed. This underscores the urgent need for reliable
methods and benchmarks to effectively ensure and evaluate the honesty of LLMs.
In this paper, we introduce BeHonest, a pioneering benchmark specifically
designed to assess honesty in LLMs comprehensively. BeHonest evaluates three
essential aspects of honesty: awareness of knowledge boundaries, avoidance of
deceit, and consistency in responses. Building on this foundation, we designed
10 scenarios to evaluate and analyze 9 popular LLMs on the market, including
both closed-source and open-source models from different model families with
varied model sizes. Our findings indicate that there is still significant room
for improvement in the honesty of LLMs. We also encourage the AI community to
prioritize honesty alignment in LLMs. Our benchmark and code can be found at:
\url{https://github.com/GAIR-NLP/BeHonest}. | [
0.13073252141475677,
-0.5545740723609924,
0.5620585680007935,
0.346752792596817,
-0.12232983857393265,
0.16337038576602936,
-0.4884384870529175,
-0.5650755167007446,
-0.2859150767326355,
0.4412035644054413,
-0.5010530948638916,
-0.5729343295097351,
-0.7178254723548889,
-0.1430514007806778,
-0.4470469355583191,
0.8613019585609436,
-0.00250196922570467,
0.1738429069519043,
-0.21359297633171082,
-0.3456844985485077,
-0.26275479793548584,
-0.396218478679657,
-0.6022575497627258,
-0.5336076021194458,
0.30314555764198303,
0.21347959339618683,
0.7869173288345337,
0.6115878224372864,
0.7648460865020752,
0.31935063004493713,
-0.17884089052677155,
0.07210205495357513,
-0.6437961459159851,
0.5719162821769714,
-0.40502455830574036,
-0.4800723195075989,
-0.5436740517616272,
0.2317851185798645,
0.2879338562488556,
0.6804954409599304,
-0.3138716220855713,
0.4096486568450928,
0.3336391746997833,
0.5058259963989258,
-0.7550800442695618,
0.10728718340396881,
-0.6755618453025818,
-0.338001012802124,
-0.26299160718917847,
0.14889217913150787,
-0.29690438508987427,
-0.9494031667709351,
0.32410672307014465,
-0.3310953378677368,
-0.3290793001651764,
0.1867649406194687,
0.8949589133262634,
0.4199399948120117,
-0.19703315198421478,
-0.394184947013855,
-0.5705915689468384,
1.0759825706481934,
-1.0129878520965576,
0.5296520590782166,
0.19657211005687714,
0.5182280540466309,
-0.21778292953968048,
-0.6612020134925842,
-0.5134985446929932,
-0.27874085307121277,
0.13507981598377228,
0.014551172032952309,
-0.3055499792098999,
-0.1396084427833557,
0.28920772671699524,
0.49023357033729553,
-0.6650553345680237,
0.23675240576267242,
0.16436472535133362,
-0.4707026183605194,
0.6838028430938721,
-0.04499668627977371,
0.1276148110628128,
0.16631783545017242,
-0.6056813597679138,
-0.2005639523267746,
-0.7930716872215271,
-0.03964606299996376,
0.7733042240142822,
-0.002769964747130871,
-0.2687639892101288,
0.6898535490036011,
-0.22558870911598206,
0.3642484247684479,
-0.1844363957643509,
-0.16600170731544495,
0.2806195318698883,
-0.5722413659095764,
-0.11980144679546356,
0.16442905366420746,
0.8289523720741272,
0.5401594638824463,
0.6174681782722473,
-0.11971398442983627,
-0.46821704506874084,
0.28470033407211304,
0.22909344732761383,
-0.7604235410690308,
-0.028264876455068588,
0.24276012182235718,
-0.5416579246520996,
-0.4413459599018097,
0.02360040321946144,
-0.5810192227363586,
-0.4592958390712738,
-0.23739126324653625,
0.40471333265304565,
-0.716090738773346,
-0.1654791235923767,
0.056668367236852646,
0.07112473249435425,
0.3901394307613373,
0.33260881900787354,
-0.6547857522964478,
0.5533154606819153,
1.1247458457946777,
0.6854924559593201,
-0.11426828801631927,
-0.3942503035068512,
-0.6915478110313416,
0.0678047314286232,
-0.4666638970375061,
0.45371076464653015,
-0.5094930529594421,
-0.21103891730308533,
0.05954623594880104,
-0.2771497368812561,
0.42964884638786316,
-0.539132833480835,
0.9880689978599548,
-0.23699495196342468,
0.02533557452261448,
-0.25898876786231995,
-0.8909071087837219,
-0.20377987623214722,
0.6245304346084595,
-0.2385871410369873,
1.0334341526031494,
0.1369449645280838,
-0.5375493764877319,
0.10065437853336334,
-0.48468077182769775,
-0.22099924087524414,
-0.010515392757952213,
-0.32943806052207947,
-0.41911470890045166,
0.3102126717567444,
0.11484444886445999,
0.27373823523521423,
-0.48748770356178284,
0.44023558497428894,
-0.33963271975517273,
-0.3414795398712158,
0.7025535106658936,
-0.7404906153678894,
0.9543086290359497,
0.04465575888752937,
-0.4272260367870331,
0.0795559361577034,
-0.40818068385124207,
0.24700872600078583,
-0.06141578406095505,
-0.050353556871414185,
-0.3116699159145355,
-0.16501566767692566,
-0.10066892206668854,
0.012785732746124268,
0.6220563650131226,
-0.8128859996795654,
-0.09752367436885834,
-0.5134832262992859,
0.2302485555410385,
1.0698926448822021,
-0.2679828703403473,
0.12824612855911255,
-0.5670899152755737,
0.28006505966186523,
-0.0844721719622612,
0.5021655559539795,
-0.08272849023342133,
-0.07309602200984955,
-0.6125807762145996,
-0.14448174834251404,
0.6727920770645142,
0.35113397240638733,
-0.3371890187263489,
0.666519045829773,
-0.6809362173080444,
-0.6531326770782471,
-0.6664370894432068,
0.10123246163129807,
0.7520318031311035,
0.3587237596511841,
0.11929500848054886,
-0.43866175413131714,
-0.21213269233703613,
-1.1767066717147827,
-0.6504853367805481,
-0.3055700659751892,
-0.13138975203037262,
0.506858229637146,
0.39080479741096497,
0.024450475350022316,
0.7509978413581848,
-0.28289172053337097,
-0.26550447940826416,
0.025143085047602654,
-0.01892680861055851,
0.24099993705749512,
0.5771865844726562,
0.29472917318344116,
-0.6591795682907104,
-0.47324422001838684,
0.04600026085972786,
-0.8910359144210815,
-0.2557564675807953,
0.25129392743110657,
0.05985840782523155,
0.257427841424942,
0.5504899621009827,
-0.656167209148407,
0.32971104979515076,
0.9860266447067261,
-0.22202107310295105,
0.7589592933654785,
-0.11735334247350693,
0.02005235105752945,
-0.9076544046401978,
0.20583860576152802,
-0.28376147150993347,
-0.4729425013065338,
-0.3461477756500244,
0.1850564330816269,
0.04815857484936714,
0.1695229411125183,
-0.4163980484008789,
0.6270751953125,
-0.4421091377735138,
-0.3626154959201813,
0.022027648985385895,
0.33481910824775696,
-0.008895807899534702,
0.19276438653469086,
-0.4859866797924042,
0.7961852550506592,
0.5613170862197876,
-0.2566787898540497,
0.5099359154701233,
0.24657069146633148,
-0.5434324145317078,
0.9203521013259888,
-0.8517166972160339,
0.36944064497947693,
0.4116832911968231,
0.12905174493789673,
-0.8574073910713196,
-0.023301947861909866,
0.12770991027355194,
-0.6771517395973206,
0.17183439433574677,
-0.2623034417629242,
-0.7416195273399353,
0.08901307731866837,
-0.4784527122974396,
0.18964321911334991,
0.4578193426132202,
-0.5901933908462524,
0.616736888885498,
0.20070260763168335,
-0.39183223247528076,
-0.8093709349632263,
-0.6268664002418518,
0.14297236502170563,
0.05680135637521744,
-0.6590231657028198,
0.3242662847042084,
-0.29597344994544983,
-0.5251957178115845,
0.007192736957222223,
-0.39479249715805054,
0.15357141196727753,
0.19916808605194092,
0.3190165162086487,
0.35962021350860596,
-0.29723116755485535,
-0.14323163032531738,
-0.09436719864606857,
-0.35569077730178833,
0.08907591551542282,
-0.4282042384147644,
0.6910023093223572,
-0.27542823553085327,
-0.5522421598434448,
-0.44175586104393005,
0.010614722035825253,
0.6215518712997437,
-0.2867099344730377,
0.6144773960113525,
0.25337255001068115,
-0.3495011627674103,
-0.17717832326889038,
-0.8868831992149353,
-0.30646154284477234,
-0.5216885805130005,
0.05644743889570236,
-0.1247292309999466,
-0.9463282823562622,
0.4388733506202698,
-0.3414495587348938,
0.324685275554657,
-0.1460445076227188,
0.39653611183166504,
0.07240141183137894,
0.6867985129356384,
0.6095529198646545,
-0.340942919254303,
-0.05904260277748108,
0.3133735954761505,
0.3558467924594879,
-0.8030723929405212,
-0.04292422905564308,
-0.6797739267349243,
-0.41801679134368896,
-0.801804780960083,
-0.35250112414360046,
0.22732877731323242,
0.030149202793836594,
-0.2967950403690338,
-0.022072795778512955,
-0.2775271534919739,
0.6804144978523254,
0.45281684398651123,
-0.08105462044477463,
0.44995227456092834,
-0.3138786256313324,
-0.12780152261257172,
-0.12078748643398285,
-0.22634221613407135,
-0.7997738718986511,
1.2244048118591309,
0.5806991457939148,
0.8443151712417603,
0.5788940191268921,
0.5941841006278992,
0.0314883217215538,
0.3207411766052246,
-0.620738685131073,
0.6792706251144409,
-0.2344774454832077,
-0.5642754435539246,
-0.5269902944564819,
-0.3567880094051361,
-0.6203887462615967,
-0.05083427205681801,
-0.10033873468637466,
-0.7810578942298889,
0.045188747346401215,
0.12256871163845062,
-0.16554537415504456,
0.007048667408525944,
-0.36587050557136536,
0.7659804821014404,
-0.2836691737174988,
-0.3660208582878113,
-0.0497145839035511,
-0.6451547741889954,
0.39481720328330994,
-0.1732187718153,
-0.0017445830162614584,
-0.3488110899925232,
-0.19623437523841858,
0.38177984952926636,
-0.33669063448905945,
0.6441994309425354,
0.058359529823064804,
-0.06195729598402977,
-0.2108517736196518,
0.4249229431152344,
0.9268618226051331,
0.023804225027561188,
-0.416989266872406,
0.5294795036315918,
-0.023584501817822456,
-0.340290904045105,
-0.6206754446029663,
0.8413078188896179,
-0.6155111193656921,
-0.3287582993507385,
-0.24727481603622437,
-0.4940105378627777,
-0.3000755310058594,
0.44970300793647766,
0.2547222375869751,
0.37339702248573303,
-0.5229537487030029,
0.38569721579551697,
0.9181792736053467,
-0.20357656478881836,
0.4266842007637024,
0.5947343111038208,
-0.5167871117591858,
-0.027353951707482338,
0.720463216304779,
-0.0741158053278923,
0.35436344146728516,
0.041947025805711746,
0.267364501953125,
-0.5198821425437927,
-0.7586345672607422,
-0.18381978571414948,
0.13922014832496643,
-0.546686053276062,
-0.39644014835357666,
-0.35961171984672546,
-0.35090744495391846,
-0.4853399097919464,
-0.03461259976029396,
-0.8260959982872009,
-0.22918666899204254,
0.33196258544921875,
-0.043422967195510864,
0.20400820672512054,
0.4771273732185364,
-0.04782078042626381,
0.3820822536945343,
-0.5536940693855286,
-0.02256932109594345,
0.1883743703365326,
0.665438175201416,
-0.3034209907054901,
-0.4393465220928192,
0.16692933440208435,
0.011672010645270348,
-0.18917931616306305,
-0.43678411841392517,
0.12897169589996338,
0.030750470235943794,
0.634446918964386,
0.3923899233341217,
0.22387953102588654,
0.23416826128959656,
-0.4166361689567566,
0.6683775186538696,
0.07900426536798477,
-1.310495376586914,
0.3299838900566101,
-0.3561655879020691,
0.024325648322701454,
0.9052026867866516,
0.20474767684936523,
-0.6484586000442505,
-0.4752151668071747,
-0.7370193004608154,
-0.6324750185012817,
0.46748441457748413,
0.37177765369415283,
0.15274548530578613,
0.38431498408317566,
0.2752765417098999,
0.4257357716560364,
0.541713297367096,
-0.6767088770866394,
-0.367444783449173,
-0.006258207373321056,
-0.38964951038360596,
-0.20675452053546906,
-0.36311620473861694,
-0.2445676177740097,
0.32660266757011414,
0.6797058582305908,
-0.05064300447702408,
-0.10175463557243347,
-0.09630212187767029,
-0.22046232223510742,
0.15033461153507233,
0.4147742986679077,
0.4272178113460541,
0.7747783660888672,
-0.1104293167591095,
0.3875355124473572,
0.086058109998703,
-0.4373718798160553,
0.07763895392417908,
0.13686108589172363,
-0.13934282958507538,
-0.026927027851343155,
0.3544858396053314,
0.37962910532951355,
0.23286905884742737,
-0.6737515330314636,
0.9652259349822998,
-0.1012667566537857,
-0.20326966047286987,
-0.5140130519866943,
0.1561761200428009,
0.21758157014846802,
0.2638667821884155,
-0.042585913091897964,
-0.09472829848527908,
-0.005294138565659523,
-0.4994935989379883,
0.1432919055223465,
0.5445274114608765,
-0.5989527106285095,
-0.21494652330875397,
0.25015774369239807,
0.1973540484905243,
-0.5012525916099548,
0.8422438502311707,
-0.17008459568023682,
-0.5836688280105591,
0.12354721873998642,
0.30851560831069946,
0.7885785698890686,
-0.5943026542663574,
0.08991669118404388,
-0.09751426428556442,
0.6598232388496399,
-0.16928550601005554,
0.3413717746734619,
0.20555993914604187,
-0.9159433841705322,
-0.41782432794570923,
-0.601279616355896,
-0.6893107891082764,
0.1613852083683014,
-0.6061781048774719,
0.13923010230064392,
-0.5686807036399841,
0.06466598808765411,
-0.04408176988363266,
0.20586369931697845,
-0.46482211351394653,
-0.03974142298102379,
-0.04411676153540611,
1.1044363975524902,
-0.5017598271369934,
0.7356635928153992,
0.3783855736255646,
0.00196944666095078,
-0.7864648699760437,
0.17121271789073944,
0.2829081416130066,
-0.8595741391181946,
0.4359848201274872,
0.22960521280765533,
-0.32707637548446655,
0.013109012506902218,
-0.9025569558143616,
-0.6420583724975586,
0.9604634642601013,
0.6883238554000854,
-0.843684196472168,
0.40167364478111267,
0.24568255245685577,
0.4157986342906952,
-0.404254674911499,
0.2811740040779114,
0.6151942014694214,
0.6332620978355408,
-0.26161500811576843,
-1.0785835981369019,
0.13378287851810455,
-0.06822550296783447,
-0.062139734625816345,
0.05334120988845825,
-0.7266864776611328,
0.782250165939331,
0.07876995950937271,
-0.11445406824350357,
0.22376850247383118,
0.4905942380428314,
0.39572396874427795,
0.3461560308933258,
0.5519281029701233,
0.44591909646987915,
1.0075346231460571,
-0.23355083167552948,
0.92033851146698,
-0.31445378065109253,
0.20207510888576508,
1.3404303789138794,
-0.6703882813453674,
0.7916796207427979,
0.44783955812454224,
0.034274470061063766,
0.3832194209098816,
0.3460039794445038,
-0.03459221497178078,
0.22180448472499847,
0.37005555629730225,
-0.13311387598514557,
-0.19135354459285736,
-0.4714808166027069,
-0.26018667221069336,
0.60882967710495,
0.22622841596603394,
-0.08528939634561539,
-0.18929189443588257,
-0.3915356397628784,
0.3107113540172577,
0.2279643714427948,
0.013646342791616917,
0.5937737822532654,
0.16917169094085693,
-0.5245492458343506,
0.179439514875412,
-0.12511736154556274,
0.6947354078292847,
-0.618183434009552,
0.08009509742259979,
-0.35830017924308777,
0.28742119669914246,
-0.02772481180727482,
-0.8237962126731873,
0.07136241346597672,
-0.03903323784470558,
0.011662045493721962,
-0.12160460650920868,
0.577081024646759,
-0.3174675405025482,
-0.21743075549602509,
0.44043484330177307,
0.6919440627098083,
0.30908215045928955,
-0.1629800647497177,
-0.8952186703681946,
0.6029083728790283,
-0.10805417597293854,
-0.10550610721111298,
0.21746739745140076,
0.5266572833061218,
0.07607893645763397,
0.9209315180778503,
0.8106021881103516,
0.245774507522583,
-0.28107309341430664,
0.0769667699933052,
0.7472065091133118,
-0.44013074040412903,
-0.3222249150276184,
-1.0948415994644165,
0.1273297369480133,
-0.4300483167171478,
-0.38479819893836975,
0.9889266490936279,
0.8606480956077576,
0.8177388906478882,
0.5502631664276123,
0.7618873119354248,
0.38701289892196655,
0.7901743650436401,
-0.5249522924423218,
0.7544325590133667,
-0.22344835102558136,
0.6100297570228577,
-0.28422313928604126,
-1.2460875511169434,
-0.03543553501367569,
0.4693116545677185,
-0.28574642539024353,
0.09438254684209824,
0.6535229086875916,
0.9857306480407715,
-0.07804019004106522,
0.2747766971588135,
0.44571125507354736,
0.5515743494033813,
0.2227504998445511,
0.33213263750076294,
1.1572097539901733,
-0.3362644612789154,
0.4884112477302551,
-0.2345598191022873,
-0.31499946117401123,
-0.22505778074264526,
-1.0791782140731812,
-0.6804367303848267,
-0.10820614546537399,
-0.33283472061157227,
-0.353525847196579,
0.40264856815338135,
0.787585973739624,
0.6529288291931152,
-0.5176482200622559,
-0.3119683265686035,
0.0448196716606617,
0.26094722747802734,
-0.26467329263687134,
-0.1220884844660759,
0.23904740810394287,
-0.2548353374004364,
-0.6469147205352783,
0.3090408742427826,
0.5849103331565857,
0.057005200535058975,
-0.42640841007232666,
-0.10663668811321259,
0.16171488165855408,
0.24507522583007812,
0.2694959342479706,
-0.15459199249744415,
-0.5662869215011597,
-0.5504873394966125,
0.10257305949926376,
-0.28520694375038147,
-0.1363362967967987,
0.6202385425567627,
-0.39765217900276184,
0.13448922336101532,
0.10143044590950012,
0.5745862126350403,
0.18432779610157013,
0.028017666190862656,
0.7024863958358765,
-0.7427096962928772,
-0.2043001353740692,
0.3677491247653961,
0.16138829290866852,
0.48782357573509216,
-0.2268741875886917,
0.6637744903564453,
-0.2307521551847458,
-0.7573578357696533,
-1.0863908529281616,
0.13420820236206055,
-0.9224649667739868,
-0.2678220272064209,
1.0170838832855225,
-0.4218479096889496,
-0.2787461280822754,
-0.3602747321128845,
0.12562121450901031,
0.029023578390479088,
-0.38819625973701477,
0.6426899433135986,
0.8358070850372314,
0.1566172093153,
0.12529437243938446,
-0.5627060532569885,
0.471929132938385,
0.555095911026001,
-0.7660250663757324,
0.639784574508667,
0.42076560854911804,
0.2903438210487366,
0.10326802730560303,
0.4808504581451416,
-0.30201059579849243,
0.1686735302209854,
-0.05162744224071503,
-0.06490590423345566,
-0.0006844323943369091,
-0.06433960795402527,
-0.26685723662376404,
-0.10686571896076202,
0.2806631922721863,
-0.058892715722322464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13250v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13250v1 | LangTopo: Aligning Language Descriptions of Graphs with Tokenized Topological Modeling | 2024-06-19T06:20:22 | 2024-06-19T06:20:22 | Zhong Guan, Hongke Zhao, Likang Wu, Ming He, Jianpin Fan | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recently, large language models (LLMs) have been widely researched in the
field of graph machine learning due to their outstanding abilities in language
comprehension and learning. However, the significant gap between natural
language tasks and topological structure modeling poses a nonnegligible
challenge. Specifically, since natural language descriptions are not sufficient
for LLMs to understand and process graph-structured data, fine-tuned LLMs
perform even worse than some traditional GNN models on graph tasks, lacking
inherent modeling capabilities for graph structures. Existing research overly
emphasizes LLMs' understanding of semantic information captured by external
models, while inadequately exploring graph topological structure modeling,
thereby overlooking the genuine capabilities that LLMs lack. Consequently, in
this paper, we introduce a new framework, LangTopo, which aligns graph
structure modeling with natural language understanding at the token level.
LangTopo quantifies the graph structure modeling capabilities of GNNs and LLMs
by constructing a codebook for the graph modality and performs consistency
maximization. This process aligns the text description of LLM with the
topological modeling of GNN, allowing LLM to learn the ability of GNN to
capture graph structures, enabling LLM to handle graph-structured data
independently. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed method on
multiple datasets. | [
-0.17801256477832794,
-0.8603222966194153,
0.38675346970558167,
-0.3483711779117584,
-0.2719884216785431,
0.3285543620586395,
-0.43984994292259216,
-0.39612358808517456,
0.41446632146835327,
0.7384837865829468,
-0.20449981093406677,
-0.8443400263786316,
-0.650307297706604,
0.1026751920580864,
-0.3157559931278229,
1.0075466632843018,
-0.16447310149669647,
-0.050046976655721664,
-0.3623993396759033,
-0.007974643260240555,
-0.313100129365921,
-0.3574817478656769,
-0.6627402901649475,
-0.39749225974082947,
0.43984925746917725,
0.31525367498397827,
1.0310786962509155,
0.7509573698043823,
0.33035534620285034,
0.43580523133277893,
-0.23065736889839172,
0.39275527000427246,
-0.6141688227653503,
-0.29979369044303894,
0.0676284208893776,
-0.2321213334798813,
-0.7071775197982788,
-0.4702080190181732,
1.1091810464859009,
1.1070563793182373,
-0.04314308241009712,
-0.17083962261676788,
0.2154911309480667,
0.573169469833374,
-0.03268517181277275,
0.49570411443710327,
-0.9176009297370911,
-0.07523747533559799,
0.028107093647122383,
0.040416695177555084,
-0.43715986609458923,
-0.3132004141807556,
-0.1391741931438446,
-0.9491732716560364,
0.12646989524364471,
0.2659108340740204,
1.0863741636276245,
0.2519759237766266,
-0.4199273884296417,
-0.1564672589302063,
-0.329496294260025,
0.35112136602401733,
-0.6219006180763245,
0.37464720010757446,
0.3216809034347534,
0.4150392413139343,
-0.33048155903816223,
-0.5093151926994324,
-0.5436176061630249,
-0.023974915966391563,
-0.5116316676139832,
-0.22537218034267426,
0.10205194354057312,
0.27495503425598145,
-0.11755029857158661,
0.5906314849853516,
-0.7524260878562927,
0.44434237480163574,
-0.3628538250923157,
-0.42097121477127075,
0.32472488284111023,
0.0685020461678505,
0.47047919034957886,
-0.31998029351234436,
-0.46083909273147583,
0.11653845012187958,
-0.6552807688713074,
-0.07389254122972488,
0.21756663918495178,
0.9753076434135437,
-0.306709885597229,
0.5985754132270813,
-0.10238217562437057,
0.9858511686325073,
-0.35679876804351807,
-0.1912916600704193,
0.21919851005077362,
-0.3726392388343811,
-0.40529853105545044,
0.0627666562795639,
0.7268784642219543,
0.2642604410648346,
0.4180873930454254,
-0.6357991099357605,
-0.03217589110136032,
-0.2402869462966919,
0.1582503765821457,
-0.7750299572944641,
-0.09396270662546158,
0.2408124953508377,
-0.25938680768013,
-0.4345259666442871,
0.07013746351003647,
-0.6984001994132996,
-0.4655395448207855,
-0.41682982444763184,
-0.024401389062404633,
-0.17774038016796112,
-0.33917903900146484,
0.17413000762462616,
0.17827391624450684,
0.05076860263943672,
0.21314412355422974,
-0.7060632109642029,
0.7202581167221069,
0.9236558079719543,
1.0775012969970703,
-0.3541627824306488,
-0.3787992298603058,
-0.6577700972557068,
0.29747793078422546,
-0.4863075911998749,
0.32067015767097473,
-0.610751748085022,
-0.17980743944644928,
0.011980066075921059,
0.3981955349445343,
-0.24460512399673462,
-0.18209175765514374,
0.2708398103713989,
-0.4035342037677765,
0.2040037363767624,
-0.08319154381752014,
-0.6981518268585205,
-0.15541549026966095,
0.4743630290031433,
-0.6128963828086853,
0.9382001161575317,
0.3091461956501007,
-0.9719641208648682,
0.104713074862957,
-0.33532193303108215,
-0.30356159806251526,
0.16808350384235382,
-0.4450051486492157,
-0.49701988697052,
-0.17699913680553436,
0.38600561022758484,
0.3324454426765442,
-0.07901544868946075,
0.6144899129867554,
-0.2368924468755722,
-0.33874794840812683,
0.11736136674880981,
0.2342371642589569,
0.7603463530540466,
0.04365358501672745,
0.008289162069559097,
0.46290481090545654,
-0.32262369990348816,
-0.0789145976305008,
0.0912255346775055,
-0.15223784744739532,
-0.015754083171486855,
0.031175890937447548,
-0.026169223710894585,
-0.025560475885868073,
0.43697935342788696,
-0.4958888292312622,
0.46180325746536255,
-0.5986641645431519,
0.5017663240432739,
0.872394323348999,
-0.4058789908885956,
0.4055953025817871,
-0.2597876191139221,
0.5038216710090637,
-0.44040682911872864,
-0.12011779844760895,
0.017939189448952675,
-0.318336546421051,
-0.5361641645431519,
-0.5121826529502869,
0.2724344730377197,
0.5431283116340637,
-0.612636148929596,
0.5328375101089478,
-0.8245636820793152,
-0.20837606489658356,
0.10114125907421112,
0.16430538892745972,
0.3369745910167694,
0.7878283262252808,
0.24399396777153015,
-0.2353077232837677,
-0.49106407165527344,
-0.6722592711448669,
0.11707708239555359,
-0.1822449117898941,
0.12577222287654877,
0.6628791689872742,
0.19716010987758636,
-0.21116600930690765,
0.9886006116867065,
-0.4695621430873871,
-0.4569246172904968,
-0.38596177101135254,
-0.08461179584264755,
0.3940003514289856,
0.3604881763458252,
0.43284842371940613,
-0.47191545367240906,
-0.41563522815704346,
0.5013185143470764,
-0.7302847504615784,
-0.06544265896081924,
0.15196527540683746,
-0.26415807008743286,
0.08495046198368073,
0.6862066984176636,
-0.6067140698432922,
-0.005697435699403286,
0.5748103260993958,
-0.2737600803375244,
0.35099831223487854,
0.016527537256479263,
-0.005896531976759434,
-1.3670966625213623,
0.22885121405124664,
-0.3390676975250244,
-0.5173032879829407,
-0.5383333563804626,
0.2961646616458893,
-0.3173726499080658,
-0.5652959942817688,
-0.1352379471063614,
1.0694459676742554,
-0.5142905116081238,
-0.33448556065559387,
-0.1837400645017624,
0.5510284900665283,
0.11579336225986481,
0.5893486142158508,
0.06988310813903809,
0.5938266515731812,
0.9652242660522461,
-0.3389674127101898,
0.1986936330795288,
0.3910665512084961,
-0.06296423822641373,
0.3211543560028076,
-0.6998313069343567,
0.16433008015155792,
0.05342470854520798,
0.344758540391922,
-1.1006044149398804,
-0.4663655757904053,
0.2625298798084259,
-0.40203502774238586,
0.5179372429847717,
-0.7050366401672363,
-0.7040079832077026,
-0.455971360206604,
-0.10519327968358994,
0.43749260902404785,
0.201348215341568,
-0.5089312195777893,
0.6757838129997253,
0.6739805936813354,
-0.2647947669029236,
-0.5138152837753296,
-0.3367742896080017,
0.2966805398464203,
-0.31168752908706665,
-0.5173048973083496,
0.4394347071647644,
0.19756309688091278,
0.0616573765873909,
-0.125435933470726,
-0.21513985097408295,
-0.21405091881752014,
0.0781794935464859,
0.14902263879776,
0.31328558921813965,
-0.14828991889953613,
0.5248147249221802,
-0.2931405007839203,
-0.24073399603366852,
-0.20971745252609253,
-0.7407830953598022,
0.6699651479721069,
-0.3155826926231384,
-0.17003850638866425,
-0.21644318103790283,
-0.024538537487387657,
0.41293004155158997,
-0.2123805433511734,
0.6192907094955444,
0.5274330377578735,
-0.6358879208564758,
-0.06425568461418152,
-0.07906568795442581,
-0.02802055887877941,
-0.5142955780029297,
0.34425821900367737,
-0.33245766162872314,
-1.0529438257217407,
0.6635908484458923,
-0.0033937827683985233,
-0.1853819191455841,
0.24246928095817566,
0.30748116970062256,
0.04473251476883888,
0.6901953816413879,
0.7546714544296265,
-0.39805716276168823,
0.29112857580184937,
-0.07516982406377792,
0.5018917322158813,
-0.5801719427108765,
-0.06062968820333481,
-0.559420108795166,
-0.14357155561447144,
-0.685887336730957,
-0.45661038160324097,
0.2574021518230438,
0.4204409420490265,
-0.2725420892238617,
0.352137953042984,
-0.7672942280769348,
0.5273850560188293,
-0.01705617643892765,
-0.0517018623650074,
0.2611824870109558,
0.398445725440979,
-0.3669973313808441,
0.18846583366394043,
-0.8004128932952881,
-0.6452581882476807,
1.0592838525772095,
0.3546842634677887,
0.8248918056488037,
0.03453869745135307,
0.5858206748962402,
0.17256931960582733,
0.09042178094387054,
-0.6052448153495789,
0.49941113591194153,
-0.33184143900871277,
-0.2188592404127121,
-0.5055386424064636,
-0.6538342833518982,
-1.110662579536438,
0.036458320915699005,
0.17722690105438232,
-1.1854114532470703,
-0.2159893810749054,
0.2615264058113098,
0.26763561367988586,
0.5807080864906311,
-0.28198885917663574,
1.187801718711853,
-0.28352421522140503,
-0.010659521445631981,
0.05925425514578819,
-0.40137532353401184,
0.2665000259876251,
0.22764986753463745,
0.6454069018363953,
-0.22218754887580872,
0.04009551182389259,
0.42208781838417053,
-0.6183061003684998,
1.0757884979248047,
0.050777845084667206,
-0.1304958462715149,
0.18341709673404694,
0.39093875885009766,
0.6905640959739685,
0.17659004032611847,
0.02380985952913761,
0.24607327580451965,
-0.13010282814502716,
-0.4815939664840698,
-0.34856143593788147,
0.7476658225059509,
-0.6461930274963379,
-0.3259676992893219,
-0.00566869368776679,
-0.7203757166862488,
-0.2432883232831955,
0.3285141885280609,
0.06164275482296944,
0.6031346917152405,
-0.1607486456632614,
-0.12022606283426285,
0.2689015567302704,
-0.11488509178161621,
0.14282236993312836,
-0.028125545009970665,
-0.6903906464576721,
-0.5859216451644897,
1.093407154083252,
-0.18776361644268036,
0.22792674601078033,
0.6378747820854187,
0.3101668059825897,
-0.28880056738853455,
-0.6026022434234619,
-0.5197697281837463,
0.324064165353775,
-0.835023820400238,
-0.3287295997142792,
-0.5800656676292419,
-0.22848671674728394,
-0.27094167470932007,
-0.3387759327888489,
-0.3031240999698639,
-0.5050474405288696,
0.053449105471372604,
-0.20563426613807678,
0.5280230045318604,
0.6894899606704712,
0.1733117252588272,
0.36960670351982117,
-0.44432663917541504,
0.2842482030391693,
0.09175678342580795,
0.5313169956207275,
-0.14728564023971558,
-0.19218817353248596,
-0.4097718596458435,
0.041664380580186844,
0.12406668812036514,
-0.7046975493431091,
-0.012907728552818298,
0.2117309868335724,
0.5887782573699951,
0.19370286166667938,
-0.16030734777450562,
0.5897073149681091,
-0.4189864993095398,
0.5548095107078552,
0.09556584060192108,
-1.0876257419586182,
0.5472723245620728,
-0.6298668384552002,
0.08254868537187576,
0.44908714294433594,
0.20723620057106018,
-0.531633734703064,
-0.5730788707733154,
-0.3998953104019165,
-0.8182008266448975,
0.463104248046875,
0.19411970674991608,
0.06722071021795273,
-0.10291659086942673,
0.2576914429664612,
0.14118953049182892,
0.2911415100097656,
-1.2452298402786255,
0.0668642669916153,
-0.27905353903770447,
-0.4947689473628998,
0.0240543931722641,
0.14882029592990875,
-0.5509281158447266,
-0.05735139548778534,
0.35466063022613525,
-0.7864159941673279,
0.18896739184856415,
-0.05393492802977562,
-0.3515264391899109,
-0.06694693863391876,
0.12099482119083405,
0.28878867626190186,
0.9433097839355469,
-0.05082663148641586,
0.36070382595062256,
0.14225821197032928,
0.08217843621969223,
-0.23638063669204712,
0.3416772782802582,
-0.08571305871009827,
-0.06318424642086029,
0.7649886608123779,
0.6731594204902649,
0.27113279700279236,
-0.4957389235496521,
0.39901915192604065,
0.21654321253299713,
-0.0019351759692654014,
0.11608362197875977,
-0.05821863189339638,
0.2494552880525589,
-0.16616609692573547,
0.05313856899738312,
-0.314191997051239,
-0.15801618993282318,
-0.41776806116104126,
0.3681088089942932,
0.6892918944358826,
-0.42296862602233887,
-0.16276617348194122,
0.5653367638587952,
0.07104156166315079,
-0.3547084331512451,
0.6510387063026428,
-0.317981094121933,
-0.7616092562675476,
0.8887928128242493,
0.5151853561401367,
0.709633469581604,
0.21811139583587646,
0.382422536611557,
0.5530320405960083,
0.2579972743988037,
0.3834851384162903,
0.04060884192585945,
-0.04220231622457504,
-0.7869792580604553,
-0.3942345082759857,
-0.7561590671539307,
-0.29016783833503723,
-0.04504605010151863,
-0.2710992395877838,
0.29897141456604004,
-0.47584760189056396,
0.09467568248510361,
-0.3956945538520813,
-0.03393948823213577,
-0.4507002532482147,
0.025634365156292915,
0.25894540548324585,
0.6526353359222412,
-0.8860973119735718,
0.7973225712776184,
0.44200047850608826,
-0.2746281027793884,
-0.7988511323928833,
-0.14540071785449982,
0.007078843656927347,
-0.9261440634727478,
0.48929598927497864,
0.4262465238571167,
-0.15510830283164978,
0.0870838314294815,
-0.21449945867061615,
-1.0220645666122437,
1.0534392595291138,
0.431238055229187,
-0.35974130034446716,
-0.07194811850786209,
0.27073395252227783,
0.48617586493492126,
-0.6984705924987793,
-0.024445516988635063,
-0.00035146885784342885,
0.4555721580982208,
0.04653455317020416,
-1.098297119140625,
0.24923495948314667,
-0.1070110946893692,
-0.10226137936115265,
0.3585723340511322,
-0.35237351059913635,
0.7812734842300415,
-0.16979284584522247,
-0.47419390082359314,
0.08352958410978317,
0.18618863821029663,
0.25789710879325867,
-0.15039309859275818,
0.4748702049255371,
0.6350840926170349,
1.0490005016326904,
-0.24574734270572662,
1.1866109371185303,
-0.5212069153785706,
0.5020195841789246,
1.1915335655212402,
-0.15233200788497925,
0.4844302237033844,
0.2887057065963745,
-0.23515278100967407,
0.4557245969772339,
0.9713830351829529,
0.1324809193611145,
0.16627609729766846,
0.39554089307785034,
0.2949308156967163,
-0.1803574413061142,
-0.20662783086299896,
-0.46225279569625854,
0.38104188442230225,
0.2554289996623993,
-0.029486576095223427,
-0.4062875509262085,
-0.34862247109413147,
0.04918798431754112,
0.21892455220222473,
-0.3062087595462799,
0.7032859325408936,
-0.10243992507457733,
-0.37529805302619934,
0.8362002968788147,
-0.11665535718202591,
0.1270671933889389,
-0.5388409495353699,
0.13340924680233002,
-0.27621397376060486,
-0.1102948933839798,
-0.23304912447929382,
-0.5594155192375183,
0.49771106243133545,
-0.19524748623371124,
0.03289978206157684,
-0.27635011076927185,
0.3830192983150482,
-0.5099862217903137,
-0.8481508493423462,
0.5810534954071045,
0.4074990749359131,
0.2987995743751526,
0.26140645146369934,
-0.725109875202179,
0.10967528074979782,
-0.22974278032779694,
0.30311787128448486,
0.11204060167074203,
0.4079427421092987,
-0.15285825729370117,
0.5576218366622925,
0.48876726627349854,
0.1169310137629509,
-0.05559545010328293,
0.3761710226535797,
0.9035999178886414,
-0.4329838156700134,
-0.672163188457489,
-0.7853302359580994,
0.3622734248638153,
-0.24246981739997864,
-0.15668414533138275,
0.4923999607563019,
0.9219685792922974,
0.7950917482376099,
0.26548153162002563,
0.4349859654903412,
0.0054637361317873,
0.18973878026008606,
-0.8895717263221741,
0.47137561440467834,
-0.6004005074501038,
0.24340665340423584,
-0.274407297372818,
-0.936297595500946,
-0.30983880162239075,
0.5207934975624084,
-0.1354866921901703,
0.023654872551560402,
0.7272471189498901,
0.9431081414222717,
-0.2374139428138733,
-0.4004499912261963,
-0.09393958002328873,
0.3182007074356079,
0.3452671766281128,
0.43892616033554077,
0.42026612162590027,
-0.2047823667526245,
0.6038295030593872,
0.10769876092672348,
-0.05135267227888107,
-0.01824308931827545,
-1.0455551147460938,
-1.1056549549102783,
-0.5140562057495117,
-0.26981648802757263,
-0.25188013911247253,
-0.01247459277510643,
0.4242129623889923,
0.8782556056976318,
-0.8237547278404236,
-0.5546684265136719,
-0.6241872906684875,
0.7883054614067078,
-0.06702373921871185,
-0.3204508423805237,
0.5854089856147766,
-0.6722745299339294,
-0.7481161952018738,
0.3654206097126007,
0.4003414213657379,
-0.009022255428135395,
-0.06652969121932983,
-0.26057541370391846,
-0.10342298448085785,
-0.16117314994335175,
0.2881834805011749,
0.1969495415687561,
-1.0253448486328125,
-0.5296843647956848,
0.016872897744178772,
-0.2474544197320938,
0.4610596001148224,
0.8706806302070618,
-0.5657675862312317,
0.4529280364513397,
0.49064508080482483,
0.8196753859519958,
0.5524556636810303,
0.08384218066930771,
0.7199409604072571,
-1.0323357582092285,
0.06865521520376205,
-0.1679168939590454,
0.6152446866035461,
0.7336612939834595,
-0.506316602230072,
0.6805951595306396,
0.1658443659543991,
-0.3417529761791229,
-0.9317189455032349,
0.38861438632011414,
-1.0686630010604858,
-0.5308196544647217,
0.9007536172866821,
-0.014714804477989674,
-0.04933035373687744,
0.08367552608251572,
-0.04409100115299225,
0.41419467329978943,
0.07242932170629501,
0.5832635760307312,
0.7235080003738403,
0.0639190748333931,
-0.09355255216360092,
-0.4441017508506775,
0.44493070244789124,
0.03775814548134804,
-0.9374536275863647,
0.356962114572525,
0.32616859674453735,
0.1685677170753479,
0.06614019721746445,
0.6918197274208069,
-0.02012050151824951,
-0.13963134586811066,
-0.19552303850650787,
0.006237273570150137,
-0.3332541584968567,
-0.5463822484016418,
-0.09320881962776184,
0.03925470635294914,
0.12646588683128357,
-0.055418193340301514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13249v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13249v1 | R^2AG: Incorporating Retrieval Information into Retrieval Augmented Generation | 2024-06-19T06:19:48 | 2024-06-19T06:19:48 | Fuda Ye, Shuangyin Li, Yongqi Zhang, Lei Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Retrieval augmented generation (RAG) has been applied in many scenarios to
augment large language models (LLMs) with external documents provided by
retrievers. However, a semantic gap exists between LLMs and retrievers due to
differences in their training objectives and architectures. This misalignment
forces LLMs to passively accept the documents provided by the retrievers,
leading to incomprehension in the generation process, where the LLMs are
burdened with the task of distinguishing these documents using their inherent
knowledge. This paper proposes R$^2$AG, a novel enhanced RAG framework to fill
this gap by incorporating Retrieval information into Retrieval Augmented
Generation. Specifically, R$^2$AG utilizes the nuanced features from the
retrievers and employs a R$^2$-Former to capture retrieval information. Then, a
retrieval-aware prompting strategy is designed to integrate retrieval
information into LLMs' generation. Notably, R$^2$AG suits low-source scenarios
where LLMs and retrievers are frozen. Extensive experiments across five
datasets validate the effectiveness, robustness, and efficiency of R$^2$AG. Our
analysis reveals that retrieval information serves as an anchor to aid LLMs in
the generation process, thereby filling the semantic gap. | [
-0.42752861976623535,
-0.6943731904029846,
0.4293418228626251,
-0.03047030046582222,
-0.18785089254379272,
0.2551790177822113,
-0.10359036922454834,
-0.6732078194618225,
0.28564777970314026,
0.31142300367355347,
-0.3337852954864502,
0.13345648348331451,
-0.5993740558624268,
0.06886189430952072,
-0.17841540277004242,
0.6746017336845398,
0.09365642070770264,
-0.09825560450553894,
-0.33008530735969543,
-0.05917874351143837,
-0.6234522461891174,
-0.143352210521698,
-0.6311989426612854,
-0.5923035740852356,
0.5719373822212219,
0.7152020335197449,
0.7129524350166321,
0.8043586611747742,
0.39422720670700073,
0.14922267198562622,
-0.08447213470935822,
0.6249695420265198,
-0.637217104434967,
0.5130533576011658,
-0.44977062940597534,
-0.5201064348220825,
-0.41950228810310364,
-0.05530580133199692,
0.7120317816734314,
0.3356650173664093,
-0.1471855193376541,
0.3082425892353058,
-0.025342117995023727,
0.8852274417877197,
-0.780733585357666,
-0.17951877415180206,
-0.97807377576828,
0.04681055620312691,
-0.42921534180641174,
-0.444273442029953,
-0.4460950195789337,
-0.09806673228740692,
-0.31608888506889343,
-0.6310742497444153,
0.42080315947532654,
0.17062026262283325,
0.9664909243583679,
0.3300876319408417,
-0.19451716542243958,
-0.3621920347213745,
-0.5145959258079529,
0.5058979392051697,
-0.3417476415634155,
0.5489236116409302,
0.6378448605537415,
0.29356709122657776,
-0.3086412250995636,
-0.7886378169059753,
-0.7217585444450378,
-0.06601520627737045,
-0.20999595522880554,
0.24239225685596466,
-0.17656120657920837,
-0.351204514503479,
0.27619701623916626,
0.3802541196346283,
-0.41040489077568054,
0.015604059211909771,
-0.1977427452802658,
0.10537520796060562,
0.42742934823036194,
-0.08252590894699097,
0.1259421557188034,
-0.3377169966697693,
-0.46938201785087585,
-0.16720688343048096,
-0.9106850624084473,
-0.13751409947872162,
0.43090492486953735,
0.462682843208313,
0.10636407881975174,
0.8617740869522095,
-0.040481552481651306,
0.6150615811347961,
0.3115291893482208,
0.04738451912999153,
0.2705700099468231,
-0.08420918136835098,
0.17096871137619019,
-0.19623303413391113,
0.39063605666160583,
0.18708179891109467,
-0.006233508232980967,
-0.12754014134407043,
-0.4186151921749115,
-0.16908074915409088,
0.3371485769748688,
-0.795234203338623,
0.059065915644168854,
-0.052355557680130005,
-0.3159220814704895,
-0.015974367037415504,
0.1546183079481125,
-0.9992086887359619,
-0.5326820611953735,
-0.20725366473197937,
0.36454975605010986,
-0.29393473267555237,
-0.5082564949989319,
-0.3515419065952301,
-0.3248122036457062,
0.2741164267063141,
0.15947264432907104,
-0.9106392860412598,
0.14800527691841125,
0.8666320443153381,
0.7273804545402527,
-0.05540740489959717,
0.018020860850811005,
-1.1098562479019165,
0.42441797256469727,
-0.40669605135917664,
1.1355968713760376,
-0.8085706830024719,
-0.5978497862815857,
0.06310170143842697,
-0.2322033792734146,
0.13129043579101562,
-0.6767727732658386,
0.47327446937561035,
-1.0798709392547607,
0.32366982102394104,
-0.0744052529335022,
-0.49413663148880005,
-0.14538142085075378,
0.24425697326660156,
-0.5760104060173035,
1.4867335557937622,
0.475082129240036,
-0.7244104743003845,
0.2946176826953888,
-0.3373580574989319,
-0.3582419455051422,
0.47046875953674316,
-0.4412354826927185,
-0.3839724361896515,
0.22957658767700195,
-0.01369165163487196,
0.08074900507926941,
-0.4315074682235718,
0.0960247814655304,
0.04426543414592743,
-0.3017495572566986,
0.0853460356593132,
-0.1777358502149582,
0.18877831101417542,
0.4252648949623108,
-0.024587884545326233,
-0.3292281925678253,
-0.6503147482872009,
0.2085941731929779,
0.22614125907421112,
-0.7040585875511169,
-0.4776823818683624,
-0.10440287739038467,
-0.1942918300628662,
-0.03818698599934578,
0.3923395872116089,
-0.3106529712677002,
0.301108181476593,
-0.5817945003509521,
-0.27483662962913513,
0.44349536299705505,
0.08861695975065231,
0.7476345300674438,
-0.292383074760437,
0.8281117081642151,
-0.2677060663700104,
-0.36721089482307434,
-0.23371171951293945,
-0.3375749886035919,
-0.746223509311676,
-0.14795665442943573,
0.4240763783454895,
0.7369763255119324,
-0.94209885597229,
0.12540608644485474,
-0.18036401271820068,
-0.15845876932144165,
-0.5404809713363647,
0.2533927857875824,
0.5368727445602417,
0.6689961552619934,
0.4473501741886139,
-0.008003078401088715,
-0.699491560459137,
-0.5992221832275391,
-0.3427715599536896,
-0.17132750153541565,
-0.14803697168827057,
0.7008309364318848,
0.10927434265613556,
-0.38062891364097595,
0.983234167098999,
-0.3445567488670349,
-0.2774551808834076,
-0.3486790359020233,
0.1336469203233719,
0.11541131883859634,
0.34797167778015137,
0.3146061301231384,
-0.9588931798934937,
-0.5113881826400757,
0.16388767957687378,
-0.7662940621376038,
-0.3326610028743744,
0.11152835190296173,
-0.2566538453102112,
0.3828947842121124,
0.55158531665802,
-0.5552884340286255,
0.2819618284702301,
0.331120103597641,
-0.39309683442115784,
0.3159329891204834,
-0.44218435883522034,
0.055049363523721695,
-1.170903205871582,
0.2519180178642273,
-0.31420180201530457,
-0.23031948506832123,
-0.4561515748500824,
0.1607450246810913,
0.17694559693336487,
-0.09162125736474991,
-0.14558783173561096,
1.0279724597930908,
-0.8486310243606567,
-0.31264662742614746,
-0.6924197673797607,
0.4428408145904541,
0.20164728164672852,
-0.02063646726310253,
-0.17642001807689667,
1.133198857307434,
0.17586222290992737,
-0.6931408643722534,
0.14095072448253632,
0.5795506834983826,
0.013948673382401466,
0.5462103486061096,
-0.39559638500213623,
0.2702864408493042,
-0.4299113154411316,
0.2119484692811966,
-0.6086514592170715,
-0.5399683117866516,
0.197672039270401,
-0.792432963848114,
0.778713047504425,
-0.2360294610261917,
-0.4149720072746277,
-0.16363608837127686,
-0.17454387247562408,
0.3491470217704773,
0.6163634061813354,
-0.6610844731330872,
0.9248393774032593,
0.5520171523094177,
-0.3914050757884979,
-0.7378568649291992,
-0.6997054815292358,
0.431478351354599,
-0.15305759012699127,
-0.733024001121521,
0.3977624475955963,
0.200099915266037,
-0.33813712000846863,
0.1404215544462204,
0.11650997400283813,
0.26194727420806885,
-0.08517680317163467,
0.05690116435289383,
0.26175352931022644,
-0.18418888747692108,
0.2941245138645172,
0.03049476444721222,
-0.3579472005367279,
-0.3183262050151825,
0.028251083567738533,
0.4883583188056946,
0.2955293655395508,
-0.2504357397556305,
-0.03385518118739128,
0.684884786605835,
0.0680570900440216,
-0.48404058814048767,
0.5266112089157104,
0.6468709111213684,
-0.19138942658901215,
-0.4414527714252472,
-0.7758745551109314,
-0.27332592010498047,
-0.481551855802536,
0.31775137782096863,
-0.5859460830688477,
-1.0009828805923462,
0.3990299701690674,
-0.30470529198646545,
-0.09515821188688278,
0.44081956148147583,
0.3908938467502594,
0.04802897199988365,
0.9929762482643127,
0.6330623030662537,
0.37904655933380127,
0.638144314289093,
-0.2808327078819275,
0.15237957239151,
-1.4282513856887817,
-0.4712173342704773,
-0.6807522177696228,
-0.11981557309627533,
-0.3600327670574188,
-0.8001951575279236,
0.27410292625427246,
0.675184965133667,
-0.07006911933422089,
0.061971306800842285,
-0.4497552812099457,
0.46289849281311035,
0.4609511196613312,
-0.07369823753833771,
0.1942223608493805,
0.2820252776145935,
-0.10720738023519516,
-0.026739927008748055,
-0.9681363105773926,
-0.46647050976753235,
0.6967136263847351,
0.3276008665561676,
0.7431212663650513,
0.4199773967266083,
0.6645857095718384,
0.4334075152873993,
0.29015839099884033,
-0.7738859057426453,
0.5784117579460144,
-0.2206418216228485,
-0.39634326100349426,
-0.0038777089212089777,
-0.44884225726127625,
-1.0988972187042236,
0.2890215218067169,
-0.3211970627307892,
-0.4841313660144806,
0.32810264825820923,
0.21258677542209625,
-0.10899251699447632,
-0.071505606174469,
-0.580538809299469,
0.39371222257614136,
-0.08668570220470428,
-0.6159034967422485,
-0.1731501817703247,
-0.6127640008926392,
0.30314531922340393,
-0.07122699916362762,
0.3819451928138733,
0.002066181041300297,
-0.23348136246204376,
0.5559702515602112,
-0.39040035009384155,
0.30310338735580444,
-0.39919474720954895,
-0.12215229868888855,
0.539314866065979,
0.29721957445144653,
1.1177012920379639,
0.12751570343971252,
-0.3500729501247406,
-0.43425774574279785,
-0.5577134490013123,
-0.0699261873960495,
-0.6386504173278809,
0.6471157073974609,
-0.32994624972343445,
-0.7809015512466431,
-0.47392889857292175,
-0.5878390073776245,
-0.3994782865047455,
0.17166174948215485,
0.09748131036758423,
0.276615172624588,
0.20925308763980865,
0.11379724740982056,
0.7155317664146423,
-0.1568976640701294,
0.2185426503419876,
0.7848537564277649,
-0.24340848624706268,
-0.48680946230888367,
1.0232205390930176,
-0.09453834593296051,
0.29794299602508545,
0.28107956051826477,
0.30377745628356934,
-0.6073006987571716,
-0.3452102839946747,
-0.6111598014831543,
0.3965519666671753,
-0.7536138892173767,
-0.5638893246650696,
-0.8349542617797852,
-0.1226639449596405,
-0.48707643151283264,
-0.1152769923210144,
-0.0036638870369642973,
-0.4018908143043518,
-0.5277186632156372,
-0.0859680101275444,
0.6227001547813416,
0.7038576006889343,
-0.5739123225212097,
0.15920136868953705,
-0.9743266105651855,
0.6361138224601746,
0.2985314428806305,
0.34031546115875244,
0.14991779625415802,
-0.8367733359336853,
-0.2579744756221771,
0.0070362575352191925,
0.010627301409840584,
-0.6923707127571106,
0.24743759632110596,
0.3717631697654724,
0.7717002034187317,
0.08859382569789886,
-0.14511094987392426,
0.7552914619445801,
-0.759133517742157,
0.7454026341438293,
0.0054588597267866135,
-0.49656105041503906,
0.6195312142372131,
-0.3263843059539795,
0.17027701437473297,
0.6349190473556519,
-0.07149829715490341,
-0.32088351249694824,
-0.3369204103946686,
-0.5674551129341125,
-1.128872275352478,
0.8530600666999817,
-0.03840729594230652,
0.2433193475008011,
-0.2660391330718994,
0.5991969108581543,
0.006337396334856749,
0.017298845574259758,
-0.329691618680954,
-0.06831222772598267,
0.07681546360254288,
-0.05318678915500641,
0.3399551808834076,
-0.7681967616081238,
-0.02824437990784645,
0.2666003704071045,
0.9732187986373901,
0.01164567843079567,
0.2218809723854065,
0.15349180996418,
0.001914321444928646,
-0.4845183193683624,
0.24307304620742798,
0.3903332054615021,
0.47295457124710083,
-0.018677765503525734,
0.3006172776222229,
0.1259566992521286,
-0.472741961479187,
0.12498855590820312,
0.19841723144054413,
-0.3198477327823639,
0.13646437227725983,
0.14984822273254395,
0.6640557646751404,
-0.12037356942892075,
-0.5902523994445801,
0.2892577648162842,
0.09518954902887344,
0.12255915254354477,
-0.32835668325424194,
0.1513608694076538,
-0.047673650085926056,
0.5405436158180237,
0.7330427169799805,
-0.08706729859113693,
0.01802723854780197,
-0.5063170790672302,
0.5106492638587952,
0.758333146572113,
-0.13642507791519165,
0.14198124408721924,
0.7235180139541626,
0.09084203839302063,
-0.5314372777938843,
0.27531930804252625,
-0.46274369955062866,
-0.4237031042575836,
0.3075312077999115,
0.8104146122932434,
0.6491633057594299,
-0.2120848000049591,
0.04645780846476555,
0.47478365898132324,
0.04065695405006409,
-0.310375452041626,
0.3834969103336334,
-0.1512387990951538,
-0.5677303075790405,
-0.5227723121643066,
-0.870859682559967,
-0.2888784408569336,
-0.10945072770118713,
-0.6384161114692688,
0.17887452244758606,
-0.10331475734710693,
-0.14826622605323792,
-0.3343018591403961,
-0.10662487149238586,
-0.30284583568573,
0.18264327943325043,
0.047041237354278564,
0.9393221139907837,
-0.279712438583374,
0.5178356170654297,
0.6531236171722412,
-0.4089511036872864,
-0.9167081117630005,
0.008477174676954746,
-0.21542251110076904,
-0.9805344939231873,
0.8838585615158081,
-0.027964429929852486,
-0.449144572019577,
0.17219023406505585,
-0.32757237553596497,
-0.9604637026786804,
1.2085120677947998,
0.16764876246452332,
-0.27676093578338623,
0.053416553884744644,
-0.029348142445087433,
0.3574192523956299,
-0.39214566349983215,
0.005791122559458017,
0.41287147998809814,
0.6350727081298828,
0.6634947657585144,
-0.4964368939399719,
0.03590165823698044,
-0.3782525956630707,
0.21156083047389984,
0.36697667837142944,
-0.5219140648841858,
0.7540844082832336,
-0.3501827120780945,
-0.6311707496643066,
0.23812268674373627,
0.8017386198043823,
0.6727006435394287,
0.3987163007259369,
0.3629731833934784,
0.784867525100708,
0.720992386341095,
0.07424865663051605,
1.0490758419036865,
-0.21791839599609375,
0.1189955398440361,
1.3788766860961914,
-0.40100356936454773,
1.0013667345046997,
0.4280926585197449,
-0.031201565638184547,
0.42287516593933105,
0.23066221177577972,
-0.07007604837417603,
0.470652312040329,
-0.03264454007148743,
-0.5560867786407471,
-0.06031624600291252,
-0.5703416466712952,
-0.6647543907165527,
0.3131634294986725,
0.5496522188186646,
-0.3181929290294647,
-0.412764310836792,
-0.024403588846325874,
0.11109673231840134,
0.35147711634635925,
-0.3079642057418823,
1.0454756021499634,
0.05963785573840141,
-0.8603764772415161,
0.49923795461654663,
0.06918919831514359,
0.5256260633468628,
-0.6444366574287415,
-0.37011149525642395,
-0.34396716952323914,
0.14184406399726868,
-0.3855976164340973,
-0.8517227172851562,
0.37577149271965027,
0.31978389620780945,
-0.34367573261260986,
-0.286383718252182,
1.0620901584625244,
-0.5998097658157349,
-0.5211582779884338,
0.28765732049942017,
0.5837011933326721,
0.1953422874212265,
0.13588160276412964,
-0.46968504786491394,
0.1190560981631279,
-0.09861262142658234,
-0.3092317581176758,
0.38302844762802124,
0.6988024711608887,
0.10999736189842224,
0.4311542212963104,
0.7212550640106201,
0.2669210731983185,
-0.12666195631027222,
0.2151072472333908,
0.9024347066879272,
-0.5532563328742981,
-0.5031738877296448,
-0.5103008151054382,
0.5474250912666321,
-0.08719360083341599,
0.040526606142520905,
0.851169764995575,
0.6987913846969604,
0.4429239332675934,
0.22799287736415863,
0.7811141014099121,
-0.3069324493408203,
1.1481767892837524,
-0.61103755235672,
0.6248153448104858,
-0.7896944284439087,
0.34138724207878113,
0.21083363890647888,
-1.0053070783615112,
-0.06648918241262436,
0.5349743962287903,
0.040913451462984085,
0.13162147998809814,
0.3063465654850006,
1.0219160318374634,
-0.004077934194356203,
-0.3750736117362976,
0.18921016156673431,
-0.005856158211827278,
0.30945515632629395,
0.21427862346172333,
0.74604332447052,
-0.392135351896286,
0.45583903789520264,
0.37106379866600037,
-0.3320838212966919,
-0.36415648460388184,
-0.7714786529541016,
-0.6201953291893005,
-0.3904549777507782,
0.10139475017786026,
-0.6358136534690857,
0.08069030940532684,
0.7168087959289551,
0.27030444145202637,
-0.40988096594810486,
0.08454526215791702,
-0.1923045963048935,
0.017768410965800285,
0.28965818881988525,
-0.31202688813209534,
0.19687938690185547,
-0.542437732219696,
-0.5147764682769775,
0.7816391587257385,
0.26705196499824524,
0.22346656024456024,
-0.2536461353302002,
-0.22793076932430267,
-0.5048325061798096,
0.15467290580272675,
0.48673275113105774,
0.4933071732521057,
-0.5708991289138794,
-0.2089986801147461,
0.001712026889435947,
-0.11376077681779861,
-0.0011070896871387959,
0.7583005428314209,
-1.0463026762008667,
0.5464621782302856,
0.6014341115951538,
0.9238473176956177,
0.48319512605667114,
0.4282214343547821,
0.4537847936153412,
-1.0111808776855469,
0.3308635354042053,
0.3888051509857178,
0.046842966228723526,
0.6324183344841003,
-0.560935378074646,
0.6725343465805054,
0.057060111314058304,
-0.6840970516204834,
-0.8587357401847839,
0.46800339221954346,
-0.7265506386756897,
-0.179106667637825,
1.511680006980896,
0.08585343509912491,
-0.008322756737470627,
0.01941348798573017,
-0.2074008584022522,
0.3421875834465027,
-0.47318795323371887,
0.6397711634635925,
0.36568427085876465,
-0.10508864372968674,
-0.17498788237571716,
-0.7112159132957458,
0.5624707937240601,
0.3639846742153168,
-0.7748586535453796,
0.12036868929862976,
0.7356927394866943,
-0.054403431713581085,
0.2851242423057556,
0.6384919285774231,
-0.19862431287765503,
0.279677152633667,
0.053148895502090454,
-0.1336495280265808,
-0.35043299198150635,
-0.2750561237335205,
-0.2315426617860794,
0.14607903361320496,
0.10648052394390106,
0.08628690987825394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13246v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13246v1 | GSR-BENCH: A Benchmark for Grounded Spatial Reasoning Evaluation via Multimodal LLMs | 2024-06-19T06:15:26 | 2024-06-19T06:15:26 | Navid Rajabi, Jana Kosecka | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | The ability to understand and reason about spatial relationships between
objects in images is an important component of visual reasoning. This skill
rests on the ability to recognize and localize objects of interest and
determine their spatial relation. Early vision and language models (VLMs) have
been shown to struggle to recognize spatial relations. We extend the previously
released What'sUp dataset and propose a novel comprehensive evaluation for
spatial relationship understanding that highlights the strengths and weaknesses
of 27 different models. In addition to the VLMs evaluated in What'sUp, our
extensive evaluation encompasses 3 classes of Multimodal LLMs (MLLMs) that vary
in their parameter sizes (ranging from 7B to 110B), training/instruction-tuning
methods, and visual resolution to benchmark their performances and scrutinize
the scaling laws in this task. | [
-0.6467323303222656,
-0.5279171466827393,
1.0343592166900635,
0.05084080621600151,
-0.14219051599502563,
-0.27665600180625916,
-0.13553863763809204,
-0.34274622797966003,
-0.3698362410068512,
0.2121576964855194,
-0.5755441784858704,
-0.5861101150512695,
-0.6572245955467224,
-0.04826928302645683,
-0.07165789604187012,
0.4622141420841217,
-0.09406714141368866,
0.5003620386123657,
-0.6730778813362122,
-0.574649453163147,
-0.6077789068222046,
-0.6216599345207214,
-0.017975935712456703,
-0.26880258321762085,
0.4126814901828766,
0.19394207000732422,
0.5480659008026123,
0.5356348752975464,
0.8798908591270447,
0.43713101744651794,
-0.17682082951068878,
0.09923232346773148,
-0.45112594962120056,
0.05930614098906517,
-0.3283999264240265,
-0.24083742499351501,
-0.12214627116918564,
-0.0286406259983778,
0.6931778788566589,
0.7704735994338989,
-0.14523880183696747,
0.27162691950798035,
-0.18602697551250458,
0.8244908452033997,
-0.7134349346160889,
0.2415306270122528,
-0.581271767616272,
0.24071542918682098,
-0.002068639500066638,
-0.09893299639225006,
-0.3076055347919464,
-0.31580832600593567,
-0.11153829842805862,
-0.6723839640617371,
0.2923344671726227,
0.0815863311290741,
0.9852451682090759,
0.47015371918678284,
-0.5773566365242004,
0.15720929205417633,
-0.5614985227584839,
0.7904902696609497,
-0.47618570923805237,
0.7783177495002747,
0.37838539481163025,
0.7924296259880066,
-0.17018434405326843,
-0.6984525918960571,
-0.3163827359676361,
-0.27565351128578186,
-0.23845188319683075,
0.3328907787799835,
0.0972016230225563,
-0.19921983778476715,
0.6780260801315308,
0.12586385011672974,
-0.73760986328125,
-0.38158783316612244,
-0.4968580901622772,
0.11572704464197159,
0.5388135313987732,
0.29689517617225647,
0.05903613194823265,
-0.31072208285331726,
-0.7666106224060059,
-0.11031123250722885,
-0.5226359963417053,
0.08701882511377335,
-0.11021409928798676,
0.07820134609937668,
-0.11899618059396744,
0.8260078430175781,
-0.2506667971611023,
0.8121087551116943,
-0.03088369406759739,
-0.3305181860923767,
0.23007416725158691,
-0.49074336886405945,
-0.30055519938468933,
-0.5304087996482849,
0.4460124671459198,
0.73980712890625,
0.2911321818828583,
-0.09085418283939362,
-0.06749731302261353,
0.3552433252334595,
0.2793021500110626,
-0.4066968262195587,
0.06412369757890701,
-0.23158018290996552,
-0.770639955997467,
0.23028244078159332,
0.09200699627399445,
-0.6764912009239197,
-0.5367510318756104,
-0.7770498991012573,
0.16445733606815338,
-0.34340769052505493,
-0.07510574162006378,
0.12634144723415375,
-0.3319660425186157,
0.40434712171554565,
0.3343733847141266,
-0.6553465723991394,
0.46109190583229065,
0.6535326242446899,
0.504851758480072,
-0.028601065278053284,
-0.7248384356498718,
-0.3126523792743683,
0.23488415777683258,
-0.27125996351242065,
1.1411843299865723,
-0.6304192543029785,
-0.42436471581459045,
-0.3054243326187134,
0.1409590095281601,
-0.2546840310096741,
-0.5697202682495117,
0.6695927977561951,
-0.36050304770469666,
-0.12889672815799713,
-0.8461216688156128,
-0.2661486864089966,
-0.21719002723693848,
0.5563427805900574,
-0.43631473183631897,
1.2255290746688843,
0.23820029199123383,
-0.6009824872016907,
0.8148175477981567,
-0.16458463668823242,
-0.0933021754026413,
0.1738019436597824,
-0.6395254135131836,
-0.08719088137149811,
0.29672902822494507,
0.43129003047943115,
0.48742184042930603,
-0.2626345753669739,
0.508548378944397,
-0.8190407752990723,
-0.35586196184158325,
0.21993198990821838,
-0.06448163092136383,
0.12658058106899261,
0.22744649648666382,
-0.009283927269279957,
0.3555654287338257,
-0.9058639407157898,
0.31373000144958496,
0.18549875915050507,
-0.14099252223968506,
-0.3592035472393036,
0.2757589817047119,
-0.10410524904727936,
0.4030214846134186,
0.08032446354627609,
-0.11405927687883377,
0.0076415082439780235,
0.1802825778722763,
0.18043513596057892,
0.6098300218582153,
-0.1618535816669464,
0.5445520281791687,
-0.19414755702018738,
0.36279168725013733,
-0.2249530404806137,
0.23561137914657593,
-0.19773392379283905,
-0.35287487506866455,
-0.5706637501716614,
-0.4342736601829529,
-0.33977678418159485,
0.3764575719833374,
-0.5117215514183044,
0.2639593183994293,
-0.36680498719215393,
-0.5895715355873108,
0.06640487909317017,
0.08329649269580841,
0.4446748197078705,
0.589978039264679,
0.39404773712158203,
-0.24557529389858246,
-0.6529103517532349,
-0.8939270377159119,
-0.1525542438030243,
-0.019850149750709534,
0.041549813002347946,
0.8351474404335022,
0.5193679928779602,
-0.39185672998428345,
0.8504076600074768,
-0.41272857785224915,
-0.3170906901359558,
-0.10057774186134338,
-0.0032418707851320505,
0.07076866179704666,
0.19452549517154694,
0.8120633959770203,
-0.5346983075141907,
-0.31042683124542236,
0.018903862684965134,
-1.1420522928237915,
-0.1316598802804947,
0.23064656555652618,
-0.23558837175369263,
-0.18113353848457336,
0.7110552191734314,
-0.6550652384757996,
0.5555940866470337,
0.4110851287841797,
-0.7006414532661438,
0.473652720451355,
-0.33767348527908325,
0.39311471581459045,
-0.42973843216896057,
-0.034189362078905106,
0.3776675760746002,
-0.05522511154413223,
-0.27267614006996155,
0.32758021354675293,
0.10963054746389389,
-0.3085591197013855,
-0.3112533390522003,
0.5301772952079773,
-0.7327659130096436,
-0.7991535663604736,
0.04727484658360481,
0.26771286129951477,
0.05811215937137604,
0.3710451126098633,
0.27478286623954773,
0.8098506331443787,
0.4263042211532593,
-0.36583662033081055,
0.3614388108253479,
0.28902050852775574,
-0.5633246898651123,
0.8592329025268555,
-0.6848795413970947,
-0.05651374161243439,
-0.26296761631965637,
0.08346959948539734,
-1.2934753894805908,
-0.14542607963085175,
-0.04644319415092468,
-0.1673005223274231,
0.058376893401145935,
-0.4080832600593567,
-0.4307008385658264,
-0.34604063630104065,
-0.039621707051992416,
0.5184686779975891,
0.274929016828537,
-0.6104139089584351,
0.895870566368103,
0.38387230038642883,
-0.09059514105319977,
-0.40790319442749023,
-0.49858564138412476,
-0.13242927193641663,
-0.3086499571800232,
-0.6742146611213684,
-0.10936813801527023,
0.05958462879061699,
-0.5250702500343323,
0.07479309290647507,
-0.0842406377196312,
-0.06503161787986755,
-0.1316361427307129,
0.45774397253990173,
0.2638362646102905,
-0.35869699716567993,
-0.050185199826955795,
-0.40336573123931885,
-0.3848782479763031,
0.18851475417613983,
0.33630192279815674,
0.28573399782180786,
-0.6459614038467407,
-0.8616159558296204,
-0.07222408056259155,
0.1739221215248108,
0.7312774062156677,
-0.19995298981666565,
0.39268866181373596,
0.513882577419281,
-0.27856865525245667,
0.19135063886642456,
-0.7141336798667908,
0.06285791099071503,
-0.41307333111763,
0.5069116950035095,
-0.6707606911659241,
-0.6067464351654053,
0.49239107966423035,
-0.21887430548667908,
-0.522007167339325,
0.2680657207965851,
0.42141303420066833,
-0.1722322702407837,
0.9370414018630981,
0.2567669153213501,
0.08303043991327286,
0.21651242673397064,
-0.05061796307563782,
0.06623674184083939,
-0.8597386479377747,
-0.7035709619522095,
-0.40553146600723267,
-0.349750816822052,
-0.16015814244747162,
-0.739140510559082,
0.2350618690252304,
0.24247080087661743,
-0.5853081345558167,
0.08365970104932785,
-0.3234397768974304,
0.637977123260498,
0.4071754217147827,
0.058174435049295425,
0.04136810451745987,
0.029687775298953056,
-0.363991379737854,
-0.6116277575492859,
-0.5918866991996765,
-0.6305206418037415,
0.8771864175796509,
0.38370516896247864,
0.8635849952697754,
0.10163894295692444,
0.1922065019607544,
0.18761706352233887,
0.27156007289886475,
-0.6858545541763306,
0.9122838973999023,
-0.07941389083862305,
-0.3123161494731903,
-0.15441030263900757,
-0.21250219643115997,
-0.6538563370704651,
0.8238425254821777,
-0.41565021872520447,
-0.7398132681846619,
0.18649211525917053,
-0.11607223749160767,
-0.06604283303022385,
0.17655256390571594,
-0.8537156581878662,
0.9069124460220337,
-0.5272653698921204,
-0.5796862244606018,
-0.11994191259145737,
-0.6069592237472534,
0.5178951025009155,
0.4450918138027191,
0.301789253950119,
-0.34881386160850525,
0.08201101422309875,
0.2469283640384674,
-0.17061512172222137,
0.576536238193512,
-0.3282400071620941,
0.16801369190216064,
0.08893781900405884,
-0.01792469434440136,
0.23449808359146118,
0.046126339584589005,
0.22353564202785492,
0.32622262835502625,
0.10247435420751572,
-0.2360018640756607,
-0.7754213213920593,
0.6922897100448608,
-0.7372651100158691,
-0.3949154317378998,
-0.5167807340621948,
-0.6570248603820801,
-0.4411538243293762,
0.10546183586120605,
-0.09204670786857605,
0.19170556962490082,
-0.31048163771629333,
0.2732195258140564,
0.5252682566642761,
-0.056271396577358246,
0.11391592025756836,
0.4637511372566223,
-0.6271312832832336,
-0.56730055809021,
0.4524942636489868,
-0.017777951434254646,
-0.044811803847551346,
0.12098872661590576,
0.03985108435153961,
-0.6099957227706909,
-0.42263680696487427,
-0.2699972987174988,
0.3414389491081238,
-1.0709391832351685,
-0.12385612726211548,
-0.38838183879852295,
-0.1960480660200119,
-0.11509556323289871,
-0.3519771993160248,
-0.1965840607881546,
-0.15490767359733582,
-0.0075803170911967754,
-0.1989595741033554,
0.06653472781181335,
0.8964722752571106,
-0.034673068672418594,
0.008899918757379055,
-0.8311337828636169,
0.48933717608451843,
0.47024938464164734,
0.3901178538799286,
-0.13229191303253174,
-0.45172107219696045,
0.03788277506828308,
-0.16635727882385254,
-0.07773441821336746,
-0.670680820941925,
0.2515166699886322,
-0.14620177447795868,
1.069323182106018,
0.6059932708740234,
-0.3926783502101898,
1.1628974676132202,
-0.6542708277702332,
0.6781901717185974,
0.2685036361217499,
-0.7347098588943481,
0.6435554623603821,
-0.36016982793807983,
0.2652572989463806,
0.3874805271625519,
0.15135876834392548,
-0.18004341423511505,
0.18524454534053802,
-0.4570595622062683,
-0.5640950798988342,
0.426835834980011,
-0.10036454349756241,
-0.21115195751190186,
-0.0588902123272419,
0.3019298017024994,
-0.10215295106172562,
0.08746413886547089,
-0.7723625302314758,
-0.05035393685102463,
-0.19512496888637543,
0.063112273812294,
-0.311542272567749,
-0.6401128768920898,
-0.455219566822052,
-0.5514995455741882,
0.11544778943061829,
-0.10494121164083481,
0.30813056230545044,
0.04625082388520241,
-0.1726120263338089,
-0.07385370880365372,
0.28482183814048767,
0.8591105341911316,
1.002357006072998,
-0.2767104208469391,
0.42625346779823303,
0.4733649790287018,
-0.1317128837108612,
0.1742965430021286,
0.09916097670793533,
0.11241483688354492,
-0.07812860608100891,
0.511555552482605,
0.7643235921859741,
0.5174798965454102,
-0.7440953850746155,
0.5896933674812317,
-0.2547329068183899,
-0.39434555172920227,
-0.1424570083618164,
-0.0385054312646389,
-0.019384587183594704,
0.6835347414016724,
0.24885427951812744,
0.4023055136203766,
0.045815810561180115,
-0.4005538821220398,
0.23176942765712738,
0.5615345239639282,
-0.40599480271339417,
-0.17393095791339874,
0.5701400637626648,
-0.1667635142803192,
0.15400972962379456,
0.5418078303337097,
-0.08079183846712112,
-0.44268548488616943,
0.6052812337875366,
0.513382077217102,
0.42131444811820984,
0.09868715703487396,
0.14622065424919128,
0.746959388256073,
0.424908310174942,
-0.09400659054517746,
0.5663782954216003,
-0.20229588449001312,
-0.8892009854316711,
-0.33713090419769287,
-0.20268657803535461,
-0.1589852124452591,
0.17451921105384827,
-0.9858440160751343,
0.025283001363277435,
-0.6006940007209778,
-0.3430511951446533,
-0.4066483974456787,
-0.2566361427307129,
-0.7679021954536438,
0.3249950706958771,
0.20970439910888672,
0.7199596166610718,
-1.0949466228485107,
0.5014904737472534,
0.8907856345176697,
-0.274421364068985,
-0.5544232726097107,
-0.3441692590713501,
0.08021137863397598,
-0.9114764332771301,
1.21515953540802,
0.13773265480995178,
-0.25474080443382263,
-0.48034852743148804,
-0.6119892001152039,
-1.099457859992981,
1.2307164669036865,
0.3648279905319214,
-0.6298294067382812,
0.4399384558200836,
-0.11266035586595535,
0.6511067152023315,
-0.28662109375,
0.30691081285476685,
0.40897336602211,
0.6091049313545227,
0.28289794921875,
-0.5893153548240662,
-0.0032322772312909365,
-0.35993680357933044,
0.3422123193740845,
-0.012605568394064903,
-0.5879316329956055,
0.745924711227417,
-0.5047495365142822,
-0.31162527203559875,
0.09431742131710052,
0.5341322422027588,
0.966427743434906,
0.5128586888313293,
0.466048926115036,
0.9853070974349976,
0.5009521245956421,
-0.46013107895851135,
1.0270352363586426,
-0.10240554064512253,
0.32457417249679565,
1.2782683372497559,
-0.7163500785827637,
1.012710690498352,
0.7511359453201294,
-0.4020506739616394,
0.32307255268096924,
0.5068147778511047,
-0.2003103643655777,
0.9472740292549133,
0.22312147915363312,
-0.04871172085404396,
-0.48502808809280396,
-0.019236860796809196,
-0.8019810318946838,
0.3068802058696747,
0.3734777271747589,
-0.17067798972129822,
-0.41902533173561096,
-0.1297939270734787,
-0.4947079122066498,
0.45233339071273804,
-0.337883323431015,
0.6410827040672302,
-0.036668647080659866,
-0.4820805788040161,
0.34958964586257935,
-0.13148002326488495,
0.16811631619930267,
-0.6916900277137756,
-0.10448500514030457,
-0.14609572291374207,
0.3880748748779297,
-0.11231964081525803,
-0.8851343393325806,
0.30959340929985046,
-0.15231233835220337,
-0.38358354568481445,
-0.21050432324409485,
1.001628041267395,
-0.13920384645462036,
-0.5196452736854553,
0.6279496550559998,
0.6086620092391968,
0.0507274754345417,
0.1653171330690384,
-0.7594557404518127,
0.3014780580997467,
-0.420784592628479,
-0.15016551315784454,
0.3664407432079315,
0.7347748875617981,
-0.0354803167283535,
0.8900116086006165,
0.7437864542007446,
0.03681595250964165,
0.26496320962905884,
0.4564010798931122,
0.9316105246543884,
-0.7631398439407349,
-0.040298592299222946,
-0.6025981307029724,
0.5130633115768433,
-0.14883358776569366,
-0.21840956807136536,
0.8380457162857056,
0.6099842190742493,
0.8457916975021362,
-0.3826901614665985,
0.6690845489501953,
0.19598577916622162,
0.40542492270469666,
-0.7535603642463684,
0.2656324803829193,
-0.6003321409225464,
0.20032115280628204,
-0.3251013457775116,
-0.9085174202919006,
-0.40890035033226013,
1.2028409242630005,
-0.750988245010376,
0.2540142238140106,
0.9177466630935669,
0.6179102063179016,
-0.21734772622585297,
-0.25488772988319397,
0.6238096356391907,
-0.07449856400489807,
-0.06504391133785248,
0.456386923789978,
1.3843939304351807,
-0.3704352080821991,
0.2793109118938446,
-0.020938554778695107,
-0.10683690756559372,
0.02291133627295494,
-0.9846888780593872,
-1.0397645235061646,
-0.40046969056129456,
0.00931666512042284,
-0.21732096374034882,
-0.060611382126808167,
0.476419061422348,
0.8665505647659302,
-0.5351517200469971,
-0.28345003724098206,
-0.053793806582689285,
-0.06023433059453964,
-0.36026903986930847,
-0.16828182339668274,
0.20720067620277405,
-0.28378960490226746,
-0.30552834272384644,
0.5022897720336914,
0.5485205054283142,
0.16143780946731567,
-0.19186510145664215,
-0.3395267128944397,
-0.14940650761127472,
-0.2606506645679474,
0.8341549038887024,
0.16182683408260345,
-1.013210415840149,
-0.2180161029100418,
-0.02694595418870449,
-0.25838616490364075,
0.058583129197359085,
0.9407065510749817,
-0.6755130887031555,
0.42353492975234985,
0.4169968366622925,
0.5198671817779541,
0.647394061088562,
0.21915476024150848,
0.2823779881000519,
-0.5075602531433105,
0.4592556357383728,
-0.0891227126121521,
0.9628822207450867,
0.34815067052841187,
-0.062255218625068665,
0.8533637523651123,
0.3517060875892639,
-0.6197547912597656,
-0.5704872012138367,
0.1489366888999939,
-1.1694614887237549,
-0.1498233526945114,
1.2179862260818481,
-0.2671418786048889,
-0.04891355708241463,
0.054587822407484055,
-0.4521462917327881,
-0.3127865195274353,
0.013859272934496403,
0.6021190285682678,
0.7608180046081543,
-0.03276054561138153,
-0.6565654873847961,
-0.4964921772480011,
0.10880390554666519,
0.2886416018009186,
-0.8686521053314209,
-0.22833514213562012,
0.9481114149093628,
0.31144019961357117,
0.013740827329456806,
0.7260134816169739,
-0.14957909286022186,
0.1978575885295868,
0.20456118881702423,
0.010702094994485378,
-0.031326305121183395,
-0.52439284324646,
-0.19591665267944336,
0.23682467639446259,
0.028488410636782646,
-0.1721653789281845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13236v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13236v1 | Data Contamination Can Cross Language Barriers | 2024-06-19T05:53:27 | 2024-06-19T05:53:27 | Feng Yao, Yufan Zhuang, Zihao Sun, Sunan Xu, Animesh Kumar, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The opacity in developing large language models (LLMs) is raising growing
concerns about the potential contamination of public benchmarks in the
pre-training data. Existing contamination detection methods are typically based
on the text overlap between training and evaluation data, which can be too
superficial to reflect deeper forms of contamination. In this paper, we first
present a cross-lingual form of contamination that inflates LLMs' performance
while evading current detection methods, deliberately injected by overfitting
LLMs on the translated versions of benchmark test sets. Then, we propose
generalization-based approaches to unmask such deeply concealed contamination.
Specifically, we examine the LLM's performance change after modifying the
original benchmark by replacing the false answer choices with correct ones from
other questions. Contaminated models can hardly generalize to such easier
situations, where the false choices can be \emph{not even wrong}, as all
choices are correct in their memorization. Experimental results demonstrate
that cross-lingual contamination can easily fool existing detection methods,
but not ours. In addition, we discuss the potential utilization of
cross-lingual contamination in interpreting LLMs' working mechanisms and in
post-training LLMs for enhanced multilingual capabilities. The code and dataset
we use can be obtained from \url{https://github.com/ShangDataLab/Deep-Contam}. | [
-0.43010053038597107,
-0.9012473821640015,
0.5749421119689941,
0.012085472233593464,
-0.30519920587539673,
0.3585800528526306,
-0.23561224341392517,
-0.9952590465545654,
-0.18451105058193207,
1.0186764001846313,
-0.16072335839271545,
-0.4718318581581116,
-0.8551651835441589,
-0.16356885433197021,
-0.5168708562850952,
0.8591500520706177,
-0.3494226932525635,
-0.11253604292869568,
-0.17995776236057281,
-0.14384858310222626,
-0.23889435827732086,
-0.7205609083175659,
-0.3450566232204437,
-0.5406150817871094,
0.3077915608882904,
0.4321275055408478,
0.658456563949585,
0.649815559387207,
0.27823132276535034,
0.33292171359062195,
-0.22481070458889008,
0.18983866274356842,
-0.5342963337898254,
0.1105140820145607,
-0.4636082053184509,
-0.6903753876686096,
-0.1301669180393219,
-0.036082230508327484,
0.6336200833320618,
0.8619602918624878,
0.03934767097234726,
-0.07121089100837708,
0.27075478434562683,
0.5269266963005066,
-0.9040200114250183,
-0.0050607589073479176,
-0.8209779262542725,
0.04300103336572647,
-0.5804227590560913,
-0.09554426372051239,
-0.3254737854003906,
0.13426120579242706,
-0.16018016636371613,
-0.6562066674232483,
0.12262976914644241,
-0.17737673223018646,
0.977290153503418,
0.2679547369480133,
-0.4340762794017792,
-0.05342234671115875,
-0.9390586614608765,
0.936440646648407,
-0.5939716696739197,
0.4282677173614502,
0.6893672943115234,
0.29489126801490784,
-0.19005334377288818,
-0.6716704964637756,
-0.36955761909484863,
-0.07421336323022842,
-0.08482572436332703,
-0.18320387601852417,
-0.29552608728408813,
-0.1679752916097641,
0.23412135243415833,
0.3457132875919342,
-0.4315747618675232,
0.3731953203678131,
-0.28721797466278076,
-0.36739349365234375,
0.5625429153442383,
0.03593141958117485,
0.695392370223999,
0.06672361493110657,
-0.5304402709007263,
-0.12418971955776215,
-1.2766155004501343,
-0.11703355610370636,
0.5282083749771118,
0.22700135409832,
-0.110942542552948,
0.35566115379333496,
-0.2791551351547241,
0.5461980700492859,
-0.2985682785511017,
0.14143502712249756,
0.35360538959503174,
-0.5794298648834229,
-0.34979555010795593,
-0.022875865921378136,
0.7277826070785522,
-0.004027117509394884,
0.6025761365890503,
-0.27529165148735046,
-0.20228035748004913,
-0.13251596689224243,
0.01492537371814251,
-0.6632929444313049,
-0.21513903141021729,
0.16963781416416168,
0.05800434574484825,
-0.17037391662597656,
-0.09622912108898163,
-0.7677991390228271,
-0.5678814649581909,
-0.32331788539886475,
0.49825772643089294,
-0.12425976991653442,
-0.375611811876297,
0.4417218863964081,
0.2050287425518036,
-0.2605728805065155,
0.10796988010406494,
-0.874375581741333,
0.25170373916625977,
0.9078668355941772,
0.4322391450405121,
-0.0064212786965072155,
-0.3465595841407776,
-0.6162241697311401,
0.20468094944953918,
-0.32880693674087524,
0.640934944152832,
-0.6411076188087463,
-0.4604165554046631,
0.17934127151966095,
-0.01463100966066122,
0.029684150591492653,
-0.9875165224075317,
0.37784284353256226,
-0.5468992590904236,
0.2808912694454193,
-0.177100270986557,
-0.40695735812187195,
-0.14368124306201935,
0.07570666074752808,
-0.650985062122345,
1.049407720565796,
-0.10318546742200851,
-0.8782577514648438,
0.47337061166763306,
-0.09940219670534134,
-0.6230747103691101,
0.20345273613929749,
-0.3749788701534271,
-0.28186243772506714,
-0.16827236115932465,
0.3487131595611572,
0.2980600893497467,
-0.07702235877513885,
0.4396597146987915,
-0.25329020619392395,
-0.6159241199493408,
0.21425524353981018,
-0.5574808120727539,
0.8009540438652039,
0.16767774522304535,
-0.5316866040229797,
-0.09090275317430496,
-0.8288739919662476,
0.12390702962875366,
-0.10276255756616592,
-0.45223385095596313,
-0.7455516457557678,
-0.22888131439685822,
-0.0961044505238533,
0.24328024685382843,
0.15579532086849213,
-0.4884720742702484,
-0.2053673267364502,
-0.3284454047679901,
0.24461273849010468,
0.696779191493988,
0.10078320652246475,
0.1871263086795807,
-0.3789559006690979,
0.5439748764038086,
0.27244508266448975,
0.28920888900756836,
-0.08280821144580841,
-0.49448418617248535,
-0.8139291405677795,
-0.2980557084083557,
0.32797306776046753,
0.5727463960647583,
-1.0424237251281738,
0.2936852276325226,
-0.2672775387763977,
-0.5300447940826416,
-0.5119470357894897,
0.4232836961746216,
0.6487494707107544,
0.4361203610897064,
0.4657781422138214,
-0.27907049655914307,
-0.4520990252494812,
-0.9088866114616394,
-0.7286924123764038,
0.018038460984826088,
-0.16846461594104767,
0.4026408791542053,
0.6130046248435974,
-0.3312543034553528,
0.7187543511390686,
-0.3636857569217682,
-0.3203335106372833,
0.06214773282408714,
0.058382924646139145,
0.11606860905885696,
0.5363225340843201,
0.22731781005859375,
-0.7156819701194763,
-0.6139171719551086,
0.06839384138584137,
-0.7844315767288208,
-0.3736943006515503,
0.07220152765512466,
-0.11177229881286621,
-0.029464617371559143,
0.9124715328216553,
-0.22707656025886536,
0.16349239647388458,
0.652180016040802,
-0.1039094403386116,
0.587395966053009,
-0.27045106887817383,
0.15364719927310944,
-0.7332295179367065,
0.14645303785800934,
-0.060775276273489,
-0.13599219918251038,
-0.7512951493263245,
0.2489219307899475,
0.11621955782175064,
0.14920029044151306,
-0.8838784098625183,
0.63565993309021,
-0.5210896134376526,
0.1377696841955185,
-0.1767139881849289,
0.1890920102596283,
0.3256438374519348,
0.1740337312221527,
-0.06162607669830322,
0.7332945466041565,
0.6062300801277161,
-0.3981499671936035,
0.1641722470521927,
0.05512665957212448,
-0.7573572993278503,
0.44447436928749084,
-0.6674818992614746,
0.11883533000946045,
0.15110784769058228,
0.05194820463657379,
-0.951763391494751,
-0.06625416874885559,
0.38940727710723877,
-0.114702507853508,
0.46592748165130615,
-0.33645546436309814,
-0.7332583665847778,
0.09906987100839615,
-0.1326642632484436,
0.6807766556739807,
0.267135351896286,
-0.8381064534187317,
0.17685601115226746,
0.35084450244903564,
-0.04522755742073059,
-0.8853649497032166,
-1.0596020221710205,
0.21900799870491028,
-0.37447986006736755,
-0.7109552621841431,
0.2386186569929123,
0.07514306902885437,
-0.4414308965206146,
-0.09162309020757675,
-0.11852412670850754,
-0.28144699335098267,
0.48218032717704773,
0.17993299663066864,
0.09938792139291763,
-0.15348345041275024,
0.14536042511463165,
0.04452897608280182,
0.10277485847473145,
0.17801569402217865,
0.12340115755796432,
0.5487490892410278,
0.23783425986766815,
-0.7140483260154724,
-0.05204494670033455,
0.2503053843975067,
0.42599284648895264,
-0.32431676983833313,
0.5925767421722412,
0.3109479248523712,
-0.5229842662811279,
-0.2278285175561905,
-0.6329599022865295,
0.06658700853586197,
-0.5889648795127869,
0.5296088457107544,
-0.3317534625530243,
-0.5983420014381409,
0.5689544677734375,
-0.058228541165590286,
-0.29111361503601074,
0.11189156770706177,
0.11313028633594513,
0.1607891321182251,
0.7142379283905029,
0.6632332801818848,
-0.23639842867851257,
0.4017092287540436,
-0.10776682198047638,
0.015406315214931965,
-0.7637074589729309,
-0.26437273621559143,
-0.5845536589622498,
-0.004367430694401264,
-0.49838924407958984,
-0.6221285462379456,
0.15952721238136292,
0.2055402547121048,
-0.2106344848871231,
0.14740338921546936,
-0.05902907997369766,
0.8143085837364197,
0.3095984160900116,
0.10289788246154785,
0.6722007393836975,
0.04227662831544876,
-0.44352832436561584,
-0.1539744734764099,
-0.4484747648239136,
-0.42160168290138245,
1.150115728378296,
0.449039489030838,
0.9145952463150024,
-0.09822476655244827,
0.8726561665534973,
0.07720736414194107,
0.2915138900279999,
-0.0999545231461525,
0.398663192987442,
-0.35295388102531433,
-0.7380731105804443,
-0.293901264667511,
-0.623101532459259,
-1.1208206415176392,
0.6067284941673279,
-0.08991868048906326,
-0.8862640261650085,
0.3675329089164734,
-0.29982054233551025,
0.042521972209215164,
0.5253759622573853,
-0.6303391456604004,
0.8305056691169739,
-0.4693893492221832,
-0.5652019381523132,
0.00006334488716674969,
-0.4424501061439514,
0.6574890613555908,
-0.5267696976661682,
0.5897334218025208,
-0.08657686412334442,
0.08398625999689102,
0.6095396876335144,
-0.27558189630508423,
0.987505316734314,
-0.00840218085795641,
-0.5434840321540833,
-0.12102951109409332,
0.18023639917373657,
0.4792391359806061,
-0.16671574115753174,
0.18378004431724548,
0.50242018699646,
-0.27429911494255066,
-0.49970582127571106,
-0.3205035626888275,
0.535097599029541,
-0.5891390442848206,
-0.7124648690223694,
-0.35593244433403015,
-0.5097029209136963,
-0.4809931218624115,
0.46472424268722534,
0.4976367652416229,
0.19899483025074005,
-0.0881403312087059,
0.10982095450162888,
0.7596866488456726,
-0.5606167316436768,
0.19960680603981018,
0.8290547132492065,
-0.283260315656662,
-0.07170680165290833,
0.9250828623771667,
0.10088547319173813,
0.5959254503250122,
0.4030602276325226,
0.0897282212972641,
-0.25849491357803345,
-0.82009357213974,
-0.31193655729293823,
0.36590781807899475,
-0.7444218993186951,
0.11759776622056961,
-0.4539850652217865,
-0.1154516413807869,
-0.2893212139606476,
0.15427365899085999,
-0.3083711266517639,
0.058867260813713074,
-0.2832603454589844,
-0.02140013501048088,
-0.07233448326587677,
0.7345104813575745,
-0.33217400312423706,
0.1400362253189087,
-0.7735591530799866,
0.33662649989128113,
0.10517261922359467,
0.5124199986457825,
-0.15848471224308014,
-0.558576226234436,
-0.36742761731147766,
0.3235852122306824,
-0.032261792570352554,
-0.62103670835495,
0.26914411783218384,
0.04988136515021324,
0.8698728680610657,
0.5277258157730103,
-0.014118705876171589,
0.45652860403060913,
-0.30391785502433777,
0.55132657289505,
0.04642738401889801,
-1.1093329191207886,
0.35605838894844055,
-0.3804911971092224,
0.2626614272594452,
0.509437620639801,
0.47197532653808594,
-0.8651623129844666,
-1.0165953636169434,
-0.3865514099597931,
-1.1361682415008545,
0.5441067814826965,
-0.12379912286996841,
0.06480961292982101,
0.2047504484653473,
0.0032922651153057814,
0.10791309177875519,
0.18521302938461304,
-0.6513327956199646,
-0.10792414098978043,
0.029556579887866974,
0.22379443049430847,
-0.449354350566864,
-0.4334932565689087,
-0.2754804790019989,
0.06829586625099182,
0.627242922782898,
0.2009548544883728,
-0.6241329312324524,
0.004170380532741547,
-0.606390118598938,
-0.15402716398239136,
0.36084315180778503,
0.5595547556877136,
0.797467052936554,
0.05768419802188873,
0.4094516634941101,
0.04835943877696991,
-0.5617073178291321,
0.2312554121017456,
0.04681112617254257,
-0.18850769102573395,
-0.1699930727481842,
0.5787559151649475,
0.37434035539627075,
0.4785953164100647,
-0.8223057985305786,
0.48568838834762573,
0.13748930394649506,
0.05134321376681328,
-0.016575517132878304,
0.12046167999505997,
0.19264322519302368,
0.10353784263134003,
0.33576086163520813,
-0.14614252746105194,
0.05415879189968109,
-0.7379232048988342,
0.5640543103218079,
0.24379967153072357,
-0.27296802401542664,
-0.06655175238847733,
0.7030126452445984,
0.18424910306930542,
0.07463517785072327,
0.4686011075973511,
0.08046160638332367,
-0.715279221534729,
0.5566166043281555,
0.29152172803878784,
0.6518101692199707,
-0.4581353962421417,
0.06196964159607887,
-0.1247747391462326,
0.5586277842521667,
0.04283415898680687,
0.15202519297599792,
0.2273329645395279,
-0.95472252368927,
-0.6178205609321594,
-0.2730873227119446,
-0.3417862057685852,
0.6158790588378906,
-0.7362378239631653,
0.09275916963815689,
-0.2929934859275818,
0.26986950635910034,
0.06687657535076141,
-0.018311532214283943,
-0.5011113286018372,
0.23117782175540924,
0.461331307888031,
0.835634171962738,
-1.2735923528671265,
0.7874696254730225,
0.3309025764465332,
-0.32444819808006287,
-0.4830058217048645,
0.14145053923130035,
-0.11231517791748047,
-0.973484992980957,
0.6607624292373657,
0.13113246858119965,
-0.02626509591937065,
-0.6147793531417847,
-0.19200220704078674,
-0.7152026891708374,
0.4713848829269409,
0.5363024473190308,
-0.5357529520988464,
0.26371583342552185,
0.7770330309867859,
0.617697536945343,
0.15266798436641693,
0.11798130720853806,
0.8735837936401367,
0.6843556761741638,
-0.4284484386444092,
-1.039249300956726,
0.31552383303642273,
-0.20541051030158997,
-0.2351042777299881,
0.2085188776254654,
-0.47794702649116516,
0.9972267746925354,
-0.013447766192257404,
-0.3699961006641388,
-0.02066981978714466,
0.07489806413650513,
0.04493740200996399,
0.2709383964538574,
0.493491530418396,
0.6037628650665283,
0.8495625257492065,
-0.10641171783208847,
0.9538891911506653,
-0.08127083629369736,
0.24876463413238525,
1.4356597661972046,
-0.5518385767936707,
0.6998181939125061,
0.5004145503044128,
-0.18236792087554932,
0.3956422805786133,
0.5391504168510437,
-0.2217015027999878,
0.46987342834472656,
0.5232005715370178,
-0.29036402702331543,
-0.19202563166618347,
-0.2531282305717468,
-0.5577908754348755,
0.5633018016815186,
0.31448930501937866,
-0.2843795120716095,
-0.606313169002533,
0.12690554559230804,
0.2444840520620346,
0.3459813892841339,
-0.12164463102817535,
0.5344036817550659,
-0.06540786474943161,
-0.658227264881134,
0.8665896654129028,
-0.017253749072551727,
0.7098126411437988,
-0.4083947241306305,
0.03731577843427658,
-0.4448498487472534,
0.2950589954853058,
-0.37441501021385193,
-0.9467614889144897,
0.13796459138393402,
-0.22370921075344086,
0.09930189698934555,
-0.2824621796607971,
0.7177344560623169,
-0.8009355664253235,
-0.15834060311317444,
0.8428596258163452,
0.765561580657959,
0.4303322732448578,
-0.4566497206687927,
-0.4777928292751312,
0.19022062420845032,
-0.03767293691635132,
-0.00013712160580325872,
0.6123887300491333,
0.38773593306541443,
-0.08209317922592163,
0.7056248188018799,
0.6877773404121399,
0.2732241749763489,
0.24491381645202637,
0.3143656551837921,
0.7744081020355225,
-0.3667961061000824,
-0.4649488031864166,
-0.8519301414489746,
0.26106077432632446,
0.12062472105026245,
-0.07211381942033768,
0.7518012523651123,
0.773884117603302,
1.1275657415390015,
0.19875697791576385,
0.8242461681365967,
0.6212030649185181,
0.3982551097869873,
-0.6011848449707031,
0.8572949171066284,
-0.5355770587921143,
0.6279954314231873,
-0.319686621427536,
-0.5539907217025757,
-0.11439496278762817,
-0.006158281583338976,
-0.38699159026145935,
0.07317674160003662,
0.7356380820274353,
0.7237923741340637,
-0.3125285506248474,
-0.10831978172063828,
0.5539594292640686,
0.3759191334247589,
0.5229738354682922,
0.8603110909461975,
1.0508317947387695,
-0.3059006631374359,
0.8565075397491455,
-0.47898155450820923,
-0.20188045501708984,
-0.28112131357192993,
-0.778712272644043,
-0.7551554441452026,
-0.3087414801120758,
-0.4324027895927429,
-0.19764283299446106,
0.2343701273202896,
-0.06165532395243645,
0.5505288243293762,
-0.7501745223999023,
-0.11301729083061218,
-0.02521125040948391,
0.3961959779262543,
-0.08432997018098831,
-0.2128375768661499,
0.23416340351104736,
-0.2706303894519806,
-0.9083212614059448,
0.6660004258155823,
-0.24527917802333832,
0.22440631687641144,
-0.30950987339019775,
0.3207584023475647,
-0.16627313196659088,
-0.09045828133821487,
0.2423698753118515,
0.34642842411994934,
-0.442649245262146,
-0.4074764847755432,
-0.37955373525619507,
-0.19251875579357147,
0.08759986609220505,
0.6595235466957092,
-0.5611767172813416,
0.538210928440094,
0.4289438724517822,
0.6329891085624695,
0.536074161529541,
-0.1145762950181961,
0.5728297233581543,
-1.128307819366455,
0.2149842083454132,
0.16336926817893982,
0.5634241104125977,
0.5443910956382751,
-0.6183018684387207,
0.5226724743843079,
0.22873060405254364,
-0.28230729699134827,
-1.1889146566390991,
0.3284050226211548,
-0.41758081316947937,
-0.5827280879020691,
1.4503216743469238,
-0.40148231387138367,
-0.022480154410004616,
-0.5053772330284119,
0.2210884988307953,
0.15219087898731232,
0.0727204754948616,
0.8127231597900391,
1.024219036102295,
0.242063507437706,
0.2921031415462494,
-0.7458433508872986,
0.32851263880729675,
0.5076523423194885,
-0.9108213782310486,
0.2585735023021698,
0.24650424718856812,
0.8155459761619568,
0.20782439410686493,
0.4086560308933258,
-0.47347527742385864,
0.3041514754295349,
0.06618618220090866,
-0.013844821602106094,
-0.22364681959152222,
-0.2872526943683624,
-0.5428876280784607,
-0.04658573493361473,
-0.0782419964671135,
-0.34397169947624207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13232v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13232v1 | Towards Robust Evaluation: A Comprehensive Taxonomy of Datasets and Metrics for Open Domain Question Answering in the Era of Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T05:43:02 | 2024-06-19T05:43:02 | Akchay Srivastava, Atif Memon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | Open Domain Question Answering (ODQA) within natural language processing
involves building systems that answer factual questions using large-scale
knowledge corpora. Recent advances stem from the confluence of several factors,
such as large-scale training datasets, deep learning techniques, and the rise
of large language models. High-quality datasets are used to train models on
realistic scenarios and enable the evaluation of the system on potentially
unseen data. Standardized metrics facilitate comparisons between different ODQA
systems, allowing researchers to objectively track advancements in the field.
Our study presents a thorough examination of the current landscape of ODQA
benchmarking by reviewing 52 datasets and 20 evaluation techniques across
textual and multimodal modalities. We introduce a novel taxonomy for ODQA
datasets that incorporates both the modality and difficulty of the question
types. Additionally, we present a structured organization of ODQA evaluation
metrics along with a critical analysis of their inherent trade-offs. Our study
aims to empower researchers by providing a framework for the robust evaluation
of modern question-answering systems. We conclude by identifying the current
challenges and outlining promising avenues for future research and development. | [
-0.598313570022583,
-0.9632183313369751,
0.44837161898612976,
-0.2693031132221222,
0.16996924579143524,
0.29513803124427795,
-0.27711549401283264,
-0.31214869022369385,
-0.46862277388572693,
0.23274144530296326,
-0.4091421663761139,
-0.38368794322013855,
-0.346471905708313,
0.032898709177970886,
-0.2279432713985443,
0.858786940574646,
-0.2670995593070984,
0.1610546112060547,
-0.5619972348213196,
-0.5956082344055176,
-0.41605982184410095,
-0.43944209814071655,
-0.37406033277511597,
0.19635720551013947,
0.15174049139022827,
0.2091057449579239,
0.8620517253875732,
0.41406863927841187,
0.6479389071464539,
0.16856065392494202,
-0.05943770334124565,
0.19705426692962646,
-0.645912766456604,
0.2982182502746582,
-0.27408841252326965,
-0.13731275498867035,
-0.5371332764625549,
-0.054823700338602066,
0.7237378358840942,
1.1673506498336792,
-0.04859061539173126,
0.5161268711090088,
0.03944379463791847,
0.33846569061279297,
-0.9895980954170227,
0.009675489738583565,
-0.516143798828125,
-0.1053764671087265,
-0.11081243306398392,
-0.07720866799354553,
-0.10353057831525803,
-0.6625626087188721,
0.10543304681777954,
-0.49503037333488464,
-0.19444867968559265,
0.04730929806828499,
0.599260687828064,
0.26097241044044495,
-0.47262856364250183,
-0.3404647409915924,
-0.6099721193313599,
0.986782431602478,
-0.5225847363471985,
0.6209016442298889,
0.18897207081317902,
0.5476077795028687,
0.0732443556189537,
-0.7804078459739685,
-0.3744826018810272,
-0.0591278001666069,
0.3261604607105255,
0.12260531634092331,
-0.1914873570203781,
-0.20186273753643036,
0.04808693006634712,
0.7604487538337708,
-0.6774028539657593,
0.12710727751255035,
-0.21621260046958923,
-0.17051416635513306,
0.3296998143196106,
0.42553624510765076,
0.2847597002983093,
0.08965228497982025,
-0.44624561071395874,
0.09653837978839874,
-0.31474360823631287,
0.20120012760162354,
0.2794780135154724,
0.28094810247421265,
0.31029409170150757,
0.6178415417671204,
-0.48372623324394226,
0.7036975622177124,
-0.24450944364070892,
-0.10065160691738129,
0.14017751812934875,
-0.6681958436965942,
-0.21419194340705872,
-0.41411903500556946,
0.6872345209121704,
0.28194648027420044,
0.14117127656936646,
-0.4013633728027344,
-0.2877006232738495,
0.10719078034162521,
0.4333532452583313,
-0.6256098747253418,
0.03033425845205784,
0.42823198437690735,
-0.5025332570075989,
-0.22558273375034332,
0.10648993402719498,
-1.0418287515640259,
-0.2641552984714508,
-0.1957952231168747,
0.6151933670043945,
-0.37269076704978943,
-0.35135751962661743,
0.39799579977989197,
-0.05803462490439415,
0.27658116817474365,
0.28927695751190186,
-0.4172271192073822,
0.6849037408828735,
0.8405099511146545,
0.5066751837730408,
-0.32999083399772644,
-0.10020910203456879,
-0.6893122792243958,
-0.43255409598350525,
-0.4623887836933136,
0.5289000868797302,
-0.593860924243927,
-0.01232505589723587,
0.3193860650062561,
-0.24830232560634613,
-0.2019047737121582,
-0.7145395874977112,
1.074361801147461,
-1.0083448886871338,
0.33005332946777344,
-0.20039653778076172,
-0.37923821806907654,
-0.10010401159524918,
0.511267364025116,
-0.608592689037323,
1.2990621328353882,
0.3455592095851898,
-0.7953073382377625,
0.5605610013008118,
-0.6871426701545715,
-0.04373123124241829,
-0.04041185975074768,
0.180549755692482,
-0.08294688165187836,
0.03378444164991379,
0.25022563338279724,
0.22801454365253448,
-0.6131433844566345,
0.2181515246629715,
-0.44496268033981323,
-0.10675327479839325,
0.3428889214992523,
-0.4211752116680145,
0.8795689940452576,
0.5475150346755981,
-0.13714700937271118,
0.11969348043203354,
-0.9168395400047302,
0.39285382628440857,
0.01526270154863596,
-0.3200266659259796,
-0.49854785203933716,
-0.20699161291122437,
-0.09617961943149567,
0.029575863853096962,
0.16830676794052124,
-0.6571121215820312,
-0.14840780198574066,
-0.20539093017578125,
0.6085487604141235,
0.4321848154067993,
0.14863069355487823,
0.3836524486541748,
-0.2719741463661194,
0.6952320337295532,
-0.23397427797317505,
0.3877502679824829,
-0.04123647138476372,
-0.3806890845298767,
-0.3407873213291168,
-0.3767927289009094,
0.6133608222007751,
0.4010070264339447,
-0.9113606810569763,
0.36824503540992737,
-0.3722890317440033,
-0.5686889886856079,
-0.7113604545593262,
-0.002537253312766552,
0.33411309123039246,
0.6161511540412903,
0.3799225091934204,
-0.71300208568573,
-0.11155925691127777,
-0.5175976753234863,
-0.15876378118991852,
-0.28020355105400085,
-0.1463860273361206,
0.2047664076089859,
0.6620655059814453,
0.21383945643901825,
0.9912813305854797,
-0.4410187304019928,
-0.0170452743768692,
-0.011110899038612843,
0.02022474631667137,
-0.01652952842414379,
0.19495375454425812,
0.4462442100048065,
-0.7572818994522095,
-0.07058285176753998,
-0.15113307535648346,
-0.6161076426506042,
0.08392870426177979,
0.3164132535457611,
-0.27844101190567017,
-0.029032176360487938,
0.3389482796192169,
-0.4684646725654602,
0.256181538105011,
0.2627665400505066,
-0.28131890296936035,
0.6641611456871033,
0.26142656803131104,
0.4282771646976471,
-0.645405113697052,
0.3928302228450775,
-0.24472488462924957,
0.011990134604275227,
-0.5831614136695862,
0.5251392722129822,
0.018979575484991074,
-0.11965014040470123,
-0.3757678270339966,
0.6319660544395447,
-0.23670963943004608,
-0.05917429178953171,
0.37526360154151917,
0.37824124097824097,
0.24262981116771698,
0.2271602749824524,
-0.1166035383939743,
0.593039870262146,
0.6010758280754089,
-0.4697019159793854,
0.4383173882961273,
0.5843372344970703,
-0.7539843320846558,
0.858267605304718,
-0.625841498374939,
0.16137973964214325,
-0.007088409271091223,
-0.08792316168546677,
-1.1335172653198242,
-0.21899448335170746,
0.20406058430671692,
-0.6278793215751648,
0.10798262804746628,
0.05367249622941017,
-0.5267958045005798,
-0.4048652648925781,
-0.5367507934570312,
0.7453328967094421,
0.24848797917366028,
-0.5170636773109436,
0.17825445532798767,
0.3839820921421051,
-0.30554506182670593,
-0.7101430296897888,
-0.3866044580936432,
0.01607731357216835,
-0.239586740732193,
-0.6783079504966736,
-0.10760612785816193,
-0.18974287807941437,
-0.6178131699562073,
0.07109358161687851,
-0.18781884014606476,
-0.5419862270355225,
0.29956844449043274,
-0.3231498599052429,
0.16140106320381165,
-0.6392607092857361,
0.20589031279087067,
-0.2848120331764221,
0.20698240399360657,
0.2588607668876648,
-0.34540289640426636,
0.3428592383861542,
-0.16339409351348877,
-0.4020450711250305,
0.12333092093467712,
0.3455803096294403,
0.49871283769607544,
-0.7169719338417053,
0.5457984805107117,
0.5858932137489319,
-0.5237172245979309,
-0.21130971610546112,
-0.21372780203819275,
-0.011149330995976925,
-0.3634505569934845,
0.413131445646286,
-0.39330101013183594,
-0.8602010011672974,
0.3193972110748291,
0.07497484236955643,
0.2593037188053131,
0.48168155550956726,
0.5482853651046753,
0.2450180947780609,
0.8560939431190491,
0.48935240507125854,
0.1535481959581375,
-0.05357205122709274,
0.05010809376835823,
0.2249283492565155,
-0.6326377391815186,
-0.09469544142484665,
-0.9500545263290405,
0.12053336203098297,
-0.1632232666015625,
-0.5947926044464111,
0.40234488248825073,
0.1724243015050888,
-0.47016289830207825,
0.01401449367403984,
-0.32073861360549927,
0.08202120661735535,
0.44900578260421753,
-0.058993950486183167,
0.5214803218841553,
-0.1981344074010849,
-0.20734857022762299,
0.04359648376703262,
-0.7378070950508118,
-0.7441608309745789,
1.2358373403549194,
0.6726323962211609,
0.8051133751869202,
0.1592060625553131,
0.17802564799785614,
0.17444266378879547,
0.12026133388280869,
-1.0370010137557983,
0.3956192135810852,
0.23086026310920715,
-0.8389922976493835,
-0.5464685559272766,
-0.5992979407310486,
-0.8912755250930786,
-0.056709252297878265,
-0.11697990447282791,
-0.6652506589889526,
0.22642263770103455,
-0.3098927140235901,
-0.4808967411518097,
0.35846132040023804,
-0.3513224124908447,
1.053823709487915,
-0.1968528777360916,
-0.384868860244751,
0.22916097939014435,
-0.603432834148407,
0.40548014640808105,
0.007418955210596323,
0.17082878947257996,
0.17284223437309265,
-0.28077757358551025,
0.7561700940132141,
-0.09175188094377518,
0.425025075674057,
-0.055499058216810226,
-0.41215553879737854,
0.520648717880249,
0.0020026916172355413,
-0.21810400485992432,
0.1264379769563675,
-0.4420710504055023,
0.0812397301197052,
0.5687384605407715,
-0.4746645987033844,
-0.5821136236190796,
0.5666808485984802,
-0.5206339955329895,
-0.09285777062177658,
-0.4233286380767822,
-0.40604305267333984,
-0.8305240869522095,
0.10668253153562546,
-0.0999700054526329,
0.8462561964988708,
-0.6712342500686646,
0.2944236993789673,
0.8768102526664734,
-0.4569208025932312,
0.11026518046855927,
0.20095381140708923,
-0.18572181463241577,
-0.7575100064277649,
0.7236931920051575,
0.10411901026964188,
0.5919662714004517,
0.36084744334220886,
0.026186039671301842,
-0.6516622304916382,
-0.6427770853042603,
-0.7680578827857971,
-0.10367049276828766,
-0.9237275719642639,
-0.3466753363609314,
-0.5370066165924072,
-0.16011035442352295,
-0.4700019061565399,
0.2732708156108856,
-0.14874635636806488,
-0.4538745582103729,
0.06901943683624268,
-0.06734324246644974,
0.12729275226593018,
0.6612579822540283,
0.36029335856437683,
-0.38128024339675903,
-0.6563277244567871,
0.4653511941432953,
0.3558506369590759,
0.8427003026008606,
0.16024471819400787,
-0.4896327555179596,
-0.2021685242652893,
0.019740736111998558,
-0.37420353293418884,
-0.5062485933303833,
-0.11807642132043839,
0.3814496695995331,
0.7415334582328796,
0.2690349817276001,
0.6823193430900574,
0.31831884384155273,
-0.2172534167766571,
0.9948604702949524,
-0.103052519261837,
-0.7750749588012695,
0.2819833755493164,
-0.39778974652290344,
0.36494168639183044,
0.8799034357070923,
0.7736902236938477,
-0.26085323095321655,
-0.17218121886253357,
-0.29748353362083435,
-0.8108642101287842,
0.45963749289512634,
0.1420842558145523,
-0.04887117072939873,
0.0018786631990224123,
0.1617184281349182,
0.5098431706428528,
0.5207292437553406,
-0.258185476064682,
-0.06309076398611069,
-0.18992501497268677,
-0.31657859683036804,
-0.03078353963792324,
0.04673267900943756,
-0.4775472581386566,
0.0027421382255852222,
0.47097840905189514,
-0.4014449119567871,
0.28799763321876526,
0.17573095858097076,
-0.13918821513652802,
-0.01885620877146721,
0.5937932729721069,
0.1654086858034134,
0.9555143713951111,
-0.3011551797389984,
-0.009785904549062252,
0.10437735915184021,
-0.45197781920433044,
-0.04238922894001007,
0.15163776278495789,
-0.11369571834802628,
-0.21521565318107605,
0.3175649642944336,
0.501114010810852,
-0.04537922143936157,
-0.9988094568252563,
0.47939249873161316,
-0.149179607629776,
-0.3376648724079132,
-0.010872241109609604,
-0.21369148790836334,
-0.26483744382858276,
-0.1185133084654808,
0.37322020530700684,
0.05512182042002678,
0.35729366540908813,
-0.9994441866874695,
0.17477330565452576,
0.3522791564464569,
-0.7912994623184204,
-0.23566006124019623,
0.716237485408783,
-0.006490466184914112,
0.0771600529551506,
0.3146600127220154,
0.04727667197585106,
-0.37029170989990234,
0.38166284561157227,
-0.0012854369124397635,
0.7404475808143616,
0.046622246503829956,
0.25692519545555115,
0.3203009366989136,
0.2978737950325012,
0.1224561259150505,
0.6092064380645752,
-0.1042063906788826,
-0.4630127251148224,
-0.31526046991348267,
-0.8823229074478149,
-0.6349409818649292,
0.1974128782749176,
-0.945568859577179,
0.03678451478481293,
-0.39012372493743896,
-0.12831981480121613,
-0.039458222687244415,
0.14397405087947845,
-0.6949602961540222,
0.5171425342559814,
-0.10395897924900055,
1.3465187549591064,
-0.4526052474975586,
0.375070184469223,
0.9587393999099731,
-0.37424802780151367,
-0.3798550069332123,
0.20179472863674164,
-0.11089115589857101,
-0.4363691806793213,
0.22629286348819733,
-0.04886915907263756,
-0.08723805844783783,
-0.280415803194046,
-0.4156288504600525,
-0.6290743947029114,
0.7520262598991394,
0.25095415115356445,
0.23023314774036407,
0.22791677713394165,
0.23509211838245392,
0.732518196105957,
-0.34262165427207947,
0.4181782007217407,
0.716984212398529,
0.5598067045211792,
-0.01913904771208763,
-1.1120377779006958,
0.03958027809858322,
-0.2550133168697357,
-0.2578282654285431,
0.1616997867822647,
-0.4799947440624237,
0.6038278937339783,
-0.022625336423516273,
-0.27850210666656494,
0.6279553771018982,
0.4667893350124359,
-0.2684742510318756,
0.45537450909614563,
0.43629416823387146,
0.5574955344200134,
0.6923230290412903,
-0.2797175347805023,
0.8009707927703857,
-0.012952601537108421,
0.2306763082742691,
0.938707172870636,
-0.5058676600456238,
1.027742624282837,
0.2895542085170746,
-0.22507119178771973,
0.19873732328414917,
0.6969690918922424,
0.29365143179893494,
0.38567864894866943,
0.4451996982097626,
-0.20645661652088165,
-0.2456383854150772,
-0.348762571811676,
-0.4134480357170105,
0.5538389682769775,
0.270888090133667,
0.01443660631775856,
-0.4109309911727905,
0.06164160743355751,
-0.26946085691452026,
0.5418014526367188,
-0.4490439295768738,
0.8031284809112549,
-0.1877422332763672,
-0.7158494591712952,
0.7701243162155151,
-0.15918992459774017,
0.3421219289302826,
-0.6277387142181396,
0.07833252847194672,
-0.08889555931091309,
0.04723064973950386,
-0.11851175129413605,
-1.005782961845398,
0.32386353611946106,
0.12048448622226715,
0.03637578338384628,
-0.20109966397285461,
0.552889883518219,
-0.1961764544248581,
-0.18098948895931244,
0.24801947176456451,
0.8561475872993469,
-0.02940710075199604,
-0.029248744249343872,
-0.5253455638885498,
0.10478620231151581,
-0.5188983678817749,
-0.11779726296663284,
0.36794453859329224,
0.6913268566131592,
-0.1429619938135147,
0.6208290457725525,
0.31145378947257996,
-0.2399340271949768,
0.0061552273109555244,
0.04969749599695206,
0.9696043729782104,
-0.37238115072250366,
-0.24808473885059357,
-0.154800683259964,
0.5215966105461121,
0.04103417694568634,
-0.6384373307228088,
0.7221387028694153,
0.6585239768028259,
0.9076269865036011,
0.022680677473545074,
0.8483421802520752,
-0.3653501868247986,
0.9172386527061462,
-0.4501325786113739,
0.5729261636734009,
-0.6470492482185364,
0.10401778668165207,
-0.42785415053367615,
-0.9419152140617371,
-0.2083318680524826,
0.09155812859535217,
-0.40355604887008667,
0.06092074513435364,
0.6042630076408386,
0.5588865876197815,
-0.15099148452281952,
0.10837548226118088,
0.3663083016872406,
0.1232195794582367,
0.020480576902627945,
0.3543011248111725,
1.1643946170806885,
-0.5725415349006653,
0.8063147664070129,
0.015038540586829185,
-0.3716643154621124,
0.16311031579971313,
-0.6219536066055298,
-0.6903889775276184,
-0.6952425241470337,
-0.3484325706958771,
-0.38027259707450867,
0.15045031905174255,
0.5798342227935791,
0.46965280175209045,
-0.9733760952949524,
-0.20168064534664154,
0.47082096338272095,
-0.00788956694304943,
-0.5382893085479736,
-0.2870813310146332,
0.3007131516933441,
-0.35623350739479065,
-0.6663312315940857,
0.3244462013244629,
0.25111839175224304,
-0.4465741515159607,
-0.46546468138694763,
0.0588667057454586,
-0.18281380832195282,
0.20990268886089325,
0.6261814832687378,
0.33537253737449646,
-0.38303422927856445,
-0.3704015016555786,
0.35215863585472107,
-0.07624927163124084,
0.06991653889417648,
0.5384295582771301,
-0.6108542084693909,
0.5750315189361572,
0.5298370122909546,
1.0852742195129395,
-0.15552635490894318,
0.12472901493310928,
0.5936999320983887,
-0.39760902523994446,
-0.5491856932640076,
0.5173583626747131,
0.051314111799001694,
0.32149606943130493,
0.16893860697746277,
0.6997402906417847,
-0.13923047482967377,
-0.5685433149337769,
-1.1218655109405518,
0.15249311923980713,
-1.0166821479797363,
-0.15523657202720642,
0.9376850128173828,
-0.4467494785785675,
-0.09799734503030777,
-0.7149172425270081,
-0.2562064230442047,
-0.23946554958820343,
-0.14770543575286865,
0.6048417091369629,
0.7282394766807556,
0.14786459505558014,
0.06037979945540428,
-0.8120487332344055,
0.4000406265258789,
0.25479814410209656,
-0.8666762709617615,
0.118744395673275,
0.5948858857154846,
0.2065965235233307,
0.16706211864948273,
0.4027106463909149,
-0.4624258577823639,
0.39112481474876404,
-0.016938941553235054,
-0.17080816626548767,
0.23221737146377563,
-0.327417254447937,
-0.4802396297454834,
0.6855394840240479,
0.34008467197418213,
-0.120228111743927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13230v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13230v1 | Enhancing Language Model Factuality via Activation-Based Confidence Calibration and Guided Decoding | 2024-06-19T05:33:34 | 2024-06-19T05:33:34 | Xin Liu, Farima Fatahi Bayat, Lu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Calibrating language models (LMs) aligns their generation confidence with the
actual likelihood of answer correctness, which can inform users about LMs'
reliability and mitigate hallucinated content. However, prior calibration
methods, such as self-consistency-based and logit-based approaches, are either
limited in inference-time efficiency or fall short of providing informative
signals. Moreover, simply filtering out low-confidence responses reduces the
LM's helpfulness when the answers are correct. Therefore, effectively using
calibration techniques to enhance an LM's factuality remains an unsolved
challenge. In this paper, we first propose an activation-based calibration
method, ActCab, which trains a linear layer on top of the LM's last-layer
activations that can better capture the representations of knowledge. Built on
top of ActCab, we further propose CoDec, a confidence-guided decoding strategy
to elicit truthful answers with high confidence from LMs. By evaluating on five
popular QA benchmarks, ActCab achieves superior calibration performance than
all competitive baselines, e.g., by reducing the average expected calibration
error (ECE) score by up to 39%. Further experiments on CoDec show consistent
improvements in several LMs' factuality on challenging QA datasets, such as
TruthfulQA, highlighting the value of confidence signals in enhancing
factuality. | [
-0.08836827427148819,
-0.721743643283844,
0.6627195477485657,
0.057312630116939545,
-0.050022877752780914,
0.18184953927993774,
-0.26762789487838745,
-0.26733240485191345,
0.030837196856737137,
0.5431268215179443,
-0.21004630625247955,
-0.6046925783157349,
-0.42563292384147644,
-0.10574376583099365,
-0.10746779292821884,
0.7098483443260193,
0.1349976360797882,
0.10656867921352386,
-0.34926921129226685,
-0.1894189715385437,
-0.5197546482086182,
-0.5518882870674133,
-0.5109916925430298,
-0.3815062642097473,
0.4150385856628418,
0.2678181529045105,
1.0599507093429565,
0.6377330422401428,
0.09543368965387344,
0.17236220836639404,
-0.041090212762355804,
0.4235590398311615,
-0.5445990562438965,
-0.04241569712758064,
-0.02623738907277584,
-0.7842419147491455,
-0.47288599610328674,
-0.07519382238388062,
0.41888025403022766,
0.6755821704864502,
-0.31479567289352417,
-0.0034280153922736645,
-0.06437098234891891,
0.6068808436393738,
-1.0442930459976196,
0.4811849892139435,
-0.5417417883872986,
-0.19534412026405334,
0.3801191449165344,
-0.5482318997383118,
-0.830967366695404,
-0.7453171610832214,
-0.23031726479530334,
-0.43490955233573914,
0.03641830012202263,
-0.1138751432299614,
0.7776946425437927,
0.48226824402809143,
-0.597852885723114,
-0.356693834066391,
-0.9537246823310852,
0.6665646433830261,
-1.092125415802002,
0.4656287729740143,
0.670696496963501,
0.11175419390201569,
-0.145083487033844,
-0.48768073320388794,
-0.5151686072349548,
-0.26509013772010803,
-0.015356658957898617,
0.12968097627162933,
0.21257556974887848,
0.20921459794044495,
0.4003499448299408,
0.33448541164398193,
-0.39408913254737854,
-0.16057686507701874,
-0.11293437331914902,
-0.6417707800865173,
0.48707839846611023,
-0.1123272031545639,
0.24811290204524994,
0.010501902550458908,
-0.2338084578514099,
-0.3787057399749756,
-0.9846315979957581,
0.30027344822883606,
0.41293656826019287,
0.1986769437789917,
0.2260417342185974,
0.3726235032081604,
-0.22451628744602203,
0.6654559373855591,
0.1822795271873474,
-0.3591058850288391,
0.3904949128627777,
-0.2571490705013275,
-0.1414133906364441,
0.3345995545387268,
0.36823752522468567,
0.22253741323947906,
-0.030000707134604454,
-0.1230621486902237,
-0.23590193688869476,
0.05211431160569191,
0.23095940053462982,
-1.0078074932098389,
-0.24967217445373535,
0.47285982966423035,
-0.11174961179494858,
-0.32563430070877075,
0.06824644654989243,
-0.260508269071579,
-0.29348134994506836,
-0.21605245769023895,
0.7385374903678894,
-0.45526695251464844,
-0.4487471282482147,
0.4241487383842468,
0.36878886818885803,
0.5606158971786499,
0.4223276674747467,
-0.7793698906898499,
0.13577993214130402,
0.5779455304145813,
0.41893330216407776,
0.13725942373275757,
0.24243691563606262,
-0.6220151782035828,
0.020492972806096077,
-0.7786223292350769,
0.6120436191558838,
-0.42959412932395935,
-0.21948347985744476,
0.23696863651275635,
-0.08074799180030823,
-0.07610011845827103,
-0.38775354623794556,
0.8840224742889404,
-0.961683452129364,
0.191510871052742,
-0.6053677797317505,
-0.630958616733551,
-0.5077602863311768,
0.4297913908958435,
-0.8548200130462646,
1.2132039070129395,
-0.16584748029708862,
-0.5054329037666321,
0.06885617226362228,
-0.2166990339756012,
-0.37267211079597473,
0.07968644052743912,
-0.34118589758872986,
-0.08503008633852005,
0.09452546387910843,
0.3421454131603241,
0.2973538637161255,
0.07648833841085434,
0.35445475578308105,
-0.1321188062429428,
-0.3882787823677063,
0.3924785852432251,
-0.7442893385887146,
0.6154553294181824,
0.2335350215435028,
-0.3140004277229309,
-0.22998085618019104,
-0.8215838670730591,
0.4832408130168915,
-0.1906367689371109,
-0.5704842805862427,
-0.1243162602186203,
0.016140557825565338,
-0.34174561500549316,
0.28932198882102966,
0.35637104511260986,
-0.5615660548210144,
-0.2229086458683014,
-0.6818481683731079,
-0.11856448650360107,
0.4218118488788605,
-0.04367387667298317,
0.24727879464626312,
-0.47969281673431396,
0.5347847938537598,
-0.041997071355581284,
-0.13412657380104065,
-0.3743985593318939,
-0.4319588541984558,
-0.8023331165313721,
-0.10314089804887772,
0.5682199597358704,
0.6609281301498413,
-0.8051594495773315,
0.6292262077331543,
-0.48296797275543213,
-0.3957524299621582,
-0.7739049792289734,
0.2201317548751831,
0.45225846767425537,
0.7689260840415955,
0.3151072561740875,
-0.5037983655929565,
-0.23552459478378296,
-0.7504422068595886,
-0.20127254724502563,
-0.421495258808136,
0.09692784398794174,
0.30046388506889343,
-0.01171153411269188,
0.07590913027524948,
1.0847114324569702,
-0.426469624042511,
0.019429147243499756,
-0.03030499815940857,
0.26589614152908325,
0.2871536314487457,
0.3907426595687866,
0.21335671842098236,
-0.9830546975135803,
-0.36170050501823425,
-0.20675045251846313,
-0.5715264081954956,
-0.18157386779785156,
-0.14575010538101196,
0.05746350809931755,
0.2223791480064392,
0.36051473021507263,
-0.49120691418647766,
0.5737296938896179,
0.6762691736221313,
-0.20400163531303406,
0.5604962110519409,
-0.3735639452934265,
0.5974870920181274,
-0.9911105632781982,
0.12212511152029037,
-0.2836838662624359,
-0.5928364396095276,
-0.7926767468452454,
0.0474737212061882,
0.3320898115634918,
0.24575175344944,
-0.3536432981491089,
0.33519312739372253,
-0.3458305299282074,
0.14850737154483795,
-0.5468084812164307,
0.22914858162403107,
0.3393245339393616,
0.5977845788002014,
0.07710728794336319,
0.81571364402771,
0.4100778102874756,
-0.5130017399787903,
0.33562594652175903,
0.14837075769901276,
-0.4164479970932007,
0.1678485870361328,
-0.3591354787349701,
0.282039999961853,
-0.1312164068222046,
0.3517480194568634,
-1.1143226623535156,
-0.016378682106733322,
0.07891964912414551,
-0.5286418795585632,
0.3243189752101898,
-0.2283676415681839,
-0.6385847330093384,
0.09312258660793304,
-0.23669032752513885,
0.6472495198249817,
0.5735874772071838,
-0.5576032400131226,
0.8471243977546692,
0.1148674339056015,
-0.0038361407350748777,
-0.9127124547958374,
-0.749656081199646,
0.21099738776683807,
0.31108903884887695,
-0.6303839087486267,
0.28686296939849854,
-0.371983140707016,
0.06224391236901283,
-0.11134637147188187,
-0.4444119334220886,
0.0014752877177670598,
0.036126863211393356,
0.2597540020942688,
0.3072955012321472,
-0.33828940987586975,
0.23759248852729797,
0.02439647912979126,
-0.05071961507201195,
0.3395346403121948,
0.02753334306180477,
0.5507913827896118,
-0.2479984164237976,
-0.6054973602294922,
-0.3898439109325409,
-0.03632218390703201,
0.4362216293811798,
-0.40332934260368347,
0.9435113072395325,
0.5583856701850891,
-0.4490930736064911,
-0.1583230197429657,
-0.878444254398346,
-0.4327671229839325,
-0.46545401215553284,
0.19345389306545258,
-0.3646383285522461,
-0.7269784212112427,
0.5234441161155701,
-0.2505607008934021,
0.0008287699893116951,
0.04907386004924774,
0.6971302628517151,
0.24622958898544312,
1.1706721782684326,
0.473673015832901,
0.05332893878221512,
0.22894197702407837,
-0.12589913606643677,
0.4841363728046417,
-0.6448485851287842,
-0.2743644118309021,
-0.39021778106689453,
0.10866863280534744,
-0.32711878418922424,
-0.6881815791130066,
0.1674785017967224,
0.09358696639537811,
0.2787158489227295,
0.1788855344057083,
-0.13409224152565002,
0.4419701397418976,
0.26965782046318054,
0.5147544741630554,
0.3784754276275635,
-0.07449283450841904,
-0.3301919996738434,
0.026079252362251282,
-0.8215621113777161,
-0.6514085531234741,
1.1383298635482788,
0.4705938994884491,
0.8387452960014343,
0.1395571231842041,
0.3797863721847534,
0.31667089462280273,
0.35285717248916626,
-0.7160772681236267,
0.5005866289138794,
0.2919325530529022,
-0.94671630859375,
-0.06261762976646423,
-0.45232751965522766,
-0.3763967454433441,
0.12078342586755753,
-0.34951579570770264,
-0.4108026325702667,
0.42450448870658875,
0.4279709458351135,
-0.461894154548645,
0.11383338272571564,
-0.7704905271530151,
0.6459166407585144,
-0.1541452258825302,
-0.5601552128791809,
-0.3487757444381714,
-0.5516683459281921,
0.2889613211154938,
-0.047488775104284286,
0.3964143693447113,
-0.1210671216249466,
0.12718069553375244,
0.36153459548950195,
-0.3594417870044708,
0.899265706539154,
-0.15648679435253143,
-0.5174737572669983,
0.3765299916267395,
0.24437618255615234,
0.6487658619880676,
0.010772368870675564,
-0.3003149926662445,
-0.23402924835681915,
0.1952909231185913,
-0.4069223999977112,
-0.945968747138977,
0.7439701557159424,
-0.40947118401527405,
-0.7261112332344055,
-0.26926061511039734,
-0.6154305934906006,
-0.551301896572113,
0.010292122140526772,
-0.13562561571598053,
0.9234259128570557,
-0.040924396365880966,
0.4744212329387665,
1.0812333822250366,
-0.08840468525886536,
0.1560450792312622,
0.6225281953811646,
-0.136694073677063,
-0.3195329010486603,
0.791534423828125,
-0.17162570357322693,
0.6251859664916992,
0.4757840037345886,
0.009229515679180622,
-0.5262765884399414,
-0.5164586901664734,
-0.18175241351127625,
0.20226803421974182,
-1.1295228004455566,
-0.30439493060112,
-0.5120537877082825,
-0.41772380471229553,
-0.5858975052833557,
0.15501388907432556,
-0.40178200602531433,
-0.4383014738559723,
-0.05965905636548996,
-0.34461158514022827,
0.15788812935352325,
0.17759807407855988,
-0.1484154313802719,
0.24602937698364258,
-0.6830877065658569,
0.33381015062332153,
0.3308923840522766,
0.2227163314819336,
-0.24519453942775726,
-0.8008654117584229,
-0.47081899642944336,
0.41168031096458435,
-0.0014687184011563659,
-0.9723941683769226,
0.2728213667869568,
0.1306678205728531,
0.4102556109428406,
0.42449453473091125,
0.33517754077911377,
0.6441137790679932,
-0.24378889799118042,
0.6379915475845337,
-0.07653417438268661,
-0.8011080026626587,
0.4210611879825592,
0.1314839869737625,
0.25905805826187134,
0.7188240885734558,
0.22507044672966003,
-0.2993500530719757,
-0.41589710116386414,
-0.5304566621780396,
-0.5665862560272217,
0.5644258856773376,
0.33720287680625916,
0.4566921591758728,
0.06748631596565247,
0.5180330872535706,
-0.13572832942008972,
0.2587251365184784,
-0.8282656073570251,
-0.3437761962413788,
-0.34168925881385803,
-0.5809609293937683,
0.11081617325544357,
-0.4997410774230957,
-0.33150583505630493,
0.0919526144862175,
1.0548290014266968,
-0.41873201727867126,
-0.0168707687407732,
0.38904112577438354,
-0.3070220351219177,
-0.09486493468284607,
0.429020494222641,
0.3941705524921417,
0.7176827192306519,
-0.5043936371803284,
0.23303280770778656,
0.2392745167016983,
-0.5368225574493408,
0.037170328199863434,
0.025860467925667763,
-0.3185071051120758,
-0.02627156302332878,
0.3196289539337158,
0.8443064093589783,
0.2615368068218231,
-0.6669882535934448,
0.7420603632926941,
-0.13000206649303436,
0.038378894329071045,
-0.0913776159286499,
0.40748074650764465,
0.02008531428873539,
0.03505250811576843,
0.4560966193675995,
0.04463258385658264,
0.06803801655769348,
-0.5328395366668701,
0.13702192902565002,
0.44246962666511536,
-0.4905007779598236,
-0.2484814077615738,
0.42823052406311035,
0.2294994741678238,
-0.1978800892829895,
0.19400352239608765,
-0.0534089095890522,
-0.5985023379325867,
0.5391268730163574,
0.7201694250106812,
0.6339946389198303,
-0.38390663266181946,
0.2381473332643509,
0.5591405034065247,
0.5068442225456238,
-0.2804420292377472,
0.2951919138431549,
-0.19483539462089539,
-1.1485891342163086,
-0.7333402633666992,
-0.5361643433570862,
-0.5634212493896484,
0.10762236267328262,
-0.6936103701591492,
0.178273007273674,
-0.35486137866973877,
-0.18499597907066345,
-0.5858073830604553,
0.26727813482284546,
-0.5222357511520386,
0.7273632287979126,
0.2165527641773224,
1.0924006700515747,
-0.7970442175865173,
1.0196807384490967,
0.5108044147491455,
-0.23591451346874237,
-1.2174654006958008,
-0.07438421249389648,
-0.2355877161026001,
-0.8371756672859192,
0.31616565585136414,
0.28248682618141174,
-0.49957093596458435,
0.29222995042800903,
-0.7169332504272461,
-0.722098708152771,
1.253675937652588,
0.6052777767181396,
-0.28437671065330505,
0.03876152262091637,
0.2543453276157379,
0.5262541174888611,
-0.5098922252655029,
0.4448190927505493,
0.4567955434322357,
0.42732852697372437,
0.3673326075077057,
-0.5742103457450867,
0.27938908338546753,
-0.12530957162380219,
-0.056613970547914505,
-0.2806949019432068,
-0.28554344177246094,
0.21863920986652374,
-0.21073885262012482,
-0.4433668553829193,
0.021227547898888588,
0.7483010292053223,
0.3460366427898407,
0.04108089208602905,
0.5854610204696655,
0.5602603554725647,
0.7615742683410645,
-0.06141979247331619,
0.8862427473068237,
-0.7946150302886963,
0.32483765482902527,
1.115944504737854,
-0.20301535725593567,
0.89921635389328,
0.3078738749027252,
0.18261690437793732,
0.8183198571205139,
0.3034366965293884,
0.28465068340301514,
0.44319748878479004,
-0.2505882680416107,
-0.5892593860626221,
-0.7552325129508972,
-0.08334382623434067,
-0.23870518803596497,
0.29759255051612854,
0.45463719964027405,
-0.16678108274936676,
-0.12480494379997253,
-0.1785978227853775,
0.13710211217403412,
0.3058243989944458,
-0.06337031722068787,
0.5383481383323669,
0.026950161904096603,
-0.7319830656051636,
0.7115757465362549,
0.09707923978567123,
0.25837135314941406,
-0.7324622869491577,
-0.16420693695545197,
-0.31993213295936584,
-0.013710768893361092,
-0.388896644115448,
-0.6060075759887695,
-0.15821833908557892,
-0.16607564687728882,
-0.04601056128740311,
-0.10268566757440567,
0.8801431655883789,
-0.7111261487007141,
-0.3156592547893524,
0.1143275797367096,
0.4435834586620331,
-0.09426626563072205,
-0.07557264715433121,
-0.5036770105361938,
0.17996704578399658,
0.08399912714958191,
-0.17716416716575623,
-0.12569333612918854,
0.25867775082588196,
0.4656691551208496,
0.7420725226402283,
0.7853231430053711,
0.23686836659908295,
0.10891171544790268,
0.02964908629655838,
0.7773516774177551,
-0.5377128720283508,
-0.3438524901866913,
-0.5410088300704956,
0.522016167640686,
0.0053922636434435844,
0.1987694501876831,
0.6375973224639893,
0.5614874362945557,
0.6587936878204346,
0.03828394040465355,
0.5672716498374939,
0.08483723551034927,
0.3312726318836212,
-0.7228469252586365,
0.6344993114471436,
-0.3614785969257355,
0.5741615295410156,
0.11256667971611023,
-0.7726677060127258,
-0.3713012933731079,
0.571777880191803,
-0.29182887077331543,
0.1270296275615692,
0.7280886173248291,
1.3856861591339111,
0.03523795306682587,
-0.06674874573945999,
0.5493463277816772,
0.39502978324890137,
0.42790818214416504,
0.47497880458831787,
0.5974421501159668,
-0.752077043056488,
0.6954490542411804,
-0.22324757277965546,
-0.37640711665153503,
-0.28630340099334717,
-1.084829330444336,
-0.7376828193664551,
-0.3991701006889343,
-0.5133314728736877,
-0.6151899695396423,
-0.0325138233602047,
0.842079758644104,
0.8338518738746643,
-1.0410760641098022,
-0.038779959082603455,
0.11583304405212402,
0.15778623521327972,
-0.10411429405212402,
-0.23775596916675568,
0.313944935798645,
-0.4568244516849518,
-0.6263226866722107,
0.5002129673957825,
0.22372211515903473,
-0.1283203363418579,
-0.24294966459274292,
-0.26179516315460205,
-0.1947716772556305,
0.5873613953590393,
0.49232032895088196,
0.5028740763664246,
-0.6484925746917725,
-0.5168372392654419,
-0.0062196869403123856,
-0.3774963617324829,
0.26660752296447754,
0.5380585789680481,
-1.1506320238113403,
0.7198132872581482,
0.34923726320266724,
0.8520073890686035,
0.32036226987838745,
0.3528546988964081,
0.6176699995994568,
-0.7707250118255615,
-0.04033650830388069,
0.19787083566188812,
0.19974513351917267,
0.5336658954620361,
-0.31721946597099304,
0.23421525955200195,
0.011147762648761272,
-0.49040403962135315,
-0.8748164176940918,
0.23758822679519653,
-1.011818766593933,
0.016156261786818504,
1.2302883863449097,
-0.25744929909706116,
-0.2823074460029602,
-0.05334126576781273,
-0.34440815448760986,
0.28020864725112915,
-0.23685556650161743,
0.8445004820823669,
0.8387668132781982,
0.21623073518276215,
-0.14959107339382172,
-0.44310078024864197,
0.7296818494796753,
0.6768829822540283,
-0.8023371696472168,
0.22893063724040985,
0.6152664422988892,
0.2950834333896637,
0.30659177899360657,
0.48259237408638,
-0.2712292969226837,
0.5003123879432678,
-0.2479478418827057,
0.12147152423858643,
-0.13139016926288605,
-0.28678297996520996,
-0.4331229329109192,
0.1708640158176422,
0.4012317657470703,
0.08933956176042557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13229v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13229v1 | Probing the Emergence of Cross-lingual Alignment during LLM Training | 2024-06-19T05:31:59 | 2024-06-19T05:31:59 | Hetong Wang, Pasquale Minervini, Edoardo M. Ponti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Multilingual Large Language Models (LLMs) achieve remarkable levels of
zero-shot cross-lingual transfer performance. We speculate that this is
predicated on their ability to align languages without explicit supervision
from parallel sentences. While representations of translationally equivalent
sentences in different languages are known to be similar after convergence,
however, it remains unclear how such cross-lingual alignment emerges during
pre-training of LLMs. Our study leverages intrinsic probing techniques, which
identify which subsets of neurons encode linguistic features, to correlate the
degree of cross-lingual neuron overlap with the zero-shot cross-lingual
transfer performance for a given model. In particular, we rely on checkpoints
of BLOOM, a multilingual autoregressive LLM, across different training steps
and model scales. We observe a high correlation between neuron overlap and
downstream performance, which supports our hypothesis on the conditions leading
to effective cross-lingual transfer. Interestingly, we also detect a
degradation of both implicit alignment and multilingual abilities in certain
phases of the pre-training process, providing new insights into the
multilingual pretraining dynamics. | [
-0.436674565076828,
-0.4817984104156494,
0.4441693425178528,
0.35052889585494995,
0.10543518513441086,
0.20976774394512177,
-0.25884711742401123,
-0.5746829509735107,
0.26186802983283997,
-0.08345848321914673,
-0.8301959037780762,
-0.15232373774051666,
-0.5230929851531982,
0.0908803790807724,
-0.40029770135879517,
0.7575139999389648,
-0.17670616507530212,
0.3448370397090912,
-0.11532271653413773,
-0.19425305724143982,
-0.33779826760292053,
-0.3263132572174072,
-0.4009826183319092,
-0.56842440366745,
0.6281300783157349,
0.1196841150522232,
0.27444973587989807,
0.4158717393875122,
0.33431777358055115,
0.24907082319259644,
-0.1480843722820282,
-0.1507449746131897,
-0.5563117265701294,
-0.016564425081014633,
-0.20117256045341492,
-0.5354195237159729,
-0.45620808005332947,
-0.24691757559776306,
0.9286628365516663,
0.7589805722236633,
0.04491027817130089,
-0.024290218949317932,
0.2836172580718994,
0.2894720137119293,
-0.5823765397071838,
-0.15374620258808136,
-0.8198770880699158,
0.2452528178691864,
-0.5003540515899658,
-0.26499465107917786,
-0.36886975169181824,
0.03348108008503914,
0.1778351366519928,
-0.5585773587226868,
0.1639941930770874,
-0.17207928001880646,
1.1883544921875,
-0.0024703429080545902,
-0.3612572252750397,
0.03978344425559044,
-0.35225483775138855,
0.625595211982727,
-0.6469857692718506,
0.4306949973106384,
-0.10287932306528091,
-0.033315032720565796,
-0.005781683139503002,
-0.19033776223659515,
-0.6478174924850464,
0.0002738085458986461,
-0.3470223546028137,
0.19419240951538086,
0.02799813449382782,
-0.014308091253042221,
0.15445290505886078,
0.31753847002983093,
-0.8906001448631287,
0.4640388786792755,
-0.12593187391757965,
-0.3293124735355377,
0.37691760063171387,
0.05844219774007797,
0.6844310760498047,
0.03071559965610504,
-0.608609676361084,
-0.029051706194877625,
-0.7330793142318726,
0.11447063088417053,
0.4355129897594452,
0.36717489361763,
-0.2656008005142212,
0.4998129904270172,
0.1581742912530899,
0.7184403538703918,
0.041289009153842926,
-0.01630186289548874,
0.3072046935558319,
-0.6660537123680115,
0.04153810441493988,
0.46591001749038696,
0.9514487385749817,
0.07994415611028671,
0.5844677686691284,
-0.2311229556798935,
-0.19677318632602692,
-0.12852346897125244,
0.19018352031707764,
-0.517751932144165,
0.010839110240340233,
-0.03151608258485794,
0.06019991636276245,
0.00971490703523159,
-0.18513984978199005,
-0.477681964635849,
0.11914893984794617,
-0.3912237286567688,
0.5417333841323853,
-0.48063424229621887,
-0.39919573068618774,
0.044212814420461655,
0.13767975568771362,
0.6310147047042847,
0.03134191036224365,
-1.1568483114242554,
0.09623601287603378,
0.6750113368034363,
0.8870061039924622,
-0.501943051815033,
-1.1461783647537231,
-0.3132738769054413,
0.308711975812912,
-0.5449119806289673,
0.5631163120269775,
-0.23191344738006592,
0.06397000700235367,
0.2668904662132263,
0.3045271039009094,
-0.5435047149658203,
-0.37168756127357483,
-0.0453389510512352,
-0.8011630177497864,
-0.020186342298984528,
-0.4409455358982086,
-0.3559684753417969,
-0.011548749171197414,
0.45523712038993835,
-0.41843751072883606,
0.9954529404640198,
-0.10771505534648895,
-0.8044564127922058,
0.4914619028568268,
-0.41865217685699463,
-0.5539969801902771,
-0.09029808640480042,
-0.3936535120010376,
-0.14293909072875977,
0.1649315357208252,
0.2370750904083252,
0.2384556382894516,
-0.020263081416487694,
0.08878510445356369,
-0.28053128719329834,
-0.37737202644348145,
0.14397205412387848,
-0.2988746166229248,
0.8195039629936218,
-0.23483197391033173,
-0.5897058248519897,
0.07991498708724976,
-0.41942641139030457,
0.11830252408981323,
0.02172311395406723,
-0.10609713196754456,
-0.1787775605916977,
-0.4370778501033783,
-0.1884029656648636,
0.26229655742645264,
0.3543495237827301,
-0.4941692054271698,
0.29371288418769836,
-0.21742703020572662,
0.18695983290672302,
0.7520992755889893,
-0.1604965776205063,
0.5405774712562561,
-0.31572970747947693,
0.45016440749168396,
0.33029699325561523,
-0.058480724692344666,
-0.4865020215511322,
-0.17108236253261566,
-0.9556497931480408,
-0.07146572321653366,
0.16790159046649933,
0.6407473683357239,
-0.3478289246559143,
0.2579819858074188,
-0.6765954494476318,
-0.29965656995773315,
-0.4261106550693512,
0.2435930371284485,
0.5512971878051758,
0.3912298083305359,
0.2675996720790863,
-0.48175084590911865,
-0.24105028808116913,
-0.9578068852424622,
-0.22167757153511047,
0.11117713898420334,
0.3590456545352936,
0.14347834885120392,
0.38642609119415283,
-0.15342213213443756,
0.8230809569358826,
-0.1543855220079422,
-0.16503867506980896,
-0.022440828382968903,
0.38834673166275024,
0.17035724222660065,
0.6311365962028503,
0.6646161675453186,
-0.30576786398887634,
-0.6144747138023376,
0.5671700239181519,
-0.7632016539573669,
-0.29018768668174744,
-0.3259352743625641,
-0.3916113078594208,
0.22709724307060242,
0.68680739402771,
-0.4951704740524292,
0.16070756316184998,
0.6827017664909363,
-0.07424214482307434,
0.5858822464942932,
-0.2137628197669983,
0.2793383002281189,
-0.8309844136238098,
0.15364529192447662,
-0.4161764085292816,
-0.015973344445228577,
-0.6523314118385315,
-0.11520373076200485,
0.34447118639945984,
0.1468813419342041,
-0.5148635506629944,
0.5018551349639893,
-0.9846786856651306,
-0.5875178575515747,
-0.1951705813407898,
0.2589150369167328,
0.04190325364470482,
0.5244451761245728,
0.24856749176979065,
0.8994359374046326,
0.8645363450050354,
-0.4980716109275818,
-0.10367877036333084,
0.1646704077720642,
-0.502763032913208,
0.517349362373352,
-0.5627171993255615,
0.08844472467899323,
0.03376629948616028,
-0.09962064027786255,
-1.0933798551559448,
-0.0493813157081604,
-0.12861791253089905,
-0.44305670261383057,
0.7056058645248413,
-0.31976181268692017,
-0.36027389764785767,
0.06388621777296066,
0.11937148123979568,
0.9739921689033508,
0.265186071395874,
-0.474772572517395,
0.5342642664909363,
0.005851306486874819,
-0.15056179463863373,
-0.7991804480552673,
-0.8784440159797668,
-0.009155298583209515,
-0.1118774339556694,
-0.5912671089172363,
0.47210267186164856,
0.22997154295444489,
0.033059027045965195,
-0.2677381634712219,
0.06262905895709991,
0.09690339863300323,
-0.07586012035608292,
-0.0096598444506526,
0.3007941246032715,
-0.598982036113739,
-0.07869177311658859,
0.006864864379167557,
0.2575879693031311,
0.1457187533378601,
-0.267017126083374,
0.851224422454834,
0.015882056206464767,
-0.7021345496177673,
-0.3782649636268616,
0.19484467804431915,
0.7427483201026917,
-0.3823970854282379,
0.7313014268875122,
0.6048078536987305,
-0.192588672041893,
0.042238492518663406,
-0.49920549988746643,
-0.07785909622907639,
-0.45248839259147644,
0.42478546500205994,
-0.4347688853740692,
-0.6856719255447388,
0.9225485324859619,
0.1997273862361908,
-0.06334827840328217,
0.3141830265522003,
0.3829442262649536,
0.06241750344634056,
0.5779073238372803,
0.6538162231445312,
-0.0356631726026535,
0.5542176365852356,
-0.0857744887471199,
0.08281324058771133,
-1.0427680015563965,
-0.21539820730686188,
-0.09079644083976746,
-0.4608832001686096,
-0.24014846980571747,
-0.4574357867240906,
0.08336374908685684,
0.35465672612190247,
-0.3312402665615082,
0.30672624707221985,
-0.07107621431350708,
0.5719268918037415,
0.2574189305305481,
-0.31513890624046326,
0.09662490338087082,
-0.004648053087294102,
-0.4178718030452728,
-0.24161837995052338,
-0.6299448609352112,
-0.06562305241823196,
0.876549482345581,
0.17060008645057678,
0.5902724862098694,
0.10073994100093842,
0.5751559734344482,
-0.18761016428470612,
0.20242640376091003,
-0.5813724398612976,
0.36120811104774475,
0.018586909398436546,
-0.5814164280891418,
-0.24018877744674683,
-0.30059075355529785,
-0.9342979192733765,
0.30677151679992676,
-0.10225638002157211,
-0.8582474589347839,
0.3143090307712555,
-0.008187953382730484,
-0.3295521140098572,
0.34668490290641785,
-0.553121030330658,
1.0344436168670654,
-0.877339243888855,
-0.5728143453598022,
0.06962498277425766,
-0.5532546639442444,
0.4386887848377228,
-0.325453519821167,
0.1287221610546112,
-0.05509774014353752,
-0.06523635238409042,
0.5291314721107483,
0.0409066416323185,
0.7889715433120728,
0.18312038481235504,
-0.5383381843566895,
-0.07427968829870224,
0.20146697759628296,
0.15793994069099426,
-0.22857661545276642,
0.40583059191703796,
0.4439314603805542,
-0.13365741074085236,
-0.5465719699859619,
-0.49377936124801636,
0.8707370758056641,
-0.838493287563324,
-0.5067178010940552,
-0.5478066802024841,
-0.7103939652442932,
-0.39224979281425476,
0.4069983959197998,
0.4846959412097931,
0.20500420033931732,
-0.24887622892856598,
-0.2954517900943756,
0.612209141254425,
-0.11550199240446091,
0.6938961148262024,
0.5346795916557312,
-0.5947585105895996,
-0.27603963017463684,
0.7626071572303772,
0.19234266877174377,
0.7629460692405701,
0.5490583181381226,
-0.19576413929462433,
-0.13543173670768738,
-0.638253927230835,
-0.571565568447113,
0.5191577076911926,
-0.5257795453071594,
0.06164081022143364,
-0.5207940936088562,
-0.36012002825737,
-0.7523139715194702,
-0.25477340817451477,
-0.4982684552669525,
-0.06164032220840454,
-0.28310275077819824,
0.02336670644581318,
0.11596662551164627,
0.6229832172393799,
-0.2799392342567444,
0.3915984630584717,
-1.0262186527252197,
-0.09109950810670853,
0.30285483598709106,
0.22134600579738617,
0.17165543138980865,
-0.7436564564704895,
-0.3114999532699585,
0.13556969165802002,
-0.04478572681546211,
-0.8142058849334717,
0.41502493619918823,
0.49850329756736755,
0.6513423323631287,
0.7080910205841064,
-0.46056583523750305,
0.9831863641738892,
-0.8256500363349915,
0.7309863567352295,
0.37770190834999084,
-0.9852153062820435,
0.2746914327144623,
-0.5089808702468872,
0.5427536368370056,
0.42922815680503845,
0.6781620383262634,
-0.5267027616500854,
-0.09903255105018616,
-0.12461826950311661,
-0.8647075295448303,
0.8160773515701294,
-0.09181784093379974,
0.12968458235263824,
-0.042019523680210114,
0.27256810665130615,
0.07621029764413834,
0.056313566863536835,
-0.8970584869384766,
-0.10212048143148422,
-0.029708297923207283,
0.21674136817455292,
-0.32610008120536804,
-0.06836280226707458,
-0.4188263416290283,
-0.12326956540346146,
0.3083237111568451,
-0.2887563407421112,
0.20549438893795013,
0.12035943567752838,
-0.4049929976463318,
-0.11269058287143707,
0.04040487855672836,
0.7845507860183716,
0.5944005250930786,
0.059951528906822205,
0.20839674770832062,
0.30614376068115234,
-0.4044725298881531,
0.279756098985672,
-0.10135035216808319,
-0.051646120846271515,
-0.014265328645706177,
0.6957211494445801,
0.8769636154174805,
0.5805649757385254,
-0.5627519488334656,
0.5968016386032104,
0.062077660113573074,
-0.22741536796092987,
-0.24980005621910095,
-0.1448461413383484,
0.16315028071403503,
0.22060762345790863,
0.21752935647964478,
-0.13433992862701416,
-0.30127593874931335,
-0.693348228931427,
0.2508183717727661,
0.5368943810462952,
-0.5030812621116638,
-0.5351053476333618,
0.3935992419719696,
-0.2310968041419983,
-0.15105320513248444,
0.8579096794128418,
0.009536021389067173,
-0.8673490881919861,
0.42944127321243286,
0.5938847064971924,
0.8401698470115662,
-0.32450157403945923,
-0.07911067456007004,
0.46600744128227234,
0.373420774936676,
0.018367527052760124,
0.008723336271941662,
-0.09847011417150497,
-0.9479455947875977,
-0.6825184226036072,
-0.7826558947563171,
0.12325061857700348,
-0.20164301991462708,
-0.9350475072860718,
0.2803793251514435,
-0.019543705508112907,
0.02440575323998928,
-0.21346718072891235,
-0.4732781946659088,
-0.43892917037010193,
0.027831843122839928,
0.5221088528633118,
0.813707172870636,
-1.0718368291854858,
0.8801069259643555,
0.4701079726219177,
-0.18496587872505188,
-0.7912046313285828,
0.2263248860836029,
-0.0073344106785953045,
-1.0776147842407227,
0.9358591437339783,
0.37459972500801086,
-0.2833751440048218,
0.022131573408842087,
-0.06699874997138977,
-1.0825029611587524,
0.930301308631897,
0.6115257143974304,
-0.7283599376678467,
-0.2985074520111084,
0.4650801122188568,
0.4952056407928467,
-0.23549491167068481,
0.38810795545578003,
0.44037768244743347,
0.3369547724723816,
0.17785154283046722,
-1.2053682804107666,
-0.0941401794552803,
-0.2766049802303314,
-0.1619490385055542,
0.4621449410915375,
-0.6131888031959534,
0.9533330202102661,
-0.12573933601379395,
-0.29247939586639404,
-0.08614112436771393,
0.5728235840797424,
0.0367695577442646,
-0.1327591985464096,
0.37842458486557007,
0.9913448095321655,
0.5179911851882935,
-0.2520778477191925,
0.7538002729415894,
-0.5682176947593689,
0.16327300667762756,
1.1674681901931763,
-0.376102477312088,
1.0079703330993652,
0.7197012305259705,
-0.04383384808897972,
0.4498467445373535,
0.7459148168563843,
0.09705764800310135,
0.5240392684936523,
0.21162690222263336,
-0.18435576558113098,
-0.32647618651390076,
-0.01619069091975689,
-0.5011038780212402,
0.2898392677307129,
0.2635144591331482,
-0.17762945592403412,
-0.20527921617031097,
-0.03211507573723793,
-0.054774511605501175,
-0.2877849042415619,
-0.3453393280506134,
0.7573320269584656,
0.02367890253663063,
-1.0530630350112915,
0.7561686038970947,
-0.6689772009849548,
0.9261676669120789,
-0.8321736454963684,
0.22243326902389526,
-0.3024888038635254,
0.13267268240451813,
-0.17815996706485748,
-0.9094741344451904,
0.386694997549057,
-0.34356796741485596,
-0.09624351561069489,
-0.48762571811676025,
0.09770368784666061,
-0.6929172277450562,
-0.09590617567300797,
0.8590576648712158,
0.4447925090789795,
0.3313998878002167,
0.15744328498840332,
-0.5978310108184814,
0.0604950413107872,
-0.026558928191661835,
-0.04991945996880531,
0.7762557864189148,
0.5806657671928406,
0.1891770213842392,
0.23064462840557098,
0.5765241980552673,
0.31398528814315796,
0.6974617838859558,
0.2279518097639084,
0.5424641966819763,
-0.4820629060268402,
-0.22198039293289185,
-0.9004396200180054,
0.4254641830921173,
0.11107369512319565,
-0.551981508731842,
0.8025565147399902,
0.679831862449646,
1.2171365022659302,
0.08199412375688553,
0.3176036477088928,
0.18426363170146942,
0.052628204226493835,
-0.76470947265625,
0.898891806602478,
-0.8960453867912292,
0.02413754351437092,
-0.10979108512401581,
-0.9088729619979858,
-0.0493326336145401,
0.42873111367225647,
-0.3694045841693878,
-0.028746211901307106,
0.8667367100715637,
0.9098681211471558,
-0.3003849387168884,
-0.2926042079925537,
0.39703038334846497,
0.2653885781764984,
0.11849217861890793,
0.6534910202026367,
0.9010609984397888,
-0.26198670268058777,
0.5741583704948425,
-0.15232667326927185,
-0.029868876561522484,
0.04099900275468826,
-0.8369328379631042,
-0.7559871077537537,
-0.510911226272583,
-0.2829771339893341,
-0.12507890164852142,
-0.056311313062906265,
0.36885809898376465,
0.6042184233665466,
-0.7772324085235596,
-0.5248011350631714,
-0.2850522994995117,
-0.33501264452934265,
-0.14280185103416443,
-0.20223920047283173,
0.24082811176776886,
-0.8173801302909851,
-0.7205904722213745,
0.44257852435112,
0.35920581221580505,
0.36993998289108276,
-0.3348294198513031,
-0.019263388589024544,
-0.6686446666717529,
-0.18627801537513733,
0.08974269777536392,
0.5198625326156616,
-0.5938915610313416,
-0.04366239160299301,
0.36288952827453613,
-0.3112353980541229,
0.2506474256515503,
0.8789665699005127,
-0.29174941778182983,
0.3758567273616791,
0.5029231309890747,
0.8413728475570679,
0.47762784361839294,
-0.36941349506378174,
0.8652944564819336,
-0.6863324046134949,
0.1377933770418167,
0.09190921485424042,
0.545272946357727,
0.3824637234210968,
-0.1741766780614853,
0.06191730499267578,
0.09436207264661789,
-0.6318808197975159,
-0.928913414478302,
0.22856906056404114,
-0.9042597413063049,
-0.06304449588060379,
1.0340524911880493,
-0.3751312494277954,
-0.37625652551651,
0.21099506318569183,
0.1365569829940796,
0.23160699009895325,
0.16900111734867096,
0.541159451007843,
1.022873044013977,
-0.2238210141658783,
-0.1891656517982483,
-0.32217198610305786,
0.33221936225891113,
0.8754934668540955,
-0.5387780666351318,
-0.03897316753864288,
0.14034388959407806,
0.35644787549972534,
0.4608078598976135,
0.37290289998054504,
-0.1412249058485031,
0.33077678084373474,
-0.008041471242904663,
0.11526776105165482,
0.445000022649765,
-0.3153786361217499,
-0.6049771904945374,
-0.03903791680932045,
0.13794632256031036,
-0.17779752612113953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13219v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13219v1 | MC-MKE: A Fine-Grained Multimodal Knowledge Editing Benchmark Emphasizing Modality Consistency | 2024-06-19T05:15:21 | 2024-06-19T05:15:21 | Junzhe Zhang, Huixuan Zhang, Xunjian Yin, Baizhou Huang, Xu Zhang, Xinyu Hu, Xiaojun Wan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) are prone to non-factual or outdated
knowledge issues, which can manifest as misreading and misrecognition errors
due to the complexity of multimodal knowledge. Previous benchmarks have not
systematically analyzed the performance of editing methods in correcting these
two error types. To better represent and correct these errors, we decompose
multimodal knowledge into its visual and textual components. Different error
types correspond to different editing formats, which edits distinct part of the
multimodal knowledge. We present MC-MKE, a fine-grained Multimodal Knowledge
Editing benchmark emphasizing Modality Consistency. Our benchmark facilitates
independent correction of misreading and misrecognition errors by editing the
corresponding knowledge component. We evaluate three multimodal knowledge
editing methods on MC-MKE, revealing their limitations, particularly in terms
of modality consistency. Our work highlights the challenges posed by multimodal
knowledge editing and motivates further research in developing effective
techniques for this task. | [
-0.35676997900009155,
-0.7731456160545349,
0.5750340223312378,
0.16807574033737183,
0.14268988370895386,
0.08733416348695755,
-0.366443008184433,
-0.2633669078350067,
-0.028157435357570648,
0.24078834056854248,
-0.430277556180954,
-0.4154137372970581,
-0.6181159019470215,
0.28751692175865173,
0.23589977622032166,
0.5149976015090942,
-0.3264995515346527,
0.26607051491737366,
-0.49560755491256714,
-0.48973679542541504,
-0.6585941314697266,
-0.41295766830444336,
-0.48481541872024536,
0.12906906008720398,
0.8236497044563293,
0.5399780869483948,
0.812237024307251,
0.5810341238975525,
0.6937365531921387,
0.35092395544052124,
0.02358953468501568,
0.7382699251174927,
-0.1894543170928955,
0.10888674110174179,
-0.39622920751571655,
-0.2330532968044281,
-0.7654547691345215,
0.007592063397169113,
0.7402644157409668,
0.5496596097946167,
0.07078643143177032,
0.14005140960216522,
-0.02688615210354328,
0.709134042263031,
-1.1231663227081299,
0.30148014426231384,
-0.5334910750389099,
-0.08717320114374161,
-0.18635854125022888,
-0.031181521713733673,
-0.5349487066268921,
-0.2587897479534149,
-0.37133345007896423,
-0.6702082753181458,
-0.004543445538729429,
-0.009647519327700138,
0.4643513858318329,
0.313601553440094,
-0.688142716884613,
-0.06226019188761711,
-0.5538514852523804,
0.7020478844642639,
-0.5571665167808533,
0.9436999559402466,
0.5487281680107117,
0.46858781576156616,
-0.07937895506620407,
-0.5553226470947266,
-0.7300083637237549,
-0.09986758232116699,
-0.036110181361436844,
0.015083709731698036,
-0.1173306554555893,
0.1384166181087494,
0.26206526160240173,
-0.09553644806146622,
-0.2987513840198517,
-0.19885312020778656,
-0.040479693561792374,
-0.549572765827179,
0.3156621754169464,
0.04829709231853485,
0.13323785364627838,
-0.3829885721206665,
-0.2355373650789261,
-0.27276819944381714,
-0.35439497232437134,
0.02572465129196644,
0.06847620755434036,
-0.06892789155244827,
0.16926559805870056,
1.047261357307434,
-0.3492373526096344,
0.5958890318870544,
-0.12364957481622696,
-0.6364337801933289,
0.3291069269180298,
-0.3886769711971283,
-0.3784441649913788,
-0.08717793971300125,
0.6293964385986328,
0.9394376277923584,
0.050901368260383606,
-0.23225808143615723,
-0.1551181674003601,
0.0403328575193882,
0.09118805080652237,
-0.4740380346775055,
-0.07306783646345139,
-0.11669272929430008,
-0.4875746965408325,
-0.14409781992435455,
-0.08838368952274323,
-0.7697006464004517,
-0.5976030230522156,
-0.32149314880371094,
0.7786920070648193,
-0.6068424582481384,
0.040692951530218124,
-0.0010706780012696981,
-0.27298077940940857,
-0.45964232087135315,
0.6081914305686951,
-0.6321483850479126,
-0.03408883139491081,
0.42764103412628174,
0.5642608404159546,
0.15709015727043152,
-0.6379808783531189,
-0.4155534505844116,
0.5152509808540344,
-0.14938774704933167,
0.7542476654052734,
-0.7586545944213867,
-0.2647249698638916,
-0.32983797788619995,
0.10160256922245026,
-0.44396504759788513,
-0.520112931728363,
0.646706223487854,
-0.21167640388011932,
-0.08836747705936432,
-0.6258336901664734,
-0.5825914740562439,
-0.2995493710041046,
0.6288771629333496,
-0.6370396018028259,
0.8357927799224854,
0.14820446074008942,
-0.7249935269355774,
0.4516325294971466,
-0.6350635290145874,
0.04289841651916504,
-0.5701668858528137,
-0.04621591791510582,
-0.33462539315223694,
0.18109136819839478,
0.35378411412239075,
0.3840360939502716,
0.08950994163751602,
0.3052022159099579,
-0.4649501144886017,
0.09165255725383759,
0.4471457600593567,
-0.739069402217865,
0.16486765444278717,
0.03196103870868683,
-0.12552295625209808,
0.18076908588409424,
-1.1930111646652222,
-0.057664837688207626,
-0.12148596346378326,
-0.3962169885635376,
-0.4432620108127594,
0.08319796621799469,
0.039886198937892914,
0.4660258889198303,
0.31928205490112305,
-0.5696713328361511,
0.4482058584690094,
0.48497194051742554,
0.12062325328588486,
0.8477544188499451,
0.032521188259124756,
0.2971106469631195,
-0.47918400168418884,
0.1471199095249176,
0.5864849090576172,
0.46096372604370117,
-0.2962663471698761,
-0.3580899238586426,
-0.7047077417373657,
-0.3416353464126587,
0.48255130648612976,
0.4018215835094452,
-1.131670355796814,
-0.3168018162250519,
-0.1883992850780487,
-0.45276960730552673,
-0.6203018426895142,
0.29796189069747925,
0.49042829871177673,
0.5396994352340698,
0.5551741719245911,
-0.2390456348657608,
-0.5948076248168945,
-1.0532753467559814,
-0.577128529548645,
0.05303347483277321,
0.2863773703575134,
0.34599781036376953,
0.3472791612148285,
-0.7114089727401733,
0.8995063900947571,
-0.2653152644634247,
-0.23364275693893433,
0.31120041012763977,
0.37932318449020386,
-0.6600030660629272,
0.7752905488014221,
0.5019621253013611,
-0.595971941947937,
-0.3474022150039673,
0.23156942427158356,
-0.6026672124862671,
-0.14830359816551208,
-0.13702940940856934,
-0.04689837619662285,
0.3174732029438019,
0.5054761171340942,
-0.5141258239746094,
0.1652287244796753,
0.7475203275680542,
-0.3415629267692566,
0.7893303632736206,
-0.2159060388803482,
0.8331589102745056,
-1.0253878831863403,
0.007270133588463068,
-0.144111767411232,
-0.29902753233909607,
-0.4533978998661041,
-0.12433698773384094,
0.6108241677284241,
0.14927202463150024,
-0.3951680362224579,
0.45054006576538086,
-0.46401768922805786,
0.06318596750497818,
0.14102143049240112,
0.18617957830429077,
0.24782705307006836,
0.5018908977508545,
-0.23290307819843292,
0.7015678882598877,
0.2411084920167923,
-0.2779214680194855,
0.15400151908397675,
0.06443493813276291,
-0.23288294672966003,
0.912217915058136,
-0.06318368762731552,
0.1458808183670044,
-0.29612231254577637,
-0.05511310696601868,
-0.7970631718635559,
-0.20051611959934235,
0.1356169879436493,
-0.13173754513263702,
0.3412899076938629,
-0.18682104349136353,
-0.7122354507446289,
0.08542504161596298,
-0.35512879490852356,
0.743347704410553,
-0.22453895211219788,
-0.11045292764902115,
0.7983689308166504,
-0.024665646255016327,
-0.14221248030662537,
-0.8143981695175171,
-0.5481253266334534,
0.15679305791854858,
0.2879888415336609,
-0.7203938961029053,
0.06895408779382706,
-0.3539349138736725,
-0.258675217628479,
0.03392046317458153,
-0.15751585364341736,
-0.18126258254051208,
-0.24721862375736237,
0.09259822219610214,
0.0759507268667221,
-0.4256182909011841,
0.17757801711559296,
0.20851244032382965,
-0.10476057231426239,
-0.29489877820014954,
0.23332561552524567,
0.2414323091506958,
0.07485606521368027,
-0.7289714217185974,
-0.4862225651741028,
0.22461608052253723,
1.0683658123016357,
-0.2820678651332855,
0.6394883394241333,
0.7489138841629028,
-0.3444487154483795,
0.4525012671947479,
-1.1388893127441406,
0.15565799176692963,
-0.3840350806713104,
0.3631577789783478,
-0.5403845906257629,
-0.7647074460983276,
0.42187270522117615,
-0.24921779334545135,
-0.10714845359325409,
0.44872379302978516,
0.10640693455934525,
-0.091623954474926,
1.0213788747787476,
0.5341007113456726,
0.25996601581573486,
0.35752686858177185,
0.07395099103450775,
-0.24256084859371185,
-0.9702473282814026,
-0.40581977367401123,
-0.4228307902812958,
-0.5157209038734436,
-0.3775055706501007,
-0.8667709231376648,
0.3824528455734253,
0.4132566750049591,
-0.0886303186416626,
0.08693583309650421,
0.07829933613538742,
0.564707338809967,
0.40290701389312744,
0.18471597135066986,
0.6452972888946533,
-0.30750560760498047,
-0.4264035224914551,
-0.5105202198028564,
-0.6239078044891357,
-0.49203047156333923,
1.0071598291397095,
0.2351202517747879,
0.5984806418418884,
0.30868199467658997,
0.11562499403953552,
0.244205042719841,
0.3725060224533081,
-0.5698555707931519,
0.41652411222457886,
-0.10708514600992203,
-0.5401532053947449,
-0.020713960751891136,
-0.6031156778335571,
-0.2979595959186554,
0.4253147840499878,
-0.5621837377548218,
-0.4923209846019745,
0.634111225605011,
0.3354674279689789,
0.1175803616642952,
0.6874929666519165,
-1.0005649328231812,
1.3538627624511719,
0.0819743201136589,
-0.14498834311962128,
-0.2442537546157837,
-0.5853456258773804,
0.40986359119415283,
-0.06624647974967957,
0.4945453405380249,
-0.22620797157287598,
-0.15196289122104645,
0.3758136034011841,
-0.2821802794933319,
0.6453033685684204,
-0.272695392370224,
0.02368376962840557,
-0.07367388904094696,
0.4976762533187866,
0.677640974521637,
0.06319114565849304,
0.010191801004111767,
-0.06606616824865341,
0.1410486400127411,
-0.4001082479953766,
-0.7328107953071594,
0.4479873478412628,
-0.6061391234397888,
-0.13369150459766388,
-0.11644915491342545,
-0.7692399621009827,
-0.677324116230011,
0.2431764453649521,
0.030345410108566284,
0.8571659922599792,
-0.370096355676651,
0.2920662462711334,
0.6338781714439392,
-0.07712891697883606,
0.5259921550750732,
0.5055410861968994,
-0.2867756187915802,
-0.7631995677947998,
0.806410551071167,
0.2619650065898895,
0.6205980777740479,
0.49048635363578796,
0.06620369106531143,
-0.13688944280147552,
-0.45098650455474854,
-0.7055864930152893,
-0.038067083805799484,
-0.918775200843811,
-0.24782365560531616,
-0.9711912870407104,
0.04378286376595497,
-0.31440460681915283,
-0.2781677842140198,
-0.5851834416389465,
-0.509966254234314,
0.07788064330816269,
0.29973021149635315,
0.14045138657093048,
0.556837797164917,
-0.25749900937080383,
0.164719820022583,
-1.036545991897583,
0.5446134805679321,
0.5988672971725464,
0.586017370223999,
-0.11512155830860138,
-0.07947824150323868,
-0.19072261452674866,
0.3696557879447937,
-0.33020636439323425,
-0.6590697765350342,
-0.221650630235672,
0.11841332912445068,
0.4219256043434143,
0.2680688202381134,
-0.2537999451160431,
1.002892255783081,
-0.5376264452934265,
0.6054792404174805,
0.3458797335624695,
-1.0838903188705444,
0.3500750958919525,
-0.21876905858516693,
0.5654105544090271,
0.7765400409698486,
0.11633460968732834,
-0.9665926694869995,
-0.36148709058761597,
-0.37686893343925476,
-0.2086545079946518,
0.42110440135002136,
0.17300885915756226,
-0.39999860525131226,
-0.14526677131652832,
-0.0149827366694808,
0.19481615722179413,
0.4204660952091217,
-0.6369795799255371,
-0.15298467874526978,
-0.3875994384288788,
-0.1452707052230835,
-0.36584776639938354,
-0.7146362662315369,
-0.11557342112064362,
-0.31870517134666443,
0.6668528318405151,
-0.14297635853290558,
0.03162461519241333,
0.4387519955635071,
-0.6524556279182434,
-0.2530654966831207,
0.6505683660507202,
1.266648292541504,
0.8313162922859192,
-0.31372421979904175,
0.33272048830986023,
0.23528306186199188,
-0.7079182267189026,
0.09682754427194595,
-0.10797024518251419,
0.03986373171210289,
0.08245354145765305,
0.22972500324249268,
0.6466280221939087,
0.5869935154914856,
-0.69175785779953,
0.5293887257575989,
-0.2279525101184845,
-0.17037837207317352,
0.44692471623420715,
-0.20838212966918945,
0.03457134962081909,
0.3725137710571289,
0.08236654102802277,
0.9955002069473267,
0.021657930687069893,
-0.5338121056556702,
0.0028456230647861958,
0.2621411979198456,
-0.28577548265457153,
-0.06980959326028824,
0.6488296985626221,
-0.03506115451455116,
-0.023833870887756348,
0.10266727954149246,
-0.10823658853769302,
-0.18456529080867767,
0.09402067959308624,
0.35271450877189636,
0.6414698362350464,
-0.19311977922916412,
0.2078304886817932,
0.11111198365688324,
0.5757790803909302,
-0.05125177279114723,
0.12396545708179474,
0.09490297734737396,
-0.756324291229248,
-0.5109654664993286,
-0.44218018651008606,
-0.46965160965919495,
-0.22942841053009033,
-0.44828033447265625,
0.13587653636932373,
-0.4459346830844879,
-0.2482757717370987,
0.1756177395582199,
-0.3562849760055542,
-0.5596567988395691,
0.2773982286453247,
-0.19683699309825897,
0.8375144004821777,
-0.5080705285072327,
0.660297155380249,
0.8116602897644043,
-0.27396896481513977,
-0.5485696196556091,
-0.29670920968055725,
0.28862977027893066,
-0.5375136137008667,
0.4266158640384674,
-0.10432387888431549,
-0.23860248923301697,
-0.12082426249980927,
-0.2221803367137909,
-0.7081373333930969,
1.132125735282898,
0.4658275544643402,
-0.6849123239517212,
0.2026492804288864,
0.27653878927230835,
0.12962867319583893,
-0.2129286676645279,
0.13898888230323792,
0.37388989329338074,
0.8991189002990723,
-0.0997219905257225,
-1.2667213678359985,
-0.23113510012626648,
-0.09744212031364441,
0.17253653705120087,
0.2962879538536072,
-0.6332991719245911,
0.7770115733146667,
0.08397477865219116,
0.0975145474076271,
-0.09470498561859131,
0.20414848625659943,
-0.13734407722949982,
0.5115562081336975,
0.3961680829524994,
0.8716900944709778,
0.6547154784202576,
-0.1887274980545044,
0.6058838963508606,
-0.08904710412025452,
0.39720484614372253,
1.1530916690826416,
-0.05437115952372551,
0.854546844959259,
0.49504929780960083,
0.13474592566490173,
0.3688325583934784,
0.20152756571769714,
0.1603579968214035,
0.2708439230918884,
-0.5198802351951599,
-0.31664443016052246,
-0.17337241768836975,
0.05131947249174118,
-0.4587804973125458,
0.6354948878288269,
0.00965637993067503,
-0.313952773809433,
-0.294039249420166,
0.36188915371894836,
0.23153166472911835,
0.11948235332965851,
-0.5185061097145081,
0.7947806119918823,
-0.3381797969341278,
-0.3695805072784424,
0.3626199960708618,
0.24891892075538635,
0.5216485261917114,
-0.5228710174560547,
0.08726144582033157,
-0.11606648564338684,
0.28013449907302856,
-0.16813690960407257,
-0.6474069952964783,
0.27415502071380615,
-0.1163458451628685,
-0.629487931728363,
-0.13918498158454895,
0.762561559677124,
-0.5659344792366028,
-0.5682426691055298,
-0.06094594672322273,
0.5828052759170532,
-0.2903188467025757,
-0.30178767442703247,
-0.6244251132011414,
0.41247597336769104,
-0.05114918202161789,
0.033561740070581436,
0.23898006975650787,
0.7092642784118652,
0.0241884533315897,
0.6257360577583313,
0.5423474907875061,
-0.35021528601646423,
0.29897376894950867,
0.10224678367376328,
0.5624637007713318,
-0.7568832039833069,
0.02326405979692936,
-0.8650662899017334,
0.8461073637008667,
-0.14948515594005585,
-0.3892093598842621,
0.8395748138427734,
0.7921047210693359,
0.7842917442321777,
-0.38881346583366394,
0.4565030038356781,
-0.03437419235706329,
0.2593703269958496,
-0.7702550888061523,
0.7478337287902832,
-0.6442984342575073,
-0.18263867497444153,
-0.6291162967681885,
-1.1185036897659302,
-0.32777175307273865,
0.239821657538414,
-0.07481115311384201,
0.010494750924408436,
1.005574345588684,
0.889786958694458,
-0.33443087339401245,
0.03000534139573574,
0.6745014786720276,
0.4569442570209503,
0.028583619743585587,
0.21875444054603577,
0.6659345030784607,
-0.566660463809967,
0.3171488046646118,
-0.5617184042930603,
-0.012496037408709526,
-0.2594955265522003,
-0.8976733088493347,
-0.7770742774009705,
-0.6571565866470337,
-0.3540385663509369,
-0.22690658271312714,
0.10019928216934204,
1.0921860933303833,
0.5675099492073059,
-0.5881637334823608,
0.14100781083106995,
0.3819190561771393,
0.14273633062839508,
-0.5519372224807739,
-0.181095689535141,
0.032648637890815735,
-0.31913983821868896,
-0.5830159783363342,
0.44797223806381226,
0.6904195547103882,
0.1989915817975998,
-0.13447605073451996,
-0.0047989096492528915,
-0.42503222823143005,
0.09998123347759247,
1.042252779006958,
0.005353427492082119,
-0.6952274441719055,
-0.522822916507721,
-0.1740344762802124,
-0.2933007478713989,
0.2394324392080307,
0.8892805576324463,
-0.3836751878261566,
1.0350887775421143,
0.25676923990249634,
0.679154098033905,
0.24760857224464417,
-0.04364988952875137,
0.2734222412109375,
-0.7774614095687866,
0.08368002623319626,
-0.06347040086984634,
0.5606791377067566,
0.42629125714302063,
-0.03096967749297619,
0.28507232666015625,
0.5339411497116089,
-0.6292142868041992,
-0.6727541089057922,
0.1078377440571785,
-1.4014629125595093,
-0.22093580663204193,
0.9016345143318176,
0.008679352700710297,
-0.1388149857521057,
-0.09541679173707962,
-0.7863953709602356,
0.17633581161499023,
-0.06567645072937012,
0.5291841626167297,
1.0509265661239624,
0.22085127234458923,
-0.4075583517551422,
-0.7561582922935486,
0.43532344698905945,
0.2573454976081848,
-0.6726801991462708,
0.18457317352294922,
0.9134541749954224,
0.334977388381958,
0.1481720358133316,
0.39263278245925903,
-0.12484873831272125,
0.562905490398407,
0.18329422175884247,
0.1521771103143692,
-0.35546037554740906,
-0.4356217384338379,
-0.006772524211555719,
0.18446364998817444,
0.06463988125324249,
0.0150998430326581
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13217v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13217v1 | Bridging Law and Data: Augmenting Reasoning via a Semi-Structured Dataset with IRAC methodology | 2024-06-19T04:59:09 | 2024-06-19T04:59:09 | Xiaoxi Kang, Lizhen Qu, Lay-Ki Soon, Zhuang Li, Adnan Trakic | cs.CL | cs.CL | The effectiveness of Large Language Models (LLMs) in legal reasoning is often
limited due to the unique legal terminologies and the necessity for highly
specialized knowledge. These limitations highlight the need for high-quality
data tailored for complex legal reasoning tasks. This paper introduces
LEGALSEMI, a benchmark specifically curated for legal scenario analysis.
LEGALSEMI comprises 54 legal scenarios, each rigorously annotated by legal
experts, based on the comprehensive IRAC (Issue, Rule, Application, Conclusion)
framework. In addition, LEGALSEMI is accompanied by a structured knowledge
graph (SKG). A series of experiments were conducted to assess the usefulness of
LEGALSEMI for IRAC analysis. The experimental results demonstrate the
effectiveness of incorporating the SKG for issue identification, rule
retrieval, application and conclusion generation using four different LLMs.
LEGALSEMI will be publicly available upon acceptance of this paper. | [
-0.21010546386241913,
-0.6975773572921753,
0.6889959573745728,
0.10465839505195618,
-0.25784602761268616,
0.16282998025417328,
-0.12923333048820496,
-0.37876462936401367,
-0.09624383598566055,
0.7053620219230652,
-0.28052806854248047,
-1.0680214166641235,
-0.27386194467544556,
0.005703484173864126,
-0.38646233081817627,
0.7464947700500488,
-0.12361400574445724,
0.12327297776937485,
-0.4684194326400757,
-0.4902134835720062,
-0.49506425857543945,
-0.34241166710853577,
-0.30936872959136963,
-0.20811603963375092,
0.19508227705955505,
0.5588993430137634,
0.4381648004055023,
0.7377116680145264,
0.44730836153030396,
0.32749849557876587,
0.12985730171203613,
-0.052254363894462585,
-0.3994635343551636,
0.21551558375358582,
-0.1402873992919922,
-0.7175460457801819,
-0.4782388210296631,
0.09282904863357544,
0.572410523891449,
0.7533321976661682,
-0.6600581407546997,
-0.07364879548549652,
-0.4607559144496918,
0.4524591267108917,
-0.7215253114700317,
0.1460694819688797,
-0.4745730757713318,
0.24870306253433228,
-0.32171720266342163,
-0.2416190505027771,
-0.38475295901298523,
-0.18865108489990234,
-0.13862207531929016,
-0.48796188831329346,
-0.08827419579029083,
0.4868268370628357,
0.7149097919464111,
0.33517012000083923,
-0.5666796565055847,
-0.4874081015586853,
-0.7011834979057312,
0.586500346660614,
-0.9608690142631531,
0.5325624346733093,
0.15044356882572174,
0.48484233021736145,
-0.35170701146125793,
-0.8455609679222107,
-0.5699499249458313,
-0.5292908549308777,
0.017005398869514465,
0.5254963040351868,
-0.16602790355682373,
0.0723002552986145,
0.5517594218254089,
-0.04029838740825653,
-0.5130523443222046,
0.32520991563796997,
-0.5182207226753235,
-0.16192781925201416,
0.8198679089546204,
0.3336007595062256,
0.3381778299808502,
-0.2535453140735626,
-0.5263199806213379,
0.10546442121267319,
-0.8093181252479553,
0.12599891424179077,
0.8177483677864075,
-0.006040835753083229,
-0.11961398273706436,
0.829983651638031,
-0.26582834124565125,
0.6538074016571045,
-0.36056068539619446,
-0.17493009567260742,
0.3918136954307556,
-0.3667100965976715,
-0.11892768740653992,
0.4853620231151581,
0.682581901550293,
0.4294990003108978,
0.1564282923936844,
-0.13977502286434174,
-0.2095181941986084,
-0.08066622912883759,
0.09635212272405624,
-0.5508456230163574,
-0.04290759563446045,
0.31786033511161804,
-0.5419982671737671,
-0.031382422894239426,
0.2980112135410309,
-0.7802309393882751,
-0.3217720091342926,
-0.5720196962356567,
-0.17359662055969238,
-0.3412594199180603,
0.012052728794515133,
0.27946537733078003,
-0.2120148092508316,
0.38098806142807007,
0.20462347567081451,
-0.05561724305152893,
0.16287337243556976,
0.8028034567832947,
0.6234304904937744,
0.1068749949336052,
0.1773480623960495,
-0.7188286185264587,
0.5556012392044067,
-0.38565510511398315,
0.9528750777244568,
-0.8845211863517761,
-0.2805117964744568,
-0.013882758095860481,
-0.22775304317474365,
0.0683676153421402,
-0.6053116321563721,
0.9961501955986023,
-0.5198130011558533,
-0.16238896548748016,
0.018545033410191536,
-0.7074910998344421,
0.08986177295446396,
0.3039627969264984,
-0.678682804107666,
0.8378990292549133,
-0.0952756479382515,
-0.7088584303855896,
0.7845746874809265,
-0.7507680654525757,
-0.6971865892410278,
0.5645034909248352,
-0.5267069935798645,
-0.4057125151157379,
-0.2244901955127716,
-0.01958751492202282,
0.5013478994369507,
-0.23933134973049164,
0.6578973531723022,
-0.6595503687858582,
-0.03822688013315201,
0.14797216653823853,
0.20171085000038147,
0.8773499727249146,
0.7624616026878357,
-0.017138469964265823,
0.01125132292509079,
-0.7120248675346375,
-0.11587480455636978,
-0.19715486466884613,
-0.38511374592781067,
-0.5244856476783752,
0.15074068307876587,
-0.39728450775146484,
0.41120654344558716,
0.006037500221282244,
-0.5191618800163269,
-0.15756286680698395,
-0.13029904663562775,
0.6822168231010437,
0.5096246600151062,
-0.0013984284596517682,
0.3401128649711609,
-0.15402238070964813,
0.5867733359336853,
0.24042019248008728,
-0.11443298310041428,
0.12126537412405014,
-0.28356435894966125,
-0.5472122430801392,
-0.3423451781272888,
0.6171866655349731,
0.7678332924842834,
-0.48821425437927246,
0.3541482090950012,
-0.3444616496562958,
-0.3127136528491974,
-0.5091162919998169,
0.2435416281223297,
-0.016762617975473404,
0.5058660507202148,
0.030052589252591133,
0.09811634570360184,
-0.8748958706855774,
-1.1560672521591187,
-0.4637586772441864,
-0.38899025321006775,
-0.0066654616966843605,
0.4965803325176239,
0.6536755561828613,
-0.12471570074558258,
0.8749870657920837,
0.05841755121946335,
-0.1970929205417633,
-0.594406247138977,
0.4900490641593933,
0.14405767619609833,
0.09751802682876587,
0.38051366806030273,
-0.804762065410614,
-0.2573377192020416,
0.09681644290685654,
-0.8986782431602478,
-0.4406220316886902,
-0.406332403421402,
-0.3162274658679962,
-0.1834867149591446,
0.9080172181129456,
-0.34606173634529114,
0.6146531105041504,
-0.08827464282512665,
-0.4133296012878418,
0.3569648563861847,
-0.3052927553653717,
0.36529603600502014,
-1.0023467540740967,
-0.0028610520530492067,
0.5000765323638916,
-0.3181602954864502,
-0.5583726167678833,
0.01809883862733841,
0.15515218675136566,
0.05908139795064926,
-0.45266062021255493,
0.35276657342910767,
-0.26791492104530334,
-0.2390025556087494,
0.08718530833721161,
0.2317277044057846,
-0.18694089353084564,
0.10598605871200562,
-0.020456453785300255,
0.7288115620613098,
0.2976449429988861,
-0.3952273726463318,
0.401231050491333,
0.1734490543603897,
-0.6541792750358582,
0.7733854055404663,
-0.5550121068954468,
-0.42068418860435486,
-0.18559908866882324,
0.174726203083992,
-0.3456975817680359,
-0.2499070018529892,
0.12822265923023224,
-0.07954420894384384,
0.06332550197839737,
-0.4033398926258087,
-0.787996232509613,
-0.21533067524433136,
-0.11929302662611008,
0.2670404314994812,
0.4285666346549988,
-0.2898874282836914,
0.8948403596878052,
0.6616917252540588,
-0.004161377437412739,
-0.23077692091464996,
-0.5372118949890137,
0.48021069169044495,
-0.6832600831985474,
-0.652571976184845,
0.1761799454689026,
0.1265006959438324,
-0.8145922422409058,
0.18810759484767914,
0.06827140599489212,
0.12277057766914368,
0.043453797698020935,
0.4846518039703369,
0.12983796000480652,
-0.17275755107402802,
-0.1402697116136551,
0.025401810184121132,
0.0018356213113293052,
0.4838327467441559,
0.0842064619064331,
0.120817169547081,
-0.07747329026460648,
-0.4396848678588867,
-0.23319877684116364,
0.4231482446193695,
0.2828110158443451,
-0.2931531071662903,
0.40914440155029297,
-0.12265074253082275,
-0.4035549759864807,
-0.45251864194869995,
-0.5044751167297363,
0.3903166353702545,
-0.40837016701698303,
0.06000405177474022,
-0.5143412351608276,
-0.879204273223877,
0.6897582411766052,
-0.5223968029022217,
0.1075914055109024,
0.40943342447280884,
0.7328640222549438,
-0.461590439081192,
0.8977575302124023,
0.1773734986782074,
0.06571938842535019,
0.20164786279201508,
-0.07958520948886871,
0.5509059429168701,
-0.6553648710250854,
-0.6736913323402405,
-0.7425410747528076,
-0.32452332973480225,
-0.5001405477523804,
-0.2759954333305359,
0.42124268412590027,
0.12021470069885254,
-0.1993504911661148,
0.30408427119255066,
0.2640369236469269,
0.5114901065826416,
0.5266158580780029,
0.053785890340805054,
0.41510865092277527,
-0.1808713972568512,
-0.37714728713035583,
0.2993934750556946,
-0.9498990178108215,
-0.7065698504447937,
1.0828752517700195,
0.19667421281337738,
0.772707462310791,
0.05227639898657799,
0.5381723642349243,
0.5486965775489807,
-0.05522477626800537,
-0.5934110879898071,
0.8341450691223145,
-0.09135107696056366,
-0.6231909394264221,
0.012813655659556389,
-0.7831728458404541,
-0.7170832753181458,
-0.15605662763118744,
-0.2235020399093628,
-0.6623918414115906,
0.203313410282135,
-0.27360567450523376,
-0.5432990193367004,
0.31127044558525085,
-0.5288338661193848,
0.6064287424087524,
-0.2654256820678711,
-0.4834102690219879,
-0.20939421653747559,
-0.7307751178741455,
0.5581530928611755,
0.051394570618867874,
0.46711158752441406,
-0.43161725997924805,
0.04100438952445984,
0.8138803839683533,
-0.6623508334159851,
0.42249733209609985,
-0.04862566292285919,
0.17306017875671387,
0.6634997725486755,
-0.015181045979261398,
0.36306020617485046,
0.3325304687023163,
-0.1077476218342781,
-0.06059252470731735,
0.10930868238210678,
-0.269099622964859,
-0.6287458539009094,
0.8317590951919556,
-0.38404202461242676,
-0.564825177192688,
-0.5723260045051575,
-0.8112481236457825,
-0.32312995195388794,
-0.010138513520359993,
-0.3164905905723572,
0.3412345349788666,
0.06158844381570816,
0.4253440201282501,
0.7306671142578125,
0.029475137591362,
0.14998143911361694,
0.6060433983802795,
0.43317246437072754,
-0.07719658315181732,
0.44146326184272766,
0.1494101732969284,
-0.2535233199596405,
0.051645129919052124,
0.07093013823032379,
-0.4438762068748474,
-0.7196325063705444,
-0.24945667386054993,
0.08800909668207169,
-0.8339390158653259,
-0.33817848563194275,
-0.6890519857406616,
-0.19961586594581604,
-0.2759591341018677,
-0.027911940589547157,
-0.04933976009488106,
-0.16880865395069122,
0.20716437697410583,
-0.25194108486175537,
0.40857651829719543,
0.42415720224380493,
-0.18102338910102844,
-0.10302336513996124,
-0.5228668451309204,
0.36052629351615906,
0.03905195742845535,
0.43465426564216614,
-0.4802468419075012,
-0.36979374289512634,
0.055297378450632095,
-0.06785579025745392,
0.31543582677841187,
-0.6280608177185059,
0.051264625042676926,
0.00992792658507824,
0.8486331105232239,
0.5439305901527405,
0.30228063464164734,
0.9598537087440491,
-0.5640295743942261,
0.33072802424430847,
0.12001502513885498,
-0.5219501852989197,
0.8698641061782837,
-0.14723268151283264,
-0.18552741408348083,
0.7764731049537659,
0.23009788990020752,
-0.23669902980327606,
-0.5405565500259399,
-0.569372832775116,
-0.8168835639953613,
0.5280132293701172,
0.41193410754203796,
-0.16541790962219238,
0.20263566076755524,
0.6665518283843994,
0.03541644662618637,
-0.03125055879354477,
-0.2216230034828186,
0.23989836871623993,
0.1400749832391739,
-0.4676988422870636,
0.288921058177948,
-0.06761809438467026,
-0.41454511880874634,
-0.4743598699569702,
0.6713077425956726,
0.1339872032403946,
-0.14858387410640717,
-0.0877716988325119,
-0.31427764892578125,
0.14397107064723969,
0.3548220992088318,
0.4623814523220062,
0.812683641910553,
-0.09547514468431473,
0.23730243742465973,
0.23511163890361786,
-0.16311094164848328,
0.09515941143035889,
0.027170870453119278,
-0.2501761019229889,
-0.18587277829647064,
0.6118125915527344,
0.7162702679634094,
0.14893227815628052,
-1.1655430793762207,
0.3927050828933716,
-0.08350668102502823,
-0.5959638953208923,
-0.3050336241722107,
0.36193475127220154,
0.06928707659244537,
0.5107954740524292,
0.22691026329994202,
-0.304047554731369,
0.3002488911151886,
-0.7638322114944458,
0.424877792596817,
0.341201514005661,
-0.12314563244581223,
0.16479797661304474,
0.7199062705039978,
0.2458430826663971,
0.0358007438480854,
0.6244813203811646,
-0.07830260694026947,
-0.3344931900501251,
0.7553897500038147,
0.1890336126089096,
0.23857812583446503,
0.2994024455547333,
0.1404261589050293,
0.37299808859825134,
0.29858553409576416,
-0.154068723320961,
0.3600664734840393,
-0.16108214855194092,
-0.481133371591568,
-0.41098788380622864,
-0.3503554165363312,
-0.2308940589427948,
0.08361950516700745,
-0.6638078093528748,
0.39061930775642395,
-0.3982660472393036,
0.11611595749855042,
0.056361835449934006,
0.21521495282649994,
-0.7986379265785217,
0.0559636689722538,
-0.11656875908374786,
1.195089340209961,
-0.9807068109512329,
0.72930508852005,
0.7333728075027466,
-0.3719605505466461,
-0.8504044413566589,
-0.3226037323474884,
0.10445305705070496,
-0.6814138293266296,
0.4756743013858795,
-0.06563504040241241,
0.023777581751346588,
-0.327438086271286,
-0.78005051612854,
-0.11740781366825104,
1.2486770153045654,
0.27319100499153137,
-0.8372486233711243,
0.30667844414711,
0.6151565909385681,
0.4674226641654968,
-0.5787917971611023,
0.06311945617198944,
1.06023108959198,
0.6385295391082764,
0.49467334151268005,
-0.2147197425365448,
-0.082720547914505,
-0.44647812843322754,
-0.054529111832380295,
0.1729142665863037,
-0.20481683313846588,
0.22033146023750305,
-0.1890607327222824,
-0.29024311900138855,
-0.14421553909778595,
0.7067161798477173,
0.621428906917572,
0.6946294903755188,
0.5864793658256531,
1.0993645191192627,
0.7287449240684509,
-0.23782145977020264,
0.8558369874954224,
-0.36057159304618835,
0.058611102402210236,
1.241815447807312,
-0.812023937702179,
0.5256083011627197,
0.6650484204292297,
-0.11936323344707489,
0.5239335298538208,
0.7656216025352478,
-0.2424011528491974,
0.40767619013786316,
0.3648809790611267,
-0.23937679827213287,
-0.8271530270576477,
-0.2625448703765869,
-0.10802531242370605,
0.37437307834625244,
0.2783893346786499,
-0.10165555775165558,
-0.40735405683517456,
0.006714655552059412,
-0.015647994354367256,
0.26760628819465637,
-0.3466358482837677,
0.8563817739486694,
-0.02006956934928894,
-0.2979556620121002,
-0.3902742564678192,
0.18341957032680511,
0.022135134786367416,
-0.42317643761634827,
-0.2762801945209503,
-0.5463815927505493,
-0.13346071541309357,
-0.3041057884693146,
-1.1174933910369873,
0.18679779767990112,
0.41243261098861694,
0.21280670166015625,
-0.19962722063064575,
0.7406284213066101,
-0.19401954114437103,
-0.7741644382476807,
0.21514436602592468,
0.4956866502761841,
0.338530033826828,
0.47708576917648315,
-0.7867904305458069,
0.042046453803777695,
-0.39354583621025085,
-0.06145342066884041,
0.15781500935554504,
1.0031688213348389,
-0.4024737775325775,
0.8496177792549133,
0.6010934114456177,
0.24215397238731384,
0.237209752202034,
0.32741230726242065,
0.9160643815994263,
-0.506566047668457,
-0.5248069763183594,
-0.6575520634651184,
0.6023284792900085,
-0.4743489623069763,
-0.12628668546676636,
0.6464530229568481,
0.9598169922828674,
0.80739825963974,
0.45257094502449036,
0.7028099298477173,
-0.2759348750114441,
0.3523140251636505,
-0.8983327150344849,
0.47919389605522156,
-0.37616172432899475,
0.7078231573104858,
0.17173999547958374,
-0.7100938558578491,
-0.4505005180835724,
0.4831662178039551,
-0.4053446352481842,
0.009476852603256702,
0.4148499369621277,
0.8472426533699036,
-0.4260725677013397,
0.06564605236053467,
0.296110063791275,
-0.01306407991796732,
0.17681464552879333,
0.5033069849014282,
0.9831787943840027,
-0.11410931497812271,
0.551978349685669,
-0.15920652449131012,
-0.12720388174057007,
-0.13307060301303864,
-0.9410113096237183,
-1.131035327911377,
-0.372222900390625,
-0.5534736514091492,
-0.2453874796628952,
0.11963574588298798,
0.7275403738021851,
0.7009167075157166,
-0.8687314391136169,
-0.32518455386161804,
-0.16442741453647614,
0.02564997412264347,
0.1577911078929901,
-0.15322226285934448,
0.09771601855754852,
-0.24875694513320923,
-0.3452243208885193,
0.4084862172603607,
0.3902885317802429,
-0.33464422821998596,
-0.03177966922521591,
-0.44634899497032166,
-0.5014427900314331,
0.25101420283317566,
0.28329282999038696,
0.24883809685707092,
-0.5522862076759338,
-0.19868560135364532,
-0.33138564229011536,
0.021033398807048798,
0.14615339040756226,
1.3383177518844604,
-0.6288623213768005,
0.417345255613327,
0.46182775497436523,
0.6107735633850098,
0.3447708487510681,
0.12640675902366638,
0.5129342675209045,
-0.48408064246177673,
0.13019776344299316,
0.38046127557754517,
0.791256844997406,
-0.19721126556396484,
-0.09727852046489716,
0.6774954199790955,
0.043552517890930176,
-0.10064993798732758,
-0.8352616429328918,
0.006902300287038088,
-0.9444977641105652,
-0.477083295583725,
1.037357211112976,
-0.27459320425987244,
-0.37981998920440674,
-0.21439862251281738,
0.20990608632564545,
0.19204182922840118,
-0.41658374667167664,
0.6023057103157043,
0.9005300998687744,
-0.06381037831306458,
-0.3112108111381531,
-1.168495535850525,
0.1455841064453125,
0.13384340703487396,
-1.2793394327163696,
-0.15786387026309967,
0.654952347278595,
0.20790918171405792,
-0.3051776587963104,
0.1783774346113205,
-0.31379595398902893,
0.06793154031038284,
-0.111007459461689,
-0.12663483619689941,
-0.2765001356601715,
-0.514585018157959,
-0.05191821604967117,
0.25458890199661255,
-0.331044465303421,
0.16553205251693726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13213v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13213v1 | Multi-Meta-RAG: Improving RAG for Multi-Hop Queries using Database Filtering with LLM-Extracted Metadata | 2024-06-19T04:53:48 | 2024-06-19T04:53:48 | Mykhailo Poliakov, Nadiya Shvai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB | The retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) enables retrieval of relevant
information from an external knowledge source and allows large language models
(LLMs) to answer queries over previously unseen document collections. However,
it was demonstrated that traditional RAG applications perform poorly in
answering multi-hop questions, which require retrieving and reasoning over
multiple elements of supporting evidence. We introduce a new method called
Multi-Meta-RAG, which uses database filtering with LLM-extracted metadata to
improve the RAG selection of the relevant documents from various sources,
relevant to the question. While database filtering is specific to a set of
questions from a particular domain and format, we found out that Multi-Meta-RAG
greatly improves the results on the MultiHop-RAG benchmark. The code is
available at https://github.com/mxpoliakov/Multi-Meta-RAG. | [
-0.8187133073806763,
-0.7668697834014893,
0.610710620880127,
-0.05022071301937103,
-0.24961599707603455,
0.42244961857795715,
0.058537036180496216,
-0.6624429821968079,
0.6498876214027405,
0.9268302321434021,
-0.5890194773674011,
-0.35665401816368103,
-0.4901219308376312,
0.20051293075084686,
-0.281514972448349,
1.0243107080459595,
0.3113197982311249,
0.03783520311117172,
-0.3332921266555786,
-0.31146296858787537,
-0.37501782178878784,
-0.3687998652458191,
-0.6672916412353516,
-0.2613401412963867,
0.7066070437431335,
0.5874157547950745,
0.4414573013782501,
0.46812182664871216,
0.7955913543701172,
0.24837520718574524,
-0.16090387105941772,
0.7616046071052551,
-0.24249880015850067,
0.631900429725647,
-0.2607380151748657,
-0.39124342799186707,
-0.7504715919494629,
-0.10181477665901184,
0.6174960732460022,
0.3457649350166321,
-0.0881599485874176,
0.5668328404426575,
-0.049122896045446396,
0.9517143368721008,
-0.9926057457923889,
-0.23830051720142365,
-0.8160760998725891,
-0.27755483984947205,
-0.507855236530304,
-0.7082637548446655,
-0.47103047370910645,
-0.2445666491985321,
-0.30894747376441956,
-0.5643562078475952,
0.32295310497283936,
0.17101283371448517,
0.6628714799880981,
0.2881072163581848,
-0.6565698981285095,
-0.35464751720428467,
-0.8226581811904907,
0.6177849173545837,
-0.2964429259300232,
0.4751673638820648,
0.6000065803527832,
0.6058903932571411,
-0.14335212111473083,
-1.0328272581100464,
-0.4360644519329071,
-0.0613524466753006,
-0.33436867594718933,
0.20161575078964233,
0.34249457716941833,
-0.1365857720375061,
0.46499836444854736,
0.27068668603897095,
-0.48429784178733826,
-0.4099603593349457,
-0.1954774707555771,
-0.14284300804138184,
0.5017328262329102,
0.18403972685337067,
0.0417933352291584,
-0.38545119762420654,
-0.29964587092399597,
-0.0465453639626503,
-0.6462772488594055,
-0.07260047644376755,
0.3700857162475586,
0.28202059864997864,
0.6191542744636536,
0.6325640082359314,
-0.28737202286720276,
0.952871561050415,
-0.01112926285713911,
-0.4731832444667816,
0.21214133501052856,
-0.4190831482410431,
0.048203762620687485,
-0.41313740611076355,
0.4514146149158478,
0.2935020923614502,
-0.2175901234149933,
-0.07688920199871063,
-0.15633231401443481,
-0.2806133031845093,
0.29755499958992004,
-0.6725027561187744,
0.08562527596950531,
0.24316208064556122,
-0.6137524247169495,
-0.2232198715209961,
0.17372430860996246,
-1.2227216958999634,
-0.6902049779891968,
-0.19828198850154877,
0.397940456867218,
-0.29656392335891724,
-0.4557165205478668,
-0.07889623194932938,
-0.3852161169052124,
0.48103514313697815,
0.2762366533279419,
-0.47807055711746216,
0.4295283257961273,
0.778564989566803,
0.6518661379814148,
-0.01453208364546299,
-0.15743376314640045,
-0.9859965443611145,
0.3619716763496399,
-0.16573669016361237,
1.219892144203186,
-0.7667794823646545,
-0.39733850955963135,
-0.32557204365730286,
-0.03846460208296776,
-0.0006952941184863448,
-0.5734333395957947,
0.8972979784011841,
-1.0149973630905151,
0.1568174958229065,
-0.372030109167099,
-0.28707563877105713,
-0.16502007842063904,
0.48977333307266235,
-0.9958277940750122,
1.2843310832977295,
-0.09150684624910355,
-1.011986255645752,
0.30635079741477966,
-0.7164506316184998,
-0.3915973901748657,
-0.03306003659963608,
0.08966193348169327,
-0.3950880467891693,
0.02126576192677021,
0.3648688495159149,
0.08260117471218109,
-0.6895308494567871,
0.17698347568511963,
-0.3494822680950165,
-0.28230610489845276,
0.12266313284635544,
-0.11391152441501617,
0.8111454844474792,
0.3579937815666199,
0.07056288421154022,
-0.13879729807376862,
-0.9210801720619202,
0.18948201835155487,
0.1315874457359314,
-0.6636751294136047,
-0.5765708684921265,
0.07507384568452835,
-0.13713286817073822,
0.30502593517303467,
0.07481116056442261,
-0.3984597325325012,
0.30472061038017273,
-0.16175700724124908,
-0.3802667558193207,
0.46444740891456604,
0.26726874709129333,
0.4489123821258545,
-0.6178987622261047,
0.632766604423523,
-0.2226991057395935,
-0.01664862409234047,
-0.4380551278591156,
-0.5625830888748169,
-0.5177964568138123,
-0.3646696209907532,
0.49282771348953247,
0.5263564586639404,
-1.0068044662475586,
-0.08613970875740051,
-0.13901378214359283,
-0.3789278268814087,
-0.6304441690444946,
0.07687380164861679,
0.18508422374725342,
0.5904161930084229,
0.5681191086769104,
-0.16100306808948517,
-0.861433207988739,
-0.48802801966667175,
-0.7232768535614014,
0.15542525053024292,
0.03440183028578758,
0.7451845407485962,
0.3297635614871979,
-0.3673964738845825,
0.9790851473808289,
-0.6715133190155029,
-0.23234951496124268,
0.04637445881962776,
0.29182472825050354,
0.29810869693756104,
0.041672687977552414,
0.43969613313674927,
-0.984879732131958,
-0.8944072723388672,
-0.046976238489151,
-0.37662801146507263,
-0.4398716688156128,
0.19638818502426147,
-0.3286305367946625,
0.24707061052322388,
0.5556225776672363,
-0.6461557149887085,
0.1747312694787979,
0.47019970417022705,
-0.3543376922607422,
0.7147239446640015,
-0.06136855110526085,
0.41305047273635864,
-1.281192660331726,
0.36330145597457886,
-0.5021350383758545,
-0.5085773468017578,
-0.6035235524177551,
0.2678617537021637,
0.1593887209892273,
0.00471943523734808,
-0.19507776200771332,
0.6111041307449341,
-0.7069013714790344,
-0.40398091077804565,
-0.6533093452453613,
0.24870899319648743,
0.37231209874153137,
0.11709309369325638,
-0.07655258476734161,
0.736757218837738,
0.47833290696144104,
-0.7222270965576172,
0.46736961603164673,
0.03543185815215111,
0.03783944249153137,
0.6566330790519714,
-0.14508682489395142,
0.31938913464546204,
-0.339219868183136,
0.4985964298248291,
-0.9513174295425415,
-0.23885288834571838,
0.11180519312620163,
-0.5719876885414124,
0.5316018462181091,
-0.6488502025604248,
-0.5595284104347229,
-0.26091402769088745,
-0.5503450036048889,
0.13049066066741943,
0.12063977122306824,
-0.5962470769882202,
1.1176373958587646,
0.435367226600647,
0.04758162423968315,
-1.0286664962768555,
-0.3655523657798767,
0.1648975908756256,
-0.32185471057891846,
-0.5657333731651306,
0.4960074722766876,
-0.0946100503206253,
-0.1922018826007843,
0.22190551459789276,
-0.1718488335609436,
-0.25340521335601807,
0.080156609416008,
-0.1025608479976654,
0.19876915216445923,
-0.16391141712665558,
0.27504369616508484,
-0.02462659403681755,
-0.32553696632385254,
-0.06243039667606354,
-0.2023472636938095,
0.6961780786514282,
0.14247313141822815,
-0.3153589963912964,
0.37884506583213806,
0.42826762795448303,
0.6305994987487793,
-0.6630979180335999,
0.8710238933563232,
0.9666599035263062,
-0.11807867139577866,
-0.1996498703956604,
-0.7076643109321594,
-0.1786082684993744,
-0.47058171033859253,
-0.04052208736538887,
-0.6181814670562744,
-0.7115334272384644,
0.37699684500694275,
-0.5576898455619812,
0.035740431398153305,
0.6655483245849609,
0.28502950072288513,
-0.24948814511299133,
0.7321687936782837,
0.46541815996170044,
0.21234130859375,
0.3323625922203064,
-0.2887408137321472,
-0.20465734601020813,
-1.2653220891952515,
-0.09743281453847885,
-0.8323963284492493,
-0.24374836683273315,
-0.8532349467277527,
-0.6083269715309143,
0.5383680462837219,
0.04669363424181938,
-0.04153008759021759,
0.10861053317785263,
-0.39850685000419617,
0.6296120285987854,
0.7514485120773315,
0.10983327031135559,
0.7122029662132263,
-0.1378319412469864,
-0.16064976155757904,
0.16260577738285065,
-0.43289998173713684,
-0.2738941013813019,
1.2912460565567017,
-0.09330873191356659,
0.8109019994735718,
0.345358669757843,
0.8476384878158569,
0.03394722566008568,
0.30540382862091064,
-0.5255375504493713,
0.46521496772766113,
-0.15921539068222046,
-1.0536296367645264,
-0.1670185625553131,
-0.5741155743598938,
-0.9275326728820801,
0.661434531211853,
-0.5835582613945007,
-0.3714748024940491,
0.1072985902428627,
0.029230117797851562,
-0.09729134291410446,
0.424813449382782,
-0.42851540446281433,
0.3784692883491516,
-0.3688258230686188,
-0.3012681007385254,
-0.02055826224386692,
-0.7206810712814331,
0.586310625076294,
-0.4630057215690613,
0.4544419050216675,
-0.09451635181903839,
-0.2042863965034485,
0.48699405789375305,
-0.24432571232318878,
0.4474963843822479,
-0.3669734597206116,
0.19010579586029053,
0.5314724445343018,
0.1296682506799698,
0.7079214453697205,
0.07415857166051865,
-0.09729401767253876,
-0.18489393591880798,
-0.04367639496922493,
-0.05290122330188751,
-0.5803447365760803,
0.35644492506980896,
-0.3318372368812561,
-0.5152345299720764,
-0.47640037536621094,
-0.507617175579071,
-0.3445247709751129,
0.4838286340236664,
0.1297347992658615,
0.25991272926330566,
0.12197422981262207,
0.3590104579925537,
0.7352232336997986,
-0.32149696350097656,
0.36674392223358154,
0.8137177228927612,
-0.6052764654159546,
-0.5532190203666687,
0.6912561655044556,
0.1351674199104309,
0.03434770926833153,
0.7081049084663391,
0.3815784454345703,
-0.3314626216888428,
-0.26261720061302185,
-0.33319517970085144,
0.24761703610420227,
-0.671424388885498,
-0.6394892334938049,
-0.9564743638038635,
-0.1829259991645813,
-0.5055274963378906,
0.4146798849105835,
-0.3159816861152649,
-0.6661968231201172,
0.0045753656886518,
0.2210765779018402,
0.4597833752632141,
0.5587432980537415,
-0.29449158906936646,
0.2934722602367401,
-1.1234233379364014,
0.8494158387184143,
0.2976905107498169,
0.5984987020492554,
-0.2812962532043457,
-0.5525234341621399,
-0.3072194457054138,
-0.2532479465007782,
-0.38709941506385803,
-1.1335439682006836,
0.0933980867266655,
0.3569611608982086,
0.6914700269699097,
0.02848093770444393,
0.16448843479156494,
0.7233410477638245,
-0.8182381391525269,
0.2927921414375305,
-0.2862105071544647,
-0.5669112205505371,
0.6295066475868225,
-0.34433257579803467,
0.17908790707588196,
0.5392541885375977,
0.3976329565048218,
-0.44826820492744446,
-0.25157517194747925,
-0.5004934668540955,
-0.9361421465873718,
0.7899572253227234,
-0.09244576096534729,
-0.2227085530757904,
0.1705964058637619,
0.45587244629859924,
-0.030574500560760498,
0.0801672637462616,
-0.6790504455566406,
-0.5030567646026611,
0.074910968542099,
0.3520664870738983,
0.08288291096687317,
-0.5831598043441772,
-0.12357249855995178,
-0.01798316277563572,
0.7284778356552124,
-0.2094508707523346,
0.2192482203245163,
0.07759527862071991,
-0.15709109604358673,
-0.2601979076862335,
0.2327955961227417,
0.5013312101364136,
0.636200487613678,
-0.3374512195587158,
0.1994921863079071,
0.215373694896698,
-0.6199848651885986,
0.04365544393658638,
0.168826162815094,
-0.04658246412873268,
0.2169211208820343,
0.30492112040519714,
0.31562262773513794,
-0.19702835381031036,
-0.2611452341079712,
0.2653583586215973,
-0.28777503967285156,
-0.047726262360811234,
-0.08102017641067505,
0.00726645952090621,
0.1980324238538742,
0.27703365683555603,
0.6046435236930847,
0.10291995108127594,
0.5218750238418579,
-0.4251631498336792,
0.470719575881958,
0.6260880827903748,
0.3656767010688782,
0.17355620861053467,
0.5986071228981018,
-0.050052281469106674,
-0.32311299443244934,
0.2909184694290161,
-0.10814716666936874,
-0.41681423783302307,
0.2955406606197357,
0.6211590766906738,
0.7791504859924316,
-0.4764775335788727,
0.1462005376815796,
0.5371623635292053,
0.5107697248458862,
0.08351317048072815,
0.4851115942001343,
-0.15823271870613098,
-0.6934041380882263,
-0.7526528835296631,
-0.8251217603683472,
-0.6673411726951599,
-0.06344148516654968,
-0.5536850690841675,
0.39140385389328003,
0.07654538005590439,
-0.4196241796016693,
-0.04885490983724594,
0.24375002086162567,
-0.44026345014572144,
0.16617047786712646,
-0.2095033973455429,
0.8610122203826904,
-0.5633567571640015,
0.7571889758110046,
0.8286702632904053,
-0.26168301701545715,
-0.5795634388923645,
0.12313719093799591,
-0.04867139458656311,
-0.4576302468776703,
0.4725639224052429,
-0.04272979870438576,
-0.3675045371055603,
-0.14371931552886963,
-0.21576547622680664,
-1.3370604515075684,
1.1196094751358032,
0.3091667890548706,
-0.26239013671875,
0.12744902074337006,
0.09501710534095764,
0.4260474741458893,
-0.08512367308139801,
0.435041606426239,
0.486135870218277,
0.7669170498847961,
0.34196022152900696,
-0.8059586882591248,
-0.3398642838001251,
-0.1228904128074646,
-0.2808845639228821,
0.5366588830947876,
-0.4669438600540161,
0.8792778253555298,
0.0025033613201230764,
-0.040380898863077164,
-0.30911028385162354,
0.31293702125549316,
0.40987086296081543,
0.5818123817443848,
0.5453299880027771,
0.650956928730011,
0.9464896321296692,
-0.0862555280327797,
1.0693118572235107,
-0.38849127292633057,
0.39250582456588745,
1.457403302192688,
-0.301506370306015,
0.7556762099266052,
0.3324083387851715,
-0.11308229714632034,
0.551696240901947,
0.4452170431613922,
0.31228744983673096,
0.4293016195297241,
-0.08195273578166962,
-0.3435588479042053,
0.09553862363100052,
0.09117980301380157,
-0.3270598351955414,
0.6898248791694641,
0.4120992422103882,
-0.1968609243631363,
-0.3255017399787903,
-0.1381482630968094,
-0.14407236874103546,
-0.25555840134620667,
-0.20491205155849457,
1.0555657148361206,
-0.1367972493171692,
-0.6776248812675476,
0.2729748487472534,
0.1808302104473114,
0.4781840443611145,
-0.49023666977882385,
-0.08941182494163513,
-0.3594817817211151,
-0.03859349340200424,
-0.3988533020019531,
-0.6855259537696838,
0.7960689067840576,
0.10271194577217102,
-0.377442866563797,
-0.15562793612480164,
1.3792903423309326,
-0.3643817901611328,
-0.32142698764801025,
0.4301241636276245,
0.9700110554695129,
0.31264227628707886,
-0.23921866714954376,
-0.6411345601081848,
-0.06666199862957001,
-0.3611360192298889,
-0.4746474325656891,
0.1739860326051712,
0.6624665856361389,
0.0186882633715868,
0.5194640755653381,
0.8675268292427063,
0.21651260554790497,
0.31268510222435,
0.07195298373699188,
0.9240389466285706,
-0.7320009469985962,
-0.2819841504096985,
-0.8150326013565063,
0.46050411462783813,
-0.2322598397731781,
0.2923924922943115,
0.7505114078521729,
0.7660848498344421,
0.5398330092430115,
0.031091168522834778,
0.47990185022354126,
-0.3351026475429535,
1.151604413986206,
-0.4303946793079376,
0.6486954689025879,
-0.788106381893158,
0.3934866786003113,
-0.411043256521225,
-1.1963316202163696,
-0.37407585978507996,
0.2985462248325348,
0.20455142855644226,
0.29943472146987915,
0.714701235294342,
0.847286581993103,
-0.08501923829317093,
-0.36079859733581543,
0.2783474922180176,
-0.042923469096422195,
0.3262694180011749,
0.029247164726257324,
0.778593122959137,
-0.3971749544143677,
0.8341789245605469,
-0.13503286242485046,
-0.1917545348405838,
-0.13443849980831146,
-1.0596039295196533,
-0.597758412361145,
-0.48261046409606934,
0.1596091240644455,
-0.4536833167076111,
-0.15529504418373108,
0.5679947137832642,
0.5657513737678528,
-0.5224369168281555,
-0.12616559863090515,
0.24176055192947388,
0.4958503246307373,
-0.16847862303256989,
-0.2318163514137268,
0.30591583251953125,
-0.6525834798812866,
-0.5699284076690674,
0.5189585089683533,
0.21650175750255585,
-0.36599040031433105,
-0.010779181495308876,
0.07714691013097763,
-0.7235246896743774,
0.05922308564186096,
0.7469050884246826,
0.015640556812286377,
-0.23266710340976715,
-0.01874302513897419,
0.10310246795415878,
-0.010639974847435951,
0.19352740049362183,
0.9083828926086426,
-0.8266055583953857,
0.502122163772583,
0.6752117872238159,
0.8129215836524963,
0.7941542863845825,
0.302994966506958,
0.0609322264790535,
-1.0476070642471313,
-0.27309751510620117,
0.2637607157230377,
0.3062537908554077,
0.1701529324054718,
-0.39363396167755127,
0.9335533380508423,
0.2858406603336334,
-0.801861584186554,
-0.7812293171882629,
0.2773101031780243,
-0.5725401043891907,
-0.3622044324874878,
1.1083654165267944,
0.34419381618499756,
-0.11461788415908813,
-0.18259908258914948,
-0.3070923686027527,
0.15501101315021515,
-0.01806141808629036,
0.4270702004432678,
0.6095101833343506,
-0.32686179876327515,
-0.3805069029331207,
-0.7891284823417664,
0.5014933943748474,
0.03942367061972618,
-0.9550120830535889,
-0.021385913714766502,
0.5644576549530029,
0.32883307337760925,
0.35720404982566833,
1.0213878154754639,
-0.16706691682338715,
0.3188057243824005,
-0.11439449340105057,
-0.0955500677227974,
0.03907713294029236,
-0.6527909636497498,
-0.052390843629837036,
0.2512962818145752,
0.0676245167851448,
-0.1378624588251114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13195v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13195v1 | Learning Translations via Matrix Completion | 2024-06-19T04:03:19 | 2024-06-19T04:03:19 | Derry Wijaya, Brendan Callahan, John Hewitt, Jie Gao, Xiao Ling, Marianna Apidianaki, Chris Callison-Burch | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Bilingual Lexicon Induction is the task of learning word translations without
bilingual parallel corpora. We model this task as a matrix completion problem,
and present an effective and extendable framework for completing the matrix.
This method harnesses diverse bilingual and monolingual signals, each of which
may be incomplete or noisy. Our model achieves state-of-the-art performance for
both high and low resource languages. | [
-0.4389294683933258,
-0.11392953246831894,
0.5393296480178833,
0.21015387773513794,
-0.23642784357070923,
0.5554883480072021,
-0.4116368293762207,
-0.33136188983917236,
0.4985561668872833,
0.4223006069660187,
-0.8063939809799194,
-0.5233069658279419,
-0.7942458391189575,
0.3869887888431549,
-0.5155490636825562,
1.158930778503418,
-0.4462234377861023,
0.30661776661872864,
-0.32086116075515747,
-0.06247613579034805,
-0.34432610869407654,
-0.08156649768352509,
-0.44135844707489014,
-0.7424300909042358,
0.5015105605125427,
0.6663933396339417,
0.7099738121032715,
0.7594109773635864,
0.3043101727962494,
0.3540998697280884,
-0.19910846650600433,
0.31970110535621643,
-0.6307878494262695,
0.022405169904232025,
-0.2964431345462799,
-0.7440445423126221,
-0.3778097629547119,
0.07034553587436676,
0.821419894695282,
1.5676478147506714,
-0.18023774027824402,
0.1433316171169281,
0.22682860493659973,
0.8257592916488647,
-0.7546915411949158,
0.3982574939727783,
-0.6019396185874939,
0.47638341784477234,
-0.08686619997024536,
-0.2404605746269226,
-0.3048310875892639,
-0.5435295701026917,
0.06697195768356323,
-0.6595516204833984,
0.26099807024002075,
-0.0841536819934845,
0.5972875952720642,
-0.06680003553628922,
-0.6640247702598572,
-0.403285950422287,
-1.0298609733581543,
0.7511085867881775,
-0.015224248170852661,
0.5386077165603638,
0.7436251640319824,
0.0854058787226677,
-0.19002361595630646,
-0.47106295824050903,
-0.6937599778175354,
-0.199835404753685,
-0.19899046421051025,
0.44648000597953796,
0.1735311895608902,
0.28646886348724365,
0.40658870339393616,
0.5741893649101257,
-0.48925456404685974,
-0.18996649980545044,
-0.9126442670822144,
0.09945248067378998,
0.08443086594343185,
0.23500321805477142,
0.5797173380851746,
-0.1620810627937317,
-0.3062424957752228,
0.060204971581697464,
-0.6930978298187256,
0.13915809988975525,
0.49043187499046326,
0.2978546619415283,
-0.3271070718765259,
0.800442636013031,
-0.21476760506629944,
0.7049532532691956,
-0.06647098064422607,
-0.2745390236377716,
0.4771808385848999,
-0.6206345558166504,
0.061449550092220306,
0.2316243201494217,
0.5646359324455261,
-0.24105997383594513,
0.29954415559768677,
-0.6143665313720703,
-0.39973458647727966,
0.13222786784172058,
0.2319427877664566,
-0.2339342087507248,
0.33069178462028503,
0.23619909584522247,
-0.1315140724182129,
0.00785395223647356,
-0.17162683606147766,
-0.5605735182762146,
0.0827944427728653,
-0.772722065448761,
0.38607749342918396,
-0.42114147543907166,
-0.4384210705757141,
0.1510850042104721,
-0.37956172227859497,
0.05574581027030945,
-0.029806053265929222,
-1.2134581804275513,
0.4259205460548401,
0.5526876449584961,
0.9015454053878784,
-0.16335678100585938,
-0.7934961318969727,
-0.5460639595985413,
0.22270241379737854,
-0.7640982866287231,
0.69525146484375,
-0.3651435375213623,
-0.6425737738609314,
0.13721267879009247,
0.009317649528384209,
-0.36418071389198303,
-0.5827257633209229,
0.33336141705513,
-0.5865894556045532,
0.13289834558963776,
-0.5467354655265808,
-0.2810330092906952,
-0.22144697606563568,
0.13096942007541656,
-0.771872878074646,
0.9774841070175171,
0.3977835178375244,
-0.8400182723999023,
0.3388339579105377,
-0.5210280418395996,
-0.6781162023544312,
0.060518328100442886,
0.03762242943048477,
0.20757591724395752,
0.15936627984046936,
0.026941103860735893,
0.12704336643218994,
-0.18415284156799316,
-0.04670938104391098,
0.025571806356310844,
-0.40403062105178833,
-0.12806256115436554,
0.270467072725296,
0.9396559596061707,
0.1317286491394043,
-0.36792895197868347,
-0.012942434288561344,
-0.7470973134040833,
-0.389021098613739,
-0.008330968208611012,
-0.630598247051239,
-0.14646576344966888,
0.10502111166715622,
-0.17466111481189728,
0.31773924827575684,
0.4143703281879425,
-0.6922820210456848,
0.07203458994626999,
-0.6731082797050476,
-0.11448096483945847,
0.34568411111831665,
-0.35732847452163696,
0.9447082281112671,
-0.48154354095458984,
0.7567803859710693,
0.2383657693862915,
-0.09493198990821838,
0.10314997285604477,
-0.573570728302002,
-1.1710197925567627,
-0.3066558241844177,
0.4151412546634674,
1.0627368688583374,
-1.2192710638046265,
0.25765541195869446,
-0.5147436857223511,
-0.4020674526691437,
-0.6048966646194458,
0.8586582541465759,
0.5317094922065735,
0.4172940254211426,
0.5403130054473877,
-0.4315827488899231,
-0.8995946645736694,
-0.9753386378288269,
0.17851747572422028,
-0.028543613851070404,
0.12315491586923599,
-0.3495453894138336,
0.5610124468803406,
-0.2602459788322449,
0.46617379784584045,
0.010320330038666725,
-0.4938652813434601,
-0.7013692259788513,
0.15241780877113342,
0.44222837686538696,
0.37519553303718567,
0.195762038230896,
-0.5658460855484009,
-0.6036040782928467,
0.41220834851264954,
-1.0716642141342163,
0.07938868552446365,
0.10235131531953812,
-0.04017903655767441,
0.0723920464515686,
0.6467750072479248,
-0.5440483093261719,
0.4594595730304718,
0.6592721939086914,
0.13142429292201996,
0.34999552369117737,
-0.4573017954826355,
0.003820079145953059,
-1.202633261680603,
-0.016585757955908775,
-0.4537452459335327,
-0.47362834215164185,
-0.8063943386077881,
0.05341510474681854,
0.1962241530418396,
-0.02997639961540699,
-0.5488373637199402,
0.1655987650156021,
-0.676546573638916,
-0.06883521378040314,
-0.4644736051559448,
0.11767683923244476,
-0.16171671450138092,
0.542778491973877,
0.10974069684743881,
0.5447282791137695,
0.5835664868354797,
-0.6193060874938965,
0.46189233660697937,
0.29820388555526733,
-0.40366020798683167,
0.3526337146759033,
-0.2987443804740906,
-0.30710843205451965,
-0.6444249153137207,
-0.06608594954013824,
-0.9334505796432495,
-0.12748509645462036,
0.05743595212697983,
-0.32891738414764404,
0.4884355068206787,
-0.0660281851887703,
-0.5666089653968811,
-0.3509595990180969,
0.0016055175801739097,
0.667370080947876,
0.5795522332191467,
-0.6684001088142395,
0.5173267126083374,
0.2743373513221741,
-0.08932647854089737,
-0.9026609063148499,
-0.6956853270530701,
-0.041443243622779846,
0.31391018629074097,
-0.21426916122436523,
0.19771134853363037,
0.20471209287643433,
-0.11142273247241974,
0.034447867423295975,
0.19582028687000275,
-0.04385591670870781,
-0.02542424201965332,
0.212712362408638,
0.15629106760025024,
-0.1189103052020073,
-0.10707924515008926,
0.3035443127155304,
-0.17743965983390808,
-0.14402849972248077,
-0.10958515852689743,
0.487594872713089,
0.06440021097660065,
-0.22415758669376373,
-0.4399682283401489,
0.9625733494758606,
0.6510339379310608,
-0.4127940535545349,
0.8092221617698669,
0.6044626235961914,
-0.5949097275733948,
-0.3116682767868042,
-0.39115604758262634,
0.014653236605226994,
-0.43984419107437134,
0.23792961239814758,
-0.5284075736999512,
-0.7269500494003296,
0.7393859028816223,
0.19572541117668152,
-0.10375700145959854,
0.2736218273639679,
0.745370090007782,
0.13516587018966675,
1.2022490501403809,
0.8514300584793091,
0.11585868149995804,
0.3984772861003876,
-0.49031221866607666,
0.20698268711566925,
-0.8330138325691223,
-0.4326476752758026,
-0.3017067313194275,
-0.30475929379463196,
-0.4712555408477783,
-0.3836769759654999,
0.3288217782974243,
0.23434366285800934,
-0.01469348557293415,
0.742156982421875,
-0.1406070590019226,
0.5063372254371643,
0.8349811434745789,
0.0007218242972157896,
0.568271815776825,
0.28260424733161926,
-0.8410571813583374,
0.02040799893438816,
-0.6755425930023193,
-0.11203490197658539,
1.1741582155227661,
0.08203578740358353,
0.4064977467060089,
0.31101611256599426,
0.9981635212898254,
-0.14705049991607666,
0.3574483096599579,
-0.8478454351425171,
0.44182947278022766,
0.10344855487346649,
-0.7059541344642639,
0.05233049392700195,
-0.4518323838710785,
-1.1357442140579224,
0.21262213587760925,
-0.5582901239395142,
-0.7357995510101318,
0.348397433757782,
-0.20714329183101654,
-0.18002310395240784,
0.2721160054206848,
-0.5401735901832581,
0.688575804233551,
0.11374089121818542,
-0.10547331720590591,
-0.49615398049354553,
-0.24032221734523773,
0.6178007125854492,
-0.29592427611351013,
0.3406764566898346,
-0.0114999208599329,
-0.2443837821483612,
0.5542975664138794,
-0.4960702657699585,
0.5595006346702576,
0.04148766025900841,
0.15818247199058533,
0.14755330979824066,
0.28941836953163147,
0.3090566098690033,
-0.05121750384569168,
0.17925846576690674,
0.05517280101776123,
0.17028672993183136,
-0.6310164928436279,
-0.4943522810935974,
0.49565014243125916,
-0.8819034099578857,
-0.45666903257369995,
-0.4964458644390106,
-0.7643793225288391,
-0.18335498869419098,
0.3123883605003357,
0.4756722152233124,
0.2418447732925415,
-0.11891717463731766,
-0.32575350999832153,
0.520867109298706,
0.032056406140327454,
0.37549835443496704,
0.39231908321380615,
-0.5572324395179749,
-0.4403136968612671,
0.97298663854599,
0.3235076665878296,
0.21361711621284485,
0.3849595785140991,
-0.3150885999202728,
-0.25451427698135376,
-0.5573505163192749,
-0.43065884709358215,
0.4950024485588074,
-0.890644907951355,
0.05774880573153496,
-0.7420941591262817,
-0.4569840133190155,
-0.3221055567264557,
-0.17175495624542236,
-0.4513404965400696,
-0.40954846143722534,
-0.13869734108448029,
-0.3012695908546448,
-0.20885276794433594,
1.0331742763519287,
-0.5629273056983948,
0.26415351033210754,
-0.7722140550613403,
0.6915303468704224,
0.5895313024520874,
0.2525448203086853,
0.041222140192985535,
-0.24578917026519775,
-0.5433356165885925,
0.11044866591691971,
-0.21799859404563904,
-1.078590989112854,
0.37230056524276733,
0.18791604042053223,
0.6831952333450317,
0.39776432514190674,
-0.28662559390068054,
0.4917411804199219,
-0.9192649126052856,
0.5357745885848999,
0.43483561277389526,
-1.0868546962738037,
0.45731663703918457,
-0.4195270836353302,
0.3416644036769867,
0.6307531595230103,
0.8498687148094177,
-0.604426383972168,
-0.5174717307090759,
-0.36370009183883667,
-0.7422859072685242,
0.6294987201690674,
0.2505952715873718,
-0.06770256906747818,
-0.5099856853485107,
0.16368326544761658,
-0.012298439629375935,
0.08749505132436752,
-0.5427191257476807,
-0.20851823687553406,
-0.08473525941371918,
-0.11113663762807846,
-0.463724285364151,
-0.2724384665489197,
-0.20854559540748596,
-0.6451075077056885,
0.7596153616905212,
0.0342368558049202,
0.26411914825439453,
0.18186205625534058,
-0.5926898121833801,
-0.41879573464393616,
0.15865547955036163,
0.752773642539978,
0.98269122838974,
-0.25855037569999695,
0.058120645582675934,
0.48449277877807617,
-0.4121471643447876,
0.2783835828304291,
-0.08605016022920609,
0.06606589257717133,
0.36143553256988525,
0.3901142179965973,
0.6678575873374939,
0.3399851322174072,
-0.586422324180603,
0.6983560919761658,
-0.1251833140850067,
-0.42675480246543884,
-0.6358510255813599,
-0.24326319992542267,
0.29969751834869385,
0.03185512125492096,
0.3582373857498169,
-0.028211114928126335,
0.06834378093481064,
-0.5271866321563721,
0.07718924432992935,
0.3806087076663971,
-0.633759081363678,
-0.3363659381866455,
0.7173277735710144,
-0.10093478858470917,
-0.10598535090684891,
0.6395991444587708,
-0.48053309321403503,
-0.6901174187660217,
0.542937159538269,
0.692734956741333,
0.7074558734893799,
-0.21612390875816345,
0.23506970703601837,
0.5733434557914734,
0.5245232582092285,
-0.43394193053245544,
0.6308879852294922,
-0.3751715421676636,
-0.9004433155059814,
-0.8406816720962524,
-0.7855087518692017,
-0.5180079936981201,
-0.2009558081626892,
-0.8589012622833252,
0.28250208497047424,
-0.4631180465221405,
-0.21636255085468292,
-0.02447977475821972,
-0.2501841187477112,
-0.8428173065185547,
-0.1983252465724945,
0.5634320974349976,
0.8731303811073303,
-0.922252893447876,
1.0577093362808228,
0.7825952768325806,
-0.45844414830207825,
-0.6850060820579529,
-0.696267306804657,
-0.020334601402282715,
-0.7842166423797607,
0.9664918780326843,
0.03223523497581482,
-0.034364279359579086,
-0.08411705493927002,
0.06911081820726395,
-1.0390369892120361,
0.7088119387626648,
0.6289415955543518,
-0.16242308914661407,
-0.1795782595872879,
0.5967362523078918,
0.42656758427619934,
-0.2131931036710739,
0.10972759872674942,
0.723141610622406,
0.4223666787147522,
0.021242819726467133,
-1.3086974620819092,
-0.22023151814937592,
-0.3037511110305786,
0.15303097665309906,
0.32039499282836914,
-0.07650305330753326,
0.8570696115493774,
-0.0670742392539978,
-0.21589289605617523,
0.10459791868925095,
0.8041820526123047,
-0.11772935837507248,
-0.12243036925792694,
0.49009594321250916,
0.7877627015113831,
0.7135518193244934,
0.03238034248352051,
1.0868403911590576,
-0.6307894587516785,
0.3397858142852783,
1.0156358480453491,
-0.10554930567741394,
0.824746310710907,
0.4816432595252991,
-0.14724388718605042,
0.6802871823310852,
0.6062702536582947,
0.3833268880844116,
0.3613570034503937,
0.06855782866477966,
-0.616804838180542,
-0.506016194820404,
-0.33686909079551697,
-0.3653508424758911,
0.6446773409843445,
0.5956757068634033,
-0.3800647258758545,
-0.6253626346588135,
0.30545634031295776,
-0.1486644148826599,
0.2815656065940857,
-0.6176961660385132,
0.7251774072647095,
0.2734294831752777,
-0.9808957576751709,
0.9071725606918335,
0.06995411962270737,
0.5456292033195496,
-0.5879989862442017,
0.015960194170475006,
-0.3852417469024658,
0.26538750529289246,
-0.40533164143562317,
-0.37595608830451965,
0.6976784467697144,
-0.2843429148197174,
-0.5181697010993958,
-0.3000781834125519,
0.20250321924686432,
-0.9156720638275146,
-0.7141237258911133,
0.8096376657485962,
0.8775414228439331,
0.14110799133777618,
0.24076519906520844,
-0.4415276050567627,
-0.4778122305870056,
-0.1736663281917572,
0.08489169180393219,
0.20173576474189758,
0.041859500110149384,
0.17799171805381775,
0.6104813814163208,
0.5474749207496643,
0.3525922894477844,
0.4276241362094879,
-0.22781503200531006,
0.5627177953720093,
-0.47514548897743225,
-0.35144466161727905,
-0.6827085614204407,
0.20151886343955994,
0.26737111806869507,
0.01662093587219715,
0.6611130237579346,
0.7588168382644653,
1.146525263786316,
-0.20777399837970734,
0.6641279458999634,
0.24484720826148987,
0.5846893787384033,
-0.25542017817497253,
0.7023479342460632,
-0.6378467082977295,
-0.12887518107891083,
0.022792724892497063,
-1.066218376159668,
-0.28571805357933044,
0.482021301984787,
-0.33276015520095825,
-0.3966808617115021,
1.234544038772583,
0.9014096856117249,
-0.28646671772003174,
-0.03890222683548927,
0.5167845487594604,
-0.17614592611789703,
-0.3149951696395874,
0.9777292013168335,
0.9480414986610413,
-0.5057187676429749,
0.655494749546051,
-0.46431615948677063,
-0.26468002796173096,
0.35127753019332886,
-0.4629541039466858,
-1.0917991399765015,
-0.8766910433769226,
-0.18635034561157227,
-0.7783461213111877,
-0.1624433994293213,
1.1920987367630005,
0.5830003023147583,
-0.8548605442047119,
-0.7552010416984558,
0.02063143439590931,
0.6860129833221436,
-0.4169680178165436,
-0.10569095611572266,
0.21225160360336304,
-0.9394695162773132,
-1.1562187671661377,
0.5927319526672363,
0.2884673774242401,
-0.11364404112100601,
-0.17245365679264069,
0.04115917906165123,
-0.5273514986038208,
0.06876461952924728,
0.474076509475708,
0.6446732878684998,
-0.345141738653183,
0.07538536936044693,
-0.21377699077129364,
-0.24639755487442017,
0.21879617869853973,
0.7444750070571899,
-0.7801885008811951,
0.6835237145423889,
0.7614001035690308,
0.6597493290901184,
0.6726035475730896,
-0.6735928058624268,
0.7179113030433655,
-0.7441038489341736,
0.5499223470687866,
-0.07722117751836777,
0.7433747053146362,
0.41095203161239624,
-0.07374821603298187,
0.2544238269329071,
0.48858699202537537,
-0.06883526593446732,
-0.6372129321098328,
0.3017279803752899,
-0.9941551089286804,
0.030595283955335617,
1.203595757484436,
-0.021996401250362396,
-0.5779964327812195,
-0.47635406255722046,
0.21169313788414001,
0.5380508899688721,
0.16491517424583435,
0.4269883334636688,
0.6794277429580688,
0.44485852122306824,
-0.022153494879603386,
-0.8141352534294128,
0.6083515882492065,
0.536078691482544,
-0.15340901911258698,
-0.5216225385665894,
0.0004798595909960568,
0.35752832889556885,
0.42188724875450134,
0.6792461276054382,
-0.10092219710350037,
0.6682082414627075,
-0.01400773972272873,
0.5256336331367493,
0.16955800354480743,
-0.39630573987960815,
-0.3049982190132141,
0.2788756191730499,
0.23663419485092163,
-0.03836342319846153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13193v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13193v1 | PRESTO: Progressive Pretraining Enhances Synthetic Chemistry Outcomes | 2024-06-19T03:59:46 | 2024-06-19T03:59:46 | He Cao, Yanjun Shao, Zhiyuan Liu, Zijing Liu, Xiangru Tang, Yuan Yao, Yu Li | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, physics.chem-ph | Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have seen growing adoption across
various scientific disciplines. These advancements encourage the investigation
of molecule-text modeling within synthetic chemistry, a field dedicated to
designing and conducting chemical reactions to synthesize new compounds with
desired properties and applications. Current approaches, however, often neglect
the critical role of multiple molecule graph interaction in understanding
chemical reactions, leading to suboptimal performance in synthetic chemistry
tasks. This study introduces PRESTO(Progressive Pretraining Enhances Synthetic
Chemistry Outcomes), a new framework that bridges the molecule-text modality
gap by integrating a comprehensive benchmark of pretraining strategies and
dataset configurations. It progressively improves multimodal LLMs through
cross-modal alignment and multi-graph understanding. Our extensive experiments
demonstrate that PRESTO offers competitive results in downstream synthetic
chemistry tasks. The code can be found at https://github.com/IDEA-XL/PRESTO. | [
-0.33715012669563293,
-0.854722261428833,
0.8973848819732666,
0.15805000066757202,
-0.13389866054058075,
0.5290107131004333,
-0.31330856680870056,
-0.1911551058292389,
0.16918043792247772,
0.3421802222728729,
-0.7275287508964539,
-0.6025959253311157,
-0.4133894443511963,
0.3892521262168884,
-0.21117696166038513,
0.9629552960395813,
-0.37896260619163513,
0.11664651334285736,
-0.43099862337112427,
0.26324597001075745,
-0.08444273471832275,
-0.6156266331672668,
-0.4291141927242279,
-0.23846469819545746,
0.9599955081939697,
-0.01524310652166605,
0.3371216654777527,
0.1499360054731369,
0.6330621838569641,
0.4583960771560669,
0.1798200011253357,
0.10519857704639435,
-0.5996968150138855,
0.4454312026500702,
0.1608252227306366,
-0.2573430836200714,
-0.9632967710494995,
0.3094085156917572,
0.7184950709342957,
0.5812109112739563,
0.04973626136779785,
-0.18356697261333466,
0.11507309228181839,
0.7029913663864136,
-0.7121606469154358,
0.14248929917812347,
-0.31423914432525635,
0.009936068207025528,
-0.43719902634620667,
0.05212569236755371,
-0.41435396671295166,
-0.21334564685821533,
0.24494189023971558,
-1.121161699295044,
0.09210128337144852,
-0.2262999713420868,
0.5240962505340576,
0.2152092605829239,
-0.6577085256576538,
-0.16390056908130646,
-0.5989466905593872,
0.4831780791282654,
-0.4918108284473419,
0.8052093982696533,
-0.18195511400699615,
0.47936898469924927,
-0.3203168511390686,
-1.500859022140503,
-0.8949418663978577,
-0.3223387897014618,
0.009061590768396854,
0.2982477843761444,
0.2049761414527893,
0.5203256011009216,
-0.06175554543733597,
0.2154216468334198,
-0.7392212748527527,
-0.25117629766464233,
-0.10068441927433014,
-0.3820420801639557,
0.153745636343956,
0.18220791220664978,
0.03512899577617645,
0.28175124526023865,
-0.5497745275497437,
-0.23102311789989471,
-0.6344163417816162,
-0.008504828438162804,
0.2544202506542206,
0.5160737633705139,
0.11582192033529282,
0.6980809569358826,
0.04105573520064354,
0.852107048034668,
-0.35032919049263,
0.14013464748859406,
0.5001146793365479,
-1.094775915145874,
-0.241344153881073,
-0.008119246922433376,
0.9272834658622742,
-0.09238295257091522,
0.3410037159919739,
0.003196307457983494,
-0.14710122346878052,
0.10439105331897736,
0.4078574478626251,
-1.165093183517456,
-0.27416107058525085,
0.06071940436959267,
-0.0955817922949791,
-0.1435997188091278,
0.15579037368297577,
-0.8962436318397522,
-0.005640271585434675,
-0.6109175086021423,
0.7283980250358582,
-0.3988853394985199,
-0.20161397755146027,
-0.0403633639216423,
-0.2897239029407501,
-0.3339077830314636,
0.333341121673584,
-0.6371367573738098,
0.07310326397418976,
0.576280951499939,
0.8630955815315247,
-0.24155230820178986,
-0.5165770649909973,
-0.4092089831829071,
0.06775981932878494,
-0.22351807355880737,
0.7402801513671875,
-0.8806528449058533,
-0.5866572260856628,
-0.29761654138565063,
0.0014254925772547722,
-0.2693682610988617,
-0.4202840030193329,
0.08305449783802032,
-0.5492995977401733,
0.2653111219406128,
0.07042529433965683,
-0.4085794687271118,
0.18461911380290985,
0.2956956624984741,
-0.6368594765663147,
0.8783971071243286,
0.1276484727859497,
-0.3593509793281555,
0.32462865114212036,
-0.7833622097969055,
-0.4520706832408905,
-0.26554009318351746,
-0.15783660113811493,
-0.4823491871356964,
0.16722902655601501,
-0.1833546906709671,
0.08003203570842743,
-0.012246399186551571,
0.03310823068022728,
-0.3626132607460022,
-0.1713505983352661,
0.4969126880168915,
-0.21036297082901,
0.2358340620994568,
0.17368091642856598,
0.026997506618499756,
0.8242237567901611,
-0.7666398286819458,
0.1780133992433548,
-0.37517255544662476,
-0.4865553081035614,
-0.06901562958955765,
-0.3750856816768646,
0.15178468823432922,
0.41635239124298096,
0.2697352170944214,
-0.29463106393814087,
0.29953017830848694,
-0.01966405101120472,
0.5276699066162109,
0.8863011002540588,
-0.11410887539386749,
0.5459900498390198,
0.12848471105098724,
0.6543369889259338,
-0.13646063208580017,
0.3293060064315796,
-0.3011803925037384,
-0.26794639229774475,
-0.49024200439453125,
-0.5895662307739258,
0.4396478533744812,
0.22802329063415527,
-0.8473021984100342,
0.3340623378753662,
-0.278602659702301,
-0.5328563451766968,
-0.07069802284240723,
0.3179607689380646,
0.5260522961616516,
0.7299655079841614,
0.5890933871269226,
-0.36795762181282043,
-0.6784689426422119,
-0.6214932799339294,
-0.3763936758041382,
-0.05836469307541847,
-0.06584470719099045,
-0.12351208180189133,
0.5244012475013733,
-0.6516914367675781,
1.124174952507019,
-0.32881224155426025,
-0.3105834424495697,
-0.29094263911247253,
0.2522105276584625,
0.16464394330978394,
0.4101676642894745,
0.2506251037120819,
-0.8894348740577698,
-0.70887690782547,
-0.25397518277168274,
-0.46131712198257446,
-0.09368971735239029,
0.17928387224674225,
-0.6313797235488892,
-0.012780290096998215,
0.5832234621047974,
-0.734994649887085,
0.06696655601263046,
0.7766829133033752,
-0.43117964267730713,
0.6233233213424683,
-0.03381633013486862,
0.11877816170454025,
-0.9170494079589844,
0.13751548528671265,
-0.2184755951166153,
-0.2775983214378357,
-0.7391555905342102,
-0.35900333523750305,
-0.08803165704011917,
-0.2673894464969635,
-0.8021451234817505,
0.5560521483421326,
-0.29210004210472107,
0.0644315704703331,
-0.14485931396484375,
0.048452477902173996,
0.34238967299461365,
0.1401701718568802,
0.23655274510383606,
1.005496621131897,
0.32586002349853516,
-0.557965099811554,
0.020170630887150764,
0.14929361641407013,
-0.10797346383333206,
0.19879408180713654,
-0.6478778123855591,
0.20357511937618256,
0.13101820647716522,
0.5644436478614807,
-1.0059422254562378,
-0.24831785261631012,
0.01982947438955307,
-0.35496413707733154,
0.5448533296585083,
0.06989386677742004,
-0.16022849082946777,
-0.19878029823303223,
-0.27991169691085815,
0.6523030400276184,
0.2723296582698822,
-0.0013812970137223601,
1.2338173389434814,
0.07376990467309952,
-0.09649313241243362,
-0.46519407629966736,
-0.3558429479598999,
-0.2835666537284851,
-0.14382508397102356,
-0.3689095079898834,
0.582237184047699,
-0.22309550642967224,
-0.02446051873266697,
-0.13871777057647705,
-0.2919975221157074,
-0.10413973033428192,
-0.1952107697725296,
0.00928137544542551,
0.323355495929718,
-0.08916039764881134,
0.26968690752983093,
-0.1847991645336151,
-0.3696107864379883,
-0.059262536466121674,
-0.4233311414718628,
0.8572293519973755,
-0.0810943990945816,
0.08428329229354858,
-0.4845596253871918,
0.1475372612476349,
0.831155002117157,
-0.5053080916404724,
0.8293036818504333,
0.7394517064094543,
0.07418239861726761,
0.12367162853479385,
-0.08636016398668289,
-0.3748352527618408,
-0.5650464296340942,
0.5642113089561462,
-0.5235320329666138,
-0.5905179977416992,
0.15264861285686493,
-0.444574773311615,
-0.3509575426578522,
0.10441745817661285,
0.560375452041626,
-0.2806449830532074,
0.8353580236434937,
0.5951292514801025,
0.6602435111999512,
0.8615150451660156,
-0.17105135321617126,
0.3312866985797882,
-0.8833042979240417,
-0.4815300405025482,
-0.2357986867427826,
-0.24347171187400818,
-0.4704495370388031,
-0.7042930126190186,
0.7776204943656921,
0.3704524040222168,
-0.5971356630325317,
0.27789193391799927,
-0.27839213609695435,
0.37084445357322693,
0.3464967906475067,
0.2246684730052948,
0.2529977858066559,
0.01034880243241787,
-0.28698769211769104,
-0.12858174741268158,
-0.5247317552566528,
-0.42204761505126953,
1.3300081491470337,
0.027542270720005035,
0.7660744190216064,
0.15526245534420013,
0.7018596529960632,
0.05226520076394081,
0.5190346240997314,
-0.5387361645698547,
0.5586487054824829,
-0.17047765851020813,
-0.7462769746780396,
-0.44858893752098083,
-0.6191319823265076,
-0.925070583820343,
0.20106995105743408,
-0.5613783001899719,
-0.2453301101922989,
-0.0667969137430191,
0.3946476876735687,
-0.16649432480335236,
-0.22824642062187195,
-0.6604922413825989,
1.3664121627807617,
-0.6059075593948364,
-0.6523746252059937,
-0.11273931711912155,
-0.6815204620361328,
0.027950309216976166,
-0.4729079008102417,
0.23294100165367126,
-0.08002549409866333,
-0.25037652254104614,
0.48530247807502747,
-0.5015283823013306,
0.5426422953605652,
-0.10015751421451569,
0.07293172925710678,
0.17188334465026855,
0.006843515206128359,
0.35322263836860657,
-0.03395171836018562,
0.07176948338747025,
0.09026297926902771,
-0.15211451053619385,
-0.41091641783714294,
-0.7125861048698425,
0.45942533016204834,
-0.46642112731933594,
-0.41604599356651306,
-0.1852516531944275,
-0.41699010133743286,
-0.39785128831863403,
0.6689608097076416,
0.4637850224971771,
0.2081376612186432,
-0.33861294388771057,
0.042751800268888474,
0.397452712059021,
-0.10761456191539764,
0.30807173252105713,
0.4081985652446747,
-0.6357446312904358,
-0.6250067353248596,
0.7460723519325256,
-0.011042896658182144,
0.4863353967666626,
0.5390697121620178,
-0.023085476830601692,
-0.6621319055557251,
-0.5182681083679199,
-0.15466034412384033,
0.05001815780997276,
-0.6422750949859619,
0.05215436592698097,
-0.5472424030303955,
0.07884108275175095,
-0.4529047906398773,
-0.08489156514406204,
-0.6956272721290588,
-0.38244062662124634,
-0.08924861997365952,
-0.072664275765419,
0.031002387404441833,
0.4478757679462433,
0.05031142011284828,
0.3226184844970703,
-0.9175289273262024,
0.3287840485572815,
0.4789213240146637,
0.20654737949371338,
-0.34979143738746643,
-0.038130927830934525,
-0.1454503983259201,
0.009383043274283409,
-0.3664821982383728,
-0.8049812316894531,
0.11565180122852325,
0.45556002855300903,
0.6143835186958313,
0.050209492444992065,
-0.22857417166233063,
0.6735409498214722,
-0.6870114207267761,
0.5772249698638916,
0.3716934621334076,
-1.122715950012207,
0.602635383605957,
-0.3219107389450073,
0.2245490550994873,
0.7088096737861633,
0.6660912036895752,
-0.22278724610805511,
-0.05870346352458,
0.03943049907684326,
-1.1399338245391846,
0.020629340782761574,
0.4147217273712158,
0.02167823165655136,
-0.10765765607357025,
0.17807886004447937,
0.148328959941864,
0.5772165656089783,
-0.8002811670303345,
-0.021485785022377968,
-0.5392733812332153,
-0.49297234416007996,
-0.48839038610458374,
0.16629323363304138,
-0.11907631158828735,
-0.42835691571235657,
0.5963631868362427,
-0.12854154407978058,
0.2645670473575592,
0.12974439561367035,
-0.3511216938495636,
0.3335350453853607,
0.19706258177757263,
0.6266217231750488,
0.8343164324760437,
-0.15772436559200287,
0.22757470607757568,
-0.15888158977031708,
-0.6332057118415833,
0.4487532079219818,
0.28653761744499207,
0.3867722153663635,
-0.16016533970832825,
0.7148016691207886,
0.65854412317276,
0.0678003653883934,
-0.7307336926460266,
0.2502163052558899,
-0.10573479533195496,
0.018228910863399506,
-0.0684838742017746,
0.10488049685955048,
-0.02023722231388092,
0.3172820508480072,
0.3519534468650818,
0.07331628352403641,
-0.026954438537359238,
-0.7765564918518066,
0.24244482815265656,
0.29139387607574463,
-0.38759225606918335,
-0.43078264594078064,
0.7870200276374817,
0.4657174050807953,
-0.1346786767244339,
0.7987275719642639,
0.18448886275291443,
-0.6400669813156128,
0.38719677925109863,
0.41376662254333496,
0.6407040357589722,
-0.3543106019496918,
0.07032060623168945,
0.14562062919139862,
-0.15441428124904633,
0.15191376209259033,
0.25647684931755066,
-0.2264566719532013,
-0.6414887309074402,
-0.4561336040496826,
-0.6862543225288391,
-0.16742199659347534,
-0.29725876450538635,
-0.2922213673591614,
0.2540631592273712,
-0.3502792418003082,
-0.6376937031745911,
0.007716494612395763,
-0.22152401506900787,
-0.686805784702301,
0.08345124125480652,
0.05884157493710518,
0.6892557740211487,
-0.7275932431221008,
0.9200093150138855,
0.7211733460426331,
-0.48732614517211914,
-0.3487820327281952,
0.022059837356209755,
0.11860807985067368,
-0.30816590785980225,
0.9630709290504456,
0.43020349740982056,
-0.4159705340862274,
0.18520495295524597,
-0.039045728743076324,
-0.7530105710029602,
1.0225093364715576,
0.4018140435218811,
-0.903160810470581,
-0.1962277740240097,
0.35009363293647766,
0.6805425882339478,
-0.3679991364479065,
0.3262907862663269,
0.5171146392822266,
0.8352577686309814,
0.048418961465358734,
-0.9314754605293274,
-0.07819824665784836,
-0.21545346081256866,
-0.16100020706653595,
0.32330521941185,
-0.4804914593696594,
1.168526291847229,
-0.017364919185638428,
-0.11680831760168076,
0.014050878584384918,
0.3366619348526001,
0.5500825643539429,
0.3888365626335144,
0.33690765500068665,
0.5784436464309692,
0.5954991579055786,
-0.36028191447257996,
0.9437488317489624,
-0.27561792731285095,
0.23371578752994537,
0.9831979870796204,
-0.45765548944473267,
0.7233534455299377,
0.64520663022995,
-0.48739925026893616,
0.7680255770683289,
0.7690021991729736,
0.40530744194984436,
0.7253828048706055,
0.26190438866615295,
-0.5410324931144714,
-0.5462016463279724,
0.07463138550519943,
-0.5734832882881165,
0.3708074390888214,
0.3364725410938263,
-0.32907748222351074,
-0.033491071313619614,
0.3206264078617096,
-0.19099114835262299,
-0.006419534329324961,
-0.19590742886066437,
0.4952479600906372,
-0.033548519015312195,
-0.5318471193313599,
0.48369067907333374,
-0.5412441492080688,
0.5002864003181458,
-0.9324243664741516,
-0.11522414535284042,
-0.042858850210905075,
0.4207412302494049,
0.025968939065933228,
-0.6377962827682495,
0.16719211637973785,
-0.2759210169315338,
-0.22561082243919373,
-0.3746171295642853,
0.3650495409965515,
-0.5097130537033081,
-0.41162267327308655,
0.43984344601631165,
0.5138055682182312,
-0.18283580243587494,
-0.21081270277500153,
-0.6064881682395935,
0.3451794385910034,
-0.30185744166374207,
-0.5612857937812805,
0.26219847798347473,
0.28601357340812683,
-0.016410991549491882,
0.4269627630710602,
0.9216833710670471,
-0.25927698612213135,
0.1966371089220047,
0.12652133405208588,
1.1745926141738892,
-0.5859972238540649,
-0.3254730999469757,
-0.9171828031539917,
0.7198426127433777,
0.0745183452963829,
-0.2189558893442154,
0.718209981918335,
0.9446282982826233,
0.8651073575019836,
-0.22961223125457764,
0.5871657729148865,
0.20638857781887054,
0.10650842636823654,
-0.8873528242111206,
0.3918301463127136,
-0.49849051237106323,
0.10047394782304764,
-0.2778431475162506,
-1.3098114728927612,
-0.3558505177497864,
0.5161413550376892,
-0.27536651492118835,
0.39376920461654663,
0.8885701298713684,
0.7019453048706055,
-0.04646649584174156,
-0.38315826654434204,
0.0007836323347873986,
0.30024680495262146,
0.620275616645813,
0.4989263415336609,
1.024969458580017,
-0.04082852602005005,
0.5723826289176941,
0.11834392696619034,
0.025903303176164627,
0.12618088722229004,
-0.880914568901062,
-0.974822998046875,
-0.4826469123363495,
0.12243551015853882,
-0.34104225039482117,
0.13044628500938416,
0.7901931405067444,
0.9402728080749512,
-0.4794366955757141,
-0.14438225328922272,
-0.6258429884910583,
-0.18986432254314423,
0.12304505705833435,
-0.24252130091190338,
0.17820768058300018,
-0.49996674060821533,
-0.8500088453292847,
0.7573699355125427,
0.356076717376709,
0.4839748442173004,
-0.17997689545154572,
-0.32241714000701904,
-0.19602070748806,
0.007133184466511011,
0.7193774580955505,
0.14352647960186005,
-0.3911491930484772,
0.2703612744808197,
0.11648956686258316,
0.1321413666009903,
0.21242092549800873,
1.235061526298523,
-0.9738203883171082,
0.7389424443244934,
0.6879348158836365,
0.3660620450973511,
1.0598417520523071,
-0.005817863158881664,
0.8980367183685303,
-0.7988148331642151,
0.3143296241760254,
0.24461209774017334,
0.07185396552085876,
0.20237931609153748,
0.12335651367902756,
0.483601450920105,
0.3675188720226288,
-0.4445429742336273,
-0.8169626593589783,
0.33500900864601135,
-0.8175485730171204,
-0.6440133452415466,
0.6446901559829712,
-0.16732241213321686,
-0.18087442219257355,
0.04339217394590378,
-0.007820640690624714,
0.5095375776290894,
-0.316712349653244,
0.40190669894218445,
0.7428597211837769,
-0.6235830187797546,
0.008371247909963131,
-0.3753688931465149,
0.6383912563323975,
0.4042549729347229,
-0.9391603469848633,
-0.1248813271522522,
0.5752422213554382,
0.20655542612075806,
0.26502683758735657,
0.6624124050140381,
-0.03367859497666359,
0.04507851600646973,
-0.07896198332309723,
-0.07529374212026596,
-0.48879173398017883,
-0.8667359352111816,
0.03712151572108269,
-0.0421362966299057,
-0.2498893439769745,
0.06196672096848488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13188v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13188v1 | Synthetic Context Generation for Question Generation | 2024-06-19T03:37:52 | 2024-06-19T03:37:52 | Naiming Liu, Zichao Wang, Richard Baraniuk | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Despite rapid advancements in large language models (LLMs), QG remains a
challenging problem due to its complicated process, open-ended nature, and the
diverse settings in which question generation occurs. A common approach to
address these challenges involves fine-tuning smaller, custom models using
datasets containing background context, question, and answer. However,
obtaining suitable domain-specific datasets with appropriate context is often
more difficult than acquiring question-answer pairs. In this paper, we
investigate training QG models using synthetic contexts generated by LLMs from
readily available question-answer pairs. We conduct a comprehensive study to
answer critical research questions related to the performance of models trained
on synthetic contexts and their potential impact on QG research and
applications. Our empirical results reveal: 1) contexts are essential for QG
tasks, even if they are synthetic; 2) fine-tuning smaller language models has
the capability of achieving better performances as compared to prompting larger
language models; and 3) synthetic context and real context could achieve
comparable performances. These findings highlight the effectiveness of
synthetic contexts in QG and paves the way for future advancements in the
field. | [
-0.6023193001747131,
-1.1255792379379272,
0.7019553780555725,
-0.14747385680675507,
-0.2342505007982254,
-0.12076424807310104,
-0.32162225246429443,
-0.49664339423179626,
-0.306072473526001,
0.45499470829963684,
-0.8368010520935059,
-0.1831398606300354,
-0.14524301886558533,
0.3980030119419098,
-0.3239865005016327,
0.85479736328125,
0.04699772596359253,
0.13771787285804749,
-0.43131881952285767,
-0.21306215226650238,
-0.6227602362632751,
-0.5473695397377014,
-0.7285992503166199,
-0.24351809918880463,
0.41261303424835205,
0.34028664231300354,
0.32657939195632935,
0.2579200267791748,
-0.10170822590589523,
0.2709461450576782,
0.007298328448086977,
0.5126941204071045,
-0.5935301780700684,
0.4672645628452301,
-0.15992984175682068,
-0.43235325813293457,
-0.07649555057287216,
0.11947198212146759,
0.766406238079071,
0.5673009157180786,
-0.017239443957805634,
0.3894864022731781,
0.05477133020758629,
0.4029991328716278,
-0.36163583397865295,
-0.10746271163225174,
-0.9761096239089966,
0.04315033182501793,
0.15286442637443542,
-0.45131564140319824,
-0.22560425102710724,
-0.39229997992515564,
0.3167867064476013,
-0.6683781743049622,
0.530051589012146,
0.15685763955116272,
0.5338751673698425,
0.05100088194012642,
-0.6589891314506531,
-0.2989861071109772,
-0.818230152130127,
0.645602822303772,
-0.6713531017303467,
0.3019505441188812,
0.13599175214767456,
0.4759572148323059,
-0.3364191949367523,
-0.9248260259628296,
-0.7542927861213684,
-0.02599487639963627,
-0.10149360448122025,
0.12446178495883942,
0.2752211093902588,
0.006925660185515881,
0.4381498396396637,
0.23595808446407318,
-0.561905562877655,
-0.18649189174175262,
-0.4729255139827728,
0.04535384848713875,
0.6248806118965149,
0.478605180978775,
0.26542899012565613,
-0.18684303760528564,
-0.15111568570137024,
-0.1314377337694168,
-1.0238975286483765,
0.14979030191898346,
0.13698223233222961,
0.42497479915618896,
0.04317989945411682,
0.4363771677017212,
-0.4104219973087311,
0.8719267249107361,
0.2243189811706543,
-0.02030087262392044,
-0.2989058494567871,
-0.5551031827926636,
-0.13282513618469238,
-0.1436898410320282,
0.4709256589412689,
0.2721763551235199,
0.3513489067554474,
-0.14113113284111023,
-0.14078842103481293,
-0.22348417341709137,
0.4040687382221222,
-0.8629558682441711,
-0.1049792543053627,
0.28878268599510193,
0.1576354205608368,
-0.18978403508663177,
-0.16621315479278564,
-0.30691444873809814,
-0.07477139681577682,
-0.7226423025131226,
0.41849663853645325,
-0.29364150762557983,
-0.15503303706645966,
-0.031370699405670166,
-0.14634281396865845,
0.5220439434051514,
0.38510945439338684,
-0.9570295810699463,
0.02267281711101532,
0.5734914541244507,
0.4699198603630066,
-0.18534110486507416,
-0.07482823729515076,
-0.4783807396888733,
0.236655130982399,
-0.4059358239173889,
0.733393132686615,
-0.5266247987747192,
-0.5484619736671448,
0.1724727302789688,
0.1747245192527771,
-0.22148647904396057,
-0.7414449453353882,
0.20122773945331573,
-0.7337953448295593,
0.4796084463596344,
-0.4465961158275604,
-0.6306801438331604,
0.054652389138936996,
0.6309065222740173,
-0.43975478410720825,
1.0814839601516724,
0.28940749168395996,
-0.642239511013031,
0.31900063157081604,
-0.27772432565689087,
-0.42412349581718445,
0.2981575131416321,
-0.49656036496162415,
-0.23059412837028503,
0.17970183491706848,
0.2448388636112213,
0.34253111481666565,
-0.48147454857826233,
0.32826346158981323,
0.0754932165145874,
-0.40196493268013,
0.44229650497436523,
-0.1368662714958191,
0.3710598349571228,
0.047929733991622925,
-0.20080474019050598,
0.11368222534656525,
-0.7791671752929688,
0.6124305129051208,
0.1402076929807663,
-0.4971955418586731,
-0.29186975955963135,
-0.09749434143304825,
-0.006001450587064028,
0.33229711651802063,
0.08324366062879562,
-0.39950281381607056,
0.08968857675790787,
-0.413473516702652,
0.5596006512641907,
0.5617677569389343,
0.37323907017707825,
0.387553334236145,
-0.40324947237968445,
0.8301730751991272,
-0.07435640692710876,
-0.1545499861240387,
-0.041655782610177994,
-0.4794268012046814,
-0.47609972953796387,
0.2553630471229553,
0.5242863893508911,
0.33232638239860535,
-0.9130616188049316,
0.07265686243772507,
0.030488483607769012,
-0.429556667804718,
-0.34927237033843994,
0.008939500898122787,
0.2802441418170929,
0.7587087750434875,
0.24930068850517273,
0.20208440721035004,
-0.7372462153434753,
-0.8836454749107361,
-0.34107667207717896,
-0.014036589302122593,
-0.049108706414699554,
0.7917771339416504,
0.4622771441936493,
-0.07368917763233185,
1.2964526414871216,
-0.6568827033042908,
0.23862609267234802,
-0.43001607060432434,
0.01642981916666031,
-0.11281484365463257,
0.6263560056686401,
0.47539249062538147,
-0.9471470713615417,
-0.45266592502593994,
-0.16487738490104675,
-0.602430522441864,
-0.0625062882900238,
-0.10730456560850143,
-0.2688881754875183,
-0.02812120132148266,
0.6151391267776489,
-0.5790573954582214,
-0.23764444887638092,
0.6554065942764282,
-0.005983928684145212,
0.8041025400161743,
-0.13827919960021973,
0.12998507916927338,
-1.370902180671692,
0.1918431669473648,
-0.11345386505126953,
-0.3020016849040985,
-0.932744026184082,
0.24382613599300385,
0.06043052673339844,
-0.3377929925918579,
-0.5926584601402283,
0.8471188545227051,
-0.16138902306556702,
0.15931540727615356,
-0.10551872849464417,
0.2245570868253708,
0.09656655043363571,
0.4095175564289093,
0.06909909099340439,
1.0942630767822266,
0.2781140208244324,
-0.8591664433479309,
0.20805929601192474,
0.28440552949905396,
-0.46154481172561646,
0.31159546971321106,
-0.9155617952346802,
0.42238497734069824,
-0.12013113498687744,
0.31635090708732605,
-0.8299612998962402,
-0.5284473896026611,
0.009932699613273144,
-0.2843826115131378,
0.11316987872123718,
-0.16807952523231506,
-0.5050126314163208,
-0.15966202318668365,
0.0309956893324852,
0.7345719337463379,
0.7210312485694885,
-0.6068629622459412,
0.23249708116054535,
0.34772366285324097,
-0.09558707475662231,
-0.1525290310382843,
-0.40751132369041443,
-0.2375040501356125,
-0.36969491839408875,
-0.7248126864433289,
0.36451101303100586,
-0.03819414973258972,
-0.18908578157424927,
-0.257815957069397,
-0.14912329614162445,
0.012548310682177544,
0.15324556827545166,
0.11561919003725052,
-0.18208110332489014,
-0.29036417603492737,
0.3473406732082367,
0.25704196095466614,
0.32297801971435547,
0.1241370141506195,
-0.4236162602901459,
0.5834697484970093,
-0.014527535997331142,
0.0031643384136259556,
0.11144483089447021,
0.5117672085762024,
0.19622382521629333,
-0.28332415223121643,
0.7603563666343689,
0.32098260521888733,
-0.42737969756126404,
-0.693980872631073,
-0.3509024381637573,
-0.47271376848220825,
-0.5501082539558411,
0.2567906677722931,
-0.38086026906967163,
-1.3101584911346436,
0.4458509385585785,
-0.27546098828315735,
-0.07815029472112656,
0.07057710736989975,
0.6881186366081238,
-0.09420174360275269,
1.3288171291351318,
0.4307999312877655,
0.4933670163154602,
0.43705320358276367,
-0.22725039720535278,
0.15066176652908325,
-0.9057374000549316,
-0.22317562997341156,
-0.23409681022167206,
-0.2241833508014679,
-0.7670707106590271,
-0.4036919176578522,
0.8088618516921997,
0.2932688593864441,
0.043265391141176224,
0.17886586487293243,
-0.2126627117395401,
0.6042211055755615,
0.5464104413986206,
0.05828864499926567,
0.15575560927391052,
0.019845997914671898,
-0.1806689351797104,
0.1802223175764084,
-0.9956996440887451,
-0.7471827268600464,
1.074715256690979,
-0.04393991082906723,
0.3893201947212219,
-0.14184096455574036,
0.6462828516960144,
-0.046509046107530594,
0.1369888186454773,
-0.49765652418136597,
0.6014813780784607,
0.2660583555698395,
-0.8809110522270203,
-0.4092634320259094,
-0.38743361830711365,
-1.0596158504486084,
0.39134594798088074,
-0.27712762355804443,
-0.3868791460990906,
-0.07969224452972412,
0.3966973125934601,
-0.7014976143836975,
-0.1888699233531952,
-0.665702760219574,
0.9287073612213135,
0.014071585610508919,
-0.43728846311569214,
-0.009011324495077133,
-0.48700574040412903,
0.4862792193889618,
-0.034266773611307144,
-0.08992458879947662,
0.08788542449474335,
0.3730848729610443,
0.6066005825996399,
-0.24371357262134552,
0.652920126914978,
-0.12150982767343521,
-0.3409777283668518,
0.7438750863075256,
0.04962432384490967,
0.47266581654548645,
0.562271237373352,
0.03208760544657707,
-0.30919787287712097,
0.2560357451438904,
-0.3485449552536011,
-0.6509689688682556,
0.7209535837173462,
-0.6188026070594788,
-0.9273751378059387,
-0.11284913122653961,
-0.7176315188407898,
-0.7518593668937683,
0.05082913860678673,
0.3633466064929962,
0.5878425240516663,
-0.2918241620063782,
0.04690145328640938,
0.7034347653388977,
-0.40380388498306274,
0.10073011368513107,
0.40252092480659485,
0.035477086901664734,
-0.25485846400260925,
0.7268434166908264,
0.05369601026177406,
0.4375237822532654,
-0.08410771191120148,
0.06863844394683838,
-0.4194527566432953,
-0.4467456042766571,
-0.6273536086082458,
0.13381414115428925,
-0.5353407263755798,
-0.20792421698570251,
-0.5758730173110962,
-0.4015926718711853,
-0.47958704829216003,
-0.020187804475426674,
-0.10168024897575378,
-0.47488781809806824,
-0.2979829013347626,
-0.011077889241278172,
0.13653796911239624,
0.471688449382782,
0.334943026304245,
0.25664007663726807,
-0.8767264485359192,
0.2578220069408417,
0.8569395542144775,
0.09270575642585754,
-0.09833195060491562,
-0.3479293882846832,
-0.3877571225166321,
0.39562734961509705,
-0.3655368387699127,
-0.7787322998046875,
0.30068424344062805,
0.27784857153892517,
0.3460637032985687,
-0.03129260241985321,
0.14947697520256042,
0.6476868987083435,
-0.734950602054596,
1.0101128816604614,
-0.3905094563961029,
-0.5280033946037292,
0.6914628744125366,
-0.6676940321922302,
0.4165998697280884,
0.6028043627738953,
0.3468022644519806,
-0.6122232675552368,
-0.310056209564209,
-0.5617203116416931,
-0.7233023047447205,
0.7744931578636169,
0.16941364109516144,
0.37764182686805725,
-0.28609099984169006,
0.7415279150009155,
0.1258510798215866,
0.36299386620521545,
-0.5369594097137451,
0.1303739994764328,
0.10341708362102509,
-0.006080057471990585,
-0.025716036558151245,
-0.07018302381038666,
-0.33248549699783325,
-0.3051051199436188,
0.5152774453163147,
-0.38547399640083313,
0.07639234513044357,
0.29383230209350586,
-0.1120334267616272,
-0.3163445293903351,
0.31786173582077026,
0.7569764852523804,
0.6833204030990601,
-0.03343501314520836,
0.01053870003670454,
0.45481887459754944,
-0.04463871568441391,
0.233218714594841,
-0.3387145698070526,
-0.3724648952484131,
-0.23977361619472504,
0.06803498417139053,
0.6422061324119568,
-0.06139373779296875,
-1.0371943712234497,
0.12374360114336014,
-0.07816983014345169,
-0.29487815499305725,
-0.5310953855514526,
0.5171444416046143,
0.173335999250412,
0.36682096123695374,
0.22139953076839447,
-0.37409916520118713,
0.03699369356036186,
-0.7399572134017944,
0.020127208903431892,
0.6083773374557495,
-0.13449187576770782,
-0.40144506096839905,
0.5881824493408203,
0.1212860569357872,
-0.22667914628982544,
0.5498818159103394,
-0.1974608153104782,
-0.6488674283027649,
0.7697193026542664,
0.8735949993133545,
0.6634795665740967,
-0.016087811440229416,
0.20013532042503357,
0.49700450897216797,
-0.07460808008909225,
-0.18815088272094727,
0.45810893177986145,
-0.19979488849639893,
-0.7829731106758118,
-0.32421985268592834,
-0.7254002690315247,
-0.5448599457740784,
0.5150370597839355,
-0.390058308839798,
0.04365329444408417,
-0.32789480686187744,
-0.09090525656938553,
-0.4182288348674774,
-0.09368240833282471,
-0.574966311454773,
0.6143056750297546,
0.021725453436374664,
0.5419837236404419,
-0.6195153594017029,
0.7809097170829773,
1.0110044479370117,
-0.039282698184251785,
-0.8654898405075073,
0.1412774622440338,
-0.46472620964050293,
-0.4378535747528076,
0.6794795393943787,
0.15454113483428955,
-0.005959169007837772,
0.32899272441864014,
-0.7213629484176636,
-0.7595019936561584,
1.1393120288848877,
0.13457538187503815,
-0.34303033351898193,
-0.30858373641967773,
0.5669361352920532,
0.8316170573234558,
-0.5099033117294312,
-0.16180934011936188,
0.7145360112190247,
0.23605838418006897,
-0.038456812500953674,
-0.5656747817993164,
0.22763416171073914,
-0.23022855818271637,
0.2161470502614975,
0.026209361851215363,
-0.6583546996116638,
0.8828991651535034,
-0.022085946053266525,
-0.42809027433395386,
0.14505012333393097,
0.4979487955570221,
0.6826156377792358,
0.1635664701461792,
0.37072038650512695,
0.22663608193397522,
0.4890681803226471,
-0.18173827230930328,
0.9922724366188049,
-0.5101071000099182,
0.07786323130130768,
0.9666178226470947,
-0.23451068997383118,
0.6632503867149353,
0.46984511613845825,
0.09566714614629745,
0.2541177272796631,
0.6464923620223999,
0.13033512234687805,
0.545187771320343,
0.3950684070587158,
-0.4465521275997162,
-0.508324146270752,
0.01178485993295908,
-0.4069567620754242,
0.4140797555446625,
0.3491840958595276,
-0.17475302517414093,
-0.049637869000434875,
-0.022106468677520752,
-0.4619208574295044,
0.12259908765554428,
-0.14096075296401978,
0.7840418815612793,
0.07799038290977478,
-1.0958212614059448,
0.7665127515792847,
0.18648041784763336,
0.3703281283378601,
-0.4512450098991394,
-0.04552179574966431,
-0.41037705540657043,
-0.033000484108924866,
0.032563962042331696,
-0.37078922986984253,
0.23396101593971252,
0.04696447774767876,
-0.1346961408853531,
-0.189696803689003,
0.5849428772926331,
-0.6711584329605103,
-0.2248726785182953,
-0.31216052174568176,
0.7628574967384338,
-0.23973964154720306,
-0.15164513885974884,
-0.30196601152420044,
-0.4631013572216034,
-0.2250693142414093,
-0.3382440209388733,
0.49653685092926025,
0.5674684643745422,
-0.1126498356461525,
0.483978807926178,
0.6674810647964478,
0.007246650755405426,
0.33581429719924927,
-0.2148696631193161,
0.896869957447052,
-0.71638423204422,
-0.4342033863067627,
-0.5410035848617554,
0.46469202637672424,
0.05338422954082489,
-0.44592851400375366,
0.7618756890296936,
0.4581378102302551,
1.033318281173706,
-0.24421043694019318,
0.9370020627975464,
0.028988424688577652,
0.4447934627532959,
-0.7857553958892822,
0.6132012605667114,
-0.6114820837974548,
0.20623062551021576,
-0.030630305409431458,
-0.8844580054283142,
0.0586136095225811,
0.374597430229187,
-0.2613924741744995,
0.19759820401668549,
0.4283929467201233,
0.8692083358764648,
-0.07772303372621536,
0.07200969010591507,
0.273349404335022,
-0.10094905644655228,
0.40670832991600037,
0.5505191087722778,
1.1279139518737793,
-0.531675398349762,
0.28726381063461304,
-0.13950027525424957,
0.25588199496269226,
-0.11412055790424347,
-0.5840975046157837,
-1.0512874126434326,
-0.6921960711479187,
-0.22860397398471832,
-0.24946515262126923,
0.05574090778827667,
1.046350359916687,
0.6479437947273254,
-0.8448936939239502,
-0.18779800832271576,
-0.3677256107330322,
-0.2037607878446579,
0.17693613469600677,
-0.23593315482139587,
0.15620028972625732,
-0.5004197359085083,
-0.8153785467147827,
0.615770697593689,
-0.1520644724369049,
0.2749212384223938,
-0.2118767499923706,
-0.038723256438970566,
-0.06580352038145065,
0.368533194065094,
0.7758786678314209,
0.307369589805603,
-0.5223276019096375,
-0.4818323850631714,
0.16350750625133514,
-0.17017048597335815,
-0.09156657010316849,
1.0324428081512451,
-1.0287657976150513,
0.13857287168502808,
0.5675533413887024,
0.6690934896469116,
0.47333911061286926,
0.39764565229415894,
0.9424946308135986,
-1.3043166399002075,
-0.012440644204616547,
0.31161370873451233,
0.10500378161668777,
0.22383591532707214,
-0.2168179452419281,
0.38330984115600586,
0.0728725716471672,
-0.5306510329246521,
-0.9842241406440735,
0.471294641494751,
-0.6088660955429077,
-0.39450308680534363,
1.413620948791504,
0.14687365293502808,
-0.041274115443229675,
0.05873209238052368,
-0.39298954606056213,
0.35554689168930054,
0.07970936596393585,
0.8855945467948914,
0.563856840133667,
-0.21907071769237518,
-0.158982053399086,
-0.6182809472084045,
0.9160743355751038,
0.6510004997253418,
-0.8444316387176514,
0.055988725274801254,
0.5627783536911011,
0.4048644006252289,
-0.1690034568309784,
0.29408106207847595,
0.06821289658546448,
0.27686166763305664,
-0.19164811074733734,
-0.28919923305511475,
-0.06755302101373672,
-0.13803155720233917,
-0.23831585049629211,
0.3587777316570282,
0.09860800206661224,
0.15932779014110565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13185v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13185v1 | Learnable In-Context Vector for Visual Question Answering | 2024-06-19T03:33:45 | 2024-06-19T03:33:45 | Yingzhe Peng, Chenduo Hao, Xu Yang, Jiawei Peng, Xinting Hu, Xin Geng | cs.CL | cs.CL | As language models continue to scale, Large Language Models (LLMs) have
exhibited emerging capabilities in In-Context Learning (ICL), enabling them to
solve language tasks by prefixing a few in-context demonstrations (ICDs) as
context. Inspired by these advancements, researchers have extended these
techniques to develop Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) with ICL capabilities.
However, applying ICL usually faces two major challenges: 1) using more ICDs
will largely increase the inference time and 2) the performance is sensitive to
the selection of ICDs. These challenges are further exacerbated in LMMs due to
the integration of multiple data types and the combinational complexity of
multimodal ICDs. Recently, to address these challenges, some NLP studies
introduce non-learnable In-Context Vectors (ICVs) which extract useful task
information from ICDs into a single vector and then insert it into the LLM to
help solve the corresponding task. However, although useful in simple NLP
tasks, these non-learnable methods fail to handle complex multimodal tasks like
Visual Question Answering (VQA). In this study, we propose \textbf{Learnable
ICV} (L-ICV) to distill essential task information from demonstrations,
improving ICL performance in LMMs. Experiments show that L-ICV can
significantly reduce computational costs while enhancing accuracy in VQA tasks
compared to traditional ICL and other non-learnable ICV methods. | [
-0.5149950981140137,
-0.8327396512031555,
0.38399288058280945,
0.18639060854911804,
-0.47920528054237366,
0.24596482515335083,
-0.09470648318529129,
-0.39001068472862244,
-0.17976850271224976,
0.1721574068069458,
-0.5585843920707703,
-0.44614049792289734,
-0.36309611797332764,
-0.05075109377503395,
-0.38779717683792114,
0.6943987011909485,
-0.1520935446023941,
0.21237552165985107,
-0.9510221481323242,
-0.4208119213581085,
-0.5466309189796448,
-0.3482813835144043,
-0.44304996728897095,
0.0193588025867939,
0.3830735683441162,
0.6807200312614441,
0.21352912485599518,
0.4250633120536804,
0.4080519676208496,
0.29185405373573303,
-0.025892876088619232,
0.45020726323127747,
-0.3861840069293976,
0.1464117467403412,
-0.10119115561246872,
-0.4752030670642853,
-0.19107936322689056,
-0.2572123408317566,
0.6663546562194824,
0.6359752416610718,
-0.019506284967064857,
0.24189187586307526,
0.12117534875869751,
0.42842957377433777,
-0.561195433139801,
0.3015446066856384,
-0.5990695953369141,
-0.049074746668338776,
-0.015876617282629013,
-0.4136221408843994,
-0.39863649010658264,
0.08043407648801804,
0.46913233399391174,
-0.6359350681304932,
0.019260626286268234,
0.052522916346788406,
0.6246366500854492,
0.3450697958469391,
-0.372935950756073,
0.03307250887155533,
-0.6756590604782104,
0.9017969369888306,
-0.5738150477409363,
0.40131065249443054,
0.0644102618098259,
0.5369834899902344,
-0.07551667094230652,
-0.8960069417953491,
-0.6597781181335449,
-0.211337149143219,
0.23325340449810028,
0.1916581690311432,
-0.2290608435869217,
0.05850811302661896,
0.5302444696426392,
0.02377861738204956,
-0.4348751902580261,
0.025122184306383133,
-0.27969712018966675,
-0.03025280125439167,
0.05568327382206917,
0.27736350893974304,
0.5177688598632812,
-0.35616835951805115,
-0.7193785309791565,
-0.20972304046154022,
-0.6109617352485657,
0.7712416648864746,
-0.17498327791690826,
0.12938576936721802,
-0.1905737966299057,
0.6754811406135559,
-0.30510300397872925,
0.7500185966491699,
-0.0886087566614151,
-0.5024869441986084,
0.26761558651924133,
-0.23700927197933197,
-0.3406723439693451,
-0.31496915221214294,
0.33570247888565063,
0.4068046808242798,
0.0536588616669178,
-0.03990869224071503,
-0.09194996953010559,
-0.20141728222370148,
0.27279120683670044,
-0.8825076222419739,
-0.12520891427993774,
0.2877466082572937,
-0.5382988452911377,
0.12004260718822479,
-0.10790311545133591,
-0.7953669428825378,
-0.09045501053333282,
-0.4584200382232666,
0.706193745136261,
-0.6301553249359131,
-0.08064888417720795,
-0.2157382071018219,
-0.3958858847618103,
0.6530979871749878,
0.7323099970817566,
-0.4151231646537781,
-0.028198665007948875,
0.3431973159313202,
0.6928985118865967,
-0.2454133927822113,
-0.24552005529403687,
-0.9269527196884155,
0.09122492372989655,
-0.29168444871902466,
0.6423889994621277,
-0.6250473856925964,
-0.26358726620674133,
-0.07096242904663086,
-0.03149855509400368,
-0.06922972947359085,
-0.5468329787254333,
0.1736026257276535,
-0.6071282625198364,
-0.13451899588108063,
-0.4769652187824249,
-0.4300793409347534,
-0.4111168682575226,
0.4344768822193146,
-0.5070341229438782,
0.8596357703208923,
0.06203664466738701,
-0.8682938814163208,
0.4047412574291229,
-0.43877166509628296,
-0.29194286465644836,
0.2905701696872711,
-0.4373437166213989,
-0.3251126706600189,
0.0486745648086071,
0.6323407888412476,
0.7677605152130127,
-0.16689373552799225,
-0.01935645379126072,
-0.41414445638656616,
-0.5094023942947388,
0.3116855025291443,
-0.5147280097007751,
0.5001809597015381,
-0.005827487912029028,
-0.4161706268787384,
0.27816954255104065,
-0.7925909161567688,
0.016697930172085762,
-0.04757162556052208,
-0.27886247634887695,
-0.46532386541366577,
0.06375518441200256,
0.014460695907473564,
0.3889528214931488,
-0.01143310684710741,
-0.5397045016288757,
0.02948722243309021,
-0.21601812541484833,
0.4053801894187927,
0.7455761432647705,
-0.07098013162612915,
0.3698040843009949,
-0.19210700690746307,
0.8347111344337463,
0.3627394139766693,
0.1137809008359909,
-0.1594921350479126,
-0.4725205600261688,
-0.9127437472343445,
-0.7798894047737122,
0.027617817744612694,
0.5662408471107483,
-1.8711904287338257,
-0.41062265634536743,
-0.1602887064218521,
-0.5605339407920837,
-0.3481478989124298,
0.2601650059223175,
0.5840659737586975,
0.9283927083015442,
0.505973219871521,
-0.03825303167104721,
-0.24096588790416718,
-1.0361453294754028,
0.08634143322706223,
-0.13720431923866272,
0.012915694154798985,
0.6020584106445312,
0.5371816754341125,
0.060155004262924194,
0.8756281733512878,
-0.3389509320259094,
-0.1832006275653839,
-0.41497802734375,
0.1282595992088318,
-0.16339801251888275,
0.28856590390205383,
0.6311784386634827,
-1.0158941745758057,
-0.40626761317253113,
-0.15008780360221863,
-0.7415543794631958,
0.15463024377822876,
-0.08883442729711533,
-0.02560853585600853,
0.030871951952576637,
0.9046362042427063,
-0.36107513308525085,
0.5328654050827026,
0.43687203526496887,
-0.07467332482337952,
0.2890518009662628,
-0.39053767919540405,
0.1379963755607605,
-0.8941137790679932,
-0.06124680116772652,
0.09778380393981934,
-0.37904486060142517,
-0.5654150247573853,
0.000276454578852281,
0.4641880989074707,
-0.09353594481945038,
-1.0441763401031494,
0.5311205387115479,
-0.39763444662094116,
0.010100082494318485,
-0.02815730683505535,
-0.005388944409787655,
-0.035059042274951935,
0.7458216547966003,
0.05044763162732124,
0.9452311396598816,
0.8583992123603821,
-0.7906907796859741,
0.20704568922519684,
0.3342739939689636,
-0.5798641443252563,
0.7881564497947693,
-0.6898419260978699,
-0.16652798652648926,
-0.7882186770439148,
0.11135229468345642,
-1.258630633354187,
-0.15378831326961517,
0.1028614416718483,
-0.2860790193080902,
0.3697602450847626,
-0.09610836207866669,
-0.24391448497772217,
-0.09195271134376526,
-0.24873068928718567,
0.7827607989311218,
0.36191627383232117,
-0.919744610786438,
0.6977545619010925,
0.22894573211669922,
-0.07784835994243622,
-0.878752589225769,
-0.5404514074325562,
-0.0442955307662487,
-0.32802480459213257,
-0.48084643483161926,
0.17622394859790802,
-0.28499364852905273,
-0.06970376521348953,
-0.10390147566795349,
0.0855027586221695,
-0.006050989497452974,
-0.08196304738521576,
0.3641682267189026,
0.4587130844593048,
-0.21968702971935272,
0.4101153314113617,
-0.04308237507939339,
0.05900567024946213,
-0.1054702028632164,
0.03187378868460655,
0.2443123161792755,
-0.1785394698381424,
-0.5055715441703796,
-0.4465582072734833,
0.6126895546913147,
0.8942676186561584,
-0.6079442501068115,
0.5913636088371277,
0.5984301567077637,
-0.35033294558525085,
-0.47015830874443054,
-0.41177329421043396,
0.11864922195672989,
-0.42195257544517517,
0.5675032734870911,
-0.4485192596912384,
-0.9121076464653015,
0.2645655572414398,
-0.08985655009746552,
0.017687270417809486,
0.1354232132434845,
0.4270254075527191,
-0.38434523344039917,
1.0868792533874512,
0.6541886329650879,
0.2929125726222992,
0.6699756979942322,
-0.31572479009628296,
0.03460252285003662,
-0.9963721632957458,
-0.47188928723335266,
-0.16923938691616058,
-0.4229491949081421,
-0.3882191777229309,
-0.7689184546470642,
0.7731413245201111,
0.03917907923460007,
0.07462389022111893,
0.04875405505299568,
-0.24257861077785492,
0.2901217043399811,
0.6710767149925232,
0.3672648072242737,
0.09569978713989258,
0.04139015078544617,
-0.14476564526557922,
-0.15139295160770416,
-0.8983369469642639,
-0.12924830615520477,
0.9565823078155518,
0.18152804672718048,
0.8373879194259644,
0.15379393100738525,
0.12551286816596985,
-0.23290249705314636,
0.20454584062099457,
-0.6366347074508667,
0.6723957657814026,
-0.19382387399673462,
-0.32381001114845276,
-0.3013215959072113,
-0.24887576699256897,
-0.598455011844635,
0.36768239736557007,
-0.45998045802116394,
-0.602121889591217,
0.3780839443206787,
0.30786874890327454,
-0.385856032371521,
0.365308940410614,
-0.6654793620109558,
0.8429494500160217,
-0.13466951251029968,
-0.389909565448761,
0.04433111101388931,
-0.6906308531761169,
0.3391244411468506,
0.1996130794286728,
0.06487619876861572,
0.08171297609806061,
-0.21864774823188782,
0.48755544424057007,
-0.2934923470020294,
0.9051873683929443,
-0.2864423096179962,
0.1374843567609787,
0.39086276292800903,
-0.07085554301738739,
0.5181294679641724,
0.22193200886249542,
0.3986021876335144,
-0.05433174967765808,
0.05119143798947334,
-0.37545278668403625,
-0.7425300478935242,
0.743193507194519,
-0.5912184715270996,
-0.4271618723869324,
-0.21814373135566711,
-0.6457503437995911,
-0.31640496850013733,
-0.10094974935054779,
0.2200852334499359,
1.0275198221206665,
0.07966253906488419,
0.5791913866996765,
0.9971664547920227,
-0.547719419002533,
0.6886785626411438,
0.2043915092945099,
0.013047385960817337,
-0.420708030462265,
1.0231037139892578,
0.12969407439231873,
0.46812471747398376,
0.6535028219223022,
-0.08240114897489548,
-0.32928889989852905,
-0.6527895331382751,
-0.5608647465705872,
-0.007347238715738058,
-1.0208324193954468,
-0.15395788848400116,
-0.8052229285240173,
-0.12326279282569885,
0.05568898469209671,
-0.11505130678415298,
-0.26195818185806274,
-0.29573535919189453,
-0.5038334131240845,
-0.04576260969042778,
0.3188970983028412,
0.2454296499490738,
0.21256683766841888,
-0.03949001431465149,
-0.5840727686882019,
0.7499594688415527,
0.8202044367790222,
0.2811981737613678,
0.0927494540810585,
-0.4445309340953827,
0.026706015691161156,
0.018534451723098755,
-0.03282066434621811,
-0.5350030064582825,
0.2970310151576996,
0.2226448357105255,
0.5327337384223938,
0.31877264380455017,
0.18924623727798462,
1.1699622869491577,
-0.547977864742279,
0.7540152668952942,
0.15994608402252197,
-0.8003042936325073,
0.32784828543663025,
-0.21160031855106354,
0.4511772096157074,
0.4176590144634247,
0.3894169330596924,
-0.38511922955513,
-0.2642008364200592,
-0.1763497292995453,
-1.058932900428772,
0.4778626561164856,
0.07221383601427078,
0.168723002076149,
-0.034759633243083954,
0.3516821265220642,
0.07213954627513885,
0.32034939527511597,
-0.6458778977394104,
-0.24940912425518036,
-0.2807281017303467,
-0.1309385746717453,
-0.2284608781337738,
-0.29156169295310974,
0.0304873064160347,
-0.5613037943840027,
0.4609161913394928,
-0.34887179732322693,
0.17852458357810974,
0.5026723742485046,
-0.33636799454689026,
0.12525193393230438,
0.1429155319929123,
0.6907090544700623,
0.9557852149009705,
-0.1684872806072235,
0.3119452893733978,
0.35826629400253296,
-0.19273485243320465,
-0.018830344080924988,
-0.1250833123922348,
-0.08161576837301254,
-0.1386025995016098,
0.4032805263996124,
0.793239414691925,
0.2981940805912018,
-1.2432262897491455,
0.9413979053497314,
-0.3600485324859619,
-0.10132061690092087,
-0.6170254349708557,
-0.021606650203466415,
0.12031836062669754,
0.6024525165557861,
0.3095512092113495,
0.10090558230876923,
0.02466197870671749,
-0.425662636756897,
0.18701501190662384,
0.8389939665794373,
-0.6399111747741699,
0.00959194079041481,
0.9277463555335999,
0.13317328691482544,
-0.10770656168460846,
0.6706396341323853,
0.01894322596490383,
-0.3309594988822937,
0.7353710532188416,
0.33642467856407166,
0.5330336689949036,
0.1104402095079422,
0.2709411084651947,
0.2612091302871704,
0.10874349623918533,
0.25504356622695923,
0.5023826360702515,
-0.16352418065071106,
-0.4643688201904297,
-0.6176068186759949,
-0.30145907402038574,
-0.42005017399787903,
0.2691954970359802,
-0.6670886278152466,
0.3268442451953888,
-0.2672646939754486,
0.1806333065032959,
-0.027213942259550095,
-0.588113009929657,
-0.8345039486885071,
0.3316427767276764,
0.1391579508781433,
0.8432832956314087,
-0.5754703283309937,
0.7230676412582397,
0.7662450671195984,
-0.31196272373199463,
-0.6495471596717834,
-0.235966756939888,
-0.25954920053482056,
-0.6884377002716064,
0.8375322818756104,
0.1575603187084198,
-0.14677925407886505,
-0.0715426430106163,
-0.7637736201286316,
-0.7067001461982727,
1.2499299049377441,
0.3891007900238037,
-0.24048393964767456,
0.044544465839862823,
0.01073717512190342,
0.3810776174068451,
-0.31308040022850037,
0.31434404850006104,
-0.05536573752760887,
0.18000802397727966,
0.4434733986854553,
-0.6193806529045105,
-0.08576346188783646,
-0.32022812962532043,
0.22423478960990906,
0.00042578860302455723,
-0.6121985912322998,
0.9264254570007324,
-0.28886836767196655,
-0.11094071716070175,
0.05396536365151405,
0.7928583025932312,
0.17528294026851654,
0.2867712378501892,
0.6880415678024292,
0.2820433974266052,
0.4835555851459503,
0.09194569289684296,
1.0975497961044312,
0.00822917278856039,
-0.04038265347480774,
0.9579323530197144,
0.1026759222149849,
1.0531314611434937,
0.887188196182251,
0.22070710361003876,
0.22014670073986053,
0.4430446922779083,
0.18479880690574646,
0.5004595518112183,
0.07701444625854492,
-0.31673887372016907,
-0.7072000503540039,
-0.07869549840688705,
-0.12370223551988602,
0.7540833353996277,
0.27548572421073914,
-0.09128285944461823,
-0.27975359559059143,
0.4310660660266876,
-0.3043963313102722,
-0.005939500872045755,
-0.47050100564956665,
0.6567527055740356,
0.0011298072058707476,
-0.6729230880737305,
0.4970717430114746,
-0.24746719002723694,
0.5778972506523132,
-0.5994401574134827,
-0.5054440498352051,
0.006953325122594833,
0.15550044178962708,
0.04589041694998741,
-0.5777682065963745,
-0.03083024173974991,
-0.12346874922513962,
-0.17818783223628998,
-0.24621433019638062,
0.49657732248306274,
-0.6407440900802612,
-0.5547099709510803,
0.1793462634086609,
0.6512733101844788,
-0.06113263964653015,
-0.028786934912204742,
-0.3044002056121826,
-0.25097769498825073,
-0.053154218941926956,
-0.18300163745880127,
0.5105285048484802,
0.39569926261901855,
-0.20581193268299103,
1.1363469362258911,
0.5734975934028625,
-0.28838181495666504,
0.10139738768339157,
-0.20686930418014526,
1.0267060995101929,
-0.539042592048645,
-0.3841738998889923,
-0.6683650016784668,
0.8149611949920654,
0.07467766106128693,
-0.2878759801387787,
0.7215027213096619,
0.28827783465385437,
0.931587815284729,
-0.2251361906528473,
0.7249741554260254,
0.06390408426523209,
0.5240116715431213,
-0.6921687126159668,
0.4992654621601105,
-0.9845870733261108,
0.14158277213573456,
-0.45941147208213806,
-0.6023514270782471,
-0.33276692032814026,
0.37974151968955994,
0.13805487751960754,
-0.13079532980918884,
0.657417893409729,
0.6512833833694458,
-0.17069683969020844,
-0.28038471937179565,
0.5502771139144897,
0.08135758340358734,
0.4675838053226471,
0.6791960597038269,
1.020965814590454,
-0.11521371454000473,
0.7642912268638611,
-0.5370404124259949,
-0.2603839933872223,
-0.17831209301948547,
-1.0044740438461304,
-1.1553707122802734,
-0.8394978046417236,
-0.4470515251159668,
-0.009127417579293251,
-0.2986319065093994,
0.9382522106170654,
0.6651821136474609,
-0.5233103036880493,
0.038035307079553604,
0.29820194840431213,
0.07910748571157455,
-0.443126380443573,
-0.18884502351284027,
0.47098925709724426,
-0.1500653177499771,
-0.9312755465507507,
0.410090833902359,
0.44307002425193787,
0.1156831756234169,
-0.10796000063419342,
0.19472642242908478,
-0.22193248569965363,
0.05484495684504509,
0.9646681547164917,
0.31456172466278076,
-0.662422239780426,
-0.5362234711647034,
0.046386949717998505,
0.1506262719631195,
0.18722541630268097,
0.6323049068450928,
-0.9275193810462952,
0.8694943785667419,
0.5648395419120789,
0.9028322100639343,
0.5250978469848633,
0.0461551807820797,
0.3370707929134369,
-0.8344476222991943,
0.31418126821517944,
0.11520775407552719,
0.4558045566082001,
0.2529505491256714,
-0.11792445927858353,
-0.008232825435698032,
0.01897413842380047,
-0.25824084877967834,
-0.6989431381225586,
0.26050323247909546,
-1.2403463125228882,
-0.42747047543525696,
1.103973627090454,
-0.07790850102901459,
-0.37444329261779785,
-0.24343271553516388,
-0.41462111473083496,
0.01590942032635212,
-0.18176986277103424,
0.3351162374019623,
0.47940710186958313,
-0.3133726418018341,
-0.45639973878860474,
-0.9140672087669373,
0.498468279838562,
0.35123565793037415,
-0.7686648368835449,
-0.25361359119415283,
0.4330118000507355,
0.35270217061042786,
-0.1720505952835083,
0.44284364581108093,
-0.025973854586482048,
0.501653254032135,
-0.2733343541622162,
0.17188651859760284,
-0.2858870029449463,
-0.5207587480545044,
-0.32136571407318115,
0.4608815014362335,
0.06038258597254753,
-0.56130450963974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13184v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13184v1 | Locating and Extracting Relational Concepts in Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T03:29:51 | 2024-06-19T03:29:51 | Zijian Wang, Britney White, Chang Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Relational concepts are indeed foundational to the structure of knowledge
representation, as they facilitate the association between various entity
concepts, allowing us to express and comprehend complex world knowledge. By
expressing relational concepts in natural language prompts, people can
effortlessly interact with large language models (LLMs) and recall desired
factual knowledge. However, the process of knowledge recall lacks
interpretability, and representations of relational concepts within LLMs remain
unknown to us. In this paper, we identify hidden states that can express entity
and relational concepts through causal mediation analysis in fact recall
processes. Our finding reveals that at the last token position of the input
prompt, there are hidden states that solely express the causal effects of
relational concepts. Based on this finding, we assume that these hidden states
can be treated as relational representations and we can successfully extract
them from LLMs. The experimental results demonstrate high credibility of the
relational representations: they can be flexibly transplanted into other fact
recall processes, and can also be used as robust entity connectors. Moreover,
we also show that the relational representations exhibit significant potential
for controllable fact recall through relation rewriting. | [
-0.32733967900276184,
-1.0020365715026855,
1.102087140083313,
0.12860505282878876,
-0.05836901813745499,
-0.11169026792049408,
-0.16475878655910492,
-0.4001207947731018,
0.38018545508384705,
0.41504427790641785,
-0.4400574266910553,
-0.28903695940971375,
-0.5793823599815369,
0.07290241122245789,
-0.30061018466949463,
0.5721444487571716,
-0.1514301747083664,
-0.196989044547081,
-0.3978671729564667,
-0.005601867567747831,
-0.6270910501480103,
-0.5728744268417358,
-0.4237416088581085,
-0.4174339771270752,
0.7412230968475342,
0.1823229044675827,
0.7331782579421997,
0.6366328001022339,
0.3703089952468872,
0.3144499361515045,
-0.22791825234889984,
0.01725955680012703,
-0.44466841220855713,
0.3257502317428589,
-0.7120322585105896,
-0.5810909867286682,
-0.054622676223516464,
0.21747203171253204,
1.1310803890228271,
0.9280797243118286,
-0.17964524030685425,
0.12249201536178589,
-0.3142499327659607,
0.43552902340888977,
-0.9031463861465454,
0.8039392232894897,
-0.6183635592460632,
-0.12199093401432037,
0.009069748222827911,
-0.26376181840896606,
-0.549197256565094,
-0.28524816036224365,
0.16668172180652618,
-0.5625335574150085,
-0.0648464635014534,
0.26495009660720825,
1.0649880170822144,
0.10298337042331696,
-0.9079881906509399,
-0.27043119072914124,
-0.9753254055976868,
0.4348489046096802,
-0.31850841641426086,
0.5786978602409363,
0.19260549545288086,
0.23036572337150574,
-0.4284193217754364,
-0.5961436629295349,
-0.8027288913726807,
-0.3399411141872406,
-0.5123516917228699,
-0.05455644428730011,
-0.22612033784389496,
-0.14646156132221222,
0.6395297646522522,
0.1824827939271927,
-0.09272222220897675,
-0.03891068324446678,
0.10561110824346542,
-0.40404921770095825,
0.36858418583869934,
0.28710517287254333,
0.5377673506736755,
-0.4076935350894928,
-0.3587476909160614,
0.14324988424777985,
-1.0326590538024902,
-0.14444677531719208,
-0.213913694024086,
0.2368295043706894,
-0.006243990734219551,
0.6205801367759705,
0.020100779831409454,
0.45121797919273376,
-0.07528472691774368,
-0.3005697727203369,
-0.023493032902479172,
-0.34821817278862,
-0.21705684065818787,
-0.09165836870670319,
0.7825651168823242,
-0.19486181437969208,
-0.17217934131622314,
-0.37450531125068665,
-0.03599558025598526,
0.05161954089999199,
-0.02801542915403843,
-0.6194394826889038,
0.06218033283948898,
-0.2639646828174591,
-0.4150884449481964,
0.0364161841571331,
0.15085339546203613,
-0.4385724365711212,
-0.3856102228164673,
-0.40090492367744446,
0.35397839546203613,
-0.1833670437335968,
-0.6746525168418884,
-0.15904559195041656,
-0.21139925718307495,
0.2711047828197479,
0.2500031590461731,
-0.8307319283485413,
0.38917407393455505,
0.7616358995437622,
0.5650680661201477,
-0.018201308324933052,
0.00816336926072836,
-0.35879334807395935,
0.602972686290741,
-0.5467166900634766,
0.4473901391029358,
-0.6803181767463684,
-0.21049270033836365,
0.18477781116962433,
0.3315346837043762,
-0.20334848761558533,
-0.40553149580955505,
0.4107948839664459,
-1.04231858253479,
0.11777215451002121,
-0.7971113920211792,
-0.8536182641983032,
-0.23348823189735413,
0.14094692468643188,
-1.114335298538208,
0.664367139339447,
-0.1539139747619629,
-1.0320680141448975,
0.16631530225276947,
-0.37115478515625,
-0.2883140742778778,
-0.19666406512260437,
-0.45731014013290405,
-0.2345471978187561,
0.21316474676132202,
-0.02610289305448532,
0.5239548087120056,
-0.6083851456642151,
0.5142384171485901,
-0.3661074936389923,
-0.14545229077339172,
0.6439327597618103,
-0.2649725377559662,
0.7971066236495972,
-0.010344844311475754,
-0.23206660151481628,
-0.14235039055347443,
-0.8347740173339844,
-0.5403884053230286,
0.27688226103782654,
-0.3208411633968353,
-0.7312864065170288,
0.02433713711798191,
-0.6825973987579346,
0.34513792395591736,
0.14781515300273895,
-0.5057823061943054,
0.155190572142601,
-0.1963934451341629,
0.2035035490989685,
0.4007163643836975,
0.5056605935096741,
0.8526344299316406,
0.1799299716949463,
0.22738975286483765,
0.37445417046546936,
-0.34169912338256836,
0.013604028150439262,
-0.2966633141040802,
-0.7147060036659241,
-0.18785466253757477,
0.14124062657356262,
0.36899110674858093,
-1.0660889148712158,
0.313277930021286,
-0.43826305866241455,
-0.07482346147298813,
-0.08720634132623672,
-0.08916489034891129,
0.3050265610218048,
0.7570374011993408,
0.11054829508066177,
0.060866180807352066,
-0.2563500702381134,
-1.153157114982605,
-0.3482738137245178,
-0.41334864497184753,
0.10295332223176956,
0.1358254998922348,
0.6435091495513916,
0.018348081037402153,
0.9909614324569702,
-0.6489166617393494,
-0.18981719017028809,
-0.14638203382492065,
0.12500861287117004,
0.30055853724479675,
0.1533433347940445,
0.1933988332748413,
-0.9831497073173523,
0.04280446469783783,
-0.22871144115924835,
-1.2119815349578857,
0.2595812678337097,
-0.3827824294567108,
-0.1702277511358261,
0.005807309411466122,
0.7392629384994507,
-1.2629574537277222,
0.30716389417648315,
-0.12015580385923386,
-0.4654223620891571,
0.5191335678100586,
-0.03952118381857872,
-0.17291930317878723,
-0.9318285584449768,
0.19264660775661469,
-0.20448850095272064,
-0.2535776197910309,
-0.337221622467041,
0.3549203872680664,
0.2473854273557663,
0.021084362640976906,
-0.2215362936258316,
0.49920591711997986,
-0.9171077609062195,
-0.1355401575565338,
0.010702112689614296,
0.434551477432251,
0.03315716236829758,
0.3805657625198364,
0.27093085646629333,
0.45958414673805237,
0.5645118355751038,
-0.6739501953125,
0.299401193857193,
0.30004268884658813,
-0.3054932951927185,
0.3736046850681305,
-0.314509779214859,
-0.22502851486206055,
-0.4110596477985382,
0.30214181542396545,
-0.6336718201637268,
-0.17087239027023315,
0.44728466868400574,
-0.15624141693115234,
0.614211916923523,
-0.20512793958187103,
-0.743465781211853,
-0.2013140320777893,
0.18941478431224823,
-0.11680836975574493,
0.3310471475124359,
-0.2622717022895813,
0.6834353804588318,
0.670592725276947,
-0.07866944372653961,
-0.66842120885849,
-0.35630059242248535,
-0.030172785744071007,
-0.27702561020851135,
-0.16577641665935516,
0.06731294840574265,
0.4044320583343506,
-0.3656780421733856,
0.3665129542350769,
-0.1676483154296875,
0.04776483401656151,
0.26659420132637024,
0.49013379216194153,
0.28422218561172485,
-0.204369455575943,
0.6636289358139038,
0.07124251872301102,
-0.24624694883823395,
0.7297782897949219,
-0.24919313192367554,
0.11789839714765549,
-0.053809672594070435,
-0.2619988024234772,
-0.3009103238582611,
0.3742057681083679,
0.49191081523895264,
-0.19364094734191895,
1.2993396520614624,
0.5502828359603882,
-0.6143714785575867,
0.13077041506767273,
-0.42748692631721497,
-0.24818269908428192,
-0.3527756333351135,
0.3476076126098633,
-0.4314683973789215,
-1.1442222595214844,
0.5549084544181824,
-0.4955790936946869,
-0.19894009828567505,
0.40704819560050964,
0.43494749069213867,
-0.014289455488324165,
0.7121112942695618,
0.7007449269294739,
-0.15045256912708282,
0.2720910906791687,
-0.16714221239089966,
0.35085034370422363,
-0.8095640540122986,
-0.3991188108921051,
-0.5346072316169739,
0.00313877547159791,
-0.6231216788291931,
-0.31854212284088135,
0.3479998707771301,
0.5395486950874329,
-0.3611697554588318,
0.1925911158323288,
0.29857033491134644,
0.37387099862098694,
0.479047954082489,
0.16798557341098785,
0.5137563943862915,
-0.0735207125544548,
-0.4945337474346161,
-0.11970246583223343,
-0.5932922959327698,
-0.3936290442943573,
0.5171065330505371,
0.2731766402721405,
0.5862640738487244,
0.446048766374588,
0.7343714237213135,
-0.19065281748771667,
0.42050138115882874,
-0.7788814902305603,
0.656429648399353,
0.4834650456905365,
-0.7786964774131775,
-0.38273411989212036,
-0.6567860841751099,
-0.8605559468269348,
0.2209174931049347,
-0.48270004987716675,
-0.9073003530502319,
0.37528711557388306,
-0.006266819313168526,
-0.15739290416240692,
0.2860648036003113,
-0.41530266404151917,
0.7163469195365906,
0.4393709599971771,
-0.5288318991661072,
-0.3752765357494354,
-0.7747009992599487,
0.624899685382843,
0.002663682447746396,
0.27204629778862,
-0.11307469010353088,
0.0500931516289711,
0.592896044254303,
-0.31251880526542664,
0.9199501872062683,
-0.19170652329921722,
-0.2662956416606903,
0.43254148960113525,
0.5521484613418579,
0.5880060791969299,
0.2440381497144699,
0.18808595836162567,
-0.21438570320606232,
-0.18624728918075562,
-0.1649162322282791,
-1.0152391195297241,
0.8112067580223083,
-0.6131920218467712,
-1.014750599861145,
-0.3425937294960022,
-0.36506351828575134,
-0.18411216139793396,
0.4202483594417572,
-0.27046480774879456,
0.3952820897102356,
-0.33923155069351196,
0.006144830025732517,
0.9010077118873596,
-0.30173516273498535,
0.45849472284317017,
0.7319079041481018,
-0.39682552218437195,
0.08212309330701828,
0.9208687543869019,
0.021800130605697632,
0.144317165017128,
0.9153302907943726,
0.1547861248254776,
-0.5061652064323425,
-0.12358986586332321,
-0.061584752053022385,
0.7529104948043823,
-0.8089045286178589,
-0.283302366733551,
-0.7253791689872742,
-0.10406677424907684,
-0.16109780967235565,
0.434837281703949,
-0.34083715081214905,
-0.6176984310150146,
-0.3673652112483978,
-0.4826705753803253,
0.1497446447610855,
0.6711695194244385,
-0.2752310037612915,
0.03433176130056381,
-0.9068194031715393,
0.4554269313812256,
0.5285207629203796,
0.12475807219743729,
0.15136389434337616,
-0.08917684853076935,
-0.26069483160972595,
-0.15734344720840454,
-0.04839377850294113,
-1.062836766242981,
0.2574441730976105,
-0.005566694308072329,
0.5499593615531921,
0.5337347984313965,
0.18989145755767822,
0.5985673666000366,
-0.5636377930641174,
0.6450634598731995,
0.16853803396224976,
-0.8257914185523987,
0.4411364793777466,
-0.20012663304805756,
0.04956046864390373,
0.12223082035779953,
0.9586596488952637,
-0.5262902975082397,
-0.17142535746097565,
-0.6212729811668396,
-0.5060547590255737,
0.36550575494766235,
0.1733909398317337,
0.05972952023148537,
-0.43668994307518005,
0.5609304308891296,
-0.24344156682491302,
0.13009147346019745,
-0.7224588394165039,
-0.4506683647632599,
0.24365831911563873,
0.1619742512702942,
0.22821582853794098,
-0.611609935760498,
-0.29489415884017944,
-0.042434241622686386,
0.42208871245384216,
0.27069157361984253,
0.5152736306190491,
0.23053894937038422,
-0.2948107421398163,
-0.23631414771080017,
0.37170037627220154,
0.2221582680940628,
0.7689319849014282,
-0.023700470104813576,
0.7356494069099426,
-0.26888418197631836,
-0.11486516892910004,
0.22499766945838928,
-0.05328751727938652,
-0.3215455710887909,
0.03838001564145088,
0.7066259980201721,
0.6317985653877258,
0.5758477449417114,
-0.25295907258987427,
0.5771088004112244,
-0.12900704145431519,
0.41225627064704895,
-0.374036967754364,
-0.03713835030794144,
0.7400221228599548,
0.35611170530319214,
0.14038437604904175,
-0.01213171798735857,
0.17526960372924805,
-0.9381003379821777,
0.2611992657184601,
0.5058007836341858,
-0.40457263588905334,
-0.5721889138221741,
0.6676440834999084,
-0.09107524156570435,
0.06311232596635818,
0.8773980736732483,
-0.31617721915245056,
-0.4036996066570282,
0.18677948415279388,
0.8126724362373352,
0.4995448887348175,
-0.14565792679786682,
0.40505972504615784,
0.5708302855491638,
0.12906140089035034,
0.0003870730579365045,
0.13456273078918457,
0.08484843373298645,
-1.1025445461273193,
-0.570046067237854,
-0.45366525650024414,
-0.013746638782322407,
-0.06749483942985535,
-0.9640474319458008,
0.01580638438463211,
-0.24714142084121704,
-0.14301341772079468,
0.06316942721605301,
-0.08666057139635086,
-0.7235966324806213,
-0.14064083993434906,
0.19956518709659576,
0.844552218914032,
-1.100631594657898,
0.9640366435050964,
0.377556174993515,
-0.7395043969154358,
-1.2729029655456543,
-0.3554615378379822,
0.19772982597351074,
-0.6550689935684204,
1.0049540996551514,
-0.3043239116668701,
-0.05363238602876663,
-0.060450416058301926,
-0.7020207047462463,
-1.0617090463638306,
1.0335389375686646,
0.4765150249004364,
-0.48194923996925354,
-0.25526368618011475,
0.06059494987130165,
0.42178311944007874,
-0.32800599932670593,
0.13059084117412567,
0.6556915044784546,
0.41481781005859375,
0.2723395526409149,
-0.6531677842140198,
0.6943246126174927,
-0.014859950169920921,
-0.022159786894917488,
0.17368215322494507,
-0.32913392782211304,
0.686854362487793,
-0.2544613778591156,
-0.6556066274642944,
-0.14170993864536285,
0.8170580267906189,
0.19803903996944427,
-0.009907776489853859,
0.3064258396625519,
0.5009074211120605,
0.7658966183662415,
0.005147803574800491,
1.101912498474121,
0.09788202494382858,
0.4169256389141083,
1.1864033937454224,
-0.2741524279117584,
0.8016273379325867,
0.5389212965965271,
0.03688843548297882,
0.822833776473999,
0.4060913026332855,
0.40477797389030457,
0.5415265560150146,
0.0010466068051755428,
-0.19910873472690582,
-0.5513495206832886,
-0.3973701298236847,
-0.21659165620803833,
0.3372521698474884,
0.7969447374343872,
-0.40905535221099854,
-0.20285628736019135,
-0.2187090963125229,
0.3372951149940491,
-0.06110488250851631,
-0.24024167656898499,
0.8838368058204651,
0.4111725091934204,
-0.5805118680000305,
0.5198057293891907,
-0.21566924452781677,
-0.1978834718465805,
-0.43114522099494934,
-0.5426012277603149,
-0.29620495438575745,
-0.16012662649154663,
0.03256377577781677,
-0.5740408897399902,
0.11240631341934204,
-0.5428680777549744,
-0.2759381830692291,
-0.1940746158361435,
0.9735956788063049,
-0.5778704881668091,
-0.2645275294780731,
0.3753463625907898,
0.6736404299736023,
0.036131974309682846,
-0.14833779633045197,
-0.34659701585769653,
-0.1418195217847824,
-0.1898026466369629,
-0.19002068042755127,
0.19688646495342255,
0.9954459071159363,
-0.4106491506099701,
0.7525404095649719,
0.43243375420570374,
0.2969565987586975,
0.03361354023218155,
0.12231233716011047,
1.0818231105804443,
-1.0299664735794067,
-0.2721952795982361,
-0.8704361319541931,
0.1536451280117035,
-0.11724510788917542,
0.2991936206817627,
0.8468127250671387,
0.2375650554895401,
0.5384032130241394,
-0.1738835722208023,
0.39275795221328735,
-0.010242665186524391,
0.5496209859848022,
-0.5605602860450745,
0.7312780618667603,
-0.1034078523516655,
0.2917844355106354,
-0.49123865365982056,
-0.9315171241760254,
-0.329405277967453,
0.3840932250022888,
-0.24627138674259186,
-0.42564740777015686,
0.9347538352012634,
0.5928651094436646,
0.07654417306184769,
-0.047905486077070236,
0.25835222005844116,
0.6981196403503418,
0.3803488314151764,
0.4278440773487091,
1.1911239624023438,
-0.18318472802639008,
0.18612541258335114,
0.06342572718858719,
-0.12758661806583405,
-0.05826088786125183,
-0.8784844875335693,
-0.796941876411438,
-0.7172428965568542,
-0.331641286611557,
-0.23524050414562225,
-0.24886104464530945,
0.6789255738258362,
0.4006488621234894,
-0.5491015911102295,
0.04349192604422569,
0.05021435394883156,
0.829282283782959,
-0.15523682534694672,
-0.2734265923500061,
0.6035346388816833,
-0.13770200312137604,
-0.26631417870521545,
0.38217461109161377,
0.33192873001098633,
-0.02440229058265686,
-0.30050620436668396,
0.13924448192119598,
-0.471357136964798,
-0.1983254849910736,
0.7527146339416504,
0.3259335160255432,
-0.7162560820579529,
-0.7261527180671692,
0.043225664645433426,
-0.02165377326309681,
-0.27364206314086914,
1.2002190351486206,
-1.0046093463897705,
0.2833128571510315,
0.3504432737827301,
0.4966377019882202,
0.5373461246490479,
-0.14715982973575592,
0.671215295791626,
-0.7993270754814148,
0.09755727648735046,
0.003374985419213772,
0.49183693528175354,
0.24052506685256958,
-0.25251901149749756,
0.29644423723220825,
0.44785967469215393,
-0.10111306607723236,
-0.5178119540214539,
0.5240504741668701,
-0.7658169865608215,
-0.39580729603767395,
1.0712023973464966,
-0.3749598264694214,
-0.30232498049736023,
-0.3064793050289154,
0.22039474546909332,
0.5472884178161621,
-0.10875625163316727,
0.6702197790145874,
0.691368043422699,
-0.10041801631450653,
-0.30558156967163086,
-0.3214040994644165,
0.5333940982818604,
0.006580449175089598,
-0.6129181981086731,
0.08929494768381119,
0.706246554851532,
0.3878912627696991,
0.40932607650756836,
0.5353308320045471,
-0.2355407178401947,
-0.11241304874420166,
0.010968214832246304,
-0.21155725419521332,
0.1487058401107788,
-0.3416072726249695,
0.08568016439676285,
0.2248072773218155,
0.06784781068563461,
0.12477557361125946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13173v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13173v2 | Biomedical Visual Instruction Tuning with Clinician Preference Alignment | 2024-06-19T03:07:33 | 2024-06-30T01:22:09 | Hejie Cui, Lingjun Mao, Xin Liang, Jieyu Zhang, Hui Ren, Quanzheng Li, Xiang Li, Carl Yang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T50, 68T45, 68T37, 68T05, 68T07, 68T09,, I.2.7; I.2.6; I.2.10 | Recent advancements in multimodal foundation models have showcased impressive
capabilities in understanding and reasoning with visual and textual
information. Adapting these foundation models trained for general usage to
specialized domains like biomedicine requires large-scale domain-specific
instruction datasets. While existing works have explored curating such datasets
automatically, the resultant datasets are not explicitly aligned with domain
expertise. In this work, we propose a data-centric framework, Biomedical Visual
Instruction Tuning with Clinician Preference Alignment (BioMed-VITAL), that
incorporates clinician preferences into both stages of generating and selecting
instruction data for tuning biomedical multimodal foundation models. First,
during the generation stage, we prompt the GPT-4V generator with a diverse set
of clinician-selected demonstrations for preference-aligned data candidate
generation. Then, during the selection phase, we train a separate selection
model, which explicitly distills clinician and policy-guided model preferences
into a rating function to select high-quality data for medical instruction
tuning. Results show that the model tuned with the instruction-following data
from our method demonstrates a significant improvement in open visual chat
(18.5% relatively) and medical VQA (win rate up to 81.73%). Our
instruction-following data and models are available at BioMed-VITAL.github.io. | [
-0.1609116941690445,
-0.7012557983398438,
0.6656112670898438,
-0.155302956700325,
-0.3002219498157501,
-0.14125995337963104,
-0.20517313480377197,
-0.09450829029083252,
0.09197478741407394,
0.5237555503845215,
-0.5284011960029602,
-0.8760362863540649,
-0.5404099822044373,
-0.33563119173049927,
0.39224544167518616,
1.133245825767517,
0.000021694406314054504,
0.4021522104740143,
-0.680804967880249,
-0.3176511228084564,
-0.9761831164360046,
-0.1542840152978897,
-0.42572975158691406,
-0.24692142009735107,
0.5064752697944641,
0.5882173180580139,
0.7901866436004639,
1.000950574874878,
0.6221649646759033,
0.26818567514419556,
0.3461245596408844,
0.3691248893737793,
-0.7120380401611328,
0.06812506169080734,
-0.331074595451355,
-0.3369857668876648,
-0.7135876417160034,
-0.07397012412548065,
0.31624412536621094,
0.6208631992340088,
0.02729426696896553,
0.23824360966682434,
-0.20112344622612,
0.8087784647941589,
-0.4970892369747162,
0.27682748436927795,
-0.5633361339569092,
0.05693826079368591,
-0.10519571602344513,
-0.7765308618545532,
-0.5103391408920288,
-0.460081547498703,
0.3060922622680664,
-0.6559445261955261,
0.3470555245876312,
-0.20981775224208832,
0.7130978107452393,
0.451150119304657,
-0.6349272131919861,
0.18317687511444092,
-0.24327120184898376,
0.7249956727027893,
-0.3141786456108093,
0.4458063542842865,
0.29786416888237,
0.45476940274238586,
-0.023072175681591034,
-0.48393264412879944,
-0.06906164437532425,
0.09211432188749313,
0.17585164308547974,
0.45309942960739136,
-0.019579358398914337,
0.3661365211009979,
0.15074683725833893,
0.0948573648929596,
-0.5980789065361023,
0.05221397057175636,
-0.4577171802520752,
-0.12875768542289734,
0.4738878309726715,
0.275483101606369,
0.2953629195690155,
0.05377144366502762,
-0.3869999647140503,
-0.28092095255851746,
-0.6695485711097717,
0.167290598154068,
0.004344655200839043,
0.1330977976322174,
-0.27227798104286194,
0.6791039705276489,
-0.24589422345161438,
1.0910753011703491,
0.3029155135154724,
-0.34288159012794495,
0.5685355067253113,
-0.44211602210998535,
-0.41565844416618347,
0.1360137015581131,
0.488603413105011,
0.7468418478965759,
0.20234376192092896,
0.0016013055574148893,
0.1527627408504486,
0.24699269235134125,
0.8120704889297485,
-0.8748981356620789,
-0.4970722496509552,
0.3111782670021057,
-0.41987305879592896,
-0.5756638050079346,
-0.3503588140010834,
-0.6682705283164978,
-0.26896122097969055,
-0.7008900046348572,
0.4666130244731903,
-0.6450322866439819,
0.13605648279190063,
0.27537432312965393,
0.10388699173927307,
-0.04148746281862259,
0.5628014802932739,
-1.0508229732513428,
-0.2737239897251129,
0.35584118962287903,
0.6401262283325195,
-0.22907257080078125,
0.15144750475883484,
-0.6202322244644165,
0.3302052915096283,
-0.27294060587882996,
0.6818056702613831,
-0.7284878492355347,
-0.43240588903427124,
-0.0682697743177414,
0.23703239858150482,
-0.2493779957294464,
-0.2587374746799469,
0.22870416939258575,
-0.379367858171463,
0.12326257675886154,
-0.21688182651996613,
-0.5581510663032532,
-0.06680656969547272,
0.19989655911922455,
-0.31265154480934143,
0.3465362787246704,
0.19749745726585388,
-0.6807072758674622,
0.6618521213531494,
-0.621691107749939,
-0.2693527638912201,
0.12893326580524445,
-0.6293215751647949,
-0.639875590801239,
-0.1455588936805725,
0.3658832907676697,
0.636086642742157,
0.09533058851957321,
0.27349257469177246,
-0.6411370038986206,
-0.15883110463619232,
0.13675448298454285,
-0.31946566700935364,
0.5686308741569519,
-0.17961689829826355,
-0.5518919825553894,
0.5060485601425171,
-0.8247123956680298,
0.264042466878891,
-0.17770738899707794,
0.016420330852270126,
-0.24165983498096466,
0.011453690007328987,
-0.32485926151275635,
0.11393783986568451,
0.04774898290634155,
-0.5121248960494995,
0.3844841718673706,
-0.22359712421894073,
0.29873278737068176,
0.8908494710922241,
0.10430333763360977,
0.4389609098434448,
-0.3119269609451294,
0.6381664872169495,
0.12185896933078766,
0.4758288860321045,
0.05586909502744675,
-0.6843801140785217,
-0.5603768825531006,
-0.6360698938369751,
0.10040894895792007,
0.4060133993625641,
-0.782639741897583,
0.09528844058513641,
-0.35564759373664856,
-0.29004231095314026,
-0.7378141283988953,
0.05522936210036278,
0.4849953353404999,
0.9424226880073547,
0.6943037509918213,
-0.18738162517547607,
-0.21155387163162231,
-1.0453542470932007,
0.36889463663101196,
0.15388572216033936,
0.3265419602394104,
0.8548915982246399,
0.10566648095846176,
-0.4265691041946411,
0.7569146752357483,
-0.5753868222236633,
-0.20953015983104706,
0.21893098950386047,
-0.05841672420501709,
0.045756321400403976,
0.5204856991767883,
0.793030858039856,
-0.8044130206108093,
-0.46123653650283813,
0.3146325945854187,
-0.7702540755271912,
-0.034140072762966156,
0.03461510315537453,
-0.7357116937637329,
-0.11206405609846115,
-0.01663878560066223,
-0.31203579902648926,
0.6776323914527893,
0.3951561152935028,
-0.28821155428886414,
0.3531828820705414,
-0.21642369031906128,
0.6558797359466553,
-1.0907964706420898,
0.023378292098641396,
-0.01671379804611206,
-0.30017903447151184,
-0.3677552342414856,
-0.16101400554180145,
0.26234984397888184,
-0.0042718141339719296,
-0.29561373591423035,
0.4636935293674469,
-0.28412583470344543,
0.29606708884239197,
-0.19826346635818481,
-0.18871496617794037,
0.0699499249458313,
0.32856717705726624,
0.3358451724052429,
0.6832176446914673,
0.6678449511528015,
-0.5102316737174988,
0.24603837728500366,
0.650069534778595,
-0.019483977928757668,
0.7305719256401062,
-0.5256128907203674,
0.0254000686109066,
-0.03322746604681015,
0.01880970597267151,
-0.7842478156089783,
-0.4804925322532654,
0.16890648007392883,
-0.3346904218196869,
0.6363219618797302,
-0.43950387835502625,
0.12453533709049225,
-0.20561714470386505,
-0.20923668146133423,
0.23121613264083862,
0.32630667090415955,
-0.5638375282287598,
0.19410718977451324,
0.40282538533210754,
-0.06824128329753876,
-0.8675487041473389,
-0.3975401222705841,
-0.34593185782432556,
-0.08612311631441116,
-0.6128510236740112,
0.4264717400074005,
-0.1147901713848114,
0.22238092124462128,
-0.19999314844608307,
-0.11773347109556198,
0.10546337813138962,
-0.24473372101783752,
0.6056635975837708,
0.7957258224487305,
-0.35333287715911865,
0.18108855187892914,
0.5223052501678467,
-0.05452495813369751,
-0.10508117079734802,
-0.4281882047653198,
0.013454882428050041,
0.11507581919431686,
-0.4996463656425476,
-0.31629592180252075,
0.2756254971027374,
0.5616244077682495,
-0.37004977464675903,
0.6878353953361511,
0.67063307762146,
-0.04593292251229286,
0.07958507537841797,
-0.4815855622291565,
-0.25801151990890503,
-0.44970524311065674,
0.3136066794395447,
-0.09920820593833923,
-0.8943005204200745,
-0.10786089301109314,
0.09372023493051529,
0.20082160830497742,
0.09824473410844803,
0.8300684690475464,
-0.23939207196235657,
1.2809374332427979,
0.5329693555831909,
0.3430853486061096,
0.4496438205242157,
-0.2562068998813629,
-0.16021758317947388,
-0.6214420199394226,
-0.24521507322788239,
0.01446552574634552,
-0.318256139755249,
-0.37273651361465454,
-0.5006641149520874,
0.8929245471954346,
-0.2667766511440277,
-0.19150157272815704,
-0.08699832856655121,
-0.7227299213409424,
0.3258885443210602,
0.39149805903434753,
0.6960165500640869,
-0.1540641486644745,
0.2233053743839264,
-0.2899417281150818,
-0.21046094596385956,
-0.7166545987129211,
-0.4303831160068512,
1.440868854522705,
0.1314258873462677,
0.7446550130844116,
0.1076170951128006,
0.6351139545440674,
-0.012734618037939072,
0.5098897218704224,
-0.5702900886535645,
0.14150120317935944,
-0.34910035133361816,
-0.4982920289039612,
-0.1079200729727745,
-0.4694894850254059,
-0.7671384811401367,
-0.022464560344815254,
-0.5733928084373474,
-0.6245774626731873,
0.4077499508857727,
0.6796262264251709,
-0.5693989992141724,
-0.005949362646788359,
-0.8220093846321106,
1.2089698314666748,
-0.32657182216644287,
-0.8877498507499695,
-0.20547360181808472,
-0.8854831457138062,
0.42036476731300354,
0.04220493137836456,
-0.1259031593799591,
0.030267199501395226,
0.1902128905057907,
0.16177131235599518,
-0.30788981914520264,
0.9519930481910706,
-0.21517951786518097,
0.19797946512699127,
-0.0850403755903244,
-0.23670132458209991,
0.025366146117448807,
0.38359394669532776,
0.2322520613670349,
-0.06756449490785599,
0.09841427952051163,
-0.4992457926273346,
-0.47107261419296265,
0.7900317311286926,
-0.794684112071991,
-0.46342888474464417,
0.007004613056778908,
-0.4315882921218872,
-0.7159036993980408,
0.06137044355273247,
0.4411281645298004,
0.8292428255081177,
-0.2145480364561081,
0.5089954733848572,
1.1104336977005005,
-0.2537836730480194,
-0.23609350621700287,
0.4743385314941406,
-0.04964131861925125,
-0.5642536878585815,
1.071155309677124,
-0.1488228589296341,
0.47080641984939575,
0.5974891185760498,
0.0733945369720459,
-0.22986729443073273,
-0.4555390179157257,
-1.006251335144043,
0.010235951282083988,
-0.6032902598381042,
-0.42130234837532043,
-0.7323413491249084,
-0.1044713482260704,
-0.4029231667518616,
-0.3604962229728699,
-0.22472220659255981,
-0.14395219087600708,
-0.5981247425079346,
-0.0008110132184810936,
0.5773465633392334,
0.11910200864076614,
0.19764123857021332,
0.26600342988967896,
-0.8764325976371765,
0.4522651731967926,
0.4079412519931793,
0.40068918466567993,
-0.41808515787124634,
-0.45977044105529785,
-0.38805603981018066,
0.18248185515403748,
-0.5240564346313477,
-0.8820409178733826,
0.15817159414291382,
0.24591706693172455,
0.5383137464523315,
0.6112998127937317,
-0.39967218041419983,
0.8395131826400757,
-0.6883918046951294,
0.35558053851127625,
0.3309440016746521,
-0.3259449005126953,
0.8776875734329224,
-0.40092065930366516,
0.13618288934230804,
0.7697870135307312,
0.4889695644378662,
0.18209189176559448,
-0.04941640421748161,
-0.4803534150123596,
-0.5324719548225403,
0.5947674512863159,
-0.018791481852531433,
-0.07078975439071655,
-0.009981398470699787,
0.3429432809352875,
0.4463122487068176,
0.34739455580711365,
-0.24455225467681885,
-0.2257823497056961,
-0.6396250128746033,
-0.5948872566223145,
-0.026704439893364906,
0.07320606708526611,
-0.5231117606163025,
-0.3831281363964081,
0.6707179546356201,
-0.5394678711891174,
0.2203516662120819,
-0.07159435003995895,
-0.004013453610241413,
-0.05373062193393707,
0.17711558938026428,
0.5363348722457886,
0.6862944960594177,
-0.3301126956939697,
-0.2850753962993622,
-0.3246016800403595,
-0.5964241027832031,
0.13346105813980103,
0.10989803075790405,
-0.0960773155093193,
-0.17102457582950592,
0.20240481197834015,
1.2416635751724243,
0.33396080136299133,
-0.6088142395019531,
0.7404747605323792,
-0.15097865462303162,
-0.3513396084308624,
0.334548681974411,
0.566372811794281,
-0.04004326090216637,
0.14000971615314484,
-0.2736881673336029,
0.3868858516216278,
0.3022058606147766,
-0.15267781913280487,
0.3098708987236023,
0.49549034237861633,
-0.5235081315040588,
-0.2747551500797272,
0.9344086647033691,
0.2748171389102936,
0.3561781346797943,
0.4843730628490448,
0.367488831281662,
0.019696349278092384,
0.41712358593940735,
0.46324217319488525,
0.5185555219650269,
-0.14577370882034302,
0.5798110961914062,
0.2649412751197815,
-0.1378372311592102,
0.16674119234085083,
0.3955904543399811,
-0.20410017669200897,
-0.7224998474121094,
-0.35810911655426025,
-0.5654063820838928,
-0.4039192795753479,
0.036643847823143005,
-0.8629564046859741,
0.4133724272251129,
-0.3425522744655609,
-0.5412783026695251,
0.3516466021537781,
-0.2671453356742859,
-0.9260748624801636,
0.4762260615825653,
0.0858088955283165,
0.5536770820617676,
-0.6794784069061279,
0.8498395681381226,
0.9286385774612427,
-0.41936567425727844,
-0.6619219183921814,
-0.4425338804721832,
0.27851974964141846,
-0.9061281681060791,
0.3898158669471741,
0.11010649055242538,
-0.032280333340168,
-0.022795217111706734,
-0.5465807318687439,
-0.4916626513004303,
1.1379379034042358,
0.4850921630859375,
-0.7344875335693359,
0.08326662331819534,
-0.2190319150686264,
0.5904479026794434,
-0.565761923789978,
0.25059154629707336,
0.3024800419807434,
0.16478581726551056,
0.09391959756612778,
-0.5395171642303467,
-0.3321506977081299,
-0.35207468271255493,
-0.17913614213466644,
0.20201940834522247,
-0.6234164237976074,
0.358999103307724,
-0.5214976668357849,
0.17399397492408752,
-0.17447736859321594,
0.36212971806526184,
0.4480787217617035,
0.3950479030609131,
0.3106631636619568,
0.4288199841976166,
0.5558971762657166,
0.01165322121232748,
0.8677107691764832,
-0.5502889752388,
-0.10715357214212418,
1.0263806581497192,
-0.23777960240840912,
0.34941667318344116,
0.43183061480522156,
0.04041406884789467,
0.240752711892128,
0.6314929127693176,
0.12426605820655823,
0.6391465663909912,
-0.39209696650505066,
-0.21238842606544495,
-0.4381605088710785,
0.0016236200463026762,
-0.6561352610588074,
0.5543339252471924,
0.41913601756095886,
-0.697446346282959,
0.18459226191043854,
0.14840178191661835,
-0.3234945237636566,
-0.15328669548034668,
-0.1778992861509323,
0.7984508275985718,
-0.1616230010986328,
-0.45663219690322876,
0.5754496455192566,
-0.36934852600097656,
0.0574575774371624,
-0.5640265941619873,
-0.36297598481178284,
-0.015925053507089615,
0.09226334095001221,
-0.2151930332183838,
-0.6936312317848206,
-0.19054238498210907,
-0.10792575031518936,
-0.47963646054267883,
-0.21638382971286774,
0.48282819986343384,
-0.6069847345352173,
-0.2860996127128601,
-0.04878922179341316,
0.4759015142917633,
-0.045298654586076736,
0.45524391531944275,
-0.7359346151351929,
-0.15165963768959045,
0.33544716238975525,
-0.07901713252067566,
0.4796219766139984,
0.4222526550292969,
-0.1604863554239273,
0.46690863370895386,
0.704621434211731,
0.10961467027664185,
-0.14094004034996033,
0.3679889738559723,
0.9106574654579163,
-0.3434197008609772,
-0.3638327121734619,
-0.49372896552085876,
0.4879104495048523,
-0.13851667940616608,
-0.5044106245040894,
0.3687528371810913,
0.4706934094429016,
0.48421207070350647,
-0.3161744773387909,
0.684811532497406,
0.2729252874851227,
0.4043738842010498,
-0.7063656449317932,
0.6543256044387817,
-0.5647628307342529,
0.010427418164908886,
-0.18911099433898926,
-0.5815132260322571,
-0.11461980640888214,
0.6015492081642151,
-0.34611809253692627,
0.06914396584033966,
0.4033094346523285,
0.8666446208953857,
-0.32522061467170715,
0.07265538722276688,
0.36415979266166687,
0.05396243929862976,
0.18301618099212646,
0.4483642578125,
0.2611929476261139,
0.036121394485235214,
-0.009354640729725361,
-0.32866424322128296,
-0.7558870911598206,
-0.3978421092033386,
-0.627375602722168,
-1.0541000366210938,
-0.23478814959526062,
-0.4496494233608246,
-0.30555909872055054,
0.280322790145874,
0.9402832388877869,
0.9465922713279724,
-0.7632321715354919,
0.25873324275016785,
0.23259489238262177,
-0.25417497754096985,
-0.23562005162239075,
-0.17524830996990204,
0.4025207757949829,
-0.34871700406074524,
-0.4232737421989441,
0.4618726074695587,
0.6266255378723145,
0.0825125128030777,
0.0843878984451294,
0.11121947318315506,
0.043134063482284546,
-0.01582186110317707,
0.580057680606842,
0.08253675699234009,
-0.43861350417137146,
-0.2645464837551117,
0.17998474836349487,
-0.28733330965042114,
0.29588958621025085,
0.6059194803237915,
-0.7623160481452942,
1.02761971950531,
0.17892472445964813,
0.7291076183319092,
0.4076176881790161,
0.15455473959445953,
0.6909611821174622,
-0.6321051716804504,
-0.12913835048675537,
0.12162026017904282,
0.22662663459777832,
0.40075141191482544,
-0.6050560474395752,
0.4016653001308441,
0.28800147771835327,
-0.6764325499534607,
-0.5616025328636169,
-0.10210398584604263,
-1.2382086515426636,
0.032209571450948715,
0.8623719215393066,
0.06549316644668579,
-0.3074449598789215,
0.14026235044002533,
-0.42826908826828003,
0.30257663130760193,
-0.3537411093711853,
0.7418856024742126,
0.30255141854286194,
-0.47510460019111633,
0.0752195492386818,
-0.7152665853500366,
0.6105306148529053,
0.32667046785354614,
-0.7833694219589233,
-0.2962034046649933,
0.7684826254844666,
0.3565482497215271,
-0.2727768123149872,
0.6349538564682007,
-0.20331501960754395,
0.6544767022132874,
-0.2589920163154602,
0.14973759651184082,
-0.1333000659942627,
-0.43057316541671753,
-0.016431499272584915,
-0.06998113542795181,
-0.4163672924041748,
-0.43614616990089417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13170v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13170v1 | Amphista: Accelerate LLM Inference with Bi-directional Multiple Drafting Heads in a Non-autoregressive Style | 2024-06-19T02:53:39 | 2024-06-19T02:53:39 | Zeping Li, Xinlong Yang, Ziheng Gao, Ji Liu, Zhuang Liu, Dong Li, Jinzhang Peng, Lu Tian, Emad Barsoum | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) inherently use autoregressive decoding, which
lacks parallelism in inference and results in significantly slow inference
speeds, especially when hardware parallel accelerators and memory bandwidth are
not fully utilized. In this work, we propose Amphista, a speculative decoding
algorithm that adheres to a non-autoregressive decoding paradigm. Owing to the
increased parallelism, our method demonstrates higher efficiency in inference
compared to autoregressive methods. Specifically, Amphista models an
Auto-embedding Block capable of parallel inference, incorporating
bi-directional attention to enable interaction between different drafting
heads. Additionally, Amphista implements Staged Adaptation Layers to facilitate
the transition of semantic information from the base model's autoregressive
inference to the drafting heads' non-autoregressive speculation, thereby
achieving paradigm transformation and feature fusion. We conduct a series of
experiments on a suite of Vicuna models using MT-Bench and Spec-Bench. For the
Vicuna 33B model, Amphista achieves up to 2.75$\times$ and 1.40$\times$
wall-clock acceleration compared to vanilla autoregressive decoding and Medusa,
respectively, while preserving lossless generation quality. | [
-0.298677921295166,
-0.8772459030151367,
0.6405565738677979,
0.5636071562767029,
-0.5130913853645325,
0.051661621779203415,
-0.12618385255336761,
-0.6656313538551331,
0.5354396104812622,
0.5955485701560974,
-0.7167973518371582,
-0.32734623551368713,
-0.6092800498008728,
0.3057262599468231,
-0.6155520081520081,
0.27965113520622253,
-0.0990278497338295,
-0.1359739899635315,
0.030164731666445732,
-0.016417231410741806,
-0.3365587890148163,
-0.21145571768283844,
-0.40855276584625244,
-0.041346319019794464,
0.4487520456314087,
0.43983519077301025,
0.4865090548992157,
1.0268434286117554,
0.36300384998321533,
0.3400293290615082,
0.2727414667606354,
0.45196300745010376,
-0.26617759466171265,
0.5388767123222351,
-0.10463821142911911,
-0.6277719140052795,
-0.5112348794937134,
-0.16757486760616302,
0.601337730884552,
0.4045182764530182,
-0.11072460561990738,
0.10634834319353104,
-0.3479202091693878,
0.5773090124130249,
-0.6228769421577454,
0.15840649604797363,
-0.6357163786888123,
-0.15625081956386566,
-0.41503968834877014,
-0.7896340489387512,
-0.6244568824768066,
-0.3077605366706848,
-0.0668758973479271,
-0.46351468563079834,
0.24991482496261597,
0.3338778018951416,
0.6289112567901611,
0.410531222820282,
-0.31154319643974304,
0.000672107795253396,
-0.7385511994361877,
0.5557711124420166,
-0.7053561806678772,
0.6923638582229614,
0.23110562562942505,
0.3321850597858429,
-0.13223548233509064,
-0.8199012279510498,
-0.8622986674308777,
0.1456412672996521,
0.3240543305873871,
0.1347517967224121,
-0.08428765088319778,
-0.01950858160853386,
0.08238904923200607,
0.384465754032135,
-0.5250598192214966,
0.33099162578582764,
-0.0075010089203715324,
-0.14174774289131165,
0.7631298899650574,
0.42994022369384766,
0.00834429170936346,
0.05813250318169594,
-0.14870122075080872,
-0.4844661355018616,
-0.686800479888916,
-0.24239705502986908,
0.4629420340061188,
0.2976764440536499,
-0.37955811619758606,
0.696114718914032,
-0.35734251141548157,
0.6930844187736511,
0.18578195571899414,
-0.08299548923969269,
0.2738470733165741,
-0.3260228931903839,
-0.25953564047813416,
-0.05544673278927803,
0.633733868598938,
0.16334164142608643,
-0.2876274585723877,
-0.4044535160064697,
-0.0016306842444464564,
0.3312739431858063,
0.06911629438400269,
-0.8447548747062683,
-0.47602009773254395,
0.3583216071128845,
-0.5039460062980652,
-0.023658515885472298,
-0.2281995266675949,
-1.0478017330169678,
-0.4559313952922821,
-0.16669821739196777,
0.23331408202648163,
-0.33797988295555115,
-0.25638511776924133,
0.4365752339363098,
-0.21110638976097107,
0.7199485301971436,
0.45461875200271606,
-0.9709455370903015,
0.016274016350507736,
0.3689051568508148,
0.7788280844688416,
-0.18306295573711395,
-0.48211684823036194,
-0.5073265433311462,
0.1334885209798813,
-0.45037686824798584,
1.3646986484527588,
-0.6429860591888428,
-0.37230148911476135,
-0.440606027841568,
-0.023383324965834618,
-0.15288099646568298,
-0.10940097272396088,
0.4526596963405609,
-0.5716618895530701,
-0.0067052291706204414,
-0.2621740996837616,
-0.3475897014141083,
-0.22400423884391785,
0.03876999020576477,
-0.5657942891120911,
0.523090124130249,
-0.08185923099517822,
-0.8881449103355408,
0.2536468505859375,
-0.40336114168167114,
-0.544073760509491,
-0.25597813725471497,
-0.22509144246578217,
-0.4253326654434204,
0.22834591567516327,
0.4345589876174927,
0.29409846663475037,
-0.7051911950111389,
0.017623502761125565,
-0.40526875853538513,
-0.3819960355758667,
-0.10519542545080185,
-0.5791707038879395,
0.7418494820594788,
0.105281300842762,
-0.4727085530757904,
0.22047680616378784,
-0.5149109959602356,
-0.2152462750673294,
0.2172759622335434,
-0.09722500294446945,
-0.21071135997772217,
-0.06846942007541656,
-0.2546687126159668,
0.21188247203826904,
-0.011854968965053558,
-0.4907383918762207,
0.2924266755580902,
-0.4190860986709595,
0.06887531280517578,
0.5885208249092102,
0.19839920103549957,
0.25524112582206726,
-0.2512536644935608,
0.42171889543533325,
0.1445627510547638,
-0.1287817806005478,
-0.15978935360908508,
-0.5311374068260193,
-0.9703875184059143,
-0.33777981996536255,
0.3016395568847656,
0.38979730010032654,
-1.1296967267990112,
0.2564604580402374,
-0.25674283504486084,
-0.5269250869750977,
-0.6948158740997314,
-0.02860158309340477,
0.3514600396156311,
0.4330770671367645,
0.4153802990913391,
-0.4815721809864044,
-0.7588565945625305,
-0.8921681046485901,
-0.4272427558898926,
-0.23076249659061432,
0.15578533709049225,
0.03788809850811958,
0.03323734924197197,
-0.1812123954296112,
0.5826103687286377,
-0.3171723783016205,
0.16912220418453217,
-0.2572081685066223,
0.4615156352519989,
0.18636274337768555,
0.23332299292087555,
0.3722149729728699,
-0.42940157651901245,
-0.4419049024581909,
0.007471184246242046,
-0.7152219414710999,
-0.2013363391160965,
-0.3343188166618347,
-0.4194105863571167,
0.2560238838195801,
0.4142075181007385,
-0.9235172867774963,
0.332221120595932,
0.6651743054389954,
-0.5815295577049255,
0.6829355359077454,
-0.1381186842918396,
0.11502807587385178,
-1.062422513961792,
0.011356011964380741,
-0.09898821264505386,
0.0021155886352062225,
-0.5758655071258545,
0.10632410645484924,
0.204586461186409,
0.34035027027130127,
-0.025838013738393784,
0.5783830285072327,
-0.8765212893486023,
-0.24546200037002563,
-0.6012663245201111,
0.03188499063253403,
0.12297313660383224,
0.4322679936885834,
0.43129783868789673,
1.1310452222824097,
0.6235848069190979,
-0.5041581392288208,
0.18429788947105408,
0.3120992183685303,
-0.06133783236145973,
0.26369521021842957,
-0.2781015634536743,
0.29478541016578674,
-0.2596305012702942,
0.29237183928489685,
-0.6995530724525452,
-0.16691522300243378,
0.03735633194446564,
-0.32283511757850647,
0.27975618839263916,
0.12596309185028076,
-0.6959490776062012,
-0.47829902172088623,
-0.3366779088973999,
0.25738370418548584,
0.40909016132354736,
-0.5185226798057556,
0.8293750286102295,
0.4047483503818512,
-0.09876777231693268,
-0.5814535617828369,
-0.7912176847457886,
0.205118790268898,
-0.14196981489658356,
-0.27194157242774963,
0.24587954580783844,
0.09666769206523895,
-0.27526769042015076,
-0.07834689319133759,
-0.02751137875020504,
0.1908273845911026,
-0.20192737877368927,
0.05681011825799942,
0.3826168477535248,
-0.3942098319530487,
-0.11702361702919006,
0.3377722501754761,
-0.10837982594966888,
0.1586064100265503,
-0.48498988151550293,
0.734394907951355,
-0.08685225248336792,
-0.3412948250770569,
-0.5995773673057556,
0.11872010678052902,
0.7972634434700012,
-0.2676387429237366,
0.6486061215400696,
0.4996068775653839,
0.04808276891708374,
-0.3357263207435608,
-0.8304045796394348,
-0.4318430721759796,
-0.47785231471061707,
0.2447427362203598,
-0.5344243049621582,
-0.40230122208595276,
0.5756767392158508,
0.03384024649858475,
0.21562731266021729,
0.4989739954471588,
0.9063049554824829,
0.19798722863197327,
0.5420750379562378,
0.633550763130188,
0.023537004366517067,
0.2582073211669922,
-0.34923407435417175,
0.13004492223262787,
-0.9512038826942444,
-0.36401015520095825,
-0.40113499760627747,
-0.2723214030265808,
-0.3516363203525543,
-0.9252750873565674,
-0.03531764820218086,
-0.32782289385795593,
0.13554833829402924,
0.6314883828163147,
-0.2702469229698181,
0.2088129222393036,
0.3967592418193817,
0.14327789843082428,
0.5974224805831909,
0.003729615593329072,
-0.2410101592540741,
0.2127969115972519,
-0.7107715010643005,
0.07299701124429703,
1.1453585624694824,
0.3188667893409729,
0.8584034442901611,
0.14035682380199432,
0.5277096033096313,
0.08362613618373871,
0.39750272035598755,
-0.6547654867172241,
0.5508313179016113,
0.02885703183710575,
-0.3878386616706848,
-0.3303455114364624,
-0.37581562995910645,
-0.7608319520950317,
0.5515235662460327,
-0.13870534300804138,
-0.4554217457771301,
0.7313477993011475,
0.04873130843043327,
-0.18797723948955536,
0.5801791548728943,
-0.602372944355011,
0.44875141978263855,
-0.04703491926193237,
-0.6473006010055542,
-0.37373220920562744,
-0.5042523741722107,
0.6154184937477112,
-0.19180864095687866,
-0.07960484176874161,
-0.22299513220787048,
-0.1262006163597107,
0.45998135209083557,
-0.196260005235672,
0.8529086709022522,
-0.23806707561016083,
-0.20398151874542236,
0.25321099162101746,
0.2681233882904053,
0.8092460036277771,
0.0775202140212059,
-0.3298425078392029,
0.0718352273106575,
-0.26314446330070496,
-0.46475720405578613,
-0.4587312638759613,
0.599409282207489,
-0.6422635316848755,
-0.6222215890884399,
-0.17771178483963013,
-1.015889286994934,
-0.7325324416160583,
0.23834553360939026,
0.24221588671207428,
0.35278233885765076,
0.09615011513233185,
-0.16814455389976501,
0.5384341478347778,
0.05019160360097885,
0.4738232493400574,
0.5496630668640137,
0.005437660496681929,
-0.08730433136224747,
0.7231796383857727,
-0.18211455643177032,
0.09615210443735123,
0.4860774874687195,
-0.09466111660003662,
-0.6239706873893738,
-1.0321083068847656,
-0.6201779246330261,
0.5424747467041016,
-0.6108711361885071,
-0.3161146342754364,
-0.9460791349411011,
-0.07593421638011932,
-0.25434210896492004,
0.030548222362995148,
-0.5047595500946045,
-0.5369422435760498,
0.012242031283676624,
0.022088829427957535,
0.5689471364021301,
0.40782344341278076,
0.03470337390899658,
0.17901493608951569,
-0.5039817690849304,
0.48706313967704773,
0.24679535627365112,
0.16817514598369598,
0.15985633432865143,
-0.6411715745925903,
-0.18132732808589935,
-0.264140248298645,
-0.026080051437020302,
-0.8119208216667175,
0.6386885046958923,
-0.17314596474170685,
0.6233927011489868,
0.22665902972221375,
0.10322625935077667,
1.0350607633590698,
-0.2486797720193863,
0.15626901388168335,
0.046704985201358795,
-0.7086671590805054,
0.03925326094031334,
-0.46265876293182373,
0.567051351070404,
0.6576262712478638,
0.04161443933844566,
-0.23998069763183594,
-0.6394644379615784,
-0.47253358364105225,
-0.676595151424408,
0.5442315340042114,
0.12787505984306335,
0.015744494274258614,
-0.07667573541402817,
0.2210727334022522,
0.3521641194820404,
0.22627529501914978,
-0.1500224620103836,
-0.12994921207427979,
-0.2731815576553345,
-0.038983579725027084,
0.04231135919690132,
-0.24580933153629303,
0.18358264863491058,
-0.338104248046875,
0.5661824345588684,
-0.17235632240772247,
0.6455033421516418,
0.33463233709335327,
-0.0994579866528511,
-0.18824782967567444,
-0.009402895346283913,
0.4614455997943878,
0.5060489177703857,
-0.11848480254411697,
0.2525905966758728,
0.18243879079818726,
-0.5725786685943604,
0.031188802793622017,
0.21678385138511658,
0.04867039993405342,
0.06062416732311249,
0.54470294713974,
0.9715676307678223,
0.08751881867647171,
-0.4860727787017822,
0.14788606762886047,
-0.3103857636451721,
-0.24428774416446686,
0.04095923900604248,
-0.13401105999946594,
0.2463366687297821,
0.49325597286224365,
0.4068109095096588,
0.16637365520000458,
0.2198084145784378,
-0.48345819115638733,
0.20155498385429382,
0.4196935296058655,
0.22106009721755981,
-0.44577425718307495,
0.6830783486366272,
0.26479533314704895,
0.1068238615989685,
0.5506350994110107,
-0.07834849506616592,
0.08302611857652664,
0.5441860556602478,
0.6030773520469666,
1.2062324285507202,
-0.3264995813369751,
-0.019724367186427116,
0.21203522384166718,
0.33349281549453735,
-0.12356895953416824,
0.5692713260650635,
-0.23766513168811798,
-0.5774903297424316,
-0.6060451865196228,
-0.8812529444694519,
-0.58555006980896,
-0.20410500466823578,
-0.45346176624298096,
0.01699623093008995,
-0.42114123702049255,
-0.050967924296855927,
-0.010602287948131561,
-0.11845579743385315,
-0.5158703923225403,
-0.21279171109199524,
0.10035520792007446,
1.2522659301757812,
-0.7873704433441162,
1.3707789182662964,
0.2815262973308563,
-0.07284581661224365,
-0.7167428135871887,
0.5892031192779541,
0.029046081006526947,
-0.8284107446670532,
0.37772005796432495,
0.06150496378540993,
-0.6228843927383423,
0.36540839076042175,
0.01820283755660057,
-0.9545064568519592,
1.2378292083740234,
0.45464661717414856,
-0.5746885538101196,
-0.292787104845047,
-0.3050663471221924,
0.4530399441719055,
-0.3884436786174774,
0.11731580644845963,
0.7434695363044739,
0.5454686880111694,
0.09313404560089111,
-0.9790277481079102,
0.17487278580665588,
-0.20461638271808624,
0.18395555019378662,
0.0938846543431282,
-0.6797986030578613,
0.9429538249969482,
-0.2362697720527649,
-0.44082391262054443,
0.23765486478805542,
0.9231036901473999,
0.38855835795402527,
-0.04944128915667534,
0.18785467743873596,
0.5331658124923706,
0.6354522109031677,
0.121809221804142,
1.1972734928131104,
-0.5566734671592712,
0.12447601556777954,
0.9173346757888794,
-0.3367658257484436,
0.9608792066574097,
0.7532104849815369,
-0.07322993874549866,
0.8923990726470947,
0.46424952149391174,
0.13469582796096802,
0.5685140490531921,
-0.3191007673740387,
-0.23611418902873993,
-0.3183857202529907,
0.18907275795936584,
-0.3018893599510193,
0.6186323761940002,
0.5276079177856445,
-0.3259168267250061,
-0.37350866198539734,
0.02679482288658619,
-0.18471170961856842,
-0.04480932652950287,
-0.10045620799064636,
0.5339351892471313,
0.06395354121923447,
-0.6454723477363586,
0.7923487424850464,
0.31343385577201843,
0.6584030389785767,
-0.5419966578483582,
0.0706549808382988,
-0.3984925150871277,
0.17936766147613525,
0.12179309129714966,
-0.661335825920105,
0.44453099370002747,
-0.37900224328041077,
0.013350486755371094,
0.02446300908923149,
0.4400165379047394,
-0.3301309049129486,
-0.5074126720428467,
0.4238986670970917,
0.7054054737091064,
-0.0040879398584365845,
0.09724045544862747,
-0.5176876783370972,
0.5103798508644104,
-0.2008383423089981,
-0.4068305492401123,
0.08228398114442825,
0.4390026330947876,
-0.20853650569915771,
0.7301167249679565,
0.8112071752548218,
0.14194640517234802,
0.15848954021930695,
-0.16194307804107666,
1.0295437574386597,
-0.7319533824920654,
-0.6380743384361267,
-0.9111891984939575,
0.11600706726312637,
0.004288746044039726,
-0.04099229723215103,
1.1728038787841797,
0.48267823457717896,
0.39056918025016785,
-0.11222060769796371,
0.5873940587043762,
-0.024785161018371582,
0.3420913517475128,
-0.9040831327438354,
0.5519896149635315,
-0.2516942024230957,
0.3058578073978424,
0.05423825606703758,
-0.8615458607673645,
-0.24457424879074097,
0.32318198680877686,
-0.45144152641296387,
-0.061316993087530136,
0.7964192032814026,
0.6828429102897644,
-0.1596500277519226,
0.1850074678659439,
0.2184882014989853,
0.5214717984199524,
-0.07687006145715714,
0.4860461950302124,
0.39509519934654236,
-0.2647145688533783,
0.17885343730449677,
-0.44949719309806824,
-0.060196880251169205,
-0.2981876730918884,
-0.6077607870101929,
-1.0230551958084106,
-0.46158283948898315,
0.020761564373970032,
-0.26615414023399353,
0.2599499821662903,
0.6184117197990417,
0.7916510701179504,
-0.6969770193099976,
-0.409685343503952,
-0.28313949704170227,
-0.15982326865196228,
-0.30359429121017456,
-0.19707612693309784,
0.4764176309108734,
-0.29987895488739014,
-0.7472235560417175,
0.7903562188148499,
0.560941219329834,
0.012064903974533081,
-0.5243839025497437,
-0.08304506540298462,
-0.3363325893878937,
0.4409767687320709,
0.5985816717147827,
0.5623180270195007,
-0.6812264323234558,
0.15637269616127014,
-0.10523442924022675,
0.01369463000446558,
0.06726573407649994,
0.9262852668762207,
-0.9144527316093445,
0.3979039490222931,
0.644814133644104,
0.6620801687240601,
0.9030646681785583,
0.14067518711090088,
0.6579137444496155,
-0.28152430057525635,
0.6891973614692688,
0.25173914432525635,
0.347989022731781,
0.18536293506622314,
-0.44266510009765625,
0.15621040761470795,
0.3151397407054901,
-0.18862195312976837,
-0.8643332719802856,
0.25738564133644104,
-0.7414751648902893,
-0.4059195816516876,
0.8813438415527344,
0.23543208837509155,
-0.6084046959877014,
-0.34612682461738586,
0.20038582384586334,
0.22060129046440125,
-0.2045658826828003,
0.8309787511825562,
0.25770822167396545,
-0.5441943407058716,
-0.6527096629142761,
-0.506065845489502,
0.3027423918247223,
0.3628845810890198,
-0.9504730701446533,
0.47888290882110596,
0.3368230164051056,
0.015362586826086044,
-0.0675976350903511,
0.7039299011230469,
-0.32916259765625,
0.5160555243492126,
0.7099650502204895,
0.06542260199785233,
-0.34357285499572754,
-0.6085304617881775,
-0.2384689301252365,
-0.01853141561150551,
0.2870386838912964,
0.01744239032268524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13167v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13167v1 | QRMeM: Unleash the Length Limitation through Question then Reflection Memory Mechanism | 2024-06-19T02:46:18 | 2024-06-19T02:46:18 | Bo Wang, Heyan Huang, Yixin Cao, Jiahao Ying, Wei Tang, Chong Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large language models (LLMs) have made notable advancements in natural
language processing, they continue to struggle with processing extensive text.
Memory mechanism offers a flexible solution for managing long contexts,
utilizing techniques such as compression, summarization, and structuring to
facilitate nuanced and efficient handling of large volumes of text. However,
existing techniques face challenges with static knowledge integration, leading
to insufficient adaptation to task-specific needs and missing
multi-segmentation relationships, which hinders the dynamic reorganization and
logical combination of relevant segments during the response process. To
address these issues, we introduce a novel strategy, Question then Reflection
Memory Mechanism (QRMeM), incorporating a dual-structured memory pool. This
pool synergizes static textual content with structured graph guidance,
fostering a reflective trial-and-error approach for navigating and identifying
relevant segments. Our evaluation across multiple-choice questions (MCQ) and
multi-document question answering (Multi-doc QA) benchmarks showcases QRMeM
enhanced performance compared to existing approaches. | [
-0.46814534068107605,
-0.9817904829978943,
0.9137725234031677,
0.11646624654531479,
-0.6102539896965027,
0.22770516574382782,
-0.21038983762264252,
-0.27551236748695374,
0.005193383898586035,
0.6457838416099548,
-0.5026787519454956,
-0.32564517855644226,
-0.2748391628265381,
0.03514266759157181,
-0.2007618099451065,
0.9205701351165771,
-0.2604104280471802,
-0.11733870953321457,
-0.6067004799842834,
-0.45864370465278625,
-0.6046899557113647,
-0.44942042231559753,
-0.7290160059928894,
-0.17881543934345245,
0.6852422952651978,
0.47804731130599976,
0.6015933752059937,
0.49239277839660645,
0.4987357556819916,
0.25441011786460876,
0.006239715032279491,
0.6685172319412231,
-0.4786529839038849,
0.42811620235443115,
-0.12548942863941193,
-0.4867422580718994,
-0.4044663608074188,
-0.2202559858560562,
1.032441258430481,
0.38847196102142334,
-0.20455129444599152,
0.29327014088630676,
0.14915721118450165,
0.7467160820960999,
-0.6115493774414062,
-0.03181738778948784,
-0.3611290454864502,
-0.11026663333177567,
-0.07432302087545395,
-0.5373548269271851,
-0.3969053328037262,
-0.24743765592575073,
0.1667861044406891,
-0.3234773576259613,
-0.12762178480625153,
0.2500935196876526,
0.5306533575057983,
0.2037336230278015,
-0.6738406419754028,
-0.3193490207195282,
-0.7162340879440308,
0.8326115012168884,
-0.5119497776031494,
0.2931321859359741,
0.1398683786392212,
0.38694247603416443,
0.005138746462762356,
-0.7216740250587463,
-0.5119209885597229,
0.04175427183508873,
-0.05093729496002197,
0.1627589613199234,
0.21155616641044617,
0.16839565336704254,
0.10941260308027267,
0.25180181860923767,
-0.874783456325531,
-0.31117919087409973,
-0.3706177771091461,
-0.1447266787290573,
0.4757097363471985,
0.3722132444381714,
0.5318552851676941,
-0.05378447100520134,
-0.671999990940094,
-0.12374939024448395,
-0.10364554077386856,
-0.1438809037208557,
0.18851208686828613,
0.15347807109355927,
0.2936666011810303,
0.48975813388824463,
-0.025185849517583847,
0.5398868918418884,
-0.43676912784576416,
-0.0893554836511612,
-0.12622149288654327,
-0.42533987760543823,
-0.028430623933672905,
0.039825692772865295,
0.6758081316947937,
0.45535093545913696,
-0.0506250374019146,
-0.19522610306739807,
-0.2282360941171646,
-0.2483430951833725,
0.474449098110199,
-0.9343066811561584,
0.1238749548792839,
0.4053117036819458,
-0.19711022078990936,
0.382287859916687,
0.039670269936323166,
-0.9472404718399048,
-0.0325436070561409,
-0.043667081743478775,
0.4892059564590454,
-0.6139741539955139,
-0.1268860101699829,
0.39264750480651855,
-0.40470027923583984,
0.23899124562740326,
0.2942773997783661,
-0.4856258034706116,
0.5789666175842285,
0.5471550226211548,
0.9394897222518921,
-0.053576286882162094,
-0.14561843872070312,
-0.608104407787323,
0.437458336353302,
0.06136760115623474,
0.8157472014427185,
-0.6873077154159546,
-0.3686100244522095,
-0.0734584778547287,
-0.26436182856559753,
-0.2889570891857147,
-0.5844414830207825,
0.47081613540649414,
-0.9863768815994263,
0.7321042418479919,
-0.24257107079029083,
-0.5032720565795898,
-0.45970165729522705,
0.4576621949672699,
-0.5541353225708008,
1.252496600151062,
0.4159258306026459,
-0.8612656593322754,
-0.1740046739578247,
-0.6558008790016174,
-0.36184778809547424,
-0.06485475599765778,
0.04711584746837616,
-0.3577393591403961,
0.07595966011285782,
0.04432445019483566,
0.2010701596736908,
-0.33864283561706543,
0.2590545415878296,
-0.10816307365894318,
-0.3956186771392822,
0.04879099503159523,
-0.23128929734230042,
0.3917842507362366,
-0.0059082661755383015,
0.0007894178852438927,
0.2611038088798523,
-0.7166184782981873,
0.2833644449710846,
0.27494192123413086,
-0.6159264445304871,
-0.6191557049751282,
0.02189595066010952,
-0.24791261553764343,
0.4843800961971283,
0.39117199182510376,
-0.3099973499774933,
0.17356161773204803,
-0.10568447411060333,
0.45388197898864746,
0.5289711952209473,
0.3250470459461212,
0.5129011869430542,
-0.4196637272834778,
0.7343320250511169,
-0.002826299285516143,
0.07935713231563568,
-0.32722094655036926,
-0.13712254166603088,
-0.6999988555908203,
-0.06763115525245667,
-0.022372817620635033,
0.6337081789970398,
-0.9605844616889954,
-0.07115679979324341,
-0.2275002896785736,
-0.02887071669101715,
-0.485668808221817,
0.33070290088653564,
0.5458874702453613,
0.6139813661575317,
0.801244854927063,
-0.3910955488681793,
-0.6813380122184753,
-0.928830087184906,
-0.1862345039844513,
-0.30089831352233887,
-0.10390794277191162,
0.28407740592956543,
0.28774479031562805,
-0.2215438187122345,
0.931632936000824,
-0.7200915217399597,
-0.15098954737186432,
-0.4161147177219391,
0.21827726066112518,
-0.14048220217227936,
0.11806351691484451,
0.10862614959478378,
-0.9291765689849854,
-0.23841750621795654,
-0.5956780314445496,
-0.5446423292160034,
-0.08260475844144821,
-0.2640352249145508,
-0.29288721084594727,
0.0046775080263614655,
0.4953530728816986,
-0.7382836937904358,
0.0181735772639513,
0.39911291003227234,
-0.22209176421165466,
0.6176409125328064,
-0.34605973958969116,
-0.028034737333655357,
-1.0577582120895386,
-0.111813984811306,
-0.1493494063615799,
-0.35331812500953674,
-0.5249196290969849,
0.2824467420578003,
0.2956213653087616,
0.05565460026264191,
-0.4434177577495575,
0.7159711122512817,
-0.8093723654747009,
0.15531036257743835,
-0.4172787666320801,
0.5472000241279602,
0.4650743305683136,
0.4996931254863739,
-0.17257773876190186,
0.8833024501800537,
-0.07809506356716156,
-0.7856233716011047,
0.16210013628005981,
0.34944117069244385,
-0.1462358832359314,
0.43126749992370605,
-0.3494792580604553,
0.45518967509269714,
-0.4368574917316437,
0.22327820956707,
-1.1598796844482422,
0.054224006831645966,
0.204769104719162,
-0.19524379074573517,
0.5058664083480835,
0.36183643341064453,
-0.6615098118782043,
-0.6166817545890808,
-0.6429495215415955,
0.6455639004707336,
0.45733025670051575,
-0.17036432027816772,
0.679895281791687,
0.2560907304286957,
-0.21627788245677948,
-0.3667466342449188,
-0.46285897493362427,
0.16916386783123016,
-0.24512998759746552,
-0.8485668301582336,
0.2161625176668167,
-0.2210136204957962,
-0.3030659854412079,
-0.06491787731647491,
-0.2663019299507141,
-0.10386395454406738,
-0.0005684035713784397,
0.023200511932373047,
0.12272477149963379,
-0.5111945867538452,
0.39170974493026733,
0.3153972327709198,
0.03332281857728958,
0.1174628809094429,
-0.23328456282615662,
0.748519778251648,
0.011086896993219852,
-0.12723124027252197,
-0.22078995406627655,
0.6405587196350098,
0.6344346404075623,
-0.41288864612579346,
0.9370745420455933,
0.4011816084384918,
-0.024460719898343086,
-0.33618661761283875,
-0.7144621014595032,
-0.3314119279384613,
-0.4513711929321289,
0.48238059878349304,
-0.305766224861145,
-1.2489957809448242,
0.5045526623725891,
-0.08021976798772812,
-0.03635198995471001,
0.16203029453754425,
0.3639981746673584,
-0.0010749133070930839,
0.9457728266716003,
0.5007175207138062,
0.07459844648838043,
0.2951028645038605,
0.0905560627579689,
0.36951830983161926,
-1.2662543058395386,
-0.1904064565896988,
-0.23614786565303802,
-0.40024736523628235,
0.0001759715669322759,
-0.8682162761688232,
0.3729191720485687,
0.20195695757865906,
-0.052942171692848206,
0.1697913110256195,
-0.25241440534591675,
0.23789341747760773,
0.48271819949150085,
0.19555093348026276,
0.36963003873825073,
-0.3719139099121094,
-0.27078646421432495,
0.12125042825937271,
-0.7329403162002563,
-0.7906815409660339,
0.7195078134536743,
0.40366092324256897,
0.3596436679363251,
0.016644641757011414,
0.6475828886032104,
-0.04492904245853424,
0.18069492280483246,
-0.5930382609367371,
1.037353277206421,
0.28241896629333496,
-0.5262455940246582,
-0.5851749777793884,
-0.46237269043922424,
-0.7061509490013123,
0.7328806519508362,
0.20718041062355042,
-0.3849114775657654,
-0.2542072534561157,
-0.07867936789989471,
-0.5528258681297302,
0.4917446970939636,
-0.5524972081184387,
0.5428118705749512,
-0.20735490322113037,
-0.5015595555305481,
-0.08242720365524292,
-0.8577648401260376,
0.3442593514919281,
-0.06811509281396866,
0.272471159696579,
-0.19534459710121155,
-0.35431939363479614,
0.7361528277397156,
-0.3373072147369385,
0.5060386657714844,
-0.08957666903734207,
-0.04853887856006622,
0.7660424113273621,
0.050104640424251556,
0.3779428005218506,
0.12352359294891357,
0.009419852867722511,
-0.22145676612854004,
0.015379520133137703,
-0.46522974967956543,
-0.7111397385597229,
0.23788343369960785,
-0.24110527336597443,
-0.8593763709068298,
-0.28430384397506714,
-0.800324022769928,
-0.4830259680747986,
0.31889238953590393,
-0.050012871623039246,
0.29413902759552,
-0.25122323632240295,
0.094838947057724,
0.7800997495651245,
-0.2561248540878296,
0.6366720199584961,
0.7358404397964478,
-0.2118600606918335,
-0.36794939637184143,
0.5659008026123047,
0.0005583607708103955,
0.30683937668800354,
0.6297028660774231,
0.11984575539827347,
-0.417121559381485,
-0.6446564793586731,
-0.3112640082836151,
0.4156506657600403,
-0.3357226252555847,
-0.2305547446012497,
-0.9519263505935669,
-0.2704024314880371,
-0.19748839735984802,
0.16849592328071594,
-0.2036098688840866,
-0.2547667324542999,
-0.3085957467556,
-0.1641968935728073,
-0.052729103714227676,
0.17521701753139496,
0.364164799451828,
0.21821708977222443,
-1.1587063074111938,
0.42650240659713745,
0.6215634942054749,
0.20967048406600952,
0.11127498000860214,
-0.466421514749527,
-0.2345713973045349,
0.0532371811568737,
-0.29552990198135376,
-0.863371729850769,
0.33492180705070496,
0.14793618023395538,
0.30897289514541626,
0.40149742364883423,
0.20043905079364777,
0.7018612623214722,
-0.8064680695533752,
0.5084314942359924,
0.03607255220413208,
-0.5775629878044128,
0.46027788519859314,
-0.36732569336891174,
0.5931819081306458,
0.796196460723877,
0.3590400815010071,
-0.7128620743751526,
-0.6335294842720032,
-0.24604205787181854,
-0.999600350856781,
0.34686946868896484,
0.03506496548652649,
0.39549413323402405,
-0.3164858818054199,
0.5559245944023132,
0.0015163227217271924,
0.3871621787548065,
-0.26244473457336426,
0.11509515345096588,
0.24735955893993378,
-0.09997779875993729,
0.06557593494653702,
-0.9003289937973022,
-0.13783493638038635,
-0.006499937269836664,
0.4871176481246948,
-0.19795075058937073,
0.20978154242038727,
0.3882369101047516,
-0.27036571502685547,
-0.06369424611330032,
0.711895763874054,
0.8386040329933167,
0.9084439277648926,
-0.3876288831233978,
0.4283270835876465,
0.14825057983398438,
-0.5105357766151428,
0.08746552467346191,
-0.10959162563085556,
-0.03275943547487259,
-0.08379063755273819,
0.2600977420806885,
0.502284586429596,
0.38800233602523804,
-0.94264155626297,
0.27928802371025085,
-0.16741016507148743,
-0.36156708002090454,
-0.011568330228328705,
0.20700067281723022,
0.2640897333621979,
0.3761897683143616,
0.42004939913749695,
-0.5884892344474792,
0.18190832436084747,
-0.7846362590789795,
0.38919752836227417,
0.32216066122055054,
-0.5291641354560852,
-0.22245006263256073,
0.6391338109970093,
-0.041071802377700806,
-0.1963629275560379,
0.8197184801101685,
-0.30333414673805237,
-0.6531942486763,
0.47083526849746704,
0.5976948738098145,
0.6582152247428894,
-0.4043385982513428,
0.4047941565513611,
0.19919443130493164,
0.236529141664505,
-0.40084174275398254,
0.5752100944519043,
0.0058573163114488125,
-0.7373637557029724,
-0.3652907907962799,
-0.7183401584625244,
-0.25125232338905334,
-0.1828812211751938,
-0.9527705907821655,
-0.21866123378276825,
-0.47431477904319763,
-0.18830610811710358,
-0.5644358992576599,
0.05830669030547142,
-0.16362805664539337,
0.20764131844043732,
0.09521771222352982,
1.0450764894485474,
-0.4558808505535126,
0.7808005213737488,
0.6710934638977051,
-0.27968013286590576,
-0.6463471055030823,
-0.05893075093626976,
-0.043524812906980515,
-0.835919976234436,
0.2693611681461334,
0.3057323098182678,
-0.18777775764465332,
-0.023380331695079803,
-0.371212363243103,
-0.5011211037635803,
1.1239128112792969,
0.09819495677947998,
-0.5914505124092102,
-0.19867835938930511,
0.062206611037254333,
0.6399173736572266,
-0.2077007293701172,
0.08960025757551193,
0.4472794830799103,
0.5196118950843811,
0.1440715193748474,
-0.5254631638526917,
0.4048614501953125,
-0.15060341358184814,
0.12864649295806885,
0.6393521428108215,
-1.1572868824005127,
0.7626231908798218,
-0.36644041538238525,
-0.432107150554657,
-0.13643202185630798,
0.7902396321296692,
0.3236798942089081,
0.5289512872695923,
0.4089696407318115,
0.6251893043518066,
0.9136852622032166,
0.24004797637462616,
0.9320328831672668,
-0.31043997406959534,
0.17230235040187836,
1.393406629562378,
-0.5782636404037476,
0.9098575711250305,
0.7200669646263123,
-0.009613120928406715,
0.7936072945594788,
0.2812234163284302,
0.22438009083271027,
0.40158921480178833,
0.2612135112285614,
-0.47592151165008545,
-0.3485880196094513,
-0.13153032958507538,
-0.3150911033153534,
0.2847067415714264,
0.19485951960086823,
-0.18979185819625854,
-0.3045750558376312,
0.00012861670984420925,
0.1061214804649353,
0.2213396430015564,
-0.20295202732086182,
0.7371183037757874,
0.36583536863327026,
-0.6250656247138977,
0.13500648736953735,
0.07760126888751984,
0.31131088733673096,
-0.719254195690155,
-0.023929042741656303,
-0.2565780580043793,
-0.08939263224601746,
0.15943816304206848,
-0.7019287943840027,
0.4054247736930847,
-0.4280417263507843,
-0.3629379868507385,
-0.4317151606082916,
0.7686862349510193,
-0.6400285363197327,
-0.09896676242351532,
0.4812895357608795,
0.6683420538902283,
-0.20817826688289642,
-0.4507092237472534,
-0.46139225363731384,
-0.1474153697490692,
-0.27512824535369873,
-0.47240325808525085,
0.5255123972892761,
0.5829604864120483,
-0.07171007245779037,
0.8652562499046326,
0.43643417954444885,
-0.25907227396965027,
0.09731488674879074,
-0.045170336961746216,
1.0283387899398804,
-0.8585957288742065,
-0.5170202255249023,
-1.0470181703567505,
0.4784989356994629,
-0.19518455862998962,
-0.010059741325676441,
1.001721978187561,
0.9154353737831116,
0.5381568074226379,
0.25603386759757996,
0.4134114384651184,
0.494139164686203,
0.5819577574729919,
-0.68017578125,
0.4099547564983368,
-0.6618829965591431,
0.27984216809272766,
0.08695030957460403,
-0.9312383532524109,
-0.3312663435935974,
0.16742867231369019,
-0.3910163342952728,
0.02632695436477661,
1.1770622730255127,
0.5575813055038452,
0.13335241377353668,
0.03975534811615944,
0.2153654545545578,
0.14330293238162994,
0.1138312965631485,
0.8959526419639587,
0.8673045039176941,
-0.20910696685314178,
0.7754718661308289,
0.11598946899175644,
-0.0353948213160038,
-0.28881868720054626,
-0.5597401261329651,
-1.0057837963104248,
-0.3865903317928314,
-0.3068360686302185,
-0.34988075494766235,
0.024587901309132576,
0.4454500377178192,
0.546197235584259,
-0.4230829179286957,
-0.10067809373140335,
0.2629477083683014,
0.3081686496734619,
-0.012021967209875584,
-0.26770859956741333,
0.3275572657585144,
-0.44405075907707214,
-0.22143805027008057,
0.3047318756580353,
0.9937896132469177,
-0.010529404506087303,
-0.14479559659957886,
0.08678918331861496,
-0.37587565183639526,
0.4229041039943695,
0.6870160698890686,
0.2917579412460327,
-0.22151713073253632,
-0.3260315954685211,
0.02629920095205307,
-0.342097669839859,
0.35783541202545166,
1.00404953956604,
-0.4679913818836212,
0.385210245847702,
0.5831130146980286,
0.7089738845825195,
0.36942383646965027,
0.2566162645816803,
0.4847746789455414,
-0.6430477499961853,
-0.03653515502810478,
0.5508401989936829,
0.09931408613920212,
0.02059066854417324,
-0.3531690537929535,
0.30595457553863525,
-0.11213316768407822,
-0.5298110842704773,
-0.7853034734725952,
0.18009687960147858,
-1.0131436586380005,
-0.6350805759429932,
1.1545497179031372,
0.06674980372190475,
-0.4238888919353485,
-0.27518224716186523,
-0.3871481120586395,
0.270022451877594,
-0.29811856150627136,
0.7843451499938965,
0.8500173091888428,
-0.13223403692245483,
-0.5719692707061768,
-0.8054957985877991,
0.12041136622428894,
0.4047251045703888,
-0.8657726645469666,
-0.201100692152977,
0.512588620185852,
0.13721753656864166,
0.08610071241855621,
0.9574412703514099,
-0.16938403248786926,
0.02078704535961151,
-0.17057989537715912,
-0.14721137285232544,
-0.23456525802612305,
-0.36163899302482605,
-0.17144761979579926,
0.6950855851173401,
-0.1955750435590744,
-0.19561557471752167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13163v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13163v1 | LLMatDesign: Autonomous Materials Discovery with Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T02:35:02 | 2024-06-19T02:35:02 | Shuyi Jia, Chao Zhang, Victor Fung | cond-mat.mtrl-sci | cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cs.AI, cs.CL | Discovering new materials can have significant scientific and technological
implications but remains a challenging problem today due to the enormity of the
chemical space. Recent advances in machine learning have enabled data-driven
methods to rapidly screen or generate promising materials, but these methods
still depend heavily on very large quantities of training data and often lack
the flexibility and chemical understanding often desired in materials
discovery. We introduce LLMatDesign, a novel language-based framework for
interpretable materials design powered by large language models (LLMs).
LLMatDesign utilizes LLM agents to translate human instructions, apply
modifications to materials, and evaluate outcomes using provided tools. By
incorporating self-reflection on its previous decisions, LLMatDesign adapts
rapidly to new tasks and conditions in a zero-shot manner. A systematic
evaluation of LLMatDesign on several materials design tasks, in silico,
validates LLMatDesign's effectiveness in developing new materials with
user-defined target properties in the small data regime. Our framework
demonstrates the remarkable potential of autonomous LLM-guided materials
discovery in the computational setting and towards self-driving laboratories in
the future. | [
-0.07320183515548706,
-0.5163853764533997,
1.1820203065872192,
0.14312642812728882,
0.016567053273320198,
0.4490368366241455,
-0.11319708824157715,
-0.2380361407995224,
0.3177720904350281,
0.27872735261917114,
-0.8178801536560059,
-0.6412584185600281,
-0.2811443507671356,
0.31966322660446167,
-0.20934025943279266,
0.40821200609207153,
-0.5106779336929321,
0.04909119755029678,
-0.3054580092430115,
0.12786012887954712,
-0.23570717871189117,
-0.04966036602854729,
-0.21090897917747498,
-0.5075592398643494,
0.5353989601135254,
0.413492351770401,
0.5007838606834412,
0.7485207319259644,
0.3268482983112335,
0.41104304790496826,
0.05342927947640419,
0.2715549170970917,
-0.18434639275074005,
0.0630732923746109,
-0.3872934579849243,
-0.5581247806549072,
-0.3792538642883301,
0.09889291971921921,
0.45229241251945496,
0.7669137120246887,
-0.08922208845615387,
0.3501810133457184,
0.03919225186109543,
0.6161332130432129,
-0.3341701328754425,
0.4255349636077881,
-0.5204806923866272,
0.40895968675613403,
-0.29532745480537415,
-0.44818922877311707,
-0.49286168813705444,
0.10876968502998352,
-0.22087275981903076,
-0.7108349800109863,
0.37901127338409424,
0.10769869387149811,
0.3293231725692749,
0.3608086407184601,
-0.296023428440094,
-0.4472469389438629,
-0.7581189274787903,
0.8369956612586975,
-0.4900890588760376,
0.5552630424499512,
0.05673741176724434,
0.47073933482170105,
-0.5267816185951233,
-0.5316000580787659,
-0.39061692357063293,
-0.3389196991920471,
-0.027335530146956444,
0.02468097023665905,
0.38606345653533936,
-0.004100153222680092,
-0.0594332292675972,
0.41037511825561523,
-0.7902846932411194,
0.3826124966144562,
-0.16110044717788696,
-0.35416051745414734,
0.6660737991333008,
0.37460198998451233,
0.3125307559967041,
0.08468136191368103,
-0.4739166796207428,
0.019835853949189186,
-0.8003931045532227,
-0.5198251008987427,
0.2219168096780777,
0.6052168011665344,
-0.03564612567424774,
0.6311657428741455,
-0.41499122977256775,
0.26988840103149414,
-0.2699001431465149,
0.009429519064724445,
0.24756722152233124,
-0.23801667988300323,
-0.23143170773983002,
0.08917520940303802,
0.7757027745246887,
0.06260522454977036,
-0.044389113783836365,
-0.19814226031303406,
-0.4369634687900543,
-0.06346619874238968,
0.08028935641050339,
-0.9466814994812012,
-0.36452150344848633,
0.268955796957016,
-0.4931398332118988,
-0.47860532999038696,
-0.23813362419605255,
-0.5203021168708801,
-0.9950337409973145,
-0.6052573323249817,
0.39717429876327515,
0.18572799861431122,
-0.36380934715270996,
0.332614004611969,
-0.008717706426978111,
-0.0922447070479393,
0.6208469867706299,
-1.0570966005325317,
0.22877268493175507,
0.3671945333480835,
0.864553689956665,
-0.4470777213573456,
-0.35314905643463135,
-0.24446547031402588,
-0.000039881666452856734,
-0.5446622967720032,
0.9818637371063232,
-0.18275783956050873,
-0.6962054371833801,
-0.5306376218795776,
0.1393517702817917,
0.3719981908798218,
-0.745358407497406,
0.2340109646320343,
-0.22856569290161133,
-0.04212971404194832,
-0.20068763196468353,
-0.174001544713974,
0.10714563727378845,
-0.1005726158618927,
-0.7193044424057007,
0.6287821531295776,
0.2627571225166321,
-0.32558518648147583,
0.16131767630577087,
-0.6748822331428528,
-0.3773629069328308,
0.2776799201965332,
-0.7071954011917114,
-0.5683534145355225,
0.49210190773010254,
-0.1315385401248932,
0.45501047372817993,
-0.6510673761367798,
0.22361211478710175,
-0.3978155851364136,
-0.23118166625499725,
0.3317825496196747,
-0.39214327931404114,
0.4519048035144806,
0.37512919306755066,
-0.3112168610095978,
0.24072706699371338,
-0.822223424911499,
-0.10176244378089905,
0.3967185914516449,
-0.45383206009864807,
0.013699070550501347,
0.08837293088436127,
0.23056650161743164,
0.25881731510162354,
0.3718252182006836,
-0.753013551235199,
0.13735826313495636,
-0.2642848789691925,
0.3005771040916443,
1.2798410654067993,
-0.21883273124694824,
0.8190699815750122,
-0.2359561026096344,
0.5375545024871826,
-0.4168334901332855,
0.08569487929344177,
-0.08493439853191376,
-0.0672532394528389,
-0.6750423908233643,
-0.019868377596139908,
0.03414586931467056,
0.17295429110527039,
-0.6259827613830566,
0.02315940149128437,
-0.08956880122423172,
-0.47808563709259033,
-0.16900750994682312,
0.541932225227356,
-0.043438076972961426,
0.2519805431365967,
0.17874029278755188,
-0.2935568690299988,
-0.5348393321037292,
-0.9359394311904907,
-0.07666829228401184,
0.13894614577293396,
-0.23964086174964905,
0.5335592031478882,
0.5109770894050598,
-0.6651172041893005,
0.9580361247062683,
-0.6861637234687805,
-0.44433146715164185,
-0.11931166052818298,
0.158732607960701,
0.38923102617263794,
0.26912975311279297,
0.32610711455345154,
-0.5199590921401978,
-0.4457469582557678,
0.3704197108745575,
-1.0908619165420532,
-0.20083238184452057,
-0.4942874014377594,
-0.05812463164329529,
0.04021264612674713,
0.771355152130127,
-0.492523193359375,
-0.03283809497952461,
0.3974514901638031,
-0.10931446403265,
0.5136576294898987,
-0.22657884657382965,
-0.3620702922344208,
-0.8161005973815918,
-0.06066322326660156,
0.011532576754689217,
0.010727053508162498,
-0.29724636673927307,
0.043579794466495514,
0.03282371535897255,
-0.3123917877674103,
-0.6985118389129639,
1.0377602577209473,
-0.7503021955490112,
-0.21225734055042267,
-0.5395646095275879,
-0.18003784120082855,
0.0038276277482509613,
0.4000163972377777,
0.05782923847436905,
0.8214651942253113,
0.37871992588043213,
-0.5138314366340637,
0.3269309401512146,
0.14012955129146576,
-0.3677962124347687,
0.5612682104110718,
-0.5848064422607422,
0.1521143913269043,
-0.20523089170455933,
0.2161337435245514,
-0.7548002600669861,
-0.35557469725608826,
0.08736056089401245,
-0.18202516436576843,
0.22169040143489838,
0.12369347363710403,
-0.7673403024673462,
-0.3629852533340454,
-0.18692053854465485,
0.4399276375770569,
-0.058416493237018585,
-0.8321801424026489,
1.1863765716552734,
0.3009469509124756,
-0.2894842028617859,
-0.0616665855050087,
-0.50140780210495,
0.11732080578804016,
-0.07938970625400543,
-0.4726238548755646,
0.6031562685966492,
-0.8015475869178772,
-0.31529322266578674,
-0.4086030125617981,
-0.37535035610198975,
0.11080579459667206,
0.4525843858718872,
0.43905049562454224,
0.1554107964038849,
-0.004786020610481501,
0.24719759821891785,
-0.0879179984331131,
-0.35073843598365784,
0.19297607243061066,
-0.23248501121997833,
0.8607746958732605,
-0.044756755232810974,
-0.35943546891212463,
-0.3245592713356018,
0.3007981479167938,
0.6937622427940369,
-0.12654894590377808,
0.14192479848861694,
0.3314109742641449,
-0.23009677231311798,
-0.7981255054473877,
-0.08044598251581192,
-0.28048449754714966,
-0.7208889126777649,
0.34871581196784973,
-0.6386061310768127,
-0.5611706376075745,
0.5106248259544373,
-0.46223780512809753,
0.1099371463060379,
0.35815921425819397,
0.8124000430107117,
-0.26070380210876465,
1.0133533477783203,
0.8883518576622009,
0.08350210636854172,
0.44187554717063904,
-0.12609164416790009,
0.0638355240225792,
-0.5503388047218323,
-0.2327987402677536,
-0.06247498467564583,
-0.3058724105358124,
-0.5189395546913147,
-0.33543407917022705,
0.50836580991745,
-0.6986571550369263,
-0.277139276266098,
0.18541017174720764,
-0.6434998512268066,
0.7599868774414062,
0.1716405749320984,
0.18257270753383636,
0.39596301317214966,
-0.02329583652317524,
-0.16705265641212463,
0.07701309770345688,
-0.47878751158714294,
-0.36798712611198425,
1.2004302740097046,
0.47211065888404846,
1.2699052095413208,
-0.04779571294784546,
0.8011808395385742,
0.4486513137817383,
0.27873867750167847,
-0.7940893769264221,
0.6395639181137085,
0.1791488230228424,
-0.6031076908111572,
-0.15390630066394806,
-0.4387531578540802,
-0.9538156986236572,
0.12365321815013885,
-0.18927577137947083,
-0.15280093252658844,
0.1806371957063675,
-0.18329989910125732,
-0.20904234051704407,
0.1742464154958725,
-0.4923263490200043,
0.5802597999572754,
-1.0101052522659302,
-0.3760753273963928,
-0.15436133742332458,
-0.19435924291610718,
0.10052644461393356,
-0.5273606777191162,
0.45548900961875916,
-0.38327574729919434,
0.00023462457465939224,
0.5466038584709167,
-0.06485513597726822,
0.9107596278190613,
0.0012979189632460475,
-0.630416989326477,
0.07321194559335709,
0.5547143220901489,
0.4474896490573883,
0.005102341528981924,
-0.24844709038734436,
-0.14355547726154327,
-0.3722701668739319,
-0.1846991330385208,
-0.6534612774848938,
0.8929466009140015,
-0.45571789145469666,
-0.5198206901550293,
-0.3725360631942749,
-0.70894855260849,
0.17097751796245575,
0.4751869738101959,
0.06001279503107071,
0.025184040889143944,
-0.3915490508079529,
-0.012834359891712666,
0.5798320174217224,
-0.4067423939704895,
0.24791741371154785,
0.8676543235778809,
-0.2861846685409546,
-0.12095754593610764,
1.4844534397125244,
0.09308015555143356,
0.09144186228513718,
0.2704905569553375,
0.2771354019641876,
-0.30625879764556885,
-0.6251438856124878,
-0.564517080783844,
0.3278524875640869,
-0.8134987950325012,
-0.07164237648248672,
-0.1731223165988922,
-0.23455911874771118,
-0.0742708146572113,
-0.35615408420562744,
-0.6292782425880432,
-0.20165228843688965,
-0.4764940142631531,
-0.24057215452194214,
0.16225434839725494,
1.034737229347229,
-0.02221868559718132,
0.13053260743618011,
-0.3031439781188965,
0.4499506652355194,
0.3049294054508209,
0.725913941860199,
-0.22363612055778503,
-0.19420747458934784,
-0.37027040123939514,
-0.2665303647518158,
-0.12864035367965698,
-0.47007837891578674,
0.3720884621143341,
-0.14598503708839417,
0.7489361763000488,
0.09931643307209015,
0.10508213192224503,
-0.13628289103507996,
-0.6704071164131165,
0.1831831932067871,
-0.004480462986975908,
-0.6055601835250854,
0.5920855402946472,
-0.5193499326705933,
0.3132809102535248,
0.3276757001876831,
0.3350782096385956,
-0.31260016560554504,
0.19939690828323364,
-0.527485191822052,
-0.867495596408844,
0.31040841341018677,
-0.01917031593620777,
-0.026840664446353912,
0.2685029208660126,
0.14074835181236267,
0.3390763998031616,
0.050654370337724686,
-0.9711019992828369,
-0.19090624153614044,
0.11228083819150925,
-0.3855849504470825,
-0.15369826555252075,
-0.01460062712430954,
-0.2473791539669037,
0.08675386756658554,
0.42748409509658813,
-0.44274455308914185,
0.3899785280227661,
-0.09882119297981262,
-0.1645374298095703,
-0.133414626121521,
0.0911981463432312,
0.6111220717430115,
0.29131945967674255,
-0.25893348455429077,
0.1401963233947754,
0.11683238297700882,
-0.1454368680715561,
0.34196150302886963,
0.12292366474866867,
-0.0026311876717954874,
-0.04323503002524376,
-0.12231491506099701,
0.42235803604125977,
-0.09177443385124207,
-0.7903557419776917,
0.18798452615737915,
-0.07361939549446106,
-0.42503809928894043,
-0.5946685075759888,
0.07735241204500198,
-0.1527414619922638,
0.43937626481056213,
0.36388877034187317,
0.006511001382023096,
0.22249090671539307,
-0.6154628396034241,
0.32642072439193726,
0.5548959970474243,
-0.07129640877246857,
-0.1913849413394928,
0.8539476990699768,
0.35374099016189575,
-0.4313526451587677,
0.3447742760181427,
-0.17196454107761383,
-0.21374106407165527,
0.6892222762107849,
0.41873475909233093,
0.8658958673477173,
-0.12999789416790009,
0.32994192838668823,
0.041473206132650375,
0.14963170886039734,
-0.0253288596868515,
0.07453268766403198,
-0.4356119632720947,
-0.6442237496376038,
0.04699386656284332,
-0.6918512582778931,
-0.7138282656669617,
0.009450516663491726,
-0.030917977914214134,
0.4225451946258545,
-0.8342801332473755,
0.20953746140003204,
0.05528078228235245,
0.14474372565746307,
-0.4542592465877533,
0.33407920598983765,
0.3080899119377136,
0.6257060766220093,
-1.012004017829895,
0.4907263219356537,
0.12747424840927124,
-0.19754108786582947,
-0.21856136620044708,
-0.4466053545475006,
0.5108263492584229,
-0.9065293669700623,
0.7114278674125671,
0.18893302977085114,
-0.4548172056674957,
0.024477792903780937,
-0.5512098670005798,
-1.1763150691986084,
1.416953444480896,
0.38080763816833496,
-0.3587537705898285,
0.07996372878551483,
0.3990582823753357,
0.3500592112541199,
-0.27337533235549927,
0.14716458320617676,
0.3756437599658966,
0.4040400981903076,
0.09577728807926178,
-0.7415862083435059,
0.19393189251422882,
-0.48415154218673706,
-0.22293129563331604,
0.05459343269467354,
-0.5082807540893555,
0.8696825504302979,
-0.12646569311618805,
-0.4856311082839966,
0.2950027585029602,
0.6244580149650574,
0.469848096370697,
0.3206286132335663,
0.2305418848991394,
0.26489967107772827,
0.7533823847770691,
0.14724960923194885,
0.9042834043502808,
-0.012370409443974495,
0.1691390424966812,
1.098282814025879,
-0.41700032353401184,
0.5042940378189087,
0.23451398313045502,
-0.14129036664962769,
0.416936993598938,
0.7673187255859375,
-0.2622579336166382,
0.5075757503509521,
0.5259435176849365,
-0.40996986627578735,
-0.2095225304365158,
-0.2755959928035736,
-0.09293175488710403,
0.3637034296989441,
0.5370867848396301,
-0.4149702191352844,
-0.3925803005695343,
0.11924616992473602,
-0.3365406095981598,
0.2632012665271759,
-0.138373002409935,
0.39265725016593933,
0.01935715787112713,
0.000760664523113519,
0.43365755677223206,
0.09423211216926575,
0.6657952666282654,
-0.3151521682739258,
-0.11950049549341202,
-0.3284150958061218,
0.2972813844680786,
-0.2848612070083618,
-0.8643180727958679,
0.10321331024169922,
-0.543941080570221,
-0.18718048930168152,
-0.6860759854316711,
0.4719012379646301,
-0.04671832174062729,
-0.5670625567436218,
0.21253280341625214,
0.6222898364067078,
-0.006186170037835836,
-0.11625806987285614,
-0.48197850584983826,
0.23053081333637238,
-0.06751047819852829,
0.044054362922906876,
0.36823776364326477,
0.4330686032772064,
-0.1455591470003128,
0.9984765648841858,
0.8002116680145264,
-0.14596709609031677,
-0.33867213129997253,
0.04804394766688347,
0.8628641963005066,
-0.6620457172393799,
-0.19768519699573517,
-0.6132373809814453,
0.2494705468416214,
0.13539883494377136,
0.15807436406612396,
0.7047522664070129,
0.9049127101898193,
0.7769777178764343,
-0.24991373717784882,
0.7803390622138977,
0.39766189455986023,
0.539682924747467,
-0.6709312200546265,
0.7400769591331482,
-0.6810569167137146,
0.5738293528556824,
-0.08764883875846863,
-0.6883214116096497,
-0.5038748383522034,
0.804183840751648,
-0.06819378584623337,
-0.02902420610189438,
0.45727118849754333,
1.0633050203323364,
-0.16815777122974396,
-0.31777769327163696,
0.10667583346366882,
0.34928563237190247,
0.6786377429962158,
0.357125848531723,
0.8091742396354675,
-0.0376974381506443,
0.31088438630104065,
-0.09638359397649765,
-0.10281436145305634,
-0.11630195379257202,
-0.7976788878440857,
-0.8249313235282898,
-0.5884592533111572,
-0.09522992372512817,
-0.05710510537028313,
-0.4207405745983124,
0.9841920733451843,
0.64003586769104,
-0.4621456563472748,
-0.5048180818557739,
-0.6599278450012207,
0.1870986670255661,
0.3542560338973999,
-0.17919735610485077,
0.2513764500617981,
-0.14691975712776184,
-0.7997766137123108,
0.9669944643974304,
0.4745909571647644,
0.4041159152984619,
-0.65102618932724,
-0.2307693213224411,
0.28920701146125793,
0.10117750614881516,
0.6611522436141968,
0.605862021446228,
-0.4424736201763153,
0.2092725932598114,
0.36763840913772583,
-0.22798828780651093,
0.2127344012260437,
0.597613513469696,
-0.8929973840713501,
0.5875535011291504,
0.4308638572692871,
0.6709616184234619,
0.6435118317604065,
-0.49466899037361145,
0.8004164695739746,
-0.4600686728954315,
0.0260333102196455,
0.105046346783638,
0.44219541549682617,
0.25956231355667114,
-0.40713173151016235,
0.6679787039756775,
0.17568565905094147,
-0.5244345664978027,
-0.6469746828079224,
0.5601284503936768,
-1.079401969909668,
-0.6546311974525452,
1.0293773412704468,
0.5511162877082825,
-0.45402732491493225,
0.10940387845039368,
-0.37630635499954224,
-0.19368627667427063,
-0.16635383665561676,
0.9944252371788025,
0.22192491590976715,
-0.2547445297241211,
-0.18606320023536682,
-0.6474980711936951,
0.3913099765777588,
0.4421536326408386,
-0.9025945663452148,
0.21066814661026,
0.4479973316192627,
0.3838115632534027,
0.13740113377571106,
0.6329673528671265,
-0.011042159050703049,
0.2624375522136688,
-0.17837713658809662,
0.03653305768966675,
-0.10399478673934937,
-0.6616856455802917,
-0.19159692525863647,
-0.17979466915130615,
0.18857912719249725,
0.1258460283279419
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13161v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13161v1 | APPL: A Prompt Programming Language for Harmonious Integration of Programs and Large Language Model Prompts | 2024-06-19T02:29:59 | 2024-06-19T02:29:59 | Honghua Dong, Qidong Su, Yubo Gao, Zhaoyu Li, Yangjun Ruan, Gennady Pekhimenko, Chris J. Maddison, Xujie Si | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.PL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have become increasingly capable of handling
diverse tasks with the aid of well-crafted prompts and integration of external
tools, but as task complexity rises, the workflow involving LLMs can be
complicated and thus challenging to implement and maintain. To address this
challenge, we propose APPL, A Prompt Programming Language that acts as a bridge
between computer programs and LLMs, allowing seamless embedding of prompts into
Python functions, and vice versa. APPL provides an intuitive and Python-native
syntax, an efficient parallelized runtime with asynchronous semantics, and a
tracing module supporting effective failure diagnosis and replaying without
extra costs. We demonstrate that APPL programs are intuitive, concise, and
efficient through three representative scenarios: Chain-of-Thought with
self-consistency (CoT-SC), ReAct tool use agent, and multi-agent chat.
Experiments on three parallelizable workflows further show that APPL can
effectively parallelize independent LLM calls, with a significant speedup ratio
that almost matches the estimation. | [
-0.2589963674545288,
-0.8121125102043152,
0.7173923254013062,
0.4748724400997162,
0.1382012516260147,
0.4535152018070221,
-0.26595786213874817,
-0.1794411540031433,
-0.14692537486553192,
0.26980772614479065,
-0.4398142695426941,
-0.44099995493888855,
-0.08555346727371216,
0.2892937660217285,
-0.273881733417511,
0.6816808581352234,
-0.28091660141944885,
-0.0899084210395813,
-0.26069918274879456,
-0.23194995522499084,
-0.7937825918197632,
-0.321928471326828,
-0.7179850935935974,
-0.5101108551025391,
0.5731478929519653,
0.45776471495628357,
0.9481467008590698,
0.6909601092338562,
0.3556218147277832,
0.3167153596878052,
0.21575289964675903,
-0.0019027941161766648,
-0.06232593208551407,
0.36657559871673584,
-0.36574143171310425,
-0.552429735660553,
-0.15538381040096283,
-0.21458157896995544,
0.41792386770248413,
0.8614460229873657,
-0.2057771384716034,
0.11284728348255157,
-0.002242501126602292,
0.6155543327331543,
-0.34063956141471863,
0.36373022198677063,
-0.27356070280075073,
-0.056732792407274246,
-0.05708291009068489,
-0.10281447321176529,
-0.3836721181869507,
-0.4922914206981659,
-0.12385319173336029,
-0.3005508482456207,
-0.33221957087516785,
0.21481938660144806,
0.2740001380443573,
0.18512479960918427,
-0.03126926347613335,
-0.4331498444080353,
-0.4628182053565979,
0.7977839112281799,
-0.592619776725769,
0.1985776573419571,
-0.08571279048919678,
0.5218825936317444,
-0.2399553805589676,
-0.7829297780990601,
-0.793761134147644,
-0.44246283173561096,
0.03210955485701561,
-0.22936424612998962,
-0.01632622629404068,
0.020356155931949615,
0.28296807408332825,
0.18893064558506012,
-0.6643092036247253,
0.16698676347732544,
-0.03557726368308067,
-0.2551337778568268,
0.424686998128891,
0.8005050420761108,
0.7882375121116638,
0.31854248046875,
-0.3436640501022339,
0.04838449880480766,
-0.7645445466041565,
0.33016130328178406,
0.13779668509960175,
0.7797982096672058,
-0.36319538950920105,
0.5055050253868103,
-0.18209050595760345,
1.1135085821151733,
-0.55210942029953,
0.08551705628633499,
-0.03867034614086151,
-0.40061327815055847,
0.027681490406394005,
0.10502171516418457,
0.9957866072654724,
0.19501478970050812,
0.3189097046852112,
0.07887811958789825,
-0.30093494057655334,
0.39856311678886414,
-0.10852515697479248,
-0.5553461313247681,
-0.16325944662094116,
0.6070727109909058,
-0.2767159938812256,
-0.11092225462198257,
-0.2576541304588318,
-0.11650697886943817,
-0.7019603252410889,
-0.5300154089927673,
0.20095881819725037,
-0.3680678606033325,
0.029416875913739204,
0.0246408861130476,
0.05051145702600479,
0.17449237406253815,
0.7114076018333435,
-0.578426718711853,
0.0908718928694725,
0.7987780570983887,
0.9365708827972412,
-0.23297898471355438,
-0.5457311868667603,
-0.8829281330108643,
-0.1753542721271515,
-0.5265761017799377,
0.6306754946708679,
-0.5431681871414185,
-0.1834057718515396,
0.025941520929336548,
-0.19602251052856445,
-0.12480217218399048,
-0.4642006456851959,
0.22978460788726807,
-0.43793442845344543,
0.0036760978400707245,
-0.11230152100324631,
-0.49678757786750793,
-0.010329554788768291,
0.3646828234195709,
-0.36075565218925476,
0.9250490069389343,
0.23142217099666595,
-0.5229682326316833,
-0.04467041417956352,
-0.6263023018836975,
-0.5371344685554504,
0.3210812211036682,
-0.3203757107257843,
0.15306875109672546,
-0.11976096779108047,
-0.18366765975952148,
0.34030184149742126,
-0.4845685064792633,
0.342087060213089,
-0.48306941986083984,
-0.4288933277130127,
0.05906480550765991,
-0.27535280585289,
0.9151865243911743,
0.5330337882041931,
-0.12152953445911407,
0.3860616683959961,
-0.3683323562145233,
0.019553814083337784,
-0.03658748418092728,
-0.47365400195121765,
-0.266762375831604,
-0.156855046749115,
0.035966623574495316,
0.1976310759782791,
0.6005224585533142,
-0.446295827627182,
0.6541080474853516,
-0.27855634689331055,
0.5090680122375488,
0.5865488052368164,
-0.5748600959777832,
0.31025248765945435,
-0.2753058075904846,
0.5672939419746399,
-0.15711751580238342,
0.19735102355480194,
-0.8970816731452942,
-0.5538507699966431,
-0.4550655484199524,
-0.20887871086597443,
-0.14020217955112457,
0.6836630702018738,
-0.7500343918800354,
0.22932671010494232,
0.2784395217895508,
-0.19128715991973877,
-0.4971737563610077,
0.2882469594478607,
0.21629001200199127,
0.7080495953559875,
0.10364485532045364,
0.01602797582745552,
-0.5253433585166931,
-0.634056568145752,
-0.26571232080459595,
-0.4517287313938141,
0.1688583791255951,
0.429478257894516,
0.0742257833480835,
-0.35609549283981323,
1.0721701383590698,
-0.2521965503692627,
-0.012681190855801105,
-0.5735926032066345,
0.10894715040922165,
0.7893775105476379,
0.2346874326467514,
0.17523528635501862,
-0.4913633465766907,
-1.1407634019851685,
0.23704718053340912,
-0.9323464632034302,
-0.5441828370094299,
-0.11849157512187958,
0.037055935710668564,
0.12543770670890808,
0.4055638909339905,
-0.7062782049179077,
0.05752275139093399,
0.4485722482204437,
-0.7162777185440063,
0.8144148588180542,
-0.5545516014099121,
0.08761235326528549,
-0.8453481197357178,
0.05446020886301994,
-0.45449644327163696,
-0.39439696073532104,
-0.7183681726455688,
0.01979541964828968,
0.23492194712162018,
-0.3408799469470978,
-0.47379761934280396,
0.850259006023407,
-0.49242451786994934,
-0.14493480324745178,
-0.4188409447669983,
0.09119443595409393,
0.05548672750592232,
-0.07379977405071259,
-0.09753847867250443,
1.0468263626098633,
0.9919701218605042,
-0.36698204278945923,
0.8629276156425476,
0.16132982075214386,
0.1831778883934021,
0.7016053795814514,
-0.5625503659248352,
-0.012843226082623005,
0.11724766343832016,
0.027265625074505806,
-0.9027338624000549,
-0.0785888209939003,
0.05118142068386078,
-0.04261766001582146,
0.09369398653507233,
0.3260476291179657,
-0.44705596566200256,
-0.5139739513397217,
-0.4463724195957184,
0.3427288830280304,
0.4926200807094574,
-0.8173723220825195,
0.5303168892860413,
-0.0653771162033081,
-0.19768686592578888,
-0.49119141697883606,
-0.3669421374797821,
0.32588252425193787,
-0.14322954416275024,
-0.7192155122756958,
-0.06535231322050095,
-0.32321906089782715,
-0.5016631484031677,
-0.11558248847723007,
0.29610610008239746,
-0.04116932675242424,
0.03144819289445877,
0.0036498578265309334,
0.4457871913909912,
-0.27940407395362854,
-0.0602581687271595,
-0.46389853954315186,
-0.16936935484409332,
-0.20591716468334198,
-0.4074663817882538,
0.6530988216400146,
-0.6309441328048706,
-0.572987973690033,
-0.6285324692726135,
0.505331814289093,
1.022020697593689,
0.008915680460631847,
0.43484535813331604,
0.32212337851524353,
0.05032345652580261,
-0.27897727489471436,
-0.42998698353767395,
0.008626701310276985,
-0.4799096882343292,
-0.0888461247086525,
-0.3235454857349396,
-0.7671531438827515,
0.8377148509025574,
-0.09000162780284882,
0.047128431499004364,
-0.15611810982227325,
0.7143844366073608,
-0.059567246586084366,
1.1094074249267578,
0.4366895854473114,
-0.2665439546108246,
0.5119470357894897,
0.18767376244068146,
0.177402526140213,
-0.5006390810012817,
-0.10763007402420044,
-0.3668438494205475,
-0.07356628775596619,
0.021658755838871002,
-0.5081745982170105,
0.22848421335220337,
0.17277254164218903,
-0.5176846385002136,
0.25824296474456787,
-0.3711901307106018,
0.4465750455856323,
0.656254768371582,
-0.2916325628757477,
0.27132269740104675,
-0.5041922330856323,
-0.1935206651687622,
0.10592617839574814,
-0.7820847034454346,
-0.467077374458313,
0.6391316652297974,
0.23308300971984863,
1.2954368591308594,
-0.03646213933825493,
0.7643488645553589,
0.671055018901825,
0.25393250584602356,
-0.7791808247566223,
0.5367120504379272,
-0.08781793713569641,
0.03631109371781349,
-0.20490489900112152,
-0.1408434361219406,
-0.8410534262657166,
0.051439978182315826,
0.3250880241394043,
-0.9399290084838867,
-0.09040422737598419,
0.34553855657577515,
-0.6336156129837036,
0.0357811376452446,
-0.8633618354797363,
1.0633243322372437,
-0.27925029397010803,
-0.5214423537254333,
0.037113118916749954,
-0.5548915266990662,
0.31523528695106506,
-0.057542119175195694,
0.44959190487861633,
-0.2784181535243988,
-0.03998025506734848,
0.07908076047897339,
-0.8938151001930237,
0.6755746603012085,
-0.06656107306480408,
-0.16300679743289948,
0.5978518724441528,
0.2627524137496948,
0.9506391882896423,
-0.01933855190873146,
0.1140637993812561,
-0.013715098612010479,
-0.020442785695195198,
-0.0841173306107521,
-0.708002507686615,
0.8912219405174255,
-0.32390400767326355,
-0.4696446657180786,
-0.2490190714597702,
-0.934920072555542,
-0.02032070979475975,
0.14372707903385162,
-0.3872329294681549,
0.6533092260360718,
0.3382132947444916,
-0.1531653255224228,
0.283096045255661,
-0.4986445903778076,
0.9210871458053589,
0.8108540177345276,
-0.3990478217601776,
-0.09883889555931091,
1.0576251745224,
-0.2979738116264343,
0.1979387402534485,
0.030076494440436363,
0.3708589971065521,
-0.5348445177078247,
-0.049356475472450256,
-0.6353064179420471,
0.10201200842857361,
-0.6434495449066162,
-0.2770466208457947,
-0.5118517875671387,
0.004467419348657131,
0.03252280503511429,
-0.5836250185966492,
-0.6446252465248108,
-0.26199570298194885,
-0.20653031766414642,
0.40400606393814087,
0.3440432548522949,
0.6112461090087891,
-0.056749943643808365,
0.03310332074761391,
-0.8227025866508484,
0.24217651784420013,
0.03579063341021538,
0.32892024517059326,
-0.029963308945298195,
-0.009898137301206589,
-0.07401426136493683,
-0.4978763163089752,
-0.026136474683880806,
-0.8369302749633789,
0.2067459225654602,
0.24342095851898193,
0.5964458584785461,
0.36158987879753113,
0.4144953787326813,
0.3557877838611603,
-0.6800963878631592,
0.9857426285743713,
0.5337520837783813,
-0.9571102857589722,
0.6462958455085754,
-0.3480461537837982,
0.43417075276374817,
0.18925021588802338,
0.06921212375164032,
-0.7766263484954834,
-0.6926221251487732,
-0.2722082734107971,
-0.7296996712684631,
0.7479872703552246,
-0.11410615593194962,
0.12848734855651855,
-0.2389378845691681,
0.01065991073846817,
0.1995791792869568,
0.3115856349468231,
-0.41893425583839417,
-0.306479811668396,
0.10220923274755478,
-0.4869040250778198,
-0.00031408341601490974,
-0.13808022439479828,
-0.14618420600891113,
-0.22864942252635956,
0.11093156039714813,
-0.34566059708595276,
-0.03712592273950577,
0.07121677696704865,
0.016094092279672623,
0.3271688222885132,
0.3190357983112335,
0.4578552842140198,
0.5545265674591064,
0.18985360860824585,
0.5531259775161743,
-0.025918010622262955,
-0.13825632631778717,
0.30921465158462524,
-0.10090824961662292,
-0.08721542358398438,
-0.12109562754631042,
0.4569675922393799,
0.5234585404396057,
-0.03781143203377724,
-1.1798328161239624,
0.5271337628364563,
-0.1525360643863678,
0.2505338191986084,
0.09972663223743439,
0.15990155935287476,
0.08774318546056747,
0.7216607332229614,
0.12049174308776855,
-0.13115975260734558,
0.1754264086484909,
-0.6974998116493225,
0.36241036653518677,
0.5348654389381409,
-0.37743034958839417,
-0.36892640590667725,
0.9018769860267639,
0.22151018679141998,
-0.6533371210098267,
0.3946438133716583,
-0.20307335257530212,
-0.579189658164978,
0.4571135640144348,
0.7147522568702698,
0.9012371301651001,
-0.2501122057437897,
0.18137280642986298,
0.18849274516105652,
0.13416923582553864,
-0.20524190366268158,
0.7569196820259094,
-0.12220705300569534,
-0.5302332639694214,
-0.4414626359939575,
-0.6110670566558838,
-0.5527626872062683,
-0.31823015213012695,
-0.09829507023096085,
0.3660285174846649,
-0.35440999269485474,
0.09934306144714355,
-0.39873096346855164,
-0.40199336409568787,
-0.4213133454322815,
-0.18786190450191498,
0.2901459336280823,
1.0665287971496582,
-0.8823626041412354,
0.7453495264053345,
1.0628695487976074,
-0.3055937588214874,
-1.1050814390182495,
-0.428587406873703,
0.05352698266506195,
-0.834129810333252,
0.8896641731262207,
0.3397834897041321,
0.09775703400373459,
0.07628592848777771,
-0.17961035668849945,
-0.4170949459075928,
0.853337824344635,
0.6596097946166992,
-0.41956469416618347,
0.44210028648376465,
0.2862514555454254,
0.39984822273254395,
-0.6846296191215515,
0.615595281124115,
0.6792372465133667,
0.40454235672950745,
0.15738874673843384,
-1.2072027921676636,
0.27626824378967285,
-0.11033208668231964,
0.18826547265052795,
-0.02404395304620266,
-0.5903275012969971,
1.312067985534668,
-0.5599060654640198,
-0.14243175089359283,
0.01532275415956974,
0.25052395462989807,
0.2302989810705185,
0.43341246247291565,
0.38666728138923645,
0.11338020116090775,
0.8537705540657043,
-0.048157669603824615,
1.1482505798339844,
-0.8106985688209534,
0.2774367332458496,
0.7962250709533691,
-0.3796307146549225,
0.5586522817611694,
0.5618306398391724,
-0.32860878109931946,
0.4606249928474426,
0.5593553185462952,
0.4024389982223511,
0.4459206461906433,
0.1432938277721405,
-0.6880694031715393,
-0.32582801580429077,
-0.44939568638801575,
-0.29230496287345886,
0.11385045200586319,
0.2336582988500595,
-0.10384570062160492,
-0.5661616325378418,
0.07203015685081482,
-0.20452629029750824,
0.1430724561214447,
-0.2701229751110077,
0.4943215250968933,
0.23735052347183228,
-0.7373772859573364,
0.6328158378601074,
-0.33894360065460205,
0.49260255694389343,
-0.5657767057418823,
-0.2091619074344635,
-0.5034845471382141,
0.4028078615665436,
-0.06895830482244492,
-1.0157263278961182,
0.3484152555465698,
-0.08237559348344803,
-0.14021843671798706,
-0.3591400980949402,
0.7863032817840576,
-0.5081018209457397,
0.08830958604812622,
0.29725325107574463,
0.4804615378379822,
0.28460603952407837,
-0.0937330573797226,
-0.8522279858589172,
0.5261327624320984,
-0.13815270364284515,
-0.27512097358703613,
0.1296682506799698,
0.35697638988494873,
-0.27737897634506226,
1.1650053262710571,
0.6578214764595032,
0.0329945906996727,
0.029487352818250656,
0.23735129833221436,
0.8681424856185913,
-0.6332201361656189,
-0.818315863609314,
-1.260472297668457,
0.6355081796646118,
0.0024502682499587536,
0.21206127107143402,
0.8357449173927307,
0.47589167952537537,
0.19199098646640778,
-0.06012452021241188,
0.8452353477478027,
-0.19772005081176758,
0.21101604402065277,
-0.2933447062969208,
0.5782984495162964,
-0.4462429881095886,
0.6412084102630615,
-0.005160437896847725,
-0.8182843923568726,
-0.2213897854089737,
0.4481922388076782,
0.1109836995601654,
-0.24968287348747253,
0.5901042819023132,
0.639617919921875,
0.1376400887966156,
-0.015626955777406693,
0.3919967710971832,
-0.07603675127029419,
0.5459322333335876,
0.7705866694450378,
1.2446850538253784,
0.15566064417362213,
0.3383706212043762,
0.04078090935945511,
-0.5427486896514893,
-0.2593914270401001,
-1.037111520767212,
-0.8735105395317078,
-0.16234029829502106,
-0.2573028802871704,
-0.27811044454574585,
-0.07161521166563034,
0.9543512463569641,
0.38736140727996826,
-0.7869694232940674,
-0.5584812164306641,
-0.343813419342041,
0.35874515771865845,
-0.2416585236787796,
-0.2352806180715561,
0.05486125871539116,
-0.9351741671562195,
-0.621049165725708,
0.6411020755767822,
0.6806008219718933,
-0.23474988341331482,
-0.4540793299674988,
-0.47640687227249146,
0.192811518907547,
-0.014275455847382545,
0.5878605842590332,
0.805130660533905,
-0.6955700516700745,
-0.3146277666091919,
-0.09522534161806107,
-0.2734006941318512,
-0.11028244346380234,
0.7943066954612732,
-0.6246368885040283,
0.9332630038261414,
0.5648961663246155,
0.7880002856254578,
-0.28188571333885193,
0.06286401301622391,
0.9723212122917175,
-0.7397862672805786,
0.1772334724664688,
0.0025860436726361513,
0.4485102593898773,
0.4311189651489258,
-0.30304333567619324,
0.3589111566543579,
0.374336838722229,
-0.5193514227867126,
-1.0026518106460571,
0.33659714460372925,
-0.7688176035881042,
-0.17615261673927307,
1.001166582107544,
-0.3329333961009979,
-0.08615094423294067,
-0.3411037027835846,
-0.5516253709793091,
-0.1473381072282791,
-0.39085763692855835,
0.4026288390159607,
0.6082073450088501,
-0.7881085276603699,
-0.0721854567527771,
-0.6212233901023865,
0.3606584966182709,
0.11239633709192276,
-0.643567681312561,
0.47433561086654663,
0.4595695436000824,
0.03627905622124672,
0.18285156786441803,
0.9268419742584229,
0.2745087742805481,
0.19892960786819458,
0.1551746129989624,
0.12755689024925232,
-0.3961695730686188,
-0.2972674071788788,
-0.36753660440444946,
0.061610400676727295,
0.24204231798648834,
-0.16803881525993347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13152v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13152v1 | Analyzing Diversity in Healthcare LLM Research: A Scientometric Perspective | 2024-06-19T02:00:51 | 2024-06-19T02:00:51 | David Restrepo, Chenwei Wu, Constanza Vásquez-Venegas, João Matos, Jack Gallifant, Luis Filipe | cs.CL | cs.CL | The deployment of large language models (LLMs) in healthcare has demonstrated
substantial potential for enhancing clinical decision-making, administrative
efficiency, and patient outcomes. However, the underrepresentation of diverse
groups in the development and application of these models can perpetuate
biases, leading to inequitable healthcare delivery. This paper presents a
comprehensive scientometric analysis of LLM research for healthcare, including
data from January 1, 2021, to June 16, 2024. By analyzing metadata from PubMed
and Dimensions, including author affiliations, countries, and funding sources,
we assess the diversity of contributors to LLM research. Our findings highlight
significant gender and geographic disparities, with a predominance of male
authors and contributions primarily from high-income countries (HICs). We
introduce a novel journal diversity index based on Gini impurity to measure the
inclusiveness of scientific publications. Our results underscore the necessity
for greater representation in order to ensure the equitable application of LLMs
in healthcare. We propose actionable strategies to enhance diversity and
inclusivity in artificial intelligence research, with the ultimate goal of
fostering a more inclusive and equitable future in healthcare innovation. | [
0.0544251874089241,
-0.20500704646110535,
0.56391441822052,
0.3579421639442444,
0.10688192397356033,
0.411025732755661,
-0.10176397860050201,
-0.7859652042388916,
0.42591622471809387,
0.09769901633262634,
-0.45330169796943665,
-0.46197760105133057,
-0.8215382695198059,
0.2619273066520691,
-0.2296067625284195,
0.8895868062973022,
0.2394970953464508,
0.744912326335907,
-0.4237111210823059,
-0.18171511590480804,
-0.07549598067998886,
-0.4889191687107086,
-0.10923880338668823,
-0.44448328018188477,
0.636661946773529,
0.1408042013645172,
0.5534175038337708,
0.6715855598449707,
0.8704474568367004,
0.2961213290691376,
-0.22833353281021118,
-0.0348094180226326,
-0.39020851254463196,
0.08039438724517822,
-0.019759349524974823,
-0.6522659659385681,
-0.44771233201026917,
-0.25964853167533875,
0.9120796322822571,
1.157194972038269,
-0.023118436336517334,
0.08274447172880173,
0.010206200182437897,
0.4442348778247833,
-0.3719934821128845,
-0.10555484890937805,
-0.1667645424604416,
0.2792781889438629,
-0.3552626669406891,
-0.25392818450927734,
0.1018916517496109,
-0.6008965969085693,
0.31909191608428955,
-0.3181816041469574,
0.2268063873052597,
0.33624815940856934,
0.39506009221076965,
0.18082064390182495,
-0.4748559296131134,
-0.3693978488445282,
-0.7667406797409058,
0.8867262601852417,
-0.7184431552886963,
0.4445248246192932,
-0.101465605199337,
0.04298064112663269,
-0.4280054271221161,
-0.5469991564750671,
-0.11738122999668121,
-0.3058146834373474,
-0.062258873134851456,
0.029804447665810585,
-0.331779807806015,
-0.17466560006141663,
0.026599116623401642,
0.38582366704940796,
-0.6128610968589783,
0.5770061016082764,
-0.6618369221687317,
0.03613101318478584,
0.8680897951126099,
0.27377402782440186,
0.7980192303657532,
0.14039643108844757,
-0.23763807117938995,
0.23525919020175934,
-0.5864138007164001,
-0.029095983132719994,
0.2926059663295746,
0.22478356957435608,
-0.290458619594574,
0.7401779294013977,
0.04153433069586754,
-0.060317546129226685,
-0.4661892354488373,
-0.35323619842529297,
0.5030869841575623,
-0.6319974660873413,
-0.07838472723960876,
0.43299728631973267,
0.8065294027328491,
0.18530933558940887,
-0.286190390586853,
-0.26941978931427,
0.13152086734771729,
-0.1301644742488861,
0.13209575414657593,
-0.7184720039367676,
0.24789227545261383,
0.15436594188213348,
-0.641485333442688,
-0.11483201384544373,
0.029981505125761032,
-0.7321764826774597,
-0.7529005408287048,
-0.009725905954837799,
-0.34908318519592285,
-0.1862587183713913,
-0.15537646412849426,
-0.08751960843801498,
-0.28783532977104187,
0.10548315942287445,
0.23150484263896942,
-0.6370505094528198,
0.358558714389801,
0.8171346783638,
0.7613797783851624,
-0.41028904914855957,
-0.2962527275085449,
0.11639311164617538,
0.09982429444789886,
-0.1476714313030243,
0.5335522294044495,
-0.4115564525127411,
-0.6638525128364563,
-0.011176981031894684,
-0.18877843022346497,
-0.011328618042171001,
-0.5140934586524963,
0.5089327692985535,
-0.11275339871644974,
0.04992150142788887,
-0.38520368933677673,
-0.5033448934555054,
0.05619354173541069,
0.10931065678596497,
-0.6281124353408813,
0.38246941566467285,
0.43787261843681335,
-0.6959818601608276,
0.6543638110160828,
-0.7097915410995483,
-0.3064737617969513,
0.4786559045314789,
-0.5055171847343445,
-0.6279218196868896,
0.32719698548316956,
0.17455796897411346,
-0.029366174712777138,
-0.5598006844520569,
0.649771511554718,
-0.5143811702728271,
-0.2709643840789795,
0.49921950697898865,
-0.37293803691864014,
1.0288403034210205,
0.28801319003105164,
-0.1762302666902542,
0.4181443750858307,
-0.5384796857833862,
-0.32020509243011475,
0.01380092278122902,
0.014848791062831879,
-0.3568803668022156,
0.1446487158536911,
0.054591137915849686,
-0.031593259423971176,
0.09742281585931778,
-0.5589665174484253,
0.08807198703289032,
-0.6108807921409607,
0.4186861515045166,
0.4638870358467102,
-0.05109734088182449,
0.6588443517684937,
-0.528252124786377,
0.7662184834480286,
-0.19145937263965607,
0.5236451625823975,
0.15713560581207275,
-0.6184874176979065,
-0.21476109325885773,
-0.6267999410629272,
0.19666148722171783,
0.34600740671157837,
-0.15500633418560028,
0.16873827576637268,
-0.24472662806510925,
-0.4599928855895996,
-0.7527428269386292,
-0.02218291349709034,
-0.0387665256857872,
0.42693063616752625,
0.1279049962759018,
-0.3097294867038727,
-0.6638912558555603,
-0.8907703757286072,
-0.3069572150707245,
-0.32571423053741455,
-0.10232595354318619,
0.3322276771068573,
0.728243350982666,
-0.5598111748695374,
0.8176606297492981,
-0.17733874917030334,
-0.164248988032341,
-0.15123702585697174,
-0.03992682695388794,
0.23831765353679657,
0.5056880116462708,
0.46933141350746155,
-0.6675467491149902,
0.05946663022041321,
-0.048306871205568314,
-1.0309357643127441,
-0.16167739033699036,
0.31494101881980896,
-0.11557931452989578,
-0.20166072249412537,
0.17659005522727966,
-0.30708059668540955,
0.41618064045906067,
0.4387282133102417,
-0.36182957887649536,
0.32208874821662903,
0.05379590764641762,
0.25016698241233826,
-0.7589499354362488,
0.05653998255729675,
0.22866028547286987,
0.3603162169456482,
-0.6091185808181763,
-0.07961751520633698,
-0.11149376630783081,
-0.1156550794839859,
-0.07194098830223083,
0.6002183556556702,
-0.3976360857486725,
-0.0215099286288023,
-0.022810935974121094,
-0.4525635242462158,
-0.20062735676765442,
-0.41509902477264404,
-0.375039666891098,
0.4563024640083313,
0.28675970435142517,
-0.1922074407339096,
0.008793114684522152,
0.11866109818220139,
-0.3797372877597809,
0.36841756105422974,
-0.8635734915733337,
-0.4824622571468353,
-0.1394340544939041,
0.3004680573940277,
-0.7541956305503845,
-0.2868190407752991,
0.2591226398944855,
-0.46377304196357727,
0.0024292112793773413,
0.2692736089229584,
-0.2587726414203644,
-0.7654110789299011,
-0.2911592721939087,
0.7445255517959595,
0.4191403388977051,
-0.07468649744987488,
0.43190091848373413,
0.7115209698677063,
-0.5997640490531921,
-0.5948355197906494,
-0.7640831470489502,
0.0071255178190767765,
-0.2601771354675293,
-0.7387018203735352,
0.5397140383720398,
-0.11390364170074463,
-0.8238410353660583,
0.07238046824932098,
-0.05501521751284599,
-0.018555480986833572,
0.3606069087982178,
0.21995730698108673,
0.5016719102859497,
-0.26772940158843994,
0.033529311418533325,
-0.010329227894544601,
0.18417514860630035,
0.33676818013191223,
-0.3469379246234894,
0.3226458430290222,
-0.05528446286916733,
-0.8244665861129761,
-0.14626003801822662,
0.7177647948265076,
0.346284955739975,
-0.14959034323692322,
0.4724763333797455,
0.5209700465202332,
-0.31366902589797974,
0.01594865322113037,
-0.37245428562164307,
-0.21812251210212708,
-0.37661126255989075,
0.6577325463294983,
0.47610267996788025,
-1.3117179870605469,
0.6284841895103455,
0.11214984208345413,
0.3648056983947754,
0.3907078206539154,
0.7278966903686523,
-0.2297590672969818,
0.8351024389266968,
0.7813613414764404,
-0.06423790752887726,
0.14125333726406097,
0.07582713663578033,
0.4077184498310089,
-0.5969399809837341,
-0.7387526631355286,
-0.88005530834198,
-0.4709719121456146,
-1.0571112632751465,
-0.5002758502960205,
0.6794238090515137,
-0.16824541985988617,
-0.2587234079837799,
-0.5572716593742371,
-0.6776993870735168,
0.08736858516931534,
0.7149779796600342,
0.0489850752055645,
0.43775439262390137,
-0.07947173714637756,
0.22181926667690277,
-0.21293415129184723,
-0.7087573409080505,
-0.15852691233158112,
1.152766227722168,
0.6748284697532654,
0.8801793456077576,
0.1528865545988083,
0.8365585803985596,
0.534826934337616,
0.5841854214668274,
-0.7353690266609192,
0.0909024104475975,
-0.12042952328920364,
-0.5424087643623352,
-0.328616738319397,
-0.5975865721702576,
-0.9991564750671387,
0.13099007308483124,
-0.045112401247024536,
-0.4093751013278961,
0.6395884156227112,
-0.27144578099250793,
-0.2167351096868515,
0.23140013217926025,
-0.2779000997543335,
0.2574649453163147,
-0.6750525236129761,
-0.11943085491657257,
0.07099210470914841,
-0.5452662110328674,
0.5023863315582275,
0.08041798323392868,
0.4865592122077942,
-0.46574312448501587,
-0.16058218479156494,
0.6132158637046814,
-0.05706055834889412,
0.6245464086532593,
0.1250607967376709,
-0.12073072791099548,
-0.2224595993757248,
-0.3018014430999756,
-0.1061534583568573,
0.17467449605464935,
-0.27587446570396423,
0.7016972303390503,
-0.29022887349128723,
-0.5096710920333862,
-0.4276668429374695,
0.6548250317573547,
-0.9907718896865845,
-0.5634931325912476,
-0.8265557885169983,
-0.8366650342941284,
-0.07589059323072433,
0.03872855380177498,
0.2220068871974945,
-0.039516881108284,
-0.38739675283432007,
0.044466760009527206,
0.5250478386878967,
-0.3220323920249939,
0.2073364555835724,
0.4387202560901642,
0.03507459536194801,
-0.40901845693588257,
0.6150043606758118,
0.3369390368461609,
-0.17887750267982483,
0.18603436648845673,
0.3309534788131714,
-0.2749391794204712,
-0.9853115081787109,
-0.1741141527891159,
0.4388442635536194,
-0.33855974674224854,
0.03513862192630768,
-0.672707736492157,
-0.3951328694820404,
-0.6008691787719727,
-0.35396674275398254,
0.02708359621465206,
-0.07915426790714264,
-0.44304990768432617,
0.13160382211208344,
0.16361600160598755,
0.8684738874435425,
0.14093108475208282,
0.157887801527977,
-0.4203870892524719,
0.04169415310025215,
-0.040070585906505585,
0.288727730512619,
-0.08619653433561325,
-0.3887210786342621,
-0.20665889978408813,
-0.058925844728946686,
-0.04869343712925911,
-0.7200543880462646,
0.61381596326828,
-0.11103688925504684,
1.1037479639053345,
0.2842031717300415,
-0.12648512423038483,
0.5426281690597534,
-0.6160180568695068,
0.7563488483428955,
0.5907672643661499,
-0.5374712347984314,
0.4087139964103699,
-0.23438037931919098,
0.197950080037117,
0.4878110885620117,
0.6007068753242493,
-0.4586302638053894,
-0.5271881818771362,
-0.5061239004135132,
-1.1109994649887085,
0.44492319226264954,
-0.09723600745201111,
0.05547940731048584,
0.26251697540283203,
-0.03244795650243759,
0.16746336221694946,
0.1871514469385147,
-0.6162962317466736,
-0.18213589489459991,
0.02375449426472187,
-0.45072540640830994,
0.20610511302947998,
-0.25098466873168945,
-0.5523332953453064,
-0.3148164451122284,
0.3709282875061035,
-0.11524837464094162,
0.4165247976779938,
0.3412783145904541,
0.04597911611199379,
-0.06069210171699524,
0.6210275888442993,
0.5710195302963257,
0.9938938021659851,
-0.06228097528219223,
0.04281523451209068,
0.0068269879557192326,
-0.4763793349266052,
0.22719766199588776,
0.530568540096283,
-0.3593057096004486,
0.03510286286473274,
0.6581076979637146,
0.5126566290855408,
0.028727639466524124,
-0.6756496429443359,
0.1858803927898407,
-0.04223543405532837,
-0.08492587506771088,
-0.1833358258008957,
0.12306316941976547,
-0.05166725069284439,
0.4578772187232971,
0.5365248918533325,
-0.012515634298324585,
0.43616440892219543,
-0.503032386302948,
0.19475597143173218,
0.36777517199516296,
-0.4569728672504425,
-0.06886585056781769,
0.6643089056015015,
0.32061001658439636,
-0.3175859749317169,
0.48472368717193604,
0.27172771096229553,
-0.1630418747663498,
0.8578721880912781,
0.5510428547859192,
0.7434313297271729,
-0.29718467593193054,
0.13681431114673615,
0.1170891746878624,
0.4040304124355316,
0.07953259348869324,
0.05915495380759239,
0.355631023645401,
-0.4024353325366974,
-0.21904471516609192,
-0.6582613587379456,
-0.5336993336677551,
-0.2790042459964752,
-0.4251684844493866,
-0.028100328519940376,
-0.26524949073791504,
-0.19582274556159973,
0.1928611546754837,
0.08349016308784485,
-0.6530372500419617,
-0.018753565847873688,
0.36660251021385193,
0.6014606356620789,
-0.5684465765953064,
0.36044880747795105,
0.5128061175346375,
-0.33568599820137024,
-0.4543764889240265,
-0.08960454165935516,
0.38774585723876953,
-1.0194616317749023,
0.6450861096382141,
-0.0804319679737091,
0.05919027701020241,
-0.44937005639076233,
-0.5989557504653931,
-0.8410438895225525,
1.2040716409683228,
0.41879215836524963,
-0.7934032678604126,
-0.25116458535194397,
0.367683470249176,
0.6448326110839844,
-0.661551833152771,
0.565407395362854,
0.516648530960083,
0.378131240606308,
-0.06326568871736526,
-0.8512263298034668,
-0.11603051424026489,
-0.40606239438056946,
0.17294077575206757,
-0.1332567185163498,
-0.560684323310852,
0.9910057187080383,
-0.3433026075363159,
-0.010928490199148655,
0.06624148041009903,
0.6121898889541626,
0.6409485340118408,
0.7580614686012268,
0.13858751952648163,
0.22336457669734955,
1.1338272094726562,
-0.23433281481266022,
1.1557714939117432,
0.011619233526289463,
0.07378630340099335,
0.7832834720611572,
-0.6151856780052185,
0.01031299028545618,
0.4709893465042114,
-0.43495604395866394,
0.4436224102973938,
0.5071371793746948,
-0.42151114344596863,
0.13675743341445923,
0.36958110332489014,
-0.4758758544921875,
0.3233701288700104,
-0.788818895816803,
-0.7454009652137756,
0.4663805067539215,
0.4758867025375366,
-0.7868736982345581,
-0.0847344845533371,
0.12972606718540192,
0.1357867270708084,
-0.03295350819826126,
-0.46298089623451233,
0.7076784372329712,
0.24593372642993927,
-0.2545122504234314,
-0.03427853435277939,
-0.04498979076743126,
0.8813191652297974,
-0.8498550653457642,
0.06170099228620529,
-0.3208957314491272,
-0.07493196427822113,
-0.35013189911842346,
-0.727411687374115,
0.2149566411972046,
0.11083562672138214,
-0.5358480215072632,
-0.10490673035383224,
0.6584442257881165,
-0.362283319234848,
-0.9284741878509521,
0.3513069450855255,
0.6927925944328308,
0.008633758872747421,
0.5168243050575256,
-0.6047081351280212,
0.2622503638267517,
0.019290270283818245,
0.19278788566589355,
0.42116692662239075,
0.29860439896583557,
-0.31614968180656433,
0.691935122013092,
0.6570167541503906,
0.6358649134635925,
-0.04953775927424431,
0.2517143785953522,
0.7590170502662659,
-0.6214970350265503,
-0.41748595237731934,
-1.2093373537063599,
0.2916148900985718,
-0.2055141031742096,
-0.41973307728767395,
0.9941369891166687,
0.4840169847011566,
0.35284119844436646,
0.3460715413093567,
0.9731560349464417,
0.03841755911707878,
0.260785847902298,
-0.021893039345741272,
0.9349058270454407,
-0.7304578423500061,
0.3617067039012909,
-0.1452919840812683,
-0.33413049578666687,
-0.5400498509407043,
0.06107896938920021,
-0.2465825378894806,
0.07729282230138779,
0.13616301119327545,
0.4668274223804474,
0.1800219565629959,
0.28753557801246643,
0.0783785805106163,
0.10123047232627869,
0.43050044775009155,
0.18480323255062103,
0.9733201265335083,
0.015162103809416294,
0.13182292878627777,
-0.0835794061422348,
-0.3401617705821991,
-0.40896809101104736,
-0.6040680408477783,
-0.40186017751693726,
0.07363332808017731,
-0.1806640923023224,
-0.31357768177986145,
0.10463036596775055,
0.9789129495620728,
0.6848828792572021,
-0.8778447508811951,
-0.43064916133880615,
0.22801034152507782,
0.5596371293067932,
-0.07864351570606232,
-0.18927264213562012,
0.21088634431362152,
-0.1370503455400467,
-0.5363579392433167,
0.15066556632518768,
0.6404881477355957,
-0.09065043926239014,
-0.5374762415885925,
-0.10086198151111603,
-0.02057449333369732,
-0.029091475531458855,
0.40787291526794434,
0.19023872911930084,
-0.6592200398445129,
0.4321287274360657,
0.32933473587036133,
-0.31785720586776733,
0.21926797926425934,
0.9309667348861694,
-0.2215607911348343,
0.349843293428421,
0.46762987971305847,
0.7357942461967468,
-0.09808547049760818,
-0.25535452365875244,
0.5265030264854431,
-0.3680705726146698,
0.0664811059832573,
0.9403720498085022,
0.3978286385536194,
0.32161492109298706,
-0.522606372833252,
0.4822251796722412,
0.42423707246780396,
-0.7058619260787964,
-1.0461972951889038,
-0.1412333846092224,
-0.7267897129058838,
-0.36392727494239807,
0.8090190291404724,
0.10839853435754776,
-0.3756765127182007,
-0.23243151605129242,
0.17793789505958557,
0.23515823483467102,
-0.4924180507659912,
0.8305100202560425,
0.46526193618774414,
-0.5314380526542664,
-0.11695186793804169,
-0.5397265553474426,
0.329763799905777,
0.4510786533355713,
-1.1027796268463135,
-0.403277724981308,
0.5109215974807739,
0.08302564173936844,
0.08588393032550812,
0.7149825692176819,
-0.41868463158607483,
0.22489801049232483,
-0.1975094974040985,
0.20183376967906952,
0.11859504878520966,
-0.2118072211742401,
-0.352367639541626,
0.16317224502563477,
-0.05336933583021164,
0.31261301040649414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13144v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13144v1 | DialSim: A Real-Time Simulator for Evaluating Long-Term Dialogue Understanding of Conversational Agents | 2024-06-19T01:37:10 | 2024-06-19T01:37:10 | Jiho Kim, Woosog Chay, Hyeonji Hwang, Daeun Kyung, Hyunseung Chung, Eunbyeol Cho, Yohan Jo, Edward Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly
enhanced the capabilities of conversational agents, making them applicable to
various fields (e.g., education). Despite their progress, the evaluation of the
agents often overlooks the complexities of real-world conversations, such as
real-time interactions, multi-party dialogues, and extended contextual
dependencies. To bridge this gap, we introduce DialSim, a real-time dialogue
simulator. In this simulator, an agent is assigned the role of a character from
popular TV shows, requiring it to respond to spontaneous questions using past
dialogue information and to distinguish between known and unknown information.
Key features of DialSim include evaluating the agent's ability to respond
within a reasonable time limit, handling long-term multi-party dialogues, and
managing adversarial settings (e.g., swap character names) to challenge the
agent's reliance on pre-trained knowledge. We utilized this simulator to
evaluate the latest conversational agents and analyze their limitations. Our
experiments highlight both the strengths and weaknesses of these agents,
providing valuable insights for future improvements in the field of
conversational AI. DialSim is available at
https://github.com/jiho283/Simulator. | [
-0.421490341424942,
-0.9850695133209229,
0.47884804010391235,
0.41819697618484497,
-0.19007913768291473,
0.496247261762619,
-0.29125580191612244,
-0.3861033618450165,
0.09809064865112305,
0.7068821787834167,
-0.8128675222396851,
-0.0745794028043747,
-0.2492535412311554,
0.011596325784921646,
-0.09112383425235748,
0.681429386138916,
0.1809663027524948,
0.2695390284061432,
-0.6032789945602417,
-0.012233341112732887,
-0.5098470449447632,
-0.677638053894043,
-0.7835823893547058,
-0.42587345838546753,
0.24333341419696808,
0.26834216713905334,
0.8108029961585999,
0.28908684849739075,
0.3559499979019165,
0.3868424594402313,
-0.04959060996770859,
0.13879911601543427,
-0.5604731440544128,
0.6055005788803101,
0.02587905526161194,
-0.6220464110374451,
-0.48912283778190613,
0.13703234493732452,
0.8468421697616577,
0.515123724937439,
-0.028199801221489906,
0.03062043897807598,
-0.17519089579582214,
0.25011634826660156,
-0.2009640336036682,
0.41923877596855164,
-0.35082611441612244,
0.24489451944828033,
0.37472841143608093,
-0.5230233669281006,
-0.4866906702518463,
-0.4448557198047638,
0.5430631637573242,
-0.6662583947181702,
-0.03701529651880264,
-0.059582654386758804,
0.8108996152877808,
0.3995138108730316,
-0.6036481261253357,
-0.2656508982181549,
-1.0832289457321167,
0.6344574093818665,
-0.6278151273727417,
0.2922405004501343,
0.1112552136182785,
0.7202902436256409,
-0.33978980779647827,
-0.5716250538825989,
-0.5405823588371277,
-0.7729701995849609,
0.2146284580230713,
0.2713644802570343,
0.12312141060829163,
0.26062822341918945,
0.5042133331298828,
0.00940623413771391,
-0.4642026722431183,
-0.04760473594069481,
-0.027707912027835846,
-0.3085695803165436,
0.15822482109069824,
0.49085715413093567,
0.4109010696411133,
0.01997733674943447,
-0.5279597640037537,
-0.0321781150996685,
-0.5156920552253723,
-0.003574077505618334,
0.2714799642562866,
-0.007416853681206703,
-0.06330705434083939,
0.319342702627182,
-0.020033452659845352,
0.39186352491378784,
-0.19744804501533508,
-0.12577220797538757,
-0.03491659089922905,
-0.285864919424057,
-0.1205148994922638,
0.06423582136631012,
0.5640403032302856,
0.3510613441467285,
0.3610585927963257,
-0.044672489166259766,
0.22919341921806335,
0.057213518768548965,
0.24618037045001984,
-1.172630786895752,
0.03149034455418587,
0.13699275255203247,
-0.2660443186759949,
-0.4585760831832886,
-0.30925098061561584,
-0.7147373557090759,
-0.5018637776374817,
-0.21404503285884857,
0.27641379833221436,
-0.3564334809780121,
-0.2645200788974762,
-0.11712970584630966,
-0.10630396753549576,
0.4713093340396881,
0.5553244352340698,
-0.13337047398090363,
0.3934158980846405,
0.5761479735374451,
0.7469771504402161,
0.05795210599899292,
-0.26020675897598267,
-0.9002740979194641,
-0.05595102533698082,
-0.25910744071006775,
0.5503819584846497,
-0.714319109916687,
-0.6467926502227783,
-0.1460149735212326,
-0.03193768858909607,
-0.20298895239830017,
-0.5032529830932617,
0.14313530921936035,
-0.5215092897415161,
0.14664104580879211,
0.06577067822217941,
-0.5492652654647827,
0.07343898713588715,
0.5165918469429016,
-0.4390830397605896,
0.5473940372467041,
-0.05499536544084549,
-0.24897177517414093,
-0.11463737487792969,
-0.8200156092643738,
-0.19290415942668915,
0.14728108048439026,
-0.16800889372825623,
-0.3558049201965332,
-0.2307792454957962,
0.058943089097738266,
0.29489588737487793,
-0.3683706521987915,
0.4709446430206299,
-0.2946636378765106,
-0.5782650709152222,
0.907987654209137,
-0.7762771844863892,
0.6186069250106812,
0.2993674874305725,
-0.2542719542980194,
0.12035563588142395,
-0.3251270651817322,
0.0016613509505987167,
0.11789772659540176,
0.12213025987148285,
-0.01683655194938183,
0.20269517600536346,
-0.2277684360742569,
0.29533952474594116,
0.056892141699790955,
-0.3738032281398773,
0.21426410973072052,
-0.38497206568717957,
0.5655504465103149,
0.7292914390563965,
0.1426972597837448,
0.36613067984580994,
-0.5012084245681763,
0.9815835356712341,
0.15805017948150635,
0.37360531091690063,
-0.6288813948631287,
-0.29711470007896423,
-1.177430510520935,
-0.20795302093029022,
0.285942405462265,
0.8556436896324158,
-0.9253901839256287,
0.2545660436153412,
-0.41469424962997437,
-0.46890687942504883,
-0.25715669989585876,
-0.09571070224046707,
0.379143625497818,
0.19760121405124664,
-0.14405134320259094,
-0.37090110778808594,
-0.3085087835788727,
-0.640489935874939,
-0.1221860870718956,
-0.3523912727832794,
0.10430461168289185,
0.578885018825531,
0.5421779155731201,
-0.42934027314186096,
1.096384048461914,
-0.5096228122711182,
-0.14829546213150024,
-0.47512850165367126,
0.22110000252723694,
-0.3456719219684601,
0.34695199131965637,
0.3588312566280365,
-0.6298162937164307,
-0.2347780019044876,
-0.24338920414447784,
-0.7082227468490601,
-0.033279452472925186,
-0.547356903553009,
0.1605217158794403,
-0.16842730343341827,
0.7187145352363586,
-0.6447969079017639,
0.29612022638320923,
0.44035273790359497,
-0.32229185104370117,
0.7237409353256226,
-0.1120653823018074,
0.2461080253124237,
-1.0799229145050049,
-0.09846651554107666,
-0.10135415941476822,
-0.6503352522850037,
-0.6400444507598877,
-0.22051680088043213,
-0.28886815905570984,
-0.6802803874015808,
-0.7124395370483398,
0.8932086229324341,
-0.3594695031642914,
-0.1518796980381012,
0.07905569672584534,
0.5289363861083984,
-0.03155488520860672,
0.5463995337486267,
-0.0899612158536911,
1.2408801317214966,
0.25115618109703064,
-0.5802233815193176,
0.607695460319519,
0.055200766772031784,
-0.5705147981643677,
0.5548149943351746,
-0.5818805694580078,
0.33946648240089417,
-0.1094394251704216,
0.6789835095405579,
-0.8251487612724304,
-0.23515504598617554,
0.3757956326007843,
-0.4176589548587799,
0.029871415346860886,
-0.2502996325492859,
-0.3108289837837219,
-0.13284613192081451,
-0.1430949568748474,
0.5505141615867615,
0.41382816433906555,
-0.4099048674106598,
0.8505764603614807,
0.3316938281059265,
-0.4827985465526581,
-0.35229527950286865,
-0.1181068941950798,
0.33367326855659485,
-0.2686240077018738,
-0.47614866495132446,
-0.11507662385702133,
-0.5219889879226685,
-0.4561995267868042,
-0.1978834569454193,
0.03498782962560654,
-0.15817396342754364,
0.4013654291629791,
0.556507408618927,
0.36249256134033203,
-0.14342570304870605,
0.034679945558309555,
-0.09211557358503342,
-0.2032136470079422,
0.1284715235233307,
0.02876299060881138,
0.7129297256469727,
-0.32039526104927063,
-0.4304683804512024,
-0.7407417297363281,
0.09790811687707901,
0.8638229966163635,
-0.14597654342651367,
0.26763930916786194,
0.3507976531982422,
-0.22355793416500092,
-0.10526014119386673,
-0.6170924305915833,
-0.304771363735199,
-0.45220646262168884,
0.5174548625946045,
-0.29938438534736633,
-0.7998731136322021,
0.5358571410179138,
-0.5141298770904541,
-0.010642729699611664,
-0.21546578407287598,
0.3680973947048187,
-0.00445164367556572,
1.3353010416030884,
0.14070793986320496,
-0.06312660127878189,
0.8034769892692566,
-0.26164016127586365,
0.24984438717365265,
-0.7418609261512756,
-0.28148916363716125,
-0.3343524932861328,
0.01832771487534046,
-0.1746712177991867,
-0.885127067565918,
0.3433820307254791,
-0.3523753583431244,
-0.038894765079021454,
0.04095480963587761,
0.18486617505550385,
0.6375882029533386,
0.21030005812644958,
-0.053846489638090134,
0.2569220960140228,
-0.27183103561401367,
0.1466619074344635,
0.025877391919493675,
-0.515488862991333,
-0.7290346026420593,
0.6657412648200989,
0.7166312336921692,
0.8585605621337891,
-0.11553358286619186,
0.3482540249824524,
0.5762385725975037,
0.28160929679870605,
-1.0986332893371582,
0.9437906742095947,
0.38209086656570435,
-0.4562641382217407,
-0.22171086072921753,
-0.5375739932060242,
-0.8076461553573608,
0.36077386140823364,
-0.11924197524785995,
-0.4309246838092804,
-0.2163102924823761,
0.08770422637462616,
-0.42131608724594116,
0.05700250715017319,
-0.6578541994094849,
0.7512252926826477,
-0.4087197184562683,
-0.2080104500055313,
-0.46641066670417786,
-0.6698033809661865,
0.057083647698163986,
0.21980643272399902,
0.1712586134672165,
-0.4547193944454193,
0.20855052769184113,
0.6451747417449951,
-0.4002413749694824,
0.9681760668754578,
-0.133511021733284,
0.06542029976844788,
0.3488862216472626,
0.28558409214019775,
0.30658698081970215,
0.36169612407684326,
0.14326421916484833,
0.03084605745971203,
0.2752205431461334,
-0.4004424810409546,
-0.7704856991767883,
0.7202335596084595,
-0.8439220786094666,
-0.5533605813980103,
-0.709680438041687,
-0.5383651852607727,
-0.39384591579437256,
0.010117333382368088,
-0.20847773551940918,
0.7178366780281067,
-0.8691608905792236,
0.07151469588279724,
0.6449352502822876,
-0.29178106784820557,
0.16008608043193817,
0.5305908918380737,
-0.44755151867866516,
-0.3372606635093689,
1.035179615020752,
-0.145796999335289,
0.4651774764060974,
0.09631137549877167,
-0.029828708618879318,
-0.023959865793585777,
-0.06200182065367699,
-0.5621053576469421,
0.18199633061885834,
-0.46334898471832275,
-0.047529589384794235,
-0.4791891872882843,
-0.4221237599849701,
-0.20064347982406616,
-0.11707156151533127,
-0.30236977338790894,
-0.40074092149734497,
-0.2134280651807785,
0.13377369940280914,
-0.08979147672653198,
0.6187394857406616,
0.3616963028907776,
0.522459864616394,
-0.7515160441398621,
0.2699364125728607,
0.6667330861091614,
0.21795906126499176,
-0.1662687510251999,
-0.22539258003234863,
-0.23080073297023773,
0.44876575469970703,
-0.35044512152671814,
-0.8087330460548401,
0.3095850348472595,
0.22908398509025574,
0.45004400610923767,
0.4641419053077698,
-0.04847543686628342,
0.6926023960113525,
-0.2508203685283661,
0.9300656914710999,
0.07902393490076065,
-0.8843643069267273,
0.3688206672668457,
-0.21202856302261353,
0.38808202743530273,
0.40480080246925354,
-0.14657051861286163,
-0.7999294996261597,
-0.5660668015480042,
-0.4142194092273712,
-0.46858835220336914,
0.8092230558395386,
0.32638877630233765,
0.2085944563150406,
0.06313209235668182,
0.14361801743507385,
0.023057762533426285,
0.23711027204990387,
-0.3772369921207428,
-0.06354611366987228,
-0.08027613162994385,
0.049199383705854416,
-0.18048635125160217,
-0.3216364085674286,
-0.11702220141887665,
-0.042336903512477875,
0.6539347171783447,
-0.10058210790157318,
0.5304931998252869,
0.1184772253036499,
-0.4809584617614746,
0.09595492482185364,
0.40145739912986755,
0.6845129132270813,
0.5407029986381531,
-0.35831570625305176,
-0.11190702021121979,
0.3725951910018921,
-0.3898860514163971,
0.12810413539409637,
0.07518693059682846,
0.1498936116695404,
-0.00785438809543848,
0.14586767554283142,
0.9923678636550903,
0.3103967010974884,
-1.053379774093628,
0.5778438448905945,
-0.5777114033699036,
-0.08696912974119186,
-0.6689325571060181,
0.17359532415866852,
-0.08955813944339752,
0.5294412970542908,
0.21880142390727997,
-0.07067813724279404,
0.00430795643478632,
-0.8577564358711243,
0.09347086399793625,
0.45880627632141113,
-0.6635665893554688,
-0.2306041419506073,
0.4068678617477417,
0.7050625085830688,
-0.6531885266304016,
0.6989923715591431,
-0.21095812320709229,
-0.8139849901199341,
1.0557535886764526,
0.5550528764724731,
0.9363986253738403,
-0.259937584400177,
0.5283645391464233,
-0.19167698919773102,
0.032363370060920715,
0.08666849136352539,
-0.01497971173375845,
-0.15807051956653595,
-0.666343092918396,
-0.3460696339607239,
-0.3337845504283905,
-0.9927129745483398,
0.19915778934955597,
-0.4498952329158783,
0.10867931693792343,
-0.4338994026184082,
-0.4017222225666046,
-0.20513246953487396,
0.04477979615330696,
-0.602332353591919,
0.1127641573548317,
0.08137393742799759,
0.7880449891090393,
-0.607272207736969,
0.7042879462242126,
0.5463171005249023,
-0.008318992331624031,
-0.25239741802215576,
0.2592693567276001,
-0.02669360674917698,
-0.6925538182258606,
0.5340762734413147,
0.36215031147003174,
-0.4423689544200897,
0.13843213021755219,
-0.4534735381603241,
-0.3725495934486389,
0.971271812915802,
0.45387500524520874,
-0.5073427557945251,
-0.34904494881629944,
0.258394330739975,
0.5821101665496826,
-0.5388391613960266,
0.712708055973053,
0.43223029375076294,
0.2330685257911682,
0.02770845592021942,
-0.8497553467750549,
-0.20899446308612823,
-0.3463238477706909,
-0.08860353380441666,
0.17018137872219086,
-0.7833693027496338,
0.28993263840675354,
-0.23168261349201202,
-0.22020067274570465,
0.37387770414352417,
0.599635899066925,
0.006257271859794855,
0.5251370668411255,
0.8049119710922241,
-0.005418258253484964,
0.5054475665092468,
-0.08970288187265396,
0.6157007813453674,
-0.47147494554519653,
0.32020339369773865,
1.0771048069000244,
-0.4305770993232727,
0.4472672641277313,
0.24795079231262207,
0.10853846371173859,
0.3699801564216614,
0.40618962049484253,
0.22030839323997498,
0.2047194093465805,
0.2611844837665558,
-0.529922366142273,
-0.590726912021637,
-0.3483096659183502,
-0.33673813939094543,
0.41740331053733826,
0.6175087690353394,
0.10985524952411652,
-0.03863818198442459,
0.28362879157066345,
0.12484575062990189,
-0.16549435257911682,
0.05436946451663971,
0.8665198683738708,
0.19420072436332703,
-0.6626237630844116,
0.2882518470287323,
-0.3986331820487976,
0.2089194506406784,
-0.6763874292373657,
-0.2414918690919876,
-0.156031534075737,
0.19639326632022858,
0.28109210729599,
-0.5266726016998291,
-0.19559255242347717,
-0.15023767948150635,
0.23595431447029114,
-0.2465742975473404,
0.6221384406089783,
-0.488809198141098,
-0.21016782522201538,
0.22324126958847046,
0.38812029361724854,
0.23841877281665802,
0.10077545791864395,
-0.8153507709503174,
0.24811166524887085,
-0.13960005342960358,
-0.14122262597084045,
0.2507784366607666,
0.12334366887807846,
0.004291629884392023,
1.196714997291565,
0.6006997227668762,
0.1272987723350525,
-0.17597831785678864,
0.19693143665790558,
0.8707918524742126,
-0.6628656387329102,
-0.45741891860961914,
-0.5983134508132935,
0.12099715322256088,
-0.2965299189090729,
-0.15036815404891968,
0.4529314935207367,
0.6014083623886108,
0.4726857841014862,
0.011692125350236893,
0.8512022495269775,
0.3323651850223541,
0.2830131947994232,
-0.38200387358665466,
0.5239769220352173,
-0.35733267664909363,
0.315580278635025,
-0.0787680372595787,
-0.9026365280151367,
0.01727713644504547,
0.6834542751312256,
-0.20010672509670258,
-0.06599945574998856,
0.5439956784248352,
0.7188130617141724,
0.07691581547260284,
0.15970896184444427,
0.40175554156303406,
0.3285163938999176,
0.7641358375549316,
0.4275638163089752,
1.3978384733200073,
-0.026212474331259727,
0.6734316349029541,
-0.18691349029541016,
-0.14441977441310883,
-0.576587438583374,
-0.7187576293945312,
-1.2379847764968872,
-0.5011240839958191,
-0.24389468133449554,
-0.3104114532470703,
0.3935106694698334,
1.2875750064849854,
0.639295220375061,
-0.41011425852775574,
-0.49524497985839844,
0.2970148026943207,
0.1919413059949875,
-0.08047047257423401,
-0.2466197907924652,
-0.3038093149662018,
-0.26291990280151367,
-0.9490931034088135,
0.6153286695480347,
0.407991886138916,
0.09494522958993912,
-0.3466413617134094,
-0.22623567283153534,
0.091957688331604,
0.5357280373573303,
0.6510965824127197,
0.34617117047309875,
-0.5430034399032593,
-0.35996344685554504,
0.008446257561445236,
-0.22049610316753387,
-0.040872007608413696,
0.9632569551467896,
-0.8561167120933533,
0.8199751973152161,
0.34331274032592773,
0.3649216890335083,
0.5415137410163879,
0.19131439924240112,
0.7637506127357483,
-0.20811091363430023,
0.2632584273815155,
0.3726534843444824,
0.06349123269319534,
0.1551402360200882,
-0.09822017699480057,
0.21255052089691162,
0.18851687014102936,
-0.6559531092643738,
-0.9504166841506958,
0.4717632830142975,
-0.9984980821609497,
-0.12637107074260712,
1.0661289691925049,
-0.164840430021286,
-0.0325646735727787,
-0.2875557541847229,
-0.7128028869628906,
0.3620436191558838,
-0.5198220610618591,
0.6505814790725708,
0.5990164875984192,
-0.0071871960535645485,
0.04781230911612511,
-0.697178304195404,
0.4313591420650482,
0.4972744584083557,
-0.8698901534080505,
0.10676078498363495,
0.550640344619751,
0.2709521949291229,
0.04208297282457352,
0.7596913576126099,
0.1394081562757492,
0.23628224432468414,
-0.30131858587265015,
-0.290040522813797,
-0.1494390219449997,
-0.5262601971626282,
-0.12616975605487823,
-0.1496375948190689,
0.15790830552577972,
-0.14074841141700745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13138v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13138v1 | Large Language Models are Biased Because They Are Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T01:08:03 | 2024-06-19T01:08:03 | Philip Resnik | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper's primary goal is to provoke thoughtful discussion about the
relationship between bias and fundamental properties of large language models.
We do this by seeking to convince the reader that harmful biases are an
inevitable consequence arising from the design of any large language model as
LLMs are currently formulated. To the extent that this is true, it suggests
that the problem of harmful bias cannot be properly addressed without a serious
reconsideration of AI driven by LLMs, going back to the foundational
assumptions underlying their design. | [
-0.32284843921661377,
-0.8969811201095581,
0.6778059601783752,
0.31960809230804443,
-0.08808790147304535,
-0.3244436979293823,
-0.4304005205631256,
-0.5717634558677673,
-0.005924182012677193,
0.9753305912017822,
-0.33029353618621826,
-0.08153361827135086,
-0.6798102855682373,
-0.21706648170948029,
-0.5338273644447327,
1.0926141738891602,
0.15606358647346497,
0.34391969442367554,
-0.2411019206047058,
-0.013384419493377209,
-0.3282885253429413,
-0.6746528148651123,
-0.7118890285491943,
-0.605703592300415,
0.5978708863258362,
0.027181128039956093,
1.0216766595840454,
0.5099510550498962,
0.3817403018474579,
0.325057715177536,
-0.2783282697200775,
-0.4174572825431824,
-0.6334171891212463,
0.4982423782348633,
-0.34941381216049194,
-0.7914441823959351,
-0.3903372585773468,
0.0785147026181221,
0.8535517454147339,
0.9158819913864136,
0.2933700382709503,
0.09951095283031464,
0.22607988119125366,
0.8539064526557922,
-0.25254324078559875,
0.07979360222816467,
-0.6367506384849548,
-0.011690991930663586,
-0.3099035918712616,
0.05342688411474228,
-0.6197189092636108,
-0.22469936311244965,
0.23495614528656006,
-0.1506216824054718,
0.07097521424293518,
0.11147549748420715,
0.6243935823440552,
0.21000373363494873,
-0.7234994173049927,
-0.42706459760665894,
-1.0065734386444092,
1.122536063194275,
-0.747210681438446,
0.29448598623275757,
0.262111097574234,
0.08163847774267197,
-0.12017489969730377,
-0.14554867148399353,
-0.511101245880127,
-0.4727313220500946,
0.2752229869365692,
-0.29043155908584595,
-0.05290204659104347,
0.15583176910877228,
0.5200233459472656,
0.38017556071281433,
-0.2876977324485779,
0.3698923885822296,
-0.30974143743515015,
0.004820335190743208,
0.8041492700576782,
0.35458582639694214,
0.37256839871406555,
0.1819942593574524,
-0.10020603239536285,
0.271567702293396,
-1.0595535039901733,
-0.3430938124656677,
0.7047843933105469,
0.2555445730686188,
-0.010887570679187775,
0.5600329637527466,
0.16818243265151978,
0.4901502728462219,
0.04853280633687973,
-0.270533949136734,
0.20471005141735077,
-0.10256947576999664,
-0.19425350427627563,
-0.003715693484991789,
0.7203418016433716,
0.5163260102272034,
0.802405059337616,
-0.1432020217180252,
-0.049673937261104584,
0.04445952549576759,
0.36325812339782715,
-0.6967480778694153,
0.3256881535053253,
0.3630278706550598,
-0.4051121771335602,
-0.42448875308036804,
-0.04039673134684563,
-0.8723462224006653,
-0.5375590920448303,
-0.4066111445426941,
0.18021175265312195,
0.15071240067481995,
-0.36992624402046204,
0.06902949512004852,
0.12289252877235413,
0.3611980080604553,
0.2860209047794342,
-0.7374840378761292,
0.21998944878578186,
0.9684909582138062,
0.416657954454422,
-0.09333974123001099,
-0.2731500267982483,
-0.17223897576332092,
0.2218591272830963,
-0.4727361798286438,
0.5775371789932251,
-0.5537934899330139,
-0.6243240833282471,
0.26620376110076904,
0.04598505422472954,
0.5643782615661621,
-0.6442156434059143,
0.8107669949531555,
-0.463282972574234,
0.25731000304222107,
-0.7643419504165649,
-0.4061095416545868,
-0.24740970134735107,
0.13782863318920135,
-0.577168881893158,
0.4209570586681366,
-0.27345454692840576,
-1.0085452795028687,
0.36485162377357483,
-0.4212997257709503,
-0.730289876461029,
-0.2712234556674957,
-0.18042834103107452,
-0.34824633598327637,
0.21912479400634766,
-0.1436629295349121,
0.2994714379310608,
-0.6660008430480957,
0.8047415018081665,
-0.5873900651931763,
-0.1240607276558876,
0.4788408577442169,
-0.7514966130256653,
0.96855628490448,
0.301539808511734,
-0.5445681214332581,
0.21042251586914062,
-0.3312022089958191,
-0.226145401597023,
0.192846417427063,
-0.5893053412437439,
-0.5340710282325745,
0.3721008598804474,
0.0049863760359585285,
0.41339799761772156,
0.1467224359512329,
-0.34235435724258423,
0.1436942219734192,
-0.40303853154182434,
0.39757201075553894,
1.0869437456130981,
-0.28560835123062134,
0.8009839653968811,
-0.43850061297416687,
0.4571160078048706,
0.10772724449634552,
0.30123060941696167,
0.040857791900634766,
-0.3198573887348175,
-0.834966778755188,
0.042219631373882294,
0.07419247925281525,
0.33880284428596497,
-0.28299933671951294,
0.3746142089366913,
-0.19454799592494965,
-0.25234416127204895,
-0.2862662971019745,
0.25764355063438416,
0.4684293270111084,
0.32073941826820374,
-0.1307978481054306,
-0.1643299013376236,
-0.5495736598968506,
-1.3065474033355713,
-0.42121216654777527,
-0.1285865753889084,
0.13622286915779114,
0.47205066680908203,
0.5133054256439209,
-0.4104115068912506,
0.615161657333374,
-0.2919103801250458,
-0.14948740601539612,
-0.22217120230197906,
-0.29229068756103516,
0.08614402264356613,
0.44841644167900085,
0.7197458148002625,
-0.6056786775588989,
-0.34585249423980713,
-0.3121475279331207,
-0.8322279453277588,
-0.4032348096370697,
0.09313969314098358,
-0.1640367954969406,
0.14557890594005585,
0.5298124551773071,
-0.9070782661437988,
0.08017723262310028,
0.45984718203544617,
-0.3660636246204376,
0.6959370970726013,
0.22031700611114502,
-0.328177273273468,
-1.08302640914917,
-0.03293730318546295,
0.29207566380500793,
0.03172886744141579,
-0.5570565462112427,
0.15926103293895721,
-0.4775037467479706,
-0.05255674943327904,
-0.518068253993988,
0.8039371371269226,
-0.4466930329799652,
-0.10196763277053833,
-0.5575419664382935,
0.05758969485759735,
0.13443022966384888,
-0.023986931890249252,
-0.13074958324432373,
0.580838143825531,
0.7065100073814392,
-0.7626971006393433,
0.39564216136932373,
-0.01598832756280899,
-0.22074416279792786,
0.4982512891292572,
-0.6872560977935791,
-0.0842389315366745,
-0.3157348930835724,
0.45559367537498474,
-0.6525688171386719,
0.018386177718639374,
0.07595003396272659,
-0.24063938856124878,
0.46576112508773804,
0.04621133580803871,
-0.38030776381492615,
-0.6559275388717651,
-0.28673896193504333,
0.48967212438583374,
0.5402592420578003,
-0.39935630559921265,
0.41963160037994385,
0.8242418169975281,
-0.031320348381996155,
-0.7442342638969421,
-0.9010853171348572,
-0.08019015938043594,
-0.4053148031234741,
-0.804623544216156,
-0.2111670821905136,
0.05618917569518089,
-1.0468584299087524,
-0.09054303169250488,
0.026426121592521667,
0.23719599843025208,
0.040070321410894394,
0.39928150177001953,
0.3260152339935303,
-0.3340962827205658,
0.25431573390960693,
-0.1602468192577362,
-0.02858263999223709,
0.5643526315689087,
-0.26066622138023376,
0.6764903664588928,
0.1318427473306656,
-0.2926199734210968,
-0.11311382055282593,
0.4920620024204254,
0.9329884052276611,
0.03952878341078758,
0.6622668504714966,
0.07638420909643173,
-0.17294560372829437,
-0.24369119107723236,
-0.7853257656097412,
-0.055458541959524155,
-0.4826704263687134,
0.6769388318061829,
-0.12559841573238373,
-1.0304089784622192,
0.5955885648727417,
0.19973430037498474,
0.08587278425693512,
0.4991910457611084,
0.9526809453964233,
0.10068695992231369,
1.2540123462677002,
0.4997211992740631,
-0.7128233909606934,
0.3884296119213104,
-0.10924916714429855,
0.2199789136648178,
-1.0224121809005737,
-0.12590059638023376,
-0.7026607990264893,
-0.20565147697925568,
-0.7066087126731873,
-0.14898358285427094,
-0.001085948315449059,
-0.29892101883888245,
-0.6970844864845276,
-0.30566033720970154,
-0.33173683285713196,
0.4537186920642853,
0.6216533184051514,
-0.021959032863378525,
-0.06381386518478394,
0.01606111228466034,
-0.05014781653881073,
-0.01577817089855671,
-0.46964967250823975,
-0.849855899810791,
1.258137583732605,
0.7304486036300659,
1.3052253723144531,
0.0046445573680102825,
0.10824383050203323,
0.16694514453411102,
0.39540812373161316,
-0.908194899559021,
0.5365798473358154,
0.04033637419342995,
-1.3924037218093872,
-0.24182744324207306,
-0.3495643436908722,
-0.7882301211357117,
0.4250433146953583,
-0.02367512881755829,
-0.6890527606010437,
-0.017220627516508102,
0.2366258203983307,
-0.014899516478180885,
0.5203189253807068,
-0.6196500062942505,
0.43476203083992004,
-0.465446799993515,
-0.8895912766456604,
-0.344215452671051,
-0.5154252648353577,
0.8360991477966309,
-0.06561850011348724,
0.5061968564987183,
-0.07251667976379395,
0.20229528844356537,
0.874187707901001,
-0.3571411669254303,
1.0233594179153442,
-0.09207573533058167,
-0.4405360817909241,
0.43810299038887024,
0.341511070728302,
0.2617119550704956,
-0.045232366770505905,
-0.18053515255451202,
0.1369485855102539,
-0.2962869107723236,
-0.4522171914577484,
-0.08791457861661911,
0.9852672815322876,
-0.9444877505302429,
-1.180633783340454,
-0.5857706665992737,
-0.6249747276306152,
-0.2679300904273987,
0.22608594596385956,
0.17688649892807007,
0.2433818131685257,
-0.34918177127838135,
0.12191187590360641,
0.7498801946640015,
-0.583791196346283,
0.286202996969223,
0.3645217716693878,
-0.7124327421188354,
0.15914298593997955,
0.639970064163208,
0.15035668015480042,
0.5657423734664917,
-0.04177514463663101,
0.19433631002902985,
-0.04061638191342354,
-0.5312867164611816,
-0.09324608743190765,
0.4641597867012024,
-0.6649730801582336,
0.18538208305835724,
-0.5502985715866089,
-0.20447152853012085,
-0.3213273286819458,
-0.19399520754814148,
-0.3863596022129059,
-0.06694992631673813,
-0.3463119864463806,
-0.12870800495147705,
-0.0842854380607605,
1.0594631433486938,
-0.030483536422252655,
0.3653373122215271,
-0.5522149801254272,
0.0911049023270607,
0.4432425796985626,
0.27255555987358093,
0.3197268545627594,
-0.747745931148529,
-0.04408795014023781,
-0.04752717912197113,
-0.5629268884658813,
-0.5698135495185852,
0.20990854501724243,
-0.3180665075778961,
0.610980212688446,
0.9033876657485962,
-0.17975245416164398,
-0.017025306820869446,
-0.6548701524734497,
0.7713217735290527,
0.19281084835529327,
-0.8770828247070312,
0.31365254521369934,
-0.5137892365455627,
0.15724390745162964,
0.20331929624080658,
0.4274456202983856,
-0.4234822690486908,
-0.46036267280578613,
-0.6595728397369385,
-0.6889312267303467,
0.5858290195465088,
-0.2898869216442108,
0.6434890627861023,
-0.2160792201757431,
0.2181469053030014,
0.2058458775281906,
0.2879764437675476,
-0.9182065725326538,
-0.2613544464111328,
0.1716615855693817,
0.06622080504894257,
-0.16007938981056213,
-0.9760488271713257,
-0.2033345252275467,
-0.0754578709602356,
0.8204149007797241,
0.020454617217183113,
0.21763649582862854,
-0.10025706887245178,
0.049593180418014526,
-0.4760783016681671,
0.3594772219657898,
0.6981639266014099,
0.8805172443389893,
0.07086220383644104,
0.3117978274822235,
0.020583955571055412,
-0.3143661618232727,
0.16832111775875092,
-0.3663911819458008,
-0.48104265332221985,
-0.3600764572620392,
0.596915602684021,
0.9039579033851624,
-0.08677035570144653,
-0.5015653371810913,
0.5446839928627014,
0.2918274700641632,
-0.11197136342525482,
-0.4367297887802124,
0.039505623281002045,
0.24032947421073914,
0.21454232931137085,
0.26398149132728577,
-0.02255854196846485,
-0.1375032514333725,
-0.9225661158561707,
0.09245007485151291,
0.9193781614303589,
-0.33055493235588074,
-0.42389968037605286,
0.7218247056007385,
0.40082651376724243,
-0.27537575364112854,
0.6242982745170593,
0.23035873472690582,
-0.8277168273925781,
0.7205833792686462,
0.5430666208267212,
0.7130271196365356,
-0.3555825650691986,
-0.04578122869133949,
0.2893594205379486,
0.5655255913734436,
-0.08028388768434525,
0.051335737109184265,
0.4600667953491211,
-0.9328992366790771,
-0.5551304817199707,
-0.6379151344299316,
-0.12987466156482697,
0.3322465717792511,
-0.30474740266799927,
0.24709004163742065,
-0.5880217552185059,
-0.3100273907184601,
-0.06958407163619995,
-0.2606412470340729,
-0.3135453462600708,
0.20401960611343384,
0.4667235016822815,
0.7987352013587952,
-1.0085890293121338,
0.7266632318496704,
0.22214935719966888,
-0.4307105243206024,
-0.48502102494239807,
0.12216299027204514,
-0.008768687024712563,
-0.8521482348442078,
1.0880194902420044,
-0.001925294753164053,
0.13822701573371887,
-0.4349319338798523,
-0.8303858041763306,
-0.9230937957763672,
0.4046778380870819,
0.5714617967605591,
-0.7324444055557251,
-0.3794386386871338,
0.20837026834487915,
0.328277051448822,
-0.37407973408699036,
0.13445742428302765,
0.3370429277420044,
0.5443263053894043,
-0.06935999542474747,
-1.0385358333587646,
0.1366039663553238,
0.15962305665016174,
0.16210873425006866,
0.16399754583835602,
-0.8900585770606995,
0.9181573987007141,
-0.23834645748138428,
0.10424984991550446,
-0.25472205877304077,
0.39277011156082153,
0.01499983947724104,
-0.029719969257712364,
0.12873919308185577,
0.49411389231681824,
0.3763386011123657,
-0.13961271941661835,
1.2981199026107788,
-0.12056082487106323,
0.1443948596715927,
0.9181270003318787,
-0.5960993766784668,
0.33339923620224,
0.5561200976371765,
-0.44527149200439453,
0.14978811144828796,
0.3014739751815796,
0.09235399961471558,
0.2701203227043152,
0.6684402227401733,
-0.3330305218696594,
-0.19520141184329987,
-0.11234500259160995,
-0.5014194846153259,
0.4055662751197815,
0.4177709221839905,
-0.7950551509857178,
-0.02932884357869625,
-0.017727727070450783,
0.3934442400932312,
0.12452150136232376,
-0.490303099155426,
0.5816114544868469,
0.40944093465805054,
-0.6996859908103943,
0.21502695977687836,
0.0246715284883976,
0.8210338950157166,
-0.33140334486961365,
0.3598978519439697,
0.051770370453596115,
0.3296136260032654,
-0.21868836879730225,
-0.9081233739852905,
0.5365692973136902,
-0.2586905360221863,
-0.4372681677341461,
0.029765009880065918,
0.830032467842102,
-0.0944623351097107,
-0.5139384269714355,
0.46396178007125854,
0.5616118907928467,
-0.1288365125656128,
-0.04559653252363205,
-0.8112449645996094,
0.6083188652992249,
0.13828665018081665,
-0.5257290601730347,
0.4194265604019165,
0.38489246368408203,
-0.12546002864837646,
0.949933648109436,
0.445034921169281,
0.1792334020137787,
0.11371509730815887,
-0.0355430468916893,
0.8737232089042664,
-0.5968974828720093,
-0.2332654893398285,
-1.2227143049240112,
0.15975186228752136,
0.05597413331270218,
-0.12164729833602905,
0.6512497663497925,
0.5040179491043091,
0.49843278527259827,
0.01383455190807581,
1.1238059997558594,
0.22806976735591888,
0.5074552297592163,
-0.5664728879928589,
0.812995433807373,
-0.29642975330352783,
0.32653743028640747,
-0.26555752754211426,
-1.2777085304260254,
-0.28261348605155945,
0.6504139304161072,
-0.7977966070175171,
0.635866105556488,
0.5999874472618103,
0.6261152029037476,
0.16758427023887634,
-0.04962217062711716,
0.35200729966163635,
0.7917028665542603,
0.3597603440284729,
0.4500485360622406,
1.1165759563446045,
0.004928575828671455,
0.14635524153709412,
-0.008708110079169273,
-0.29325777292251587,
-0.22143328189849854,
-0.7813371419906616,
-1.1590059995651245,
-0.3620343804359436,
-0.1986302137374878,
-0.6712749600410461,
-0.06538604944944382,
0.7620068788528442,
0.512880802154541,
-0.8065618872642517,
-0.39893561601638794,
0.015951992943882942,
0.38802751898765564,
0.5132632851600647,
-0.2708722949028015,
0.17146170139312744,
-0.08074599504470825,
-0.7960651516914368,
-0.26060721278190613,
0.14987128973007202,
-0.10764272511005402,
-0.9227496385574341,
-0.01577543467283249,
0.0007280089193955064,
0.23757149279117584,
0.8017047643661499,
0.29948562383651733,
-0.8813883662223816,
-0.5053102374076843,
-0.3617979884147644,
-0.412934809923172,
-0.060377199202775955,
0.8045880794525146,
-0.4231013357639313,
0.10845230519771576,
0.42625898122787476,
0.5337647795677185,
0.04585658386349678,
-0.35567086935043335,
0.8759674429893494,
-0.23764172196388245,
0.2598617374897003,
0.21474170684814453,
0.5663331151008606,
0.37081900238990784,
-0.4149969220161438,
0.21295775473117828,
0.24903449416160583,
-0.7528821229934692,
-0.9516872763633728,
0.5366426110267639,
-0.751638650894165,
-0.4577621817588806,
1.668040156364441,
0.25159668922424316,
-0.3452450633049011,
-0.0049292477779090405,
-0.46495023369789124,
0.1353146731853485,
-0.19513142108917236,
0.6904016733169556,
0.9879024624824524,
0.16637735068798065,
0.06303625553846359,
-0.767682671546936,
0.29543519020080566,
0.3635956346988678,
-0.4555070698261261,
0.2866472601890564,
0.5954710841178894,
0.43568095564842224,
0.09838613867759705,
0.49078235030174255,
-0.31219130754470825,
-0.10575796663761139,
-0.030694054439663887,
0.13376960158348083,
0.3396630883216858,
-0.14209631085395813,
-0.33342230319976807,
0.1276884227991104,
0.624526858329773,
0.3792083263397217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13133v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13133v1 | PathoLM: Identifying pathogenicity from the DNA sequence through the Genome Foundation Model | 2024-06-19T00:53:48 | 2024-06-19T00:53:48 | Sajib Acharjee Dip, Uddip Acharjee Shuvo, Tran Chau, Haoqiu Song, Petra Choi, Xuan Wang, Liqing Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, q-bio.GN | Pathogen identification is pivotal in diagnosing, treating, and preventing
diseases, crucial for controlling infections and safeguarding public health.
Traditional alignment-based methods, though widely used, are computationally
intense and reliant on extensive reference databases, often failing to detect
novel pathogens due to their low sensitivity and specificity. Similarly,
conventional machine learning techniques, while promising, require large
annotated datasets and extensive feature engineering and are prone to
overfitting. Addressing these challenges, we introduce PathoLM, a cutting-edge
pathogen language model optimized for the identification of pathogenicity in
bacterial and viral sequences. Leveraging the strengths of pre-trained DNA
models such as the Nucleotide Transformer, PathoLM requires minimal data for
fine-tuning, thereby enhancing pathogen detection capabilities. It effectively
captures a broader genomic context, significantly improving the identification
of novel and divergent pathogens. We developed a comprehensive data set
comprising approximately 30 species of viruses and bacteria, including ESKAPEE
pathogens, seven notably virulent bacterial strains resistant to antibiotics.
Additionally, we curated a species classification dataset centered specifically
on the ESKAPEE group. In comparative assessments, PathoLM dramatically
outperforms existing models like DciPatho, demonstrating robust zero-shot and
few-shot capabilities. Furthermore, we expanded PathoLM-Sp for ESKAPEE species
classification, where it showed superior performance compared to other advanced
deep learning methods, despite the complexities of the task. | [
-0.11298932880163193,
-1.017702579498291,
0.4305320978164673,
-0.24139754474163055,
-0.4460289478302002,
0.1929399073123932,
0.019797537475824356,
-0.2926067113876343,
0.23508979380130768,
0.5377190113067627,
-0.41166430711746216,
-0.5825085639953613,
-0.9184708595275879,
0.20319266617298126,
-0.2989579737186432,
0.9079709053039551,
0.35538628697395325,
-0.04508413001894951,
-0.29289668798446655,
-0.21009598672389984,
-0.2160547375679016,
-0.4184395968914032,
-0.22844402492046356,
-0.22254866361618042,
0.4492493271827698,
0.5286344885826111,
0.6105090975761414,
0.764028787612915,
0.9629670977592468,
0.17716297507286072,
-0.25032177567481995,
0.21511556208133698,
-0.33214449882507324,
0.2594609558582306,
-0.02661394700407982,
-0.2469664216041565,
-0.2184337079524994,
-0.044616375118494034,
0.23750077188014984,
0.9940028190612793,
-0.08531571179628372,
0.4458655118942261,
-0.3746086359024048,
0.673750102519989,
-0.5865936875343323,
-0.1253969818353653,
-0.1790965348482132,
0.4453577697277069,
-0.494741827249527,
-0.2154218852519989,
-0.7168315649032593,
-0.3024217486381531,
0.2163749784231186,
-0.6172125339508057,
-0.1232571080327034,
-0.36304548382759094,
0.5026319622993469,
0.32037267088890076,
-0.6890613436698914,
-0.11685886979103088,
-0.9624965786933899,
0.3413081765174866,
-0.5442266464233398,
0.501968264579773,
-0.07053471356630325,
0.34909677505493164,
-0.4047231674194336,
-0.5444117784500122,
-0.08186367899179459,
-0.13761641085147858,
0.2529037296772003,
0.03563258424401283,
-0.3642016053199768,
-0.06595370918512344,
0.29084306955337524,
0.26395097374916077,
-0.9846756458282471,
-0.15456418693065643,
-0.5584794878959656,
-0.18626055121421814,
0.44315049052238464,
0.06874879449605942,
0.5020124316215515,
-0.2786106467247009,
-0.5750978589057922,
-0.184725821018219,
-0.6114981770515442,
0.31045016646385193,
0.37808161973953247,
0.38929036259651184,
0.11942580342292786,
0.32305723428726196,
-0.014822755940258503,
0.9020453691482544,
-0.038636207580566406,
-0.3537400960922241,
0.3700107932090759,
-0.11840518563985825,
-0.4468280076980591,
0.12473652511835098,
0.5694483518600464,
0.015184633433818817,
-0.3137767016887665,
-0.051612891256809235,
0.272365927696228,
-0.18283459544181824,
0.4954555928707123,
-0.8526228666305542,
-0.41818100214004517,
0.27271658182144165,
-0.4438709616661072,
-0.5017731189727783,
-0.0306010153144598,
-0.8547143340110779,
-0.6223335862159729,
-0.10232146084308624,
0.18807639181613922,
-0.5844842791557312,
-0.365748792886734,
-0.013937746174633503,
-0.2028570920228958,
0.3732101023197174,
0.20964694023132324,
-0.5730118155479431,
0.25329115986824036,
0.784977912902832,
0.9744245409965515,
-0.4133104085922241,
0.1329939067363739,
-0.5451065301895142,
0.1683914214372635,
-0.35437774658203125,
0.4828767478466034,
-0.7392891645431519,
-0.5578383803367615,
-0.42793402075767517,
-0.1017773300409317,
0.045694272965192795,
-0.6148472428321838,
0.5630108118057251,
-0.2663491666316986,
-0.5603601932525635,
-0.09710751473903656,
-0.5657800436019897,
-0.3175046741962433,
0.11470503360033035,
-0.6581306457519531,
0.7671209573745728,
-0.033828120678663254,
-0.7767679691314697,
0.28437677025794983,
-0.2451900690793991,
-0.7139589786529541,
0.3629762828350067,
0.12575596570968628,
-0.7616369724273682,
0.12066031992435455,
0.0013885579537600279,
0.5555539131164551,
-0.21454109251499176,
0.5831207633018494,
-0.5843791365623474,
-0.09818989038467407,
-0.08000598847866058,
-0.21563459932804108,
0.8960056900978088,
0.398954838514328,
0.08167244493961334,
0.19642381370067596,
-0.8128716945648193,
-0.3489599823951721,
0.17887544631958008,
0.06031439080834389,
-0.42125701904296875,
-0.012416374869644642,
-0.11464384198188782,
-0.1239420622587204,
-0.2212640941143036,
-0.5233379602432251,
0.494108110666275,
-0.5475751161575317,
0.4310307502746582,
0.6593961715698242,
0.11202613264322281,
0.42902854084968567,
-0.24768227338790894,
0.8021638989448547,
0.2083335965871811,
0.6953617930412292,
-0.21576479077339172,
-0.8664126396179199,
-0.15461929142475128,
-0.27771618962287903,
0.11556103825569153,
0.758102536201477,
-0.2566992938518524,
0.1617627590894699,
-0.37329915165901184,
-1.0208724737167358,
0.050211917608976364,
0.029051881283521652,
0.20311713218688965,
0.8018661141395569,
0.4573346674442291,
-0.5407015085220337,
-0.5872898697853088,
-0.6267179846763611,
-0.022700045257806778,
-0.2715149521827698,
0.21418777108192444,
0.38245970010757446,
0.48613041639328003,
-0.30086809396743774,
0.7903738021850586,
-0.6469079852104187,
0.0684744194149971,
-0.31854599714279175,
-0.03904738277196884,
0.5312673449516296,
0.3665357828140259,
0.22236371040344238,
-1.0440666675567627,
-0.3143448531627655,
0.36121445894241333,
-0.7102077603340149,
-0.021976005285978317,
0.37466058135032654,
0.02246650494635105,
-0.27806997299194336,
0.35834699869155884,
-0.49383431673049927,
0.3118668496608734,
0.3806174099445343,
-0.17031927406787872,
0.31226685643196106,
0.09997200965881348,
-0.006109948270022869,
-1.0862234830856323,
0.380226194858551,
-0.08864470571279526,
-0.2636207938194275,
-1.0343040227890015,
0.4050056040287018,
0.10229012370109558,
-0.5149108171463013,
-0.5911757349967957,
0.2673574686050415,
-0.05575306713581085,
0.2015705704689026,
0.31258153915405273,
-0.5957633256912231,
0.01573237217962742,
0.14535774290561676,
0.12150373309850693,
0.32081910967826843,
0.6957640051841736,
-0.4066648781299591,
0.4586392045021057,
0.11774161458015442,
0.18353131413459778,
0.16863958537578583,
-0.4906568229198456,
0.31180381774902344,
0.024264220148324966,
0.3237243890762329,
-0.6399455666542053,
-0.21584883332252502,
0.6409043073654175,
-0.39319539070129395,
0.5103753805160522,
-0.4948985278606415,
-0.1455622911453247,
-0.5674585700035095,
-0.27615678310394287,
0.7264070510864258,
0.5996285080909729,
-0.3933551609516144,
1.1244471073150635,
0.4548598527908325,
-0.11001603305339813,
-0.7531755566596985,
-0.2515420913696289,
-0.10379206389188766,
-0.5376720428466797,
-0.5341562628746033,
0.11169762909412384,
-0.023291269317269325,
-0.10980407148599625,
-0.3738357722759247,
-0.37801674008369446,
-0.1646321564912796,
0.38453546166419983,
0.6551627516746521,
0.3716984987258911,
-0.25548189878463745,
0.3078691065311432,
-0.12212914228439331,
-0.15539850294589996,
-0.13290925323963165,
-0.5635325908660889,
0.2969033718109131,
0.0033241058699786663,
-0.5093023180961609,
-0.030008934438228607,
0.3228882849216461,
0.6034496426582336,
-0.3541884124279022,
0.23120270669460297,
0.414518266916275,
-0.5665609836578369,
-0.14900533854961395,
-0.07921358197927475,
-0.061358753591775894,
-0.4044380784034729,
0.34719595313072205,
-0.28632211685180664,
-0.42735612392425537,
0.3238440155982971,
-0.5072113275527954,
-0.2677854299545288,
0.12910617887973785,
0.29317930340766907,
0.05695482715964317,
0.30795976519584656,
0.6022207140922546,
-0.3375582695007324,
-0.23655259609222412,
-0.12239610403776169,
0.6062598824501038,
-0.49271562695503235,
-0.43166714906692505,
-0.4656207263469696,
0.1833754926919937,
-0.3248303234577179,
-0.6414712071418762,
0.31097036600112915,
0.27702999114990234,
-0.16944104433059692,
0.44194215536117554,
-0.6477476358413696,
0.23650436103343964,
0.4206639528274536,
0.23838689923286438,
0.10792693495750427,
-0.4697244167327881,
-0.23270456492900848,
0.38806650042533875,
-0.719554603099823,
-0.5352029204368591,
1.3619556427001953,
0.48635196685791016,
0.5800615549087524,
0.4909166693687439,
0.9456393122673035,
0.5469706058502197,
0.13272029161453247,
-0.8381967544555664,
0.31942614912986755,
-0.38770443201065063,
-0.4275146722793579,
-0.2856086492538452,
-0.29058387875556946,
-0.8273947834968567,
-0.29839223623275757,
-0.08592697232961655,
-0.7058125138282776,
0.3233714997768402,
0.2802791893482208,
-0.6768580079078674,
0.38833093643188477,
-0.6267694234848022,
1.0196092128753662,
-0.15592864155769348,
-0.0403248593211174,
0.3248528242111206,
-1.0590771436691284,
0.4558497369289398,
-0.15591086447238922,
0.2873123586177826,
-0.15716174244880676,
0.3077107071876526,
0.5474010705947876,
-0.5869067907333374,
0.8936151266098022,
0.04891869053244591,
-0.007246426306664944,
0.05599191412329674,
0.3037870228290558,
0.2619618773460388,
0.271975040435791,
0.0763552263379097,
0.34970366954803467,
-0.2821884751319885,
-0.35257792472839355,
-0.31230664253234863,
0.29584580659866333,
-0.45261842012405396,
-0.7930269241333008,
-0.47362929582595825,
-0.2898698151111603,
-0.06618405133485794,
0.3307252824306488,
0.298699289560318,
0.5867571830749512,
-0.3021370768547058,
0.009681686758995056,
1.1299749612808228,
-0.42299216985702515,
0.293458491563797,
0.23555968701839447,
-0.0759272426366806,
-0.16840216517448425,
1.0498692989349365,
-0.2545228600502014,
0.32485029101371765,
0.72439044713974,
0.3557039201259613,
-0.175319641828537,
-0.6406503915786743,
-0.7035350203514099,
-0.47845524549484253,
-0.7538928389549255,
-0.5667316317558289,
-0.6603303551673889,
-0.23359014093875885,
-0.5742959976196289,
-0.09946074336767197,
-0.2556459903717041,
-0.16179169714450836,
-0.2927216589450836,
-0.4086413085460663,
0.7501543164253235,
0.7217066287994385,
-0.138800710439682,
0.0036131779197603464,
-0.8425632119178772,
0.29150864481925964,
0.17133964598178864,
-0.09219509363174438,
-0.2903136610984802,
-0.39220526814460754,
0.13168217241764069,
-0.1284867376089096,
-0.35260245203971863,
-1.2856056690216064,
0.6527498364448547,
0.4395168125629425,
0.329967200756073,
0.716785728931427,
-0.07395423948764801,
0.2943277359008789,
-0.6172953248023987,
0.6914101839065552,
0.137270987033844,
-0.8181777000427246,
1.1404081583023071,
-0.25064876675605774,
0.02866431139409542,
0.3180505931377411,
0.6453383564949036,
-0.5060849785804749,
-0.4080796241760254,
-0.4119708240032196,
-0.9997242093086243,
0.3940604627132416,
0.08828907459974289,
-0.2736622989177704,
-0.032937292009592056,
0.16091661155223846,
0.3417041003704071,
-0.25700902938842773,
-0.45480456948280334,
-0.5881924629211426,
-0.36716726422309875,
-0.26730895042419434,
-0.0897010788321495,
-0.003779085585847497,
-0.16924871504306793,
-0.32548731565475464,
0.5419025421142578,
-0.0038620743434876204,
0.10745291411876678,
0.34515678882598877,
-0.3739100396633148,
-0.26237115263938904,
0.1097717136144638,
0.6466827392578125,
0.4651593863964081,
-0.2812148630619049,
0.3375161290168762,
-0.01880955509841442,
-0.8752382397651672,
0.5035267472267151,
0.5813788771629333,
-0.3262789845466614,
0.025122422724962234,
0.7021458148956299,
0.5228320360183716,
-0.2857969403266907,
-0.759070873260498,
0.619796633720398,
0.2006906121969223,
0.16280575096607208,
-0.13309995830059052,
0.15455833077430725,
0.006698321085423231,
0.29388314485549927,
0.6558547019958496,
0.5404159426689148,
0.5812263488769531,
-0.2084318846464157,
0.443227082490921,
0.35460102558135986,
-0.46921506524086,
-0.38140764832496643,
0.49543496966362,
0.16917559504508972,
-0.3842349946498871,
0.6204742789268494,
0.012247429229319096,
-0.5838651657104492,
1.1634752750396729,
0.4688142240047455,
0.6445436477661133,
-0.7546306848526001,
0.4038255512714386,
0.3507503867149353,
0.25521329045295715,
0.29829806089401245,
-0.13666251301765442,
-0.06846845149993896,
-0.7428781986236572,
-0.08526449650526047,
-0.8658723831176758,
-0.18936455249786377,
0.09517310559749603,
-0.6758577227592468,
0.29171714186668396,
-0.4468526840209961,
-0.09426876157522202,
0.429130882024765,
-0.14161843061447144,
-0.1925479769706726,
0.17999297380447388,
0.3391905128955841,
0.9857614636421204,
-1.4729890823364258,
0.8223297595977783,
0.4565388560295105,
-0.3897629380226135,
-0.8310940861701965,
-0.232210174202919,
0.34933552145957947,
-0.6753142476081848,
0.6242408752441406,
0.49588221311569214,
0.007861373946070671,
-0.09811536222696304,
-0.06818940490484238,
-0.797370195388794,
1.1283613443374634,
0.3353526294231415,
-0.7810817360877991,
0.281518816947937,
0.14895415306091309,
0.31181246042251587,
-0.17182397842407227,
0.056942690163850784,
0.2807850241661072,
0.3327166736125946,
0.13197442889213562,
-0.7202794551849365,
0.129595547914505,
-0.47823652625083923,
0.04507846385240555,
0.6066862940788269,
-0.23947854340076447,
0.5461089015007019,
-0.5648462772369385,
-0.07342635840177536,
-0.046388160437345505,
0.3287504315376282,
0.32714128494262695,
0.3758629858493805,
0.1642981767654419,
0.9787912964820862,
0.8992961645126343,
-0.17009855806827545,
1.0065205097198486,
-0.05904042348265648,
0.0504748597741127,
1.012585163116455,
-0.34786519408226013,
0.5552969574928284,
0.5155239701271057,
-0.21534700691699982,
0.21377606689929962,
1.0423511266708374,
-0.22175055742263794,
0.5592437386512756,
0.4102592170238495,
-0.18715819716453552,
-0.1920592486858368,
-0.11894155293703079,
-0.4758254885673523,
0.24462343752384186,
0.36640703678131104,
-0.38212236762046814,
0.22278152406215668,
0.3383369743824005,
-0.3912857174873352,
-0.18774357438087463,
-0.39018842577934265,
0.6599330902099609,
0.08148044347763062,
-0.07916249334812164,
0.11824655532836914,
-0.28674203157424927,
0.2664201259613037,
-0.5033431649208069,
-0.24876439571380615,
-0.1833738088607788,
0.006843052804470062,
-0.0718223825097084,
-0.4021359086036682,
0.3177133798599243,
-0.410910040140152,
-0.2646196782588959,
-0.031813282519578934,
0.7528824210166931,
-0.1476961225271225,
-0.6756328344345093,
0.2958807945251465,
0.2995792031288147,
0.01580802910029888,
0.3086966574192047,
-0.2984820306301117,
-0.2188451588153839,
-0.2550915479660034,
-0.13751856982707977,
-0.32306602597236633,
0.2935241758823395,
-0.015795079991221428,
0.7783000469207764,
0.7407938241958618,
0.2344537079334259,
-0.11348526179790497,
0.07041054219007492,
0.5846182107925415,
-0.32431215047836304,
-0.2215711921453476,
-1.1450830698013306,
0.2429446280002594,
-0.04018550366163254,
-0.2517387270927429,
0.5915471911430359,
0.6838201880455017,
0.8808444142341614,
-0.19840267300605774,
0.5925135016441345,
0.08850664645433426,
0.2584381699562073,
-0.1583154946565628,
0.47994664311408997,
-0.2615230977535248,
0.17664387822151184,
-0.35303643345832825,
-0.36633676290512085,
-0.5185201168060303,
0.22297407686710358,
0.029479708522558212,
-0.21387097239494324,
0.5461627840995789,
0.5508026480674744,
-0.15027667582035065,
-0.08617326617240906,
0.05688776448369026,
0.31331440806388855,
0.21769309043884277,
0.7022790312767029,
0.785923182964325,
-0.23854972422122955,
0.2651048004627228,
-0.4039502739906311,
-0.26879996061325073,
-0.21726463735103607,
-1.0155309438705444,
-0.6612374186515808,
-0.46127960085868835,
-0.29164862632751465,
-0.16855379939079285,
0.6209219098091125,
0.8890888690948486,
0.9534070491790771,
-0.8895646333694458,
0.1314591020345688,
-0.3777755796909332,
0.13899390399456024,
-0.33523285388946533,
-0.12385836243629456,
0.3135221004486084,
0.13783220946788788,
-0.13182184100151062,
0.4180234968662262,
0.6482444405555725,
0.12633731961250305,
0.034954529255628586,
-0.11854806542396545,
-0.13091354072093964,
-0.14996552467346191,
0.422618567943573,
0.5338076949119568,
-0.7413111329078674,
-0.060593873262405396,
0.2025224268436432,
-0.08416252583265305,
0.07801278680562973,
0.5385342836380005,
-0.5694926381111145,
0.6012263894081116,
0.3172670006752014,
0.8781419992446899,
0.18826736509799957,
-0.11807489395141602,
0.7882699370384216,
-0.4776274859905243,
0.11584494262933731,
0.6069887280464172,
0.2353789508342743,
0.3338610827922821,
-0.8133755326271057,
0.6591181755065918,
0.4605233371257782,
-0.10001341253519058,
-0.8781527876853943,
0.4591483771800995,
-0.9843434691429138,
-0.38605377078056335,
0.9737361073493958,
-0.2416151762008667,
-0.26122650504112244,
-0.20718201994895935,
0.28066542744636536,
0.28316861391067505,
-0.19119736552238464,
0.20742644369602203,
0.35246187448501587,
-0.10641716420650482,
-0.07024239003658295,
-0.08212428539991379,
0.5031929612159729,
0.17898651957511902,
-0.6863407492637634,
-0.15725092589855194,
0.1639227271080017,
0.21999287605285645,
0.320689857006073,
0.5516844987869263,
0.005746173672378063,
0.28648051619529724,
-0.29626739025115967,
-0.04094240069389343,
-0.07854550331830978,
-0.7134329676628113,
-0.5129303336143494,
0.22671400010585785,
0.09748324006795883,
-0.014942764304578304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13131v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13131v2 | When Parts are Greater Than Sums: Individual LLM Components Can Outperform Full Models | 2024-06-19T00:48:44 | 2024-06-24T15:13:13 | Ting-Yun Chang, Jesse Thomason, Robin Jia | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper studies in-context learning (ICL) by decomposing the output of
large language models into the individual contributions of attention heads and
MLPs (components). We observe curious components: good-performing ones that
individually do well on a classification task, even when the model performs
poorly; bad-performing ones that do much worse than chance; and label-biased
components that always predict the same label. We find that component
accuracies are well-correlated across different demonstration sets and
perturbations of prompt templates, even when the full-model accuracy varies
greatly. Based on our findings, we propose component reweighting, which learns
to linearly re-scale the component activations from a few labeled examples.
Given 24 labeled examples, our method improves by an average of 6.0% accuracy
points over 24-shot ICL across 8 tasks on Llama-2-7B. Overall, this paper both
enriches our understanding of ICL and provides a practical method for
improvement by examining model internals. | [
-0.18145647644996643,
-0.385381817817688,
0.5331461429595947,
0.17748373746871948,
-0.4062543213367462,
0.08782152831554413,
-0.33992862701416016,
-0.35669559240341187,
-0.14461031556129456,
0.34293824434280396,
-0.4735247492790222,
-0.3424561023712158,
-0.6151162385940552,
-0.013480840250849724,
-0.4603472948074341,
1.1598594188690186,
0.05209017172455788,
0.13332335650920868,
-0.5859150886535645,
-0.421933114528656,
-0.5696335434913635,
-0.5342539548873901,
-0.6343913674354553,
-0.7496399879455566,
0.603469729423523,
0.7267518639564514,
0.09108966588973999,
0.43470972776412964,
0.33854347467422485,
0.2518214285373688,
-0.049344394356012344,
0.2149803191423416,
-0.6549200415611267,
0.09688739478588104,
-0.10445156693458557,
-0.6302310228347778,
-0.26567932963371277,
0.041898731142282486,
0.752770185470581,
0.7446281313896179,
0.03373933210968971,
0.3228488564491272,
0.6188839077949524,
0.541458010673523,
-0.6371203064918518,
0.5219197273254395,
-0.6857059597969055,
0.001954424660652876,
0.03102431446313858,
-0.18820253014564514,
-0.9367673397064209,
0.17197196185588837,
0.08458079397678375,
-0.3877367079257965,
0.00036735119647346437,
0.03480993211269379,
0.5975081324577332,
0.5326962471008301,
-0.5948926210403442,
-0.17954693734645844,
-0.468723326921463,
1.170451045036316,
-0.786756157875061,
0.386739581823349,
0.34229016304016113,
0.152495339512825,
-0.25490447878837585,
-0.6956798434257507,
-0.2513576149940491,
-0.16096340119838715,
-0.026208030059933662,
0.020262200385332108,
-0.13181504607200623,
0.02704370766878128,
0.09388477355241776,
0.2543380558490753,
-0.11442623287439346,
0.37038540840148926,
-0.15094684064388275,
-0.021085230633616447,
0.45941758155822754,
0.02701839804649353,
0.2558503746986389,
0.23255813121795654,
-0.4262086749076843,
-0.23437410593032837,
-1.0986833572387695,
0.23283542692661285,
-0.10101500898599625,
0.46650996804237366,
-0.22805385291576385,
0.5101032853126526,
-0.10013598203659058,
0.7324561476707458,
0.4978395104408264,
-0.5103282928466797,
0.20726032555103302,
-0.29039713740348816,
-0.47278717160224915,
0.23455969989299774,
0.2681140601634979,
0.2265041023492813,
0.1416998654603958,
-0.25346967577934265,
-0.21733589470386505,
-0.2705681622028351,
0.13332928717136383,
-0.7393004298210144,
-0.27203020453453064,
0.10233865678310394,
-0.3557865023612976,
-0.1004885658621788,
-0.007065702695399523,
-0.011792096309363842,
-0.248276948928833,
-0.8888427019119263,
0.5020027756690979,
-0.2242090255022049,
0.2168276011943817,
-0.011478100903332233,
0.23697373270988464,
0.217239648103714,
0.4252816438674927,
-0.754223108291626,
0.2719739079475403,
0.7748360633850098,
0.6116867661476135,
-0.3583938181400299,
-0.3885176181793213,
-0.7814511656761169,
0.04936882480978966,
-0.4254459738731384,
0.9579164385795593,
-0.27980557084083557,
-0.12913668155670166,
-0.20628705620765686,
-0.01933332346379757,
0.22775603830814362,
-0.8309783339500427,
0.21093697845935822,
-0.35427844524383545,
-0.015006139874458313,
-0.6345744729042053,
-0.7425395846366882,
-0.20792929828166962,
0.16135209798812866,
-0.4146299958229065,
0.9104557633399963,
0.15779772400856018,
-0.7619084715843201,
0.7800536155700684,
-0.03861605003476143,
-0.3637005388736725,
-0.06012594327330589,
-0.38186967372894287,
-0.4486978054046631,
0.5089620351791382,
0.2094164788722992,
0.8102274537086487,
-0.2725682556629181,
0.2530580461025238,
-0.21692121028900146,
-0.4954085052013397,
0.5030499696731567,
-0.29469847679138184,
0.7853321433067322,
-0.19333091378211975,
-0.29803454875946045,
0.4223702847957611,
-0.7018898725509644,
-0.09009632468223572,
-0.243306502699852,
-0.6304886937141418,
-0.433149129152298,
0.018429262563586235,
-0.10133633762598038,
0.2616885304450989,
-0.10992461442947388,
-0.5677086710929871,
0.12367364764213562,
-0.5448277592658997,
0.24113145470619202,
0.9779664278030396,
-0.03718188777565956,
0.5599377751350403,
-0.31496965885162354,
0.26247143745422363,
0.34998056292533875,
-0.1135711520910263,
-0.40018168091773987,
-0.4134063422679901,
-0.9752047061920166,
-0.33736422657966614,
0.17298729717731476,
0.11559201776981354,
-0.7994263768196106,
0.4174366891384125,
-0.18219688534736633,
-0.32715216279029846,
-0.3602182865142822,
0.2682938873767853,
0.5976355075836182,
1.0058503150939941,
0.3714545965194702,
-0.38605746626853943,
-0.15997496247291565,
-1.0680218935012817,
-0.020222537219524384,
-0.22134165465831757,
-0.2488013207912445,
0.16151751577854156,
0.34550556540489197,
0.082778699696064,
0.9237692356109619,
-0.30404022336006165,
-0.25436729192733765,
-0.3442348837852478,
0.08949945867061615,
0.03779296949505806,
0.3249458074569702,
0.40452784299850464,
-0.5471101403236389,
-0.7325843572616577,
0.0023408762644976377,
-0.6607726216316223,
-0.20706021785736084,
0.03793024644255638,
0.13795553147792816,
0.16518954932689667,
0.7030879855155945,
-0.26585736870765686,
0.31316471099853516,
0.3573426604270935,
-0.3927968442440033,
0.4468744397163391,
-0.31534478068351746,
-0.24074691534042358,
-1.053685188293457,
-0.23869678378105164,
0.25335341691970825,
-0.347867488861084,
-0.5524293184280396,
0.3424210250377655,
0.321189284324646,
0.23686233162879944,
-0.735378086566925,
0.5300477743148804,
-0.4445968270301819,
-0.3507417142391205,
-0.5678389072418213,
0.15042424201965332,
0.004110477399080992,
0.6183640956878662,
-0.4309821128845215,
0.8437110185623169,
0.34008553624153137,
-0.6308281421661377,
0.20940741896629333,
-0.26379096508026123,
-0.9026631712913513,
0.526134729385376,
-0.4919029772281647,
0.03562336415052414,
-0.5389721989631653,
0.5233469009399414,
-1.252909779548645,
-0.2327013611793518,
-0.0033681760542094707,
-0.08180483430624008,
0.7649332284927368,
0.19853375852108002,
-0.4254947900772095,
0.08997543901205063,
-0.19646650552749634,
0.5886811017990112,
0.3128918707370758,
-0.7713221907615662,
0.48943933844566345,
0.4693034589290619,
0.02778007835149765,
-0.8208836317062378,
-0.860906720161438,
-0.09645657986402512,
-0.39100223779678345,
-0.0815877914428711,
0.5360333919525146,
-0.20046012103557587,
-0.3898034691810608,
-0.011724653653800488,
-0.08418982475996017,
-0.06397592276334763,
0.18507170677185059,
0.12413699179887772,
-0.14860379695892334,
-0.21511545777320862,
0.49160218238830566,
-0.0876695066690445,
-0.2472231537103653,
-0.1235058382153511,
-0.31238260865211487,
0.36472201347351074,
-0.06269684433937073,
-0.4445360004901886,
-0.4908556044101715,
0.18153655529022217,
0.5751529335975647,
-0.06391077488660812,
0.5195187926292419,
0.28990310430526733,
-0.387519896030426,
-0.46873512864112854,
-0.42403239011764526,
-0.3197605311870575,
-0.40301698446273804,
0.7356751561164856,
-0.3865872323513031,
-0.7900441884994507,
0.5321147441864014,
0.2527293860912323,
0.28122565150260925,
0.32337963581085205,
0.6134772300720215,
-0.019346514716744423,
0.9242892861366272,
1.0424871444702148,
-0.523908793926239,
0.45062801241874695,
-0.235538512468338,
0.20556777715682983,
-1.0149147510528564,
-0.3284149467945099,
-0.2649560570716858,
-0.520696759223938,
-0.16979511082172394,
-0.6543173789978027,
0.415908545255661,
0.05286792665719986,
-0.3110806345939636,
0.21063582599163055,
-0.37383541464805603,
0.68815016746521,
0.5305824875831604,
0.4340529441833496,
0.33276841044425964,
0.0966123640537262,
-0.04256462678313255,
-0.20101499557495117,
-0.7312242388725281,
-0.19437962770462036,
1.1633381843566895,
0.34448298811912537,
0.9095553755760193,
0.05726923793554306,
0.3360925316810608,
0.13112856447696686,
0.8121390342712402,
-1.0302162170410156,
0.3208821713924408,
-0.30937570333480835,
-0.25663185119628906,
-0.29975250363349915,
-0.11828532814979553,
-0.6192370653152466,
0.4379465579986572,
0.05716856196522713,
-0.815332293510437,
0.2909521162509918,
0.2431400865316391,
-0.4116469919681549,
0.2933594882488251,
-0.5247616171836853,
0.49637049436569214,
-0.2246527224779129,
-0.26434326171875,
-0.27864715456962585,
-0.4909002482891083,
0.46671023964881897,
-0.11473724991083145,
-0.08477575331926346,
-0.032878898084163666,
-0.08879921585321426,
0.4350532293319702,
-0.2002211958169937,
1.1830674409866333,
0.0975366085767746,
-0.3024778664112091,
0.3694859445095062,
-0.1452566683292389,
0.320686012506485,
-0.1373308300971985,
0.086467444896698,
-0.06374664604663849,
-0.5066574811935425,
-0.47992902994155884,
-0.824268639087677,
0.7610334753990173,
-0.785407543182373,
-0.47095704078674316,
-0.08733480423688889,
-0.6432123780250549,
-0.253167986869812,
-0.11016640067100525,
0.4085608720779419,
0.8971365690231323,
0.23484379053115845,
0.6649244427680969,
0.977271556854248,
-0.2583329975605011,
0.4882943630218506,
0.3694016635417938,
-0.1646646112203598,
-0.14309810101985931,
0.9018796682357788,
0.35318848490715027,
0.40230879187583923,
0.8221308588981628,
0.18217572569847107,
-0.12040488421916962,
-0.35362038016319275,
-0.39066654443740845,
0.23573686182498932,
-1.1713777780532837,
-0.43135762214660645,
-0.5687410235404968,
-0.014333455823361874,
-0.1683342009782791,
-0.19310232996940613,
-0.45524683594703674,
-0.2066035270690918,
-0.3607329726219177,
-0.33652034401893616,
-0.2959789037704468,
0.8843535780906677,
0.33761849999427795,
0.31922805309295654,
-0.20951494574546814,
-0.19774684309959412,
0.6584113240242004,
0.06759937852621078,
0.5334354043006897,
-0.7206190228462219,
-0.5535356998443604,
-0.0958586260676384,
-0.404725581407547,
-0.5730336308479309,
0.23491762578487396,
0.26907193660736084,
0.6633760929107666,
0.6407679915428162,
-0.07507796585559845,
0.8155210018157959,
-0.5135250091552734,
0.7936641573905945,
0.06754246354103088,
-0.8821598291397095,
0.03627491742372513,
-0.03257831186056137,
0.8157603144645691,
0.4927881062030792,
0.17378614842891693,
-0.3483467400074005,
-0.5080065727233887,
-0.4789453446865082,
-0.9277533888816833,
0.6294779181480408,
-0.18066509068012238,
0.05015536770224571,
0.12649112939834595,
0.5475931763648987,
0.05391465127468109,
0.07509643584489822,
-1.0164103507995605,
-0.27160823345184326,
0.15326638519763947,
-0.4800354540348053,
-0.3599901497364044,
-0.5898404717445374,
0.08937887102365494,
-0.31103116273880005,
0.774718701839447,
-0.42873725295066833,
0.2078295201063156,
0.14499863982200623,
-0.26884910464286804,
-0.057525791227817535,
0.05321858823299408,
0.8439813852310181,
1.0571134090423584,
-0.01523583009839058,
0.41026079654693604,
0.32722359895706177,
-0.005704313982278109,
0.30468326807022095,
-0.444045752286911,
-0.05239188298583031,
-0.2569929361343384,
0.782406747341156,
0.7723812460899353,
0.8171256184577942,
-0.7197251319885254,
0.5416272282600403,
-0.11769574135541916,
0.1591731160879135,
-0.177696093916893,
-0.120785653591156,
0.06426052749156952,
0.204389289021492,
0.501929521560669,
-0.188566654920578,
0.07125798612833023,
-0.7807270884513855,
0.4535970687866211,
0.317313551902771,
-0.6881619095802307,
-0.5565227270126343,
0.5152783989906311,
0.030924929305911064,
-0.10905663669109344,
0.5851233601570129,
0.013266247697174549,
-0.4740300178527832,
0.7906325459480286,
0.8681666254997253,
0.9594830870628357,
-0.2714337408542633,
0.016518745571374893,
0.17994312942028046,
0.2855473458766937,
-0.02769857458770275,
-0.22746780514717102,
-0.3493508994579315,
-0.831713080406189,
-0.8714303970336914,
-0.39530566334724426,
-0.36394795775413513,
0.25400301814079285,
-0.5419175028800964,
0.15916194021701813,
-0.32929298281669617,
0.07368918508291245,
-0.01769493892788887,
-0.11984658986330032,
-0.5788958072662354,
0.2283172756433487,
0.1755198985338211,
0.6604151129722595,
-1.0862724781036377,
0.9625503420829773,
0.7467318177223206,
-0.25884002447128296,
-0.7929514050483704,
0.25896281003952026,
0.013023433275520802,
-0.5324593186378479,
1.191576600074768,
0.32642778754234314,
-0.051632288843393326,
-0.22141844034194946,
-0.6266069412231445,
-1.2409604787826538,
0.9566629528999329,
0.4020826816558838,
-0.3409391939640045,
-0.028652774170041084,
-0.13012216985225677,
0.41561031341552734,
-0.6877036690711975,
0.1353241503238678,
0.18451723456382751,
0.008320493623614311,
-0.2234116792678833,
-0.7604230046272278,
-0.08926641196012497,
0.1625799983739853,
-0.0824664831161499,
0.026993950828909874,
-0.8786646127700806,
1.1191062927246094,
0.01722843386232853,
-0.23287706077098846,
-0.14950266480445862,
0.9518178701400757,
0.3736152946949005,
0.23728427290916443,
0.5902377367019653,
0.48103055357933044,
0.6915974020957947,
0.05999120697379112,
1.193369746208191,
-0.179923877120018,
0.24100640416145325,
1.4679421186447144,
-0.21039283275604248,
0.8035503625869751,
0.6433153748512268,
-0.11900463700294495,
0.42576003074645996,
0.631348729133606,
0.5586777925491333,
0.6298174858093262,
0.23554322123527527,
-0.3003389537334442,
-0.4145902991294861,
-0.12693850696086884,
0.1277739256620407,
0.488194078207016,
0.36110228300094604,
-0.3031599521636963,
-0.311195969581604,
0.4345703125,
-0.01382482424378395,
0.02591039426624775,
-0.3326517641544342,
0.7546981573104858,
0.40928739309310913,
-0.7494834065437317,
0.20153161883354187,
0.0462055578827858,
0.5902663469314575,
-0.3288671374320984,
-0.07180391252040863,
-0.3519081175327301,
0.5258249640464783,
0.052024174481630325,
-0.5146298408508301,
0.12487003207206726,
-0.3064367175102234,
-0.5058769583702087,
-0.23300312459468842,
0.7183060646057129,
-0.6063824892044067,
-0.5632622241973877,
0.22581930458545685,
-0.026155658066272736,
-0.011930488049983978,
0.055475685745477676,
-0.43691226840019226,
-0.04755730554461479,
0.15075375139713287,
-0.21166862547397614,
0.6317412853240967,
0.3047367334365845,
-0.13155438005924225,
0.9942487478256226,
0.14170774817466736,
-0.11364340037107468,
-0.001587661332450807,
-0.0955534428358078,
0.830264687538147,
-0.26228559017181396,
-0.4339207112789154,
-0.9072149395942688,
0.6949422955513,
-0.1037285253405571,
-0.395374059677124,
0.9600151777267456,
0.4728037416934967,
1.3586546182632446,
-0.008151397109031677,
0.3942471444606781,
0.45575979351997375,
0.49697113037109375,
-0.5557414293289185,
0.39013180136680603,
-0.6784851551055908,
0.22248117625713348,
-0.17146244645118713,
-1.027168869972229,
-0.5126036405563354,
0.5183132290840149,
-0.0008507533930242062,
-0.12321619689464569,
0.5582717061042786,
0.4607745409011841,
-0.13670581579208374,
-0.3531136214733124,
0.6019852757453918,
0.2391328662633896,
0.5234246850013733,
0.5304335355758667,
0.6474135518074036,
-0.4124387800693512,
0.025723768398165703,
-0.4634481370449066,
-0.28137508034706116,
-0.28795820474624634,
-0.8857484459877014,
-0.8771089911460876,
-0.6463324427604675,
-0.425540953874588,
-0.03788885474205017,
-0.21590833365917206,
1.0427148342132568,
0.9441348314285278,
-0.8460288047790527,
-0.5247898697853088,
0.1888938546180725,
0.243822380900383,
-0.3754151165485382,
-0.19619594514369965,
0.4265265464782715,
-0.6494044661521912,
-0.8003386855125427,
0.6232143640518188,
0.5237634181976318,
-0.1185990422964096,
-0.5186819434165955,
0.14771664142608643,
-0.0223054401576519,
-0.015522602945566177,
1.112385869026184,
0.03775233030319214,
-0.9667503237724304,
-0.42487508058547974,
-0.3245905041694641,
-0.08969051390886307,
0.020485972985625267,
0.9189214110374451,
-0.85860276222229,
0.4991484582424164,
0.48669156432151794,
0.8650665283203125,
0.40751996636390686,
0.17062661051750183,
0.5255390405654907,
-1.0912549495697021,
0.365196168422699,
0.01874646544456482,
0.5187546014785767,
0.4284386932849884,
-0.306350439786911,
0.3302208483219147,
-0.018686242401599884,
-0.8397431969642639,
-0.8316342830657959,
0.30950650572776794,
-0.7045201063156128,
-0.5270506739616394,
0.9690679907798767,
-0.2716917097568512,
-0.3732755184173584,
0.029009832069277763,
-0.0640406534075737,
0.14151954650878906,
-0.20206193625926971,
0.8982800245285034,
0.7486108541488647,
-0.296792596578598,
-0.11727967113256454,
-0.39357563853263855,
0.35599231719970703,
0.4483569264411926,
-0.44988712668418884,
0.12243048846721649,
0.4416080713272095,
0.3274986147880554,
0.09382400661706924,
0.6092436909675598,
0.05585016310214996,
-0.15562641620635986,
-0.3980492651462555,
0.012855051085352898,
0.17776742577552795,
-0.6928575038909912,
-0.5226744413375854,
0.19352415204048157,
0.27632299065589905,
-0.05184436962008476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13124v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13124v1 | Learning to Generate Answers with Citations via Factual Consistency Models | 2024-06-19T00:40:19 | 2024-06-19T00:40:19 | Rami Aly, Zhiqiang Tang, Samson Tan, George Karypis | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) frequently hallucinate, impeding their
reliability in mission-critical situations. One approach to address this issue
is to provide citations to relevant sources alongside generated content,
enhancing the verifiability of generations. However, citing passages accurately
in answers remains a substantial challenge. This paper proposes a
weakly-supervised fine-tuning method leveraging factual consistency models
(FCMs). Our approach alternates between generating texts with citations and
supervised fine-tuning with FCM-filtered citation data. Focused learning is
integrated into the objective, directing the fine-tuning process to emphasise
the factual unit tokens, as measured by an FCM. Results on the ALCE few-shot
citation benchmark with various instruction-tuned LLMs demonstrate superior
performance compared to in-context learning, vanilla supervised fine-tuning,
and state-of-the-art methods, with an average improvement of $34.1$, $15.5$,
and $10.5$ citation F$_1$ points, respectively. Moreover, in a domain transfer
setting we show that the obtained citation generation ability robustly
transfers to unseen datasets. Notably, our citation improvements contribute to
the lowest factual error rate across baselines. | [
-0.31507447361946106,
-0.8766093254089355,
1.0542106628417969,
-0.06592006236314774,
-0.046471092849969864,
-0.012921441346406937,
-0.5778850317001343,
-0.3432773947715759,
-0.16864372789859772,
0.4907341003417969,
-0.5537337064743042,
-0.5398399233818054,
-0.59218829870224,
0.33508431911468506,
-0.12375150620937347,
1.1009794473648071,
0.16550306975841522,
-0.14001354575157166,
-0.5688397288322449,
-0.07993436604738235,
-0.25831976532936096,
-0.21663108468055725,
-0.32310861349105835,
-0.20912836492061615,
0.7489174604415894,
0.7820766568183899,
0.6789496541023254,
0.8317937254905701,
0.548456072807312,
0.24580784142017365,
-0.13768059015274048,
0.9504427313804626,
-0.6147868037223816,
0.16668130457401276,
-0.7977336645126343,
-0.21457043290138245,
-0.08709223568439484,
-0.11688191443681717,
0.48581263422966003,
0.8969020843505859,
0.28942376375198364,
0.425435334444046,
0.18544599413871765,
0.4973018765449524,
-0.774768590927124,
0.1887582242488861,
-1.2762285470962524,
-0.43160030245780945,
-0.11591371893882751,
-0.47771844267845154,
-0.8027069568634033,
-0.575171172618866,
0.003352831583470106,
-0.6534605622291565,
0.602478563785553,
0.1430114209651947,
1.0356765985488892,
0.4527503550052643,
-0.4322549104690552,
-0.23824666440486908,
-0.6175326108932495,
0.8680431246757507,
-0.5516695380210876,
0.09857852011919022,
0.3878573775291443,
-0.1709507256746292,
-0.3236279785633087,
-0.7837293744087219,
-0.21457454562187195,
-0.09030050784349442,
-0.35061517357826233,
-0.17524905502796173,
0.10905428975820541,
-0.16693457961082458,
0.27599093317985535,
0.0051952265202999115,
-0.3785521984100342,
-0.12799020111560822,
-0.37316957116127014,
-0.20239578187465668,
0.5527982115745544,
-0.013429473154246807,
-0.3018922507762909,
-0.2882823050022125,
-0.29148462414741516,
-0.0023608135525137186,
-0.778277575969696,
-0.17791743576526642,
0.11525510251522064,
1.0316870212554932,
0.09952731430530548,
0.6958296895027161,
-0.4284738600254059,
0.5150608420372009,
0.45559966564178467,
-0.3478858768939972,
0.1335175335407257,
-0.5898703932762146,
-0.2427757829427719,
0.04810337722301483,
0.3703702688217163,
0.05738518014550209,
0.24565915763378143,
-0.5715185403823853,
0.08569219708442688,
-0.2363286167383194,
0.3903507888317108,
-0.9562450051307678,
-0.27409395575523376,
0.04170355200767517,
-0.201371967792511,
-0.3787740468978882,
0.1848713904619217,
-0.44921377301216125,
-0.37722542881965637,
-0.7862623929977417,
0.47782593965530396,
-0.4908406138420105,
0.1381060779094696,
-0.3234327435493469,
0.12219861894845963,
0.036614615470170975,
0.4480428099632263,
-0.7533886432647705,
-0.0650576800107956,
0.6430008411407471,
0.824957013130188,
-0.0843420997262001,
-0.035204965621232986,
-1.086225152015686,
0.26654040813446045,
-0.38961806893348694,
1.071498990058899,
-0.40611568093299866,
-0.37633392214775085,
0.29252156615257263,
0.23895230889320374,
-0.0999952033162117,
-0.7297512888908386,
0.8484328985214233,
-0.5092546939849854,
-0.3934370279312134,
-0.7301568984985352,
-0.6292631030082703,
0.15257427096366882,
0.24941624701023102,
-0.17175093293190002,
1.065068006515503,
-0.06631170213222504,
-0.6107795834541321,
0.49200090765953064,
-0.16844366490840912,
-0.5779579281806946,
-0.017043232917785645,
-0.07538127899169922,
-0.5886864066123962,
0.21404682099819183,
0.16074559092521667,
0.5054224133491516,
-0.1348453164100647,
0.6129353642463684,
-0.4435539245605469,
-0.2916279733181,
0.06446003913879395,
-0.2326497584581375,
0.47227805852890015,
0.3860023021697998,
-0.23786337673664093,
0.0861009731888771,
-1.0811933279037476,
0.08977257460355759,
-0.10083919763565063,
-0.5393542051315308,
-0.26143670082092285,
0.14454638957977295,
-0.060307569801807404,
-0.008485083468258381,
0.34889039397239685,
-0.4981858432292938,
0.09448600560426712,
-0.01850193925201893,
-0.13344508409500122,
0.6763126254081726,
0.31937089562416077,
0.40554964542388916,
-0.4652855396270752,
-0.03993234783411026,
0.08574929088354111,
-0.23522718250751495,
-0.2503250539302826,
-0.15465927124023438,
-0.8280963897705078,
-0.27871862053871155,
0.20652802288532257,
0.23801669478416443,
-0.7577201128005981,
0.2946852445602417,
-0.5803390741348267,
-0.4026617407798767,
-0.23022490739822388,
0.7873387336730957,
0.13761202991008759,
0.9783103466033936,
0.760185718536377,
0.45081162452697754,
-0.6066895723342896,
-0.8248186707496643,
-0.3471547067165375,
-0.3899824321269989,
0.011091634631156921,
0.397808313369751,
0.4840562045574188,
-0.18027763068675995,
0.952142596244812,
-0.429153174161911,
-0.11577578634023666,
0.09972722083330154,
0.5670713186264038,
0.07791229337453842,
0.6463614106178284,
0.5038546919822693,
-0.69358891248703,
-0.5035849809646606,
0.003963025286793709,
-0.9486202001571655,
-0.13670197129249573,
-0.204740509390831,
-0.3110530972480774,
0.13609284162521362,
0.6969687342643738,
-0.3547515869140625,
0.08797969669103622,
-0.006350778043270111,
-0.27824336290359497,
0.32397669553756714,
-0.07181527465581894,
0.1172923594713211,
-0.8655944466590881,
0.22433803975582123,
0.0827372670173645,
-0.4434507191181183,
-0.13367444276809692,
0.0839291661977768,
0.1894756406545639,
0.0485437847673893,
-0.3371005952358246,
0.18501044809818268,
-0.3571665287017822,
0.2499082386493683,
-0.43804416060447693,
0.12559854984283447,
0.09336245059967041,
0.2418735772371292,
0.06395526975393295,
0.5873731970787048,
0.26692140102386475,
-0.5565536618232727,
0.009699477814137936,
0.19498875737190247,
-0.18720215559005737,
0.813969075679779,
-0.6100804209709167,
0.11850210279226303,
-0.1859540194272995,
0.03609450161457062,
-0.8386673927307129,
-0.2739037871360779,
-0.24163907766342163,
-0.1755525767803192,
0.4707320034503937,
-0.6787800788879395,
-0.6639792323112488,
0.13731098175048828,
-0.1523248255252838,
0.06556233018636703,
0.31143683195114136,
-0.8479955196380615,
0.3792206645011902,
-0.030484268441796303,
-0.29908445477485657,
-0.3941945433616638,
-0.40311017632484436,
-0.0733097493648529,
-0.012418324127793312,
-0.7408262491226196,
0.41806620359420776,
-0.19148467481136322,
-0.2637211084365845,
0.054978031665086746,
-0.2524597942829132,
0.09790869802236557,
0.2249997854232788,
0.29321786761283875,
0.34731197357177734,
-0.5993555784225464,
0.22213546931743622,
0.24435624480247498,
0.18451549112796783,
-0.045735735446214676,
-0.22862045466899872,
-0.07770607620477676,
-0.3241845965385437,
-0.16217966377735138,
-0.05660498887300491,
0.2617205083370209,
0.3797617256641388,
-0.01378963328897953,
0.9802270531654358,
0.6434258818626404,
-0.23934243619441986,
-0.2458711415529251,
-0.5218338966369629,
-0.2629263997077942,
-0.4472694396972656,
-0.040534645318984985,
-0.32805147767066956,
-0.8742551207542419,
0.30389904975891113,
-0.41223129630088806,
0.2626974582672119,
0.39175787568092346,
0.514629602432251,
-0.1626867949962616,
0.6447727084159851,
0.5621575117111206,
0.23723195493221283,
0.23888514935970306,
0.0713578537106514,
-0.09653205424547195,
-0.39283517003059387,
-0.24605481326580048,
-0.8449338674545288,
-0.11675651371479034,
-0.5731603503227234,
-0.4097594916820526,
0.31186050176620483,
0.18387871980667114,
-0.4262038469314575,
0.06407152861356735,
-0.21060796082019806,
0.5028970837593079,
0.5342142581939697,
0.09149329364299774,
0.5608809590339661,
0.2313855141401291,
-0.1626507192850113,
-0.011458365246653557,
-0.5543136596679688,
-0.712837278842926,
1.1981968879699707,
0.13481956720352173,
0.7377267479896545,
0.19873976707458496,
0.7030593752861023,
0.31300076842308044,
0.4792838394641876,
-0.5116280913352966,
0.4121955335140228,
0.01643148623406887,
-0.6700111627578735,
-0.11069315671920776,
-0.4554236829280853,
-0.5261321067810059,
0.1776723712682724,
-0.506324052810669,
-0.5690508484840393,
0.4671046733856201,
0.16939952969551086,
-0.3590925931930542,
-0.04198508337140083,
-0.6935150623321533,
0.6115816235542297,
0.1301160752773285,
-1.0419310331344604,
-0.028035249561071396,
-0.648918628692627,
0.3697560131549835,
-0.12592960894107819,
0.15311460196971893,
-0.16084043681621552,
0.3482189476490021,
0.3309899568557739,
-0.523572564125061,
0.7646901607513428,
-0.23733247816562653,
-0.01921357400715351,
0.39470744132995605,
-0.06067133694887161,
0.8580299615859985,
0.5767514705657959,
-0.30568262934684753,
-0.12449831515550613,
-0.16508354246616364,
-0.5943596959114075,
-0.43060022592544556,
1.150381326675415,
-0.553899884223938,
-0.5883796215057373,
-0.313059538602829,
-0.54167640209198,
-0.6353616714477539,
0.23207446932792664,
0.21619880199432373,
0.282081663608551,
-0.09871649742126465,
0.659645140171051,
1.0380470752716064,
0.10445551574230194,
0.208191379904747,
0.7200614213943481,
0.14311301708221436,
-0.2734413146972656,
0.7833498120307922,
0.03966353461146355,
0.09892261028289795,
0.2469731569290161,
-0.09261234104633331,
-0.2522325813770294,
-0.6929489970207214,
-0.6104447245597839,
0.3197188377380371,
-0.7746971845626831,
-0.628318727016449,
-0.5283889770507812,
-0.21987630426883698,
-0.44933462142944336,
-0.19008472561836243,
-0.48414546251296997,
-0.11252027750015259,
-0.4985961318016052,
-0.3528795838356018,
0.471728652715683,
0.20842444896697998,
-0.1624571830034256,
0.10448074340820312,
-0.5008550882339478,
0.4438073933124542,
0.25502532720565796,
0.10144448280334473,
-0.28488999605178833,
-0.7504413723945618,
-0.4715000092983246,
0.1887165904045105,
-0.35633209347724915,
-0.376669704914093,
-0.20771393179893494,
0.4623594284057617,
0.3386474847793579,
0.21655850112438202,
0.4403983950614929,
0.993066132068634,
-0.5954998135566711,
0.6448245048522949,
-0.29189246892929077,
-0.6951565146446228,
0.6777307391166687,
-0.3179647922515869,
0.09946723282337189,
1.2291162014007568,
0.27487775683403015,
0.37183859944343567,
-0.38355955481529236,
-0.611750066280365,
-0.8775733709335327,
0.5583402514457703,
0.16256214678287506,
0.07038483768701553,
-0.2895765006542206,
0.4028075635433197,
0.04876057058572769,
0.010313277132809162,
-0.46184104681015015,
-0.3494624197483063,
-0.20565812289714813,
-0.36471661925315857,
-0.00676855118945241,
-0.08556370437145233,
-0.2972692847251892,
-0.2276020646095276,
1.1043559312820435,
-0.6800202131271362,
-0.24774135649204254,
0.418478399515152,
-0.3297805190086365,
-0.4067254662513733,
0.31779345870018005,
0.724784255027771,
0.79937744140625,
-0.44018712639808655,
0.5927818417549133,
0.08313505351543427,
-0.08367246389389038,
0.050903771072626114,
0.22070783376693726,
-0.5804128050804138,
0.342917263507843,
0.1461586356163025,
0.4411312937736511,
0.39350396394729614,
-0.6386824250221252,
0.38283753395080566,
0.16197358071804047,
-0.2924368679523468,
-0.14789298176765442,
0.09221004694700241,
0.16967527568340302,
0.22856593132019043,
0.727545976638794,
0.3557562828063965,
-0.1127254068851471,
-0.5047024488449097,
0.23267412185668945,
0.4529118239879608,
-0.18771007657051086,
-0.1536039561033249,
0.6736300587654114,
0.0637117475271225,
0.35591745376586914,
0.34725844860076904,
-0.12109394371509552,
0.10245814919471741,
0.2526262700557709,
0.6456673741340637,
0.4616907238960266,
0.3717866539955139,
0.33319470286369324,
0.7278187274932861,
0.26823142170906067,
-0.21167157590389252,
0.06894858926534653,
-0.22244109213352203,
-0.5298638343811035,
-0.3894615173339844,
-0.9080580472946167,
-0.48007696866989136,
0.23019741475582123,
-0.6784995794296265,
0.27808812260627747,
-0.4879469573497772,
-0.13276244699954987,
0.24044886231422424,
0.1979021430015564,
-0.7561742663383484,
0.36448609828948975,
0.19298408925533295,
0.7557498216629028,
-0.8312986493110657,
0.7756052017211914,
0.7221930623054504,
-0.590461254119873,
-0.7967814803123474,
0.042341843247413635,
-0.14710326492786407,
-0.2476264238357544,
0.5802516937255859,
-0.2539057731628418,
-0.3620644807815552,
0.0673445537686348,
-0.8582948446273804,
-0.9315131306648254,
1.0361804962158203,
0.724884033203125,
-0.4437839090824127,
0.24495752155780792,
-0.025989897549152374,
0.42822110652923584,
-0.272413045167923,
-0.08650150150060654,
0.35451585054397583,
0.5409638285636902,
0.28423959016799927,
-0.37237539887428284,
0.25745269656181335,
-0.05897581949830055,
-0.10538579523563385,
-0.30836349725723267,
-0.5983445644378662,
0.3758494555950165,
-0.3778109848499298,
-0.10444310307502747,
0.3349984586238861,
1.236063003540039,
0.6309564709663391,
0.48035916686058044,
0.20430469512939453,
0.23868019878864288,
1.1926913261413574,
-0.06888960301876068,
0.7345238327980042,
-0.25066548585891724,
0.38450008630752563,
1.406136393547058,
-0.3439873158931732,
0.8484916090965271,
0.7782514691352844,
0.09642791748046875,
0.6773278117179871,
0.2883557677268982,
-0.15812331438064575,
0.5779679417610168,
-0.16354316473007202,
-0.2223639041185379,
-0.605126678943634,
-0.419556587934494,
-0.23047533631324768,
0.07445887476205826,
0.014946356415748596,
-0.6915321946144104,
-0.3116895854473114,
-0.2915129065513611,
0.18797944486141205,
0.4907502233982086,
-0.3417185842990875,
0.7081590890884399,
0.07904457300901413,
-0.8281049728393555,
0.8014281988143921,
0.10693442821502686,
0.5135626196861267,
-0.3963419198989868,
0.11144465953111649,
-0.3589133620262146,
0.1597287952899933,
-0.4612358808517456,
-0.2967040538787842,
0.3575276732444763,
0.4622567594051361,
-0.7570092082023621,
-0.21144257485866547,
0.7982048988342285,
-0.4455912411212921,
-0.7034342885017395,
-0.21849912405014038,
0.45467981696128845,
-0.13148769736289978,
0.12928035855293274,
-0.15735848248004913,
-0.022293820977211,
-0.004109715111553669,
-0.15111681818962097,
0.43596476316452026,
0.5361146330833435,
0.03833940997719765,
0.27972447872161865,
0.8847441077232361,
-0.10417946428060532,
0.12563931941986084,
0.030521661043167114,
0.5867838263511658,
-0.34298062324523926,
0.007937416434288025,
-0.7898749709129333,
0.45522886514663696,
-0.24414470791816711,
-0.2549199163913727,
0.8816768527030945,
0.7536658644676208,
0.7437366843223572,
-0.19114769995212555,
0.8182176947593689,
-0.02890920266509056,
0.6209957599639893,
-0.5993757843971252,
0.4886638820171356,
-0.5104894042015076,
0.3215872645378113,
-0.33494332432746887,
-0.6568459272384644,
-0.20700842142105103,
0.4781985878944397,
-0.19702886044979095,
-0.22179552912712097,
0.46335485577583313,
0.8059775829315186,
-0.3203825056552887,
-0.1593455970287323,
0.18875974416732788,
0.23060114681720734,
0.1810901165008545,
0.17669187486171722,
0.5667334794998169,
-0.4741438329219818,
0.6107982993125916,
-0.25389429926872253,
0.22111941874027252,
-0.3763331472873688,
-1.0312790870666504,
-0.7450948357582092,
-0.15381073951721191,
-0.7558013200759888,
-0.47877418994903564,
0.07486465573310852,
0.9588884115219116,
0.7745876312255859,
-0.9934191107749939,
0.3495485782623291,
-0.14256981015205383,
0.2941797077655792,
-0.1327359974384308,
-0.2410488873720169,
0.3034796416759491,
-0.8883705139160156,
-0.7221947908401489,
0.6910682320594788,
0.051523204892873764,
-0.17940810322761536,
0.1872025728225708,
-0.035933513194322586,
-0.2637622654438019,
0.2748201787471771,
0.4589482843875885,
0.3395269513130188,
-0.5361469984054565,
-0.7052774429321289,
0.13325271010398865,
-0.24367845058441162,
0.03248322382569313,
0.5397093296051025,
-0.820902407169342,
0.11018028855323792,
0.30401545763015747,
0.9226034283638,
0.547158420085907,
0.5682931542396545,
0.23379527032375336,
-1.0843253135681152,
-0.16342756152153015,
0.039620157331228256,
0.34625598788261414,
0.6746285557746887,
-0.27748167514801025,
0.5202279090881348,
0.4694133996963501,
-0.6253228187561035,
-1.0005754232406616,
-0.07486928999423981,
-1.1636322736740112,
-0.2704200744628906,
1.2007948160171509,
-0.329973429441452,
-0.010176913812756538,
-0.18588881194591522,
0.029794424772262573,
0.1627010703086853,
-0.1645568162202835,
0.734552800655365,
0.5730379223823547,
-0.04613272100687027,
0.1674869954586029,
-0.08357488363981247,
0.4368281662464142,
0.45335012674331665,
-0.6661055684089661,
0.11828972399234772,
0.6629793047904968,
0.6060656309127808,
0.42485296726226807,
0.15485090017318726,
0.01639229990541935,
0.22861328721046448,
-0.08328130096197128,
-0.44037574529647827,
-0.19642850756645203,
-0.4750199615955353,
0.18879634141921997,
0.4889543652534485,
0.37044757604599,
0.23142756521701813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13121v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13121v1 | Can Long-Context Language Models Subsume Retrieval, RAG, SQL, and More? | 2024-06-19T00:28:58 | 2024-06-19T00:28:58 | Jinhyuk Lee, Anthony Chen, Zhuyun Dai, Dheeru Dua, Devendra Singh Sachan, Michael Boratko, Yi Luan, Sébastien M. R. Arnold, Vincent Perot, Siddharth Dalmia, Hexiang Hu, Xudong Lin, Panupong Pasupat, Aida Amini, Jeremy R. Cole, Sebastian Riedel, Iftekhar Naim, Ming-Wei Chang, Kelvin Guu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Long-context language models (LCLMs) have the potential to revolutionize our
approach to tasks traditionally reliant on external tools like retrieval
systems or databases. Leveraging LCLMs' ability to natively ingest and process
entire corpora of information offers numerous advantages. It enhances
user-friendliness by eliminating the need for specialized knowledge of tools,
provides robust end-to-end modeling that minimizes cascading errors in complex
pipelines, and allows for the application of sophisticated prompting techniques
across the entire system. To assess this paradigm shift, we introduce LOFT, a
benchmark of real-world tasks requiring context up to millions of tokens
designed to evaluate LCLMs' performance on in-context retrieval and reasoning.
Our findings reveal LCLMs' surprising ability to rival state-of-the-art
retrieval and RAG systems, despite never having been explicitly trained for
these tasks. However, LCLMs still face challenges in areas like compositional
reasoning that are required in SQL-like tasks. Notably, prompting strategies
significantly influence performance, emphasizing the need for continued
research as context lengths grow. Overall, LOFT provides a rigorous testing
ground for LCLMs, showcasing their potential to supplant existing paradigms and
tackle novel tasks as model capabilities scale. | [
-0.3030160665512085,
-0.7842033505439758,
0.45152536034584045,
0.4132757782936096,
-0.051577452570199966,
0.178697407245636,
-0.44185200333595276,
-0.7133529782295227,
-0.34868988394737244,
0.4713551104068756,
-0.4874425232410431,
-0.3469126224517822,
-0.16853544116020203,
0.18662621080875397,
-0.7416417002677917,
0.8877739906311035,
0.3563619554042816,
-0.11991073936223984,
-0.4142383933067322,
-0.1288684606552124,
-0.9264195561408997,
-0.7880774736404419,
-0.5862405300140381,
-0.023725586012005806,
0.6766135096549988,
0.05108843371272087,
0.5784611105918884,
0.22590890526771545,
0.20663024485111237,
0.1561635285615921,
-0.3309837281703949,
-0.058097921311855316,
-0.6214234232902527,
0.3076605796813965,
-0.2680792510509491,
-0.4050784111022949,
-0.3991389572620392,
-0.23496600985527039,
0.5061963796615601,
1.0244990587234497,
-0.10866374522447586,
0.08462513983249664,
0.229598730802536,
1.0153005123138428,
-0.5484766960144043,
-0.2177976369857788,
-0.8768941760063171,
-0.16767221689224243,
-0.18955205380916595,
-0.1367497593164444,
-0.6904816627502441,
0.08626112341880798,
0.12167337536811829,
-0.49837154150009155,
0.03091668151319027,
0.4636245369911194,
0.4494285583496094,
0.12821461260318756,
-0.4550754725933075,
-0.5460099577903748,
-0.5500649213790894,
1.0687681436538696,
-0.5410247445106506,
0.7630186676979065,
0.3377313017845154,
0.39314234256744385,
-0.3596327602863312,
-0.7713785171508789,
-0.25260281562805176,
-0.637423038482666,
-0.3604024052619934,
-0.05538604035973549,
0.11016932129859924,
-0.03141963481903076,
0.4128049314022064,
0.054535433650016785,
-0.4904976785182953,
0.19428810477256775,
-0.4841172397136688,
0.06471403688192368,
0.3865141272544861,
0.1603601574897766,
0.1944616436958313,
-0.3988155126571655,
-0.5440647006034851,
0.23385022580623627,
-1.0202088356018066,
0.39387282729148865,
-0.010847375728189945,
0.5692992210388184,
0.21890206634998322,
0.3524540066719055,
-0.27433091402053833,
1.0474135875701904,
-0.2795332074165344,
0.05366627499461174,
-0.22019368410110474,
-0.37874704599380493,
-0.40715697407722473,
-0.12429682910442352,
0.3246748447418213,
0.24459563195705414,
-0.04064938798546791,
-0.4074041247367859,
-0.4151734709739685,
-0.2690783143043518,
0.26144731044769287,
-0.4822552502155304,
0.12741272151470184,
0.4613286256790161,
-0.28026431798934937,
-0.05604519322514534,
-0.15958499908447266,
-0.5446006059646606,
-0.3693065345287323,
-0.6500646471977234,
0.19403740763664246,
-0.34191903471946716,
-0.20891256630420685,
0.04965338855981827,
-0.08619014173746109,
0.39500904083251953,
0.29547229409217834,
-0.5816726684570312,
0.39555129408836365,
1.0811406373977661,
0.8409014344215393,
-0.5355533361434937,
-0.09594041854143143,
-0.4879789352416992,
0.07496055215597153,
-0.6132728457450867,
0.5950980186462402,
-0.5593262910842896,
-0.6454558372497559,
0.07929609715938568,
0.03213657811284065,
0.12028571218252182,
-0.7006693482398987,
0.6604042053222656,
-0.6070433259010315,
0.1371692419052124,
-0.725007176399231,
-0.5228736400604248,
0.17739441990852356,
0.34057319164276123,
-0.6111841797828674,
1.4875733852386475,
0.2055850625038147,
-0.6361761093139648,
0.5128270387649536,
-0.7649523019790649,
-0.4820592999458313,
0.17242734134197235,
0.0011486443690955639,
0.11381562054157257,
0.15674644708633423,
-0.018537646159529686,
0.4871707856655121,
-0.4063645303249359,
0.4126218855381012,
-0.11276472359895706,
-0.6552469730377197,
0.14116151630878448,
-0.23099835216999054,
0.9812211394309998,
0.21313440799713135,
-0.14388863742351532,
0.15886543691158295,
-0.5609993934631348,
0.04778537526726723,
-0.18107154965400696,
-0.2794917821884155,
-0.5518143177032471,
0.10023755580186844,
0.2131839394569397,
0.30418872833251953,
0.3583858907222748,
-0.4395596385002136,
0.11392158269882202,
-0.3400636911392212,
0.5780575275421143,
0.5889359712600708,
-0.5092872977256775,
0.5452151298522949,
-0.2800121605396271,
0.3597877323627472,
-0.08597391098737717,
0.16893203556537628,
-0.3114577829837799,
-0.0473724864423275,
-0.6732093095779419,
-0.33543601632118225,
0.0021359955426305532,
0.36752456426620483,
-0.2982414960861206,
0.27883613109588623,
-0.2345140427350998,
-0.38931387662887573,
-0.13924284279346466,
0.045967619866132736,
0.3082541823387146,
0.7021289467811584,
0.5787916779518127,
0.05432603508234024,
-0.6819236278533936,
-0.734714150428772,
-0.3544735014438629,
0.15773364901542664,
-0.13354051113128662,
0.528066873550415,
0.3609378933906555,
0.0376223623752594,
1.310874342918396,
-0.15165534615516663,
-0.23214848339557648,
-0.29655084013938904,
-0.10541746765375137,
0.41535747051239014,
0.4393473267555237,
0.41253724694252014,
-0.8953168392181396,
-0.4398431181907654,
-0.07124780118465424,
-0.7250006198883057,
-0.19345293939113617,
-0.11882840842008591,
-0.017375744879245758,
0.5928719639778137,
1.052703619003296,
-0.5757836103439331,
0.36048585176467896,
0.31373369693756104,
-0.1457999050617218,
1.0002644062042236,
-0.11342641711235046,
-0.18019990622997284,
-0.6824774742126465,
0.4674186408519745,
-0.5639688968658447,
-0.322313129901886,
-0.6311350464820862,
0.22359202802181244,
0.19448573887348175,
-0.10089477896690369,
-0.5654258131980896,
0.9611126780509949,
-0.7548173069953918,
-0.5295147895812988,
-0.20641694962978363,
0.19691923260688782,
0.1741306185722351,
0.28540778160095215,
0.06796617060899734,
0.8604572415351868,
0.5164343118667603,
-0.7421555519104004,
0.1880822330713272,
-0.16509932279586792,
-0.5188382863998413,
0.6980741024017334,
-0.8012288808822632,
0.18710094690322876,
-0.27409636974334717,
0.7012407779693604,
-0.928605854511261,
-0.0667533129453659,
-0.38096705079078674,
-0.02295791171491146,
0.14608298242092133,
-0.14453282952308655,
-0.46632444858551025,
-0.49787628650665283,
-0.10956936329603195,
0.2918887138366699,
0.4689188301563263,
-0.5451574325561523,
0.5084636807441711,
-0.06499333679676056,
-0.01533115841448307,
-0.9360389113426208,
-0.4110451340675354,
0.3770482838153839,
-0.2561737596988678,
-0.22383883595466614,
0.49362772703170776,
0.008845527656376362,
-0.25664734840393066,
-0.13379311561584473,
-0.04663199186325073,
0.06306301802396774,
0.21036219596862793,
0.2546609938144684,
0.2999182343482971,
-0.14669758081436157,
0.5438644886016846,
-0.03867584094405174,
0.01942763663828373,
-0.08636613190174103,
-0.4504235088825226,
0.5578040480613708,
-0.31190016865730286,
-0.3767421245574951,
-0.1556747704744339,
0.5572231411933899,
0.6071473360061646,
-0.26286405324935913,
0.7531934976577759,
0.32883110642433167,
-0.34984269738197327,
-0.30194297432899475,
-0.6396426558494568,
-0.22443056106567383,
-0.4686916768550873,
0.4453546702861786,
-0.5336818099021912,
-0.9595980048179626,
0.45145145058631897,
-0.08004483580589294,
0.3124542832374573,
0.14409320056438446,
0.1572137326002121,
-0.24399913847446442,
0.8443710207939148,
0.6305475831031799,
0.12768268585205078,
0.44769176840782166,
-0.12398907542228699,
0.3257445991039276,
-1.2125003337860107,
-0.12903691828250885,
-0.4752819836139679,
-0.17654500901699066,
-0.21253012120723724,
-0.5025945901870728,
0.4954179525375366,
0.4385526478290558,
-0.25978395342826843,
0.46537840366363525,
-0.562073826789856,
0.7038870453834534,
0.21060128509998322,
-0.19150258600711823,
0.3435715436935425,
-0.48419904708862305,
-0.17675034701824188,
0.08827559649944305,
-0.641512393951416,
-0.5758630037307739,
0.8929112553596497,
0.11937221884727478,
0.4481801688671112,
-0.013470581732690334,
0.44631335139274597,
0.1732928454875946,
0.5963216423988342,
-0.8819282054901123,
0.6842795014381409,
-0.09246917068958282,
-0.8673213720321655,
-0.6024038195610046,
0.07114773988723755,
-0.9477778077125549,
0.32290875911712646,
0.0698276162147522,
-0.7391132116317749,
-0.03331323713064194,
-0.011074877344071865,
-0.3346635103225708,
0.16168098151683807,
-0.37883272767066956,
0.798792839050293,
-0.2645830810070038,
-0.5406625866889954,
-0.14384213089942932,
-0.6366499662399292,
0.2516118288040161,
-0.13515014946460724,
0.4783286154270172,
-0.21097230911254883,
-0.19179213047027588,
0.4098515510559082,
-0.11617659032344818,
0.8244191408157349,
-0.2245512753725052,
-0.14983899891376495,
0.26130369305610657,
0.3328574299812317,
0.5029289722442627,
-0.05590757727622986,
-0.40573322772979736,
-0.07557181268930435,
0.3931344449520111,
-0.41765666007995605,
-0.6390100121498108,
0.763141393661499,
-0.14999604225158691,
-0.6854445338249207,
-0.14793676137924194,
-0.5517261028289795,
-0.34613651037216187,
0.24399180710315704,
0.036134637892246246,
0.6739476323127747,
-0.39197614789009094,
0.5723278522491455,
0.24683386087417603,
-0.14917095005512238,
0.665267288684845,
0.35355421900749207,
-0.5122870206832886,
0.28057506680488586,
0.5536091327667236,
0.10437488555908203,
0.2769373655319214,
0.409826397895813,
0.23473770916461945,
-0.6166043877601624,
-0.37244510650634766,
-0.31488677859306335,
-0.08709558099508286,
-0.8305136561393738,
-0.1898839920759201,
-0.7346934676170349,
0.04408019781112671,
-0.29358619451522827,
-0.6239027976989746,
-0.28193479776382446,
-0.2679557800292969,
-0.21880555152893066,
-0.001528914668597281,
0.04309256374835968,
0.7532751560211182,
0.24682080745697021,
-0.07407213747501373,
-0.659902036190033,
-0.186312735080719,
0.33666619658470154,
0.3009459972381592,
0.29471346735954285,
-0.4475797116756439,
-0.154292032122612,
-0.08707094937562943,
0.04278528317809105,
-0.6457175612449646,
0.307489812374115,
0.14163097739219666,
0.4447437524795532,
-0.01377187855541706,
0.18464379012584686,
0.8330283164978027,
-0.6844214797019958,
0.9872530102729797,
-0.15813477337360382,
-0.9487291574478149,
0.2702137231826782,
-0.4729755222797394,
0.2948042154312134,
0.5128299593925476,
0.38404572010040283,
-0.7441793084144592,
-0.1420457512140274,
-0.3465111255645752,
-0.8807089924812317,
0.44634750485420227,
-0.20750416815280914,
0.3487817943096161,
-0.19236460328102112,
0.37895330786705017,
0.20011326670646667,
0.22047819197177887,
-0.6360003352165222,
0.39901238679885864,
-0.1545972377061844,
0.10568256676197052,
0.12340917438268661,
-0.11511489748954773,
0.007947692647576332,
-0.2939780354499817,
0.3036518096923828,
-0.341244637966156,
0.04875112697482109,
0.307934433221817,
-0.20087163150310516,
0.2173822522163391,
0.5474950671195984,
0.6566994786262512,
1.084697961807251,
-0.14446541666984558,
-0.037734001874923706,
0.5078415870666504,
0.18759219348430634,
-0.25830480456352234,
-0.41402044892311096,
0.04380790516734123,
-0.10920603573322296,
0.2304551601409912,
0.41667312383651733,
0.6092095375061035,
-0.9867608547210693,
0.4661315381526947,
0.2398781031370163,
0.20749156177043915,
-0.5304514169692993,
-0.08619807660579681,
0.29877498745918274,
-0.05338083580136299,
0.7164087295532227,
-0.22294177114963531,
0.2248404622077942,
-0.7963957190513611,
0.1982799768447876,
0.8020244240760803,
-0.48630285263061523,
-0.238528311252594,
0.36325258016586304,
0.13408200442790985,
-0.3576546013355255,
0.3481404781341553,
-0.027874119579792023,
-0.43969082832336426,
0.5320194363594055,
0.7623241543769836,
0.48545727133750916,
0.07837887108325958,
-0.11616407334804535,
0.45241791009902954,
0.01590990088880062,
-0.21300314366817474,
-0.05835108458995819,
-0.362487256526947,
-0.3740794360637665,
-0.4447537660598755,
-0.7896590828895569,
-0.45947539806365967,
0.13592195510864258,
-0.6705084443092346,
0.395739883184433,
-0.4427343010902405,
-0.05458799749612808,
-0.24974985420703888,
-0.17626218497753143,
-0.6126323938369751,
0.1946626603603363,
-0.14846152067184448,
1.1468391418457031,
-0.27932751178741455,
0.8312774896621704,
0.40119343996047974,
0.021117031574249268,
-0.40471604466438293,
-0.23583105206489563,
-0.16468410193920135,
-0.5368584990501404,
1.1445118188858032,
0.5067769289016724,
-0.32329773902893066,
-0.16139131784439087,
-0.6153887510299683,
-0.7828770279884338,
0.9568743705749512,
0.07671651244163513,
-0.697781503200531,
-0.43519625067710876,
-0.0956387147307396,
0.7197049260139465,
-0.5234087705612183,
0.12323343753814697,
0.629375159740448,
0.3432447910308838,
0.05941827595233917,
-1.116904616355896,
0.06676359474658966,
0.14908678829669952,
0.15198557078838348,
0.2026963233947754,
-0.38238587975502014,
0.959697425365448,
-0.20732353627681732,
-0.3216765820980072,
0.19971975684165955,
0.6589037179946899,
0.27065423130989075,
0.13567404448986053,
0.6119419932365417,
0.0669555515050888,
0.768212080001831,
0.029251305386424065,
1.0897098779678345,
-0.3947976529598236,
0.12975507974624634,
1.2329673767089844,
-0.6109473705291748,
1.324791431427002,
0.5901128053665161,
-0.14597918093204498,
0.702747106552124,
0.26536795496940613,
0.5449395179748535,
0.20692867040634155,
0.38050204515457153,
-0.1764497458934784,
-0.27066823840141296,
-0.274850994348526,
-0.24753093719482422,
0.3864147961139679,
0.6626833081245422,
0.008400078862905502,
-0.14471286535263062,
0.13270065188407898,
-0.0500822588801384,
0.2106664925813675,
-0.04112283140420914,
0.5665485262870789,
0.17280681431293488,
-0.9897846579551697,
0.8270256519317627,
-0.2692544758319855,
0.9029933214187622,
-0.5200459957122803,
0.08248668164014816,
-0.11131597310304642,
-0.07592258602380753,
-0.12524504959583282,
-0.6114403605461121,
0.5153388381004333,
-0.046064186841249466,
0.011997656896710396,
-0.4137752950191498,
0.7254559397697449,
-0.3123552203178406,
-0.2926185131072998,
0.5334884524345398,
0.49139124155044556,
0.07558073848485947,
-0.12262896448373795,
-0.6301923990249634,
0.05509806424379349,
-0.5079648494720459,
-0.2992047071456909,
0.3165821135044098,
0.30754491686820984,
-0.3283693492412567,
0.7754963636398315,
0.9546722769737244,
-0.07963842153549194,
0.05881156772375107,
0.04467454552650452,
0.7926812171936035,
-0.8449926376342773,
-0.44549816846847534,
-0.6029605269432068,
0.3992495536804199,
-0.23231574892997742,
-0.19694973528385162,
0.5426517128944397,
0.5493329763412476,
0.7447630763053894,
0.07017552852630615,
0.5333072543144226,
-0.19264230132102966,
0.82032710313797,
-0.4900709390640259,
0.6075659394264221,
-0.7184098958969116,
0.28057727217674255,
-0.02254854328930378,
-0.8663079142570496,
-0.2946672737598419,
0.34522780776023865,
-0.32027220726013184,
0.16399508714675903,
0.7815765142440796,
0.7992368936538696,
0.005436787847429514,
-0.01511459518224001,
0.5839564204216003,
0.1077490746974945,
0.4977843761444092,
0.4636302590370178,
0.8743572235107422,
-0.07472674548625946,
0.3569400906562805,
0.05104299634695053,
-0.0758325383067131,
-0.4374734163284302,
-1.2671716213226318,
-0.9608610272407532,
-0.7007840871810913,
0.286246120929718,
-0.010145485401153564,
0.20691794157028198,
0.9828539490699768,
0.8336737751960754,
-0.6632832288742065,
-0.3475702106952667,
-0.1837613433599472,
0.060141224414110184,
-0.3176285922527313,
-0.2618626356124878,
0.3874300718307495,
-0.8064091205596924,
-0.7065160274505615,
0.7487730979919434,
0.39734992384910583,
-0.12586764991283417,
-0.46662214398384094,
0.18493738770484924,
-0.06097814813256264,
0.11762331426143646,
1.0266977548599243,
0.38219502568244934,
-1.0453866720199585,
-0.34878936409950256,
0.46732696890830994,
-0.33059263229370117,
-0.08206522464752197,
0.9130653738975525,
-1.1935234069824219,
0.22501333057880402,
0.5397006273269653,
0.4744623005390167,
0.17973482608795166,
-0.028325676918029785,
0.46280282735824585,
-0.8171994090080261,
0.2532775402069092,
0.4475412666797638,
0.3194437026977539,
0.5033357739448547,
-0.3316762447357178,
0.5311247110366821,
-0.11364124715328217,
-0.5179613828659058,
-1.203147292137146,
0.28710150718688965,
-0.908625602722168,
-0.5211153030395508,
1.0930635929107666,
0.08250340819358826,
-0.294473260641098,
-0.46161696314811707,
-0.4500969350337982,
-0.14192868769168854,
-0.18251343071460724,
0.6519197225570679,
0.717046320438385,
-0.11498191952705383,
0.0033598868176341057,
-0.7439935207366943,
0.8369007110595703,
0.7245249152183533,
-0.72474205493927,
0.554518461227417,
0.4369417428970337,
0.2677875757217407,
0.10402340441942215,
0.7787980437278748,
-0.23234200477600098,
0.23452265560626984,
-0.4288008511066437,
-0.4045291543006897,
-0.08980320394039154,
-0.5638433694839478,
-0.11754755675792694,
0.24390888214111328,
-0.0023522383999079466,
0.4357106685638428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13114v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13114v1 | Multi-Stage Balanced Distillation: Addressing Long-Tail Challenges in Sequence-Level Knowledge Distillation | 2024-06-19T00:01:14 | 2024-06-19T00:01:14 | Yuhang Zhou, Jing Zhu, Paiheng Xu, Xiaoyu Liu, Xiyao Wang, Danai Koutra, Wei Ai, Furong Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have significantly advanced various natural
language processing tasks, but deploying them remains computationally
expensive. Knowledge distillation (KD) is a promising solution, enabling the
transfer of capabilities from larger teacher LLMs to more compact student
models. Particularly, sequence-level KD, which distills rationale-based
reasoning processes instead of merely final outcomes, shows great potential in
enhancing students' reasoning capabilities. However, current methods struggle
with sequence level KD under long-tailed data distributions, adversely
affecting generalization on sparsely represented domains. We introduce the
Multi-Stage Balanced Distillation (BalDistill) framework, which iteratively
balances training data within a fixed computational budget. By dynamically
selecting representative head domain examples and synthesizing tail domain
examples, BalDistill achieves state-of-the-art performance across diverse
long-tailed datasets, enhancing both the efficiency and efficacy of the
distilled models. | [
-0.3490498960018158,
-0.6569221615791321,
0.7384343147277832,
0.577030599117279,
-0.24967890977859497,
0.5660040974617004,
-0.3244396448135376,
-0.11375418305397034,
-0.23033656179904938,
0.438071072101593,
-0.5808683633804321,
-0.39074140787124634,
-0.7501495480537415,
0.11847791075706482,
-0.4988834261894226,
1.0931460857391357,
-0.02212260663509369,
-0.08829003572463989,
-0.22521787881851196,
-0.095431387424469,
-0.6619769930839539,
-0.5658097863197327,
-0.8444772362709045,
-0.8157203197479248,
0.5470127463340759,
0.6120464205741882,
0.3993789255619049,
0.45700863003730774,
0.2183629274368286,
0.24749410152435303,
-0.10447221994400024,
0.013536038808524609,
-0.5806744694709778,
0.40695714950561523,
-0.24600188434123993,
-0.3318701982498169,
-0.22870802879333496,
-0.22912953794002533,
0.5635663270950317,
1.2064857482910156,
-0.6498309373855591,
-0.13798899948596954,
0.42262423038482666,
1.0216213464736938,
-0.6919827461242676,
0.15051385760307312,
-0.7268689274787903,
-0.12097582221031189,
-0.09434153139591217,
0.19655545055866241,
-0.33216726779937744,
-0.18941240012645721,
0.4123324453830719,
-0.5767008662223816,
0.25246307253837585,
-0.22823986411094666,
0.6135742664337158,
0.38900619745254517,
-0.5319452881813049,
-0.32450607419013977,
-0.8104149103164673,
1.1906101703643799,
-0.903910219669342,
0.2975872755050659,
0.2695927917957306,
0.5067670941352844,
-0.2945575416088104,
-0.7031757235527039,
-0.6769221425056458,
0.3151405155658722,
0.12320171296596527,
-0.0817556157708168,
-0.20508749783039093,
0.07777296006679535,
0.21058879792690277,
0.39959049224853516,
-0.39243853092193604,
0.044510889798402786,
-0.4181674122810364,
0.18545804917812347,
0.4917489290237427,
-0.07376548647880554,
-0.262405127286911,
-0.01981247588992119,
-0.352364718914032,
-0.3905990719795227,
-0.2823760211467743,
-0.23841360211372375,
0.3508092761039734,
0.5700924396514893,
0.2864803671836853,
0.6079179048538208,
-0.44457414746284485,
0.6860332489013672,
0.43724220991134644,
-0.4798402190208435,
0.13967065513134003,
-0.2863025665283203,
-0.404413640499115,
0.24637475609779358,
0.5764806270599365,
0.09099246561527252,
0.38310298323631287,
0.03341613709926605,
-0.15454982221126556,
-0.04089697077870369,
0.22984954714775085,
-1.0417717695236206,
-0.29011204838752747,
0.46500274538993835,
-0.021821018308401108,
-0.3240377902984619,
-0.3704374432563782,
-1.0132590532302856,
-0.4740447998046875,
-0.643453061580658,
0.4081861674785614,
-0.4653836786746979,
-0.3135722875595093,
0.45684486627578735,
-0.44591042399406433,
-0.13216924667358398,
0.29914405941963196,
-0.9416185617446899,
0.38443082571029663,
0.7527899146080017,
0.7579451203346252,
-0.42673736810684204,
-0.29796072840690613,
-0.012267246842384338,
0.3444902300834656,
-0.1408643275499344,
0.41619858145713806,
-0.3272573947906494,
-0.3042117953300476,
-0.07165338099002838,
-0.3006974756717682,
0.047062620520591736,
-0.8206307888031006,
0.6990379691123962,
-0.44739851355552673,
0.0055535780265927315,
-0.2870519161224365,
-0.569550633430481,
-0.09515246003866196,
0.06519587337970734,
-0.5093849897384644,
0.9096530079841614,
0.07363879680633545,
-0.7360891699790955,
0.5549327731132507,
-0.2648783326148987,
-0.8099597692489624,
-0.19954237341880798,
-0.039078980684280396,
-0.4787057340145111,
-0.05222723260521889,
0.25248077511787415,
0.5475021004676819,
-0.24865615367889404,
0.748227059841156,
-0.35294878482818604,
0.09119415283203125,
-0.1885155439376831,
-0.4531140923500061,
0.7933922410011292,
0.3970130681991577,
-0.21307429671287537,
-0.08923712372779846,
-1.1693977117538452,
-0.2514590620994568,
0.021067950874567032,
-0.31038281321525574,
-0.7611790895462036,
0.1329297125339508,
-0.2097313106060028,
0.12538442015647888,
0.0454791858792305,
-0.38185006380081177,
0.3465207517147064,
-0.07474245876073837,
0.6064082980155945,
0.675225019454956,
0.04558160528540611,
0.4979712963104248,
-0.2365330457687378,
0.21690601110458374,
0.3633117973804474,
-0.06181975454092026,
-0.09625333547592163,
-0.41416043043136597,
-0.8329315781593323,
-0.6029657125473022,
0.054886993020772934,
0.4487612843513489,
-0.8549094796180725,
0.3949609100818634,
-0.19216081500053406,
-0.3970937132835388,
-0.18092525005340576,
0.32415124773979187,
0.09006533771753311,
0.6742868423461914,
0.563149631023407,
0.028947552666068077,
-0.41638925671577454,
-0.8509692549705505,
-0.010049056261777878,
-0.12822602689266205,
0.09092172235250473,
-0.13438762724399567,
0.2763335704803467,
-0.16967932879924774,
0.9673197269439697,
-0.7978358268737793,
-0.41914501786231995,
-0.25199222564697266,
0.6436666250228882,
0.6752608418464661,
0.3903530240058899,
0.46775537729263306,
-0.6031193733215332,
-0.5161208510398865,
-0.07091519981622696,
-0.6062473058700562,
-0.3039531409740448,
-0.32738062739372253,
-0.3813980221748352,
-0.05194668471813202,
0.3095755875110626,
-0.8457844853401184,
0.008881482295691967,
0.4107578694820404,
-0.10708727687597275,
0.4074850380420685,
-0.04128704592585564,
0.24971680343151093,
-1.0413545370101929,
0.007847484201192856,
0.14839807152748108,
-0.13230134546756744,
-0.6924718618392944,
-0.07129507511854172,
0.0851106271147728,
-0.007559025660157204,
-0.10402343422174454,
0.1997837871313095,
-0.35175952315330505,
0.2543918788433075,
-0.4192327558994293,
-0.020849796012043953,
0.18859906494617462,
0.42948129773139954,
0.057546962052583694,
0.4844236373901367,
0.3663458824157715,
-0.5885328650474548,
0.3190769851207733,
0.09816984832286835,
-0.19250130653381348,
0.8966343402862549,
-0.5678881406784058,
-0.16774828732013702,
-0.06962360441684723,
0.17767195403575897,
-1.1486854553222656,
-0.14336593449115753,
-0.15310537815093994,
-0.07059329748153687,
0.4726320207118988,
-0.30709385871887207,
-0.26234251260757446,
-0.5102854371070862,
-0.16764137148857117,
0.4956912100315094,
0.4880967438220978,
-0.5168911814689636,
0.67769855260849,
0.12580762803554535,
-0.4865153729915619,
-0.9175940752029419,
-0.5993382930755615,
0.12745869159698486,
-0.4512140154838562,
-0.6823260188102722,
0.32524871826171875,
-0.04857626184821129,
-0.2803439497947693,
-0.14322884380817413,
-0.4284895360469818,
-0.3992530405521393,
-0.012973101809620857,
0.016171740368008614,
0.16417476534843445,
0.008594113402068615,
-0.13126689195632935,
0.5062086582183838,
0.22097821533679962,
0.03961115702986717,
-0.6336923241615295,
0.45446276664733887,
0.35410237312316895,
-0.3012129068374634,
-0.11833003908395767,
0.2979097366333008,
0.8123487234115601,
0.17727136611938477,
0.713541567325592,
0.26391127705574036,
-0.5586464405059814,
-0.6871969699859619,
-0.6446707248687744,
-0.08579637110233307,
-0.45351195335388184,
0.277696818113327,
-0.33235639333724976,
-0.8404162526130676,
0.4857833683490753,
-0.19970375299453735,
0.326473593711853,
0.37916100025177,
0.5158607363700867,
0.022225258871912956,
0.805972158908844,
0.4582778215408325,
-0.07571530342102051,
0.07147306203842163,
-0.25623324513435364,
0.3819931447505951,
-0.3776516020298004,
-0.11083021759986877,
-0.5415787696838379,
-0.2906058132648468,
-0.01046148594468832,
-0.5322465896606445,
0.22158707678318024,
0.4988262355327606,
-0.2711312174797058,
0.17637503147125244,
-0.3473608195781708,
0.46632009744644165,
0.6204385161399841,
-0.10112249851226807,
0.6387554407119751,
-0.0024666176177561283,
-0.24857188761234283,
0.04706724360585213,
-0.5800354480743408,
-0.19108082354068756,
1.2469542026519775,
0.2920868694782257,
0.9322129487991333,
-0.05168120190501213,
1.0282584428787231,
0.32946863770484924,
-0.04592094570398331,
-0.76874178647995,
0.3483213186264038,
-0.3182803988456726,
-0.48842230439186096,
-0.42498788237571716,
-0.5475077033042908,
-0.6842855215072632,
0.4428722560405731,
-0.14964981377124786,
-0.22915853559970856,
0.38126999139785767,
0.2472272366285324,
-0.47860094904899597,
0.2511560916900635,
-0.7441107034683228,
0.7635489106178284,
-0.2582172453403473,
-0.5046258568763733,
-0.445696622133255,
-0.5206559896469116,
0.8454371690750122,
-0.6705883145332336,
0.37650272250175476,
-0.07611880451440811,
0.461018443107605,
0.6251810789108276,
-0.6292139291763306,
0.6824631690979004,
-0.3308928608894348,
-0.3472936749458313,
0.2837124764919281,
-0.0374622717499733,
0.4379332661628723,
-0.018383586779236794,
0.08227060735225677,
0.18079183995723724,
0.24344293773174286,
-0.36332812905311584,
-0.5483993887901306,
0.7336710095405579,
-0.6954522728919983,
-0.6320917010307312,
-0.658165693283081,
-0.5308407545089722,
-0.489561527967453,
0.2975773811340332,
-0.24519312381744385,
-0.08618924766778946,
-0.005136496387422085,
0.22876840829849243,
0.8047162890434265,
-0.1422225683927536,
0.3575960695743561,
0.27368322014808655,
-0.278364896774292,
-0.5731029510498047,
0.6814048290252686,
0.07666060328483582,
0.6815544366836548,
0.16807317733764648,
0.24781209230422974,
-0.27921706438064575,
-0.6845240592956543,
-0.4247772693634033,
0.01499847136437893,
-0.7478682994842529,
-0.40548643469810486,
-0.7470953464508057,
-0.2499515414237976,
-0.31015822291374207,
-0.06317038089036942,
-0.5760355591773987,
-0.5651662945747375,
-0.3088655173778534,
-0.04479655623435974,
0.2699189782142639,
0.4792811870574951,
-0.2148340940475464,
0.4932628870010376,
-0.5455020070075989,
0.8033451437950134,
0.6415082216262817,
0.1655157059431076,
0.3132511377334595,
-0.3710867464542389,
-0.19957418739795685,
0.33420994877815247,
-0.48777109384536743,
-0.584717333316803,
0.4004175662994385,
0.47353753447532654,
0.47037938237190247,
0.5301070213317871,
0.2391141951084137,
1.0856924057006836,
-0.7675662040710449,
0.6357780694961548,
0.48987364768981934,
-0.8904189467430115,
0.3760840594768524,
-0.28589388728141785,
0.28430941700935364,
0.7247357368469238,
0.5693398118019104,
-0.503373384475708,
-0.6093575358390808,
-0.24474871158599854,
-1.1091053485870361,
0.4836643636226654,
0.10933872312307358,
-0.059997960925102234,
-0.0074118454940617085,
0.31394654512405396,
0.328091561794281,
0.47782617807388306,
-0.35250550508499146,
-0.26933416724205017,
-0.27131232619285583,
-0.527273952960968,
0.02424824982881546,
-0.11783266067504883,
-0.10837936401367188,
-0.4801386594772339,
0.8122304677963257,
-0.09690868109464645,
-0.349586546421051,
0.06378474086523056,
-0.05153464525938034,
-0.1173066645860672,
0.36826273798942566,
0.38272997736930847,
0.9196833968162537,
-0.39326363801956177,
0.2862353026866913,
-0.05407101288437843,
-0.5910863876342773,
0.37994101643562317,
0.2792942523956299,
-0.06835795193910599,
-0.17301538586616516,
0.19270379841327667,
0.5573300719261169,
0.25902265310287476,
-0.521514892578125,
0.3506181240081787,
0.07076281309127808,
-0.5688289403915405,
-0.09697334468364716,
0.03674846887588501,
0.25488319993019104,
0.5087549686431885,
0.8877047896385193,
-0.010371007956564426,
0.1863383799791336,
-0.561583936214447,
0.43666961789131165,
0.3378674387931824,
0.23961374163627625,
0.032165270298719406,
0.703080952167511,
0.07388664782047272,
0.38016191124916077,
0.7161180377006531,
0.04222333803772926,
-0.3615320920944214,
0.3132546544075012,
0.48079046607017517,
0.8388383984565735,
-0.1154555082321167,
0.12851178646087646,
0.39896342158317566,
0.030979031696915627,
-0.5442028641700745,
0.18159066140651703,
-0.016494497656822205,
-0.7329685091972351,
-0.702246367931366,
-1.1203030347824097,
-0.33102577924728394,
0.22245530784130096,
-0.8104769587516785,
0.25049135088920593,
-0.5330983400344849,
-0.40638577938079834,
0.33856210112571716,
-0.21654614806175232,
-0.42585018277168274,
-0.07894781231880188,
0.21322712302207947,
0.7659607529640198,
-0.9261044263839722,
0.9331328272819519,
0.17147627472877502,
-0.187123641371727,
-0.6172042489051819,
-0.11620131134986877,
0.06974398344755173,
-0.5517467856407166,
0.816055417060852,
-0.10737720876932144,
-0.10303253680467606,
-0.015081244520843029,
-0.39914748072624207,
-0.557780921459198,
1.1170958280563354,
0.3720194399356842,
-1.0504580736160278,
-0.22524221241474152,
0.4209522008895874,
0.4170539379119873,
-0.08616656810045242,
-0.1926422417163849,
0.8287745118141174,
0.449327677488327,
0.80738365650177,
-0.9085354208946228,
-0.29136714339256287,
0.15740105509757996,
-0.1627623587846756,
0.193030446767807,
-0.27282166481018066,
0.9809489250183105,
-0.060758836567401886,
-0.22126728296279907,
-0.18820792436599731,
0.8361488580703735,
0.4730460047721863,
0.3914972245693207,
0.5349421501159668,
1.0752846002578735,
0.7815172672271729,
-0.1278119683265686,
0.39184752106666565,
-0.1714382767677307,
0.3328046500682831,
1.2843050956726074,
-0.6321088075637817,
0.794696033000946,
0.8189770579338074,
-0.4820728302001953,
0.44210344552993774,
0.3547348082065582,
0.07643479853868484,
0.782289445400238,
0.44289544224739075,
-0.36727404594421387,
-0.27300289273262024,
0.20644114911556244,
-0.17222999036312103,
0.06184231489896774,
0.22543931007385254,
-0.04093044251203537,
-0.4792039394378662,
0.2333139330148697,
-0.012680546380579472,
0.10605883598327637,
-0.2678736448287964,
0.802818775177002,
0.23803439736366272,
-0.8542745113372803,
0.8733721971511841,
-0.05944190174341202,
0.8096140623092651,
-0.6626021265983582,
-0.24148058891296387,
-0.1862882673740387,
0.5254995822906494,
-0.12557865679264069,
-0.9197894334793091,
0.29081353545188904,
0.004432737361639738,
-0.37444716691970825,
-0.5118013024330139,
0.6091932654380798,
-0.8146229982376099,
-0.6767224669456482,
0.2853698432445526,
0.5006396174430847,
-0.22053885459899902,
-0.23603571951389313,
-0.456816703081131,
-0.03476564213633537,
-0.09473521262407303,
0.08807455748319626,
0.40645265579223633,
0.7120864391326904,
-0.0808417946100235,
0.5968321561813354,
0.6499911546707153,
0.19554199278354645,
0.2989676594734192,
0.36805668473243713,
1.023361325263977,
-0.32114624977111816,
-0.24871419370174408,
-0.9576852321624756,
0.5102787017822266,
-0.17101028561592102,
0.08994168043136597,
0.7166222333908081,
0.5433993339538574,
0.9628781676292419,
-0.06991957128047943,
0.8606435060501099,
-0.010616492480039597,
0.6006059646606445,
-0.35231173038482666,
0.6536837816238403,
-0.43852847814559937,
0.2021249383687973,
-0.364652544260025,
-0.9460048079490662,
-0.16224803030490875,
0.6126124262809753,
0.12484046816825867,
-0.08417332172393799,
0.6010516285896301,
0.2950814664363861,
-0.17128080129623413,
0.03843986988067627,
0.10178478807210922,
0.20285233855247498,
0.4279327690601349,
0.6204528212547302,
0.7931844592094421,
-0.15472976863384247,
0.1578986495733261,
-0.441796213388443,
-0.3005015254020691,
0.10190276801586151,
-1.0762287378311157,
-1.0320210456848145,
-0.4838394820690155,
-0.4160510003566742,
-0.24747222661972046,
0.2606342136859894,
0.8431611061096191,
0.5767984390258789,
-0.8771884441375732,
-0.5075593590736389,
-0.3030935525894165,
0.11529536545276642,
-0.23356357216835022,
-0.24608537554740906,
0.11012259125709534,
-0.5398449301719666,
-0.6363064646720886,
0.23693789541721344,
0.14203980565071106,
-0.037113942205905914,
-0.28877463936805725,
0.1388784795999527,
-0.4461979866027832,
0.15530788898468018,
0.8178719282150269,
0.15136565268039703,
-0.5722140073776245,
-0.18779568374156952,
-0.10804545134305954,
0.03278722986578941,
-0.03464112803339958,
0.7416456937789917,
-0.6821823716163635,
0.26037025451660156,
0.3756503760814667,
0.6933051347732544,
0.6655433177947998,
0.15907645225524902,
0.7061029672622681,
-0.941976010799408,
0.03244089335203171,
0.14049573242664337,
0.20774045586585999,
0.1719706654548645,
-0.10411670058965683,
0.33026668429374695,
0.41519662737846375,
-0.490850567817688,
-0.91391521692276,
-0.1463342308998108,
-1.1470379829406738,
-0.5647441148757935,
1.1090608835220337,
-0.08570918440818787,
0.09333202242851257,
-0.024189528077840805,
-0.06742734462022781,
0.3861083388328552,
-0.41389673948287964,
0.7058501243591309,
1.1006584167480469,
-0.017877284437417984,
-0.05243157967925072,
-0.5984517335891724,
0.5533062815666199,
0.2674008011817932,
-0.7463828921318054,
0.38631391525268555,
0.748650848865509,
0.295378714799881,
0.22892671823501587,
0.3630375862121582,
0.06803575158119202,
-0.3110857605934143,
-0.28009289503097534,
0.005259580910205841,
0.02898426167666912,
-0.6182616949081421,
-0.12069780379533768,
0.23161694407463074,
0.11443693190813065,
0.15500611066818237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13106v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13106v3 | Accelerating Complex Disease Treatment through Network Medicine and GenAI: A Case Study on Drug Repurposing for Breast Cancer | 2024-06-18T23:40:00 | 2024-06-27T08:28:51 | Ahmed Abdeen Hamed, Tamer E. Fandy | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, I.2; I.2.6 | The objective of this research is to introduce a network specialized in
predicting drugs that can be repurposed by investigating real-world evidence
sources, such as clinical trials and biomedical literature. Specifically, it
aims to generate drug combination therapies for complex diseases (e.g., cancer,
Alzheimer's). We present a multilayered network medicine approach, empowered by
a highly configured ChatGPT prompt engineering system, which is constructed on
the fly to extract drug mentions in clinical trials. Additionally, we introduce
a novel algorithm that connects real-world evidence with disease-specific
signaling pathways (e.g., KEGG database). This sheds light on the
repurposability of drugs if they are found to bind with one or more protein
constituents of a signaling pathway. To demonstrate, we instantiated the
framework for breast cancer and found that, out of 46 breast cancer signaling
pathways, the framework identified 38 pathways that were covered by at least
two drugs. This evidence signals the potential for combining those drugs.
Specifically, the most covered signaling pathway, ID hsa:2064, was covered by
108 drugs, some of which can be combined. Conversely, the signaling pathway ID
hsa:1499 was covered by only two drugs, indicating a significant gap for
further research. Our network medicine framework, empowered by GenAI, shows
promise in identifying drug combinations with a high degree of specificity,
knowing the exact signaling pathways and proteins that serve as targets. It is
noteworthy that ChatGPT successfully accelerated the process of identifying
drug mentions in clinical trials, though further investigations are required to
determine the relationships among the drug mentions. | [
-0.19117547571659088,
-0.8296259045600891,
0.5223317742347717,
0.08284066617488861,
0.06068185344338417,
0.4121481776237488,
0.4121449887752533,
-0.38923758268356323,
0.6696145534515381,
0.992224931716919,
-0.7430916428565979,
-0.34570735692977905,
-0.7982770204544067,
-0.1325507014989853,
-0.1975756287574768,
0.7605030536651611,
0.0036894239019602537,
0.4820227324962616,
0.15988174080848694,
-0.21728330850601196,
-0.5515409708023071,
-0.2520333528518677,
-1.0605528354644775,
-0.9003562927246094,
0.987719714641571,
0.29704543948173523,
0.3891277015209198,
0.5559864640235901,
0.7496449947357178,
0.2481422871351242,
-0.05016344040632248,
0.31679821014404297,
-0.48177894949913025,
0.5465613603591919,
-0.048883549869060516,
-0.3940221071243286,
-0.6151731014251709,
-0.20722439885139465,
0.25043776631355286,
0.9797707200050354,
-0.335178017616272,
-0.009394722990691662,
0.11992410570383072,
0.8039133548736572,
-0.5085882544517517,
-0.13281773030757904,
-0.2381197214126587,
0.43892720341682434,
-0.213508740067482,
-0.45437803864479065,
0.16604338586330414,
-0.3084280490875244,
0.22422200441360474,
-0.6507202982902527,
0.10283800959587097,
0.13251711428165436,
0.7906575798988342,
0.07821094244718552,
-0.4953968822956085,
-0.43184688687324524,
-0.4676377475261688,
0.3646371364593506,
-0.7563704252243042,
-0.1923246830701828,
0.06301682442426682,
0.8702757358551025,
-0.9573212265968323,
-1.0748740434646606,
-0.04307343438267708,
-0.19239725172519684,
-0.03686287999153137,
0.1880749613046646,
-0.024057738482952118,
0.381806880235672,
0.23541906476020813,
0.48032137751579285,
-0.5331789255142212,
0.183693528175354,
-0.4646824896335602,
-0.43312448263168335,
0.05361436307430267,
0.3348652124404907,
0.9052508473396301,
-0.047858789563179016,
-0.3591414988040924,
0.23039187490940094,
-1.0227245092391968,
0.11402829736471176,
-0.13558638095855713,
0.38287153840065,
0.05194772779941559,
0.7338358759880066,
-0.43814489245414734,
0.7181936502456665,
-0.0800587609410286,
0.3251459300518036,
0.17020323872566223,
-0.4807056486606598,
-0.4138759970664978,
0.3957397937774658,
0.8571420311927795,
0.3908708691596985,
-0.3078049123287201,
-0.030700894072651863,
0.43547919392585754,
-0.11367356032133102,
0.08955305814743042,
-1.0741597414016724,
-0.507644772529602,
0.5794550776481628,
-0.6002466678619385,
-0.3921006917953491,
0.017309198155999184,
-0.9528728127479553,
-0.4414703845977783,
0.21006764471530914,
0.6810461282730103,
-0.2887019217014313,
-0.47230082750320435,
0.45225411653518677,
-0.5110119581222534,
-0.03278264030814171,
0.021372053772211075,
-0.6901747584342957,
0.15018288791179657,
0.908926248550415,
0.9791325926780701,
0.1610160619020462,
-0.2557656764984131,
-0.9812444448471069,
0.5812788605690002,
-0.1827077865600586,
1.0292675495147705,
-0.4949655532836914,
-0.359878271818161,
0.01278455089777708,
0.09273092448711395,
-0.1748303771018982,
-0.3821618854999542,
0.5778040289878845,
-0.4451036751270294,
0.26457440853118896,
-0.7781256437301636,
-0.5097883939743042,
-0.16477255523204803,
0.42498084902763367,
-0.9096030592918396,
0.24049527943134308,
-0.05783878639340401,
-0.7091825604438782,
0.31904640793800354,
-0.9435587525367737,
-0.4965243637561798,
0.19095109403133392,
-0.11477941274642944,
-0.227393239736557,
-0.1075272336602211,
0.34095966815948486,
0.5090672969818115,
-0.1283889263868332,
0.44286271929740906,
-0.3700789213180542,
-0.42862674593925476,
0.12798891961574554,
-0.15488563477993011,
0.7917085886001587,
0.4573709964752197,
-0.19296704232692719,
0.2775959372520447,
-0.6899917721748352,
-0.023202206939458847,
-0.06217532977461815,
-0.2515479028224945,
-0.46715766191482544,
-0.39621031284332275,
-0.1989171802997589,
0.3122327923774719,
0.18984714150428772,
-0.5654034614562988,
0.5856102705001831,
-0.46634575724601746,
0.8096956610679626,
0.6789616942405701,
0.4400610625743866,
0.18960444629192352,
-0.48939400911331177,
0.405993789434433,
-0.04654098302125931,
0.28053826093673706,
-0.09307105094194412,
-0.9422057271003723,
-0.3216860294342041,
-0.3309524357318878,
0.2991032898426056,
0.4310398995876312,
-0.625622570514679,
-0.16082064807415009,
-0.20770539343357086,
-0.14915455877780914,
-0.594913125038147,
-0.30149906873703003,
0.4094082713127136,
0.34219640493392944,
0.3945103883743286,
-0.5318220853805542,
-0.5269715189933777,
-0.8358272314071655,
-0.12780079245567322,
0.11078586429357529,
0.047215428203344345,
0.30440640449523926,
0.08394111692905426,
-0.3828478455543518,
0.5286791324615479,
-0.5793009996414185,
-0.318947970867157,
-0.08037173748016357,
0.2967509925365448,
0.41093936562538147,
0.37458378076553345,
0.07654599100351334,
-0.5837790369987488,
-0.169870063662529,
0.2465735822916031,
-0.8006885647773743,
-0.3759925067424774,
-0.04922536015510559,
-0.4059731364250183,
-1.0460125207901,
0.5255830883979797,
-0.44256463646888733,
0.1902908980846405,
0.4468664526939392,
-0.3218751549720764,
0.29559043049812317,
-0.6660987138748169,
0.5713149905204773,
-1.3031822443008423,
0.003525362117215991,
-0.060622528195381165,
-0.36993226408958435,
-0.7028656601905823,
-0.13889361917972565,
-0.5388758778572083,
-0.24165330827236176,
-0.10610674321651459,
0.36906182765960693,
-0.3760688006877899,
-0.09032458811998367,
-0.27656200528144836,
-0.24711492657661438,
0.05328085646033287,
0.18972232937812805,
-0.33520185947418213,
0.3935311436653137,
0.38393187522888184,
-0.42879343032836914,
0.44399628043174744,
0.1334379017353058,
-0.1385423094034195,
0.556529700756073,
-0.6817324161529541,
-0.3248548209667206,
0.028600918129086494,
0.38099679350852966,
-1.0529338121414185,
-0.23191571235656738,
0.8798706531524658,
-0.3579535186290741,
0.18338370323181152,
-0.501680850982666,
-0.3168221116065979,
-0.335602730512619,
-0.008842471055686474,
0.1574845016002655,
0.013758622109889984,
-0.24701233208179474,
0.5849850177764893,
0.48068559169769287,
-0.2505629062652588,
-0.4547085464000702,
-1.034354567527771,
0.48833194375038147,
-0.06941372901201248,
-0.6057952642440796,
0.4072565734386444,
0.04393178969621658,
0.04118552431464195,
0.12825411558151245,
0.2823716998100281,
0.07187873870134354,
-0.09788590669631958,
0.49738380312919617,
-0.18144840002059937,
-0.20674999058246613,
0.01947079971432686,
0.6470297574996948,
-0.4616970717906952,
-0.08752578496932983,
-0.2800694406032562,
0.4837694764137268,
0.2871234714984894,
-0.6872118711471558,
-0.4701479971408844,
1.0114178657531738,
0.7155468463897705,
-0.1229279637336731,
0.3814869821071625,
0.7866709232330322,
-0.4148614704608917,
0.036331288516521454,
-0.098798468708992,
-0.3888370096683502,
-0.4317820966243744,
0.20453938841819763,
-0.4843597114086151,
-0.8750110268592834,
0.6559221148490906,
-0.7459112405776978,
-0.013963357545435429,
0.15339259803295135,
0.6277202367782593,
0.34710994362831116,
0.7551429271697998,
0.2343873232603073,
0.03956138342618942,
0.22858263552188873,
-0.3574979305267334,
0.29604819416999817,
-0.8717761635780334,
-0.4012084901332855,
-0.17487141489982605,
-0.6306376457214355,
-0.6586262583732605,
-0.36985111236572266,
0.46599599719047546,
0.04525196552276611,
-0.48310956358909607,
0.36510929465293884,
-0.7925663590431213,
0.02218945324420929,
0.6123310923576355,
0.44758501648902893,
0.5237689018249512,
0.0842389464378357,
-0.09895213693380356,
0.22973673045635223,
-1.231765866279602,
0.05707810819149017,
1.3824570178985596,
0.23539410531520844,
0.08516619354486465,
0.025021862238645554,
0.6308311223983765,
0.23693892359733582,
0.5224149227142334,
-0.552409291267395,
0.42314034700393677,
-0.053826428949832916,
-0.6389976739883423,
0.04405401647090912,
-0.5756804347038269,
-1.1915940046310425,
0.0013582652900367975,
-0.3457804024219513,
-0.6101211309432983,
0.6451538801193237,
-0.1462249904870987,
-0.7565483450889587,
0.4339119493961334,
-0.5485639572143555,
0.7299165725708008,
-0.12485480308532715,
-0.2188369780778885,
-0.16019383072853088,
-0.8145667314529419,
0.312960684299469,
0.1453559398651123,
0.2942597568035126,
-0.14429223537445068,
0.20473189651966095,
0.6090845465660095,
-0.6375569105148315,
0.5459792017936707,
0.10862872004508972,
0.21018055081367493,
-0.03649866208434105,
0.06833558529615402,
0.23840512335300446,
-0.06941138207912445,
0.19987735152244568,
0.25208690762519836,
0.08710527420043945,
-0.6276737451553345,
-0.5206100344657898,
1.1109089851379395,
-0.45574140548706055,
-0.16134102642536163,
-0.38231024146080017,
-0.39977625012397766,
-0.08664383739233017,
0.2384786605834961,
0.48891112208366394,
0.6882932782173157,
0.006896685808897018,
-0.30649110674858093,
0.429261714220047,
-0.2116803675889969,
0.06075672060251236,
0.3614537715911865,
-0.38659486174583435,
-0.4933372437953949,
0.9892140030860901,
0.3599007725715637,
0.21424199640750885,
0.5473772883415222,
0.13364310562610626,
0.13358934223651886,
-0.4642428755760193,
-0.2616100311279297,
-0.029011188074946404,
-0.28146490454673767,
-0.013631020672619343,
-0.6004995703697205,
-0.12579520046710968,
-0.2456960678100586,
-0.03524618223309517,
-0.4635576009750366,
-0.2393140196800232,
-0.01272612065076828,
-0.05301475152373314,
0.29268160462379456,
0.6240876913070679,
-0.2558756172657013,
0.46423786878585815,
-0.8518977761268616,
0.3821832835674286,
0.19141818583011627,
0.35682591795921326,
0.18377655744552612,
-0.08435242623090744,
-0.09071554988622665,
0.48626843094825745,
-0.08907260000705719,
-1.0221425294876099,
0.23977027833461761,
0.1398671269416809,
0.5672209858894348,
0.5363298058509827,
-0.3904784321784973,
0.5159632563591003,
-0.3466736674308777,
0.3489890694618225,
0.47747522592544556,
-0.3137543201446533,
0.6271143555641174,
-0.49929749965667725,
-0.1072426363825798,
0.17900195717811584,
0.151432603597641,
-0.6579029560089111,
0.019820498302578926,
-0.575004518032074,
-0.911611795425415,
0.2297450304031372,
0.4336268901824951,
-0.3068891763687134,
0.25744694471359253,
0.5885366797447205,
-0.048975713551044464,
0.15195463597774506,
0.02988503873348236,
-0.5058937668800354,
-0.08769556134939194,
-0.11450624465942383,
0.2895165681838989,
-0.22706247866153717,
-0.7686476111412048,
0.040674351155757904,
0.4883858561515808,
0.020555008202791214,
0.49603167176246643,
0.3794335424900055,
0.2821783721446991,
0.017311500385403633,
0.30327314138412476,
0.12665535509586334,
0.3392198085784912,
-0.42512521147727966,
-0.07250045239925385,
-0.5533304810523987,
-0.6435269117355347,
-0.138032004237175,
0.4907122254371643,
-0.11919113248586655,
-0.23221687972545624,
0.5610324144363403,
0.46019959449768066,
0.1283532977104187,
-0.4726700484752655,
0.07731463015079498,
-0.1303185075521469,
-0.021072102710604668,
0.2503049373626709,
-0.05373314768075943,
0.023976778611540794,
0.7268362045288086,
0.32915204763412476,
0.2908836901187897,
0.7098405361175537,
-0.7323322296142578,
0.5330879092216492,
0.25895386934280396,
-0.8449351787567139,
-0.12333923578262329,
0.5855436325073242,
0.13435642421245575,
-0.31122827529907227,
0.5400121808052063,
0.05694758892059326,
-0.2439921349287033,
0.7461081743240356,
0.40729424357414246,
0.7017181515693665,
-0.18546974658966064,
0.5908826589584351,
0.4025021493434906,
0.06157306581735611,
-0.3331432044506073,
0.03663824498653412,
0.30638524889945984,
-0.8976826667785645,
-0.33988770842552185,
-0.2535146176815033,
-0.32005491852760315,
-0.1872490644454956,
-0.1838100403547287,
0.03768821805715561,
-0.4115605652332306,
-0.46251118183135986,
0.5076510310173035,
0.20559169352054596,
-0.07014039903879166,
-0.02488122507929802,
-0.168177530169487,
0.42987060546875,
-0.9670815467834473,
0.7164249420166016,
0.7222119569778442,
-0.6131535768508911,
-0.830410361289978,
-0.2967742681503296,
-0.013471050187945366,
-0.6968465447425842,
0.22057893872261047,
0.15622751414775848,
0.11528459936380386,
0.10627758502960205,
-0.3484099209308624,
-0.7164178490638733,
1.4638656377792358,
0.13017380237579346,
-0.6978788375854492,
0.1961906999349594,
0.14057676494121552,
0.5256304740905762,
-0.6430302858352661,
0.2550675868988037,
0.3026544749736786,
0.4744894504547119,
0.6896713972091675,
-0.6720364093780518,
0.28962069749832153,
-0.2789490520954132,
-0.1842910647392273,
0.06402625888586044,
-0.3833010494709015,
0.713483452796936,
-0.4412083625793457,
-0.10997944325208664,
0.481650710105896,
0.03578275069594383,
0.412822961807251,
0.608642578125,
0.033974722027778625,
0.870596170425415,
0.9218230843544006,
-0.29757750034332275,
0.8327189087867737,
-0.1973954141139984,
0.24093037843704224,
0.6684775352478027,
-0.06339757144451141,
0.34603065252304077,
0.42987343668937683,
-0.3263729512691498,
0.35517770051956177,
0.7656825184822083,
0.08837027847766876,
0.5226007103919983,
0.31765276193618774,
-0.3919364809989929,
-0.38234490156173706,
-0.36192604899406433,
-0.5716480612754822,
-0.25823917984962463,
0.41324326395988464,
-0.3398992717266083,
-0.3791094720363617,
0.37168073654174805,
0.1448209285736084,
-0.22145479917526245,
-0.38503217697143555,
0.6441988348960876,
0.43856552243232727,
-0.38338035345077515,
0.12916283309459686,
-0.14578498899936676,
0.17321857810020447,
-0.7432108521461487,
-0.4565191864967346,
-0.3364188075065613,
0.18732470273971558,
-0.2947731912136078,
-0.7742245197296143,
0.06788399815559387,
-0.7400935888290405,
-0.09151852875947952,
0.38067618012428284,
0.8472414016723633,
-0.3937300443649292,
-0.4722490608692169,
0.37849655747413635,
0.5630699992179871,
0.09632160514593124,
-0.040040288120508194,
-0.8384625911712646,
0.15658092498779297,
-0.047012437134981155,
-0.009566840715706348,
0.5028829574584961,
0.5280877351760864,
0.07308972626924515,
0.9827696084976196,
1.013285517692566,
0.4081442356109619,
-0.27413037419319153,
0.03190046548843384,
0.9809221029281616,
-0.3782292604446411,
-0.14338983595371246,
-0.6780868768692017,
0.15881578624248505,
-0.299277126789093,
-0.28308433294296265,
0.5103965401649475,
0.3480786979198456,
-0.3065229654312134,
0.4640224874019623,
0.6526009440422058,
0.2565058469772339,
0.2742905616760254,
-0.5206608772277832,
0.8583087921142578,
-0.4058833122253418,
0.4646089971065521,
-0.02254648320376873,
-0.7411948442459106,
-0.5668759346008301,
0.0003172623983118683,
-0.28965210914611816,
-0.12712505459785461,
0.44019144773483276,
0.7887818813323975,
0.1704099476337433,
0.21287786960601807,
-0.09213962405920029,
0.45446208119392395,
0.8559010028839111,
1.0676521062850952,
0.25757309794425964,
-0.7336471676826477,
0.21429993212223053,
0.12354981154203415,
-0.6955118775367737,
-0.29835420846939087,
-0.7078606486320496,
-0.42819157242774963,
-0.4614892303943634,
-0.12075090408325195,
-0.755815863609314,
0.5956369042396545,
0.7961705327033997,
0.7511106729507446,
-0.6362976431846619,
-0.03194519132375717,
-0.22359953820705414,
0.36360570788383484,
-0.6747336983680725,
-0.11116481572389603,
0.6167998313903809,
0.22865355014801025,
-0.3034983277320862,
0.5173142552375793,
0.7162907719612122,
-0.2299950122833252,
-0.21895986795425415,
-0.020303690806031227,
-0.6271916031837463,
-0.16798728704452515,
0.48030272126197815,
0.6401848196983337,
-0.10918880999088287,
0.15324777364730835,
-0.043152373284101486,
-0.08200065046548843,
-0.09737461060285568,
0.9455966353416443,
-0.7954087853431702,
0.7122393846511841,
0.8643155097961426,
0.5750945806503296,
0.5555316209793091,
-0.06163110211491585,
1.0660320520401,
0.19007256627082825,
-0.2140893191099167,
0.05412152037024498,
0.3077887296676636,
0.24269987642765045,
-0.3509772717952728,
0.18748724460601807,
0.4760045111179352,
-0.618000864982605,
-0.49104809761047363,
0.2875699996948242,
-1.3388948440551758,
-0.518516480922699,
1.090765357017517,
-0.29721778631210327,
-0.2750967741012573,
-0.38447657227516174,
-0.33427801728248596,
0.19741284847259521,
-0.4843183755874634,
0.8426450490951538,
0.38804739713668823,
-0.19265268743038177,
-0.1784939467906952,
-0.5014596581459045,
0.36558204889297485,
-0.04422735795378685,
-0.5823068618774414,
-0.18403427302837372,
0.33268073201179504,
0.34656959772109985,
0.02420848049223423,
1.0268868207931519,
-0.25007185339927673,
-0.07026487588882446,
-0.013710745610296726,
-0.2710551917552948,
-0.3185993432998657,
0.047657303512096405,
-0.07733163237571716,
0.4837401509284973,
-0.4856712520122528,
-0.38262057304382324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13094v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13094v1 | Exploring and Benchmarking the Planning Capabilities of Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T22:57:06 | 2024-06-18T22:57:06 | Bernd Bohnet, Azade Nova, Aaron T Parisi, Kevin Swersky, Katayoon Goshvadi, Hanjun Dai, Dale Schuurmans, Noah Fiedel, Hanie Sedghi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We seek to elevate the planning capabilities of Large Language Models
(LLMs)investigating four main directions. First, we construct a comprehensive
benchmark suite encompassing both classical planning domains and natural
language scenarios. This suite includes algorithms to generate instances with
varying levels of difficulty, allowing for rigorous and systematic evaluation
of LLM performance. Second, we investigate the use of in-context learning (ICL)
to enhance LLM planning, exploring the direct relationship between increased
context length and improved planning performance. Third, we demonstrate the
positive impact of fine-tuning LLMs on optimal planning paths, as well as the
effectiveness of incorporating model-driven search procedures. Finally, we
investigate the performance of the proposed methods in out-of-distribution
scenarios, assessing the ability to generalize to novel and unseen planning
challenges. | [
-0.5581743121147156,
-0.6133154034614563,
0.7504743933677673,
0.22697092592716217,
0.06691337376832962,
-0.02499808743596077,
-0.5928331017494202,
-0.5223316550254822,
-0.2751506268978119,
0.5500198006629944,
-0.70042884349823,
-0.4927597939968109,
-0.23752786219120026,
0.12643757462501526,
-0.23623786866664886,
0.3719058930873871,
-0.28405487537384033,
0.08633958548307419,
-0.10198850929737091,
-0.0607151985168457,
-0.6283544898033142,
-0.5466291904449463,
-0.8257211446762085,
-0.5232789516448975,
0.1995646357536316,
0.7382670044898987,
0.613121747970581,
0.5119901299476624,
0.44145724177360535,
0.1937219500541687,
-0.25407785177230835,
0.27243733406066895,
-0.594495952129364,
0.1919824182987213,
-0.3458518981933594,
-0.05971801280975342,
-0.4043996036052704,
-0.31043264269828796,
0.9878208637237549,
0.8352785706520081,
-0.19583244621753693,
0.15858107805252075,
-0.08527780324220657,
0.5746203064918518,
-0.7553832530975342,
0.2762746512889862,
-0.8721935153007507,
0.05025074630975723,
-0.08542539924383163,
-0.2058335691690445,
-0.3004164397716522,
-0.15729105472564697,
0.33282583951950073,
-0.24680839478969574,
-0.0320889912545681,
0.1085694283246994,
0.40005844831466675,
0.03881019726395607,
-0.4712628424167633,
-0.4929001033306122,
-0.9894818663597107,
0.8818206191062927,
-0.8472537994384766,
0.42017507553100586,
0.3508185148239136,
0.5505025386810303,
-0.4594931900501251,
-0.6966052055358887,
-0.3034727871417999,
-0.25634440779685974,
0.06922657787799835,
-0.16156373918056488,
0.01732046715915203,
0.1398741602897644,
0.5413462519645691,
0.2055259346961975,
-0.5119043588638306,
0.5270699262619019,
-0.14447174966335297,
0.19364477694034576,
0.9454522728919983,
0.4135940372943878,
-0.029829002916812897,
0.13793820142745972,
-0.1757679134607315,
-0.19846773147583008,
-0.9980627298355103,
0.16322174668312073,
0.3114582896232605,
0.40945690870285034,
-0.019911034032702446,
0.5636647939682007,
-0.6526444554328918,
0.6642233729362488,
-0.4947495758533478,
-0.1860572248697281,
-0.09987282007932663,
-0.4284781217575073,
-0.30005261301994324,
-0.1494792103767395,
0.28256359696388245,
0.3180901110172272,
0.1891913264989853,
-0.1745002418756485,
-0.4877978265285492,
-0.39930030703544617,
0.052780672907829285,
-0.8836246728897095,
-0.03472357615828514,
0.01966804265975952,
-0.2445460706949234,
0.03596099838614464,
-0.38569405674934387,
-0.7822818756103516,
-0.2527606189250946,
-0.5289101600646973,
0.2481297105550766,
-0.5807799696922302,
-0.09220748394727707,
0.3429381251335144,
0.013674653135240078,
0.41867896914482117,
0.15301719307899475,
-1.1345149278640747,
0.5831417441368103,
0.7815310955047607,
0.5038383603096008,
-0.05856848135590553,
-0.3357624411582947,
-0.4429442584514618,
0.3928256332874298,
-0.5270108580589294,
0.8449135422706604,
-0.4842315912246704,
-0.5738902688026428,
0.48595523834228516,
-0.31717756390571594,
0.17883121967315674,
-0.8020336627960205,
0.7252855896949768,
-0.34552204608917236,
-0.15766213834285736,
-0.47712060809135437,
-0.6825858950614929,
-0.2748839259147644,
0.6336729526519775,
-0.42974698543548584,
1.150498628616333,
0.18291449546813965,
-0.2803967595100403,
0.5747023224830627,
-0.748871386051178,
-0.5789744853973389,
0.16302818059921265,
-0.161061093211174,
-0.1991925835609436,
0.08040442317724228,
0.2535230815410614,
0.7624198794364929,
-0.6348783373832703,
0.4508051872253418,
-0.15899378061294556,
-0.261969655752182,
0.05078938975930214,
-0.23597006499767303,
0.3865197002887726,
0.14705996215343475,
-0.3469405472278595,
0.3226933777332306,
-0.7076095938682556,
0.12740105390548706,
0.11737298965454102,
-0.5004456043243408,
-0.1376146674156189,
0.4593345820903778,
0.12473395466804504,
0.2408275008201599,
0.28049397468566895,
-0.24567456543445587,
0.4722636938095093,
-0.44757717847824097,
0.45807284116744995,
0.5409618616104126,
-0.06010783836245537,
0.6402037143707275,
-0.21382279694080353,
0.5277233123779297,
-0.4286344647407532,
0.25485894083976746,
-0.2378699630498886,
-0.1589410901069641,
-0.6697092652320862,
0.1377713829278946,
0.021256037056446075,
0.24336552619934082,
-0.6595110297203064,
0.19406858086585999,
-0.3487805426120758,
-0.4808500111103058,
0.21266278624534607,
0.07452917098999023,
0.3267265260219574,
0.37193048000335693,
0.3676375150680542,
-0.21694651246070862,
-0.43845871090888977,
-0.8245995044708252,
-0.22345857322216034,
-0.10993971675634384,
0.14738203585147858,
0.3783833682537079,
0.4362727105617523,
-0.2374022901058197,
0.7627565860748291,
-0.4427092671394348,
-0.11022371798753738,
-0.6601278781890869,
-0.142465740442276,
0.18369366228580475,
0.16746817529201508,
0.5340417623519897,
-0.8591998815536499,
-0.48321372270584106,
0.04946349933743477,
-0.599355161190033,
-0.1312066614627838,
0.04847341775894165,
-0.01375280600041151,
0.10812247544527054,
0.6363669633865356,
-0.37702205777168274,
0.4207724332809448,
0.4283943176269531,
-0.11054889857769012,
0.6736290454864502,
-0.4574652910232544,
-0.25445935130119324,
-0.908740758895874,
-0.0892133042216301,
0.09711091220378876,
-0.020474085584282875,
-0.6955568790435791,
0.32051587104797363,
0.29290515184402466,
-0.14100097119808197,
-0.47656404972076416,
0.7000340819358826,
-0.6267946362495422,
-0.4891819655895233,
-0.12129032611846924,
0.004758738446980715,
-0.26993033289909363,
0.37418821454048157,
0.0489593967795372,
0.8788563013076782,
0.5148709416389465,
-0.7816833853721619,
0.09987511485815048,
0.16807226836681366,
-0.6128076314926147,
0.2660095989704132,
-0.3096773326396942,
-0.15296095609664917,
0.0152351139113307,
0.3550220727920532,
-0.6941758394241333,
-0.2763116955757141,
-0.24392876029014587,
0.1950112283229828,
0.3810975253582001,
-0.09188024699687958,
-0.8325996398925781,
-0.37329933047294617,
-0.18564237654209137,
0.3353768587112427,
0.38829323649406433,
-0.6269755363464355,
0.6052271723747253,
0.41770514845848083,
-0.170318141579628,
-0.24558626115322113,
-0.34842076897621155,
0.19731248915195465,
-0.510967493057251,
-0.5324282050132751,
0.6162219047546387,
-0.24385981261730194,
-0.5819962620735168,
-0.3691036105155945,
0.07399753481149673,
0.020369242876768112,
0.08544619381427765,
-0.03604261577129364,
-0.06060591712594032,
-0.1461278796195984,
0.04908021539449692,
-0.2161298245191574,
-0.033208999782800674,
0.1585921198129654,
-0.16717804968357086,
0.8643266558647156,
0.06303425133228302,
-0.2563524544239044,
0.004378471989184618,
0.3766065537929535,
0.3137916326522827,
-0.3451670706272125,
0.4474647641181946,
-0.04280878230929375,
-0.5298038721084595,
-0.42910268902778625,
-0.6486855745315552,
0.04613865539431572,
-0.4913290739059448,
0.4756340980529785,
-0.5010961890220642,
-0.7009284496307373,
0.5312311053276062,
-0.5772092342376709,
0.2778087854385376,
0.15926304459571838,
0.5540242791175842,
0.16995427012443542,
1.1239031553268433,
1.029241681098938,
-0.10606904327869415,
0.37070122361183167,
-0.48426324129104614,
0.2664129436016083,
-0.959551990032196,
-0.18095777928829193,
-0.5220654010772705,
-0.24704478681087494,
-0.54971843957901,
-0.518505334854126,
0.4584169387817383,
0.2120635062456131,
-0.26455387473106384,
0.4170311987400055,
-0.00545506039634347,
0.6544711589813232,
0.35284268856048584,
-0.339771568775177,
0.22446370124816895,
-0.09462745487689972,
-0.2014545351266861,
0.07582780718803406,
-0.7359731197357178,
-0.7020015716552734,
1.0946847200393677,
0.37006404995918274,
0.5506536364555359,
0.14725500345230103,
0.5286569595336914,
-0.3424021601676941,
0.27911123633384705,
-0.6501338481903076,
0.7906494140625,
-0.03535499796271324,
-0.571128785610199,
-0.5915704369544983,
-0.26078420877456665,
-0.7375549674034119,
0.22933121025562286,
-0.2799377739429474,
-0.9349184632301331,
0.0008344920934177935,
-0.12537099421024323,
-0.15700428187847137,
0.5110647082328796,
-0.5418046116828918,
0.6348657608032227,
-0.4662429690361023,
-0.3499622941017151,
-0.46556147933006287,
-0.2710702419281006,
0.199823796749115,
-0.17466439306735992,
0.10103674232959747,
-0.3659711182117462,
-0.03892071172595024,
0.34797215461730957,
0.09984422475099564,
0.4276471436023712,
0.03151727840304375,
-0.1018957644701004,
-0.03771476447582245,
0.1281253546476364,
0.6737244725227356,
0.032242730259895325,
-0.586240828037262,
0.06902895122766495,
-0.21980708837509155,
-0.27438661456108093,
-0.2855147123336792,
0.8072019219398499,
-0.3680466413497925,
-0.3625533878803253,
-0.054184410721063614,
-0.9822877645492554,
-0.6262552738189697,
0.2685029208660126,
0.1875358521938324,
0.5979431867599487,
-0.6860590577125549,
0.11518588662147522,
0.5440120100975037,
-0.4940223693847656,
0.9676524996757507,
0.6451845765113831,
-0.3827594518661499,
-0.046928536146879196,
0.4153631031513214,
0.310194194316864,
0.37588536739349365,
0.5637921690940857,
0.25108978152275085,
-0.5231718420982361,
-1.1219825744628906,
-0.2532990276813507,
0.04172492399811745,
-0.8465120196342468,
-0.00016362355381716043,
-0.39972877502441406,
-0.18819399178028107,
-0.4790811240673065,
-0.34405162930488586,
-0.27530843019485474,
-0.0290299654006958,
0.15134161710739136,
-0.013785203918814659,
-0.008756529539823532,
1.0065006017684937,
0.08231005072593689,
0.33138734102249146,
-0.3714854419231415,
-0.06655509024858475,
0.10696377605199814,
0.386442095041275,
0.05741129070520401,
-0.03655697777867317,
-0.33254143595695496,
-0.08118464797735214,
-0.48831480741500854,
-0.4527633786201477,
0.7019533514976501,
-0.00009344788850285113,
0.7472142577171326,
0.32740119099617004,
0.037146735936403275,
0.8990373015403748,
-0.681414783000946,
0.6740878224372864,
-0.18489252030849457,
-0.5781735777854919,
0.5393198132514954,
-0.5144177079200745,
0.43836888670921326,
0.6066524982452393,
0.5635035634040833,
-0.3450465202331543,
0.013746719807386398,
-0.6431432366371155,
-1.139899492263794,
0.5164760947227478,
0.16606521606445312,
0.03841513767838478,
0.08364728093147278,
0.36955222487449646,
0.08203824609518051,
0.0825830027461052,
-0.5714247226715088,
0.01691695675253868,
0.6131471991539001,
0.2652193605899811,
-0.5576002597808838,
-0.5534324049949646,
-0.08191901445388794,
-0.39870136976242065,
0.6832377910614014,
-0.23632335662841797,
-0.04024810343980789,
-0.1496443748474121,
0.028559809550642967,
-0.17091649770736694,
0.24375776946544647,
0.8199617862701416,
1.3111275434494019,
-0.2532055675983429,
-0.013463708572089672,
0.6562726497650146,
0.0033834197092801332,
-0.24362999200820923,
0.24208758771419525,
-0.039913784712553024,
-0.2800111472606659,
0.3867419362068176,
0.646135687828064,
0.5793333649635315,
-0.9780607223510742,
0.19922329485416412,
-0.20817960798740387,
-0.2580510377883911,
-0.6375560164451599,
-0.05042874813079834,
0.22830496728420258,
0.36707040667533875,
0.36675894260406494,
-0.48061323165893555,
0.1346600502729416,
-0.6805078387260437,
-0.03729572892189026,
0.4898017644882202,
-0.29001230001449585,
-0.0983024388551712,
0.29320403933525085,
-0.042327508330345154,
-0.5161276459693909,
0.5447537302970886,
-0.1688275784254074,
-0.5020042061805725,
0.5289755463600159,
0.7195261716842651,
0.7256008982658386,
0.014989756979048252,
-0.0575346015393734,
0.34288933873176575,
0.353461354970932,
-0.13906949758529663,
0.43952521681785583,
-0.03651592507958412,
-0.6539728045463562,
-0.43407633900642395,
-0.6171801686286926,
-0.48040148615837097,
0.27262547612190247,
-0.4101080894470215,
0.5395691394805908,
-0.3603809177875519,
0.17638154327869415,
-0.22540761530399323,
0.3490656614303589,
-0.8883573412895203,
0.06550770252943039,
0.07250088453292847,
1.3208565711975098,
-0.5199918150901794,
0.8319974541664124,
0.7560924291610718,
-0.09791409224271774,
-0.9695348143577576,
0.23926378786563873,
-0.1325051188468933,
-0.743983805179596,
0.6551160216331482,
0.2677847146987915,
-0.10928931087255478,
-0.06244446337223053,
-0.36552685499191284,
-0.9515504837036133,
1.2975140810012817,
0.18175579607486725,
-0.6920084953308105,
-0.04622134193778038,
0.37735193967819214,
0.4953204095363617,
-0.5530431270599365,
0.16602569818496704,
0.7893176674842834,
0.34025052189826965,
-0.008842232637107372,
-1.0496792793273926,
-0.2350998818874359,
0.2560269236564636,
0.29598164558410645,
0.4424816370010376,
-0.4486004710197449,
0.7693004608154297,
0.01305742934346199,
-0.2326170802116394,
0.1637512743473053,
0.5292319655418396,
0.3064419627189636,
0.39938437938690186,
0.46601516008377075,
0.5623776316642761,
0.5777900218963623,
0.06125852093100548,
1.1734050512313843,
-0.38325735926628113,
0.0996675193309784,
1.0577250719070435,
-0.774928867816925,
1.1572253704071045,
0.4317004382610321,
-0.058295201510190964,
0.3204634487628937,
0.6769370436668396,
0.3940269649028778,
0.562741219997406,
0.36577290296554565,
-0.4352470338344574,
-0.10578019917011261,
-0.15752337872982025,
-0.17866620421409607,
0.4464317560195923,
0.5100623965263367,
0.0007710917270742357,
-0.5611320734024048,
-0.025844324380159378,
-0.09162409603595734,
0.3278869390487671,
-0.4399928152561188,
0.700442373752594,
0.013053571805357933,
-0.7904182076454163,
0.3268621265888214,
0.15527072548866272,
0.5912075638771057,
-0.6319671869277954,
0.031064987182617188,
-0.1251617819070816,
0.3769758343696594,
0.21617819368839264,
-0.9426611065864563,
0.2845594882965088,
-0.20108109712600708,
0.03349637985229492,
-0.5073308944702148,
0.7741549015045166,
-0.2004922777414322,
-0.3201553523540497,
0.6119217872619629,
0.40420153737068176,
-0.03913046047091484,
-0.051108576357364655,
-0.5369974374771118,
0.08952143788337708,
-0.27842652797698975,
-0.1415746808052063,
0.5694602727890015,
0.5968279242515564,
-0.3139384686946869,
0.9465709328651428,
0.6378078460693359,
0.14002124965190887,
0.06661725789308548,
0.042137522250413895,
0.8022420406341553,
-0.7618839144706726,
-0.4865466356277466,
-0.799387514591217,
0.2948206067085266,
-0.21739187836647034,
-0.48091256618499756,
0.6783407330513,
0.8299488425254822,
1.2109349966049194,
0.06236813962459564,
0.4036429524421692,
0.16382187604904175,
0.43958064913749695,
-0.6893026828765869,
0.24069184064865112,
-0.44382378458976746,
0.43361666798591614,
-0.1357366144657135,
-1.1314390897750854,
-0.28199779987335205,
0.41700077056884766,
-0.6719493269920349,
-0.21114379167556763,
0.5633885860443115,
0.8548238277435303,
-0.10404554009437561,
-0.06793122738599777,
0.582260012626648,
-0.20916010439395905,
0.6139722466468811,
0.7223578095436096,
1.0494304895401,
-0.1376713514328003,
0.20045632123947144,
-0.43350064754486084,
-0.09505068510770798,
-0.228207528591156,
-1.1771899461746216,
-0.9372249245643616,
-0.6625057458877563,
0.049932654947042465,
0.20336276292800903,
-0.016107697039842606,
0.9584167003631592,
0.920973539352417,
-0.38935616612434387,
-0.8646661639213562,
-0.21118097007274628,
-0.06415487825870514,
-0.10536852478981018,
-0.17339171469211578,
0.02343134395778179,
-0.3866521716117859,
-0.5462227463722229,
0.8114047646522522,
0.44162923097610474,
0.002521638059988618,
-0.42428258061408997,
-0.29320308566093445,
-0.3185315430164337,
0.008120816200971603,
0.8793650269508362,
0.31594231724739075,
-0.6550061702728271,
-0.12221965938806534,
-0.16935934126377106,
0.06119886413216591,
-0.19167734682559967,
1.000137209892273,
-0.5290189385414124,
0.29400718212127686,
0.38146206736564636,
0.5662928223609924,
0.8061767816543579,
-0.3476489186286926,
0.8427100777626038,
-0.8429651260375977,
0.2950768768787384,
0.3833647668361664,
0.5004380941390991,
0.26867979764938354,
-0.24303530156612396,
0.7990961074829102,
-0.5515849590301514,
-0.7836968898773193,
-0.8077091574668884,
0.42973682284355164,
-0.7653451561927795,
-0.39979127049446106,
1.309762954711914,
0.18346962332725525,
0.1946335732936859,
-0.0582304447889328,
-0.20260533690452576,
-0.03160536661744118,
-0.03923945128917694,
0.5666325688362122,
0.6393188834190369,
-0.42117759585380554,
-0.01731541007757187,
-1.0021229982376099,
0.6327524781227112,
0.10399968177080154,
-0.8356822729110718,
0.2784900665283203,
0.5001880526542664,
0.21109209954738617,
-0.0539434589445591,
0.8498416543006897,
0.049808893352746964,
-0.13584411144256592,
-0.48004934191703796,
-0.03833167254924774,
0.3210327923297882,
-0.4901742935180664,
-0.38200321793556213,
0.09116089344024658,
0.49476194381713867,
0.4222372770309448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13092v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13092v1 | Multilingual Synopses of Movie Narratives: A Dataset for Story Understanding | 2024-06-18T22:44:50 | 2024-06-18T22:44:50 | Yidan Sun, Jianfei Yu, Boyang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Story video-text alignment, a core task in computational story understanding,
aims to align video clips with corresponding sentences in their descriptions.
However, progress on the task has been held back by the scarcity of manually
annotated video-text correspondence and the heavy concentration on English
narrations of Hollywood movies. To address these issues, in this paper, we
construct a large-scale multilingual video story dataset named Multilingual
Synopses of Movie Narratives (M-SYMON), containing 13,166 movie summary videos
from 7 languages, as well as manual annotation of fine-grained video-text
correspondences for 101.5 hours of video. Training on the human annotated data
from SyMoN outperforms the SOTA methods by 15.7 and 16.2 percentage points on
Clip Accuracy and Sentence IoU scores, respectively, demonstrating the
effectiveness of the annotations. As benchmarks for future research, we create
6 baseline approaches with different multilingual training strategies, compare
their performance in both intra-lingual and cross-lingual setups, exemplifying
the challenges of multilingual video-text alignment. | [
-0.28984397649765015,
-0.36570262908935547,
0.3239991366863251,
0.014101332053542137,
-0.25887438654899597,
0.3003780245780945,
-0.36161336302757263,
-0.3968449831008911,
0.5186253190040588,
0.19212928414344788,
-0.8325919508934021,
-0.3853600025177002,
-0.5433791279792786,
0.4097564220428467,
-0.16699610650539398,
1.3282753229141235,
-0.4317682087421417,
0.22275269031524658,
-0.07495103776454926,
-0.5729650855064392,
-0.32869529724121094,
-0.4556041359901428,
-0.20515774190425873,
0.25230473279953003,
0.5065281987190247,
0.3501643240451813,
0.8465107679367065,
0.9627545475959778,
0.4673776924610138,
0.21777449548244476,
0.3134303689002991,
0.44094613194465637,
-0.15579363703727722,
0.1705133616924286,
-0.03291349858045578,
-0.19560717046260834,
-0.21426323056221008,
-0.19723129272460938,
0.8315435647964478,
0.4366867244243622,
-0.015566092915832996,
0.6633827686309814,
-0.12721949815750122,
0.3077293038368225,
-0.7679697871208191,
0.03583333268761635,
-0.15931670367717743,
0.23178474605083466,
-0.4378940761089325,
-0.053988970816135406,
-0.1639341413974762,
-0.00044858595356345177,
0.11621638387441635,
-0.9258575439453125,
0.25887230038642883,
-0.08670797944068909,
0.7069031000137329,
0.2797324061393738,
-0.23057205975055695,
-0.025927193462848663,
-0.5152243971824646,
0.5884389877319336,
-0.3937484323978424,
0.41899558901786804,
0.3664827346801758,
0.43271946907043457,
0.49556130170822144,
-0.08881373703479767,
-0.6640645265579224,
0.2401144802570343,
-0.12272781878709793,
-0.00964562501758337,
0.0830787643790245,
-0.08485668152570724,
0.3956209123134613,
0.16757363080978394,
-0.8397989273071289,
0.19814209640026093,
-0.40145596861839294,
-0.44250303506851196,
0.6955154538154602,
0.3743346035480499,
0.3969269096851349,
-0.40886110067367554,
-0.4031621813774109,
-0.4423693120479584,
-0.2406163513660431,
0.13040991127490997,
0.4647528827190399,
0.16329611837863922,
-0.3532226085662842,
0.6510138511657715,
-0.01713237166404724,
0.7392277717590332,
-0.3695458769798279,
-0.6908068060874939,
0.4346911609172821,
-0.661571741104126,
-0.2230876237154007,
0.4649202227592468,
0.8793012499809265,
0.8307172060012817,
0.4440305233001709,
0.004314351361244917,
0.2750721275806427,
0.3645950257778168,
-0.07318578660488129,
-0.5549321174621582,
0.02231672964990139,
-0.03929375112056732,
-0.18532727658748627,
0.275208055973053,
0.1366380751132965,
-0.8240119814872742,
-0.5229634642601013,
-0.28160983324050903,
0.4322196841239929,
-0.340452641248703,
0.10634582489728928,
-0.09379241615533829,
-0.30890485644340515,
0.006845842581242323,
0.17272768914699554,
-1.1110175848007202,
0.06560541689395905,
0.3935009241104126,
0.9128691554069519,
0.03533729910850525,
-0.945622980594635,
-0.6853774785995483,
0.6827985644340515,
-0.30430611968040466,
0.6304886341094971,
-0.23932768404483795,
0.33446839451789856,
0.18829673528671265,
0.0051527321338653564,
-0.2113836109638214,
-0.08171641081571579,
0.4467390477657318,
0.04622416943311691,
0.4377965033054352,
-0.05760807543992996,
-0.20672564208507538,
-0.2932579219341278,
0.44126516580581665,
-0.6712448596954346,
0.6743365526199341,
-0.23012764751911163,
-0.6397826075553894,
0.2942766547203064,
-0.14626255631446838,
-0.4243922531604767,
-0.39389675855636597,
-0.44575947523117065,
-0.07752493023872375,
0.03863045200705528,
0.6930535435676575,
0.3562210500240326,
-0.1651429384946823,
0.48048537969589233,
0.035340845584869385,
-0.38801127672195435,
0.20662538707256317,
-0.5108503699302673,
0.4820120930671692,
0.14726190268993378,
-0.2205735743045807,
-0.12634246051311493,
-0.6469712257385254,
-0.20849809050559998,
-0.23596851527690887,
0.21458777785301208,
-0.21013252437114716,
-0.26807060837745667,
0.09158886969089508,
0.4340618848800659,
0.03985363245010376,
-0.4095117449760437,
0.07903902232646942,
-0.2853047251701355,
0.3263861835002899,
0.5810920000076294,
-0.2988586723804474,
0.36707544326782227,
-0.22661618888378143,
0.7440847754478455,
-0.10595167428255081,
0.18330878019332886,
-0.8678770065307617,
-0.08508039265871048,
-0.4273265600204468,
-0.1630885750055313,
-0.024832140654325485,
0.5941644906997681,
-0.7258650064468384,
-0.13284114003181458,
-0.4624830484390259,
-0.3155798316001892,
-0.7712664604187012,
0.36698079109191895,
0.6600193977355957,
0.35569682717323303,
0.42468348145484924,
-0.21986234188079834,
-0.6417450904846191,
-0.8221834301948547,
-0.2505479156970978,
-0.16936145722866058,
0.06667749583721161,
-0.06465313583612442,
0.16421987116336823,
0.10748551785945892,
0.6314098834991455,
-0.4615553021430969,
-0.5050246119499207,
-0.27124011516571045,
-0.12809684872627258,
0.2978435754776001,
0.17581546306610107,
0.3487068712711334,
-0.6860454678535461,
-0.5377396941184998,
0.18521615862846375,
-1.086410641670227,
0.13143473863601685,
-0.21939140558242798,
0.12212992459535599,
0.16407954692840576,
0.6318672895431519,
-0.6254116296768188,
0.13843069970607758,
0.803826093673706,
-0.22724135220050812,
0.7449659705162048,
-0.3207208514213562,
0.5612005591392517,
-1.1571297645568848,
-0.05884290859103203,
0.16698746383190155,
0.036310695111751556,
-0.47412925958633423,
-0.22241008281707764,
-0.07521530985832214,
-0.23781906068325043,
-0.5560970306396484,
0.5763182640075684,
-0.3223460912704468,
-0.23502986133098602,
0.20783092081546783,
0.5915581583976746,
0.12054307758808136,
0.6382022500038147,
0.11654329299926758,
0.6318250298500061,
0.3969072699546814,
-0.24883030354976654,
0.4323054254055023,
0.6059406399726868,
-0.40123263001441956,
0.666714072227478,
-0.17041681706905365,
-0.23241932690143585,
-0.30912768840789795,
0.24491572380065918,
-0.9129069447517395,
-0.5363596677780151,
0.04114940017461777,
-0.2938140332698822,
0.03876341134309769,
-0.1454295516014099,
-0.5621550679206848,
-0.05933860316872597,
-0.3890630006790161,
0.6041172742843628,
-0.0837322473526001,
-0.39007243514060974,
0.4521925747394562,
0.47717297077178955,
-0.4079808294773102,
-0.9868583679199219,
-0.5885698199272156,
0.33319854736328125,
-0.599127471446991,
-0.6688386797904968,
0.4003264605998993,
0.045219823718070984,
-0.17042924463748932,
-0.39050087332725525,
-0.3009091913700104,
-0.1617612987756729,
-0.3364921808242798,
0.06836646050214767,
0.28711754083633423,
-0.21871508657932281,
0.2064511775970459,
0.11693497002124786,
-0.20627479255199432,
-0.19925644993782043,
-0.10148634016513824,
0.29972824454307556,
0.28481483459472656,
0.012905464507639408,
-0.5424231290817261,
0.5724075436592102,
0.5296868085861206,
-0.28313878178596497,
0.37285202741622925,
0.9370900988578796,
-0.23978646099567413,
0.3153061270713806,
-0.4717773199081421,
0.0325017049908638,
-0.3183507025241852,
0.697303295135498,
-0.362393319606781,
-0.8723466396331787,
0.3132888674736023,
0.3343484103679657,
0.2631364166736603,
0.35266751050949097,
0.25988805294036865,
-0.44723403453826904,
0.9836714267730713,
0.6163358688354492,
-0.14682771265506744,
0.516749918460846,
-0.057998307049274445,
0.09757760912179947,
-0.445171594619751,
-0.15148651599884033,
-0.3112242519855499,
-0.4419404864311218,
-0.43587008118629456,
-0.2883961498737335,
0.4479868412017822,
0.2249738574028015,
-0.26073315739631653,
0.5970199108123779,
0.055446017533540726,
0.8384394645690918,
0.18690553307533264,
-0.24443387985229492,
0.4765024483203888,
0.3218317925930023,
-0.024536291137337685,
-0.42796075344085693,
-0.7251648902893066,
-0.5462828278541565,
0.6995816826820374,
0.2970450520515442,
0.5766741037368774,
0.44277679920196533,
0.42266950011253357,
0.01041312888264656,
-0.24275460839271545,
-0.3268580436706543,
0.3728744387626648,
-0.5533778667449951,
-0.47090670466423035,
-0.3204217553138733,
-0.21228787302970886,
-0.6691355109214783,
0.1921890377998352,
-0.37066850066185,
-1.0260201692581177,
-0.13399893045425415,
0.16643156111240387,
-0.5296853184700012,
0.14341437816619873,
-0.8478264808654785,
1.2651035785675049,
-0.3959905803203583,
-0.37331971526145935,
-0.1804124265909195,
-1.165125846862793,
0.13514436781406403,
-0.07066675275564194,
0.6048464179039001,
-0.09025774151086807,
0.08336827903985977,
0.8825064897537231,
-0.3339470326900482,
0.6686161160469055,
0.07138830423355103,
-0.06466137617826462,
0.17191506922245026,
0.0666327252984047,
0.17793972790241241,
0.19202330708503723,
0.2997957170009613,
0.11551432311534882,
0.2636258900165558,
-0.2555410861968994,
-0.6250288486480713,
0.36376431584358215,
-0.6723888516426086,
-0.31129294633865356,
-0.4569820463657379,
-0.8407595157623291,
-0.26264292001724243,
0.04422524571418762,
0.26497405767440796,
0.6120883226394653,
-0.1600928157567978,
-0.23106034100055695,
0.2753630578517914,
-0.24399884045124054,
0.7598844766616821,
0.15298931300640106,
-0.28320637345314026,
-1.0529515743255615,
0.7936969995498657,
0.11060398817062378,
0.21658110618591309,
0.5298551917076111,
-0.16305099427700043,
-0.31924310326576233,
-0.1195841133594513,
-0.9728206396102905,
0.25621163845062256,
-0.5305309891700745,
-0.20215833187103271,
-0.540488064289093,
0.08787935972213745,
-0.25004687905311584,
-0.2614753246307373,
-0.2385561466217041,
-0.39554741978645325,
0.21339242160320282,
-0.4685780107975006,
0.3938966989517212,
0.30996593832969666,
-0.0022752191871404648,
0.497137188911438,
-1.0335439443588257,
0.27932417392730713,
-0.013659271411597729,
0.10538212209939957,
-0.30638325214385986,
-0.46003150939941406,
-0.8490744829177856,
-0.15106356143951416,
-0.2929023504257202,
-0.7247214913368225,
0.27082639932632446,
0.5107714533805847,
0.3288259506225586,
0.33958378434181213,
-0.3338642716407776,
1.3320986032485962,
-0.5117061734199524,
0.766631007194519,
0.5215752720832825,
-0.8143107295036316,
0.42555737495422363,
-0.42840495705604553,
0.5216636061668396,
0.7444813251495361,
0.4847714900970459,
-0.8638399243354797,
-0.24140207469463348,
-0.4234682619571686,
-0.6237697601318359,
0.740382730960846,
0.12206801027059555,
0.21525157988071442,
0.2533895969390869,
0.022551098838448524,
0.44357550144195557,
0.25636962056159973,
-0.6146113276481628,
-0.18560566008090973,
-0.06133608520030975,
-0.4591285288333893,
-0.8801679015159607,
0.045235078781843185,
-0.22519586980342865,
-0.14981357753276825,
0.37385043501853943,
-0.29148146510124207,
-0.2755945026874542,
0.13802114129066467,
-0.5013969540596008,
-0.07476048171520233,
0.13935689628124237,
0.5200836062431335,
0.5333338379859924,
-0.12076332420110703,
0.36592426896095276,
0.15580087900161743,
-0.601756751537323,
0.4235230088233948,
0.26328957080841064,
-0.03354274481534958,
0.20968277752399445,
0.6969671249389648,
0.8732635974884033,
0.1853688508272171,
-1.1469790935516357,
0.33145254850387573,
0.16694027185440063,
-0.13947373628616333,
-0.1100035160779953,
-0.3187417685985565,
-0.2463798075914383,
0.3538304567337036,
0.2606728971004486,
-0.03957879915833473,
-0.0959651842713356,
-0.6535273790359497,
0.16894373297691345,
0.08060326427221298,
-0.32675695419311523,
-0.33057236671447754,
0.4036093056201935,
-0.10559377074241638,
-0.1382322460412979,
0.5316601395606995,
0.05952448397874832,
-0.3669048249721527,
0.3590894639492035,
0.43772315979003906,
0.5380863547325134,
-0.16598449647426605,
0.43614470958709717,
0.5550089478492737,
0.3857344090938568,
-0.27783918380737305,
-0.0352676585316658,
-0.025950651615858078,
-0.5701136589050293,
-0.9169223308563232,
-0.5478625893592834,
-0.23157092928886414,
-0.22892358899116516,
-0.4930412471294403,
0.43611207604408264,
-0.08996906131505966,
0.02626127563416958,
0.1264955997467041,
-0.16159960627555847,
-0.3761404752731323,
0.11881779879331589,
0.3912199139595032,
0.6698494553565979,
-1.291483759880066,
0.6663265228271484,
0.834377110004425,
-0.4803546965122223,
-0.7641997337341309,
-0.12075474113225937,
0.1029888316988945,
-0.4139361083507538,
0.4692314863204956,
0.4957822859287262,
0.12015538662672043,
-0.22467274963855743,
0.0782385915517807,
-0.7929734587669373,
1.031032919883728,
0.8039552569389343,
-0.510024905204773,
-0.21463854610919952,
0.21392515301704407,
0.6501515507698059,
-0.33359482884407043,
0.1747891753911972,
0.4831192195415497,
0.26191285252571106,
-0.22419008612632751,
-1.1923961639404297,
-0.4578993618488312,
-0.2792341411113739,
-0.456950306892395,
0.4634344279766083,
-0.5071601867675781,
0.5033445358276367,
-0.28670352697372437,
-0.12969434261322021,
0.020831648260354996,
0.5019838213920593,
0.46767911314964294,
0.7074698805809021,
0.3033824861049652,
0.6766138076782227,
0.4637330174446106,
0.1279507428407669,
0.7654918432235718,
0.041705723851919174,
0.07544421404600143,
1.4088577032089233,
0.03723347187042236,
0.7496013641357422,
0.7438154816627502,
-0.15700191259384155,
0.49074703454971313,
0.6142327785491943,
-0.04261539503931999,
0.330095112323761,
-0.1272139698266983,
-0.04127194732427597,
-0.28157714009284973,
-0.432495653629303,
-0.06128906458616257,
0.5926311612129211,
0.030593479052186012,
-0.217900350689888,
-0.3035140335559845,
0.3190237879753113,
0.01660277508199215,
0.38239794969558716,
-0.39696183800697327,
0.8156579732894897,
-0.03532092645764351,
-0.7529206871986389,
0.27041664719581604,
-0.36264777183532715,
0.47815176844596863,
-0.6732263565063477,
-0.006082410458475351,
-0.1513884961605072,
0.11162292212247849,
-0.25725433230400085,
-0.648535430431366,
0.1656268984079361,
0.4594748616218567,
-0.3917253911495209,
-0.2507769465446472,
-0.107463039457798,
-0.8267457485198975,
-0.46946778893470764,
0.09706833958625793,
0.35172238945961,
0.3572298288345337,
0.21417248249053955,
-0.46061432361602783,
0.2589709758758545,
0.017269453033804893,
0.3895181119441986,
0.40241897106170654,
0.38184255361557007,
-0.37065303325653076,
0.2064494788646698,
0.24038977921009064,
-0.1462879627943039,
-0.1299191564321518,
0.18306715786457062,
0.18475782871246338,
-0.5120808482170105,
-0.6227636337280273,
-1.0812368392944336,
0.5488749742507935,
0.02053218148648739,
-0.5742502212524414,
0.9711205959320068,
0.792385458946228,
1.2306454181671143,
-0.1959855705499649,
0.58905428647995,
0.019927073270082474,
0.009174070321023464,
-0.7941182255744934,
0.11378324031829834,
-0.38674798607826233,
0.0651932880282402,
-0.5700153708457947,
-1.1800642013549805,
-0.40843239426612854,
0.589296817779541,
0.02877730503678322,
-0.2897019684314728,
0.9037410616874695,
0.5866135954856873,
-0.08550072461366653,
-0.05555059015750885,
0.009088649414479733,
0.04340144991874695,
0.07557941228151321,
0.6282327175140381,
0.8299243450164795,
-0.625409722328186,
0.772406816482544,
-0.3560790717601776,
-0.0500839538872242,
0.08580592274665833,
-0.8487921357154846,
-0.7676063179969788,
-0.7494741678237915,
-0.36880171298980713,
-0.08848168700933456,
0.13904474675655365,
0.9912940859794617,
0.5322516560554504,
-0.5900103449821472,
-0.7592898011207581,
0.36971384286880493,
-0.08394493162631989,
-0.5362458825111389,
-0.07282247394323349,
0.5485478639602661,
-0.09836824983358383,
-0.7377133369445801,
0.43866151571273804,
0.4266161620616913,
-0.023108558729290962,
-0.10866878181695938,
-0.19449280202388763,
-0.32580628991127014,
-0.4742558002471924,
0.401693195104599,
0.22112244367599487,
-0.5811101198196411,
-0.0710882693529129,
0.0882955938577652,
0.024959124624729156,
0.047672055661678314,
0.8367636203765869,
-0.3756447732448578,
0.7453701496124268,
0.3671344518661499,
0.5712770819664001,
0.644801139831543,
0.12109068781137466,
0.8245014548301697,
-1.1325775384902954,
0.3170633614063263,
-0.17893876135349274,
0.4833866357803345,
0.35584548115730286,
-0.196017324924469,
0.5523916482925415,
0.13853971660137177,
-0.20680515468120575,
-0.827978253364563,
0.08824437111616135,
-1.2297115325927734,
-0.15810665488243103,
0.9601936936378479,
-0.07187964022159576,
-0.08053183555603027,
0.08180961012840271,
-0.43048200011253357,
0.3054785430431366,
-0.16420632600784302,
0.5813706517219543,
0.8880918025970459,
0.002064972184598446,
-0.3104551434516907,
-0.6837557554244995,
0.5886138081550598,
0.3958711624145508,
-0.6808117032051086,
0.40038639307022095,
0.6403171420097351,
-0.12310495972633362,
0.4346785545349121,
0.3671003580093384,
-0.013045519590377808,
0.45012667775154114,
-0.1409756988286972,
0.016438540071249008,
-0.11011744290590286,
-0.6642451286315918,
-0.5211887359619141,
0.06373332440853119,
-0.3567816913127899,
-0.21129721403121948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13069v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13069v2 | Evaluating $n$-Gram Novelty of Language Models Using Rusty-DAWG | 2024-06-18T21:31:19 | 2024-06-25T15:02:40 | William Merrill, Noah A. Smith, Yanai Elazar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | How novel are texts generated by language models (LMs) relative to their
training corpora? In this work, we investigate the extent to which modern LMs
generate $n$-grams from their training data, evaluating both (i) the
probability LMs assign to complete training $n$-grams and (ii) $n$-novelty, the
proportion of $n$-grams generated by an LM that did not appear in the training
data (for arbitrarily large $n$). To enable arbitrary-length $n$-gram search
over a corpus in constant time, we develop Rusty-DAWG, a novel search tool
inspired by indexing of genomic data. We compare the novelty of LM-generated
text to human-written text and explore factors that affect generation novelty,
focusing on the Pythia models. We find that, for $n > 4$, LM-generated text is
less novel than human-written text, though it is more novel for smaller $n$.
Larger LMs and more constrained decoding strategies both decrease novelty.
Finally, we show that LMs complete $n$-grams with lower loss if they are more
frequent in the training data. Overall, our results reveal factors influencing
the novelty of LM-generated text, and we release Rusty-DAWG to facilitate
further pretraining data research. | [
-0.27781885862350464,
-0.9599657654762268,
0.7400892972946167,
-0.2396138310432434,
-0.38290733098983765,
0.15424324572086334,
-0.22535331547260284,
-0.2811063826084137,
0.1993977427482605,
0.15266050398349762,
-0.41664499044418335,
-0.6868807673454285,
-0.4853464365005493,
0.410359650850296,
-0.7763811945915222,
1.0755038261413574,
0.3037991225719452,
-0.08316008001565933,
-0.3080236315727234,
0.2795672118663788,
0.035414427518844604,
-0.5461790561676025,
-0.09374921768903732,
-0.306887686252594,
0.7559453248977661,
0.4540536403656006,
0.6626908779144287,
0.7289745807647705,
0.41364777088165283,
0.24327276647090912,
-0.39447593688964844,
0.09594780206680298,
-0.6241858601570129,
-0.018871324136853218,
0.18837128579616547,
-0.37233027815818787,
-0.25994083285331726,
0.07787071168422699,
0.878869354724884,
0.8514634966850281,
0.025613492354750633,
-0.013697435148060322,
-0.20985352993011475,
0.7066220045089722,
-0.6312751770019531,
-0.1261417418718338,
-0.825810968875885,
-0.028321774676442146,
-0.5000128746032715,
-0.3816794455051422,
-0.5349953770637512,
-0.5510815382003784,
0.3039677143096924,
-0.3899671137332916,
0.6829236149787903,
-0.09052198380231857,
0.8954543471336365,
-0.2685968577861786,
-0.3370197117328644,
-0.5691428780555725,
-0.6812607049942017,
0.7342272400856018,
-0.9504752159118652,
-0.10912153869867325,
0.15796789526939392,
0.03666239604353905,
-0.6186577677726746,
-0.6971291899681091,
-0.7490146160125732,
-0.5842493772506714,
0.12187378853559494,
-0.20041398704051971,
-0.14988374710083008,
-0.014407999813556671,
0.07638250291347504,
0.8372793793678284,
-0.6971598863601685,
0.1931871771812439,
-0.12237133085727692,
-0.039477989077568054,
0.7558459043502808,
0.3462272882461548,
0.549706757068634,
-0.05852612853050232,
-0.20191489160060883,
-0.25425559282302856,
-0.6569470167160034,
-0.3335646688938141,
0.9066930413246155,
0.23878446221351624,
0.020426403731107712,
0.3971940577030182,
-0.30926525592803955,
0.7534490823745728,
-0.1710423231124878,
-0.213234081864357,
0.6058469414710999,
-0.19508881866931915,
0.016600660979747772,
0.07818620651960373,
1.0106698274612427,
0.14376845955848694,
0.4832542836666107,
-0.5778995156288147,
-0.21006761491298676,
-0.02996561862528324,
0.2091599851846695,
-0.8031068444252014,
-0.3621089458465576,
0.010004715994000435,
-0.5647446513175964,
-0.7289509773254395,
0.2008250653743744,
-0.479783833026886,
-0.3298197388648987,
0.20793284475803375,
0.40986767411231995,
-0.6209641098976135,
-0.3504886031150818,
0.2721805274486542,
-0.730715274810791,
0.0006388465990312397,
0.14722710847854614,
-0.9533359408378601,
0.16717034578323364,
0.4191552996635437,
0.7989569306373596,
-0.1460960954427719,
-0.35481035709381104,
-0.3886573314666748,
-0.1927897036075592,
-0.6022879481315613,
0.5916513204574585,
-0.4705826938152313,
-0.4667346179485321,
-0.031270965933799744,
-0.12601369619369507,
0.08300384134054184,
-0.5270801782608032,
0.4501315653324127,
-0.5017520189285278,
0.07300150394439697,
-0.04640917852520943,
-0.5670077204704285,
-0.09102674573659897,
0.06329670548439026,
-0.5263360738754272,
1.1304384469985962,
0.22533152997493744,
-1.1186999082565308,
0.5974357724189758,
-0.3326761722564697,
-0.363063246011734,
0.30086550116539,
-0.2091262936592102,
-0.3708743453025818,
0.5188810229301453,
-0.322198748588562,
0.25181782245635986,
-0.47417351603507996,
0.18766064941883087,
-0.581788182258606,
-0.7390116453170776,
0.6700230836868286,
-0.6073440313339233,
0.509674608707428,
0.19231672585010529,
-0.2910735309123993,
-0.09838294982910156,
-1.1436495780944824,
0.28329578042030334,
0.5450964570045471,
-0.6072567105293274,
-0.5738430023193359,
0.022276489064097404,
0.15970000624656677,
-0.07913720607757568,
0.34387362003326416,
-0.8074095845222473,
0.3247629404067993,
-0.540059506893158,
0.4352608919143677,
0.396577388048172,
0.053542181849479675,
0.31227031350135803,
-0.44864147901535034,
0.32783243060112,
-0.0024083491880446672,
-0.09974056482315063,
-0.18015645444393158,
-0.5810410976409912,
-0.49275100231170654,
-0.08456402271986008,
0.47762012481689453,
0.1041642352938652,
-0.6434547305107117,
0.2100684940814972,
-0.49853530526161194,
-0.7871119976043701,
-0.23644787073135376,
0.07576940953731537,
0.2900656759738922,
-0.002566716866567731,
0.04696737974882126,
-0.4516819715499878,
-0.37145915627479553,
-0.9528012871742249,
-0.37992003560066223,
-0.030292868614196777,
-0.1742154359817505,
0.1718246340751648,
0.3942044973373413,
-0.2915681302547455,
1.1342124938964844,
-0.4758239984512329,
0.22528806328773499,
-0.40265390276908875,
0.633371889591217,
0.21014362573623657,
0.2505166530609131,
0.819465696811676,
-0.5271140933036804,
-0.5256127715110779,
-0.029444601386785507,
-0.5628522038459778,
-0.24488449096679688,
0.09814567118883133,
0.4119824767112732,
0.4294499158859253,
0.3459581136703491,
-0.43951472640037537,
0.4756074547767639,
0.5452868938446045,
-0.02361268363893032,
0.6662084460258484,
-0.5696319341659546,
-0.2248729020357132,
-0.8216524124145508,
0.16268470883369446,
-0.28338566422462463,
-0.02784394845366478,
-0.6650952100753784,
0.2812226116657257,
0.1162719577550888,
0.08434387296438217,
-0.2897213399410248,
0.5679160356521606,
-0.7933587431907654,
0.03502904251217842,
-0.6567479372024536,
0.43574732542037964,
-0.2269267588853836,
0.30416226387023926,
-0.20344693958759308,
0.6894816756248474,
0.3779803216457367,
-0.690650463104248,
-0.010076281614601612,
-0.0006299306987784803,
-0.41828465461730957,
-0.16616572439670563,
-0.5092273950576782,
0.48532938957214355,
-0.23845186829566956,
0.022128872573375702,
-0.7973818182945251,
-0.21696233749389648,
0.050824906677007675,
-0.6027222275733948,
0.25243496894836426,
-0.30361390113830566,
-0.6755228638648987,
-0.4913734197616577,
-0.4092642366886139,
0.24493329226970673,
0.5230770707130432,
-0.2592700123786926,
0.17843082547187805,
0.2963348627090454,
-0.1867285966873169,
-0.41041266918182373,
-0.7654774785041809,
0.2731609344482422,
-0.16184797883033752,
-0.46484196186065674,
0.43721193075180054,
-0.13160014152526855,
-0.15880344808101654,
0.1067647859454155,
-0.09545733034610748,
-0.022714650258421898,
0.35298940539360046,
0.09791918098926544,
0.0005732226418331265,
-0.08957776427268982,
0.16381098330020905,
-0.09970744699239731,
0.055681951344013214,
0.11248648911714554,
-0.389640748500824,
0.9126099348068237,
-0.22809451818466187,
-0.13669778406620026,
0.08546393364667892,
0.3357015550136566,
0.30917853116989136,
0.0020628743804991245,
0.8106009364128113,
0.8249086737632751,
-0.14175865054130554,
-0.2415773719549179,
-0.28316619992256165,
-0.08537718653678894,
-0.45645150542259216,
0.5418916344642639,
-0.28840458393096924,
-0.5412569046020508,
0.3147681653499603,
0.18722426891326904,
-0.10711575299501419,
0.48893988132476807,
0.7722072601318359,
0.18845833837985992,
0.8859653472900391,
0.7309466600418091,
0.13459165394306183,
0.5430219769477844,
-0.19820499420166016,
0.2965829372406006,
-0.453940212726593,
-0.05393964797258377,
-0.5262137055397034,
-0.23917913436889648,
-0.9643046855926514,
-0.24745652079582214,
0.2944128215312958,
0.14007429778575897,
0.0876956433057785,
0.0738498792052269,
-0.33171501755714417,
0.4373020529747009,
0.8228315711021423,
-0.15530097484588623,
0.27451515197753906,
0.04550686106085777,
-0.4284707009792328,
0.09217704832553864,
-0.9902202486991882,
-0.7788180112838745,
1.4353467226028442,
0.3066202700138092,
0.8209579586982727,
0.23864386975765228,
1.1659518480300903,
0.1481970250606537,
0.286300927400589,
-0.7622191905975342,
0.5885964035987854,
-0.38219600915908813,
-0.5358320474624634,
-0.23213762044906616,
-0.8643478155136108,
-1.0857346057891846,
-0.08527704328298569,
-0.3342554271221161,
-0.7053875923156738,
-0.06858702749013901,
0.002525497693568468,
0.012938106432557106,
0.312368243932724,
-0.662021279335022,
0.5921685695648193,
-0.22494471073150635,
-0.2566748261451721,
-0.08266328275203705,
-0.5055667757987976,
0.3922979533672333,
-0.07825470715761185,
0.1570085734128952,
-0.19663693010807037,
0.20284555852413177,
0.6054285168647766,
-0.4414138197898865,
0.5900669693946838,
0.032768238335847855,
-0.3721426725387573,
0.3757261633872986,
0.03478025272488594,
0.4247225224971771,
0.1134423241019249,
0.0622241385281086,
0.05127885937690735,
0.013485409319400787,
-0.3548271059989929,
-0.3080155551433563,
0.7450714707374573,
-0.5756948590278625,
-0.5888892412185669,
-0.6542901396751404,
-0.8492245078086853,
0.034081775695085526,
0.4547189772129059,
0.4647139608860016,
0.5172159075737,
-0.42016345262527466,
0.41711530089378357,
0.5522550940513611,
-0.5234055519104004,
0.5676074028015137,
0.5614449381828308,
-0.246425062417984,
-0.16367411613464355,
1.10830557346344,
0.20564676821231842,
0.4816420376300812,
0.32855460047721863,
0.4946923851966858,
-0.0974763035774231,
-0.8751996159553528,
-0.653072714805603,
0.11495053768157959,
-0.63411945104599,
0.14216546714305878,
-0.7768458127975464,
-0.3491778075695038,
-0.26546862721443176,
0.2927200198173523,
-0.08380719274282455,
-0.4669787585735321,
-0.24202083051204681,
0.25910380482673645,
0.5190795660018921,
0.9329548478126526,
-0.05275948345661163,
0.3223414421081543,
-0.9847912788391113,
0.172959104180336,
0.10271681845188141,
0.33644646406173706,
0.11798423528671265,
-0.5035329461097717,
-0.4665006995201111,
0.2435581237077713,
-0.27810606360435486,
-1.1082475185394287,
0.3835197389125824,
0.282667875289917,
0.620366632938385,
0.4264681041240692,
0.16341547667980194,
0.029682662338018417,
-0.5545358657836914,
0.692931592464447,
-0.08612959831953049,
-0.6813956499099731,
-0.027003634721040726,
-0.7788349390029907,
0.4279405176639557,
0.3764362037181854,
0.24445967376232147,
-0.4099147617816925,
-0.6632343530654907,
-0.8119083642959595,
-1.0524073839187622,
0.588084876537323,
0.2530199885368347,
0.4888642728328705,
-0.4488667845726013,
0.2395797073841095,
0.08308803290128708,
0.31033021211624146,
-0.6502582430839539,
-0.48687174916267395,
0.07606606185436249,
-0.32516545057296753,
-0.0033344279509037733,
-0.5588119029998779,
0.12402891367673874,
0.18610283732414246,
0.4998437166213989,
-0.13809674978256226,
0.202882781624794,
0.034231241792440414,
-0.1757909506559372,
0.11140083521604538,
0.40569499135017395,
0.6705585718154907,
0.26190727949142456,
-0.5087428092956543,
0.1475909799337387,
0.04096393659710884,
-0.8477710485458374,
0.11345075070858002,
-0.019509177654981613,
-0.3626803755760193,
0.49698153138160706,
0.19374202191829681,
0.754289984703064,
0.3544507622718811,
-0.7480342984199524,
0.3357635736465454,
-0.15292008221149445,
-0.46198195219039917,
-0.32033511996269226,
0.27583250403404236,
0.27526935935020447,
-0.21913132071495056,
0.5853003859519958,
-0.2308642566204071,
0.2647057771682739,
-0.7073113322257996,
0.02573447860777378,
0.4999125897884369,
0.30442842841148376,
-0.1297464519739151,
0.4073268175125122,
-0.0371081605553627,
-0.2836652100086212,
0.42812785506248474,
-0.8183724284172058,
-0.3537234961986542,
0.5671282410621643,
0.6975458264350891,
0.8881479501724243,
0.2837519943714142,
0.27873149514198303,
0.2924727201461792,
0.257790207862854,
-0.014765636995434761,
0.25406238436698914,
0.20464931428432465,
-0.5360088348388672,
-0.07797165215015411,
-0.7280842065811157,
-0.30387377738952637,
0.3125079274177551,
-0.6259486675262451,
0.3766731917858124,
-0.2997729778289795,
-0.21344579756259918,
-0.1481548696756363,
0.06861283630132675,
-0.4627276062965393,
0.17385415732860565,
0.16022583842277527,
0.8177226185798645,
-0.6070495247840881,
0.8289459943771362,
0.5860840082168579,
-0.47748059034347534,
-0.670852541923523,
0.33580735325813293,
-0.17686507105827332,
-0.5421932935714722,
0.573467493057251,
0.1817227005958557,
-0.16592265665531158,
0.14153291285037994,
-0.24335412681102753,
-0.9186999201774597,
0.8606770038604736,
0.2458629161119461,
-0.6718953847885132,
-0.2727236747741699,
0.20324257016181946,
0.698065996170044,
-0.04973256215453148,
0.2138851284980774,
0.4987391531467438,
0.24010063707828522,
-0.03374211862683296,
-0.7687165141105652,
-0.31928732991218567,
-0.5959271192550659,
0.10441556572914124,
0.3526845872402191,
-0.3677174150943756,
1.3503713607788086,
-0.4013749063014984,
-0.530927836894989,
0.414081871509552,
0.2270076423883438,
0.3292262554168701,
0.31689825654029846,
0.2341013103723526,
0.5503718256950378,
0.736007809638977,
-0.0037526916712522507,
1.0828946828842163,
-0.4184711277484894,
0.3669894337654114,
1.0878028869628906,
-0.07532458752393723,
0.7380349040031433,
0.3733808696269989,
-0.017502374947071075,
0.6879500150680542,
0.48953089118003845,
-0.030965683981776237,
0.3701249957084656,
0.649685800075531,
-0.32514283061027527,
0.028589516878128052,
0.230033740401268,
-0.5580087304115295,
0.5591607093811035,
0.05797621235251427,
-0.4661801755428314,
-0.3871743679046631,
-0.2748523950576782,
0.11693113297224045,
0.10645220428705215,
-0.08636239916086197,
0.7780356407165527,
0.018990695476531982,
-0.24732953310012817,
0.9002779722213745,
0.3874218463897705,
0.7118977904319763,
-0.5633909702301025,
0.19226253032684326,
-0.33447518944740295,
0.231105774641037,
-0.06934693455696106,
-0.41179484128952026,
0.11263084411621094,
0.2330501675605774,
-0.40070223808288574,
0.14919567108154297,
0.5824822783470154,
-0.5793787240982056,
-0.44957810640335083,
0.0033318395726382732,
0.4292910099029541,
0.40918904542922974,
0.05582359433174133,
-0.167229562997818,
-0.10440385341644287,
-0.29195985198020935,
-0.2894217073917389,
0.6178752779960632,
0.7098492383956909,
-0.10573244094848633,
0.6845871210098267,
0.736950695514679,
0.19555217027664185,
0.2515850365161896,
0.05999422445893288,
0.7291613817214966,
-0.7045825719833374,
-0.5896818041801453,
-0.8167165517807007,
0.09120826423168182,
-0.015546206384897232,
-0.3253965377807617,
1.0660842657089233,
0.4810003638267517,
0.8234533071517944,
-0.38475531339645386,
1.066537618637085,
-0.23566147685050964,
0.4642959237098694,
-0.7025511860847473,
0.9148135781288147,
-0.6581724286079407,
0.13872721791267395,
-0.4564692974090576,
-0.6866670846939087,
0.10657548904418945,
0.4588541090488434,
-0.4476073682308197,
0.23120513558387756,
0.7346181273460388,
0.6697568297386169,
0.1444317251443863,
-0.05438278988003731,
0.28696924448013306,
0.16445019841194153,
0.21993273496627808,
0.5814247131347656,
0.9003645181655884,
-0.4293232858181,
0.6149260997772217,
0.10658901184797287,
-0.011739631183445454,
-0.4919409155845642,
-1.0704864263534546,
-0.7967767119407654,
-0.438262015581131,
-0.0359407514333725,
-0.17257100343704224,
-0.15405961871147156,
0.7542625069618225,
0.22390860319137573,
-0.5500518083572388,
-0.0506725050508976,
-0.49169403314590454,
-0.13592013716697693,
-0.03408031165599823,
-0.2234075963497162,
0.08480540663003922,
-0.5270379781723022,
-0.757167637348175,
0.4658215343952179,
0.06971634179353714,
0.2839249074459076,
-0.3133164942264557,
-0.10430099815130234,
-0.21246841549873352,
0.010848243720829487,
0.21922922134399414,
0.0969037190079689,
-0.5511952042579651,
-0.1983393430709839,
0.1936406046152115,
-0.30941271781921387,
-0.08559540659189224,
0.8437578082084656,
-0.7838644981384277,
0.40371066331863403,
0.5388229489326477,
0.5467367768287659,
0.33658862113952637,
-0.3575967848300934,
0.7525603771209717,
-0.8199548125267029,
0.3006584048271179,
0.15064439177513123,
0.16717536747455597,
0.374595046043396,
-0.08642347902059555,
0.21297454833984375,
0.3773001730442047,
-0.47689542174339294,
-1.0582990646362305,
0.19182057678699493,
-0.5181291103363037,
-0.3352634906768799,
1.2899247407913208,
-0.17815402150154114,
-0.17186369001865387,
-0.10164390504360199,
-0.15387417376041412,
0.30218425393104553,
-0.0860992893576622,
0.9341716170310974,
0.7335343956947327,
0.3800705075263977,
0.061487775295972824,
-0.5703747272491455,
0.6011965870857239,
0.3350672125816345,
-0.6041851043701172,
0.03804081305861473,
0.3477298319339752,
0.6355170607566833,
0.19427187740802765,
0.5247875452041626,
-0.12862533330917358,
0.4296308755874634,
0.4347471296787262,
0.24605703353881836,
-0.2912432849407196,
-0.368644654750824,
-0.17914068698883057,
0.12968817353248596,
0.500266969203949,
-0.08288874477148056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13050v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13050v1 | Think-then-Act: A Dual-Angle Evaluated Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-06-18T20:51:34 | 2024-06-18T20:51:34 | Yige Shen, Hao Jiang, Hua Qu, Jihong Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite their impressive capabilities, large language models (LLMs) often
face challenges such as temporal misalignment and generating hallucinatory
content. Enhancing LLMs with retrieval mechanisms to fetch relevant information
from external sources offers a promising solution. Inspired by the proverb
"Think twice before you act," we propose a dual-angle evaluated
retrieval-augmented generation framework \textit{Think-then-Act}. Unlike
previous approaches that indiscriminately rewrite queries or perform retrieval
regardless of necessity, or generate temporary responses before deciding on
additional retrieval, which increases model generation costs, our framework
employs a two-phase process: (i) assessing the input query for clarity and
completeness to determine if rewriting is necessary; and (ii) evaluating the
model's capability to answer the query and deciding if additional retrieval is
needed. Experimental results on five datasets show that the
\textit{Think-then-Act} framework significantly improves performance. Our
framework demonstrates notable improvements in accuracy and efficiency compared
to existing baselines and performs well in both English and non-English
contexts. Ablation studies validate the optimal model confidence threshold,
highlighting the resource optimization benefits of our approach. | [
-0.27532723546028137,
-0.8059588074684143,
0.5276862978935242,
0.09327472746372223,
-0.21747660636901855,
0.21657155454158783,
-0.06821565330028534,
-0.5232149958610535,
0.24807551503181458,
0.5859169363975525,
-0.6496877074241638,
0.21984921395778656,
-0.21162593364715576,
-0.05646137520670891,
-0.39821213483810425,
0.569448709487915,
-0.018275519832968712,
0.3894173502922058,
-0.05127697438001633,
0.03471687436103821,
-0.4668195843696594,
-0.14020583033561707,
-1.143031358718872,
-0.3400864005088806,
0.3018508851528168,
0.3230888247489929,
0.7788844704627991,
0.10907957702875137,
0.5280288457870483,
0.32562756538391113,
0.24620495736598969,
0.41378021240234375,
-0.4269940257072449,
0.2542349696159363,
-0.3497470021247864,
-0.7727755904197693,
-0.3138342797756195,
-0.008420060388743877,
0.6360230445861816,
0.4598742425441742,
-0.24841190874576569,
0.3502415418624878,
-0.06321384012699127,
0.8537588715553284,
-0.5666704177856445,
-0.10435369610786438,
-0.6174601912498474,
0.023497363552451134,
-0.037608612328767776,
-0.3005361258983612,
-0.42310798168182373,
-0.49874696135520935,
0.06051120534539223,
-0.34948253631591797,
0.1342589259147644,
0.39580661058425903,
0.5154613256454468,
0.027294252067804337,
-0.42472296953201294,
-0.005604040343314409,
-0.6903893351554871,
0.6017125248908997,
-0.55619877576828,
0.5385807156562805,
0.027132326737046242,
0.22298677265644073,
-0.36292946338653564,
-1.1358717679977417,
-0.9719595909118652,
-0.33665895462036133,
0.04562866687774658,
-0.12750878930091858,
-0.10601305961608887,
-0.07428247481584549,
0.2369624376296997,
0.3598485589027405,
-0.644750714302063,
-0.2509513199329376,
-0.22492335736751556,
-0.205624520778656,
0.7124978303909302,
-0.09680414944887161,
0.25705409049987793,
-0.18301263451576233,
-0.6015658974647522,
-0.2692869305610657,
-0.7804214954376221,
0.05052553117275238,
0.35443657636642456,
0.4167332351207733,
0.3438870906829834,
0.9307348132133484,
0.05234231799840927,
0.2734508216381073,
0.37805190682411194,
0.2816336750984192,
0.01751790940761566,
-0.5851626396179199,
-0.21821697056293488,
-0.10524292290210724,
0.7699300646781921,
0.16972920298576355,
0.24374040961265564,
0.03302650526165962,
-0.40301525592803955,
0.06026408076286316,
0.6466834545135498,
-0.6796205639839172,
-0.03899700567126274,
0.4015358090400696,
-0.306747704744339,
-0.177587628364563,
-0.12946370244026184,
-0.7256126403808594,
-0.3327479362487793,
-0.49447908997535706,
0.8513928651809692,
-0.4171321988105774,
-0.7400851845741272,
-0.028698505833745003,
0.11841031908988953,
0.060586124658584595,
-0.18948478996753693,
-0.5374852418899536,
0.28751078248023987,
0.8949731588363647,
0.6508027911186218,
0.0631093680858612,
-0.1647517830133438,
-0.6990682482719421,
-0.15260283648967743,
-0.5805328488349915,
0.9354831576347351,
-0.5737727880477905,
-0.49107104539871216,
0.24239277839660645,
-0.27659136056900024,
0.17273707687854767,
-0.4898928701877594,
0.4832620620727539,
-0.9918418526649475,
0.37502020597457886,
-0.5008878111839294,
-0.3364720642566681,
-0.043496184051036835,
0.17020395398139954,
-0.6551850438117981,
1.4632399082183838,
0.05082487314939499,
-0.6525300741195679,
0.792197048664093,
-0.6179215908050537,
-0.6144158244132996,
0.22930830717086792,
-0.3253866732120514,
-0.2922738492488861,
0.3285485506057739,
-0.027430841699242592,
0.03831322491168976,
-0.29610034823417664,
0.30886489152908325,
-0.28125253319740295,
-0.02365909330546856,
0.318952351808548,
-0.18893510103225708,
0.5878617763519287,
-0.037757184356451035,
-0.5247210264205933,
0.0810217335820198,
-0.5290623307228088,
0.7030380368232727,
0.28789299726486206,
-0.3231825828552246,
-0.33336496353149414,
0.0440010130405426,
-0.1908954530954361,
0.4497033357620239,
0.24128615856170654,
-0.5665717720985413,
0.14565224945545197,
-0.6668521165847778,
0.04666706547141075,
0.6718905568122864,
0.019307684153318405,
0.4182170033454895,
-0.3492336869239807,
0.587261438369751,
-0.2316475659608841,
0.015425311401486397,
0.17865388095378876,
-0.28226107358932495,
-0.8659064769744873,
0.2593739628791809,
-0.09320595115423203,
0.5142052173614502,
-1.278783917427063,
0.11240755766630173,
-0.2774030566215515,
-0.22321195900440216,
-0.6636092066764832,
0.26821058988571167,
0.8234607577323914,
0.5218519568443298,
0.4000130593776703,
-0.30145955085754395,
-0.8036921620368958,
-0.8540975451469421,
-0.615253746509552,
-0.6847430467605591,
0.36805644631385803,
0.14483313262462616,
0.4332917034626007,
0.1695469170808792,
0.8320543766021729,
-0.5353682637214661,
-0.0706186518073082,
-0.4618174731731415,
0.5106230974197388,
-0.19868285953998566,
0.12555748224258423,
0.13278384506702423,
-1.2439930438995361,
-0.31043198704719543,
-0.33303576707839966,
-0.349691241979599,
-0.20723047852516174,
-0.08312997967004776,
-0.5165003538131714,
0.4485623836517334,
0.44573861360549927,
-0.7592960000038147,
0.10836458206176758,
0.146293506026268,
-0.46268418431282043,
0.48741090297698975,
-0.3186667859554291,
0.2702154517173767,
-1.0458592176437378,
0.07284516841173172,
-0.3458346128463745,
-0.20937445759773254,
-0.5183858275413513,
0.2254926711320877,
0.21227356791496277,
0.05625450238585472,
-0.45383477210998535,
0.681046724319458,
-0.5225827693939209,
-0.12814678251743317,
-0.5793065428733826,
0.16631759703159332,
0.2174273282289505,
0.2901114821434021,
0.06336647272109985,
1.2008036375045776,
0.18749713897705078,
-0.817042350769043,
0.03211770951747894,
0.04050813615322113,
-0.5873433947563171,
0.7387803196907043,
-0.3119308352470398,
0.4215828478336334,
-0.20702378451824188,
0.12741202116012573,
-0.8985795974731445,
-0.13574138283729553,
0.07463174313306808,
-0.26235926151275635,
0.7257338166236877,
0.22648507356643677,
-0.5303022861480713,
-0.80341637134552,
-0.3919820487499237,
0.34761884808540344,
0.248224675655365,
-0.64069002866745,
0.750173032283783,
0.6360183358192444,
-0.22479894757270813,
-0.9456264972686768,
-0.6842268109321594,
0.04744461178779602,
0.005827315617352724,
-0.753226637840271,
0.37780898809432983,
-0.3056538999080658,
-0.44628018140792847,
-0.055286213755607605,
-0.10422862321138382,
0.1440701186656952,
-0.06545601785182953,
-0.04193505272269249,
0.077536940574646,
-0.1570056974887848,
0.17059138417243958,
0.1678062528371811,
-0.0608799010515213,
0.13454988598823547,
-0.5480563044548035,
0.6886955499649048,
-0.03229207918047905,
-0.29154160618782043,
-0.3159222900867462,
0.5824140906333923,
0.39158201217651367,
-0.45892587304115295,
0.4849022924900055,
0.5024995803833008,
-0.3281390368938446,
-0.3691521883010864,
-0.7895926833152771,
-0.24640579521656036,
-0.5172802805900574,
0.5292124152183533,
-0.4687733054161072,
-0.527597188949585,
-0.04391009733080864,
0.09793725609779358,
0.4007050096988678,
0.14927470684051514,
0.689227819442749,
-0.30370721220970154,
1.0254836082458496,
0.7144970893859863,
0.45286616683006287,
0.6645956635475159,
-0.23814526200294495,
0.6005016565322876,
-0.8414480686187744,
-0.5217424631118774,
-0.13067007064819336,
-0.376314640045166,
-0.29157865047454834,
-0.6745624542236328,
0.39569827914237976,
0.0833284929394722,
-0.17176653444766998,
0.32389897108078003,
-0.10292957723140717,
0.2175241857767105,
0.45331326127052307,
0.14965415000915527,
0.16368883848190308,
-0.042724043130874634,
-0.14179684221744537,
-0.019635584205389023,
-0.37329357862472534,
-0.4780796468257904,
1.3507634401321411,
-0.13771305978298187,
0.3055857717990875,
0.531838595867157,
0.6509273648262024,
0.42120230197906494,
0.5384910106658936,
-0.8606732487678528,
0.8607639670372009,
0.04938309267163277,
-0.8440477848052979,
-0.23406259715557098,
-0.3616490066051483,
-0.8849477171897888,
0.5398463606834412,
-0.2604648470878601,
-0.3751565217971802,
0.10019772499799728,
0.27213624119758606,
-0.6006256937980652,
0.28425300121307373,
-0.7989409565925598,
0.22850751876831055,
-0.6313571929931641,
-0.7474117279052734,
-0.4724482297897339,
-0.3371812105178833,
0.46872222423553467,
-0.3254818022251129,
0.26817893981933594,
0.011985160410404205,
-0.38344520330429077,
0.6583073735237122,
-0.31463971734046936,
0.4237890839576721,
-0.3288560211658478,
-0.03171151503920555,
0.6642454862594604,
0.45695608854293823,
0.6445392966270447,
0.03681076318025589,
-0.2424178272485733,
-0.3150462508201599,
-0.041727785021066666,
-0.033469539135694504,
-0.774933934211731,
0.5549584627151489,
-0.30835703015327454,
-0.9115606546401978,
-0.32647836208343506,
-0.39706656336784363,
-0.3363534212112427,
0.5888421535491943,
0.17612604796886444,
0.39620834589004517,
-0.442142516374588,
-0.1036384180188179,
0.3710920810699463,
0.3469395339488983,
0.5064799189567566,
0.8545078635215759,
-0.5262622833251953,
-0.44904443621635437,
0.4940722584724426,
0.18469879031181335,
0.4315776824951172,
0.4717206656932831,
0.12053535133600235,
-0.6928678154945374,
-0.3646409809589386,
-0.26205867528915405,
0.31782278418540955,
-0.32824403047561646,
-0.2920389175415039,
-0.7429165840148926,
0.0824953019618988,
-0.5559369325637817,
0.25978511571884155,
-0.5049195885658264,
-0.4731855094432831,
0.14996933937072754,
-0.17400361597537994,
-0.009620859287679195,
0.4152352213859558,
-0.34366461634635925,
0.1134147197008133,
-0.3840712904930115,
0.519039511680603,
0.3652198314666748,
0.1618185043334961,
-0.1446235179901123,
-0.5083457827568054,
-0.062231842428445816,
0.15534918010234833,
-0.3530406057834625,
-0.6518886685371399,
0.26194724440574646,
0.3019527494907379,
0.4746658205986023,
0.23508836328983307,
-0.0014376732287928462,
0.6138777732849121,
-0.7326762676239014,
0.6818569302558899,
0.10654234886169434,
-0.753915548324585,
0.4237595200538635,
0.12423547357320786,
-0.09530143439769745,
0.7214279770851135,
0.1166435182094574,
-0.18697598576545715,
-0.06971507519483566,
-0.6306888461112976,
-0.878058671951294,
0.7032933235168457,
0.2292729616165161,
0.36231690645217896,
-0.05604121461510658,
0.4425199031829834,
-0.01196256559342146,
0.44504278898239136,
-0.6178252696990967,
-0.14929571747779846,
0.20893678069114685,
0.11895614117383957,
0.023180454969406128,
-0.6662399768829346,
-0.13648785650730133,
0.1666901558637619,
0.8798169493675232,
-0.17032591998577118,
0.339368611574173,
0.1511734127998352,
-0.14676077663898468,
-0.475227952003479,
0.34569162130355835,
0.39005494117736816,
0.6414469480514526,
-0.07614509016275406,
0.1660715788602829,
0.041506100445985794,
-0.4331488013267517,
0.23663868010044098,
-0.10054332762956619,
-0.1318807154893875,
-0.30506232380867004,
0.20208337903022766,
0.553530216217041,
0.3498782217502594,
-0.6331207752227783,
0.5416103601455688,
-0.014812083914875984,
0.07888206839561462,
-0.6108975410461426,
0.2953146994113922,
-0.08905544877052307,
0.6159011125564575,
0.19480738043785095,
0.13977067172527313,
0.19974656403064728,
-0.7000819444656372,
0.3448529541492462,
0.5314018726348877,
-0.09780286997556686,
-0.3379860520362854,
0.582986056804657,
0.04108887538313866,
-0.7355796694755554,
0.4853736162185669,
-0.34415432810783386,
-0.556039035320282,
0.3628746271133423,
0.7474277019500732,
1.0556637048721313,
-0.4339115619659424,
0.34424445033073425,
0.42797863483428955,
0.32500171661376953,
-0.4233604073524475,
1.0873810052871704,
-0.06507934629917145,
-0.7551319003105164,
-0.36797869205474854,
-0.5120071172714233,
-0.14977501332759857,
0.06323707103729248,
-0.8687999248504639,
0.42914968729019165,
-0.2880406975746155,
-0.7091506719589233,
-0.29203709959983826,
0.3266063332557678,
-0.7636227607727051,
0.31121915578842163,
0.2598037123680115,
0.9479443430900574,
-0.6154149174690247,
0.6244274973869324,
0.7019112706184387,
-0.33138179779052734,
-0.7272263765335083,
0.21413564682006836,
0.11628532409667969,
-0.9388263821601868,
0.4771006405353546,
0.0746787041425705,
-0.6902235746383667,
-0.027958931401371956,
-0.2517538368701935,
-1.2093671560287476,
1.0695587396621704,
0.3104681074619293,
-0.5716058611869812,
-0.1055854856967926,
-0.013945561833679676,
0.6498153209686279,
-0.4569404423236847,
0.2705554664134979,
0.7893708348274231,
0.41538727283477783,
0.13301530480384827,
-0.6102534532546997,
0.06846722960472107,
-0.23783397674560547,
-0.06316890567541122,
0.4084569811820984,
-0.8182454109191895,
0.8172081708908081,
-0.692933201789856,
-0.5595802664756775,
0.10418157279491425,
0.9514249563217163,
0.2812082767486572,
0.2981100380420685,
0.6932888031005859,
0.43353232741355896,
1.0382981300354004,
0.18510021269321442,
1.1954963207244873,
-0.29466336965560913,
0.01422545313835144,
1.4085718393325806,
-0.4041484594345093,
1.3523054122924805,
0.606660783290863,
-0.26644957065582275,
0.6228768229484558,
0.272182822227478,
0.45643892884254456,
0.6045716404914856,
0.005672791972756386,
-0.2919048070907593,
-0.38022372126579285,
-0.2450065165758133,
-0.3651879131793976,
0.4535510540008545,
0.40888363122940063,
-0.19794286787509918,
0.0354347750544548,
-0.10587979853153229,
0.22384271025657654,
0.147099107503891,
-0.2460024654865265,
0.5592433214187622,
0.3288624584674835,
-1.1078766584396362,
0.21921758353710175,
-0.11041438579559326,
0.24860699474811554,
-0.5801052451133728,
0.10847152769565582,
-0.17104105651378632,
0.2346249371767044,
-0.10754560679197311,
-0.9604657292366028,
0.22440272569656372,
0.0046492996625602245,
-0.39556947350502014,
-0.3756815195083618,
0.4217400550842285,
-0.5750853419303894,
-0.7828131914138794,
0.5688849687576294,
0.502040445804596,
-0.012156013399362564,
0.01212651189416647,
-0.9463366866111755,
-0.19177313148975372,
0.16434785723686218,
-0.48969566822052,
0.015942221507430077,
0.23834766447544098,
-0.11269447207450867,
0.7178866267204285,
0.6864837408065796,
0.2407083809375763,
0.07516857981681824,
0.2370811253786087,
0.7609165906906128,
-0.3392201066017151,
-0.4544192850589752,
-0.5772719979286194,
0.6534398198127747,
-0.15986908972263336,
-0.11253975331783295,
0.2963966429233551,
0.5555179715156555,
0.8683853149414062,
0.4137274920940399,
0.693422257900238,
-0.15886381268501282,
0.7054235339164734,
-0.7428383231163025,
0.5776476263999939,
-0.9262074828147888,
0.24427378177642822,
-0.020163055509328842,
-0.9482539892196655,
-0.12347286194562912,
0.19897127151489258,
-0.599054217338562,
0.4215241074562073,
0.9251142740249634,
1.121104121208191,
0.054323263466358185,
0.06530758738517761,
0.16983285546302795,
0.33524537086486816,
0.336220920085907,
0.46664664149284363,
0.7485331892967224,
-0.4228615462779999,
0.6288506388664246,
-0.2528896629810333,
-0.12343939393758774,
-0.10747635364532471,
-0.6527146100997925,
-0.6749975681304932,
-0.5840275883674622,
-0.353881299495697,
-0.6498082280158997,
-0.32146933674812317,
1.0596753358840942,
0.5718730688095093,
-0.8035781979560852,
-0.019967615604400635,
0.08311954885721207,
-0.10087652504444122,
-0.19673871994018555,
-0.18852731585502625,
0.42531707882881165,
-0.4602262079715729,
-0.6251357197761536,
0.7494349479675293,
0.2207091748714447,
-0.16504830121994019,
-0.4259328544139862,
0.1085510328412056,
-0.38120102882385254,
0.5124363899230957,
0.49138057231903076,
0.40842217206954956,
-0.6658849120140076,
-0.24266858398914337,
-0.003679388202726841,
-0.20070742070674896,
0.05122584104537964,
1.198156476020813,
-0.8163188099861145,
1.0042717456817627,
0.5071362257003784,
0.39850568771362305,
0.24729426205158234,
0.13599400222301483,
0.7813413143157959,
-0.3871794044971466,
0.06815948337316513,
0.3523414731025696,
0.34534263610839844,
0.3620329797267914,
-0.586610734462738,
0.2684803009033203,
-0.07255906611680984,
-0.20148396492004395,
-0.8157249689102173,
0.47620484232902527,
-0.4937096834182739,
-0.0905410423874855,
1.0313446521759033,
0.035841889679431915,
-0.08963261544704437,
-0.020170575007796288,
-0.25524574518203735,
0.3513883352279663,
-0.22501865029335022,
0.8216302990913391,
0.46108800172805786,
-0.2872820496559143,
0.040418561547994614,
-0.3416960537433624,
0.5468392968177795,
0.7984034419059753,
-0.6407308578491211,
-0.04510549083352089,
0.3220135271549225,
0.09999800473451614,
0.22067154943943024,
0.8082429766654968,
-0.23636393249034882,
0.15341466665267944,
0.03397311270236969,
0.027177803218364716,
-0.13984522223472595,
-0.5856289267539978,
-0.13847316801548004,
0.26507213711738586,
0.08047401905059814,
-0.0022109681740403175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13035v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13035v2 | D2O: Dynamic Discriminative Operations for Efficient Generative Inference of Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T20:01:51 | 2024-06-23T08:27:48 | Zhongwei Wan, Xinjian Wu, Yu Zhang, Yi Xin, Chaofan Tao, Zhihong Zhu, Xin Wang, Siqi Luo, Jing Xiong, Mi Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Efficient inference in Large Language Models (LLMs) is impeded by the growing
memory demands of key-value (KV) caching, especially for longer sequences.
Traditional KV cache eviction strategies, which prioritize less critical
KV-pairs based on attention scores, often degrade generation quality, leading
to issues such as context loss or hallucinations. To address this, we introduce
Dynamic Discriminative Operations (D2O), a novel method that utilizes two-level
discriminative strategies to optimize KV cache size without fine-tuning, while
preserving essential context. Initially, by observing varying densities of
attention weights between shallow and deep layers, we use this insight to
determine which layers should avoid excessive eviction to minimize information
loss. Subsequently, for the eviction strategy in each layer, D2O innovatively
incorporates a compensation mechanism that maintains a similarity threshold to
re-discriminate the importance of previously discarded tokens, determining
whether they should be recalled and merged with similar tokens. Our approach
not only achieves significant memory savings and enhances inference throughput
by more than 3 times but also maintains high-quality long-text generation.
Extensive experiments across various benchmarks and LLM architectures have
demonstrated that D2O significantly enhances performance with a constrained KV
cache budget. | [
-0.06156783178448677,
-0.7676958441734314,
0.6128832101821899,
0.22341874241828918,
-0.3617529273033142,
0.2747589647769928,
-0.170854389667511,
-0.2762143313884735,
-0.23620302975177765,
0.4279535114765167,
-0.41583380103111267,
-0.471330851316452,
-0.45592570304870605,
-0.3193102478981018,
-0.33336639404296875,
0.4387402832508087,
0.026101943105459213,
-0.18351420760154724,
-0.3403370678424835,
0.033427007496356964,
-0.4741939306259155,
-0.17211180925369263,
-0.8354973196983337,
-0.24123358726501465,
0.5033987164497375,
0.4807087481021881,
0.555388331413269,
0.9802944660186768,
0.357627809047699,
0.29985862970352173,
-0.29709160327911377,
0.45527467131614685,
-0.7728150486946106,
0.4391324818134308,
0.053096506744623184,
-0.6945086121559143,
-0.39384162425994873,
-0.09189962595701218,
0.7625512480735779,
0.5307896733283997,
-0.45139938592910767,
-0.07011142373085022,
-0.19209718704223633,
0.9411714673042297,
-0.9298757314682007,
0.246773824095726,
-1.0161737203598022,
0.2782655358314514,
-0.15031352639198303,
-0.10434738546609879,
-0.5808449387550354,
-0.215767040848732,
-0.05628368631005287,
-0.5859105587005615,
0.22764664888381958,
-0.14954739809036255,
0.6331861019134521,
0.7166297435760498,
-0.41762179136276245,
-0.2012995481491089,
-0.846991777420044,
0.7814598083496094,
-0.4745398759841919,
0.3500792980194092,
0.25999388098716736,
0.179759219288826,
-0.29686081409454346,
-0.6251547932624817,
-0.8236085176467896,
-0.05857102945446968,
0.13538797199726105,
0.2894366979598999,
-0.05318336933851242,
0.12858788669109344,
0.3289620876312256,
0.43501755595207214,
-0.10151003301143646,
0.5220999121665955,
0.00841306522488594,
0.016515769064426422,
0.5217100381851196,
0.09870906919240952,
0.09017463028430939,
0.26754528284072876,
-0.39457595348358154,
-0.2826250493526459,
-0.8548581004142761,
-0.22333869338035583,
0.4632434844970703,
-0.0015767492586746812,
-0.050193071365356445,
0.21361446380615234,
-0.062142323702573776,
0.3724037706851959,
0.36077338457107544,
-0.12313974648714066,
0.2342858910560608,
0.03723332658410072,
-0.06727377325296402,
0.2971724569797516,
0.5222786068916321,
0.3987446129322052,
0.042139261960983276,
-0.26881635189056396,
-0.26773807406425476,
0.05697868391871452,
0.17499616742134094,
-0.9152201414108276,
-0.22441409528255463,
0.3225198984146118,
-0.3161526024341583,
-0.5230787396430969,
-0.2133217751979828,
-1.1831601858139038,
-0.46089646220207214,
-0.1703152060508728,
0.012140324339270592,
-0.10811587423086166,
-0.37122833728790283,
0.14677344262599945,
-0.18341611325740814,
0.0007509736460633576,
0.5427889823913574,
-1.0354710817337036,
0.38370034098625183,
0.603326141834259,
0.6636472940444946,
-0.3925107717514038,
0.13779157400131226,
-0.8178433179855347,
0.40692171454429626,
-0.4656987190246582,
0.36030688881874084,
-0.624539852142334,
-0.1563214361667633,
0.07273595035076141,
-0.4019022583961487,
0.08859124779701233,
-0.9809110760688782,
0.3095300793647766,
-0.9610769152641296,
-0.1610858291387558,
-0.12360783666372299,
-0.43598806858062744,
0.19978338479995728,
-0.12960733473300934,
-0.8622477650642395,
1.4183077812194824,
0.22688104212284088,
-0.4909580647945404,
0.47015291452407837,
-0.33314236998558044,
-0.5276614427566528,
0.09061668813228607,
-0.10926491022109985,
-0.6443110704421997,
0.34723883867263794,
0.1085587739944458,
0.28408947587013245,
-0.311042457818985,
0.2394443154335022,
-0.2911483943462372,
-0.31854578852653503,
-0.04016149416565895,
-0.46760857105255127,
0.44204312562942505,
0.2109561711549759,
-0.6890996098518372,
-0.005109809339046478,
-0.9559696316719055,
-0.23779208958148956,
0.39321085810661316,
-0.4392830729484558,
-0.5654540657997131,
0.4608601927757263,
-0.3754933178424835,
0.15834571421146393,
0.258134126663208,
-0.5506439805030823,
0.3523619771003723,
-0.48619675636291504,
0.6002811789512634,
0.6516647338867188,
-0.20648911595344543,
0.5386511087417603,
0.2722261846065521,
0.3085123300552368,
0.18871691823005676,
0.01520362589508295,
0.08740769326686859,
-0.09837458282709122,
-1.0074383020401,
-0.5704951286315918,
0.124417744576931,
0.5660423040390015,
-0.6872259974479675,
0.516669511795044,
-0.33284133672714233,
-0.2503564655780792,
-0.5438358187675476,
0.1814645379781723,
0.4559553861618042,
0.3926168382167816,
0.14233523607254028,
0.03253824636340141,
-0.3021906018257141,
-0.8456713557243347,
0.20462743937969208,
-0.24250267446041107,
0.18616516888141632,
0.35484132170677185,
0.22861425578594208,
-0.16968365013599396,
0.6945398449897766,
-0.6556371450424194,
-0.06109979376196861,
0.03308332711458206,
0.16747882962226868,
-0.16894938051700592,
0.34535613656044006,
0.48945537209510803,
-0.7514435052871704,
-0.38814032077789307,
0.01619962602853775,
-0.5592944622039795,
-0.21630710363388062,
-0.22196805477142334,
-0.2372513860464096,
0.3523412048816681,
0.6257291436195374,
-0.8363499045372009,
0.2406620979309082,
0.5122137665748596,
0.13668739795684814,
0.17681674659252167,
-0.3318319320678711,
-0.1225082203745842,
-0.725300669670105,
-0.06568507850170135,
-0.49911728501319885,
-0.1362067312002182,
-0.4884469211101532,
0.23180165886878967,
0.13598959147930145,
-0.002219963585957885,
-0.35201311111450195,
0.7525330781936646,
-0.7045980095863342,
-0.12921728193759918,
-0.3045008182525635,
0.29400917887687683,
-0.03073113225400448,
0.25282570719718933,
-0.05175355449318886,
0.8996664881706238,
0.26305943727493286,
-0.5574826598167419,
0.4992228150367737,
0.11440423130989075,
-0.4265442192554474,
0.20435011386871338,
-0.33053749799728394,
0.5058119893074036,
-0.24038730561733246,
0.2942611873149872,
-1.2673628330230713,
0.026408016681671143,
0.0436355322599411,
-0.10223444551229477,
0.5787081718444824,
-0.08335264027118683,
-0.792325496673584,
-0.37013861536979675,
-0.39283862709999084,
0.5737902522087097,
0.5445465445518494,
-0.883285641670227,
0.4082289934158325,
0.4861065149307251,
-0.008312580175697803,
-0.5700770616531372,
-0.5269696712493896,
0.19108015298843384,
-0.4014240503311157,
-0.4551919400691986,
0.6440421938896179,
0.1359551101922989,
-0.2899097204208374,
-0.08209381252527237,
-0.29648712277412415,
-0.04229744151234627,
0.3203939199447632,
0.06994825601577759,
-0.04624871909618378,
0.006184724159538746,
0.31345662474632263,
0.532842755317688,
-0.12142646312713623,
-0.03221043571829796,
-0.138945534825325,
0.8052497506141663,
0.397930383682251,
-0.189935564994812,
-0.5310381650924683,
0.36566162109375,
0.8488137125968933,
-0.3413483798503876,
0.6666491031646729,
0.4820747971534729,
-0.2995361387729645,
-0.605500340461731,
-0.7743722200393677,
-0.23773735761642456,
-0.4998883903026581,
0.4860573410987854,
-0.489703506231308,
-0.8512117862701416,
0.5542764067649841,
-0.2642260193824768,
-0.002554885111749172,
0.39123833179473877,
0.7533341646194458,
-0.008023007772862911,
1.137424111366272,
0.0919850692152977,
-0.0930674746632576,
0.6185467839241028,
-0.19187502562999725,
0.28671351075172424,
-0.7291464805603027,
-0.2792145609855652,
-0.24823814630508423,
-0.28799504041671753,
-0.4479246139526367,
-0.6457526683807373,
0.14885078370571136,
0.24847297370433807,
-0.06000795215368271,
-0.06770813465118408,
-0.538422703742981,
0.2918168902397156,
0.5096217393875122,
0.20229209959506989,
0.07111316919326782,
0.30452093482017517,
-0.12718872725963593,
0.05934379622340202,
-0.5660683512687683,
-0.19453337788581848,
0.8016765713691711,
0.3691517114639282,
0.79439777135849,
0.17995710670948029,
0.6434394717216492,
0.4314930737018585,
-0.023295901715755463,
-0.8118915557861328,
0.7028321623802185,
-0.30250343680381775,
-0.3882489502429962,
-0.2654705345630646,
-0.5060867667198181,
-0.9590846300125122,
0.20937316119670868,
0.07748590409755707,
-0.6006188988685608,
0.230910986661911,
0.47263678908348083,
-0.3216758370399475,
0.25874486565589905,
-0.5319079160690308,
0.5805688500404358,
-0.24295783042907715,
-0.7195793390274048,
-0.749100923538208,
-0.5227196216583252,
0.2599005699157715,
-0.13564305007457733,
-0.1224626824259758,
-0.1673174500465393,
-0.25462403893470764,
0.4225168824195862,
-0.39232590794563293,
0.8065508008003235,
-0.3958613872528076,
-0.49912694096565247,
0.3443295955657959,
0.16006438434123993,
0.8899950981140137,
0.08786483854055405,
-0.2464112639427185,
0.11750240623950958,
-0.3449285924434662,
-0.10294703394174576,
-0.7441962957382202,
0.8826558589935303,
-0.6747530102729797,
-0.6015310883522034,
-0.20289137959480286,
-0.5130320191383362,
0.10666719079017639,
0.1140802726149559,
-0.15416774153709412,
0.15541377663612366,
0.08256392180919647,
0.21208010613918304,
0.8151834011077881,
-0.38974806666374207,
0.3248567581176758,
0.4774281680583954,
0.22266308963298798,
-0.45503389835357666,
0.8106460571289062,
-0.1442873328924179,
0.49062472581863403,
0.8335666656494141,
0.27483248710632324,
-0.3955160677433014,
-0.7775592803955078,
-0.4377962350845337,
0.15395531058311462,
-0.5907859802246094,
-0.12833741307258606,
-0.614764392375946,
0.0027372180484235287,
-0.18375720083713531,
0.04524369537830353,
-0.6302298903465271,
-0.31486642360687256,
-0.238833948969841,
-0.20657159388065338,
0.2932959794998169,
0.290219783782959,
0.06294392794370651,
0.38293883204460144,
-0.6093233227729797,
0.47266432642936707,
0.3777894973754883,
0.25261881947517395,
0.16587413847446442,
-0.20256762206554413,
-0.14122425019741058,
-0.009735467843711376,
-0.20418192446231842,
-0.6085794568061829,
0.2751367688179016,
0.23155371844768524,
0.524771511554718,
0.4719558358192444,
0.18652066588401794,
0.8689005374908447,
-0.5673784017562866,
0.5216997265815735,
0.05713895335793495,
-0.8617953062057495,
0.5596262812614441,
-0.2661846876144409,
0.10121485590934753,
0.4935917854309082,
-0.14462782442569733,
-0.30688369274139404,
-0.25145015120506287,
-0.2518972158432007,
-1.2439699172973633,
0.8119551539421082,
0.10845348984003067,
0.25963354110717773,
-0.39258384704589844,
0.748024046421051,
-0.07404648512601852,
0.3617633581161499,
-0.24787282943725586,
-0.1794164776802063,
0.09071323275566101,
-0.3487148880958557,
0.28066736459732056,
-0.5639217495918274,
-0.027719346806406975,
-0.28574657440185547,
0.3865428864955902,
-0.0727681964635849,
0.40539416670799255,
-0.060120586305856705,
-0.13258132338523865,
-0.15417948365211487,
-0.09420180320739746,
0.7217640280723572,
0.381310373544693,
-0.23513668775558472,
0.2475171536207199,
0.23361125588417053,
-0.5012361407279968,
0.1637793630361557,
0.06467371433973312,
-0.23790615797042847,
-0.23954813182353973,
0.17156586050987244,
1.03441321849823,
0.18914377689361572,
-0.7975899577140808,
0.34941935539245605,
-0.02469499595463276,
-0.14345219731330872,
-0.3136340379714966,
0.1333618462085724,
0.03206643834710121,
0.1962762176990509,
0.19797424972057343,
-0.42879214882850647,
0.07308009266853333,
-0.4630482494831085,
0.1828840970993042,
0.42849186062812805,
-0.19913475215435028,
-0.1991446614265442,
0.7485873699188232,
0.4768695831298828,
-0.036899175494909286,
0.9923452138900757,
-0.1734044849872589,
-0.43362414836883545,
0.7884370684623718,
0.5116310715675354,
0.9311896562576294,
-0.2832004129886627,
0.04453925043344498,
0.4155561029911041,
0.01245881523936987,
-0.1267612874507904,
0.07383515685796738,
-0.26604169607162476,
-0.8298991322517395,
-0.3688238859176636,
-0.6531856656074524,
-0.04674133285880089,
0.40545710921287537,
-0.6064937114715576,
0.06259401142597198,
-0.5736692547798157,
-0.0324227400124073,
-0.03797871246933937,
-0.09081794321537018,
-0.3983834385871887,
0.22308166325092316,
0.27030909061431885,
0.634633481502533,
-0.5799355506896973,
0.903285026550293,
0.25182998180389404,
-0.02082711271941662,
-0.3002440333366394,
0.05700531229376793,
0.1372787058353424,
-0.9696693420410156,
1.1200025081634521,
0.1972612589597702,
-0.3059259355068207,
0.16643184423446655,
-0.18445977568626404,
-0.8742161989212036,
0.9569525718688965,
0.5821336507797241,
-0.881199061870575,
-0.12808917462825775,
0.20985852181911469,
0.44577762484550476,
-0.15502455830574036,
0.073482446372509,
0.6948341727256775,
0.4486793875694275,
0.2126239687204361,
-0.5346052646636963,
0.18328355252742767,
-0.10448871552944183,
0.2440824806690216,
0.5007420778274536,
-0.8268639445304871,
0.5496534109115601,
-0.205978661775589,
-0.4598320722579956,
0.2313624769449234,
0.5028089284896851,
0.09377279877662659,
0.01966995559632778,
0.8421907424926758,
0.9240655899047852,
0.7463621497154236,
-0.28013575077056885,
0.8840900659561157,
-0.4683268368244171,
0.27677011489868164,
1.1304453611373901,
-0.6137079000473022,
0.7736731171607971,
0.5035670399665833,
-0.22111116349697113,
0.25798550248146057,
0.5306214690208435,
-0.001344760530628264,
0.864869236946106,
0.5436631441116333,
-0.5723993182182312,
-0.2690512537956238,
-0.01958831399679184,
-0.10019971430301666,
0.5524865388870239,
0.3911427855491638,
-0.31245818734169006,
-0.0037506516091525555,
-0.310297429561615,
0.10586142539978027,
0.06841309368610382,
0.039650529623031616,
0.9646139740943909,
-0.13915260136127472,
-0.824009120464325,
0.669942319393158,
-0.10613138973712921,
0.36442384123802185,
-0.489062637090683,
-0.32455432415008545,
-0.3432970345020294,
0.5947341322898865,
-0.05595887079834938,
-0.5310903787612915,
0.11050952225923538,
-0.19934017956256866,
-0.5137308835983276,
-0.33888381719589233,
0.31290292739868164,
-0.5919066667556763,
-0.35226354002952576,
0.6152770519256592,
-0.1371815800666809,
-0.1140921339392662,
-0.06814608722925186,
-0.4781791865825653,
0.3052870035171509,
-0.16277307271957397,
-0.1757037341594696,
0.3040107786655426,
0.5478389859199524,
-0.09260811656713486,
0.6055594086647034,
0.6286298632621765,
0.09638078510761261,
0.12923547625541687,
0.3794436454772949,
0.9034463167190552,
-0.3853042423725128,
-0.19090169668197632,
-0.9477221965789795,
0.39911457896232605,
-0.33650508522987366,
-0.14929518103599548,
0.5332456231117249,
0.7825176119804382,
0.738802969455719,
-0.012706016190350056,
0.6156697869300842,
0.17344532907009125,
0.18162934482097626,
-0.7435513138771057,
0.5018438696861267,
-0.7191175818443298,
0.3236582279205322,
-0.11946967244148254,
-0.8583312630653381,
-0.24616387486457825,
0.5363516211509705,
-0.15739695727825165,
-0.060110755264759064,
0.5250334739685059,
0.7861417531967163,
0.09878963977098465,
-0.6646748185157776,
0.21643835306167603,
0.25344547629356384,
0.5890845060348511,
0.5229591727256775,
0.6812270879745483,
-0.24935583770275116,
0.4323914349079132,
-0.2288844883441925,
-0.28402698040008545,
-0.3692902624607086,
-0.9023992419242859,
-0.6961795687675476,
-0.33603402972221375,
-0.5004916191101074,
-0.1137915551662445,
0.28114256262779236,
0.4217657446861267,
0.7849124073982239,
-0.6279094219207764,
-0.03267573192715645,
-0.3829241394996643,
0.06610361486673355,
-0.25925594568252563,
-0.2855917513370514,
0.5832966566085815,
-0.37032896280288696,
-1.0602850914001465,
0.40476194024086,
0.5052824020385742,
-0.19449906051158905,
-0.2731620967388153,
-0.01849830523133278,
0.009832995943725109,
-0.003842627862468362,
0.8791365623474121,
0.06499447673559189,
-0.9297152757644653,
-0.300394743680954,
-0.23945851624011993,
-0.14759254455566406,
0.032233379781246185,
0.6482267379760742,
-0.5157452821731567,
0.6987354159355164,
0.6749211549758911,
0.8296221494674683,
0.8627268671989441,
-0.051946964114904404,
0.5505402088165283,
-0.71876060962677,
0.4424454867839813,
0.13399389386177063,
0.16341885924339294,
0.24770089983940125,
-0.46467283368110657,
0.35144174098968506,
0.3907550573348999,
-0.29474207758903503,
-0.8746498227119446,
0.3530089855194092,
-1.0696512460708618,
-0.21211571991443634,
1.2703930139541626,
-0.12282413244247437,
0.01381679903715849,
0.21732227504253387,
-0.1973242610692978,
0.3785628378391266,
-0.5633804798126221,
1.0230094194412231,
0.47751757502555847,
0.2274376004934311,
-0.3978402316570282,
-0.4653841257095337,
0.5306147336959839,
0.39067578315734863,
-0.7859839200973511,
0.5064173340797424,
0.5596566796302795,
0.0677812322974205,
0.007818764075636864,
0.35724490880966187,
-0.1048818826675415,
0.05667895823717117,
0.11913733184337616,
0.1223096251487732,
-0.018472252413630486,
-0.3789503872394562,
0.0026898898649960756,
0.09095305949449539,
-0.06241171807050705,
-0.2990778982639313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13009v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13009v1 | Detecting Errors through Ensembling Prompts (DEEP): An End-to-End LLM Framework for Detecting Factual Errors | 2024-06-18T18:59:37 | 2024-06-18T18:59:37 | Alex Chandler, Devesh Surve, Hui Su | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Accurate text summarization is one of the most common and important tasks
performed by Large Language Models, where the costs of human review for an
entire document may be high, but the costs of errors in summarization may be
even greater. We propose Detecting Errors through Ensembling Prompts (DEEP) -
an end-to-end large language model framework for detecting factual errors in
text summarization. Our framework uses a diverse set of LLM prompts to identify
factual inconsistencies, treating their outputs as binary features, which are
then fed into ensembling models. We then calibrate the ensembled models to
produce empirically accurate probabilities that a text is factually consistent
or free of hallucination. We demonstrate that prior models for detecting
factual errors in summaries perform significantly worse without optimizing the
thresholds on subsets of the evaluated dataset. Our framework achieves
state-of-the-art (SOTA) balanced accuracy on the AggreFact-XSUM FTSOTA,
TofuEval Summary-Level, and HaluEval Summarization benchmarks in detecting
factual errors within transformer-generated text summaries. It does so without
any fine-tuning of the language model or reliance on thresholding techniques
not available in practical settings. | [
0.05894133448600769,
-0.8615127801895142,
0.7984183430671692,
0.3141329288482666,
-0.07229062914848328,
0.20736418664455414,
-0.0665862187743187,
-0.18558567762374878,
0.03513193503022194,
0.5754304528236389,
-0.6164998412132263,
-0.5150477886199951,
-0.5945245623588562,
0.4631495177745819,
-0.5109580159187317,
1.018020510673523,
-0.18324044346809387,
-0.0778888687491417,
-0.6544538140296936,
-0.16842511296272278,
-0.5222766399383545,
-0.24960383772850037,
-0.5379161834716797,
-0.013006783090531826,
0.22669237852096558,
0.6127939820289612,
0.39203256368637085,
0.25402364134788513,
0.419126957654953,
0.327040433883667,
-0.14715488255023956,
0.7091875076293945,
-0.5133992433547974,
0.42602109909057617,
-0.06825386732816696,
-0.5914483070373535,
-0.3741976320743561,
-0.24812299013137817,
0.7003346681594849,
0.47752857208251953,
-0.04280635342001915,
-0.009324917569756508,
0.14308814704418182,
0.7474483847618103,
-0.5425053834915161,
0.061793308705091476,
-0.43107864260673523,
-0.06125650554895401,
-0.047569967806339264,
-0.32054242491722107,
-0.6055794954299927,
-0.7380235195159912,
-0.08484866470098495,
-0.2196381539106369,
0.3658472001552582,
0.13708288967609406,
0.8498479127883911,
0.7004388570785522,
-0.3742879331111908,
-0.6164462566375732,
-0.42643243074417114,
0.5619942545890808,
-1.0759589672088623,
0.2992333769798279,
0.2979295551776886,
0.14915424585342407,
-0.06897090375423431,
-0.47006574273109436,
-0.6583864092826843,
-0.17500707507133484,
-0.3481416702270508,
0.42289072275161743,
-0.2745223641395569,
0.04822085425257683,
0.3056018650531769,
0.13775713741779327,
-0.6739931702613831,
0.2032238394021988,
-0.22856363654136658,
-0.2449052482843399,
0.5029395818710327,
0.3061574697494507,
0.37205633521080017,
-0.05141962319612503,
-0.16413432359695435,
-0.012542740441858768,
-0.8498095273971558,
0.203146830201149,
0.4264424443244934,
0.18943557143211365,
-0.4938814342021942,
0.709945797920227,
-0.2706954777240753,
0.5118261575698853,
0.3093549907207489,
-0.1704973429441452,
0.005181760992854834,
-0.4780915379524231,
-0.33890408277511597,
0.4996332824230194,
0.5513697266578674,
0.6756945252418518,
0.2965807318687439,
-0.19629517197608948,
-0.3984525501728058,
0.10101865977048874,
0.0077368589118123055,
-0.8391475081443787,
-0.03209931030869484,
0.5208766460418701,
-0.13811355829238892,
-0.427853524684906,
-0.087705597281456,
-0.5692775249481201,
-0.801123857498169,
-0.3263671398162842,
0.21221241354942322,
-0.3815207779407501,
0.1502348780632019,
0.22331035137176514,
0.0024763888213783503,
0.03436170145869255,
0.5965530276298523,
-0.7776462435722351,
0.12194287031888962,
0.6596972942352295,
1.0258210897445679,
-0.10411949455738068,
-0.23897233605384827,
-0.680384635925293,
0.05450478941202164,
-0.591707706451416,
1.174787163734436,
-0.23207201063632965,
-0.19242459535598755,
-0.04438992962241173,
-0.045995745807886124,
0.009973523207008839,
-0.5290486812591553,
0.665838360786438,
-0.3062411844730377,
0.21361522376537323,
-0.4539856016635895,
-0.799079418182373,
-0.24590939283370972,
0.5840292572975159,
-0.5288432240486145,
0.711776852607727,
-0.08481568843126297,
-0.7332183718681335,
0.3164963722229004,
-0.366008996963501,
-0.5379781126976013,
-0.1925831288099289,
-0.13148579001426697,
-0.4799671769142151,
0.15240512788295746,
0.4274831712245941,
0.5515831112861633,
-0.25145813822746277,
0.7088004350662231,
0.02835000306367874,
-0.35444068908691406,
0.31931039690971375,
-0.6685616374015808,
0.7412647008895874,
-0.15512068569660187,
-0.3071134388446808,
0.3005441427230835,
-0.838207483291626,
-0.5474068522453308,
-0.16875912249088287,
-0.41030362248420715,
-0.08228128403425217,
0.010367740876972675,
-0.37792089581489563,
-0.16150398552417755,
0.19063521921634674,
-0.4616186320781708,
-0.1167086660861969,
-0.43735453486442566,
-0.12348250299692154,
0.6514356136322021,
0.12520837783813477,
0.46053189039230347,
-0.48050814867019653,
0.40616220235824585,
0.1735692322254181,
-0.30998197197914124,
-0.7863726019859314,
-0.3377443253993988,
-0.818997859954834,
-0.2623235583305359,
0.12582822144031525,
0.8290407061576843,
-0.6535288691520691,
0.8602259755134583,
-0.29190054535865784,
-0.31326860189437866,
-0.2990109324455261,
-0.05504449084401131,
0.3100748360157013,
0.9532486200332642,
0.281234472990036,
0.29732075333595276,
-0.6079051494598389,
-0.6353603601455688,
-0.3786988854408264,
-0.2672420144081116,
-0.04441070556640625,
-0.11263241618871689,
0.43211355805397034,
-0.39758628606796265,
1.070428490638733,
-0.30110833048820496,
-0.2379239946603775,
-0.10505663603544235,
0.3372819423675537,
0.48602545261383057,
0.36642271280288696,
0.33535438776016235,
-0.48621368408203125,
-0.45251578092575073,
-0.10354948788881302,
-1.0757445096969604,
-0.3921295404434204,
-0.45769989490509033,
0.2202845960855484,
0.4503294825553894,
0.6390827894210815,
-0.6237421631813049,
0.25555428862571716,
0.2571776807308197,
-0.4842798709869385,
0.7749060392379761,
-0.21885958313941956,
0.40819308161735535,
-0.7749425768852234,
-0.11975733190774918,
0.07666132599115372,
-0.3852556645870209,
-0.4566865861415863,
-0.01586371287703514,
0.23493820428848267,
0.2663448750972748,
-0.06701477617025375,
0.2900337874889374,
-0.22641323506832123,
0.17198196053504944,
-0.2007412612438202,
0.18856172263622284,
0.29338136315345764,
0.23309491574764252,
-0.07533623278141022,
0.7655738592147827,
0.27020296454429626,
-0.5002806186676025,
0.6379230618476868,
0.2349012792110443,
-0.33012545108795166,
0.8276419043540955,
-0.6649498343467712,
-0.3031599223613739,
-0.471195250749588,
0.3132936954498291,
-1.3163251876831055,
-0.5178694725036621,
0.25508877635002136,
-0.6395519971847534,
0.4018095135688782,
0.025358490645885468,
-0.46713969111442566,
0.12902507185935974,
-0.5554189085960388,
0.05797484144568443,
0.3973052203655243,
-0.6328185200691223,
0.6973934173583984,
0.18140491843223572,
-0.4510854184627533,
-0.835919976234436,
-0.6900359988212585,
0.22755597531795502,
0.05846872180700302,
-0.8657602071762085,
-0.00526076415553689,
0.06529468297958374,
-0.37841978669166565,
0.02767573855817318,
-0.28666412830352783,
0.18462519347667694,
0.1372542679309845,
0.0011164392344653606,
0.28423944115638733,
-0.4248718321323395,
0.1605653315782547,
0.23916366696357727,
-0.2225644588470459,
0.26305869221687317,
-0.11616652458906174,
0.24141018092632294,
-0.2991442084312439,
-0.5423357486724854,
-0.22189824283123016,
0.17601287364959717,
0.645027756690979,
-0.0015326503198593855,
0.47805267572402954,
0.2940928637981415,
-0.6572751998901367,
-0.08409091085195541,
-0.8003583550453186,
-0.16821376979351044,
-0.43935155868530273,
0.4329836964607239,
0.02337779477238655,
-0.8023053407669067,
0.6544526815414429,
0.13227039575576782,
0.355815589427948,
0.390216588973999,
0.36734095215797424,
-0.4781472980976105,
0.8335539698600769,
0.4703100919723511,
0.12000615894794464,
-0.10956921428442001,
0.12843523919582367,
0.3583304286003113,
-0.44469431042671204,
-0.19326350092887878,
-0.5452984571456909,
-0.20626598596572876,
-0.3254270851612091,
-0.3726230263710022,
0.5041552186012268,
0.07805968075990677,
-0.2994075119495392,
-0.16023008525371552,
-0.24181096255779266,
0.7731881141662598,
0.373003214597702,
0.0002716252638492733,
0.4705113470554352,
0.04239391162991524,
-0.03712235763669014,
-0.10501555353403091,
-0.4274529218673706,
-0.5791518092155457,
0.7227831482887268,
0.3485068380832672,
0.8963010907173157,
0.217366024851799,
0.5746099352836609,
0.3751852810382843,
0.3075063228607178,
-0.7583760023117065,
0.3749368190765381,
-0.06647942215204239,
-0.21986402571201324,
-0.5691518783569336,
-0.5262898802757263,
-0.42864254117012024,
0.0736580640077591,
-0.1958393156528473,
-0.530222475528717,
0.3036086857318878,
0.2938798666000366,
-0.7001776099205017,
0.4761849641799927,
-0.4725407660007477,
0.6973324418067932,
-0.2072911411523819,
-0.25714734196662903,
0.03796764090657234,
-0.651573896408081,
0.6893083453178406,
-0.1440894603729248,
0.26606640219688416,
-0.1159713864326477,
-0.1720448136329651,
0.5631113052368164,
-0.2724769115447998,
1.1237434148788452,
-0.05480780452489853,
-0.3922479450702667,
0.2612744867801666,
0.3180803954601288,
1.00710928440094,
0.05572523549199104,
0.07506776601076126,
-0.08950033038854599,
-0.3465641736984253,
0.0006703227409161627,
-0.729288637638092,
0.40765082836151123,
-0.43834811449050903,
-0.48336273431777954,
-0.48713216185569763,
-0.3994055390357971,
-0.12814229726791382,
0.06444188207387924,
0.5745671987533569,
0.7375913858413696,
-0.05430809035897255,
0.27002695202827454,
1.0734885931015015,
-0.3550739288330078,
0.34647485613822937,
0.5408787727355957,
-0.11331475526094437,
-0.29854530096054077,
0.9677601456642151,
0.12447280436754227,
-0.0004270417266525328,
0.5138972401618958,
0.17818541824817657,
-0.5711543560028076,
-0.7252508401870728,
-0.7553582191467285,
0.2075519561767578,
-0.9300898313522339,
-0.48344680666923523,
-0.8988641500473022,
-0.08964862674474716,
-0.46280577778816223,
-0.43348464369773865,
-0.2388305366039276,
-0.31222647428512573,
-0.36593174934387207,
-0.5024639368057251,
0.2726430892944336,
0.5188272595405579,
-0.07498617470264435,
0.3655892610549927,
-1.0867328643798828,
0.2526014447212219,
0.10673992335796356,
0.12036323547363281,
-0.11013852059841156,
-0.8822683691978455,
-0.14618465304374695,
0.022853493690490723,
-0.09264896810054779,
-0.9146764874458313,
0.36327341198921204,
0.011919910088181496,
0.2865881025791168,
0.4452877938747406,
0.23939576745033264,
0.42892783880233765,
-0.3908618688583374,
0.9014150500297546,
0.35153838992118835,
-1.0032501220703125,
0.3970892131328583,
-0.3330444395542145,
0.34164395928382874,
0.616827130317688,
0.22841158509254456,
-0.9324691891670227,
-0.5302436351776123,
-0.43600693345069885,
-0.8181711435317993,
0.6182146668434143,
-0.09479406476020813,
-0.04587535932660103,
-0.04725785180926323,
0.10562427341938019,
0.08443968743085861,
0.20964312553405762,
-0.6477434039115906,
-0.07763969153165817,
-0.015778683125972748,
-0.6784026622772217,
-0.018749043345451355,
-0.5777411460876465,
-0.04322650283575058,
0.0791623443365097,
0.9675628542900085,
-0.3838356137275696,
-0.14607660472393036,
0.32715755701065063,
-0.49903205037117004,
-0.26374301314353943,
0.25973328948020935,
0.8710852265357971,
0.7332354187965393,
-0.2378760576248169,
0.27609574794769287,
0.5335022807121277,
-0.20954830944538116,
0.2647797763347626,
-0.1423792541027069,
-0.4306127429008484,
0.3096815347671509,
0.7355443835258484,
0.5561831593513489,
0.5266300439834595,
-0.9989688396453857,
0.6825652122497559,
0.05788540840148926,
0.06855510175228119,
-0.2197708785533905,
-0.1664244383573532,
0.1372089833021164,
0.17186319828033447,
0.39907509088516235,
0.3303285837173462,
0.37739554047584534,
-0.36090242862701416,
0.32504287362098694,
0.18247093260288239,
-0.3109720051288605,
-0.20661336183547974,
0.495147705078125,
0.36129146814346313,
-0.013151467777788639,
0.5320184230804443,
-0.33782365918159485,
-0.5509068965911865,
0.7796929478645325,
0.35477909445762634,
1.100184440612793,
-0.12938717007637024,
0.3308306634426117,
0.34613096714019775,
0.6950128078460693,
-0.21548083424568176,
-0.00871056318283081,
0.09033484011888504,
-0.956335186958313,
-0.652948796749115,
-0.46483114361763,
-0.6914505362510681,
-0.1933395266532898,
-0.2737891674041748,
0.3662357032299042,
-0.32377853989601135,
0.27710190415382385,
-0.1649036556482315,
-0.44350308179855347,
-0.16714513301849365,
0.20888099074363708,
0.20570015907287598,
0.8375505805015564,
-0.8686658143997192,
0.022876568138599396,
0.44672098755836487,
-0.2930281162261963,
-0.49486812949180603,
-0.06218557432293892,
0.28298941254615784,
-0.6098899245262146,
0.4333639144897461,
0.26201555132865906,
-0.32402628660202026,
-0.20312845706939697,
-0.6383548378944397,
-0.7562890648841858,
0.9186832904815674,
0.4772636890411377,
-0.7618899941444397,
-0.06239759922027588,
0.013842209242284298,
0.2539953589439392,
-0.1369822919368744,
0.453791081905365,
0.761681079864502,
0.543800950050354,
0.10301486402750015,
-0.49592360854148865,
0.2549649775028229,
-0.030746541917324066,
-0.6225929856300354,
0.12154941260814667,
-0.5173013210296631,
0.8325226902961731,
-0.4478682577610016,
-0.45256131887435913,
-0.16787534952163696,
0.7715832591056824,
0.3754241168498993,
0.5961928963661194,
0.3695494532585144,
0.4854170083999634,
1.3335708379745483,
-0.26627054810523987,
0.8762057423591614,
-0.05755716562271118,
0.17492090165615082,
1.2754647731781006,
-0.5009244084358215,
0.3746953308582306,
0.13964615762233734,
-0.08577007800340652,
0.25422126054763794,
0.6625846028327942,
-0.032465290278196335,
0.26752063632011414,
-0.19314470887184143,
-0.25442713499069214,
-0.2052122950553894,
0.12462985515594482,
-0.25262030959129333,
0.0010204834397882223,
0.4632626473903656,
-0.03388507291674614,
-0.5416661500930786,
-0.16618914902210236,
0.0716131404042244,
0.18329370021820068,
-0.17957285046577454,
0.811143159866333,
0.106480173766613,
-0.7326921820640564,
0.43716961145401,
-0.01134999468922615,
1.0670535564422607,
-0.446059912443161,
-0.04645936191082001,
-0.49721091985702515,
0.03882661089301109,
-0.4095460772514343,
-0.7544028162956238,
0.44409430027008057,
0.3087905943393707,
-0.30724766850471497,
-0.06330396980047226,
0.9315426349639893,
-0.5305150747299194,
-0.602294921875,
-0.09533734619617462,
0.442251980304718,
0.09408707916736603,
-0.1551564335823059,
-0.2020816206932068,
-0.12263553589582443,
0.08571726083755493,
-0.017354493960738182,
-0.12509024143218994,
0.6547449231147766,
0.08526751399040222,
0.566653311252594,
0.6642732620239258,
-0.10992714762687683,
-0.07228787243366241,
0.11213915050029755,
0.4943524897098541,
-0.5216478705406189,
-0.7726459503173828,
-1.2625483274459839,
0.739625871181488,
-0.3451695740222931,
-0.17531801760196686,
0.733329176902771,
0.6071604490280151,
0.6281342506408691,
-0.12423289567232132,
0.945313036441803,
0.31321802735328674,
0.49438273906707764,
-0.7869044542312622,
0.7819005846977234,
-0.29386797547340393,
0.5162895917892456,
-0.008952596224844456,
-0.6702030897140503,
-0.3731920123100281,
0.48815280199050903,
-0.09419795125722885,
-0.26676610112190247,
0.6334747672080994,
0.9088532328605652,
0.14303253591060638,
0.3026438057422638,
0.46896985173225403,
0.44858619570732117,
0.2708738148212433,
0.15373928844928741,
1.1192935705184937,
-0.2411710023880005,
0.23071855306625366,
0.12922750413417816,
-0.36401867866516113,
-0.45027461647987366,
-0.9204914569854736,
-0.8456969261169434,
-0.2934357523918152,
-0.4806903600692749,
-0.44045230746269226,
0.10748451203107834,
0.9452588558197021,
0.11929700523614883,
-1.0596896409988403,
-0.06354571878910065,
-0.08291482925415039,
0.5497065782546997,
-0.1011052057147026,
-0.21413537859916687,
0.3095034956932068,
-0.7498440146446228,
-0.5323704481124878,
0.490590363740921,
0.5775623321533203,
0.19844843447208405,
0.007132450584322214,
-0.12123331427574158,
0.041881170123815536,
0.2518477737903595,
0.6275601387023926,
0.04456057772040367,
-0.5483477115631104,
-0.3255724608898163,
0.047827381640672684,
-0.153164803981781,
-0.003086622105911374,
0.7661747336387634,
-0.5754144191741943,
0.3105766177177429,
0.6811674237251282,
0.9771803021430969,
0.13009051978588104,
0.010345658287405968,
0.5639500617980957,
-0.9569191336631775,
-0.22387723624706268,
0.27169644832611084,
0.5641428828239441,
0.5597821474075317,
-0.7183956503868103,
0.5267882347106934,
0.3455861806869507,
-0.41455021500587463,
-1.024712085723877,
-0.02713729813694954,
-0.7611304521560669,
-0.1765136867761612,
0.9205101132392883,
-0.2369050830602646,
-0.26407307386398315,
-0.19534745812416077,
-0.1604875773191452,
0.2354051172733307,
-0.27379435300827026,
0.6293712854385376,
0.7469597458839417,
0.057112984359264374,
-0.10640133172273636,
-0.22705163061618805,
0.47974905371665955,
0.3614192008972168,
-0.9531605839729309,
0.3354315757751465,
0.7340770959854126,
0.18307872116565704,
0.25672098994255066,
0.42528486251831055,
0.11097025871276855,
0.5603660345077515,
0.05502324551343918,
-0.08200882375240326,
-0.11428241431713104,
-0.4056648015975952,
-0.4892737567424774,
-0.0073342518880963326,
-0.4463682770729065,
0.04485781118273735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12998v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12998v1 | Articulatory Encodec: Vocal Tract Kinematics as a Codec for Speech | 2024-06-18T18:38:17 | 2024-06-18T18:38:17 | Cheol Jun Cho, Peter Wu, Tejas S. Prabhune, Dhruv Agarwal, Gopala K. Anumanchipalli | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD | Vocal tract articulation is a natural, grounded control space of speech
production. The spatiotemporal coordination of articulators combined with the
vocal source shapes intelligible speech sounds to enable effective spoken
communication. Based on this physiological grounding of speech, we propose a
new framework of neural encoding-decoding of speech -- articulatory encodec.
The articulatory encodec comprises an articulatory analysis model that infers
articulatory features from speech audio, and an articulatory synthesis model
that synthesizes speech audio from articulatory features. The articulatory
features are kinematic traces of vocal tract articulators and source features,
which are intuitively interpretable and controllable, being the actual physical
interface of speech production. An additional speaker identity encoder is
jointly trained with the articulatory synthesizer to inform the voice texture
of individual speakers. By training on large-scale speech data, we achieve a
fully intelligible, high-quality articulatory synthesizer that generalizes to
unseen speakers. Furthermore, the speaker embedding is effectively disentangled
from articulations, which enables accent-perserving zero-shot voice conversion.
To the best of our knowledge, this is the first demonstration of universal,
high-performance articulatory inference and synthesis, suggesting the proposed
framework as a powerful coding system of speech. | [
-0.3157031834125519,
-0.6624044179916382,
0.31058236956596375,
0.03778652101755142,
-0.1255919635295868,
0.06504066288471222,
-0.022817132994532585,
-0.11205285787582397,
0.8457302451133728,
0.45883867144584656,
-0.535847008228302,
-0.6365063786506653,
-0.3238355815410614,
-0.27617010474205017,
-0.5356053709983826,
0.7607137560844421,
0.2609640061855316,
0.20097145438194275,
0.06567209213972092,
-0.14172545075416565,
-0.18842341005802155,
-0.9317778944969177,
-0.4726027250289917,
-0.40388932824134827,
0.19342143833637238,
0.09271154552698135,
0.5346959829330444,
0.6663264036178589,
0.17561137676239014,
0.24423636496067047,
-0.24684052169322968,
-0.12427663803100586,
-0.2976379692554474,
0.4313954710960388,
0.3984753489494324,
-0.44215723872184753,
-0.8797677755355835,
-0.08481785655021667,
0.6927259564399719,
1.0152232646942139,
-0.49894487857818604,
-0.1385084092617035,
-0.06443795561790466,
0.43312501907348633,
-0.6279605031013489,
0.23218967020511627,
-0.26439201831817627,
0.26670610904693604,
-0.12377149611711502,
-0.472520112991333,
-0.3665136396884918,
-0.39699259400367737,
-0.2899584472179413,
-0.34088075160980225,
-0.06356357038021088,
-0.4028507173061371,
0.3086314797401428,
0.3709897994995117,
-0.22600160539150238,
-0.32939913868904114,
-0.8564252853393555,
-0.09004835039377213,
-0.664895236492157,
0.7656181454658508,
0.3648640215396881,
0.14907075464725494,
-0.17390857636928558,
-0.6195765137672424,
-0.4402191936969757,
-0.12855401635169983,
0.47694161534309387,
0.33438917994499207,
-0.11203871667385101,
0.588742733001709,
-0.09816387295722961,
0.3401782214641571,
-0.5256959795951843,
0.04898484796285629,
-0.24889929592609406,
-0.11613693088293076,
0.45855259895324707,
-0.050377681851387024,
0.33170199394226074,
0.07063788175582886,
0.08791016787290573,
-0.04265720397233963,
-0.4863002598285675,
0.07862073928117752,
0.6873570680618286,
0.08829101175069809,
-0.3025519549846649,
0.4382539987564087,
-0.1973436176776886,
0.4288913905620575,
0.15773265063762665,
-0.15331527590751648,
0.32649895548820496,
0.17018873989582062,
-0.29415324330329895,
0.5535414218902588,
0.7123162746429443,
0.07046537846326828,
0.16783736646175385,
-0.36893728375434875,
0.001521802507340908,
0.10394858568906784,
0.1355680227279663,
-0.48611167073249817,
-0.2420409768819809,
0.28735119104385376,
-0.5589520335197449,
-0.2994191646575928,
0.14797411859035492,
-0.27234789729118347,
-0.16777029633522034,
-0.4850606322288513,
0.06939617544412613,
-0.4207167625427246,
-0.5940425395965576,
0.08826413005590439,
-0.09076131880283356,
0.13066527247428894,
-0.2077726274728775,
-1.20961332321167,
0.4139060080051422,
0.5056143403053284,
0.8367187976837158,
0.04351341351866722,
-0.385547012090683,
-0.48519012331962585,
0.12796398997306824,
-0.7866756319999695,
0.4254913926124573,
-0.6657131314277649,
-0.07159242033958435,
0.12146688997745514,
-0.00453947763890028,
-0.07150411605834961,
-0.3902837336063385,
0.3013576567173004,
-0.3293432593345642,
-0.21955715119838715,
0.19650112092494965,
-0.5417314171791077,
-0.21882888674736023,
-0.3818296790122986,
-0.7575938701629639,
0.40436846017837524,
0.056442778557538986,
-0.3038627803325653,
-0.0349603034555912,
-0.6549081206321716,
-0.4134269654750824,
0.08153939247131348,
-0.08917804062366486,
0.14524215459823608,
0.2788403630256653,
-0.12579764425754547,
0.34918808937072754,
0.05449458211660385,
0.3099367320537567,
-0.17915700376033783,
-0.32416173815727234,
0.4742116332054138,
-0.5581877827644348,
0.5997070074081421,
0.5316083431243896,
-0.3770379424095154,
0.04558491334319115,
-0.9911877512931824,
0.060172948986291885,
-0.11971155554056168,
-0.3889228105545044,
0.15326599776744843,
-0.26623815298080444,
0.024440158158540726,
-0.2275099903345108,
-0.032135941088199615,
-0.5702230930328369,
-0.1838793158531189,
-0.6389195322990417,
0.9082945585250854,
0.24870829284191132,
0.1529121696949005,
0.8279153108596802,
0.10142892599105835,
0.47534680366516113,
-0.17903997004032135,
0.008192986249923706,
-0.1225748285651207,
-0.49488070607185364,
-0.748441219329834,
0.0875362753868103,
0.26259738206863403,
0.5383123159408569,
-0.5634549260139465,
0.6612669229507446,
-0.21503174304962158,
-0.2883528470993042,
-0.7524846196174622,
-0.21663162112236023,
0.26635149121284485,
0.10577712953090668,
0.052308037877082825,
-0.5066246390342712,
-0.47420233488082886,
-0.7241162657737732,
-0.039615388959646225,
-0.34409773349761963,
-0.25429293513298035,
-0.08113523572683334,
0.06719563901424408,
0.12127206474542618,
0.46853965520858765,
0.03395751491189003,
-0.06683635711669922,
-0.16583307087421417,
0.11024721711874008,
0.19585365056991577,
0.764782726764679,
0.4515543580055237,
-0.2251574844121933,
-0.031087074428796768,
0.05418675020337105,
-0.6238020062446594,
-0.23208054900169373,
0.0755314975976944,
-0.3865092694759369,
0.13878333568572998,
0.5535356998443604,
-0.8794239163398743,
0.5633657574653625,
0.6410276889801025,
-0.30799782276153564,
0.10222294926643372,
-0.31085076928138733,
0.40738165378570557,
-0.6310486793518066,
0.06811963766813278,
-0.5638698935508728,
-0.0039807395078241825,
-0.9439138770103455,
-0.041691429913043976,
-0.02172945998609066,
-0.5365734696388245,
-0.33832260966300964,
-0.19020932912826538,
-0.3604249358177185,
-0.03909774869680405,
-0.28751516342163086,
-0.08562225103378296,
0.03137290105223656,
0.8138919472694397,
0.0833861380815506,
0.22736699879169464,
0.777409553527832,
-0.5182961821556091,
0.8004093766212463,
0.2210659682750702,
0.0921468436717987,
0.7571333050727844,
-0.4264141917228699,
0.5010197758674622,
-0.3317992687225342,
0.3564228415489197,
-0.783103883266449,
-0.34519705176353455,
0.24446861445903778,
-0.8034224510192871,
0.4805200695991516,
-0.3472365140914917,
-0.07246916741132736,
-0.15012520551681519,
0.17301544547080994,
0.49585211277008057,
0.8063130378723145,
-0.5281295776367188,
0.5958366394042969,
0.6744146347045898,
-0.006574558559805155,
-0.037685826420784,
-0.9930490255355835,
0.2428784817457199,
0.004747163038700819,
-0.534090518951416,
0.09731030464172363,
0.18008312582969666,
0.06087735295295715,
-0.053973693400621414,
0.04040711745619774,
-0.1488405019044876,
-0.1766163855791092,
0.4560527205467224,
-0.16048531234264374,
-0.1931980699300766,
0.11539182811975479,
0.10807523876428604,
-0.23939408361911774,
0.24184095859527588,
-0.7368758320808411,
0.49526992440223694,
0.2871457040309906,
-0.6351940035820007,
-0.9067769646644592,
0.5861484408378601,
0.8197461366653442,
-0.18633006513118744,
0.27150583267211914,
0.605539083480835,
-0.4160623252391815,
0.17760296165943146,
-0.43904629349708557,
-0.22644758224487305,
-0.37958794832229614,
0.27049732208251953,
-0.2877735495567322,
-0.5925301909446716,
0.437551349401474,
-0.02182547003030777,
-0.36882925033569336,
0.03127163648605347,
0.4324800372123718,
-0.03851351514458656,
1.1545532941818237,
0.2922215461730957,
-0.15441188216209412,
0.43851786851882935,
-0.4113965928554535,
0.23129279911518097,
-0.6292793154716492,
-0.42141926288604736,
-0.5867896676063538,
-0.4441056251525879,
-0.365058571100235,
-0.48911553621292114,
0.2676716148853302,
-0.17078843712806702,
-0.3327977657318115,
0.06900147348642349,
-0.6454278826713562,
0.21947388350963593,
0.6535025835037231,
0.09249836951494217,
-0.15554334223270416,
0.22938694059848785,
-0.15475942194461823,
-0.09915726631879807,
-0.6809169054031372,
-0.3050398826599121,
0.8532605767250061,
0.5826802849769592,
0.7954879999160767,
0.04175912216305733,
0.6040865778923035,
0.11385829001665115,
-0.31181639432907104,
-0.8484176397323608,
0.27945393323898315,
-0.3407995104789734,
-0.1934582144021988,
-0.06602147221565247,
-0.08859752118587494,
-0.614948570728302,
-0.07188831269741058,
-0.10570374131202698,
-0.7650740742683411,
0.4837195873260498,
0.1768438220024109,
-0.38891899585723877,
0.5316163897514343,
-0.6465652585029602,
0.5708212852478027,
-0.14705725014209747,
-0.17116282880306244,
-0.09161713719367981,
-0.6826798915863037,
-0.02331010438501835,
0.6345558762550354,
0.11397914588451385,
0.0016577641945332289,
0.0831087976694107,
0.7484551668167114,
-0.250535786151886,
0.9104118347167969,
-0.5336112380027771,
-0.16966187953948975,
0.33979690074920654,
0.3208177983760834,
0.15729515254497528,
-0.32283157110214233,
-0.05320502817630768,
0.46138760447502136,
-0.016445331275463104,
-0.08565156906843185,
-0.769946277141571,
0.6103546619415283,
-0.5442065596580505,
-0.21162395179271698,
0.12878839671611786,
-0.20482291281223297,
-0.19814422726631165,
-0.29248178005218506,
0.27027377486228943,
0.7752662301063538,
-0.43232569098472595,
0.4308152496814728,
0.5049650073051453,
0.0861927717924118,
0.40791454911231995,
0.24765585362911224,
0.1624232828617096,
-0.7585889101028442,
0.9407055974006653,
-0.0392819419503212,
0.25443607568740845,
0.4884756803512573,
-0.1136024072766304,
-0.3079068660736084,
-0.7731180191040039,
-0.47050368785858154,
0.1612057387828827,
-0.8057597279548645,
-0.18558508157730103,
-0.5571390986442566,
-0.5158536434173584,
-0.5953767895698547,
0.012243319302797318,
-0.5440137982368469,
-0.49741876125335693,
-0.3934369385242462,
-0.2599967420101166,
0.18057389557361603,
0.9688229560852051,
-0.4464554786682129,
0.2504907250404358,
-0.5897626876831055,
0.3904031217098236,
0.3790085017681122,
0.4399859309196472,
-0.06368179619312286,
-0.4406129717826843,
-0.2810271978378296,
0.3295680284500122,
-0.0833485871553421,
-1.028428077697754,
0.685099720954895,
0.4801333546638489,
0.4390247166156769,
0.3824693560600281,
-0.17413108050823212,
0.5762135982513428,
-0.5960729718208313,
0.9094942808151245,
0.41071856021881104,
-1.23317289352417,
0.698305070400238,
-0.017689509317278862,
0.375438928604126,
0.23689031600952148,
0.04976271092891693,
-0.7098915576934814,
-0.6255514621734619,
-0.6352055072784424,
-0.7584916949272156,
0.6143811345100403,
0.38033175468444824,
0.1105729267001152,
-0.03935408219695091,
0.379282683134079,
0.13104261457920074,
0.272329717874527,
-0.1888950914144516,
-0.18043252825737,
-0.6872930526733398,
-0.4843354821205139,
0.1097540408372879,
-0.3189489543437958,
-0.5415499210357666,
-0.28247639536857605,
0.3653012812137604,
-0.33810386061668396,
0.6569601893424988,
0.4309382736682892,
0.2098837047815323,
-0.2524693012237549,
0.3418762981891632,
0.578606367111206,
0.29762256145477295,
-0.1896003931760788,
0.3640742301940918,
0.028711505234241486,
-0.732231855392456,
0.396426260471344,
-0.12927111983299255,
0.0767812505364418,
0.16938671469688416,
0.33403071761131287,
1.4342135190963745,
0.12082742899656296,
-0.3365553915500641,
0.49764129519462585,
-0.11394543200731277,
-0.39846283197402954,
-0.42084217071533203,
0.1018836572766304,
0.08765684813261032,
0.25842103362083435,
0.37120142579078674,
0.21027927100658417,
0.38905423879623413,
-0.49787771701812744,
-0.020282061770558357,
0.3017643094062805,
-0.46777406334877014,
-0.5383602380752563,
0.9619516134262085,
0.37707412242889404,
-0.5243958830833435,
0.1813371181488037,
-0.002400302095338702,
-0.35935088992118835,
0.6635729670524597,
0.426308810710907,
1.2615244388580322,
-0.4011330306529999,
0.045454174280166626,
0.28811824321746826,
0.1055096760392189,
0.27366092801094055,
0.3526984751224518,
-0.3374389410018921,
-0.4087026119232178,
-0.2892446517944336,
-0.720409095287323,
-0.30309340357780457,
-0.01848500221967697,
-0.8085150718688965,
-0.12076766043901443,
-0.3728044629096985,
-0.1650310605764389,
-0.1409500241279602,
-0.6459766626358032,
-0.5275169610977173,
0.09936434775590897,
0.6850261092185974,
0.6134061217308044,
-0.6778558492660522,
0.8568007349967957,
0.625648021697998,
-0.05602138116955757,
-0.8377366065979004,
-0.1353188306093216,
-0.07363052666187286,
-0.7619805335998535,
0.6530981659889221,
-0.10375318676233292,
-0.32421910762786865,
0.2535271942615509,
-0.5621311664581299,
-0.80985027551651,
0.9024643898010254,
0.7790865302085876,
-0.6796720027923584,
0.19652655720710754,
0.33487534523010254,
0.5770367980003357,
-0.8255596160888672,
0.3582301437854767,
1.0254961252212524,
0.16058628261089325,
0.34672126173973083,
-1.1685212850570679,
-0.11228886246681213,
-0.42364174127578735,
0.15501855313777924,
-0.17934224009513855,
-0.14905160665512085,
0.5924314260482788,
0.06365399062633514,
-0.3288410007953644,
0.3259412348270416,
0.4016996920108795,
0.029341334477066994,
0.156126469373703,
0.2888115644454956,
0.5869570374488831,
0.6674874424934387,
-0.26772740483283997,
0.5218347311019897,
-0.601189911365509,
0.00020572364155668765,
0.516861081123352,
0.06994838267564774,
0.8478894233703613,
0.37150561809539795,
-0.1676446497440338,
0.4199943244457245,
0.2052202671766281,
0.5737355947494507,
0.6414079666137695,
0.1835004687309265,
-0.40633130073547363,
-0.14094065129756927,
-0.1111757680773735,
-0.5734114050865173,
1.055422067642212,
0.5272006988525391,
-0.39149361848831177,
0.2238806188106537,
0.44506514072418213,
-0.2029845118522644,
0.0010723767336457968,
-0.22649450600147247,
1.1283026933670044,
-0.05066222324967384,
-0.4925459623336792,
1.1307376623153687,
-0.4802509844303131,
0.4330531358718872,
-0.7517496347427368,
-0.2590850591659546,
-0.21902230381965637,
-0.06677582114934921,
-0.3536529541015625,
-0.6399176716804504,
0.1502917855978012,
-0.26629361510276794,
0.18877163529396057,
-0.2758171558380127,
0.5877718329429626,
-0.901896595954895,
0.14663323760032654,
0.2875533998012543,
0.26326990127563477,
0.5883070826530457,
-0.11684492230415344,
-0.22389616072177887,
0.42807939648628235,
-0.0283698458224535,
0.02804190292954445,
0.05790118873119354,
0.6305610537528992,
0.5595105886459351,
0.36894848942756653,
0.5622203350067139,
0.5714001655578613,
0.058919016271829605,
0.6585942506790161,
0.7604193091392517,
-0.7113069891929626,
-0.9724941253662109,
-0.34367823600769043,
0.3842015266418457,
0.18760845065116882,
0.12046397477388382,
0.13549920916557312,
0.17508916556835175,
0.39871886372566223,
-0.12861445546150208,
0.8446236252784729,
0.05603807047009468,
0.2026204764842987,
-0.8334359526634216,
0.9315834641456604,
-0.29222750663757324,
-0.15768441557884216,
0.19598084688186646,
-0.7505000233650208,
-0.2314641773700714,
0.6732527017593384,
0.2546409070491791,
-0.0015367837622761726,
0.8021584153175354,
0.7166632413864136,
0.19821688532829285,
0.45667600631713867,
0.5746885538101196,
0.14020207524299622,
0.15719088912010193,
0.6847322583198547,
0.8085602521896362,
-0.3618580996990204,
0.49034830927848816,
-0.3404548168182373,
-0.29761791229248047,
-0.20139887928962708,
-0.5624454021453857,
-0.5799348950386047,
-0.6881716847419739,
-0.3520640432834625,
-0.2881840467453003,
0.25680011510849,
0.8023782968521118,
0.9534919857978821,
-0.8726980686187744,
-0.5208889842033386,
-0.42796921730041504,
-0.13283628225326538,
-0.29317331314086914,
-0.260775089263916,
0.12340475618839264,
-0.19577184319496155,
-0.8832293748855591,
0.7566711902618408,
0.4152979254722595,
0.29323866963386536,
-0.5072513222694397,
-0.4132888615131378,
0.2973308265209198,
-0.2808411419391632,
0.3831457495689392,
0.4354332685470581,
-0.7580803036689758,
-0.18727757036685944,
-0.005567162297666073,
0.04187661409378052,
0.1433652937412262,
1.145214557647705,
-0.5135658383369446,
0.5976130366325378,
0.6278635859489441,
0.37998953461647034,
0.2826139032840729,
-0.21252723038196564,
0.5996624231338501,
-0.7218529582023621,
0.5576111078262329,
0.5730049014091492,
0.29104194045066833,
0.44440215826034546,
-0.3331819474697113,
0.1566709578037262,
0.297613263130188,
-0.4564123749732971,
-0.6387163996696472,
0.14472311735153198,
-1.0553041696548462,
0.09689299762248993,
1.0153545141220093,
-0.018939459696412086,
-0.5104362368583679,
-0.14912842214107513,
-0.2893662750720978,
0.5084474682807922,
-0.568257749080658,
0.23216791450977325,
0.4305760860443115,
-0.39127084612846375,
-0.3292553424835205,
-0.5124330520629883,
0.5066529512405396,
0.1820322424173355,
-0.48105937242507935,
0.08562805503606796,
0.6081991791725159,
-0.050122540444135666,
0.25011011958122253,
0.5967613458633423,
-0.13238541781902313,
0.33543044328689575,
0.5363809466362,
0.5550890564918518,
-0.1248551607131958,
-0.46110329031944275,
-0.5557170510292053,
0.4787749648094177,
0.05716966465115547,
-0.6400013566017151
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12997v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12997v1 | Suitability of CCA for Generating Latent State/ Variables in Multi-View Textual Data | 2024-06-18T18:37:24 | 2024-06-18T18:37:24 | Akanksha Mehndiratta, Krishna Asawa | cs.CL | cs.CL | The probabilistic interpretation of Canonical Correlation Analysis (CCA) for
learning low-dimensional real vectors, called as latent variables, has been
exploited immensely in various fields. This study takes a step further by
demonstrating the potential of CCA in discovering a latent state that captures
the contextual information within the textual data under a two-view setting.
The interpretation of CCA discussed in this study utilizes the multi-view
nature of textual data, i.e. the consecutive sentences in a document or turns
in a dyadic conversation, and has a strong theoretical foundation. Furthermore,
this study proposes a model using CCA to perform the Automatic Short Answer
Grading (ASAG) task. The empirical analysis confirms that the proposed model
delivers competitive results and can even beat various sophisticated supervised
techniques. The model is simple, linear, and adaptable and should be used as
the baseline especially when labeled training data is scarce or nonexistent. | [
-0.0050490363501012325,
-1.0203293561935425,
0.9554579257965088,
0.1462588757276535,
-0.4151577949523926,
0.0031084364745765924,
0.13420815765857697,
-0.19644823670387268,
0.5345878005027771,
0.22584854066371918,
-0.3177339434623718,
-0.6180229187011719,
-0.40928056836128235,
-0.1908218115568161,
-0.29181787371635437,
0.9832625389099121,
-0.050561510026454926,
0.21222899854183197,
-0.5346717238426208,
-0.16184929013252258,
-0.8313277363777161,
-0.90511554479599,
-0.49143850803375244,
0.009204336442053318,
0.4976450502872467,
0.5082309246063232,
0.5807497501373291,
0.2185770571231842,
0.6528580784797668,
0.29673609137535095,
-0.03525681793689728,
0.15719926357269287,
-0.4124372899532318,
0.11208204180002213,
-0.14657913148403168,
-0.6705614924430847,
-0.7244072556495667,
0.4494539201259613,
0.7038376331329346,
0.824988603591919,
0.06345083564519882,
0.16483144462108612,
0.10545309633016586,
0.8052617907524109,
-0.7366387248039246,
0.4455453157424927,
-0.37230443954467773,
-0.08280850946903229,
-0.17069296538829803,
-0.31705108284950256,
-0.4125860631465912,
-0.4002687931060791,
0.5054391622543335,
-0.8391203880310059,
0.25758132338523865,
-0.08796453475952148,
0.7709038257598877,
0.04290685057640076,
-0.5658206939697266,
-0.5005848407745361,
-0.736955463886261,
0.878455400466919,
-0.23661278188228607,
0.025042768567800522,
0.4965716600418091,
0.17146368324756622,
-0.021947205066680908,
-0.7300032377243042,
-0.7487900257110596,
-0.23336565494537354,
-0.29720887541770935,
0.43026411533355713,
0.1234346479177475,
-0.14195966720581055,
-0.15627169609069824,
0.5082710981369019,
-0.46036237478256226,
-0.044689204543828964,
-0.24934718012809753,
-0.009391763247549534,
0.46521252393722534,
0.34634992480278015,
0.2605457901954651,
-0.4731919765472412,
-0.41608449816703796,
-0.07737161219120026,
-0.507588267326355,
0.308830589056015,
0.5909044742584229,
0.5203638076782227,
-0.2685031592845917,
0.4759334623813629,
-0.04357563331723213,
0.661980152130127,
0.04187777638435364,
0.13281448185443878,
0.06790744513273239,
-0.516281008720398,
-0.025545205920934677,
-0.14604803919792175,
0.7874744534492493,
0.1415761113166809,
-0.26201173663139343,
-0.016451101750135422,
0.1810225397348404,
0.27840715646743774,
0.4936830699443817,
-0.7184261679649353,
-0.5836893320083618,
-0.0011215063277631998,
-0.5588672757148743,
-0.5173603892326355,
0.135451540350914,
-0.8965280652046204,
-0.06517571210861206,
-0.7169427871704102,
0.2601046562194824,
-0.14071880280971527,
0.04279429838061333,
-0.30684220790863037,
0.3174809217453003,
0.20333319902420044,
0.5096626877784729,
-0.5676824450492859,
0.3030737638473511,
0.49447396397590637,
0.9244663715362549,
-0.4796566963195801,
0.07213553786277771,
-0.6257305145263672,
-0.2756219804286957,
-0.6815711855888367,
0.7499027252197266,
-0.6927283406257629,
-0.24045981466770172,
-0.042800579220056534,
-0.08058103919029236,
-0.24634011089801788,
-0.21191073954105377,
0.46920230984687805,
-0.7569906711578369,
0.2877746820449829,
-0.36928099393844604,
-0.5357276201248169,
-0.0903795063495636,
0.2991190552711487,
-0.9110209941864014,
0.7902845740318298,
-0.03785300999879837,
-0.847542941570282,
0.3660888075828552,
-0.14866018295288086,
-0.08397454768419266,
-0.05841269716620445,
-0.40485110878944397,
-0.7610337138175964,
-0.150355726480484,
0.046247486025094986,
0.5714454650878906,
-0.30972301959991455,
0.41674885153770447,
-0.38954463601112366,
-0.1611454337835312,
0.4781833589076996,
-0.44191887974739075,
0.3038843870162964,
0.23292005062103271,
0.1125887930393219,
-0.13275779783725739,
-0.7977923154830933,
-0.06391549110412598,
-0.1796688735485077,
-0.30312126874923706,
-0.7218617796897888,
0.4141533076763153,
0.04876915365457535,
0.29381275177001953,
0.28165867924690247,
-0.272186815738678,
0.21241097152233124,
-0.20766958594322205,
-0.0786806270480156,
0.7110123634338379,
0.3896390497684479,
0.6102701425552368,
-0.1220991313457489,
0.5480490326881409,
0.3905605375766754,
-0.16267864406108856,
0.04276735708117485,
-0.4817441701889038,
-0.607184648513794,
-0.26780182123184204,
0.4776104688644409,
0.5348846912384033,
-1.0022262334823608,
0.4707290232181549,
-0.04243748262524605,
-0.46022674441337585,
-0.19582392275333405,
0.13334475457668304,
0.6707019805908203,
0.3866310715675354,
0.44485798478126526,
-0.681726336479187,
-0.3489323556423187,
-0.7853685021400452,
-0.09811079502105713,
-0.33170145750045776,
0.22454513609409332,
0.26497092843055725,
0.4241546094417572,
0.1976081281900406,
1.0952261686325073,
-0.8858302235603333,
-0.7623163461685181,
-0.20093609392642975,
0.5120502710342407,
-0.07514553517103195,
0.505622923374176,
0.6301518082618713,
-0.8459306359291077,
-0.4315352141857147,
-0.32225629687309265,
-1.0487644672393799,
0.24032904207706451,
-0.35954442620277405,
-0.29916617274284363,
-0.12598522007465363,
0.5342350602149963,
0.008642460219562054,
0.6985135078430176,
0.46193912625312805,
-0.34908080101013184,
0.46194151043891907,
-0.23838718235492706,
0.18582451343536377,
-1.3169814348220825,
0.024187946692109108,
0.28072190284729004,
-0.0029148540925234556,
-0.708376944065094,
-0.11358626186847687,
-0.09586521983146667,
-0.003959194757044315,
-0.417161226272583,
0.3237888216972351,
-0.3032037913799286,
0.04999366030097008,
-0.38423168659210205,
0.3695821464061737,
-0.2199355810880661,
0.7250558137893677,
0.36983054876327515,
0.7590340971946716,
0.22176815569400787,
-0.7556385397911072,
-0.009613160975277424,
0.41985201835632324,
-0.1244429275393486,
0.6267215609550476,
-0.39136114716529846,
-0.00007578716758871451,
-0.1961822509765625,
0.40593063831329346,
-1.0494080781936646,
0.044819507747888565,
0.00587418582290411,
-0.5911704301834106,
-0.007092467974871397,
0.11503782868385315,
-0.4875989854335785,
0.02711651474237442,
-0.25967124104499817,
0.7012861371040344,
-0.04079129174351692,
-0.5705013871192932,
0.38478633761405945,
0.3584055006504059,
-0.07983274012804031,
-0.517250657081604,
-0.2971298396587372,
-0.2265329658985138,
-0.07474881410598755,
-0.24831704795360565,
0.2525291442871094,
-0.16899769008159637,
-0.22292165458202362,
-0.10332480072975159,
-0.02795843966305256,
-0.3613074719905853,
0.09734822064638138,
0.22205431759357452,
0.4929881989955902,
-0.13813799619674683,
0.3287517726421356,
0.08539571613073349,
-0.0953124538064003,
0.1147308275103569,
0.043603502213954926,
0.17791436612606049,
-0.25606676936149597,
-0.10864695906639099,
-0.6102370023727417,
0.17596757411956787,
0.13064952194690704,
-0.10272831469774246,
0.840352475643158,
0.28689709305763245,
-0.38582199811935425,
-0.016979435458779335,
0.06990502774715424,
-0.014062976464629173,
-0.36835864186286926,
0.24017208814620972,
-0.31951579451560974,
-0.4321630895137787,
0.56150221824646,
0.018701978027820587,
-0.19608120620250702,
0.595697283744812,
0.5939757227897644,
-0.06526640802621841,
0.6581910252571106,
0.8493667244911194,
0.008571472018957138,
0.5747920274734497,
-0.3557783365249634,
0.33670467138290405,
-0.7909969091415405,
-0.3530504107475281,
-0.5420584678649902,
-0.09721241891384125,
-0.8774297833442688,
-0.47501206398010254,
0.4235427677631378,
0.1336168348789215,
0.17692172527313232,
0.14989392459392548,
-0.3627941906452179,
0.325687438249588,
0.42828109860420227,
0.31390535831451416,
0.2850622832775116,
-0.34370213747024536,
-0.3001381754875183,
-0.3049977123737335,
-0.367604523897171,
-0.7894852161407471,
1.1858413219451904,
0.14472797513008118,
0.7012909650802612,
0.262175977230072,
0.5073153376579285,
0.3486334979534149,
0.3077496588230133,
-0.9319232106208801,
0.3706652820110321,
-0.4475806653499603,
-0.41904979944229126,
-0.14609688520431519,
-0.17506694793701172,
-0.8978064656257629,
0.42757901549339294,
-0.5949267148971558,
-0.6716268062591553,
0.4354688823223114,
0.23201890289783478,
-0.37081414461135864,
0.12723292410373688,
-0.6298537254333496,
0.8087717294692993,
-0.03456386551260948,
-0.6123644709587097,
-0.032056257128715515,
-0.6802782416343689,
0.5697383880615234,
-0.4568237364292145,
0.07624588906764984,
0.13850636780261993,
0.21649551391601562,
1.060070276260376,
-0.4564838409423828,
1.0226099491119385,
-0.09416279196739197,
-0.05195531249046326,
0.6730791926383972,
-0.0072229402139782906,
0.25977760553359985,
0.33269166946411133,
0.20054525136947632,
-0.21348565816879272,
0.1449054330587387,
-0.4454100430011749,
-0.557857871055603,
0.7017583847045898,
-1.0802174806594849,
-0.233621284365654,
-0.9010592699050903,
-0.40621182322502136,
-0.35958078503608704,
-0.05774788185954094,
-0.046801455318927765,
0.39665135741233826,
-0.47369447350502014,
0.2983453869819641,
0.6709508895874023,
-0.3194963335990906,
0.26584041118621826,
0.5577815175056458,
0.2328626662492752,
-0.10758227854967117,
1.0886999368667603,
0.13485638797283173,
0.13980446755886078,
0.7335212826728821,
0.11759006232023239,
-0.09380879253149033,
-0.276850163936615,
0.0026950277388095856,
0.09846704453229904,
-0.6657459139823914,
-0.1809990555047989,
-0.5491964221000671,
-0.19789086282253265,
-0.17922097444534302,
-0.21346525847911835,
-0.4052904546260834,
-0.4798614978790283,
-0.7555451393127441,
-0.09068344533443451,
-0.17896084487438202,
0.6638043522834778,
0.18275704979896545,
0.6149898767471313,
-0.5399034023284912,
0.5002202391624451,
0.45082587003707886,
0.11275207996368408,
0.015126553364098072,
-0.34957820177078247,
-0.26862746477127075,
-0.20751844346523285,
-0.7773964405059814,
-0.8313061594963074,
0.47299936413764954,
0.024966461583971977,
0.5535507798194885,
0.26562929153442383,
0.1609872579574585,
0.5857101082801819,
-0.34773558378219604,
1.0124746561050415,
0.26667320728302,
-0.9238604307174683,
0.5574620962142944,
-0.23816771805286407,
0.09530376642942429,
0.6380098462104797,
0.50188809633255,
-0.23353007435798645,
-0.5482473373413086,
-0.722556471824646,
-1.0043461322784424,
0.7206380367279053,
0.4483068287372589,
-0.024645114317536354,
0.018128184601664543,
0.4745144546031952,
0.09925668686628342,
0.07029777765274048,
-0.5627663135528564,
-0.33651381731033325,
-0.1910889744758606,
-0.39499643445014954,
-0.22142156958580017,
-0.28764379024505615,
0.005878993775695562,
0.15849585831165314,
0.5817743539810181,
-0.419314444065094,
0.5011172890663147,
0.10601640492677689,
-0.27270397543907166,
0.24995890259742737,
0.3500119745731354,
0.571280300617218,
0.7296132445335388,
-0.24426063895225525,
0.1328183263540268,
-0.08685702085494995,
-0.8384025692939758,
0.20274019241333008,
0.04345215484499931,
-0.04207611083984375,
-0.22100363671779633,
0.47141367197036743,
0.5006343126296997,
0.05774915963411331,
-0.29006072878837585,
0.8433736562728882,
-0.42895421385765076,
-0.15187206864356995,
-0.6214297413825989,
-0.29883620142936707,
-0.31047841906547546,
-0.0539025254547596,
0.4168223440647125,
0.14582325518131256,
0.2085154503583908,
-0.5737733244895935,
0.4064181447029114,
0.23894093930721283,
-0.5099667906761169,
-0.4750773012638092,
0.7366266250610352,
0.12520663440227509,
0.21434420347213745,
0.6245742440223694,
-0.1448725163936615,
-0.2454364150762558,
0.7395555973052979,
0.20863717794418335,
0.6030085682868958,
-0.06541439145803452,
0.30425992608070374,
0.5485242009162903,
0.05113464221358299,
-0.0011254785349592566,
0.07694435864686966,
0.05526608228683472,
-0.6932715177536011,
-0.21889331936836243,
-0.6855620741844177,
-0.5971231460571289,
0.15357893705368042,
-1.0987132787704468,
0.32896286249160767,
-0.4358762502670288,
0.010008124634623528,
0.3487037420272827,
0.24533581733703613,
-0.753116250038147,
0.5544434189796448,
0.009676648303866386,
0.235338032245636,
-1.2916978597640991,
0.9847834706306458,
0.6734083890914917,
-0.7638072967529297,
-0.8427937626838684,
0.2531346082687378,
0.09259986132383347,
-0.5638618469238281,
0.7299724221229553,
-0.025851335376501083,
-0.11802581697702408,
-0.5676679015159607,
-0.5281326770782471,
-0.8105882406234741,
1.1020399332046509,
-0.08201059699058533,
-0.3756694793701172,
-0.08462856709957123,
-0.05180986598134041,
0.9389587640762329,
-0.43672820925712585,
0.2530566155910492,
0.43756380677223206,
-0.08676796406507492,
0.2688097655773163,
-0.5718406438827515,
0.025677010416984558,
-0.15700462460517883,
0.14489349722862244,
-0.05808454751968384,
-0.7686473727226257,
0.8895419836044312,
-0.0912691205739975,
0.021571727469563484,
0.20923195779323578,
1.1813634634017944,
0.45804041624069214,
0.4738982617855072,
0.39157387614250183,
0.24847647547721863,
0.6228326559066772,
-0.09220067411661148,
0.7777702212333679,
-0.1825975924730301,
0.4634486436843872,
1.2275192737579346,
-0.059873610734939575,
1.0528829097747803,
0.3597467541694641,
-0.13435028493404388,
0.83980792760849,
0.6667266488075256,
0.3204266130924225,
0.6472305655479431,
0.2426862120628357,
-0.1104845181107521,
-0.3011961281299591,
0.0971749946475029,
-0.008469834923744202,
0.7380884289741516,
0.614468514919281,
-0.3041727840900421,
0.039990998804569244,
-0.07541118562221527,
-0.05466080084443092,
0.5391783118247986,
-0.26715710759162903,
0.7888367772102356,
0.23751944303512573,
-0.7473968863487244,
0.11628261208534241,
0.08324315398931503,
0.4804920256137848,
-0.35695400834083557,
-0.3592682182788849,
-0.1606418341398239,
0.36591580510139465,
-0.22174061834812164,
-0.5679462552070618,
0.29192981123924255,
-0.10148187726736069,
-0.36105531454086304,
-0.10483132302761078,
0.49270203709602356,
-0.4815791845321655,
-0.5055136680603027,
0.09954125434160233,
0.5912012457847595,
0.2152797281742096,
0.31436511874198914,
-0.5020737648010254,
-0.3602951467037201,
-0.29890963435173035,
0.0818408876657486,
0.4067761301994324,
0.29952555894851685,
-0.37968629598617554,
0.2968371510505676,
0.4349674880504608,
-0.15853141248226166,
-0.06447437405586243,
-0.0740075334906578,
0.8312563896179199,
-0.6438312530517578,
-0.8757684230804443,
-0.33214855194091797,
0.4090422987937927,
0.14045079052448273,
-0.19947053492069244,
0.6155470609664917,
0.6618066430091858,
0.6564223766326904,
0.1309317946434021,
0.6584108471870422,
-0.05824005976319313,
0.7018901109695435,
-0.746945321559906,
0.5183697938919067,
-0.5170149803161621,
0.3368074595928192,
-0.5733487010002136,
-0.6228339672088623,
-0.2387392669916153,
0.6045538187026978,
-0.5225369334220886,
-0.06339219212532043,
1.307142972946167,
0.3760416507720947,
0.07224884629249573,
0.1668803095817566,
0.17999841272830963,
-0.14657610654830933,
0.5599178075790405,
0.4485607147216797,
0.5077211856842041,
-0.6283318400382996,
0.5124127864837646,
-0.20455621182918549,
-0.3641757071018219,
0.013139878399670124,
-0.6387470364570618,
-0.9917625188827515,
-0.9853383302688599,
-0.3594836890697479,
-0.3384571075439453,
-0.1614811271429062,
0.578476071357727,
0.4031044542789459,
-0.7586144208908081,
-0.10825331509113312,
0.07082024961709976,
0.02921290695667267,
-0.3800695240497589,
-0.2777769863605499,
0.8397060632705688,
-0.5280786156654358,
-0.8649088144302368,
0.190997913479805,
-0.19189785420894623,
0.0672982782125473,
-0.24303953349590302,
0.19964122772216797,
-0.5591680407524109,
0.16108976304531097,
0.7513405084609985,
0.052159473299980164,
-0.4790474772453308,
-0.2520322799682617,
-0.15485574305057526,
-0.3112911283969879,
0.08424422889947891,
1.020835518836975,
-0.8449616432189941,
0.7263311147689819,
0.4512009024620056,
0.4616079330444336,
0.45311686396598816,
0.328487366437912,
0.6204836964607239,
-1.0393543243408203,
0.14057980477809906,
0.036834392696619034,
0.1588771939277649,
0.09939317405223846,
-0.5936100482940674,
0.323659211397171,
0.376473605632782,
-0.5891194939613342,
-0.3820946514606476,
0.12240476161241531,
-1.2801491022109985,
-0.2914353013038635,
1.0474790334701538,
-0.35575559735298157,
-0.23652130365371704,
-0.1440744698047638,
-0.018254881724715233,
0.34323185682296753,
-0.45626962184906006,
0.7755993008613586,
0.7379313707351685,
-0.2917429804801941,
0.22346821427345276,
-0.6177587509155273,
0.48944225907325745,
0.3518246114253998,
-1.1872309446334839,
-0.21671897172927856,
0.5568082928657532,
0.16163647174835205,
0.37428727746009827,
0.8892320394515991,
-0.19856832921504974,
0.26301759481430054,
-0.11082247644662857,
-0.22537274658679962,
0.43789881467819214,
-0.5026455521583557,
-0.34071311354637146,
0.31644538044929504,
0.0713919848203659,
-0.5673826932907104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12975v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12975v1 | SHIELD: Evaluation and Defense Strategies for Copyright Compliance in LLM Text Generation | 2024-06-18T18:00:03 | 2024-06-18T18:00:03 | Xiaoze Liu, Ting Sun, Tianyang Xu, Feijie Wu, Cunxiang Wang, Xiaoqian Wang, Jing Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Large Language Models (LLMs) have transformed machine learning but raised
significant legal concerns due to their potential to produce text that
infringes on copyrights, resulting in several high-profile lawsuits. The legal
landscape is struggling to keep pace with these rapid advancements, with
ongoing debates about whether generated text might plagiarize copyrighted
materials. Current LLMs may infringe on copyrights or overly restrict
non-copyrighted texts, leading to these challenges: (i) the need for a
comprehensive evaluation benchmark to assess copyright compliance from multiple
aspects; (ii) evaluating robustness against safeguard bypassing attacks; and
(iii) developing effective defenses targeted against the generation of
copyrighted text. To tackle these challenges, we introduce a curated dataset to
evaluate methods, test attack strategies, and propose lightweight, real-time
defenses to prevent the generation of copyrighted text, ensuring the safe and
lawful use of LLMs. Our experiments demonstrate that current LLMs frequently
output copyrighted text, and that jailbreaking attacks can significantly
increase the volume of copyrighted output. Our proposed defense mechanisms
significantly reduce the volume of copyrighted text generated by LLMs by
effectively refusing malicious requests. Code is publicly available at
https://github.com/xz-liu/SHIELD | [
-0.3518446683883667,
-0.829455554485321,
0.32865890860557556,
0.15107855200767517,
-0.26718372106552124,
0.4274410307407379,
-0.08050873130559921,
-0.48674148321151733,
-0.08616767078638077,
1.1279047727584839,
-0.5304871797561646,
-0.402942031621933,
-0.7667837738990784,
0.24300669133663177,
-0.6233788132667542,
1.1506569385528564,
-0.17639710009098053,
-0.04440807178616524,
-0.318930983543396,
0.03380382061004639,
-0.39994335174560547,
-0.5756457448005676,
-0.475276380777359,
-0.09573516249656677,
0.26535913348197937,
0.24165819585323334,
0.3447541892528534,
0.7751491665840149,
0.5989106893539429,
0.2706449031829834,
-0.006056603509932756,
-0.03161071613430977,
-0.5648622512817383,
0.6567241549491882,
-0.22644680738449097,
-0.25092652440071106,
-0.29867878556251526,
0.08893391489982605,
0.6657024621963501,
0.17158615589141846,
0.2607754170894623,
0.16308225691318512,
0.1848914623260498,
0.641169548034668,
-0.8959817290306091,
-0.31522083282470703,
-0.9049619436264038,
0.14721381664276123,
-0.32694530487060547,
-0.22864331305027008,
-0.7164133787155151,
-0.19448548555374146,
-0.06644367426633835,
-0.3144950866699219,
0.15698358416557312,
0.28414392471313477,
0.6955935955047607,
0.29654523730278015,
-0.4489913582801819,
-0.41474640369415283,
-0.4217380881309509,
0.8180730938911438,
-0.545056164264679,
0.13965699076652527,
0.36891239881515503,
0.08513193577528,
-0.3642047345638275,
-1.0384026765823364,
-0.4894094467163086,
-0.40545302629470825,
0.3905258774757385,
0.28842103481292725,
-0.6050226092338562,
0.07008450478315353,
0.42360782623291016,
0.14119184017181396,
-0.5428456664085388,
0.3507554531097412,
-0.18726211786270142,
-0.3913056254386902,
0.9088714718818665,
0.2082953006029129,
0.6225849390029907,
-0.1702321618795395,
-0.5793440937995911,
-0.14162899553775787,
-1.1147692203521729,
-0.2005503922700882,
0.8373229503631592,
-0.009806153364479542,
-0.07114853709936142,
0.7682507634162903,
0.09596742689609528,
0.4049881100654602,
-0.020377514883875847,
0.10587047785520554,
-0.0541829913854599,
-0.16190677881240845,
-0.19177857041358948,
0.32469019293785095,
0.9314766526222229,
0.41473641991615295,
0.0458986833691597,
-0.12627947330474854,
-0.23102903366088867,
-0.07565896213054657,
0.40994036197662354,
-1.012436866760254,
0.017745858058333397,
0.2628236413002014,
-0.587006688117981,
-0.7837119102478027,
0.23819370567798615,
-0.8836804628372192,
-0.9088436365127563,
-0.15576963126659393,
0.29829737544059753,
-0.17512443661689758,
-0.026158878579735756,
0.14449262619018555,
-0.24441970884799957,
0.15026052296161652,
-0.18498767912387848,
-0.5418451428413391,
0.3375868499279022,
0.7467765808105469,
0.6563913822174072,
-0.29732537269592285,
-0.21337942779064178,
-1.0303232669830322,
0.21443834900856018,
-0.2547174096107483,
0.6040419340133667,
-0.14298312366008759,
-0.6238275766372681,
0.09827930480241776,
0.0718972235918045,
-0.059428587555885315,
-0.6854339241981506,
0.6792410612106323,
-0.6356495022773743,
-0.05572860315442085,
0.10938923805952072,
-0.6925692558288574,
0.1326877623796463,
0.14939913153648376,
-1.0121592283248901,
0.58397376537323,
-0.057033516466617584,
-0.995646059513092,
0.1403593122959137,
-0.455684095621109,
-0.754332423210144,
0.14037111401557922,
0.001897105248644948,
-0.8359296917915344,
0.060325220227241516,
0.05036468803882599,
0.5267581939697266,
-0.3828953504562378,
0.11321162432432175,
-0.3981459438800812,
-0.08979139477014542,
0.6190769672393799,
-0.39397507905960083,
0.9196290969848633,
0.5621089935302734,
-0.6469795107841492,
0.32589584589004517,
-0.5903047323226929,
-0.05638476461172104,
0.42269304394721985,
-0.2269856482744217,
-0.16934633255004883,
0.3036923110485077,
-0.015313182957470417,
-0.037945374846458435,
0.21715477108955383,
-0.6357883214950562,
0.047485850751399994,
-0.3316669166088104,
0.6121107339859009,
0.7333133816719055,
0.16933360695838928,
0.27597054839134216,
-0.6715050339698792,
0.7692579030990601,
-0.21795833110809326,
0.23582729697227478,
-0.18882988393306732,
-0.41886940598487854,
-0.4144335091114044,
-0.3697042465209961,
0.1692793220281601,
0.7077811360359192,
-0.8448023796081543,
0.3980364203453064,
-0.12609270215034485,
-0.42242950201034546,
-0.4803449213504791,
0.5140248537063599,
0.6276241540908813,
0.31059643626213074,
0.2585827112197876,
-0.2664257287979126,
-0.7285470366477966,
-0.628975510597229,
-0.3881746232509613,
0.062313053756952286,
0.007136533036828041,
0.1524563431739807,
0.6041744351387024,
-0.35645270347595215,
0.8789449334144592,
-0.3572777509689331,
-0.023669281974434853,
-0.5779386162757874,
0.0732380673289299,
-0.14512528479099274,
0.476644366979599,
0.4613649249076843,
-0.6640469431877136,
-0.2911200523376465,
-0.2022310197353363,
-0.7098562717437744,
-0.6077567338943481,
-0.21192675828933716,
-0.07940267771482468,
0.2366257607936859,
0.725508987903595,
-0.32324230670928955,
0.33676019310951233,
0.5765988230705261,
-0.4424140155315399,
0.8057461977005005,
0.06494563817977905,
0.0019364894833415747,
-1.2016407251358032,
0.008482511155307293,
-0.11583105474710464,
-0.28206390142440796,
-0.672930896282196,
0.4440280795097351,
0.028415527194738388,
-0.19239568710327148,
-0.6167473196983337,
0.6483497023582458,
-0.20109538733959198,
0.1976175457239151,
-0.42989978194236755,
0.1277138739824295,
0.1589125692844391,
-0.1995585560798645,
-0.1494547426700592,
0.7025393843650818,
0.3066839873790741,
-0.4821338355541229,
0.5073909759521484,
0.048997506499290466,
-0.4697076082229614,
0.6553417444229126,
-0.7054035663604736,
0.19684629142284393,
-0.07615332305431366,
0.3493902087211609,
-0.5169076323509216,
-0.12714090943336487,
0.2974524199962616,
-0.30637800693511963,
0.3568740785121918,
-0.26843610405921936,
-0.4996317923069,
-0.22800296545028687,
-0.795208215713501,
0.2742762565612793,
0.44278526306152344,
-0.6114429235458374,
0.48277372121810913,
0.4420427978038788,
-0.12094389647245407,
-0.8309947848320007,
-0.8202967047691345,
0.3570312261581421,
-0.48096925020217896,
-0.699587881565094,
0.6667301654815674,
-0.3438090980052948,
-0.5196237564086914,
-0.07165665179491043,
0.12585602700710297,
0.1939513385295868,
0.49321895837783813,
0.4170650839805603,
0.17654630541801453,
0.11819978803396225,
-0.29361701011657715,
0.09164059907197952,
-0.03983071818947792,
0.3735867440700531,
-0.3958302140235901,
0.5852877497673035,
0.16996602714061737,
-0.5023213028907776,
-0.17739547789096832,
0.22454963624477386,
0.4677957594394684,
-0.13110724091529846,
0.42438971996307373,
0.547088623046875,
-0.18267028033733368,
-0.582917332649231,
-0.46606534719467163,
-0.13988129794597626,
-0.4865769147872925,
0.33186498284339905,
-0.2508184015750885,
-1.039426565170288,
0.45454561710357666,
-0.10521422326564789,
0.1163710281252861,
0.46628791093826294,
0.7008329033851624,
0.07468467205762863,
0.6913386583328247,
0.3726475238800049,
-0.25266703963279724,
0.48159071803092957,
-0.1844785511493683,
0.14779022336006165,
-0.8075094819068909,
-0.110454261302948,
-0.6091625690460205,
-0.12652011215686798,
-0.7074450850486755,
-0.24486970901489258,
-0.04165267199277878,
0.1340583860874176,
-0.31796255707740784,
0.5378703474998474,
-0.565329909324646,
0.5336008667945862,
0.5675588250160217,
0.06154954060912132,
0.3499283194541931,
-0.022543789818882942,
-0.12758800387382507,
0.11644025892019272,
-0.4911743998527527,
-0.5717209577560425,
1.2988901138305664,
0.5606639385223389,
0.8643840551376343,
0.19352224469184875,
0.9524022936820984,
0.7647228240966797,
0.35938549041748047,
-0.704155445098877,
0.5969082713127136,
-0.18065762519836426,
-0.6431715488433838,
0.1441918909549713,
-0.7125711441040039,
-1.1485008001327515,
0.04593070223927498,
-0.35735011100769043,
-0.6227797269821167,
-0.2888907194137573,
-0.16819675266742706,
0.020766731351614,
0.46823999285697937,
-0.438225656747818,
0.6777584552764893,
-0.42626631259918213,
-0.8594692349433899,
-0.05934872850775719,
-0.5112065076828003,
0.48963674902915955,
-0.39418792724609375,
0.31741905212402344,
0.05461844056844711,
-0.03089585155248642,
0.8163527250289917,
-0.3605717122554779,
0.9067828059196472,
-0.01880066841840744,
-0.11627805233001709,
0.5883685946464539,
0.3452407717704773,
0.4499596655368805,
-0.03381716087460518,
0.09257324784994125,
-0.06278470158576965,
0.11276472359895706,
-0.3019964098930359,
-0.22382038831710815,
0.6687336564064026,
-0.5228232741355896,
-0.5441479086875916,
-0.24492888152599335,
-0.48527470231056213,
0.17127235233783722,
0.4181097149848938,
0.59229576587677,
0.20280010998249054,
-0.24739044904708862,
0.2697364389896393,
0.870376467704773,
-0.48634228110313416,
0.47955378890037537,
0.3432965874671936,
-0.2602445185184479,
-0.7194218039512634,
1.1624457836151123,
-0.12821532785892487,
0.2223322093486786,
0.267622172832489,
0.31546035408973694,
-0.3630044758319855,
-0.8011722564697266,
-0.45331236720085144,
0.028662070631980896,
-0.6478525400161743,
-0.47011202573776245,
-0.37084224820137024,
-0.42467746138572693,
-0.4642464518547058,
-0.2789633870124817,
-0.07147537171840668,
-0.21233998239040375,
-0.12767082452774048,
-0.027211079373955727,
0.32524916529655457,
0.8653758764266968,
0.2555285692214966,
0.1408330202102661,
-0.8710346221923828,
-0.04304027929902077,
0.003682323032990098,
0.2791883647441864,
-0.17960990965366364,
-0.5871998071670532,
-0.059892959892749786,
-0.2736503481864929,
-0.610054075717926,
-0.8836336135864258,
0.321243554353714,
-0.2206270545721054,
0.607549250125885,
0.27930212020874023,
0.44846490025520325,
-0.04058963060379028,
-0.468923419713974,
0.6879207491874695,
0.20315638184547424,
-1.207373023033142,
0.35018929839134216,
-0.321467787027359,
-0.06673405319452286,
0.2502274811267853,
0.08568751811981201,
-0.07633641362190247,
-0.48698902130126953,
-0.5799272060394287,
-0.7926852107048035,
0.13876962661743164,
0.38717684149742126,
0.26901373267173767,
0.10951292514801025,
0.15173812210559845,
-0.2291909158229828,
0.22960570454597473,
-0.8086598515510559,
0.12878012657165527,
-0.2058119773864746,
-0.46172550320625305,
0.26762697100639343,
-0.25937139987945557,
-0.3648698925971985,
0.21126919984817505,
0.6991913318634033,
0.0017837508348748088,
-0.06255453079938889,
0.04257681220769882,
-0.3465116620063782,
0.15213243663311005,
0.42019009590148926,
0.7511730194091797,
0.028788913041353226,
0.06474165618419647,
0.2526933550834656,
0.1501127928495407,
-0.789821207523346,
0.205945685505867,
0.23500071465969086,
-0.31289201974868774,
-0.3112497925758362,
0.5419704914093018,
0.49105775356292725,
0.05605950206518173,
-0.9131955504417419,
0.5992900729179382,
0.1021474227309227,
-0.5010137557983398,
-0.18600235879421234,
0.021346693858504295,
-0.1348980814218521,
0.23230983316898346,
0.07773275673389435,
-0.3651234805583954,
0.027981994673609734,
-0.2241598516702652,
0.3310064673423767,
0.5516726970672607,
-0.23640897870063782,
0.04011628031730652,
0.8080018162727356,
0.07626541703939438,
-0.08734798431396484,
0.2192261666059494,
-0.012027239426970482,
-0.7289422154426575,
0.6848531365394592,
0.812676191329956,
1.1286778450012207,
-0.08282459527254105,
-0.1542784720659256,
0.02564316615462303,
0.5337473750114441,
-0.017587732523679733,
-0.01497008465230465,
-0.009553724899888039,
-0.6949676275253296,
-0.34686189889907837,
-0.5139524936676025,
-0.5703232884407043,
0.13683143258094788,
-0.36123159527778625,
0.23332491517066956,
-0.7658165097236633,
-0.34007492661476135,
-0.2748308777809143,
0.1807086169719696,
-0.1976635456085205,
-0.04280402511358261,
0.19188466668128967,
0.8690685629844666,
-0.5089480876922607,
0.7111179232597351,
0.4038865566253662,
-0.4553128778934479,
-0.4363531172275543,
-0.15877500176429749,
0.28489047288894653,
-0.4203394949436188,
0.3892521858215332,
0.18159575760364532,
-0.40020641684532166,
-0.03941313922405243,
-0.786503791809082,
-0.33963146805763245,
0.9981406331062317,
0.40376487374305725,
-0.5021512508392334,
0.5176969766616821,
0.180450439453125,
0.19660529494285583,
-0.4036170542240143,
-0.15279969573020935,
0.5519407391548157,
0.32492318749427795,
-0.1458865851163864,
-0.3537890911102295,
0.22411178052425385,
-0.29953280091285706,
-0.010974009521305561,
0.11143923550844193,
-0.32877254486083984,
0.5575207471847534,
0.045786499977111816,
-0.10766768455505371,
0.2469329535961151,
0.3490724563598633,
0.5915015935897827,
0.6541069149971008,
0.2800087034702301,
0.7166142463684082,
0.5771858096122742,
-0.10528422147035599,
1.1561377048492432,
-0.38991329073905945,
0.0428786464035511,
1.0500330924987793,
-0.6169993877410889,
0.7995982766151428,
0.3294242322444916,
0.12277719378471375,
0.40929606556892395,
0.3238815665245056,
-0.5753262042999268,
0.19614703953266144,
0.8350595235824585,
-0.6566692590713501,
0.11430132389068604,
-0.13147257268428802,
-0.1451960802078247,
0.17309364676475525,
0.15090933442115784,
-0.5254961848258972,
0.09990232437849045,
0.1649087369441986,
0.4917607009410858,
0.4944702386856079,
-0.2505097985267639,
0.8326462507247925,
0.09235874563455582,
-0.48557618260383606,
0.3089620769023895,
0.3203279972076416,
0.6945928335189819,
-0.571281909942627,
0.28322938084602356,
-0.10654281824827194,
0.35674312710762024,
-0.3989522457122803,
-0.775619387626648,
0.16772641241550446,
0.5299862623214722,
-0.20236606895923615,
-0.21391081809997559,
1.009200930595398,
-0.11293011903762817,
-0.1724247932434082,
0.5352612137794495,
0.14385099709033966,
0.08664803206920624,
0.15574835240840912,
-0.7634844183921814,
0.5275238752365112,
-0.09219498932361603,
-0.29563289880752563,
0.6829875111579895,
-0.09871597588062286,
-0.17223435640335083,
0.6692513227462769,
0.8228486180305481,
0.08976204693317413,
0.15276944637298584,
0.16314713656902313,
0.7829275727272034,
-0.33354806900024414,
-0.1380043625831604,
-1.166305422782898,
0.3666021227836609,
-0.2944680154323578,
0.07163883000612259,
0.7540163397789001,
0.6974583268165588,
0.8193773031234741,
0.05137798935174942,
1.1012800931930542,
-0.006976555101573467,
0.13201692700386047,
-0.8112064003944397,
1.050782322883606,
-0.3181440234184265,
0.49595150351524353,
-0.3908846378326416,
-0.8401861190795898,
-0.4816526472568512,
0.2996908128261566,
-0.23571230471134186,
-0.17074431478977203,
0.5359653234481812,
0.6620273590087891,
0.20010466873645782,
-0.012435264885425568,
0.1483004093170166,
-0.10490579158067703,
0.8209586143493652,
0.48158401250839233,
0.9334989786148071,
-0.4205409288406372,
0.7045164704322815,
-0.1894492506980896,
-0.24083660542964935,
0.016145391389727592,
-1.3386847972869873,
-0.9567601084709167,
-0.2923952639102936,
-0.20617914199829102,
-0.9378498196601868,
0.006804239936172962,
0.8960974812507629,
0.4909954369068146,
-0.7624480128288269,
-0.4582819938659668,
-0.232781782746315,
0.27936649322509766,
0.030084360390901566,
-0.22574594616889954,
0.30185896158218384,
-0.3626929819583893,
-0.5622432231903076,
0.5259242057800293,
0.05650819465517998,
0.17880895733833313,
-0.26434728503227234,
-0.19965627789497375,
0.1625915765762329,
0.29153749346733093,
0.65645432472229,
0.412828266620636,
-0.5397178530693054,
0.06400115042924881,
-0.2014801949262619,
-0.356823205947876,
-0.440997838973999,
0.9516671299934387,
-0.42322301864624023,
0.5298883318901062,
0.5617616176605225,
1.160102128982544,
0.32493460178375244,
-0.08583632856607437,
0.556722104549408,
-0.5936851501464844,
0.058285754173994064,
0.18528620898723602,
0.3817501664161682,
0.24426130950450897,
-0.2173449546098709,
0.47000110149383545,
0.40136921405792236,
-0.6222655177116394,
-0.9968914985656738,
0.38901665806770325,
-0.8919284343719482,
-0.5119822025299072,
1.0273308753967285,
-0.307839959859848,
-0.13213977217674255,
-0.018715875223279,
-0.2206144481897354,
0.1869720071554184,
-0.11513666808605194,
0.5974768400192261,
0.5040239095687866,
0.3181394040584564,
-0.10927906632423401,
-0.6844504475593567,
0.507317841053009,
0.329606831073761,
-0.9344196319580078,
0.2361166924238205,
0.4335198998451233,
0.41150879859924316,
-0.09213759750127792,
0.26876023411750793,
-0.3103939890861511,
0.17140640318393707,
-0.09218598902225494,
0.09313877671957016,
-0.2716730237007141,
-0.2650221884250641,
-0.4353286623954773,
0.23539766669273376,
0.10475892573595047,
-0.03256900608539581
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12845v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12845v1 | Interpretable Preferences via Multi-Objective Reward Modeling and Mixture-of-Experts | 2024-06-18T17:58:28 | 2024-06-18T17:58:28 | Haoxiang Wang, Wei Xiong, Tengyang Xie, Han Zhao, Tong Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) has emerged as the primary
method for aligning large language models (LLMs) with human preferences. The
RLHF process typically starts by training a reward model (RM) using human
preference data. Conventional RMs are trained on pairwise responses to the same
user request, with relative ratings indicating which response humans prefer.
The trained RM serves as a proxy for human preferences. However, due to the
black-box nature of RMs, their outputs lack interpretability, as humans cannot
intuitively understand why an RM thinks a response is good or not. As RMs act
as human preference proxies, we believe they should be human-interpretable to
ensure that their internal decision processes are consistent with human
preferences and to prevent reward hacking in LLM alignment. To build RMs with
interpretable preferences, we propose a two-stage approach: i) train an
Absolute-Rating Multi-Objective Reward Model (ArmoRM) with multi-dimensional
absolute-rating data, each dimension corresponding to a human-interpretable
objective (e.g., honesty, verbosity, safety); ii) employ a Mixture-of-Experts
(MoE) strategy with a gating network that automatically selects the most
suitable reward objectives based on the context. We efficiently trained an
ArmoRM with Llama-3 8B and a gating network consisting of a shallow MLP on top
of the ArmoRM. Our trained model, ArmoRM-Llama3-8B, obtains state-of-the-art
performance on RewardBench, a benchmark evaluating RMs for language modeling.
Notably, the performance of our model surpasses the LLM-as-a-judge method with
GPT-4 judges by a margin, and approaches the performance of the much larger
Nemotron-4 340B reward model. | [
-0.474284827709198,
-0.33872827887535095,
0.48882725834846497,
0.12636713683605194,
-0.23045186698436737,
0.12337717413902283,
-0.42534783482551575,
-0.5931722521781921,
0.1492995172739029,
0.6052302122116089,
-0.6091062426567078,
-0.3080289661884308,
-0.6947808861732483,
-0.03957732766866684,
0.139264315366745,
1.1342562437057495,
-0.05876459553837776,
-0.09410613775253296,
-0.09652062505483627,
-0.21428614854812622,
-0.49780675768852234,
-0.7240862250328064,
-0.6012406349182129,
-0.7866834998130798,
0.46397364139556885,
0.6414303779602051,
0.7062332630157471,
0.6589187979698181,
0.20179802179336548,
0.2656213045120239,
0.06076149642467499,
0.37037593126296997,
-0.5034175515174866,
0.04193167760968208,
-0.2973824739456177,
-0.3745492696762085,
-0.44127926230430603,
0.20478032529354095,
0.1614716351032257,
0.13486886024475098,
-0.5133084058761597,
-0.15832127630710602,
0.013697306625545025,
0.5395325422286987,
-0.49690738320350647,
0.4434283971786499,
-0.6430813670158386,
0.08977943658828735,
0.007557191886007786,
-0.42161768674850464,
-0.622448205947876,
-0.11418505012989044,
0.2185005396604538,
-0.5838537216186523,
-0.17873390018939972,
0.35641416907310486,
0.8395437598228455,
0.2938341200351715,
-0.3742274343967438,
-0.14775599539279938,
-0.3232487440109253,
1.1444056034088135,
-0.6303603053092957,
0.4254002869129181,
0.5893445014953613,
0.2716851532459259,
-0.22546571493148804,
-0.11449995636940002,
-0.4483465850353241,
-0.3688879907131195,
-0.14695951342582703,
0.22351524233818054,
0.17802011966705322,
0.1818428486585617,
-0.23107178509235382,
0.1764705777168274,
-0.4411076307296753,
0.32991915941238403,
0.06410880386829376,
-0.2632332146167755,
0.7119016647338867,
0.150881826877594,
0.14701807498931885,
-0.32875776290893555,
-0.6577524542808533,
-0.2959998846054077,
-0.730117917060852,
0.24902166426181793,
0.4406823217868805,
0.31593939661979675,
-0.07081301510334015,
0.4542314112186432,
-0.40304848551750183,
0.6704140901565552,
0.21151098608970642,
-0.2761894464492798,
0.2421804666519165,
0.10394033044576645,
0.017623355612158775,
0.1158718392252922,
0.7969983220100403,
0.563573956489563,
0.180796816945076,
-0.41127920150756836,
-0.43815919756889343,
0.042234987020492554,
0.49123597145080566,
-0.7305777668952942,
-0.2613552510738373,
0.16470861434936523,
-0.49963685870170593,
-0.5050827264785767,
-0.012733454816043377,
-0.6303513050079346,
-0.6551782488822937,
-0.5489419102668762,
0.5609962344169617,
-0.28581753373146057,
-0.3587823510169983,
0.4729253053665161,
-0.04692351445555687,
0.10823994874954224,
0.2844618856906891,
-1.2191764116287231,
0.30410075187683105,
0.7574151754379272,
0.608873724937439,
-0.3722790479660034,
-0.4973253905773163,
-0.655137836933136,
0.12170740216970444,
-0.01854759268462658,
0.9402557611465454,
-0.6131758689880371,
-0.2540799379348755,
-0.21040548384189606,
-0.24345487356185913,
0.049695033580064774,
-0.5375456809997559,
0.7941596508026123,
-0.6904242038726807,
0.1388540267944336,
-0.19107727706432343,
-0.48367947340011597,
-0.2019602209329605,
0.4042353332042694,
-0.40512150526046753,
0.7318515777587891,
0.07818073779344559,
-0.6147403717041016,
0.5831924080848694,
-0.6339988112449646,
-0.14653150737285614,
-0.03391510620713234,
-0.17047671973705292,
-0.28427350521087646,
-0.009677930735051632,
0.5038268566131592,
0.5067600011825562,
-0.1627158671617508,
0.45340654253959656,
-0.3651805520057678,
-0.30587533116340637,
0.39378485083580017,
-0.39573168754577637,
0.04551267623901367,
0.15930932760238647,
-0.4944433867931366,
0.35525259375572205,
-0.5774479508399963,
0.016499055549502373,
0.01458004955202341,
-0.6334695816040039,
-0.247028186917305,
0.4008617103099823,
0.04864949360489845,
0.3827509880065918,
0.2143390029668808,
-0.43137791752815247,
0.07783935219049454,
-0.4740576446056366,
0.44748181104660034,
1.2269290685653687,
-0.17371784150600433,
0.5366013050079346,
-0.3121791183948517,
0.5512844324111938,
0.016681792214512825,
0.07906883955001831,
0.19976024329662323,
-0.40823373198509216,
-0.612375795841217,
-0.26998358964920044,
0.12763185799121857,
0.42575177550315857,
-0.5820506811141968,
0.48404550552368164,
-0.2295817732810974,
-0.3194941282272339,
-0.6391417384147644,
0.013682768680155277,
0.4796019494533539,
0.49238094687461853,
0.5438976883888245,
-0.46377381682395935,
-0.3829706907272339,
-1.127339482307434,
-0.45144304633140564,
-0.430839866399765,
0.00980269256979227,
0.610487163066864,
0.2545376121997833,
-0.17818662524223328,
0.8563182950019836,
-0.6351943612098694,
-0.20910970866680145,
-0.3662714958190918,
0.3611499071121216,
0.20255887508392334,
0.3692217469215393,
0.169624462723732,
-0.6740159392356873,
-0.35197940468788147,
0.09815314412117004,
-0.5177253484725952,
-0.01109211053699255,
-0.015468505211174488,
-0.2667112350463867,
-0.0709100216627121,
0.007257374003529549,
-0.35041964054107666,
0.07551032304763794,
0.5436335206031799,
-0.3356148898601532,
0.5846908092498779,
-0.15810540318489075,
0.32940176129341125,
-0.7283554077148438,
-0.09726782143115997,
0.22840258479118347,
-0.38053300976753235,
-0.48263487219810486,
0.12403011322021484,
0.10495170950889587,
0.31114569306373596,
-0.4105103611946106,
0.9044914841651917,
-0.19772544503211975,
-0.07540732622146606,
-0.4675408601760864,
-0.09112726151943207,
0.06783917546272278,
0.8505008220672607,
0.5023533701896667,
0.7363389134407043,
0.255060076713562,
-0.5504116415977478,
0.2878727614879608,
0.3412051498889923,
-0.47803083062171936,
0.833533525466919,
-0.5877575874328613,
0.19401748478412628,
-0.05844898894429207,
0.3030315637588501,
-0.6150359511375427,
-0.4059399664402008,
0.45183873176574707,
-0.45411375164985657,
0.16454137861728668,
-0.166068896651268,
-0.1806229054927826,
-0.007451547775417566,
-0.2554468512535095,
0.34411194920539856,
0.2503953278064728,
-0.7775762677192688,
0.5949667096138,
0.48815247416496277,
-0.21715864539146423,
-1.0156927108764648,
-0.5273014307022095,
0.13276894390583038,
-0.3292466104030609,
-0.43922343850135803,
0.4694051444530487,
-0.09645982086658478,
-0.08314758539199829,
-0.09283293038606644,
-0.11170655488967896,
0.03357287496328354,
0.21317456662654877,
0.3711158335208893,
0.4036526381969452,
0.1579609513282776,
0.024378569796681404,
-0.04982719570398331,
-0.4066784977912903,
0.10103297233581543,
-0.31627824902534485,
0.4979585111141205,
-0.40162134170532227,
-0.3542211055755615,
-0.3831409811973572,
0.18649329245090485,
0.3607807457447052,
-0.28966808319091797,
0.896087110042572,
0.5395377278327942,
-0.06812985986471176,
-0.14975185692310333,
-0.5709162354469299,
-0.4546758830547333,
-0.4472803473472595,
0.4641913175582886,
-0.41242530941963196,
-0.9296241402626038,
0.3084598481655121,
0.2088184356689453,
0.14416588842868805,
0.189754456281662,
0.6583787202835083,
0.10152224451303482,
1.3551928997039795,
0.3798291087150574,
-0.39272838830947876,
0.5323201417922974,
0.13317304849624634,
0.06633057445287704,
-0.8133365511894226,
-0.508770763874054,
-0.34630441665649414,
-0.36121007800102234,
-0.22764985263347626,
-0.08763784915208817,
0.4538932144641876,
-0.051876116544008255,
-0.2857445478439331,
0.06331893056631088,
-0.3878195285797119,
0.5110121369361877,
0.49309486150741577,
0.45111340284347534,
0.1670028120279312,
0.08010948449373245,
-0.10181190073490143,
0.015152559615671635,
-0.4679275155067444,
-0.4873058497905731,
1.0750502347946167,
0.5170947909355164,
0.9771150946617126,
0.06478355079889297,
0.6057681441307068,
0.3498091399669647,
0.3659001290798187,
-0.9246079325675964,
0.2403590828180313,
0.06376557052135468,
-0.506579577922821,
-0.31312108039855957,
-0.5599789023399353,
-0.7908256649971008,
0.5947893261909485,
-0.41509613394737244,
-0.6756850481033325,
0.14973250031471252,
0.33361077308654785,
-0.29358232021331787,
0.2693711221218109,
-0.6785445809364319,
0.844319760799408,
-0.4870675802230835,
-0.41285282373428345,
-0.5103658437728882,
-0.7362547516822815,
0.36316850781440735,
0.23321443796157837,
0.42167893052101135,
-0.06899053603410721,
0.12417467683553696,
0.732231080532074,
-0.08731561154127121,
0.694457471370697,
-0.2055070847272873,
0.061584874987602234,
-0.302083283662796,
0.04366063326597214,
0.6711838245391846,
0.1834486573934555,
-0.29833129048347473,
0.06717614084482193,
-0.3362620770931244,
-0.4336026906967163,
-0.5750328898429871,
0.6783254146575928,
-1.235925316810608,
-0.5526118874549866,
-0.4872156083583832,
-0.6770370602607727,
-0.36325860023498535,
0.004378851968795061,
-0.03650175407528877,
0.4679712653160095,
-0.020421819761395454,
0.025612708181142807,
0.657622754573822,
-0.22107920050621033,
-0.06839117407798767,
0.50410395860672,
-0.1753690540790558,
-0.42784276604652405,
1.006849765777588,
-0.43083667755126953,
0.3695560693740845,
0.5718485713005066,
0.3380180597305298,
-0.5939258337020874,
-0.5385000109672546,
-0.6648877859115601,
0.11174655705690384,
-0.7263616919517517,
0.002538239350542426,
-0.5885739326477051,
0.07564013451337814,
-0.04053720831871033,
-0.11112656444311142,
-0.31441181898117065,
-0.2125689536333084,
-0.3082747161388397,
-0.17803257703781128,
0.21417580544948578,
0.9155985713005066,
-0.14849503338336945,
0.3297930359840393,
-0.6160351037979126,
0.32206547260284424,
0.5349892973899841,
0.523797333240509,
0.10215695202350616,
-0.6095362305641174,
-0.3956052362918854,
0.13534121215343475,
-0.16297292709350586,
-0.7187591791152954,
0.5011757016181946,
-0.07026304304599762,
0.7506852149963379,
0.5697743892669678,
-0.010089080780744553,
0.5641865134239197,
-0.30172666907310486,
0.5094034075737,
0.17414285242557526,
-0.9021056890487671,
0.22515133023262024,
-0.262738436460495,
-0.15901528298854828,
0.6289904117584229,
0.2140512466430664,
-0.7288844585418701,
-0.15424756705760956,
-0.2828306257724762,
-0.7782630920410156,
1.1418404579162598,
-0.17487876117229462,
-0.14097543060779572,
0.08786283433437347,
0.3798627257347107,
0.33506035804748535,
0.41344740986824036,
-0.8861846327781677,
-0.1203620582818985,
-0.45521634817123413,
-0.13760070502758026,
-0.32925495505332947,
-0.23658066987991333,
-0.1825772225856781,
0.0373477004468441,
0.7527366280555725,
-0.21351322531700134,
0.1367688626050949,
-0.1932024210691452,
-0.3087305724620819,
-0.10104237496852875,
0.6701105833053589,
0.5891894698143005,
0.6775557994842529,
-0.5882473587989807,
0.3355075418949127,
-0.04725965857505798,
-0.03234763443470001,
0.3463382422924042,
-0.13376303017139435,
0.1379210352897644,
-0.5759983062744141,
0.019754063338041306,
1.1460381746292114,
0.33579912781715393,
-0.6919706463813782,
0.5066056847572327,
-0.1991528421640396,
-0.17035752534866333,
0.06525718420743942,
0.11267562210559845,
0.06793344020843506,
0.1347678154706955,
0.15786801278591156,
0.28622016310691833,
0.08252432942390442,
-0.5135617852210999,
0.03873485326766968,
0.4200343191623688,
-0.6695842146873474,
-0.26770901679992676,
0.5504843592643738,
0.1869126558303833,
-0.010478918440639973,
0.5376965999603271,
-0.2512752413749695,
-0.7646722197532654,
0.3056006133556366,
0.36817121505737305,
0.6125121116638184,
-0.15191660821437836,
0.44701752066612244,
0.1688448041677475,
0.21745532751083374,
-0.37898942828178406,
0.0032217835541814566,
-0.064242422580719,
-0.9289476275444031,
-0.36085715889930725,
-0.6504102945327759,
-0.6450561285018921,
0.01791955903172493,
-0.8700205087661743,
0.04857192561030388,
-0.19100485742092133,
0.053221914917230606,
-0.10532796382904053,
-0.2433960884809494,
-0.617380678653717,
0.19505172967910767,
-0.04670023173093796,
0.5253344774246216,
-0.9426559805870056,
0.6460351347923279,
0.7985081076622009,
-0.3756446838378906,
-0.8748964071273804,
-0.19303202629089355,
0.09570932388305664,
-1.1534733772277832,
0.6133880019187927,
0.06550078839063644,
-0.16453513503074646,
-0.15204483270645142,
-0.45721182227134705,
-0.5441019535064697,
0.8351845741271973,
0.19368842244148254,
-0.26878124475479126,
0.14772742986679077,
-0.031001020222902298,
0.3731185495853424,
-0.4028368592262268,
0.625069260597229,
0.6987292766571045,
0.6645235419273376,
-0.08845896273851395,
-0.7808093428611755,
-0.03626135736703873,
-0.1566952019929886,
-0.2991418242454529,
0.19446219503879547,
-0.5570763349533081,
0.775521993637085,
0.011358421295881271,
0.16462506353855133,
-0.1640820950269699,
0.5361558198928833,
0.7034119963645935,
0.03447834774851799,
0.796799898147583,
0.6036452054977417,
0.5918304920196533,
0.07034546136856079,
1.1578686237335205,
-0.22464998066425323,
0.28253233432769775,
0.9260028600692749,
-0.24150894582271576,
1.015648603439331,
0.4494517743587494,
-0.1222253292798996,
0.6139583587646484,
0.8382611870765686,
0.36155185103416443,
0.8074106574058533,
0.13960950076580048,
-0.12862233817577362,
-0.7549241781234741,
-0.20068973302841187,
-0.2879224121570587,
0.34718048572540283,
0.18167109787464142,
-0.05822153389453888,
-0.03284711763262749,
-0.15760372579097748,
-0.032209720462560654,
0.030458973720669746,
-0.27215391397476196,
0.7887551784515381,
0.0762508288025856,
-0.9059642553329468,
0.3350513279438019,
0.40643349289894104,
1.017580509185791,
-0.6147207021713257,
0.001602871692739427,
0.00758034223690629,
0.16675376892089844,
-0.3275849223136902,
-0.8514277935028076,
-0.17262621223926544,
-0.12026470899581909,
-0.27483299374580383,
-0.3408164381980896,
0.5844985842704773,
-0.48366284370422363,
-0.14276202023029327,
0.24536734819412231,
0.36207887530326843,
0.09580501168966293,
-0.21330626308918,
-0.7457317113876343,
-0.18268711864948273,
0.01573777198791504,
-0.3224611282348633,
0.6331379413604736,
-0.03729231655597687,
-0.045245103538036346,
0.8551292419433594,
0.6389992833137512,
0.15243975818157196,
-0.2404109239578247,
0.02828143909573555,
0.8082188367843628,
-0.527929961681366,
-0.7759689688682556,
-0.8094286918640137,
0.4452868103981018,
0.1400357037782669,
-0.13120535016059875,
0.3748488426208496,
0.35566118359565735,
0.6958338022232056,
0.012440163642168045,
0.890031635761261,
0.22681476175785065,
0.3785158097743988,
-0.552439272403717,
0.561964213848114,
-0.6774945855140686,
0.3610846698284149,
-0.17282801866531372,
-0.7624462246894836,
-0.017244266346096992,
0.68427973985672,
-0.3626531958580017,
0.07889857143163681,
0.4703556299209595,
0.7391772270202637,
-0.0648702010512352,
0.05056069791316986,
0.1494964361190796,
-0.004425648599863052,
0.503220796585083,
0.6943050026893616,
1.1432560682296753,
0.17921365797519684,
0.45396581292152405,
-0.14248254895210266,
-0.28558993339538574,
-0.4169124364852905,
-0.8487436771392822,
-0.7397994995117188,
-0.27928364276885986,
0.04739970713853836,
-0.2543089687824249,
0.05609791353344917,
1.3245850801467896,
0.8695945739746094,
-0.8599380850791931,
-0.4016919434070587,
0.101217120885849,
0.34190061688423157,
-0.36902856826782227,
-0.21790017187595367,
0.28655850887298584,
-0.22440172731876373,
-0.5488040447235107,
0.5074663758277893,
0.3301488161087036,
-0.3075857162475586,
-0.464398592710495,
-0.7178834080696106,
0.06715326011180878,
-0.004683702252805233,
0.5043730735778809,
0.09716733545064926,
-0.9000217914581299,
-0.5129915475845337,
-0.04097986966371536,
0.024896936491131783,
0.2060600221157074,
0.5748426914215088,
-0.7639138698577881,
0.500836193561554,
0.3907366394996643,
0.6602062582969666,
0.47432294487953186,
0.16088418662548065,
0.7150093913078308,
-0.6058764457702637,
-0.04107683524489403,
0.08364153653383255,
0.3770630955696106,
0.24950666725635529,
-0.25788307189941406,
0.28652340173721313,
-0.06082693114876747,
-0.8406885266304016,
-0.6463221907615662,
0.29759129881858826,
-0.9949477314949036,
-0.20503169298171997,
1.1857919692993164,
-0.1618046909570694,
0.04228772595524788,
-0.25249508023262024,
-0.28085529804229736,
-0.03127328306436539,
-0.9153875708580017,
0.9742099046707153,
0.7776459455490112,
-0.21950672566890717,
-0.2085825651884079,
-0.37403884530067444,
0.4901517927646637,
0.5732648968696594,
-0.8462132811546326,
-0.03821148723363876,
0.46508660912513733,
0.2451334148645401,
-0.21022868156433105,
0.5618739128112793,
0.07753515988588333,
0.29284706711769104,
-0.4127555191516876,
0.3251412808895111,
-0.2774410545825958,
-0.36090371012687683,
-0.40646782517433167,
0.14764225482940674,
0.5668380856513977,
-0.016101598739624023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12832v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12832v1 | LaMDA: Large Model Fine-Tuning via Spectrally Decomposed Low-Dimensional Adaptation | 2024-06-18T17:52:59 | 2024-06-18T17:52:59 | Seyedarmin Azizi, Souvik Kundu, Massoud Pedram | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Low-rank adaptation (LoRA) has become the default approach to fine-tune large
language models (LLMs) due to its significant reduction in trainable
parameters. However, trainable parameter demand for LoRA increases with
increasing model embedding dimensions, leading to high compute costs.
Additionally, its backward updates require storing high-dimensional
intermediate activations and optimizer states, demanding high peak GPU memory.
In this paper, we introduce large model fine-tuning via spectrally decomposed
low-dimensional adaptation (LaMDA), a novel approach to fine-tuning large
language models, which leverages low-dimensional adaptation to achieve
significant reductions in trainable parameters and peak GPU memory footprint.
LaMDA freezes a first projection matrix (PMA) in the adaptation path while
introducing a low-dimensional trainable square matrix, resulting in substantial
reductions in trainable parameters and peak GPU memory usage. LaMDA gradually
freezes a second projection matrix (PMB) during the early fine-tuning stages,
reducing the compute cost associated with weight updates to enhance parameter
efficiency further. We also present an enhancement, LaMDA++, incorporating a
``lite-weight" adaptive rank allocation for the LoRA path via normalized
spectrum analysis of pre-trained model weights. We evaluate LaMDA/LaMDA++
across various tasks, including natural language understanding with the GLUE
benchmark, text summarization, natural language generation, and complex
reasoning on different LLMs. Results show that LaMDA matches or surpasses the
performance of existing alternatives while requiring up to 17.7x fewer
parameter updates and up to 1.32x lower peak GPU memory usage during
fine-tuning. Code will be publicly available. | [
-0.6814359426498413,
-0.8504335284233093,
0.2876107394695282,
0.003041018033400178,
-0.5717936158180237,
-0.08857353776693344,
-0.5279495120048523,
-0.38648054003715515,
0.17567254602909088,
0.6900544166564941,
-0.3676812946796417,
-0.5758179426193237,
-0.43359631299972534,
-0.4396008551120758,
-0.010387063957750797,
0.8046543598175049,
0.09593287855386734,
-0.19828759133815765,
0.058994170278310776,
-0.2521483302116394,
-0.6703488230705261,
-0.2226964682340622,
-0.9734774827957153,
-0.16682879626750946,
0.7043957710266113,
0.49284645915031433,
0.4714353084564209,
0.5454871654510498,
0.29472115635871887,
0.2819709777832031,
-0.15485672652721405,
0.6192431449890137,
-0.795264482498169,
-0.0746157094836235,
-0.1451561450958252,
-0.4547780454158783,
-0.7173317074775696,
-0.16357088088989258,
0.6767225861549377,
0.580848217010498,
-0.27496737241744995,
0.4155523180961609,
0.06187250837683678,
0.7956427931785583,
-1.006300926208496,
0.2756987512111664,
-0.9043806791305542,
-0.10214885324239731,
-0.3261394798755646,
-0.18780846893787384,
-0.4486447274684906,
-0.28592029213905334,
-0.3610006272792816,
-0.5730301141738892,
-0.15375638008117676,
-0.09909860789775848,
0.685457706451416,
0.6807346940040588,
-0.25485557317733765,
0.014834982343018055,
-0.6822747588157654,
0.5629491806030273,
-0.8294931650161743,
0.3967132568359375,
0.36679574847221375,
0.3115907311439514,
0.04561518505215645,
-0.5452978014945984,
-0.48261138796806335,
-0.02056712843477726,
0.4359104633331299,
-0.0448744036257267,
-0.2688075006008148,
0.17578384280204773,
0.253359317779541,
0.18703974783420563,
-0.28371092677116394,
0.6872317790985107,
-0.4484168589115143,
0.0273421723395586,
0.4976273477077484,
0.18548455834388733,
0.13793784379959106,
-0.0012374656507745385,
-0.17080746591091156,
-0.19864796102046967,
-0.7573695182800293,
0.07191319018602371,
0.27879807353019714,
0.5776901245117188,
-0.3031163811683655,
0.21386556327342987,
0.02564915642142296,
0.8442341685295105,
0.15543484687805176,
-0.037434980273246765,
0.021442821249365807,
-0.03726045787334442,
-0.5306142568588257,
0.20084170997142792,
0.47143176198005676,
0.3158179521560669,
0.14939101040363312,
0.03494853898882866,
0.011152071878314018,
0.057399503886699677,
0.1519140750169754,
-1.0866808891296387,
-0.3440219461917877,
0.047596707940101624,
-0.4858885407447815,
-0.028401877731084824,
-0.5309197902679443,
-0.7461116909980774,
-0.6060991287231445,
-0.4943152964115143,
0.4159137010574341,
-0.3680213987827301,
0.17576321959495544,
0.40216201543807983,
0.3667932450771332,
0.34396302700042725,
0.46802085638046265,
-1.128123164176941,
0.39196932315826416,
0.7412799596786499,
0.6780668497085571,
-0.13866357505321503,
-0.2103094458580017,
-0.8687418103218079,
0.11405903846025467,
-0.4222789704799652,
0.6684531569480896,
-0.5288687944412231,
-0.05120319128036499,
-0.3060409128665924,
-0.18691220879554749,
-0.15894204378128052,
-0.6225000023841858,
0.7867933511734009,
-0.5775352120399475,
0.037402406334877014,
-0.1381189227104187,
-0.26557791233062744,
-0.20224183797836304,
-0.02331453189253807,
-0.577460765838623,
0.8168668746948242,
0.015587052330374718,
-0.44861799478530884,
0.2538723051548004,
-0.8137486577033997,
-0.29566457867622375,
-0.13089261949062347,
0.35824155807495117,
-0.49403277039527893,
0.3261786699295044,
0.40250545740127563,
0.5070189833641052,
-0.603036642074585,
-0.07801417261362076,
-0.3444293737411499,
-0.6056522727012634,
-0.017590554431080818,
-0.24923650920391083,
0.6777815818786621,
0.31575703620910645,
0.07946257293224335,
0.2437659353017807,
-0.9479597210884094,
0.03868516534566879,
-0.005720330867916346,
-0.43750452995300293,
-0.5182855129241943,
-0.022001713514328003,
0.023381587117910385,
-0.02228984422981739,
0.3464328348636627,
-0.3379300534725189,
0.4322911202907562,
-0.4953646957874298,
0.6223338842391968,
0.8456611633300781,
-0.048978544771671295,
0.46388739347457886,
-0.04119795933365822,
0.1713142991065979,
-0.033048659563064575,
0.17181001603603363,
0.00417531980201602,
-0.2091469019651413,
-1.010833501815796,
-0.38840577006340027,
0.4129931926727295,
0.2812790870666504,
-0.5611728429794312,
0.32306361198425293,
-0.3267385959625244,
-0.5092828273773193,
-0.6583655476570129,
0.4519346058368683,
0.27651965618133545,
0.4057061970233917,
0.38127559423446655,
-0.30871427059173584,
-0.6179291009902954,
-0.8074209094047546,
-0.038573671132326126,
0.04096369445323944,
-0.005379695910960436,
0.3442874550819397,
0.35126879811286926,
-0.23740126192569733,
0.5824803709983826,
-0.8042618036270142,
-0.6008841395378113,
0.0649673268198967,
-0.016317259520292282,
0.3392254710197449,
0.3489495813846588,
0.6131696105003357,
-0.4670873284339905,
-0.4985285699367523,
0.07011231780052185,
-0.24455401301383972,
-0.03379581868648529,
0.029230991378426552,
-0.06379637122154236,
0.19865623116493225,
0.5264257788658142,
-0.5009108185768127,
-0.12448249757289886,
0.841162919998169,
-0.3411640524864197,
0.23242664337158203,
-0.6650210618972778,
-0.2860458195209503,
-1.1136000156402588,
0.156705841422081,
-0.1431964635848999,
-0.12615852057933807,
-0.6104403734207153,
0.14416798949241638,
0.04207157716155052,
-0.28396177291870117,
-0.22772590816020966,
0.4928150475025177,
-0.3489622175693512,
-0.06122048199176788,
-0.4055798351764679,
0.27122241258621216,
-0.10644406080245972,
0.6517165899276733,
-0.3385407626628876,
0.7983329892158508,
0.46303972601890564,
-0.5664085745811462,
0.15391287207603455,
0.1948746293783188,
-0.6012750267982483,
0.44464293122291565,
-0.4373224973678589,
0.35520535707473755,
-0.2507207691669464,
0.20016387104988098,
-0.6702418327331543,
-0.03875479847192764,
-0.03824014589190483,
0.01332426443696022,
0.25705331563949585,
-0.19223999977111816,
-0.2841714918613434,
-0.07258648425340652,
-0.36159414052963257,
0.2680857479572296,
0.6485686302185059,
-0.7212715148925781,
0.5722844004631042,
0.5656797289848328,
-0.10970672219991684,
-0.3175216317176819,
-0.5699930191040039,
0.2693905532360077,
-0.18998289108276367,
-0.5024515390396118,
0.33133548498153687,
-0.26887956261634827,
-0.18840372562408447,
-0.2980578541755676,
0.16185027360916138,
-0.111567422747612,
0.3361174762248993,
0.20365747809410095,
0.12109383195638657,
-0.45082220435142517,
0.04282368719577789,
0.15821658074855804,
-0.14520810544490814,
-0.15895168483257294,
-0.1804313361644745,
0.7889411449432373,
-0.15064306557178497,
-0.09834178537130356,
-0.3848884403705597,
-0.11046302318572998,
0.7740842700004578,
-0.4699307978153229,
0.8527879118919373,
0.8878390789031982,
-0.32550695538520813,
-0.6513800024986267,
-0.3737168610095978,
-0.08767621219158173,
-0.5025493502616882,
0.4741618037223816,
-0.3984488546848297,
-0.8049086928367615,
0.674906313419342,
-0.15468977391719818,
-0.19755011796951294,
0.19240090250968933,
0.7005776166915894,
-0.00004399433237267658,
0.7869598269462585,
0.642073392868042,
-0.25428834557533264,
0.5551933646202087,
-0.30769476294517517,
0.24992813169956207,
-1.0780917406082153,
-0.010075329802930355,
-0.46238213777542114,
-0.6817473769187927,
-0.5110098719596863,
-0.6981936693191528,
0.34663593769073486,
0.26804956793785095,
-0.5629526972770691,
0.17190447449684143,
-0.5078113675117493,
0.6897887587547302,
0.31281930208206177,
0.23402619361877441,
0.31474000215530396,
-0.05973779782652855,
0.3008994460105896,
-0.01633450575172901,
-0.5016446709632874,
0.0036963336169719696,
0.8071754574775696,
0.4033997058868408,
0.7040801644325256,
0.15223219990730286,
0.4412502348423004,
0.19426396489143372,
0.0030194201972335577,
-0.6398777365684509,
0.5694316625595093,
-0.8159419298171997,
-0.13670624792575836,
-0.38111376762390137,
-0.29528456926345825,
-0.8357520699501038,
0.2689115107059479,
-0.25831514596939087,
-0.7868574857711792,
0.4516353905200958,
0.010973863303661346,
-0.5230473279953003,
0.42780202627182007,
-0.7970057129859924,
0.6718200445175171,
-0.01658467948436737,
-0.39021676778793335,
-0.4849476218223572,
-0.27010804414749146,
0.5103235840797424,
-0.3400551378726959,
0.008252119645476341,
-0.30623286962509155,
-0.11779923737049103,
0.6700626015663147,
-0.15839886665344238,
0.9003891348838806,
-0.48114749789237976,
-0.5792804956436157,
-0.07644644379615784,
0.120091512799263,
0.7945138812065125,
-0.053240321576595306,
-0.27137669920921326,
0.011852988041937351,
-0.0948469266295433,
-0.400654137134552,
-0.5429503321647644,
1.0028843879699707,
-0.8977395296096802,
-0.409259557723999,
0.09777988493442535,
-0.844340443611145,
-0.45477738976478577,
0.12742292881011963,
-0.15597021579742432,
0.34568285942077637,
-0.11165743321180344,
0.26747217774391174,
0.6825888156890869,
-0.42038437724113464,
0.4036436975002289,
0.5274493098258972,
-0.09863289445638657,
-0.37894105911254883,
1.0912405252456665,
-0.020494559779763222,
0.14028070867061615,
0.32806846499443054,
0.10139811038970947,
0.02607985958456993,
-0.9589459896087646,
-0.2617671489715576,
0.19463062286376953,
-0.6453052163124084,
-0.24648833274841309,
-0.14856810867786407,
-0.19866032898426056,
-0.0704270526766777,
-0.16812589764595032,
-0.5811172127723694,
-0.3286147117614746,
-0.3217630386352539,
0.18683990836143494,
0.3263423442840576,
0.3870655596256256,
0.04431556537747383,
0.3061029613018036,
-0.4308139383792877,
0.565984308719635,
0.4484529197216034,
0.5956355333328247,
0.07588349282741547,
-0.5486230850219727,
-0.3445669710636139,
0.09534528106451035,
0.05750443413853645,
-0.19912542402744293,
0.4064966142177582,
0.5541270971298218,
0.13801389932632446,
0.3742486536502838,
0.08806486427783966,
0.930162787437439,
-0.4214856028556824,
0.5403227210044861,
0.036260541528463364,
-1.0743589401245117,
0.3577544391155243,
-0.461211621761322,
0.492415189743042,
0.5320048928260803,
-0.1024722158908844,
-0.303325891494751,
0.045208387076854706,
0.03573142737150192,
-0.5790813565254211,
0.6996616125106812,
-0.14648933708667755,
0.26618295907974243,
0.5056567788124084,
0.44624826312065125,
-0.05772371217608452,
-0.1708213984966278,
-0.5138709545135498,
-0.1700754165649414,
-0.11124170571565628,
-0.09709614515304565,
-0.4225454330444336,
-0.34775590896606445,
-0.2092488557100296,
-0.5208153128623962,
0.5578147172927856,
-0.4994224011898041,
0.10626237839460373,
-0.3076428174972534,
-0.1653890758752823,
-0.08503463119268417,
0.37826329469680786,
0.8553600907325745,
0.6093317866325378,
-0.48343655467033386,
0.14218400418758392,
0.638029932975769,
-0.4207018315792084,
-0.07739648222923279,
0.11779017001390457,
-0.019525859504938126,
-0.49229174852371216,
0.10862956196069717,
1.3002827167510986,
0.43130916357040405,
-0.5700991153717041,
0.08051411062479019,
-0.024135196581482887,
-0.10638678818941116,
0.10736756771802902,
0.2681097090244293,
0.2750363051891327,
0.3810523450374603,
0.2734741270542145,
0.18595059216022491,
-0.2558799982070923,
-0.5371714234352112,
-0.11767145991325378,
0.41030818223953247,
-0.3313734531402588,
-0.35112616419792175,
0.7213946580886841,
0.09088899940252304,
-0.07817107439041138,
0.3797564208507538,
-0.13735659420490265,
-0.10612059384584427,
0.44299229979515076,
0.6806901097297668,
0.7479277849197388,
-0.23973996937274933,
0.23596911132335663,
0.29870834946632385,
0.14729461073875427,
0.14237229526042938,
0.2608937919139862,
0.10505659133195877,
-0.756371259689331,
-0.6143776178359985,
-0.8888695240020752,
-0.24440495669841766,
0.1774701178073883,
-0.3998832702636719,
0.3285270035266876,
-0.6731898784637451,
0.1031314954161644,
0.11881613731384277,
0.3086477518081665,
-0.2763915956020355,
0.0029714691918343306,
0.5231350660324097,
0.9238786101341248,
-0.5799056887626648,
1.3944495916366577,
0.3336278200149536,
-0.19423815608024597,
-0.5899803638458252,
-0.1655094176530838,
-0.3063891530036926,
-0.7976358532905579,
0.641173243522644,
-0.30651286244392395,
-0.2474614828824997,
0.18343353271484375,
-0.3434591591358185,
-0.9025848507881165,
1.1953140497207642,
1.0935050249099731,
-0.5174916386604309,
-0.0764819011092186,
0.14715120196342468,
0.6770071983337402,
-0.2604435384273529,
-0.14600546658039093,
0.6224406957626343,
0.6223931908607483,
-0.02399042807519436,
-0.9312518835067749,
0.23206792771816254,
-0.07039958983659744,
0.08494686335325241,
0.33661991357803345,
-0.8688042163848877,
1.183687686920166,
-0.20272111892700195,
-0.16928523778915405,
0.06898565590381622,
0.4550253450870514,
0.008926625363528728,
0.026455258950591087,
0.48912566900253296,
0.6716708540916443,
1.0912463665008545,
0.010997592471539974,
0.827372670173645,
-0.4527474343776703,
0.35778117179870605,
1.0510720014572144,
-0.4361252188682556,
1.154796838760376,
0.2857024371623993,
-0.05005234107375145,
0.6323994994163513,
0.3557220697402954,
-0.08969178795814514,
0.5778161883354187,
0.10206438601016998,
0.005766171962022781,
-0.34020501375198364,
-0.17764005064964294,
-0.3419305384159088,
0.7829843163490295,
0.47247564792633057,
-0.12707841396331787,
-0.2842787802219391,
0.27979424595832825,
-0.08679172396659851,
-0.000269907817710191,
-0.6893935203552246,
0.6276566982269287,
0.13677823543548584,
-0.47674065828323364,
1.2763909101486206,
0.1449729949235916,
0.5561110377311707,
-0.5594935417175293,
0.10669028759002686,
-0.27834266424179077,
0.6122171878814697,
-0.1774589568376541,
-0.3180699050426483,
0.19160936772823334,
-0.1835768222808838,
-0.16783839464187622,
-0.0902857631444931,
0.7234629392623901,
-0.3899521231651306,
-0.3211289346218109,
0.2975229322910309,
0.1779470592737198,
-0.35140854120254517,
-0.1114831194281578,
-0.5909278988838196,
0.43466103076934814,
-0.09516950696706772,
0.08827310055494308,
0.5464089512825012,
0.10589651018381119,
0.07368438690900803,
0.786028265953064,
0.7559757828712463,
0.2606157660484314,
-0.044745586812496185,
0.0742441862821579,
0.9853168725967407,
-0.5110275149345398,
-0.43612930178642273,
-0.6162363290786743,
0.09724678099155426,
0.12598828971385956,
-0.24818794429302216,
0.6065746545791626,
0.5314887166023254,
0.4134255051612854,
-0.04620705917477608,
0.3366912305355072,
0.2384711354970932,
0.21445953845977783,
-0.9466524720191956,
0.9003182649612427,
-0.5809629559516907,
0.44291090965270996,
-0.13823144137859344,
-1.1173826456069946,
-0.3526323139667511,
0.2720722556114197,
-0.29807400703430176,
-0.20562970638275146,
0.47104325890541077,
0.7754919528961182,
-0.3268905580043793,
-0.21352146565914154,
0.3297353982925415,
0.7206641435623169,
0.27108874917030334,
0.8587642312049866,
0.354550302028656,
-0.46487975120544434,
0.33784541487693787,
-0.034682560712099075,
0.16237741708755493,
-0.2637901306152344,
-0.6732518672943115,
-0.9209302067756653,
-0.7444697618484497,
-0.19277159869670868,
-0.13896140456199646,
0.23514077067375183,
0.7346228957176208,
0.7913716435432434,
-0.8289860486984253,
-0.25101548433303833,
0.1546790897846222,
0.07310274243354797,
-0.05916871875524521,
-0.16372838616371155,
0.7248731851577759,
-0.25951066613197327,
-0.8312897086143494,
0.5956707000732422,
0.2859218716621399,
-0.2354585975408554,
-0.4275180697441101,
-0.20791436731815338,
-0.15705564618110657,
0.22575314342975616,
0.7829265594482422,
0.3776903450489044,
-0.4944759011268616,
-0.3978428542613983,
-0.36203962564468384,
-0.03633544221520424,
0.2720504403114319,
0.5052120685577393,
-0.8335527777671814,
0.35690298676490784,
0.5037129521369934,
0.6366999745368958,
0.9941155910491943,
-0.16417482495307922,
0.40290358662605286,
-0.6519757509231567,
0.29342228174209595,
-0.04046886786818504,
0.2867504060268402,
0.07200849056243896,
-0.05763619765639305,
0.3510507643222809,
-0.23490333557128906,
-0.3844638764858246,
-0.9818351864814758,
0.05211808159947395,
-1.3395859003067017,
-0.492939293384552,
0.9069944024085999,
0.2659510672092438,
-0.3295547068119049,
0.11514706909656525,
-0.41696998476982117,
0.01705002970993519,
-0.22888582944869995,
0.8690074682235718,
0.3232131898403168,
0.12501361966133118,
-0.3972194790840149,
-0.3985503911972046,
0.5913151502609253,
0.226678729057312,
-0.9179763197898865,
0.40406662225723267,
0.22423294186592102,
0.007591926027089357,
0.06602676212787628,
0.3143603801727295,
0.25255286693573,
0.1085134968161583,
-0.1902685910463333,
-0.050685785710811615,
-0.34694603085517883,
-0.08702455461025238,
-0.45265519618988037,
0.3943135440349579,
0.2259638011455536,
0.03645100072026253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12830v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12830v1 | What Are the Odds? Language Models Are Capable of Probabilistic Reasoning | 2024-06-18T17:51:24 | 2024-06-18T17:51:24 | Akshay Paruchuri, Jake Garrison, Shun Liao, John Hernandez, Jacob Sunshine, Tim Althoff, Xin Liu, Daniel McDuff | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LM) are capable of remarkably complex linguistic tasks;
however, numerical reasoning is an area in which they frequently struggle. An
important but rarely evaluated form of reasoning is understanding probability
distributions. In this paper, we focus on evaluating the probabilistic
reasoning capabilities of LMs using idealized and real-world statistical
distributions. We perform a systematic evaluation of state-of-the-art LMs on
three tasks: estimating percentiles, drawing samples, and calculating
probabilities. We evaluate three ways to provide context to LMs 1) anchoring
examples from within a distribution or family of distributions, 2) real-world
context, 3) summary statistics on which to base a Normal approximation. Models
can make inferences about distributions, and can be further aided by the
incorporation of real-world context, example shots and simplified assumptions,
even if these assumptions are incorrect or misspecified. To conduct this work,
we developed a comprehensive benchmark distribution dataset with associated
question-answer pairs that we will release publicly. | [
-0.34038347005844116,
-0.7543026208877563,
1.0222442150115967,
0.27744507789611816,
-0.26617157459259033,
-0.3947245180606842,
-0.25836873054504395,
-0.1006496399641037,
-0.33284541964530945,
0.7042653560638428,
-0.43961358070373535,
-0.6084209680557251,
-0.21217432618141174,
-0.21334081888198853,
-0.3372916579246521,
0.6854724287986755,
0.07595211267471313,
0.07114693522453308,
-0.273848295211792,
0.13929183781147003,
-0.16309167444705963,
-0.5213052034378052,
-0.4064916670322418,
-0.28840914368629456,
0.08538499474525452,
0.1769271343946457,
0.9937227368354797,
0.37079381942749023,
0.8196490406990051,
0.1697201430797577,
0.014677627943456173,
-0.12442947179079056,
-0.13688567280769348,
0.07652749121189117,
-0.30500486493110657,
-0.6990469694137573,
-0.14834383130073547,
0.043947283178567886,
0.5888163447380066,
1.1569396257400513,
-0.28018295764923096,
0.18005946278572083,
-0.20414824783802032,
0.46706241369247437,
-0.753934383392334,
0.2611231207847595,
-0.44799837470054626,
0.09659505635499954,
-0.1125805675983429,
-0.16089576482772827,
-0.7175360918045044,
-0.7325740456581116,
0.1964789628982544,
-0.42613765597343445,
0.10164840519428253,
0.03490692377090454,
0.36776840686798096,
0.06940054893493652,
-0.32030439376831055,
-0.287411630153656,
-0.8399646878242493,
0.7635311484336853,
-0.5619047284126282,
0.3494715988636017,
0.7482506632804871,
0.6931459903717041,
-0.3109305202960968,
-0.4822124242782593,
-0.5479373931884766,
-0.2849717438220978,
0.23868277668952942,
-0.08285418152809143,
-0.19637799263000488,
0.047083452343940735,
0.02257930114865303,
0.11716174334287643,
-0.5531900525093079,
-0.13717947900295258,
-0.03975857421755791,
0.09145618975162506,
0.7631758451461792,
0.08207716047763824,
0.33631089329719543,
-0.18049338459968567,
-0.016731005162000656,
-0.4015522599220276,
-0.568282961845398,
-0.015788085758686066,
0.5259656310081482,
0.19939425587654114,
-0.18888765573501587,
0.5758114457130432,
-0.20412157475948334,
0.9867298007011414,
-0.5944119095802307,
-0.08911091834306717,
0.08436579257249832,
-0.3689803183078766,
-0.27320748567581177,
-0.2981327176094055,
0.6755313277244568,
0.49283719062805176,
0.9085946083068848,
-0.16714832186698914,
-0.2041786015033722,
-0.2244454026222229,
0.11559463292360306,
-0.2637895345687866,
-0.35002243518829346,
0.47597354650497437,
-0.44114381074905396,
-0.3811246454715729,
0.015092449262738228,
-0.3049588203430176,
-0.33611541986465454,
-0.10146163403987885,
0.43582966923713684,
-0.6530441045761108,
-0.4411565661430359,
0.43523937463760376,
-0.4792627692222595,
-0.2276238352060318,
0.24395422637462616,
-0.6652288436889648,
0.1903698444366455,
0.8852738738059998,
0.4107988774776459,
0.090324766933918,
-0.0046921721659600735,
-0.07291841506958008,
0.0725492313504219,
-0.557905375957489,
1.0228360891342163,
-0.4991384446620941,
-0.10581929981708527,
0.05536545440554619,
-0.21508459746837616,
-0.0997975692152977,
-0.6835713386535645,
0.8056580424308777,
-0.3744490146636963,
-0.1498900204896927,
-0.09060800820589066,
-0.8016595840454102,
-0.19237862527370453,
0.06697262078523636,
-0.6378729939460754,
0.5819156169891357,
0.008178598247468472,
-0.8392889499664307,
0.4462267756462097,
-0.22265726327896118,
-0.1315300166606903,
0.3068445920944214,
-0.10677048563957214,
-0.017100578173995018,
0.2011415958404541,
-0.01018122211098671,
0.5739631056785583,
-0.28884539008140564,
0.4967173933982849,
-0.7449193596839905,
-0.2692255973815918,
0.761103093624115,
-0.8616137504577637,
0.7773273587226868,
0.44112905859947205,
-0.12530861794948578,
-0.40613555908203125,
-0.5999836325645447,
0.18742768466472626,
-0.060407593846321106,
0.13441051542758942,
-0.5295143127441406,
0.3941824436187744,
-0.04335155710577965,
0.014384844340384007,
-0.19989201426506042,
-0.22203490138053894,
0.10936997830867767,
-0.43211331963539124,
0.2259959727525711,
0.3931485116481781,
0.2783609926700592,
0.5800924301147461,
-0.20781953632831573,
0.5628407597541809,
-0.050729312002658844,
0.2954593896865845,
0.10085444152355194,
-0.6305370330810547,
-0.20180021226406097,
-0.3001756966114044,
0.36063700914382935,
0.743464469909668,
-0.6280544400215149,
0.30851635336875916,
-0.09572526067495346,
-0.7157368659973145,
-0.3656286597251892,
-0.22690074145793915,
0.30221113562583923,
0.38299760222435,
0.05178183689713478,
-0.003388735931366682,
-0.2802267074584961,
-1.0000402927398682,
-0.4494644105434418,
-0.36474084854125977,
-0.12769576907157898,
0.05501394718885422,
0.3967882990837097,
0.2569677531719208,
1.2207688093185425,
-0.5928197503089905,
0.24861368536949158,
-0.5383983850479126,
0.08910325169563293,
0.32752203941345215,
0.269035279750824,
0.6031844615936279,
-0.8258478045463562,
-0.06617583334445953,
-0.18213984370231628,
-1.1029114723205566,
-0.19531577825546265,
0.02183183655142784,
-0.23108571767807007,
-0.08649192750453949,
0.08960357308387756,
-0.7012525796890259,
0.614100456237793,
0.3927310109138489,
-0.3268592059612274,
0.7165069580078125,
-0.33425217866897583,
0.06234828010201454,
-0.672596275806427,
-0.1737607717514038,
0.4098540246486664,
-0.03496134653687477,
-0.7867894172668457,
0.25052309036254883,
-0.025133153423666954,
-0.006948837544769049,
-0.42538756132125854,
0.7120445370674133,
-0.2069183886051178,
-0.2574930191040039,
0.02049281634390354,
0.11373932659626007,
-0.1732657551765442,
-0.20946428179740906,
0.45974284410476685,
0.47510436177253723,
0.5399463772773743,
-0.46255722641944885,
0.17455646395683289,
-0.25874751806259155,
-0.9596071243286133,
0.38797086477279663,
-0.5177217721939087,
-0.5542445182800293,
-0.3198665976524353,
0.4251538813114166,
-1.0768049955368042,
-0.24993278086185455,
0.27572256326675415,
-0.30529075860977173,
-0.2788962423801422,
-0.2579880356788635,
-0.6685365438461304,
-0.363617867231369,
-0.136102557182312,
0.196712926030159,
0.610000729560852,
-0.17083638906478882,
0.13718697428703308,
0.49965232610702515,
-0.12859328091144562,
-0.5326528549194336,
-0.7416844367980957,
-0.09501419961452484,
-0.28036150336265564,
-0.6157105565071106,
-0.1447189748287201,
0.04833707958459854,
-1.2621128559112549,
0.17198212444782257,
0.1590520590543747,
-0.23857481777668,
0.25483864545822144,
0.09752960503101349,
0.05917859449982643,
-0.23043513298034668,
0.29166796803474426,
-0.06831201910972595,
-0.059529148042201996,
0.12987084686756134,
-0.2879384458065033,
0.34618887305259705,
0.11874798685312271,
-0.6832492351531982,
-0.3541721999645233,
0.12086199223995209,
0.04797635227441788,
-0.055990103632211685,
0.8793482184410095,
0.146188884973526,
-0.5500034093856812,
-0.38997477293014526,
-0.5594350695610046,
-0.16427935659885406,
-0.37447717785835266,
0.17658880352973938,
-0.7076980471611023,
-0.25510919094085693,
0.4244250953197479,
0.2503829002380371,
0.08060213178396225,
0.20120109617710114,
0.5016902685165405,
-0.41923388838768005,
1.1256372928619385,
0.22172436118125916,
0.45857349038124084,
0.2011830359697342,
-0.24673081934452057,
0.6088071465492249,
-0.28311628103256226,
-0.10210065543651581,
-0.35777950286865234,
0.25673970580101013,
-0.49378156661987305,
-0.8724559545516968,
0.27729490399360657,
0.5117142796516418,
0.00695818429812789,
0.2679879069328308,
-0.22342471778392792,
0.644961416721344,
0.5700957179069519,
-0.04661651328206062,
0.17309924960136414,
0.09583292156457901,
-0.25612637400627136,
0.07243791222572327,
-0.5480061769485474,
-1.124216914176941,
1.1156692504882812,
0.41550296545028687,
0.8185033798217773,
0.16920262575149536,
0.7619960904121399,
0.4203203320503235,
0.5865870714187622,
-0.5686867833137512,
0.5884602665901184,
-0.23489411175251007,
-0.6153616905212402,
-0.3835272789001465,
-0.51103276014328,
-0.6987650990486145,
0.42173343896865845,
-0.1629813015460968,
-0.8852471113204956,
0.20002438127994537,
0.09481333196163177,
-0.2735030949115753,
0.32901352643966675,
-0.950810432434082,
0.9235728979110718,
0.025002051144838333,
0.05469402298331261,
-0.09346877038478851,
-0.38853922486305237,
0.6651182174682617,
-0.027797438204288483,
0.8885653018951416,
-0.40840086340904236,
0.13197451829910278,
0.40363186597824097,
-0.3222964107990265,
0.5613871216773987,
-0.1379126012325287,
-0.22868861258029938,
0.7958168983459473,
0.3659707009792328,
0.11225687712430954,
0.0990271270275116,
-0.7962334752082825,
-0.08093869686126709,
0.3940022587776184,
-0.19787301123142242,
-0.8227455019950867,
0.2952013909816742,
-0.6416791677474976,
-0.4583519995212555,
-0.22011873126029968,
-0.664176881313324,
-0.3763447105884552,
-0.3015141189098358,
0.13250842690467834,
0.6525138020515442,
-0.24090535938739777,
0.09428658336400986,
0.39774835109710693,
-0.210683673620224,
0.3242141902446747,
0.4304066598415375,
-0.09411550313234329,
-0.20280037820339203,
0.8963971138000488,
0.15822993218898773,
0.5173162817955017,
0.40739554166793823,
0.26908448338508606,
-0.7340380549430847,
-0.38799336552619934,
-0.4915314018726349,
0.2737886607646942,
-1.2446686029434204,
0.19964982569217682,
-0.6679401397705078,
0.01716861128807068,
-0.44124287366867065,
-0.14342078566551208,
0.07597777247428894,
-0.6434935927391052,
0.1668345183134079,
-0.18963941931724548,
0.14326806366443634,
0.7247617244720459,
-0.04509824886918068,
0.30031290650367737,
-0.6158734560012817,
0.23938991129398346,
0.16088329255580902,
0.07957428693771362,
0.01926376111805439,
-0.47384339570999146,
0.16975104808807373,
0.19399818778038025,
-0.043268635869026184,
-1.266873836517334,
0.39747679233551025,
0.02493128925561905,
0.7834285497665405,
0.2598378658294678,
0.16586574912071228,
0.3088892996311188,
-0.5415382385253906,
0.7197006940841675,
-0.024632172659039497,
-0.5651542544364929,
0.4778484106063843,
-0.264472097158432,
-0.12925060093402863,
0.4500805735588074,
0.5233703851699829,
-0.38381075859069824,
-0.7106621861457825,
-0.7665227651596069,
-0.5112679600715637,
0.5993804931640625,
0.3468802869319916,
-0.008042262867093086,
-0.4637874364852905,
0.34181076288223267,
-0.05437847599387169,
0.0019636747892946005,
-0.4838932454586029,
-0.257377028465271,
0.1326165646314621,
-0.5942890644073486,
-0.31318211555480957,
-0.0797143206000328,
-0.028882522135972977,
-0.11608229577541351,
0.36117517948150635,
-0.03845591843128204,
-0.016634434461593628,
-0.06859220564365387,
-0.17717356979846954,
0.14578992128372192,
0.39241892099380493,
0.5969159007072449,
1.0914769172668457,
-0.4695812463760376,
0.5420612096786499,
0.04163682833313942,
-0.17694666981697083,
0.2880856394767761,
0.1217820942401886,
-0.19933612644672394,
0.17825138568878174,
0.5516138076782227,
0.7376879453659058,
0.14689983427524567,
-1.0503391027450562,
0.494645893573761,
-0.21846260130405426,
-0.13948197662830353,
-0.37299680709838867,
0.1440141201019287,
0.6092138886451721,
0.08755704760551453,
0.5657514333724976,
-0.17723746597766876,
0.33338460326194763,
-0.8237600326538086,
0.37900835275650024,
0.3621652126312256,
-0.1415494680404663,
-0.3212854564189911,
0.4980070888996124,
-0.11632955074310303,
-0.4423109292984009,
0.27031728625297546,
-0.46504032611846924,
-0.31761714816093445,
0.9494881629943848,
0.504271924495697,
0.6566669344902039,
-0.031050648540258408,
0.5295435786247253,
0.20153436064720154,
0.33656391501426697,
-0.42470690608024597,
0.541999876499176,
0.09165935218334198,
-0.8980616927146912,
-0.4973980188369751,
-0.8877844214439392,
-0.6460300087928772,
-0.23711736500263214,
-0.4719550311565399,
0.27918535470962524,
-0.008260947652161121,
-0.19870297610759735,
0.2555173933506012,
-0.29956015944480896,
-0.553716778755188,
0.4544571042060852,
0.2669004499912262,
1.1413211822509766,
-1.1501957178115845,
0.6972584128379822,
0.6669876575469971,
-0.48310279846191406,
-0.7539821863174438,
0.00046308539458550513,
-0.11441076546907425,
-0.8347225785255432,
0.9969928860664368,
-0.09612805396318436,
0.21503151953220367,
-0.16277185082435608,
-0.26968035101890564,
-0.5939170718193054,
0.41319841146469116,
0.45011505484580994,
-0.4894964098930359,
0.4965707063674927,
0.3717137277126312,
0.6346057057380676,
-0.3953966498374939,
0.729924738407135,
0.626884937286377,
0.40151339769363403,
-0.13942664861679077,
-0.8362440466880798,
-0.23388560116291046,
0.05386801436543465,
0.09366074949502945,
0.07844265550374985,
0.03276197984814644,
0.7646474242210388,
-0.4159512221813202,
-0.0433347225189209,
-0.21275369822978973,
0.4822259843349457,
0.8018053770065308,
0.34756216406822205,
0.715060830116272,
0.60991370677948,
0.5419198870658875,
-0.05315108597278595,
1.522662878036499,
-0.3748827874660492,
0.321098655462265,
0.8448022603988647,
-0.29097434878349304,
1.2502282857894897,
0.2343357801437378,
-0.6196348071098328,
0.39735594391822815,
0.7487746477127075,
0.5093647837638855,
0.5420323610305786,
0.5135229825973511,
-0.6467891335487366,
-0.5751137733459473,
-0.15487156808376312,
-0.1764010488986969,
0.22078770399093628,
0.5241159200668335,
-0.2574334442615509,
-0.32253119349479675,
0.0032691387459635735,
-0.2861013412475586,
0.23621174693107605,
0.09523165225982666,
0.491483598947525,
0.290190190076828,
-0.8190929293632507,
0.28897276520729065,
0.048201899975538254,
0.26770544052124023,
-0.3463767170906067,
-0.12459606677293777,
-0.2010117471218109,
0.35976794362068176,
-0.05801575258374214,
-1.6667635440826416,
0.3871961236000061,
0.13354142010211945,
-0.015024377964437008,
-0.1156361773610115,
0.608376145362854,
-0.36320093274116516,
-0.67383873462677,
-0.06653698533773422,
0.5351199507713318,
0.7661846876144409,
-0.1367512345314026,
-0.5748345255851746,
0.06340774893760681,
-0.2230263352394104,
-0.3406795561313629,
0.25860902667045593,
0.6252487897872925,
-0.39872029423713684,
1.0147656202316284,
0.42983850836753845,
0.3469853401184082,
0.016464844346046448,
0.5871402621269226,
0.18418627977371216,
-0.4794548749923706,
-0.4390672445297241,
-0.9587224721908569,
0.24322552978992462,
-0.00584057392552495,
-0.14219237864017487,
0.7189311981201172,
0.22664374113082886,
0.5621327757835388,
-0.16244304180145264,
0.8997661471366882,
0.023433052003383636,
0.3926072418689728,
-0.3075544536113739,
0.36152708530426025,
-0.3117552697658539,
0.17520451545715332,
-0.16441179811954498,
-0.8742342591285706,
-0.4485970139503479,
0.9120453000068665,
-0.814873993396759,
-0.21741090714931488,
0.42612141370773315,
0.5475034713745117,
-0.07528091967105865,
0.14165480434894562,
0.3496248424053192,
-0.39281946420669556,
0.18315373361110687,
0.3883834481239319,
0.9894418120384216,
-0.24904736876487732,
0.46320658922195435,
-0.5629149675369263,
-0.26368531584739685,
-0.152639240026474,
-0.909568727016449,
-0.5577938556671143,
-0.2599588632583618,
-0.2369663268327713,
-0.03604678437113762,
0.20092114806175232,
0.8434023261070251,
0.6366949081420898,
-0.7472230195999146,
-0.45232951641082764,
-0.16074414551258087,
0.33981814980506897,
-0.18409310281276703,
-0.3009064793586731,
0.3047332763671875,
-0.3707963228225708,
-0.5386263728141785,
0.12106986343860626,
0.28153276443481445,
0.0033746720291674137,
-0.2497001588344574,
0.09868855774402618,
0.09235671907663345,
0.17753615975379944,
0.6192135810852051,
-0.05234766751527786,
-0.9291959404945374,
-0.46316251158714294,
-0.014261357486248016,
-0.1994466483592987,
-0.48175495862960815,
0.37734168767929077,
-0.5253639817237854,
0.32295310497283936,
0.8890764117240906,
0.361227810382843,
-0.030939750373363495,
0.2412090003490448,
0.8257952928543091,
-0.4568164348602295,
0.27317848801612854,
0.30084896087646484,
0.39500337839126587,
0.20012591779232025,
0.05110624060034752,
0.781274139881134,
0.16444557905197144,
-0.4286128580570221,
-1.1661415100097656,
0.17726115882396698,
-0.5653612613677979,
-0.4368036389350891,
1.2488219738006592,
-0.22784365713596344,
-0.16621243953704834,
-0.2713845372200012,
0.10854516923427582,
-0.03560107946395874,
0.08686681091785431,
0.17063003778457642,
0.9016331434249878,
-0.23917746543884277,
-0.3151298761367798,
-1.047049880027771,
0.45583975315093994,
0.45702803134918213,
-0.7980978488922119,
0.16531981527805328,
0.23519815504550934,
0.4851669371128082,
-0.025758996605873108,
0.7844501733779907,
0.16541366279125214,
0.21307355165481567,
0.10590206831693649,
0.15313293039798737,
0.6558369994163513,
-0.09810982644557953,
-0.22120416164398193,
0.22169630229473114,
0.23309089243412018,
0.11108645051717758
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12824v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12824v1 | From RAGs to rich parameters: Probing how language models utilize external knowledge over parametric information for factual queries | 2024-06-18T17:46:08 | 2024-06-18T17:46:08 | Hitesh Wadhwa, Rahul Seetharaman, Somyaa Aggarwal, Reshmi Ghosh, Samyadeep Basu, Soundararajan Srinivasan, Wenlong Zhao, Shreyas Chaudhari, Ehsan Aghazadeh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) enriches the ability of language models
to reason using external context to augment responses for a given user prompt.
This approach has risen in popularity due to practical applications in various
applications of language models in search, question/answering, and chat-bots.
However, the exact nature of how this approach works isn't clearly understood.
In this paper, we mechanistically examine the RAG pipeline to highlight that
language models take shortcut and have a strong bias towards utilizing only the
context information to answer the question, while relying minimally on their
parametric memory. We probe this mechanistic behavior in language models with:
(i) Causal Mediation Analysis to show that the parametric memory is minimally
utilized when answering a question and (ii) Attention Contributions and
Knockouts to show that the last token residual stream do not get enriched from
the subject token in the question, but gets enriched from other informative
tokens in the context. We find this pronounced shortcut behaviour true across
both LLaMa and Phi family of models. | [
-0.46624499559402466,
-0.9639785289764404,
0.7728066444396973,
-0.12552131712436676,
-0.19631344079971313,
-0.20159387588500977,
-0.06063150241971016,
-0.25200533866882324,
0.17245669662952423,
0.7700519561767578,
-0.4264701008796692,
0.13237300515174866,
-0.5846118927001953,
-0.02670702524483204,
-0.4087224006652832,
1.316826581954956,
0.1395658254623413,
-0.09179054945707321,
-0.2889225482940674,
-0.4321311116218567,
-0.22663149237632751,
-0.49456605315208435,
-0.5890141129493713,
0.05712001770734787,
0.8779460787773132,
0.41214191913604736,
0.9657126069068909,
0.7655836939811707,
0.25031861662864685,
0.33999136090278625,
-0.17426005005836487,
0.044698406010866165,
-0.6880213618278503,
0.48246264457702637,
-0.40833714604377747,
-0.6213775277137756,
0.020174207165837288,
-0.0007217932143248618,
0.5014119148254395,
0.8487715721130371,
0.30715563893318176,
0.6889945268630981,
0.3053880035877228,
0.5835484862327576,
-0.9639458656311035,
-0.20959189534187317,
-0.8336963653564453,
-0.6204983592033386,
-0.4150359034538269,
-0.5577312707901001,
-0.2811402678489685,
0.006128871347755194,
0.08016902953386307,
-0.11841350793838501,
0.44789889454841614,
-0.004540088586509228,
0.9008945226669312,
0.36673447489738464,
-0.5908399820327759,
-0.5989563465118408,
-0.8357340693473816,
0.8393318057060242,
-0.5002707839012146,
0.4332040548324585,
0.6653114557266235,
0.4337427020072937,
0.11136576533317566,
-0.7172789573669434,
-0.28842976689338684,
-0.37508121132850647,
-0.26568466424942017,
-0.2881750464439392,
0.05132327228784561,
-0.00560847157612443,
0.33763250708580017,
0.17521503567695618,
-0.36313673853874207,
-0.29890987277030945,
-0.6042423248291016,
-0.1342851221561432,
0.35409003496170044,
0.3236185908317566,
0.2199094146490097,
-0.3933095932006836,
-0.24502936005592346,
0.01765426993370056,
-0.721023678779602,
0.2728683054447174,
0.4497617781162262,
0.34640148282051086,
-0.060229502618312836,
0.9459101557731628,
-0.14154912531375885,
1.0164459943771362,
-0.09431668370962143,
-0.27915090322494507,
-0.47589248418807983,
-0.39477044343948364,
-0.08961033076047897,
-0.28695568442344666,
0.5029708743095398,
-0.15773873031139374,
0.030816398561000824,
-0.21354638040065765,
-0.2156326025724411,
-0.393904447555542,
0.10357806086540222,
-0.7529938817024231,
0.008221365511417389,
0.08166395872831345,
-0.43661221861839294,
-0.14404602348804474,
-0.2085099071264267,
-0.7276721596717834,
-0.27641215920448303,
-0.4124176800251007,
0.4597793519496918,
-0.059101033955812454,
-0.013835915364325047,
-0.18227899074554443,
-0.3595011830329895,
0.27452558279037476,
0.018131528049707413,
-0.683916449546814,
0.2654262185096741,
0.7020736336708069,
0.5503700971603394,
0.14880283176898956,
-0.19128240644931793,
-0.8448250889778137,
0.4129401445388794,
-0.28819605708122253,
0.8184068202972412,
-0.8380674719810486,
-0.19898609817028046,
-0.24475441873073578,
-0.15616902709007263,
0.006611081771552563,
-0.4056239426136017,
0.5411099195480347,
-0.835371732711792,
0.2860332429409027,
-0.8461236953735352,
-0.3457249701023102,
-0.2628025710582733,
-0.006514537148177624,
-0.7032179236412048,
0.8503052592277527,
0.10802646726369858,
-1.020579218864441,
0.35322025418281555,
-0.18449732661247253,
-0.11153814196586609,
-0.2515542507171631,
-0.14632557332515717,
-0.07320493459701538,
0.3812312185764313,
0.045349832624197006,
0.313507616519928,
-0.8734060525894165,
0.4710557162761688,
-0.5566543340682983,
-0.3253116011619568,
0.3953540623188019,
-0.6090390682220459,
0.7683730125427246,
0.3264831006526947,
-0.18428289890289307,
-0.1518983393907547,
-0.804398238658905,
-0.25247642397880554,
0.23256346583366394,
-0.32087332010269165,
-0.7321821451187134,
0.013178900815546513,
-0.13760145008563995,
0.33914270997047424,
0.17562340199947357,
-0.23464305698871613,
-0.08035295456647873,
-0.40299567580223083,
0.19301365315914154,
0.5647059082984924,
0.32381317019462585,
0.5757974982261658,
-0.3377249240875244,
0.32204216718673706,
-0.1726563274860382,
0.011024960316717625,
-0.09145544469356537,
-0.44045358896255493,
-0.983166515827179,
-0.1437803953886032,
0.2744990885257721,
0.16818411648273468,
-0.6247150301933289,
-0.18472419679164886,
-0.12605001032352448,
-0.36001670360565186,
-0.5978356003761292,
0.30432841181755066,
0.324764221906662,
0.9361395239830017,
0.171120285987854,
0.19081802666187286,
-0.3440060019493103,
-1.0545556545257568,
-0.681039571762085,
-0.32511037588119507,
-0.10338687896728516,
0.6373058557510376,
0.24964050948619843,
-0.06190234795212746,
0.9883686900138855,
-0.3236517012119293,
0.1653463989496231,
-0.43052494525909424,
0.1636928766965866,
0.13997650146484375,
0.14747275412082672,
0.6204502582550049,
-0.734714686870575,
-0.4669405519962311,
-0.46276432275772095,
-0.40460291504859924,
-0.22393260896205902,
-0.08885884284973145,
-0.31120479106903076,
0.006350625306367874,
0.4314638376235962,
-0.6141009330749512,
0.41414761543273926,
0.4198974668979645,
-0.4111312925815582,
0.3539039194583893,
-0.018148379400372505,
0.057759545743465424,
-0.8962592482566833,
0.3574111759662628,
-0.2000199854373932,
-0.0675491914153099,
-0.5400349497795105,
0.2146158665418625,
-0.013329360634088516,
-0.2895995080471039,
-0.3313574492931366,
0.9563425183296204,
-0.5689284205436707,
-0.36576157808303833,
-0.4971453845500946,
0.06148858368396759,
0.24539658427238464,
0.6105057597160339,
-0.22675222158432007,
0.9162377119064331,
0.3353787660598755,
-0.9608865976333618,
-0.032048165798187256,
-0.07578045129776001,
-0.0011164385359734297,
0.13588446378707886,
-0.7457113265991211,
0.1703672558069229,
-0.4095443785190582,
-0.06272587180137634,
-1.0987248420715332,
-0.27571219205856323,
0.08087031543254852,
-0.4137265682220459,
0.4273723363876343,
-0.2649246156215668,
-0.5424281358718872,
0.0758051797747612,
-0.24550165235996246,
0.6530736088752747,
0.5026254057884216,
-0.34408554434776306,
0.566646158695221,
0.49486809968948364,
-0.17514771223068237,
-0.42397770285606384,
-0.4241178631782532,
-0.08312609791755676,
-0.4309587776660919,
-0.6261301040649414,
-0.030176131054759026,
0.06562415510416031,
-0.5391813516616821,
0.0639479011297226,
-0.06603110581636429,
-0.24584023654460907,
0.01334181148558855,
-0.17025698721408844,
0.09525629132986069,
-0.3378361165523529,
0.07068897038698196,
0.11069036275148392,
-0.04694555699825287,
0.011722613126039505,
0.3496510684490204,
0.5259838700294495,
0.11343932151794434,
-0.3670797646045685,
0.007411668077111244,
0.52013099193573,
0.5839770436286926,
-0.32107794284820557,
0.8867031931877136,
0.3186652660369873,
-0.041279446333646774,
-0.02011590637266636,
-0.7248364090919495,
-0.4414392113685608,
-0.51991868019104,
0.2098485231399536,
-0.49053946137428284,
-0.7725712060928345,
0.6931928396224976,
0.08947751671075821,
-0.15447475016117096,
0.44661781191825867,
0.6217703819274902,
0.056779514998197556,
1.0725480318069458,
0.447091668844223,
0.08175285160541534,
0.16629745066165924,
-0.11402726173400879,
0.23928403854370117,
-1.016831874847412,
0.070411317050457,
-0.8091586232185364,
-0.3261677026748657,
-0.6920040249824524,
-0.5955673456192017,
0.5747095346450806,
0.37442120909690857,
-0.33831295371055603,
0.1576419174671173,
-0.16258537769317627,
0.41399937868118286,
0.5618249177932739,
-0.02939373254776001,
-0.03673061728477478,
-0.3301939368247986,
-0.00030735036125406623,
-0.1444641500711441,
-0.7701320052146912,
-0.3291308879852295,
1.017909049987793,
0.29480060935020447,
0.8387237191200256,
-0.05495687574148178,
0.5498647689819336,
-0.2864164412021637,
0.18303029239177704,
-0.5411867499351501,
0.5602165460586548,
0.27375683188438416,
-0.9396785497665405,
-0.3038361370563507,
-0.24827566742897034,
-0.8912454843521118,
0.21453700959682465,
0.13648222386837006,
-0.5560987591743469,
0.38039231300354004,
0.13318811357021332,
-0.22488094866275787,
0.22870758175849915,
-0.4874281585216522,
0.5865644216537476,
-0.3739560842514038,
-0.8851069808006287,
-0.10025717318058014,
-0.7366639971733093,
0.5519765019416809,
-0.03948300704360008,
0.21099545061588287,
-0.035181742161512375,
-0.34010833501815796,
0.7053534388542175,
-0.37268900871276855,
0.7456363439559937,
-0.18579421937465668,
0.11964618414640427,
0.5751203298568726,
0.4099847674369812,
0.7675965428352356,
0.12587791681289673,
-0.05868813395500183,
-0.19827526807785034,
-0.1731482744216919,
-0.5336787104606628,
-0.7949227690696716,
0.6165330410003662,
-0.4800744354724884,
-0.9351250529289246,
-0.18805912137031555,
-0.6735860705375671,
-0.5650429725646973,
-0.03427762910723686,
0.18763479590415955,
0.5483449697494507,
0.2717258334159851,
0.39720070362091064,
0.5573230385780334,
-0.4282102882862091,
0.30640915036201477,
0.5243217945098877,
0.031251516193151474,
-0.06607218831777573,
0.7670222520828247,
0.25065556168556213,
0.36786532402038574,
0.40825027227401733,
0.517445981502533,
-0.31323128938674927,
-0.23003871738910675,
-0.3520982265472412,
0.6626148819923401,
-0.8928085565567017,
-0.15712615847587585,
-0.7595778107643127,
-0.11069431900978088,
-0.3891676962375641,
-0.000099088967544958,
-0.3967900574207306,
-0.4393562376499176,
-0.25949689745903015,
0.011714237742125988,
0.28523632884025574,
0.521346926689148,
0.028097646310925484,
0.03490807116031647,
-0.9042850732803345,
0.48893725872039795,
0.5459047555923462,
0.08934438973665237,
0.1214219257235527,
-0.7027079463005066,
-0.20339302718639374,
0.13159853219985962,
-0.21762339770793915,
-1.245387077331543,
0.2905973494052887,
0.20124398171901703,
0.6482020616531372,
0.43979787826538086,
0.1431831568479538,
0.8919506669044495,
-0.5864384174346924,
0.80547696352005,
-0.42089787125587463,
-0.6656149625778198,
0.439039945602417,
-0.45075148344039917,
0.13697457313537598,
0.6522650122642517,
0.4203339219093323,
-0.2932705879211426,
-0.596114456653595,
-0.6564373970031738,
-0.7945389747619629,
0.4828029274940491,
-0.09488091617822647,
0.43483760952949524,
-0.08796060085296631,
0.44195666909217834,
0.19781139492988586,
0.19168727099895477,
-0.5640683770179749,
-0.2517440915107727,
0.2111920267343521,
0.07671825587749481,
-0.018169939517974854,
-0.8325036764144897,
-0.13606183230876923,
-0.1453840285539627,
0.4381762444972992,
-0.043556615710258484,
0.2640738785266876,
0.02071564458310604,
-0.0882970318198204,
-0.0983908548951149,
0.15297187864780426,
0.6862819790840149,
0.776549220085144,
0.029529724270105362,
0.1461106538772583,
-0.029675088822841644,
-0.030513601377606392,
-0.08379736542701721,
-0.18666601181030273,
-0.23820172250270844,
0.16902126371860504,
0.4220293462276459,
0.8409224152565002,
0.5429071187973022,
-0.6369844675064087,
0.41370683908462524,
0.08449654281139374,
0.23684433102607727,
0.18779967725276947,
-0.029801679775118828,
0.031318750232458115,
0.2865656614303589,
0.28664225339889526,
0.04296870157122612,
0.5958454608917236,
-0.5600413084030151,
0.22767424583435059,
0.7342391610145569,
-0.21301549673080444,
-0.443712055683136,
0.7759648561477661,
-0.1089186891913414,
-0.1893380582332611,
0.22931700944900513,
0.045277565717697144,
-0.39017313718795776,
0.24305479228496552,
0.4262319803237915,
0.8996062874794006,
-0.06649411469697952,
0.19785942137241364,
0.3168739974498749,
0.1301933228969574,
0.31721046566963196,
-0.01694968342781067,
-0.49925631284713745,
-0.29892459511756897,
-0.5008264183998108,
-0.8239709138870239,
-0.1465643346309662,
0.31284284591674805,
-0.5719586610794067,
0.37491241097450256,
-0.10158233344554901,
0.09561562538146973,
-0.14069943130016327,
-0.1809503585100174,
-0.7993478775024414,
0.1922667920589447,
-0.2416004091501236,
0.6164894700050354,
-0.7535363435745239,
0.755465030670166,
0.2876495122909546,
-0.5751657485961914,
-1.0196970701217651,
0.32873645424842834,
-0.21493491530418396,
-1.0055444240570068,
0.9471260905265808,
-0.1602725386619568,
0.07414554804563522,
-0.22411277890205383,
-0.541437029838562,
-1.3102325201034546,
0.6071110367774963,
0.6353137493133545,
-0.013019251637160778,
-0.3504759669303894,
0.2533756196498871,
0.4469783306121826,
0.0775332972407341,
0.1510336846113205,
0.49413415789604187,
0.2519390881061554,
0.30316251516342163,
-0.8020731806755066,
0.025019461289048195,
-0.10008348524570465,
0.09063582122325897,
0.21137386560440063,
-0.5565425157546997,
1.0708482265472412,
-0.13017569482326508,
-0.11203999817371368,
-0.017605075612664223,
0.591021716594696,
0.475636750459671,
0.32995522022247314,
0.23640598356723785,
0.35213521122932434,
0.2676343321800232,
0.20998497307300568,
1.3224766254425049,
-0.5933161973953247,
0.16489894688129425,
0.9961923360824585,
-0.10435604304075241,
0.7082589268684387,
0.8335919380187988,
0.06766539812088013,
0.2393353283405304,
0.5733598470687866,
0.6053193807601929,
0.801291823387146,
-0.046653877943754196,
-0.14554370939731598,
-0.032895490527153015,
-0.1550462543964386,
-0.13788245618343353,
0.5225068926811218,
0.29692789912223816,
-0.4239492118358612,
-0.5109725594520569,
0.10668622702360153,
0.14958493411540985,
-0.03868689015507698,
-0.24815714359283447,
0.9564635157585144,
-0.007661866489797831,
-0.9858458042144775,
0.682716429233551,
0.09469130635261536,
0.23701123893260956,
-0.5955219864845276,
-0.036038681864738464,
-0.3257737457752228,
-0.1438651829957962,
0.2090984582901001,
-0.4875974953174591,
0.6655664443969727,
0.10354588180780411,
-0.13332821428775787,
-0.08417460322380066,
0.9749571084976196,
-0.3607974648475647,
-0.38918110728263855,
0.21261724829673767,
0.6418638229370117,
0.08006886392831802,
0.032901521772146225,
-0.6967863440513611,
0.12057014554738998,
-0.1525726616382599,
-0.5912886261940002,
0.509242832660675,
0.8242645859718323,
-0.002114298054948449,
0.5109901428222656,
0.5855050086975098,
0.29288506507873535,
0.3620123267173767,
-0.1616358906030655,
0.9489405751228333,
-0.43763718008995056,
-0.45420390367507935,
-0.8415363430976868,
0.6789079308509827,
0.08315689116716385,
-0.14169366657733917,
1.013264775276184,
0.4778441786766052,
0.5592668652534485,
-0.00770244374871254,
0.4716099798679352,
0.1712379902601242,
0.8675985336303711,
-0.5201823711395264,
0.5590895414352417,
-0.7166886925697327,
0.32590314745903015,
-0.2214534878730774,
-0.9496892094612122,
0.14212818443775177,
0.1617579311132431,
-0.4568036198616028,
0.24270522594451904,
0.5275397896766663,
0.8173751831054688,
-0.16715338826179504,
-0.38492119312286377,
0.4145377278327942,
-0.06400669366121292,
0.2403499335050583,
0.17371681332588196,
0.6637497544288635,
-0.2856287956237793,
0.5075845718383789,
-0.2706584632396698,
-0.04391025751829147,
-0.2278553992509842,
-0.5666083097457886,
-0.8329135775566101,
-0.8144700527191162,
0.17549459636211395,
-0.3567682206630707,
-0.10700066387653351,
0.46030959486961365,
0.4719164967536926,
-0.5096221566200256,
-0.30249080061912537,
-0.19067437946796417,
0.15826258063316345,
0.28169119358062744,
-0.26023975014686584,
0.3628328740596771,
-0.744135320186615,
-0.6707939505577087,
0.22739741206169128,
0.3785867989063263,
-0.17505376040935516,
-0.4145597815513611,
0.045404769480228424,
-0.23352667689323425,
0.5822538733482361,
0.3018132150173187,
0.2891344726085663,
-0.7131810784339905,
-0.25160524249076843,
0.2244063913822174,
-0.1880488097667694,
-0.17206889390945435,
1.123313069343567,
-0.7722564935684204,
0.3631652891635895,
0.8865566849708557,
0.9822692275047302,
0.3964119553565979,
0.041351933032274246,
0.5882550477981567,
-0.8989322185516357,
0.49481022357940674,
0.41620975732803345,
0.2761595845222473,
0.30360499024391174,
-0.40475308895111084,
0.18149101734161377,
0.14829030632972717,
-0.7151191830635071,
-1.0491639375686646,
0.29642176628112793,
-0.4748624861240387,
-0.5127580165863037,
1.3015739917755127,
0.3149568438529968,
-0.46460050344467163,
-0.06190934404730797,
-0.2007261961698532,
0.2210642248392105,
0.053934525698423386,
0.6108498573303223,
0.6525263786315918,
-0.26719385385513306,
-0.2782943546772003,
-0.8708728551864624,
0.8752376437187195,
0.39411962032318115,
-0.4280198812484741,
0.06691452860832214,
0.5502113103866577,
0.24763691425323486,
0.14297807216644287,
0.6883699893951416,
-0.03239163011312485,
0.15064746141433716,
-0.02951093763113022,
-0.7027014493942261,
0.20808301866054535,
-0.46334153413772583,
-0.04765019193291664,
0.3949114680290222,
0.21551047265529633,
-0.025012070313096046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12822v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12822v1 | Is It Good Data for Multilingual Instruction Tuning or Just Bad Multilingual Evaluation for Large Language Models? | 2024-06-18T17:43:47 | 2024-06-18T17:43:47 | Pinzhen Chen, Simon Yu, Zhicheng Guo, Barry Haddow | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models, particularly multilingual ones, are designed, claimed,
and expected to cater to native speakers of varied languages. We hypothesise
that the current practices of fine-tuning and evaluating these models may
mismatch this intention owing to a heavy reliance on translation, which can
introduce translation artefacts and defects. It remains unknown whether the
nature of the instruction data has an impact on the model output; on the other
hand, it remains questionable whether translated test sets can capture such
nuances. Due to the often coupled practices of using translated data in both
stages, such imperfections could have been overlooked. This work investigates
these issues by using controlled native or translated data during instruction
tuning and evaluation stages and observing model results. Experiments on eight
base models and eight different benchmarks reveal that native or generation
benchmarks display a notable difference between native and translated
instruction data especially when model performance is high, whereas other types
of test sets cannot. Finally, we demonstrate that regularization is beneficial
to bridging this gap on structured but not generative tasks. | [
-0.3027854561805725,
-0.7194346785545349,
0.07022088766098022,
0.2524472177028656,
-0.26351144909858704,
-0.09255938977003098,
-0.7467887997627258,
-0.5149403810501099,
-0.2557649612426758,
0.4096815884113312,
-0.35364508628845215,
-0.5687390565872192,
-0.430376261472702,
0.09257031232118607,
-0.23846884071826935,
1.2590049505233765,
-0.18299148976802826,
0.3329353928565979,
-0.1628146916627884,
-0.2363966703414917,
-0.8280086517333984,
-0.5752810835838318,
-0.5642856955528259,
-0.2530747652053833,
0.2902831733226776,
0.5733650922775269,
0.8051353693008423,
0.8452163934707642,
0.35269874334335327,
0.26493963599205017,
0.09539299458265305,
0.5758323073387146,
-0.6776843070983887,
-0.021943621337413788,
-0.11249256879091263,
-0.5512499809265137,
-0.37759265303611755,
0.2320762276649475,
0.8608871102333069,
0.8847973942756653,
-0.17102615535259247,
0.223847433924675,
0.28415727615356445,
0.47404783964157104,
-0.659095287322998,
0.4229802191257477,
-0.33616453409194946,
-0.0495603121817112,
-0.3258897364139557,
-0.05738135799765587,
-0.603480875492096,
-0.4419489800930023,
-0.14701607823371887,
-0.46371346712112427,
0.3940204083919525,
-0.10494734346866608,
0.7737551331520081,
0.21265438199043274,
-0.5186741352081299,
-0.2600160539150238,
-0.8741670250892639,
1.1838983297348022,
-0.8915980458259583,
0.5664823651313782,
0.5687022805213928,
0.3029809296131134,
-0.04561790078878403,
-0.10155230015516281,
-0.20999525487422943,
-0.26954105496406555,
-0.14750434458255768,
0.04219808429479599,
0.08263520151376724,
0.002345307730138302,
0.23875635862350464,
0.5736033916473389,
-0.4816426634788513,
0.6053502559661865,
-0.5843180418014526,
-0.38703131675720215,
0.7428457736968994,
0.1572895497083664,
0.3272920250892639,
-0.06224644184112549,
-0.026921574026346207,
-0.23309747874736786,
-0.7515305876731873,
0.0198249239474535,
0.68684321641922,
0.8023504018783569,
-0.41928061842918396,
0.4620682895183563,
-0.15123018622398376,
1.0941705703735352,
-0.3043522834777832,
-0.25243741273880005,
0.2133181095123291,
-0.6174320578575134,
0.11978946626186371,
0.06103121489286423,
0.5646012425422668,
0.575150728225708,
0.816135585308075,
-0.2874419093132019,
-0.4527050852775574,
0.13912983238697052,
0.051442693918943405,
-0.7148381471633911,
-0.10219790041446686,
-0.18001329898834229,
-0.23509955406188965,
0.12953270971775055,
0.1119278147816658,
-0.6806541085243225,
-0.03731844574213028,
-0.5857816934585571,
0.18343894183635712,
-0.23622652888298035,
-0.08982604742050171,
0.3286747634410858,
0.29180607199668884,
0.0713832750916481,
0.12087848782539368,
-1.0681591033935547,
0.27494296431541443,
0.6447146534919739,
0.5371375679969788,
-0.23976315557956696,
-0.39024391770362854,
-0.6340689659118652,
-0.12015834450721741,
-0.7364600300788879,
0.5076659321784973,
-0.7388602495193481,
-0.45780184864997864,
0.04155098274350166,
0.23251809179782867,
-0.4760863780975342,
-0.5649751424789429,
0.5723046064376831,
-0.4482453167438507,
0.20826612412929535,
-0.2650098502635956,
-0.42831167578697205,
-0.11882282793521881,
0.11524096876382828,
-0.6779696941375732,
0.8320286273956299,
0.009159576147794724,
-0.35140979290008545,
0.48097047209739685,
-0.3462531268596649,
-0.753211259841919,
-0.25767427682876587,
0.00597513560205698,
-0.2813720703125,
0.18172523379325867,
0.2113410085439682,
0.43670129776000977,
-0.25444841384887695,
0.20242427289485931,
0.011909672059118748,
-0.7307448983192444,
-0.005458482541143894,
-0.6359280347824097,
0.42413151264190674,
0.24908125400543213,
-0.25963807106018066,
-0.10975281894207001,
-0.8044818043708801,
0.15115857124328613,
-0.09612315148115158,
-0.5960213541984558,
-0.5219852328300476,
0.1421949714422226,
-0.010176877491176128,
0.1769227385520935,
0.19260182976722717,
-0.5464521646499634,
0.3054828941822052,
-0.48829975724220276,
0.2230563908815384,
0.6460546255111694,
-0.02165495976805687,
0.37151116132736206,
-0.1541460007429123,
0.558527410030365,
0.0374295748770237,
0.19268178939819336,
-0.3934946060180664,
-0.5508978366851807,
-0.8030681014060974,
0.2041245847940445,
0.5907366275787354,
0.4411775767803192,
-0.6024040579795837,
-0.019998818635940552,
-0.27590829133987427,
-0.33995336294174194,
-0.8032340407371521,
0.3931333124637604,
0.7752804160118103,
0.3373588025569916,
0.41846469044685364,
-0.17799989879131317,
-0.1233752891421318,
-1.0392653942108154,
-0.14981098473072052,
0.27030226588249207,
0.054411306977272034,
0.25744086503982544,
0.31824254989624023,
-0.02892722561955452,
0.22012434899806976,
-0.18562693893909454,
-0.09964656084775925,
-0.08283209800720215,
0.15310870110988617,
0.17079633474349976,
0.7973671555519104,
0.5354719758033752,
-0.5851439833641052,
-0.5731633901596069,
0.44159623980522156,
-0.544340968132019,
0.11016668379306793,
-0.24204303324222565,
-0.07803774625062943,
0.3830612897872925,
0.3296065628528595,
-0.28634122014045715,
0.18339455127716064,
0.744498074054718,
-0.10080215334892273,
0.5707112550735474,
-0.5221794843673706,
0.5759615302085876,
-0.8948144912719727,
-0.06810159236192703,
0.047710586339235306,
-0.015184012241661549,
-0.5988984704017639,
0.24662765860557556,
0.4503397047519684,
-0.10350635647773743,
-0.2885187864303589,
0.4133104085922241,
-0.5237883925437927,
0.045618146657943726,
-0.11337301135063171,
-0.04678976535797119,
0.13467173278331757,
0.2650459110736847,
-0.17515452206134796,
1.0919833183288574,
0.391226589679718,
-0.7188132405281067,
0.2141396552324295,
0.16250699758529663,
-0.7749037742614746,
0.33381086587905884,
-0.5188016295433044,
0.2585286498069763,
-0.070156030356884,
-0.29806390404701233,
-0.7147043347358704,
-0.4160814881324768,
-0.030173219740390778,
-0.2760002315044403,
0.768420398235321,
-0.253777414560318,
-0.7003369927406311,
-0.1382177323102951,
0.013941861689090729,
0.3706956207752228,
0.28342393040657043,
-0.5601537227630615,
0.007593052927404642,
-0.0281682051718235,
-0.027856942266225815,
-0.5155272483825684,
-0.7577703595161438,
-0.11203557252883911,
-0.1470738798379898,
-0.558685302734375,
0.22588497400283813,
-0.03288933262228966,
-0.19841018319129944,
-0.2229209989309311,
-0.09921663999557495,
-0.08265846967697144,
0.19082558155059814,
-0.18200364708900452,
0.24882473051548004,
-0.616877019405365,
0.2690492272377014,
0.1916116625070572,
-0.0008994349627755582,
-0.05738677829504013,
0.006034437566995621,
0.35418063402175903,
0.05121453478932381,
-0.48770076036453247,
-0.4161892831325531,
0.43057554960250854,
0.644860029220581,
-0.7277616262435913,
0.7662702202796936,
0.4230388402938843,
-0.37570667266845703,
-0.28873756527900696,
-0.5470672249794006,
-0.06356319785118103,
-0.42970889806747437,
0.4943116307258606,
-0.40848508477211,
-0.4951161742210388,
0.5170044898986816,
0.17106615006923676,
0.17938610911369324,
0.3124270439147949,
0.3771933615207672,
0.09365014731884003,
1.4172008037567139,
0.6172975301742554,
-0.16066917777061462,
0.3395473062992096,
-0.1819923222064972,
0.16275590658187866,
-0.665922224521637,
-0.11242438107728958,
-0.7483052015304565,
-0.3881852924823761,
-0.7671610713005066,
-0.33741143345832825,
0.20094019174575806,
0.24919924139976501,
0.02510170266032219,
0.14823153614997864,
-0.2683931887149811,
0.7318386435508728,
0.3347722589969635,
-0.09651918709278107,
0.22436578571796417,
0.0500551275908947,
-0.08411022275686264,
-0.3709266781806946,
-0.8154326677322388,
-0.5975021123886108,
1.0931456089019775,
0.0886029601097107,
1.0182970762252808,
0.02817976288497448,
0.38111215829849243,
-0.07452481240034103,
0.3193979859352112,
-0.7819791436195374,
-0.02073284611105919,
-0.49190494418144226,
-0.6305256485939026,
-0.1252160668373108,
-0.636268675327301,
-1.1685433387756348,
0.16385383903980255,
-0.1061251237988472,
-0.679154634475708,
0.18790195882320404,
0.2481754869222641,
-0.26173192262649536,
0.15075354278087616,
-1.2000819444656372,
1.225548505783081,
-0.5077880620956421,
-0.41759395599365234,
-0.27667978405952454,
-0.36456429958343506,
0.42796745896339417,
-0.16478078067302704,
0.40559327602386475,
0.12641671299934387,
0.3168705999851227,
0.6947792172431946,
0.006706857122480869,
0.7425316572189331,
-0.18568187952041626,
-0.2776111662387848,
0.026243606582283974,
0.11124685406684875,
0.31678706407546997,
-0.07720458507537842,
-0.4236043393611908,
-0.013238481245934963,
0.11926349252462387,
-0.6152953505516052,
-0.6925902962684631,
0.879969596862793,
-0.7242892384529114,
-0.5221583247184753,
0.040882620960474014,
-0.7335075736045837,
-0.5106559991836548,
0.2714386582374573,
0.17271988093852997,
0.6310563087463379,
-0.016121063381433487,
0.3068714737892151,
0.6759781241416931,
-0.4962840974330902,
0.12440823763608932,
0.6479831337928772,
0.08210412412881851,
0.14744330942630768,
1.4351816177368164,
0.3551729917526245,
0.6327194571495056,
0.13816405832767487,
0.22918766736984253,
-0.1314323991537094,
-0.591963529586792,
-0.9317449331283569,
0.28760507702827454,
-0.6916905045509338,
-0.10798358917236328,
0.1095699816942215,
0.08881335705518723,
-0.3021266758441925,
0.155949205160141,
-0.6594556570053101,
-0.0966818556189537,
-0.3169085383415222,
-0.10440435260534286,
-0.03447609394788742,
0.831082820892334,
0.14511041343212128,
0.1816147267818451,
-0.9570465683937073,
0.0914313942193985,
-0.02992277219891548,
0.5702780485153198,
0.011741463094949722,
-0.4924798011779785,
-0.7952601313591003,
0.40116962790489197,
-0.17172230780124664,
-0.6167802810668945,
0.14486834406852722,
0.4895622730255127,
0.7767577767372131,
0.43812790513038635,
-0.2179526686668396,
0.756569504737854,
-0.585648238658905,
0.6872694492340088,
-0.35347992181777954,
-0.7067564725875854,
0.49230876564979553,
-0.27567538619041443,
0.5470136404037476,
0.5496093034744263,
0.5563796162605286,
-0.6621179580688477,
-0.301029771566391,
-0.11482087522745132,
-0.5072855353355408,
0.8742668628692627,
-0.2085803896188736,
0.5104504227638245,
-0.06887704133987427,
0.37236207723617554,
0.34304872155189514,
0.15230652689933777,
-0.36428090929985046,
-0.29482144117355347,
-0.07967931032180786,
0.008429919369518757,
-0.5763542056083679,
-0.14216336607933044,
0.04490215331315994,
-0.14723753929138184,
0.40897315740585327,
-0.10456718504428864,
-0.14937858283519745,
-0.354114294052124,
-0.3069522976875305,
-0.24795663356781006,
0.36961546540260315,
0.689723789691925,
0.8176997303962708,
0.035918235778808594,
-0.1593177318572998,
0.0005542630678974092,
-0.2628822326660156,
-0.07020372897386551,
0.015768785029649734,
-0.22099265456199646,
-0.01441108901053667,
0.5179765224456787,
0.8085103631019592,
0.5633359551429749,
-0.5105583667755127,
0.3091108500957489,
0.04964775964617729,
0.12315106391906738,
0.34737321734428406,
0.21087802946567535,
-0.02701340802013874,
-0.18274319171905518,
-0.03719421476125717,
0.05294756963849068,
0.01016887929290533,
-0.6405389904975891,
-0.018422378227114677,
0.24233223497867584,
-0.26373618841171265,
-0.5794450044631958,
0.4798457622528076,
0.15706059336662292,
-0.2200779914855957,
1.0317275524139404,
-0.1480182558298111,
-0.462364137172699,
0.5906849503517151,
0.6706908345222473,
0.1911933571100235,
-0.6531559228897095,
0.11296349763870239,
0.5958092212677002,
0.6761627197265625,
-0.09730052947998047,
0.22485458850860596,
-0.01672566868364811,
-0.685531735420227,
-0.7770813703536987,
-0.5819798111915588,
-0.18709984421730042,
0.17342393100261688,
-1.0045955181121826,
0.2865658402442932,
-0.05927126109600067,
0.14799843728542328,
-0.07243305444717407,
-0.16985926032066345,
-0.7152077555656433,
0.36106494069099426,
0.2441982477903366,
0.7908143401145935,
-1.163535475730896,
0.8341554403305054,
0.5811418294906616,
-0.2598002254962921,
-0.7990734577178955,
-0.2265913039445877,
-0.32177528738975525,
-0.548053503036499,
0.5015554428100586,
0.15211015939712524,
0.10839021950960159,
-0.19265012443065643,
-0.19114704430103302,
-0.7858715057373047,
0.2826477587223053,
0.5909179449081421,
-0.6080912947654724,
0.035606302320957184,
0.252822607755661,
0.6372591257095337,
-0.056703560054302216,
-0.0014673990663141012,
0.7662742137908936,
0.7294517159461975,
-0.3128372132778168,
-1.1184066534042358,
-0.2939371168613434,
-0.3573760688304901,
-0.1546974927186966,
0.3762665390968323,
-0.6089805960655212,
1.0402586460113525,
-0.1101691722869873,
-0.3944769501686096,
-0.051906537264585495,
0.25840169191360474,
-0.19090954959392548,
0.006023424211889505,
0.1886926144361496,
0.29143857955932617,
0.6645436882972717,
-0.27992358803749084,
1.5016556978225708,
-0.3605269193649292,
0.13997358083724976,
1.0921272039413452,
-0.059616055339574814,
0.7068830132484436,
0.34286215901374817,
-0.057051945477724075,
0.08220869302749634,
0.8892436027526855,
-0.03468433767557144,
0.336716890335083,
0.2066100537776947,
0.1638573706150055,
-0.37810686230659485,
-0.12092791497707367,
-0.47978588938713074,
0.5561360120773315,
0.4199027717113495,
-0.15894734859466553,
-0.36579304933547974,
0.11665184795856476,
-0.11335592716932297,
0.3511238098144531,
-0.2968533933162689,
0.47805604338645935,
-0.0968003123998642,
-0.9056843519210815,
1.0136796236038208,
0.3243560194969177,
0.5397515892982483,
-0.594231128692627,
-0.2531984746456146,
-0.5050697922706604,
0.15429864823818207,
-0.28254011273384094,
-0.41489657759666443,
0.29691997170448303,
0.1511082798242569,
-0.23275034129619598,
-0.2488628327846527,
0.16166992485523224,
-0.5215684771537781,
-0.5981320738792419,
0.13113988935947418,
0.4449750781059265,
0.26768559217453003,
0.17999593913555145,
-0.5036766529083252,
0.23974139988422394,
0.02089087665081024,
-0.22024710476398468,
0.29173314571380615,
0.2664467692375183,
-0.477206289768219,
0.447897344827652,
0.4899823069572449,
0.2687554359436035,
0.2572036385536194,
0.4699670374393463,
0.5655707120895386,
-0.29335182905197144,
-0.2613914906978607,
-0.6566882133483887,
0.4656605124473572,
0.19656029343605042,
-0.6424588561058044,
0.9819893836975098,
0.7791104316711426,
1.2992379665374756,
-0.08195571601390839,
0.383068710565567,
0.487686425447464,
0.4169743061065674,
-0.773926854133606,
0.6274421811103821,
-0.6793737411499023,
0.11466174572706223,
-0.09285226464271545,
-0.9761343598365784,
-0.22023023664951324,
0.5216554999351501,
-0.572672963142395,
0.19985437393188477,
0.5452022552490234,
0.7830832600593567,
-0.4378521144390106,
-0.1169295385479927,
0.4399794638156891,
0.05824990198016167,
0.1363217681646347,
0.44784975051879883,
0.7611950635910034,
-0.5030133724212646,
0.3311814069747925,
-0.36073142290115356,
-0.20060543715953827,
0.02835828997194767,
-0.4284997880458832,
-0.7969561815261841,
-0.3640073835849762,
-0.22432652115821838,
0.06741742044687271,
0.04135902598500252,
0.6323491334915161,
0.7243185043334961,
-1.0811214447021484,
-0.4575883448123932,
0.2986278831958771,
0.18233473598957062,
-0.3380187153816223,
-0.15443798899650574,
0.3395255208015442,
-0.6122822165489197,
-1.1673142910003662,
0.750015377998352,
-0.04400486499071121,
0.09575269371271133,
-0.38960886001586914,
-0.02504490315914154,
-0.11418528109788895,
-0.1368982046842575,
0.43040594458580017,
0.15469324588775635,
-0.5413796901702881,
-0.22334548830986023,
0.163528710603714,
-0.08876772224903107,
0.03626614063978195,
0.6773105263710022,
-0.3010057210922241,
0.9052709341049194,
0.18358643352985382,
0.7462843060493469,
0.4999757707118988,
-0.04057896137237549,
0.8339582085609436,
-0.9302935600280762,
0.2805982828140259,
0.12386535108089447,
0.28122273087501526,
0.6161535382270813,
-0.30073586106300354,
0.2759314179420471,
-0.17019836604595184,
-0.41637614369392395,
-0.993384838104248,
0.13619667291641235,
-0.3305134177207947,
-0.1400422751903534,
0.9893584251403809,
-0.3125384747982025,
-0.13885733485221863,
0.16527840495109558,
-0.04927773028612137,
0.26723867654800415,
-0.03098328784108162,
0.8319907188415527,
0.9766256213188171,
0.14487265050411224,
0.1735769808292389,
-1.1287133693695068,
0.3906988203525543,
0.5115318894386292,
-0.5545167326927185,
0.11517483741044998,
0.6175947785377502,
0.1541108936071396,
0.13201099634170532,
-0.06652116030454636,
-0.15233467519283295,
0.53730309009552,
-0.08731316030025482,
-0.09956133365631104,
-0.05823659524321556,
-0.3923923969268799,
-0.45918357372283936,
-0.2984180152416229,
0.29455655813217163,
-0.24424296617507935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12814v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12814v1 | Adversarial Attacks on Multimodal Agents | 2024-06-18T17:32:48 | 2024-06-18T17:32:48 | Chen Henry Wu, Jing Yu Koh, Ruslan Salakhutdinov, Daniel Fried, Aditi Raghunathan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CV | Vision-enabled language models (VLMs) are now used to build autonomous
multimodal agents capable of taking actions in real environments. In this
paper, we show that multimodal agents raise new safety risks, even though
attacking agents is more challenging than prior attacks due to limited access
to and knowledge about the environment. Our attacks use adversarial text
strings to guide gradient-based perturbation over one trigger image in the
environment: (1) our captioner attack attacks white-box captioners if they are
used to process images into captions as additional inputs to the VLM; (2) our
CLIP attack attacks a set of CLIP models jointly, which can transfer to
proprietary VLMs. To evaluate the attacks, we curated VisualWebArena-Adv, a set
of adversarial tasks based on VisualWebArena, an environment for web-based
multimodal agent tasks. Within an L-infinity norm of $16/256$ on a single
image, the captioner attack can make a captioner-augmented GPT-4V agent execute
the adversarial goals with a 75% success rate. When we remove the captioner or
use GPT-4V to generate its own captions, the CLIP attack can achieve success
rates of 21% and 43%, respectively. Experiments on agents based on other VLMs,
such as Gemini-1.5, Claude-3, and GPT-4o, show interesting differences in their
robustness. Further analysis reveals several key factors contributing to the
attack's success, and we also discuss the implications for defenses as well.
Project page: https://chenwu.io/attack-agent Code and data:
https://github.com/ChenWu98/agent-attack | [
-0.5641281604766846,
-0.8847672939300537,
0.17991527915000916,
-0.06501650810241699,
-0.10632243752479553,
0.21687085926532745,
0.13703295588493347,
-0.42608678340911865,
-0.06180114299058914,
0.7831940054893494,
-0.4007406234741211,
-0.09833434224128723,
-0.7871779799461365,
-0.058364253491163254,
-0.5540647506713867,
1.0394995212554932,
0.1564159095287323,
0.08985177427530289,
-0.11775036156177521,
-0.3567172586917877,
-0.5110638737678528,
-0.8159206509590149,
-0.4066515266895294,
0.3660176992416382,
0.7140964269638062,
-0.2941710650920868,
1.0653105974197388,
0.45373013615608215,
0.6823296546936035,
0.42566734552383423,
0.13916225731372833,
0.06395190954208374,
-0.3724140524864197,
0.2385430932044983,
0.09816411882638931,
-0.4386306405067444,
-0.3341559171676636,
0.05197645351290703,
0.3086370825767517,
-0.018802419304847717,
0.07632696628570557,
-0.17518840730190277,
-0.19484253227710724,
0.41340336203575134,
-0.6784321069717407,
-0.058951061218976974,
-0.8614637851715088,
0.11858725547790527,
-0.30011945962905884,
-0.20058177411556244,
-0.3642842173576355,
-0.03359423950314522,
-0.009241542778909206,
-0.52951580286026,
0.2868448793888092,
0.05416043475270271,
1.133996605873108,
0.4980819523334503,
-0.5619337558746338,
-0.30500027537345886,
-0.39691898226737976,
0.5554429292678833,
-0.3491863012313843,
-0.02581961825489998,
0.003967450466006994,
0.4547823369503021,
-0.19622574746608734,
-0.7154181599617004,
-0.6979560852050781,
-0.27226006984710693,
0.02438201755285263,
0.1539088636636734,
-0.5999469757080078,
0.08487749844789505,
0.37504151463508606,
-0.0730605199933052,
-0.4241037964820862,
-0.020508084446191788,
-0.5458081364631653,
-0.3394847810268402,
0.44417065382003784,
0.1441151201725006,
0.5822504758834839,
-0.18660643696784973,
-0.9444875121116638,
-0.35354262590408325,
-0.652317225933075,
0.12309792637825012,
0.5164950489997864,
0.08755533397197723,
-0.017338408157229424,
0.5522899627685547,
0.13035841286182404,
0.6777682304382324,
-0.1753835678100586,
-0.05598834529519081,
-0.10796129703521729,
-0.49662086367607117,
-0.12843866646289825,
-0.23796838521957397,
1.0121990442276,
0.5711237788200378,
0.4235347509384155,
-0.0596245601773262,
-0.32100027799606323,
0.18375959992408752,
0.7657649517059326,
-0.5712397694587708,
-0.3202314078807831,
0.056109920144081116,
-0.02675485983490944,
-0.5456732511520386,
0.24728992581367493,
-0.9211440682411194,
-0.7333328127861023,
0.12586644291877747,
0.6053172945976257,
-0.383373886346817,
0.1522550880908966,
-0.32236239314079285,
-0.3669264316558838,
0.3395792543888092,
0.3490769863128662,
-0.46354907751083374,
0.11166632175445557,
0.25186264514923096,
0.794036328792572,
0.0029471714515239,
-0.5231220722198486,
-0.7948791980743408,
0.13117897510528564,
-0.2734164893627167,
0.6562287211418152,
-0.19440753757953644,
-0.3645317256450653,
0.047695890069007874,
0.02300393022596836,
-0.16338038444519043,
-0.16949133574962616,
0.21665965020656586,
-0.823171854019165,
-0.003184350673109293,
-0.16317211091518402,
0.042063549160957336,
-0.3879920244216919,
0.5620314478874207,
-1.1077196598052979,
0.2579457759857178,
-0.143121138215065,
-0.7892847061157227,
0.22770513594150543,
-0.6987936496734619,
-0.5592055320739746,
-0.058525361120700836,
-0.21373213827610016,
-0.4338686466217041,
-0.008284633047878742,
0.48842179775238037,
0.3649197220802307,
0.03174624964594841,
-0.29852113127708435,
-0.318584680557251,
-0.0946059599518776,
0.6566071510314941,
-0.7951266169548035,
0.8344094753265381,
0.18633729219436646,
-0.40567997097969055,
0.46884873509407043,
-0.44149866700172424,
-0.07512345165014267,
0.430557519197464,
-0.10392159223556519,
-0.21907861530780792,
-0.04505378380417824,
0.0629466250538826,
0.29051145911216736,
0.15998680889606476,
-0.29928427934646606,
0.189763143658638,
0.061770275235176086,
0.4899173676967621,
0.8855679631233215,
0.18596552312374115,
0.26072534918785095,
-0.2004164457321167,
0.789142906665802,
-0.22924821078777313,
0.7127839922904968,
-0.24758906662464142,
-0.39542052149772644,
-0.46095237135887146,
-0.5368432998657227,
0.06462015956640244,
0.5787906050682068,
-1.405590295791626,
-0.4308569133281708,
-0.020146092399954796,
-0.4244549572467804,
-0.3504886329174042,
0.20385906100273132,
0.668235182762146,
0.1066431775689125,
0.31044504046440125,
-0.15246789157390594,
-0.21685615181922913,
-0.7678820490837097,
-0.05567660555243492,
0.024986160919070244,
0.18870633840560913,
0.10578342527151108,
0.5193365812301636,
-0.35652869939804077,
0.6583122611045837,
-0.5328998565673828,
-0.36407360434532166,
-0.06419327110052109,
-0.09279368072748184,
-0.3427641689777374,
0.3072494864463806,
0.9659045934677124,
-1.229371428489685,
-0.5441691279411316,
-0.13304200768470764,
-0.8812339305877686,
0.34098440408706665,
-0.2108186036348343,
0.005333661567419767,
0.2341020703315735,
0.4587230086326599,
-0.8366386294364929,
0.38552212715148926,
0.6212864518165588,
-0.1336994171142578,
0.6058778762817383,
-0.22875361144542694,
0.19147594273090363,
-0.7517881393432617,
-0.20714356005191803,
-0.08043194562196732,
-0.2953033149242401,
-0.8005212545394897,
0.6114651560783386,
-0.006839861162006855,
-0.20710508525371552,
-0.8862208724021912,
0.24543751776218414,
-0.4453084468841553,
0.052778515964746475,
-0.30592313408851624,
0.025873474776744843,
0.17603521049022675,
0.6830171346664429,
-0.3393459618091583,
0.8306916356086731,
0.6956306099891663,
-0.4192286431789398,
0.6856820583343506,
0.17873011529445648,
-0.07856570184230804,
0.5874357223510742,
-0.6985300183296204,
0.2007254660129547,
-0.09389320760965347,
0.14178240299224854,
-0.813677966594696,
-0.16236244142055511,
0.4068031907081604,
-0.5898347496986389,
0.4401737153530121,
0.036248475313186646,
-0.4233684241771698,
-0.2016291320323944,
-0.7640995979309082,
0.055259887129068375,
0.14371705055236816,
-0.507176399230957,
0.6121385097503662,
0.40464866161346436,
-0.014772876165807247,
-0.9617587327957153,
-0.5568770170211792,
0.5638628005981445,
-0.3217881917953491,
-0.560290515422821,
-0.048503223806619644,
-0.07212913036346436,
-0.25893938541412354,
0.09467487037181854,
0.027980294078588486,
-0.11926984786987305,
0.4160194993019104,
0.4341959059238434,
0.3399460017681122,
0.1260366439819336,
-0.2942209541797638,
-0.4534803330898285,
0.03450825810432434,
0.16008207201957703,
-0.08864086121320724,
0.4374259114265442,
-0.35555821657180786,
-0.5325258374214172,
-0.1630626767873764,
0.4718776047229767,
1.1253671646118164,
-0.5520418286323547,
0.7013062238693237,
0.9025493264198303,
-0.1942448616027832,
0.03768787905573845,
-0.3487201929092407,
-0.14129041135311127,
-0.47448840737342834,
0.6328550577163696,
-0.3761071562767029,
-0.6169558763504028,
0.42693135142326355,
0.5265781879425049,
0.04206268861889839,
0.3436008393764496,
0.3575076758861542,
-0.16663776338100433,
1.166783094406128,
0.42870619893074036,
-0.09437984228134155,
0.6439779996871948,
-0.381725937128067,
-0.09857659041881561,
-0.7319328784942627,
-0.18969781696796417,
-0.15296407043933868,
0.10934764891862869,
-0.5463460683822632,
-0.41610607504844666,
0.5251259803771973,
-0.24453051388263702,
-0.012052563950419426,
0.43435433506965637,
-0.2608371376991272,
0.17073209583759308,
0.6373401284217834,
-0.07252690941095352,
-0.07712062448263168,
-0.016292039304971695,
0.07975686341524124,
0.18547594547271729,
-0.7475520372390747,
-0.4137055277824402,
1.0997639894485474,
0.4035174250602722,
1.0322067737579346,
0.48238039016723633,
0.12874886393547058,
0.8104497790336609,
0.22335468232631683,
-0.42145130038261414,
0.4606925845146179,
-0.06907352060079575,
-0.6764811277389526,
-0.33270224928855896,
-0.14328746497631073,
-0.9684240221977234,
0.7833342552185059,
-0.3348504602909088,
-0.4637466073036194,
-0.07321124523878098,
0.15393412113189697,
-0.2675015926361084,
0.3103530704975128,
-0.7623761892318726,
0.9935141801834106,
-0.6519066691398621,
-0.4645683765411377,
0.051722001284360886,
-0.8437080383300781,
0.39654073119163513,
-0.13862678408622742,
0.2893105149269104,
0.1015399694442749,
0.009856436401605606,
0.3548679053783417,
-0.36592531204223633,
0.9875460863113403,
-0.2386876940727234,
0.061262380331754684,
0.40351155400276184,
0.00556973647326231,
0.7119572758674622,
-0.043736834079027176,
0.49072879552841187,
0.06683868914842606,
-0.03465883433818817,
-0.5692614912986755,
-0.6787542104721069,
0.481548547744751,
-0.6965314745903015,
-0.8937294483184814,
-0.5680167078971863,
-0.4784998595714569,
0.08339444547891617,
0.07036144286394119,
0.35924744606018066,
0.7187477946281433,
-0.05397026613354683,
0.16000060737133026,
0.6000382900238037,
-0.2712972164154053,
0.6609728336334229,
0.5672697424888611,
0.13671797513961792,
-0.7453590631484985,
1.2223209142684937,
0.05684823542833328,
0.7618529796600342,
0.28128883242607117,
-0.2303732931613922,
-0.3095342814922333,
-0.640923798084259,
-0.7792585492134094,
-0.15427082777023315,
-0.9301994442939758,
-0.3522987961769104,
-0.6202273368835449,
-0.05715499818325043,
-0.44147762656211853,
-0.08176617324352264,
-0.25313279032707214,
0.025224804878234863,
-0.06795300543308258,
0.030748682096600533,
0.09626545011997223,
0.784311056137085,
0.2562853991985321,
0.22409850358963013,
-0.8424760699272156,
0.22055046260356903,
0.7050630450248718,
-0.3061569035053253,
-0.15623082220554352,
-0.0728435292840004,
-0.21137110888957977,
-0.10844357311725616,
-0.4868091642856598,
-1.1107944250106812,
0.4181089997291565,
-0.0471365861594677,
0.7293877601623535,
0.4622214436531067,
0.06327738612890244,
0.4557795524597168,
-0.5301731824874878,
0.8908472061157227,
0.31684011220932007,
-0.7899651527404785,
0.2201603502035141,
-0.32103231549263,
0.32110342383384705,
0.24549926817417145,
0.0805632621049881,
-0.19031073153018951,
-0.589743971824646,
-0.46405112743377686,
-0.7245365381240845,
0.45829063653945923,
0.4848618507385254,
0.24112708866596222,
0.16033606231212616,
-0.13674437999725342,
-0.18266339600086212,
0.5093081593513489,
-0.9709758162498474,
-0.31410786509513855,
-0.682100772857666,
0.09205501526594162,
0.06944159418344498,
-0.2894713282585144,
-0.45565783977508545,
0.2541113495826721,
0.316305011510849,
-0.2914518713951111,
0.19741040468215942,
0.2894081175327301,
-0.40189820528030396,
0.18577808141708374,
0.3337177336215973,
1.1393976211547852,
0.3317229449748993,
0.04300979524850845,
0.34569957852363586,
0.14004427194595337,
-0.5151627659797668,
0.09480240195989609,
0.34062278270721436,
-0.173915296792984,
-0.2326173633337021,
0.8216636180877686,
0.8924368023872375,
0.03718995302915573,
-0.8777453303337097,
0.8358516097068787,
-0.3157539963722229,
0.02473045513033867,
-0.3704264163970947,
-0.11675244569778442,
-0.39010360836982727,
0.3911399245262146,
0.4074958562850952,
0.4828905463218689,
0.047101959586143494,
-0.4919554889202118,
0.19489292800426483,
0.8438644409179688,
-0.8162936568260193,
-0.2945842742919922,
0.7812193036079407,
0.18618297576904297,
-0.035886842757463455,
0.0716639906167984,
-0.24274501204490662,
-1.0597374439239502,
0.8374535441398621,
0.353244423866272,
0.6620093584060669,
-0.18885831534862518,
0.18565349280834198,
-0.3064063489437103,
0.8662759065628052,
0.21553374826908112,
-0.12914146482944489,
0.10209472477436066,
-0.642455518245697,
-0.13435040414333344,
-0.23587407171726227,
-0.40967947244644165,
0.028982622548937798,
-0.5218806266784668,
-0.08165862411260605,
-0.5795354247093201,
-0.19180536270141602,
-0.03783847391605377,
-0.4775085747241974,
-0.46740999817848206,
0.1721208691596985,
0.22154530882835388,
0.28338438272476196,
-0.5362721681594849,
0.6456101536750793,
0.8691738843917847,
-0.5988806486129761,
-0.2653558552265167,
0.011692033149302006,
0.3227817118167877,
-0.629571259021759,
0.5325607061386108,
0.1352653205394745,
-0.20777775347232819,
-0.34914660453796387,
-0.48460766673088074,
-0.8511974215507507,
0.8999729156494141,
0.41592761874198914,
-0.21011103689670563,
0.13302959501743317,
-0.1336071491241455,
0.4426238238811493,
-0.09202835708856583,
-0.027914952486753464,
0.12266281247138977,
0.34721508622169495,
-0.13924956321716309,
-0.6896594166755676,
0.14346322417259216,
-0.24717724323272705,
-0.08399801701307297,
0.15392321348190308,
-0.7743605375289917,
1.171191692352295,
-0.35247910022735596,
-0.32599252462387085,
-0.058791715651750565,
0.5145826935768127,
-0.056941837072372437,
0.126693457365036,
0.6557111740112305,
0.2244812697172165,
0.35508275032043457,
0.078616663813591,
1.4722610712051392,
-0.13442887365818024,
0.138623908162117,
0.7746315598487854,
-0.046086374670267105,
0.5624104142189026,
0.4488300383090973,
-0.08608141541481018,
0.1600104123353958,
0.08705675601959229,
-0.34326377511024475,
0.5930461883544922,
0.05622105672955513,
-0.15753917396068573,
-0.019931774586439133,
-0.05704585462808609,
-0.23852936923503876,
0.4770067036151886,
0.08837651461362839,
-0.1167842447757721,
0.07167894393205643,
0.6608890295028687,
0.28492680191993713,
0.22803056240081787,
-0.1627284437417984,
0.538001537322998,
-0.130746990442276,
-0.41528987884521484,
0.5556053519248962,
-0.11841216683387756,
0.5830363035202026,
-0.7754325866699219,
0.09357183426618576,
0.17421184480190277,
0.2060769647359848,
0.008072121068835258,
-0.5486248731613159,
-0.04778364300727844,
0.07434383779764175,
-0.09205471724271774,
-0.0062679811380803585,
0.6089072227478027,
-0.2937372624874115,
-0.2886418104171753,
0.3125438392162323,
0.19490431249141693,
-0.1976308375597,
-0.339942991733551,
-0.6723271012306213,
0.21073055267333984,
0.13727526366710663,
-0.2539350390434265,
0.38966992497444153,
-0.09197364002466202,
-0.13592134416103363,
0.8079626560211182,
0.6044789552688599,
-0.0901825949549675,
0.4201330542564392,
0.013213933445513248,
0.9387104511260986,
-0.54158616065979,
-0.32856637239456177,
-1.0099523067474365,
0.3390776515007019,
-0.3361262381076813,
-0.0273482333868742,
1.0536316633224487,
0.22520573437213898,
0.6076602339744568,
-0.26372030377388,
0.9169715046882629,
-0.10796591639518738,
-0.1312842220067978,
-0.7676576375961304,
0.8575552105903625,
-0.5433119535446167,
0.28270503878593445,
-0.3793891966342926,
-0.5022633671760559,
-0.1760701835155487,
0.05218345299363136,
-0.047683533281087875,
-0.1546376347541809,
0.6823607683181763,
0.7108732461929321,
0.33260634541511536,
-0.3061939477920532,
0.5100451111793518,
0.03429725393652916,
0.847791314125061,
0.5322632193565369,
1.0944015979766846,
-0.41542884707450867,
1.1920360326766968,
-0.15014222264289856,
-0.02156197279691696,
-0.09918802976608276,
-0.6563826203346252,
-1.2660003900527954,
-0.45895645022392273,
-0.24256551265716553,
-0.2892497777938843,
0.24764813482761383,
0.45277029275894165,
0.6731105446815491,
-0.6202138662338257,
0.30550727248191833,
0.32643550634384155,
0.2050592005252838,
-0.28805044293403625,
-0.23493248224258423,
0.31391531229019165,
-0.14148542284965515,
-0.7137429118156433,
0.4322473406791687,
0.2133827656507492,
0.2856288254261017,
-0.5813161730766296,
-0.021417958661913872,
-0.17986977100372314,
0.1469373106956482,
0.5303136706352234,
0.32836881279945374,
-1.0237623453140259,
-0.3304499685764313,
-0.18201903998851776,
-0.3425550162792206,
-0.17368341982364655,
0.5493058562278748,
-0.3694218695163727,
0.6396582126617432,
0.1074347123503685,
0.6419628858566284,
0.20360532402992249,
0.1731562316417694,
0.5408871173858643,
-0.7042798399925232,
0.2743507921695709,
-0.019461484625935555,
0.4431403875350952,
0.4796806275844574,
-0.37751489877700806,
0.26209500432014465,
0.48464280366897583,
-0.15879638493061066,
-0.8442314863204956,
0.3024965822696686,
-0.9634844064712524,
-0.5321149826049805,
1.059487223625183,
-0.31073489785194397,
-0.3797299563884735,
0.030927887186408043,
-0.6167395710945129,
-0.12056856602430344,
-0.3724537789821625,
0.5549713969230652,
0.5215517282485962,
0.2172521948814392,
-0.13414393365383148,
-0.825869083404541,
0.5419110655784607,
0.07629112899303436,
-0.7133625745773315,
-0.22609882056713104,
0.42199039459228516,
0.14111018180847168,
0.4579017460346222,
0.17998412251472473,
-0.04909229651093483,
0.4733699858188629,
0.38489794731140137,
0.09011217951774597,
-0.6665340065956116,
-0.40608730912208557,
-0.3261483907699585,
0.880376935005188,
-0.1084483340382576,
-0.702483594417572
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12809v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12809v1 | Can Large Language Models Always Solve Easy Problems if They Can Solve Harder Ones? | 2024-06-18T17:25:47 | 2024-06-18T17:25:47 | Zhe Yang, Yichang Zhang, Tianyu Liu, Jian Yang, Junyang Lin, Chang Zhou, Zhifang Sui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities, but
still suffer from inconsistency issues (e.g. LLMs can react differently to
disturbances like rephrasing or inconsequential order change). In addition to
these inconsistencies, we also observe that LLMs, while capable of solving hard
problems, can paradoxically fail at easier ones. To evaluate this hard-to-easy
inconsistency, we develop the ConsisEval benchmark, where each entry comprises
a pair of questions with a strict order of difficulty. Furthermore, we
introduce the concept of consistency score to quantitatively measure this
inconsistency and analyze the potential for improvement in consistency by
relative consistency score. Based on comprehensive experiments across a variety
of existing models, we find: (1) GPT-4 achieves the highest consistency score
of 92.2\% but is still inconsistent to specific questions due to distraction by
redundant information, misinterpretation of questions, etc.; (2) models with
stronger capabilities typically exhibit higher consistency, but exceptions also
exist; (3) hard data enhances consistency for both fine-tuning and in-context
learning. Our data and code will be publicly available on GitHub. | [
-0.12400490790605545,
-0.9583745002746582,
0.8666977286338806,
0.3753812611103058,
0.1726870834827423,
-0.0159045048058033,
-0.6034798622131348,
-0.5053853392601013,
-0.3734550476074219,
0.2218022346496582,
-0.3813188076019287,
-0.3119008541107178,
-0.8445866703987122,
0.22044308483600616,
-0.29634416103363037,
0.8685316443443298,
-0.25012442469596863,
-0.058041851967573166,
-0.18095369637012482,
-0.3734115958213806,
-0.6849769353866577,
-0.3661259412765503,
-0.6607406139373779,
-0.4737560749053955,
0.3521139621734619,
0.4939589202404022,
0.8300623297691345,
0.8435528874397278,
0.883281409740448,
0.3753606677055359,
-0.03560219705104828,
0.15542997419834137,
-0.48586297035217285,
0.28460580110549927,
-0.2926912307739258,
-0.32786494493484497,
-0.33804747462272644,
-0.055232662707567215,
0.658484697341919,
1.0301488637924194,
-0.5361903309822083,
-0.08503531664609909,
0.4215071201324463,
0.6000810861587524,
-0.1818607747554779,
0.35268959403038025,
-0.8489645719528198,
-0.31757551431655884,
-0.12283444404602051,
0.11239562928676605,
-0.18267403542995453,
-0.4687804877758026,
-0.08448760211467743,
-0.5304145216941833,
0.16356681287288666,
0.021856024861335754,
0.915761411190033,
0.3856785297393799,
-0.3752877414226532,
-0.421478807926178,
-0.6692046523094177,
0.7414237260818481,
-0.5498968362808228,
0.3855665922164917,
0.20179179310798645,
0.2039429098367691,
-0.4585783779621124,
-0.5057781338691711,
-0.5020217895507812,
-0.4050385057926178,
0.20661424100399017,
-0.22601985931396484,
-0.14000704884529114,
-0.10825532674789429,
0.6138993501663208,
0.2836316227912903,
-0.6893277168273926,
0.082376629114151,
-0.12001389265060425,
-0.07695954293012619,
0.5439572930335999,
0.4713590145111084,
0.2219036966562271,
-0.06145080551505089,
-0.14048217236995697,
-0.14793291687965393,
-0.8387669920921326,
0.2028714269399643,
0.16367846727371216,
0.3346722424030304,
-0.1778034269809723,
0.5193277597427368,
-0.33271005749702454,
0.5562329888343811,
0.07078301161527634,
-0.07652000337839127,
0.28698137402534485,
-0.2750405967235565,
-0.05000697076320648,
-0.2848842144012451,
0.6560499668121338,
0.08999774605035782,
0.40019941329956055,
-0.02358231134712696,
-0.3215297758579254,
-0.04054330289363861,
-0.015962278470396996,
-0.5319028496742249,
-0.38263824582099915,
0.295974999666214,
-0.05739043653011322,
0.21544013917446136,
0.08588919043540955,
-0.2386186569929123,
-0.3639914095401764,
-0.49572569131851196,
0.5759145021438599,
-0.5577006340026855,
-0.31583279371261597,
0.2656960189342499,
0.3197125494480133,
0.18075117468833923,
0.5093144178390503,
-0.7038695216178894,
0.4252191483974457,
1.0569372177124023,
0.6969895362854004,
-0.23441961407661438,
-0.42669564485549927,
-0.5080815553665161,
-0.06151523441076279,
-0.45804980397224426,
0.5904446244239807,
-0.3745472729206085,
-0.16320161521434784,
-0.1950552761554718,
0.2015237957239151,
0.020736807957291603,
-0.7857488393783569,
0.5762335062026978,
-0.1241760104894638,
-0.26539960503578186,
-0.4844222366809845,
-0.8682440519332886,
0.12748070061206818,
0.6300995945930481,
-0.5550321340560913,
0.9357826113700867,
0.029971802607178688,
-0.43566539883613586,
0.10546153038740158,
-0.07389658689498901,
-0.12411712110042572,
-0.02854432351887226,
-0.3499462306499481,
-0.46809300780296326,
0.2681709825992584,
-0.29613903164863586,
0.21618317067623138,
-0.40103641152381897,
0.5970450639724731,
-0.37246155738830566,
-0.5478454828262329,
0.2546077370643616,
-0.5235505700111389,
0.6200628280639648,
-0.02563335932791233,
-0.4715913236141205,
-0.13134834170341492,
-0.53495192527771,
0.4181927442550659,
0.22825202345848083,
-0.6073793172836304,
-0.17940199375152588,
0.0024788423907011747,
-0.2363910973072052,
0.10957822948694229,
0.42810484766960144,
-0.4423367381095886,
0.416324257850647,
-0.052957504987716675,
0.22476154565811157,
0.8423520922660828,
-0.1978500783443451,
0.0746101513504982,
-0.46794945001602173,
0.18699610233306885,
-0.02678854390978813,
0.05618700385093689,
0.03876151517033577,
-0.5469980835914612,
-0.7739985585212708,
0.043146293610334396,
0.4229516088962555,
0.5166779160499573,
-0.47416242957115173,
0.20646460354328156,
-0.3136208653450012,
-0.6074852347373962,
-0.3660507798194885,
0.4881100356578827,
0.5758910179138184,
0.4736028015613556,
0.2580536901950836,
-0.2586437165737152,
-0.36771541833877563,
-0.8260717988014221,
-0.45776495337486267,
-0.2124066948890686,
-0.017488373443484306,
0.24284136295318604,
0.4558306932449341,
-0.08159958571195602,
0.5693472623825073,
-0.41059356927871704,
0.04846867546439171,
-0.13843011856079102,
0.16366806626319885,
0.46753665804862976,
0.7549307942390442,
-0.006007973570376635,
-0.6367820501327515,
-0.4741952419281006,
-0.15472586452960968,
-0.807249128818512,
-0.21223530173301697,
0.44155269861221313,
0.24288928508758545,
0.17385494709014893,
0.6499682664871216,
-0.724414050579071,
-0.06974516063928604,
0.6056299805641174,
-0.1482876092195511,
0.5777618885040283,
-0.5478700399398804,
0.24212586879730225,
-0.4983602464199066,
-0.029947979375720024,
0.18303531408309937,
-0.24149090051651,
-0.446166455745697,
0.04960167407989502,
0.31169140338897705,
-0.006448466796427965,
-0.2674580514431,
0.4401513338088989,
-0.22804129123687744,
0.18314620852470398,
-0.04549741744995117,
-0.1007179543375969,
0.03137337043881416,
0.43369826674461365,
-0.21982090175151825,
0.5347285270690918,
0.28761669993400574,
-0.38529685139656067,
0.28318727016448975,
-0.14140982925891876,
-0.6501408815383911,
0.5176073312759399,
-0.9488359093666077,
0.3272124230861664,
-0.11221951246261597,
0.07215690612792969,
-1.2467823028564453,
-0.49063950777053833,
-0.0859094113111496,
-0.10425618290901184,
0.4695177376270294,
-0.09539476037025452,
-0.6408026218414307,
-0.052176930010318756,
-0.10879898816347122,
0.5265566110610962,
0.37752845883369446,
-0.31511756777763367,
0.2103678584098816,
0.16527310013771057,
-0.25820761919021606,
-0.4801834225654602,
-0.3882211148738861,
-0.09567184746265411,
0.022387366741895676,
-0.5085242986679077,
0.21661916375160217,
-0.42483702301979065,
-0.41179728507995605,
-0.02001236192882061,
-0.07655148953199387,
-0.0515410453081131,
0.03963052108883858,
0.23199611902236938,
0.07778732478618622,
-0.24455614387989044,
0.29888463020324707,
-0.446213960647583,
-0.12827222049236298,
-0.08106383681297302,
0.015093054622411728,
0.4643815755844116,
-0.5058690905570984,
-0.6020110845565796,
-0.3404558598995209,
0.3354220390319824,
0.49790263175964355,
0.05280550196766853,
0.4004475772380829,
0.030336324125528336,
-0.5140533447265625,
-0.019191203638911247,
-0.7936530113220215,
-0.05585058033466339,
-0.48822885751724243,
0.4036337435245514,
-0.6965776085853577,
-0.8825995326042175,
0.6095077991485596,
-0.04313710704445839,
-0.06108247488737106,
0.385786771774292,
0.2860428988933563,
-0.18531830608844757,
1.1902740001678467,
0.6057144403457642,
0.051144637167453766,
0.0052827210165560246,
0.003638428868725896,
0.07268296927213669,
-0.5202765464782715,
-0.24363009631633759,
-0.6209322810173035,
-0.17060905694961548,
-0.9388841986656189,
-0.06152122840285301,
0.4679248332977295,
0.39994606375694275,
-0.7246934771537781,
0.21475528180599213,
-0.3008687198162079,
0.7505306601524353,
0.34436145424842834,
0.03207845613360405,
0.5340494513511658,
-0.19641226530075073,
-0.07432252913713455,
-0.20538213849067688,
-0.5882657170295715,
-0.4518478512763977,
1.0198158025741577,
0.39115554094314575,
0.7117841243743896,
0.3830590844154358,
0.5542397499084473,
0.03293280303478241,
0.4900699555873871,
-0.5544086694717407,
0.4806894361972809,
-0.3131246864795685,
-0.701836109161377,
-0.3945015072822571,
-0.541526198387146,
-0.8685259222984314,
0.03825397044420242,
-0.02538347616791725,
-0.5748730897903442,
0.042938511818647385,
0.13760404288768768,
-0.12058660387992859,
0.053959380835294724,
-0.7910500764846802,
1.0894455909729004,
-0.30855220556259155,
-0.6106961369514465,
0.1877611130475998,
-0.4750087857246399,
0.46888843178749084,
-0.24196799099445343,
0.31939592957496643,
-0.45541781187057495,
0.02410094626247883,
0.42082276940345764,
-0.4492252767086029,
0.6274582147598267,
-0.09944469481706619,
-0.17447443306446075,
0.22630207240581512,
0.3734523057937622,
0.7110348343849182,
-0.031103292480111122,
-0.26770487427711487,
0.22352121770381927,
-0.019960517063736916,
-0.5155454277992249,
-0.8018990159034729,
0.8447681069374084,
-0.7244284749031067,
-0.8803295493125916,
-0.3408585786819458,
-0.5637823939323425,
-0.37388089299201965,
0.02700643055140972,
0.10271187126636505,
0.37705370783805847,
0.04038623347878456,
0.21102432906627655,
0.8189271688461304,
0.0646895095705986,
0.30492207407951355,
0.7395114898681641,
0.030574718490242958,
-0.07921472191810608,
0.7580497860908508,
0.4059869647026062,
0.32424214482307434,
0.01389504224061966,
0.2267400473356247,
-0.28288519382476807,
-0.6411232948303223,
-0.2573739290237427,
0.2312016636133194,
-0.8234954476356506,
-0.26647478342056274,
-0.30158695578575134,
-0.14180375635623932,
-0.08758575469255447,
0.12281087040901184,
-0.47566357254981995,
-0.0814475417137146,
0.20170104503631592,
0.13438130915164948,
0.17999204993247986,
0.8554747104644775,
-0.058039821684360504,
-0.05433624982833862,
-0.6167798042297363,
0.15739281475543976,
0.4538818299770355,
0.5904804468154907,
-0.010661732405424118,
-0.6673397421836853,
0.06810612976551056,
-0.0015547372167930007,
-0.3539011478424072,
-0.45490702986717224,
-0.08943958580493927,
0.09527533501386642,
0.2976590692996979,
0.10684973746538162,
-0.16760315001010895,
0.6241655945777893,
-0.7050585746765137,
0.49702829122543335,
0.1780175119638443,
-1.073965311050415,
0.18493029475212097,
-0.48812445998191833,
0.4288281798362732,
0.7756535410881042,
0.3809254765510559,
-0.5594648718833923,
-0.47550302743911743,
-0.5804519057273865,
-0.7387898564338684,
0.3807116150856018,
-0.0043282038532197475,
0.2071453183889389,
-0.23253928124904633,
0.6609559059143066,
0.2470230758190155,
0.09088172018527985,
-0.7530280351638794,
-0.10302182286977768,
0.07959886640310287,
-0.507001519203186,
-0.22564998269081116,
-0.27067291736602783,
0.04259617254137993,
-0.1609201729297638,
0.5065640807151794,
-0.06901159137487411,
-0.10443343222141266,
0.0025147933047264814,
0.11138328909873962,
-0.2865667939186096,
0.32817625999450684,
0.6540592908859253,
0.9486873745918274,
-0.3475862443447113,
0.3437502384185791,
0.22106227278709412,
-0.29065388441085815,
0.44405442476272583,
0.042774979025125504,
0.05827541649341583,
-0.14272785186767578,
0.4217107594013214,
0.32029610872268677,
0.26584377884864807,
-0.7743495106697083,
0.6630350351333618,
-0.04171428829431534,
-0.20894579589366913,
-0.23915427923202515,
0.2869914174079895,
0.28693991899490356,
0.3440712094306946,
0.4606110453605652,
-0.1387336403131485,
-0.24132142961025238,
-0.8597310781478882,
0.17679069936275482,
0.5128740072250366,
-0.30158206820487976,
-0.14470699429512024,
0.5339044332504272,
-0.05910186097025871,
-0.49788951873779297,
0.7311432361602783,
-0.300337553024292,
-0.41927510499954224,
0.7700494527816772,
0.4465456008911133,
0.3845280110836029,
-0.4631907045841217,
-0.11462348699569702,
0.18889233469963074,
0.43468940258026123,
-0.6369754672050476,
0.49463963508605957,
0.27173781394958496,
-0.6898902654647827,
-0.4944436550140381,
-0.4884219467639923,
-0.751366138458252,
0.5038684606552124,
-0.32668647170066833,
0.30439862608909607,
-0.5844641923904419,
0.053348392248153687,
0.09498990327119827,
0.2590796947479248,
-0.7949895858764648,
0.47154319286346436,
-0.16387788951396942,
0.7454059720039368,
-0.7078099846839905,
0.8641694784164429,
0.42768290638923645,
-0.3585115969181061,
-1.1701067686080933,
-0.11819010972976685,
-0.06011518836021423,
-0.6722316741943359,
0.6187364459037781,
0.18650788068771362,
0.04041982442140579,
-0.034780725836753845,
-0.7449509501457214,
-0.9251236319541931,
0.8054937124252319,
0.6565451622009277,
-1.0878479480743408,
0.20571498572826385,
0.2505522668361664,
0.546018660068512,
-0.26237621903419495,
0.12776456773281097,
0.5926802754402161,
0.5862637758255005,
-0.12795370817184448,
-1.148445725440979,
0.23494718968868256,
-0.1954142451286316,
-0.2849564254283905,
0.3365543782711029,
-0.6838278770446777,
1.123581051826477,
-0.18445374071598053,
0.023389510810375214,
0.1782228797674179,
0.42726731300354004,
0.44802945852279663,
0.46276596188545227,
0.45178186893463135,
0.7071930170059204,
0.9018017053604126,
-0.48188653588294983,
1.0192877054214478,
-0.261816143989563,
0.5265792012214661,
1.3089714050292969,
-0.49350273609161377,
0.991818368434906,
0.3511979579925537,
-0.2925359606742859,
0.2806502878665924,
0.5436232089996338,
0.07027182728052139,
0.35962000489234924,
0.4312232732772827,
-0.19322878122329712,
-0.44868457317352295,
0.09228961914777756,
-0.3812848925590515,
0.54353266954422,
0.17934800684452057,
0.047964878380298615,
-0.1666654348373413,
-0.17527328431606293,
0.04723390191793442,
0.18637987971305847,
-0.24824854731559753,
0.5114267468452454,
0.23523788154125214,
-0.7869846224784851,
0.8682231903076172,
0.1522594839334488,
0.38576123118400574,
-0.6572282314300537,
-0.15085649490356445,
-0.4860243499279022,
0.33564165234565735,
-0.12813644111156464,
-0.9900975227355957,
0.17296670377254486,
-0.061876632273197174,
-0.3665024936199188,
0.12062880396842957,
0.3922540545463562,
-0.5801449418067932,
-0.3827246427536011,
0.07653967291116714,
0.7704616785049438,
0.2494068443775177,
0.030064281076192856,
-0.7632266879081726,
0.5095596313476562,
-0.2594031095504761,
-0.12303566932678223,
0.28391358256340027,
0.6664727926254272,
-0.07059389352798462,
0.6945197582244873,
0.3938400447368622,
-0.02348090335726738,
-0.14830012619495392,
-0.05761472135782242,
0.5548877716064453,
-0.6573394536972046,
-0.07342910766601562,
-0.9418319463729858,
0.31843045353889465,
-0.024435730651021004,
-0.3443421721458435,
0.6709159016609192,
0.47475600242614746,
0.7828869819641113,
0.2550646960735321,
0.5960456132888794,
0.138440802693367,
0.5505744814872742,
-0.437211275100708,
0.33765649795532227,
-0.5958603024482727,
0.43971431255340576,
-0.220048725605011,
-1.178849220275879,
-0.3538559377193451,
0.3649236261844635,
-0.4577767252922058,
0.12541604042053223,
0.7688800692558289,
0.6883988380432129,
-0.19051682949066162,
-0.1324540376663208,
0.2858189642429352,
0.3456495702266693,
0.3180427551269531,
0.9099010825157166,
0.7565539479255676,
-0.45027557015419006,
0.5308756828308105,
-0.024901196360588074,
-0.12425278127193451,
-0.09963066130876541,
-0.9788240790367126,
-0.3502582013607025,
-0.4243958294391632,
-0.5270047187805176,
-0.6309176683425903,
0.3500068485736847,
0.8708597421646118,
0.3237624764442444,
-0.7650190591812134,
-0.2955142557621002,
-0.403083860874176,
0.30775418877601624,
-0.14092135429382324,
-0.17382219433784485,
0.44705384969711304,
-0.4687071144580841,
-0.6997959017753601,
0.2416599988937378,
0.2116069346666336,
0.06773506104946136,
-0.11579020321369171,
-0.11098331212997437,
0.024749791249632835,
0.1992969512939453,
0.16637718677520752,
0.3899232745170593,
-0.5866418480873108,
-0.6596333980560303,
-0.13738073408603668,
-0.5258467793464661,
0.1397717297077179,
0.6344415545463562,
-0.3825358748435974,
0.3055291175842285,
0.30465155839920044,
0.629406213760376,
0.29126250743865967,
0.05410129949450493,
0.28375744819641113,
-0.5363566875457764,
-0.14886324107646942,
-0.0000914317715796642,
0.5178283452987671,
0.6410388350486755,
0.03360447287559509,
0.47033053636550903,
0.19909892976284027,
-0.6992380023002625,
-0.8536438345909119,
0.29144465923309326,
-0.831041157245636,
-0.2904660701751709,
1.0813748836517334,
-0.3586697280406952,
-0.19256363809108734,
-0.2535480856895447,
0.12976038455963135,
-0.015416397713124752,
-0.013526392169296741,
0.987567663192749,
1.0472334623336792,
-0.18868739902973175,
-0.06537692248821259,
-0.7517650127410889,
0.5824360251426697,
0.7355077862739563,
-0.6319729089736938,
0.18454191088676453,
0.37305188179016113,
0.751662015914917,
0.14023339748382568,
0.6683197617530823,
-0.022572366520762444,
0.277138888835907,
-0.12059060484170914,
-0.3128257691860199,
0.08221415430307388,
-0.3066994845867157,
-0.39160871505737305,
0.5176742076873779,
0.3247129023075104,
0.29118993878364563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12793v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12793v1 | ChatGLM: A Family of Large Language Models from GLM-130B to GLM-4 All Tools | 2024-06-18T16:58:21 | 2024-06-18T16:58:21 | Team GLM, :, Aohan Zeng, Bin Xu, Bowen Wang, Chenhui Zhang, Da Yin, Diego Rojas, Guanyu Feng, Hanlin Zhao, Hanyu Lai, Hao Yu, Hongning Wang, Jiadai Sun, Jiajie Zhang, Jiale Cheng, Jiayi Gui, Jie Tang, Jing Zhang, Juanzi Li, Lei Zhao, Lindong Wu, Lucen Zhong, Mingdao Liu, Minlie Huang, Peng Zhang, Qinkai Zheng, Rui Lu, Shuaiqi Duan, Shudan Zhang, Shulin Cao, Shuxun Yang, Weng Lam Tam, Wenyi Zhao, Xiao Liu, Xiao Xia, Xiaohan Zhang, Xiaotao Gu, Xin Lv, Xinghan Liu, Xinyi Liu, Xinyue Yang, Xixuan Song, Xunkai Zhang, Yifan An, Yifan Xu, Yilin Niu, Yuantao Yang, Yueyan Li, Yushi Bai, Yuxiao Dong, Zehan Qi, Zhaoyu Wang, Zhen Yang, Zhengxiao Du, Zhenyu Hou, Zihan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce ChatGLM, an evolving family of large language models that we
have been developing over time. This report primarily focuses on the GLM-4
language series, which includes GLM-4, GLM-4-Air, and GLM-4-9B. They represent
our most capable models that are trained with all the insights and lessons
gained from the preceding three generations of ChatGLM. To date, the GLM-4
models are pre-trained on ten trillions of tokens mostly in Chinese and
English, along with a small set of corpus from 24 languages, and aligned
primarily for Chinese and English usage. The high-quality alignment is achieved
via a multi-stage post-training process, which involves supervised fine-tuning
and learning from human feedback. Evaluations show that GLM-4 1) closely rivals
or outperforms GPT-4 in terms of general metrics such as MMLU, GSM8K, MATH,
BBH, GPQA, and HumanEval, 2) gets close to GPT-4-Turbo in instruction following
as measured by IFEval, 3) matches GPT-4 Turbo (128K) and Claude 3 for long
context tasks, and 4) outperforms GPT-4 in Chinese alignments as measured by
AlignBench. The GLM-4 All Tools model is further aligned to understand user
intent and autonomously decide when and which tool(s) touse -- including web
browser, Python interpreter, text-to-image model, and user-defined functions --
to effectively complete complex tasks. In practical applications, it matches
and even surpasses GPT-4 All Tools in tasks like accessing online information
via web browsing and solving math problems using Python interpreter. Over the
course, we have open-sourced a series of models, including ChatGLM-6B (three
generations), GLM-4-9B (128K, 1M), GLM-4V-9B, WebGLM, and CodeGeeX, attracting
over 10 million downloads on Hugging face in the year 2023 alone. The open
models can be accessed through https://github.com/THUDM and
https://huggingface.co/THUDM. | [
-0.2519460916519165,
-0.6652829647064209,
0.4075678884983063,
0.2101273536682129,
0.16564185917377472,
0.3329315185546875,
-0.20955932140350342,
-0.7486204504966736,
-0.37207403779029846,
0.4705880582332611,
-0.3880743980407715,
-0.5024772882461548,
-0.4682001769542694,
-0.08553247898817062,
-0.3731306195259094,
0.971522331237793,
0.06509320437908173,
0.17293313145637512,
-0.15730339288711548,
-0.1183219775557518,
-0.3250846266746521,
-0.8531107902526855,
-0.5376881957054138,
-0.38922831416130066,
0.5820879936218262,
0.026080884039402008,
0.9483550786972046,
0.45828959345817566,
0.6628315448760986,
0.2872162163257599,
-0.08257126808166504,
-0.043343931436538696,
-0.621380627155304,
-0.21970300376415253,
-0.01031270157545805,
-0.31820979714393616,
-0.7364058494567871,
0.1859656125307083,
0.5229527354240417,
0.6215269565582275,
-0.30027276277542114,
0.13983425498008728,
-0.048045702278614044,
0.5060967803001404,
-0.2999234199523926,
0.19937148690223694,
-0.7131924033164978,
-0.1347266435623169,
-0.2602488398551941,
0.12750305235385895,
-0.4487784206867218,
-0.4260607957839966,
0.14634406566619873,
-0.5516274571418762,
0.14550670981407166,
0.20005013048648834,
1.0735286474227905,
-0.09119337052106857,
-0.3705919682979584,
-0.38732606172561646,
-0.6214112043380737,
0.9053281545639038,
-0.8948536515235901,
0.5487450361251831,
0.25135183334350586,
0.4347951412200928,
-0.3721265196800232,
-0.8942591547966003,
-0.2099137157201767,
-0.17929543554782867,
0.15029573440551758,
0.27912524342536926,
-0.18224655091762543,
0.15436041355133057,
0.304092139005661,
0.4801173806190491,
-0.7748873233795166,
0.10264208167791367,
-0.5931925177574158,
-0.30192673206329346,
0.5596159100532532,
0.24522678554058075,
0.49507543444633484,
0.19379909336566925,
-0.41378888487815857,
0.1953924298286438,
-0.925775408744812,
-0.09518822282552719,
0.4538111984729767,
0.1933964341878891,
-0.27071958780288696,
0.33194372057914734,
0.08969463407993317,
0.8916813731193542,
-0.2710115611553192,
-0.20747864246368408,
0.27449119091033936,
-0.6005294322967529,
-0.23471839725971222,
-0.32352128624916077,
0.8900673985481262,
0.29997923970222473,
0.2298247516155243,
-0.1392020285129547,
-0.26043349504470825,
-0.09687840938568115,
0.12371491640806198,
-0.902778685092926,
-0.2947289049625397,
0.0657297745347023,
-0.47130703926086426,
-0.2418169528245926,
-0.11986665427684784,
-0.49655625224113464,
-0.19055397808551788,
-0.3440215587615967,
0.5153284072875977,
-0.5096054673194885,
-0.2535690665245056,
0.249259814620018,
0.09050257503986359,
0.6072759628295898,
0.6141080260276794,
-1.044526219367981,
0.39413323998451233,
0.7477399706840515,
0.9954079389572144,
-0.2723016142845154,
-0.28838616609573364,
-0.5678508281707764,
0.00981083232909441,
-0.49935609102249146,
0.530411958694458,
-0.6342966556549072,
-0.33156445622444153,
0.2395382821559906,
0.03501873090863228,
-0.05769941210746765,
-0.49722912907600403,
0.32006365060806274,
-0.474700003862381,
0.6800172924995422,
-0.13743993639945984,
-0.6763575673103333,
-0.49382102489471436,
0.3786086440086365,
-0.6262624263763428,
1.0742543935775757,
0.2832728326320648,
-0.6033793091773987,
0.02757173217833042,
-0.6973620057106018,
-0.0419497936964035,
0.21767674386501312,
-0.007994599640369415,
-0.3611435294151306,
0.036703918129205704,
0.06478928029537201,
0.29494693875312805,
-0.5282326340675354,
0.23637868463993073,
-0.582536518573761,
-0.36440929770469666,
-0.19471780955791473,
-0.171408548951149,
0.8975457549095154,
0.21792559325695038,
-0.12302897870540619,
0.5476142764091492,
-0.2209140658378601,
0.08633997291326523,
0.23442614078521729,
-0.24616225063800812,
0.09389328956604004,
-0.15660317242145538,
0.11690594255924225,
0.5773252844810486,
0.4623470604419708,
-0.39168834686279297,
0.18977071344852448,
-0.45846179127693176,
0.7339372634887695,
0.6238167881965637,
-0.30445873737335205,
0.3293183147907257,
-0.2068769633769989,
0.7422741055488586,
0.028057267889380455,
0.46056416630744934,
-0.4178546071052551,
-0.7544006109237671,
-0.5590167045593262,
-0.04857153445482254,
0.269488662481308,
0.43877795338630676,
-0.47006651759147644,
0.1914115995168686,
-0.14048321545124054,
-0.5682682991027832,
-0.3545399010181427,
0.22065168619155884,
0.1773400604724884,
0.281819224357605,
0.2222539186477661,
-0.21919941902160645,
-0.26699450612068176,
-0.7884218096733093,
-0.14602380990982056,
-0.31765711307525635,
-0.08828455209732056,
0.13592399656772614,
0.26568111777305603,
-0.38515785336494446,
0.8068063855171204,
-0.29393118619918823,
-0.10467661917209625,
-0.3742392957210541,
-0.0479905791580677,
0.186066135764122,
0.14511938393115997,
0.7507266998291016,
-0.6813698410987854,
-0.5637856721878052,
0.27708205580711365,
-0.6968690752983093,
0.05332397669553757,
0.19235001504421234,
-0.25138455629348755,
0.41894152760505676,
0.42877209186553955,
-0.5672893524169922,
0.06563559174537659,
0.900733470916748,
-0.23370268940925598,
0.6333543658256531,
-0.1378358006477356,
-0.1879558563232422,
-1.0879034996032715,
0.1683681458234787,
-0.0991412103176117,
-0.4272301197052002,
-0.7889972925186157,
0.05660393089056015,
0.22098617255687714,
-0.2287326455116272,
-0.5672056674957275,
0.8172738552093506,
-0.6776462197303772,
-0.19747546315193176,
-0.11400458216667175,
0.2666788697242737,
-0.0653187558054924,
0.5344642996788025,
-0.1635391265153885,
0.6474007964134216,
0.7137192487716675,
-0.19755375385284424,
0.5111321806907654,
0.10134927928447723,
-0.19130556285381317,
0.03818487375974655,
-0.6013287305831909,
0.3307451605796814,
0.13534881174564362,
0.16818852722644806,
-0.7668843865394592,
-0.24747736752033234,
0.23093824088573456,
-0.38886117935180664,
0.20894171297550201,
-0.04298054054379463,
-0.4310329854488373,
-0.5754654407501221,
-0.3355522155761719,
0.1295977234840393,
0.76273113489151,
-0.5144582390785217,
0.7525742053985596,
0.39596232771873474,
-0.3237892687320709,
-0.4774034321308136,
-0.17309845983982086,
0.257269024848938,
-0.3115176260471344,
-0.8343656063079834,
0.21446779370307922,
-0.2533226013183594,
-0.11162763088941574,
0.04913001507520676,
0.004008101765066385,
-0.008028954267501831,
0.15737348794937134,
0.23768258094787598,
0.7171342372894287,
-0.25072893500328064,
0.004992092493921518,
-0.5625545978546143,
0.0919223204255104,
-0.09652320295572281,
-0.336993545293808,
0.7309983372688293,
-0.5549062490463257,
-0.39365458488464355,
0.0674145445227623,
0.057566165924072266,
0.42306530475616455,
-0.42233821749687195,
0.5289474725723267,
0.8539658188819885,
-0.42407292127609253,
0.17449180781841278,
-0.5935282707214355,
-0.02938576228916645,
-0.49050799012184143,
0.3729182481765747,
-0.22679488360881805,
-1.213688611984253,
0.6852148771286011,
0.07855682820081711,
0.5309131741523743,
0.231220081448555,
0.9035115838050842,
0.32276609539985657,
1.2638473510742188,
0.6549544930458069,
-0.4708019196987152,
0.5415304899215698,
0.07115328311920166,
0.1813344806432724,
-0.5724987983703613,
-0.032210808247327805,
-0.29326164722442627,
-0.08843140304088593,
-0.5986288785934448,
-0.41234368085861206,
0.10321395099163055,
0.17582984268665314,
-0.28168874979019165,
0.1406773328781128,
-0.37409958243370056,
0.37979936599731445,
0.5013675093650818,
-0.3100090026855469,
0.15576744079589844,
-0.19561581313610077,
0.1378483772277832,
0.2706376910209656,
-0.5968195199966431,
-0.5181212425231934,
1.1637128591537476,
0.538016676902771,
0.7680276036262512,
0.14325258135795593,
0.4688989222049713,
-0.11766573786735535,
0.5668447017669678,
-0.8052269220352173,
0.39714115858078003,
-0.13146869838237762,
-0.7022972702980042,
-0.1785215437412262,
-0.4164642095565796,
-1.0424963235855103,
0.27699050307273865,
0.15436503291130066,
-0.674288809299469,
-0.478687584400177,
0.2055853009223938,
-0.2819662094116211,
0.2744833827018738,
-0.6980222463607788,
1.0722726583480835,
-0.38671180605888367,
-0.3327420651912689,
-0.10296688973903656,
-0.7835496664047241,
0.6814387440681458,
-0.2881627678871155,
0.20017306506633759,
-0.5008897185325623,
0.08765796571969986,
0.45182332396507263,
-0.15331749618053436,
0.512754499912262,
-0.1485241800546646,
-0.2543172836303711,
0.3105081021785736,
-0.13156193494796753,
0.3468016982078552,
-0.2817705571651459,
-0.07893291115760803,
0.5281374454498291,
-0.01567358337342739,
-0.4391750395298004,
-0.5055336952209473,
0.7087503671646118,
-0.8729242086410522,
-0.664211630821228,
-0.41783592104911804,
-0.5674012303352356,
-0.19048786163330078,
0.40741685032844543,
0.14303477108478546,
0.6524447798728943,
-0.3262723386287689,
0.21537096798419952,
0.22436538338661194,
-0.38599029183387756,
0.45147448778152466,
0.4452136158943176,
-0.9273684620857239,
-0.25239506363868713,
0.9021846652030945,
0.027290314435958862,
0.5791155695915222,
0.11701790243387222,
0.1740378737449646,
-0.4264136254787445,
-0.5028305053710938,
-0.4516551196575165,
0.33668410778045654,
-0.5682523846626282,
-0.11634242534637451,
-0.5148173570632935,
-0.5300451517105103,
-0.4667544662952423,
-0.04926889389753342,
-0.15386706590652466,
-0.09404865652322769,
0.01682254858314991,
0.17481368780136108,
0.2680419683456421,
0.9069234728813171,
0.15218497812747955,
0.30481281876564026,
-0.8833334445953369,
0.1676577776670456,
0.2323731631040573,
0.346172958612442,
-0.23514646291732788,
-0.3794633448123932,
-0.3678019642829895,
0.16990460455417633,
-0.5855374336242676,
-0.4912108778953552,
0.39513856172561646,
0.2910621464252472,
0.5012598633766174,
0.35332173109054565,
-0.38883423805236816,
0.5176311731338501,
-0.7898882031440735,
1.0486127138137817,
0.2982216477394104,
-0.9301401376724243,
0.1796341836452484,
-0.6956697702407837,
0.4154314696788788,
0.02484048157930374,
0.2790575623512268,
-0.912471354007721,
-0.5339502692222595,
-0.5709551572799683,
-0.5557219982147217,
0.9209606051445007,
0.20584620535373688,
0.23186485469341278,
0.12389186769723892,
0.20587830245494843,
0.07967672497034073,
0.17017534375190735,
-0.6117244362831116,
0.09282681345939636,
-0.27071821689605713,
-0.37139391899108887,
-0.11023247987031937,
-0.057325296103954315,
-0.018915563821792603,
-0.02475064992904663,
0.6535851359367371,
-0.31405138969421387,
0.17256253957748413,
-0.36188116669654846,
0.013476197607815266,
0.011167406104505062,
0.010996256023645401,
0.59437096118927,
0.8297454714775085,
-0.20212987065315247,
0.025955775752663612,
0.13126155734062195,
-0.6253796219825745,
0.01116985734552145,
0.05609844997525215,
0.1059756651520729,
-0.07473848760128021,
0.35493332147598267,
0.9977240562438965,
0.1877875179052353,
-0.673981249332428,
0.5677179098129272,
-0.10928541421890259,
-0.1898539662361145,
-0.3658808767795563,
0.12200559675693512,
0.5235832333564758,
-0.0034409440122544765,
0.058816198259592056,
-0.26648035645484924,
0.1056281253695488,
-0.5540011525154114,
0.049598708748817444,
0.5445042848587036,
-0.31463325023651123,
-0.7128884196281433,
0.7172880172729492,
0.2919591963291168,
-0.11545459926128387,
0.6508939862251282,
-0.17508794367313385,
-0.6520870923995972,
0.3906477391719818,
0.5739251971244812,
0.755359947681427,
-0.4962310492992401,
0.14075376093387604,
0.3367024064064026,
0.249349907040596,
-0.3944756090641022,
0.21745026111602783,
0.44925135374069214,
-0.8059874176979065,
-0.4539010524749756,
-0.6362928152084351,
-0.6903270483016968,
0.2934533357620239,
-0.48593437671661377,
0.6685338020324707,
-0.41356587409973145,
-0.06607721745967865,
-0.08208468556404114,
0.05673089995980263,
-0.8073384165763855,
-0.010490607470273972,
0.33099842071533203,
0.8617760539054871,
-0.47301748394966125,
0.9670000076293945,
0.7424959540367126,
-0.2737964689731598,
-0.8622066378593445,
-0.1883372813463211,
0.45951277017593384,
-0.9896990656852722,
0.47236865758895874,
0.43018272519111633,
-0.0431746244430542,
0.2509593963623047,
-0.7077888250350952,
-0.9813430905342102,
1.0190898180007935,
0.36435773968696594,
-0.5685439705848694,
-0.34080249071121216,
-0.06056907773017883,
0.3979473412036896,
-0.2445068061351776,
0.3810439109802246,
0.5141995549201965,
0.2701329290866852,
0.16538512706756592,
-1.1187694072723389,
-0.17921961843967438,
-0.2862186133861542,
0.056530892848968506,
0.4368944764137268,
-0.7511342763900757,
0.9155870079994202,
-0.08521004021167755,
-0.2545105516910553,
0.17246179282665253,
0.40915027260780334,
0.23719075322151184,
0.03493772819638252,
0.4286477863788605,
0.25003519654273987,
0.6751678586006165,
-0.2681511640548706,
0.8587475419044495,
-0.4913160502910614,
0.3633742332458496,
0.9526606798171997,
-0.5303916335105896,
0.6704382300376892,
0.07040436565876007,
-0.20712755620479584,
0.3590088486671448,
0.8058354258537292,
-0.12656353414058685,
0.21241484582424164,
0.16532133519649506,
-0.18508896231651306,
-0.2539619207382202,
0.044888269156217575,
-0.34906259179115295,
0.35892483592033386,
0.4635290205478668,
0.10544972121715546,
-0.3630225658416748,
-0.062282975763082504,
0.1686755269765854,
-0.3689645528793335,
-0.23787765204906464,
0.7035999298095703,
0.23482520878314972,
-0.5776767134666443,
0.6406201124191284,
-0.04636324569582939,
0.649475634098053,
-0.8963481783866882,
0.22755828499794006,
-0.24783095717430115,
0.1472276896238327,
-0.04944271221756935,
-0.8263559937477112,
0.12760421633720398,
-0.09055512398481369,
0.17089252173900604,
-0.11733053624629974,
0.833431601524353,
-0.6164595484733582,
-0.43138256669044495,
0.4412258565425873,
0.5197538733482361,
0.2725445032119751,
-0.0608154758810997,
-0.7475292682647705,
0.30426228046417236,
0.07664773613214493,
-0.3283689320087433,
0.4020743668079376,
0.4640500545501709,
-0.18956002593040466,
0.7317438721656799,
0.6440383791923523,
0.09292257577180862,
0.24366407096385956,
0.2089235484600067,
0.7387235164642334,
-0.7826499342918396,
-0.2740944027900696,
-0.8024724125862122,
0.34354138374328613,
-0.14024290442466736,
-0.2453341782093048,
0.8356260061264038,
0.6326057314872742,
0.7337517738342285,
0.09490837156772614,
0.897028386592865,
0.11697078496217728,
0.38983431458473206,
-0.3597618341445923,
0.5052814483642578,
-0.5872716307640076,
-0.19270676374435425,
-0.20821093022823334,
-1.1669089794158936,
-0.39097437262535095,
0.31392529606819153,
-0.3137911558151245,
0.18846964836120605,
0.37839314341545105,
0.63385009765625,
0.07607366889715195,
0.19675789773464203,
0.49711427092552185,
0.07241841405630112,
0.808019757270813,
0.7119455337524414,
0.9398522973060608,
-0.12662973999977112,
0.6180762648582458,
0.050655823200941086,
-0.2746889591217041,
-0.3894146978855133,
-0.7687497735023499,
-0.9485787153244019,
-0.4274258613586426,
-0.15745416283607483,
0.007290706504136324,
-0.16899360716342926,
0.783639132976532,
0.7624555826187134,
-0.6268549561500549,
-0.32774320244789124,
0.14785335958003998,
-0.1135842576622963,
-0.013958480209112167,
-0.16803935170173645,
0.11059321463108063,
-0.6523618102073669,
-0.802863359451294,
0.28603753447532654,
0.534905731678009,
0.07565415650606155,
-0.44976314902305603,
-0.27840709686279297,
0.03394125774502754,
0.025251047685742378,
0.8076108694076538,
0.14796721935272217,
-0.9583469033241272,
-0.4944361448287964,
0.34753748774528503,
-0.2657648026943207,
0.13740664720535278,
0.5275649428367615,
-0.3742433786392212,
0.4526864290237427,
0.3872750401496887,
0.5552364587783813,
0.4240741729736328,
0.09018279612064362,
0.8082007765769958,
-0.41457509994506836,
0.06240974739193916,
0.07189223170280457,
0.528058648109436,
0.5656237006187439,
0.00031776505056768656,
0.7774180173873901,
-0.017427170649170876,
-0.9093046188354492,
-0.8508006930351257,
0.18466617166996002,
-0.9047303199768066,
-0.15816155076026917,
1.1244311332702637,
-0.19183039665222168,
0.029082514345645905,
-0.08721815794706345,
-0.36895325779914856,
0.05188621208071709,
-0.22205761075019836,
0.5971677303314209,
1.0691148042678833,
-0.2202659249305725,
-0.1762797087430954,
-0.8622826337814331,
0.5133342742919922,
0.20246312022209167,
-1.0579369068145752,
0.1742391586303711,
0.6349713802337646,
0.28424662351608276,
0.13971112668514252,
0.5802836418151855,
-0.3921442925930023,
0.18356037139892578,
-0.2492358535528183,
0.4003722369670868,
0.06400571018457413,
-0.1425325572490692,
-0.310001939535141,
-0.04922341927886009,
0.2869440019130707,
-0.02382177673280239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12787v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12787v1 | Generating Educational Materials with Different Levels of Readability using LLMs | 2024-06-18T16:55:10 | 2024-06-18T16:55:10 | Chieh-Yang Huang, Jing Wei, Ting-Hao 'Kenneth' Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | This study introduces the leveled-text generation task, aiming to rewrite
educational materials to specific readability levels while preserving meaning.
We assess the capability of GPT-3.5, LLaMA-2 70B, and Mixtral 8x7B, to generate
content at various readability levels through zero-shot and few-shot prompting.
Evaluating 100 processed educational materials reveals that few-shot prompting
significantly improves performance in readability manipulation and information
preservation. LLaMA-2 70B performs better in achieving the desired difficulty
range, while GPT-3.5 maintains original meaning. However, manual inspection
highlights concerns such as misinformation introduction and inconsistent edit
distribution. These findings emphasize the need for further research to ensure
the quality of generated educational content. | [
-0.2429308146238327,
-0.8908251523971558,
0.5340453386306763,
-0.07394744455814362,
-0.38510650396347046,
0.2339547872543335,
0.03302140161395073,
-0.4709135591983795,
-0.19335351884365082,
0.20313765108585358,
-0.6151807308197021,
-0.7405675649642944,
-0.6929391622543335,
0.38382744789123535,
-0.6103787422180176,
1.2116352319717407,
-0.33410924673080444,
-0.33618730306625366,
-0.007714118342846632,
0.2405310422182083,
-0.5494094491004944,
-0.2093999683856964,
-0.7570914030075073,
-0.41410622000694275,
0.8363300561904907,
0.8127073645591736,
0.5918853282928467,
0.9217669367790222,
0.519546389579773,
0.17824548482894897,
-0.3777698278427124,
0.11217695474624634,
-0.6099665760993958,
0.43263185024261475,
-0.1700097918510437,
-0.5340914726257324,
-0.6827740669250488,
-0.11629720777273178,
0.8275347948074341,
0.3424939215183258,
-0.04035625979304314,
0.2524411678314209,
0.47456514835357666,
0.6226348280906677,
-0.5704898834228516,
-0.1478852480649948,
-0.4578705430030823,
0.29956403374671936,
-0.3644771873950958,
-0.49381697177886963,
-0.46040770411491394,
-0.10867530107498169,
-0.015703586861491203,
-0.9137284159660339,
0.4555363357067108,
0.027924736961722374,
0.6630989909172058,
0.16660372912883759,
-0.11854280531406403,
-0.5983365178108215,
-0.5300279855728149,
0.8103887438774109,
-0.6991292834281921,
0.20752055943012238,
0.5200885534286499,
0.07605191320180893,
-0.11715270578861237,
-0.5974240303039551,
-0.7604928016662598,
0.14583836495876312,
0.18932783603668213,
0.40561866760253906,
-0.07359156012535095,
-0.09637843817472458,
0.3918764591217041,
0.4156895577907562,
-0.573350191116333,
0.20691326260566711,
-0.6632714867591858,
-0.09456708282232285,
0.3859688937664032,
0.4593479037284851,
0.43339258432388306,
-0.5766482353210449,
-0.23802344501018524,
-0.22864675521850586,
-0.9360566139221191,
-0.027850888669490814,
0.5908812284469604,
0.1812383532524109,
0.08431106805801392,
1.0746724605560303,
-0.3030377924442291,
0.393685519695282,
0.06568808108568192,
-0.7419818043708801,
0.19282427430152893,
-0.5961748957633972,
-0.26594242453575134,
0.0060393353924155235,
0.3374389708042145,
0.36703816056251526,
0.06480730324983597,
0.253872811794281,
-0.42821353673934937,
-0.22824643552303314,
0.2417091429233551,
-0.7939804792404175,
-0.03807341307401657,
0.171117901802063,
-0.5234866142272949,
-0.36402496695518494,
-0.17480695247650146,
-0.6145466566085815,
-0.42753005027770996,
-0.4996093213558197,
0.5668599009513855,
-0.6441753506660461,
-0.09102118015289307,
0.14392481744289398,
-0.1516558676958084,
0.22395102679729462,
0.7242821455001831,
-1.0373685359954834,
-0.12319484353065491,
0.48143696784973145,
0.8918535113334656,
-0.43792176246643066,
-0.1706870049238205,
-0.1663312315940857,
0.4898095726966858,
-0.21453163027763367,
0.8859483003616333,
-0.4178907871246338,
-0.6402904391288757,
0.03818010166287422,
-0.2479485124349594,
0.142218217253685,
-0.6525954008102417,
0.43361136317253113,
-0.25279903411865234,
0.2727777361869812,
-0.15555672347545624,
-0.4920550286769867,
-0.03664019703865051,
0.419981449842453,
-0.49198487401008606,
1.1920697689056396,
0.406241774559021,
-0.75554358959198,
0.6895440220832825,
-0.14855870604515076,
-0.45446667075157166,
0.1817990243434906,
-0.041792530566453934,
-0.3144771158695221,
-0.008781719952821732,
0.2180245965719223,
0.40107423067092896,
-0.00007522088708356023,
-0.1776648461818695,
0.33860933780670166,
-0.5936917662620544,
-0.16783249378204346,
-0.6485117673873901,
0.3124036192893982,
0.13261115550994873,
-0.4210640490055084,
-0.10056571662425995,
-0.8708943128585815,
-0.060724224895238876,
0.020598113536834717,
-0.964525043964386,
0.06388000398874283,
-0.02199704945087433,
-0.130886971950531,
0.21487045288085938,
0.3661143183708191,
-0.4446157217025757,
0.21718762814998627,
-0.09885590523481369,
0.004288242198526859,
0.8711870312690735,
0.254916250705719,
0.4835469722747803,
-0.6051993370056152,
0.8180522918701172,
0.3196731209754944,
-0.03594355285167694,
-0.39491018652915955,
-0.6480127573013306,
-1.0514196157455444,
-0.12402494996786118,
-0.2038671225309372,
0.7143030166625977,
-0.9394671320915222,
-0.058746837079524994,
0.21060310304164886,
-0.44943705201148987,
-0.4408169388771057,
0.628680408000946,
0.5270534157752991,
0.7135817408561707,
0.3386780321598053,
-0.13325300812721252,
-0.2068236917257309,
-0.6003674268722534,
-0.05964937061071396,
-0.08006831258535385,
-0.12126031517982483,
0.1773671656847,
0.39018094539642334,
-0.18844203650951385,
0.640794575214386,
-0.652755081653595,
-0.14892546832561493,
-0.24000728130340576,
0.22838249802589417,
0.2767077088356018,
0.4408905804157257,
0.35002627968788147,
-0.1459914594888687,
-0.6147515773773193,
-0.06492727994918823,
-0.7502850890159607,
-0.20071732997894287,
-0.190608412027359,
-0.2844478189945221,
0.15772727131843567,
0.09555675834417343,
-0.3264678418636322,
0.5074089169502258,
-0.00900888629257679,
-0.08752699941396713,
0.3096639811992645,
-0.16013433039188385,
0.38028043508529663,
-1.0878283977508545,
-0.3627912700176239,
0.044432226568460464,
-0.04389364272356033,
-0.5745598673820496,
-0.10637207329273224,
-0.09980825334787369,
-0.12767627835273743,
-0.7643758058547974,
0.37195706367492676,
-0.5017849802970886,
0.007869618013501167,
-0.3479333221912384,
0.7502423524856567,
0.2239915281534195,
0.13245509564876556,
-0.03647764027118683,
0.961157500743866,
0.28205642104148865,
-0.5243329405784607,
0.20358526706695557,
0.43250155448913574,
-0.29168763756752014,
1.0414025783538818,
-0.7808609008789062,
0.08146029710769653,
-0.5200318694114685,
0.11415160447359085,
-0.850005030632019,
-0.35074859857559204,
0.5743441581726074,
-0.2221308946609497,
0.4238714873790741,
0.3063318729400635,
-0.6179256439208984,
-0.14290699362754822,
-0.5070083737373352,
0.20368242263793945,
0.5631552934646606,
-0.3609161972999573,
0.12679727375507355,
-0.20937976241111755,
-0.5364289879798889,
-0.5944410562515259,
-0.6846824288368225,
-0.054645437747240067,
-0.12707377970218658,
-0.5888800621032715,
-0.020916642621159554,
-0.43155696988105774,
-0.056361787021160126,
-0.19442303478717804,
-0.31508123874664307,
0.13825109601020813,
-0.24778860807418823,
0.39090225100517273,
0.3827906548976898,
-0.4326759874820709,
-0.015036906115710735,
0.5550640821456909,
0.04642133414745331,
-0.2671302556991577,
0.09766576439142227,
0.2522575557231903,
0.16889192163944244,
-0.34580498933792114,
-0.37536513805389404,
0.3940120041370392,
-0.15949077904224396,
0.2212762087583542,
0.6435511708259583,
0.5296522378921509,
-0.35166022181510925,
-0.46721845865249634,
-0.21183711290359497,
-0.023051129654049873,
-0.500147819519043,
0.13478514552116394,
-0.473270058631897,
-0.8206764459609985,
0.30337053537368774,
0.2481200098991394,
0.2758719027042389,
0.4626212418079376,
0.6798086166381836,
-0.23922520875930786,
0.6742539405822754,
0.4807334244251251,
0.5283576846122742,
0.6632776856422424,
-0.2409994900226593,
0.03607114776968956,
-0.7588678002357483,
-0.5140311121940613,
-0.3968922793865204,
-0.5615931153297424,
-0.46836966276168823,
-0.5287029147148132,
0.23749083280563354,
0.2746453881263733,
-0.20823001861572266,
0.2159462869167328,
-0.795080304145813,
0.7291472554206848,
0.6375576853752136,
0.33314788341522217,
0.743332028388977,
0.2590217888355255,
0.0636444240808487,
-0.054196443408727646,
-0.5507424473762512,
-1.0026285648345947,
1.2298487424850464,
0.24785856902599335,
0.9565854668617249,
0.19269201159477234,
1.1689587831497192,
0.23943839967250824,
0.48889297246932983,
-0.8372601866722107,
0.6210087537765503,
-0.09503670781850815,
-0.7397239804267883,
-0.3705250322818756,
-0.23821383714675903,
-0.8842071294784546,
0.19686830043792725,
-0.3563757836818695,
-0.5853683948516846,
0.10994193702936172,
0.019740596413612366,
-0.060941677540540695,
0.3053748905658722,
-0.5416772365570068,
0.3290775716304779,
0.09822283685207367,
-0.21864232420921326,
0.05674290657043457,
-0.5517211556434631,
0.35490313172340393,
-0.4270569980144501,
-0.06392362713813782,
-0.2369263470172882,
-0.33565396070480347,
0.6418060064315796,
-0.027019722387194633,
0.8459693193435669,
0.18119964003562927,
-0.6498122811317444,
0.6612009406089783,
0.24018977582454681,
0.2227969467639923,
0.06700331717729568,
-0.23877198994159698,
-0.1432696133852005,
-0.017423411831259727,
-0.42773109674453735,
-0.3983517587184906,
0.5256575345993042,
-1.0545156002044678,
-0.7832563519477844,
-0.4611263871192932,
-0.8702203035354614,
0.14008191227912903,
0.4554932117462158,
0.5270175337791443,
0.3711293637752533,
0.03746585547924042,
0.2104283720254898,
0.7977218627929688,
-0.2609102427959442,
0.48228031396865845,
0.41867315769195557,
0.23433426022529602,
-0.33803388476371765,
1.0980494022369385,
0.381638765335083,
0.5531922578811646,
0.38309288024902344,
-0.0839264765381813,
-0.013988977298140526,
-0.7946900725364685,
-0.5262913703918457,
-0.06513725221157074,
-0.9832375049591064,
-0.2575109004974365,
-0.2275586575269699,
-0.3896804451942444,
-0.1344928741455078,
-0.5202379822731018,
0.21460282802581787,
-0.5324397087097168,
-0.8626590967178345,
-0.364041805267334,
0.03356458991765976,
1.3586580753326416,
-0.22153308987617493,
0.7410244345664978,
-0.7462030649185181,
0.5769316554069519,
0.12941862642765045,
0.24221321940422058,
-0.1302931308746338,
-0.7438658475875854,
-0.20005390048027039,
-0.008889906108379364,
-0.7147616744041443,
-0.8418411016464233,
0.04736359789967537,
0.24079254269599915,
0.46508052945137024,
0.3197225034236908,
-0.2019292116165161,
0.28378280997276306,
-0.49393150210380554,
0.9975357055664062,
0.18665462732315063,
-0.8798533082008362,
0.8338444232940674,
-0.5747727155685425,
0.35854634642601013,
0.4513261020183563,
0.4335603713989258,
-0.18789419531822205,
-0.716145396232605,
-0.5814087986946106,
-0.8621576428413391,
0.6990602016448975,
0.26543936133384705,
0.24507436156272888,
-0.08538215607404709,
0.45811304450035095,
0.4490857422351837,
0.2212599366903305,
-0.620241641998291,
-0.11308808624744415,
-0.5260519981384277,
-0.3539055585861206,
0.07686252146959305,
-0.5269112586975098,
-0.04442329332232475,
0.15852229297161102,
0.5968307256698608,
0.16152137517929077,
-0.2296949326992035,
0.061763059347867966,
-0.20788581669330597,
-0.2609597444534302,
0.6533679366111755,
0.7589616775512695,
0.8070265650749207,
-0.26935410499572754,
0.22628453373908997,
0.10889504849910736,
-1.0370432138442993,
0.5320160388946533,
-0.35683226585388184,
-0.5918072462081909,
-0.10808324813842773,
0.42958006262779236,
0.5431502461433411,
0.010672859847545624,
-0.4063456058502197,
0.18917380273342133,
0.21031293272972107,
-0.41863512992858887,
0.23421595990657806,
0.541519284248352,
-0.13028033077716827,
0.2899790406227112,
0.34901201725006104,
-0.4454786777496338,
-0.057658009231090546,
-0.40862777829170227,
0.2058529555797577,
-0.09425090253353119,
0.25575363636016846,
-0.02046787180006504,
0.760063111782074,
0.27609163522720337,
-0.23090818524360657,
0.7506479620933533,
-0.13428901135921478,
0.17899727821350098,
0.5219008922576904,
0.9905457496643066,
0.33867841958999634,
-0.07860986143350601,
0.6549797058105469,
0.48504412174224854,
0.5319066047668457,
-0.011050568893551826,
0.528563380241394,
-0.10423452407121658,
-0.7116515636444092,
-0.0789232924580574,
-0.587024450302124,
-0.8636754155158997,
-0.25402817130088806,
-0.625951886177063,
0.0767015814781189,
-0.7277815937995911,
-0.18657007813453674,
-0.18678514659404755,
0.0953747108578682,
-0.569581151008606,
0.6927786469459534,
-0.02123834937810898,
0.6300402879714966,
-0.771925151348114,
0.2489149421453476,
0.5762303471565247,
-0.7900829315185547,
-0.9502300024032593,
-0.12854896485805511,
0.010488869622349739,
-0.8093404173851013,
0.6020835638046265,
-0.0748925432562828,
-0.05196366459131241,
0.1370355784893036,
-0.45758575201034546,
-0.7184559106826782,
1.541932463645935,
0.2608032822608948,
-0.6308161616325378,
-0.23965147137641907,
0.4679369330406189,
0.4391668438911438,
-0.09097129851579666,
-0.04158013314008713,
0.5942493081092834,
0.41910985112190247,
0.37450507283210754,
-0.37424105405807495,
-0.0023726006038486958,
-0.19322001934051514,
-0.15650402009487152,
0.019121775403618813,
-0.39378443360328674,
0.8255884051322937,
-0.1455574929714203,
-0.35832810401916504,
0.09341882169246674,
0.7177964448928833,
0.7560834884643555,
0.47359639406204224,
0.14283515512943268,
0.6483440399169922,
0.8683149218559265,
-0.06775080412626266,
0.8657280802726746,
0.07160519063472748,
0.029504628852009773,
0.9462934136390686,
0.04666803777217865,
0.9591368436813354,
0.39372625946998596,
-0.09243668615818024,
0.474124550819397,
0.8521657586097717,
-0.13593022525310516,
0.23678523302078247,
0.23257887363433838,
-0.670961856842041,
0.06383199989795685,
-0.2341884821653366,
-0.5017727613449097,
0.1719450205564499,
0.23030921816825867,
-0.3165363669395447,
-0.11639764159917831,
-0.11411821097135544,
0.23493382334709167,
-0.1348433941602707,
-0.44401803612709045,
0.5816066861152649,
0.31165042519569397,
-0.40181437134742737,
0.4788297116756439,
-0.07869365066289902,
0.5917899012565613,
-0.24072764813899994,
-0.12330703437328339,
-0.40821579098701477,
-0.18709003925323486,
-0.6026197671890259,
-1.453696370124817,
0.05460136756300926,
0.3405120372772217,
-0.41697803139686584,
-0.42724835872650146,
0.9783807396888733,
-0.522720217704773,
-0.41544240713119507,
-0.21016518771648407,
0.705096423625946,
0.3896217346191406,
0.4875304400920868,
-0.36783748865127563,
0.04781405255198479,
-0.08905438333749771,
-0.6178439259529114,
0.3405682146549225,
0.7032332420349121,
0.20738232135772705,
0.42511361837387085,
0.6317439675331116,
0.26155248284339905,
0.32861465215682983,
0.24853134155273438,
0.6922636032104492,
-0.5315467715263367,
0.018719663843512535,
-0.5037561058998108,
0.6864334344863892,
0.24899928271770477,
-0.5791376829147339,
0.781879723072052,
0.47234517335891724,
0.810862123966217,
-0.16819894313812256,
0.6827883124351501,
0.15146340429782867,
0.252322256565094,
-0.5182799100875854,
0.619003176689148,
-0.554535448551178,
0.08879674971103668,
-0.4264390468597412,
-1.3513386249542236,
-0.2457694709300995,
0.5296817421913147,
-0.0586516410112381,
0.09377314150333405,
0.7869035005569458,
0.5906192064285278,
0.10397759079933167,
-0.21414965391159058,
0.40261614322662354,
-0.1050143614411354,
0.24884502589702606,
0.6304566860198975,
0.7968792915344238,
-0.2903701364994049,
0.6550378799438477,
-0.04007170721888542,
-0.19722400605678558,
0.045539092272520065,
-0.8588515520095825,
-1.0363155603408813,
-0.07265286147594452,
-0.24003678560256958,
-0.4628503918647766,
0.03364434465765953,
0.30635690689086914,
0.2631301283836365,
-0.39884844422340393,
0.015743788331747055,
0.09314431250095367,
0.2899281084537506,
0.32653000950813293,
-0.1979978382587433,
0.17765426635742188,
-0.2411344200372696,
-0.8582478761672974,
0.4534858465194702,
0.33789536356925964,
0.4783715307712555,
-0.25405049324035645,
0.0708269476890564,
0.17550542950630188,
0.3449418246746063,
0.7379630208015442,
0.19572822749614716,
-0.4243555963039398,
-0.36243975162506104,
0.07439320534467697,
-0.38413724303245544,
0.19283035397529602,
0.42733877897262573,
-0.3576982021331787,
0.39053013920783997,
0.8174315094947815,
0.5419939756393433,
0.4573497772216797,
0.11555658280849457,
0.3211972713470459,
-0.7835419178009033,
-0.015875425189733505,
0.03994372487068176,
0.15738806128501892,
0.4495820105075836,
-0.4656531512737274,
0.6586683988571167,
0.11901360750198364,
-0.6720484495162964,
-0.6679931879043579,
0.2002050131559372,
-1.0990846157073975,
0.18857908248901367,
1.1475049257278442,
-0.11953484266996384,
-0.03714527562260628,
0.16017654538154602,
-0.6166263818740845,
0.5299336910247803,
-0.2674528658390045,
0.4770762622356415,
0.9365354180335999,
-0.21051906049251556,
-0.34457024931907654,
-0.7503257989883423,
0.17576545476913452,
0.2380247563123703,
-1.1384941339492798,
-0.6169077157974243,
0.5255491733551025,
0.4099082946777344,
-0.06643185764551163,
0.6861194372177124,
-0.15401120483875275,
0.2589077949523926,
0.3452150821685791,
-0.2200019508600235,
-0.13466088473796844,
-0.4136483669281006,
-0.008602128364145756,
0.14898908138275146,
0.07792395353317261,
0.0468490831553936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12784v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12784v1 | UBENCH: Benchmarking Uncertainty in Large Language Models with Multiple Choice Questions | 2024-06-18T16:50:38 | 2024-06-18T16:50:38 | Xunzhi Wang, Zhuowei Zhang, Qiongyu Li, Gaonan Chen, Mengting Hu, Zhiyu li, Bitong Luo, Hang Gao, Zhixin Han, Haotian Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid development of large language models (LLMs) has shown promising
practical results. However, their low interpretability often leads to errors in
unforeseen circumstances, limiting their utility. Many works have focused on
creating comprehensive evaluation systems, but previous benchmarks have
primarily assessed problem-solving abilities while neglecting the response's
uncertainty, which may result in unreliability. Recent methods for measuring
LLM reliability are resource-intensive and unable to test black-box models. To
address this, we propose UBENCH, a comprehensive benchmark for evaluating LLM
reliability. UBENCH includes 3,978 multiple-choice questions covering
knowledge, language, understanding, and reasoning abilities. Experimental
results show that UBENCH has achieved state-of-the-art performance, while its
single-sampling method significantly saves computational resources compared to
baseline methods that require multiple samplings. Additionally, based on
UBENCH, we evaluate the reliability of 15 popular LLMs, finding GLM4 to be the
most outstanding, closely followed by GPT-4. We also explore the impact of
Chain-of-Thought prompts, role-playing prompts, option order, and temperature
on LLM reliability, analyzing the varying effects on different LLMs. | [
-0.3294139504432678,
-0.8575373888015747,
0.9105121493339539,
0.3319861590862274,
-0.1695576310157776,
0.170815572142601,
-0.4473416805267334,
-0.3459206223487854,
-0.2766634523868561,
0.3095332086086273,
-0.19995030760765076,
-0.17304037511348724,
-0.3782481551170349,
-0.057447053492069244,
-0.3335812985897064,
0.48853012919425964,
-0.12193858623504639,
0.3337317705154419,
-0.3806026577949524,
-0.23831458389759064,
-0.37987250089645386,
-0.5709913969039917,
-0.5778573155403137,
-0.4809913635253906,
0.3853840231895447,
0.2658444344997406,
0.8015353083610535,
0.3948138654232025,
0.4746743440628052,
0.32341355085372925,
-0.01680278591811657,
-0.21202759444713593,
-0.32263126969337463,
0.3111429512500763,
-0.3164280652999878,
-0.36921754479408264,
-0.29342156648635864,
-0.11115922778844833,
0.7739095687866211,
0.8130357265472412,
-0.46148881316185,
0.27498188614845276,
0.03438500687479973,
0.3537786900997162,
-0.7394835948944092,
0.06675194948911667,
-0.6504473090171814,
-0.16792984306812286,
-0.42918360233306885,
0.34794968366622925,
-0.3750867247581482,
-0.23585332930088043,
-0.21160508692264557,
-0.18064893782138824,
-0.15294988453388214,
0.27788248658180237,
0.4588544964790344,
0.22589318454265594,
-0.3134172856807709,
0.16022208333015442,
-0.7969722151756287,
0.9605405330657959,
-0.8627193570137024,
0.5737313032150269,
0.39090171456336975,
0.44195592403411865,
-0.5375784635543823,
-0.625617265701294,
-0.4721960127353668,
-0.4113903343677521,
0.2930814027786255,
0.14963845908641815,
-0.13153085112571716,
0.021115196868777275,
0.13834014534950256,
0.1979360431432724,
-0.5864801406860352,
0.23927366733551025,
-0.0843561589717865,
-0.3631318211555481,
0.45003920793533325,
0.14423677325248718,
0.25087082386016846,
-0.19156095385551453,
-0.3673788905143738,
-0.1975681334733963,
-0.3992963135242462,
0.05145160108804703,
0.4247439205646515,
-0.0414600595831871,
0.337889701128006,
0.5383682250976562,
-0.20087429881095886,
0.7091171145439148,
-0.45731279253959656,
-0.07988426834344864,
0.11952020972967148,
-0.2382163554430008,
-0.13458603620529175,
-0.3227354884147644,
0.9683014750480652,
0.30068475008010864,
0.15001878142356873,
-0.2733279764652252,
-0.03701993450522423,
-0.1343873292207718,
0.19585272669792175,
-0.5185927152633667,
-0.14500167965888977,
0.4442499876022339,
-0.14693230390548706,
0.0077488659881055355,
0.024010080844163895,
-0.9424862861633301,
-0.4000134766101837,
0.07625120133161545,
0.20989888906478882,
-0.3189431428909302,
-0.3463878631591797,
0.0793507844209671,
0.016408363357186317,
-0.011822694912552834,
0.21765664219856262,
-0.6547415852546692,
0.31490257382392883,
0.4177629351615906,
0.5162741541862488,
-0.5108925700187683,
-0.666921854019165,
-0.5214391350746155,
-0.05768752843141556,
-0.3653952181339264,
0.9230766892433167,
-0.5288592576980591,
-0.4181247651576996,
-0.19275237619876862,
-0.18691790103912354,
0.0981677696108818,
-0.4446515440940857,
0.7245926856994629,
-0.4560825228691101,
-0.08915678411722183,
-0.4124394357204437,
-0.5971519351005554,
0.011383496224880219,
0.30090221762657166,
-0.7682709693908691,
1.4458863735198975,
0.20167285203933716,
-0.7379348874092102,
0.16023282706737518,
-0.2769325375556946,
-0.08088554441928864,
0.05855175480246544,
-0.3811056315898895,
-0.193570077419281,
0.2947252094745636,
0.024020325392484665,
0.24208904802799225,
-0.7150395512580872,
0.435376912355423,
-0.8184503316879272,
-0.3318774998188019,
0.7078108191490173,
-0.9012567400932312,
0.6430530548095703,
0.08346088975667953,
-0.31817010045051575,
0.003697071922942996,
-0.8614532351493835,
0.5391033887863159,
0.14362940192222595,
-0.5022748112678528,
-0.09525644034147263,
-0.018058620393276215,
0.18336255848407745,
0.29327690601348877,
0.1814316213130951,
-0.5298092365264893,
0.035749007016420364,
0.025293942540884018,
0.17261233925819397,
0.7758657932281494,
-0.049931831657886505,
0.073649100959301,
-0.09534215182065964,
0.6826241612434387,
-0.19755323231220245,
0.11877992004156113,
0.34302613139152527,
-0.4494199752807617,
-0.7036166787147522,
0.047062668949365616,
0.41487979888916016,
0.4833349883556366,
-0.5041482448577881,
0.14913809299468994,
-0.05051074177026749,
-0.5168547034263611,
-0.34315094351768494,
0.3275603652000427,
0.46896129846572876,
0.32150086760520935,
0.4373264014720917,
-0.43816182017326355,
-0.3232366442680359,
-0.8326518535614014,
-0.34137076139450073,
-0.3711875081062317,
-0.09926871210336685,
0.18412771821022034,
0.4657284915447235,
-0.15025776624679565,
0.831366240978241,
-0.3149664103984833,
0.2648274600505829,
-0.40128979086875916,
0.22394204139709473,
0.1109093725681305,
0.17901308834552765,
0.29835718870162964,
-0.3407191336154938,
-0.2355041354894638,
-0.2943250238895416,
-0.5431272983551025,
-0.03415130823850632,
0.09248290956020355,
-0.1439233124256134,
0.3319205045700073,
0.32661452889442444,
-0.6046517491340637,
0.19161352515220642,
0.8002963662147522,
-0.07696101814508438,
0.8215859532356262,
-0.4182173013687134,
0.13776099681854248,
-0.7774311304092407,
0.2775062322616577,
-0.26664501428604126,
0.042889513075351715,
-0.3204650282859802,
-0.02551894262433052,
0.12387276440858841,
0.11019573360681534,
-0.47518280148506165,
0.7749282717704773,
-0.4200892746448517,
-0.49390894174575806,
-0.041221749037504196,
0.17546625435352325,
-0.1338890939950943,
0.14515849947929382,
-0.27147218585014343,
0.7824373841285706,
0.3540055453777313,
-0.28274843096733093,
0.6349480152130127,
-0.07998058944940567,
-0.621880054473877,
0.709307074546814,
-0.6384323239326477,
0.3314838707447052,
0.26702815294265747,
0.2762928605079651,
-1.0629528760910034,
-0.3262706696987152,
-0.07325952500104904,
-0.12193458527326584,
0.14484894275665283,
0.13601082563400269,
-0.679928183555603,
-0.673866331577301,
-0.19235184788703918,
0.2795029282569885,
0.25996118783950806,
-0.3869418203830719,
0.5862857103347778,
0.1711093634366989,
-0.18011300265789032,
-0.7664865851402283,
-0.5700604319572449,
0.11175656318664551,
0.00001995149978029076,
-0.3895854949951172,
-0.1048382818698883,
-0.41629424691200256,
-0.4831838607788086,
0.01671374961733818,
-0.4802359938621521,
-0.21160544455051422,
0.4594316780567169,
0.1300279051065445,
0.10814777761697769,
-0.03562881425023079,
0.22962486743927002,
-0.31098809838294983,
-0.18370592594146729,
0.03841046988964081,
-0.03931017965078354,
0.6863279342651367,
-0.47598227858543396,
-0.8345058560371399,
0.1421128511428833,
0.26606035232543945,
0.6020089387893677,
-0.2486143559217453,
0.4603880047798157,
0.4470067024230957,
-0.127863347530365,
-0.3305712938308716,
-0.7641420364379883,
0.005984652787446976,
-0.44486498832702637,
0.3705682158470154,
-0.31555017828941345,
-0.8018900156021118,
0.6612346768379211,
-0.18398450314998627,
0.002578901592642069,
0.33552420139312744,
0.4187746047973633,
-0.3479110896587372,
0.7808526158332825,
0.4049006700515747,
-0.27502429485321045,
0.10510920733213425,
0.24056437611579895,
-0.09533249586820602,
-0.6146730780601501,
0.08608966320753098,
-0.5871598124504089,
-0.18467079102993011,
-0.24915684759616852,
-0.6235387325286865,
0.3360637128353119,
0.3530895411968231,
-0.4239950478076935,
0.032006677240133286,
-0.08164568990468979,
0.6875603199005127,
0.6889775991439819,
-0.2464350461959839,
0.5755734443664551,
-0.16816502809524536,
-0.5471320748329163,
0.06872409582138062,
-0.544750988483429,
-0.5664553642272949,
1.2852689027786255,
0.19593729078769684,
0.8826969265937805,
0.24258765578269958,
0.5429239273071289,
-0.033043358474969864,
0.3089587092399597,
-0.28685441613197327,
0.6180590987205505,
0.16994832456111908,
-0.9613409638404846,
-0.6678382754325867,
-0.46405714750289917,
-0.8852466344833374,
0.46626201272010803,
-0.04522540047764778,
-1.1218788623809814,
-0.22003841400146484,
0.042667534202337265,
-0.437741219997406,
0.5250838398933411,
-0.4235589802265167,
0.8148241639137268,
-0.8001375794410706,
-0.4250946044921875,
-0.0769016370177269,
-0.6247211694717407,
0.3321491479873657,
-0.29312995076179504,
0.27380990982055664,
-0.2280588001012802,
0.07488371431827545,
0.4584486484527588,
-0.09571254253387451,
0.6180561184883118,
0.22906430065631866,
-0.052819181233644485,
0.2530479431152344,
0.23689697682857513,
0.3974023163318634,
0.11598475277423859,
-0.5100167393684387,
0.292415052652359,
0.051144879311323166,
-0.4092141389846802,
-0.5291106104850769,
0.7849478125572205,
-0.7510499358177185,
-0.4579561948776245,
-0.6070295572280884,
-0.6063105463981628,
-0.7142161726951599,
0.32870903611183167,
0.1977059692144394,
0.2073669731616974,
-0.546578049659729,
0.23537977039813995,
0.43340352177619934,
-0.243895024061203,
0.61626797914505,
0.6381669640541077,
-0.38552626967430115,
-0.49153271317481995,
0.6467500329017639,
0.21001188457012177,
0.4747964143753052,
-0.04368145018815994,
0.14759080111980438,
-0.3375104069709778,
-0.637906014919281,
-0.6049056053161621,
0.020883163437247276,
-0.836607038974762,
-0.13891664147377014,
-0.4350440800189972,
-0.15652790665626526,
0.1528843641281128,
-0.031000211834907532,
-0.6825613379478455,
-0.29868343472480774,
-0.019885441288352013,
-0.2631605267524719,
0.22389528155326843,
0.7734546661376953,
-0.057882681488990784,
0.14303703606128693,
-0.714480996131897,
0.19723069667816162,
0.5366488099098206,
0.8873524069786072,
-0.05257503315806389,
-0.2782418727874756,
-0.01288578286767006,
-0.11690665036439896,
-0.3014635741710663,
-0.7367624640464783,
-0.12384949624538422,
-0.03972870483994484,
1.0275588035583496,
0.19042649865150452,
0.07823266834020615,
0.3961675465106964,
-0.38093698024749756,
0.7954975366592407,
0.16476474702358246,
-0.950747549533844,
0.18652750551700592,
-0.37603840231895447,
0.3722301721572876,
0.9563310146331787,
0.20008395612239838,
-0.45477697253227234,
-0.44638746976852417,
-0.8090299963951111,
-0.8177449107170105,
0.3866752088069916,
-0.022488093003630638,
-0.1587190479040146,
0.07326799631118774,
0.11406837403774261,
-0.029373155906796455,
0.3023892045021057,
-0.5654093623161316,
-0.26274779438972473,
-0.017631419003009796,
-0.01099415123462677,
-0.38643723726272583,
-0.3108771741390228,
-0.06699707359075546,
-0.1330466866493225,
0.49390488862991333,
-0.22899837791919708,
-0.05738672614097595,
-0.21696332097053528,
-0.16874122619628906,
-0.24238403141498566,
0.8053257465362549,
0.4351477026939392,
0.8669373989105225,
-0.46973341703414917,
0.35329771041870117,
0.5525874495506287,
-0.19825974106788635,
0.4059074819087982,
0.22209036350250244,
0.039902254939079285,
-0.11112113296985626,
0.23119327425956726,
0.4877473711967468,
0.5452320575714111,
-0.8110866546630859,
0.22743475437164307,
-0.1240551769733429,
0.05885813385248184,
-0.16106832027435303,
-0.04123067110776901,
0.45663392543792725,
0.1390678584575653,
0.152581587433815,
-0.14840082824230194,
0.019706012681126595,
-0.6841484904289246,
0.2323930263519287,
0.41798198223114014,
-0.3382243514060974,
0.026391131803393364,
0.5110029578208923,
0.07819093763828278,
-0.02890571765601635,
0.6594879627227783,
-0.21502366662025452,
-0.4023200571537018,
0.5082460045814514,
0.48988938331604004,
0.609782338142395,
-0.42963749170303345,
0.34969544410705566,
0.1293351650238037,
0.46373751759529114,
-0.5639857053756714,
0.565078854560852,
0.4012337327003479,
-0.682506799697876,
-0.4247494339942932,
-0.6702155470848083,
-1.0380916595458984,
0.29345887899398804,
-0.5632994771003723,
-0.25462353229522705,
-0.3860057592391968,
-0.3519965708255768,
-0.3430083394050598,
0.04176364466547966,
-0.6924146413803101,
0.11560790240764618,
0.06316730380058289,
0.7799656987190247,
-0.6941478252410889,
0.8058413863182068,
0.6815006136894226,
-0.37233254313468933,
-0.9454582333564758,
-0.08991922438144684,
0.25750720500946045,
-0.6963720917701721,
0.3171877861022949,
-0.027255039662122726,
-0.2011786252260208,
-0.06702394783496857,
-0.3583317995071411,
-1.0874320268630981,
1.12241792678833,
0.5676731467247009,
-0.7453808784484863,
0.35444334149360657,
0.23135431110858917,
0.5065624713897705,
0.05171903222799301,
0.6718421578407288,
0.9408278465270996,
0.6735565066337585,
0.05028070881962776,
-1.123730182647705,
0.06307757645845413,
0.001509357593022287,
0.12680543959140778,
0.07911001890897751,
-0.7815021276473999,
0.8411770462989807,
-0.3559412658214569,
-0.030008399859070778,
0.14692074060440063,
0.41880062222480774,
0.47018375992774963,
0.0032564529683440924,
0.5849746465682983,
0.6645222306251526,
1.0845973491668701,
-0.20262524485588074,
1.1115671396255493,
-0.23394176363945007,
0.37988483905792236,
1.4579073190689087,
-0.5988011956214905,
1.1552433967590332,
0.43577390909194946,
-0.45326411724090576,
0.37998706102371216,
0.45873862504959106,
-0.08218447864055634,
0.07624869793653488,
0.6213465332984924,
-0.13567593693733215,
-0.6507145762443542,
-0.09679491072893143,
-0.32325223088264465,
0.47898492217063904,
0.1468709260225296,
0.06239834055304527,
-0.4683966040611267,
-0.16495630145072937,
0.010522065684199333,
-0.18027900159358978,
-0.027077853679656982,
0.47762808203697205,
0.23957200348377228,
-0.6420049071311951,
0.4398743808269501,
-0.17589597404003143,
0.43008261919021606,
-0.6753456592559814,
0.2344035804271698,
-0.3751274347305298,
0.3485713303089142,
0.14202524721622467,
-0.9584686160087585,
-0.2023210972547531,
-0.10769438743591309,
0.06344042718410492,
0.015962088480591774,
0.5998021364212036,
-0.2892948389053345,
-0.7306869626045227,
0.5353966951370239,
0.9482877850532532,
0.21744030714035034,
-0.07352682203054428,
-0.7443776726722717,
0.5014387369155884,
-0.2545261085033417,
-0.5314227342605591,
0.5641546845436096,
0.24689210951328278,
-0.025422170758247375,
0.9473061561584473,
0.5459014773368835,
0.12506496906280518,
-0.0921231284737587,
0.22254064679145813,
0.6494362950325012,
-0.6939689517021179,
0.06680580973625183,
-0.7440465092658997,
0.45676079392433167,
-0.12004086375236511,
-0.4318438768386841,
0.8763251900672913,
0.3684452772140503,
0.7739580273628235,
0.2180047333240509,
1.0128886699676514,
0.13039831817150116,
0.3274092674255371,
-0.3526110053062439,
0.6519291996955872,
-0.4532364308834076,
0.3031467795372009,
-0.4184226095676422,
-1.0403778553009033,
-0.297769695520401,
0.4309621751308441,
-0.22347398102283478,
0.24343198537826538,
0.9255964756011963,
0.4681088924407959,
-0.06283149123191833,
-0.08315824717283249,
0.523009717464447,
0.1569770872592926,
0.27662166953086853,
0.5284665822982788,
0.9814636707305908,
-0.10128915309906006,
0.7554000020027161,
-0.34472957253456116,
-0.19577737152576447,
-0.2167753130197525,
-1.058365821838379,
-0.7318853735923767,
-0.3003203868865967,
-0.0830380991101265,
-0.23681063950061798,
-0.06718159466981888,
0.8533819317817688,
0.5215228199958801,
-0.8247918486595154,
-0.43471968173980713,
0.08229623734951019,
0.1756851226091385,
-0.32880455255508423,
-0.12118245661258698,
0.39091506600379944,
-0.38425132632255554,
-0.2812759578227997,
0.4427730143070221,
0.22863851487636566,
0.10058269649744034,
-0.4327280521392822,
0.0953434631228447,
-0.05149923637509346,
0.1897459477186203,
0.33706212043762207,
0.36098405718803406,
-0.8434270024299622,
-0.4358347952365875,
0.023508207872509956,
-0.08324248343706131,
-0.11456499993801117,
0.5171058773994446,
-0.3133421540260315,
0.542475700378418,
0.2923544645309448,
0.70206218957901,
0.32988303899765015,
0.06882978975772858,
0.6822779774665833,
-0.4034864902496338,
-0.3064958453178406,
0.17212960124015808,
0.6980704665184021,
0.3148682713508606,
0.18530282378196716,
0.5759234428405762,
-0.03938683122396469,
-0.7813323140144348,
-0.7292040586471558,
0.2199326753616333,
-0.8225343823432922,
-0.3805341124534607,
1.355247139930725,
-0.22289858758449554,
0.004751734901219606,
-0.3823269009590149,
-0.2030249387025833,
-0.07100453972816467,
-0.41557106375694275,
0.6463730931282043,
1.2535616159439087,
-0.2081170529127121,
-0.2108745276927948,
-0.8921422362327576,
0.17624042928218842,
0.6010978817939758,
-0.9962288737297058,
0.3572653830051422,
0.6398196220397949,
0.5321148633956909,
0.1920021027326584,
0.7003836035728455,
0.0660373792052269,
0.19571496546268463,
-0.036157023161649704,
0.22042500972747803,
0.14695066213607788,
-0.3491451144218445,
-0.2394142597913742,
0.2691531479358673,
0.5739542841911316,
0.30266276001930237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12779v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12779v1 | Composited-Nested-Learning with Data Augmentation for Nested Named Entity Recognition | 2024-06-18T16:46:18 | 2024-06-18T16:46:18 | Xingming Liao, Nankai Lin, Haowen Li, Lianglun Cheng, Zhuowei Wang, Chong Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Nested Named Entity Recognition (NNER) focuses on addressing overlapped
entity recognition. Compared to Flat Named Entity Recognition (FNER), annotated
resources are scarce in the corpus for NNER. Data augmentation is an effective
approach to address the insufficient annotated corpus. However, there is a
significant lack of exploration in data augmentation methods for NNER. Due to
the presence of nested entities in NNER, existing data augmentation methods
cannot be directly applied to NNER tasks. Therefore, in this work, we focus on
data augmentation for NNER and resort to more expressive structures,
Composited-Nested-Label Classification (CNLC) in which constituents are
combined by nested-word and nested-label, to model nested entities. The dataset
is augmented using the Composited-Nested-Learning (CNL). In addition, we
propose the Confidence Filtering Mechanism (CFM) for a more efficient selection
of generated data. Experimental results demonstrate that this approach results
in improvements in ACE2004 and ACE2005 and alleviates the impact of sample
imbalance. | [
-0.4770394563674927,
-0.35452011227607727,
0.06365888565778732,
0.1394806057214737,
-0.41879355907440186,
0.6961439847946167,
-0.35456380248069763,
-0.7453289031982422,
0.13777053356170654,
0.28610944747924805,
-0.4615255296230316,
-0.6953189373016357,
-0.4785585105419159,
0.4190247654914856,
-0.033440809696912766,
1.0875400304794312,
-0.018194537609815598,
0.1743575632572174,
-0.5253833532333374,
0.02745264209806919,
-0.3546777665615082,
-0.5991882085800171,
-0.7605050206184387,
-0.4855509102344513,
0.5823777318000793,
0.37996822595596313,
0.22915202379226685,
0.4296782910823822,
0.34755802154541016,
0.24469396471977234,
-0.12874004244804382,
0.488435298204422,
-0.3873932957649231,
0.0935806855559349,
0.1505296677350998,
-0.6262012720108032,
-0.5167453289031982,
-0.24212288856506348,
0.7507889270782471,
0.8456642627716064,
0.09336013346910477,
-0.3274860978126526,
0.14553074538707733,
0.34462660551071167,
-0.9053493142127991,
0.6227542161941528,
-0.5770334005355835,
0.2102174162864685,
-0.14600203931331635,
-0.18591052293777466,
-0.2850956320762634,
-0.11580391973257065,
0.15741880238056183,
-0.7806528210639954,
0.3491838276386261,
0.24976538121700287,
0.5779456496238708,
0.1676201969385147,
-0.35448500514030457,
-0.21438227593898773,
-0.595364511013031,
0.9179395437240601,
-0.5319327116012573,
0.6726148724555969,
0.1919107735157013,
0.06656349450349808,
-0.33129650354385376,
-0.6299406290054321,
-0.7763763070106506,
-0.34246429800987244,
-0.39701101183891296,
0.24190182983875275,
-0.1280137449502945,
0.14545756578445435,
0.06780721992254257,
0.6834931373596191,
-0.3145964443683624,
0.494080126285553,
-0.17886489629745483,
-0.16474604606628418,
0.5481113195419312,
0.13244591653347015,
0.19896890223026276,
-0.01674790494143963,
-0.630820631980896,
-0.3272855281829834,
-0.43404895067214966,
-0.0773749053478241,
0.20388130843639374,
0.6337785720825195,
-0.01605806313455105,
0.429252564907074,
-0.30130594968795776,
0.6155692934989929,
0.46375757455825806,
-0.052542682737112045,
0.4132363796234131,
-0.20595121383666992,
-0.3935740888118744,
0.5226012468338013,
0.4451843202114105,
0.22790981829166412,
-0.11482148617506027,
-0.5706485509872437,
-0.37146300077438354,
0.2781561315059662,
0.0520535446703434,
-0.7756577134132385,
-0.3629744350910187,
0.1920885592699051,
0.05596268177032471,
-0.4249604046344757,
0.44425293803215027,
-0.7483423352241516,
-0.1930648237466812,
-0.47359153628349304,
0.12733468413352966,
-0.3575036823749542,
-0.16384851932525635,
-0.12261486053466797,
-0.07234456390142441,
0.252523809671402,
0.2667108476161957,
-0.7112830877304077,
0.6403711438179016,
0.927444577217102,
0.6092560291290283,
-0.5332088470458984,
0.05731762945652008,
-0.5163570642471313,
0.0921347513794899,
-0.2909947633743286,
0.6980260014533997,
-0.7291194200515747,
-0.4342982769012451,
-0.15632303059101105,
0.058944880962371826,
-0.2702457904815674,
-0.7149228453636169,
0.5155043005943298,
-0.8105847239494324,
0.4278959631919861,
0.053058773279190063,
-0.8645206689834595,
-0.15537650883197784,
0.5664266347885132,
-0.9906713366508484,
0.9841253757476807,
0.09414110332727432,
-0.8695541620254517,
0.6026371121406555,
-0.47487252950668335,
-0.5322812795639038,
0.38154247403144836,
-0.38079893589019775,
-0.5653194785118103,
-0.07609137892723083,
0.4795319736003876,
0.3214925527572632,
-0.15957042574882507,
0.20334985852241516,
-0.14617794752120972,
-0.2822156846523285,
0.1848512887954712,
-0.2671186327934265,
0.5751168131828308,
-0.2190006673336029,
-0.13555194437503815,
-0.1280127763748169,
-0.9839387536048889,
-0.0718517154455185,
-0.09341069310903549,
-0.7590869665145874,
-0.47813305258750916,
-0.3555995225906372,
0.30751219391822815,
0.03188134729862213,
0.16889382898807526,
-0.7504106163978577,
0.1419435292482376,
-0.7823758125305176,
0.20736531913280487,
0.3681335151195526,
0.29710233211517334,
0.6793949007987976,
-0.3625129461288452,
0.35247722268104553,
0.4894246459007263,
-0.13165616989135742,
0.18132299184799194,
-0.24141302704811096,
-0.7206180095672607,
-0.32001084089279175,
0.9154491424560547,
0.5110598802566528,
-0.9614430665969849,
0.5661932229995728,
-0.49712738394737244,
-0.46864721179008484,
-0.20107628405094147,
0.008440615609288216,
0.33638784289360046,
0.5784280896186829,
0.7237042784690857,
-0.45047593116760254,
-0.8470454216003418,
-0.6183693408966064,
0.20883053541183472,
0.09175367653369904,
-0.05375627055764198,
0.44562482833862305,
0.423583447933197,
-0.348772257566452,
0.7961273193359375,
-0.4396316409111023,
-0.4887597858905792,
0.05429254472255707,
0.2538129985332489,
-0.07150132209062576,
0.6845865845680237,
0.24914012849330902,
-1.094851016998291,
-0.3741091191768646,
0.03203370049595833,
-0.5042110681533813,
0.205520898103714,
-0.06085210666060448,
-0.02110975608229637,
0.1029401421546936,
0.3456369936466217,
-0.6750155687332153,
0.214722141623497,
0.2303646355867386,
0.31821951270103455,
0.43577051162719727,
0.030171765014529228,
0.0030130816157907248,
-0.9637270569801331,
-0.3037303388118744,
0.056135986000299454,
-0.025587474927306175,
-0.5683371424674988,
0.027140548452734947,
0.0757383480668068,
0.17412948608398438,
-0.21044467389583588,
0.385456919670105,
-0.8349161148071289,
0.0035039118956774473,
-0.4365604817867279,
0.21969690918922424,
0.23566687107086182,
0.3483741581439972,
0.2638869881629944,
0.6220557689666748,
0.6425368189811707,
-0.6756302118301392,
0.19308902323246002,
0.32918044924736023,
-0.15684913098812103,
0.6831899881362915,
-0.22042198479175568,
0.0262298546731472,
-0.2143821120262146,
0.6388237476348877,
-0.7988343834877014,
-0.27579453587532043,
0.42515018582344055,
-0.4812156856060028,
0.7108407616615295,
-0.09265580028295517,
-0.4326276183128357,
-0.1671685129404068,
-0.19702810049057007,
0.4430672526359558,
0.048019181936979294,
-0.9086213707923889,
0.7887923717498779,
0.21397964656352997,
0.09707570821046829,
-0.5496104955673218,
-0.9295817017555237,
0.1872541606426239,
-0.18248353898525238,
-0.3682001531124115,
1.1993558406829834,
0.14108043909072876,
0.09976086765527725,
0.32931068539619446,
-0.3396907448768616,
-0.3718799650669098,
-0.21942071616649628,
0.29658955335617065,
0.4811323285102844,
-0.5092957019805908,
0.3808227479457855,
0.028618190437555313,
-0.08413447439670563,
-0.027947740629315376,
-0.22194451093673706,
0.3444254696369171,
-0.015062064863741398,
0.023705314844846725,
-0.2596883773803711,
0.28266507387161255,
0.36819496750831604,
-0.2915840446949005,
1.02262544631958,
0.6036646962165833,
-0.86477130651474,
-0.0819939523935318,
-0.4419953525066376,
-0.2797926068305969,
-0.36332228779792786,
-0.1768074482679367,
-0.3286159634590149,
-1.1265689134597778,
0.3139477074146271,
-0.1001395434141159,
-0.054566726088523865,
0.4901639521121979,
0.19965684413909912,
-0.011977254413068295,
0.6163939237594604,
0.390262633562088,
-0.04907827824354172,
0.45038068294525146,
-0.28465020656585693,
0.3808772563934326,
-1.3368041515350342,
-0.5597249865531921,
-0.2710224986076355,
-0.20073936879634857,
-0.7649546265602112,
-0.5346506834030151,
0.108151376247406,
-0.02190195769071579,
0.16123144328594208,
0.3655497133731842,
-0.5179773569107056,
0.31886041164398193,
0.44699791073799133,
0.46361044049263,
0.31175699830055237,
-0.0004754400288220495,
-0.22427530586719513,
0.05788498744368553,
-0.6475099921226501,
-0.19044014811515808,
0.8498003482818604,
0.019908087328076363,
0.49728116393089294,
0.0006581373163498938,
0.793050229549408,
0.06257681548595428,
0.27626824378967285,
-0.7855824828147888,
0.3163864016532898,
-0.22465132176876068,
-0.29086384177207947,
0.014088246040046215,
-0.392867773771286,
-1.0650320053100586,
0.22856317460536957,
-0.6662940382957458,
-0.5548948645591736,
0.6803421974182129,
0.130249485373497,
-0.4248731732368469,
0.19878748059272766,
-0.45244482159614563,
0.2876014709472656,
-0.28479915857315063,
-0.24965891242027283,
0.0959584042429924,
-0.5445292592048645,
0.5000342726707458,
-0.07936668395996094,
-0.09046013653278351,
0.42242667078971863,
-0.08280417323112488,
0.5437756776809692,
-0.31797704100608826,
0.7437983155250549,
-0.11578359454870224,
0.2493603229522705,
0.20509237051010132,
-0.4848938286304474,
0.561927318572998,
0.0000011949539384659147,
-0.055867794901132584,
0.056654952466487885,
-0.43946602940559387,
-0.10721388459205627,
-0.851310670375824,
0.9319525957107544,
-0.3130027651786804,
-0.22248311340808868,
-0.5696613192558289,
-0.35767632722854614,
-0.2066526710987091,
0.06510459631681442,
0.12986566126346588,
0.3942764103412628,
0.009192241355776787,
0.6223928928375244,
0.6124709248542786,
-0.03607606887817383,
0.1451893001794815,
0.12697912752628326,
0.3103722631931305,
-0.6220179200172424,
0.8061997294425964,
0.2990281879901886,
-0.002149498090147972,
0.8235248923301697,
-0.02905542217195034,
-0.6263524293899536,
-0.5051106214523315,
-0.25803765654563904,
-0.032252371311187744,
-0.46998679637908936,
-0.42565423250198364,
-0.8029183745384216,
-0.4741533398628235,
-0.5126592516899109,
0.07119777798652649,
-0.1250174194574356,
-0.3894897401332855,
-0.5999606251716614,
-0.28200140595436096,
0.2525276243686676,
0.21557684242725372,
-0.043229714035987854,
0.3805485665798187,
-0.4787200093269348,
0.27218130230903625,
0.22498886287212372,
0.31419652700424194,
0.2347014844417572,
-0.009806524962186813,
-0.06131598353385925,
-0.004365119151771069,
-0.0039825523272156715,
-0.7661611437797546,
0.06383241713047028,
0.4135059416294098,
0.7837210893630981,
0.29184067249298096,
0.36733904480934143,
0.7146006226539612,
-0.19408518075942993,
0.48964694142341614,
0.011138572357594967,
-0.5202006697654724,
0.25036829710006714,
0.06982727348804474,
-0.08348725736141205,
0.5476911067962646,
0.4253859221935272,
-0.012287584133446217,
-0.0614435188472271,
-0.782219648361206,
-1.2010509967803955,
0.26770350337028503,
0.40343573689460754,
-0.032723698765039444,
-0.11411002278327942,
0.3370096981525421,
-0.056004032492637634,
0.4841892719268799,
-0.5519683361053467,
-0.24429738521575928,
-0.005471073556691408,
-0.22260169684886932,
0.059396229684352875,
0.023470619693398476,
0.11741200089454651,
-0.2667434811592102,
0.85507732629776,
0.06873498111963272,
0.21232907474040985,
0.2847071588039398,
-0.26222044229507446,
0.0855335220694542,
0.3604004681110382,
0.28738081455230713,
-0.04167665168642998,
-0.19608286023139954,
0.16970568895339966,
0.19079628586769104,
-0.34072205424308777,
-0.12674318253993988,
0.4300750195980072,
-0.29171088337898254,
-0.05668408423662186,
0.288837194442749,
1.0956082344055176,
0.7279114723205566,
-0.39867231249809265,
0.2746610939502716,
-0.003841194324195385,
-0.0877077654004097,
-0.40332356095314026,
0.2971075177192688,
-0.11238862574100494,
0.2350340336561203,
0.2857225239276886,
0.038655538111925125,
0.2743745446205139,
-0.33011603355407715,
0.47935160994529724,
0.44143375754356384,
-0.28209492564201355,
0.15105916559696198,
0.48979809880256653,
-0.16119828820228577,
-0.2042289823293686,
0.8305383920669556,
-0.2531903386116028,
-0.6478140354156494,
0.5671567916870117,
0.7168945074081421,
0.672904372215271,
-0.07615004479885101,
0.03652748093008995,
0.5586376786231995,
0.11674506217241287,
0.17087872326374054,
-0.019346073269844055,
-0.4331324100494385,
-0.8613201975822449,
-0.29269465804100037,
-0.6365916728973389,
-0.5709362626075745,
0.33392253518104553,
-1.034700632095337,
0.13683560490608215,
-0.4675312340259552,
-0.043132755905389786,
0.2871614694595337,
0.16855119168758392,
-0.7725160121917725,
0.682560920715332,
0.2267058789730072,
0.8444003462791443,
-0.7431524395942688,
0.4069303274154663,
0.7331380844116211,
-0.4314572513103485,
-0.8469052910804749,
0.11877363920211792,
-0.253012478351593,
-0.3849274814128876,
0.4561225473880768,
0.431326299905777,
-0.0031762276776134968,
0.27274763584136963,
-0.3243514895439148,
-0.6190820932388306,
1.1785601377487183,
-0.07234276086091995,
-0.5177938342094421,
0.05155446007847786,
0.13071304559707642,
0.6576781868934631,
-0.781644880771637,
0.05564572662115097,
0.4980025589466095,
0.639832615852356,
0.3999190628528595,
-0.4010312259197235,
-0.037643805146217346,
-0.32723695039749146,
0.009576542302966118,
0.06099473685026169,
-0.3743689954280853,
0.855154275894165,
-0.12862136960029602,
-0.41758835315704346,
-0.060198910534381866,
0.7452087998390198,
0.5127628445625305,
0.5546029806137085,
0.6894622445106506,
0.7205862998962402,
0.9523854851722717,
-0.17908504605293274,
0.6965546011924744,
-0.1474681794643402,
0.25452911853790283,
1.54622483253479,
-0.29245525598526,
0.9745202660560608,
0.4474011957645416,
-0.0009841348510235548,
0.8447872400283813,
0.701698899269104,
-0.4452345669269562,
0.4704247713088989,
0.2309478372335434,
-0.5893760919570923,
-0.16886210441589355,
-0.38500702381134033,
-0.24507883191108704,
0.5703246593475342,
0.6195414066314697,
-0.2325577437877655,
-0.2886687219142914,
0.07770205289125443,
-0.299719899892807,
-0.12205535173416138,
-0.2537064850330353,
0.8972457051277161,
0.09701277315616608,
-0.40314728021621704,
0.22045214474201202,
0.12984830141067505,
0.6496321558952332,
0.08317392319440842,
-0.19734443724155426,
0.04248115420341492,
-0.017149273306131363,
-0.46472302079200745,
-0.5740215182304382,
0.0490761436522007,
-0.15636184811592102,
-0.33719775080680847,
0.2908932864665985,
0.8865584135055542,
-0.6862346529960632,
-0.5329027771949768,
0.28475162386894226,
0.2445627748966217,
0.013578744605183601,
-0.30238407850265503,
-0.4928117096424103,
-0.1801835149526596,
-0.44978633522987366,
0.07023439556360245,
0.30741646885871887,
0.166621133685112,
-0.18774481117725372,
0.3757694959640503,
0.9324239492416382,
0.05242036655545235,
0.3215632736682892,
0.07510215789079666,
1.0781947374343872,
-0.26921898126602173,
-0.7123681902885437,
-0.4980175197124481,
0.47309640049934387,
-0.260394811630249,
0.09520477801561356,
0.5587372779846191,
0.8776999711990356,
1.1262060403823853,
-0.15277989208698273,
0.6785802245140076,
-0.02296430431306362,
0.3951478898525238,
-0.5904207229614258,
0.22337254881858826,
-0.4736131429672241,
0.16372326016426086,
-0.07459944486618042,
-0.9242039322853088,
-0.6802542209625244,
0.629822850227356,
-0.3860040605068207,
0.19607627391815186,
0.37282949686050415,
0.6995346546173096,
-0.24240410327911377,
0.1592002958059311,
-0.0029350395780056715,
0.05035400390625,
0.015200882218778133,
0.5794865489006042,
0.6703168749809265,
-0.7208541631698608,
0.246287539601326,
-0.5733434557914734,
-0.05998304858803749,
-0.33556270599365234,
-0.8515614867210388,
-0.7049078941345215,
-0.4704934060573578,
-0.6299857497215271,
-0.054489318281412125,
-0.039839908480644226,
0.8673560619354248,
0.8031153082847595,
-1.051429033279419,
0.4226226508617401,
-0.49044716358184814,
0.05976336449384689,
-0.2004459798336029,
-0.3303832709789276,
0.4381662905216217,
-0.08191616833209991,
-0.8470005393028259,
0.5672425031661987,
0.1619163453578949,
0.2684578001499176,
-0.07813362777233124,
-0.014639601111412048,
-0.20862805843353271,
-0.26336637139320374,
0.4582565426826477,
0.29754170775413513,
-0.635974645614624,
-0.12600721418857574,
-0.02779737114906311,
0.041931718587875366,
0.35800522565841675,
0.5766595005989075,
-0.94526606798172,
0.43165403604507446,
0.19729827344417572,
0.9958707690238953,
0.4522315561771393,
0.42667147517204285,
0.16188949346542358,
-0.9921141266822815,
-0.1784951388835907,
0.3395625948905945,
0.19319675862789154,
0.6379780173301697,
-0.7640581130981445,
0.2860281765460968,
0.3282504081726074,
-0.24734064936637878,
-0.7700936794281006,
-0.12778480350971222,
-1.266112208366394,
0.1811005026102066,
0.7230727076530457,
-0.10278929024934769,
-0.1451077163219452,
-0.1611473113298416,
0.023356614634394646,
0.560217022895813,
-0.3917379081249237,
0.586197018623352,
0.5196130275726318,
-0.3124602138996124,
-0.5267341136932373,
-0.06348413228988647,
0.2121494859457016,
0.0032991066109389067,
-0.8320233225822449,
-0.34901711344718933,
0.4817122519016266,
0.22994038462638855,
0.30176296830177307,
0.2704051434993744,
-0.045687802135944366,
-0.04663346707820892,
0.09336196631193161,
-0.13867677748203278,
-0.24053293466567993,
-0.5545091032981873,
-0.14132627844810486,
0.35913193225860596,
-0.18298612534999847,
-0.5200422406196594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12775v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12775v1 | Hopping Too Late: Exploring the Limitations of Large Language Models on Multi-Hop Queries | 2024-06-18T16:44:13 | 2024-06-18T16:44:13 | Eden Biran, Daniela Gottesman, Sohee Yang, Mor Geva, Amir Globerson | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) can solve complex multi-step problems, but
little is known about how these computations are implemented internally.
Motivated by this, we study how LLMs answer multi-hop queries such as "The
spouse of the performer of Imagine is". These queries require two information
extraction steps: a latent one for resolving the first hop ("the performer of
Imagine") into the bridge entity (John Lennon), and one for resolving the
second hop ("the spouse of John Lennon") into the target entity (Yoko Ono).
Understanding how the latent step is computed internally is key to
understanding the overall computation. By carefully analyzing the internal
computations of transformer-based LLMs, we discover that the bridge entity is
resolved in the early layers of the model. Then, only after this resolution,
the two-hop query is solved in the later layers. Because the second hop
commences in later layers, there could be cases where these layers no longer
encode the necessary knowledge for correctly predicting the answer. Motivated
by this, we propose a novel "back-patching" analysis method whereby a hidden
representation from a later layer is patched back to an earlier layer. We find
that in up to 57% of previously incorrect cases there exists a back-patch that
results in the correct generation of the answer, showing that the later layers
indeed sometimes lack the needed functionality. Overall our methods and
findings open further opportunities for understanding and improving latent
reasoning in transformer-based LLMs. | [
-0.4505208134651184,
-0.8529505133628845,
0.9338839054107666,
0.5257956385612488,
0.0777430459856987,
0.449266254901886,
-0.005536108277738094,
-0.6322422623634338,
0.22157403826713562,
0.7259852886199951,
-0.9319958686828613,
-0.05043422803282738,
-0.6062452793121338,
-0.21337197721004486,
-0.10539335757493973,
0.7006525993347168,
-0.05509214848279953,
-0.22184349596500397,
-0.13563373684883118,
0.09212169796228409,
-0.546760618686676,
-0.29681748151779175,
-0.7919673919677734,
-0.29154878854751587,
0.4909656345844269,
0.3865968883037567,
0.6515004634857178,
0.25369417667388916,
0.5553136467933655,
0.21624039113521576,
-0.4260248839855194,
0.07045159488916397,
-0.5357198715209961,
0.24207371473312378,
0.07432719320058823,
-0.8273476958274841,
-0.5570122599601746,
0.1605166792869568,
0.6945402026176453,
0.9420973658561707,
0.301655650138855,
0.12114129215478897,
-0.0943705290555954,
0.7225467562675476,
-0.517227053642273,
-0.009062323719263077,
-0.8239357471466064,
0.11975371092557907,
-0.47657299041748047,
-0.3106285631656647,
-0.5422772169113159,
-0.08578725159168243,
-0.20431756973266602,
-0.35468629002571106,
-0.06374640017747879,
0.05095676705241203,
0.6031110882759094,
0.43967464566230774,
-0.5282938480377197,
-0.2838725447654724,
-1.1060900688171387,
0.6685556173324585,
-0.5711687207221985,
0.5289435386657715,
0.3750263750553131,
0.4434277415275574,
-0.6151490211486816,
-0.45488807559013367,
-0.6663855910301208,
-0.2712147831916809,
-0.1897309124469757,
0.02121983841061592,
-0.24138674139976501,
-0.18845780193805695,
0.5911722183227539,
0.3905480206012726,
-0.5010671019554138,
0.20181146264076233,
-0.21894901990890503,
-0.08154846727848053,
0.4568115174770355,
0.07016509771347046,
0.2851771116256714,
-0.05511820688843727,
-0.3268391788005829,
0.08767469227313995,
-0.8338286280632019,
0.3132200539112091,
0.442739337682724,
0.1594117283821106,
-0.08078573644161224,
0.6279000639915466,
0.18874581158161163,
0.7116734385490417,
0.09100975096225739,
-0.17035049200057983,
0.18776293098926544,
0.03144804388284683,
0.14895698428153992,
-0.31761375069618225,
0.7496907114982605,
-0.055892620235681534,
0.12928877770900726,
-0.3655396103858948,
-0.3639809191226959,
-0.24125434458255768,
0.1047983169555664,
-0.44793984293937683,
-0.09851399064064026,
0.45628029108047485,
-0.3938423693180084,
-0.17734964191913605,
-0.14437167346477509,
-0.7805726528167725,
-0.21801210939884186,
0.14617039263248444,
0.576900839805603,
-0.15990668535232544,
-0.4098822772502899,
-0.15257608890533447,
0.009899739176034927,
0.09992693364620209,
0.1743605136871338,
-0.4443185031414032,
0.253037691116333,
0.8181563019752502,
0.933682918548584,
0.02142833173274994,
-0.45104748010635376,
-0.7814265489578247,
0.17331728339195251,
-0.5620437860488892,
0.6931460499763489,
-0.6294635534286499,
-0.3840692937374115,
-0.39365124702453613,
0.10917892307043076,
-0.05637446418404579,
-0.3522604703903198,
0.48513734340667725,
-1.063731074333191,
0.26561176776885986,
-0.1991552859544754,
-0.49610432982444763,
0.011517154984176159,
0.2524047791957855,
-0.978836178779602,
0.9173298478126526,
0.010711310431361198,
-0.8132954835891724,
-0.10302319377660751,
-0.6755572557449341,
-0.3295615315437317,
-0.13371701538562775,
-0.24190036952495575,
-0.6300747990608215,
0.2955523729324341,
0.2954930365085602,
0.3021445572376251,
-0.20582112669944763,
-0.02257905714213848,
-0.28837716579437256,
-0.5359896421432495,
0.36395570635795593,
-0.2319355010986328,
0.9446024298667908,
0.02554982714354992,
-0.2054823637008667,
-0.2714652121067047,
-0.7824608683586121,
-0.09056280553340912,
0.528232753276825,
-0.43180331587791443,
-0.28189173340797424,
0.03707974776625633,
-0.27597764134407043,
0.330473929643631,
0.0833830013871193,
-0.8306873440742493,
0.39667999744415283,
-0.4996369481086731,
0.34810858964920044,
0.6605273485183716,
0.04464326426386833,
0.46026694774627686,
-0.32024118304252625,
0.7490629553794861,
0.06421323120594025,
0.10620041936635971,
-0.718144953250885,
-0.8067955374717712,
-0.5227091312408447,
0.17521612346172333,
0.03915533795952797,
0.5404151082038879,
-0.610113799571991,
-0.005022475030273199,
-0.3710756301879883,
-0.561840832233429,
-0.4330568313598633,
-0.1333310753107071,
0.3565623164176941,
0.34192416071891785,
0.46384289860725403,
0.12067325413227081,
-0.48772695660591125,
-0.7356393933296204,
-0.5877164006233215,
-0.4352688193321228,
0.10233817249536514,
0.3975990116596222,
0.41297903656959534,
-0.22772997617721558,
0.8868198394775391,
-0.6727203726768494,
-0.2855270206928253,
0.04978827014565468,
0.007062836550176144,
0.6687152981758118,
0.5897957682609558,
0.36855483055114746,
-0.7618802189826965,
-0.3573881685733795,
-0.07761798799037933,
-0.4989841878414154,
-0.07914687693119049,
-0.3654850423336029,
-0.025581317022442818,
-0.0614788718521595,
0.7207642793655396,
-0.741448700428009,
0.2698429226875305,
0.7554556727409363,
-0.12208056449890137,
0.5510849356651306,
0.0034499356988817453,
0.028928037732839584,
-0.8412063717842102,
-0.07139058411121368,
-0.4392354190349579,
-0.16385382413864136,
-0.46862778067588806,
0.12190352380275726,
0.18627771735191345,
-0.10829830169677734,
-0.08399388194084167,
0.3931671977043152,
-0.7618745565414429,
-0.32761135697364807,
-0.35506340861320496,
-0.05609879270195961,
0.06739943474531174,
0.41675499081611633,
-0.26208212971687317,
0.6979458332061768,
0.454211562871933,
-0.3461654484272003,
0.3731023371219635,
0.1327272206544876,
0.07470481842756271,
0.42651766538619995,
-0.5102129578590393,
0.687728226184845,
-0.2933119237422943,
0.4706173837184906,
-1.2627097368240356,
-0.07200882583856583,
0.2324478030204773,
-0.6009503602981567,
0.5343728065490723,
-0.8418647646903992,
-0.31318166851997375,
-0.6835492253303528,
-0.08427699655294418,
0.6497290730476379,
0.29458728432655334,
-0.6037602424621582,
1.0043244361877441,
0.4344468414783478,
-0.043888483196496964,
-0.567310094833374,
-0.7199227213859558,
0.3603399991989136,
-0.13065145909786224,
-0.9199166893959045,
0.5152559876441956,
-0.2229459136724472,
-0.19791284203529358,
0.11043688654899597,
-0.10708107054233551,
-0.0538516566157341,
0.09988899528980255,
0.1733267456293106,
0.2540084421634674,
-0.3708350658416748,
0.06073008477687836,
-0.010880090296268463,
-0.3446241021156311,
0.3209238052368164,
-0.42014914751052856,
0.5522981286048889,
-0.021724259480834007,
-0.6942384839057922,
-0.05144811421632767,
0.6343257427215576,
0.769668698310852,
-0.25446638464927673,
0.6492147445678711,
0.6028411984443665,
-0.47989219427108765,
-0.22378970682621002,
-0.7773605585098267,
0.011968294158577919,
-0.4355992376804352,
0.2010263353586197,
-0.8549630045890808,
-0.7558445334434509,
0.7947909235954285,
-0.22029519081115723,
0.20029595494270325,
0.5158510804176331,
0.2813533842563629,
-0.3149266541004181,
0.7396906018257141,
0.768599808216095,
0.14245738089084625,
0.25691425800323486,
-0.26514652371406555,
0.24170441925525665,
-1.073164463043213,
-0.510073721408844,
-0.5236629247665405,
-0.41440778970718384,
-0.7635492086410522,
-0.6164864897727966,
0.6261820197105408,
0.28326600790023804,
0.06438827514648438,
0.33146074414253235,
-0.023898499086499214,
0.6593314409255981,
0.38448894023895264,
0.0918552577495575,
0.45199668407440186,
-0.2541925609111786,
-0.22619378566741943,
-0.02961103431880474,
-0.48051586747169495,
-0.11523982137441635,
1.0503489971160889,
0.40760788321495056,
0.9067637920379639,
0.35291483998298645,
0.7115863561630249,
-0.13126398622989655,
0.00489859888330102,
-0.8443436622619629,
0.3861687183380127,
0.10542668402194977,
-0.708723247051239,
-0.2918927073478699,
-0.6276249885559082,
-0.9237247705459595,
0.23536089062690735,
-0.028375428169965744,
-0.8656209707260132,
0.18544533848762512,
0.09901256859302521,
-0.32518965005874634,
0.6559016704559326,
-0.5786157846450806,
0.5857985615730286,
-0.3509000539779663,
-0.22722934186458588,
0.076282799243927,
-0.8825222849845886,
0.4704274535179138,
-0.35470688343048096,
0.5221952199935913,
0.09455806761980057,
-0.021784532815217972,
0.722048282623291,
-0.3763806223869324,
0.6180659532546997,
-0.11318088322877884,
-0.3023340106010437,
0.08671580255031586,
0.39063677191734314,
0.8694847822189331,
-0.06949909031391144,
0.1535727083683014,
0.04375118017196655,
-0.10804464668035507,
-0.3811192214488983,
-0.7435920238494873,
0.7775554060935974,
-0.608161449432373,
-0.6327187418937683,
-0.35377922654151917,
-0.3427148759365082,
-0.548700749874115,
0.09727843105792999,
0.29124394059181213,
0.10794175416231155,
0.13401451706886292,
-0.0917108878493309,
0.6113107204437256,
-0.3870059847831726,
0.7061797976493835,
0.5251277685165405,
-0.521094024181366,
-0.14646929502487183,
0.5733031630516052,
0.30478447675704956,
0.14940230548381805,
0.4717944860458374,
0.36201202869415283,
-0.23527543246746063,
-0.4269367456436157,
-0.40591415762901306,
0.5684460401535034,
-0.687789797782898,
0.013225357979536057,
-1.0408438444137573,
-0.35384517908096313,
-0.1959030032157898,
0.2167850285768509,
-0.6831423044204712,
-0.3168529272079468,
-0.12162800133228302,
0.19062481820583344,
0.10191739350557327,
0.8766557574272156,
-0.1502029448747635,
0.432797372341156,
-0.999500036239624,
0.3964925706386566,
0.32052454352378845,
0.6426550149917603,
0.245304673910141,
-0.6076340675354004,
-0.3256734311580658,
-0.28179171681404114,
-0.19492803514003754,
-1.2943979501724243,
-0.06641603261232376,
0.10240016877651215,
0.6775696873664856,
0.059650201350450516,
-0.2280810922384262,
0.766953706741333,
-0.7230936884880066,
0.7596001029014587,
0.04837821051478386,
-0.8207042217254639,
0.8110992312431335,
-0.21786299347877502,
0.03783107548952103,
0.0729970633983612,
0.43378686904907227,
-0.6334168910980225,
-0.25312796235084534,
-0.7795895934104919,
-0.9911737442016602,
0.8148810267448425,
0.34140706062316895,
0.08243782818317413,
0.3368547558784485,
0.3690171539783478,
0.061189163476228714,
-0.05140334740281105,
-0.9281941652297974,
-0.36341920495033264,
0.21944059431552887,
0.5348954796791077,
-0.12430978566408157,
-0.35393446683883667,
0.06823776662349701,
0.12288978695869446,
0.6031122207641602,
0.04199180379509926,
0.33670270442962646,
0.006896001752465963,
-0.12573234736919403,
-0.592958927154541,
0.27620160579681396,
0.2772095799446106,
0.5835307240486145,
-0.3248637616634369,
0.21221770346164703,
-0.03651440516114235,
-0.3669629693031311,
0.002019174164161086,
0.052804917097091675,
-0.0941331535577774,
0.09980510920286179,
0.6659125089645386,
0.7695772647857666,
-0.03824348747730255,
-0.3987106382846832,
0.686913788318634,
-0.04616975039243698,
0.3467174768447876,
-0.4516852796077728,
-0.11982674896717072,
0.2635611295700073,
0.5172011256217957,
0.6559280157089233,
0.2992289364337921,
-0.14363795518875122,
-0.4908185303211212,
0.1902889907360077,
0.46581733226776123,
-0.3274385333061218,
-0.4020639955997467,
0.7214165329933167,
-0.32780230045318604,
-0.6829262375831604,
0.5227554440498352,
-0.005589157808572054,
-0.663726270198822,
0.42141833901405334,
0.7232115864753723,
0.8387581706047058,
-0.272286981344223,
-0.06099967658519745,
0.24498280882835388,
0.5276111364364624,
0.12142529338598251,
0.33408215641975403,
0.00154964835382998,
-0.6216370463371277,
-0.8768242597579956,
-0.5853465795516968,
-0.2790206968784332,
0.37119749188423157,
-0.49139946699142456,
0.10384068638086319,
-0.09264873713254929,
-0.2143774777650833,
-0.09215431660413742,
-0.1265055239200592,
-0.7431937456130981,
0.06197338551282883,
0.11709246784448624,
0.7267757654190063,
-0.9555075168609619,
0.48052987456321716,
0.6290857195854187,
-0.32847753167152405,
-0.9668245911598206,
0.41343048214912415,
-0.06045468524098396,
-0.8224595189094543,
0.5968692302703857,
-0.09858549386262894,
-0.2385077178478241,
0.07239406555891037,
-0.4496959447860718,
-1.01313054561615,
0.7169275879859924,
0.3001772463321686,
-0.660993754863739,
-0.2544853091239929,
0.06013846397399902,
0.32740792632102966,
-0.163173645734787,
0.4628821015357971,
0.5033968687057495,
0.4465453624725342,
0.47500860691070557,
-1.007611632347107,
0.036482106894254684,
-0.15484799444675446,
-0.12298167496919632,
0.3033103942871094,
-0.6021906733512878,
1.1874496936798096,
-0.558134138584137,
-0.04407983273267746,
-0.09259860217571259,
0.3979329466819763,
0.17930756509304047,
0.3082348108291626,
0.7569817304611206,
0.6765317320823669,
0.6953343152999878,
-0.05972512066364288,
1.0438870191574097,
-0.0477692186832428,
0.45792174339294434,
1.2131068706512451,
0.08386275917291641,
0.8684258460998535,
0.5942292809486389,
-0.5933735966682434,
0.3287283480167389,
0.6502833962440491,
0.20507383346557617,
0.23990842700004578,
0.1867787092924118,
0.050423312932252884,
-0.19251909852027893,
0.3256024718284607,
-0.5647179484367371,
0.6335716247558594,
0.34524276852607727,
-0.2714310884475708,
-0.14471159875392914,
-0.03506520763039589,
0.12327150255441666,
-0.3147408962249756,
-0.17428123950958252,
0.7482131123542786,
0.2341035008430481,
-0.7022442817687988,
0.3933344781398773,
-0.037630848586559296,
0.3828410506248474,
-0.2977020740509033,
-0.029573554173111916,
-0.3769598603248596,
-0.11850294470787048,
-0.3622257113456726,
-1.0193842649459839,
0.46522197127342224,
0.010411752387881279,
-0.08874234557151794,
-0.0042856414802372456,
0.48884549736976624,
-0.306471586227417,
-0.5634967684745789,
0.6029059886932373,
0.9253584742546082,
0.35811328887939453,
-0.34310558438301086,
-0.4774162471294403,
0.22138172388076782,
-0.1617811769247055,
-0.3889410197734833,
-0.017666112631559372,
0.7464682459831238,
0.02794315293431282,
0.677536129951477,
0.8140138983726501,
0.4725155234336853,
0.4178633689880371,
0.13349109888076782,
1.1280230283737183,
-0.7842962145805359,
-0.7181251049041748,
-1.005253791809082,
0.5585859417915344,
0.2619565725326538,
0.010930961929261684,
0.5866316556930542,
0.5425536036491394,
0.7577614784240723,
0.11897294968366623,
0.5152354836463928,
0.21707677841186523,
0.6590480804443359,
-0.6924602389335632,
0.5036057829856873,
-0.8432531952857971,
0.8000666499137878,
-0.6055909395217896,
-0.9906872510910034,
-0.2623240351676941,
0.262924462556839,
-0.33658742904663086,
0.12706144154071808,
0.6763337850570679,
0.7212498188018799,
-0.19424033164978027,
-0.058088064193725586,
0.3976117968559265,
0.5836496353149414,
0.5271216630935669,
0.7585567235946655,
1.323333978652954,
-0.6155948638916016,
0.6769475340843201,
-0.17239293456077576,
-0.28244584798812866,
-0.11980431526899338,
-0.8982586860656738,
-0.679848313331604,
-0.5612049698829651,
-0.1422765552997589,
-0.597540020942688,
-0.1792859435081482,
0.6226654052734375,
0.6331861615180969,
-0.5826319456100464,
-0.06689503788948059,
0.12457506358623505,
0.28567975759506226,
-0.11465173214673996,
-0.15551719069480896,
0.45253947377204895,
-0.3181612491607666,
-0.4999978542327881,
0.7443957924842834,
0.33692675828933716,
0.08770702034235,
-0.43062910437583923,
0.11348665505647659,
-0.08444838970899582,
-0.12281685322523117,
0.45201635360717773,
0.11379677802324295,
-0.7382750511169434,
-0.10103099048137665,
0.15297481417655945,
0.15512783825397491,
0.3437337577342987,
1.0062553882598877,
-0.8845284581184387,
0.47748661041259766,
0.30160266160964966,
0.7506834268569946,
0.7870168089866638,
-0.18597641587257385,
0.2584570646286011,
-0.8024218082427979,
-0.11011990159749985,
0.45908159017562866,
0.2350679486989975,
0.2542351186275482,
-0.573101282119751,
0.29949718713760376,
0.41799095273017883,
-0.5767727494239807,
-0.7824236750602722,
0.5678961873054504,
-0.993532121181488,
-0.3095746338367462,
0.9334166049957275,
-0.19656087458133698,
-0.21951539814472198,
-0.23786568641662598,
-0.0437626987695694,
0.1367299109697342,
-0.06996545940637589,
0.6144620180130005,
0.4957837462425232,
-0.330440878868103,
-0.3302733302116394,
-0.5338893532752991,
0.22640812397003174,
0.16403870284557343,
-0.4611453711986542,
-0.09120166301727295,
0.3049371540546417,
0.2841944992542267,
0.44087061285972595,
0.8897116780281067,
-0.11356224864721298,
-0.12182435393333435,
0.07685583084821701,
-0.523095428943634,
-0.03346380963921547,
-0.5360878705978394,
-0.1823364496231079,
0.3729493319988251,
0.13663597404956818,
-0.22580939531326294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12770v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12770v2 | Informatics & dairy industry coalition: AI trends and present challenges | 2024-06-18T16:39:21 | 2024-06-19T11:49:03 | Silvia García-Méndez, Francisco de Arriba-Pérez, María del Carmen Somoza-López | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Artificial Intelligence (AI) can potentially transform the industry,
enhancing the production process and minimizing manual, repetitive tasks.
Accordingly, the synergy between high-performance computing and powerful
mathematical models enables the application of sophisticated data analysis
procedures like Machine Learning. However, challenges exist regarding
effective, efficient, and flexible processing to generate valuable knowledge.
Consequently, this work comprehensively describes industrial challenges where
AI can be exploited, focusing on the dairy industry. The conclusions presented
can help researchers apply novel approaches for cattle monitoring and farmers
by proposing advanced technological solutions to their needs. | [
-0.23905408382415771,
-0.6871712803840637,
0.2931371033191681,
-0.11003178358078003,
0.18515320122241974,
-0.04268837720155716,
0.29189416766166687,
-1.112196922302246,
-0.08747000247240067,
0.512590229511261,
-1.0424216985702515,
-0.3027247190475464,
-0.8397393226623535,
0.39900103211402893,
-0.6151318550109863,
0.7463874220848083,
-0.12511970102787018,
-0.014508439227938652,
-0.43941739201545715,
-0.3016562759876251,
-0.4025191068649292,
-0.6273468732833862,
-0.6295793652534485,
-0.20906153321266174,
0.29992032051086426,
0.4241679608821869,
0.6987566351890564,
0.6697181463241577,
0.8055184483528137,
0.5826348066329956,
0.3129459321498871,
0.10505165159702301,
-0.18006019294261932,
0.3445150852203369,
0.21566182374954224,
-0.515673816204071,
-0.2767915427684784,
0.3025714159011841,
0.2758404314517975,
1.1232444047927856,
0.07765389233827591,
0.35896727442741394,
-0.3274502754211426,
0.8660395741462708,
-0.6061209440231323,
0.6012398600578308,
-0.44022423028945923,
0.34824424982070923,
-0.3959135115146637,
-0.1129327118396759,
0.030540816485881805,
-0.5502504706382751,
0.18544740974903107,
-0.6069799661636353,
-0.03490270674228668,
0.07108472287654877,
0.661537230014801,
0.9055454134941101,
-0.34370896220207214,
-0.3956524431705475,
-0.8714759349822998,
0.7338700890541077,
-0.2755681872367859,
0.045663513243198395,
0.4003649652004242,
0.5018481016159058,
-0.3032514452934265,
-0.9438458681106567,
-0.3715938329696655,
0.10334295779466629,
0.15180669724941254,
0.05128360539674759,
-0.7027506232261658,
-0.3101922273635864,
0.15150198340415955,
0.2262158840894699,
-0.10703244060277939,
0.5253741145133972,
-0.5143037438392639,
-0.2732982039451599,
0.5875040888786316,
0.5310214757919312,
0.28534063696861267,
0.7392172813415527,
-0.13358847796916962,
-0.2952764630317688,
-0.34613335132598877,
0.4830910861492157,
0.7163888216018677,
-0.10852237790822983,
0.30723103880882263,
0.29787489771842957,
-0.6694045662879944,
0.525078535079956,
-0.11145047843456268,
0.18954207003116608,
0.3140276074409485,
-0.35252901911735535,
-0.17987066507339478,
0.056380487978458405,
0.5334529280662537,
0.20733371376991272,
-0.23275351524353027,
0.1727491170167923,
-0.15159495174884796,
0.5195105671882629,
0.14863979816436768,
-0.49830761551856995,
-0.24666617810726166,
0.46279507875442505,
-0.401843786239624,
-0.4687040150165558,
0.2195989340543747,
-0.6344004273414612,
-0.5347041487693787,
-0.18377329409122467,
0.13787387311458588,
-0.0654364749789238,
-0.2671021819114685,
0.1679215133190155,
-0.6290974020957947,
0.439433217048645,
0.37600061297416687,
-0.8106040954589844,
0.21085907518863678,
0.816716194152832,
0.4120979905128479,
-0.19003364443778992,
0.05689869821071625,
-0.6170387864112854,
0.29941150546073914,
-0.2588757574558258,
0.9280170202255249,
-0.5059163570404053,
-0.19091185927391052,
-0.20713846385478973,
0.11008657515048981,
-0.09732228517532349,
-1.074510097503662,
0.04848383367061615,
-0.387529581785202,
-0.15090665221214294,
-0.10235501825809479,
-0.19753344357013702,
-0.5533751845359802,
0.4650332033634186,
-0.9639739394187927,
0.7035917639732361,
0.32257917523384094,
-0.5347495079040527,
0.5408310890197754,
-0.8069790601730347,
-0.5917878746986389,
0.04881151020526886,
-0.14935986697673798,
-0.808660626411438,
-0.22412358224391937,
-0.06808711588382721,
0.22174383699893951,
-0.5042398571968079,
0.1464148759841919,
-0.44060590863227844,
0.20566050708293915,
0.7126740217208862,
-0.45930665731430054,
0.5164919495582581,
0.1757417470216751,
-0.3849087953567505,
0.47806084156036377,
-0.8350475430488586,
-0.1443108767271042,
-0.11732348799705505,
-0.006446022540330887,
0.19734333455562592,
0.020398272201418877,
-0.011842302046716213,
0.0013148103607818484,
0.25753772258758545,
-0.23902587592601776,
-0.11071635037660599,
-0.10039825737476349,
0.6145429611206055,
0.6242666244506836,
-0.013431884348392487,
0.05553542822599411,
-0.7554624080657959,
0.4058396518230438,
0.3313755691051483,
0.29929277300834656,
0.1649829000234604,
-0.4160318076610565,
-0.6253517270088196,
0.09189961105585098,
0.40558284521102905,
0.828143835067749,
-0.41480493545532227,
0.17032302916049957,
0.2591819167137146,
-0.512382984161377,
-0.7942025661468506,
-0.06306514143943787,
-0.22013936936855316,
0.7320248484611511,
0.1551111489534378,
-0.5743951201438904,
-0.5126757621765137,
-0.8459736108779907,
-0.00889040157198906,
-0.05443132296204567,
0.12321944534778595,
-0.05297259986400604,
0.30678287148475647,
-0.36968058347702026,
0.7087965607643127,
-0.363912433385849,
-0.27194806933403015,
-0.0850311666727066,
0.4346809387207031,
0.5551034212112427,
0.6133501529693604,
0.3948661684989929,
-1.1743844747543335,
-0.2847748100757599,
0.4170133173465729,
-1.1165800094604492,
-0.086864173412323,
0.26260122656822205,
0.26253557205200195,
0.3823942244052887,
0.42625692486763,
-0.5787526369094849,
0.8022463321685791,
0.07420231401920319,
-0.21492786705493927,
0.9144660830497742,
-0.07722832262516022,
0.36011645197868347,
-0.3244560956954956,
0.06010271981358528,
0.22050030529499054,
0.009969733655452728,
-0.68485426902771,
-0.5082218050956726,
-0.5860823392868042,
-0.19461655616760254,
-0.25925466418266296,
0.18248483538627625,
-0.1303597092628479,
-0.3070719540119171,
-0.3398095667362213,
-0.4430205821990967,
-0.23483598232269287,
0.0013889954425394535,
-0.023364657536149025,
0.5859794020652771,
0.7628157734870911,
-0.8247485160827637,
0.9528730511665344,
0.21203505992889404,
-0.39134612679481506,
0.6708804368972778,
-0.425631046295166,
-0.2038809061050415,
-0.12114690989255905,
0.20798321068286896,
-0.7028082609176636,
-0.5942383408546448,
0.6311527490615845,
-0.4512161612510681,
0.3407532870769501,
0.4507542550563812,
-0.4505963623523712,
-0.6164847016334534,
-0.2239127904176712,
0.27548059821128845,
0.4758642613887787,
0.0003406585310585797,
0.6632952094078064,
0.6206811666488647,
-0.2945803999900818,
-0.6168944239616394,
-0.7015761733055115,
0.027409972622990608,
-0.5513060092926025,
-0.6782341599464417,
0.14538632333278656,
-0.1506340056657791,
-0.771624743938446,
0.3001473844051361,
-0.2604517638683319,
-0.19966670870780945,
0.34067463874816895,
0.2128065824508667,
-0.07131126523017883,
-0.26320546865463257,
-0.029345974326133728,
0.11889814585447311,
-0.6379251480102539,
0.33975139260292053,
-0.47286829352378845,
0.14366962015628815,
0.04589565098285675,
-0.25133997201919556,
-1.3164803981781006,
0.6847602128982544,
0.6975076794624329,
-0.0617377795279026,
0.4447581171989441,
0.8969345092773438,
-0.4614449143409729,
0.022210458293557167,
-0.21132393181324005,
-0.22907963395118713,
-0.5908012390136719,
0.4344213008880615,
-0.27764269709587097,
-0.4356469511985779,
0.39669060707092285,
-0.7690980434417725,
-0.08426718413829803,
0.6474727392196655,
0.42148658633232117,
-0.4703690707683563,
1.1577669382095337,
0.8347449898719788,
-0.3414875566959381,
0.1056564599275589,
-0.37346988916397095,
0.10561151057481766,
-0.1010272428393364,
-0.5692919492721558,
-0.903369665145874,
-0.5659180879592896,
-0.6024337410926819,
0.21258988976478577,
0.6296695470809937,
-0.309335321187973,
-0.35709112882614136,
0.038796424865722656,
-0.6123949289321899,
0.008686983026564121,
0.9632523059844971,
-0.1346507966518402,
0.3315799832344055,
-0.2592853307723999,
0.543200671672821,
0.38024866580963135,
-0.8865128755569458,
-0.2718128263950348,
0.49954959750175476,
0.13074864447116852,
0.7368911504745483,
-0.0764118954539299,
0.13711804151535034,
0.7085581421852112,
0.15157319605350494,
-0.771289050579071,
0.15878689289093018,
-0.025679076090455055,
-0.2580597400665283,
-0.3561621308326721,
-0.23586544394493103,
-1.1390399932861328,
-0.46963030099868774,
-0.22939105331897736,
-0.7481436133384705,
0.19107164442539215,
0.0017233367543667555,
0.02029275707900524,
0.3401847183704376,
-0.7692186832427979,
0.7904167175292969,
-0.3179791569709778,
-0.23289357125759125,
-0.09248121082782745,
-0.7016065716743469,
-0.22684746980667114,
-0.0808764398097992,
0.49374842643737793,
-0.4175628125667572,
0.006410161964595318,
0.7865535616874695,
-0.6519330739974976,
1.2310197353363037,
0.0600319504737854,
0.19066239893436432,
0.605423629283905,
-0.15776197612285614,
0.22882325947284698,
-0.11336532980203629,
-0.38877755403518677,
0.214743971824646,
0.185957670211792,
-0.39346960186958313,
-0.25697943568229675,
0.3114965260028839,
-0.8669774532318115,
-0.7775833606719971,
-0.7463159561157227,
-0.7263060212135315,
-0.37749820947647095,
0.024386674165725708,
0.1562352031469345,
0.04921555146574974,
0.023978540673851967,
0.11013230681419373,
0.2707866430282593,
0.14774788916110992,
0.5792287588119507,
0.11520188301801682,
0.4476349353790283,
-0.29761362075805664,
0.8409065008163452,
0.3216879367828369,
-0.2961057722568512,
0.15494711697101593,
0.06051081791520119,
-0.24567723274230957,
-0.690619707107544,
-0.5370789170265198,
-0.29748496413230896,
-0.6167164444923401,
-0.5214282274246216,
-0.4547485113143921,
-0.20723609626293182,
-0.30289599299430847,
-0.015206649899482727,
-0.1149074137210846,
-0.4011465907096863,
-0.6830610036849976,
-0.12188535928726196,
0.3391299843788147,
1.0771937370300293,
-0.22621645033359528,
0.3433593809604645,
-0.5273640155792236,
0.10717625170946121,
0.4023292362689972,
0.3435700535774231,
-0.16458897292613983,
0.49564915895462036,
-0.09994039684534073,
0.05317211151123047,
-0.6086512207984924,
-0.8010357022285461,
0.26797574758529663,
-0.0751916691660881,
0.6386955976486206,
0.5032083988189697,
0.12303906679153442,
0.25278910994529724,
-0.020893480628728867,
0.6014189124107361,
0.26406732201576233,
-0.738480806350708,
0.5769200325012207,
-0.19761528074741364,
0.23651082813739777,
0.3208386301994324,
0.6959642767906189,
-0.2264927327632904,
-0.01402969565242529,
-0.49711233377456665,
-0.8912703990936279,
0.6126706600189209,
0.06720399111509323,
-0.27307721972465515,
0.24945658445358276,
0.23754189908504486,
0.7217506766319275,
0.3544255793094635,
-0.26228100061416626,
-0.1953776478767395,
0.09362661093473434,
-0.3615376055240631,
0.4364415109157562,
0.3281862437725067,
-0.23809394240379333,
-0.47967690229415894,
0.7595207691192627,
-0.07242351770401001,
0.12436280399560928,
-0.0828852504491806,
0.10928293317556381,
-0.4445115923881531,
-0.061377618461847305,
0.09806477278470993,
0.8368322849273682,
0.1296328753232956,
-0.11557340621948242,
0.15727326273918152,
-0.18057946860790253,
0.10785162448883057,
0.3450624942779541,
-0.20470446348190308,
-0.3294198513031006,
0.3417920768260956,
0.7776823043823242,
-0.42436012625694275,
-0.6633346080780029,
-0.012396244332194328,
0.14349380135536194,
-0.48775798082351685,
-0.5445346236228943,
0.49299871921539307,
-0.13766077160835266,
0.7383745908737183,
0.7166982889175415,
0.38029125332832336,
0.16321925818920135,
-0.69302898645401,
0.2087327241897583,
0.3067488372325897,
-0.7286593914031982,
-0.18424507975578308,
0.7412997484207153,
-0.06413552165031433,
-0.36025744676589966,
0.6742897629737854,
0.1561536192893982,
-0.37048983573913574,
1.3932796716690063,
0.6432356834411621,
0.254564493894577,
-0.13212256133556366,
0.18167859315872192,
-0.20328935980796814,
0.023850807920098305,
0.2215205878019333,
0.18076783418655396,
0.2337038666009903,
-0.6272339224815369,
-0.10454676300287247,
-0.409417986869812,
-0.8206843137741089,
0.08084841817617416,
-0.38639357686042786,
0.2448405623435974,
-0.2422260195016861,
-0.3343358337879181,
0.6573681235313416,
-0.07342179119586945,
-0.8304082751274109,
0.38867804408073425,
0.072847381234169,
0.6043561697006226,
-0.502175509929657,
0.5286247730255127,
0.8325029611587524,
-0.26504385471343994,
-0.22866947948932648,
-0.4404192566871643,
-0.0030264502856880426,
-0.7140617966651917,
0.49129509925842285,
0.468987375497818,
-0.23515267670154572,
-0.02416089177131653,
-0.856889009475708,
-0.682636022567749,
1.0719852447509766,
-0.0069829924032092094,
-0.15013602375984192,
0.5212100148200989,
0.45902112126350403,
0.35652703046798706,
-0.5984338521957397,
0.11470556259155273,
0.8078399896621704,
0.9967007637023926,
0.07904303818941116,
-0.696353554725647,
-0.4017125368118286,
-0.3984086513519287,
-0.43806228041648865,
0.2078903764486313,
-0.769907534122467,
0.7191712856292725,
-0.006002369336783886,
-0.13378189504146576,
0.03224537521600723,
0.8285117149353027,
-0.0795607715845108,
1.1211390495300293,
0.5038268566131592,
0.3813062608242035,
1.0417258739471436,
-0.272847980260849,
0.7240611910820007,
-0.1065690740942955,
-0.1094437912106514,
0.28611165285110474,
-0.41501009464263916,
0.3221866190433502,
0.40309232473373413,
-0.35631808638572693,
0.5854873657226562,
0.9042473435401917,
-0.26305505633354187,
0.34895631670951843,
0.24435825645923615,
-0.41324570775032043,
-0.13187438249588013,
-0.5802415013313293,
-0.492594450712204,
0.8676470518112183,
0.9552257657051086,
0.16262096166610718,
0.04029988497495651,
0.3507864475250244,
-0.17781473696231842,
0.23034243285655975,
-0.6607381701469421,
1.0546257495880127,
-0.1967703253030777,
-0.4058879613876343,
-0.05310099944472313,
0.0441427081823349,
0.4779447615146637,
-0.6649265885353088,
-0.29329606890678406,
0.21394358575344086,
0.19119103252887726,
-0.1077839732170105,
-0.553435742855072,
0.8076998591423035,
-0.20116330683231354,
-0.184274360537529,
-0.1608520746231079,
0.873374879360199,
-0.0937085822224617,
-0.44958555698394775,
0.05988799035549164,
0.6685895919799805,
0.12582577764987946,
0.09284534305334091,
-0.5312214493751526,
0.26220351457595825,
-0.1984703689813614,
0.26751989126205444,
0.2079363912343979,
0.5651151537895203,
-0.2589415907859802,
0.8715730905532837,
0.5442729592323303,
-0.2969774901866913,
-0.07256543636322021,
-0.5408717393875122,
1.0375518798828125,
-0.8677910566329956,
-0.5143221616744995,
-0.5491527915000916,
0.18159399926662445,
-0.22699326276779175,
-0.21436342597007751,
-0.009902513585984707,
0.37054964900016785,
0.8975372314453125,
-0.1560642123222351,
1.2888792753219604,
-0.24028976261615753,
0.013856732286512852,
-0.3315226435661316,
0.6642345190048218,
-0.31743869185447693,
-0.07708166539669037,
0.3006337583065033,
-0.4715964198112488,
-0.35934922099113464,
0.2032226324081421,
-0.3373356759548187,
-0.04403034970164299,
0.5582497715950012,
0.23291654884815216,
0.04186740145087242,
0.5573509335517883,
0.04841766133904457,
0.2466498613357544,
0.010297456756234169,
0.4519672691822052,
0.9101737141609192,
-0.27529171109199524,
0.5077463984489441,
-0.5547866821289062,
-0.33045846223831177,
-0.28219255805015564,
-0.7525295615196228,
-0.25069132447242737,
-0.5342795252799988,
-0.6783812046051025,
-0.08850527554750443,
0.05910827964544296,
0.5607893466949463,
0.6839269399642944,
-1.1895712614059448,
-0.47330066561698914,
0.11564257740974426,
0.3074687421321869,
-0.8259513974189758,
-0.1822396218776703,
0.38710883259773254,
-0.3980717658996582,
-0.8316406607627869,
0.2916637063026428,
0.5040308833122253,
0.07369546592235565,
-0.041550543159246445,
0.2246028631925583,
-0.2394123673439026,
-0.19123579561710358,
0.3219514787197113,
0.4911918640136719,
-0.09564060717821121,
-0.24198848009109497,
-0.023256178945302963,
0.20416057109832764,
0.22336168587207794,
0.6105520129203796,
-0.8646467328071594,
0.20723578333854675,
0.3689573407173157,
1.0247682332992554,
0.6696409583091736,
-0.051204148679971695,
0.5519160032272339,
-0.24697214365005493,
0.27930450439453125,
0.3383623957633972,
0.13808026909828186,
0.328498899936676,
-0.6936731338500977,
0.6273967027664185,
0.6819714903831482,
-0.3878366947174072,
-0.36271992325782776,
0.4461682140827179,
-0.9055706858634949,
-0.36311575770378113,
0.32531118392944336,
0.08653989434242249,
-0.7328823208808899,
-0.4101041257381439,
0.13017967343330383,
0.5935717821121216,
-0.17903685569763184,
0.6913866996765137,
0.5723204016685486,
-0.7733859419822693,
0.11698231101036072,
-0.7988335490226746,
0.3711724579334259,
0.25094467401504517,
-1.0603017807006836,
-0.43831756711006165,
0.4016793668270111,
0.10372603684663773,
-0.07622269541025162,
0.3348639905452728,
0.03894650563597679,
0.20312775671482086,
0.34437093138694763,
-0.26876041293144226,
-0.1688888669013977,
-0.5201622247695923,
0.04055037721991539,
0.5528751015663147,
-0.18062014877796173,
-0.24915355443954468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12754v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12754v1 | Chumor 1.0: A Truly Funny and Challenging Chinese Humor Understanding Dataset from Ruo Zhi Ba | 2024-06-18T16:22:05 | 2024-06-18T16:22:05 | Ruiqi He, Yushu He, Longju Bai, Jiarui Liu, Zhenjie Sun, Zenghao Tang, He Wang, Hanchen Xia, Naihao Deng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing humor datasets and evaluations predominantly focus on English,
lacking resources for culturally nuanced humor in non-English languages like
Chinese. To address this gap, we construct Chumor, a dataset sourced from Ruo
Zhi Ba (RZB), a Chinese Reddit-like platform dedicated to sharing
intellectually challenging and culturally specific jokes. We annotate
explanations for each joke and evaluate human explanations against two
state-of-the-art LLMs, GPT-4o and ERNIE Bot, through A/B testing by native
Chinese speakers. Our evaluation shows that Chumor is challenging even for SOTA
LLMs, and the human explanations for Chumor jokes are significantly better than
explanations generated by the LLMs. | [
-0.0027442071586847305,
-0.7110547423362732,
0.18045340478420258,
0.5308887362480164,
-0.7412745356559753,
-0.2259383350610733,
-0.16949109733104706,
-0.3617398142814636,
0.13309131562709808,
0.3590417504310608,
-0.8902886509895325,
-0.0849270150065422,
-0.17980720102787018,
0.19163581728935242,
0.026669688522815704,
1.2469416856765747,
0.37818390130996704,
0.39122772216796875,
-0.20271684229373932,
-0.07605233788490295,
-0.6752272248268127,
-0.177604079246521,
-0.4419057369232178,
-0.7399967908859253,
1.0063039064407349,
0.6793917417526245,
0.6841912865638733,
0.5626146793365479,
0.9167316555976868,
0.16304023563861847,
0.18175022304058075,
-0.039504121989011765,
-0.5990996360778809,
-0.17937077581882477,
-0.2238512486219406,
-0.46088656783103943,
-0.18242616951465607,
-0.5097371339797974,
0.09403283894062042,
0.627152681350708,
-0.3825884759426117,
-0.04017965868115425,
-0.2775307595729828,
0.8179622292518616,
-0.17939892411231995,
-0.05365907773375511,
-0.553723931312561,
0.29405269026756287,
-0.21576343476772308,
-0.3116631805896759,
-0.22136247158050537,
-0.609004557132721,
-0.0006853725644759834,
-0.6262383460998535,
0.061713963747024536,
-0.3279886841773987,
0.9846062064170837,
0.31947067379951477,
-0.4825056791305542,
-0.40557020902633667,
-0.5895203351974487,
0.8213112354278564,
-0.5187843441963196,
0.19455386698246002,
0.08563966304063797,
0.6670789122581482,
-0.20268477499485016,
-0.5590474009513855,
-0.6202087998390198,
0.017309168353676796,
-0.07231844216585159,
0.1998472809791565,
0.06785236299037933,
-0.4325058162212372,
-0.16472473740577698,
0.4735007584095001,
-0.9503958225250244,
-0.13285145163536072,
-0.5552203059196472,
-0.12318911403417587,
0.8942811489105225,
0.30586662888526917,
0.26062989234924316,
-0.3738008141517639,
-0.487903356552124,
0.05015459656715393,
-0.4464828372001648,
-0.07014238089323044,
0.3362102806568146,
0.045920807868242264,
-0.2934815287590027,
0.2098640352487564,
0.1629425287246704,
0.5878048539161682,
-0.21262295544147491,
-0.25170302391052246,
0.33230283856391907,
-0.12222397327423096,
-0.3151804208755493,
-0.06542491167783737,
1.032025694847107,
0.43902263045310974,
0.7745086550712585,
-0.018480919301509857,
-0.02577405795454979,
-0.22833731770515442,
-0.08134405314922333,
-0.36218878626823425,
-0.5767704248428345,
0.17513038218021393,
-0.494156152009964,
-0.3473440110683441,
0.36854085326194763,
-0.5314222574234009,
-0.5564128756523132,
0.3266735076904297,
0.3343448340892792,
-0.5463129878044128,
-0.07952013611793518,
0.35721418261528015,
-0.39502233266830444,
0.5772246718406677,
0.4463455080986023,
-0.5008949637413025,
-0.22735902667045593,
0.6578221917152405,
0.584293007850647,
0.26122626662254333,
-0.13736549019813538,
-0.46406662464141846,
-0.020342744886875153,
-0.31825950741767883,
0.805436909198761,
-0.44750478863716125,
-0.2911919057369232,
-0.1409289389848709,
0.16401246190071106,
0.13480962812900543,
-0.5951138138771057,
0.8575042486190796,
-0.4621039927005768,
0.26729267835617065,
-0.37889933586120605,
-0.1694072037935257,
-0.3375411629676819,
0.18752934038639069,
-0.41893866658210754,
0.7035714983940125,
0.29881659150123596,
-0.8347919583320618,
0.2471320778131485,
-0.8244427442550659,
-0.8334375023841858,
0.564413845539093,
-0.003080926137045026,
0.05358462780714035,
-0.04653311148285866,
0.059671323746442795,
0.14277657866477966,
-0.2863386869430542,
0.1890348345041275,
-0.012123788706958294,
-0.6202767491340637,
0.5892652273178101,
-0.30805450677871704,
1.2077796459197998,
0.7855781316757202,
-0.04886401444673538,
-0.25413569808006287,
-0.5314201712608337,
0.11102545261383057,
0.642708957195282,
-0.22841130197048187,
-0.3415703773498535,
0.18878276646137238,
-0.07047691196203232,
0.2696496844291687,
0.36958959698677063,
-0.3608282506465912,
0.00606771232560277,
-0.26183533668518066,
0.7985882759094238,
0.593272864818573,
-0.16853953897953033,
-0.250605970621109,
-0.48827382922172546,
0.6689662337303162,
0.19267645478248596,
0.23111125826835632,
-0.7310540676116943,
-0.4183683395385742,
-0.8346225023269653,
-0.3080337643623352,
0.06944066286087036,
0.9582486152648926,
-0.5753982067108154,
0.4432539641857147,
-0.5540969371795654,
-0.5723090171813965,
-0.6337655782699585,
0.3449520766735077,
0.27908411622047424,
0.5285112261772156,
0.17730744183063507,
-0.5044614672660828,
-0.3094058632850647,
-0.8891229033470154,
-0.41022640466690063,
-0.19730833172798157,
-0.5067787170410156,
0.4078420400619507,
0.47757959365844727,
0.01299261674284935,
0.6793123483657837,
-0.1028849333524704,
-0.21824833750724792,
-0.5269469022750854,
0.02659527026116848,
0.33263063430786133,
0.2168862372636795,
0.43895700573921204,
-0.7650574445724487,
-0.5712358951568604,
0.42237308621406555,
-0.8908869624137878,
-0.24290524423122406,
-0.232002392411232,
0.28457313776016235,
0.21561698615550995,
-0.0527457557618618,
-0.3192743957042694,
0.14667098224163055,
0.520546019077301,
-0.19281063973903656,
0.38285788893699646,
-0.20933043956756592,
0.20382127165794373,
-0.6381181478500366,
-0.1804659515619278,
-0.1500404328107834,
-0.29958784580230713,
-0.47197943925857544,
0.19415956735610962,
-0.016730671748518944,
0.0642293393611908,
-0.6878025531768799,
0.6231437921524048,
-0.24660751223564148,
0.057242441922426224,
0.08315318077802658,
0.2697356939315796,
0.14623236656188965,
0.07847540825605392,
-0.32116836309432983,
0.5199995636940002,
0.4288857877254486,
-0.5468514561653137,
0.6343929171562195,
0.3156774044036865,
-0.4374936819076538,
0.30650633573532104,
-0.8166890144348145,
0.41976678371429443,
-0.17045791447162628,
0.27455031871795654,
-1.0255529880523682,
-0.542891263961792,
0.531972348690033,
-0.632955014705658,
-0.018619757145643234,
-0.18492838740348816,
-0.4200132191181183,
-0.4406810402870178,
-0.41734638810157776,
0.2534227967262268,
0.6820417642593384,
-0.6331812143325806,
0.2382676750421524,
0.1373034566640854,
-0.1954999715089798,
-0.7951809167861938,
-1.1115832328796387,
0.24291808903217316,
-0.5014334917068481,
-1.0113246440887451,
-0.08170438557863235,
-0.2239203006029129,
-0.37493789196014404,
-0.1561819612979889,
-0.07599008828401566,
-0.07732564955949783,
0.04756641760468483,
-0.11409240961074829,
0.02983982488512993,
-0.34857091307640076,
-0.07181981205940247,
-0.41325896978378296,
0.06468061357736588,
0.22677987813949585,
0.11454426497220993,
0.4857383668422699,
-0.039460476487874985,
-0.39733150601387024,
-0.5096698999404907,
0.036613404750823975,
0.21135389804840088,
0.04325481876730919,
0.4867742955684662,
0.37557774782180786,
-0.11595411598682404,
-0.07913337647914886,
-0.4361216425895691,
0.05176186561584473,
-0.4675945043563843,
0.2385551780462265,
-0.4572799801826477,
-0.7587880492210388,
0.7197441458702087,
0.4359419047832489,
-0.0011524450965225697,
0.1552984118461609,
0.4936372935771942,
-0.19936783611774445,
0.767507791519165,
0.3588712811470032,
-0.025072872638702393,
0.2747841775417328,
0.23508526384830475,
0.38994500041007996,
-0.19040817022323608,
-0.41688114404678345,
-0.39873525500297546,
-0.4444044828414917,
-0.6365301609039307,
-0.7251202464103699,
-0.002113587688654661,
-0.19909831881523132,
-0.18825368583202362,
0.07012441009283066,
-0.20883430540561676,
0.8297703862190247,
0.36612099409103394,
0.03825978934764862,
0.44148820638656616,
0.131971076130867,
0.19885209202766418,
-0.15468427538871765,
-0.9075977802276611,
-0.4939267337322235,
0.4140855669975281,
0.4559890627861023,
1.207544207572937,
0.04413611814379692,
0.38634711503982544,
0.3042047321796417,
0.26637235283851624,
-0.8751504421234131,
0.5468843579292297,
-0.5187168121337891,
-0.6533048748970032,
-0.04209832474589348,
-0.7850189208984375,
-0.8704875111579895,
0.027817044407129288,
0.1684432476758957,
-0.5441709756851196,
-0.2818155586719513,
0.04842882230877876,
-0.07245054841041565,
0.1459706574678421,
-0.7130981087684631,
0.7812737226486206,
-0.5723339319229126,
-0.3673655390739441,
0.06348040699958801,
-1.039152979850769,
0.5522406101226807,
0.09330353885889053,
0.654096245765686,
0.024347256869077682,
0.11186498403549194,
0.40544116497039795,
-0.20495685935020447,
0.3935798704624176,
-0.08892195671796799,
-0.21375884115695953,
0.46118035912513733,
0.3597031533718109,
0.05189872905611992,
0.19766446948051453,
-0.35320591926574707,
0.6569814682006836,
-0.3516167104244232,
-0.6511660218238831,
-0.5727264285087585,
0.7129775285720825,
-0.48765960335731506,
-0.524235725402832,
-0.4204690456390381,
-0.8338198661804199,
0.3884587585926056,
-0.03274376690387726,
0.29149773716926575,
-0.013826819136738777,
-0.07930479943752289,
0.526950478553772,
0.352877676486969,
-0.5456850528717041,
0.001100819674320519,
0.3557107150554657,
0.023981761187314987,
-0.256088525056839,
0.8262359499931335,
-0.021288983523845673,
0.048747718334198,
0.35458579659461975,
0.4389905333518982,
-0.12843526899814606,
-0.07039546221494675,
-0.3782433569431305,
0.38874319195747375,
-0.9086953997612,
-0.004375445656478405,
-0.5787426233291626,
-0.4380892813205719,
-0.24509084224700928,
-0.4284888207912445,
-0.04673455283045769,
-0.48919036984443665,
0.17817331850528717,
0.08361449092626572,
0.28689509630203247,
0.6556488275527954,
-0.3350582420825958,
0.27414554357528687,
-1.0282986164093018,
0.22697259485721588,
0.27091461420059204,
0.2318204790353775,
-0.2436266392469406,
-0.9032633900642395,
-0.17314046621322632,
0.1767989695072174,
-0.28696534037590027,
-0.8356648683547974,
0.4161015450954437,
0.4002106189727783,
0.438441663980484,
0.9030892252922058,
0.03227771818637848,
0.9314852952957153,
-0.4702089726924896,
1.034317135810852,
0.044620268046855927,
-0.6072721481323242,
0.7208784818649292,
-0.5435483455657959,
0.09444142132997513,
0.24508167803287506,
0.36458536982536316,
-0.7795891165733337,
-0.20978738367557526,
-0.4240299463272095,
-0.7417269349098206,
0.8124930262565613,
0.09752731770277023,
0.744767427444458,
-0.308496356010437,
0.592778205871582,
0.5493903756141663,
-0.01041815709322691,
-1.102990984916687,
-0.4252133369445801,
-0.48831960558891296,
-0.2917778491973877,
0.1056516245007515,
-0.1342356950044632,
-0.22248056530952454,
-0.1090002954006195,
0.5318850874900818,
0.07032353430986404,
0.06741596758365631,
0.2594112157821655,
-0.1766277402639389,
-0.46258488297462463,
0.31449246406555176,
0.5960866808891296,
0.951578676700592,
-0.3091597855091095,
0.03899360075592995,
0.17630106210708618,
-0.5020347833633423,
-0.2738126516342163,
-0.10675694793462753,
-0.08574581146240234,
0.12339436262845993,
0.5847148299217224,
0.6577167510986328,
-0.13690036535263062,
-1.199260950088501,
0.3696339726448059,
-0.2871328890323639,
-0.2556680142879486,
-0.43206873536109924,
0.44391658902168274,
0.12459199875593185,
0.0011395615292713046,
0.6722022891044617,
-0.5152602195739746,
-0.03226478770375252,
-0.8181639313697815,
0.14741970598697662,
0.3587389588356018,
-0.6589107513427734,
-0.44743403792381287,
0.677802562713623,
0.30336788296699524,
-0.5694934129714966,
0.6284760236740112,
-0.2591398358345032,
-0.7087936997413635,
0.835805356502533,
0.6288213729858398,
0.5741385817527771,
-0.1453467309474945,
0.33735764026641846,
0.43103262782096863,
0.6361144185066223,
0.1213729977607727,
0.44398435950279236,
0.2451954036951065,
-0.6825534701347351,
-0.3954121172428131,
-0.28470906615257263,
-0.5073729157447815,
0.4468066692352295,
-0.45917025208473206,
0.7499989867210388,
-0.424417108297348,
0.5066525936126709,
-0.25106367468833923,
-0.06387113034725189,
-0.4799777865409851,
0.32756927609443665,
0.08118454366922379,
1.0247299671173096,
-0.6606341004371643,
0.5781888365745544,
1.0512068271636963,
-0.260438472032547,
-0.4529980421066284,
0.21550299227237701,
0.08409660309553146,
-1.026821255683899,
0.7086318135261536,
0.25688645243644714,
-0.08577054738998413,
-0.1546231210231781,
-0.6338793635368347,
-0.06731105595827103,
1.0610229969024658,
0.4287485182285309,
-0.5002971887588501,
0.4120929539203644,
0.11062757670879364,
0.6007925868034363,
-0.38097578287124634,
0.4896721839904785,
0.3068482279777527,
0.5887691378593445,
0.26471269130706787,
-0.6747691035270691,
-0.20950345695018768,
-0.24125199019908905,
-0.40382009744644165,
0.03450074791908264,
-1.0073317289352417,
0.9122891426086426,
-0.6259235143661499,
-0.2723429501056671,
-0.04779459163546562,
0.6068289875984192,
0.586054265499115,
0.774575412273407,
0.7865544557571411,
0.41777464747428894,
0.5283923149108887,
-0.08440178632736206,
1.127960205078125,
-0.1200350672006607,
0.3238397240638733,
1.0541094541549683,
-0.466310977935791,
0.2623179852962494,
0.553366482257843,
-0.25643303990364075,
0.8562070727348328,
0.6819954514503479,
-0.04286148399114609,
0.3596560060977936,
0.3453134596347809,
-0.039042264223098755,
-0.34836193919181824,
-0.21677181124687195,
-0.422320157289505,
0.46550503373146057,
0.06228996813297272,
0.0608254000544548,
-0.2455996572971344,
-0.2941853106021881,
0.19543197751045227,
0.15154694020748138,
0.007336541078984737,
0.4748769700527191,
0.22338446974754333,
-0.37074369192123413,
0.31675103306770325,
-0.1286831498146057,
0.7231524586677551,
-0.8088981509208679,
-0.13546283543109894,
-0.7464682459831238,
0.04842786863446236,
-0.36210891604423523,
-0.8062418699264526,
0.2601385712623596,
0.3135838806629181,
0.22227823734283447,
0.250797301530838,
0.7904291152954102,
-0.2161576896905899,
-0.5119233131408691,
0.4307042956352234,
0.4857487082481384,
0.6292645931243896,
0.25584161281585693,
-0.7634976506233215,
-0.12148328870534897,
0.008477830328047276,
-0.42295610904693604,
0.21273313462734222,
1.0885289907455444,
-0.13213028013706207,
1.1586413383483887,
0.6161413192749023,
-0.02601468190550804,
-0.02745172567665577,
0.229723259806633,
0.6593967080116272,
-0.9990754127502441,
-0.5109006762504578,
-0.8795422315597534,
0.6276518106460571,
0.07421688735485077,
-0.1589362919330597,
0.6685271859169006,
0.4329354166984558,
0.8629116415977478,
-0.3422236442565918,
0.9564407467842102,
-0.5072086453437805,
0.41473302245140076,
-0.30549192428588867,
0.8107088208198547,
-1.1686955690383911,
0.39701443910598755,
0.032048195600509644,
-0.7220149636268616,
-0.33266592025756836,
1.177127480506897,
0.15223328769207,
0.25851884484291077,
0.6695003509521484,
0.7240077257156372,
-0.1897142231464386,
-0.18535079061985016,
0.4885377883911133,
0.3053065240383148,
0.13136716187000275,
0.8775085806846619,
1.054871678352356,
-0.5361595153808594,
1.099893569946289,
-0.4980117082595825,
0.005823126528412104,
-0.3544667959213257,
-1.2282838821411133,
-0.9274252653121948,
-0.18960805237293243,
-0.28226804733276367,
-0.16712935268878937,
-0.036022353917360306,
0.9153711199760437,
0.46708887815475464,
-0.655877411365509,
-0.20358088612556458,
0.21521057188510895,
0.4716005325317383,
-0.17872633039951324,
-0.41240382194519043,
-0.10629621893167496,
-0.16912409663200378,
-0.6642230749130249,
0.40471145510673523,
0.22613579034805298,
-0.48653191328048706,
-0.12968118488788605,
-0.3622104525566101,
-0.006889392621815205,
0.35667112469673157,
0.387304425239563,
0.2936960458755493,
-0.7314183115959167,
-0.6658704280853271,
0.2505252957344055,
-0.03599817305803299,
0.2179669588804245,
0.6559468507766724,
-0.5390999913215637,
0.2909742295742035,
0.7525361776351929,
0.5280990600585938,
-0.08250951766967773,
0.1336154043674469,
0.239304319024086,
-0.5777736902236938,
0.18078584969043732,
0.16077114641666412,
0.15909862518310547,
0.7198570966720581,
-0.45183470845222473,
0.9590348601341248,
0.3443925678730011,
-0.6346835494041443,
-0.9362199902534485,
0.18157534301280975,
-1.299707055091858,
-0.27346763014793396,
0.9554176330566406,
-0.370687335729599,
-0.4182223379611969,
-0.2674752473831177,
-0.10411673784255981,
0.24634893238544464,
-0.10720743983983994,
1.1139264106750488,
0.9318544864654541,
-0.2566279470920563,
-0.5177261829376221,
-0.8540134429931641,
-0.134384885430336,
0.5206429958343506,
-0.72239089012146,
0.09566750377416611,
0.3437231183052063,
0.6333705186843872,
-0.05521479621529579,
0.8505910634994507,
-0.2561223804950714,
0.601078987121582,
-0.3043149709701538,
0.2662840485572815,
-0.1371900588274002,
-0.16414035856723785,
-0.41255953907966614,
-0.2624678611755371,
-0.1655362993478775,
0.06095907464623451
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12753v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12753v1 | OlympicArena: Benchmarking Multi-discipline Cognitive Reasoning for Superintelligent AI | 2024-06-18T16:20:53 | 2024-06-18T16:20:53 | Zhen Huang, Zengzhi Wang, Shijie Xia, Xuefeng Li, Haoyang Zou, Ruijie Xu, Run-Ze Fan, Lyumanshan Ye, Ethan Chern, Yixin Ye, Yikai Zhang, Yuqing Yang, Ting Wu, Binjie Wang, Shichao Sun, Yang Xiao, Yiyuan Li, Fan Zhou, Steffi Chern, Yiwei Qin, Yan Ma, Jiadi Su, Yixiu Liu, Yuxiang Zheng, Shaoting Zhang, Dahua Lin, Yu Qiao, Pengfei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The evolution of Artificial Intelligence (AI) has been significantly
accelerated by advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) and Large
Multimodal Models (LMMs), gradually showcasing potential cognitive reasoning
abilities in problem-solving and scientific discovery (i.e., AI4Science) once
exclusive to human intellect. To comprehensively evaluate current models'
performance in cognitive reasoning abilities, we introduce OlympicArena, which
includes 11,163 bilingual problems across both text-only and interleaved
text-image modalities. These challenges encompass a wide range of disciplines
spanning seven fields and 62 international Olympic competitions, rigorously
examined for data leakage. We argue that the challenges in Olympic competition
problems are ideal for evaluating AI's cognitive reasoning due to their
complexity and interdisciplinary nature, which are essential for tackling
complex scientific challenges and facilitating discoveries. Beyond evaluating
performance across various disciplines using answer-only criteria, we conduct
detailed experiments and analyses from multiple perspectives. We delve into the
models' cognitive reasoning abilities, their performance across different
modalities, and their outcomes in process-level evaluations, which are vital
for tasks requiring complex reasoning with lengthy solutions. Our extensive
evaluations reveal that even advanced models like GPT-4o only achieve a 39.97%
overall accuracy, illustrating current AI limitations in complex reasoning and
multimodal integration. Through the OlympicArena, we aim to advance AI towards
superintelligence, equipping it to address more complex challenges in science
and beyond. We also provide a comprehensive set of resources to support AI
research, including a benchmark dataset, an open-source annotation platform, a
detailed evaluation tool, and a leaderboard with automatic submission features. | [
-0.5549191832542419,
-0.574379026889801,
0.9837358593940735,
0.16287390887737274,
0.04277290776371956,
0.05802113562822342,
-0.31955158710479736,
-0.8100682497024536,
-0.27952903509140015,
0.2126730978488922,
-0.6063628792762756,
-0.31382787227630615,
-0.7827491164207458,
0.3136719763278961,
-0.2569103538990021,
0.7806040644645691,
-0.14694125950336456,
0.3227481544017792,
-0.6133569478988647,
-0.49736201763153076,
-0.5947933793067932,
-0.39559537172317505,
-0.5261163115501404,
-0.5437628030776978,
0.21886947751045227,
0.42015373706817627,
0.37123310565948486,
0.49497154355049133,
0.6040962934494019,
0.3862711191177368,
0.14802539348602295,
0.5406990647315979,
-0.09045077860355377,
0.1939026266336441,
-0.5373650789260864,
-0.7929040789604187,
-0.28576424717903137,
0.016892248764634132,
0.199140727519989,
0.3401760756969452,
0.10046212375164032,
0.2625328600406647,
-0.3127671480178833,
0.35951918363571167,
-0.5298953652381897,
0.5318306684494019,
-0.5940638780593872,
-0.09100871533155441,
-0.35320794582366943,
-0.012654608115553856,
-0.03781207278370857,
-0.10592972487211227,
0.03603195771574974,
-0.8746610879898071,
-0.07736638188362122,
0.3022123873233795,
0.5158331394195557,
0.578725278377533,
-0.21240249276161194,
-0.22077259421348572,
-0.7046808004379272,
0.861045241355896,
-0.46897509694099426,
0.317870557308197,
0.4312506318092346,
0.366899698972702,
0.067291758954525,
-0.5704694986343384,
-0.7314181327819824,
-0.5085940361022949,
0.7713936567306519,
0.5088701844215393,
-0.20834122598171234,
-0.3439696431159973,
0.07492193579673767,
-0.08215760439634323,
-0.6462191939353943,
0.12298878282308578,
-0.5327556729316711,
0.10270924121141434,
1.01539945602417,
0.3420056998729706,
0.37573209404945374,
0.320015549659729,
0.08168026059865952,
-0.0047716121189296246,
-0.3908986747264862,
-0.18631814420223236,
0.45825687050819397,
-0.17715129256248474,
0.09626304358243942,
0.4540259838104248,
-0.3259645402431488,
0.13080082833766937,
-0.17824622988700867,
0.44379398226737976,
0.12225346267223358,
-0.3256724774837494,
0.18298231065273285,
-0.03403512015938759,
0.757499098777771,
0.2724740207195282,
0.2409106194972992,
-0.4413050413131714,
0.22697874903678894,
0.3335196375846863,
0.33108770847320557,
-0.4644879400730133,
-0.22549478709697723,
0.5290898084640503,
-0.23509590327739716,
0.1902438849210739,
-0.05578240752220154,
-0.5829850435256958,
-0.20827721059322357,
-0.4707219898700714,
0.2777170240879059,
-0.6963595151901245,
-0.06184064969420433,
0.2655996084213257,
-0.12470873445272446,
-0.20500893890857697,
0.4250151216983795,
-0.6616753935813904,
-0.004545676987618208,
0.887186586856842,
0.5636628866195679,
-0.1279018223285675,
-0.6700677275657654,
0.02071508765220642,
0.0034333106596022844,
-0.4162270128726959,
1.089863657951355,
-0.657097578048706,
-0.0027388548478484154,
-0.23626255989074707,
-0.38583293557167053,
-0.22790288925170898,
-0.6082233190536499,
0.7313912510871887,
-0.5821259021759033,
-0.15561647713184357,
-0.16450797021389008,
-0.5146156549453735,
-0.23883850872516632,
0.3977600038051605,
-0.5720743536949158,
0.9425266981124878,
-0.3941294848918915,
-0.40989625453948975,
0.2641335129737854,
-0.9283281564712524,
-0.09169664978981018,
0.3066321313381195,
-0.2606971263885498,
-0.14765852689743042,
0.12324965000152588,
0.31273165345191956,
0.0914268046617508,
-0.8575658798217773,
0.4204595386981964,
-0.49484461545944214,
-0.04122943431138992,
0.38420388102531433,
-0.24552302062511444,
0.6640925407409668,
0.32903528213500977,
-0.7436268329620361,
0.1706835776567459,
-0.6012996435165405,
0.17061512172222137,
0.045722596347332,
-0.000996507820673287,
-0.28467440605163574,
0.16353997588157654,
-0.17148001492023468,
0.22854678332805634,
0.3719826340675354,
-0.629403829574585,
0.18801838159561157,
0.11516565084457397,
0.8053522109985352,
0.7113483548164368,
-0.2847263514995575,
0.039150286465883255,
-0.31022539734840393,
0.3919867277145386,
-0.1406804919242859,
0.568651556968689,
0.010541035793721676,
-0.7299230694770813,
-0.4710724949836731,
-0.29465949535369873,
0.21577312052249908,
0.7593013048171997,
-0.8453991413116455,
0.3950119912624359,
-0.3174435496330261,
-0.8068855404853821,
-0.6456092596054077,
0.04615538939833641,
0.5192115306854248,
0.44514453411102295,
0.5271139144897461,
-0.05942004173994064,
-0.15656188130378723,
-0.9720544815063477,
-0.4123861491680145,
-0.08559799939393997,
0.22351261973381042,
0.4168119430541992,
1.0855025053024292,
-0.19770002365112305,
0.4457786977291107,
-0.08359145373106003,
-0.21530644595623016,
-0.24701081216335297,
0.4477044343948364,
0.0256517231464386,
0.592737078666687,
0.254923939704895,
-0.752599835395813,
0.04079575091600418,
0.21288277208805084,
-1.335972785949707,
-0.13180512189865112,
-0.05435962229967117,
-0.24766382575035095,
-0.15804828703403473,
0.44146767258644104,
-0.7212298512458801,
0.35353168845176697,
0.38164106011390686,
-0.317532479763031,
0.7892359495162964,
-0.43503713607788086,
0.47040101885795593,
-0.5003135800361633,
0.2007812112569809,
0.09155352413654327,
0.20098520815372467,
-0.41925689578056335,
0.5322771072387695,
0.029279770329594612,
0.17095305025577545,
-0.270660936832428,
0.48000025749206543,
-0.28204283118247986,
0.1380453109741211,
-0.16309599578380585,
0.1256193369626999,
-0.1470671147108078,
0.19456860423088074,
0.03704259544610977,
0.612177312374115,
0.5584694743156433,
-0.46695274114608765,
0.505473792552948,
0.2621954679489136,
-0.4128285348415375,
0.8196505904197693,
-0.6226292848587036,
0.25468167662620544,
-0.14725367724895477,
0.3473343253135681,
-0.5394651889801025,
-0.08896215260028839,
-0.11020030826330185,
-0.37135443091392517,
-0.22845137119293213,
0.3239331543445587,
-0.6531692147254944,
-0.4944443106651306,
-0.18611040711402893,
1.0133181810379028,
0.012966524809598923,
-0.33315372467041016,
0.6382951140403748,
0.2663963735103607,
-0.15384969115257263,
-0.36803239583969116,
-0.7228405475616455,
0.2959209382534027,
-0.1866854429244995,
-0.6619561314582825,
0.2785976529121399,
-0.4866306781768799,
-0.30876246094703674,
0.16602851450443268,
-0.06719829142093658,
-0.15135690569877625,
0.12741510570049286,
0.03587782382965088,
0.23112861812114716,
-0.170523539185524,
-0.12664590775966644,
-0.08155559748411179,
-0.23935289680957794,
0.04916645959019661,
-0.4912289083003998,
0.3425343334674835,
-0.34392258524894714,
-0.49236270785331726,
-0.7687697410583496,
0.4810675382614136,
0.7561306357383728,
-0.6140820384025574,
0.7002658843994141,
0.4134436547756195,
-0.45005670189857483,
0.09295941889286041,
-0.6913691759109497,
-0.024712206795811653,
-0.28141799569129944,
0.5145609378814697,
-0.435619980096817,
-0.5437268614768982,
0.7331804633140564,
-0.06319884955883026,
0.05610622465610504,
0.4713098108768463,
0.5702896118164062,
0.037728726863861084,
1.4613566398620605,
0.2089783400297165,
0.0430801585316658,
0.19705548882484436,
-0.5608992576599121,
0.12940654158592224,
-1.0847821235656738,
-0.6710596084594727,
-0.651237964630127,
-0.3819916844367981,
-0.19355741143226624,
-0.37363842129707336,
0.5617768168449402,
-0.08070738613605499,
-0.6331753730773926,
0.14233598113059998,
-0.3895564675331116,
0.5674184560775757,
0.820639967918396,
0.23774391412734985,
0.46415090560913086,
-0.5268261432647705,
-0.10408758372068405,
-0.06286607682704926,
-0.8361560106277466,
-0.48528361320495605,
1.3311419486999512,
0.05444880947470665,
0.4545498490333557,
0.00935995765030384,
0.47793540358543396,
0.25874724984169006,
0.4374295771121979,
-0.32563403248786926,
0.44069889187812805,
0.00619992520660162,
-0.9984162449836731,
-0.10336335003376007,
-0.5646881461143494,
-0.8819889426231384,
0.2823435664176941,
-0.3328982889652252,
-0.916558563709259,
0.11564496904611588,
-0.05579068139195442,
-0.4840298295021057,
0.33132266998291016,
-0.37292325496673584,
0.852209746837616,
-0.5792965292930603,
-0.5653719305992126,
-0.5201011896133423,
-0.45860040187835693,
0.5641591548919678,
-0.10985086858272552,
0.48516005277633667,
-0.2815477252006531,
-0.09657842665910721,
0.7260758876800537,
-0.18850113451480865,
0.3823457658290863,
0.2801363468170166,
0.2814966142177582,
0.21521686017513275,
0.14528430998325348,
0.004844914190471172,
0.30739134550094604,
-0.0817074254155159,
0.5538976192474365,
0.03552987799048424,
-0.4804616868495941,
-0.5256980657577515,
0.833527684211731,
-1.0464510917663574,
-0.5729941129684448,
-0.47160086035728455,
-0.9052073955535889,
-0.258522629737854,
0.2577721178531647,
0.3144805133342743,
0.5128179788589478,
0.049396052956581116,
0.15208207070827484,
0.6289970278739929,
0.10025758296251297,
0.1743137091398239,
0.21887053549289703,
0.2811459004878998,
-0.4524137079715729,
0.8631394505500793,
0.2310095578432083,
-0.2119961827993393,
0.09216868132352829,
0.025319959968328476,
-0.47370320558547974,
-0.9508568644523621,
-0.4901791512966156,
0.22544871270656586,
-0.5821466445922852,
-0.22604671120643616,
-0.4288380742073059,
0.13986101746559143,
-0.06276458501815796,
-0.02417078986763954,
-0.6643439531326294,
-0.43616124987602234,
0.06121823191642761,
0.056546200066804886,
-0.11997029930353165,
0.7518261671066284,
-0.10673633217811584,
-0.08989638835191727,
-0.5307003259658813,
0.3470679521560669,
0.145197331905365,
0.133916974067688,
0.05629143863916397,
-0.20673131942749023,
-0.11983668059110641,
-0.1663082242012024,
-0.4814774990081787,
-0.664141058921814,
0.0016459246398881078,
-0.07791714370250702,
0.8594745397567749,
0.3771803081035614,
-0.0022219556849449873,
0.61733078956604,
-0.4699973165988922,
0.8545490503311157,
0.11385037750005722,
-0.9092634916305542,
0.5019932985305786,
-0.18958857655525208,
0.29168206453323364,
0.6420319080352783,
0.41582632064819336,
-0.11924134194850922,
-0.5609287023544312,
-0.7600414752960205,
-0.9506806135177612,
0.7457399964332581,
0.2933940589427948,
-0.246804878115654,
-0.08212846517562866,
0.3874574899673462,
0.13229745626449585,
0.12473475188016891,
-0.35296696424484253,
-0.08984283357858658,
-0.2118125706911087,
-0.42347076535224915,
-0.09826572984457016,
0.436479777097702,
-0.4888441264629364,
-0.197321355342865,
0.8125147819519043,
-0.13913054764270782,
0.06594724208116531,
0.36066001653671265,
-0.1997913122177124,
0.2913064658641815,
-0.004414966329932213,
0.5901567339897156,
0.8164969086647034,
0.26033565402030945,
0.08993177115917206,
0.27645787596702576,
-0.3003374934196472,
0.04116581752896309,
0.37893226742744446,
-0.18187110126018524,
-0.6755037903785706,
0.8906370401382446,
0.49142831563949585,
0.10062144696712494,
-1.0966511964797974,
0.052849672734737396,
-0.2412324696779251,
-0.36611130833625793,
-0.1619090437889099,
0.07497157901525497,
0.01737351156771183,
0.8899003863334656,
0.5821619033813477,
0.35867059230804443,
0.26024898886680603,
-0.7872826457023621,
-0.09124144911766052,
0.414431095123291,
-0.06446269899606705,
-0.4103274643421173,
1.2789297103881836,
0.039794232696294785,
-0.08581121265888214,
0.6157165765762329,
-0.0769754946231842,
-0.5841270685195923,
0.879590630531311,
0.2639480531215668,
0.6792649626731873,
-0.17456121742725372,
0.05150178447365761,
0.15183021128177643,
0.44157764315605164,
-0.3594300448894501,
0.3146005868911743,
-0.09762962907552719,
-0.6939294934272766,
-0.19664248824119568,
-0.11038991808891296,
-0.4742997884750366,
0.13184525072574615,
-0.5597450733184814,
-0.3420639932155609,
-0.3681267201900482,
-0.33286476135253906,
0.1166890561580658,
0.22508902847766876,
-0.8867202401161194,
0.1084309071302414,
0.27764925360679626,
1.1101559400558472,
-0.8157344460487366,
0.31823351979255676,
0.7910269498825073,
-0.6182611584663391,
-0.2393612414598465,
-0.29208672046661377,
0.0011832733871415257,
-0.710027277469635,
0.6993424296379089,
0.04620927944779396,
-0.018059564754366875,
-0.21739782392978668,
-0.5938417315483093,
-0.6331732869148254,
1.1397802829742432,
0.563627302646637,
-0.40672826766967773,
0.21261954307556152,
-0.03251846507191658,
0.5823654532432556,
-0.514614999294281,
0.7325936555862427,
0.8393046855926514,
0.7967444658279419,
-0.18224972486495972,
-0.9081578850746155,
-0.104588583111763,
-0.4209802746772766,
-0.07696163654327393,
-0.35474497079849243,
-1.0453619956970215,
0.7168980836868286,
-0.12922519445419312,
0.19795122742652893,
0.4268096685409546,
0.7072812914848328,
0.6091006398200989,
0.6378001570701599,
0.19775785505771637,
0.7914925813674927,
0.8494997620582581,
-0.23104199767112732,
1.137546181678772,
-0.33198103308677673,
0.08069729059934616,
0.7814673781394958,
-0.5774804949760437,
0.6491662263870239,
0.260201632976532,
0.07819002866744995,
0.4655766189098358,
0.4394526779651642,
0.2082945853471756,
0.3919980525970459,
0.049956921488046646,
-0.18101482093334198,
-0.54831463098526,
-0.20036274194717407,
-0.22840291261672974,
0.4925268590450287,
0.35076704621315,
0.21337686479091644,
-0.1759936809539795,
0.2447466254234314,
0.19442789256572723,
0.2803916335105896,
-0.4231414496898651,
0.3554641008377075,
-0.0796547383069992,
-0.985974907875061,
0.26945793628692627,
-0.07052658498287201,
0.3637760281562805,
-0.45033252239227295,
0.023042617365717888,
-0.3545435667037964,
0.45184189081192017,
-0.04892672970890999,
-0.7355849146842957,
-0.01381217036396265,
0.20758061110973358,
-0.10236335545778275,
0.17715252935886383,
0.044573355466127396,
-0.14978691935539246,
-0.5223333835601807,
0.3313901424407959,
0.5216217637062073,
0.13698215782642365,
-0.14584872126579285,
-1.0014100074768066,
0.4063878655433655,
-0.39866557717323303,
-0.22198253870010376,
0.1193678230047226,
0.5437504649162292,
-0.481280654668808,
0.9490494728088379,
0.7112340927124023,
0.10228802263736725,
0.21527238190174103,
0.03566480427980423,
0.7149672508239746,
-0.45010942220687866,
-0.4427390396595001,
-0.7547392845153809,
0.20301055908203125,
-0.24913831055164337,
-0.6921054124832153,
0.5325531363487244,
0.646240234375,
0.7361651659011841,
0.09897457808256149,
1.072889804840088,
0.01233698520809412,
-0.15077123045921326,
-0.5493292808532715,
0.4867434501647949,
-0.48446783423423767,
0.059669505804777145,
-0.006682645529508591,
-0.765172004699707,
-0.5197370648384094,
0.5215214490890503,
-0.6628493666648865,
0.0800459161400795,
0.8008058667182922,
0.31256356835365295,
-0.2252134084701538,
0.2690753936767578,
0.11021378636360168,
0.3290650248527527,
0.5051587820053101,
0.9779384732246399,
1.0999268293380737,
-0.30948787927627563,
0.6292708516120911,
-0.003344424068927765,
-0.6768654584884644,
-0.207660973072052,
-0.7569620609283447,
-0.8406558632850647,
-0.5729681253433228,
-0.5050923228263855,
0.10283529758453369,
0.4050877094268799,
0.6902769207954407,
0.9899424910545349,
-0.6804839372634888,
-0.03666594624519348,
-0.16782262921333313,
-0.1209184005856514,
-0.5410624742507935,
-0.16702796518802643,
0.333192378282547,
-0.2397867739200592,
-0.9217133522033691,
0.5404852032661438,
0.3241721987724304,
-0.6004701852798462,
-0.22476820647716522,
-0.12383891642093658,
-0.2639218866825104,
0.4702918827533722,
0.3429945409297943,
0.5721229314804077,
-0.6638791561126709,
-0.268349289894104,
-0.24418146908283234,
0.32287701964378357,
-0.26443418860435486,
0.5867618918418884,
-0.5262097120285034,
0.42990726232528687,
0.34733670949935913,
0.7243128418922424,
0.6640058755874634,
-0.2077268362045288,
0.28344041109085083,
-0.002176234032958746,
0.0700351670384407,
0.42024701833724976,
0.6100131273269653,
0.058868687599897385,
-0.1348106414079666,
0.5581534504890442,
0.2618251144886017,
-0.8495851159095764,
-0.6669426560401917,
0.137017160654068,
-0.6627490520477295,
-0.4711982309818268,
0.4826076328754425,
-0.28882649540901184,
-0.33090776205062866,
-0.22061514854431152,
-0.14935506880283356,
0.15368017554283142,
-0.289183109998703,
1.2159287929534912,
0.8202661871910095,
-0.7009921669960022,
-0.06314744800329208,
-1.070546269416809,
0.014900356531143188,
0.5675963163375854,
-0.9972423315048218,
-0.04825323447585106,
0.30216917395591736,
0.11040566116571426,
0.44261208176612854,
0.382857084274292,
-0.2490300089120865,
0.5625255107879639,
0.08996622264385223,
0.006376183126121759,
-0.39304637908935547,
-0.7771962285041809,
-0.09121612459421158,
0.1582101583480835,
-0.26187440752983093,
-0.006134605035185814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12746v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12746v3 | Rationale-based Ensemble of Multiple QA Strategies for Zero-shot Knowledge-based VQA | 2024-06-18T16:06:38 | 2024-06-23T03:06:42 | Miaoyu Li, Haoxin Li, Zilin Du, Boyang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge-based Visual Qustion-answering (K-VQA) necessitates the use of
background knowledge beyond what is depicted in the image. Current zero-shot
K-VQA methods usually translate an image to a single type of textual decision
context and use a text-based model to answer the question based on it, which
conflicts with the fact that K-VQA questions often require the combination of
multiple question-answering strategies. In light of this, we propose
Rationale-based Ensemble of Answer Context Tactics (REACT) to achieve a dynamic
ensemble of multiple question-answering tactics, comprising Answer Candidate
Generation (ACG) and Rationale-based Strategy Fusion (RSF). In ACG, we generate
three distinctive decision contexts to provide different strategies for each
question, resulting in the generation of three answer candidates. RSF generates
automatic and mechanistic rationales from decision contexts for each candidate,
allowing the model to select the correct answer from all candidates. We conduct
comprehensive experiments on the OK-VQA and A-OKVQA datasets, and our method
significantly outperforms state-of-the-art LLM-based baselines on all datasets. | [
-0.5978811383247375,
-0.9319283366203308,
0.9324028491973877,
-0.02063206024467945,
-0.19468790292739868,
0.2127024084329605,
0.10399527102708817,
-0.20028048753738403,
0.15825973451137543,
0.40860068798065186,
-0.9916461110115051,
-0.45328983664512634,
-0.04807787761092186,
0.3097379207611084,
-0.07160027325153351,
0.6100579500198364,
-0.22589011490345,
0.07492496073246002,
-0.4799109697341919,
-0.6240073442459106,
-0.7764626145362854,
-0.4638727009296417,
-0.37180572748184204,
-0.09419228136539459,
0.41726717352867126,
0.7328063249588013,
0.2255091816186905,
0.4468853175640106,
0.16012117266654968,
0.21155104041099548,
0.28438350558280945,
0.0770951434969902,
-0.2959783673286438,
0.612765908241272,
-0.16967934370040894,
-0.4479610025882721,
-0.04653892293572426,
-0.007007366046309471,
0.2962888479232788,
-0.08475159108638763,
-0.1608257293701172,
0.5211402177810669,
-0.6546813249588013,
0.31635332107543945,
-1.2629661560058594,
-0.2905036211013794,
-0.8175675868988037,
0.04278992861509323,
0.3995234966278076,
-0.4649887979030609,
-0.5367895364761353,
-0.16353954374790192,
0.30005523562431335,
-0.9093831181526184,
-0.15739157795906067,
-0.1724827140569687,
0.6783862709999084,
0.3727092742919922,
-0.787808358669281,
-0.05893700197339058,
-0.7561799883842468,
0.8203669786453247,
-0.43025925755500793,
-0.03681595250964165,
-0.010319951921701431,
0.7876386642456055,
0.13146919012069702,
-0.43823033571243286,
-0.7382944226264954,
0.2796202003955841,
0.19153760373592377,
0.6563050746917725,
0.09331339597702026,
-0.017657410353422165,
0.1834918111562729,
-0.13961997628211975,
-0.5600775480270386,
-0.31788456439971924,
-0.1723642349243164,
-0.16066165268421173,
0.6781052947044373,
0.10797572135925293,
0.3005625307559967,
-0.08197779208421707,
-0.8468440175056458,
-0.40345272421836853,
-0.47497493028640747,
0.3007128834724426,
-0.21583950519561768,
-0.026939423754811287,
0.08788717538118362,
0.6711697578430176,
-0.8500357866287231,
0.782884418964386,
0.2875671684741974,
-0.2231125384569168,
-0.08395048975944519,
-0.5452964305877686,
-0.39269647002220154,
0.11041298508644104,
0.6670371890068054,
0.5085544586181641,
0.038515809923410416,
0.009938089177012444,
-0.006488712038844824,
0.3058292865753174,
0.22941015660762787,
-0.7442317605018616,
-0.01074344851076603,
0.5081183910369873,
-0.04097382351756096,
-0.6554079055786133,
-0.30889424681663513,
-0.8801049590110779,
-0.1284123659133911,
-0.3732578158378601,
1.0177346467971802,
-0.44660013914108276,
-0.15537793934345245,
-0.127900630235672,
-0.5746943354606628,
0.9769629240036011,
0.5012721419334412,
-0.3270263969898224,
-0.01370680145919323,
0.033158376812934875,
0.32060569524765015,
-0.0891362801194191,
-0.2266272008419037,
-0.7155030965805054,
0.18172438442707062,
-0.4892667829990387,
1.0802099704742432,
-0.4849131405353546,
-0.1328529268503189,
0.06256688386201859,
-0.22550231218338013,
-0.23179082572460175,
-0.2007787525653839,
0.35860583186149597,
-0.9422882199287415,
0.46334967017173767,
-0.7285079956054688,
-0.48836588859558105,
-0.3324502110481262,
0.7845455408096313,
-0.4275585114955902,
0.6500326991081238,
-0.009228031150996685,
-0.37261518836021423,
0.42808568477630615,
-0.5576155185699463,
-0.10974076390266418,
0.10939420014619827,
-0.4969022274017334,
-0.14068999886512756,
-0.15974564850330353,
0.5699023008346558,
0.399536669254303,
-0.11589904874563217,
-0.19279277324676514,
-0.31124618649482727,
-0.24314258992671967,
0.3597842752933502,
-0.46238264441490173,
0.5320363640785217,
0.2378961592912674,
-0.37582942843437195,
0.36178258061408997,
-0.7250934839248657,
0.5407588481903076,
0.21370361745357513,
-0.15353108942508698,
-0.1710253208875656,
-0.07430485635995865,
-0.4141842722892761,
0.5527461767196655,
0.06272918730974197,
-0.390963077545166,
0.1544882208108902,
-0.03621162101626396,
0.18859803676605225,
0.48482999205589294,
0.6220453977584839,
0.6031862497329712,
-0.5398221611976624,
0.8759807348251343,
-0.02646813355386257,
0.20523403584957123,
-0.4302867352962494,
-0.4819614291191101,
-0.3768860101699829,
-0.3917257487773895,
0.06485296040773392,
0.8695659041404724,
-1.586364507675171,
-0.2153356373310089,
-0.003452695906162262,
-0.4331960082054138,
-0.2392949014902115,
-0.2885745167732239,
0.45727211236953735,
0.8576157093048096,
0.5463352799415588,
0.10350663214921951,
-0.33066895604133606,
-0.8605058789253235,
-0.08363237231969833,
-0.3493522107601166,
0.27321699261665344,
0.4792681038379669,
0.44904446601867676,
0.3065730035305023,
0.9768211245536804,
-0.6153699159622192,
0.1499553769826889,
0.0007856616284698248,
-0.0022486550733447075,
-0.1185690313577652,
0.030144857242703438,
0.6464537382125854,
-0.9109840989112854,
-0.42230698466300964,
-0.1109413430094719,
-0.870052695274353,
0.05827195197343826,
-0.32116803526878357,
-0.49432384967803955,
0.29989802837371826,
0.3832153081893921,
-0.6568442583084106,
0.4082202911376953,
0.2164512276649475,
-0.25704100728034973,
0.9854149222373962,
0.233803391456604,
0.7147364020347595,
-1.1923123598098755,
0.018687579780817032,
0.11110819876194,
-0.08461689203977585,
-0.8083075881004333,
0.563048243522644,
0.11795580387115479,
-0.07943426817655563,
-0.8055177927017212,
0.7270315289497375,
-0.19788910448551178,
0.25367116928100586,
-0.05816712975502014,
0.12128925323486328,
0.1498233824968338,
0.8170080780982971,
0.1626957803964615,
0.7547962069511414,
0.5802735686302185,
-0.4755405783653259,
0.4579572379589081,
0.3483603298664093,
-0.006359216291457415,
0.9037535190582275,
-0.5467724800109863,
0.11103824526071548,
-0.3132163882255554,
0.31087106466293335,
-1.3249534368515015,
-0.5536737442016602,
0.37300533056259155,
-0.5866371989250183,
0.07801516354084015,
-0.229694664478302,
-0.09928685426712036,
-0.26339191198349,
-0.472613126039505,
0.7861922383308411,
0.5454403162002563,
-0.5158453583717346,
0.8412328958511353,
0.03342452272772789,
-0.06869441270828247,
-0.9256138801574707,
-0.33847951889038086,
-0.26724711060523987,
-0.4517821669578552,
-0.7742674350738525,
0.11615511029958725,
-0.09090522676706314,
-0.25951138138771057,
-0.0068228174932301044,
-0.46148544549942017,
-0.3364860415458679,
0.03298644721508026,
-0.09853130578994751,
0.5283679366111755,
-0.27480053901672363,
0.17762216925621033,
0.14787447452545166,
0.33920326828956604,
-0.027201417833566666,
-0.2152961641550064,
0.3310214579105377,
-0.05085953697562218,
-0.3124775290489197,
-0.2313186228275299,
0.5751307606697083,
0.9421803951263428,
-0.4948500692844391,
0.6436211466789246,
0.40887653827667236,
-0.18613381683826447,
-0.3096368610858917,
-0.5964193344116211,
-0.45383134484291077,
-0.3934192657470703,
0.020215466618537903,
-0.3991855978965759,
-0.8644758462905884,
0.768527090549469,
-0.04683234915137291,
0.12345084547996521,
0.249716654419899,
0.6142940521240234,
-0.29371657967567444,
0.9878100156784058,
0.07504444569349289,
0.3039446771144867,
0.1316973865032196,
-0.22047705948352814,
-0.05361539125442505,
-0.38714271783828735,
-0.2945287525653839,
-0.2650184631347656,
-0.2554827630519867,
-0.3119964599609375,
-0.3088214695453644,
0.7734058499336243,
0.3030247390270233,
-0.32770344614982605,
0.1150018721818924,
-0.6807540059089661,
0.5094479322433472,
0.6097437739372253,
0.07583808153867722,
0.17738878726959229,
0.10225705802440643,
-0.20991504192352295,
0.4345676600933075,
-1.040225863456726,
-0.16031840443611145,
1.2721294164657593,
-0.13220155239105225,
0.41897615790367126,
0.1961350440979004,
0.7552736401557922,
-0.023865677416324615,
0.21407368779182434,
-0.9631177186965942,
0.6233548521995544,
0.5014755725860596,
-0.7256151437759399,
-0.6315879225730896,
-0.3558517098426819,
-0.7037269473075867,
0.5194939970970154,
-0.6182491183280945,
-0.4810221791267395,
0.32653334736824036,
0.32863849401474,
-0.7682511210441589,
-0.13450507819652557,
-0.7638471126556396,
0.818198025226593,
-0.04334830120205879,
-0.3995319902896881,
-0.03362390771508217,
-0.7707780003547668,
0.7907587885856628,
-0.06525932252407074,
0.03293156251311302,
0.11676345765590668,
0.008980458602309227,
0.5009203553199768,
-0.33640608191490173,
0.3868103325366974,
-0.13837435841560364,
0.05463571473956108,
0.8015128374099731,
0.026007911190390587,
0.3922971189022064,
0.15314161777496338,
0.0547163262963295,
-0.24763593077659607,
0.5658668279647827,
-0.5135583281517029,
-0.7639607787132263,
0.5392229557037354,
-0.6409545540809631,
-0.5416305661201477,
-0.40660572052001953,
-0.3896501362323761,
-0.4391990303993225,
0.15037037432193756,
0.3615834712982178,
0.698009729385376,
-0.06905923038721085,
0.1735701858997345,
0.6858553290367126,
-0.20890027284622192,
0.4926677644252777,
0.4858359396457672,
0.03025004267692566,
-0.7715558409690857,
0.7721577882766724,
0.0440002866089344,
0.45702582597732544,
0.27214521169662476,
0.1054939404129982,
-0.5281167030334473,
-0.1432904303073883,
-0.8502300977706909,
-0.08274450153112411,
-0.6651865839958191,
-0.3490602672100067,
-0.2887423038482666,
-0.17260609567165375,
-0.31269514560699463,
-0.354088693857193,
0.14644192159175873,
-0.34226807951927185,
0.02781142108142376,
0.10796064883470535,
0.3600643575191498,
0.05735722556710243,
0.24055702984333038,
0.2586502134799957,
-0.7678017020225525,
0.6098209619522095,
0.8349366188049316,
0.025752974674105644,
-0.22863583266735077,
-0.09904737025499344,
0.1283397078514099,
0.15158921480178833,
-0.5414518117904663,
-1.4669355154037476,
0.05131625384092331,
-0.038301125168800354,
0.6217796802520752,
-0.06431695818901062,
0.45774027705192566,
0.49709051847457886,
-0.3865755498409271,
0.8100175261497498,
0.3285385072231293,
-0.5852051973342896,
0.6568356156349182,
-0.555482804775238,
0.5192075371742249,
0.7165882587432861,
0.2714408338069916,
-0.3569815456867218,
-0.16747145354747772,
-0.5350939035415649,
-0.7954832911491394,
0.7029643058776855,
0.2689441442489624,
-0.19648399949073792,
-0.05360561981797218,
0.44559067487716675,
-0.28460076451301575,
0.34973153471946716,
-0.5435189008712769,
-0.2585637867450714,
-0.35806867480278015,
-0.13402125239372253,
0.45998987555503845,
0.14129053056240082,
-0.6199935078620911,
0.004214925691485405,
0.7292242646217346,
-0.6615694761276245,
0.19000361859798431,
0.6266844272613525,
0.013634888455271721,
-0.14084970951080322,
0.48899543285369873,
0.686011016368866,
0.5269275307655334,
-0.12991510331630707,
-0.15013059973716736,
0.3627950847148895,
-0.006425369065254927,
0.5753931403160095,
-0.12613898515701294,
-0.5112453699111938,
-0.29418760538101196,
0.1744181215763092,
0.538516640663147,
-0.26958999037742615,
-0.8462029695510864,
0.6794607639312744,
-0.13901324570178986,
-0.7162285447120667,
-0.36757194995880127,
0.2129381000995636,
-0.2711218595504761,
0.3023397624492645,
0.5258333086967468,
0.3420445919036865,
0.09092476218938828,
-0.5720590353012085,
0.43529200553894043,
0.6216071248054504,
-0.27749770879745483,
0.08343054354190826,
0.36393457651138306,
0.09591801464557648,
0.05523330718278885,
0.19229602813720703,
-0.14996963739395142,
-0.39734795689582825,
0.9176477193832397,
0.1352197229862213,
0.6994843482971191,
-0.268611341714859,
0.7561767101287842,
0.38228726387023926,
0.03583473339676857,
-0.11238453537225723,
0.736060380935669,
-0.2297784835100174,
-0.9351345300674438,
-0.8876402974128723,
-0.3099462389945984,
-0.41958996653556824,
0.407122403383255,
-0.6175475716590881,
0.2756015956401825,
-0.4787571430206299,
0.06800219416618347,
-0.09035459905862808,
-0.23432745039463043,
-0.5343227982521057,
0.4239859879016876,
0.14940159022808075,
0.8011489510536194,
-0.6844008564949036,
0.30051496624946594,
0.9670758843421936,
-0.423120379447937,
-1.0361934900283813,
0.1937350630760193,
0.1726197749376297,
-0.7556062936782837,
0.19724932312965393,
-0.027228843420743942,
-0.12234359979629517,
0.09654603898525238,
-0.9345992207527161,
-0.8518682718276978,
1.3857117891311646,
0.1910436451435089,
-0.15077534317970276,
0.2183459848165512,
-0.29046350717544556,
0.34023067355155945,
-0.3176156282424927,
0.3024104833602905,
0.22598455846309662,
0.47302746772766113,
0.6877301335334778,
-0.4785986840724945,
0.030857553705573082,
-0.2000807672739029,
-0.16547158360481262,
0.076609306037426,
-0.6827906966209412,
0.3370460867881775,
-0.17735515534877777,
-0.32994359731674194,
0.16300944983959198,
0.37235134840011597,
0.8175420761108398,
0.4682174026966095,
0.5020641684532166,
0.6319650411605835,
0.3356373608112335,
0.06757844239473343,
0.907492995262146,
-0.3942239582538605,
0.05869796499609947,
1.0289857387542725,
-0.3938787579536438,
0.863119900226593,
0.46555858850479126,
0.3375576138496399,
0.39291277527809143,
0.3641735017299652,
0.14903748035430908,
0.6356862187385559,
0.10046102851629257,
-0.5646753907203674,
-0.6569193005561829,
0.048116717487573624,
-0.05643109604716301,
0.6837233304977417,
0.11609023064374924,
0.17916974425315857,
-0.4604712426662445,
-0.08633731305599213,
-0.31180575489997864,
0.11831788718700409,
-0.2946743369102478,
0.9755846858024597,
-0.22533456981182098,
-1.1654019355773926,
0.6963629722595215,
-0.1343689113855362,
0.288099080324173,
-0.49561774730682373,
-0.21730023622512817,
-0.02840672992169857,
-0.29593920707702637,
0.020436083897948265,
-0.8334442973136902,
-0.029162738472223282,
-0.24307015538215637,
-0.25279679894447327,
-0.09589113295078278,
0.9700456857681274,
-0.5061994791030884,
-0.33680713176727295,
-0.20765632390975952,
0.9559712409973145,
-0.3456050157546997,
-0.05278480798006058,
-0.49402010440826416,
-0.33712145686149597,
-0.0476277656853199,
-0.20873764157295227,
0.23106475174427032,
0.486370325088501,
-0.2103235423564911,
0.6077030897140503,
0.6772460341453552,
-0.4340265393257141,
0.0864768847823143,
-0.2669881582260132,
0.7783976793289185,
-0.2799287736415863,
-0.33614838123321533,
-0.6025448441505432,
0.836663007736206,
-0.22493036091327667,
-0.36111652851104736,
0.5932753086090088,
0.17628048360347748,
0.5330187678337097,
-0.11036843806505203,
0.9464815855026245,
0.09162845462560654,
0.13164347410202026,
-0.49297013878822327,
0.5195551514625549,
-0.7229138612747192,
-0.08018121868371964,
-0.23351064324378967,
-0.7459463477134705,
-0.08812480419874191,
0.43162357807159424,
-0.17682960629463196,
-0.13166318833827972,
0.4577409625053406,
0.7331994771957397,
0.15972323715686798,
-0.06756190210580826,
0.47721606492996216,
-0.09160725772380829,
0.22595837712287903,
0.6872516870498657,
0.9899244904518127,
-0.4714046120643616,
0.8078932762145996,
-0.15421248972415924,
-0.38057219982147217,
-0.16247804462909698,
-0.7718099355697632,
-0.6028662919998169,
-0.6094497442245483,
-0.41544970870018005,
-0.32324355840682983,
-0.1609082967042923,
0.7035837173461914,
0.7326611280441284,
-0.58782958984375,
0.1251988559961319,
-0.05186823010444641,
0.1198793277144432,
-0.31437838077545166,
-0.2869710624217987,
0.10867249965667725,
-0.44567233324050903,
-0.11061983555555344,
0.4889651834964752,
0.3171139359474182,
-0.07436879724264145,
-0.04253952577710152,
0.008748806081712246,
-0.3106014132499695,
0.583775520324707,
0.8334446549415588,
0.537187933921814,
-0.5864760875701904,
-0.4965513348579407,
0.627739429473877,
0.05398298799991608,
-0.16550974547863007,
0.40795204043388367,
-1.1891807317733765,
0.44237497448921204,
0.7154830098152161,
0.789436399936676,
0.29296377301216125,
0.2832707166671753,
0.7619103789329529,
-0.7875344753265381,
-0.3097850978374481,
0.30873602628707886,
0.04219312220811844,
-0.11671361327171326,
-0.2432713657617569,
0.3349115550518036,
0.34144145250320435,
-0.4722432792186737,
-0.653959333896637,
0.4050145745277405,
-1.2320082187652588,
-0.6283029913902283,
1.3641213178634644,
0.17872588336467743,
-0.2839578688144684,
0.05175735801458359,
-0.34745439887046814,
0.07034158706665039,
-0.440945565700531,
0.5912981033325195,
0.7378852963447571,
-0.24208557605743408,
-0.5063729286193848,
-0.39640888571739197,
0.47503897547721863,
0.5981265306472778,
-0.9265853762626648,
-0.3838682770729065,
0.8946660161018372,
0.27566272020339966,
0.3526122570037842,
0.6584025621414185,
0.015601303428411484,
0.7813113927841187,
-0.158521369099617,
0.10684666037559509,
0.06276662647724152,
-0.4787435829639435,
-0.193963423371315,
0.5954449772834778,
-0.3181180953979492,
-0.36674731969833374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12742v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12742v1 | Benchmarking Multi-Image Understanding in Vision and Language Models: Perception, Knowledge, Reasoning, and Multi-Hop Reasoning | 2024-06-18T16:02:18 | 2024-06-18T16:02:18 | Bingchen Zhao, Yongshuo Zong, Letian Zhang, Timothy Hospedales | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | The advancement of large language models (LLMs) has significantly broadened
the scope of applications in natural language processing, with multi-modal LLMs
extending these capabilities to integrate and interpret visual data. However,
existing benchmarks for visual language models (VLMs) predominantly focus on
single-image inputs, neglecting the crucial aspect of multi-image
understanding. In this paper, we introduce a Multi-Image Relational Benchmark
MIRB, designed to evaluate VLMs' ability to compare, analyze, and reason across
multiple images. Our benchmark encompasses four categories: perception, visual
world knowledge, reasoning, and multi-hop reasoning. Through a comprehensive
evaluation of a wide range of open-source and closed-source models, we
demonstrate that while open-source VLMs were shown to approach the performance
of GPT-4V in single-image tasks, a significant performance gap remains in
multi-image reasoning tasks. Our findings also reveal that even the
state-of-the-art GPT-4V model struggles with our benchmark, underscoring the
need for further research and development in this area. We believe our
contribution of MIRB could serve as a testbed for developing the
next-generation multi-modal models. | [
-0.693149983882904,
-0.6569931507110596,
0.8541707992553711,
0.19410638511180878,
-0.3930418789386749,
-0.20383229851722717,
-0.04568265378475189,
-0.6592305302619934,
-0.4141789972782135,
0.40314826369285583,
-0.4422300457954407,
-0.5637641549110413,
-0.5681394934654236,
0.09286142140626907,
-0.07296378165483475,
0.28368425369262695,
-0.055711884051561356,
0.4125421643257141,
-0.6082412600517273,
-0.7574523091316223,
-0.7069665789604187,
-0.18809057772159576,
-0.13909007608890533,
-0.04658479616045952,
0.5626184344291687,
0.26038873195648193,
0.7215552926063538,
0.4833066761493683,
0.9937729835510254,
0.29580992460250854,
0.1114637702703476,
0.23623912036418915,
-0.19729402661323547,
0.07194148749113083,
-0.1877221018075943,
-0.24886149168014526,
-0.1625024974346161,
0.09226609021425247,
0.7540233135223389,
0.46809884905815125,
0.2776963710784912,
0.33159875869750977,
-0.3886159360408783,
0.672452449798584,
-0.8380521535873413,
0.34018173813819885,
-0.6859152913093567,
-0.07467754930257797,
-0.1092308759689331,
-0.057209379971027374,
-0.4602832794189453,
-0.20790044963359833,
0.011321652680635452,
-0.4099120497703552,
0.1082678884267807,
0.25907599925994873,
0.943836510181427,
0.3655795753002167,
-0.5282428860664368,
0.16950051486492157,
-0.394518107175827,
0.7669907808303833,
-0.47091779112815857,
0.9547188878059387,
0.05367843434214592,
0.6364231705665588,
0.16906192898750305,
-0.6673874855041504,
-0.5261366367340088,
-0.2307567000389099,
-0.015355841256678104,
0.20227842032909393,
-0.3026752173900604,
-0.10808733105659485,
0.26797521114349365,
0.20978443324565887,
-0.6469352841377258,
-0.147552490234375,
-0.2944123148918152,
-0.08099710941314697,
0.1274583339691162,
0.06145599111914635,
0.09751155972480774,
-0.20265628397464752,
-0.7535110712051392,
-0.2258155196905136,
-0.6150841116905212,
0.07721228897571564,
-0.08944836258888245,
-0.01781337708234787,
0.009709592908620834,
0.5317659974098206,
-0.135298952460289,
1.0175377130508423,
-0.5604879260063171,
-0.14775530993938446,
0.4056985378265381,
-0.6966620683670044,
-0.42688193917274475,
-0.6340115666389465,
0.7941870093345642,
0.6402345895767212,
0.14381080865859985,
-0.2086314558982849,
-0.04982119798660278,
0.2748588025569916,
0.20465682446956635,
-0.8933309316635132,
-0.13698577880859375,
-0.18866688013076782,
-0.6751066446304321,
-0.05050372704863548,
-0.10544692724943161,
-0.7524130940437317,
-0.30958476662635803,
-0.4299158751964569,
0.6466552019119263,
-0.6141288876533508,
-0.23432250320911407,
-0.005060642026364803,
-0.26206696033477783,
0.4723261296749115,
0.43918660283088684,
-0.38885411620140076,
0.17129744589328766,
0.5015084743499756,
0.9102941751480103,
-0.04094856232404709,
-0.800984263420105,
-0.5861955881118774,
0.03027077205479145,
-0.3632243573665619,
1.1501020193099976,
-0.7059651017189026,
-0.03822954744100571,
-0.34239745140075684,
-0.15153753757476807,
-0.14384725689888,
-0.4625570774078369,
0.45024964213371277,
-0.5183024406433105,
-0.007790491916239262,
-0.4310966730117798,
-0.2720881998538971,
-0.4943045377731323,
0.5738020539283752,
-0.7555987238883972,
0.6901064515113831,
0.013721529394388199,
-0.7303539514541626,
0.6095898747444153,
-0.5621449947357178,
-0.2821083068847656,
-0.01908101513981819,
-0.5944563746452332,
-0.4539265036582947,
0.22110141813755035,
0.5702701210975647,
0.4916098117828369,
-0.7073552012443542,
0.3255951702594757,
-0.7518987655639648,
-0.3909817934036255,
0.2297324240207672,
-0.4613995850086212,
0.4542120397090912,
0.1817043423652649,
-0.1389460563659668,
0.29311516880989075,
-0.793707013130188,
0.13019436597824097,
0.21632982790470123,
-0.1140688806772232,
-0.21244515478610992,
-0.028890961781144142,
-0.044381655752658844,
0.4765843152999878,
-0.03686385229229927,
-0.38765954971313477,
0.13300012052059174,
0.2154495120048523,
0.2019270956516266,
0.7231123447418213,
-0.18062451481819153,
0.09980551898479462,
-0.005772641859948635,
0.3543468713760376,
0.37587058544158936,
0.4139871299266815,
-0.6085763573646545,
-0.7473419308662415,
-0.6824437379837036,
-0.49195319414138794,
0.007403269410133362,
0.2706429958343506,
-0.9155915379524231,
-0.2380664199590683,
-0.375628799200058,
-0.40704041719436646,
-0.7879854440689087,
0.07323860377073288,
0.48978230357170105,
0.5500767230987549,
0.7095580101013184,
-0.3980873227119446,
-0.22953538596630096,
-1.2225871086120605,
-0.46733537316322327,
-0.1312725692987442,
0.06883633881807327,
0.6600637435913086,
0.4665563404560089,
-0.30530738830566406,
0.6745086908340454,
-0.222609281539917,
-0.2148815542459488,
0.05807953700423241,
0.3175027072429657,
0.18945100903511047,
0.1339525729417801,
0.7259970903396606,
-0.9189751744270325,
-0.22244524955749512,
-0.005105867981910706,
-0.8638898134231567,
-0.020800061523914337,
-0.14298978447914124,
-0.2063080221414566,
-0.0019307752372696996,
0.35196882486343384,
-0.47161078453063965,
0.6176717281341553,
0.7726881504058838,
-0.5981269478797913,
0.5871618986129761,
-0.09485315531492233,
0.6460756063461304,
-0.6121628284454346,
0.019956566393375397,
0.11989448219537735,
-0.2334858626127243,
-0.4741843044757843,
0.2087014764547348,
0.4589845538139343,
0.020506776869297028,
-0.4588901996612549,
0.39668557047843933,
-0.786629855632782,
-0.6295556426048279,
-0.10493647307157516,
0.035790521651506424,
0.3021247088909149,
0.4405791163444519,
0.11215797811746597,
0.8969087600708008,
0.9582350850105286,
-0.3310092091560364,
0.369945764541626,
0.1817760169506073,
-0.5501739382743835,
0.7679257988929749,
-0.6788392066955566,
0.06611169129610062,
-0.21202658116817474,
-0.14312510192394257,
-1.0316834449768066,
0.1352815479040146,
0.07099782675504684,
-0.36063581705093384,
0.0787685438990593,
-0.35644182562828064,
-0.5716591477394104,
-0.32471856474876404,
-0.16319803893566132,
0.3845667541027069,
0.30603334307670593,
-0.7344669699668884,
0.9743806719779968,
0.0741504579782486,
0.25215983390808105,
-0.7166465520858765,
-0.6367951035499573,
0.30226531624794006,
-0.048167843371629715,
-0.9835286140441895,
0.1009501963853836,
-0.06716468930244446,
-0.26378345489501953,
0.2256057858467102,
-0.0734127014875412,
-0.16911517083644867,
-0.017809012904763222,
0.31468403339385986,
0.5489246249198914,
-0.5361239314079285,
0.09624864906072617,
-0.41946759819984436,
-0.06278029084205627,
-0.022231481969356537,
-0.09323868155479431,
0.20641900599002838,
-0.7636869549751282,
-0.8106725811958313,
-0.11992183327674866,
0.25326189398765564,
0.8966854214668274,
-0.6271219849586487,
0.8167349696159363,
0.8458206057548523,
-0.01807754673063755,
0.11724647134542465,
-0.8276689052581787,
0.07831307500600815,
-0.3578002154827118,
0.2991311550140381,
-0.7939093708992004,
-0.7657879590988159,
0.2662508189678192,
-0.1657162457704544,
-0.10992711782455444,
0.27196231484413147,
0.5434282422065735,
-0.10672289878129959,
0.900692880153656,
0.5451841950416565,
0.0832609161734581,
0.339340478181839,
-0.05267336964607239,
0.15223683416843414,
-0.8322030305862427,
-0.2962802052497864,
-0.2686653733253479,
-0.2857324182987213,
-0.2534095346927643,
-0.9229119420051575,
0.47404900193214417,
0.12699729204177856,
-0.11341740936040878,
0.1927223801612854,
-0.22268055379390717,
0.6824964284896851,
0.7225462794303894,
0.05972863733768463,
0.5008932948112488,
-0.17418532073497772,
-0.3755717873573303,
0.06892309337854385,
-0.5517821311950684,
-0.3172979950904846,
1.0083781480789185,
0.23867417871952057,
0.7940764427185059,
0.25529927015304565,
0.19986478984355927,
-0.16115595400333405,
0.4099879264831543,
-0.5756735801696777,
0.5616658926010132,
-0.059241682291030884,
-0.5462127327919006,
-0.05090772360563278,
-0.4981570243835449,
-0.6555601358413696,
0.9903250336647034,
-0.30890607833862305,
-0.5446674823760986,
0.20112170279026031,
0.1885581761598587,
0.1348240226507187,
0.5062097311019897,
-0.903339147567749,
1.2390633821487427,
-0.49292993545532227,
-0.6031836271286011,
-0.21855902671813965,
-0.7086372971534729,
0.7039216756820679,
0.10454075038433075,
0.4316498637199402,
-0.4347068667411804,
0.04077207297086716,
0.14810997247695923,
0.024016454815864563,
0.4773562252521515,
-0.18181565403938293,
0.37985777854919434,
0.0862327292561531,
0.07231903076171875,
0.099225252866745,
-0.03976491838693619,
0.16417469084262848,
0.5296393632888794,
0.03266388550400734,
-0.26844608783721924,
-0.37264353036880493,
0.5604284405708313,
-0.6794429421424866,
-0.26452088356018066,
-0.2648266553878784,
-0.5151646733283997,
-0.3565099835395813,
0.2896833121776581,
-0.009212285280227661,
0.520710825920105,
-0.17240580916404724,
0.3802425265312195,
0.4471406638622284,
-0.4294748902320862,
0.33385831117630005,
0.5700939297676086,
-0.46376535296440125,
-0.4128323197364807,
0.649531364440918,
-0.3308994472026825,
0.3741283714771271,
0.29106953740119934,
0.13986892998218536,
-0.3563585579395294,
-0.6554139256477356,
-0.6597422361373901,
0.18536663055419922,
-1.1082978248596191,
-0.27490177750587463,
-0.6670084595680237,
0.18246214091777802,
-0.3543079197406769,
0.15315620601177216,
-0.39226430654525757,
0.024149730801582336,
0.014775867573916912,
0.2541144788265228,
0.23329302668571472,
0.7434228658676147,
-0.05529475212097168,
-0.058953385800123215,
-0.9178051352500916,
0.8466026186943054,
0.5061347484588623,
0.8332658410072327,
-0.09111206233501434,
-0.3661947548389435,
-0.12764956057071686,
-0.314974844455719,
-0.23463872075080872,
-0.836260199546814,
0.08016401529312134,
0.09107509255409241,
0.828575611114502,
0.33044350147247314,
-0.5053827166557312,
0.9969225525856018,
-0.7056458592414856,
0.568671464920044,
0.4486539363861084,
-0.887377142906189,
0.5220350027084351,
-0.16748836636543274,
0.4871945381164551,
0.5366184711456299,
0.22918029129505157,
-0.4949735105037689,
-0.16742102801799774,
-0.3389444649219513,
-0.6015831232070923,
0.5059462785720825,
0.22629886865615845,
-0.4094134271144867,
0.1860440969467163,
-0.14179806411266327,
0.09157243371009827,
0.22261950373649597,
-0.8588585257530212,
-0.08382304757833481,
-0.3557703197002411,
0.09230148047208786,
-0.052052684128284454,
-0.02041793055832386,
-0.07083218544721603,
-0.3703555166721344,
0.3105951249599457,
-0.31542468070983887,
0.34723377227783203,
0.041224297136068344,
-0.37092772126197815,
0.08334022015333176,
0.2547893822193146,
0.4994519352912903,
0.8930945992469788,
-0.1341250091791153,
0.47698357701301575,
-0.00318603846244514,
-0.19753317534923553,
-0.053179290145635605,
0.11012154072523117,
0.11516133695840836,
-0.04478270187973976,
0.5713195204734802,
1.1291533708572388,
0.12546250224113464,
-0.6194716691970825,
0.7816817760467529,
-0.4777223765850067,
-0.23879756033420563,
0.16251230239868164,
-0.1381412148475647,
0.351576566696167,
0.49405497312545776,
0.010497843846678734,
0.5775989294052124,
0.20224231481552124,
-0.578088104724884,
0.1475214660167694,
0.6039767861366272,
-0.087295763194561,
-0.21167618036270142,
0.7230998873710632,
-0.06323380768299103,
0.04930704087018967,
0.6261346340179443,
-0.08748620003461838,
-0.42839619517326355,
0.5306271910667419,
0.2918916642665863,
0.5906677842140198,
0.20029938220977783,
-0.04501199349761009,
0.390490859746933,
0.5203218460083008,
0.0430542454123497,
0.46075236797332764,
-0.11394967883825302,
-0.908502459526062,
-0.5607706904411316,
-0.4813960790634155,
-0.5585516095161438,
0.06166141480207443,
-0.5577064752578735,
0.2102028727531433,
-0.2440461665391922,
-0.13226504623889923,
0.16085422039031982,
-0.6094747185707092,
-1.1845426559448242,
0.09781859815120697,
0.45889002084732056,
0.8533643484115601,
-0.7472988963127136,
0.84934401512146,
0.673431932926178,
-0.5989091396331787,
-0.6064441204071045,
-0.2924650311470032,
0.10013359785079956,
-1.055931806564331,
0.7774465084075928,
0.5122172832489014,
-0.41023802757263184,
-0.299236923456192,
-0.6288905143737793,
-0.9003615379333496,
1.0452706813812256,
0.3858228027820587,
-0.5155590772628784,
0.4163564443588257,
-0.15786047279834747,
0.3366261124610901,
-0.30295801162719727,
0.37096652388572693,
0.5840921998023987,
0.6509305834770203,
0.18877723813056946,
-0.8167601823806763,
-0.17486213147640228,
-0.33052217960357666,
0.12932337820529938,
0.3082107901573181,
-0.6008166670799255,
0.9953652620315552,
-0.481120228767395,
-0.12301965057849884,
-0.14197228848934174,
0.3963210880756378,
0.3901293873786926,
0.3487766981124878,
0.5883991122245789,
0.7529282569885254,
0.4363180696964264,
-0.21704545617103577,
0.9361757040023804,
-0.13866394758224487,
0.3053135275840759,
1.201094388961792,
-0.30050867795944214,
0.7987504005432129,
0.6087116599082947,
-0.2241021990776062,
0.321826308965683,
0.34085404872894287,
-0.32450535893440247,
0.5634543299674988,
-0.06884315609931946,
-0.07750431448221207,
-0.4603118896484375,
0.07050354778766632,
-0.3263246417045593,
0.6251316666603088,
0.1521890014410019,
-0.3216303586959839,
-0.2234838306903839,
0.06533120572566986,
-0.5512769222259521,
-0.19923129677772522,
-0.2125474363565445,
0.7068644762039185,
-0.06994611024856567,
-0.5953155755996704,
0.4228593111038208,
-0.19450519979000092,
0.5707888007164001,
-0.4231538474559784,
-0.17196375131607056,
0.039074450731277466,
0.21911446750164032,
0.05408015474677086,
-1.0026817321777344,
0.14580585062503815,
-0.04725582152605057,
-0.08196074515581131,
-0.22254706919193268,
0.9622100591659546,
-0.26674923300743103,
-0.44335705041885376,
0.5398415923118591,
0.8072722554206848,
0.24010945856571198,
-0.29542237520217896,
-0.7707199454307556,
0.3756188750267029,
-0.13173553347587585,
-0.25034019351005554,
0.09430832415819168,
0.5032159686088562,
0.14145411550998688,
0.7887484431266785,
0.63898766040802,
-0.06510817259550095,
0.2412455528974533,
0.46136096119880676,
0.9047120809555054,
-0.8779179453849792,
-0.10067301988601685,
-0.9799245595932007,
0.4330568313598633,
-0.1374225616455078,
-0.25141289830207825,
0.6427481770515442,
0.456569641828537,
0.7936000227928162,
-0.14683862030506134,
0.6736574769020081,
0.05770367383956909,
0.2195633351802826,
-0.5872788429260254,
0.3971155285835266,
-0.8305935263633728,
-0.016572771593928337,
-0.4331861436367035,
-0.8072447776794434,
-0.4526040554046631,
0.6576675772666931,
-0.1969127058982849,
-0.034397680312395096,
0.8830955624580383,
0.5881078839302063,
-0.2326689213514328,
0.007780869957059622,
0.637698769569397,
0.04082898795604706,
0.33012330532073975,
0.513772189617157,
1.1517435312271118,
-0.2599946856498718,
0.64031583070755,
-0.23613932728767395,
-0.13444030284881592,
0.018608568236231804,
-1.19199538230896,
-0.889416515827179,
-0.44959619641304016,
-0.013849129900336266,
0.07419761270284653,
-0.1472386121749878,
0.43720316886901855,
0.8319519758224487,
-0.5393938422203064,
-0.0034705207217484713,
0.07206647843122482,
0.10729250311851501,
-0.35346880555152893,
-0.11537668108940125,
0.13068115711212158,
-0.18644408881664276,
-0.33857065439224243,
0.4130229651927948,
0.8393482565879822,
0.054640136659145355,
-0.3132933974266052,
-0.03681448847055435,
-0.3037817180156708,
-0.22779306769371033,
0.7776297926902771,
-0.10737550258636475,
-1.0167829990386963,
-0.2257889211177826,
0.08123032748699188,
-0.0011279608588665724,
0.5076864361763,
0.6977104544639587,
-0.8907927870750427,
0.7733296155929565,
0.4288119375705719,
0.7115330696105957,
0.6805114150047302,
-0.004289831966161728,
0.32335805892944336,
-0.44536617398262024,
0.09813986718654633,
0.14058013260364532,
0.8233875632286072,
0.48945558071136475,
0.11402769386768341,
0.642261803150177,
0.29223790764808655,
-0.5424124598503113,
-0.5651741623878479,
0.2376568466424942,
-0.9801445603370667,
-0.5379073023796082,
0.8843933343887329,
-0.1411331444978714,
-0.13453996181488037,
0.14806696772575378,
-0.07385770231485367,
-0.0016626414144411683,
-0.07063475996255875,
0.2347336709499359,
0.7785388231277466,
-0.26706695556640625,
-0.7343672513961792,
-0.7685112357139587,
-0.16168415546417236,
0.26442715525627136,
-1.0739691257476807,
-0.00798728410154581,
0.9797229766845703,
0.2975083887577057,
0.05044274032115936,
0.6725874543190002,
-0.10534655302762985,
0.42733824253082275,
0.19503064453601837,
0.16015580296516418,
-0.22019605338573456,
-0.6937127709388733,
-0.26332414150238037,
0.14254188537597656,
0.11455918848514557,
-0.3890703022480011
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12739v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12739v1 | Self-Distillation for Model Stacking Unlocks Cross-Lingual NLU in 200+ Languages | 2024-06-18T16:00:20 | 2024-06-18T16:00:20 | Fabian David Schmidt, Philipp Borchert, Ivan Vulić, Goran Glavaš | cs.CL | cs.CL | LLMs have become a go-to solution not just for text generation, but also for
natural language understanding (NLU) tasks. Acquiring extensive knowledge
through language modeling on web-scale corpora, they excel on English NLU, yet
struggle to extend their NLU capabilities to underrepresented languages. In
contrast, machine translation models (MT) produce excellent multilingual
representations, resulting in strong translation performance even for
low-resource languages. MT encoders, however, lack the knowledge necessary for
comprehensive NLU that LLMs obtain through language modeling training on
immense corpora. In this work, we get the best both worlds by integrating MT
encoders directly into LLM backbones via sample-efficient self-distillation.
The resulting MT-LLMs preserve the inherent multilingual representational
alignment from the MT encoder, allowing lower-resource languages to tap into
the rich knowledge embedded in English-centric LLMs. Merging the MT encoder and
LLM in a single model, we mitigate the propagation of translation errors and
inference overhead of MT decoding inherent to discrete translation-based
cross-lingual transfer (e.g., translate-test). Evaluation spanning three
prominent NLU tasks and 127 predominantly low-resource languages renders
MT-LLMs highly effective in cross-lingual transfer. MT-LLMs substantially and
consistently outperform translate-test based on the same MT model, showing that
we truly unlock multilingual language understanding for LLMs. | [
-0.27497050166130066,
-0.3712499439716339,
0.3989258408546448,
0.3452986776828766,
-0.30897608399391174,
0.39039111137390137,
-0.10107757151126862,
-0.41458791494369507,
0.009312918409705162,
0.6051955819129944,
-0.5263268947601318,
-0.3481299877166748,
-0.579557478427887,
0.5176106095314026,
-0.26695331931114197,
1.0850847959518433,
-0.14584980905056,
0.22336754202842712,
-0.3998827040195465,
-0.022932231426239014,
-0.30134475231170654,
-0.6317157745361328,
-0.36934998631477356,
-0.5310410857200623,
0.4765053987503052,
0.009306419640779495,
0.27147576212882996,
0.5937987565994263,
0.3121523857116699,
0.3364953100681305,
0.017696982249617577,
0.43126747012138367,
-0.6594426035881042,
-0.023471519351005554,
-0.06178740784525871,
-0.6868054270744324,
-0.5804458856582642,
-0.03775710612535477,
0.5191214680671692,
0.6621357202529907,
-0.20373094081878662,
0.15322977304458618,
0.3977881371974945,
0.6090500950813293,
-0.5236034989356995,
0.03805781155824661,
-0.8100361227989197,
0.17125284671783447,
-0.1012551411986351,
-0.1764565110206604,
-0.5654118657112122,
0.0072382111102342606,
-0.09323352575302124,
-0.6050899624824524,
0.12211808562278748,
0.18487270176410675,
0.6082754731178284,
0.48909667134284973,
-0.49279141426086426,
-0.2613545358181,
-0.6583117842674255,
0.9339283108711243,
-0.718362033367157,
0.5205984115600586,
0.24017539620399475,
0.31351929903030396,
-0.08784741163253784,
-0.5172439217567444,
-0.48097068071365356,
0.09508510679006577,
-0.37676140666007996,
0.32293468713760376,
-0.39588066935539246,
-0.14867454767227173,
-0.12402402609586716,
0.6413524746894836,
-0.7123052477836609,
0.3570919334888458,
-0.5213527083396912,
-0.024367768317461014,
0.45220014452934265,
0.15023598074913025,
0.22071640193462372,
-0.4273990988731384,
-0.7495934963226318,
0.01443753857165575,
-0.7194989919662476,
-0.18386422097682953,
0.24551047384738922,
0.280430406332016,
-0.21886363625526428,
0.42016327381134033,
0.1346229761838913,
0.5369793772697449,
0.3855503499507904,
-0.10955667495727539,
0.2993113100528717,
-0.5426836609840393,
-0.40224725008010864,
0.06081495061516762,
1.0989558696746826,
0.08475271612405777,
0.16296245157718658,
-0.29686328768730164,
-0.15023811161518097,
-0.20160925388336182,
0.18513990938663483,
-0.8902803659439087,
-0.1436053365468979,
0.17106875777244568,
-0.2876841425895691,
-0.21026112139225006,
-0.3981163799762726,
-0.6087646484375,
-0.07036875933408737,
-0.2371251881122589,
0.24448662996292114,
-0.31923964619636536,
-0.3532891869544983,
0.20130221545696259,
-0.043637193739414215,
0.02906816452741623,
0.040637653321027756,
-1.0164010524749756,
0.1575036197900772,
0.4408344626426697,
0.7033044695854187,
-0.5351055264472961,
-0.3735337555408478,
-0.4386220872402191,
0.3134491443634033,
-0.3275012969970703,
0.5581396222114563,
-0.16325892508029938,
-0.39321455359458923,
-0.2712511420249939,
0.040479060262441635,
-0.1851450353860855,
-0.7005193829536438,
0.2617519497871399,
-0.5337800979614258,
0.393128365278244,
0.005220018792897463,
-0.3814922869205475,
-0.11565686762332916,
0.3964170515537262,
-0.5877830982208252,
1.180907130241394,
-0.20530883967876434,
-0.6857528686523438,
0.1095312163233757,
-0.4653601050376892,
-0.39136722683906555,
-0.013810978271067142,
-0.05714430287480354,
-0.2483542412519455,
0.2961174547672272,
0.6171368956565857,
0.5741580128669739,
-0.3626334071159363,
0.2613314986228943,
-0.32845449447631836,
-0.03891008719801903,
0.043870579451322556,
-0.5892683267593384,
0.8298816084861755,
0.41392406821250916,
-0.042259782552719116,
-0.07524239271879196,
-0.6746413707733154,
-0.1932007521390915,
0.10255052149295807,
-0.412667840719223,
-0.7180866599082947,
-0.400154173374176,
-0.16194836795330048,
0.3931313753128052,
0.37812256813049316,
-0.38610321283340454,
0.1865837574005127,
-0.26655203104019165,
0.3815511465072632,
0.6711441278457642,
-0.3811757266521454,
0.6552863121032715,
-0.10339176654815674,
0.5603342056274414,
0.2026878297328949,
-0.0736367329955101,
-0.20281840860843658,
-0.16115687787532806,
-0.8063898086547852,
-0.42662176489830017,
0.42015519738197327,
0.6269241571426392,
-0.9298918843269348,
0.4888804256916046,
-0.5201401114463806,
-0.3567381799221039,
-0.9214884638786316,
0.5428917407989502,
0.47193118929862976,
0.5594310164451599,
0.5944312214851379,
-0.15024110674858093,
-0.469161719083786,
-0.9194198250770569,
-0.13611909747123718,
-0.06792587786912918,
-0.1896098107099533,
-0.13197562098503113,
0.4219023287296295,
-0.24082447588443756,
0.7700353264808655,
-0.19703707098960876,
-0.32828155159950256,
-0.6088290810585022,
0.30605947971343994,
0.3228558301925659,
0.4416113793849945,
0.45537519454956055,
-0.6813735961914062,
-0.5075648427009583,
0.08280208706855774,
-1.0840983390808105,
-0.30470216274261475,
-0.13555693626403809,
-0.3172701597213745,
0.23751983046531677,
0.4230315089225769,
-0.3914458751678467,
0.0649571418762207,
0.976505696773529,
0.056392017751932144,
0.3785187304019928,
-0.5351724028587341,
0.0841483622789383,
-1.4262800216674805,
-0.04701877757906914,
-0.1439591646194458,
-0.36911672353744507,
-0.5690075755119324,
-0.05390937626361847,
0.2667268216609955,
0.13264457881450653,
-0.5256108641624451,
0.4784201979637146,
-0.949601411819458,
-0.20573608577251434,
-0.2559463083744049,
0.3598466217517853,
0.47229430079460144,
0.5165643692016602,
0.03567562252283096,
0.6798722743988037,
0.30787593126296997,
-0.6063884496688843,
0.1093313992023468,
0.16684864461421967,
-0.21574750542640686,
0.6177346706390381,
-0.5178695321083069,
0.08036613464355469,
-0.16441912949085236,
0.35188236832618713,
-0.9794370532035828,
0.2763538360595703,
-0.021771201863884926,
-0.16918662190437317,
0.4259072542190552,
-0.3755335807800293,
-0.46853435039520264,
-0.3509465754032135,
-0.03517445549368858,
0.4829283654689789,
0.4686602056026459,
-0.8124073147773743,
0.9166828393936157,
0.37511447072029114,
-0.017989516258239746,
-0.7805088758468628,
-1.1451009511947632,
0.051650214940309525,
-0.3705102503299713,
-0.5934142470359802,
0.4092760384082794,
-0.18978117406368256,
-0.011298387311398983,
-0.003188586328178644,
-0.12971119582653046,
-0.000866599497385323,
0.08309558033943176,
0.015217870473861694,
0.3906782269477844,
-0.130857914686203,
0.0548861138522625,
0.21998780965805054,
-0.22817611694335938,
0.04531245306134224,
-0.5531169772148132,
0.5259522199630737,
-0.03005252033472061,
-0.46569663286209106,
-0.2846985459327698,
0.32461944222450256,
0.5910269021987915,
-0.41397109627723694,
0.6495702862739563,
0.5824041366577148,
-0.21798814833164215,
-0.30455443263053894,
-0.6274227499961853,
-0.03663257136940956,
-0.455806165933609,
0.3051316738128662,
-0.8207474946975708,
-0.8810790777206421,
0.5802310705184937,
-0.1747259497642517,
0.20166781544685364,
0.4960569441318512,
0.5538804531097412,
-0.23423810303211212,
0.8772380352020264,
0.6079565286636353,
-0.23995333909988403,
0.1471632570028305,
-0.3781789243221283,
0.1538429707288742,
-0.9551675319671631,
-0.09253603965044022,
-0.20992077887058258,
-0.3423294425010681,
-0.6092323064804077,
-0.7790880799293518,
0.4313846826553345,
0.25999125838279724,
0.25994929671287537,
0.43566301465034485,
-0.41370341181755066,
0.4853614568710327,
0.316035658121109,
-0.1752547323703766,
0.6512060761451721,
0.18348701298236847,
-0.5088748931884766,
-0.1536780446767807,
-0.972173810005188,
-0.31157150864601135,
1.0013755559921265,
0.3120649456977844,
0.9443525671958923,
0.049400266259908676,
0.9727602601051331,
0.08498746901750565,
0.23178531229496002,
-0.5668838024139404,
0.2955683469772339,
-0.45497366786003113,
-0.5423330664634705,
-0.11710301041603088,
-0.6057664155960083,
-0.877352237701416,
0.7144718766212463,
-0.003413648344576359,
-0.285950243473053,
0.20145952701568604,
0.18672193586826324,
-0.26628053188323975,
0.5083009004592896,
-0.58106529712677,
1.0345020294189453,
-0.7753121256828308,
-0.3784629702568054,
-0.21161313354969025,
-0.4759862720966339,
0.5037064552307129,
-0.2676854133605957,
0.6070078015327454,
-0.16128817200660706,
0.09507452696561813,
0.389212965965271,
-0.19300946593284607,
0.8895922899246216,
0.20598538219928741,
-0.47573724389076233,
0.0901704803109169,
0.3374529778957367,
0.3995240330696106,
-0.2181294560432434,
-0.07335858792066574,
0.4615801274776459,
-0.07141246646642685,
-0.2460106611251831,
-0.704341471195221,
0.7209960222244263,
-0.6921574473381042,
-0.650762677192688,
-0.3319002687931061,
-0.6339306235313416,
0.10482140630483627,
0.11857812851667404,
0.28025761246681213,
0.2573273777961731,
-0.212655708193779,
0.10662728548049927,
0.586515486240387,
-0.12061833590269089,
0.38137316703796387,
0.6090978384017944,
-0.5327244400978088,
-0.3460685610771179,
0.756936252117157,
0.016246609389781952,
0.6659225225448608,
0.7510368824005127,
0.19992081820964813,
-0.5428501963615417,
-0.5570517778396606,
-0.8508487343788147,
0.2809417247772217,
-0.6999794840812683,
-0.19918055832386017,
-0.8347469568252563,
-0.08789894729852676,
-0.3711448013782501,
-0.03462338075041771,
-0.6613742709159851,
-0.3728976249694824,
-0.2204800695180893,
-0.2085551917552948,
0.1555962711572647,
0.6836867928504944,
-0.38251572847366333,
0.09590691328048706,
-0.986842930316925,
0.4266647398471832,
0.2969513535499573,
-0.09648953378200531,
-0.18194858729839325,
-0.7854178547859192,
-0.31991520524024963,
0.10089364647865295,
-0.026048345491290092,
-0.6476892828941345,
0.7566295862197876,
0.04809603840112686,
0.6244933605194092,
0.20327460765838623,
0.15716779232025146,
1.0192692279815674,
-0.6349179148674011,
0.5451925992965698,
0.2634158730506897,
-0.8812774419784546,
0.32160669565200806,
-0.10359548777341843,
0.4855630695819855,
0.5711235404014587,
0.6018694043159485,
-0.5087153315544128,
-0.44030603766441345,
-0.14511503279209137,
-0.8568161725997925,
0.49372604489326477,
0.1320226490497589,
0.05594459921121597,
-0.009668425656855106,
0.05625850334763527,
0.3045089542865753,
0.09417194873094559,
-1.019623041152954,
-0.25019508600234985,
-0.21997246146202087,
-0.3300448954105377,
-0.12185295671224594,
-0.1292390674352646,
-0.1243903636932373,
-0.15411482751369476,
0.5531318783760071,
-0.2107165902853012,
-0.11512058973312378,
0.1582963466644287,
-0.5469566583633423,
0.06810945272445679,
0.3152669370174408,
0.16748656332492828,
0.416988730430603,
-0.09639399498701096,
0.6329159736633301,
0.5247599482536316,
-0.1671711504459381,
0.12938204407691956,
0.10818741470575333,
0.0053252424113452435,
-0.0333736427128315,
0.17518839240074158,
0.7901194095611572,
0.5055105686187744,
-0.3371666669845581,
0.1280834823846817,
-0.05014850199222565,
-0.03681904077529907,
-0.17193779349327087,
-0.26708951592445374,
0.41481754183769226,
0.11456160992383957,
0.4994395077228546,
-0.18658578395843506,
0.14570291340351105,
-0.5041407942771912,
0.14308016002178192,
0.41972652077674866,
-0.12883104383945465,
-0.3281779885292053,
0.805141031742096,
0.33625173568725586,
0.03645810857415199,
0.5361647605895996,
-0.20760475099086761,
-0.5462927222251892,
0.30157002806663513,
0.8299611210823059,
0.8442902565002441,
-0.2866988182067871,
-0.04973573982715607,
0.4387373626232147,
0.3462611734867096,
-0.03226589038968086,
-0.16237667202949524,
-0.13334637880325317,
-0.7687050700187683,
-0.4946146309375763,
-0.9591380953788757,
-0.20650431513786316,
0.032057687640190125,
-0.6145503520965576,
0.08351647108793259,
0.024814743548631668,
0.06053372472524643,
-0.2378087192773819,
-0.19138845801353455,
-0.6431611180305481,
-0.005315057933330536,
0.3511418104171753,
0.7392371296882629,
-0.7807511687278748,
1.045030117034912,
0.30805253982543945,
-0.2523866295814514,
-0.5366419553756714,
-0.3222525417804718,
0.008664287626743317,
-0.9079239368438721,
0.8896574974060059,
0.20420989394187927,
-0.45120128989219666,
0.07366210222244263,
-0.12268588691949844,
-0.8231040239334106,
1.2436209917068481,
0.4972197115421295,
-0.8446270823478699,
-0.18964175879955292,
0.4696912467479706,
0.5363125205039978,
-0.5305747389793396,
0.305341899394989,
0.41509774327278137,
0.31951650977134705,
0.23115666210651398,
-1.0733375549316406,
0.042088139802217484,
-0.3479309678077698,
0.07062872499227524,
0.04512326046824455,
-0.4254397749900818,
0.7779778838157654,
-0.10497648268938065,
-0.39364299178123474,
-0.2373875230550766,
0.6966689825057983,
0.4819261431694031,
0.0427258126437664,
0.5049241781234741,
0.6793183088302612,
0.6912105679512024,
0.053899191319942474,
1.08431875705719,
-0.4138171076774597,
0.19485042989253998,
1.342525839805603,
-0.24622341990470886,
0.9303164482116699,
0.5909287929534912,
-0.1261642873287201,
0.5412911772727966,
0.501725435256958,
0.06430689245462418,
0.5031209588050842,
0.10971654206514359,
-0.08276529610157013,
-0.5179956555366516,
0.021749421954154968,
-0.34270915389060974,
0.4777120053768158,
0.2731868028640747,
-0.25144925713539124,
-0.29758670926094055,
-0.023852935060858727,
0.001871147658675909,
0.13230940699577332,
-0.2091715931892395,
0.7726255655288696,
0.3573882579803467,
-0.6482788324356079,
0.871775209903717,
-0.10922719538211823,
1.1111247539520264,
-0.7489731311798096,
0.14568117260932922,
-0.3553188443183899,
0.302598237991333,
-0.10811619460582733,
-0.6243865489959717,
0.4811800420284271,
0.16773205995559692,
-0.18591755628585815,
-0.7797425985336304,
0.6000006198883057,
-0.8145878911018372,
-0.7266563773155212,
0.8274810910224915,
0.9108505845069885,
0.4179145097732544,
0.037657059729099274,
-0.6469841003417969,
-0.12493105977773666,
-0.06252072006464005,
-0.029662828892469406,
0.4978468418121338,
0.6749040484428406,
0.16126926243305206,
0.6909970641136169,
0.8092449903488159,
-0.01627829670906067,
0.35414060950279236,
0.11524228006601334,
0.7124098539352417,
-0.3618285655975342,
-0.4038720428943634,
-1.0854642391204834,
0.5716874599456787,
-0.019661029800772667,
0.009831174276769161,
0.9491379261016846,
0.7901656627655029,
1.020626425743103,
-0.09764762967824936,
0.7910916209220886,
0.16563338041305542,
0.19762739539146423,
-0.6247256398200989,
0.8874837160110474,
-0.8405164480209351,
0.3073238432407379,
0.053394485265016556,
-0.6367985010147095,
-0.10833587497472763,
0.5018072128295898,
-0.2864944040775299,
-0.23811574280261993,
0.582805871963501,
0.5602931380271912,
-0.2706453204154968,
-0.35816091299057007,
0.5187634229660034,
0.16265276074409485,
0.16732122004032135,
0.6679465770721436,
0.7194177508354187,
-0.4654066264629364,
0.8294402360916138,
-0.20191150903701782,
0.011388294398784637,
-0.03932392597198486,
-1.0391650199890137,
-1.117936134338379,
-0.37061169743537903,
-0.15967130661010742,
-0.00009368802420794964,
-0.11009722948074341,
0.7918954491615295,
0.7995833158493042,
-0.7573948502540588,
-0.584496021270752,
0.060753174126148224,
0.2389139086008072,
-0.17285573482513428,
-0.16371425986289978,
0.08156361430883408,
-0.4477090537548065,
-1.1027079820632935,
0.7698023915290833,
0.36400118470191956,
0.13831830024719238,
-0.6041993498802185,
-0.2263009250164032,
-0.23031015694141388,
-0.08956558257341385,
0.6074417233467102,
-0.0178823359310627,
-0.7863655686378479,
0.20684203505516052,
0.16251808404922485,
-0.3645130693912506,
0.35988497734069824,
0.5422506332397461,
-0.7863757610321045,
0.5478530526161194,
0.5754929184913635,
0.7233951687812805,
0.8144868612289429,
-0.16188527643680573,
0.9223714470863342,
-0.8456342220306396,
0.09132453799247742,
-0.06200214847922325,
0.5713896751403809,
0.5347157120704651,
-0.305989533662796,
0.5399395823478699,
0.10670001804828644,
-0.2575274705886841,
-0.8131972551345825,
0.1964665949344635,
-0.7990519404411316,
-0.32269832491874695,
0.896964967250824,
-0.316372275352478,
-0.30894535779953003,
-0.006393940653651953,
0.16291947662830353,
0.39651989936828613,
-0.12392459064722061,
0.7352902889251709,
0.5668179392814636,
0.007271552924066782,
-0.33411654829978943,
-0.5007049441337585,
0.25609341263771057,
0.4609868824481964,
-0.880478024482727,
0.1816956102848053,
0.2591099739074707,
0.45208773016929626,
0.30903175473213196,
0.5114854574203491,
-0.16758470237255096,
-0.269649863243103,
-0.21748416125774384,
0.27259573340415955,
-0.2343365103006363,
-0.29305335879325867,
-0.4065267741680145,
0.07589882612228394,
-0.2440805584192276,
-0.26674938201904297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12738v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12738v1 | Large Language Model as a Universal Clinical Multi-task Decoder | 2024-06-18T15:58:36 | 2024-06-18T15:58:36 | Yujiang Wu, Hongjian Song, Jiawen Zhang, Xumeng Wen, Shun Zheng, Jiang Bian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The development of effective machine learning methodologies for enhancing the
efficiency and accuracy of clinical systems is crucial. Despite significant
research efforts, managing a plethora of diversified clinical tasks and
adapting to emerging new tasks remain significant challenges. This paper
presents a novel paradigm that employs a pre-trained large language model as a
universal clinical multi-task decoder. This approach leverages the flexibility
and diversity of language expressions to handle task topic variations and
associated arguments. The introduction of a new task simply requires the
addition of a new instruction template. We validate this framework across
hundreds of tasks, demonstrating its robustness in facilitating multi-task
predictions, performing on par with traditional multi-task learning and
single-task learning approaches. Moreover, it shows exceptional adaptability to
new tasks, with impressive zero-shot performance in some instances and superior
data efficiency in few-shot scenarios. This novel approach offers a unified
solution to manage a wide array of new and emerging tasks in clinical
applications. | [
0.10003681480884552,
-0.5882711410522461,
0.6032118797302246,
0.279418021440506,
-0.3614899516105652,
-0.3728190064430237,
-0.4915854036808014,
-0.10670371353626251,
0.021985609084367752,
0.5667132139205933,
-0.4046463668346405,
-0.630894660949707,
-0.9989753365516663,
0.151253804564476,
-0.16475017368793488,
0.9629338383674622,
-0.030939729884266853,
0.5020872950553894,
0.027208009734749794,
-0.15659767389297485,
-0.6822256445884705,
-0.7076367139816284,
-0.5329079031944275,
-0.39062631130218506,
0.5854843854904175,
0.34823769330978394,
0.3538409471511841,
0.6769511103630066,
0.5490943193435669,
0.26183515787124634,
0.409405916929245,
0.09711801260709763,
-0.33081725239753723,
0.09523706883192062,
-0.1253339648246765,
-0.28286972641944885,
-0.7207945585250854,
-0.49909865856170654,
0.6067332625389099,
0.9437068700790405,
-0.35093238949775696,
-0.13326485455036163,
0.1362171471118927,
0.3247409164905548,
-0.8979237079620361,
0.32863080501556396,
-0.7517910003662109,
-0.02122950367629528,
-0.11383341997861862,
-0.22853118181228638,
-0.7404031753540039,
0.4398921728134155,
0.18366281688213348,
-0.6443742513656616,
0.14596165716648102,
-0.6408147811889648,
0.3146743178367615,
0.1564883440732956,
-0.6934587955474854,
-0.2978605031967163,
-0.6552320122718811,
0.6492112278938293,
-0.45742079615592957,
0.5362313389778137,
0.06708648800849915,
0.4525376856327057,
-0.12567126750946045,
-0.829686164855957,
-0.39745885133743286,
-0.15242178738117218,
0.13651028275489807,
0.06545590609312057,
-0.18957367539405823,
0.15047290921211243,
-0.07462019473314285,
-0.15628772974014282,
-0.6367993950843811,
0.22592617571353912,
-0.059052471071481705,
-0.13152340054512024,
0.3343220055103302,
0.4178857207298279,
0.41674259305000305,
0.0871887058019638,
-0.0844532698392868,
0.07485750317573547,
-0.5895014405250549,
-0.2348373532295227,
-0.5001729726791382,
0.571628987789154,
-0.12023421376943588,
0.22357037663459778,
-0.14336660504341125,
0.6358767151832581,
-0.16410136222839355,
-0.3998103439807892,
0.19827328622341156,
-0.021798577159643173,
-0.5254040360450745,
0.07781925797462463,
0.8172549605369568,
0.07270573824644089,
-0.15246982872486115,
-0.21439529955387115,
0.20399992167949677,
0.21023844182491302,
0.6753688454627991,
-0.8157814741134644,
-0.16064414381980896,
0.22774504125118256,
-0.4910772144794464,
-0.04763412103056908,
-0.308074414730072,
-0.6256319284439087,
-0.4040201008319855,
-0.3862728774547577,
0.26371297240257263,
-0.5990799069404602,
-0.2615344822406769,
0.6579495072364807,
0.35885709524154663,
-0.018489552661776543,
0.7178781032562256,
-0.8678446412086487,
0.20294365286827087,
0.6829468607902527,
0.5965812802314758,
-0.2653166353702545,
-0.48009464144706726,
-0.8497518301010132,
0.29610031843185425,
-0.29384762048721313,
0.56954026222229,
-0.5176708698272705,
-0.21715259552001953,
0.15732139348983765,
0.3307056128978729,
-0.3508443534374237,
-0.24361585080623627,
0.5340946912765503,
-0.21826967597007751,
0.04295313358306885,
0.05129505693912506,
-0.35170093178749084,
0.029126329347491264,
0.3497454524040222,
-0.49122530221939087,
0.2839377224445343,
0.17947261035442352,
-0.5058198571205139,
0.3174031376838684,
-0.8950890898704529,
-0.5225627422332764,
0.32895711064338684,
-0.16445830464363098,
-0.3284558951854706,
0.2080739289522171,
0.3265343904495239,
0.8117866516113281,
-0.39742711186408997,
0.496583491563797,
-0.3339044451713562,
-0.1492161750793457,
0.030856354162096977,
-0.337668240070343,
0.6613556146621704,
0.2673693299293518,
-0.18339215219020844,
0.27820104360580444,
-0.7185846567153931,
-0.05164635553956032,
0.12713460624217987,
-0.32120707631111145,
-0.14976228773593903,
-0.26895567774772644,
0.3610168993473053,
0.2298503816127777,
0.12808774411678314,
-0.5314491987228394,
0.2086995542049408,
0.001540529658086598,
0.41813600063323975,
0.26037296652793884,
-0.19639141857624054,
0.15837682783603668,
-0.24229486286640167,
0.7081247568130493,
0.09715939313173294,
0.16566430032253265,
-0.576598048210144,
-0.2239842414855957,
-0.48220157623291016,
-0.6202805638313293,
0.13483603298664093,
0.6952989101409912,
-0.6156831979751587,
0.2715703248977661,
-0.35789215564727783,
-0.4620395004749298,
-0.5765500068664551,
0.1197369247674942,
0.42841246724128723,
0.37279173731803894,
0.47220417857170105,
-0.2075190544128418,
-0.5653396844863892,
-0.5977173447608948,
-0.014890545979142189,
0.36852678656578064,
-0.09870699793100357,
0.0708698257803917,
0.5457140207290649,
-0.728706955909729,
0.2790294289588928,
-0.3782726526260376,
-0.40560320019721985,
-0.5601590871810913,
0.24390865862369537,
0.3128202557563782,
0.7298174500465393,
0.22127088904380798,
-0.660593569278717,
-0.43231576681137085,
0.1756536066532135,
-0.9949791431427002,
0.3533967435359955,
-0.4010688066482544,
-0.08067908883094788,
-0.041955552995204926,
0.4746747314929962,
-0.6204152703285217,
0.20307308435440063,
0.5206868052482605,
-0.06453961133956909,
0.5925034880638123,
-0.7350171804428101,
0.11723554879426956,
-1.3124027252197266,
0.1845962107181549,
-0.06336849182844162,
-0.12144884467124939,
-0.8885482549667358,
0.22157098352909088,
0.39126020669937134,
-0.266282856464386,
-0.41729095578193665,
0.3670767545700073,
-0.41452547907829285,
0.41886404156684875,
-0.5152663588523865,
-0.3387092053890228,
-0.11562959849834442,
0.2631109952926636,
0.22714710235595703,
0.28472957015037537,
0.9905164241790771,
-0.5460278391838074,
0.23205025494098663,
0.37597209215164185,
-0.21635283529758453,
0.6123459339141846,
-0.6628770232200623,
0.10959799587726593,
-0.5153321623802185,
0.5005718469619751,
-0.6997271180152893,
-0.46473175287246704,
-0.18404650688171387,
-0.25034308433532715,
0.5058550238609314,
-0.13092125952243805,
-0.48391327261924744,
-0.4165852963924408,
0.07683081924915314,
0.4063456356525421,
0.3303823173046112,
-0.2317114919424057,
0.6158708930015564,
0.3947940170764923,
-0.28177890181541443,
-0.7622156739234924,
-0.5424181222915649,
0.25597599148750305,
0.02442556619644165,
-0.2480466514825821,
0.3056568503379822,
-0.12167738378047943,
0.19388698041439056,
-0.19526934623718262,
0.00641515152528882,
-0.3274345099925995,
0.1770227998495102,
0.32985273003578186,
0.40887829661369324,
-0.38462668657302856,
0.3363167345523834,
0.21335197985172272,
-0.23724552989006042,
-0.17057766020298004,
-0.43211209774017334,
0.6433275938034058,
0.20215000212192535,
-0.45031678676605225,
-0.6245197653770447,
0.6701611280441284,
0.8614193201065063,
-0.3240944743156433,
0.7389020919799805,
0.6947530508041382,
-0.5486807823181152,
-0.059918418526649475,
-0.35377374291419983,
0.008433573879301548,
-0.3977908492088318,
0.9537074565887451,
-0.4159197211265564,
-1.0050110816955566,
0.12972146272659302,
-0.2022479921579361,
0.1813281625509262,
0.22489410638809204,
0.9488564133644104,
0.04531792923808098,
1.1857024431228638,
0.7416986227035522,
0.07617281377315521,
0.1574859321117401,
0.022380756214261055,
0.09237274527549744,
-0.7568606734275818,
-0.124148890376091,
-0.40324559807777405,
0.12399803847074509,
-0.16113895177841187,
-0.5874114036560059,
0.5778175592422485,
0.06684305518865585,
-0.3439164459705353,
0.1586121916770935,
-0.49880486726760864,
0.23475798964500427,
0.189838245511055,
0.2680968940258026,
0.222479447722435,
-0.1675877869129181,
-0.023102041333913803,
0.11756128817796707,
-0.6619468927383423,
-0.42625105381011963,
1.646409273147583,
0.3158324360847473,
0.5379288196563721,
-0.10653596371412277,
0.6453848481178284,
0.21896031498908997,
0.5857020616531372,
-0.5501463413238525,
0.2640152871608734,
-0.6265941858291626,
-0.5017656087875366,
-0.3026614785194397,
-0.1765867918729782,
-1.3277605772018433,
0.6384994983673096,
-0.3872927129268646,
-0.8019666075706482,
-0.2778245806694031,
0.2864060699939728,
-0.47074419260025024,
0.22579146921634674,
-0.5749471187591553,
1.3153340816497803,
-0.25677061080932617,
-0.18126678466796875,
-0.2078453153371811,
-0.6266363859176636,
0.2572001516819,
-0.24406036734580994,
0.33212512731552124,
-0.006099047139286995,
0.01560472883284092,
0.48848623037338257,
-0.07127650082111359,
0.8028013706207275,
-0.13523492217063904,
-0.13932570815086365,
-0.18238507211208344,
0.07616002857685089,
0.2512046694755554,
0.1213049441576004,
-0.044798269867897034,
-0.026487555354833603,
0.2133650779724121,
-0.6180236339569092,
-0.4746403992176056,
0.6060027480125427,
-0.6801896691322327,
-0.36086365580558777,
-0.3407934904098511,
-1.0491613149642944,
-0.5683872699737549,
0.43457725644111633,
0.2298678457736969,
0.7189989686012268,
-0.5269079208374023,
0.2284512221813202,
0.5353544354438782,
-0.3598138391971588,
0.031071456149220467,
0.6930981874465942,
0.18679767847061157,
-0.2977524399757385,
0.6508840322494507,
-0.44745832681655884,
0.28414982557296753,
0.7019204497337341,
0.12781819701194763,
-0.21884292364120483,
-0.9516352415084839,
-0.37624090909957886,
0.21869347989559174,
-0.6571792364120483,
0.00880907941609621,
-0.9737825393676758,
0.11208382993936539,
-0.7437486052513123,
-0.19956707954406738,
-0.33271729946136475,
0.14081817865371704,
-0.1939513087272644,
0.19481274485588074,
-0.056070465594530106,
0.5598873496055603,
0.1436852067708969,
0.46540987491607666,
-1.1507699489593506,
0.44181951880455017,
0.31195953488349915,
0.20003366470336914,
-0.0030295425094664097,
-0.3986198306083679,
-0.31221097707748413,
0.0809377059340477,
-0.2762276828289032,
-0.7924620509147644,
0.507219672203064,
0.21876969933509827,
0.6092763543128967,
0.38779348134994507,
-0.06342579424381256,
0.5274161696434021,
-0.9059801697731018,
0.456339955329895,
0.6967799663543701,
-0.8428749442100525,
0.3348690867424011,
-0.513900637626648,
0.6927723288536072,
0.4946025013923645,
0.5645139217376709,
-0.665669322013855,
-0.1543331742286682,
-0.2947540283203125,
-0.5420272350311279,
0.6342054009437561,
-0.38120096921920776,
0.23548439145088196,
0.04813694953918457,
0.0963904857635498,
0.5160266160964966,
0.28933417797088623,
-0.5739691853523254,
-0.07641772925853729,
-0.1416328251361847,
-0.5034113526344299,
-0.40638643503189087,
-0.0787140429019928,
-0.27886688709259033,
-0.32746225595474243,
0.16448141634464264,
-0.5536487698554993,
0.5489888787269592,
-0.057190537452697754,
-0.3830050826072693,
0.08258867263793945,
0.6584822535514832,
0.5912611484527588,
0.779812216758728,
-0.03737359121441841,
0.14296074211597443,
0.14232447743415833,
-0.5504187345504761,
0.05114853382110596,
0.18980318307876587,
0.3384481966495514,
-0.009805204346776009,
0.6602244973182678,
1.0107191801071167,
0.3435326814651489,
-0.9466018676757812,
0.5329050421714783,
-0.05096343532204628,
-0.37917184829711914,
-0.13078276813030243,
-0.14820827543735504,
0.13130556046962738,
0.1254439651966095,
0.20480558276176453,
0.07040511816740036,
0.0902882069349289,
-0.6907874345779419,
0.4703008532524109,
0.2767970561981201,
-0.5026780962944031,
-0.33277207612991333,
0.6131053566932678,
0.010828826576471329,
-0.09112086892127991,
0.3124494254589081,
-0.1899382323026657,
-0.4516323208808899,
0.48537084460258484,
0.9276198148727417,
0.6404570937156677,
-0.3755236864089966,
0.3691785931587219,
0.14171569049358368,
-0.028995951637625694,
-0.3382062315940857,
0.3693768382072449,
0.04022001847624779,
-0.6606766581535339,
-0.6828270554542542,
-0.4799255132675171,
-0.21416005492210388,
0.3970504403114319,
-0.7768407464027405,
0.15114055573940277,
-0.33947035670280457,
0.03453255072236061,
0.22348228096961975,
-0.4714828133583069,
-0.8684516549110413,
0.34851741790771484,
0.3660098910331726,
0.6283255219459534,
-0.6079203486442566,
1.3400263786315918,
0.7834745645523071,
-0.08913569897413254,
-0.5943838357925415,
-0.12138385325670242,
0.0984092652797699,
-0.9805747270584106,
0.5256620049476624,
0.20356103777885437,
0.21184870600700378,
-0.2510693371295929,
-0.12630513310432434,
-0.6372076869010925,
0.7706518769264221,
0.5944154262542725,
-0.5565491914749146,
-0.28240591287612915,
0.2076624482870102,
0.5867115259170532,
-0.720304548740387,
0.23627988994121552,
0.38443729281425476,
0.11937831342220306,
-0.021677285432815552,
-1.2545466423034668,
0.26894766092300415,
-0.2650960683822632,
-0.16762995719909668,
0.28420794010162354,
-0.11117316782474518,
1.021203875541687,
-0.3843083083629608,
0.14065617322921753,
0.1366344839334488,
0.23533238470554352,
0.10717238485813141,
0.2580091655254364,
0.4346749484539032,
0.31835177540779114,
0.7030108571052551,
0.15840403735637665,
1.0507889986038208,
-0.2992352247238159,
0.31931501626968384,
1.1663810014724731,
-0.6897860765457153,
0.719882607460022,
0.2154170721769333,
-0.1311471164226532,
0.3785281777381897,
-0.006896319333463907,
0.12872163951396942,
0.41597339510917664,
0.0762089192867279,
-0.29673194885253906,
-0.6711069345474243,
-0.10255440324544907,
-0.37767472863197327,
0.6888771653175354,
0.5835310816764832,
-0.2693369388580322,
-0.4923720359802246,
0.606563925743103,
-0.028994956985116005,
0.01226222887635231,
-0.38642027974128723,
0.6357651948928833,
0.03804274648427963,
-0.6826180815696716,
0.8230157494544983,
-0.11316251009702682,
0.659670889377594,
-0.9500119090080261,
-0.07490837574005127,
0.41107431054115295,
0.581608235836029,
0.054556552320718765,
-0.2654935121536255,
0.07603473216295242,
-0.1919097751379013,
-0.05350690707564354,
-0.25554829835891724,
0.45581990480422974,
-0.5378391146659851,
-0.5549424290657043,
0.23969179391860962,
0.5170807838439941,
-0.16620531678199768,
-0.25237011909484863,
-0.7432551980018616,
0.22498224675655365,
-0.0232086181640625,
0.27666062116622925,
0.7004363536834717,
0.619124710559845,
0.11967560648918152,
0.5991519093513489,
0.6243778467178345,
0.23274275660514832,
-0.0972704067826271,
0.11342012137174606,
0.6510034203529358,
-0.5925450325012207,
-0.7746472954750061,
-0.6327686905860901,
0.43761464953422546,
-0.0037782834842801094,
-0.4358270466327667,
0.47961047291755676,
0.21386851370334625,
0.42603588104248047,
-0.19705446064472198,
0.974065899848938,
0.1621856987476349,
0.5071808099746704,
-0.31128832697868347,
0.53892982006073,
-0.7482823729515076,
-0.11615217477083206,
-0.28226912021636963,
-0.2486109435558319,
-0.6161180138587952,
0.327303409576416,
-0.14333651959896088,
-0.16855549812316895,
1.0422451496124268,
0.42185571789741516,
-0.12494705617427826,
0.14898622035980225,
0.5178161263465881,
0.0860757902264595,
0.4271078407764435,
1.0111321210861206,
0.38191062211990356,
-0.16288544237613678,
0.44680649042129517,
-0.045558247715234756,
-0.3760121464729309,
-0.23933544754981995,
-0.770063042640686,
-0.8685306906700134,
-0.5540520548820496,
-0.30742523074150085,
-0.2693091630935669,
0.18117974698543549,
1.1481854915618896,
1.1066867113113403,
-1.017460823059082,
-0.25417855381965637,
0.09415363520383835,
-0.4365794062614441,
-0.4926953613758087,
-0.08078259974718094,
0.518591582775116,
-0.5738862156867981,
-0.5981366634368896,
0.3947966396808624,
0.3848365545272827,
-0.28898948431015015,
0.02780766971409321,
-0.05416438728570938,
-0.011460719630122185,
-0.30371060967445374,
0.8642281889915466,
0.2967614531517029,
-0.5681324601173401,
0.23091238737106323,
-0.00475388765335083,
-0.23477983474731445,
0.02913770265877247,
1.1882939338684082,
-0.4709402918815613,
0.5889955759048462,
-0.03623690828680992,
1.091802716255188,
0.5415602326393127,
-0.46508708596229553,
0.6804689764976501,
-0.2901289165019989,
0.4265556037425995,
0.4884735941886902,
0.5243240594863892,
0.2223423421382904,
-0.3097825348377228,
0.002574986545369029,
0.11000026762485504,
-0.3252595067024231,
-0.8699156045913696,
0.3309956192970276,
-1.2000353336334229,
-0.582182765007019,
0.901788055896759,
-0.3691105246543884,
-0.0449068620800972,
-0.43120333552360535,
-0.1293485462665558,
0.258933961391449,
-0.30176758766174316,
0.7500835061073303,
0.39013054966926575,
-0.15572115778923035,
-0.11393475532531738,
-0.6214964985847473,
0.21818891167640686,
0.48621100187301636,
-1.0381684303283691,
0.141044020652771,
0.4822964370250702,
0.39294540882110596,
0.07805829495191574,
0.8821114301681519,
-0.21630960702896118,
0.5993603467941284,
-0.14259685575962067,
0.10165837407112122,
-0.08130538463592529,
-0.4776420295238495,
-0.35708510875701904,
0.4823705852031708,
-0.11844538897275925,
-0.27756279706954956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12725v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12725v1 | Can Large Language Models Code Like a Linguist?: A Case Study in Low Resource Sound Law Induction | 2024-06-18T15:46:04 | 2024-06-18T15:46:04 | Atharva Naik, Kexun Zhang, Nathaniel Robinson, Aravind Mysore, Clayton Marr, Hong Sng Rebecca Byrnes, Anna Cai, Kalvin Chang, David Mortensen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Historical linguists have long written a kind of incompletely formalized
''program'' that converts reconstructed words in an ancestor language into
words in one of its attested descendants that consist of a series of ordered
string rewrite functions (called sound laws). They do this by observing pairs
of words in the reconstructed language (protoforms) and the descendent language
(reflexes) and constructing a program that transforms protoforms into reflexes.
However, writing these programs is error-prone and time-consuming. Prior work
has successfully scaffolded this process computationally, but fewer researchers
have tackled Sound Law Induction (SLI), which we approach in this paper by
casting it as Programming by Examples. We propose a language-agnostic solution
that utilizes the programming ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) by
generating Python sound law programs from sound change examples. We evaluate
the effectiveness of our approach for various LLMs, propose effective methods
to generate additional language-agnostic synthetic data to fine-tune LLMs for
SLI, and compare our method with existing automated SLI methods showing that
while LLMs lag behind them they can complement some of their weaknesses. | [
0.14673706889152527,
-0.5834323167800903,
0.6769605875015259,
0.0371783971786499,
-0.029152067378163338,
-0.14538009464740753,
-0.49433600902557373,
-0.4629686176776886,
0.3018643856048584,
0.6212767362594604,
-0.6305489540100098,
-0.14078108966350555,
-0.3227529227733612,
0.0878928154706955,
-0.5751239061355591,
0.7089512944221497,
0.22706127166748047,
0.004129587206989527,
0.2436503916978836,
-0.23425640165805817,
-0.06594819575548172,
-0.40266793966293335,
-0.47115445137023926,
-0.41444912552833557,
0.06554032862186432,
0.009557006880640984,
0.5617524981498718,
0.6879777908325195,
0.03187495097517967,
0.28484493494033813,
-0.32725217938423157,
-0.02129017561674118,
-0.40139806270599365,
-0.05073218420147896,
-0.17944994568824768,
-0.6720443367958069,
-0.2889408767223358,
-0.03627985715866089,
0.5250420570373535,
0.9121097326278687,
-0.4233532249927521,
0.1641400009393692,
-0.11788756400346756,
0.36080238223075867,
-0.6358255743980408,
0.31754058599472046,
-0.8591688871383667,
0.0700823962688446,
0.04027621075510979,
-0.3802667558193207,
-0.6314824819564819,
-0.4461655616760254,
-0.2827276587486267,
-0.6134107112884521,
0.09221363067626953,
0.04480656608939171,
0.44579795002937317,
0.557979166507721,
0.0567871518433094,
-0.7406145334243774,
-0.8567875027656555,
0.9262338876724243,
-1.2863129377365112,
0.32240790128707886,
0.09586305171251297,
-0.06698641926050186,
-0.5888060927391052,
-0.32341110706329346,
-0.7866455316543579,
-0.3767209053039551,
-0.010186468251049519,
-0.12378758192062378,
-0.21701981127262115,
0.09832243621349335,
0.6831573247909546,
0.22801749408245087,
-0.5596678853034973,
0.3157351315021515,
-0.4189631938934326,
-0.1537175178527832,
0.7090368866920471,
0.19449210166931152,
0.35440194606781006,
-0.12691771984100342,
0.4051368832588196,
-0.006528783123940229,
-0.8723805546760559,
-0.08915930986404419,
0.4072972536087036,
0.6261539459228516,
-0.3185611963272095,
0.6396950483322144,
-0.19868789613246918,
0.6125288009643555,
0.04713001474738121,
-0.5159207582473755,
0.32736140489578247,
-0.28827255964279175,
0.032454829663038254,
0.5742818117141724,
0.7189522385597229,
-0.15203572809696198,
0.6490427255630493,
-0.11813081800937653,
-0.6216943860054016,
0.20918110013008118,
-0.016786783933639526,
-0.7144088745117188,
-0.031439218670129776,
0.245599165558815,
-0.6134824156761169,
-0.24427849054336548,
-0.49514514207839966,
-0.3079089820384979,
-0.6731613278388977,
-0.5265533924102783,
0.25351133942604065,
-0.3684239089488983,
-0.5016816854476929,
0.23702223598957062,
-0.021890895441174507,
0.5061505436897278,
-0.09577374160289764,
-1.2058236598968506,
0.20872263610363007,
0.9197613000869751,
0.6736530661582947,
0.43860960006713867,
-0.3606660068035126,
-0.6025375127792358,
0.09230270981788635,
-0.4814968407154083,
0.3275354504585266,
-0.5688473582267761,
-0.5235965251922607,
0.34290581941604614,
-0.21639104187488556,
0.2611656188964844,
-0.659491777420044,
0.2744429409503937,
-0.23243172466754913,
-0.31632712483406067,
0.2920786738395691,
-0.4944444000720978,
0.3881596624851227,
-0.3062601387500763,
-0.5922154188156128,
0.5531561374664307,
0.27529841661453247,
-0.4177241623401642,
0.37275171279907227,
-0.6739712357521057,
-0.7107668519020081,
-0.03293641656637192,
-0.4418727457523346,
-0.34357401728630066,
0.48340463638305664,
-0.03376297280192375,
0.24162332713603973,
-0.29777979850769043,
0.5171140432357788,
-0.375413715839386,
-0.630804181098938,
0.2590213716030121,
-0.3225235342979431,
1.0950490236282349,
0.3429989218711853,
-0.44052454829216003,
-0.12819497287273407,
-0.7547094225883484,
0.061948977410793304,
0.09021199494600296,
-0.5795894861221313,
-0.2541923522949219,
0.07297663390636444,
-0.18495479226112366,
-0.020119618624448776,
-0.1368640512228012,
-0.5795612335205078,
0.5766950249671936,
-0.6606729030609131,
0.85441654920578,
0.5869857668876648,
-0.25400596857070923,
0.4574579894542694,
-0.2890996038913727,
0.3282408118247986,
-0.19729579985141754,
-0.2131112664937973,
-0.281745582818985,
-0.29450753331184387,
-0.7333204746246338,
-0.039634596556425095,
0.2841731905937195,
0.38712844252586365,
-0.607944905757904,
0.17977184057235718,
-0.5285683870315552,
-0.22458525002002716,
-0.8505933880805969,
0.2502281963825226,
0.27670416235923767,
0.12522073090076447,
0.08811148256063461,
0.12065133452415466,
-0.8877207040786743,
-0.7458450794219971,
-0.345791220664978,
-0.4562748968601227,
-0.13125191628932953,
0.24495165050029755,
0.39705049991607666,
-0.22373516857624054,
0.5969172120094299,
-0.24175123870372772,
0.08403228968381882,
-0.32829180359840393,
0.4270864725112915,
0.7633388042449951,
0.4544682800769806,
0.5870838761329651,
-0.31253060698509216,
-0.02966845966875553,
0.02211710996925831,
-0.741984486579895,
-0.4877644181251526,
-0.2330232411623001,
0.14151811599731445,
0.2889538109302521,
0.6686728596687317,
-0.6215677261352539,
0.32787731289863586,
0.3471098244190216,
-0.16757570207118988,
0.9207427501678467,
-0.25780680775642395,
-0.06556662917137146,
-0.7583876252174377,
0.05495661497116089,
0.0419587641954422,
0.07802202552556992,
-0.862345814704895,
0.286822110414505,
-0.19047436118125916,
-0.3308262228965759,
-0.5178833603858948,
0.40243446826934814,
-0.4074077904224396,
-0.2579832375049591,
-0.6821200251579285,
-0.3166012763977051,
-0.6016750931739807,
0.409024715423584,
0.31640902161598206,
0.6400669813156128,
0.6546291708946228,
-0.6649366021156311,
0.39845916628837585,
-0.10792694985866547,
-0.4080197811126709,
0.2953640818595886,
-0.5577157139778137,
0.0740543007850647,
-0.10262221843004227,
0.07266777753829956,
-0.3015032708644867,
-0.23134812712669373,
-0.07479354739189148,
-0.10394702106714249,
0.3303029239177704,
-0.4146542549133301,
-0.6381819844245911,
-0.29088908433914185,
0.02688165381550789,
0.673632800579071,
1.071786880493164,
-0.5363357067108154,
0.6025612354278564,
0.441243439912796,
-0.184305801987648,
-0.4912140369415283,
-0.5973327159881592,
0.12090332806110382,
-0.2259645313024521,
-0.40233543515205383,
0.07743247598409653,
-0.07998036593198776,
-0.7637506723403931,
-0.014415403828024864,
0.15211091935634613,
-0.22512969374656677,
0.09301242232322693,
0.22167953848838806,
-0.11678038537502289,
-0.6243121027946472,
-0.009031673893332481,
-0.08897155523300171,
0.20242111384868622,
0.16390913724899292,
-0.6587521433830261,
0.5885420441627502,
-0.023320507258176804,
-0.4277217388153076,
-0.5987871885299683,
0.2511650025844574,
0.9476621747016907,
-0.0831722691655159,
0.1820385903120041,
0.2478468269109726,
-0.30192965269088745,
-0.652002215385437,
-0.5378772020339966,
-0.21204163134098053,
-0.48468685150146484,
0.08506649732589722,
-0.38880521059036255,
-0.6943392157554626,
0.41209426522254944,
-0.24767212569713593,
0.06809640675783157,
0.17072133719921112,
0.7963699102401733,
0.13349108397960663,
0.6547178030014038,
0.6759147047996521,
-0.3854804039001465,
0.44576022028923035,
-0.2665949761867523,
0.24580322206020355,
-0.38427576422691345,
0.11786855757236481,
-0.6026401519775391,
-0.28196588158607483,
-0.6202401518821716,
-0.3187503218650818,
0.22761274874210358,
-0.1289970725774765,
-0.25819164514541626,
0.5570095181465149,
-0.39232322573661804,
0.6689794659614563,
0.6170583963394165,
-0.12693645060062408,
0.11672316491603851,
0.04339861497282982,
0.05385010316967964,
0.1979653686285019,
-0.8477181792259216,
-0.23388220369815826,
1.110345482826233,
0.0610995851457119,
1.1150168180465698,
0.02540082298219204,
1.1346007585525513,
0.4118473529815674,
0.09919094294309616,
-0.9914491772651672,
0.5786641836166382,
-0.15293128788471222,
-0.3223528563976288,
-0.41575881838798523,
-0.456402987241745,
-0.80189049243927,
0.00231271144002676,
-0.24429459869861603,
-0.7532395124435425,
0.3838353455066681,
0.19983811676502228,
-0.409004807472229,
0.32015877962112427,
-0.42643436789512634,
0.4001123905181885,
-0.22627395391464233,
-0.3968442678451538,
-0.45229601860046387,
-0.18650782108306885,
0.45990556478500366,
-0.30444300174713135,
0.558536171913147,
-0.028668472543358803,
0.5690113306045532,
0.666658341884613,
-0.7167426347732544,
0.8826420903205872,
-0.394871324300766,
-0.49634113907814026,
0.6714313626289368,
0.38744473457336426,
0.6431198716163635,
-0.20284084975719452,
-0.31313198804855347,
-0.03279239311814308,
-0.036494433879852295,
-0.2634718120098114,
-0.6281391382217407,
0.789093017578125,
-0.5392071008682251,
-0.6686539649963379,
-0.14847910404205322,
-0.8396298885345459,
0.06051022559404373,
0.14832431077957153,
-0.02811576798558235,
0.5293379426002502,
0.13476049900054932,
-0.08655178546905518,
0.5246019959449768,
-0.20145165920257568,
0.7443858981132507,
0.7485447525978088,
0.10441193729639053,
-0.027357840910553932,
0.9837605357170105,
0.02227144129574299,
-0.09198804944753647,
0.12077025324106216,
0.38520097732543945,
-0.19023767113685608,
-0.8008795380592346,
-0.29549166560173035,
0.40703415870666504,
-0.5024188160896301,
0.15591900050640106,
-0.14758850634098053,
-0.2301805466413498,
-0.5192840695381165,
-0.2834250330924988,
-0.4131214916706085,
-0.32160133123397827,
0.08183806389570236,
0.36806198954582214,
0.1331896036863327,
0.8431761860847473,
-0.19802814722061157,
0.0650414451956749,
-0.443535178899765,
0.43594101071357727,
0.1311810314655304,
0.3216466009616852,
-0.032540738582611084,
-0.6891183257102966,
-0.14221110939979553,
0.18496322631835938,
0.13714246451854706,
-0.4768308401107788,
0.28103208541870117,
0.402342289686203,
0.6161362528800964,
0.34330520033836365,
0.1301822066307068,
0.7955225110054016,
-0.9301071763038635,
0.578988790512085,
0.40010717511177063,
-1.116955280303955,
0.6498332619667053,
-0.1770707666873932,
0.25871819257736206,
0.27721697092056274,
-0.12763924896717072,
-0.3911273181438446,
-0.796145498752594,
-0.4679076671600342,
-0.5768879652023315,
0.6359784603118896,
0.043199148029088974,
0.26396504044532776,
0.13883645832538605,
0.5944215059280396,
0.043690986931324005,
0.18761524558067322,
-0.7331870198249817,
0.3227454721927643,
-0.20394019782543182,
-0.25755712389945984,
-0.016233021393418312,
-0.16112211346626282,
0.05088574439287186,
-0.2518713176250458,
0.6108986139297485,
-0.21033921837806702,
-0.06704343855381012,
-0.03513135015964508,
-0.3725661635398865,
-0.050626955926418304,
0.6518580317497253,
0.8424590229988098,
0.6001784205436707,
0.10010739415884018,
0.14945711195468903,
0.15551243722438812,
-0.26735350489616394,
0.44174450635910034,
-0.3383566439151764,
-0.36378875374794006,
-0.008848515339195728,
0.582794725894928,
0.609197735786438,
0.17273148894309998,
-0.8836073875427246,
0.5629673004150391,
0.33885762095451355,
-0.416668176651001,
-0.5964019894599915,
0.1955862194299698,
0.07292003184556961,
0.4084222912788391,
0.2374199628829956,
-0.4026423990726471,
0.0803612694144249,
-0.9052929282188416,
0.1888704001903534,
0.5095283389091492,
-0.16436010599136353,
-0.4201579689979553,
0.929673433303833,
0.11109314113855362,
-0.450687974691391,
0.7794533967971802,
-0.2787950336933136,
-0.23773370683193207,
0.5212883353233337,
0.7854235768318176,
0.7816558480262756,
-0.1313764899969101,
-0.25428104400634766,
0.31829988956451416,
0.4776836037635803,
-0.3458212614059448,
0.45132729411125183,
-0.03776407614350319,
-0.5800612568855286,
-0.9473448395729065,
-0.9216009974479675,
-0.2323567420244217,
0.4849891662597656,
-0.4657234847545624,
0.3482646346092224,
-0.5160496234893799,
-0.006123080383986235,
0.3044608533382416,
-0.4583406150341034,
-0.4627053737640381,
-0.20721054077148438,
0.6614513993263245,
0.7734257578849792,
-1.0646686553955078,
0.9399546980857849,
0.5267232656478882,
-0.3799852132797241,
-0.7911561131477356,
0.019548088312149048,
0.07577981054782867,
-0.6976185441017151,
0.8968974947929382,
-0.17378616333007812,
-0.4120512306690216,
-0.21314558386802673,
-0.6962012052536011,
-0.5114684104919434,
0.6748696565628052,
0.6296597123146057,
-0.616235613822937,
-0.20036084949970245,
0.3421142101287842,
0.6873353719711304,
-0.38106900453567505,
0.0860869511961937,
0.8191391825675964,
0.3208780884742737,
-0.12287838757038116,
-1.2522788047790527,
0.10981898009777069,
-0.36401206254959106,
-0.08507830649614334,
0.11781225353479385,
-0.22564248740673065,
0.804977536201477,
-0.46487995982170105,
-0.17662008106708527,
0.2803235352039337,
0.5553572773933411,
0.30831143260002136,
0.22636084258556366,
0.4690118432044983,
0.5460211634635925,
0.6802479028701782,
-0.006577043794095516,
0.9894155263900757,
-0.7874614596366882,
0.12385987490415573,
1.0391192436218262,
-0.5866249203681946,
0.7589938044548035,
0.577815055847168,
-0.21123969554901123,
0.5597768425941467,
-0.011521215550601482,
-0.25845855474472046,
0.3168984353542328,
0.8041198253631592,
-0.2766338884830475,
-0.3705042898654938,
-0.2498900145292282,
-0.019100017845630646,
0.6840923428535461,
0.3392958641052246,
-0.4558769166469574,
-0.12416321039199829,
-0.008159603923559189,
-0.1550416350364685,
0.08761274814605713,
-0.6132487654685974,
0.7654861807823181,
0.24454078078269958,
-0.5755897164344788,
1.0802936553955078,
-0.11676111817359924,
0.7496353983879089,
-0.4577963650226593,
-0.0973588228225708,
-0.0979660302400589,
0.20242929458618164,
-0.30275315046310425,
-0.6635197401046753,
0.14068451523780823,
0.10855548828840256,
-0.23803436756134033,
0.041348010301589966,
0.5643405318260193,
-0.3240414261817932,
-0.4366815686225891,
0.07802943140268326,
0.30259665846824646,
0.5051905512809753,
0.3619599938392639,
-0.31002578139305115,
0.08262263238430023,
-0.11720319837331772,
0.10777684301137924,
0.07475606352090836,
0.28945788741111755,
-0.03898077458143234,
0.8741880059242249,
0.6613954305648804,
0.7445294857025146,
0.1752120405435562,
0.15630780160427094,
0.6315781474113464,
-0.7383411526679993,
-0.6799384355545044,
-0.9806746244430542,
0.12492542713880539,
0.07694867253303528,
0.07481405138969421,
0.397691547870636,
0.6050726771354675,
0.75941401720047,
-0.327076256275177,
1.1184226274490356,
0.06468065083026886,
0.21843039989471436,
-0.7248315215110779,
0.7302802205085754,
-0.37836024165153503,
0.286729633808136,
-0.11077918857336044,
-0.9374091625213623,
-0.19139136373996735,
0.38913244009017944,
-0.05690068379044533,
-0.41620805859565735,
0.47845396399497986,
1.0850754976272583,
-0.32142874598503113,
-0.11697519570589066,
0.37802234292030334,
0.34418466687202454,
0.11021829396486282,
0.7308908700942993,
0.8909493088722229,
0.06924368441104889,
0.6280665993690491,
-0.08999959379434586,
-0.043398432433605194,
-0.2433423101902008,
-0.5264123678207397,
-0.6980907917022705,
-0.3568517863750458,
-0.5146340727806091,
-0.44450104236602783,
0.04628721997141838,
0.9323785901069641,
0.62595134973526,
-0.9971470236778259,
-0.7203971743583679,
-0.12597590684890747,
-0.1227952316403389,
-0.21506266295909882,
-0.14733000099658966,
0.29206791520118713,
-0.35457903146743774,
-0.7884312272071838,
0.8242111206054688,
0.08182188868522644,
0.128031924366951,
-0.40868231654167175,
-0.37947648763656616,
0.2700680196285248,
0.24456444382667542,
0.6240009665489197,
0.7466857433319092,
-1.029403567314148,
-0.21927541494369507,
-0.4196493923664093,
0.015307513996958733,
-0.046248652040958405,
1.2680517435073853,
-0.6567115187644958,
0.3967081904411316,
0.42604637145996094,
0.47523075342178345,
0.2664532959461212,
-0.29129552841186523,
0.5559197664260864,
-0.5343342423439026,
0.445419579744339,
0.3314932882785797,
0.7404672503471375,
-0.06783155351877213,
-0.08218543976545334,
0.4196414053440094,
0.2565684914588928,
-0.503458559513092,
-1.0931415557861328,
0.5762399435043335,
-0.7689117193222046,
-0.3877232074737549,
1.4526286125183105,
0.018771659582853317,
-0.5036203265190125,
-0.06595243513584137,
0.0863952487707138,
0.17593294382095337,
-0.26191389560699463,
0.7209712862968445,
0.3702054023742676,
-0.11584628373384476,
-0.026184793561697006,
-0.4860594868659973,
0.5503126978874207,
0.17818157374858856,
-0.2569319009780884,
0.3079099655151367,
0.44921737909317017,
0.36313891410827637,
0.4544016718864441,
0.6196264624595642,
-0.13389040529727936,
0.30262303352355957,
0.47493964433670044,
0.4135463833808899,
-0.06965026259422302,
-0.05838407948613167,
-0.5442418456077576,
0.02424570918083191,
0.40295109152793884,
0.4374712109565735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12719v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12719v1 | On the Robustness of Language Models for Tabular Question Answering | 2024-06-18T15:41:15 | 2024-06-18T15:41:15 | Kushal Raj Bhandari, Sixue Xing, Soham Dan, Jianxi Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs), originally shown to ace various text
comprehension tasks have also remarkably been shown to tackle table
comprehension tasks without specific training. While previous research has
explored LLM capabilities with tabular dataset tasks, our study assesses the
influence of $\textit{in-context learning}$,$ \textit{model scale}$,
$\textit{instruction tuning}$, and $\textit{domain biases}$ on Tabular Question
Answering (TQA). We evaluate the robustness of LLMs on Wikipedia-based
$\textbf{WTQ}$ and financial report-based $\textbf{TAT-QA}$ TQA datasets,
focusing on their ability to robustly interpret tabular data under various
augmentations and perturbations. Our findings indicate that instructions
significantly enhance performance, with recent models like Llama3 exhibiting
greater robustness over earlier versions. However, data contamination and
practical reliability issues persist, especially with WTQ. We highlight the
need for improved methodologies, including structure-aware self-attention
mechanisms and better handling of domain-specific tabular data, to develop more
reliable LLMs for table comprehension. | [
-0.04552139341831207,
-1.1748236417770386,
0.6852291822433472,
0.04464451223611832,
-0.16286920011043549,
-0.014638938009738922,
-0.09593110531568527,
-0.2835901975631714,
-0.4341960549354553,
0.5605056285858154,
-0.3107776641845703,
-0.5928238034248352,
-0.15574109554290771,
0.02909483201801777,
-0.5478312969207764,
1.088085412979126,
-0.18849614262580872,
0.17446373403072357,
-0.5434867143630981,
0.022816333919763565,
-0.603590726852417,
-0.3629077970981598,
-0.2865090072154999,
-0.08752661198377609,
0.5143622756004333,
0.6165037751197815,
0.8511939644813538,
1.0215034484863281,
0.6009818911552429,
0.27269428968429565,
-0.031996458768844604,
-0.034617356956005096,
-0.6039900779724121,
0.40168294310569763,
-0.12016454339027405,
-0.6042857766151428,
-0.6741614937782288,
-0.23322544991970062,
0.5872512459754944,
0.619460940361023,
-0.5011410117149353,
0.31997808814048767,
0.15410079061985016,
0.7364915609359741,
-0.23617225885391235,
0.3803819715976715,
-1.1493631601333618,
-0.17643634974956512,
-0.06871499866247177,
-0.047110363841056824,
-0.5010862350463867,
-0.34175750613212585,
0.09640747308731079,
-0.6177256107330322,
-0.02215580828487873,
0.21804404258728027,
0.8758682608604431,
0.3642522990703583,
-0.4372839629650116,
-0.22457125782966614,
-0.6593950986862183,
0.5605838298797607,
-0.7885696887969971,
0.5101748108863831,
0.5912297368049622,
0.32994943857192993,
-0.20957501232624054,
-0.8324658274650574,
-0.5279020071029663,
-0.41924136877059937,
0.04354783892631531,
-0.01786208152770996,
-0.03515058010816574,
0.01347084529697895,
0.45715731382369995,
0.2670496702194214,
-0.7924622297286987,
0.29473593831062317,
-0.16950790584087372,
-0.03475983813405037,
0.10624874383211136,
0.2947233021259308,
0.4322429299354553,
-0.24078860878944397,
-0.3499840199947357,
-0.037952203303575516,
-0.8064731955528259,
0.16731363534927368,
0.03548068180680275,
0.31023114919662476,
-0.1278635412454605,
0.5290578007698059,
-0.2639172375202179,
0.9064774513244629,
-0.19695542752742767,
-0.3427869975566864,
-0.18293386697769165,
-0.2819831669330597,
-0.4604078531265259,
-0.46551430225372314,
0.486689954996109,
0.10516201704740524,
0.42070549726486206,
-0.5442290902137756,
-0.1919194757938385,
-0.15796580910682678,
0.46366533637046814,
-0.47976988554000854,
-0.15577588975429535,
0.3323650360107422,
-0.20281516015529633,
-0.2548668682575226,
-0.04454084113240242,
-0.7187229990959167,
-0.12665826082229614,
-0.2900056838989258,
0.6104542016983032,
-0.2142387479543686,
0.2684440314769745,
-0.2611982524394989,
0.3128742277622223,
0.6300498843193054,
0.28578394651412964,
-1.0276830196380615,
0.20734763145446777,
0.7827880382537842,
0.4989052712917328,
-0.19660449028015137,
-0.331800252199173,
-0.8228062987327576,
0.2978631556034088,
-0.5043712258338928,
0.8909748792648315,
-0.4381542205810547,
0.024025527760386467,
0.03149978443980217,
-0.07769788801670074,
-0.15118622779846191,
-0.5125508308410645,
0.43529391288757324,
-0.8406170010566711,
0.007928574457764626,
-0.5962271690368652,
-0.472677081823349,
-0.038912612944841385,
0.3796604871749878,
-0.8764784336090088,
0.7352126240730286,
0.3048814833164215,
-0.83118736743927,
0.45866063237190247,
-0.26943981647491455,
-0.4025167226791382,
-0.09598355740308762,
-0.06431042402982712,
-0.42875778675079346,
-0.11318875849246979,
0.4573739469051361,
0.48757779598236084,
-0.3119557499885559,
0.20104214549064636,
-0.5199508666992188,
-0.3306732475757599,
0.6023336052894592,
-0.48383623361587524,
0.4547605812549591,
0.04651407524943352,
-0.12091124802827835,
0.03517570346593857,
-0.5523869395256042,
0.19664017856121063,
-0.029741115868091583,
-0.447417289018631,
0.1737886369228363,
0.04631343483924866,
-0.09244504570960999,
0.05480477586388588,
0.027956189587712288,
-0.10117361694574356,
-0.07231748849153519,
-0.18942409753799438,
0.5212451815605164,
0.7563452124595642,
0.022030876949429512,
0.3615680932998657,
-0.5166650414466858,
0.8043860793113708,
-0.01448877528309822,
-0.035814519971609116,
0.061002183705568314,
-0.24696096777915955,
-0.3276588022708893,
-0.027546584606170654,
0.5416600704193115,
0.7822535037994385,
-1.044514775276184,
-0.07505618780851364,
-0.39308810234069824,
-0.36205947399139404,
0.06724703311920166,
0.3089247941970825,
0.27320343255996704,
0.9605644941329956,
0.3297940790653229,
0.04900465905666351,
-0.13573519885540009,
-0.9750688672065735,
-0.33288174867630005,
-0.31700271368026733,
-0.10166539251804352,
0.35889720916748047,
0.4093821942806244,
0.08697187900543213,
0.7051474452018738,
-0.19346992671489716,
0.03357435017824173,
-0.5823647975921631,
-0.259931355714798,
0.26358774304389954,
0.2128559798002243,
0.32451537251472473,
-0.6100034117698669,
-0.7257313132286072,
0.017537938430905342,
-0.6212018132209778,
-0.018509641289711,
-0.04981684684753418,
-0.15474160015583038,
0.35942161083221436,
0.2912040054798126,
-0.6724258065223694,
0.2709513306617737,
0.31034690141677856,
-0.16134333610534668,
0.46719059348106384,
-0.04574110358953476,
-0.004871488083153963,
-1.0568106174468994,
0.09949098527431488,
0.1267528086900711,
-0.2996180057525635,
-0.995619535446167,
0.18792888522148132,
0.31521034240722656,
0.01698845997452736,
-0.4872851073741913,
0.27168264985084534,
-0.373956561088562,
-0.3043920397758484,
-0.11987711489200592,
0.3037678897380829,
0.17841000854969025,
0.43030762672424316,
-0.19493266940116882,
1.043765902519226,
0.48521560430526733,
-0.5126553773880005,
0.13144615292549133,
0.39498192071914673,
-0.5523099899291992,
0.533976137638092,
-0.771325945854187,
0.1742507964372635,
-0.2117786556482315,
0.0002661057224031538,
-0.9998229742050171,
-0.3511456549167633,
0.1508013755083084,
-0.3909534811973572,
0.7267612218856812,
-0.003047678153961897,
-0.38841065764427185,
-0.2743302881717682,
-0.3546348214149475,
0.03335569053888321,
0.20716089010238647,
-0.4521421194076538,
0.5795949101448059,
0.44255849719047546,
-0.24837934970855713,
-0.9581515192985535,
-0.7864434123039246,
0.14374268054962158,
-0.4766941964626312,
-0.48947569727897644,
0.025942765176296234,
0.0119388522580266,
-0.5006677508354187,
-0.21654130518436432,
-0.5196055769920349,
-0.35807332396507263,
0.2683219313621521,
-0.03094947710633278,
0.4734993278980255,
-0.263993501663208,
0.1579585075378418,
-0.13035671412944794,
0.16325749456882477,
0.18804043531417847,
-0.005197169724851847,
0.35059115290641785,
-0.14504358172416687,
0.04697561636567116,
-0.41271883249282837,
0.05709383264183998,
0.5165432691574097,
-0.127628356218338,
0.9209148287773132,
0.4216015040874481,
-0.35115519165992737,
-0.38093462586402893,
-0.5568004846572876,
-0.12823592126369476,
-0.4853854775428772,
0.47048652172088623,
-0.3261224627494812,
-0.9165659546852112,
0.813926100730896,
0.5205849409103394,
0.036686383187770844,
0.3674570620059967,
0.6169297099113464,
-0.49161162972450256,
0.4194452464580536,
0.28783923387527466,
-0.30539005994796753,
0.2807251513004303,
0.0646926537156105,
0.008219661191105843,
-0.7442254424095154,
-0.1253870278596878,
-0.891485869884491,
-0.1786714345216751,
-0.6121249794960022,
-0.31752052903175354,
0.447907954454422,
-0.20998962223529816,
-0.2562849819660187,
0.08332577347755432,
-0.059104301035404205,
0.547039270401001,
0.40870732069015503,
0.20824527740478516,
0.39246025681495667,
0.23564459383487701,
0.2188231348991394,
0.021670157089829445,
-0.8156311511993408,
-0.6121368408203125,
1.259977102279663,
0.5013218522071838,
1.2357218265533447,
-0.061391692608594894,
0.14672395586967468,
0.32603588700294495,
0.38020649552345276,
-0.43583056330680847,
0.3482007384300232,
-0.082611083984375,
-0.5582962036132812,
-0.7149771451950073,
-0.7859615087509155,
-0.897853672504425,
0.12648926675319672,
-0.047460585832595825,
-1.0631078481674194,
-0.032862596213817596,
0.2593156695365906,
-0.24765552580356598,
0.23325687646865845,
-0.6900678277015686,
1.0974502563476562,
-0.1516243815422058,
-0.5231639742851257,
0.24378705024719238,
-0.4518987238407135,
0.4302591383457184,
-0.15605545043945312,
0.25700053572654724,
0.03785421699285507,
-0.10734731703996658,
0.6419576406478882,
-0.21478915214538574,
0.6458223462104797,
-0.026179268956184387,
-0.38088080286979675,
0.3523006737232208,
0.22631146013736725,
0.6918056011199951,
0.4150904715061188,
-0.11308084428310394,
-0.14541888236999512,
0.3525472581386566,
-0.4278906285762787,
-0.6469395160675049,
0.7798383235931396,
-0.6507217288017273,
-0.8854140043258667,
-0.11833585798740387,
-0.9514166116714478,
-0.7214730978012085,
-0.09356888383626938,
-0.015241076238453388,
0.6203809380531311,
0.006134868133813143,
0.5574201345443726,
0.9178724884986877,
-0.10565440356731415,
0.4089553952217102,
0.4118098020553589,
0.010881807655096054,
-0.4167277216911316,
0.7246137857437134,
0.30379727482795715,
0.2965552508831024,
0.7644419074058533,
0.08110542595386505,
-0.598922848701477,
-0.8114454746246338,
-0.7475860118865967,
0.11765079200267792,
-0.7567325234413147,
-0.5514345765113831,
-0.41870635747909546,
-0.1122223511338234,
-0.09799404442310333,
0.2043866664171219,
0.0635778084397316,
-0.5157368183135986,
-0.3839133083820343,
-0.3915290832519531,
0.35480573773384094,
0.7213482856750488,
0.3671839237213135,
0.19304421544075012,
-0.70006263256073,
0.5470014214515686,
0.6121219992637634,
0.47826817631721497,
0.1096554845571518,
-0.7992721796035767,
-0.31482645869255066,
-0.009815185330808163,
-0.06990751624107361,
-1.1986374855041504,
0.06195714697241783,
0.1823354810476303,
0.6797215938568115,
0.19859038293361664,
0.08480047434568405,
0.33762845396995544,
-0.2942400872707367,
0.6287627816200256,
-0.48643413186073303,
-0.9617459177970886,
0.1286371350288391,
-0.7012974619865417,
0.5145151019096375,
0.686375081539154,
0.3202414810657501,
-0.2551794946193695,
-0.5138819217681885,
-0.11086153239011765,
-0.583912193775177,
0.7433168888092041,
0.006006227340549231,
0.11346322298049927,
0.21546979248523712,
0.8436568379402161,
0.2609332799911499,
0.20532481372356415,
-1.1970397233963013,
-0.0009474457474425435,
-0.1281614899635315,
-0.2374878078699112,
0.17467404901981354,
-0.3891153335571289,
0.15332859754562378,
-0.07289361953735352,
0.5918787121772766,
-0.1739967167377472,
-0.043399304151535034,
0.036279741674661636,
-0.29699259996414185,
-0.2580781877040863,
0.49954792857170105,
0.4982803761959076,
1.1748043298721313,
-0.013827204704284668,
0.07042918354272842,
0.5165328979492188,
-0.5271903872489929,
0.08235633373260498,
0.006956561002880335,
-0.34268155694007874,
-0.47490283846855164,
0.38258105516433716,
0.6183949112892151,
-0.0037827459163963795,
-0.6477095484733582,
0.0876549482345581,
-0.22881658375263214,
-0.17560900747776031,
0.08810194581747055,
0.22654303908348083,
0.19337907433509827,
0.24119806289672852,
0.4905410408973694,
-0.7136605381965637,
0.10933287441730499,
-0.6888111233711243,
0.22429007291793823,
0.6744890213012695,
-0.24356931447982788,
-0.04084458947181702,
0.8168640732765198,
-0.36713072657585144,
-0.07323008030653,
0.6093101501464844,
0.16218417882919312,
-0.45303067564964294,
0.7114405632019043,
0.6175698041915894,
0.3628111183643341,
-0.1515636295080185,
0.3589807450771332,
0.07341687381267548,
0.6204980611801147,
0.07250840961933136,
0.5793865919113159,
-0.11271562427282333,
-0.4829944670200348,
-0.47207826375961304,
-0.5914427638053894,
-0.6081288456916809,
0.41859400272369385,
-0.6480927467346191,
-0.2997019588947296,
-0.30627164244651794,
-0.1193525642156601,
-0.3206287622451782,
-0.08326406031847,
-0.6580063104629517,
0.34625518321990967,
-0.0943516418337822,
0.8468301296234131,
-0.5674794316291809,
0.7543057203292847,
0.6227129101753235,
-0.099659763276577,
-1.1013622283935547,
0.168263778090477,
-0.36921852827072144,
-0.5225116610527039,
0.1265164017677307,
-0.08875909447669983,
0.21506163477897644,
-0.08230537176132202,
-0.4950371980667114,
-1.0153816938400269,
0.991797924041748,
0.48434144258499146,
-0.47167128324508667,
-0.11664125323295593,
0.49267029762268066,
0.6160894632339478,
0.06558778136968613,
0.12419324368238449,
0.8128664493560791,
0.43651896715164185,
-0.129416361451149,
-0.8696908950805664,
0.16033582389354706,
0.0792892798781395,
-0.0711551308631897,
-0.07541200518608093,
-0.5776366591453552,
0.6252959966659546,
-0.14351242780685425,
-0.024641983211040497,
0.03144838288426399,
0.8698959350585938,
0.0927649661898613,
0.21494781970977783,
0.33772361278533936,
0.52874755859375,
0.7257617712020874,
-0.20417903363704681,
0.9818387031555176,
-0.21715377271175385,
0.07104025036096573,
1.1473515033721924,
-0.32894638180732727,
1.0112489461898804,
0.3277956247329712,
-0.42026641964912415,
0.4005497694015503,
0.5828983187675476,
-0.03356235474348068,
0.2409854680299759,
0.17849910259246826,
0.17129552364349365,
-0.19887647032737732,
0.13614237308502197,
-0.2338225245475769,
0.6273817420005798,
0.33410829305648804,
-0.112004853785038,
-0.21966767311096191,
-0.22258523106575012,
-0.10198557376861572,
0.07355903089046478,
-0.41413336992263794,
0.8622134327888489,
0.12038271874189377,
-0.6441648602485657,
0.5558614730834961,
-0.2161538451910019,
-0.06397081166505814,
-0.5159639120101929,
0.19105905294418335,
-0.5785354971885681,
-0.20130202174186707,
-0.12495727837085724,
-0.7519806623458862,
0.1273992508649826,
0.22523339092731476,
-0.11559727042913437,
0.0810641199350357,
0.6364538073539734,
-0.32828131318092346,
-0.4046725928783417,
-0.2785387635231018,
0.9502489566802979,
-0.1389670968055725,
-0.0032511509489268064,
-0.32694023847579956,
0.17346292734146118,
-0.09022857993841171,
-0.44476062059402466,
0.46246615052223206,
0.47717684507369995,
-0.0026127148885279894,
0.9908033609390259,
0.3163158595561981,
-0.11724450439214706,
0.0626852884888649,
0.0033645315561443567,
0.8371979594230652,
-0.5477414131164551,
-0.4269130825996399,
-0.8117098808288574,
0.24486424028873444,
0.2614894211292267,
0.06232800707221031,
0.8298402428627014,
0.38629457354545593,
0.5703005194664001,
-0.16432978212833405,
0.40766602754592896,
0.30801910161972046,
0.43628546595573425,
-0.7805125117301941,
0.8777583241462708,
-0.4764370918273926,
0.3200013339519501,
-0.3256150186061859,
-1.1721434593200684,
-0.22791804373264313,
0.2974598705768585,
-0.3863075375556946,
0.3148418962955475,
0.6584951281547546,
0.6391986012458801,
0.06553535908460617,
-0.03487902507185936,
0.37140583992004395,
0.395862340927124,
0.060513779520988464,
0.3928905129432678,
0.8415368795394897,
-0.11637505143880844,
0.8671576976776123,
-0.12617573142051697,
0.06940651684999466,
0.041407518088817596,
-0.6713775992393494,
-0.9828343987464905,
-0.4681312143802643,
-0.08140868693590164,
-0.30942997336387634,
0.07530839741230011,
0.4977874159812927,
0.3997693359851837,
-0.8585824370384216,
-0.1766292005777359,
0.10478335618972778,
0.40710189938545227,
-0.006450854707509279,
-0.2416820377111435,
0.6781845092773438,
-0.4991998076438904,
-0.5374729633331299,
0.45187708735466003,
0.18371498584747314,
0.07348807156085968,
-0.2208787500858307,
0.3468274176120758,
0.141037255525589,
0.09169810265302658,
0.4333828091621399,
0.2031629979610443,
-0.59217768907547,
-0.2935536205768585,
0.3321482837200165,
-0.18656910955905914,
0.26234766840934753,
0.5045095086097717,
-0.49680474400520325,
0.1428004801273346,
0.4499986469745636,
0.8188872337341309,
0.35062992572784424,
0.4572080075740814,
0.47803330421447754,
-0.3060922622680664,
-0.32042717933654785,
0.13297560811042786,
0.3072187602519989,
0.4338500499725342,
-0.42128852009773254,
0.2937127947807312,
-0.21987663209438324,
-0.8302274942398071,
-0.9703750610351562,
0.01551654003560543,
-0.9966184496879578,
-0.18870025873184204,
1.0436131954193115,
0.009268485940992832,
-0.630033016204834,
-0.19541463255882263,
0.06384293735027313,
0.10316461324691772,
-0.33315086364746094,
1.1037508249282837,
0.7160499691963196,
-0.00878836028277874,
-0.36969372630119324,
-0.8045149445533752,
0.5609163045883179,
0.4253147840499878,
-1.2032790184020996,
0.30098992586135864,
0.5712909698486328,
0.31348007917404175,
-0.39997047185897827,
0.29435551166534424,
0.04209208860993385,
0.5673176050186157,
-0.0815996304154396,
-0.4507288932800293,
-0.12162689864635468,
-0.583233654499054,
-0.24678215384483337,
0.3855507969856262,
0.4707030653953552,
0.14956925809383392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12718v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12718v2 | AGLA: Mitigating Object Hallucinations in Large Vision-Language Models with Assembly of Global and Local Attention | 2024-06-18T15:38:41 | 2024-06-21T17:33:21 | Wenbin An, Feng Tian, Sicong Leng, Jiahao Nie, Haonan Lin, QianYing Wang, Guang Dai, Ping Chen, Shijian Lu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite their great success across various multimodal tasks, Large
Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) are facing a prevalent problem with object
hallucinations, where the generated textual responses are inconsistent with
ground-truth objects in the given image. This paper investigates various LVLMs
and pinpoints attention deficiency toward discriminative local image features
as one root cause of object hallucinations. Specifically, LVLMs predominantly
attend to prompt-independent global image features, while failing to capture
prompt-relevant local features, consequently undermining the visual grounding
capacity of LVLMs and leading to hallucinations. To this end, we propose
Assembly of Global and Local Attention (AGLA), a training-free and
plug-and-play approach that mitigates object hallucinations by exploring an
ensemble of global features for response generation and local features for
visual discrimination simultaneously. Our approach exhibits an image-prompt
matching scheme that captures prompt-relevant local features from images,
leading to an augmented view of the input image where prompt-relevant content
is reserved while irrelevant distractions are masked. With the augmented view,
a calibrated decoding distribution can be derived by integrating generative
global features from the original image and discriminative local features from
the augmented image. Extensive experiments show that AGLA consistently
mitigates object hallucinations and enhances general perception capability for
LVLMs across various discriminative and generative benchmarks. Our code will be
released at https://github.com/Lackel/AGLA. | [
-0.516118586063385,
-0.9556038975715637,
0.4679366648197174,
0.001012363820336759,
-0.14163386821746826,
-0.16130827367305756,
0.12453014403581619,
-0.8282171487808228,
0.3950970470905304,
0.5880649089813232,
-0.3002544343471527,
-0.1972731649875641,
-0.36111190915107727,
0.1145111694931984,
-0.4961110055446625,
0.5360131859779358,
-0.06111735850572586,
-0.07245489209890366,
-0.4450874626636505,
-0.36557552218437195,
-0.6333943605422974,
-0.783851683139801,
-0.5554013252258301,
0.12293407320976257,
0.4110170900821686,
-0.08067420870065689,
0.8254872560501099,
0.5513896346092224,
0.5653173327445984,
0.28008124232292175,
-0.09354492276906967,
0.5240974426269531,
-0.34844261407852173,
0.04813415929675102,
-0.16912855207920074,
-0.11088470369577408,
-0.47027134895324707,
-0.4077586233615875,
0.42968273162841797,
0.4378901720046997,
-0.10026977956295013,
0.007781292777508497,
-0.03165807947516441,
0.6165900230407715,
-0.9672544002532959,
-0.04993293061852455,
-0.8139222264289856,
0.4898649752140045,
0.28180092573165894,
-0.18903593719005585,
-0.31991928815841675,
0.016901373863220215,
-0.08676163107156754,
-0.4869523346424103,
0.7108273506164551,
0.1114526018500328,
0.7429201602935791,
0.5652569532394409,
0.012635805644094944,
-0.43139904737472534,
-0.5984955430030823,
0.5190839171409607,
-0.09044727683067322,
0.37159010767936707,
0.4075247347354889,
0.32285231351852417,
-0.11770644038915634,
-0.24890151619911194,
-0.5213083624839783,
-0.39186960458755493,
-0.12674587965011597,
-0.01677343249320984,
-0.13123707473278046,
-0.000722560565918684,
0.12252816557884216,
0.3926423490047455,
-0.595004677772522,
-0.1818368136882782,
-0.5733682513237,
-0.380740225315094,
0.43464529514312744,
0.06833644211292267,
0.34859323501586914,
0.1279493272304535,
-0.38207632303237915,
-0.000028380080038914457,
-0.6644781231880188,
0.03540700301527977,
0.07375126332044601,
0.3925262689590454,
0.031962260603904724,
0.5233535766601562,
-0.1539837121963501,
0.8605923652648926,
0.11975543200969696,
-0.07743486762046814,
0.3224727213382721,
-0.0935598835349083,
-0.3347100615501404,
0.3807556629180908,
0.4104958176612854,
0.47114965319633484,
0.26028966903686523,
-0.6335838437080383,
-0.06279485672712326,
0.6822651624679565,
0.45361873507499695,
-0.4751390218734741,
-0.012949894182384014,
0.2703924775123596,
-0.3103373646736145,
-0.17172937095165253,
-0.03696288540959358,
-0.9180411696434021,
-0.7278440594673157,
-0.5157518982887268,
0.5632162690162659,
0.015705609694123268,
0.016756577417254448,
0.24892283976078033,
0.39067932963371277,
0.3035586178302765,
0.2589568793773651,
-1.0184118747711182,
0.14109677076339722,
0.25102052092552185,
1.060103416442871,
-0.5044780969619751,
-0.34503331780433655,
-1.1987260580062866,
0.2640950679779053,
-0.4094487130641937,
0.9177824854850769,
-0.5188209414482117,
-0.28768327832221985,
0.11592418700456619,
0.31254470348358154,
0.006524240132421255,
-0.8113614320755005,
0.28357017040252686,
-0.061838194727897644,
0.11188328266143799,
-0.08945529162883759,
0.021063435822725296,
-0.17402125895023346,
0.26657938957214355,
-0.573175847530365,
0.665382981300354,
-0.0798206552863121,
-0.5709530115127563,
0.013902640901505947,
-0.4106764495372772,
-0.4673188030719757,
-0.14375905692577362,
-0.33937352895736694,
-0.28112146258354187,
0.3523883819580078,
0.7035905718803406,
0.510963499546051,
-0.011384875513613224,
0.30849263072013855,
-0.24100463092327118,
-0.694423496723175,
0.023882107809185982,
-0.1735495775938034,
0.3225964307785034,
0.11625818908214569,
-0.39324620366096497,
0.6171211004257202,
-0.8455103039741516,
-0.3397253155708313,
0.23214532434940338,
0.18441729247570038,
-0.059696782380342484,
0.019129976630210876,
-0.2538997232913971,
0.02508804202079773,
0.011700894683599472,
-0.05066806450486183,
0.24262121319770813,
-0.5605702996253967,
0.1390419900417328,
0.6025571227073669,
0.04807357117533684,
0.5832558870315552,
-0.10884053260087967,
0.5396250486373901,
0.20798934996128082,
0.4204481244087219,
-0.38245290517807007,
-0.3630785644054413,
-0.9152631163597107,
-0.16160139441490173,
-0.510828971862793,
0.5463956594467163,
-0.882694661617279,
0.348101943731308,
0.14081384241580963,
-0.0921417772769928,
-0.5332226157188416,
0.04682591184973717,
0.3181171715259552,
0.5792755484580994,
0.5341965556144714,
-0.35450172424316406,
-0.5291421413421631,
-1.0355606079101562,
0.25195184350013733,
0.19858118891716003,
-0.19971267879009247,
0.10603666305541992,
0.33902719616889954,
-0.37781020998954773,
0.6510174870491028,
-0.36154401302337646,
-1.1216727495193481,
0.06532728672027588,
-0.2985146939754486,
-0.08743768185377121,
0.0018944712355732918,
0.5198570489883423,
-0.7606624364852905,
-0.21603259444236755,
0.37105825543403625,
-0.8858177065849304,
0.08144380152225494,
-0.21936164796352386,
-0.0285433791577816,
0.595715343952179,
0.42310643196105957,
-0.6889976263046265,
0.7310603857040405,
0.18111346662044525,
-0.4583255648612976,
0.5371838212013245,
-0.3307271897792816,
0.1669270247220993,
-0.7681743502616882,
0.14552825689315796,
-0.081010602414608,
0.04852892458438873,
-0.65179044008255,
0.485581636428833,
-0.21926924586296082,
-0.19204775989055634,
-0.6247698664665222,
0.7926545143127441,
-0.7833654880523682,
-0.39475691318511963,
-0.34184107184410095,
0.26463693380355835,
0.19429276883602142,
0.6199604272842407,
0.1670299768447876,
0.8873724937438965,
1.0696414709091187,
-0.45077982544898987,
0.5779203772544861,
0.3803165853023529,
-0.26903632283210754,
0.34875136613845825,
-0.444652795791626,
0.3883017301559448,
-0.34807640314102173,
-0.17778295278549194,
-0.6943580508232117,
-0.4652908742427826,
0.7114555239677429,
-0.2540188729763031,
0.11261475086212158,
0.29969343543052673,
-0.19804193079471588,
-0.30784112215042114,
-0.3812907338142395,
0.13283151388168335,
0.30680471658706665,
-0.5972700119018555,
0.9692862629890442,
0.33008715510368347,
0.025836151093244553,
-0.6293132305145264,
-0.6370242834091187,
0.11350005120038986,
-0.19286301732063293,
-0.4009912610054016,
0.06297877430915833,
-0.1525135189294815,
-0.3055267035961151,
-0.09939629584550858,
-0.22273217141628265,
0.08160746842622757,
-0.021848419681191444,
0.24007084965705872,
0.2765997648239136,
0.02514207363128662,
-0.002779926173388958,
-0.44948410987854004,
0.0035682993475347757,
0.09298273921012878,
0.11753816902637482,
0.6716620922088623,
-0.24384766817092896,
-0.5532960295677185,
-0.08123656362295151,
0.504723072052002,
0.6638215184211731,
-0.42510998249053955,
0.5221295952796936,
0.6292272806167603,
-0.4628559947013855,
-0.08274582773447037,
-0.7031230330467224,
-0.33415794372558594,
-0.47983264923095703,
0.4851769208908081,
-0.3701600134372711,
-0.6646118760108948,
0.8949912786483765,
0.5393940806388855,
-0.40110087394714355,
-0.012126065790653229,
0.7385392785072327,
0.3949570953845978,
0.9462088942527771,
0.41045501828193665,
-0.19376887381076813,
0.18148675560951233,
-0.2297532856464386,
0.3966602385044098,
-0.8745452165603638,
-0.48225051164627075,
-0.2197537124156952,
-0.25555530190467834,
0.2348804771900177,
-0.7525454759597778,
0.11330690234899521,
0.07882273197174072,
0.07183283567428589,
-0.3017028570175171,
-1.1522403955459595,
0.9775879383087158,
0.4468972384929657,
0.09513446688652039,
0.18110880255699158,
0.4411191940307617,
0.07033825665712357,
0.09636710584163666,
-0.32530927658081055,
-0.1561763882637024,
0.5635963678359985,
0.1007435992360115,
0.7508827447891235,
-0.3279651701450348,
0.30564385652542114,
0.48590025305747986,
-0.11794080585241318,
-0.7136368751525879,
0.8579103350639343,
-0.056792739778757095,
-0.1538931429386139,
-0.09812644869089127,
-0.19930635392665863,
-0.7713057398796082,
0.42737865447998047,
-0.06434229761362076,
-1.1888519525527954,
0.5174586772918701,
0.1869245320558548,
-0.4341563880443573,
0.3051743805408478,
-0.7308404445648193,
0.8483163714408875,
-0.31147298216819763,
-0.5073778629302979,
0.06682730466127396,
-0.5935974717140198,
0.4139223098754883,
-0.14388103783130646,
0.15629783272743225,
0.08980995416641235,
0.2724613845348358,
0.11966663599014282,
0.2474529892206192,
0.851386547088623,
-0.19010281562805176,
-0.34319931268692017,
0.38883888721466064,
0.09967192262411118,
0.5444245338439941,
-0.03037443943321705,
0.4392313063144684,
0.27955693006515503,
-0.5733190774917603,
-0.026274899020791054,
-0.496017187833786,
0.702551007270813,
-0.6029033064842224,
-0.7285863757133484,
-0.33664098381996155,
-0.8819602131843567,
-0.07868470996618271,
-0.20051716268062592,
0.35166531801223755,
0.4767663776874542,
0.175648495554924,
0.20339767634868622,
0.816250741481781,
-0.2440127283334732,
0.40845823287963867,
-0.009650390595197678,
-0.7386277914047241,
-0.5978763103485107,
1.0929882526397705,
0.05052337795495987,
0.09465761482715607,
0.18498551845550537,
-0.18798501789569855,
-0.20837664604187012,
-0.4917798340320587,
-0.27034392952919006,
0.034688469022512436,
-0.9743058681488037,
-0.23793837428092957,
-0.7487318515777588,
-0.2979356348514557,
-0.4833844006061554,
-0.3799125850200653,
-0.18436747789382935,
-0.008720319718122482,
-0.48394906520843506,
0.07187448441982269,
0.048582810908555984,
0.3411053717136383,
0.1400410234928131,
0.03759312257170677,
-0.6029694080352783,
1.0112217664718628,
0.44605153799057007,
0.11144217848777771,
0.36859646439552307,
-0.4195335805416107,
-0.2702752649784088,
-0.15018443763256073,
-0.15256236493587494,
-0.6813914775848389,
0.5471296906471252,
0.25459030270576477,
0.6197808384895325,
0.5245481133460999,
0.03681730106472969,
0.7964516282081604,
-0.5427277088165283,
0.6859970688819885,
0.3052491843700409,
-0.7963995933532715,
0.7828570008277893,
-0.11810548603534698,
0.38567280769348145,
0.17753766477108002,
0.13257624208927155,
-0.29827436804771423,
-0.7712165713310242,
-0.21366913616657257,
-0.9408276677131653,
0.6517359614372253,
0.19683685898780823,
0.08686477690935135,
-0.10926055908203125,
0.25097399950027466,
0.1479998677968979,
0.06215447187423706,
-0.9466692209243774,
-0.0078230369836092,
-0.20407186448574066,
0.004455856047570705,
0.17145679891109467,
-0.3531542718410492,
-0.3210649788379669,
-0.3827882409095764,
0.5056019425392151,
-0.32959869503974915,
0.4374275505542755,
0.4303770661354065,
-0.19231531023979187,
-0.1875590980052948,
-0.14174188673496246,
0.9141974449157715,
0.5802054405212402,
-0.20222418010234833,
0.11381751298904419,
0.12761478126049042,
-0.6233460307121277,
0.28207629919052124,
0.061871014535427094,
-0.3942614495754242,
-0.02775975689291954,
0.21399761736392975,
1.177786111831665,
-0.15195661783218384,
-0.5948616862297058,
0.0629860907793045,
-0.0001562303223181516,
-0.03250211477279663,
-0.18493978679180145,
0.3816441297531128,
-0.1841350942850113,
0.44362032413482666,
0.6762067079544067,
0.2655702829360962,
0.3188139498233795,
-0.5329549908638,
0.11342281103134155,
0.43908780813217163,
-0.18752947449684143,
-0.33961406350135803,
0.8787667155265808,
-0.12557777762413025,
-0.41453036665916443,
0.15093562006950378,
-0.32347357273101807,
-0.410718709230423,
0.7218835353851318,
0.5701326727867126,
1.0644230842590332,
-0.4085943102836609,
0.1972808837890625,
0.3068124055862427,
0.3514564335346222,
-0.12817540764808655,
0.2253626585006714,
0.07079502940177917,
-0.6625862717628479,
-0.3557054400444031,
-0.6537385582923889,
-0.3439406752586365,
0.18982452154159546,
-0.4924491047859192,
0.25118809938430786,
-0.2864382266998291,
0.13318157196044922,
-0.3935837149620056,
-0.4545266032218933,
-0.35451409220695496,
0.12161578238010406,
0.5469709038734436,
0.23615507781505585,
-0.6795212626457214,
0.6628545522689819,
0.7838847637176514,
-0.23939113318920135,
-0.4108518362045288,
0.12723633646965027,
-0.36374059319496155,
-0.7066749334335327,
0.4644567370414734,
0.8011474013328552,
-0.25162917375564575,
-0.1254190355539322,
-0.37653928995132446,
-0.7687655091285706,
0.7086964845657349,
0.5436456203460693,
-0.5329332947731018,
-0.1813523769378662,
0.2020253986120224,
0.3165123760700226,
-0.5973160862922668,
-0.1579452008008957,
0.3358616828918457,
0.18722474575042725,
0.43222689628601074,
-0.5831273198127747,
0.043930403888225555,
-0.229329451918602,
0.0309346504509449,
0.10591619461774826,
-0.5621404647827148,
0.6240477561950684,
-0.4965956211090088,
-0.27490848302841187,
-0.045939378440380096,
0.5609148740768433,
0.3628990352153778,
0.46503469347953796,
0.42687490582466125,
0.6475451588630676,
0.7619988918304443,
-0.05162448063492775,
0.7528037428855896,
-0.1970350444316864,
0.18074016273021698,
1.3024154901504517,
-0.6614437103271484,
0.6192729473114014,
0.5784562826156616,
0.025495948269963264,
-0.03823551535606384,
0.23537184298038483,
-0.320186585187912,
0.9196667075157166,
0.03236912190914154,
-0.3152599334716797,
-0.11860581487417221,
-0.28465041518211365,
-0.6883596181869507,
0.46595993638038635,
0.17123301327228546,
-0.04249393194913864,
-0.17113907635211945,
0.7819235324859619,
-0.515659749507904,
-0.07369235157966614,
-0.5159133076667786,
0.6839847564697266,
-0.058734629303216934,
-0.4671344757080078,
0.9492318034172058,
-0.7307032942771912,
0.5719426274299622,
-0.46188586950302124,
-0.20093132555484772,
-0.6816271543502808,
0.35545966029167175,
-0.03599764034152031,
-0.33757755160331726,
0.5551906824111938,
-0.004512861371040344,
-0.3614260256290436,
0.21798330545425415,
0.9294020533561707,
-0.3657679855823517,
-0.6795790791511536,
0.5098630785942078,
0.02302553690969944,
0.23999132215976715,
-0.41723060607910156,
-0.2147965133190155,
0.46104222536087036,
0.12907423079013824,
-0.2258189171552658,
0.4302244782447815,
0.3382638394832611,
-0.19423386454582214,
0.8023938536643982,
0.5532839298248291,
0.10808627307415009,
0.1022074893116951,
0.22610943019390106,
0.7817338109016418,
-0.44338637590408325,
-0.445818692445755,
-0.8966658711433411,
0.5979267358779907,
-0.025189021602272987,
-0.039134375751018524,
0.38237494230270386,
0.3402116298675537,
0.6270898580551147,
-0.4964312016963959,
0.21292197704315186,
0.1234106793999672,
-0.030649036169052124,
-0.5634154677391052,
0.7118344902992249,
-0.7074489593505859,
0.04732629284262657,
0.04330810159444809,
-1.3965651988983154,
-0.6188636422157288,
0.9785045385360718,
0.0035034825559705496,
-0.2143537551164627,
0.6091545820236206,
0.8302958011627197,
-0.01534323301166296,
-0.45360010862350464,
0.668609082698822,
0.2506403923034668,
0.2180050164461136,
0.6526066064834595,
0.833943784236908,
-0.2674630284309387,
0.568396270275116,
-0.06572569161653519,
0.04941585287451744,
-0.276872456073761,
-0.7053248882293701,
-1.0644835233688354,
-0.40308377146720886,
-0.3761589229106903,
-0.0684191882610321,
0.16019976139068604,
0.536015510559082,
0.41278597712516785,
-0.9653756022453308,
0.13955213129520416,
-0.12642765045166016,
-0.04515853524208069,
-0.0171147920191288,
-0.26797887682914734,
0.6389607787132263,
-0.4318216145038605,
-0.6731917858123779,
0.4005541205406189,
0.6947023272514343,
0.235577791929245,
-0.6238711476325989,
-0.16863909363746643,
0.015002402476966381,
-0.2540111839771271,
0.6533389091491699,
0.11840270459651947,
-1.2777221202850342,
-0.369219034910202,
0.20484699308872223,
0.06818533688783646,
0.3036136031150818,
0.25782501697540283,
-1.0896937847137451,
0.6692105531692505,
0.06353650987148285,
0.6142985820770264,
0.05371331423521042,
-0.09757669270038605,
0.1754978448152542,
-0.8906694650650024,
0.838325023651123,
0.08207353204488754,
0.49850600957870483,
0.46862369775772095,
-0.6727970838546753,
0.7859843969345093,
0.16156919300556183,
-0.6271561980247498,
-1.0612398386001587,
0.11583080142736435,
-1.069100022315979,
-0.20562958717346191,
0.8781115412712097,
0.15359129011631012,
-0.37713736295700073,
0.029147136956453323,
-0.6796028017997742,
0.016904395073652267,
-0.09075076133012772,
1.3817024230957031,
0.5621926784515381,
0.1573369950056076,
-0.4037995934486389,
-0.5396198630332947,
0.26892971992492676,
0.2595095634460449,
-0.8800699710845947,
0.34973418712615967,
0.7876806259155273,
-0.4687078297138214,
0.7127249240875244,
0.42058804631233215,
0.20080041885375977,
0.4314042925834656,
-0.024005891755223274,
0.4009765088558197,
-0.1898796707391739,
-0.8511764407157898,
-0.2898613512516022,
0.4594825208187103,
-0.3809255361557007,
-0.33617204427719116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12708v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12708v1 | AgentReview: Exploring Peer Review Dynamics with LLM Agents | 2024-06-18T15:22:12 | 2024-06-18T15:22:12 | Yiqiao Jin, Qinlin Zhao, Yiyang Wang, Hao Chen, Kaijie Zhu, Yijia Xiao, Jindong Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Peer review is fundamental to the integrity and advancement of scientific
publication. Traditional methods of peer review analyses often rely on
exploration and statistics of existing peer review data, which do not
adequately address the multivariate nature of the process, account for the
latent variables, and are further constrained by privacy concerns due to the
sensitive nature of the data. We introduce AgentReview, the first large
language model (LLM) based peer review simulation framework, which effectively
disentangles the impacts of multiple latent factors and addresses the privacy
issue. Our study reveals significant insights, including a notable 37.1%
variation in paper decisions due to reviewers' biases, supported by
sociological theories such as the social influence theory, altruism fatigue,
and authority bias. We believe that this study could offer valuable insights to
improve the design of peer review mechanisms. | [
-0.1690903753042221,
-0.6716127395629883,
0.6628856062889099,
0.22433622181415558,
-0.03632975369691849,
0.270270973443985,
0.1282830387353897,
-0.4337541460990906,
0.3699553906917572,
0.4397923946380615,
-0.43778496980667114,
-0.3696683645248413,
-0.6384881734848022,
0.16922737658023834,
-0.22824053466320038,
1.0465070009231567,
-0.038761649280786514,
0.5291008949279785,
0.010628740303218365,
0.11388731002807617,
0.21264027059078217,
-0.451401948928833,
-0.3913417160511017,
-0.6307525038719177,
0.8863005042076111,
-0.014046487398445606,
0.7241032719612122,
0.16840089857578278,
0.6022723913192749,
0.2917218804359436,
-0.3948856592178345,
0.09907808154821396,
-0.7483184933662415,
0.3218839168548584,
-0.33317267894744873,
-0.3080654740333557,
-0.7259858250617981,
0.569421648979187,
0.8492571711540222,
0.5207064151763916,
-0.17243905365467072,
0.055440016090869904,
0.19908036291599274,
0.767277717590332,
-0.2984236776828766,
0.48398664593696594,
-0.24524350464344025,
0.1559232622385025,
0.19487664103507996,
-0.2752905488014221,
-0.3542596399784088,
-0.4258469343185425,
0.17056044936180115,
-0.34080949425697327,
0.3423859179019928,
0.07910307496786118,
0.6220278143882751,
0.07720103114843369,
-0.6898875832557678,
0.004381021950393915,
-0.8260631561279297,
0.39318612217903137,
-0.29113784432411194,
0.362992525100708,
0.3363906145095825,
0.17309047281742096,
-0.291252076625824,
-0.678611695766449,
-0.572670042514801,
-0.4498746395111084,
0.18218453228473663,
0.007673392537981272,
0.15068116784095764,
0.31706246733665466,
0.08399349451065063,
0.08391730487346649,
-0.22991178929805756,
-0.2362121343612671,
-0.23159538209438324,
-0.09084969758987427,
0.8804813623428345,
0.2787390947341919,
-0.10286946594715118,
-0.057921357452869415,
-0.10728835314512253,
-0.496576189994812,
-0.644836962223053,
0.2654310166835785,
0.7141141295433044,
0.07608103007078171,
-0.037884004414081573,
0.46357178688049316,
-0.19665978848934174,
0.13647162914276123,
0.043218567967414856,
0.08378109335899353,
0.28495925664901733,
-0.6254327893257141,
0.03407253324985504,
-0.11564427614212036,
0.798483669757843,
0.52529376745224,
-0.08208588510751724,
0.11639653891324997,
-0.16346785426139832,
-0.2172926962375641,
0.3662256896495819,
-0.9958388209342957,
0.008974567987024784,
0.344224750995636,
-0.8908974528312683,
-0.7513962984085083,
0.17099006474018097,
-0.875860333442688,
-0.9523406028747559,
-0.1509273499250412,
0.24746601283550262,
0.1834867149591446,
-0.47137653827667236,
0.08449447900056839,
0.039648186415433884,
0.015741795301437378,
0.8917647004127502,
-0.20672917366027832,
0.40103065967559814,
0.8828638792037964,
0.8924442529678345,
-0.40248849987983704,
-0.5413647890090942,
-0.5247414112091064,
0.012214777991175652,
-0.19962656497955322,
0.6510663032531738,
-0.6484515070915222,
-0.5847664475440979,
-0.12123695760965347,
0.27627506852149963,
0.16994766891002655,
-0.10209731012582779,
-0.016779910773038864,
-0.727350652217865,
-0.2151663452386856,
-0.288593053817749,
-0.38224083185195923,
-0.11548484861850739,
0.39349088072776794,
-0.8332996368408203,
0.5087543725967407,
-0.1706918627023697,
-0.6701631546020508,
0.3997403383255005,
-0.5586701035499573,
0.002899779472500086,
-0.23988781869411469,
-0.24664129316806793,
-0.5366472601890564,
0.19012632966041565,
-0.14592362940311432,
0.3050576448440552,
-0.2137908935546875,
0.5062375068664551,
-0.4758445620536804,
-0.07977514714002609,
0.5333304405212402,
-0.4373514950275421,
0.44599562883377075,
0.2360571324825287,
-0.1795026808977127,
0.2517531216144562,
-0.45389696955680847,
-0.14111630618572235,
-0.10446608066558838,
-0.1531127542257309,
-0.03812593221664429,
0.2226957380771637,
0.12904082238674164,
-0.13541553914546967,
-0.059347715228796005,
-0.7727888226509094,
0.4503564238548279,
0.008494510315358639,
0.37477466464042664,
0.8400850892066956,
0.5892035961151123,
0.5482465028762817,
-0.37439221143722534,
0.775363564491272,
-0.24725644290447235,
0.49889740347862244,
-0.07016265392303467,
-0.5691555142402649,
-0.01407813373953104,
0.15370048582553864,
0.4909187853336334,
0.11342145502567291,
-0.5453078150749207,
-0.45189616084098816,
-0.010395321995019913,
-0.5651443600654602,
-0.3051529824733734,
0.09328210353851318,
0.39877983927726746,
-0.18777905404567719,
-0.21958373486995697,
-0.5206627249717712,
0.04952988401055336,
-0.5824410319328308,
-0.35902756452560425,
-0.7282652854919434,
0.3211206793785095,
0.45573627948760986,
0.5458966493606567,
-0.28683990240097046,
0.7287103533744812,
-0.37293916940689087,
-0.34874415397644043,
-0.17831258475780487,
0.29215168952941895,
0.06977828592061996,
0.4301234185695648,
0.25340163707733154,
-0.7819794416427612,
-0.1867227852344513,
-0.11033995449542999,
-0.6620972752571106,
-0.2870749533176422,
-0.10821248590946198,
-0.04947226122021675,
0.17323991656303406,
0.6717569828033447,
-0.5415581464767456,
0.49212267994880676,
0.5127463936805725,
-0.5370193719863892,
0.552773654460907,
-0.2020324021577835,
0.1811646819114685,
-0.6850219368934631,
-0.014753395691514015,
0.18260638415813446,
-0.2909028232097626,
-0.35922324657440186,
0.24716821312904358,
-0.09856986254453659,
-0.235834002494812,
-0.4098426103591919,
0.47470802068710327,
-0.7224845886230469,
0.09344694763422012,
-0.4224618971347809,
-0.014661801978945732,
0.21597251296043396,
0.1434301733970642,
0.14927968382835388,
0.5665181875228882,
0.2809668183326721,
-0.2416195571422577,
0.13105462491512299,
0.06260029226541519,
-0.21751666069030762,
0.08752119541168213,
-0.9241318106651306,
0.19224834442138672,
-0.5054641962051392,
0.4609173834323883,
-1.0369181632995605,
-0.137115478515625,
0.341897577047348,
-0.5831029415130615,
0.3909780979156494,
-0.2812821567058563,
-0.5682539343833923,
0.11289045214653015,
-0.5469164848327637,
0.3425011932849884,
0.058197468519210815,
-0.07746122777462006,
0.9093050360679626,
0.7431807518005371,
-0.33253490924835205,
-0.6543099880218506,
-0.11076940596103668,
0.20895273983478546,
0.2988359332084656,
-0.4162989854812622,
-0.06233909726142883,
-0.07299447059631348,
-0.6949032545089722,
-0.07181555777788162,
-0.08645626902580261,
0.14893653988838196,
-0.1444321721792221,
0.4317111372947693,
0.14362230896949768,
0.25600332021713257,
0.06225075200200081,
0.16061459481716156,
0.0952281653881073,
0.4219321608543396,
0.14750730991363525,
0.4512721002101898,
-0.24762539565563202,
-0.4389455318450928,
-0.4230400323867798,
0.16659337282180786,
0.6358597874641418,
-0.23697130382061005,
0.43234115839004517,
-0.014648249372839928,
0.05036346986889839,
-0.38366591930389404,
-0.6395155787467957,
-0.5887516140937805,
-0.46343034505844116,
0.5532470941543579,
0.011451509781181812,
-0.7004246115684509,
0.5362261533737183,
-0.03962074965238571,
-0.021433858200907707,
-0.05130568891763687,
0.6903684735298157,
0.12037303298711777,
0.9318813681602478,
0.7331101894378662,
0.06379584223031998,
0.549323320388794,
-0.34892937541007996,
-0.09184633940458298,
-0.6748684644699097,
-0.5079143047332764,
-0.5910577178001404,
-0.4043169915676117,
-0.6120927333831787,
-0.8108853101730347,
0.5246860980987549,
-0.3385155200958252,
0.09057990461587906,
-0.16046853363513947,
-0.3529945909976959,
0.5848757028579712,
0.10390770435333252,
0.2185908555984497,
0.5591768622398376,
0.03604466840624809,
-0.12040923535823822,
0.04706011712551117,
-0.4407002925872803,
-0.6388342976570129,
1.2358736991882324,
0.6480461359024048,
1.3393595218658447,
-0.13863664865493774,
0.7194994688034058,
0.5418189167976379,
0.6702075600624084,
-0.5164253115653992,
0.6989830136299133,
0.42500367760658264,
-0.6839750409126282,
-0.4696449041366577,
-0.29508671164512634,
-0.8553483486175537,
0.6551076769828796,
-0.19270718097686768,
-0.3347303867340088,
0.6719405055046082,
-0.06822777539491653,
0.03287263959646225,
0.36470404267311096,
-0.3731917440891266,
0.4558839201927185,
-0.14287754893302917,
-1.0807911157608032,
-0.37924692034721375,
-0.7900786399841309,
0.1515708714723587,
-0.13605272769927979,
0.26018574833869934,
-0.08892668783664703,
-0.12446456402540207,
0.5690953731536865,
-0.6501061320304871,
1.1853290796279907,
-0.3647567331790924,
-0.18847259879112244,
0.3642931580543518,
0.5070315599441528,
0.6859153509140015,
0.681422770023346,
-0.18934693932533264,
0.1369331330060959,
0.24771982431411743,
0.04430621489882469,
-0.47431981563568115,
0.5514820218086243,
-1.0358010530471802,
-0.7011123299598694,
-0.9144766330718994,
-0.49307218194007874,
0.014469278044998646,
0.03516518324613571,
-0.11537014693021774,
0.10066293925046921,
-0.3824528455734253,
0.15879788994789124,
0.5214604735374451,
-0.1193498969078064,
0.2515280246734619,
1.2161439657211304,
-0.6056522130966187,
-0.42561209201812744,
0.3727957308292389,
0.18524128198623657,
-0.022627945989370346,
0.030440302565693855,
0.3081817924976349,
-0.2688722014427185,
-0.6359415650367737,
-0.1529700756072998,
0.4650430679321289,
-0.37641510367393494,
0.054166361689567566,
-1.057763695716858,
0.04752013832330704,
-0.3291122317314148,
0.4626222848892212,
-0.43053823709487915,
-0.27734309434890747,
-0.0015574190765619278,
-0.13146334886550903,
0.14512604475021362,
1.162165641784668,
-0.2673289179801941,
0.2727324664592743,
-0.682175874710083,
0.1356460601091385,
0.23853065073490143,
0.5816070437431335,
0.25034216046333313,
-0.264003723859787,
-0.1222124770283699,
-0.2640601694583893,
-0.606653094291687,
-1.1867104768753052,
0.3952433466911316,
0.08751081675291061,
0.6123371720314026,
0.5379714965820312,
0.21320687234401703,
-0.04106113687157631,
-0.574748158454895,
0.8075800538063049,
-0.2778385281562805,
-0.7290952801704407,
0.3288900852203369,
-0.5978142619132996,
-0.09859209507703781,
0.7076712846755981,
0.28974851965904236,
-0.3236190676689148,
-0.5375871062278748,
-0.4848692715167999,
-0.650397777557373,
0.7395317554473877,
0.3106538951396942,
0.13459458947181702,
0.3491363823413849,
0.556458592414856,
0.24862632155418396,
0.6443017721176147,
-0.9240025877952576,
-0.07659509032964706,
-0.05232183262705803,
0.554527997970581,
-0.3222147226333618,
-0.32917922735214233,
-0.2931169867515564,
-0.027860842645168304,
0.5683202743530273,
-0.03496821969747543,
0.17051471769809723,
0.5493552684783936,
0.15775913000106812,
-0.5011073350906372,
0.09959275275468826,
0.6578233242034912,
0.7903680205345154,
-0.38838571310043335,
-0.016784409061074257,
-0.2996838688850403,
-0.9089729189872742,
0.3602057695388794,
0.14561794698238373,
-0.3279074728488922,
0.07292032241821289,
0.11994645744562149,
0.3884199261665344,
-0.26725971698760986,
-0.4222871959209442,
0.6516574025154114,
-0.4078208804130554,
-0.3408208191394806,
-0.29939478635787964,
-0.20036405324935913,
-0.1905968189239502,
0.6861523985862732,
0.41934579610824585,
-0.08980777859687805,
0.33548852801322937,
-0.5770303606987,
0.23248699307441711,
0.5171722173690796,
-0.4582716226577759,
-0.5633223652839661,
0.9255192279815674,
0.34713855385780334,
-0.4723542630672455,
0.11090848594903946,
-0.12128245085477829,
-0.4007240831851959,
0.8878251314163208,
0.055714838206768036,
0.9908150434494019,
-0.23457954823970795,
0.6469860076904297,
-0.02810482867062092,
0.610327959060669,
-0.2561090290546417,
0.2798379361629486,
-0.03428468853235245,
-0.5213626623153687,
-0.5096632838249207,
-0.578883707523346,
-1.200348973274231,
-0.019118132069706917,
-0.580533504486084,
0.1514563411474228,
-0.4696780741214752,
-0.5990269780158997,
-0.08985374867916107,
0.2757347822189331,
-0.12764881551265717,
-0.28750666975975037,
-0.05191313847899437,
0.8739322423934937,
-0.7989736199378967,
0.7596349716186523,
0.9368118047714233,
-0.21605657041072845,
-0.6739904284477234,
0.17970789968967438,
0.27815476059913635,
-0.5439860820770264,
0.7031437158584595,
0.016739027574658394,
-0.510736346244812,
-0.3191286325454712,
-0.9272559881210327,
-0.6519102454185486,
0.8594300746917725,
0.25314828753471375,
-0.4847995340824127,
0.08464944362640381,
-0.03315197303891182,
0.9454816579818726,
-0.3898674249649048,
0.38814643025398254,
-0.03736759349703789,
0.46481582522392273,
-0.06946393847465515,
-0.7850750088691711,
-0.07577802240848541,
-0.6825857758522034,
0.006996625103056431,
-0.028879057615995407,
-1.1168811321258545,
1.0618289709091187,
-0.34894993901252747,
0.1538579910993576,
-0.16104307770729065,
0.4835064113140106,
0.5034658312797546,
0.8619887828826904,
0.3794732987880707,
-0.031137023121118546,
0.38101497292518616,
0.24428848922252655,
1.0893367528915405,
-0.7290722131729126,
0.5601959228515625,
0.9081975817680359,
-0.9767611026763916,
0.5249390602111816,
0.6909762024879456,
-0.1722143590450287,
0.37824946641921997,
0.4582631587982178,
-0.1649700403213501,
0.305339515209198,
0.3529178500175476,
-0.02510041370987892,
-0.12315476685762405,
-0.3138394355773926,
-0.5076152682304382,
0.3571915626525879,
0.030744893476366997,
-0.4694488048553467,
-0.011209782212972641,
-0.12623322010040283,
0.11618699878454208,
0.0791972205042839,
-0.3450491726398468,
0.8404346108436584,
0.2090425044298172,
-0.5879119038581848,
0.04993126913905144,
0.03556152433156967,
0.33832839131355286,
-0.7405737638473511,
-0.31267720460891724,
-0.21531547605991364,
0.10641380399465561,
-0.03715410828590393,
-0.8347322344779968,
-0.14414863288402557,
-0.08378350734710693,
-0.101029172539711,
-0.6687168478965759,
0.6575592160224915,
-0.12398675084114075,
-0.3953549861907959,
0.5144370198249817,
0.9704723358154297,
0.22777122259140015,
-0.039325300604104996,
-0.4597824215888977,
0.2892591655254364,
-0.37229177355766296,
-0.7692503333091736,
0.4660649597644806,
0.5094533562660217,
-0.0007504508248530328,
0.7768986821174622,
0.5409209728240967,
0.5061133503913879,
-0.19270706176757812,
0.08132370561361313,
1.0571777820587158,
-0.48002269864082336,
-0.7529247999191284,
-0.738272488117218,
-0.04954710230231285,
-0.08470882475376129,
-0.004886855836957693,
0.6967619061470032,
0.4413665235042572,
0.5648006200790405,
-0.11504977196455002,
0.6527931690216064,
0.27020230889320374,
0.3794865906238556,
-0.3610532879829407,
1.330175518989563,
-0.6586992144584656,
0.4091311991214752,
-0.577141284942627,
-0.998127281665802,
-0.09848777204751968,
0.43725621700286865,
-0.28243374824523926,
0.19808277487754822,
0.7526938915252686,
0.9437503218650818,
0.4450919032096863,
0.13679571449756622,
0.07151424139738083,
0.38214144110679626,
0.425042986869812,
0.11974800378084183,
1.0625455379486084,
-0.16496208310127258,
0.37717676162719727,
-0.19493944942951202,
-0.1240609660744667,
-0.14448101818561554,
-1.094006896018982,
-1.0708588361740112,
-0.31652194261550903,
-0.3342353105545044,
-0.7516902685165405,
0.2519022822380066,
0.9798988103866577,
0.5885975360870361,
-0.6081218123435974,
-0.6014225482940674,
0.13183636963367462,
0.2498609572649002,
-0.04170907661318779,
-0.19250744581222534,
0.29902490973472595,
0.02273322455585003,
-0.7078883647918701,
0.0495828315615654,
0.09561839699745178,
0.021156134083867073,
-0.6057869791984558,
-0.1528671830892563,
-0.005350806284695864,
0.10107558965682983,
0.36091864109039307,
0.09418559819459915,
-0.3889145851135254,
0.06819117814302444,
0.08317621797323227,
-0.0941048189997673,
-0.10229283571243286,
1.0676114559173584,
-0.6639387607574463,
0.6047610640525818,
0.6800581216812134,
0.31831663846969604,
0.43512263894081116,
0.21283693611621857,
0.4983116686344147,
-0.19797973334789276,
0.0996704027056694,
0.25016164779663086,
0.08021765947341919,
-0.1881680190563202,
-0.4876919388771057,
0.5887697339057922,
0.33507928252220154,
-1.006971001625061,
-1.2362611293792725,
0.054362889379262924,
-0.9917497038841248,
-0.09458214789628983,
1.3020710945129395,
0.08873873203992844,
-0.30056557059288025,
-0.06528206169605255,
-0.3338976502418518,
-0.020588478073477745,
-0.9532647132873535,
0.9739904403686523,
0.6885350942611694,
-0.31852981448173523,
-0.3679724335670471,
-0.6482106447219849,
0.41730326414108276,
0.16525661945343018,
-0.646399736404419,
0.12344886362552643,
0.5457690358161926,
0.27992120385169983,
0.029697855934500694,
0.8057987689971924,
-0.3875049352645874,
0.18295758962631226,
-0.17260989546775818,
-0.005240841303020716,
-0.3930553197860718,
-0.49082526564598083,
-0.7371149659156799,
0.5161253213882446,
0.23163771629333496,
0.4554045498371124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12707v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12707v1 | Talk With Human-like Agents: Empathetic Dialogue Through Perceptible Acoustic Reception and Reaction | 2024-06-18T15:19:51 | 2024-06-18T15:19:51 | Haoqiu Yan, Yongxin Zhu, Kai Zheng, Bing Liu, Haoyu Cao, Deqiang Jiang, Linli Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Large Language Model (LLM)-enhanced agents become increasingly prevalent in
Human-AI communication, offering vast potential from entertainment to
professional domains. However, current multi-modal dialogue systems overlook
the acoustic information present in speech, which is crucial for understanding
human communication nuances. This oversight can lead to misinterpretations of
speakers' intentions, resulting in inconsistent or even contradictory responses
within dialogues. To bridge this gap, in this paper, we propose
PerceptiveAgent, an empathetic multi-modal dialogue system designed to discern
deeper or more subtle meanings beyond the literal interpretations of words
through the integration of speech modality perception. Employing LLMs as a
cognitive core, PerceptiveAgent perceives acoustic information from input
speech and generates empathetic responses based on speaking styles described in
natural language. Experimental results indicate that PerceptiveAgent excels in
contextual understanding by accurately discerning the speakers' true intentions
in scenarios where the linguistic meaning is either contrary to or inconsistent
with the speaker's true feelings, producing more nuanced and expressive spoken
dialogues. Code is publicly available at:
\url{https://github.com/Haoqiu-Yan/PerceptiveAgent}. | [
-0.27617475390434265,
-0.7769811153411865,
0.8676677346229553,
0.3914394974708557,
-0.1532316356897354,
0.06690499931573868,
-0.32399803400039673,
-0.4307464063167572,
0.4554218053817749,
0.25300005078315735,
-0.7315782308578491,
-0.34227636456489563,
-0.24899907410144806,
0.16576321423053741,
-0.02492726780474186,
0.46415066719055176,
0.3526271879673004,
0.13104017078876495,
0.24340105056762695,
-0.0251640435308218,
-0.2259591966867447,
-0.4911419153213501,
-0.5826904773712158,
-0.8035218715667725,
0.6740533709526062,
0.42297422885894775,
0.668394148349762,
0.2083682119846344,
0.05449381843209267,
0.4472682476043701,
0.18726837635040283,
0.1346501111984253,
-0.2084602415561676,
0.3672744333744049,
-0.11911360174417496,
-0.4926588535308838,
-0.7127373218536377,
0.048105765134096146,
0.3123137354850769,
0.34237292408943176,
-0.28518441319465637,
-0.1913052201271057,
-0.10070283710956573,
-0.05703732743859291,
-0.4849213659763336,
0.29813846945762634,
-0.38304558396339417,
0.3754119277000427,
0.08793789893388748,
-0.46896472573280334,
-0.39079928398132324,
0.2072315663099289,
0.16707482933998108,
-0.6362766027450562,
-0.41671618819236755,
-0.19235707819461823,
0.19219200313091278,
0.6777211427688599,
-0.5699105262756348,
-0.03035757504403591,
-0.8823112845420837,
0.7587265968322754,
-0.6653451323509216,
0.57562655210495,
0.5106397271156311,
0.20591133832931519,
0.10135811567306519,
-0.36871403455734253,
-0.9185513257980347,
-0.43189090490341187,
0.11438675969839096,
0.3999893367290497,
-0.20520439743995667,
0.3436657786369324,
0.11027736961841583,
-0.07814038544893265,
-0.5010936856269836,
0.11146640032529831,
0.508843183517456,
-0.2477329820394516,
0.5881025791168213,
0.4587259590625763,
0.281917005777359,
-0.2813367247581482,
-0.24990999698638916,
0.0805283710360527,
-0.19982755184173584,
-0.1087377667427063,
0.43379566073417664,
0.281219482421875,
-0.44217461347579956,
0.418111652135849,
0.05022956058382988,
0.6026467084884644,
0.3463473320007324,
-0.2837284207344055,
0.3860699534416199,
-0.13542988896369934,
-0.3844406008720398,
0.2906532883644104,
0.6325209140777588,
0.13806061446666718,
0.16956806182861328,
-0.009131358936429024,
-0.22632674872875214,
0.10509246587753296,
0.30018478631973267,
-0.6264365315437317,
-0.05385902151465416,
0.47318631410598755,
-0.33154061436653137,
-0.4066842794418335,
-0.1572093963623047,
-0.44076645374298096,
-0.6214443445205688,
-0.5357197523117065,
0.3286686837673187,
-0.5402764678001404,
-0.4482384920120239,
-0.03627790883183479,
-0.055790942162275314,
0.4811839163303375,
0.6205829977989197,
-0.7034250497817993,
-0.053257789462804794,
0.6871758699417114,
0.5361173152923584,
0.37319403886795044,
-0.4942210912704468,
-0.48045703768730164,
0.19917114078998566,
-0.03139162063598633,
0.7588983178138733,
-1.0212746858596802,
-0.3718448579311371,
-0.33703404664993286,
-0.24430009722709656,
-0.12481493502855301,
-0.14890559017658234,
0.5788537859916687,
-0.2115446776151657,
-0.2138580083847046,
-0.13338793814182281,
-0.24115963280200958,
-0.1380367875099182,
0.43433716893196106,
-0.40183642506599426,
-0.0318913497030735,
-0.11175315082073212,
-0.5731510519981384,
0.14708733558654785,
-0.7222312688827515,
-0.24849265813827515,
0.24549533426761627,
-0.5604026913642883,
0.13362421095371246,
0.12185768783092499,
0.012422102503478527,
0.17542988061904907,
-0.31911978125572205,
0.031059160828590393,
-0.023861678317189217,
-0.2824666202068329,
0.8604899644851685,
-0.9866973161697388,
0.4872903823852539,
0.298821359872818,
-0.35592350363731384,
0.23860684037208557,
-0.549401581287384,
-0.17313209176063538,
-0.03459019586443901,
-0.41852080821990967,
-0.19594766199588776,
0.08109760284423828,
0.18558011949062347,
0.2385282814502716,
0.20431405305862427,
-0.8123843669891357,
-0.06940146535634995,
-0.37808743119239807,
0.3918387293815613,
0.8738687038421631,
-0.062469225376844406,
0.5947291851043701,
-0.3528634309768677,
0.6237438321113586,
-0.0907452255487442,
0.3262435495853424,
-0.27661484479904175,
-0.25047487020492554,
-0.5565117001533508,
-0.45453310012817383,
-0.33854857087135315,
0.6765751242637634,
-0.692972719669342,
0.5363755226135254,
-0.05214428901672363,
-0.4613950252532959,
-0.5876051783561707,
-0.1279067099094391,
0.6208922266960144,
0.4129496216773987,
0.027547787874937057,
-0.1488761305809021,
-0.3331727981567383,
-0.656760573387146,
-0.5744927525520325,
-0.17172746360301971,
-0.1842612773180008,
0.7155815958976746,
-0.005960036069154739,
-0.5102888941764832,
0.8253453373908997,
-0.34252265095710754,
-0.324312686920166,
-0.27599048614501953,
0.048602428287267685,
0.04644722864031792,
0.31729447841644287,
0.21028655767440796,
-1.001666784286499,
-0.4304317533969879,
0.19601958990097046,
-0.7587586641311646,
-0.31379231810569763,
-0.2126314342021942,
0.19926100969314575,
0.07812626659870148,
0.3552364110946655,
-0.6838898658752441,
0.4152980148792267,
0.7213645577430725,
-0.6350961923599243,
0.3604154884815216,
0.13813287019729614,
0.25792673230171204,
-0.9869586825370789,
-0.15120141208171844,
-0.24558666348457336,
-0.16405734419822693,
-0.8768131136894226,
-0.31991255283355713,
-0.3157794177532196,
-0.013627621345221996,
-0.6685752868652344,
0.6697497367858887,
-0.305604487657547,
0.02820924110710621,
-0.22423574328422546,
0.20980766415596008,
-0.08116117119789124,
0.5178752541542053,
-0.08388625830411911,
0.6450445055961609,
0.43410003185272217,
-0.3919975161552429,
0.7844424247741699,
0.6683552861213684,
0.16253840923309326,
1.0103282928466797,
-0.44633522629737854,
0.43069711327552795,
-0.025598634034395218,
0.4010019898414612,
-0.9100732207298279,
-0.5240711569786072,
0.42898231744766235,
-0.7715144157409668,
0.27960115671157837,
-0.021900873631238937,
-0.028200475499033928,
-0.08447317034006119,
-0.15388116240501404,
0.48204606771469116,
0.09472695738077164,
-0.5112677812576294,
1.4083571434020996,
0.23896557092666626,
-0.3237610459327698,
-0.3903557062149048,
-1.0553503036499023,
0.14080055058002472,
0.021468965336680412,
-0.5186906456947327,
-0.16573353111743927,
-0.20647893846035004,
-0.6208882331848145,
-0.3777455985546112,
-0.07555720955133438,
-0.004931020550429821,
-0.15321232378482819,
0.4986330270767212,
-0.07956195622682571,
0.1406536102294922,
0.3640858829021454,
0.15101581811904907,
-0.21745406091213226,
0.10083293914794922,
-0.24907168745994568,
0.8312850594520569,
-0.23280063271522522,
-0.7136738896369934,
-0.8503268957138062,
0.23838648200035095,
0.6700459718704224,
-0.28581690788269043,
0.29811227321624756,
0.7577646374702454,
0.057066891342401505,
0.027872750535607338,
-0.6058757901191711,
-0.580298900604248,
-0.532111406326294,
0.26111462712287903,
-0.7296520471572876,
-0.7174569964408875,
0.48631924390792847,
-0.11190306395292282,
-0.4027723968029022,
-0.14717578887939453,
0.5289618372917175,
0.18170636892318726,
1.069272518157959,
0.15453536808490753,
-0.0657183974981308,
0.7875571846961975,
0.052155978977680206,
0.28093889355659485,
-0.9993534684181213,
-0.2944454252719879,
-0.25276872515678406,
-0.403344064950943,
-0.42835575342178345,
-0.4066891670227051,
0.5189986228942871,
-0.7512654066085815,
-0.4762135446071625,
-0.11501681059598923,
-0.24405016005039215,
0.23045065999031067,
0.3483783006668091,
0.3213368058204651,
0.44071877002716064,
-0.06275434792041779,
-0.10656647384166718,
-0.014329006895422935,
-0.26042962074279785,
-0.6227028965950012,
0.7916351556777954,
0.3656747341156006,
1.0580567121505737,
0.43747678399086,
0.5272445678710938,
0.17479996383190155,
0.12392491102218628,
-1.0006314516067505,
0.5875341892242432,
0.16151189804077148,
-0.49975863099098206,
-0.535631537437439,
-0.3543795645236969,
-0.94661945104599,
0.376650869846344,
-0.23909804224967957,
-0.9960533380508423,
0.3839516043663025,
-0.006020519882440567,
-0.42041775584220886,
0.1196456179022789,
-0.5355366468429565,
0.5446487665176392,
-0.3896130621433258,
-0.47484785318374634,
-0.42110925912857056,
-0.7944902777671814,
0.025961333885788918,
-0.1992647498846054,
0.07878909260034561,
-0.19526000320911407,
-0.2496560961008072,
0.3017401099205017,
-0.33101263642311096,
1.0989896059036255,
-0.24058236181735992,
-0.29048052430152893,
0.15751464664936066,
0.3782409131526947,
0.33936288952827454,
0.10720560699701309,
-0.21546876430511475,
0.06938348710536957,
-0.48017066717147827,
-0.2713847756385803,
-0.6082566380500793,
0.6834307312965393,
-0.9601377248764038,
-0.5690509080886841,
-0.22926834225654602,
-0.7552832365036011,
-0.2477511316537857,
0.06967201083898544,
0.023352494463324547,
0.5386579632759094,
-0.48815667629241943,
-0.12525853514671326,
0.3856823146343231,
-0.3492335379123688,
0.4913252294063568,
1.0411620140075684,
0.08132718503475189,
-0.22209419310092926,
0.7796137928962708,
-0.27145150303840637,
0.30342724919319153,
0.6846239566802979,
0.31746792793273926,
-0.1868736296892166,
0.13069725036621094,
-0.3084370791912079,
0.33707568049430847,
-0.3793163001537323,
-0.061978310346603394,
-0.7843079566955566,
0.09713903814554214,
-0.27149534225463867,
-0.32938626408576965,
-0.23733606934547424,
-0.20221896469593048,
-0.272833913564682,
-0.3233577311038971,
0.3453839123249054,
0.9023922681808472,
-0.27069008350372314,
0.4586260914802551,
-0.7411569356918335,
0.10691451281309128,
0.6646993160247803,
0.03948986530303955,
0.09312093257904053,
-0.5784018039703369,
0.15024422109127045,
0.18062183260917664,
-0.45844563841819763,
-0.9364405274391174,
0.7610664367675781,
0.06300996989011765,
0.44337189197540283,
0.9080389142036438,
-0.07546811550855637,
0.2901662290096283,
-0.29292455315589905,
0.6767105460166931,
0.1752077043056488,
-1.169270396232605,
0.5245678424835205,
-0.669779896736145,
0.5126078128814697,
0.3116389214992523,
-0.00047749216901138425,
-0.5700291395187378,
-0.4826675057411194,
-0.572939932346344,
-0.6291589736938477,
0.7529171705245972,
0.03366325795650482,
0.30169910192489624,
0.15251749753952026,
0.09404629468917847,
-0.06407401710748672,
0.42122960090637207,
-0.3621007204055786,
-0.05632440745830536,
-0.2399166375398636,
-0.21751777827739716,
-0.31240832805633545,
-0.07682254910469055,
-0.33376556634902954,
-0.045629341155290604,
0.22507570683956146,
-0.2924545705318451,
0.6622436046600342,
0.43803903460502625,
-0.17440655827522278,
-0.4405014216899872,
0.5468578934669495,
0.5885593891143799,
0.4930868148803711,
-0.15157108008861542,
0.332504004240036,
0.1748262494802475,
-0.5425081849098206,
0.2551957666873932,
0.17130480706691742,
0.2561911642551422,
-0.28592732548713684,
0.5068378448486328,
0.6133133769035339,
0.1885589063167572,
-0.7470924854278564,
0.7286267876625061,
-0.20437811315059662,
0.19793292880058289,
-0.5525057315826416,
-0.17015181481838226,
0.14888283610343933,
0.7158223986625671,
0.3211808502674103,
0.15374606847763062,
0.38252338767051697,
-0.6643431782722473,
0.03331102430820465,
0.3132771849632263,
-0.7273781299591064,
-0.665928840637207,
0.5614000558853149,
0.5962917804718018,
-0.7087510824203491,
0.5707892775535583,
-0.03635573014616966,
-0.8100773692131042,
0.3304797112941742,
0.45311012864112854,
1.0685396194458008,
-0.8075125217437744,
0.18290257453918457,
-0.3482217788696289,
0.0406777486205101,
0.6177468299865723,
0.5443052649497986,
-0.29438385367393494,
-1.2082446813583374,
-0.19598722457885742,
-0.4049745500087738,
-0.5619197487831116,
-0.31224000453948975,
-0.3874962329864502,
-0.27995800971984863,
-0.3821840286254883,
-0.3853065073490143,
0.002028112765401602,
-0.13764986395835876,
-0.7697178721427917,
0.043766554445028305,
0.270614892244339,
0.6539430022239685,
-0.9690018892288208,
0.6946774125099182,
0.8387174606323242,
-0.6160086989402771,
-1.221572995185852,
0.15511833131313324,
0.44267192482948303,
-0.8535417318344116,
0.5612925887107849,
-0.09502269327640533,
-0.6013621091842651,
-0.019345592707395554,
-0.48150113224983215,
-0.3154486119747162,
1.132253646850586,
0.42497408390045166,
-0.5874226093292236,
0.17235919833183289,
0.09324679523706436,
0.5391244292259216,
-0.4482893645763397,
0.7471614480018616,
0.6966280341148376,
0.9077662229537964,
0.2475801557302475,
-1.3046505451202393,
0.1471026986837387,
-0.22356824576854706,
-0.31808051466941833,
0.05478550121188164,
-1.0511356592178345,
0.9167647957801819,
-0.22126245498657227,
0.12010730803012848,
0.0638304129242897,
0.19190649688243866,
0.15536805987358093,
0.506395697593689,
0.4901328980922699,
0.2676227390766144,
0.6694537997245789,
0.12072916328907013,
1.097143530845642,
-0.1517993062734604,
-0.16796740889549255,
1.0180836915969849,
-0.47100991010665894,
0.7075629234313965,
0.5637034177780151,
0.06624969840049744,
0.45038989186286926,
0.03771614283323288,
0.44714638590812683,
0.07154820114374161,
-0.04011792317032814,
-0.886416494846344,
-0.5317044854164124,
-0.5883839130401611,
0.0803767666220665,
1.154698133468628,
0.47457996010780334,
-0.295793741941452,
0.16541720926761627,
0.2092842012643814,
-0.0041210344061255455,
0.14637406170368195,
-0.2092570662498474,
0.8629176020622253,
0.3957257866859436,
-0.3729415535926819,
0.2729088366031647,
-0.3882530629634857,
0.6745933890342712,
-0.5139079093933105,
-0.08699853718280792,
-0.03269365429878235,
0.42598700523376465,
-0.4619809091091156,
-0.6594986319541931,
-0.12815281748771667,
-0.3379323482513428,
0.10658901929855347,
-0.24053624272346497,
0.8028904795646667,
-0.46875301003456116,
0.07477928698062897,
0.619409441947937,
0.7852988243103027,
0.3132132589817047,
-0.3125327229499817,
-0.5957266092300415,
0.2849419116973877,
0.03161606937646866,
-0.32520735263824463,
-0.043902475386857986,
0.6132314205169678,
0.17034173011779785,
0.8309145569801331,
0.4510265588760376,
0.019827911630272865,
-0.2866661846637726,
0.5094800591468811,
1.0397932529449463,
-0.6463581323623657,
-0.4693424701690674,
-0.7343219518661499,
0.28343626856803894,
0.1532605141401291,
-0.11434429883956909,
0.7478071451187134,
0.19517934322357178,
0.35706281661987305,
-0.09184486418962479,
0.7385732531547546,
0.1443718522787094,
0.42882853746414185,
-0.08391450345516205,
0.6583536267280579,
-0.40759289264678955,
0.13657163083553314,
-0.44035887718200684,
-0.8180763721466064,
-0.16998496651649475,
0.9061040878295898,
-0.5544462203979492,
0.18194220960140228,
0.4716947376728058,
0.8549485206604004,
0.08656475692987442,
0.2680943012237549,
0.750595211982727,
0.6590808033943176,
0.42294183373451233,
0.6319056153297424,
1.3142083883285522,
0.14722461998462677,
0.36374136805534363,
0.3566080331802368,
-0.3504948914051056,
-0.35142678022384644,
-0.5004448294639587,
-0.7771055102348328,
-0.35024523735046387,
0.21128855645656586,
-0.06777218729257584,
0.036180172115564346,
1.3219424486160278,
0.6509552597999573,
-0.408162385225296,
-0.34933850169181824,
-0.08943894505500793,
-0.018201565369963646,
0.1703946888446808,
-0.25800684094429016,
-0.15626978874206543,
-0.055324338376522064,
-0.9013032913208008,
0.6649218201637268,
0.5168545842170715,
0.16594478487968445,
-0.3178838789463043,
-0.4213711619377136,
-0.11428578197956085,
0.4978761374950409,
0.6384064555168152,
0.27390098571777344,
-0.7649175524711609,
-0.3246418237686157,
-0.08938245475292206,
0.012118601240217686,
-0.15866351127624512,
0.7313143014907837,
-0.6386522054672241,
0.5734472274780273,
0.2457938939332962,
0.2514423131942749,
0.37345340847969055,
0.08682941645383835,
0.7699277997016907,
-0.4483472406864166,
0.5369927287101746,
0.565024733543396,
0.07520664483308792,
0.34499791264533997,
-0.43951866030693054,
0.22466591000556946,
-0.0008292908896692097,
-0.6780084371566772,
-0.44443315267562866,
0.6344769597053528,
-1.1382319927215576,
-0.07036016136407852,
1.231108546257019,
-0.0024805814027786255,
-0.2723451256752014,
-0.2992129325866699,
-0.6278388500213623,
0.3062332272529602,
-0.9613465666770935,
0.29864701628685,
0.2703481912612915,
-0.46666720509529114,
-0.10212399065494537,
-0.05408622696995735,
0.39400020241737366,
0.4350234568119049,
-0.5274603366851807,
-0.055380359292030334,
0.5326600074768066,
0.09513778984546661,
0.37925177812576294,
0.8392156958580017,
0.24068032205104828,
0.1362316608428955,
0.37275049090385437,
0.20339393615722656,
-0.031667549163103104,
-0.27871665358543396,
-0.47520872950553894,
-0.15457145869731903,
0.24002255499362946,
-0.07670816779136658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12702v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12702v2 | [WIP] Jailbreak Paradox: The Achilles' Heel of LLMs | 2024-06-18T15:14:35 | 2024-06-21T00:05:35 | Abhinav Rao, Monojit Choudhury, Somak Aditya | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce two paradoxes concerning jailbreak of foundation models: First,
it is impossible to construct a perfect jailbreak classifier, and second, a
weaker model cannot consistently detect whether a stronger (in a
pareto-dominant sense) model is jailbroken or not. We provide formal proofs for
these paradoxes and a short case study on Llama and GPT4-o to demonstrate this.
We discuss broader theoretical and practical repercussions of these results. | [
-0.14829252660274506,
-0.559005856513977,
0.9786560535430908,
0.08131545782089233,
-0.18342244625091553,
0.5282655358314514,
0.3642427921295166,
-0.7766570448875427,
0.14259687066078186,
0.6650443077087402,
-0.24883247911930084,
0.017292961478233337,
-0.8224566578865051,
0.1196170449256897,
-0.7396990060806274,
1.0492624044418335,
-0.2722170650959015,
0.06679914146661758,
-0.18726541101932526,
-0.3350536525249481,
-0.8968750834465027,
-0.5514295697212219,
-0.19323131442070007,
-0.5641328692436218,
-0.07977726310491562,
0.5751956105232239,
0.6403677463531494,
0.6665652394294739,
0.5373954176902771,
0.2808423638343811,
-0.2188115268945694,
-0.5157073736190796,
-0.41212785243988037,
0.2150276154279709,
-0.12180407345294952,
-0.8469990491867065,
-0.20963311195373535,
0.2675933539867401,
0.09906716644763947,
0.3392925560474396,
-0.16473083198070526,
-0.02800549939274788,
-0.39283287525177,
1.0523375272750854,
-0.6040805578231812,
-0.5297255516052246,
-0.9627512693405151,
0.11396253108978271,
-0.3713330626487732,
0.10925278812646866,
-0.07340496778488159,
-0.3561670780181885,
0.020965605974197388,
-0.13849447667598724,
0.33715906739234924,
0.220945343375206,
0.8723551034927368,
0.45191746950149536,
-0.4948936104774475,
-0.27563661336898804,
-0.7560989260673523,
0.5293521285057068,
-0.4430072605609894,
-0.06354117393493652,
0.325772762298584,
0.7096711993217468,
0.12845803797245026,
-0.8470189571380615,
-0.4656628966331482,
-0.6242736577987671,
0.2909194529056549,
-0.3650205433368683,
-0.1214686781167984,
-0.15686865150928497,
0.3481285274028778,
0.9159787893295288,
-0.22126322984695435,
0.21180923283100128,
-0.44651541113853455,
0.009781645610928535,
0.2864936292171478,
0.26319652795791626,
0.2725420594215393,
-0.034040406346321106,
-0.7931274771690369,
0.26152312755584717,
-1.3285077810287476,
-0.13763166964054108,
0.7059088349342346,
-0.11477917432785034,
-0.21891635656356812,
0.5615425109863281,
0.1989041268825531,
0.5580140948295593,
0.12235701084136963,
-0.31450730562210083,
0.31007444858551025,
-0.09363003075122833,
-0.21206757426261902,
0.16224968433380127,
0.48841750621795654,
0.3470609486103058,
0.212056502699852,
-0.4765101373195648,
-0.4216937720775604,
0.20092663168907166,
0.2177819311618805,
-0.5833060145378113,
-0.020838556811213493,
0.5688174962997437,
-0.28169479966163635,
-0.8457878828048706,
0.21338501572608948,
-0.581080436706543,
-0.6592554450035095,
0.260434627532959,
0.47436514496803284,
0.10748692601919174,
-0.21758577227592468,
0.23896601796150208,
-0.3222454786300659,
0.31232038140296936,
-0.11139193922281265,
-0.8097467422485352,
0.5732129812240601,
0.6010735630989075,
0.9636878371238708,
0.05859684199094772,
-0.3327396810054779,
-0.04221029207110405,
0.04951895773410797,
-0.23911599814891815,
0.7161397337913513,
-0.18639075756072998,
-0.45479002594947815,
-0.32328101992607117,
-0.17223265767097473,
0.10288150608539581,
-0.920264720916748,
0.42073723673820496,
-0.3109814524650574,
-0.4194360375404358,
-0.43908408284187317,
-0.6026047468185425,
0.011811851523816586,
0.28489717841148376,
-0.7022199630737305,
0.6328385472297668,
0.1126183569431305,
-0.8872816562652588,
0.06268395483493805,
-0.29471802711486816,
-0.4286257028579712,
-0.479209840297699,
-0.2106536328792572,
-0.6033634543418884,
0.23693746328353882,
-0.22005344927310944,
0.401216059923172,
-0.6674889326095581,
0.6640815138816833,
-0.5836806893348694,
-0.4816336929798126,
0.34156137704849243,
-0.03331877291202545,
0.8459338545799255,
0.23528364300727844,
-0.8678083419799805,
-0.28559985756874084,
-0.6308562755584717,
-0.5418943762779236,
0.8788877725601196,
-0.048029571771621704,
-0.20173338055610657,
0.4084712564945221,
-0.30483293533325195,
0.06068674474954605,
0.19618730247020721,
-0.5523030161857605,
0.47287583351135254,
-0.07728283107280731,
1.0163620710372925,
0.8639729022979736,
-0.12688441574573517,
0.22228343784809113,
-0.584809422492981,
0.33200761675834656,
-0.07212387025356293,
0.0006444554310292006,
-0.03064575232565403,
-0.3614976704120636,
-0.7740842700004578,
0.11164060980081558,
0.29430273175239563,
1.0241552591323853,
-0.4115717113018036,
-0.13658514618873596,
0.04041502997279167,
-0.5122339129447937,
-0.1229570135474205,
0.14326031506061554,
0.5613471269607544,
0.5189899802207947,
0.2104867547750473,
-0.6391681432723999,
-0.5678496956825256,
-0.7877974510192871,
-0.632249653339386,
-0.3986167311668396,
0.3523644208908081,
0.488433301448822,
0.7388157844543457,
-0.09060294181108475,
0.7877274751663208,
-0.3768835961818695,
-0.1975393444299698,
-0.3000195026397705,
-0.18433798849582672,
0.28081685304641724,
0.5935661792755127,
0.9754598140716553,
-0.8717367649078369,
0.08436957001686096,
-0.43273189663887024,
-0.9311323761940002,
-0.13808368146419525,
0.025251710787415504,
0.3532562255859375,
-0.129900723695755,
0.40426579117774963,
-0.8590077757835388,
0.6811267733573914,
0.04259128123521805,
-0.4130193889141083,
1.1532399654388428,
0.1397159844636917,
0.10472112149000168,
-0.6585626006126404,
-0.29178234934806824,
-0.14504268765449524,
-0.0185837559401989,
-0.7043730616569519,
0.3680284321308136,
-0.03745646774768829,
-0.013134603388607502,
-0.41456982493400574,
0.3429620862007141,
-0.20567579567432404,
-0.6200679540634155,
-0.25459393858909607,
0.12849581241607666,
-0.2056322991847992,
-0.01579361967742443,
-0.3106958866119385,
0.7359241247177124,
0.4556888937950134,
-0.5645081996917725,
0.6446356177330017,
0.15694786608219147,
-0.3832693099975586,
0.4623323380947113,
-0.8518330454826355,
0.07343356311321259,
0.16560032963752747,
0.16884909570217133,
-0.9424440264701843,
-0.3267163336277008,
0.04625900089740753,
-0.23196843266487122,
0.46689078211784363,
-0.33372196555137634,
-0.5189628005027771,
-0.5614996552467346,
-0.5455505847930908,
0.3751294016838074,
0.4584757089614868,
-0.8440303802490234,
0.034273792058229446,
0.29689815640449524,
0.1397516429424286,
-0.8438693881034851,
-0.7307222485542297,
0.16757991909980774,
-0.6804412603378296,
-0.6659647226333618,
0.47825706005096436,
-0.1032976359128952,
-0.6948122978210449,
0.09388013184070587,
-0.4931657910346985,
-0.05382988974452019,
0.7780939340591431,
0.4643884599208832,
0.17566198110580444,
-0.14881274104118347,
-0.1466873586177826,
-0.1662219762802124,
-0.2539393901824951,
0.20623637735843658,
-0.23449569940567017,
0.30792155861854553,
-0.491874098777771,
-0.6370007395744324,
-0.2789318561553955,
-0.06930452585220337,
0.8418486714363098,
0.03711201623082161,
0.37127426266670227,
-0.1917961835861206,
-0.349365770816803,
0.2248438596725464,
-0.6504716277122498,
0.08005478978157043,
-0.4637264609336853,
-0.03163311630487442,
-0.4645223021507263,
-0.8893900513648987,
0.6848679184913635,
-0.38900476694107056,
-0.12057514488697052,
0.49755945801734924,
0.49060317873954773,
0.08530710637569427,
0.5031027793884277,
0.9702010154724121,
-0.6619781255722046,
0.22220000624656677,
-0.39136290550231934,
0.34488052129745483,
-0.8002797365188599,
-0.1091359332203865,
-0.6964461207389832,
-0.3541781008243561,
-0.6859970092773438,
0.3291027843952179,
0.12576758861541748,
0.6961045861244202,
-0.600663423538208,
0.5916187763214111,
-0.268899530172348,
0.9341587424278259,
0.27691909670829773,
0.10697638243436813,
0.4215417504310608,
-0.19907689094543457,
-0.41327157616615295,
0.2980859577655792,
-0.6218109726905823,
-0.5161014199256897,
1.1877027750015259,
0.5320963263511658,
0.6245949864387512,
0.36149337887763977,
0.8665017485618591,
0.2813750207424164,
0.41681501269340515,
-0.5047169923782349,
0.3436504602432251,
0.12058503925800323,
-1.0570945739746094,
-0.028253775089979172,
-0.21991658210754395,
-0.5605612993240356,
0.14443588256835938,
-0.047292642295360565,
-1.1392720937728882,
0.28915631771087646,
0.21228836476802826,
-0.23102149367332458,
0.7872599363327026,
-0.6297993659973145,
1.0560214519500732,
-0.6235286593437195,
-0.48821592330932617,
-0.00590487290173769,
-0.8769749999046326,
0.9379723072052002,
-0.28583231568336487,
0.31822261214256287,
-0.45362594723701477,
0.3186729848384857,
0.4339200556278229,
-1.0055911540985107,
0.8229213356971741,
-0.2213192731142044,
0.3512188792228699,
0.5053836107254028,
0.2805744409561157,
0.6137500405311584,
0.11020748317241669,
0.209712952375412,
0.042217470705509186,
-0.11644711345434189,
-0.57567298412323,
-0.16481052339076996,
0.5985630750656128,
-0.9323922395706177,
-0.9514942765235901,
-0.616340696811676,
-0.23626866936683655,
-0.3994806706905365,
-0.13947314023971558,
0.6488339304924011,
-0.10584800690412521,
-0.14121009409427643,
-0.20761194825172424,
0.48241859674453735,
-0.04049721360206604,
0.5217451453208923,
0.47696998715400696,
-0.2424420565366745,
-0.25440096855163574,
0.6932199597358704,
0.14012248814105988,
0.23397882282733917,
-0.06401829421520233,
0.3901250660419464,
0.1164012998342514,
-0.8197000026702881,
-0.34687966108322144,
0.2334386110305786,
-0.632434606552124,
-0.24952736496925354,
-0.010602719150483608,
-0.29276785254478455,
0.176838219165802,
-0.3089774549007416,
-0.499035120010376,
-0.5949495434761047,
-0.08928368240594864,
-0.5627488493919373,
0.4789273142814636,
1.0210371017456055,
-0.22250212728977203,
0.49606451392173767,
-0.46945589780807495,
0.37691354751586914,
0.44513922929763794,
0.1796894371509552,
0.08187415450811386,
-0.5756989121437073,
0.16566264629364014,
-0.4377334713935852,
-0.6968788504600525,
-1.320143461227417,
-0.0359523668885231,
-0.06574175506830215,
0.45279115438461304,
0.6690739989280701,
0.04885279759764671,
0.4230756461620331,
-0.6327991485595703,
0.700468122959137,
0.5055105686187744,
-1.07840895652771,
0.65533047914505,
-0.20012593269348145,
-0.5557112097740173,
0.5413724780082703,
0.4457750618457794,
-0.052993904799222946,
-0.38947832584381104,
-0.7948827743530273,
-1.035780906677246,
0.24443916976451874,
0.15014874935150146,
0.028920527547597885,
-0.0018369787139818072,
0.7131338119506836,
0.1914285272359848,
0.41734156012535095,
-0.9544707536697388,
-0.5290060639381409,
-0.18868544697761536,
0.2681846618652344,
0.059551727026700974,
-0.7158668041229248,
-0.1579628437757492,
-0.10853438824415207,
0.5246204733848572,
0.566699206829071,
0.10514426231384277,
0.11235950887203217,
-0.31304728984832764,
-0.04889431968331337,
0.19210657477378845,
0.5621936321258545,
0.836843729019165,
-0.36186403036117554,
0.2105533629655838,
0.06943253427743912,
-0.4967499077320099,
0.7313531637191772,
-0.059076592326164246,
-0.25126755237579346,
-0.2267652153968811,
0.3752094507217407,
0.8571537137031555,
0.28754934668540955,
-0.6093558669090271,
0.7864348888397217,
0.07179251313209534,
-0.1628846675157547,
-0.37931984663009644,
0.03028530441224575,
0.0962957888841629,
0.5477299094200134,
0.4667561948299408,
0.09849300980567932,
0.035953275859355927,
-0.8166761994361877,
0.3583791255950928,
0.28864818811416626,
-0.12975455820560455,
-0.15486691892147064,
0.938847541809082,
0.14305981993675232,
-0.39261212944984436,
0.4748532176017761,
-0.12711244821548462,
-0.8925634622573853,
0.99250328540802,
0.6947516202926636,
0.8951758146286011,
-0.41537556052207947,
-0.13147002458572388,
-0.13479459285736084,
0.6483961939811707,
-0.4457502067089081,
0.06580433249473572,
0.0812433660030365,
-0.853740394115448,
-0.15362641215324402,
-0.2419339120388031,
-0.7151783108711243,
0.2660963833332062,
-0.7053197026252747,
0.06469277292490005,
-0.7716047763824463,
-0.26525038480758667,
-0.014761566184461117,
-0.09514559060335159,
-0.25770333409309387,
-0.07371026277542114,
-0.1812964379787445,
1.0321818590164185,
-0.990175187587738,
0.769248366355896,
0.4009908437728882,
-0.15838219225406647,
-0.5378017425537109,
0.05591955408453941,
0.36407577991485596,
-0.7156691551208496,
0.495797723531723,
0.3966186046600342,
0.1771828830242157,
-0.3320576548576355,
-0.9686764478683472,
-0.7326982021331787,
1.2355862855911255,
0.6130461692810059,
-0.7343085408210754,
0.25272589921951294,
-0.1291559487581253,
0.058170564472675323,
-0.27237722277641296,
-0.31385287642478943,
1.1298692226409912,
0.3639400899410248,
0.05097760632634163,
-0.8779606819152832,
-0.006096998229622841,
0.014029722660779953,
-0.2877460718154907,
0.3475847840309143,
-0.6006544232368469,
1.0051156282424927,
-1.0217771530151367,
0.052788086235523224,
0.5858669281005859,
0.18752960860729218,
0.5504795908927917,
0.6556455492973328,
0.48026028275489807,
1.1870002746582031,
0.561994731426239,
-0.3812335133552551,
1.2878563404083252,
-0.41095030307769775,
0.5572381615638733,
0.9352776408195496,
-0.5427489876747131,
0.6081346273422241,
0.5639103651046753,
-0.4708273410797119,
0.33915790915489197,
0.8898681998252869,
-0.23207804560661316,
0.6615141034126282,
0.2674665153026581,
-0.3137032389640808,
-0.10819220542907715,
0.4608767032623291,
-0.4901374280452728,
0.394067645072937,
0.22705599665641785,
-0.12388516962528229,
-0.09172466397285461,
-0.19968053698539734,
0.3080237805843353,
-0.26628386974334717,
-0.3671945631504059,
0.34926095604896545,
0.49183982610702515,
-0.12749741971492767,
0.40942835807800293,
0.4097207188606262,
0.38076838850975037,
-0.34518805146217346,
0.18982267379760742,
-0.3134547173976898,
0.12436413764953613,
-0.29604753851890564,
-0.556476891040802,
0.23035070300102234,
0.37349629402160645,
-0.09412267804145813,
0.4036647081375122,
0.902824342250824,
0.28451529145240784,
-0.0594969168305397,
0.539466381072998,
0.5201948881149292,
0.17163990437984467,
0.019017934799194336,
-0.7959581017494202,
0.04041855037212372,
-0.261112242937088,
-0.4231472909450531,
0.536923885345459,
0.012722666375339031,
-0.1585744172334671,
1.0473854541778564,
0.44129514694213867,
-0.177761971950531,
0.08700960874557495,
-0.5101584792137146,
0.959223210811615,
-0.8884401321411133,
-0.2603408992290497,
-1.3246616125106812,
0.28463348746299744,
0.18754351139068604,
-0.10916963964700699,
0.5026031732559204,
0.32929325103759766,
0.729893147945404,
0.013116007670760155,
0.7530869841575623,
-0.2008862942457199,
0.14561708271503448,
-0.6079239845275879,
0.529035210609436,
-0.47727543115615845,
0.8849066495895386,
-0.41471171379089355,
-0.7743862867355347,
-0.11332236230373383,
0.720625102519989,
-0.4580121338367462,
-0.04624279588460922,
0.8765859603881836,
0.18653731048107147,
0.15787141025066376,
-0.0552385114133358,
0.17606644332408905,
0.46274110674858093,
-0.1417841762304306,
0.8390927314758301,
1.043373465538025,
-0.4798741638660431,
0.40728381276130676,
-0.24433809518814087,
-0.11417724937200546,
-0.37783679366111755,
-1.0686042308807373,
-0.7793188691139221,
-0.17150883376598358,
-0.20415513217449188,
-0.6621823310852051,
0.25232142210006714,
0.26280176639556885,
0.46624109148979187,
-0.6875995993614197,
-0.3727107644081116,
-0.19951321184635162,
0.9411799311637878,
-0.020592160522937775,
-0.11422543227672577,
0.1104108914732933,
0.0586959645152092,
0.027855264022946358,
0.3845044672489166,
0.37399402260780334,
0.41085267066955566,
-0.06936056166887283,
-0.18758469820022583,
0.17592129111289978,
-0.005061452742666006,
0.2359221875667572,
0.6993707418441772,
-0.7637668251991272,
-0.37531033158302307,
-0.5364395976066589,
0.04192240536212921,
0.15180546045303345,
0.9478707909584045,
-0.7576688528060913,
0.05328503996133804,
0.0005148005438968539,
0.7195155620574951,
0.6099502444267273,
-0.20055530965328217,
0.3377744257450104,
-0.6280630826950073,
0.3869214653968811,
-0.010386737994849682,
0.7183195948600769,
0.28492027521133423,
-0.24510128796100616,
0.8864374756813049,
0.9401437640190125,
-0.5593207478523254,
-1.1213246583938599,
0.6013778448104858,
-0.7387045621871948,
-0.5685650706291199,
0.5968105792999268,
-0.2054552435874939,
-0.09853748977184296,
0.007373292464762926,
0.22702531516551971,
-0.2929541766643524,
0.2911474108695984,
0.8737145662307739,
0.7499942183494568,
-0.18895688652992249,
0.028434153646230698,
-1.029198408126831,
0.25468799471855164,
0.06578830629587173,
-0.5498052835464478,
-0.270678848028183,
0.1586199700832367,
0.8626603484153748,
0.19648239016532898,
0.5371901988983154,
-0.23939231038093567,
0.4529116451740265,
0.13903889060020447,
-0.19209057092666626,
-0.24686060845851898,
-0.42590779066085815,
-0.46140119433403015,
0.14215795695781708,
0.4067240357398987,
0.16637009382247925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12692v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12692v1 | MAGIC: Generating Self-Correction Guideline for In-Context Text-to-SQL | 2024-06-18T15:06:06 | 2024-06-18T15:06:06 | Arian Askari, Christian Poelitz, Xinye Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.HC | Self-correction in text-to-SQL is the process of prompting large language
model (LLM) to revise its previously incorrectly generated SQL, and commonly
relies on manually crafted self-correction guidelines by human experts that are
not only labor-intensive to produce but also limited by the human ability in
identifying all potential error patterns in LLM responses. We introduce MAGIC,
a novel multi-agent method that automates the creation of the self-correction
guideline. MAGIC uses three specialized agents: a manager, a correction, and a
feedback agent. These agents collaborate on the failures of an LLM-based method
on the training set to iteratively generate and refine a self-correction
guideline tailored to LLM mistakes, mirroring human processes but without human
involvement. Our extensive experiments show that MAGIC's guideline outperforms
expert human's created ones. We empirically find out that the guideline
produced by MAGIC enhance the interpretability of the corrections made,
providing insights in analyzing the reason behind the failures and successes of
LLMs in self-correction. We make all agent interactions publicly available to
the research community, to foster further research in this area, offering a
synthetic dataset for future explorations into automatic self-correction
guideline generation. | [
-0.06444098055362701,
-0.7444496154785156,
0.34835222363471985,
0.26786670088768005,
0.03396264463663101,
-0.10819655656814575,
-0.22595646977424622,
-0.06668613851070404,
0.3064180314540863,
1.1127386093139648,
-0.9572526812553406,
-0.3942534923553467,
-0.07946636527776718,
0.588593065738678,
-0.17766311764717102,
1.3910257816314697,
0.04213825985789299,
0.14070698618888855,
-0.126083642244339,
0.042440783232450485,
-0.8247297406196594,
-0.5064449906349182,
-0.3314328193664551,
-0.2756909132003784,
0.5469486713409424,
0.8009036779403687,
0.7123822569847107,
0.7059656977653503,
0.5154998302459717,
0.3065803050994873,
0.5991145372390747,
1.047401785850525,
-0.5527658462524414,
0.38012516498565674,
-0.35348212718963623,
-0.4616154432296753,
-0.96342933177948,
0.036588434129953384,
0.5775938630104065,
0.26218143105506897,
-0.5160223841667175,
0.09157703071832657,
0.23448540270328522,
1.0037497282028198,
-0.43845558166503906,
0.049256958067417145,
-1.0930055379867554,
0.02817167155444622,
-0.4379776120185852,
-0.6394943594932556,
-0.47844991087913513,
-0.2539607584476471,
-0.322739839553833,
-0.7209951877593994,
0.4985465109348297,
0.14727620780467987,
0.43069714307785034,
0.5305381417274475,
-0.5335155725479126,
-0.32361242175102234,
-0.9419566988945007,
0.3093593120574951,
-0.6353809833526611,
-0.17284934222698212,
0.3598659038543701,
0.5173724293708801,
-0.7451114654541016,
-0.4905456304550171,
-0.8368492722511292,
-0.0662151426076889,
-0.1690409630537033,
0.0030638875905424356,
0.31970158219337463,
0.11742247641086578,
0.05316614732146263,
0.004506576806306839,
-0.24967987835407257,
-0.5133770704269409,
-0.19161616265773773,
-0.04385559260845184,
0.915676474571228,
0.4345638155937195,
0.04247494786977768,
0.13267046213150024,
0.09444992989301682,
0.04156595095992088,
-0.8245837688446045,
-0.6469271779060364,
0.40611836314201355,
0.5267805457115173,
0.4918288588523865,
0.5821642875671387,
-0.11057600378990173,
0.5096564888954163,
0.41372066736221313,
-0.4511100947856903,
0.026295017451047897,
-0.590135395526886,
-0.15621508657932281,
0.22380566596984863,
0.8696878552436829,
0.6543826460838318,
0.34882014989852905,
-0.2693953812122345,
-0.3157668709754944,
-0.3783795237541199,
0.5162347555160522,
-0.561074435710907,
-0.2577401399612427,
-0.02847605012357235,
-0.026160122826695442,
-0.1747726947069168,
-0.2469199299812317,
-0.5415355563163757,
-0.7206793427467346,
-0.40396788716316223,
0.5458270311355591,
-0.17047099769115448,
-0.14531758427619934,
-0.12184266746044159,
0.11345051974058151,
0.003088671015575528,
0.6258121132850647,
-0.8259726166725159,
0.23405590653419495,
0.2770722508430481,
0.48295915126800537,
-0.14547082781791687,
-0.7637091875076294,
-0.45062145590782166,
0.6215270757675171,
-0.7168049812316895,
1.008653998374939,
-0.17091956734657288,
-0.47352156043052673,
-0.22552184760570526,
0.002621229039505124,
-0.09468554705381393,
-0.5160637497901917,
0.3108230531215668,
-0.3937267065048218,
0.25497862696647644,
-0.24853184819221497,
-0.5097995400428772,
0.27133113145828247,
0.2237314134836197,
-0.48113495111465454,
0.8981459736824036,
-0.15202338993549347,
-0.4265132248401642,
0.4269796907901764,
-0.8843162655830383,
-0.31410640478134155,
0.03257162123918533,
-0.1962861269712448,
-0.613269567489624,
-0.15496858954429626,
0.0905437245965004,
0.23075619339942932,
-0.3786775767803192,
0.20078250765800476,
-0.19155986607074738,
-0.17292405664920807,
0.299309104681015,
-0.5568166375160217,
0.3949797451496124,
0.195147305727005,
-0.26500406861305237,
0.13192924857139587,
-0.8698422908782959,
0.10125299543142319,
0.22338861227035522,
-0.21486683189868927,
-0.14071746170520782,
0.094039186835289,
-0.24686671793460846,
0.34956610202789307,
0.21887032687664032,
-0.12668141722679138,
0.6609943509101868,
-0.21082918345928192,
0.17382438480854034,
0.8422733545303345,
0.08313952386379242,
0.45274341106414795,
-0.22800837457180023,
0.27693986892700195,
-0.2589569389820099,
0.3272259533405304,
-0.44401970505714417,
-0.17687472701072693,
-0.5374264121055603,
0.012877273373305798,
0.17286285758018494,
0.5478699803352356,
-0.6933216452598572,
0.43702492117881775,
-0.1525295525789261,
-0.4786747694015503,
-0.6560873985290527,
0.38408610224723816,
0.4175325632095337,
0.6344613432884216,
0.4951147437095642,
-0.017455406486988068,
-0.41335785388946533,
-0.7381492853164673,
-0.6355234980583191,
0.0694189965724945,
0.3868393301963806,
0.19572582840919495,
0.479091614484787,
-0.34262192249298096,
1.36871337890625,
-0.37868812680244446,
-0.9424756169319153,
0.25033846497535706,
-0.07626184076070786,
0.08142034709453583,
0.3933306634426117,
0.30707648396492004,
-0.33432990312576294,
-0.7144454121589661,
-0.003882668213918805,
-0.8363887667655945,
-0.22167888283729553,
-0.25020813941955566,
-0.3842061460018158,
0.6936538815498352,
0.3375212252140045,
-0.2103404700756073,
0.4524359405040741,
0.3878575563430786,
-0.599624752998352,
0.7480790019035339,
-0.7351781725883484,
0.3983767330646515,
-1.1085840463638306,
-0.2172900140285492,
-0.25430363416671753,
-0.10067424923181534,
-0.5935054421424866,
-0.30813083052635193,
0.10213276743888855,
0.27163243293762207,
-0.06386245042085648,
0.5407891273498535,
-0.8065981268882751,
0.13290470838546753,
-0.4551372528076172,
-0.005050503648817539,
-0.024705279618501663,
0.5498058795928955,
-0.2399364411830902,
1.0070569515228271,
0.23661915957927704,
-0.6101706624031067,
0.569247305393219,
0.30357521772384644,
0.43586286902427673,
1.0205459594726562,
-0.27556031942367554,
0.37938714027404785,
-0.025533271953463554,
0.33833903074264526,
-0.8552946448326111,
-0.28160133957862854,
0.48950451612472534,
-0.2888225317001343,
0.34512847661972046,
-0.3582473397254944,
-0.7503498196601868,
-0.2532510459423065,
-0.04510480538010597,
0.1699790358543396,
0.22128432989120483,
-0.39465874433517456,
0.8414916396141052,
0.4080141484737396,
0.19420325756072998,
-0.7427834272384644,
-0.7134679555892944,
0.6250877380371094,
-0.01614304445683956,
-0.7304345369338989,
0.35055747628211975,
-0.39155641198158264,
-0.15237395465373993,
-0.17280946671962738,
-0.027192382141947746,
-0.09574290364980698,
-0.13109932839870453,
0.12069312483072281,
0.007525818422436714,
0.2203970104455948,
0.2970784306526184,
0.11896446347236633,
-0.04802638292312622,
0.2827184498310089,
-0.19509413838386536,
0.14292003214359283,
-0.0715271607041359,
-0.4615945816040039,
-0.29423266649246216,
0.3744102716445923,
0.5008795857429504,
-0.22824876010417938,
0.7836360931396484,
0.245126411318779,
-0.18830446898937225,
-0.4918558597564697,
-0.8067392110824585,
-0.4857493042945862,
-0.5019591450691223,
0.0035187210887670517,
-0.44727402925491333,
-0.2954544126987457,
0.46235570311546326,
0.055212367326021194,
0.25924643874168396,
0.5807702541351318,
0.5999483466148376,
-0.019825294613838196,
1.1634938716888428,
0.5274419784545898,
0.5426011085510254,
0.24538113176822662,
0.018260272219777107,
-0.06864383816719055,
-0.484271377325058,
-0.33072689175605774,
-0.3649350106716156,
0.1379389762878418,
-0.501124382019043,
-0.4098149240016937,
0.6434648036956787,
-0.09690690040588379,
-0.04456000030040741,
0.14621908962726593,
-0.8733830451965332,
0.6976822018623352,
0.4514482617378235,
-0.012270946986973286,
0.6774839162826538,
0.11962828040122986,
-0.18988090753555298,
-0.23001064360141754,
-0.6178460717201233,
-0.6663299202919006,
1.2385516166687012,
0.00178281229455024,
0.9828820824623108,
0.06697861105203629,
0.8527504205703735,
0.6008490324020386,
0.4825354218482971,
-0.28127047419548035,
0.44336622953414917,
0.20855551958084106,
-0.7543941140174866,
-0.4828178286552429,
-0.3057183027267456,
-0.9176150560379028,
0.30527544021606445,
-0.48871222138404846,
-0.016198568046092987,
-0.11301843822002411,
0.5988376140594482,
-0.22585797309875488,
0.19726364314556122,
-0.8383442163467407,
0.8572767376899719,
-0.17059679329395294,
-0.5975481271743774,
-0.2812197208404541,
-0.599251389503479,
0.24537581205368042,
-0.4564768373966217,
0.3130180537700653,
-0.04225554317235947,
-0.08282861858606339,
0.48892301321029663,
-0.983356237411499,
0.9506081938743591,
-0.11936056613922119,
-0.5331559777259827,
0.4606648087501526,
0.278122216463089,
0.9039303064346313,
-0.10325401276350021,
-0.14024798572063446,
0.021063420921564102,
-0.0022398564033210278,
-0.17441235482692719,
-0.7642395496368408,
0.4520995020866394,
-0.6543697714805603,
-0.6116575002670288,
-0.5441875457763672,
-0.4659852981567383,
-0.15179578959941864,
0.21035048365592957,
0.06191479042172432,
0.18891960382461548,
-0.01789931207895279,
-0.21133212745189667,
0.46553781628608704,
0.18812240660190582,
0.397693008184433,
1.0548126697540283,
-0.2684832215309143,
-0.6841912269592285,
0.8899857997894287,
0.5893422365188599,
0.018325675278902054,
-0.10950517654418945,
0.0724274069070816,
-0.3446047902107239,
-0.5012322664260864,
-0.6952511072158813,
0.4737069308757782,
-0.7875102162361145,
-0.253396600484848,
-0.5292327404022217,
-0.2128506898880005,
-0.5043309926986694,
0.07035693526268005,
-0.5263438820838928,
-0.13483290374279022,
-0.31318923830986023,
0.27019691467285156,
0.6561583280563354,
0.9913149476051331,
-0.23924140632152557,
0.31801074743270874,
-0.8574649095535278,
0.08586389571428299,
0.5726258754730225,
0.376054972410202,
-0.3413626253604889,
-0.5245152711868286,
-0.3950047492980957,
0.19323371350765228,
-0.5365662574768066,
-1.2866151332855225,
0.5120241045951843,
0.486797571182251,
0.5491369366645813,
0.045808181166648865,
0.21503473818302155,
0.9867714047431946,
-0.9710331559181213,
0.5974797010421753,
0.11763819307088852,
-0.8825381398200989,
0.764874279499054,
-0.5852856040000916,
-0.21160097420215607,
0.3657521605491638,
-0.22151805460453033,
-0.596274733543396,
-0.4604368507862091,
-0.5536477565765381,
-0.5742522478103638,
0.7459077835083008,
0.35300296545028687,
0.10966498404741287,
-0.16571031510829926,
0.7621785998344421,
0.09481921046972275,
0.3934616446495056,
-0.6190882921218872,
-0.6985037326812744,
-0.20257331430912018,
-0.050614096224308014,
0.19550248980522156,
-0.05921487137675285,
-0.44373881816864014,
-0.08052793890237808,
0.8034414649009705,
-0.6919924020767212,
0.2188359498977661,
0.48920735716819763,
-0.14186514914035797,
-0.548277735710144,
0.16450470685958862,
0.7305115461349487,
0.8753242492675781,
-0.013754325918853283,
-0.109084852039814,
0.5422952175140381,
-0.2462923675775528,
0.00044460236676968634,
0.06943260878324509,
0.04626525938510895,
-0.14081589877605438,
0.11523226648569107,
0.2678770422935486,
-0.38879507780075073,
-0.3928367495536804,
0.40566614270210266,
-0.3188757002353668,
-0.25297364592552185,
-0.5879335999488831,
0.25837913155555725,
-0.26062074303627014,
0.1152285635471344,
0.6336777210235596,
0.23289264738559723,
0.1678493767976761,
-0.5146061778068542,
0.24280647933483124,
0.6226816177368164,
-0.1622258871793747,
-0.11094918847084045,
0.6568158268928528,
0.38154152035713196,
-0.5563051700592041,
0.3788389563560486,
-0.5018026828765869,
-0.19342458248138428,
0.33034229278564453,
0.6299742460250854,
0.6999874114990234,
-0.3869076669216156,
0.15699684619903564,
0.1533656120300293,
0.3102128803730011,
-0.22325551509857178,
0.2230789065361023,
0.1981087476015091,
-0.6832337379455566,
-0.5764565467834473,
-0.18547610938549042,
-0.5094872713088989,
-0.27860474586486816,
-0.2412717491388321,
0.3504546582698822,
-0.2730444371700287,
-0.14971347153186798,
-0.28359293937683105,
0.08909739553928375,
-0.34470051527023315,
0.11050932854413986,
-0.18453694880008698,
0.5202263593673706,
-0.5004343390464783,
1.002921462059021,
0.5008734464645386,
-0.45536330342292786,
-0.9363030195236206,
-0.026106279343366623,
0.02946232445538044,
-0.7942687273025513,
0.2510165870189667,
-0.17556068301200867,
-0.34069064259529114,
0.021900614723563194,
-0.7647995948791504,
-0.7158766388893127,
1.2395583391189575,
0.5940535068511963,
-0.4938172996044159,
-0.21913215517997742,
0.18469968438148499,
0.8419554233551025,
-0.5631674528121948,
0.5338956117630005,
0.5312303304672241,
0.5813380479812622,
0.0990835577249527,
-1.0968223810195923,
0.09481508284807205,
-0.1852007955312729,
-0.13139481842517853,
0.2367761731147766,
-0.8354846239089966,
0.6488440632820129,
-0.3819883167743683,
0.017591189593076706,
-0.23521818220615387,
0.587014377117157,
0.3140474855899811,
0.23926304280757904,
0.40598583221435547,
0.10985789448022842,
0.9044234156608582,
0.05419129878282547,
0.8377768397331238,
-0.5214398503303528,
0.25740325450897217,
1.200972557067871,
-0.33994895219802856,
0.3627113401889801,
0.3381096124649048,
-0.027960341423749924,
0.6308427453041077,
0.4779748320579529,
-0.24033015966415405,
0.1845257729291916,
0.1272474080324173,
-0.08667664974927902,
-0.3272819519042969,
0.015462619252502918,
-0.3768548369407654,
0.20549657940864563,
0.2880438566207886,
-0.2842429578304291,
-0.12096168100833893,
-0.264384001493454,
0.21542632579803467,
0.3528271019458771,
-0.4230436384677887,
0.9317748546600342,
-0.2260858416557312,
-1.044112205505371,
0.564559280872345,
-0.011016026139259338,
0.5461521744728088,
-0.5802891850471497,
-0.42911428213119507,
-0.2855275273323059,
0.4278988242149353,
-0.4684221148490906,
-0.7952340841293335,
0.5026326775550842,
-0.20324638485908508,
-0.32863861322402954,
-0.33983203768730164,
0.6337175369262695,
-0.8091243505477905,
-0.2689175307750702,
0.10966487973928452,
0.5349295139312744,
0.13413089513778687,
-0.3355533182621002,
-0.9921543002128601,
-0.5209169387817383,
-0.15068641304969788,
-0.16206222772598267,
0.15409056842327118,
0.921371340751648,
-0.10703393071889877,
0.7573593258857727,
0.6614544987678528,
0.0801493301987648,
0.17037387192249298,
-0.0008669469389133155,
0.6207137107849121,
-0.6541642546653748,
-0.3381947875022888,
-1.029512882232666,
0.49959078431129456,
-0.22098347544670105,
-0.20437273383140564,
1.0229711532592773,
0.41292718052864075,
0.4714576005935669,
-0.13515296578407288,
0.6928068399429321,
0.2884957790374756,
0.4374159574508667,
-0.42216819524765015,
0.8880139589309692,
-0.6721392273902893,
0.4017787277698517,
-0.27496570348739624,
-0.7732941508293152,
-0.29980745911598206,
0.43005532026290894,
-0.03231921046972275,
0.23823197185993195,
0.8911927938461304,
1.2701843976974487,
0.4693041741847992,
-0.34535619616508484,
0.33060145378112793,
0.2288462519645691,
0.35334745049476624,
0.13585245609283447,
0.6441693902015686,
-0.45876845717430115,
1.0338585376739502,
-0.031607888638973236,
-0.029847875237464905,
-0.32755935192108154,
-1.1110312938690186,
-0.9859411716461182,
-0.6050755977630615,
-0.40298545360565186,
-0.8996763825416565,
0.3864547610282898,
1.419856071472168,
0.7661505341529846,
-0.5961121916770935,
-0.34529024362564087,
-0.19586358964443207,
0.3608238399028778,
-0.44246068596839905,
-0.20663262903690338,
0.24901650846004486,
-0.6107848286628723,
-0.5556697845458984,
0.3679179847240448,
0.21881259977817535,
0.11264976114034653,
-0.47902679443359375,
-0.3980892300605774,
0.08519803732633591,
0.3196892738342285,
0.29816335439682007,
0.11517802625894547,
-0.6674428582191467,
0.10802304744720459,
-0.10855105519294739,
-0.45752236247062683,
0.24959900975227356,
0.7823681235313416,
-0.5951084494590759,
0.6867551207542419,
0.1470833718776703,
0.30872830748558044,
0.15715603530406952,
-0.2738245129585266,
0.7700691223144531,
-0.9063841700553894,
-0.5781177878379822,
0.0031437037978321314,
0.15231043100357056,
0.3087438941001892,
-0.7052362561225891,
0.8150867819786072,
0.5115883946418762,
-0.9846951961517334,
-0.7326991558074951,
0.051912032067775726,
-0.636766791343689,
-0.07020099461078644,
1.27297043800354,
0.23488394916057587,
-0.4389152526855469,
-0.22472214698791504,
-0.7067088484764099,
0.22731611132621765,
-0.6113308072090149,
0.982262372970581,
0.48227542638778687,
-0.1613580733537674,
-0.08998971432447433,
-0.2088741809129715,
1.0134613513946533,
0.1350662261247635,
-0.9114554524421692,
0.43832212686538696,
0.6768808364868164,
0.5264923572540283,
0.1518755555152893,
0.8761317729949951,
0.09770356863737106,
0.29844823479652405,
-0.11384105682373047,
0.47993195056915283,
-0.29166457056999207,
-0.42777344584465027,
-0.2855495512485504,
0.03222959488630295,
0.09735571593046188,
0.3026474118232727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12687v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12687v1 | Using LLMs to Aid Annotation and Collection of Clinically-Enriched Data in Bipolar Disorder and Schizophrenia | 2024-06-18T15:00:24 | 2024-06-18T15:00:24 | Ankit Aich, Avery Quynh, Pamela Osseyi, Amy Pinkham, Philip Harvey, Brenda Curtis, Colin Depp, Natalie Parde | cs.CL | cs.CL | NLP in mental health has been primarily social media focused. Real world
practitioners also have high case loads and often domain specific variables, of
which modern LLMs lack context. We take a dataset made by recruiting 644
participants, including individuals diagnosed with Bipolar Disorder (BD),
Schizophrenia (SZ), and Healthy Controls (HC). Participants undertook tasks
derived from a standardized mental health instrument, and the resulting data
were transcribed and annotated by experts across five clinical variables. This
paper demonstrates the application of contemporary language models in
sequence-to-sequence tasks to enhance mental health research. Specifically, we
illustrate how these models can facilitate the deployment of mental health
instruments, data collection, and data annotation with high accuracy and
scalability. We show that small models are capable of annotation for
domain-specific clinical variables, data collection for mental-health
instruments, and perform better then commercial large models. | [
-0.3449558913707733,
-0.7388134598731995,
0.9796877503395081,
0.3033992648124695,
-0.1853339523077011,
-0.04302646964788437,
-0.18584950268268585,
-0.5750685334205627,
0.5113956332206726,
0.5545510649681091,
-0.6452884674072266,
-0.7728431224822998,
-0.7551491260528564,
0.30731797218322754,
-0.4145585894584656,
1.2147786617279053,
-0.03033916838467121,
0.4167321026325226,
-0.0813451036810875,
0.03803151100873947,
-0.34322166442871094,
-0.6972452402114868,
-0.5503003001213074,
-0.28348278999328613,
0.9038498997688293,
0.34249192476272583,
0.8359812498092651,
0.4659125506877899,
0.9020557403564453,
0.07833606749773026,
-0.05970378220081329,
0.472064346075058,
-0.39768126606941223,
0.2563164234161377,
-0.26918697357177734,
-0.2914468050003052,
-0.8624134659767151,
-0.19858935475349426,
0.5785708427429199,
1.0091519355773926,
-0.09130839258432388,
0.3293170928955078,
-0.18646226823329926,
0.4519137740135193,
-0.4593003988265991,
0.08173015713691711,
-0.04945588484406471,
0.15584810078144073,
-0.37468221783638,
-0.17737643420696259,
-0.36820507049560547,
-0.11611305922269821,
-0.05973559617996216,
-0.5615962147712708,
0.07911349833011627,
0.017449164763092995,
0.5164305567741394,
0.24281489849090576,
-0.4044567346572876,
-0.251628577709198,
-0.9111366271972656,
0.26609042286872864,
-1.0548473596572876,
0.13579629361629486,
0.6895381808280945,
0.024467358365654945,
-0.26784756779670715,
-0.78389972448349,
-0.35814425349235535,
0.2579241991043091,
-0.19665974378585815,
-0.11722727119922638,
0.035852767527103424,
0.1116485446691513,
0.6978158950805664,
0.25727131962776184,
-0.33484622836112976,
0.22643789649009705,
-0.40773841738700867,
-0.008408473804593086,
0.9897159934043884,
0.6299222111701965,
0.49087634682655334,
-0.20649035274982452,
-0.012210368178784847,
0.4132699966430664,
-0.6293874382972717,
-0.09538799524307251,
-0.2740260660648346,
0.5938054323196411,
-0.16813838481903076,
1.0338993072509766,
-0.07943491637706757,
0.7814565300941467,
0.024794859811663628,
-0.475676953792572,
0.06277333199977875,
-0.3403547406196594,
-0.26908206939697266,
-0.09426505863666534,
0.663966715335846,
0.5267996788024902,
0.01845654845237732,
-0.39263999462127686,
-0.18016773462295532,
-0.1366485357284546,
0.424426406621933,
-0.6074554920196533,
-0.27975329756736755,
0.4096960425376892,
-0.24984219670295715,
0.1638464629650116,
-0.16509123146533966,
-0.5645383596420288,
-0.5664151906967163,
-0.554060697555542,
0.21821051836013794,
-0.2634432315826416,
-0.10093097388744354,
0.2811123728752136,
-0.07308588176965714,
-0.07640650123357773,
0.2676028311252594,
-1.0622562170028687,
0.5796397924423218,
0.9843149781227112,
1.0011204481124878,
-0.33926597237586975,
0.11417572945356369,
-0.34367769956588745,
0.2907216250896454,
-0.39175209403038025,
0.7742370963096619,
-0.2914934456348419,
-0.39366257190704346,
0.06659192591905594,
0.19495028257369995,
0.15500935912132263,
-0.42843949794769287,
0.23700444400310516,
-0.3181166648864746,
-0.12541761994361877,
-0.5031387209892273,
-0.7249633073806763,
0.09390448778867722,
-0.06641478836536407,
-0.5271560549736023,
0.85495525598526,
0.4022177755832672,
-1.0917640924453735,
0.26455336809158325,
-0.30488091707229614,
-0.6419615745544434,
0.37816065549850464,
-0.2161640226840973,
-0.19205242395401,
0.36770057678222656,
0.1464501917362213,
0.818668007850647,
-0.27105164527893066,
0.5234285593032837,
-0.5959066152572632,
-0.46250447630882263,
0.3614848256111145,
0.0691864937543869,
0.6055018305778503,
-0.12705351412296295,
0.045080870389938354,
0.11484450846910477,
-0.6894945502281189,
-0.33675432205200195,
0.01879185438156128,
-0.1995885968208313,
-0.5340524315834045,
0.25938859581947327,
0.15016496181488037,
0.15054276585578918,
0.0965653732419014,
-0.3875780701637268,
0.1282585710287094,
-0.3760547935962677,
0.3263629972934723,
0.23730731010437012,
0.3919523060321808,
0.1473534107208252,
-0.6902176737785339,
0.5569650530815125,
-0.07770068198442459,
0.07047639787197113,
-0.06476572155952454,
-0.6959128975868225,
-0.23577164113521576,
-0.9313494563102722,
0.06802308559417725,
0.804935097694397,
-0.48060986399650574,
0.652965247631073,
-0.36730697751045227,
-0.45780640840530396,
-0.6856858730316162,
0.09731687605381012,
-0.052397795021533966,
0.5095298886299133,
0.5744059681892395,
-0.3863872289657593,
-0.5615480542182922,
-0.8212313055992126,
0.13788844645023346,
0.13507898151874542,
-0.15360672771930695,
0.2012719362974167,
0.2506169080734253,
-0.5803757905960083,
0.9518212080001831,
-0.36346179246902466,
-0.05833929404616356,
-0.3424796164035797,
0.21348921954631805,
0.019951047375798225,
0.2738155126571655,
0.12009292840957642,
-0.4310464859008789,
-0.22519029676914215,
-0.29305562376976013,
-0.9726676940917969,
-0.3790348768234253,
-0.050737544894218445,
-0.2322436422109604,
-0.212051659822464,
0.23050931096076965,
-0.6886603236198425,
0.28212806582450867,
0.3509901463985443,
-0.3625390827655792,
0.28065037727355957,
0.013041778467595577,
-0.15624494850635529,
-1.186906099319458,
0.044014640152454376,
0.15805332362651825,
-0.42722171545028687,
-0.8129739761352539,
-0.1729922890663147,
-0.12332647293806076,
0.1356588900089264,
-0.36373668909072876,
0.37075337767601013,
-0.19297382235527039,
-0.05771936476230621,
-0.28070396184921265,
0.3925663232803345,
-0.04710268974304199,
-0.007806942332535982,
-0.05226608365774155,
0.46034857630729675,
0.5289587378501892,
-0.32419800758361816,
0.41251340508461,
0.24593670666217804,
-0.19293786585330963,
0.49943897128105164,
-0.31866222620010376,
-0.04941379651427269,
-0.09937182068824768,
0.04223882779479027,
-0.9089410305023193,
-0.4819326400756836,
0.33323243260383606,
-0.12341978400945663,
0.37926948070526123,
0.2934597134590149,
-0.8596614599227905,
-0.3745758533477783,
-0.21072866022586823,
0.31534358859062195,
0.31720587611198425,
-0.11866208910942078,
0.08191081881523132,
0.7849889397621155,
-0.4892722964286804,
-0.1973704695701599,
-0.7514554858207703,
0.11763123422861099,
-0.45256805419921875,
-0.38711419701576233,
0.34101054072380066,
0.06230888143181801,
-0.47982287406921387,
-0.06535941362380981,
0.07782360911369324,
0.09742294996976852,
0.2718333899974823,
0.3592231273651123,
0.3957367241382599,
-0.24717363715171814,
0.5416446924209595,
0.08173170685768127,
0.09042797237634659,
0.2866321802139282,
0.21838802099227905,
0.4006575345993042,
0.13073711097240448,
-0.3725329339504242,
-0.43439367413520813,
0.8236677646636963,
0.24636602401733398,
0.16368414461612701,
0.7529903054237366,
0.3162810802459717,
-0.8338375687599182,
-0.051617562770843506,
-0.4582068920135498,
-0.27013254165649414,
-0.32866817712783813,
0.21526063978672028,
0.041979096829891205,
-1.1290478706359863,
0.5214895606040955,
-0.030308695510029793,
0.0766562670469284,
0.21859721839427948,
0.7170662879943848,
-0.2617572247982025,
1.2213952541351318,
0.684529721736908,
-0.08487759530544281,
0.2830263078212738,
-0.06394104659557343,
0.5415442585945129,
-1.092548131942749,
0.03071293607354164,
-0.11769407242536545,
-0.17369435727596283,
-0.6249239444732666,
-0.5320832133293152,
0.2643600404262543,
0.2027832418680191,
-0.3306986689567566,
-0.06944580376148224,
-0.5345282554626465,
-0.1674637645483017,
0.18674395978450775,
0.4953761100769043,
0.4717235565185547,
-0.2044656127691269,
0.26534420251846313,
-0.45520782470703125,
-0.5996685028076172,
-0.7667993903160095,
1.1564511060714722,
0.4215105175971985,
0.6889373660087585,
-0.08108869940042496,
0.7041261792182922,
0.45535317063331604,
0.9401858448982239,
-0.8702287673950195,
0.4802493155002594,
-0.02150806598365307,
-0.5617392063140869,
-0.30209288001060486,
-0.1308712512254715,
-0.665562629699707,
-0.010183790698647499,
-0.29424533247947693,
-1.0445817708969116,
0.26610302925109863,
0.05887388810515404,
-0.8497501611709595,
0.08306114375591278,
-0.204041987657547,
0.5759859085083008,
-0.30166515707969666,
-0.24277380108833313,
0.0783466175198555,
-0.751419186592102,
0.5770367980003357,
-0.4449692368507385,
0.4315768778324127,
-0.629854142665863,
-0.22981475293636322,
0.7846855521202087,
-0.2773750424385071,
0.9042282700538635,
0.16364410519599915,
-0.10863932222127914,
0.037346020340919495,
-0.11932335793972015,
0.11326614767313004,
0.29211190342903137,
-0.0056927260011434555,
0.08460389077663422,
0.3170761168003082,
-0.22006942331790924,
-0.623924970626831,
0.4300989806652069,
-0.560752272605896,
-0.7762275338172913,
-0.3577660620212555,
-0.8957042098045349,
-0.37336742877960205,
-0.030965493991971016,
-0.003904102835804224,
0.44721606373786926,
0.06503357738256454,
-0.2540648877620697,
0.5312991142272949,
-0.04199506714940071,
0.19373053312301636,
0.5104846358299255,
-0.3574894666671753,
-0.4435671269893646,
0.4336714446544647,
0.1701878309249878,
0.23741285502910614,
0.0868009701371193,
-0.0029296947177499533,
0.14181376993656158,
-0.3901996910572052,
-0.02909730188548565,
0.7061474919319153,
-0.7387253046035767,
-0.4062019884586334,
-0.6333013772964478,
-0.28862547874450684,
-0.6380998492240906,
-0.28824394941329956,
-0.18049165606498718,
-0.42649951577186584,
-0.3599936068058014,
-0.36514121294021606,
0.6669177412986755,
0.7905418872833252,
-0.23071931302547455,
0.37602075934410095,
-0.7203470468521118,
0.6099808216094971,
0.00495996093377471,
0.0814579650759697,
-0.0056485142558813095,
-0.3400081396102905,
-0.490294486284256,
0.046128351241350174,
-0.09533960372209549,
-1.3034530878067017,
0.6634100675582886,
0.005143557209521532,
0.3470180034637451,
0.4076455533504486,
0.10968728363513947,
0.881792426109314,
-0.57879239320755,
0.6806706786155701,
-0.030539734289050102,
-0.7279137969017029,
0.7252211570739746,
-0.36726364493370056,
0.14270897209644318,
0.5323177576065063,
0.832358717918396,
-0.7613717913627625,
-0.605559229850769,
-0.516410768032074,
-1.0468918085098267,
0.5950044393539429,
-0.19860012829303741,
-0.00911709014326334,
-0.44692039489746094,
0.8456031680107117,
-0.040144871920347214,
0.059739965945482254,
-0.5168251991271973,
-0.3230026960372925,
0.19561192393302917,
-0.5255292057991028,
-0.3061554431915283,
-0.4098108410835266,
-0.4866868853569031,
-0.4938042163848877,
0.5078919529914856,
-0.04909953474998474,
0.45559340715408325,
0.5367475152015686,
0.0711921975016594,
-0.17436937987804413,
0.06393026560544968,
0.4582749605178833,
0.5008841753005981,
-0.28047800064086914,
0.2975417971611023,
0.029517874121665955,
-0.2870124280452728,
0.06264469772577286,
0.20217011868953705,
-0.25898513197898865,
-0.04401237890124321,
0.4987547695636749,
0.5277828574180603,
0.2971516251564026,
-0.865625262260437,
0.3129301369190216,
0.19386310875415802,
0.21348045766353607,
-0.2331816703081131,
0.0033017434179782867,
0.5078156590461731,
0.589400053024292,
-0.03007703833281994,
-0.5331296324729919,
0.4876062870025635,
-0.49851956963539124,
0.3637253940105438,
0.3731873035430908,
-0.3283001780509949,
-0.36211246252059937,
0.35452982783317566,
-0.14083856344223022,
-0.7455196380615234,
0.6249841451644897,
-0.007118967827409506,
-0.05258993059396744,
0.4245281219482422,
0.9201826453208923,
0.5362170934677124,
0.10698489844799042,
0.10408680140972137,
0.16463516652584076,
0.06737298518419266,
-0.544066846370697,
0.5271391868591309,
-0.04587007313966751,
-0.702436089515686,
-0.41663143038749695,
-0.47029760479927063,
-0.5865412950515747,
0.03898123279213905,
-1.1209166049957275,
0.2835168242454529,
-0.43653610348701477,
-0.8840146660804749,
-0.021250788122415543,
-0.06399977952241898,
-0.553799033164978,
0.1711045354604721,
0.6807681918144226,
0.8087330460548401,
-0.9174911975860596,
0.7883097529411316,
0.7695941925048828,
-0.2772097587585449,
-0.6189072728157043,
-0.16804109513759613,
0.05423053354024887,
-0.5658688545227051,
0.3807238042354584,
0.09390197694301605,
0.16548191010951996,
-0.024665592238307,
-0.48652979731559753,
-0.9922885894775391,
1.025549054145813,
0.06773160398006439,
-0.48646995425224304,
-0.18461045622825623,
0.3278694748878479,
0.9269798398017883,
-0.7635980844497681,
-0.07881845533847809,
0.7160735726356506,
0.42861664295196533,
-0.24071143567562103,
-0.6943376660346985,
0.23453213274478912,
-0.2148912250995636,
0.017045876011252403,
0.05228735879063606,
-0.10619296878576279,
0.5852215886116028,
-0.38166528940200806,
-0.2695949971675873,
-0.04668533802032471,
0.49898821115493774,
0.55308598279953,
0.46930739283561707,
-0.0680684894323349,
0.5149207711219788,
0.9530724883079529,
0.039210245013237,
0.9712036848068237,
-0.3543865382671356,
0.26682764291763306,
1.2843385934829712,
-0.483015239238739,
1.0652647018432617,
0.37249577045440674,
-0.05232926458120346,
0.19301638007164001,
0.8761811852455139,
-0.15756693482398987,
0.45945870876312256,
0.3668133318424225,
-0.4590785801410675,
-0.3051240146160126,
-0.18808947503566742,
-0.11801531910896301,
-0.16393505036830902,
0.8780654668807983,
-0.38792139291763306,
0.03184106945991516,
0.19180749356746674,
0.28817716240882874,
0.02770354226231575,
-0.3442225158214569,
0.7789949774742126,
0.5887166857719421,
-0.3539808392524719,
0.18613435328006744,
0.005815942771732807,
0.511265754699707,
-0.2968469560146332,
0.2096516489982605,
-0.1514221578836441,
-0.009014509618282318,
-0.24184098839759827,
-0.6869680881500244,
0.7023230195045471,
-0.05723510682582855,
-0.26119065284729004,
-0.24249586462974548,
0.6236562132835388,
-0.38943761587142944,
-0.8401310443878174,
0.38097625970840454,
0.743105947971344,
0.1819823831319809,
0.13357295095920563,
-0.24161458015441895,
-0.1951882392168045,
-0.4667489230632782,
-0.21923847496509552,
0.3048901855945587,
0.5222876071929932,
-0.2780483365058899,
0.6824992299079895,
0.28917041420936584,
0.7143122553825378,
0.09601949155330658,
0.0963648110628128,
0.6408777832984924,
-0.988303542137146,
0.1442110538482666,
-0.923112690448761,
0.26749899983406067,
0.03883744776248932,
-0.26968052983283997,
0.667535126209259,
0.32434630393981934,
0.5784983038902283,
0.19790878891944885,
0.5898996591567993,
0.11601542681455612,
0.7959936261177063,
-0.107294462621212,
0.38033801317214966,
-0.532076895236969,
0.13692964613437653,
0.016615673899650574,
-0.30907487869262695,
-0.7893996238708496,
0.5830379724502563,
-0.38508376479148865,
-0.27060046792030334,
0.4997822046279907,
0.6239932179450989,
0.25175875425338745,
-0.004169897176325321,
0.21653765439987183,
0.21941670775413513,
0.3343161940574646,
0.5428881645202637,
0.6555519104003906,
-0.20524346828460693,
-0.6306828856468201,
-0.4838254749774933,
-0.10699930787086487,
-0.06384985893964767,
-0.6502282023429871,
-1.0213087797164917,
-0.32781532406806946,
-0.4338229298591614,
-0.11527605354785919,
0.1652548611164093,
1.13925039768219,
0.5376996397972107,
-0.6403635740280151,
-0.19019821286201477,
0.366010457277298,
0.14925014972686768,
-0.29426148533821106,
-0.1974606066942215,
0.16755366325378418,
-0.42792245745658875,
-0.19671325385570526,
0.17182527482509613,
0.5256838202476501,
0.0802004411816597,
-0.32863688468933105,
0.4359976351261139,
-0.23494701087474823,
0.20329762995243073,
0.7430636286735535,
0.11389287561178207,
-0.8316992521286011,
-0.20188505947589874,
-0.05256284773349762,
-0.4510212540626526,
0.18602128326892853,
0.7938781380653381,
-0.5841161608695984,
0.07670807838439941,
0.3531433939933777,
0.4699476659297943,
0.27015164494514465,
0.19106587767601013,
0.6993431448936462,
-0.24069611728191376,
-0.14239001274108887,
0.38038867712020874,
0.39678773283958435,
0.5583310723304749,
-0.5801915526390076,
0.42514821887016296,
0.2997615933418274,
-0.45163577795028687,
-0.8964577317237854,
-0.05783870816230774,
-1.2084611654281616,
-0.047936536371707916,
1.1679586172103882,
-0.2887866795063019,
0.05602254346013069,
-0.40342751145362854,
-0.09655292332172394,
0.40602514147758484,
-0.0896255373954773,
1.0350819826126099,
0.7413056492805481,
-0.561297595500946,
-0.1543811410665512,
-0.9128654599189758,
0.5205904841423035,
0.21102790534496307,
-1.0135643482208252,
0.04246581345796585,
0.33563026785850525,
0.20006133615970612,
-0.02777990698814392,
0.9246877431869507,
-0.16632325947284698,
0.12177058309316635,
-0.3415401875972748,
0.13284756243228912,
0.23984463512897491,
-0.07538247108459473,
-0.3289937973022461,
-0.00798118021339178,
0.0182042233645916,
0.46243566274642944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12680v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12680v1 | Measuring Psychological Depth in Language Models | 2024-06-18T14:51:54 | 2024-06-18T14:51:54 | Fabrice Harel-Canada, Hanyu Zhou, Sreya Mupalla, Zeynep Yildiz, Amit Sahai, Nanyun Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Evaluations of creative stories generated by large language models (LLMs)
often focus on objective properties of the text, such as its style, coherence,
and toxicity. While these metrics are indispensable, they do not speak to a
story's subjective, psychological impact from a reader's perspective. We
introduce the Psychological Depth Scale (PDS), a novel framework rooted in
literary theory that measures an LLM's ability to produce authentic and
narratively complex stories that provoke emotion, empathy, and engagement. We
empirically validate our framework by showing that humans can consistently
evaluate stories based on PDS (0.72 Krippendorff's alpha). We also explore
techniques for automating the PDS to easily scale future analyses. GPT-4o,
combined with a novel Mixture-of-Personas (MoP) prompting strategy, achieves an
average Spearman correlation of $0.51$ with human judgment while Llama-3-70B
scores as high as 0.68 for empathy. Finally, we compared the depth of stories
authored by both humans and LLMs. Surprisingly, GPT-4 stories either surpassed
or were statistically indistinguishable from highly-rated human-written stories
sourced from Reddit. By shifting the focus from text to reader, the
Psychological Depth Scale is a validated, automated, and systematic means of
measuring the capacity of LLMs to connect with humans through the stories they
tell. | [
-0.5659772753715515,
-0.5666449666023254,
0.9016596078872681,
0.7922428250312805,
-0.31485480070114136,
0.21762526035308838,
-0.27038508653640747,
-0.6326382160186768,
0.09088847786188126,
0.12725725769996643,
-0.42575567960739136,
-0.5526250600814819,
-0.6768556237220764,
0.29833048582077026,
-0.2942498028278351,
0.9404600262641907,
-0.09820396453142166,
-0.1921471655368805,
-0.27601417899131775,
0.004787820857018232,
-0.050374437123537064,
-0.39554712176322937,
-0.3614254593849182,
-0.3886238932609558,
0.7776214480400085,
0.11522382497787476,
0.825685977935791,
0.5331110954284668,
0.6852808594703674,
0.22619780898094177,
-0.03814505413174629,
-0.14534209668636322,
-0.6429958939552307,
0.11994628608226776,
-0.20240597426891327,
-0.49570584297180176,
-0.4636092185974121,
0.287922739982605,
0.4303482472896576,
0.9698320627212524,
-0.03812255710363388,
-0.07689020037651062,
0.15825869143009186,
0.7326640486717224,
-0.5010661482810974,
-0.17982466518878937,
-0.0182502418756485,
0.3302525579929352,
0.0009433261002413929,
-0.16601476073265076,
-0.32483431696891785,
-0.4528810977935791,
0.5220239758491516,
-0.24100227653980255,
0.2779690623283386,
-0.20047669112682343,
0.6623996496200562,
-0.04897481948137283,
-0.5948063135147095,
-0.37474969029426575,
-0.6341355443000793,
0.7851086258888245,
-0.6188350915908813,
0.1697317361831665,
0.46623194217681885,
-0.1425955891609192,
0.35348936915397644,
-0.3219856321811676,
-0.6570936441421509,
-0.44353732466697693,
-0.20829294621944427,
0.13470451533794403,
-0.25843822956085205,
-0.011458693072199821,
0.1371641755104065,
0.7657854557037354,
-0.6457948088645935,
-0.06643910706043243,
-0.12841828167438507,
0.15115228295326233,
1.011216640472412,
0.5245344638824463,
0.35987579822540283,
-0.15637461841106415,
-0.3170144557952881,
-0.20052587985992432,
-0.36193445324897766,
0.42641595005989075,
0.4723915159702301,
-0.16344738006591797,
-0.38363295793533325,
0.649714469909668,
-0.01182403415441513,
0.31832408905029297,
0.13096179068088531,
-0.4751023054122925,
0.263419508934021,
-0.27935245633125305,
0.03479484096169472,
-0.2168775051832199,
1.043553113937378,
0.8481186032295227,
0.5355242490768433,
-0.1978830248117447,
-0.14040732383728027,
0.40381962060928345,
0.3638540804386139,
-0.7887123227119446,
-0.20708461105823517,
0.21552002429962158,
-0.3879111409187317,
-0.40506336092948914,
-0.04382803663611412,
-0.7018389701843262,
-0.9371905326843262,
-0.11380963027477264,
0.14861945807933807,
-0.5690644979476929,
-0.46993288397789,
0.3917069137096405,
-0.2308260053396225,
0.3739810287952423,
0.24428512156009674,
-0.9030560851097107,
0.5106518864631653,
0.5876317620277405,
1.0847342014312744,
-0.3601190447807312,
-0.4940985143184662,
0.10614609718322754,
-0.05915457010269165,
-0.7487345337867737,
0.8448545336723328,
-0.3081916272640228,
-0.5245275497436523,
-0.13466030359268188,
-0.49884912371635437,
0.3421117663383484,
-0.3146435022354126,
0.6023142337799072,
-0.08497711271047592,
0.415552020072937,
-0.46655037999153137,
-0.4326508045196533,
0.01342539768666029,
0.3470418155193329,
-0.3095419406890869,
0.793877124786377,
0.28386732935905457,
-0.5791651606559753,
0.4996299743652344,
-0.48565801978111267,
-0.6335497498512268,
-0.06626442074775696,
-0.05392182618379593,
0.022814186289906502,
0.44406917691230774,
0.3104437291622162,
0.5132849216461182,
-0.4133089780807495,
0.3943995237350464,
-0.44802209734916687,
-0.3736944794654846,
0.4993390142917633,
-0.2934580147266388,
0.6749424338340759,
0.015154053457081318,
-0.1759466975927353,
0.13028042018413544,
-0.6931525468826294,
-0.06559247523546219,
0.11115694046020508,
-0.31743258237838745,
-0.3636953830718994,
-0.16677811741828918,
-0.1404396891593933,
0.09739856421947479,
0.2991974651813507,
-0.6111434698104858,
-0.04487914219498634,
-0.7163197994232178,
0.2719213664531708,
0.67885422706604,
0.14239926636219025,
0.6859789490699768,
-0.32201334834098816,
0.7346134781837463,
-0.21652506291866302,
0.06358541548252106,
-0.1824112981557846,
-0.2844630181789398,
-0.4105786383152008,
-0.6648865938186646,
-0.20761780440807343,
0.35000061988830566,
-0.0889509990811348,
0.8784748911857605,
-0.14159424602985382,
-0.9993554949760437,
-0.4913501739501953,
0.08201292157173157,
0.26553869247436523,
0.41226014494895935,
0.01624516397714615,
-0.7406939268112183,
-0.15477246046066284,
-0.7550672292709351,
-0.7530451416969299,
-0.3953440487384796,
-0.5450420379638672,
0.29484301805496216,
0.22680813074111938,
-0.09728022664785385,
1.0742709636688232,
-0.43473973870277405,
-0.19692666828632355,
-0.2757008969783783,
0.4625898599624634,
0.2311760038137436,
0.2530144453048706,
0.5678454041481018,
-0.2951679229736328,
-0.5787332057952881,
-0.19463969767093658,
-1.033058524131775,
-0.46631309390068054,
-0.08817043155431747,
0.08981002122163773,
-0.07100675255060196,
-0.03414582833647728,
-0.905062198638916,
0.357048362493515,
0.47892099618911743,
-0.6757259368896484,
0.55776047706604,
-0.17585325241088867,
0.14728403091430664,
-0.6587086915969849,
-0.034982915967702866,
0.3893943428993225,
0.16039979457855225,
-0.49338263273239136,
-0.07415080815553665,
0.0632273256778717,
0.05400784686207771,
-0.28262078762054443,
0.6708740592002869,
-0.4381939172744751,
-0.21208873391151428,
0.07542963325977325,
0.2832185626029968,
0.4908007085323334,
0.4141480624675751,
0.07148809731006622,
0.33613064885139465,
0.5069815516471863,
-0.430969774723053,
0.6811290383338928,
0.02362103760242462,
-0.4248301088809967,
1.0078850984573364,
-0.6623627543449402,
0.1896606832742691,
0.01653517410159111,
0.34148815274238586,
-1.1470561027526855,
-0.2057335376739502,
-0.02588391676545143,
-0.4774969220161438,
-0.046901531517505646,
0.31451651453971863,
-0.6873711347579956,
-0.2903194725513458,
-0.5546271800994873,
0.22645412385463715,
0.38854649662971497,
-0.33420950174331665,
0.698680579662323,
0.2597304582595825,
-0.5023189783096313,
-0.1745310127735138,
-0.6560453772544861,
0.506235659122467,
-0.5077204704284668,
-0.837709903717041,
0.27519097924232483,
-0.34363576769828796,
-0.6201912760734558,
-0.15858420729637146,
0.006203874945640564,
-0.08321643620729446,
-0.022504081949591637,
0.1706046164035797,
-0.07358439266681671,
-0.20553740859031677,
-0.09714198857545853,
0.20590859651565552,
0.03505638986825943,
0.6514168381690979,
0.448594868183136,
0.5750236511230469,
-0.5612934231758118,
-0.3898763656616211,
-0.56993567943573,
0.2598048150539398,
0.6382208466529846,
-0.27774015069007874,
0.6331032514572144,
0.6215941905975342,
-0.2684284448623657,
0.14389237761497498,
-0.5515332221984863,
-0.24260354042053223,
-0.4363972544670105,
0.36665087938308716,
-0.5928150415420532,
-0.6298264265060425,
0.6241517663002014,
0.15413449704647064,
-0.30175212025642395,
0.2236633598804474,
0.5717066526412964,
-0.26741623878479004,
1.1877573728561401,
0.6253170371055603,
-0.11235596239566803,
0.23516301810741425,
-0.09441252797842026,
0.5683107376098633,
-0.792970597743988,
-0.1828889697790146,
-0.18131989240646362,
-0.5933712720870972,
-0.1480216234922409,
0.06579896062612534,
0.3490404784679413,
0.2971000075340271,
-0.2649458050727844,
-0.13071289658546448,
-0.2706870138645172,
0.6877415180206299,
0.31982284784317017,
0.11640226095914841,
0.5228156447410583,
-0.09130564332008362,
0.09758198261260986,
-0.4319884479045868,
-0.17129631340503693,
-0.7320547103881836,
1.0180493593215942,
0.840104877948761,
0.920333743095398,
0.22672870755195618,
0.6457604765892029,
0.29237475991249084,
0.5323801636695862,
-0.9490746259689331,
0.6171329617500305,
0.4268970191478729,
-0.42888039350509644,
-0.6154842972755432,
-0.31265103816986084,
-0.8034543991088867,
0.3547227382659912,
0.10562444478273392,
-0.812612771987915,
0.35397064685821533,
-0.30160194635391235,
-0.4566996693611145,
0.004986740183085203,
-0.6691690683364868,
0.7074753642082214,
-0.4765424430370331,
-0.3772807717323303,
-0.20879444479942322,
-0.5952785611152649,
0.3790695071220398,
-0.055133990943431854,
-0.006527836434543133,
-0.27079910039901733,
-0.46296629309654236,
0.6495551466941833,
-0.12246806919574738,
0.9063997268676758,
0.0075132837519049644,
-0.6772581338882446,
0.1814388781785965,
0.7331631779670715,
0.1348496973514557,
0.20849965512752533,
-0.06809500604867935,
0.18970435857772827,
0.00949862040579319,
-0.41527050733566284,
-0.6937524676322937,
0.6132375001907349,
-0.8932090997695923,
-0.4575749337673187,
-0.6095218062400818,
-0.9097297191619873,
-0.5219666957855225,
0.11711014062166214,
0.1712310016155243,
0.04433538019657135,
-0.47148528695106506,
0.21251626312732697,
0.45186346769332886,
-0.36094921827316284,
0.2580278217792511,
0.6568213701248169,
-0.23173007369041443,
-0.4645951986312866,
0.689171552658081,
-0.2945946753025055,
0.24915075302124023,
0.27754780650138855,
0.5074822902679443,
-0.48892220854759216,
-0.39980366826057434,
-0.1519390046596527,
0.48000916838645935,
-0.6107859015464783,
-0.001289686537347734,
-0.6629894971847534,
0.0560794472694397,
-0.43788307905197144,
-0.47815844416618347,
-0.24088409543037415,
-0.025034179911017418,
-0.26822611689567566,
-0.6122375726699829,
0.3024401366710663,
0.8539291620254517,
-0.3378260135650635,
0.23232288658618927,
-0.5876252055168152,
0.1786211133003235,
0.19175906479358673,
0.5483010411262512,
0.03866219520568848,
-0.6703607439994812,
-0.08259597420692444,
-0.12851747870445251,
-0.52797532081604,
-0.9116986393928528,
0.6969350576400757,
-0.026408061385154724,
-0.03766031190752983,
0.8225234746932983,
0.04902445897459984,
0.6428294777870178,
-0.16141335666179657,
0.8809978365898132,
0.2960453927516937,
-1.2273204326629639,
0.38124170899391174,
-0.7012223601341248,
0.21515235304832458,
0.34752678871154785,
0.4516511857509613,
-0.7253170609474182,
-0.5863145589828491,
-0.5200504660606384,
-0.6882830262184143,
0.5354785323143005,
0.03852347284555435,
0.5409440994262695,
-0.07459826022386551,
0.28736719489097595,
0.12627822160720825,
0.25169074535369873,
-0.8559189438819885,
0.14112314581871033,
-0.0689675360918045,
-0.47981610894203186,
-0.4677215814590454,
-0.46072182059288025,
-0.18122099339962006,
-0.32914286851882935,
-0.03332509100437164,
0.10236917436122894,
0.08710633963346481,
0.26858922839164734,
-0.014293118380010128,
-0.5010313987731934,
0.0366852767765522,
0.4618571996688843,
0.8616324067115784,
-0.4400288462638855,
0.36798399686813354,
0.028449196368455887,
-0.33289358019828796,
0.21275928616523743,
-0.16493107378482819,
0.39458930492401123,
-0.39583706855773926,
0.7797740697860718,
0.37519288063049316,
0.05102166160941124,
-0.9614400267601013,
0.7379152178764343,
-0.11726293712854385,
-0.22370371222496033,
0.010944627225399017,
0.03891976550221443,
0.29844748973846436,
0.45489829778671265,
0.18417717516422272,
-0.10073112696409225,
0.06307787448167801,
-0.7376339435577393,
-0.0967482328414917,
0.1660895198583603,
-0.28808629512786865,
-0.4725312888622284,
0.0334724597632885,
0.38803479075431824,
-0.42489784955978394,
0.40240761637687683,
-0.13744273781776428,
-0.2178144007921219,
0.4444526135921478,
0.39756056666374207,
0.8587729930877686,
-0.2097437083721161,
0.3374839425086975,
0.05268317833542824,
0.41514232754707336,
-0.06637117266654968,
0.2527894675731659,
0.0717000961303711,
-0.8419976234436035,
-0.3141728341579437,
-0.7083196043968201,
-0.44931045174598694,
0.26742464303970337,
-0.7349035143852234,
-0.09820034354925156,
-0.5455514192581177,
0.008104492910206318,
-0.44963982701301575,
0.17050550878047943,
-0.5175015330314636,
0.3494717478752136,
0.1369684934616089,
0.775657057762146,
-0.9595215320587158,
0.36715197563171387,
0.44329819083213806,
-0.48865917325019836,
-0.32545557618141174,
0.11392901092767715,
-0.028168944641947746,
-0.6112065315246582,
0.4701877534389496,
0.09027309715747833,
-0.14444543421268463,
0.0084381103515625,
-0.2785208225250244,
-0.6913102865219116,
0.9547368288040161,
0.5030011534690857,
-0.27077677845954895,
-0.12314215302467346,
0.3572009801864624,
1.3282794952392578,
-0.4578832983970642,
0.16692863404750824,
0.6838133335113525,
0.33958321809768677,
-0.4028007388114929,
-0.7888013124465942,
0.04342484474182129,
-0.2895456552505493,
0.07029958069324493,
-0.16592365503311157,
-0.46295851469039917,
0.7129606604576111,
-0.382806658744812,
-0.26920589804649353,
0.26939743757247925,
0.5390973687171936,
0.4520615041255951,
0.38969719409942627,
0.4049737751483917,
0.6312386393547058,
0.7046462893486023,
0.15538400411605835,
1.3747389316558838,
-0.270805299282074,
0.19017381966114044,
0.8642275929450989,
-0.547057032585144,
0.6293383240699768,
0.44457778334617615,
-0.3776130676269531,
0.5802856683731079,
0.7729806900024414,
0.08536350727081299,
0.4963626265525818,
0.561191976070404,
-0.34965285658836365,
0.041216667741537094,
-0.09989374876022339,
-0.23448233306407928,
0.2274339199066162,
0.29484644532203674,
-0.550955057144165,
0.10687670111656189,
0.07546676695346832,
0.0003505120985209942,
0.4096280634403229,
-0.09143253415822983,
0.7422710061073303,
0.3928561806678772,
-0.5722895264625549,
0.3299180865287781,
0.036111630499362946,
0.5088806748390198,
-0.4244128167629242,
0.3910466432571411,
-0.5519765615463257,
0.28185799717903137,
-0.10032350569963455,
-1.3111308813095093,
0.13313837349414825,
0.3365930914878845,
-0.2478640079498291,
-0.4039209485054016,
0.5965824127197266,
-0.2658911645412445,
-0.4517475366592407,
0.5029907822608948,
0.7712720036506653,
0.1437356173992157,
-0.4454324543476105,
-0.44969889521598816,
0.2319760024547577,
-0.46186017990112305,
-0.5888246297836304,
0.4142054319381714,
1.050548791885376,
0.4005716145038605,
0.8108397126197815,
0.528103232383728,
0.17975693941116333,
-0.292718768119812,
0.2332225888967514,
0.5228443145751953,
-0.851198673248291,
-0.6201645135879517,
-1.0353761911392212,
0.4214535355567932,
0.013116348534822464,
-0.5752934813499451,
0.7743783593177795,
0.41557615995407104,
0.5868304371833801,
0.0044671534560620785,
0.7840779423713684,
0.19353751838207245,
0.394205778837204,
-0.1039467379450798,
0.759563684463501,
-0.3992941081523895,
0.38337182998657227,
-0.6139517426490784,
-1.0291690826416016,
-0.3263361155986786,
0.8704557418823242,
-0.5995301604270935,
0.11038046330213547,
0.814906120300293,
0.6394667625427246,
0.17668034136295319,
-0.03426765277981758,
0.3872956335544586,
0.3241179287433624,
0.31832754611968994,
0.47190171480178833,
1.2150523662567139,
0.060324542224407196,
0.31115493178367615,
-0.31807783246040344,
-0.5638933777809143,
0.08060335367918015,
-0.8462046384811401,
-1.141623854637146,
-0.40479645133018494,
-0.10410414636135101,
-0.31567496061325073,
-0.3669259250164032,
0.39198037981987,
0.3154112994670868,
-0.17403274774551392,
-0.5397816300392151,
-0.12632755935192108,
-0.14022134244441986,
-0.18979942798614502,
-0.3552137613296509,
0.14105990529060364,
-0.2315474897623062,
-0.46884945034980774,
0.13987477123737335,
0.5946426391601562,
-0.09593915939331055,
-0.75501549243927,
-0.357261598110199,
0.32398054003715515,
0.3216570019721985,
0.9131501913070679,
-0.23470598459243774,
-0.9483247995376587,
-0.2320755571126938,
-0.003480627667158842,
-0.3923107981681824,
0.04514950141310692,
0.7449759840965271,
-0.4973064959049225,
0.3341481387615204,
0.5208224058151245,
0.4151386022567749,
0.24916589260101318,
-0.12952643632888794,
0.8948662281036377,
-0.7158755660057068,
-0.28384310007095337,
0.48854324221611023,
0.24975264072418213,
0.4458582401275635,
-0.4666070342063904,
0.5287657380104065,
0.3466874957084656,
-0.33600547909736633,
-1.0514978170394897,
0.1992575079202652,
-0.9636814594268799,
-0.17837513983249664,
1.0471270084381104,
-0.16695792973041534,
0.07811291515827179,
0.1806279420852661,
-0.4209713339805603,
-0.19064348936080933,
-0.4120262563228607,
1.1809011697769165,
1.082271695137024,
-0.42941686511039734,
-0.47996360063552856,
-0.059924036264419556,
0.4053899049758911,
0.35758671164512634,
-0.8404136896133423,
0.15368252992630005,
0.3493860363960266,
0.20778147876262665,
0.2342856526374817,
0.7940189838409424,
-0.15632987022399902,
-0.004937228746712208,
-0.0040555689483881,
0.12569932639598846,
0.413080096244812,
-0.1618557721376419,
-0.2835720479488373,
0.27227503061294556,
-0.024321816861629486,
0.5452008247375488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12679v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12679v1 | Vernacular? I Barely Know Her: Challenges with Style Control and Stereotyping | 2024-06-18T14:51:30 | 2024-06-18T14:51:30 | Ankit Aich, Tingting Liu, Salvatore Giorgi, Kelsey Isman, Lyle Ungar, Brenda Curtis | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly being used in educational and
learning applications. Research has demonstrated that controlling for style, to
fit the needs of the learner, fosters increased understanding, promotes
inclusion, and helps with knowledge distillation. To understand the
capabilities and limitations of contemporary LLMs in style control, we
evaluated five state-of-the-art models: GPT-3.5, GPT-4, GPT-4o, Llama-3, and
Mistral-instruct- 7B across two style control tasks. We observed significant
inconsistencies in the first task, with model performances averaging between
5th and 8th grade reading levels for tasks intended for first-graders, and
standard deviations up to 27.6. For our second task, we observed a
statistically significant improvement in performance from 0.02 to 0.26.
However, we find that even without stereotypes in reference texts, LLMs often
generated culturally insensitive content during their tasks. We provide a
thorough analysis and discussion of the results. | [
-0.37343305349349976,
-0.8342722058296204,
0.3823469281196594,
0.3023671507835388,
-0.15609169006347656,
0.4299522340297699,
-0.22297170758247375,
-0.5619309544563293,
0.056476570665836334,
0.20973016321659088,
-0.25236088037490845,
-0.5239223837852478,
-1.1174707412719727,
0.42308714985847473,
-0.5675013065338135,
0.5597125291824341,
-0.08573643118143082,
0.111043781042099,
0.14160898327827454,
-0.0025199681986123323,
-0.658818781375885,
-0.5651728510856628,
-0.42340174317359924,
-0.0941939577460289,
0.23856937885284424,
0.6138722896575928,
0.7509530782699585,
0.37351781129837036,
0.41796743869781494,
0.32132744789123535,
-0.5719853639602661,
0.08575805276632309,
-0.6078876852989197,
-0.016520505771040916,
-0.15974925458431244,
-0.20937040448188782,
-0.48874232172966003,
0.14444172382354736,
0.5437287092208862,
0.9511963129043579,
-0.001626875950023532,
0.23080794513225555,
0.03037349507212639,
0.7716631293296814,
-0.3461475074291229,
0.169578418135643,
-0.6851215958595276,
-0.024127475917339325,
-0.3197384774684906,
0.24246826767921448,
-0.504852294921875,
-0.3425658345222473,
0.013428699225187302,
-0.44131314754486084,
0.03212124481797218,
0.17634616792201996,
0.9814080595970154,
-0.004308209288865328,
-0.8943170309066772,
-0.5643258690834045,
-0.8447261452674866,
0.6972368955612183,
-0.5561350584030151,
0.4602498710155487,
0.5568785071372986,
0.24968068301677704,
0.09382567554712296,
-0.584363579750061,
-0.4359208047389984,
-0.2623291313648224,
-0.146260067820549,
-0.05388582870364189,
-0.4112420678138733,
-0.10692674666643143,
0.1744760125875473,
0.1634196937084198,
-0.3125405013561249,
0.20242050290107727,
-0.8650140166282654,
-0.20382222533226013,
0.41357967257499695,
0.30067726969718933,
0.17182159423828125,
-0.1364181637763977,
-0.3789774179458618,
0.26357752084732056,
-0.7641395330429077,
0.05847069248557091,
0.18285438418388367,
0.3445625305175781,
-0.2889001965522766,
0.5476275682449341,
-0.22162014245986938,
0.7114694118499756,
0.12472250312566757,
-0.5914380550384521,
-0.08589155972003937,
-0.22711960971355438,
-0.1184990406036377,
-0.3040463626384735,
0.3129650950431824,
0.44398972392082214,
0.8090218901634216,
-0.10954321175813675,
-0.18120983242988586,
-0.31630486249923706,
0.10955195873975754,
-0.5864198803901672,
-0.1428397297859192,
-0.23810338973999023,
-0.3053441643714905,
-0.29418009519577026,
-0.26799720525741577,
-0.43477848172187805,
-0.3893921971321106,
-0.5314590930938721,
0.4809376895427704,
-0.4787294864654541,
-0.11450795829296112,
-0.08219065517187119,
-0.14002549648284912,
0.23176489770412445,
0.6582525968551636,
-1.1835395097732544,
0.47373509407043457,
0.2553044557571411,
1.2880799770355225,
-0.252079039812088,
0.045136842876672745,
0.1573408842086792,
0.014445018023252487,
-0.7530055642127991,
0.25616908073425293,
-0.5096961259841919,
-0.7000807523727417,
0.013103662058711052,
-0.11975099891424179,
-0.0960121601819992,
-0.5872591733932495,
0.020909320563077927,
-0.48821744322776794,
-0.09727973490953445,
-0.31661325693130493,
-0.3701970875263214,
0.1864093393087387,
0.07933288812637329,
-0.5764870643615723,
0.8621669411659241,
0.34788671135902405,
-0.6098101139068604,
0.3848797678947449,
0.062395013868808746,
-0.3985259234905243,
-0.039891041815280914,
0.021070344373583794,
0.18318159878253937,
0.1096908375620842,
-0.0616951510310173,
0.47653934359550476,
0.07505302876234055,
0.28987568616867065,
-0.24027873575687408,
-0.6331636309623718,
0.057828858494758606,
-0.49904441833496094,
0.6880844235420227,
0.29572588205337524,
-0.2682132422924042,
-0.0229251217097044,
-0.6659775972366333,
-0.3666784465312958,
0.2609246075153351,
-0.4480562210083008,
-0.6308848261833191,
-0.5094202160835266,
0.1980414092540741,
0.2757417857646942,
0.24415695667266846,
-0.2199103683233261,
0.3635990023612976,
0.07956131547689438,
0.40669122338294983,
1.0287749767303467,
-0.3038495182991028,
0.6227301955223083,
-0.5517358183860779,
0.6865528225898743,
-0.33224812150001526,
-0.05486958473920822,
-0.030825914815068245,
-0.2264222800731659,
-0.5544062852859497,
-0.20334716141223907,
0.19877293705940247,
0.464538037776947,
-0.7315447330474854,
0.048447076231241226,
-0.1151261106133461,
-0.6190788745880127,
-0.2786954939365387,
0.48680534958839417,
0.3945620656013489,
0.41536787152290344,
0.4446990489959717,
-0.06627671420574188,
-0.28195706009864807,
-0.8759311437606812,
-0.3759705126285553,
-0.029737012460827827,
-0.11634253710508347,
0.07536368072032928,
0.48555171489715576,
0.16421735286712646,
0.8971185088157654,
-0.39538130164146423,
-0.26910778880119324,
-0.4819478690624237,
0.06340103596448898,
-0.07556583732366562,
0.44167688488960266,
0.6358430981636047,
-0.5919996500015259,
-0.5538326501846313,
-0.3649051785469055,
-0.39777329564094543,
-0.21424145996570587,
0.17806217074394226,
-0.015779748558998108,
0.20213918387889862,
0.9054973125457764,
-0.08344370871782303,
0.26013174653053284,
0.6224623322486877,
-0.2903023064136505,
0.7679921388626099,
-0.1192907840013504,
-0.1312524825334549,
-0.9641206860542297,
-0.42048129439353943,
0.3807312846183777,
-0.1803896576166153,
-0.7910977005958557,
0.006530613638460636,
0.14051717519760132,
0.172119140625,
-0.4751400351524353,
0.8293160796165466,
-0.5732925534248352,
0.24422164261341095,
-0.018730442970991135,
-0.08622810244560242,
0.06917820870876312,
0.2644560635089874,
0.4090135097503662,
0.7576648592948914,
0.171199232339859,
-0.5648739337921143,
-0.042180366814136505,
0.1267935037612915,
-0.42572346329689026,
0.5282006859779358,
-0.7108877897262573,
0.2756499648094177,
-0.15990224480628967,
0.1526028960943222,
-1.2404731512069702,
-0.5175424814224243,
0.024995004758238792,
-0.022996578365564346,
0.6538848280906677,
-0.30272942781448364,
-0.4124601185321808,
-0.10537226498126984,
-0.007988116703927517,
0.19844309985637665,
0.5070396065711975,
-0.49001795053482056,
0.4932229518890381,
0.22256571054458618,
-0.5766481161117554,
-0.3652688264846802,
-0.7103275060653687,
0.07602456212043762,
-0.3058635890483856,
-0.451912522315979,
-0.12334409356117249,
-0.29418933391571045,
-0.9379818439483643,
-0.667793869972229,
-0.29689469933509827,
-0.32959312200546265,
0.11412607878446579,
0.07606969028711319,
0.27873677015304565,
-0.07971176505088806,
0.133302241563797,
0.38362371921539307,
0.33739498257637024,
-0.15082930028438568,
0.23662059009075165,
0.5778737664222717,
-0.27398794889450073,
-0.2659536600112915,
-0.1783156543970108,
0.1363508403301239,
0.7195830345153809,
0.06085168570280075,
0.5535593628883362,
0.3165019750595093,
-0.07161884009838104,
-0.23982222378253937,
-0.567082941532135,
-0.1590377539396286,
-0.538346529006958,
0.4151235818862915,
-0.6226198673248291,
-1.1137032508850098,
0.3187938630580902,
-0.11438549309968948,
-0.03056498058140278,
-0.06692472100257874,
0.4451599419116974,
-0.2163233906030655,
0.6676819324493408,
0.7778015732765198,
0.02695312723517418,
0.4990898072719574,
0.10974200069904327,
-0.050093356519937515,
-0.5077956318855286,
-0.31471213698387146,
-0.4631483554840088,
-0.3996489942073822,
-0.6681607365608215,
-0.5305600166320801,
0.6557965278625488,
0.11975760012865067,
-0.482009619474411,
-0.0317472442984581,
-0.12249081581830978,
0.46698886156082153,
0.6140589118003845,
0.06888824701309204,
0.7218208909034729,
-0.12979264557361603,
0.10097178816795349,
-0.18370658159255981,
-0.6733896136283875,
-0.7923882007598877,
1.108355164527893,
0.6314608454704285,
1.144371509552002,
0.5874523520469666,
0.6126014590263367,
0.21488602459430695,
0.2927248477935791,
-0.8390763401985168,
0.453192800283432,
-0.28091081976890564,
-0.7664554119110107,
-0.4410834014415741,
-0.03725634515285492,
-0.4651884436607361,
0.36436495184898376,
-0.019514592364430428,
-0.8009976148605347,
0.2067594975233078,
0.3728639483451843,
-0.060313258320093155,
0.2890373170375824,
-0.8752668499946594,
0.6173161268234253,
0.06978537887334824,
-0.26441916823387146,
0.44212284684181213,
-0.6908902525901794,
0.8208467960357666,
-0.17323777079582214,
0.6901296973228455,
-0.2347719371318817,
-0.1381874531507492,
0.3882404863834381,
-0.24853144586086273,
1.3022834062576294,
0.36942383646965027,
-0.209659144282341,
0.14546801149845123,
0.7408608198165894,
0.5147306323051453,
-0.18184584379196167,
0.18781857192516327,
0.3526347577571869,
0.13117659091949463,
-0.6196251511573792,
-0.2289402335882187,
0.46107766032218933,
-0.6360812187194824,
-0.7370110750198364,
-0.40343138575553894,
-0.7170264720916748,
-0.4017656147480011,
0.16084809601306915,
0.45401039719581604,
0.4903630018234253,
-0.4015143811702728,
0.07149039208889008,
0.6435847878456116,
0.06271900236606598,
0.610907793045044,
0.6434099674224854,
-0.22405456006526947,
0.19955475628376007,
0.7073985934257507,
0.49844038486480713,
1.020493507385254,
0.012490876950323582,
0.2507595717906952,
-0.16483230888843536,
-0.5836081504821777,
-0.5337125062942505,
0.13615204393863678,
-0.8409278392791748,
0.3214396834373474,
-0.440394788980484,
-0.03895752131938934,
-0.7370508909225464,
-0.3968675136566162,
-0.21010786294937134,
-0.3707370162010193,
-0.22726647555828094,
-0.09785502403974533,
0.17460796236991882,
1.38437020778656,
0.1809631586074829,
0.3988790214061737,
-0.4251323938369751,
0.001985949696972966,
0.2482772171497345,
0.15303228795528412,
-0.14334872364997864,
-1.0288382768630981,
-0.1025550588965416,
-0.5206296443939209,
0.051916949450969696,
-1.1333444118499756,
0.47793811559677124,
0.012437867000699043,
0.058021362870931625,
0.5136365294456482,
0.012716280296444893,
0.3381107449531555,
-0.4890791177749634,
0.8097508549690247,
-0.21365655958652496,
-1.071696162223816,
0.19406571984291077,
-0.46822798252105713,
0.5910423994064331,
0.3546186685562134,
0.7124937176704407,
-0.61637943983078,
-0.8306615352630615,
-0.5311169624328613,
-0.7862954139709473,
0.5532911419868469,
-0.08611293137073517,
0.5604671835899353,
-0.08042038977146149,
0.06102100759744644,
0.04104066640138626,
0.41565901041030884,
-0.7482603192329407,
-0.36430415511131287,
-0.2965080738067627,
0.0765472874045372,
-0.13335591554641724,
-0.5159761309623718,
-0.13516095280647278,
-0.3823496401309967,
0.4261331558227539,
-0.23213641345500946,
-0.38865530490875244,
-0.08335381001234055,
-0.17984436452388763,
0.11189362406730652,
0.6316600441932678,
0.7294890880584717,
0.7519005537033081,
-0.2330632507801056,
0.35331737995147705,
0.3133854269981384,
-0.6824203133583069,
0.09890466183423996,
-0.21439795196056366,
-0.3017756938934326,
0.21023708581924438,
0.7308973073959351,
0.45217469334602356,
0.3407146632671356,
-0.41975685954093933,
0.26055803894996643,
0.08294831961393356,
-0.1287430375814438,
-0.28329065442085266,
0.07268877327442169,
0.14298853278160095,
0.05012983828783035,
0.13583438098430634,
0.09214243292808533,
-0.11589009314775467,
-0.60964035987854,
-0.33668097853660583,
0.5153358578681946,
-0.36113429069519043,
-0.1703552007675171,
0.5082910656929016,
0.20519618690013885,
0.11685540527105331,
0.21487383544445038,
-0.16454964876174927,
-0.27420005202293396,
0.7055596709251404,
0.7672392725944519,
0.3337418735027313,
-0.2906637191772461,
0.24477899074554443,
0.2613666355609894,
0.7782964110374451,
-0.07260647416114807,
-0.05340273305773735,
-0.11688206344842911,
-1.0463086366653442,
0.07212689518928528,
-0.7888895273208618,
-0.5258129239082336,
0.2144317775964737,
-0.5995419025421143,
0.18073299527168274,
-0.7400935888290405,
0.0898275375366211,
-0.05121346563100815,
-0.21796360611915588,
-0.7426903247833252,
0.1679159700870514,
-0.003070126287639141,
1.3225281238555908,
-1.3789138793945312,
0.7726356387138367,
0.7098313570022583,
-0.46501654386520386,
-1.1895815134048462,
0.15303248167037964,
0.6663035154342651,
-0.6631042957305908,
0.9702655673027039,
-0.3834702670574188,
-0.20694799721240997,
0.08372387290000916,
-0.4403771758079529,
-1.0073683261871338,
0.9856094717979431,
0.04030200093984604,
-0.913083553314209,
-0.42186346650123596,
-0.17280860245227814,
0.42692163586616516,
-0.1977648288011551,
0.31985244154930115,
1.0743626356124878,
0.6849147081375122,
0.49910297989845276,
-1.3369040489196777,
-0.23690181970596313,
-0.020884685218334198,
0.12734974920749664,
-0.2616484761238098,
-0.9217051863670349,
0.9938173890113831,
-0.3067070543766022,
0.04029039666056633,
0.2231677621603012,
0.6513631939888,
0.10553168505430222,
0.43322527408599854,
0.29400959610939026,
0.06404144316911697,
0.7942621111869812,
-0.22661462426185608,
1.0575412511825562,
-0.15551093220710754,
-0.02727585658431053,
1.2407994270324707,
-0.022312836721539497,
0.6664578914642334,
0.4028712511062622,
-0.2582344710826874,
0.21411462128162384,
0.7047393918037415,
0.3479284346103668,
0.08649768680334091,
0.05391274765133858,
-0.46603265404701233,
-0.1863757222890854,
-0.15441493690013885,
-0.3862539827823639,
0.5905055999755859,
0.18071062862873077,
-0.4898063540458679,
-0.08101767301559448,
-0.003826708300039172,
0.6156648397445679,
0.3695431351661682,
-0.4710475206375122,
0.6611876487731934,
0.21077893674373627,
-0.19881387054920197,
0.6685771346092224,
0.056271061301231384,
0.8845670223236084,
-0.6732298731803894,
0.11865011602640152,
-0.49655383825302124,
-0.0696454644203186,
-0.0431574210524559,
-0.618545651435852,
0.10931049287319183,
0.14644289016723633,
-0.2370656430721283,
-0.27933183312416077,
0.7267920970916748,
-0.6213786005973816,
-0.6172795295715332,
-0.09808464348316193,
0.7188557982444763,
0.13521704077720642,
0.09540686011314392,
-0.10829368233680725,
0.28873211145401,
-0.15728630125522614,
-0.19343233108520508,
0.5428353548049927,
0.4406907856464386,
-0.5911752581596375,
0.7596729397773743,
0.2155912220478058,
0.21415238082408905,
0.25621530413627625,
0.12704592943191528,
0.7702541351318359,
-0.44479116797447205,
-0.1463077962398529,
-0.6509856581687927,
0.11621181666851044,
0.23723104596138,
-0.6732150912284851,
0.9069782495498657,
0.3092964291572571,
1.0150561332702637,
-0.3826255202293396,
0.8199372887611389,
0.08254386484622955,
0.3873741030693054,
-0.6748642921447754,
0.6393448114395142,
-0.4711589813232422,
0.25175899267196655,
-0.46859294176101685,
-0.6582580804824829,
-0.13968080282211304,
0.34700044989585876,
-0.4380938708782196,
0.45849037170410156,
0.539779543876648,
0.7570985555648804,
0.057474285364151,
-0.03925405815243721,
0.7277660965919495,
0.5367116332054138,
0.15729683637619019,
0.11401969939470291,
0.8494744300842285,
0.394760400056839,
0.26076915860176086,
-0.467603862285614,
-0.3188619315624237,
-0.14757272601127625,
-0.8050463199615479,
-1.0423001050949097,
-0.6247633099555969,
-0.007269492372870445,
-0.39752328395843506,
0.2470116764307022,
1.2302420139312744,
0.8366925716400146,
-0.5030788779258728,
-0.34858450293540955,
0.30459314584732056,
0.23136280477046967,
0.10392972826957703,
-0.21775753796100616,
0.03103536367416382,
-0.33081838488578796,
-1.2242008447647095,
0.530526340007782,
0.09075956046581268,
0.452488511800766,
-0.27719995379447937,
-0.05374951660633087,
-0.06042329967021942,
0.2924290597438812,
0.7499732375144958,
0.2152884304523468,
-0.8947975635528564,
-0.2283855378627777,
-0.036508675664663315,
-0.3508497476577759,
-0.2777266204357147,
0.774534285068512,
-0.3071040213108063,
0.5479469299316406,
0.08300068974494934,
-0.03748694807291031,
0.23432692885398865,
0.33086827397346497,
0.3638395071029663,
-0.9601460695266724,
0.16215971112251282,
0.19031010568141937,
0.3402731716632843,
0.3802652359008789,
-0.23647408187389374,
0.28340083360671997,
0.34001585841178894,
-0.29693150520324707,
-0.5293082594871521,
0.35323435068130493,
-0.7931889891624451,
-0.514829695224762,
1.310521125793457,
0.07685662060976028,
-0.09188630431890488,
-0.3404589295387268,
-0.34957587718963623,
-0.03309450298547745,
-0.3614828288555145,
0.6519624590873718,
1.0268105268478394,
-0.08571240305900574,
-0.1360555738210678,
-0.8091450333595276,
0.6832966804504395,
0.30026498436927795,
-0.34722015261650085,
-0.014768199995160103,
0.6847207546234131,
0.8077587485313416,
-0.13678504526615143,
0.8964914679527283,
-0.044159360229969025,
0.046276576817035675,
-0.06679755449295044,
0.026656795293092728,
-0.27475428581237793,
-0.6387698650360107,
-0.44318610429763794,
0.2656335234642029,
0.453537255525589,
0.20158901810646057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12673v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12673v1 | Estimating Knowledge in Large Language Models Without Generating a Single Token | 2024-06-18T14:45:50 | 2024-06-18T14:45:50 | Daniela Gottesman, Mor Geva | cs.CL | cs.CL | To evaluate knowledge in large language models (LLMs), current methods query
the model and then evaluate its generated responses. In this work, we ask
whether evaluation can be done $\textit{before}$ the model has generated any
text. Concretely, is it possible to estimate how knowledgeable a model is about
a certain entity, only from its internal computation? We study this question
with two tasks: given a subject entity, the goal is to predict (a) the ability
of the model to answer common questions about the entity, and (b) the
factuality of responses generated by the model about the entity. Experiments
with a variety of LLMs show that KEEN, a simple probe trained over internal
subject representations, succeeds at both tasks - strongly correlating with
both the QA accuracy of the model per-subject and FActScore, a recent
factuality metric in open-ended generation. Moreover, KEEN naturally aligns
with the model's hedging behavior and faithfully reflects changes in the
model's knowledge after fine-tuning. Lastly, we show a more interpretable yet
equally performant variant of KEEN, which highlights a small set of tokens that
correlates with the model's lack of knowledge. Being simple and lightweight,
KEEN can be leveraged to identify gaps and clusters of entity knowledge in
LLMs, and guide decisions such as augmenting queries with retrieval. | [
-0.30087944865226746,
-0.7028090357780457,
0.962946891784668,
0.0029751737602055073,
-0.24110694229602814,
-0.029432283714413643,
-0.6074748039245605,
-0.5243497490882874,
0.39595815539360046,
0.4432681202888489,
-0.45380493998527527,
-0.5309284329414368,
-0.4616383910179138,
-0.26365938782691956,
-0.4549657702445984,
0.8098555207252502,
0.34654703736305237,
0.002581103704869747,
-0.469725102186203,
-0.04780671373009682,
-0.42637899518013,
-0.49546459317207336,
-0.4455033242702484,
-0.20679369568824768,
0.2997109591960907,
0.40027663111686707,
0.21584513783454895,
0.21780255436897278,
0.4610419273376465,
0.2949073910713196,
-0.2706668972969055,
0.170748770236969,
-0.682766318321228,
0.22754521667957306,
-0.4111644923686981,
-0.8201728463172913,
-0.21447749435901642,
-0.05787619203329086,
0.9044599533081055,
0.793520987033844,
0.10212986916303635,
0.37764522433280945,
0.09956851601600647,
0.41884374618530273,
-0.7842176556587219,
0.2221112847328186,
-1.1703625917434692,
-0.16448988020420074,
-0.38993775844573975,
-0.06620875000953674,
-0.5296955108642578,
-0.08693675696849823,
0.3826102614402771,
-0.3821192979812622,
0.20999789237976074,
0.024782251566648483,
0.7674281001091003,
0.21240362524986267,
-0.4782227575778961,
-0.06960491091012955,
-0.608286440372467,
0.7914239764213562,
-0.7158975005149841,
0.5376307964324951,
0.4331032335758209,
0.12457484006881714,
-0.08751116693019867,
-0.643368661403656,
-0.48368632793426514,
-0.5216492414474487,
-0.0752316564321518,
0.06823821365833282,
0.047432173043489456,
-0.011953074485063553,
0.3018600046634674,
0.584350049495697,
-0.009350976906716824,
0.03683396428823471,
-0.12901736795902252,
-0.2963055372238159,
0.5211015939712524,
0.15708628296852112,
0.018799034878611565,
-0.3235473036766052,
-0.5285579562187195,
0.2034461498260498,
-0.7371599078178406,
0.14130955934524536,
0.1518268883228302,
0.20372721552848816,
0.09416764229536057,
0.8185229897499084,
-0.09528622031211853,
0.4785088002681732,
0.27614903450012207,
-0.06574411690235138,
-0.03923790156841278,
-0.43370920419692993,
-0.25973081588745117,
-0.09705528616905212,
0.7554954290390015,
0.1401604264974594,
0.07318906486034393,
-0.4142255187034607,
-0.5926898121833801,
0.10337229818105698,
0.29009687900543213,
-0.6190534234046936,
-0.1122426763176918,
0.10372675210237503,
-0.17933043837547302,
0.03469689562916756,
0.12926916778087616,
-0.5588904023170471,
-0.528122067451477,
-0.23054583370685577,
0.38571926951408386,
-0.34919285774230957,
-0.3423042595386505,
-0.09052012115716934,
-0.049375955015420914,
0.22617195546627045,
0.1151830404996872,
-0.5927868485450745,
0.3938941955566406,
0.9109956622123718,
0.7093881368637085,
-0.18233145773410797,
-0.33834102749824524,
-0.7235696315765381,
0.08166977018117905,
-0.3952925503253937,
0.8367141485214233,
-0.30434635281562805,
-0.40109920501708984,
-0.17141322791576385,
-0.155861034989357,
-0.06589414179325104,
-0.38523995876312256,
0.4402669370174408,
-0.8560484647750854,
0.004467017482966185,
-0.5142580270767212,
-0.936431884765625,
-0.1999262422323227,
0.440940260887146,
-0.6335451006889343,
0.9797595143318176,
-0.1423746645450592,
-1.0328526496887207,
0.8059476613998413,
-0.5313153862953186,
-0.27408158779144287,
0.10843601077795029,
-0.19400154054164886,
-0.1561150997877121,
0.4238584339618683,
0.24594609439373016,
0.618265688419342,
-0.5298938155174255,
0.4395373463630676,
-0.4736986756324768,
-0.3395076096057892,
0.4900689125061035,
-0.29888924956321716,
0.5465139150619507,
-0.22525571286678314,
-0.4307921826839447,
0.21406127512454987,
-0.6038888096809387,
0.02142043597996235,
0.039988014847040176,
-0.38229963183403015,
-0.4980314075946808,
0.03368550166487694,
-0.3452989161014557,
-0.2702747881412506,
0.39575886726379395,
-0.5536088347434998,
0.13162995874881744,
-0.7388579845428467,
0.11049208045005798,
0.804843544960022,
0.34226882457733154,
0.4484383165836334,
-0.08585555851459503,
0.34628742933273315,
0.014879384078085423,
-0.0018774605123326182,
-0.14909474551677704,
-0.5307225584983826,
-0.9334014058113098,
-0.28215062618255615,
0.4806986451148987,
0.2715357840061188,
-0.5362293124198914,
0.16475863754749298,
-0.32639211416244507,
-0.5857475996017456,
-0.4339526295661926,
0.10115711390972137,
0.4865419566631317,
0.4568541347980499,
0.08527597039937973,
-0.299996942281723,
-0.4354470372200012,
-0.8372973203659058,
-0.5045539140701294,
-0.3796088695526123,
0.08715241402387619,
0.4516482949256897,
0.3118990361690521,
0.017435329034924507,
0.9285660982131958,
-0.6266053915023804,
0.07502909004688263,
-0.023558378219604492,
0.2364538013935089,
0.3394746780395508,
0.38123899698257446,
0.41726693511009216,
-0.6290503144264221,
-0.27797871828079224,
0.07865043729543686,
-0.7388727068901062,
0.2251179814338684,
0.0810823068022728,
-0.34786680340766907,
0.1376415491104126,
0.355684757232666,
-0.931094765663147,
0.20822912454605103,
0.18829220533370972,
-0.40050122141838074,
0.6114850044250488,
0.01440586056560278,
0.11913745850324631,
-0.8633150458335876,
0.32251566648483276,
-0.034614190459251404,
-0.3150654137134552,
-0.4881337583065033,
0.3217087388038635,
0.21199719607830048,
0.0737568810582161,
-0.27737128734588623,
0.9516263604164124,
-0.716040313243866,
-0.2735094726085663,
-0.10919736325740814,
0.3389880657196045,
-0.05389093980193138,
0.4134438931941986,
-0.006283437367528677,
0.9182685613632202,
0.6917257905006409,
-0.816555917263031,
0.048618897795677185,
0.05894006788730621,
-0.8917731642723083,
0.4374510645866394,
-0.5461399555206299,
0.3942966163158417,
-0.1950867921113968,
-0.4089910387992859,
-0.7790528535842896,
-0.23860234022140503,
0.06430081278085709,
-0.5247495770454407,
0.33274364471435547,
-0.4169786274433136,
-0.252636194229126,
-0.43637633323669434,
-0.09315885603427887,
0.22316019237041473,
0.31678491830825806,
-0.38098594546318054,
0.5936903357505798,
0.5491071939468384,
-0.13921651244163513,
-0.7217118740081787,
-0.5274856090545654,
-0.03133406117558479,
-0.16301698982715607,
-0.6141306161880493,
-0.017483266070485115,
-0.021158866584300995,
-0.49235478043556213,
0.18658220767974854,
-0.15482169389724731,
-0.19162581861019135,
0.32283079624176025,
0.2207346111536026,
0.4213654696941376,
-0.5053746104240417,
0.5031788349151611,
-0.10342754423618317,
0.057612914592027664,
0.2955838143825531,
-0.49693989753723145,
0.4310425817966461,
-0.1642376333475113,
-0.6539625525474548,
-0.13004057109355927,
-0.02048979327082634,
0.6526818871498108,
-0.44797953963279724,
0.6678822636604309,
0.2760419249534607,
-0.48419612646102905,
-0.20959429442882538,
-0.8839348554611206,
-0.35026589035987854,
-0.3870900571346283,
0.2648634910583496,
-0.5299351811408997,
-0.703501284122467,
0.6819357872009277,
0.16164477169513702,
0.030677668750286102,
0.6690649390220642,
0.617991030216217,
0.31446707248687744,
0.788288950920105,
0.8464165329933167,
-0.07270970195531845,
0.32192686200141907,
-0.27117788791656494,
0.0459449328482151,
-0.7311347723007202,
-0.424490362405777,
-0.4439081847667694,
-0.05291524901986122,
-0.31954219937324524,
-0.45632630586624146,
0.5440769195556641,
0.21064743399620056,
-0.08508943021297455,
0.025016045197844505,
-0.13744930922985077,
0.4526539146900177,
0.8078393936157227,
0.2314971387386322,
0.3705674707889557,
-0.24304109811782837,
-0.28081339597702026,
0.10022291541099548,
-0.6209900379180908,
-0.4597792625427246,
1.2912929058074951,
0.24885988235473633,
0.5045357346534729,
-0.03125283867120743,
0.5931210517883301,
0.07672908157110214,
0.7356472611427307,
-1.1144518852233887,
0.4796772301197052,
0.13053961098194122,
-0.8709560036659241,
-0.34887731075286865,
-0.6090143918991089,
-0.5724790096282959,
0.2566536068916321,
-0.314398854970932,
-0.8193645477294922,
0.15564730763435364,
0.2369331568479538,
-0.44358834624290466,
0.3292705714702606,
-0.8370134234428406,
0.7716764211654663,
-0.2806553840637207,
-0.4762366712093353,
-0.25618499517440796,
-0.3517904579639435,
0.6949765086174011,
-0.23432649672031403,
-0.06966590881347656,
-0.2216767817735672,
-0.021810146048665047,
0.9120951294898987,
-0.3927227258682251,
0.7900485992431641,
-0.3506690561771393,
-0.08648541569709778,
0.5404903292655945,
0.17208737134933472,
0.5727048516273499,
0.3541407883167267,
-0.41115376353263855,
-0.01868133805692196,
0.08341342955827713,
-0.3466469645500183,
-0.7023921012878418,
0.6559242010116577,
-0.5014151334762573,
-0.9570255279541016,
-0.06528487056493759,
-0.2965472638607025,
-0.5439751148223877,
0.4687211215496063,
0.13941769301891327,
0.42431268095970154,
-0.3921152949333191,
-0.054392408579587936,
0.5752081871032715,
0.05531196668744087,
0.20200231671333313,
0.5847200155258179,
-0.3344433009624481,
-0.31444305181503296,
0.6365234851837158,
0.014405889436602592,
0.12906397879123688,
0.4111033082008362,
0.32700788974761963,
-0.5107173919677734,
-0.48422595858573914,
-0.5140023827552795,
0.4349111020565033,
-0.7935339212417603,
-0.266914039850235,
-0.6463358998298645,
0.14338384568691254,
-0.24231112003326416,
0.206284761428833,
-0.4741324782371521,
-0.10568417608737946,
-0.2810490131378174,
-0.17565999925136566,
0.38422149419784546,
0.9657673239707947,
0.16991201043128967,
0.08093682676553726,
-0.9603891968727112,
0.024502748623490334,
0.48049071431159973,
0.5168216824531555,
0.19663695991039276,
-0.45219212770462036,
-0.3501304090023041,
0.17926868796348572,
0.17663584649562836,
-0.8575170040130615,
0.05635124072432518,
0.07387624680995941,
0.6729520559310913,
0.6290065050125122,
0.04135061427950859,
0.6800369620323181,
-0.3072702884674072,
0.8140943646430969,
0.06814044713973999,
-1.2169134616851807,
0.39008358120918274,
-0.17807921767234802,
0.08984869718551636,
0.7006067633628845,
0.3372633755207062,
-0.24113044142723083,
-0.397325336933136,
-0.4875537157058716,
-0.6041731238365173,
0.5948678255081177,
-0.13901007175445557,
0.16657668352127075,
-0.11116864532232285,
0.4559835195541382,
0.08970791846513748,
0.5247666239738464,
-0.6245570778846741,
-0.07073019444942474,
0.159133642911911,
0.07226510345935822,
-0.17473572492599487,
-0.5715560913085938,
-0.0702090710401535,
-0.0892433151602745,
0.7168406248092651,
-0.26066452264785767,
0.3214132785797119,
0.07010254263877869,
-0.30214923620224,
-0.10162950307130814,
0.1515190452337265,
0.18657584488391876,
0.9352880120277405,
-0.2471337914466858,
0.35584700107574463,
0.22017526626586914,
-0.2560898959636688,
-0.12769873440265656,
0.0363207571208477,
-0.23538894951343536,
-0.07309149205684662,
0.4407604932785034,
0.8702683448791504,
0.4754239022731781,
-0.8672717213630676,
0.741732656955719,
0.13353092968463898,
0.0922606885433197,
-0.11556486785411835,
-0.15171879529953003,
0.08200010657310486,
0.4849722385406494,
0.22845131158828735,
-0.0688994750380516,
0.1330939382314682,
-0.6254967451095581,
0.2046879380941391,
0.6526142954826355,
-0.47139430046081543,
-0.45487117767333984,
0.5695810914039612,
0.06593544781208038,
0.05109560117125511,
0.6635938286781311,
-0.24277734756469727,
-0.7780658006668091,
0.48922526836395264,
0.44258275628089905,
0.940565288066864,
0.0744907483458519,
-0.019061530008912086,
0.19628988206386566,
0.2890370786190033,
-0.013219992630183697,
0.3259428143501282,
-0.13542646169662476,
-0.8623991012573242,
-0.7145693898200989,
-0.682700514793396,
-0.30454328656196594,
0.05628611147403717,
-0.6298118829727173,
0.22704854607582092,
-0.3370670974254608,
-0.4208008348941803,
0.0007404088973999023,
0.0356186106801033,
-0.8599317669868469,
0.14876696467399597,
-0.014580218121409416,
0.9934425950050354,
-0.5700199604034424,
0.52680903673172,
0.9327925443649292,
-0.392240434885025,
-0.9598820209503174,
0.2763003706932068,
-0.32700636982917786,
-0.9078016877174377,
0.7025336623191833,
0.14105379581451416,
-0.17438724637031555,
-0.029406849294900894,
-0.505579948425293,
-1.0601472854614258,
0.7543274164199829,
0.4175707995891571,
-0.5139702558517456,
0.09279832988977432,
-0.3784114122390747,
0.3842214345932007,
0.05610058456659317,
0.2826003134250641,
0.37855982780456543,
0.48049572110176086,
0.004004891496151686,
-0.8737208247184753,
0.10220538824796677,
-0.19496026635169983,
-0.3486557900905609,
0.444303959608078,
-0.5378340482711792,
0.8988760113716125,
-0.35776352882385254,
-0.5818779468536377,
-0.02291901595890522,
0.7953325510025024,
0.014045733027160168,
0.2739088833332062,
0.6050980091094971,
0.4899353086948395,
1.2526969909667969,
0.05769123136997223,
1.1433472633361816,
-0.6771127581596375,
0.43933531641960144,
1.0708142518997192,
-0.24764737486839294,
0.8053886890411377,
0.44250428676605225,
-0.14502905309200287,
0.15091842412948608,
0.4730716347694397,
0.2671745717525482,
0.29901638627052307,
0.18112654983997345,
-0.3570176064968109,
-0.5937759280204773,
-0.06876827776432037,
-0.14639915525913239,
0.5619526505470276,
0.32558342814445496,
-0.1254921406507492,
0.13330261409282684,
-0.20284663140773773,
-0.0921001210808754,
-0.04365658015012741,
-0.46604683995246887,
0.9267367720603943,
0.17059555649757385,
-0.9642274975776672,
0.45757925510406494,
0.15551616251468658,
0.6146551966667175,
-0.4558843970298767,
0.24418208003044128,
-0.24012349545955658,
0.12047190219163895,
0.08986279368400574,
-0.8090132474899292,
0.14619676768779755,
0.0028957684990018606,
-0.36222219467163086,
0.202605202794075,
0.9988453984260559,
-0.3445677161216736,
-0.5815244913101196,
0.16743090748786926,
0.8210055828094482,
0.2143472284078598,
-0.40097686648368835,
-0.26227059960365295,
-0.23772858083248138,
-0.13146460056304932,
-0.40441784262657166,
0.005231824237853289,
0.6519989967346191,
0.0010591666214168072,
0.7663685083389282,
0.5473561882972717,
0.14077486097812653,
0.10123968124389648,
-0.10714567452669144,
0.9117008447647095,
-0.6455967426300049,
-0.40257444977760315,
-0.8730955719947815,
0.4239928424358368,
-0.07992512732744217,
-0.2751292884349823,
0.868969738483429,
0.5064834952354431,
0.6829783916473389,
-0.04744622856378555,
0.7633863091468811,
0.12504151463508606,
0.6406978964805603,
-0.7575821876525879,
0.6051278114318848,
-0.5944424867630005,
0.22893020510673523,
-0.07542655616998672,
-0.9060682058334351,
-0.05320977419614792,
0.2718266248703003,
-0.6203631162643433,
-0.10055119544267654,
0.5338218808174133,
0.7154616117477417,
-0.1408073753118515,
0.03666752949357033,
0.3676539361476898,
0.4333772361278534,
-0.10642801970243454,
0.1640952229499817,
1.0807162523269653,
-0.02431630901992321,
0.10590565949678421,
-0.23055239021778107,
-0.13530725240707397,
-0.11122701317071915,
-0.7154699563980103,
-0.9727095365524292,
-0.47767797112464905,
0.03927856311202049,
-0.1921282410621643,
-0.0453566312789917,
0.8354002833366394,
0.7028694152832031,
-0.6531720757484436,
-0.2101021260023117,
0.09819288551807404,
0.4486622214317322,
-0.0002960411657113582,
-0.2042592316865921,
0.4300660789012909,
-0.43049630522727966,
-0.6677724123001099,
0.5982205271720886,
0.15533190965652466,
-0.0950281023979187,
-0.5157765746116638,
0.28005775809288025,
-0.17203833162784576,
0.04847573861479759,
0.7115363478660583,
0.023588277399539948,
-0.6151513457298279,
-0.3883078098297119,
0.22287854552268982,
0.11229054629802704,
-0.1283113658428192,
0.9812754392623901,
-0.8203855156898499,
0.4525986313819885,
0.3360156714916229,
0.86969393491745,
0.6640356779098511,
0.025354521349072456,
0.5748910307884216,
-0.7619280219078064,
0.0792742446064949,
0.3302597105503082,
0.44632193446159363,
0.33514878153800964,
-0.5865488052368164,
0.24881456792354584,
0.2739001214504242,
-0.3705679774284363,
-0.7929897904396057,
0.13826429843902588,
-0.7376604080200195,
-0.12093494087457657,
1.072047472000122,
-0.3540526330471039,
-0.2963304817676544,
0.13842418789863586,
0.053480733186006546,
0.2012445330619812,
-0.3408114016056061,
0.5703589916229248,
0.6049500107765198,
0.1929721236228943,
0.10975124686956406,
-0.390788733959198,
0.27493658661842346,
0.5110644102096558,
-0.6485132575035095,
0.042858757078647614,
0.5666465163230896,
0.388298898935318,
0.12514248490333557,
0.7069196105003357,
0.09744545072317123,
0.03297065570950508,
0.07621719688177109,
0.1015533059835434,
0.12783129513263702,
-0.3442270755767822,
0.026531299576163292,
0.23223836719989777,
0.5955662727355957,
-0.08937148004770279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12665v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12665v1 | CollabStory: Multi-LLM Collaborative Story Generation and Authorship Analysis | 2024-06-18T14:35:12 | 2024-06-18T14:35:12 | Saranya Venkatraman, Nafis Irtiza Tripto, Dongwon Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The rise of unifying frameworks that enable seamless interoperability of
Large Language Models (LLMs) has made LLM-LLM collaboration for open-ended
tasks a possibility. Despite this, there have not been efforts to explore such
collaborative writing. We take the next step beyond human-LLM collaboration to
explore this multi-LLM scenario by generating the first exclusively
LLM-generated collaborative stories dataset called CollabStory. We focus on
single-author ($N=1$) to multi-author (up to $N=5$) scenarios, where multiple
LLMs co-author stories. We generate over 32k stories using open-source
instruction-tuned LLMs. Further, we take inspiration from the PAN tasks that
have set the standard for human-human multi-author writing tasks and analysis.
We extend their authorship-related tasks for multi-LLM settings and present
baselines for LLM-LLM collaboration. We find that current baselines are not
able to handle this emerging scenario. Thus, CollabStory is a resource that
could help propel an understanding as well as the development of techniques to
discern the use of multiple LLMs. This is crucial to study in the context of
writing tasks since LLM-LLM collaboration could potentially overwhelm ongoing
challenges related to plagiarism detection, credit assignment, maintaining
academic integrity in educational settings, and addressing copyright
infringement concerns. We make our dataset and code available at
\texttt{\url{https://github.com/saranya-venkatraman/multi_llm_story_writing}}. | [
-0.33047953248023987,
-0.4980126619338989,
0.6385336518287659,
0.3241831064224243,
0.22881612181663513,
0.5364435315132141,
-0.33323201537132263,
-0.42897745966911316,
0.2564258277416229,
0.6998517513275146,
-0.8347247242927551,
-0.7590733766555786,
-0.41251882910728455,
0.42242512106895447,
-0.23715496063232422,
1.0979636907577515,
-0.27244335412979126,
0.0061435759998857975,
-0.9127027988433838,
-0.21435269713401794,
-0.5225242376327515,
-0.5870952606201172,
-0.16402263939380646,
-0.022898783907294273,
0.7051254510879517,
0.6464312672615051,
0.22445766627788544,
0.21551750600337982,
0.6856168508529663,
0.3187897205352783,
0.35346031188964844,
0.2838468849658966,
-0.7996742129325867,
0.34017252922058105,
0.3754172623157501,
-0.20631161332130432,
-0.5888840556144714,
0.3318037986755371,
0.5439571142196655,
0.7686662673950195,
0.013078486546874046,
0.28173866868019104,
0.25973325967788696,
0.5128526091575623,
-0.7552241683006287,
-0.02924625761806965,
-0.20227351784706116,
0.10690025240182877,
-0.2848791778087616,
-0.11962656676769257,
-0.5015989542007446,
-0.31713369488716125,
0.004015394486486912,
-0.757013201713562,
0.5800902843475342,
0.4012473523616791,
0.1130967065691948,
0.09109070152044296,
-0.05937238782644272,
-0.5822546482086182,
-0.37954214215278625,
0.8028386235237122,
-0.3493140935897827,
0.10953725874423981,
-0.00720462528988719,
0.0011370162246748805,
-0.388645738363266,
-0.9554188251495361,
-0.577605664730072,
-0.1595911979675293,
-0.2531397342681885,
0.2782756984233856,
0.015513693913817406,
-0.20375284552574158,
0.04899129644036293,
0.3562268912792206,
-0.46208471059799194,
0.1735035926103592,
-0.3971027135848999,
-0.2740778923034668,
0.5796595811843872,
0.3731210231781006,
0.41585788130760193,
0.10509432852268219,
-0.7797259092330933,
0.17151173949241638,
-0.678951621055603,
-0.028792113065719604,
0.585189700126648,
0.3123917579650879,
-0.18040485680103302,
0.7186079621315002,
0.1509498506784439,
0.3082273602485657,
-0.29671791195869446,
-0.04890424758195877,
0.17337152361869812,
-0.9096895456314087,
0.12428222596645355,
0.3329092860221863,
1.0634030103683472,
0.38822662830352783,
-0.039011307060718536,
-0.365078866481781,
0.11919067800045013,
-0.21448735892772675,
0.15131333470344543,
-0.6504546403884888,
-0.29362910985946655,
0.14837871491909027,
-0.11768119782209396,
-0.47631147503852844,
0.10809879750013351,
-0.7791409492492676,
-0.8858533501625061,
-0.4278254210948944,
0.048631180077791214,
-0.13230396807193756,
-0.1567932367324829,
-0.0532524548470974,
0.03957284614443779,
-0.1618007868528366,
0.19343949854373932,
-0.6373431086540222,
0.6558433175086975,
0.711761474609375,
0.9666343331336975,
-0.6106578707695007,
-1.1012673377990723,
-0.5879833102226257,
0.28425952792167664,
-0.03234313428401947,
0.4536772072315216,
-0.11947154998779297,
-0.27304843068122864,
-0.10877427458763123,
-0.33841100335121155,
-0.13078583776950836,
-0.17521153390407562,
0.24725967645645142,
-0.2017783224582672,
0.46079298853874207,
-0.4972274899482727,
-0.6513935923576355,
0.3061869144439697,
0.14136865735054016,
-0.738629937171936,
0.6607325673103333,
-0.07458736002445221,
-0.81034916639328,
0.3779773414134979,
-0.7372516393661499,
-0.11319620907306671,
0.18566660583019257,
-0.2390049397945404,
-0.5551553964614868,
-0.07887547463178635,
0.27753379940986633,
0.5237887501716614,
-0.4800524115562439,
0.545116126537323,
-0.34006279706954956,
-0.44806334376335144,
0.38183507323265076,
-0.07342681288719177,
1.0471826791763306,
0.05734596401453018,
0.28656190633773804,
0.024143895134329796,
-0.5929959416389465,
-0.24131006002426147,
0.130647212266922,
-0.35224223136901855,
0.00805649533867836,
-0.28168365359306335,
0.03756295144557953,
-0.20430362224578857,
0.560886025428772,
-0.767368733882904,
0.20017005503177643,
0.28491830825805664,
0.09658916294574738,
0.49587324261665344,
-0.0878586694598198,
0.5453123450279236,
-0.5089434385299683,
0.71695476770401,
-0.3727121651172638,
0.024087432771921158,
-0.30510076880455017,
-0.46675556898117065,
-0.3070032596588135,
-0.6441566348075867,
0.0568678081035614,
0.49023187160491943,
-0.31734800338745117,
0.1437845528125763,
-0.11545662581920624,
-0.30754536390304565,
-0.5883601903915405,
0.3770391047000885,
0.5384031534194946,
0.5021682381629944,
0.26811352372169495,
-0.24906931817531586,
-0.7714534401893616,
-0.5711405277252197,
-0.3568938970565796,
0.23601555824279785,
0.07190052419900894,
0.13721534609794617,
0.5092287063598633,
0.12150612473487854,
1.1578012704849243,
-0.6222448348999023,
-0.6209936141967773,
-0.3707139194011688,
0.35922059416770935,
0.08772242069244385,
0.26044565439224243,
0.534674882888794,
-0.6326509118080139,
-0.6476393342018127,
-0.31312698125839233,
-1.035148024559021,
-0.4824942648410797,
-0.06985687464475632,
-0.09145761281251907,
0.18306313455104828,
0.8367328643798828,
-0.47335875034332275,
0.07822565734386444,
0.7157350182533264,
-0.3122299015522003,
0.8058040142059326,
-0.15113428235054016,
0.28175774216651917,
-1.3587160110473633,
0.0659334808588028,
-0.12376437336206436,
0.027048932388424873,
-0.6302310228347778,
0.16632017493247986,
-0.17379841208457947,
-0.2161000818014145,
-0.3158377707004547,
0.30228567123413086,
-0.7362719178199768,
-0.3040596544742584,
-0.002233718754723668,
0.33247339725494385,
-0.0038980457466095686,
0.4826076328754425,
-0.19300124049186707,
0.8882277011871338,
0.33349958062171936,
0.06097237393260002,
0.45077624917030334,
0.47322800755500793,
-0.4667355418205261,
0.5279006361961365,
-0.3581607937812805,
0.23863700032234192,
0.05878687649965286,
0.36920663714408875,
-0.9234468936920166,
-0.23582658171653748,
0.20447491109371185,
-0.3703857958316803,
-0.00395365571603179,
0.06380215287208557,
-0.9829133152961731,
-0.20652376115322113,
-0.532904326915741,
0.16689516603946686,
-0.12021549046039581,
-0.6333590149879456,
0.3643461763858795,
0.2566778361797333,
-0.47245290875434875,
-0.6254904270172119,
-0.6426581144332886,
0.36994990706443787,
-0.29632940888404846,
-0.6666440963745117,
0.2358373999595642,
-0.45490989089012146,
-0.38789141178131104,
-0.047352783381938934,
0.2949860394001007,
-0.12751270830631256,
-0.051042262464761734,
0.4327223300933838,
0.45473504066467285,
0.08910313248634338,
-0.07512740790843964,
0.1337692141532898,
-0.21964073181152344,
0.10474993288516998,
0.09343282878398895,
0.3446834981441498,
-0.18794012069702148,
-0.2033935785293579,
-0.08948014676570892,
0.43965575098991394,
0.41604796051979065,
-0.0807403102517128,
0.7631569504737854,
0.7244371175765991,
-0.03029508702456951,
-0.013950181193649769,
-0.48280778527259827,
-0.11545409262180328,
-0.4520122706890106,
0.11479483544826508,
-0.17781740427017212,
-1.1569461822509766,
0.5964875817298889,
-0.08422967791557312,
0.1994643360376358,
-0.056536052376031876,
0.6473552584648132,
-0.15244781970977783,
0.24137304723262787,
0.5980092883110046,
-0.0036071829963475466,
0.062398992478847504,
-0.10384336858987808,
0.2705175280570984,
-0.8883108496665955,
-0.31769758462905884,
-0.2425825595855713,
-0.4931671917438507,
-0.3959439694881439,
-0.19117234647274017,
0.5938335657119751,
0.08417338877916336,
0.033603958785533905,
0.4068944752216339,
-0.4508286714553833,
0.8271737098693848,
0.653926432132721,
-0.10215841978788376,
0.7439298629760742,
-0.12195926904678345,
-0.11237692087888718,
-0.2582985460758209,
-0.5872732400894165,
-0.35761985182762146,
1.224340558052063,
-0.0719691663980484,
0.3753616511821747,
0.10480671375989914,
1.1735548973083496,
0.26360586285591125,
0.26204779744148254,
-0.3369734287261963,
0.6290413737297058,
-0.12798304855823517,
-0.5653972029685974,
-0.3345593512058258,
-0.28542718291282654,
-0.7840879559516907,
0.2873947024345398,
-0.3467407524585724,
-0.776448667049408,
-0.13261446356773376,
-0.23289626836776733,
-0.2415936291217804,
0.2339143306016922,
-0.7909179925918579,
0.7731502056121826,
-0.15453137457370758,
-0.6716278195381165,
0.08552762866020203,
-0.7449045181274414,
0.6533589363098145,
-0.5082656145095825,
0.3328395187854767,
-0.021924937143921852,
0.02942202426493168,
0.7134586572647095,
-0.38581952452659607,
1.000496506690979,
0.06156371161341667,
-0.05512995272874832,
0.35708510875701904,
0.18616703152656555,
0.21782267093658447,
0.23793281614780426,
-0.06054307147860527,
0.251341313123703,
-0.1763375848531723,
-0.2171286642551422,
-0.15444909036159515,
1.117479920387268,
-0.7266173362731934,
-0.2259698361158371,
-0.3569048345088959,
-1.3060368299484253,
-0.21802125871181488,
0.24356357753276825,
0.45821627974510193,
0.3078547716140747,
-0.17374861240386963,
0.17279058694839478,
0.2320135235786438,
-0.019108016043901443,
0.625117838382721,
0.3940061330795288,
-0.22372668981552124,
-0.575558602809906,
0.8560643792152405,
-0.04122726619243622,
0.03005376271903515,
0.28488001227378845,
0.16567447781562805,
-0.0719403550028801,
-0.6209270358085632,
-0.19395236670970917,
0.13128076493740082,
-0.4334270656108856,
-0.12190559506416321,
-0.5309175848960876,
-0.0000053647536333301105,
-0.34994712471961975,
-0.6461144089698792,
-0.2298789620399475,
-0.22154803574085236,
-0.4564019441604614,
0.02406972646713257,
0.351070761680603,
0.7702590227127075,
-0.19752444326877594,
0.25329679250717163,
-0.7965481877326965,
0.31624189019203186,
0.11325149238109589,
0.19168785214424133,
-0.11639685928821564,
0.0036423911806195974,
-0.25072744488716125,
-0.21602053940296173,
-0.35617300868034363,
-0.5210506916046143,
0.3058517277240753,
-0.1032591462135315,
0.2808259129524231,
-0.11089317500591278,
0.16184429824352264,
0.5253801941871643,
-0.3547831177711487,
0.6853363513946533,
0.5460926294326782,
-0.7858460545539856,
0.10338986665010452,
-0.45548129081726074,
0.15635190904140472,
0.7679738998413086,
0.33857452869415283,
-0.3230403959751129,
-0.6156378388404846,
-0.23355044424533844,
-0.9214621782302856,
0.9077020287513733,
0.49050089716911316,
-0.029562518000602722,
0.4130355715751648,
0.24660111963748932,
0.7466844916343689,
0.45506060123443604,
-0.8724521398544312,
-0.17725157737731934,
0.28343465924263,
-0.22656086087226868,
-0.30405884981155396,
-0.16280420124530792,
-0.3103031516075134,
-0.13316179811954498,
0.36104658246040344,
-0.11944444477558136,
0.025678599253296852,
-0.0895165354013443,
-0.14433228969573975,
-0.12728583812713623,
0.10170208662748337,
0.34295716881752014,
0.7330403327941895,
-0.27411121129989624,
-0.02457047626376152,
0.10963878035545349,
-0.5358417630195618,
-0.1813764125108719,
0.3727778494358063,
0.16011855006217957,
-0.4196111261844635,
0.6975365877151489,
0.5822240114212036,
0.3216627538204193,
-0.5934359431266785,
0.7166688442230225,
-0.13620759546756744,
-0.613650918006897,
-0.4419906437397003,
0.003726146649569273,
0.32874229550361633,
0.45782434940338135,
0.17735113203525543,
-0.12420712411403656,
0.021170848980545998,
-0.41629940271377563,
0.09168913960456848,
0.18557609617710114,
-0.09028664976358414,
-0.23766548931598663,
0.6085560321807861,
0.11018095165491104,
-0.19718363881111145,
0.6833242774009705,
-0.26612588763237,
-0.10223083198070526,
0.6016595363616943,
0.49884557723999023,
0.7986556887626648,
0.13588905334472656,
0.30754753947257996,
0.11286799609661102,
0.218481183052063,
0.13044536113739014,
0.0727664977312088,
-0.08358614891767502,
-0.8117265105247498,
-0.3479090631008148,
-0.48288822174072266,
-0.7651748657226562,
0.027973419055342674,
-0.5315565466880798,
0.4112462103366852,
-0.14181435108184814,
0.4435614347457886,
0.08097311109304428,
0.3105941414833069,
-0.35079091787338257,
-0.32801923155784607,
0.10020840167999268,
0.27425751090049744,
-0.7370456457138062,
0.3549737334251404,
0.6617580652236938,
-0.293020635843277,
-0.23638305068016052,
-0.27545350790023804,
0.31960123777389526,
-0.6804370284080505,
0.2685029208660126,
0.2299252301454544,
-0.09495644271373749,
0.1107865422964096,
-0.8181678652763367,
-0.4988737404346466,
1.6330989599227905,
0.46034902334213257,
-0.7840554118156433,
0.048425476998090744,
0.530055582523346,
0.6667052507400513,
-0.5875834226608276,
-0.19572100043296814,
0.2918309271335602,
0.36511266231536865,
0.10614944249391556,
-0.6183846592903137,
0.06457682698965073,
-0.015547903254628181,
-0.47269105911254883,
0.11274398863315582,
-0.6081323623657227,
0.9755539298057556,
-0.6731677651405334,
0.12643010914325714,
0.35764598846435547,
0.27694472670555115,
0.8277702927589417,
0.8853760361671448,
0.18716274201869965,
0.6454299092292786,
0.7897956371307373,
0.08734260499477386,
0.9151179790496826,
-0.21108949184417725,
0.35216936469078064,
1.5751683712005615,
-0.5651223659515381,
0.3385067284107208,
0.5715798735618591,
-0.21587902307510376,
0.25723376870155334,
0.1992948353290558,
-0.29392722249031067,
0.2976936399936676,
0.2861742377281189,
-0.3706263601779938,
-0.15630276501178741,
-0.1640099734067917,
-0.1144266352057457,
0.3276410698890686,
0.07563988864421844,
-0.18823128938674927,
-0.21764416992664337,
0.09765496104955673,
0.18796797096729279,
0.25334131717681885,
0.1567821204662323,
0.604084312915802,
0.1932149976491928,
-0.3801782429218292,
-0.10814207047224045,
-0.4132741689682007,
0.4842054843902588,
-0.33299314975738525,
0.10529276728630066,
-0.10149318724870682,
0.018475452437996864,
-0.21295370161533356,
-0.9768021106719971,
-0.0723714679479599,
0.11906486004590988,
-0.18403570353984833,
-0.5588223934173584,
0.6040593385696411,
-0.6279287338256836,
-0.4006589353084564,
0.34900832176208496,
1.0054495334625244,
0.12347322702407837,
0.10849826782941818,
-0.3219863176345825,
0.26067453622817993,
-0.21625737845897675,
-0.1445506364107132,
0.5036910772323608,
0.4011300206184387,
0.19482755661010742,
0.4601280987262726,
0.731878399848938,
-0.10255616903305054,
0.01974622905254364,
0.1171877384185791,
0.7101567387580872,
-0.31874313950538635,
-0.24424885213375092,
-0.7071430087089539,
0.40055757761001587,
-0.06386084854602814,
-0.3600161373615265,
0.8694165945053101,
0.9370908141136169,
0.7240890860557556,
-0.03874967619776726,
0.8635224103927612,
-0.0950760543346405,
0.4544927179813385,
-0.3606674075126648,
0.8759452104568481,
-0.42309150099754333,
0.368638277053833,
-0.41377636790275574,
-0.9546204209327698,
-0.4276297688484192,
-0.13813799619674683,
-0.06695413589477539,
-0.19984547793865204,
0.9438084363937378,
0.5691378116607666,
0.012113098055124283,
0.4432080388069153,
0.16283148527145386,
0.04689529910683632,
0.22851334512233734,
0.5383110642433167,
0.8836483359336853,
-0.20776280760765076,
0.7285866141319275,
-0.5243065357208252,
-0.14820556342601776,
0.061611466109752655,
-0.966896653175354,
-1.0460619926452637,
-0.7321329712867737,
-0.3437604308128357,
-0.04358835890889168,
-0.03791283816099167,
0.6025380492210388,
0.13046647608280182,
-0.6002218127250671,
-0.47112298011779785,
-0.47592535614967346,
0.10683488100767136,
-0.010369322262704372,
-0.2316572219133377,
0.16939657926559448,
-0.3120065927505493,
-0.8064277768135071,
0.4862474799156189,
0.09437330812215805,
-0.2242777794599533,
-0.37894758582115173,
-0.2075623869895935,
-0.0712946429848671,
-0.2210158407688141,
0.5418779253959656,
-0.05323747918009758,
-0.2514784038066864,
0.18368959426879883,
0.10467848181724548,
-0.0707048773765564,
-0.06842687726020813,
1.071534276008606,
-0.604607880115509,
0.5634111762046814,
0.3112013638019562,
0.3998749256134033,
0.42539018392562866,
-0.21014797687530518,
0.4041879177093506,
-1.0334490537643433,
-0.2528291940689087,
0.09669674932956696,
0.38402339816093445,
0.4057875871658325,
-0.3758460581302643,
0.6031784415245056,
0.34572774171829224,
-0.7946272492408752,
-0.8463720083236694,
-0.059519022703170776,
-1.0491362810134888,
-0.2508939206600189,
0.9335367679595947,
-0.259951651096344,
0.1974571943283081,
-0.0733414962887764,
-0.23986013233661652,
0.2274583876132965,
-0.47735413908958435,
0.8352147936820984,
0.9355713129043579,
-0.37089547514915466,
-0.21863199770450592,
-0.4372152090072632,
0.12531057000160217,
0.015029125846922398,
-1.0294747352600098,
0.36844515800476074,
0.7099933624267578,
0.0870770663022995,
0.2846989333629608,
0.7566300630569458,
0.03809446841478348,
0.14186504483222961,
0.07625868171453476,
0.17222018539905548,
-0.6565694808959961,
-0.5435287356376648,
0.013014906086027622,
0.563753604888916,
-0.28473642468452454,
-0.18256527185440063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12651v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12651v1 | Transforming Surgical Interventions with Embodied Intelligence for Ultrasound Robotics | 2024-06-18T14:22:16 | 2024-06-18T14:22:16 | Huan Xu, Jinlin Wu, Guanglin Cao, Zhen Chen, Zhen Lei, Hongbin Liu | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | Ultrasonography has revolutionized non-invasive diagnostic methodologies,
significantly enhancing patient outcomes across various medical domains.
Despite its advancements, integrating ultrasound technology with robotic
systems for automated scans presents challenges, including limited command
understanding and dynamic execution capabilities. To address these challenges,
this paper introduces a novel Ultrasound Embodied Intelligence system that
synergistically combines ultrasound robots with large language models (LLMs)
and domain-specific knowledge augmentation, enhancing ultrasound robots'
intelligence and operational efficiency. Our approach employs a dual strategy:
firstly, integrating LLMs with ultrasound robots to interpret doctors' verbal
instructions into precise motion planning through a comprehensive understanding
of ultrasound domain knowledge, including APIs and operational manuals;
secondly, incorporating a dynamic execution mechanism, allowing for real-time
adjustments to scanning plans based on patient movements or procedural errors.
We demonstrate the effectiveness of our system through extensive experiments,
including ablation studies and comparisons across various models, showcasing
significant improvements in executing medical procedures from verbal commands.
Our findings suggest that the proposed system improves the efficiency and
quality of ultrasound scans and paves the way for further advancements in
autonomous medical scanning technologies, with the potential to transform
non-invasive diagnostics and streamline medical workflows. | [
-0.1078733503818512,
-0.47877800464630127,
0.9410203099250793,
-0.3733217418193817,
-0.6522045731544495,
0.35474804043769836,
0.06829944252967834,
-0.7020221948623657,
0.6464198231697083,
0.5220730304718018,
-0.6981809735298157,
-0.4877954125404358,
-0.8547619581222534,
0.046425383538007736,
-0.41827088594436646,
0.6574648022651672,
-0.012983577325940132,
0.1937783807516098,
0.02442326955497265,
-0.4540395438671112,
-0.30170971155166626,
-0.160719633102417,
-0.05788411945104599,
-0.29840949177742004,
0.41307660937309265,
-0.07213444262742996,
1.12726628780365,
0.8307449817657471,
0.5491408109664917,
0.34641972184181213,
0.3259323239326477,
0.8903006315231323,
0.05311420559883118,
0.030026983469724655,
-0.2193784862756729,
-0.24413765966892242,
-0.5540414452552795,
-0.2615814208984375,
0.3765442967414856,
0.9317348599433899,
-0.2783139646053314,
-0.16940267384052277,
-0.1663915365934372,
0.4547814130783081,
-0.4727887213230133,
0.08680731058120728,
-0.06181391701102257,
0.09119192510843277,
0.48956921696662903,
-0.6802757382392883,
0.04694776237010956,
-0.2745441794395447,
-0.04312092065811157,
-0.802126407623291,
-0.291999876499176,
-0.33093124628067017,
0.4000374972820282,
0.8932511806488037,
-0.49833518266677856,
-0.39147546887397766,
-1.088028073310852,
0.4251718819141388,
-0.5224329233169556,
0.7783808708190918,
-0.25821489095687866,
0.24154061079025269,
-0.02252378687262535,
-0.7657169103622437,
-0.34552162885665894,
-0.10332170873880386,
-0.15380358695983887,
0.3729652166366577,
-0.18029479682445526,
0.3469473719596863,
0.18765300512313843,
0.006398526486009359,
-0.34685254096984863,
0.09452235698699951,
-0.22057539224624634,
0.114456906914711,
0.580896258354187,
0.4167267978191376,
0.5037017464637756,
0.26883718371391296,
-0.3630703389644623,
-0.2629927098751068,
-0.2593601942062378,
-0.13424433767795563,
-0.026417240500450134,
0.268375039100647,
-0.18372119963169098,
0.7655928730964661,
-0.10783354938030243,
0.6031290888786316,
0.0917641744017601,
-0.43486905097961426,
0.2390017807483673,
-0.06509921699762344,
-0.18479406833648682,
0.2715977728366852,
0.6506255269050598,
0.15594010055065155,
-0.2933937609195709,
-0.08421068638563156,
-0.44096365571022034,
-0.00403745798394084,
0.703599214553833,
-0.5610256791114807,
0.14048126339912415,
0.27131855487823486,
-0.6222904920578003,
-0.054522980004549026,
-0.09565798938274384,
-0.2500056326389313,
-0.7695661783218384,
-0.5194442272186279,
0.39987361431121826,
-0.3893001079559326,
-0.30059531331062317,
0.7001500725746155,
-0.04156510531902313,
0.22055204212665558,
0.5952165722846985,
-0.7911570072174072,
0.22998441755771637,
0.8432734608650208,
0.6003274917602539,
0.4067647457122803,
0.07730118930339813,
-0.3467588722705841,
0.5200956463813782,
-0.6525269746780396,
0.7269282937049866,
-0.5785099864006042,
-0.702799916267395,
0.05466805770993233,
-0.07495703548192978,
-0.18496884405612946,
-0.6592963933944702,
0.35222113132476807,
-0.30635350942611694,
-0.22784219682216644,
0.12967193126678467,
-0.4557929039001465,
-0.5441423058509827,
-0.029994485899806023,
-0.6577413082122803,
0.5537030100822449,
0.29676225781440735,
-0.023584667593240738,
0.12229911237955093,
-0.7637888193130493,
-0.7514142990112305,
0.3980901539325714,
-0.5627298951148987,
-0.2534655034542084,
0.17211274802684784,
0.375201553106308,
0.6742655038833618,
-0.40517187118530273,
0.2797676920890808,
-0.057150840759277344,
-0.6175850629806519,
0.17690947651863098,
-0.05759714916348457,
0.5084760189056396,
-0.26317843794822693,
-0.4818192720413208,
0.22799304127693176,
-0.33417755365371704,
-0.446763813495636,
0.1951407492160797,
0.0789768397808075,
-0.012155985459685326,
-0.06566904485225677,
-0.5979691743850708,
-0.08776473253965378,
0.459920197725296,
-0.34982219338417053,
0.5662038326263428,
-0.7065573930740356,
0.01444443129003048,
0.3278637230396271,
-0.03303496539592743,
0.5018070340156555,
-0.6875061988830566,
0.5948563814163208,
-0.42647433280944824,
0.3107775151729584,
0.1407209187746048,
-0.5414485335350037,
-0.6663172841072083,
-0.561433732509613,
-0.3838850259780884,
0.705129086971283,
-0.940502941608429,
0.41008105874061584,
-0.24817481637001038,
-0.6990004777908325,
-0.7732722163200378,
-0.057861823588609695,
0.2843160331249237,
0.796321451663971,
0.400686115026474,
-0.12834706902503967,
-0.46446993947029114,
-0.6435965895652771,
0.02082413248717785,
-0.3991259038448334,
-0.19577330350875854,
0.7386612296104431,
0.08471325784921646,
-0.314544141292572,
0.13118746876716614,
-0.34570038318634033,
-0.4219070076942444,
-0.29198843240737915,
0.3241153359413147,
0.8555645942687988,
0.41328561305999756,
0.38564085960388184,
-0.608009397983551,
0.2569034695625305,
0.35956627130508423,
-1.166035532951355,
0.007417704910039902,
-0.4773221015930176,
-0.06417421251535416,
0.24781571328639984,
0.508389949798584,
-0.849773108959198,
0.6426818370819092,
0.3168838918209076,
0.05587412416934967,
0.4005245864391327,
-0.4764445126056671,
0.46357262134552,
-0.8285877108573914,
-0.027436189353466034,
-0.17489072680473328,
0.14932221174240112,
-0.40367525815963745,
0.24943885207176208,
-0.009598086588084698,
-0.005320767872035503,
-0.2964540421962738,
0.4798212945461273,
-0.4621095657348633,
-0.2320210188627243,
-0.3235485851764679,
-0.1708679348230362,
0.07235957682132721,
0.355068176984787,
0.23116958141326904,
0.591671347618103,
0.4258372187614441,
-0.5408529043197632,
0.6364874839782715,
0.3490631878376007,
-0.058948758989572525,
0.39898473024368286,
-0.5982427597045898,
0.38985979557037354,
0.27639320492744446,
0.24708959460258484,
-0.5970059037208557,
-0.06506280601024628,
0.24900846183300018,
-0.6660870313644409,
0.4921933710575104,
-0.3302159607410431,
-0.5538169741630554,
-0.4612899720668793,
-0.1972072571516037,
0.14367760717868805,
0.8779584765434265,
-0.5126553773880005,
1.5202703475952148,
0.33069074153900146,
-0.16373582184314728,
-0.6788321733474731,
-0.38703277707099915,
0.19203349947929382,
0.043072786182165146,
-0.40133389830589294,
0.17151492834091187,
0.11378638446331024,
-0.17955251038074493,
0.018460078164935112,
-0.22075068950653076,
0.054861001670360565,
0.17753256857395172,
0.06262599676847458,
0.6492050290107727,
-0.18121357262134552,
0.12271202355623245,
0.7261848449707031,
-0.1455068290233612,
0.1284720003604889,
-0.6467870473861694,
0.523209810256958,
0.3255838453769684,
-0.667648434638977,
-0.9773846864700317,
0.24564692378044128,
0.8452338576316833,
-0.1998993456363678,
0.4808419346809387,
0.6470016241073608,
-0.32775557041168213,
-0.13174831867218018,
-0.5890925526618958,
-0.7361280918121338,
-0.49183958768844604,
0.35089758038520813,
-0.1852903664112091,
-0.6549778580665588,
0.3975922763347626,
-0.38058796525001526,
0.09089602530002594,
0.0032018511556088924,
0.7326837778091431,
-0.6156184077262878,
1.3521908521652222,
0.46499761939048767,
0.15774652361869812,
0.17786826193332672,
-0.4704630672931671,
0.35945451259613037,
-0.9117277264595032,
-0.5506740212440491,
-0.3480777442455292,
-0.46106845140457153,
-0.4715143144130707,
-0.7386276125907898,
0.8998335003852844,
-0.37743932008743286,
-0.2009451538324356,
0.013282137922942638,
-0.7612758278846741,
0.019681453704833984,
0.41208410263061523,
0.3793359398841858,
0.029454179108142853,
-0.2581169307231903,
-0.10177541524171829,
0.35865217447280884,
-0.7034097909927368,
-0.6187223196029663,
0.9563212394714355,
-0.02574150264263153,
0.8425416946411133,
-0.04021450877189636,
0.7095142602920532,
0.23701578378677368,
-0.12560556828975677,
-0.8952441811561584,
0.7354526519775391,
-0.4418160021305084,
-0.05712999030947685,
-0.2476324886083603,
0.06272965669631958,
-0.9823993444442749,
0.029654143378138542,
-0.3907530605792999,
-0.34018635749816895,
0.12761859595775604,
0.1120695248246193,
-0.668387234210968,
0.5680785179138184,
-0.2522357702255249,
0.06208726391196251,
-0.4219372570514679,
-0.49653157591819763,
-0.5557307004928589,
-0.6787419319152832,
-0.100906603038311,
0.07321548461914062,
0.25339022278785706,
-0.2099922150373459,
-0.7049522399902344,
0.4699939489364624,
-0.3693847954273224,
0.8465602397918701,
-0.3842361569404602,
-0.3286002576351166,
-0.054596494883298874,
0.34758809208869934,
0.4047768712043762,
0.033953797072172165,
-0.1311524361371994,
0.3606463074684143,
-0.48909759521484375,
-0.06522920727729797,
-1.0217475891113281,
0.3767838478088379,
-0.566365122795105,
-0.5647448301315308,
0.024039113894104958,
-0.8946302533149719,
-0.29545485973358154,
-0.0515858456492424,
-0.42779847979545593,
0.6044840216636658,
0.08532436937093735,
-0.168832927942276,
0.5190114378929138,
-0.32977911829948425,
0.1888567954301834,
0.5459755659103394,
0.33446580171585083,
-0.16875824332237244,
0.6923194527626038,
-0.03352135792374611,
-0.18803715705871582,
0.5778435468673706,
0.194388285279274,
-0.524989664554596,
-0.8158838152885437,
-0.8737466335296631,
0.5707877278327942,
-0.5522755980491638,
-0.24398000538349152,
-0.8722078800201416,
-0.009471970610320568,
-0.5919051766395569,
-0.7759223580360413,
-0.44918322563171387,
-0.18066851794719696,
-0.4574083983898163,
0.06954096257686615,
0.29535436630249023,
0.8805286884307861,
-0.1518716663122177,
0.010658052749931812,
-1.1089953184127808,
0.6026483774185181,
0.35769379138946533,
0.04205755516886711,
-0.09961073845624924,
-0.5372185707092285,
-0.13494795560836792,
0.005397474858909845,
0.18251459300518036,
-0.622395396232605,
0.43691959977149963,
-0.12664029002189636,
0.5498350858688354,
0.43587735295295715,
0.00047605831059627235,
0.7541542053222656,
-0.30861663818359375,
0.4436446726322174,
0.08853917568922043,
-0.6940553188323975,
0.39650994539260864,
-0.5009099245071411,
0.25891396403312683,
0.27471399307250977,
0.3712877035140991,
-0.16756877303123474,
-0.5730069279670715,
-0.4109448194503784,
-0.7453008890151978,
0.4996178150177002,
-0.32219377160072327,
0.13879965245723724,
0.3248929977416992,
0.5380071997642517,
0.1265736073255539,
0.3987658619880676,
0.13950611650943756,
0.07064977288246155,
0.12886163592338562,
-0.3716171681880951,
0.2553187608718872,
0.19076460599899292,
-0.3834504187107086,
-0.5028244853019714,
0.7602874636650085,
-0.5469148755073547,
0.43616998195648193,
0.014994077384471893,
0.0847250446677208,
-0.05703591927886009,
-0.2825794219970703,
0.5634464025497437,
0.3382004201412201,
0.07755451649427414,
-0.22303961217403412,
0.16874146461486816,
-0.43705251812934875,
-0.11169837415218353,
0.20151157677173615,
0.3055945634841919,
-0.21700038015842438,
0.6811032891273499,
0.5428836941719055,
0.17162618041038513,
-0.8103991746902466,
0.3316737413406372,
-0.033385269343853,
-0.18885135650634766,
-0.09444648772478104,
0.20448392629623413,
0.2716560959815979,
0.6635640859603882,
0.38387107849121094,
0.028263868764042854,
0.46175143122673035,
-0.2697482407093048,
0.15587858855724335,
0.45454511046409607,
-0.30331113934516907,
-0.22494785487651825,
0.5378320217132568,
0.2734706699848175,
-0.12822724878787994,
0.6389656662940979,
0.05142999440431595,
-0.3443456292152405,
0.82420414686203,
0.20291803777217865,
0.7397221326828003,
-0.5092483758926392,
0.04638439789414406,
0.1513078212738037,
0.5600141286849976,
0.40879741311073303,
0.6557955741882324,
-0.3711146414279938,
-0.8173425197601318,
-0.5286720991134644,
-0.2630102038383484,
-0.5839905738830566,
-0.29848742485046387,
-0.5547171831130981,
0.25760143995285034,
-0.6149152517318726,
0.2306438535451889,
0.04754204675555229,
-0.2622995376586914,
-0.29008153080940247,
0.38039809465408325,
0.45423001050949097,
0.4387461841106415,
-0.3738085627555847,
0.6462951302528381,
1.0383448600769043,
-0.14392082393169403,
-0.9545084834098816,
-0.07156557589769363,
0.17717593908309937,
-1.4819327592849731,
0.2947978079319,
-0.004465262871235609,
-0.908858597278595,
-0.23554107546806335,
-0.44091176986694336,
-0.6365689039230347,
0.9795596599578857,
0.40857693552970886,
-0.4393795132637024,
0.08405724912881851,
0.1860269159078598,
0.6505934596061707,
-0.24758319556713104,
0.35804739594459534,
0.5248258709907532,
0.48213112354278564,
0.2570236325263977,
-1.161985993385315,
0.06647829711437225,
-0.23020604252815247,
-0.45788756012916565,
0.43982261419296265,
-0.34531480073928833,
0.2638472318649292,
-0.6314557194709778,
-0.09733866900205612,
0.24385729432106018,
0.49911317229270935,
0.20273025333881378,
0.33458107709884644,
0.5563662648200989,
0.6034709215164185,
0.6839543581008911,
-0.05640707537531853,
1.0932773351669312,
-0.7394393682479858,
-0.24489392340183258,
0.5319384932518005,
-0.5633894205093384,
0.23242482542991638,
0.2641623318195343,
0.13693445920944214,
0.6152199506759644,
0.14251773059368134,
0.151855930685997,
0.1956896036863327,
-0.28377220034599304,
-0.5235525965690613,
-0.45235440135002136,
-0.5897548794746399,
-0.26168501377105713,
0.9892216920852661,
0.7057949304580688,
-0.10626647621393204,
0.16757911443710327,
0.3690623641014099,
0.04895312711596489,
0.09462424367666245,
-0.3639422655105591,
1.2528892755508423,
-0.03851088881492615,
-0.4885548949241638,
0.6975231170654297,
-0.31994450092315674,
0.5435603857040405,
-0.7035371661186218,
-0.4634031057357788,
0.01020443718880415,
0.0732487142086029,
-0.19970087707042694,
-0.8168625831604004,
0.38520559668540955,
-0.3942175805568695,
0.3151465952396393,
-0.323749840259552,
0.6963868141174316,
0.04409013316035271,
-0.37080755829811096,
0.5032166242599487,
0.5975388884544373,
0.029764721170067787,
0.1471785008907318,
-0.7096468806266785,
0.18266178667545319,
0.008934853598475456,
0.14013689756393433,
0.1376023292541504,
0.22133322060108185,
0.18900831043720245,
0.7995006442070007,
0.6584256291389465,
0.04597350209951401,
-0.5141233801841736,
0.12946423888206482,
1.0791555643081665,
-0.4801810085773468,
-0.24860072135925293,
-0.4434519112110138,
0.4107065796852112,
0.14564324915409088,
0.07945790886878967,
0.2538699507713318,
0.4553245007991791,
0.4717898368835449,
0.1426343470811844,
0.5693578720092773,
0.24778836965560913,
0.5986171960830688,
-0.5281836986541748,
0.8371700048446655,
-0.938033401966095,
0.1920762062072754,
-0.1355326920747757,
-0.27320030331611633,
-0.4320831000804901,
0.6250621676445007,
-0.10869567096233368,
0.25101813673973083,
0.456545352935791,
0.7972760796546936,
0.013025502674281597,
0.08267208933830261,
0.48684266209602356,
0.17037776112556458,
0.10556257516145706,
0.29383713006973267,
0.7826826572418213,
0.11002335697412491,
0.07197145372629166,
-0.4767756164073944,
-0.39963844418525696,
-0.323966383934021,
-0.4819192588329315,
-0.476218044757843,
-0.5074861645698547,
-0.27020519971847534,
-0.04848812147974968,
0.3588184416294098,
0.8394866585731506,
1.0654963254928589,
-0.13213703036308289,
-0.3608454763889313,
0.4414690434932709,
-0.009063154458999634,
-0.4086994230747223,
-0.05118001997470856,
0.38953980803489685,
0.09044942259788513,
-0.9101642966270447,
1.146722435951233,
0.7900501489639282,
-0.06049516797065735,
-0.013537520542740822,
0.014398426748812199,
0.06783302128314972,
0.2951207756996155,
0.37619301676750183,
0.18701016902923584,
-0.498249351978302,
-0.1529981940984726,
0.18233799934387207,
-0.02217889577150345,
0.046874333173036575,
0.8054283261299133,
-1.1134285926818848,
0.6068590879440308,
0.1705804318189621,
0.7798028588294983,
0.12021034210920334,
-0.16662050783634186,
0.3163163661956787,
-0.2018253654241562,
0.3691236674785614,
0.8695877194404602,
0.4588998258113861,
0.136252298951149,
-0.8084965348243713,
0.5300028920173645,
0.21268945932388306,
-0.29499271512031555,
-0.5544924736022949,
0.05304000899195671,
-1.1474485397338867,
-0.3876790702342987,
0.7477320432662964,
0.1032596006989479,
-0.3114081025123596,
-0.2927229404449463,
-0.09769343584775925,
0.5976041555404663,
-0.2977798283100128,
0.7096712589263916,
-0.2477651685476303,
-0.8098840117454529,
-0.062484752386808395,
-0.23484383523464203,
0.04535369947552681,
0.5390830636024475,
-0.8061878085136414,
-0.40810245275497437,
0.38891148567199707,
-0.16951397061347961,
0.20838718116283417,
0.4518738090991974,
-0.3513128161430359,
0.7559211850166321,
-0.14332476258277893,
0.4266946017742157,
-0.3659549653530121,
-0.31278568506240845,
-0.31538739800453186,
-0.017072616145014763,
-0.31141242384910583,
-0.2477513700723648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12645v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12645v1 | Evaluating Transparency of Machine Generated Fact Checking Explanations | 2024-06-18T14:13:13 | 2024-06-18T14:13:13 | Rui Xing, Timothy Baldwin, Jey Han Lau | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | An important factor when it comes to generating fact-checking explanations is
the selection of evidence: intuitively, high-quality explanations can only be
generated given the right evidence. In this work, we investigate the impact of
human-curated vs. machine-selected evidence for explanation generation using
large language models. To assess the quality of explanations, we focus on
transparency (whether an explanation cites sources properly) and utility
(whether an explanation is helpful in clarifying a claim). Surprisingly, we
found that large language models generate similar or higher quality
explanations using machine-selected evidence, suggesting carefully curated
evidence (by humans) may not be necessary. That said, even with the best model,
the generated explanations are not always faithful to the sources, suggesting
further room for improvement in explanation generation for fact-checking. | [
-0.48129338026046753,
-0.7873799204826355,
1.0863674879074097,
-0.059599459171295166,
-0.35224980115890503,
-0.3275075852870941,
-0.07909281551837921,
-0.5399174094200134,
-0.21310119330883026,
0.6080690622329712,
-0.5704387426376343,
-0.2390681654214859,
-0.8475295305252075,
0.2637115716934204,
-0.4904569685459137,
1.1086738109588623,
-0.1284685581922531,
0.0034825438633561134,
-0.19715626537799835,
0.1552812159061432,
-0.3881095349788666,
-0.3455785810947418,
-0.37221479415893555,
-0.7795283198356628,
0.5521734356880188,
0.4761388301849365,
1.0301446914672852,
0.9800492525100708,
0.2722669541835785,
0.38198795914649963,
-0.07970522344112396,
0.42116960883140564,
-0.5273191332817078,
0.030440090224146843,
-0.5055776834487915,
-0.2686009109020233,
-0.12523627281188965,
0.42755305767059326,
0.6263015270233154,
0.7021183967590332,
0.1194557398557663,
0.2568088471889496,
0.027755731716752052,
0.6765135526657104,
-0.7469146251678467,
0.01269312109798193,
-0.597828209400177,
-0.04411890730261803,
0.050671566277742386,
-0.26799681782722473,
-0.5334666967391968,
-0.5673019886016846,
0.4865136444568634,
-0.467591255903244,
0.533292829990387,
0.2869302034378052,
1.1897339820861816,
0.04368700459599495,
-0.3104507029056549,
-0.5921032428741455,
-0.9600472450256348,
0.7857091426849365,
-0.394586443901062,
0.3881784975528717,
0.43447187542915344,
0.40786755084991455,
-0.14894947409629822,
-0.7513605952262878,
-0.5842763185501099,
-0.21127848327159882,
-0.34504374861717224,
0.1373627781867981,
-0.16572929918766022,
-0.003016206668689847,
0.49279674887657166,
0.3712388277053833,
-0.5303317308425903,
0.0462312325835228,
-0.4192948043346405,
-0.798969030380249,
0.8610088229179382,
-0.0329001285135746,
0.014638932421803474,
-0.3230862319469452,
-0.16395793855190277,
-0.23634065687656403,
-0.8014699220657349,
-0.09474509209394455,
0.6194653511047363,
-0.28778645396232605,
0.09529944509267807,
0.6674440503120422,
-0.3104301691055298,
0.7639155983924866,
0.02792353741824627,
-0.18442188203334808,
-0.20877361297607422,
-0.7035233974456787,
-0.3935438096523285,
0.41052064299583435,
0.8986080884933472,
0.41695621609687805,
0.014157423749566078,
-0.13184240460395813,
-0.28229567408561707,
0.10137437283992767,
0.0970364362001419,
-1.0171535015106201,
-0.10055629163980484,
0.4897787868976593,
-0.8771303296089172,
-0.3371078073978424,
0.5957233309745789,
-0.650521457195282,
-0.47233808040618896,
-0.3447684943675995,
0.48647451400756836,
-0.13603776693344116,
-0.27926766872406006,
0.27256089448928833,
-0.5267627239227295,
-0.2116236835718155,
0.5478413701057434,
-0.7032015323638916,
-0.22863630950450897,
0.8222490549087524,
0.5409388542175293,
-0.014878679998219013,
-0.051770567893981934,
-0.8494531512260437,
-0.050607167184352875,
-0.45529237389564514,
0.885463535785675,
-0.33453747630119324,
-0.2877446711063385,
0.018275313079357147,
0.1253255158662796,
0.45116379857063293,
-0.4705536663532257,
0.8084434866905212,
-0.48152822256088257,
0.7993792295455933,
-0.5880811214447021,
-0.5829681754112244,
-0.5837907195091248,
-0.04791077971458435,
-0.83509361743927,
0.5209464430809021,
-0.14377693831920624,
-0.8771694302558899,
0.8828248977661133,
-0.9820643067359924,
-0.4265560507774353,
-0.02038656547665596,
-0.07585664093494415,
-0.6084395051002502,
-0.03870033845305443,
0.330005019903183,
0.38212424516677856,
-0.09320781379938126,
0.6617925763130188,
-0.058230992406606674,
-0.3248980939388275,
0.7742620706558228,
-0.5718503594398499,
1.2272847890853882,
0.4857501983642578,
-0.5752813220024109,
0.1719890683889389,
-0.5744922161102295,
-0.2293030321598053,
0.12502926588058472,
-0.4581398665904999,
-0.04791133850812912,
0.07059590518474579,
-0.3110354542732239,
-0.027700457721948624,
0.26330164074897766,
-0.6073789596557617,
-0.26905393600463867,
-0.17622819542884827,
0.365521639585495,
0.7605526447296143,
0.15404321253299713,
0.30031225085258484,
-0.36429786682128906,
0.36122897267341614,
0.08058154582977295,
0.35284215211868286,
-0.5084787011146545,
-0.7277786135673523,
-0.3666294515132904,
-0.1346290111541748,
0.6434335112571716,
0.1158214807510376,
-0.5069140791893005,
0.30967628955841064,
-0.09105922281742096,
-0.16742797195911407,
-0.7612154483795166,
-0.011978670954704285,
0.4662057161331177,
0.5257766842842102,
0.033037733286619186,
-0.1986592561006546,
-0.608528733253479,
-1.054009199142456,
-0.633053183555603,
-0.3226452171802521,
-0.28726693987846375,
0.31132662296295166,
0.5928840637207031,
-0.1543964296579361,
1.1570146083831787,
-0.31679677963256836,
0.5519306659698486,
-0.0931924432516098,
0.4282909333705902,
0.07602273672819138,
0.1916671246290207,
0.34399843215942383,
-0.8373348116874695,
-0.1097266674041748,
-0.10578039288520813,
-0.8027072548866272,
-0.16094136238098145,
-0.3191770017147064,
-0.3300751745700836,
0.27353599667549133,
0.21982891857624054,
-0.8103094100952148,
0.438517689704895,
0.5599675178527832,
-0.5152666568756104,
0.7582720518112183,
-0.20658375322818756,
0.3055760860443115,
-0.6969598531723022,
0.21844589710235596,
-0.16162636876106262,
-0.48480260372161865,
-0.4638283848762512,
-0.07026201486587524,
0.06679046899080276,
-0.02927549183368683,
-0.3136504888534546,
0.28096845746040344,
-0.5055267810821533,
-0.18705938756465912,
-0.3791000545024872,
0.34509262442588806,
0.4094425141811371,
0.07065246254205704,
-0.1470669060945511,
0.5958385467529297,
0.4676588773727417,
-0.717074453830719,
0.1006464958190918,
-0.0016572081949561834,
-0.6112787127494812,
0.18227215111255646,
-0.6373096704483032,
0.05034050717949867,
-0.23769985139369965,
0.23905889689922333,
-0.8865973949432373,
-0.7094365954399109,
0.2663944363594055,
-0.6577310562133789,
0.10114431381225586,
-0.23720428347587585,
-0.607957661151886,
-0.3615123927593231,
-0.3561478853225708,
-0.1357344537973404,
0.49356454610824585,
-0.8880259990692139,
0.4838922917842865,
0.11162744462490082,
0.15205620229244232,
-0.5699106454849243,
-0.6188169717788696,
0.047945380210876465,
-0.2429279088973999,
-0.8258125185966492,
0.2311582714319229,
-0.12347988784313202,
-0.7146519422531128,
-0.0052372911013662815,
-0.4569988250732422,
0.15603923797607422,
0.4533328115940094,
0.3255592882633209,
0.1939907670021057,
-0.30903488397598267,
0.1378757506608963,
0.11581309139728546,
-0.12356606125831604,
0.48792392015457153,
-0.04471414163708687,
0.23262780904769897,
0.0010230011539533734,
-0.4637921452522278,
-0.7238898873329163,
0.40410974621772766,
0.6551140546798706,
-0.17258286476135254,
1.0577313899993896,
0.6019642949104309,
-0.15730419754981995,
0.10453125834465027,
-0.797200083732605,
-0.6484730839729309,
-0.47064369916915894,
0.12663844227790833,
-0.1772637665271759,
-0.9237087965011597,
0.43509143590927124,
0.020047500729560852,
0.35904839634895325,
0.7894895672798157,
0.6924242973327637,
-0.02698095701634884,
1.5974218845367432,
0.3511379659175873,
0.2708764970302582,
0.42294660210609436,
0.11379087716341019,
0.2003064751625061,
-0.3807702362537384,
-0.2625698745250702,
-0.9301328659057617,
0.25424420833587646,
-0.9397531151771545,
-0.10443539917469025,
0.20401547849178314,
0.07027442753314972,
-0.14443081617355347,
-0.13023436069488525,
-0.5992990136146545,
0.6035930514335632,
0.6582052111625671,
0.15207035839557648,
0.630872905254364,
0.2740407884120941,
0.28532329201698303,
0.31267839670181274,
-0.7996971011161804,
-0.7058770060539246,
1.035226821899414,
0.5346364974975586,
0.5364888310432434,
0.07427392154932022,
0.5666102766990662,
0.36769914627075195,
0.4164108335971832,
-0.5229811668395996,
0.2685948610305786,
0.14970679581165314,
-0.8196612000465393,
-0.49418148398399353,
-0.4889865815639496,
-1.208661675453186,
0.39262402057647705,
-0.5148083567619324,
-0.49483948945999146,
-0.057095158845186234,
0.2451593279838562,
-0.22948719561100006,
-0.15156620740890503,
-0.9684807658195496,
0.6076462864875793,
-0.14730189740657806,
-0.2792559862136841,
-0.42279958724975586,
-0.3753911554813385,
0.6512596607208252,
-0.08780597150325775,
0.27174779772758484,
0.2080666869878769,
0.2850986421108246,
0.8606285452842712,
-0.5144969820976257,
0.4896017909049988,
-0.14678683876991272,
-0.21663086116313934,
0.43720585107803345,
0.3196258842945099,
0.5677742958068848,
0.2338976114988327,
-0.41336777806282043,
0.43209347128868103,
-0.449197918176651,
-0.44522401690483093,
-0.686150074005127,
0.29655396938323975,
-0.6821138262748718,
-1.1333446502685547,
-0.10308575630187988,
-0.4734334349632263,
0.3015199601650238,
0.1695527583360672,
0.4548576772212982,
0.3309430181980133,
-0.024699760600924492,
0.32806622982025146,
0.9033277034759521,
-0.2868501842021942,
0.2293553650379181,
0.7224829792976379,
-0.2402079999446869,
-0.06831693649291992,
0.6562182307243347,
0.09675366431474686,
0.13360406458377838,
0.0953056737780571,
0.7611485719680786,
-0.47835251688957214,
-0.8030115962028503,
-0.8328127264976501,
0.23497384786605835,
-0.7605338096618652,
0.10111144930124283,
-0.557945191860199,
-0.03717060387134552,
-0.06436149775981903,
0.12901188433170319,
-0.11313211917877197,
-0.51060551404953,
-0.20371700823307037,
-0.20583558082580566,
0.30711108446121216,
0.9563297033309937,
-0.12634532153606415,
0.013266145251691341,
-0.6753342747688293,
0.5253096222877502,
0.4791475832462311,
0.365691214799881,
-0.17273107171058655,
-0.5567629337310791,
-0.36685308814048767,
0.29299166798591614,
-0.37468421459198,
-1.0693538188934326,
-0.16910700500011444,
-0.12679938971996307,
0.578190267086029,
0.8221445083618164,
-0.03753911331295967,
0.4768694043159485,
-0.21421849727630615,
1.0610305070877075,
0.14608387649059296,
-0.9117127060890198,
0.8073676228523254,
-0.1686953455209732,
0.25801384449005127,
0.18584044277668,
0.3402649164199829,
-0.07359228283166885,
-0.6606161594390869,
-0.8546262383460999,
-0.34949809312820435,
0.8379290103912354,
0.4070764183998108,
-0.10851705074310303,
0.12948331236839294,
0.40029945969581604,
0.6156944632530212,
0.07237880676984787,
-0.5865278244018555,
-0.10997533798217773,
-0.4045490026473999,
0.1760970503091812,
0.19516023993492126,
-0.45403826236724854,
-0.5717833638191223,
0.13394606113433838,
0.5773391127586365,
-0.06863820552825928,
0.29011791944503784,
0.4379727244377136,
-0.1765255331993103,
-0.616397500038147,
0.3395044505596161,
0.9580426812171936,
1.1208750009536743,
0.033933933824300766,
0.2450447678565979,
-0.23052483797073364,
-0.42434054613113403,
-0.3167864680290222,
0.021784281358122826,
-0.4471193850040436,
0.3533901274204254,
0.6679502129554749,
0.9539635181427002,
-0.40184685587882996,
-0.6465649604797363,
0.3854184150695801,
-0.0014721049228683114,
-0.48802366852760315,
0.11506691575050354,
0.37633487582206726,
0.10891035199165344,
0.10340359061956406,
0.23862120509147644,
0.04636629298329353,
0.33838987350463867,
-0.7461845874786377,
-0.07345770299434662,
0.6234012842178345,
0.045745477080345154,
-0.22869719564914703,
0.5797821283340454,
0.01677982322871685,
-0.37806403636932373,
0.7655402421951294,
-0.0831710696220398,
-0.6305286288261414,
0.5736890435218811,
0.20589059591293335,
0.8039342164993286,
-0.13829073309898376,
0.34302401542663574,
0.4611572027206421,
0.4507324993610382,
-0.2767162322998047,
0.054678142070770264,
-0.141169011592865,
-0.6482929587364197,
-0.9381570219993591,
-0.2675427198410034,
-0.6271963119506836,
0.3447503447532654,
-0.5188448429107666,
-0.1102149710059166,
-0.13257449865341187,
-0.18273955583572388,
0.40407902002334595,
-0.06387035548686981,
-0.6594304442405701,
0.18365971744060516,
0.005826469045132399,
0.7643976211547852,
-0.8696388006210327,
0.42009738087654114,
0.4474618136882782,
-0.4278222620487213,
-0.8287229537963867,
0.24437662959098816,
-0.03391364961862564,
-0.7035771608352661,
0.5697517991065979,
0.23677268624305725,
-0.27277272939682007,
-0.6618555784225464,
-0.9987353086471558,
-0.6682945489883423,
0.9487712383270264,
0.6539938449859619,
-0.5768166780471802,
0.6043872237205505,
0.029154883697628975,
0.6419944763183594,
-0.24472257494926453,
0.2735614776611328,
0.5665615797042847,
0.8431183099746704,
-0.09621620923280716,
-0.8806735873222351,
0.31398749351501465,
0.12305865436792374,
-0.14268268644809723,
-0.029988912865519524,
-0.30625537037849426,
0.7170350551605225,
-0.3000068664550781,
-0.42611828446388245,
-0.23314443230628967,
0.660484790802002,
0.32123932242393494,
0.5988734364509583,
0.6977222561836243,
0.2008431851863861,
1.0473088026046753,
-0.15976136922836304,
1.4036036729812622,
-0.2228209674358368,
0.23406314849853516,
0.712017834186554,
0.029851693660020828,
0.31130826473236084,
0.5080501437187195,
0.013744868338108063,
0.9197073578834534,
0.9114663004875183,
-0.14320845901966095,
0.2786436378955841,
0.030627159401774406,
-0.06775833666324615,
-0.4856438934803009,
-0.38164427876472473,
-0.14803431928157806,
0.38194748759269714,
0.1646398901939392,
-0.8107872605323792,
-0.06509554386138916,
-0.27964168787002563,
0.089327372610569,
-0.08779305219650269,
-0.34670358896255493,
0.8336496353149414,
-0.31388363242149353,
-1.3630483150482178,
0.7711436152458191,
0.053475357592105865,
0.1880563646554947,
-0.15187162160873413,
-0.2542498707771301,
-0.1240847036242485,
-0.23917020857334137,
-0.5661992430686951,
-1.1634730100631714,
0.13459880650043488,
0.3461299240589142,
-0.3871990144252777,
-0.3574208617210388,
0.8625167012214661,
-0.23986633121967316,
0.022069469094276428,
-0.12027060240507126,
0.6061704754829407,
0.5129719972610474,
-0.2681058645248413,
-0.5858923196792603,
0.1373906433582306,
0.18925070762634277,
-0.6177803874015808,
0.18083296716213226,
0.5938529372215271,
-0.34189191460609436,
0.6264922618865967,
0.9472492933273315,
-0.23346121609210968,
-0.23240070044994354,
0.2011372148990631,
0.668431282043457,
-0.30029141902923584,
-0.5553142428398132,
-1.2046846151351929,
0.6763432621955872,
-0.30118370056152344,
0.2100280374288559,
0.7345896363258362,
0.6257568597793579,
0.5722081065177917,
-0.1087828278541565,
0.8524278998374939,
0.13693904876708984,
0.4514669179916382,
-0.7769660949707031,
0.7786035537719727,
-0.4625321626663208,
0.28450441360473633,
0.046492427587509155,
-0.9004636406898499,
0.11620276421308517,
0.46913862228393555,
-0.10263244807720184,
0.17372895777225494,
0.9743949770927429,
0.8266118168830872,
-0.11532983183860779,
0.40737903118133545,
0.17789927124977112,
0.6218979358673096,
0.07739057391881943,
-0.13293036818504333,
0.8625497221946716,
-0.1091790571808815,
0.6361954212188721,
-0.036099355667829514,
-0.2716640532016754,
-0.46305137872695923,
-1.3369566202163696,
-0.9467728734016418,
-0.42027679085731506,
-0.4357445240020752,
-0.6518900990486145,
-0.03285885229706764,
0.4615381360054016,
0.9581171870231628,
-0.8200942277908325,
0.1376228779554367,
-0.17607201635837555,
0.7760080099105835,
-0.24189436435699463,
-0.24819254875183105,
0.5185665488243103,
0.12523549795150757,
-0.5757482647895813,
0.3132587969303131,
0.1880529373884201,
-0.07867632806301117,
-0.5568340420722961,
-0.15859495103359222,
0.34806543588638306,
0.22548633813858032,
0.7908404469490051,
-0.08953091502189636,
-0.9904347658157349,
-0.6474789381027222,
-0.09435459971427917,
-0.03837179020047188,
0.08935411274433136,
1.0783827304840088,
-0.7189522385597229,
0.7129352688789368,
0.8192013502120972,
0.44938820600509644,
0.6115680932998657,
0.09082669019699097,
0.7203270196914673,
-0.3663877248764038,
-0.25353294610977173,
-0.11498983204364777,
0.39845892786979675,
0.43302738666534424,
-0.5356752872467041,
0.4145600497722626,
-0.00509187625721097,
-0.6593306064605713,
-0.930610716342926,
0.3783329725265503,
-0.8528922200202942,
-0.4501623511314392,
1.2526750564575195,
-0.15376222133636475,
-0.26039084792137146,
-0.5074706077575684,
-0.2830966114997864,
0.3666350245475769,
-0.491735577583313,
1.2910648584365845,
1.0707423686981201,
-0.20204880833625793,
-0.18766015768051147,
-0.671614944934845,
0.5396143198013306,
0.3066856861114502,
-0.7717071771621704,
0.28809741139411926,
0.5514199137687683,
0.34410232305526733,
0.3021870255470276,
0.16107818484306335,
-0.18435165286064148,
0.8079808354377747,
-0.00032333601848222315,
-0.07721119374036789,
-0.22814227640628815,
-0.1382056176662445,
-0.30992990732192993,
0.12953250110149384,
0.14574898779392242,
-0.12351186573505402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12644v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12644v2 | Hierarchical Prompting Taxonomy: A Universal Evaluation Framework for Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T14:12:27 | 2024-06-27T14:32:07 | Devichand Budagam, Sankalp KJ, Ashutosh Kumar, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Assessing the effectiveness of large language models (LLMs) in addressing
diverse tasks is essential for comprehending their strengths and weaknesses.
Conventional evaluation techniques typically apply a single prompting strategy
uniformly across datasets, not considering the varying degrees of task
complexity. We introduce the Hierarchical Prompting Taxonomy (HPT), a taxonomy
that employs a Hierarchical Prompt Framework (HPF) composed of five unique
prompting strategies, arranged from the simplest to the most complex, to assess
LLMs more precisely and to offer a clearer perspective. This taxonomy assigns a
score, called the Hierarchical Prompting Score (HP-Score), to datasets as well
as LLMs based on the rules of the taxonomy, providing a nuanced understanding
of their ability to solve diverse tasks and offering a universal measure of
task complexity. Additionally, we introduce the Adaptive Hierarchical Prompt
framework, which automates the selection of appropriate prompting strategies
for each task. This study compares manual and adaptive hierarchical prompt
frameworks using four instruction-tuned LLMs, namely Llama 3 8B, Phi 3 3.8B,
Mistral 7B, and Gemma 7B, across four datasets: BoolQ, CommonSenseQA (CSQA),
IWSLT-2017 en-fr (IWSLT), and SamSum. Experiments demonstrate the effectiveness
of HPT, providing a reliable way to compare different tasks and LLM
capabilities. This paper leads to the development of a universal evaluation
metric that can be used to evaluate both the complexity of the datasets and the
capabilities of LLMs. The implementation of both manual HPF and adaptive HPF is
publicly available. | [
-0.2260362058877945,
-0.8855093121528625,
0.48320043087005615,
0.7687292695045471,
0.062111712992191315,
0.1327880322933197,
-0.2555411756038666,
-0.017026271671056747,
-0.30985960364341736,
-0.0646297037601471,
-0.6601336598396301,
-0.5338340401649475,
-0.38648414611816406,
0.3723379373550415,
-0.10526850819587708,
0.8398020267486572,
0.09770546108484268,
-0.024923937395215034,
-0.32472243905067444,
-0.020705735310912132,
-0.6519041061401367,
-0.2776009440422058,
-0.5157665014266968,
-0.48120516538619995,
0.6291623711585999,
0.4042520821094513,
0.7178700566291809,
0.6497313976287842,
0.4609072506427765,
0.33791425824165344,
-0.3296556770801544,
0.11487916857004166,
-0.3330274224281311,
0.2305622100830078,
-0.3155076801776886,
-0.027035430073738098,
-0.5022597312927246,
-0.4524192810058594,
0.8491201996803284,
0.8030181527137756,
-0.11043667048215866,
0.39848408102989197,
0.4322524964809418,
0.49515795707702637,
-0.7007185220718384,
0.2566273808479309,
-0.5374369025230408,
0.06194845587015152,
-0.08582787215709686,
-0.528111457824707,
-0.3555693030357361,
-0.16764502227306366,
0.20016497373580933,
-0.5079153776168823,
-0.2753955125808716,
0.1016087606549263,
0.3740619719028473,
0.1630195826292038,
-0.5051888823509216,
-0.30365660786628723,
-0.43608441948890686,
0.78287672996521,
-0.4145547151565552,
0.1535782366991043,
0.08703506737947464,
0.22622574865818024,
-0.24176575243473053,
-0.5082712769508362,
-0.2353634387254715,
-0.4457273483276367,
0.14775089919567108,
0.17835955321788788,
-0.5135626196861267,
0.23640821874141693,
0.3463367819786072,
0.41184866428375244,
-0.7798685431480408,
0.5219051837921143,
0.060758911073207855,
-0.23380917310714722,
0.18331660330295563,
0.5209636092185974,
0.38934239745140076,
-0.5046550631523132,
-0.32895296812057495,
-0.04998219385743141,
-0.584363579750061,
0.18916262686252594,
0.18205980956554413,
0.5406293869018555,
-0.21804462373256683,
0.1364908665418625,
-0.21744947135448456,
0.6945584416389465,
0.19238215684890747,
-0.468722403049469,
0.061224136501550674,
-0.1309697926044464,
-0.4898119270801544,
-0.336905300617218,
0.9151657819747925,
0.12674279510974884,
0.18392375111579895,
-0.08150263875722885,
-0.2981641888618469,
-0.2239176481962204,
0.1471688598394394,
-0.5481804609298706,
0.10191900283098221,
0.16500379145145416,
-0.49247151613235474,
-0.256820410490036,
-0.1646646410226822,
-0.9479950666427612,
-0.480788916349411,
-0.18858052790164948,
0.6373564004898071,
-0.2377186268568039,
-0.1023549810051918,
-0.011068368330597878,
0.17395684123039246,
0.33530139923095703,
0.3277040719985962,
-1.127474069595337,
0.42842593789100647,
0.7875224947929382,
0.7627713680267334,
-0.49707192182540894,
-0.5584802031517029,
-0.6454518437385559,
-0.17396655678749084,
-0.2857153117656708,
0.7246150374412537,
-0.4913105368614197,
-0.4766886532306671,
0.18453168869018555,
-0.09884621948003769,
-0.33724063634872437,
-0.6787736415863037,
0.7394309639930725,
-0.3037320673465729,
0.1934838891029358,
-0.4737151861190796,
-0.4145505428314209,
-0.10552539676427841,
0.49797484278678894,
-0.5347881317138672,
1.2263978719711304,
0.2880035638809204,
-0.7469886541366577,
0.28363993763923645,
-0.6948187351226807,
-0.25580644607543945,
0.3767865002155304,
-0.06255272775888443,
-0.03452325239777565,
-0.03993590548634529,
0.458849161863327,
0.4493306279182434,
-0.6980371475219727,
0.4546472430229187,
-0.11028371751308441,
-0.37210455536842346,
-0.17536969482898712,
-0.586053192615509,
0.9179590940475464,
0.0022485710214823484,
-0.43106186389923096,
0.5642093420028687,
-0.5844635963439941,
0.0784774050116539,
-0.04045131802558899,
-0.563216507434845,
-0.04109015315771103,
-0.15354251861572266,
0.01248315628618002,
-0.014233517460525036,
0.1723792999982834,
-0.13089244067668915,
0.227087140083313,
-0.14182375371456146,
0.23062343895435333,
0.9180329442024231,
0.05090344324707985,
0.2333274632692337,
-0.6198611259460449,
0.9206368327140808,
-0.2759222090244293,
0.2533067762851715,
-0.4897296726703644,
-0.4599379897117615,
-0.43269720673561096,
-0.4049442410469055,
0.20281219482421875,
0.7377492785453796,
-0.43586087226867676,
0.6563092470169067,
-0.27932608127593994,
-0.439435750246048,
-0.36697497963905334,
0.1750810295343399,
0.4743427634239197,
0.649727463722229,
0.21664923429489136,
-0.09731170535087585,
-0.4773997962474823,
-0.6236338019371033,
-0.17455561459064484,
-0.47433561086654663,
-0.16384413838386536,
0.27387624979019165,
0.5464645624160767,
-0.24639438092708588,
0.5943605899810791,
0.20686374604701996,
-0.005144351162016392,
-0.19011488556861877,
0.1974378377199173,
0.3118283748626709,
0.2627997100353241,
0.42187297344207764,
-0.4960765242576599,
-0.3628500699996948,
0.016773296520113945,
-0.5993905067443848,
-0.4052673876285553,
-0.1951592117547989,
0.15151911973953247,
0.11280591040849686,
0.25339189171791077,
-0.5221651792526245,
0.04511022940278053,
0.6674745678901672,
-0.24104832112789154,
0.938032329082489,
-0.17876069247722626,
0.4503951668739319,
-0.7253657579421997,
0.15313661098480225,
-0.06680379062891006,
-0.026775170117616653,
-0.5243421196937561,
0.2850722372531891,
0.1206854060292244,
0.09757844358682632,
-0.4409160912036896,
0.6978746056556702,
-0.4203113913536072,
-0.21779580414295197,
0.08096112310886383,
-0.013969664461910725,
-0.19627468287944794,
0.4837363660335541,
-0.3379411995410919,
0.708234429359436,
0.8399844169616699,
-0.5676898956298828,
0.6330909729003906,
0.06884270906448364,
-0.527156412601471,
0.6908196806907654,
-0.7488008737564087,
0.028422582894563675,
-0.02279410883784294,
0.08945675939321518,
-1.2788158655166626,
-0.3268795609474182,
0.09370099008083344,
-0.26546090841293335,
0.04545300826430321,
0.07507683336734772,
-0.682323694229126,
-0.549251139163971,
-0.32302528619766235,
0.19058775901794434,
0.6194227337837219,
-0.7189602255821228,
0.46419671177864075,
-0.0857841745018959,
-0.35741716623306274,
-0.6718008518218994,
-0.31504324078559875,
0.10113470256328583,
-0.31114524602890015,
-0.5251885652542114,
0.3806346654891968,
-0.3329332768917084,
-0.24495671689510345,
-0.2879936993122101,
-0.2801283299922943,
0.0740206390619278,
0.2760502099990845,
0.2738719582557678,
0.27725282311439514,
-0.3345997631549835,
0.17586281895637512,
0.06859223544597626,
-0.009512762539088726,
0.12493792176246643,
-0.2772931456565857,
0.4989977180957794,
-0.27628767490386963,
-0.5625311732292175,
-0.5412804484367371,
0.1775653213262558,
0.6756900548934937,
0.033241380006074905,
0.3001183271408081,
0.4984044134616852,
-0.36146771907806396,
-0.12315864115953445,
-0.3390505909919739,
0.05632377043366432,
-0.4720451235771179,
0.30659645795822144,
-0.451211154460907,
-1.1211705207824707,
0.5525750517845154,
-0.1536123901605606,
0.25676435232162476,
0.43061381578445435,
0.9861453771591187,
0.1401800513267517,
1.1448743343353271,
0.4352383017539978,
-0.21828562021255493,
0.15429891645908356,
0.1900024712085724,
-0.09593160450458527,
-0.6819383502006531,
-0.29111334681510925,
-0.7179175019264221,
-0.12137260288000107,
-0.4940020442008972,
-0.27309420704841614,
0.4366944134235382,
0.1793791949748993,
-0.536748468875885,
-0.1169549748301506,
-0.3714677393436432,
0.5338598489761353,
0.31276339292526245,
-0.1998908519744873,
0.3891914486885071,
0.09673646092414856,
-0.44756534695625305,
0.08264017850160599,
-0.7862837910652161,
-0.5684500336647034,
0.7640933990478516,
0.4752116799354553,
0.6627917885780334,
-0.007028551772236824,
0.424755334854126,
0.3692791759967804,
0.3292887508869171,
-1.1649017333984375,
0.5145635604858398,
-0.032831545919179916,
-0.31923526525497437,
-0.4270431101322174,
-0.5642337799072266,
-1.0719778537750244,
0.38478174805641174,
-0.13787592947483063,
-0.9205030798912048,
0.005818432662636042,
0.12224594503641129,
-0.5430344939231873,
0.19272483885288239,
-0.36354297399520874,
0.9336699843406677,
-0.3155122697353363,
-0.03981177881360054,
0.11594410985708237,
-0.41491270065307617,
0.26929256319999695,
-0.08493483811616898,
0.32141152024269104,
-0.11064624786376953,
-0.24021689593791962,
0.697381854057312,
-0.04000872001051903,
0.8410133719444275,
-0.06290090084075928,
-0.27264586091041565,
0.03651713952422142,
0.2443222552537918,
0.19330395758152008,
-0.1926088035106659,
-0.3213747441768646,
-0.18077552318572998,
0.12634629011154175,
-0.296135276556015,
-0.6822752356529236,
0.6001601219177246,
-0.643761157989502,
-0.6998238563537598,
-0.2375139445066452,
-0.8402687311172485,
-0.5320746302604675,
0.2772069573402405,
0.3078249394893646,
0.548322856426239,
-0.35120487213134766,
0.27276092767715454,
0.5275406837463379,
-0.30293288826942444,
0.3526851534843445,
0.3732559084892273,
-0.24094262719154358,
-0.3234807252883911,
0.5859225392341614,
-0.11216311901807785,
0.29027917981147766,
0.5504518747329712,
0.5599828958511353,
-0.33694279193878174,
-0.5194277167320251,
-0.4691670536994934,
-0.14238683879375458,
-0.7462078332901001,
-0.3789573013782501,
-0.4386669099330902,
-0.01893341727554798,
-0.5019664764404297,
-0.1345537304878235,
0.2596791386604309,
-0.14142650365829468,
-0.17206323146820068,
-0.01651429757475853,
0.2964847981929779,
0.8092561960220337,
-0.14480234682559967,
0.4264901876449585,
-0.7392989993095398,
0.3178800046443939,
0.6246671676635742,
0.24154092371463776,
0.2981730103492737,
-0.725779116153717,
0.26404324173927307,
-0.17402417957782745,
-0.2953776717185974,
-0.8398300409317017,
0.19550034403800964,
0.2633085548877716,
0.8262946009635925,
0.18781810998916626,
-0.12810231745243073,
0.7407830953598022,
-0.4090248942375183,
0.7984519004821777,
0.2512569725513458,
-1.2318919897079468,
0.3886920213699341,
-0.6399031281471252,
0.7901274561882019,
0.40043482184410095,
0.6717846393585205,
-0.6838856339454651,
-0.1247469112277031,
-0.3354770243167877,
-0.7509173154830933,
0.5740457773208618,
-0.17689895629882812,
0.15301673114299774,
0.01914125867187977,
0.21820639073848724,
0.13925987482070923,
0.0476691834628582,
-0.5691908597946167,
-0.12762276828289032,
0.18343941867351532,
-0.33418774604797363,
0.283939003944397,
-0.24090683460235596,
-0.0328645221889019,
-0.23829756677150726,
0.3570885956287384,
-0.2948046326637268,
0.0856623724102974,
-0.07115733623504639,
-0.105433389544487,
-0.2688807547092438,
0.6588036417961121,
0.046984586864709854,
0.9121880531311035,
-0.0818689838051796,
0.00736784003674984,
0.35702380537986755,
-0.2864866852760315,
0.2203659564256668,
-0.06281670182943344,
-0.20288291573524475,
-0.21147049963474274,
0.7921361923217773,
0.8166875243186951,
0.4207000732421875,
-0.6513782143592834,
0.4439361095428467,
0.07095027714967728,
-0.34480127692222595,
0.3820204436779022,
0.11785377562046051,
0.046206019818782806,
0.05569873005151749,
0.4686373770236969,
-0.26315078139305115,
0.2113015204668045,
-0.6301333904266357,
0.16132603585720062,
0.1547691822052002,
-0.432418555021286,
-0.1105223074555397,
0.18628093600273132,
0.09335079044103622,
-0.34868255257606506,
0.4546530842781067,
-0.26950985193252563,
-0.41015535593032837,
0.6643612384796143,
0.7503246068954468,
0.7920697927474976,
-0.6410014629364014,
0.401373952627182,
0.36490052938461304,
0.38073229789733887,
-0.09809059649705887,
0.3691518008708954,
-0.2733169198036194,
-0.49142855405807495,
-0.5606907606124878,
-0.7660554647445679,
-0.6015159487724304,
0.2543160915374756,
-0.7758840918540955,
-0.1045861467719078,
-0.6325429081916809,
0.017203938215970993,
0.03577045723795891,
0.015155445784330368,
-0.48503461480140686,
0.16353273391723633,
0.03897766023874283,
1.14466392993927,
-0.6428138017654419,
0.4146396815776825,
0.8051936626434326,
-0.021153153851628304,
-0.8653116822242737,
0.14559097588062286,
0.4435989558696747,
-0.9075068831443787,
0.6093416810035706,
0.12686187028884888,
-0.16115109622478485,
-0.08102723956108093,
-0.41468438506126404,
-0.6387022137641907,
0.9483050107955933,
0.4561682641506195,
-0.5403006672859192,
-0.13139040768146515,
0.017677100375294685,
0.6218558549880981,
-0.5240786075592041,
0.28800979256629944,
0.8856620192527771,
0.6772146224975586,
0.24313993752002716,
-1.1994082927703857,
0.0874662920832634,
-0.3502292037010193,
0.21347397565841675,
-0.10682834684848785,
-0.30161145329475403,
0.7148247957229614,
-0.23221498727798462,
-0.33727920055389404,
0.4560289978981018,
0.3806959092617035,
0.6259186863899231,
0.001433934667147696,
0.7125782370567322,
0.19539639353752136,
0.9550374746322632,
-0.13710035383701324,
0.9067482948303223,
-0.057337887585163116,
0.27131664752960205,
0.8619828820228577,
-0.274291068315506,
0.7117909789085388,
0.17219087481498718,
-0.16263936460018158,
0.4276130795478821,
0.806563138961792,
0.028833117336034775,
0.15033912658691406,
0.47382861375808716,
-0.11618064343929291,
-0.3157552182674408,
-0.27919861674308777,
-0.18211022019386292,
0.37406688928604126,
0.47626230120658875,
0.08983009308576584,
-0.45315882563591003,
0.07078598439693451,
-0.003949157427996397,
0.03512661159038544,
-0.5807355642318726,
0.7309145927429199,
0.06888879090547562,
-0.8033665418624878,
0.843917727470398,
-0.09038326144218445,
0.7355715036392212,
-0.6287559866905212,
0.15709547698497772,
-0.14307615160942078,
-0.1875603199005127,
-0.3325667381286621,
-1.0102213621139526,
0.01234583742916584,
0.25065648555755615,
-0.1754561811685562,
-0.292590469121933,
0.537377119064331,
-0.2524642050266266,
-0.2695806622505188,
0.4985538721084595,
0.5830913782119751,
-0.08943240344524384,
0.08049008250236511,
-1.0341334342956543,
0.2401707023382187,
-0.26457977294921875,
-0.2618580162525177,
0.2292698174715042,
0.5426239967346191,
-0.10055486857891083,
0.7746813893318176,
0.5586975812911987,
0.057707902044057846,
-0.17583727836608887,
0.4967624545097351,
0.5661182403564453,
-0.5000544786453247,
-0.4378379285335541,
-0.8028212785720825,
0.4334704577922821,
0.3004869818687439,
-0.5334060192108154,
0.8226906061172485,
0.06243761256337166,
0.4379080832004547,
0.0549759641289711,
0.7260999083518982,
-0.01512258592993021,
0.42861267924308777,
-0.4018479585647583,
0.30397307872772217,
-0.5997317433357239,
0.2810506522655487,
-0.4600221514701843,
-0.9413011074066162,
-0.5041634440422058,
0.3821055293083191,
-0.25824686884880066,
0.29635030031204224,
0.7012407779693604,
0.7756180167198181,
0.0858575627207756,
0.09602788090705872,
0.4088362157344818,
0.27488619089126587,
0.04168884828686714,
0.6367641091346741,
1.156856894493103,
-0.010793546214699745,
0.48382899165153503,
0.13006210327148438,
-0.5791870951652527,
-0.15409345924854279,
-0.9851152896881104,
-0.8355231285095215,
-0.5119896531105042,
-0.16015149652957916,
-0.11177743226289749,
0.18394571542739868,
1.0056976079940796,
0.6149234771728516,
-0.7833943963050842,
-0.5648808479309082,
0.104396753013134,
0.25424882769584656,
-0.34042057394981384,
-0.1940016746520996,
0.4342305064201355,
-0.5539567470550537,
-0.4690043032169342,
0.39079660177230835,
0.5736081004142761,
-0.2238539755344391,
-0.32297283411026,
-0.08103512972593307,
0.06496559083461761,
-0.04979907348752022,
0.7243664860725403,
0.2642394006252289,
-0.7500096559524536,
-0.1975690722465515,
0.16374719142913818,
-0.1394319236278534,
-0.04115388169884682,
0.7640882730484009,
-0.5178474187850952,
0.30759644508361816,
0.7472699284553528,
0.7540763020515442,
-0.16063396632671356,
-0.11421851068735123,
0.44167977571487427,
-0.48548319935798645,
-0.20107464492321014,
0.2729664444923401,
0.34625867009162903,
0.3810475766658783,
-0.24508291482925415,
0.22917917370796204,
0.0700487345457077,
-0.6482899785041809,
-0.6610767245292664,
0.2270345538854599,
-0.939208984375,
-0.22494029998779297,
1.150903582572937,
-0.1714666783809662,
-0.23687498271465302,
-0.18602296710014343,
-0.18193653225898743,
-0.18041957914829254,
-0.3214922547340393,
0.6880227327346802,
0.5904161334037781,
-0.03931812942028046,
-0.2055647075176239,
-0.3804647922515869,
0.49376001954078674,
0.5446857810020447,
-1.0053523778915405,
0.1904609054327011,
0.49086299538612366,
0.13876302540302277,
0.0133905578404665,
0.765669047832489,
-0.27423566579818726,
0.5496261119842529,
-0.2519386410713196,
-0.3277914822101593,
0.17027318477630615,
-0.46323683857917786,
-0.7994457483291626,
0.26571372151374817,
0.1457091122865677,
0.37147051095962524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12641v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12641v1 | DetectBench: Can Large Language Model Detect and Piece Together Implicit Evidence? | 2024-06-18T14:08:01 | 2024-06-18T14:08:01 | Zhouhong Gu, Lin Zhang, Xiaoxuan Zhu, Jiangjie Chen, Wenhao Huang, Yikai Zhang, Shusen Wang, Zheyu Ye, Yan Gao, Hongwei Feng, Yanghua Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Detecting evidence within the context is a key step in the process of
reasoning task. Evaluating and enhancing the capabilities of LLMs in evidence
detection will strengthen context-based reasoning performance. This paper
proposes a benchmark called DetectBench for verifying the ability to detect and
piece together implicit evidence within a long context. DetectBench contains
3,928 multiple-choice questions, with an average of 994 tokens per question.
Each question contains an average of 4.55 pieces of implicit evidence, and
solving the problem typically requires 7.62 logical jumps to find the correct
answer. To enhance the performance of LLMs in evidence detection, this paper
proposes Detective Reasoning Prompt and Finetune. Experiments demonstrate that
the existing LLMs' abilities to detect evidence in long contexts are far
inferior to humans. However, the Detective Reasoning Prompt effectively
enhances the capability of powerful LLMs in evidence detection, while the
Finetuning method shows significant effects in enhancing the performance of
weaker LLMs. Moreover, when the abilities of LLMs in evidence detection are
improved, their final reasoning performance is also enhanced accordingly. | [
-0.6732699871063232,
-0.9271811246871948,
1.1349079608917236,
0.0857570543885231,
-0.33770591020584106,
-0.221367746591568,
-0.21932490170001984,
-0.733522891998291,
-0.17559365928173065,
0.22420063614845276,
-0.4982215166091919,
-0.5828635692596436,
-0.5639940500259399,
0.2184409201145172,
-0.46227899193763733,
0.5129671096801758,
-0.03354845568537712,
0.20841144025325775,
-0.14898362755775452,
-0.23626568913459778,
-0.5846253633499146,
-0.3340042233467102,
-0.9119769334793091,
-0.21985723078250885,
0.24247699975967407,
0.45837506651878357,
0.1245720386505127,
0.4492931663990021,
0.09888906031847,
0.38626301288604736,
-0.29089316725730896,
0.2811906039714813,
-0.3617423474788666,
0.3308750092983246,
-0.44498980045318604,
-0.8974644541740417,
-0.3543460965156555,
-0.0991365984082222,
0.5531269311904907,
0.3439998924732208,
0.15478664636611938,
-0.013038444332778454,
-0.1308063566684723,
0.37512585520744324,
-0.7145491242408752,
-0.07135072350502014,
-0.5225616097450256,
-0.21447886526584625,
-0.360991507768631,
-0.11475687474012375,
-0.5531085133552551,
-0.1317507028579712,
-0.09723323583602905,
-0.30379006266593933,
0.2905080318450928,
0.15951980650424957,
0.4646521806716919,
0.27818599343299866,
-0.5699166655540466,
-0.2016890048980713,
-0.34805920720100403,
0.6499837636947632,
-0.6907528638839722,
0.2675732672214508,
0.22121509909629822,
0.4046379625797272,
-0.4848213493824005,
-0.6468684673309326,
-0.5557942986488342,
-0.32753390073776245,
-0.22388657927513123,
0.024539874866604805,
-0.041140101850032806,
-0.09530558437108994,
0.8650374412536621,
0.1803278625011444,
-0.5198874473571777,
0.21713468432426453,
0.0686277374625206,
-0.4712155759334564,
0.618176281452179,
0.29195335507392883,
0.3167758882045746,
-0.18345320224761963,
-0.2755795121192932,
-0.15982724726200104,
-0.6994614601135254,
0.20329277217388153,
0.16328828036785126,
-0.015004750341176987,
0.20598523318767548,
0.37871015071868896,
-0.537824809551239,
0.47166579961776733,
0.09834253787994385,
-0.2166479527950287,
0.024116696789860725,
-0.37832725048065186,
-0.00346920033916831,
0.5725560188293457,
0.5655593872070312,
0.3934173583984375,
0.11317551881074905,
0.17235112190246582,
-0.14405986666679382,
0.29368674755096436,
-0.1810620278120041,
-1.1200884580612183,
0.1839170753955841,
0.4055294096469879,
-0.40858525037765503,
0.05805451050400734,
-0.3458537459373474,
-0.5795120000839233,
-0.5709183216094971,
-0.2965925931930542,
0.1736125499010086,
-0.5506431460380554,
-0.22630886733531952,
0.2170563042163849,
-0.30083587765693665,
0.3519589304924011,
0.690260112285614,
-0.4890584647655487,
0.42906785011291504,
0.8671738505363464,
0.6533467173576355,
-0.1773890107870102,
-0.11200881004333496,
-0.8316361308097839,
0.03868245333433151,
-0.39774036407470703,
1.2600609064102173,
-0.4064229130744934,
-0.23608800768852234,
-0.08642391860485077,
0.46302878856658936,
0.2842312455177307,
-0.5620424747467041,
0.9503175616264343,
-0.3683150112628937,
0.1919621378183365,
-0.543766438961029,
-0.7274709939956665,
-0.14583879709243774,
0.5456686615943909,
-0.6861522197723389,
1.2083942890167236,
-0.2482312023639679,
-0.608942985534668,
0.7502667903900146,
-0.5205026268959045,
-0.4950278103351593,
0.143072247505188,
-0.2998451888561249,
-0.16191373765468597,
0.009244710206985474,
0.649409830570221,
0.45693930983543396,
-0.16265186667442322,
0.2770788371562958,
-0.3890770375728607,
-0.705653965473175,
0.29910561442375183,
-0.4959120750427246,
0.7236983776092529,
-0.04164667800068855,
-0.7006040811538696,
0.18066847324371338,
-0.8099594712257385,
0.03685265779495239,
0.013264581561088562,
-0.5597311854362488,
-0.43099722266197205,
0.2419946938753128,
-0.2836894690990448,
0.17257684469223022,
0.08589286357164383,
-0.713909387588501,
0.028028372675180435,
-0.1903199851512909,
0.1410529464483261,
0.7693973779678345,
0.015112805180251598,
0.1593685746192932,
-0.20874463021755219,
0.2841675579547882,
0.12499129772186279,
-0.17993423342704773,
-0.2333461344242096,
-0.3581632673740387,
-0.8088210821151733,
-0.37515825033187866,
0.16519513726234436,
0.4794154763221741,
-0.46474599838256836,
0.42449429631233215,
-0.22101625800132751,
-0.06772603839635849,
-0.24190571904182434,
0.12545281648635864,
0.30721375346183777,
0.5119572281837463,
0.5218694806098938,
-0.009713787585496902,
-0.5089642405509949,
-0.783938467502594,
-0.3781009912490845,
0.12015026807785034,
-0.3224172294139862,
0.20469826459884644,
0.7782263159751892,
0.03187030553817749,
0.8768703937530518,
-0.24407251179218292,
-0.12069391459226608,
0.003976589534431696,
0.14563508331775665,
0.3626875877380371,
0.3976042866706848,
0.2943810820579529,
-0.41783177852630615,
-0.21667036414146423,
-0.27999642491340637,
-0.8719780445098877,
-0.20449472963809967,
0.0710206925868988,
-0.227174773812294,
0.3242451548576355,
1.0295621156692505,
-0.6437620520591736,
0.40164047479629517,
0.002018601866438985,
-0.5363643765449524,
0.679595410823822,
0.026014143601059914,
0.16625921428203583,
-0.7099496722221375,
0.06389360129833221,
-0.13591258227825165,
-0.4619685709476471,
-0.3366146683692932,
-0.016848567873239517,
0.22673717141151428,
0.2535146474838257,
-0.4620344936847687,
0.7990818619728088,
-0.537410318851471,
-0.14249935746192932,
-0.3647160232067108,
0.4664994776248932,
-0.06996560096740723,
0.29247841238975525,
0.17709456384181976,
0.8149601221084595,
0.4826904237270355,
-0.5821455717086792,
0.44761961698532104,
-0.04149799421429634,
-0.8446213006973267,
1.130295991897583,
-0.6430974006652832,
0.04745609313249588,
-0.1592758744955063,
0.5491275787353516,
-1.0931628942489624,
-0.36652737855911255,
-0.12669456005096436,
-0.12636798620224,
0.22673457860946655,
-0.2402430921792984,
-0.5691225528717041,
-0.2516697347164154,
-0.31668582558631897,
0.1942506581544876,
0.259559690952301,
-0.8384143710136414,
0.6945893168449402,
-0.10291752964258194,
-0.12445027381181717,
-0.723686158657074,
-0.5230133533477783,
0.13949230313301086,
-0.357892781496048,
-0.8656120896339417,
0.20664770901203156,
-0.07936861366033554,
-0.42046549916267395,
-0.1325938105583191,
-0.3877604007720947,
0.38498228788375854,
0.2036149948835373,
0.19118261337280273,
-0.0695151835680008,
-0.3508363366127014,
0.30120858550071716,
0.025443950667977333,
-0.19292008876800537,
0.3826577365398407,
0.012204763479530811,
0.4410993158817291,
-0.39364683628082275,
-0.623799741268158,
-0.14934386312961578,
0.36380288004875183,
0.4335586130619049,
0.042188744992017746,
0.46863409876823425,
0.5884259939193726,
-0.2463172823190689,
-0.3909284770488739,
-1.046940803527832,
-0.34492823481559753,
-0.4865277111530304,
0.273123562335968,
-0.6058446764945984,
-0.9796686768531799,
0.6688596606254578,
-0.5842640995979309,
-0.23974734544754028,
0.3278714716434479,
0.5601727366447449,
0.13318641483783722,
1.315678596496582,
0.04816778004169464,
-0.10174816101789474,
0.2399354726076126,
0.03440349921584129,
-0.0633956789970398,
-1.0199965238571167,
-0.16910959780216217,
-0.5119500756263733,
-0.24376130104064941,
-0.2578771114349365,
-0.31238099932670593,
0.34667521715164185,
0.34121468663215637,
-0.42283812165260315,
-0.010155515745282173,
-0.47592633962631226,
0.6401263475418091,
0.6194794178009033,
0.5179105997085571,
0.4718042314052582,
-0.22322480380535126,
-0.4334750175476074,
0.2380475252866745,
-0.3639887571334839,
-0.5134918093681335,
0.9828897714614868,
0.21025130152702332,
0.4760582745075226,
0.3408433198928833,
0.4415625035762787,
0.14877572655677795,
0.18807703256607056,
-0.7000622749328613,
0.9702364206314087,
0.25823721289634705,
-0.9115554690361023,
-0.4273741841316223,
-0.05969507619738579,
-0.7681400179862976,
0.4634648263454437,
-0.08734279125928879,
-0.863996148109436,
0.1707002818584442,
-0.33854979276657104,
-0.06510265171527863,
0.0026358601171523333,
-0.4288696050643921,
0.7728773355484009,
-0.4445250630378723,
-0.874387800693512,
-0.33311763405799866,
-0.4343452453613281,
0.45903027057647705,
0.10628657788038254,
0.0886714830994606,
-0.31592416763305664,
0.07183527201414108,
0.7991094589233398,
-0.41743624210357666,
0.6682062745094299,
-0.3197117745876312,
-0.1598924845457077,
0.3392961621284485,
0.2815306782722473,
0.8125483393669128,
0.34319379925727844,
-0.17114877700805664,
-0.21977658569812775,
-0.045359883457422256,
-0.36319056153297424,
-0.5951700806617737,
0.6248577833175659,
-0.13158224523067474,
-0.9537732601165771,
-0.33728015422821045,
-0.45078009366989136,
-0.23563407361507416,
0.38357236981391907,
0.1768312305212021,
0.4676838517189026,
-0.31143227219581604,
0.2941994369029999,
0.7689308524131775,
0.009424339979887009,
0.4899628460407257,
0.7738859057426453,
0.05335620418190956,
-0.019977374002337456,
0.2890223562717438,
-0.2758764326572418,
-0.08884987235069275,
0.19565920531749725,
0.3304409384727478,
-0.5276773571968079,
-0.7579389810562134,
-0.38945430517196655,
0.07013888657093048,
-1.1165374517440796,
-0.051497720181941986,
-0.4777531623840332,
0.08057470619678497,
-0.10119893401861191,
-0.10992582142353058,
-0.11626392602920532,
-0.06841867417097092,
0.14390042424201965,
-0.23348338901996613,
0.4212821125984192,
0.2763824760913849,
-0.04014338180422783,
0.1601954996585846,
-0.4391804337501526,
0.36003535985946655,
0.6124421954154968,
0.272085577249527,
-0.18602022528648376,
-0.2859693765640259,
0.07445298880338669,
-0.020887799561023712,
0.14241617918014526,
-0.47714173793792725,
-0.015957191586494446,
-0.25127843022346497,
0.8481758832931519,
0.6740115880966187,
0.09972494095563889,
0.6652433276176453,
-0.3680664300918579,
0.6859066486358643,
-0.136012464761734,
-0.943987250328064,
0.7229494452476501,
-0.4354151785373688,
0.43285486102104187,
0.6397638916969299,
0.37319880723953247,
-0.14393214881420135,
-0.44404348731040955,
-0.322014182806015,
-0.49385860562324524,
0.6528484225273132,
-0.13955318927764893,
-0.19534257054328918,
-0.04359355568885803,
0.127989262342453,
-0.19673414528369904,
-0.18507316708564758,
-0.6405532956123352,
0.21929173171520233,
0.10316384583711624,
-0.06703229993581772,
0.08308476954698563,
-0.4234178364276886,
-0.47929564118385315,
-0.3470748960971832,
0.359661340713501,
-0.4471050202846527,
0.22776421904563904,
0.41234204173088074,
-0.26655030250549316,
0.13608694076538086,
0.5373337864875793,
0.6801136136054993,
0.692324697971344,
-0.4258926510810852,
0.36200809478759766,
0.5930522084236145,
-0.20069022476673126,
0.24493196606636047,
0.15099792182445526,
0.07158245146274567,
-0.10160940885543823,
0.6998322606086731,
0.548913836479187,
0.16024746000766754,
-0.9124534130096436,
0.5917598009109497,
-0.22300632297992706,
-0.2916439175605774,
-0.4504331350326538,
0.3840811252593994,
0.21054480969905853,
0.5687218904495239,
0.3430251479148865,
-0.22174151241779327,
0.22344310581684113,
-0.7692234516143799,
0.14291499555110931,
0.5385616421699524,
-0.17885226011276245,
0.30400484800338745,
0.4662407636642456,
0.030223635956645012,
-0.03755383938550949,
0.6780612468719482,
-0.26931101083755493,
-0.7464452385902405,
0.7305964231491089,
0.39005303382873535,
0.5259339213371277,
-0.15606631338596344,
-0.30173179507255554,
0.32853031158447266,
0.13227787613868713,
-0.41919124126434326,
0.39269375801086426,
-0.24817419052124023,
-0.7969043254852295,
-0.6677381992340088,
-0.2506749927997589,
-0.3026125431060791,
0.1566239893436432,
-0.44764244556427,
0.2951410412788391,
-0.29886430501937866,
-0.03502222150564194,
0.1406077891588211,
0.10227528214454651,
-0.5904957056045532,
0.11664706468582153,
0.10071095824241638,
0.9974859952926636,
-0.6692377328872681,
0.6408334970474243,
0.3142409324645996,
-0.12807919085025787,
-0.6571528315544128,
-0.29161953926086426,
0.31489554047584534,
-0.5776565074920654,
0.970931887626648,
0.5840514898300171,
-0.33378589153289795,
-0.4810461103916168,
-0.8210685849189758,
-0.6639237999916077,
1.1510752439498901,
0.17236566543579102,
-0.5485936999320984,
0.280266135931015,
-0.11529954522848129,
0.5806029438972473,
-0.3917652368545532,
0.6665711402893066,
0.8754263520240784,
0.7158544063568115,
0.14187254011631012,
-0.6393212080001831,
0.7189779877662659,
-0.3125142455101013,
-0.3695148229598999,
0.13415710628032684,
-0.3209546208381653,
0.8029906749725342,
-0.020195016637444496,
-0.433931440114975,
0.11090073734521866,
0.34821248054504395,
0.6453248262405396,
0.5270051956176758,
0.6725376844406128,
0.6062401533126831,
0.8502063155174255,
-0.31480705738067627,
0.9489657878875732,
-0.21014438569545746,
-0.08886778354644775,
1.3267663717269897,
-0.5435954928398132,
0.808635413646698,
0.28483492136001587,
-0.16769813001155853,
0.9924578070640564,
0.5393108129501343,
-0.14348143339157104,
0.3096703290939331,
0.3378790318965912,
-0.520240843296051,
-0.6318092942237854,
-0.1833651214838028,
-0.34373849630355835,
0.4372595250606537,
0.6958415508270264,
-0.1218084841966629,
-0.22583629190921783,
-0.08544805645942688,
0.10639487951993942,
-0.10807077586650848,
-0.3144204318523407,
0.6829797029495239,
-0.0396420881152153,
-1.061621904373169,
0.6165105700492859,
-0.013204547576606274,
0.6928296089172363,
-0.45403367280960083,
-0.16503764688968658,
-0.33348560333251953,
0.49364498257637024,
-0.27656471729278564,
-0.9056257605552673,
-0.12416879087686539,
-0.18080683052539825,
0.0073988428339362144,
0.11946722865104675,
1.068915843963623,
-0.11371767520904541,
-0.21824347972869873,
0.5229921340942383,
0.5144893527030945,
0.23503153026103973,
-0.3700643479824066,
-0.4462479054927826,
-0.07216989248991013,
-0.307756245136261,
-0.39975810050964355,
0.2942788004875183,
0.5423375964164734,
-0.30918699502944946,
0.7328298091888428,
0.8732694983482361,
-0.13010165095329285,
0.025449438020586967,
0.14124807715415955,
0.864173412322998,
-0.6620570421218872,
-0.38121283054351807,
-0.9058719277381897,
0.3418373167514801,
-0.7126936316490173,
0.07400893419981003,
0.8996787667274475,
0.5316330194473267,
0.7499271631240845,
0.1822451949119568,
0.5306668877601624,
0.06341338902711868,
0.6309391260147095,
-0.814626157283783,
0.1891728937625885,
-0.4206720292568207,
0.34198328852653503,
-0.14188414812088013,
-0.837984025478363,
-0.06754584610462189,
0.6393496990203857,
-0.4651362895965576,
0.1108456701040268,
1.0700103044509888,
1.0037480592727661,
-0.19646480679512024,
0.24183185398578644,
0.02576371841132641,
0.14364637434482574,
0.3674898147583008,
0.7792341709136963,
1.0817391872406006,
-0.26797404885292053,
0.5037155151367188,
-0.0690135508775711,
-0.19615697860717773,
-0.26686331629753113,
-1.1078513860702515,
-1.2575196027755737,
-0.07583681493997574,
-0.1329546868801117,
-0.4052850604057312,
-0.07428772747516632,
0.5141306519508362,
0.8705337643623352,
-0.8481668829917908,
-0.07297850400209427,
-0.373050719499588,
0.28418952226638794,
-0.2851090431213379,
-0.28020355105400085,
0.5418350100517273,
-0.29503676295280457,
-0.6403211951255798,
0.8851599097251892,
0.07362179458141327,
-0.170022115111351,
-0.17353463172912598,
0.06188748776912689,
-0.44507119059562683,
-0.06442847847938538,
0.757375180721283,
0.06491701304912567,
-0.6458697319030762,
-0.5276336669921875,
-0.18065296113491058,
-0.041466206312179565,
-0.07533682137727737,
0.8211523294448853,
-0.9164804816246033,
0.41286301612854004,
0.7308574914932251,
0.3673945963382721,
1.0493513345718384,
0.02508207969367504,
0.39193546772003174,
-0.7378302216529846,
0.35299086570739746,
0.040030159056186676,
0.7692028880119324,
0.0263028834015131,
-0.37896183133125305,
0.8433453440666199,
0.056523747742176056,
-0.6174505352973938,
-0.6933092474937439,
0.18252652883529663,
-0.9134371876716614,
-0.7792912721633911,
1.0439400672912598,
-0.15691152215003967,
-0.17243191599845886,
-0.47741037607192993,
-0.26388561725616455,
0.0753595158457756,
-0.39454221725463867,
0.5097547173500061,
0.9458786249160767,
-0.2657036781311035,
-0.2950042188167572,
-0.5995340943336487,
0.4291844367980957,
0.5409305095672607,
-0.8602107167243958,
-0.15603895485401154,
0.742183268070221,
0.5790818929672241,
0.29522401094436646,
0.49286365509033203,
-0.07511026412248611,
0.4654301702976227,
0.16298002004623413,
-0.23382891714572906,
-0.26177018880844116,
-0.11835642904043198,
-0.21881534159183502,
0.3208986818790436,
-0.09173386543989182,
0.12593381106853485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12639v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12639v1 | Ask-before-Plan: Proactive Language Agents for Real-World Planning | 2024-06-18T14:07:28 | 2024-06-18T14:07:28 | Xuan Zhang, Yang Deng, Zifeng Ren, See-Kiong Ng, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The evolution of large language models (LLMs) has enhanced the planning
capabilities of language agents in diverse real-world scenarios. Despite these
advancements, the potential of LLM-powered agents to comprehend ambiguous user
instructions for reasoning and decision-making is still under exploration. In
this work, we introduce a new task, Proactive Agent Planning, which requires
language agents to predict clarification needs based on user-agent conversation
and agent-environment interaction, invoke external tools to collect valid
information, and generate a plan to fulfill the user's demands. To study this
practical problem, we establish a new benchmark dataset, Ask-before-Plan. To
tackle the deficiency of LLMs in proactive planning, we propose a novel
multi-agent framework, Clarification-Execution-Planning (\texttt{CEP}), which
consists of three agents specialized in clarification, execution, and planning.
We introduce the trajectory tuning scheme for the clarification agent and
static execution agent, as well as the memory recollection mechanism for the
dynamic execution agent. Extensive evaluations and comprehensive analyses
conducted on the Ask-before-Plan dataset validate the effectiveness of our
proposed framework. | [
-0.6962910890579224,
-0.9314359426498413,
0.7567296624183655,
0.10798092186450958,
0.0759713351726532,
-0.02436375617980957,
-0.32661697268486023,
-0.3226899802684784,
0.20046953856945038,
0.6832194924354553,
-1.234880805015564,
-0.2687370479106903,
-0.057311560958623886,
-0.26083070039749146,
-0.03852822631597519,
0.5692633390426636,
-0.13322903215885162,
-0.19656077027320862,
0.0747382864356041,
-0.08824923634529114,
-0.6580970883369446,
-0.2306404709815979,
-0.5341008901596069,
-0.31265953183174133,
0.5347594022750854,
0.7987426519393921,
0.9695386290550232,
0.289935827255249,
0.25530505180358887,
0.35033899545669556,
0.1381017118692398,
0.5616766810417175,
-0.16916319727897644,
0.3843788206577301,
-0.2507328391075134,
-0.26227617263793945,
-0.6579039096832275,
-0.34448501467704773,
0.5180079340934753,
0.37590187788009644,
-0.15306240320205688,
0.1502823382616043,
-0.4102875590324402,
0.24864892661571503,
-0.900971531867981,
0.19528473913669586,
-0.6231517791748047,
-0.019658619537949562,
0.028935788199305534,
-0.18661870062351227,
-0.2789137661457062,
-0.20393280684947968,
0.04175804555416107,
-0.7487276792526245,
0.0374164842069149,
-0.2989793121814728,
0.7159159183502197,
0.37566912174224854,
-0.11982487142086029,
-0.22932295501232147,
-0.8457021713256836,
0.3844110071659088,
-0.4467911720275879,
0.2983122169971466,
0.1386812925338745,
0.6633544564247131,
-0.42190098762512207,
-0.7586718201637268,
-0.8067110776901245,
-0.14519870281219482,
-0.08900965005159378,
0.05015157163143158,
0.07094555348157883,
0.11209841072559357,
0.22277750074863434,
-0.2598693072795868,
-0.700125515460968,
-0.022159462794661522,
0.12393601983785629,
-0.11105901747941971,
0.6018968224525452,
0.12668929994106293,
-0.07295151054859161,
0.47546881437301636,
-0.386017382144928,
0.005111785605549812,
-0.7886765599250793,
-0.12287234514951706,
0.23354285955429077,
0.2548365294933319,
0.17380940914154053,
0.32465317845344543,
-0.5032870173454285,
0.5097976922988892,
-0.2025100290775299,
0.27666452527046204,
-0.043455105274915695,
-0.4287060499191284,
-0.041312847286462784,
-0.23803499341011047,
0.33069685101509094,
0.22229325771331787,
0.7341719269752502,
-0.03403650224208832,
-0.21888667345046997,
-0.012935693375766277,
0.2742322087287903,
-0.7497445940971375,
-0.01435136515647173,
0.4226871728897095,
0.01256539672613144,
0.1257256120443344,
-0.20643365383148193,
-0.6781740784645081,
-0.24466125667095184,
-0.41149118542671204,
0.37165433168411255,
-0.29402703046798706,
-0.525231122970581,
0.2321997582912445,
0.2283591628074646,
0.3482522666454315,
0.3099948465824127,
-0.46538451313972473,
0.31640100479125977,
0.6639158129692078,
0.30669310688972473,
0.3985917866230011,
-0.6260358691215515,
-0.5248594880104065,
0.2513059377670288,
-0.23724687099456787,
1.1321085691452026,
-0.5592254996299744,
-0.3513907194137573,
0.21544571220874786,
-0.11921433359384537,
-0.058410316705703735,
-0.3956456780433655,
0.4600248336791992,
-0.6169323921203613,
-0.016366632655262947,
-0.5960192680358887,
-0.2386033684015274,
-0.10945428907871246,
0.5713228583335876,
-0.45621874928474426,
0.7459887266159058,
-0.10598239302635193,
-0.3376901149749756,
0.5356312990188599,
-0.7787168622016907,
-0.31780970096588135,
0.42148005962371826,
-0.34050697088241577,
-0.17135286331176758,
-0.3207060694694519,
0.3903255760669708,
0.4002128839492798,
-0.15051060914993286,
0.34048229455947876,
-0.04858093336224556,
-0.3249532878398895,
0.11403613537549973,
-0.06988765299320221,
0.3274671137332916,
0.34381356835365295,
-0.30011993646621704,
0.5683532357215881,
-0.5671036839485168,
0.5270918011665344,
0.11706828325986862,
-0.1382049173116684,
0.2901860773563385,
0.3062465190887451,
-0.3816244602203369,
0.36972951889038086,
0.5409381985664368,
-0.09208233654499054,
0.2288612276315689,
-0.36166927218437195,
0.13700349628925323,
0.668983519077301,
0.14524737000465393,
0.32075515389442444,
-0.48753276467323303,
0.8325312733650208,
-0.4071756601333618,
0.4300755560398102,
-0.3543149530887604,
-0.2947956919670105,
-0.487701416015625,
0.120522640645504,
-0.18380600214004517,
0.8215615153312683,
-0.726269006729126,
0.2637045383453369,
-0.14957702159881592,
-0.5477641224861145,
-0.14666993916034698,
-0.1696566641330719,
0.5970110893249512,
0.32043343782424927,
0.5145217180252075,
0.18119016289710999,
-0.5110294818878174,
-0.7271972894668579,
-0.40456828474998474,
-0.3417409658432007,
0.20113453269004822,
0.14211775362491608,
0.35932794213294983,
-0.23178435862064362,
1.0252615213394165,
-0.5295355319976807,
-0.11600254476070404,
-0.7969600558280945,
0.03160518780350685,
-0.007161176763474941,
0.16489450633525848,
0.3096895217895508,
-0.9178683161735535,
-0.3841111958026886,
-0.2730166018009186,
-0.1512315571308136,
-0.2902906537055969,
-0.2773491442203522,
-0.13498304784297943,
-0.1673915833234787,
0.4321279525756836,
-0.9453259110450745,
0.23404154181480408,
0.313720166683197,
-0.3193710446357727,
0.8207998275756836,
-0.5076526403427124,
-0.1723029911518097,
-0.7540225982666016,
0.11367940902709961,
-0.3396681249141693,
-0.17877955734729767,
-0.769707441329956,
0.2816688120365143,
0.12699764966964722,
-0.10085666924715042,
-0.6519154906272888,
0.9947500228881836,
-0.5213908553123474,
-0.03927907347679138,
-0.4839603006839752,
0.26262447237968445,
-0.17885993421077728,
0.6506153345108032,
0.29931411147117615,
0.8443222641944885,
0.32650306820869446,
-0.860191822052002,
0.0794302374124527,
0.26615652441978455,
-0.002145787701010704,
0.2439093291759491,
-0.4330504834651947,
0.11529169976711273,
-0.12055335193872452,
0.3980661630630493,
-0.5874208211898804,
-0.1671602725982666,
0.3106059432029724,
-0.21999721229076385,
0.026892557740211487,
-0.10339457541704178,
-0.5057250261306763,
-0.3309967815876007,
-0.15005505084991455,
0.28820309042930603,
0.23715372383594513,
-0.28838372230529785,
0.7066113352775574,
0.38273024559020996,
-0.17341198027133942,
-0.6373034715652466,
-0.2540516257286072,
-0.12990064918994904,
-0.024592595174908638,
-0.7485193610191345,
0.5177101492881775,
-0.1940634846687317,
-0.43156886100769043,
-0.13095951080322266,
-0.17238713800907135,
-0.006079282145947218,
0.11473831534385681,
0.15946687757968903,
-0.09693188965320587,
-0.003903415286913514,
0.122932069003582,
-0.31364381313323975,
-0.30895307660102844,
0.08893949538469315,
-0.04392141476273537,
0.698807954788208,
-0.14484825730323792,
-0.33744317293167114,
-0.22239060699939728,
0.32088178396224976,
0.250488817691803,
-0.5581722855567932,
0.3780812621116638,
0.36765238642692566,
-0.33390653133392334,
-0.3023281991481781,
-0.535704493522644,
-0.22804038226604462,
-0.4991910457611084,
0.2102917730808258,
-0.6934763193130493,
-0.43215954303741455,
0.6658796668052673,
-0.47057992219924927,
0.43507838249206543,
0.12144821137189865,
0.5807143449783325,
0.10897859930992126,
1.1455823183059692,
0.4720820486545563,
0.4627450108528137,
0.49828392267227173,
-0.2948119044303894,
0.03616753965616226,
-0.3477185368537903,
-0.10492060333490372,
-0.44425541162490845,
-0.36320430040359497,
-0.2811703085899353,
-0.5075289011001587,
0.12770865857601166,
-0.11623059958219528,
-0.08805087208747864,
0.5063424706459045,
-0.044638168066740036,
0.598281979560852,
0.3854057192802429,
-0.2946208417415619,
-0.08540509641170502,
-0.4395921528339386,
-0.2147826999425888,
0.26631873846054077,
-0.28401491045951843,
-0.7785142660140991,
0.7771540880203247,
0.04950731247663498,
0.3330274820327759,
0.10146906971931458,
0.39717960357666016,
0.11643993109464645,
0.07672667503356934,
-0.43224677443504333,
1.0310975313186646,
0.2939215898513794,
-0.6978247761726379,
-0.3924628496170044,
-0.048431646078825,
-1.1632943153381348,
0.6066524386405945,
-0.0935121476650238,
-0.7433898448944092,
0.2568030059337616,
0.3590236008167267,
-0.4810471832752228,
-0.047141920775175095,
-0.835403323173523,
1.0831384658813477,
-0.564358651638031,
-0.3708386719226837,
-0.48109766840934753,
-0.6219784617424011,
-0.14017121493816376,
0.08352549374103546,
0.3560146987438202,
-0.5077747702598572,
-0.20524244010448456,
0.24950286746025085,
-0.5691556334495544,
0.3938472270965576,
-0.7633874416351318,
0.04348507151007652,
0.567505419254303,
0.10560950636863708,
0.9649598002433777,
0.07750430703163147,
-0.17452673614025116,
-0.38723257184028625,
0.026331981644034386,
-0.3397112488746643,
-0.49195751547813416,
0.4099506437778473,
-0.3975483179092407,
-0.6805445551872253,
-0.006938370410352945,
-0.37885981798171997,
-0.5055603981018066,
0.37063515186309814,
0.00522414268925786,
0.32964226603507996,
-0.4630625247955322,
-0.27943265438079834,
0.2980384826660156,
-0.06285227835178375,
0.41939446330070496,
1.0425653457641602,
-0.2648559510707855,
0.00875869020819664,
0.6163903474807739,
0.1481446474790573,
0.15019477903842926,
0.47410979866981506,
0.19497941434383392,
-0.4255495071411133,
-0.8333159685134888,
-0.1961597502231598,
0.3353625535964966,
-0.7047231793403625,
0.07595013827085495,
-0.44822564721107483,
0.03593345731496811,
-0.46420159935951233,
-0.23839151859283447,
-0.3067406713962555,
-0.16097064316272736,
0.031498730182647705,
-0.025058217346668243,
-0.07639002054929733,
0.44350966811180115,
0.07224652171134949,
0.5408337116241455,
-0.5835590362548828,
0.30704787373542786,
0.08947534114122391,
-0.0710686668753624,
-0.5270422697067261,
0.06833404302597046,
-0.12589353322982788,
0.08548501878976822,
-0.4725530743598938,
-1.056595802307129,
0.5028245449066162,
0.18681128323078156,
0.9204140305519104,
0.44267967343330383,
0.33755990862846375,
0.7055557370185852,
-0.3799378573894501,
0.5721837282180786,
-0.43738827109336853,
-0.39244434237480164,
0.7847089171409607,
-0.20525191724300385,
0.69572514295578,
0.7518861293792725,
0.28624945878982544,
-0.40488219261169434,
-0.4206081032752991,
-0.7465856671333313,
-0.8696094751358032,
0.7563408017158508,
0.19017572700977325,
-0.09325041621923447,
-0.030405011028051376,
0.3100558817386627,
0.0009088656515814364,
0.23524223268032074,
-0.46472278237342834,
0.04396302253007889,
0.1728956401348114,
0.12148744612932205,
0.008475200273096561,
-0.2685537338256836,
-0.06908532977104187,
0.17820727825164795,
0.5411861538887024,
-0.40509891510009766,
0.20003977417945862,
0.07221633940935135,
-0.3304866552352905,
-0.07847782969474792,
0.5847311615943909,
0.7473961710929871,
1.087204933166504,
-0.20442281663417816,
0.03479352965950966,
0.4485655426979065,
-0.3483137786388397,
0.010041050612926483,
0.2960096001625061,
-0.0017210444202646613,
-0.2375919371843338,
0.2690263092517853,
0.4361914396286011,
0.07989422231912613,
-1.1823207139968872,
0.40068715810775757,
-0.3163148760795593,
-0.27155905961990356,
-0.7109317183494568,
0.3705824613571167,
0.008161664940416813,
0.41570356488227844,
0.05206761509180069,
-0.060726553201675415,
-0.1388750672340393,
-0.44388890266418457,
0.08955177664756775,
0.31264904141426086,
-0.3138899803161621,
-0.4680432975292206,
0.37573546171188354,
0.1751401275396347,
-0.5532997250556946,
0.3208619952201843,
-0.520601212978363,
-0.45757296681404114,
0.6226942539215088,
0.2678055167198181,
0.7693572044372559,
-0.292545348405838,
0.25066426396369934,
0.09983709454536438,
0.2028474062681198,
0.022390859201550484,
1.0773791074752808,
-0.23629291355609894,
-0.8817949295043945,
-0.5237357020378113,
-0.297506719827652,
-0.4626294672489166,
0.13308069109916687,
-0.03958890214562416,
0.5360122323036194,
-0.48583996295928955,
-0.2413116991519928,
-0.32831841707229614,
0.2867034673690796,
-0.6829763054847717,
0.1681608110666275,
-0.11878938227891922,
1.0055856704711914,
-0.461518794298172,
0.9090905785560608,
0.8594552874565125,
-0.276125967502594,
-0.7034356594085693,
0.23827707767486572,
-0.04113791137933731,
-0.7454957962036133,
0.31694111227989197,
0.3199675381183624,
-0.3782922029495239,
-0.07760635018348694,
-0.14817684888839722,
-0.8643152117729187,
1.017311692237854,
0.4233103394508362,
-0.7176996469497681,
-0.3193773627281189,
0.05635375529527664,
0.4703991711139679,
-0.24792997539043427,
0.43686050176620483,
0.5974029302597046,
0.7927128076553345,
0.1920536756515503,
-0.6979708671569824,
0.12889084219932556,
-0.07272161543369293,
-0.6177489757537842,
0.4897085428237915,
-0.599643349647522,
0.7245602607727051,
-0.4399194121360779,
-0.41842082142829895,
-0.06736268848180771,
0.425778865814209,
0.32460033893585205,
0.36167827248573303,
0.7062640190124512,
0.24833934009075165,
0.7267460823059082,
0.09254048764705658,
0.8523457646369934,
-0.41740748286247253,
-0.27011120319366455,
1.4061579704284668,
-0.5239717960357666,
0.8787646889686584,
0.12485270947217941,
-0.012081963941454887,
0.2968527376651764,
0.4793565571308136,
0.44653016328811646,
0.5227043032646179,
0.15435349941253662,
-0.27104106545448303,
-0.4904688894748688,
0.08567448705434799,
-0.31225404143333435,
0.39467406272888184,
0.6124270558357239,
0.16141033172607422,
-0.41343027353286743,
-0.2408553510904312,
0.16651016473770142,
0.20896269381046295,
-0.10670570284128189,
0.7723578214645386,
-0.3492974042892456,
-1.1287201642990112,
0.31408238410949707,
0.00320156617090106,
0.2131769359111786,
-0.8508679270744324,
0.09526870399713516,
-0.04730730876326561,
0.48461148142814636,
0.0453965850174427,
-0.8491605520248413,
0.44648826122283936,
-0.2956298589706421,
0.17359130084514618,
-0.5351771116256714,
0.8126833438873291,
-0.2630595862865448,
0.02819664590060711,
0.39576494693756104,
0.5473050475120544,
0.12426797300577164,
-0.496630996465683,
-1.0241187810897827,
-0.194050133228302,
-0.26559093594551086,
-0.3466976284980774,
0.06699717789888382,
0.42854297161102295,
-0.4143611192703247,
0.8411425948143005,
0.5069848895072937,
0.24896004796028137,
-0.013185620307922363,
0.13870418071746826,
0.8734902143478394,
-0.44523686170578003,
-0.6734603047370911,
-0.6898220181465149,
0.4460503160953522,
0.018221618607640266,
-0.2699924409389496,
0.41073259711265564,
0.4450904428958893,
0.7420403957366943,
0.31003183126449585,
0.3914290964603424,
0.1634267121553421,
0.6195084452629089,
-0.46982133388519287,
0.20990340411663055,
-0.3884786367416382,
0.3817684054374695,
0.09100291877985,
-0.835679292678833,
-0.11169365793466568,
0.4650951325893402,
-0.5491465926170349,
0.08188825845718384,
0.5465951561927795,
1.0041254758834839,
0.24624235928058624,
0.025155941024422646,
0.13394179940223694,
-0.136531800031662,
0.7430372834205627,
0.5361307859420776,
1.0246258974075317,
0.22780077159404755,
0.7587467432022095,
-0.02291898801922798,
-0.0531889908015728,
-0.3617364466190338,
-0.8119982481002808,
-0.5791386961936951,
-0.5143312811851501,
-0.18714876472949982,
0.2752339243888855,
0.30127885937690735,
1.0249806642532349,
0.8741858601570129,
-0.5512236952781677,
-0.1138775646686554,
-0.46814000606536865,
0.15694770216941833,
-0.5373772978782654,
-0.12389940768480301,
0.10682220757007599,
-0.5702874660491943,
-0.39535602927207947,
0.845255434513092,
0.07234160602092743,
-0.0895460918545723,
-0.3544028103351593,
-0.4172144830226898,
-0.41718074679374695,
0.2891586124897003,
0.27677980065345764,
0.6292972564697266,
-0.7138500809669495,
-0.0871398076415062,
-0.11953166127204895,
0.26602327823638916,
-0.19088329374790192,
1.160825252532959,
-0.8645138740539551,
0.4461779296398163,
0.47919443249702454,
0.3780868947505951,
0.45057106018066406,
0.09020758420228958,
0.7531484365463257,
-0.9247422814369202,
0.3183039724826813,
0.47526249289512634,
0.23449286818504333,
-0.17890241742134094,
-0.35304680466651917,
0.35674571990966797,
-0.2246900349855423,
-0.7436744570732117,
-0.4198164939880371,
0.6163076162338257,
-0.5492507219314575,
-0.6264650225639343,
1.115119457244873,
-0.0056829568929970264,
0.007200946565717459,
-0.3507991135120392,
-0.6325134634971619,
0.06870933622121811,
-0.4068446755409241,
0.3179090917110443,
0.451801061630249,
-0.4037041962146759,
-0.34308069944381714,
-0.48951855301856995,
0.6300360560417175,
0.4075564444065094,
-0.9358792304992676,
0.38489532470703125,
0.6539378762245178,
-0.2208651751279831,
0.12332237511873245,
1.118231177330017,
0.2441239207983017,
0.2798176407814026,
-0.13422651588916779,
-0.051039308309555054,
-0.1969091147184372,
-0.8002470135688782,
0.2436562329530716,
0.3213360011577606,
0.43529027700424194,
-0.17002570629119873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19413v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19413v1 | Saliency Attention and Semantic Similarity-Driven Adversarial Perturbation | 2024-06-18T14:07:27 | 2024-06-18T14:07:27 | Hetvi Waghela, Jaydip Sen, Sneha Rakshit | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | In this paper, we introduce an enhanced textual adversarial attack method,
known as Saliency Attention and Semantic Similarity driven adversarial
Perturbation (SASSP). The proposed scheme is designed to improve the
effectiveness of contextual perturbations by integrating saliency, attention,
and semantic similarity. Traditional adversarial attack methods often struggle
to maintain semantic consistency and coherence while effectively deceiving
target models. Our proposed approach addresses these challenges by
incorporating a three-pronged strategy for word selection and perturbation.
First, we utilize a saliency-based word selection to prioritize words for
modification based on their importance to the model's prediction. Second,
attention mechanisms are employed to focus perturbations on contextually
significant words, enhancing the attack's efficacy. Finally, an advanced
semantic similarity-checking method is employed that includes embedding-based
similarity and paraphrase detection. By leveraging models like Sentence-BERT
for embedding similarity and fine-tuned paraphrase detection models from the
Sentence Transformers library, the scheme ensures that the perturbed text
remains contextually appropriate and semantically consistent with the original.
Empirical evaluations demonstrate that SASSP generates adversarial examples
that not only maintain high semantic fidelity but also effectively deceive
state-of-the-art natural language processing models. Moreover, in comparison to
the original scheme of contextual perturbation CLARE, SASSP has yielded a
higher attack success rate and lower word perturbation rate. | [
-0.539686381816864,
-1.0036042928695679,
0.3948233723640442,
0.38071906566619873,
-0.4655584394931793,
-0.24119801819324493,
-0.11062357574701309,
-0.0742112323641777,
0.35969439148902893,
0.9708014130592346,
-0.6444031596183777,
-0.499019980430603,
-0.7622128129005432,
0.1279752254486084,
-0.7178218364715576,
1.0459436178207397,
0.3674235939979553,
-0.01784762367606163,
-0.1699841022491455,
0.10527636110782623,
-0.2348671704530716,
-0.6397673487663269,
-0.48834407329559326,
0.04613543301820755,
0.5817000865936279,
0.1512395590543747,
1.023166537284851,
0.3671024441719055,
0.9855026006698608,
0.30064842104911804,
-0.3902302384376526,
-0.1599297970533371,
-0.6488662958145142,
0.3690997064113617,
-0.13718506693840027,
-0.3425557017326355,
-0.003162386827170849,
-0.06074602156877518,
0.6720293760299683,
0.2157837450504303,
0.32452893257141113,
-0.1490456610918045,
0.20490488409996033,
0.536858081817627,
-0.869440495967865,
-0.3183823227882385,
-1.066680669784546,
-0.019756536930799484,
-0.27227264642715454,
-0.258646160364151,
-0.3594970703125,
-0.13227716088294983,
0.18560180068016052,
-0.46897438168525696,
0.3550994098186493,
-0.10485271364450455,
1.04021418094635,
0.6682681441307068,
-0.06339243054389954,
-0.12521213293075562,
-0.24510620534420013,
0.7711561322212219,
-0.5854975581169128,
0.03488554432988167,
0.2459707111120224,
0.22278837859630585,
-0.3754117488861084,
-0.7759189009666443,
-0.49461600184440613,
-0.46077874302864075,
-0.0984703004360199,
0.14765077829360962,
-0.24308115243911743,
0.014564940705895424,
0.4462016820907593,
0.16436651349067688,
-0.45139285922050476,
-0.20858001708984375,
0.11730963736772537,
-0.17877574265003204,
0.3135545253753662,
-0.00035500526428222656,
0.31622064113616943,
-0.2983747720718384,
-1.0973516702651978,
-0.3574341833591461,
-0.6512641310691833,
-0.28853532671928406,
0.4056491255760193,
0.06812088191509247,
0.10283840447664261,
0.516004204750061,
-0.3627128303050995,
0.5200186371803284,
0.05872505158185959,
0.3131275773048401,
-0.14886708557605743,
-0.36740565299987793,
-0.17685993015766144,
0.14558136463165283,
0.6422688961029053,
0.34175577759742737,
0.10971898585557938,
-0.18750497698783875,
-0.1533484011888504,
0.338952898979187,
0.5388288497924805,
-0.5111026763916016,
-0.3656499981880188,
0.006961334031075239,
-0.07915636152029037,
-0.6319757699966431,
-0.03709877282381058,
-1.1256839036941528,
-0.5372998118400574,
-0.09250380098819733,
0.6191245913505554,
-0.7692362070083618,
0.312600702047348,
-0.04222467169165611,
-0.3261410892009735,
0.163580521941185,
0.14854133129119873,
-0.8949905037879944,
0.4518258571624756,
0.8125680088996887,
0.6743179559707642,
-0.2328471690416336,
-0.44172966480255127,
-0.5293245911598206,
0.4517967998981476,
-0.17413312196731567,
0.9892910718917847,
-0.6642159223556519,
-0.17744076251983643,
-0.29420438408851624,
-0.41032156348228455,
-0.027381323277950287,
-0.1989576518535614,
0.5442635416984558,
-0.6865161657333374,
0.13726156949996948,
-0.40061086416244507,
-0.22858645021915436,
-0.15812495350837708,
0.39487916231155396,
-0.6966404914855957,
0.9322956204414368,
-0.055070314556360245,
-1.17116117477417,
0.17921048402786255,
-0.8199606537818909,
-0.41687607765197754,
0.05370710417628288,
0.034444522112607956,
-0.5541902780532837,
0.05954669043421745,
0.5127237439155579,
0.4042249917984009,
-0.1599634289741516,
-0.2968742251396179,
-0.34497663378715515,
-0.5251809358596802,
0.2910258173942566,
-0.5170527100563049,
0.46890988945961,
0.04012862965464592,
-0.5730423927307129,
0.4333643615245819,
-0.5268369317054749,
-0.03782157972455025,
0.24491924047470093,
0.20128744840621948,
-0.6686751842498779,
0.0004075248434673995,
0.04152534157037735,
-0.015058445744216442,
0.4821164309978485,
-0.4785424768924713,
-0.12826164066791534,
-0.7896172404289246,
0.16880761086940765,
0.5675013661384583,
0.4491254389286041,
0.3139649033546448,
-0.04761600121855736,
0.24848192930221558,
-0.26539406180381775,
0.3118964433670044,
-0.08783601969480515,
-0.20004180073738098,
-0.6932845115661621,
-0.5105931758880615,
0.3554723262786865,
0.2997466027736664,
-0.7330595850944519,
0.25401028990745544,
-0.09145162254571915,
-0.31215691566467285,
-0.47064486145973206,
-0.10046648979187012,
0.4983304440975189,
0.3261614739894867,
0.6620621681213379,
-0.1365668773651123,
-0.47207605838775635,
-1.010789155960083,
-0.6217728853225708,
0.08033381402492523,
0.08782300353050232,
-0.03707833215594292,
0.4465358555316925,
-0.2211354523897171,
0.6064794063568115,
-0.697073221206665,
-0.35350432991981506,
0.01718171313405037,
0.03933028131723404,
-0.33234506845474243,
0.2171649932861328,
0.9054050445556641,
-1.145599603652954,
-0.5171006917953491,
-0.2602643072605133,
-0.3482624292373657,
-0.13336728513240814,
-0.08695545792579651,
-0.38980230689048767,
-0.03438395634293556,
0.4464752972126007,
-0.35531413555145264,
0.4870145320892334,
0.2512245774269104,
-0.4152847230434418,
0.3569672107696533,
0.021700087934732437,
0.44772908091545105,
-1.0009595155715942,
0.024033769965171814,
-0.19075727462768555,
-0.16614249348640442,
-0.7197680473327637,
0.4999192953109741,
-0.010190106928348541,
-0.22336100041866302,
-0.5970081090927124,
0.3279155492782593,
-0.21085108816623688,
-0.15087898075580597,
-0.4702262282371521,
0.3367164433002472,
-0.10713960230350494,
0.4622761309146881,
-0.1412191241979599,
0.6116781234741211,
0.42523881793022156,
-0.5261139273643494,
0.5460492968559265,
0.42107224464416504,
0.15649452805519104,
0.7268907427787781,
-0.688552737236023,
0.05424462631344795,
-0.11251896619796753,
0.08043815940618515,
-1.1384923458099365,
-0.2079744189977646,
0.20935440063476562,
-0.6439946889877319,
0.16429650783538818,
0.2640897333621979,
-0.3880119323730469,
-0.08615896850824356,
-0.7066823840141296,
-0.19766680896282196,
0.1451607346534729,
-0.5605461597442627,
0.5217280387878418,
0.01773759350180626,
-0.2044098675251007,
-0.7460959553718567,
-0.7836270332336426,
0.4596141278743744,
-0.29038000106811523,
-0.43307411670684814,
0.4518556296825409,
0.07884343713521957,
-0.13380619883537292,
0.01571093685925007,
0.009694165550172329,
0.18185372650623322,
0.4400680661201477,
0.055320072919130325,
0.07490123063325882,
0.12614767253398895,
-0.14785949885845184,
-0.015056236647069454,
-0.13693839311599731,
-0.02746993862092495,
0.004799403250217438,
0.755856454372406,
0.013259723782539368,
-0.46606501936912537,
-0.6119982004165649,
0.4709913432598114,
0.6707932949066162,
-0.30406585335731506,
0.5683422088623047,
0.8111594319343567,
-0.2988482415676117,
0.15859414637088776,
-0.6667830944061279,
-0.4051784873008728,
-0.470161497592926,
0.6260064244270325,
-0.4337194859981537,
-0.6648600697517395,
0.23506313562393188,
0.2424478679895401,
-0.07371494919061661,
0.42856863141059875,
0.43849343061447144,
-0.09559504687786102,
0.8919591307640076,
0.4568824768066406,
-0.17352081835269928,
0.6133485436439514,
-0.06403826922178268,
-0.22224684059619904,
-0.9169579148292542,
-0.10610774904489517,
-0.5523241758346558,
-0.3815290927886963,
-0.20134587585926056,
-0.14999008178710938,
0.20548029243946075,
-0.12755320966243744,
-0.4433198869228363,
0.6440386176109314,
-0.5348916053771973,
0.3189447224140167,
0.4830186665058136,
0.2838670611381531,
-0.0791798084974289,
0.3937954306602478,
-0.26070159673690796,
-0.4219062030315399,
-0.5099576115608215,
-0.44063660502433777,
0.8719497919082642,
0.18420973420143127,
0.6854456067085266,
0.267253577709198,
0.7059223651885986,
0.47466903924942017,
0.03205230459570885,
-0.3347623944282532,
0.8700822591781616,
-0.3894976079463959,
-0.13092918694019318,
-0.2009708434343338,
-0.1533534973859787,
-0.8270675539970398,
0.4036083519458771,
-0.442569375038147,
-0.7880173921585083,
0.06322208046913147,
-0.0023719503078609705,
-0.25802767276763916,
0.13021083176136017,
-0.5472546815872192,
0.7758491039276123,
-0.1274716705083847,
-0.43744271993637085,
-0.3955531418323517,
-0.6875138878822327,
0.10356436669826508,
-0.0066573950462043285,
-0.20944613218307495,
0.1905226856470108,
-0.461652547121048,
0.4718468487262726,
-0.14619022607803345,
0.8245892524719238,
-0.019893823191523552,
0.05921591818332672,
-0.07014436274766922,
0.05009043216705322,
0.7338213920593262,
-0.07601073384284973,
-0.06561286002397537,
-0.15061436593532562,
-0.21877369284629822,
-0.5635181069374084,
-0.8921718597412109,
1.0420606136322021,
-0.6074910759925842,
-0.933198869228363,
-0.35554224252700806,
-0.47250309586524963,
-0.22229424118995667,
0.1508987545967102,
0.3016310930252075,
0.33527687191963196,
-0.27372628450393677,
0.40542566776275635,
0.7840116620063782,
0.058274026960134506,
0.42153283953666687,
0.40946683287620544,
0.28123900294303894,
-0.7202980518341064,
0.7896355986595154,
-0.3283807635307312,
0.6364656686782837,
0.6127172112464905,
-0.044374484568834305,
-0.2459631711244583,
-0.42687132954597473,
-0.13133765757083893,
0.0727178156375885,
-0.715408980846405,
-0.1838793307542801,
-0.7922993898391724,
-0.011298966594040394,
-0.6767171621322632,
-0.26346826553344727,
-0.09775861352682114,
-0.15755756199359894,
-0.36219850182533264,
0.5071756839752197,
0.4591999650001526,
0.4749077558517456,
0.3683014214038849,
0.44508105516433716,
-0.381500244140625,
0.4874716103076935,
0.22432400286197662,
0.033890850841999054,
-0.19812457263469696,
-0.5317409634590149,
0.0624089315533638,
0.09521962702274323,
-0.3709295094013214,
-1.2254788875579834,
0.3010116517543793,
0.01650720089673996,
0.5575840473175049,
0.37513428926467896,
0.28037789463996887,
0.5199944972991943,
-0.29288503527641296,
0.9845343828201294,
0.13671819865703583,
-0.878399133682251,
0.7558124661445618,
-0.16769567131996155,
0.5963009595870972,
0.6519625186920166,
0.29041817784309387,
-0.20792719721794128,
-0.6285359859466553,
-0.7799202799797058,
-0.7091299295425415,
0.5467702746391296,
0.527228593826294,
-0.06128721311688423,
0.009903916157782078,
0.2821696698665619,
-0.3439192473888397,
0.24513189494609833,
-0.47829270362854004,
-0.1643521934747696,
-0.24858152866363525,
-0.2511383593082428,
0.0059268358163535595,
-0.3338589370250702,
-0.0416112020611763,
0.3411588668823242,
0.7574390172958374,
-0.03735179826617241,
0.1818842589855194,
0.43639811873435974,
-0.07968834787607193,
0.17409151792526245,
0.28388556838035583,
0.5163111686706543,
0.046831414103507996,
0.07912153750658035,
0.22639930248260498,
0.5013405680656433,
-0.8377746939659119,
-0.04174420237541199,
0.30460214614868164,
-0.4302513897418976,
-0.04664372652769089,
0.19821374118328094,
0.861412763595581,
0.7188274264335632,
-0.4805053770542145,
0.5881969928741455,
-0.1307687908411026,
-0.013710793107748032,
-0.01558834407478571,
0.08184682577848434,
-0.19885718822479248,
0.47314146161079407,
0.3402615189552307,
0.2688884437084198,
0.24811753630638123,
-0.3365439176559448,
0.33759933710098267,
0.7387611865997314,
-0.6348056793212891,
0.04027872905135155,
0.6446081399917603,
-0.07611765712499619,
-0.21311824023723602,
-0.06551939994096756,
0.16997738182544708,
-1.1602997779846191,
0.6147221326828003,
0.5481925010681152,
0.7669122815132141,
-0.3685888648033142,
-0.03574196621775627,
-0.07472296804189682,
0.4627894163131714,
0.06780929863452911,
0.1814773678779602,
-0.1945839822292328,
-0.22798356413841248,
-0.030112771317362785,
-0.5238692760467529,
-0.3685738444328308,
0.2627798318862915,
-0.5757180452346802,
0.5343503952026367,
-0.6071835160255432,
-0.07772192358970642,
-0.006081586703658104,
0.15616239607334137,
-0.12740308046340942,
0.5752308964729309,
0.015358195640146732,
0.5024182200431824,
-0.6430298089981079,
0.4884569048881531,
0.9280781745910645,
-0.48687684535980225,
-0.2560412287712097,
0.6583655476570129,
-0.049221526831388474,
-0.3301575779914856,
0.45363566279411316,
-0.0357777401804924,
-0.3161700963973999,
0.08981136977672577,
-0.5258097648620605,
-1.1124966144561768,
0.8640111684799194,
0.47468650341033936,
-0.27035486698150635,
0.12571683526039124,
-0.09060526639223099,
0.5374522805213928,
-0.07453418523073196,
-0.012535646557807922,
0.49625974893569946,
0.3959125876426697,
0.24438153207302094,
-0.3050800859928131,
0.26148268580436707,
0.018832266330718994,
0.20004521310329437,
0.24811211228370667,
-0.7107177376747131,
0.5265375375747681,
0.02359503135085106,
-0.3193955421447754,
0.29892224073410034,
0.9899365305900574,
0.10611920058727264,
-0.07420872151851654,
0.4809817671775818,
0.5837797522544861,
0.25596052408218384,
-0.05069167912006378,
1.0049937963485718,
-0.37637388706207275,
0.1654210090637207,
0.9965456128120422,
-0.2427157163619995,
1.0150840282440186,
0.5526295900344849,
-0.06343451887369156,
0.2787526249885559,
0.3796161413192749,
-0.18983903527259827,
0.8655456304550171,
0.03288517892360687,
-0.2559424340724945,
-0.1246151328086853,
0.0026406024117022753,
-0.4416784644126892,
0.35763517022132874,
0.43220919370651245,
-0.4014317989349365,
-0.2540549337863922,
0.3122817277908325,
-0.04112382233142853,
0.5758845806121826,
-0.1940678358078003,
0.8886373043060303,
-0.27647602558135986,
-0.5645374059677124,
0.6553936004638672,
-0.03302827477455139,
0.7160800695419312,
-0.8543509840965271,
0.10931112617254257,
0.2450600415468216,
0.3316289484500885,
-0.05612744018435478,
-0.5626197457313538,
0.2609592378139496,
0.0011663982877507806,
-0.24108073115348816,
0.22504925727844238,
1.0627520084381104,
-0.38052910566329956,
-0.17062371969223022,
0.3224097192287445,
-0.37254518270492554,
0.010170620866119862,
-0.2949380576610565,
-0.7556145191192627,
0.13059569895267487,
0.1646382212638855,
-0.1744280606508255,
0.5052914023399353,
0.11445613950490952,
0.12900976836681366,
0.46945369243621826,
0.5253039002418518,
0.17230333387851715,
-0.14537380635738373,
0.012509012594819069,
1.052459478378296,
-0.38175737857818604,
-0.7425182461738586,
-0.920940101146698,
-0.040887534618377686,
-0.5884318351745605,
-0.23966345191001892,
1.031912922859192,
0.2767242193222046,
0.36975082755088806,
0.007038923446089029,
0.6588169932365417,
0.30538687109947205,
0.4713563919067383,
-0.45950859785079956,
0.7535150647163391,
-0.37746667861938477,
0.34729573130607605,
-0.745543897151947,
-0.8844099640846252,
-0.4833287298679352,
0.46515077352523804,
-0.6316468715667725,
-0.16647253930568695,
0.7853822112083435,
0.8682534098625183,
0.16418251395225525,
0.27613863348960876,
0.3835907578468323,
0.2516691982746124,
0.032597947865724564,
0.468093603849411,
0.5947582125663757,
-0.5919029712677002,
0.6478822827339172,
-0.0388566218316555,
-0.31582608819007874,
-0.2829330265522003,
-0.7421944737434387,
-0.9195799231529236,
-0.4214192032814026,
-0.28871941566467285,
-0.381645143032074,
0.7127969861030579,
0.5846211910247803,
0.13434818387031555,
-0.7789779305458069,
0.512467086315155,
-0.033440325409173965,
-0.07063295692205429,
-0.2463587522506714,
-0.24708692729473114,
0.5721648931503296,
-0.5440405607223511,
-0.6176618337631226,
0.3727774918079376,
0.4184304177761078,
0.0482930950820446,
-0.42887216806411743,
0.3286410868167877,
-0.6389992237091064,
0.30777937173843384,
0.4111188054084778,
-0.08933324366807938,
-0.8096252083778381,
-0.24961383640766144,
-0.11505080759525299,
-0.46498167514801025,
-0.3266443908214569,
0.5537934303283691,
-0.7726094126701355,
0.22069667279720306,
0.4430018961429596,
0.8347259759902954,
0.25423455238342285,
0.26241520047187805,
0.36847561597824097,
-0.8330788612365723,
0.29461702704429626,
0.32007700204849243,
0.18326348066329956,
0.5405664443969727,
-0.6973462104797363,
0.20895344018936157,
0.23629553616046906,
-0.3045859932899475,
-0.6657778024673462,
0.440183162689209,
-0.6093471646308899,
-0.5008660554885864,
1.2496062517166138,
-0.21357198059558868,
-0.4067079424858093,
-0.05461440607905388,
-0.5240015983581543,
0.1458573341369629,
-0.31437554955482483,
0.611082911491394,
0.5152339935302734,
0.24269196391105652,
0.22884000837802887,
-0.012870626524090767,
0.6713704466819763,
0.8369482755661011,
-0.5985352396965027,
0.011095847003161907,
0.25798043608665466,
0.05061616003513336,
0.32467013597488403,
-0.10060753673315048,
-0.1921088546514511,
0.5051134824752808,
0.0996779277920723,
-0.21358710527420044,
0.08219438791275024,
-0.2577083110809326,
-0.39005380868911743,
0.5109513998031616,
-0.4124410152435303,
-0.2631615698337555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12629v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12629v1 | SeTAR: Out-of-Distribution Detection with Selective Low-Rank Approximation | 2024-06-18T13:55:13 | 2024-06-18T13:55:13 | Yixia Li, Boya Xiong, Guanhua Chen, Yun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Out-of-distribution (OOD) detection is crucial for the safe deployment of
neural networks. Existing CLIP-based approaches perform OOD detection by
devising novel scoring functions or sophisticated fine-tuning methods. In this
work, we propose SeTAR, a novel, training-free OOD detection method that
leverages selective low-rank approximation of weight matrices in
vision-language and vision-only models. SeTAR enhances OOD detection via
post-hoc modification of the model's weight matrices using a simple greedy
search algorithm. Based on SeTAR, we further propose SeTAR+FT, a fine-tuning
extension optimizing model performance for OOD detection tasks. Extensive
evaluations on ImageNet1K and Pascal-VOC benchmarks show SeTAR's superior
performance, reducing the false positive rate by up to 18.95% and 36.80%
compared to zero-shot and fine-tuning baselines. Ablation studies further
validate our approach's effectiveness, robustness, and generalizability across
different model backbones. Our work offers a scalable, efficient solution for
OOD detection, setting a new state-of-the-art in this area. | [
-0.4905877709388733,
-0.2639363706111908,
0.13187554478645325,
-0.13819178938865662,
-0.5691187381744385,
-0.04696404188871384,
-0.021577179431915283,
-0.3863712549209595,
0.23848867416381836,
0.6601784825325012,
-0.24064980447292328,
-0.13433580100536346,
-0.5500239729881287,
-0.2880440056324005,
-0.3655748963356018,
0.3709525763988495,
0.015779998153448105,
-0.17785099148750305,
0.20715652406215668,
-0.6809595823287964,
-0.42715638875961304,
-0.1820150911808014,
-0.6416293978691101,
-0.39938968420028687,
0.21765144169330597,
0.4643884301185608,
0.6869805455207825,
0.51167231798172,
0.9953266978263855,
0.1404617875814438,
-0.45315155386924744,
0.30834126472473145,
-0.49700722098350525,
-0.12937860190868378,
-0.22360466420650482,
-0.5217427015304565,
-0.47038403153419495,
-0.23582114279270172,
0.7419388890266418,
0.46592918038368225,
-0.2960579991340637,
0.323442280292511,
-0.2940819561481476,
0.8026037216186523,
-1.349998116493225,
-0.5521742105484009,
-0.7284833192825317,
0.3276040852069855,
-0.22356949746608734,
-0.49230438470840454,
-0.46220287680625916,
-0.20488935708999634,
-0.21420469880104065,
-0.4849323332309723,
0.07773375511169434,
0.10575004667043686,
0.7196216583251953,
0.5218952894210815,
-0.07452131062746048,
0.07853544503450394,
-0.5534633994102478,
1.0188767910003662,
-0.6832879781723022,
0.35808297991752625,
0.43884894251823425,
0.7208925485610962,
-0.2124376744031906,
-0.38479599356651306,
-0.4099181592464447,
-0.228492870926857,
0.5362762212753296,
0.12138687074184418,
-0.3571971654891968,
-0.061015792191028595,
0.04392625018954277,
0.3943292200565338,
-0.2024303674697876,
0.1568727344274521,
-0.4538542628288269,
0.2642676532268524,
0.37112104892730713,
-0.29158681631088257,
0.14206156134605408,
0.19429387152194977,
-0.5381526350975037,
-0.15821872651576996,
-0.7017029523849487,
-0.03586670011281967,
0.5416285395622253,
0.284353643655777,
-0.10758677124977112,
0.6264573335647583,
-0.11752810329198837,
0.732772707939148,
0.4275723993778229,
0.11483766883611679,
0.28978222608566284,
-0.1316353976726532,
-0.49017533659935,
0.10205136239528656,
0.6637929081916809,
0.28147730231285095,
-0.07702282816171646,
0.09745504707098007,
-0.5126904249191284,
-0.049971383064985275,
0.22616134583950043,
-0.7055755257606506,
-0.09399239718914032,
0.04681391268968582,
-1.057472825050354,
-0.7834307551383972,
-0.18288631737232208,
-0.8180355429649353,
-0.547957181930542,
0.1794031858444214,
0.6357520818710327,
-0.44719749689102173,
-0.46855640411376953,
0.28757745027542114,
-0.3440287113189697,
0.160753533244133,
0.17689867317676544,
-0.6205207705497742,
0.06227574869990349,
0.3926519751548767,
1.0563184022903442,
-0.3019980490207672,
-0.07536102086305618,
-0.9405582547187805,
0.016401994973421097,
-0.8521393537521362,
0.881291389465332,
-0.5815137028694153,
-0.06222526729106903,
-0.2273017019033432,
-0.13323836028575897,
-0.0066231656819581985,
-0.9859778881072998,
0.3229089081287384,
-0.6123858690261841,
-0.23240788280963898,
0.0353134460747242,
-0.10022961348295212,
0.0009051054948940873,
0.21402692794799805,
-0.5876153111457825,
1.233838677406311,
0.3601939082145691,
-0.6515182852745056,
0.741992712020874,
-0.92715984582901,
0.03977268934249878,
0.09413471072912216,
0.10148876905441284,
-0.33112549781799316,
0.23847593367099762,
0.3485592007637024,
0.26139047741889954,
-0.06024744361639023,
-0.3200334906578064,
-0.6277397871017456,
-0.6005118489265442,
-0.18507875502109528,
-0.27922865748405457,
0.7376366853713989,
0.24892930686473846,
-0.2777233421802521,
0.28480449318885803,
-0.8329287171363831,
0.2833089828491211,
-0.05932868644595146,
-0.11297077685594559,
-0.575259804725647,
0.012888436205685139,
-0.18176470696926117,
0.24081538617610931,
-0.1103314459323883,
-0.8375774025917053,
0.04752925783395767,
-0.5655274987220764,
0.361294686794281,
0.5388020277023315,
0.1198304072022438,
0.6433719992637634,
-0.24180176854133606,
0.686051070690155,
0.14378052949905396,
0.43767255544662476,
0.07217198610305786,
-0.42899197340011597,
-0.3298044502735138,
-0.8042256832122803,
-0.1154642403125763,
0.48330309987068176,
-0.8765881061553955,
0.7068907618522644,
-0.03517264127731323,
-0.4963214099407196,
-0.3671668469905853,
0.1767360121011734,
0.4866318702697754,
0.6044137477874756,
0.4124836027622223,
-0.26229897141456604,
-0.6274505257606506,
-0.5402671694755554,
0.2640360891819,
0.1237526684999466,
0.3211170732975006,
-0.049913547933101654,
0.7616885304450989,
-0.043443020433187485,
0.9913653135299683,
-0.5952298641204834,
-0.8197486996650696,
-0.39772218465805054,
-0.48317939043045044,
0.18734486401081085,
0.5540309548377991,
0.988260805606842,
-0.6047261357307434,
-0.3060041666030884,
0.28237754106521606,
-0.8671146035194397,
0.24513310194015503,
0.31580281257629395,
-0.30071768164634705,
-0.09864015877246857,
0.8193149566650391,
-0.1148890033364296,
0.9005751013755798,
0.5148342847824097,
-0.1693432331085205,
0.2194923758506775,
-0.5382165312767029,
-0.16254223883152008,
-1.0129034519195557,
0.20325976610183716,
-0.20085959136486053,
-0.2072855681180954,
-0.49952709674835205,
0.19593305885791779,
-0.029837455600500107,
-0.3829572796821594,
-0.7648053765296936,
0.5830719470977783,
-0.13996650278568268,
-0.136908620595932,
-0.4683706760406494,
-0.19525092840194702,
0.026879549026489258,
0.2624279856681824,
0.03524363413453102,
0.9142925143241882,
0.5830525159835815,
-0.46705740690231323,
0.21425683796405792,
0.46816107630729675,
-0.48691079020500183,
0.6694052219390869,
-0.6815783381462097,
-0.15919634699821472,
-0.42573270201683044,
0.20467567443847656,
-0.6713935732841492,
-0.11029838025569916,
0.5917269587516785,
-0.13706223666667938,
0.03166446089744568,
-0.7556823492050171,
-0.04021560400724411,
-0.24138657748699188,
-0.6857311725616455,
0.6847516298294067,
0.7021105289459229,
-1.0417182445526123,
0.3574105501174927,
0.39779558777809143,
0.6566051840782166,
-0.9396224617958069,
-0.8722965121269226,
-0.3030168116092682,
-0.2216147780418396,
-0.41233327984809875,
0.32600244879722595,
0.04115763679146767,
-0.12328965216875076,
-0.02059648372232914,
-0.16560253500938416,
-0.6218661665916443,
-0.05373575538396835,
0.15100038051605225,
0.023718295618891716,
-0.2940690517425537,
-0.12289790064096451,
0.028748897835612297,
0.0491890087723732,
-0.5497162342071533,
-0.3037562668323517,
0.5529613494873047,
0.04472159594297409,
-0.5369651913642883,
-0.22168578207492828,
0.48289865255355835,
0.5705575346946716,
-0.38381364941596985,
0.6532284617424011,
0.41177770495414734,
-0.5304316878318787,
-0.6310259103775024,
-0.10721682757139206,
-0.06816241145133972,
-0.553214430809021,
0.4677271246910095,
-0.04817086085677147,
0.005598961375653744,
0.6536892652511597,
0.22251737117767334,
-0.16882945597171783,
0.07256795465946198,
0.23819933831691742,
-0.02333386428654194,
0.8130379319190979,
0.5975314974784851,
0.10579287260770798,
0.8990883231163025,
-0.5730940103530884,
0.13867446780204773,
-0.9416163563728333,
0.04349290207028389,
-0.048908036202192307,
-0.2646900713443756,
0.0853877142071724,
-0.4367816746234894,
0.49931710958480835,
0.30915749073028564,
-0.04111241176724434,
0.24358995258808136,
-0.7618153691291809,
0.7445471882820129,
0.5526311993598938,
0.4833536744117737,
0.022955764085054398,
0.23928774893283844,
0.23244798183441162,
0.42675861716270447,
-0.6682937741279602,
-0.0814705565571785,
1.191972017288208,
0.26525792479515076,
0.7448434829711914,
-0.030987190082669258,
0.6262975931167603,
0.7216702699661255,
0.06625768542289734,
-0.7428303360939026,
0.5292928218841553,
-0.5125010013580322,
-0.4473290741443634,
-0.32014036178588867,
-0.23754754662513733,
-0.7857356071472168,
0.28743985295295715,
0.039883073419332504,
-0.6334981918334961,
0.8897477984428406,
0.5705779790878296,
-0.4857708513736725,
0.7901602983474731,
-0.5960558652877808,
0.6584680080413818,
-0.04429351165890694,
0.07523223757743835,
-0.08280470222234726,
-0.39375045895576477,
0.3773118853569031,
0.027164649218320847,
-0.28038257360458374,
-0.41562703251838684,
0.02047087252140045,
0.5864251255989075,
-0.8375099301338196,
0.5800942182540894,
-0.57772296667099,
0.016632525250315666,
0.5314211249351501,
-0.22323372960090637,
0.46851053833961487,
-0.13332878053188324,
-0.35666874051094055,
0.3307986259460449,
0.10547812283039093,
-0.3273514211177826,
-0.39484331011772156,
0.4586532711982727,
-0.48261788487434387,
0.28995540738105774,
-0.3791647255420685,
-0.46599701046943665,
0.12383706122636795,
0.32189053297042847,
0.7026848196983337,
0.6218188405036926,
0.19351214170455933,
0.13739846646785736,
0.5598779320716858,
-0.18319179117679596,
0.6682371497154236,
-0.049034204334020615,
-0.3349159359931946,
-0.5834901928901672,
1.1230148077011108,
-0.07744951546192169,
0.42817768454551697,
0.22454795241355896,
0.30931904911994934,
-0.1746073216199875,
-0.9353910684585571,
-0.5951241850852966,
-0.0696522444486618,
-0.9340096116065979,
-0.512789785861969,
-0.07633218169212341,
-0.039198193699121475,
-0.0844796821475029,
-0.3011339008808136,
-0.6726415157318115,
-0.15497829020023346,
-0.3068189322948456,
0.2696068286895752,
0.33450937271118164,
0.22002260386943817,
-0.31685230135917664,
0.7796632647514343,
-0.3472645580768585,
0.5659664273262024,
-0.03988857567310333,
0.6523295044898987,
-0.015784887596964836,
-0.7552279829978943,
0.04252001643180847,
0.10064733773469925,
-0.08878456801176071,
-0.4491605758666992,
0.540363609790802,
0.6908971667289734,
0.4433048367500305,
0.8664863109588623,
0.3175117075443268,
0.623736560344696,
-0.19289177656173706,
0.3902079164981842,
0.3704099655151367,
-0.7380654215812683,
0.5341023802757263,
-0.25990960001945496,
0.024902507662773132,
0.7875614762306213,
-0.24542248249053955,
0.02226843871176243,
-0.005135924089699984,
0.025046583265066147,
-0.8219950795173645,
1.017059326171875,
0.15990455448627472,
-0.15848302841186523,
0.017330072820186615,
0.20761381089687347,
-0.0015462542651221156,
0.20861756801605225,
-0.20171384513378143,
-0.08744640648365021,
-0.19415795803070068,
-0.28478577733039856,
0.22533734142780304,
-0.1677524894475937,
-0.2093142420053482,
-0.027185818180441856,
0.47463205456733704,
-0.31009334325790405,
0.5430015325546265,
0.16867883503437042,
-0.25956687331199646,
-0.4503950774669647,
0.009170889854431152,
0.5858487486839294,
0.7560755014419556,
-0.7846627831459045,
-0.10259009897708893,
0.14088696241378784,
-0.8233247399330139,
0.19732417166233063,
-0.17920595407485962,
-0.43780288100242615,
0.060073208063840866,
0.12919458746910095,
0.7666019201278687,
0.14482812583446503,
-1.009609341621399,
0.9382291436195374,
0.21192556619644165,
-0.24472036957740784,
-0.35236549377441406,
0.16302219033241272,
-0.7083008885383606,
0.36174169182777405,
0.5235113501548767,
0.9119459986686707,
0.1393328756093979,
-0.3530203402042389,
0.184067040681839,
0.5971918106079102,
-0.7179465293884277,
-0.3146633803844452,
0.6022549271583557,
0.0734281837940216,
-0.01806015521287918,
0.21773110330104828,
-0.43596896529197693,
-0.23638449609279633,
0.8723751902580261,
0.4538115859031677,
0.8263078331947327,
-0.07189246267080307,
0.2739534378051758,
-0.20492801070213318,
0.3248007893562317,
-0.5609611868858337,
0.7728304266929626,
0.13612037897109985,
-0.9976527094841003,
-0.381131649017334,
-0.5183401107788086,
-0.27994734048843384,
0.13651558756828308,
-0.906265377998352,
0.3477354347705841,
-0.8269773721694946,
-0.22176119685173035,
0.0029796480666846037,
-0.5191789269447327,
-0.2191314846277237,
0.13987837731838226,
0.12371650338172913,
1.079875111579895,
-0.6063200235366821,
0.6533560752868652,
0.7967075705528259,
-0.3134104311466217,
-0.36863353848457336,
-0.0897088274359703,
-0.36948949098587036,
-0.7632648348808289,
0.602522075176239,
0.1578565090894699,
-0.2863243520259857,
-0.04929939657449722,
-0.3322419822216034,
-0.9824150800704956,
0.7821776866912842,
0.8033884167671204,
-0.12549683451652527,
0.06809759140014648,
-0.20631596446037292,
0.2355213612318039,
-0.22292204201221466,
0.3978019654750824,
0.2718439996242523,
0.18100996315479279,
0.2354106903076172,
-0.8306307196617126,
-0.22127321362495422,
0.0006133503629826009,
-0.03999059274792671,
0.6250729560852051,
-0.5707206130027771,
0.8415204286575317,
-0.30499130487442017,
0.06997024267911911,
0.03791493922472,
0.34976866841316223,
0.17207171022891998,
0.5950804352760315,
0.6625614166259766,
0.4747138023376465,
0.6380544900894165,
0.4327496588230133,
0.8159500956535339,
-0.06839253753423691,
0.23039141297340393,
0.8017448782920837,
-0.5825077295303345,
1.0960979461669922,
0.7073968052864075,
0.10511007905006409,
0.04681626707315445,
0.319286972284317,
-0.08798545598983765,
1.167738914489746,
-0.034440912306308746,
-0.2477552890777588,
-0.1568702608346939,
-0.1077236607670784,
-0.4698053300380707,
0.5142827033996582,
0.07831916958093643,
-0.39663782715797424,
-0.3916553556919098,
0.5140743255615234,
-0.33892181515693665,
-0.1584073007106781,
-1.011621117591858,
0.20974329113960266,
-0.19658531248569489,
-0.39919745922088623,
0.8808692693710327,
-0.12943492829799652,
0.9140267968177795,
-0.5085638761520386,
-0.1806490272283554,
-0.16506977379322052,
0.8240601420402527,
-0.3454182744026184,
-0.44688680768013,
0.47125935554504395,
-0.28423038125038147,
-0.2943572402000427,
0.05279061570763588,
0.8702008128166199,
-0.19328320026397705,
-0.5676417350769043,
0.35375815629959106,
0.14841359853744507,
0.0826001688838005,
-0.38319632411003113,
-0.2782242000102997,
-0.09492294490337372,
-0.20413389801979065,
-0.02620519883930683,
0.37114468216896057,
-0.07297364622354507,
-0.3795870840549469,
0.9362740516662598,
0.782166063785553,
0.21701392531394958,
0.38003531098365784,
-0.1612735241651535,
0.7801582217216492,
-0.2624471187591553,
-0.6210322380065918,
-0.423227995634079,
-0.017322896048426628,
-0.14865556359291077,
-0.6992542743682861,
0.10338570922613144,
0.3986251652240753,
0.5683802962303162,
-0.34276676177978516,
0.5508267879486084,
-0.23515476286411285,
0.36580532789230347,
-0.30768153071403503,
0.756935179233551,
-0.7996273040771484,
0.06441941857337952,
-0.022103894501924515,
-0.6306779980659485,
-0.38710087537765503,
0.47658631205558777,
-0.16079260408878326,
-0.07240608334541321,
0.49825796484947205,
0.719330370426178,
-0.6749404668807983,
-0.4756510257720947,
0.5639484524726868,
-0.3815527558326721,
0.160679891705513,
0.2855186462402344,
0.7555558681488037,
-0.6097043752670288,
0.9317591190338135,
-0.33199143409729004,
-0.32432520389556885,
-0.532384991645813,
-0.9075122475624084,
-1.1383650302886963,
-0.039157502353191376,
-0.28260940313339233,
-0.18349182605743408,
0.32054102420806885,
1.0447077751159668,
1.2352845668792725,
-0.9041274785995483,
0.14565765857696533,
-0.20168161392211914,
0.04363567754626274,
-0.7573990225791931,
-0.13302810490131378,
0.4668828845024109,
-0.16031505167484283,
-0.3534378409385681,
1.0260426998138428,
0.42344656586647034,
-0.17008806765079498,
0.06679889559745789,
-0.11873820424079895,
-0.11115901917219162,
0.2558591961860657,
0.32577037811279297,
0.6356516480445862,
-0.45926934480667114,
-0.3984437584877014,
-0.14863131940364838,
0.2605011463165283,
0.2906377613544464,
0.5500540137290955,
-0.7481316924095154,
0.4668339788913727,
0.5821990370750427,
0.3741588890552521,
0.14213785529136658,
0.07208631932735443,
0.3343888223171234,
-1.1187161207199097,
0.9112421870231628,
0.42828696966171265,
0.3256540596485138,
0.04093732684850693,
-0.3466968536376953,
0.5761716365814209,
0.12499586492776871,
-0.2916107773780823,
-1.446855902671814,
0.2318173348903656,
-1.0503419637680054,
0.06056641414761543,
0.9254639148712158,
-0.21866856515407562,
-0.44067367911338806,
-0.14365464448928833,
-0.10277175158262253,
-0.128440260887146,
-0.6795654892921448,
0.46337300539016724,
-0.1405952125787735,
-0.0010450681438669562,
-0.18251386284828186,
-0.2940460443496704,
0.4056100845336914,
0.35023388266563416,
-0.7277466058731079,
-0.1206679567694664,
0.1005096510052681,
0.29327085614204407,
0.008799735456705093,
0.5315663814544678,
0.08927144855260849,
0.5605566501617432,
0.00393024692311883,
0.16136792302131653,
-0.5744879841804504,
-0.23866282403469086,
-0.41562697291374207,
0.3928232192993164,
-0.010880201123654842,
-1.0313841104507446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12624v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12624v2 | Judging the Judges: Evaluating Alignment and Vulnerabilities in LLMs-as-Judges | 2024-06-18T13:49:54 | 2024-07-02T02:57:01 | Aman Singh Thakur, Kartik Choudhary, Venkat Srinik Ramayapally, Sankaran Vaidyanathan, Dieuwke Hupkes | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Offering a promising solution to the scalability challenges associated with
human evaluation, the LLM-as-a-judge paradigm is rapidly gaining traction as an
approach to evaluating large language models (LLMs). However, there are still
many open questions about the strengths and weaknesses of this paradigm, and
what potential biases it may hold. In this paper, we present a comprehensive
study of the performance of various LLMs acting as judges. We leverage TriviaQA
as a benchmark for assessing objective knowledge reasoning of LLMs and evaluate
them alongside human annotations which we found to have a high inter-annotator
agreement. Our study includes 9 judge models and 9 exam taker models -- both
base and instruction-tuned. We assess the judge model's alignment across
different model sizes, families, and judge prompts. Among other results, our
research rediscovers the importance of using Cohen's kappa as a metric of
alignment as opposed to simple percent agreement, showing that judges with high
percent agreement can still assign vastly different scores. We find that both
Llama-3 70B and GPT-4 Turbo have an excellent alignment with humans, but in
terms of ranking exam taker models, they are outperformed by both JudgeLM-7B
and the lexical judge Contains, which have up to 34 points lower human
alignment. Through error analysis and various other studies, including the
effects of instruction length and leniency bias, we hope to provide valuable
lessons for using LLMs as judges in the future. | [
-0.4022142291069031,
-0.46347808837890625,
0.9195935726165771,
-0.05325023829936981,
-0.2791367173194885,
0.18093863129615784,
-0.3009946048259735,
-0.5664589405059814,
0.030211400240659714,
0.5663201212882996,
-0.0731075182557106,
-0.4539233446121216,
-0.8601545095443726,
0.01772989332675934,
-0.5193688869476318,
0.8694649338722229,
0.036774687469005585,
0.5255525708198547,
-0.46044957637786865,
-0.08140140026807785,
-0.5836030840873718,
-0.49915143847465515,
-0.3991491198539734,
-0.5599222183227539,
0.3168547749519348,
0.5682613253593445,
1.017449140548706,
0.7103948593139648,
0.7991800904273987,
0.2581360340118408,
-0.33951517939567566,
-0.1349092572927475,
-0.1356612890958786,
0.028633352369070053,
-0.43745407462120056,
-0.7936887741088867,
-0.45638641715049744,
0.1697840392589569,
0.42423418164253235,
0.683937668800354,
-0.28129664063453674,
0.2664091885089874,
-0.15158718824386597,
0.6366170048713684,
-0.6400691866874695,
-0.19399532675743103,
-0.6026355624198914,
0.0822456106543541,
-0.3999404013156891,
-0.06509081274271011,
-0.4022577404975891,
-0.7400684952735901,
0.17321419715881348,
-0.48501378297805786,
-0.1638157218694687,
0.43055906891822815,
0.8368175029754639,
0.6839303970336914,
-0.7329964637756348,
-0.2293345183134079,
-0.5105069875717163,
0.6509968638420105,
-0.7418302297592163,
0.295387864112854,
0.43088212609291077,
0.5438525080680847,
-0.14710406959056854,
-0.49082300066947937,
-0.47363030910491943,
-0.46490219235420227,
-0.03273812681436539,
0.10964609682559967,
-0.06168327480554581,
0.15617236495018005,
0.4041752815246582,
0.3851636052131653,
-0.5095988512039185,
0.5410536527633667,
-0.3158828616142273,
-0.1493590623140335,
0.6114374995231628,
0.2506183087825775,
0.07745131105184555,
-0.3237171471118927,
-0.3431837260723114,
-0.03339241072535515,
-0.48772019147872925,
0.07461990416049957,
0.49367037415504456,
0.018413690850138664,
0.24754098057746887,
0.6271090507507324,
-0.26579344272613525,
0.9416952133178711,
0.21824784576892853,
-0.08321398496627808,
-0.047191984951496124,
-0.137482151389122,
-0.1985558420419693,
0.0791952982544899,
0.8145641684532166,
0.7029550075531006,
0.4640355408191681,
-0.18966466188430786,
-0.10242845118045807,
-0.0582544170320034,
0.6957171559333801,
-0.3965252637863159,
0.0665913075208664,
0.11071835458278656,
-0.4082658290863037,
-0.47151419520378113,
0.2170507311820984,
-0.7370694875717163,
-0.8096679449081421,
-0.5384319424629211,
0.4655087888240814,
-0.22748424112796783,
0.26209935545921326,
0.19940122961997986,
-0.004010926000773907,
0.5305504202842712,
0.34718894958496094,
-0.7294617295265198,
0.4124738276004791,
0.8845441341400146,
0.3734975755214691,
-0.23682831227779388,
-0.39885520935058594,
-0.643700361251831,
-0.23723703622817993,
-0.3345943093299866,
0.5847800374031067,
-0.5110788941383362,
-0.23882938921451569,
-0.1923423707485199,
-0.4488867521286011,
0.07532800734043121,
-0.48176929354667664,
0.9274091124534607,
-0.8061246871948242,
-0.0119291041046381,
-0.4364229142665863,
-0.7510843873023987,
-0.09503932297229767,
0.48198381066322327,
-0.524777889251709,
0.9668508172035217,
-0.060006070882081985,
-0.6587560176849365,
0.6040925979614258,
-0.3104788362979889,
-0.25835680961608887,
-0.08106882870197296,
-0.20847609639167786,
-0.3426873981952667,
0.2309253066778183,
0.3081892728805542,
0.22961191833019257,
-0.5221803784370422,
0.42783263325691223,
-0.4423038363456726,
-0.7170590758323669,
0.3742786645889282,
-0.22193987667560577,
0.7074571847915649,
0.13357293605804443,
-0.42721760272979736,
0.16021552681922913,
-0.8011590242385864,
0.012288764119148254,
-0.09201999753713608,
-0.27891433238983154,
-0.16964469850063324,
0.1638420969247818,
-0.34784525632858276,
0.19940005242824554,
0.026086974889039993,
-0.46274229884147644,
0.24126531183719635,
-0.2741488814353943,
0.30278050899505615,
0.8904571533203125,
0.08679933100938797,
0.38691624999046326,
-0.34722673892974854,
0.7171452641487122,
-0.229188933968544,
0.5369104743003845,
0.33310869336128235,
-0.4093947410583496,
-0.8267629742622375,
0.16733795404434204,
0.7362722754478455,
0.5860707759857178,
-0.3932377099990845,
0.5172138810157776,
-0.40256670117378235,
-0.7455297112464905,
-0.6626044511795044,
0.18719756603240967,
0.48354169726371765,
0.417799711227417,
0.10768327116966248,
-0.6169172525405884,
-0.21249331533908844,
-0.9957319498062134,
-0.6607250571250916,
-0.4976549446582794,
0.16665209829807281,
0.12649010121822357,
0.5622101426124573,
0.12691454589366913,
0.9091359376907349,
-0.2271716445684433,
0.10412278771400452,
0.1877620369195938,
-0.14922872185707092,
0.11159071326255798,
0.2788758873939514,
0.5923407077789307,
-0.46883970499038696,
-0.2023945152759552,
0.06173079460859299,
-0.7456902861595154,
-0.405219703912735,
0.12376080453395844,
-0.22181835770606995,
0.08761024475097656,
0.5195251703262329,
-0.4405757188796997,
0.6004672646522522,
0.270322322845459,
-0.577873706817627,
0.8074558973312378,
0.016521945595741272,
0.21547247469425201,
-0.5949745178222656,
-0.18459196388721466,
-0.27260836958885193,
-0.36471036076545715,
-0.49666929244995117,
0.2101866751909256,
0.13319066166877747,
0.28751689195632935,
-0.21010765433311462,
0.5512251853942871,
-0.3535561263561249,
-0.4693374037742615,
-0.13649432361125946,
0.4682547450065613,
0.09472983330488205,
0.21409253776073456,
-0.3174809217453003,
0.6372293829917908,
0.27503809332847595,
-0.3967365622520447,
0.5067492127418518,
0.2096017301082611,
-0.7128589153289795,
0.9568437933921814,
-0.39592283964157104,
0.2430759072303772,
0.2179325520992279,
0.09843724220991135,
-0.7515712380409241,
-0.23123957216739655,
0.20366136729717255,
-0.42074054479599,
0.45545312762260437,
-0.08353644609451294,
-0.689087450504303,
-0.48649170994758606,
-0.3358101546764374,
0.20449477434158325,
0.27171412110328674,
-0.5719012022018433,
0.7267204523086548,
0.1534116268157959,
-0.030503353103995323,
-0.9002653956413269,
-0.4519783854484558,
0.2657761573791504,
-0.4312868118286133,
-0.6754018068313599,
0.0799785852432251,
-0.05037694424390793,
-0.6959185600280762,
-0.03637179732322693,
-0.3034786880016327,
0.27069345116615295,
0.5701147317886353,
0.3752632439136505,
0.2316354215145111,
-0.1472456008195877,
0.13711926341056824,
-0.18684600293636322,
-0.023953432217240334,
0.2689833641052246,
-0.10418476909399033,
0.3027040958404541,
-0.321647584438324,
-0.8954573273658752,
-0.3414440155029297,
-0.001584269804880023,
0.6860981583595276,
-0.40717676281929016,
0.5009819865226746,
0.19642621278762817,
-0.054293014109134674,
0.1207355409860611,
-1.0055210590362549,
0.08551209419965744,
-0.37068766355514526,
0.2432643473148346,
-0.2701207995414734,
-0.9298407435417175,
0.4681331217288971,
0.20466575026512146,
0.03575499728322029,
0.34156495332717896,
0.7438157796859741,
-0.24116946756839752,
0.6565633416175842,
0.292624831199646,
-0.17972169816493988,
0.4879654347896576,
0.36485522985458374,
0.17026540637016296,
-0.9234054088592529,
-0.23507647216320038,
-0.5982835292816162,
-0.5841892957687378,
-0.5664064288139343,
-0.38084879517555237,
0.3758554756641388,
0.22941695153713226,
-0.5962332487106323,
0.041345566511154175,
-0.31515756249427795,
0.6807157397270203,
0.7545674443244934,
-0.01407064963132143,
0.43337008357048035,
-0.4220364987850189,
-0.3763156533241272,
0.18850035965442657,
-0.28035515546798706,
-0.8689901828765869,
1.454169750213623,
0.405509352684021,
0.7517618536949158,
0.2196059674024582,
0.7970774173736572,
0.20579588413238525,
0.2952989339828491,
-0.8013721704483032,
0.5787414312362671,
0.0009534062701277435,
-0.8167991042137146,
-0.2007668912410736,
-0.20997855067253113,
-0.38190963864326477,
0.4713922142982483,
-0.1505720615386963,
-0.9153989553451538,
0.21664202213287354,
-0.05074143782258034,
-0.5817827582359314,
0.3746953010559082,
-0.7621383666992188,
0.8605078458786011,
-0.8266383409500122,
-0.33182358741760254,
0.05053495243191719,
-1.0603816509246826,
0.4098532497882843,
-0.180837944149971,
0.21271288394927979,
-0.09081653505563736,
0.0003336920926813036,
0.6194552779197693,
-0.381405770778656,
0.7423834800720215,
-0.16940779983997345,
-0.016516631469130516,
0.14278878271579742,
0.22374872863292694,
0.29798680543899536,
0.02822868712246418,
-0.26387497782707214,
0.018518546596169472,
0.09364008158445358,
-0.2683369815349579,
-0.6394223570823669,
0.38964542746543884,
-0.8791742324829102,
-0.988144040107727,
-0.5892673134803772,
-0.5007505416870117,
-0.5554212331771851,
0.08132415264844894,
0.012930498458445072,
0.028321050107479095,
-0.24024929106235504,
0.10339674353599548,
0.4487355649471283,
-0.049737319350242615,
0.1407093107700348,
0.6025973558425903,
-0.41528889536857605,
-0.3867979943752289,
0.5553345084190369,
-0.02028096280992031,
0.44622012972831726,
0.2998493015766144,
0.17379219830036163,
-0.13335955142974854,
-0.7422659397125244,
-0.4071333110332489,
0.23490087687969208,
-0.8695913553237915,
-0.2528713047504425,
-0.19632305204868317,
-0.1279768943786621,
-0.07827653735876083,
-0.22326207160949707,
-0.14066769182682037,
-0.648825466632843,
-0.154991015791893,
-0.2859678864479065,
0.1347111165523529,
0.8623223304748535,
0.1926417201757431,
0.5615479350090027,
-0.44868946075439453,
-0.034063391387462616,
0.428947776556015,
0.48287731409072876,
-0.08349192142486572,
-0.8249388933181763,
0.04564646631479263,
-0.4807731509208679,
-0.42953765392303467,
-0.7251230478286743,
-0.21037238836288452,
-0.13444067537784576,
0.6530584096908569,
0.5726606249809265,
-0.1627868115901947,
0.7170069813728333,
-0.43093881011009216,
0.8084361553192139,
-0.03739852458238602,
-0.9847915172576904,
0.3912031650543213,
-0.08490991592407227,
0.06201283261179924,
0.9363476634025574,
-0.04632595553994179,
-0.46817320585250854,
-0.6016956567764282,
-0.3430538475513458,
-0.4843076765537262,
0.9835917949676514,
0.07574518024921417,
-0.24126023054122925,
0.20227284729480743,
0.6504706144332886,
0.0817994475364685,
0.18919703364372253,
-0.6342461705207825,
-0.05567481741309166,
-0.026260538026690483,
-0.08938522636890411,
-0.03971811383962631,
-0.3919841945171356,
-0.1834135502576828,
-0.26350948214530945,
0.6369689702987671,
0.018932832404971123,
-0.2513538599014282,
-0.031812094151973724,
-0.2450975626707077,
-0.031794529408216476,
0.6113243103027344,
0.6561486721038818,
0.684495210647583,
-0.2888098955154419,
0.14023521542549133,
0.32186058163642883,
-0.24492652714252472,
0.20151181519031525,
0.1612728238105774,
-0.07621785998344421,
-0.4476010501384735,
0.6707762479782104,
0.81683748960495,
0.46485382318496704,
-0.5954257845878601,
0.6091482639312744,
-0.21488705277442932,
-0.15203985571861267,
-0.17077946662902832,
0.15007691085338593,
0.21180512011051178,
0.6068901419639587,
-0.05823928490281105,
0.024508370086550713,
0.0032206419855356216,
-0.3878720998764038,
0.11084118485450745,
0.3246002495288849,
-0.4752183258533478,
-0.07087220996618271,
0.7880386114120483,
0.07877134531736374,
-0.3349926173686981,
0.6683980822563171,
-0.22044742107391357,
-0.7654509544372559,
0.5697687268257141,
0.08558226376771927,
0.6119020581245422,
-0.17241550981998444,
-0.17169348895549774,
0.029950398951768875,
0.4953753352165222,
-0.1837296485900879,
0.10590068995952606,
-0.22190089523792267,
-0.7505394816398621,
-0.14546886086463928,
-0.8829449415206909,
-0.7846324443817139,
-0.4287903904914856,
-1.00260591506958,
0.24437227845191956,
-0.44398388266563416,
-0.529238224029541,
0.058725327253341675,
0.25060683488845825,
-0.5735797882080078,
0.05612191930413246,
0.3484092056751251,
1.0265519618988037,
-0.6816724538803101,
0.5281849503517151,
0.7582956552505493,
-0.28848549723625183,
-0.7997555732727051,
0.1852196455001831,
0.4100213348865509,
-0.9813771843910217,
0.6550726294517517,
0.028633160516619682,
0.05807744711637497,
-0.33236056566238403,
-0.45570114254951477,
-0.7193717956542969,
1.2806587219238281,
0.538820743560791,
-0.8002374172210693,
-0.21323418617248535,
0.08313687145709991,
0.7081176042556763,
-0.19614967703819275,
0.46453163027763367,
1.0852559804916382,
0.698071300983429,
0.06466849148273468,
-1.1454554796218872,
-0.19646023213863373,
-0.06180548667907715,
-0.06774426251649857,
0.21980974078178406,
-0.7820377349853516,
0.4970872700214386,
-0.17710360884666443,
0.2349550426006317,
0.1093822717666626,
0.4403616189956665,
0.4480532705783844,
0.1826927363872528,
0.5443772077560425,
0.870579183101654,
0.8716474771499634,
-0.25012439489364624,
1.2191672325134277,
-0.178068608045578,
0.22261320054531097,
1.2903897762298584,
-0.5585366487503052,
0.6702131032943726,
0.6009464859962463,
-0.3543925881385803,
0.48675528168678284,
0.7127946615219116,
-0.15572725236415863,
0.09209658205509186,
0.42025285959243774,
0.1562768816947937,
-0.5658437609672546,
-0.014459352940320969,
0.03315179795026779,
0.760152280330658,
0.03867347165942192,
-0.30881232023239136,
-0.17173823714256287,
-0.34336885809898376,
-0.0004279628046788275,
0.19912351667881012,
-0.48906299471855164,
0.5784111022949219,
0.3169027268886566,
-0.8612921237945557,
0.010868280194699764,
0.04624605178833008,
0.38905593752861023,
-0.3253426253795624,
0.2689041495323181,
-0.14587122201919556,
0.1955321729183197,
-0.2327178418636322,
-1.072040319442749,
0.08395102620124817,
0.3101791441440582,
-0.08954436331987381,
-0.0788276419043541,
0.4920654296875,
0.12828725576400757,
-0.4487408697605133,
0.4950151741504669,
0.4430291950702667,
0.226571187376976,
0.021674877032637596,
-0.48685237765312195,
0.09876372665166855,
-0.21031461656093597,
-0.31993284821510315,
0.2810920178890228,
0.4067220985889435,
-0.4521850645542145,
0.5898045301437378,
0.2204759120941162,
0.16926154494285583,
0.4241432547569275,
0.388668954372406,
0.6710236668586731,
-0.7805692553520203,
-0.17686286568641663,
-0.9518256187438965,
0.2584373652935028,
-0.14442384243011475,
-0.3609926104545593,
0.7211098074913025,
0.46828413009643555,
0.7610758543014526,
0.2518659830093384,
0.3043493628501892,
0.10342610627412796,
0.4322715103626251,
-0.5981854796409607,
0.7060605883598328,
-0.6067484617233276,
0.46802258491516113,
-0.13639089465141296,
-0.7675087451934814,
-0.2810429036617279,
0.22103051841259003,
-0.6320090293884277,
0.2062269002199173,
0.6062778234481812,
0.5172871947288513,
0.19275975227355957,
0.16193422675132751,
0.37223899364471436,
0.22377248108386993,
0.33938583731651306,
0.619234561920166,
1.2188706398010254,
-0.21131843328475952,
0.5456744432449341,
-0.16223761439323425,
-0.001534094917587936,
-0.37273359298706055,
-0.7360311150550842,
-1.0507434606552124,
-0.07916343957185745,
-0.06443838030099869,
-0.048704955726861954,
-0.13168025016784668,
0.7274339199066162,
0.3841862380504608,
-0.7136847972869873,
-0.17746038734912872,
0.4592524766921997,
0.3502977192401886,
-0.0715995505452156,
-0.16876181960105896,
0.3616524040699005,
-0.22478808462619781,
-0.47399652004241943,
0.21998658776283264,
0.24463297426700592,
-0.4154159128665924,
-0.12829531729221344,
-0.13260388374328613,
-0.07024627178907394,
0.013045387342572212,
0.28205227851867676,
-0.03979519382119179,
-1.1494981050491333,
-0.6523562073707581,
-0.21608655154705048,
-0.19764691591262817,
0.08534655719995499,
0.4962976574897766,
-0.5836973190307617,
0.713106632232666,
0.29138755798339844,
0.7261675000190735,
0.36955079436302185,
0.3588448166847229,
0.43602293729782104,
-0.4782799780368805,
-0.39579272270202637,
0.23700159788131714,
0.5019980669021606,
0.18836276233196259,
-0.1599796712398529,
0.6515374183654785,
-0.009362228214740753,
-0.9154119491577148,
-0.9359065890312195,
0.09159233421087265,
-1.1821093559265137,
0.022959917783737183,
0.9807291626930237,
0.12837259471416473,
-0.1682901382446289,
0.003955158870667219,
-0.02325390838086605,
0.05420118570327759,
-0.15246069431304932,
0.7188081741333008,
1.247296929359436,
-0.20717348158359528,
0.1457972675561905,
-0.8806957006454468,
0.13379926979541779,
0.5735704898834229,
-0.650746762752533,
-0.011794312857091427,
0.3891022801399231,
0.5712645649909973,
0.23107340931892395,
0.41631191968917847,
-0.36450278759002686,
0.43751683831214905,
-0.28478124737739563,
0.24959337711334229,
-0.07968924194574356,
-0.05407329276204109,
-0.8465697169303894,
-0.027047527953982353,
0.5412044525146484,
0.1993592232465744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12621v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12621v1 | Growing Trees on Sounds: Assessing Strategies for End-to-End Dependency Parsing of Speech | 2024-06-18T13:46:10 | 2024-06-18T13:46:10 | Adrien Pupier, Maximin Coavoux, Jérôme Goulian, Benjamin Lecouteux | cs.CL | cs.CL | Direct dependency parsing of the speech signal -- as opposed to parsing
speech transcriptions -- has recently been proposed as a task (Pupier et al.
2022), as a way of incorporating prosodic information in the parsing system and
bypassing the limitations of a pipeline approach that would consist of using
first an Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) system and then a syntactic parser.
In this article, we report on a set of experiments aiming at assessing the
performance of two parsing paradigms (graph-based parsing and sequence labeling
based parsing) on speech parsing. We perform this evaluation on a large
treebank of spoken French, featuring realistic spontaneous conversations. Our
findings show that (i) the graph based approach obtain better results across
the board (ii) parsing directly from speech outperforms a pipeline approach,
despite having 30% fewer parameters. | [
-0.3847924470901489,
-0.8985245823860168,
0.5272586345672607,
0.5297572612762451,
-0.2098221778869629,
0.39277616143226624,
-0.1203858032822609,
-0.8762238025665283,
0.3182922303676605,
0.2958199381828308,
-0.43977218866348267,
-0.29180750250816345,
-0.6648808121681213,
0.36936163902282715,
-0.5947167277336121,
0.4369629919528961,
0.2915838658809662,
-0.041866883635520935,
-0.11947734653949738,
-0.09628850221633911,
-0.5063124299049377,
-0.6477958559989929,
-0.9826948642730713,
-0.1400655210018158,
0.5551261305809021,
0.19980846345424652,
0.6439943909645081,
0.7701374292373657,
0.31091544032096863,
0.39300185441970825,
-0.5888609886169434,
-0.2337823361158371,
-0.1820676028728485,
0.2708801329135895,
0.09993059933185577,
-0.1637677550315857,
-0.25891995429992676,
-0.016962308436632156,
0.6159549951553345,
0.8452264070510864,
0.20369848608970642,
0.07963372021913528,
0.1941826194524765,
0.4977562129497528,
-0.28893426060676575,
0.36404770612716675,
-0.38096877932548523,
0.24696670472621918,
-0.27160677313804626,
-0.38726720213890076,
-0.6473148465156555,
-0.18952137231826782,
0.31347355246543884,
-0.12681813538074493,
0.12013722211122513,
-0.35598066449165344,
0.8343793749809265,
0.07243082672357559,
-0.40894344449043274,
-0.4505997598171234,
-0.9011964797973633,
0.465095192193985,
-0.6068997383117676,
0.7761148810386658,
0.28093820810317993,
0.14294162392616272,
-0.1339883953332901,
-0.9898500442504883,
-0.09992317855358124,
-0.20542460680007935,
-0.1726861298084259,
0.05548674985766411,
-0.37138795852661133,
0.4126962721347809,
0.551180362701416,
0.3602628707885742,
-0.31136947870254517,
0.02142385207116604,
-0.2440350353717804,
-0.1832827627658844,
0.39649197459220886,
-0.39466139674186707,
0.41422778367996216,
-0.275640606880188,
0.07270433753728867,
-0.2830033004283905,
-0.408248633146286,
0.679552435874939,
0.4260721802711487,
0.7226720452308655,
0.02462904527783394,
0.5026155710220337,
-0.12794658541679382,
1.0167124271392822,
0.02047116681933403,
0.018903344869613647,
0.18469120562076569,
-0.32587507367134094,
-0.2954280376434326,
0.3478221297264099,
0.7009252905845642,
0.10305579006671906,
0.36395618319511414,
-0.133156880736351,
-0.12067622691392899,
0.4365757405757904,
-0.24816755950450897,
-0.7469413876533508,
-0.5132290124893188,
0.22381992638111115,
-0.23814672231674194,
-0.13471542298793793,
-0.30630630254745483,
-0.6551676988601685,
0.006496254354715347,
-0.5904698371887207,
0.07917648553848267,
-0.3783155381679535,
-0.060262084007263184,
-0.18005512654781342,
-0.30361059308052063,
0.05918239429593086,
0.2548629641532898,
-0.798355758190155,
0.7260217666625977,
0.677272379398346,
1.2705254554748535,
0.0914948359131813,
0.17879600822925568,
-1.1061865091323853,
-0.23409058153629303,
-0.29442089796066284,
1.128063678741455,
-0.603092610836029,
-0.7102742195129395,
-0.11546210199594498,
0.1537753939628601,
-0.017194297164678574,
-0.699095606803894,
0.7747457027435303,
-0.052768465131521225,
-0.01043664664030075,
-0.5241714715957642,
-0.43372389674186707,
-0.18460096418857574,
-0.1618480533361435,
-0.5237202644348145,
0.8448816537857056,
0.19541507959365845,
-0.6861243844032288,
0.47121569514274597,
-0.527912974357605,
-0.6175008416175842,
0.063324935734272,
-0.502298891544342,
-0.06906016170978546,
-0.08764062076807022,
0.09179676324129105,
0.1704445332288742,
-0.19122754037380219,
0.47004589438438416,
0.004414048511534929,
-0.021141335368156433,
-0.07958527654409409,
-0.40764227509498596,
1.2476178407669067,
0.1708594262599945,
-0.3482981026172638,
0.3356960415840149,
-0.8817690014839172,
0.04276035353541374,
-0.08022170513868332,
-0.24670976400375366,
-0.15053515136241913,
0.42879822850227356,
0.042229074984788895,
0.20232322812080383,
-0.24107462167739868,
-0.8182845711708069,
-0.11267893016338348,
-0.7980393767356873,
0.7796756029129028,
0.5860790014266968,
0.11306487768888474,
-0.03799229487776756,
-0.1321249157190323,
0.3131985366344452,
-0.05949060991406441,
-0.03398650884628296,
-0.543541431427002,
-0.7626253366470337,
-0.6986247897148132,
-0.24626591801643372,
0.5901414752006531,
0.6440945863723755,
-0.025031166151165962,
0.577322781085968,
-0.07581466436386108,
-0.22845065593719482,
-0.10451576858758926,
-0.09025943279266357,
0.3042142391204834,
0.5333994030952454,
0.2605084776878357,
-0.9828657507896423,
-0.8229172825813293,
-0.7129603624343872,
-0.2227744609117508,
-0.3414899706840515,
-0.03973127901554108,
0.19763998687267303,
-0.06546756625175476,
0.11315295100212097,
1.3399325609207153,
-0.3424275517463684,
-0.10593795776367188,
-0.03712010011076927,
0.10797570645809174,
0.20196180045604706,
0.3705621063709259,
0.38999396562576294,
-0.4512956142425537,
-0.6470665335655212,
0.03383153676986694,
-0.6135938167572021,
-0.21516290307044983,
0.2214595079421997,
0.44794905185699463,
-0.1668088585138321,
0.5037729740142822,
-0.5001890063285828,
0.21454621851444244,
0.5380868911743164,
-0.5358669757843018,
0.3990981876850128,
0.09091819822788239,
-0.1302199810743332,
-0.48676085472106934,
-0.0515267476439476,
0.09401261806488037,
-0.46189650893211365,
-0.9752270579338074,
-0.3834967315196991,
-0.5247797966003418,
-0.33772531151771545,
-0.45158329606056213,
0.12504899501800537,
-0.5678712725639343,
-0.46970227360725403,
0.10190145671367645,
-0.0462787002325058,
0.019781198352575302,
0.32543298602104187,
0.046556685119867325,
0.5726009607315063,
0.6078433990478516,
-0.2552333474159241,
0.38246315717697144,
0.18236050009727478,
-0.3050064742565155,
0.1107976958155632,
-0.8145253658294678,
0.48111826181411743,
-0.0994647815823555,
0.22282224893569946,
-1.3073585033416748,
0.026968568563461304,
0.18141786754131317,
-0.5081683397293091,
0.28871476650238037,
-0.4538840055465698,
-0.47863417863845825,
-0.28197646141052246,
-0.03838683292269707,
0.23738336563110352,
0.6678397059440613,
-0.40146610140800476,
0.39855465292930603,
0.35318729281425476,
-0.416772723197937,
-0.020778264850378036,
-0.5936394333839417,
0.28876447677612305,
-0.2708408534526825,
-0.8454295992851257,
-0.09124696254730225,
0.20841769874095917,
-0.6559368968009949,
-0.02153708040714264,
-0.1647530347108841,
-0.048896290361881256,
0.017990563064813614,
0.3588084578514099,
-0.27431774139404297,
-0.39853501319885254,
-0.21018105745315552,
-0.1034812182188034,
-0.24673008918762207,
0.10791128128767014,
-0.3315111994743347,
0.6376380324363708,
-0.04575794190168381,
-0.3340892493724823,
-0.4055154323577881,
0.33202385902404785,
0.36055269837379456,
-0.27854281663894653,
0.07332909852266312,
0.035532139241695404,
-0.12473589181900024,
0.04366754740476608,
-0.3133731484413147,
-0.08568482100963593,
-0.5248700380325317,
0.1448296755552292,
-0.4668523073196411,
-0.86777263879776,
0.38589778542518616,
-0.4958304464817047,
0.12199599295854568,
0.3135392665863037,
0.21077100932598114,
-0.12148189544677734,
1.010172724723816,
0.4251525104045868,
0.11075594276189804,
0.5326365828514099,
-0.23638713359832764,
0.45834505558013916,
-0.5246076583862305,
-0.020075447857379913,
-0.6759470105171204,
-0.27386733889579773,
-0.569530725479126,
-0.5514162182807922,
0.02896517515182495,
0.2208787351846695,
-0.11584337055683136,
0.4859478175640106,
-0.6470498442649841,
0.4217959940433502,
0.4615282118320465,
-0.20513564348220825,
0.48554664850234985,
0.27168482542037964,
-0.10729362070560455,
0.08987973630428314,
-0.725066602230072,
-0.3567981421947479,
0.6756938695907593,
0.48201799392700195,
-0.05734717473387718,
-0.1783638894557953,
0.3934840261936188,
0.23976312577724457,
-0.0030090156942605972,
-1.167898178100586,
0.601864755153656,
-0.4110938012599945,
-0.016750410199165344,
-0.5167193412780762,
-0.2506844401359558,
-1.218946099281311,
0.4074961841106415,
0.127347931265831,
-1.0481197834014893,
0.5528234243392944,
0.13268154859542847,
-0.23501095175743103,
0.19309164583683014,
-0.7801439166069031,
0.8789677619934082,
-0.2271653562784195,
-0.1461767703294754,
0.18642355501651764,
-0.7345899939537048,
0.038138024508953094,
0.07128142565488815,
0.5119673013687134,
-0.2111557424068451,
0.43388086557388306,
1.0004576444625854,
-0.3360067307949066,
0.8453444838523865,
-0.4573659598827362,
-0.07938072830438614,
0.7425811290740967,
0.15241022408008575,
0.5622552633285522,
-0.3189791738986969,
0.07961178570985794,
0.13478757441043854,
0.13226065039634705,
-0.21561479568481445,
-0.5586636066436768,
0.48614031076431274,
-0.7635881900787354,
-0.6695677042007446,
-0.3517390787601471,
-0.3572681248188019,
-0.6100637912750244,
0.0889168381690979,
0.11059358716011047,
0.8383926749229431,
-0.3110739588737488,
0.10489559918642044,
0.20623604953289032,
-0.11592096090316772,
0.5870747566223145,
0.22991843521595,
-0.46689578890800476,
-0.4281747341156006,
0.8893662095069885,
0.5416809916496277,
0.3751855492591858,
0.06740240007638931,
0.41972988843917847,
-0.29629969596862793,
-0.38644126057624817,
-0.5638041496276855,
0.14147014915943146,
-0.6165242195129395,
0.14285030961036682,
-0.9667915105819702,
-0.4004879295825958,
-0.5741175413131714,
-0.0429806150496006,
-0.2768956422805786,
-0.5550847053527832,
0.10880374163389206,
-0.3372095227241516,
0.42368829250335693,
0.6921703219413757,
-0.12108460068702698,
0.34724313020706177,
-0.7359896898269653,
0.11837068200111389,
0.4605519473552704,
0.20015893876552582,
-0.19303669035434723,
-0.3369106650352478,
0.08675739914178848,
0.050538454204797745,
-0.30499035120010376,
-1.2566277980804443,
0.4045763313770294,
0.2643512785434723,
0.1417103260755539,
0.41284650564193726,
-0.28690969944000244,
0.8300790190696716,
-0.5474331974983215,
0.7544740438461304,
0.42062053084373474,
-1.0931673049926758,
0.7521201372146606,
-0.4721970856189728,
0.24886929988861084,
0.49991706013679504,
0.2104087620973587,
-0.6367775201797485,
-0.43772250413894653,
-0.8828248977661133,
-1.121942162513733,
0.6684473752975464,
0.3320240080356598,
-0.15649181604385376,
-0.029488062486052513,
-0.06427755951881409,
-0.329158216714859,
0.02891400270164013,
-0.3024974763393402,
-0.10919780284166336,
-0.02801155298948288,
0.1293768584728241,
-0.3942731022834778,
-0.2740977108478546,
-0.14279036223888397,
-0.5906322002410889,
0.15959781408309937,
0.07187889516353607,
0.23316523432731628,
0.42123574018478394,
0.21619285643100739,
-0.388337641954422,
0.31927528977394104,
0.1037951186299324,
0.5048308968544006,
-0.2171034812927246,
0.41397732496261597,
0.10642041265964508,
-0.34126970171928406,
0.5019822120666504,
-0.11876887828111649,
-0.43732115626335144,
0.45224007964134216,
0.4925890862941742,
0.986642599105835,
0.12373620271682739,
-0.7843775749206543,
0.3875660002231598,
0.20799267292022705,
-0.370106965303421,
-0.04735999554395676,
-0.09068728238344193,
0.42283332347869873,
0.035512179136276245,
-0.13958218693733215,
0.259763240814209,
0.31572121381759644,
-0.8892716765403748,
0.4944489598274231,
0.18882279098033905,
-0.7835165858268738,
-0.4977697730064392,
0.2549428343772888,
0.2563941180706024,
-0.6992640495300293,
0.4757920801639557,
-0.15653282403945923,
-0.31781527400016785,
0.7479202747344971,
0.7160688638687134,
1.0521948337554932,
-0.4403615891933441,
0.09641110152006149,
0.41560232639312744,
0.1343131810426712,
-0.042051028460264206,
0.26167160272598267,
-0.3916860520839691,
-0.6679735779762268,
-0.8425692319869995,
-0.7376280426979065,
-0.46266838908195496,
-0.10749372094869614,
-0.56187504529953,
0.34031665325164795,
-0.5768649578094482,
-0.2779258191585541,
0.2299664169549942,
-0.26818975806236267,
-0.39708855748176575,
0.18123972415924072,
-0.15394327044487,
0.8099144697189331,
-1.100710391998291,
0.793273389339447,
0.6773492693901062,
-0.045473646372556686,
-0.8687344789505005,
-0.1037430539727211,
0.14486847817897797,
-0.4725983440876007,
0.8920255899429321,
0.15382397174835205,
-0.16341301798820496,
0.296612948179245,
-0.02499118633568287,
-0.9473185539245605,
0.652496874332428,
0.49498212337493896,
-1.0184593200683594,
0.21113432943820953,
0.24598641693592072,
0.6890274882316589,
0.012657674960792065,
0.35346999764442444,
0.8151053786277771,
0.3928009867668152,
0.4075551927089691,
-1.1839572191238403,
-0.05808750167489052,
-0.2712191939353943,
-0.12612956762313843,
0.4179740250110626,
-0.5728453993797302,
0.6380188465118408,
0.07793170213699341,
-0.7022852301597595,
-0.4296568036079407,
0.6223627328872681,
-0.02917962707579136,
0.41401106119155884,
1.0331594944000244,
0.5777500867843628,
0.7499842643737793,
0.06883258372545242,
0.7390825748443604,
-0.4623720645904541,
0.15403001010417938,
1.2631683349609375,
-0.2825091481208801,
1.0270758867263794,
0.33114537596702576,
-0.7159940004348755,
0.37556037306785583,
0.8413411974906921,
0.16301265358924866,
0.2375938445329666,
0.6835265755653381,
-0.3647327125072479,
0.031220950186252594,
-0.5492866635322571,
-0.20125338435173035,
0.37480974197387695,
0.2973611056804657,
-0.26155826449394226,
-0.2530573606491089,
-0.005633664783090353,
0.04314851388335228,
-0.011215027421712875,
0.021122517064213753,
0.922015905380249,
0.3863702118396759,
-0.549630343914032,
0.4864440858364105,
-0.33798104524612427,
0.1956849992275238,
-0.48571398854255676,
-0.06474105268716812,
0.16161666810512543,
-0.09631841629743576,
-0.40065041184425354,
-0.639163076877594,
0.6819000840187073,
0.19841471314430237,
0.12755036354064941,
-0.568030834197998,
0.7046259641647339,
-0.09989403188228607,
-0.42651593685150146,
0.800279974937439,
0.6209207773208618,
0.2350645512342453,
0.043431833386421204,
-0.45614299178123474,
0.2452920526266098,
0.04035785421729088,
-0.12209280580282211,
0.3572756350040436,
0.41154518723487854,
0.027316806837916374,
0.32379183173179626,
0.7359915375709534,
0.32934144139289856,
0.04241422191262245,
0.2955071032047272,
0.9020001292228699,
-0.47229260206222534,
-0.5349689722061157,
-0.9016649127006531,
0.3534613251686096,
0.11555749922990799,
-0.11936905980110168,
0.8937140107154846,
0.8727323412895203,
0.7179194688796997,
0.4227061867713928,
0.7527309656143188,
-0.16230517625808716,
0.38266924023628235,
-0.2464141696691513,
-0.054990772157907486,
-0.09222052991390228,
0.09618009626865387,
-0.4428226053714752,
-1.2068090438842773,
-0.2458430975675583,
0.5534538626670837,
-0.2902337312698364,
-0.27201950550079346,
0.8072887659072876,
0.514217734336853,
-0.04838864132761955,
0.3848656415939331,
0.40406090021133423,
0.4497743844985962,
0.3568871021270752,
0.22670532763004303,
1.0554773807525635,
0.00009283571125706658,
0.19142909348011017,
-0.2990835905075073,
-0.33316949009895325,
0.35024309158325195,
-0.5508794784545898,
-0.43923598527908325,
-0.48386937379837036,
-0.3577485680580139,
-0.429171085357666,
0.22210344672203064,
0.9242333769798279,
0.5302846431732178,
-0.9988754391670227,
-0.6903831362724304,
-0.5847015976905823,
-0.24907726049423218,
-0.25227391719818115,
-0.22173212468624115,
0.346049040555954,
-0.4811696708202362,
-0.5827600359916687,
0.9618699550628662,
0.567154586315155,
-0.03372977674007416,
0.0031322562135756016,
0.04815054312348366,
-0.15068741142749786,
0.013531610369682312,
0.8236910104751587,
0.4536105990409851,
-0.6683765649795532,
-0.5070004463195801,
-0.044312674552202225,
0.429286390542984,
0.552315354347229,
1.1267298460006714,
-0.8586757183074951,
0.5893571376800537,
0.8433216214179993,
0.3621125817298889,
0.6269121170043945,
0.33460938930511475,
0.6212923526763916,
-0.4616885483264923,
0.2020377367734909,
0.33138906955718994,
0.2805366814136505,
0.27792665362358093,
-0.1798209547996521,
0.5953614711761475,
0.5772499442100525,
-0.5961505174636841,
-0.8622923493385315,
0.2933541536331177,
-1.0828903913497925,
-0.08472385257482529,
1.049966812133789,
-0.32456353306770325,
0.006139591336250305,
-0.5469110012054443,
-0.3771648108959198,
0.4751957058906555,
-0.39787688851356506,
0.12377770990133286,
0.5874391198158264,
-0.6507351398468018,
-0.14583225548267365,
-0.6266289353370667,
0.586532473564148,
0.48045897483825684,
-0.5253791213035583,
0.19839653372764587,
0.5116789937019348,
0.0935346782207489,
0.3768385350704193,
1.046388030052185,
0.025672318413853645,
-0.2593797445297241,
0.30515483021736145,
-0.3452860713005066,
0.2601633071899414,
-0.41544100642204285,
-0.3883613646030426,
0.3861665725708008,
0.40518856048583984,
-0.012411732226610184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12620v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12620v2 | What Makes Two Language Models Think Alike? | 2024-06-18T13:45:50 | 2024-06-24T06:34:35 | Jeanne Salle, Louis Jalouzot, Nur Lan, Emmanuel Chemla, Yair Lakretz | cs.CL | cs.CL | Do architectural differences significantly affect the way models represent
and process language? We propose a new approach, based on metric-learning
encoding models (MLEMs), as a first step to answer this question. The approach
provides a feature-based comparison of how any two layers of any two models
represent linguistic information. We apply the method to BERT, GPT-2 and Mamba.
Unlike previous methods, MLEMs offer a transparent comparison, by identifying
the specific linguistic features responsible for similarities and differences.
More generally, the method uses formal, symbolic descriptions of a domain, and
use these to compare neural representations. As such, the approach can
straightforwardly be extended to other domains, such as speech and vision, and
to other neural systems, including human brains. | [
-0.5500030517578125,
-0.551996111869812,
0.5221880674362183,
0.10406938195228577,
-0.07666029781103134,
0.08025967329740524,
-0.17380142211914062,
-0.6387574076652527,
0.05689114332199097,
0.5025022029876709,
-0.41222843527793884,
-0.3371106684207916,
-0.7197728753089905,
-0.011867373250424862,
-0.12261048704385757,
0.680225133895874,
0.03195149078965187,
0.42847511172294617,
-0.20951126515865326,
-0.3476456105709076,
-0.4066397547721863,
-0.656208336353302,
-0.8119184970855713,
-0.6387806534767151,
0.3803553581237793,
-0.39032769203186035,
0.9068740010261536,
0.7215609550476074,
0.6943527460098267,
0.28740811347961426,
-0.13773740828037262,
0.18659789860248566,
-0.22597135603427887,
0.031225794926285744,
-0.11786465346813202,
-0.5243796110153198,
-0.237385094165802,
-0.07017089426517487,
0.559287965297699,
0.8175836801528931,
0.041266608983278275,
0.4415717124938965,
0.3962804675102234,
0.6918265223503113,
-0.5042420625686646,
0.32336992025375366,
-0.8711181282997131,
0.2692423164844513,
0.14959529042243958,
-0.10212188959121704,
-0.4001041054725647,
-0.35317158699035645,
0.01904713734984398,
-0.30128592252731323,
0.15091325342655182,
0.04725215584039688,
0.9929028153419495,
0.13346919417381287,
-0.20174230635166168,
-0.26469963788986206,
-0.7072917222976685,
0.7592970728874207,
-0.8432995676994324,
0.7296293377876282,
0.21295639872550964,
0.34621527791023254,
-0.04501480236649513,
-0.19337323307991028,
-0.47601187229156494,
-0.28159719705581665,
-0.28996628522872925,
-0.1234407052397728,
-0.1904773712158203,
-0.179839089512825,
0.14949563145637512,
0.048178449273109436,
-1.0285251140594482,
0.3266979455947876,
-0.4802776575088501,
-0.2869071364402771,
0.4493025839328766,
-0.11817790567874908,
0.25045454502105713,
-0.13425272703170776,
-0.3793655335903168,
-0.32019925117492676,
-0.8191626071929932,
-0.02109687589108944,
0.3636312782764435,
0.3333567976951599,
-0.04532996192574501,
0.32954660058021545,
0.24000558257102966,
0.47585079073905945,
-0.27144190669059753,
0.10316857695579529,
0.48313918709754944,
0.21036642789840698,
-0.508160412311554,
-0.13968046009540558,
0.6521344780921936,
0.43573760986328125,
0.4847426414489746,
-0.3444370925426483,
-0.3238583207130432,
0.18364731967449188,
0.22631192207336426,
-0.48025813698768616,
-0.2761772572994232,
0.09126169979572296,
-0.788101315498352,
-0.052846476435661316,
0.11651141196489334,
-0.4459700584411621,
-0.28563281893730164,
-0.6828889846801758,
0.63853520154953,
-0.4056781530380249,
-0.382383793592453,
0.004572438541799784,
-0.18315789103507996,
0.4900868535041809,
0.07565287500619888,
-1.034714698791504,
0.5742785930633545,
1.2553409337997437,
0.8522443771362305,
0.058365125209093094,
-0.38535287976264954,
-0.0714336633682251,
-0.06165316700935364,
-0.5387879610061646,
0.5512455701828003,
-0.8748152256011963,
-0.23183883726596832,
0.011384780518710613,
-0.31893226504325867,
0.0987766906619072,
-0.9571936726570129,
-0.04840636998414993,
-0.47785684466362,
0.18856455385684967,
-0.44030842185020447,
-0.6555098295211792,
-0.36620771884918213,
0.21363584697246552,
-0.7116076946258545,
1.1584391593933105,
0.07347787916660309,
-0.7389366030693054,
0.5040413737297058,
-0.6524103879928589,
-0.1813793182373047,
-0.3064652979373932,
-0.5872101187705994,
-0.43427103757858276,
0.3937186300754547,
0.23689162731170654,
0.6542051434516907,
-0.10023104399442673,
-0.18584956228733063,
-0.396426796913147,
-0.34857600927352905,
0.19416022300720215,
-0.11637094616889954,
0.8191096782684326,
0.5422137379646301,
-0.23753920197486877,
-0.22761112451553345,
-0.8843672871589661,
0.09446007013320923,
0.3572133183479309,
-0.28708919882774353,
-0.5427838563919067,
0.26613321900367737,
-0.29543057084083557,
0.2023475021123886,
0.47142550349235535,
-0.4311490058898926,
0.20107430219650269,
-0.2312139868736267,
0.3758585751056671,
0.7405966520309448,
-0.19080783426761627,
0.5353549122810364,
-0.25554224848747253,
0.2479756474494934,
0.2941030263900757,
0.15422464907169342,
-0.1272078901529312,
-0.6226249933242798,
-0.7924178242683411,
-0.08821965008974075,
0.2720029056072235,
0.6500102281570435,
-0.4034596383571625,
0.14443045854568481,
-0.19692550599575043,
-0.468250036239624,
-1.0473214387893677,
0.047545015811920166,
0.6871501803398132,
0.1141158863902092,
0.3961992859840393,
-0.6826804280281067,
-0.6183576583862305,
-1.2676441669464111,
-0.2682362198829651,
-0.27393239736557007,
-0.42653149366378784,
0.5575597882270813,
0.26628047227859497,
0.04712213948369026,
0.5471556782722473,
-0.2303054928779602,
0.15706852078437805,
0.007402803283184767,
0.29054272174835205,
0.1552375853061676,
0.4201396405696869,
1.1740092039108276,
-0.5851761102676392,
-0.48358210921287537,
0.454257071018219,
-0.8864465355873108,
0.024934295564889908,
0.10376104712486267,
0.09759171307086945,
-0.0533294752240181,
0.45868128538131714,
-0.4272092878818512,
0.17867127060890198,
0.6399374604225159,
-0.067039355635643,
0.36697277426719666,
-0.3603212237358093,
0.5015604496002197,
-1.0190411806106567,
-0.17811475694179535,
-0.16106989979743958,
0.0670427531003952,
-0.5984078049659729,
0.2665289044380188,
0.03407067805528641,
-0.1467905193567276,
-0.3879289925098419,
0.558738112449646,
-0.6122401356697083,
-0.7284597754478455,
-0.14773555099964142,
0.07681523263454437,
0.1103738471865654,
0.7267299294471741,
0.040640607476234436,
0.848867654800415,
0.742342472076416,
-0.6317840814590454,
0.042769499123096466,
0.0711434930562973,
-0.6503591537475586,
0.3700733184814453,
-0.5283769965171814,
0.5432912111282349,
-0.23016585409641266,
-0.030147189274430275,
-0.8538762331008911,
0.2826666831970215,
0.10983212292194366,
-0.7973111867904663,
0.21790848672389984,
-0.1602851301431656,
-0.6084142923355103,
-0.28420940041542053,
-0.23016996681690216,
0.25702232122421265,
0.8554890155792236,
-0.28803202509880066,
0.6109533309936523,
0.3823811709880829,
-0.3997509777545929,
-0.7553924918174744,
-0.9985644817352295,
0.0043866257183253765,
-0.1657773107290268,
-0.4909054934978485,
0.040371138602495193,
0.19421601295471191,
-0.4083133935928345,
0.1268572211265564,
0.1393623650074005,
-0.40478765964508057,
0.2240273505449295,
0.19854247570037842,
0.17697225511074066,
-0.8198389410972595,
0.1915993094444275,
-0.01130963210016489,
0.1820601373910904,
0.05848216265439987,
-0.5730369091033936,
0.523930549621582,
0.12398774176836014,
-0.4605286419391632,
-0.48180627822875977,
0.5808295011520386,
0.5198585987091064,
-0.5130963921546936,
0.9339531660079956,
0.6644972562789917,
-0.19958512485027313,
-0.20608797669410706,
-0.5149668455123901,
-0.31060272455215454,
-0.4224666953086853,
0.6175726652145386,
-0.7570822834968567,
-0.8783179521560669,
0.7287644147872925,
0.013607841916382313,
0.4045218825340271,
0.25888878107070923,
0.8758304119110107,
-0.3828992247581482,
1.1007230281829834,
0.9135665893554688,
-0.2722960114479065,
0.5555993318557739,
-0.1106191873550415,
0.27116504311561584,
-0.8864492177963257,
-0.2984623908996582,
-0.8369894027709961,
-0.6777787804603577,
-0.3559839725494385,
-0.525781512260437,
-0.0923202708363533,
-0.09177659451961517,
-0.3383050262928009,
0.701991081237793,
-0.4942851662635803,
0.587380051612854,
0.5144276022911072,
-0.15784130990505219,
0.03507322072982788,
0.17754071950912476,
-0.5494595766067505,
-0.1668512374162674,
-0.7802168726921082,
-0.8565003275871277,
1.2150025367736816,
0.376140296459198,
0.4473327100276947,
0.2066192924976349,
0.5534886121749878,
0.4106672704219818,
0.34750431776046753,
-0.39692968130111694,
0.5756614804267883,
-0.4066677689552307,
-0.5759490132331848,
0.08491985499858856,
-0.44610944390296936,
-0.91808021068573,
0.5218443274497986,
-0.3008096218109131,
-0.9047839641571045,
0.20762203633785248,
-0.0020458768121898174,
-0.04864361882209778,
0.7769619822502136,
-0.8241873979568481,
0.5671311616897583,
-0.10645965486764908,
0.26574215292930603,
-0.3757854700088501,
-0.5517560243606567,
0.10148242861032486,
0.05554869771003723,
0.2981695234775543,
-0.26134252548217773,
0.0803886279463768,
0.6512481570243835,
-0.008868735283613205,
0.5235811471939087,
-0.11653526872396469,
-0.062047116458415985,
0.2565764784812927,
0.49000978469848633,
0.09041918069124222,
-0.48678532242774963,
-0.31353437900543213,
0.5772988200187683,
-0.07386185228824615,
-0.5165631175041199,
-0.916475236415863,
0.4955286681652069,
-1.0885032415390015,
-0.44525137543678284,
0.17066003382205963,
-0.5932724475860596,
-0.1543881595134735,
-0.14069098234176636,
0.11507982015609741,
0.43494197726249695,
-0.45612093806266785,
-0.03607182204723358,
0.42558205127716064,
-0.159853994846344,
0.20880378782749176,
0.49325835704803467,
-0.4754958152770996,
-0.019709479063749313,
0.5776201486587524,
-0.02237694337964058,
0.3927927613258362,
0.7359219789505005,
-0.1489603966474533,
-0.07116607576608658,
-0.6189442276954651,
-0.29263588786125183,
0.1929115355014801,
-0.7560558319091797,
0.13830888271331787,
-0.5513169169425964,
-0.309872031211853,
-0.4437877833843231,
-0.06785410642623901,
-0.4925975799560547,
-0.3764016628265381,
0.05487838014960289,
-0.021153094246983528,
-0.062751404941082,
1.181917428970337,
-0.06270863115787506,
0.2228066474199295,
-0.7257338762283325,
-0.0484430231153965,
0.3068537712097168,
0.10265743732452393,
0.2871324121952057,
-0.6707891821861267,
-0.4136924147605896,
0.19688871502876282,
-0.24004106223583221,
-0.7458223700523376,
0.12868279218673706,
0.33249151706695557,
0.7118239998817444,
0.5987467169761658,
-0.6369487643241882,
0.40133368968963623,
-1.008192539215088,
0.8456103801727295,
0.11350911855697632,
-0.8263702392578125,
0.4864264726638794,
0.19338218867778778,
0.0399971567094326,
0.3677913248538971,
0.5431138277053833,
-0.5631071925163269,
-0.5783827900886536,
-0.5727651715278625,
-0.14618487656116486,
0.3263981342315674,
0.3746934235095978,
0.3118855953216553,
-0.02352377213537693,
0.42225557565689087,
0.42897382378578186,
0.04620629549026489,
-0.5812696218490601,
-0.2977412939071655,
-0.00278152315877378,
-0.20257294178009033,
-0.029171908274292946,
-0.08140022307634354,
-0.012972512282431126,
0.07434015721082687,
0.33988991379737854,
0.1556924432516098,
0.6841817498207092,
-0.12165656685829163,
-0.14152510464191437,
0.19886475801467896,
0.29654476046562195,
0.4597146511077881,
0.5325989127159119,
-0.16059917211532593,
0.33022794127464294,
0.21581301093101501,
-0.26061302423477173,
0.04866506904363632,
-0.46000248193740845,
-0.05026043951511383,
0.47769755125045776,
0.5646540522575378,
1.1114330291748047,
0.22285903990268707,
-0.3606458008289337,
0.30510589480400085,
0.001911804429255426,
-0.29794842004776,
0.47506803274154663,
0.2248937487602234,
0.18504667282104492,
0.5712300539016724,
0.014169018715620041,
0.3441828787326813,
0.013292600400745869,
-0.8536803722381592,
0.263006329536438,
0.40263864398002625,
-0.3156087398529053,
-0.5361520051956177,
0.5465270280838013,
0.13399367034435272,
-0.6558160185813904,
0.5513920187950134,
-0.24606890976428986,
-0.5319889187812805,
0.8917471766471863,
0.42935171723365784,
0.8997316956520081,
-0.37462201714515686,
0.00940646417438984,
0.3252217471599579,
0.4311729967594147,
0.10115215182304382,
0.15670514106750488,
-0.23708048462867737,
-0.9897472262382507,
-0.25591161847114563,
-0.6516407132148743,
-0.3628734350204468,
0.07217258960008621,
-0.8132888078689575,
0.16181442141532898,
-0.6559426784515381,
-0.299615740776062,
0.32607951760292053,
-0.1984412670135498,
-0.8759748935699463,
0.05995320528745651,
0.6227652430534363,
0.7346229553222656,
-1.0587222576141357,
0.9172208905220032,
0.8028815388679504,
-0.15394026041030884,
-0.8034313321113586,
-0.09166277945041656,
0.1595858633518219,
-1.0995463132858276,
0.7920916676521301,
0.01893441751599312,
-0.0730779692530632,
-0.29685157537460327,
-0.2549097239971161,
-0.7132458090782166,
0.9270429611206055,
0.5742936730384827,
-0.682661235332489,
0.03817937895655632,
0.2207629233598709,
0.6129404306411743,
-0.8604849576950073,
0.08303486555814743,
0.5289751291275024,
0.2115769237279892,
-0.18593202531337738,
-1.2051880359649658,
-0.3884347975254059,
-0.11550942063331604,
0.09980226308107376,
0.24756589531898499,
-0.391435444355011,
1.041578769683838,
-0.30317428708076477,
-0.3411750793457031,
0.06865289062261581,
0.5332227349281311,
0.05093975365161896,
0.0486290268599987,
0.27472755312919617,
0.5517097115516663,
0.774653434753418,
-0.018737711012363434,
0.9459176659584045,
-0.4054013788700104,
0.7186683416366577,
1.2402235269546509,
-0.3490833640098572,
1.206068992614746,
0.168904110789299,
-0.7007179856300354,
0.6503743529319763,
0.7002903819084167,
-0.23065368831157684,
0.592522919178009,
0.08366084843873978,
0.2043156921863556,
-0.017887379974126816,
0.3276439309120178,
-0.52821284532547,
0.4538957178592682,
0.19775277376174927,
-0.6214115619659424,
-0.2417653501033783,
-0.1084081381559372,
0.08459916710853577,
0.0643862634897232,
-0.3312387764453888,
0.8308216333389282,
0.2384488880634308,
-0.4818997383117676,
0.49115362763404846,
-0.06405503302812576,
0.47122839093208313,
-0.5427317023277283,
0.08669634163379669,
-0.23189353942871094,
0.07881274819374084,
0.09759892523288727,
-0.8924079537391663,
0.33799421787261963,
0.09620136767625809,
-0.2767733037471771,
0.044539984315633774,
0.40914079546928406,
-0.5003838539123535,
-0.4352167248725891,
0.6390434503555298,
0.7005971670150757,
0.5069243907928467,
0.10145175457000732,
-1.140488624572754,
0.17469251155853271,
-0.026158887892961502,
-0.042845044285058975,
0.21533672511577606,
0.45403897762298584,
0.05830607935786247,
0.6273967027664185,
0.3868454694747925,
0.33251768350601196,
0.40081363916397095,
0.3560104966163635,
0.41660481691360474,
-0.49154287576675415,
-0.433896541595459,
-0.995910108089447,
-0.007620078045874834,
-0.05189131572842598,
-0.14448030292987823,
0.47757819294929504,
0.5851685404777527,
1.0798704624176025,
-0.22006253898143768,
0.570116400718689,
0.18654285371303558,
0.45560166239738464,
-0.684358537197113,
0.7623090744018555,
-0.687299907207489,
0.3090662360191345,
-0.05625297874212265,
-1.6108624935150146,
-0.27500903606414795,
0.7361302971839905,
-0.15499283373355865,
0.17452572286128998,
0.8343517184257507,
0.9900603890419006,
-0.31374862790107727,
-0.13552361726760864,
0.5872877240180969,
0.43602195382118225,
0.11152093857526779,
0.7969955801963806,
0.7633190155029297,
-0.23557758331298828,
0.2281409204006195,
0.03901175782084465,
-0.12039509415626526,
-0.13114143908023834,
-0.5928722023963928,
-0.8939139246940613,
-0.7360301613807678,
-0.2979643642902374,
0.06863978505134583,
0.21664710342884064,
0.8368415832519531,
0.9124326109886169,
-0.945023238658905,
-0.2019578218460083,
0.5051178336143494,
-0.06831856071949005,
-0.44062480330467224,
-0.08933603763580322,
0.45000597834587097,
-0.2448887676000595,
-0.7487885355949402,
0.18274249136447906,
0.7517411708831787,
-0.0011662704637274146,
-0.5809586644172668,
-0.04328199848532677,
0.07611133903265,
0.6168968677520752,
0.5168632864952087,
0.0202039647847414,
-0.9146524667739868,
-0.5466394424438477,
-0.1682671457529068,
-0.38347384333610535,
0.5969461798667908,
0.9958264231681824,
-0.768930196762085,
0.25773724913597107,
0.44721269607543945,
0.7277776002883911,
0.1852717101573944,
-0.4606782793998718,
0.41012728214263916,
-0.6813002824783325,
0.48477455973625183,
0.027682531625032425,
0.5126616954803467,
0.4526708722114563,
-0.10514198988676071,
0.4852542281150818,
-0.08278535306453705,
-0.45814016461372375,
-0.46908363699913025,
0.5268218517303467,
-0.9660037159919739,
-0.4834730625152588,
0.8437378406524658,
-0.39774954319000244,
-0.30066898465156555,
0.11679340153932571,
-0.034376826137304306,
0.0190934669226408,
-0.04579051211476326,
0.9443198442459106,
0.9551488161087036,
0.011604266241192818,
-0.012892731465399265,
-0.6138201355934143,
0.24991416931152344,
0.42348527908325195,
-0.38119766116142273,
-0.09626230597496033,
-0.047768548130989075,
0.5174621343612671,
0.12672172486782074,
0.2672841548919678,
-0.22246649861335754,
0.18430082499980927,
0.29178187251091003,
0.16090275347232819,
-0.009412706829607487,
-0.3087695837020874,
-0.26999631524086,
0.06576232612133026,
0.01161552406847477,
-0.30474579334259033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12618v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12618v1 | From Insights to Actions: The Impact of Interpretability and Analysis Research on NLP | 2024-06-18T13:45:07 | 2024-06-18T13:45:07 | Marius Mosbach, Vagrant Gautam, Tomás Vergara-Browne, Dietrich Klakow, Mor Geva | cs.CL | cs.CL | Interpretability and analysis (IA) research is a growing subfield within NLP
with the goal of developing a deeper understanding of the behavior or inner
workings of NLP systems and methods. Despite growing interest in the subfield,
a commonly voiced criticism is that it lacks actionable insights and therefore
has little impact on NLP. In this paper, we seek to quantify the impact of IA
research on the broader field of NLP. We approach this with a mixed-methods
analysis of: (1) a citation graph of 185K+ papers built from all papers
published at ACL and EMNLP conferences from 2018 to 2023, and (2) a survey of
138 members of the NLP community. Our quantitative results show that IA work is
well-cited outside of IA, and central in the NLP citation graph. Through
qualitative analysis of survey responses and manual annotation of 556 papers,
we find that NLP researchers build on findings from IA work and perceive it is
important for progress in NLP, multiple subfields, and rely on its findings and
terminology for their own work. Many novel methods are proposed based on IA
findings and highly influenced by them, but highly influential non-IA work
cites IA findings without being driven by them. We end by summarizing what is
missing in IA work today and provide a call to action, to pave the way for a
more impactful future of IA research. | [
-0.1553650200366974,
-0.5952811241149902,
0.38130366802215576,
0.4213910698890686,
0.10329550504684448,
0.06952985376119614,
0.12489805370569229,
-0.970317542552948,
0.6823060512542725,
0.3012063801288605,
-0.13765230774879456,
-0.15699109435081482,
-0.9060528874397278,
0.2562151253223419,
-0.6903026700019836,
1.0308489799499512,
0.19140823185443878,
-0.14922703802585602,
-0.2328421026468277,
-0.527511715888977,
-0.5739695429801941,
-0.4103493094444275,
-0.7382870316505432,
-0.289879709482193,
0.7104687094688416,
0.11883515119552612,
0.5294861197471619,
0.331455260515213,
0.6315853595733643,
0.18725207448005676,
-0.4671328663825989,
-0.04203592240810394,
-0.342610239982605,
-0.09113263338804245,
-0.2930918037891388,
-0.601370632648468,
-0.6594424247741699,
0.05991441383957863,
0.6391753554344177,
1.052811861038208,
-0.035730015486478806,
0.16393223404884338,
0.26117053627967834,
0.5334821343421936,
-0.6279641389846802,
0.16660818457603455,
-0.3360452353954315,
0.06042955815792084,
-0.3159945607185364,
-0.41595888137817383,
-0.4217102527618408,
0.067881278693676,
0.43145880103111267,
-0.4992803633213043,
-0.15314941108226776,
0.09183289110660553,
0.4068793058395386,
0.198947936296463,
-0.5416662096977234,
-0.48076537251472473,
-0.9885116815567017,
0.9579489231109619,
-0.9152889251708984,
0.10520899295806885,
0.2408342808485031,
-0.017206113785505295,
-0.15377509593963623,
-1.101725697517395,
-0.34840628504753113,
0.3135741353034973,
-0.5159447193145752,
0.18009857833385468,
-0.4749120771884918,
-0.14542342722415924,
0.24169501662254333,
0.3297753930091858,
-0.1739962249994278,
-0.011758428998291492,
-0.5346861481666565,
0.233401358127594,
0.6963108777999878,
0.2486804574728012,
0.3299870789051056,
-0.005044468212872744,
0.009259787388145924,
0.09503971040248871,
-0.43383315205574036,
0.18874745070934296,
-0.021618677303195,
0.1692267656326294,
-0.12610186636447906,
0.668742299079895,
-0.08509530127048492,
0.41833969950675964,
-0.25009751319885254,
-0.06314888596534729,
0.11066384613513947,
-0.35339465737342834,
-0.1771392673254013,
-0.3587456941604614,
0.578586220741272,
0.15779568254947662,
-0.23708771169185638,
-0.3401493430137634,
0.08746644109487534,
-0.28013908863067627,
0.5192807912826538,
-0.4157435894012451,
-0.2454252988100052,
0.43382737040519714,
-0.7105598449707031,
-0.002730190521106124,
-0.044632669538259506,
-0.920142412185669,
-0.513418972492218,
-0.47990313172340393,
0.17716342210769653,
-0.2429957538843155,
-0.6707262992858887,
-0.19152459502220154,
-0.2656042277812958,
0.5426945090293884,
0.4112565517425537,
-0.539820671081543,
0.2540818750858307,
0.7828357219696045,
0.9993224740028381,
-0.3238428235054016,
-0.2850402295589447,
-0.26335927844047546,
-0.20775499939918518,
-0.3286207318305969,
0.8363650441169739,
-0.6114339828491211,
-0.4353030323982239,
0.15186947584152222,
-0.2222679704427719,
-0.45812883973121643,
-0.3645651340484619,
0.6412603259086609,
-0.5578804612159729,
-0.059695858508348465,
-0.045372575521469116,
-0.5987938046455383,
-0.5199079513549805,
0.3346904516220093,
-0.6622265577316284,
0.7949928641319275,
-0.21056587994098663,
-0.7791010141372681,
0.4213634133338928,
-1.0503555536270142,
-0.39472880959510803,
0.13071440160274506,
-0.030292797833681107,
-0.10522036254405975,
0.5211696028709412,
-0.01092697773128748,
0.1510351449251175,
-0.18270185589790344,
0.256599485874176,
-0.1924227625131607,
-0.1811763048171997,
0.3458464741706848,
-0.30256399512290955,
1.2013520002365112,
0.0166335366666317,
-0.4647253453731537,
-0.029516732320189476,
-1.130587100982666,
0.17182856798171997,
-0.12140018492937088,
-0.19876879453659058,
-0.5464702844619751,
0.33696696162223816,
0.295454740524292,
0.13372096419334412,
-0.025068307295441628,
-0.2437315732240677,
0.046521201729774475,
-0.5679084658622742,
0.2549024224281311,
0.3568856120109558,
0.06793253868818283,
0.48646897077560425,
0.07915589958429337,
0.9477206468582153,
-0.47994598746299744,
0.15465538203716278,
0.09488305449485779,
-0.6704813838005066,
-0.9208695888519287,
-0.08621428161859512,
0.3443274199962616,
0.2959924042224884,
-0.5479126572608948,
0.39251092076301575,
-0.20991411805152893,
-0.6623571515083313,
-0.6128891706466675,
-0.17251905798912048,
0.29159224033355713,
0.41799038648605347,
0.5979406833648682,
-0.39830440282821655,
-0.6994984745979309,
-0.7575221657752991,
-0.7192944884300232,
-0.1957731992006302,
0.08627200871706009,
0.04016207158565521,
0.7701534032821655,
-0.225128173828125,
1.0192114114761353,
-0.2707187533378601,
-0.4480557143688202,
-0.314547061920166,
0.45339223742485046,
0.010754307731986046,
0.3277374505996704,
0.5132073163986206,
-0.7706608176231384,
-0.5005788207054138,
-0.13779164850711823,
-0.9264436364173889,
-0.07064207643270493,
-0.08023900538682938,
-0.017303254455327988,
-0.26145875453948975,
0.5816535353660583,
-0.30947476625442505,
0.8716932535171509,
0.5962079167366028,
-0.6546679735183716,
0.4035768508911133,
0.20649079978466034,
-0.22677081823349,
-0.6071650385856628,
0.70289546251297,
-0.11135249584913254,
0.31468909978866577,
-0.8244292736053467,
0.11762264370918274,
-0.23791544139385223,
-0.019677191972732544,
-0.2709517478942871,
0.621259868144989,
-0.401494562625885,
-0.11009685695171356,
-0.5157719254493713,
-0.2053675651550293,
0.1670275777578354,
0.23156417906284332,
-0.07336404174566269,
0.44608429074287415,
0.4882500469684601,
-0.6099924445152283,
-0.3290953040122986,
0.30853232741355896,
-0.24951522052288055,
0.6387363076210022,
-0.8319947123527527,
0.1390516757965088,
-0.014565634541213512,
0.3379184305667877,
-0.4883876144886017,
0.022707821801304817,
0.3727727234363556,
-0.4520081877708435,
0.04937303438782692,
-0.1789955198764801,
-0.313477486371994,
0.18810392916202545,
-0.02978469245135784,
0.5046548843383789,
-0.026741094887256622,
-0.3634336292743683,
1.3228732347488403,
0.39072421193122864,
-0.07005048543214798,
-0.6992553472518921,
-0.6742034554481506,
0.2988851070404053,
-0.3410005569458008,
-0.4589415490627289,
0.11855622380971909,
0.008322232402861118,
-0.9547272324562073,
0.24146270751953125,
-0.13151749968528748,
-0.0656791552901268,
0.38100236654281616,
0.19721867144107819,
-0.1552787870168686,
-0.18596796691417694,
-0.009270367212593555,
-0.09749936312437057,
-0.2758830189704895,
0.44766491651535034,
0.06373979896306992,
0.25536325573921204,
-0.19724330306053162,
-0.3171704411506653,
-0.34448543190956116,
0.6717216372489929,
0.2912823557853699,
-0.4383123219013214,
0.969021201133728,
0.37246015667915344,
0.0014392704470083117,
-0.21807202696800232,
0.1536581963300705,
0.142912358045578,
-0.37303248047828674,
0.15516741573810577,
0.02560572512447834,
-0.46564531326293945,
0.48916491866111755,
-0.052927166223526,
0.7467962503433228,
0.8140943050384521,
0.10061424225568771,
-0.23105177283287048,
0.8255633115768433,
0.9623891115188599,
0.31236836314201355,
0.5572073459625244,
-0.45316919684410095,
0.6102880239486694,
-0.9915804862976074,
-0.23843640089035034,
-0.6900107860565186,
-0.5723814964294434,
-0.5240612626075745,
-0.1999513953924179,
0.3316982090473175,
0.01340262871235609,
0.5355821847915649,
0.02303086407482624,
-0.3752223253250122,
0.13662925362586975,
0.600311279296875,
-0.28917303681373596,
0.5001994371414185,
-0.43876293301582336,
0.5756977200508118,
-0.1790069043636322,
-0.5152046084403992,
-0.32254040241241455,
1.3098796606063843,
0.35926905274391174,
0.35129958391189575,
0.2807781994342804,
0.45792356133461,
0.4436611831188202,
0.5684770941734314,
-1.1779743432998657,
0.3249002993106842,
0.25735148787498474,
-0.7919224500656128,
-0.10195941478013992,
-0.3581109046936035,
-1.1650816202163696,
0.5523144602775574,
-0.3442959487438202,
-0.5565695762634277,
0.4326912462711334,
0.056149743497371674,
-0.09204541146755219,
0.03674202039837837,
-0.7160719633102417,
0.4573955237865448,
-0.08564022928476334,
0.05069040134549141,
-0.2499602735042572,
-0.658997654914856,
0.15858307480812073,
0.09846210479736328,
0.7102669477462769,
0.14723122119903564,
0.12669438123703003,
1.2190393209457397,
-0.22895000874996185,
0.9118800759315491,
-0.18236342072486877,
-0.07893329858779907,
0.3239307403564453,
-0.22216759622097015,
0.3404942452907562,
-0.03220764175057411,
-0.04370826482772827,
0.48685985803604126,
0.14414192736148834,
-0.464101105928421,
-0.8050891757011414,
0.4084628224372864,
-0.2912379503250122,
-0.4378302991390228,
-0.8683324456214905,
-0.5145810842514038,
-0.31662505865097046,
0.1894221007823944,
0.014780676923692226,
0.45107579231262207,
-0.06302638351917267,
0.36683711409568787,
0.2734377086162567,
0.036656901240348816,
0.4886626601219177,
0.3847956657409668,
-0.12327521294355392,
-0.2792123854160309,
0.6053000688552856,
0.3457682728767395,
-0.09171631187200546,
0.28513768315315247,
0.13602931797504425,
0.018158799037337303,
-0.8431190252304077,
0.06867363303899765,
0.16810958087444305,
-0.6994220018386841,
0.023903116583824158,
-0.7544870972633362,
0.009890610352158546,
-0.3729623854160309,
-0.11113084852695465,
-0.433393657207489,
-0.44346386194229126,
-0.21921516954898834,
-0.004720326978713274,
0.18554028868675232,
0.7941164374351501,
-0.27693498134613037,
0.45541563630104065,
-0.5918113589286804,
0.038467276841402054,
0.044866420328617096,
0.2272701859474182,
0.48468196392059326,
-0.5196739435195923,
-0.7497767806053162,
-0.19309598207473755,
-0.1508360654115677,
-0.5431150197982788,
0.4184304177761078,
0.17308206856250763,
0.3374095559120178,
0.31575095653533936,
-0.024155450984835625,
0.8183733224868774,
-0.2189670354127884,
0.7969388961791992,
0.10946131497621536,
-0.8446984887123108,
0.4992094933986664,
0.022960711270570755,
0.15724393725395203,
0.7338850498199463,
0.272100567817688,
-0.4075177013874054,
-0.2845703065395355,
-0.8905177712440491,
-1.3364216089248657,
0.6734794974327087,
0.40817439556121826,
0.009884926490485668,
0.33003169298171997,
0.11928921192884445,
0.08357506990432739,
-0.05683285370469093,
-0.7872122526168823,
-0.5746893286705017,
0.14001435041427612,
0.0647849515080452,
-0.028003260493278503,
-0.07749878615140915,
-0.4271444082260132,
-0.3387368321418762,
0.5072993040084839,
-0.20016241073608398,
0.23105409741401672,
0.08352541923522949,
0.08074863255023956,
0.1828128546476364,
0.23725293576717377,
0.1530027538537979,
1.1545848846435547,
-0.19551251828670502,
0.12128902971744537,
-0.1294533610343933,
-0.4582248032093048,
-0.49562427401542664,
0.11225733160972595,
-0.5196322202682495,
0.06457467377185822,
0.9730848073959351,
0.5342575311660767,
0.10969436168670654,
-0.6953188180923462,
0.22473132610321045,
-0.16946852207183838,
-0.004938189871609211,
-0.5249701142311096,
-0.04370458424091339,
-0.1929103434085846,
0.2749529182910919,
0.6083004474639893,
0.4934573769569397,
0.550586462020874,
-0.8024026155471802,
-0.10242876410484314,
0.2224884331226349,
-0.5632107257843018,
-0.5078786015510559,
0.3781178593635559,
0.199067622423172,
-0.30824267864227295,
0.2281579077243805,
0.27465754747390747,
-0.21352460980415344,
0.5831130146980286,
0.272019624710083,
0.762441873550415,
0.3662429451942444,
0.050081055611371994,
0.17477500438690186,
0.3187773823738098,
0.20296454429626465,
0.0702921450138092,
0.13664399087429047,
-0.32888415455818176,
-0.7201136350631714,
-0.5720303058624268,
-0.5413110256195068,
0.2880491316318512,
-0.9579530954360962,
-0.053873755037784576,
-0.2965084910392761,
0.0220478642731905,
0.37057098746299744,
0.025922056287527084,
-0.595957338809967,
0.3945785164833069,
-0.6447871327400208,
0.7781525254249573,
-0.8503977060317993,
0.3493479788303375,
0.8786261677742004,
-0.4865758717060089,
-0.5583198666572571,
0.4103698134422302,
0.20379270613193512,
-0.5705858469009399,
0.23977124691009521,
-0.04332295060157776,
-0.05104504153132439,
-0.09028731286525726,
-0.6863802075386047,
-1.0849992036819458,
0.8905339241027832,
-0.21334414184093475,
0.02118588238954544,
0.07950109243392944,
-0.20948882400989532,
0.9758321642875671,
-0.2481585294008255,
0.3141787052154541,
0.7489123940467834,
0.5381098389625549,
-0.10180331021547318,
-0.7034656405448914,
-0.1831497699022293,
-0.37127333879470825,
-0.32219457626342773,
0.265334814786911,
-0.4814729690551758,
0.4196802079677582,
0.15911689400672913,
-0.265440970659256,
-0.17299634218215942,
1.0028495788574219,
0.02070603519678116,
0.8526838421821594,
0.28411969542503357,
0.3681008815765381,
0.5522544980049133,
0.21919885277748108,
0.9994673728942871,
0.14841122925281525,
0.09429621696472168,
1.1244759559631348,
0.11820247769355774,
1.0243241786956787,
0.8852872848510742,
-0.2763439416885376,
0.42551761865615845,
0.15099415183067322,
0.14493310451507568,
0.3820284903049469,
-0.23206953704357147,
0.03982730209827423,
0.1867348849773407,
-0.3607872426509857,
-0.2736530601978302,
0.7335875034332275,
0.621545672416687,
-0.3997316062450409,
0.05224383622407913,
-0.12468641996383667,
0.18248532712459564,
0.12172874063253403,
-0.1917949616909027,
0.7830518484115601,
0.36898666620254517,
-0.6485687494277954,
0.14546285569667816,
-0.09087570011615753,
0.6417015790939331,
-0.5492393970489502,
-0.24104951322078705,
-0.2452656775712967,
0.004404764156788588,
-0.4696097671985626,
-0.9194988012313843,
1.0523196458816528,
0.04636960104107857,
-0.059295326471328735,
-0.4045921862125397,
0.6329420208930969,
0.10642603039741516,
-0.26088404655456543,
0.6249926686286926,
0.8478720188140869,
0.14122144877910614,
0.05072299763560295,
-0.47479745745658875,
-0.00523802824318409,
0.07934867590665817,
-0.3354266881942749,
0.5283368825912476,
0.5932555198669434,
0.2460928112268448,
0.33824700117111206,
0.5815233588218689,
0.20283164083957672,
-0.07168257981538773,
-0.16071279346942902,
0.6017409563064575,
-0.650188148021698,
-0.07646917551755905,
-0.6022354364395142,
0.7927286624908447,
-0.17758376896381378,
-0.9016715884208679,
0.9162821769714355,
0.27400872111320496,
0.4370926022529602,
0.3133702576160431,
0.6922429800033569,
-0.759698212146759,
0.6025380492210388,
-0.41520819067955017,
0.5906863212585449,
-0.7890951633453369,
0.39404019713401794,
-0.17484386265277863,
-0.7468748092651367,
-0.5395969748497009,
0.25751808285713196,
-0.2581832706928253,
-0.10181199759244919,
0.6988334059715271,
0.111519955098629,
-0.01888982579112053,
0.1586240977048874,
0.05133858695626259,
0.21452312171459198,
0.47654807567596436,
-0.3399410545825958,
0.6996675133705139,
-0.5884662866592407,
0.630215585231781,
-0.3297674357891083,
-0.4510575532913208,
-0.19933690130710602,
-0.7488754987716675,
-0.6593626737594604,
-0.5651563405990601,
-0.29431694746017456,
-0.3645111918449402,
-0.3540850877761841,
0.3804962635040283,
0.33102768659591675,
-0.848621129989624,
-0.07671715319156647,
-0.1762743890285492,
0.17242316901683807,
-0.6607005000114441,
-0.3628348410129547,
0.6377899646759033,
-0.1693640649318695,
-0.7264782786369324,
0.59401935338974,
0.13568177819252014,
-0.45707935094833374,
-0.09929344803094864,
0.11206664890050888,
-0.44736576080322266,
0.10817661881446838,
0.8688485622406006,
0.6955702900886536,
-0.5647851824760437,
-0.10141230374574661,
0.043025173246860504,
0.4118962585926056,
0.11066252738237381,
0.8907604813575745,
-0.3482961058616638,
0.49209684133529663,
0.4253852665424347,
0.6696766018867493,
0.27278661727905273,
-0.101150281727314,
0.772673487663269,
-0.6892126202583313,
-0.22474487125873566,
0.649622917175293,
0.35552534461021423,
0.08982864022254944,
-0.10824597626924515,
1.0386297702789307,
0.1416492462158203,
-0.5665938258171082,
-0.7421042919158936,
0.10287661850452423,
-1.0427627563476562,
-0.29048603773117065,
1.030400037765503,
-0.35683107376098633,
0.04454507678747177,
-0.5176447629928589,
0.021603301167488098,
-0.14387233555316925,
-0.3774528503417969,
0.9540907740592957,
0.6686554551124573,
-0.780961275100708,
-0.24649828672409058,
-0.5293972492218018,
0.4788346290588379,
0.6494172811508179,
-0.9099722504615784,
-0.044583775103092194,
0.3588532507419586,
-0.2792513370513916,
0.7518279552459717,
0.675724983215332,
-0.08901236206293106,
-0.04470374435186386,
0.29178017377853394,
-0.018713686615228653,
0.45891332626342773,
-0.43528610467910767,
-0.28662416338920593,
0.10963701456785202,
0.21701385080814362,
0.2977042496204376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12614v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12614v1 | EUvsDisinfo: a Dataset for Multilingual Detection of Pro-Kremlin Disinformation in News Articles | 2024-06-18T13:43:22 | 2024-06-18T13:43:22 | João A. Leite, Olesya Razuvayevskaya, Kalina Bontcheva, Carolina Scarton | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This work introduces EUvsDisinfo, a multilingual dataset of trustworthy and
disinformation articles related to pro-Kremlin themes. It is sourced directly
from the debunk articles written by experts leading the EUvsDisinfo project.
Our dataset is the largest to-date resource in terms of the overall number of
articles and distinct languages. It also provides the largest topical and
temporal coverage. Using this dataset, we investigate the dissemination of
pro-Kremlin disinformation across different languages, uncovering
language-specific patterns targeting specific disinformation topics. We further
analyse the evolution of topic distribution over an eight-year period, noting a
significant surge in disinformation content before the full-scale invasion of
Ukraine in 2022. Lastly, we demonstrate the dataset's applicability in training
models to effectively distinguish between disinformation and trustworthy
content in multilingual settings. | [
-0.24110901355743408,
-0.5860534906387329,
0.3745902180671692,
0.18841518461704254,
-0.5423654913902283,
0.4582478404045105,
-0.21531158685684204,
-0.19563190639019012,
0.06197390705347061,
0.12228564918041229,
-0.5515916347503662,
-0.7436259388923645,
-0.6908436417579651,
0.27291178703308105,
-0.616188645362854,
0.9930011630058289,
0.0019553902093321085,
0.5694121718406677,
-0.2335565686225891,
0.00701791699975729,
0.010402432642877102,
-0.3561483323574066,
-0.026634173467755318,
-0.09174518287181854,
0.14142808318138123,
0.6921952962875366,
0.28042522072792053,
0.47036170959472656,
0.42507344484329224,
0.22603744268417358,
-0.04596571624279022,
-0.06754043698310852,
-0.45494914054870605,
0.14878317713737488,
-0.21829751133918762,
-0.3692568838596344,
0.07302264124155045,
-0.06707251816987991,
0.5343140959739685,
0.22303590178489685,
-0.6152130961418152,
0.30898308753967285,
-0.012607288546860218,
0.6895806193351746,
-0.4463038742542267,
-0.16795563697814941,
-0.507214367389679,
-0.014522201381623745,
-0.5087790489196777,
-0.06247832253575325,
-0.42605388164520264,
-0.3388541042804718,
-0.09001842886209488,
-0.6775417923927307,
0.22706358134746552,
-0.3981987535953522,
0.5909595489501953,
-0.034618861973285675,
-0.6397603154182434,
-0.5595144033432007,
-0.7070351243019104,
0.7875927090644836,
-0.08235598355531693,
0.6909212470054626,
0.44255420565605164,
0.21973982453346252,
-0.20639796555042267,
-0.5257264971733093,
-0.510615885257721,
0.1049121841788292,
0.07659175992012024,
0.2601332664489746,
-0.6092580556869507,
-0.5875654816627502,
-0.1405457854270935,
0.05678281560540199,
-0.730663001537323,
-0.0006921004969626665,
-0.6300621628761292,
-0.5852063894271851,
0.4492495059967041,
-0.3317362368106842,
0.12834036350250244,
-0.27052706480026245,
-0.5494833588600159,
0.06424790620803833,
-0.894631564617157,
-0.06298258155584335,
0.9082833528518677,
-0.024937404319643974,
-0.3586955964565277,
0.28668835759162903,
-0.42259681224823,
0.6162538528442383,
0.06517130881547928,
-0.5437803268432617,
0.42169880867004395,
-0.5839817523956299,
0.05488839000463486,
0.6140211224555969,
0.44260624051094055,
0.4850749969482422,
0.10144677758216858,
0.008500011637806892,
0.05353103578090668,
0.08872811496257782,
0.2515561282634735,
-0.7724375128746033,
-0.24406744539737701,
0.1723940670490265,
-0.31986114382743835,
-0.58985835313797,
0.37829720973968506,
-0.998458743095398,
-0.4767131805419922,
-0.18013614416122437,
0.026281237602233887,
-0.2544185221195221,
-0.3374975919723511,
0.31222131848335266,
-0.20894759893417358,
-0.5304229259490967,
0.15103541314601898,
-0.5518848896026611,
0.04719553515315056,
0.3919084072113037,
0.4845716953277588,
0.1791115701198578,
-0.12295320630073547,
-0.6952434778213501,
-0.014765194617211819,
-0.3277771472930908,
0.8158652782440186,
-0.6112371683120728,
-0.21145331859588623,
0.25799375772476196,
0.5857794880867004,
0.7194138765335083,
-0.2424127161502838,
0.7170637845993042,
-0.5824048519134521,
0.16056539118289948,
-0.3231796622276306,
-0.25161853432655334,
-0.18101893365383148,
0.22565916180610657,
-0.7445146441459656,
0.8340710997581482,
-0.052036769688129425,
-0.9177104830741882,
0.7757633924484253,
-0.3429320156574249,
-0.3739350438117981,
0.049809277057647705,
-0.14480820298194885,
-0.46118319034576416,
-0.17158888280391693,
0.056126657873392105,
0.5611327886581421,
-0.04552522301673889,
0.3303478956222534,
-0.1966240406036377,
0.03176821023225784,
0.26328516006469727,
-0.5093476176261902,
0.6692565083503723,
0.49021220207214355,
-0.25617408752441406,
-0.25259554386138916,
-0.9310161471366882,
-0.5884080529212952,
0.12297240644693375,
-0.414730429649353,
-0.8937934637069702,
0.07479672133922577,
-0.05331077054142952,
0.30183345079421997,
0.2689449191093445,
-0.9471485018730164,
-0.07458964735269547,
0.11000756919384003,
0.2262648344039917,
0.4559040069580078,
0.21199218928813934,
0.45732542872428894,
-0.04477006196975708,
0.5350261926651001,
0.7491356730461121,
0.4379488527774811,
-0.31922590732574463,
-0.15009760856628418,
-0.3521184027194977,
-0.10491117089986801,
0.22870784997940063,
0.5432581305503845,
-1.0422415733337402,
0.22288954257965088,
-0.09014734625816345,
-0.7055800557136536,
-0.344137966632843,
0.05633411929011345,
0.2869434654712677,
0.5255394577980042,
0.18734395503997803,
0.27020585536956787,
-0.860667884349823,
-1.0061427354812622,
-0.1043391078710556,
0.011440635658800602,
0.307406485080719,
-0.4073202908039093,
0.6809572577476501,
0.1506667584180832,
0.4603770077228546,
-0.2478642761707306,
-0.05283373221755028,
-0.09302736073732376,
0.1291208416223526,
0.1539333462715149,
0.30785635113716125,
0.6667832732200623,
-1.3829736709594727,
-0.788996160030365,
0.0007296756957657635,
-0.4305326044559479,
0.3837631642818451,
-0.10835462808609009,
0.20577138662338257,
0.3191080391407013,
0.4591829478740692,
-0.2246946096420288,
0.2662702202796936,
0.7877345085144043,
-0.5569515228271484,
0.37814104557037354,
-0.3260789215564728,
0.5882962346076965,
-1.5337657928466797,
-0.1051483303308487,
0.21458734571933746,
-0.334311306476593,
-0.745699405670166,
-0.40272265672683716,
0.3622315526008606,
0.18971265852451324,
-0.8438278436660767,
-0.01424871664494276,
-0.39666101336479187,
0.054627396166324615,
0.25546491146087646,
0.24242685735225677,
0.020885242149233818,
-0.21029448509216309,
-0.30145204067230225,
0.6294972896575928,
1.0077840089797974,
-0.5535882711410522,
0.7225534915924072,
0.24938908219337463,
-0.8108922839164734,
0.8339313864707947,
-0.3259209990501404,
-0.3258834183216095,
-0.40892788767814636,
0.11656786501407623,
-0.8751358389854431,
-0.27152493596076965,
0.3083646297454834,
-0.5552675127983093,
0.04613031446933746,
-0.4730965197086334,
-0.7087525129318237,
-0.14921186864376068,
-0.36924314498901367,
-0.011754613369703293,
0.20383180677890778,
-0.44945886731147766,
-0.25724783539772034,
0.6561052799224854,
-0.2422550618648529,
-1.0669840574264526,
-0.543989896774292,
-0.042144957929849625,
-0.4531385600566864,
-0.19984881579875946,
0.3212171494960785,
-0.037207670509815216,
-0.46630164980888367,
0.13160601258277893,
-0.15278084576129913,
-0.1089787408709526,
0.16995447874069214,
-0.0033498769626021385,
0.036998700350522995,
0.16709373891353607,
0.36106938123703003,
0.0008329717093147337,
-0.04976632446050644,
-0.16526813805103302,
-0.1558908224105835,
0.4737524688243866,
-0.012108728289604187,
-0.31308797001838684,
-0.7290073037147522,
0.35030266642570496,
0.7528917193412781,
-0.20895695686340332,
0.816242516040802,
0.6979748010635376,
-0.30487051606178284,
-0.1505383402109146,
-0.1817922741174698,
-0.16566568613052368,
-0.3614214360713959,
0.5288220047950745,
-0.10790160298347473,
-0.4507540166378021,
0.5274429321289062,
-0.08120450377464294,
0.00855043064802885,
0.508813738822937,
0.4044971466064453,
-0.12223490327596664,
0.8397968411445618,
0.7394611835479736,
-0.19463743269443512,
0.301852822303772,
-0.2792668044567108,
-0.15857282280921936,
-0.05214081332087517,
-0.7653318047523499,
-0.6103292107582092,
-0.1728283166885376,
-0.5822250843048096,
-0.26163578033447266,
0.005624917335808277,
0.08230635523796082,
0.10897259414196014,
0.3052201569080353,
-0.34996816515922546,
0.5598847270011902,
0.19871360063552856,
-0.3482681214809418,
0.4173140525817871,
0.5030361413955688,
-0.16095472872257233,
-0.2660558819770813,
-0.48581773042678833,
-0.34736168384552,
0.9940927028656006,
0.2949475347995758,
0.9811673760414124,
0.34426307678222656,
0.33107811212539673,
0.6925691962242126,
0.11017946898937225,
-0.41663873195648193,
0.040183279663324356,
-0.35328221321105957,
-0.6774083375930786,
-0.3141108751296997,
-0.20290611684322357,
-0.8632982969284058,
-0.09977252781391144,
-0.059364307671785355,
-0.661825954914093,
0.41744840145111084,
-0.09595802426338196,
-0.12073635309934616,
0.552425742149353,
-0.15812167525291443,
0.508142352104187,
-0.10247460752725601,
0.0230807363986969,
-0.5460211634635925,
-0.3354463577270508,
0.270929217338562,
-0.30755022168159485,
0.46327853202819824,
-0.3529895842075348,
-0.14039607346057892,
0.6773053407669067,
0.14507023990154266,
0.6224590539932251,
-0.2658637464046478,
-0.3626166582107544,
0.10129403322935104,
-0.11783594638109207,
0.4426683783531189,
0.537803053855896,
0.02738543599843979,
0.19389097392559052,
0.03529119864106178,
-0.3128083646297455,
-0.016250690445303917,
0.8413970470428467,
-0.6965116858482361,
-0.1188497394323349,
-0.5260465741157532,
-0.20803263783454895,
0.22901780903339386,
0.28337541222572327,
0.3717699944972992,
0.8080282807350159,
-0.7070145606994629,
0.7065214514732361,
0.833888590335846,
-0.014605806209146976,
0.5021485686302185,
0.960491418838501,
-0.206907719373703,
-0.49763694405555725,
0.8649367690086365,
0.3587551414966583,
-0.03433368727564812,
0.41320130228996277,
-0.17844516038894653,
-0.4504709541797638,
-0.42131948471069336,
-0.847847044467926,
0.01780552603304386,
-0.800591230392456,
-0.2812355160713196,
-0.24937860667705536,
0.11426913738250732,
-0.174968883395195,
0.21944744884967804,
-0.5876622796058655,
-0.27178123593330383,
-0.26634618639945984,
-0.26742565631866455,
0.6264131665229797,
0.8905408978462219,
-0.37648215889930725,
0.15497764945030212,
-0.7095072865486145,
0.3867765963077545,
-0.05327945202589035,
0.3671872019767761,
-0.7586053013801575,
-0.4678018391132355,
-0.6703249216079712,
0.40866512060165405,
-0.43404901027679443,
-1.2512023448944092,
0.31153401732444763,
0.0590108260512352,
0.8757789731025696,
0.6093065738677979,
0.2332954853773117,
0.19271525740623474,
-0.4621492922306061,
0.878312349319458,
0.22516696155071259,
-0.610842764377594,
0.5571696162223816,
-0.5919312834739685,
0.13739013671875,
0.4990723431110382,
1.1246587038040161,
-0.6989321708679199,
-0.22802117466926575,
-0.8199890851974487,
-0.6080990433692932,
0.7599994540214539,
0.00526663102209568,
0.15350893139839172,
-0.015648242086172104,
0.07680509239435196,
0.505882203578949,
0.3112854063510895,
-0.44555237889289856,
-0.6369155049324036,
-0.2766773998737335,
-0.08711933344602585,
-0.17696821689605713,
-0.5076400637626648,
-0.5484218597412109,
-0.09372996538877487,
0.8597273230552673,
0.024015644565224648,
-0.01043268945068121,
0.3365060091018677,
-0.29015934467315674,
-0.15672801434993744,
0.3275702893733978,
1.0359519720077515,
1.142841100692749,
0.07005403190851212,
0.272194504737854,
-0.1251094490289688,
-0.8770766258239746,
0.39869409799575806,
0.11065244674682617,
-0.173379585146904,
0.6119087338447571,
-0.08351108431816101,
0.4484465420246124,
-0.06394390016794205,
-0.6095302104949951,
0.6418761014938354,
-0.28375354409217834,
-0.6559241414070129,
-0.7282994389533997,
-0.597406804561615,
0.20729288458824158,
0.2532561421394348,
0.720819890499115,
0.03639814630150795,
0.0949644073843956,
-0.4250798523426056,
0.5756544470787048,
-0.007070146966725588,
-0.6273704767227173,
-0.7579175233840942,
0.34208860993385315,
0.33926311135292053,
-0.047731973230838776,
0.2993093430995941,
-0.09381162375211716,
-0.38612979650497437,
0.6170372366905212,
0.249189093708992,
0.359340637922287,
-0.6418554782867432,
1.0022565126419067,
0.31179261207580566,
0.37369710206985474,
0.04956778511404991,
0.6076655983924866,
0.06579390168190002,
-0.6496659517288208,
-0.24340938031673431,
-0.3378504514694214,
0.10817203670740128,
0.6886891722679138,
-0.8166606426239014,
0.31960785388946533,
0.012522303499281406,
-0.07145772129297256,
0.046132151037454605,
0.05150177329778671,
-0.4267094135284424,
0.20173227787017822,
0.31736600399017334,
0.8667424321174622,
-1.1181964874267578,
0.8125340938568115,
0.8208809494972229,
-0.028580695390701294,
0.1274658590555191,
-0.059508632868528366,
0.41452300548553467,
-0.23599687218666077,
0.5408963561058044,
0.13861796259880066,
-0.00781315565109253,
-0.1675940304994583,
-0.19675213098526,
-0.8637587428092957,
0.9987607598304749,
0.6646051406860352,
-0.6344901323318481,
0.5625078678131104,
0.27250415086746216,
0.08094542473554611,
-0.30211347341537476,
-0.5388853549957275,
0.5761815905570984,
0.5760394334793091,
-0.4396396577358246,
-0.7433899641036987,
-0.2459019273519516,
-0.2685230076313019,
-0.5935197472572327,
0.4518943130970001,
-0.7782294154167175,
0.592849850654602,
0.03485792502760887,
-0.3076249957084656,
-0.2749118208885193,
0.2800465226173401,
-0.19798003137111664,
0.28720706701278687,
0.7278857827186584,
0.47313418984413147,
0.7049363851547241,
-0.11564487963914871,
0.5205726027488708,
-0.5755400061607361,
0.29379940032958984,
0.8591087460517883,
0.15705172717571259,
0.6420578956604004,
0.6747018098831177,
0.07791035622358322,
0.5324603915214539,
0.7096362113952637,
-0.13629360496997833,
1.1043903827667236,
0.008886926807463169,
-0.4627534747123718,
-0.08909472078084946,
-0.38286149501800537,
-0.4311550259590149,
0.6898877620697021,
0.4551028907299042,
-0.2960870563983917,
-0.6018794775009155,
0.35499489307403564,
0.2366914600133896,
0.309659481048584,
-0.1014978438615799,
0.7078274488449097,
-0.33043161034584045,
-0.321379154920578,
0.28793883323669434,
0.1744215041399002,
0.3797113299369812,
-0.6618102192878723,
-0.09210142493247986,
-0.17252998054027557,
0.351027250289917,
-0.13681384921073914,
-0.9103397727012634,
0.33798956871032715,
0.17493769526481628,
-0.2625075578689575,
-0.37459903955459595,
0.6525099277496338,
-0.5751544237136841,
-0.49761223793029785,
0.2807576060295105,
0.5982329249382019,
0.22098809480667114,
0.11962109059095383,
-0.6706029772758484,
0.0617198571562767,
0.10974231362342834,
-0.23480916023254395,
0.2865486443042755,
0.6516154408454895,
0.05514010041952133,
0.5828002691268921,
0.6464152932167053,
0.20496869087219238,
-0.23556049168109894,
0.2172926366329193,
0.934304416179657,
-0.1259257197380066,
-0.6032987236976624,
-0.9531293511390686,
0.7180964946746826,
-0.3487226366996765,
-0.3214550018310547,
1.102036476135254,
0.8272853493690491,
1.1047613620758057,
-0.06494574248790741,
0.9307118654251099,
-0.0219267550855875,
0.6168788075447083,
-0.3593467175960541,
1.1537885665893555,
-0.6914654970169067,
-0.06202707439661026,
-0.052915338426828384,
-0.37135371565818787,
-0.1249186098575592,
0.16292522847652435,
-0.029741400852799416,
-0.4639820158481598,
0.45828789472579956,
0.7355586886405945,
-0.1889091432094574,
-0.08045941591262817,
0.44861719012260437,
0.22137466073036194,
0.09307459741830826,
-0.025802509859204292,
0.9679405093193054,
-0.255235880613327,
0.8358058929443359,
-0.6555309891700745,
0.14872311055660248,
-0.3568325340747833,
-0.8604233860969543,
-0.6928867101669312,
-1.0642818212509155,
-0.13038203120231628,
-0.10217089205980301,
0.21049156785011292,
0.4761424660682678,
0.6763373017311096,
-0.7290534973144531,
0.04634040966629982,
0.09520124644041061,
0.165040522813797,
-0.05853923037648201,
-0.10719580948352814,
0.17631851136684418,
0.09173356741666794,
-0.7034077048301697,
0.4773229956626892,
0.17176781594753265,
0.21450115740299225,
-0.6540313959121704,
0.014680437743663788,
-0.3464503586292267,
-0.0831599161028862,
0.3681354820728302,
0.023384906351566315,
-0.5294557213783264,
-0.13957317173480988,
0.13422146439552307,
0.053245075047016144,
-0.14221486449241638,
0.5923745632171631,
-0.5122331380844116,
0.5679921507835388,
0.44003719091415405,
0.06845933943986893,
0.1884712427854538,
-0.12612570822238922,
0.4430743455886841,
-1.006866216659546,
0.7463828325271606,
-0.032586470246315,
0.38261836767196655,
0.5516277551651001,
-0.5668721795082092,
0.13589265942573547,
0.35166817903518677,
-0.2535521984100342,
-0.9259366989135742,
0.14808176457881927,
-0.46261003613471985,
-0.4059217572212219,
1.0131219625473022,
-0.23831811547279358,
-0.24402157962322235,
-0.6435920596122742,
-0.012879464775323868,
0.22522972524166107,
-0.6260237097740173,
0.8414155840873718,
1.01609468460083,
0.47618916630744934,
-0.0061560263857245445,
-0.9209039211273193,
0.7613590359687805,
-0.09301479905843735,
-0.751248300075531,
0.20054547488689423,
0.4824971556663513,
0.47186920046806335,
0.3507181406021118,
0.1657184660434723,
-0.20947755873203278,
0.5934981107711792,
0.1897818148136139,
0.01572665385901928,
-0.14132572710514069,
-0.8651639819145203,
-0.2523289620876312,
0.089129239320755,
-0.4969083368778229,
-0.3661457896232605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12611v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12611v1 | Rapid Language Adaptation for Multilingual E2E Speech Recognition Using Encoder Prompting | 2024-06-18T13:38:58 | 2024-06-18T13:38:58 | Yosuke Kashiwagi, Hayato Futami, Emiru Tsunoo, Siddhant Arora, Shinji Watanabe | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | End-to-end multilingual speech recognition models handle multiple languages
through a single model, often incorporating language identification to
automatically detect the language of incoming speech. Since the common scenario
is where the language is already known, these models can perform as
language-specific by using language information as prompts, which is
particularly beneficial for attention-based encoder-decoder architectures.
However, the Connectionist Temporal Classification (CTC) approach, which
enhances recognition via joint decoding and multi-task training, does not
normally incorporate language prompts due to its conditionally independent
output tokens. To overcome this, we introduce an encoder prompting technique
within the self-conditioned CTC framework, enabling language-specific
adaptation of the CTC model in a zero-shot manner. Our method has shown to
significantly reduce errors by 28% on average and by 41% on low-resource
languages. | [
-0.2376675009727478,
-0.6650047898292542,
0.2915589213371277,
0.3116910457611084,
-0.1537891924381256,
-0.11409921944141388,
-0.40856805443763733,
-0.2380143105983734,
0.0750022828578949,
0.06755945086479187,
-0.546176016330719,
-0.16647590696811676,
-0.3533763587474823,
0.5942957401275635,
-0.09023849666118622,
0.6571858525276184,
-0.06860784441232681,
-0.08300044387578964,
0.044157981872558594,
-0.2792545258998871,
-0.8674174547195435,
-0.43091273307800293,
-1.3352292776107788,
-0.021771512925624847,
0.7236672043800354,
0.546440601348877,
-0.10768596082925797,
0.3415761888027191,
-0.3145923912525177,
0.22106820344924927,
0.06328943371772766,
-0.020502185449004173,
-0.15020893514156342,
0.38959917426109314,
0.046508729457855225,
-0.4730754792690277,
-0.12287648767232895,
-0.4164526164531708,
0.5528936386108398,
0.39394882321357727,
-0.2856132686138153,
-0.025342559441924095,
0.25327786803245544,
0.4461749494075775,
-0.7731304168701172,
0.17809028923511505,
-0.5572839975357056,
0.1200740709900856,
-0.039938587695360184,
-0.49106940627098083,
-0.8502524495124817,
-0.028158020228147507,
0.16491366922855377,
-0.46002617478370667,
0.24658122658729553,
-0.21992218494415283,
0.26686927676200867,
0.29058489203453064,
-0.37451958656311035,
-0.22309494018554688,
-0.5376279354095459,
0.42759525775909424,
-0.40701812505722046,
0.9098765254020691,
0.45989754796028137,
0.35920217633247375,
0.23478636145591736,
-0.37573370337486267,
-0.5556530952453613,
-0.23453691601753235,
0.1575073003768921,
0.588439404964447,
-0.1142134815454483,
-0.03892535716295242,
0.32525038719177246,
-0.5221499800682068,
-0.8708357810974121,
0.38158881664276123,
-0.32574769854545593,
-0.434282124042511,
-0.01425650343298912,
-0.19411642849445343,
0.25475940108299255,
0.08566044270992279,
-0.18647144734859467,
0.05787545442581177,
-0.6720260977745056,
0.3894888758659363,
0.3117040991783142,
0.4260413944721222,
-0.458615243434906,
0.11446278542280197,
0.048144593834877014,
0.844671368598938,
0.4015815556049347,
0.11812449991703033,
0.2902291715145111,
-0.09912625700235367,
-0.0020432022865861654,
0.7298864126205444,
0.4675951302051544,
0.1435548961162567,
0.37345585227012634,
0.00604857737198472,
-0.01789785549044609,
-0.11208562552928925,
-0.1725083738565445,
-0.7628898024559021,
-0.004889619071036577,
0.40405431389808655,
-0.1371389478445053,
0.3900851011276245,
-0.17274770140647888,
-0.6758662462234497,
-0.0774988979101181,
-0.1781834363937378,
0.28390294313430786,
-0.010425078682601452,
-0.2823020815849304,
0.1473303735256195,
-0.1608312427997589,
0.5407156348228455,
0.2974989712238312,
-0.987623929977417,
-0.007132846396416426,
-0.021308939903974533,
0.9323363900184631,
0.007598964963108301,
-0.3654412627220154,
-0.8528569936752319,
0.30097270011901855,
-0.36640465259552,
0.9194855093955994,
-0.3454950153827667,
-0.47079259157180786,
0.18742908537387848,
0.32529306411743164,
-0.3200063407421112,
-0.3762965202331543,
0.2252632975578308,
-0.5635533332824707,
0.3951338827610016,
-0.2923513650894165,
-0.18455471098423004,
-0.07777979969978333,
0.22821272909641266,
-0.49343493580818176,
0.8510282039642334,
-0.03875155374407768,
-0.5761811137199402,
0.30528831481933594,
-0.634015679359436,
-0.4396986961364746,
0.10862176865339279,
-0.12979191541671753,
-0.03881783038377762,
-0.056909456849098206,
0.6378077268600464,
0.35347214341163635,
-0.23157277703285217,
0.06838742643594742,
-0.15994039177894592,
0.05874473229050636,
0.04421163722872734,
-0.6506446003913879,
0.7901391386985779,
0.39343640208244324,
-0.17397166788578033,
0.06450219452381134,
-0.5583464503288269,
0.164373978972435,
0.1876557171344757,
-0.34986722469329834,
-0.06340204179286957,
-0.26584169268608093,
0.12619484961032867,
0.34814974665641785,
0.28373128175735474,
-0.4586470127105713,
-0.1071227490901947,
-0.4399818181991577,
0.5163403153419495,
0.6774901747703552,
0.05377550050616264,
0.32512739300727844,
-0.00887152086943388,
0.5079606771469116,
0.18687589466571808,
-0.04043787717819214,
-0.7535678148269653,
-0.3998056948184967,
-0.8933190107345581,
-0.09239447861909866,
0.3020559549331665,
0.9872608780860901,
-0.9462328553199768,
0.382809579372406,
-0.078221894800663,
-0.10363651812076569,
-0.4983057379722595,
-0.10173846781253815,
0.4226933717727661,
0.49176740646362305,
0.3107881546020508,
-0.30589038133621216,
-0.5086736679077148,
-0.6572785377502441,
-0.18748319149017334,
-0.34376826882362366,
-0.16795973479747772,
0.21585021913051605,
0.034778062254190445,
0.08308889716863632,
0.7819158434867859,
0.07742315530776978,
-0.14974761009216309,
-0.42640477418899536,
0.02925635315477848,
0.2739802300930023,
0.3835817873477936,
0.558630108833313,
-0.5150063633918762,
-0.7671180963516235,
0.025468047708272934,
-0.6756920218467712,
-0.3474568724632263,
-0.45178118348121643,
0.2756296396255493,
0.449297159910202,
0.7295426726341248,
-0.1550944447517395,
0.16161556541919708,
0.47619181871414185,
-0.24096070230007172,
0.2299991399049759,
-0.5869088768959045,
0.26694825291633606,
-1.194806456565857,
-0.05679340288043022,
-0.09868820756673813,
-0.2079702913761139,
-0.9668793678283691,
-0.4131975769996643,
0.22428393363952637,
-0.3009125888347626,
-0.7137776017189026,
0.6915754675865173,
-0.7051317095756531,
0.03104514628648758,
-0.17672815918922424,
0.2082347422838211,
-0.07961199432611465,
0.44506174325942993,
0.35701000690460205,
0.8634805083274841,
0.9105221629142761,
-0.798751175403595,
0.19800467789173126,
0.21672646701335907,
0.14758111536502838,
0.7023653984069824,
-0.7800930738449097,
0.5962590575218201,
-0.43452903628349304,
0.1736246645450592,
-0.8372271656990051,
-0.1597391664981842,
0.1553177684545517,
-0.6245324015617371,
0.6736363172531128,
-0.2404349446296692,
-0.21739837527275085,
-0.224319726228714,
0.009956298395991325,
0.6288198828697205,
0.4525936245918274,
-0.9948806762695312,
0.5497711300849915,
0.12829262018203735,
-0.42994412779808044,
-0.21780720353126526,
-0.7538968324661255,
0.1392798125743866,
-0.05218688026070595,
-0.4454481303691864,
0.22545157372951508,
-0.3829353153705597,
0.31534507870674133,
-0.407492995262146,
0.028119172900915146,
-0.23922953009605408,
-0.18710878491401672,
-0.11341286450624466,
0.003850073553621769,
-0.12361538410186768,
0.13466958701610565,
0.08303623646497726,
-0.35884249210357666,
-0.13075955212116241,
-0.43710213899612427,
0.5348231792449951,
0.08837582170963287,
-0.3591136634349823,
-0.7973742485046387,
0.5593492388725281,
0.3829585909843445,
-0.47433897852897644,
0.39214420318603516,
0.6455222368240356,
-0.5508241057395935,
-0.12418901175260544,
-0.5541774034500122,
-0.4227847158908844,
-0.4521433413028717,
0.4926743805408478,
-0.5641143321990967,
-0.9062745571136475,
0.5658933520317078,
0.16025470197200775,
-0.08074049651622772,
0.1467185914516449,
0.776533305644989,
0.19966749846935272,
0.989496648311615,
0.46681755781173706,
-0.10913894325494766,
0.6319910287857056,
0.14501237869262695,
0.1959483027458191,
-0.7088834047317505,
-0.2934129536151886,
-0.7524663805961609,
0.24437522888183594,
-0.4422817528247833,
-0.28726786375045776,
0.5243946313858032,
0.08404591679573059,
-0.3111093044281006,
0.3705405294895172,
-0.35559800267219543,
0.521833598613739,
0.29187241196632385,
0.12377248704433441,
-0.18502022325992584,
0.16427603363990784,
-0.11425038427114487,
-0.026531213894486427,
-0.9162958264350891,
-0.004773199558258057,
0.8165231347084045,
0.19174335896968842,
0.39732709527015686,
0.18941065669059753,
0.6664531230926514,
0.19884498417377472,
-0.24329106509685516,
-0.7891034483909607,
0.17859791219234467,
-0.01899649016559124,
-0.4502744674682617,
-0.1861066371202469,
-0.18778856098651886,
-0.8875215649604797,
-0.016323816031217575,
0.11260176450014114,
-0.8561365604400635,
0.571998655796051,
0.28988972306251526,
-0.6899351477622986,
-0.044951263815164566,
-0.824062168598175,
0.8072469234466553,
-0.2680756747722626,
-0.24647021293640137,
-0.06156191602349281,
-0.5992164015769958,
-0.21242395043373108,
-0.29006510972976685,
0.2902774512767792,
-0.05472181364893913,
-0.09830525517463684,
0.7028740048408508,
0.07911986857652664,
0.8393365740776062,
-0.5188263654708862,
0.10544893890619278,
0.5848478674888611,
0.11918584257364273,
0.7114753127098083,
-0.015108316205441952,
-0.11287128180265427,
-0.024941490963101387,
0.031097233295440674,
-0.4400584399700165,
-0.6310662627220154,
0.47852298617362976,
-0.6882985234260559,
-0.45859643816947937,
-0.23731151223182678,
-0.18063807487487793,
-0.3947297930717468,
-0.0914175882935524,
0.342641144990921,
0.6721560955047607,
-0.02990061230957508,
0.02824205532670021,
0.6402186155319214,
-0.438159704208374,
0.9269216656684875,
0.7578536868095398,
0.18682268261909485,
-0.5368473529815674,
0.8462095856666565,
0.12332701683044434,
0.36646732687950134,
0.41114741563796997,
0.21011756360530853,
-0.7082463502883911,
-0.4397951364517212,
-0.7919161319732666,
0.12403886765241623,
-0.7975192070007324,
-0.09042580425739288,
-0.6215157508850098,
-0.11844857782125473,
-0.5344034433364868,
-0.3689916729927063,
-0.23296885192394257,
-0.27868205308914185,
-0.4346674680709839,
-0.03750200569629669,
0.3008872866630554,
0.27202335000038147,
-0.014186245389282703,
0.4278205931186676,
-0.9840308427810669,
0.1672162413597107,
0.48130449652671814,
0.12445035576820374,
-0.18613718450069427,
-1.0235382318496704,
-0.25726184248924255,
-0.22470267117023468,
0.11983547359704971,
-1.208093285560608,
0.3597368001937866,
0.6974862813949585,
0.6498270034790039,
0.39247557520866394,
0.18493707478046417,
0.7831531763076782,
-0.7674418687820435,
0.837628960609436,
0.5909040570259094,
-0.9686336517333984,
0.6866676211357117,
-0.12109559029340744,
0.6704313158988953,
0.29555729031562805,
0.2884760797023773,
-0.9045525193214417,
0.07935485243797302,
-0.18343499302864075,
-0.7622036933898926,
0.7698913216590881,
-0.19532237946987152,
0.11028959602117538,
-0.25592750310897827,
0.35049349069595337,
0.02433456853032112,
-0.27157825231552124,
-0.7197719812393188,
-0.0658545047044754,
-0.40782660245895386,
-0.3277910053730011,
0.036280304193496704,
-0.40211841464042664,
0.07007677108049393,
-0.04065684601664543,
0.5697869658470154,
-0.6021031141281128,
0.5034392476081848,
0.4663061499595642,
-0.2805870473384857,
0.03688286244869232,
0.702254593372345,
0.6213884353637695,
0.33882519602775574,
0.20679064095020294,
0.08417538553476334,
0.7001754641532898,
-0.05943134054541588,
0.43353500962257385,
0.024261828511953354,
-0.05077531188726425,
0.02539904974400997,
0.20851008594036102,
0.9348938465118408,
0.08009037375450134,
-0.4030480980873108,
0.4223654866218567,
-0.09825485199689865,
-0.051380425691604614,
-0.3604739308357239,
-0.32935577630996704,
-0.06865137070417404,
0.06401558220386505,
0.25652173161506653,
-0.17101053893566132,
0.0343148335814476,
-0.26646602153778076,
0.1432173252105713,
0.012067969888448715,
-0.6430302858352661,
-0.5733991861343384,
0.7114045023918152,
0.39614278078079224,
-0.22309863567352295,
0.5856412649154663,
-0.26906630396842957,
-0.4788702428340912,
0.6362989544868469,
0.9467901587486267,
1.2295650243759155,
-0.8888105154037476,
-0.002819012850522995,
0.8499824404716492,
0.24490512907505035,
0.07138971984386444,
0.41336071491241455,
-0.15984055399894714,
-0.8125776052474976,
-0.36290934681892395,
-0.38211557269096375,
-0.09492689371109009,
-0.23643040657043457,
-0.720477283000946,
0.33160898089408875,
-0.35912275314331055,
0.0487285852432251,
-0.29847556352615356,
-0.6045130491256714,
-0.7261797189712524,
0.047811467200517654,
0.371547669172287,
0.8022928237915039,
-0.6648553609848022,
1.165449857711792,
0.4260891377925873,
-0.22143161296844482,
-0.7976167798042297,
-0.17279884219169617,
0.24778762459754944,
-0.8025298714637756,
0.5983374714851379,
0.4085537791252136,
-0.2520018219947815,
0.28958484530448914,
-0.093995600938797,
-0.6519719958305359,
0.8568850159645081,
0.48552703857421875,
-0.9514004588127136,
0.22307144105434418,
0.00997503288090229,
0.28026068210601807,
-0.43339309096336365,
0.5792550444602966,
0.46238774061203003,
0.49381929636001587,
0.05128188803792,
-1.1773606538772583,
-0.011366774328052998,
-0.0817851722240448,
0.0886320173740387,
0.0334903709590435,
-0.43026942014694214,
0.5148032307624817,
-0.5371765494346619,
-0.45227882266044617,
-0.26960065960884094,
0.4449397623538971,
0.18348702788352966,
0.2319595217704773,
0.7393521666526794,
0.15021339058876038,
0.5927847623825073,
0.07642338424921036,
0.536221444606781,
-0.6359416842460632,
0.07925122231245041,
1.0953716039657593,
-0.5304586291313171,
1.024793028831482,
0.539320170879364,
-0.15620003640651703,
0.23392784595489502,
0.9771843552589417,
0.21784262359142303,
0.6206822991371155,
-0.3180646002292633,
-0.5059623718261719,
-0.3897418677806854,
-0.4133647084236145,
-0.38926637172698975,
0.49912673234939575,
0.2883712947368622,
0.015665987506508827,
-0.3024406433105469,
0.20198456943035126,
-0.07414399832487106,
-0.18521276116371155,
-0.35991954803466797,
1.0195858478546143,
0.07136812806129456,
-0.5921717882156372,
0.7528470754623413,
-0.2213841676712036,
0.5698479413986206,
-0.7027031183242798,
0.04013536125421524,
-0.08270814269781113,
-0.0986265167593956,
-0.18989327549934387,
-0.3513711988925934,
0.21921785175800323,
0.13944736123085022,
-0.28351056575775146,
-0.24431581795215607,
0.4829750955104828,
-0.8510915637016296,
-0.19091492891311646,
0.584287166595459,
0.6147563457489014,
0.24635757505893707,
-0.09770708531141281,
-0.7459954023361206,
-0.16442377865314484,
0.05058928579092026,
-0.014229328371584415,
0.28287848830223083,
0.3350355625152588,
0.06852087378501892,
0.4176681339740753,
0.8300912976264954,
-0.13611015677452087,
0.22371555864810944,
0.6083484888076782,
0.43688035011291504,
-0.5716611742973328,
-0.7850931882858276,
-0.7047364115715027,
0.4505038261413574,
0.2959768772125244,
-0.1557292491197586,
0.5218408107757568,
0.41038778424263,
0.949567973613739,
-0.23454099893569946,
0.7781305313110352,
-0.033495865762233734,
0.2666943371295929,
-0.688380241394043,
0.611200749874115,
-0.4869389533996582,
0.06179684028029442,
0.31754159927368164,
-0.6074756383895874,
-0.29999247193336487,
0.49656832218170166,
0.15740260481834412,
0.1622058004140854,
0.834630012512207,
1.0197076797485352,
0.3375808894634247,
-0.003553585149347782,
0.71229487657547,
-0.009652955457568169,
0.26421114802360535,
0.7348412871360779,
0.63334721326828,
-0.18427476286888123,
0.5716984272003174,
-0.015152978710830212,
-0.2805037498474121,
-0.0026429491117596626,
-0.9330731630325317,
-0.8023990392684937,
-0.701354444026947,
-0.40184375643730164,
-0.3149679899215698,
0.3017156422138214,
1.3069961071014404,
0.6170843839645386,
-1.0945510864257812,
-0.2906241714954376,
0.031453412026166916,
-0.1968405842781067,
-0.28914397954940796,
-0.165616974234581,
0.29796215891838074,
-0.5460290312767029,
-0.7377944588661194,
0.7096543908119202,
0.4832945764064789,
0.23067606985569,
-0.026410313323140144,
-0.32727670669555664,
0.09995727986097336,
-0.1569085270166397,
0.6292678713798523,
0.5707455277442932,
-0.7769650816917419,
-0.40091902017593384,
0.07051309198141098,
0.3091960847377777,
0.2074415683746338,
0.8730839490890503,
-0.8008036613464355,
1.011096715927124,
0.4802168607711792,
0.623408317565918,
0.2939435839653015,
-0.5307695865631104,
0.4650108814239502,
-0.6528173089027405,
0.4657995402812958,
0.11690623313188553,
0.5146674513816833,
0.45001187920570374,
-0.2180568426847458,
0.03987966850399971,
0.29814237356185913,
-0.5120840072631836,
-0.4503287076950073,
0.4502469003200531,
-1.0257073640823364,
-0.04590556025505066,
1.0605404376983643,
-0.3618837893009186,
-0.30680668354034424,
-0.472412109375,
-0.3217237591743469,
0.3290375769138336,
-0.6368561387062073,
0.3364596664905548,
0.42555534839630127,
-0.1439363956451416,
-0.6548329591751099,
-0.5488327145576477,
0.2161504179239273,
0.31731268763542175,
-0.8001068234443665,
0.18932276964187622,
0.3017611801624298,
0.36039307713508606,
-0.13504283130168915,
0.7808441519737244,
0.035768117755651474,
0.5394573211669922,
-0.029336290434002876,
0.3819664716720581,
-0.08993558585643768,
-0.5794035196304321,
-0.9024581909179688,
-0.032500654458999634,
0.25020986795425415,
-0.24971112608909607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12608v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12608v1 | Bridging Local Details and Global Context in Text-Attributed Graphs | 2024-06-18T13:35:25 | 2024-06-18T13:35:25 | Yaoke Wang, Yun Zhu, Wenqiao Zhang, Yueting Zhuang, Yunfei Li, Siliang Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Representation learning on text-attributed graphs (TAGs) is vital for
real-world applications, as they combine semantic textual and contextual
structural information. Research in this field generally consist of two main
perspectives: local-level encoding and global-level aggregating, respectively
refer to textual node information unification (e.g., using Language Models) and
structure-augmented modeling (e.g., using Graph Neural Networks). Most existing
works focus on combining different information levels but overlook the
interconnections, i.e., the contextual textual information among nodes, which
provides semantic insights to bridge local and global levels. In this paper, we
propose GraphBridge, a multi-granularity integration framework that bridges
local and global perspectives by leveraging contextual textual information,
enhancing fine-grained understanding of TAGs. Besides, to tackle scalability
and efficiency challenges, we introduce a graphaware token reduction module.
Extensive experiments across various models and datasets show that our method
achieves state-of-theart performance, while our graph-aware token reduction
module significantly enhances efficiency and solves scalability issues. | [
-0.19536863267421722,
-0.7605845928192139,
0.4172222912311554,
-0.027199793606996536,
-0.17361518740653992,
0.32301637530326843,
0.08151084184646606,
-0.7457267642021179,
0.21996279060840607,
0.2636560797691345,
-0.2568829357624054,
-0.6812077164649963,
-0.469882994890213,
-0.1345130056142807,
-0.24909767508506775,
0.9582517743110657,
-0.4166409373283386,
-0.23541755974292755,
-0.6191198229789734,
-0.25063711404800415,
-0.4411545693874359,
-0.6089674830436707,
-0.8365742564201355,
-0.45490288734436035,
0.8832669258117676,
0.19660218060016632,
0.41023796796798706,
0.7698630690574646,
0.4302792549133301,
0.32428795099258423,
-0.24700677394866943,
0.5172150731086731,
-0.42017653584480286,
-0.08288751542568207,
-0.255767822265625,
-0.28896525502204895,
-0.667840838432312,
-0.08044472336769104,
0.9066306948661804,
0.9339247345924377,
0.22846123576164246,
0.13141000270843506,
0.15223096311092377,
0.2674978971481323,
-0.544485867023468,
0.6304652690887451,
-0.47811341285705566,
0.014678788371384144,
-0.15913794934749603,
-0.04100353270769119,
-0.520030677318573,
-0.051451217383146286,
-0.07843291014432907,
-0.6849818825721741,
0.11799059808254242,
0.09127792716026306,
1.0502620935440063,
-0.04790406674146652,
-0.7464161515235901,
-0.2687494158744812,
-0.3142961859703064,
0.4104556739330292,
-0.43097248673439026,
0.04795362800359726,
0.4003313481807709,
-0.04760602489113808,
0.16136124730110168,
-1.1137586832046509,
-0.16363462805747986,
0.28005722165107727,
-0.7553094029426575,
-0.007393624633550644,
-0.37543681263923645,
0.18507838249206543,
-0.1631324589252472,
0.4598481059074402,
-0.3447277545928955,
0.030201366171240807,
-0.2018948197364807,
-0.5466626882553101,
0.32412710785865784,
0.22326542437076569,
0.3494010865688324,
-0.6693078875541687,
-0.40535804629325867,
0.19948269426822662,
-0.4057779610157013,
0.249783456325531,
0.26273390650749207,
0.6289438009262085,
-0.2320096343755722,
0.18878406286239624,
-0.06440099328756332,
0.7020567655563354,
-0.15516595542430878,
0.09491279721260071,
0.4295751750469208,
-0.5850387811660767,
-0.08915949612855911,
-0.04774092510342598,
0.7635204792022705,
0.01694532297551632,
-0.04918099194765091,
-0.6436792016029358,
0.021822411566972733,
0.08746565878391266,
0.024793090298771858,
-0.9730891585350037,
-0.10727480798959732,
0.23721939325332642,
-0.4151146709918976,
-0.2782440185546875,
0.1339392513036728,
-0.21299093961715698,
-0.3138297498226166,
-0.17697064578533173,
0.35925763845443726,
-0.491184800863266,
-0.07243051379919052,
-0.13066062331199646,
-0.42777732014656067,
0.03990059345960617,
0.23112896084785461,
-0.5988547205924988,
0.3074093759059906,
0.7115783095359802,
1.3144844770431519,
0.09590478986501694,
-0.4013657867908478,
-0.6447449326515198,
0.7133151888847351,
-0.04894797131419182,
0.784699022769928,
-0.7869929075241089,
-0.3418094515800476,
-0.18093453347682953,
0.11509520560503006,
-0.16323524713516235,
-0.2950136661529541,
0.38919609785079956,
-0.3691377639770508,
-0.19227707386016846,
-0.27424538135528564,
-0.38959020376205444,
-0.21980144083499908,
0.436905175447464,
-0.7908436059951782,
1.2203493118286133,
0.13752856850624084,
-1.2402886152267456,
0.196083664894104,
-0.6509699821472168,
-0.9009417295455933,
-0.012802239507436752,
-0.14245425164699554,
-0.30973079800605774,
0.05777258798480034,
0.46453675627708435,
0.6369433403015137,
0.10914105921983719,
0.18033677339553833,
-0.111455537378788,
-0.406776487827301,
-0.15467479825019836,
-0.2902477979660034,
0.4047483503818512,
0.1441766768693924,
0.17799364030361176,
0.19356724619865417,
-0.6824684143066406,
-0.18397203087806702,
-0.04577501490712166,
-0.27977532148361206,
-0.6338644623756409,
0.03940889239311218,
0.025725191459059715,
0.17692527174949646,
0.2867683470249176,
-0.5761640667915344,
0.4066210389137268,
-0.48304420709609985,
0.9035946130752563,
0.7491743564605713,
0.07296431064605713,
0.782520055770874,
-0.1341857612133026,
0.12654632329940796,
0.1981533318758011,
-0.009931863285601139,
-0.6011285781860352,
-0.4330759346485138,
-0.4101482927799225,
-0.39571377635002136,
0.4601978361606598,
0.4562995433807373,
-0.8223099112510681,
0.15295974910259247,
-0.5510808229446411,
-0.4184412658214569,
-0.3285180330276489,
-0.09856472909450531,
0.21370166540145874,
0.6998867392539978,
0.3009416460990906,
-0.310295969247818,
-0.42688262462615967,
-0.5793492794036865,
-0.4044869542121887,
-0.20414024591445923,
0.03463558480143547,
0.592981219291687,
0.533753514289856,
-0.3765198290348053,
1.3958455324172974,
-0.6340084671974182,
-0.4832611382007599,
-0.24044986069202423,
0.5430427193641663,
-0.019519934430718422,
0.5750800967216492,
0.49994683265686035,
-0.9557672142982483,
-0.5044476985931396,
0.550280749797821,
-0.6260874271392822,
-0.016790833324193954,
-0.08775018155574799,
-0.18103709816932678,
-0.17542347311973572,
0.4104980230331421,
-0.6052099466323853,
0.6234139800071716,
0.445425808429718,
-0.2913822829723358,
0.1819782704114914,
-0.3318611681461334,
0.09530426561832428,
-1.3246906995773315,
0.16335301101207733,
-0.13551966845989227,
-0.6267377138137817,
-0.5720120668411255,
0.09299462288618088,
0.13142730295658112,
-0.28717294335365295,
-0.04536689445376396,
0.8096245527267456,
-0.5099349617958069,
-0.03499924764037132,
0.15178349614143372,
0.4898068606853485,
0.4074493646621704,
0.43467971682548523,
-0.2828863859176636,
0.7195121049880981,
0.5756145715713501,
-0.3858283460140228,
0.23358161747455597,
0.18243804574012756,
-0.0010975389741361141,
0.6009137630462646,
-0.48974254727363586,
0.059664446860551834,
-0.444394588470459,
0.4754272997379303,
-1.1471621990203857,
-0.465754896402359,
0.17286892235279083,
-0.5909318327903748,
0.32233697175979614,
-0.2627507150173187,
-0.5984835028648376,
-0.19895175099372864,
-0.2827298641204834,
0.70755934715271,
-0.061126310378313065,
-0.526321291923523,
1.2075095176696777,
0.3612626791000366,
-0.136945441365242,
-0.5129063725471497,
-0.9067872166633606,
0.2755949795246124,
0.13325999677181244,
-0.7562822699546814,
0.688953697681427,
0.2725137770175934,
0.08399210125207901,
0.2226434201002121,
-0.23168504238128662,
-0.18007899820804596,
-0.06265658140182495,
0.34826669096946716,
-0.09581107646226883,
0.0891021266579628,
0.45032045245170593,
0.21980084478855133,
-0.40703243017196655,
-0.06482608616352081,
-0.4753071069717407,
0.6483221650123596,
-0.16429845988750458,
-0.26117101311683655,
-0.3917383551597595,
0.596977710723877,
0.18905824422836304,
-0.5549281239509583,
0.6877599358558655,
0.8128550052642822,
-0.3732075095176697,
-0.05402837321162224,
0.011540760286152363,
0.278094083070755,
-0.46267130970954895,
0.511480450630188,
-0.43784579634666443,
-1.0931835174560547,
1.0019946098327637,
-0.4592214822769165,
-0.2063741832971573,
0.2978193759918213,
0.03986610472202301,
-0.25613096356391907,
0.926213800907135,
0.5310905575752258,
-0.24962908029556274,
0.5810319185256958,
-0.5860666036605835,
0.4469852149486542,
-0.8641421794891357,
-0.2966986298561096,
-0.5081997513771057,
-0.44798970222473145,
-0.3501424491405487,
-0.7978577017784119,
0.14723210036754608,
0.19706657528877258,
-0.23427660763263702,
0.16419406235218048,
-0.4335547983646393,
0.6201930642127991,
0.21664950251579285,
0.23371054232120514,
0.46071764826774597,
0.07374434173107147,
-0.18820743262767792,
0.07127394527196884,
-0.7803866267204285,
-0.19782347977161407,
0.6838582158088684,
0.22551561892032623,
0.7272749543190002,
-0.04104098677635193,
0.6842636466026306,
0.3861840069293976,
0.38546210527420044,
-0.8848551511764526,
0.41573336720466614,
-0.17967891693115234,
-0.35601404309272766,
-0.009652186185121536,
-0.8815069794654846,
-1.0126194953918457,
0.3347298800945282,
0.07133965194225311,
-1.0087978839874268,
0.05756724253296852,
0.07239409536123276,
0.17982031404972076,
0.6318485140800476,
-0.806751549243927,
0.9426987171173096,
0.2383812516927719,
-0.18785855174064636,
0.05611665919423103,
-0.6078453063964844,
0.03494386002421379,
0.2143062949180603,
0.6329861283302307,
0.10422864556312561,
-0.13871419429779053,
0.4188677966594696,
-0.5604242086410522,
1.1010040044784546,
-0.08219735324382782,
-0.14745193719863892,
0.3650396168231964,
-0.07555796205997467,
0.8029927015304565,
0.15787726640701294,
0.046198759227991104,
0.3396037817001343,
-0.3562752902507782,
-0.5300905704498291,
-0.42620712518692017,
0.7718695402145386,
-0.7308040857315063,
0.0024692704901099205,
-0.1778162717819214,
-0.9145828485488892,
-0.1176653802394867,
0.2862221300601959,
0.12682472169399261,
1.0680664777755737,
-0.0365121103823185,
-0.029951881617307663,
0.3603498041629791,
0.16553185880184174,
0.5725506544113159,
-0.30258476734161377,
-0.29157504439353943,
-0.7073884010314941,
1.0005015134811401,
0.3775419592857361,
0.28012731671333313,
0.6672518253326416,
0.08481321483850479,
-0.13930542767047882,
-0.3556593954563141,
-0.24973972141742706,
0.27317917346954346,
-1.0378916263580322,
-0.35940420627593994,
-0.6586123704910278,
-0.24538232386112213,
-0.38353559374809265,
-0.3528938889503479,
0.05857757851481438,
-0.27548128366470337,
-0.2829280495643616,
-0.24504582583904266,
0.3327145576477051,
0.7282940149307251,
0.011009208858013153,
0.7530678510665894,
-0.7537001371383667,
0.2023935467004776,
0.20112483203411102,
0.5654697418212891,
0.4676658809185028,
-0.04483818635344505,
-0.5807325839996338,
-0.17892925441265106,
-0.06284186989068985,
-0.7320723533630371,
-0.11639216542243958,
0.07871682196855545,
0.3891860842704773,
0.2206643968820572,
-0.015265190042555332,
1.0648709535598755,
-0.5163673162460327,
0.6923216581344604,
0.12206482887268066,
-1.2344326972961426,
0.4344618618488312,
-0.43799319863319397,
0.3457980751991272,
0.3577999770641327,
0.2942390739917755,
-0.7052713632583618,
-0.4375156760215759,
-0.539775013923645,
-1.2265057563781738,
0.7385539412498474,
0.22716596722602844,
0.3749020993709564,
0.014095507562160492,
0.6460068225860596,
-0.11795385181903839,
0.14438697695732117,
-0.9983140826225281,
-0.28815844655036926,
-0.022265847772359848,
-0.3569546341896057,
0.34237727522850037,
0.14274492859840393,
-0.0577462874352932,
-0.5018669366836548,
0.3562103807926178,
-0.5132479071617126,
0.06386713683605194,
0.28085190057754517,
-0.3860894739627838,
0.33498498797416687,
0.06904502958059311,
-0.0930672138929367,
0.6705282330513,
0.023563800379633904,
0.4631809592247009,
0.16000042855739594,
-0.5664438009262085,
-0.17547021806240082,
0.035830117762088776,
-0.2863227128982544,
0.12701071798801422,
0.7993522882461548,
0.838753879070282,
0.3518267869949341,
-0.16260768473148346,
0.4780224561691284,
-0.058127276599407196,
0.07656572014093399,
0.47385919094085693,
-0.1765296757221222,
0.28654834628105164,
-0.0682177022099495,
0.3505071997642517,
0.33456137776374817,
0.10332413017749786,
-0.5489698648452759,
0.15121662616729736,
0.4125062823295593,
-0.5224707722663879,
-0.2569834887981415,
0.4753883183002472,
0.3637453615665436,
-0.19890163838863373,
0.16430765390396118,
-0.2938808798789978,
-0.42998597025871277,
0.5205094218254089,
0.6117867827415466,
0.5950182676315308,
0.0936289131641388,
0.47153687477111816,
0.44563716650009155,
0.19883693754673004,
0.48262032866477966,
0.01614547334611416,
-0.5512101650238037,
-0.532315731048584,
-0.6300029754638672,
-0.45624226331710815,
-0.27637478709220886,
-0.49643421173095703,
-0.5946189761161804,
-0.059818968176841736,
-0.34664303064346313,
-0.3452413082122803,
-0.0603109635412693,
-0.051711708307266235,
-0.3603939116001129,
0.01005477737635374,
-0.058343738317489624,
0.8433980345726013,
-0.8776787519454956,
0.6198065876960754,
0.7990835309028625,
-0.5404677391052246,
-0.7632122039794922,
-0.009950489737093449,
-0.4883531928062439,
-0.6016308069229126,
0.4929170608520508,
0.46413686871528625,
-0.2566981315612793,
0.17383238673210144,
-0.5882424116134644,
-0.7402676343917847,
1.2205476760864258,
0.39251866936683655,
-0.027551816776394844,
-0.2201487421989441,
0.3741188943386078,
0.14930877089500427,
-0.4626014828681946,
0.18886889517307281,
0.33460336923599243,
0.47543004155158997,
0.29316288232803345,
-0.6764659285545349,
0.02618473209440708,
-0.20239713788032532,
0.33822697401046753,
0.5609506964683533,
-0.665457546710968,
1.1597585678100586,
0.019549159333109856,
-0.4246533215045929,
-0.14920128881931305,
0.6462137699127197,
-0.1852659434080124,
0.3256961405277252,
0.1967601627111435,
0.7405819296836853,
1.1049023866653442,
-0.3343043327331543,
1.0448369979858398,
-0.24331526458263397,
0.715112030506134,
1.05721914768219,
-0.042923107743263245,
0.7127810120582581,
0.4380502998828888,
0.015174947679042816,
0.9521166086196899,
0.6191974878311157,
0.4722408056259155,
0.3183059096336365,
-0.008417473174631596,
-0.24728041887283325,
-0.31834539771080017,
-0.4082307815551758,
-0.25377508997917175,
0.20819325745105743,
0.2713328003883362,
-0.20178312063217163,
-0.5962576270103455,
-0.1179317906498909,
0.36670854687690735,
0.03526164963841438,
-0.6839545965194702,
0.7828357219696045,
-0.10145721584558487,
0.06387822329998016,
0.16242951154708862,
0.0715540423989296,
0.482016384601593,
-0.7757197022438049,
0.010294715873897076,
-0.15715111792087555,
0.1830555498600006,
-0.48530322313308716,
-0.7998862862586975,
0.34197014570236206,
-0.14042513072490692,
-0.4580315947532654,
-0.28076937794685364,
1.0065009593963623,
-0.30977144837379456,
-0.4688616991043091,
0.4794278144836426,
0.20678839087486267,
-0.23362495005130768,
-0.07342793047428131,
-0.3854033946990967,
0.04109368100762367,
-0.4256603717803955,
0.0841173529624939,
0.2689162492752075,
0.876224935054779,
-0.10649099200963974,
0.4516080319881439,
0.60252845287323,
0.003110895399004221,
-0.2383713275194168,
0.21627630293369293,
1.163905382156372,
-0.6479275226593018,
-0.8351775407791138,
-0.866400957107544,
0.7496345639228821,
-0.6215137243270874,
-0.24700163304805756,
0.7380122542381287,
0.7010800242424011,
0.8171613812446594,
0.4609231650829315,
0.835075318813324,
-0.0668661892414093,
-0.19095276296138763,
-0.36871498823165894,
0.7792810797691345,
-0.56610107421875,
-0.059314701706171036,
-0.37211695313453674,
-0.5806886553764343,
-0.4701351225376129,
0.48902347683906555,
-0.2951388955116272,
-0.038486432284116745,
0.6090100407600403,
0.3690347969532013,
-0.16998621821403503,
-0.14484064280986786,
-0.09037807583808899,
0.22508685290813446,
0.39902353286743164,
0.5168771743774414,
0.6052622199058533,
-0.6032305955886841,
0.5994961857795715,
0.1288326531648636,
-0.16476666927337646,
0.14041730761528015,
-0.9977551698684692,
-0.8962166905403137,
-0.5312418937683105,
-0.07302797585725784,
-0.15242381393909454,
-0.42524710297584534,
0.3960355520248413,
0.7311385869979858,
-0.4622909128665924,
-0.03389133885502815,
-0.057934340089559555,
0.4854903817176819,
-0.008983656764030457,
-0.22530004382133484,
0.5515475273132324,
-0.5714297890663147,
-0.4637850522994995,
-0.019409870728850365,
0.7359597682952881,
-0.15016622841358185,
-0.1093120202422142,
-0.042569588869810104,
-0.24759702384471893,
0.16686084866523743,
0.7361432909965515,
-0.12338772416114807,
-0.486699640750885,
-0.5680985450744629,
-0.27643364667892456,
-0.1741277426481247,
0.5154407620429993,
0.9675719141960144,
-0.868900716304779,
0.4150471091270447,
0.660810112953186,
0.6680220365524292,
0.557099461555481,
0.27282658219337463,
0.16397689282894135,
-1.4732091426849365,
0.33260828256607056,
0.03871222585439682,
0.44456401467323303,
0.4190545976161957,
-0.2520344853401184,
0.42348310351371765,
0.41354864835739136,
-0.2474534958600998,
-0.8452824950218201,
0.4504941701889038,
-0.8974663615226746,
-0.3672037720680237,
0.7972499132156372,
-0.23857705295085907,
-0.44109907746315,
-0.12433777004480362,
-0.42221710085868835,
0.2876005172729492,
-0.23556795716285706,
0.1242341473698616,
0.7951598763465881,
-0.10632997006177902,
0.16543124616146088,
-0.12079260498285294,
0.09585197269916534,
-0.2295246571302414,
-1.026473045349121,
0.3795396685600281,
0.407622367143631,
-0.05755927786231041,
0.3922838866710663,
0.8708422780036926,
0.08890685439109802,
-0.1698443442583084,
0.21692873537540436,
-0.053561437875032425,
-0.19464240968227386,
-0.3659941256046295,
-0.14454902708530426,
0.4206483066082001,
-0.2548001706600189,
0.012713229283690453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12606v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12606v1 | Low-Redundant Optimization for Large Language Model Alignment | 2024-06-18T13:34:40 | 2024-06-18T13:34:40 | Zhipeng Chen, Kun Zhou, Wayne Xin Zhao, Jingyuan Wang, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are still struggling in aligning with human
preference in complex tasks and scenarios. They are prone to overfit into the
unexpected patterns or superficial styles in the training data. We conduct an
empirical study that only selects the top-10\% most updated parameters in LLMs
for alignment training, and see improvements in the convergence process and
final performance. It indicates the existence of redundant neurons in LLMs for
alignment training. To reduce its influence, we propose a low-redundant
alignment method named \textbf{ALLO}, focusing on optimizing the most related
neurons with the most useful supervised signals. Concretely, we first identify
the neurons that are related to the human preference data by a gradient-based
strategy, then identify the alignment-related key tokens by reward models for
computing loss. Besides, we also decompose the alignment process into the
forgetting and learning stages, where we first forget the tokens with unaligned
knowledge and then learn aligned knowledge, by updating different ratios of
neurons, respectively. Experimental results on 10 datasets have shown the
effectiveness of ALLO. Our code and data are available at
\url{https://github.com/RUCAIBox/ALLO}. | [
-0.0586746484041214,
-0.4532676637172699,
0.5317853093147278,
0.0237567238509655,
-0.2087600976228714,
-0.12476465106010437,
-0.42790305614471436,
-0.25475427508354187,
0.3646464943885803,
0.2583502531051636,
-0.5716134905815125,
-0.48358914256095886,
-0.5227765440940857,
-0.09229753911495209,
-0.18400947749614716,
0.8833034038543701,
0.03960415720939636,
0.13618309795856476,
-0.4445139467716217,
-0.3348671495914459,
-0.3807898163795471,
-0.11542956531047821,
-0.6060476899147034,
-0.6851952075958252,
0.6082882881164551,
0.6420548558235168,
0.43785032629966736,
1.069103717803955,
0.15386968851089478,
0.36203283071517944,
-0.36290308833122253,
0.23756346106529236,
-0.8528102040290833,
-0.10704950243234634,
-0.10704249888658524,
-0.33188048005104065,
-0.6056681275367737,
-0.23631685972213745,
0.5866866707801819,
0.8108073472976685,
-0.4664117395877838,
0.19700117409229279,
0.09503547847270966,
0.7576228976249695,
-0.9337784647941589,
-0.2618862986564636,
-0.9783973097801208,
-0.11575793474912643,
-0.08197572082281113,
-0.18363870680332184,
-0.2309330403804779,
-0.388601154088974,
-0.12077069282531738,
-0.726565420627594,
-0.1021900475025177,
0.010869203135371208,
0.8272090554237366,
0.5746878385543823,
-0.19210901856422424,
0.036666445434093475,
-0.3903716206550598,
1.0262361764907837,
-0.5362866520881653,
0.37462833523750305,
0.2637477517127991,
-0.09445594251155853,
-0.23244863748550415,
-0.032729372382164,
-0.5879310965538025,
-0.1287512332201004,
0.11772222071886063,
0.18063969910144806,
-0.08652108907699585,
0.1291513442993164,
0.06682657450437546,
0.04044332727789879,
-0.5716681480407715,
0.5506525039672852,
-0.16568094491958618,
-0.3170999586582184,
0.502740740776062,
0.005852638278156519,
0.1647314876317978,
-0.004307876341044903,
-0.5555351972579956,
-0.05501001700758934,
-0.7961233854293823,
-0.14160513877868652,
0.4161527156829834,
0.15183782577514648,
-0.05385337024927139,
0.5754066705703735,
-0.12853308022022247,
0.8562498688697815,
0.1671939194202423,
-0.23874670267105103,
0.4395208954811096,
-0.17800821363925934,
-0.1599702537059784,
0.35249999165534973,
0.8649896383285522,
0.3248385787010193,
0.344636470079422,
-0.3060399293899536,
-0.30142080783843994,
-0.039047352969646454,
0.41163370013237,
-0.3016837537288666,
0.14545957744121552,
0.06463870406150818,
-0.3252314031124115,
-0.2680503726005554,
-0.5209027528762817,
-0.47355350852012634,
-0.31228527426719666,
-0.5636006593704224,
0.2614193558692932,
-0.4519803524017334,
0.06909113377332687,
0.16294825077056885,
0.2674527168273926,
0.14766208827495575,
0.3769214451313019,
-1.1837921142578125,
0.047643717378377914,
0.9150130748748779,
0.8564045429229736,
-0.35387206077575684,
-0.6509088277816772,
-0.5601741671562195,
0.16818147897720337,
-0.27125057578086853,
0.6160665154457092,
-0.3097918629646301,
0.019888492301106453,
-0.10789626091718674,
-0.24150703847408295,
-0.19284893572330475,
-0.4326217472553253,
0.7043263912200928,
-0.4648360013961792,
0.0014672244433313608,
-0.28529220819473267,
-0.6727978587150574,
-0.0323672816157341,
0.3305010199546814,
-0.5761269927024841,
0.94367915391922,
-0.03410063311457634,
-0.5347321033477783,
0.18168847262859344,
-0.45992356538772583,
-0.3801518678665161,
-0.22422361373901367,
-0.1665133535861969,
-0.5580443143844604,
0.1356721967458725,
0.08524192124605179,
0.25309088826179504,
-0.4217500388622284,
0.33724284172058105,
-0.4451529085636139,
-0.5606766939163208,
0.02041163295507431,
-0.207998126745224,
0.7210838794708252,
0.1466962695121765,
-0.1906474232673645,
0.34045931696891785,
-0.7876317501068115,
-0.07000761479139328,
0.03237977251410484,
-0.3344440758228302,
-0.34538736939430237,
0.08743365854024887,
-0.14184699952602386,
0.03190509229898453,
0.4762851893901825,
-0.5288801789283752,
0.3431128263473511,
-0.4644271433353424,
0.43808355927467346,
0.9723357558250427,
-0.3456781506538391,
0.8350898027420044,
-0.47714439034461975,
0.26916569471359253,
-0.02082269825041294,
0.22362864017486572,
0.15102744102478027,
-0.2879313826560974,
-0.8252681493759155,
-0.30689701437950134,
0.2979978621006012,
0.6384793519973755,
-0.3205922245979309,
0.9775905609130859,
-0.6256995797157288,
-0.3354341983795166,
-0.6428837180137634,
0.447513222694397,
0.39476147294044495,
0.6812574863433838,
0.231858491897583,
-0.21279358863830566,
-0.644403338432312,
-1.0182627439498901,
-0.022747982293367386,
-0.0568203441798687,
0.052505895495414734,
0.1465805470943451,
0.3042435348033905,
-0.33464717864990234,
0.8659530878067017,
-0.4866360127925873,
-0.4294632077217102,
-0.07905454188585281,
-0.145514115691185,
0.21069370210170746,
0.6133277416229248,
0.5640469789505005,
-0.2474379986524582,
-0.3054618835449219,
0.2588745355606079,
-0.631401777267456,
-0.0553458109498024,
-0.08032163977622986,
-0.4559299647808075,
0.2943439185619354,
0.3069629967212677,
-0.823767900466919,
-0.18699124455451965,
0.5097542405128479,
0.4028094410896301,
0.030232079327106476,
-0.12154635041952133,
-0.07248067855834961,
-1.1767246723175049,
0.2988088130950928,
-0.13782313466072083,
-0.09491850435733795,
-0.5634369850158691,
-0.3990516662597656,
0.14931513369083405,
0.0199415422976017,
-0.38530248403549194,
0.7492758631706238,
-0.5212745666503906,
-0.054482124745845795,
-0.19765354692935944,
0.3580884635448456,
-0.21832625567913055,
0.7413870096206665,
-0.05737241357564926,
0.5446170568466187,
0.639531672000885,
-0.3772214651107788,
0.32396742701530457,
0.3978010416030884,
-0.3481467366218567,
0.3365389406681061,
-0.4099441468715668,
0.291483074426651,
-0.32626962661743164,
-0.05466991290450096,
-0.9583134651184082,
-0.1561013013124466,
0.24247364699840546,
-0.48967835307121277,
0.4168594777584076,
-0.179913729429245,
-0.30296963453292847,
0.029891300946474075,
-0.41349977254867554,
0.4927724301815033,
0.4791831076145172,
-0.6222161054611206,
0.5420808792114258,
0.4826740026473999,
0.10389209538698196,
-1.1543577909469604,
-0.3097895085811615,
-0.16329853236675262,
-0.2411837875843048,
-0.38680002093315125,
0.317706435918808,
0.20536918938159943,
0.15303364396095276,
-0.13466864824295044,
-0.25060954689979553,
0.14661915600299835,
0.1843525618314743,
-0.015347893349826336,
0.4091700613498688,
-0.059910763055086136,
0.27681925892829895,
-0.12418317049741745,
-0.14738702774047852,
-0.3212452530860901,
-0.4714812636375427,
0.5984915494918823,
-0.013289449736475945,
-0.35473474860191345,
-0.47866663336753845,
0.08424292504787445,
0.6562583446502686,
-0.024868501350283623,
0.5139516592025757,
0.3343764543533325,
-0.43954983353614807,
-0.06244876980781555,
-0.6592085957527161,
-0.049706604331731796,
-0.4519405961036682,
0.6389319896697998,
-0.02815757319331169,
-0.7254031300544739,
0.5664732456207275,
0.03288378193974495,
-0.04099905490875244,
0.17713434994220734,
0.4330260157585144,
-0.22483505308628082,
0.789435863494873,
0.513620913028717,
-0.7090767621994019,
0.6423762440681458,
-0.03405711427330971,
0.2293277382850647,
-0.8631463646888733,
-0.13943172991275787,
-0.37169149518013,
-0.7013373374938965,
-0.3886146545410156,
-0.13147485256195068,
0.04873400926589966,
0.4705270528793335,
-0.32831838726997375,
0.33008769154548645,
-0.5664766430854797,
0.6997461915016174,
0.6069924235343933,
0.011604925617575645,
0.15071487426757812,
0.2412581890821457,
0.05694383755326271,
0.05304110422730446,
-0.873806893825531,
-0.3369194269180298,
1.0957775115966797,
0.13636355102062225,
0.9887838363647461,
-0.005279625300318003,
0.8965668678283691,
-0.04438822716474533,
0.30555668473243713,
-1.0722277164459229,
0.4956495463848114,
-0.17979183793067932,
-0.23910409212112427,
-0.4777272641658783,
-0.651422917842865,
-1.0524482727050781,
0.1716764271259308,
-0.4088450074195862,
-0.9371826648712158,
0.15190991759300232,
0.4473330080509186,
-0.4332059323787689,
0.314159095287323,
-0.5946749448776245,
0.8492046594619751,
-0.5384464859962463,
-0.44168123602867126,
-0.0781470462679863,
-0.6227453351020813,
0.36723580956459045,
-0.13877138495445251,
-0.07429216057062149,
-0.04462626576423645,
-0.061906587332487106,
0.6979620456695557,
-0.16518451273441315,
0.8908137083053589,
0.13194791972637177,
-0.11543594300746918,
0.09927155077457428,
-0.18238875269889832,
0.6422238945960999,
-0.27417176961898804,
-0.15534809231758118,
0.3684932291507721,
-0.3867296576499939,
-0.4065050482749939,
-0.5105385184288025,
0.9866886734962463,
-0.9500780701637268,
-0.3475300967693329,
-0.3691498935222626,
-0.5444497466087341,
-0.2780933380126953,
0.2484394907951355,
0.3096361756324768,
-0.06528142839670181,
-0.2198101431131363,
0.06390655040740967,
0.5829880833625793,
0.035519279539585114,
0.46841666102409363,
0.18355600535869598,
0.2155904769897461,
-0.6463946104049683,
0.8306803703308105,
-0.043891724199056625,
0.21599628031253815,
0.5152971744537354,
0.14060768485069275,
-0.32193848490715027,
-0.6051363945007324,
-0.5690279006958008,
0.43880268931388855,
-0.6776503324508667,
-0.3949992060661316,
-0.4612683355808258,
0.016813376918435097,
-0.2869637608528137,
-0.2819134593009949,
-0.7036670446395874,
-0.4042665660381317,
-0.471935898065567,
0.04906269907951355,
0.23033443093299866,
0.31054407358169556,
0.05247030034661293,
0.5716730356216431,
-0.963678777217865,
0.04956662282347679,
-0.017961962148547173,
0.36636143922805786,
0.22286517918109894,
-0.35933178663253784,
-0.30362996459007263,
0.20726966857910156,
-0.47622624039649963,
-0.6231521964073181,
0.21748049557209015,
0.32972317934036255,
0.7709804773330688,
0.6916869282722473,
-0.1952262669801712,
0.8747726678848267,
-0.5111430287361145,
0.26174768805503845,
0.6272301077842712,
-0.9838760495185852,
0.40708446502685547,
-0.30262666940689087,
0.19486194849014282,
0.7978894114494324,
0.4809834659099579,
-0.4999817907810211,
0.16483086347579956,
-0.40322211384773254,
-0.830335259437561,
0.9180812239646912,
0.07187491655349731,
0.0213940367102623,
0.08484494686126709,
0.6114013195037842,
-0.07658606022596359,
0.2676581144332886,
-0.822365939617157,
-0.20612722635269165,
0.16206036508083344,
-0.600426971912384,
-0.02125573717057705,
-0.04871392250061035,
-0.43830522894859314,
-0.24667346477508545,
0.7072336077690125,
-0.33455660939216614,
0.19183014333248138,
-0.28709810972213745,
-0.2869608998298645,
-0.38244324922561646,
0.12329040467739105,
0.7718374729156494,
0.5978012681007385,
-0.07886747270822525,
-0.15786001086235046,
0.3410418629646301,
-0.23342318832874298,
0.2814696133136749,
-0.2646750509738922,
-0.36961525678634644,
-0.27975407242774963,
0.48412376642227173,
0.9885580539703369,
0.3201669156551361,
-0.5955649614334106,
0.728029727935791,
0.30564016103744507,
-0.3170640170574188,
-0.24512965977191925,
0.10896259546279907,
0.16036754846572876,
0.1015402302145958,
-0.004897403065115213,
0.33821460604667664,
-0.15704654157161713,
-0.5199949741363525,
0.14571501314640045,
0.6798034906387329,
-0.38913342356681824,
-0.19240407645702362,
0.5020288825035095,
0.22616083920001984,
-0.18003016710281372,
0.7496832609176636,
-0.06709826737642288,
-0.5373134016990662,
0.4794653058052063,
0.5083383917808533,
0.9240679144859314,
-0.13317462801933289,
-0.05828185752034187,
0.5245343446731567,
0.2461603432893753,
-0.521577775478363,
0.07733576744794846,
-0.1249304860830307,
-1.0157030820846558,
-0.611473798751831,
-0.6959750652313232,
-0.06803391128778458,
0.10685843229293823,
-0.5385698676109314,
0.5303336977958679,
-0.4556538164615631,
-0.06162929907441139,
-0.19129019975662231,
-0.34227797389030457,
-0.21928302943706512,
-0.05190032348036766,
0.16496829688549042,
0.5102565288543701,
-1.0011242628097534,
0.9934539198875427,
0.6158981323242188,
-0.20078308880329132,
-0.48135852813720703,
-0.08695054054260254,
0.09736510366201401,
-1.1377689838409424,
0.7176422476768494,
-0.021173251792788506,
-0.3185218274593353,
0.08982134610414505,
-0.5799476504325867,
-1.2312884330749512,
0.983085572719574,
0.5129284262657166,
-0.8761131763458252,
-0.14478644728660583,
-0.015390380285680294,
0.4093882441520691,
-0.3724522292613983,
0.1954168826341629,
0.48050549626350403,
0.316860169172287,
0.41920164227485657,
-0.8683322668075562,
-0.018991077318787575,
-0.049908820539712906,
-0.019498463720083237,
0.5449258089065552,
-0.7233456969261169,
0.6793518662452698,
-0.26729917526245117,
-0.1998576819896698,
0.17816446721553802,
0.3676491677761078,
0.26381683349609375,
0.008500911295413971,
0.6132410764694214,
1.03559410572052,
0.8920639753341675,
-0.15047933161258698,
0.6701645851135254,
-0.2502167224884033,
0.5223105549812317,
1.2952219247817993,
-0.4608725905418396,
0.8958293199539185,
0.6231326460838318,
0.11535759270191193,
-0.08755552768707275,
0.668286144733429,
-0.050798237323760986,
0.6432761549949646,
0.3652978539466858,
-0.005759244319051504,
-0.43551352620124817,
0.0461389422416687,
-0.08516092598438263,
0.4945492148399353,
-0.020865757018327713,
-0.09188233315944672,
-0.1695038229227066,
-0.16257742047309875,
-0.04261650890111923,
0.00004530850492301397,
-0.21294766664505005,
1.0027518272399902,
-0.046085577458143234,
-0.8602311015129089,
1.18815279006958,
-0.21238331496715546,
0.8035300374031067,
-0.6971819996833801,
0.18108323216438293,
-0.38871118426322937,
0.3970028758049011,
-0.286396861076355,
-0.4802589416503906,
0.12079926580190659,
-0.2515762746334076,
-0.2367536574602127,
-0.19194327294826508,
0.2822343409061432,
-0.6296656727790833,
-0.20812976360321045,
0.4771982729434967,
0.183368980884552,
-0.02194257080554962,
0.0980134829878807,
-0.6307206749916077,
-0.011529161594808102,
0.185050368309021,
-0.008375268429517746,
0.48901090025901794,
0.1871180534362793,
-0.16678623855113983,
0.7686948776245117,
0.6687307953834534,
0.32977956533432007,
0.001995248021557927,
0.19025787711143494,
0.729096531867981,
-0.6404332518577576,
-0.21483761072158813,
-0.9342982769012451,
0.282234787940979,
-0.18484772741794586,
-0.48737308382987976,
0.41802147030830383,
0.7005196213722229,
0.900015115737915,
0.045247044414281845,
0.494010329246521,
0.20359693467617035,
0.20079034566879272,
-0.7125282287597656,
0.7409198880195618,
-0.8825538754463196,
0.29672878980636597,
-0.17194817960262299,
-1.2472718954086304,
-0.4005371630191803,
0.7305459976196289,
-0.0765952318906784,
-0.0876997709274292,
0.6791138648986816,
0.9800545573234558,
-0.21516264975070953,
-0.1707358956336975,
0.3133540749549866,
0.10919798165559769,
-0.1333632469177246,
0.7873806357383728,
0.8749814629554749,
-0.39551302790641785,
0.47363701462745667,
-0.10813906043767929,
-0.3034835159778595,
-0.27945220470428467,
-0.8233906030654907,
-0.7256819009780884,
-0.3678600788116455,
-0.22062665224075317,
-0.07485611736774445,
0.16138751804828644,
1.192336082458496,
0.688385009765625,
-0.6832410097122192,
-0.45442017912864685,
-0.03482615947723389,
0.20716659724712372,
-0.17084011435508728,
-0.04249349236488342,
0.3568664789199829,
-0.4028111398220062,
-0.8183371424674988,
0.36822497844696045,
0.23483425378799438,
0.03486858680844307,
0.176273912191391,
-0.2648838460445404,
-0.4468289911746979,
-0.27162519097328186,
0.5220638513565063,
0.28973594307899475,
-0.770233690738678,
-0.27082857489585876,
0.1320580542087555,
-0.19280187785625458,
0.30884864926338196,
0.6418607234954834,
-0.2066136598587036,
0.23186632990837097,
0.725605309009552,
0.8980984687805176,
0.3335890471935272,
0.23485052585601807,
0.5119538307189941,
-0.8376273512840271,
0.12680584192276,
0.15343084931373596,
0.622968852519989,
0.37187904119491577,
-0.39676904678344727,
0.32857248187065125,
0.07602878659963608,
-0.6596785187721252,
-0.6587112545967102,
0.20012108981609344,
-1.184808373451233,
-0.19214001297950745,
1.1408922672271729,
0.122864730656147,
-0.47857871651649475,
0.22960196435451508,
-0.05157385766506195,
0.26594278216362,
-0.5196598768234253,
0.9560903310775757,
0.6314105987548828,
-0.18305258452892303,
-0.09229091554880142,
-0.22163817286491394,
0.509080708026886,
0.816607654094696,
-0.6057965159416199,
0.1745835542678833,
0.5985525250434875,
0.371082067489624,
0.28075775504112244,
0.6018199920654297,
0.03531415015459061,
0.017699597403407097,
-0.38392123579978943,
0.5663451552391052,
0.1145247370004654,
-0.2595632076263428,
-0.5473006963729858,
-0.1585133969783783,
0.06360189616680145,
-0.4598536193370819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12593v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12593v1 | PromptDSI: Prompt-based Rehearsal-free Instance-wise Incremental Learning for Document Retrieval | 2024-06-18T13:25:18 | 2024-06-18T13:25:18 | Tuan-Luc Huynh, Thuy-Trang Vu, Weiqing Wang, Yinwei Wei, Trung Le, Dragan Gasevic, Yuan-Fang Li, Thanh-Toan Do | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Differentiable Search Index (DSI) utilizes Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs)
for efficient document retrieval without relying on external indexes. However,
DSIs need full re-training to handle updates in dynamic corpora, causing
significant computational inefficiencies. We introduce PromptDSI, a
rehearsal-free, prompt-based approach for instance-wise incremental learning in
document retrieval. PromptDSI attaches prompts to the frozen PLM's encoder of
DSI, leveraging its powerful representation to efficiently index new corpora
while maintaining a balance between stability and plasticity. We eliminate the
initial forward pass of prompt-based continual learning methods that doubles
training and inference time. Moreover, we propose a topic-aware prompt pool
that employs neural topic embeddings as fixed keys. This strategy ensures
diverse and effective prompt usage, addressing the challenge of parameter
underutilization caused by the collapse of the query-key matching mechanism.
Our empirical evaluations demonstrate that PromptDSI matches IncDSI in managing
forgetting while significantly enhancing recall by over 4% on new corpora. | [
-0.20881471037864685,
-0.326458603143692,
0.7427132725715637,
0.17464607954025269,
-0.28502801060676575,
0.1543816477060318,
-0.0922740176320076,
0.4128563404083252,
0.26388606429100037,
0.024665726348757744,
-0.9278346300125122,
-0.5780506730079651,
-0.25829702615737915,
0.25006791949272156,
-0.21809318661689758,
0.568250834941864,
0.045296140015125275,
0.1349453628063202,
-0.4193303883075714,
-0.18935446441173553,
-0.6348493695259094,
-0.3616308271884918,
-0.837867259979248,
0.13150332868099213,
0.8032411336898804,
0.6330793499946594,
0.11611494421958923,
0.5568615198135376,
0.045408837497234344,
0.26048314571380615,
-0.10940436273813248,
0.033275630325078964,
-0.4265185296535492,
0.6048789024353027,
-0.0551985464990139,
-0.5953643321990967,
0.04151802137494087,
0.37666046619415283,
0.7771830558776855,
0.5848644971847534,
-0.3285076916217804,
-0.35248154401779175,
-0.15287011861801147,
0.5526998043060303,
-0.6195328235626221,
-0.06676407903432846,
-0.7246045470237732,
0.09949810057878494,
-0.19332027435302734,
-0.5962044596672058,
-0.49580955505371094,
-0.444036066532135,
0.020693562924861908,
-0.7710167765617371,
0.47341668605804443,
-0.25895029306411743,
0.4400707185268402,
0.15861523151397705,
-0.26264873147010803,
-0.6110217571258545,
0.012035364285111427,
0.7308631539344788,
-0.4695349633693695,
0.5379385352134705,
0.30209675431251526,
0.1776188313961029,
-0.049771182239055634,
-0.7719769477844238,
-0.5890715718269348,
-0.27248069643974304,
0.09512989968061447,
0.21106180548667908,
0.32440322637557983,
-0.03413786366581917,
0.4746408462524414,
0.3508889079093933,
-0.6935743093490601,
0.16302134096622467,
-0.03160570561885834,
0.041578587144613266,
0.2621770203113556,
0.20513176918029785,
0.3816152811050415,
0.06692694872617722,
-0.18226368725299835,
-0.20536626875400543,
-0.7657187581062317,
0.036465514451265335,
0.4359206557273865,
0.5814571380615234,
-0.006227059289813042,
0.13783515989780426,
-0.1412145048379898,
0.409709632396698,
0.460050493478775,
0.026150472462177277,
0.31429407000541687,
-0.24897873401641846,
0.2638396620750427,
0.16651315987110138,
0.18674686551094055,
0.101895272731781,
-0.14014869928359985,
-0.48293066024780273,
-0.3425233066082001,
0.22380970418453217,
0.255386620759964,
-0.9080023765563965,
-0.008681333623826504,
0.20224206149578094,
-0.17014338076114655,
-0.15658578276634216,
0.08337036520242691,
-0.6662817001342773,
-0.3994975984096527,
-0.46138429641723633,
0.3188824951648712,
-0.7771211862564087,
0.08516710251569748,
-0.3414156436920166,
-0.4021613597869873,
0.3058936595916748,
0.3708707392215729,
-0.9241428971290588,
0.16796892881393433,
0.7502889633178711,
0.8726310729980469,
0.005413927603513002,
-0.4943692088127136,
-1.307826042175293,
-0.16745872795581818,
-0.5771145224571228,
0.6536383628845215,
-0.7541816234588623,
-0.724147617816925,
0.21812565624713898,
0.1531103551387787,
-0.4352748394012451,
-0.44550469517707825,
0.6389716267585754,
-0.6861425042152405,
0.4461614489555359,
-0.4766518771648407,
-0.8801066279411316,
0.19191162288188934,
0.24596518278121948,
-0.4768572449684143,
0.9021802544593811,
0.02507464587688446,
-0.7054991126060486,
0.386043518781662,
-0.41498056054115295,
-0.32480284571647644,
0.22790277004241943,
-0.3712272047996521,
-0.16732506453990936,
0.1641867309808731,
0.06961304694414139,
0.18041224777698517,
-0.1569342464208603,
0.4303659498691559,
-0.17225617170333862,
-0.6276711821556091,
0.09943395853042603,
-0.4448973834514618,
0.4211152195930481,
0.35280731320381165,
0.04526442289352417,
0.4078909158706665,
-0.8794174790382385,
-0.08756721019744873,
-0.10598616302013397,
-0.25756362080574036,
-0.5145829916000366,
-0.1916852444410324,
-0.1428002119064331,
0.18880224227905273,
0.04086310788989067,
-0.4479483962059021,
0.371550589799881,
-0.25825366377830505,
0.47188928723335266,
0.736852765083313,
0.280883252620697,
0.5887501239776611,
-0.3983042538166046,
0.4492637813091278,
0.1485404670238495,
-0.0008022756082937121,
-0.8082496523857117,
-0.28544169664382935,
-0.5680489540100098,
-0.3605344891548157,
0.18889668583869934,
0.4184114634990692,
-1.0041396617889404,
0.13520635664463043,
-0.22732633352279663,
-0.3918285667896271,
-0.6100484728813171,
-0.14908598363399506,
0.15861418843269348,
0.68817138671875,
0.2323470562696457,
-0.26689621806144714,
-0.2708546817302704,
-0.47977179288864136,
0.13821418583393097,
0.13641272485256195,
-0.17452335357666016,
0.3188801109790802,
0.17045457661151886,
-0.2734883725643158,
0.7997265458106995,
-0.29968124628067017,
-0.21386133134365082,
-0.06809259951114655,
0.5759239196777344,
0.24988724291324615,
0.6077213287353516,
0.49619489908218384,
-0.8924902677536011,
-0.40414270758628845,
-0.6754035949707031,
-0.7152186036109924,
-0.11885067075490952,
-0.42303767800331116,
0.12773770093917847,
0.3082432448863983,
0.661181628704071,
-0.6043856739997864,
0.10348206758499146,
-0.10366549342870712,
-0.38883712887763977,
0.14076600968837738,
-0.6625390648841858,
0.45651108026504517,
-0.9765543937683105,
0.20082275569438934,
-0.02576306462287903,
0.11838867515325546,
-0.44450244307518005,
0.06974365562200546,
0.5872008800506592,
-0.7451359629631042,
-0.4433545768260956,
0.609411895275116,
-0.6144942045211792,
0.004184683319181204,
-0.1564638614654541,
0.4856138229370117,
-0.12775364518165588,
0.46095800399780273,
0.08213397115468979,
1.215253233909607,
0.7285288572311401,
-0.893405020236969,
-0.088226318359375,
0.3512354791164398,
-0.12830542027950287,
0.7974779009819031,
-0.4675402343273163,
0.4725840389728546,
-0.4665849208831787,
0.09503951668739319,
-0.9352447390556335,
0.09098749607801437,
0.046823181211948395,
-0.23046855628490448,
0.8609768748283386,
-0.19982221722602844,
-0.19999167323112488,
-0.15602894127368927,
-0.7819390892982483,
0.21384508907794952,
0.23789754509925842,
-0.7793560028076172,
0.3282226622104645,
0.10322444140911102,
-0.3778740465641022,
-0.4834368824958801,
-0.038732342422008514,
0.1785804182291031,
-0.15737305581569672,
-0.35281383991241455,
0.5705007910728455,
-0.4666186273097992,
-0.017291070893406868,
-0.10645437985658646,
-0.3428898751735687,
-0.16351141035556793,
0.32725289463996887,
0.08527645468711853,
0.0733226016163826,
-0.021875839680433273,
0.414494127035141,
0.2531712055206299,
-0.49176129698753357,
-0.5115466117858887,
-0.4321550130844116,
0.5068411231040955,
0.14832018315792084,
-0.2671114206314087,
-0.473976194858551,
0.816304624080658,
0.6565777063369751,
-0.2690284848213196,
0.45324864983558655,
0.318453311920166,
-0.30581286549568176,
-0.11413168162107468,
-0.5955695509910583,
-0.26221510767936707,
-0.4564404785633087,
0.10075502097606659,
-0.7385239601135254,
-0.7886922359466553,
0.38234955072402954,
-0.18892663717269897,
-0.1794954538345337,
0.24802981317043304,
-0.013325503095984459,
0.0009141647606156766,
0.5725837349891663,
0.7405137419700623,
-0.06330052763223648,
0.6371914148330688,
-0.3901805281639099,
-0.18343758583068848,
-0.8466274738311768,
-0.10827885568141937,
-0.6808784604072571,
-0.11392044275999069,
-0.3911987245082855,
-0.36050185561180115,
0.11565907299518585,
0.11832471191883087,
-0.26970174908638,
0.17150676250457764,
-0.3262951970100403,
0.42274510860443115,
0.6917361617088318,
-0.11018940061330795,
0.02461596205830574,
-0.2514934539794922,
-0.2885962128639221,
-0.3135226368904114,
-0.6803291440010071,
-0.30269894003868103,
0.7948635816574097,
-0.09849863499403,
0.5467720031738281,
-0.08071419596672058,
0.8825038075447083,
0.3446837365627289,
0.16171789169311523,
-0.6012589931488037,
0.5954079031944275,
-0.13550209999084473,
-0.013165143318474293,
-0.23011940717697144,
-0.4048871397972107,
-0.8676134347915649,
0.10011399537324905,
0.139565110206604,
-0.4923916459083557,
0.6252026557922363,
-0.2272864282131195,
-0.3612368404865265,
0.03473259508609772,
-0.7104785442352295,
0.7207632064819336,
-0.1893063485622406,
-0.46811217069625854,
-0.3933635652065277,
-0.5507104992866516,
-0.32392197847366333,
0.07764919847249985,
-0.1687985509634018,
0.055322643369436264,
-0.3130140006542206,
0.6228560209274292,
-0.3102011978626251,
0.6780753135681152,
-0.5642604231834412,
0.09287144988775253,
0.2148078978061676,
-0.024129673838615417,
0.6286149024963379,
0.42541712522506714,
-0.40677374601364136,
-0.22690129280090332,
-0.13193070888519287,
-0.30136972665786743,
-0.792963445186615,
1.1315639019012451,
-0.569715142250061,
-0.7152683138847351,
-0.6297953128814697,
-0.14191566407680511,
-0.18515238165855408,
0.11722958087921143,
0.3184804618358612,
0.8037843108177185,
-0.3159763514995575,
-0.0763011947274208,
0.937545657157898,
-0.23937563598155975,
0.6842548847198486,
0.8628482222557068,
0.303478866815567,
-0.45348259806632996,
0.9597641825675964,
0.22651560604572296,
-0.30681779980659485,
0.5941100120544434,
-0.08939985185861588,
-0.5242437720298767,
-0.42886683344841003,
-0.33751988410949707,
0.34714457392692566,
-0.7161542773246765,
-0.07901673763990402,
-0.783044695854187,
0.03781513869762421,
-0.4073319733142853,
-0.32703372836112976,
-0.12629127502441406,
-0.32949915528297424,
-0.6497780680656433,
-0.30320674180984497,
0.3415410816669464,
0.13562864065170288,
-0.13019731640815735,
-0.014906374737620354,
-0.6011457443237305,
0.2827810049057007,
0.5451728105545044,
0.609246015548706,
-0.04249774292111397,
-0.5637287497520447,
0.07074134051799774,
-0.39048323035240173,
-0.07758031785488129,
-0.948348343372345,
0.5643851161003113,
0.40857595205307007,
0.7622069120407104,
0.35286301374435425,
0.3598008453845978,
0.47659096121788025,
-0.6361072659492493,
0.6095095276832581,
0.012368589639663696,
-0.8917384147644043,
0.7966697812080383,
-0.22497166693210602,
0.26378387212753296,
0.9316977262496948,
0.6933690309524536,
-1.0008701086044312,
-0.05436323583126068,
-0.44916635751724243,
-1.00778067111969,
0.902226984500885,
-0.3121063709259033,
0.14938150346279144,
-0.5381268262863159,
0.7133294343948364,
0.4214194715023041,
0.4572930634021759,
-0.11198949813842773,
-0.08893118798732758,
-0.20492006838321686,
-0.35590866208076477,
-0.20926690101623535,
-0.7458274960517883,
0.09419753402471542,
-0.01183878444135189,
0.8269122242927551,
-0.3348175287246704,
0.4382627308368683,
0.6191927790641785,
-0.341465562582016,
0.008754042908549309,
0.4465923309326172,
0.4754423499107361,
0.41715148091316223,
-0.4068273901939392,
0.05040125921368599,
0.052911560982465744,
-0.33476704359054565,
0.27322590351104736,
0.3186754882335663,
-0.32800203561782837,
0.12224705517292023,
-0.10738896578550339,
0.9275246262550354,
0.501929521560669,
-0.634581983089447,
0.4314083158969879,
-0.4552919864654541,
0.07859399914741516,
-0.3359416425228119,
-0.15449589490890503,
-0.06144839525222778,
0.20146247744560242,
0.5252339243888855,
-0.09370344877243042,
0.04333788529038429,
-0.5372055768966675,
0.5351926684379578,
0.12971311807632446,
-0.6462889313697815,
-0.3561377227306366,
0.6034097075462341,
0.32531240582466125,
-0.5107003450393677,
0.9581942558288574,
-0.4502876102924347,
-0.1141965463757515,
0.3299809992313385,
0.4470449984073639,
1.1714937686920166,
-0.29359957575798035,
0.4857654273509979,
0.37935659289360046,
-0.016678612679243088,
-0.004041342530399561,
0.41361796855926514,
-0.4917465150356293,
-0.4172895550727844,
0.06684084981679916,
-0.2577124238014221,
-0.4028339982032776,
0.07832511514425278,
-0.44632428884506226,
0.2038072943687439,
-0.4479522109031677,
0.22624006867408752,
-0.27910104393959045,
0.2393081784248352,
-0.5605910420417786,
0.08200730383396149,
-0.03112911619246006,
1.2343851327896118,
-0.5090288519859314,
0.9836744070053101,
0.5937260985374451,
-0.7765953540802002,
-0.3947201669216156,
0.2663946747779846,
-0.09999893605709076,
-0.234087273478508,
0.4293806850910187,
0.49450868368148804,
0.12519671022891998,
0.20166000723838806,
-0.26052820682525635,
-0.846934974193573,
1.2165894508361816,
0.33546411991119385,
-0.6543914675712585,
-0.038691215217113495,
-0.6037680506706238,
0.4571733772754669,
-0.3637482225894928,
0.5295224785804749,
0.11986924707889557,
0.1982961744070053,
0.07073798775672913,
-0.19080354273319244,
0.030183669179677963,
-0.4516092538833618,
0.3102945387363434,
-0.06844644993543625,
-0.5452842712402344,
0.8905996084213257,
-0.1389307826757431,
-0.7094388604164124,
0.4866415560245514,
0.4550570249557495,
0.09949462860822678,
0.709729790687561,
0.3622336983680725,
0.5123506188392639,
1.2056471109390259,
-0.13942267000675201,
1.1758650541305542,
-0.4363759458065033,
-0.04515579342842102,
1.036284327507019,
-0.5863857269287109,
0.7046017646789551,
0.473417192697525,
0.25745803117752075,
0.294569194316864,
0.7405271530151367,
0.2741181254386902,
0.9509966373443604,
0.07833660393953323,
-0.5482434034347534,
-0.15598785877227783,
-0.14880631864070892,
-0.3341671824455261,
-0.26353034377098083,
0.2025778889656067,
0.06171894818544388,
-0.2289436012506485,
0.29389169812202454,
-0.1896306425333023,
0.48412227630615234,
-0.07042501866817474,
0.85999596118927,
-0.09785258769989014,
-0.7712892293930054,
0.5038747787475586,
-0.019026512280106544,
0.8899135589599609,
-0.8534369468688965,
0.09972749650478363,
-0.7602810263633728,
0.01890033483505249,
0.2939606010913849,
-0.17716054618358612,
0.09265081584453583,
-0.0712931901216507,
-0.418805330991745,
-0.257904052734375,
0.5648225545883179,
-0.6293745040893555,
-0.08767622709274292,
0.229191392660141,
0.44158151745796204,
-0.0645221695303917,
0.003930156119167805,
-0.48514240980148315,
-0.04720607399940491,
-0.28333520889282227,
-0.04596174508333206,
0.6279333829879761,
0.8166802525520325,
-0.11033299565315247,
0.656898021697998,
0.4602629840373993,
-0.3879682421684265,
-0.22339501976966858,
0.3832184970378876,
0.9437307715415955,
-0.8532605171203613,
-0.7644830346107483,
-0.25574398040771484,
0.25567343831062317,
-0.019253907725214958,
-0.2620583772659302,
0.5090609192848206,
0.49844321608543396,
0.6715826988220215,
-0.29537972807884216,
0.5412840247154236,
0.2847592234611511,
0.5816237330436707,
-0.5747635364532471,
0.6935294270515442,
-0.377478688955307,
0.32616084814071655,
-0.10850436240434647,
-0.6194585561752319,
-0.05364461988210678,
0.37274956703186035,
-0.25454315543174744,
-0.10438883304595947,
0.7405430674552917,
0.862899899482727,
0.13287881016731262,
0.034370530396699905,
0.42490068078041077,
-0.039556197822093964,
0.2766125202178955,
0.21989859640598297,
0.8550652265548706,
-0.4730072021484375,
0.2430751621723175,
-0.03553580865263939,
-0.30283650755882263,
0.019276782870292664,
-0.7630154490470886,
-0.42286399006843567,
-0.90464848279953,
-0.6719520688056946,
0.15681178867816925,
0.5146312713623047,
0.9134105443954468,
0.4127967357635498,
-0.7276952266693115,
-0.025915618985891342,
-0.3832339644432068,
0.3469066321849823,
-0.3501087725162506,
-0.2259027361869812,
0.4894122779369354,
-1.1057345867156982,
-0.806679904460907,
1.055423617362976,
0.4014231562614441,
0.06767231225967407,
0.18468984961509705,
-0.04722059890627861,
-0.5992276072502136,
0.20158250629901886,
0.30063796043395996,
0.4207400381565094,
-0.17267730832099915,
-0.12176360934972763,
0.1228247806429863,
-0.1374746710062027,
0.07664195448160172,
1.1148793697357178,
-1.152421474456787,
0.5031967759132385,
0.4705336093902588,
0.7233734726905823,
0.4746774435043335,
-0.21088507771492004,
0.4324110746383667,
-1.0666018724441528,
0.5602817535400391,
0.22823235392570496,
0.4136892259120941,
0.5270666480064392,
-0.4659011960029602,
0.44582271575927734,
0.6173014640808105,
-0.229828342795372,
-0.5783654451370239,
0.11698339879512787,
-0.7670982480049133,
-0.40005552768707275,
0.6158406138420105,
-0.2934767007827759,
-0.08333178609609604,
0.01096940878778696,
-0.26601681113243103,
0.2762804925441742,
-0.799683153629303,
0.8904920220375061,
0.2124636024236679,
0.5292521715164185,
-0.2774967849254608,
-0.06655719876289368,
0.5773580074310303,
0.34728652238845825,
-0.29342520236968994,
-0.04780462011694908,
0.593584418296814,
0.09723164141178131,
0.18315836787223816,
0.9584822654724121,
-0.13831935822963715,
0.28174659609794617,
0.1506190448999405,
-0.19990544021129608,
-0.1603858768939972,
-0.5122573971748352,
-0.7838454842567444,
0.40647268295288086,
-0.07058795541524887,
-0.36541175842285156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12585v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12585v1 | Breaking the Ceiling of the LLM Community by Treating Token Generation as a Classification for Ensembling | 2024-06-18T13:17:26 | 2024-06-18T13:17:26 | Yao-Ching Yu, Chun-Chih Kuo, Ziqi Ye, Yu-Cheng Chang, Yueh-Se Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Ensembling multiple models has always been an effective approach to push the
limits of existing performance and is widely used in classification tasks by
simply averaging the classification probability vectors from multiple
classifiers to achieve better accuracy. However, in the thriving open-source
Large Language Model (LLM) community, ensembling methods are rare and typically
limited to ensembling the full-text outputs of LLMs, such as selecting the best
output using a ranker, which leads to underutilization of token-level
probability information. In this paper, we treat the Generation of each token
by LLMs as a Classification (GaC) for ensembling. This approach fully exploits
the probability information at each generation step and better prevents LLMs
from producing early incorrect tokens that lead to snowballing errors. In
experiments, we ensemble state-of-the-art LLMs on several benchmarks, including
exams, mathematics and reasoning, and observe that our method breaks the
existing community performance ceiling. Furthermore, we observed that most of
the tokens in the answer are simple and do not affect the correctness of the
final answer. Therefore, we also experimented with ensembling only key tokens,
and the results showed better performance with lower latency across benchmarks. | [
-0.1935858428478241,
-0.7599256038665771,
0.5228822827339172,
-0.14271512627601624,
-0.4441414773464203,
0.4067094922065735,
-0.17516213655471802,
-0.4006614685058594,
0.1910073459148407,
0.5172322392463684,
-0.29346996545791626,
-0.6360456347465515,
-0.7663710117340088,
-0.08120591938495636,
-0.4465980529785156,
0.8141016960144043,
0.05916464328765869,
-0.23563571274280548,
-0.6182314157485962,
-0.005363443400710821,
-0.3673587143421173,
-0.8940727710723877,
-0.7210281491279602,
-0.15091311931610107,
0.3667588531970978,
0.5603466033935547,
0.2803483307361603,
0.857842743396759,
0.6784663200378418,
0.3070361018180847,
-0.31508946418762207,
0.4755290746688843,
-0.5128161907196045,
0.10101839900016785,
0.13301178812980652,
-0.6909263730049133,
-0.5277386903762817,
-0.006450585555285215,
0.5316397547721863,
0.5339891314506531,
-0.3613191843032837,
0.3472684323787689,
0.3986196219921112,
0.42703279852867126,
-0.770888090133667,
0.18400312960147858,
-0.9831629395484924,
-0.012666520662605762,
-0.7892395853996277,
-0.41101524233818054,
-0.7732721567153931,
-0.17792175710201263,
-0.6288938522338867,
-0.26145949959754944,
0.3371764123439789,
0.2583349347114563,
0.6847305297851562,
0.2500168979167938,
-0.2602832019329071,
-0.3307924270629883,
-0.47315990924835205,
0.7070106863975525,
-0.9349442720413208,
0.1290988326072693,
0.13329565525054932,
0.22860465943813324,
-0.1485605537891388,
-0.5958206653594971,
-0.4716693162918091,
0.21297980844974518,
0.16732004284858704,
0.03703346848487854,
-0.023913081735372543,
0.30109965801239014,
0.14789128303527832,
0.11685145646333694,
-0.5105252265930176,
0.3755253553390503,
-0.5058457851409912,
-0.13907715678215027,
0.496856689453125,
0.2606121599674225,
0.08913962543010712,
-0.20026488602161407,
-0.41548776626586914,
0.02723114565014839,
-1.0690116882324219,
0.0035455564502626657,
0.40856850147247314,
0.43378743529319763,
0.3642158508300781,
0.7347123026847839,
0.04773712903261185,
0.6096467971801758,
0.08441273868083954,
-0.08645602315664291,
0.37105491757392883,
-0.3401626646518707,
-0.27461931109428406,
0.15237723290920258,
0.6849087476730347,
0.1945076435804367,
0.09458956867456436,
-0.39295250177383423,
-0.2567022740840912,
0.06726191192865372,
0.2830735146999359,
-0.6754438281059265,
0.04669071361422539,
0.39847156405448914,
-0.44588953256607056,
-0.6273947358131409,
0.235162153840065,
-0.7450125217437744,
-0.2694205343723297,
-0.06607148051261902,
0.277813583612442,
-0.04944394901394844,
-0.08877060562372208,
-0.005664439406245947,
-0.011906445026397705,
0.04958376660943031,
0.16782048344612122,
-0.8130619525909424,
0.3942115604877472,
1.2692525386810303,
1.1437560319900513,
-0.317157119512558,
-0.2687079608440399,
-1.0258336067199707,
0.3315242826938629,
-0.34996819496154785,
0.6434498429298401,
-0.6743363738059998,
-0.26033666729927063,
0.1281874179840088,
-0.30928927659988403,
-0.07922127097845078,
-0.6451533436775208,
0.36543628573417664,
-0.47122740745544434,
-0.1565956175327301,
-0.006424970459192991,
-0.7710505723953247,
0.14879797399044037,
0.1957949697971344,
-0.3909573554992676,
0.6975934505462646,
-0.39513570070266724,
-0.6809431314468384,
0.515807569026947,
-0.537213921546936,
-0.2588939964771271,
0.24710440635681152,
-0.28524091839790344,
-0.31024622917175293,
0.3624055087566376,
0.2394094616174698,
0.5518923401832581,
-0.13237223029136658,
0.29026079177856445,
-0.3315627872943878,
-0.5379576683044434,
0.28132298588752747,
-0.5126953721046448,
0.5808618664741516,
0.32349446415901184,
-0.10454855114221573,
0.09371864795684814,
-0.5378706455230713,
0.08328483253717422,
-0.1492217630147934,
-0.46477776765823364,
-0.1990424394607544,
0.14230918884277344,
-0.34245017170906067,
0.21278707683086395,
0.2752073109149933,
-0.6850876212120056,
0.26811477541923523,
-0.6732978224754333,
0.5316025614738464,
1.1435456275939941,
0.022938581183552742,
0.5065858960151672,
-0.33288687467575073,
0.4933291971683502,
0.246450275182724,
0.16937637329101562,
0.06103656440973282,
-0.6250284910202026,
-0.8996056318283081,
-0.15050062537193298,
0.40190941095352173,
0.3683711290359497,
-0.6118684411048889,
0.5053694844245911,
-0.33221927285194397,
-0.4936569035053253,
-0.6582738757133484,
0.2010190635919571,
0.21351811289787292,
0.32372793555259705,
0.11346811801195145,
-0.30392590165138245,
-0.4690534472465515,
-0.5081906914710999,
-0.2405170500278473,
-0.532649576663971,
0.07349205017089844,
0.2475278526544571,
0.2324187010526657,
-0.00010369734081905335,
0.8240284323692322,
-0.5265184640884399,
-0.27936962246894836,
-0.21301588416099548,
0.30896851420402527,
0.42755192518234253,
0.5437085032463074,
0.11489802598953247,
-0.37135642766952515,
-0.15632155537605286,
-0.1411028802394867,
-0.6754447817802429,
-0.1019248217344284,
-0.09735235571861267,
-0.26038646697998047,
0.3552359640598297,
0.7168984413146973,
-0.5996001362800598,
0.4560663402080536,
0.28552961349487305,
-0.20226459205150604,
0.5588513016700745,
-0.07651733607053757,
-0.03053506650030613,
-0.9131953120231628,
-0.24166077375411987,
-0.22399811446666718,
-0.006050667259842157,
-0.6266939043998718,
0.568207323551178,
0.08786986768245697,
0.19052675366401672,
-0.47089383006095886,
0.3241886794567108,
-0.42038294672966003,
0.1815357655286789,
-0.2490999549627304,
0.0806955099105835,
-0.2561537027359009,
0.3197751045227051,
-0.2574019432067871,
0.45449045300483704,
0.5470420122146606,
-0.5441553592681885,
0.3356393575668335,
0.16276957094669342,
-0.36222875118255615,
0.1350446492433548,
-0.40438804030418396,
0.5036938786506653,
-0.24104006588459015,
0.027221981436014175,
-0.9683703780174255,
-0.1220560222864151,
0.22379419207572937,
-0.6554557681083679,
0.3792230188846588,
-0.30306780338287354,
-0.764063835144043,
-0.2920551002025604,
-0.14195042848587036,
0.3805677890777588,
0.593582808971405,
-0.7676400542259216,
0.4646284580230713,
0.37997108697891235,
-0.09476388245820999,
-0.7473276853561401,
-0.8250858187675476,
0.2207467257976532,
-0.43993067741394043,
-0.7232144474983215,
0.15687572956085205,
-0.02739166095852852,
-0.30398231744766235,
-0.13710498809814453,
-0.20040038228034973,
0.09452702850103378,
0.232041135430336,
0.30025750398635864,
0.27769115567207336,
-0.1015552207827568,
0.4002719223499298,
-0.12000058591365814,
-0.0940532386302948,
0.030254162847995758,
-0.1940663903951645,
0.7947447896003723,
-0.08702381700277328,
-0.8414279818534851,
0.1288047432899475,
0.2331998199224472,
0.4880068004131317,
-0.36747413873672485,
0.9906333088874817,
0.19770871102809906,
-0.39042234420776367,
-0.3745810389518738,
-0.6599124073982239,
-0.17267484962940216,
-0.5293743014335632,
0.36187461018562317,
-0.44041600823402405,
-1.0059516429901123,
0.5452515482902527,
-0.0860544890165329,
0.4924277663230896,
0.22456833720207214,
0.4437245726585388,
-0.028862973675131798,
1.1045385599136353,
0.5568075776100159,
-0.04985399544239044,
0.060996163636446,
0.13264524936676025,
0.38162732124328613,
-0.7277820706367493,
-0.25958484411239624,
-0.7223145365715027,
-0.5002052783966064,
-0.3670521378517151,
-0.7557200193405151,
0.3501848876476288,
0.3523429036140442,
-0.27465805411338806,
0.1440240740776062,
-0.6882483959197998,
0.6261381506919861,
0.4324577748775482,
0.026987096294760704,
0.45508283376693726,
0.143770232796669,
-0.16952550411224365,
0.10234362632036209,
-0.8123186230659485,
-0.5128538012504578,
1.2485295534133911,
0.3706320524215698,
0.7537243366241455,
0.26783064007759094,
1.3481981754302979,
-0.08131109923124313,
0.49223554134368896,
-0.648255467414856,
0.7031136751174927,
-0.2916434705257416,
-0.3811454772949219,
-0.3781707286834717,
-0.7782493233680725,
-0.9331461787223816,
0.3689017593860626,
0.12599031627178192,
-0.8183799982070923,
0.2434813678264618,
-0.04451020061969757,
-0.26594117283821106,
0.640278697013855,
-0.3393821716308594,
0.5766723155975342,
-0.12427742779254913,
-0.058603014796972275,
-0.21665680408477783,
-0.33781659603118896,
0.5654414892196655,
-0.38817140460014343,
0.5572729110717773,
-0.02724871039390564,
-0.24101348221302032,
0.7965236306190491,
-0.5792685747146606,
0.9092597365379333,
-0.1423664391040802,
-0.051394861191511154,
0.3591466248035431,
0.2219163179397583,
0.7383489012718201,
-0.16335833072662354,
-0.05128017067909241,
0.29456135630607605,
-0.3382250666618347,
-0.21958431601524353,
-0.5508102178573608,
0.651931643486023,
-0.6215159893035889,
-0.7938260436058044,
-0.29988622665405273,
-0.13426321744918823,
-0.16317389905452728,
-0.22436834871768951,
0.3718227446079254,
0.4872247874736786,
0.16420955955982208,
0.24467143416404724,
0.4011792838573456,
0.04199010878801346,
0.48385685682296753,
0.2978447675704956,
-0.2704147696495056,
-0.41457581520080566,
1.0738848447799683,
0.43095481395721436,
0.3246479630470276,
0.20342814922332764,
0.11100578308105469,
-0.14352384209632874,
-0.9639477729797363,
-0.20142251253128052,
0.12941251695156097,
-0.8293483257293701,
-0.4153946340084076,
-0.5044960379600525,
-0.5038352608680725,
-0.5398640632629395,
-0.19780242443084717,
-0.09729869663715363,
-0.4741353988647461,
-0.37957948446273804,
-0.4395519495010376,
-0.014179233461618423,
0.6024796366691589,
-0.17957577109336853,
0.24149364233016968,
-0.9118716716766357,
-0.14839132130146027,
0.2092127650976181,
0.32368969917297363,
0.4021076560020447,
-0.6066849231719971,
-0.23049545288085938,
-0.1513775885105133,
-0.3200891315937042,
-0.826540470123291,
0.2580921947956085,
0.31397756934165955,
0.7054869532585144,
0.626857578754425,
0.12041864544153214,
0.8483794331550598,
-0.585156261920929,
0.7658072710037231,
0.5052083134651184,
-0.924045979976654,
0.5063726305961609,
0.0420096181333065,
0.12219436466693878,
0.39898407459259033,
-0.15275417268276215,
-0.9037964940071106,
-0.853904664516449,
-0.6682798862457275,
-1.2410216331481934,
0.6768063902854919,
0.15728266537189484,
0.08511917293071747,
-0.4912211000919342,
0.29451224207878113,
0.07239989936351776,
0.24095043540000916,
-0.6083987951278687,
-0.08156073838472366,
0.07174524664878845,
-0.36374711990356445,
-0.1417982280254364,
-0.156996488571167,
-0.13245683908462524,
-0.07087551057338715,
0.6624308228492737,
-0.2560025155544281,
0.13882224261760712,
-0.14395423233509064,
-0.18871548771858215,
-0.2604007124900818,
0.26298820972442627,
0.13592568039894104,
0.529193639755249,
0.022636108100414276,
0.37887176871299744,
0.19216102361679077,
-0.27240806818008423,
0.20753125846385956,
-0.3904048800468445,
-0.14511802792549133,
-0.10901623964309692,
0.4981473684310913,
0.5101428627967834,
0.046261098235845566,
-0.7153434157371521,
0.5152380466461182,
0.17335696518421173,
-0.3682309687137604,
-0.12119072675704956,
0.2735999524593353,
0.030772143974900246,
0.14617949724197388,
0.5360255837440491,
0.2067948281764984,
-0.03701363131403923,
-0.49994397163391113,
0.38897061347961426,
0.5313451886177063,
-0.1822981834411621,
-0.04295547306537628,
0.6963269114494324,
0.34661969542503357,
-0.342648983001709,
0.7924385666847229,
-0.17481209337711334,
-0.4831673800945282,
0.7551713585853577,
0.40058428049087524,
1.0734076499938965,
0.10536152124404907,
0.2421732395887375,
0.39706459641456604,
0.4908483326435089,
-0.20297573506832123,
-0.0011980334529653192,
-0.056876420974731445,
-0.9239249229431152,
-0.7543147206306458,
-0.8883145451545715,
-0.3343236446380615,
-0.016009440645575523,
-0.5622890591621399,
0.05437842011451721,
-0.525587797164917,
-0.17640867829322815,
-0.33534327149391174,
-0.23722021281719208,
-0.608736515045166,
-0.3033182919025421,
0.40211451053619385,
1.0939536094665527,
-0.6843002438545227,
0.583931028842926,
0.524063229560852,
-0.35358649492263794,
-0.665444016456604,
0.07378676533699036,
0.06522522121667862,
-0.7142751216888428,
0.7164685130119324,
0.29624292254447937,
0.19748270511627197,
-0.1521845906972885,
-0.830786943435669,
-0.8639156222343445,
0.8997380137443542,
0.148833766579628,
-0.8218913078308105,
-0.22591283917427063,
0.420793741941452,
0.33010002970695496,
-0.3761214315891266,
0.11943010985851288,
0.4915517270565033,
0.4435945451259613,
0.27432766556739807,
-0.8232061266899109,
0.06715023517608643,
-0.2964803874492645,
-0.2992359697818756,
0.36758917570114136,
-0.8551076054573059,
0.7979848384857178,
-0.12503042817115784,
-0.4656949043273926,
0.12206775695085526,
0.5840303897857666,
0.592000424861908,
0.24893435835838318,
0.642136812210083,
0.6943681836128235,
1.180209994316101,
-0.24398449063301086,
0.6039198040962219,
-0.12055905163288116,
0.3130829930305481,
0.924692690372467,
-0.38576263189315796,
1.0438789129257202,
0.529211699962616,
-0.1796916127204895,
0.22952055931091309,
0.6357588171958923,
0.0007776815327815711,
0.45892199873924255,
0.5179471373558044,
-0.23235554993152618,
-0.6474332213401794,
0.29677441716194153,
-0.07199124246835709,
0.5092753767967224,
0.32658469676971436,
-0.10574768483638763,
-0.2424086183309555,
-0.018975025042891502,
-0.1749776303768158,
-0.18322941660881042,
-0.4984612464904785,
0.9741579294204712,
0.19704113900661469,
-0.5298124551773071,
0.4963150918483734,
0.048695169389247894,
0.9358601570129395,
-0.31957995891571045,
0.0617881640791893,
-0.11518093943595886,
0.20320972800254822,
-0.26533201336860657,
-0.690625011920929,
0.295209676027298,
0.21440251171588898,
0.10060731321573257,
-0.2624184191226959,
0.7572969198226929,
-0.330708384513855,
-0.5636898875236511,
0.10982053726911545,
0.5786449909210205,
0.4959329068660736,
0.08223702013492584,
-0.24542191624641418,
-0.11183159053325653,
-0.01882595382630825,
-0.17938490211963654,
0.5431127548217773,
0.5282599925994873,
0.16298358142375946,
0.7243171334266663,
0.8353345990180969,
0.29665622115135193,
0.21677826344966888,
0.05728505551815033,
0.70745849609375,
-0.5392839908599854,
-0.4866652190685272,
-1.167667269706726,
0.4190495014190674,
-0.2050664871931076,
-0.31565940380096436,
0.7147266864776611,
0.6352686285972595,
0.8391167521476746,
0.2593191862106323,
0.705244779586792,
0.14460182189941406,
0.2410239726305008,
-0.547347366809845,
0.7123184204101562,
-0.5886742472648621,
0.5413268804550171,
-0.06444111466407776,
-0.8311777114868164,
-0.27183517813682556,
0.300863653421402,
0.016911519691348076,
-0.23588082194328308,
0.580346941947937,
0.7417868971824646,
0.29983511567115784,
-0.04097761586308479,
0.48567065596580505,
0.24301724135875702,
0.5893341898918152,
0.6481290459632874,
0.8438273668289185,
0.0366932712495327,
0.8612838387489319,
0.024689728394150734,
-0.24587523937225342,
-0.2254667431116104,
-0.623370885848999,
-0.8693789839744568,
-0.30199578404426575,
-0.25071823596954346,
-0.32745781540870667,
0.11672273278236389,
0.8243972063064575,
0.536939263343811,
-0.7423467040061951,
-0.14581869542598724,
-0.20425808429718018,
0.1977192759513855,
-0.3760208785533905,
-0.22064021229743958,
0.2297631949186325,
-0.7519583106040955,
-0.675574779510498,
0.4128548502922058,
0.24451398849487305,
-0.212454691529274,
-0.27577224373817444,
-0.13993500173091888,
0.26752057671546936,
0.27563512325286865,
0.3124512732028961,
-0.1471835821866989,
-0.7322317957878113,
-0.4610062539577484,
0.007032973691821098,
-0.006841885857284069,
0.15342307090759277,
0.7162042260169983,
-0.7589258551597595,
0.3677097260951996,
0.6111978888511658,
0.6365023255348206,
0.37590399384498596,
0.015507957898080349,
0.3798881471157074,
-1.0748013257980347,
-0.23784437775611877,
0.32935434579849243,
0.4758227467536926,
0.01829151064157486,
-0.4647705852985382,
0.6385048627853394,
0.258566677570343,
-0.6636048555374146,
-1.1820522546768188,
0.12099842727184296,
-0.6347144246101379,
-0.44537675380706787,
1.1520180702209473,
-0.002649513306096196,
-0.38869190216064453,
-0.08891450613737106,
0.12879186868667603,
0.2516533434391022,
-0.38629022240638733,
0.8411110639572144,
1.0057151317596436,
0.060759782791137695,
-0.038991477340459824,
-0.395000159740448,
0.03485623374581337,
0.15267804265022278,
-0.6479350328445435,
0.32382702827453613,
0.1698872447013855,
0.12120099365711212,
0.25408393144607544,
0.4991873502731323,
-0.22516551613807678,
0.1325613558292389,
0.05739962309598923,
0.06974483281373978,
-0.17919084429740906,
-0.39193195104599,
-0.33814626932144165,
0.674634575843811,
0.09590114653110504,
-0.19532939791679382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12572v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12572v2 | Mathador-LM: A Dynamic Benchmark for Mathematical Reasoning on Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T13:02:12 | 2024-06-19T12:28:10 | Eldar Kurtic, Amir Moeini, Dan Alistarh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7 | We introduce Mathador-LM, a new benchmark for evaluating the mathematical
reasoning on large language models (LLMs), combining ruleset interpretation,
planning, and problem-solving. This benchmark is inspired by the Mathador game,
where the objective is to reach a target number using basic arithmetic
operations on a given set of base numbers, following a simple set of rules. We
show that, across leading LLMs, we obtain stable average performance while
generating benchmark instances dynamically, following a target difficulty
level. Thus, our benchmark alleviates concerns about test-set leakage into
training data, an issue that often undermines popular benchmarks. Additionally,
we conduct a comprehensive evaluation of both open and closed-source
state-of-the-art LLMs on Mathador-LM. Our findings reveal that contemporary
models struggle with Mathador-LM, scoring significantly lower than average 3rd
graders. This stands in stark contrast to their strong performance on popular
mathematical reasoning benchmarks. | [
-0.17914432287216187,
-0.7130424976348877,
0.510840654373169,
0.5444877743721008,
-0.1598295271396637,
-0.022443648427724838,
-0.3570324182510376,
-0.3605634868144989,
-0.055230773985385895,
0.3270593583583832,
-0.6917489171028137,
-0.634553849697113,
-0.5131573677062988,
-0.15547695755958557,
-0.3105248808860779,
0.6431481838226318,
-0.37737923860549927,
0.2048783153295517,
-0.37540069222450256,
-0.2834477722644806,
-0.6203382015228271,
-0.33655163645744324,
-0.6515840291976929,
-0.5993417501449585,
0.5966002941131592,
0.08406566083431244,
0.9659442901611328,
0.9226678609848022,
0.7775431275367737,
0.30955439805984497,
-0.06558027863502502,
0.151969775557518,
-0.46424731612205505,
0.3745468258857727,
-0.07676084339618683,
-1.0254420042037964,
-0.4429962635040283,
0.10025142133235931,
0.6169735789299011,
0.7336961030960083,
-0.4807403087615967,
0.07300686091184616,
-0.5367648005485535,
0.7447998523712158,
-0.5880184769630432,
0.5215029716491699,
-0.6805904507637024,
0.4285072088241577,
-0.37027406692504883,
0.08760561794042587,
-0.3375049829483032,
-0.8333078026771545,
-0.017621934413909912,
-0.7206910252571106,
-0.3280061185359955,
-0.136137917637825,
0.48672711849212646,
0.48381155729293823,
-0.2367890477180481,
-0.47091710567474365,
-0.4915708005428314,
1.0605697631835938,
-0.5429022312164307,
0.375863254070282,
0.20297175645828247,
0.7763100862503052,
-0.33387741446495056,
-0.5149737000465393,
-0.40062370896339417,
-0.27871859073638916,
0.31637468934059143,
0.07761460542678833,
-0.48060142993927,
-0.3130630552768707,
0.5392934083938599,
0.25069618225097656,
-0.3366880714893341,
0.08421187847852707,
-0.16533498466014862,
0.14031647145748138,
0.5575441122055054,
0.36254367232322693,
0.09646361321210861,
0.41796085238456726,
-0.05961058288812637,
-0.21643035113811493,
-1.0349035263061523,
-0.007440448272973299,
0.36898529529571533,
-0.08599944412708282,
0.05785911902785301,
0.49578940868377686,
-0.02495167963206768,
0.5236961841583252,
-0.2956202030181885,
-0.11564614623785019,
0.2803928852081299,
0.2784625291824341,
-0.15473774075508118,
0.045984070748090744,
0.7793054580688477,
0.1746586412191391,
0.6002492904663086,
-0.10686133056879044,
-0.36277836561203003,
0.3032900094985962,
-0.10328713804483414,
-0.9100398421287537,
0.039630334824323654,
-0.09228920191526413,
-0.24996687471866608,
-0.5565686225891113,
-0.18945136666297913,
-0.7473236918449402,
-0.3989610970020294,
-0.27542534470558167,
0.48828306794166565,
-0.4795491695404053,
-0.07968927919864655,
0.3465914726257324,
0.09097535163164139,
0.34847259521484375,
0.7093574404716492,
-0.7608498930931091,
0.4650612473487854,
1.1093010902404785,
0.8217904567718506,
-0.16672377288341522,
-0.3788210451602936,
-0.8083207011222839,
-0.19402921199798584,
-0.6258712410926819,
0.70599764585495,
-0.5873869061470032,
-0.18022999167442322,
0.06862680613994598,
-0.38978099822998047,
0.019194593653082848,
-0.9752899408340454,
0.6165795922279358,
-0.5837492942810059,
0.03845665231347084,
-0.10753542929887772,
-0.4978899657726288,
-0.11126551032066345,
0.49570930004119873,
-0.7377100586891174,
1.2201988697052002,
-0.0726868286728859,
-0.27092212438583374,
0.16945324838161469,
-0.5219715237617493,
-0.41467592120170593,
0.006308382842689753,
-0.38452139496803284,
-0.27509379386901855,
0.28993016481399536,
0.00840511079877615,
0.062065254896879196,
-0.894042432308197,
0.349261999130249,
-0.4966663718223572,
-0.47842076420783997,
0.4624221920967102,
-0.5567750930786133,
0.6868531107902527,
0.2158975899219513,
-0.4134002923965454,
-0.14235590398311615,
-0.6588543653488159,
0.18084971606731415,
0.3449573814868927,
-0.20112134516239166,
-0.1915571093559265,
0.34436747431755066,
-0.7843536138534546,
0.18884830176830292,
0.45956704020500183,
-0.13473336398601532,
0.3223463296890259,
-0.1678340584039688,
0.13325950503349304,
0.9032368659973145,
-0.45553824305534363,
0.043143030256032944,
-0.6244640350341797,
0.6079345345497131,
-0.35767829418182373,
0.08974215388298035,
-0.3413073420524597,
-0.37434256076812744,
-0.7982155680656433,
-0.31806057691574097,
0.39550110697746277,
0.7169808149337769,
-0.5470232367515564,
0.18900710344314575,
-0.34562647342681885,
-0.8868393301963806,
-0.20846091210842133,
0.12381906807422638,
0.40717750787734985,
0.3234612047672272,
0.20327194035053253,
0.11260557919740677,
-0.1901324838399887,
-0.6350690722465515,
-0.5736434459686279,
0.03840322047472,
-0.05627370625734329,
0.31549951434135437,
0.5483111143112183,
-0.0064560603350400925,
0.5298030376434326,
-0.5962989330291748,
-0.46882644295692444,
-0.20595800876617432,
0.284595251083374,
0.7809151411056519,
0.21796776354312897,
0.6534937620162964,
-0.57888263463974,
-0.5357723832130432,
-0.0027744974941015244,
-1.1564276218414307,
-0.46775710582733154,
0.17664675414562225,
-0.17896170914173126,
-0.23484498262405396,
0.4980774521827698,
-0.6479191780090332,
0.11435161530971527,
0.5848759412765503,
-0.13562148809432983,
0.56847083568573,
-0.15214967727661133,
-0.057513173669576645,
-0.6157035231590271,
-0.07727706432342529,
0.031742438673973083,
-0.04019555822014809,
-0.4102029502391815,
0.32032838463783264,
0.10718585550785065,
-0.15753673017024994,
-0.5844363570213318,
0.46888065338134766,
-0.283998966217041,
-0.1307675689458847,
-0.062451496720314026,
0.03138672932982445,
-0.21118603646755219,
0.37540769577026367,
-0.08343816548585892,
0.7740417122840881,
0.6578998565673828,
-0.3386271893978119,
0.8301249146461487,
-0.20689116418361664,
-0.6036023497581482,
0.7902684211730957,
-0.9738889932632446,
0.05437012389302254,
0.005168127361685038,
0.1720142513513565,
-0.47269129753112793,
0.11560505628585815,
-0.22561092674732208,
-0.27329349517822266,
0.02543923258781433,
-0.19734150171279907,
-0.756849467754364,
-0.09302213788032532,
-0.3858533799648285,
0.5628853440284729,
0.7039804458618164,
-0.5456421971321106,
0.7171759009361267,
0.3890409469604492,
-0.047863446176052094,
-0.4583324193954468,
-0.474396675825119,
-0.061680085957050323,
-0.4248809814453125,
-0.8371265530586243,
0.20247697830200195,
-0.15888163447380066,
-0.7178927063941956,
-0.08711636066436768,
-0.23129381239414215,
-0.08804505318403244,
0.19690647721290588,
0.04006795212626457,
0.2581932246685028,
-0.4257298707962036,
0.0767817273736,
-0.08428981155157089,
-0.265316367149353,
0.4063073992729187,
-0.09249313175678253,
0.7356111407279968,
-0.2872496545314789,
-0.43423959612846375,
-0.11352049559354782,
0.08752570301294327,
0.6720458269119263,
-0.36264392733573914,
0.5945535898208618,
-0.0159994475543499,
-0.6688222289085388,
-0.38267019391059875,
-0.41809242963790894,
0.2501266598701477,
-0.5043898820877075,
0.27079054713249207,
-0.6552234888076782,
-0.45001715421676636,
0.5665046572685242,
-0.46973535418510437,
0.15210294723510742,
0.3630661368370056,
0.6000268459320068,
-0.010873747989535332,
1.1383168697357178,
0.0901910588145256,
-0.008552564308047295,
0.30293866991996765,
-0.19192709028720856,
-0.1555076539516449,
-0.3002179265022278,
-0.21718715131282806,
-0.6178911328315735,
-0.3824266791343689,
-0.30674001574516296,
-0.7161468267440796,
0.39657753705978394,
0.07012519985437393,
-0.2943633794784546,
0.1572893261909485,
0.04011739417910576,
0.900446891784668,
0.4341268837451935,
-0.13862137496471405,
0.373172402381897,
-0.15269242227077484,
-0.41925111413002014,
-0.46389317512512207,
-0.3424092233181,
-0.2849966585636139,
0.9739888310432434,
0.34420785307884216,
1.1335397958755493,
0.5135259032249451,
0.5217639207839966,
0.3712165653705597,
0.4910563826560974,
-0.8793195486068726,
0.7636195421218872,
-0.21824179589748383,
-0.4314688444137573,
-0.14643888175487518,
-0.8469274044036865,
-0.995202362537384,
0.6353114247322083,
-0.11358501017093658,
-0.5335270166397095,
-0.27377545833587646,
-0.044470712542533875,
-0.03941376134753227,
0.2210966944694519,
-0.21925270557403564,
0.8644019961357117,
-0.6406610012054443,
-0.539417564868927,
-0.3767434060573578,
-0.09338406473398209,
0.49861273169517517,
-0.3483641743659973,
0.3966675400733948,
-0.5734409093856812,
-0.16220328211784363,
0.6926025748252869,
-0.7222504019737244,
0.42835095524787903,
-0.08706708997488022,
-0.3972351551055908,
0.04455478489398956,
0.5447628498077393,
0.6837764382362366,
-0.0025745888706296682,
-0.3259564936161041,
0.3486425280570984,
-0.15266811847686768,
-0.20991338789463043,
-0.8454495072364807,
0.8267656564712524,
-0.8127150535583496,
-0.5446561574935913,
-0.775490939617157,
-0.6806634664535522,
-0.3350027799606323,
0.4550882875919342,
-0.23203647136688232,
0.537257730960846,
-0.07577022165060043,
0.40491601824760437,
1.0032092332839966,
-0.2011335790157318,
0.13711747527122498,
0.6258897185325623,
-0.3025517463684082,
-0.6215792298316956,
0.7579775452613831,
0.10365010052919388,
0.20424026250839233,
0.5670919418334961,
0.4828879237174988,
-0.3770967423915863,
-0.42728012800216675,
-0.4266469478607178,
0.3793453574180603,
-0.7703644633293152,
-0.20950569212436676,
-0.004421501886099577,
-0.1953287422657013,
0.20632213354110718,
-0.06492365151643753,
-0.6762206554412842,
-0.39794960618019104,
0.2363305389881134,
0.27436983585357666,
0.08935501426458359,
0.5643420219421387,
0.06714875251054764,
0.13964906334877014,
-0.5452362895011902,
0.33596381545066833,
0.36905714869499207,
0.45959973335266113,
-0.04315076768398285,
-0.5008090734481812,
-0.008760363794863224,
0.014229820109903812,
-0.2755153477191925,
-0.6209611296653748,
0.23828072845935822,
0.0351729579269886,
0.7182755470275879,
0.378154993057251,
-0.04512874782085419,
0.6720306277275085,
-0.7719677090644836,
0.18669730424880981,
0.32338041067123413,
-0.9876003861427307,
0.4811159670352936,
-0.564915657043457,
0.30602291226387024,
0.4128025770187378,
0.3295608162879944,
-0.6181761026382446,
-0.1366240233182907,
-0.3155953884124756,
-0.39980772137641907,
0.6419501900672913,
0.19912035763263702,
-0.041981253772974014,
0.20832030475139618,
-0.045180194079875946,
0.0189956147223711,
0.36564895510673523,
-0.7011553645133972,
-0.28021177649497986,
0.14826205372810364,
-0.3776019811630249,
0.1222056895494461,
-0.0055351112969219685,
-0.21173980832099915,
-0.2145577371120453,
0.427789568901062,
-0.1058151125907898,
0.12690390646457672,
-0.4763256311416626,
-0.3107788860797882,
-0.21478475630283356,
-0.08816126734018326,
0.6906266212463379,
0.7653358578681946,
-0.17618034780025482,
0.287801057100296,
0.318759560585022,
-0.3972699046134949,
0.13582555949687958,
0.4060523808002472,
-0.10954121500253677,
-0.09015757590532303,
0.5161608457565308,
0.5998122096061707,
0.5370626449584961,
-1.0222880840301514,
0.58745276927948,
-0.20912937819957733,
-0.43783968687057495,
-0.5613829493522644,
0.3006168305873871,
-0.0765085369348526,
0.29367464780807495,
0.46572962403297424,
-0.1303960233926773,
-0.3785054087638855,
-0.6119885444641113,
-0.006565634626895189,
0.39431530237197876,
-0.1410692036151886,
-0.22624628245830536,
0.7236095666885376,
-0.012639871798455715,
-0.38895800709724426,
0.383068323135376,
-0.06405101716518402,
-0.558893620967865,
0.7471426725387573,
0.5208836793899536,
0.4715909957885742,
-0.07383895665407181,
-0.017494145780801773,
0.2420843243598938,
0.34492912888526917,
-0.33177506923675537,
0.4125846028327942,
-0.06784908473491669,
-0.7284206748008728,
-0.5386249423027039,
-0.42053651809692383,
-0.7234922647476196,
0.10298291593790054,
-0.5202212333679199,
0.48969021439552307,
-0.6183959245681763,
0.2091647833585739,
-0.08868137001991272,
0.1408107429742813,
-0.41712188720703125,
0.004002496134489775,
0.13955287635326385,
1.234744906425476,
-0.5067874789237976,
0.6776484251022339,
0.5225591063499451,
-0.11518127471208572,
-0.5354548692703247,
-0.33829063177108765,
0.14691659808158875,
-1.2488292455673218,
0.7234750390052795,
0.25889360904693604,
-0.14193609356880188,
-0.19170065224170685,
-0.341584712266922,
-0.8599529266357422,
1.1523258686065674,
0.6561404466629028,
-0.5658218860626221,
0.10152124613523483,
0.5383269190788269,
0.5361102819442749,
-0.13401493430137634,
0.3848422169685364,
0.6162747740745544,
0.5246526598930359,
0.4219872057437897,
-0.8112857341766357,
-0.06419060379266739,
-0.4554048478603363,
-0.272976815700531,
0.6504509449005127,
-0.9215064644813538,
1.0228813886642456,
-0.03713299334049225,
0.06678503751754761,
0.17790192365646362,
0.575023889541626,
0.6793075203895569,
0.30422690510749817,
0.5982200503349304,
0.9940773844718933,
0.7676487565040588,
-0.5210472941398621,
0.7934378981590271,
-0.07199502736330032,
0.2466224879026413,
0.912380576133728,
-0.5667497515678406,
0.749251127243042,
0.0970645397901535,
-0.45106375217437744,
0.42450565099716187,
0.2936186194419861,
-0.07469835132360458,
0.4591638147830963,
0.6868475079536438,
-0.35889551043510437,
-0.29258447885513306,
0.0817098394036293,
-0.49220898747444153,
0.4828668534755707,
0.41604918241500854,
-0.03898293897509575,
-0.5443581342697144,
-0.623130202293396,
0.5183574557304382,
0.16629570722579956,
-0.4632927179336548,
0.38783517479896545,
0.11488166451454163,
-0.863895058631897,
0.6425846219062805,
0.06241815537214279,
0.4571002125740051,
-0.8123098015785217,
-0.11986757814884186,
-0.6132969260215759,
0.640364408493042,
0.10707711428403854,
-0.7326458692550659,
0.039593663066625595,
0.23763428628444672,
0.16692298650741577,
-0.2514279782772064,
0.49650904536247253,
-0.3200167417526245,
-0.6194236874580383,
0.11008573323488235,
0.5067923069000244,
0.13889771699905396,
0.03442845121026039,
-0.7454469203948975,
0.42844584584236145,
-0.33453047275543213,
0.054881855845451355,
0.3253712058067322,
0.9251731634140015,
-0.17530572414398193,
0.885728657245636,
0.8703016638755798,
0.21258845925331116,
0.2659378945827484,
0.20337918400764465,
0.6649142503738403,
-0.7689096331596375,
-0.3668762743473053,
-1.0796934366226196,
-0.062379270792007446,
-0.03434675559401512,
-0.3240266442298889,
0.7867304682731628,
0.6875619292259216,
0.6626889109611511,
0.1618838757276535,
0.47910594940185547,
0.2615627944469452,
0.2102641761302948,
-0.5951193571090698,
0.47624143958091736,
-0.5203543901443481,
0.43980422616004944,
-0.16497443616390228,
-1.0497398376464844,
-0.525407075881958,
0.8545520901679993,
-0.41534650325775146,
-0.01781317964196205,
0.6811118721961975,
0.45698368549346924,
-0.0658082440495491,
0.009004360996186733,
0.41489288210868835,
0.0669201910495758,
0.6464205980300903,
1.0003957748413086,
1.3369845151901245,
-0.25417786836624146,
0.6807675361633301,
-0.21461205184459686,
-0.4150357246398926,
-0.06322120875120163,
-1.1680701971054077,
-0.942545473575592,
0.17847095429897308,
-0.12735480070114136,
-0.17249900102615356,
-0.07445415109395981,
0.839705228805542,
0.33055251836776733,
-0.433714896440506,
-0.5358906984329224,
-0.18096892535686493,
0.22924086451530457,
-0.267562597990036,
-0.18606515228748322,
0.11889947205781937,
-0.29809173941612244,
-0.8855807185173035,
0.28810039162635803,
0.22785045206546783,
-0.16718800365924835,
-0.3230758309364319,
-0.14932793378829956,
0.19517387449741364,
0.2228393256664276,
0.4491023123264313,
0.26269054412841797,
-0.286721408367157,
0.18545299768447876,
0.17442922294139862,
0.0474923700094223,
-0.029044343158602715,
0.89371657371521,
-0.6956741809844971,
0.18294371664524078,
0.31619176268577576,
0.8032069206237793,
0.5375221967697144,
-0.44359344244003296,
0.6559650301933289,
-0.22297419607639313,
0.2123158723115921,
0.22628362476825714,
0.6186410784721375,
-0.032773204147815704,
0.3039236068725586,
0.7828503847122192,
0.2935032248497009,
-0.22802472114562988,
-1.0674972534179688,
0.11597180366516113,
-0.6279552578926086,
0.1227981373667717,
1.0640954971313477,
-0.17488925158977509,
-0.2768200635910034,
0.4347265660762787,
0.11060318350791931,
-0.2888122797012329,
-0.27463626861572266,
0.6957753896713257,
0.6951325535774231,
0.08022194355726242,
-0.05650337412953377,
-0.5092352032661438,
0.13441427052021027,
0.4667917788028717,
-1.0449341535568237,
-0.026533013209700584,
0.46941351890563965,
0.057021960616111755,
-0.047631893306970596,
0.27021023631095886,
-0.35939306020736694,
0.5606021881103516,
-0.036559492349624634,
-0.20259065926074982,
-0.15070845186710358,
-0.3003997504711151,
-0.06748862564563751,
0.14308501780033112,
0.06338702142238617,
0.08883937448263168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15490v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15490v1 | Causal Discovery Inspired Unsupervised Domain Adaptation for Emotion-Cause Pair Extraction | 2024-06-18T13:01:30 | 2024-06-18T13:01:30 | Yuncheng Hua, Yujin Huang, Shuo Huang, Tao Feng, Lizhen Qu, Chris Bain, Richard Bassed, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.4 | This paper tackles the task of emotion-cause pair extraction in the
unsupervised domain adaptation setting. The problem is challenging as the
distributions of the events causing emotions in target domains are dramatically
different than those in source domains, despite the distributions of emotional
expressions between domains are overlapped. Inspired by causal discovery, we
propose a novel deep latent model in the variational autoencoder (VAE)
framework, which not only captures the underlying latent structures of data but
also utilizes the easily transferable knowledge of emotions as the bridge to
link the distributions of events in different domains. To facilitate knowledge
transfer across domains, we also propose a novel variational posterior
regularization technique to disentangle the latent representations of emotions
from those of events in order to mitigate the damage caused by the spurious
correlations related to the events in source domains. Through extensive
experiments, we demonstrate that our model outperforms the strongest baseline
by approximately 11.05% on a Chinese benchmark and 2.45% on a English benchmark
in terms of weighted-average F1 score. The source code will be publicly
available upon acceptance. | [
-0.2897672653198242,
-0.49825868010520935,
0.47099003195762634,
0.35686051845550537,
-0.23874472081661224,
-0.1555335819721222,
-0.06054260954260826,
-0.34677261114120483,
0.0715813860297203,
0.11611644923686981,
-0.7026399374008179,
-0.37403517961502075,
-0.52902752161026,
-0.23202498257160187,
-0.1338222175836563,
0.8962655663490295,
-0.1693478375673294,
-0.04375077411532402,
-0.09645693749189377,
-0.09596993029117584,
-0.3627192974090576,
-0.5403364896774292,
-0.5537778735160828,
-0.28320392966270447,
0.563906729221344,
0.1218835636973381,
0.11460902541875839,
-0.005696275271475315,
0.5955263376235962,
0.12381884455680847,
0.2619749903678894,
0.1482262909412384,
-0.820300817489624,
-0.10065306723117828,
-0.3707420825958252,
-0.2874021530151367,
-0.5156930088996887,
-0.04467637464404106,
0.22374719381332397,
0.5259261727333069,
-0.2366325557231903,
-0.19652840495109558,
0.11448705196380615,
0.9086886644363403,
-0.8316113352775574,
0.16119492053985596,
-0.5332210659980774,
0.1617293357849121,
-0.06867045909166336,
-0.4494182765483856,
-0.3410605490207672,
0.036675333976745605,
0.17284321784973145,
-0.7709272503852844,
0.5511199831962585,
-0.05713904649019241,
0.7282540798187256,
0.44363605976104736,
-0.8210192322731018,
0.12333314120769501,
-0.6648507714271545,
0.4146277904510498,
-0.6111780405044556,
0.3255634009838104,
0.06686635315418243,
-0.06850875169038773,
-0.36017102003097534,
-0.521080732345581,
-0.6356496214866638,
0.18257157504558563,
-0.01677321270108223,
0.3373427093029022,
-0.6229958534240723,
-0.16572710871696472,
0.14270976185798645,
0.45380041003227234,
-0.839991569519043,
0.08591220527887344,
0.020543349906802177,
0.07513116300106049,
0.8428406715393066,
0.19571973383426666,
0.4254697859287262,
-0.21770532429218292,
-0.4615842401981354,
-0.11971122026443481,
-0.8725335001945496,
0.12112879753112793,
0.22016820311546326,
0.01509891264140606,
-0.4296199381351471,
0.08872342109680176,
0.04567226395010948,
0.3005599081516266,
0.2875445485115051,
0.5131721496582031,
0.20630459487438202,
0.05317939072847366,
-0.3763120174407959,
-0.19217239320278168,
0.8477510213851929,
0.49799323081970215,
0.04239940270781517,
-0.16134244203567505,
0.01654163934290409,
0.09400132298469543,
0.254615843296051,
-0.8991382122039795,
-0.5945884585380554,
0.02477729693055153,
-0.6226165294647217,
-0.22972039878368378,
0.21917787194252014,
-1.1793307065963745,
-0.7650336027145386,
-0.4545389711856842,
0.5386192202568054,
-0.17771726846694946,
-0.6152008175849915,
0.3188203275203705,
-0.09425319731235504,
0.30945464968681335,
0.3840794861316681,
-0.6782268285751343,
0.4331228733062744,
0.45889997482299805,
0.6032019853591919,
-0.5875571370124817,
-0.06612996757030487,
-0.3958286941051483,
-0.09035670757293701,
-0.3302234411239624,
0.6522029042243958,
-0.25904029607772827,
-0.48485174775123596,
0.001989225624129176,
0.28419244289398193,
-0.17695876955986023,
-0.34131401777267456,
0.5251343250274658,
-0.7168808579444885,
0.2336246818304062,
-0.36347290873527527,
-0.594343900680542,
-0.4026522636413574,
-0.2859356701374054,
-0.6850513219833374,
0.8454204201698303,
0.2275087833404541,
-0.7438221573829651,
0.3119457960128784,
-0.5159229636192322,
-0.5943947434425354,
-0.17756615579128265,
-0.037358205765485764,
-0.36212611198425293,
0.5090876817703247,
0.3239571750164032,
0.5687249898910522,
-0.7502493262290955,
0.46482378244400024,
-0.5163217782974243,
-0.09875267744064331,
0.03627128526568413,
-0.32178181409835815,
0.7088798880577087,
-0.03762291371822357,
-0.7270200848579407,
0.07039646059274673,
-0.8266530632972717,
-0.7125558257102966,
0.4696463942527771,
0.34127914905548096,
-0.8186556100845337,
0.06011219322681427,
0.07155413180589676,
0.46935272216796875,
-0.02853548526763916,
-0.2874152362346649,
0.20174723863601685,
-0.3323770761489868,
-0.06813175231218338,
0.9870584607124329,
0.5275882482528687,
0.5272358655929565,
0.037242282181978226,
0.3444919288158417,
0.48348143696784973,
0.1383596658706665,
0.1623307764530182,
-0.27026718854904175,
-0.7765225172042847,
-0.032916583120822906,
-0.020098300650715828,
0.41867882013320923,
-0.5651742815971375,
0.4853927493095398,
0.07651261985301971,
-0.3761700987815857,
-0.3998667597770691,
0.02769400365650654,
0.2654183804988861,
0.7419862747192383,
0.39104318618774414,
-0.46829867362976074,
-0.3809136152267456,
-0.5983682870864868,
-0.17989714443683624,
0.122566357254982,
0.005613111890852451,
0.5938746929168701,
0.5217380523681641,
-0.3784351050853729,
0.6928494572639465,
-0.8839164972305298,
-0.1827913075685501,
0.49699386954307556,
0.6131352186203003,
0.12918686866760254,
0.6459736824035645,
0.8811883926391602,
-1.0156575441360474,
-0.419131875038147,
-0.009631793946027756,
-1.0121040344238281,
-0.16899645328521729,
-0.242508664727211,
-0.31212055683135986,
-0.07536430656909943,
0.4320096969604492,
-0.2788199782371521,
0.5976329445838928,
0.34865161776542664,
-0.5293049216270447,
0.4449825584888458,
-0.1684039682149887,
0.4318002462387085,
-1.0973001718521118,
0.11562313139438629,
0.200718954205513,
0.07315067201852798,
-0.4094989001750946,
-0.2907188832759857,
0.06519094109535217,
-0.06461107730865479,
-0.2975917160511017,
0.6029217839241028,
-0.44128820300102234,
0.15684519708156586,
-0.2431386560201645,
0.00828852504491806,
0.0880027487874031,
0.6387069225311279,
0.0225918460637331,
0.40741562843322754,
0.8483036756515503,
-0.601054847240448,
0.4660341739654541,
0.32644081115722656,
0.02937815710902214,
0.8188589215278625,
-0.4875291585922241,
0.1110466793179512,
-0.20091529190540314,
0.044209759682416916,
-0.9627000093460083,
-0.23337718844413757,
0.1474854052066803,
-0.4909156858921051,
0.5093071460723877,
-0.11164605617523193,
-0.12449268996715546,
-0.12691493332386017,
-0.14640218019485474,
0.4111618995666504,
0.6592913866043091,
-1.0840591192245483,
0.6656078100204468,
0.2496436983346939,
-0.22650839388370514,
-0.28174951672554016,
-0.3983447849750519,
0.03568485751748085,
-0.3921377658843994,
-0.5984401702880859,
0.586064875125885,
-0.33605462312698364,
0.020065858960151672,
0.25988003611564636,
-0.08938422799110413,
-0.18803198635578156,
0.19985216856002808,
0.38704103231430054,
0.11102153360843658,
-0.43498557806015015,
0.2606355845928192,
0.24059900641441345,
-0.04972585290670395,
0.3646470904350281,
-0.14498388767242432,
0.04420821741223335,
0.1799982339143753,
-0.232509583234787,
-0.47789621353149414,
0.6873350143432617,
0.4787166118621826,
-0.2942274510860443,
0.6546682715415955,
0.7969713807106018,
-0.7061843276023865,
-0.4228314161300659,
-0.3516687750816345,
-0.39372825622558594,
-0.40073511004447937,
0.2892826497554779,
-0.31070834398269653,
-0.8733279705047607,
0.6383597254753113,
-0.5785537362098694,
-0.7001248002052307,
0.7692275643348694,
0.5460526347160339,
0.04295115917921066,
0.9627867937088013,
0.9134204983711243,
-0.38425809144973755,
0.5322798490524292,
-0.10826646536588669,
0.309967577457428,
-0.870116114616394,
-0.2416663020849228,
-0.1146690621972084,
0.062087152153253555,
-0.6435431838035583,
-0.4646870493888855,
0.32891592383384705,
0.30774545669555664,
-0.2639232575893402,
0.0023548626340925694,
-0.24173633754253387,
0.1481546312570572,
0.4232873022556305,
0.23637133836746216,
-0.09558501094579697,
-0.05426402390003204,
0.2170805186033249,
-0.29313692450523376,
-0.5907766819000244,
0.16310803592205048,
0.9385735988616943,
0.019989129155874252,
0.5956825613975525,
0.3299238383769989,
0.5557610988616943,
0.6677287817001343,
0.21982158720493317,
-0.4573671519756317,
0.07119390368461609,
-0.2894251048564911,
-0.21823230385780334,
-0.06754758208990097,
-0.45781195163726807,
-0.9934654831886292,
-0.0019518494373187423,
-0.31724637746810913,
-0.803247332572937,
0.8624887466430664,
-0.07321543991565704,
-0.09787572920322418,
0.0724741593003273,
-0.5574937462806702,
1.1296191215515137,
-0.07468786835670471,
-0.577802836894989,
-0.24918414652347565,
-0.7294074892997742,
0.6569452285766602,
-0.34320467710494995,
0.03771035373210907,
0.06204618886113167,
0.5031156539916992,
0.8175871968269348,
-0.32547199726104736,
1.0907933712005615,
-0.3166746497154236,
-0.015561874955892563,
0.1895436942577362,
0.21599827706813812,
0.5987797975540161,
0.1102006658911705,
0.15322759747505188,
0.06984380632638931,
-0.5614221692085266,
-0.397154837846756,
-0.9998304843902588,
0.7879514694213867,
-0.9634820222854614,
-0.5080768465995789,
-0.19015520811080933,
-0.28704819083213806,
-0.22755464911460876,
0.027534348890185356,
0.17112983763217926,
0.1805449277162552,
-0.47017621994018555,
0.04883815348148346,
0.8194218873977661,
-0.24805764853954315,
0.4499046504497528,
0.8594020009040833,
0.28016671538352966,
-0.348074734210968,
1.0432759523391724,
-0.5452786684036255,
-0.15639375150203705,
0.5537915825843811,
0.3052506744861603,
-0.14466311037540436,
-0.20563766360282898,
-0.08809181302785873,
0.23085348308086395,
-0.6519026160240173,
-0.3469187617301941,
-0.5135939717292786,
0.0742209404706955,
-0.6809943318367004,
-0.23611509799957275,
-0.4367853105068207,
-0.052443891763687134,
-0.7222676873207092,
-0.1500767171382904,
0.44134244322776794,
0.6479073166847229,
-0.4333677291870117,
0.2619321644306183,
-0.6316125392913818,
0.3850734531879425,
0.47864410281181335,
0.18092723190784454,
0.06207345798611641,
-0.7073413133621216,
-0.12631262838840485,
-0.3673204481601715,
-0.21836645901203156,
-1.1386018991470337,
0.6982854604721069,
0.13073866069316864,
0.4659838378429413,
0.5815479159355164,
0.45363375544548035,
0.4744327664375305,
-0.337213933467865,
0.732558012008667,
0.3499845266342163,
-1.2128520011901855,
0.6902892589569092,
-0.3847990036010742,
-0.4039836823940277,
-0.05260351672768593,
0.7052198648452759,
-0.4260936677455902,
0.18483251333236694,
-0.8789655566215515,
-0.9830335974693298,
0.5714644193649292,
0.19616225361824036,
-0.19814622402191162,
0.12159764021635056,
0.6573290824890137,
0.06380972266197205,
-0.03357068449258804,
-0.6375275254249573,
-0.4520118534564972,
-0.21469679474830627,
-0.3134240508079529,
-0.32091420888900757,
-0.4018547236919403,
-0.14796330034732819,
-0.1399185210466385,
0.6166800260543823,
-0.11558391153812408,
0.49662160873413086,
0.48538273572921753,
-0.27651873230934143,
-0.42605698108673096,
-0.14570167660713196,
0.5630819201469421,
0.03582947701215744,
-0.32805323600769043,
0.1819622665643692,
-0.06506998836994171,
-0.08565457910299301,
0.2369447946548462,
0.5338104963302612,
0.37201663851737976,
-0.2372192144393921,
0.48423266410827637,
1.099031686782837,
0.18887218832969666,
-0.33052510023117065,
1.1038109064102173,
-0.17581245303153992,
0.06893052905797958,
-0.020169364288449287,
-0.19795963168144226,
-0.10321912169456482,
0.534740686416626,
0.3972109854221344,
0.022915970534086227,
0.560645341873169,
-0.21443502604961395,
0.5545544624328613,
0.16055327653884888,
-0.5072700381278992,
-0.7503955364227295,
0.8073933124542236,
0.3585852384567261,
-0.06283949315547943,
0.35982245206832886,
-0.3123081624507904,
-0.6077409386634827,
0.7561556696891785,
0.46207407116889954,
1.1701143980026245,
-0.643176794052124,
0.04749451205134392,
0.3297887146472931,
0.08045298606157303,
0.11495859175920486,
0.19693133234977722,
0.04073340445756912,
-0.7983189821243286,
-0.34671324491500854,
-0.23294968903064728,
-0.22660256922245026,
0.13404914736747742,
-0.9450654983520508,
0.05889321118593216,
0.0008676032884977758,
0.24334658682346344,
-0.17838039994239807,
-0.10524667054414749,
-0.8082588315010071,
0.5539008975028992,
0.2121751308441162,
0.4034302830696106,
-1.3783338069915771,
0.6584832072257996,
0.5333321690559387,
-0.474225252866745,
-0.7256838083267212,
0.025842813774943352,
0.20921002328395844,
-0.5484728217124939,
0.8101752996444702,
-0.23232385516166687,
0.14565713703632355,
0.052935004234313965,
-0.4336492121219635,
-0.6431294679641724,
1.018846035003662,
0.26964297890663147,
-0.5602861046791077,
0.33942779898643494,
-0.21446840465068817,
0.6065895557403564,
-0.5076236128807068,
-0.03195066750049591,
0.27036622166633606,
0.08091533184051514,
-0.024118421599268913,
-0.4271019697189331,
0.4679991900920868,
-0.4380365312099457,
-0.17376896739006042,
0.0651603490114212,
-0.6274961233139038,
0.7638263702392578,
-0.17771916091442108,
-0.01226063258945942,
-0.5709072947502136,
0.8171721696853638,
-0.018106695264577866,
0.5772952437400818,
0.34408828616142273,
0.3921315371990204,
0.8664042353630066,
0.13759027421474457,
0.9589523077011108,
-0.2600271999835968,
0.5305064916610718,
1.1354453563690186,
-0.4587135910987854,
0.6341784596443176,
0.3898966610431671,
-0.1449008584022522,
0.6104657649993896,
0.8644034266471863,
0.1262555867433548,
0.7635776996612549,
0.17539550364017487,
-0.3735886514186859,
-0.2242797464132309,
-0.14523670077323914,
-0.3556492328643799,
0.29185596108436584,
0.3371290862560272,
-0.31752529740333557,
-0.062390170991420746,
0.055070146918296814,
-0.10275658965110779,
-0.1724742203950882,
-0.167812779545784,
0.710058331489563,
0.19714953005313873,
-0.3331991136074066,
0.40941953659057617,
-0.30844762921333313,
0.3877772390842438,
-0.1676652878522873,
-0.14914703369140625,
-0.5334088802337646,
0.19617560505867004,
-0.15574578940868378,
-0.28722473978996277,
0.11904134601354599,
-0.11801604926586151,
-0.5332912802696228,
0.09628614038228989,
0.8702746629714966,
-0.46701833605766296,
-0.17934256792068481,
0.7565120458602905,
0.5506946444511414,
-0.08798345923423767,
-0.4825844466686249,
-0.611068606376648,
-0.1517534703016281,
-0.09338324517011642,
-0.5630320310592651,
0.417307049036026,
0.9617473483085632,
-0.1021779328584671,
0.09080825746059418,
0.7256656885147095,
-0.09817207604646683,
-0.08215074986219406,
0.22529064118862152,
1.038564682006836,
-0.8401241898536682,
-0.34728601574897766,
-0.7179006934165955,
0.7990343570709229,
-0.14359405636787415,
-0.23795241117477417,
0.3558405637741089,
0.25225830078125,
0.48956695199012756,
-0.4015633165836334,
0.7376673221588135,
0.09645509719848633,
0.07104543596506119,
-0.40782907605171204,
0.5602981448173523,
-0.9352327585220337,
-0.04832148924469948,
-0.665932297706604,
-0.5560016632080078,
-0.4004225432872772,
0.4471653699874878,
-0.16796855628490448,
-0.14337559044361115,
0.8069245219230652,
0.7109284996986389,
-0.035348836332559586,
-0.16572661697864532,
0.3877370357513428,
0.40256834030151367,
0.5011433959007263,
1.0439465045928955,
0.5542054176330566,
-0.6801530718803406,
0.0011917318915948272,
-0.1472206562757492,
-0.5910990238189697,
-0.4433879256248474,
-1.2141233682632446,
-0.8167282938957214,
-0.9468579888343811,
-0.8373360633850098,
-0.22057588398456573,
0.12584726512432098,
0.5379461050033569,
0.7051090598106384,
-0.7842246890068054,
0.18424835801124573,
-0.46101218461990356,
0.1551111936569214,
-0.13979092240333557,
-0.3347592353820801,
0.8172808289527893,
-0.19619224965572357,
-0.4166961908340454,
0.43630364537239075,
0.39142248034477234,
0.13694143295288086,
0.22634020447731018,
-0.09801235049962997,
-0.09173847734928131,
0.11964280158281326,
0.572884202003479,
0.3420027196407318,
-0.42547982931137085,
-0.20256704092025757,
-0.16524380445480347,
-0.0493207648396492,
-0.04466813802719116,
1.0188963413238525,
-0.5067729949951172,
0.4982755780220032,
0.494231253862381,
0.7803521752357483,
0.6646385788917542,
-0.1956334114074707,
0.7608002424240112,
-0.7944009304046631,
0.24305343627929688,
-0.018973590806126595,
0.5709369778633118,
0.34983402490615845,
-0.7096993923187256,
0.5981274247169495,
0.8455284833908081,
-0.5970875024795532,
-0.6364141702651978,
0.17286749184131622,
-1.3068870306015015,
-0.30910369753837585,
1.0818407535552979,
-0.44581642746925354,
-0.18213523924350739,
0.21628731489181519,
-0.07747770100831985,
0.586265504360199,
-0.2598145008087158,
0.9916678071022034,
0.37842363119125366,
-0.2983451187610626,
-0.19212916493415833,
-0.059501662850379944,
0.6034924387931824,
0.48753103613853455,
-0.92219477891922,
0.1673489212989807,
0.4476412236690521,
0.19809316098690033,
-0.18222379684448242,
0.4203905463218689,
0.07710515707731247,
0.4381983280181885,
0.055209748446941376,
0.552683413028717,
0.2722683250904083,
-0.22202226519584656,
-0.6527575254440308,
-0.015091150999069214,
-0.23474548757076263,
-0.024424046277999878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12570v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12570v1 | Applying Ensemble Methods to Model-Agnostic Machine-Generated Text Detection | 2024-06-18T12:58:01 | 2024-06-18T12:58:01 | Ivan Ong, Boon King Quek | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we study the problem of detecting machine-generated text when
the large language model (LLM) it is possibly derived from is unknown. We do so
by apply ensembling methods to the outputs from DetectGPT classifiers (Mitchell
et al. 2023), a zero-shot model for machine-generated text detection which is
highly accurate when the generative (or base) language model is the same as the
discriminative (or scoring) language model. We find that simple summary
statistics of DetectGPT sub-model outputs yield an AUROC of 0.73 (relative to
0.61) while retaining its zero-shot nature, and that supervised learning
methods sharply boost the accuracy to an AUROC of 0.94 but require a training
dataset. This suggests the possibility of further generalisation to create a
highly-accurate, model-agnostic machine-generated text detector. | [
-0.18791675567626953,
-0.9281964302062988,
0.7762901186943054,
-0.24086406826972961,
-0.13483217358589172,
0.07325480878353119,
-0.1265823245048523,
-0.686710774898529,
0.07242442667484283,
0.4257752299308777,
-0.331672340631485,
-0.5142609477043152,
-0.7342330813407898,
0.25101518630981445,
-0.8224565982818604,
0.8865613341331482,
-0.09668951481580734,
-0.44538652896881104,
0.12869872152805328,
0.006979393772780895,
0.01632598042488098,
-0.5725454092025757,
-0.6942919492721558,
-0.24271006882190704,
0.22536952793598175,
0.21056106686592102,
0.19859722256660461,
0.7115210890769958,
0.23346847295761108,
0.24358348548412323,
0.12371928244829178,
0.26160451769828796,
-0.15483659505844116,
0.32068589329719543,
0.08512812852859497,
-0.49955931305885315,
-0.2113819271326065,
0.10098478943109512,
0.7261950969696045,
0.15293259918689728,
-0.08434315025806427,
-0.004796262364834547,
0.04537130519747734,
0.3578554391860962,
-0.8690542578697205,
-0.03723698481917381,
-1.0705801248550415,
0.07239259779453278,
-0.2519964277744293,
-0.32856303453445435,
-0.9124568104743958,
0.11388250440359116,
-0.2869493067264557,
-0.34874868392944336,
0.6599363088607788,
0.03712211176753044,
0.670417845249176,
0.17905327677726746,
-0.37892207503318787,
-0.5716165900230408,
-0.7701231837272644,
0.9799371957778931,
-0.7217450737953186,
0.1195429265499115,
0.37212303280830383,
0.27465254068374634,
-0.01338573545217514,
-0.38987988233566284,
-0.7506929039955139,
-0.14145465195178986,
0.09741637855768204,
0.41077888011932373,
-0.5626503825187683,
-0.008093415759503841,
0.1557069569826126,
0.3836286962032318,
-0.7793881297111511,
0.4256671369075775,
-0.075230173766613,
-0.3116771876811981,
0.746059775352478,
-0.08097036182880402,
0.4093952178955078,
0.05091020092368126,
-0.2554019093513489,
-0.026033544912934303,
-0.7215821743011475,
-0.28999754786491394,
0.7705678939819336,
0.30420708656311035,
-0.047904983162879944,
0.6597698330879211,
-0.2500971853733063,
0.9266660809516907,
0.11505551636219025,
0.14091569185256958,
0.07234104722738266,
-0.049888838082551956,
-0.31103065609931946,
0.4123289883136749,
1.120375633239746,
-0.039045557379722595,
0.5409114360809326,
-0.23796196281909943,
-0.5262907147407532,
0.5762107968330383,
0.14002424478530884,
-0.6376391053199768,
-0.45162177085876465,
0.232603520154953,
-0.3083582818508148,
-0.8999218940734863,
0.02712223492562771,
-0.25565510988235474,
-0.11748815327882767,
0.03183421865105629,
0.4683217704296112,
-0.3175917863845825,
-0.14133214950561523,
-0.08968441933393478,
-0.18805469572544098,
0.2018938809633255,
0.33398202061653137,
-0.9455093145370483,
-0.052641045302152634,
0.4384409785270691,
0.6718582510948181,
-0.2070152461528778,
-0.12907534837722778,
-0.8373159170150757,
0.19107072055339813,
-0.7000836133956909,
1.1236872673034668,
-0.6502598524093628,
-0.2811018228530884,
-0.04910695552825928,
0.09609613567590714,
-0.11753953993320465,
-0.41861388087272644,
0.8569383025169373,
-0.43843138217926025,
0.4844496548175812,
0.3901650309562683,
-0.7692646980285645,
-0.038212403655052185,
0.2804309129714966,
-0.45553499460220337,
1.0138057470321655,
-0.03557738661766052,
-0.9591842293739319,
0.586663544178009,
-0.4341423809528351,
-0.5654649138450623,
0.11138390004634857,
-0.19474433362483978,
-0.5732817649841309,
0.11616194993257523,
0.4714769721031189,
0.6482167840003967,
0.15845009684562683,
0.19996169209480286,
-0.2578599452972412,
-0.35520032048225403,
0.03282521292567253,
-1.01754891872406,
0.7624753713607788,
0.3305889070034027,
-0.3063897490501404,
-0.1127275675535202,
-0.8933280110359192,
0.1820838451385498,
0.11234542727470398,
-0.44568848609924316,
-0.3461107015609741,
-0.0328875295817852,
0.039510056376457214,
-0.17993344366550446,
0.25046542286872864,
-0.7804919481277466,
0.091888427734375,
-0.2357688695192337,
0.36801910400390625,
0.6625008583068848,
-0.05715472996234894,
0.44414857029914856,
-0.1268412470817566,
0.4579539895057678,
-0.1425154209136963,
-0.4334314167499542,
-0.7138690948486328,
-0.592804491519928,
-0.6672616600990295,
-0.4678894579410553,
0.5040950179100037,
0.7692084908485413,
-0.9192001223564148,
0.7180742025375366,
0.07656580209732056,
-0.5248757600784302,
-0.30895185470581055,
-0.1342449188232422,
0.32051822543144226,
0.3505679666996002,
0.03948677331209183,
-0.1566241979598999,
-0.6229957342147827,
-0.7816795706748962,
-0.5229829549789429,
-0.47316500544548035,
-0.3925412595272064,
0.04076460376381874,
0.5601652264595032,
-0.21970950067043304,
0.6986313462257385,
-0.34001120924949646,
0.06036612018942833,
-0.2055334895849228,
0.41165220737457275,
0.11661532521247864,
0.5111297369003296,
0.5824515223503113,
-0.47310498356819153,
-0.6771343350410461,
0.37465354800224304,
-1.0786246061325073,
-0.339168906211853,
-0.015327387489378452,
0.20615552365779877,
0.6332197785377502,
0.4490593671798706,
-0.5688478350639343,
0.4382888674736023,
0.5186510682106018,
0.019017430022358894,
0.5637409687042236,
-0.3013531565666199,
0.17474833130836487,
-1.1836838722229004,
-0.09133066236972809,
0.33506083488464355,
-0.4851698875427246,
-0.8659883737564087,
0.2964526116847992,
0.1889573484659195,
0.08887281268835068,
-0.16705353558063507,
0.4768807888031006,
-0.47555574774742126,
-0.020741255953907967,
-0.5777376294136047,
0.02583598531782627,
-0.115621417760849,
0.18917633593082428,
0.2552648186683655,
0.7467873692512512,
0.578864574432373,
-0.6087011694908142,
0.12703044712543488,
-0.24744075536727905,
-0.37010636925697327,
0.5640891194343567,
-0.542181134223938,
0.24968582391738892,
-0.15208664536476135,
0.18522962927818298,
-1.068282961845398,
-0.5528191924095154,
0.3080082833766937,
-0.8856275677680969,
0.4775948226451874,
-0.2725600600242615,
-0.5832487344741821,
-0.3058430254459381,
-0.022530851885676384,
0.2022208720445633,
0.6597214341163635,
-0.5717207789421082,
0.41584816575050354,
0.4449712336063385,
-0.022309189662337303,
-0.5470804572105408,
-0.8120803236961365,
0.046792805194854736,
-0.18752405047416687,
-0.4244237542152405,
0.28022438287734985,
0.2109266221523285,
-0.22377879917621613,
-0.12503623962402344,
0.026140669360756874,
-0.07159754633903503,
0.2101980298757553,
-0.10879659652709961,
0.14170245826244354,
-0.3162352442741394,
0.2867082953453064,
0.01229801680892706,
-0.11212173849344254,
-0.15242445468902588,
-0.5329859852790833,
0.6770558953285217,
-0.039931368082761765,
-0.557449221611023,
-0.29944613575935364,
0.3243296444416046,
0.3977533280849457,
-0.16624298691749573,
0.49021175503730774,
0.755879819393158,
-0.5129538178443909,
-0.35587459802627563,
-0.34678906202316284,
-0.23262076079845428,
-0.43328189849853516,
0.17453895509243011,
-0.19685636460781097,
-0.9336803555488586,
0.6658726334571838,
0.4098077118396759,
-0.051940448582172394,
0.7813326120376587,
0.6806620359420776,
-0.014466884545981884,
1.3162639141082764,
0.7951201796531677,
-0.1764308214187622,
0.25079068541526794,
0.21851953864097595,
0.36309200525283813,
-0.42647960782051086,
0.2029268741607666,
-0.6863265037536621,
0.02479446493089199,
-0.9206805229187012,
-0.1031610518693924,
0.1227995902299881,
0.06962409615516663,
-0.24185073375701904,
0.48123428225517273,
-0.7829224467277527,
0.5961606502532959,
0.6876277923583984,
0.06715159118175507,
0.4615742862224579,
0.18282823264598846,
-0.011591159738600254,
0.4426754117012024,
-0.7188757658004761,
-0.6166813373565674,
1.2864322662353516,
0.1736593246459961,
0.6655741930007935,
-0.14166070520877838,
0.9071168303489685,
0.40988102555274963,
0.42750784754753113,
-0.7760784029960632,
0.3339769244194031,
-0.2502780854701996,
-0.6519573330879211,
-0.3074871897697449,
-0.49593767523765564,
-0.979820728302002,
0.17925430834293365,
-0.19657213985919952,
-0.9713672399520874,
-0.13067254424095154,
0.303357869386673,
-0.08890986442565918,
0.5056380033493042,
-0.7493822574615479,
0.5470823645591736,
-0.10681165754795074,
-0.1307498663663864,
0.12635836005210876,
-0.26075661182403564,
0.5326396822929382,
-0.3075600564479828,
0.0817275196313858,
0.04228711873292923,
0.21033811569213867,
0.5978139638900757,
-0.11154913157224655,
0.7950635552406311,
-0.00024476193357259035,
-0.4706551730632782,
0.8036240935325623,
0.32536056637763977,
0.7747034430503845,
-0.3899955153465271,
-0.043050169944763184,
-0.007384039461612701,
-0.32671329379081726,
-0.4910086989402771,
-0.34273314476013184,
0.5194504261016846,
-0.4463271200656891,
-0.5543373227119446,
-0.4444637596607208,
-0.5821728110313416,
0.15569613873958588,
0.29077786207199097,
0.7732373476028442,
0.30255165696144104,
-0.14749714732170105,
0.07323050498962402,
0.6973744034767151,
-0.2847769856452942,
0.6093431711196899,
0.5634663105010986,
-0.3399765193462372,
-0.050867658108472824,
0.8945505023002625,
-0.03700706362724304,
0.265346497297287,
0.5758074522018433,
0.030984103679656982,
-0.1991359293460846,
-0.5825287103652954,
-0.8106530904769897,
-0.322727233171463,
-0.5357668995857239,
-0.16951973736286163,
-0.823619544506073,
-0.35615265369415283,
-0.3687460720539093,
-0.16627827286720276,
-0.11016719788312912,
-0.41969072818756104,
-0.24439050257205963,
-0.10891807824373245,
0.35837408900260925,
0.6047042608261108,
0.021432839334011078,
0.5314440131187439,
-0.7410191893577576,
-0.02493198961019516,
0.11631176620721817,
-0.002439481671899557,
-0.022683128714561462,
-0.6706256866455078,
0.023490197956562042,
0.12901559472084045,
-0.34943172335624695,
-0.746442973613739,
0.6518620252609253,
0.1562952995300293,
0.7119137644767761,
0.4639233350753784,
0.07494307309389114,
0.022227037698030472,
-0.5114957690238953,
0.7023603320121765,
0.0947999432682991,
-0.7731106877326965,
0.6994509100914001,
-0.7745652794837952,
0.33579590916633606,
0.04594883695244789,
0.16462455689907074,
-0.3254562020301819,
-0.5708505511283875,
-0.7652063369750977,
-0.44575703144073486,
0.5717800259590149,
0.45651647448539734,
0.13959161937236786,
-0.1437283456325531,
0.07688909769058228,
0.12241650372743607,
0.17778073251247406,
-0.8421948552131653,
0.1839684695005417,
0.07811591774225235,
-0.558539628982544,
-0.19003081321716309,
0.09038051217794418,
0.19378761947155,
0.27881404757499695,
0.7223436236381531,
-0.3717424273490906,
0.5212064981460571,
0.02406322956085205,
-0.11709444224834442,
-0.24167437851428986,
0.32443419098854065,
0.5219758749008179,
0.055716466158628464,
-0.022657224908471107,
0.36842578649520874,
0.11653860658407211,
-0.40660855174064636,
0.24563215672969818,
-0.0156093155965209,
-0.55234694480896,
0.12327355146408081,
0.6164759993553162,
0.5447938442230225,
-0.24573580920696259,
-0.597588062286377,
0.39322012662887573,
0.3433111906051636,
-0.35578545928001404,
-0.24878180027008057,
0.2410881370306015,
-0.2209368497133255,
0.042458608746528625,
0.4504324197769165,
0.3229151666164398,
0.2850986123085022,
-0.5881057381629944,
0.4815566837787628,
0.8310690522193909,
-0.563525915145874,
-0.25867918133735657,
0.7075250744819641,
-0.1198212131857872,
-0.3935769498348236,
0.3704078197479248,
-0.353149950504303,
-0.7347736954689026,
0.9334374070167542,
0.6500892639160156,
1.0653890371322632,
-0.34095337986946106,
0.39087581634521484,
0.16087579727172852,
0.5481491684913635,
-0.2571503520011902,
-0.08484308421611786,
-0.15164700150489807,
-1.170872688293457,
-0.47379034757614136,
-0.6207544803619385,
-0.3378756642341614,
0.15446388721466064,
-0.467792272567749,
0.3370606303215027,
-0.15902604162693024,
0.08576922118663788,
0.24905923008918762,
-0.2613237202167511,
-0.3043791651725769,
0.11807358264923096,
0.2519601285457611,
0.6710948944091797,
-1.0635335445404053,
0.7804584503173828,
0.6095844507217407,
-0.19803832471370697,
-0.6403254866600037,
0.3021855056285858,
0.10274959355592728,
-1.0891672372817993,
0.3245980441570282,
0.42574822902679443,
-0.1444888710975647,
0.14604666829109192,
-0.8945931196212769,
-0.4785749614238739,
0.7784598469734192,
0.2368708848953247,
-0.5364215970039368,
0.3164557218551636,
-0.10905523598194122,
0.6198658347129822,
-0.43266531825065613,
0.3128243386745453,
0.34786438941955566,
0.23904936015605927,
0.024504445493221283,
-0.8153970837593079,
-0.22443567216396332,
-0.22865459322929382,
-0.3174321949481964,
0.47959139943122864,
-0.4005098342895508,
0.9732797741889954,
-0.08247441053390503,
-0.47943878173828125,
0.1783318668603897,
0.38299599289894104,
0.4874967038631439,
0.5594478249549866,
0.31647300720214844,
0.7967773675918579,
0.8270954489707947,
-0.030761176720261574,
1.112077236175537,
-0.2802503705024719,
0.4749172627925873,
0.8259739875793457,
-0.46358636021614075,
0.8091735243797302,
0.14008823037147522,
-0.17294886708259583,
0.4071279466152191,
0.6200255751609802,
-0.10968668013811111,
0.39599382877349854,
0.05931700021028519,
-0.6088003516197205,
-0.48616349697113037,
0.18002896010875702,
-0.030685104429721832,
0.6443028450012207,
0.2899608314037323,
-0.7484094500541687,
-0.3918623626232147,
-0.11802110821008682,
-0.08040951192378998,
0.15040162205696106,
-0.4711308181285858,
0.660698652267456,
-0.016164420172572136,
-0.7641996145248413,
0.5051057934761047,
0.22804175317287445,
0.9189382195472717,
-0.1962803304195404,
0.07051856070756912,
0.11611085385084152,
0.3706895411014557,
-0.1864122450351715,
-0.9544989466667175,
0.11870356649160385,
0.3509226441383362,
-0.2215147316455841,
0.0681706890463829,
1.3938266038894653,
-0.4802285134792328,
-0.8659184575080872,
-0.06894169747829437,
0.6858594417572021,
0.40207532048225403,
-0.19237691164016724,
-0.12694846093654633,
-0.26406994462013245,
0.15522761642932892,
-0.07519640028476715,
0.35095489025115967,
0.6596086025238037,
-0.2573776841163635,
0.49878984689712524,
0.6129780411720276,
-0.28175970911979675,
-0.01226060837507248,
-0.22756598889827728,
0.403266578912735,
-0.17807979881763458,
-0.4417545795440674,
-1.1921005249023438,
0.21080158650875092,
-0.03889501839876175,
-0.040972206741571426,
0.768406093120575,
0.5827826857566833,
0.9985823631286621,
-0.27097252011299133,
1.27880859375,
0.004800545051693916,
0.5260792970657349,
-0.6535489559173584,
0.7110403180122375,
-0.41404294967651367,
0.26560357213020325,
-0.24349574744701385,
-0.9058477878570557,
-0.3801043629646301,
0.8370720744132996,
-0.34726575016975403,
0.12287033349275589,
0.2831287980079651,
0.7216437458992004,
-0.20298250019550323,
0.2265777438879013,
0.5268401503562927,
-0.07569257915019989,
0.1763700544834137,
0.4914610683917999,
0.8532578945159912,
-0.5958021879196167,
0.47422823309898376,
0.07910812646150589,
-0.24715064465999603,
-0.16938309371471405,
-1.022165060043335,
-0.8766357898712158,
-0.35143956542015076,
-0.3125031590461731,
-0.13854895532131195,
0.08199381828308105,
0.30622225999832153,
0.5312895178794861,
-1.0160411596298218,
0.06887625902891159,
-0.6320444345474243,
-0.015510199591517448,
-0.048961084336042404,
-0.2574157416820526,
0.1606026142835617,
-0.3239116668701172,
-0.8198934197425842,
0.3296984136104584,
0.3496200442314148,
0.3845843970775604,
-0.22329145669937134,
0.053179338574409485,
-0.018557630479335785,
0.08757471293210983,
0.6458582282066345,
0.24950769543647766,
-0.5407223105430603,
-0.5782429575920105,
0.12264063954353333,
-0.003278170945122838,
0.019986592233181,
0.5232001543045044,
-0.9016416072845459,
0.21635136008262634,
0.5828129649162292,
0.4955340325832367,
0.47282686829566956,
0.01505536399781704,
0.5987164974212646,
-0.964565634727478,
0.18650737404823303,
0.16742010414600372,
0.34342536330223083,
0.2878194749355316,
-0.5022085309028625,
0.6127493381500244,
0.3253951370716095,
-0.6860284805297852,
-1.0394395589828491,
0.5343996286392212,
-0.6865402460098267,
-0.29588964581489563,
0.9336970448493958,
-0.21118663251399994,
-0.1965656578540802,
0.10507065802812576,
0.030071789398789406,
0.35073480010032654,
-0.4155498445034027,
0.5722123980522156,
0.6929190754890442,
-0.08779348433017731,
-0.418931782245636,
-0.4754714071750641,
0.08470581471920013,
0.15226081013679504,
-0.7636407017707825,
0.03095533326268196,
0.3852319121360779,
0.1936204582452774,
0.30196765065193176,
0.46582216024398804,
-0.03147229924798012,
0.10220473259687424,
0.3778857886791229,
0.19265341758728027,
0.21788324415683746,
-0.29191091656684875,
-0.07473871111869812,
0.189030259847641,
-0.10592106729745865,
-0.1558489203453064
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.